Spatially Resolved Magnetic Resonance Edited by P. Blumler, B. Blumich R. Botto, E. Fukushima
@3WILEY-VCH
This Page ...
54 downloads
1280 Views
38MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Spatially Resolved Magnetic Resonance Edited by P. Blumler, B. Blumich R. Botto, E. Fukushima
@3WILEY-VCH
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Spatially Resolved Magnetic Resonance Methods, Materials, Medicine, Biology, Rheology, Geology, Ecology, Hardware
Edited by P. Blumler, B. Blumich, R. Botto, E. Fukushima
8WILEY-VCH Weinheim . New York Chichester Brisbane .Singapore .Toronto 1
Editors: Dr. Peter Bliimler Prof. Dr. Bernhard Bliimich Lehrstuhl fur Makromolekulare Chemie und Magnetic Resonance Center, MARC, RWTH Aachen Worringer Weg 1 D-52074 Aachen, Germany
Prof. Dr. Robert E. Botto Chemistry Division Argonne National Laboratory 9700 South Cass Avenue Argonne, Illinois 60439-4828 USA
Dr. Eiichi Fukushima 2425 Ridgecrest Dr. SE Albuquerque New Mexico 87108 USA
This book was carefully produced. Nevertheless, authors, editors and publisher do not warrant the information contained therein to be free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate.
Cover picture: Velocity NMR image of shear bands in a cone-plate rheometer. For details see chapter 49. Reproduced with permission of M. M. Britton and P. T. Callaghan.
Library of Congress Card No. applied for A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Die Deutsche Bibliothek - CIP-Einheitsaufnahme Spatially resolved magnetic resonance : methods, materials, medicine, biology, rheology, geology, ecology, hardware / ed. by Peter Bliimler ... Weinheim ; New York ; Chichester ; Brisbane ; Singapore ; Toronto : Wiley-VCH, 1998 ISBN 3-527-29637-9
0 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1998
Printed on acid-free and low chlorine paper All rights reserved (including those of translation into other languages). No part of this book may be reproduced in any form - by photoprinting, microfilm, or any other means - nor transmitted or translated into machine language without written permission from the publishers. Registered names, trademarks, etc. used in this book, even when not specifically marked as such, are not to be considered unprotected by law. Printing: betz-druck GmbH, D-64291 Darmstadt Bookbinding: GroBbuchbinderei J. Schaffer, D-67269 Griinstadt Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany
Foreword Just as the ,,Heidelberg Conference" has moved about, even as far as the American Southwest, it has broadened its scope to include essentially all non-clinical magnetic resonance imaging. The immense variety of techniques and applications in human diagnostic NMR imaging is driven by medical needs, but limited by considerations of safety, time, and economics. In the broader worlds of science and technology, the seemingly-unlimited ways spin magnetization can be manipulated, and the forms of matter that can be studied, are much more various, and the experiments involve a broader range of the knowledge and skills of physicists, chemists, and materials scientists. The addition of spatial resolution to the tools available for such studies allows them to be applied to many heterogeneous objects, and to processes, such as transport, that involve spatial dimensions on the supramolecular scale. Still, however, much of the ingenuity of practitioners in the field is devoted to overcoming difficulties and artifacts that limit its usefulness. NMR, with or without imaging, is a powerful but fragile technique, and all too often promising approaches to beautiful experiments are blocked by ugly details. One way to read this volume is to look for the implicit terrain maps of practicality. What is being attempted, and why not something else? Why is a particular set of techniques, a particular piece of equipment, being used? Because it is available, or because nothing else will do? In clinical studies, the questions to be asked and the priorities are often better defined, but in other areas NMR spectroscopy and imaging often seem to be answers looking for questions. As practitioners learn more about the wider world, and outsiders become more familiar with the possibilities, limitations and peculiarities of magnetic resonance methods, the field is maturing. This volume documents a long stride toward such maturation and integration, along with the ever increasing power and subtlety of techniques and analyses, and should inspire developers and users in all areas, from medicine to geology.
Urbana, January 1998
Paul C . Lauterbur
Preface In the year 1991 the First Conference on Magnetic Resonance Microscopy has taken place in Heidelberg, Germany. Based on the contributions to this meeting the book Magnetic Resonance Microscopy: Methods and Applications in Materials Science, Agriculture and Biomedicine, VCH Weinheim, 1992, had been edited by Bernhard Bliimich and Winfried Kuhn and provided an up-to-date reference on the subject of non-medical imaging. At the time the methods in magnetic resonance imaging evolved largely from the area of clinical diagnostics, but were adapted more and more to other applications, and extensive studies on test phantoms demonstrated potential use in various fields of science and engineering. Six years later, the Fourth International Conference on Magnetic Resonance Microscopy was held in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and it was felt, that an update of the Microscopy Book was needed. During this time, the field has advanced significantly, and several new techniques were introduced as well as interesting new applications covering such diverse areas as polymer and elastomer characterization, analysis of construction materials and material flow, various topics in biomedicine, and plants studies. The focus on microscopy features was broadened to include magnetic resonance of macroscopic systems. Applications in the area of oil-well analysis, and non-destructive quality and process control are made possible by the development of dedicated instrumentation which can readily be moved to the site of interest. The editors are indebted to the authors for timely submission of their contributions and to the referees, who helped to improve a number of manuscripts. We are indebted to Tanja Rente for transforming the manuscripts into book format and to VCH for their cooperation and help with the final editing and production process.
September 1998
Peter Bliimler, Bernhard Blurnich, Robert E. Botto. and Eiichi Fukushima
Contents Foreword P. C. Lauterbltr ...................................................................................................
V
Preface P. Bliimler, B. Bliinziclz,R. E. Botto, and E, Fukushinia ....................................
VI
Methods 1.
Spatial Resolution in Spectroscopic Imaging
M. von Kienlin and R. Pohrnann ................................................................... 2.
3
CYCLOCROP Mapping of 13C Labelled Compounds: Perspectives in Polymer Science and Plant Physiology
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N . Chandrakunzar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimniich ............................................................................... 2 1 3. Contrast Enhancement Based on Intermolecular Zero Quantum Coherences for Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Microscopy R. R. Rizi, S. Ahn, J. Hopkins, J. S. Leigh, and W. S. Warren ................... 53 4.
Frequency Dependence of EPR Sensitivity G. R. Eaton, S. S. Eaton, and G. A. Rinnrd ................................................
65
5. SPRITE Imaging of Short Relaxation Time Nuclei B. J. Balconi ................................................................................................
75
6. Refocusing a Spin-Echo in the Presence of a Strong Readout Gradient Field Using an Underdriven Gradient Pulse G. PlaninSic and M . Syrnms........................................................................
87
7.
The Analysis and Development of Pulse Sequences for Self-Diffusion Weighted Stray-Field Imaging A. J. Bohris, D. A. Faux, D. G. Gillies, and P. J. McDonald .....................
95
VIII
Conterztc
8. Imaging Diffusion with Non-Uniform B, Gradients K. Woelk,B. L. J. Zwank, J. Bargon, R. J. Klingler R. E. Gerald 11, and J. W.Rathke .............................................................
103
9. In Situ Imaging of Charge Carriers in an Electrochemical Cell
R. E. Gerald 11, R. J. Klingler, J. W.Ratlike, G. Sandi, and K. Woelk..... 1 1 1
10. Efficient Simulation of Spin Echo, Gradient Echo, Fast, and Ultrafast NMR Imaging Sequences by Isochroinat Summation P. Shkarin and R. G. S. Spencer ...............................................................
121
11. A Novel Algorithm for Tumor Characterization by Analysis of Transversal Relaxation Rate Distributions in MRI
R. Martin and M. Martin-Landrove .........................................................
133
Materials 12. Materials Imaging with Examples from Solid Rocket Propellants W.E. Maas, L.H. Merwin, and D.G. Cory ..............................................
141
13. 129XeMRM Characterization of Pore Structures in Silica Aerogels
D.M. Gregovy, R. E. Gerald II, D. J. CEifSord, and R. E. Botto...............163 14. NMR Imaging of Mechanically Treated Polymers
B. Traub, S. Hafner, D. Maring, and H. W. Spiess...................................
179
15. Soft-Matter Relaxation by the NMR-MOUSE A. Guthausen, G. Zimmer, R. Eymael, U. Schmitz, P. Bliirnler, and B. Bliimich ......................................................................
195
16. Application of NMR-Imaging to Industrial Polymers M. Knorgen, U. Heuert, H. Schneider ......................................................
21 1
17. Electron Spin Resonance Imaging (ESPRI) of Transport Processes in Polymeric Systems S. Schlick, P. Eagle, K. Kruczala, and J. Pilar .......................................
.22 1
Contents
IX
18. Stray-Field Imaging and Magnetic Resonance Microimaging Studies of High Impact Polystyrene, an Elastomer-Toughened Material J. A. Chudek, G. Hunter, F. Mohd Soin, P. J. McDonald, and B. Newling .........................................................................................
235
19. Mixed Solvent Ingress into PMMA Measured by Stray-Field Magnetic Resonance Imaging D. M. Lane, P. J. McDonald, and J , L. Keddie ........................................
241
20. Stray-Field Imaging and Magnetic Resonance Microimaging Studies of the Anisotropic Absorption of Solvents by Extruded Polypropylene
R. J. Abbott, J. A. Chudek, G. Hunter, R. L. MacKay, P. J. McDonald, and L. Squires ................................................................
253
21. NMR Microimaging: A Useful Tool to Study the Dissolution of Solids N. Black, T. Vienneau, and Y. Pan ...........................................................
259
22. Observation of the Water Distribution During Drying of Textiles
J. Leisen, L. Hou, H. W.Beckham, and W. W. Carr .................................
265
23. A Broad-Line Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study of Water Transport in Cementitious Building Materials A. J. Bohris, U. Goerke, P. J. McDonald, MMulheron, B. Newling, and B. Le Page ......................................................................
273
24. Stray-Field Imaging and Magnetic Resonance Microimaging Studies of Water Intrusion/Stress Mobilisation in Dense Polymer Systems Used in Construction S. N. Scrimgeour, G. Hunter, W. J , Harvey, C. H. Lloyd, D. M. Lane, and P. J. McDonald ..............................................................
281
25. Stray-Field Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Hardening Materials T. G. Nunes, P. R. Bodart, and E. W.Randall ..........................................
287
26. Applications of Stray-Field Imaging to Dental Materials Science S. N. Scrimgeour, C. H. Lloyd, G. Hunter, D. M. Lane, and P. J. McDonald ..............................................................
293
x
Contents
27. Particle Compaction as Observed by MRI R. A. Waggoner, M. Nakagwa, S. J. Glass, M. Reece, and E. Fukushima .....................................................................................
299
Medicine and Biology 28. 2H Double Quantum Filtered NMR Histology and Diffusion Measurements in Isolated Nerves and Blood Vessels
H. Shinar, Y. S h a ~U. Eliav, Y. Seo, and G. Navon ................................
307
29. Translational Diffusion of Water in Lung Tissue B. Geil, D. C. Ailion, C. Laicher, and A. G. Cutillo .................................
323
30. Studies of Perfused Brain Slices with MR Microscopy
J. D. Bui, D. L. Buckley, M, I. Phillips, and S. J. Blackband ...................337 31. Application of NMR Micro-Imaging to the Study of Water Transport in Eye Lenses B. A. Moffut, R. J. W. Truscott, M. H. J. Sweeney, and J , M. Pope .......... 345
32. Relaxation Anisotropy as a Possible Marker for Macromolecular Orientations in Articular Cartilage Y. Xia ........................................................................................................
351
33. Morphometric Analysis of Cartilage Grown in a Hollow Fiber Bioreactor Using NMR Microscopy K. Potter, K. W.Fishbein, W.E. Horton, and R. G. S. Spencer ...............363 34. EPR Imaging of the Rat Heart J. L. Zweier and P. Kuppusumy................................................................
373
35. Application of High Resolution Cardiac Magnetic Resonance Imaging to Monitor a Rodent Model of Cardiac Dysfunction S. Chandru, K. G. Gurbanov, R. Strittmatter, E. H. Ohlstein, G. Z, Feuerstein, and S. K. Sarkar ...........................................................
389
36, Fast MR Imaging of Esophageal Motility Y. Seki, S. Naruse, Y. Seo, M. Murakami, T. Ozaki, M. Kitagawa, H. Zshiguro, Y.Nakue, and T. Hayakawa .................................................
395
Corntents
XI
37. Spatial NMR Studies of Tumor Spheroids K. R, Minard, R. A. Wind, W,E. Maas, K. Millis, and D. G. Cory ..........403 38. 19F Chemical Shift Imaging of F-nuc Formed from 5-FU in Mouse Tumor by Fast Spin Echo
Y. Doi and Y. Kunazawa ...........................................................................
413
39. I7O and 31P Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Spectroscopy: In Vivo Investigations of Cell Bioenergetics G. D. Mateescu, M. Cabrera, and D. Fercu .............................................
421
40. Volume Localized 'H MRS of Renal Osmolytes G. J. Cowin, I. A. Leditschke, S. Crozier, and 2.H. Endre ......................
431
41. MRM in the Modeling of the Ossicular Chain
E. W.Abel, J. A. Chudek, G. Hunter, R. M. Lord, R. L. MacKay, and R. P. Mills ..................................................................
439
42. NMR Imaging of Rigid Biological Tissues
Y. Seo, H. Takarniya, H. Ishikawa, T. Nakashima, Y. S h a e and G. Navon .............................................................................
445
43. Magnetic Resonance Microimaging of Teeth S. N. Scrimgeour, C. H. Lloyd, G. Hunter, J. A. Chudek, and R. L. MacKay ...............................................................
459
44. MRM, an Alternative Approach to the Study of HostParasitoid Relationships in Insects
1.A. Chudek, G. Hunter, R. L. MacKay, S. Moritz, A. N. E. Birch, I. E. Geoghegan, R. J , McNicol, and M. E. N. Majerus ...........................
467
45. Plant Growth Studies Using Low Field NMR L. van der Weerd, T. Ruttink, D. van Dusschoten, F. J. Vergeldt, P. A. de Jager, and H. Van As ..........................................
473
46. Fast Spatially Resolved Displacement Imaging in (Bio)Systems T. W.J. Scheenen, D. van Dusschoten, P. A. de Jager, and H. Van As ...481
XI1
Contents
Diffusion and Flow 47. Generalized Treatment of Modulated Gradient Spin Echo Attenuation for Restricted Diffusion in Spherical Pores S. L. Codd and P. T. Callaghan ................................................................
489
48. NMR-Imaging Techniques for Quantitative Characterization of Periodic Motions: 'Incoherent Averaging' and 'Spectral Side Band Analysis' U. Goerke and R. Kivnmich.......................................................................
499
49. Shear-Banding in a Cone-and-Plate Rheometer M. M. Britton and P. T. Callaghan ...........................................................
507
50. Applications of NMR Flow Imaging in Material Science S. Laukemper-Ostendor- K. Rombach, and P. Blumler ...........................
517
5 1. A Non-Invasive Investigation of Concentration Polarization in Crossflow Microfiltration of Colloidal Silica D. Airey, V. Chen, J. Wu, and J. M. Pope ................................................
531
52. Evaluation of Mixing Profiles of Power Law Fluids in Scraped Surface Heat Exchanger Geometry Using MRI W. Wang, J. H . Walton, M , J. McCarthy, and K. L. McCarthy ................539 53. The Self Diffusion of 1,3 Propylene Glycol in Track Etched Membrane Pores E. Vasina, V. Skirda, V. Volkov,A. Nechaev, and B. Mchedlishvili .........547
Geology and Ecology 54. Review: NMR Detection and Characterization of Hydrocarbons in Subsurface Earth Formations
R. L. Kleinberg, and C. Flaum .................................................................
555
55. Why Would an Oil Company Use MRI? B. A. Baldwin and R. L. King ....................................................................
575
Contents
XI11
56. Pore Structure and Connectkty of Porous Rock by High Resolution NMR Microscopy
D. A. Doughty and L. Tornutsa .................................................................
603
57. Relaxation-Diffusion Processes and Local Magnetic Field Distributions in Natural Porous Media
D. Pe'rez, A. Benavides, S. Gonzdez, D. Barrantes, and M. Martin-Lundrove ..........................................................................
617
58. MR Microscopy of Savannah River Tank Waste Simulants
K. R. Minard, R. A. Wind, and L. 0. Dworjanyn ......................................
627
Hardware 59. A Compact, Superconducting Magnet for Magnetic Resonance Microscopy S. Crozier and D. M. Doddrell .................................................................
639
60. MRI Gradient Coil Optimization
F. D. Doty ................................................................................................. 647 61. Novel, Asymmetric Gradient Coil Sets for Magnetic Resonance Microscopy S. Crozier, W. U. Roffmann, and D. M. Doddrell .....................................
675
62. Novel Gradient Coils for Magnetic Resonance Microscopy E. R. Andrew, M. Kempka, S. Sagnowski, and E. Szczesniak ................... 683
63. The NMR Endoscope R. Haken, P. Bliimler, and B. Bliimich .....................................................
695
64. Development of a Flexible Pulse Programmer for MRI Using a Commercial Digital Signal Processor Board K. Kose and T. Haishi ...............................................................................
703
XIV
Contents
Tutorial 65. Introduction to Magnetic Resonance Y.Xia ........................................................................................................
713
Author Index. ..................................................................................................
.74 1
Subject Index ...................................................................................................
745
Methods
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1. Spatial Resolution in Spectroscopic Imaging Markus von Kienlin and Roy Pohmunn Physikalisches Institut (Biophysik) Universitat Wurzburg, D-97074 Wurzburg, Germany
Abstract This contribution reviews various aspects of the spatial resolution obtained in spectroscopic imaging experiments. After showing the fundamental difficulty to define “spatial resolution”, it is shown that the precision in the determination of the location of a point source is only limited by the signal-to-noise ratio, and is much better than the nominal resolution. Then the resolving power is analyzed using the Rayleigh criterion, and the importance of a sufficient digital resolution is illustrated. Finally, the importance of the “spatial response function” is emphasized.
1.1 Introduction: Localized Spectroscopy Most conventional methods to examine physiologic parameters or metabolic processes directly in living tissue require to extract a sample, which then is analyzed with biochemical means. These biopsies in animals or humans can not only be painful, but often carry some risk. Localized NMR spectroscopy provides non-invasive biopsy: it can analyze the chemical composition of well defined regions within the body, without the need to extract a specimen. Localized NMR spectroscopy therefore has not only found many applications in fundamental research, where it contributes to a better understanding of metabolism, but is also gaining importance in clinical diagnostics. To these ends, a high quality and reliability of localization is prerequisite, and huge research efforts have been made to improve the sensitivity, the spatial resolution, the stability and the patient comfort of these techniques.
4
M. von Kienlin and R. Pohmann
First attempts to acquire NMR spectra within a larger object employed surface coils [1,2] or shaped the homogeneous region of the main, static magnetic field (“topical magnetic resonance TMR’ 13-51). P. Bendel et al. were the first to acquire spectroscopic information in the presence of a magnetic field gradient [6]. The first to employ pulsed magnetic field gradients and selective excitation pulses to select a voxel within the sample were W. Aue et al. [7]. Their work started the development of a large number of techniques which allow to measure the spectrum of more or less rectangular volumes; the best known of these are DRESS 181, ISIS [9], STEAM [lo-121 and PRESS 1131. These single voxel techniques today tend to be replaced by “spectroscopic imaging”, also called “chemical shift imaging CSI [14,15].” CSI has become available to a large number of users through the advent of actively shielded gradient systems and more sophisticated instruments. It offers the advantage to measure spectra not only in a single volume element, but simultaneously in a whole grid of many volumes across the sample, thus allowing to compare local variations within the studied object. In this contribution, we analyze the spatial resolution obtained in spectroscopic imaging. The knowledge of the spatial resolution is important for further technical developments, but it is also crucial for the correct interpretation of spectroscopic images. After a more precise definition of the topic, the basic principle of Fourier imaging will be briefly introduced. The concept of the spatial response function will be described, followed by an in depth analysis of the spatial resolution. Finally, the impact of numerical data representation will be clarified.
1.2 What is “Spatial Resolution”? The goal of localized NMR spectroscopy in vivo is to acquire spectra from well circumscribed anatomical areas. To achieve high specificity, a good discrimination from neighboring regions is essential, the contamination by signals from other regions must be as low as possible. It is furthermore advantageous to have as small a sensitive volume as possible, which fits well into the target region, and to avoid as much as possible tissue heterogeneity. The major hurdle is the poor sensitivity of NMR spectroscopy, which usually imposes the lower limit for the size of the sensitive volume.
1. Spatial Resolution in Spectrosropic Imnging
5
While this qualitative description of the goal of spntial resolution is straightforward, it is much more difficult to define a quantitative measure for the spatial resolution. The notion “spatial resolution” can be interpreted in many different ways. A possible meaning can be the precision, by which the location of a signal source within the sample can be determined. Another and completely different definition is to measure the minimal distance between two signal sources within the sample, which still allows to distinguish them. Both definitions allow to calculate some specific number for the spatial resolution of some measurement method. Such a number does allow to compare various methods its significance is nevertheless questionable. In biomedical applications, there are no point sources of NMR signal, but one has to deal with extended and heterogeneous regions with irregular shape. The knowledge of the “spatial response fimction SRF’ is essential for a correct interpretation of the results, and to estimate the degree of possible signal contamination from adjacent regions. The SRF indicates the weight of the contribution of every point in space to a localized spectrum. The shape of the SRF essentially depends on the number of image points, the sampling scheme, and eventual filtering and other parameters of the acquisition and the sample. It is therefore not sufficient to indicate only the nominal resolution of the experiment: one should also show the SRF! Other circumstances which can further deteriorate the quality of localization - like motion artifacts or diffusion - will not be considered in the following.
Fig. 1.1: The spatial resolution is mainly limited by the low sensitivity. If a spectrum with sufficient SNR can be acquired from the large sphere in only 10 min, it takes almost 11 hours (!) to obtain a spectrum with the same SNR from the smaller sphere with half the diameter!
6
M. von Kienlin and R. Pohmann
The issue of spatial resolution is mainly due to the low sensitivity of NMR spectroscopy. As demonstrated in Fig. (1. l), the low sensitivity is the main obstacle to increase the spatial resolution. The detected NMR signal is directly proportional to the sample magnetization within the sensitive volume. If the spin distribution is homogeneous, the signal decreases with the third power of the linear dimension of the volume. The signalto-noise ratio (SNR) is proportional to the square root of the total duration of an experiment, the duration required to achieve some given SNR therefore depends to the sixth power of the linear dimension of the sensitive volume. At the current state of coil and receiver technology, where the SNR already is mainly dominated by the properties of the sample, substantial further improvements in sensitivity cannot be expected. Sensitivity thus sets a lower limit to the size of volumes selected in localized spectroscopy. If their size can hardly be reduced, it is nevertheless possible to improve their sharpness. The following sections show which parameters influence the shape of the SRF, and how that shape can be improved in spectroscopic imaging.
1.3 Fourier Methods for Spectroscopic Imaging The most common way to acquire spectroscopic images is based on a Fourier method proposed by A. Kumar et al. [14]. As early as 1979, A. Maudsley applied phase encoding and Fourier reconstruction to map an inhomogeneous magnetic field by measuring the spatial dependence of the resonance frequency [16]. Successful experiments both on phantoms [15,17] and in vivo [18,19] have shown the numerous advantages of spectroscopic imaging, which now is being used in an increasing number of clinical studies. A more detailed survey can be found for instance in [20]. The simplest possible pulse sequence for spectroscopic imaging is plotted in Fig. 1.2. The excitation pulse is followed by a short gradient pulse of length T~ in one, two or all three directions, which encodes the spatial information as phase modulation of the transverse magnetization. Then, all gradient fields are switched off and the signal of the freely precessing spins is detected. This experiment is repeated for some number of repetitions, applying regularly incremented gradient strengths. The spectroscopic image is then obtained by applying Fourier-transformations in all spatial and the spectral dimensions. This simple sequence can be modified by generating spin-echoes or stimulated echoes, or by using slice-selective excitation or refocusing pulses, but these variations do not affect
I . Spatial Resolution in Spectroscopic Imaging
7
the basic principle of spectroscopic imaging. In the following mathematical description only one spatial dimension is treated, the generalization to two or three dimensions is straightforward.
a
RF I I I
Fig. 1.2: A pulse sequence of spectroscopic imaging. After excitation, gradients are switched on for a short time to modulate the phase of the magnetization. The signal is then acquired in the homogeneous field.
The volume covered by the spectroscopic image is usually called "field-of-view''
(FOV). The nominal resolution AT-,,,, is the size of the image elements (voxels). For an image with N points it is given by:
Ar,,,
= FOV/N
(1.1)
For the mathematical description, it is advantageous to define a variable k which describes the gradient strength integrated over time [21]:
with zG the duration of the gradient pulse. The variable k can be interpreted as the spatial
8
M. von Kienliri and R. Pohmann
frequency: the higher the value of k, the faster the spatial variation of the phase of the transverse magnetization after the gradient pulse. The required increment Ak between two successive gradient steps is determined directly by the F O E 1
Ak =-FOV The gradient steps are usually applied in increasing order, beginning at -NAk/2 and ending at (Nl2-1)Ak. It is, however, advantageous to use gradient values that are distributed symmetrically about zero, from - (N - 1)Ak12 to (N - 1)Ak12 [22-241. Using such a phase encoding scheme yields a purely real pointspread function (cf. section 1.4). The strength of the n* gradient pulse then is:
For high N , large values of the spatial frequency k are reached, and a small nominal resolution Ar is obtained. If p(r) is the signal emanating from location r, the signal that is detected after the nth phase encoding gradient can be written as the integral over the entire object, modulated by a phase which depends on the position and the gradient strength:
Performing a discrete Fourier transformation on the N acquired signals, one obtains for the signal from the point n' Ar (as long as the sampling theorem has been respected and the signal has not been truncated):
Except for the phase factor, the image represents the actual distribution of the magnetization in the sample. The phase factor can be compensated by either taking the magnitude of the image, or by applying an appropriate phase correction. Spectroscopic imaging has the considerable advantage that in only one experiment, the spectra from all N voxels are obtained simultaneously. Furthermore, the localization is not affected by chemical shift artifacts.
1. Spatial Resolution in Spectroscopic Imaging
9
A disadvantage of conventional spectroscopic imaging is the long minimal duration of an experiment: in contrast to techniques like STEAM or PRESS, which can acquire the spectrum of a voxel in a single transient, spectroscopic imaging requires at least N repetitions. Several methods for fast spectroscopic imaging have been proposed, which sample the signal in the presence of gradients and reduce the minimal duration drastically [25-301. However, they require high experimental complexity, and do not offer any gain in sensitivity.
1.4 The Spatial Response Function In contrast to conventional IH-imaging or to multi-dimensional spectroscopy techniques, the number N of voxels (i.e. phase encode steps) in spectroscopic imaging is usually very small. This is due to restrictions on the duration and to the low sensitivity of the experiment. The high spatial frequencies of the sample are then inevitably truncated, and the assumptions behind eqn. (1.6) are no longer valid.
A spectroscopic image thus does not reflect the actual distribution of the spins, but its convolution with a function that is caused by the lack of the high spatial frequencies, the pointspread function PSF [31-351. The signal from some location in the sample is found not in only one pixel of the spectroscopic image, but spread out across all pixels. The PSF describes the amplitude of the propagation of the signal from the point ro in the sample to the image pixel with coordinate rn=n Ar:
This equation can be read in two ways: for a fixed yo, the PSF indicates how the signal from spins at this position is distributed over all pixels of the image. The PSF is a discrete function consisting of N points. A complementary way of interpreting eqn. (1.7) is usually more relevant for localized spectroscopy: for a fixed yn, its dependence on yo yields the spatial response function SRF. This continuous function describes the contribution of every point of the sample to the spectrum in one image pixel.
10
M. von Kienlin and R. Pohmann
In Fig. 1.3, the shape of the SRF for the case of N = 8 phase encoding steps obtained with an unfiltered Fourier transformation is shown. Several important properties of Fourier imaging become visible: Not only does the magnetization from inside the volume of interest (VOI), nominally placed in the region n' Ar, contribute to the signal of its image pixel, but a more or less strong contamination by signals from outside this pixel is possible. The spatial response function even extends beyond the actual FOV. This has to be taken into account for samples that are larger than the FOV, and this can cause contamination of voxels close to the edge of the image by signals emanating from the opposite side of the image.
1.o
c 0.5
0 .-
I\
I\
I
\
c
0
c
3
a, rn
5Q
0.0
(I)
F (d .c
(d
% -0.5
4-
FOV
-1 .o
spatial coordinate r
Fig. 1.3: The spatial response function (SRF) of a spectroscopic image with N = 8 phase encode steps for an unfiltered Fourier transformation. The largest contribution to the signal emanates from the region marked 'VOI'. The SRF, however, extends beyond the VOI and even beyond the entire FOV. Signals from outside the FOV thus are aliased into the FOV. Mainly signals from sharply edged regions with high signal amplitudes can propagate over the entire image.
The contamination due to the SRF is particularly high if regions with a high signal amplitude and sharp edges are present. This situation is given for instance in spectroscopic IH-imaging of the brain, where a thin layer of fat outside the skull often contaminates all the spectra in the brain. The quality of the spectra then does not allow reliable
1. Spatial Resolution in Spectroscopic Imaging
11
conclusions about the spatial distribution of the examined substances as long as no additional measures are applied to correct or to avoid these effects. Only with an accurate knowledge of the SRF, the reliability of an experiment can be assessed.
