Errett Albert Bishop speaking at the 50th summer meeting of the Mathematical Association of America in Eugene, Oregon in 1969. His topic was "The Constructive Point of View."
SELECTED PAPERS Errett Bishop
,~ World Scientific
-~PUbiished
by
World Scientific Publishing Co Pte Ltd. P. O. Box 128, Farrer Road, Singapore 9128 242, Cherry Street, Philadelphia PA 19106-1906, USA
The publisher would like to thank the following for granting permission to reproduce the reprinted papers included in this volume. American Mathematical Society (Bull. A mer. Math Soc, Proc. A mer. Math. Soc., Proc Sympos. Pure Math., Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.); Annales de L'Institut Fourier; Annals of Mathematics; Duke University Press (Duke Math. 1.); Indiana University Mathematical Journal (J. Math. Mech.); Kluwer Group (Function Algebras); Michigan Mathematical Journal; Pacific Journal of Mathematics; Springer-Verlag (Proc. Cant. Complex Analysis); The Johns Hopkins University Press (Amer J. Math.); VAAP (Proc. Int '/. Congr Math.)
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Bishop, Errett, 1928-1983 Selected papers. Bibliography: p xxiii 1. Functional analysis. 2. Bishop, Errett, 1928 -1983. I. Title. QA321.B5725 1986 515.7 ISBN 9971-50-127-9
86-22420
Copyright © 1986 by World Scientific Publishing Co Pte Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereot. may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the PubliSher.
Printed in Singapore by Fong and Sons Printers Pte. Ltd.
CONTENTS
Vita - Errett Bishop
vii
Introduction John Wermer
ix
Bibliography of the Publications of Errett Bishop
xxiii
Reprinted Papers
(1]
Spectral Theory for Operators on a Banach Space
[2]
Subalgebras of Functions on a Riemann Surface
1
33
(3) Measures Orthogonal to Polynomials
55
[4] The Structure of Certain Measures
58
[5] Approximation by a Polynomial and its Derivatives on Certain Closed Setsr
65
[6]
A Duality Theorem for an Arbitrary Operator
73
[7]
A Minimal Boundary for Function Algebras
92
[8] Some Theorems Concerning Function Algebras
106
[9] The Representations of Linear Functionals by Measures on Sets of Extreme Points
108
[10]
Simultaneous Approximation by a Polynomial and its Derivatives
135
[11]
Boundary Measures of Analytic Differentials
138
[12]
A Generalization of the Stone- Weierstrass Theorem
148
[13]
A Proof that Every Banach Space is Sub reflexive
155
[14] Mappings of Partially Analytic Spaces
157
[15] Some Global Problems in the Theory of Functions of Several Complex Variables
191
[16] Partially Analytic Spaces
211
[17] A General Rudin-Carleson Theorem
235
[18] Analytic Functions with Values in a Frechet Space
239
[19] Analyticity in Certain Banach Algebras
255
[20] The Support Functionals of a Convex Set
293
[21] Holomorphic Completions, Analytic Continuation, and the Interpolation
302
of Semi-Norms
[22] Representing Measures for Points in a Uniform Algebra
335
[23] Conditions for the Analyticity of Certain Sets
337
[24] Uniform Algebras
353
[25] Differentiable Manifolds in Complex Euclidean Space
363
[26] Constructive Methods in the Theory of Banach Algebras
384
[27] An Upcrossiog Inequality with Applications
387
(:29]
400
A Constructive Ergodic Theorem
[30] The Constructivization of Abstract Mathematical Analysis
vi
409
VlTA*
Errett Bishop was born July 14, 1928. He received a Bachelor of Science degree in 1947, a Master of Science in 1949, and a Ph. D. in 1955 allfrom the University of Chicago. From 1950 to 1952 he was in the U. S. Army stationed at the Bureau of Standards in Washington, D. C. carrying out mathematical research in ordnance. His academic positions are listed: Instructor of Mathematics 1954-1957 1957-1959 Assistant Professor of Mathematics 1959-1962 Associate Professor of Mathematics 1962-1965 Professor of Mathematics all at the University of California, Berkeley. Professor of Mathematics University of California, San Diego.
1965 -1983
Bishop held a Sloan Foundation Fellowship from 1958 to 1961. In 1961-1962 he was a member of the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton. He was a Miller Fellow during the year 1964-1965. Bishop gave a number of distinguished invited lectures, among them an invited talk to the International Congress of Mathematicians at Moscow, USSR (1966), the Hedrick lectures of the Mathematical Association of America (1969), and the Colloquium Lectures of the American Mathematical Society (1973). He was elected a fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Science. His doctoral students at UCSD were James D. Brom (1974), Yuen-Kwok Chan (1969), Henry Cheng(1971), Merrill B. Goldberg (1969), John A. Nuber (1969), and Jonathan B. Tennenbaum (1973). Those at UCB were Laura Ketchum Kodama (1963), Thomas Morton Creese (1964 ), and Michael Benton Freeman ( 1965 ).
*Ileprinted from Contemporary Mathematics (1985), Errett Bishop, Vol. 39, p. xiiI, by permission of the American Mathematical Society. The last sentence was added separately.
vii
INTRODUCTION
Errett Bishop's mathematical work was divided between complex and functional analysis, on the one hand, and constructive mathematics on the other hand. He made fundamental discoveries in each of these areas, and the influence of these discoveries is still strongly felt today. From 1955, when he wrote his Ph. D. theSis, to 1964, he worked on analysis within the framework of classical mathematics. A stream of original ideas poured forth from rum and his work showed over and over again the essential unity of the "abstract" and the "concrete" in mathematics. From 1964 to the end of his life he rejected classical mathematics and devoted himself to developing and explaining constructive mathematics. In particular he wrote the book Foundations of Constructive Analysis, McGraw-Hill, 1967, in which he "develops a large portion of abstract analysis witrun a constructive framework" . The discussion which follows gives a brief introduction to Bishop's papers on classical mathematics. This work may be grouped in four areas.
1) Polynomial and rational approximation in the complex plane and their generalization to Riemann surfaces Papers 2, 3, 4, 5, 10, 11, in LIST I 2) The general theory of uniform algebras Papers 7, 8,12,17,19,22 in LIST I 3) Banach spaces and operator theory Papers 1,6,9,13,20 in LIST I 4) Several complex variables Papers 14, 15, 16,18,23,25 in LIST I There is of course some overlap between the subject matter of papers in different categories.
1) Polynomial and Rational Approximation In 1952 a long development, starting with Runge's and Weierstrass' approximation theorems, had culminated in the follOWing result:
ix
MERGELYAN:s' THEOREM: Let K be a compact set in the z -plane with
In this first paper on approximation theory, [2] , Bishop extended Mergelyan's theorem to an open Riemann surface ~. Denote by R the algebra of all holomorphic functions on ~ and replace the polynomials in z by a subalgebra R' of R containing the constant functions. Fix a compact set K on ~ and denote by R' (K) the uniform closure of R' on K. The basic problem is to find conditions under wluchR'(K) coincides with the set of all functions continuous on K and analytic on int K. This problem is completely solved in [2], (Theorem 1 and corollaries). The hypothesis "
max If lover K". The methods used, Bishop writes, "are highly measure-theoretic and make constant use of the fact that any bounded linear functional on the space of all continuous complexvalued functions on K can be represented as a Borel measure on K". In view of the Hahn -Banach theorem, the approximation problem under consideration is then equivalent to the problem of identifying the measures on K which are orthogonal to R'. (Unless otherwise specified, all measures considered are complex-valued and of finite total mass.) As a tool in this study, Bishop proved the following result (Lemma 6) which became known as "Bishop's Splitting Lemma". Let F be a compact subset of
[GI-We) and [Gil). Proofs of Melgelyan's theorem based on Bishop's ideas but simpler than his proof in [II) are found in [GI-We), [We 1) and rCa 1). Papers [5) and [10) are concerned with the following problem: given a compact set K in the complex plane and given continuous functions fo , f1 , ... ,fn on K, can a sequence of polynomials {Pk} be found such that Pk converges to fo uniformly on K and for each i the ith derivative pf) approaches fi uniformly on K, I " i " n? Let in particular K be a Jordan arc. Clearly if K has a rectifiable subarc, this problem is not solvable for arbitrary fj. However, under a mild regularity condition, Bishop showed in [5] that the desired approximation is possible provided that K has no rectifiable subarc. In [10] a related problem is solved.
2) The General Theory of Uniform Algebras Let K be a compact subset of the z-plane. Denote by (JJ(K) the collection of all functions which are uniform limits on K of polynomials in z. For PE(JJ(K), put liP II = max IP (z) I for z E K. Then (JJ(K) is an algebra of continuous functions on K, and, in the given norm, a normed algebra. The normed algebra (JJ(K) has the following properties: (i) It is complete in its norm, or, equivalently, it is closed under uniform convergence onK.
(ii) It separates points of K. (iii) It contains the constants.
Let X now be an arbitrary compact Hausdorff space and consider an algebra .sI of complex-valued continuous functions defined on X which satisfies the corresponding properties. with IIf II = max If I over X, s.f is complete in its norm, separates point on X and contams the constants. Bishop coined the name uniform algebra for such an algebra. It was one of Bishop's achievements to bring to light a series of general properties of uniform algebras which connect them with the study of concrete questions concerning analytic functions, operator theory and other parts of analysis. ( a) The generalized Stone- Weierstrass theorem Marshall Stone has shown that, in our terminology, a uniform algebra .sI on X which is self-adjoint, i.e. is closed under complex conjugation, contains every continuous function on x. In symbols: .sI = C(X). Suppose now that .sI is a uniform algebra not known to be self-adjoint. For each subset S of X let s% denote the restriction of sI to Sand call S a set of anti-symmetry if each real-valued function in ~ is constant. Bishop's generalization of Stone's result, given in [12] , is the following. Theorem. There exists fl partition 'IT of X into disjoint closed sets of anti-symmetry such that if a function fin C(X) has, for each S in 'IT, a restriction to S which belongs to sis, then f is in .st.
Moreover, ~ is closed in C(S) for each S in 1T, and the elements of 1T can be taken to be the maximal sets of anti-symmetry. A theorem of similar nature, but with a weaker conclusion, had been proved by Silov in [Si 1] , and was the origin of Bishop's work. A simplified proof of Bishop's theorem was given by Glicksberg in [Gl 2].
(b) Peak points and the minimal boundary A famous result of Silov, [Si 2] , asserts that, if .s:1' is a uniform algebra on X then there exists a smallest closed subset S of X, the Silov Boundary of .s:1', such that every function in .s:1' attains its maximum absolute value at some point of S. Does there exist a smallest subset M of X (not necessarily closed) with the same property? If M exists, it is called the Minimal Boundary of .s:1'. I.et us call a point x in X a peak point of .s:1' if there exists f in .s:1' such that f(x) = 1, If (y ) I < 1 if Y E X\{ x}. Clearly each such peak point will have to belong to the minimal boundary, if there is one. In [7] Bishop proved:
Theorem: Let sI be a uniform algebra on the compact metnzable space X. Then sI has a minimal boundary M and M coincides with the set ofpeak points of sI. lt follows that the set of peak points is a dense subset of the Silov boundary of .s1' . Bishop further showed that the minimal boundary is a Go -set. Next he proved, under the preceding hypothesis:
Theorem. Let x be a point of X\M where M is the minimal boundary of.s1' Then there exists a non-negative Borel measure f..l on X\{x}, of total mass 1, such that f(x) = fdf..l for all f in sI
f
In later work, joint with DeLeeuw, Bishop showed that f..l can be taken to lie onM. Perhaps the most amazing result of [7] was a necessary and sufficient condition in terms of peak points for rational approximation in the plane. Let X be a compact set in the z -plane WIth empty interior. Denote by R (X) the class of functions on X which can be uniformly approXImated on X by rational functions with poles in (J:\X. ThenR(X) is a uniform algebra on X. Let M denote the set of peak points of R (X).
Theorem: R(X) = C(X), i.e. every continuous function on X is a limit of rational functions, if and only if X\M has measure 0 (in particular is void). The proof, using properties of the Cauchy transform of a measure, is very short. This result gave rise to a question known as the Peak Point Conjecture Let.s1' be a uniform algebra on a compact metric space X such that X is the full maXImal ideal space of .xi and each point of X is a peak point of sf. Does it follow that .s1' = C(X)? The empirical evidence was strongly in favor of this conjecture, since uniform algebras other than C( X) in most known cases have analytic structure in their maximal ideal space, and this produces points in X which are not peak points. However, the answer is No in general, as was shown by Brian Cole in 1968. ([Co]; see also Basener [Ba] , for another example.)
(c) Interpolation
Let f be the unit circle in the z-plane and A (f) the space of all continuous functions on f which admit analytic extension to the open disk I z I < 1. A (f) is a closed subspace of C(r). Let E be a closed set on f of Lebesgue measure O. In [Ri], F. and M. Riesz showed that if JJ. is any Borel measure on f which is orthogonal to A (f), then JJ. restricts to the O-measure on E. In [17], Bishop generalized this as follows: Let B be a closed subspace of the space C(X), where X is a compact Hausdorff space. (B is not assumed to be an algebra.) For each Borel measure on X, denote by jl the regular Borel extension of /1. Theorem: Let E be a closed subset of X such that, whenever JJ. is a measure on X which is orthogonal to B, then jl restricts to the O-measure on E. Then E is an interpolation set for B, i e. the restriction of B to E is C( E). Moreover, iff is in C( X) and g is a positive function in C( X) with If I < Ig I on E, then there exists F in B with F = f on E and IF I < Ig Ion X.
This theorem was suggested by, and contains, the corresponding result when X = f and B = A (f), which had previously been obtained by Rudin, [Ru] , and Carleson, rCa 2]. In VIew of the above-mentioned result of F. and M. Rlesz, the hypothesis of the theorem is fulfilled in this case for each closed subset E of f having Lebesgue measure O. For extensions of Bishop's theorem, see Glicksberg [G12] . ( d) Gleason parts
Andrew Gleason in [Glea I] introduced a decomposition of the maximal ideal space X of a uniform algebra .sf as follows: Points x and y in X are equivalent if there is some € > 0 such that If(x) - f(y) I .;; (2 - €) whenever fE,#, IIfll .;; l. He shows that this is indeed an equivalence relation on X. The equivalence classes are called the Gleason Parts of X. A representing measure 0 for a point x in X is a probability measure on X such that Jfdo=f(x) for all fin 4. In [22] Bishop proved the following, extending earlier results of Gleason. Theorem: Fix sf, X as above and let x and y belong to the same Gleason part. Then there exists c > 0 and representing measures Ox for x and 0y for y such that cox';; 0y ';;(C)-lox'
An independent proof of thIs result was given by Gleason (unpublished). ( e) Jensen measures
Let D be a bounded plane domain with smooth boundary aD. Fix Z 0 in D. The harmonic measure JJ.z of Zo relative to D is a probability measure on aD which represents o the value at Zo of a harmonic function on D as a boundary integral. It follows that JJ.z is o a representing measure, (in the sense defined in (d) above) for z 0 for the uniform algebra A (D) consisting of all functions which are analytic on D and continuous on the closure of D. Moreover, JJ.z has the property that Jensen's inequality holds, i.e. that log If(zo) I o
xiii
..;; flog If(z) Idtl zo (z) for each f in A (D). This is a consequence of the fact that log If I is subharmoruc on D . In [21] Bishop generalized Jensen's inequality in the following way: Let sf be a uniform algebra on X and let r denote the Silov boundary of .Pi. Theorem: Fix x in X There exists a probability measure tl on flog If(y) Idtl(y), f E S¥ .
r
such that log If(x) I..;;
This theorem strengthens an earlier result of Arens and Singer, [Ar-Si]. A measure satisfying the inequality above is called a Jensen Measure for x. Such a measure is automatically a representing measure for x. Jensen measures have proved to be extremely useful in the study of uniform algebras and in other problems. (f) The Bishop-DeLeeuw theorem
Let X be a compact Hausdorff space and denote by Cr(X), resp. Cc(X), the Banach space of continuous real-valued, resp. complex-valued, functions on X. Choose a subspace B of Cr(X) or Cc(X) that contains the constants. In [9] Bishop and Karel DeLeeuw considered the problem let L be a linear functional in the dual space B* of B. In what manner can L be represented by a measure on X? For example, if X is the unit disk and B is the subspace of Cc ( X) consisting of functions analytic on the interior, then each L ill B* can be represented by a measure carried on the unit circumference. This question is closely related to Choquet's refinement of the Krein-Milman theorem on convex sets in linear topological spaces. Bishop and DeLeeuw defined the Choquet Boundary of B, M(B), as the set of x in X such that the unit point mass at x is the unique positive Baire measure representing the evaluation functional f -+ f(x) on B. They prove in particular the following Representation Theorem. Assume that B is a separable subspace of Cr ( X) or Cc ( X). Then each linear functional L in B* has a representation of the form: L( f) = Jfdtl, fin B, where tl is a Baire measure concentrated on M ( B) in the sense that {l( S) = 0 for each Borel set S disjoint from M( B). (As above, {l denotes the regular Borel extension of tl.)
Assume now that X is metrizable and assume that B is a uniform algebra on X, i.e. is closed under multiplication and is a closed subspace of Cc(X) = C(X), separating points on X. Then the Choquet boundary M(B) coincides with the minimal boundary of B dtscussed in (b) above. Furthermore, one has the following beautiful critenon for a point x to be a peak-point of B. Theorem. Fix x in X. Then x is a peak point of B if and only if for each open neighborhood U of x there is some f in B with IIfll ..;; I, If( x) I > 3/4 and If( y) I ..;; 1/4 for all y outside of U.
In another direction, they use the above representation theorem to give a new proof of Choquet's
xiv
Theorem: Let K be a compact convex subset of a locally convex linear topological space. Assume that K is metrizable. Denote by Ext (K) the set of extreme points of K. Then Ext (K) is a Go -set in K. For every vector kin K there is a representation: k t=: jydJ.l(Y) for some ( Baire) probability measure J.l on K such that J.l( Ext ( K)) = J.l( K) = 1.
They also give generalizations of the Representation Theorem for subspaces that are not separable, and gIve a version of Choquet's theorem without metrizability assumption.
3) Banach Spaces and Operator Theory
Let E be a normed linear space and denote by S the unit sphere of E. It may happen that not every continuous linear functional on E attains its supremum on S at some point of S If the functionals which do attain their supremum are norm dense in E *, E is called subreflexive. In [13] Bishop and R. R. Phelps proved that every Banach space is subreflexive. By extending and simplifying the method of [13], Bishop and Phelps went on to answer questions concerning support points. Let E be a real Banach space, C a convex subset of E and x a point on the boundary of C. If there eXIsts a functional f in E such that f(x) = sup f( C), then x is called a support point of C and f is called a support functional. Geometrically speaking, x is a support point of C if C has a supporting hyperplane at x. V. L. Klee had asked if every convex set in a Banach space has at least one support point. In [20] Bishop and Phelps proved Theorem. If C is a closed convex subset of a Banach space E. then the support points of C are dense in the boundary of C Furthermore the support functionals are dense in E *.
In lus work on operator theory in [1] and [6] Bishop was concerned with questions about operators on a reflexive Banach space which in some way generalize the theory of normal operators on a Hilbert Space. [I] deals with spectral operators in the sense of Dunford, on a reflexive Banach space B. Such an operator is given by a representation T = fzdE(z), where E is a spectral measure. Bishop studied the closure in the strong operator topology of certain sets of spectral operators. One application of the work is the followmg striking result. Theorem. Let H be a Hilbert space. The subnormal operators on H. (i.e. operators Ton H such that there exists a Hilbert space if containing H and a normal operator T on if which is an extension of T), are the closure of the normal operators on H in the strong topology
In [6] Bishop constructed what he called duality theories for an operator T on a reflexive Banach space B. Let T be an operator, aCT) its spectrum in C. For each vector x in B, (T-zI)-l x is an analytic vector-valued function fez) on CC\a(T). However, for certain vectors x
xv
the function f(z) may admit analytic continuation to a larger open set W so that the equation: (T-zI)f(z}=xholdson W. Let F be a closed subset of
Bishop also defined weaker duality theories which apply to larger classes of operators, and in particular he defines a duality theory which holds for every bounded linear operator on the refleXlve space B .
4) Several Complex Variables ( a) Function theory on Stein manifolds
Papers [14], [15], [16] deal with Stein manifolds and a generalization, partially analytic spaces. defined in (14], and with the analytic mapping of such spaces into
This result means in particular that the function theory on a domain of holomorphy in (Cn is equivalent to the function theory of a suitable analytic submanifold of (CN for some N. Rhagavan Narasimhan, [Na], independently and with other methods, proved this result, and Reinhold Remmert, [Re 1], started this theory. Bishop's approach is via analytic polyhedra. Let K be a complex manifold and f= lfi Ii = 1, 2, ... , n} be an n - tuple of analytic function on K. Put
xvi
An analytic polyhedron P in K defined by f is a connected component ot 1'0 haVIng compact closure in K. The fundamental result of [14] is
Theorem Let K be as above with dim K = d, and let P be an analytic polyhedron in K defined by an n-tuple f of analytic functions Fix a compact subset S of P. Then there exists an analytic mapping g of K into Cd which defines an analytic polyhedron Q such that SeQ c P An analytic polyhedron of the type of Q, i.e. defined by a d -tuple of analytic functions, is called a special analytic polyhedron If K is a Stein manifold, then K is holomorphically convex and hence can be exhausted by an increasing sequence of analytic polyhedra, and hence by a sequence of special analytic polyhedra. Bishop first showed that K admits an analytic almost proper map f into (Cd, where d = dim K. ("Almost proper" means that each component of the inverse image of a compact set is compact.) He next constructed a proper mapping ofK into (Cd+1, with d as above. Finally, using the defining properties of a Stein manifold, he extended the map to a biholomorpluc proper map of K into <e 2d +1, proving the embedding theorem stated above. In [15] the properties of special analytic polyhedra proved in [14] are used by Bishop to give a new approach to some global questions from the classical theory of Stein manifolds. Let L be an analytic subvariety of a Stein manifold K The following are basic results from the Oka-Cartan theory of Stein manifolds I. The set L is the set of common zeros of some farruly of analytic functions on K .
II
If L is a submanifold of K, then every analytic function on L can be extended to an analytic function on K .
Bishop gave new proofs of I and II which are independent of sheaf theory He used the fact that special analytic polyhedra on the one hand can be used to exhaust K, while on the other hand each such polyhedron can be spread out as a branched covering over the open unit polydisk in (Cd where d = dim K. In [16] Bishop extended the theory developed in [14] and [15]. In particular he gave new proofs of the Remmert-Stein theorem of [Re-St] and of Remmert's Proper Mapping Theorem [Re 2]. In [18] Bishop generalized Cartan's theorem of the vanishing of the cohomology groups HP(M, ,;1), p;;, 1, for a coherent analytic sheaf 3'-on a Stein manifoldM to the case of analytic functions on M with values in a Frechet space This result has found application in work by Gleason on integral formulas and work of Douady in deformation theory
(b) Analytic disks with boundaries on smooth submamfold of <en It is possible to do "function theory" on a smooth submanifold L of (Cn even when L is not a complex manifold. L may for instance be a hypersurface in (Cn. One studies the restrictions to L of functions analytic in a neighborhood of L in <en. Questions
arise concerning the polynomially convex hull and the hull of holomorphy of ~. These questions have been much studied in recent years, and are related to so -called CR -structures (Cauchy -Riemann structures) on a smooth manifold, and to general problems concerning partial differential equations. In [25) Bishop made major progress on these problems by proving, under general conditions on ~, the existence of certain families of simple closed curves on ~, each of which bounds an analytic disk in <en. Let k be the (real) dimension of ~ and assume k> n. Then the tangent space Tp to ~ at a point p in ~ contains a complex-linear subspace of complex dimension k - n .
Theorem Fix p in ~ Assume Tp contains no complex-linear subspace of dimension k - n + 1. Then in a given neighborhood of p on ~ there exists a simple closed curve which bounds an analytic disk (analytic image afthe unit disk) in ([:Il . In the case n = k the problem is different since a tangent-space Tp may contain no complex -linear subspace. Bishop gave a generalization of the previous result for the case k = n as well. For the special case of a smooth 2-sphere ~ in <e 2 he showed that there exist in general two points on ~ which admit boundaries of analytic disks in arbitrary neighborhoods on ~. The example.
1,
1m Z2 = 0 ~
is typical here. Hans Lewy in [Le 1], [Le 2] had done pioneering work on the envelopes of holomorphy of smooth manifolds in ([:Il Bishop went on in [25] to use the analytic disks he had constructed to study the envelope of holomorphy of a compact subset of ~ for certain dimensions, extending Lewy's results The work in [25] has been greatly developed by other authors ( [Hi -Ta] )
(c) Analytic structure in the spectrum af a Banach algebra Let .!# be a uniform algebra, M its specTrum M may be viewed either as the space of all homomorphisms of 91 into the scalar field <e, or as the space of maximal ideals of ,,;y. We say that M has analytic structure if there exists a continuous one-one map T from a plane domain W into M such that f· T ,is analytic on W for each f in ,r;{! • The first result giving general conditions for the existence of analytic structure in M was given by Gleason [Glea 2] . If K is a compact set in ([:11 , the polynomially convex hull of K is the set K consisting of all points y in ([:n such that I Q (y ) I " max I Q I, taken over K, for every polynomial Q on <ell. The set K can be identified with the spectrum of the algebra [z 1 , ••• , Z n' K] which denotes the uniform closure on K of the poJynorruals in the coordinates The problem of analytic structure here is to exhibit analytic varieties of positive dimension which are subsets of K . For the case when K is a simple closed real-analytic curve in <en, Wermer showed in [We 2] that K\K always possesses analytic structure; in fact, K\K is either empty or it is a one complex dimensional analytic variety.
xviii
In [19] and [21] Bishop gave far-reaching extensions of this result. In these papers he developed new methods in the study of commutative Banach algebras. In particular he proved the following in [19] .
Theorem: If .s1 is a uniform algebra with Silov boundary X and spectrum Y and if .s1 contains a function g such that g is finite- to-one from X to g( X) and such that g( X) is "thin" in a sense made precise, then Y\X can be given the structure of a Riemann surface with at most a countable discrete set of singularities such that each f in .s1 is analy tic on Y \X . In [21] Bishop attacked the problem of analytic structure once more. Consider an algebra A of holomorphIc functions on a complex manifold X of complex dimension n and assume that for each p in X, A contains an n-tuple of function gIving local coordinates at p. Let K be a compact subset of X and denote by A (K) the uniform closure of A on K. If A separates point on K, then A (K) is a unifonn algebra on K. In [21] Bishop proved
Theorem: Fix A, X. K as above. Let M denote the spectrum of A( K). Then any n + 1 elements fl , .. ,fn +1 in A have the property that for almost all (z 1, • . . , Z n) in <en the set {m(fn+l) 1m EM, m(fJ is finite Already for the case: n = 1, X is an annulus in the z -plane, K is a circle concentric With X, this is a highly non-trivial, and useful, result. Bishop gave two applications of this theorem in [21]. First he considered a complex manifold X spread over <en such that analytic functions separate point on X, and proved the following. If E( X) denotes the envelope of holomorphy of X. then E( X) is a Stein manifold. This result was due to Cartan, Thuller and Oka. (See Rossi and Bungart [Ro] ) Secondly, he considered an algebra A of holomorphic functions on a Riemann surface ~. Let K be a finite union of diSjoint closed real-analytic curves on ~ He showed. Let M denote the spectrum of A (K). Then M\K can be given the structure of a Riemann surface with certain discrete identifications, such that the functions of A are holomorphic onM\K This contains the result on real-analytic curves in [We 2]. Similar results on the polynomially convex hull of curves in <en were proved, extending Bishop's methods, for smooth curves by Stolzenberg in [Stolz] and for rectifiable curves by Herbert Alexander in [Al1. For arbitrary Jordan curves, severe pathology can occur. See also [Roy] . It has been found out in recent years that the study of maximal ideal spaces of uniform algebras is closely related to the theory of singularities of analytic functions of several variables, and to spectral theory of analytic families of operators In [Au-We1, [Se1, potential-theoretic methods had been used to extend the work in [21], and in [We 3] connections between Bishop's work in [211 and singularity questions were exhibited.
xix
A broad theory, which encompasses all these areas, called the theory of analytic multivalued function, was developed by Slodkowski in [S1]. (See also [Au] .) ( d) Limits of sequences of analytic sets and removable singularities In [23] Bishop generalized results of Stoll, [Sto], on the problems mentioned in the title. He proved Theorem Let A be an analytic set of pure dimension k in the complement of an analytic set B. Assume that the 2k-dimensional volume of A is finite Then A can be analytically continued through B. Further he proved that the limit of a convergent sequence {A i} of analytic sets of pure dimension k is an analytic set, provided that the 2k-dimensional volumes of the sets {A i} are uniformly bounded. (e) Surveys A general expository discussion of many of the topics considered above is contained in Bishop's paper [24] from the Proceedings of the Conference on Complex Analysis, Minneapolis, 1964. Detailed expositions and applications of various portions of Bishop's work are contained in the following books: A. Browder [Br] , T. W. Gamlin [Ga] , Gunning and Rossi, [Gu-Ro], Wermer [We 4], Stout [Stou]. The Memorial Volume, "Errett Bishop, Reflections on Him and His Research", Contemporary Mathematics, Volume 39, AMS ( 1985), edited by Murray Rosenblatt, contains lectures on Bishop's work given at a Conference at the University of California, San Diego, in September 1983. It also contains Bishop's article "Schizophrenia in Contemporary Mathematics"
Bibliography [AI]
H. Alexander, Polynomial approximation and hulls in sets of finite linear measure in <en, Amer J Math 93 (1971) 65 -74.
[Ar-Si]
R. Arens and 1. M. Singer, Function values as boundary integrals, Froc Amer. Math. Soc 5 (1954)735-745.
[Au]
B. Aupetit, Analytic multivalued functions in Banach algebras and uniform
algebras, Adv. Math. 44 # 1 (1982) 18-60. [Au-We] B. Aupetit and J. Wermer, Capacity and uniform algebras, J. Funct Anal. 28 (1978) 386-400. [Ba]
R. Basener, On rationally convex hulls, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc 182 (1973) 353-38l.
[Br]
A. Browder, Introduction to Function Algebras (book), W. A. Benjamin (1969).
xx
lCa 1]
L. Carleson, Mergelyan's theorem on uniform polynomial approximation, Math. Scand.15 (1964) 167-175.
rCa 2]
L. Carleson, Representations of continuous functions, Math. Z. 66 (1957) 447-451.
[Co]
B. Cole, One point parts and the peak point conjecture, Thesis, Yale University (1968).
[Ga]
T. W. Gamelin, Uniform Algebras (book), Prentice-Hall Inc. (1969).
[GIl]
1. Glicksberg, The abstract F. and M. Riesz theorem, J Funct. Anal (1967)
109-122. [GI2]
1. Glicksberg, Measures orthogonal to algebras and sets of anti-symmetry, Trans. A mer. Math. Soc. 105 (1962) 415-435.
[Glea 1] A. Gleason, Function algebras, Seminar on Analytic Function, 11, Inst. for Adv. Study, Pnnceton (1957), 213-326. [Glea 2] A. Gleason, Finitely generated ideals in Banach algebras, J Math. Mech. 13 (1964) 125-132. [GI-We]
1. Glicksberg and J. Wermer, Measures orthogonal to a Dirichlet algebra, Duke Math. J 30 (1963) 661-666.
[Gu-Ro] R. Gunning and H. Rossi, Analytic Functions of Several Complex Variables (book), Prentice-Hall, Inc. (1965). [Hi-Ta]
D. C. Hill and G. Taiani, Families of analytic disks in (Cn with boundaries on a prescribed CR-manifold, Racolta deg/i scritti dedicati a Hans Lewy, Scuola Normale di PIsa (1978).
[Le 1]
H. Lewy, On hulls of holomorphy, Comm. Pure Appl. Math 13 (1960) 587591.
[Le 2]
H. Lewy, On the local character of the solutions of an atypical linear differential equation in three variables and a related theorem for regular functions of two complex variables, Ann Math. 64 (1956) 514-522.
[Na]
R. Narasimhan, Imbedding of holomorphically complete complex spaces, Amer. 1. Math. 82 (1960) 917-934.
[Re 1]
R. Remmert, Sur les espaces analytiques holomorphiquement separables et holomorphiquement convexes, Comptes Rendus Acad Sci Paris 243 (1956) 118-121.
[Re 2]
R. Remmert, Holomorphe und meromorphe Abbildungen komplexer Raume, Math. Ann. 133 (1957) 328-370.
[Re-St]
R. Remmert and K. Stein, Ober die wesentlichen Singularitaten analytischer Mengen,Mat. Ann. 126 (1953) 263-306.
[Ri]
F. Riesz and M. Riesz, Uber die Randwerte einer analytischen Funktion, 4e Congres des Math. Scand. (1916), 27 -44.
xxi
[Ro]
H. Rossi and L. Bungart, Global theory of several complex variables, mimeo-
graphed notes, Princeton University (1962). [Roy 1
H. Royden, Algebras of bounded analytic functions on Riemann surfaces, Acta Math. 114 (1965) 113-142.
[Rul
W. Rudin, Boundary values of analytic functions, Proc. A mer. Math. Soc. 7 (1956)808-811.
[Se]
V. N. Senichkin, Subharmonic functions and the analytic structure in the
space of maximal ideals of a uniform algebra, Mat. Sb. 108 (1979) 115 ·133. lSi 1]
G. E. SHov, On rings of functions with uniform convergence, Ukrainian Math. J. 3 (1951)404-411.
lSi 2]
I. M. Gelfand, D. A. Raikov and G. E. SHov, Commutative Normed Rings, Uspehi matem. Nauk 1 (1946) 48-146.
[SI]
Z. Slodkowski, Analytic set-valued functions and spectra, Math. Ann. 256 (1981)363-386.
[Sto)
W. Stoll, The growth of the area of a transcendental analytic set of dimension one,Math. Z. 81 (1963) 76-98.
[Stou]
E. L. Stout, The Theory of Uniform Algebras (book), Bogden and Quigley, Inc. (1971).
[Stolz]
G. Stolzenberg, Uniform approximation on smooth curves, Acta Math 115 (1966) 185·198.
[We 1]
J. Wermer, Seminar ilber Funktionen Algebren, Lecture Notes in Math., # I, Springer· Verlag, Berlin ( 1964 ).
[We 2]
J. Wermer, The hull of a curve in <en, Ann. Math. 68 (1958) 550-561.
[We 3]
J. Wermer, Maximum modulus algebras and singularity sets, Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh 86A (1980) 327 -331.
[We 4]
J. Wermer, Banach Algebras and Several Complex Variables, 2nd edition
(book), Springer- Verlag (1976).
January 13, 1986
JOHNWERMER Department of Mathematics Brown University Providence, R. I. USA
ltxii
BIBLIOGRAPHY OF THE PUBLICATIONS OF ERRETT BISHOP (LIST I)
[1]
Spectral theory for operators on a Banach space, Trans Amer. Math. Soc 86 (1957) 414-445.
[2]
Subalgebras of functions on a Riemann surface, Pacific J. Math. 8 (1958) 29-50.
[3]
Measures orthogonal to polynomials, Proc Nat. Acad Sci. USA 44 (1958) 278280.
[4]
The structure of certain measures, Duke Math. J. 25 (1958) 283 -290.
[5]
Approximation by a polynomial and its derivatives on certain closet sets, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 9 (1958) 946-953.
[6]
A duality theorem for an arbitrary operator, Pacific J. Math. 9 (1959) 379-397.
[7]
A mmimal boundary for function algebras, Pacific J Math 9 (1959) 629-642.
[8]
Some theorems concerning function algebras, Bull. A mer. Math. Soc 65 (1959) 77-78.
[9]
(with K. de Leeuw). The representations of linear functionals by measures on sets of extreme pomts, Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 9 (1959) 305 -331
[10] Simultaneous approximation by a polynomial and its derivatives, Proc Amer Math. Soc. 10 (1959)741-743. [11] Boundary measures of analytic differentials, Duke Math J. 27 (1960) 331-340. [12] A generalization of the Stone-Weierstrass theorem, Pacific J Math 11 (1961) 777 -783. [13] (with R. R. Phelps). A proof that every Banach space is subreflexive, Bull. Amer Math. Soc. 67(1961)97-98. [14] Mappings of partially analytic spaces,Amer. J Math. 83 (1961) 209-242. [15] Some global problems in the theory of functions of 'several complex variables, Amer. J. Math. 83 (1961) 479·498. [16] Partially analytic spaces, A mer. J. Math. 83 (1961) 669-692. [17] A general Rudin-Carleson theorem,Proc Amer. Math. Soc 13 (1962) 140-143. [18] Analytic functions with values in a Frechet space, Pacific J Math. 12 (1962) 1177-1192.
xxiii
[19] Analyticity in certain Banach algebras, Trans. A mer. Math. Soc. 102 (1962) 507-544. [20] (with R. R. Phelps). The support functionals of a convex set, Proc. Symp. Pure Math Vol. 7, Amer. Math. Soc., 1963,27-35. [21] Holomorphic completions, analytic continuations and the interpolation of seminorms, Ann. Math. 78 (1963) 468-500. [221 Representing measures for points in a uniform algebra, Bull. A mer. Math. Soc. 70 (1964) 121-122. [231 Conditions for the analyticity of certain sets, Mich. Math. J 11 (1964) 289-304. [241 Uniform algebras, Proc. Cant Complex Analysis (Minneapolis, 1964), SpringerVerlag, Berlin, 1965,272-281. [251 Differentiable manifolds in complex Euclidean space, Duke Math J. 32 (1965) 1-22. [26] Constructive methods in the theory of Banach algebras in Function Algebras, ed. F. T. Birtel, Proc. Int'l Symp. Function Algebras (1966) 343-345. [271 An upcrossing inequality with applications, Mich. Math J 13 (1966) 1-13. [281 Foundations of constructive analysis, McGraw -Hill, New York, 1967. [291 A constructive ergodic theorem,!. Math. Mech. 17 (1968) 631-640. [301 The constructivization of abstract mathematical analysis, Proc Int 'I Congr. Math., Moscow, 1966,308-313.
xxiv
REPRINTED PAPERS
lUI
upeIalul~
un "
DcU14lvU
';'Valv'll;:;;,
.c.ll~""
Ul.,UVY,
• v ............ ""
........ , yt-
the American Mathematical Society
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE (1) BY
ERRETT BISHOP
O. Introduction. The purpose of this paper is to study the spectral theory of a dosed linear transformation T on a reflexive Banach space B. This will be done by means of certain vector-valued measures which are related to the transformation. (A set function m from the Borel sets of the complex plane to B will be called a vector-valued measure if the series L:t:l m(Si) converges t,o m(U i Si) for every sequence {Si I of disjoint Borel sets. The relevant properties of vector-valued measures are briefly derived in §1(2). A vector-valued measure m will be called a T-measure if Tm(S) = jszdm(z) for all bounded Borel sets S. The properties of T-measures are studied in §2. The results of §2 are applied in §3 to a class of transformations which have been called scalar-type transformations by Dunford [5], and which we call simply scalar transformations. A scalar operator as defined by Dunford is essentially one which admits a representation of the type t = jzdE(z) , where E is a spectral measure. Unbounded scalar transformations have been studied by Taylor [16]. The main result of §3 is Theorem 3.2, in which properties of the closures of certain sets of scalar transformations are derived. This theorem is actually a rather general spectral-type theorem, which has applications to several problems in the theory of linear transformations. As a corollary we obtain a well-known theorem, which might be called the spectral theorem for symmetric transformations, as given in Stone [15]. We also derive as a corollary the spectral theorem for self-adjoint transformations. Other corollaries of Theorem 3.2, which apply to results of Bade [2] and Halmos [9] are derived. In §4 a functional calculus is developed for a class r of transformations T for which both T-measures and T*-measures exist in sufficient abundance. This is a very general functional calculus, so that correspondingly the usual theorems of functional calculus must be weakened if they are to remain true. There is a generalization of the concept of a T-measure introduced in §5. Many theorems proved in §2 have analogues which hold after the generalization. The new type of vector-valued measures have much the same relation Received by the editors November 11, 1955. (1) A paper which treats this subject in some detail is Dunford, Bartle, and Schwartz [4] (2) This paper is a part of a dissertation in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Chicago The author wishes to thank Professors P. R Halmos, J. L. Kelley and F Wolf for their advice and encouragement.
414
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
415
to spectral transformations (generalizations of scalar transformations, defined by Dunford [5]) as T-measures have to scalar transformations. 1. Vector-valued measures. Let X be a set, IS a u-ring of subsets of X, and m a function from IS to a Banach space B with the property that for every sequence I Si I of disjoint measurable sets (measurable sets are sets in IS) we have m(U i Si) = m(Si), where the convergence is convergence in norm. Such a set function m is called a vector-valued measure. Bv a theorem of Orlicz, proved by Pettis [14], unconditional convergence of se;ies Lt-l Xi of vectors to a vector x is equivalent to unconditional weak convergence of the series to x, i.e., convergence of (Xi, u; to (x, u; for each u in B*. Thus m is a vector-valued measure if and only if (m(U i Si), u) = (m(Si), u) for each disjoint sequence of measurable sets and each u in B*. Equivalently, the set function mu defined by mu(S) = (m(S), must be a complex-valued measure for each u in B*. If m is a vector-valued measure and So any measurable set, then the equation m(S) = m(S(\So) obviously defines a vector-valued measure m, called the restriction of m to So, and m is said to live on So. We define the norm Ilmil of a vector-valued measure m to be the sup of the quantities II L7~ I ~,m(Si)ll, where SI, ... , Sn is any finite sequence of disjoint measurable sets and ~l' " , ~n is a corresponding sequence of complex numbers with I ~il ~ 1. To show that Ilmil is finite, let u be any vector in B*. Then it is known that the quantities I L~~ I ~imu(Si) I defined for the finite numerical measure mu considered above are bounded. By the uniform bounded ness theorem (see Banach [3]), Ilmil is finite. It is easily seen that the norm Ilmil makes the set Q of vector-valued measures into a normed linear space. Indeed Q is a Banach space, although we do not give the simple proof because for the special case which will interest us this is a COl ollary of a later theorem. A useful fact is that
Li:!
Lt:\
Lt: \ u;
I sd
where the measure mu is defined by muCS) = (m(S), u). This follows easily from the definition of Ilmli. It is now simple to define what is mednt by the integral of a bounded measurable complex-valued functionfwith respect to the vector-valued measure m. \iVe first consider the case of a simple function f (a finite linear combination of characteristic functions of measurable sets), f = L~~ 1 Ad; S i' and define ff(z)dm(z) = L7~1 A,m(Si). The definition is easily seen to be unique. Letting Ilfll denote sup If(z) I, we see immediately that Ilff(z)dm(z)11 ~ IIfllllmll, and in fact that
Ii llmll
= sup f
2
f
jCz)dm(z) I
IIiII
416
ERRETT BISHOP
[November
where the sup is taken over all simple functions. Thusf--"ff(z)dm(z) is a linear transformation of norm from the set of simple functions to B, and therefore has a unique bounded linear extension to the set of bounded measurable functions. The value of this extension at f we call ff(z)dm(z) , so that the integral is a linear transformation of norm on the set of bounded measurable functions. Again defining mu by mu(S) = (m(S), uj, we obviously have ff(z)dmu(z) =
Ilmil
Ilmil
(m(U;Si),
u) = (fuis/(Z)dm(Z), u) = fuis/(Z)dmu(Z) ~ fs/(Z)dmu(Z) L
=
~(fs/(Z)dm(Z), u)
(iii(Si), u),
so that iii is a vector-valued measure. If f is an arbitrary measurable function, write iii(S) = fsf(z)dm(z) for any measurable set S on which f is bounded, so that as we have just seen iii(S) = iii(Si) if {Si} is a sequence of disjoint measurable sets with U i Si = S and if f is bounded on S. We say that f is integrable with respect to m if II iii(S)11 is less than some constant K for all Borel sets Son whichf is bounded. This implies for each sequence {Si of disjoint measurable sets on each of whichfis bounded and for each u in B* that (iii (Si) , u) converges, since a series of complex numbers converges if there is a uniform bound for the sums of finite subseries. Thus for each measurable set S we may represent S as the union of a sequence {Si} of disjoint measurable sets on each of which f is bounded, and define a linear functional iii(S) on B* whose value on u is Lt~l (iii (Si) , u). This linear functional is bounded because I (iii(Si) , u)1 ~suPn Iliii(U:~l Si)llllull ~ Kllull. It is seen by the usual methods that iii(S) is unique, i.e., independent of the choice of the sequence {Si}, and that it defines a vector-valued measure iii with values in B** if B is reflexive. For iii(X) we write ff(z)dm(z) , the integral of f with respect to m, which we have defined under the hypothesis that f is integrable with respect to m. If B is reflexive, then ffCz)dm(z) may be considered to be in B itself. Under the assumption that B is reflexive, that m is a vector-valued measure, thatf is integrable with respect to m, and that g is integrable with respect to the vector-valued measure iii defined by niCS) = fsf(z)dm(z) , it follows thatfg is integrable with respect to m and that fsf(z)g(z)dm(z) = f sg(z)diii(z).
Li
I
Li
Li:l
1957]
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS
O~
A
BA~ACH
SPACE
417
This is easily proved for the case of a simple function g and a bounded measurable function J. Then since both sides depend continuously on g in the uniform topology, it follows that the equation holds for all bounded measurable functions J and g. This implies that if J and g are any functions satisfying the hypothesis, then the equation holds for sets S on which both J and g are bounded. Then it follows easily for all measurable sets S, because both sides of the equation are countably additive set functions. In addition to the
(f J(z)dm(z), u ) = f JCz)dmu(z) = 1>u(J) = (1)(J), u) for all u in B *, so that cp(f) = fJ(z)dm(z) for all J in WC(X). Thus cP =CPm. Moreover, Ilmil = sup., (1Imu!l/llull) =supu (1ICPull/llull) =llcpll. Thus m----?CPm is a metric isomorphism of Q with the Banach space of operators from 9R(X) to B. In particular, Q is a Banach space and Ilmil =SUPfEm(X) (1IfJ(z)dm(z)II/II!II). In this equation we may even take the sup over those J with compact support, since they are dense in 9J1(X).
4
Ef{f{ETT HISHOP
4H!
[November
DEFINITION 1.1. The weak operator topology of Q is that topology obtained by considering Q as the bounded linear transformations from mceX) to B, and then defining the weak topology in the usual fashion. The unit sphere of Q is compact in this topology. 2. Measures associated with operators. We turn now to the study of a closed linear transformation T whose domain is a dense subset of the reflexive Banach space B and whose range is a subset of B. The class of such transformations we call ~. It is well known (see, for instance, von Neumann [17]) that each T in ~ has an adjoint which is a closed linear transformation T* on B* with dense domain and that T** = T. This means that (Tx, u) = (x, T*u) for each x in 'IJ(T) and each u in 'IJ(T*). Thus ~*, the set of T* for Tin :t, is the set of closed linear transformations on B* with dense domain. A vector-valued measure m on the Borel sets IS of the complex plane X will be called a T-measure if for each bounded Borel set 5 we have m(5) E'IJ(T) and Tm(5) = fszdm(z). The vector x=m(X) will be said to have the T-measure m under these conditions. I t is clear that the set of all T-measures is a linear subset of Q. Later we shall see that this set is closed. As an illustration, let m be a T-measure and Zo be a point with m( zo}) ~O. Then Tmdzoj) =flzolzdm(z) =zomc!zo}), so that mUzo}) is a characteristic vector of T. Conversely if m is a vector-valued measure which lives on a countable set 50, then it is easy to see that if Tm( z = zm( z for each z in 50 then m is a T-measure. Thus the notion of a T-measure is a generalization of the notion of a characteristic vector. As another example, let B be a Hilbert space and let T = fzdE(z) be a normal transformation on B. Select any x in B and consider the set function m on IS defined by m(5) =E(5)x. From the properties of the spectral measure E it follows that m is a vector-valued measure. Moreover
I
I l)
Tm(5) = TE(5)x =
f
I l)
zdE(z)E(5)x = f/dE(Z)X = f/dm(Z),
so that m is a T-measure. We shall show later that x has no T-measures other than m. In the following pages we collect a few simple properties of T-measures which will be useful later and then prove the fundamental theorems about T-measures. Given aT-measure m and a Borel set So, it is obvious that the restriction of m to 50, i.e., the vector-valued measure m defined by m(5) =m(5n5 o), is also aT-measure. If m is a T-measure and f a bounded measurable function, and if the Borel set 5 is bounded, then fsf(z)dm(z) E 'IJ(T) and Tfsf(z)dm(z) = fszf(z)dm(z). For a simple function f= L~~l Aiy.,Si' where y.,s. is the characteristic function of the set 5 i , this amounts to a quick computation:
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS
1957]
O~
A BANACH SPACE
41'1
T f/(Z)dm(Z) n
=
L
>..;T(m(5 n 5;»
= iZ](Z)dm(Z). For an arbitrary bounded measurable function] it can be proved by approximating] in the uniform topology by a simple function g and noting that fsg(z)dm(z) approximates fd(z)dm(z) and that fszg(z)dm(z) approximates fsz](z)dm(z) , so that by the closure of T the assertion follows. If it is assumed merely that] is integrable with respect to m, then the above proof holds only on bounded sets S on which] is bounded. To prove the equality for all bounded Borel sets 5, it is necessary to make use again of the fact that T is closed. Conversely if the vector-valued measure m has the property that for every function] in 9JC(X) with compact support it is true that fj(z)dm(z) E'1)(T) and T f](z)dm(z) = fz](z)dm(z) , then m is a T-measure. To prove this define a numerical measure mu for each u in B* by mu(5) = (m(S), u). Then for each u in '1)(T*) we have
f
](z)dmT*u(z) =
=
(f z](z)dm(z) , U) = f z](z)dmu(z).
Since the functions with compact support are dense in 9JC(X) and since the representation of a linear functional on 9JC(X) as a measure is unique, we must have mT*u(S) = fszdmu(z) for all Borel sets S. For S bounded this becomes (m(S) , T*u) = (fszdm(z) , u). Since u is any vector in '1)(T*) this implies that m(S)E'I:J(T) and Tm(S) =fszdm(z), as was to be proved. We have seen that m(S) = fs](z)dm(z) is a vector-valued measure if] is integrable with respect to m. On the other hand if m is a T-measure it was shown above that m(S) E'1)(T) and Tm(S) = fsz](z)dm(z) = fszdm(z) for all bounded Borel sets S, so that fit is also a T-measure. In particular, we see again by taking] to be a characteristic function that the restriction of m to a Borel set So is aT-measure. To note that the concept has suitable in variance properties, let m be a T-measure which lives on the spectrum 0' of the operator T. (We shall see
420
ERRETT BISHOP
[November
later that every T-measure has this property.) Let j be analytic on all open set about (J', and let C be a finite collection of simple closed rectifiable curves lying in the domain of f and surrounding (J'. Then the operator jeT) is defined by f(T) = (l/21ri) jcfC)..)d)../ (A- T) (seeHiIIe [10]). We omit the easy proof that the vector-valued measure m defined by m(S) =m(f-I(S) is anf(T)-measure. For a Hilbert space B it will at times be necessary to state theorems about T-measures in terms of the Hilbert space adjoint TO and the inner product in B rather than in terms of T* and the bilinear product (x, u). There exists a unique 1-1 norm-preserving anti-linear map r from B onto B* such that (x, y) = (x, ry) for all x and y in B. If yo denotes the Hilbert space adjoint of T, then TO=r-IT*r. If }.t is a vector-valued measure with values in B * let }.to be the vectorvalued measure with values in B defined by }.t°(S) = r-I}.t(S*) Then if }.t is a T*-measure, }.to is a TO-measure. Conversely, if }.to is a TO-measure then }.t is a T*-measure. We now prove some of the more fundamental properties of T-measures. LEMMA 2.1. Let SI and S2 be compact disjoint subsets of the complex plane. Let T be in ~, let XI. be an analytic function from S{ to B such that x" E'1J(T) for all A in S{ and (T -A)xx = x, a constant. Similarly let u" be an analytic function from S{ to B* such that u"E'1J(T*) for A in S{ and (T*-A)ux=U, a constant. Then if X A-70 as IA1-7 OCJ it follows that (xx, u) = O.
Proof. Define the function f(A) to be (x)" u) for A in S{ and (x, u,,) for A in S{ . This definition is consistent since for A in S{ nS{ we have
Since Xx is analytic in S{ and u" in S{ it follows that f(A) is everywhere analytic and therefore a constant. Butf(A)-70 as A-? OCJ since X,,-70 as A-7 OCJ, so that f(A) = 0 identically. COROLLARY.
If in addition to the hypotheses of the theorem T is bounded,
then (x, u)=O.
Proof. If Tis bounded, then x" = (T -A)-IX for =x. Thus (x, u)=liml"I_x> -A(Xx, u)=O.
IAI > I Til and lim IXI • ., -
AX"
THEOREM 2.1. Let T be in ~ and let m and}.t be T and T*-measures respectiveiy which live on Borel sets SI and S2 respectively with s Ins2 = O. Then m.L}.t, i.e., (m(U),}.t(V»=Ofor all Borel sets Uand V.
Proof. Replacing U by unsl and V by vns2 if necessary, we may assumethat UCSI and VCSz. As a function of the Borel set S, (m( U), }.t(Sn V» is a numerical measure, so to show that (m( U),}.t( V» = 0 it is enough to prove that (m( U), }.teV» = 0 for all compact subsets V of V. Thus we may assume that V is compact. Similarly we may assume that U is compact. Define
1957)
x
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
= m( U), u = p,( V), Xx = ]u(1/(z - 'A»dm(z) for 'A in U', and
421 UA
]v(1/(z-'A»dp,(z) for 'A in V'. Then XI. is analytic on U ' and (T-'A)xA =x. Also Ux is analytic on V' and (T* - 'A)u A = u. Since XI. vanishes at infinity, Lemma 2.1 states that (Xl., u)=O. Since iimlxl_",-'Axx=m(U) =X, this gives (x, u)=O or (m(U), p,(V»=O, as was to be proved. To see the significance of this theorem, let m be a T-measure concentrated at the point Z1, so that me{ zd) is a characteristic vector and Tme{ zd ) =Z1mc{ zd). Also let p, be a T*-measure concentrated at the point Z27""Zl, so that T*p,({z2})=z2P,({z21). Then the theorem says that (m({zd), p,C{zz}» = 0, i.e., that characteristic vectors of T are orthogonal to characteristic vectors of T* which belong to different characteristic values. This is a wellknown and trivial result. =
COROLLARY
1. If m is a T-measure and p, a T*-measure, then (m(S1), P,(S2»
= 0 for disjoint Borel sets S1 and S2. Proof. Let m be the T-measure defined by m(S) =m(SnS1), so that m lives on S1. Let fj similarly be defined by fj(S) =p,csns2), so that fj lives on S2. By Theorem 2.1, m..lfj, so that (m(S1), P,(S2» = (m(S1), fj(S2» =0, as was to be proved. COROLLARY 2. If m is any T-measure and p, is a T*-measure for which p,(X) =0 (X is the entire complex plane), then m..lp" i.e., (m(U), p,(V»=0 for all Borel sets U and V.
Proof. We have (m(U), JL(V»
= (m(U n
+ (m(U n V'), JLCV» V), JL(V ' »+ (m(U n V'), JL(V»
V), JL(V»
= - (m(U n =0 by Corollary 1.
COROLLARY 3. If the values of T*-measures are dense in B*, then each x in B has at most one T-measure.
