Seepage Hydraulics
DEVELOPMENTS IN WATER SCIENCE, 10 advisory editor VEN TE C H O W Professor of Civil and Hydrosyste...
407 downloads
3403 Views
35MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Seepage Hydraulics
DEVELOPMENTS IN WATER SCIENCE, 10 advisory editor VEN TE C H O W Professor of Civil and Hydrosystems Engineering Hydrosystems Laboratory University of Illinois Urbana, IL.. U. S. A. OTHER TITLES IN THIS SERIES I G. BUGLIARELLO A N D F. GUNTER COMPUTER SYSTEMS A N D WATER RESOURCES 2 H. L. GOLTERMAN PHYSIOLOGICAL LIMNOLOGY
3 Y. Y. HAIMES, W. A. H A L L and H. T. FREEDMAN MULTIOBJECTIVE OPTIMIZATION IN WATER RESOURCES SYSTEMS: THE SURROGATE WORTH TRADE-OFF METHOD
4 J. J. FRIED GROUNDWATER POL LUTlON 5 N. RAJARATNAM TURBULENT JETS
6 D. STEPHENSON PIPELINE DESIGN FOR WATER ENGINEERS
7 V. HALEK A N D J. SVEC GROUNDWATER HYDRAU LlCS 8 J. BALEK HYDROLOGY A N D WATER RESOURCES IN TROPICAL AFRICA 9 T. A. McMAHON A N D R. G. MElN RESERVOIR CAPACITY A N D YIELD 10 G. KOVACS SEEPAGE HYDRAULICS
11 W. H. GRAF A N D C. H. MORTIMER (EDITORS) HYDRODYNAMICS OF LAKES
12 W. BACK A N D D. A. STEPHENSON (EDITORS) CONTEMPORARY HYDROGEOLOGY
Seepage Hydraulics Gyorgy K o v k s Corresponding Member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences Director-General of the Research Centre of Water Resources Development (VITUKI) Budapest, Hungary
Elsevier Scientific Pubtishing Company Amsterdam
Oxford
New York i981
This book is the revised English version of the "A sziv6rgds hidraulikdja" published by Akademiai Kiad6. Budapest Translated by Katalin Kovdcs The distribution of this book i s being handled by the following publishers and Canada Elsevier North-Holland, Inc. 52 Vanderbilt Avenue New York. New York 10017, U.S.A.
for the U.S.A.
for the East European countries, Democratic People's Republic of Korea, People's Republic of China. People's Republic of Mongolia, Republic of Cuba and Socialist Republic of Vietnam
Akademiai Kiad6, The Publishing House of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest for a11 remaining areas
Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company 335 Jan van Galenstraat P. 0. Box 211, lo00 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Kovdcs. Gyorgy, 1925Seepage hydraulics. (Developments in water science ; 10) Translation of A szivdrgds hidraulikdja. Bibliography: p. Includes index. 1. Seepage. 2. Groundwater flow. 1. Title. II. Series. TCI 76.K6813 627'.17 ISBN 0 -444- 99755 5 ISBN 0-444-41669-2 (Series)
-
0 Akadimiai
80-20236
Kiad6, Budapest 1981
Joint edition published by Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam, The Netherlands and A k a d h i a i Kiad6, The Publishing House of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary Printed in Hungary
Preface
Seepage hydraulics, a relatively small branch of hydro- and aeromechanics, deals in general with the properties, the behaviour and the motion of liquid and gmeous media. Its methodology differs basically, however, from that applied to investigating other transport processes of fluids or gases. The main differences result from the special structure of the flow-domain in which the seepage develops. Most of this flow-domain is filled with solid particles; the movement of water or other fluid is only possible through randomly interconnected channels. These channels are of a size which varies considerably and are composed either of the pores surrounded by the grain3 or of fissures and fractures. From this definition of seepage i t can be seen that seepage hydraulics covers bordering fields of the earth sciences, physics and technical sciences. The role of the earth sciences is to determine the properties of the solid matrix. The principles of physics are utilized to describe the transport and storage processes effected by means of the versatile system of water-conveying interstices and to derive the basic relationships between the kinematic parameters by using applied mathematics. The solution of practical problems by simultaneously satisfying the kinematic equations and the boundary conditions developing along the perimeter of the flow-domain (which condition may represent either natural effects or man-induced actions) belongs to the technical sciences. There are numerous handbooks already published concerning the problems of flow through porous media. Some of them give excellent summaries of applied mathematics related to seepage. Others give similarly good physical and mathematical treatments of flow theory. I n another group, the geological approach ie emphasized by dealing mostly with the characterization of the solid matrix and with the description of its behaviour. The new feature of this book is that i t provides an integrated system covering the entire field of seepage hydraulics and i t presents solutions for practising engineers without neglecting the scientific background. It is hoped that the different approaches (theoretical and practical; mathematical and physical) and the various scientific aspects (hydraulics, hydrology, geology, soil science) a m presented in a balanced form in relation to:
6
the characterization of porous media, the dynamic analysis of the acting processes, and the kinematic description of the transport of fluids. It is also hoped that the book will provide guidance towards the complete solution of the problems, ensuring thereby not only a firm theoretical basis for the investigations but also their practical application. Large numbers of experimental and field data are summarized in the tables; these should be of value to those who wish to use the book for further research. This manualwaa written primarily forhydraulic engineers; apart from them it can be used also by others who need to solve various problems related to the movement o i subsurface water in geology, mining, civil and geotechnical engeneering, agricultural sciences (land reclamation, irrigation and drain&ge) etc. The book was first published in Hungarian in 1972. For the English version the original version has been completely revised and up-dated to include the latest developments, which have been extremely rapid in the first half of the 1970s. Important new parts concerning seepage through fractured rocks and unsaturated media have been added. -
Dr. Gyiirgy Kovdcs
Contents
Part 1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Chapkr 1 . 1 General characterization of subsurface water and its movement 1.1.1 Classificationof the various types of subsurface water 1.1.2 Characterization of flow through various aquifers 1.1.3 T h e definition of seepage References to Chapter 1.1
....
........ ........... ................................ ........................................
Chapter 1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of loose clastic sediments influencing permeability 1.2.1 The size and shape of grains forming a layer 1.2.2 Investigation of grain-size distribution 1.2.3 Mineralogical composition of sediments and its influence on the determination of the effective diameter 1.2.4 Relationship between porosity and the geometrical parameters of grains 1.2.5 Physical model representing the irregular network of pores and channels between grains References to Chapter 1.2
...................................... ................. .................... ..................
............................................. ................................
.......................................
.................
Chapter 1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture above the water table 1.3.1 General characterization of soil moisture and processes acting in the soil-moisture zone 1.3.2 Parameters characterizingthe various moisture content8 of soil samples 1.3.3 Interpretation of field capacity, gravitational porosity and soil-moisture retention curve 1.3.4 Description and determination of the soil-moisture retention curve References to Chapter 1.3
................................ .............................................. ............................
................................................ ....................................... Chapter 1.4 Investigation of the balance of the ground-water space ............ 1.4.1 General hydrological characterization of water exchange between soil moisture and ground water ....................
13 13 20 28
37 38 39 43
60 76
87 94 98 99 104 109 123 146 147 148
8
Contents
............................. .................... ............................... .......................................
1.4.2 Storage capacity of aquifers 1.4.3 Analyeis of horizontal ground-water flow for the determination of the vertical water exchange 1.4.4 Interpretation and determination of the characteristic curve of the ground-water balance References to Chapter 1.4
153 178 188 199
Part 2 Dynamic interpretation and determination of hydraulic conductivity in homogeneous loose clastic sediments
.................................. ................. ....................................... ................... ........................................
Chapter 2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage 202 203 2.1.1 Forces influencing the flow between grains 2.1.2 Dimensionless numbers characterizing the various validity zones of seepage 226 2.1.3 Numerical limits of the zones of seepage 230 References to Chapter 2.1 238
..................... ........... ...........................
Chapter 2.2 Hydraulic conductivity of saturated layers 239 2.2.1 Determination of D ~ C Y ’hydraulic B conductivity 240 2.2.2 Investigation of the turbulent and transition zones of seepage 251 2.2.3 Investigation of microseepage 269 References to Chapter 2.2 281
.......................................
........................... 283 284 ............ 293
Chapter 2.3 Seepage through unsaturated layers 2.3.1 Movement equations characterizing unsaturated flow ........ 2.3.2 Physical soil paremeters used in diffusion theory 2.3.3 Theoretical analysis of hydraulic conductivity in unsaturated porousmedia References to Chapter 2.3
.......................................... .......................................
301 314
Part 3 Permeability of natural layers and processes influencing its change in time
Chapter 3.1 Characterization of special behaviour of hydraulic conductivity in loose claatic sediments 3.1.1 Laboratory and field methods to determine permeability .... 3.1.2 Evaluation of pumping tests with more observation wells 3.1.3 Characterization. determination and practical consideration of anisotropy References to Chapter 3.1
.......................................
.... ............................................
........................................
318 319 326 338 348
........ 349 ...................... 351 ............................. 362 ................. 369 ........................................ 378
Chapter 3.2 The motion of grains in cohesionless loose claatic sediments 3.2.1 The motion of f h e grains (suffusion) 3.2.2 T h e liquidization of the layer 3.2.3 Design of protective filters and well screens References to Chapter 3.2
9
Contents Chapter 3.3 Investigation of clogging .................................... 3.3.1 The change of concentration of the percolating water depending on time and place ................................... 3.3.2 Application of the capillary tube model of the porous medium to characterize the clogging process ...................... References to Chapter 3.3
380
381 387
........................................ 395
Chapter 3.4 Hydraulic conductivity and intrinsic permeability of fissured and fractured rocks ........................................ 3.4.1 Characterization of various non.carbonate, water.bearing, fissuredandfracturedrocks .............................. 3.4.2 Hydraulic properties of carbonate rocks ................... 3.4.3 Models for the characterization of flow through the openings of solid rocks ............................................ 3.4.4 A conceptual model for the determination of hydraulic conductivity of fissured rocks .............................. References to Chapter 3.4
........................................
396 397 417 437 454 470
Part 4 Kinematic characterization of seepage
Chapter 4.1 Kinematic relationships characterizing laminar seepage ........... 475 4.1.1 Interpretation of velocity-potential and potential water 476 movement ............................................ 4.1.2 Interrelation between stream-function and potentia1.function Theflownet ........................................... 482 4.1.3 Geometrical and kinematic classification of seepage .......... 493 References to Chapter 4.1 ....................................... 504
.
Chapter 4.2 Boundary and initial conditions of potential flow through porous media ............................................... 505 4.2.1 Characterization of external boundary conditions ........... 506 4.2.2 T h e investigation of the layered seepage field ............... 519 4.2.3 Application of hodograph image and other special transformations for the characterization of boundary conditions ........ 529 4.2.4 Consideration of initial conditions ........................ 539 References to Chapter 4.2 ........................................ 541 Chapter 4.3 Kinematic characterization of non-laminar seepage .............. 4.3.1 Differential equations equivalent t o Laplece’s equations for the various zones of seepage ............................. 4.3.2 Consideration of the continuous change of the flow condition within the seepage field ................................. References to Chapter 4.3
........................................
542 543 549 555
10
Contents Part 5 Solution of movement equations describing seepage
............ ....................
Chapter 6.1 Characterization of two-dimensionalpotential seepage 660 6.1.1 Complex potential Conjugate velocity 663 6.1.2 Solution of seepage problems by applying mapping .......... 667 6.1.3 Basic mapping functions applied most frequently ........... 676 6.1.4 Application of Schwartz-Christoffel’s mapping ............. 686 References to Chapter 6.1 ........................................ 695
.
Chapter 5.2 Combined application of various mapping functions .............. 6.2.1 Application of a series of mapping functions within the flow plane of a two-dimensional seepage 6.2.2 Combination of mapping functions applied on two different planes of the flow space ................................. 6.2.3 Combined application of hodogreph and conformal mappings 6.2.4 Characterization of unconfined field by the application of Zhukovsky’s function Referencesto Chapter 6.2 ........................................
.......................
696 697 610
. . 616 ................................... 626
Chapter 6.3 Horizontal unconfined steady seepage (Dupuit’s equations and the limits of their application) 6.3.1 Derivation of Dupuit’s equations ......................... 6.3.2 The influence of the capillary water conveyance 6.3.3 Characterization of horizontal unconfined seepage influenced by accretion 6.3.4 Local resistance occurring in the vicinity of the entry and exit faces References to Chapter 6.3
626
627 ............................... 628 ............. 648 .......................................... 661 ................................................. 670
........................................
686
.................... 687 ........................ 688 ............... 696 ............ 704 ........................................ 712 Chapter 6.6 Model laws for sand box models ............................... 713 6.6.1 General derivation of model laws for hydraulic models ....... 714 6.6.2 Geometrically distorted sand box models ................... 719 722 References to Chapter 6.6 ....................................... Subject index ................................................... 723
Chapter 6.4 Investigation of horizontal unsteady seepage 6.4.1 Derivation of Boussinesq’s equations and the problems in connection with their linearization 6.4.2 Application of the differentialequation of unsteady flow to the characterization of seepage in an infinite field 6.4.3 Unsteady seepage in a horizontally limited field References to Chapter 6.4
Part 1
Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
The greatest amount of water on the globe is stored in the basins of oceans and seas. This water however, is salty, and therefore, unsuitable for direct congumption. Fresh water comprises only 2.8% of the total amount of water (i.e. about 37 million cubic kilometres) and is stored on and below the surface of the earth. It occurs in several different forms: ice and snow in polar areas and mountainous regions, ground water in the pores of aquifers, water in the beds of lakes and rivers, etc. Water stored below the surface of the earth in the form of soil moisture and ground water makes u p more than 20 % of the earth’s total fresh water resources. It is distributed almost equally over the continents, and its exploitation is a fundamental basis of water management in every country. Although only the smaller part of the total amount is available for direct use, (because the exploitation of water stored in clay, or at great depth is not yet economical) even this amount would be enough to meet the increased world demand for a very long period. It is not permissible however, to use up large quantities of stored water, because it is one of the basic elements of the biosphere, and some very serious changes would be caused by its absence (e.g. heat balance would be disturbed by the decrease in evaporation, or vegetation would be destroyed by lowering the water table over large areas). The tltored water - the so-called stutic water resource - haa t o be considered therefore, as a safety reservoir, from which water may be exploited on a limited scale, when its recharge is expected. For this reason, the amount of water replenished per annum on the surface of the continents in the form of precipitation is more important from the aspect of water reaources development, than the stored quantity. The detailed investigation of these dynamic resources involves the determination of parameters characterizing the subsurface branch of the hydrological cycle. This topic belongs to hydrology, especially ground-water hydrology. Another baaic requirement for this investigation is the study of the movement of water within the cycle, namely hydrodynamics. The investigation of the subterranean part of the hydrological cycle - the dynamics of flow through porous media - is also a fundamental part of the scientific background of water resources development. Apart from the analysis of this general flow system, many hydrodynamical problems have to be solved when designing the structures (wells, shafts, or
12
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
drains) through which the exploitation of ground water becomes possible. I n other cases, hydraulic structures (reservoirs, dams, canals) raise the level of surface waters above thenatural ground-water table, and thus, create seepage. Sometimes the position of the water table, and the moisture content of the upper soil have t o be controlled, either t o ensure higher agricultural production (land drainage, irrigation), or to create better environmental conditions (marsh reclamation). Similarly, the permanent or temporary modification of the position of the phreatic ground-water surface and/or the pressure condition of ground water might be the aim of special operations (dewatering of construction pits, protection of mines against water intrusion). The solution of all the problems related either to the design or the operation of the hydraulic structures listed, requires the investigation of water movement in various flow domains, the boundaries of which are determined by the geological structure of the layers. The boundary conditions are influenced by hydrological and hydrogeological phenomena, and the flow conditions are governed by the soil- or rock-mechanical properties of the beds in question. This short summary of the problems already indicates the multidisciplinary character of seepage hydraulics. It is basically part of hydromechanics, starting with the theoretical discussion of the kinematics and dynamics of water movement, and also including the practical application of the theoretical results. The fundamental topics of hydromechanics (e.g. interpretation and determination of mass, density, specific weight and viscosity of fluids, or that of hydrostatic pressure and its distribution) may be regarded as wellknown, and need not be repeated here. The reader is referred to existing manuals dealing with these basic concepts of hydrodynamics (e.g. NBmeth, 1963; Bear, 1972). At the same time, because of the multidisciplinary character of seepage hydraulics, i t is necessary to deal with some aspects of the interrelated sciences as well (e.g. hydrology, hydrogeology, mineralogy, soil phyeics, soil sciences, etc.), whichcan be regarded as fundamental to our discussion. Naturally, the same basic philosophy as mentioned in connection with hydromechanics is followed here, that is, that the principles of these sciences are not explained - only some special points having close connection with seepage hydraulics are considered. Those aspects are emphasized, which may influence the discussion of flow through porous media. Sometimes the method of discussion of topics taken from other scientific fields and summarized in Part 1 does not follow that generally used in the original literature. Slight modifications are made, or ideas further developed, to facilitate the easy application of the results in seepage hydraulics. It is hoped that these changes do not alter the basic concepts of the related sciences, and that contradictions are not caused by them.
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
13
Chapter 1.1 General characterization of subsurface water and i t s movement The first problem which hau to be solved before starting the detailed discussion of the various scientific topics is the establishment of a common terminology, so that misunderstandings can be avoided. The clarification of the definitions of terms used generally is necessary not only because the meanings of some expressions differ in different languages, but also because differences can be found in the literature of the various sciences written in the same language. To create a suitable framework for the comparison of the various expressions, and to clarify the defhitions used in this book, a short summary of basic hydrogeological concepts, and of expressions concerning the flow of water through porous media, will be given here as an introduction. This chapter includes, therefore, the analysis of the various effects influencing the character of water movement below the surface, and finally, the defhition of seepage itself. When establishing the proposed terminology, attempts were made to follow the definitions accepted in recently published international manuals and glossaries (UNESCO, 1972;FAO, 1972;FAO-UNESCO, 1973;IAHS, 1974; UNESCO-WMO, 1974). Changes - or more precisely supplementation were made only in a few cases, where the special character of some aspects of seepage hydraulics required them.
1.1.1 Classification of the various types of subsurface water
A considerable amount of the water falling on the continents in the form of precipitation infiltrates through the surface. This infiltrating water becomes part of the subsurface water, which is stored for either a short or a long period in the various interstices of the crust (pores, hollows, joints, fissures and fractures), and moves along the channels composed of these pores and openings. When investigating the hydrological processes occurring under the surface of the earth, the most important aspects to be considered are the part of the subsurface water plays in the entire hydrological cycle, and the characterization of both flow and storage in the layers as influenced by their structure, and physical characteristics. The subsurface waters can be classified in many different ways, taking their various properties into consideration as the basis of the classification (e.g. temperature, chemical composition, origin, character of movement, etc.). As explained earlier, the two most important aspects from the hydrological point of view are the character of the water-bearing layers and their connection with the meteorological and hydrological processes on and above the surface. According to the claasification based on these two parameters (Table 1.1-l),three different levels of subsurface water can be distinguished (soil moisture, shallow ground water and deep ground water). Each level can
14
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage Table 1.1-1. Hydrological classification of the various types of subsurface water B
L o w elastic sediment
I
Position
of aquifer
-(limestone, (dolomite) Karstio
gravel, send, silt, clay
Zone of aeration
I
Nan Laretic
moisture content of rocks
i Zone of eaturation
M i d rocka
cohive
2
3
-
shallow ground water
shallow karstic water
-~ deep ground water
deep kerstic water
Iw
~ ~ ~ ~ Of t e n t
in shallow position in deep position
be further divided into two main groups, considering those characteristics of the water-bearing layers, which influence the flow of water, and the process of its storage to the greatest extent (loose clastic sediments, or fissured and fractured solid rocks). Soil moisture is the water content of the pores in the soil above the water table, retained in various forms against gravity. The most important forces influencing the development of soil moisture are adhesion and capillarity. Adhesion creates a thin fllm of water covering the wall of the pores (adhesive water) while capillarity completely fills some of the pores with water (or all the pores, depending on the height above the water table of the point considered) (capillary water). In fissured and fractured solid rocks, the same type of water is called the moisture content of rocks. For the complete clarification of this definition, it is necessary to analyze the term water table as well. According t o the generally accepted meaning, it is the surface of unconfined ground water bodies dividing the ground water and the soil moisture zones. Another characteristic feature of the water table is that the pressure of the water included in the pores is equal here to that of the atmosphere. It is necessary t o note that the water table is not a real surface, because there is no rapid change in the saturation of pores at this level. Both the ground-water zone and the lower part of the capillary zone are completely saturated. The decrease in water content related to porosity starts gradually only in the upper reaches of the closed capillary zone, and it is continued in the open capillary zone. Thus the level of the water table is indicated only by the change in the sign of the water pressure - it is positive in the ground-water zone and negative (suction, tension) above the water table. It should be noted here that water pressure is always expressed in the form of excess pressure (p),i.e. the difference between the total ( p l ) and the atmospheric ( p o )value:
P = Pt
- Po.
