Fabienne G. Durdin
Sonata for Flute
http://www.sonata.durdin.net/
Sonata for Flute Fabienne G. Durdin
FABIENNE. G. DURDIN Publisher http://www.sonata.durdin.net
To my husband, brother in Christ, and best friend, John Macgregor Durdin
SONATA FOR FLUTE Copyright © 1994, 1999 by Fabienne Gabrielle Durdin First published 1999 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, posting on another website, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication data: Durdin, Fabienne G. Sonata for flute. ISBN 0 9577741 0 9. I. Title. A823.3
Published by Fabienne G. Durdin <
[email protected]> http://www.sonata.durdin.net/sonata.pdf Cover illustration © 1995 by Fabienne G. Durdin.
PRELUDIO "O LORD, You have examined me through and through and You know everything about me... You planned and recorded all the days of my life before even one of them occurred." PSALM 139:1,16
Mrs. Taylor wiped her hands on her apron as she came out of her kitchen. She stood by the living room door and watched the small boy who was sitting on the chair by her front window, gazing out at the street expectantly. He had been back and forth between her kitchen and his lookout post all afternoon. His blue eyes at first had been bright with the excitement of anticipation, but as the hours went past they became increasingly clouded by confusion and anxiety. Now he sat swinging his legs, his light brown hair blowing about in the breeze from the open window. He caught sight of her, and for the umpteenth time that hour he jumped down from the chair and skipped over to her. Hopping from one foot to the other, he looked up at her appealingly. "Mrs. Taylor, when are they coming?" he asked, "Why is it taking so long?" With both his hands he took hold of the elderly woman's hand and gazed up at her as he waited for her answer. Although she couldn't complain about his behaviour, Mrs. Taylor had been finding the boy more wearying than usual that day. The boy, a bright, gentle lad of four years, and his parents were her neighbours, and now and then she minded him in the daytime when the regular babysitter was at school. She was the one who had offered to look after him on this special day when his mother would be coming home from hospital with her new baby. She had started to become anxious about an hour after lunch, when his parents still hadn't arrived. Now it was almost evening. The boy's father had dropped him off mid-morning. "We should be back in about an hour or so," he had told her. Several hours had gone by since he had driven off to pick up his wife and still there was no sign of them. Should she call the police? Surely he would have rung if they had been held up for some reason. Maybe they'd had car trouble? She was about to answer the boy's question when she thought she heard a car pulling up next door, at his home. She squeezed his hand and smiled at him. "I expect they've had a flat tyre or something like that," she said, trying to reassure him, "They should be home soon." I hope that's them now, she thought, though that didn't really sound like their car. She went to the window and glanced towards their house, and what she saw made her heart skip a beat. The boy was regarding her with a puzzled expression as she turned to him. "You just sit here for a bit while I go to your house," she said, trying not to sound anxious, "There's some visitors
1
Sonata for Flute
just arrived and I'll go tell them no-one's home. You stay here in case Daddy gets back while I'm over at your place. Okay?" "Okay," he answered, gave a little hop, and went to sit in one of her flowered armchairs. He sat quietly, as he'd been taught to, and waited, tracing around the flowered pattern of the upholstery with his finger and humming softly to himself. Mrs. Taylor walked out of her front door as calmly as she could, shut the door, then hurried along the footpath to the front of her neighbours' house. The police sedan parked in their driveway was real all right, and so were the two constables standing on the front porch. A few minutes later she returned to her house accompanied by the two policemen. As they walked up to the front door, the boy heard one of them talking and for a moment mistook the voice for his father's. He raced to the door and opened it, then stopped short when he saw the men in uniform. Like most small boys he was in awe of policemen, but he had never seen one quite as close as this. He wondered what occasion had brought him this privilege. Then he noticed Mrs. Taylor's face—she was pale and her eyes were red, her face wet. She was twisting her handkerchief nervously as she walked up the path with the two men. Something was wrong. He couldn't recall ever having seen Mrs. Taylor crying before. "Don't worry, I'll deal with it," one of the men was saying to her, "I've got kids of my own, I'll talk to the lad." Then he looked towards the house and saw the boy standing there staring at them. He felt a sudden pang of pity for the child and a dreadful feeling almost of guilt for the job he had to carry out. "Come inside, dear," Mrs. Taylor said, taking the boy's hand as she got to the door, "The constables want to talk to you." Her tone of voice, almost flat and expressionless, frightened him. As he followed Mrs. Taylor into the living room he glanced anxiously over his shoulder at the policemen. Had he done something wrong? Were they coming to take him to gaol? He knew that one of the jobs policemen performed was taking people who did bad things to gaol. He tried to remember what he had done that day, but he couldn't remember being naughty. He had simply sat looking out of the window, drawing pictures, or talking with Mrs. Taylor. And he had eaten all his lunch, even the bits he didn't like. The two men sat down at the old lady's invitation. The boy stood halfhidden behind an armchair, watching them shyly. "I'll just go and put the kettle on for a cuppa," Mrs. Taylor said uneasily, and hurriedly left the room. One of the policemen smiled and beckoned to the boy. "Come here, son," he said gently, "I need to talk with you." His apprehension somewhat allayed by the man's kind tone of voice, the boy went over to him. Still smiling, the policeman picked him up and sat him on his knee. "Well, my boy," he said kindly, "I've got a little boy like you. His name is Peter. Tell me now, what's your name?"
2
Sonata for Flute
The boy was rather amazed that a real policeman should be talking to him, and he felt a little overwhelmed. "Carl. With a 'c'," he answered timidly, looking at his feet. He glanced up at the policeman to see his reaction. The constable nodded. "Carl, with a 'c'," he repeated thoughtfully, "Have you got a last name, too?" "Yep, and a middle name, too!" Carl, feeling more at ease now, answered brightly. "Can you tell me all of your names, then?" the man urged gently. Carl straightened his shoulders and looked at him proudly. "Carl... Emmanuel... Slade!" he answered confidently. "And I'm four years old," he added, holding up four fingers to illustrate. "Well, those are very good names for a big boy of four," the policeman said, ruffling his hair and grinning. Carl, feeling rather pleased with himself, turned to look at the other man and saw him writing in a small notebook. "What's he writing?" he asked the first man. "Your name," the constable replied, and added to his colleague, "That's Carl with a 'c'—make sure you get it right!" The other man nodded but did not look up. Carl was feeling bolder now. "What's your name?" he asked his new friend. "I'm Constable Smithers," the policeman answered, and then he remembered why he was there. He gazed sadly at the child, swallowed hard, and put his arm around his shoulders. He kept thinking of his own two small children. His little Peter was only four... "Well, Carl," he said, and his tone of voice, suddenly sober, brought back all Carl's apprehensions, "I have something very, very sad to tell you. You're going to have to be very brave, Carl." He hesitated, wondering how far the boy's understanding went. "You've been waiting for Mummy and Daddy to come home, haven't you?" Carl nodded, his eyes wide. "Yep," he said dubiously. "Well, Carl," Constable Smithers said quietly, "I'm afraid that Mummy and Daddy are not going to come home." Carl's eyes grew even wider with a mixture of incredulity and fear. "They aren't?" he asked in a small voice. "There's been a horrible accident and your Mummy and Daddy are dead, Carl." The boy stared at him. He knew about accidents—on the way to the hospital with Daddy the other day he'd seen two smashed cars surrounded by ambulances, police cars, tow trucks, and people. Accidents were when cars smashed. Dead—that was what had happened to their cat. It was dead because a car had hit it. Dead meant it didn't move any more, it was all stiff, and it got put in a hole in the ground... Understanding slowly dawned on him.
3
Sonata for Flute
"No!" he yelled, pushing away from the man, jumping off his knee, and backing away from the two of them, "Mummy and Daddy aren't dead! They aren't dead! They aren't dead! You're lying! You're nasty liars!" Mrs. Taylor had been about to bring the tea-tray into the lounge, but she decided to delay and retreated into the kitchen. Crises were things she had always let her husband deal with, until the crisis of his death. She was always at a loss in this sort of situation—especially if a child was involved. Now she was afraid she would be asked to take on looking after Carl and she couldn't face that. She was too old. Minding the boy now and then was one thing—he was not a difficult lad—but she knew she would not be able to cope with him on a permanent basis. Carl stood in the corner of the living room, his blue eyes full of defiance, as if daring the policeman to repeat what he'd said. Horror and negation fought in his mind. That his parents would never come back was something his four years of life experience would not let him believe. Constable Smithers left his chair and crouched down in front of the boy. He gently took Carl's hands and pulled him closer. The boy eyed him warily but didn't resist. Despite his terrible words, the policeman was not a frightening man. "Carl," Smithers said softly, "I wish I could tell you that it's all a mistake, that it isn't true. But I can't. Your Mummy and Daddy's car was hit by a big truck. It was smashed. Mummy and Daddy are dead. They will never come home again." Carl continued staring at him in disbelief. Then, to Smithers' astonishment, he smiled. "That means I'll have to take care of Helen for them, won't I?" he said brightly, "I told her I'd look after her!" The policeman was stunned. "Helen? Who's Helen?" he asked. "She's my baby sister," Carl answered cheerfully, "She's only new, she's very, very little. I can hold her, she's not very heavy." Oh, my God, the man thought, He doesn't realize she's gone too—I didn't tell him! His heart ached at the thought of having to disillusion the boy. Once again he put his arm around Carl's shoulders. "Carl," he said, so softly it was almost a whisper, "I have something horrible I have to tell you. Helen isn't coming home either. She was also in the car. She's dead too." ! ! ! Only four days before, Carl had met his new sister. His father had taken him to the hospital to see his mother and the new baby the day after she was born. Carl had felt very small in the maze of hospital corridors through which his father had led him, but he had also felt quite safe holding tightly onto Daddy's hand and skip-running to keep up with his father's long and sure strides. As they had waited for the lift, his father had grinned at him conspiratorially—he had a surprise for Mummy in his pocket—and Carl, feeling very important about being let in on the secret, had grinned back. The hallways through which they walked seemed enormous to a small boy of four. Their cream-tiled surfaces echoed every sound, the fluorescent 4
Sonata for Flute
lamps bathed them in a strange whiteness, the chemical smells permeating the air tickled his nose. He was glad of his father's hand. It would be horrible to get lost in here—one might just keep going round and round forever. And all those mysterious doors... He caught glimpses of weird machinery beyond some of the open ones. When they reached his mother's room they found her sitting in an armchair, with a small bundle in her arms. As they came in she looked up, and smiled joyfully as she saw them. She got up and put the bundle down in a little trolley by her bed, then went to Carl and gathered him in her arms. "Hello, my big boy," she said, kissing him on the cheek, "I'm so glad to see you!" "Hello, Mummy," he replied, automatically kissing her, but then he wriggled out of her arms and looked around the room, as if searching for something. "Where is she, Mummy?" he asked, "Where's my new sister?" "Hang on a minute, Carl," his father said, "Let me say hello to Mummy, too." His parents embraced, much to Carl's annoyance, for to him it seemed far more important right now to find this sister of his. "Come on, Mummy," he pleaded, tugging at her dressing-gown, "I wanna see her." His mother laughed and reached for the bundle in the trolley. "Go sit in the chair, Carl," she told him, "Would you like to hold her?" "I can hold her?" he asked wide-eyed. His father picked him up and sat him right back in the armchair, and his mother placed the bundle in his arms, keeping one hand on it in case it proved too hard for him to hold. Carl had seen many babies, he had even held one or two before, but somehow he hadn't associated 'babyness' with his new sister, and no-one had thought to tell him that this little sister who had just been born was a baby. They had assumed it would be obvious to him. His parents had talked about 'the baby' many times, but when Mrs. Taylor had announced the birth to him after the phone call the day before he hadn't put the two ideas together. For the first time, and for the last time, Carl saw his little sister's face. How small she was! Her face was like a doll's, with a tiny nose—he touched the tip of it with his finger—and a funny little mouth that she kept puckering up. There was a halo of downy black hair on her head—he was surprised at how soft it was. Her eyes—he was pleased to see they were also blue—were wide open and looking straight at him! He looked up at his parents and grinned. "She's looking at me, she is!" he whispered excitedly. His mother, crouching by the chair, smiled back. His father took a photo. Carl gazed at the baby in wonder. Again he marvelled, She's so tiny! One small hand poked out of the blanket in which she was wrapped, and he took it gently in his own hand. Her fingers curled around his thumb. Her smallness overwhelmed him. How could she be safe? Even in his four 5
Sonata for Flute
short years of life he had become aware that the world was full of dangers, and he found himself wanting very much to protect this tiny person. Then and there he assigned himself the role of protector of his sister. "What's her name, Mummy?" he whispered. "We've named her Helen," she answered, "Helen Joy." Carl leant his face close to the baby's, hugging her tightly. "Hello, Helen," he whispered to her, "I'm Carl, and I'm your big brother, and I'm gonna look after you, you know." Helen didn't seem terribly impressed, but this didn't worry Carl. He felt completely happy in his new self-appointed role. How wonderful to be a big brother! He looked at her fondly a while longer, then up at his parents, his blue eyes shining with bliss. His mother took Helen from him, to his relief for she was getting heavy and he was afraid he might drop her. He slid off the chair, skipped over to his father, and gave him a hug, then he gave his mother a hug as she went to sit down in the chair with Helen in her arms. He wanted to hug everyone, he felt so incredibly happy. ! ! ! At the constable's words, Carl's face turned as white as the wall behind him. "They're never coming back home?" he asked fearfully, "Not Mummy, not Daddy, not Helen? Never?" His eyes searched the constable's face for any hint of hope, in vain. Smithers' statement had hit him with the finality of the last axe-blow on a tree being felled. "She's dead too." The world he knew came crashing down around him with all the horror he had ever experienced in his worst nightmares. He cried out, in the same terrified way that he did whenever he woke from a bad dream, "Mummy!" He hid his face on the man's shoulder and then the tears came, first slowly, and then in a flood, and Constable Smithers picked him up and went to sit with him cradled in his arms on his lap. Carl sobbed wretchedly, unconsolably, until he wore himself out with crying and fell asleep, still sobbing, in Smithers' arms. ! ! ! As it turned out, nobody seemed to want Carl, although several people were keen to direct his future. None of his relatives were interested in adding to their own broods. Mrs. Taylor said she was too old to take him on permanently although he'd be welcome for short stays. Other friends of the family were sympathetic but, alas, they already had their hands full with their own problems... After the funeral one of his aunts on his father's side, a member of the Protection Party as well as of Federal Parliament, arranged for him to become a Ward of the State. Using her not insubstantial political clout and the proceeds from Carl's father's small life insurance policy, she also 6
Sonata for Flute
managed to persuade the very progressive Rainbow Garden Children's Home to add Carl E. Slade to its list of resident orphans.
7
FIRST MOVEMENT: ADAGIO PESANTE
"At a time when people are declaring that they have peace and security they will suddenly face destruction in the way a pregnant woman suddenly finds herself in labour, and not one will escape." I THESSALONIANS 5:3 "...there was once in man a true happiness, but now only a hint and the empty trace of it are left, and in vain he tries to fill this space with everything around him... this infinite chasm can only be filled by something infinite and immutable, that is, God Himself..." BLAISE PASCAL, 'Pensées'
Chapter 1
The Rainbow Garden Children's Home was a private orphanage sponsored by the Protection Party. This was an obscure and small but rapidly growing group of progressive thinkers who had their own social and educational philosophies, and whose power was increasing even faster than the number of its adherents. They had only one representative in Parliament, and this was Carl's aunt. Despite her controversial pronouncements and her belligerent attitude her popularity with the public had increased very quickly. The ranks of the Protectioners had swelled along with her success. Within a fortnight of the funeral of his parents and sister Carl was in the Rainbow Garden Children's Home. He was too young to understand what was happening or the finality of it. He had spent the fortnight at his aunt's house, a place he had never visited before and where despite his young age he could tell he was not welcome. As soon as all the arrangements were made he was taken to the Home, and that was the last he ever saw of his aunt, though she continued to monitor him for many years. At first he missed his parents terribly. In the Children's Home there was not a person he knew. Death was still something confusing and misunderstood for him, and he kept expecting his parents to turn up to take him home. This unmet hope was like a daily whipping—the pain of it was almost physical. The people who had been everything to him were gone forever, and his complete happiness of such a short time before had been so suddenly and utterly shattered. Every night he had nightmares about wandering down huge, brightly lit and strange-smelling hospital corridors crying out for his father. He would wake up screaming for his mother, and this happened several times a night, usually waking some of the other children.
8
Sonata for Flute
Carl noticed very soon that the other children in the Home did not seem to like him. Most of them were older than him and looked on him with disdain. He thought that it was his nightmares which caused their hostility, and this was in fact partly true. There had to be other reasons, however, because they called him names that he didn't understand and which had nothing to do with keeping people awake at night. Even most of the children who were closer to his age avoided him, for the older ones had warned them that if they made friends with him they would also have nightmares. He had never experienced rejection before, and he felt its pain keenly. None of his attempts to make friends met with success, and after a while he gave up. As the weeks and months went by he withdrew ever further into himself and began to develop a quick temper. After a few months he had more or less settled into the routine of the Home, but he still had no friends. Unconsciously now he avoided becoming attached to anyone—he could not face risking the pain of separation. The initial rejection by the residents of the Home had only made it easier for him to have this attitude. Over the years the staff and the other orphans would find that Carl Slade was not someone you could get close to. He willingly joined in games, he liked to have fun, he willingly helped with chores, but he had built a fence around himself beyond which no one seemed able to go. Anyone who tried soon ran into his anger. Carl himself was not aware that he had put up a barrier. He just assumed others avoided him because they didn't like him. Even at the age of four he had found that many of his ideas were ridiculed or even censured by the others. He soon discovered that there were ways of thinking which were not welcome at Rainbow Garden Children's Home. For most of the residents, it was easier to give in and fit in with what was acceptable. Carl, however, simply buried his ideas and pretended to fit in. Each week the children in the Home had to take part in group sessions called "Sharing". During these they were urged to freely talk about their feelings with the staff and the other children. Carl dreaded the Sharings. He hardly ever had anything to say in those sessions and both staff and children badgered him about it. They would pester him and "try to pry"—as he called it—until he would become furious. There were occasions when he quite lost control and lashed out violently. Whenever that happened he would be sent to his room until the next mealtime. Being banned to solitude for a few hours was considered the worst punishment in the Home. To Carl it was welcome relief. As he grew up he forgot what his parents and his baby sister had looked like, and there were even times when he wondered if he had simply imagined them. He had no photographs of them, no memento of them except for one framed print that had once hung on their living room wall. Of course, Carl was not the only child there who knew nothing about his parents, but the other children were company for each other. Because of his increasingly violent temper, however, the other children and many of the staff at the Home avoided him as much as possible. In an effort to get 9
Sonata for Flute
some attention he tried to be helpful to the staff, often succeeding only in being a nuisance. His efforts actually served to further alienate him from the other children. At one point there was talk of sending Carl to a State children's home, but his aunt heard of it and intervened to ensure it would not happen. For her own reasons, she wanted him brought up strictly within the Protection philosophy of child-rearing and education. This contended that "children should be encouraged in every way to find their own individual, personal truth, to develop their limitless potential, and to express themselves freely from their inner source." "Self-Fulfillment first—the rest will follow," was one of their slogans. Externally-imposed values would hamper such a process, thus they could not be allowed. The Rainbow Garden Children's Home had its own school, where "Self-Expression" was the core and aim of the curriculum, especially in what was referred to as "The Expressive Arts"—a term which covered everything from painting and music to cooking and architecture. To the Protectioners, what they termed "Sexual Celebration" was the pinnacle of Self-Expression and Self-Fulfillment. A person was only truly free when able to take part in any kind of sexual activity without any feelings of guilt. Thus Protectioners and their sympathisers promoted free living as part of their policies. This policy was made viable by the recent development of an effective vaccine against the dreaded AIDS disease which had been such a scourge at the turn of the century. There was even the promise of a cure being "just around the corner". There were many who objected to the Protectioners' teaching, and a large number of experts were quoted in its defense. However, it did not need much for it to become generally acceptable among most of the population, for whom SelfFulfillment had become the life-goal. As they entered adolescence, the residents of the Home were encouraged to embrace Sexual Celebration wholeheartedly. All except one complied. Fifteen-year-old Carl was further ostracised as he and the other residents of the home became aware that he had deeply-ingrained feelings about sex which were in stark contrast to the permissiveness of the Protection teaching. The thought of indulging in the fleeting relationships and experimentation that his peers soon considered an essential part of their growing up horrified him. But he couldn't explain to anyone why he felt the way he did—he didn't know himself. The children's home staff, concerned about what they saw as abnormal behaviour, tried in diverse ways to get him to conform. Once they even sent one of the girls to his room in the middle of the night in the hope that when half asleep he would respond more positively. He had woken up to find the girl, wearing nothing at all, climbing into his bed, and he had panicked. The whole Home had been awakened as he had raged at her to leave his room and had slammed and locked his door behind her. At that point, after two years of their own efforts, the staff gave up and arranged a visit with a psychologist.