Proof. If x had the two T-measures m1 and mz, then m =m1-mZ would be a nontrivial T-measure with m(X) =0. By the previous corollary (with the roles of m and p, interchanged), for every Borel set S the vector m(S) is orthogonal to the values of all T*-measures. Thus m(S) =0, which contradicts the fact that m is nontrivial. COROLLARY 4. Let f be a Borel function which is integrable with respect to the T-measure m and the T*-measure p,. Then for each Borel set S,
(f f(z)dm(z) , II-(S) )
= ( m(S),
f f(z)dJL(z) ).
ERRETT BISHOP
422
(November
Proof. Let the measure m be defined by m(G) = (m(G), j.L(S» and let the measure p, be defined by p,( G) = (m(S), j.L( G». Then for each Borel set G we have m(C) = \m(C), J..L(S» = (m(C n S) m(C n S'), J..L(S»
+
=
by Corollary 1
(meC n S), J..L(S)
\m(C n S), J..L(C n S» = \m(S), J..L(C n S» = \m(S), J..L(C» = p,(C),
so that iii = p,. Thus
=
f
=
<m(S), f f(z)dJ..L(z) ).
f(z)dm(z) =
f
f(z)dp,(z)
COROLLARY 5. Let T be the operator on the Hilbert space B which acts on the complete orthonormal set x;J;: 1 by TXi = Xi+I. Then there are no nontrivial Tmeasures.
I
Proof. In the dual space B* there exists a complete orthonormal set with (Xi, Uj)=Oij. Also T*Ui=Ui-I for i>1 and T*UI=O. Thus for each a with Ia I < 1 the vector Va = 1 exiu; is a characteristic vector of T* corresponding to the characteristic value ex. This means that the measure consisting of a point mass Va concentrated at the point ex is a T*-measure. Thus if SC Ix: I xl ~ 1/2} and i.f I al < 1/2, Corollary 1 implies that (m(S), va) =0 for each T-measure m. Now it is easy to see that the vectors Va with lal <1/2 span B*. Thus m(S) =0. Similarly it can be shown that m(S) =0 if Sclx: Ixl <1/2}. But every Borel set S can be written in the form S=SIUS2 with SIC Ix: Ixl ~ 1/2} and S2C Ix: Ixl < 1/2}. Thus m(S) = m(SI) +m(S2) = o. Hence m(S) = o. Therefore m is trivial, as was to be proved. It is easy to see that in case B is a Hilbert space Theorem 2.1 can be stated as follows: Let T be in ~ and let m and j.L be T- and TO-measures respectively, which live on Borel sets SI and S2 respectively with SInS; =0. Then m1-j.L, i.e., (m(U), j.L(V» =0 for all Borel sets U and V.
{Udi:l
Li:
THEOREM 2.2. If SI and S2 are compact disjoint sets such that each component of S{ nS{ contains a point of the resolvent set of T, then for any two T-measures mi and m2 it is true that mI(SI)¥m2(S2) unless mI(SI) =m2(S2) =0.
Proof. Suppose mI(SI) =m2(S2) =x. Define x, =
f s, z -
_1_ dmI(z)
A
for A in
Sf,
19571
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS
~\
=
J
O~
for A in Sf
_1_ dm2(Z)
s,
Z -
423
A BANACH SPACE
A
To see that this definition is consistent for ']I. in S{ nS{, note that it is consistent for A in the resolvent set since in that case there is only one vector x~ with (T-A)XA=X Then note that the definition must be consistent on each component of S{ nS{ because each component intersects the resolvent set in an open region. Thus XI. is everywhere analytic and xA->O as ']1.-> if) , so that XI. is identically zero. This gives X=(T-A)XA=O, as desired. THEORE~I
2.3. Every T-measure m lives on (j( T).
Proof. Let RA be the resolvent of T and K the resolvent set. Let S be any compact subset of K, and write X =m(S). Then x~ = !s(1/(z-A))dm(z) is analytic in Sf and (T-']I.)XA =x. On the other hand R).,x is analytic in K and (T-A)RAx=x. Moreover, RAx=x A for ']I. in Knsf. Thus XI. can be extended to be analytic in the whole complex plane. Thus XI. = 0 since xA->O as ']1.-> i f ) . Therefore x = (T -X)x)., = O. Thus the measure m is zero on all compact subsets of K. It follows that the measure m" defined by mu(S) = (m(S), u) is zero on compact subsets of K, for all u in B*. By regularity mu is zero on all subsets of K. Hence m is zero on all subsets of K. Thus m lives on (j(T), as was to be proved. It is natural to define the basic sets OCTo, Jtl, t) of a topology on :t as follows: let To be any member of :t, }'1 any finite-dimensional subspace of '1:J(T o) , and f any positive number; write OCTo, M, c:) = {T: MC'1::CT), IICT-To)xll T* strongly. It will be the principal tool in the investigation of §3.
l
l
THEOREM 2.4. Let T be in :t and let 1Ta I be a directed set of transformations in :t such that T: -> T* in the strong topology of :t *. Let ma be a T a-measure with mall ~ c for all a. Let m in Q be a cluster point of the directed set {m a in the weak operator topology of Q (such cluster points exist because those measures m in Q with are compact in the weak operator topology). Then m is a Tmeasure.
II
I
llmll;:::;c
Proof. It will be enough to show that for each fin W'/CX) with compact
10
424
[November
ERRETT BISHOP
support we have jf(z)dm(z) E'1J(T) and T Jf(z)dm(z) alently that
(f
f(z)dm(z) , T*U) =
(f
=
jzf(z)dm(z) , or equiv-
zf(z)dm(z), U)
for all U in ~(T*). Since T:-'>T*, there exists for each E>O an index ao such that uE'1J(T:) and IIT*u-T:ull <E for all a>ao. Then ao because ma is a Ta-measure. Since m is a cluster point of ma} in the weak operator topology, we can choose a particular a > ao such that I
I
I
u)1
I(f
f(z)dm(z) , T*U) -
~
(f
I(f +
+
1
j(z)dm(z) , T*U) -
(f
I(f
~ E+ Ell f ~ =
zj(z)dm(z) , u)1
(f (f
j(z)dma(z), T*U)/
j(Z)dma(Z), T*U) -
zj(z)dma(z) , u) -
j(z)dma(z)
j(z)dma(z) , T:U)
i
zj(z)dm(z), u)/
II + E
2E + EllmallllJll 2E + Eell!ll.
Since E is arbitrary, this gives
Ilmil ~ 1 is
closed in the weak
Proof. Call the set in question C. If m is in C then there exists a directed set ma} of elements in C converging to m. Define a directed set ITa} of elements of ~ by Ta = T, so that IT:} converges to T* and ma is a To.measure. By the theorem, m is a T-measure, as was to be proved. To make Theorem 2.4 useful there must be some way of showing that the T-measure m is nontrivial. An example of how this can be done may be seen in Theorem 3.2. 3. Application to scalar transformations. Consider a function E( ) on the Borel sets of the complex plane whose values are operators on the reflexive Banach space B, such that for every disjoint sequence lSi} of Borel sets we
I
1957J
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
425
Ll:t
t
have E(U j: S.) = E(S.) in the strong topology, and such that E(X) = I, and such that E(SlnS2) = E(Sl)E(S2) for all St and S2' This function is called a spectral measure. It is not hard to show (see Dunford [5]) that the norms are uniformly bounded. The reason we use E( ) instead of the more usual symbol E for a spectral measure will become apparent. I t follows directly from the definition that for each x in B the set function E( )x defined by (E( )x)(S) =E(S)x is a vector-valued measure. We define a transformation T = jzdE(z) , which has for its domain the set of all x in B for which z is integrable with respect to E( )x, by setting Tx = jzdE(z)x. It is obvious that T is a linear transformation. Dunford calls T a scalar-type transformation, which we abbreviate to scalar transformation. The domain of T is dense because E(S)xE'1:J(T) for each bounded Borel set S and each x in B. Since the set function E*( ), defined by E*(S) = (E(S»* for each Borel set S, is also a spectral measure, we may analogously define a transformation U= jzdE*(z). It is also linear and has dense domain. For x in '1:J(T) and u in '1:J(U) we have
IIE(S)II
(Tx, u)
=
=
(f zdE(z)x, u ) = f zdU,-(z)x, u)
f
= ( x,
zd(x, E*(z)u)
f
ZdE*(Z)U)
= (x, Uu),
so that T has an adjoint and UCT*. For x in '1:J(T) and u in '1:J(T*) it is true that
12
426
ERRETT BISHOP
(November
Proof. If T = jzdE(z) is a scalar transformation and if x is an arbitrary vector in B, then for each bounded Borel set S the function z is integrable with respect to E( )(E(S)x) and the integral is jszdE(z)x. Thus E(S)xE'n(T) and TE(S)x = jszdE(z)x. It follows that x has the T-measure E( )x. Similarly every u in B* has the T*-measure E*( )u. If every x in B has a T-measure and every u in B* has a T*-measure, then by Corollary 3 to Theorem 2.1 every x in B has a unique T-measure. If every x in B has a unique T-measure m:r;, then define the transformation W from B to Q by Wx =m x • Then since Amx+fJ.m" is a T-measure for AX+fJ.Y it follows that mxx+uy =Amx+fJ.my. Hence ~V is a linear transformation. If Xn~X in Band WXn = m:r;,,->m in Q, then m is a T-measure by the corollary to Theorem 2.4. Since m:r;,,(X)->m(X) we have m(X) =x. Hence Wx=m. Thus W is closed. By the closed graph theorem W is bounded. For all x in B we have = ~ For each x in B and each Borel set S define E(S)x=m"CS) = (Wx)(S). E(S) is an operator because W is an operator. It follows immediately that E(U i: 1 Si) = Lt: 1 E(Si) in the strong topology for every disjoint sequence lSi} of Borel sets. Finally note that the vector E(S)x has a T-measure which is the restriction of m" to S. Hence E(S)E(S)x = mE(S)x(S) = nlE(S)x(X) =E(S)x. Thus E(S) is an idempotent operator. The set function E( ) is therefore a spectral measure. If xEB and S is a bounded Borel set, then E(S)xE'JJ(T) and TE(S)x = Tmx(S) = jszdm,,(z) = jszdE(z)x. It follows from the closure of T that Tx exists and Tx= jzdE(z)x whenever xE'D(jzdE(z», i.e., whenever jzdE(z)x exists. Thus jzdE(z) C T. Therefore T is an extension of a scalar transformation. Now if each x in B has a T-measure and each u in B* a T*-measure, then by what we have just proved there is some scalar transformation jzdE(z) of which T is an extension. For the same reasons there is some scalar transformation jzdF(z) of which T* is an extension. Therefore jzdF(z~ C T* CjzdE*(z). Thus for each u in B* the function F( )u is a jzdE*(z)-measure. Since u has the unique jzdE*(z)-measure E*( )u, it follows that F( )u = E*( )u. Hence F( ) =E*( ). Thus jzdF(z) = T'" =jzdE*(z), so that T = jzdE(z) is a scalar transformation. This proves the first statement of the theorem. The second statement has already been proved. I t has been shown that T is the extension of a scalar transformation if every x in B has a unique T-measure. If T is bounded, the scalar transformation is also bounded, and so must be equal to T. This completes the proof of the theorem. If T = jzdE(z) is a scalar transformation, define
Ilm,,11 II Wxll II Wllllxll·
IIITIII
=
SUPXEB
(IIE( )xll/llxll)·
Then
13
lY;)' J
;:,rl'..\.,l KAL 1 HEUR Y
FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
4'1.1
where the sup is taken over all x and u with I!xll =llull =1 and over all finite disjoint sequences {5i of Borel sets and corresponding finite sequences {Ad with I Ail ~ 1. By the uniform bounded ness theorem (see Banach [3]), III Till is finite if the above sup is finite for each fixed x. This is the case because for fixed x the sup is equal to II E( )xll. Let Gc be the set of all scalar transformations T with IIITI!I ~c. It is easy to see that then IIIT*III ~c, so that G:, the adjoint of the set Go, consists of all scalar transformations U on B * with III ulll ~ c. It will be seen later that the following theorem about G< is generalization of the spectral theorem.
l
THEOREM 3.2. Let T be in the closure Gc of Go in the strong topology. Then there exists a function E( ) from the Borel sets of X to operators on B such that (1) for each u in B*, E*( )u is a T*-measure for u and IIE*( )ull ~cllull; (2) if xE:tl(T), then Tx= JzdE(z)x; (3) if T is in the closure of the subset of Gc consisting of those transformations whose spectrum is in a given closed set C, then E(5) = 0 ~f 5 is disjoint from C; (4) ~f B is a Hilbert space and c= 1, then E(5) is a positive Hermitian operator and II Txll = JI zI2d(E(z)x, x) for all x in :tl(T).
Proof. Since TEG" there exists a directed set {To<} from G c converging to T, and under the assumption of (3) we may choose the transformations T" to have their spectra in C. Let T" = JzdE,,(z) so that T: = JzdE!(z). For each index IX and each u in B* consider the T:-measure E:( )u, which depends linearly on u. The inequality IIIT:II/ ~c implies IIE:( )ull ~cllull· Let Du be the set of all m in Q with Ilm[[ ~c[lu . Then D" is compact in the weak operator topology. Hence the Cartesian product space D = IIuEB' D" is also compact. For each index IX, E:( ) can be identified with the point of D whose coordinate in Du is E:( )u. Since D is compact the directed set E:( )} has a cluster point in D which we call E*( ). The coordinate of E*( ) in Du will be written E"( )u. The value of E*( )u on the Borel set 5 will be written E*(5)u. The transformation on B which takes u into E*(5)u will be written E*(5). By Theorem 2.4, E*( )u is a T*-measure for each u in B*. To prove the equality E*( ) (AU+fl V ) =XE*( )U+flE*( )v, note that we can simultaneously approximate E*( ) (XU+fl V ) by E:( ) (XU+fl V ) , E*( )u by E:( )u, and E*( )v by E: ( )v in the weak operator topology because E*( ) is a cluster point of the directed set E:( ). Hence the equality in question is a consequence of the equalities E:( ) (XU+fl V) =XE:C )U+flE:C )v. Now E*( ) we may consider to be the function on the Borel sets of the complex plane whose value at 5 is E*(5). For each Borel set 5, E*(5) is a
!
14
428
ERRETT BISHOP
[November
)ull
linear operator on B* because E*( )u is a linear function of u and IIE*( ~cllull. Under the assumption of (3) we have (x, ff(z)dE: (z)u) =0 for each index 0:, each x in B, each u in B*, and eachfin 9JC(X) with compact support disjoint from C. Passing to the limit we obtain (x, fj(z)dE*(z)u) = o. Since this holds for all x and 1 the measure E*( )u lives on C. Thus E*(S) = 0 if S is disjoint from C. Hence E(S) = (E*(S»* =0 if S is disjoint from C. To show that E*( )u is a T*-measure for u, i.e., that E*(X)u = u, assume otherwise. Choose x In 1:J(T) such that (x, u - E*(X)u) ~ O. Define St = {z: Izl ~rl. Then
II Ea(
) Ea(Snxl I = sup I I 11/11=1
= sup II 11/11=1
= sup
III
11/11=1,
~
f f
f(z)dE",(z)E",(S:)x II
.
s;
zf(z) dE,,(z)x Ii
z
:
f, fez) dEa(z) Lx
sup
II/II =1/,
Sr
I'
!II
Z
f
f(z)dE,,(z) TaX II
"
1
= -IIEa( )T",xll r
~ -
c r
(11Txll
+ 1)
if 0: is sufficiently large, say 0:>0:0. For each positive number r choose a function fr in 9JC(X) with compact support which is 1 on Sr and for which 111,11 = 1. Since E*( )u is a vector-valued measure, the vector fjr(z)dE*(z)u-u converges to E*(X)u-u as r---+oo. Therefore for each e>O a number r,> lie exists for which I ( x,
f
jr,(z)dE*(z)u - u ) - (x, E*(X)u - u) I
<
E.
Since E:( )u has E*( )u as a cluster point in the weak operator topology, an index 0:,>0:0 exists for each e>O for which
I( x,
f
jr,(z)dE*(z)u -
u ) - (x,
We have
15
f
jr,(z)dE:,(z)u - u )
I<
€.
I (x,
E*(X)u - u) I
<x, f fr,(z)dE*(z)u - u ) I
+I
<
E
<
2E
= 2E 2E
=
+ Iil\ x,
f + 1< f + 1<
f
* fr,(z)dEa,Cz)u - u \1
Ii
(jr,(Z) - l)dEa,(z)x,
1t) I
(fr,CZ) - l)dEa ,(z)Ea,CS:)x,
U)
I
(since fr, (z) - 1 = 0 for z in S:.)
~ 2E+llulillfr,Cz) ~
-ljillE
a ,( )
E a , (S:,) xl I
2c
2E + -r, [II Txll + iJlluil 2c
~
2E + liE [If Txll + 1Jllull ~ E[2 + 2ccllTxli + 1)lluIIJ.
Since E is arbitrary this gives the contradiction (x, E*(u)-u)=O. Thus E*( )u is a T*-measure for u. For x in !l(T) , u in B*, and each bounded Borel set 5 we have (Tx, E*(S)u)
=
=
(x, T* E*(S)u) =
is
zd(x, E*(z)u) =
< is x,
is
zdE*(z)u )
zd(E(z)x, u).
Since this holds for all bounded Borel sets 5, Jzd(E(z)x, u) exists and equals (Tx, u). Since this holds for all u in B* it follows that JzdE(z)x exists and equals Tx. We have thus proved (1), (2), and (3). If B is a Hilbert space and c= 1, then Ea(5) and E:(5) are idempotents of Horm 1 and therefore projections. Thus for each non-negative function fin IDC(X) with compact support and each x in B we have
(f = (x, f
o~
f(z)dEaCz)x, x) = fCz)dE:(z)rx ).
Passing to the limit this gives
16
f(z)dE,,(z)x, rx)
430
[November
ERRETT BISHOP
(f J(z)dE(z)x, X) <x, f
J(Z)dE*(Z)rX) ;?; O.
=
It follows that (E(5)x, x);?; 0 for all Borel sets 5. Hence E(5) is a positive Hermitian operator. Since E*C )rx is a T*-measure, the measure mx defined by
mx(5) = r- 1E*(5*)rx = r-1(r£O(S*)r-1)rx
=
£O(S*)x = E(5*)x
is a TO-measure. Therefore
ro
f
s
JCz)dE(z)x =
ro
=
f
f
s·
s·
J(z*)dE(z*)x
zJCz*)dECz*)x
= f/*JCZ)dE(Z)X for each bounded Borel set 5 and each bounded measurable function J. Thus for each x in <J:J(T) we have
(Tx, Tx) = ( f zdE(z)x, TX) = lim i-4
=
lim (TO r~"
= lim T-""
=f
(f
Iz
1
f
(f
Q(I
zdE(z)x, TX)
l Z 1<1
zdE(z)x, x) 1.I
Iz
1
2
dE(z)x, x)
1 z 1
2d(ECz)x,
x).
This completes the proof of the theorem. The double strong topology on :t is defined after von Neumann by taking the open sets in the strong topology of :t and the adjoints of the open sets in the strong topology of :t* and letting these form a sub-basis. COROLLARY
1. The set Gc is closed in the double strong topology.
Proof. If T is in the closure of Gc in the double strong topology, then by part (1) of the theorem each u in B* has a T*-measure, since T is in the closure of Gc in the strong topology. Similarly each x in B has aT-measure. By Theorem 3.1 it follows that T is a scalar transformation. By part (1) of Theorem 3.2 it follows that IIIT*III ~c, or IIITIII ~c. Thus TEG c as was to be proved.
17
COROLLARY 2. If T is a symmetric transformation on the Hilbert space B (that is, TE'1:. and TC TO), then there exists a set function E( ) (called a generalized spectral measure) from the Borel sets of the real line to the positive Hermitian operators on B such that (1) for each x in B, E( )x is a TO-measure for x, (2) if xE'1:J(T) , then Tx=JzdE(z)x and IITx/l 2=JlzI2d(E(z)x, x).
Proof. For any finite-dimensional subspace MC'1:J(T) let P be the projection whose range is M. Then PTP is a Hermitian operator whose range is finite-dimensional. By the theory of finite-dimensional matrices this implies tha.t PTPEG I (see [15 ]). It is clear that the operators PTP form a directed set if we let PITP I precede P Z TP 2 whenever P IP 2 =P1, and that this directed set converges to T strongly. Thus TEGI . Hence there exists a set function E( ) with the properties described in Theorem 3.2. Since for each .,}! the spectrum of PTP is included in the real line, E( ) lives on the real line by (3) of Theorem 3.2. Since B is a Hilbert space and c= 1, part (4) of Theorem 3.2 is true. It remains only to prove that E( )x is a TO-measure. This follows from the fact that E*( )rx is a T*-measure, since the measure fJ,0 defined by fJ,°(S) =r-IE*(S*)rx is therefore a TO-measure and J.l-0(S) = T-IE*(S*)TX = T-1(TED(S*)T-I)TX = ED(S*)x = E(S*)x = E(S) x,
since E(S) =E(S*) (because E( ) lives on the real line). COROLLARY 3. If H is a self-adjoint transformation on the Hilbert space B, then H is a scalar transformation, H = JzdE(z) , where the operators E(S) are projections and E( ) lives on the real line.
Proof. By Corollary 2 there exists a generalized spectral measure E( ) which lives on the real line such that Hx = JzdE(z)x for x in '1:J(H) and such that E( )x is a HO =H-measure for each x in B. Thus H is a scalar transformation since every x in B has an H-measure as well as an HO-measure (which implies that every u in B* has an H*-measure). By the unicity of H-measures, E( ) must be the spectral measure for H, so that H = JzdE(z). Therefore E(S) is an idempotent which is positive Hermitian, or a projection. This completes the proof. Professor F. \Volf has called the attention of the author to an interesting result of Bade [2]. Bade considers a directed set {T" I of operators in Ge such that T:---'>T* strongly for some operator Ton B, much as in Theorem 3.2. In addition he assumes that there is a closed set C of complex numbers such that the spectrum of each T" lies in C and such that linear combinations of functions of the type 1/(z-zo) with Zo in C' can be used to approximate any continuous function on C. The conclusion is that TEGc. This result can be derived from Theorem 3.2, with the hypothesis that the spectrum of each T" lies in C replaced by the weaker hypothesis that the spectrum of T lies in C. To see this, let T be such an operator in Ge, so that (1) and (2) of Theo-
18
432
ERRETT BISHOP
[November
rem 3.2 hold for some function E( ). The T*-measure E*( )u lives on C because it lives on the spectrum of T*. If J.1 is any other T*-measure for u, then J.1 also lives on C, so that E*( )u - J.1 is a T*-measure for 0 which lives on C. For each "A in C' define x>.=Jcd(E*( )u-J.1)(z)j(z-"A), so that (T-"A)x>.=O for all "A in C'. Since "A is in the resolvent set of C this implies that x>. = 0 for all "A in ct. By the assumptions about C this means that Jcf(z)d(E*( )u-J.1)(z) =0 for every continuous functionf(z) on C. Therefore the measure E*( )u-J.1 is zero. Thus u has the unique T*-measure E*( )u. It follows from Theorem 3.1 that T* is a scalar operator. The author knows of no way to show directly that G1 includes the set of normal transformations if B is a Hilbert space. Therefore Theorem 3.2 cannot be used to prove the spectral theorem for normal transformations directly, but instead the usual proofs based on Corollary 3 may be given. For the rest of the paper we assume that the spectral theorem for normal transformations is known. Halmos [9] has defined an operator T on a Hilbert space B to be subnormal if there exists an extension B of B and a normal operator t on B which is an extension of T. We define similarly a transformation T in ~ to be subnormal if there exists an extension B of B and a normal transformation t on B which is an extension of T. The following theorem gives a new characterization of the subnormal transformations. THEOREM 3.3. The transformation T is subnormal if and only if TEG 1 • Since G1 is the set of normal transformations, this means that the subnormal transformations are the strong closure of the set oj normal transformations. The transformation T is subnormal if and only tf there exists a generalized spectral measure E( ) such that (1) for each u in B, E*( )u is a T*-measure, (2) Tx = JzdE(z)x for all x in '1)(T) , (3) II Txllz = JI zIZd(E(z)x, x) for all x in '1)(T).
Proof. We may assume that B is infinite-dimensional since otherwise the various transformations mentioned in the theorem can easily be shown to be normal. Let T be subnormal, so that Band t exist. We may assume that B has the same dimension as B, since the least subspace of B including Band invariant under T and T* will have this property; and on this subspace T is normal. For any finite-dimensional subspace M of '1)(T), we may therefore find a unitary map V of B onto B which takes each vector of MUT(M) onto itself. Thus V-ltV is a normal transformation on B, which agrees with T on M. The existence of such a transformation for arbitrary M means that TEGl . If TEGl , conditions (1), (2), and (3) follow from Theorem 3.2. If there is a generalized spectral measure E( ) satisfying (1), (2), and (3), then by a theorem of N eumark [13] there exists an extension B of B and a
19
19571
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
433
spectral measure E( ) on B such that E( ) = P E( )P, where P is the projection whose range is B. Let T = fzdE(z). Then for x in 'V(T), IITxl12 =flzI2d(E(z)x, x)=flzI 2 d(PE(z)Px, x)=flzI 2d(E(z)x, x). Since the latter integral converges, xE:D( T), and so Txli = Tx!l. Moreover
II
PT(x) = P
f
zdE(z)x =
II
f
zdPE(z)Px = Tx.
II
Since /I Txl/ = Txll, we must have Tx = Tx. Thus T is a normal extension of T, so that T is a subnormal transformation. This completes the proof of the theorem. See [1] for this type of argument. COROLLARY 1. The subnormal operators are the closure of the normal operators in the strong operator topology. Proof. It follows from the theorem that the closure of the set of normal operators is included in the set of subnormal operators. To prove the converse, it is only necessary to repeat the first part of the proof of Theorem 3.3 for operators instead of transformations. 4. Functional calculus. A functional calculus for certain transformations Tin ::t will be developed. It is clear by induction that if m is a T-measure and S is a bounded Borel set then m(S) E'JJ(Tn) for each positive integer nand Tnm(S) = fszndm(z). YIore generally if peT) is a polynomial in T, then under the same assumptions m(S) E'J)(p(T» and p(T)m(S) = fsP(z)dm(z). This gives one hopes of establishing a functional calculus by defining, for a given Borel function f, f(T)x = y to mean that x = m(S) for some Borel set S over whichfis integrable with respect tosome T-measure m and thaty = fsj(z)dm(z). There are two requirements which such a definition of f(T) might not fulfill. First, there might not be a sufficient number of T-measures, in which case the domain of f(T) would not be dense. Second, it might turn out that f(T) so defined is multiple-valued. Neither of these things can happen, as we shall see, for the following class r of transformations. DEFINITION 4.1. The class r consists of those Tin :t for which the set F of values of T-measures is dense in B and the set F* of values of T*-measures is dense in B*. LEMMA 4.1. If TEr, then each x in F has a unique T-measure m", and each u in F* has a unique T*-measure )lu. The sets F and F* are linear, and m" and )l" are linear functions oj x and u respectively. Proof. If xE F there exists aT-measure m and a Borel set So such that x=m(So). Defining ml by ml(S) =m(SnSo), we see that x has the T-measure mI· Since the values of T*-measures are dense, there is no other T-measure for x by Corollary 3 of Theorem 2.1. If x has the T-measure mx and y the T-measure my, then AIX+A2Y has the T-measure Almx+A2my; hence F is
20
434
ERRETT BISHOP
[November
linear and mx is a linear function of x. The statements about F* are proved similarly. We now consider any Borel measurable function f on the complex plane and any Tin r. Let Ff be all those x in F for which f is integrable with respect to mx. Define F/ similarly. LEMMA 4.2. The set F j is linear and dense in B. The set F/ is linear and dense in B*.
Proof. If x and yare in Ff , then f is integrable with respect to mx as well as my, and so is integrable with respect to m)'lx+x,y=Almx+A2my. Thus A1X+A2yEFj, so that Ff is linear. Write U n = (z: If(z) I
Proof. For x in Ff and u in F/ we must prove <Jo(T)x, u) = (x,jo(T*)u), or
r. Then (1) if fez) =z, then f(T) C T; (2) f(AT) =Af(T); (3) f(T*)C(J(T»*; (4) if xEFf and ~f the measure fitx is defined by fitx(S) = mx(J-l(S» , then fitx is a f(T)-measure for x; (5) f(T)Er; (6) if {Sn},~~1 is an increasing sequence of sets with Un Sn=X, if C is the set of all x in F for which Inx lives on one of the sets Sr., and if CCFj, thenf(T) is the closure of f( T) Ie; THEOREM 4.1. Let f and g be Borel functions and let T be in
21
JC",,-',,-.nL
J.YJ/J
Int!.VKI' l'V1{ UJ:'t,KAIUK~
4J')
UN A J::IANACH SPACE
(7) iff(z) is bounded, then F=Fr ;
= (fo g)(T); (9) there exists a dense linear set 53C'V(f(T»)I\'1J(g(T»n'V«(fg) (T» n'V«(f+g)(T) for which the closures of the transformations f(T) I53, geT) I53, (f+g)(T) 53, and (fg)(T) 53 are respectivelyf(T), geT), (f+g)(T), and (fg)(T), and for which (f+g)(T) 153 = f(T) 'i3+g(T) 'i3 and (fg) (T) 53 =f(T)g(T) 53; (10) tf f,,(z)-'>f(z) as n-'> 00 for all z, then there exists a dense linear subset of B such that the closure of f(T) is f(T) and such that fn(T)x-,>f(T)x as n-'> 00 for all x in m. (8) if (fo g)(z) =f(g(z» , thenf(g(T)
I
I
I
I
I
I
Im
m
Proof. Iff(z)=z and xEFr = '1J(fo(T» , thenfo(T)x=Jzdmx(z)=Tx, as was shown in §2. Thusfo(T)CT, and since Tis closed,f(T)CT, proving (1). It is obvious that f(AT) =Af(T). Since (f(T)*=(fo(T»***=(fo(T»* and since (fo(T»*~fo(T*), we have (f(T»*~fo(T*). Since (f(T)* is closed, this gives (f(T»*~f(T*). If xEFr and if S is a bounded Borel set, then we saw in §1 that Jszdm",(z) = Jr- 1(sd(z)dm",(z). Since fez) is bounded on f-I(S) it follows that mx(S) = m",(j-l(S» E Fr and f(T)mx(S) = f(T)mx(f-l(S» = fo(T)mx(f-I(S» = Jr1(S)f(z)dmx(z) = Jszdmx(z). Thus m", is a f(T)-measure. We have just seen that each x in F j has af(T)-measure. Similarly each u in F/ has af(T*)-measure, which is at the same time a (f(T»*-measure since f(T*) C(f(T)*. Since Fj is dense in Band F/ is dense in B*, this implies that f(T)
Er.
To prove (6) it is necessary only to show that fo(T) is included in the closure of f(T)1 C, since the closure of fo(T) isf(T). If xEF/let xn=m",(Sn). By hypothesis xnE C. We have Xn-'>X andfo(T)xn = JsJ(z)dm",(z)-'>Jf(z)dmx(z) =fo(T)x as n-'> 00 since xE Fr. Thusfo(T) is included in the closure of f(T) C, as was to be proved. If fez) is bounded, then for each x in F the integral Jf(z)dm",(z) exists so that F=Fj • To prove that f(g(T» = (f 0 g) (T), we consider the sequence of sets {Sn defined by S" = g-I z. If(z) I ~ n} n (z: Ig(z) I ~ n}, which satisfies the h:.pothesis of (6). Take any x in C, so that there exists an n for which m", lives on Snp and define mx by mx(S) =mx(g-l(S». Then mx is a g(T)-measure for x by (4). Moreover for ally subset S of {z:lf(z)l>nl we have mx(S) =mx(g-I(S» =0, since m", lives on S" and Snng-I(S) is void. Thus mx lives on {z: If(z) ~ n}. Hence x E '1J(f(g(T») and f(g(T»x = Jf(z)dmx(z) = Jf(g(z»dm",(z) = J(fog)(z)dmx(z) = (fog)(T)x. Therefore, f(g(T»IC = (f 0 g)(T) I C = A. It follows from (6) thatf(g(T» as well as (f 0 g)(T) is the closure of A, so that f(g(T» = (f 0 g) (T). To prove (9), let Sn = {z: If(z) I ~ n and I g(z) I ~ n so that {Sn satisfies the hypothesis of (6). Write 'i3= C. Then 53CFj , 'i3CFg , 'i.!CFrH' and 'i3CF/ g • It follows from (6) thatf(T), geT), (f+g) (T), and (fg)(T) are the closures respectively of f(T) 'i.!, geT) 'i3, Cf+g)(T) 'i.!, (fg)(T) 'i.!. Moreover, for x in 2
I
I
i
I
l.
I
I
I
22
I
I
+
+
have f(T)x g(T)x = Jf(z)dm",(z) Jg(z)dm",(z) = J(f +g)(z)dmx(z) = (f g)(T)x. Choose n for which m", lives on Sn. Define m", by m",(S) = Jsg(z)dm",(z). As was shown in §2, mz is a T-measure. By definition g(T)x = ?hiS,,) = mx(X), and hence m .. is a T-measure for g(T)x. Since f(T) is bounded on Sn we have g(T)x E '1)(f(T» and f(T)g(T)x = f(T)mz(Sn) = jsJCz)dm",Cz) = js,J(z)g(z)dm",Cz) = (fg)(T)x. Thus (fg)(T)x=f(T)g(T)x for we
+
x in ~. This completes the proof (9). To prove (10), define the sequence Sn of (6) by Sn = I z: If(z) I ~ nand If.(z) -fez) I ~ 1 for all i ~ n l and write m for C. Clearly S" is a monotone increasing sequence. Also Un Sn = X because limnfn(z) = fez) pointwise. Any element x of mis in Ff becausef(z) is bounded on each Sn. Thus by (6),fCT) is the closure of f(T) I m. For any x in m, m", lives on Sn for some n, so that xEFfi for i~n. Moreover fi(T)x=jS,Ji(z)dm",(z) converges to jsJCz)dmx(z) = f(T)x as i--7OO by Lebesgue's bounded convergence theorem (which is easily shown to hold for vector-valued measures). This finishes the proof of Theorem 4.1. At several points the calculus just developed falls short of the functional calculus for self-adjoint transformations. One would like to have equality instead of inclusion in (1) and (3). It would also be desirable to strengthen (9), and prove for instancef(T) +g(T) C (J+g)(T), or at least thatf(T) +g(T) and (f+g)(T) agree on their common domain. The author was not able to decide these questions. In analogy with the case of a self-adjoint transformation, it might be expected that J(T) is bounded in case fCz) and T are bounded. That this is not true can be seen from very simple examples. We merely state, without giving the somewhat lengthy proof, that an operator T in r is a scalar operator if and only if f( T) is bounded for every bounded Borel function f. 5. Weak T-measures. For certain operators T there are no nontrivial Tor T*-measures. For instance, let T be quasi-nilpotent. Then any T-measure m must be concentrated at the origin. Its value at the origin must be in the null space of T. Thus there are no nontrivial T- or T*-measures in case the null spaces of T and T* are trivial. On the other hand it would be desirable to generalize the notion of T-measure in order to have every measure concentrated at the origin be a T-measure when T is quasi-nilpotent. Before giving the generalization in question, we must prove some prelimmary lemmas. LEMMA 5.1. If T is a closed linear transformation on the reflexive Banach space B, and if m is a vector-valued measure on the set of positive integers with values in 'V(T), then Tm is a vector-valued measure.
Proof. We first note that if {x,} is a sequence from 'V(T) converging to II TXil1
x in '1)(T) for which
23
1957]
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
437
as i-'> 00. To see this, note that for all u in ~(T*) we have (Tx, u) = (x, T*u) = lim (Xi, T*u) = lim (TXi' u). This, together with TXil1 no can be chosen so that E U whenever SIC {n: n> nd. From this and the above we see that Tm(S)11 ~Ko for some constant Ko independent of S. It follows that Lt~\ Tm(Si) converges weakly to Tm(U i Si) for every disjoint sequence {S;} of Borel sets In other words, (Tm)u is a vector-valued measure for each u. This proves the lemma.
I
IITm(S)11
I
IITxll m(SlUSo) II
x
LEMMA 5.2. If T is a closed linear transformation on the reflexive Banach space B and if m is a vector-valued measure with values in 'Jj(T), then Tm is a vector-valued measure.
I
Proof. If {Si is a disjoint sequence of measurable sets, define the vectorvalued measure J.l on the positive integers C by J.l(R) =m(U iER Si). Then TJ.l is a vector-valued measure by Lemma 5.1, so that Li:\ Tm(S,) = Lt: I TJ.lCl i}) = TJ.l( C) = Tm(U i Si), as was to be proved. If f is a simple function and Tm exists (i e., Tm(S) exists for all Borel sets S) we obviously have fj(z)dm(z)E'V(T) and Tff(z)dm(z) = ff(z)d(Tm)(z). For an arbitrary bounded Borel function f take a sequence Un} of simple functions converging uniformly to f. Then ffn(z)dm(z)-'>jf(z)dm(z) and ffn(z)d(Tm)(z)-'>ff(z)d(Tm)(z) as n-'> 00. Since T is closed, this gives ff(z)dm(z)E'V(T) and Tff(z)dm(z) = ff(z)d(Tm) (z). Thus if we define the measure m O by mO(S) = fsf(z)dm(z) , it follows that Tm o exists and that Tmo
= (Tm)o.
II
II Tlilimli.
It is clear that if T is an operator, then Tmll ~ 5.1. The set Qo is the set of those JI in Q which have compact SUpport, i.e., those JI which live on bounded sets. The transformation Q from Qo into Qo is defined by (QJI)(S)=fszdJl(z). A measure JI in Qo is said to be a slice of a measure m in Q if there exists a bounded Borel set So with JI(S) =m(SnSo) for each S; JI is called the slice of m lying on So, i.e., the restriction of m to So. I t is clear that Q is a linear transformation from Qo to Qo. If JI in Qo lives DEFINITION
24
438
ERRETT BISHOP
[November
on the set S = {z: I z I ~ c } , then for each Borel function f with Ilfll ~ 1 we have
II f
fCz)dCQv)(z)
I
=
II f
zf(z)dv(z)
Ii ~
Ilzfllllvll
~ cllvll·
Therefore by definition IIQvl1 ~cllvll. Let v be in Qo and let f be integrable with respect to v. Let v be the measure defined by v(S) = isf(z)dv(z). Since v lives on the same sets as v, vEQo. \Ve have
(Qv)(S) = f/dv(Z) = f/f(z)dv(z)
= f/(Z)d(QV)Z =
(Q v)-C5).
Thus Qv = CQ v)-. If mEQo and Tm exists then taking fez) = z and taking mO as above we have seen that Tmo = (Tm)o. This means that TQ}v1 = QTm, assuming that Tm exists. DEFINITION 5.2. A measure m in Q is a weak T-measure if for each slice v of m and each positive integer n, Tnv exists and II(T-Q)nvill/n-.o as n-.w. The notion of a weak T-measure includes that of a T-measure. It is clear that any slice of a weak T-measure is a weak T-measure, and that if mEQo is a weak T-measure, then Qm is a weak T-measure. More generally let f be a bounded Borel function and define mO as above. For any slice v of m, VO is the corresponding slice of mO. Thus IlcT-Q)"vOI11/"=IIC(T-Q)nv)0111/u ~llflll/"II(T-Q)nvlll/n-+o as n-+ oo , so that mO is also a weak T-measure. Furthermore, if Tm exists, then each slice of Tm is of the form Tv for some slice v of m and
as n-+ 00 so that Tm is a weak T-measure. As an example consider a weak T-measure m and a point {zo which has measure x. Let v be the measure of mass x concentrated at Zo, i.e., the slice of m on {zo I t is easy to see that
I
I.
II (T -
Q)nvll
=
I (T -
zo)nxll,
so that IICT-zo)nxill/n-+o as n----'>oo because v is a slice of m. Conversely it follows easily that a measure of mass x concentrated at a point {zo is a weak T-measure if II CT - zo) nxI11/n-+o as n----'> 00. Applied to a quasi-nilpotent operator T this means that every measure concentrated at the origin is a weak Tmeasure.
I
THEOREM 5 1. If m is a weak T-measure, then for every bounded Borel set S there exists an analytic function x" on 5' such that CT - X)x" = m(S) for each X in 5', defined by Xx= - L::~oJsC1/(X-z)nt-l)d[(T-Q)nm](z). It has the property xx-+O as Ixl-+ 00 and -XxA----'>m(S) as IXI----'> 00.
25
__ ~ __ .",~
rVK Vr~Kf\lVK;' V,',
1\ J::l1\NACH SPACe;
4JY
Proof. Since l/(A-z) considered as a function of z is bounded on 5 for each 'J\ in S', the integral Js(l/(A-Z)n+l)d[(T-fl)nm]Cz) defines an analytic function Xn on S' and I/Xn(A)//
~ max zES
I__ l_-I//CT CA -
~l)"v//
z)n+l
= _1
r n +1
I/(T -
n)"v//,
where r is the distance from ;\ to 5 dnd v is the slice of m lying on 5. Since //(T-fl)nvlll'n---70 as n---7C/), the series X), = - L:~o xn(;\) converges uniformly 011 compact subsets of Sf and therefore defines an analytic function on Sf. Obviously x>'---70 and -'J\x>.-'>m(5) as ;\---7C/). We shall prove that (T-'J\) L:~~o Xn(;\) )-'>m(5) as N---7 c/). Since T is closed, this will show that (T-;\)x>.=m(5). We have
.(-
(1' - A) ( -
t \
n~O
Xn(A)
)
= -
+
,\ f S
+~i
-± n~O
=
=
i
f
.t
f
S
1
I>
S
d[(T -
(A - z)n+l
Q)lIm](z)
_(A_-_Z)_+_z d[(T - Q)nm1(z) (A - z)n+l
_ _l_ _ d [T(T - Q)nm](z) (A - z)n+l
+
±
n~O
f
~l)nm1(z)
S
1 d[(T (J.. - z)n
S
_l-dUT - Q)nmJ(z) (A - z)n
1 - - - d[Q(T - Q)nm](z) (J.. - z)n+1
__ l_d[(T - n)n+lm1(z) (J.. - z)n+1
dm(z) -
m(S) -
Tf
N
n~O
- - L: n~O
L n~O
i
i
+
±
n~O
f
1 - - - d[(1' - Q)N+lm1(z) (A - Z)N+I
1 - - - - d[(T - n)N+lmJ(z). (A - Z)N+l
Since
Iii as N~ C1J , this complete:> the proof. This theorem has as some consequences results analogous to results for T-measures which were demonstrated in §2. The most important of these is the analog of Theorem 2.1. THEOREM 5.2. If m is a weak T-measure, fJ. a weak T*-measure, and 52 are disjoint Borel sets, then (m(51), fJ.(5 2 =0.
»
26
51
and
440
ERRETT BISHOP
[November
Proof. Since (m(5 1), fJ.(G» is a numerical measure as a function of C, (m(5 1 ), fJ.(5 2) will be zero if (m(5 1), fJ.( G» is zero for all closed bounded subsets G of 52. Thus we may assume that 52, and similarly 51, is closed and
°
bounded. By Theorem 5.1 there exists a function XI.. analytic on 5f and at infinity such that (T-A)x A =m(51). Similarly there exists U A analytic on 5{ such that (T*-A)ux=fJ.(5 2). By Lemma 2.1, (m(5 1), fJ.(5 2) =0, since -Axx -+m(51) as A-+ 00. COROLLARY 1. If m is a weak T-measure and fJ. is a weak T*-measure with fJ.(X) = 0, then (m(5 1) , J.t(52) = for all 51 and 52. If those X having weak Tmeasures are dense in B then each u has at most one weak T*-measure. If f is integrable with respect to the weak T-measure m and the weak T*-measure fJ., then Uf(z)dm(z) , fJ.(X) = (m(X), ff(z)dfJ.(z).
°
Proof. If fJ.(X) =0, then fJ.(50 = -fJ.(52). Therefore (m(SI), JL(S2)
<m(S\ n SO, JL(S2)
=
+ (m(Sl n
= (m(Sl n Sn, }.l(S2» -
52), JL(S2)
(m(SI n 52), fJ.(SO)
0
=
by Theorem 5.2. If u in B* has weak T-measures fJ.l and fJ.2, then (m(X), (fJ.l - fJ.2) (5) = 0 for each weak T-measure m and each Borel set 5, as has just been demonstrated. Thus under the assumption that a dense set in B has weak T-measures, this shows that fJ.l = fJ.2. To verify that last assertion of the corollary, put x = m(X) and u = J.1.(X). Define the measures mu and fJ.x by m,,(5) = (m(5), u) and fJ.x(5) = (x, fJ.(5). Thus mu(S) = (m(S), u) = (m(S), JL(S) JL(S') = (m(S), fJ.(S)
+
= (mCS)
+ m(S'), JL(S)
= (x, JL(S)
=
}.lx(S) ,
and so mu = fJ.x. This gives
(f f(z)dm(z) , fJ.(X)) f !(z)dmu(z) f !(z)dJLx(z) =
=
(XI
f
=
!CZ)dJL(Z)) = (m(X),
f
!(Z)dJL(Z).
The next two theorems are not proved because the proofs follow exactly the proofs of Theorems 2.3 and 2.2. THEOREM 5.3. If m is a weak T-measure it lives on the spectrum of T. THEOREM 5.4. Let ml and mz be weak T-measures and 51 and 52 be closed disjoint sets such that each component of 5{ n5{ contains a point of the resolvent set of T. Then ml(5J) =m2(5z) implies that ml(51) =m2(52) =0.
27
1957]
SPECTRAL THEORY FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
441
The exact analog of Theorem 2.4 does not hold. Instead we have the following result.
I
THEOREM 5.5. Let Ta} be a sequence of operators on Band T an operator for which T:~T* strongly. For each a let ma bea weak Ta-measure with Ilmall ;22C. Let m be a cluster point of the sequence ma in the weak operator topology. Let an} be a sequence of positive constants converging to 0 such that II CTa - Q)nmaI1 1'n ;22 an for all nand a. Then m is a weak T-measure and IICT-Q)nmlllln;22anfor all n.
I I
I
Proof. For each fin 9JCCX) with compact support and each u in B* we have Ilff(z)d [(Ta - Q)nma](z)11 ;2211J1111 (Ta - Q)nmall ;22llflla~ and Ilfzi(z)dm,,(z)11 ;22 c sup. 1zi(z) Also
I.
( f f(z)d[(Ta - n)nma](z),u) = "E(-1)i(;)(f Z1(Z)dm a (Z),(T:)n-i U )
and
Now (T:)n-iu_CT*)n-iu as n- 00 because T:-T* strongly. Thus we may choose ao such that (T:)n-iu is arbitrarily near to (T*)n-iu for all a>ao and then choose a>ao such that (jz1(z)dm a(z) , (T*)n-iu ) is arbitrarily near to (jz1(z)dm(z) , (T*)n-iu ) for l;22i;22n, because ma has m as a cluster point in the weak operator topology. Thus the quantities 1
( f z1(z)dma(z) , (T:)n-iu) - ( f z1(z)dm(z) , (T*)n-i U ) ;2211 f
+
I(
I
z1(z)dm"Cz) 1111 (T:)n-iu - (T*)n-iu // f
z1(z)dma(z) , (T*)n-i U)
-
( f z1(z)dmCz), (T*)n-iu)
I
can simultaneously be made arbitrarily small for all i with 1;22 i;22 n. Hence (jf(z)d [(Ta - Q)nma](z), u) can be made arbitrarily close to ( f f(z)d[(T- n)nm](z), u)
by an appropriate choice of a. It follows that
28
442
ERRETT BISHOP
[November
Since this holds for all u in B* we have Ilff(z)d[(T-Q)nm](z)11 ~a~llfll. As was shown in this implies that ~a~. Thus m is a weak Tmeasure, since the same inequality must also hold for all slices of m. This completes the proof.
§1
SUPPLEMENT.
II(T-Q)nmll
II
If for each positive integer a we have Tamall ~ K and ma(X)
=
x, then m(X) =x. Proof. Let f be any function with compact support ill 9JC(X) for which fez) = 1 for ~ M and 0 ~f(z);'i; for all z, so that (f(z) ;'i; M for all z. For each u in B*,
Izl
1
I
-1)/zl 1/
I
1<
f
f(z)dm(z), u) - (x, u) I
f = s~p 1< f
;'i;
;'i;
s~p I<
f(z)dm,,(z) , u) - (x, u)
I = s~p 1< f
fez) z- 1 d(Qma)(Z), u)
I ~ s~p Ifez) z- 1\llull s~p II nmall
Ilull Ai s~p (II Tamall + II (Ta - Q)mall) ;'i; Ilull M
(K
(f(z) - 1)dm a(z), u)
I
+ at).
Letting M become infinite we obtain I (m(X), u)-(x, u)1 =0, or (m(X),u) = (x, u). Since u is arbitrary this gives m(X) =x, which finishes the proof. As defined by Dunford [6], a spectral operator T on a reflexive Banach space B is one for which there exists a spectral measure E( ) such that for all Borel sets S (1) TE(S) =E(S)T, (2) the spectrum of l)(E(S) is a subset of S. The spectral measure E( ) is uniquely determined. The adjoint T* of T is also a spectral operator and the corresponding spectral measure, denoted by E*( ), has the value (E(S»* on the Borel set S. If x is any vector in B there exists a function x. analytic for z in S' with values in l)(CE(S» such that (T-z)xz=E(S)x. This follows from the fact that the spectrum of TI l)(E(S» is a subset of S. This implies (we omit the proof) that EC )x is a weak T-measure. This remark enables us to characterize the class of spectral operators.
TI
THEOREM 5.6. An operator T on a reflexive Banach space B is a spectral operator if and only if every x in B has a weak T-measure and every u in B* has a weak T*-measure.
29
lY;)/
J
.:>rc\'-!Kf\L
IHJ:<.URY FOR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
443
Proof. We omit the proof that if T is a spectral operator then every x in B has a weak T-measure Every U in B* has a weak T*-measure because T* is also a spectral operator. Conversely assume that every x in B has a weak T-measure mx and that every U in B* has a weak T*-measure }-tu. The measures mx and}-tu are unique by Corollary 1 to Theorem 5.2. Therefore mx and }-tu are linear functions of x and u respectively. The transformations x->mx and U->}-tu are closed. To see this let a sequence x n } from B converge to x and let {mxni converge to a measure m in Q. Then m(X) = lim mx,,(X) =lim xn=x. By Theorem 5.5, m is a weak T-measure. Therefore m = m x • This proves that the transformation x->mx is closed. By the closed graph theorem, the transformation x->mx is bounded. Similarly the transformation U----+}-tu is bounded. Thus for each Borel set S the transformation x->mx(S) is an operator E(S) on B. Since (mx(S), u; = (x, }-tu(S); for all U in B*, the adjoint E*(S) of E(S) is the transformation u->}-tu(S). If y = E(S)x, then my is defined by my( U) =m x ( U(lS) , so that my lives on S. Therefore E(S)y =y, so that E(S) is an idempotent. The set function E( ) is therefore a spectral measure since E(X) = ] and
I
R( ~
S.)x
=
mx(
~
s) = ~
mx(Si)
=
~ E(Si)X
for every disjoint sequence lSi} of Borel sets and all x in B. For any x, Tmx is a weak T-measure, so that by uniqueness Tmx = m/,x. Thus TE(S)x = Tmx(S) =mTx(S) =E(S) Tx.
It remains to prove that the spectrum of TI m(E(S» is included in S. We first calculate the adjoint of TI m(E(S». Each U in B* is a bounded linear functional on B and therefore on ))(E(S)). Two such, Ul and U2, are equal on mCE(S» if and only if (E(S)x, UI-U2) =0 for all x in B, or (x, E*(S)Ul) = (x, E*(S)U2), which implies E*(S)Ul = E*(S)U2. Since any bounded linear functional on m(E(S» comes from such a U in B*, by the Hahn-Banach theorem, it follows that there is a 1-1 map u----+il from m(E*(S» onto the dual space of m(ECS». It is obvious that ull. From the closed graph theorem it therefore follows that the map u----+il is a homeomorphism and that m(E*(S» may be identified with the dual space of m(E(S». For x in m(ECS» and U in m(E*(S» we have (Tx, u) = (x, T*u). Therefore the adjoint of TI m(E(S» is
II illl ;211
T*I m(E*(S».
Let A be any number in S'. By Theorem 5.1, for every x =mx(S) in m(E(S» there exists yin B with (T-A)y=X. This gives x = E(S)x
=
E(S)(T - ;\)y
=
(T - ,,)E(S)y,
I
so that we may suppose yEmCE(S». Thus m«T-A) mCE(S») = mCE(S». Similarly, l}((T* -A) l}(E *(S) » = m(E*(S». Since (T* -A) m(E*(S» is the
I
30
I
444
[November
ERRETT BISHOP
I
adjoint of (T->") m(E(S» itfollows that>.. is in the resolvent set of TI m(E(S», as was to be proved. Consider a spectral operator T and the corresponding spectral measure E( ). It is known [6] that T- j'AdE(>") is a quasi-nilpotent operator, so that there exists a sequence {an} of positive numbers converging to 0 such that (T - j}..dE(>") ~ an for all positive integers n. Since the projections E(S) are uniformly bounded there also exists a constant c such that E( ~ for all x in B. If we define IJC to be the set of T satisfying these conditions for fixed c and {an}, then the following analog to Corollary 1 of Theorem 3.2 is valid.
II
)nlll/"
II
cllxll
)xll
THEOREM 5.7. Each operator T which is a limit in the double strong topology of a sequence {Ta of operators in IJC is a spectral operator.
l
Proof. Let E,,( ) be the spectral measure associated with T", so that for each x in B the set function E,,( )x is a weak T,,-measure for x. For each Borel set S we have [nE,,( )x](S) = f/,dEa(A)X
=
f AdEa(A)E,,(S)x.
Hence nE,,( )x=j>"dE,,(>")E,,( )x. Therefore (T-n)nE,,( )x= (T- j>..dEa(>..»n . E,,( )x. It follows that
II(T -
n)nEa( )xli lin
~
l\(T - f
~ an(ell
xii)
AdE(A)Y
III/"IIE,,( )xli
lin
lin.
By Theorem 5.5 this implies that any cluster point m" in the weak operator topology of the sequence {E,,( )x} is a weak T-measure. Since lim"_",, 1\ Taxi I = Txll, the norms Taxll are bounded. Thus the norms T"Ea( )x are bounded, since by the commutativity of T" and E,,( ) we see that T"Ea( = Taxi ~ Taxll· By the supplement to Theorem 5.5 it follows that
II IIEa( )
II
II
I ell
II
I
)xll
mx(X) =x.
Thus every x in B has a weak T-measure. Similarly, every u in B* has a weak T*-measure. Therefore T is a spectral operator, as was to be proved. REFERENCES
1. N. Akhiezer and I. Glazman, Teoriia Lineinykh Operatorov, Moscow, 1950. 2. W. Bade, Weak and strong limits of spectral operators, Pacific Journal of Mathematics vol 4 (1954) pp 393-413. 3. S. Banach, Theorie des operations lineaires, Warsaw, 1932 4. R. G. Bartle, N. Dunford, and J. Schwartz, Weak compactness and vector measures, Canadian Journal of Mathematics vol. 7 (1955) pp. 289-305. 5. N. Dunford, Spectral theory II, Resolutions of the identity, Pacific Journal of Mathematics vol 2 (1952) pp. 559-614.