(1.1-1)
This parameter becomes negative where and when the total pressure is lower than that caused by the atmosphere a t the time and place of the
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
15
investigation. The change in the sign of the excess pressure is naturally a gradual quantitative modification, and no qualitative difference occurs a t the boundary. Hence, the most important common characteristic of any type of soil moisture (and of the moisture content of rocks) is the negative pressure governing the behaviour and the movement of water in this zone. (A more detailed explanation of the various subzones of the soil moisture zone, and the description of the forces acting there, will be given in Chapter 1.3.) Having established a definition of “water table”, i t is relatively eaay to define the term most commonly used in this book. Qround water is that part of the subsurface water which is stored (or moves) in the interstices of the crust below the water table. Hence its total pressure is higher than the atmospheric one. This pressure may be hydrostatic, or influenced by the movement of water (hydraulic pressure), but its excess value is always positive. In the ground-water zone, all the pores and other types of interstices are completely filled with water (or with other fluids, and in exceptional cases, with gases under pressure). Considering the connection of ground water with the hydrological and meteorological processes on and above the surface, two groups may be distinguished: shallow and deep ground water. Shallow ground water is stored near the surface, below the water table and above the first, largely extended, continuous, impervious formation. It is directly influenced by meteorological and hydrological events (recharged by precipitation, drained by evaporation and transpiration, having interactions with surface waters). Deep ground water can be found in aquifers, lying below continuous, impervious beds, which hinder the direct contact between surface and ground water over a very large area, as well aa the influence of atmospheric prosesses on ground water. It hm no direct recharge from precipitation or surface waters, and is drained only through the shallow ground water. It is very difficult to make clear distinctions between the two types of ground water. Shallow ground water may be partly covered by impervious strata, but if the covering layers are not continuous or large enough, the effects of the meteorological and hydrological events can be clearly observed in the regime of the ground water. On the other hand, i t is also possible, that the aquifer covered by impervious formations over a large area may occur near the surface far from the place of investigation. Thus, the same groundwater body may be regarded aa deep within the investigated area, and shallow elsewhere. It is not possible therefore, to draw a sharp line between the two types. There are several transition forms, and the distinction can be baaed only on the investigation of the dominating factors influencing the ground-water regime. The means of this investigation are the observed ground-water data. Considering the rough sketch of the vertical section of a sedimentary basin given in Fig. 1.1-1, deep ground water may be divided into several subgroups: e.g. closed ground water, when the aquifer is completely surrounded by impervious layers; artesian water, which hm a recharge area where the water table is above the artesian area, and thus, the water level in wells tapping the artesian layer rises above the surface. The adjective
16
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Fig. 1.1-1. Rough vertical section of a sedimentary basin for representing the Various types of aquifers
confined (or unconfined) also indicates whether the water-bearing layer is covered by impervious formations or not. This term does not however, express the extension of the cover. Hence, it is suillcient for characterizing the behaviour of water movement in the aquifer, but not for that of its hydrological contact. It can well be used therefore, in seepage hydrtGulics without providing su5cient information for hydrogeologists. It can be seen from the foregoing that such expressions aa confined, closed or artesian aquifer have special meanings, and they do not completely characterize the hydrological behaviour of the water-bearing layers. It is advisable, therefore, to use the adjectives of shallow and deep for distinguishing ground water directly influenced by meteorological and hydrological phenomenon from that recharged or drained only through another part of the ground-water space. Several expressions have already been used to characterize the layers containing water, or hindering its movement: e.g. aquifer or water-bearing layer, impervious formation etc. Four terms are generally used t o describe the behaviour of strata with respect to the flow of water. These are as follows:
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
17
(a) Aquifers - permeable geological formations having interconnected interstices, which permit an appreciable quantity of water t o move through them under ordinary field conditions. Ground-water reservoir, waterbearing or permeable layer are commonly used synonyms. impermeable strata, which may contain a great quan(b) Aquicludes tity of water (in some cmes more than aquifers, e.g. clay). Some aquicludes do not transmit water at all, and others only a very small quantity. (c) Aquifuges - also impermeable formations but neither contain nor transmit water. These rocks have no interconnected pores or fissures and cannot therefore, either absorb water or allow it to pass through. Aquicludes and aquifuges are the two opposite types of impermeable geological formations. (d) Aquitard - a transition form between aquifers and aquicludes. This type of layer contains interconnected pores, but the water-conveying capacity of the channels made up of pores is relatively small compared to that in aquifers. However, if the direction of flow is perpendicular to the large bordering surface of such a layer, the amount of water conveyed by seepage is not negligible, because of the great extent of the area. These strata are often called semi-pervious or leaky formations. The hydrogeological terms listedin the previous paragraphs are not entirely sufficient for clwsifying the layer hydrologically, or from the point of view of seepage hydraulics. They indicate only the existence, or the lack of interconnected pores, and thus, the possibility of water movement, but do not describe the structure of the network composed of the interstices, which is one of the most important factors influencing the character of flow. The latter information is basically required t o classify the layers from the aspects of hydrology and hydraulics. Considering the origin of the various rocks, the geological classification distinguishes the following types:
-
Sediments - of mechanical origin: loose clastic sediments or cemented sediments; - of chemical origin; - of biological origin; Igneous rocks - effusive ( h e grained) volcanic rocks; - intermediate (porphyriiic) rocks; - intrusive (coarse grained) plutonic rocks; Metamorphic rocks. Because the water-conveying network in some of these formations (and hence, the character of the movement in or through the layers) are very similar, several geological groups may be combined when deciding the h a 1 form of the hydrological classification. The most important difference is between the network of pores in loose clastic sediments, and that of the fissures and fractures of solid rocks. Hence, these two main groups were selected as the basis of the hydrological classification. Within both groups, two further subgroups were distinguished: the non-cohesive loose clastic sediments are pervious formations, and the cohesive ones may be regarded 2
18
1 Fundament& for the investigation of seepage
as impervious, or semi-pervious layers, although there is a continuous transition between the two subgroups without any sharp borderline. In the group of solid rocks, it is reasonable to deal with the karstic formations separately. In these, the water-conveying openings are generally enlarged by chemical solution and mechanical erosion cawing high permeability.The other remaining subgroup is composed of non-karstic solid rocks. It can easily be seen that the structure of the basic classification summarized in Table 1.1-1 is also suitable to determine the relationship between
Fig.
absorbed fossil ,juvenile water water water _.Grouping c vsriouS types of mbsurface water according to their O L ~ J in he system of h~dmlogicalc l d o a t i q n
the hydrological c l d c a t i o n of subsurface water, and some other types of grouping baaed on different parameters of the water, or those of the layers containing it. The origin of water can be used as an example to show this (Fig. 1.1-2). It is well known that generally three types of subsurface water can be distinguished amording to their origin: internal water (juvenile water) is derived from the interior of the earth as anew resource; external water originates from atmospheric or surface water and may be trapped in rocks when the constituent material was deposited (fossil or connate water), or i t may be absorbed into the interstices of the layers some time after deposition, even quite recently (absorbed water) (UNESCO,1972). The amount of juvenile water is negligible from the point of view of water resources development. Coming from very great depths, its occurence in deep rather than shallow ground water is more probable. Because the upward movement of juvenile water generdy follows faults, larger amounts may be expected in solid rocks, where it sometimes rises into shallow positions. I n most cases, fossil water preserves its original characteristics (e.g. chemical composition) derived from the water-bearing layers in which it formed or into which it idltrated during their development. Changes may occur aa a result of water exchange between aquifers, for instanoe by migration and diffusion. For this reason, a higher ratio of fossil water may be expected
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
19
in layers where the movement of water is considerably hindered. Thus, the highest amount is probable in cohesive, loose, clastic sediments. Adsorbed water indicates the recent influence of meteorological and hydrological processes. It is quite evident that soil moisture is entirely, and shallow ground water almost completely composed of this type of water. Similar to the previous example, the interest of the various water oriented sciences in the multidisciplinary field of subsurface water can also be clearly represented in the proposed system of classification (Fig. 1.1-3).
nydrohydrology hydropedology mechanics geologi Fig. 1.1-3. The grouping of various types of subsurface water according to the sciences involved in the system of hydrological claasifkation
Soil moisture and part of shallow ground water ensuring the recharge of the former are the most important sources of water supply to plants, and they take part in the development of the various types of soils. Thus, the investigation of this part of subsurface water is an important field of soil science: i.e. hydropedology. The most important taak of hydrology is to explore the interrelationships between the various forms of water on the globe and to analyse its continUOUE movement along the hydrological cycle. When investigating subsurface water from the hydrological point of view, its contact with atmospheric and surface water aa well as the flow of water along the subsurface branch of the cycle have to be studied. The field of interest of hydrology is concentrated, therefore, mostly on soil moisture and shallow ground water, these having direct contact with hydrological and meteorological processes on and above the surface. This interest also extends partly t o deep ground water, which may join the hydrological cycle in the form of water exchange between deep and more shallow layers. The pores and other interstices of strata developed in geological ages are m e d with water. The presence, pressure, chemical composition and movement of water also influence the behaviour of the layers. Thus, the water itself is also part of the crust, and a topic of geology, a science which investigates the structure and composition of the crust. That part of geology which investigates the extension of water-bearing layers, their parameters in con2*
20
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
nection with the storage and movement of water, and the characteristics of ground-water is called hydrogeology. All three sciences mentioned in the previous paragraphs require the investigation of the movement of various types of subsurface water (infiltration; flow of water and air through unsaturated pores; confined or unconfined seepage of both shallow and deep ground water, etc.). The analysis of movement is part of physics, and, within this large field, that of mechanics. When dealing with the flow of fluids it is called hydromechanics. This branch of science - together with hydraulics which is a form of hydromechanics simplified and applied in engineering practice - supply important supplementary information for soil science and geology, as well as hydrology, and covers the entire domain of subsurface water.
1.1.2 Characterization of flow through various aquifers
As explained in the previous section, hydromechanics and hydraulics include the investigation of movement of all types of subsurface water. When further distictions have to be made according to the different forms of flow, it is necessary to analyse the parameters characterizing the movement of the previously selected groups of subsurface water. It has also been mentioned that the character of the flow is basically determined by the structure of the water-conveying network composed of the interconnected interstices of the layers. Apart from its structure, the instantaneous conditions of the network at the time of the movement (e.g. the rate of saturation, or the prevailing pressure condition) also provide important aspects for the classification of flow. The greater part of subsurface water (at least that water available for practical utilization, and economical exploitation) is stored in loose clastic sediments. The flow of ground water is, therefore, closely related t o the physical character of these aquifers. The pores between grains form randomly interconnected, complicated pipe- or channel-systems in such a layer. The resistance of these continuous but very tortuous channels has t o be overcome when water flows through the layer. The network of the waterconducting channels is generally equally distributed in these sediments, the contact between the pores being ensured in each direction with equal probability. Hence, in most cases these aquifers can be regarded as the homogeneous flow space of a porous medium limited by the neighbouring impervious formations. In connection with the previous statement, it can easily be seen from the description of the character of the channel network composed of the pores between grains, that the loose clmtic sediments satisfy the requirements set up in the definition of porous media by various authors (Bear et al., 1968; Bear, 1972), mostly in the form of relative terms. The solid matrix surrounds the pores, the significant majority of which are interconnected. The pores are filled with liquid and/or gases, and the pore size is relatively small compared to the whole aquifer. The specific surface (the internal surface dividing the different phases of the heterogeneous medium
1 . 1 General characterization of subsurface water
21
related to its total volume) is relatively high, and the phases of which the medium is composed, are present in each representative elementary volume. [The detailed interpretation of the representative elementary volume is based on the continuum approach of porous media (Bear, 1972). This is defined as the limit of the size of an elementary cube or sphere around an arbitrarily chosen point of the domain, above which the numerical parameters describing the structure of the multiphase medium (e.g. ratio of pores to the total volume, or specific surface) do not change considerably as a function of the size of the investigated body, but only have random fluctuation. Below this limit, the same parameters determined for a volume of the same shape may change in magnitude depending on the size in question (see Fig. 1.1-8).] The constancy of characteristic values determined for bodies larger than the representative elementary volume makes the elementary volume values characteristic of the whole aquifer. This reasoning, which is generally valid for loose clastic sediments, is the basis of the practice, which regards the aquifers as unified flow spaces. It has also been mentioned that in most cases, the pores are equally distributed in these formations, and the development of channels composed of the interconnected pores may be observed in all directions with equal probability. This is the basis of the theory which states that loose clastic sediments usually form homogeneous flow domains. Solid rocks having equally distributed pores, or a dense network of fine fissures, form unified flow domains similar to that of loose clastic sediments (sandstone, fractured dolomite). This is because the structure of the channels built up by these pores and fissures never or rarely differs from the network composed of the interconnected pores between individual grains. However, some differences may be caused by the different size of the pores (e.g. in sandstones the cementation decreases the size of the pores), or in fissured rocks the closed and open fissures may be oriented according to the main directions of geomechanical forces. Inhomogeneity may also result from porous solid rocks (sandstone, basaltic lava flows) because the permeability of the fractured zones is generally higher, than that of the whole mass of the formation. The development of fractures causes not only inhomogeneity of the flow domain, but also changes some of the characteristics of the formation. If the characteristics of the solid matrix are the function of the direction of flow, the domain is called anisotropic. Orientation of the interstices is more dominant in beds where water movement develops along the contact planes of thin layers. In this way, the flow in laminated rocks (e.g. slate, marl) may become two-dimensional, even if the movement extends to the total volume of the layer. Sometimes, the flow in the space of the aquifer may be further simplified and investigated as a one-dimensional movement in solid rocks, where flow can develop only along large openings or dissolved channels (e.g. karstic limestone), when the channels are not interconnected. Naturally these types of movement may be present simultaneously as well. For instance in limestone in addition to one-dimensional flow, or in sandstone in addition to the three-dimensional movement, there may develop two-dimensional flow along fractured zones. The latter may even become dominant. As another example, loose clastic
22
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
sediments can be mentioned, which may have anisotropic properties caused by varying conditions during the process of their deposition. In the previous paragraphs the structure of the flow domain, or that of the water conveying network was described only qualitatively. Even when describing porous media, relative terms were used and not numerical parameters. Naturally, quantitative values are also applied t o characterize the various aquifers, e.g. specific surface which has already been mentioned, or porosity, which is the most commonly used parameter. Porosity (or volumetric porosity) is defined a,s the ratio of the volume of void space to the bulk volume of the porous medium. When determining this parameter, one of the basic requirements is, that the investigated sample should be larger than the representative elementary volume (Bear, 1972). Another important aspect is t o distinguish the pores acting as part of the interconnected water-conveying network from those not taking part in water transport. The pores may be inactive, either because they are completely separated from the interconnected channels, or the same pores may form dead ends of the network, or the opening may be so small that the fluids contained in them are rendered essentially static by the close proximity of the force fields at the surface of the solid matrix (De Wiest et al., 1969). Taking into account the difference between the numerical values of the pore volume used as the basis of the calculation of porosity, different terms may be distinguished such as: (a) Total porosity, when the volume of all pores are related to that of the sample; (b) E8ective porosity considering only the pores available for the transmission of fluid in the porous medium; (c) Isolccted porosity due to separated and inactive interstices. The detailed analysis of porosity in loose clastic sediments will be given in Chapter 1.2, and some special aspects of determining porosity in solid rocks (e.g. interpretation of primary and secondary porosity; statistical evaluation of porosity in karstic formations) will be discussed in Part 3. It is also necessary to note that there are other interpretations of porosity which differ from that given previously as the ratio of pore volume to total volume, and which is called volumetric porosity. The other possible msthods of determining porosity are the calculation of linear and areal values (Fig. 1.1-4).
Analysing the porosity of a sample along a line, the lengths of the pores are related to the total length of the sample. The calculated ratio is the parameter called linear porosity: k
n , =-1-1
Ax
(1.1-2) *
Similarly, the sum of the arew of the pores in a given section has to be related t o the total area of ths cross section t o obtain areal porosity:
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
23
(1.1-3)
Special relationships exist between the various parameters of porosity, on the basis of which they can be substituted by each other. The average areal porosity can be calculated aa the mean value of the same parameters
------Fig. 1.1-4. Interpretation of linear, areal, and volumetric porosities
determined for several parallel sections. If the distances between the sections are not equal t o each other, the areal porosities measured in various sections have to be adjusted according to the length of the sample belonging to the section in question. Assuming that the element distance is small ( d z ) and the change in areal porosity in the direction of the z axis is given by a continuous function m(z) the calculation of the average value can be expressed in the form of an integral:
where S is the total area of the cross section (S = Ax Ay in the figure) and the s h ( 2 ) fundion expresses the sum of the area of pores in the sections depending on its position [thus, sh(z)= Sm(z)].It is evident, therefore, that the length of the sample multiplied by the area of the cross section is equal to the volume of the sample ( V ) ,in prismatic or cylindrical samples. The integration of the s&)function dong the length of the sample similarly gives the total pore volume of the sample (V,,).Because the ratio of these
24
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
two volumes is equal to the volumetric porosity, i t can be stated, that the average areal porosity is equal to the volumetric parameter in the case of randomly distributed pores [the latter hypothesis originates from the condition where the m(z) function is continuous]. The equality of the average linear porosity and areal porosity can similarly be proved. Hence, it can be
Y
Fig. 1. 1-5. Ih e a r , areal and volumetric porosities of a structure having interstices composed of equidistant spaces between cubes
assumed, that the three different interpretations of porosity calculated for samples larger than the representative elementary volume, pro\-ide the same numerical value. A condition of the previous derivation was the random distribution of pores. In the case of a regular structure of fissures [when the m(z) function is not continuous], 8ome complications are caused by the difference between total and effective porosity. The orthogonal system of equidistant spaces between cubes can be used as an example (Fig. 1.1-5) for investigating the problems arising. Two different values of linear porosity can be calculated parallel to one of the main axes of the structure. Depending on the position of the line in question, it may cross the cubes or run inside the spaces: (1.1-5)
Similarly, two parameters characterize areal porosity as well:
25
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
while total volumetric porosity is determined by the following equation:
(a + b)3- a3 3ab2+ 3a2 b + b3 (a b)3 (a b)3.
n=
+
+
(1.1-7)
Comparing the parameters, which are not equal to unity, an apparent contradiction occurs because these values are not equal, although equality would be expected for randomly distributed pores. At the same time, it is evident that the areal porosity expressed by Eq. (1.1-6) assumes a flow, perpendicular to one of the main planes of the structure lying along two axes of the coordinate system. In this case, however, a considerable portion of the pores (those spaces perpendicular to the direction of flow) do not transmit water, because there is no pressure difference within them. After decreasing the pore volume by the volume of the inactive spaces, effective porosity can be calculated [(a b ) 2 - u'](u b ) 2ab + b2 neff= = n;. (1.1-8) ( a bI3 (a"b)2
+
~
+
+
It can be proved in this way, that the equality of areal and volumetric porosity is valid also in the case of a regular network of fissures, but effective porosity has to be determined for such systems, considering only interstices taking part in water transport. After describing the structure of water conveying networks, the acting forces have also to be analysed for the complete characterization of flow. According to Newton, movement can only develop as a result of a driving force or forces, and, if there is movement in the system, forces are also acting as a reaction to the accelerating forces to stop, or slow down the motion. Steady movement can only develop, if the entire system of forces (both those accelerating and retarding the motion) is in a balanced condition. The most important accelerating force in the case of ground-water flow is gravity. Apart from this force, the pressure of the upper layers may be taken into account. These cause compression and force water to flow out of the pores due to their reduced volume. Sometimes there may be a further accelerating force as well: the pressure of vapour and gases enclosed in the layers. These are generally only significant at greater depth. Their effects become important, therefore, in mining of hydrocarbons, and also in the case of water exploitation from deep aquifers, and should be taken into consideration, when determining hydrodynamic relationships related to deep wells. There is a special case due to gravity caused by the Werent specific weights of water stored in various layers. The specific weights of water can differ from each other, because of differences in the amount of dissolved salts and/or temperature. These effects may be important, when investigating water exchange between deep and shallow aquifers and when studying sea-water intrusion. Soil moisture adheres to the wall of the solid matrix and is kept in an elevated pobition above the water table against gravity by adhebive forces.