10
Sonata for Flute
Carl had only one meeting with the psychologist. It was shortly after his seventeenth birthday and, "so he wouldn't feel threatened", the woman met with him in the study of the Home's director rather than in her own office downtown. Carl had been told that Dr. Millner could help him with his hang-ups and he had been encouraged by the Home's director to be frank and open with her. Carl did not exactly welcome this advice. Dr. Millner was waiting for him in the study when he went there at the appointed time just after lunch. She was a graying but still trim and attractive middle-aged woman, dressed in the latest Protection-approved fashion guaranteed to embarrass a self-conscious and guilt-ridden adolescent. As Carl came through the open study door warily she greeted him cheerfully. "Come in, Carl, come in," she said, almost singing it, "Take a seat, make yourself comfortable." She indicated one of the armchairs to one side of the director's desk. Carl took a seat on the very edge of the armchair she had pointed out, and nervously clasped his hands together in front of him. He glanced quickly around the room, as if he expected to see other people present, but he did not look at Dr. Millner. He was not there because he wanted to be and he did not feel very warmly toward this person whom, as he understood it, was there to pry and coerce. Dr. Millner closed the door and walked briskly to the other armchair. "Well, Carl," she said brightly, "I think the first thing we ought to do is get acquainted, don't you? I'm Dr. Agnes Millner, but everyone calls me Agnes. I'm a psychologist, and I counsel young people like you who need help understanding themselves." Carl nodded but said nothing, and stared at the pattern on the carpet in front of him. Dr. Millner waited a few moments, then suddenly got up and fetched a large, thin briefcase from the desk. She resumed her seat, pulled out a folder of papers from the briefcase, and opened it. "Carl E. Slade," she read out, "Oh, I see you've just turned seventeen." She looked up and beamed at him. "Well," she said, "Happy birthday, Carl. It's a bit late, I know, but better late than never, eh?" Carl glanced at her and grimaced. "Thanks," he mumbled, and looked back at the floor. Dr. Millner was not easily disconcerted. She was used to having to draw out her patients. "Well, Carl, what seems to be the problem?" she asked, "Why makes you so unhappy?" She waited for his reply, her smile frozen on her face. Carl raised his head slowly and gazed at her, but did not answer right away. What kind of nonsense was this? What was this woman expecting him to say? She looks ridiculous in that stupid outfit, he thought, Thinks she's still sixteen or something. Why does she think I'm the one who has a problem? "I don't have a problem," he said finally, "I'm perfectly happy the way I am. It's Thomas and Jarelle and Kate who say I have a problem. They just won't leave me alone and they get all the kids and the rest of the staff to bug me about what they think I ought to do." 11
Sonata for Flute
"From the information they gave me I understand that you don't mix freely with the girls here. Is that right?" Carl sighed. Not again! he said to himself. "They mean I don't have sex with them, don't they?" he said wearily, and felt anger growing inside him. "Yes, but—" "If that's what they mean, why don't they say that?" he snapped, "Always talking in doubletalk! They don't seem to be able to say anything straight!" Dr. Millner was taken off-guard, but she stayed calm. "Now, Carl," she said softly, "There's no need to get upset. We can just talk about this reasonably and quietly." "Maybe you can!" he exclaimed hotly, "You haven't been hounded day and night because you won't go to bed with a girl—a different girl, what's more—every night, have you? It's all they've got on their mind! They don't seem to see all the other things I do right, they just think I should be like everybody else and ---- every girl in sight!" The directness of the expletive seemed to make Dr. Millner slightly uneasy. "Well," she said, "I don't think they would go quite so far as to—" "So far as to send a naked girl into my bedroom in the middle of the night?" Carl asked defiantly, interrupting her. Dr. Millner changed her position slightly, and also changed the subject. "Let's talk about you for a bit, Carl," she said calmingly, "Tell me, what do you like to do most of all?" Again he did not reply immediately. He was sick of people asking him to talk about himself. Whenever he did, they always latched onto something about which they could pester him. "I like playing the flute," he blurted out at last, and right away he knew he shouldn't have said it. Dr. Millner's response confirmed his misgivings. "Now why would an intelligent boy like you play such an old-fashioned instrument?" she asked, "It's the sort of thing that you have to spend countless boring hours practising! Surely it's more to the point to use a Musicmaker. No boring practice sessions—all you have to do is push a few buttons and you can have any piece of music you like, played any way you want!" "I happen to enjoy practising on my flute," Carl said defiantly. "Perhaps if you gave it up, Carl, you'd find you have more energy to pursue other things," Dr. Millner suggested softly. "Like ---- girls, you mean?" he said sarcastically, "Whatever happened to Self-Expression, then? What if I prefer playing my flute to bedding down with a girl? Can't I do what I feel like doing? Everybody else is allowed to!" The psychologist didn't answer. She considered him pensively for some moments as he frowned at the floor. Then she took another folder out of her briefcase and spread out its contents on the low table in front of Carl. "Take a look at these, Carl," she said, "and tell me how they make you feel." He took one quick look at the photographs, blushed crimson, and turned his back on them. The pictures—some of women, some of men and women—left nothing to the imagination. "Put them away," he said hoarsely, "I don't want to see them." Please put them away, because I do 12
Sonata for Flute
want to look at them and yet I don't, and I'll have nightmares all night again if I do see them. Oh why can't I be like everybody else? "Do they excite you, Carl?" Dr. Millner asked levelly, "Do they make you want to do those things too? Why don't you look at them?" "Put them away," he repeated, quietly but fiercely, keeping his back to them and to her. She sighed, and replaced the photographs and folder in the briefcase. "Is it girls that are the problem, Carl?" she asked, "Maybe that's what's bothering you. Perhaps you should try some of the boys. Perhaps that's more your leaning. It's perfectly all right, you know. Several of the boys here are gay, and no-one thinks anything of it. Why don't you approach them?" Carl wheeled around and stared at her speechlessly. He had grown up with the teaching that all kinds of sexual behaviour were acceptable and yet he was still convinced that there was only one right condition for sex, and that was within marriage. He clung to this conviction as if his life depended on it. This wasn't the first time sex with a man had been suggested to him— didn't Dr. Millner's notes tell her how he'd reacted to that advice before? "Why on earth are you people so determined to get me into bed with someone else?" he asked fiercely, "I don't want to do it! You people keep asking me why I don't want to! I don't know why—I just don't want to!" He started shouting. "Self-Expression is the motto of the Protection Party, isn't it? This is my way of expressing myself! You're not going to change it with any of your psychology stuff! I'm happy the way I am, I told you! Why don't you just leave me alone?" Dr. Millner seemed unruffled by his outburst. "You seem to be a very unhappy young man, Carl," she said quietly, "From what my notes tell me, you have no friends, you spend a great deal of time playing your music or walking about by yourself in the gardens, you don't take part in the Sharings, and of course, you have your sexual hangups as well. I'm going to suggest to Thomas that I have a few counselling sessions with you, to sort out these inhibitions and get you straightened out. You'll be much happier, you'll see. Don't lose hope." "Lose hope?" Carl echoed incredulously, "I didn't ask to meet with you, Dr. Millner, it was Thomas and Jarelle who made me come! I keep telling you, I'm happy! I'm happy the way I am! I'm not using doubletalk, just plain English! I-am-happy! Do psychologists understand plain English? I don't have a problem—I'm just expressing myself, me, who I am!" He stubbornly refused to have any more to do with the psychologist. He insisted that his way of seeing things was just another way of expressing oneself, and the staff at Rainbow Garden eventually decided to agree with him. because of his aunt thay couldn't get rid of hom, but they were tired of the battle. They reckoned there would be other ways of getting him on the "Straight" track, and to his great relief they finally dropped the subject. In many ways Carl wanted to be like his peers and give in to his natural urges and desires, if only because then they might accept him and he wouldn't be so lonely. Whenever he seriously considered following their 13
Sonata for Flute
example, however, his whole being revolted and his nightmares would start again. He wondered why in the world he felt that strongly about it, but, search as he might, he couldn't find a reason in his memory. In the end he decided that he would just have to live his life his own way and put up with the loneliness. Despite all the "freedom" being preached and practised by society during Carl's growing-up years, people still got married, although what was understood by 'marriage' was becoming more and more vague. Somewhere Carl had got the idea that marriage was supposed to be a lifelong commitment of a man and a woman to each other, and he held on to this notion despite all attempts to prove to him that liberal divorce laws meant it needn't be so binding. To such arguments he always countered that there was no point in going through all the rigmarole of getting married if one intended to divorce at the first sign of dissatisfaction. Once a classmate was extolling the wonders of wedding feasts after just having expressed relief that divorce laws were further being relaxed. The contradiction didn't seem to strike the others who were listening to her, including the teacher. Carl saw it, however, and for once voiced his opinion. "A wedding is supposed to be the start of a lifetime together," he said, "Divorce ought to be made harder, not easier." "What if you get married and find you've married the wrong person, then?" the girl replied, her tone defensive, "You think you ought to to be miserable for the rest of your life?" "If you're going to insist on the trial and error approach," Carl retorted sarcastically, "then you ought to just live together in a so-called partnership! It's a lot less complicated than getting married and you don't have all that farce and expense of a wedding! You live in the same house, decide who owns what, sleep together, and when you're tired of each other, you simply move in with someone else! It's quite acceptable and you don't have all that rigmarole of getting a divorce. Why have a wedding and all those silly promises if you don't intend to stay together all your life?" "So you think those things people say at weddings are binding for life, huh?" the teacher said. "It seems to me," Carl replied, turning to face him, "that the best thing would be for a man and a woman to marry for life, to promise to live together and share everything, and look out for each other, no matter what." "Do you mean a monogamous relationship, with no other sexual partners, then?" the man asked dubiously. "Yes, of course," Carl said, "If both the man and the woman promised to be faithful to each other, and they meant it, then they would never have to worry about anyone else taking their partner away, would they?" "Well, it wouldn't work, you know," the man laughed, "Research in the nineties showed that our genes program us to be polygamous. Nature intends us to have more than one partner. So it isn't healthy to restrict oneself to just one person. It goes against nature." 14
Sonata for Flute
"I still think it would be wonderful to live with the same woman all my life," Carl replied dreamily, oblivious to the sniggering going on around him, "To know that we'd promised to be faithful to each other and to love each other no matter what, you know. Even if everybody says it isn't natural." "Do you really think any woman would willingly enter into that kind of relationship with a man these days? To promise to be stuck with him for life even if they turn out to be incompatible? It's cruel to expect that of any woman. Or any man, for that matter." "Well, but wouldn't they be able to sort it out somehow, to find a way to cope with the incompatibility? Surely they could find enough things they have in common to compensate? Or maybe they could compromise or something?" His teacher crossed his arms and looked at him with some disdain. "Well, now, how many women do you know, Carl," he sneered, "who'd be willing to live all their lives with you?" Carl stared at him in dismayed astonishment, and became aware that his classmates were finding the exchange very amusing. He lowered his eyes to his desk. "Uh, I don't know of any, actually," he said very quietly. "Well, then?" the teacher said triumphantly. Carl looked up quickly. "But I don't know of any girl I'd want to marry, either!" he protested. "Do you have any idea what sort of girl you're looking for?" "Yes, I do, but none of those I know come anywhere near to it..." "There you are, then! You can see yourself this 'marriage for life' idea is a stupid notion. It requires a kind of person that doesn't exist." The argument didn't convince Carl, and he insisted that lifelong marriage had to be the best way. That was how he saw it, and he stuck to his idea. Anything else was for him unthinkable. By this time his classmates were in stitches. The teacher looked at him darkly. "You'd better be careful who you talk to about this, boy," he warned, "Put these ridiculous ideas out of your head! Only those weirdoes, the Rebels, believe that marriage is for life, and they're way out of touch with the times! You wouldn't want people to think you're one of them, would you?" A flurry of whispering around him in which he caught the word "rebel" several times convinced Carl to drop the argument. He knew that to be thought a Rebel would be the ultimate black mark. Rebels were the bane of the Republic, and there were many people who hoped a final solution would soon be found to this social problem. It was bad enough not having any friends—to be seen as a Rebel would guarantee him enemies and he certainly didn't want any. "No, Sir," he said, "I wouldn't want to be one of them or to have people think I am."
15
Chapter 2
About the time Carl reached adulthood a new form of entertainment was becoming very popular. These were the Fantasy Dreamers, machines that enabled one to escape the problems of real life and live out one's fantasies in colourful, imaginary, computer-produced interactive settings. At first one could only indulge in a Fantasy Dream in special Fantasy Arcades dotted around the country. But by the time the new Republic was ten years old, they were fast replacing CD-viewers in people's homes. Many people devoted an entire room to the machine or several of them. New house plans included a Fantasy Dream Room as standard, and those who did not have such a room were regarded as deprived. Most of the men and women Carl knew spent a great deal of time pursuing they knew not what in Fantasy Dreamers. After trying it once, Carl had no intention of repeating what for him had turned out to be a most unpleasant experience. The sensation of being detached from reality was one he did not enjoy—it reminded him of his nightmares. But he began to understand why the people around him often seemed to have no ideas of their own but just accepted whatever the increasingly influential Protection Party offered them. A person in a Fantasy Dreamer did not have to think, they only had to react. The machine's computer did all the thinking for them. Carl's solitude enabled him to develop interests which other people considered a waste of time or simply childish. He enjoyed the beauties of nature for their own sake and he delighted in making music on the flute. His walks in the garden and his hours of flute practice were his only comforts. He longed to be able to share with some of his fellow residents the pleasure that was his, but he never dared to—he knew they would laugh at him if he did. He was puzzled that so few people seemed to be able to enjoy beauty for its own sake. One day as he lay resting after lunch he noticed the picture hanging on the wall above his bed. It was a reproduction of a Redouté watercolour of a rose which had once adorned his parents' living room. It was the only one of his parents' belongings that had come to him after his relatives had gone through their home after the funeral—he had been told that his aunt was holding the rest in trust. He took the picture down and sat on his bed studying it. He walked to the window and looked out at the real roses growing in the garden. What is beauty? he asked himself, What makes a rose different from say, an old rag? Why are the print and the real rose beautiful? Why does the warbling of that currawong out there make me happy when the screech of an electric saw has the opposite effect? Why isn't anyone else interested in such questions? He shrugged, put the picture back on the wall, got out his flute, and spent the remaining hour before lunch trying to imitate the currawong's song.
16
Sonata for Flute
Playing and improvising on the flute was Carl's one real escape from the pain of being a misfit. He had started learning at the age of twelve, at a time when fewer and fewer people in the Republic were taking up the classical instruments. Playing such instruments was too much hard work— getting computers to produce music on a synthesizer was so much easier. Playing the flute would have been enough to label Carl as peculiar. As it was it only meant one more oddity in the list of his peculiarities. That the director of the Children's Home had even allowed him to take it up, let alone provided an instrument, was an inexplicable aberration in the eyes of the rest of the staff, but they did not dare to argue with their boss. One of the things about himself which bothered Carl greatly was his short temper. He could fly into a rage at the hint of a sneer and too often he lashed out in self-defense and got into trouble as a result. Despite all the talk about Self-Expression, some forms of self-expression remained less acceptable than others, and anger was one of them. Carl was distressed by his inability to control his anger. At the suggestion of one of the Home staff who thought getting rid of excess energy might help cool his temper, he took up running. He would go for a long run every morning before breakfast, but although he enjoyed the activity, it didn't help his temper. Someone else pointed out to him that repressing himself in other areas was what made it so difficult for him in that one, but Carl wasn't about to try indulging his sexual desires in an attempt to control his temper. In any case, he had a sneaking suspicion it probably wouldn't work. He couldn't imagine that having a guilty conscience from going against his convictions could possibly help his temper. At the turn of the century certain enlightened chemists had perfected several drugs which allowed those who took them to change their personalities, at least for the duration of the effects of a dose. These drugs, dubbed "Personality Pills" were eagerly greeted by the vast number of people who were dissatisfied with the characters they had been given by nature. A shy, retiring fellow could become the life of the party just by popping a pill as he walked in the door. An extrovert with foot-in-mouth disease could swallow a taciturnity capsule which would make him reluctant to voice his opinions freely. A woman who had trouble relating to men could enjoy a few hours of no inhibitions simply by taking a tablet. For Carl, the Personality Pills offered the hope of a cure for his bad temper—even if only for a few hours at a time. He asked the Children's Home nurse if she thought they might help. She told him that, yes, help was indeed as close as swallowing a pill now, and offered him a dose of the appropriate one. His hopes high, he decided to try it, and took the tablet before going to classes the next morning. That was the first and last time he made the attempt. Not only did the tablet make no difference to his temper, but he discovered that he was one of those very rare individuals whom the Personality Pills made violently ill. Within two or three minutes of taking the tablet he had double vision, became so dizzy and nauseous he felt as if the room was bouncing up and down, and developed the worst headache he had ever experienced. His 17
Sonata for Flute
breakfast refused to remain in his stomach and he collapsed on the floor of his bedroom. The cleaner found him and took him to the nurse's office, where he spent a miserable morning under observation. "No more Personality Pills for you," the nurse told him when she let him go that afternoon, "You'll just have to cope with life with your own personality." In a way Carl didn't mind. Although it would have been nice to be able to solve his problem that simply, it would only have been a temporary cure every time. For a permanent solution he would have to keep trying to control his anger himself anyway. It was all right, however, only as long as his frustration level remained below boiling point. On most occasions it didn't. When he finished school, Carl decided to continue studying, and aimed at qualifying in Social Welfare. He longed to do something to redeem himself, and he saw helping other people as the way to do it. From what he understood, the whole point of social work was to help people. He enrolled in the Training College of the Welfare Ministry, determined that he would fit in completely with their programme and become a "Straight Thinker". That would mean he would then be able to work in the Welfare Ministry after he graduated. Carl put all his efforts into his studies, even relegating his daily flute practice to three times weekly instead of daily. In his field work he was careful to do everything according to what was prescribed by the Welfare Ministry. He was terrified of being rejected by them. His five years in the Training College seemed to succeed where all the years of childhood indoctrination had failed. He excelled in all his courses and easily spouted all the accepted relativist teachings of the Protectioners: "tolerance", Eastern philosophy, eco-conservationism, and nationalism. He feared the Protectioners more than anything else. As he neared the end of his studies it seemed clear to him that Brent Denson, the leader of the Protection Party, was likely to win the next Presidential elections. He wanted to be on the right side of the Protection when that happened. Already the Protectioners had won many important seats in Parliament, and the effects of this were being felt throughout the Republic. At the turn of the century the new Republic had been proclaimed and the northern part of the country had seceded. The southern states which formed the Republic had been plunged into an unprecedented deep economic depression for many industries were closed down and moved elsewhere. Thousands of inhabitants of the Republic, most of them of nonAnglo-Saxon background, had left and moved to other countries in search of work and better living. The rate of unemployment hit an all-time high, prices were getting much too high, and the crime rate soared. The consequent atmosphere of despair in the Republic led most of the remaining population to seek escape from the realities of daily life in all sorts of amusements, drug-induced euphorias, and electronic fantasies. The government, having an agenda of its own, was only too happy to provide the funding to make it easier for people to indulge in escapism—it stopped them asking questions. 18
Sonata for Flute
Amid the growing gloom of the late Tens and early Twenties the Protection Party came to the fore. Since they had managed to achieve ownership of most of the media, their teachings, as well as Brent Denson's own peculiar version of conservatism, suffused all of the Republic. The majority of the population lived from one Fantasy Dream to the next and refused to consider the future. They yearned only for peace, security, and safety at any price, and thus they greeted the policies of the Protectioners enthusiastically. The stage was well set for Brent Denson to appear offering hope with his "Glory to the Nation" and "Back to Basics" platforms in his campaign for the Presidency. Denson was a pragmatist who was able to gauge accurately the public's frame of mind. To serve his own ends, he offered them what they thought they wanted. Very few people in the Republic had ever heard of the Roman Empire and the history of its fall. During those years when thinking was an unpopular occupation it was very easy to convince the people that it was high time books were done away with. Books used up far too many resources to produce and were too difficult to store and keep in good condition. Video-CDs and Fantasy Dreamers were aggressively promoted as a much more comfortable and civilised alternative to books. From every angle the public was told that the government and the increaasingly powerful Protection Party were "leading the way for the world's march towards a brighter and better future". Only a handful of people outside the government were aware that the rest of the world was not in fact following this path, and only they and the government knew that it was far easier to control the content of CD's than that of books. Generous bonuses in kind—that is, in Video-CDs—were offered to all who handed their books in at their local Ministry of Information office. The occasional warnings from those few who realized the dangers went unheeded by a population devoted to self-fulfillment and seduced by several decades of "free" gifts. In the nineties the socio-political catchcry had been "Political Correctness". In the late tens it became "Straight Thinking." Anyone who didn't fit in with the prevalent attitude of conformity was viewed with suspicion. Thousands of "Crooked Thinkers" fled the Republic when they found the majority of the population turning, sometimes violently, against them. People saw these "Crooked Thinkers" as threats to society because they refused to believe in the dangers of absolute values, or to recognise the superiority of women, or to uphold the Republic without reservations. Although Carl's professors and advisers in the Welfare Ministry Training College were puzzled by his lack of social life, they found him to be a trouble-free, obedient, and enthusiastic student. When he graduated they recommended him to the Ministry hierarchy as one of their best Straight Thinkers, and on the strength of this he was immediately granted a position as one of the Welfare Ministry's elite Welfare Officers. Strangely enough, no-one seemed unduly worried by the fact that he apparently did not to apply "Straight Thinking" to his own lifestyle. Perhaps they felt that it was
19
Sonata for Flute
his own problem as long as it didn't affect anyone else and as long as he carried out the duties of his job properly. A major part of his work as Welfare Officer involved searching out and "taking into care" to the Ministry the school-age children of parents identified as Rebels. He would turn up at their home with a Police Officer and a warrant and take the children away. The devastated parents had no idea where their children were taken—they simply disappeared. Carl himself didn't know what happened to the children. He assumed that they were put into state children's homes. He had tried to find out once, but had quickly discovered it wouldn't do to ask questions about areas which were not his responsibility. He had arrived back at the Welfare Ministry with yet another group of children, two small girls and their brother, who had been removed from their parents' custody. Another Welfare Officer met him to take charge of the children when he arrived back at the Ministry. "These are the Walker children," he told her, "The boy is six, the girls are five and seven. Their parents are Rebels and they have been warned to cease their antisocial activities. They were also told the procedure for getting their children back should they change their lifestyle." He looked down at the frightened children beside him and smiled at them. "Officer Bryson will look after you," he said, speaking softly to try and re-assure them. "I'll take over now," the woman replied, "Come this way, children. Officer Slade, please fill in the log as usual, won't you?" She started to lead the children away, but Carl started to follow her. "Just a minute, please, Officer Bryson," he called, "Could I have a word with you?" She stopped and looked back at him, frowning. "What is it?" "Uh, I just wanted to ask you," he said cautiously, "Where are you taking the children?" Bryson stared at him coldly. "Officer Slade," she said warningly, "Please fill in the log." "I just wanted to know where the children go from here," Carl said quietly. "Have you forgotten how to switch on the compufiler, Officer?" Bryson asked sarcastically, and loudly, "Here, let me show you. Children, stay where you are for a minute." She went over to the desk and studied the compufiler. The children huddled together and followed her with their eyes. Carl leant over the desk to see what she was doing. Bryson switched on the compufiler and beckoned him closer. "You're an idiot, Slade," she whispered, "Don't you value your position? Mind your own business." Out loud, she added, "There you are, will you remember next time?" "Uh, yes, I expect so," Carl replied uncertainly as he straightened up. Bryson went back to the children and shepherded them briskly down the hall and through a doorway. Carl watched them until the door slid shut behind them, wondering why he wasn't allowed to know what would 20
Sonata for Flute
happen to the children. Slowly he turned back to the compufiler, tapped in the information for the log, and switched the machine off. Carl was angry at himself for his imprudence. He would have to be more careful and try not be curious. Questions were dangerous—"why" questions most of all, but any questions that were not part of one's actual duties. He knew that—it had been drilled into him for years now. Now and then, however, he forgot, and he was lucky that so far he hadn't actually got into trouble because of these lapses. I must remember to keep my thoughts to myself, he thought, Better yet, I should try not to think at all. It would be terrible to be seen as a non-conformist. The Protection Party was against "Crooked Thinkers", as they called nonconformists. In particular they were against the group of people who had become variously known as the Rebels, the Secret Ones, or the Subversives. The Rebels believed that there was such a thing as Absolute Truth, but in this new society there was no room for that kind of thinking. Absolute Truth was a concept that was out of date, divisive, and dangerous. Carl's knowledge of the Rebel teachings was practically non-existent, but he was vehemently at enmity with them on principle, for he had been taught over and over that they were the worst enemies of the Republic. They refused to bow to the policies of either the government or the Protectioners and that could not be allowed. It was even suggested that they were mentally unstable and should all be taken into care. However, the Rebels were the ones who did all the menial work, so the government was reluctant to follow such a course of action. They did increase the ranks of the Police Force in order, they said, to protect the general population from possible attacks by the Rebels. The Protectioners were instrumental in establishing the Neighbour Watchers movement. They promoted it as a vast improvement on the old "neighbourhood watch" programmes so popular in the West in the eighties and nineties. With the building up of the Police Force and the faithful reporting by the Neighbour Watchers representatives there was a marked decrease in crime all over the Republic within months. This was greeted with great pleasure and relief by a population that had become terrorised by criminals of all sorts. They overlooked that under the new political guidelines the definition of the word crime had become relative. One could never know now when a particular activity might be considered a crime by the Police Force. A key part of the programme of the Enwuh—as the Neighbour Watchers were popularly called—was the forbidding of meetings in homes. Parties and celebrations had to have official permission from the local Enwuh chapter—with strict control over number and names of guests and an Enwuh representative attending. For this reason, and also because of the effort and expense involved, by the mid-tens parties in private homes became rather rare. When Denson came to power a nightly curfew was imposed. It was strictly patrolled by Enwuh reps with the help of sophisticated electronic equipment. 21
Sonata for Flute
The prohibition of meetings, the curfew, and the patrols served to discourage any gatherings in private homes after sunset, and certainly made it difficult for the Rebels to gather in groups. And yet, although it took much ingenuity for them to get together without being discovered by the authorities, get together they did. It was one of the frustrations the Protectioners seemed unable to get rid of. By the time Brent Denson won the Presidential election in 2026, his mechanisms for full control of the population were already in place. Even a fully electrified Border Fence along the inland border had been built with almost complete ignorance of it on the part of the population. It had been easy enough to describe the work as "upgrading and repairing of the existing fence". There were a few people who realized what was going on and tried to sound the alarm. Not only were they dismissed as paranoid nut-cases by the media and the people, but they were quickly tracked down by the Enwuh and "taken into care". On the day following Denson's victory his troops appeared as if out of nowhere, the Protectorate was declared with much fanfare and fireworks, and a special ceremony was held closing the borders, ports, and airports of the Protectorate to the "nefarious and inimical influences of outsiders who would presume to rob our nation of its glory." The people, immersed in the thick fog of their over-entertained minds, cheered. The foreign diplomats who were still in the country left en masse. One of the first moves of Denson's government was to close down all religious buildings, of which there were very few left as it was. Churches, mosques and temples of most religions had closed down following the exodus in the 2010s of the followers of those religions. Increasingly violent xenophobia had made life intolerable for most of these people and they found a welcome in the North that was denied them in the South. Their temples and other buildings had also become too expensive as the Republican government had imposed heavier and heavier taxes on all religious property. The northern states which had seceded from the Republic had at first remained independent, but after two years, by majority approval in a referendum, they had become a province of the country to the north, Kawanyama, to the amazement of the world community. After 2026, the Kawanyaman government tried to apply pressure on the Protectorate to reopen its borders but as no other nation was willing to be partner to these moves they decided in the end that instead they would simply continue to offer asylum to the few people who still managed to escape from the Protectorate. Thereafter the Protectorate was essentially ignored by the rest of the world, at least on the surface. A few years after 2026, however, a handful of individuals formed an underground movement with members in both Kawanyama and the Protectorate and secret support from a dozen other nations. Most of the members of the Underground in the Protectorate were Rebels, and their main aim was to liberate that country, not only from the Protectioners' grasp, but especially from the grasp of the endless entertainment and fear 22
Sonata for Flute
which dulled the people's thinking. It was a sore point with Denson and his government that so far they had been unable to trace the whereabouts of the Underground. Despite all the resources they were putting into their campaign against the new group they were even unable to break the code they used in their radio communications. Five years into the Protectorate, the Police Counselling Institute was established. Its purpose was to deal with the growing problem of Crooked Thinking among the population. Because of his excellent record as a Welfare Officer, Carl was offered a position as one of five Head Counsellors by the Chief of the Counselling Institute, Ross Lancaster. Of course, Carl realized that he didn't really have the choice of rejecting the offer, for that would be seen as suspicious. Besides, it was quite a promotion and included lodgings, board, and a car. A Police Counsellor was considered a high official in the government of the Protectorate. Carl never questioned what his work would entail. He had been told that the main aim of the Institute was to persuade non-conformists to wholeheartedly embrace the Protection philosophy, and this was a goal he was happy to agree to. That he himself might be a non-conformist didn’t even cross his mind.