31
lY,11J
~rCLIKf\L
1t11:<,UKY ",UR OPERATORS ON A BANACH SPACE
445
6. - - - , Spectral operators, Pacific Journal of Mathematics vol 4 (1954) 7 P. R. Halmos, lvleasure theory, New York, 1950 8. - - - , Introduction to Hilbert space and the theory of ,pectrat multiplicity, New York, 1951. 9. - - - , Normal dilation and e>::tension, of operators, Summa Brasiliensis Mathematicae vol. 2 (1950) pp 125-134. 10 E Hille, Functional analysis and semi-groups, Amer Math Soc Colloquium Publications, vol 31, 1948. 11. L H. Loomis, An introduction to abstract harmonic analysis, New York, 1953. 12. E R. Lorch, The spectrum of linear transformations, Trans Amer Math Soc. vol. 52 (1942) pp 238-248. 13. M A Neumark, On a representation of additive operator set functions, C R (Doklady) Acad. Sci. URSS vol. 41 (1943) pp 359-361 14. B. J Pettis, On integration in vector spaces, Trans Amer Math Soc vol 44 (1938) pp. 277-304. 15. M H Stone, Linear fran ,formation I' in Hilbert space and their appliilltion, to analy,is, Amer. Math Soc. Colloquium Publications. vol 15, 1932 16. A E Taylor, Spectral theory of c/O)ed distributive operators, Acta Math vol 84 (1950) pp. 189-224. 17. J. von Neumann, Zur Algebra der Funktionaloperatoren und Theorie der normalen Operatoren, Math. Ann vol 102 (1929) pp 370-427. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY, CALIF UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO, CHICAGO, ILL
32
SUBALGEBRAS OF FUNCTIONS ON A RIEMANN SURF ACE ERRETT BISHOP
1.
Introduction and preliminaries.
A set of problems, which has
attracted much attention in recent years, treats the question of what functions can be approximated in some given topology by a given function algebra on a given set of points. The classical Weierstrass approximation theorem, and its generalization, the Stone-Weierstrass approximation theorem, are well-known results of this type which have proved very useful in analysis. Very important work has more recently been done by Lavrentiev, Keldys, and Mergelyan, and their results generalize the classical theorem of Runge (see Saks and Zygmund [4] for Runge's theorem). The theorem of Mergelyan states that every continuous function on a compact set C of the complex plane, which is analytic at interior points, can be uniformly approximated on C by polynomials, if C does not separate the plane, i.e., if the complement of C is connected. We prove a theorem which generalizes this result in two respects: the plane is replaced by an arbitrary separable Riemann surface (without boundary, but not necessarily connected), and the algebra of all polynomials is replaced by what we call a total subalgebra of the algebra R of all functions which are everywhere analytic on the Riemann surface. The subalgebra R' is called total if it contains the constant functions and if the set {pipE C and there exists q*p in C, with f(p) =f(q) for all f in R'} U {pipe C and no function in R' is one-to-one in any neighborhood of p}, called the singular set of C relative to R', is finite for all compact sets C. (It can be shown that when RI is not total, but contains the constant functions, one can identify points on the surface to obtain a new surface on which R' is total.) Our methods are highly measure-theoretic, and we make constant use of the fact that any bounded linear functional lIon the space Q(C) of all continuous complex-valued functions on a compact set C of our surface can be represented as a Borel measure /1 on C. This means that
~fdf1=/I(f) for all
fin Q(C).
We shall somewhat loosely identify
A and /1, so that by the value of /1 on f we shall mean
~f
dl', and by
saying that f1 is orthogonal to f we shall mean ) f d/1= O. For a compact Received October 25, 1957. The author wishes to express his thanks to the Office of Naval Research for the partial support of the work through ONR 041 157. 29
33
30
ERRETT BISHOP
set C, (/l(C) will denote the set of all continuous functions on C which are analytic at interior points. Wre are actually interested in bounded lineae functionals /1 on (/l(C) , but by means of the Hahn-Banach theorem every such A can be extended to Q(C), and therefore can be represented by a measure /i on C. If R' is a subalgebra of R, then R'(C) will denote the set of all continuous functions on C which are uniform limits on C of functions in R'. Obviously R'(e)c (/l(G) , and the problem, roughly' speaking, is to determine by how much R'(C) differs from (/l(e). We do this via an investigation of those measures f1 on e which are orthogonal to R'(e), that is, we see how much these measures miss being orthogonal to (/l(e). We proceed to some definitions, which are necessary to the statement of the theorem to be proved. If C is a compact set, and if R' is a subalgebra of H, then Y (e, R') wil} denote the set {pI for each f in R', there exists q in C with If(q)I~lf(p)I}. The condition Y(e, R')=C is the natural extension of Mergelyan's condition-that C not separate the plane-to the more general situation considered here. The bounded linear functionai A on rfJ(C) will be called an R'-local differential operator on (/l(e) , of order not exceeding N, if (1) A is orthogonal to R'(e), and (2) there exists a finite subset S- of the singular set of C with respect to R', such that f(p)=f(q) for all f in R and all p and q in S, and such that A(g)=O whenever 9 is a function in (/l(e) which vanishes at all points of S and vanishes to order at least N at all points of S which are interior to e. The bounded linear functional A on (/l(e) will be called a R'-homogeneous 'differential operator on rfJ(e), of order not exceeding N, if it is a finite sum of R'-local differential operators on rfJ(e), of orders not exceeding, N. The result to be proved reads: If R' is a total subalgebra of R, if e is a compact set with ,Y'( e, R') = e, and if A is a bounded linear functional on rfJ( e) which is orthogonal to R'(e), then A is a R-homogeneous differential operator on rfJ(e), of order not exceeding N, where N depends only on H' and e. Since it will be easy to show that the only R-homogeneous differential operator' on rfJ(e) is 0, this will have the corollary that R( C) = rfJ( e) whenever Y( e, R) = C. In general, we shall only be able to conclude that the vector space R'(C) (over the complex field) is of finite codimension In the vector space rfJ(e). It will be possible to describe R'(e) exactly in case C has no interior points. Of the six preparatory lemmas to be proved, Lemmas 4 and 6 are of some interest in themselves. Lemma 6, in particular, seems to be a very useful tool in the theory of approximation by polyn.omials, and the author will give other applications of this lemma elsewhere. We develop more notation for later use. If C is compact, and if the function f in R generates the subalgebra R' , then eY(C, f) will
34
SUBALGEBRAS OF FUNCTIONS ON A RIEMANN SURFACE
31
mean .V(C, R'), so that p will be in the complement .Y'(C, f) of y'(C, f) if and only if j(p) is in the unbounded component of the complement of f( C). If C1 has compact closure and if C2 is compact, we say that f in R is schlicht on C1 relative to C 2 if there exists a neighborhood U of the closure of C 1 such that no point in U is identified with any other point of U U C by f. If C2 is void, we simply say that f is schlicht on Cu and if also C 1 is a point {q}, we say that f is schlicht at q (or that f is one-to-one in some neighborhood of q). Since a separable Riemann surface is ]11etrizable, we assume the existence of a metric p on the surface. If SI and S2 are compact and SI ~SH we define p(S" S2)=.sup[inf{p(p, q)lqESJlpES,} .
An arc is a homeomorphic image of [0, 1], and an open arc IS an arc minus its endpoints. A closed disc is a homeomorphic image of {zllzl ;;;;1}, and a disc is a closed disc minus its boundary. 2.
Preparatory lemmas.
1. Let F be a compact set of the complex plane with connected complement, and let 0 be in the boundary of F. Let N be a positive-integer .. Then the junction z can be un?formly approximated on F by polynomials whick vanish at 0 to order at least N. LEMMA
Proof. If there is il sequence {h n} of polynomials whose derivatives vanish at 0 and which converge uniformly to z on F, then the sequence {hn-hn(O)] of polynomials vanishes at 0 to order at least 2 and converges uniformly to z on. F. Now assume that z cannot be uniformly approxima~ed on F by polynomials which vanish at 0 to order at least 2. Then z cannot be uniformly approximated on F by polynomials whose derivatives vanish at O. If we let Q(F) be the Banach space of all continuous complex-valued functions on F, this means that z is not in the subspace of Q(F) generated by the polynomials whose derivatives vanish at 0. Thus there will exist a bounded linear functional A on Q(F) which will vanish on all polynomials whose derivatives vanish at 0, but with A(z)=a=tO. It follows that A(h)=ah'(O) for all polynomials h. We may assume that the bound of A is 1 and that a>O. Let U be a simply connected open set containing F, the distance 1) of whose boundary to is less than aj16. Let ¢ be the conformal map of Izl < 1 onto U, with ¢(O)=O and ¢'(O»O. Since the boundary of U contains points at a distance "T) from 0, it is known (see [1], page 75) that ¢'(0);;;;41). If we let IJf be the map of Uonto [zl
°
35
32
ERRETT BISHOP
f'(O)=
/[f'(0) = ll1f!'(O)1 ~ _1 12 -/[f(0)1" 4 - 16'7
>l . a
Since f is analytic on V, there will exist a sequence {gn} of polynomials converging uniformly to f on some neighborhood of F. Therefore g~(O) will converge to reO). Thus,
This contradiction shows that z is the subspace T2 of Q(F) generated by polynomials h which vanish at to order at least 2. Thus z"=z·z is in the- subspace TJ of Q(F) generated by polynomials z·h which ~anish at 0 to order at least 3. Thus all polynomials which vanish to order at least 2 at 0 are in T " so that T2 = To. Thus z E T J • By a continuation of this process, it can be shown that z is in the subspace T A , consisting of the closure in Q(F) of all polynomials which vanish at o to order at least N. This completes the proof.
°
LEMMA 2. Let R' be a total subalgebra of R, let C be a compact set with ,v(C, R')=C, and let S be the singular set of C relative to R' (so that S is finite). Then there exists a closed C-neighborhood C' of S and a positive integer N, such that any function in (/J(C') which vanishes at all points of S which are interior to C, to order at least N, and which vanishes at all points of S, is in R'(C'), and such that C' is the union of disjoint closed sets {C p }, each containing exactly one point p of S.
Proof. Let p and (j be any two distinct points of S. Let f be'any non-zero function in R' which vanishes on S but which does not vanish identically in a neighborhood of any point of S. Such a function can be round because R' is total. Let n be the exact order to 'which f vanishes at p. Then it is easy to find a closed disc V containing 1) in its interior, and an analytic function q) which is defined and one-to-one on some neighborhood of V, which maps V onto {zllzl ~c} for some C>O, which vanishes at p, and for which [q,(r)r=f(r) for all r in V. Since f vanishes on S, we can also find a closed neighborhood H of S containing V such that f(H)=f(V). Since R' is total, we can in addition take V and H to be so small that S will be the singular set of H relative to R'. Let qo be any point in the component of the interior of H which contains q, except q itself, with f(qu) *0, and let Po be any point of V with f(Pu)=f(qo). Let ( be a primitive nth root of unity, and let 7r be the map of V onto itself defined by )(71:r) = ()(r). Obviously f(r)=f(71:r) for all r in V. Since S alone is the singular set of H relative to R', there exists g in R' taking distinct values at the points q", Po, and the first n-1 images, Pl=71:(PO), P2=7r(Pl), .,. , Pn-l=7r(Pn-2) of Po under
36
Note that f(pj)=f(po} for l;::;j;::;n-l. Now gk, for 0;;;' k;;;. n, can be expanded on U as a uniformly convergent power series in powers of ¢, which implies that gk can be
71:.
n-1
written on U in the form gk= -:£fki¢i, where fki is the sum on U of a i=O
power series in powers of f=¢n which converges uniformly on U. The series defining fki will actually converge uniformly on H, because f(Jl.) =f(U). Thus we may extend the definition of f
This implies that the product of the matrices (fki(PO», 0;::;k;::;n-1, 0;;;'i;C::n-1 ,
and ([¢(P!)ji), 0;C::i;;;'n--1, 0;;;'j;;;'n-1, is the non-singular Vandermonde matrix ([g(pj)]k), 0;;;'k;;;'n-1, O;;;'j::'?n-l. Therefore, the Junction fir[ in R'(H) defined by M=det(fkJ, 0;::;k;::;n-1, 0;C::i;::;n-1, does not vanish at Po. Now for each r in U the linear system n-l
-[g(r»)'xo+ 2.:.fki(r)x;+1=0 , i=O
has the non-trivial solution x o=l, x,=l, x2=¢(r), Thus the function h m R'(H) defined by --1
100
fa n-l
-g
fro
f,
,,-1
h=
fn "-1
vanishes identically on U. On the other hand, we have just seen that the coefficient (_1)n+l fir[ of [In in this determinant does not v.anish at PJ·
We may therefore write h in the form
±
hkg k , where hk is a function
k=O
in R'(H) which identifies any pair of points which is identified by f, and where hn(po) *0. By substitution of Po, '" , P"-l into this expression for h, we obtain
37
since f identifies P; and Pu. of the nth degree equation
Thus g(po), ••• , g(Pn-l) are n distinct roots
i
hk(pO)Xk=O, so that g(qu), which is distinct
k=O
from these roots, does not satisfy the equation. h(go) =
Therefore
*
~ h.( qu)[g( qo))" = k=O f hk(Po)[g(qo) Jk 0 .
k=Q
Thus h does not vanish identically in any neighborhood of g, or it would vanish in the component of the interior of H containing q, and therefore it would vanish at qo. Thus we see that for distinct points P and g in S there exists a closed neighborhood H of S and a function h in R'(H) such that h vanishes identically in a neighborhood of p but does not vanish identically in any neighl,lorhood of q. By multiplying together such functions, we see that for all points P in S there exists a closed neighborhood K of S, and a function f in R'(K) which does not vanish in any neighborhood of p, but vanishes in some neighborhood of every other point of S. With this new function J, whose multiplicity at p we call n, choose U cp, r., and H in the same way as they were chosen for the old function f. In addition, we may assume that H is so small that f vanishes on H - U. We now extend the definition of cp to all of H by defining cp to vanish on H -- U. Let Po be any point in U distinct from p, and define Pu p" •• , , Pn-l as above. Choose any function 9 in R' which takes distinct values at Po, PII ••• , 'Pn-l' Let the functions f k be j
1/-1
defined as before, so that gk =
2. Jki cpt on
U, for O:;=; k:;=; n -1.
(We shall
i=O
not need the equation for gn.) We have seen that the determinant M defined above is in R'(H) and does not vanish identically on U. Apply-, ing Cramer's rule to the set of equations for the g\ we can solve them for cp, obtaining M in the denominator and some function of R'(U) in the numerator. It follows that the restriction of the function cp·M to U is in R'(U). Now M, being a polynomial in the fkj, is equal on U to the sum of a power series in powers of I which converges uniformly on U. Let the first non-zero term of this power series be auf'. Then I'IM will be a uniformly convergent power series on some neighborhood U'={qjqe U,I¢(q)l:;=;c'
38
35
SUBALGEBRAS OF FUNCTIONS ON A RIEMANN SURF ACE
Now let p be a boundary point of C, and we shall show that the last statement continues to hold with N= 1 if H' is replaced by H' n C. From Y (C, R')=C, it follows that none of the components of U'-C lies interior to U', since ~Y'( C, R') would contain such a component. Therefore every component of U' -C contains boundary points of U'. Since > is a homeomorphism on U', it follows that the complement of >(U'nC)=>(ll'nC)=F is connected. Since >(p) = 0, the number 0 is in the boundary of F, By Lemma 1, there exists a sequence {h n } of polynomials which vanish at 0 to order at least N and which converge uniformly to z on F. The function h" 0 (p uniformly on H' n C as n---'>=. Therefore rj> E R'(H' rl C). By Mergelyan's theorem, any function which is continuous on (/>(H' (I C) and analytic at interior points can be' uniformly approximated by polynomials h. Therefore, any function in (/J(ll' n C) which vanishes at p and vanishes on (ll' n C) - U' can be uniformly approximated by functions of the form h 0 1>, and so belongs to [(ll' n C). 0
It follows from what we have just proved that there exist disjoint closed C-neighborhoods {C p }, one for each point p in S, whose union we denote by C', and a positive integer N, such that any function f in @(C') which vanishes on S, which vanishes on C' - C p for some p, and which vanishes to order at least ~V at p if p is interior to C, will be in R'(C'). Since any function in i/J(C') which s~tisfies the conditions of the lemma can be written as a sum of such functions f, the conclusion of the lemma follows. LEMMA 3. Let C be compact, and let R' be a total subalgebra of R with ,y(C, R')=C. Let /1 be a bounded linear functional on (/J(C), which 'is orthogonal to R'(C) and which can be l'epre.'!ented as a measure on an arbitrary C-neighborhood of the singular set S of C relative to R'. Then A is a R' -homogeneous differen6al opel'ator .on 1/)( C), whose ordm' does not exceed an integer N depend1'ng on R' and C out not on /1.
Proof, Partition S into equivalence classes S,' S""', Sn, by defining p-q to mean g(p)=g(q) for all g in R'. Then there exist fUGctions f., .f, ... ,In in R' such that f,(p)=O for p in S-Si and fi(p) = 1 for p in S. Thus, by Runge's theorem, there exist disjoint closed C-neighborhoods U" U" '" , Un, of S" SCI '" , Sn respectively, such that, for l;;;;i;;;;n, there exists a sequence of functions in R' which converges uniformly on U = U I U U 2 U ••• U Un to a function gi which has the value 1 on U i and the value 0 on U - U i , Since .II can be realized as a measure on U, it can be extended to be a bounded linear functional A' on (/J( U), Obviously A' will vanish on R'(U), Therefore, if we define
39
\
ERRETT BISHOP
06
the functionals A" ••• , A," by /I,(n = A'(fq,) , for all f in rtJ(C) , we obtain bounded linear functionals on rtJ(C) which vanish on R/(e) and have sum A. For each i, 1:$1';£n, let Vi be any closed e-neighborhood of Si which is a subset of Ui' By hypothesis, there wiII exist a measure f1 on V = V] U ... U V which represents JI. For each i, 1 ~ i;£ n, let {gil,,} ;:O~I be a sequence of functions in R' converging uniformly on U to y,. Then for each f in rjJ(G) we have 7I
A,(f) = J (iff,) = lim /IVy",,) = lim LI(Jg.,,) It.,.""
1..---'>=
Therefore Ai is represented by the restriction of fl to Vi' from which it follows that "1, can be represented as a measure on an arbitrary e-neighborhood of Si' To finish the proof, it is only necessary to show that "Ii is a R'-Iocal differential operator on (/J(G) of order not exceeding some positive integer N depending only on R' and G. Let the closed G-neighborhood C' of S and the positive integer N have the properties stated in Lemma 2. If we write Gi = U {C"ip E S;}, then C i is a closed C-neighborhood of Si such that any function in rjJ(G;) which vanishes on Si' and which vanishes at all points of Si which are interior to G, to order at least N, is in R'(C;). Since Ai can be represented as a measure on C, and since ,Ii is orthogonal to R'( e), we see that Ai wiII be orthogonal to any function in rjJ(G) which agrees on C, with a function in R'(C;). Thus /l;(f) = 0 whenever f is a function in rjJ(C) which vanishes on Si and which vanishes to order at least N at all points of Si which are interior to C. Since y(p)=g(q) for all p and q in Si and all g in R' , it follows from the definition that Ai is a R' -local differential operator on
of f( C u U J ), It'here U Z 1'S the closure of U", and let yeA) be in the outs1:de boundary of g(eU VI).
Then /1 vanishes on all subsets of A.
Proof. Consider any open sub-arc B of At which has endpoints a and b in A with f1( {a} )=/1( {bJ )=0. Let Bl be any closed sub-arc of A which contains the closure of B in its interior. Since the analytic arc f(A) forms part of the outside boundary of f(Cu UJ, we can find a function cj> on f(Gu U,) which is a uniform limit of polynomials, which maps f(Cu U2~B]) into {zi~(z»O}, which maps feB]) in one-to-one
40
SUB ALGEBRAS OF FUNCTIONS ON A RIEMANN SURF ACE
37
fashion onto a subset of the real axis, and which maps the endpoints of feB) onto and 1. , To find cj), let J be a simple closed curve about the set f(eu UJ which has f(B as part of its boundary and which has no other points of f(Cu UJ in its boundary. Let (/JI be the Riemann map of the interior of J into the unit disc. Then by Bieberbach [IJ, it follows that )1 can be extended to be continuous on J and to map J homeomorphically onto {z\\z\=l}. By Mergelyan [3], (1)1 is the uniform lrruit of polynomials. Then we can find a function '_ which is analytic on the unit disc and continuous on the closed unit disc, which maps the closed unit disc in a one-to-one fasnion into [z\~(z)::;CO}, which maps the arc cj)Jf(B1 » in one-to-one fashion onto a subset of the real axis, and which maps (Mi(a)) and cj)l(f(b)) (but not necessarily in that order) onto o and 1. The composite function 1)=1)2 0 1'J will have the desired properties. Thus the function f =(p 0 f is the uniform limit on C U U2 of functions in R', maps (CU UJ-B, into [z\Zs(z»O}, maps B J in onet to-one fashion onto a subset of the real line, and maps B onto the uniinterval (0, 1). The function f' can be extended to be analytic and schlicht in some neighborhood of the closure of B because it maps U 2 into {z\8'(z»O} and maps BI in one-to-one fashion into the real line. In the same way we can find a function [I' on C U U1 which is the uniform limit of functions in R', which maps CUU,-B, into {Z\~5(Z)<0}, which maps B, in one-to-one fashion into the real axis, and which maps B onto (0, 1). As above, g' can be extended to be schlicht on some neighborhood of the closure of B, and the values of the extended function at points of U 2 sufficiently near to B will lie in the set {z\~(z»·O}. Thus both i' and g' have positive imaginary part at points of U 2 near B. Therefore f' and g' increase in the same direction along B. We may therefore label the endpoints a and b of B in such a way that .f'(a) = g'(a) =0 and f(b)=r/(b) =1. It is clear that the algebra T generated on C- {a, b} by f and g' is orthogonal to the measure p, because p({a})=p({b})=O. The function
°
I)
f' , 1 h = '-- ~=-I g' .f' -1 ' defined on C - {a, b}, can be extended to aeon tinuous function hI on C, because both numerator and denominator vanish only at a and b, about which points they can be extended to be analytic with simple zeros. For a> 0 consider the function f' fl' -ai
[1'-1
f' -1 +ai
defined on C. Its absolute value will be less than the absolute value of hi' Therefore, as a--+O, it converges boundedly to h, on C- {a, b}.
41
ERRETT BISHOP
38
Now l/(g' -ai) and 1/(f' -1 +ai) are uniform limits on C of polynomial functions of g' and f' respectively, so that hI is a bounded limit on C - {a, b} of functions in the algebra T. Therefore all powers of h, are orthogonal to the measure p. Now f' has positive imaginary part on C-Bp so thatf'/(f' -1) has negative imaginary part on C-BI' Similarly, (g'-l)/g' has negative imginary part on C-BI' Thus it is possible to define the arguments of f'/(f'-1) and (g'-l)/g' to be continuous on the set C-BI and to have values in the interval (--rr, 0). Since these functions are real on B I - {a, b}, we may therefore define the arguments on C- {a, b} to be continuous and to have values in the interval (-rr,OJ, Thus the argument of hu since hI is the product of the functions just considered, can be defined continuously on C to have values in the interval (-271", OJ, Since C is compact, the values will actually lie in the interval (E -271", 0] for some E >0. We may therefore obtain the function log hI on C as a uniform limit of polynomial functions of hl1 so that the real part of log hI will be log If'(g' -1)
g'(f' -1)
I and
the imaginary
part will have values in (-271", 0] and will vanish on B 1 • that
~
It follows
log h, df1=O.
For each a>O, by an argument similar to the one just given, the function f'+ai f'-l+ai
h" = --''----''---will be a uniform limit on C of will have an argument function Thus log h" can be defined to limit of polynomial functions of
g'-l-ai g'-ai
polynomial functions of f' and g', and with values in the interval (-271", 0). be a function on C which is a uniform f' and g', and whose imaginary part
has values in the interval (-271", 0).
Therefore,
~ log
real part of log hoJ converges uniformly on C - BI to because g' and f' -1 are bounded away from on real part of log he< converges boundedly on B 1 - {a, function, since the reality of f' and g' on BI implies
°
values of the functions f'+ai and g' - ai
than are
The
log IhI I, as a~O, C- B Also the b} to the same that the absolute j •
g'-l-ai are nearer to 1 on BI f' -1 + ai
1f'1 and 11_=~1 respectively. f'-l g'
hoJ dp=O.
It follows that the real part
of log he< converges boundedly on C- {a, b} to log IhII=:R(log hj)' The imaginary part of log hal? on the other hand, must converge boundedly on C-BI to 3(log hI)' because h" converges to h, on C-BI and both :;j(log hI) and :;j(log h",) have values in the interval (-2rr, 0) on C-B j •
42
SUBALGEBRAS OF FUNCTIONS ON A RIEMANN SURFACE
39
On the sub-arc B of B), f' and g' are positive whereas f' -1 and g'-1 are negative, so that the argument of hx will be a small positive number, on B, modulo 271", if a is small, which means the argument of h", will be near -271" on B. Thus, as a-O, we see that ~(log h"J converges to -271" on B. Similarly, we see that fI(log h",) converges to 0 on B 1 -B - {a, b}. Thus log h", converges boundedly as a-O to a function 11,2 on C - {a, b}, for which log hI - h, has the value 271"i on B and the value 0 on C-B- {a, b}.
Since) log h", d/-,-=O,
Therefore 0=) (log h l --h,)d/1=271"i,u(B).
we must have
~ h~
dfL=O.
Since this is true whenever fl
vanishes at the endpoints of B, it follows that of A, as was to be proved.
/1
vanishes on all subsets
LEMMA 5. Let R' be a total sllbaluebra of R. Let S be a compact set and C a compact subset of S. Let qo be it non-isolated point of S-C. Let go be a function in R' ?chich assume.'! ,'ts maximum modulus for S at the point qo, and at no points of C. Let go be non-constant on every component of the Riemann surface u'hich contains points of S. Then there exists a function g ,'n R' ?Dhich assumes its 1na:cimum modulus for S at a unique point q, lying in S -- C, and there exists a neighborhood W of q on which g is schlicht relative to S.
Proof.
Let
T J = {pip E s, go is not schlicht at p} . Since, by the hypothesis, the points of S at which gil is not schlicht must be isolated, it follows that 1\ is finite. Therefore the set T, defined to be the union of T\ and the singular set of S relative to R', is finite. Thus goeS) is a compact subset of the complex plane, !lo(C) is a compact subset of go(S) , and UuCqo) is a point of maximum modulus of gu(S) which is a non-isolated point of flu(S)-gu(C). Thus go(qo) is in the outside boundary of go(S) , and since [Jo({Jo) is a non-isolated point of [luCS), there must exist points Zo distinct from Uu(Uo) but arbitrarily near to UuC(Jo) which lie in the outside boundary of ooeS). By taking Zu sufficiently close to flo«(Jo) , we may assume that Zu is not in flo(C) , nor in the finite set Ou(r). We may therefore find a pointw in the unbounded component of the complement of [/o(S) whose distance to Zo is less than its distance to {fJC) U Yu(i '). The minimum distance of 1C to !lueS) is therefore attained at no point of {fo(C) U flu(r). The function (z-?c)-J of z therefore attains its maximum modulus for OI.(S) at no point of flu(C) U go(1')· Since 10 is in the unbounded component of the complement of {fo(S) , it follows that (z-1O)-J can be uniformly approximated on some neighborhood N of [Ju(S) by polynomials h. If the approximation is
43
ERRETT BISHOP
40
sufficiently good, h will be schlicht on gu(S) because (Z-W)-I is schlicht on N, and h will attain its maximum modulus for goeS) at a point z, in gJS)-gu(C)-gu(f'). Therefore the function gl=h gu is in R' and attains its maximum modulus for S at a point ql (any point of S with gu«(J,)=z,) of s-c-r. Since ql is not in r, gu is schlicht at ql' Since h is schlicht on gu(S), the function gl will therefore be schlicht at qt· Let the finite set S' consist of all those points P in S, except q" for which gl(P)=gl(q,), By replacing gl by [/,+g,«(J,)' if necessary, we may assume that [II attains its maximum modulus for S only at (j, and at points of S'. Since q, is not in r, we can find a function g, in R' with g,(ql)=O, g2(P) = -y,(q,) for all P in S'. Let e be a positive number, and consider the function g=gl+ eg, of R'. Since gl is schlicht at q" there will exist a neighborhood U of q, such that Y will be schlicht on U for all e sufficiently small. Also there will exist a neighborhood Vof the set S' such that Ig,(p)+gJp)I
!g(P)!=!gl(P)+ egip)!=!(l- e)gl(p)+ e(glp)+gl(p»!«l- e)lg/p)1 +elgl(ql)I~lg/(h)l~
sup {lg(r)llreS}.
Thus g does not attain its maximum modulus for S on the set V. If e is sufficiently small, on the other hand, 9 can attain its maximum modulus for S only near S' or near q" since [It attains its maximum modulus only at S' and at ql' Therefore!! can attain its maximum modulus for S only at points of U, if E is sufficiently small. The point q of U where this happens may not be unique, but if we take such a point q and replace 9 by g+g(q), then q will be the unique point where 9 attains its maximum modulus for S, because 9 is schlicht on U. Since g assumes its maximum modulus at the unique point q in S and is schlicht on U, there will exist a disc W in U containing q on which g is schlicht relative to S. This completes the proof of the lemma. LEMMA 6. If F is a compact subset of the complex plane, and lJ is a measure on F which is orthogonal to all polynom?'als, then jor almost all real numbers Xu there exists a measure fJ on the set L= {zlm(z)=xu and z is not in the unbounded component Qf the complement of F}, such that
rh
J
dlJ = -
FI
rh
JF2
jor all polynomials h, where
44
dlJ = [h d(J
J
41
SUBALGEBRAS OF FUNCTIONS ON A RIEMANN SURFACE
Proof. There will exist a measure /" on F which assumes non-negative values and which dominates the complex-valued measure v in the sense that Iv(s)1 ;;::/1(.'1) for all Borel sets S. Let '/> be the non-negative, non-decreasing function of the real variable Xo defined by ';,(J:o) =,11( [x+illix;;::x,,}). Then cj,'(xo) will exist for almost all 'C Assume
L/1 dv= - t.h dv II '
Xu
is such that ,t,'(x,) exists.
consequence of the equation <:j,'(x 0 )
exists,
vanishes
on
theorem, we will then have
Then the equation
L
h dv=O and the fact that
all
L?
subsets dv= -
~r/7
of (h,
PI (I
F~.
).>,
By
whenever
if
is a
because Runge's IS
any
function analytic on some neighborhood of the set consisting of the union of F and the bounded components of the complement of P. Choose E with 0< E <1. Write T= [z=xlI+iyl the distance from z to L does not exceed E}, and V = {ylxo+iy E T}. Let h be any polynomial, and write Ilhll=sup {lh(z)llzET}. For :ll(z»x'IJ define
where the direction of integration along T is upward.
For :H(z)<J"IJ let
Then it is well known and easy to see that both h, and h. have continuous boundary values at points Zll of T which are interior points of T, relative to the line {zl:H(z) = XII; , and that the difference of those boundary values, h,(zu) -h.(zll), is h(z,,). Therefore, if we define hJz) =h(z)+h,(z) for m(z)<x," and hlz)=h,(z)-h(z) for :H(z)'>xlI' then by extending to the interior of T by continuity, we obtain analytic functions h, and h2 on some neighborhood of the set consisting of the union of F and the bounded components of the complement of F, such that h=h,-h2 • Thus we have
We consider the first term of this sum, and obtain
45
ERRETT BISHOP
42
ILJ
~ IH
:}(XO _X)2 + t']-Tdt dp(z)
=llh!l[j:)(XO -X)'+t 2]-+dt d¢(x) ,
where M is some constant not depending on K=sup {x[ffi(z) =x,
zE
E
and where
F 1}
Since ¢'(xo) exists, the difference quotient [¢(X)-¢(Xn)J(X-xo)-l will be bounded, so that there will exist a constant r; such that ¢(x)-¢J(xo) xo. Thus the function 1 defined for all X>Xo by sb(x)=r;(x-xo)-[¢(x)-¢(xo)] is positive. Also
is a positive decreasing function of x for x>xo, and sb(x)f(x) ~ r;(x-xolf'(x)-",O as X---3>-X n .
It follows by integration by parts that
r f(x)dsb(x);:o;; 0, K
JXo
or
Therefore
Now the last integral is finite, as may be seen by transforming to polar coordinates. Now since a similar estimate can be obtained for
we see that there exists a constant Q, not depending on
ILlh(Z)d))(Z)I~Qllh'I!' E,
for all polynomials h.
we see that
46
E,
such that
Since Q does not depend on
r h(z) dlJ(z) ~ Q sup
{lh(z)llz e L} ,
JFJ for all polynomials h.
Since the linear functional h--->-
r h(z) dlJ(z)
J/l
can be
extended, by the Hahn-Banach theorem, to a linear functional of bound Q on (/J(L), we see that the measure /3 exists, as was required to prove. LEMMA 7. Let C be compact, and p a measure on C orthogonal to the total .'Iubalgebm R'. Let .'/(C, R')=C. Let f be a function in R'. Let a and c be real numbers, a
exist8 a measure pi on
Cn {ql~R(f(q»~b} such that )gdp = ~gd/ll for all g
in (/J(C). Proof.
Define a measure
h is any polynomial, we have
IJ
on F=f(C) by IJ(S)=f/(f- 1(S».
~hd).l= ~hofdf1=O,
Then if
since hofe R'. Now let
be chosen as in Lemma 6, where we may impose the additional requirement that a<xo
Xo
E=.Y(C, f)
n {ql1R(f(q»=xo} n D
and cl=Cn {qlm(f(q»~xo} are contained in the interior of D. Write c,=cn {ql~(f(q»~xo}, so that f(C1)=F and f(CJ=F2' in the notation 1
of Lemma 6.
By the definition of
).I,
we see that
r hofdf/= hI r hdv
JC
for
J
all polynomials h. Consider the complex number Zo not in f(E) with m(zo)=xo. There are two cases to consider, depending on whether Zo is in feD) or not. In case ZJ ef(D), then ZJ =f(qo) for qo in (D-E)n {ql1R(f(q»=xo} c yl(C, f) ,
by definition of E. Therefore, Zo is in the unbounded component of the complement of F=f(C). In case Zo is not in f(D) , then Zo can be joined to a point Zl in the boundary of feD) by a closed interval I whose interior lies in {zl1R(z)=xo} -feD), because {zPH(z)=xo} nf(D) is non-void by the hypotheses of the theorem. Now Fn {zl:H(z)=xo} is contained in the interior of f(D) , because Cn {ql1R(f(q»=x o} is contained in the interior of D. It follows that the interval I lies in the complement of F. Since we have already seen that a point ZI with :H(zl)=xo and Zl ef(D)-feE) must lie in the unbounded component of the complement of F, it follows that Zo lies in the unbounded component of the complement
47
ERRETT BISHOP
44
of F. Thus, from a consideration of the two possible cases, we see that the set {zlffi(z) = XII} - feE) is a subset of the unbounded component of the complement of P. It foIlows that Lcf(E), where the set L is defined in Lemma 6. Thus, since f is schlicht on D, we may define the measure a on E by a(S)=~(f(S», where P is the measure on L defined in Lemma 6, and obtain
~hd;3= ~hofd(~ for all polynomials
h.
Thus
for all polynomials h. Since both E and G, are subsets of D, and since any analytic function on D can be uniformly approximated on D by polynomial functions of J (because f is schlicht on D), we therefore see that L,gd,u= ~gda for all
{J
in R.
Since
j)
vanishes on all subsets of
P J n F21 then f1 will vanish on all subsets of G, 11 e2 , so that
for all g in R'.
We therefore see that LpdP = -
~gda
Thus if H is the carrier of the measure a and if that \
gd(p-a)=O, and
r
[J
for all g in R'. is in R', we see
gd(,u+Ci)=O.
JClUH
]C1UH
We now show that a, which we know is a measure on E, is actually a measure on EnG, that is, that the carrier H of a is a subset of C. Assume first that H-G contains an isolated point r. Then r is isolated point of HU GI , and since f is schlicht on the subset HU C of D, the point fer) is an isolated point of f(HU GI ). Also ~J{(f(r»=xu~:J\(z) for all z in J(HU G,). It follows that the function 0 on f(HU CI ) which has value 1 at fer) and vanishes elsewhere is a uniform limit of polynomials. Thus (}of is in R'(HU GI ). By the equation derived at the end of the last paragraph, it
foIlows
that
a({?·})=-\
{}ofd(/1-a)=O.
JC Iun
This
contradicts the fact that 1· is an isolated point of the carrier H of a, and hence H - C has no isolated points. There exists a function go in R' which assumes its maximum modulus for HU C at no point of G, if H-G is non-void, because Y (G, R')=C. Since HU C is compact, there are only a finite number of components of the Riemann surface which intersect HU G. Since R' is total, we can find gl in R' which is non-constant on each component of the surface which intersects HU G. Therefore, if E is sufficiently small, the function g2=gO+ E g, in R' will be non-constant on
48
SUBALGEBRAS OF FUNCTIONS ON A RIEMANN SURFACe
4:>
each component of the surface which intersects HU C, and will assume its maximum modulus for HU C at no point of C. Therefore, by Lemma 5, there exists g in R' assuming its maximum modulus for HU C at a unique point (j of H- C which has a neighborhood on which 9 is schlicht relative to HU C. Since q E E - C, we can find an arc B of {rl:H(f(r» =xu} n D which contains (j in its interior, which is disjoint from C, and which lies in some disc NcD-C on which U is schlicht relative to IlU C. We may choose Hand B so that Nn {rpl(f(r»>x u} and Nn {rl~H(j(1'»<x0} are connected. \Vrite S=HU Cu B. Then we can find a point (]u in N such that IY(I]u)l> max {lu(r)llrE; B} =max [lu(r)I!)"
E
S}
By moving IJu slightly, we may actually assume that (]o E N- {J'!:JI(J'»=:l'oj .
Let U be a disc contained in N and containing (j" and IJ such that UnS is an open sub-arc A of B dividing U -"4 into components U,=[hl [r!~H(f()"»>.I·J} and U 2 ,=Url {rl'H(f(r»<xu }
,
with [/11 S = A, where [/ is the closure of l '. Since f is schlicht on D relative to C, and since UcD and ScDU C, then f is schlicht on U relative to S. Let (j, be any point of Su D, at which g assumes its maximum modulus. Since IU(II,)I~lg«(]lI)l> max [!!I(i')jJ'ES:, we have (hEU-S. Thus either (j, E UL or (]L E [1" but q is not in [;~ n ULcAcS. Assume (j, E~. Then g(I/L) is in the boundary of the unbounded component of the complement of u(S u U), since it is a point of maximum modulus of U(SU [/). Since g(l/J is not in g(SL; VJ, it is therefore in the unbounded component of the complement of y(S U [/). The set f/( U r- B)
is
connected
!s disjoint from S I.J
V
and disjoint from u(S U [/J.
and
u
because
is schlicht on [; relative to S.
V r-
B
Since
U«(]r)EUCUr-B), it follOWS that U(U,--B) is in the unbounded component
of the complement of g(S U 7/).
Since g(A) = !I(B n U) is in the boundary
of g(VL-B), it follows that g(A) is in the outside boundary of u(SU VJ, in this case. In case (1, E V_. it similarly follows that yeA) is in the outside boundary of y(Su V,). First consider the case in which g(A) is in the outside boundary of Then g(A) is in the outside boundary of g(HU C2 U B U VI)' Since the real part of f equals Xu on A and is less than or equal to Xu on IlU C2 U fl., the open arc f(A) is in the outside boundary of
g(SU VI)'
49
46
ERRETT BISHOP
r h d(p+a)=O for all h in R', we can apply Lemma 4, to the JHUC2 UB compact set HU C2 U B, to the measure p+a, to the disc U, and to the functions f and g in R', to conclude that the measure p+a, and therefore a itself, vanishes on all subsets of U. Next consider the case in which g(A) is in the outside boundary of g(S U VJ ). Then g(A) is in the outside boundary of g(HU C, U B U VJ. Since the real part of f equals Xo on A and is greater than or equal to Xu on HU C, U B U U" in this case f(A) is in the outside boundary of J(HU C1 U B u V,), Since h d(p-a)=O for all h in R', we see by Lemma 4 again that the Since
r
JHUC,UB
measure p-a, and therefore a, vanishes on all subsets of U. Thus, in either case, we see that iX vanishes on all subsets of U. This contradicts the fact that the point q in U is in the carrier H of a. This contradiction shows that H - C is void, so that a is a measure on EnC.
Now cV (C" R') c,'/ (C, R') = C. Moreover, if q E C - C then qEY'(C" R') because ~J~(i~q))<xli~m(J(q')) for all q' in C. Hence .-:/(C" R')= c,. If D- C, were not connected, there would exist a component of D- C, containing only interior points of D (because C, is a subset of the interior of D), so that ,1/ (C" R') would contain all points of this component, contradicting the fact that cC/"(C"R')=C,. Thus D- C, is connected. Since f is schlicht on D, it follows that Fl =f(C1) has a connected complement. By the theorem of Mergelyan, every continuous function on Fl which is analytic at interior points can therefore be uniformly approximated by polynomials. From this it follows that every continuous function on C1 which is analytic at interior points can be uniformly approximated by polynomial functions of f, so that (/J(C1)=R'(C1). Since HcEnCcC" and since we have already seen that
for all g in (/J( C1).
r gdp= J\ gda
JC1
for all g in R', it follows that
II
If we define the measure ,/ on (C- C1 )
u Hc C c C n {ql))1(f(q))~b} 2
by p'(S)=p(S-C1)+a(S), we obtain
rgdp' = Jc-c r gdp + J\ gda = JC-G\ \ gdp + \
J
1
1I
for all g in (/J(C) , as was to be proved.
50
r
gdp = gdp
JC 1
J
3.
The tnain theoretn and its consequences.
THEOREM 1. Let R' be a total subalgebra of R. Let C be a compact set with
Proof. We know that A can be represented as a measure on C. Therefore the class 1', consisting of all compact subsets S of C for which L'1 can be represented as a measure on S and for which ,(/ (S, R') =S, is non-void, because C E 1'. We construct a sequence {Sn} of sets from r by taking S,=C, and choosing S"+1 such that Sn+lCSn and
Then p(Sn' S,,+,)->O as n->oo, because otherwise the compact set C would contain an infinite set of points whose mutual distances were larger than some fixed positive number. Write S= n Sn, and assume that there exists a point qo in S not in the singular set T of C relative to R'. Then there exists a function go in R' which vanishes on T but does not vanish on qo. Since S is compact, there exist only a finite number of components of the surface which intersect S. Since H' is total, there exists a function g, in R' which is non-constant on every component of the surface which intersects S. Thus, if E is sufficiently small, g2=gO+ E gl will be non-constant on every component of the surface which intersects S, and the set K consisting of those points of S where g2 attains its maximum modulus will not intersect T. If there exists a point in K which is a non-isolated point of S, then by Lemma 5 there exists a function f in R' which attains its maximum modulus for S at a unique point p, and which is schlicht relative to S on some closed disc D containing p in its interior. On the other hand, if all points of K are isolated, then K is finite, and since K does not intersect T, there exists a function 03 in RI which has the value g2(P) at some point p of K, which has the value -glr) at all other points r of K, and which is schlicht at p. For a sufficiently small positive number E, it follows that the function i=g2+ E g3 will attain its maximum modulus for S at the unique point p and will be schlicht relative to S on some closed disc D containing p in its interior. Thus, if we assume that S is not a subset of the singular set of C relative to R', we may find i, p, and D which have the properties described. We may assume also that i(p»O. Let au be some real number less than f(p) such that the set
51
48
ERRETT BISHOP
D n [q\'11(j(q»=a} is non-void whenever (io<-a
and Wn=Sn n {q\9t(.f(q»;;;;a} , for each positive integer n. Since n Sn=S, we have n V n = Va and n nrn = nra • Thus, if n is sufficiently large, the sets Vn and Wn will be contained in the interior of D. Let b be any number with ab;;;; sup {:H(f(q'»lq' E S~}, so that q E LV'(S,;, R'). Thus Y(S~, R')=S;" and so S;, E 1'. Also p(Sn' S;,)~d>2p(Sn' Sn+I)' This contradicts the choice of Sn+" Therefore S is a subset of the singular set of C rela ti ve to R'. Since n Sn = S and since A can be represented as a measure on Sn, then /1 can be represented as a measure on an arbitrary C-neighborhood of S. It follows from Lemma 3 that A is a R'-homogeneous differential operator on @(C), of order not exceeding N, as was to be proved. 1l
COROLLARY 1. If C is c01npact, and If R' 1'S a total subalgebm of R, with y (C, R')= C, then there exists a posihue integer N such that R'(C) contains the ideal I(C, R', N) of @(C) consisting of those functions in @(C) u,Mch 'vam'sh on the sinyular set S of C relati1'e to R' and 1J)hich vanish to order at least N at those points of S which are interior to C. The ideal I(C, R', N), and therefore R'(C) itself, has finite codimension when considered as a t'ector subspace of @(C).
Proof. Choose N as in Theorem 1. Then, by Theorem 1, it follows that every bounded linear functional on @(C) which vanishes on R'(C) will vanish on I( C, R', N). I t follows from the Hahn-Banach theorom that I(C, R', N)cR'(C). The last statement of the corollary is obvious. COROLLARY 2. If C is compact, if R' is a total subalgebra of R with 9'( C, R') = C, and if the singular set of C relative to R' is void, then R'(C)=@(C).
52
SUBALGEBRAS OF FUNCTIONS ON A RIEMANN SURFACE
49
Proof. This corollary is in immediate consequence of Corollary l. This corollary applies to R itself, if no component of the surface is compact, since then it is known that R is total, and that the singular set of R relative to C is void, for all C. COROLLARY 3. Let C be compact and 'without inten'ol' points. Let R' be a total subalgebra of R with '/ (C, R') = C. Let f be a cont1nuous fi-lnction on C for Wh1:ch f(rJ)=f(q) whenever p and q are points in C for which h(p)=h(q) for all h in g. Then fe R'(C).
PJ·oof. Let L1 be a bounded linear functional on ifJ( C) which is orthogonal to R'(C). We must show that /1 (f) = 0, and the Hahn-Banach theorem will do the rest. Since .11, by Theorem 1, is a R'-homogeneous differential operator on $(C), and since C has no interior points, we see that A is a finite sum A=1'Ai' where /li is orthogonal to R'(C) and has 1li,
the form Ai(g)="L,aug(pij), with Pij in C and with h(Pu)=h(Pil) for j~l
l;;:;j;;:;n i and all h in R'.
Thus f(Pij)=f(PiJ) for l;;:;j;;:;n i .
Since the
n,
function 1 is in R', this implies "L, aij=O,
Thus we have
j=l
n;,
rti
"1[
Ai(f) = "L, auf(pu) = "L, aijf(Pil)=f(Pil)'L. aij= 0 . j~l
J~l
j~l
This completes the proof. The hypothesis that R' contain the constant functions, which is made in Theorem 1 (because R' is required to be total), is undesirable, since, for instance, it rules out the case of an ideal R', We now show that this hypothesis is not necessary to the validity of Theorem 1. To this end, let R' and C satisfy the hypotheses of Theorem 1, except that we weaken the word "total" by dropping the requirement that R' contain the constant functions. Let.11 be any bounded linear functional on (/J(C) which is orthogonal to R'(C). Let the original Riemann surface be enlarged by the addition of the extra disc {zllzl
{Zllzl;;;; ~ } of the extra disc.
Then Jl can be considered as a bounded
linear functional on (/J(H) , and obviously the functional A' on (/J(ll) defined by LJ'(g)=/J(g-g(O» will vanish on T'(H). By Theorem 1, we see that A' is a T'-homogeneous differential operator on (jJ(H) of order
53
50
ERRETT BISHOP
not exceeding some constant N depending on T' and H (and, therefore, depending on R' and C). It follows that A is a R'-homogeneous differential operator on rj)(C) of order not exceeding N, as was to be proved. REFERENCES L. Bierberbach, Lehrbuch de'r Funktioncntheorie Vol 2, Leipzing, 1930 2. J. Kelley, General topology, New York, 1955. 3 S Mergelyan, On the repreHcntation oj functions by series of polynomials on closed sets, Amer Math Soc Translation, No 85, 1953. 4. S. Saks and A Zygmund, Analytic functions, Warsaw, 1952. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
54
MEASURES ORTHOGONAL TO POLYNOMIALS By ERRI<;TT BISHOp· UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
Communicated by Gnffith C. Evans, January 10, 1958
I
The structure of a (finite, complex-valued, Borel) measure on the unit circle Iw It i::; given by the following theorem,1 which is partially due to F and M. Riesz, and partially due to Fatou. THEOREM O. If v is a measure on Iw I = 1 which is orthogonal to all polynomials, then v is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure dw OlL Iw I = 1. The = 1 which is orthogonal to all polynomiab in w is well known.
analyticfunctionf(w) =
2~
f
(t - w) - I dv(t) on Iw
I < 1 has radial boundary values
dv equal to dw = v(w) at almost all points on the unit circle
The function f(re tB ) of O.
1. The purpose of thi::; paper is to extend this theorem. Let C he a compact subset of the complex plane, with connected interior U and connected complement. Let J.i, be a measure on the boundary B of C which is orthogonal to all polynomials An analytic differential g(z)dz on U will be said to represent J.L if there exists a sequence l'Ynl of simple closed rectifiable curves lying in U for which [g, 'Ynl- J.L as n - 00, in the weak star topology for measures on C, where (g, 'Yn1 is that measure on 'Yn obtained by integrating g(z)dz. It is clear that g(z)dz will represent some measure on B if and only if a sequence l'Ynl converging to B can be found for which the norms II(g, 1',,111 are bounded. Thus, if '" i::; a conformal map of U onto the interior of another set such as C, the differential ip(g(z)dz) = g(",-I(w»d",-I(W) on
measure on B.
Also, if g(z)dz represents
J.L,
then g(z)
=
1. lim -2 n-oo
g(z)
=
_1. 211'z
f
(l" - Z)-I dJ.LCI).
1f'1
f (\ 1"1
Z)-I
(1)
THEOREM 1. If", is a conformal map of U onto [w [ < 1, if J.L is a measure on B which is orthogonal to all polynomials, and if g(z) is defined by (1), then there exists a measure v on Iw [ = 1 which is orthogonal to all polynomials, such that the differential f(w)dw = 'P(g(z)dz) = g('P-I(w))d",-l(w) on [w < 1 represents v, and such that all statements of Theorem 0 hold for v and f Proof; Let be 11 sequence of simply connected open sets containing C,
I
I unl
with U 1'1+1 C Un and nUn = C. Let Zo be a point in U, and let "'n be the conformal map of U onto Iwl < 1, with ipn(ZO) = ",(zo) and ",,,'(zo) [",'(zo)l-l > O. Then 'Pn -- 'P uniformly on all compact subsets of U as n -- 00. 2 From this it is not hard to show that. 278
55
MATHEMATICS
VOl,. 44, 1958
1. few) = lim -2 n-=
1ft
f
E BISHOP
279
[I -;
If
lim - .
n-" 211'1
Since the measures "'n(J.L) all have norms equal to IIJ.LII, there will exist a subsequence of these measures which will converge to a measure von Iw I = 1 in the weak star topology.
By the last equation, few) =
ments of Theorem 0 obtain.
Iw / = 1 -
2~if
(t - W)-1 dv(t).
Thus all state-
In particular, f(w)dw represents v (take 'Yn to be
~).
n THEOREM 2. The differential g(z)dz represents J.L. Proof: Since the differential f(w)ctw defined in Theorem 1 represents v, it follows that g(z)dz represents some measure X on B Thus J (z - I) -1 d(J.L - X) = 21ri(g(z) - g(z» = 0, for all z in U. Since}.l and X are orthogonal to all polynomials, J (z - I)-I d(}.L - X) = 0 for all z in the complement of C. Hence }.I - X is orthogonal to all rational functions whose poles are in the complement of B. It is known 3 that any continuous function Oil B can be uniformly approximated by such rational functions. Thus}.l - X is orthogonal to all continuous functions on B, so that X = }.I, thus proving the theorem By a theorem of Fatou,2 the mapping function ",-1 will have radial boundary values u(w) at almost all points w of the unit circle, and clearly u(w) ~ B. It is known 2 that distinct points have distinct radial boundary values, so that u is one to one. By Lusin's theorem, u will be a homeomorphism on arbitrarily large closed subsets of /w / = 1, so that there will exist a Borel function u- I on B with u-I(u(w» = w, a.e. on /w / = 1. Let vo be the measure dw on Iw I = l. Since vo is represented by the differential dw on /w / < 1, the differential d",(w) on U represents some measure }.Lo on B. THEOREM 3. Thefollowing statements are true: (i) }.I = u(v). (ii) v = u-I(J.L).
en
en
}.I is absolutely continuous with respect to}.Lo and ddJ.L = vou- I. }.Io Proof: Let h be any continuous function on C. We can choose a sequence Irn} converging to 1, with 0 ~ rn ~ 1, such that [g, 'Ynl converges as n --. 00 in the weak star topology to some measure X on B, where 'Yn = ",-I wi Iw = rn }, since /I[g, 'Ynl/l = /I[f, Iw I = rnlll--' /lv/l as n - 00 by Theorem O. As in the proof of Theorem 2, A =}.L. Thus, if h is any continuous function on C, we have (iii)
I
Jh d}.l
= lim J h(z)g(z)dz n-Q,)
')'...
= lim n_CD
I
J h(",-I(w»f(w)dw = Iwl-r"
J h(u(w»dv(w) This proves (i). It follows that u-I(}.I) = u-I(u(v» (iii), let h be any continuous function on C. Then
J (vou-I)h dJ.Lo
= J(vou-I)h du(vo)
=
56
=
J (hou)v dvo =
v, proving (ii).
J (hou)dv
=
J hdu(v). To prove
Jh d}.l,
1"1 A 1 "L1l!JIYlA
"11{"~
1l1.
Il.
1\..l!t1[. t' .'1..1: n~
since (i) and (ii) are also valid for !J,o and yo. This proves (iii). As an application of Theorem 3, let !J, be real. Then,. is real by (ii). Hence v = O. Then)J. '= 0 by (i). It follows that, for any continuous function h on B, there exists a sequence of polynomials whose real parts converge uniformly to h on B. By the maximum modulus principle, the sequence of real parts must converge uniformly on C, and the limit function will be harmonic on U. Thus we have: THEOREM 4. Let h be a continuous function on B. Then h can be extended to be continuous on C and harmonic on U, and the extended function can be uniformly approximated on C by real parts of polynomials This theorem includes the solution of the Dirichlet problem for C, which is known The further fact that the resulting harmonic extension of h can be uniformly approximated by real parts of polynomials seems to be new. As an application of Theorem 4, one can prove the following theorem,4 whose proof will be given elsewhere: THEOREM 5. If A is a uniformly closed algebra oj continuous junctions on B, which includes the polynomials, then either each function of A can be extended to be continuous on C and analytic on U, or A consists of all continuous functions on B. This generalizes a well-known result of Wermer. 6 • This work was done with the support of ONR Contract NONR-222(37). A. Zygmund, Tn'gonometricalSeries (New York, 1955). 2 L. Bieberbach, Lehrbuch der Punktionenlheorie (Leipzig, 1930), Vol. 2. , S. N. Mergelyan, On the Representation of Functions by Series of Polynomials on Closed Set8 ("Am. Math. Soc. Translations," No. 85/1953)) 1 E. Bishop, On the Structure oj Certain l.feasures, ("Technical Reports," No II, ONR Contract NONR-222[37J [1957J). • J Wermer, "On Algebras of Continuous Functions," Proc. Am. ]'.fath. Soc., 4, 866---869,1953. 1
57
pp 211j-211'l
COpyrtght © 1'l511tly Uul<e Umverslty Press.