26
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
The dynamics of this type of water differs from the water movement in the saturated zone, because the adhesive forces created by the interaction of the solid particles and water molecules are also accelerating forces apart from gravity. On the basis of the hydrodynamic aspects described above, the movement of subsurface waters can be divided into the following main groups:
( A ) Flow through saturated porous media, wherein the network of the pores is equally distributed and connected at random This and the following groups can be subdivided according to the main accelerating forces: (a) Gravity which is the solely dominant accelerating force; (b) The pressure of overlying layers, the difference i n the specific weights of water, or the pressure of vapour and gases also have important roles apart from gravity. Further clrtssification within this group considers the three possible retarding forces, and their combined effects related to one another. These forces are: inertia, friction and the adhesive forces between solid grains and water molecules. This type of subdivision can of course be applied in both previously mentioned subgroups baaed on the weight of the accelerating forces. Thus, the following secondary subgroups can be distinguished:
( i ) All other retarding forces can be neglected except inertia, the flow being turbulent ; ( i i ) There are two retarding forces to be taken into consideration, inertia and friction. The condition of flow can be regarded m a transition from the turbulent to the laminar zone; ( i i i ) The solely dominant retarding force is friction; the flow is laminar (the greater part of ground-water movement pertains t o this group, which is the so-called Darcy’s flow condition); ( i v )Adhesive forces createdby tension, and acting between the solid walls of pores and water molecules, also have an important role in the system as retarding forces apart from friction. This type of flow is called micro-seepage. Ground-water movement in loose clmtic sediments can mainly be characterized by the types of flow through the saturated porous medium previously described. There are, however, some solid rocks aa well (sandstone, fractured dolomite, basaltic lava, etc.), the water movement in which can be considered in this main group. The importance of the latter is, however, s m d e r , than that in sedimentary baains filled with loose claetic sediments, which are generally the major possibilities for the large-scale use of ground-water resources. For this remon, the determination of the hydrodynamic parameters of flow through porous media is baaed on the investigation of samples built up from grains and saturated pores.
( B )Flow through saturated, fracturated and fissured r o c b In solid rocks, water movement can develop mostly along the contact planes of layers, fractured zones and fbsures, or through dissolved openings
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
27
and channels. The flow is usually turbulent, or belongs to the transition zone, because the size of the water conducting channels is generally larger, than that of the pores between the grains. The interstices are not equally distributed through the whole volume of the layer, but are concentrated in fractured zones. Their interconnections do not occur at random, but are directed in most cases by the structural planes of the strata. A classification based on the accelerating forces, is unreasonable for this group. There are only very rare cases, when the second most important accelerating force, the pressure of overlying layers, may have any role in addition t o gravity. Adhesion can be neglected in almost every cme, because the ratio of the internal specific surface, or the surface of the solid matrix related to the volume of water contained in the pores, is considerably smaller than that in loose cla.stic sediments. There are many cams, when inertia has a dominant role in the relatively largeopenings. Hence, Darcy’s equation can hardly be applied, or only in a modified form. I n other cases, where the interstices are narrow, the supposition of laminar flow is acceptable, but the non-evenly, or non-randomly distributed pores make the application of the hypothesis of united flow domain more difficult. There is another aspect, according to which some distinction between the various types can be made. This is the character of the water conducting channels or structures: (a) One-dimensional flow in openings, channels, and conduits connected in only a few places, the investigation of which is similar to the hydraulics of water movement in networks of pipes. This type of movement is characteristic of karstic formations, most important of all in limestones. (b) Two-dimensional flow along the contact planes of layers, structural planes, and in fractured zones. This type of movement can develop both in karstic and non-karstic formations. The most important types of rocks in the latter group are mark and slates. (c) Flow through the interstices of solid rocks where no definite relationship exists between the material of the layer and the structure, or character of the water conducting network.
( C ) Flow through unsaturated porous layers
M fractured rocks Among the accelerating forces creating and maintaining this type of water movement, two have a dominant role: gravity and the tension diflerence between two points on the surface of water films created by adhesive forces. The size of the effective area of the flow cross section is essentially influenced by the amount of air entrapped in the sample. Some subgroups within this type of flow can be distinguished according to, whether the air bubbles in the flow space are in contact with the atmosphere, or not. In the former case, it is advisable to distinguish between porous sediments and fractured rocks. As a result, the following classification can be given:
(a) In the case of flow through unsaturated porous sediments above the water table, the air included in the layer is in direct contact with the atmosphere, its pressure is determined by the atmospheric pressure and it may also be
28
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
influenced by the air-permeability of the formation (Morel-Seytoux, 1973; Morel-Seytoux and Khanji, 1974).The surface of the solid grains is relatively large, compared to the volume of the moving water, and the influence of adhesive forces as a retarding effect is, therefore, considerable. The decrease in these two parameters (e.g. in coarse-grained gravel) forms a transition to the second subgroup. (b) In fractured zones or conduits of solid rocks above the water table, contact with the atmosphere is similar t o that mentioned in the previous case, but the flow is less affected by adhesion. Infiltration is relatively rapid, storage capacity is small, and the evaporation of ground water through this unsaturated zone can be neglected. As a special form of this type of water movement, the open channel flow in karstic conduits can he mentioned, the hydraulic description of which is similar t o that of water courses on the surface. (c) Unsaturated layers can develop at great depths as well, where the gaseous phase originates from vapours and dissolved gases in the water, when the temperature is raised considerably. The pressure of this phase is determined by the local conditions prevailing at depth.
1.1.3 The definition of seepage
On the basis of the clausification of subsurface water and that of the hydrodynamical aspects explained in connection with the analysis of groundwater flow, those types of subsurface water whose detailed investigation is the objective of seepage hydraulics can easily be selected. It wm clearly demonstrated that the scope of hydrodynamics may include the investigation of the movement of any kind of ground water or soil moisture. Sometimes the whole section of hydraulics dealing with subsurface flow is called seepage hydraulics. This use of the term seepage is, however, not quite correct, because some examples of this water movement (e.g. turbulent flow in large karstic conduits either under pressure or with a free water surface) are far from the idea generally connected with the word: seepage. The best way to understand the clear concepts of seepage is to go back into the past and analyse the results of the original experiments by Darcy, who established the scientific study of seepage hydraulics. He investigated the resistance to flow of sand filters, and on the basis of the empirical evaluation of the measurements, in his famous book (Darcy, 1856) he evolved a relationship between the hydraulic parameters of flow through a sandy layer, thought to be generally valid for the characterization of water movement in porous media. The sketch of equipment used for repeating Darcy’s baaic experiments is shown in Fig. 1.1-6. A tube of constant cross-sectional area A (cylindrical or prizmatic) is flled with the porous medium. The sample is bordered at both ends by planes, perpendicular to the axis of the tube, and its length (the distance between the two borders) is L. Flow through the sample is created by a constant difference ( A H ) between the pressure heads of headand tail-water, maintained by recharging the upper space of the system,
29
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
reference level Fig. 1.1-6. Sketch of equipment used for repeating Darcy's experiments
and draining the lower one, ensuring a constant water level at both places. The sample is in a horizontal position in the figure, although the original experiments were executed with vertically standing samples, and the literature also describes equipment generally using vertical samples. This difference, however, does not cause any discrepancy, because the potentials at any point of 110th ends of the sample are calculated as the sum of potential- and pressure-energy ( z y p ) , or, when expressed as the height of an equivalent water column, that of the height of the point above an arbitrarily chosen reference level, and the height of the water level above the point (z h ) . The reistance against the flow before and behind the sample is negligible because the cross section of the tube is relatively very large. The pressure is proportional to the difference in level, and hence independent of the po,4tions of the points of meaurement, depending on the vertical difference between the head- and tail-water levels only. The constant pressure head difference creates steady flow, the discharge (&) of which can be determined as the amount of water flowing through the system. This is measured in unit time at the spill way of the tail water. Darcy found, that the specific discharge (the ratio of the measured discharge to the total area of a section of the sample perpendicular to the direction of flow which is equal to the cross section of the tube containing the sample) is linearly proportional to the difference between the pressure heads and inversely proportional to the length of the sample:
+
+
(1.1-9)
The dimeiision of the specific discharge is equal to that of velocity [LT-l], and, therefore, Darcy named this parameter as seepage velocity. This is,
30
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
however, an apparent value, because a considerable part of the cross section of the tube is occupied by the solid matrix, and the area which is free for conveying water, is only a portion of the total area ( Z a ) .The ratio of free and total surfaces is equal t o areal porosity ( n l ) , which, considering Eq. ( 1 . 1 4 ) , can be substituted by effective porosity ( n ) .The actual mean velocity of water in the pores can be calculated as the quotient of the discharge and the sum of the free areas of the pores. This parameter is called eflective velocity and is proportional to Darcy’s seepage velocity, being l / n , the factor of proportionality: & & 1 V,ff = -= --- - v ; because Za = n A . (1.1-10) Za n A n
(To avoid misinterpretation of seepage velocity and effective mean velocity, the former is often called flux or specific flux in the literature, and is indicated by q instead of v.) Both terms in the quotient on the right handsideof Eq. (1.1-9) (difference between pressure heads and the length of the sample) have a dimension of [L], and hence their ratio I is dimensionless. This parameter, the hydraulic gradient expresses in an equivalent water column the energy loss necessary t o overcome the resistance against the flow along a unit length of the porous medium. In the case of steady flow, it is constant in time, and independent of the position of the investigated section, if the flow domain is homogeneous, and the area of the cross section does not change. Since the publication of Darcy’s book, Eq. (1.1-9) became the basic law of seepage hydraulics, often referred to in the literature as Darcy’s law. It states that seepage velocity is linearly proportional to the hydraulic gradient, and the factor of proportionality ( K D , hydraulic conductivity) is independent of either velocity or gradient, being a material constant which summarizes all the parameters of both solid matrix and moving,fluid, influencing the resistance against seepage. Hydraulic conductivity has a dimentjion of velocity [LT-l], and according to the dehition, i t is equal to seepage velocity created by a hydraulic gradient of unity in a given porous medium and a given fluid. Research workers, having further developed Darcy’s basic ideas, determined the dependence of conductivity on the parameters of the transported fluid. They found that hydraulic conductivity is proportional to Che ratio of specific weight ( y) and dynamic viscosity ( p ) of the fluid, or t o acceleration due to gravity (9) divided by the kinematic viscosity ( v ) of the fluid, which is equivalent to this quotient. The remaining part of the parameter i.e. E , the factor of proportionality in the mentioned relationship, depends only on the properties of the solid matrix of the porous medium, and is called intrinsic permeability, matrix permeability, rock permeability or sometimes only permeability. The dimension of k is consequently [L2]:
K D -- k - =Y k - . 9 P
(1.1-11)
V
Since the establishment of Darcy’s law, many research workers have tried to prove its accuracy and validity on the basis of their own measurements
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
31
and theoretical studies (Hazen, 1893, 1895; Carman, 1956; Koieny, 1953; Zamarh, 1928; Zauberei, 1932; Zunker, 1930). Others - on the basis of experimental data - have denied the accuracy and applicability of this equation, and proposed other formulae instead of Darcy’s law (Forchheimer, 1886,1924; Lindquist, 1933; Lovaas, 1954). On the baais of the dynamic analysis of the movement of fluids through porous medium, recent investigations have proved that there is a large zone of flow conditions (i.e. laminar seepage), where Darcy’s equation is acceptable aa a good approximation As a further result of these investigations, (Kovhcs, 1969s; 1969b; 1969~). it can be stated that the formal application of Eq.(1.1-9) can be extended to non-laminar flow conditions aa well, if Darcy’s hydraulic conductivity is multiplied by a function depending on either seepage velocity or hydraulic gradient, and the non-linear proportionality between the two variables can be followed in this way: v =KI; where
R = R D @ I ( v ) = k -@9I
( v );
V
or
R
= KD@2(I)= k -9a 2 ( I ) .
(1.l-12)
V
Consequently, the generalized hydraulic conductivity is composed of three factors: (a) Intrinsic permeability, including all the parameters of the solid matrix influencing the development of seepage; (b) Properties of the flowing fluid, expressed a,a the ratio of acceleration due to gravity and kinematic viscosity of the fluid in question; (c) Function depending on either seepage velocity or hydraulic gradient for characterizing the mtml flow condition. A further expansion of the concept of hydraulic conductivity is its application t o the description of flow through unsaturated porous media (Averjanov, 1949a, 1949b; Bear et al., 1968; Bear, 1972; Irmay, 1954; Kovhcs, 1971a, 1971b). It is a generally accepted assumption that the specific flux through an unsaturated sample is smaller but proportional to that flowing through the same porous matrix in a saturated condition, assuming that hydraulic gradients are equal in both systems. It follows from this relationship that the apparent hydraulic conductivity of an unsaturated sample, generally called unsaturated conductivity can be determined by multiplying Darcy’s hydraulic conductivity, or more precisely, the generalized hydraulic conductivity, by a factor depending on the rate of saturation of the sample. Unsaturated conductivity includes not only the resistance of the solid matrix, but also the effect of the decrease in area available for the transport of fluid, when part of the pores is occupied by air. In the equation
32
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
below the rate of saturation s is the quotient of volumetric water content W and effective porosity n:
K,
9
= K f ( s ) = K D @ z ( I ) f ( s ) = k -@ 2 ( 1 )
f(8).
(1.1.13)
V
It is necessary to note here that in the caae of unsaturated flow, apart from friction, the molecular forces become dominant as retarding forces. I n this zone, the modification of Darcy’s parameter can be better expressed aa the function of hydraulic gradient, than that of seepage velocity. For this reason, the second form of the generalized hydraulic conductivity waa used in Eq. (1.1-13). In connection with the validity of Darcy’s law in most cases only the interpretation of hydraulic conductivity and the applicability of the linear relationship is queried in the literature. As summarized in the previous paragraphs and aa will be explained in detail in Part 2 of the book, the solution of these problems can eaaily be found in the form of the dynamic interpretation of the generalized hydraulic conductivity, and the relationships between the various parameters can be determined. In Part 2, the practical application of certain factors will be discussed, together with their numerical determination from known physical parameters of soil. There is, however, a further hypothesis in the derivation of Eq. (1.1-9) which has to be considered when applying either Darcy’s relationship, or any other type of seepage laws. This supposition is included in Eq. (1.1-9) in the form of Darcy’s seepage velocity, although this fact is not explicitly explained either in Darcy’s publication or by other research workers having followed his experiments. The exact wording of the condition is aa follows: any type of seepage law can be applied only if the water-conveying openings in the cross sections, perpendicular to the main direction of flow, are randomly distributed, and small, compared to the entire area of the crosa section. If this condition is fulflled, the effective mean velocity in the pores can be substituted by seepage velocity (specific flux) calculated for any subarea of the cross section. Here a further condition arises: the subarea used as a unit should be larger in magnitude, than the representative elementary unit. In thitj caae, the ratio of seepage and effective velocities can be regarded aa equal to areal porosity, and the porous medium, bordered by pervious or impervious boundaries having geometrically fixed positions, can be dealt with aa a continuous flow domain. The basic physical concept of this special approach t o the investigation of seepage summarized in the previous paragraph is explained in various ways in recently published manuals dealing generally with hydromechanics (NBmeth, 1963), or especially with the hydrodynamics of flow through porous media (De Wiest, 1969). One of the latest and most comprehensive explanations is that given by Bear and discussed as a continuum approach in his book (Bear, 1972). For this reason, this main line of thought is pursued in the following paragraphs. To achieve the objective, of the characterization of the porous aquifer as a continuous flow field, the double application of statistical averaging has
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
33
to be performed. The flowing water has to be described first of all as a continuum, instead of a mass of numerous, separately moving molecules. The molecular structure of water is substituted by water particles of a conveniently chosen size, ensuring that the material behaviour of the maas and the average parameters of movement can be regarded as homogeneous within the particles. Using these particles as parts of the water continuum, their dynamic and kinematic analysis provides the investigators with all the necessary information and means to solve the movement equations, and to determine in this way the parameters of flow if the boundary conditions of the flow domain are known. I n a porous matrix however, the actual flow field is composed of the very complicated and ramifying channels formed by the interstices. It is almost impossible to apply to seepage hydraulics the methods of solution, generally accepted in hydrodynamics and easily applicable to relatively simple forms of flow domains, because the consideration of the boundary conditions in the microscopic network of channels results in a large group of complex movement equations which cannot be dealt with mathematically. A second statistical averaging enables investigators to neglect the microscopic flow pattern of the actual water movement, and describe the entire domain of the porous medium as a unified and continuous flow space, the behaviour of which is influenced by both the solid matrix and the transported fluid. On this macroscopic scale the simplified parameters of flow can be easily determined by applying the basic movement equations for the new continuum, substituting the statistically averaged macroscopic properties of the domain, and considering the boundary conditions of this complex system. Thus any investigation of seepage requires the substitution of the molecular structure of the water with the Continuum of water particles, and the microswpic flow pattern followed by these particles with the macroscopic continuum of the porous medium. The application of the continuum approach is based on the theory of random variables, where the expected value of a quantity scattered randomly around a given value can be characterized by the average of the observed data, if the number of observations is large enough for statistical evaluation. As an initial example, the investigated random variable may be the velocity vector of the water molecules. It is well known that they have random movement (Brownian movement), even if the mass of water is in a static state. The resultant average of the velocity vectors scatters around zero in this case, and the variance can be lowered below a given limit, assuming, that the number of molecules included in the investigation is large enough. Ahove this limit the variance is practically constant, but below it the scattering gradually increases with the decreasing number of molecules, and achieves its highest value, equal to the fluctuation of the velocity of one molecule, if a single molecule is considered. Because the velocity of the Brownian movement depends on temperature, it is evident, that the smallest possible number of molecules, or the smdlest volume of water including this number of molecules - which is called the representative elementary unit - will change with temperature, and also with any other variables influencing the Brownian movement. Therefore, the size of the water par-
34
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
ticles has t o be determined, so, that they are hrger than the largest representative elementary unit occurring under the conditions of the investigation. The expected value of the resultant of Brownian velocities determined for such particles is zero, Therefore, the velocity vector of a particle characterizes the actual flow in the continuum. There is an upper limit to the particle size as well. The purpose of the concept of continuum approach is to describe some behaviour of the flow domain: e.g. the movement in the present caBe. The parameter to be determined may continuously change from point to point and i t may be represented by a series of discrete data calculated for each particle. Thus, the approximation of the continuum would be very rough, when applied to a particle of large size. The average value of a parameter determined for the particles still haa a random variance, compared to the expected value. It is necessary, therefore, to evduate statistically the number of particles for a reliable calculation of the expected value. Hence, a set of some tens of particles are regarded a~ a unit. These units can then characterize the behaviour of the flow space, a condition which requires the particle size to be smaller in magnitude, than the investigated domain. The transformation of a set of molecules into homogeneous particles ia the basis of the interpretation of most of the physical parameters of water e.g. the mass or density can be described by the number of molecules within a representative elementary volume. The latter is also a random variable, which gives an approximate value only, when a particle larger than a given limit is analyzed. The ratio of the jointed dipole molecules and the freely moving ones within a particle also may be statistically evaluated as a random variable influenced by Brownian movement. This property is viscosity. As already explained, the use of a regular system of discrete continuous functions for describing the properties and behaviour of the domain, instead of individual molecules randomly filling in the space, makes possible the application of hydrodynamic movement equations. These equations can be solved however, only in the case of relatively simple boundary conditions, and it is hardly regarded a~ a likely method to determine the parameters of flow through the microscopic channels of porous media, even if the capacity of today’s computers could be considerably enlarged. The microscopic view should be changed to the macroscopic characterization of the flow domain, following the same general concepts a~ previously used. It is necessary to note that the parameters calculated in this way are only statistical averages for a unit area or volume (larger than the representative elementary
Fig. 1 .l-7. Actual and average flow direction of watm particles t,hroughporous medium
35
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
unit), and do not represent the actual extreme values: e.g. a continously changing velocity characterizes the flow domain although the effective velocity in a channel changes rapidly and periodically, following the random variation of the cross section. I n Fig. 1.1-7, the possible paths of water particles are shown through a porous matrix. Two particles following each other, may choose different paths at a bifurcation. Thus this process itself is a random variable, and the effective velocity at a given point may fluctuate with time. It can be stated, therefore, that the movement is time variable, even if the boundary conditions are time invariant, and theoretically, an unsteady flow is created by steady conditions, the average parameters of which (mean direction of flow, average flow rate through a unit area, etc.) are constant, and the movement in the flow domain can be regarded zw a quasi steady flow. The interpretation of porosity is a good example of the application of continuum approach for the determination of the parameters of a macroscopic flow domain. Similar to the process explained in connection with the averaging of molecular velocities, the porosity may also be determined for gradually increasing volumes. The extremes occur when using infinitesimal volumes. They are one or zero depending on whether the centre of the investigated volume is in a pore or within the solid matrix, and are independent of the actual character of the porous medium. When increwing the volume, the scattering decreases and achieves a constant minimum at the representative elementary volume. The calculated porosity fluctuates randomly around the expected value when the volume is above this limit. Naturally, the size of the representative elementary unit is strongly influenced by the structure of the solid matrix of the porous medium in question.
i
R
. . . -, ,..-. - .. .....,. ... .. : ,.... ... . -.,.'><;->.L< . ,/: ..;. ' .
t.;:
.