1.5 Position of a Point Source In section 1.2, one possible definition for “spatial resolution” was given as the precision in the determination of the location of a single signal source. In the following section, it will be demonstrated that in a Fourier imaging experiment the exact location of a point
source can be determined with very high precision. The accuracy of this measurement is only limited by the signal-to-noise ratio, and it is in all practical circumstances much better than the nominal resolution. These statements will be further clarified and quantified. In a one-dimensional situation (see Fig. 1.4), a single point source is located at position xo. One conducts N phase-encoded experiments, in each of which the strength of the phase-encoding gradient is incremented by Akx. According to eqn. (lS), the detected signals s, can be written as: sn
=
A e-inAkk,xo
,
N n =-- N --+ 2’ 2
N 1, ...,-2
In this equation, A is the amplitude of all the signals, and i = f
1
i . The phase qn of the
measured signals is given by:
From the exponent in eqn. (1.Q one can also recognize the following relation for the phase of the signal:
qn = n Akx xo
(1.10)
This is the expression of a straight line through the origin, with the slope rn = Ak, xo (cf. Fig. 1.4). If one determines m from the measured values qn,the location of the signal
12
M. von Kienlin and R. Pohmann
source can be calculated as:
xo =-
m
(1.11)
Akx The values of the employed phase-encoding gradients are known, the precision of the calculated position xo hence depends mainly from on accuracy of the phase measurement. In principle, it is even possible to determine the position with only two independent experiments. In Fourier imaging, the detected signals are generally reconstructed with a Fourier transformation. A spatial Fourier transformation can be looked at as a correlation of the . Through variation of x the fremeasured signal with the reference function e-i quency of the reference function is changed, and the correlation yields the image of the spatial distribution of the spin magnetization. In our particular case of a single point source, this corresponds to determining the spatial frequency A k x o in the measured signal. Under these circumstances, (continuous) Fourier transformation and the determination of the slope (eqn. 1.10) are equivalent.
Fig. 1.4: The position of a single point source can be measured with an accuracy that is only limited by the signal-to-noise ratio. a) Let the location of the point source in a one-dimensional setup be x,,. b) The phase of the NMR signal is measured in N = 8 phase-encoded experiments. The location of the point source can be determined from the slope of the obtained phase ramp.
How precisely can one determine the position of a point source, if each of the measured signals is deteriorated by thermal noise? Let the signal-to-noise ratio SNR of each measurement be
A SNR = 0 s
(1.12)
1. Spatial Resolution in Spectroscopic Imaging
13
with os being the standard deviation of the thermal noise, and A the signal amplitude in each measurement. The noise in the real and imaginary parts of the signal is independent.
How does this noise propagate when computing the phase of the signals? In conventional error analysis, the standard deviation ototof a variable y i = f (x,,x2,...,xt) is given by the standard deviations oi as:
(1.13)
In eqn. (1.9), both the numerator and the denominator contain an uncertainty due to the (uncorrelated) noise. Partial derivatives according to eqn. (1.13) yield for the standard deviation of the phase ocp:
-
0,
(1.14)
>.Im2{sn}
JRe2 {sn
The slope m of the regression line through all phase values is calculated as [36]:
n=l
\n=~
,)
The standard deviation omof this slope becomes, using eqn. (1.14):
(1.15)
14
M. von Kienlin and R. Pohmann
(1.16)
The position of the point source is calculated from eqn. (1.11). The standard deviation (T,
in this calculation, which is the uncertainty of the position, is related to the standard deviation of the slope as:
(1.17)
-
1 SNR
FOVfi N f i
Incorporating the expression for the nominal resolution Ax = FOV/N , one finally obtains the following, simple expression for the relative error of the position:
(1.18)
The error in the determination of the position of a point source is inversely proportional to the signal-to-noise ratio of the individual measurements, and to the square root of the number of phase-encoding steps. With an SNR of 25 and N = 8 phase-encoding steps, one obtains (3, /Ax = 0.049 : the precision is more than twenty times higher than the nominal resolution! On the other hand, a low SNR can be the factor limiting the resolution.
1. Spatial Resolution in Spectroscopic Imaging
15
1.6 The Rayleigh Criterion One of the possible definitions for spatial resolution which were mentioned in section 1.2 was the minimal distance between two objects required for them to be distinguishable in the image. This can be analyzed with the Rayleigh criterion which is well known from optics. According to the Rayleigh criterion, two objects can be distinguished if the maximal intensity of one occurs at the first diffraction minimum of the other. A different description of the same criterion runs that the intensity between the two image maxima has to drop to 8 1% of the maximum value for the two maxima to be distinguishable. This criterion is also applicable to Fourier NMR imaging. Figure 1.5 elucidates the Rayleigh criterion for two neighboring point sources. The thin lines represent for each of the two sources the intensity (the square of the SRF‘) as a function of space, the thick line is the sum of the two. The two sources must be at a distance which is just equal to the size of a voxel (which is the nominal resolution according to eqn. 1.1) for the intensity to drop to 81% of its maximum value. In this position, the maximum of one source occurs exactly at the first minimum of the other. At first glance, this result doesn’t appear to be surprising: the spatial resolution according to the Rayleigh criterion is equal to the nominal resolution. However, closer inspection reveals that the two objects nevertheless would be indistinguishable on a conventionally processed image: two neighboring image pixels would have the same gray value, and there is no way to tell whether the image originates from a single larger or two smaller objects. In order to distinguish the two objects, at least one image pixel with lower image amplitude needs to appear between the two. This is a first indication that the
digital resolution of the image needs also to be considered; this will be treated further in section 1.7. Lord Rayleigh himself was very critical towards his own rule to quantify the resolving power. He wrote [37]: “This rule is convenient on account of its simplicity and it is sufficiently accurate in view of the necessary uncertainty as to what exactly is meant by resolution.” The Rayleigh criterion is not an absolute, quantitative measure for the limit of resolution, but only indicates its order of magnitude. Indeed, there are even other criteria which are used in optics, for instance the less stringent Stokes-criterion. The difficulty to give an exact measure of resolving power is mainly due to the fact that the examined objects are not point sources, but have some finite dimensions and irregular shapes. In every single case, one would have to examine how accurately any claim about the exact position of
16
M . lion Kienlin and R. Pohmann
some border or the size of some object can be - the Rayleigh criterion can only give an indication. The best accurate statement that can be given is that the visualized image arises from a convolution of the real distribution with the pointspread function of the imaging method. 1.2
1.o
,
I
p . 0 4
0.8
x .-+
2a,
0.6
c
S .-
0.4
0.2
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
spatial coordinate r
Fig. 1.5: Rayleigh criterion in Fourier NMR imaging. The intensity between two image drops to 81% if the distance between two objects is just equal to the nominal resolution. According to the Rayleigh criterion, this is the minimal distance for the objects to be distinguishable.
1.7 Digital Resolution and Fourier Interpolation Up to here, only the influence of the acquisition parameters of a Fourier imaging method on the spatial resolution has been considered. The processing and the visualization methods also affect the ultimately obtained resolving power. In contrast to most optical instruments, NMR instruments usually use digitized signals and numerical processing prior to some graphical visualization. As long as there is no violation of the sampling condition (also called “Shannon theorem”), there is essentially no loss of information due to
I . Spatial Resolution in Spectroscopic Imaging
17
the digitization. Indeed, it is possible to show that -provided some requirements are fulfilled, which is the case in most practical situations - one can at any time switch to and fro between a discrete and a continuous representation of a signal: both representations are equivalent. The connection between a bandlimited, digitized signal and its analog counterpart is given by the Fourier interpolation [38]. The eye of a human observer only performs a linear interpolation between discrete points. Information contained in a signal which is only represented by its values at some discrete sample points can therefore remain invisible until Fourier interpolation has been conducted. On most instruments, it is easier not to apply some Fourier interpolation algorithm directly, but to expand the measured data with zeroes prior to Fourier transformation. Mathematically, this “Zerofilling” procedure is strictly equivalent to Fourier interpolation. In NMR spectroscopy, the importance of zero filling has been known for a long time. J. Lindon et al. for instance demonstrate an example where some line splitting became only visible after eightfold zero filling [39].
Fig. 1.6: Zero filling in NMR imaging. a) high-resolution NMR image of a phantom containing various structures. b) NMR image of the same phantom acquired with identical FOV, but with only 8 x 8 phase encoding steps. c) Image reconstructed from the same raw data as in (b), after zero filling to 256 x 256 points. The structures in the phantom can be distinguished much better yet all the information was already present in panel b).
The same holds true in NMR imaging. Figure 1.5 showed a situation where two sources with a distance of one voxel size have been imaged. On an image processed without zero filling, the two points appear in adjacent pixels. Both pixels have the same gray value, and one cannot decide whether these represent one larger or two smaller objects. Applying zero filling, the dip between the two maxima appears, and the two
18
M. von Kienlin and R. Pohmann
objects become discernible. The effect of zero filling in a two-dimensional image is further illustrated in Fig. l .6. Even if the positive effect of zero filling appears clearly, it is important to note that zero filling does not add any information to the signal: it only makes all the information contained in the signal visible to the observer. Now that the positive effect of zero filling is manifest, it may not be overestimated: zero filling only improves the digital resolution in discrete data, but by no means the spatial response function or the resolution according to the Rayleigh criterion! This important issue may become clearer knowing that zero filling mathematically is strictly equivalent to %oxel shifting [33,35,40-42]”. Voxel shifting means to shift the grid of data points in space, until a voxel fully covers the desired region in the object. This is used to reduce partial volume effects. Zero filling is a way to move the voxel in smaller steps across the object, resulting in a finer gridding - the size of the voxel remains unaffected.
1.8 Conclusion In Fourier spectroscopic imaging, one usually indicates the nominal resolution (i.e., the field-of-view divided by the number of phase encoding steps) as the resolving power. The goal of this contribution was to show the difficulty of defining what “spatial resolution” really means. When looking for the position of some small object, the resolution is mainly limited by the signal-to-noise ratio, and can be much better than the nominal resolution (cf. eqn. 1.18). When the separation of two objects is required, the Rayleigh criterion is a convenient indicator, which can be computed from the spatial response function. To fully exploit the information contained in the acquired data, Fourier interpolation (or zero filling) is essential to increase the digital resolution. When dealing with extended objects, an exact definition of resolution is not possible. The acquired image represents a convolution of the object with the pointspread function of the imaging method. This implies that signals can propagate across the whole image and lead to substantial contamination. A good shape of the pointspread function therefore is crucial for a high quality of the results, and this is particularly true in the low resolution images typically acquired in spectroscopic imaging. The Rayleigh criterion only considers the shape of the central section of the pointspread function, but disregards
1. Spuriul Resolution in Spectroscopic Imuging
19
any undulations on its baseline. These undulations can be significantly reduced by some spatial filtering applied during processing - at the cost of reduced resolution. No penalty in resolution or sensitivity has to be paid when using acquisition weighted spectroscopic imaging [33,40,42-47]. These techniques can significantly reduce the signal contamination between adjacent voxels, and should be employed in any spectroscopic imaging experiment. Finally, the spatial resolution can be somewhat increased by including a priori knowledge in the data reconstruction. Examples are the limited support assumption [48], extrapolation of k-space in the Papoulis-Gerchberg algorithm [49,50] or the incorporation about geometric information of compartments in the object [51]. A full discussion of these modern techniques is beyond the scope of this article.
References 1.
0. Morse, J. R. Singer, Science 170 (1970) 440.
2.
J. Ackerman, T. Grove, G. Wong et al., Nature 283 (1980) 167.
3.
R. Damadian, L. Minkoff, M. Goldsmith et al., Science 194 (1976) 1430.
4.
R. E. Gordon, P. E. Hanley, D. Shaw, et al., Nature 287 (1980) 736.
5.
R. E. Gordon, P. E. Hanley, D. Shaw, Prog. NMR Spectrosc. 15 (1982) 1.
6.
P. Bendel, C.-M. Lai, P. C. Lauterbur, J. Mugn. Reson. 38 (1980) 343.
7.
W. P. Aue, S. Miiller, T. A. Cross, J. Seelig, J. Magn. Reson. 56 (1984) 350.
8.
P. A. Bottomley, T. B. Foster, R. D. Darrow, J. Mugn. Reson. 59 (2) (1984) 338.
9.
R. J. Ordidge, A. Connelly, J. A. B. Lohman, J. Magn. Reson. 66 (1986) 283.
10.
G. C. McKinnon, 5th Annual Meeting of the SMRM (1986) 168.
11.
J. Frahm, K. D. Merboldt, W. Hanicke, J. Mugn. Reson. 7 2 (1987) 502.
12.
R. Kimmich, D. Hoepfel, J. Mugn. Reson. 7 2 (1987) 379.
13.
P. A. Bottomley, US Putenr4,480,228 (1984)
14.
A. Kumar, D. Welti, R. R. Ernst, J. Magn. Reson. 18 (1975) 69.
15.
T. R. Brown, B. Kincaid, K. Ugurbil, Proc. Nutl. Acad. Sci. USA79 (1982) 3523.
16.
A. A. Maudsley, A. Oppelt, A. Ganssen, Siemens Forsch. 8 (1979) 326.
17.
A. Maudsley, S. Hilal, W. Perman, H. Simon, J. Mugn. Reson. 51 (1983) 147.
18.
J. Haselgrove, V. Subramanian, J. Leigh et al., Science 220 (1983) 1170.
19. I. L. Pykett, B. R. Rosen, Radiology 149 (1983) 197. 20.
M. Dtcorps and D. Bourgeois, NMRBasic Principles and Progress 27, (1992) 119
21.
D. B. Twieg, SPIE347 (1982) 354.
22.
A. Bax, A. F. Mehlkopf, J. Smidt, J. Magn. Reson. 35 (1979) 373.
20
M. von Kienlin and R. Pohmunn
23.
K. F. King, P. R. Moran, Med. Phys. 11 (1984) 1.
24.
P. B. Barker, B. D. Ross, J. Mugn. Reson. 75 (1987) 467.
25.
L. D. Hall, S. Sukumar, J. Mugn. Reson. 50 (1982) 161.
26.
P. C. Lauterbur, D. N. Levin, R. B. M a r , J. Mugn. Reson. 59 (1984) 536.
27.
Y. Manassen, G. Navon, J. Mugn. Reson. 61 (1985) 363.
28.
E. Feig, F. Greenleaf, Appl. Optics 24 (1985) 3977.
29.
H. W. Park, Z. H. Cho, Mugn. Reson. Med. 3 (1986) 448.
30.
A. Haase, D. Matthaei, J. Mugn. Reson. 71 (1987) 550.
31.
F. J. Harris, ProcIEEE66 (1978) 51.
32.
C. van Uijen, J. den Boef, F. Verschuren. Mugn. Reson. Med. 2 (1985) 203.
33.
H. R. Brooker, T. H. Mareci, J. T. Mao, Mugn. Reson. Med. 5 (1987) 417.
34.
E. M. Haacke, 2. -P. Liang, S. H. Izen, Med. Phys. 16 (1989) 388.
35.
P. Bottomley, C. Hardy, P. Roemer, R. Weiss, NMR Biomed. 2 (1989) 284.
36.
J. R. Taylor, An Introduction to Error Analysis, University Science Books, Mill Valley, 1982
37.
Lord Rayleigh, Phil. Mug. 8 (1 879) 261.
38.
E. 0. Brigham, Prentice Hall International, London, 1974.
39.
J. C. Lindon, A. G. Ferrige, Prog. NMR Spectros. 14 (1980) 27.
40.
T. H. Mareci, H. R. Brooker, J. Mugn. Reson. 57, (1984) 157.
41.
D. Twieg, D. Meyerhoff, B. Hubesch et al., Mugn. Reson. Med. 12 (1989) 291.
42.
T. H. Mareci, H. R. Brooker, J. Mugn. Reson. 92 (1991) 229.
43.
M. Garwood, T. Schleich, B. Ross et al., J. Mugn. Reson. 65 (1985) 239.
44.
D. L. Parker, G. T. Gullberg, P. R. Frederick, Med. Phys. 14 (1987) 640.
45.
Y. Le Fur, Dissertation, University Joseph Fourier, Grenoble (France), 1993.
46.
A. G. Webb, T. H. Mareci, R. W. Briggs, J. Mugn. Reson. B 103 (1994) 274.
47.
P. Hodgkinson, R. Kemp-Harper, P. Hore, J. Mugn. Reson. B 105 (1994) 256.
48.
S. Plevritis, A. Macovski, IEEE Trans. Medical Imaging 14 (1995) 487.
49.
A. Papoulis, IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. CAS (1975) 735.
50.
R. W. Gerchberg, Opticu Actu 21 (1974) 709.
51.
M. von Kienlin, R. Mejia, J. Mugn. Reson. 94 (1991) 268.
2. CYCLCROP Mapping of 13 C Labelled Compounds: Perspectives in Polymer Science and Plant Physiology M . Heidenreichl, A. Spyros’, W.Kockenberge?, N. Chandrakumarl *, R. Bowtel12,and R. Kimmichl Sektion Kernresonanzspektroskopie, Albert Einstein Allee 11, Universitat Ulm, 89069 Ulm, Germany * On leave from the Central Leather Research Institute, Madras, India Magnetic Resonance Centre, Department of Physics, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, United Kingdom
Abstract The 13C nucleus has scarcely been considered as a nucleus for magnetic resonance imaging. The reasons are the low natural abundance and the low gyromagnetic ratio so that the sensitivity appears to be not particularly promising. However, 13C NMR imaging and spectroscopy can be of particular interest in experiments where high chemical shift selectivity is required to identify a certain molecule of interest. The wide range of chemical shifts of the 13C nucleus makes such unambiguous identification possible even under demanding conditions which are encountered for example in heterogeneous mixtures or in vivo experiments. Furthermore, the low natural abundance of the 13C nucleus allows its use as a tracer which, once incorporated into the samples, permits to follow its redistribution or conversion into newly formed products in a time resolved manner. In close analogy to conventional radioactive tracers, this labelling strategy opens a whole class of in vivo experiments to be performed, but with the additional advantages of product identification and the non-invasive spatial mapping without any radioactive emission. Indirect detection of the 13C nucleus via proton signals combines an optimal NMR sensitivity with the potential of 13C NMR. Here we are referring to the cyclic J crosspolarization technique (CYCLCROP) which is based on two consecutive J cross-polari-
22
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrukumnr, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
zation steps with an intermediate module for the saturation of all non-selected proton signals. To our experience, CYCLCROP turned out to be particularly reliable, robust and convenient. Indirectly detected 13C NMR imaging on this basis is demonstrated in heterogeneous polymer mixtures and with the observation of the synthesis and movement of labelled sucrose in plants.
2.1 Introduction Up to now I3C has scarcely been judged as a nucleus suitable for magnetic resonance imaging. The reasons are the low natural abundance and the low gyromagnetic ratio so that the sensitivity appears to be rather unfavorable. However, the latter problem can be overcome by recording proton signals edited in such a way that only hydrogen nuclei coupled to 13C are detected whereas signals due to all other protons are suppressed. That is, using double-resonance radio frequency (rf) pulse sequences designed appropriately, 13C nuclei in hydrocarbon groups can be detected in principle with about the same sensitivity as an equal number of protons. In particular, if the spatial distribution of I3C enriched compounds is to be mapped, one can expect reasonable acquisition times permitting a good temporal resolution. Labelling of compounds by isotopic enrichment makes only sense if background signals due to natural abundance are minor. That is, the low natural abundance of I3C may be considered as an advantage rather than a drawback.
Proton detected I3C imaging schemes might be regarded as an alternative to spectroscopic proton imaging of hydrocarbon distributions, i.e. a more conventional but easy to apply method (for a comparison see ref. [I]). However, the main motivation for hydrocarbon monitoring employing 13C nuclei is the rather unique potential of chemically inert labelling. Furthermore chemically selective signal generation can easily be achieved as a consequence of the about ten times wider chemical shift range of 13C relative to protons. Mapping of concentrations of pre-selected compounds of interest thus becomes possible. The spatial distribution of products of chemical reactions taking place in the course of the experiments can also be selectively imaged. For biological systems this means that metabolisms can be studied in a particularly informative way. In the literature different principles of proton-detected 13C imaging have been suggested [2-51. These include SEDOR (Spin Echo Double Resonance, a two-transient
2. CYCLCROPMapping of”C Labelled Compounds
23
subtraction method [4]), HYCAT (Hydrogen CArbon Tomography, a single-transient multiple-quantum filtering technique [3]), and CYCLCROP (CYCLic J CROss-Polari-
Zation, a scheme based on rotating-frame coherence transfer back and forth between the two nuclear species [ 5 ] ) . With the SEDOR method, similarly large signals are subtracted from each other leading to small differences which are unavoidably prone to severe experimental errors. HYCATand other pulse schemes implying free-evolution intervals in the spectral editing part of the sequence tend to be subjected to motional artifacts. We have therefore focused on cyclic cross-polarization techniques from which to our experience the CYCLCROP method turned out to be particularly reliable, robust, and convenient. The insensitivity to motions within the sample and the radio frequency power deposition has been tested and discussed in ref. [6]. In the following we first describe the basic principle of rotating-frame cross-polarization (CP) [7,8]. The transfer efficiency and the susceptibility to Hartmannmahn m i s match of diverse CP schemes are discussed. In section 2.3 we describe the CYCLCROP imaging pulse sequence employed in the 13C’mappingstudies referred to later on. The influence of relaxation is discussed in view of how quantitative 13C concentrations can be mapped. Section 2.4 contains an application to polymer science. The selective mapping of different polymer species in mixtures is demonstrated. As a second field of useful applications transport and metabolism of 13C enriched (i.e. labelled) hexoses were studied in plants. This not only demonstrates the temporally resolved migration of the labelled compounds into the plants, but also their chemical conversion by metabolism. Finally the future prospects of the technique also with respect to biomedical applications are outlined.
2.2 Principles of Rotating Frame Cross-Polarization 2.2.1
The Oscillatory JCP Process
Originally cross-polarization in the rotating fi-ame was invented primarily as a method for NMR sensitivity enhancement of rare spins with low gyromagnetic ratio y in the solid state. This is accomplished by tapping the much higher polarization of abundant high y
24
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
spins, especially protons. In their pioneering 1962 work [q Hartmann and Hahn also indicated the application of the technique to solution state J cross-polarization (JCP) where one is dealing with spin systems comprising only a few spins. The essential idea of CP is the realization that polarization could be transferred by matching the resonance frequencies of the two spin species in the rotating frame, under rf irradiation - even though their Larmor frequencies in the laboratory frame differ widely. Thus HurtmundHuhn match with respect to the rf fields B,,,, B I S is specified by the condition on-resonance:
where the indices Z and S refer to the two coupled spin species. One may arrange to satisfy the above with respect to rf field amplitudes, although not with respect to the Zeeman field Bo:
Under Hartmanflahn match, dipolar couplings in the solid state
-
or J couplings in
solution state - then effect the desired transfer of magnetization - or more generally, of coherence. Assuming rf irradiation for each spin to be along the x axis of the (doubly) rotating frame, the effective JCP Hamiltonian in the rf interaction frame (otherwise known generally as the toggling frame, or specifically in the context of CP as the synchronized doubly rotating frame) takes the following form when Hartmanflahn match is satisfied
181: -
H = $(ZySy + ZzSz)
The great merit of cross-polarization for practical applications is its ability to effect inphase magnetization transfer, as may be seen with reference to a two-spin-112 AX system:
1,
Ht
> l2z , (1 + COS(RJt))+ 3s. (1 - cos(nJt)) (2.4)
+ (zYsz - z,~,)sin(n~t)
2. CYCLCROPMapping of 13C Labelled Compounds
25
For this prototype spin system, magnetization residing initially on the spin I (X) is thus completely transformed into magnetization residing on spin S(A) after a cross-polarization time t = J-' , in an experiment that commences with the establishment of transverse I magnetization in phase with the subsequent I spin rf irradiation. In-phase transfer occurs because the coupling between the two heteronuclear species, which is weak by definition - owing to truncation of non-secular terms in the doubly rotating frame has been transformed under the influence of matched rf fields into a strong coupling which has axial symmetry in spin operator space.
2.2.2
Damped Coherence Transfer
In practice, quantitative transfer at the theoretical mixing time occurs - even in a twospin-1/2 AX system - only when spectral linewidths are much smaller than the coupling constant in question, J. To assess the effect of relaxation processes occurring during cross-polarization, we may define a coherence transfer function f(t), employing a coherence damping term with an effective rotating-frame relaxation time constant Tp,effto damp the oscillatory term corresponding to transverse S(A) magnetization in eqn. (2.4): f(t) =
(
t ( ~ - c o s ( . n ~ r ) ) e x p--
TP:B
)
With a Tp,eEsuch that the 'linewidth' Av = (.nTp,eff)-lranges from one-tenth to the full coupling, for example, we find from eqn. (2.5) the ranges for the optimum cross-polarization times and maximum transfers, respectively, as being 94% to 50% and 74% to 10% of the values predicted by eqn. (2.4). Note, however, that coherence damping active during the cross-polarization process could be slower than T2.
26
M. Heidenreich. A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger. N . Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
0.2 -
0.0.
*
1
0.2
.
*
.
*
I
0-4&
*
1
.
[ J ] 0.6
a
*
1
*
*
a
0.8
1.o
Fig. 2.1: Transfer efficiency and optimum contact times topt for the single J cross-polarization as a function of the 'linewidth Av = ( ~ T , , , ~ f f ) - l .
2.2.3
HartmandHahn Mismatch
The price paid for in-phase transfer and a possibly longer effective relaxation time is, however, continuous rf irradiation and high sensitivity to Hurtnznnn/Huhn mismatch, transfer efficiency reducing to 50% for a mismatch k that amounts to half the coupling. Indeed, with the mismatch parameter defined on-resonance as: k=,, A
A=v
1I
-v1s
(2.6a)
we find for the modified average Hamiltonian : -
H = f ( ( Z y S y+ZzSz)+k(Zx -Sx))
This leads to modified coherence transfer in a two-spin-1/2 AX system [9,10]:
(2.6b)
2.CYCLCROPMapping of 13C Lubelled Compounds -
Ix+ Ht
L
Z
27
x
2(1+4k2)
+ 2(1+4k2) L S x { l
-
cos[ (1 + 4k2)'7CJtl
+ (1+4k2) (z ,S, + I , Sz)
{
1- cos[ (1 + 4 k 2 ) i m ] }
+1 .J1+4k2 (ZyS, - Z z S y ) {sin[ (1 + 4 k 2 ) ' ~ J t ] ] The maximum in-phase transfer clearly corresponds now to the maximum value of the coefficient of the S, term in eqn. (2.71, i. e., (1+4k2)-I. The mismatch characteristics of JCP makes it a delicate sequence for solution state applications. However, this limitation has been overcome by a number of strategies, including refocused JCP [10,11], conversion to heteronuclear zero quantum coherence [ 121 or the use of phase alternated pulse sequences to effect coherence transfer under JCP [ 13,141. Continuous, phase modulated irradiation is the principal strategy employed currently to effect broadband JCP. Several schemes of this kind are in use, including those based on MOZST [6], WALTZ [15] and DIPSI; MGS-type sequences [161 belong in this same general category. The performance of these sequences on-resonance may be judged straightaway on the basis of the zeroth order average Hamiltonian that they give rise to. Numerical simulation would appear preferable to map the off-resonance behavior.
28
2.2.4
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakurnar, R. Bowtell, R. Krnmich
Mismatch Optimized IS Transfer (MOIST)
It may be readily shown, for instance, that the average oflset Hamiltonian for MOIST (which is a back-to-back phase alternated pulse sequence of the form 8x(x,,,)- 8,(~,)) takes the form:
H
=
6Zz
-
-
= -J[Ze
z sine
+
~,(cos0-1)]
Qx
.
Q-x
.
Fig. 2.2: Element of the back-to-back phase alternated MOIST pulse sequence.
Here, 6 is the resonance offset, 8 refers to the individual pulse flip angle in the back-toback phase alternated pulse sequence, while 7, is the individual pulse duration, the sequence cycle time being 27,; H refers to the Hamiltonian in the toggling frame [17]. The average Hamiltonian for bilinear z coupling, on the other hand, takes the form:
H
=
JZzSz
(2.9) -&(l-C0S28)
(zysz+ z z s y ) ]
This expression reduces to the desired form of eqn. (2.3) for 8 = nn (n = 1,2,...).
29
2. CYCLCROPMupping of 13C Labelled Compounds
2.2.5
Pulsed Rotating Frame Transfer Sequence with Windows (PRAWN)
It turns out, however, that for the application in view, i.e., selective, on-resonance transfer of magnetization within a specific coupled proton-carbon spin system (of type AX, AX, or AX,, where X indicates protons), a simple possibility exists to achieve JCP highly efficiently, and with a useful degree of tolerance to Hartmann-Hahn mismatch. We have shown recently [ 181 that highly windowed cyclic pulse sequences with constant pulse phase, say x,flip angle 8 and pulse interval T,, issued on both spin channels, fit the bill very well indeed. They may be represented as (8, - T&.
Fig.2.3: Windowed cyclic pulse sequence on which the PRAWN method is based.
Cyclicity (or unimodularity) implies simply that n8 = 27c. Typically just one cycle of the sequence is required to cover the JCP mixing period. These sequences, which we term PRAWN (Pulsed Rotating frame trAnsfer sequence with WiNdows), have proved extremely desirable because of their robustness, very low rf power deposition and consequent acceptability both from the point of view of the sample and the probehead electronics. Furthermore, they are very undemanding on the hardware in the sense that no rf phase or amplitude modulation is employed throughout the mixing sequence. The average offset Hamiltonian of PRAWN takes the following form, which is independent of the sequence parameters: n
n
n
+%I,
++
C (sin me - sin(m - i)e) m=l n
I
c
m=l
(cos me-cos(m - l)8) = 0
(2.10)
30
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakurnar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
For the case 0 = 2n, the average offset Hamiltonian takes the form:
For bilinear weak coupling, the average Hamiltonian now takes the parameter independent form:
+z(zzsy + I Y S ,j
1
~(cos(2Pn~)-cos(2(~-1)0)) [m=l
For the two cases corresponding to 0 = n: and 0 = 27c, however, we find:
The tolerance of PRAWN to Hartmann-Hahn mismatch may be understood in terms of the fact that any number of PRAWN sequences would be possible in principle, subject only to cyclicity; in particular, the low flip angle solutions cluster closely together. Equivalently, it may be said that PRAWN effectively scales up or transforms the mismatch tolerance of continuous wave (CW) JCP by the inverse of the duty cycle factor. PRAWN sequences have the further interesting property of being tunable for broadband or for narrowband applications. For example, by simply inserting a single n: pulse in the middle of the cycle on both spin channels (i. e., (0, - T,),/~ - (n:)$ - (0, - QnI2), and depending on its phase, either the bandwidth may be substantially reduced ((I = x) - or alternatively the mismatch tolerance substantially increased ((I= t y ) ; further, this strat-
2. CYCLCROP Mapping of 13C Labelled Compounds
31
egy offers the capability of selective transfer under a remote coupling while refocusing couplings to directly bonded spins. On the other hand, the bandwidth may be substantially increased by inserting a 7c pulse in the middle of every (0 - TJ segment. Other such refocusing options are clearly available to generate a range of behaviour.