23
Chapter 3 Welfare Officers whose duty it was to rescue children from the homes of Rebels were always accompanied by a Police Officer in case the children's parents gave any trouble. Occasionally a Police Officer had to intervene when a distressed parent attacked the Welfare Officer, but in general the removal of children went ahead without any aggression on the part of the parents. At first Carl had been assigned a male Police Officer, a Black man by the name of Andrew Parker. The Police Escort roster was changed regularly, however, and in the next duty list Carl saw that Officer Cecilia Janssen was to be his Police Escort. Carl was not pleased about Janssen's being assigned to accompany him, and not only because Lieutenant Parker and he had become friends. He'd had one or two encounters with Janssen when she had first arrived at the Ministry and she frightened him. He had the impression—not mistakenly— that Cecilia Janssen very willingly subscribed to the Protectioners’ teachings on relationships between men and women and that she viewed every man she had dealings with as a potential bedmate. The first time he had come across her, at a Ministry get-together, he had found to his disquiet that he couldn't keep his eyes off her. Since the wearing of uniforms had been optional for this function, she had chosen to wear her most revealing evening wear, a flowing violet silk dress with a sleeveless bodice and a floor-length skirt split thigh-high in several places so that her legs were visible no matter how she stood. Although Carl hadn't been the only man there whose eyes kept straying to her corner of the room, Janssen had soon become aware of Carl's fascination, and she had decided that she fancied him. She had encouraged his interest by making sure that she was always—and enticingly so—within his field of vision during the whole gathering. She had kept an eye on him so that every time she had noticed him looking her way she had smiled at him. He'd had difficulty concentrating on conversations with others and had kept finding his mind wandering back to the subject of Cecilia Janssen's attractions. He had even found himself agreeing with the other men that Janssen was too attractive to be a Police Officer and should instead have been acting in Fantasy Dream productions. Halfway through the evening the Minister for Welfare had made a speech and everyone had stood still to listen to him. Janssen had sidled over to stand next to Carl and he had found it almost beyond his strength to avoid touching her. The perfume she had been wearing had overwhelmed him and had emphasised her presence. On top of that, she had kept brushing his hand with hers and several times she had moved so that she was actually leaning against him. The only thing that had prevented Carl from giving in to what his whole body was screaming for had been the memory of his stand against sex outside marriage. Even after all the years of indoctrination he still believed his idea was right. Cecilia Janssen's 24
Sonata for Flute
behaviour had made him begin to waver in his conviction, however. She was attractive and she knew it. She had chosen to pay attention to him rather than to any of the other men and it was difficult for him not to feel flattered. Although he had been mildly disappointed, relief had been his strongest feeling when at one point Janssen had needed to leave the room briefly. It had given him time to collect himself and renew his resolve to wait and control himself until he found the woman he wanted to marry. One thing he was quite certain about was that Cecilia Janssen was not that woman. When, at the end of the evening, Janssen had started to make her way towards him again, her intentions fully spelt out by the way she moved and looked at him, he had forced himself to turn around and walk hurriedly out of the room. As soon as he had reached the hallway he had fled outside to his car and had driven home as fast as he could, his whole body urging him go back and succumb to Janssen while his heart revolted at the whole idea. There had been other occasions when Cecilia Janssen had tried to seduce him, and more than once she had almost succeeded. Each time, the struggle between his heart and his body had worn him out, and he did not relish having anything to do with her—he had no idea how long he would be able to hold out against her spell. When Carl had seen on the duty list that Janssen was to be his Police Escort, his first reaction was to head for the Personnel Manager's office to submit an Assignment Objection form. He caught himself before he got there, however. What reason could he possibly give—sexual attraction?! Unfortunately, he realized that he couldn't very well submit an Objection to the Ministry for that sort of reason—after all, they would expect him, as a “Straight Thinker”, not to be bothered by such a thing but rather to welcome it. The Ministry was more likely to side with Janssen than with him if he objected to her. Besides being an attractive woman, Cecilia Janssen was ambitious, and she never worried about who she had to get out of her way in order to achieve her ambitions. She had set her sights on power, and one of her aims was to have power over men who had power. On the way she intended to enjoy having power over any other man she wanted, even if only for one night. Cecilia Janssen acted on only one principle—her own advancement. She was an almost fanatical follower of the Protection Party and had joined the Police Force when the Protectorate was barely one month old. They had been glad to have her for she had come with highest recommendations from the Party as a zealous upholder of their policies. Although she was not very tall, Janssen was physically strong and fit, the legacy of a childhood and adolescence spent in gymnastics and athletics. She was just tall enough to meet the requirements of the Police Force recruiters, who had noted with satisfaction that she followed the accepted fashions in clothing and hairstyle. Her wavy black hair, though it covered her ears, was trimmed quite short apart from a fringe which covered her forehead almost to her narrow eyebrows and made her small, upturned nose look more prominent than it actually was. Her small mouth had full 25
Sonata for Flute
lips made startling by the use of violet lipstick which matched the colour of her fingernails. It would have made her skin look too white in comparison, had it not been for the artificial tan that she got touched up regularly. Her dark brown, almost black, eyes were never still, and the recruiters found that she missed very little of what was happening around her. She usually dressed in the kind of coloured tights and body-hugging thigh-length sleeveless vests which most women wore, and had been a little dismayed to find that the uniform she would be wearing did not display her figure to advantage. She soon worked out how to overcome this drawback, however, for she knew how to catch a man's attention. One of the points both for and against her when she had joined the Police Force had been her fierce stubbornness. When Cecilia Janssen wanted something, she did not give up until she had it. When she bore a grudge, she bore it with a vengeance. On the other hand, when she was given an assignment, she carried it out all the way, and sometimes even too far. Her instructors had noted in her file that she was to be handled with care. As a newly-commissioned Police Officer she was sent to the Welfare Ministry as one of the Police Escorts for Welfare Officers. It was in this capacity that she was assigned to accompany Welfare Officer Carl Slade. But Officer Slade did not want her accompanying him. If only he could find a valid reason for filing an Assigment Objection! It was Janssen herself, however, who provided Carl with a valid reason, and she did so on her first shift as his Police Escort. When he came out of the Ministry building that morning she was already waiting for him, lounging against his Ministry car, and she smiled alluringly as he reached the vehicle. He did not smile back but nodded curtly to her, trying to avoid looking at her, and especially at her eyes, as he unlocked the car. As soon as he had caught sight of her the fight in himself had started, and conflicting thoughts about being in her company were wreaking havoc in his mind. He felt almost as if he were two people— one wanting to run away from this woman as fast as possible, the other trying to think of a way to be alone with her somewhere. He suddenly remembered that Freeway Rest Areas offered Pleasure Rooms for the use of those who needed a break from driving. No! he reminded himself, Pleasure Rooms, Pleasure Houses, and Fantasy Dreamers are all out of bounds when one is on duty! He was dismayed to realize that he had to be blushing, for his face felt hot. "Good morning, Officer Janssen," he said abruptly, trying to hide his disquiet, "We're to pick up four children in one of the far southern suburbs today." "Good morning, Carl," she answered languidly, drawing his name out to two syllables, "That's quite a long drive, isn't it?" Carl winced. She’s already taking liberties, using my first name, and like that, too, he thought, I’d better put a stop to it right away. Don't look at her, don't even appear interested, he said to himself. It was all he could do to keep his head from turning to look at Janssen, but he was aware of her every move from the corner of his eye. How does she manage to be so 26
Sonata for Flute
seductive in a Police uniform? he asked himself, None of the other women Officers are like that! "You're to call me Officer Slade," he said testily, "Yes, it's a long drive, so get in and let's go!" "Yes, Carl," Janssen purred in reply to his order, smiling sweetly. Her audacity made him bristle, especially as he was struggling with an urge to flirt back which made him angry at himself. He clenched his teeth and made no comment, but got into the driver's seat, slammed his door, and started the engine. Janssen climbed in hurriedly and pulled her door closed just as the car started moving. Carl drove out towards the Southern Freeway. He forced himself to keep his eyes on the road and on the traffic and tried to think of the job ahead, but he felt uneasy about Janssen, for he was conscious that she kept eyeing him furtively. His misgivings were fully confirmed when they got to the Freeway. He drove into the stream of traffic, set the car on "cruise", and typed the exit number into the computer. Although the traffic was light and the car was steering itself, he gripped the steering wheel with both hands and watched the other cars, wishing all the time that he were somewhere else, far away from Cecilia Janssen, and free from this awful battle with himself. "You're not very talkative, are you, Carl?" Janssen said suddenly in a husky voice. "My name is Officer Slade," Carl said grimly. Out of the corner of his eye he saw Janssen stretch and smile widely to herself. He hastily pushed down a sudden urge to stop the car and take her in his arms. This is madness, he thought, Why on earth is this woman having this effect on me? In the next instant Janssen did two things which almost caused an accident. "Let's stop for a bit at that rest area that's coming up," she said silkily, pointing at a sign they were passing, "There's no rush to get those brats, after all. We could have a good time, you and I." As she spoke she leant over and took hold of the steering wheel with her left hand, pulling it around slightly, and at the same time she placed her right hand on Carl’s thigh. He was so startled that he wrenched the steering wheel over hard to the right, overriding the cruise command and causing the car to swerve violently into the next lane. It narrowly missed another car which had just overtaken them. His heart beating from fright like a pile-driver gone wild, he hastily switched off the cruise command, slowed the car down, and steered it back into its own lane. Then he drove onto the shoulder and stopped. He turned to Janssen, his face livid with rage. "Keep your hands to yourself, Officer!" he exploded, "You could have got us killed!" Janssen was pale, for the near miss had given her quite a fright too, but she was also vexed by Carl's continued refusal of her advances. She scowled. "Why didn't you just pull into the rest area, like I said?” she said sullenly, “There’s a Pleasure Room there. We could have had a bit of fun, the two of us. Collecting brats is such a dull job." 27
Sonata for Flute
To his astonishment the suggestion actually made him feel sick now, and he stared at her with a mixture of anger and incredulity. Finally he sat back in his seat and started up the car. "Your career in the Police Force won't last long with that kind of behaviour, Officer," he said harshly, “Pleasure Rooms are off-limits during duty hours and you know it. Even suggesting their use is reportable.” "Is that a threat?" Janssen spat. Carl kept his eyes on the oncoming traffic. "A self-imposed one, Officer," he answered levelly, “You're the one who made the suggestion.” He eased the car back onto the Freeway and continued towards the southern suburbs. This time he didn't reset the cruise command, and he concentrated on driving. He didn't even glance once at Janssen the rest of the way, but he was aware that she was sulking and fuming to herself. As he drove he puzzled over his sudden discovery that she was no longer attractive to him. He wasn't quite sure how it had happened, but her spell was broken and the battle between his body and his heart was over. This impression was underlined by her behaviour at their destination. From the moment they arrived, Janssen seemed bent on verbally, and almost physically, abusing the parents of the children they had come to pick up. He ordered her to go back to the car while he dealt with them, but she ignored him and was as unpleasant as possible. To his disgust she seemed to take delight in the tears and stricken faces of the parents and children. As far as Carl was concerned, his job was that of getting children out of what he understod were potentially harmful home situations, but he had no particular ill-feelings towards the parents he dealt with and always treated them courteously, if firmly. Taking the children away was just part of his work. He liked children, and he always tried to be gentle with the children he had to take from their families, although with some of them he found his patience wore thin very quickly. Janssen's attitude was another matter—she treated the parents like dirt and was quite rough with the children. She had been frustrated and she was taking it out on them. The worst part of it, as far as Carl was concerned, was that she was apparently enjoying abusing them. Thus she had now provided Carl with two definitely acceptable reasons for submitting an official Assignment Objection, and he proceeded to do just that as soon as he returned to the Ministry. On the form he indicated that Janssen had breached rules by suggesting using a Pleasure Room during duty hours, and she had attempted to soil the good name of the Protection Party by her behaviour on the job. His Objection was granted and Janssen was re-assigned to a different role in the Police Force. This was a slight to her pride which she was not prepared to forgive. She already had a long mental list of people whom she did not intend to forgive, and now she added Carl Slade to the list. She would work against him as long as necessary. No man who refused her attentions could consider himself or his career safe from then on if she had anything to say about it, especially if he then went and spoiled her record 28
Sonata for Flute
with accusations! She now hated Carl both for refusing her and for the black mark on her work file. Janssen now turned most of her efforts to the pursuit of Ross Lancaster, an up-and-coming favourite disciple of President Brent Denson. The fact that Lancaster was married didn't matter to her, and from what she knew about the man it didn't matter much to him either. As far as either of them was concerned, Myra Lancaster was not even in the way. Lancaster had begun to notice Janssen and her interest in him, for he was growing tired of his latest mistress. He decided at last that not only could she be very useful to him, as a member of the Police Force, but she could provide him with some the extra services which she seemed actually to be offering him. When President Denson appointed him Chief of the Police Counselling Institute he offered Janssen the position of Head Carer of the Women's Residential Facility in return for those services. He had observed a certain sadistic streak in her and felt this was appropriate for the job. The position was quite a promotion from her current one, and becoming Lancaster's mistress provided her with the kind of hold on him that she wanted—or so she thought. Ross Lancaster had been a Protectioner almost from the cradle. He had still been a preschooler—in a very progressively thinking establishment— when the Party had first inoculated him against anything that might carry absolute truth. Throughout his schooling and his University studies—in Politics and Management—he had never wavered in his zeal for the cause of self-advancement. The policies of the Protectioners suited him very well for they allowed him to be ruthless in his pursuit of power and wealth, with impunity. His marriage to Myra Strathmore had been one of mutual convenience—he needed her father’s inheritance and she needed his connections. They had had only one child, stricken with anencephaly, and she had lived only a few hours. From then on the very idea of any sort of handicap, physical or mental, made Ross Lancaster throw up. He became one of the most vocal supporters in Brent Denson’s campaign for “Healthy minds in Healthy bodies” which was eventually to lead to enforced euthanasia of the handicapped in the Protectorate. Although he was above average in height, Lancaster was also heavily built. He thought of himself as handsome and carried himself with an air of importance. His face was on the pudgy side, his small grey eyes looking mockingly out at the world from under thick black eyebrows. He had a large nose which tended to turn red in cold weather, much to his dismay. His mouth was small and looked even smaller than its real size because of his tendency to purse his lips in disdain, and because he seldom smiled except sideways. He was very proud of his thick black hair although he deemed it prudent to keep it always trimmed to a crew cut. One day he would be the one setting the fashions, he reminded himself. Both Lancaster and Janssen were under the impression that by pairing up they had achieved a small victory towards their ultimate goals. In addition, in her new job Janssen saw an opportunity to get back at Carl Slade who was now a Counsellor at the Institute. She decided to aim at 29
Sonata for Flute
turning Lancaster against Slade by carefully manipulating who was assigned to him for counselling. It might take two or three years or more to destroy Counsellor Slade's career—maybe even his sanity—but she was quite prepared to take her time about it. She intended to enjoy herself as she did this little by little. At the same time, however, she was not about to give up trying to get him to surrender to her charms. What Janssen didn't realize, though she could have guessed it had she tried, was that Ross Lancaster was at least as unscrupulous as she was. His goal was nothing less than the Presidency, and he considered that by having got into Denson's good books he was halfway there. Slowly but surely, he planned to worm his way into Denson's place. Taking Janssen as his mistress would help him towards his goal. She could get information for him in many ways—he didn't mind sharing her around—but he would happily get rid of her when her usefulness ran out or he tired of her. He had the upper hand there—he was her boss. President Denson had no inkling that his favourite disciple was plotting against him, but perhaps that didn't matter because he trusted no-one, not even Lancaster. Denson was a charismatic but ruthless man. He had celebrated his fiftieth birthday on the same day he had proclaimed both his victory at the polls and the founding of the Protectorate. Physically he was unremarkable, with thinning grey hair and a sallow face covered in age spots and showing many scars from the removal of skin cancers. Nevertheless, he had quite a large following of both women and men whose interest in him was definitely not political and whom he indulged when he felt like it—but only when he felt like it. He aimed to keep his aides very busy, and giving Lancaster the honour of the directorship of the Police Counselling Institute was a way of making sure he had no time for mischief. In his palace in the capital or wherever else he went, Denson surrounded himself with bodyguards day and night because, like all tyrants, he was afraid.
30
Chapter 4 Police Lieutenant Andrew Parker arrived home to be greeted enthusiastically by his two children, Christopher and Elsie. They were waiting for him at the top of the stairs to their floor and, as usual, they were full of the news of their day. Andrew was thankful that his family did not have one of those Fantasy Dreamers that dulled the minds of so many of the people he knew and denied their children the joys of discovering the wonders around them. He loved to sit down with his wife and children after his day at work and hear about their day. This time was all the more precious to him these days, for he was finding his own job at the Counselling Institute increasingly depressing. Denise, his wife of almost ten years, greeted him with a hug at the door to their flat and the two of them walked arm in arm into the apartment. The children followed, skipping into the hallway and shutting the door behind them. They all went straight to the kitchen, where Andrew hung his jacket and cap on the back of a chair and sat down with his family to have a cup of tea. This was their ritual of every afternoon, a time to which all of them looked forwards and with which almost nothing else could interfere. Even when Andrew brought a friend home, the visitor joined them at the kitchen table and was welcome to contribute to the family news time. Andrew was always very careful about who he brought home. The Parkers’ kitchen was very small, like all the kitchens in their block of flats. Unlike most of the other kitchens in the building, however, it was a room full of warmth and life because of its owners. A counter-top with cupboards and drawers under it ran along three walls, interrupted below the window by a sink and halfway along the wall to the left by an upright stove. Denise had chosen the buttercup-coloured furnishings and warm yellow and white tiles back in the days before she and Andrew had met, when she was studying at the University of the Republic and working as a shop assistant. The window, with white daisy-sprinkled yellow curtains on either side, looked out over the centre of Densonia towards the telecommunications tower and satellite dishes on Lakeside Hill. Although on this particular day it was raining, whenever the day was fine the kitchen at this time of the afternoon would be bright with the light of the westering sun, which suffused the room with a warm golden glow. Andrew often said, with a twinkle in his eyes, that it was afternoon tea in Denise's kitchen that had won his heart to her. On the end of the counter to the right, near the doorway, stood a collection of jars and plastic containers which held plants and seeds at various stages of growth as well as an assortment of small creatures such as grasshoppers and minnows. This was the children’s end of the counter, where they observed their tiny menagerie, followed the development of beanplants and carrot stalks, and rolled out interestingly shaped objects 31
Sonata for Flute
from coloured flourdough which Denise prepared for them. Denise knew of no other children who did such things. From what her pupils had told her, when they were not at school they sat in Fantasy Dreamers at home or at one of the many arcades throughout the city. The tiny kitchen, with just enough floor space to allow one to walk around the table, was a special room. But that went for all four rooms in the Parker flat. Even the bathroom, a tiny space with sink, shower stall, and toilet so crowded together there was hardly any floor between them, was a special spot, for that was where Denise did their washing. As she scrubbed their clothing early in the morning before going to work she did a great deal of her singing, very softly, and Andrew and the children would often sit in the hallway outside the bathroom to finish their breakfast, just so they could listen to her. Sometimes they joined in. The Protectorate had been declared very shortly after Andrew and Denise were married, and soon after the new government took over, the housing market was frozen and people who had been in the process of selling or buying a house found that they had to move into whatever housing the government assigned to them. The Parkers were very glad that they had decided to make Denise's flat their home rather than look for a house. Andrew’s job with the Police Force did not cover even their everyday expenses, and anyway the Protectioners required all able-bodied women to work outside the home, so Denise had applied for a teaching position at one of the primary schools. When Chris and Elsie had started school she had hoped they could go to the one where she taught. It was government policy, however, that school-age children were not to be near their parents during school hours, so Chris and Elsie were sent to the nearby Primary School Number Six while their mother worked at School Number Five in the next suburb. She was thankful that Chris and Elsie were at home in the evenings and on Wednesdays. Denise brought the teapot and matching cups, one of their few remaining wedding presents, to the table. She had already poured out some milk for the children, who had also sat down at the table and were chatting happily with their father. As Denise poured tea into their cups, Andrew turned his attention to her. "How were your pupils today, Denise?" he asked. "They were quite a handful," she answered, handing him his cup, "They could hardly stay still for two seconds, all day. I thought perhaps there might be a thunderstorm brewing, but so far all we've had is a downpour without the fireworks!" "Did you two have trouble keeping still at school, too?" Andrew asked Chris and Elsie with a grin. "We didn't have to," six-year-old Elsie answered cheerfully, and bounced up and down as if to illustrate her answer, “but we had to listen, and write, and read our lessons, and—" "We had to stand up in class assembly!" interrupted her brother with eight-year-old importance, "because Billy Anderson said his grandfather had disappeared and boy was he glad about it, because his grandfather was 32
Sonata for Flute
a pain, always talking that religious stuff, and our teacher said we should stand up to cheer Billy." Andrew looked at Denise and frowned. "Isn't Billy's grandfather the elderly man who lives with the Mercers?" he asked. She nodded and her pretty, dark brown face turned very serious. "Yes," she said quietly, "That’s him, Chester Brown. They took him to the Institute this morning." Andrew caught his breath and stared at the wall for a moment. Then he shook himself, sat back on his chair, and looked puzzled. “Must’ve been while I was in the Monitoring Centre,” he muttered, "Usually I’m one of the Officers they send out to pick up counsellees during the day.” He shrugged helplessly. “I suppose we shouldn't be surprised that he was taken into care, though—he was one of the more vocal of the Rebels. In a way I'm surprised they waited this long. You'd have thought they'd want to try to reform him in time to get him into one of the retirement communities..." Denise, glancing at the children, decided to change the subject. The less they heard the less they could say at school, by accident or otherwise. She got up and took a bag of potatoes out of a cupboard. She put a few potatoes in the sink and started scrubbing them. "Were you on the monitoring roster again today?" she asked Andrew. "No, but I had to report to the MC,” he replied wryly, “I start on the new roster tomorrow. Carl gets a new counsellee and I get the joy of monitoring his sessions..." "Is that Uncle Carl, Daddy?" Christopher asked. His question reminded Andrew the children were still in the room. "Yes, Chris," he replied, and turned to them. "Now, Chris, Elsie, I want you to go to the lounge and play by yourselves for a bit,” he said, “I want to talk with Mummy." “Okay, Daddy,” Christopher said. He got up and took his sister by the hand. "C'mon, let's go to the lounge," he said. The two children skipped out of the kitchen and their parents could hear them laughing together as they went down the hallway. Andrew got up and joined his wife at the counter by the window. He gazed down through the rain at the traffic on the Northern Freeway for a moment, then sighed and started helping Denise to prepare the evening meal by peeling the potatoes. “You’ve got something on your mind, Andrew,” Denise said, “What’s the problem? Is it Chester Brown?” "That's a worry, yes, but it's not what's really bugging me, Denise," he replied, "I'm worried about Carl. You know how he's highly strung at the best of times, but lately he's been on a short fuse so much of the time that I'm afraid one of these days he'll do something stupid." “Something stupid?” “Say something he shouldn’t. Lose his temper with the wrong person. Have a breakdown or worse. I don’t know, but whatever, it would be stupid for it to happen.” "Do you have any idea what’s troubling him?" 33
Sonata for Flute
"I'm thinking that he's having doubts..." "Doubts? About his counselling work, do you mean?" "No, more fundamental than that. About the whole reason for the Counselling Institute's existing at all." "Oh, about the Protection teachings, you mean." "Yes." Andrew's handsome dark face was very sober. "If I'm right, he's in a very dangerous spot. You know how Chief Lancaster reacts to those who don't toe the line, don’t you, especially if they work at the Institute... And I’d say Carl hasn’t been very good lately at toeing Lancaster’s line." "You've known Carl some ten years, haven’t you?" Denise asked. "Almost ten years, that's right," he answered, "ever since I was assigned to work as his Police Escort when he worked in the Welfare Ministry. That was just before the start of the Protectorate, if you remember, not long after we got married." "Yes, I remember. Has he ever been in this sort of state before? Since you've known him?" "Nothing as bad as this. Oh, he's had plenty of down times, as you know. When he starts to think deeply he tends to get rather morose, but this is different somehow. And again, his temper's always been very short, but lately he seems to be intent on making a storm in every teacup he encounters. He has been thinking too much, probably. It’s dangerous." Denise was pensive for a moment. "Do you think perhaps we should have that talk with him?" she asked finally. Andrew leant on the counter and gazed out of the window towards the hill. "Mmmm... No, probably not at this stage," he said slowly, "I don't think he's ready for that. But he's going to be starting this new round of counselling tomorrow and I'm worried the stress is going to be too much, especially if he gets assigned someone difficult. He had a bad enough time with the last counsellee. It’s quite likely, for example, that Lancaster would assign Chester Brown to him, and I think that old man could be quite a challenge." He finished peeling the potatoes, handed them to Denise, and washed his hands at the sink. "Do you think I'd be asking too much of you if I suddenly decided to ask him to come and spend all his evenings with us?" he asked quietly. "Do you think that would be necessary?" she asked, “Is it really that bad?” He turned to her and sighed deeply. "Yes, I think it’s that bad,” he replied. "Look, Andrew,” Denise said firmly, “If Carl's sanity is at stake and we can prevent his going over the edge by getting him to spend most of his free time here, by all means tell him to come. He's your closest friend. You're like brothers. You'd never forgive yourself if anything happened to him because he wasn't welcome here. I'd never forgive myself, either!" "I didn't think you'd refuse," he said, "but I didn't think I should just presume, either. Thank you." He gave his wife a hug and kiss. "I think I'll take my cup to the lounge and see what the children have up their sleeves this evening." 34
Sonata for Flute
"Okay. Tea will be ready in about ten minutes." "We'll see that the table is set in time, m'lady." He bowed to her with a grin, picked up his cup of tea, and went out of the kitchen. ! ! ! Emma Winston stood in the porch shaking the rainwater off her umbrella. The downpour had started again shortly after she had set off to walk home from her job as cleaner at the local primary school. Rather than seek shelter she had continued on her way, walking through the heavy rain singing hymns. One didn't often get the chance to sing the Lord's praises out loud in the Protectorate, and Emma was not one to pass up such an opportunity. She left her umbrella and wet shoes in the porch and went inside. There was no one in the front room but she could hear her sister-in-law Rose working in the kitchen. She went through the room to the back hallway and into the bathroom where she hung up her sodden raincoat over the bath. Her shoulder-length brown hair had got wet despite the umbrella, and she towelled it and brushed it out before going to join her Rose in the kitchen. Rose, her long, straw-coloured hair in a plait wound round her head, was sitting slicing vegetables at the big, old, wooden kitchen table. She had bought the table many years ago from a farm which had been razed to make way for a new suburb. The lady who had sold it to her had told her the history of every mark on it, and as she worked on it she often thought about the people who had owned it before her. She had obviously been thinking along those lines then, for as Emma arrived she noticed Rose tracing along one of the scratches with her finger, a faraway look in her eyes. Emma reached into the pantry for her apron. “Hi, Rose,” she said cheerfully, “Was that one the cut from the knife that missed someone’s finger by a hairbreadth?” Rose laughed. "Hello, Emma,” she answered, “No, this one’s the scratch done by the two-year-old who wanted to ‘help Mummy’. Actually, I wouldn’t be surprised if he got too near his own fingers too!” She transferred a pile of carrot slices to a bowl and started working on a chunk of cabbage. “How was your work today?” she asked Emma. "Same as usual,” Emma replied, “Except that those children must have had another cooking session, so there was quite a mess to clear up in the kitchen area, and crumbs from one end of the school to the other." She grinned at Rose. "It was very satisfying to see it all clean when I finished!" "Did you get caught in the rain?” Rose asked, glancing out of the window, “Oh, of course you did—it's still raining!" Emma put the kettle on the stove and settled down to help her sister-inlaw to prepare dinner. "Yes, I did," she said, "and I got wet, but I had a lovely session of singing in the shower!" She laughed. "Thank you, Lord, for such a blessing."