,.TTfVT S T ? r n f f T '
'
. : 4 .
f 7 ffff
,
I .
3;
,
,
of a homogenpors layer
0
maximum hoinoge~eausvolume Fig. 1.1-8. Interpretation of representative elementary unit using the example of determination of porosity representative elementary volume
3*
36
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Porosity represents a good example of this statement as well. In a loose clastic sediment, the limit above which porosity fluctuates randomly, may be expected to be low, especially in sand and gravel. If the formation is layered, a slow change in the average porosity is probable after crossing an upper limit, indicating that above a given size, the investigated volume becomes inhomogeneous (it includes also a layer having properties different to the basic one), and the average parameter is more and more influenced by the second layer. Figure 1.1-8 shows the interpretationof porosity asa function of the volume size, based on the figures in Bear (1972). In fissured and fractured rocks, the distribution of the interstices is more uneven than that in a loose clastic sediment. The representative elementary length is generally longer in such formations and greatly varies with the structure of the rock type. To substantiate this statement, the linear porosity of a dolomite covered with dense fine joints is compared to the same parameter in karstic limestone. Four lines of various lengths in the dolomite were investigated, and the two extremes are represented in the figure. 1.6
(a) dolomite
a.9
( 2 samples of 50 rm) 0.8 0.05
n.7 ~
0.6
& B
$
a5
o
L
s
5
IO
{5
za
30
25
length af the separafely enalysed part of the fine rcm3
RJ
0.4
(b) limesfone
a3
( I sample of 25 m)
$& 2%
frequency disfribufian of the parasity of samples
0.2
8s -* & p 3 sz
a.i
a
-._._._
b.
I
I
1
1
I
I
I
2
4
6
8
ID
12
44
16
length of the separatply analysed part of the line [mi Fig. 1.1-9. Comparison of porosity distribution of limestone and dolomite
1.1 General characterization of subsurface water
37
Although the joints are relatively well distributed, the range of porosity determined for various stretches of 10 cm is still about 30-707; of the average parameters, while it is reduced below 10-20% if the investigated length is 25 cm. In karstic limestone, where chemically dissolved openings as large aa 50 cm may be found, the length of the acceptable representative elementary unit is 50-100 times longer than in dolomite (Fig. 1.1-9). On the basis of continuum approach and considering the interpretation of the general seepage law determining the relationship between seepage velocity and hydraulic gradient, the definition of seepage can be clarified. T h e movement of any type of subsurface water i s called seepage, if seepage velocity, as a characteristic parameter of the flow space, can be calculated and applied to any point of the domain, as a function of the local hydraulic gradient. In loose clastic sediments and solid rocks having similar structures (e.g. sandstone), the flow may be called seepage almost without any restriction according to the extension of the flow domain. In the case of fissured and fractured rocks, the minimum size of the flow space above which the aquifer can be substituted by a continuous domain may be determined and thus, the movement can be investigated by applying the seepage law. However, if the size of the investigated layer is smaller than the limite, the water transport through the separate channels has to be calculated. The applicability of both the term seepage and the relationships determined for the characterization of seepage depends on the size of the flow domain, if the latter is composed of fissured and fractured rocks as will be discussed in detail in Part 3.
References to Chapter 1.1 AVERJANOV, S. V. (1949a): Relationship of Permeability of Soil with Air Content (in Russian). D.A.N., No. 2. AVERJANOV, S. V. (1949b): Approximative Evaluation of the Role of Seepage in the Capillary Fringe (in Russian). D.A.N., No. 3. BEAR,J. (1972): Dynamics of Fluids in Porous Media. Elsevier, New York, London, Amsterdam. S. (1968): Physical Principles of Water PercolaBEAR, J., ZASLAVSKY,D. and IRMAY tion and Seepage. UNESCO, Paris. CARMAN, P. C. (1966): Flow of Gases through Porous Media. Butterworth, London. DAROY,H. (1866): Publio Water Supply of Dijon (in French). Dalmont, Paris. DEWIEST,R. J. M. (1969): Flow through Porous Media. Academic Press, New York, London. F A 0 (1972): Glossary and Multilingual Equivalents of Karst Terms. Paris. PAO-UNESCO (1973): Irrigation, Drainege and Salinity. Hutohison and Co., London, Southampton. FOROEH&IMER, PE.(1886): On the Yield of Wells and Drains (in German). Hannover Z&chrift dea Archdekten und Ingenieure. Vol. 32. FOROHHEIBIER, PH. (1924): Hydraulios (in German). Teubner, Leipzig, Berlin. HAZEN,A. (1893): Some Physioal Properties of Sands and Gravels with Reference Lo Tbeir Use in Filtration. 24th Annual Report of the Massachusetts State Board of Health, Boeton. HAZEN, A. (1896): The Filtration of Publia Water Supplies. New York. IAHS (1974): Hydrologid Investigation of the Unsaturated Zone. 2nd Circular. International Glossary. Budapest.
38
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepege
IRMAY, S. (1964): On the Hydraulic Conductivity of Unsaturated Soil. Trunaactwn of ABU, Vol. 36, No. 1. KovAcs, G. (1969a): General Characterization of Different Types of Seepage. 13rd COngreee of IAHR, Kyoto, 1969. KOVACS, a. (1969b): Rdationahip Between Velocity of Seepage and Hydraulic Gradient in the Zone of High Velocity. 13th Congreee of IAHR, Kyoto, 1969. KovAcs, G. (19690): Seepage Law of Microseepage. 13th Cmgreaa of IAHR, Kyoto, 1969. KovAcs, G. (1971a): Seepage through Saturated and Unsaturated Layer. Bulletin of IAHS, No. 2. KovAcs, G. (1971b): Seepage through Unsaturated PorousMedie. 14th Cbngrese of IAHR, Paria, 1971. KO-, (1963): Hydraulics (in German). Springer, Wien. LINDQUIST,E. (1933): On the Elow of Water through Porous Soils.1atCbrrgreee of ICOLD, Stockholm, 1933. LOVASS,L. (1964): New Reeulta of Investigations Related to the Permeability of Soils (in Hungmian). Hidrol6giai Ko&ny, No. 9-10. MORE~SEYTOUX, H. J. (1973): On a Modified Theory of Infiltration (in French). Cahiere ORSTOM, Sene Hydrolo ie, Part 1, No. 2 and Part 2, No. 3. M O ~ E Y T O T J XH. , J. and !CE.AN~I, J. (1974): Derivation of an Equation of Infiltration. Water Reaoumes Reaearch, No. 4. N ~ T HE., (1963): Hydromeahmica (in Hungarian). Tankonyvkiad6, Budapest. UNESCO (1972): Ground-water Studies. Paris. UNESCO-WMO (1974): International Glossary for Hydrology. Geneva. ZAXARIN, J. A. (1928): Calculation of Ground-water Flow (in Ruesian). Trudey I.V.H. Twkent. ZAUBEREI, I. I. (1932): On the Problem and Determination of Hydraulio Conduotivity (in Ruesian). Iaveetia V.N.I.I.G. M n g r a d , No. 3-6. ZUNKER, F. (1930): Bebviour of Soils in Connection with Water (in Germen). Handbook of Soil Science, Springer, Berlin. Vol. VI.
Chapter 1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of loose clastic sediments influencing permeability During the process of seepage, the resistance of channels formed! by pores between grains connected almost continuously and distributed at random in the flow space, must be overcome by the forces accelerating and maintaining the movement. The resistance of the network depends mostly on the size and shape of the pores forming the channels. It is also influenced however, by the adhesive forces acting between the solid walls of the channels and water molecules. It is necessary, therefore, t o investigate and determine all the geometrical factors describing the size of the channels, and the other characteristics influencing the conditions of their w d s . The geometrical parameters of the network depend on the size and shape of the grains, the degree of sorting of grain sizes (grain distribution), and the porosity. Apart from the latter, the adhesive forces are affected by the mineralogical and chemical character of the grains. These factors and their influence on the flow of water are discussed in this chapter, which summarizes some physical and mineralogical fundamentals of seepage.
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clmtic sediments
39
1.2.1 The size and shape of grains forming a layer Grains and their main parameters (surface, area volume, etc.) can be characterized by one or more dimensions of the particle only in the case of regular geometrical forms. In nature, the grains forming the various layers differ considerably from regular forms, especially from that of the sphere, which is generally used in soil physics to substitute the actual shape of grains, because this is the simplest form, all the parameters of which can be determined knowing only one datum, i.e. the diameter of the sphere. For this rertson, the introduction of a shape coefficient is also necessary in addition t o the diameter of the grains to characterize the difference between the sphere and the actual form. There are two different definitions of the diameter of a sphere equivalent to the actual grain. Both are related to the methods used in soil physics for measuring the size of grains. If the grain is larger than 0.1 mm, this measurement is determined using sievee. Thus, the diameter of the equivalent sphere in this range is equal to the size of the holes in the sieve (which is the diameter for a circular hole, or the length of the side of a square), through which the grain can fall. I n the case of finer grains, whose clize is determined by sedimentation (hydrometric method), the equivalent diameter is the size of a sphere settling in the water at the same velocity as the actual grain in question. In the first case, the diameter of the grain is equal to the diameter of the clphere encircling the grain. In the smaller grain-size range such a clear relationship between the grain size and the substituting sphere cannot be determined. A further problem is caused in the latter case by the fact that the colloid grains may sink separately or joined together as a flake, according to the colloidal character of the suspension (morphology of the surface of grains, coagulation, peptization). The settling velocity of an aggregate composed of many grains is equal to that of a single grain having the same diameter rts the flake. Taking into consideration this uncertainty, it is also acceptable t o assume that a grain size measured by sedimentation is approximately equal to the diameter of the encircling sphere, and t o ensure in this way the uniformity of the interpretation of grain size. There are several shape coefficients for characterizing the difference between the actual grain and the equivalent sphere. These are generally, calculated from the three main dimensions of the grain, perpendicular to each other. A further basic requirement is that the shape coefficient should characterize the difference mentioned above from aspects relevant to the investigation in question. Thus there are shape coefficients used in geology to determine the origin of the grains and the distance they have travelled (Hagerman, 1938; MihBltz and UngBr, 1954; Sztideczky-Kardoss, 1933) and in hydraulics concerning sediment transport and sedimentation (Heywood, 1938; Ivicsics, 1957; Stelczer, 1967). To investigate seepage, a shape coefficient has to be chosen, which suits the physical description of the process in question (KovBcs, 1968a). Friction is the most important force among those retarding the velocity of seepage. Apart from this inertia and adhesion may be dominant. TWOof
40
1 Fundamentala for the investigation of seepage
these forces (friction and adhesion) are proportional to the contact surface between the solid and liquid phases of the system. Acceleration due to gravity is proportional to the volume of water. The aftect of solid grains can be accounted by using the porosity. Finally the ratio of retarding and accelerating forces, which physically, characterize the flow, can be approximated by the ratio of the surface area of a grain (A) to its volume (V). The dimension of this ratio is [L-'1. Hence it can be expressed as the quotient of a dimensionless shape coefficient (a) and a characteristic diameter ( d ): (1.2- 1)
As shown by the equation, a is a function of the diameter chosen to characterize the grain. According to the physical determination of the soil, this diameter can be that of the encircling sphere (D). The corresponding value of the shape coefficient ( a D )for some particles having regular geometrical form is as follows: Sphere a D = 6; Cube tcg = 10.4; Octahedron aD= 10.4; Tetrahedron aD= 18. There are some crystals, where the ratio of the two main axes is constant (those determining its cross section) and the third varies considerably. Thus, the grains may have any form from a laminated plate to the shape of an elongated nail (pyramid, tetragonal, or hexagonal prism, circular cylinder, tetragonal or hexagonal pyramid). The shape coefficient of such grains can be expressed as a function of the quotient calculated from the diameter of a circle encircling the main section of the grain (d,) and the height of the grain ( 1 ) (Fig. 1.2-1). The dotted lines show the values of a,,.(the shape coefficient being calculated not from the diameter of the encircling sphere but from dl). The comparison of the graphs reveals that there is practically no difference between the two types of shape coefficient (i.e. aD and adl) in the zone of the disc-shaped grains, but the two values differ considerably in the case of nail-shaped crystals. Another conclusion which can be drawn from the figure is that the shape coefficients of prismatic forms having a square and oblong cross section respectively may also differ only in the caae of elongated grains, and only where the ratio of the sides of the oblong is significant (e.g. 1 : 10). The shape coefficient depends on the mineralogical character of the grains, which in turn may relate to the size of the grains. I n gravels, the dominant material of this grain size being quartz, the partioles are generally stubby, the lengths of the main axes not differing considerably, and the quotient l/d, is nearly 1. Their form can be approximated by a sphere, or a cube, depending on the amount of abrasion whioh has occurred during transport from the place of origin to the sedimenbation location. Thus, their shape coefficient is generally about aD =
1.2 Physical end mineralogical parametere of clastic sediments
ratio of hetghf to tbe dhneief of the circle surrounding the cross section ofa gmn1
C/q
Fig. 1.2-1. Shape coefficient of grains as a function of the ratio of their length to the circle encircling their cross seotion
E
42
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Table 1.2-1. Shape coefficients of clay minerals
1 Kaolinite Illite Montmorillonite Na-montmorillonite Nail-shaped grains (e.g. halloysite, attapulgite)
1
I~UI
I
4~
I
W,
aD
0.16-0.40 O.OpO.03 gO.01
0.5-0.15 0.7-0.30
0.10-0.030 0.20-0.060 0.03-0.016 0.003-0.0016
30-70 20-60 70-100 700-1000
2.0-0.6
0.25-0.04
10-30
40-100
1.4-0.40
= 7 - 11. The cme of gravels originating from laminated rocks (sandstone, slate) is an exception; the shape coefficient of such particles may be = 20. high ZiS Quartz is the main component of sand as well. The shape of sand grains is very similar to that of gravels. I n this group, abrasion depends mostly on whether the investigated sediment is a fluvial or wind borne deposit. In the &st cme the edges of the grains are generally sharp and hence, the shape coefficient aD = 9 - 11, while the quartz grains of a wind borne sand can be characterized,bby a coefficient of about aD = 7 - 9. In sands, and especially the finer grained ones, a considerable amount of mica may
' \
I I
\ \
Gravel
'' i\
I R
30
NI
40
0
14
-
a
\
B
\ \
I
\
I!
% 20
12
\
/
1
t t
..................
d
I h
I
d
\
I
quartz .......... andesife (slope deposit)\ k l u v i a l and marine) 'f4. *'
slate (slope deposit)
..........
\ \
'\.- ---*.-..............
...................
\
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
48
also be found. This is a characteristically laminated mineral, and hence its shape coefficient is much higher than that of quartz (aD = 20 - 50). The clay minerals form a quite separate group from the point of view of shape. Their diameter is smaller than 2 p and they generally form very thin plates (illite, kaolinite, montmorillonite), but some special types can exhibit the form of a nail, which is really a tube rolled from thin plate (halloysite). These minerals have the highest shape coefficients (Albert, 1967; Kuhn, 1963) (Table 1.2-1). According to this summary, the shape coefficient of clay minerals generally varies between 30 and 100. Na-montmorillonite is an exceptional case, where the lattices are separated into very thin independent lamellae and thus, the internal surface of the crystals becomes active. The probable value of the shape coefficient for various grains of different sizes, origin, and mineralogical character can be determined by statistical evaluation of numerous measurements (Fig. 1.2-2). Such studies furnish suitable data for the approximation of the actual shape coefficient, which is applicable in practice without any further detailed investigation.
1.2.2 Investigation of grain-size distribution All parameters discussed in the preceding paragraphs are related only to a single grain. In nature, however, no layer is built up from particles of identical size and shape. It is necessary, therefore, to find methods by which the layer can be characterized a,s a mixture of various grains. For comparing the amount of grains of various sizes, the so-called grainsize distribution curwe is generally used, the dehition of which is well known in soil physics (Fig. 1.2-3) (JAky, 1944; KBzdi, 1972). Presented in some manuals are comparisons showing the different names used to indicate the Y O
/OD
90 80 70 L7U
50 40
30 20 I0
0
Fig. 1.2-3. The ratio of grains having different diameters in the sample characterized by thg grain-size distribution curve
44
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
various grain sizes in different countries or organizations (Bear, 1972). Many attempts have been made to fkd only one parameter by which the sample can be described, to identify it numerically, and to characterize its most important physical behaviour. Such parameters are the various characteristic diameters (e.g. maximum diameter Dmax;diameter corresponding t o the 50 % value of the distribution curve Ds0;diameter of grains of maximum weight present in the sample i.e. the inflexion of the distribution curve D,; etc.). Hazen’s design diameter, which pertains to the 10 % value of the distribution curve (Dlo),has an important role in seepage hydraulics (Hazen, 1895). Previously, its use wag generally accepted when taking into comideration that both the size of pores and the inner surface of the sample are influenced mostly by the fine grains. Thus, the physical character of seepage can be related t o a value measuring the amount of fine grains in the sample. This parameter is usually supplemented by the coeficient of uniformity which is the ratio of the grain diameter corresponding t o the 60 yovalue of the distribution curve (Dao)to Hazen’s diameter:
u = -QO.