2.2.6
Coherence Transfer Spectra
The actual behaviour of various mixing sequences for JCP may be readily determined experimentally by means of coherence ti*aizsfer spectra, which correspond to the Fourier transformation of the coherence transfer functionf(t), of eqn. 2.5. These may be simply obtained by acquiring a series of JCP free-induction decays, as a function of the JCP mixing time, which may be systematically incremented from experiment to experiment. A double Fourier transformation, once with respect to the normal acquisition time t2 and a second time with respect to the variable mixing time tl then generates the desired coherence transfer spectrum along the F , dimension, for each transition in F2. The PRAWN family of sequences also permits a quick 1D acquisition of the CT spectrum by sampling during the windows of the sequence, at the expense of information relating to the relevant individual transitions.
2.2.7
Adiabatic J Cross-Polarization
A quite different strategy may, on the other hand, be adopted to effect J cross-polarization, as well. This is the approach of adiabatic J cross-polarization [19,201. Here, the rf irradiation amplitude on spin Z(X) is decreased while that on spin S(A) is increased adiabatically, following initial establishment of transverse Z spin magnetization in phase with the subsequent Z spin rf irradiation. In a two-spin-112 system, for example, the avoided crossing between the levels T 1 ) and 1 T ) results in the desired polarization
I
I
transfer. The transfer is no longer oscillatory and can be accomplished in a J-independent manner if adiabaticity is satisfied with respect to the smallest coupling. Typically, simple linear ramps may be used to effect the adiabatic passage in rf amplitudes, the ramp time T being of the order of lo2 ms. The rate of passage must satisfy the condition of adiabaticity :
32
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
(2.14) Here, wll is the rf field amplitude on spin I, while
is the effective rf amplitude inclu-
sive of the effect of resonance offset Amop
0
T
Fig. 2.4: Radio frequency pulses for adiabatic J cross-polarization (AJCP).
The bandwidth over which adiabatic J cross-polarization works is in turn governed by the rf field mismatch at the start and at the end of the ramp-time, respectively, for the S and the I spins:
Considering typical contact times and power deposition levels, however, it appears that
AJCP is sub-optimal for applications that require selective J cross-polarization.
33
2.CYCLCROPMapping of 13C Labelled Compounds
2.3 Pulse Sequences for Cyclic J CrossPolarization Imaging 2.3.1
The Cyclic J Cross-PolarizationImaging Scheme
The CYCLCROP pulse sequence for indirect mapping of 13C concentrations consists of two sections, the spectral-editing part and the imaging part (Fig. 2.5) [5,8]. The purpose of spectral editing procedure is to select a certain resonance while all other signals are suppressed. The selectivity achieved in this way permits one to specifically address the chemical compounds of interest. The resulting selective proton coherences are then used for conventional proton magnetic resonance imaging rendering information on the spatial distribution of the pre-selected compound. The imaging method can be any of the well known standard NMR imaging pulse schemes [ S ] .
sL
'
1
Fig. 2.5: Basic CYCLCROP pulse scheme for proton-detected chemical-shift selective 13C spin density mapping.
34
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandt-akumnr,R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
The spectral-editing principle may be illustrated by considering a small J coupled spin system such as a CHN group within a certain compound. In a first step, the 13C magnetization is enhanced by cross-polarization from the proton to the 13C side. The resulting 13C rotating-frame coherences are then stored in the form of z-magnetization. That is, it is not effected by the subsequent comb of gradient - and proton rf pulses serving to saturate the levels and to spoil any coherences of all protons (see section 2.3.3). The second cross-polarization pathway leads inversely from the 13C to the proton side. The 13C magnetization stored before is now transferred back to proton rotatingframe coherences. The only signal detectable at the end of the editing cycle thus arises from protons coupled to 13Cin the selected CHN group.
2.3.2
Transfer Efficiency and Selectivity of CYCLCROP
If the case of off-resonance irradiation is included, the Hartmandahn condition [7,8] reads generally:
where Beff,[ and Beg,S represent the magnetic flux densities effective for protons and 13C nuclei in the doubly rotating frame, respectively. Violation of the Hartmanmahn condition either by B,-field mismatch andlor by off-resonant irradiation leads to a reduced transfer efficiency. The relative roles played by B1-field mismatch and off- resonant irradiation depend on the pulse scheme employed. They need not to be equivalent. The MOIST [13,14] and PRAWN [18] variants of J cross-polarization, which were used in the applications to be described in the following are B, compensated but nevertheless remain frequency selective. That is, these methods are easy to use even under in vivo conditions without sacrificing the high spectral selectivity of the 13C nucleus. As mentioned before, the efficiency of proton to carbon polarization transfer depends on the spin system size. For AX (IS) systems, the proton polarization is completely transferred to the carbon side whereas for A2X (Z2S) and A3X (Z3S) systems only 50 and 35% of the proton magnetization is exploited, respectively. That is, the resulting 13C polarization is essentially the same irrespective of the number of coupled protons. In the absence of relaxation effects, the finally acquired proton CYCLCROP signal intensity Sois expected to reflect the spin density ps of the S nucleus according to [21]
2. CYCLCROPMapping of 13C Labelled Compounds
system, respectively.
35
(2.17)
For quantitative concentration mapping it may be important to take reZaxation effects into account. The signal intensity may then be estimated with the aid of the modified formula
WI
where Tp,effis the relaxation time of the total spin system effective during the crosspolarization period topt, as defined in eqn. 2.5. The quantities TI,^ and T2,1 are the longitudinal and transverse proton relaxation times, respectively. The longitudinal relaxation time of the 13C spins is represented by . The time required for proton saturation and coherence spoiling is denoted by T,,. Finally, TR is the recycle delay of the pulse sequence implying the echo time TE. In most cases, the 13C carbon longitudinal relaxation times are much longer than the interval needed to saturate the proton spin levels and to spoil proton coherences. Therefore the last factor in eqn. (2.18) almost always approaches unity. The first exponential factor in eqn. (2.18) plays a role only whenever the effective relaxation times in the doubly rotating frame are in the order of typical contact times tOpt5 .I(see ' Fig. 2.1). On the other hand, longitudinal and transverse proton relaxation losses can be kept minor if the parameters TR and TE are chosen long and short enough, respectively. Keeping these factors in mind, it should be possible to evaluate 13C spin density maps quantitatively with reasonable accuracy from CYCLCROP imaging experiments.
36
2.3.3
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W.Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
Saturation Schemes
In special cases such as with applications to polymers (vide infia) proton coherences in the interval between forward and backward cross-polarization can be spoiled by a short “blank“ delay of a few milliseconds in which the coherences die away owing to the short proton T; values in such materials [22]. Otherwise proton saturation and coherence spoiling is achieved by “suppression by mismatched echo and repetitive gradient episodes“ [23]. That is, a train of hard rf pulses with subsequent field gradient pulses is applied. The hard rf pulses may be replaced by adiabatic halfpassages in combination with field gradient pulses (see the pulse scheme shown in Fig. 2.5) [24]. This turned out to be particularly favourable in the plant experiments to be described below. The major difficulties in this context were: (i) the ratio of T2 and Tl is no longer small, (ii) the proton resonances to be saturated are dispersed over a wide range of proton frequencies, and (iii) the sample extends beyond the homogeneous volume of the rf coil. The adiabatic half passages permitted us to obtain good results despite of extreme B1-field inhomogeneities. Typically four adiabatic half passages were applied with their frequencies shifted towards the most intense resonance: in our case the water signal. Moreover a simple twostep phase cycle was employed in order to remove all possible residual proton signals having leaked through the spectral-editing process.
2.4 Selective Mapping of Polymer Species in Mixtures Special polymers and most polymeric products used in everyday applications are heterogeneous materials, either blends of different polymers, or mixtures of polymer and additives such as fillers, cross-linking agents, antioxidants, etc. CYCLCROP imaging has the ability to probe the spatial distribution of one component out of an heterogeneous polymeric material, and is therefore ideal for the study of inhomogeneities, phase separation, or ageing in such systems. Elastomers represent a class of commercially important polymers which can be studied using conventional ‘high resolution’ imaging techniques due to their reduced static linewidth resulting from a combination of increased segmental
2. CYCLCROPMapping of I3C Labelled Compounds
37
mobility and reduced crystallinity. For this reason they represent an excellent candidate for the demonstration of advantages of CYCLCROP in selective mapping of polymers in heterogeneous mixtures.
2.4.1
Heterogeneous 13C Labelled Polymer Systems
cis-Polyisopreneand Polybutadiene CYCLCROP imaging was first tested in a polymer sample consisting of a mixture of cispolyisoprene, PI, and polybutadiene, PB. PI was 54% 13C-enrichedat the methylene C-4
position and was synthesized in the laboratory (Fig. 2.6). The sample was constructed by mixing 43 mg of PI with 31 mg PB in a perspex holder, heating for -3 h at 60 "C in an oven and cooling for a period of several weeks at room temperature. This procedure resulted in the preparation of an heterogeneous polymer mixture containing 58% w/w PI. Smaller quantities of pure PI and PB were placed at the higher left and right corner, respectively, of the perspex sample holder to serve as external reference. Fig. 2.7a presents the conventional 'H image of this PIPB sample. A rather homogeneous distribution of proton intensity throughout the sample is observed. Both PI and PB external references can be seen.
5CH3
\ L
'C =3CH
JX
Fig. 2.6: Polyisoprene, PI, 54% 13C enriched at the methylene C-4 position (*)
The CYCLCROP image of the PIPB mixture using the MOIST cross-polarization variant, with the lH and I3C channel frequencies centered on the 13CH, moiety of PI is presented in Fig. 2.7b. The PI reference can still be seen in the upper left comer of the image, whle the PB reference at the upper right produces no intensity at all. Thus it can be concluded that the CYCLCROP image of the polymer mixture represents the spatial
38
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenbergei; N. Chandrukumur, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
distribution of PI in this sample. With the help of the PI and PB references, difference images can be produced by subtracting the scaled CYCLCROP image (cf. eqn. 2.17) of Fig. 2.7b from the conventional proton image of Fig. 2.7a, scaling being empirically adjusted to give minimum intensity at the PI reference. The resulting semi-quantitative difference IH image is displayed in Fig. 2 . 7 ~and represents the spatial distribution of PB in the polymer mixture, as can be easily verified by the appearance of the PB reference in the upper right. It is important to note that in the 1D proton spectrum of the PIPB sample the H-4 methylene resonance of PI are covered by an unresolved broad peak of the PI H-1, H-5 and the methylene protons of PB. After editing with CYCLCROP the proton spectrum consists of a single resonance resulting from the H-4 methylene protons of PI, with all other proton resonances successfully suppressed. Thus, the lack of resolution in the nonedited 'H spectrum of a polymer mixture does not present any obstacle for performing the cyclic CP transfer, and it is demonstrated that CYCLCROP allows the 13C-edited imaging even of completely unresolved proton peaks. For reasons of comparison a 13C direct detected image of the PVPB sample was also acquired. Although its appearance was similar to that of the CYCLCROP image of Fig. 2.7b, the S/N of the 13C image was 2.8 times smaller than that of the CYCLCROP image, under identical experimental imaging conditions. Thus the time needed to acquire a CYCLCROP image is 1/8 of that needed for a directly detected 13C image of the same S/N, resulting in significant savings in experimental time for the acquisition of I3C-edited images of elastomeric materials.
cis-Polyisoprene and Polyhydroxyoctanoate Figure 2.8 shows the CYCLCROP images of another polymer mixture, a homogeneous blend of PI and polyhydroxyoctanoute, PHO, recorded to compare the efficiency of the two different CP variants, MOIST and PRAWN. Although both PRAWN and MOIST are very efficient in selectively editing the PI signals and suppressing the PHO reference visible on the top right of the conventional lH image, the S/N ratio of the image acquired with PRAWN is about 65% of the MOIST variant. A 50% rf duty cycle was used for PRAWN in the imaging of the PI/PHO blend. CYCLCROP experiments performed on polymer solutions showed that both methods are equally efficient in effecting CP [22], in accordance with a recent application of this technique to the imaging of sugar metabolism in plants [21]. Thus, it appears that the reduced S/N of the PRAWN image in bulk PWHO is a result of the relaxation properties and the heterogeneity of elastomers in the bulk phase compared to solution.
2. CYCLCROPMapping of "C Labelled Compounds
39
Fig. 2.7: 1H NMR images of a PVPB sample, no slice selection, sample thickness -1 mm: (a) conventional 1H NMR image showing the PI and PB references and the PVPB mixture. Parameter values: FOV 2 x 2 cm*; Read gradient 81 mT/m; Phase gradient 43 mT/m; TR = 0.5 s; TE = 2.4 ms; pixel matrix 256 x 64 zero-filled to 256 x 256. @) CYCLCROP image of the same sample with MOIST tuned to the frequencies of the methylene C-4 group of PI, and displaying the spatial distribution of PI in the polymer mixture. The PB reference is no longer visible. Same parameter values as in (a), but l k transients; experiment time 7.5h. (c) Difference image (a)-(b) normalized empirically to minimum overall intensity at the PI reference (top left). Qualitative information regarding the distribution of PB in the polymer mixture is obtained from this difference image.
40
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
Fig. 2.8: 1H NMR images of a PLPHO blend, no slice selection, sample thickness -1mm: (a) conventional 1H NMR image showing the PHO reference (top right) and the PWHO blend. Parameter values: FOV 2 x 2 cmz; Read gradient 81 mT/m; Phase gradient 43 mT/m; TR= 0.5 s; TE = 2.4 ms; pixel matrix 256 x 64 zero-filled to 256 x 256. (b)-(c) CYCLCROP image of the same sample tuned to the frequencies of the methylene C-4 group of PI, using PRAWN (b), and MOIST (c) and displaying the spatial distribution of PI in the polymer blend. The PHO reference is no longer visible. Same parameter values as in (a), experiment time 7.5h.
2. CYCLCROPMapping of I3CLnbelled Compounds
41
Bulk magnetic susceptibility and spin diffusion are factors that become important in the solid state [25]. Since with PRAWN rf irradiation is not ‘on’ continuously it is possible that semi-rigid or interphase regions close to crystallites, where spin diffusion is more effective, are less likely to be efficiently cross-polarized. This means that the reduced intensity and the somewhat different contrast obtained in the PRAWN image of the PVPHO blend in Fig. 2.8 could be related to the absence of contribution to the signal intensity from regions of lower mobility. Thus it is demonstrated that an additional relaxation contrast might be created with CYCLCROP depending on the method (MOIST or PRAWN) used to achieve the cyclic polarization transfer.
2.4.2
Natural Abundance 13C Samples
Finally, Fig. 2.9 depicts the IH and CYCLCROP images of a sample consisting of a piece of natural abundance PI placed next to a piece of a common laboratory hose. Although both are visible in the ‘H image, only the PI piece can be seen in the CYCLCROP image, while any signal from the rubber hose has been edited out. The above images demonstrate the applicability of CYCLCROP for the acquisition of I3Cedited images of natural abundance elastomeric materials of moderate size.
Fig. 2.9: 1H NMR images of the PUrubber hose sample: (a) conventional 1H NMR image showing both polymer pieces. Parameter values: FOV 4 x 4 cm2; Read gradient 41 mT/m; Phase gradient 44 mT/m; TR = 0.5 s; TE = 2.4 ms; pixel matrix 256 x 128 zero-filled to 256 x 256. (b) CYCLCROP image of the same sample with MOIST tuned to the frequencies of the methine C-3 group of PI, where the proton signal from the rubber hose has been eliminated. Parameter values: FOV 4 x 4 cm2; Read gradient 41 mT/m; Phase gradient 11 mT/m; TR = 0.6 s; TE= 2.4 ms; pixel matrix 256 x 32 zero-filled to 256 x 256; 128 transients; experiment time 43 min.
42
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
2.5 Spatially and Temporally Resolved Study of Transport and Metabolism in Plants 2.5.1
Motivation
In plants not all leaves are equally able to produce energy rich compounds by CO, fixation and photosynthesis. Developing leaves, fruits, shoots and roots rely on the import of energy rich compounds from more mature leaves (sources). Plants possess a specialised tissue, the phloem, in which photoassimilates such as sucrose are conducted from the source to the site of their consumption (sinks). In this tissue a system of communicating small tubular cells (sieve tubes) expands through the whole plant. The investigation of the mechanism and the control of the transport process has long been of great interest to plant physiologists since the partitioning of photoassimilates between different plant organs has a strong effect on growth patterns of the whole plant and particularly on the development of agricultural products such as tubers and fruit [26].
Conventional Techniques Several techniques can be used to monitor long distance transport in plants. A common tool is the application of 14C labelled compounds [27,28]. After supplying either 14C0, or other labelled compounds such as sucrose to the source leaves, the accumulation of radioactivity is measured in other parts of the plant by harvesting and sectioning of the plant, followed by determination of radioactivity in the plant tissue. Since for each point in a time course study of radioactivity accumulation a new plant must be harvested, the data obtained in this manner are strongly affected by natural physiological variations between different plants. Ideally a non-destructive technique is required to make time course studies with a single plant possible. Such a technique is labelling of photoassimilates with 11C02 [29-311. The movement of the incorporated llC tracer within the intact plant can be observed with external monitors since the decay of the isotope l l C results in the emission of p and y rays. Unfortunately it is difficult to identify the compound in which the 'C tracer has been incorporated because the isotope has a short half-life time
(zlI2 = 20.4 min) and a rapid extraction and separation technique is therefore required. Recently the versatility of lH NMR microimaging techniques in plant physiology has been successfully demonstrated in the in vivo study of metabolite distribution in small plants [32-371. Using this non-invasive technique, metabolic maps with high spatial
2. CYCLCROPMapping
0f13cLabelled
Compounds
43
resolution can be obtained. However, labelling of metabolites is essential for the observation of either movement or metabolic conversion of these metabolites within plants by NMR microimaging. Labelling can be achieved with the stable isotope 13C in experiments similar those employing the radioactive carbon isotopes.
2.5.2
13CLabelling
The use of the isotope 13C is a well known tool in organic chemistry. The NMR spectrum of natural abundance 13C forms a characteristic fingerprint of a compound and the appearance, increase and disappearance of resonance lines in the I3C NMR spectrum indicate the chemical conversion of one compound into another during chemical synthesis. This ability to observe the conversion of chemical compounds by NMR has made the use of the isotope 13C particularly attractive for studies of metabolic pathways in medical research [38], as well as in plant physiology [3943]. The natural abundance of 13Cnuclei is low (1.1%) and additionally in most situations the metabolites under investigation are only weakly concentrated in the living system. Hence, applications of direct detected 13CNMR to intact systems with natural abundance 13C have been limited. However, the low natural abundance of 13C means that it can be used as an excellent tracer in labelling studies. Therefore compounds with positions highly enriched in 13C are commonly used to increase the sensitivity of the NMR experiment and to study selected metabolic pathways. Any NMR signal detected from a sample can also be spatially encoded by the superposition of magnetic field gradients on to the main field. Therefore, images of the distribution of the compound carrying the 13C tracer can be obtained. However, imaging of 13C labelled compounds is limited by the intrinsically low NMR sensitivity in the direct detection of 13C nuclei. Hence, the observation of the movement of 13C labelled compounds in intact living systems has not been possible using direct detected 13C NMR imaging. Indirect detection techniques for 13C nuclei such as cyclic J cross-polarization (CYCLCROP) result in a significant enhancement of the NMR signal and so make the spatially resolved acquisition of the NMR signal in a reasonably short experimental time possible. Using the combination of NMR imaging with cyclic J cross-polarization we have studied the movement of 13C labelled metabolites in an intact plant for the first time in a dynamical experiment. In these experiments castor bean seedlings were used as a model system.
44
2.5.3
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumnr, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
Castor Bean Seedlings - a Model System
Castor bean (Ricinus cornrnunis L.) plants have been used extensively in the investigation of phloem transport. This is a consequence of the relatively inefficient wound sealing system in the castor bean plant; a feature which is shared with only a very small number of other plant species. In most plants this system would normally block phloem transport following an incision, via callose production in the sieve tubes. In the castor bean plant exudate can however be collected after incision of the plant stem. This technique has been used to demonstrate photoassimilate transport, by monitoring the increase of radioactivity in the exudate after exposure of source leaves to l4CO, [44]. Detailed studies of phloem transport have been carried out with seedlings of the castor bean plant [45-501.
\
nutrient depot
Fig. 2.10: Experimental setup for 13C observations of movements of sucrose in castor bean seedlings. Plants were grown on top of glass tubes which could be inserted into the probehead. During the experiment, the root system was aerated from below by a gentle stream of air bubbles. The cotyledons were incubated in a small nutrient depot containing the labelled hexoses. The shaded region within the hypocotyl indicates the position of the NMR rf coil.
2. CYCLCROPMapping of I3C Labelled Compounds
45
Castor bean seedlings have a hook shaped hypocotyl with two cotyledons at the apical end and the root system at the basal end (Fig. 2.10). The cotyledons are embedded in
the endosperm, a tissue rich in oil and fat [51], which supplies the seedling with nutrients during the first days after germination. Instead of taking up the nutrients from the endospem, the cotyledons can absorb nutrients from an aqueous solution, if the endospem is removed and the cotyledons are incubated in a weak buffer (the incubation medium). Since the seedlings take up carbohydrates and amino acids directly from the incubation medium 13Clabelled compounds can be easily introduced into the plant in this manner. We used 50 mM 13C1 glucose and 50 mM 13C1fructose in our first experiments. These hexoses are readily taken up by the cotyledons [50] and fructose is particularly rapidly converted to the disaccharide sucrose [50,52]. Sucrose is the major transport form for carbohydrates and it is exported from the cotyledons into the hypocotyl and the roots of the seedling by active loading into the phloem. Concentrations of up 300 mM sucrose have been reported in the phloem exudate of castor bean seedlings [47,49]. After de novo synthesis of sucrose from the supplied 13C labelled hexoses within the cotyledons, the sucrose molecule is either labelled on the C, position of the fructose moiety, the C, position of the glucose moiety or on both positions.
2.5.4
Experimental Setup of the Castor Bean Experiment
A probehead for a BRUKER 400 MHz wide bore magnet which can host an intact castor bean seedling and which provides a small vessel for the incubation of the cotyledons during the NMR experiment has been designed. A double resonance saddle coil was used for simultaneous irradiation of both the lH and 13C nuclei. Castor bean seedlings were grown hydroponically on top of glass tubes (14 mm o.d, 200 mm length) containing a weak solution of CaC12 (0.5 mM) for six days in the dark [53]. The NMR experiment was carried out on a region of the hypocotyl about 10 mm below the hook.
46
2.5.5
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
Spectroscopic Experiment
We used the CYCLCROP sequence (Fig. 2.5) to enhance the signal in a spectroscopic experiment. Immediately after the end of the second transfer, the signal in the proton channel was recorded (1024 points). Signal averaging over 256 scans was performed. Total acquisition time was 3 min. The irradiation frequencies for polarization transfer between the protons coupled to the 13C1 of the glucose moiety (termed GI) were 5.33 ppm and 93.1 ppm. For the transfer between the protons coupled to the 13C1of the fructose moiety (termed F1) 3.56 ppm and 62.3 ppm were used. We repeated the spectroscopic experiment for both labelled positions in the sucrose molecule every 30 min thus observing the increase of the signal intensity of the F1 and the GI frequencies due to the accumulation of labelled sucrose in the sensitive area of the rf coil (8 mm) (Fig. 2.1 la)
,
-
,
-
,
.
i
I
.
0 mrn (center of the coil) -4 rnm (bottom)
L
0
I
100
200
300
400
Time of incubation [min]
Fig. 2.11: Increasing 13C labelled sucrose concentration measured from (a) the F1 and GI resonances of sucrose and (b) from three different 2 mm thick slices of the hypocotyl, using the G1 resonance.
Slice Selection By applying a slice selective refocusing rf pulse after the CYCLCROP sequence, the signal of the G1 and the F1 resonances was acquired alternately for three different slice positions along the axis of the hypocotyl. Figure 2.11b shows the increase of the G1 signal intensity in the three separate slices. The different slopes in the increase are caused by variation in unloading of the labelled sucrose from the phloem. Such time dependent
2. CYCLCROP Mapping of 13C Labelled Compounds
47
curves can be analysed using an input/output model to obtain transport velocities of the labelled sucrose within the phloem.
2.5.6
Imaging Experiment
CYCLCROP spectral editing was combined with a spin echo imaging sequence. We found the PRAWN version of cross-polarization with an rf duty cycle of only 8% to give highest efficiency and lowest power deposition in our experiment. The total acquisition time for one image was reduced by almost a factor of 2 through the use of acquisition weighted k-space sampling [54-561. The number of averages taken for each phase encoding step is calculated according to the Hanning filter, resulting in the highest number of averages at zero phase encoding gradient strength and a decreasing number of averages with increasing phase encoding gradient. The total acquisition time for an image with an in-plane resolution of 500 km x 62.5 pm and a slice thickness given by the sensitive region of the coil (8 mm) was 90 minutes. This was fast enough to allow observation of the movement of 13C labelled sucrose in the hypocotyl through repetition of the experiment. Figure 2.12 shows a series of 11 images obtained for the F, resonance of sucrose. The total measured signal intensity corresponding to each image is shown on the right hand side. Starting from a baseline level due to the signal from naturally abundant 13C nuclei present before the incubation of the cotyledons with labelled hexoses, the intensity increases in time throughout the experiment. An enrichment by a factor of 14 was achieved at the end of the 16 h experiment. The first image was also acquired with naturally abundant 13C. In the second image, no contrast is visible although the total intensity of the observed resonance has already increased, indicating the arrival of labelled sucrose in the observed slice. The signal is clearly visible in the third image, showing the arrival of the labelled sucrose within the phloem. The intensity of the signal within the phloem increases during the experiment, corresponding to either an increase in the sucrose 13C enrichment factor or a process of sucrose storage within the phloem parenchyma. In the course of the study the signal spreads out into the periphery of the vascular bundles particularly in the cortex parenchyma. This indicates that either the flux of sucrose is directed after unloading from the phloem into this tissue or that sucrose delivered from the phloem is rapidly metabolised within the pith parenchyma.
48
M. Heideareich, A. Spyros, W.Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
u ! ! 1
T1 proton image
Fig. 2.12: Indirect detected 13C CYCLCROP images of the distribution of labelled sucrose from the hypocotyl of 6 days old castor bean seedlings. The first image is recorded before incubation with labelled hexoses (50 mM fructose and 50 mM glucose). The acquisition time for each image was 1.5 h, in plane resolution is 500 pm x 62 ,urn, the slice thickness is given by the sensitive volume of the rf coil to 8 mm. On the bottom right side, the total F1 edited spectra of sucrose (13C decoupled).
2. CYCLCROPMapping of 13C Labelled Compounds
49
2.6 Discussion and Outlook The purpose of CYCLCROP indirect I3C imaging is to map 13C concentrations in softmatter objects quantitatively, with molecule specificity, insensitivity to motions, and with spatial and temporal resolution. This is in contrast to ordinary magnetic resonance imaging of morphologies where contrasts are usually weighted representations of local spin-lattice and transverse relaxation times, diffusivities and spin densities. In order to comply with these requirements, the pulse sequence must be designed in such a way that relaxation losses are prevented as far as possible while the detection sensitivity is optimized. We have shown that cyclic cross-polarization (or rotating-frame polarization transfer) in the sense of the HartmannMahn experiment as a spectral editing element optimally serves the goal of an operational 13Cmapping scheme. From a more practical point of view, a further requirement is the ease of experimental handling in particular in the frame of in vivo experiments where time consuming adjustments are not possible. As concerns cross-polarization this condition means that the pulse sequence should be insensitive to HartmandHahn mismatch. In this respect we have successfully tested the MOIST and, as a new pulsed version of cross-polarization, the PRAWN modifications. In this context, the radio frequency power deposition connected with the pulse sequence may also be a limiting factor. It was shown that both methods, the latter somewhat better than the former, are uncritical in this respect. The theoretical sensitivity enhancement of proton mediated detection of 13C nuclei is a factor of roughly ( ~ ~ =: 644 relative ~ to) the~direct acquisition of 13C signals without nuclear Overhauser effect enhancement. It should be noted here that the number of protons coupled to a 13C nucleus virtually does not matter as our considerations proved. A further sensitivity gain is due to the fact that the signals are acquired in the proton channel, that is, that the repetition rate is limited by proton spin-lattice relaxation rather than that of 13Cwhich may be slower by a factor of ten or so. This is a crucial point: Since the purpose of CYCLCROP mapping is to render the spatial distribution of 13C concentration quantitatively as accurate as possible, the pulse sequence should be applied to the totally relaxed sample only. Ernst angle optimization of the repetition rate is therefore not feasible in this context. The application of CYCLCROP 13C mapping on polymer mixtures, i. e., heterogeneously distributed polymers of a different chemical nature, showed that a clear distinction is possible on a total acquisition time scale which is adequate for materials. The short relaxation times intrinsic to polymers permit one to simplify the spectral editing
50
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W.Kockenberger, N . Chandrakumar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
part of the pulse sequence because "saturation" of the protons in this case simply means to wait a period T2 in the order of 1 ms. It was shown that the chemical selectivity of the procedure is unambiguous. We have demonstrated that movement and metabolism of 13C labelled compounds in castor bean seedlings could be observed by CYCLCROP indirect 13C imaging. The tremendous progress in plant molecular biology within the last few years now allows the transformation of a whole range of transporter and key enzymes genes in plants. The non-invasive approach of measuring the movement and the metabolic conversion of labelled I3C metabolites in intact plants, described here, may provide a versatile and valuable supplementary technique in plant molecular biology. By using cyclic J crosspolarization techniques it should be possible to measure metabolic flux rates and transport velocities of labelled metabolites. These important parameters will facilitate the evaluation of the success of transformation of a target and how the physiology of the plant is affected. Since NMR imaging experiments are non-destructive, different techniques can be used with one plant. Thus, it is possible to carry out an experiment for the measurement of water flow in the phloem [53],followed by an experiment for the determination of the flux of 13C labelled photoassimilates in the phloem. Such experiments are important for the investigation of the mechanism and regulation of phloem transport. Indirect 13C imaging applications for biomedical purposes may be more demanding because the total acquisition time may conflict with what one can expect of a patient. However it has already been demonstrated that 13C resonances in humans can be probed even under natural abundance conditions. For example, in ref. [57] glycogen in the human liver was detected in vivo with a 2 T whole-body tomograph. The acquisition time may be reduced combining CYCLCROP spectral editing with echo planar imaging. Furthermore, the metabolic pathways of 13C enriched nutrients or drugs may be sensitively traced also for diagnostic purposes. The feasibility of biomedical applications of CYCLCROP indirect I3C imaging under in vivo conditions is also corroborated by the striking insensitivity to motions [6].