35
Sonata for Flute
When Brent Denson had come to power, Emma had been living in her parents' house, not far from where Rose and her husband Jack, Emma's brother, lived. Her parents, her younger brother Mike, and Jack's twin sister Liz had gone overseas to Europe for a long holiday, visiting scattered relatives they hadn't seen for many years. Emma had stayed home as she was just finishing her nursing course and couldn't get time off. When the government had changed, she had been informed that her parents' house was being requisitioned since the owners were not in the country and would not be allowed back for they had been classified as Rebels. Another family was to live in the house and she was told she would have to leave it and move to a government-appointed flat unless the new family were willing for her to stay and board with them, which was unlikely. Rose had asked Jack if Emma might be able to live with them, and he had made the offer to his sister. Emma had accepted their invitation very happily. Her nephews and niece would have been delighted to know that their Auntie Emma would be living with their family, for they had always enjoyed it when she came to stay with them. It took Emma some time after she moved in to get used to their not being around, even though she remembered the day a few months before when they had been taken away by the Welfare Ministry. For almost ten years now, Jack and Rose’s home had also been Emma’s home. Every day for almost ten years she had been cleaning the local school and Rose had been cleaning at the City Hospital. "How did your day at the hospital go, Rose?" Emma asked. Rose stopped slicing the cabbage and gazed at nothing. "It was quiet, just the usual cleaning, until just after lunch," she answered, "I was down in Casualty today. Just after lunch they brought in a man who must have been in some awful accident—he was a mess, bleeding profusely all over. There was even blood dripping off the trolley. They told me to clean up around him, and so I was able to talk to him." "You mean he was conscious?" Emma was surprised. If he had bleeding that much she would have expected him to be in deep shock. "Oh, yes, amazingly, he was conscious, and so frightened! I suppose he must have been around thirty, it was hard to tell, he was so torn up, even his face. But they just left him there, you know, no one with him in the cubicle but me. They must have decided he was going to die anyway, so put him down as low priority. It was ages before anyone got back to him." Rose paused, then said, soberly, "It was too late to save his life then, his physical life, that is..." Emma’s dark brown eyes widened in astonishment. "Was he a Christian, then?" she asked. "He wasn't when he was brought in, but when he left, I'm sure it was heaven that he went to," Rose said quietly, "And you know, Emma, I know I told him about Jesus and shared the Gospel with him, but I haven't a clue what I actually said. I can remember trying to say some words of comfort to start with, but he obviously realized he was likely to die and he was terrified—you could see it in his eyes—so I asked him if he would like me to 36
Sonata for Flute
pray for him and he nodded ever so slightly. After that, I don't know what I said. All I can remember is the look on his face and what he said before he lost consciousness. He only said one thing: "Jesus." Then he smiled, yes, he smiled, then he blacked out. He died about five minutes later. I was out of the cubicle by then. A nurse came and shooed me out, but only a few minutes after she arrived she called for an orderly to wheel him out, and the sheet was over his head." "Euthanasia?" Emma asked grimly. Rose had tears in her eyes. "Probably. She had a hypo in her hand when she went in to the cubicle," she said, "It happens all the time in Casualty." "Yeah, I know...” Emma said sadly, then exclaimed bitterly, “When I was doing my nursing training, hospitals were still for saving lives! How long has it been since that was true?" "But praise the Lord, that young man's true life is safe!" Rose reminded her. Emma went around the table to her and gave her a hug. "I'm so glad you were there, Rose!" she said, "Thank God!" Rose looked embarrassed. "Yes, thank God," she said, and got up. "Well... we'd better get on and get tea cooking," she continued, "Jack should be home soon and I expect he'll be hungry after walking all over town." "Where did he go?" "I'm not sure, but he was planning to visit some of our people." The two women continued working and talking as they worked. The food rationing system provided meager supplies for each household, and many people, the Winstons among them, grew vegetables in their tiny back yards or on their balconies to supplement what they were able to buy. Rose and Emma together had worked out many ways of stretching meals, so that even on the rare occasions when Jack brought home an unexpected guest there was enough for everyone, at least for the evening meal. “I was really pleased about the rain today,” Rose said, “It meant the garden got a decent watering for once. It needed it.” “It was wonderful to be able to sing hymns out loud, you know," Emma said softly, "I so often want to sing at the top of my voice..." She trailed off, remembering those days years ago when she used to sing out loud all the time. Mike and Liz would get tired of it and ask her to stop and give them a bit of peace and quiet for a change, while Jack, ten years her senior and very fond of his little sister, would tease them by joining in the singing with her. "Thank God for the rain this evening, then, in more ways than one!" Rose laughed. She, too, could remember the days when singing hymns was not forbidden. Emma smiled. She still felt the need to make more music. "If you don't mind,” she said to Rose, “once tea's cooking I'd like to play a few pieces while we wait for Jack." 37
Sonata for Flute
"Oh, Emma, you know I love to listen to you playing," Rose exclaimed, “Go now and play something!" Emma didn't need to be cajoled into playing the piano. "All right, then, I will," she replied. Without further ado she washed her hands at the sink and hung her apron up in the pantry, then went into the lounge to sit down at the old upright piano. The Winstons' living and dining room was not large, but it was warmly welcoming. Rose had done the best she could with the little they had to make the once drab and cheerless front room into a haven for residents and visitors alike. The original blue-grey carpet, first installed when the house had been built in the mid-20th century, still covered the floor. Though it was not a pretty colour, it was made of good-quality wool and had survived the wear of the years quite well, even after Rose had scrubbed it in order to get rid of most of the stains on it. The windows were hung with heavy lined curtains for it got quite cold in the winter in Densonia. In the Protectorate, an added benefit of the thick drapes was that they hid well the fellowship meetings that were occasionally held in the Winstons' front room. The Winstons had no lounge suite, and only one armchair. Rose had managed to cover a couple of mattresses with colourful flowered fabric and had made some cushions to match so that they had somewhere reasonably comfortable for visitors to sit. The piano had belonged to Jack and Emma's parents, who had moved it to Jack's house when they had been making renovations to their own home. They hadn't got around to taking it back before the fateful holiday overseas from which they were unable to return. Emma had often thanked God that the piano had been at Jack’s when the government took over her parents’ house and all its furnishings. Playing it was one of her joys in life. She began playing one of Schubert’s Impromptus, but was not even halfway through it when her brother came in the front door. He shut the door more brusquely than was his habit and started to remove his raincoat. Emma stopped playing and turned to look at him. He seemed quite distressed, and she got up and took the raincoat from him. “I'll hang it up for you," she said, "Whatever's the matter, Jack? You seem awfully upset." He pushed his wet hair back from his face with his hand and headed towards the kitchen. "Come over to the kitchen," he replied, "I'll tell you both at the same time." She took his raincoat into the bathroom then went into the kitchen. Jack was sitting on one of the stools at the table and Rose, looking concerned, was pouring him a cup of tea. He was drumming his fingers on the table, as he tended to do when something upset him. He looked from Rose to Emma and back to Rose. His brown eyes were troubled, his round face more serious than usual. Again he combed his hair back with his fingers. When his hair was wet it had an annoying habit of falling down in front of his eyes. "I've got some very disturbing news," he began, speaking slowly, "Chester was taken to the Counselling Institute this morning..." 38
Sonata for Flute
“Oh, no!” Rose said, her eyes widening in horror. Emma stood by the table, her hands gripping the edge, her face white. "Not Uncle Chester!” she cried, “Why? How?" Jack's fingers continued their drumming and he stared down at them as if wondering how they did it. "Apparently he was caught sharing the Gospel in the City Park with a man who turned out to be a Police Officer," he said sadly. "Oh dear," Rose said, "Do you think it was a trap?" Emma, still whitefaced, sat down abruptly and stared at Rose. "Oh, Rose," she blurted out, "Do you realize the same thing might have happened to you if you'd been caught today?" Jack turned to his wife in surprise. "Why, Rose," he said, "What happened today?" Rose quietly told him about the injured man at the hospital. "Well, praise God you were there," said Jack softly, then added, "That poor man..." "Do you think Uncle Chester was set up, Jack?" Emma asked, returning to Rose’s question. "I expect so, Em," Jack shook his head sadly, "It's the kind of thing they do, and I’m sure Chester's been under scrutiny for some time now." "Oh, we must pray for him, Jack," Rose said anxiously, "Right now!" She turned off the stove and all three sat where they were. Jack led them, and they prayed with tears in their eyes for this beloved Elder of the little group of believers of Densonia. They had some idea of what it meant to be taken to the Counselling Institute. They knew of enough people who had been broken by a stay in that place—and Uncle Chester was over seventy. When they had finished, they set the table for their evening meal together, and the three of them sat down to eat in silence, wondering if they would ever see the old man again. Chester Brown, known as "Uncle Chester" to most of the Christians in Densonia, was like a father to them and to many of the other believers. He was an encourager and a man of wisdom. They felt quite sure he would never turn his back on Jesus Christ, no matter what was done to him, but they also knew that so far, those counsellees who did not give in to the Institute treatment had never been seen again. Unlike the government people who were occasionally arrested for treason, they were never executed publicly. No one seemed to know what happened to them. Emma knew that Uncle Chester, to whom she was especially close, would not have wanted any sadness for his sake. After dinner she decided to go and play his favourite hymns and songs on the piano. As she played the songs one after the other, she was very tempted to sing them as well. She resisted the temptation, for she knew that sometimes Jack’s house was monitored. Anyone found singing religious songs risked being taken to the Counselling Institute. When they had finished clearing up in the kitchen, Rose and Jack joined Emma in the lounge. Jack brought out his Bible and they all sat down around the table for their nightly devotions. Jack read out Psalm 37 to 39
Sonata for Flute
them, and it seemed a very apt passage as they thought about Uncle Chester's situation. As they talked about it, Emma had a thought. "You know," she observed, "I think it would be a good idea if we had a Scripture verse which we could use in case one or the other of us got 'taken into care'. I mean— if we were able somehow to get a message out or something, we could use the verse as a sort of password. What do you think?" "It sounds like a good idea to me," Rose said. Jack agreed. "Do you have a particular verse in mind?" he asked. "I hadn't thought about it until just now," Emma said, "but I guess I would choose Job, chapter nineteen, verse twenty-five. It's my favourite verse, as you know: 'I know that my Redeemer lives.'" "Yes, that's a good one," Rose agreed. "All right,” Jack said, “Job nineteen, twenty-five it is—but let's hope we never have to put this idea to the test. Let's pray now.” As they did every evening, Jack, Rose, and Emma knelt down by the dining table and prayed quietly together.
40
Chapter 5 The next morning, Carl and Andrew arrived at the Counselling Institute at the same time, from opposite directions. "G'day, Carl!" Andrew greeted his friend, "I gather you've got a new counsellee today." "Morning, Andrew. Yes, that's right," Carl said, "Some old bloke who got caught preaching religion to people in the City Park." Together they crossed the carpark towards the main entrance of the Institute. "Well, it looks like I'm assigned to monitor your sessions again, so you'd better take it easy," Andrew warned him. Carl stopped, frowning. "What do you mean?" he asked defensively. Andrew patted him on the shoulder. "Watch your temper, mate," he suggested quietly. Carl scowled but didn't comment, and resumed walking towards the building. Went for a run as usual this morning," he said, changing the subject, "About sunrise. Thought I'd go alongside the lake even though it was still drizzling. Not much of a sunrise, though." "See anything interesting?" "Nothing unusual, if that's what you mean." "I know you'd notice if there were," Andrew said. He stopped at the foot of the steps leading up to the main doorway. "Hey, that reminds me—don't ask me what the connection is—how about coming and having tea with us some evening this week? Denise reminded me that it's been over a week since last time." "I'd really appreciate that. Would tomorrow night be all right?" "I'm sure that'd be fine. Be sure to bring your flute, too. We can play a few things together." "I will, thanks," Carl said, glancing at his watch, "but we'd better get to work now." He was feeling very nervous about the coming counselling sessions, and disconcertingly he was finding Andrew's solicitude annoying. The two of them went into the building and stopped at the front desk. Andrew picked up their ID cards and handed Carl his. He gave his friend a neutral nod and went off towards the Monitoring Centre. Carl took a lift to his floor. As he walked towards his office he wondered how long it would take to make this new counsellee see the light. An old man—it might be quite easy, for the fellow probably wouldn't want to miss out on his retirement. On the other hand, in his experience elderly people could be quite stubborn. He had also heard from fellow Protectioners that this particular elderly man had an unshakeable faith, and this worried him. He placed his hand on the ID panel to open his office door and walked through as it slid open. He still had half an hour before the new counsellee would be brought in. He shut his door, pulled up the blind behind his desk, and sat down on the counter-top beneath the window to contemplate the view of the City Park and the Lake.
41
Sonata for Flute
Andrew was right about his temper. How many times over the years had he tried to control it and failed? It seemed that the harder he tried, the harder he failed. These days he was losing his cool at the least little provocation, and so far nothing in Protection teaching or custom offered any lasting help. As he drank in the beauty of the view from his window, Carl wondered again, as he had been doing with ever-increasing frequency, why he found such solace in beauty, especially the beauties of nature. So few people he knew shared this attitude. Most saw it as childish and preferred to indulge in Fantasy Dreams. For Carl, his love of beauty was like something calling out to the very depths of his being. Sometimes he stood on the balcony of his flat of an evening, before curfew, gazing at the night sky and wondering how one answered such an ethereal call. Was it because his job was becoming so ugly to him that the "voice" seemed to be getting louder? It was certainly true that over the last several months he had been finding that his work was getting him down more and more. The teachings of the Protectioners, which he had accepted as his own beliefs years ago, were beginning to lose their hold on him. He was no longer convinced. The more he thought about it, the more it seemed to him that there were too many contradictions in the Protectioners' philosophy. And yet, what else was there? Even if the Protection Party doctrines left him feeling more and more empty, the thought of discarding them was frightening. As far as he knew, there was no alternative to them. This situation resulted in a dilemma for Carl. How does one convince someone else of something one no longer believes in? he asked himself, Yet there is nothing else I can believe in—I have to try again. Perhaps as I work on this old man I'll be able to see clearly again? He realized that he was afraid that he might fail again with this counsellee, not only because it would be another black mark on his record, but especially because it would increase his feelings of despair. He would have to use all the methods available if the man turned out to be obstinate. The thought of this only increased his turmoil for he was also finding that the idea of the "treatment" used on counsellees made him increasingly uncomfortable. During the five years Carl had worked in the Institute, only a complicated process of rationalisation had made it possible for him to accept the what he knew was the torturing of counsellees. Part of the process had been the constant drumming into him over the years of the idea that nonProtectioner beliefs such as Christianity were dangerous not only to the Protectorate but indeed more so to the poor souls who professed them. Thus one had to use all means available to "cure" them of this condition. Had he been required to administer the "treatment" himself, he didn't think he could have done it. He had been able to accept it because it was carried out by the Carers, the prison guards of the Institute, and his presence was not required while they did it. However, his lack of confidence in the philosophy he had once accepted as truth only served to undermine that process of rationalization. He had even gone as far as to wonder whether he 42
Sonata for Flute
shouldn't find out just exactly how the Carers "treated" the counsellees he sent them. Counsellors were discouraged from doing that, but it wasn't actually forbidden them. Perhaps he should observe this new counsellee's treatment, or at least the recordings of it? He looked at his watch and with sinking heart saw it was almost time for the counselling session. Reluctantly, he pulled down the blind, sat down at his desk, and called up Chester Brown's records on his compufiler. ! ! ! A few months after the founding of the Police Counsellng Institute Emma and Jack had been helping Rose to clear the table after a meal. Emma had taken the opportunity to ask Jack about the new Institute for she had been starting to suspect that its purpose was not quite what the public had been told. "Jack, do you know what happens to people who are taken to the Counselling Institute?" she had asked, "The ones I've seen who've come back from there seem so broken, and most of them claim they're no longer Christians. What do they do to them? What does 'counselling' involve?" "Well," Jack had answered, "It's obvious that what they call 'counselling' is not the same thing I studied when I was training for pastoring. In those days it meant giving someone advice to help them sort out a problem. Of course, in my case we were taught to seek advice in the Bible whenever we counselled anyone. But psychologists, social workers, and lots of other people who didn't believe the Bible did counselling too. The aim was usually to help people with their problems. It could go on for years, what's more." "And the aim now isn't still to help people?" Rose had asked him. "No, Rose, it isn't," Jack had replied slowly, "I think the aim, in the Protectorate, anyway, is to stamp out truth. 'Truth' to the Protectioners means Christianity and anything else—Judaism, for example, and even the few vestiges of Islam left in this country—anything else that goes contrary to the teachings of the Protection. Anything that suggests that there is such a thing as absolute Truth." "But why? Why are they so afraid of Truth?" Emma had asked. Jack had thought about this for a moment. "Why?" he said, "Em, Truth is a light, and it makes those who do wrong or who lie very uncomfortable, because it shows up the wrong they do. It also tends to wake people up. If the people of this country were allowed even a hint that there is something other than the fog and dreams they live in day to day, Brent Denson would soon find himself without a following. They're fed fictions and fantasies day and night so that they no longer have any idea of what is real and what is imagined. They think they're happy, and Denson wants them to continue thinking it. But, as you know, since you're one of them, there are a few people who are opposed to what Denson represents. The Police Counselling Institute is one of the most aggressive forms of the attack on Denson's opposition, and from what I've been able to find out, he also uses it to feed certain of his followers' megalomanic hunger. I suppose they get a kick out 43
Sonata for Flute
of having power of life and death over the people taken into so-called 'care'. But," he had hastened to add, "I gather that not everyone who works at the Institute is there because of a sadistic bent. For some, it's just their job and they've effectively killed their own consciences. Others are there because they are deathly afraid not to be. They were given a choice which was no choice at all. And one or two are there because that's where God wants them to be at this point in time." "How do you know all this?" Emma had asked. "I'm afraid I can't tell you, Em," Jack had replied, apologetically, "It could put someone else's life in jeopardy if I did. There is such a thing as information that cannot be shared." "Oh," Emma had said softly. She had paused to consider this, and not for the first time she had wondered how large a burden of unshareable information her brother carried. "I'm afraid I can't tell you," was something he said every other day, it had seemed to her. She had long admired Jack for his quiet wisdom, and for the way he willingly shared in the joys and sorrows of his flock. Her esteem for him had embraced Rose as well, for the two of them, so different in personality, were yet so much of one heart and mind in their service to others. She had longed to be as devoted to her Lord as they were. And she had often wished she could be as discreet as they were—it was difficult for her not to speak her mind when challenged. After a moment she had reminded Jack of her original question. "I still don't understand what happens to people there that can cause them to turn from God." "They torture them, Emma...." Jack had spoken as if explaining the obvious to a child. "Hadn't you thought of that possibility?" Emma had put the dishes she had just picked up back on the table and had sat down on one of the chairs. "Yes, Jack, I had, more than once," she had told him, "But I guess I kept hoping it wasn't true. I hoped fervently that it wasn't so." Tears had streamed down her cheeks. "But how can they do that? How can anyone torture another human being?" "My dear little sister," Jack had said gently, putting a hand on her shoulder, "It's only by the grace of God that you and I and Rose don't torture other people. It's part of fallen human nature and anyone could stoop that low given enough incentive—fear, or power-greed, and so on— unless they're restrained by God's mercy. Don't be surprised that it happens—just pray for the people who are involved, both the victims and the torturers. In fact, I'd say the torturers are more in need of pity than the victims—'They know not what they do'." Now Emma recalled that conversation. She had known many of the believers who had already been taken there, but none had been as old as Chester Brown. The elderly man had been taken to the Counselling Institute only the day before! The thought of Uncle Chester being tortured was horrifying. After breakfast she asked Jack if she thought it was likely that Chester would be tortured. 44
Sonata for Flute
"I expect so," Jack said soberly, "He isn't likely to give in easily, if at all." Rose was very distressed at the idea. "Would Uncle Chester survive that sort of treatment?" she asked, "He's over seventy. He's pretty fit for his age, but he's still old." "We can only pray that the Lord will sustain him through it," Jack replied, "but, you know, we can be thankful as well that patience is definitely not one of the virtues of the Protectioners and that such treatment does not keep going for long—usually a few weeks at most. In former times and other places it could go on for years..." "But what if he doesn't give in, if he stands firm, as he's likely to, what then?" Emma asked anxiously, "What will happen to him?" Jack shook his head sadly. "I don't know, Em," he said softly, "I don't know. "I only know what happens to those who do give in, and my heart aches for them." Rose looked at the clock on the wall and jumped up from her chair. "Emma, we'll be late for work!" she exclaimed, and hurriedly started to clear the table. Emma also sprang up from her chair to help her. "Rose, Em, don't worry about the table," Jack said to them, "I'll do it, you two just get to work. This is not the time to get into trouble with your jobs." Rose gave her husband a hug. "Thank you, Jack," she said, "We'll just get our things and go, then." She gathered together her raincoat and umbrella, gave Emma hers, and the two women hurried out the front door. Emma turned to Jack before she left. "Thanks, Jack, God be with you," she said, and went out, shutting the door behind her. Jack, still sitting at the table, put his head down on his arms and cried out to God for Chester Brown and for whoever would be "counselling" him. ! ! ! Carl counselled Chester Brown for five weeks. At the end of those five weeks he had to admit defeat. He had never had to cope with someone who clung so obstinately to his beliefs, or who endured so patiently the treatment meted out by the Carers. Carl had lost his temper himself, violently, so many times he had lost count. He was exhausted, and his nights were plagued by recurring nightmares. Yet the old man was always serene, his grey eyes gazing at him with such a sad expression that finally Carl couldn't bear to look at him. In the end he had handed him over to Lieutenant Parker to take to the Experimental Farm. He knew this would incur the wrath of Chief Lancaster, but there was no alternative. He made himself review all the recordings of his sessions with Chester Brown, not only the required once, but three times. He'd tried everything from just straight discussion to detailed threats of the Farm, through humiliation, beatings, and worse. As the days and then the weeks had gone by, his frustration and fear of failure had become unbearable, to the 45
Sonata for Flute
point that even playing his flute did not console him. Chester Brown had an exasperating habit of quoting from the Christians' book, the Bible, in answer to almost everything Carl said, and this had caused Carl to fly into a rage each time. Chester's words had struck a chord in his heart, something that he would rather not acknowledge, to which, in fact, he was afraid to admit. Andrew had monitored Brown's counselling sessions, and he had watched with concern the growing battle going on in his friend. He worried more than ever that Carl might be headed for a breakdown, and he tried to help him by being available as a sounding board and by making sure that Carl spent most of his evenings with him and his family. In the end he had even approached Chief Lancaster with the suggestion that Counsellor Slade be given a couple of weeks off work to recover from the sessions with Brown. Lancaster, fuming about Counsellors who sent their counsellees to the Experimental Farm, had reluctantly agreed to Parker's request, for he had other things on his mind at the time. Carl spent the two weeks taking long walks by the Lake, sleeping every afternoon, and playing his flute for hours on end, finishing each day with dinner at the Parkers' home. He felt incredibly sad, as if he were mourning for the old man. Chester Brown might have driven him to distraction with his obstinate faith, but Carl's admiration for him had increased, not decreased, over the five weeks of dealing with him, and sending him to the Experimental Farm had been a move of desperation. As he walked in the Park he thought about some of the things Brown had said, and he compared them to the philosophies he himself had lived by most of his life. Although to him Brown's beliefs didn't make sense, it occurred to him that if by some incredible chance it turned out Brown was right—a suggestion that kept springing up in his mind uninvited—then his career, both in the Welfare Ministry and in the Institute, had been worse than just a waste of time and of a great part of his life. It would essentially imply, he felt, that his whole life had been an absurdity, completely meaningless. Such a thought was unendurable and he pushed it away every time. He also wondered why, if Christianity was a form of mental illness, were government people executed practically on the spot if they converted? Surely they should be put through the counselling at the Institute in the same way as other people? Perhaps it had been found that this didn't work? Then why weren't they just given an injection to put them out of their misery as was done with other incurables? Why public execution? That was how criminals and traitors were treated. It puzzled him, but he didn't dwell on it at length. He had been trained not to question the government. Asking questions is dangerous, he reminded himself. He kept his thoughts on this to himself, not even sharing them with Andrew. A careless slip of the tongue could mean being "taken into care". Towards the end of his leave, Carl was asked by Myra Lancaster if he could get his trio together to play at a gathering she was hosting. Carl agreed to it, thinking it would do him good to get back into playing music 46
Sonata for Flute
together with Andrew and Matt. It seemed like years since the time when they had last met together, before Brown's counselling. Matt Lewis was one of the other four Head Counsellors and although in every other way he seemed to be a model "Straight Thinker" with a "Straight" lifestyle, he had one oddity—he played the violin. For the last three years he had joined with Carl and Andrew in playing as a trio. Since musicians who played classical instruments were a rarity in the Protectorate, Carl's trio had had quite a few opportunities to play for high-level Protection officials, the only ones who would dare have such live music played at their social events. Matt and Andrew were agreeable to playing for the Lancasters' party, so the three of them got together in Carl's flat several times to practice beforehand. Both Carl himself and Andrew had hoped it would cheer Carl up. If anything, it made him more melancholy than ever, for Matt's conversation made the growing gap between Carl's thoughts and the Protectioners' line even more obvious to himself. He found himself losing his temper at every wrong note played during their practice sessions. Will I ever be able to sort myself out? he silently asked the night sky when his fellow musicians had gone home after a particularly stormy practice session. The stars blinked at him but didn't answer his question, and he stood on his balcony contemplating them, his unanswered questions dancing fearfully in his mind.