(1.2-2)
DlO
There are some other design diameters, whose authors wanted to combine both Hazen’s diameter and the coefficient of uniformity, and construct one parameter from D,, and Dlw ,An example of these is Fedorenko’s diameter (Melentev, 1960). (1.2-3)
On the basis of recent investigations, theuse of Kozeny’s effective diameter
(Dh)can be recommended as a parameter, which can accurately describe the heterodisperse sample in seepage hydraulics (Koieny, 1953). According to the original definition, this is the diameter of a sphere, whoxe homodisperse sample (a sample of particles having the same diameter) has the same surface-volume ratio as the investigated heterodisperse spherical sample. The determination of the effective diameter using the symbols in Fig. 1.2-4, can be given aa follows. The distance between the maximum and minimum diameter is divided into n equidistant intervals. The average diameter in thei-thinterval is Di, and the weight of grains in this interval compared to the total weight of the sample is represented by ASi. Aswming the grains t o be spheres in both systems, and the surface-volume ratio of the solid phase to be identical for both the model and the investigated sample, the following relationship can be given: Qi
ND; n ND#n/6
-
6
=y,g 2% ; YS
Dh=
1
(1.2.- 4)
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
45
I00
90 80 70 QI
$
60
.% 50
0
Fig. 1.24. Symbols used for the calculation of effect,ivediameter
where N is the number of spheres in the homodisperse sample, and ys is the specific weight of the solid grains. A similar relationship can be determined in the c5tse of grains with shapes differing from the sphere, using the shape coefficient described in the preceding section. It has to be assumed that the shape coefficient of grains in each intercan be apprnximately characterized by an average value (ai) val. Following the same steps taken to derive Eq. (1.2-4), the quotient of the effective diameter and the average shape coefficient can be calculated: D h
1
(1.2-5)
The determination of the shape coefficient for every fraction requires mineralogical and microscopic investigation. For the practical application of Eq. (1.2-5) however, some informative data can be given on the basis of statistical evaluation of numerous samples. An example is given in Fig. 1.2-5, which indicates the probable shape coefficient of grains according t o their origin (alluvial or aeolian), mineralogical composition (quartz, feldspar, mica, clay mineral), and size, in terms of the forms generally used to represent grain-size distribution. Using a simple mathematical equation to approximate actual grain-size distribution, relationships can be determined between the various charac-
46
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage Table 1.2-2. Relationships between varioua characteristic diameters Coefecient of uniformity (V)
Ratio of characteristic diameters on the baais of linear distribution
1.0
I
1.5
I
2.0
dculated
1.00
1.30
1.69
calculated
1.00
1.07
1.13
1.00
1.33
1.69
Ratio of characteristic diameters on the baais of logarithmic distribution 1.00
1.03
1.09
teristic diameters aa t h e functioncj of the coefficient of uniformity. I n Table 1.2-2,the results of two different approximations are given. It was first assumed that the relationship between the diameter and the integrated weight is linear. The second (so-called logarithmic) approximation which is generally used aasumes that a linear relationship exists between the integrated weight: and the logarithm of the corresponding diameter. The calculated
grain diameter, 0
[mmJ
Fig. 1.2-6 The average shape coefficients represented in the heading of forms used for plotting distribution c w w
47
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
aa the functions of the coefficient of uniformity 2.5
I
I
3.0
1.79
1.95
1.23
1.33
4.0
1
I
5.0
2.10
1.92
2.10
2.20
1.62
2.19
1.62
7.0
1
1
10.0
15.0
I
ao.0
1
25.0
2.25
2.25
2.25
2.25
2.25
1.92
2.58
3.67
5.42
7.18
8.90
1.77
1.94
2.13
2.28
2.48
2.64
2.73
2.77
2.78
1.17
1.26
1.40
1.58
1.87
2.42
3.12
3.85
4.42
ratios of D,/Dl0 and Ds,,/Dh were compared with meamred values (Fig. 1.2-6). It can be seen that the actual ratios generally lie between the two approximations nearer the logarithmic one. The figure is supplemented by another curve aa well. Paladin has used the diameter corresponding t o the integrated weight of SO%, to calculate the hydraulic conductivity of the sample. He has however, applied a corrective U=- OEO ’
I
2
3 4 5678910
40
W 30 405OSa.B0/0~ rtWionsb@ c u m on tbg b m s of lineur sipproximetion corrected lineer 8pproxirnution lajariihmic Bpproximation Palsdin formulls
3.5
3.0
2-2.5. 6 2.0
1.5 1.0
I
2
3 4 5 s?;Ssta
24 30 M ~ O ~ O ~ O O U
-
/J= Dl90
40
Fig. 1.2-6. Relationships between the ratios of different,characteristic diameters and the coefficient of uniformity
48
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
factor t o include the heterogeneity of the sample (Juhhsz, 1966; Paladin, 1964). If permeability really depends on the effective diameter, this factor is proportional to the ratio of D3,,/Dh.Reconstructing this relationship, it can be perceived that the curve corresponds to the measured data and is of similar character t o that based on logarithmic approximation. This fact verifies not only the accuracy of the described relationship between various characteristic diameters, but also the statement according to which Koieny's effective diameter is the most suitable parameter to characterize a heterodisperse sample in seepage hydraulics. The problem of aggregation of very fine grains has already been mentioned in connection with the determination of grain size. This process also makes less accurate the section of the distribution curve measured by sedimentation. The flakes settle with a velocity corresponding t o their diameter, ' and not to that of the individual grains. A higher weight is measured in intervals including the diameter of flakes and this amount is missing at the lower section of the curve (Szilvtigyi, 1966, 1967). Figure 1.2-7. represents some examples showing the deformation of the distribution curve. The first sample is a bentonite with no grains above the limit of 0.1 mm. All but one curve were determined by sedimentation, and the last by computing the weight of grains smaller than 2 p, using mineralogical methods (electron microscope, X-ray analysis, differential thermoanalysis). The first sedimentation was executed in distilled water and the others by adding various chemicals to the suspension. The sedimentation in distilled water measures the weight of grains finer than a given diameter (e.g. D = 2 p ) , and not bound to flakes in the natural condition. This is the lowest curve in the example in question. The mineralogical method determines the total weight of fine grains independent of aggregation (fully peptized conditions), and naturally, the corresponding curve gives the highest value at a given diameter. The other curves are between these two, showing the various grades of peptization created by the chemicals used. In the second example, where the sample contains mostly kaolinite among the clay minerals, the effect of the chemicals is somewhat different. Some of these chemicals do not increase the grade of dispersity, but on the contrary promote coagulation. Thus, the curve determined in distilled water is not the lowest in this case. Finally, the third sample was an illite. Its distribution curve was not altered by the chemicals used. From these examples the following question arises: when the sample contains clay minerals which distribution curve should be used to determine the effective diameter for the purposes of investigating the seepage? I n answering this question it must be realized that there are two kinds of bonds between the grains. The i%st is loose, the grains bound in this way can easily be separated either mechanically or by using chemicals. There are, however, irreversible bonds as well. In the latter case, from the point of view of seepage, the aggregated grains behave as one solid grain. The purpose of the investigation is, therefore, to measure the amount of individual and loosely bound grains separately from those irreversibly aggregated. The ratio of mobile or active (individual or loosely aggregated) clay minerals to those irreversibly bound to aggregates (immobile or inactive) is called the I
49
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
.bentonite (Mid) nOnfn7mifJOUXe 44%
illite keotinh’e 17% others 39 % (quartz, orthoclase)
too 4 -.
c
80
*%
2
60
8
40
s
20
-
0
.s
grain diameter, D. CmmJ kaoljnite ( Bombo/y) monfmoritlonite -
4s
$
100
p‘ 80 .9
3
G QJ
2
60
montmorillonite
-
40
h
!s
20
ki0 grain diameter, D tmnl
Fig. 1.2-7. Deformat,ionof grain-size distribution curves caused by the presence of colloid particles
morphological condition of colloid grains. This value has t o be determined and characterized by the distribution curve. Intense drying, frost, or chemicals change the structure of the crystals considerably, and can alter the morphological condition. For this reason, treatment cauning such alternation (e.g. drying) must be avoided during the preparation of the sample. 4
50
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
1.2.3 Mineralogical composition of sediments and its influence on the determination of the effective diameter
The mineralogical character of grains has a close correlation with their size. Naturally, it also depends on the type of rocks from which the particles in the sediments have originated. Grains larger in diameter than 2 mm (gravels) are mostly of quartz and feldspars. There are, however, many rock fragments in this fraction composed of several minerals. The amount of calcite may also be high in some places. I n sand (2 mm < D < 0.1 mm) the grains are composed predominantly of one mineral. Among the minerals, quartz is the most common. The amount of feldspars and calcite is less significant. The presence of mica may also be characteristic in this fraction. The next size interval (0.1 mm < D < 20 p ) is called mo or rock flour in soil physics. The mineral composition of this fraction does not differ from that of sand, except perhaps, in the larger amount of mica. The size of silt particles is 20 p < < D < 2 p. The considerable change in the physical behaviour of such samples (i.e. plasticity) is due mostly to clay minerals, which may already be present in this fraction in the h e r grainsizeportion. Finally, the character of clays ( D < 2 p ) is determined mostly by clay minerals and micas, although the other minerds (quartz, feldspar, and carbonate) may remain dominant in quantity. To illustrate the relationship between the size of grains and the mineralogical composition within a heterodisperse sample, Fig. 1.2-8. represents the distribution of various minerals according to the diameters of the particles (Kdzdi, 1972). As shown in the foregoing, the interaction between water and grains is mostly influenced by the surface-volume ratio of the latter. I n a homodisperse sample of spheres, this ratio is inversely proportional t o their diameter. I n the case of spheres of 2 p diameter (clay), this value is 10 000 times greater than that of a sample of particles having a diameter of 20 mm (gravel). The surface related to volume is further increased in the zone of small grains by the fact that the laminated forms are more frequent here than in the zone of gravel and sand, as clearly indicated by the higher probable shape coefficient of the small particles. Finally the mineralogical structure of the minerals having small diameters (mica and clay minerals) VJ
gfaiin dhmeter, 0 r,W Fig. 1.2-8. Mineralogical composition of a semple aa the function of the diameter of grains
51
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clestic sediments
may also increase the internal surface of the samples. At the same time however, the aggregation of these small particles can cause contrary effects, as mentioned in the previous section. Before investigating the determination of the effective diameter of samples containing colloid particles, a short summary of the structure of clay minerals will be given. Clay minerals originate mainly from the decomposition of feldspars in eruptive rocks. Generally three main groups of these minerals are distinguishable. The main representatives of these groups are kaolinite, illite and
the silicium net
A- A .section scheme o f the aluminium net
E -B section structure
of kuoknite cr&9tuI
structure of tnanttnarillonL+etrystd 60
4 Si
.
2(OH) + 40 4 A/ 2 (OHP40 4 Si
6 0 Fig. 1.2-9. The probable crystal structures of kaolinite and montmorillonite 48
52
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
montmorillonite. A common feature of clay minerals is the laminated structure of their crystalu. One type of lamella is composed of the plain net of one silicium and four oxygen atoms bound to each other in the form of tetrahedrons, while the other lamella is a net of octahedrons consisting of one aluminium and six oxygen atoms, or hydroxide radicals (Fig. 1.2-9) (Baver, 1948). In the caae of kaolinites [A14(Si401,)(OH),]the peaks of the tetrahedra in the silica net are aligned in the direction of the alumina net (the number of silica nets and aluminanets is the same), and thus, the oxygen atoms here are built into the octahedra with their free charges. The charges of the silica net are therefore, neutralized by the A l 3 + and OH- ions of the other lamella and the whole system of kaolinite haa free charges only at the edges of the crystals, where ions can be absorbed from the water surrounding the particles. H,0] In the crystals of montmorillonite [n(Ca, Mg)O Al,O34SiO, * H,O all lamellae of aluminiumhydroxide are surrounded by two silica nets (the aluminium can be substituted by iron or manganese in the octahedron net). Owing to the probable structure of the crystal, only every second tetrahedron of the silica net is joined to the alumina net, and the peaks of the others are turned outwards. Hence, the crystal grid has free negative charges on the surface of each group of lamella composed of three nets (one alumina and two silica nets). Ions can therefore, be absorbed at the internal surfaces of the crystals, and the type of the binding ions influences the behaviour of the montmorillonite. Water molecules can also be inserted between the crystal grids and absorbed by the free charges, causing the swelling of montmorillonite. The third type of clay mineral is illite (hydromica). Its structure and also its behaviour in connection with water and thus its role in seepage, can be considered aa a transition between kaolinite and montmorillonite. Summarizing the foregoing, it can be stated that clay minerals create electrostatic fields due to the free charges of the crystals. Thus, they can absorb ions from the surrounding solution. The binding of these ions however, is not permanent, and the so-called ion exchange can therefore, alter the chemical character of the minerals aa well. It is not yet clear whether the interaction between water and grains is also modified by the ion exchange or not. According to investigations on the adhesive forces, the tension is inversely proportional to the sixth power of the distance measured from the wall of the grains, and both the character of this relationship and the numerical parameters of the latter are constant, and is not influenced by the absorbed ions. The most acceptable hypothesis is therefore, to asume that the adhesive force binding the water to the grains is independent of the mineralogical and chemical character of the particles (as generally stated in the literature under the so-called Van der Waals force). The interaction between grains in the suspension, however, is influenced by the adhesive and repulsive forces (KovBcs, 1968b). Thus, the relationship between the distance from the wall and the total energy (which is the result of attractive and repulsive forces)will be considerably modified by the change in the repulsive force (Fig. 1.2-10).
-
+
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clmtic sediments
53
4
2 e 3!
,
-
' .
3 -
P
\
\ \
\
\
n\\
",
r ~ l s e\
f I
resu/tent
ettraction
l/tc
thickness of the diffuse double layer
Fig. 1.2-10. Dist,ributionof total electrostatic energy around a grain
grains (the ratio of independent, loosly aggregated, or irreversibly bouiid grains), and thus, alter the effective diameter, which depends on the active surface of the grains related t o their volume. Since the interaction between water and grains - accepting a constant adhesive force - is influenced only by the active surface of grains, change in this paramefer modifies the hydraulic character of the sample (water content, hydraulic conductivity, etc.). This line of thought returns t o the problem mentioned at the end of the last section: i.e. the correct method of determining the effective diameter (the grain-size distribution curve, or some of its characteristic points: e.g. the ratio of the weight of grains smaller than 2 ,u t o the total weight of the sample), when colloid particles are present in the sample. If the actual morphological character (the ratio of irreversible aggregates t o the total amount of colloid grains) can be taken into consideration using the granulometric curve, separate investigation of the influence of mineralogical and chemical
54
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
character is not necessary, because the effective diameter includes all the existing effects. It has already been mentioned in connection with Fig. 1.2-7, that the total amount of fine grains can be measured by mineralogical methods, and therefore, the clay content so determined is always greater than the actual amount of active particles, or equal to the latter if no grains are bound together by irreversible aggregation in the sample. (Clay content represented by the symbol Szccmeans the weight of grains smaller than 2 p related to the total weight of the sample). The clay content measured by sedimentation can only be smaller than, or equal to, the amount of active grains smaller than 2 p. I n the suspension prepared for sedimentation, some loose aggregation may occur apart from the irreversible bonds, and hence some active particles will be measured among the larger grains. It is necessary therefore, to find suitable methods for the direct determination of the actual active clay content. Previous attempts have been made to use the plasticity of the sample to characterize its clay content. It is obvious that plastic behaviour is caused by the clay content, and hence, a relationship must exist between the two phenomena. At the same time, the parameters characterizing plasticity (e.g. those used in soil physics: limit of plasticity wpr and liquid limit wL)can easily be measured the procedures being well known and standardized all over the world. Numerous data can be found in the literature, which give the corresponding values of plasticity ( w pand wL) and clay content (#,+) in the same sample. Some of these data are listed in Table 1.2-3. Data obtained by various measuring methods greatly differ from each other, and can be divided into two main groups. The first includes data measured by mineralogical methods (i.e. electron microscope, X-ray, DTA), and the second includes those determined by Sedimentation. The diversity of results is further increased by the use of different chemical treatment of the soil sample before or during sedimentation. There are also numerous articles investigating and describing the direct relationship between plasticity and clay content (Herczog et al., 1966; Seed et al., 1964; Szilviigyi, 1966, 1967), which differ widely, especially in the measurements used in the determination of the clay content. One article (Dumbleton and West, 1966) has to be dealt with in detail because the results they achieved and explained provided the Grst steps for further investigations (KovBcs, 1971). The first result in their paper is represented by four curves, which characterize the w p - Szp,and w L - Szp relationships for montmorillonite and kaolinite respectively. The clay content of pure montmorillonite and kaolinite samples determined by mineralogical methods was found to be nearly 100%. The limit of plasticity and the liquid limit of samples with a lower clay content have been measured using mixtures of these pure clay mineral samples with quartz sand and silt in various predetermined ratios. The second part of the paper presents the measured parameters of numerous natural clays. The clay contents of the latter have been determined by sedimentation. It is very interesting to note that the relation curves con-
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
55
Table 1.2-3. Corresponding values of plasticity and clay content of various samples (A) Data measured by mineralogical methods K - kaolinite, M - montmorillonite, 0 - others or undetermined 1 - illite, ~~
~
Clay content and the ratio of the various clay minerals
OharacteristiCa
of plasticity [%3
[%I
The type of the sample
Kaolinite HR. Kaolinite Ub. E.
88
-
-
96
6
64
33
84
-
-
96
69
30
Montmorillonite I. Illite-montmorillonite B.
93
86
-
10
187
63
88
60*
-
46
6 6 6
103
39
Illite-montmorilloniteS. Illite F. Halloysite N.
92
20*
20
60
10
70
30
82
-
90
-
10
63
66
76 _ _ ~ ~ _ _ ~ 77 Natural Ce bentonite 76
-
SO**
20
66
32
-
6
18
114 94
34 36
40
7
93
-
-
48 43
30 26
Kaolinite Mixture of the former three samples
26
-
6
91
4
26
23
60
38
2
48
12
67 60
63
68
1
26
16
76
38
19
3
70
8
49 48 67
26 42 60
70 46 23
1 2 3
4 10 14
74 42 46 61 67 82
21 21 29 26 20
60
60
26 28
32 30
26 12
16 30
49 47
27 29
87
44
17
39
80
26
70
-
96
-
6
93
36
-
82
18
27
23
46 61 74 43 63 61 74 78 83
11 22 33
-
66
60
24 28 34 16 10 9 14 21 31
61
-
60 72 66 79 82 84 80 78
22 26 30 24 32 36 33 32 31
100
96
6
76
96
168 116
68 40
60 26
96 96
6 6
82
28 17
Kaolinite Mixture of the former three samples
Ca bentonite Its mixture with quartz sand
36
-
-
11 22 33
Craft, 1967
~
Illite
Natural bentonite Illite
Referenma
~
24 46 71 71 48 23
33 61 44 20 4 9 13
_ _ _ -
_ _ -
60
Szilvhgyi, 1966
21 29 27 30
Dumbletonand West, 1966
56
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage Table 1.2-3. (cont.) Clay content and the ratio of the varions clay miner&
Characteristics of plasticity [%I
[%I
The type of the sample
Kaolinite
96
-
-
96
6
82
42
Its mixture with quartz sand
72
-
-
96
6
64
31
48 24
-
-
-
-
96 96
6 6
44 23
22 14
100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100
30 34 36 33 38 40 49 48 66 46 47 69 66
16 20 18 20 20 23 26 29 34 27 28 34 40
Keuper marl
6 62 6 68 66 6
7 77
0
-
-
-
4
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
~
9
0
-
-
-
-
-
-
81 87 87 88 9 4 -
-
-
100
-
-
-
.-
-
-
-
-
DWEPK kaolinite
60
-
96
6
29
26
Clay
20
10
10
16
66
67
28
Mixture
13
10
-
-
90
30
16
Clay
63
--
46
-
66
38
19
Kaolinite
60
-
-
96
6
62
31
CLY
86
86
6
-
10
160
46
Bentonite
41
*
-
-
-
92
18
Na bentonite
63
*
-
-
__
391
31
Ca bentonite Kaolinite
62
*
-
-
-
122
28
-
78
32
ChY
68
-
78
19
Activated Na bentonite Its mixture with quartz sand
86
94
-
6
-
71 66 42 34 28 21 10
94 94 94 94 94 94 94
-
6 6 6 6 6 6 6
-
398 310
34 32
234 179 143 130 94 46
26
72
96
48 36 29
96 96 96
Ca bentonite Its mixture with quartz
56
~
*
-~
*
~
-
~
-~
~
-
-
--
-
23 14 14 14 16
6
-
87
35
6
-
67
6 6
-
46 49
21 19 16
References
Schrnertmann, 1962
Arcrtn, 1966
author's measurements
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of claatic sediments
Table 1.2-3.
(COT&)
Clay content and the ratto of the various clay minerale
Charactaristicaof P l d i d t Y 1%1
The type of the sample
18 7
96 95
-
-
32
-
-
Clay (Oligocen)
36
-
71
29
46
22
Its mixture with quartz sand
29 23 17
-
71 71 71
29 29 29
38 32 26
16 16 13
Silt (Oligocen)
20
-
33
19
17 13 10
--
76 76
25
Its mixture with quartz sand
26 25 25
28 26 21
16 15 14
36 17
43 50
43 50
14
30
-
28
22 20
Silt (Alluvium)
-
75
76
13
-
Clay (Alluvium)
60
60
30
-
44
24
I t s mixture with quartz sand
41 33 25
50 50 50
30 30 30
-
42 31 26
21 17 16
*
References
Illite-montmorillonite
** Halloysite
(B) Data measured by sedimentation
The type of sample
the
Clay
Clay content and the type of the various clay minerals ~.
-
52
0
Method used for peptization
Na hexametaphosphate
Characteristics of plasticity [yo] Referelices
75
30
-
30
0
62
26
Na bentonite
-
87
M
530
120
Clay
-
50 46
0
44
0
80
21 30
20
M
114
34
Natural Ca bentonite
10
Boiled with N%CO3
Illite
2
14
I
N%Si03
Kaolinit e
6
23
K
Boiled with NaZCO3
Lo, 1961
Szilvhgyi, 1966
4843 26
30-25 23
57
58
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Table 1.2-3. (omt.)