2. CYCLCROPMupping of 13C Labelled Compounds
51
References 1.
R. Kimmich, U. Goerke, J. Weis, J. Truce & Microprobe Techn. 13 (1995) 285.
2.
A. Knuttel, R. Kimmich, K.-H. Spohn, J. Mugn. Reson. 81 (1989) 570.
3.
A. Kniittel, K.-H. Spohn, R. Kimmich, J. Mugn. Reson. 86 (1990) 542.
4.
F. De Luca, R. Campanella, A. Bifone, B. Maraviglia, J. Mugn. Reson. 93 (1991) 554.
5.
C. Kunze, R. Kimmich, Mugn. Reson. Imaging 12 (1994) 805.
6.
C. Kunze, R. Kimmich, J. Mugn. Reson. B 105 (1994) 38.
7.
S. R. Hartmann, E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 128 (1962) 2042.
8.
R. Kimmich, NMR-Tomography,Difisometry, Reluxometry, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1997.
9.
N. Chandrakumar, J. Mugn. Reson. 67 (1986) 457.
10.
G. C. Chingas, A. N. Garroway, R. D. Bertrand, and W. B. Moniz, J. Mugn. Reson. 35 (1979) 283.
11.
G. C. Chingas, A. N. Garroway, R. D. Bertrand, and W. B. Moniz, J. Chem. Phys. 74 (1981) 127.
12.
N. Chandrakumar and K. Nagayama, Chem. Phys. Lett. 133 (1987) 288.
13.
M. H. Levitt, D. Suter and R. R. Ernst, J. Chem.Phys. 84 (1986) 4243.
14.
M. H. Levitt, J. Chem. Phys. 94 (1991) 30.
15.
D. Yu. Artemov, J. Mugn. Reson. A 103 (1993) 297.
16.
S. J. Glaser and J. J. Quant, Adv. Mugn. Reson. 19 (1996) 59.
17.
J. D. Ellett, Jr., and J. S . Waugh, J. Clzem. Phys. 51 (1969) 2851.
18. N. Chandrakumar and R. Kimmich, submitted for publication. 19.
G. C. Chingas, A. N. Garroway, W. B. Moniz and R. D. Bertrand, J. Amer. Chem. Sac. 102
(1980) 2526. 20.
D. E. Demco, H. Kostler, and R. Kimmich, J. Mugn. Reson. A 110 (1994) 136.
21.
M. Heidenreich, W. Kockenberger, N. Chandrakumar, R. Kimmich, R. Bowtell, J. Mugn. Reson. 132 (1998) 109-124.
22.
A. Spyros, N. Chandrakumar, M. Heidenreich, R. Kimmich, Macromolecules 31 (1998) 3031-3029.
23.
D. M. Dodrell, G. J. Galloway, W. M. Brooks, J. Field, J. M. Bulsing, M. G. Irving, H. Baddeley,
J , Magn. Reson. 70 (1986) 176.
24. 25.
M. R. Bendall, D. T. Pegg, J. Mugn. Reson. 67 (1986) 376. R. A. Komoroski, ,,Carbon-13 NMR of Solid Amorphous Polymers Above Ti', High Resolution NMR Spectroscopy of Synthetic Polymers in Bulk, VCH Publishers, Deefield Beach, FL, 1986.
26.
C. J. Pollock, J. F. Farrar, A. J. Gordon (eds.) Carbon partitioning within and between organisms, Bios
Scientific Publishers, (1992).
27.
E. Fritz, R. F. Evert, H. Nasse, Pluntu 178 (1989) 1.
52
M. Heidenreich, A. Spyros, W.Kockenberger, N. Chandrakurnar, R. Bowtell, R. Kimmich
28.
H. Jones, R. V. Martin, H. K. Porter, Ann. Botany 23 (1959) 493.
29.
J. Moorby, M. Ebert, N. T. S. Evans, J. Exp. Bot. 14 (1963) 210.
30.
M. R. Thorpe, P. E. H. Minchin, J. Exp. Bot. 42 (1991) 461.
31.
S. Jahnke, G. Stocklin, J. Willenbrink, Plunta 153 (1981) 56.
32.
A. Metzler, W. Kockenberger, M. van Kienlin, E. Komor, A. Haase, J. Magn. Reson. B 105
33
A. Metzler, M. Izquierdo, A. Ziegler, W. Kockenberger, E. Komor, M. von Kienlin, A. Haase, M.
(1994) 249.
Decorps, Proceed. Nut. Acad. Science Am.92 (1995) 11912.
34.
A. Ziegler, A. Metzler, W. Kockenberger, M. Izquierdo, E. Komor, A. Haase, M. Decorps, M. von Kienlin, J. Magn. Reson. B 112 (1996) 141.
35.
H. Rumpel, J. Pope, Magn. Reson. Imaging 10 (1992) 187.
36.
Y. Xia, L. W. Jelinski, J. Magn. Reson. B 107 (1995) 1.
37.
T. Y. Tse, R. M. Spanswick, L. W; Jelinski, Protoplasnza 194 (1996) 54.
38.
N. Beckrnann, NMR basic principles and progress 28, P. Diehl, E. Flnck, H. Gunther, R. Kosfeld, J. Seelig (eds.), Spinger, New York, (1993) 73.
39.
Y. Sachar-Hill, P. E. Pfeffer, M. W. Germann, Analytical Biochemistry 243 (1996).
40.
R. Viola, H. V. Davies, A. R. Chudeck, Planta 183 (1991) 202.
41.
T. H. Thomas, R. G. Ratcliffe, Physiol. Plantarurn 63 (1985) 284.
42.
E. Gout, R. Bligny, N. Pascal, R. Douce, J. Biol. Chern. 268 (1993) 3986.
43.
B. Schneider, Planta 203 (1997) 1.
44.
S. M. Hall, D. A. Baker, J. A. Milburn, Planta 100 (1971) 200.
45.
P. Kriedemann, H. Beevers, Plant Physiol. 42 (1967) 161.
46.
C. Schobert, E. Komor, Plantu 181 (1990) 85.
47.
G. Orlich, E. Komor, Plunta 187 (1992) 460.
48.
W. Zhong, S. Langenberger, E. Komor, C. Schobert, J. Plant Physiol. 145 (1995) 453.
49.
J. Kallarackal, G. Orlich, C. Schobert, E. Komor, Planta 177 (1989) 327.
50.
J. Kallarackal, E. Komor, Plunta 177 (1989) 336.
51.
M. Nishimura, H. Beevers, Plant Physiol. 64 (1979) 31.
52.
P. Geigenberger, S. Langenberger, I. Wilke, D. Heineke, D.W. Heldt, M. Stitt, Planta 190 (1993) 446.
53.
W. Kockenberger, J. M. Pope, Y. Xia, K. R. Jeffrey, E. Komor, P. T. Callaghan, Planta 201 (1997) 53.
54.
M. Garwood, T. Schleich, B. D. Ross, G. B. Matson, W. D. Winters, J. Magn Reson. 65 (1985) 239.
55.
P. Hodghnson, R. 0. Kemp-Harper, P. J. Hore, J. Magn. Reson. B 105 (1994) 256.
56.
T. Mareci, H. R. Brooker, J. Magn. Reson. 57 (1984) 157.
57.
A. Kniittel, R. Kimmich, K.-H. Spohn, M a p . Reson. Med. 17 (1991) 470.
3.
Contrast Enhancement Based on Intermolecular Zero Quantum Coherences for Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Microscopy
Rahim R. Rizi2, Sangdoo Ahnl, Jeff Hopkins2, John S. Leigh2, and Warren S. Warren1 lDepartment of Chemistry, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544-1009, USA 2Department of Radiology, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104,USA
Abstract A new method for Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is reported based on the detection of relatively strong signal from intermolecular zero-quantum coherences (iZQCs) using a simple pulse sequence. Such a signal would not be observable in the conventional framework of magnetic resonance; it originates in long range dipolar couplings (10 pm - 10 mm) which are traditionally ignored. Unlike conventional MRI, where image contrast is based on variations in spin density and relaxation times (often with injected contrast agents), contrast with iZQC images comes from variations in the susceptibility over a distance dictated by gradient strength.
3.1 Introduction We have demonstrated a new type of MRI based on detection of intermolecular zeroquantum coherences (iZQCs) [11. These coherences correspond to detecting the signal produced by simultaneously flipping two water spins in opposite directions on molecules separated by 10 p m - 1Omm. Such a signal is completely unobservable in the conventional picture of solution magnetic resonance, where couplings between independent molecules in solution are ignored. Over the last few years, however, strong signals from such "impossible" intermolecular cross-peaks and extra resonances have been detected
54
R. R. Rizi, S.Ahn, J. Hopkins, .I S. .Leigh, and W. S.Warren
[2-71. As we Qscuss below, the iZQC linewidth (hence the image contrast) is determined by local susceptibility gradients, which are not measured by any other technique. P
a
x TEI2
RF
G, (slice)
n
r----,
;
W
Fig. 3.1 : Intermolecular zero-quantum coherence (iZQC) imaging pulse sequence. A standard spin echo echo-planar imaging pulse sequence was modified to include a slice selective preparation pulse and filter gradient before the normal excitation and refocusing pulses. The filter (correlation) gradient is applied immediately after the a pulse (flip angle 90" in our experiments). A second slice selective RF pulse of variable flip angle (0) is applied after a delay 4. A typical delay time between a and p pulses was 50 ms. Similarly a typical delay of 100 ms was used between the p pulse and the K refocusing pulse.
The sequence we use to detect an iZQC image is shown in Fig. 3.1. If the first pulse were omitted, this would be a conventional echo-planar imaging (EPI) sequence and would generate contrast only because of differences in T2 relaxation during the delays after the second pulse. Instead, however, the pulse labeled a (a d 2 pulse) converts the equilibrium magnetization I , into I , . The gradient after the interval 7, which we will call the correlation gradient, modulates this transverse magnetization. None of the later gradient pulses ever match this correlation gradient, so a conventional treatment would predict no signal except from spins that relax back towards equilibrium during z. This treatment turns out to be incorrect-iZQC signal is detectable because of the direct dipoledipole interaction between nuclei in solution. This direct dipole-dipole interaction is proportional to (3cos2 O-l)/r3 , where Y is the internuclear separation and 0 is the angle the internuclear vector makes with the applied magnetic field. Diffusion makes the angle 8 vary rapidly for pairs of nearby spins, so the coupling is generally assumed to be
3. Contrast Enhancement Based on Intermolecular Zet-o Quantum Coherences (iZQC)
55
averaged away [S]. However, this assumption is only valid for spins closer than the distance molecules diffuse on an NMR time scale [5] (typically 10 pm). If the magnetization is not spatially uniform (as happens if the spins precess in a gradient, as in virtually all imaging sequences), the interaction between distant spins can be quite important, and detection of intermolecular resonances is possible.
3.2 Theory Several different theoretical models have been used to quantitatively understand these effects One approach treats the couplings classically [4,5,9-111 using Bloch equations modified to include the “dipolar demagnetizing field“, which had been introduced almost two decades earlier to explain multiple echoes in concentrated solutions [12,13]. It is also possible to use a fully quantum treatment [2,4] (retaining the dipolar couplings, and discarding the high temperature approximation to the density matrix) or a classical/quantum hybrid [14]. Both treatments can make fully quantitative predictions of the signals for simple sequences [4,14,15] but the quantum approach leads to an easier understanding of this experiment. The equilibrium density matrix for N spin-1/2 nuclei is pe4 = 2--Nn(1-3Z,i);
3 =2tanh(qoo/kT)
(3.1)
Z
where ZZi is the operator for z-magnetization spin i, coo is the resonance frequency, and kT is the thermal energy. The a pulse (90° in all of our experiments) rotates the equilibrium z magnetization into transverse magnetization p = 2 - N n ( 1 - 3 ~ , i ~ i n a - 3 1 ,cosa) ~
(3.2)
i
The S2 and higher even order terms give double- and zero-quantum coherences between every pair of spins in the entire sample:
During the delay T the last two terms in eqn. (3.3) (the iZQC terms) evolve at the differ-
56
R. R. Rizi, S. Ahn, J. Hopkins, J. S. Leigh, and W. S. Warren
ence between resonance offsets of the two spins i andj. They will not evolve at all when the gradient is off for two water molecules in regions with the same susceptibility (Am, - A m j = 0 ) . However, during the correlation gradient (strength G,, duration t,, and direction s) they may evolve at different frequencies if the two spins are separated. Assuming uniform magnetization (no density or resonance frequency variations) for the moment, at the end of the delay z the iZQC component of the 2-N-1
32 sin . 2
g2 term will then be [ 1,4]:
[ ( Z + ~ I+- ~ I - ~ Z + ~ ) C O ~ {-(~Aw~~~ ) T + y c , ( S- S~j ) t c } ]
(3.4)
i>j
The p RF pulse transfers these ZQ coherences into two-spin single quantum (IQ) terms such as IxiZzj.Finally, the magnetization can be rendered observable by a number of small intermolecular dipolar couplings, which remove the I , term, leaving one-spin 1QC terms for detection. Still assuming uniform magnetization, the exact signal is [l]
M + =iMosin2 a c o s p J 1 As = {3(s .Z ) - 1}/2
(3.5)
where the dipolar demagnetization time z d = 240 ms for pure water at room temperature in a 4 Tesla magnet). Note that this signal can be quite substantial (the maximum value of the Bessel function J , is 0.58). In the conventional picture, which ignores dipolar couplings, the signal vanishes completely because the correlation gradient wipes out the magnetization. We previously showed [3J that the intermolecular double-quantum coherence (iDQC) signal without inhomogeneous broadening comes primarily from spiiis separated by a distance d = n/(yG,t,) - half a cycle of the magnetization helix generated by the correlation gradient - thus we observed crosspeaks between coaxial tubes when the helix pitch was long. Reference [7] extended this approach to extract more structural detail. With inhomogeneous broadening, an additional contrast mechanism becomes available because iZQC evolution during the delay z (100 ms in our experiments) is only affected by the resonance frequency difference between spins i and j . In these phantom experiments, this frequency difference arises from two sources-residual imperfections in the shimming and susceptibility variations near the edges. Both effects increase as the
3. Contrast Enhancemenr Based on Intermolecular Zero Quantum Coherences (iZQC)
57
separation between spins increases. This also will generate an inhomogeneous linewidth 1/Ti on each pixel, but there is a fundamental difference. The measured value of 1/Tl reflects the linewidth averaged over an entire voxel (typically 1 x 1 x 5 mm in the images below), but the iZQC evolution is only affected by frequency differences dictated by the correlation gradient (typically G, = 1 G/cm and t, = 4 ms, giving d = 300 pm, which is much smaller than the slice thickness). We thus expect the iZQC image to partially refocus inhomogeneous broadening, giving T2,zgcontrast in general whch is somewhat different from T2 or T; contrast.
3.3 Experimental Results Images were acquired using a twelve-strut birdcage headcoil in a GE SIGNA 4T whole body scanner equipped with experimental, high speed, 2.3 G/cm shielded gradients. The a pulse phase (which does not affect the iZQC signal) and the receiver phase are inverted on alternate cycles. Single quantum coherence generated by the a pulse is completely dephased by the correlation gradient and is undetectable; however, the sequence could be modified to cancel the a pulse phase inversion. A 10 cm spherical head phantom filled with polydimethyl siloxane (TI = 0.78 s, T2 = 0.21 s) was used to demonstrate contrast generated near interfaces. The phantom is nearly homogeneous except for an air bubble at the top and two screws on either side, which were intentionally placed in the imaging plane. A sixteen average image of a 64 x 64 one shot spin echo (TE = 100 ms, TR = 4 s) EPI image of the Si oil head phantom with a total scan time of less than one minute is shown in Fig 3.2A. The image was expanded to 128 x 128 pixels by bilinear interpolation. The image is mostly homogeneous except for the bright ring near an air bubble at the top, an intensity variation on the upper right edge caused by the screw capping a filling hole, a slight brightening and distortion on the lower right edge presumably from RF inhomogeneity, and what might be a slight intensity variation on the middle left edge caused by the screws. Figure 3.2B-D also shows images acquired using the iZQC filtered pulse sequence with a 1 G/cm correlation gradient applied for 4 ms (d = 300 pm) and T = 50 ms. These images were signal averaged 128 times. These images exhibit broad internal banding structure from residual shimming imperfections; they also exhibit sharp structures due to
58
R. R. Rizi, S.Ahn, J. Hopkins, J. S. Leigh, and W. S.Warren
Fig. 3.2: Comparison of standard EPI images (parts A and E) with Z Q C images (B,C,D,F) for a silicone oil phantom with an air bubble (top) and a head phantom (bottom). The iZQC images were taken with two different methods for suppression of residual transverse magnetization: coadding p = 45" and p = -135" spectra (part B) and subtracting x-correlation gradient spectra from z-correlation gradient (parts C,D,F). Shifting the phantom down (parts C verses D) shows that features around the air bubble are susceptibility differences, whereas the broad bands are residual static inhomogeneity .
susceptibility variations (primarily near the air-liquid interface where the susceptibility changes rapidly). To demonstrate that the broad banding is dependent on shimming, the phantom was lowered in the head coil to bring it closer to the lower struts; the broad bands do not move, but the sharp bands move to remain near the air-liquid interface. It is important to point out that no contrast agent is required for this sort of contrast enhancement, although it certainly would be possible to develop and investigate ZQ-sensitive contrast agents (paramagnetic ions shft the resonance frequency as well as increase the linewidth). A resolution test phantom filled with water ( T I = 1.16 s, T2 = 0.18 s) was used to examine the sensitivity of the new contrast technique to small structures (Fig.
3.2E-F), and verifies that in this case, with a susceptibility-matched housing, we produce a normal looking image. Figure 3.3 shows 128 x 128 pixel phantom iZQC images, taken as a function of correlation gradient strength (z = 10 ms, TE = 100 ms, gradient length t, = 4 ms). This changes the characteristic separation d = .n/yGt, of the pair of spins in the observed iZQC coherences. For very close spins the resonance frequency difference is small; for more distant spins the resonance frequency variation due to residual static inhomogeneity and susceptibility variations causes enhanced contrast.
3. Contrast Enhancement Based on Intermolecular Zero Quantum Coherences (iZQCj
2G/cm
0.5 G/cm
1G/cm
59
0.25 G/cm
Fig. 3.3: Phantom iZQC images, taken as a function of correlation gradient strength from 2 G/cm to 0.25 G/cm. This changes the characteristic separation d = x/yGt, of the pair of spins in the observed iZQC coherences.
Numerous control experiments confirm that the image actually arises from iZQCs, rather than some unaccounted source of transverse magnetization. If the second pulse flip angle is changed from +45" to -135" the desired signal is unaffected, but transverse magnetization excited from residual z magnetization before the second pulse (generated by RF pulse imperfections or T1 relaxation during 2) is inverted (Fig. 3.2B). Another approach is to alternate between z ( A , = 1) and x ( A , = -1/2 ) correlation gradients, which inverts the desired signal and leaves transverse magnetization unaffected, and take the difference between the two spectra (Fig. 3.2C). In this case we can estimate the total magnetization in regions where nearby spins are at nearly the same frequency:
3TE
= - iM0 sin2 a si n(2~)__ 8ed
In our experiments both approaches work, but the latter approach is better because the slice profile is unaltered. No signal was observed when the correlation gradient axes were switched to alternate between the x and y directions instead of the x and z directions, or if the p pulse was omitted. Equation (3.6) shows that the iZQC signal grows during the echo delay, whereas new transverse magnetization would decay with T2 relaxation during this time. Figure 3.4 shows a graph of signal intensity from a series of
60
R. R. Rizi, S. Ahn, J. Hopkins, J . S. Leigh, and W. S. Warren
images obtained for echo times ranging from 120 ms to 320 ms, and shows an the increase in signal intensity up to an echo time of 220 ins followed by decreasing signal. A theoretical calculation predicts that maximum signal is achieved for an echo time of 200 ms, which is in good agreement with our experimental results. The iZQC-based signal will be maximized when the second pulse has a tip angle of p = 45"; ordinary transverse magnetization generated by the second pulse would continue to increase up to 90" and then decrease. Figure 3.5 shows a graph of signal intensity as a function of with a correlation gradient of 2 G/cm, and a single data point collected with a 1 G/cm correlation gradient demonstrating a smaller average signal (as expected since the iZQC signal now comes from more separated spins). Also shown is a (scaled) calibration curve obtained by turning off the a pulse and matching the p pulse phase to that of the receiver in order to observe transverse magnetization as a function of flip angle.
3.4 Future Directions How can this technique be generalized? Resonance frequency variations due to the bulk magnetic susceptibility can be significant for structured materials [16,17]. Well characterized examples include lung tissue [I81 (at the interface between air with = 0.4 ppm and normal tissue with = -9 ppm; 1 ppm is 170 Hz in a 4 T magnet), arterial blood
x
x
x
vessels (with different degrees of blood oxygenation on either side, changing by about 0.3 ppm) and sites of tissue necrosis (fully deoxygenated hemoglobin, changing by about 1 ppm). In conventional MRI this variation shows up as an inhomogeneous broadening but iZQC detection would provide a much more sensitive, and distance-selected,
x
method for measuring these variations. Figure 3.4 shows that the signal is approximately 5% of the conventional epi signal in our 4T experiments. It would also be trivial to extend these results to multiple echoes or other imaging sequences to further enhance the detected signal, and this might be advantageous in applications where chemical shift variations (e.g. water verses fat) are significant complications. However, we should note that the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) in conventional MRI scales with concentration (C), gyromagnetic ratio (y) and magnetic field (B) as SNR
0~
yl1I4 C B7I4 (conventional MRI)
3. Contrast Enhancement Based on Intermolecular Zero Quantum Coherences (iZQCj
n
0'06
s 0.05
.-c0
I
1 1 v 0
m
0.04
61
0
.
0
0
0 S
0 0.01
' J
0
E .c
v
0
I-
0
100
0
200
Simulation Experiment
300
I
400
500
Echo time
Fig. 3.4: Dots: experimental signal intensity as a function of the echo time for the resolution phantom. Solid line: simulation of iZQC intensity based on experimentally measured values of 7'1 and T2.
(The fractional powers come from the assumption that, for constant probe Q, the noise scales as the 1/4 power of the frequency). Equation (3.5) shows that, for TE
This suggests that iZQC contrast enhancement is most appropriate for water imaging in relatively large fields, or with nonequilibrium magnetization (e.g. spin polarized Xe). Note that the correlation distance does not enter into these equations-the iZQC signal will have the same sensitivity for pairs of spins separated by 1 pm as for pairs of spins separated by 1 mm, if diffusion can be neglected during the intervals zZqand TE. In practice, it takes tens of 1-1s for a significant signal to grow in, hence this type of imaging in water would be appropriate for distance scales >10 pm (the approximate distance water molecules diffuse in 10 ms), although for more viscous materials the distance could be made shorter.
62
R. R. Rizi, S. Ahn, J. Hopkins, J. S. Leigh, and W. S. Warren
30 25
-I
-4
sin 0 iZQC (1G/cm) 0
20
40
60
80
100
Second pulse flip angle (degrees) Fig. 3.5: Experimental signal intensity as a function of the flip angle of the p pulse, for iZQC images and conventional epi images (the conventional image is obtained by setting the first pulse flip angle to zero). Equation (3.6) shows that the iZQC signal should be proportional to sin p cos p (= sin (2p)) for TE < ‘rd; the signal in a conventional image should be proportional to sin p. Note that the average iZQC signal decreases as the gradient pulse strength is decreased, reflecting the onset of resonance frequency differences (but enhanced contrast).
3.5 Conclusion In summary, we have shown on phantom samples that it is possible to produce spatially resolved images with good signal-to-noise ratios and contrast coming from a mechanism that is different from T2 or T; . Applications to a variety of structured materials should be possible, including extensions to in vivo imaging [191.
Acknowledgements This work was supported by the NIH under grants GM35253 (Princeton), RR02305, and HL07614 (Penn). W2 wishes to thank Drs. John Videen, Michael Middleton, and Eric Wong (UCSD) for useful discussions.
3. Contrast Enhancement Eased on Intermolecular Zero Quantum Coherences (iZQC)
63
References 1.
S. Vathyam, S. Lee, and W. S. Warren, Science 272 (1996) 92.
2.
W. S. Warren, W. Richter, A. H. Andreotti, and S. Farmer, Science 262 (1993) 2005.
3.
W. Richter, S. Lee, W. S. Warren, and Q. He, Science 267 (1995) 654.
4.
S. Lee, W. Richter, S. Vathyam, and W. S. Warren, J. Chem. Phys. 105 (1996) 874.
5.
W. S. Warren, S. Lee, W. Richter, and S. Vathyam, Chem. Phys. Lett. 247 (1995) 207; Q. He, W. Richter, S. Vathyam, and W. S. Warren, J. Chem. Phys. 98 (1993) 6779.
6.
P. Broekaert, A. Vlassenbroek, J. Jeener, G. Lippens, and J-M. Wieruszeski, J. Mug. Reson. A 120,
7.
P. Robyr and R. Bowtell, J. Mag. Res. A 121 (1996) 206; R. Bowtell and P. Robyr, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76
8.
N. Bloembergen, E. M. Purcell, and R. V. Pound, Phys. Rev. 73 (1948) 679.
9.
M. Levitt, Concepts in Magnetic Resonance 8 (1996) 77.
10.
M. Augustine and K. Zilm, J. Mag. Reson. A 123 (1996) 145.
11.
G. J. Bowden, T. Heseltine, and M. J. Prandolini, Chem. Phys. Lett. 233 (1995) 639.
12.
G. Deville, M. Bernier, and J. M. Delrieux, Pkys. Rev. E 19 (1979) 5666; D. Einzel, G. Eska,
(1996) 97.
(1996) 4971.
Y. Hirayoshi, T. Kopp, and P. Wolfle, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53 (1984) 2312; R. Bowtell, R. M. Bowley, and P. Glover, J. Mug. Res. 88 (1990) 643; H. Korber, E. Dormann, and G. Eska, J. Mag. Res. 93 (1991)
589; A. S. Bedford, R. Bowtell, and R. M. Bowley, J. Mug. Res. 93 (1991) 516. 13.
X. Zhou, C. S. Potter, and P. C. Lauturbur, Proc. SOC.Magnetic Resonance in Medicine (1991) 345.
14.
J. Jeener, A. Vlassenbroek, and P. Broekaert, J. Ckem. Phys. 103 (1995) 1309.
15.
W. S. Warren and S. Ahn, J. Chem. Phys. 108 (1998) 1313.
16.
C. S. Springer, NMR in Physiology and Medicine, R. J. Gillies (ed.), Academic Press, Orlando,
17.
Z. M. Bhujwalla, D. C. Shungu, Q. He, J.P. Wehrle, and J. D. Glickson, NMR in Physiology and
1994, p. 75-99.
Medicine, R. J. Gillies, (ed.), Academic Press, Orlando, 1994, p. 311-328 and references therein. 18.
C. H. Durney, J. Bertolina, D. C. Ailion, R. Christmas, A. G. Cutillo, A. H. Morris, and S. Hashemi, J. Magn. Reson. 85 (1989) 554.
19.
W. S. Warren, S. Ahn, M. Mescher, M. Garwood, K. Ugurbil, W. Richter, R. R. Rizi, J. Hopkins, J. S. Leigh, Science, in press.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
4. Frequency Dependence of EPR Sensitivity G. R. Euton, S. S. Euton, and G. A. Rinard Departments of Chemistry and Biochemistry and Engineering, University of Denver, Denver, CO, 80208, USA
Abstract Contrary to some prior derivations, it is shown that the sensitivity of EPR measurements is the same as for NMR, and that in general comparisons of EPR sensitivity as a function of frequency u) have been pessimistic by one factor of u). The frequency dependence of EPR signal intensity depends on what parameters are held constant. At constant microwave magnetic field ( B , ) signal intensity varies as u)0714 if the sample and resonator size are constant, as u)0-1’4 if sample and resonator size both scale as o0-l, or as if the sample size is constant and resonator size is scaled as oOp1. SIN as a function of frequency depends on the dominant source of noise. Predictions are made for the case in which thermal noise due to resistance of the resonator materials dominates and for the case in which losses in the sample dominate.