47
Chapter 6 Jack Winston stood at one end of the room and gazed around at the people gathered there. About thirty of them had come together in the small living room of the Mercers' home that night. There had been no announcement about the meeting, the time, or the venue, yet all of them had known about it. A few at a time, they had made their way to Ted and Anne's house as the day drew to its end. By eight o'clock they had all arrived. Jack marvelled at the mysterious ways of his God. Even though this kind of thing and even more wonderful things had been happening more and more often over the years since the Protection's power against the believers had begun to be felt, he still felt a thrill of joy each time it happened. How could one ever get enough of the loving care of the Lord God Almighty for His children? The men and women gathered in the room had come together for a time of worshipping God and praying together, yet from outside the house there was not a hint of their presence within. According to the laws of the Protectorate the meeting was illegal, and they could not afford to show any sign that it was going on. The heavy drapes at the windows were closed tightly but even so the only light in the room was provided by a small lamp with a low-powered globe which sat around the corner on the hall table. Ted and Anne had left on the light in their own bedroom, as if it were occupied. The door to the kitchen was shut, lest any stray sound reach out through the back door. Any talking was whispered, and right now the group was "singing" a hymn in whispers. Already they had prayed quietly and at length, in the name of Jesus Christ, for their country, their families, their brothers and sisters who had been "taken into care" by the Protection. Jack was the pastor of this secret church. He was in his mid-forties, a quiet, gentle man with receding dark brown hair, of medium height and medium build, slightly overweight—the sort of man one doesn't notice in a crowd. His deep brown eyes, already surrounded by dozens of smilewrinkles, gazed with a quizzical kindness at all who had anything to do with him, whether friend or foe. When he wasn't actually beaming or laughing, he wore a perpetual half-smile which made anyone who met him feel that life must be very pleasant for him and that was why he was full of goodwill towards everyone. Jack and his wife, Rose, and his sister, Emma, were treasured by the believers in Densonia. Their love for Jesus Christ was evident in the countless ways in which they served and encouraged the believers and in Jack's perseverance in pastoring the church despite the constant threat of arrest. Like most of the parents in that part of the community known as Rebels—a name imposed by the government and which included Christians and Jews—Jack and Rose had seen their children taken away by the Welfare Ministry to be schooled in the ways of the Protectioners. They had no idea where they were. Every day they and their congregation prayed fervently 48
Sonata for Flute
that none of their children would lose the love for God that had been instilled in them from when they were tiny. The Winstons had put into their little flock all the energy they would have spent on bringing up their children. Although they never forgot their children, they trusted them to God, and decided that these, their spiritual children, were now their responsibility in the way their physical children would have been. Nonetheless, there were times when Rose found the pain of separation from her three offspring very hard to bear, as on their birthdays, or when she remembered particular traits, or came across one of their toys or clothes which somehow had not been packed away. At those times Jack would just hold his slightly-built wife tightly in his arms and let her weep her grief out, his own tears dropping onto her blond head, as he asked the Lord to comfort them and to give them strength to keep going. Almost from the day the Republic had been declared, it had been a long, hard road, and it wasn't getting any easier. It was very difficult to keep the Protection teachings out of the minds and hearts of the believers, for they pervaded every aspect of life in the Republic. If the Christians had only made a regular discipline of praying and of reading and memorizing the Scriptures, they would have been alert to the lies being spread by the relativists. Jack did all he could to warn them, in his sermons, in his talks, and through the Bible studies he and the elders led. Other pastors throughout the Republic who were faithful to the Word had found that they were up against the same challenge. But life had become too easy, thinking ahead too bothersome. Television, then CD-vision, Fantasy Dreamers, spectator sports, and other entertainment featured prominently in the daily lives of their congregations, and blunted their minds to the danger. They lived from one source of pleasure to the next. Few of them read much of anything other than popular magazines, let alone the Bible. Their children were being fed the Protection philosophies in school and the parents had no way of countering the lies, for they themselves were increasingly living in a fog of fantasy, dissipated living, and lies. Jack, Rose, and Emma spent hours every week, by themselves or with other pastors and elders and their wives, praying for their people. With heavy hearts they saw their flocks shrink as this or that member left for the pleasures of the world. But those who remained grew stronger in their faith as the persecutions increased. When the Protectorate had been established, church properties had been taken over by the State and Christians and Jews had come to be referred to as "Crooked Thinkers" and almost considered mentally ill. Along with other non-conformists they had been declared Rebels and accused of being involved in subversion. Some of them had been "taken into care" by the State, to be "counselled" into "Straight Thinking", first at the Ministry of Welfare, then, five years later, at the Counselling Institute. The true believers had not been daunted, and they became very adept at making the most of every opportunity to pray, to meet together for fellowship, and to read the Scriptures. The Bible had become even more precious to them since they now had access only to those copies they 49
Sonata for Flute
already owned. Those who had been only nominally Christian fell away very quickly, some of them even turning against those whom just a few days before they had been calling "Brother" and "Sister." Many of them, believing they were doing the right thing to protect society, became eager members of the Neighbour Watchers. Most were unaware that the role of the Enwuh had taken on a more sinister meaning. Life for the believers became very much a matter of looking to God for wisdom at all times. Priorities became rather clear for them. For those believers with school-age children, the coming of the Protection had been harrowing. Their beloved sons and daughters were taken away from them and they had no way of finding out where they were. As it had for Jack and Rose, separation had come when the Welfare Ministry had decided that these "fanatical" parents were having a detrimental effect on the development of their offspring. Welfare Officers were sent out regularly to take these children considered "at risk" away from their parents. One could get one's children back, of course—it was a "simple" matter of denying God and embracing the Protection. For a handful of Jack's flock, the pain had been too hard to bear, and in order to see their children again they had publicly proclaimed that henceforth they would serve the Protectorate, not Christ. ! ! ! A sudden crash interrupted the whispered hymn as the front door was battered down to let in a mob of Police Officers wielding stunners and nightsticks. The interruption was only momentary, however, for the believers started singing out loud even as the officers methodically lashed out at them. As soon as the Police had entered, the worshippers on the far side of the room had opened the door leading to the kitchen and the back door, and had started escaping. Two of the men near Jack and Rose grabbed the couple and pushed them out of the room, through the kitchen, and out of the house. Emma saw them leave but couldn't follow as she was supporting one of the other women who had fainted next to her when the police had come in. "Jack!" she yelled, "Remember Job! The verse from Job! Jack! Rose! Don't forget!" She had no idea whether they had heard her over the general tumult, but she hoped they would remember the signal to which they had agreed in case anything should go wrong. Somehow Emma had known that tonight "something would go wrong" and here it was... The room had rapidly emptied of most of the people, until only six of the believers were left, three men and three women—one of the elders and his wife, a middle aged man who had been hampered by a sprained ankle and one of the younger men in the church who had been trying to help him escape, and Emma and her companion who had now revived. The officers prodded them with their stunners and herded them out to a van parked in front of the house. On the side of the van were stencilled in dark green the 50
Sonata for Flute
words Police Counselling Institute and the logo of the Institute, a "helping hand" reaching down towards another hand stretched upwards as if seeking help. They were pushed into the van and the doors slammed shut behind them. A wave of fear washed over them, and the elder's wife was quietly sobbing on her husband's shoulder, but the younger man quietly started to sing a chorus of praise. The rest of them, taking the cue, joined in as the van sped through the deserted city streets. They sang it a few times, then another one, and then the elder, his arm around his wife, prayed aloud for them all. The van stopped, having reached its destination, as he got to the end of his prayer. He gave his wife a hug and kissed her, and whispered something to her. The others smiled their thanks to him, and he smiled back encouragingly, as the doors opened and they were ordered out of the van. The officers roughly separated the elder and his wife, and the women and the men were led away in opposite directions. Emma would never see those three men again. ! ! ! In the richly appointed reception room of the Lancaster mansion on the southern shore of the Lake, a chamber ensemble finished playing the last few notes of a Bach trio. A ripple of applause swept around the room. The musicians stood up and bowed to their audience. Ross Lancaster, their host, full of the assurance of his importance, got up from his seat in the front row and went up onto the musicians' low dais. "Well, well!" he boomed jovially, and clapped Counsellor Matt Lewis on the shoulder, almost making him drop his violin. He turned and glanced at the other two musicians. "Thank you very much, Gentlemen, for a very pleasant ending to the day. We have enjoyed your talented playing very much, as always." "It's a pleasure to play for such an appreciative audience, Sir," Lewis replied, bowing again, this time to Lancaster. The Chief of the Police Counselling Institute acknowledged him with a nod, then beckoned him forwards. Lewis went to stand by the man, who put a hand on his shoulder and turned to his guests. "My dear friends," he announced, "May I present to you one of my most successful Counsellors, Matthew Lewis. Not one of his counsellees has failed to be cured of their dangerous attitudes. He is an asset to our Institute." The men and women in the room applauded and Lewis bowed yet again, a self-satisfied smile on his face. He turned and glanced at his companions, expecting to receive their adulation as well, and was surprised to find that they were not even looking at him. Carl, still acutely conscious of his failure with Chester Brown, felt humiliated, and he busied himself with cleaning his flute so he wouldn't have to look at Matt. Andrew, frowning as if deep in thought, was putting his cello away very carefully, as if the instrument had suddenly become more fragile than usual.
51
Sonata for Flute
Lancaster did not notice the little scene behind his back. He now suggested to his guests that they might like to avail themselves of the refreshments prepared for them at the back of the room, and went off to try and impress some of them with his conversation. Carl watched the audience get up and disperse as he folded up his music stand. Some intimate gathering, this! he thought. There had to be at least a hundred people in the room, most of them important government officials, military officers and academics, Police Chiefs. When Myra Lancaster had asked him if he and his friends would play for an "intimate gathering of friends" he had imagined there would be about ten guests at most, as would be the case with parties in the homes of other officials. It had been a shock to his weary system to see such a crowd gathered for their little concert. Still, I did enjoy playing the music, he told himself, the rest shouldn't matter, even that vexing commendation of Matt by the Chief. He felt unconvinced by his own rebuke. Andrew finished packing up his cello and music, and looked up at his fellow-musicians. "Well, Carl, Matt, what do we play next time?" he asked lightly, "We're running out of new pieces for our repertoire, you know. We're going to have to start repeating our previous concerts." "You'll just have to compose something, Andrew!" Matt joked. "I'll try, but only if you promise me you'll play it!" Andrew retorted, grinning. "As far as I can tell we've exhausted what's available on the public network," Carl said, "We'll have to try one of the private ones." "Maybe the Chief has some." Matt said as he folded up his music stand. He pointed towards Lancaster with his chin. "The Chief being rather fond of music, he ought to have some sources, don't you think?" At that point a loud voice interrupted their exchange. "Oh, Carl, that was simply wonderful!" A short, pretty woman with very short black hair, dressed in a long, flowing purple gown, had approached them. "You do play the flute so wonderfully!" she gushed. Carl went pale, but did not turn around. He closed his flute case abruptly and began to gather up his music books into his briefcase. "Carer Janssen, Counsellor Slade is not deaf, you know," Andrew scolded the woman, "Would you mind lowering your voice?" Janssen looked at Andrew disdainfully, as if he were something dirty. "Mind your own business, Blackie!" she sneered. Andrew felt very ungentlemanly towards her, but he held his tongue. She turned her attention back to the flautist, grabbing him by his arm and forcing him to turn around to face her. Won't this woman ever leave me alone? Carl grumbled to himself, Surely after all these years she must have got the message... "Oh, Carl," she said invitingly, "I would just love it if you would come and play at my place some—" "Excuse me, Carer Janssen," Carl interrupted angrily, his eyes flashing now, "I'm not interested in going to your home at any time, or in playing 52
Sonata for Flute
the flute for you, and right now, I'd like to try some of Mrs. Lancaster's fruit punch before it's all gone. Good evening." He shook her hand off his arm and walked off hurriedly towards the refreshments table, leaving Janssen staring open-mouthed after him and Matt and Andrew doing their best not to laugh. The woman's face creased into a dark scowl, and she walked off towards Ross Lancaster. Andrew and Matt joined their friend by the bowl of punch. "That took care of the Carer!" chuckled Andrew, clapping Carl on the shoulder, "Has the Counsellor recovered from the attack?" "I don't find it at all amusing, Andrew!" Carl snapped. "Wow, sorry, didn't mean to add to it," Andrew murmured, throwing a glance at Matt, who shrugged. "How's the punch?" he said, changing the subject. "As usual. Go easy on it, you have to get home in one piece," Carl answered, handing him a glass of it. "I wouldn't mind drowning in it, myself," he added bitterly. Carl's evening had been thoroughly spoiled, first by the Chief's action and now by the episode with Janssen, and he grimaced at Andrew. "There's no rush for that music, you know," he said gloomily, "I'll get around to asking Lancaster sometime. Or maybe Matt should, he seems to be in the Chief's good books these days." "Speaking of the Chief," Matt muttered over the rim of his glass, "Here he comes now." Lancaster came over to where they stood and took hold of Carl's arm. With great difficulty, Carl resisted the urge to shrug him off. "Counsellor Slade, I must have a word with you," the Chief said, "Would you mind coming over to my study for a minute." It was an order, not an invitation. The Chief didn't sound quiet as affable as he had when he'd thanked them for their music. "Yes, Sir, of course." Carl put his glass down on the table and glanced at his companions uneasily. "I'll see you fellows after," he said, and followed his boss to the study which opened off the reception room. Matt and Andrew watched as Carl moved away. "Is it my imagination, or is Carl's temper worse than ever, Andrew ?" Matt asked, "He seems to be reacting, even over-reacting, so much of the time these days." "Yeah, he certainly does," agreed Andrew, "Just look at the way he lost his cool whenever we played a wrong note during practice, for example." "Well, I must admit,” Matt said, “he's never been one of those people you can easily explain. Still, it seems to me that something's not quite right at the moment." "Perhaps he's getting too involved with his cases?" Andrew suggested, "You know, not being detached enough, thinking about them outside working hours, that sort of thing?" He wanted to protect his friend and felt uncomfortable discussing him with Matt. "Or maybe Carer Janssen has been running after him too much?" Matt chuckled again at the thought.
53
Sonata for Flute
"I somehow don't think she's quite the kind of lady Carl would be interested in, Matt," Andrew said defensively. "Is Carl interested in any kind of lady?" Matt exclaimed, "I can't recall ever seeing him with a woman other than at work! That's one of the things that keep puzzling me about him: he has no interest in either the ladies or the lads, as far as I can see. And no way can you talk to him about it, he just flies off the handle! He's forty, never been married, lives by himself, hardly ever has visitors, eats all his meals at the Institute... Maybe he's afraid of something? Ha! Who knows what he's hiding in his past... One wonders how he ever made it to Counsellor!" "Did you know that he grew up in a children's home?" Andrew asked quietly, "One of those experimental ones that were so popular in the late nineties. Must have had his temper back then, too. I gather he often got into trouble. Maybe they taught him a thing or two..." "Ha! Repressed him, more like!" Matt said, and drained his glass. "All except his temper!" he added after a moment. "Well, he's a pretty good friend, despite his oddities, Matt," Andrew said, "and he's a good flautist, too! Each to his own. You know, selfexpression and all that..." Andrew couldn't see any point in continuing this analysis of Carl. "Hey, let's have some of those edibles before they get all eaten up!" he said as he picked up a plate of snacks and offered it to Matt. ! ! ! Lancaster held the study door open for Carl to enter and then closed it behind him. "Take a seat, Counsellor." Again it was an order. Lancaster sounded annoyed. Carl sat down on one of the velvet chairs facing Lancaster's enormous carved mahogany desk and glanced around the room. It had not changed much since his last summons there two years before. The walnut-panelled wall behind the desk still held the same huge portraits of Brent Denson and of Lancaster himself, the windows to the left were still hidden behind heavy wine-coloured velvet curtains, the same carved mahogany cupboard which occupied the entire wall to the right hid whatever Lancaster put in it behind ornate locked doors. Three standard lamps sheltered their flurolite tubes under wine-coloured silk shades, and a smaller, similarly dressed table lamp illuminated the desk top. Lancaster's compufiler was sequestered in a built-in enclosure behind his desk. In the corner between the desk and the window a deep, velvet-covered armchair rested invitingly. Like everything in the Chief's house, the furnishings of his study spoke of a plush, luxurious lifestyle. Carl had never felt comfortable with the seeming contradiction between the Chief's lavish standard of living and his constant preaching of Protection dogma, which imposed "simple living" on the inhabitants of the Protectorate. Even in choosing the furnishings of the Counsellors' flats Lancaster had strictly followed his interpretation of the Protection's directives, and imposed "simplicity". But not in his own home. 54
Sonata for Flute
The Chief sat down in his velvet-covered swivel chair behind the massive desk. He picked up a pen and toyed with it as he considered his subordinate in what Carl felt was an ominous manner. "Well, Counsellor," he said, in a tone as if he were addressing a schoolboy, "I expect that you're aware that we've picked up a new lot of counsellees tonight." "Yes, I did see that a raid was planned and that I'm scheduled to start a new course of counselling tomorrow morning," Carl answered cautiously. He was on the defensive, and he didn't like the Chief's tone of voice. "Slade, until now your record as a Counsellor, and before that, as a Welfare Officer, was impeccable. However, over the last year you have had more than one failure, and as you know, I wasn't very happy with your last case, that old man, I forget his name..." "Chester Brown, Sir." Carl usually made a point of forgetting his counsellees' names once he had finished with them, but that old man he simply could not forget. Nor could he forget that he'd failed to get him to change. Nor, apparently, could Ross Lancaster. "Yes, well, his name doesn't matter, really." Lancaster dismissed Brown with a flick of the pen, as one might brush away an annoying fly. "The fact is you failed with him and he ended up at the Farm." The Chief did not like sending counsellees to the Experimental Farm—it gave the Institute a bad name. Of course the Farm needed subjects for all those experiments, but he'd rather they got them elsewhere. He wanted his Institute's statistics to look good. A counsellee sent to the Farm was a negative mark on the list of the Institute's achievements. "Chief," Carl exclaimed, "I tried everything with that bloke. He was the most stubborn person I've ever come across! He clung to all that nonsense no matter what. Even the threat of the Farm didn't budge him!" He wondered what this interview was leading up to. He'd already gone over Brown's case with Lancaster and he didn't relish the idea of going over it again. "I assume that you've reviewed the CDs of all the sessions?" Lancaster asked, tapping his pen on his chin. "Yes, Sir, several times!" He knows that already, Carl thought, Why's he asking again? Lancaster sat back in his chair, crossed his legs, and continued to toy with the pen, now tapping it on the desktop, now twirling it between his fingers. He was taking his time and it was getting on Carl's nerves. The Chief suddenly straightened up, put the pen down and looked at him grimly. "Counsellor, tomorrow I'm assigning one of the women to you for counselling," he snapped, "Emma Winston, Jack Winston's sister. You know who Jack Winston is, don't you? One of the Rebel leaders." Carl nodded. He couldn't speak. His heart sank as he heard he was being assigned a female counsellee. Quite apart from his own problems in relating to women, he knew that to be assigned a counsellee of the opposite sex was a demotion in the Institute.
55
Sonata for Flute
"It should be no trouble at all," Lancaster continued, "to get a silly spinster like her to come to her senses, don't you agree?" He actually leered as he said it. Carl knew what he was thinking, and he felt sick, because he knew that Lancaster was aware of his difficulties with regards to women. He had never liked the Chief, and tonight's experience was not improving his opinion of the man. "I should think it will be no trouble at all," he said somewhat defiantly. But I'll use my own approach, if you don't mind, he added to himself. Lancaster got up and walked to the door. "Tomorrow, then, Counsellor," he said, and his tone was still vaguely menacing, "And I suggest that you go home and get a good night's rest now. Good night, Counsellor." Was it Carl's imagination, or had he heard Lancaster emphasize the word 'now'? In any case, he got the message—he was no longer welcome at this party. "Good night, Sir," he said, and went back into the reception room. Andrew caught sight of him as he went to collect his flute and music, and came over to him. "What, are you leaving already?" he asked. "Yes, big day at work tomorrow, you know," Carl answered sarcastically, "I have to get some rest. I've been told!" "Ah! Right you are, Carl." Andrew was familiar with being told. He too had had his encounters with the Chief. "See you tomorrow, Carl," he said quietly, "Be careful." "I will be, don't you worry, mate," Carl muttered, "but I'm not sure that it'll guarantee my safety. I've been assigned a female counsellee." "Oh, I'm sorry," Andrew said, realizing that Lancaster had effectively told Carl he was being demoted and what a blow that must be to his friend, "Do you have any idea who it is?" "Jack Winston's sister, Emma Winston." Andrew frowned at the name, but didn't comment. He patted Carl on the shoulder. "Better do as you're told, mate," he warned, "before you get any further into trouble." "Yeah, thanks," Carl grimaced, "See you tomorrow, Andrew." Actually, he wasn't completely unhappy about having to leave. He enjoyed playing the music at such gatherings, but although he could hold his own in the small talk that went on afterwards, he never took pleasure in it and so didn't really mind not being involved. This time, Lancaster's censure had added to his gloom. Perhaps an early night wasn't such a bad idea after all. ! ! ! That night Carl dreamt that he was running down the hospital corridors, calling out, searching for something, but he couldn't remember what it was he was looking for. The tiled hallways seemed endless and echoed his cries over and over so that it sounded like they were laughing maliciously at him. 56
Sonata for Flute
He woke up feeling panicky. He hadn't had that particular dream for a long time, and it brought back painful memories of fear and rejection. Rejection... He not only felt humiliated at being assigned a female counsellee, he was horrified at the prospect of having to counsel a woman. On top of that was his fear of renewed failure, and his increasing doubts about all he'd believed in only increased his panic. He dreaded the weeks ahead.