The type of the sample
Olay oontent snd the type of the various clay mlnerals without with peptiza- peptization tion
-~
Mixture of the former three
1 2
0 0 6 0 4 16
&y
minerals
0 7
Natural bentonite The former sample after cation exchange Illite
13
60
-.
60 42 28
M M M
16
27
The former sample after cation exchange Kaolinite
-
20 16 18
I I I I
3
18
K
42
0
62
0 0 I 0 M 0 M M 0 M 0 0 M M M 0 0 0
Silty clay
silty soil
aharaoteristica of PMiCits I% 1
-
WL
I
References WP
17 14 16 21 24 29 6 18 7 12
-
Method osed for peptiration
39 46
Silty soil
19 38 30 34 20
silty clay-soil
30 34
Silty soil
29 62 19 32 21
Clay
26 26
silty soil
16
NqCO, (NH,),CO, Cacl,
N%CO,
PO*
CaC1,
116 88 64
27 27 22
93
36
70 70 62
36 40 29
37
23
68
36
63
24
69
20
49
22
33 64 34 63 32
26 22 19 22 20
50 64
29 24
46
63 41 60 32
28 24 30 21 22
36 33
14 18
26
24
~
Na hexemetaphosphate
Thompson, 1966
_
_
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
59
Table 1.2-3. (cont.) (Ray content and the type Of the various
The type of the sample
Silty soil
clay minerals
I I
-
Clay
-
soil
-
B level of soil Silty soil
-
Limely loess
-
Loess Silty soil
-
-
Clay
Soil on slate
Soil (alluvium) Soil on basement ChY
26 29 31 27 18 17 28 14 18 11 26 23 7 11 29 40 36 31 39 27 34 64 69 71 76 72 83 74 67 62 68 41 63 73 81 83 83 86 87
Oharactarlatics of P W t Y C%1
osed tor
Without with oky peptiza- pepth- minw tion tion ale
-
Silty clay soil Silty soil
Method
0 M 0 0
M 0 0 I I 0 0
0 M M 0 M 0 0 M M M M M M M M
M M
M M M K R K K K K K R
Referenoes
pepthation
N8 hemmetephosphete
41 44 46 39 34
24 24 17 18 16
26 37 26 26 26 28 29 28 30 36 64 61 63 63
13.. 18 14 17
41 49 81 94 92 100 98 118 122 116 64 68 62 77 94 80 86 89 78 87
-
16 14 26 26 20 29 27 29 29 19 Dumbleton end 22 West, 1966 47 62 61 67 44 47 39 42 30 36 27 36 38 39** 42**
a** 38**
48**
60
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage Table 1.2-3. (cont.) Clay content and the type of the various
The type of the sample
~
without] with
I
clay
~
I
lCL
I
I
-
30
K
90
36
-
47 52 69 61
62 97 106 62
26 38 40 28
Kmlinite
-
39
K K K K K
50
21
Kaolinite with bauxite
-
67
K
88
39
Kaolinite and Goethite
-
38
K
38
23
.-
54 80 89 41 20 79 18
0
60 106 103 69 titi 104 67
34 70 66 43 46 70 60
23 24 28 36 27
0 0 0 0
30 34 35 33 38
15 20 18 20 20
-
29
0
40
23
-
32 12 24 22 30 36 26
0 0
49 48 56 46 47 59 66
26 29 34 27 28 34 40
103
67
Kmlinite and Goethite
Bauxite Halloysite
-
-
-
Keuper marl
-
-
__ -
-~
Ca bentonite
10
78
Its mixture with quartz sand
10 8
60 43 38 32 11
7 5 3
Illite Its mixture with quartz sand
49
61
40 28 24
44 33 28
K* K* K* K* K* K* 0
0
0 0 0 0
M M M M M M I I I I
NaOH
c
of plesticity [yo]
Method
6o
83 61 55 47 32
36 28 24 21
87
43
76 68 50
32 24 21
Derab et al., 1967
a
61
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments Table 1.2-3. (cont.)
I The type of the sample
Clav content and the type of the vartons clay minerals
i I
without with peptiaa- peptition tion
18 9 0
clay mine-
0 0 0 0
Kaolinite
-
48
K
IUite
-
36
I M
Its mixture with quartz sand
0
Na bentonite
Na bentonite Ca bentonite Clay (Oligocene)
78 11 0 0 3 0
Silt (Oligocene) Silt (alluvium) Clay (alluvium)
**
8
96
80 29 11 7 13 17 12
Method d for pepthtion
Ohteristics of plasticity [%] References
I I
23 10 18 14 11 10 8 4
Kaolinite
1
42 29 33 28 22 19 17 11
22 16 22 17 14 13 11 11
46
36
48 622
24 48
398 87 46 33 30 28 44
34 35
K K
K K K K
M
Na hexametaphosphate
Na$iO,
M I 1 0 0 M
Seed et al., 1964
author’s measurement
22 19 22 20 24
Halloysite The parameter increased due to keeping the sample still.
( C ) Data of brown forest soils from clayey Pliocene marine sediments measured by sedimentation
(The types of clay minerals were not determined) Clay content
12 12 10 16 17 20 10 16 13 37 20
Characteristics
34 36 39 56
89 86 42 60 38 73 44
21 19 22 23 27 26 20 25 20 38 28
Chanrcteristics
14 12 13 10 11 22 24 21 11 18 16
46 48 41 34 39 48 68 61 37 55 48
18 20 19 20 19 24 27 27 25 26 20
11 10 12 12 18 23 17 16 28 13 18
37 34 44 40 44 42 66 73 73 24 37
19 16 26 23 23 24 26 34 33 16 19
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Table 1.2-3.(con$.)
16 13 12 12 11 12 13 10
12 13 11 17 12 11 9 14 28 20 19 23 16 14 14 12 20 13 19 22 16 23 16 18 16 19 16
36 60 66 48 46 46 41 60 48 38 46 43 47 47 48 46 70 66 71 61 67 62 46 46 67 40 44 64 46 60 60 62 61 68 46
22 26 23 23 22 21 21 26 22 21 24 24 26 23 24 24 28 29 34 24 33 27 24 26 21 23 20 29 23 23 20 26 26 24 24
6 13 10 8 16 18 16 20 26 19 6 27 18 34 11 20 12 16 18 30 9 13 7 6 6 7 6 11 10 8 10 6 10
9 9
42 43 60 40 66 61 40 67 62 76 46 63 66 71 38 48 43 47 66
66 34 33 63 43 32 30 33 48 43 38 66 32 42 60 62
29 24 24 24 24 21 24 23 23 36 21 26 28 26 24 22 20 18 22 20 18 18 19 18 13 16 20 23 22 22 23 16 20 22 20
10 14 16 7 9 13 7 10 12 14 17 10 14 16 14 8 11 6 7 14 6 6 10 10 9 8 11 8 8 12 10 14 6 27 17 8
48 60 82 70 48 49 46 46 42 48 66 61 43 60 60 34 32 26 27 47 27 26 46 41 41 38 43 42 38 37 33 32 38 67
46 37
21 26 39 32 23 27 26 20 23 20 31 29 23 24 24 22 18 18 20 21 17 16 20 20 19 18 19 20 20 19 18 21 21 23 31 26
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
63
(D) Data of alluwicrl loess eods meaeured by sedimentation (Peptization with NaPO,; the types of clay minerals were not determined)
24 12 7 4 2 4
6 6 3 8
6 6 6 3 4
6 6 6 4 14
6 6 16 10 1 6 6 6 3 2 33 2 1 2 37 21 40 6
6 4 10 23 13 30 13 26 3 14 16 24 16
32 31 29 23 16 20 36 23 12 37 19 18 31 18 18 18 29 18 14 30 30 23 23 16 14 26 37 23 37 26 42 19 19 38 31 43 47 34 17 16 39 31 40 29 32 39 16 36 24 32 24
67 69 68 43 31 40 62 39 32 73 37 42 67
40 46 36 68 33 32 66 61
44 44 33 28
60 66 48 79 47 76 41 29 62 60 67 86 73 63 38 67 61 64 86 46 67 28 68 46 63 42
26 26 24 23 19 22 28 22 22 30 21 20 26 22 23 21 26 20 20 28 21 20 20 18 19 21 22 23 26 21 23 28 14 21 22 24 19 24 22 19 22 24 27 28 22 28 21 21 22 26 26
16 6 21 12 17 24 10 17 14 6 16 28 11 18 11 8 37 8 30 29 10 10 41 33 30 16 23 19 16 20 26 13 22 10 24 19 10 22 9 26 10 3 6
7 3 20 12 2
3 18 1
33 11 31 17 32 36 17 18 28 28 27 39 12 34 19 26 41 30 30 46 24 31 46 46 26 28 40 20 33 29 39 24 32 28 32 22 17 22 13 39 28 23 19 26 33 34 30 16 21 34 22
60 29 60 38 62 68 31 37 46 48 49 67 36 60 39
42 82 49 42 63 40 49 86 71 63 60 62 68 48 72
60 49 64 49 68 38 41 68 36 71 22 42 40 46 48 67 69 30 40 67 44
26 19 23 20 30 28 24 19 22 24 24 28 24 22 23 20 30 23 21 28 23 26 36 29 20 21 28 26 21 28 18 23 24 23 23 21 21 26 18 26 18 20 27 24 28 24 27 18 19 26 19
6 6 1 6 36 7 4 6 10 9 20 13 11 31 19
44 6 7 6 6 11 16 10 4 0 26
6 6 10 20 6 20 7 26 7 4 3 3 2 17 30
6 6 11
6 11 2
0 2 38 10
20 28 13 29
60 32 23 10 26 14 21 27 27 60 27 41 11 30 26 24 18 23 22 12 27 32 23 26 20 23 17 31 26 37 19 16 9 12 26 27 41 21 26 19 14 11 18 14 20 62 26
40 48 34 68 92 66 41 40 47 30 49 47 68 83 60 88 21 48 47 39 38 47 60 29 61
66 48 44 38 49 43 60 41 66 37 62 28 27 42 44 41 64 64 34 48 26 40 30 38 86 60
19 24 22 26 36 23 20 20 22 22 26 20 24 30 26 36 16 22 30 20 19 24 26 24 26 23 24 23 19 24 24 23 22 24 20 23 23 23 21 24 23 24 23 20 23 19 20 12 20 30 32
64
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
structed from these data, do not show such marked differences between the types of clay minerals, as those based on the results of artificial samples: e.g. the curve of natural kmlinites more closely resembles the curve of artificial montmorillonite, than the curve representing artificial kmlinite samples (Fig. 1.2-11). The series of measurements quoted in Dumbleton and West’s paper reveals that the relation curve changes according to the methods used to determine
0
0
0.5
Determined wifh
minerological method
-- ------
monfmorillonife
-.-._.-kaoJihfe ......_._.......[puppr marl
sedirnenfsfiun
-----...- ...-...-
(siflgle data)
Fig. 1.2-1 1. Relationship between clay content and the parameters of plasticity (after Dumbleton and West, 1966)
the clay content. In their investigations, the authors used various samples of Keuper marl and the results are summarized in a figure which is reproduced here aa Fig. 1.2-12. The data obtained by mineralogical measurements indicate a close relationship. The scattering of points representing the data measured by sedimentation is greater, and the clay content corresponding to a given plasticity according to these data is considerably smaller than that obtained when the mineralogical data are used. When data measured in different countries and by various investigators are plotted on one figure (the w p - Szprelationship in Fig. 1.2-13. and the w L - S, relationship in Fig. 1.2-14), the separation of the points bears a direct relation to the methods used to determine the clay content, and not to the various types of clay minerals. This statement is verified by Fig. 1.2-13a and 1.2-14a, which represent almost all data listed in Table 1.2-3.
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clestio sediments
65
Only a few data had to be omitted, their results being very different from that of the majority of the samples. The different behaviour of these samples, however, can always be explained by the presence of special clay minerals (Na-montmorillonite, halloysite, or amorphous colloids). The left-hand side of each of these figures constructed from more than 500 data is covered with points measured by sedimentation, while on the right-hand side, the data determined by mineralogical methods can be found.
s?
*
% g
30 20 10
* 50 Q
g
o
io 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
loo
creg confent, SZp I%3 o
The S2/1 determinetion with sedimenfation wifh mineralogical
metbads Fig. 1.2-12. Modification of relationships between clay content and the parameters of plasticity caused by the methods used for determination of clay content (after Dumbleton and West, 1966)
There is quite a well defined border between these two regions in each cme. For characterizing these borders the following curves expressed by mathematical equations can be used:
+ 0.42Sg , w L = 0.175 + 1.26 s v .
wP = 0.125
(1.2-6) (1.2-7)
Only a few points from each group do not lie on their own particular side of the border, and the distance of these points from the given curves is generally smdler than the probable error in the original measurements (differences of -+lo% are indicated in the figures). The existence of a border between the two different groups of data is clearly demonstrated by the figures, and its sigdicance cannot be ignored. The first question however, concerning the evaluation of the figures is, what do the lines characterized by Eqs (1.2-6)and (1.2-7)mean? To answer this 5
66
1 Fundamentals for the investigetion of seepage
I aj Arrangement of data according to methods
used for measurement 0
50 -
dota determined by sedimentation data. determined by mineralogical methods
. . .
25
0
*
50
75
J
ib) Arrangement of data determined by mineralogical methods
?I
25
50
75
SZP Kb'?lCD
Fig. 1.2-13. Relationship between clay content and the limit of plasticit,y
question, it is necessary to recall that the total amount of clay content can be divided into three groups: '
(a) Individual grains (the total surface is active); (b) Grains united by loose bonds (almost the entire surface of each grain is active);
1.2 Physical and mineralogical pmxneters of clastic sediments
67
c) Arrangement of dsfa dztemioed b j seri'lmeffiafiou according to methods usEd for pepfisafion
x
English standard
o
Na CO,
8
wifbout peptisation
9
(c) Grains bound by irreverbible aggregation (the inner surface of these aggregates is not active).
It has already been mentioned that the total amount of fine grain&is measured by mineralogical methods, and therefore, the clay content determined in this way is always greater than or equal to the actual amount of active grains, if there are no grains bound together by irreversible aggregation in the sample. Meanwhile, the clay content measured by sedimentation can only be smaller than or equal to the amount of active grains smaller than 2 p, depending on the coagulation in the suspension. The right-hand sides of the figures include data greater than (or equal to) the active clay content, and the left-hand sides, those which are smaller than (or at the limit equal to) it. Thus, it is evident that the border line indicates the relationship between the really active clay content (including the fist two groups of fine grains, but excluding the grains bound by irreversible aggregation), and the parameter of plasticity in question. Consequently, i t can be stated that Eys (1.2-6) and (1.2-7) give the correct weight of active grains of 2 p diameter which is needed for the determination of the effective diameter. This value (azp) isafunctionof the limit of plasticity and the liquid limit, respectively. 5*
1 Fundament& for the investigation of seepage
68
(a)Arrangemenenf of data according to methods of measurement used 0
0
data determined by sedimenttion data determined by minerafogicaf meihods
Q
( illite monfmori:ionife)
0
mixed or undetermined samples
25
.
50
75
Fig. 1.2-14. Relationship between clay content and liquid limit
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clestic sediments
69
[c) Arrangeme& of dafa defermined by sedlinenfaff'on according to methods used for pe@WiOn x
W$
J
too
75
50
x
25
English stirndaro
wifhouf peptisation
I0
0
1
I
,
25
50
75
sz/lfil
1
A second question has also to be considered in connection with the present investigation: i.e. do the various types of clay minerals have any influence on the proposed relation curves ? Contrary to previous investigations, the answer is negative and requires further explanation. The points in the figures are not separated according to the clay minerals. The various points representing kaolinite, montmorillonite, illite, or other minerals can be found situated along the border with almost the same probability, which indicates that the border line can stand for all types of clay minerals (except for Na-montmorillonite, halloysite, and amorphous colloids). On the other hand, some separation can be observed on the right-hand side of the figures, among data determined by mineralogical methods (see Figs 1.2-13b and 1.2-14b). I n general the points for kaolinites, or other small grains that are not members of the three main clay-mineral groups (e.g. Keuper marl) are dispersed farthest away from the border line, while points for montmorillonite are located along it.
70
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Recalling the energy curves shown in Fig. 1.2-10, some explanation of the differences can also be given. The energy curve of montmorillonite is similar to type A in the figure, while that of kaolinite is similar to type B. In the first case, the repulsive force is higher than the adhesive one over a considerable distance, and their difference increases as the distance decreases. The sign of the resultant changes only in the very close vicinity of the wall. The number of irreversible aggregations is, therefore, very small. The energy curve of type B shows, however, a higher adhesive force at each point, that of A . A considerable number of kaolinites - represented by this type of curve - can therefore easily be aggregated, so that the total clay content is always higher than the active one. The effects of various chemicals used to disintegrate the flakes in the suspension can also be investigated (Figs 1.2-13c and 1.2-14c). It can be seen that the use of sodiumhexametaphosphate (English standard) is the most reliable method. In general, however, the sedimentation involves a very high uncertainty. As a result it can be stated that the relationship between plasticity and the active clay content is not influenced by the type of clay mineral as long as Na-montmorillonite, halloysite, and amorphous colloids are excluded from the investigation. The probable ratio between active and total clay content, however, depends on whether montmorillonite, illite, kaolinite, or other minerals are dominant in the sample. The next step is the necessity t o control the validity of Eqs (1.2-6) and (1.2-7) and to provide a method for determining the presence of interfering clay minerals in the investigated sample. The simplest control is to calculate the active clay content, using different parameters of plasticity, and to compare the values obtained. When the two values of clay content determined from w p and wL are close to each other, the proposed method is applicable, while a difference higher than a given limit (e.g. 10 15%) refers to the presence of clay minerals, which exclude the application of the derived relationships. Some results of this type of comparison are given in Table 1 . 2 4 . Another method of control mentioned is the use of Casagrande’s A line. It is well known that the equation of this line gives a linear relationship between the index of plasticity (i.e. I , = wL - wp) and the liquid limit: I = w L - wp = 0.73(wL - 0.2). (1.2-8) A similar relation curve can be derived from Eqs (1.2-6) and (1.2-7): TV
,
I , = wL - wP = 0.05
+ 0.84 Sir = 2/3(wL - 0.1).