4.1 Introduction To obtain adequate depth penetration into large aqueous samples, including animals, EPR imaging is performed at the lowest feasible frequency - typically between 250 MHz and 2 GHz. The feasibility of imaging physiologically significant signals at these frequencies is dependent upon obtaining adequate signal-to-noise (SIN). A frequently-posed question is “what, in principle, should one expect to be able to achieve with an ideal spectrometer”? This paper presents a basis for making such predictions, and concludes that the potential for imaging at low frequency is more optimistic than has been suggested by others.
66
G. R. Euton, S. S. Euton, and G. A. Rinard
The issue of EPR signal intensity as a function of frequency has been confused for many years because of an unfortunate error in Poole's book [ 11. Experimental tests of the frequency dependence of SIN have typically compared performance on extensively engineered X-band systems with results obtained on low-frequency EPR systems that have been built with minimal budget andlor for specialized purposes and are unlikely to approach ultimate sensitivity. The predictions and experimental results in the literature have provided a rather pessimistic picture. We have re-derived the expressions for EPR signal intensity as a function of frequency. NMR and EPR traditions, reflecting the historic differences in frequency range of interest and the associated technologies, express frequency dependence of sensitivity differently. An attempt at translation between these traditions is presented. Derivations of some of the equations stated in this paper are presented in a general discussion of signal and noise [2], which should be referred to for more detail.
4.2 Frequency Dependence of EPR Signal Intensity A general expression for EPR signal intensity is eqn. (4.1) [2], where AE is the signal
voltage at the end of the transmission line connected to the resonator, q is the resonator filling factor, QL is the loaded quality factor, Q, of the resonator, Z, is the characteristic impedance of the transmission line, and P is the microwave power to the resonator produced by the external microwave source. The magnetic susceptibility of the sample, f',
is the imaginary component of the effective RF susceptibility. For a Lorentzian line with linewidth Am at resonance frequency coo, substitution for the susceptibility in (4.1) yields (4.2), where S = 1/2, N is the number of spins per unit
(4.2)
volume and Tsampleis the temperature of the sample.
4. Frequency Dependence of EPR Sensitivity
67
Prediction of the frequency dependerzce of EPR signal intensity involves examination of the frequency dependence of each term in eqn. (4.1). Equation. (4.2) explicitly shows the frequency dependence of the magnetic susceptibility. We now seek the frequency dependence of the filling factor, r\, and of Q. Since an experiment may be done at constant incident power or constant B , , we also derive the frequency dependence of these terms. We then consider three cases: case 1 - the size of the sample and resonator are constant, case 2 - the size of the sample and resonator are scaled with mop,, and case 3 the size of the sample is constant and the size of the resonator is scaled as oopl.
4.2.1
Frequency Dependence of Q for LGR
The loaded Q, QL, for a loop gap resonator (LGR), is given by QL = ooLl2R. The inductance, L, is related to the length z and the cross-sectional area of the loop, A = mi 2/4, by eqn. (4.3). A L=po2
(4.3)
The resistance, including skm effect, (skin depth 6 = [opo 0 / 2 ] - ~ of / ~the ) resonator loop is
(4.4)
Substitution of (4.3) and (4.4) into the definition of Q, gives the frequency dependence of
Q, (4.5): (4.5)
where o is the conductivity of the surface of the resonator and po is the permeability in a vacuum. Since o is assumed to be independent of frequency, the frequency dependence of Q is determined by o0li2d (d is the diameter of the resonator), which is if the resonator size is kept constant, and is oop1’2 if the LGR size is scaled proportional to o0-1.
68
G. R. Eaton, S. S. Eaton, and G. A. Rinard
4.2.2
Frequency Dependence of Filling Factor
Thefilling factor, q, must be determined for each sample and resonator combination, and requires a detailed analysis of the electromagnetic fields in the resonator. However, we often can make an educated guess for q. We will assume as a first approximation that the filling factor for LGRs as a function of frequency will scale as if the microwave magnetic field were uniform and confined to the loop. For resonators with a constant loop size and sample size, this approximation overestimates 11 at higher frequency because the gap spacing must increase with frequency for a constant loop size, and as the gap increases, the magnetic field will no longer be completely confined to the loop.
4.2.3
Signal Intensity at Constant Incident Power
Substitution of eqn. (4.5) into eqn. (4.2) gives
( A q= K , q d o y f i
(4.6)
where terms that do not depend on frequency are combined in K , = ~0 ,/-/8Aw, and
xo = Ng2p2S(S+ 1)/3kTs.Equation. (4.6) indicates that the frequency dependence of
the ESR signal is a function of filling factor
4.2.4
and diameter d as well as w0312.
Frequency Dependence of Microwave Field B1
The frequency dependence of B , is given by eqn. (4.7) [2]:
where: K , = k , f 2 p & ~ / n and ~ k , is a constant of proportionality between B , , the rms magnitude of the circularly polarized component of the microwave magnetic field that is perpendicular to the external magnetic field and in phase with the Larmor precession and
4. Frequency Dependence of EPR Sensitivity
69
B1,, the total magnetic field in the resonator. Typically, one would seek to maintain the same B , at the sample, unless the spin relaxation time changed with frequency.
4.2.5
Application to Three Specific Cases
In case 1 we assume constant sample size and constant loop size. For example, one could have a LGR of a given loop size, with the frequency varied by changing the gap dimension. In this case, the variation with frequency is that given in eqns. (4.5-4.7) with filling factor and resonator dimensions held constant. In case 2 (“unlimited sample”) we assume that sample and loop sizes scale as m0-l. The length z and diameter d of the resonator scale with frequency. With this assumption eqn. (4.6) and (4.7) give eqn. (4.8) and (4.9).
In case 3 (“limited sample”) we assume that the sample size is constant and the dimension of the loop scales as m0-l. Since the sample volume is constant and the resonator volume varies as the frequency dependence of the filling factor is,
7 =k4mi
(4.10)
Substituting eqn. (4.10) into eqn. (4.6) gives,
]AE/ =K , k 3 k 4 ~ 0 i / ~ f i
(4.11)
The expression for B , in this case is the same as for case 2. The results obtained for these three cases are summarized in Tab--: 4.1. Alt..ough results were derived for the case of an LGR, they are also applicable to other resonators, including cavities, provided the assumptions for each case are matched. For the unlimited sample case, the dependence on wo1/2 agrees with the predictions of Abragam and Bleaney [3], Wilmshurst [4], and Fraenkel [5]. For the limited sample case the depen-
70
G. R. Eaton, S.S.Eaton, and G. A. Rinard
dence on w07/2 agrees with the results of many others, including Feher [6], Abragam and Bleaney [31, and Fraenkel [5]. The dependence of signal at constant power [3,5] (unlimited sample, case 2) on of signal intensity for constant sample (case 3) at constant power [3,5-71 on and of constant sample [7] (case 3) at constant B , on w011/4 agrees with predictions in the references cited, among others. In the frequently cited discussion of Nminin [ 11, an additional factor of wO-l was included based upon a set of assumptions concerning the frequency dependence of the relationship between incident microwave power in the waveguide outside a cavity and B , in the cavity. The relationships in Table 4.1 do not bear out this assumption. The range of exponents in Table 4.1 indicates that one needs to exercise great care in selecting the appropriate relationships to predict frequency dependence of signal intensity for a particular situation. One also needs to consider practical realities. Scaling a resonator design over a wide frequency range may not be possible because of machining tolerances, or because gaps become too small to prevent arcing during high-power pulses. In addition, resonator dimensions may become so much smaller at higher frequencies that it is not possible to maintain a constant sample size. Thus the practical need for different resonators at different frequencies may prevent one from taking advantage of theoretically predicted advantages. Table 4.1. Predicted Frequency Dependence of EPR Signal Intensity
Case 1 const. Sample size
Case 2 sample size oc wO-l
Case 3 const. sample size
const. LGR size
LGR size = wO-l
LGR size = wO-l
L
1
(4.3)
wO-l
(4.3)
wO-1
(4.3)
R
w01/2
(4.4)
w01/2
(4.4)
w01/2
(4.4)
Q
oo1/2
(4.5)
00-%
w0-%
(4.5)
r\
1
EPR signal, AE,at constant P
w03/2
(4.6)
wo1/2
0-?4
(4.7)
P to maintain constant B ,
wo1/2
(4.7)
EPR signal, AE,at constant B ,
007/4(4.6,4.7)
/fi
B1
(4.5,4.7)
(4.10)
(4.8)
wo3 w07/2
w03/4
(4.9)
030314
(4.9)
w0-3/2
(4.9)
w0-312
(4.9)
1
w0-1/4
(4.8,4.9)
(4.11)
(4.9,4.11)
aThe equation numbers that are the bases for the various statements are given in parentheses. The table lists overall frequency dependence and does not include proportionality constants.
4. Frequency Dependence of EPR Sensitivity
71
4.3 Comparison with Frequency Dependence of NMR Since the fundamental spin resonance is the same, the frequency dependencies predicted in Table 4.1 should agree with the predictions for NMR when the same assumptions are made. In NMR the signal typically is represented as a current induced in a coil by precession of the spins [S-151. The typical NMR case would be case 1, i.e., a constant sample size and constant loop size, for which the inductance L is constant. The NMR expression derived for the same assumptions as the table entries gives an 002 dependence, where one factor of coo comes from (as in eqn. 4.1 and 4.2) and the second factor of wo comes from Lenz’s law. To compare this frequency dependence with that described for EPR signals note that since QL = wd;/2R, eqn. (4.2) can be written as
x“
Thus, both approaches predict an O$ dependence at constant power if the frequency dependence of R is ignored. Frequency dependence of sensitivity (signal-to-noise, SIN) depends on the frequency dependence of both signal and noise. The NMR literature discusses “sample noise” and “coil noise,” while the EPR literature, largely based on microwave engineering descriptions of cavity resonators, describes these features in terms of changes in Q of the resonator. For example, losses or dissipation of power must be due to resistance, and whether one describes the losses separately, or as part of what contributes to a change in Q, the effect must be the same. If one increases gain to compensate for the decrease in signal due to the lower Q, there is an increase in the noise relative to the signal. T h s is the origin of the concept of sample noise. This effect increases as w2 [13-161. Based on early work by Lauterbur, Hoult, Andrew and others [9,13-151 it is now generally agreed that the SIN in MRI and spectroscopy in living systems follows a o~~~ to w1 frequency dependence. Since EPR approaches the same frequencies for imaging and in vivo EPR, the analysis is relevant. The NMR signal voltage is proportional to w2, where w is the operating frequency. Noise voltage due to resistance in the radiofrequency coil probe circuit is proportional to o ~ whle / ~ , noise due to losses in the patient’s body is proportional to a.At low frequencies where losses are small, the SIN varies as At higher frequencies, where the coil losses are less important, the SIN depends linearly on w.
72
G. R. Euton, S. S. Euton, and G. A. Rinard
Analogies with MIU informed the effort to strive for lower frequency for EPR imaging (see, for example, Halpern and Bowman [17]). Thus, the EPR signal at constant Q should be proportional to w2 while the thermal noise should be proportional to all2, resulting in an overall SIN proportional to w3l2. If inductive losses in tissue dominate, the effective resistance is proportional to 02,and SIN is predicted to scale linearly with W. Measurements at low frequency have confirmed the linear dependence of SIN on frequency in EPR [ 181 and NMR [ 16,191.
4.4 Design of EPR in vivo Imaging Experiments The real situation for animal samples will be somewhere between the extremes of and 0712. One might scale the resonator size with frequency (case 2) from X-band to Lband, in order to be able to study a mouse. But then there would be no further benefit in making the resonator large relative to the mouse, so then one would switch to keeping both the sample and resonator size constant (case 1) as the frequency is lowered by another factor of 5 to 200 MHz. For this one would pay a signal amplitude price of about 17. However, this loss would be ameliorated somewhat by the greater penetration depth of the RF at the lower frequency. If the signal came from the center of the mouse, one might not lose much signal by lowering frequency, since the skin depth is proportional to and is significant for an animal the size of a mouse at frequencies above about 200 MHz. Together with the noise due to losses in the sample discussed above, the net result is that in practical applications sensitivity (SIN) appears to increase approximately linearly with frequency for animal imaging in the RF range [ 16,18,19]. As measurements proceed to larger animals, it will be necessary to scale the resonator size to fit them, and the best results will be obtained if the wavelength is large compared with the size of the animal. If the organ of interest increases in size proportionately with the overall size of the animal, the situation is more like case 2, and SIN should not be much worse at lower frequency. Interaction of the dielectric and conductivity properties of the sample with the microwaves also decreases SIN. Aqueous and conducting samples have frequencydependent skin depths [ 17,201. The dielectric properties can produce phase changes that can null signals from certain locations in samples [ZO]. The much larger penetration
4. Frequencj Dependence of EPR Sensitivity
73
depth at low frequencies can result in many more spins in a large sample being visible at low frequency than at high frequency. This effect can reverse the general trend toward greater sensitivity at higher frequency. Heterogeneous samples appear to have greater penetration depth than homogeneous samples of the same type of material. The physical interactions that result in the losses mentioned here also result in reduction of the resonator Q, and the detected ESR signal is proportional to resonator Q. All of the above discussion is relevant to signal intensities in both CW and pulsed EPR, if the relaxation times are long enough, as they usually are in NMR. However, if electron spin relaxation times are short enough to be comparable to instrument deadtimes, then new sensitivity considerations apply. If Q is constant, and the electron spin relaxation time is constant and equal to the dead-time at one frequency, then the sensitivity for pulsed EPR decreases as e-nz, where n is the proportional relative frequency. To avoid this strong dependence on frequency, it is necessary to reduce the dead-time proportional to the reduction in frequency. This could be done with a combination of a crossed-loop resonator [21,22], active Q-spoiling [23], and passive or active pulse cancellation [24,25]. Pulsed EPR imaging of a radical injected into a mouse has been achieved [26]. The reduction in Q due to a given lossy sample decreases with frequency, even for the same filling factor. This effect also tends to favor lower frequency ESR for lossy samples. All of these effects together could even reverse the expected trends of SIN with frequency, such that it is conceivable that the ultimate molar (spins per volume) sensitivity for biological samples and other lossy samples could increase as the frequency decreases. This remains to be demonstrated, but there is good basis for exploration in this direction.
Acknowledgments We appreciate discussions with Richard W. Quine (University of Denver) and with Professors Howard J. Halpern (University of Chicago), Jack H. Freed (Cornell University), R. Linn Belford (University of Illinois) and others.
74
G. R. Eaton, S. S. Eaton, and G. A. Rinard
References I. 2.
C. P. Poole, Jr., Electron Spin Resonance, Wiley, New York, 1967, chapter 14.
G. A. Rinard, S. S. Eaton, G. R. Eaton, C. P. Poole, Jr. and H. A. Farach, in Handbook of Electron Spin
Resonance, Vol. 2, C. P. Poole, Jr. and H. A. Farach, eds, Springer-Verlag.in press. 3.
A. Abragam and B. Bleaney, Electron Paramagnetic Resonance of Transition Ions. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1970.
4.
5.
T. M. Wilmshurst, Electron Spin Resonance Spectrometers, Plenum Press, New York, 1968.
G. K. Fraenkel, Paramagnetic Resonance Absorption, Chapter XLII in Technique of Organic Chemistry, Vol. I
-
Part IV, Physical Methods of Organic Chemistry, Third Edition, A. Weissberger, ed.,
lnterscience Publishers, New York, 1960.
6.
G. Feher, Bell System Technical Journal 36 (1957) 449.
7.
Varian spectrometer manual 87-125-052, page 3-8.
8.
A. Makovski, Mugn. Reson. Med. 36 (1996) 494.
9.
E. R. Andrew, Magnetic Resonance and Related Phenomena, Elsevier, 1989 (241hAmpere Congress, Poznan, 1988), page 45-51.
10.
A. Abragam, The Principles of Nuclear Magnetism. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1961.
11.
D. I. Hoult, Encyclopedia of NMR.D. M. Grant and R. K. Harris, eds., 7 (1996) 4256.
12.
D. I. Hoult and R. E. Richards, J. Magn. Reson. 24 (1976) 71.
13.
D. I. Hoult and P. C. Lauterbur, J. Mugn. Reson. 34 (1979) 425.
14.
C.-N. Chen and D. I. Hoult, Biomedical Magnetic Resonance Technology,Adam Hilger, Bristoi, 1989.
15.
M. T. Vlaardingerbroek and J. A. den Boer, Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Springer, 1996.
16.
D. L. Hoult, C.-N. Chen, and V. J. Sank, Magn. Reson. Med. 3 (1986) 730.
17.
H. J. Halpem and M. K. Bowman, in EPR fmaging and in vivo EPR, G. R. Eaton, S. S. Eaton, and K. Ohno, eds., CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1989, Ch. 6.
18.
L. G. Stoodley, J. Elect. Control 14 (1963) 531.
19.
W. A. Edelstein, G. H. Glover, C. J. Hardy, and R. W. Redington, Magn. Reson. Med. 3 (1986) 604.
20.
M. Sueki, G. A. Rinard, S. S. Eaton, and G. R. Eaton, J. Magn. Reson. A 118 (1996) 173.
21.
G. A. Rinard, R. W. Quine, B. T. Ghim, S. S. Eaton, and G. R. Eaton, J. Magn. Reson. A 122 (1996) 50.
22.
G. A. Rinard, R. W. Quine, B. T. Ghim, S. S. Eaton, and G. R. Eaton, J. Magn. Reson. A 122 ( 1 996) 58.
23.
S. Pfetminger, W. Froncisz, J. Forrer, J. Luglio, and J. S. Hyde, Rev.Sci. Instrum. 66 (1995) 4857.
24.
J. L. Davis and W. B. Mims, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 52 (1981) 131.
25.
P. A. Narayana, R. J. Massoth, and L. Kevan, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 53 (1982) 624.
26.
R. Murugesan, J. A. Cook, N. Devasahayam, M. Afeworki, S. Subramanian, R. Tschudin, J. A. Larsen,
J. B. Mitchell, A. Russo, M. C. Krishna, Mugn. Reson. Med. 38 (1997) 409.
5. SPRITE Imaging of Short Relaxation Time Nuclei Bruce J. Balcom MRI Center, Department of Physics, University of New Brunswick, P.O. Box 4400, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada, E3B 5A3
Abstract A generic pulse sequence based on the Single Point Imaging method is introduced. The pulse sequence, Single Point Ramped Imaging with T I Enhancement (SPRITE) is a pure phase encode technique with broadband RF excitation pulses and a stepped or ramped primary phase encode gradient. The technique, which is a version of the constant time imaging method, permits visualization of nuclei with T2*relaxation times of well under 100 ps. Applications of the method to imaging porous media, gas phase nuclei and bone materials are described.
5.1 Introduction Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) has proven to be a superior method of visualizing internal structure in a large range of non-medical systems [ 11. It is nevertheless true that the majority of these applications correspond to materials or systems with relatively long lived MR signals, and that the imaging methods employed are traditional spin echo or gradient echo methods popular in clinical MRI. There exist a large number of interesting and important systems where the MR signal lifetimes are short, < 1 ms, and therefore not readily visualized with these methods. We are interested in the development of MRI methods which are able to image systems with short relaxation times due to surface relaxation in water bearing porous mate-
rials, quadrupolar relaxation of quadrupolar nuclei in asymmetric environments, polymer and other ‘solid’ materials with short T2 due to dipolar broadening, and gas phase
16
6.J. Balcom
nuclei with short relaxation times due to spin rotation relaxation [2]. In all but the third area listed above not only are transverse relaxation times typically under 1 ms but the spin lattice relaxation times are also usually on the order of milliseconds. In porous concrete materials, the area in which we have the greatest experience, the T2*relaxation time of evaporable water is typically under 200 ps with TI relaxation times of several ms.
5.1.1
Review of Short T i Methods
Many groups have proposed short
T.* imaging methods. Three dimensional projection
reconstruction (PR) has been espoused by several groups [3-5). Unfortunately the PR techniques inherently corrupt the origin of k space, due to the RF pobe ring down andlor gradient switching. These methods require data correction and regridding prior to Fourier reconstruction. The PR technique is not an imaging method wherein contrast is easily manipulated and since it is based on frequency encoding it has an inherent resolution limitation. Multiple pulse line narrowing methods have been successful for small scale samples which have short transverse relaxation times due to the dipolar interaction [6]. These methods however require RF pulses with well defined flip angles and phases and therefore are not likely to be amenable to use with larger samples. These multiple pulse methods are useful for MRI of dipolar broadened solids but not any of the other three classes of problems outlined above. The STRAFZ technique has recently grown in popularity [7]. It is well suited to the visualization of ultra short relaxation time nuclei and has superior spatial resolution. However the technique is slow and not readily implemented in two or three dimensions because of the necessity of physical motion of the sample in the static Bo gradient. The range of flip angles experienced by off resonance nuclei also complicates the interpretation or imposition of contrast in the image. The oscillating gradient technique [8,9] shows promise for the rapid visualization of short relaxation time nuclei however it requires a specialized gradient set and k space is not rectilinearly sampled, requiring, once more, regridding prior to Fourier reconstruction. The technique is also not useful for nuclei with transverse relaxation times less than the period of the oscillating gradient.
5. SPRITE Imaging of Short Relaxation Time Nuclei
5.1.2
77
Single Point (Constant Time) Methods
We seek an MRI method which employs conventional ideas of raster k space sampling and Fourier reconstruction, that maintains flexibility of contrast through changes in timing parameters, and does not require specialized hardware. The method must, by definition, be able to encode very short lived signals, ideally signals which are of the order of the RF probe dead time (tens of ps). In a concrete sample the transverse relaxation time, 200 ps, is of the order of a gradient rise time. Therefore one must excite the sample in the presence of a magnetic field gradient rather than pulsing the field gradient after excitation as is the usual practice. Furthermore, excitation will require broadband RF pulses of duration much less than T,*. Single Point Imaging (SPZ), satisfies these conditions and was suggested as a solids imaging method by Cory in 1994 [lo]. Despite its promise, SPI, Fig. 5.1, has been sparsely utilized [ 11,121.The technique is also known as Constant Time Imaging.
Fig. 5.1: One dimensional SPI sequence. Note the broadband RF pulse applied in the presence of the phase encode gradient. k Space is sampled, point by point, by amplitude cycling the phase encode gradient with repetitive RF excitation pulses. The encoding time is tp, the repetition time is TR.
SPI relies on broadband RF pulses of limited duration with the pulse bandwidth greater than the maximum spectral width (Gmaxx sample size) of the object under study [lo]. Position is encoded in reciprocal space, S(k), where k = 1 4 2 ~yG ) t, by amplitude cycling of the applied phase gradients G. A single point on the FID is sampled in quadrature a fixed encoding time tp after the RF pulse. Unlike frequency encoded images, SPI images are free from distortions due to B, inhomogeneity, susceptibility variations, and
78
B. J. Balcom
chemical shift [lo]. In addition, as a pure phase encode technique SPI avoids the line width restrictions on resolution common to time based sampling, frequency encode, methods [lo].
5.2 SPRITE The signal intensity, S , from any point in an SPI image is related to local proton density, p, by eqn. (5.1) where the pulse flip angle is 8 [ 131
The term in square brackets represents steady state longitudinal magnetization established through a succession of excitation pulses where we assume transverse magnetization is completely dephased between pulses. This term suggests the possibility of introducing TI contrast into the image by employing large flip angle pulses with repetition times on the order of T I .The short TI of many systems of interest further suggests that rapid pulsing should permit rapid k space traversal. The finite time required to safely and repetitively switch magnetic field gradients can be the limiting condition on a minimum TR [13]. Intense, rapidly switched gradient pulses in this sequence can lead to excessive, even dangerous gradient vibration. In response to these limitations we have developed the SPRITE sequence which greatly reduces imaging times, minimizes gradient vibration and also enables the introduction of quantitative TI contrast, or T I suppression, into a variety of images 1131. In the SPRITE sequence we ramp the primary phase encode gradient in discrete steps and apply an RF pulse, collecting a single data point, at each gradient step, Fig. 5.2. A major advantage of SPRITE is that we retain, for short T2*samples, the traditional flexibility of contrast manipulation through relaxation time weighting. The SPRITE experiment, due to minimal overall dBJdt, is silent.
5. SPRITE Imaging 01 Short Relanation Timr Nit( lei
79
RF
Fig. 5.2: Two dimensional SPRITE sequence. The primary phase encode gradient is stcpped betwecn discrete values as a function of the secondary phase encode gradients (one shown). The encoding time is tp, the repetition time is TR. A single point is acquired at cach gradient value. SPRITE phantom tests showed that we are readily able to observe
T7*signals under
100 ps in duration with T , contrast over at least four orders of magnitude [13]. Large flip angle pulses permit suppression of long TI signal components, from lH containing plastics in the RF probe or sample holder. The SPRITE cxperiment does not permit slice selection with KF pulses, therefore unless the samplc symmetry permits one or two dimensional imaging, it is inherently a three dimensional method.
5.3 SPRITE Implementation The principal SPRITE acquisition time limitations are gradient amplifier or gradient coil overheating. Actively cooled gradient coils, with modern gradient amplifiers will however support 100%gradient duty cyclcs in which case thc SPRITE acquisition time limitation will become experimental sensitivity. A 1 ms TR, h43 SPRITE acquisition, with no signal averaging, will require under 5 minutes to acquire. Lacking slice selection, it is not possible to average signal over an arbitrarily thick slice. This may however be desirable for low sensitivity SPRITE experiments. We have shown that physical slice selection with an RF shield works surprisingly well I 13,141.
80
B. J. Balcom
The primary and secondary phase encode gradients in the SPRITE sequence inherently spoil transverse magnetization everywhere except at the origin of k space. In some instances, with long T, signal components, we have observed spin echo contribution to the k space origin signal which produces an elevated baseline artifact in the image. These artifacts are easily removed by the imposition of a pseudo random low amplitude spoiling gradient following the observed point at low amplitudes of the primary phase encode gradient [15]. This removes spin echo artifacts and reintroduces a small amount of periodic gradient noise to the experiment. This noise is a useful audio queue to the progress of the SPRITE acquisition. Quadrature RF probes are highly advantageous to increase the experimental sensitivity in order to avoid signal averaging. It is possible to sample multiple time points following each RF pulse in a SPRITE experiment and reconstruct one image from each set of detected points. Although these images differ in field of view, they may be interpolated onto a common field of view and added to effectively signal average without any increase in acquisition time! [16] As a pure phase encode technique SPRITE is immune to distortions in B, introduced by nearby sensors and ancillary equipment within the RF probe. We have undertaken a large number of temperature controlled SPRITE experiments, including MRI calorimetry with thermocouples implanted in and on samples under study [16,17]. The thermocouples, and other sensors, do not introduce image artifacts. In order to predict and understand contrast in SPRITE images it is useful to quantitatively measure, spatially resolved, T I , T2, and
T2*relaxation times. Relaxation time
mapping also provides a better understanding of the sample properties. We have recently developed, tested and validated a battery of methods to make these measurements [ 181.
5.3.1
Concrete Materials
The behavior of water in concrete presents a unusual dichotomy. Water is essential to formation of the material through the hydration process. However, once substantially formed the uncombined (free) water usually acts as the prime agent for distress or deterioration of the material. In commercial and industrial settings, concrete is moist cured (kept water saturated) for several days and then allowed to dry out naturally with the drying process continuing at a decreasing rate for months or years. The free water content prior to drying is usually at least 5%. The actual moisture content as a function of
5. SPRITE Imaging of Short Relaxation Time Nuclei
81
space and time depends on the size of the concrete member and the drying conditions. Our inability to predict moisture levels at the local level, and to understand the role this moisture plays in the various deterioration mechanisms, is one of the main reasons we have major problems with decay of our civil engineering infrastructure in Canada and the world.
Fig. 5.3: Proton density weighted three dimensional SPRITE image of a non porous aggregate embedded in a small concrete sample (diameter 3.3 cm). The 64 x 64 x 128 image had an encoding time 130 ps and the repetition time 1.5 ms. The image, 8 averages, required 8 hours principally due to a conservative delay introduced following each primary phase encode ramp to prevent gradient amplifier overheating.
We have employed SPI and SPRITE imaging techniques to study one dimensional drying of real concrete samples [19,20]. Due to sample size restrictions the STRAFI technique is unable to study concrete specimens which contain aggregates. These aggregates however are vital to the function of concrete, and cement paste samples alone are known to have different behavior (in many ways) from real concrete specimens. We are
82
B. J. Balcom
employing high resolution three dimensional SPRITE imaging to examine cement paste structure in close proximity to aggregates, in model samples, because the aggregate/paste interface is known to be a source of weakness and failure in many concretes [21]. We are also able to use our single point relaxation time mapping techniques and SPRITE calorimetry to study cement paste structure in the interfacial zone. Figure 5.3 is a high resolution three dimensional SPRITE image, rendered, and cut to reveal a single aggregate embedded in a concrete specimen.
5.3.2
Gas Phase Imaging
The high diffusion coefficient, low density and short relaxation times (spin rotation) of most gas phase nuclei largely prevent MRI of the gas phase. Non-equilibrium hyperpolarized gases 3He and 129Xe(which have unusually long T,) have attracted attention recently due to their potential for lung imaging [22]. Other investigators have proposed the use of hyperpolarized gases to probe the void space of porous materials. However the non-equilibrium hyperpolarized magnetization will regress to equilibrium governed by the time constant T,. If, in a porous medium, T , is short, due to for example surface interactions, the hyperpolarization will be rapidly depleted and a thermal equilibrium reestablished. We feel a more useful and aesthetically pleasing approach is to exploit the short relaxation times of most gas phase nuclei with gas phase SPRITE. Sulfur hexafluoride, SF, is an ideal tracer, it is inert and has a bulk T, of approximately 1 ms with a T2*of 900 ps. We anticipate negligible background 19F signal in most porous solids and plastic materials in sample holders and RF probes. One must avoid the use of Teflon materials. Figure 5.4 shows a three dimensional 643 I9F gas phase SPRITE image of a balloon containing one atmosphere of SF, which has penetrated a small sample of coral. The coral, a porous limestone material, is an ideal gas phase MRI phantom because it contains structure with a variety of size scales [23]. The largest scale structure is associated with the wedge shaped slices of high and low density limestone which originate from the center of the coral. The coral/gas phantom was sealed for several hours, under one atmosphere of SF,, prior to image acquisition. Note the region of high uniform signal from bulk gas surrounding the coral. Within the coral high signal regions (wedges) which originate from the sample center are clearly visible. These structures correspond to the low density, high porosity regions in the coral.