57
SECOND MOVEMENT: AGITATO "Love your enemies. Do good to people who hate you. Bless people who curse you. Pray for people who treat you badly." LUKE 6:27, 28 "God moves in a mysterious way His wonders to perform;" WILLIAM COWPER, 'Light Shining Out of Darkness'
Chapter 7
It appeared that they were in an underground carpark, and Emma assumed they were at the Police Counselling Institute. She had heard their captors talking about "counsellees", and decided that they must have been referring to their prisoners. The three women were led to one of several steel doors at one end of the carpark. One of the officers pressed his palm to the ID panel next to the door and it slid open. "Get in, you lot," he growled, and prodded the women forward, and they entered the cubicle which the opening of the door had revealed. The door slid shut behind them, the officers remaining outside. There was barely enough room for the three women to move inside the tiny space between the door through which they had entered and another steel door, which remained shut, in front of them. A female voice spoke harshly from a speaker in the ceiling. "Remove all your clothing and put on the Institute uniforms," the voice ordered. The women looked at each other, embarrassed and frightened at the same time. They looked around them for the uniforms that had been referred to, and saw some dark blue tracksuits hanging on hooks on the wall, and blue sneakers on the floor beneath them. "One size fits all, I guess," muttered the woman who had fainted earlier. "We'd better do as she says," Emma suggested. They hurriedly undressed and put on the loose-fitting outfits, dropping their own clothing on the floor. What were they supposed to do with it? they wondered. "Pick up your clothes," the voice from the speaker said, as if answering the unspoken question. The second steel door slid open. The voice spoke again, only this time it was not coming from the speaker above their heads, but from the doorway. "Come out and place your clothing in the barrel." The door opened into a long, white-tiled passageway, harshly lit by flurolite lamps. There was a large metal receptacle just outside the door, into which they obediently dropped their bundles as they walked out of the little room. In front of them stood three women in yellow uniforms of jacket 58
Sonata for Flute
and slacks and wearing dark glasses—the Carers who were in charge of them. Each one carried a stunner. "Walk in front of the Carers," one of the guards barked. They recognized the voice they'd heard over the speaker. The guards motioned to their prisoners to walk ahead down the passageway. Emma squeezed her companions' hands to encourage them. "Remember Joshua 1:9," she whispered to them. "Keep your hands to yourself and shut up!" commanded one of their escorts. They turned down another hallway which sloped downwards. One of the Carers stopped and called out the name of the woman who had fainted, who turned around. The Carer pointed to a door on their left which she had just opened, and motioned for the woman to go in, which she did. The Carer touched the ID panel on the wall, and the door slid shut. "Look straight ahead and keep moving!" ordered the guard. They continued down the passageway and the second counsellee was locked into her cell—for the rooms behind the doors were just small cubicles. That was the last time Emma ever saw the two women who had been arrested with her. As each prisoner had been locked up, the Carer in charge of her had turned around and gone back the way they had come. Now only Emma and her guard, a short woman with black hair, were left. The Carer's dark glasses, protecting her eyes from the constant glare of the flurolite lamps, made it impossible to know what she really looked like, or what her attitude to her prisoner might be. Emma wondered what she was like outside working hours. Would her voice be as harsh as it was now? Did she have a family? It was rumoured that the Counsellors, both male and female, were not married—apparently one of President Denson's whims— but many of the Carers and Police Officers did have families. Emma found it hard to imagine this woman cradling a baby. The Carer's voice cut across her thoughts. "Stop your dreaming and do as I said!" the woman shouted, and used her stunner to emphasize what had apparently been an order to turn left. They now went into a passageway that sloped upwards. There seems to be quite a maze of corridors under the Institute! Emma thought to herself. The Carer made her stop in front of door number 143, pressed the ID panel, pushed her in when the door slid open, and then slid the door shut. The tiny room, like the passageways, was completely tiled in white except for a sprinkling of tiles bearing the green Institute logo of the "helping hand". The cell was lit by a flurolite lamp recessed in the ceiling behind a locked screen. The ceiling also bore a speaker and what Emma assumed was a video lens. Opposite the door, in one corner of the cell, was a covered bucket, and in the corner facing it, an open bucket of water with a metal cup chained to it. A straw mat lay rolled up along the wall, between the two buckets.
59
Sonata for Flute
She turned around and looked at the door. It was another steel door, but it had what looked like a sliding panel a third of the way down it. For passing things through without opening the door? she wondered, or for checking on one? Perhaps both? I wonder if the light stays on all the time? she thought to herself, it could be difficult to sleep if it does. She thought it must be around midnight, she'd better try to get some sleep. What would morning bring? She knew that despite the image of caring and helping that was promulgated about the Institute it was really just a prison. I'll find out all too soon, she decided, I'd better not worry about it, but rather I should pray for the Lord to have His way. She was distressed to find that little hints of doubt began to spring up in her mind about the fact that she was here—had God abandoned her? Why was He letting this happen? Is this what was meant by God's loving care? Was this how God treated those who submitted to Him? What had she done to deserve this? The doubts were like a swarm of bees buzzing in her head, and she felt herself on the edge of panic. She suddenly remembered Uncle Chester and how he'd disappeared into the Institute and never come out. What had happened to him? Would the same thing happen to her? She told herself that she should not be worrying about it, it only made the situation worse. But, oh God, only You can calm my fears, she cried in her heart, "You will keep him—her!—in perfect peace whose mind is on You, because his—her—trust is in You." Who else can I trust but You, Lord, in this place? Dear Lord, You know Yourself what it's like, after all. You are with me, I know, because You've promised me You would be. I'll trust you, Lord, because I know You're faithful. The doubts fled and she knew God that was indeed with her. She unrolled the mat on the floor and knelt on it. She turned all her thoughts to God and prayed, praising and thanking Him for being with her. She asked for courage and wisdom, and that she might stand firm no matter what. She prayed for her brother and his wife, for her fellowprisoners. And then somehow Matthew 5:44 came to her mind, like a gentle tap on the shoulder—"Love your enemies and pray for those people who persecute you."—and she prayed for whoever was going to be "counselling" her, and for her guard. Then, her heart at peace, she lay down on the mat and tried to sleep. At first sleep eluded her, and she wondered again if she would be able to sleep in that brightly-lit cell, until she remembered Jack's advice on insomnia. "Think of all the Scriptures you've learned by heart, and review them in your mind," he'd said, "There is nothing better last thing at night than to fall asleep with God's Word going through your mind." She started with Job 19:25, of course, then reviewed verses learned recently, then less recently, until she fell asleep thinking about John 16:33, "Be encouraged [Jesus said]! I have overcome the world." ! ! !
60
Sonata for Flute
The sound of the steel door sliding open woke Emma up, and she opened her eyes to see a pair of yellow shoes in front of her face. They were on the feet of her Carer, who stood by her mat. Cecilia Janssen glowered down at her, and prodded her with the stunner. "Get up," Janssen barked, "Prepare for your counselling session. Now." We'll use this one to finally trap that man, she thought, this will be the end of his career for sure, maybe even of his life. Very thoughtful of Ross to take my advice and assign a female counsellee to Slade, especially this one. This one will never budge, just like that old fellow. Slade will pay to the end for his refusal of me, for his rudeness. It pays to have Ross Lancaster on side. Carer Janssen felt smug. It had taken some seven years, but her desire for revenge was reaching its goal. She'd had the satisfaction of watching Carl Slade's ever-increasing distress over that time, and she thought it was all her own manipulations that had achieved it. Emma got up slowly and stretched, keeping her eyes on the guard and trying to stay just out of reach. She was determined to avoid the stunner as far as possible. "I'll come to fetch you in two minutes, you'd better be ready!" the Carer said loudly, and went out, sliding the door close behind her. Emma realized that the covered bucket was meant to be used as a toilet. She sighed, and went to use it, aware that her every move was probably being watched by someone via the "eye" in the ceiling. As she replaced the lid on the bucket, she wondered how they expected her to wash. Oh, well, there isn't time for that now, anyway. She went to the water bucket and dipped the cup into it. She drank the water, and it made her aware that she was quite hungry. As she dipped the cup a second time, it occurred to her that the Carer had not mentioned breakfast. Oh, Lord, please keep my mind off food if it's going to be like that, please, she prayed. The door slid open again and Carer Janssen motioned to her impatiently. "Come on, it's time for your session," she barked, "Walk ahead of me, that way!" She pointed down the passage. Emma did as she was told. At each turn the Carer prodded her with the stunner to indicate a right or left turn. They came to a lift and the guard used the ID panel on the lift door to open it. They got in, and the lift rose several levels, then stopped, and the door opened. They got out into a wood-panelled and carpeted hallway discreetly lit by concealed flurolite lamps. The difference between this and the subterranean corridors made Emma gasp. "Quiet!" Janssen ordered, then made her turn right. This time they didn't go very far. They stopped in front of a polishedwood door and the guard pressed a signal cube to let the occupant behind the door know of their arrival. The door slid open to reveal a sizeable room with a white tile floor, furnished as an office and also illuminated by concealed lighting. Immediately in front of them was a large oakwood desk with a compufiler on the left end of it, which was against the wall. In front of the desk were two straight-backed metal chairs, and behind it stood a swivel armchair 61
Sonata for Flute
upholstered in dark green wool. Behind the desk there appeared to be a window running the length of the wall, but it was covered by a heavy grey blind. Along the wall under the window ran a low counter-top cupboard with sliding wooden doors. The oak-panelled wall to the right held a lone framed print of a rose. On the left side, the wall as far as the desk was covered by what appeared to be two built-in cupboards with wooden sliding doors. Emma wondered if all this wood was the real thing, for she was familiar with the Protection Party's strong words about conservation. It certainly looks like real wood, she thought, how odd. A tall man wearing the dark green uniform of a Police Counsellor was standing leaning back against the upright between the two cupboards, his arms crossed, and as they walked into the room he kept his eyes on Emma, not even glancing at the Carer. Emma felt as if he were inspecting her, but she decided she couldn't let it bother her. She gazed at him with interest as she remembered what Jack had told her about the Counselling Institute. So this was a Counsellor. She wasn't close enough to be able to read the name on his badge. Never mind. He was well above average in height—something more than a metre eighty. Like Uncle Chester, Emma thought. He had slightly wavy, light brown hair which was a bit too long and worn in a swept-back style which was not common among government people, who tended to favour crewcuts like their president. His somewhat oblong face, Emma felt, looked like it could use a bit of sunlight on it, both literally and figuratively. His long, straight nose and his too wide, thin-lipped mouth gave him a disdainful air, although his wide-set blue eyes and rounded chin softened the effect. He's not especially good-looking, she concluded, which is just as well, in his sort of job.
62
Chapter 8 Carl had not been sure whether he had ever seen Emma Winston before, although he had come across her brother Jack several times. He watched her as she walked into his office, trying to guess by her manner whether he would have trouble with her or not. He was used to assessing his counsellees as they came in for their first session, and had usually been able to tell which of them would be difficult to deal with. He had been right about his last counsellee—as soon as the tall old man had walked in the door Carl had known he was as firm as a rock in his faith. But all his previous clients had been men, of course. Could he assess a woman's attitude the same way? Emma Winston did not seem cowered by her circumstances, he noticed with some uneasiness. In fact, she seemed to be more curious than anything else. He saw her glance quickly around the room, her gaze lingering a little longer on the Redouté print than on the rest of the furnishings. She finally caught sight of him as she turned to look at that side of the room. As she looked at him he had the impression that she was sizing him up, too, and this irritated him. At least she's good-looking, he thought, not that it makes any difference, but it would be a double insult to have to counsel an unpleasant-looking female. He was annoyed with himself, however, for finding Emma attractive. This is stupid, he scolded himself, I hardly ever look at women and here I am appraising a Rebel, of all things! I must admit, though, she has a good figure—doesn't take after her brother, anyway!—and her face is pretty, with those brown eyes and straight nose and full mouth, even that slight frown, and framed nicely with all that brown hair. She may need counselling, but she won't be hard on the eyes. Those Rebels have the right idea, insisting that their women wear their hair long. This last thought, heretical as it was for a Protectioner, took him so by surprise that it brought him back to reality. I am a Police Counsellor and I have a job to do, he told himself, This woman is a Rebel, she is involved with traitors to the Protectorate, and it is my task to set her straight, no matter what it takes to do it. Dwelling on her looks will not make my job easier... Nor will having that Janssen woman hanging around! "Carer Janssen," he said curtly, without looking at the guard, "I will call you to fetch the counsellee when the session is ended. You may leave." Janssen went out and the door slid shut behind her. Emma stood where Janssen had left her, wondering what she was about to face. The Counsellor's voice had startled her. It had a commanding, deep sound and seemed to announce to her that he was someone to reckon with. Carl noticed the twinge of disquiet which appeared fleetingly on her face when he spoke. He straightened up, walked over to the desk and pressed a switch to lock the door.
63
Sonata for Flute
He indicated the two chairs in front of the desk. "Sit down," he said abruptly, and Emma did as she was told. She sat up straight on the chair, her feet tucked under it, and clasped her hands lightly in her lap, noticing that her palms were very moist. Not knowing what to expect, she prayed in her heart for wisdom. The Counsellor went to sit down behind his desk and looked at his computer screen. "You're Emma Winston," he read out from the display, "thirty-five years old, now resident in Cell 143, found last night associating with elements who are undermining our Protectorate." He tapped on the keyboard and continued his introduction. "I'm Counsellor Slade and my job is to help you get your thinking straightened out now that you're away from those corrupting influences. Unfortunately your records show that you've been under that influence all your life—that's thirty-five years! It could take much work and effort to sort you out..." He glanced at her, then looked back at the screen. His eyes are awfully blue, Emma observed to herself, irrelevantly. Carl went on, "You can reduce the number of counselling sessions and the length of your stay at the Institute by being cooperative and determined to learn quickly, and to forget all the nonsense that's been taught you all those years." "It isn't nonsense, it's the truth!" Emma blurted out, incensed that this man should call 'nonsense' all that was most precious to her, as she knew quite well he meant her Christian faith. "Miss Winston, do not interrupt!" Carl snapped, slapping the desktop, "You'll talk only when asked a question!" Wow, Emma thought, this man has a quick temper. I'd better be more careful. Carl was annoyed at himself because he was finding it difficult to look this woman in the eye the way he had always done with his male counsellees. It seemed that his initial reaction to her—seeing her as a woman first and a counsellee second—had unsettled him. Had that been part of Chief Lancaster's plan in assigning a woman to him? He was still feeling vexed at Lancaster's obvious lack of confidence in him, and on top of that he was rather annoyed that the Chief had put Carer Janssen in charge of this counsellee. His sense of frustration was such that his control over his temper felt about as effective to him as a saucepan lid on a volcano about to erupt. Emma Winston's immediate reaction to his statement also told to him that here was another strong believer who would be very hard to reform. He had a fleeting recollection of Chester Brown's first session. He stood up, walked out from behind his desk, and leant back on it in front of her, crossing his arms. "I'm sure you're aware that your whole system of belief is quite contrary to the teachings of the Protection." he said dryly, looking down at her, "therefore you won't be surprised to find out that it poses a threat to the stability of the Protectorate. Ultimately your beliefs are a threat to you, too, since a threat to the Protectorate is a threat to any of its citizens, and vice versa. We all have the responsibility to do what is best for the Protectorate so that all may live happy, peaceful lives." 64
Sonata for Flute
"It's impossible to have peace or real happiness without God," Emma answered levelly, looking straight at him. He did not appreciate her interruption. His face livid, he slapped her hard on the face. "I told you to keep quiet!" he shouted at her, "You are not to talk unless you are asked a question, do you understand?" Emma stared at him in fright, her hand on her injured cheek. He was appalled that he had slapped her. Why, he didn't know. He'd slapped previous counsellees more times than he could remember, without obvious remorse—but this time his action had unnerved him. On the other hand, he couldn't let her guess that—he had to stay in control of the session. "Put your hand down and answer me!" he ordered through clenched teeth. "Y-y-yes, Sir," Emma stammered, putting her hand down and clasping it with the other. Her cheek was aching, but nowhere near as much as her heart. Carl was now not only horrified because of his outburst but angry with himself as well. This was not at all the way he had planned to start. It would have been much better to begin with a gentler approach, but now he'd messed it up because of his temper. He walked away from her, trying to force himself to calm down. When he reached the cupboard he turned around and looked back at her He spoke in a more controlled tone of voice. "My last counsellee was an old man who started out pretty much the way you're—" "Uncle Chester!" Emma exclaimed, and gasped as she realized that she'd interrupted him again. Her hands shot up to cover her face. But this time Carl restrained himself. He glared at her, then cleared his throat and continued speaking. "Yes, his name was Chester Brown. Obviously you knew him quite well. He refused to reform and just hung on to these silly ideas like yours and your bro—" "You mean he stood firm, he held on to the faith," Emma blurted out with joy, clapping her hand over her mouth in the next instant, her eyes wide with horror as she waited for his reaction. Carl regarded her with exasperation. "You have a bad habit of interrupting!" he snapped, "We'll have to work on that too!" Nonetheless her statement about Brown had struck him, and he thought in passing about the difference between being stubborn and standing firm. Only in passing, however. He returned to his chair behind the desk, and tried to get back to the Introductory Session procedure. "As I was saying, Miss Winston, you can shorten the time of your counselling by being cooperative and reforming as quickly as possible. In these sessions you will be taught the correct manner in which to think and therefore to act in order to be a good citizen of the Protectorate. The faster you learn, the more quickly you will be able to leave the Institute. Is what I'm telling you clear? Do you understand?" He paused for her to answer. "Yes, Sir, I understand that the sooner I turn my back on God the sooner you'll let me go," Emma said softly, "What if I refuse to do that?"
65
Sonata for Flute
Carl took a deep breath to avoid loosing his cool again. "If you're obstinate it will take much longer and the training will be much harder on you." He shrugged. "It's up to you." "I think I understand," she said, quietly. She took a deep breath and looked him in the eye. "I have no intention of denying my faith," she informed him, "I think I'd better tell you at the outset." Carl's blue eyes turned stormy. Anger overwhelmed him—at Lancaster for doing this to him, at Emma for being determined to hold out, at himself for bungling his first session with her. With considerable effort he kept a hold on himself, and contemplated her coldly. "If I were you I would not be so cocky, Miss Winston," he said in a tight voice, "This is only your first session. We keep going for as long as necessary, up to a point. Beyond that point are things I'm sure you'd prefer never to encounter. Chester Brown went beyond that point." "I know you're trying to frighten me into submission, Sir, but I have no intention of conforming to the teachings of the Protectorate, which go against my Lord Jesus Christ." "Shut up! Shut up!" Carl shouted, slamming both hands down on his desk top. He was seething with rage. He lowered his voice menacingly. "Miss Winston, I will repeat it once more: You are not to talk unless you are asked to. This is a warning. If you interrupt me again you'll be punished." Dear Lord Jesus, please help me to hold my tongue, Emma prayed in her heart. For a moment she looked at the floor, then she looked up at the Counsellor again, the thought having come to her that unlike her, the man was lost—he did not know Jesus Christ. This is madness, Carl thought, why am I losing control so easily? I have a bad temper, but this is ridiculous. And I wish she wouldn't look at me like that! I'll have to try and avoid her eyes... "Now, having settled that," he said, sitting back in his chair, "We'll start your counselling properly." He began to recite a litany that was all too familiar to Emma. "We citizens of the Protectorate embrace the principles of diversity and tolerance," he intoned, "Nature, in all its variations, including human beings, is all one, and all good, so that what each one thinks is right for himself or herself is as valid as what others think is right for themselves. What is right for someone else may not be right for me. You may not tell me I'm wrong just because I think differently from you." "But you've just told me that my views are wrong," Emma pointed out in astonishment, "That they're a threat to society..." Carl was taken aback, and for a moment he was at a loss as to how to respond, for he recognized in her statement the basis of all his doubts—the unresolvable contradictions in the Protection propaganda. He looked at her with a puzzled frown as he searched for some way to answer. He didn't seem to have taken notice this time of the fact that she had interrupted him yet again. "Your beliefs are a threat to our Protectorate because you people insist that you're the only ones who are right," he said finally, "You don't believe in diversity, you have to try and get everyone to convert!" 66
Sonata for Flute
"Christianity is the only right way, because it's God's way!" Emma countered, "But aren't you doing precisely what you hold against us? You're trying to convert me to your view! Trying to force me to adopt your views! The Gospel gives people a choice—no-one is forced to believe." "Ah, but your choice isn't much of one, is it?" he replied, avoiding her point, "Believe and all will be well. However, don't believe and burn in hell. Some choice!" "It isn't quite like that—" "Miss Winston, I didn't ask you to tell me about your views," he interjected irritably, "You're here to change them, to learn and accept the Protection teaching." He didn't want to hear any more of her arguments. Their reasonableness made him uncomfortable and therefore more irritable. Even Chester Brown hadn't done this sort of thing. This Emma Winston was rather sure of her views, and not especially timid in letting them be known, either. He continued his lecture. "If, as the movements of the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries have shown, truth is relative to the situation each individual finds himself or herself in, then you can understand that there is no way of proving that something is right or wrong. However, there is one thing that is always right and that is for each person to make self-realization their goal, because it's only as self-realization and enlightenment are attained by everyone that we can have peace and unity in society, because then the whole of society will be enlightened." "Is that why everyone spends hours in Fantasy Dreamers, Pleasure Houses, parties, and so on?" Emma asked, "To attain self-realization?" Carl stared at her wordlessly. Since those things had no appeal for him, and he saw them only as a waste of time and money, he did not often think about them. Once or twice he had wondered why the Protectioners were so keen to promote their use, and he could only conclude that they were a means of keeping people under control. Whether that led to 'self-realization' was anyone's guess. His frustration increased as she hit yet another of his doubts. "Those things help people relax," he said dryly. Yes, mate, he said to himself sarcastically, I noticed just how relaxing they are when I tried them! "It helps them come to a consciousness of their essential oneness with nature," he added, shrugging. "You mean, they end up behaving like animals!" Emma said indignantly. "Would you stop interrupting!" he snapped. His anger was rising dangerously again. She was rubbing too many of his sore spots. Why on earth had the Chief done this to him? He took up the now tenuous thread of his recitation. "Each of us sees reality in his or her own way," he recited, "that is, uh... reality is what I make it for me and that doesn't mean any one else sees it the same way. Uh... the fact is that we each create our own reality and we each need to express ourselves from that reality." Emma was finding it hard to listen to what she knew was a pack of nonsensical lies. She looked down at the floor and wondered why it wasn't carpeted like the hallway, and tried to distract herself by counting the tiles. 67
Sonata for Flute
It occurred to her to pray that somehow this man might see the absurdity of the things he was saying and start searching for the Truth. Little did she know that her being there at all was part of the answer to her own prayer... Carl suddenly realised that Emma was not listening. "Pay attention!" he shouted, pounding his desk with his fist. Emma jumped, and reacted. "I don't see why I should listen to this stuff which I've heard so many times and which is all lies!" she replied crossly. This was too much for Carl's fragile hold on his temper. He leapt from his seat, came around his desk, and grabbed her by the shoulders, pulling her up from her chair. "Miss Winston, you will listen, and you will learn," he yelled, "And you will endeavour not to interrupt!" He threw her against the panelled wall with all his strength. She hit it so hard that the picture of the rose came off its hook and fell on the floor, smashing glass and frame. Emma bounced off the wall onto the floor, where the back of her head hit the tiles hard enough that she blacked out. Shaking with fury and with horror at his own behaviour, Carl turned away, sank onto her chair, and buried his face in his hands. Why had he done that? Why was he losing control so easily? Why, oh why, couldn't she shut up? A thought flashed through his mind—what if she's right? No, no! That's insane! She can't be right! Alarmed, he dismissed the idea as quickly as it had come. Emma, recovering consciousness, groaned, and he turned to look at her. She slowly sat herself up and leaned against the wall. He stood up, and she winced at his sudden movement and raised her arm protectively in front of her face. But he did not go near her. He gave her a few minutes to recover, then told her to get up and get back on her chair. She slowly complied. Carl went back to his seat behind the desk. He felt wearier than ever. He leant his elbows on the desk and held his chin on his clasped hands, and watched her. Emma looked down at her feet. She had an incredible headache and it hurt her eyes to look at the white floor tiles. She closed her eyes and held her hands over her face. He sat looking at her, a jumble of thoughts rushing about his mind. Chester Brown had infuriated him, and now Emma Winston was having the same effect. Why? Well, he said to himself, why am I trying to convince her about something I'm not even sure about, when she's obviously very sure about her own beliefs? That's only likely to lead to frustration, isn't it? But that was part of the problem—he couldn't stand the fact that she was sure and he wasn't. If he succeeded in converting her, would he be able to convince himself, too? What would Lancaster do if he failed with this counsellee as he had with Brown? Maybe he should get Janssen to deal with her? After all, that was the usual procedure—get the Carers to do the "treatment". For the first time in his career, he shuddered at the idea. He knew that Janssen would take great pleasure in "treating" a counsellee—everyone in the Institute knew 68
Sonata for Flute
what Janssen was like in the "treatment room". He was so repelled by the thought of putting his counsellee into Janssen's hands that he was quite confused. He had never worried about what a Carer might do to his counsellee before. He looked for some reason for not handing Emma Winston to Janssen to deal with, and almost immediately found one. Getting the Carer involved hadn't worked with Chester Brown—why should it work with Emma Winston? With relief he turned from that direction. His thoughts took on a new tack. How could Winston be so sure about her beliefs? And there again, without warning, was that quiet little question. It seemed to hide in the back of his mind, never quite going away, popping out when he least wanted to hear it. What if Brown is right? What if Emma Winston's right? Time to get back to business, he scolded himself. He looked again at his counsellee. She was sitting up, leaning against the back of her chair and gazing at her hands clasped in front of her. She looked somewhat the worse for wear. Her left cheek still bore the mark of his hand, her hair was in disarray, and her face had turned quite pale, probably from the blow to her head when she fell. This was the first time he had actually done more himself to a counsellee than just insult and slap. He looked at his hands. I've got to the point where I'll actually beat someone up myself, he realised. It was small comfort to him that he didn't get any pleasure out of it. He wondered vaguely whether he should just give up right now. Was there any point in going on with this when he was clearly bound to fail? But no—he couldn't assume that. Lancaster had seemed to think that he should be able to get through easily to a female counsellee. But then, of course, he knew very well what the Chief had in mind—female counsellees were usually threatened with rape. Yet Lancaster was aware of Carl's "hang-ups", as he called them. He would have known that Carl was hardly likely to take that approach. Or did he expect Carl to hand Winston over to the male Carers? What had the Chief been planning when he assigned Winston to him? The unfairness of the assignment was getting to him again, and he swore out loud, banging his hand on his desk. Emma looked up with a start. "Wh-what's the matter?" she blurted out automatically. Carl wasn't expecting such a question, and he also reacted automatically. "Oh, I was just thinking of the unfair—" He caught himself. "Miss Winston, I'm the one who asks the questions here, not you!" "Sorry, Sir," she said apologetically, and gritted her teeth because of the pain in her head. Carl looked at his watch and decided to end the session, even if it was a bit early. Make a fresh start tomorrow, he thought. "You're going back to your cell now," he said, "Tomorrow we'll start again, and I want you to think hard and consider how you'll cooperate." Emma nodded. Her head throbbed and she felt confused. Carl pressed the switch on his intercom. "Carer Janssen, come and fetch Number 143," he ordered. 69
Sonata for Flute
Janssen came in shortly, pulled Emma up roughly and led her out. Carl did not look up from his desk until the door slid shut. He mentally reviewed what had happened, and he felt sick. Why on earth had he so completely lost control? He dreaded having to review the recording of the session, which he would have to do that afternoon. He stood up to open the blind and caught sight of the broken glass and frame and crumpled print on the floor. He went and retrieved the picture, making a mental note to call in a cleaner later. The print was creased, and he did his best to smooth it out. He felt sad about the damage to the print. As the only one of his parents' things that he owned, it was a link with a nebulous but precious past. He rolled it up tightly and put it in his flute case. He would get a new frame for it sometime. His rage having abated, Carl felt empty and bewildered, and wondered again why this was happening to him. Why couldn't he just be like the other Counsellors, like the other Protectioners, sure of what they believed and always doing exactly what they were supposed to? He opened the blind and stared out of the window at the City Park and the Lake. A vague longing hovered in his mind. A longing for what? He didn't know. What he did know was that it was there more and more of the time, and it was like an ache that one couldn't exactly locate, but that was nonetheless there and just strong enough to upset all one's life. What he also knew was that there was nothing in the Protection which would remove the longing. He decided to go to the Monitoring Centre to collect the CD of the session. He would have a word with Andrew, whom he knew had been monitoring the session this morning. He was grateful that it was his friend who had been assigned to monitor his counselling sessions with Emma Winston. Andrew might even have some suggestions for the next session. At the very least, he could be counted on to be willing to listen.