(1.2-9)
To evaluate the difference between Eqs (1.2-8) and (1.2-9) the possible scattering of points wm determined by assuming that there may be an error of &loyoand f 1 5 % respectively in the measurements of both the liquid limit and the limit of plasticity. 84.2% of points representing the sampleo listed in Table 1.2-3 are within the zone of 10% error covering this field almost uniformly. 32 points are located above this zone and 49 below it, from which 26 and 35 respectively are within the zone of f 1 5 y 0 error (Fig. 1.2-15). The figure was supplemented by the results of some previous
71
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
Material
euthor’ameasurement SzilvAgyi (1966) Craft (1967)
Kwlinite
Dumbleton and West (1966) Dumbleton and West (1966) Craft (1967)
Y
Silt
0.33 0.43 1.03
0.19 0.23 0.39
0.20 0.40 0.88
0.07 0.14
0.26
-
0.79
0.28 0.39 0.74
0.62
0.26
-
0.41
0.42
0.44
0.82 0.69
0.42
0.96 0.88
-
0.64 0.47
0.79
0.30
-
I
Actdm day wntent
0.36
0.66
Schmertmann (1962) Dumbleton and West (1966)
0.38
0.19
0.63
-
0.30
0.29
0.77
0.36
-
0.63
0.60
0.66
author’s measurement Thompson (1966)
0.33 0.64
0.19 0.24
0.20
0.07 0.34
0.26 0.43
0.28 0.41
’
Material
Claycontent determined by
Investigator
Illite
a
almm&z%ics of plasticity
Oharacteristica o! plasticity
IIlVestigator VL
I
-
Clay wntent determined by mtnereaedimentation
WP
:zz81
0.38
-
Active day wlltent
2;
I 2:
..
the preparation of the sample (probably amorphous colloids)
(1966)
0.78
0.86
0.61
0.74
72
100
rpPLI
90
70 .
number of data above the line o f 15 % error 60 50
number of data below the line of 45% error 14 (2.7 %)
40
30. I0f.S~
A
(DUn~~V8fOS)
20
Casagrande's A line A
Dumbleton and Wesf
(0
'
0-
Fig. 1.2-15. Represontation of the investigated samples in 8 coordinate system compoaed of the index of plaeticity and liquid limit (Ca88grande's A line)
1 Fundarnentale for the investigation of seepage
ao
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
73
investigations as well (Rkthhti, 1971; Herczog et al., 1966; Dumbleton and West, 1966). The comparison shows the reliability of Eqs (1.2-6) and (1.2-7). It is also reasonable in practice t o use Eq. (1.2-9) instead of Caagrande’s equation [i.e. Eq. (1.2-8)]. Not only is the accuracy of Eqs (1.2-6) and (1.2-7) supported by the existence of such a linear relationship, but at the same time the explanation of these equations, which was missing until now serves aa a physical background of Casagrande’s A line. The linear relationship of I , and wL is based on the fact that both values (more precisely w p and wL) depend on the active clay content of the samples, and this common cause creates close contact between the parameters of plasticity. Excluding some special minerals (Na-montmorillonite, halloysite, amorphous colloids), this relationship is not influenced by the type of clay minerals. Knowing the memured w p and wL values of a sample, the latter can be represented by a point in the I , - wL system. If this point is within the zone determined by the possible error in measurements, Eqs (1.2-6) and (1.2-7) can be used to calculate the active clay content of the sample. Considering the results of these investigations, the grain-size distribution curves, the lower stretches of which were either measured by sedimentation or determined by mineralogical analysis, can be corrected so that they represent the actual morphological character of the colloid particla. The method of corredion is as follows. Firstly, the distribution of grain diameters of particles larger than 0.1 mm has to be determined by sieving. The method generally used for memuring the lower section of the distribution curve is the sedimentation of the bample, from which the grains larger than 0.1 mm have already been separated. It is advisable to execute this analysis both with distilled water and by adding sodiumhexametaphosphate t o the suspension (English standard). The difference between the curves determined by these two methods indicates the morphological character of the colloid grains. If the ordinates of the two curves belonging t o the D = 2 p diameter differ considerably, the sample contains large amounts of rtctive colloid particles. It is expected that the active clay content is equal to, or near the value determined by the analysis of the chemically treated suspension. When there is a possibility of detailed investigation of the mineralogical composition of the sample (X-ray, electron microscope, DTA), informa,t’ion can be obtained not only on its total colloid content, but aldo on the ratio of different minerals (montmorillonite, kmlinite, illite, amorphous colloids) in the fraction of the sample, smaller than 2 p. This type of analysis is relatively expensive and therefore, not generally applied in every day routine work. After measuring the two plastic properties of the sample (liquid limit and limit of plasticity) the active clay content (the ratio of the weight of colloid particles having a smaller diameter than 2 p , and not bound irreversibly in aggregates to the total weight of the sample) has to be determined from Eqs (1.2-6) and (1.2-7). If the two values calculated in this way do not differ considerably, or the point representing the measured wL and w p value, lie near or along the corrected Casagrande’s A line in Fig. 1.2-15. the average
74
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
of the two calculated S2,, values can be accepted as the most probable active clay content. This value indicates the height of the grain-size distribution curve belonging to the diameter of 2 p. Hence, the curve may be corrected to pass through this point. The corrected distribution curve can be the bmis for the determination of the effective diameter, the calculation of which is explained in the previous section [Fig. 1 . 2 4 and Eq. ( 1 . 2 4 ) or (1.2-5)]. It is hoped that this diameter correctly expresses the morphological character of the colloid particles, being calculated from the grain-size distribution curve corrected by considering the active clay content of the sample. According to the hypothesis explained previously, the mineralogical composition of the grains modifies the behaviour of the sample in relation to water only through influencing the development of irreversible or loose aggregates. It is assumed therefore, that the effective diameter calculated in this way is suitable for the characterization of the resistance to flow through the pores of the sample, without any further mineralogical investigations if the colloid particles behave normally. It has already been mentioned that there are some minerals, the presence of which considerably changes the interaction between water and grains in the sample. The most important minerals causing such “abnormal7’ behaviour are Na-montmorillonite, halloysite and the amorphous colloids. The interfering effects of these minerals are indicated by the large difference calculated from Eqs (1.2-6) and (1.2-7), or between the two values of S2,, by the fact that the point representing the measured wL and w p parameters of the sample does not lie along the Cmagrande’s A line. In this case, detailed mineralogical investigation of the sample is advisable. Examples of the correction to the grain-size distribution curve according to the calculated active clay content are shown in Fig. 1.2-16. The distribution curves of two samples are represented in the figure. The samples (Ca bentonite and clay) were analyzed both mineralogically (curve I ) and by sedimentation, the latter with distilled water (curve 2) and after treating the suspension with NaCO, (curve 3). Thus, originally three curves were determined for each sample. The correction was executed on the basis of the calculated active clay content (curve a), and the effective diameters were determined. The ratio of the effective diameters determined from the corrected distribution curve, and that calculated on the basis of the analysis of the chemically treated suspension is 1/300 TV 1/200. (N.B. I n the examples, the probable active clay contents were determined from a third parameter of plasticity, i.e. maximum molecular water retention capacity, which also hm a close relationship with the active clay content.) The examples can also be used to demonstrate the change occurring as the result of any modification of the morphological character of the colloid particles. For this purpose, the influence of intense and repeated drying was investigated. The water films surrounding the grains are decreased by drying, and hence the distance between the grains also decreases, a process which increases the number of irreversible aggregates in the sample. The consequence of drying is therefore, the lowering of plasticity, and the increase in the hydraulic conductivity. The latter parameter can be mea-
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of claatic sediments
75
groin diameter CmmJ Fig. 1.2-16. Change in grain-size distribution curves aa a result of drying
sured for the control of the accuracy of the distribution curves constructed on the basis of the previously explained method. The numerical results of the investigation are summarized in Table 1.2-5, and the probable grain-size distribution curves are represented by dotted lines. The clecreme in the parameter used for the characterization of plasticity, clearly indicates the increase in the number of the irreversibly bound Table 1.2-6. The change in maximum molecular water retention capacity and hydraulic conductivity aa the results of drying
Cs bentonite
37.6
1.3 x 10-o
29.0
9.3 x 10-0
Clay
20.2
4.6 x
16.9
4.1 x 10-7
particles. The new distribution curve shows the increase in the effective diameters, which is the expected result of aggregation. In the case of the first sample, the effective diameter is 2.65 times greater than that of the original sample, while for clay this ratio is 3.16/1. This result can be checked by comparing hydraulic conductivities measured before and after drying. As will be proved further on, hydraulic conductivity is linearly proportional to the square of the effective diameter. Thus, the expected ratio of the
16
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
increase in the former parameter is 7/1 and l o l l , while the measured quotients are 7.1 and 9.1, respectively. This investigation proves both the reliability of the method proposed to determine the relationship between active clay contents and pmameters characterizing plasticity, and the influence of the change in the number of irreversible aggregates on active clay content.
1.2.4 Relationship between porosity and the geometrical parameters of grains Apart from the size and shape of grains and the grain-sizedistribution, there is a further important variable influencing the size of pores and channels between the grains i.e. porosity. This is the volume of pores (V,) related t o the total volume (V,) of the sample*: (1.2-10)
[the meaning of the symbols used in Eq.(1.2-10) is indicated in Fig. 1.2-17, KBzdi, 19721. In some investigations, the use of void ratio instead of porosity is reasonable. This parameter is the volume of pores related to that of the solid grains:
V V
e =2, and
consequently e =
n
.
~
1-n
(1.2-11)
ti0
3
p = - =VPp ' + e "
V
n=-=-G V,+V
e e+t
Fig. 1.2-1 7. Symbols used in connection with the determination of porosity and void ratio
* The problems occurring in connection with the correct interpretation of porosity have already been mentioned in Section 1.1.2, but the differences between total and effective porosities caused by the presence of pores not interconnected with the network of the other interstices can be neglected when loose clastic sediments are investigated.
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
77
The scattering of porosity is considerable. The porosity of the loosest structure of a homodisperse sample of spheres (Fig. 1.2-18), when the centres of the spheres form a hexahedron in space (a= go"), and each sphere is in contact with six others, is n = 0.476. I n the case of the most compact sample, the angle with the same configuration being a = 60°, horizontal seri7on
vertical section
Fig. 1.2-18. Position of grains in a homodisperse sample of spheres having various porosities
each sphere is in contact with twelve others, and the porosity is n = 0.259. I n general, when the angle mentioned previously lies between the two limits (a = 90 + 60),the porosity can be calculated from the following equation (Slichter, 1899): n=l-
nl 6(1 - cos a) 1/1
+ 2 cos a
(1.2-12) *
The upper limit of porosity, however, is not absolutely invariable. A stable structure of spheres can be built up where the particles form arches, and 0.7 (Jkky, porosity is higher than the theoretical upper limit: n = 0.6 1944). The variability of porosity is even greater in the case of natural layers. It is influenced by the origin of the layer, the size and shape of the grains, the grain-size distribution, and the pressure affecting the layer a8 well. Fluvial sediments (sand and gravel) are generally well compacted, while sand of lacustrine origin is usually deposited in less compact layers. The porosity of cohesive materials (clay) is influenced by chemicals dissolved in the water. When these chemicals increase coagulation, the settled flakes build up a loose layer, while a more compact layer is formed from suspensions in which the development of flakes is hindered. The relationship between porosity and the size of particles can be explained by the fact that the number of contacts between grains related to the unit weight of the sample increases when the size of particles decreases. Thus, the resistance against the movement of a grain attempting a more stable position, is also increased, the layer of fine grains being generally less compacted. This effect is strenghtened by the shape of the grains as well. Among fine grains there are more laminated particles and, therefore, their surface-
-
78
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Homodiapersesamples consisting of following grains
Material
I
The porosity of the sample
I
I
D i ~ e r d cShape ient
inloose incompacted ~condition
Ground rocksalt
1.60
Ground mica
1.60
90*
Lead balls
2.42 2.03 1.40
6.0 6.0
6.0
0.369 0.369 0.370
Round beans
3.43
10*
0.376
Poppy seeds
0.61
8*
0.398
2.24 0.36 0.12 0.046
8* 8* 8* 8*
0.377 0.382 0.386 0.426
Sand
0.218 0.281 0.366 0.448
9.4 8.0 8.3 7.6
0.437-0.428 0.408-0.424 0.412-0.426 0.424-0.41 9
0.372-0.384 0.374-0.373 0.384-0.386 0.377-0.374
Sand after making i t glow
0.218 0.281 0.366 0.448
8.4 7.8 8.0 8.1
0.462-0.436 0.468-0.440 0.439-0.466 0.436-0.436
0.392-0.382 0.389-0.393 0.406-0.419 0.384-0.386
Ground flint
0.068 0.106 0.163 0.264 0.386 0.63 0.81 1.40 2.12
Washed round sand
Flint sand
0.2-0.4
20-26*
20-26*
Referenen
0.620
0.436
0.924
0.873 Westmann and Hugill, 1930
Chardabellaa, 1964
0.698 0.693 0.686 0.670 0.660 0.660 0.660 0.640 0.626
0.4& 0.484 0.479 0.460 0.460 0.460 0.460 0.460 0.460
Andreasen, 1960
0.642
0.462
Donat, 1929
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clagtic sediments
79
Table 1.2.-6. (cant.)
Sand
0.010 0.003 0.001
Sand
0.096 0.162 0.483 0.611
Sea sand
0.016 0.030 0.040 0.060 0.136 0.190 0.300
Sea sand
0.010 0.030 0.040 0.060 0.070 0.080 0.090
diSCS
Aluminium pins
1958
0.406 0.460 0.376 0.369 0.376 0.376 0.373 0.384 0.396 0.41 8 0.443 0.442
8*
0.467 0.363 0.250 0.177 0.126 0.089 0.061
Aluminium
Fuchtbauer and Reineck,
0.776 0.760 0.615 0.630 0.606 0.604 0.676 0.490 0.426 0.426 0.446 0.430 0.446 0.420 0.410 0.436 0.436
0.600
36.4 18.6 14.3 10.4
39.0 23.1 20.4 23.9
0.608 0.663 0.670 0.686
0.601 0.467 0.403 0.410
10.0
36.6
0.686
0.600
* Estimated values
King, 1899
Hamilton and Menard, 1966
0.676 0.610 0.720 0.612-0.610 0.476 0.467 0.410
0.120 0.130 0.140 0.160 0.160 0.170 0.190 0.200 0.210 0.220 0.230 1.386 0.693
1962 0.386 0.368 0.329 0.362
0.110
Sand
Emery and Rittenberg,
0.730 0.800 0.890
Stakman, 1966a
author's measurements
80
1 Fundamentala for the investigation of seepage
volume ratio is higher, a fact which further increases the number of contacts, and helps in forming arches. Table 1.2-6 shows measured data collected from the literature representing the porosity of homodisperse samples (or samples built up from grains having very small differences in size) as a function of the diameter and the shape of the grains. !. 0
0.3 0.8
e 0.7 9 % 0.6
8 a c cx
0.5 0.4
0.3 0.2
5
6
7
8
910
20
30
40
50
60 70 BD 90 110
shape coefficient, a Fig. 1.2-19. Relationship between porosity and shape coefficient
The graphs in Fig. 1.2-19 constructed from these data show the relationship between porosity and shape coefficient. Only measurements concerning grains larger than 0.2 mm were used. I n this zone the influence of the grain size can be neglected, and thus, the data characterizingtherelation of porosity to shape coefficient can be regarded as a homogeneous set, suitable for the unambiguous representation of the relationship between the two variables. In the semi-logarithmic coordinate system used for plotting the data, the curves - representing both compacted and loose conditions - can be approximated by a parabola of the second order [see Eq. (2.1-14)]. The lower limit of validity, above which this approximation can be applied, is the 0.2 mm grain diameter as mentioned previously. A set of data from the same series can also be chosen representing grains of approximately the same shape. According to graphs constructed from these data (Fig. 1.2-20), the porosity of homodisperse samples does not depend on the diameter of grains, if the latter is greater than 0.2 mm. Below this limit porosity increases with decreasing diameter. It has also been shown, that some measurements (Hamilton and Menard, 1956; Fuchtbauer and Reineck, 1958) contain data of samples differing from each other not
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clestic sediments
RO~
0102 alu
005
41
nz
81
lo
Fig. 1.2-20. Relationship between porosity and the diameter of grains 0.40
e
0.38
.s2
0.36
0
0.34
0.32 0.30 WLY
,
o
dz
i4
ols
la
ihemt~oofthe two mtked wmples, rn
r'o
mu-vd, vd2
0
02
0.4
0.8
0.8
10
the ratio of the two nixed samples, m Fig. 1.2-21 .. The porosity of a mixture of two homodispanm munples and the modification of porosity es a fmction of the ratio of the weights of the two samples
6
82
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
only in particle size, but in the shape of grains as well. The probability of this statement is proved not only by the origin of the samples (natural samples from the sea bed were investigated, where the grains may be separated according to both size md shape), but also by comparison with data of grains with a known shape coefficient. For this reason, the rapid chamge in porosity, represented by a dotted line in the figure, cannot be accepted, although some authors have drawn this conclusion from the observations mentioned (Chardabellas, 1964; Engelhardt, 1960). A further well-known relationship between porosity and grain-size distribution exists. Porosity is generally higher in a homodisperse sample than that in a layer composed of grains of various sizes. In the latter case, the very fine grains can fill the pores between the larger particles, thus decreasing the volume of the pores without changing the total volume of the sample, King’s experiments exhibit this effect very well, representing the change in porosity of a mixture of two homodisperse samples as the ratio of the two samples when the mixture was modified (Fig. 1.2-21) (King, 1899). Chardabellas has made very detailed analyses during investigations on the way in which porosity is influenced by grain-size distribution. He has found 4
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
coefficient of uniformity, U Fig. 1.2-22. Relationship between porosity and the coefficient of uniformity
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
83
that the shape of the distribution curve, the location of its maximum, whether the curve has one or more maxima, all affect the porosity in both compacted and loose conditions (Chardabellas 1964). I n practice, however, it is preferable to give an equation which can describe the existing relationship numerically as a function of only one or a few known parameters with acceptable accuracy, rather than use a classification based on the comparison with standard curves, as proposed by Chardabellas. Figure 1.2-22 constructed from data listed in Table 1.2-7, shows that porosity is closely related to the coefficient of uniformity. Although there is some scattering of the points, the relationship can be well approximated by an exponential equation in both cases representing compacted and loose conditions [see Eq. (1.2-15)]. As a summary of the results shown in Figs 1.2-19 and 1.2-22, the calculation of the expected lowest and highest porosity can be given for samples having a greater effective diameter than 0.2 mm as follows: (a) The probable extreme values of porosity for a homodi.yperse sample of spheres can be taken in practice as no mIn = 0.38; and no max = 0.43;
(1.2-13)
(b) The relationship between porosity and shape coefiient can be approximated by a parabola of the second order in the system used in Fig. 1.2-19. Thus, the porosity of a homodisperse sample composed of irregular grains is
[+
n , = no 1
I al'l
Ion! log-
,
(1.2-14)
which gives the porosity of a compacted and a loose sample respectively, according to the substituted value of no; (c) The porosity of a heterodisperse sample can be determined as a function of the coefficient of uniformity and the corresponding n, value: 2 n=-n 3
u-1
(1.2-15)
As the investigation was limited to grains larger than 0.2 mm the influence of the grain diameter could therefore, be neglected. For the analysis of the relationships between porosity and the geometrical parameters of grains, the cases of compacted and loose samples were investigated separately. These two extreme values indicate a relatively large interval, which covers the probable porosity of the natural layers. As already mentioned, the pressure acting on the layer also affects porosity. I n addition porosity is influenced not only by present day pressures, but by all pressures in force during previous geological ages, due to the lack of elasticity of the layers. The relationship between porosity, or more precisely, void ratio, and the present acting pressure can be expressed in terms of the depth of the layer below the surface, the latter being proportional to the pressure. The equation generally used to represent this relationship is based on the hypothesis 6*
Table 1.2-7. Data characterizing the porosity of heterodispeme samples The pomsity of the eample
The investigated @ample
Heterodiepem eemple of send
Mixture of homodisperse semples of send
10.9 9.7 10.4 9.6 9.1 9.0 8.3 10.4 10.3 9.2 9.1 9.6 9.6 9.2 10.0 9.1
0.466 0.466 0.676 0.662 0.378 0.387 0.739 0.162 0.162 0.366 0.366 0.478 0.404 0.404 0.466 0.430 0.460 0.464 0.138 0.802 0.810 0.306 0.261 0.211
9.9 10.4 9.2 8.3 10.6 10.3 10.7
10 10
0.246 0.246 0.320 0.320 0.401
8.3 8.0 7.6 7.6 8.0
10 10 10 10 10
8.7
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
2.10 2.00 3.16 3.03 1.81 1.86 6.40 1.66 1.66 2.09 2.09 3.36 2.46 2.46 2.67 2.39 3.83 3.38 1.81 4.38 3.76 2.80 2.00 2.89
0.384 0.377 0.364 0.352 (0.390) (0.391) (0.318) 0.429 0.416 (0.364) (0.367) 0.310 0.399 (0.398) 0.364 (0.349) (0.360) 0.366 0.414 (0.329) (0.334) 0.344 0.346 0.374
1.27 1.27 1.26 1.26 1.26
(0.436) (0.426) (0.429) (0.436) (0.426)
0.396 0.397 0.326 0.368 0.370 0.403 0.363 0.367 0.333 0.342
0.446 0.437 0.444 0.449 0.436
0.343 0.336 0.308 0.308 (0.348) (0.349) (0.266) 0.368 0.366 (0.324) (0.333) 0.290 0.364 (0.362) 0.328 (0.321) (0.304) 0.287 0.378 (0.284) (0.292) 0.308 0.308 0.324 (0.386) (0.398) (0.388) (0.386) (0.381)
chardabellas, 1964
2
1 W
0.361 0.363 0.271
R
E ?
?
0.327 0.336
w.