5. SPRITE Imaging of Short Relaxation Time Nuclei
83
Fig. 5.4: Three dimensional SPRITE image of an SF6 containing balloon, diameter approximately 4 cm, with a porous limestone phantom (coral) inside. The low density, high porosity channels in the coral readily take up SF6 and are clearly visualized in this rendered, cut, image. The encoding time was 320 ps and the repetition time 1.5 ms. The image was acquired overnight.
5.3.3
Solid Bone Imaging
Knowledge of bone mineral density is of crucial importance in the diagnosis of osteoporosis, predicting the risk of fracture and monitoring healing. Despite prolonged attention by several well known clinical MRI research groups [24-261, a flexible MRI method suited to the detection and quantification of signal directly from the solid bone material has not been developed. We feel that a low flip angle SPRITE experiment, which does not significantly deplete z magnetization, may provide a fast flexible and quantitative method of assessing bone mineral density. A three dimensional lH 643 SPRITE image of a bovine femur is shown in Fig. 5.5. As shown, the low flip angle SPRITE experiment permits observation of signal from all components of the femur including marrow, cartilage, flesh and compact bone [27].
84
B. J. Balcom
Fig. 5.5: Three dimensional SPRITE 128 x 128 x 64 image of a bovine femur. Note the compact bone surrounding the bone marrow in the interior. With these imaging parameters, the bone signal is 25% of the marrow signal. The field of view was 14 x 14 x 28 cm3. The encoding time was 150 ps and the repetition time 1.5 ms. The image, 4 averages, required 5 hours. Once more the long acquisition time ensured the gradient amplifiers did not overheat.
31P low flip angle SPRITE experiments reveal signal only from bone mineral in the compact bone. The marrowlsolution concentration of 31P is much less than the solid phase 31Pconcentration. We are exploring methods of suppressing the unwanted long T I , T2 signal from marrow and flesh to isolate the true solid signal from trabecular and compact bone.
5. SPRITE Imaging of Short Relaxation Time Nuclei
85
5.4 Conclusion The SPRITE technique appears to be a robust flexible method of imaging a wide range of systems with short T2*signals. For example, we feel that the SPRITE technique will be a viable method of imaging free radical species, with attendant short relaxation times, in the fringe field of a superconducting magnet. SPRITE employs traditional ideas of k space sampling and permits the introduction of both T2*and T, contrast. Derivatives of the technique permit T1, T2 and T2*mapping. The technique requires good hardware but no unusual or custom built equipment.. The technique is still rapidly evolving. Our current work is aimed at increasing the sensitivity and speed of the method. We are also exploring alternative k space trajectories to minimize the acquisition time and manipulate the image contrast.
Acknowledgments The development of the SPRITE technique has been a collaborative effort of the many members of the MRI Center at the University of New Brunswick. Special thanks are due Robin Armstrong, without whom the MRI Center would not exist. We have been greatly assisted by colleagues from other departments and institutions who have presented a litany of interesting short T;” problems. These include Jon Shah, Joseph White, Frank Rack, Theodore Bremner, Alan Logan, Eric Gozna and Patrick Grattan-Bellew. The work has been supported by NSERC through equipment and operating grants and an NSERCNRC Research Partnership award with a consortium of concrete/building materials companies. The New Brunswick Medical Research Fund has supported the work on SPRITE bone imaging.
References 1.
B. Bliimich, W. Kuhn, eds. Magnetic Resonance Microscopy, VCH, Weinheim, 1992.
2.
J. A. Courtney, R. L. Armstrong, Can. L Phys. 50 (1972) 1252.
3.
G. H. Glover, J. M. Pauly, K. M. Bradshaw, Magn. Reson. Med. 8 (1988) 231.
4.
F. E. Boada, J. S. Gillen, G. X. Shen, S. Y. Chang, Magn. Reson. Med. 37 (1997) 706.
5.
D. Kuethe, A. Caprihan, E. Fukushima, R. A. Waggoner, Abstracts of the 5th ISMRM, (1997) 1066.
6.
D. G. Cory, Ann. Rep. NMR Spectrosc. 24 (1992) 87.
86
B. J. Balcom
7.
P. J. McDonald, Prog. NMR Spectrosc. 30 (1997) 69.
8.
M. J. Mallett, S. L. Codd, M. R. Hake, T. A. Green, J. H. Strange, J. Magn. Reson. A 119 (1996) 105.
9.
J. M. Star-Lack, M. S. Roos, S. T. Wong, V. D. Schepkin, T. F. Budinger, J. Magn. Reson. 124 (1997)
420. 10.
S. Gravina. D. G. Cory, J. Magn. Reson. B 104 (1994) 53.
11.
A. Nauerth, B. Gewiese,Abstracts of the 12th SMRM (1993) 1215.
12.
D. E. Axelson, A. Kantzas, T. Eads, Can. J. Appl. Spec. 40 (1995) 16.
13.
B. J. Balcom, R. P. MacGregor, S. D. Beyea, D. P. Green, R. L. Armstrong, T. W. Bremner,
J. Magn. Reson. A 123 (1996) 131. 14.
F. R. Rack, B.J. Balcom, R. P. MacGregor, R. L. Armstrong, J. Paleolimnology 19 (1998) 255.
15.
C. B. Kennedy, B. J. Balcom, I. V. Mastikhin, submitted.
16.
P. J. Prado, B. J. Balcom, S. D. Beyea, R. L. Armstrong, T. W. Bremner, Solid State NMR 10 (1997) 1.
17.
P. J. Prado, B. J. Balcom, S. D. Beyea, T. W. Bremner, R. L. Armstrong, P. E. Grattan-Bellew, Cem. Concr. Res. 28 (1998) 261.
18.
S. D. Beyea, B. J. Balcom, P. J. Prado, A. R. Cross, C. B. Kennedy, R. L. Armstrong, T. W. Bremner, submitted.
19. 20.
M. Bogdan, B. J. Balcom, R. L. Armstrong, J. Magn. Reson. A 116 (1995) 266.
S. D. Beyea, B. J. Balcom, T. W. Bremner, P. J. Prado, D. P. Green, R. L. Armstrong, P. E. GrattanBellew, Cein. Concr. Res. 28 (1998) 453.
21. 22.
S. D. Beyea, B. J. Balcom, P. J. Prado, manuscript in preparation.
M. S. Albert, G. D. Cates, B. Driehuys, W. Happer, €3. Saam, C. S. Springer, A. Wishnia, Nature
370 (1994) 199. 23.
P. J. Prado, B. J. Balcom, I. V. Mastikhin, A. C. Cross, R. L. Armstrong, A. Logan, submitted.
24.
K. Selby, S. Majumdar, D. C. Newitt, H. K. Genant, J. M a p . Reson. Inzag. 6 (1996)549.
25.
H. Chung, F. W. Wehrli, J. L. Williams, S. D. Kugelmass, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 90 (1993) 10250.
26.
C. Ramanathan, Y . Wu, B. Pfleiderer, M. J. Lizak, L. Ganido, J. L. Ackerman, J. Magn. Reson. A
121 (1996) 127. 27.
C. B. Kennedy, J. Dysart, B. J. Balcom, manuscript in preparation.
6. Refocussing a Spin-Echo in the Presence of a Strong Readout Gradient Field Using an Underdriven Gradient Pulse G. PlaninSic Physics Department, University of Ljubljana, Slovenia M. Symrns Department of Clinical Neurology, Institute of Neurology, London, UK
Abstract A decrease in the amplitude of a spin-echo in the presence of a strong readout gradient field is explained for the pulse sequence where defocusing and refocusing gradients are applied with equal amplitudes. It is shown that the spin-echo can be completely refocused by applying different gradient rise time values.
6.1 Introduction A basic assumption commonly used to simplify calculations in MRI is that the crossterms caused by application of a "gradient field" are negligible. This is not the case when the gradient field is strong, when these concomitant or Maxwell terms can cause image distortions [11. Such distortions have been discussed in low-field MRI, phase-contrast flow sequences [2], and even in exotic variants such as electron spin resonance and Overhauser imaging [ 3 ] .It has been observed that echo-planar imaging (EPI) can also be subject to distortions caused by concomitant gradients [4]. Previously, we showed how a pi-pulse-refocused EPI variant, which is similar to the snap-shot fast spin-echo (SS-FSE) sequences now becoming available on commercial machines, could be made relatively insensitive to the effect of concomitant gradients [5].
88
G.PlaninSic and M . Symms
Here we extend this analysis and develop a novel method of refocusing a spin-echo in the presence of concomitant gradients: the "underdriven"pulse.
6.2 Theory The envelope of the spin-echo is calculated in two steps: first the time dependence of the phase angle at a particular point in the selected plane is calculated using the adiabatic approximation. In the second step, the spin-echo envelope for a square sample is calculated by integrating the magnetic moment projections. For simplicity spin relaxation effects have been neglected. Consider a main magnetic field Bo = (O,O,Bo)and a time dependent real gradient field of the form
where H(t) is a dimensionless function describing the gradient time dependence and Go is the gradient amplitude. Therefore the total magnetic field vector Btot = Bo
+ B,
changes both in magnitude and direction. It has been shown [6] that if the rate of change in the direction of B,,,(t) is much smaller than the Larmor frequency (adiabatic approximation) the spins precess in the plane perpendicular to B,,,(t) direction all the time. The angle subtended by B,,(t) and the z axis is given by
8 = arctan((-H(t) Go y)l(Bo+H(t) Go z ) )
(6.2)
The angular velocity deldt at switch-on of the trapezoidal gradient waveform (rise time T)
for the corner points of a square sample with sides 2a is given by T). deldt = (Go ~)l(Bo
(6.3)
For typical parameters occurring in a commercial whole-body EPI scanner (Go = 22 mT/m, T = 0.184 ms, a = 0.25 m, Bo = 1.5 T) we have deldt = 20 Hz which clearly fulfils the adiabatic approximation. The phase angle of spins at a particular point in the sample can be calculated by treating the B,, magnitude only but bearing in mind that the plane of precession is perpendicular to the direction of BtOt.The phase angle in this case
6. Refocussing a Spin-Echo in a Strong Gradient Using an Underdriven Gradient Pulse
89
is defined as the angle in the time varying plane which is always perpendicular to BtOt.
For spins at coordinates (y,z) the phase angle accumulated during time tl in the time dependent total magnetic field is given by
Let us now calculate the total phase accumulated by spins at point (y,z) during the pulse sequence shown in Fig.6.1. where we may choose a different second gradient rise time. n
z
z’
z
t
I 90’
180’
Fig. 6.1: SE pulse sequence with underdriven second gradient pulse.
For now we still allow the arbitrary gradient switch-odoff shape function H ( t ) requiring only that all the ramps are described with the same shape function which can be mirrored
for switch-off or stretched to give a different z. Using eqn.(6.4) the total phase angle can be described in the form
where q = Bd(Goa),to measures the time of constant gradient field Go between ramps, z and z’ are the first and second gradient rise time values, indexes C and SW indicate constant and switching gradient and M(y,z), N(y,z) are functions of y and z only, defined
90
G.PlaninSic and M. Symms
by the sample geometry. Note that time t is measured from the end of second gradient switch-on. The following conclusions can be drawn from eqn. (6.5): 1) In practice normally all gradient switches are performed with the same rise time T. In this case the term T M b , z ) represents an additional position-dependent phase
shift at point b,z) in the sample. This phase shift does not allow all the spins to refocus at the same time and so causes the decrease in SE amplitude. The decrease can be reduced by shortening the rise time value, providing the adiabatic approximation remains valid and gradient performance permits. 2) If the second gradient is switched with rise time ‘c’ = 27 then the term with M(y,7) vanishes for all y and z. Complete spin refocusing occurs at t = to. This holds for an arbitrary gradient switch shape function as long as the switch-on and switchoff shapes are mirror images of each other. Using the expressions above the SE envelope for trapezoidal gradient waveforms with fixed rise time T and a sample with square cross section (2a x 212) centered in the plane @,z) can be calculated. Since Bo > Goa in all practical cases, the expression under the integral in eqn. (6.4) can be written using the following approximation
where coordinates are measured in units a (y’ = yla, 2’ = ?/a). Using this approximation the integrals in eqn. (6.5) can be calculated, taking the linear shape function for trapezoidal waveforms. The resultant total phase angle can be expressed in the following form
W y ’ , ~ ’ ,=t C ) ~+ ~ Dz’ ~ +EY’~ where
c = 2 d tL (2T - ’C’ + to - t ) D = X I (q tL) (22 - 2’ + 2(to - t>) E = XI(3q2 tL) (2T - ‘C’
+ 3(to - t))
(6.7)
6. Refocussing a Spin-Echo in a Strong Gradient Using an Underdriven Gradient Pulse
91
and tL = 2n/yB0is the Larmor period. The signal is given by the integration of the spin projections in the direction of the detection coil axis all over the sample slice: 1
1
-1
-1
Combining the eqns. (6.7), (6.8) and (6.9) the following result can be obtained S(t) = So (sin(D)/D) (Fcos(p)/p)
(6.10)
where Fcos is the Fresnel cosine, p 2 = 2IElh and So is the signal amplitude obtained for complete refocusing. This result can be interpreted in the following way: the Fourier transform of the square sample, which is known to be a sinc function, is modulated by the factor that comes from the concomitant gradient components. The value of modulation is less or equal to unity and is shown as a function of p in Fig. 6.2.
Y 1 0.8 0.6
0.4 0.2
0
1
2
3
4
‘P
Fig. 6.2: Fcos(p)/p as a function of p .
It can be shown that the SE peek occurs approximately at time t = to + T - ~ ’ / 2From . the eqn. (6.10) the decrease in SE amplitude for pulse sequence with constant gradient rise time T can be calculated. The results of calculation of the SE amplitude as a function of ratio q for several rise times T and T = T’ are shown in Fig. 6.3. The results were obtained with Mathematica 3.0 .
92
G.PlaninSic and M. Symms
Fig. 6.3: Normalised SE amplitude as a function of logarithm of q = Bd(Goa)for different rise time values T and T’ = T. Rise time values are measured in Larmor periods tL. The SE amplitudes has been obtained using Mathematics 3.0. The oscilations at high gradient values (low q) are due to partial refocussation.
6.3 Discussion As the range of applications of MRI continues to develop, images will be acquired in more extreme regimes where commonplace assumptions can fail. In order to preserve maximal signal-to-noise and information content, experiments will have to increase in complexity to meet these ever more stringent demands. Concomitant gradients are an example of the challenges that can be posed in numerous different MFU regimes, and while post-processing correction algorithms are often useful, the underdrive pulse as part of a spin-echo refocused imaging sequence offers a theoretically perfect solution. SS-FSE, for instance, is potentially a very attractive imaging acquisition module, with a speed and flexibility approaching that of EPI, but without the latter‘s sensitivity to off-resonance effects that cause undesirable image distortions in many applications. In the clinical realm, a SS-FSE sequence that is immune to concomitant gradient distortions would be particularly suitable at low-field where the Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) is low: open-magnet configurations for claustrophobic patients or interventional scanners, and Overhauser-enhanced imaging systems that cannot switch their main field [7], are two possible areas of exploitation. The underdrive pulse may also find application in
6. Refocussing a Spin-Echo in a Strong Gradient Using an Underdriven Gradient Pulse
93
particular EPI acquisitions that are refocused under a spin-echo (SE-EPI), where the suggestion of Weisskoff et. al. of a "pre-warping" pulse [4] might be implemented. Other areas that might warrant investigation are the use of very large uni-polar gradients for diffusion-weighting, especially in the microscopic regime. There are only two small drawbacks of the underdrive pulse. The first is the need to produce a gradient lobe with half the slew-rate of the rest of the imaging sequence. In some modern clinical systems where all the gradient slew-rates are limited in an attempt to prevent neural stimulation, some additional pulse-sequence programming complexity will ensue. The second drawback is a slight increase in the minimum possible echo time. In spite of these obstacles, the underdrive pulse offers the ability to completely refocus concomitant gradients in a spin-echo sequence.
References 1.
D. G. Noms, J. M. S. Hutchison, Mugn. Reson. Zmug. 8 (1990) 33-37.
2.
J.-H. Gao, A. W. Anderson, J. C. Gore, Phys. Med. Biol. 37 (1992) 1705-1715.
3.
D. G. Gillies, L. H. Sutcliffe, M. R. Symms, J. Chem. SOC.Furuduy Trans. 90 (1994) 2671-2675.
4.
R. M. Weisskoff, M. S. Cohen, R. R. Rzedzian, Magn. Reson. Med. 29 (1993) 796-803.
5.
M. R. Symms, G. Planinsic, 4th Meeting ISMRM,New York, 1996, Abstract #1391.
6.
J. StepiSnik, M. Kos, G. PlaninSic, V. Erzen, J. Mugn. Reson. A 107 (1994) 167-172.
7.
T. Claasen-Vujcic, J. Slotboom, A. F. Mehlkopf, 3rd Meeting ZSMRM,Nice, 1995, Abstract #314.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
7. The Analysis and Development of Pulse Sequences for Self-Diffusion Weighted Stray Field Imaging A. J. Bohris, D. A. Faux, D. G. Gillies, and P. J. McDonald
School of Physical Sciences, University of Surrey, Guildford, Surrey, GU2 5XH, UK
Abstract A Fourier method of solving the Bloch equations for nuclear magnetisation precession in
a strong magnetic field gradient has been developed for the purpose of simulating the increasing number of pulse sequences now used in stray field experiments. The simulation explicitly includes the action of the gradient during rf-pulses and the effects of spin relaxation and diffusion. The method is used here to analyse a multiple echo diffusion sequence which is designed to offer spatially resolved one-shot (multiple wave vector, 4 = yG6/27c; near constant diffusion time, A) measurement of self-diffusion in the stray field. A rapid one-shot method is required because stray field imaging is inherently slow since the measurement must be repeated at each spatial location.
7.1 Introduction Stray field magnetic resonance imaging [l] is increasingly used to image broad line
systems such as cementitious materials and polymers. Stray field self-difision techniques [2] are used to measure small diffusion coefficients in systems such as polymer melts. Both the imaging and diffusion applications exploit the extremely strong and stable magnetic field gradients found around high field superconducting magnets. However, this gradient cannot be switched off. Consequently, in multiple pulse sequences a large number of coherence pathways are excited and complex phase cycling is required to eliminate signals from unwanted pathways. Moreover, the effects of spin relaxation cannot be eliminated by comparative measurements with and without
96
A. J. Bohris, D. A. Faux, D. G. Gillies, and P. J. McDonald
gradients, unless a second magnet operating with a centre frequency equivalent to the stray field frequency of the first is available. Careful pulse sequence analysis is therefore required before any new sequences can be used with confidence. The Fourier method of solving the Bloch equation presented here has been developed with the purpose of simulating the increasing number of pulse sequences, which are now used in stray field experiments. The simulation explicitly includes the action of the gradient during the pulses and the effects of spin relaxation and diffusion. The simulation has been applied in particular to show that the sequence (2~~-a,),z1-90,-z1-(echo-2zl),-(z2-(2n + l)zl)-90,-z,-(echo-221), (Fig. 7. I), where a is a low flip angle pulse, affords an excellent means for achieving a spatially resolved one-shot diffusion sequence. The sequence is an adaptation of standard stimulated echo [3] and DANTE [4] type sequences.
I..... I
,
t
n a,- pulses
9OY n direct echoes
90
n stimulated echoes
Fig. 7.1: The one-shot diffusion pulse sequence.
Following Kimmich and Fischer [5], the diffusion coefficient is evaluated from the ratios of the amplitudes of the direct and stimulated echo intensities so that the measurement is independent of T2 relaxation. Moreover, T , relaxation enters only as a constant factor which need not be known. For the proposed sequence the functional dependence of the ratio of the i-th stimulatvd and direct echo on the diffusion coefficient is given by
where 6iand Ai are defined as 6i= (2i+ l)zl and Ai = z2 + 6,.
7. The Analysis and Development of Pulse Sequencesfor Self-DiffusionWeightedSTRAFI
97
7.2 Fourier Solution of the Bloch Equation The starting point is the Bloch equation including the diffusion term [6]
where all the parameters have their usual meanings. The magnetic field is of the form B = B, + B(z)where B, is the constant field (along z ) and B(z)is a function of z. In the absence of rf pulses B(z) is equal to G z where G is the field gradient. The calculation initially proceeds as Torrey. The complex transverse magnetisation is defined as rn =
M;, + M y and the analysis leads to a differential equation involving rn which can be solved by writing
This is the same substitution made by Torrey except that Q is now a function of both z and t, rather than t alone. Allowing (I to be a function of z is the critical advance which enables the time evolution of the magnetisation to be evaluated when the initial magnetisation is z-dependent. It can be shown by substitution and solving that
(7.4) A(z,t ) = c c : exp(k ik, z ) expk D yGt2k, - Dk;t)
(7.5)
n
where kn = n d l are a set of Fourier wave numbers and 1 is a suitably large length. Starting at t = 0, the complex constants cn* are written as
* 1 c, = $7,
1 k s,)+-i(., 2
T 4,)
(7.6)
98
A. J. Bohris, D. A. Faux, D. G. Gillies, andP. . I McDonald .
Expanding the complex exponential involving kn z into cosine and sine terms, it may be shown that
so that M,(z,O) and M&O) are represented as a Fourier series, with p,, q,, appropriate Fourier coefficients. For the z-magnetisation
Y,
and s, the
where g, and the hn are the Fourier coefficients required to reproduce the z-magnetisation at t = 0. In the presence of a pulse field the total applied field is a vector of magnitude B,. pointing along the 2’-axis at an angle p to the z-axis where Bzq=
and
p = arctan[z)
(-7~125 p 5 ~ / 2 ) (7.10)
IzI In the (x’,y’, z’) frame of reference the applied field has a magnitude given by eqn. 7.10 and points along the 2’-axis. The same procedure as already described can be adopted to solve for the magnetisation during the application of a pulse by first rotating the (x,y , z ) frame to the (x’,y’, z’) frame, solving for M as described, before rotating back to the (x,y , z ) frame. To simulate the evolving magnetisation during a pulse sequence the time evolution has to be calculated sequentially for each time period with either a pulse field switched on or off.
99
7. The Analysis and Development of Pulse Sequences f o r Self-DiJusion Weighted STRAFI
7.3 Experiment and Results 7.3.1
The Simulation
Figure 7.2a shows the direct and stimulated echoes for the sequence shown in Fig. 7.1 obtained from the simulation using the following parameters: T2 = T1 = 00, z1 = 15 ps,
z2= 275 ps, D
cm2 smland G = 50 T m-*. The low flip angle pulses had a
= 2.5 .
duration of 3 ps with a nominal flip angle a = 4.5" and 8 low flip angle pulses were applied. The 90" pulses had a length of 10 ps. Keeping the phase of the a pulses constant at (+x>the phases of the two 90" pulses were cycled in the following manner +y+y, +y-y, -y+y and -y-y. In Fig. 7.2b the ratios of stimulated to direct echo intensities are plotted against 8Z(Ai - &J. The diffusion coefficient obtained from these data yields D = cm2 s-l which is in excellent agreement with the input value for D.
2.51 .
10 r
I
I
I
I
1
I
bl
direct echo stimulated echo
I
I
I
I
0 ._
I
-2
d
0
100 200 Time [ps]
Io - ~
300
Fig. 7.2: a) The simulated echo trains for the direct echo (dash-dot line) and the stimulated echo (solid line). b) The ratios of the stimulateddirectechoes plotted against 6?(Ai - 6J.
7.3.2
The Experiments
All experiments were performed on a Chemagnetics Infinity spectrometer and a Magnex 400 MHz, 89 mm bore, superconducting magnet. The magnetic field strength is B , = 5.5 T at the sample position and the magnetic field gradient strength is G = 58 Tm-I. Water and glycerol were used as standard samples. For the spatially resolved measurements a phantom was used consisting of two small glass vials filled with water
100
A. L Bohris, D. A. Faux, D. G. Gillies, and P. .I McDonald .
and hexadecane which were placed one above the other in an 8 mm (0.d.) glass tube with a separation between the liquids of about 1.2 mm. The temperature was 20" f 1 "C. Figure 7.3a shows the echo profile of an experiment with glycerol. The pulse duration for both low flip angle and 90" pulses was 5 ps. The flip angle a was nominally 4.5". The pulse separations were zl= 40 ps and z2 = 5 ms. 16 a pulses were applied. In Fig. 7.3b the ratio of the echo amplitudes is plotted against 6:(Ai - 6,) The diffusion coefficient extracted from these data is D = 1.58 . cm2 s-l which is in reasonable agreement with literature values and reference measurements at this temperature.
0 .-
iii
U
0
800
1600 Points
2400
3200
Fig. 7.3: a) The experimental echo train obtained from glycerol. Acquisition parameters are as specified in the text. b) The ratio of the stimulated to direct echoes plotted against Si2(Ai - SJ.
In the imaging experiment all pulse durations were again 5 ps which corresponds to an excitation slice thickness of = 70 pm. The low flip angle a was nominally 4.5". The other parameters were: zl= 10 p;22 = 400 p;12 a-pulses; slice separation 0.3 mm and number of slices = 21. Figure 7.4a shows a spatial density map obtained from the intensities of the first direct echo across the vial interface region. The spatial distribution of diffusion coefficients is seen in Fig. 7.4b. The mean values of the self-diffusion coefficients measured in the experiment are for hexadecane D = 6.2 f 0.7 . cm2 s-l. These cm2 s-l and for water D = 2.3 f 0.2 . values are in good agreement with reference measurements using the modified stimulated echo sequence discussed in ref. [ 5 ] . The total imaging time was 18 hours, acquiring 1024 averages per slice and using a TI recycle time of 3 seconds.
101
7. The Analysis and Development of Pulse Sequencesfor SelfDifision Weighted STRAFI
-B
1o4
1.o
.-
[I)
c
2
%
0.8
u
hexadecane
Y
.,x 0.6 S u)
a,
.E 0.4
8 r
c
oooooo
1
t
r 0 .U
t o-~ "
S
0 .[I) zl c .0
0.2
i
L
0.0
-
1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1o-6
-
Position [mm]
1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Position [mm]
Fig 7.4: a) Spin density map of the sample interface region of the hexadecane-water phantom over a sample region of 6 mm. b) Spatial distribution of the diffusion coefficients in the same region. The gap arises from the glass of the vial walls.
7.4 Conclusions A Fourier method for solving the Bloch equations including a diffusion term has been presented. This technique has been used to simulate the effects of pulse sequences applied in the presence of strong and time-independent magnetic field gradients. A novel one-shot diffusion sequence has been proposed for use in stray field imaging. The envelope of the experimental echo decays indicates imperfections to which the ratios are insensitive. Most important is that the decrease of the ratio is independent of T2 relaxation, since the corresponding terms in the direct and stimulated echo decay cancel out. The proposed pulse sequence has been implemented in a one-dimensional imaging routine to obtain spatially resolved diffusion data. Acquiring multiple wave vector q = y6GI2n data may prove useful for use in the analysis of restricted diffusion.
Acknowledgements We thank the EPSRC (GWK12397) for support of the STRAFI facility at Surrey University. AJB acknowledges an EPSRC RoPA studentship (GWK64525) and the University of Surrey for financial support. Furthermore, AJB thanks the NMR Discussion Group and the IoP C.R. Barber Trust Fund for travel grants.
102
A. J. Bohris, D. A. Faun, D. G. Gillies, and P. J. McDonald
References 1.
A. A. Samoilenko, D. Yu. Artemov and A. L. Sibel’dina, JETP Lett. 47 (1988) 348.
2.
R. Kimmich. W. Unrath, G. Schnur and E. Rommel, J. Magn. Reson. 91 (1991) 136.
3.
J. E. Tanner, J . Chern. Phys. 52 (1970) 2523.
4.
G. A. Moms and R. Freeman, J . Magn. Reson. 29 (1978) 433.
5.
R. Kimmich and E. Fischer, J. Magn. Reson. A 106 (1994) 229.
6.
H. C. Torrey, Phys. Rev. 104 (1956) 563.
8. Imaging Diffusion with Non-Uniform B1 Gradients Klaus Woelk,Bernd L. J. Zwank, and Joachim Bargon Institut fiir Physikalische und Theoretische Chemie, Universitat Bonn, Wegelerstr. 12, D-53 115 Bonn, Germany Robert J. Klingler, Rex E. Gerald 11,and Jerome W.Rathke Chemical Technology Division, Argonne National Laboratory, 9700 South Cass Avenue, Argonne, Illinois 60439, USA
Abstract Rotating-frame imaging with the mathematically well-defined, non-uniform magnetic field gradient of toroid cavity detectors represents a new technique for evaluating diffusion in solids, fluids, or mixed-phase systems. While conventional NMR methods for measuring diffusion utilize constant (i.e., uniform) magnetic field gradients and, therefore, constant k-space wave numbers across the sample volume, the hyperbolic B , fields of toroid cavity detectors exhibit large ranges of wave numbers radially distributed around the central conductor. As a consequence, signal amplitudes decay, depending on the radial distance from the center axis of the torus. Applying a numerical finite-difference procedure to solve partial differential transport equations makes it possible not only to determine diffusion in toroid detectors to a high precision, but also to include and accurately reproduce transport phenomena at or through singularities, such as phase transitions, membranes, or impermeable boundaries.