70
Chapter 9
"Well, Carl," Andrew said, looking up from the recording desk as Carl came into the Monitoring Centre, "that was some performance this morning..." Carl scowled at his friend and sat down on a chair next to him. He stared unseeing at the bank of monitoring screens and control instruments in front of him. "I really botched it this time," he grumbled, "I'd been planning to start off gently, easily, but wouldn't you know it, that woman had to go and be so damned sure of herself!" He slammed his fist down on the desk as he said this, making Andrew jump, "She's just like that old man—you'd think Lancaster's doing it on purpose!" Andrew put his hand placatingly on Carl's shoulder. "Calm down, Mate, the session's over now," he said quietly, "Maybe Lancaster's suddenly got something against you, but you're not going to improve things—or get anywhere with that counsellee—the way you're getting yourself into a frenzy at the drop of a hat, you know." "I know! I know!" Carl almost yelled, "I don't know what's wrong with me, Andrew. I realize I've got a bad temper, but I seem to be going off the deep end continuously lately." He got up, stuffed his hands in his pockets and walked over to the CD file. "I'd better have a look at that recording before anyone else does," he muttered. "It's still in the recorder," Andrew told him, and reached over to remove the disc from the machine. He put it in a case and handed it to Carl, who had resumed his seat by the recording desk. "Tell you what, Mate," he said, "Why don't you have a break. Let's go have some lunch, then you can lock yourself in your office and get your flute out for an hour or so before you review that CD, okay? Then come and share one of Denise's culinary delights tonight before you go home. What do you say?" Carl looked at his friend gratefully. "Thanks, Andrew," he said quietly, "I'll do that." He watched as Andrew methodically switched off equipment, labelled CD cases, filled in the log, and checked that everything was in its place. At one point Andrew turned to him. "I don't think I labelled that disc," he said, "The one of your session this morning, I mean." He reached out for it and Carl handed it to him. He marked it and gave it back to Carl, who automatically read the sticker. Defective, it announced in Andrew's bold handwriting. He looked up at the Police Officer in surprise. Andrew grinned. "It happens now and then, you know," he said cheerfully, and winked, "I don't know what was wrong with the disc, but it's certainly a description of the recording. Rather messy, don't you think?" Carl was astounded. Did Andrew realise the risk he was taking by doing that? Yes, surely he must be aware of the close watch Lancaster kept on
71
Sonata for Flute
the Monitoring Centre records... He must feel pretty certain that the disc would not be missed. Carl sighed. "Thank you," he said. What else could he say? Andrew patted his shoulder, then rubbed his hands in satisfaction. "Well, everything's ship-shape in here," he announced, "Let's go get some tucker!" He led the way out of the Monitoring Centre, pausing by the door to register his departure in the compufiler log. As they were leaving it suddenly struck Carl that none of the other Centre staff had been there. He stopped in the doorway and glanced back around the room. "Hey, Andrew, where are the rest of the MC mob?" he asked. "They had a meeting with the Department Head. He told me to hold the fort," Andrew answered lightly, "Good thing, no?" He took Carl's arm and pulled him out of the way so he could shut the door, then he led him off towards the lift to the dining hall. Over a lunch of veal cutlets, cottage fries, and broccoli in cheese sauce, Andrew talked about his family, about music, about some of the other Police Officers' problems—anything to take his friend's mind off the morning's fiasco. But Carl was brooding, and kept coming back to the topic of Emma Winston, until Andrew gave up trying to distract him. "You're really upset, aren't you?" he remarked, "This is going to be just like your last lot of counselling, I can see. Or worse." "Just thinking about the fact that tomorrow brings another session with that woman is almost enough to make me want to scream," Carl muttered as he toyed with his food. He hadn't eaten much. "And today was only the first session!" he added. "She might turn out to be a lot less convinced about her beliefs than she seems," Andrew suggested. "Ha! You saw the whole session and you can say that?" Carl exclaimed angrily, "Anyone with half a brain can tell she's going to be at least as much trouble as Brown!" Andrew put his finger to his lips briefly. "Keep calm, Mate," he whispered, "This is the Institute dining hall, not your flat." "Sorry," Carl mumbled, stirring the cheese sauce around his plate with his knife, "Must try to keep calm. Wouldn't do to lose my temper here, would it?" He looked up at his friend. "What time do you want me to come over tonight?" "Straight from work. Is that all right with you? Gives us more time before curfew." "Fine," Carl said, and sighed, "Sometimes I wish I were back in the Welfare Ministry... Rescuing children and keeping tabs on Enwuh reps was far less trouble..." Andrew looked horrified. "Better keep such ideas to yourself, Carl," he said softly, "If anyone hears you say that you'll be in far more trouble than anything you've seen yet!" Carl sighed again and looked slowly around the dining hall. Few of the tables were occupied, as it was not yet lunchtime for most of the Institute 72
Sonata for Flute
staff. He recognized two of the Enwuh reps at a table halfway across the hall from them. They were not looking in his direction and so did not see him scowl, but Andrew, who had followed his gaze, did. "Time to get back to your office, Carl," he said warningly. "Yeah, you're right," Carl agreed. He, too, realised that his guard was too far down for his own good. He got up from the table and put on his cap. He smiled wearily at Andrew. "If you come up with any ideas on new counselling tactics," he said, "let me know, won't you?" Andrew grimaced. "Uh-uh," he said non-committally. "See you tonight," Carl said, and walked off. "Take care," Andrew replied, and watched him leave before continuing his meal. ! ! ! In her cell, Emma lay down on the mat and wept. Her head throbbed and she felt confused and frightened. She'd never met with such an outburst of rage, and she wondered briefly if the Counsellor was sane. She tried to pray, but could only manage, Dear God, help me, please. Lying on the floor, her face wet with tears and still sore from the Counsellor's slap, she finally drifted off to sleep. The clatter of a metal bowl being placed on the floor beside her woke her up, and she opened her eyes just in time to see a yellow-uniformed figure disappear as her door slid shut. She sat up carefully. Her headache was gone, but the bruise on the back of her head was very sore. She looked at the dish in front of her and realized that she was quite hungry. She had no idea what time it might be, but she knew that she hadn't eaten since tea the night before. In the bowl was a nondescript mush which didn't look very appetizing, but which smelled like some sort of stew. There was no spoon or other eating implement with it, and she wondered how they expected her to eat it. She shrugged, picked up the dish, and sipped the stew in small mouthfuls. It tasted all right, but it was a messy way to eat, as some of the stew dripped down her chin. She'd hardly finished when the panel in her door slid open, a hand came through, and a woman's voice called for the bowl. Emma handed it to her unseen guard, who withdrew her hand and slammed the panel shut. Emma stared at the door, and suddenly felt very alone. She thought of home, of Jack and Rose, and a wave of homesickness almost defeated her. Angry thoughts came to mind. Why had God let this happen? Hadn't she always done the right thing by Him? What had she done to deserve this? How could God have let this happen to her? With a start she realized where those thoughts were coming from. Thanking God for the reminder, she resolutely pushed them aside, and asked Him to keep her from dwelling on them should they return. I know that you love me, Lord, that you haven't let me down. Don't let me give in to self-pity, please. 73
Sonata for Flute
She sat back down on the mat, cross-legged, and considered her situation. She looked up at the lens in the ceiling and wondered if she was being observed. Although she didn't like the thought of it, she decided she couldn't let it worry her. It looked like her stay in this place could drag on a long time—the Counsellor certainly seemed like a determined man who would not give up easily. She thought of people she knew who had broken under "counselling" and denied the Lord. Would the accumulation of the kind of treatment she'd got today cause her to do the same? Deep down, she felt a reassurance that it would not. She wasn't here on her own. She remembered exhorting her fellow-prisoners to think of Joshua 1:9, "Don't be frightened or discouraged, for the LORD your God is with you wherever you go." Now she thought about that verse herself. And yet, she had been very frightened by the violence of Counsellor Slade's reactions. She had never seen anyone other than Police Officers behaving like that. What if the violence increased? What other forms of persuasion was he likely to try? Could she withstand such a daily onslaught of pain and fear? For weeks on end? The train of her thoughts switched track and she pondered on the Counsellor himself. What could make a man be so full of anger? Why did her words enrage him so? Did he really believe all that Protection stuff? She decided that he must believe it, or he wouldn't be trying to convince others of it. But surely then he needn't get so angry about it... Her thoughts turned into a prayer for him, and then into asking the Lord to help her to forgive him and to keep her from any bitterness towards him or the Carer. She thought back to the meeting the previous night—how wonderful it was that they had all assembled without anyone but the Lord planning it, without any announcement being made... And then it struck her—how had the Police known? Somehow they had found out about the meeting. She had to conclude that there had been a betrayer in the church, someone who had also been told about the meeting by the Lord, and then had used the information against His people... Or else the Mercers' house was being watched... On the other hand, God had known it would happen! The words of Isaiah 55 came to her mind unbidden: "I do not think the way you think, and My ways are not the same as yours," says the LORD. "As the skies are high above the earth, so My ways are far above yours and My thoughts are far above your thoughts. Just as the rain and the snow come down from the sky and water the ground to make it produce..., so My Word that comes out of My mouth will not be fruitless, but will accomplish all that I sent it for." Yes, God was with her here, He would see her through, for He had His plans and she was willing to fit in with them. She knelt and closed her eyes. Her heart was brimming over with love for her Lord. She thought of what Jesus Christ had endured for her sake, and she told Him that she was willing to go through anything He wanted her to, for Him. She knelt there praising and worshipping, for quite a long 74
Sonata for Flute
time, then feeling refreshed and encouraged, she sat back on her heels and wondered what time it could be. It looked like the light in her cell would be on all the time—there was no way for her to know if it was night or day. She would have to set herself some sort of routine. All right, the meal she'd been served a little while ago could be considered as lunch, she decided. Morning would be when the Carer came to get her for the counselling session. Would there be a session in the afternoon as well? No way of knowing unless it happened. After "lunch" she would spend time in prayer and meditating on the Scriptures she had memorized. She could also do some exercises so as to keep fit. She wondered if there would be an evening meal of some sort. Would she get to wash sometime? Already she was feeling rather grubby and her hair was quite tangled. She combed it out with her fingers as best she could. She decided to take her shoes off when she was in her cell, so she removed the blue sneakers that she'd been issued with the uniform and placed them by the door. What else could she do? Oh, yes, she could try and sing all the hymns and songs she knew, maybe even hum all the piano pieces she liked to play. Why not start right now? She began to sing, quietly at first, the first verse of Great is Thy Faithfulness. As she sang she felt more confident and sang more loudly. She thought of the many times she had sung this with Jack and Rose and the other believers, and was encouraged. "Shut up!" Carer Janssen's voice came over the speaker, "You are not allowed to speak or make any other noise!" Emma was startled, then dismayed. But not being one to stay down very long, she decided she could still sing in whispers or even in her heart, and proceeded to do so, working her way through half a dozen hymns and meditating on the words as well as singing them. At least the Carer could not hear her thoughts, only God could. For quite some time—several hours?—she was alone in her cell. No-one came to get her; no-one yelled through the speaker. Then suddenly the panel in the door slid open again, and a chunk of bread was thrown in. She went to pick it up and assumed that this must be tea. She sat down again and examined the bread. It wasn't exactly fresh, but at least it was food. She thanked the Lord for providing it, and ate it as slowly as possible, tearing off small pieces at a time and savouring each mouthful as long as possible. When she had finished the bread she had another drink of water, which she sipped very slowly, washing each mouthful around in her mouth before swallowing it. She deliberately moved slowly, trying to fill up the time which she could see could threaten to stretch out seemingly endlessly when she was in her cell. Finally, she made use of the covered bucket, then lay down on the mat and began, as on the previous night, to review her memorized Bible verses. But she was very tired, and didn't get through many verses before she fell asleep.
75
Chapter 10 Carl drove up to the block of flats where the Parkers lived and stopped his car in the visitors' carpark. It was still daylight, but he had not driven straight there from the Institute. Instead, he had gone for a drive right around the Lake before heading back towards the Parkers' home. He knew that Andrew and he had left the Institute at the same time, and he felt happier about giving his friend a chance to warn his family that he was coming for tea. He walked slowly up the stairs to the fourth floor, grateful that in his own building there was a lift, for he lived on the sixth floor of the Counsellors' Residence. He didn't like stairs much, they reminded him of the children's home. Andrew opened the door when he pressed the buzzer. "Come on in, Carl," he said, "How are you doing?" "A lot better than when you saw me at lunchtime, Andrew," Carl answered, "I went for a drive around the Lake before coming here. The Park is beautiful at this time of year. How's Denise?" "I'm fine, Carl," Denise laughed as she came up to the door behind her husband, "Let me take your jacket." He took his green coat off and handed it to her, and she hung it up on the coat-rack by the door. He hung his cap over it. "Why don't you go to the lounge, Carl," Andrew suggested, taking his wife's hand and leading the way, "You go sit down while I give Denise a hand with finishing the cooking." Christopher and Elsie came skipping over, greeting Carl happily. He gave each of them a hug and each took one of his hands and led him to the lounge, where they sat down, one on each side of him, on the sofa. The Parkers' lounge was living, dining, and playing room as well as Denise's study. It was not a big room, and the armchairs, dining suite, piano, and two cupboards took up most of the floor space. For Carl it was almost more home than his own flat, for he was always welcome in the Parkers' flat and never felt he was in the way. On more than one occasion he had spent the night on the Parkers' sofa when he hadn't got away before curfew, but he tried not to let that happen very often for he knew that staying overnight in other people's homes without Enwuh permission was frowned upon by the government. He also knew that the Enwuh rep lived on the same floor as the Parkers and that she had reported his overnight stay more than once. Andrew's children had known Carl all their short lives. As far back as they could remember he had been a regular visitor in their home, and he had always enjoyed spending some time playing with them and reading to them, even when they were babies. "Uncle Carl, please read us a story," piped Elsie, handing him a wellworn children's storybook that dated back to Denise's childhood.
76
Sonata for Flute
"Chris, Elsie," their father warned them, "Uncle Carl's had a very difficult day at work, so go easy on him, hey?" "It's okay, Andrew," Carl smiled, "This is probably the best medicine anyone could prescribe for me at this point." Andrew went off to join Denise in the kitchen and Carl opened the book and flipped through looking for a story he hadn't read too recently. He found one and began reading slowly, his deep voice calm and expressive. The children leant against him and listened attentively, even though they'd heard the story many times before. It was always special when Uncle Carl read to them. Carl delighted in the affection freely lavished on him by Andrew's children, and to them he was able to return affection in equal measure. Chris and Elsie were the only people with whom he had never lost patience, and this was something which hadn't escaped Andrew's observant eye. When Carl was with their children, Andrew and Denise caught glimpses of another side of their friend's character, one which they had also seen hints of on odd occasions when they'd had a good time playing music together. Much as Carl's foul temper often drove them to distraction, they couldn't help but assume from those glimpses that there was hope for him yet. There were times when Carl feared that the children might somehow find out what he was like at other times, when he wasn't with them. Would they also reject him, as almost every one else he had ever known did? What if they knew about the sort of work he did? What if, say, their schoolmates told them? He wasn't sure if schoolchildren would know the nature of a Police Counsellor's job, actually, but it was a fear that haunted him. He had voiced this to Andrew once, and his friend had immediately reassured him. "We've told Chris and Elsie that sometimes you get very angry, so if it did happen when they're around it wouldn't be a complete shock to them," Andrew had explained, "but we've also told them that it makes you very unhappy when you do lose your temper, and they understand that, because they don't like it when they get cross. I think as long as it wasn't directed at themselves they'd be able to cope with your temper, Carl. I think they'd be able to cope with knowing what your work is, too—they know it gets you down, they're not blind. They love you, Carl—we all do. No matter what, you're our friend, Carl, for real. Chris and Elsie think you're wonderful, and you are, you know. No matter what, Carl, you'll always be welcome here, you know that." To Carl, Andrew's words had been like a revelation. He knew that the Parkers considered him their friend, he knew he was always welcome in their home, but to hear Andrew actually say it had been like finding a shelter on a stormy night. He'd been speechless with gratitude, his blue eyes speaking all that he couldn't put into words, and Andrew had received his hug as the thanks it was meant to be.
77
Sonata for Flute
When Carl finished reading the children their story, Denise called them all to the table in the kitchen, and they sat down to eat. Carl felt the tensions of the day dissolve in the company of the Parker family. As they sat around the table and ate together they talked about many things, but the Counselling Institute was never mentioned. The meal over, Carl helped Andrew and Denise to clear the table and wash up. Unlike most of the Institute employees, Andrew ate his evening meals at home with his family, and washing up formed an important part of their custom. By choice, they didn't own a dishwasher. This was a time when Andrew and Denise could discuss all sorts of things that might be on their minds while Elsie and Chris played quietly in the lounge before their bedtime. Usually, when Carl came to tea he took part in these discussions, although on some occasions he would choose instead to play a game with the children before they went to bed. But the discussions in the kitchen were something he valued, for it was only with these friends that he could freely talk about whatever was on his mind. ! ! ! Their friendship had started when Andrew had been assigned to the Welfare Ministry to work as police escort for Welfare Officers on their "missions of mercy". Once, several years before, as they were driving out on one of their first jobs together, Carl had asked Andrew why he had joined the Police Force. "Same reason you went into Welfare work, Carl," Andrew had answered slowly, "I wanted to help uphold the Protection and to help people live in peace and safety." He'd been about to add something, but apparently had thought better of it, and changed the subject. At first, as they went about their errands for the Ministry they had been cautious in this way about their topics of conversation. And then one day, as they were travelling down the Southern Freeway to an assignment, they had heard a cello solo on the car radio, a rare occurrence. "One of my favourite pieces," Andrew had said suddenly and dreamily, "I wish I could play it that well!" Carl, astonished, had glanced quickly at him, wondering at his admitting to what amounted to Crooked Thinking. Was Andrew trying to trap him? For a moment he didn't know whether he should respond to Andrew's comment or not, but finally he'd decided to risk it. He had heard that there were one or two government officials besides himself who had odd habits. Lieutenant Parker might well be one of them. Oh, how he'd longed all those years for someone to whom he could talk openly! Carefully he'd turned down the microphone on the two-way radio and turned up the volume on the music. "Do you play the cello, then?" he'd asked Andrew in as casual a tone as he could muster, "I didn't think anyone in the Protectorate did." "I've been playing it since I was ten," Andrew had replied cheerfully, "I fell in love with the instrument after hearing a recording of Pablo Casals 78
Sonata for Flute
playing music by Bach. He was a master cellist in the middle of last century—Casals, I mean. I pestered my father for lessons until he agreed to pay for them. Of course that was long before the Protectorate, when they still had a cellist on staff at the School of Music." For how many years have I been longing for someone else to play music with? Carl had thought, I wonder if Andrew has too? "Do you know of any music for cello and flute together?" he'd asked. "Not offhand, but I could find out. Why?" "Well, I've played the flute since I was twelve. But I've only ever played by myself. It would be great to play duets. There are so few people in this country who play the classical instruments..." "Yeah, Fantasy Dreamers, Pleasure Houses, Personality Pills!" Andrew had exclaimed airily, waving his hands around, "No-one has the incentive or perseverance to do anything that means a little extra effort. And that includes making music on the classical instruments! Punch a few buttons on a synthesizer, yes! Practise for hours, no!" Fiercely, he had added, "Everyone's living in a fog of well-being, their minds slowly rotting away..." Carl had been thoroughly amazed. In all his thirty years he had no recollection of ever hearing anyone echo his own thoughts this way. "Don't you use any of those things?" he'd asked Andrew cautiously. "No way!" Andrew had answered, "Look, Mate, I value my mind, and I want to enjoy life, all of it! Those things dull your senses, stop your brain working properly, and what's more, they're addictive! Start taking part in those fantasies, keep popping pills to change your personality to suit the occasion, and soon you can't bear life in the real world! You end up glassyeyed, walking around in a daze, only coming alive in your FantasyDreamer. That's how it is with most of the people I know, except Denise. She's my girlfriend. She doesn't like them either. Do you make use of them?" Carl had been taken aback by Andrew's vehemence, but his heart had leapt for joy at finding someone of like mind after all his years of loneliness. All thoughts of caution and of a possible trap had flown as Andrew had been speaking. "Well, no, I don't, actually," he'd replied, "I've tried them, but I can't say I was attracted. Those Pills—I did try them once, I hoped they would help me control my temper. Well, they made me violently ill, and my temper was just as short as ever. The Fantasy Dreamer... That made me feel like I was disembodied, not really there, you know, sort of floating about. It was horrible! I've never felt inclined to visit a Pleasure House— vicarious sex doesn't draw me." "Doesn't attract me either," Andrew had said, and then had asked with apparent interest, "What about the real thing?" Carl had reddened considerably at the question. "Uh... I don't know," he'd muttered, "I've never found the right girl..." He'd quickly changed the subject. "We'll soon be getting to that house. You'd better get the warrant out so we can get this over with quickly. I can't bear the parents' reactions..."