THE STRUCTURE OF CERTAIN MEASURES
By
ERRETT BISHOP
1. Introduction and preliminaries. This paper is concerned with extending the following theorem, which is essentially due to F. and ~1. Rie"z (see Zygmund [6; 162]). THEOREM. Jz
I=
J h(z)
Let v be a finite complex-valued Borel measure on the 1tnit circle
1 of the complex plane, which is orthogonal to all polynomials (i.e., for which
°
dv(z) = for all polynomials h). Then (i) v is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure on I z I = 1, 80 that there exists an integrable Borel measurable function u on I z I = 1 such that v(S) = Js u(z) dz for every Borel subset S of I z I = 1, (ii) if the function f is defined for I z I < 1 by fez) = (1/21Ti) J dvm/G- - z), then f(re iB ), considered for each r as a function on [0, 21T), converges in L, as r ~ 1 to the function u(e ifl ), and (iii) for almost all values of Zo on the unit circle, fez) converges to u(zo) when z converges to Zo non-tangentially (i.e., when z converges to Zo through any triangle lying in I z I S;; 1 and having Zo as a vertex)_
We shall say, in these circumstances, that the differential fez) dz on I z I < 1 represents the measure v in the sense of F. and 1\1. Riesz. In this paper, we consider an arbitrary compact set C of the complex plane, such that the complement of C and the interior V of Care eonnected sets, and a finite complex-valued Borel measure J.L on the boundary B of C which is orthogonal to all polynomials. The analytic function g on V will be defined by g(z) = (1/21Ti) J dJ.L(t)/(r - z). If there exists a differential g, (z) dz on L', where 9, i'l an analytic function on V, and a sequence bn} of simple closed rectifiable curves, lyiug in V and converging to the boundary B of V, such that for every continuous function h on C the sequence {f..,. h(z)g,(z) dzj converges to J h(z) dJ.L(z), then the differential gl(z) dz will be said to represent the measure J.L. If this is the case, then for eaeh z in V and eaeh suffieiently large n, it follovvs that g, (z) = (1/21Ti) L.9,(t) dr/r - z). By taking the limit of this expression as n - t 00, we obtain g,(z) = (l/21Ti) J dJ.L(t)/(r - z) = g(z). Thus the differential g,(z) dz which represents the measure J.L, if it exists at all, is the differential g(z) dz defined above. We shall prove in §2, as the principal result of this paper, that the differential g(z) dz does in fact always represent the measure j.J.. If C is the set I z I S;; 1, this is already implied by the result of F. and 1\1. Riesz, and in this case 'Yn can be taken to be the curve I z I = 1 - I/n. In §3 we investigate in detail the structure of the measure J.L, using the result, Received September 10, 1957. This work has been sponsored, in part, by the Office of Naval Research, Contract Nonr·222(37). 283
58
ERRETT BISHOP
proved in §2, that J.I. is represented by g(z) dz. Section 4 is devoted to applications. A summary of the results of this paper was given in [1]. 2. The representation of J.I. by g(z) dz. will be used throughout this paper. THEOREM
1. It g(z)
=
The notation and definitions of §1
0 for all z in U, then f..!
=
O.
Let Zo be any point of U. By differentiation, we obtain - z(Jn = 0 for all positive integers n. :\ow by a theorem of :Ylergelyan [4), any continuous function on can be uniformly approximated by functions of the form h,(t) + L7~, aiCr - zo)-" \V'here h, is a polynomial and the a i are constants It follow:-, that J her) df..!(t) = 0 for every continuous function h on B. Therefore f..! = 0, as was to be proved Proof.
J dJ.l.(r)/(t
COROLLARY.
hen
B
If A is a measure on B which is represented by g(z) dz, then A
= f..!.
Proof. Apply Theorem 1 to the measure A-f..!.
e
THEOREM 2. Let l be a compact set with connected complement, with connected interior U 1 , and with boundary B 1 • Let
Proof. It is sufficient to prove the second assertion of the theorem, since this implies the first. Let the Banach space V consist of all continuous complexvalued functions h on e, with the norm II h II = sup (I h(z) II z £ e}, and let V* be the dual of V. Define VI and V~ similarly. It is well-known that V* consists of all finite complex-valued Borel measures on e. Let the meUf->ure J.l.n on e be defined by J.l.nCS) = Jsn~n g(z) dz, for all Borel subsets S of e. Then I h(z) dJ.l.n(z) = J~" h(z)g(z) dz - t J h(z) df..!(z) as n - t OJ, for every continuous function h on e. This means that (J.l.n} converges to f..! in the weak star topology of V*. It is known that this implies that II f..!n II is bounded. ~ ow define the measure Tn = rp(f..!n) on e, , so that J k(z) dTn(z) = J k(
e, .
59
THE STRUCTURE OF CERTAI:S MEASURES
ThEOREM
3.
The meaSllre
p.
285
is represented by g(z) dz.
Proof Let Zo be any point in U. Let 'I' be the conformal map of I z I < 1 .onto U for which '1'(0) = Zo and '1" (0) > O. Let {J n I be a sequence of simple dosed curves containing C ill their interiors and converging to B Let 'l'n be the conformal map of I z I < 1 onto the interior of J" for which '1'.,(0) = "'0 and ¥,~(O) > O. Then, by a theorem in Caratheodory [3), 'l'n converges to '1', as n - 7 co, uniformly 011 all compact subsets of I z I < 1. For each n we define the differential fn(z) dz = 'I'~'(g(Z) dz) = g('I',,(z» d'l'"(z) on 'I',~'(U). We also define fez) dz = ",-l(g(z)dz) = g('I'(z»d'l'(z) on I z I < 1, so that 'I'(f(z)dz) = g(z)dz It is clear that fn converges to f, as n -7 co, uniformly on all compact subsets of I z I < l. Let v" be the measure 'I'~'(p.) so that II 1'" il = II p. II We may therefore assume, by passing to a subsequence if necessary, that {v" I converges in the weak star topology to some measure v on I z I = 1. For each I z I < 1 and each n sufficiently large, we therefore have f (z) n
=
(
g '1'"
(z» d'l',,(z) = _1 dz 21T'i
J t -dp.Ct)'I',,(z) d'l',,(z) = -~ J dl'"(s) d'l'"Cz) . dz 21T'i 'l'nW - 'I'"(z) dz
Now the function aCt) = l/['I'"(S) - 'l'n(Z)] d'l',,(z)/dz - l/(t - z) of t is analytic in I r I < 1. Hence a('I'~l(S) is analytic interior to J" , and can therefore be uniformly approximated on C by polynomials Since p. is orthogonal to all polynomials, it follows that f a(S) dl'" (S) = f a ('I': I (S) dp.(S) = O. Combined with the abO\'e equality, this gives fn(z) = (l/21T'i) J dl',,(S)/(t - z). Taking the limit as n - 7 co, this gives fez) = (l/21T'i) f dv(S)/(t - z). Since, for each n, Pn = 'I'~' (p.) is orthogonal to all polynomials, the measure v is orthogonal to all polynomials. By the theorem of F. and 1\1. Riesz, it follows that fez) dz represents the measure v. By Theorem 2, it follows that the differential 'I'(f(z)dz) = g(z) dz represents some measure X on B. By the corollary to Theorem 1, X = ).I.. This completes the proof.
3 The structure of jJ.. Throughout this section, 'I' will denote a fixed conformal map of I z I < 1 onto U, and fez) dz will denote the differential 'I' -'(g(z) dz) = g('I'(z» d'l'(z). Since we have shown in Theorem ;) that g(z) dz represents jJ., it follows from Theorem 2 that f(z) dz represents some measure v on I z I = l. By the theorem of F. and M. Hiesz, fez) dz represents v in the sense of F. and M. Riesz, the measure v is continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure on I z I = I, and there exists an integrable Borel measurable function u on I z I = 1 such that properties (i), (ii), and (iii) of §1 obtain. The purpose of the present section is to investigate in more detail the relationship between the measures ).I. and P. LEMMA 1. There exists a Borel measurable function v on I z I = 1, with values in the set of essential boundary points of V, and a Borel set M consisting of almost all points of I z I = 1 relative to Lebesgue measure, such that'l'(z) converges to v(zo) whenever z converges non-tangentially to any point Zo of M. There exists a Borel
60
ERRETT BISHOP
measurable function w on B, with values in almost all z with I z I = 1.
Iz I =
1, such that w (v (z »
= z for
Proof. The bounded function tp assumes non-tangential boundary values on some Borel set M consisting of almost all points of I z I = 1, by a theorem of Fatou, to be found in Bieberbach [2]. The non-tangential boundary values of tp will define a Borel measurable function v on M, whose values obyiously lie in the set of accessible boundary points of U. If we define v on the rel'lt of I z I = 1 to have some fixed accessible boundary point of U as its value, then v will obviously have the required properties Also, v will be one-to-one on l~f, because distinct points of M correspond to distinct accessible boundary points (see Carath~odory [;)]). By Lusin's theorem, there exists a sequence I Tnl of closed subsets of M, such that v is continuous on T" and such that almost all points of I z I = 1 relative to Lebesgue measure are in U T". Since v is one-toTherefore 11 is a homeomorphism on one on 111, it is one-to-one on each Tn T. for each n. It follows that the function w defined on 11 (U Tn) so that w(v(z» = z for all z in U Tn is a homeomorphism on each veT,,). Therefore w is a Borel function. If we define w to have the value 1 on B - v (U Tn), then w will have the desired property. This completes the proof. Since the differential dz on I z I < 1 represents the measure Vo = dz on I z = 1, it follows by Theorem 2 that the differential tp(dz) = d
Proof of (i). The statement (i) is equivalent to the statement that dp.(z) = J h(v(z» dv(z) for all continuous functions h on C. Let Ir.} be any sequence of positive numbers smaller than 1 which converge to 1. Since fez) dz represents JI in the sense of F. and M. Riesz, it follows that 11<1- •• k(z)f(z) dz - J k(z) d/l(z) for all continuous functions k on I z I ~ 1. By Theorem 2, there exists a subsequence Is,,) of {rn) and a measure A on B such that f!. h(z)g(z) dz -+ J h(z) dA(Z) for eyery continuous function h on C, where On is the curve
J h(z)
f
h(z) dp.(z) =
J h(z) dA(Z) = lim Lh(z)g(z) dz = lim
r
h(tp(z»f(z) dz
= lim
1 2
0
Jlzl=sn
61
,..
h(cp(Sne;9»f(sne;9) dS,/9.
281
THE 5TRUCTCRE OF CERTAIN MEASURES
1\ow h(rp(s"e;"» is bounded uniformly in nand 0, and as n ---> co it converges for almo~t all 0 to h(v(e;8». Also f(sne;o) converges as n -> co in LI mean to u(e'o) Therefore h(rp(sne;6»f(s,/8) converges as n -> co in LI mean to hCvCe'"»u(e i6 ). It follows that the above limit equals
{r h(v(e,6»u(c;8) de;8 = L'-I h(v(z»u(z) dz = Jh(vCz»
d1l(z),
as \\a<; to he pro\'cd. Proof of (il) Since w 01' ie.; the idC'ntity function almost e\'erywhere on I z I = 1, we have weu) = w(\(1I» = (w 0/')(11) = II, as was to be proved Proof of (iii). Let 8 be any Borel subset of B. By (i) abO\'e, \ye have J.I.(8) = 11(1,-1(8» = I,-.(s) 11(Z) dz. :\o\\" (i) above applies to the measure J.l.o as well as to the nwac.;ure J.I., so that J.l.o = v(v o ) It follows that
r
u(w(z» d/-Lo(z)
=
f~,,,,
u(w(v(z») d1lo(z)
=
f~.(q
u(z) dz,
since w(u(z» = Z for almo~t all z of I z I = 1. Comparing the equations just obtained, we get jJ.(8) = Is u(w(z» djJ.u(z) , as was to be proved. 4. Applications. W{' no\\" use the theorems of the previolls seC'tions to gi\'e a solution to the Dirichlet problem on C. We continue to use the previous notation LEMMA
2.
If the measure
jJ.
considered above is real-valued, then J.I. = O.
Proof. Since jJ. is real-valued, the measure II = w(JI.) will be real-valued. Since II is orthogonal to all polynomials, it will be orthogonal to the real parts of all polynomials. Since any continuous function on I z I = 1, by Feier's theorem (see Zygmund [5]), is a uniform limit of real parts of polynomials, we see that II is orthogonal to all continuous functions, and therefore II = O. Since jJ. = V(II), it follO\,"s that J.I. = 0, as was to be proved. THEOREM 5 If h is any real-valued continuous function on B, there ext'sis a continuous extension of h 10 C, which is uniformly approximable on C by the real parts of polynomials, and therefore harmonic on U.
Proof L('t K denote the set of all continuous real-\'alucd functions on B which are uniform limits on B of the real parts of polynomials If h t K, then there exists a non-trivial real-valued measure J.I. on B such that I h dJl. ~ 0, and J1. is orthogonal to K It follo,,"s that jJ. is orthogonal to all polynomial;;;. By Lplllma 2, J1. = O. This contradiction shows that h t K, so that h is a uniform limit 011 B of a sequence of r(':11 parts of polynomials. Since the real part of a polynomial assumes its maximum for C at a point of B, the sequence \\'il! con\'erge ulliformly Oil C, and the limit function will give the desired extension of h. The next theorem is a genernlization of a theorem of Wenner [3J. The proof
62
J<;HHJ<;'l''l' IH:"HUl'
given here is modeled on a proof of Wenner's original theorem whiC'h is due to K. Hoffman. THEOREM 6. Let T be the Banach algebra of all comple.r contirmmlS functions on B. Let R be the subalgebra of T consisting of all functions in T which are uniform limits of polynomials. Let Q be any closed subalgebra of T with R C Q C T. Then either Q = R or Q = T.
Proof. It is rlear that every fum·tion ill R ran 1)(' extended to he continuous on C and analytic interior to C A"sume that this has lWE'1l dOlle Then for each w in U we have the homomorphism cp" of R into the complex Ilumiwrs defined by
o = (~<, + ~~2)(Zhl(Z) ax
ay
=
QtlJz2 + i ax
ahl(z}
ay
These are jUfit the Cauchy-Hiemann equations for hI' Therefore hI is analytiC' on U. It follows that h is in It, by a theorem of }Iergelyan [-!J Thus we see that h l: R for all h in Q, so that Q = R. We have left the case to consider in which there existsw in U for which ip", is not extendable to Q. Then the maximal ideal in R consisting of all h in R with hew) =
63
THE STRUCTl:RE OF CERTAIN MEASURES
289
structure of a measure JJ. on B which is orthogonal to all polynomials can be obtained as follows. We again define the function 9 on V by g(z) = (1/27ri) f dJL(n/(!; - z). Let Vi be any component of V, and choose Zo £ Vi . Let the curves I J n I converging to B and the mapping functions {CPn I be chosen as in the proof of Theorem:3 Then {CPn I will converge to the mapping fUllction cP of I z I < 1 onto Vi , uniformly on compact subsets of I z I < 1, by the theorem of Caratheodory quoted above. It then follows, exactly as in the proof of Theorem 3, that the differential fez) dz = cp-l(g(Z) dz) on I z I < 1 represents a measure v on I z I = 1. Thus, by Theorem 2, the differential g(z) dz representliJ a measure JLi on the boundary of Vi' It readily follows that the measure ).I 2:~~1 ).I, on B is orthogonal to all functions on B of the form h(z) = 1/(z - zo), where Zo is any point not in B. By applying the theorem of Mergelyan, ,ve see that therefore JL = L';:~l JL,. This fully describes the structure of JJ. in this case. In case U has an infinite sequence {Vi I of components, the same proof shows that the differential 9(z) dz on V, represents some measure JLi on the boundary of Vi , but it is not clear that the series 2:~~1 JLi need converge in any of the standard topologies for measures The fact that this series actually converges to ).I in the norm topology for measures requires a more refined analysis of the problem, which will be given in a later paper. REFERENCES
1. E BISHOP, On measures orthogonal to polynomials, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, vol 44(1958), No.3 2 L. BIEBERBACH, Lehrbuch der Funktionentheorie, vol. 2, Leipzig, 1930. 3. C. CARATHEODORY, Conformal Representation, Cambridge, 1952. 4. S. N. MEIWELYAN, On the repreoentation of functions by series of polynomials on closed sets, American :\lathematical Society Translation, No 85, 1953 5. J. WERMER, On algebras of continuous f1mctions, Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, vol 4(1953), pp 866-869 6. A. ZYGMUND, 7'rigonometrical Series, ~ew York, 1955. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY
64
Volume 9, pp. 946-953, by permission of the American Mathematical SOciety.
APPROXIMATION BY A POLYNOMIAL AND ITS DERIVATIVES ON CERTAIN CLOSED SETS ERRETT BISHOP The work on the theory of approximations initiated by Weierstrass and continued by Walsh, Keldysh, and Lavrentiev, among others, has culminated in the following theorem of Mergelyan (See Mergelyan [3]): Given any compact subset C of the complex plane, which does not separate the plane, and given any continuous function] on C which is analytic interior to C, then] can be approximated uniformly on C by polynomials. This theorem leaves the following question unanswered: If ]0, ]1, ... , ]n are continuous functions on C, can a sequence {Pk of polynomials be found with the property that for each integer i with ~ i ~ n the sequence {p~ll, where p~1 denotes the ith derivative of h, converges uniformly on C to]i? If C is totally disconnected, it is easy to show that the answer to this question is always yes. We omit the simple proof, because a more general result will be given elsewhere. If C is a Jordan arc, the question becomes more complicated. It is clear that if C has a rectifiable sub-arc J, whose endpoints we call Zo and Zi, then for the approximation to be possible it is necessary that !d>+l(Z)dz=]i(Zl)-]i(ZO) for O~i~n-l. Thus, if the approximation is to be possible whatever the functions ]0, ]1, ... , in, it is necessary that C have no rectifiable sub-arcs. Conversely, if C is a Jordan arc having no rectifiable sub-arcs, we conjecture that the approximation is always possible. It is the purpose of this paper to prove this conjecture by means of an additional hypothesis, that C satisfy a Lipschitz condition of a fixed order c at a dense set of points. (This concept will be defined below.) The author has been unable to prove the conjecture without this restriction. If Sl and S2 are any subsets of the complex plane, define d(Sl, S2) =min {\Zl-Z2\\ZlES1, ZzEsd. DEFINITION 1. Let cf> be a homeomorphic map of [0, 1] into the complex plane, so that cf>[0, 1] is a Jordan arc C. We say that C satisfies a Lipschitz condition of order c at a point cf>(t) of C, tE [0, 1], ifthere exist A >0 and I> > 0 such that max {d(cf> [0, t], z), d(cf> [t, 1], z) } ~A\cf>(t)-z\·whenever \cf>(t)-z\ . Then we have
I
°
THEOREM 1. I] C has no rectifiable sub-arcs and if there exists c > 0 such that C satisfies a Lipschitz condition of order c at a dense set S oJ Received by the editors April 23, 1957, and, in revised form, May 3, 1958.
946
65
947
APPROXIMATION BY A POLYNOMIAL
points, then for any continuous functions fo, ... ,fn on C there exists a sequence {Pi} of polynomials for which P~tl-'>fk uniformly on C as i-'> 00 , for ~ k ~ n.
°
The proof of Theorem 1 will utilize the Riesz representation theorem (see Banach [1, p. 60 X is the set of all n+1 tuples (fo, . . . , fn) of continuous functions on C, topologized by the norm (fo, . . . , fn) = sup { Ifi(z) zE c, ~ i ~ n}, then by the Riesz theorem we see that to any bounded linear functional L on X correspond unique measures Mo,···, Mn on [0, 1] such that L(fo,···, fn) = ftfo(>(t»dMo(t) f~fn(>(t»dMn(t). Now let Y be the subset of X consisting of all (p, p[l), ... , p[nJ), where P is any polynomial. Then Theorem 1 states that Y is dense in X. By the Hahn-Banach theorem (see Banach [1 D, this is equivalent to saying that every bounded linear functional on X which vanishes on Y vanishes on X. If L is the bounded linear functional in question, then by the above representation of L we see that L(p, ... , p[n J) = f~P(>(t»dMo(t) f~p[nJ (>(t) )dMn(t) = for all polynomials p. To prove Theorem 1 we must show that this implies that Mo=M1= . . . =Mn=O. The linear functional L and therefore Mo, . . . , Mn will be fixed during the discussion. As an abbreviation we set Lt(P) = f~P(>(t»dMo(t) f~p[nJ (>(t) )dMn(t) for all t in [0, 1] and all functions p analytic in some neighborhood of C. Then L 1 (P) =0. Assume now that >(t) ES. We proceed to obtain a new formula for Lt(p). To do this, take A and 0 as in Definition 1, and let E be positive and less than o. Let J be the circle z ->(t) = E. Then by Definition 1, for z in J either d(z, U1»AE c or d(z, U2»AE c , where U1=> [0, t] and U2 = > [t, 1]. Thus we can write J = J 1U J 2, where J 1 and J 2 are disjoint Borel sets and d(z, Ui) > A eo for z in J;. Now if P is any polynomial, let K=max {lp(z)llzEJ}. Then
D.H
II
II
°
II
+ ... +
°
+ ... +
+ ... +
I
p(z) for
Iz ->(t) I < E.
=
If for i
Ji(Z)
=
(l/27ri) =
I
1
p(f)df / (f - z)
1 and 2 we define
(1/27ri) l/(f)df/(f - z),
then we see that fi is analytic on the complement of the closure of J i, that If,ltl(z) I ~Kjld(z,Ji)-Ci+l), and that P(z)=h(z)+f2(Z) for Iz->(t) <e. Thus we see that IfJJI(z) [0, t] and O2 a neighborhood of > [t, 1] such that 01 (\0 2 = {zll z ->(t) < e} and 01(\J1 = 02(\J2 =>. Then f1 +f2 = p on 01(\0 2 and fi is analytic in 0,. Therefore we may
I
I I
66
J<:RRJ<:'IT BISHUP
define an analytic function gl on 01U02 by specifying gl(Z) =!t(z) for z in 01 and gl(Z) = P(z) -j2(Z) for z in O2, Also define g2 on 0 1U02 by g2(Z) =h(z) for z in O2 and g2(Z) = p(z) - jl(Z) for z in 01, Then gl +g2 = P in 01U02. Also Ig~l(z)1 = Ijl1(z) I ~Kj![AEc]-(i+l) for z in Ui, where i = 1 or 2 and j is arbitrary. For i = 1 this inequality, in conjunction with the definition of L 1(gl), tells us that Lt(gl)j ~MIKE-c(n+l), where Ml is a constant. For i = 2 the inequality tells us that L(g2) -L t (g2) 1 ~ M 2KE- c(n+l). Thus we see that j L,(p) I = I L,(gt} +L 1(g2) j ~ I L1(gl) I I L t (g2) 1 = I L1(gl) I 1L 1(g2) - L(g2) I ~ MKE- m , where M = Ml +M2 and m is any integer larger than c(n+l). Taking p to be the polynomial (z-c/>(t))i, we see that K =Ei, so that Lt([z-c/>(t) ]i) <ME i - m for all E<8. If j>m, this implies that Lt([z-c/>(t) ]i) =0. Therefore L1(p) depends only on the first m 1 terms of the expansion of p in powers on z-c/>(t), so that
I
+
I
+
+
m
Lt(p) =
L: {3i(t)P !il (cfJ(t)) ,
where (3o(t),"', (3m(t)
;=0
are certain complex numbers. For the remainder of the proof, the only use which will be made of the fact that C satisfies a Lipschitz condition of order c at points of S will be to conclude that the expression just obtained for L1(p) is valid whenever c/>(t) is in S. Therefore, the conjecture of the introductory paragraphs can be proved whenever the expression just obtained for L1(p) can be shown to be valid for a set of values of t which is dense in [0,1]. We now obtain another formula for L1(p), where now t may be any point in (0, 1). For any polynomial p and any complex number z we have the Taylor's formula
p(z) =
t
p!i1(cfJ(t)) [z - .;(t)];
i=O
Thus
L1(p)
=
Ei E
=
t
1.
p!Hil(cfJ(t)) [cfJ(x)
I {
p!il(cfJ(t))
(± f ;=0
i=O
t
~ cfJ(t)]} d,uj(x)
[cfJ(X).- cfJ?;]H dJ.£i(X)), (1 - J).
0
where /J-j=O if j>n. If we define i
ai(t) =
L: ;_0
f
I
0
[cfJ(x) - cfJ(t)]H
..
(1 - J)!
67
dJ.£;(X),
APPROXIMATION BY A POLYNOMIAL
949
L:.o
for t in (0, 1), we therefore have L,(p) = pI.1(cf>(t))ai(t). We see that a. is continuous on the right. Comparing the two formulas ob~ tained for L,(P), we see that 'L':'..o(3.(t)pl i l(cf>(t») = 'L;:'o a.(t)plil(rfJ(t) for all t in (0, 1) with rfJ(t)ES, and for all polynomials p. It follows that ai(t) =0 for i>m, tECO, 1), and cf>(t)ES. Since S is dense and since a. is continuous on the right, it follows that a. = 0 for i > m. Be~ fore proceeding, we need a definition. DEFINITION 2. If f and g are two complex valued functions on [0,1], if tE [0,1), and if a is a complex number, then a is said to be a right conditional derivative at the point t of f with respect to g if there exists a sequence {t.}, with tiECt, 1), t.~t as i~oo, and
[((Ii) - f(t)] [get,) - get) ]-1 ----+ a as i ----+ 00. To get more information about ai, take 0
= J.'i [0,
{[ai(t) - Ai(t)] - [ai(to) - A,(to)] }[cf>(t) - cf>(to) ]-1
f'
i-I
=
{
L
;_0
i=O
10
i-lI'O +L f
J .
~ -
0
_EI - L i-O
[4>(x) - 4>(t)]H C ')1 dJJ.j(x) [cf>(X).(~
0
4>~to)]H dJJ.j(X)} [4>(t)
[4>(x) - cf>(t)];-; - [cf>(X) - 4>(to)]H
. J)! .
(~
0
..
(~
'0<"':5 1
-
[4>(t) - 4>(/0) ]-ldJJ.j(x)
-
[cf>(x) - cf>(t)]H
i-I
i-O
- 4>(tO)]-1
J)!
-
[cf>(t) - 4>(/0) ]-ldJJ.j(x).
J)!
The second of these summations less than i- 1
f
2· (2B)H-l
I dJJ.j(x) I in absolute value, if B is the bound of Icf>(x) I and if t is chosen so that IcJ>(t) -ep(to) I ~ 2- 1ep(x) -cJ>(t) I for all x in [to, t J. The latter condition will be satisfied if ep(t) -ep(to) I ~ Icf>(x) -cf>(lo) I for all x in [to, t], and L
i-O
..
'0<"':5 1
(~- J) I
1
values of t can be found arbitrarily close to to for which this will be true. Thus the second summation can be made arbitrarily small for certain values of t close to to. Due to uniform convergence under the integral signs, the other of the above summations approaches i-I
Li-O
f
10 0
[cJ>(x) - cf>(/o) Ji-i-l
(..J $ -
1)!
dILi(X) = - ai-l(to) as t ----+ to.
Thus we see that ai-l(to) is a right conditional derivative at to of cf>, for j ~ 1 and all to in (0, 1).
X/-al with respect to
68
Since aj=O for j>m and since Aj=O for j>n, if m>n we see that a".(t), which is a right conditional derivative at t of Am+l-a".+l =0 with respect to cP, must vanish for t in (0, 1). Thus a". =0. The argument can then be continued to show step by step that ai=O for i~n. Therefore an-let) is a right conditional derivative at the point t of A,,-an=An with respect to cp, for all t in (0, O. If an_l(t)r£O, this implies that [an-let) ]-1 is a right conditional derivative at t of cP with respect to An. Since an-l is continuous on the right, we can find u > t and r>O such that an-l (x) >r for x in [t, u). Therefore for x in [t, u) we see that lan_l(x)l-l
I
I
I
:'1
I
I
I
I
< ,-11 AnCW) -
An(X')
I.
Thus we have
I
-
<
I
~
\
-
,-1 \ AnCw) - AnCx') \
+ \
-
+ ,-1 IxX! I dAn \
I ~ ,-1 Ix I dAn \ • W
Therefore wE T so that [x, w] C T. Thus [x, w] is a neighborhood of x' in [x, y]. Hence T is both open and closed in [x, y]. Since xET, T= [x, y]. Therefore yET, so that IcP(y)-Cx)1 ~,-11~ldAnl for all x and y in [t, u). Therefore has bounded variation on [t, u], so that [t, u] is a rectifiable sub-arc of C. This contradicts the hypothesis. This contradiction shows that an_let) =0 for all t in CO, 1), so that an-l =0. Having proved this, we can use the same argument to show step by step that a n -2=a n -S= ... =ao=O. But ao(t) = f odJLo(t). Thus JLo vanishes on all subsets of [0, 1). Since there is inherent symmetry between the endpoints, JLo=O. Then
so that JLl = O. Thus we show step-by-step that JLo = JLl = . . . This completes the proof of Theorem 1.
69
= JLn = O.
951
APPROXIMATION BY A POLYNOMIAL
There exists Jordan arcs for which condition (2) is fulfilled. For instance, a Jordan arc which has no rectifiable sub-arcs and which has a tangent at a dense set of points will do, because the existence of a tangent implies that a Lipschitz condition of order 1 is fulfilled. To see this, assume that C has a tangent at ¢(to). By this we mean that the parameter t can be so chosen that ¢'(to) exists and is not zero. Now if C does not satisfy a Lipschitz condition of order 1 at ¢(to), then for each 0 >0 there exists z with ¢(to) <0 such that d(¢[O, to], z)
1 -zl z)
1¢(t
1)
z
-
1 < 1¢(to)
- zI
/4
and 1¢(t2)-zl <1¢(to)-zl/4, so that 1¢(t 1 )-¢(t 2)1 Also, 1
<1¢(to)-zl/2.
¢(to) - z 1
~
1¢(to)
- ¢(t 1)
1 + 1(t
1)
-
z
1< 1¢(to)
- ¢(/l)
1+ 1¢(to) -
z 1/4,
so that 31¢(to)-zl/4<1¢(to)-¢(t1 )1. Thus,
I ¢(tl)
- ¢(t2)
1 < 21 ¢(to)
- ¢(t 1)
1/3.
It follows that 'Y
=
1¢(/l)
1
- ¢(/ 2) [ \ 11 - t 2 \-I[ ¢(to) - ¢(t 1) \
1to -
t 1 1- 1]-1
< 2/3.
On the other hand, as 0-'>0 the quantity 'Y converges to 1 ¢' (to) \ [¢' (to) [-I = 1. This contradiction shows that C satisfies a Lipschitz condition of order 1 at ¢(Io). To construct a Jordan arc which has no rectifiable sub-arcs and which has a tangent at a dense set of points, let f be any continuous real function on [0, 1] such that l' exists at a dense set S of points and such that in any sub-interval the set of points where l' does not exist has positive measure. Let ¢Ct) =t+1f(t), so that ¢ [0, 1] = C is a Jordan arc having a tangent at the dense set of points ¢(S). Also C has no rectifiable sub-arcs, because if ¢ [t, u] were a rectifiable sub-arc then ¢ would be of bounded variation on [t, u], which would imply that l' would exist almost everywhere in [t, u], contrary to the condition on f. I t only remains to construct the function f. The standard techniques for the construction of nondifferentiable functions can be used (see Hobson [2]). Let {rn} =s be a sequence of irrational numbers which is dense in [0, 1]. It is easy to construct inductively a sequence {C n } of countable subsets of [0, 1], each consisting of rational numbers and each containing 0 and 1, such that the accumulation points of Cn are exactly rl, . . . ,rn> such that the distance
70
J:!..l\..l\.,c 1 1
IU;:,nVr
of two consecutive points t1 and t2 of Cn is not larger than 6-"d, where d is the distance between the sets {ttt t2} and {rl' ... , r n} , and such
that DnCC,,+I. Here Dn=CnUC n, where Cn consists of all points which lie midway between two consecutive points of C n • Thus D" consists of rational numbers, and therefore is disjoint from the sequence s. Define the function fn on [0, 1] as follows. Let fn(t) = if t E Cr. U {rI' ... , r,,}. For consecutive points tl and t2 in C", let fnCt) = 3 n(t - t1) if t1 ~ t ~ (i1 +t2) /2 and fn(t) = 3"(t2 - t) if (t1 +t2) /2 ~ t ~t2' Since any point of [0,1] which is not in c"uh, .. " rn} lies between two consecutive points of Cn, this defines fn uniquely at all points of [0, 1 J. The functionf" is clearly continuous, except possibly at the points r1, ... , rr" and If..' (t) exists and equals 3 n if t is not in the set DnU{rtt"" rn}. Also, if U1 and U2 are consecutive points of D", it is clear that If,,(u2) - fn(U1) (U2 -Ul)-l = 3". To investigate the behavior of fn at the point ri, where i~n, let t be any point of [0, 1] - {r1' ... , rn}. There exist consecutive points t1 and t2 of C" with t1 ~ t ~t2' By the definition offn' we have Ifn(t) I ~ 3 n(t2 -t1)' By the construction of Cn. we have t2-t1~6-nl t-riI2. Thus, Ifn(t) -fn(r;) =If,,U)1 ~2-nlt-riI2 for all t in [0,1]. In particular, we see thatf..' (r;) =0, so thatf,.' (t) exists if t is not in Dr., and thatf" is continuous at rio Therefore, fn is continuous on [0, 1]. We also see that ~fn(t) ~ 2- n for all t. The series L:=l fn therefore converges uniformly on [0, 1] to a continuous function J. It will be shown that 1'(t) exists if and only if t is a member of the sequence S. If t =r; is a member of s, letf=g+h, where g= L~:11fn and h= L:-dn. Then g'(r;) exists because r, is not in Dn for all n. Also,
°
I
I
I
°
00
00
Ih(u)-h(r.)1 ~Llfn(u)-fn(r;)1 ~L2-nlu-riI2~
lu-r.12
n=i
for all u, so that hi (r i) exists and is zero. Therefore l' (r ,) exists. Now assume that t is not an element of the sequence s. Let n be arbitrary. Since t is not an accumulation point of Cn, there exist consecutive points U1 and U2 in Dn with UI~t~U2. Thenf(uz) -f(Ul) = L~-lfk(UZ) -fk(Ul) because fk(U) =0 if uED nCC n+1 and k ;;;n+l. Thus
If(uz)
I (U2 -
U1)-1
- fn(U1)
I (U2 -
- f(U1)
;;; Ifn(Ul)
n-l
U1)-I - L k-I
n
;;; 3 n
-
L
3k
;;;
n.
k-I
71
Ifk(U2)
I
- A(UI) (U2 -
UI)-I
APPROXIMATION BY A POLYNOMIAL
953
are not bounded. It follows that f'(t) does not exist, as was to be proved. REFERENCES
1. S. Banach, Theorie des operations lineaires, Warsaw, 1932. 2. E. W. Hobson, The theory of functions of a real variable, vol 2, Cambridge, 1926. 3. S. N. Mergelyan, Uniform approximations to functions of a complex variable, Amer. Math Soc. Translation no. 101, Providence, 1954. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
,,)
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR ERRETT BISHOP
L Introduction. This paper studies the spectral theory of an operator (or bounded linear transformation) on a Banach space B. Although it would be possible to modify the results to apply to operators on non-reflexive spaces, for simplicity only reflexive spaces are considered. The distinctive feature of the treatment is that we are primarily interested in the spectral properties of a completely arbitrary operator. That is, we seek a spectral theory which will be valid independently of any of the usual restrictions (such as normality or complete continuity). It is, of course, not to be expected, in view of many known counter examples, that such a theory will even approach in power the spectral theory of a Hermitian or normal operator on a Hilbert space. In fact, it is surprising that a spectral theory for an arbitrary operator exists at alL The results obtained here are incomplete, but it seems likely that any spectral theory which is valid for an arbitrary operator will be closely related to the theory developed here. It is interesting that certain known results in spectral theory, which imply the spectral theorem for a Hermitian or a unitary operator, can be obtained from the theory which we develop for an arbitrary operator. The principal ideas of this paper are developments of ideas which appeared in rudimentary form in unpublished portions of the author's University of Chicago doctoral dissertation. The program of the paper is as follows. Instead of considering one type of spectral theory, we consider four. Since the content of these theories is that a certain duality exists between an operator and its adjoint, and since the term "spectral theory" is somewhat deceptive, we shall employ the term "duality theory" in its stead. The duality theories are not all of comparable strength. The weakest, type 4, will be shown to be valid for an arbitrary operator. This will be the principal result. This having been shown, it will then be possible to show that certain of the stronger and more conventional duality theories are satisfied provided that the operator is subject to appropriate restrictions. The duality theories will concern the existence and properties of spectral manifolds. Two types of spectral manifold are needed. The first type of spectral manifold, the strong type, is defined as one might expect, but it is the introduction of the second or weak type of spectral manifold that permits the construction of a theory which will apply to an arbitrary operator. The two types of spectral manifold and the four types of duality Received July 18, 1958 379
73
380
ERRETT BISHOP
theory will be defined in § 2, and certain elementary consequences of the definitions will be obtained. In § 3 the principal result, that an arbitrary operator admits a duality theory of type 4, will be derived. The proof will entail a preliminary investigation of certain Banach spaces of analytic functions. In § 4, the concluding section, conditions will be given under which the stronger duality theories obtain. In particular, conditions on the rate of growth of the norm II (T - zI)-'11 of the resolvent will be given which imply the existence of a strong type of spectral theory. Such rate of growth conditions have been studied by Lorch [4] and Wolf [7], but the treatment given here is much more general and the methods are distinct. 2. Definitions and preliminaries. It can be seen that the definition given below of a strong spectral manifold coincides with the usual definition if the operator is Hermitian or if, more generally, the operator can be written in the form Dunford [2].
~ AdE(A), in the sense of Lorch [4] or
DEFINITION 1. Let T be an operator on a reflexive Banach space B. Let F be a closed subset of the complex plane. We define the strong spectral manifold M(F, T) to be the closure of the set of all vectors x in B which have the property that there exists an analytic function f on the complement -F of F with values in B such that (T - zI)f(z) = x for all z in - F. It will be seen that the strong spectral manifolds are not sufficient to give an adequate duality theory for an arbitrary operator. (What is meant by an adequate duality theory will become clear later.) We therefore define the second type of spectral manifold. DEFINITION 2. Let T be an operator on a reflexive Banach space B. Let F be a closed subset of the complex plane. We define the weak spectral manifold N(F, T) to be the set of all vectors x in B which have the property that for each c > 0 there exists an analytic function f on the complement - F of F with values in B such that II(T-zI)f(z)-xll<s for all z in -F. It is clear from the definition that N(F, T) is closed and that M(F, T) is a subspace of N(F, T). Examples can be given to show that M(F, T) can actually be a proper subspace of N(F, T); however, it can be show that M(F, T) = N(F, T) if T is a normal operator on a Hilbert space. It is also clear that M(F" T)cM(F" T) and N(F" T) cN(F" T) if F,eF.. Also, M(a(T), T) = N(a(T), T) = B, where aCT) denotes the spectrum of T. The task of investigating the spectral manifolds M(F, T) and N(F, T)
74
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
381
now presents itself. An obvious possibility is to attempt to prove, for instance, that M(F" T) and M(F" T) span M(FJ U F" T). Although this is the case if T acts on a finite-dimensional space or if T is a normal operator on a Hilbert space, it is not true in general. A much more promising possibility for investigation is suggested by the fact that if B is finite-dimensional and if F[ and F, are disjoint closed sets with F] U F;~a(T) then the subspace M(F" T~) of B"- is the annihilator M(Fu T)'L of the subspace M(FJ' T) of B. This is easily seen from the theory of operators on finite-dimensional spaces. By means of the theory of integration around subsets of a( T) which are both open and closed, which has been developed by Lorch and is given in Hille [3], it is not difficult to show that this statement remains valid \vithout the restriction that B be finite-dimensional. In case it is noL possible to decompose a( T) into disjoint closed sets, the essence of the statement can nevertheless be recaptured. This is done by means of the following definition. DEFINITION 3. An operator T on a reflexive Banach space B will be said to admit a d1lality theory of type 1 if JIJ(F" T)' ~1II(F" TX) whenever F[ and F, are compact and disjoint and if l~I(Gu T)'L c JJ(G2 , T"") whenever G1 and G, are the closures of open sets G J and G_ which together cover the complex plane. It is clear that T and T"" play symmetric roles m this definition because B is reflexive and because the inclusions M(F" T)'L ~M(F" T ') and 1I1(G[, T)" C 1IJ(G" T") are equivalent respectively to the inclusions
M(F2' T*-)'L ~ M(F[, T) and M(G21 T ")'L:= l\1(G" T) .
Later we shall see that not every operator admits a duality theory of type 1. More precisely, there exist an operator T and open sets G] and G 2 which cover the complex plane such that M(CI T)' is not a subset of M(G" T~). Since it will be seen that the inclusion JI(Fj) T)' ~M(F2' T*) is always valid, it is a case of the strong spectral manifolds being too small. This is what was meant above when it was asserted that the strong spectral manifolds are not sufficient to give an adequate duality theory for an arbitrary operator, and this is the reason for consideration of the weak spectral manifolds. Conditions on an operator which imply that it admits a duality theory of type 1 will be obtained in §4. Since the duality theory of type 1 does not have much surface resemblance to the usual spectral theories, we no,\, define duality theories of types 2 and 3 which bear a closer surface resemblance to the usual spectral theories, but which will be seen to be intimately related to the duality theory of type 1. Some of the ideas occurring in the development of these duality theories are closely related to ideas which occur in [1]. J •
75
382
ERRETT BISHOP
DEFINITION 4. The operator T on the reflexive Banach space B will be said to admit a duality theory of type 2 if M(G" T), ... , M(Gn , T) span B whenever Gil ... , Gn are open sets which cover the complex plane. If 'T is an operator and M is a subspace of B which is invariant under T, the restriction of T to M will be denoted by T / M. DEFINITION 5. Let T be an operator on a reflexive Banach space B such that for arbitrary open sets G" ... , Gn which cover the complex plane there exist subs paces M" ... , Mn which span B and are invariant under T and have the property that a(T/Mi)cG i • Then T is said to admit a duality theory of type 3. It was shown by Lorch [4] that T admits a duality theory of type 3, in our terminology, if (1) a(T)c (z: Izl = I} and (2) there exists a constant K such that II Tn II ~ K for all positive and negative integers n. This work has been generalized by various authors. In §4 general conditions will be obtained which imply that T admits a duality theory of type 3. We now define the fourth type of duality theory. DEFINITION 6. Let T be an operator on a reflexive Banach space such that the inclusions M(F" T)1.~N(F" T"), N(F)I T)1.~M(F" T'-), M(G II T)1. C N(G 2 , T ), and N(G" T)1.c M(G" Tl-) are valid for arbitrary disjoint compact sets F, and F, and arbitrary open sets G, and G 2 which cover the complex plane. Then T is said to admit a duality theory of type 4. It is clear that T and T* play symmetric roles in this definition. Although this definition seems awkeward, it is justified by the nontrivial theorem, to be proved below, that every operator on a reflexive Banach space admits a duality theory of type 4. This fact makes it plausible that there exists a third type of spectral manifold L(F, T), intermediate between M(F, T) and N(F, T), which is self-dual in the sense that L(F" T) 1 ~ L(F" T") and L(G" T)1. c L(G" T) whenever F, and F2 are disjoint and compact and G, and G, are open and cover the complex plane. The author has not succeeded in formulating a conjecture as to how such intermediate spectral manifolds might be obtained.
3. Duality theory of type 4. Since the definitions of the spectral manifold involve vector-valued analytic functions, it will be necessary to make a preliminary study of spaces composed of such functions. Let B be a Banach space with dual B*. Let U, be an unbounded open subset of the complex plane whose boundary C consists of a finite number of disjoint closed rectifiable Jordan curves. The set U, will be called an unbounded simple open set. Let U z be the complement
76
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
383
of U, U C, so that U, is a bounded open set whose boundary is C. The set U, will be called a bounded simple open set, and U, and U, will be called complementary simple open sets. Let W, be the set of all analytic functions from U, to B which vanish at infinity, and let W 2 consist of all analytic functions from U, to B*. We topologize W, and W, by the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of U, and U, respectively. It is clear that W, and W, are locally con vex linear topological spaces. Let V, consist of those functions in W, which can be extended to be continuous on U, U C, and let V, consist of those functions in W, which can be extended to be continuous on U, U C. If 1 E V, we define 11111 = sup {111(z) II: Z E U,}, and if 9 E V 2 we define Ilgll = sup {llg(z)ll: ZE U,}. The Banach space V, is called the Banach space of analytic functions from U, to B which have continuous boundary values, and V, is called the Banach space of analytic functions from U, to B* which have continuous boundary values. Before proceeding, we state the Cauchy integral formula in a form suitable to our purposes: there exists a unique orientation on C, called the canonical orientation, such that
whenever Zo E U 2 and 9 is an analytic function on some neighborhood of U, U C, and such that
whenever Zo E U, and 1 is an analytic function on some neighborhood of U, U C which vanishes at infinity. For Z in U" ZO in Un and x in B we define o(x, ZO, z) = (z - zo)-'x. For each x in B and each Zo in U" the element a(x, ZO, .) will be called an elementary element of V,. The Banach space V, called the restricted Banach space of analytic functions from U to B which have continuous boundary values, is defined to be that subspace of V, which is spanned by the elementary elements of V,. If 1 E V, and 9 E V" we define j
r ndc
<1, g) = - 12. <1(z), g(z»dz , where C is given the canonical orientation and where we have extended 9 to be continuous on C. It is clear that this defines a jointly continuous bilinear functional between V, and V,.
1 and
77
384
ERRETT BISHOP
LEMMA 1. Let V be the restricted Banach space of analytic functions from an unbounded simple open set U1 to a Banach space B which have continuous boundary values. Let V 2 and W 2 be defined as above. Then there exists a linear subset Y of W, and a norm on Y such that (1) Y is a Banach space. (2) V,c Y. (3) The inclusion mappings V 2 -~ Y and Y --"> W, are continuous. (4) The inner product between V and V 2 can be extended to an inner product between V and Y in such a way that Y becomes isometrically isomorphic to V*.
Proof. Let 'P be an arbitrary element of V -l- • For each x in B and Zo in U2 define 1'(x, zo) = r",(x, zo) = 'p(a(x, Z'l> • For Zo fixed, it follows that r(·, zo) is a continuous linear functional on B, because convergence of {x n } to x in B implies convergence of ~(l(Xn' zo, .)} to a(x, zo, .) in V" which in turn implies convergence of {(p(a(x", ZO, .»} ,= {r(xn,zo)} to (p(a(x,zo, = r(x,zo). Thus J'(·,zo)EB' for each Zo in U,. We now prove that l' E W,. By this we mean that the mapping Zo --"> r(., zo) is an analytic function from U, to B*. It is sufficient to show that this mapping is weakly analytic, i.e., to show that Zo ~ r(x, zo) is an analytic function on U 2 for each x in B (see Hille [3], page 53). To this end we consider the difference quotient
».
.»
[r(x, Z1) - r(x, ZO)](Z, - ZO)-1
= (p{[a(x, z" .) - a(x, ZO, • )](Z1- ZO)-1} .
As Z1 -+ ZO, the element [a(x, Zt> .) - a(x, ZO, • )](Z1 - ZO)-1 converges in V to flex, ZO, .), where (3(x, ZO, z) is defined by flex, zo' z) = (z - zo)-'x for x in B, Zo in U" and Z in U1 • The difference quotient in question therefore converges to 'p«(:J(x, zo, as Z1 --"> Zo' It follows that r E W 2 • We have thus defined a linear mapping 'I' --"> 1'
.»
.»
78
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
385
limit, so that the inclusion map Y ~ W 2 is continuous. To prove V 2 c Y, consider 9 in V 2 and define the continuous linear functional 'P on V by 'p(f) == <1, g), where the inner product between V, and V 2 was defined above. Thus (P E V*, so that 1''1' E Y. Also,
1'",(x, zo) = rp(a(x, zo'
.» =
= _1_. \
~\ (z - zo)-'(x, g(z»dz 27r~
Jc
=',
<x, g(zo»
.
Thus I'", = g. It follows that V 2 c Y. We define the inner product between V and Y by <1, 1 ''I') = 'p(f), so that Y becomes isometrically isomorphic to V;. Since we have seen in the preceding paragraph that 'J!(f) = (f, g) for each 9 = l'.p in V" it follows that this inner product extends the inner product bet\'. een V and V,. It remains to show that the inclusion map V 2 --" Y is continuous, Let ~gn~ converge to 9 in V 2 • Define 'fJn in Vi' by 'fJn(f) = (t, gn) for all 1 in V, so that gn = l''''n by the above. To show that ~gn: converges to 9 in Y we must show that {'Pn} converges to 'jJ in V'. This follows from the joint continuity of the inner product between V and V 2 • This completes the proof of the lemma. We shall identify the space Y of Lemma 1 with V", so that Viwill be thought of as a subset of W 2 • Define the bounded linear mapping T of V into B by T 1 = lim =zl(z). Then the adjoint mapping ," of B* into V* is defined by taking ,"u to be that function of V, whose value at each point of U 2 is u, i.e., by setting (T'U)(Z) = u for all z in U 2 • This is seen by the following computation: H
'0')
Z
..
27r'L
=
oJ C
=~r <1(t), u)dt 2;:-t Je
.
The mapping T is onto, because nr(x, 2o, .) = x for all x III B and all in U" as a simple computation shows. In addition to the above objects, we now consider an operator T on B. We define the operator H on V by (Hf)(z) = (T - zI)l(z) + Tf for all z in U[. In order to obtain a formula for the adjoint operator H" on V*, consider an elementary element 1 = a(x, zo' .) of V and an element 9 of V*. We consider 9 as an element of W 2 • and let (1' be the element of V* which corresponds to g. Then <x, g(zo» = 'p(a(x, zo, = (p(f) , by the definition of g. Also, <1, g) = rp(f) when 9 is interpreted Zo
.»
79
386
ERRETT BISHOP
as the element T of V*. Thus
=
+X ZO)-' x + X
=
(T - zI)(z - ZO)-I X
= a(Tx, zo, z) - z(z -
Therefore Hf = a(Tx, zo, .) - zoa(x, zo, .). <x, (H*g)(zo»
=
=
=
= a(Tx, zo, z) - zo(z - ZO)-' x .
Thus
- zo<x, g(zo» = <x, (T-+ - zoI)g(zo»
.
Since this is true for all x in B, it follows that the adjoint operator is given by the formula (H*g)(zo) = (T* - zoI)g(zo) for all Zo in U2. Of the many possible norms for V x V, we consider only those norms obtained by defining
II (I,,!,) II
=
II (I" f,) II" =
(1) Ilf, 112
+ Ilf,II')'/2 ,
where r; is an arbitrary positive constant. Then the norm on V* x V* will be given by II(g" g,)11 = (~-Illg,II' + IIg,II')'/2. We define an operator K on V x V by K(I" f,) = (I" Hf, - f2)' A simple computation shows that K' = I and that K* is the operator on V* x V* defined by K*(g" g2) = (H*g, + g" -g,). Since K' = I it has an inverse and therefore the norm [ J on V x V defined by [fJ = II Kfll is equivalent to the norm II II. Similarly, the norm [ J on Vi' x V* defined by [gJ=IIK-+gll is equivalent to the norm II II. Also, for each 9 in V-+ x V* we have
[gJ
= IIK*g II = sup {I
g)l: IIfll = 1} g)l: IIK(Kf) II
Ilfll
= 1}
= 1} = sup {I
g)l:
[hJ
=
1]
Thus the norm [ J on V* x V* corresponds to the norm [ J on V x V. In the proof of Theorem 1 we shall need the following simple lemmas. They correspond to well-known results, but we sketch their proofs for the sake of completeness and in order to have them in exactly the form they are needed. LEMMA 2. Let A be a bounded linear transformation which maps a Banach space B, homeomorphically into a Banach space B,. Then the norm [ ] on Bi defined by [uJ = inf {II v II: v E B i, A -+v = u] corresponds to the norm [ ] on B, defined by [x] = II Ax II.
Proof. Consider u in Bi. By the Hahn-Banach theorem, there exists v in Bi such that <x, u) =
80
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
387
then
IIv,lI
~
sup {1
Thus
[u] = Ilvll = sup {I
~
1}
as was to be proved. LEMMA 3. Let A be a bounded linear transforrnation of a Banach space B2 onto a Banach space B,. Then the norrn on Bi defined by [u] = Ilkl-ull corresponds to the norrn on B, defined by [x] = inf {Ilyll: Ay = x}, and the norrns [ ] and II lion B, are equivalent.
It is easily seen that [ ] is a norm on B, and that II x II ~ Let [x,,} be a Cauchy sequence of elements in B relative to the norm []. We may assume, by passing to a subsequence if necessary, that [x n - xn+,l < 2- n. Thus we can inductively find Yn in B, with AYn = Xn and llYn - Yn+,11 < 2- n. Thus [Yn} converges to a vector Y in B,. Thus {xn} converges to x = Ay relative to the norm 1 on B Thus B, is complete under the norm []. By the closed graph theorem, it follows that the norms II II and [] on B, are equivalent. Also, if UE Bi then [u] = IIA-i'ull = sup U
Proof.
IIAII[x] for all x in B,. j
r
j •
THEOREM 1. Let T be an operator on a Banach space B. Let U, be an unbounded sirnple open set, and let V be the 1'estricted Banach space of analytic functions from U, to B. Let Yj be positive. For x in B define
{x} = [x}" = inf [("llfI1 2
+ IIHfll')!/2:
fE V, ;:f = x} .
For u in B* define
Then the function { } on B is a norrn which is equivalent to the norrn
II II and the function { } on B'" is the norrn on B* which corresponds to the norrn { } on B. Proof.
The map (u, g)
-->
(;:*u, g) of B"" x V* into V* x V* is the
81
ERRETT BISHOP
388
adjoint of the map (f" f2) ->- ('[ f" f') of V x V onto B x V. It follows from Lemma 3 that the norm on Bi- x V"- defined by [(u, g)] = [('["-u, g)] corresponds to the norm on B x V defined by [(x, f)] = inf ~[(fo, f)]: '[fa = x}, and that the norms [ ] and II lion B x V are equivalent. Now the map (u, g) ->- u of B* x V* onto B"- is the adjoint of the map x ->- (x, 0) of B into B x V. It follows from Lemma 2 that the norm defined on B* by [u] = inf {[(u, g)]: g E V"} corresponds to the norm defined on B by [x] = [(x, 0)], and that the norms [ ] and II II on B are equivalent. But [x]
=
inf {[(f, 0)]: '[f
=
x}
=
inf UIK(f, 0)11: '[ f
= inf {11(f, Hf)ll: '[I = x} = inf {(~IIII12 + IIHIII')'!2: '[I =
=
x}
x] = {x] .