8.1 Introduction The difusion measurements introduced here are based on the rotating-frame imaging (RFI) technique, i.e., on B,-gradient imaging, first introduced by Hoult [l]. In RFI, spatial resolution is obtained from NMR spectra taken at incrementally increased pulse
104
K. Woelk,B. L. J. Zwank, J. Bargon, R. J. Klingler, R. E. Gerald II, J . W.Rathke
widths. After a two-dimensional Fourier transformation, nutation frequencies of NMRactive nuclei are derived versus chemical shift. Since nutation frequencies are proportional to the B , field at the location of a nucleus, a transformation into spatial information is easily accomplished if the B , field distribution is known. More recent RFI applications utilize the time-saving, chemical-shift selective method called rapid-imaging pulse train (RIPT) [2-41, where a one-dimensional, real-data Fourier transformation reveals an image of nuclei precessing at the transmitter frequency. A quantitative image of spin density versus distance is revealed [5] when signalintensities are corrected by considering the sample volume and the principle of reciprocity [6].
8.1.1
Magnetization-Grating Rotating-Frame Imaging
To measure diffusion coefficients of fluids, Kimmich et al. [7] introduced magnetization-
grating rotating-frume imaging (MAGROFI), which uses constant B , gradients of surface coils to create homogeneous z-magnetization gratings across a sample. The gratings are generated by single hard pulses (preparation pulse PI in Fig. 8.1) applied with the same constant gradient that is used later for recording the image (P2 in Fig. 8.1). During an evolution time T between the preparation pulse and the imaging procedure, the initial grating decays because of TI relaxation and diffusion. If the evolution time is shorter than five times T,, undesired transverse magnetization remains from the preparation pulse. This unwanted part of the magnetization is usually removed by putting the pulse sequence through a transmitter phase cycling of the preparation pulse versus the imaging pulses. The remaining z-grating is sampled by RFI and analyzed to determine the diffusion coefficient.
z
IIIII
P2
AQ
I I I I I
t Fig. 8.1: Pulse sequence of an NMR experiment using the MAGROFI technique. In a B 1 gradient, the preparation pulse P1 generates a z-magnetization grating that, after an evolution period z, is imaged with the RFI procedure, i.e., with incrementally increased pulse widths P2 followed by the acquisition time AQ.
8. Imaging Diffusion with Nan-Uniform B, Gradients
105
Unfortunately, a single experiment using surface-coil MAGROFI delivers only one data point for a linear regression of amplitudes versus evolution time [7] or, alternatively, versus k-space wave number. Accordingly, many experiments at different evolution times or different preparation pulse widths must be performed using the MAGROFI technique to determine a single diffusion coefficient.
8.1.2
Imaging Diffusion in Toroid Cavity Detectors
The MAGROFI technique can also be applied to the non-uniform gradients of coaxial
toroid cavity detectors (Fig. 8.2) [8]. However, as a consequence of the hyperbolic B , field of toroids (B1 = A h , where A is a proportionality constant, i.e., the torus factor, and r is the radial distance from the long axis of the torus), the wave number of the grating changes continuously with the radius. Diffusion causes a fast decay of the grating, where the wave number is high, and a slow decay, where the wave number it low (Fig. 8.3). In contrast, the form of the grating, either symmetric or asymmetric, does not affect T , relaxation that uniformly returns z-magnetization to Boltzmann equilibrium. Because of the large range of wave numbers exhibited in toroid detectors, a single RFI experiment is sufficient to determine diffusion coefficients from three-parameter computer fits of propagation equations [8], refining longitudinal relaxation time ( T I ) , diffusion coefficient (D), and signal amplitude (I). In addition, because B , gradients in toroid cavity detectors are very “clean” (i.e., mathematically well-defined) and very strong, diffusion coefficients are determined to a high precision.
8.2 Partial Differential Transport Equations Fick’s first and second laws of difision are basic partial difSerentia1 equations with which one can analyze isotropic transport of matter because of Brownian motion. For z-magnetization gratings generated by MAGROFI experiments, Fick’s equations can be solved analytically if the gradient is strictly constant, the sample expands evenly perpendicular to the gradient, and no singularities exist along the gradient. Furthermore, the diffusion coefficient must be independent of concentration and space. Therefore, analysis
106
K. Woelk,B. L. J. Zwank, J. Bargon, R. J. Klingler, R. E. Gerald II, J. W.Rathke
of experimental data with analytical solutions is limited to homogeneous samples remote from the walls of the sample container. Phenomena that occur at singularities, such as phase transitions, membranes, or impermeable boundaries (e.g., dz@sive edge enhancement [9], Fig. 8.3), must be analyzed by numerical approaches.
Fig. 8.2: Schematic drawing of a toroid cavity detector used for diffusion measurements with the MAGROFI technique. The detector consists of a central conductor and a cylindrical hollow body. The sensitive volume is confined to the inside of the torus. Inside the detector, a z-magnetization grating generated by a single hard pulse PI is shown.
The decay of magnetization by diffusion represents an open-ended propagation problem that starts with an initial condition, i.e., the initial grating generated by the preparation pulse. In addition, impermeable boundaries (the walls of the sample container) or other known singularities confine the spatial range of analysis.
107
8. Imaging Diffusion with Nun-Unzfui-mB, Gradients
t
7
8
9
10
RADIAL POSITION, mm
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
Fig. 8.3: Results of an experiment in a toroid cavity detector using the MAGROFI technique. The wave number of the asymmetric magnetization grating is large near the central conductor and drops off with increasing radial distance. Experimental data (open circles) from a chloroform solution are compared to the analysis based on analytical propagation equations (solid line). Diffusive edge enhancement is visible at the central conductor (lower detailed plot) .
8.2.1
Finite-Difference Approach
If the time progress of a function with complex boundary conditions cannot be reproduced by analytical equations, finite-diference calculations are commonly used to numerically solve propagation problems [101. In a finite-difference procedure, data points of an initial condition are repeatedly advanced by finite time steps until the experimental data set is matched to a maximum likelihood. Thereafter, the transport parameter or function is evaluated from the number and width of time steps.
108
K. Woelk,B. L. J. Zwank, J. Bargon, R. J. Klingler, R. E. Gerald II, J. W. Rathke
Applying Finite-Differences to Magnetization Gratings To use finite differences in time and space for the analysis of magnetization gratings received from the MAGROFI technique, the locations of the experimental data points are used to calculate the grating’s decay during the evolution time z by finite time steps, starting from the initial grating. For each location, the change of magnetization density is estimated by solving the parabolic partial differential equation &/at = d(D3c)/(&)2, where c is the magnetization density, and x is the spatial dimension along the B , gradient. Concentration-dependence of the difSusion coefficient, the shape of the sample volume, or boundary conditions and singularities can all be included in the parabolic differential equation. For example, data points remote from singularities need the magnetization densities of the two neighboring data locations as boundary conditions. For points adjacent to singularities, however, a boundary condition such as the impermeability of the sample container applies. The maximum time step (At) that can be used without the numerical solution diverging from the true solution is given by the Einstein-Smoluchowski relation [ 111, which determines the mean square distance a particle travels by random walk [i.e., (Ax)2 = ~ D A TThe ] . distance Ax must not be larger than the smallest interval between two
data points. Otherwise particles would travel further than from one data-point location to the next. As a consequence, data points farther apart than the neighboring data must be included as boundary conditions, and higher-order partial differential equations must be solved. The relation that limits the time step of finite-difference procedures is generally known as Courant’s condition [12].
Fit to Experimental Data Figure 8.4 shows the finite-difference simulation that has been fitted to experimental data by a least-squares optimization, in which TI, D, and Z are refined. Clearly, the diffusive edge enhancement is accurately reproduced. In contrast, the analytical propagation equation can only be used to analyze data remote from singularities (Fig. 8.3). In addition, the finite-difference solution shows that in toroid detectors, grating extrema tend to shift to smaller radii. This effect has been observed before [8], when grating extrema decayed to less than 10% of their initial values, but is not accounted for by analytical propagation equations.
8. Imaging Diffusion with Non-Uniform BI Gradients
109
> t v)
z
W
+ z
o
0.7
09
1.1
13
15
1.7
19
RADIAL POSITION, mm
Fig. 8.4. Finite-difference analysis of diffusive edge enhancement at the central conductor (hatched area) of a toroid cavity. The numerical simulation (solid line) matches the experimental data (open circles) even at the impermeable boundary. A diffusion coefficient of D = 2.16 . 10-9 m2 s-1 was found for the chloroform sample.
8.3 Summary The MAGROFI technique is a robust and versatile method to evaluate diffusion. If applied along with the non-uniform, mathematically well-defined, and strong B , gradient of toroid cavity detectors, it is an excellent tool to measure diffusion precisely in a single RFI experiment. Since the analytical propagation equations are limited to uniform, i.e., constant gradients and areas remote from singularities, a finite-difference numerical procedure is required to determine the effects of diffusion correctly. Furthermore, this numerical approach makes it possible to analyze diffusion in mixed-phase systems and through membranes or other singularities. As an example, diffusive edge enhancement observed adjacent to impermeable boundaries has been reproduced accurately by this numerical approach.
Acknowledgments This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Division of Chemical Sciences, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, under Contract W-3 1-109-Eng-38 and by the German Research Foundation (DFG) under program WO 61312-1. We thank Prof. Dr. G. Woelk, Technical University of Aachen, Germany, for many helpful discussions.
110
K. Woelk,B. L. J. Zwank, J. Bargon, R. J. Klingler, R. E. Gerald II, J. W.Rathke
References 1.
D. I. Hoult, J. Magn. Reson. 33 (1979) 183.
2.
K. R. Metz and J. P. Boehmer, Magn. Reson. Imaging 6 (Suppl. 1) (1988) 53.
3.
J. L. Bowers, P. M. Macdonald, and K. R. Metz, J. Magn. Reson. Ser. B 106 (1994) 72.
4.
D. Canet, Progr. NMR Spectr. 30 (1997) 101.
5.
K. Woelk, J. W. Rathke, and R. J. Klingler, J. Mugn. Reson. A 109 (1994) 137.
6.
D. I. Hoult and R. E. Richards, J. Magn. Reson. 24 (1976) 71.
7.
R. Kimmich, B. Simon, and H. Kostler, J. Magn. Reson. A 112 (1995) 7.
8.
K. Woelk, R. E. Gerald 11, R. J. Klingler, and J. W. Rathke, J. Magn. Reson. A 121 (1996) 74.
9.
B. Piitz, D. Barsky, and K. Schulten, Chem. Phys. Lett. 183 (1991) 391.
10.
J. Crank, “The Mathematics ofDiffusion,” 2nd Ed, p. 141, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1975.
11.
P. W. Atkins, “Physical Chemistry,” 3rd Ed., p. 681, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1986.
12.
R. Courant, K. Friedrichs, and H. Lewy, Mathematische Annalen 100 (1928) 32.
9. In Situ Imaging of Charge Carriers in an Electrochemical Cell Rex E. Gerald II, Robert J. Klingler, Jerome W.Rathke, and Giselle Sand$ Chemical Technology and k h e m i s t q Divisions, Argonne National Laboratory,
9700 South Cass Avenue, Argonne, Illinois 60439, USA Klaus Woelk Institut fur Physikalische und Theoretische Chemie Universitat Bonn, Wegelerstr. 12, D-53 115 Bonn, Germany
Abstract A toroid cavity nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) detector capable of quantitatively recording radial concentration profiles, diffusion constants, displacements of charge carriers, and radial profiles of spin-lattice relaxation time constants was employed to investigate the charge/discharge cycle of a solid-state electrochemical cell. One-dimensional radial concentration profiles (1D-images) of ions solvated in a polyethylene oxide matrix were recorded by 19F and 7Li NMR for several cells. A sequence of I9F NMR images, recorded at different stages of cell polarization, revealed the evolution of a region of the polymer depleted of charge carriers. From these images, it is possible to extract the transference number for the Li+ ion. Spatially localized diffusion coefficients and spin-lattice relaxation time constants can be measured simultaneously for the ions in the polymer electrolyte by a spin-labeling method that employs the radial B1-field gradient of the toroid cavity. A spatial resolution of 7 pm neas the working electrode was achieved with a gradient strength of 800 G/cm. With this apparatus, it is also possible to investigate novel intercalation anode materials for lithium ion storage. These materials are coated onto the working electrode in a thin film. The penetration depth of lithium cations in these films can be imaged at different times in the charge/discharge cycle of the battery.
112
R. E. GeraldIl, R. J. Klingler, J. W . Rathke, G. Sandi, and K. Woelk
9.1 Introduction The demand for solid state energy storage devices that are transportable has encouraged research on solid polymer electrolytes. At room temperature, however, polymer electrolytes are currently incapable of achieving the conductivity requirements for batteries with high current output [l]. The ideal electrolyte would have the physical and mechanical properties of solids, the high conductivity characteristic of fluids, and the ability to transfer the electroactive ion exclusively [2]. Traditional NMR methods have been used to study ionic mobility in bulk polymer electrolytes [3]. The application of NMR imaging methods, however, can provide details of the temporal and spatial transport of charge carriers in typical polymer electrolyte systems. In particular, by combining an electrochemical cell with a toroid cavity NMR detector probe [4], it is possible to measure the macroscopic transport properties, local dynamics, and chemistry of ions as functions of distance from the electrodes.
9.2 Materials and Experimental Apparatus The chemicals used in this work were obtained from Aldrich Chemical Co. and were used without further purification. The polyethyleize oxide and lithium trifZnte were dissolved in hot tetrahydrofuran, which was subsequently removed by heating under vacuum. A white solid nionolith remained after complete removal of the solvent. The white solid was heated for several minutes at 174 "C in a closed container until the solid melted into a moderately viscous, clear liquid that could be handled easily. The plasticized polymer electrolyte was prepared by mixing the hot liquid polyethylene oxide polymer electrolyte with tetraglyme, propylene carbonate, and additional lithium triflate salt. The mole ratio of the electrolyte used in this work was 1.000 LiCF3S03: 0.043 CH3(0CH2CH2)9,0CH3:0.840 CH3(OCH2CH2),0CH3: 1.682 propylene carbonate. A quantity of 1.255 g of the polymer electrolyte mixture was placed in the electrochemical cell that forms part of the toroid cavity NMR detector. The cylindrical cell was formed by a glass tube with an inside diameter of 10.4 mm and a length 19.6 mm. Circular rubber septa of diameter 11 mn and thickness 3 mni (Varian Instruments, Palo Alto, California) were used to seal the tube at both ends. A 0.80 mm diameter gold wire
9. In Siru Imriging ($Charge Carriers in c i n Electrochemical Cell
113
counterelectrode was formed into a 5 turn helix and placed against the inner wall of the glass tube. One end protruded through the top septum. A 0.62 mm diameter copper wire (22 gauge QT, Phoenix Wire, Inc. South Hero. Vermont) passed through the center axis of the cell, piercing both septa. A potential was applied across the cell, with the negative and positive terminals of a potentiostat (Model EG&G 273A) connected to the central working electrode and the outer counterelectrode, respectively. The working electrode of the electrochemical cell assembly also functioned as the central conductor of the toroid cavity NMK probe. Fluorine- 19 NMR rotating-frame images were recorded at room temperature by using a Varian “N1TYINOVA-300WBspectrometer at the following settings: spectrometer frequency, 282.224 MHz; spectral width, 6 kHz; 1024 data points; 4 s recycle delay; four transients per spectrum; 128 spectra were recorded with a pulse width increment of 4 ps (spectral width, 125 kHz). The two-dimensional data sets were processed with 50 Hz and 2000 Hz line broadening in the F2 and F1 dimensions, respectively. Onedimensional T , spatial images, which record the spin-lattice relaxation as a function of radial position, required that a composite 180” pulse be executed prior to the acquisition of the normal rotating frame image [5].
9.3 Results and Discussion The current vs. time profile of an electrochemical cell subjected to an applied potential is determined by the cell geometry, the equivalents of charge carried by the charge carriers, and the mobility of the charge carriers. Electrochemical cell polarization is the deleterious result of the transport of nonelectroactive ions of opposite charge. In a polarized cell, the charge carriers near one of the electrodes (the working electrode) are depleted to zero, thereby effectively forming an open circuit. In such a case, the cell ceases to function until the charge carriers near the working electrode are replenished by diffusion or other means of mass transport. The conduction of charge through solid polymer electrolytes in an electrochemical cell can proceed very slowly, requiring an extended period of time to obtain sufficient cell polarization (i.e., decrease in total number of ions near the electrode) for observation by NMR. Therefore, we formulated a plasticized polymer electrolyte (as described
114
R. E. Gerald II, R. J. Klilzgler, J. W.Rathke, G. Sand;, and K. Woelk
Fig. 9.1: 19F NMR images of the tnflate (CF$03-) anion in an amorphous polyethylene oxide based electrolyte monitoring the formation of the depletion zone during the charge half-cycle. (a) Initial profile; (b) After 50 mC; (c) After 3.5 h charging; (d) Following several days charging. The radial profile images are presented in reciprocal space so that the region of interest (near the working electrode) is expanded. The total number of spins decreases in the concentric annular shells closest to the working electrode, therefore, in this region the signal-to-noise ratio diminishes.
9. In Situ Imaging of Charge Carriers in an Electrochemical Cell
115
7.0
6.0
5.0 >I
+ .cn 4.0
a, +
S
6 3.0 S
.-m
cn
2.0
0 7
1.0
0.0 03
0.4
05
06
07
08
09
Radial Position (mm) Fig. 9.2: Radial profiles of the images in Fig. 9.1. The gray rectangle on the left side of the figure represents the working electrode, which has a 0.31 mm radius. The signal intensity of each radial profile was scaled using a scale factor that was determined by averaging the measured 19F signal intensity values in the region of the electrochemical cell between 0.60 and 1.73 mm. Across this region of the electrochemical cell all of the intensity profiles were nearly constant before and after charging the cell. The plot insets indicate a nonlinear decrease in charging current with increasing time for the time period between image profiles a and b. We recorded the current and total accumulated charge passed through electrochemical cells of identical geometry to the cell used here to estimate the size of the depletion region at various stages of cell charging. For long charging times the current decreased linearly with the square root of charging time, and typical charging currents were 10 - 40 FA. All the radial profiles shown here were recorded during cell charging, that is, while current was flowing through the charging circuit. No deleterious effects from the charging current on the external magnetic field homogeneity were observed under these conditions.
116
R. E. Gerald 11,R. J. Klingler, J. W. Rathke, G. Sandi, and K. Woelk
above) that exhibits substantially larger charge conduction at room temperature. However, at room temperature, the plasticized polymer electrolyte slowly transforms from a viscous liquid to a heterogeneous gel or to a homogeneous waxy solid, depending on the composition. We used this electrolyte to investigate various aspects of cell polarization, including the physical dimensions and profile of the depletion zone, as depicted in Figs. 9.1 and 9.2, and the molecular dynamics of the anions through measurements of spatially resolved spin-lattice relaxation time constant (Figs. 9.3 and 9.4). The conductivity of this electrolyte is sufficient to make electrochemical processes observable by NMR methods that utilize the high sensitivity near the central electrode of a toroid cavity probe. In fact, while the total number of 19F spins in the detector is substantial, 13.59 mmol, the decrease in the number of 19F spins next to the working electrode following 50 mC of charge is only 1.55 ymol. This decrease (about 1 part in 9000) can be seen in the difference between the vertical regions of curve a and curve b in Fig. 9.2. Of course, this miniscule change in the total number of 19F spins can be observed because it is spatially confined to a very small volume (an annular shell of radius 310 ym, thickness 10 - 20 ym, and height 12.9 mm), where the change in the 19F spins is nearly 100%. Figure 9.4 shows the spin-lattice relaxation time constants (including their respective standard errors) plotted as a function of the radial distance from the working electrode. The curve suggests that the triflate anions are not entirely depleted in the volume around the working electrode. These data were recorded for the cell in the state of polarization depicted by image d of Fig. 9.1. The spatial resolution near the electrode surface is 7 pm; therefore, the TI value for the region next to the working electrode is obtained from the residual 19F signal from a shell volume of radius 310 ym, thickness 7 pn, and height 12.9 mm. Very little is known about the effects on the polymer structure and the ion mobility by
concentration gradients in the electrolyte. It is generally believed that the cations tend to crosslink the polymer chains, thereby influencing the segmental motion of the polymer [1,6]. Furthermore, the segmental motion is commonly believed to be the most important factor controlling the ionic conductivity in polymer electrolytes. Importantly, there are fluctuating effects in the region adjacent to the electrodes due to the dynamic nature of the concentration gradients of ions in the polymer matrix. With the toroid cavity/electrochemicalcell NMR imager described here, it is possible for the first time to probe for structure and mobility differences in the polymer and ions across the concen-
9. In Situ Imaging of Charge Carriers in an Electrochemical Cell
117
Fig. 9.3: T l ( r ) images of the triflate anion across the concentration gradient of charge carriers in the plasticized polymer electrolyte.
1I8
R. E. Gerald II, R. J. Klingler, J. W.Rathke, G. Sandi, and K. Woelk
1 .o 0.8
I--
0.4
0.2 03
OB
05
Oh
0
n
oa
Radial Position (mm)
Fig. 9.4: Spin-lattice relaxation time constant measurements of the 19F nuclei in the triflate anions dissolved in the plasticized polyethylene oxide electrolyte as a function of the distance from the working electrode in the polarized electrochemical cell. (a) The solid and dashed curves are the radial profiles shown as curves a and d in Fig. 9.2, respectively. (b) The function T I(r) (including standard confidence intervals) measured for the dashed curve in (a).
tration gradients in the electrolyte. This is done by measuring the N M R spin relaxation time constants (TI, TIP,and T . )as a function of distance from the electrodes. Thus, the N M R imaging method described here is capable of addressing some of the most important questions with regard to the dynamics of the polymer-electrolyte performance. Does the ratio of amorphous-to-crystalline polymer phases change in the immediate vicinity of the electrodes as the concentration gradients in the electrolyte evolve? Is the segmental motion of the polymer uniform throughout the cell? How quickly do the ionic crosslinks reform as the concentration of the ions in the polymer matrix increases? On what timescale do the ions in the amorphous and crystalline polymer-electrolyte phases undergo exchange? In addition, since the toroid cavity/electrochemical cell N M R imager records chemical shifts and coupling constants, we are able to explore various chemical transformations that occur during cell operation. What ancillary oxidatiodreduction reactions take place at the electrodes? What side reactions do lithium ions undergo when they intercalate into the pores of carbon based materials, which serve as novel electrodes? How is the irreversible capacity of an electrochemical cell related to the chemistry of lithium ion intercalation and deposition, and electrolyte degradation? These are just a few of the questions that are significant to modern battery research and development. In
9. In Situ Imaging of Charge Carriers in an Electrochemical Cell
119
this paper we have demonstrated the feasibility of several in situ NMR imaging methods that will allow us to investigate these questions.
Acknowledgments We are indebted to Dr. Christopher Johnson of the Chemical Technology Division at k g o n n e National Laboratory for providing materials and helpful advice. This work was performed under the auspices of the Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Division of Chemical Sciences, U.S. Department of Energy, under contract no. W-3 1-109-ENG-38.
References 1.
Ratner, M. A,, Shnver, D. F. Chem. Rev. 88 (1988) 109.
2.
Mellander, B.-E., Albinsson, I. Solid State Ionics: New Developments, Ed. Chowdari, B. V. R., 1997, 97.
3.
Ward, I. M., Boden, N., Crnickshank, J., Leng, S. A. Electrochimica Actu, 40 (1995) 2071.
4.
Woelk, K., Rathke, J. W., Klingler, R. J. J. Magrz. Reson. A 109 (1994) 137.
5.
Woelk, K., Rathke, J. W. J. Magn. Reson. A 115 (1995) 106.
6.
Bruce, P. G., Vincent, C. A,, J. Chem. Soc. Faruday Trans. 89 (1993) 3187.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
10. Efficient Simulation of Spin Echo, Gradient Echo, Fast, and Ultrafast NMR Imaging Sequences by Isochromat Summation Pave1 Shkarin and Richard G. S. Spencer National Institutes of Health, National Institute on Aging, 4940 Eastern Avenue, Baltimore, MD 21224, USA
Abstract One of the earliest computational methods used to simulate imaging sequences is based upon following the time evolution of spin isochromats as they evolve in response to rf pulses and periods of free precession. While accurate, application of this method has been limited by the enormous number of isochromats required to achieve accurate results, resulting in excessively long computation times. We have re-examined this approach and developed an efficient, flexible, and accurate isochromat summation algorithm which permits the simulation of the full time-domain signal resulting from arbitrary two-dimensional Fourier imaging sequences. The number of isochromats required to achieve a specified degree of precision as compared with the exact image is calculated, talung into account transverse relaxation and the potential for artifactual refocusing due to finite isochromat spacing. No assumptions are made regarding transverse dephasing, so that complicated sequences of direct and stimulated echoes are fully modeled. This permits modern single-shot methods such as Burst to be simulated readily.
122
P. Shkurin and R. G. S. Spencer
10.1 Limitations of the Imaging Equation and Advantages of Time-Domain Simulation The imaging equation may be written: (10.1)
where by Sect) we indicate the exact signal, Mo (x) is the local transverse magnetization prior to acquisition, and
l r G(t') dt'
k ( t )= t'E
(10.2)
(0,t)
In writing this, an assumption which is implicitly made is that Mo(x)is not a function of k(t),the order in which k-space in traversed. There are a number of circumstances in which this assumption is false. Examples include 1) the early readouts of spin warp imaging when TR = T2, 2) Burst imaging, when large flip angles are used, leading to echo amplitude distortions, 3) any inultipulse sequence when unwanted stimulated or Hahn echoes occur, or when parts of FID's intrude into the acquisition window, and 4) when a significant amount of transverse relaxation occurs during the imaging sequence.
10.2 Basics of the Time-Domain Simulation: Effect of Hard Pulses and Free Precession For the nthhard pulse, of flip angle 0 and phase x, we have
(10.3)
10. Efficient Simulation of NMR Imaging Sequences by Isochromat Summation
123
For free precession over the time At = t2 - t,, two cases must be distinguished. In the spectroscopic case, there is an initial distribution of isochromat frequencies given by f(v). Then M,(t2) =
bx(tl) cos(2nvAt)
-
M , ( t l ) sin(2nvAt)]exp(-At/T2)
M y ( t 2 ) = [M,(tl) sin(2mAt) + M y ( t l ) cos(2.nvAt)]exp(-At/T2)
(10.4)
With these, explicit calculation of echo timings and amplitudes for a sequence of strong pulses of arbitrary number, timing, flip angle, and phase can be performed in one dimension [ 11. In the imaging case, with (piecewise) constant gradients, we take f(v) = 8(v-vo) and obtain M,(t2)
= [M,(t,)
cos(2n yG.xiAt) - M , ( t , ) sin(2nyG.xiAt)]exp(-AtlT2) (10.5)
M , ( t 2 ) = [M,(t,) sin(2nyG.xiAt) + M y ( t l ) cos(2nyG.xiAt)]exp(-At/T2)
These expressions give us the magnetization vector for each isochromat, and the summation over isochromats gives the net signal: (10.6)
10.3 Required Number of Isochromats 10.3.1 One Dimension We first consider the one-dimensional case, with magnetization distributed uniformly over the field of view. The values of the parameter k which are reached can be calculated from the preceding definition of k. The maximum excursion in k-space can then be We also define by derived; we denote this by AK = kmaX- kmin, where kfin < k < k,. S,(k) the approximate signal, obtained by replacing the integral in the imaging equation by a sum over J isochromats - that is, the Fourier integral is replaced by a truncated
124
P. Shkarin and R. G.S.Spencer
Fourier series. The number of terms in the Fourier series, that is, the number of isochromats in the simulation, can be selected to achieve a desired degree of accuracy. The required value of J also depends on AK,as expected. We define the overall error in the image as the maximum value of FT(S,(k) - S,(k)). We have selected, as a reasonable criterion for required accuracy, a value of approximately 1% for this error. It can be shown explicitly [2] that an overall error < 1.5% will result if J23AK
(10.7)
For FOV = 1, then AK = N , number of pixels in the image reconstruction. Then the criterion becomes: J23N
(10.8)
If number of pixels in the source matrix, M , is M > 3N, this becomes J 2 A4 to ensure at least one isochromat per pixel in the source matrix.
10.3.2 Two Dimensions In two-dimensions, the phase dimension is treated as above, since k-space is traversed only once in that dimension. However, k-space can be scanned multiple times in the read direction. Therefore, in a single-shot experiment of total duration T in which full transverse relaxation never occurs, the maximum range of kread, u r e a d = kread,max- kread.min, must be calculated using the expression
(10.9)
where t takes values over the time interval (0, T). This is also required for multiple-shot experiments, such as spin warp, when TR is on the order of T2, so that full transverse relaxation cannot be assumed to occur. The read condition is therefore: aread
(10.10)
Two further comments are in order. When full transverse relaxation occurs between
10. Efficienr Simulation of NMR Imaging Sequences by Isochromat Summation
125
acquisitions, one can use the same calculation as for the phase dimension. Also, the required number of isochromats may be greatly reduced by considering transverse relaxation. Artifactual refocusing cannot occur at a time greater than approximately 5T2 following a pulse, so that AKread may be replaced by the maximum variation of k for all time intervals of duration 5T2 in the sequence. In general, this is considerably smaller than AKr,,d. These considerations can decrease computation time by an order of magnitude or more, rendering the simulation very efficient while maintaining accuracy.
10.4 Computation Outline The source object consists of regions with assigned density (p), TI and T2.Typical CPU times for calculations performed on a Silicon Graphics Challenge XL with 6 processors (one gigabyte of RAM, 450 MFLOPS) are: 1) 64 x 64 spin warp, full relaxation between acquisitions: < 1 minute; 2) 64 x 64 spin warp with incomplete relaxation: < 20 minutes; 3) 32-echo Burst: < 3 minutes. Figure 10.1 shows the object used in spin-warp, Burst, and PREVIEW simulations. The matrix size is 256 x 256. The pixels within each region, A, B, C, and D, are respectively characterized by a given isochromat density and set of relaxation times. These are specified for each example. The eye has zero density. Note that the matrix size chosen
Fig. 10.1: Object used in simulations of the spin-warp, Burst, and QUEST imaging sequences.