79
Sonata for Flute
Later that day, as he'd prepared for bed, it had suddenly struck Carl that Andrew and he had shared their "Crooked" thoughts very freely, something which would normally be unthinkable, for to admit to such thoughts was asking to be "taken into care" by the Welfare Ministry. Most people had been well trained by the Neighbour Watchers to report immediately any cases of "Crooked Thinking". He himself had been known to report a neighbour or fellow-worker once or twice, and normally he knew better than to let anyone else know his own thoughts about anything. He'd been staggered at how easily he had thrown caution to the wind. Yet somehow he knew that he was safe with Andrew. There was something about that black man which told Carl that he could talk freely with him and his words would never be reported. What an incredible relief it had been to be able to talk freely! What had amazed him even more, however, was that Andrew had obviously trusted him, too... ! ! ! "If you don't mind my mentioning the Institute," Denise ventured to ask Carl as the three of them worked in the kitchen, "How are things going at work these days?" Carl hesitated. He glanced at Andrew, who raised his eyebrows but remained silent, then he stared at the dish he was drying up as he answered Denise's question. "If you really want to know, Denise," he said slowly, "Things at work are pretty bad. This current lot of counselling's got off to a very bad start." "Why do you say that?" she asked gently. "Why? Because I bungled it, I messed it up!" "Oh. How?" "Because of my rotten temper!" Carl said fiercely, "And because Lancaster assigned to me the most stubborn woman he could find." "He assigned a woman to you? Who's your counsellee?" Denise asked. Carl stared at her. Did the counsellee's identity matter? Denise had never asked him about names before. One didn't ask such questions. Again he looked at Andrew before answering. Andrew shrugged. "Her name's Emma Winston," Carl said hesitantly, "She's Jack Winston's sister. You know who he is, don't you? One of the Rebel leaders. Well, this Winston woman shows every sign of being as obstinate as Chester Brown. He was my last counsellee, and I failed to convert him. After my encounter with Chief Lancaster last night, the thought of another course of counselling ending in failure fills me with dismay." Denise looked surprised. "What makes you think you'll fail?" Carl hesitated again. Why was Denise asking him these questions? She had never done this before. But it was good to be able to talk about it, and with people who cared about him. And of course, that's why she was asking—because she cared. "Well, uh... my experience with that bloke Brown, for one thing," he answered, "The fact that I lost my temper 80
Sonata for Flute
thoroughly and disastrously in the very first session, for another, and the frightening fact that I'm not even sure if I subscribe to the Protection line any more, for a third..." Denise looked at Andrew and nodded. His guess had been right. Carl noticed the silent exchange and he looked at Andrew questioningly. "I thought as much," Andrew said quietly, "Just things you've said to me now and then... You'd better not mention that to too many people, Mate." "I won't, to anyone, you can be sure about that," Carl assured him, "But perhaps you two can help me?" "We can talk about it with you and listen to anything you care to tell us, and it'll be safe with us," Andrew said, "but in the end you have to make up your own mind, you know, we can't do that for you." "I know, but it's good to be able to talk about it, you know," Carl said quietly, "I feel like I'm going mad, sometimes, having to keep it all bottled up and being afraid I'll blurt it all out in my sleep or something." "No wonder you keep losing your temper," Denise said, "It must be awful to have doubts and no-one to turn to." "Well, Carl does have someone to turn to," Andrew said, and looking at Carl, added, "so don't you hesitate to turn to us, all right?" "All right," Carl replied, "Thanks. I won't." When they had finished clearing up, Denise got the children ready for bed while Andrew got out his cello and tuned it to the piano. When they were ready, Christopher and Elsie said their goodnights and were put to bed by their father. That done, the three adults went back into the lounge. Carl took his flute out of its case and assembled and tuned it to the piano while Denise and Andrew set up the music stands and looked through their collection of sheet music. "What do you fancy playing tonight?" Andrew asked Carl. "How about some of that Japanese music you found the other week?" Carl suggested. "Okay! Actually, Denise has been learning the piano accompaniment to some of those pieces, isn't that lucky?" Andrew handed the scores around, and Carl tried a few bars of the first piece. "Yes, I can still play this," he said, "Let's get on with it!" Andrew settled himself in his corner with his cello. "Denise, the piano plays the introduction," he said, "Off you go!" They played the first piece through, then the rest of the suite, and then went on to play other pieces for about an hour. By then the curfew was not far off, and Denise suggested they have a cup of tea before Carl had to leave. She went out to the kitchen while Carl and Andrew put away their instruments and music. "Thank you for that," Carl said as they worked, "It was a good remedy for my state of mind." "We ought to get Matt to join us here sometime with his violin," Andrew replied.
81
Sonata for Flute
Carl's reaction to the suggestion took him by surprise. "No way!" he exclaimed angrily, "Not one of Lancaster's successful Counsellors! Not after he's been commended for his perfect record at the same party where Lancaster told me off for failing with Brown! Didn't you see Matt smirk last night? Look, Andrew, at least while I'm involved in this round of counselling I do not want to see Matt Lewis, especially not here!" Andrew was annoyed that Carl should react this way. Yes, Matt was a successful Counsellor but he did play the violin, and because of this peculiarity he had few friends besides Carl and Andrew. "Aren't you being rather unfair, Carl?" Andrew said impatiently. "No, I'm not being unfair!" Carl was almost shouting now. "The one being unfair is the Chief! Why did he assign Emma Winston to me? Why not give Matt a challenge for a change? He gets all the easy cases! Now wonder he never fails!" Denise came running into the lounge, looking very apprehensive. "What are you two fighting about?" she said urgently, "Could you keep your voices down? You'll wake the children—and the Enwuh rep." They both looked at her in surprise, and then felt rather abashed. "It was my fault, Denise," Andrew said quietly, taking her hand. "I'm sorry," he added, turning to Carl, "I should have known better than to suggest something like that at this stage. Now I've gone and spoiled the evening for you." Carl looked sheepishly at the flute in his hands, his face red. "It's okay, Andrew," he replied, "I'm the one who spoiled the evening by blowing my top about it. I seem to be getting rather petty." He looked down a moment longer, took a deep breath, and looked up at them again. "Let's have that cup of tea," he said softly, "then I'd better leave before the curfew." He followed Andrew and Denise into the kitchen, where Denise poured out their tea. The three of them sat down around the table in silence. Carl felt ashamed about his outburst. Andrew was afraid to say anything more in case he put his foot in it again. Denise glanced from one to the other and waited for one of them to speak. Finally she broke the silence herself. "I hope you'll sleep well tonight, Carl," she said, "A good night's sleep should help you a lot." "I hope so too, Denise," he answered, "I certainly haven't been sleeping well lately. I seem to be having a lot of nightmares." "Well, let's hope tonight will be different," Andrew said. He looked at his watch. "You'd better get moving, you've got just long enough to get home before curfew." Carl got up and went to the lounge to pick up his flute case, and Denise and Andrew followed him to the door. He took his cap and coat down and put them on, then turned to his friends. "Thank you for a lovely evening," he said quietly, "I mean that. Sorry I messed it up at the end... You two are very good to me—I don't know where I'd be if it wasn't for you and the way you look after me." He paused, frowning at the floor as if trying to remember something. He was reluctant to go. Here was warmth and trust and love. Out there in the cold were only 82
Sonata for Flute
suspicion, hate, and loneliness. But he reminded himself that he knew he could come here whenever he needed to. He looked up at them again and smiled. "Good night, Denise, Andrew." "Good night, Carl," they answered. Denise added, "Take care. See you next time." Andrew opened the door to let him out. Carl smiled at them again, then turned and strode off towards the stairs. Andrew shut the door and he and his wife went back into their flat in a pensive mood.
83
Chapter 11
When Carer Janssen brought Emma to Counsellor Slade's office the next morning, she pushed Emma into the room and lingered at his door, her arms crossed, staring at him through her dark glasses and hating him. Carl, sitting behind his desk, was irritated by Janssen's continued presence. "You may leave, Carer," he said testily, "You'll be called when needed." He was well aware that he had no intention of calling her for anything other than to take Emma back to her cell at the end of the session. He had made a firm decision—he would not be handing this counsellee over for treatment. After having seen, earlier that morning, some of the recordings of the treatment Chester Brown had undergone, there was no way he would be handing any more counsellees over to the Carers. He had no words to describe how he had felt when he'd seen to what he had sent Chester Brown. That the old man had stood firm in his faith through all that was incomprehensible to him, and he found himself admiring Brown and wondering what could have made him so strong in the face of all that he had suffered. But there was no way he wanted to put anyone else through such treatment, no matter how stubborn they might be. He pressed the switch to make his door slide shut and Carer Janssen stepped back just in time to avoid it. He locked the door, then turned his attention to Emma who was standing by the chair in front of his desk. He didn't tell her to sit down. Instead, he got up and came around to the front of his desk, crossed his arms, and looked down at her. "Have you thought at all about changing your views since yesterday?" he asked her. "No, Sir," Emma replied, levelly, "I told you I've no intention of changing my views." She winced involuntarily, expecting a reaction like the previous day's. Carl clenched his fists but controlled himself. He walked brusquely away from her, considering his next move. He returned to his seat behind the desk. "Sit down," he ordered, and Emma obeyed. "Perhaps we ought to discuss this matter for a bit," he suggested reasonably, "I realize that it's possible that with the upbringing you had you may be confused to such an extent that only an exposition of the errors in your ideas will help you see how futile they are." "Sir, in my experience they are not futile," Emma said quietly. Here we go again, he thought, She's interrupting already. He looked daggers at her. "You've been warned about speaking out of turn," he said menacingly, "Kindly stop doing it." He paused for a moment to let the warning sink in, then started on his lecture. "The Protection assures us that everyone has certain rights which are to be respected as long as they do not disrupt the order of our society. Your religious beliefs are disruptive. Your religion says that you're better than other people—" "It does not!" Emma exclaimed.
84
Sonata for Flute
"Shut up!" Carl yelled, and banged his fist down on his desk. Emma jumped. I must try to stop interrupting him, she told herself. And yet, how can I be silent when he attacks the Truth? Carl succeeded in calming himself down. "You believe that you're the only ones who are right, but you're mistaken," he went on, "There's no such thing as absolute truth, as you claim. There are many roads to fulfillment, many ways of looking at life, many styles of living. Some are right for some people, others are right for other people. Thus they are, all of them, right. You can't say that your way is right and someone else's is wrong because it's different from yours. You must remember that for our society to progress, it must be made up of happy, self-fulfilled citizens, and each one's path to self-fulfillment is an individual choice." "'There is a way that seems right to a man, but in the end it leads to death.' Proverbs fourteen, verse twelve," Emma offered. Carl was speechless. Chester Brown had said something like that to him, and to have Emma repeat it infuriated him. Still trying very hard to keep his temper, he groped for some answer to what she'd said, and grasped at the last word she'd said. "Death is only a gateway," he said, "the way to the next step in the process of self-realization and union with the Universal. Each death and re-incarnation brings one closer to that ultimate destination." "I'm not talking about physical death," she pointed out, "I'm talking about spiritual death, eternal separation from God." "Since there is no such thing as God, your talk is nonsense," Carl replied. "Do you really believe that?" Emma asked gently, but incredulously. Carl stared at her. The question was one that until recently he had always avoided asking himself, and now here he was being asked it by one of his counsellees for the second time in less than two months. When Brown had asked him the same question, he'd just called in the Carer to "set the old man straight". Now he was angry at Emma for rubbing an increasingly sore spot. There was no calling the Carer in this time, however. Not only that, but he knew that he wasn't sure any more what he believed or didn't believe, and this only increased his agitation. "Of course I believe it!" he snapped, rather too defensively, "Stop interrupting!" He looked down in confusion at the notes he had been using. What had he been telling her? Something about self-fulfillment... He took a long breath. "At the end of the last century," he continued, "before the Protectorate was established, a movement which was the forerunner of the Protection had already started in this country. There was complete freedom of expression and the Arts flourished." For some unfathomable reason he suddenly thought of his Redouté print and the old masters reproductions in his flat and contrasted them with what was now called Art. He pushed the thought away hastily and went on with his talk. "Alternative lifestyles became completely acceptable and the family was redefined," he said, "We see the results of that revolutionary movement in the great diversity of family groups in our city. The only dissenting voice 85
Sonata for Flute
in those days, and even still today, was that of the Christians and the Jews and other people we know as Rebels, who keep insisting that life should be directed by the tenets in a book many thousands of years out of date." Emma couldn't contain herself. "God's Word is eternal and it doesn't change just because you want it to!" she blurted out. Carl glared at her. "God does not exist, Miss Winston," he repeated, pointedly and angrily, "What you call God's Word is just a collection of writings put together by ignorant men centuries ago. They are quite irrelevant to twenty-first century people!" Emma stared at him open-mouthed. She knew—she knew to the depths of her being—that God does exist, that without Him nothing else can exist, even that He was right there with them at that moment, but she couldn't prove it, she couldn't show Him to Counsellor Slade, she didn't even know how to respond to his statement. Lord, I've got to leave it to You to show him, she prayed in her heart, I can't do it, I don't know how. Please show him You're real. To her surprise and Carl's, she burst into tears. "What are you crying about?" he asked, his tone annoyed. "I-I don't know," she stammered, "No. I mean yes, I do know," she added, tears streaming down her face, "I'm crying because you blasphemed and you have no idea of what you've done. And because God does exist and you don't even know it. And you don't even know how much He loves you. Because you're lost. And because you think His Word is irrele—" As she spoke Carl lost his hold on his mounting fury. He got up and walked around his desk, and grabbing her by the arm he pulled her up from her chair and slapped her over and over. Then he threw her to the floor and began kicking her, pouring out his rage. "Stop it! Stop it!" he roared, "I don't want to hear about your God and His Word! Shut up! Shut up! Do you understand?! Do you?!" Emma held her arms over her head and tried to keep her mouth shut. He kicked her side, and she was unable to stop herself crying out in pain. Her cry brought Carl back to his senses. He looked down at her in horror. His thoughts were in a whirl and sweat was pouring down his face and his back. He felt as if he were two people—one a monster who did such things, the other a man whose world was falling apart and who was pleading for help. Completely bewildered by his own behaviour, he pulled Emma up by her arm and almost threw her back onto her chair, where she just caught herself from falling off. She bent over in pain, and was breathing in short, noisy gasps. Carl stood for a few minutes with his back to her, his arms crossed, trying to catch his breath and staring at the place on the wall where the print of the rose had hung. He had never before attacked anyone so viciously. Was he going mad? At that idea, he put the blame on her—why did she have to provoke him? How long was she going to go on like this? Finally he turned around but avoided looking at her. "You have no choice but to change your ideas or you'll have to undergo much worse
86
Sonata for Flute
treatment," he said crossly, though his anger was not directed at her this time. Emma was taking shallow breaths because of a sharp pain in her side, and had difficulty speaking. "I-I can't change m-my ideas, Sir," she replied, "I c-can't turn m-my back on God. How c-can a person choose to return to d-darkness once they've known His light?" He had no idea what she was talking about, and this only added to his distress. He went back to his seat behind the desk. "You're going back to your cell," he said wearily, "You'd better consider turning to the light of the Protection before it's too late!" He pressed the intercom switch and called Janssen to take Number 143 back to her cell. When they had gone, he crossed his arms on his desk and buried his face in them. ! ! ! Towards the end of the second week of counselling Emma Winston, Carl decided that he would have to find some other approach if he was to get anywhere with her. He needed to discuss her case with someone else, but he found himself reluctant to talk it over with any of the other Counsellors, or even the Department Head. He was acutely aware that having a woman counsellee assigned to him had caused him to become an object of ridicule at the Institute. Everyone knew that Lancaster had demoted him on the same night that he'd commended Matt Lewis. The worst of it was that, apart from his failures earlier in the year and then his failure with Chester Brown, he had no idea what he done that he had ended up on the wrong side of the Chief. Other Counsellors who'd failed—more often than he had, even—were still working as usual. The other, and perhaps more compelling, reason for his reluctance to consult with his colleagues, were his doubts about the Protection itself. He could hardly confide his waverings to hard-line Protectioners! In the end he made up his mind to talk about Emma Winston's case with Andrew again. Andrew—the faithful friend who kept picking him up whenever he went to pieces! He could tell him anything and he was never betrayed, even when Andrew was angry with him. Andrew would listen, and he would think about it, and he might even have some answers. Andrew was a gentle man who took an interest in people and was always ready and willing to lend a hand, a very rare thing in the Protectorate. It never occurred to Carl to wonder why Andrew was the way he was, though he'd sometimes puzzled about how he got away with so much apparently "Crooked Thinking" in his kind of job. Andrew was the one true friend he had and he was simply grateful for him. The other good reason for consulting Andrew was that he'd been monitoring his sessions with Emma, and he'd monitored a large number of Carl's counselling assignments since they'd both arrived at the Institute five years before. He should be familiar with Carl's counselling procedures. 87
Sonata for Flute
Except that he hadn't exactly been using his usual procedure with Winston... It did occur to Carl then that it was perhaps strange that his career and Andrew's had been linked in one way or another even when they'd been moved from the Welfare Ministry to the Counselling Institute. He mused about this. Should it seem strange? It was almost as if someone had planned it that way. Was it just a coincidence that his closest friend should be the one monitoring his work? It struck him suddenly how painful it must be for Andrew to have that job. What kept him in the Police Force? For that matter, why did he stay on at the Institute? Andrew had agreed to meet him at the City Park after work. They walked along the lakeside in silence for a while, watching the water and the moorhens, until finally Carl began to talk. "Andrew, does your job ever get you down? Have you ever thought of changing jobs?" he asked his friend. "Not the way yours gets you down," Andrew replied, "but yes, I do find it extremely unpleasant at times. And yes, I've often wondered if I shouldn't change jobs." "What keeps you at the Institute, then? Aren't there any other options?" Andrew smiled as if he were privy to a secret that he wasn't about to share, but Carl's eyes were on the water of the Lake. "Oh, there are plenty of other options," Andrew said, "but so far I don't feel right about moving. It's hard to explain, but for the time being it seems I'm where I belong." Carl looked at him for a moment, puzzled by his answer. He sighed. "I, for one, am very glad that you're there," he said, "but sometimes I find it strange that almost from the start we've been teamed up in some way." "Perhaps you shouldn't worry about it and just make the most of it," Andrew replied, and laughed, much to Carl's annoyance. On a more serious note, he added, "But surely that's not what you wanted to talk about, is it?" Carl stopped at one of the picnic tables scattered throughout the Park. "You're right. What I need to talk about is my current counsellee and how to deal with her. Let's sit down, shall we?" They sat down, one on each side of the table. Carl had his back to the Lake, and he turned around on the bench, leaning back against the table, so he could face it. He gazed at the water and watched a small flotilla of ducks gliding past. "Andrew," he began, "you've seen how my sessions with Emma Winston have been going. You've seen me lose my temper more times than I care to remember. You've seen a side of me in those sessions that has no doubt horrified you—it's certainly horrified me. You can remember the course I put Chester Brown through and how I failed with him. Do you have any suggestions which might help me get through this course without failing?" He added in almost a whisper, "And without killing my counsellee?" Andrew had been tracing the patterns on the concrete table top with his finger as he listened to Carl. He continued to do so as he considered Carl's question. He didn't answer for some minutes. 88
Sonata for Flute
At last he got up and walked around to Carl's side of the table, his hands in his trouser pockets. "Well, Mate, I don't know if my comments can help you or not," he said at last, "but I'll give them to you, for all they're worth, since you ask." He stood half-facing the Lake, half-facing Carl. His friend continued gazing at the water. "Point one," he said, "It's pretty obvious to me that Emma Winston is not going to budge, no matter what you do to her—and you haven't exhausted the possibilities, as you know. But this is my first comment, Carl—you are going to fail, as you put it. You're not going to succeed in getting her to deny her faith. You're going to have to cope with that. I may be wrong, of course, but to me, her position looks no different from Chester Brown's. I think you said as much yourself back on the first day." Having hoped for some words of encouragement from Andrew, Carl was dismayed at hearing the opposite. His heart sank as he realized that he had to agree with Andrew's analysis. He rested his elbows on his knees and held his head on his hands as if it ached. "Surely it can't be that hopeless," he said, knowing full well that it was. Emma Winston was a rock-steady believer. "Don't you think there's some approach I haven't tried that just might work?" he asked Andrew. "Point two," Andrew said quietly, not answering him, "Your uncontrollable temper keeps getting in your way, it keeps fouling everything up. Unless you can master it, Carl, you'll end up killing either yourself or your counsellee, or both. Forty is still too young to die of a heart attack, you know... or worse... And as you know, a dead counsellee isn't likely to get you back into the Chief's good books, either!" "Andrew!" Carl jumped up and grabbed his friend's shoulders, "You know I've tried and tried and tried to control my anger! I can't do it! Just when I think I've finally achieved it something happens and it's worse than ever! That last session with the Winston woman, this morning—I thought I'd finally managed to stay calm for a whole session, and I even thought she was beginning to actually pay attention. And what did she go and do? She quoted all this stuff from her Bible which contradicted everything I'd just said! She just sat there and lectured me with it!" He flung up his arms in exasperation, then stuffed his hands in his pockets and scowled at the ground. "You saw how I reacted to that..." he said despondently. Andrew came up and placed a hand on his shoulder. "Yeah, I saw," he said, "She's got two awful black eyes now, and probably a whopping headache..." Carl was startled to feel his friend shudder. "My point still stands, though," Andrew continued, "and you've only confirmed it. Your quick temper is a big handicap." He paused, then added, "And may I suggest that you try and keep calm while we're out in the open, what's more." Carl walked down to the edge of the lake. The dark water was lapping the bank in little oily waves. He crouched down, picked up a pebble and
89
Sonata for Flute
tried to skip it across the water, unsuccessfully. The pebble just sank. He sighed deeply. Andrew joined him by the water's edge and stood watching him. He did not stand up, but continued trying to skip pebbles. "Have you ever considered suicide, Andrew?" he suddenly asked, quietly, "Have you ever felt that your life had become so unbearable that the only thing you could possibly do was to end it?" What's he leading to? Andrew wondered, taken by surprise by the question. "No," he answered, "I can't say I have. Have you?" "Yes." Carl kept throwing in pebbles, some of which skipped many times, some of which just disappeared into the water. He didn't say any more, and Andrew waited to see if he would. After a while Carl looked up at him. "I was just thinking that perhaps that would be best, you know—to let myself sink beneath the surface of the Lake, like the pebbles that get to the end of their skipping. I don't mean that literally—I'm a coward and drowning is too much of a challenge. I'd make it an overdose of sleeping tablets. Sink beneath the surface of sleep. Go to bed and never wake up again." He threw in a pebble, hard. "No more having to face Lancaster." Another pebble. "No more having to cope with my temper." A third one. "No more having to deal with Emma Winston..." As he said her name, he became aware, with a shock, that he actually liked Emma Winston and her strong faith. He became aware that the last thing he wanted was for her to deny her faith. He wanted her to remain rock-steady. He liked her faith. He liked her. He stood up hastily. He now felt even more bewildered than ever. This was a complication he had never expected. Andrew was silent. He felt Carl's anguish pierce his heart. He himself had never got to such a low point that suicide seemed desirable. The very idea made him feel sick. Yet here was his best friend actually talking about killing himself, and the tone of his voice convinced him that it wasn't idle talk. To Andrew, ever the optimist, Carl's situation didn't look anywhere near that disastrous. It was clear to him, however, that Carl saw it very differently. He was not aware, of course, of the complications to which Carl had just then woken up. Carl sighed again, and stared out over the lake. Feeling quite incapable of facing it, he pushed his new dilemma to the back of his mind, and returned to the question of suicide. "It happened when I was counselling Brown, too," he said, "I even worked out the dose I'd need and bought the tablets." He smiled wryly at Andrew. "Do you know what stopped me?" he asked. His friend shook his head, his dark eyes watching Carl with compassion.