Also, [u]
=
inf {[('[*u, g)]: g E V*}
=
inf {II K-1-(,[*u, g) II: g E V*}
inf {11(H*g + r-"-u, -g) II: g E V"} = inf UI (H*g - r-"u, g) II: g E V*} = inf {(~-'IIH"-g - r-"-uI1 2+ IlgI12)"2: gE V"-] = {u} . =
This proves Theorem 1. Of the two constituents, ~l '11111 and IIHIII, \vhich enter into the norm {xl = inf {(~IIIII' + IIHIII')'2: r- I=:c} on B, imprecisely speaking the second constituent
IIHIII = sup {II(T - zI)I(z) + x II: z E U
J}
measures the degree of approximation to which one can solve the resolvent equation (T - zI)I(z) = x on Up and the first 1}111II1 measures the size of the approximate solution. A similar comment can be made for the norm ~ ~ on B". Thus Theorem 1, which states that the norms correspond, establishes a relationship between approximate solutions to the resolvent equation for T on the set U and approximate solutions to the resolvent equation for T"- on the set U,. In view of the fact that the spectral manifolds were defined in terms of approximate solutions to the resolvent equation, it is not surprising that Theorem 1 should contain information pertinent to the duality theories defined above. Actually, the duality theory which we obtain as a consequence of Theorem 1 will be less precise than Theorem 1 itself. It therefore seems likely that a complete duality theory for an arbitrary operator will be based upon some version of Theorem 1 itself rather than upon the duality theory which we now proceed to derive from Theorem 1. It would have been possible to derive Theorem 1 in more generality by considering possibilities other than V for the Banach space of analytic functions from U l to J
82
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
389
B, but this was not necessary for the applications to be made. Let the subset N of B consist of all x such that for each c > 0 there exists f in V with IIHfl1 < c and 7:f = x. Let the subspace M of B* be the closure of the set Mo of all u in B" such that there exists g in V* with H"g = 7:"u. Then N is a subspace and M1. = N. COROLLARY.
We first show that N = [x: {xL --> 0 as r) --> 0]. If x EN f in V with 7:f = x and IIHfl1 < c. Thus {x}~ ~ (1J11fW + C')'/' --> C as IJ --> O. Since c is arbitrary it follows that {X}, --> 0 as 7J --> O. Conversely if {x}" --> 0 as ~'--> 0 then for each c > 0 there exists r; > 0 such that {xL < c, which implies that there exists f in V with Tf = x and (~IIJII' + IIHfll')" < c. Thus IIHfl1 < c, so that Proof.
for each c
> 0 there exists
xEN.
We next show that Mo = {u: {u; 1 is bounded for r; then there exists g in V* with H*g = 7:i-u. Therefore
> O}.
If u E Mo,
is bounded for r; > O. Conversely, assume now that {u}" < c for all positive ~'> Then for each positive integer n there exists gn in V" with (nIIH*gn - r*ull' + Ilgnll') < c'. Thus Ilgnll < c. Since the unit sphere of V" is compact in the weak star topology, there exists a cluster point g of {gn} in the weak star topology. Therefore H*g is a cluster point of {H*gn} in the weak star topology. Since IIH*gn - T*ull' ~ c'n- 1 , it follows that H*g = T*U. Therefore u E Mo. If xENand uEMo, then l<x,u)1 ~ {X}1{U},--> 0 as ~'-->O. Therefore Nand Mo are orthogonal. If x is not in N, then {X}1 does not converge to 0 as 7J --> 0, so that there exists a sequence {r;n) of positive constants converging to 0 and a constant c > 0 such that {xL > c for all n. It follows that there exists a sequence [un} of element; in B'" with {unL < 1 and <x, un) > c. We can thus find a sequence {gn} of elements i~ V* with
As before, there exists a cluster point (g, u) of the sequence Ugn, un)} in the weak star topology of V'" x B*. It follows, as before, that H*g = 7:"u. Thus u E Mo. Since also <x, u) ~ c, the vector x is not in MoL. Thus M if- = N. It follows that N is a subspace and that M 1. = N, as was to be proved. As an easy consequence of this corollary, we obtain the following fundamental theorem.
83
390
ERRETT BISHOP
THEOREM 2. Every operator T on a reflexive Banach space B admits a duality theory of type 4.
Proof. Let F, and F2 be disjoint compact sets. Then there exists an unbounded simple open set U" whose complementary simple open set will be called U., such that F,c U, and F,c U 2 • Define N as in the above corollary. To see that N(F" T)cN, take x in N(F" T) and take c: > O. Let Zo be any point in U2 and let inf {Iz - zol: ZE U,} = c > O. By the definition of N(F" T), there exists an analytic function f from -F, to B such that II(T - zl)f(z) - xll < c: for all z in -F" Since f is analytic on the neighborhood -F, of U, U C, Runge's theorem for vector-valued analytic functions (whose proof is exactly the same as the proof of Runge's theorem in the scalar case) implies that f can be uniformly approximated on U, U C by linear combinations of elementary elements of V,. Therefore f E V. Define f, in V by f, = - f + a(x
+ Tf, zo,
,) .
Then Tf, = -Tf + lim z(z - ZO)-'(X
+ Tf) =
X.
Also,
l1 = sup lIl(T - ZI)f,(Z) + Tf,ll: ZE U,} sup {II-(T - zI)f(z) + (z - zo)-'(T - zl)(x + T f) + T f,ll: sup {ll(T - zl)f(z) - x ll: Z E U1 } + sup {11(z - zo)-1(T - zI)(x + Tf)ll: c: + sup {1I(z - zo)-I(T - zl)(x + Tf)ll: ZE U,} .
IIHf,
= ~
~
E
U1 }
ZE
U,}
Z
Now
Ilx + rfll
= lim
II-[(T -
zI)f(z) - x] II ~ c: .
Thus lI(z - zo)-'(T - zl)(x
+ Tf)11
~ ~
11[(z - zo)-'(T - zol) - 1](x + Tf)11 [c-'II Tll + c-'Izol + 1]c: .
Thus
IIHf,l1
~
[c-'II Til + c-'Izol + 2]c: .
Since c: is arbitrary, x E N. Thus N(FH T)cN. We next show that M(F" T*)cM, where M is defined in the above corollary, It is sufficient to consider u in M(F" T*) such that there exists an analytic function g from -F2 to B* with (T* - zl)g(z) = u
84
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
391
for all z in -F" since the set of such u is dense in M(F" T*). Since g is analytic on the neighborhood - F2 of U 2 U C, g E V,c V*. By the definition of H* it follows that H*g = ,*u. Thus u E M, so that M(F" T*)cM. Since M 1- = N by the above corollary, it follows that
Since this holds for all operators T, we may replace T by T* and mterchange F, with F, to obtain
It remains to consider open sets G, and G2 which cover the complex plane. There exists an unbounded simple open set U, such that U,cG,U -a(T) and (J,cG" where U, is the bounded simple open set which is complementary to U,. Define V, M, and N as in the above corollary. We first show NcN(iJ" T). Consider x in N, so that for each c > 0 there exists f in V with ' f = x and IIHfl1 < c. This implies that
II(T - zI)f(z)
+ xII =
II(T - zI)(-f(z)) - xii
for all z in U,. Since -G,c U" it follows that x E N(G" T). We next show M c M(G" T). Consider u in M o, so that there exists g in V* with H'-g = ,'"u. Thus (T'- - zI)g(z) = u for all z in U,. If z E -a(T) let g(z) = (T* - zI)-'u. We thus obtain an analytic extension of g to U,U -a(T) which has the property that (T" - zI)g(z) = u for all z in U,U -a(T). Since -G, c U,U -a(T), it follows that u E M(G" T*). Thus MocM(G" T'-), and therefore McM(G" T*). Since M1- = Nand is reflexive, N 1- = M. Hence N(G" TV'- c M(G" T*). In this inclusion we may replace T by T'- and interchange G, and G, to obtain N(G" T'-)1-cM(G" T) or M(G" T)1-cN(G" T") .
This completes the proof of Theorem 2. We close this section by considering an example, which will show that M(F, T) N(F, T) in general and that not every operator admits a duality theory of type 1. Let {xn}:__ ~ be a complete orthonormal basis for a Hilbert space B, and let {an}:=-~ be a sequence of real numbers with 2- 1 < an < 2 and
'*
and lim inf
(a,a, . an)'!" = lim inf n-~
(a_la_, a_n)'i n = 2- 1 n_~
85
•
ERRETT BISHOP
392
Define the operator Ton B by T(Ea,x,) = Ea,a ,x , + 1. Then T", T-l, and (T ')-1 are operators of the same type as T. For each r with 2- 1 < r < 2 let Kr = {z: \z\ :;;; r} and Lr = {z: \z\ ~ r}. We shall show that M(KT' T) = M(LT' T) = to}, that N(K" T) = N(L" T) = B, and that corresponding equalities hold for Ti-. To show M(K" T) = {O}, let x be any vector in B such that there exists an analytic function f from -Kr to B with (T - z1)f(z) = x for all z in - K r • The Laurent expansion for f is therefore 00
fez) = -
E
z-n-1Tnx .
11,=0
Since this series con verges for Iz I > r we have lim
sUPn~=11
Tn x
wn :;;; r < 2 .
By the formula for T, this implies that x = O. Thus M(K" T) = [0;. Since T-l and T' are operators of the same type as T, we also have M(K" T-l) = M(Kn T*) = to}. Now consider x E M(L" T). Thus there exists f analytic for Iz I< r with values in B such that (T - z1)f(z) = x. Therefore
for Izl < r. Thus -zf(z) = g(Z-I) is an analytic function of Z-1 for Iz- 11 > r- 1 and (T-l - z-l1)g(Z-I) = T-I X • Therefore T-I X E M(Kr-t, T-l). By the above, this implies that T-I X = O. Therefore x = O. Therefore M(L" T) = {O}. Similarly, M(L" Ti-) = {O}. This already shows that T does not admit a duality theory of type 1, since by the above it is not true that
<s
M(K" T)l.cM(L" T*) if 2- 1
1 Then To show that N(K" T) = B, choose s N(K" T)~ cM(L" T"') = {OJ since T admits a duality theory of type 4. It follows that N(K" T) = B. The equality N(I-'n T) = B is proved similarly.
4.
The other duality theories.
DEFINITION 7. The operator T on the reflexive Banach space B is said to satisfy condition a if N(Fn T)cM(F" T) whenever Fl and F2 are closed and F, c interior F,. THEOREM 3. An operator T which satisfies condition a admits a duality theory of type 1. Proof. Assume that T satisfies condition a. joint compact sets. Then
86
Let Fl and F, be dis-
A DUALITy Tm:OREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
M(F" T)c N(F" T),
SO
~N(F"
that M(F" T)1-
393
T)1- ~M(F2> T*)
by Theorem 2. Consider now open sets G, and G, which cover the complex plane. Choose an open set G3 such that GJcG, and such that G2 and GJ cover the complex plane. Then N(G" T)cM(G" T) by condition a. Thus M(G" T)1- cN(G3 , T)1- C M(G 2 , T*) by Theorem 2. This completes the proof of Theorem 3. We now investigate conditions which are sufficient for T to admit duality theories of types 2 and 3. DEFINITION 8. The operator T on the reflexive Banach space B satisfies condition f:J if for every open set U and every sequence {In} of analytic functions from U to B such that (T - z1)ln(z) --+ 0 uniformly on U as n --+ = it follows that the sequence lin] is uniformly bounded on compact subsets of U. There are various reformulations of Definition 8. We shall need the following: T satisfies condition /'3 if and only if for every open set U and every sequence {Inl of analytic functions from U to B and every x in B such that (T - z1)ln(z) -> x uniformly on compact subsets of U as n --+ it follows that {In} is uniformly bounded on compact subsets of U. That this reformulation implies condition /3 is clear. To see that /'3 implies this reformulation, let {In} be a sequence of analytic functions from U to B such that (T - z1)ln(z) ---+ x uniformly on compact subsets of U, and let K be a compact subset of U. Then there exists a neighborhood U, of K such that (T - z1)ln(z) ----> x uniformly on U,. If Un} is not uniformly bounded on K, by passing to a subsequence if necessary we may assume that d n +, > n + d n for each n, where
=
d n = sup
~ll/n(z)
Thus the sequence {gn] defined by gn on K. On the other hand,
=
II:
Z
j~+ 1
E -
K} . In is not uniformly bounded
(T - z1)gn(z) = (T - z1)ln+,(z) -- (T - z1)ln(z)
converges uniformly to x - x = 0 on U,. This contradicts condition /3. Therefore {In} is uniformly bounded on K, as was to be proved. DEFINITION 9. The operator T on the reflexive Banach space B will be said to satisfy condition ~/ if for every open set U and every non-zero analytic f from U to B there exists z in U with (T - z1)f(z) O.
'*
THEOREM 4. If T satisfies condition /'3 and if F is an arbitrary closed subset of the complex plane, then (1) M(F, T) = N(F, T), (2) for
87
394
ERRETT BISHOP
each x ~n M(F, T) there exists an analytic function f from - F to B with (T - z1)f(z) = x for all z in -F, and (3) T satisfies conditions a and /. Proof. For each x in N(F, T) there exists a sequence {fn} of analytic functions from -F to B such that II (T - zI)fn(z) - x II < n -1 for all z in -F. By condition (3, {fn} is uniformly bounded on compact subsets of - F, so that there exists a subset, which we continue to call Un}, converging pointwise in the weak topology of B to an analytic function f from -F to B. Clearly (T - z1)f(z) = x for all z in -F. This proves assertions (1) and (2). If F, and F2 are closed and F, c interior F 2 , then N (F" T) = M(F" T)cM(F" T) by (1), so that T satisfies condition a. If T does not satisfy condition /, there exists an open set U and a non-zero analytic function f from U to B with (T - zI)f(z) = 0 for all z in U. Let fn = nf, so that (T - zI)fn(z) -'r 0 as n -'r = uniformly on U. Since T satisfies condition (:J, it follows that the sequence ~nf~ is pointwise bounded. This contradiction proves that T satisfies condition /'. The theorem just proved is related in part to results of Wermer [5]. As a corollary of this theorem, T admits a duality theory of type 1 if T satisfies condition /:J. THEOREM 5. If T+ sat'isfies condition (J, then T admits a duality theory of type 2. If T and T* satisfy condition (3, then T admits a duality theory of type 3.
Proof. Assume that T' satisfies condition {J. Then T", and therefore T, admits a duality theory of type 1. Also, T*- satisfies condition /'. Let G,,···, Gn be open sets covering the complex plane. If M(G" T), . ", M(G a , T) do not span B, there exists u * 0 in B' orthogonal to these subspaces. Since G,,···, Gn cover the complex plane, n7~1 -G, is void. There therefore exist open sets U,,"', Un such that -G,c U, and nr~1 U, is void. Since U, and G, cover the complex plane and since T admits a duality theory of type 1, we see that M((J., T)~ c M( U" T ') .
Thus u € M( Ui , T') for each i. Since T" satisfies condition fJ it follows from Theorem 4 that there exist an analytic function g, from - U, to B* with (T* - z1)g,(z) = u for all z in - U,. If z E - [i, n - U), we have (T* - zI)(g,(z)-g;(z» = O. Since g,-gj is analytic on -uin -(fj and since T* satisfies condition /, it follows that g,(z) = g,(z) for z in - U, n - (fj. Thus if we define the function 9 by g(z) = g,(z) for z in - U" then 9 is uniquely defined and is analytic on U~-l - (f,. Also
88
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
~95
(T" - zI)g(z) = u whenever 9 is defined. But the sets -l1; cover the plane because n~~l Ui is void. Also g(z) = (T' - zI)-J u -40 as Iz 1---> co. Thus 9 is everywhere analytic and vanishes at infinity, so that 9 = O. Thus u = (T > -- zI)g(z) = O. This contradiction implies that M(G]> T), "', M(G,,, T) span B. Therefore T admits a duality theory of type 2. Assume now that T also satisfies condition /3. We must show that T admits a duality theory of type 3. First consider a bounded open set H such that -H is connected. By Theorem 4 for each x in M=M(H, 1') there exists an analytic function f(x, .) from U =- -H to B such that (T - zI)f(x, z) = x for all z in U. Since l' satisfies condition /-], and therefore condition OJ, the function f(x, .) is unique. For each z" in U define the linear transformation T 0 and II Tzuxn II -4 co as n ---> CD. Since T satisfies condition ;3, it follows that U(x n, zo)} = [T'uxn} is bounded. This contradiction implies that Tzu is a bounded transformation for each Zo in U. If z in U is sufficiently large and if x E M, T,x = (T - zI)-lx EM. Since T,x is an analytic function on U and since U is connected, it follows that T,x EM for all x in M and all z in U. Thus for each z in U the operator T, on M is a right inverse of (T - zI)/A1. To show that T z is the inverse of (T - zI)/M it is sufficient to establish that x = 0 whenever x EM and (T-zI)x = O. To this end, consider x in M with (T-zI)x == O. Define the analytic function h from U to B by h(A) = x + (,\ - z)T"x. Then (T - AI)h(A) = (1' - zI)x
=
0
+ (z
+ (z
- A,)X
- A)X
+ (,\, -
+ (A z)x
=
- z)(T - AI)T"x
0 .
Since T satisfies condition (3, and therefore condition "j, this implies h = O. Thus x = h(z) = O. Therefore (T - zI)/M has an inverse for all z in U, so that (J(T/M(R, T»cH. Now let a covering G]O "', G n of the complex plane by open sets be given. There exists a family [H ik ] , 1 ;;;; i ;:;:: n, 1 ;:;:: k ;:;:: mil of open sets which cover the complex plane such that HikcG i and either Hi" is bounded and -Ri" is connected or Hikc -(J(T). From the preceding paragraphs we see that the M(H'k' T) span B and that (J(T / M(R" , T»cRik
if Hi" is bounded and -Hik is connected. Also a(T/M(H,,,, T»cH", if Rikc -(J(T) because M(Rit> T) consists only of the zero vector in this case. If this were not true, there would exist x -cf' 0 in M(R" , 1') and
89
396
ERRETT
BISHOP
-it.
an analytic function f from to B such that (T - zI)f(z) = x. If we extended the definition of f to -aCT) by defining fez) = (T - zI)-'x for z in -aCT), then f becomes an analytic function defined everywhere and vanishing at infinity. Thus f = O. Therefore x = (T - zI)f = O. Hence a(T/M(ii,., T»cii'k for all i and k. Define M! to be the subspace spanned by the sets M(H'H T), "', M (H""" T). Since -
-
M(Hie , T)cM(G" T) for each k, we have M,cM(G" T). Also M" "', Mn span B. To complete the proof of the theorem we must show that a(T/M,)cG,. As before, with the set H replaced by G" for each x in M,cM(G" T) there exists a unique analytic function f(x, .) from -Gi to B such that (T - zI)f(x, z) = x for all z in -Gi . As before, for each z in -G! define the linear transformation T z from Mi to B by Tzx = f(x, z). As before, T z is a bounded linear transformation for each z in -G t • If the set H,. is bounded and -iii. is connected, we see as before that the spaces M(iiild T) are invariant under T, for each z in -iiik~ -G,. Since otherwise H,. has the property that M(lt, , T) consists only of the vector 0, and since the M(iiik' T) span M, it follows that M, is invariant under Tz for all z in -G,. Thus the operator T z on M, is a right inverse of (T - zI)/ Mi' As before, it follows that T z is the inverse of (T - zI)/M, for each z in -G,. Thus a(T/M,)cGi , as was to be proved. As an immediate consequence of the preceding theorems, it follows that T and T* both admit duality theories of types 1, 2, 3, and 4 whenever T and T* both satisfy condition /3. DEFINITION 10. Let r be a function from the complex plane to the set [0, (;0]. The function r will be said to be a modulus of control for analytic functions if for every open set U and every sequence {fn} of complex-valued analytic functions on U such that Ifn(z) I ~ r(z) for all z in U the sequence {fn} is uniformly bounded on all compact subsets of U. THEOREM 6. Let T be an operator on a reflexive Banach space B. Let the function r defined by r(z) = II(T - zIt'l1 if Ze -aCT) and r(z) = (;0 if Z e aCT) be a modulus of control for analytic functions. Then both T and T'" satisfy condition /3 and therefore admit duality theories of types 1, 2, 3, and 4.
Proof. Since II(T - zIt'l1 = II(T* - zI)-'11 whenever Ze -aCT), it is sufficient to show that T satisfies condition /3. To do this, let U be open and let {fn} be a sequence of analytic functions from U to B such
90
A DUALITY THEOREM FOR AN ARBITRARY OPERATOR
397
that (T - zI)fn(z) -+ 0 uniformly on U as n -+ oo. It is then possible to choose a constant K such that Ilfn(z) II ;<::; KII(T - zI)-' II for all nand all z in U. Assume that there exists a compact subset C of U on which {fn} is not uniformly bounded. By the uniform boundedness theorem [3J, it is possible to choose u in B* such that the sequence {gn} of complex-valued analytic function on U defined by .9a(z) =
110g+ log+ sup {II(T - zIt'lI: I(z)
=
y}dy
is finite, then T admits duality theories of types 1, 2, 3, and 4.
Proof. By Wolf [6], the function r defined by r(z) = II(T- zI)-11l is a modulus of control for analytic functions, so that the result follows from Theorem 6. It follows that a Hermitian operator, for instance, admits duality theories of types 1, 2, 3, and 4. From this fact it is not difficult to derive the spectral theorem. REFERENCES 1. E Bishop, Spectral theory for operators on a Banach Space, Trans Amer Math Soc, 86 (1957), 414-445 2 N Dunford, Spectral operators, Pacific J Math, 4 (1954), 321-354 3. E Hille, Functional analysis and semi groups, Amer Math Soc Colloquium Publica tions, 31 (1948) 4 E. R Lorch, The integral representational of weakly almost periodic transformations in reflexive vector spaces, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc, 49 (1941), 18-40. 5 J Wermer, The existence of invariant subspaces, Duke Math J, 19 (1952), 615-622 6. F. Wolf, On majorants of subharmonic and analytic functions, Bull. Amer Math Soc, 48 (1942), 925-932. 7 - - - , Operators in a Banach space which admit a generalized spectral decom positirYn, Nederl Akad. Wetensch Indag. Math, 19 (1957), 302-311. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY
91
A MINIMAL BOUNDARY FOR FUNCTION ALGEBRAS ERRETT BISHOP
An algebra ~{ of continuous functions on a compact Hausdorff space C will be understood to be a set of complex-valued functions on C which is closed under the operations of addition, multiplication, and multiplication by complex numbers. The algebra ~{ is called separating if to any two distinct points of C there exists a function in ~{ which takes distinct values at the given points. The norm IIIII of a continuous function I on a compact space is defined to be the maximum absolute value of the function. The algebra 2l is thus a normed algebra. ~{ is called a Banach algebra if it is complete with respect to its norm, i.e., if the limit of every uniformly convergent sequence of elements of ~{ is in ~l. An important theorem of Silov (see [5], p. 80) asserts that if ~{ is a separating algebra of continuous functions on a compact Hausdorff space C then there is a smallest closed subset S of C having the property that every function of ~{ attains its maximum absolute value at some point of S. This set is called the Silov boundary of 91. A simple example is obtained by taking C to be a compact subset of the complex plane and ~{ to be the set of all continuous functions on C which are analytic at interior points; in this case the Silov boundary of ~{ coincides with the topological boundary of C. Given a separating normed algebra ~l of continuous functions on a compact space C, it seems natural to ask, in view of Silov's theorem, whether there exists a smallest subset M (not necessarily closed) of C having the property that every function in ~{ attains its maximum absolute value at some point of M. The answer in general is no. However, it will be shown (Theorem 1 below) that such a set M, called the minimal boundary of ~{, always exists if in addition it is assumed that ~{ is a Banach algebra and that there is a countable basis for the open sets of C, i.e., that C is metrizable. An example will be given to show that the metrizability of C is necessary. If the minimal boundary M exists, it is clear that the closure of M is the Silov boundary. An example will be given to show that M need not be closed, so that M in general is smaller than the Silov boundary. This raises the question of the topological structure of M, which is answered (Theorem 2) by showing that M is a G s, i.e., a countable intersection of open sets. 1.
Introduction.
Received December 1, 1958, in revised form February 23, 1959 Sloan Foundation Fellowship
629
92
The author holds a
630
ERRETT BISHOP
The next portion of the paper concerns the representation of bounded linear functionals on 21 by measures. It is an easy consequence of the classical Hahn-Banach theorem and the Riesz representation theorem that any bounded linear functional 'P on 21 of norm 1 can be represented by a (complex-valued, Borel) measure p of norm 1 on the Silov boundary S of
~(, in the sense that
'P(f)
= ~/dll for all f in ilL
It is natural
to conjecture that p can actually be taken to be a measure on the minimal boundary M of A. The author will devote a subsequent paper to a proof of this result and a consideration of related questions. Karl de Leeuw also has a proof of this result, based on work of Choquet [3]. In the present paper we prove a special case, which is needed to prove the general result and which will be sufficient for the applications considered here. This special case, Theorem 3 below, states that for any point x in C - M there exists a non-negative valued measure /1 of norm 1 on C - {x} such that f(x) =
~fdP for all f in ,)L
The final section is concerned with problems of approximation in one complex variable. Necessary and sufficient conditions are obtained on a compact set C without interior of the complex plane that every continuous function on C be uniformly approximable by rational functions whose poles lie in the complement of C. Mergelyan [6] has obtained sufficient conditions, of a different type, that the approximation be possible. A summary of the results of this paper was given in [1]. 2.
The minimal boundary.
1. Let f be a continuous function on a compact space Then S(f), the maximal set of f, consists of all points x in C such that If (x) I = llill. DEFINITION
C.
DEFINITION 2. Let ~l be a separating algebra of continuous function on a compact space C. A subset N of C is said to bound ':I( if N n S(f) is non-void for all f in ilL If the class of subsets of C which bound Il( contains a smallest set M, the set M will be called the minimal boundary of 21. THEOREM 1. Let ill be a separating Banach algebra of continuous functions on a compact metrizable Hausdorff space C. Then ')( has a minimal boundary M and M equals the subset Mo of C consisting of all x in C such that there exists f in ~( with S(f) = {x}
Proof.
Let N be an arbitrary subset of C which bounds 21.
93
For
A MINIMAL BOUNDARY FOR FUNCTION ALGEBRAS
631
each x in M o, there exists f in ~{ with S (f) = {x}. Thus {x} n N = S(f) n N is non-void. Hence x EN. Therefore MocN. To show that Mo is indeed the minimal boundary of ~, it remains to prove that Mo bounds~. It must therefore be shown that Mo n S(f) is non-void for each I in ~. Let f be given. Let I' be the class of all subsets "'I of G such that there exists Iy in ~r with S(fr) ="'1. By Zorn's lemma, there is a subclass 1'0 of I' which contains S(f), which has the finite intersection property, and which has the property that no larger subclass of r has the finite intersection property. Since G is ro"'l is non-void compact and since each cy in 1'0 is closed, the set D = and closed. Since there is a countable basis for the open sets of G, and since the family {G - cy: "'I E ro} of open sets covers G - D, there exists a sequence {"'In} from 1'0 such that {G - CYn} covers G - D, i.e., such that D = n"'ln. Fix a point Xo of D. Define
n
In = [fyn(xo)]-I/Y n
•
Clearly S(fn) = "'In and Illn II = In(xo) = 1. Thus the series ~n~~l 2- n l n converges uniformly on G to a function g in ~r with Ilg II = g(xo) = 1. If x E G - "'I" then Ig(x) I ~ ~ 2- n lfn(x) 1< 1 since Iln(x) I ~ 1 for all n and Ilk(x) I < 1. Therefore S(g)C"'l". Thus S(g)Cn"'lk = D. Assume that S(g) contains more than one point. Since ~{ separates points, there exists ho in ~ which is not constant on S(g). We may assume that the maximum of Ihol on S(g) is 1 and that ho takes the value 1 at some point of S(g). If we set h = ho + h~, it follows that the maximum of Ih I on S(g) is 2 and that this maximum is attained only where ho takes the value 1. Thus Ihl is not constant on S(g). Therefore the set E = {x: x E S(g) and Ih(x) I ;;c: Ih(y) I for all y in S(g)}
is a proper closed subset of S(g). Let x, be any point in E. Define the functions
and ho = fh(X1)]-lh .
Thus ligo II = go(x 1) = 1 and S(go) = S(g). Also ho(x 1) = 1, Iho(X) I ~ 1 if x E S(g), and IhoCx) I < 1 if x E S(g) - E. Let K = Ilho II. For each positive integer n, let Vn = {x: 1
+ 2- n(K -
1) ~ IhoCx) I ~ 1
+ 2- n+ (K 1
In .
Clearly UVn= {x: Iho(x)I>I}. Thus VnnS(g) = VnnS(go) is void for each n. Therefore IOo(x) 1< 1 for each x in V n • Since Vn is compact, it follows that there exists a positive integer Pn such that IOo(x)jPn :;;:; 1/2
94
632
ERRETT BISHOP
for all x in V n •
Since Ilgoll ;:;; 1, the series ho
+ 4(K -
1)2: 2- n g0'" T!=1
converges uniformly on G to a function k in k(x l )
=
1
+
4(K - 1)2: 2- n
=
1
~l.
+
We have
4(K - 1) .
n=l
If x E S(g) - E, then Iho(x) 1< 1 and Igo(x) I = 1, so that Ik(x) 1< H- 4(K -1). If xEG - UV", then IhoCx) I ;:;; 1 and Igo(x) I ;;::: 1, so Ik(x)l;:;; 1 + 4(K-1). If XE Vj' then Iho(x)l;:;; 1 + 2- 1 + I (K -1), Iglr)I"n;:;; 1 for all n, and Igo(x) IP j ;:;; 1(2, so that Ik(x) I;:;; 1 + 4(K - 1). Therefore k(x,) = 1 + 4(K - 1) = Ilkll. Thus Xl E S(k) and S(k) is disjoint from S(g)-E. Since Xl E S(g)cD= nro'Y, and since S(k) E 1', it follows from the maximality of 1'" with respect to the finite intersection property that S(k) E 1'0. Therefore S(g)cnr,,'/cS(k). Since S(g) - E is non-void, this contradicts the fact that S(g) - E is disjoint from S(k). Therefore the assumption that S(g) contains more than one point is false. Thus S(g) consists of a single point Xo. It follows that XoE Mo. Since S(g)cD = nro'YcS(f), it follows that Xu E S(f) n Mo. Thus S(f) n Mo is non-void, as was to be proved. We now give an example to show that Theorem 1 fails if G is not metrizable. Let I denote the unit interval [0, 1] with the usual topology. Let I' be an uncountable set. Let G consist of all families X = [X",}aE., with x", E I for each (l'. Thus G is the Cartesian product of an uncountable number of intervals, and is therefore compact. Let ~( consist of all continuous functions f on G which have the property that there exists / a countable subset J of l' such that f(x) = fCy) whenever x and y an:; points in G such that Xx = y" for all ()' in J. It is easy to see that ~( is a separating Banach algebra of continuous functions on G. By the Stone-Weierstrass theorem it follows that ~l consists of all continuous functions on G. Let Nl = {x: x" = 0 except for a countable set of a] and N2 = {x: x", = 1 except for a countable set of a}. It is easy to see that Nl and N2 bound \lL Since Nl n N, is void, it follows that ~( does not have a minimal boundary. For an example of a function algebra whose minimal boundary is distinct from its Silov boundary, let G be the subset {z: \z\ = I; of the complex plane and let ~( consist of all continuous functions f on G which have the property that there exists a continuous function j on [z: \ z \ ;;::: 1] such that fez) =f(z) for z in G, such that j is analytic on {z: Iz\ < I}, and such that j(l) = j(0). It is easy to see that ~l is a separating Banach algebra of continuous functions on G. It is also not difficult to show that the Silov boundary of ~ is G, whereas the minimal boundary
95
633
A MINIMAL BOUNDARY FOR FUNCTION ALGEERAS
of 91 is the set {z:
Izl = 1,z *- 1} = C- {1}.
THEOREM 2. Let 'ill be a separating Banach algebra of continuous functions on a compact metrizable Hausdorff space C. For each positive integer n, let Un consist of all points x in C such that there exists f in ~l with Ilfll ;;;;; 1, If(x) I > 3/4, and If(y) I < 1/4 for all y in Dn(x), where Dn(x) = {y: p(x, y) ;:::: n- ' } and fJ is a metric on C. Then Un is open and Un = M, where M is the minimal boundary of ~l.
n
Proof. If f is any function in 'ill, it is clear that the set a n(f) = {x: x e C, If(x) I > 3/4, If(y) I < 1/4 whenever ye D,,(x)} is open for each n. Since Un is the union of the sets belonging to the class {an(f):f e ~l,
Ilfll;;;;; I} ,
it follows that Un is open. If x e M, by Theorem 1 there exists f in ~( with S (f) = {x}. It is clearly no restriction to assume that Ilfll = 1. Hence If(x) I = 1. Since If(y) I < 1 when y is in the compact set Dn(x), it follows that there exists a positive integer Pn such that If(y) IP n < 1/4 when ye D,,(x). Thus x e (In(fPn). Therefore x e Un. Since this is true for each n, it follows that x e Un. Therefore Men Un. Now consider a fixed x in Un. We must prove that x eM. To this end, we construct by induction a sequence {gn} of functions in ~( having the following properties:
n
(i)
(ii) (iii) (iv)
n
IIgn+! - gnll ;;;;; 2- n + IIgnll;;;;; 3(1 - 2- n -
1
1)
gn(x) = 3(1 - 2- n ) Ign+l(y) - gn(y) I < 2- n - 1 if ye Dn(x) .
We first construct g,. Since x e U" there exists a function that Ilfll ;;;;; 1 and x e (J,(f). Let gl
f in
~{
such
= ~ [f(x)]-lf .
Since If(x) I > 3/4, we have IlgIII;;;;; 3/2 . 4/3 = 2 < 3(1 - 2- 2 ), so that g, satisfies (ii). Clearly g,(X) = 3(1 - 2- ' ), so that gt satisfies (iii). Hence g, satisfies all of the relevant conditions. Assume now that g" "', gk have been chosen to satisfy all of the relevant conditions. Since gk(X) = 3(1-2- k ), there exists an integer }>k such that Igk(y)I<3(1-2- k)+2- k- 2 for p(x, y) < }-" i.e., for y in C - D;(x). Since x e U j , there exists a function f in 'iJ{ such that Ilfll;;;;; 1 and x e a;(!). Define h = 3· 2- k - 1[f(x)]-lf. Thus hex) = 3 . 2- k - \ Since IIfll ;;;;; 1 and If(x) I > 3/4, we see that IIh II ;;;;; 2- k + l . Since also If(y) I < 1/4 for y in Dj(x), we see
96
ERRETT BISHOP
634
that Ih(y)1 < 2-~-1 for y in Dlx). mediately that
Let gUI
=
gk
+ h.
It
+3.
2- k -
follows Im-
that
and that (iii) If y
E
gUl(X)
+ hex) =
=
gk(X)
=
3(1 - 2- k -
1)
3(1 -- 2-<)
Dix), then
Igu/Y) I ;;:; IOk(Y) 1+ Ih(y) I < Ilg, \I + 2- k - 1 ;;:; 3(1 - 2-<-1) = 3 - 2- k < 3(1 - 2-<-') . If y
E
1
•
+ 2-
k - 1
C - Dix), then
Igk+l(y) I ;;:; Igk(y) I + Ih(y)1 ;;:; 3(1 - 2- k ) + 2-<-2 + Ilhl\ ;;:; 3(1 - 2- k ) + 2-!A + 2-<+1 = 3(1 - 2-~-2) . It follows that
Thus gk+l has the relevant properties. We have thus constructed the sequence {gn}. By condition (i), the sequence {gn} converges uniformly / on C to a function 9 in 1)(. By (ii), Ilg II ;;:; 3. By (iii), g(x) = 3. II' y E Da(x), then Ig(y) I ;;:; Ilgn II
=
+ 2..: Igk+l(y)
- gk(y) 1< 3(1 - 2- n - 1)
k=n
Thus S(g)
=
{x}.
Therefore
=
+ L. 2-"-1 <
3 .
k=n
XE
M, as was to be proved.
COROLLARY. If I){ is a separating Banach algebra of continuous functions on a compact metrizable Hausdorjf' space C, then the minimal boundary M of ~1 is a countable intersection of open sets.
3.
Representation by measures.
We now prove the fundamental result of this paper. THEOREM 3. Let 1)1 be a separating Banach algebra of continuous functions on a compact metrizable Hausdorff space C. Let I){ contain the function 1. Let x be a point of C - M, where M is the minimal
97
635
A MINIMAL BOUNDARY FOR FUNCTION ALGEBRAS
boundary of ';If.
Then there exists a non-negative Borel measure
norm 1 on C - {X) such that f(x)
= ~fd'Y
=
{y: y
E
of
for all f in ';/1.
Proof. We assume that a metric p on C is given. tive integer n, let Dn
'Y
C, p(x, y) ::;; n- I }
For each posi-
•
Let band c be real numbers such that 0 < b < 1/4 < 3/4 < e < 1. For each positive integer n and each positive integer m, let hr.m be a continuous function on C such that hn"Jy) = bUm for y ED", hnm(y) = e'lm for y € C - D'n, and bl / m ~ hnm(y) ~ e'lm for all y. Such a function exists because the closures of the sets Dn and C - D'n are disjoint. There are two cases to consider. Either there exists (Case 1) for each positive integer n a positive integer m and a function f in ';It such that If(x) I > (3/4)'/m and If(Y) I ~ hnmCY) for all y in C, or (Case 2) there exists a positive integer n such that for all positive integers m and for all f in ';It either If(x) I ~ (3/4)1/'" or If(Y) I > hnm(y) for some y in C. We shall show that Case 1 is impossible and that Case 2 implies the theorem to be proved. Assume now that Case 1 obtains. Let the positive integer n be given, and choose fin ';!l and a positive integer m such that If(x) I >(3/4)I/m and If(y) I ~ hnm(y) for all y. Write g =fm. Since If(y) I ~ hnm(y) ~ e' /m for all y, we have Ig(y)1 ~ e for all y . .Thus Iigll ~ e < 1. Since If(x)1 > (3/4)I/m we have Ig(x) I > 3/4. Since IfCy) I ~ hnm(y) = bl / m for y in D n, we have Ig(y) I ~ b < 1/4 for y in Dn. It follows that x E Un, where Un is the set defined Un = M, in Theorem 2. Since this is true for each n, we have x by Theorem 2. This contradicts the hypothesis of Theorem 3. Therefore Case 1 is impossible. We are therefore justified in assuming that Case 2 obtains. Thus there exists a positive integer n, henceforth fixed, such that for all positive integers m and allf in ~l either If(x) I ~ (3/4)I/m or I fey) I>hmn(y) for some y in C. Consider now a positive integer m. For each f in ';!( either If(x) I ~ (3/4)I/m or Ilfh- 1 11 > 1, where h = h nm . Thus If(x) I ~ (3/4)I/1n whenever f E ';II and Ilfh- 1 11 ~ 1. Let)S be the Banach space of all continuous functions on C, under the uniform norm, and let ~\ be the subspace Uh- I : f e ~{} of 5B. Define the linear functional cp on l.L~o by defining
en
98
636
ERRETT BISHOP
for all f in
~L
If we define the measure
=
/I",(S)
flm
by
Lh-ldJ)m
for all Borel subsets S of C, it follows that f(x) =
kdllm
for all f
in
~L In particular, 1 = Jdflm. Thus II/1m 11:;0; 1. Let the measure J):n, the restriction of J)", to the set Dw be defined by J)~,,(S) = J)m(S n D for each Borel set S. Let l.I~", the restriction of l.I mto C - D,,,, be defined 2n )
similarly.
Thus
II J)~n II +
IIl.I~"
II
=
II J) m II;::; (43)1/'" .
Similarly, let f/;" be the restriction of II,,, to D 2n , and let fl:" be the restriction of 11m to C - D2n • Thus Ilfl~11
+ 11f!~11 = IIp,,,II:;o;
1 .
Since [h(y)]-l = e- 1 / m for all y in C - D'n and since p:,.(S) =
L-n
h-ldJ)m, 2'1
for all Borel sets S, we see that /1;, = e-l/mJ)~" so that el/"'II P:" II = Ill.I:" II. Since Ih(y) 1-1;::; b- 1 / m for all y, and therefore for all y in D"" we see similarly that bl/mll,u~n II ;::; Ill.I~n II. Thus
Combined with the inequality
this gives
Thus
Since IIPml1 = Ilp~11
+ 11p~ll;::; b-l/mllJ)~,,11 + b-l/mlll.l:" II ;::; b-
1/ m
ll J)m II ;::; b-
1/
m ,
there exists a subsequence {Pm) of {Pm} which converges in the weak star topology for measures ou C to a measure ,u on C with 11/111 ;::; 1. Also,
99
637
A MINIMAL BOUNDARY FOR FUNCTION ALGEBRAS
for each f in ~. Since C - D 2n is open and since
for each m, we have
where p' is the restriction of p to C - D,n.
! rl/!~ ! )(! r !-
ll~ [(
bl')c l' - bh]-I
[(In
=
Now
= [In
(lnb)b h ][(lnc)c h
(lnb)bh]-I
-
lnb JElnc - lnb]-I = In(! b-I)[ln(cb-I)]-I
<1.
Thus, if p2 denotes the restriction of p to the set {x}, we have II p2J1 ~ II p'Jl < 1. Thus there exists a constant a with 1a 1< 1 such that 1fdp2 = af(x) for all t!ontinuous functions f on C.
tion of It to C - {x}, so that p2 Thus 1fd P = 1fd P2
for all f in
+
+ p3 =
k P3 d
~1. Therefore (1 - a)f(x)
IIp3J1~1-lIp211=1-lal,
111dPai ~ IIPaJl
~ 1-
Let p3 be the restric-
P and IIfl211
= af(x)
+ IIp 11 =11/111 ~ 1. 3
+ 1fdPa
= 1fdP3 for all f
in~.
Since
and since 1€~, we have 1-lal~11-al=
lal. Thus a is positive.
Define 7 = (1 - a)-'p3.
Thus f(x) = (1 - a)-'1fdP3 = 1fd7
for all f in~. 1 = 1d7.
Also, 117 II ~ (1 - a)-'lIp311 ~ 1.
Since 1 € ~{ we have
Therefore 7 is a non-negative valued measure.
This completes
the proof of the theorem. COROLLARY.
Let
~
be a separating Banach algebra containing the
100
638
~KKt;Tl
HI::'HUY
unit function of continuous functions on the compact metrizable Hausdorff space C. Let ~o consist of all functions on C which are real parts of functions in ~, and let ~ be the uniform closure of mo. Let Mo consist of all points x in C such that there exists f in ~H with If(x) I > If(Y) I for all y *- x in C. Then Mo equals the minimal boundary M of~. Proof. If x eM, there exists g in C such that Ig(x) I > Ig(y) I for all y *- x in C. It is no loss of generality to assume that g(x) = 1. If we let f be the real part of g, then f e lnoC~ and If(x)l = Ig(x)l > Ig(y) I ~ If(Y) I for all y *- x. Hence x e Mo. If x is not in M, then there exists a real-valued measure ry on M - {x} of norm 1 such that g(x) = ~gdry for all g in ~, by Theorem
3.
Since ry is real-valued, it follows that f(x) =
Thus f(x) =
~fd'Y for all f in
f in lH with 1
11 f d'Y 1< 1,
= f(x) >
m.
mo.
If x where in Mo, there would exist
If(y) I for all y
since If(y) I < 1 for y
~fdry for all f in
*- x.
Thus 1
*- x and since II?, II
= f(l) = ~fd'Y ~
= 1.
This contra-
diction shows that x is not Mo. Hence M = Mo, as was to be proved. DeLeeuw has found a proof of Theorem 3 which is somewhat simpler than the one given here. 4. Applications. We now apply the results of the previous sections to certain problems of approximation in one complex variable. DEFINITION 3. Let C be a compact subset of the complex plane. Then Ao(C) will consist of all continuous functions on C which are analytic at interior points of C, and A/C) will consist of all continuous functions on C which can be uniformly approximated arbitrarily closely by rational functions whose poles lie in the complement of C. It is clear that A l (C)c A 0(C), and that A 0(C) and A1(C) are separating Banach algebras of continuous functions on C. Mergelyan [2] has shown that A o(C) = A 1(C) in case the complement of C consists of only a finite number of components. No necessary and sufficient condition is known that A1(C) = A0(C). In case C has no interior, we shall obtain in Theorem 5 below a necessary and sufficient condition that every continuous function on C be uniformly approximable by rational functions with poles in - C. THEOREM 4. Let C be a compact subset of the complex plane with no interior and let M be the minimal boundary of A 1(C). Then either
101
A MINIMAL BOUNDARY FOR FUNCTION ALGEBRAS
A,cC)
= Au(C)
639
or C - M has positive 2-dimensional Lebesgue measure.
Proof. Assume that A,(C) *- Ao(C). We must show that C - M has positive 2-dimensional Lebesgue measure. Now A (C) is the Banach space of all continuous complex-valued functions on C, and A,(C) is a proper subspace, since A,(C) *- Ao(C). By the Hahn-Banach theorem, there exists a continuous linear functional 'P *- 0 on A (C) which vanishes " exists a finite on A1(C). By the Riesz representation theorem, there complex-valued Borel measure II on C which represents 'p. Thus It *- 0
and
~fdfL = 0 for all
f
in A,(C).
In particular,
~(Z
-1;)-'d,IL(t)
=0
whenever z is not in C, since the function (z - 1;)-' is a rational function of I; whose pole, z, is not in C. Since the function Z-I of z is integrable with respect to Lebesgue measure dxdy over any finite region of the plane, and since It is a finite measure on the compact set C, the integral
will exist for almost all values of z, and the function h(z) so defined, called the convolution of the measure p and the function Z-' and written h = z-I,,-p., will be integrable with respect to Lebesgue measure over any finite region of the plane. Since we have seen' above that h(z) = 0 if z is not in C, it f9llowS that h is integrable. Assume that the integrable function h vanishes almost everywhere, so that the integral h(z) = all z. tion
1
(z - I;)-'dp(t;) exists and vanishes for almost
To obtain a contradiction from this assumption, we use the equa-
aa. l. z z
=
no
([7] p. 49) from the theory of distributions. This means
that for any function g on the complex plane which vanishes in a neighborhood of co and which has continuous partial derivatives of all orders we have
- i r(z JJ
for all values of 1;.
-
t)-ll.(~ + i ~)g(z)dxdy 2
ax
ay
If we write gl(Z) =
~
(a:
= 7rg(t;)
+ i :y )g(Z) and integrate
both sides of the above equation with respect to p we obtain
HH (z - t;)-lgl(Z)dxdY}dp(t;) = - Hg,(Z)U (z - t;)-ldp.(t;) }dxdy = 0 ,
7r)g(t;)dP.(t) = -
102
ERRETT BISHOP
640
since h(z) vanishes almost everywhere. The use of Fubini's theorem is justified since z - t, and therefore (z - t)-', is measurable with respect to the product of the measures g,(z)dxdy and dp(O and since
is finite.
Now every continuous function go on C can be uniformly ap-
proximated by such functions
g,
that~go(t)d/l(O
so
=
O.
By the unique-
ness part of the Riesz representation theorem, it follows that II = O. This contradiction shows that there exists a set r of C of positive Lebesgue measure such that the integral h(z) exists and does not vanish for all z in r. We may clearly assume that at no point of r does /1 have point mass. Let Zo be any point in r, so that h(zo) = c exists and is not zero. Let f be any function in A,(C) such that f(zo) = O. Let Un} be a sequence of rational functions with poles in the complement of C converging uniformly to f on C. Since fn(zo) ~ f(zo) = 0 as n ~ oa, we see that {g",} converges uniformly to f on C, where Yn = fn - fn(z,,). Thus gn is a rational function with poles in - C which vanishes at zo, so that there exists a rational function g~ with poles in -C such that gn(z) = g~(z)(z - zo) for all z. Hence I
,!
for each n, since V;, E
AI(C).
Passing to the limit, we see that
~ f(z)(z
- zo)-ld/l(Z) = 0 .
Since this is true for all f in A,(C) with f(zo) = 0, it follows that for an arbitrary f in A,(C) we have
~ f(z)(z
- zo)-ldf1(z) =
+ ~f(Zo)(Z -
~ [fez)
zo)-ld/l(Z)
=
- f(zo)](z - zo)-ld/l(Z)
0
+ f(zo)( -h(zo» =
If we let Ou denote the measure of mass that J)
= (z - ZO)-'f1
+1
-cf(zo) .
at the point zo, it follows
+ COo
is a measure on C which annihilates A,(C). Now if Zo were in M, there would exist f in A,(C) with f(zo) = 1 and If(z) I < 1 for all z *- Zo in C. Since J)({zo}) = c
*- 0, it is clear that ~rdJ) *- 0 if n is sufficiently large.
103
l\ MINIMAL BOUNDARY FOl{ FUNCTION ALGEBRAS
641
This is a contradiction, since fn E AI(C). This shows that Zu is not in M. Since Zu was any point in r we have Fe C - M. Since /' has positive measure, C - M has pos-itive measure, as was to be proved. To restate the theorem, if for every point z on C, with the possible exception of a set of measure 0, there exists a continuous function f on C with If(z) I > If(n I for all I; cd=- z in C which can be uniformly approximated by rational functions with poles in - C, then every continuous function on C can be uniformly approximated by rational functions whose poles lie in - C. THEOREM 5. Let C be a compact subset of the complex plane without interior. Let Au(C) be the algebra of all continuous complex-valued functions on C and let A'(C) be those functions in AJC) which can be umformly approximated by rational functions with poles in - C, and let M be the minimal boundary of A I(C), Let Ju(C) consist of all continu01.ls real-'wlued functions on C, and let J,(C) consist of all continuous real-valued functions on C which are uniforrnly approximable by real parts of functions in A I(C), Let Mo consist of all points z in C such that there exists f in JI(C) with If(z) I > If(l;) I for all I; z in C. Then M = Mu and the following statements are equivalent:
"*
(i)
(ii) (iii) (iv)
AI(C) =-= Au(C) C - M has measure 0 M = C J,(C)
=
Ju(C) .
Proof. The fact that M = Mil is a special case of the corollary to Theorem 3. It is clear that (i) ~ (iii) ~ (ii). But (ii) ~ (i) by Theorem 4. Thus (i), (ii), and (iii) are equivalent. It is also clear that (i) ~ (iv). But (iv) implies that M" = C. Thus (iv) ~ (iii). This proves Theorem 5. Theorem 5 thus gives results concerning approximation on a nowhere dense subset of the complex plane by rational functions or by real parts of rational functions, and shows that the two problems are related. The results for approximation by the real parts of rational functions are similar in outward appearance to results of Brelot [2] and Deny [4], who consider approximation by functions harmonic in a neighborhood of C, but there does not seem to be an essential connection, due to the fact that a function harmonic in the neighborhood of C need not be the real part of an analytic function, since the conjugate harmonic function might be mUltiple-valued. REFERENCES
E Bishop, Some theOl'ems concerning function algeb7'as, Bull (1959), 77-78.
104
Amer Math. Soc 65
~KK~
1 1
Ol;:,nvr
2. M. Brelot, Criteres de refJUlarite et de stabilite, Acad Roy Belgique Bull Cl Sci 25 (1939), 125-137. 3. G. Choquet, Existence dC's npresentation8 int6graZ!'s au moyen des points ertremaur dans les cones converes, C R. Acad Sci. Paris 243 (1956), 699-702 4 J. Deny, Sur l'approrimation des fonctions harmoniques, Bull Soc Math France 73 (1945), 71-73 5 L. H. Loomis, Abstract harmonic analysis, New York, 1953 6 S. N Mergelyan, On the representation of functions by series of polynomials on closed sets, Amer. Math. Soc Translation no 85, 1953 7. L. Schwartz, Theorie des distnbutions vol 1, Actualities Scient et Indust, Paris, 1951 UNIVERSITY OF CALH'ORNIA BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA
105
the American Mathematical Society.
SOME THEOREMS CONCERNING FUNCTION ALGEBRAS BY ERRETT BISHOpl
Communicated by
J L Kelley, November 21, 1958
In what follows, C wIiI be a compact Hausdorff space, and m: will be a uniformly closed separating algebra of continuous complexvalued functions on C. That is, sums, products, and complex multiples of elements of mare in m, uniform limits of elements of mare in m, and for distinct points x and y in C there existsfin mwithf(x) y5.f(y). SiJov (see [1]) has shown that there exists a smallest closed subset B of C, called the Silov boundary of m:, such that for eachf in m: there exists in B with = where = max {IJ()') y E C}. The following theorem generalizes this result, in case C is metric.
If(x) I IVII '
x
I:
IVII
THEOREM 1. Let C be a compact metnc space, and let m: be a uniformly closed separating algebra oj continuous complex-valued Junctions on C. Then there exists a smallest subset M oj C, called the minimal boundary of m, such that for each fin 21: there exists x in M with If(x) = The set M 1'S equal to the set M 0 which is defined as follows:
I II! II .
Mo=
lx:xEc,
3finmwith If(x)
I>
If(y)lforallyy5.xincl.
The closure of M is the Silov boundary of 21:. The question of the topological structure of .M is answered by the following theorem. THEOREM
Un =
2. Lt't p be the metric on C. For each positive integer n, let
Ix: X E C,
3fin 21: with
IIfll
I f(x) I > 3/4,
~ 1,
and
I fey) I < 1/4 for
p(x, y) ~
,,-l}.
Then nUn=M.
Since it is easy to see that Un is open, it follows that },{ is a G•. lt is known that every bounded linear functional cf> on mcan be represented by a complex-valued Borel measure J.L with IIJ.LII = 11cf>1I on the Silov boundary B of 21:. I t is conjectured that J.L can be taken to be a measure on the minimal bounary of m:. The following theorem constitutes an important case of this conjecture. THEOREM 3. Let x be a point of C which is not in the minimal boundary M of m:. Let mcontain the constant functions. Then there exists a non-negative Borel measure J.L on B-1 x} of norm 1 such that f(x) = fdJ.L for all f in 21:.
J
1
This research was supported by the Sloan Foundation
77
106
,u
~AI\.C.l
I.
Dhll'lVl.
As an application of these concepts, we have the following theorem. THEOREM 4. Let C be a compact subset of the complex plane without interior. Let ~ be the algebra of all continuous functions on C which are uniform limits of rational functions with poles in - C. Let M be the minimal boundary of ~. Let 58 be the set of all continuous real functions on C which are umform limits of the real parts of rational junctions with poles in - C. Let N be the set
{x: x E C, 3f in 58 with If(x)
I>
IfCy)
I for ally ~
xin C}.
Then ]vI = N and the following conditions are equivalent: (i) ~ consists of all continuous functions on C, (ii) 58 consists of all continuous real functions on C, (iii) M = C, (iii i) C - .1£ has measure O. Theorem -l gives a necessary and sufficient condition on a compact subset C of the complex plane that every continuous function on C be uniformly approximable by rational functions Mergelyan [2] has given sufficient conditions. Added in proof. The conjecture preceding Theorem 3 has been proved. REFERENCES
1. L. H. Loomis, Abstract harmonic analysis, New York, 1953.
2. S. N. Mergelyan, On the representation of functions by series of polynomials on closet! sets, Amer. Math Soc. Translations, no 85, 1953. UNIVERSITY OF CALlrORNIA, BERKLEY
107
THE REPRESENTATIONS OF LINEAR FUNCTIONALS BY MEASURES ON SETS OF EXTREME POINTS by Errett BISHOP and Karel de LEEUW (I)
1. -
INTRODUCTION
Let X be a compact Hau'idorff space.