126
P. Shkurin and R. G. S. Spencer
provides a fine-grain source image. The actual image matrix size, generally 64 x 64 in the following, is determined by the specifics of the pulse sequence. For example, in spinwarp imaging, it is determined by the number of phase encode steps and the data size of each digitized echo. The minimum number of isochromats used in the simulation is equal to the source image matrix dimension, that is, 256 x 256 = 65,536.
Fig. 10.2: Spin-warp simulation. A) Stripe artifact resulting from pulse imperfections. B) Removal of the stripe artifact by homospoil pulses.
10.5 Spin-Warp Imaging The standard spin-warp pulse sequence was simulated as a basic demonstration of the method. Figure 10.2 shows the stripe artifact due to imperfect pulses. TR = 100 s, TE = 15 ms. Object parameters: spin density = unity. ( T I ,T2) values: Region A: (5000 ms, 1000 ms); Region B: (2000 ms, 1000 ms); Region C: (3000 ms, 1000 ms); Region D:
(4000 ms, 1000 ms). A) 90" - 180" pulses misset by 30% to become 63" - 126". Artifact results from occurrence of an FID after the imperfect 180" pulse. B) Removal of the stripe artifact by placement of balanced homospoil gradients about the 180" refocusing pulse. Figure 10.3 shows the zipper artifact due to TR = T,. All object parameters as in the previous figure. A) TR = 5000 ms, leading to T , weighted image. B) TR = 1000 ms, with artifact due to stimulated echoes formed at end of each phase-encode. C) TR = 1000 ms, with removal of zipper artifact by placement of homospoil gradient after signal
10. Efficient Simulation of NMR Imaging Sequences by Isochroinat Summation
127
Fig. 10.3: Spin-warp simulation. A) T I weighted image, with TR >> T2. B) Zipper artifact resulting from TR on the order of T2. C) Removal of zipper artifact by homospoil pulses.
Fig. 10.4: Spin-warp simulation. A) Aliasing artifact in the phase-encode dimension. B) Aliasing artifact in the read dimension.
acquisition. Figure 10.4 shows aliasing artifacts. ( T I ,T2) values for the regions are: Region A: (5000 ms, 1000 ms); Region B: (2000 ms, 250 ms); Region C: (3000 ms, 300 ms); Region D: (4000 ms, 500 ms). TE = 500 ms. Ideal YGread = l/(dwell.FOV) =10 kHz/cm. Since the duration of Gphase is one-half the duration of Gread,the maximum of yGphasein the ideal case is also 10 kHz/cm. A) YGphase= 20 kHz/cm. B) YGphase= 20 kHz/cm, yGread= 20 kHz/cm.
128
P. Shkarin and R. G. S.Spencer
10.6 FLASH Imaging FLASH imaging utilizes a gradient-eL,,o rather than a spin-echo for refocusing [3 This forms the basis for a number of rapid imaging sequences. Figure 10.5 shows the FLASH sequence used for simulation and indicates the position of optional homospoil gradients. The phantom characteristics are defined as indicated, with column TI values and row T, values as labeled. The expected TI weighting is seen across rows, with increased image intensity for shorter TI values. For TR >> T2,both spoiled (not shown) FLASH and nonspoiled FLASH produce accurate images. For TR = T . , the effect of residual transverse
%
i
.ri
I
U
0
I
a
m 0 v, 0
TR
TI ,ms
5000
3000
1000
8-
-~
.+ 0
a
m
TR = 800 ms
TR = 200 ms
Fig. 10.5: FLASH pulse sequence and simulation. For TR on the order of T2, residual transverse magnetization leads to zipper and shadowing artifacts. These artifacts are removed by homospoil pulses.
10. Efficient Simulation of NMR Imaging Sequences by Isochromat Summation
129
magnetization in non-spoiled FLASH leads to a zipper artifact across the entire image, as well as image shadows. These are greatly reduced or eliminated by application of the homospoil gradients in the position indicated in the pulse sequence. Other simulations (not shown) demonstrate that susceptibility artifacts, greatly attenuated in spin-echo imaging sequences, are maintained with the FLASH sequence.
10.7 Burst Imaging Burst is an ultrafast spin echo sequence which produces density-weighted images. A large number of equidistant rf pulses (32 in the present simulations) are followed by a refocusing pulse of 180". Refocused echoes are then sampled under constant read and phase gradients. One important feature of the sequence is that it makes only very modest
demands on gradient performance [4]. Figure 10.6 shows the Burst sequence used in the simulation, incorporating symmetric k-space sampling and requiring zero filling prior to reconstruction. Figure 10.7 shows that increasing pulse angle, a, results in increasing image distortion. Object parameters: TI = 5000 ms and T2 = 2000 ms throughout. Density in each region: Region A: 5; Region B: 2; Region C : 3; Region D: 1. Figure 10.8 shows the increasing influence of transverse relaxation during the Burst sequence as the object T2 decreases. Object parameters: T2 as shown in the figure; all others the same as in Fig. 10.7. density: Region
f
hase
1 Fig. 10.6:Burst pulse sequence.
@ad
130
P. Shkurin and R. G. S. Spencer
A: 5 ; Region €3: 2; Region C: 3; Region D: 1. A) For T2 = 400 ms, echo distortions increase more rapidly as a function of a than in Fig. 10.7, where T2 = 2000 ms. The images themselves are similar. B) For T . = 200 ms, further nonidealities in the echoes are seen, and subtle increases in image distortion are evident. C) For T2 = 100 ms, severe distortions of echoes and images are present even at small excitation pulse angles.
Fig. 10.7: Burst simulation. Increasing the pulse angle a results in increasing image distortion.
10.8 PREVIEW Imaging PREVIEW is an imaging sequence which is similar to Burst, except that it makes use of all echoes generated by relatively few rf pulses spaced at specific intervals [5]. For example, four pulses with interpulse intervals related as 1:3:9 generate 27 equidistant echoes. As in the case of Burst, these pulses are followed by a refocusing pulse of 180". Figure 10.9 shows image distortions resulting from an imperfect refocusing pulse of
120", resulting in unwanted additional echoes. Figure 10.10 shows the effect of using different excitation pulse sets, with an ideal refocusing pulse, on noisy images. The standard PREVIEW sequence pulse angles are derived such that performance is optimized. However, in the presence of significant noise the original set of PREVIEW pulses, {45", -60", 120°, -90') is no longer optimal. In both panels of Fig. 10.10 pseudorandomnoise of 5% maximum magnetization amplitude has been added to the signal, resulting in significant image degradation. Some performance is recovered by use of a new set of rf pulses optimized to give high average echo amplitude (right hand panel), as compared with the original set of PREVIEW pulses (left hand panel).
10. Efficient Simulation of NMR Imaging Sequences by Isochrornat Summation
131
Fig. 10.8: Burst simulation. Artifacts resulting from transverse relaxation. The distortions are seen to be more pronounced with larger pulse angle a.
10.9 Conclusions We have presented representative results for simulations of the standard spin-warp experiment, for FLASH, and for Burst and PREVIEW, modern ultrafast single-shot experiments. As demonstrated, our algorithm permits the simulation of a number of real effects which depend on specifics of the pulse and gradient sequences implemented. As nearly any pulse sequence can be simulated, the algorithm is exceedingly flexible. In addition, the characteristics of a large number of artifacts, including several which arise specifically from stimulated echoes, may be investigated. We have found this simulation to be of great utility in understanding new imaging sequences and correcting imaging artifacts. Further details of some of this work can be found in [ 11 and [2].
132
P. Shkurin and R. G. S. Spencer
Fig. 10.9: PREVIEW simulation. Distortion resulting from refocusing pulse imperfection.
Fig. 10.10: PREVIEW simulation. Demonstration of improved image quality with non standard excitation pulses in the presence of noise.
References 1.
P. Shkarin, R. G. S. Spencer, ConceptsMugn. Reson. 8 (1996) 253-268.
2.
P. Shkann, R. G. S. Spencer, Intern. J. Imag. Systemsand Technol. 8 (1997) 419-426.
3.
A. Haase, J. Frahm, D. Matthaei, W. Hanicke, K. D. Merboldt, J. Mugn. Reson. 67 (1986) 258-266.
4.
J. Hennig , M. Hodapp, MAGMAl(1993) 39-48.
5.
C. J. R. Counsell, Mugn. Reson. Imug. 11 (1993) 603-616.
11. A Novel Algorithm for Tumor Characterization by Analysis of Transversal Relaxation Rate Distributions in MRI R. Martin and M. Martin-Landrove Departamento de Fisica and Centro de Resonancia Magnktica, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Central de Venezuela, A.P. 47586, Caracas 1041-A, Venezuela
Abstract A novel algorithm to determine transversal relaxation rate distributions is presented to
characterize tumors and neoplasic tissue. The methodology is applied to a variety of tumors with different degrees of malignancy as well as to healthy tissue. The results show that when there is malignancy it frequently happens in a definite relaxation rate window outside of which only liquid or benign neoplasic tissue are present. The methodology developed in this work can be easily implemented in any type of scanner at any magnetic field and can be extended to study other pathologies.
11.1 Introduction In complex and heterogeneous systems, as for instance living tissues, the proton transversal magnetization decay is not governed by a single relaxation rate but by a superposition of different relaxation rates, each one corresponding to different dynamical environments. In general, this situation is represented by a continuous distribution function and the measured decay corresponds to its Laplace transform. In the present work a novel algorithm is developed and used to invert the Laplace transform in order to obtain the relaxation rate distribution function from the experimental decay. The methodology is applied to a variety of tumors, with different degrees of malignancy as well as to healthy tissue.
134
R. Martin and M. Martin-Landrove
11.2 Materials and Methods The measurements were realized in a Siemens Magnetom operating at 1 Tesla. More than 40 patients were studied including diagnosis of lymphoma, lung cancer, human papiloma, etc.. The standard Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) pulse sequence was used, and images for different echoes were registered and then for the same region of interest in each image, the pixel intensity was averaged in order to obtain the decay curve of the average intensity for that specific region. Only even numbered echoes were considered in order to control 180" pulse adjustment. The number of regions selected for each tumor depended on the size and heterogeneity as observed on the nmr image. In the case of patients with positive diagnostic of cancer, samples on the tumor periphery and in different tissues were taken in order to control for possible metastasis. The decays so obtained were processed by the proposed algorithm and correlated to results obtained by biopsies. The total number of samples processed was 60. Finally, the intersection of the spectra is obtained in order to determine characteristic zones assigned to the presence of malignancy in the tumor.
Inverse Laplace Transform Algorithm There are a wide variety of different approaches [ 1,2] to solve numerically the Inverse Laplace Transform Problem and some of them are of standard use in very many laboratories around the world. Such is the case of DISCRETE and CONTIN programs [I], which are applicable in many situations. Most of this attempts make use of assumptions about the mathematical properties of the function to be obtained by the inversion procedure and rely on this properties in the general development of the algorithm, while others introduce regularization parameters or a fixed number of components in the relaxation spectrum. None of those problems are present in the algorithm described in this work The signal is known in a finite number of points on the real axis, and can be represented as a first kind Fredholm integral equation of the form:
(11.1)
where M ( t ) corresponds to the transversal magnetization and h is the relaxation rate. Equation (1 1.1) represents a very general way to express the transversal relaxation decay
11. Algorithmfor Tumor Characterization by Analysis of Trunsversal Relaxation Rate Distributions
135
depending on the particular relaxation rate distribution P(h)[3,4]. This distribution can be represented by a histogram or collection of bars of variable width, which is given by N
p(A>=
pk
(I)
(11.2)
k=l
where N is the number of components and Pk (1)is the k-th elemental component given by
This representation can be used for the description of discrete and continuous distributions as well. The problem to be solved can be stated as an optimization procedure where a set of distribution components, which provides the best fit for the M ( t ) function, has to be found. For that purpose Simulated Annealing and Metropolis algorithms [5-81 are used. The configuration to be tested in each Metropolis algorithm cycle is given by a finite , number of elementary components which are sampled in the relaxation rate position 1 and width 6?Lk for the k-th element. At the same time, the total number of components N for the configuration is also changed, which is a new feature in an optimization procedure of this kind. This sampling in the total number of components is performed by considering two options with the same probability within the Metropolis algorithm cycle: a) The total number of components N is unchanged and in this case one component is taken with equal probability from the current configuration set to change its numerical value of the relaxation rate position and width. b) A new component is created and added to the existing configuration. The new component is located either within the existing set or it is the maximum of a new configuration set. In the latter case, its position is determined with a non-uniform probability distribution vanishing at large relaxation rates. The simplest choice corresponds to an exponential distribution, but other distributions can be considered as well and it is an open problem. The cost function was chosen on results of robust statistics to noise filtering and it is known in the literature as Least Absolute Deviation (LAD) optimization [9]. For n p points it is given by
136
R. Martin and M.Martin-Landrove
and it can be seen as an average relative error. In the presence of information loss the absolute value provides a better noise filtering than the usual quadratic value since the median is much less sensitive than the mean to the presence of fluctuations of any size. The quantity Mexp( t ) corresponds to the measured signal and Mop( t ) is the optimized signal given by
Mop( t ) =
2J'dhe-"
Pk (A)
(11.5)
k o
In this work a fast simulated annealing approach is used (Cauchy machine) [ 101 and then it means that the temperature parameter is proportional to the inverse of the Monte Car10 iteration number. In order to avoid the problem of the appearance of metastable states [5-81 which are intrinsic to the Metropolis algorithm, up to 20 parallel simulations with different initial conditions were performed. The final histogram is taken by averaging the total set of particular histograms corresponding each one to different initial conditions. This procedure is performed in order to avoid the increase in condition number for the matrix used in the least square procedure when the number of components is also increased.
11.3 Results and Discussion The results show that when there is malignancy it occurs in a very defined relaxation rate window and outside of it only liquid or benign neoplasic tissue are present. This situation can be easily depicted in Fig. 11.1 in which results for 60 samples, including also healthy tissue are presented. Some of the results in the Figure are represented with some uncertainty which corresponds to a positive diagnostic of malignancy but for a sample taken on the tumor periphery or in a different tissue where there is a finite probability of a benign situation. Only those samples taken on tumors with positive diagnostic of malignancy were used to
137
11.Algorithm for Tumor Characterization by Analysis of Transversal Reluxation Rate Distributions
produce the intersected spectrum. Other parameters of the relaxation rate distribution are also under study to correlate them with clinical data. It is worthwhile to mention that CPMG sequences are very sensitive to exchange and diffusional processes and the sort of algorithm implemented in this work could be particularly useful for their study. The methodology developed in this work can be implemented easily in any type of scanner working at any magnetic field and can be extended to study other pathologies.
104
h
I
,
,
103
0
Q
E
v
102
* E
10’
0
10
20
30
40
Sample
50
60
70
10’ 0.008
0.010
0.012
h (msec-’)
Fig.ll.1: On the left, transversal relaxation time obtained for different samples including malignant tumors, benign tumors and healthy tissue. Circles represent malignancy, triangles possible malignancy and squares benign tissue. On the right the intersected relaxation rate spectra.
Acknowledgments We would like to thank the cooperation of the Instituto de Resonancia MagnCtica for the use of the NMR scanners and also the financial support given by CONICIT to present this work.
138
R. Martin and M. Martin-Landrove
References S. W. Provencher, Comput. Phys. Comm. 27 (1982) 213 and Comput. Phys. Comm. 27 (1982) 229. J. P. Butler, J. A. Reeds, and S. V. Dawson, SIAMJ. Numer. Anal. 18 (1981) 381. M. Martin-Landrove, R. Martin, and A. Benavides, Bull. Magn. Reson. 17 (1995) 73.
I. Bonalde, M. Martin-Landrove, A. Benavides, R. M a t h , and J. Espidel, J. A[?$. Phys. 78 (1995) 6033.
5.
G. Bhanot, Rep. Prog. Phys. 51 (1988) 429.
6.
S. Kirkpatrick, C. D. Gelat, and M. P. Vecchi, Science 220 (1983) 671.
I.
S. Kirkpatrick, J. Stat. Phys. 34 (1984) 975.
8.
E. Bonomi and J. L. Lutton, SIAM Rev. 26 (1984) 551.
9.
A. Scales and A. Gersztenkorn, Inverse Problems 4 (1988) 1071.
10.
H. Szu and R. Hartley, Phys. Lett. A 122 (1987) 157.
Materials
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
12. Materials Imaging with Examples from Solid Rocket Propellants W. E. M u a d , L.H. Merwin2, aizd D.G. Cory3 1Bruker Analytical Systems, Inc., 19 Fortune Drive, Billerica, MA 01821, USA 2Chemistry and Materials Branch, Weapons Division, Naval Air Warfare Center, China Lake, CA 93555, USA 3Department of Nuclear Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
Abstract: Methods for NMR imaging of solids have been developed over the past decade in parallel to those for medical imaging and microscopy. The major challenges in the solid state are (I) the large NMR linewidths, and (2) developing a sufficient contrast to noise ratio. Unlike biomedical applications where the vast majority of studies are of water, the systems studied in materials applications vary widely, as do the NMR properties and suitable methods. Here the range of methods is briefly reviewed followed by a detailed case study of solid rocket motor propellants. This particular system was chosen since the methods used are straightforward and relatively accessible, and since useful information about the processing of these materials can be derived from the images.
12.1 Introduction to Materials Imaging A wide variety of imaging methods specific to proton rich solid materials have been developed which reflect the great variations in the NMR linewidth. These methods are carefully tailored to the NMR characteristics of the sample and often include the need for specialized hardware such as very strong or very fast switching gradients. The particulars of these methods have been described in reviews [l-31 and will not be repeated here. Instead, the range of solutions will be briefly described and, in the second portion of this
142
W . E. Muus, L.H. Merwin, and D. G. Cory
paper, a case study of NMR imaging of a complex elastomeric system will be described. The choice of system was dictated first by the available methods as elastomers can be successfully studied using extensions of liquid state schemes that are widely available. Stray field, constant time and coherent averaging approaches to imaging are less available and are mainly still restricted to the laboratories of experts. This system is also of interest since useful information is directly available from the images. Much of the work in solid state imaging of rigid proton rich samples has been directed towards methods development and few applications have been explored where the image provided information that was not available elsewhere. For the filled elastomeric systems, the length scales of interest for processing problems are well matched to those available in the image.
12.1.1 Encoding of Spatial Information via Spin Evolution in a Magnetic Field Gradient The measurement of spatial information in NMR at length scales greater than that resolvable by dipolar couplings depends up011 the creation of a magnetization grating with a period commensurate with the spatial scale [4]. Such a grating is most directly developed through the differential rate of spin precession in a magnetic field gradient [5],
o(r) =YBo + Y
(12.1)
which spatially and periodically modulates the phase of the spin magnetization. The normal NMR symbols are used throughout, y is the gyromagnetic ratio, B the magnetic field, r the location of a test spin and p(r) the spin density. The latter is assumed to be spatially complex and the object of the imaging experiment. The magnetization then becomes,
M , p(r)
gradient evolution
> M , p(r)exp(- i k . r )
(12.2)
12. Materials Imaging with Examples from Solid Rocket Propellants
143
The wave-vector of the grating, k, describes the pitch of the grating, and in the simplest case is proportional to the area of the gradient waveform,
k = y J V B z( t ) dt
(12.3)
The NMR signal is the spin magnetization integrated across the sample,
s ( k ) =y j p ( r ) e x p ( - i k . r ) d r
(12.4)
so that what is directly measured in the presence of a magnetic field gradient is a Fourier component of the spin density. Clearly if a sufficient set of Fourier components are measured, then the signal may be simply recovered by an inverse Fourier transform. The image field of view and the reso-
lution are governed by the normal Nyquist sampling conditions. In solid state studies an important additional consideration is the decay of the transverse magnetization. There is thus a competition between the decay rate (1/T2) and the rate of creating a grating, so that in a time independent magnetic field gradient where k increases according to,
-dk_ dt
-
YVB,
(12.5)
the time dependent signal includes attenuation due to spin-spin relaxation, (12.6)
The Fourier relation is clearer when the signal is described in terms of a wave number, and the rate of change of the wave number, as,
(12.7)
It is clear from the convolution kernel of the Fourier mapping that the image resolution is limited by,
144
W. E. Muas, L.H. Merwin, and D. G. Cory
(12.8)
The spin-spin relaxation time varies greatly from sample to sample and the methods available to obtain high-resolution images vary with this.
12.1.2 Length Scales of Spatial Information Available in Solid State NMR The ranges of spatial measurements available by NMR are shown schematically in Fig.
12.1.
1 cm
lmm
Imaging
100 pm
Molecular diffusion based scattering
10 pm
LtEL
100 nm
10 nm
Dipolar coupling based scattering
1 nm Dipolar coupling
1A
Fig. 12.1: Spatial scale of NMR measurements.
In general the range of length scales is divided into three regions: an absolute length scale area in which the signal (image) is directly related to a specific location in the sample; a relative area, at intermediate length scales where the distances between features are obtained, but the information is that averaged over the sample; and a spectroscopic length scale where the information is obtained directly from a resolved dipole-dipole interaction between spins. The first two of these provide a spatial mapping based on an applied magnetic field gradient and so the spatial scale is linear.
12. Materials Imaging with Examplesfrom Solid Rocket Propellants
145
The lower limit of resolution for NMR imaging is determined by the sensitivity (or lack there of) of NMR and is approximately 10 pm, though this is somewhat dependent on the sample characteristics and the methods used. In general the resolution is limited by the smallest volume that contains a minimum number of detectable spins. Scattering methods avoid this sensitivity limit by measuring an average property of the local geometry to which the entire sample contributes [5]. The resolution limit is determined solely by the strength of the gradient. The information from scattering methods is the conditional probability of spin translational displacements, over a time interval:
s(q) = jp(r) P(rlr’,t) exp(-ig.(r-r’))drdr’
(12.9)
where r and r‘ are the location of the spin, P denotes the probability and q is the wave vector. Where the displacements are introduced by molecular motions, diffusion coefficients and the geometry of barriers to free diffusion can be measured. Recent developments in gradient hardware have significantly extended the spatial range of these experiments to permit the direct observation of the extent of magnetization transport in rigid, strongly coupled spin systems via the dipole-dipole interaction [6,7]. In addition to the resolution limit for materials imaging, there is a related limit on the field of view and size of the sample. Most imaging methods depend upon strong gradient and/or RF fields, and these tend to dictate that the sample be relatively small to physically fit within a confining coil structure. The short spin-spin relaxation times also limit the number of Fourier components that can be measured and, thus, the field of view. Typically, the number of voxels across any axis of an image is limited to being equal to, or less than 256. So for a 1 cm diameter sample (that is easily contained within a high field magnet and gradient set), the highest resolution is 40 pm, even though the minimum number of detectable spins may be contained within a much smaller volume.
12.1.3 Approaches to NMR Imaging of Solids The various approaches to NMR imaging of materials are outlined in table 12.1, based primarily on the experimental setup required. The comments point to the types of materials that can be successfully imaged with these methods and provide a rough idea of the sensitivity and resolution. What is not described is the level of expertise necessary to
146
W. E. Muus, L.H. M e w i n , and D. G. Corj
successfully employ these methods. With the exception of the liquid state and constant time methods, all require specialized hardware that is presently found only in a limited number of laboratories. Of these, only the hardware for stray field imaging is commercially available. Table. 12.1: Classes of materials imaging methods
Type
Useslcomments
liquid state methods
Restricted to samples with sharp lines, such as elastomers. Resolution and sensitivity depends on the line-width. Relatively easy to include contrast.
constant time methods
No restriction on the sample. The resolution can be high, but the sensitivity depends on the line-width (typically low).
stray field
No restriction on the sample. The resolution is tied to the experimental setup. The sensitivity depends on the TIP and is typically low.
force detection
Samples must have a long Tip. The resolution depends on the mechanical setup and can be very high. These methods are still being developed [8].
coherent averaging
Resolution and sensitivity can be high and depend on the residual line-width.
- magic angle spinning
Works best for samples with small dipolar couplings or large susceptibility variations.
- multiple-pulse
No restrictions of the sample, but works best with very rigid materials. Care must be taken to avoid distortions
Liquid state and constant time methods [9,10] are widely available via micro-imaging accessories to NMR spectrometers and permit high quality images to be obtained for select materials. In neither of these is the NMR linewidth modified by coherent averaging, and so this presents a fundamental limit to the available sensitivity. In the liquid state approach the gradient is used to frequency encode spatial information in the presence of the full linewidth and so the resolution is that given by eqn. (12.8). This method is most appropriate for materials with relatively sharp NMR lines. With a magnetic field gradient of 100 Gkm, typical of commercial micro-imaging probes, a resolution of 10 pm can be obtained for samples with T2’s longer than about 0.5 ms (corresponding to
12. Materials Imaging with Examples from Solid Rocket Propellants
147
linewidths of less than 650 Hz). Examples of suitable samples include elastomers and solvent swollen plastics. Constant time methods rely on the high field truncation of spin Hamiltonians to their secular components, to decouple the gradient and dipolar contributions to the NMR linewidth at a fixed time. Gradient encoding may still be achieved, while leaving the dipolar evolution fixed, by incrementing the strength of the magnetic field gradient systematically between observations. The method then becomes a single point acquisition, which is very inefficient in sampling terms, although when sampled with a matched filter it may be very sensitive. Since the decoupling of the dipolar contributions to the linewidth arise not from a refocusing of the interaction, but rather from observing at a fixed point, the spin-spin relaxation time still leads to significant signal attenuation. However, this only influences the image sensitivity. The image resolution is limited solely by Nyquist sampling conditions. Stray field imaging (STRAFI) [ 111 approximates a continuous wave detected wideline experiment in a static magnetic field gradient. It typically utilizes the region near the end of the superconducting magnet windings where there is a very large magnetic field gradent. The field strength at this point is approximately 0.4 the field strength of the homogeneous region of the magnetic field. The maximum gradient varies with the central field strength of the magnet, and is found to be 40 T/m for a 4.7 T magnet and 80 T/m for a 9.4 T magnet. This gradient is homogeneous over a disk approximately 30 mm in diameter for a wide-bore magnet. Since the gradients are large, RF pulses at accessible power levels will only excite a small portion of a macroscopic sample placed in the field. The principle of STRAFI then is that a pulse selectively excites a plane transverse to the gradient with the selected thickness on the order of 100 pm. The sample is translated and another slice is observed, etc. Since each slice is observed separately, there is no need for a relaxation delay and the entire sample may be rapidly scanned. One version of this device can scan up to 512 slices with a separation of 60 pm in 1 second. A two-dimensional image is acquired by the back projection reconstruction technique. Each scan of the sample through the selective plane yields a projection of the spin density directly (no Fourier Transformation is required). The sample is then reoriented transverse to the gradient direction and scanned again. This is repeated until sufficient projections are accumulated to calculate the back-projection image. The process can be repeated in a third orthogonal direction to acquire a full three-dimensional image.
148
W. E. Muas, L.H. Merwin, and D.G. Cory
The STRAFI method is conceptually straightforward, but the probe is extremely complex, having to reorient the sample about two orthogonal axes and translate the sample along a third axis and perform all of this in a well controlled and reproducible manner while in a high magnetic field. Coherent averaging schemes [4,12] aim to artificially reduce the NMR linewidth by suppressing the time averaged spin evolution from all internal Hamiltonians while simultaneously restoring the evolution from the magnetic field gradient. This is most often accomplished as a combination of multiple-pulse and pulsed gradient methods, although magic angle spinning approaches [ 131 have also been demonstrated. The hardware for these methods is demanding, and the methods are prone to artifacts unless great care is exercised since the gradient and internal Hamiltonians interact in a profoundly non-linear fashion [ 14). Table 12.2: Common contrast mechanisms in solid state NMR imaging
Relaxation Times T1
Spectral density of molecular motions at the Larmor frequency
T2
Range of local fields Spectral density of molecular motions at the Larmor frequency in the rotating frame (typically tens of kilohertz)
Tl x
Spectral density of molecular motions at a pulsed effective field frequency (typically low audio frequencies)
Chemical Shifts Isotropic chemical shifts
Chemical species, morphology
Anisotropic chemical shifts
Orientation, dynamics
Susceptibility
Morphology, chemical heterogeneity
12. Materials Imaging with Examplesfrom Solid Rocket Propellants
149
12.1.4 Contrast in Solid State Imaging Table 12.2 lists the range of commonly available relaxation and contrast methods in solid state imaging. Most studies develop contrast based either on spin density or T, differences since these show up immediately without the need to modify the imaging sequence. Other relaxation times are best introduced by preceding the imaging measurement by a sequence to create the desired contrast [ 151.
12.2 Case Study: NMR Imaging of Rocket Motor Propellants 12.2.1 Introduction Elastomers are most widely used as binder in composite materials and NMR imaging has been shown to be a useful tool to obtain physical and chemical information from the elastomer distribution [2,16,17]. Solid rocket motor propellants are an example where a binder material is highly filled with particulate oxidizer [21]. Characteristics such as the burn rate and mechanical properties depend on the distribution, size and concentration of the filler material as well as the properties of the polymer matrix. This problem is a good example of where NMR imaging can make a unique contribution to understanding materials processing [ 18-20].
12.2.2 Experimental Section The NMR imaging experiments were performed at magnetic field strengths of 3 T and 14.1 T. The 3 T imaging system has a magnet with a horizontal room temperature bore of 15 cm. This system is based on a Bruker AMX console, operating at a proton frequency of 125 MHz. RF probes that accommodate samples of 18 mm, 8 mm and 6 mm were employed in a gradient set capable of generating 300 Gkm.
1so
W. E. Maas, L.H. Merwin, and D. G. Cory
In addition