We shall denote by
C,(X) the real Banach space of continuous real valued functions on X, and by Cc(X) the complex Banach space of continuous complex valued functions on X, supplied with norms denoted by 11.11 and defined by
IIfII =
Sup i((x) I· XE'{
Suppose that B is some linear subspace of either Cr(X) or Cc(X) that distinguishes points of X and that contains the constant functions. We are concerned in this paper with the problem of representing the linear functionals in the dual space B* of B by measures on X. It is well known that such representations are always possible; if B is a linear subspace of Cr(X), by the Hahn-Banach theorem, any L in B* extends to a continuous linear functional of Cr(X) and thus by the Riesz representation theorem, there will be some signed Baire measure !J. on X so that
(1. 1)
L(f)
=
J(dp.,
all (in B.
If B is a linear subspace of Cc(X), a similar argument shows (1) The authors wish to thank the Sloan Foundation and the United States Air Force Office of Scientific Research, respectively, for the support of this research.
20
108
306
ERRETT BISHOP ET
K.~REL
DE
LEEUW
that each L in B* has a representation of the form (1. 1) for [J. a complex valued Baire measure. There are cases in which it is possible to find a. subset Y of X which is such that each L in B* has a representation of thp form (1. 1) for some [J. concentrated on Y. In this paper wp introduce such a subset, the Choquet boundary of B. The Choquet boundary of B is denoted by M(B) and consists of all points x in X having the following property: there is a unique positi()e Baire measure 1-'- that represent'>, in the sense of (1. 1), the linear functional L~ defined by (1. 2)
all fin B.
LAf) = f(x),
This unique 1-'- will of course be the unit point mass at x. In the case that B is a uniformly closed subalgebra of Cc(X) and X is metrizable, M(B) is the minimal boundary of [3] and [4]. We show in Section 4 that the extreme points of the subset
!L: L E B*,
L(1) = IILII = 1l
of B* are those Lc defined by (1. 2) for x in M(B). From this and the Krein-Milman theorem it follows easily that any L in B* has a representation of the form (1. 1) with [J. a measure concentrated on the closure of M(B). The question that concerns us is whether it is possible to choose the measure 1-'- so that it is concentrated on M(B) itself. / If X is metrizable, an application of the theorem of Choquet / in [7] shows that this is indeed possible. We proceed in the reverse direction, showing directly that the measure can be concentrated on M(B); this leads to a relatively simple proof of the Choquet theorem. In the case that X is not metrizable the situation is much more complicated. We give examples in the concluding section of the paper to show that M(B) need not even be a Borel set. We prove nevertheless that each L in B* has a representation of the form (1. 1) for a measure 1-'- that is ({ concentrated on M(B) » in following sense: it is a measure on the a-ring generated by M(B) and the Baire sets of X, and is zero on each set in this a-ring which is disjoint from M(B). Furthermore if L(1) = liLli, the measure 1-'- can be chosen to be non-negative. This leads to an extension of the theorem of Choquet to convex sets that are not metrizable.
109
THE
REPRESENTATIONS
OF
LINEAR
FUNCTIONALS
307
The existence of measures concentrated on the Choquet boundary is obtained roughly as follows. An ordering relation on the class of non-negative Baire measures on X is introduced. We say that fJ- is a B-cover of YJ if
J f dYJ J f dfJ-, I f2 dYJ < f f2 dp., =
and (1. 3)
allfinB, all fin B.
We say that fJ- is a proper B-col'er of Yj if fJ- is a B-cover of YJ and furthermore the inequality in (1. 3) is strict for some fin B. YJ is called B-maximal if it has no proper B-eover. A simple argument using Zorn's Lemma and weak* compactness assures for any given non-negative Bairc measure "1), the existence of a B-maximal fJ- that is a B-cover for "1). The crucial result now is theorem 5. 3 which shows that fJ-(S) = 0 if fJ- is B-maximal and S is disjoint from M(B). From this it follows simply that any B-maximal po can be extended to a measure « concentrated on M(B) » in the sense described above. Since each linear functional in B* has a representation of the form (1. 1) for some Baire measure fJ- on X, and such a p. is a linear combination of non-negative Baire measures, and each nonnegative Baire measure has a B-maximal B-cover that is concentrated on M(B), it follows that any linear functional in B* has a representation of form (1. 1) for some p. concentrated on M(B). Section 6 is devoted to uniformly closed subalgebras of C.(X). We give somewhat simpler proofs of some of the results of [3J and [4J and remove the hypothesis of metrizability of X imposed there. We show that if A is a uniformly closed subalgebra of Cc(X) that distinguishes points of X and contains the constant functions, the points x of M(A) can be characterized by either of the following conditions: I. For each neighborhood U of x there is a function f in A with Ilfll
< 1,
f(x)
> ~
and If(y) I <
{
for all y not in U.
I I. If S is a closed Go containing x, then there is some in A with If(x)1 = Ilfll
and
!y: If(y)1
=
f
Ilflll c S.
A subse.t Y of X is said to be a boundary for A if for each f
308
ERRETT BISHOP ET KAREL DE
LEEUW
in A there is some y in Y with If(y)1 = Ilfll. It is a simple consequence of the Krein-Milman theorem that the Choquet boundary of A is a boundary for A. ConditioR II shows that in addition, any Baire subset of X that is a boundary for A must contain M(A). Furthermore if X has the property that each point is a Go (in particular if X is metrizable), condition II shows that for each point x of M(A) there is some f in A that « peaks» at x, so that M(A) is the smallest boundary for A, that is, the minimal boundary (for X mctrizable, this was established in [3J and [4J). If not every point of X is a Go, there may bp no smallest boundary, even if A is all of Cc(X). Since each L in A* has a representation of the form (1. 1) for p. a measure concentrated on M(A), it is reasonable to inquire whether for any set Y that is a boundary for A, a measure can be found that represents L and is concentrated on Y. We show by example in Section 7 that thi"l cannot be done for linear subspaces of Cc(X) that are not subalgebras. Nevertheless we are able to show that for sub algebras such measures can always be found. The existence of these measures was suggested to us by Irving Glicksberg, who studied essentially the same problem for the case A = Cc(X) in [8J. In all that follows, by « subspace of Cr(X) » (or « of Cc(X) ») we shall mean a linear subspace containing the constant functions, but not necessarily closed or distinguishing points of X.' For applications it is useful to have results concerning not necessarily closed linear subspaccs; furthermore it is necessary for technical reasons for us to consider linear subspaces that do not distinguish points of X. By « measure » in the following, we shall always mean finite measure.
II. -- THE BASIC DEFINITIONS
In the following X is a fixed compact Hausdorff space. We shall denote by H the class of all non-negative Baire measures on X. This class H will be identified in the usual manner with a subset of the dual space of Cr(X). By the weak*
111
I
THE
309
I1EPRESENTATIONS OF LINEAR FUNCTIONALS
topology of H we shall mean the restriction to H of the weak* topology on the dual space of Cr(X). The basic fact concerning the weak* topology that we shall need is that bounded closed subsets of Hare weak* compact. The following allows us to reduce questions concerning linear functionals on sub5paces of Cr(X) or Cc(X) to questions about the Haire measures in H.
2. 1. - Let B be a subspace of Cr(X) or Cc(X). each L in B* has a representation of the form LEMMA
f fdfJ-,
L(f) =
(2. 1)
Then
all fin B;
where p. is a Baire measure which is of the form
(2. 2) ifB is a subspace of Cr(X), and of the form
p.! -
fJ-2
+ ifJ-J -
fJ-1l ••• , p.. in H,
ifJ-4I
if B is a subspace of Cc(X). Furthermore the fJ- in (2. 1) can be chosen to be in H if and only if L(1) = IILII. PROOF. We shall treat the case of B a subspace of Cr(X); the proof for Cc(X) is completely analogous. By the HahnBanach theorem, L can be extended to all of Cr(X) with preservation of norm; i.e. there is a linear functional L' on Cr(X) with L'(f) = L(f), all fin B,
and IIL'II = IILII. By the Riesz representation theorem, there is a signed Baire measure p. on X so that
L'(f)
=
.r
f dp.,
all fin Cr(X).
Each signed Baire measure on X is of the form (2. 2). L(1) = liLli, then
11fJ-11
=
IIL'il
=
IILII
=
L(1)
=
If
[J.(X),
so p. must be non-negative and thus in H. Conversely if p. is in H, the L defined by (2. 1) clearly satisfies L(1) = IILII. If B is a subspace of Cr(X) or Cr(X), and x is a point of X, we define H",(B) to be the subset of H consisting of all fJ- with (2. 3)
f f dfJ-
= f(x),
112
all fin B.
310
ERRETT BISHOP ET
K <\REL
DE
LEEUW
H.,(B) is always non-empty since it must contain at least the unit point mass at x. Since subs paces are assumed to contain the constant functions, by (2. 3) each [J. in H.,(B) satisfies p.(X) = 1. If S is any subset of X and B is any collection of functions on X, we define i8(S) to be the subset of X consisting of those points that cannot be distinguished from points of S by the functions in B; i.e. iH(S) is
1y : f(y) =
f(x)
for some
xeS and all
feB
l.
If P. is any Baire measure in H, we denote by p. its regular Borel extension. This is the unique regular Borel measure on X that agrees with p. on the Baire sets of X. It is defined by
P.(S)
=
Inf p.(U),
where U runs over all open Baire sets that contain S. If B is a subspace of either Cr(X) or Cc(X), the Choquet boundary of B, denoted by M(B), is defined to consist of those points x in X which are such that any p. in H..,(B) satisfies p.(in(x)) = 1. If B contains sufficiently many functions to distinguish a point x from all other points of X, ill(x) = fxl, so that x will be in the Choquet boundary of B if and only if the unit point mass at x is the only p. in Hc(B). If B is a subspace of Cc(X), we shall denote by Br the subspac(y/ of Cr(X) consisting of real parts of the functions in B. The following is immediate. LEMMA
H,,(B r )
=
2. 2. H,,(B).
M (Br)
=
M (B), and for each x in X,
We next introduce some ordering relations on H which are basic to the constructions that follow. If B is a subspace of Cr(X) and fI. and Yj are in H, we shall say that fI. is a B-co~er of Yj if all fin B, and (2. 4)
all fin B.
We shall say that p. is a proper B-cover of YJ if P. is a B-cover of YJ and furthermore the inequality (2. 4) is strict for some fin B.
113
THE
A measure
REPRESENTATIONS
OF
LINEAR
FUNCTIONALS
311
will be called B-maximal if it has no proper
Yj
B-co~er.
Much of the work done in the remainder of the paper goes into demonstrating that any B-maximal measure must be concentrated on the Choquet boundary of B. The following two lemmas will be applied later. LEMMA 2. 3. Let x be a point of X and Yj in H be the unit point mass at x. Let B be a subspace of Cr(X). Then any [.I. in Hx(B) is a B-cover of Yj.
By the Schwarz inequality, for each fin B,
PROOF. -
Furthermore for all Yj
f
in B.
LEMMA 2. 4. Let B be a subspace of Cr(X). in H has a B-co~er that is B-maximal.
Then each
PROOF. Consider subsets! [.I.a.! a.EJ of H indexed by totally ordered sets J, where the ordering is such that fAp is a B-cover of [.I.a. if IX <~. By Zorn's lemma there is a maximal such subset [.I.a.l a.EJ that contains Yj. Since B contains the constant functions, each [.I.a. is in
!
(2. 5)
!v:vEH,
v(X) = Yj(X) I.
(2. 5) is compact in the weak* topology and thus contains a weak* cluster point [.I. for the net ! [.I.a.l a.EJ. It is clear that [.I. is a B-cover of Yj and that [.I. is B-maximal.
III. -
REPRESENTATION OF LINEAR FUNCTIONALS IN THE SEPARABLE CASE.
The main result in this section is Theorem 3. 2. Using it we establish in Theorem 3. 4 the possibility of representing linear functionals on B by measures on the Choquet boundary of B in the case that B is separable, that is, has a countable
114
dense subset. Theorem 3. 2 will also be applied later in the non-separable case. We shall need the following well known lemma. LEMMA 3. 1. Let S be a closed subset of X. each positilJe real number c, the subset
f p.:
!J. e H,
!J.(X)
=
p.(T)
=
c,
for some finite
Then for T c S~
of H is dense in
!P.:!J.E H,
p.(X) = ~(S) =
c!
in the weak* topology. We can now prove THEOREM 3. 2. Let B be a subspace of Cr(X), and p. in H be a B-maximal measure. Let S be a closed subset of X which has the following property: there is a separable subspace D of B so that for each x in S there is some IJ' in HAB) with lJ'(in(x)) < 1. Then (l(S) = O. The statement of this theorem is necessarily complicated as it must be applied later to the situation where B is not separable. In that case D will necessarily be a proper subspace of B and will not distinguish points of X. In the application in this section however D = B, and in this case the hypothesis on S in the theorem becomes simply that it be disjoint from the Choquet boundary of B. /
!
PROOF OF THEOREM 3. 2. Let f fn: n = 1, 2, ... be a countable subset of D that is dense in D. For each pair of positive integers nand m define Lnm to be the subset of X consisting of all x for which there is some po in H",(B) with.
(3. 1)
For if !xa; ~ is a net of points in Lnm converging to a point x in X, and if for each or; a measure !J.a; is chosen in H",jB) so that
Lnm is closed.
by the weak'" compactness of
I!J.: fL e
po(X) =
H,
115
11
THE
REPRESENTATIONS
OF
LINEAR
313
FUNCTIONALS
the net j fJoa.l will have a weak· cluster point fJo in H...,(B), and fJo will satisfy (3. 1). We will show next that
S c U Lnm.
(3. 2)
Let x be a point of X that is in none of the L HAB). By the definition of the L nm ,
(3.3)
Jf!dcr
<
(fn(x))2
=
IJ{n dcr I 2
Il,".
Let cr be in
•
On the other hand, by the Schwarz inequality, (3. 4)
f f,. da J{~ dcr f 12 da > f {n dcr =
1
12 ,
with equality if and only if {n is constant a.e. with respect to cr. Comparing (3. 3) and (3. 4) we see that each (n must be constant a.e. with respect to cr. Since also fn(x) = (n da, it follows that fn is equal to (,,(x) a.e. with respect to cr for each n. Thus the set
J
in(x)
=
[y: (n(Y)
= (n(x),
n = 1,2, ... ]
has a measure 1. Since this holds for each cr in HAB), x cannot be in S. This completes the proof of the inclusion (3. 2). We now show that fl(S) > 0 contradicts the B-maximality of fJo. Suppose that P.(S) > O. Then by (3. 2), fl(Lnm) > 0 for some Lnm. Let v be the measure in H that is the restriction of fJo to Lnm : i.e., v(T) = fl(T n Lnm) for all Baire sets T. Now v =/= 0 since v(X) = fl(Lnm) -=1= O. By Lemma 3. 1, v is the limit in the weak* topology of a net [va.] of measures in H with va.(X) = v(X) and each Va. concentrated on a finite subset of Lnm. By Lemma 2. 3 and the definition of L llm it follows that there exists a corresponding net [YJa.] of measures in H such that each YJa. is a B-cover of Va. and in addition that
f f,.
dYJa. L
v~) + .J 'f,. dva..
If YJ is any weak· cluster point of the net [YJa.] , YJ l~ a B-cover of v and
J'r,. dYJ Lvi;) + f r. dv.
Thus YJ is a proper B-cover of v and it follows that (fJo -
116
v)
+ YJ
is a proper B-cover of fJ-. This contradicts the B-maximality of fJ- and shows that (1(5) must be O. This completes that proof of Theorem 3. 2.
COROLLARY 3. 3. - Let D be a separable subspace of C,(X). Then the Choquet boundary of D is a Gil. If YJ is any measure in H, then there is some measure fJ- in H with (3. 5)
J fdp. = J fdYJ,
all fin D,
and which is concentrated on M(D); i.e. satisfies f1(M(D)) = p.(X).
PROOF. - Let f fn: n = 1, 2, ... j be a countable subset of D that is dense in D. Define the closed subsets Lnm of X as in the proof of theorem 3.2. We shall show that M(D) is the complement of U Lnm and is thus a Ga. Let x be any point which is not in M(D). Then that part of the hypothesis of theorem 3. 2 which concerns B, D, and 5 is satisfied if B is taken to be D and S to be Ix j. The proof of Theorem 3. 2 shows that x is in U Lnm. Conversely, from the definition of the Lnm it is clear that no point in U Lnm can be in M(D). Thus M(D) is a Gil as claimed. Now let YJ be any measure in H. Let p. be aD-maximal measure in H that is a D-cover of YJ. The existence of such a p. is guaranteed by Lemma 2. 4. Equality (3. 5) holds since p. is a D-cover of YJ. To show that f1(M(D)) = fJ-(X), by regularity of f1 it suffices to show that (1(S) = 0 for each closed S that is disjoint from M(D). That this holds is a consequence of Theorem 3. 2 for the special case D = B. This completes the proof of Corollary 3. 3. The following is an immediate consequence of Lemma 2. 1 and Corollary 3. 3. THEOREM 3.4. - Let D be a separable subspace of C,(X) or C.(X). Then any linear functional L in D* has a representation of the form (3. 6)
L(f) =
Jf dp.,
all fin D,
for p. a Baire measure on X that is concentrated on M(D) in the sense that (1(S) = 0 for each Borel set S disjoint from M(D). Furthermore the p. in (3. 6) can be chosen to be in H if and only if L(1) = IILII.
117
THE
IV. -
REPRESENTATIONS
OF
LINEAR
FUNCTIONALS
315
EXTREME POINTS AND THE CHOQUET THEOREM
Let E be a real locally convex topological linear space with dual space E*. Let X be a compact convex subset of E and B the linear subspace of C,(X) consisting of all functions ( ha ving the form
((x) = F(x)
+ c,
all x in X,
for some F in E* and some real constant c. If p. is a real-valued measure on X whose domain includes the Baire sets of X and if S is a Baire subset of X, we shall denote by (4. 1)
.fs
the unique element y of E that satisfies F(y) = F dfJ- for each F in E*. We shall usc standard properties of the vector valued integral (4. 1) that are discussed for example in [6]. The following lemma was announced by Bauer in [2]. LEMMA 4. 1. Let x be a point of X. are equiyalent: 1. x is an extreme point of X. 2. x is in M(B).
Then the following
To show that 2 implies 1, let x be a point of X 1 that is not extreme. Then x = 2 (u y) for some u and y PROOF. -
+
=F y. Thus the measure fJ- in H that satisfies (l( f u}) = (l( f y}) = ~ and p.(X) = 1 is in Hx(B) by the defini-
in X with u
tion of B. Since the functions of B distinguish points of X, in(x) = Ix} so p.(ill(x)) = 0 and x is not in M(B). To show that 1 implies 2, suppose that x is an extreme point of X. Let fl. be in H,,(B). We shall show that fJ- is the unit point mass at x so that x is in the Choquet boundary of B. Since fJ- is in Hx(B), x = Y dfJ-(Y). If S is any Baire subset
f
118
ERRETT
BISHOP ET
KAREL
DE
of X with 0 < p.(S) < 1, and T = X tion as a convex combination
of points in X. (4.2)
p.(S)x
LEEUW
S, x has a representa-
Since:L is an extreme point of X, =
J:y dp.(y),
all Baire
Sc X.
J:F d;.,
all Baire
SeX, FE E*.
Equivalently, (4.3)
p.(S)F(x) =
(4. 3) is possible only if
(4. 4)
p.(j y : F(y)
=
F(x) l)
=
all
1,
FE E*.
If C(p.) is the carrier of p., that is, the smallest closed subset of X whose complement has p. measure 0, (4. 4) shows that C(p.)
c
!y: F(y)
=
F(x) J,
all FE E*.
But since the functions in E* distinguish points of X, C(p.) must be I x I and p. must be the unit point mass at x. Thus x is in M(B) and the proof of Lemma 4. 1 is completed. We can now establish the Choquet theorem by using our Theorem 3. 4. ,/ THEOREM 4. 2. - Let X be a compact convex metrizable subset of a locally convex topological linear space. E. Let X. be the set of extreme points of X. Then X. is a Go in X and every x in X has a representation of the form
(4. 5)
x =
Iy dp. (y)
for some non-negative Baire measure p. on X satisfying
p.(X.) = p.(X)
=
1.
PROOF. - Let B be the subspace of Cr(X) defined earlier. Since X is metrizable, B is separable, so X. = M(B) is a Go in X. Let x be a point in X and L the linear functional of B defined by all fin B. L(f) = f(x),
119
THE
REPRESENTATIONS OF
LINEAR
FUNCTIONALS
317
Then L(1) = IILII = 1, so by Theorem 3. 4 there is a non-negative Baire measure fJ. with fL(M(B)) = fJ.(X) = 1 and (4. 6)
L(F) = JF dfL,
all Fin E*.
But (4.6) is simply a restatement of (4.5). And fJ.(X.) = 1 since by Lemma 4. 1, X. = M(B). This completes the proof. LEMMA 4. 1. gives a characterization of the Choquet boundary in terms of extreme points in a very special situation. It will be necessary for our later work to have a suitable replacement of this in the general case. LEMMA 4. 3. - Let X be a compact Hausdorff space, B a subspace o{ Cr(X). Let Lo be a linear functional in B*. Then the following are equivalent: 1. Lo is an extreme point o{ (4. 7)
!L: L
E
B*,
L(1)
= liLl1 = 1j
2. There is a point x in M(B) so that
Lo(f) = {(x), PROOF. -
all (in B.
To show that 2 implies 1, suppose that Lo is not
an extreme point of (4.7).
Lo =
*
; (Ll
+ L 2),
with Ll and
'"
L2 in (4.7), Ll Lo. By Lemma 2.1 there are measures fJ.l and fJ.2 in H with fJ.l(X) = P.2(X) = 1 and Li (f) =
J{dfLi'
Since Lo =1= L 1 , P.l(iB(X))
<
all (in B,
1.
i = 1, 2. 1
Let p. = 2(fJ.1
+ fL2).
Then p.
is in H",(B) and fL( ill (x) ) < 1, so x is not in M(B). This completes the proof that 2 implies 1. To show that 1 implies 2, suppose that Lo is an extreme point of (4. 7). By Lemma 2. 1 there is a measure p. in H so that Lo(f) = {dp., all (in B.
J
Let SI be any Baire subset of X with 0 < :J.(SI) < 1, and S2 = X - SI. Then if the linear functionals Ll and L2 in (4. 7) are defined by 1 " Li(f) = :J.(SiL(/ dp., all {in B,
120
a:.nnr.J.J.
.Dl~HU.l'"
J:!.1
~A""''''''''''''
___
___ _
we have a representation of Lo as a convex combination
+
Lo = fJ-(SI) Ll ~J.(S2) L2 of points in (4. 7). Since Lo is an extreme point of (4. 7), this must be a trivial representation, so
fJ d'f =
'f(S).r f dfJ-,
for all fin B and all Baire Sin X. Thus each fin B is constant almost everywhere with respect to if, and if x is chosen to be in the carrier C(fJ-), of p., that constant value must be f(x). This shows that Lo(f) = f(x) for all fin B and that (4.8)
C(fJ-)
C
!y: f(y)
=
f(x),
all fin Bj = in(x).
Since fJ- could have been chosen to be any measure in HAB), (4.8) shows that x is in M(B). This completes the proof of the lemma. LEMMA 4. 3. allows us to draw a useful conclusion concerning the relation between M (B) and (CM) where B is a subspace of Cr(X) and C is a subspace of B. For this we need the following. LEMMA 4. 4. - Let El and E2 be real locally con~ex topological linear spaces and 9 : El ~ E2 a continuous linear transformation. Let Y be a compact con~ex subset of E 1 . Then for each extreme point ~ of
(4.9)
lL:LeB*,
L( 1)
= II LII =
1j
IL:LeC*,
L(1)
=
11·
under p is
(4. 10)
121
IILII =
I
THE
REPRESENTATIONS
OF
LINEAR
FUNCTIONALS
319
Let x be a point in M(C). Then by Lemma 4.3 the linear functionnal Lx in C * defined by Lx(f)
=
{(x),
all (in C,
is an extreme point of (4.10). By Lemma 4.4, Lx is the image under l' of an extreme point of (4. 9), which must by Lemma 4. 3 be of the form Ly, all (in B, for some y in M(B); 9(Ly) = Lx means simply that Ly when restricted to C agrees with L.e, that is, (4. 11)
{(x) = {(y),
all (in C.
Since y is in M(B), (4.11) shows that x is in ic(M(B)). Since x was any point in M(C), it follows that M(C) c ic(M(B)), as was to be proved. It is worth noting that under the hypotheses of Corollary 4. 5, neither M(C) c M(B) nor M(B) c M(C) holds in general.
v. -
REPRESENTATION OP LINEAR PUNCTIONALS IN THE GENERAL CASE
The purpose of thIS section is to extend our Theorem 3. 4 on the representation of linear functionals to the case of subspaces that are not separable, and to use this result to remove the hypothesis of metrizability in the Choquet theorem. If B is a subspace of Cr(X) that distinguishes points of X, the fact that any linear functional in B* can be represented by a measure concentrated on the Choquet boundary of B follows simply from the following (which is our Theorem 5. 3) : If fJ. in His B-maximal and S is a Baire set disjoint from M(B), then fJ.(S) = O. This in turn is an immediate consequence of Theorem 3. 2 if it is possible to find for each x in S a measure rr in Hx(B) with rr(S) < 1. It is the establishment of the existence of these measures that is the main work of this section. This is accomplished by a reduction to the separable case and an application of Corollary 3.3.
122
ERRETT BISHOP ET
ur.
KAREL
Lr.r.U..,
For each subset S of X, we shall denote by "'/..s the characteristic function of S, ~ 1, x in S 'X.s(x) = ~ 0, x not in S. LEMMA 5. 1. Let B be a subspace of C.(X), S a closed subset of X and x a point of S. Then the following are equivalent: 1. Each po in Hx(B) has P.(S) = 1, 2. For each g in C.(X) with g ~ AS, Sup If(x): (e B, gl > 1.
«
Let fJ. be in Hx(B).
Suppose that 2 holds. for each g in C.(X) with g L Z.~, PROOF. -
Jg dfJ. 2 But
J
g!
(~ = «gl>1. g dfJ.: g e C.(Xl, gL"'/..sL
Sup) (dfJ.: (e B, Sup) ((x) : ( e B,
P.(S) = Infl
Then
J
so P.(S) L 1. For the converse suppose that 2 does not hold. a function in C.(X) with g > I.~ and Sup I((x) : (
e
«
B,
gl = 1 -
Let g be
Eo
Define the linear functional Lx on B by all (in B.
(5. 1)
L". is a positive linear functional on B (that is, non-negative on non-negative functions) and thus by a standard result (see [10J, p. 22) on the extension of such functionals, there is a positive linear functional L on C.(X) with L(f) = Lx(f) ,
(5. 2)
all (in B,
and L(g) = 1 - t:. By the Riesz representation theorem, there is a p. in H with (5. 3)
L(f) =
Jf dfJ.,
all (in C.(X).
Because of (5. 1), (5. 2) and (5. 3), po is in Hx(B) and P.(S) =
f AS dfJ. < Jg d[l.
=
1-
This completes the proof of Lemma 5. 1.
123
E
<
1.
321
THE REPRESENTATIONS OF LINEAR FUNCTIONALS
LEMMA 5. 2. - Let B be a subspace of Cr(X) and S a closed Gil in X. Let x be a point of s. Suppose that each ~ in H.,(B) satisfies fL(S) = 1. Then there is a separable subspace C of B which is such that each fL in H.,(C) satisfies ~(S) = 1. PROOF. -
Since S is a closed Go, there is a sequence
f gn : n
=
1, 2, ... J
in Cr(X) decreasing point wise to x.s. By « 1 implies 2 » of Lemma 5. 1, for each positive nand m it is possible to find some fnm in B with fnm < gn and fnm(x).2: 1 - m-l. Let C be the subspace of B generated by the fnm and the constant functions. C is a separable subspace. If fL is in H.,,(c), then :1.(S)
= I~f
Jgn dp. .2: I~f (S~p Jf'IlTI dp.) = I~f (S~p fnm(x)) L
1,
so p.(S) must be 1. THEOREM 5.3. - Let B be a subspace of Cr(X) that distin· guishes points of x. If S is a Baire set disjoint from M(B), and fL in H is B-maximal, then p.(S) =
o.
PROOF. - By regularity of p. we can assume S closed Baire and thus a Go. B distinguishes points of X so there will be a separable subspace D of B that distinguishes the points of S from those of X - S; i.e. that satisfies in(S) = S. We consider two cases. Case 1 : For each x ip S there is a a- in Hx(B) with a-(S) < 1. Case 2: For some x in S, and all a- in H",(B), a-(S) = 1. We shall use Theorem 3. 2 to show that p.(S) = 0 follows in case 1, and then use Corollories 3. 3 and 4. 5 and Lemma 5. 2 to show that case 2 cannot occur. Case 1: Sin('e iD(S) = S, for each x in S, in(x) c S. Thus for each x in S there is some '.T in H",(B) with a-(in(x)) < '.T(S) < 1, so by Theorem 3. 2, p.(S) = o. Case 2: If each a- in H",(B) satisfies a-(S) = 1, then by Lemma 5.2 there is a separable subspace C of B (which can be chosen to contain D) so that each a- in HAC) satisfies a-(S) = 1. We shall now use Corollary 3. 3 to contradict this by showing that there actually is a a- in Hx(C) with '.T(S) = o. Since D·c C and in(S) = S, ic(S) = S, and S will be disjoint 21
124
from ic(M(B)) since it is disjoint from M(B). But by Corollary 4. 5, M(C) c ic(M(B)), so S is disjoint from M(C). By Corollary 3. 3 applied to the unit mass Yj at x, there is a a in HAC) with &(M(C)) = 1 and thus with a(S) = O. This contradicts the earlier assertion that each a in Hx(C) must satisfy a(S) = 1. Thus Case 2 cannot occur, and Theorem 5. 3 is completely proved. COROLLARY 5.4. - Let B be a subspace of Cr(X) that distinguishes points of X. Let [J. in H be B-maximal. Then p. can be extended to a measure that is concentrated on M(B); to be precise, there is a measure ~ on the a-ring generated by M(B) and the Baire sets that satisfies fi(S) = p.(S), all Baire S, fi(M(B)) = p.(X) = 1.
and
PROOF. - Any set T in the a-ring generated by M(B) and the Baire sets has a representation of the form
(5.4)
T = \ Sl n M(B) I u [S2 n (X-M(B)) l,
Sl' S2 Baire.
It is simple to check, using Theorem 5. 3, that if p. is defined by with Sl as in (5.4),
il is well defined
and satisfies the conditions claimed. The following is now an immediate consequence of Lemmas 2. 1, 2. 4 and Corollary 5. 4.
THEOREM 5. 5. - Let B be a subspace of Cr(X) or C.(X) that distinguishes points of X. Let;J be the a-ring generated by M(B) and the Baire sets of X. Then any linear functional L in B* has a representation of the form (5.5)
L(f)
=
Jfdp.,
all fin B,
for p. a measure on j' that satisfies p.(T) = 0 for each T e ;Y disjoint from M(B). Furthermore the p. in (5. 5) can be chosen to be non-negative if and only if L(1) = IILII. We can now state the generalized Choquet theorem. Its proof is identical with that of Theorem 4. 2, except that Theorem 5. 5 is used instead of Theorem 3. 4.
125
THE
REPRESENTATIONS
OF
LINEAR
323
FUNCTIONALS
THEOREM 5. 6. - Let X be a compact conlJex subset of a real locally conlJex topological linear space. Let X. be the set of extreme points of X and;1 the a-ring generated by X. and the Baire subsets of X. Then each x in X has a representation of the form Y d(J.(y)
f
for some non-negatilJe measure (J. on !l that satisfies
f1.(X.) = (J.(X) = 1.
VI. -
ALGEBRAS
If B is a subspace of C.(X) or C«X), a subset Y of X will be called a boundary for B if for each f in B there is some y in Y with If(y)i = Ilfll. The following lemma was announced by Bauer [2J. LEMMA 6.1. - If B is a subspace of C.(X) or C«X), M(B) is a boundary for B. PROOF. - If B is a subspace of C«X), and B. is the subspace of C.(X) consisting of the real parts of the functions in B, then M(B.) = M(B) and also any boundary for Br will be a boundary for B. Thus it suffices to consider the case of B a subspace of C.(X). The subset K of B* defined by
(6 1)
K =
jL: LeB*,
L(1) = IILI! = 1\
is convex and weak * compact. Choose any function h in B. Let Lo be a point of K with ILo(h)i= maxlIL(h)): L E K I, and Ko = I L: L e K, L(h) = Lo(h) I. By the Krein-Milman theorem, the compact convex set Ko has an extreme point. This extreme point must also be an extreme point of K. By Lemma 4. 3, sueh an extreme point will be of the form Ln LAf)=f(y),
for some y in M(B).
allfmB,
Since for each x in X, the Lx defined by
LAf) = f(x),
all fin B, 21.
126
&...0 ... , ... ,.&.1
IS In
..............
ua.........
__ ___ _
K, it follows from the choice of Ly that
Ilhll = =
max !lh(x)l: x e Xl max flL",(h)\ : x E Xl = iLy(h)1 = ih(Y)I·
Since y is a point of M(B), and h is an arbitrary function in B, M(B) is a boundary for B. Throughout the remainder of this section, A is a uniformly closed subalgebra of Cc(X) that distinguishes the points of X and contains the constant functions. It is well known that there is a smallest closed boundary for the algebra A, the Silov boundary (the Silov boundary has been related to extreme points in [1J, [2J and [5]). We are concerned here with boundaries that are smaller than the Silov boundary, and in particular with the question of whether if B = A, Lemma 6. 1 is the strongest result possible; i.e., whether any boundary for A must contain the Choquet boundary of A. We show that this is indeed so if each point of X is a Go, while we show in the general case that any boundary for A that is a Baire set must contain the Choquet boundary of A. In order to do this we must study two properties of points of X that are equivalent to being in M(A). \Ve shall say that a point x of X satisfies Condition I if for each open neighborhood U of X there is some f in A with
Ilfll< 1, If(x)1 > ~
and If(y)J<
~
for all y outside of U.
/
We shall say that a point x of X satisfies Condition II if for each closed set S containing x that is a Go, there is some function f III A with if(x)! = Ilfll and jy: If(Y)1
= IIfl15
c
S.
Note that if \ x I is a Gil, Condition II simply states that there is some f in A « peaking» at x. LEMMA
6. 2. -
PROOF. -
in A. Let U in Cr(X) with of U. Since ~(I xl) = 1.
If x is m M(A), x satisfies Condition I.
Let Ar be the subspace of real parts of functions be any neighborhood of x. Choose a function g 0 < g < 1, g(x) = 1 and g(y) = 0 for y outside M(A) = M(A,.), any [J. in H",(A r) must satisfy Thus by « 1 implies 2 » of Lemma 5. 1. applied
127
rHE
REPRESENTATIONS OF LINEAR
325
FUNCTIONALS
to S = !xj and B = Ar , there is some ho in Ar with ho < g log6 and ho(x) > logS' Let h= (logS) (ho -1). Since h is in A r ,
+
there is a k in Ar so that h ik is in A, and since A is a uniformly closed sub algebra, the function f defined by
f=
e(h+ik)
.is in A (the use of the exponential function at this point was suggested to us by H. Royden). It is simple to check that f satisfies the conditions wanted; i.e. Ilfll and
If(y)l~ ~ <
1
< 1,
If(x)l>
6
8 =
3
7;'
for y not in U.
LEMMA 6. 3. -- If x satisfies Condition I, it must satisfy
Condition I I. PROOF. - Let S be a closed Go containing x. Let r Vnl be a decreasing sequence of open sets with S = nV n' The construction of a function f in A with If(x)1 = Ilfll and
ly: If(y)1
= Ilflll
c
S
is identical with the construction in Theorem 2 of [4J, if the sets Dn(x) used in that construction are taken to be the X - V n' LEMMA 6. 4. -
If x satisfies Condition I I, it must be in M(A).
PROOF. - Let p. be in H,(A). Let S be any closed Go containing x. By Condition II there is an fin A with (6. 2)
,r
E
ly: If(y)1
= Ilfll!
c
S.
Since fJ.. is in Hx(A), f'f d:J. = f(x), which by (6. 2) is possible only if 1-'-(5) = 1. Thus by the regularity of p.., p..( Ixl) = 1, so x is in M(A). Thus we have established. THEOREM 6. 5. - Let x be a point of X. Then the following are equiIJalent: 10 x satisfies Condition I; 20 x satisfies Condition II; 30 X is in M(A). This equiIJalence for the case X metrizable is contained in [4J.
128
ERRETT
BISHOl' ET
KAHEL
COROLLARY 6. 6. - If each point smallest boundary for A.
DE
of
LEEUW
X is a Gil, M(A) is the
PROOF. - By Lemma 6. 1, M(A) is a boundary for A. By Condition II, at each point x of M(A) there is some f in A with
If(y) 1< If(x) \,
all y =1= x.
Thus any boundary for A must contain M(A). This result for X metrizable was established in [4J. COROLLARY 6. 7. - Let Y be any Baire subset of X that is a boundary for A. Then Y contains M(A). PROOF. - Suppa'll' on the contrary that there is some point x in M(A) that is 110t in Y. Then there is a closed set S containing x that is a G 0 and is disjoint from Y. By Condition I I there i~ an f in A with X
E
IY: [f(y)\ = Ilflll
c
S.
This f does not attain its maximum modulus on Y, contradicting the fact that Y is a boundary for A. It is however not true that M(A) is the intersection of all of the Baire boundaries for A, as can be seen from some of the examples in the next section. COROLLARY 6. 7. will now be used to show that if Y is any boundary for A, all linear functionals in A" can be represented as measures on Y. To establish this result we need first a lemma. LEMMA 6. 8. - Let Y be a boundary for A. Let fJ. be any Ar-maximal measure in H. If S is a Baire set disjoint from Y,
p.(S)
= o.
PROOF. - Since Y c X - S, the set X - S is a Baire boundary for A. By Corollary 6. 7, M(A) c X - S, so that S is disjoint from M(A). It follows from Theorem 5.3 that [1-(S) = O. THEOREM 6. 9. below now follows from Lemma 6. 8 in the same manner that Theorem 5. 5 follows from Theorem 5. 3. We omit the details.
129
~Hr; HEI'HESENIAl'IO:olS 01' LINCAH I'U'NCTIONALS
327
THEOREM 6. 9. Let Y be a boundary for A, and ~ the a-ring generated by Y and the Baire sets of X. Then each linear functional L in A'" has a representation of the form
(6. 3)
L(f)
=
J fdfJ-,
all
f
in A,
for fL a measure on :1 that satifies fJ-(T) = 0 for each T m :f that is disjoint from Y. Furthemwre the fJ- in (6. 3) can he chosen to be non-negatilJe if and only ~f L(l) = IILII·
VII. -
EXAMPLES
We present in this section a dass of examples showing that thr Choquet boundary, whieh must be a Go in the separable case, can be arbitrarilv bad in general. We al~o show that Theorems 5. J and 5.5 cannot be strengthened to assertiom about Borel sets rather than Baire sets. Finally there I'> a simple example which shows that the analogue of Theorem 6. 9 for subspaces rather than subalgebras is false. Let 1Y.c l.cEX be a family of disjoint non-empty topological spaces indexen by a topological space X. Let Y = yx
U
XE~
and 'it: Y -7 X be the projection map defined by 7t(y) = x if y is in Y". Let s: X ~ Y be a cross-section; i.e., 'its(.'r;) = :r for all x in X. We shall describe a topology \ .:alled the porcupine topology} for Y. Let 'tt be the class of all subsets U of Y that satisfy the following: there is some x in X so that U is an open subsrt of Y not containing s(x). Let:r be the class of all subsets S of Y that satisfy the following: there is some x in Y so that S is a closed subset of Y x not containing s(x). Let ttl be the class of all subsets of Y of the form 7t- l (V) - (SI U •.. uSn), where V is an open subset of X and the S, ar(~ in~. The collection 'U u qJ is closed under intersections and thus is the basis for a topology for Y. This is our porcupine topology. In this topology a net !ua.l of points in Y converges to a point y in Y:r - Is(x) I if and only if the net is ultimately in Y.J: and converges in the original topology of Y J: to y. If none of the Ua. are in Y x> ! ua.l converges to s(x) if and only if the net I
130
!n( Ua.) l converges to x in the topology of X. If X and the Y.z; are compact Hausdorff, then Y is compact Hausdorff. Suppose now that X and the Y x are compact Hausdorff. Let D be a subspace of Cr(X) and for each x in X, let Bx be a subspace of Cr(Y r)' Let B be the subspace of Cr(Y) consisting of all fin Cr(Y) such that f S is in D, and for each .1': in X, f restricted to Y x is in Bx. If D and all the 87: are closed subspaces and distinguish points, B will be a closed subspace and distinguish points. It is simple to check that the Choquet boundary M(B) of B is 0
(7. 1) We shall now consider a special cas(' of the above construction. Let X be an arbitrary compact Hausdorff sp8.ce and K an arbitrary subset of X. For each .'C in K, let Y x eomist of the one point S r, and for (,Heh .1' in X -K, let Y be the rliscrete topological space eonsisting of the three points rJ') Sec, tx;' Define s: X -?- Y by s (x) = S.c, all x III X. Let D be Cr(X), and if x is in K, let H.r = Cr(Y x)' If x is in X - K, let B be the suhspace of Cr(Y x) consisting of those f that satisfy 7
!
L
f(sJ')
1
= 2 (f(r,)
+ f(tx)).
The construction described above applied to D and the Bx yields a ('losed subspace B of Cr(Y) that distinguishes points. Its Choquet boundary is (7. 1) and is therefore easily seen to satisfy Y - M(B) = s(X - K). Since K was an arbitrary subset of X, this shows that the Choquet boundary can be arbitrarily bad. An example of a bad houndary has also been given by Choquet in [8J. Suppose now that in this example we take X to be the unit interval with the usual topology and K to be the void set. Let ') be Lebesgue measure on X, and let p. be the Baire measure on Y defined by
for all Baire subsets S of Y. Then fJ- is B-maximal. ~ever theless its regular Borel extension p. satisfies P.(M(B)) = O.
131
THE
REPRESENTATIONS
OF
LINEAR
FUNCflONALS
329
This is in contrast to Theorem 5. 3 which shows that a B-maximal measure must be (( concentrated on M(B) » In the sense that p.(S) = 0 for each Baire set S disjoint from M(B). The example shows that thc conclusion of the theorem cannot be strengthened to P.(S) being 0 for each Borel set S disjoint from M(B), even if M(B) itself is Borel. It also shows that the measures p. appearing in Theorem 5. 5 may not be regular. In order to obtain a morp stnkillg example, we take X to be the sub'let of the complex plane
X=rz:[z[<1j In the usual topology, and take K to be the set
K=;z:l z l<1l· For each x in K, let Y c consist of one point 8 c and for each 1: in X - K, let Y L be the discrete topological "pace consisting of the three points I r", 8 oX , and loX 1· Define 8: X ~ Y by s(x) = 8~, all x in X. Let D consist of all functions in Cr ( X) which are harmonic on K. If x is in K, let Bx = Cr (Y x). If x is in X - K, let Be be the sub'ipace of Cr( Y,,,) COIl'il!.tIng of those f that satisfy
The construction above applied to D and the Bx yields a closed subspace B of Cr(Y) that distinguishes points. Its Choquet boundary is easily seen by (7.1) to be M(B) = Y Let
Yo
be the point 8(0) =
So
8
(X).
of Y.
P.(M (B))
=
We shall prove that
0
for all p. in Hyo (B). To this end, WI' first note that the only compact subsets of M(B) are finite, by the definition of the topology on Y. It follows that in order to show that p. (M (B)) = 0, it will be sufficient to show that p. (I rx I) = P. t.e l) = 0 for each x in X K. :\ssllme tha t this is not the ca"e, so that
(r
132
330
ERRETT BISHOP ET KABEL DE LEEUW
p.( 1r:x, l) = C > 0, say, for some Xo in X - K. Let h be any non negative harmonic function on X with h(xo) > 1 and h (0) = C. Define the function ( in B by ((y)
Since p.
e
=
h(x), for all y in Y",.
H y " it follows that
Since also
((Yo)
=
this gIves a contradiction.
h(O)
=
C,
Thus
P.(M(B))
=
O.
This points up Theorem 5. 5, which states that there exists p. in H y , which can be extended to a measure on the cr-ring generated by M(B) and the Baire sets so as to have p.(M(B)) = 1. The point is that the extension of p. does not agree with the regular Borel extension p. of p.. The next example demonstrates that the analogue of Theorem 6. 9 for subs paces is false. Let X be the subset
Iz : Iz of the plane. the form
11
=
11
u Iz : Iz + 11 =
11
Let B be the space of all functions (on X of
((x, y)
=
ax
+ by + c,
(x, y) in X,
for a, band c real. Then each (in B that attains its maximum on X at p = (1, 1) also attains its maximum at (-1, 1), so X - Ip I is a boundary for B. However the linear functional L in B* defined by
L(f)
=
((p),
(
in B,
has no representation of the form
L(f)
= J(dp.,
(in B,
for p. a non-negative measure on X-) p l.
133
THE
REPRESENTATIONS
OF
LINEAR
FUNCTIONALS
331
BIBLIOGRAPHY [1 J R. ARENs and 1. SI"'IGER, Function values as boundary intcgrals, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., vol. 5 (1954), 735-745. [2J II. B \UER, Un probleme de Dirichlet pour la frontierc de Silov d'un espace compact, C. fl. Acad. Sci., Paris, vol. 247 (19;)8), pp. 843-846. [3J E. BISHOP, Some theorems concerning function algebras, Bull. Amer. _'lifath. Soc, vol. 85 (1959), pp. 77-78. [4) E. BISHUP. A minimal boundary for function algebras, to appear in Pacific. JOltr. "Vlath. [5] II. BOH'II::;>O!BLUSI and S. K'\RLIl'if, Geometrical prnpertif's of the unit sphrre of Banaeh algpbras, Ann. of Math., vol. 62 (1955), pp. 217-229 [oj ~. BouRB \KI, Integratwn, Elements de Afathemat~ques, XIII, Book VI, Paris, 195:2. [7J G. CHOQUET, Existence des representations integrales au moyen des points extremaux dans les cones convexes, C. R. Acad. Sc~., Paris, vul. 243 (1956), pp. 699-702. [8] G. CHOQUET, Existence de" representatiom integrale~ dam leq cones convexes, C. R. Acad. Sci., Paris, Vol. 24.3 (1956), 736-737. [9J G. CHOQUET, Existence et unicite des representations integrales. Seminaire Bourbak~, Decembre 1956, 139-01 a 139-15. [10J 1. GLICKSBERG, The representation of functionals by integrals, Duke Math. Jour., vol. 19 (1952), pp 253-261. [l1J P. H\.LMOS, l'lifeasure Theory, Van Nostrand, 1950. [12J R. KA..DISON, A representation theory for commutativc topological algebra, Mem. Amer. 1I.1ath. Soc., no 7. [13J J. KELLEY, General topology, Van Nostrand, 1957. 1. The topologicdl terminology is that of [11], and the measurc thcoretic terminology is that of [9].
134
7 .. ", oy permission or tne American MatnemanCBI :'OCI"'Y.
741
SIMULTANEOUS APPROXIMATION BY A POLYNOMIAL AND ITS DERIVATIVES ERRETT BISHOp!
1. Introduction. \Ve shall prove the following theorem: THEOREM. If fo is a continuous function on a compact set C w1thout interior and with connected complement of the complex plane, and tf flo ... , fn are continuous functions on a compact totally disconnected subset E of C, then there exists a sequence {Pi} of polynomwls such that pi-+fo uniformly on Cas i-+ ~ , and Pi[l.l-+fl. uniformly on E as i-+ ~ , for 1 ~ k ~ n, where ppl is the kth derivative of Pi.
For the case in which E is void, this reduces to a well-known theorem of Lavrentiev [3]. A different case of the problem of simultaneous approximation by a polynomial and its derivatives-the problem of simultaneous approximation on a Jordan arc-has been considered in a previous paper [1], by methods distinct from the methods of the present paper. \Ve make some preliminary remarks concerning distributions. The distributions in question will all be defined on the complex plane and have complex values and have a compact support. If T is such a distribution and if f is a function defined on the complex plane and having partial derivatives of all orders, then (f, T) will denote the Received by the editors March 26, 1958 and, in revised form, December I, 1958. This work was partially supported by the Office of Naval Research through Contract ONR 041 157. 1
135
742
ERRETT BISHOP
[October
value of Ton f. Thus if T is a measure ,tL we have (f, ,tL) = ffd,tL, and if T is an integrable function h we have (f, h) = ff(z)h(z)dxdy. By Schwartz [4, p. 70], we have (a/az*) [(7rZ)-1 * T] = T. 2. Proof of the Theorem. Let 11-0 be any measure on C, and let 11-1, ... , ,tLn be measures on E such that jpdl1-o+ jp[1Jd,tL1 + ... + jp[nJdl1-n = 0 for all polynomials p, where by measure we mean finite, complex-valued, Borel measure. If we let T be the distribution T= L~~1 (-l)k [a/az]kl1-k' it follows that the support of T is a subset of E and that (p, T + ,(.La) = 0 for all polynomials p. Define the distribution R = (7rZ)-1 * (T +11-0), so that (a/az*)(R) = T +,tLo. Also, R agrees on the complement of C with the analytic function cp(z) = ([7r(z - n ]-t, (T +,tLo)(n) of z. Since the complement of C is connected, for each z in the complement of C the function (z - n- 1 of can be uniformly approximated on som~ neighborhood of C by polynomials, so that the derivatives of (z-n- 1 will be uniformly approximated on some neighborhood of C by the corresponding derivatives of the approximating polynomials. Since T +11-0 is orthogonal to all polynomials, we see that cp therefore vanishes on the complement of C. Thus the support of R is a subset of C. Now (7rZ)-1 is clearly the sum of an integrable function CPl and a continuous function CP2. Since the measure 11-0 has compact support, CPl * 11-0 is an integrable function and CP2 *,tLo is a continuous function. (See [4].) Therefore (7rZ)-1 * 11-0 is a locally integrable function. Since also (7rZ)-1 * T agrees with an analytic function on the complement of E, the distribution R = (7rZ)-1 * 11-0+ (7rZ)-1 * T will agree with a locally integrable function h on the complement of E. Since R vanishes on the complement of C, h will vanish on the complement of C. Now let be any point in C-E, and letf be an infinitely differentiable function with compact support, such that fez) = 1 for all z in some neighborhood U of and such that the support H of f does not intersect E Then the distribution (aJjaz*)R is equal to the integrable function caf/az*)h = g, so that a(fR)/az* = (aflaz*)R +JaR/az* = g+f(T +11-0) = g+JI1-O, since H is disjoint from E. Since the support of h is a subset of C and the support of af/az* is a subset of H - U, the support of g is a subset of HnC- U. Thus the distribution g+fl1-o is a measure II on HnC which agrees with,tLo on all subsets of U. For any polynomial p, we have (p, II) = (p, a (fR)/az*) = -(ap/az*, fR)= -(0, fR)=O. Thus II is orthogonal to all polynomials. By the hypothesis of the theorem, HnC will have no interior and will have connected complement. By the theorem of Lavrentiev, any
r
r
r
136
APPROXIMATION BY A POLYNOMIAL
continuous function on HnC can be uniformly approximated by polynomials. Thus v is orthogonal to any continuous function on HnC, so that v=O. It follows that J.Lo vanishes on all subsets of the neighborhood U of r. Since r was an arbitrary point in C-E, J.Lo is therefore a measure on E. If D is any open and closed subset of E, there will exist, by Runge's theorem, a sequence {Pi} of polynomials converging uniformly to 1 on some neighboruood of D and to 0 on some neighborhood of E-D. Thus all derivatives pIt! will converge uniformly to 0 on E as i~ co. Thus we see that O=jpidjJ.o+jpll!dJ.Ll+ .. + jp\n!dJ.Ln-->jJ.o (D) as i--> co, so that J.Lo vanishes on all open and closed subsets of E. Since E is compact and totally disconnected, the open and closed subsets of E form a basis for the open sets of E (see [2, p. 20 ]). Therefore J.Lo=O. Thus jpdJ.Ll+jp[lldJ.L2+ ... +jpln-l]dJ.Ln=O for all polynomials p. By repeating the above argument, we can therefore show successively that J.Lo = J.LI = ... = J.Ln = o. Let V denote the Banach space consisting of all n+ 1-tuples (fo, ii, ... ,iT.)' where 10 is a continuous function on C and ik for 1 ~ k ~ n is a continuous function on E, under the norm (fo, . . . = in where lIikll is defined in the usual fashIOn. The dual V* of V then consists of all n + 1-tuples of measures (J.Lo, J.Ll, ••• , J.Ln), where J.Lo is a measure on C and J.Lk for 1 ~ k ~ n is a measure on E. We have just shown that the only element of V* which vanishes on all elements of Vof the form (p, p[lJ, . . . , pIn]), where p is a polynomial, is the zero element From the Hahn-Banach theorem it follows that any element in V is a limit of elements of the form (p, pl1], ••• , pIn]), and this is just the theorem.
II
Ilioll + ... +II II ,
,in)ii
BIBLIOGRAPHY 1. E. Bishop, Approximation by a polynomial and its derivatives on certain closed
sets, Proc. Amer Math. Soc vol 9 (1958) pp 94Cr-953 2. \V. Hurewicz and H. \Val1man, Dimension theory, Princeton, 1948. 3. M. Lavrentiev, Sur les fonetions d'une variable complex representable par des ,eries de polynomes, Actualites Sci. Ind., Paris, 1936. 4. L. Schwartz, Theorie des distributions, vol 2, Actualites Sci. Ind , Paris, 1951. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
137
~
I
..1,
pp. ,,;, 1 ~..1'+U
\..Opynglll
\bI
uUl\e UIlIVt=rsny
rr~bb
1
~OU.
BOUNDARY MEASURES OF ANALYTIC DIFFERENTIALS By ERRETT BISHOP
1. Introduction. We consider a compact set C in the complex plane with connected complement, and define a class H of analytic differentials on the interior U of C. In case C is the unit disk, for example, H will consist of all analytic differentials j(z)dz with f in the class HI (see Zygmund [7]). We also consider the class M of finite complex-valued Borel measures on the boundary B of C which are orthogonal to polynomials. Our main result, Theorem 3 below, will establish a natural one to one correspondence between Hand M. (Actually, Theorem 3 contains a somewhat more general result) If dw I: H, the associated Jl. in M is roughly describable as the boundary measure of the analytic dIfferential dw. The difficulty consists in showing that each Jl. in M is the boundary measure of some analytic differential dw in H. As a simple corollary of our main theorem, we shall derive Mergelyan's result (Theorem 4 below), that every continuous function on C which is analytic on U is uniformly approximable by polynomials. This paper is a sequel to a previous paper [1]. Many of the results needed here were established in [1] in somewhat less generality. Since the proofs of certain of these results carryover word for word to the more general case considered here, we do not give them in such detail as would otherwise be necessary.
2. The classes M and H. We now introduce the sets with which we shall be working, which are somewhat more general than the sets with connected complement mentioned above. DEFINITION 1. The compact set C in the complex plane will be called balanced if the boundary B of C equals the boundary of the unbounded component of - C. The open set U in the complex plane will be called balanced if U is bounded, if the closure C of U is balanced, and if U is the interior of C. The following lemma needs no proof. LEMMA 1. A compact balanced set has a balanced interior. An open balanced set is simply connected The union of any set of components of an open balanced set is an open balanced set.
By measure we always mean finite complex-valued Borel measure. We now define the class M. DEFINITION 2. Let C be a compact balanced set in the complex plane. The class M(C) is defined to be the class of all measures !J. on the boundary B of C such that
Received September 15, 1959. The author holds a Sloan Foundation Fellowship. 331
138
ERRETT BISHOP
J(t -
Z)-l dfJ.(t) = 0
for all z in - C. If U is an open balanced set whose closure is C, then M(U) is defined to be equal to M(C). It follows that f fdfJ. = whenever fJ. E M(C) and f is analytic in some neighborhood of C. The following lemma needs no proof.
°
LEMMA 2. If G is a compact balanced set in the complex plane and if V is the union of some set of components of the interz"or U of G, then MeV) C M(G). LEMMA 3. If G is a compact balanced set in the complex plane, if fJ. is in M(G), and if f is analytic in some neighborhood of G, then for each point z in the inter-ior U of C we have
J(t -
z)-lf(t) dfJ.(t)
= fez)
J(t -
Z)-l dfJ.(t)
Proof. The function g defined by get) = (t - Z)-l [f(t) - fez)] is analytic in a neighborhood of C. By the above remark we see that f gdp. = 0, from which the lemma follows. The following lemma is a slight generalization of Theorem 1 of [1]. LEMMA 4. Let G be a compact balanced set in the complex plane. be measured in M (C) such that
for all z in the
~·nterior
U of C. Then
fJ. =
Let
fJ.
and"
P.
Proof. By the definition of M(G), the measure X = p. - " in M(G) will be orthogonal to all rational functions whose poles lie in - B, where B IS the boundary of G. By a theorem of Mergelyan (see [4; 21]), every continuous function on B is uniformly approximable by such rational functions. (The hypotheses of this theorem of Mergelyan are satisfied because each point in B is in the boundary of the unbounded component of - B.) It follows that A is orthogonal to all continuous functions on B. Thus X = 0, as was to be proved. DEFINITION 3. Let U be a simply connected open set in the complex plane. A sequence hi I of compact subsets of U will be said to delimit U provided that (i) Each "Ii is the union of a finite number of disjoint rectifiable simple closed curves lying in U, no two of which belong to the same component of U, and (ii) If S is any compact subset of U, then for all i sufficiently large S will lie
in the union of the bounded components of - "Ii. We now define the class H (U), first remarking that an analytic differential dw on an open set U in the complex plane will mean a complex differential I-form on U of the type dw = f(z)dz, where f is an analytic function on U.
139
BOUNDARY MEASURES
333
DEFINITION 4. Let U be a bounded simply connected open set in the complex plane. The class lIeU) consists of all analytic differentials dw on U with the property that there exists a sequence bd of compact sets which delimit U and a positive constant K such that
Joy, I dw I <
K
for all values of i. If dw E lIeU), then II dw II will denote the greatest lower bound of all such constants K. If. U is connected, it is clear that lIeU) is conformally invariant. That is if II' is a one-to-one conformal map of U onto V, then lI(V) consists of all differentials of the form II' (dw) for dw E lIeU). It is also clear that then II dw II = 111P(dw) II. DEFINITION 5. Let U be a bounded simply connected open set in the complex plane, and let B be the boundary of U. A measure JI. on B is said to be a boundary measure of a differential dw in lIeU) if the sequence {'Y.} of Definition 4 can be chosen to have the additional property that
~,
h dw -)
J
h dJi.
as
t -)
<Xl
for all continuous functions h on U U B. The following lemmas need no proof. LEMMA 5. If JI. is a boundary measure of dw, then
II JI. II :::; II dw II.
LEMMA 6. Let U be a bounded simply connected open set and let r be the class of components of U. Let dw be an analytic dijJ·erential on U such that the restriction dwv of dw to V is m lI(V) for all V in r. Assume that Lv.r II dwv II < <Xl. Then dw
E
H(U)
and
II
dw
II :::;
L v.r
II dwv II·
The following theorem gives additional information about boundary measures. THEOREM 1. Let U be an open balanced set in the complex plane with closure C. Then any analytic dij)"erential dw m lIeU) has a boundary measure J.L, which is unique. The measure JI. belongs to M(U), and dw = f(z)dz is given in terms of JI. by the formula (*) for all z in U. Proof. Since dw E H(U), there exists a sequence bd which delimits U for which J"1' I dw I is bounded. By the weak * compactness of bounded closed sets in the space of measures on C, we see that there exists a measure JI. on C such that
1,
h dw -)
J
h dJi.
140
as
i -)
<Xl
334
ERRETT BISHOP
for all continuous functions h on G, where {a.} is some subsequence of {'Y.}. (This argument is given in detail in [1; 284].) It is clear that J.I. is actually a measure on the boundary B of U. By Definition 5, J.I. is therefore a boundary measure of dw. If z is any point in - G, then
J
(t - Z)-1 dJ.l.(t)
so that J.I.
(211"~rl
E
J
M(G)
=
M(U).
(t - Z)-1 dJ.l.(t)
= lim
fa. (t -
Z)-1 dw(t) =
0,
For all z in U we have
= lim (211"ifl
L
(t - Z)-1 dw(t)
=
lim (211"i)-1
L
(t - z)-lf(t) dt
= fez).
This proves the formula (*). N ow let 11 be another boundary measure for dw. Thcn formula (*) is valid with J.I. replaced by 11. Since both J.I. and 11 are in M(G), it follows from Lemma 4 that J.I. = 11 Thus J.I. is unique, as was to be proved. The following theorem is essentially Theorem 3 of [1], slightly generalized and supplemented by some additional remarks. THEOREM 2. Let G be a compact balanced set in the complex plane, and let J.I. be a measure ~'n M(G). Let the analytic dijJerential dw = f(z)dz on the interior U of G be defined by
(*)
for all z in U Let V be any component of U. is in H(V) and II dwv II :::; II J.I. II
Then the restriction dwv of dw to V
Proof. Let {J" I be a sequence of simple closed curvcf, surrounding G and converging to some compact set containing the boundary of C Let Zo be any point in V. Lct 'Pn be the Hiemann map of the interior of J n onto D = {w: I w i < I}, normalized by the conditions 'Pn(ZO) = 0 and 'P~(zo) > O. Let 'P be the Riemann map of V onto D, normalized in the same way. By a theorem of Caratheodory [3], {'Pn I converges uniformly to 'P on compact subf,ets of V. Since J.I. is in M(C) ann. 'Pn is analytic on a neighborhood of C, from (*) and Lemma 3 we have
for all z in V. Let lin be the measure 'P,,(J.I.) on D defined by lIn(S) = J.I.('P;:'(S)), so that II lin II :::; II !J. II. By substituting w = cp,,(z) in the cquation just derived, we obtain
141
BOUNDARY MEASURES
335
for all w in rp,,(V). Let v be any weak'" cluster point of the sequence I v" I, so that v is a measure on Iw: I wi = 11 with II v 11:$ 1111-11. It is clear that each v"' and therefore v, is orthogonal to polynomials in w. Passing to the limit in the last equation, we obtain
(271"i)-1
(**)
for
Iw I <
1, where g(w)
J
(t - W)-l dv(t) = g(w)
= t(rp-l(W)) [drp-l(W)/dw].
Since the measure v is orthogonal to all polynomials, it follows from the classical theory (which is quoted on page 283 of [1]) that v is the boundary measure of some analytic differential d{3 in H(D) and that II v II = II d{3 II By (*"'), ,ve see that d{3 = g(w)dw From the fact that H(D) is conform ally invariant, it follows thatrp-l(d{3) EH(V) Butrp-l(d{3) = rp-l(f(rp-l(W))drp-l(W)) = f(z)dz = dwv. Thus dwl' E H(V) and II dwv II = II d{3 II = II v II :$ II Jl. II, as was to be proved. 3. The main theorems. vVe come now to that part of the paper which extends the results of [1] in an essential manner. LEMMA 7. Let C be a compact balanced set 1'n the complex plane. Let U be the interior of C and let V be the union of some set r of components of U. Then there exists a sequence If d of functions analyt~c in some neighborhood of C such that
(a) I Mz) I :$ 1 for all Z 1'n C, (b) (fkl converges uniformly to 0 on compact subsets of V, and (c) Ifd converges uniformly to 1 on compact subsets of U - V. Proof· It is clearly sufficient to consider the case in which V consists of a single component of U, since the general case will then follow by taking products and using the diagonal process Let Zo be any point in V. As in the proof of Theorem 2, let I J"I be any sequence of simple closed curves surrOLlIlding C and converging to some compact set containing the boundary B of C. Let rpn be the Riemann map of the interior of J" onto D = f w I w I < 11 with rpn(zo) = 0 and rp~(zo) >. O. Let rp be the Riemann map of V onto D, normalized in the same way, so that {cp,,1 converges uniformly to rp on compact subsets of V. Since the functions {CPn} are uniformly bounded on each component TV of U, we may assume, by passing to a subsequence if necessary, that {cp,.} converges uniformly on compart subsets of lV, for each component TV of U. Since cp,,(TV) is disjoint from cp,,( V), for TV ~ V, and since cp,,( V) e\"entually fills all of D, it follows that the limit of {rp,,} 011 TV has modulus everywhere 1. Thus f cp" I converges uniformly on compact subsets of W to a constant IX" of modulus I. N OIV for any finite set r of components of U, not containing V, and any f > 0,
142
.J!,j11.1'tl'.lr.L D10nvr
and any positive number K, we can find a positive integer N such that N > K and l(aw)N - 1 I < E for all Win r. (see [5; 132]). If S is any compact subset of U, this means that we can choose L such that
I (CPn(Z»N
- 1
I<
E
for all n > L and all Z in S (\ Uw.rW. Since sup {I cp(z)l: z we can also choose K and n so large that
I (cp'(Z)N I <
E
S (\ V}
<
1,
E
for all z in S (\ V. It follows that a sequence If k I can be constructed having properties (a), (b), and (Cl') where (cr) is the property (er) ltd converges uniformly to 1 on compart subsets of U WEl W. Since this is true for each r, and since U has a denumerable number of components, it follows by the diagonal process that a sequence ''lith properties (a), (b), and (c) can be constructed. LEMMA 8. Let C be a compact balanced set and let /Jo be a measure in M(C). Define the analytic differential dw = f(z)dz on the interior U of C by
(*)
for all z in U. For each component W of U let /Jow be the boundary measure of the difJerential dww obtained by restricting dw to W. The existence of /Jow is guaranteed by Theorems 1 and 2. Then II Lr/Jow II ::; II /Jo II, where the summation is taken over any finite subset r of components of U. Proof. Let V be the union of those components of U which are not in r. By Lemma 7, there exists a sequence It.d of functions analytic in some neighborhood of C and having properties (a), (b), and (c) above. Let Ilk be the measure fk/Jo, defined by IIk(S) = Is fkd/Jo. Thus Ilk t M(C) and II Ilk II ~ II )Jo11. Let II be any weak* limit point of the sequence {Vk} so that II II II ~ II /Jo II. For z in U. the quantity (**) is a limit point of the sequence whose terms are (21rtl- 1
J
(t - Z)-1 dVk(t) = (2mrl
J(t -
z)-IMt) dp,(t)
= Mz)f(z), by Lemma 3, so that a(z) = 0 if z E V and a(z) = fez) if z E U - V. Since p,w is a measure in M(W), we have, on the other hand,
143
337
BOUNDARY MEASURES
depending on whether that
Z E
War
(271"~")-1
(***)
Z E
f
U - W. If we write u
=
Lrlo'w , it follows
(t - Z)-I duet) = a(z)
for all z in U. Now Io'w E M(G) by Lemma 2. It follows that u E M(G). By Lemma 4 it follows from (**) and (***) that u = JI. Hence II u II = II JI II ~ II JJ. II, as was to be proved. LEMMA 9. Let U be a connected balanced open set, and let JJ. be in M(U). Then {i) JJ. is a measure on the set P of accessible boundary points of U, in the sense that there exists a Borel subset G of P such that JJ.(S) = JJ.(G S) for all Borel sets S and (ii) JJ. vanishes on points.
n
Proof. Assume first that the complement of the closure G of U is connected. It follows from Lemma 1 and Theorem 4 of [1] that there exists a measure JI .on the set F = {w: I w I = I} which is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure, a Borel function von F with values in P such that JJ. = v(JI), where the measure v(JI) is defined by v(JI)(S) = JI(v-I(S)) for all Borel sets S. The proof of Lemma 1 of [1] shows that there also exists a sequence {Tn! of dosed subsets of F such that T = UTn contains almost all points of F, and such that v is one-to-one on T and continuous on each Tn. Thus v(Tn) is compact, so that G = veT) is a Borel subset of P. It follows that JJ.(S) = JI(v-I(S)) = JI(v-I(S) n V-I (G)) ,
since T C v-leG) and since T contains almost all points of F relative to Lebesgue measure, and therefore relative to JI. But
JI(v-I(S) n v-leG)) = JI(v-I(S n G)) = JJ.(S n G),
n
so that JJ.(S) = JJ.(S G) for all Borel sets S. Thus JJ. is a measure on P. If z is any point, the set V-I ( {z J) T consists of at most one point, because v is
n
n
.one-to-one on T. We therefore have JJ.({z)) = JI(v-1({z)) T) = 0, since JI is absolutely continuous Thus JJ. vanishes on points. In the general case, when - G is not necessarily connected, the proof proceeds as follows. Lemma 1 and Theorem 4 of [1] are first proved for the general case. These proofs are word for word the same as the proofs given in [1]. This having been done, the remainder of the proof is exactly the same as the proof just given of the special case. This completes the proof of Lemma 9. LEMMA 10. Let U be a balanced open set and let V and W be components of U. Let dw be £n H(V) with boundary measure JJ. and let da be in H(W) with boundary measure JI. Then JJ. and II are mutually singular.
Proof. Assume that JJ. and JI are not mutually singular. Since JJ. is a measure .on the set P of essential boundary points of V and JI is a measure on the set Q of essential boundary points of W, and since both JJ. and II vanish on points, it
144
uuu
.l!.iIUt.r...J..l. luOnut
follows that P n Q is infinite. Let Zo and z, be distinct points of P n Q. There exists a simple arc J, whose interior lies in V and whose endpoints are Zo and z, , because Zo and z, are accessible. There similarly exists a simple arc J. whose interior lies in Wand whose endpoints are Zo and Z,. Thus J = J] U J~ is a simple closed curve lying in C Let L be the interior of J. Since no point in L is in the unbounded component of - C, and since C is balanced, we see that no point in L is in the boundary B of C It follows that L lies entirely in C. Since L is conneeted and clearly contains poilJt~ of both U and V, this is a contradiction. Therefore fJ. and II are mutually singular, as was to be proved. We now prove the main theorem. ThEOREM 3. Let C be a compaci balanced set with interior U. Define the mapping from H(U) to AJ(C) by u(dw) = fJ., where fJ. is the boundary measure for d:.J. Then u is a one-to-one map of H(U) onto JlJ(C) and II dw II = [I u(dw) [I for each dw in H(U). (J"
Proof. We first remark that u(dw) is actually in JI(C) for each dw in H(U), because M(U) C M(C) by Lemma 2 and u(dw) £ 111(U) by Theorem 1. By Theorem I, we see that the map (J" i~ one-to-om' To finish the proof, we must show that any fJ. in M(C) is the image of some dw in H(e) and that [I dw II = II!J. [t To this end, consider an arbitrary !J. in M(C) Define the analytie differential dw = j(z)dz on U by t(z) = (211'i) -]
(*)
J
(t - z) -1 dfJ.(t).
We shall prove that dw £ lIeU), that u(dw) = fJ., and that I! dw [[ = [[ fJ. [I, thus completing the demonstration of the theorem. Let r denote the set of components of U, and for each V in r let dwv be the restriction of dw to V. By Theorem 2, dwv £ H(V). Let fJ.v be the boundary measure of dwv. By Theorem 1, we see that}Lv £ M(V) and (**)
for all z in V If we apply Theorem 2 to the measure fJ.v in AI(V) C M(C), \\e therefore have [[ dw y II ~ II }Lv II· Sinee the measures!J.V are mutually singular, by Lemma 10, we have
II L
!J.v
Vdl
for every finite subset n of
L
II
dwv
r.
II ~
II
=
L II !J.v II YEn
It follows from Lemma 8 that
II
L
all sums being taken over V in
L
ILv
II
=
II
L}Lv
n. Thus we have
v.r
1\
dwv
II ~ IIIL II·
145
II ~ I[ IL II,
339
BOUNDARY MEASURES
It follows from Lemma 6 that dw Thus II £ M(C) and
(***)
fez)
=
£
R(U) and
J
(2nr 1
(t -
II dw II Z)-l
~
II Jl. I.
Write
II
= u(dw).
dll(t)
for all z in U, by Theorem 1. Because of (*) and (***), it follm,s from Lemma 3 that II = Jl.. Thus Jl. = u(dw) and II dw II ~ II f.l II· But II Jl. il ~ II dw II by Lemma 5. This completes the proof We now derive Mergelyan's approximation theorem for sets which do not separate the plane. THEOREM 4 (Mergelyan). Let C be a compact set with connected complement in the complex plane Let f be a contmuous function on C whlch is analytw on the interior U of C Then f can be uniformly approximated on C by polynomials Proof. Assume the contrary. It follows that f cannot be uniformly appro>..imated on the boundary B of C by polynomials There therefore exists a measure Jl. on B which is orthogonal to all polynomials, but not orthogonal to f. Since
Jl. is orthogonal to polynomials and since - C is connected, we see that M(C). By Theorem 3, there exists dw in H(U) such that Jl. is the boundary measure of dw. By Definition .5, it follows that there exists a bequence (-y,} Jl. £
of compact subsets of U ,,,hich delimits U such that
I.
h dw
---7
J
h dp.
as i
---7 00
for all continuous functionb h on C. Applied to the function f, this gives
1f
dp. = lim
1'"1' f dw =
0,
since fdw is an analytic differential on U. This eontradietb the fact that not orthogonal to f, thereby proving the theorem
Jl. IS
4. Remarks. 1. We have relied heavily, in proving Lemma 4, on Mergelyan's approxi-
mation theorem ([4, 21]) for approximation by rational functiom, on compact sets without iuterior Lemma 4 could be proved equally ,yell by appeal to the general approximation theorem announced ab Theorem 4 of [2] and to a cIabsical theorem of Wah;h [6] on approximation by harmonic functionb. The author wishes to take thib opportunity to point out that Theorem 5 of [1] ib a special case of this theorem of Walsh II. ''Ye have derived Theorem 4 as a bimple consequence of Theorem 3 This raises the question of whether, for a compact set C with connected complement, Theorem 3 can be derived from Theorem 4 That is, it might be suspected that Theorem 3 and Theorem 4 are equivalent, Theorem 3 being a reinterpretation
146
O":l:U
ERKE'rI' HII:!J::lUr
in the dual space of Theorem 4, This does not seem to be the case, so that Theorem 3 represents an essential strengthening of Theorem 4. III. It is natural to ask whether the analog of Theorem 3 holds for more general sets C, provided that H(U) and M(C) are defined appropriately. This seems to be a difficult question. It is clear that some hypotheses on Care necessary. REFERENCES
1. E. BISHOP, The structure of certain measures, this Journal, vol. 25(1958), pp. 283-289. 2. E. BISHOP, Some theorems concerning function algebras, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, vol. 65(1959), pp. 77-78. 3. C. CARATHEODORY, Conformal Repre8entation, Cambridge, 1952. 4. S. N. MERGELYAN, Uniform approximation to functions of a complex variable, American MathamaticaI Society Translation no. 101, 1954. 5. O. PERRON, Irrationalzahlen, New York, 1951. 6. J. L. WALSH, The approximation of harmonic functions by harmonic polynomials and by harmonic rational functions, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, vol. 35(1929), pp. 499-544. 8. A. ZYGMUND, Trigonometrical Series, New York, 1955. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY
147
A GENERALIZATION OF THE STONE-WEIERSTRASS THEOREM ERRETT BISHOP
1. Introduction. Consider a compact Hausdorff space X and the set C(X) of all continuous complex-valued functions on X. Consider also a subset ~ of C(X) which is an algebra, which is closed in the uniform topology of C(X), which contains the constant functions, and which contains sufficiently many functions to distinguish points of X. Such an algebra ~ is called self-adJ'oint if the complex conjugate of each function in %( is in~, The classical Stone-Weierstrass Theorem states that if 21 is self-adjoint then ~l = C(X). If ~ has the property that the only functions in ~I which are real at every point of X are the constant functions then 21 is called anti-symmetric. Clearly antisymmetry and self-adjointness are opposite properties, in the sense that if ~ has both properties then X must consist of a single point. Hoffman and Singer [2] have studied these two properties and given several interesting examples. The present paper was inspired by their work but it more directly relates to a previous paper of Silov [3]. The purpose of the present paper is to prove the following decomposition theorem for a general algebra ~ of the type defined above. THEOREM. There exists a partition P of X into disjoint closed sets such that ( i) for each S in P the restriction ~s of '2{ to S is anti-symmetric, (ii) if a function f in C(X) has, for each S in P, a restriction to S which belongs to 2l s , then f is in ~, (iii) for each S in P, each closed subset T of X - S, and each c > 0 there exists g in ~l with II g II ;£ 1, with Ig(x) -- 11 < c for x in S, and with Ig(x) I < c for x in T.
Property (ii) of this theorem is the essential new fact of this paper. ,!,he construction given below which leads to the partition P is due to Silov [3], who in essence proved (i) and (iii). Silov proved a weaker property than (ii). Our proofs are different from those of Silov, although the construction is the same. The fact that the Stone-Weierstrass theorem is a special case of the theorem to be proved here is clear. If 21 is self-adjoint then each ~s is self-adjoint. Since ~s is also anti-symmetric, each set S in P consists of a single point. Therefore ~s = C(S). By the theorem to Received June 15, 1960,
777
148
778
ERRETT BISHOP
be proved, it follows that each function in C (X) is in Ill. Thus III = C (X), which is the conclusion of the Stone-Weierstrass Theorem. 2.
Proof of the theorem.
The key step in the proof will be the
following lemma. LEMMA. Let Y be a compact Hausdor.tf space and lB be a subalgebra of C (Y) which contains the constant functions. Let ~ be all real functions in lB. Define Yl 0= y" for Y, and Y2 in Y, to mean that f(Y,) = f(Y2) for all fin !H. Let Q be the set of all equivalence classes for this equivalence relation, so that Q is a partition of Y into disjoint closed sets. Let p. be a finite complex-valued Baire measure on Y and f a function in C (Y) such that
(a)
11p.11~1,
(b)
}gdP.
=
0
(c)
} fdp.
*-
O.
for all g in )S,
Then there exists So in Q and a finite complex-valued Baire measure
lJ on So such that (a,) IllJ II ~ 1, (b,) ~ gdlJ = 0 for all g in ~\ (c,)
In
\
~fdlJ \ ~ \ ~fdP. \.
Proof. It is clearly no loss of generality to assume that)S is closed C (Y). Let 'Y = {gil be a finite set of functions in ~ such that gi ~ 0 for all i,
Xg i = 1 . Let r denote the class of all such 'Y. by writing
Define a partial ordering on
r
{g;} ~ {gil
if there exists a mapping rp of the set of indices j onto the set of indices i such that
for all i. To see that r is a directed set relative to this partial ordering, let {gil and {gil be any two elements of r. Then the set {giga is clearly a common successor of {gil and {gil. Consider 'Y = {gil in r. For each index i let P.i be the measure
149
A GENERALIZATION OF THE STONE WEIERSTRASS THEOREM
779
defined by
for each Baire subset H of S.
Clearly
and kdfl
=
~ ~fdfli .
Thus for at least one value of i with
II fl. II*-O we have
Choose such a value of i and write
It follows that
(a) and (fj)
By the compactness in the weak* topology of the unit sphere of the set of Baire measures on X, it follows that the net {fly} has a cluster point ); in the weak" topology. Let Xo be any point in the support of the measure );, and let So be that member of the partition P which contains Xo. Let X, be any point in X - So. Thus there exists ho in :R with hoexo) *- hoCx,). Let
If the real constants
C,
and
C2
are chosen properly then
It follows that there exists a neighborhood Uo of Xo and a neighborhood U, of X, such that h,(x)
< t,
and
150
X €
Uo
Let A. be continuous real-valued function on the range of h, with 0 ~ A, ~ 1, ;>.,(t) = 0 for t ~ t, A.(t) = 1 for t ~ t. By the Weierstrass approximation theorem, ;>.,(t) is a uniform limit of polynomials in t. Therefore the function h. = A.oh, IS III m. Clearly 0 ~ h. ~ 1, h,(x) = 0 for x in U o, and h,(x) = 1 for x in U,. Define g, = h. and g, = 1 - h.. so that {gJ E r. If 'Y = {gj} is an element of r which follows {g;}, then each vanishes on either Uo or U,. Therefore the support of f1~ is either a subset of X - Uo or of X - U,. Thus the support of v is either a subset of X - Uo or X - U,. By the choice of x o, it follows that the support of v cannot be a subset of X - Uo and is therefore a subset of X - U,. Therefore x, is not in the support of v. Since X, was any point in X - So, it follows that the support of v is a subset of So. Thus v is a Baire measure on So. It is clear from the definition of v and from (0:) and (,8) that (a I) and (e,) are valid. It only remains to prove (b,). Now for each g in )B and each 'Y in r we have
g:
by (b) and the fact that ggi E)B. Passing to the limit gives (b,). This completes the proof of the lemma. Let Q be the class of ordinal numbers whose cardinal numbers are less than or equal to 2~, where f3 is the cardinal number of X. For each (J in Q we define ):)y transfinite induction a partition Pa- of Q into disjoint closed sets. This is to be done in such a way that P u is a refinement of P, for (J > T. The definition is started by defining P, = {Xl'. so that the first partition P, consists of the set X alone. Assume that P, has been defined for all ordinals T < (J. If (J has a predecessor (Jo, let S be any element of P Uo ' and let l! be the set of all functions in ~l which are real on S. Partition S by defining X, == x, for X, and x. in S to mean that !(x,) = !(x,) for all ! in~. Clearly S is partitioned into disjoint closed sets by this equivalence relation. The totality of all sets into which the elements S of PUo are partitioned in this way is defined to be the class P u • If (J has no predecessor, define X, == X 2 , for X, and x. in X, to mean that X, and x. belong to the same element of P, for all T < (J. The equivalence classes of this equivalence relation clearly form a partition P u of X into disjoint closed sets. Thus the classes P u are defined for-
151
A GENERALIZATION OF THE STONE WEIERSTRASS THEOREM
781
all a in Q, and it is clear that P u is a refinement of P whenever a > r. Assume that PU + 1 is a proper refinement of P u for all a in Q, i.e., that P U - 1 -=1= P u • Then P u +! contains a set not in any p. for r < a + 1. Therefore the cardinal number of subsets of X is at least equal to the cardinal number of the set Q. This contradicts the choice of Q. Therefore there exists an ordinal in p such that Pp+! = Pp. We shall show that the partition P = P r satisfies all requirements of the theorem. The fact (i) that 'lls is anti-symmetric for each S in P = Pp is a consequence of the fact Pp = Pr+!. We next prove (ii). Consider to this end f in C(X) such that the restriction of f to S belongs to 'lls for all S in P. Assume that f is not in '2l. By the Hahn-Banach theorem, there exists a bounded linear functional on C(X) which vanishes on m and does not vanish at f. By the Riesz representation thaorem, this functional can be realized as a measure I'- on X. Thus T
~gdl'- = Vdl'-
0 ,
gem
*0.
we may clearly assume that II I'- II ~ 1. We now construct, by transfinite induction, a set Su in P u for each a in Q and a finite complex-valued Baire measure I'-u on Su with
(1)
Su c S-
(2)
I kdl'-u I ~ I kdl'-i
(3)
Ii I'-u II ~ 1 ,
(4 )
~gdl'-" =
for
0,
T
,
'
all g in
~r.
Clearly the measure 1'-, = fl does the trick for a = 1. Assume therefore that the sets S. and the measures p. have been constructed for all r < a. If a is a limit ordinal, let
and let I'-er be any cluster point in the weak* topology of the net {I'-.}-<er. Clearly this set Ser and the measure I'-u do the trick. If a is not a limit ordinal, then there exists r with a = r + 1. Let Y be S. and let )J3 be the restriction to Y of the algebra Ilt. By the above lemma, applied to the measure 1'-" there exists a finite complexvalued Baire measure fl" on some Su e P u, with ST c Y = Sq, such that
(3)
II I'-er [I
(4)
~gdl'-er=O,
~
1, all g in
~
152
782
ERRETT BISHOP
(2)
I ~fdp" I ~ ! VdPr I ~ If d Pl
.
Thus the set S" and the measure P" do the trick. This completes the construction of the sets S" and the measures fl.". For a = p we have
and ~gdPp = 0 for all g in~. Therefore the restriction of f to Sp is not in ~sp. This contradicts the assumption of (ii), thereby proving that f is in 21. This proves (ii). It remains to prove (iii). To do this we prove by induction on a that for each a in Q, each S in P", each closed subset T of X - S, and each c > 0 there exists g in ~ with II g II ~ 1, I g(x) - 11 < c for all x in S, and I g(x) I < c for all x in T. Once this is done (iii) is obviously obtained by letting a equal p. Since the existence of g is clear if a = 1, consider a > 1 and assume that all smaller values of a have been disposed of. If a is a limit ordinal, there exists T < a and R in P. with S c R and T c X - R. By the induction hypothesis, there exists g in I2l: with II g II ~ 1, I g(x) - 11 < c for all x in R, and I g(x) I < c for all x in T. Since S c R this function g has the required properties. It remains to consider the case of an ordinal a which has a predecessor T, so that a = T + 1. Let R be that element of P, for which S cR. Let ~ be the closure in C(R) of I2l: R • Let x, be any point in Sand Xo any point in Tn R. By the definition of the partition P" there exists h, in I2l: such that the restriction of h, to lR is real and such that h,(x o) *- h,(x,). Let A. be a function on h,(R) with 0 ~ A. ~ 1, A.(h,(xo)) = 0, A.(h,(x,)) = 1. Define the function h. in C(R) by Since A. is a uniform limit of polynomials, h. E~. Clearly II h211 ~ 1, h 2(x O) = 0, and h 2(x,) = 1. Thus h 2(x) = 1 for all x in S. By the compactness of Tn R, the product of a certain finite number of such functions h2 will be a function hg in ~ with II hgll ~ 1, hg(x) = 1 for x in S, I hg(x) I < S for x in Tn R, where S is an arbitrarily small positive number. By the definition of ~, there exists h. in I2l: with
for all x m R.
so that h5
E
12l:.
Define
Also
153
A GENERALIZATION OF THE STONE WEIERSTRASS THEOREM
783
for all x in R. Thus there exists an open set Uo c X with R c Uo such that I h.(x) I < 1 for all x in Uo• If 15 is sufficiently small it is clear that
I h.(x)
-
11 < ~ 2
for all x in 8 and
I h.(x) I < e for all x in T n R. Thus there exists an open set UI in X with Tn R c UI such that I h.(x) I < e for all x in UI • By the induction hypothesis at stage T there exists h6 in ~ with II h611 ~ 1, I h 6(x) - 11 < e/2 for x in R,
for all x in X - Uo, and
I h6(X) I < min {e I h5(X) I-I:
W
x e T -
UI }
,
for all x in T - UI • Define g = h5h6' so that g e~. For x in Uo we have I h.(x) I ~ 1, so that I g(x) I ~ 1 since II h611 ~ 1. For x in X - Uo we have I g(x) I ~ 1 because of H. Thus II g II ~ 1. For x in 8 we have I h6 (x) - 11 < e/2 and I h.(x) - 11 < e/2, so that
I g(x)
-
11
~
I h (x) II h.(x) 6
-
11 + I ho(x)
-
11 < e •
For x in U1 we have I h 5(x) I < e, so that I g(x) I < e since II hall ~ 1. For x in T - U1 we have W, so that I g(x) I < e. Thus I g(x) I < e for all x in T. Thus g has all of the required properties. This completes the proof of (iii) and thereby the proof of the theorem. We note in conclusion that property (iii) and some results to be found in [1] imply that ~s is closed in C(8) for each 8 in P. REFERENCES 1 H. S. Bear, Some boundary properties of function algebras, Proc Amer Math Soc, 11 (1960), 1-4. 2 K Hoffman and 1. Singer, On some conjectures of Gelfand (in Russian), Uspehi Math Nauk (N S), 14 (1959), 99-114 3. G E. Silov, On rings of functions with uniform convergence (in Russian), Ukrainian Math Journal, 3 (1951), 404-411
154
by permission of the American Mathematical Society
A PROOF THAT EVERY BANACH SPACE IS SUBREFLEXIVE BY ERRETT BISHOP AND R. R. PHELPS
Communicated by Mahlon M. Day, August 19, 1960
A real or complex normed space is subrefiexive if those functionals which attain their supremum on the unit sphere S of E are normdense in E*, i.e., if for each f in E* and each E > 0 there exist g in E* and x in S such that I g(x) I = Ilgll and Ilf - gil < E. There exist incomplete normed spaces which are not sub reflexive [1] 1 as well as incomplete spaces which are subreflexive (e.g, a dense subspace of a Hilbert space). It is evident that every reflexive Banach space is subreflexive. The theorem mentioned in the title will be proved for real Banach spaces; the result for complex spaces follows from this by considering the spaces over the real field and using the known isometry between complex functionals and the real functionals defined by their real parts. We first cite a lemma which states, roughly, that if the hyperplanes determined by two functionals f and g (of norm one) are nearly parallel, then one of IIf-gll. IIf+gll must be small.
LEMMA. Suppose E is a normed space and E>O. If f, gEE*, Ilfll = 1 =llgll, are such that Ig(x)1 ~E/2 whenever f(x) =0 and Ilxll ~1, then Ilf-gil ~E or Ilf+gll ~E.
A proof of the lemma may be found in [2, Lemma 3.1]. To prove the theorem suppose fEE* and E>O. We may assume that Ilfll = 1; by the lemma, we want to find gin E* such that I g(x) I ~ 1 for all x in T= {x:f(x) =0 and Ilxll ~2cq, and for which there exists x in S such that g(x) = 1 = Ilgll. Let C be the convex hull of the union ofI the sets T and U = {x: Ixii ~ 1}, and suppose there exists Xo in U which is also in the boundary of C. Since C has nonempty interior, by the support theorem there exists g in E*, Ilgll = 1, such that 1 An easily described example has been suggested by Y. Katznelson: Let E be the space of all polynomials on [0, I), with the supremum norm. (The example in [1] shows clearly how the method of proof given below fails without the assumption of completeness.)
97
155
98
ERRETT BISHOP AND R R. PHELPS
sup(g(x):xEcl =g(xo). It follows that g(xo)=l=l!xoll, so that the lemma applies and the theorem is proved. Thus, it remains to show that Unbdry Cis nonempty. To this end, choose z in U such that f(z»O and let K=(f(Z»-1(1+2c 1 ). Define a partial ordering on the set Z= {xE U:f(x) ~f(z) 1 as follows' Say that x>y if
(i) (ii)
f(x)
IIx - yll
> fey)
and
~ K[j(x) - fey)].
Suppose that W is a totally ordered subset of Z; by (i), the net of real numbers IJCx): xE is (bounded and) monotone, and hence converges to its supremum. From (ii) it follows that W is a Cauchy net; by the completeness of E, W converges to a point y in U. By the continuity of f and the norm it follows that y is an upper bound for W. Thus, by Zorn's lemma, there eXIsts a maximal element Xo of Z; since xoE uec, we need only show that xoEbdry C. If not, then Xo is in the interior of C, and there exists a> 0 such that xo+azE C. From the definition of C we see that there exist y in U, x in T and A in [0,1] such that xo+az=Ay+(1-A)X. Thenf(z) ~f(xo) Xo, a contradiction which completes the proof. A possible generalization of this theorem remains open: Suppose E and F are Banach spaces, and let £(E, F) be the Banach space of all continuous linear transformations from E into F, with the usual norm. For which E and F are those such that = II (for some x in E, II xii = 1) dense in £(E, F)? This is true for arbitrary E if F is an ideal in m(A) (the space of bounded functions on the set A, with the supremum norm). Added in proof: If C is a bounded closed convex set, let C' = IJEE* :f(x) = sup lJ(y): yE for some x in C A slight modification of the above argument shows that C' is dense in E*. This solves a problem proposed by Klee in Math. Z. vol. 69 (1958) p. 98.
wl
Ily-xoll (1-A)lly -xii
(l-A)(lIyll +llxll)
T
cl
(1-A)(1
II Til
Txll
I.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. R. R. Phelps, Subreflexive normed linear spaces, Arch. Math. vol. 8 (1957)
pp 444--450 2. - - , A representation theorem for bounded convex sets, Proc Amer Math. Soc., to appear. UNIVERSITY OF C~LIFORNIA, BERKELEY
156
MAPPINGS OF PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.· By
ERRETT
BISHOP.
1. Introduction. We study a mapping f of a partially analytic space K into n-dimensional complex affine space Cn. A partially analytic space K is a Hausdorff topological space which is a countable union of conditionally compact open sets, which is locally connected, and which is endowed, at least partially, with an analytic structure. This means that a countable family {Ma} of subsets of K is given, each with the structure of a complex analytic manifold. An algebra ~ of continuous functions on K, called the analytic functions on K, is also given, with the property that each function in ~ is analytic on each "Ma. The algebra ~r is closed in the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of K. The coordinates of the mapping fare required to lie in~. The purpose of this paper is to show that for certain spaces K the mapping f can be chosen to have certain properties. For instance, sufficient conditions are given for there to exist an f which is proper, or which separates points, or which has a certain rank at certain points. Since the complex spaces of Cartan [4J or Behnke and Stein [2J can be thought of as partially analytic spaces, these results apply to complex spaces. 1 Theorem 1 is concerned with the dimensions of the level sets of the mapping f. The statement of Theorem 1 is somewhat complicated; a special case reads as follows. If the level sets of ~ intersect each Ma in a countable set, then f can be chosen so that the level sets of f intersect each Ma in a set of (complex) dimension at most max {d a - n, O}, where da - dim M a. Theorem 1 is closely related to a theorem of Grauert ([6], Satz 12), but the proof given here differs from Grauert's proof and a more gpneral theorem is obtained. The next part of the paper is concerned with analytic polyhedra. With f as above, write
Po-{p: pEUM... lfc(p)1
1
209
157
210
ERRETT BISHOP.
Theorem 3 states that if S is a compact subset of P then there exists an analytic mapping g of K into Cd which defines an analytic polyhedron Q with seQ C P, where d is the maximum of the dimensions of the Ma (which is assumed to be finite). Theorem 3 (in a more general form) is basic to the theorems which follow. To prove Theorem 3, one first modifies the mapping t = (f1, . ,tn) slightly so that for each 0: the sets of simultaneous constancy of the functions tdt1'· .. , tn/l1 on
have the same dimension at each point of Ifa as the sets of simultaneous constancy of 2f. That this can be done follows from Theorem 1 if n > d, and if n < d there is nothing to prove. This modification of having been made, choose the constant r> 1 such that I (p) I < r 1 for all p in Sand 1 < i < n, and write
ti
t
Then if N is sufficiently large the mapping g = (g2' . . ,gn) of K into Cn-1 defines an analytic polyhedron pI with S C P' c P. After n - d such constructions one obtains the analytic ployhedron Q of Theorem 3. Next it is assumed that K is weakly holomorphically convex, which means that K = U Ma and that for each compact S C K each component of the set
s= {p: pE K, I l(p)1 <maxq€S I l(q)1
for all I in 2f}
is compact. Since weak holomorphic convexity implies that K is the umon of an increasing sequence of analytic polyhedra, one is able to apply Theorem 3 to show (Theorem 4) that K admits an almost proper analytic map I into Cd, where d is the maximum of the dimensions of the Ma and where almost proper means that each component of the inverse image of a compact set is compact. There follows a section of the paper devoted to the study of certain special analytic polyhedra (Theorem 5). As a result of this study we obtain some integral formulas (Theorems 6 and 7) which are an attempt to generalize the usual one dimensional planar formula to several dimensions and to manifolds. These formulas recall the several dimensional integral formulas of Weil [13] and Bergmann [3], although they seem to be fundamentally different from those formulas. Next we return to the study of mappings and show (Theorem 8) that it K is weakly holomorphically convex, if 2f separates points of K, and if certain other minor conditions are satisfied, there exists a proper mapping
158
211
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
of K into Crl+" with d as above, where proper means that the inverse images of compact sets are compact. The proof of this theorem goes as follows. Let f be an almost proper mapping of K into Crl. Let {Sd be an increasing sequence of compact sets the union of whose interiors is K. Let
J k = {z:
Z
= (Z,,"
,Zrl) E Crl, I Zi I
For each positive integer k let HI. be the union of those components of f- ' (J k) which intersect Sk. Let Gk be the set [f-1(JI.;) n HI.+1J -H k • The sets G" and HI. are disjoint compact sets. If ~k denotes the set of all uniform limits on Gk U H k of functions in ~, it can be shown that the maximal ideal space of the Banach algebra ~h is just the set GI. U Ih. It follows from the general theory of Banach algebras that there exists WI< in ~ arbitrarily large on G" and arbitrarily small on HI.. Since {H d is an increasing sequence of compact sets the union of whose interiors is K, it follows that the functions WI. can be
w" converges uniformly on ~r with I f rl+1 (p) I > k for all p in
chosen so that the series
~
compact subsets of K
k=1
to a function f ,hI in GI. and all k. that the mapping f X frl+1 of K into Crl+1 is proper, write
F,,= {p: pE
K.I f.(p) I
To see
1
and consider p in F k • Let j be the smallest integer not less than k such that p E H j • If j> k then p E Gj-l- Therefore k > I frl+1 (p) I > j -1. This contradiction shows that j = k, so that p E HI<.' Thus Flo C H k , so that Fie is compact and the mapping f X frl+1 is proper. It is now relatively simple (Theorem 9) in case K, for instance, is a Stein manifold to choose functions f1O+2' . ,f2n+1 in ~r such that (f,,' . " f2n) has rank n at pach point of K and (f,,' . " f2n+1) distinguishes points of K. This is done by choosing the functions successively to decrease the dimensions o~ certains singular sets associated with the mapping. This last result is a special case of as yet unpublished results 2 on the problem by R. Narasimhan, who used other methods. The first result of this type is due to Remmert [8]. If one looks at the proofs morp closely, it can be seen that all of the mappings considered are dense in the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of K. It is intended to devote a subsequent paper to applications of the results given here. I
• Since this was written Narasimhan's paper has appeared in Amerioan Journal of Mathematios, vol. 82 (1961), pp. 917-934.
159
212
ERRETT BISHOP.
2. Dimensions of level sets of mappings. Rather then begin by considering what is known in the literature as analytic space we introduce a notion which is somewhat more general and which is sufficient for the purposes of this section.
Definition 1. A partially analytic space K consists of a Hausdorff space K, a countable family {Ma} of subsets of K, each of which is a (complex) analytic manifold, and a set ~ of continuous (complex-valued) functions on K. The relative topologies of the subsets Ma are the same as the topologie<; which they possess as analytic manifolds. The space K is a countable union of open sets whose closures are compact, and each component of an open set in K is open. Each function in ~ is analytic on each Ma. ~(is closed ill the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of /(. Also ~[ is an algebra in the sense that sums, products, and complex multiples of elements in Ware in W. In the abo,·e definition and in the sequel an analytic manifold will be understood to be connected and coverable by a countable number of coordinate neighborhoods. Thus each Ma has a (complex) dimension da , which is the same as the dimension of Ma at each of its points. As an abbreviation, we speak of a partially analytic space K, the rest of the structure-the manifolds M a , called the structure manifolds of K, and the algebra W, called the set of analytic functions on K-being understood. The set of continuous complex-valued functions on K is written C (K), and the subset of C (K) consisting of those functions analytic on each )1 a is written A (K). The set of all analytic functions on an analytic manifold M is written A (M). The topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of K is easily seen to be a metrizable topology for C(K). To see this, let {F .. } be a sequence of compact sets whose interiors cover K, and let 11/11,,==sup{lf(p)l: pEF.. } for each
1 in
C (K).
Let
..
p(f,g) = ~2-"1I I-g 11=1
11 .. (1
+
II
I-g 11 .. )-1
for all 1 and gin C(K). Then p is a metric for C(K) and C(K) is complete in the metric p. As a closed subset of C (K), W is also a complete metric space with metric p. We now recall some standard material from the theory of several complex variables which will be of use later. See in this connection the notes [4], [5],
160
and [10J, and the paper [12]. A set A in an analytic manifold },f is analytic if to each point p of M there exists a neighborhood U of p and a finite set of analytic functions on U such that A n U is the set of common zeros in U of the functions. A set A is locally analytic in M if to each p in A there exists a neighborhood U of p and a finite set of analytic functions on U such that A n U is the set of common zeros in U of the functions. A locally analytic set is analytic if and only if it is closed. A point p of a locally analytic set A in a manifold jl is called regular if there exists a coordinate neighborhood U of p and coordinate functions f 1,· . ., f n on U such that A n U
=
{q:
fi (q)
=
0, 1 < i < le}
for some positiye integer le. The set AR of regular points of a locally analytic set A is a locally analytic set which is open and dense in A; if A = A R , then A is called a regular locally analytic set. A connected regular locally analytic set is called a submanifold of 111. Then AR has a countable number of components, each open in A, each of ",hich is a submanifold of Jl and each of which inherits from .11 in a natural way the structure of an analytic manifold. The (complex) dimension of A, which equals one-half of the topological dimension of A, is the maximum of the dimensions of the components of A R . If p is a point in A, the local dimension of A at p is the minimum of the dimensions of the locally analytic sets A n U, where the sets U are neighborhoods of p. The dimension of A is the maximum of the local dimensions of its points. The set As = A - AR is a locally analytic set whose dimension is strictly less than that of A; it is an analytic set if A is an analytic set. This gives rise to a sequence
of locall~ analytic se~s, each a closed subse~ of the preceding: such t~atl A' = (A H) S for 1 < '/, < le and such that A k 1S empty. Thus A 1S the umor! of the disjoint regular locally analytic sets (A ih,
°
• The referee has pointed out that this fact, while true, is not trivial if ~ consists of all functions on an analytic space K which are analytic in the narrow sense, that is,
161
214
ERRETT BISHOP.
Definition 2. A set f 1 , ' • " f d of analytic functions of ad-dimensional analytic manifold M will be called a coordinate set of functions at a point p in M if there exists a neighborhood U of p and a constant r > 0 such that
maps U homeomorphically onto the set E={Z=(Z"
. ',Zd): !Z,-fi(P)!
in d-dimensional complex affine space Cd. '1'he set U will then be called a coordinate neighborhood of p for the functions f 1,' . " f d· LEMMA 1. Let K be a partially analytic space with a single structure manifold M. Let m be a positive integer not larger than the dimension d of JIJ. Let f 1, . ,fd in A (1V1) be a caordinate set of functions at a point p of M, and let U be an associated coordinate neigh borhood,
Let fm be in ~{ and h in A (M). Then the set G of functions g in m wch that the level sets V (sets of simultaneous constancy) of the functions
+
f 1,'
. " f m-1, g h on U are all of dimension d - m or less is dense in ~r and is a countabZe intersection of open subsets of ~r.
Proof. Let go be any element of ~{ and € a positive number. assume the value b at some point in U. Define d+l
g
=
go
+ ~j=l aj(fm-b)j -
Let fm
d+l
~ aj(-b)j,
j=l
where the aj are constants to be chosen. Thus gEm and p (g, go) < € if the aj are sufficiently small. Choose the aj to be that small and in addition to have the property that the functions
(*) have no common zero in U. This is possible because the range of the mapping 0':
P~
(c 1,' . " Cd+1),Ci= (i!)-l ai(go+h)/(a!m)i] p
of U into Cd+l has topological dimension at most 2d and therefore contains which arise from functions analytic in open subsets of the analytic manifolds in which K is considered as locally imbedded. The difficulty in this case is to show that W is closed in elK). This was proved by Grauert and Remmert in Mathematische Annalen, vol. 136 (1958), pp. 245-318.
162
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
no neighborhood of the origin. To see that 9 is in G, it is enough to show that g h is not constant on each of the coordinate planes
+
L
=
{p: p E U,fi(p)
=
Ci, 1
since the sets V are then proper analytic subsets of such planes L and therefore have dimensions less than the dimensions d - (m - 1) of the planes. h is constant on some plane L. Thus Assume therefore that 9
+
8i (g
+ h)/(8fm)i
d+1
=
8i (go
+ h)/8(fm) + ~;=1(].;(j!j(j -i)!) (fm- b)H i
vanishes everywhere on L. If po denotes a point of L for which fm(Po) = b, it follows that the functions (*) have a common zero at po. This contradiction to the choice of the constants (].j means 9 E G. Since go and £ were arbitrary, G is dense in W. To finish the proof of the lemma, define Fie, for each positive integer k, to consist of all 9 in W such that there exists a coordinate plane L with ICil
Definition 3. If M is an analytic manifold, a subset S of A (M) is said to have dimension m over a subset T of A PI) at a point p of M, if the level set of T containing P includes the level set of S containing p and if the difference in the local dimensions at P of these two leyel sets is m. The set S is said to have dimension mo over T on 111 if each level set of S on M is contained in a level set of T on }rf and if rno is the maximum of m for p in M. If T is void, then one speaks simply of the dimension m of S at a point p or of the dimension rno of S on J1. The rank of S at p is the rank at p of the Jacobian matrix of S with respect to some roordinate set of functions at p. LEMMA 2. Let K be a partially analytic space with a single structure manifold 111 of dimension d. Let B be a subset of A (1II) and h an element of A (1If). Let P consist of all points p in 111 such that the dimension of WU B U {h} over B at p is at least 1. Let G be the set of all 9 in W such that the dimension of B U {g h} over B at p is at least 1 for all p in P. Then W- G is of the first category in ~L
+
Proof. The proof proceeds by induction on d. The lemma is clearly true if d = 0, since in that case the set P is void. Assume therefore that the lemma is true for all values of d less than the given value. At each point p in M let J p be the (possibly infinite) Jacobian matrix of the functions in B with respect to a set of coordinates at p, and let J p have rank mp. Let m be
163
216
ERRETT BISHOP.
the maximum of the mp. Choose Po with mpo = m, and let f1" . " fm be elements of B whose Jacobian matrix at po has rank m. Let V be the set of points in M where the Jacobian matrix of these functions has rank m, i. e., where these functions are part of a coordinate set of functions. Thus V is open in M. The level sets of B have dimension d - rn at each point of V. Either the level sets of WU B have dimension d - m at each point of V (case I) or there exists go in W such that the Jacobian matrix of f1" . ',fm, go has rank m 1 at some point of V (case 1). In case 1, let lV be the set of all points in M where the Jacobian matrix of fl" . " fm, go has rank m 1. In case I, either the Jacobian matrix of f 1, " , f m, h has rank m at every point of V (case 3) or has rank m 1 at some point of V (case 2). In case 3 define W = V. In case 2 let lV consist of those points of M at which the Jacobian matrix of f 1,' . " f m, h has rank rn 1. Thus we see that in all three cases W is a non-void open subset of lrl and M - W is an analytic subset of .'vI. Thus M - W is the union of a countable family {Mo:} of disjoint submanifolds of M. The dimension da of Ma is less than d. Let the partially analytic space Ka consist of the Hausdorff space K with the single structure manifold M a and with the set of analytic functions W. Let P a consist of all points p in Ma such that WU B U {h} has dimension at least lover B at the point p on the manifold Ma. Since do: < d, it follows from the induction hypothesis that the set Gex of all g in W such that B U {h g} has dimension at least lover B on the manifold Mex at all points of P ex has the property that W- Go: is of the first category in W. Consider now case 1. For each point p in W, let Up be a coordinate neighborhood of p for some coordinate set of functions containing the functions f1" . " fm, go· Since the topology of M has a countable base, a countable family {U j } of the Up covers 111. From Lemma 1 it follows that W- Gj is of first category in W, where Gj consists of all g in W such that the level sets of f1'" ,fm' g h on U j have dimension at most d - m -1. Define
+
+
+
+
+
+
In cases 2 and 3, define
Thus, in any case, H is of first category in W. We shall complete the proof by showing that W- G c H. To this end, consider g in W- G. Thus there exists p in P such that the dimension of B U {g h} at p equals the dimension of B at p. Let D, E, and F respectively be the level sets of B, of
+
217
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
+
h}, and of ~ U B U {h} which contain p. Let their respective dimensions at p be A, p., and v. Thus A = p.. Since pEP, we have v < A. Let 0 1 be a neighborhood of p such that D n 0 1 , EnO l , and F n 0 1 have dimensions A, p., and v respectively. Since the level set F n 0 1 of ~ U B U {h} on 0 1 which contains p has dimension v, there exists a neighborhood 0 C 0 1 of P such that every level set of ~ U B U {h} on 0 has dimension at most v (see [5], Exp. XIV). Now for each IX the set En 0 n Ma. is a countable union of compact sets; so is the set En 0 n w. ~\lso, En 0 is the union of En 0 n Wand the sets En 0 n Ma.. By a standard theorem of dimension theory (see [7], p. 30), it follows that A = dim(E n 0) is the maximum of the dimensions of En 0 n Wand the sets En 0 n !lIa.. Thus
B U {g
dim(E nOn Q) =A, where Q is either lV or one of the sets Ma.. Thus there exists a point po in E nOn Q such that the dimension of E n Q at Po is A. By the choice of 0, the dimension at po of the level set Fo of ~ n B n {h} containing po is at most v. Also, the dimension of the level set D n Q of B at Po on Q is at least A, since it contains the set E nOn Q which has dimension A at po; on the other hand, the dimension of D n Q at po is at most p. = A, and therefore this dimension equals "-. Consider first the case in which Q = Ma for some IX. Since v < A the dimension of Fo n Jfa at po is less than the dimension of D n Q = D n lila at po; therefore po EPa. Also the dimension of D n JIa. at Po is A and the dimension of En]Ia at po is A. By the definition of Ga, it follows that g E ~ - Ga. Thus g E H. It remains to consider the case Q = lV and to show that g E H in this case also. To do this, cases 1, 2, and 3 must be considered separately. consider! first case 1. Let U j be one of the sets of the family {U j } which contains po. By the choice of f1' . ,fm any function f in B must be constant on each component of each level set of these functions on W: otherwise, there would exist f in B such that the Jacobian of fl' .. ,fm' f with respect to a coordinate set of functions would be of rank m 1 at some point of W. Thus the dimension A at Po of the level set D n Q = D n W of B equals d - m. Since also A is the dimension of the level set E n W = E n Q of B U {g h} at po, it follows that g E ~ - Gj • Thus g E H. Next consider case 2. Since the function g in ~ is locally constant on the level sets in W of the coordinate functions f 1, . . , fm, the level sets of f 1, . . , f m, g h on Ware locally the same as those of the functions
+
+
+
165
218
ERRETT BISHOP.
f " . , f m,
h and therefore have dimension d - m - 1. Thus the dimensions at po of the level sets of Band B U {g h} are d - m and d-m - 1 respectively. This contradicts the fact, derived above, that both these dimensions are.\.. Thus case 2 does not arise. N ext consider case 3. In this case it is clear that locally the level sets of B, B U {g h}, and ~ U B U {h} are the same as the level sets of f" ,fm. This contradicts the fact that the level sets of B and ~ U B U {h} containing po have respective dimensions.\. and v < .\. at Po. Thus case 3 also does not arise. This completes the proof of Lemma 2.
+
+
Definition 4 (by induction). Let X be the Cartesian product of complete metric spares X,,· ,Xn • If n = 1, then Fe X is said to be of third category if it IS of first category. If n> 1, then F is said to be of third ClLtegory if the set of all points p in X, X XX 11-1 for which the set of points q in Xn such that (p, q) E X is not of first category is of third category. It is clear that a countable union of sets of third category i" of third category, and that the complement of a set of third category is uen'<e THEOREM 1. Let K be a partially analytic space. For each at, let Ba be a subset of A (.11",) and let hI"" .. , hk", be elements of A (JI",), where le is a fixed positwe integer. Let pir>., 1 . we have
(*)
The dimension on the manifold Ma at p of B", U {g,
+ hI""
.. , g ..
+h
k ,,}
over Ba is at least i. Then k~( - G is of third category tn the le-fold cartesian pi"oduct k~r of ~( with itself.
We show by induction on le that the theorem is true for all positive integers le. We aSbume that the theorem is true for all values of le smaller than the one being considered. The proof of the theorem when le = 1 is the same as the proof of the general inductive step, and so need not be considered separately Having fixed le, let fI,· . ,h be any elements of~. Let Qia, 1
166
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
+
+
of B U {g, h' "" . ,g1v--1 hk-1",} over B", is at least i has the property that k- 1m: - Go is of third category. Fix some (g" .. , g1v--1) in Go. Let Qa be the set of points p in Ma for which the dimension at p of 8 1=
m: U
B", U {g,
+ h ' a,
.
,g"-1
+h
k - 1 a}
U {hka}
over
is at least 1. By Lemma 2, the set Z of gIG in ~r such that for each ex and each p in Qa the dimension at p of Ba U {g, h ' a, . , gk hka } over Ba U {g, h1a, .. , gl.--1 P-1",} is at least 1 has a complement of first ., gl.--1 category. We first show that 9 = (g1, .. , gkJ is in G for each 91, in Go and each g.. in Z. Afterward, we show that this implies that km: - G is of third category. We therefore now prove that 9 E G. Consider a point p in some Pia. Let A be the dimension at p of
+
+
+
T1 =
~{U
Ba U {h 1 a,
+
,h".,}
and p. that of Be., so that A- p. :> i because p E pia. at p of
Let v be the dimension
+
Then either A = v or A = v 1 (see [10], p. 43), since T 1 contains one more function than T 2. Consider first the case v = A and i < le. Then v - JJ- :> i, so that p E Qi a. Therefore the dimension at p of Ba U {g1 h1a, .. , gk-1 hk - 1a } over Ba is at least i. Therefore 9 satisfies (*) at the point p. N ext consider the cabe in which either v = A-I or i = le. Thus v-p.:>i-l, so that pE Qi- 1 a if i#l. Therefore the dimension at p of Ba U {g1 h' ", . ,g1v--1 hle- 1a} over Ba is at least i - I ; this clearly also holds if i = 1. Thus to show that 9 satisfies (*) at the point p it is enough to show that the dimension at p of Ba U {g, h 1a,·· ,g .. hka } over Ba U {g, h 1a,· .. , gk-1 hk-1a } is at least 1. Therefore it is enough to show that p E Qa, or that the dimension of 8 1 over 8 2 is at least 1 at p. Consider first the case v = A-1. N ow the level sets of 8 , and 8 2 U m: are the same as the level sets of T1 and T2 respectively, because g1,· .. , g1v--1 are in m:. Thus the dimension at p of 8 1 over 8 2 is at least A- v = 1, so that p E Qa and 9 therefore satisfies (*) at the point p. Consider next the case A = v and i = le. Then A :> p. i = JL le, and as above we see that A is the dimension of 8 1 at p. Since 8 2 contains lc - 1 more functions than Ba and since B", has dimension JL at p, the dimension
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
167
+
220
ERRETT BISHOP.
of 8 2 at p is at most p,+ (k-l). Therefore the dimension of 8 1 over 8 2 at p is at least p, k - (p, k-l) = 1. Thus P E Qa so that g satisfies condition (*) at the point p in this case and therefore in all cases. It follows that (gl,' . " gk) E G. To see now that "& - G is of third category in k&, note that 1..-1& - Go is of third category in k-l& and for each (gl, " , gk-l) in Go the set of gk in & with (gl,' . " gk) in k& - G is a subset of & - Z and therefore of first category in &. Therefore k& - G is of third category, as was to be proved.
+
+
3. Analytic polyhedra and weak holomorphic convexity. In this section we investigate mappings of a d-dimensional partially analytic space into Cd. Theorem 1 of the last section of course has applications to such mappings, but the purpose of this section is to obtain stronger results, under the assumption that K has certain analytic convexity properties. The basic notion is that of an analytic polyhedron. Definition 5. A subset L of a partially analytic space K is called central if it is the union of some subfamily of the family of structure manifolds of K and if each component of an open set in L is open. Let (fl, " , fn) be functions in & and let L be a central subset of K. Define Po= {p: pE L, I fi(p)
1< 1,1
Let P be a union of certain components of Po. If the closure P of P is a compact subset of L, then P is called an analytic polyhedron defined by the functions (f1," , f,,), and L is called the frame of P. The dimension of P is the maximum of the dimensions of & on the manifolds },fa n P for},fa C L. P is called reduced if n < dim P; otherwise U is called unreduced. An unreduced analytic polyhedron P is called prepared if for each structure manifold },fa of K which is a subset of L and intersects P the set & has dimension 0 on thE' manifold },fan P n {p: f 1 (p) =1= O} over the set {f2{fl)-'" . ·,f.. (fl)-l}. BdryP denotes the boundary of P when P is considered as a subset of its frame L. Note that an analytic polyhedron P is an open subset of its frame L, since each component of the open set Po in L is open in L. Therefore
bdryP=P-P. 3. If P is an analytic polyhedron defined by fl' . ea'Ch pin bdry P there exi5ts k, 1
, f n, then for
Proof. Let Po be defined as above. Assume the lemma is not true. Then I fi(p) I < 1, 1
168
221
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
in Po, and since p E bdry PCP, it follows that pEP. shows that the lemma is true.
This contradiction
THEOREM 2. Let K be a partially analytic space and let fl,· . ,fn be functions in m: defining an analytic polyhedron P with frame L. Let S be a compact subset of P and r > 1 a constant such that
For each positive integer N let Q be the union of those components of Qo = {p: pEL, I (rf, (p))N
I < 1, I (rf,;(p) )N -
(rfl (p) )N
I < 1,2 < i <
n}
which contain points of S. Let R be the union of those components of
which contain points of s. If N is sufficiently large, then Q is an analytic polyhedron with frame Land SeQ C P. If P is prepared and if N is sufficiently large, then R is an analytic polyhedron with frame Land S eRe P. Proof. Clearly seQ and S C R if N is chosen so large that I f,;(p) I 1 < i < n, pES. Clearly, also, the fact that Q and R are analytic polyhedra with frame L will follow from the inclusions Q C P and Rep. Consider first the general case, so that P need not be prepared. We wish to prove Q C P. Now if p is any point in bdry P, then I f,;(p) 1= 1 for some i. If I fl(p) I >r" then by the definition of Qo it is clear that p is not in Q.
< irN,
If
I fl(P) 1<
r"
then
I (rf.(p))N -
(rfl (p))N I >rN -
(rrl)N
=
r N -1,
so that p is not in Q is N is sufficiently large. Thus if N is sufficiently large Q does not intersect bdry P. Thus each component of Q is eitHer a subset of P or disjoint from P. Since each component of Q intersects S C P, it follows that Q C P, as was to be proved. Now assume that P is prepared. We must show that ReP if N is sufficiently large. To this end it suffices as above to show that R does not intersect bdry P. Assume therefore that (bdry P) n R is non-void for a sequence {Nm} of values of N, where Nm->;oo as m->;oo. Choose a constant c with r l < c < 1 and write where
v=
{p:
I I,; (p) I < c, 1 < i < n}.
169
222
ERRETT BISHOP.
Since (bdry P) n R is non-void, there exists a component G of R - V which intersects bdry P. Now G contains a point qo of the boundary (in L) of V n L, since otherwise G would be a component of R containing no points of S. Let T m be the component of TOm containing qo, so that T meG. Now T m intersects bdry P, for otherwise T m would be a component of R - V and would therefore equal G, contradicting the fact that G contains a point of bdry P. For each p in T m there exists le, 1 < k < n, with \ flc (p) \ :> c. For this value of k we have
r N \ f,(P) \N:> \ (rh(p))N where N
=
N m'
1-\ (rh(p))N f, (p) oF 0
Hence, for pETm,
\ (f.(p) )N(f,(P) )-N -1\
<
(rf1(p))N \ :> (cr)N -1, and
«cr)N _1)-1
< 2(cr)-N
if N = N m is sufficiently large. Let Dm consist of all complex numbers z such that I zN-ll < 2(cr)-N. For z in D m ,
1-2(cr)-N
< \ z \N < 1 + 2(cr)-N,
so that 1-
2 (cr) -N
<
Iz \
< 1 + 2 (cr) -N,
or \1-\ z \ I < 2 (cr) -N. Also, if arg ZN is chosen between -.". and ."., then I zN - 1 I :> i \ arg ZN \, so that I arg ZN I < 4 (cr) -N. There therefore exists an integer j, 0 < j < N -1, such that
I arg z - 2j.".N-1 \ <4N-1 (cr)-N < 4(cr)-N if arg z is chosen properly.
\ z - Ci I <
Thus, if Ci
=
I I z I - I Ci II + I arg z -
exp (2.". (-1) IljN-1), we have
arg Ci I < 2(cr)-N 4(cr)-N = 6 (cr)-N.
+
Therefore Dm is contained in the union of the circular neighborhoods of radii 6(cr)-N about the Nm-th roots of unity. These neighborhoods are clearly disjoint if N m is sufficiently large. Thus the functions f. (f1) -" 2 < i < n, each map T m into the union of these disjoint neighborhoods. Since T m is connected, fdfd -1 maps T m into a particular such neighborhood F m" Let the corresponding N m-th root of unity be Cm.i' Thus
for all p in T m' By passing to a subsequence of {Nm} if necessary, we may assume that {Cm.'} converges for each i to a number C. as m ~ 00. The sequence {Tm} of compact subsets of the compact set P may also be assumed
170
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
to converge to a compact subset T of P, in the usual topology for compact subsets of a compact space. f'm is connected because T m is connected, so that T is connected. Clearly T is a closed subset of P. Since T m contains pointR in bdry P and bdry V, T also contains points in bdry P and bdry V. Also for all p in T. Partition T into equivalence classes by defining p == q, for p and q in T, to mean fi (q) = fi (p), 1 < i < n. Since T is connected and contains points in bdry P and bdry V, since each f; is bounded in absolute value by c < 1 on bdry V, and since to each point in bdry P there exists fi having absolute value 1 at that point, it follows that some fi assumes an uncountable number of values on the set Tn P. Thereforc there are an uncountable number of partition classes of Tn P. Thus there exist an Ma C L such that Ma intersects an uncountabll:> number of partition classes of T n P. Let S be that level set of the functions f 2(f1) -".. , f n (fd -ion PnMan {p: fI(p) ~O} which contains the set Tnp, so that S contains an uncountable number of level sets of f1' ,fn on "Ala. The locally analytic set 8 in Ma splits into a countable family {Sd of irreducible analytic sets, none of which is a subset of the union of the others There exists ko such that f,,' . ,fn are not all constant on S"". Since Sho is irreducible the sets of constancy of f1' ", fn on Ska arc all of dimension less than the dimension of 8 ko ' If po is a point in 8 4 not in any of the other 8/.., it follows that the dimension on the manifold M a of f 1,' • " f n oycr f 2 (f d -" . , f n (f1) -1 at Po is at least 1, contradicting the fact that P is prepared. This completes the proof. LEMMA 4. Let {Lj} be a finite family of centred subsets of a partiaUy analytic space K, and let f,,' . " f n be functions in ~r such that for each j there exists an integer y = y (j), 1 < y (j) < n, such that f 1, . ,f"t define an analytic polyhedron P j with frame L j • For each j let 8 j be a compact subset of Pj. Then there exist functions 1'" ",1'.. in ~r such that for each j the functions /'1" . ,f'"t define an analytic polyhedron P'j with frame L j with
Sj
c
pi; C P j
such that P'j is unreduced and prepared if P j Proof.
i~
unreduced.
Choose t:> 0 such that
SjCPjn{p:lfi(p)1
<
1-2t:,1
for all values of j. Consider a value of j for which P j is unreduced and let Ma be any structure manifold which intersects P j and is a subset of L j • Let
Nja=PjnMan {p: f,(p)
171
~O}.
ERRETT BISHOP.
The dimension of W on NjO/ is less than 'I, since P j is unreduced. level sets of Ware the same as the level sets of
Since the
the dimension of H on NjO/ is at most 'I -1. Let Gi be the set of all (g2,' . " gn) in n-lW such that for all a the set H has dimension 0 on the manifold NjO/. over the set
and let G =
nG
j•
By Theorem 1, with EO/. the void set,
n-l~r
-
Gj is of third
j
category in n-IW.
Thus the set n-lW -
G = U (n-lW -
Gj )
j
is of third category in n-lW, where the union is taken over all j for which P j is unreduced. Thus there exists (g2" . " gn) in G such that for all j we have I gi (p) I < £ whenever 2 < i < 'I (j) and p E Pj, whether or not Pi IS unreduced. Define
and 1'1 = fl' Since the level sets of Ware the same as the level sets of H, we see by the above that ~r has dimension 0 over the set
on the manifolds Njcx for each j for which P j is unreduced. Pi be the union of those components of
For each j let
P"j={P: pELj,ll'i(P)1
For each p in Sj and for 2 < i < 'I, we have
Clearly also 11'1 (p) I < 1 for p in Si' Therefore S} C P"j and hence 8 j C P l f • Consider now p in bdry Pi' By Lemma 3, I fi (p) I = 1 for some i, 1 < i < y. If i = 1, then clearly p is not in P'j. If 2
that p ¢ p} in this case also. Thus p l j does not intersect bdry Pj' Since each component of P'j contains a point of 8 j C Ph it follows that P'j C Pj. Thus P'j is an analytic polyhedron with frame L j defined by /'1" . " /''Y' If P j is unreduced then p l j is also unreduced since p l j C P j implies dim P'j IiO
172
225
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
-< dim P J ; p'J is also prepared since we have seen that /' 2(f/l) -1,.. , /' "Y ( / ' l) -1 on each of the manifolds
~
has dimension 0 over
This completes the proof. THEOREM 3. Let {L J} be a finite family of central subsets of the partially analytic space K. Let the functions fl,· .. , fn in ~ define for each j an analytic polyhedron P J with frame L J. Let 'Y = 'Y (j) = min {n, dim 1\}. Let 8 J be a compact subset of PJ. Then there exist functions 1'1, ,f~ in ~ such that for each j the functions /'1'· .. , r"Y define an analytic pulyhedron p'J with frame L; such that 8; C P'; C PJ.
Proof. Let T be the class of all positive integers m such that there ,h5 define exist hl' .., hn in ~ such that for each j the functions hl' an analytic polyhedron Q; with frame L; with 8 J C Qj C Pi> where 1l=1l(]) =max{y(j),m}. Clearly the set T is non-void, since by hypothesis nE T. Clearly also the lemma will be proved if it is shown that 1 E T. To this end, assume 1 ¢ T. Let m be the least integer in T, and choose hl' .., h" as above. We will prove that m - 1 E T and thus obtain a contradiction. The polyhedra Q; with 'Y (j) < m are unreduced, since dim Q; -< dim P J = 'Y (j). Therefore, by applying Lemma 4, we may assume that the polyhedra Q; with 'Y (j) < m are prepared. Let r> ] be such that I hi (p) I < 1 -< i -< 'Y (j), p E 8j, for all values of j. We define
r"
h'm-l= (rhm)N- (rhl)N, h'm = (rh.)N, h'm+l = (rhm+1)N - (rh.)N
h'" =
(rh,,)N -
(rh1)N.
If N is sufficiently large it follows from Theorem 2 that h /1 , · • . , h' fl defi ne an analytic polyhedron Q'; with frame L J such that 8 J C Q'; C Q; C Pi> where .B = max{y(j), m - I } . This shows that m - 1 E T. From this contradiction we conclude that 1 E T, as was to be proved. Definition 6.
A partially analytic space K is called weakly holomor-
2
173
226
ERRETT BISHOP.
phically convex if it is the union of its structure manifolds and if for each compact 8 C K each component of the set S
=
{p: p E K, [ f (p) [ < max q E 8
[
f (q) [, all f in m}
is compact. Definition 7. A continuous mapping > of a topological space T, into a topological space T 2 is almost proper if each component of >-1 (8) is compact for each compact subset 8 of T 2 • THEOREM 4. Let {Lj} be a finite family of closed central subsets of a weakly holomorphically convex partially analytic space K. Let the dimensions of m on the structure manifolds of K be bounded and have the maximum value n. Let y = y (j) be the maximum of the dimensions of 9f on the structure manifolds of K which are subsets of L j • Then the set of elements f = (f,,' . " fn) in n9f such thai for each j the mapping
fi:
p~
(f,(P),' . ',f'Y(p»
of L} into G'Y is almost proper is dense in nm. Proof. It is permissible to assume that L, = K. Let {8d be a sequence of compact sets whose union is K with 8, C interior 8 i +1 • Let Ti be an open set containing 8 i whose closure is compact and whose boundary does not intersect Si. For each point P in bdry T i , there exists h in W with
[ h(p) [ > 1
> maxqEs,
[h(q) [.
By the compactness of bdry T i , there therefore exist a finite number h" , hm of functions in W such that [hk(q) [ < 1 for q in 8 t and 1 1 for at least one k if P E bdry T i . If we let Q be the union of those components of
Qo={P: pEK,[hi(p)[
be given functions in W.
We show that if the complex constants {ail and the
174
PARTIALLY ANAL~TIC SPACES.
positive integers {til are chosen properly then the functions", defined by the series
h=
. a.(gi
~
+ Ak,
k ) tt
i;;:l
h
have the required properties and that To this end, write m
fll'k
~
=
a, (gik) t,
i=l
1 <: k<:n,
is arbitrarily close to Ak in
+ A/,.,
~.
1 <: 7c <: n, 1 <: m
<
00 •
Let mo be an arbitrary positive integer. Choose a,,' . " am. to be zero and t,,' . " tm~ to be 1. We now give the rules for choosing am and t m, assuming that the previous ai and ti have been chosen. Choose
I am I > max{ I
f,"-l k
(p)
I:
1 <: 7c <: y(j), p E bdry Qm;, all j}
+ m + 1.
Then choose t,n so large that
This can be done since for s
<m
we have
so that I gmk(p) I < 1 for p E Q'i and 7c <: y(j). The sequences {am} and {tm} having been chosen in this way, we show first that the series defining the funC'tions h converge uniformly on compact subsets of K, so that fk is welldefinerl and belongs to ~L It is clearly sufficient to consider the compact sets Qn:J S,. Now I am(gml.-(p)) 1m 1 <: 2- m for m > 8 and p in Q81' so that the series for h converge., uniformly on Q81' Therefore h E~. To see that the mapping fi is almost proper, consider a compact set [{ C C1'. sufficient to assume that II
=
{
(Zl'
" , z'Y) : I z, I <: <x, 1 <: i <: y}
for some <x> O. Let r be all)' component of (fi)-l(H). Choose i such that Qii is non-void. Choose a positive integer m larger than <x, i, and mo. Then I g"'k(P) 1= 1 for some le, 1 <: 7c <: Y (j), if P E bdry Qmi' Therefore
r n
1h(p) 1= 1f m -
1
k(P)
+
.
~ a,.(grk(p) tr r=m+l
+ am (gml.-(p» 1 1m
~
>[am l-lf m- 1 k(P)I-
~
la r (gr k (p») tr l>m+l-
.
~ 2- r >m>a. r=m+l
r=m+l
Thus we see that (fi) -1 (H) does not intersect bdry Qmi' We therefore have r C Qmj. Thus r is a closed subset of the compact set Qmi' Therefore r is
175
JHut.!'.:'!"!' Hll:!liU.I:'.
compact. It follows that fi is almost proper, as was to be proved. It is also clear that fk can be made arbitrarily close to Ak by taking mo sufficiently large.
4. Special analytic polyhedra and integration. In order to study the local properties of an analytic ployhedron, it is helpful to impose certain restrictions. Definition 8. A reduced analytic polyhedron P in a partially analytic space K with frame L defined by functions fl' . " fn in ~r will be called special if the level sets of fl, . , fn on P are countable and if the set A of all a such that M", C L, .M", intersects P, and dimM",=n has the property that ( U M",) n P is dense in P and that M", n P is open in L for each a in A, 'lEA
It is clear that each component of a special analytic polyhedron is a special analytic ployhedron.
Definition 9. If X is a topological space we define vY, called the k-fold unordered product of X with itself, to be the set of all unordered Ie-tuples of elements of X. '1'he natural map of the k-fold Cartesian product kX of X with itself into",X is denoted by Ox, or Okx if k is not clear from the context. A set in kX is defined to be open if and only if its inverse image under the map Ox is an open set in kX. It is clear that kX is Hausdorff if X is Hausdorff and compact if X is compact. THEOREM 5. Let P be a special analytic polyhedron with frame L in a partially analytic space K defined by the functions f 1," , f n in W. Let En be the subset of On consisting of points whose coordinates are less than 1 in absolute value, and let f be the map
',f,,(p» of P into En. For each a in A let M"'l be the subset of M", consisting of all points in Ma n P at which (fl, . ,fn) is a coordinate set of functions. Then the set M1 = U MIa is dense in P and H = f(P-1I-f 1 ) is closed and nowhere a
dense in En. There exists an integer A > 1, called the multiplicity of P, such that for each z in En-H there exist exactly A distinct points p in M1 with f (p) ~ z. Th e map w from En - H into "P which takes z into the unordered A-tuple of such points can be uniquely extended to a continuous map w of En into "P. The set P has only a finite number of components. Proof.
If a E A the set M 2 a = (M", n P) -MIa is a locally analytic
176
.I:'Al1TIALL:r
A.N AL:r IlL
!!.I:'AU ..... !!.
subset of Ma , since locally it is given by the vanishing of a certain Jacobian. Also M2a=FM(JI.nP because 1I1 2 (J1.=M a nP would imply that locally one of the functions f" ,fn depends on the others, contradicting the fact that the level sets of f = (f,,' " fn) on MOl n P are countable. Thus M 2 a is the union of a finite family {N"'./l} of analytic submanifolds of M a , with dim NOl./l < dim J[ a = n. Since 111, Of. is clearly dense in M and U 111 is dense (JI.
(JI.
(JI.EA
in P, }'1, is dense in P. Now each NOl./l is a countable union of closed sets, as is each 11101 n P, (X ¢ A. Thus f(NOf../l)' 2 E A, and f(M", n P), (X ¢ A arp countable unions of closed sets of topological dimensions < 2n - 2, since the analytic image of a closed set of dimensions < 2n -2 is of dimension < 2n - 2. I t follows that real dim H < 2n - 2. Therefore En - H is connedcd (see r'l] for these theorems) . Since f (.11.) is of real dimension 2n, f( .~[ 1) - II is nOll-void. For each z in En-II let l(z) be the number of points p in 111, with f(p) =Z If l(z) were not iinitt', the set of such points p would have a limit point po in P. Actually Po is in P, since f(po) E En implies by Lemma 3 that po is not in bdry P. If po E JIa for some (X E A, the fact that ."'fla n P i~ open in P implies that the level set of f on Jla containing po also contains the points p which are sufficiently near to Po. Thus this level set has po as a limit point and is therefore not O-cl.imensional; it is therefore uncountable, contradicting the fact that P is a special analytic polyhedron. Thus po is not in JI, C U JI a. Also po is not in P - Jl, SlIlce z is not in H. Thus po <",A
is not 1Il P at all. This contradiction shows that I (z) is finite. positn'e lIlteger y let TI'={z: zEEn-11,I(z) >y}.
For each
If Zo E T 1', there are distinct points P" " PI' in .Il, with f(Pi) = Zoo Choose 2j in A with Pi E .~I,"", For each i, 1 y. Thus TI' is an open set in En-H. To see that T I' is closed in En - H, consi der Zo in T I' n (En - H) . Let {Zj} be a sequence of points in TI' converging to zoo Let p'j, " Pl'i be distinct points in M, with f(pij) = Zi' We may assume that for each i, 1
In
177
ERRETT BISHOP.
230
Thus f is not one-to-one on any neighborhood of pi, contradicting the fact that pI E MI. Thus the points pi, 1 <: i <: 'I, are distinct. Therefore Z E T 'Y. Thus T'Y is both open and closed in En - H. Since En - H is connected it follows that either T'Y is void or T'Y = En - H. Now T'Y is certainly void for some integer y; take 'I larger than I (z) for some z in En - H. Let'\ be the greatest integer such that T" is not void. It is clear that l(z) >,\ for all z, since Tx=En-H. If l(z) >,\ for some z, then T"+1 is non-void, contradicting the choice of,\. Therefore I (z) =,\ for all z in En - H. This integer ,\ is called the multiplicity of the analytic polyhedron P. To see that H is closed in En, for each r < 1 let
Now j}[1 is open in P since each MIa is open in P. Therefore f(P r -M1 ) is closed in En. But
f (P r -
M 1)
=
f (P -
M I)
n {( ZI'··
,
Thus P r -."'1[1 is compact.
Zn) E En: I Zi I < r, 1 <: i <: n}.
It follows that H = f (P - M d is closed in En. It remains to show that w is continuous on En - H and to extend w continuously to En. The extension of w will perforce be unique because En-H is dense in En. To see that w is continuous on En-H, let {Zi} be a sequence of points in En-H converging to a point Zo in En-H. Let W(Zi) be the unordered A-tuple {p\,. ., pi.,.} in "P and let w(z) be {P1, .. , p,,}. If w is not continuous on En-H, the sequence {zd and the point Zo can be chosen so that W(Zi) converges to a point JL#w(zo) in "P. As above we see that JL consists of A distinct points P in lrf, with f (p) = Z00 Therefore p. = W (zo), a contradiction, proving that W is continuous on En - II. To show that w can be extended continuously to En it is enough, since "P is metnzable, to show that w has a continuous extension to (En-H) U {zo} for each Zo in H. To do this, let P1, .. , Pk be all points in P with f (Pi) = zo, so that actually Pi E P, 1 <: i <: le. Let U 1, • . , U" be dlsjoint neighborhoods of P" ,p" respectively. Assume that there exists a sequence {z;} of points converging to Zo such that for each i there exists a pomt qi in P - U 1 _ .. -Uk with f(gi) =Zi. Then any limit point q of the sequence {gd has the property that f( q) = Zo and q E P - U 1 . Uk. This contradiction shows that the seqeunce {Zi} does not exist. Therefore f-1(V) nP
c
U 1 U·
U Uk
if V is a small enough neighborhood of Z00 Since V is open in En and real dim H <: 2n - 2, the set V - H is connected. For each Z in V - H let Il i (z),
178
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
1 <: i <: 7c, be the number of elements in the set w(z) n U~ = t-l (z) n Ui . Since w is continuous on En-H, 8i is continuous. Since V - H is connected, 8i is therefore constant on V-H. Clearly ~8i=.\. Define w(zo) E ~P to consist of the points Pl, .., Pk with the respective multiplicities 81 , . . . , 8k· This choice is clearly independent of the neighborhood V, and the extension of w so defined to (En-H) U {Zo} is clearly continuous at zoo To see finally that P has a finite number of components, note that each component of P is itself a special analytic polyhedron, and therefore by the analysis just given contains a point p with f(p) = o. Since by the analysis just given P contains only A such points p, it follows that actually P has at most A components. LEMMA 5. Let P be a special analytic polyhedron in a partially analytic space K defined by functions f 1,· . ., f.... Let s be a function on O~ which is a symmetric polynomial in the variables (Zl,· .. , z~) and let s be the unique continuous function on ~O (where 0 is the complex plane) such that so Ox = s. Let g be a continuous function on P. Let ~g be the continuous function on >.P which ta7ces the unordered A-tuple {Pl'· . ., p~..} into the point {g (P1),· .. , g (p~)} in >.0. Let 9 = s 0 ~g 0 w. Then 9 is a continuous function on En which is analytic on En if g is analytic on M", n P for each IX in A.
Proof. Since g is continuous >.g is continuous. Therefore 9 = s 0 >.g 0 w is continuous. Assume that g is analytic on each Ma n P for IX E A. Consider any point z in En-H. There exists a neighborhood U of z such that r(U) n P is the union of disjoint neighborhoods U 1 , · . , U~ of the points of w(p). We may assume that each Ui lies in some M"" IXE A, and that U; is mapped homeomorphically onto U by f. This makes it clear that 9 is analytic at z. Thus 9 is analytic on En-H. To show that 9 is analytic on ~ we need only show that 9 is analytic on all one-dimensional coordinate planes: As typical of such coordinate planes, consider the planes
,cn-d }, where c is a point of En-1. Let G consist of all c in En-1 such that H n Lc is countable. Since 9 is continuous on En and analytic on En - H, 9 is analytic on Lc for each c in G. Clearly, then, 9 is analytic on Lc for all c in G. Thus we need only show that G = En-1. To do this we shall show that En-l _ G is of first category in En-1. Let {Ud be a countable basis for the open sets in E1. Let {J6} be the family consisting of the manifolds M", n P, IX ¢ A, and N"'{J, IX E A, where the N"'p are defined as in Theorem 5. Thus He U f(J6). For each 8 let {Gn'Y} II
179
232
ERRETT BISHOP.
be a countable family of open sets in J o which have compact closures in J,l and which cover J o. Then
For each 8, each '1, and each positive integer le let
FO,),k= {c: cE En-t, {c} X Uk C f(G o')')}. The set FO'Yk is closed because Uk and f (Go'Y) are closed. Also F{hk has no interior points, since otherwise f (Go'Y) would have an interior point in En, contradicting the fact that real dim f (Gli'Y) < 2n - 2. It follows that Y = U FO'Yk is of first category in En-l. To complete the o,')',k proof we show that En-l - G C Y. Consider c E En-l_ G. There exists Go'Y such that f (Go')') n Lc is uncountable. Thus tn assumes an uncountable number of distinct values on the analytic subset
of Go'Y' It follows that f.,(8) contains some open set in El, so that rIle C fn(8) for some le. Thus {c} X Uk C I (Go'Y)' so that c E FO'Yk' Thus En-l - G C Y, as was to be proved. Definition 10. Let K be a partially analytic space and P a speC'ial analytic polyhedron in P defined by the functions fl" . " In. For 0 < r < 1 let P r = P n {p: ! ti(P)! r, 1
<
Let B r =Pr n{p:!fi(p)!=r,l
Let
. , zn) : ! Zi ! < T, 1 < i < n} and V r = f (Br) C bdry Enr- Let s be the function on 0)0. defined by 2)0.. If 9 is a continuous function on P, define s (2 1 ' . • ,2)0.) = Zl !J as in Lemma 5, so that
+ . .+
where w (2) = {PI, . . ,P)o.}. Thus!J is continuous and analytic on each Mcx n P, IX EA. Now the linear functional
9~ IS
r
..JVr
!J (z) dz l
'
.
.
IS
analytic if 9
IS
dZn
a continuous linear functional in the uniform norm on the space of all
180
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
continuous functions 9 on By. It follows by the Riesz representation theorem for such linear functionals that there exists a unique finite complex-valued Borel measure p. on BT such that
J'
g(p)dp.(p)
=
[
aJv r
Br
for all continuous functions 9 on By.
g(z)dz, · .. dz",
The measure dp. is written df,
dfn.
We now give an integral formula for special analytic polyhedra which, while trivial, is fundamental. THEOREM
6.
n
function on Ma
(271"i)-"
r
)B r
Under the conditions of Definition 10, if 9 is an analytic P for each ex E A and if q E P r, then
g(P)[f,(P) -f,(q)]-'
.. [f.,(p) -fn(q)J-1df,(P)·
=g(f(q)). Proof. Write h=gLf,-f,(q)]-l . .. [f,,-fn(q)]-l. The proof depends on computing h, which is defined on Vr because h is continuous on B r. Consider z in Vr and let IlJ (z) = {PI'· .. , p~}. Since Ii (pj) = Zi for all j, where z = (ZI'· . , zn), it follows that
We therefore have
(2.".i)-n
r h(p)df,(q)· .. dfn(P)
)B r
=(271"i)-n
f
.ll(z)[z,-f,(q)]-I .. [zn-f",(q)J-'dz, · . ·dz". Vr
Since (f 1 (q), .. , f n (q)) E En. it follows from the n-times iteration of the Cauchy integral formula that this quantity is just fj (f (q) ), as was to be "\ proved. The integral formula of Theorem 6 is apparently only good for representing functions which have equal values at points of P mapping into the same point of En. That this is not the case is shown by the following theorem. THEOREM 7. With the notation of Lemma 5 and Theorem 6, let w be any analytic function on P (continuous on P and analytic on Man P for each tZ E A). Let w be the function on P X P defined by
w(p, q)
=
[W(P2) -w(q) ] ...
[w(p~)
w
-w(q)],
where w(f(p) ={P=Pl'· . ·,PA}. Then is continuous on PXP and analytic in q for each value of P and analytic in p for each value of q. If w
181
J<;HH.I!:'l"l' BU!HOl'.
is in W, then W(p, g) is in W when considered as a function of g for each fixed p in P. For each function 9 analytic on P and each g in P r (2wi)-n
r
J B•
g(p)w(p, g)[Mp) - fl(g)] - 1 . .
[f,,(p) - f .. (q)J-ldMp)· .. df,,(p)
= w(g)g(g),
where the function 1V(q) =w(q,q) is analytic on P. Proof.
Clearly A-I
w(p, q)
=
~
-t-
1=0
a.(p) [w(q) J',
where ai (p) is the A - i -l-th elementary symmetric function of
{W(P2),' . " w(PA)}' Since P ~ {P2' . . ,p,.} is a continuous map of Pinto A-IP, it follows that the a. are continuous functions on P. Thus ill is continuous on P X P. Clearly ill is analytic in q for each fixed P and (p, q) E W for each fixed p if w E W. To show that w is analytic in p, it is enough to show that the elementary symmetric functions of {w (P2),' . " w (PA)} are analytic as functions of p. It is a consequence of Lemma 5 that the elementary symmetric functions of {w (PI),' . " w (PA)} are analytic as functions of p. Now each elementary symmetric function of {w (p2),· . ',10 (PA)} is a linear combination of an elementary symmetric function of {w (PI),' . " W (PA)} and the product of w (PI) = W (p) by an elementary symmetric function of {w (P2),' .. , w (PA)} of lower order. ThuB it follows by induction that the a., are analytic functions of p. By Theorem 6,
w
(271'i)-n
J
g(p)w(p, q)[fI(p)-fl(q)J-l
. [fn(P)-f.,(q)J-ldfl(P)··
dfn(P)
Br
=
li(f(q»,
where h is the function on P defined by
h(p) =g(p)w(p,q). By Definition 10,
li(z)
=
h(pd
+. .+ h(PA) =g(Pl)W(PI,q)
Thus to compute li(f(q»
we replace {PI"
+ .
+ . ·+g(PA)w(PX,q). ',px} by {ql,
. ',qx}, obtaining
li(f(q» =g(ql)W(ql,q) '+g(qx)w(qX,q) =g(q)iiJ(q,q) =g(q)w(q)
182
l'AN'.l'.lALLX
Al'oIALX .lll'
!:)J:'A"..,.<>.
since q, = q and iii (qi, q) = 0 for 2 <: i <: A. Since h is analytic on P, n is analytic on En, so that h 0 f = gw is analytic on P. Taking g = 1 it follows that iii is analytic on P.
5.
Mappings into higher dimensional spaces.
The following lemma
continues the study of special analytic polyhedra. LEMMA 6. Let P be a special analytic polyhedron in a partially analytic space K defined by functions f,,' . ,fn in ~. Let
Pr
P n {p: I fi (p)
=
I < r, 1 <: i <: n}
< <
for 0 r 1. Let ~r be the uniform closure of ~ on Pr , so that ~r is a Banach algebra in the uniform norm. If a is any bounded mUltiplicative linear functional on ~" then there exists a point po in P r such that .. a(g) =g(po), all g in ~rIf in addition 1 E ~r and ~r separates points of P" there exists a function cp in ~r which has the value 1 on any open and closed set in P r and the value 0 on its complement. Proof.
Since a is bounded, Zo
=
I a(fi) I <: r
for 1 <: i <: n.
Thus
(a(f,),' . " a(fn)) E En r.
We wish to show that there exists Po in Pr with f(po) =Zo and a(g) =g(po) for all g in~. Assume that this is not the case. Then there exists gi in ~ with gi(pOi) =;1= a (gi) for each pOi in ",(zo) = {pO,," ,p\}. There therefore exists a linear combination go of g" ", gA such that go (pOi) =;1= a(go), 1 <: i <: A. :For each z in En and each i with 1 <: i <: A write
\ where {PI, " , PAl = " , (z) and" here j,,' ,ji runs over all combinations ' of the integers 1, ,A taken i at a time. By Lemma 5, 8; is an analytic function on En. If we let Si = 0; 0 f, then clearly A _
(gO)A
+.L Oi(gO)A-i =
0
i=l
identically on P, since A
[go(p)]A
+ .L 8 (p)[go(p) ]A-i i
A
=
i=l
II
(go (p) -
gO(Pi»
=
0
i=l
for all p in P. Since 8i is analytic on En, it can be uniformly approximated on f (P r) = Enr by polynomials F in z,' " , Zn. Therefore 8i can be uniformly
183
236
ERRETT BISHOP.
approxImated on P r by polynomials F in f1" is continuous, we have
. " fn.
Hence
S; E ~r'
Since a
0'(8;) =O'[FU1,' ',fn)] =limF(
=
[O'(go) J"
A
+ ~ [8 (zo)] [a (go) F-i. i
i=l
Since ill (zo), . , il" (Zo) are the elementary s} mmetric functions of go (pol), ,go(p\), this implies that a(go) = go (pOi) for some i. This contradictlOn shows that a point po III Fr with the desired property exi~ts. Assume now that 1 E ~r. According to what we have just proved, P r is the ma.:.imal ideal space of the Banach algebra ~(,. Therefore according to a theorem 01 Silo, -Calderon-Arens, (see L1]), the function 1> exists. TIlEOHE~I
8. Let J{ be a lI;eakly holonlO1 jJh~cally con~ex partially analytic the 1n(uilnum of the dimensions of lI;ho~e ~tructure manifolds i~ n Let each n-dimenstonal structure manifold be open and let their union .l/ o be denle in K. Let ~r contain the unit fundion and separate points of K. For each [,ub:,et r of ~r let each compact component Yo of each level set Y of r onK con~i~t of Just one point, which i~isolated in Y. Let f= (f1' . ',fn), fi E ~r, be an almo~t proper map of K into Let {8d be a sequence of compact :,ubsets of K, with U 81. = K and 8/" C interior 8/"+1, each of wI! ich has a finite number of component~. Let 2;, 1 < i < n, be po~itice functions of a real rariable x, with limHOC2,(r) =00. F01 r > let ~}Jace,
en.
°
D,={z'
zEC",
[z,[
For each positive intege! 7c let HI, be the union of tlwoSe componentl of j-1(Ih) which intersect 8/... lI'rite
for 7c > 1 Write Go = H l ' For each non-negatil e integer 7c let A.k be any function in ~r and Ek < 1 a positire 1 eal number. Then H k is compact and there e.rists fnn in ~r wch that 7c=O,1,2,
The map ( #)
1=
f X fn+1 of ]{ into e,,+1 inf
pE
G.
i~
proper if
[ A.h (p) [ ~ 00 as k ~ 00 .
184
:.\is'l
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
If S is a countable subset of M o at each point of which rank f < nand rank m: = n, f"+1 can in addition be chosen to have the property (*) rank (/,,' " f,H1) = 1 rank f at each point of S. The function f"+1 can also be chosen to have the property (:) of taking distinct values at the points of a given countable subset of K.
+
Proof. Let Q be any component of j-1 (D j ). Since Q is a subset of some component of j-1 (Dj), Q is compact. Thus Q is an analytic polyhedron with frame K defined by multiples of the functions f,,' . " tn. Since each level set of on Q is closed in Q, and therefore compact, it follows from the hypotheses of the theorem that such level sets are finite. Therefore Q is a special analytic polyhedron. For k given, choose j so large that f(SI.) CD;. Thus each component of Sk is contained in some Q, so that a finite number of such Q cover Sk. The union Q of these Q is an analytic polyhedron. Clearly IIk C Q, so that II.,. is compact. "Ve conbtruct by induetion functions go, g" . in il( such that for all k=>l I gdp) I < £k2-(k+l) for p in Ih and for all k => 0
t
For this purpose there is no loss of generality in assuming that £k+1 < £k for all k. Choose go = '\0, and a'>sume that go, . ,gk-l have been chosen with the abovc properties. Let r be a real number with k <:: r < k 1. From the compactness of IIk+1 it follows that
+
pr=II k +1 n j-l(D r ) is an analytic pol}hedron with frame K, defined by multiples of the functionSx ,tn. It follows, as above for the analytic polyhedron Q, that pr is a, special analytic polyhedron. By Theorem 0, pr has only a finite number or component" .•\.1;;0 by Theorem 5, applied to pr, it is eabY to see if k < r < k 1 that Hk+1 n j-1(iJ",) = {p: p E pr, I /i(p) I <:: lXi(k), 1 <:: i <:: n}
t,,··
+
is the closure of the set pk = j-' (D k ) n H 1.+1. number or components, the set
GkU II k =
t-
1
Since pk has only a finite
(Dk) nH/"+1
has only a finite number of components. By the definition of II k , Hk is the union of certain components of Gk U H k; thererore Gk is the union of the remaining components of Gk U H k. Thus Gk and H k are disjoint closed sets.
185
238
ERRETT BISHOP.
+
Since Gk U Hk is the intersection of the nested compact sets pr, k < r < k 1, there therefore exists a value of r in the range such that the finite number of components of G k U Hk all belong to separate components of pro
Then
Gk belongs to an open and closed set W in pr and HI< belongs to p~ - W. It follows from Lemma 6 that there exists a function T in m which is arbitrarily near to 0 on Hk and to 1 on Gk • Write
gk = -T[go
+ ... + gk-l-Ak].
It is then clear that gk has the desired properties if 1 on Hk and Gk respectively. Define
T
is near enough to 0 and
'l'his series converges uniformly on HI. "ince for j >- k
N ow if ~ is any com pact subset of K, there exists j wi th ~ C 8 j. If k > j is chosen so large that f(8 j ) C D k , it follows that ~ C 8 j C H k • Therefore the series for fn+l is well-defined and lies in m. For p in Gk we have
I Adp) -fn+l(P) I < I Ak(P) -
k
~ gj(p) ;=0
< t~k + ;=k+l ~ ,,,2-
j
<
I+
""
~
I g;(p) I
;=k+l
fIe·
Thus the function f1l+1 satisfies the required inequalities. An obvious modification of the proof yields a function f7Hl which in addition has properties (*) and I t remains to show that f X f n+1 = 1 is proper if the condItion (#) is satisfied. Consider p in 1-1 (F,,), where Fk = D" X {z: z E Ct, I z I < k}. Let j be the smallest integer >- k such that p E H j . If j> k, then p is in Gj - 1 • Therefore
un.
It follows from condition (#) that this can happen for only a finite number of values of i. Therefore 1-1 (F,,) is contained in the union of H k and such H j . Since H j and HI.. are compact, this implies that 1 is proper, as was to be proved. The hypothesis in the last theorem, and also in the following theorem, that compact components Vo of V consist of just one point" which is isolated in V, is in fact unnecessary if K is a complex space. This can be seen from
186
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
239
results of Stein [l1J, which states that if f is an analytic mapping of a complex space K having the property that the components of the level sets of f on K are compact then it is possible to introduce an analytic structure into the class k of such components in such a way that the natural map of K into k is analytic. However, we will not pursue this question here. THEOREM
9. Let K be a weakly holomorphically convex partially analytic
space, the maximum of the dimensions of whose structure manifolds is n. Let each n-dimensional structure manifold be open and let their union Mo be dense in K. Let ~ contain the unit function and separate points of K. For each subset r of ~ let each compact component Va of each level set of V on K consist of just one point, which is isolated in V. Let K be the union of a sequence Sk of compact sets, each having a finite number of components, with Sk C interior Skn. Let J.I be a particular n-dimensional structure manifold of K, such that ~ has rank n at each point of M. Let G be the set of functions (fl'· . . , f2Ml) in 2n+l~ such that
(i) (ii)
f
=
(fl'·
., fn) is almost proper,
1= (fl' . . ,ffl+l)
is proper,
(iii)
the rank of (fl,· .. , f2") at each point of M is n,
(iv)
the functions (fl,· .. , f211+l) separate points of M.
Then G is dense in
2n+l~.
Proof. By Theorem 4, the elements f in n~ which are almost proper are dense Fix such an element f. If V is a level set of f, each component Va of V is compact because f is almost proper. It follows from the hypothes~s of the theorem that Va consists of one point, which is isolated in V. Therefore V is countable, so that all level sets of f are countable. For 1 < i < n let A at consist of all points in M at which rank f < i. Each of these sets is analytic in M and A C A °i+l. Clearly
0.
dim A 0"
< dim M =
n,
since f, whose level sets are countable, must have rank n at some point of lrI. We now show inductively, starting with i = n and working backward, that dim A °i < i. Assume therefore that dim A °in < i 1. Let the analytic set A °i+l be written as the union of submanifolds {Ni+l'Y} of JI, and let {Ni+lll} consist of those Ni+l'Y of dimension i. To show dim A < i, it will be sufficient to show that A 0, does not contain any of the Ni+lll . For if this is the case the inclusion A io C A °in implies that A °i is contained in the union of certain
+
0.
187
240
ERRETT BISHOP.
proper analytic subsets of the Ni+lf3 and of the Ni+1'Y of dimension less than i. so that dim A °i < i. To see that Ni+1f3 q: A °i, note that t has rank i at some point of Ni+1f3, since its level sets are countable and dim Ni+1f3 = i. This completes the proof that dim A °i < i. Let S be a countable dense set in M. For each Nif3, 1 < i < n, choose a point p i f3 in Nif3 at which the rank of t is at least i - I . Let II be the f'et of all tn+1 in ~r such that 1 = t X tn+1 is proper, sueh that 1 has rank i on N at the point pif3 for each i and (3, and such that tn+1 takes distinct ,alues at the points of the set j-1(S). By Theorem 8, there exists tn+1 in H such that
I tn+1(p) -A(p) 1<
£
for all p in Go = H1 where II1 is defined as in Theorem 8, where A is any function in ~r, and where £ > O. Since by an appropriate choice of the sequrnce {Sd and the functions IXi of Theorem 8 the set H1 can be made to contain any compact subset of K, it follows that H is dense in W. We now choose the functions tn+2, . ,t2n+1 by induction. Assuming that t n+1, . . ,tn+'" haye been chosen, let A ki' 1 < i < n, consist of all points in 1',1 at which t1' . ,tn+'" have rank less than i. Clearly each A\ is an analytic subset of 1',[. Let B~ consist of all points in J[ -A"'n which are identified with some other point of ]1,[ by the functions t1' ,tn+"" Since 1 is proper, the points in K which are identified with a given point pin Bk by the functions t1)' . " tn+k form a compact set L. By the hypothesis of the theorem it follows that L is finite. Let p = P1," ,Pi be the points of J[ n L. Let £ be a small positive number and write
gi =
£-1
(fi - ti (p) ),
1
Since t is almost proper g = (gl," ,gn) IS almost proper. Therefore each component of g-l (En) is an analytic polyhedron defined by g with frame K. Let Pm be that component of g-l (En) which contains pm, 1 < m < j. For a fixed m the intersection 1m of the Pm, taken for all values of £, is clearly a subset of the countable discrete set j-1 (f (p) ). Since 1m is also the intersection of the Pm, which are nested connected compact sets, it follows that 1m is connected. Hence 1m = {pm}. It follows that £ can be chosen so small that P 1, " Pi are disjoint subsets of M. We can also choose £ so small that (f1," ,tn+k) is one-to-one on P 1, since p,=pEM-Akn. Write 1
n+ k,
h = (h " . " hn+k)' It follows by an argument similar to the one just useel that there exists a neighborhood U C P 1 of p such that
188
PARTIALLY ANALYTIC SPACES.
Now h map" Pm properly into En X OJ.., since P'" is an analytic polyhedron defined by g= (hl' ·,hn). Let W",=h(P m). Since h is proper on Pm, it follows from a standard result ([9J, Satz 23) that Wm is an analytic subset U Wi is analytic. ThU'l Un h-' (ll') of En X OJ.. Thus W = lV, U = U n B .. is an analytic subset of U. Since 1) was any point in B ,,, it follows that B " is locally analyti(·. We choose the functions t n+2," ,t2n+l by induction to be arbitTarily close to given functions in ~r on a given compact subset of K and to have the properties uimA\ < ma"\: {O,i-7c}, uim B ..
< n-
7c
+ 1.
t
'We first check that thc function n+l already cho<;en has these propertics. Since 1 has rank i on !vi at p i f3' it follows that 'P i intert'ects Ni/3 in a proper subset, which therefore has dimension at most i - 2. Since A \ c A °i, it then follows as above that dim A \ < i - 2. Let}J be any point in S - A. In. By the choice of tMl we see that ]J ¢ B l • Thus Bl is a proper analytic subset of the manifold M -Aln; it follows that dimB l < n. "\.ssnme now that t" . ,t/Hk have been chosen so that the above dimension inequalities are true. Write A\=
U Nf3 il" /3
a countable union of submanifolds of M.
Write
B .. =UJ/3, Il
a countable umon of submanifolds of J1. N ow if i -lc > 0, consider Nil." of dimension i - lc - 1, the maximum possible dimension by the induction hypothesis. Since Nf3 i .. q::Aki _ 1, (f,," ,tn+/") have rank at least i - I at some point pf3i l.. of Nf3ih • Thus tn+/"+l can be chosen to be arbitrarily close to a given function in ~ on a given compact subset of K anu to have the property that tl' . ,tll+k+1 has rank i at pf3ik for each pllil'" It follows then that dim A /.,+\
< max {O, i-7c -I}.
The function t n+I..+1 can be chosen to have the additional property that each J /3 contains some point p not identified by n+/"+l with any of the points which f" . ,t,,+l.. identify with p. Thus P is not in B k+1, so that Bk+1 intersects J/3 in a set of dimension at most (dim J/3) - 1 < (dim B .. ) - 1 < n-7c. Since
t
it follows that 3
189
242
ERRETT BISHOP.
dimBk+l < max{dimAk", dimB,,+!
n J p } < n-7c =n- (7c + 1)
+ 1.
Thus the functions fl" . " f"Hl with the desired properties are dense in 2"+1~r. Now (iii) follows from the fact that dim An" so that A"" is void. void and that dimB,,+!
< max {O,n-n} =0,
Finally, (iv) follows from the fact that A "+1.. cAn..
< n - (n + 1) + 1 =
IS
0, so that Bn+l is void.
This completes the proof. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY.
REFERENCES.
[1] R. Arens and A. P. Calderon, "Analytic functions of several Banach algebra
elements," Annals of Mathematics, vol. 62 (1955), pp. 204-216. [2] H. Behnke and K. Stein, "Modification komplexer Mannigfaltigkeiten und Riemannscher Gebiete," Mathematische Annalen, vol. 124 (1955), pp. 1-16. [3] S. Bergmann, "tiber eine in gewissen Bereichen mit Maximumflache giIltige Integral darstellung der Funktionen zweier komplexer Variabler," Mathematische Zeitschrift, voL 3'9 (1934), pp. 76-94. [4] H. Cartan, Seminaire Ecole Normale Superieure, 1951 1952. [5] - - - , Seminaire Ecole Normale Superieure, 1953-1954. [6] H. Grauert, "Characterzierung der holomorphvolstiindigen komplexen Rii.ume,"
Mathematische Annalen, voL 129 (1955), pp. 233-259. [7] W. Hurewicz and H. Wallman, Dimension theory, Princeton, 1948. [8] R. Remmert, "Sur les espaces analytiques holomorphiquement separables et holo-
[9]
[10] [11] [12] [13]
morphiquement convexes," Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Seances de l'Academie des Sciences, Paris, vol. 243 (1956), pp. 118-121. - - - , "Holomorphe und meromorphe Abbildungen komplexer Raume," Mathematische Annalen, vol. 133 (1957), pp. 328370. H. Rossi, Analytic spaces, U. S. Air Force technical report, Princeton University, 1960_ K. Stein, "Analytische Zerlegungen komplexer Raume," Mathematische Annalen, vol. 132 (1956), pp_ 63-93. - - - and R. Remmert, .. tiber die wesentlichen Singularitaten analytischer Mengen," ibid., vol. 126 (1953), pp. 263 306. A. Weil, .. L'integrale de Cauchy et les fonctions de plusieurs variables," ibid, vol. III (1935), pp_ 178-182.
190
SOME GLOBAL PROBLEMS IN THE THEORY OF FUNCTIONS OF SEVERAL COMPLEX VARIABLES. * By ERRETT BISHOP.'
1. Introduction. In a previous paper [2] the global structure of a complex analytic variety was examined ill some detail The present paper is a sequel containing some application of those results. In order that thi~ paper be ~elf-colltained. the definitions and results of [2] are summarized in SectIOn 2 Consider HOW an analytic !>ubset L of a Stem manifold K. It is a consequence of Theorems A and B of [3] that
I The set L is the set of common zeros of Rome family r of analytic functions on [( II. If L IS a sllbmanIfold of K then every analytic function on Lean be extended to an analytic function on K PrevIOus work on Problems I and II was done by Oka [5], r6], and others. In Section 3 we give new proofs of I and II which are independent of sheaf theory. The proof of I contains an explicit formula for the functions in the class r, and in thiR respeC't gives information which is not available from the sheaf-theoretic proof. Slmilarly the proof of II contains a specific formula for the extension of a function analytic on L to a function analytic on K. This formula makes it clear that II continues to hold tor analytic functions whose values lie in a Banach space, thus answering a question posed by H. Rossi in a conversation with the author. In Section 4 we prove that the first cohomology group of the shea:! of germs of holomorphic functions on a Stein manifold is trivial. Again tb~s result follows from sheaf theory [3]. Previous work was done by Cousin [4], Oka [5], [6], [7J, and others. Since it is the purpose of this paper to proceed independently of sheaf theory, this result is formulated and proved without mention of sheaves or cohomology. As is well-known, the EOlutions to Cousin's first and second problems are consquences of this result. The techniques which we use for solving these problems are all essentially similar. Since all of the problems considered have previously been solved, • Received December 27, 1960. 'This work was supported by the Sloan Foundation and the National Science Foundation
479
191
480
ERRETT BISHOP.
we have not attemptt'd to push the theory to the limit of its generality. It should however be clear to someone familiar with the subject that the
methods employed here are capable of handling the same problems in greater generality. These methods, which seem not to afford so powerful a general approach to these questions as does the theory of sheaves, nevertheless have the advantages of explicitness and simplicity. The gain in explicitness comes from the use of explicit formulas to construct the various analytic functions which arise. These formulas make it clear, for instance, that all of the above mentioned results hold for Banach space valued analytic functions. 2. Preliminaries. In order not to burden the exposition with too much generality (as was done in [2]), we confine our attention to Stein manifolds, merely remarking that there are obvious possibilities for generalizing the results to one type or another of analytic space.
Definition 1. A Stein manifold K of dimension n is an n-dimensional separable complex analytic manifold K having the following properties where A (K) denotes the set of analytic functions on K (a) (b)
For each pair (p, q) of distinct points in K there exists f in ..L (K) with f(p) =l=1(q)· For each p in K there exist 11, ,I.. in A (K) which m