1
0.366 0.323 0.309 0.286 0.297
0.392 0.406 0.397 0.394 0.387
Chardabellas, 1964
0.401 0.277 0.277 0.349 0.349 0.300 0.295 Mixture of homodisperse samples of sand
0.185 0.288
Heterndisperse samples of sand
0.016 0.028
Glass bells Sandy gravel
7.6 7.6 7.0 7.3 7.0 6.9 7.3
0.173 6.0 0.136 6.0 _____ 10 10 10
10 10 10 10 10 10 10
1.26 1.41 1.41 1.45 1.45 1.59 1.69
(0.429) (0.433) (0.431) (0.421) (0.431) (0.411) (0.429)
0.443 0.447 0.447 0.435 0.447 0.426 0.444
5.06 4.00 -____ 3.0 0.390 1.3 0.430 10 10
1.45 1.59 37.0 48.0 10.4
(0.426) (0.406) 0.307 0.300 0.318
(0.386) (0.328) (0.377) (0.371) (0.368) (0.368) (0.372)
0.394 0.390 0.385 0.381 0.377 0.377 0.382 0.255
c1
ia
5!
King, 1899
0.303
0.442 0.422
E
5
Weweling and Wit, 1966
n4 !3 5'
Sine and Bentz,
1
1966 0.240 0.263 0.285
2.
author's measurements
k 2. 1 W
c
B 3 1 %
86
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
which assumes linear correlation between the modulus of compressibility and pressure (Terzaghi, 1943): %+0 0 . e = e , - clog---,
(1.2-16)
0,;
where 0, is the actual effective normal stress at a depth of z ; and 0 , is the actual effective normal stress at a starting level, near the surface, where the porosity of the layer is characterized by e , (loose condition). There is some contradiction in this equation, because it gives a negative value at very great depth. To eliminate this problem a modified equation wm proposed (Juhhz, 1966): ( 1.2-17)
although there is no significant difference between the two formdm in the range of small depths, and, therefore, Terzaghi’s equation can be used, when the investigated depth is not greater than 100 m. The curves representing the relationship characterized by Eqs (1.2-16) or (1.2-17) are compared t o measured data in Fig. 1.2-23. Both equations can give only rough estimates, because the material of the layer is not elastic and only partial expansion can develop after decreasing the pressure. 0
0.25
0.50
0.75
ele,
la
Fig. 1.2-23. Relationship between porosity and the depth of the investigated point
1.2 Physical and minerelogicel parameters of clestic sediments
87
Thus, compression is not an unambiguous function of the present load (i.e. the depth of the layer in question below the surface at the time of investigation), since porosity has preserved the influence of previous pressures as well. The difference between actual and theoretically calculated porosity may possibly result from the slow development of consolidation. The total stress caused by the load on the layer can be divided into two parts: one taken by the solid skeleton of grains (effective stress), and the other balanced by water pressure (neutral stress). The latter does not cause any compression, and hence, porosity may be a function of the effective stress only. The rate of the effective and neutral stresses changes in time, ae the surplus water is drained from the system. The process depends on the size of loads, and on the permeability of layers. The actual porosity is therefore, the function of all these factors. Finally, it can be stated that the probable zone of the expected porosity can be determined on the basis of Eqs (1.2-13), (1.2-14) and (1.2-15), knowing the geometrical parameters of the grains in the investigated layer. The probable location of the actual value within this interval can also be estimated using Eqs (1.2-16), or (1.2-17). The reliability of the latter, however, is very low because of the effects of many unknown factors.
1.2.5 Physical model representing the irregular network of pores and channels between grains Several attempts have been made previously to substitue the irregularly connected channels formed by the pores of a loose clastic sediment with a regular physical model, in which the relationship between the geometric and hydraulic variables can be determined theoretically. Naturally, the models provide only the most probable form of the movement equations, and carefully executed experiments are necessary to prove the reliability of the model, to examine its validity zone and the accuracy of the equations achieved in this way, and to determine the numerical constants of the formulae. The best known models are those composed of capillary tubes (Scheidegger, 1953, 1960). The most simple form of these models is a bundle of straight pipes. I n other cams the tortuosity of the capillary tubes is also considered. According to another proposal, straight tubes composed of small sections of different diameters are very suitable to simulate flow through the water conveying channels of the sediments. Such bundles can be composed of tubes having only two different diameters (Wyllie and Spangler, 1952), or many different sections ensuring only a constant area free for water transport in a cross section perpendicular to the main direction of flow (Wyllie and Gardner, 1958). Bear and Bachmat’s model (1967) is a generalized form of the capillary tube models, because it is composed of a spatial network of interconnected random passages of varying lengths, cross section and orientation, and of junctions, where the channels (a minimum of three) meet (Bear, 1972).
88
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Another method usually applied for determining the resistivity of the porous medium is to consider the analogy between the drag force acting on a sphere settling in water and the resistance against flow in the interconnected pores (Goldstein, 1938; Ward, 1964). Rumer gives a detailed summary of the results achieved by applying this type of model to characterize the relationship between seepage velocity and hydraulic gradient in the various zones of seepage (De Wiest, 1969). Irmay’s proposal can also be included in this group of models (Bear et al., 1968). In this theory, the resistance of spheres located in steady flow along a line perpendicular t o the flow direction is determined by averaging the solution of Navier-Stokes’ equations, considering also the inertial terms within them. For simulating water movement through fissured and fractured rocks, the various forms of Hele-Show’s model is used (narrow slit between two parallel plates). The slit may have a constant or a varying width. A network of such slits is used many times, assuming either the same width of the slits in all three main directions (see Fig. 1.1-5),or considering the possible anisotropy by applying different gaps in different directions (Louis, 1970;Bocker, 1973). A network of pipes may also be used for the characterization of fractured rocks, especially karstic formations. A large number of geometrical parameters are needed, however, for the description of such a system. It is not euitable therefore, for the general characterization of the resistance of aquifers, but is used for solving special problems in the form of small scale models (Mijatovib, 1970). Although Rumer has stated in the previously quoted 1,ook (De Wiest, 1969),that the capillary tube model is not suitable to characterize non-laminar flow, it can be proved that the difficulties he encountered can be avoided by a conveniently chosen form of pipe (see Chapter 2). On the other hand, from a practical point of view, it is desirable to select the most simple model, from which however, the largest possible amount of information can be gained. For this reason, a bundle of capillary tubes aligned in the main direction of flow will be used as a physical model of the water conveying channels. To ensure the reliable simulation of both non-laminar flow and capillary effect, it is necessary t o use tubes of varying diameters. As will be seen, the simplest of these types of models (that of Wyllie and Spangler using two different diameters) is adequate for this purpose and, therefore, the nurnerical determination of the geometrical parameters of this model will be summarized here. On the basis of the movement equation valid for the investigated condition of flow and determined for a model pipe (e.g. in the case of laminar flow, when the dominating forces are gravity and friction, this equation is the well-known Poiseuille’s formula), the relationship between the hydrodynamic parameters of seepage can be determined, or the previously established empirical formulae can be controlled, and their numerical factors determined (in the case of laminar movement mentioned before as an example, the validity of Darcy’s equation can be determined, and its factor, i.e. hydraulic conductivity can be calculated). Previous investigations have shown that in the caae of homodisperse samples, the diameter of the pipes forming the models is proportional to the
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
89
diameter of grains. Authors investigating heterodisperse samples proposed various design diameters to characterize the sample (e.g. Hazen Dlo; Seelheim Ds0; etc.). The basis of these proposals was the hypothesis that this diameter is proportional to the pipe diameter of the bundle of capillary tubes, which from a hydraulic point of view, is equivalent to the channels composed of the pores in a heterodisperse sample, even if this assumption was not mentioned by the authors (Hazen, 1895; Forchheimer, 1924). Koieny’s work is a very important corner stone of all investigations related to the determination of the characteristic diameter for a heterodisperse sample, and to that of the hydrodynamically equivalent pipe-diameter as well (Koieny, 1953). He has proved that the surface-volume ratio has to be identical in the original sample and the model systems, because in these cases, the sufficient ratio of the two most important forces (i.e. gravity and friction) is ensured. This is the basis of the determination of his effective diameter, as explained in connection with Eq. ( 1 . 2 4 ) . Since the surfacevolume ratio is influenced by the shape of grains as well, the original formula was supplemented by the use of the shape coefficient. Following Koieny’s line of thought Eq. (1.2-5) was finally proposed to determine the quotient of the effective diameter and the average shape coefficient. The same result was achieved by Carman, who proposed the use of the actual surface-volume ratio instead of a characteristic diameter (Caiman, 1956; Engelhardt, 1960). This value is, however, identical to the quotient of Dh/a proposed here, as can easily be proved taking Eq. (1.2-1) into consideration. The advantage of the latter method is that this parameter can be approximated, using average values determined by statistical evaluation of numerous measurements, and thus, it does not require special measurements or investigation for practical purposes. Assuming that the parameter Dh/a is known [e.g. i t was calculated from Eq. (1.2-5)], two conditions can be found to determine the average diameter of the model pipe (do),and the number of pipes crossing the unit area of the section, perpendicular to the main direction of flow ( N ) .According to the first condition, the surface of the pipe-wall related to its inner volume should be equal to the ratio of the grain surface ( A ) in the sample to the pore volume ( V p ) :
consequently, do=--.
4 n D,
(1.2-19)
a The second condition states that the cross section of flow should be identical in both the original and the model system. It follows from this condition that the crobs section of one model pipe multiplied by the number of l-n
90
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
pipes crossing a unit area should be equal to areal porosity, and therefore, the number of pipes can be calculated
N = - =4n” -, din
4n
din
.
(1.2-20)
because according to Eq. (1.1-4), areal porosity is equal to effective porosity. It is necessary to note that some difference can be caused here by the various possible interpretations of the effective and total porosity. I n the case of a porous medium composed of equal cubes (see Fig. 1.1-5), areal and effective porosity values are equal only if the gaps perpendicular to the flow direction are regarded as inactive ones, and thus, the effective porosity is about 0.7 times smaller than the total porosity, although there are no dead ends, isolated pores, or very thin joints. It can be assumed that in a sample composed of individual grains, a few channels me directed at right angles to the flow direction, and therefore, the velocity in them is very smdl, or it may even be zero. These channels only play a role in equalizing the pressure between the stretches of the water conveying network, but not in water transport, as from this aspect, they are inactive. Considering the calculated ratio of the inactive pores in the system of cubes mentioned before &e a lower limit, it may be supposed that the porosity value n used in Eqs (1.2-18), (1.2-19) and (1.2-20), respectively is 0.85-0.95timessmallerthantheparameter determined in soil physics. Knowing the diameter and the number of the pipes, the discharge carried by the model system under a given pressure head can be calculated by using Poiseuille’s equation, assuming the flow t o be laminar. This value can be compared to the results of some very carefully executed experiments (Zunker, 1930; Lindquist, 1933; Carman, 1956).The actual hydraulic conductivity is 2.5 times smaller than that recalculated from the resistance of the model pipe system. (The constant proposed by Carman to be used inKoieny’s equation, i.e. 1/5, means similarly a multiple of 0.4 compared to the theoretical value calculated for straight tubes.) The difference can be caused by three possible factors (Fig. 1.2-24): (a) The cross section of the actual channels is not circular; (b) The channels in the network are longer than the length of the sample, and the tubes do not cross the cross section (which is directed at right angles to the main flow direction) perpendicularly; (c) The cross-sectional areas of the channels are not constant, but change continuously. The discharge of laminar flow through pipes having a non-circular cross section (triangle, ellipse, etc. Fig. 1.2-24b) was calculated (Forchheimer, 1924; Engelhardt, 1960), and compared with that in a circular pipe. This showed that the effect of the pipe shape can be expressed by a multiplying factor from 0.8 to 1.2, and thus, the’difference in question cannot be explained by this cause.
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clestio sediments
91
Fig. 1.2-24. Physical model to substitute the system of irregular channels composed of pores between grains
The two phenomena summarized as the second possible cause are generally included in one term, i.e. tortuosity. As explained by Bear (1972), this effect can be correlated to the ratio of the average length of the channels (1') t o the length of the sample in the flow direction ( I ) , but this relationship is not linear, as supposed by several authors. The linear relationship considers only the difference in length, but the change in the area free for water transport has to be taken into account as well, and this influence may also be related t o the ratio of lengths. Thus, i t can be assumed that the parameter of toris proportional or equal t o the square of the ratio of the length tuosity (T) of the sample to the average length of the channels (Fig. 1.2-24c): (1.2-21)
Many authors have proposed numerical values for considering tortuosity. Thus Irmay's parameter (Bear et al., 1968) i.e. 0.4 as a multiplying factor, eliminated the difference mentioned earlier (hydraulic conductivity of the actual sample is 2.5 times smaller than that of a bundle of straight capillary tubes). The tortuosity can also be investigated theoretically, if the average length of the water conveying channels can be determined. Bear haa pointed out that two different averages can be obtained depending on the aspects used as the basis of the calculation. If only the pore geometry were considered, it could be assumed that the average angle between the flow direc-
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
92
tion and the axes of the channels was n/4.These hypotheses result in a parameter, T = 0.5. It is necessary, however, to investigate the kinematic differences between the various directions, a requirement which needs the determination of the mean velocities of the channels as well (weighing the channels according to the mean velocities in them). It is evident that channel velocity is higher in tubes parallel to the flow direction than in those directed at different angles, and therefore, the average position of the tubes considering kinematic aspects forms a smaller angle with the flow direction than the geometricaverage. As alreadymentioned, even inactive channels may be expected, and hence, the overall result can be characterized by a considerably higher tortuosity factor than 0.5. Considering the T = 0.5 value with the influence of the non-circular tubes, these two effects could explain the observed difference. Because of the kinematic character of the channels, the numerical results, however, can probably cover only half the expected value and therefore, a third cause has also to be considered. It would be possible to take into account all three effects separately, and finally to summarize the numerical parameters. Effort is made, however, to apply only a very simple model and to base the total explanation of experimental observations, as well as the determination of the numerical factors, on the basis of this model. It is considered, therefore, that the best method of eliminating the difference mentioned previously, is the use of model pipes constructed from short stretches of various diameters (Fig. 1.2-24d). The tubes are parallel to the main flow direction (the ratio of the inactive channels perpendicular to this direction, may be considered by decreasing total porosity by a factor smaller than unity). The tubes are located so that the area free for water transport is constant. This model is suitable not only for the verification of the difference mentioned, characteristic of laminar movement, but the numerical comparison indicates also good agreement between measured and calculated data in the case of non-laminar flow conditions. According to Lindquist’s investigation, the ratio of the largest to the narrowest cross-sectional area of the channels in a homodisperse sample of spheres can be afj high as 10. This value is however, a very extreme one, which is valid only at a few points in the channel. To determine a model pipe having two different stretches (with a diameter of d , and d,, respectively), the average ratio of the area of large to narrow sections in the channel should be investigated. A pipe was chosen as a final model (Fig. 1.2-24d), the volume of which is the same, as that of the pipe with a constant d,, diameter, but constructed from short stretches of d , and d , diameters (d, < d o < d,) in such a way that half the length has the smaller and the other half, the larger diameter. The @scharge of this pipe was calculated and plotted against the ratio of the two cross-sectional a r e a (dg/dI) (Fig. 1.2-25). Similar graphs were determined not only for circular pipes but for other shapes as well. It is shown by the result of this investigation that the discharge becomes equal to that of the pipe with a constant diameter multiplied by 0.4 (i.e. the actual discharge of the original seepage according to the experiments represented in the figure), when the ratio of the two areaa is 113 1/3.5. On the basis of the foregoing, the following equations
-
1.2 Physical and mineralogical parameters of clastic sediments
93
Fig. 1.2-26. The flow rate of a pipelcomposed of two types of short stretches with different diameters, as a function of the ratio of the areas of the two different cross sections
can be given to calculate the characteristic diameters of the pipe: d, = 1.86 d,;
d d, = 2 ; d, = 1.25 d o ; 1.5
(1.2-22)
while the length of each stretch can be approximated, taking into consideration the actual character of the channels, by the following formula
I , = (1
-
1.5) d o .
(1.2-23)
The accuracy of the proposed ratio of the cross-sectional areas can be checked by other measurements as well. The air bubbling pressure method is the usual test to determine the capillary behaviour of samples. For this investigation, the pressure required to push the air bubbles through a thin saturated layer of the sample is measured. Stakman has found that this 20 pressure is constant when the thickness of the layer is greater than 15 mm. Below this limit, the necessary pressure decreases with decreasing thickness. He has assumed, that the constant value of the required pressure is proportional to the narrowest cross section of the capillary pores, while the pressure necessary to push the air bubbles through a layer of 1 mm thickness has the same correlation with the largest pores. According t o his 1 : 3.5, similar numerous memurements, the ratio of the two areas is 1 : 3
-
-
94
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
t o the results of the hydraulic deduction, and the scattering of the data points is insignificant. On the basis of Stakman’s measurements, the average pipe diameter could be recalculated as well, and his results are in good agreement with the parameter calculated from Eqs (1.2-19) and (1.2-22) (Fig. 1.2-26).
210(50/057550-
300 210 I50 105 75
/6- 50
-3 -%
-k --&9r
---8
D
b equivalent pare diameter
[p 1
Fig. 1.2-26. Relationship between pore size and grain diameter (after Stakman, 1966)
Although this model was developed, and has served the purpose of describing the flow of water through pores, d, and d, were found to be numerically equal to the actual smallest and largest ,pore diameters, determined by Stakman with air bubbling experiments. Thus, the diameters calculated in this way can also be used a,s parameters, characterizingthe expected actual size of pores in a given sample, when studying the movement of fine grains or the capillary rise in the pores. References to Chapter 1.2 ~LLBEET, J. (1967): The Materials of Brick and their Use in Rough Ceramics (in Hungarian). Mffizaki Konyvkiadb, Budapest. A L B E R ~ O N , M. L. (1962): Effect of Shape on the Fall Velocity of Gravel Particles. 5th Hydraulic Conference, Iowa, 1952.
References
95
ANDEREASEN, A. H. M. (1960): Adhesive Forces between Grains within their Pores in Clastic Sediments (in German). Kolloid-Zei$ung. h a m , L. (1966): The Determination of Clay Com onent of Soil by Infrared Spectrophotogrammetry (in French). Sympoeium on fiater i n Unaaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. BAVER,L. D. (1948): Soil Physics. John Wiley, London, New York. BEAR,J. (1972): Dynamics of Fluids in Porous Media. Elsevier, New York, London, Amsterdam. BEAR,J. and BACHMAT, Y. (1967): A Generalized Theory on Hydrod namic Dispersion in Porous Media. I A S H Sympoeium on Artifical Recharge and &anageme& o f Aquifere, Haifa, 1967. BEAR, J., ZASLAVSKY,D. and IRMAY, S. (1968): Physical Prhciples of Water Permlation and Seepage. UNESCO, Paris. BIDLO,G., KLEB,B. and TBROK,M. (1967): Analysis of Aggregatee of Concrete of Hydraulic Structures (in Hungarian). ZpitSanyag, No. 11. BOCKJCR, T. (1973): Theoretical Model for Karetic Rocks. Karezt- b Barlangkutatci.8, Budapest. Vol. VII. C a w , P. C. (1966): Flow of Gases through Porous Media. Butterworth, London. P. (1964): Standardization of k-value Determination by FieldTests CEWRDABELLIL~, through Standardizing the Grain-size Distribution Curve of Water-bearing Clastic Sediments (in German). Mitteilurrg InatitUte8 f i r WmeerWirtechoft, No. 20. Chum, J. (1967): The Influence of Soil Mineralogical Composition on Cement Stabilization. Ueotechnique, 2. DARAB, K., RBDLIN~, and R E ~ N Y I N I(1967): ~ Development of Methods for Determination of Clay Minerals (in Hungarian). (Manuscript).MTA Talajtani 6s Agrokemiai IntAzet, Budapest. DE WIESTJ. M. (1969): Flow through Porous Media. Academic Press, New York, London. DOLOOV, S. I. (1948): Studies Related to the Determination of Soil Moisture and its Availability for Plants (in Russian). Izd. A d . Nauk SSSR, MOSCOW,Leningrad. DONAT,J. (1929): Study on the Permeability of Sands (in German). Waeeerkraft ~ n d w a S 8 d & C h a f t , No. 17. DUMBLETON, M. J. and WEST, G. (1966): Some factors Affecting the Relation between the Clay Minerals in Soils and their Plasticity. Clay Minerale, No. 3. ELRICK,D. E. (1966): The Mineralogic Characterization of Soils. Sympoeium on Water i n the Unaaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. EMERY,K. 0. and RITTENBERO, S. C. (1962): Early Diagenesis of California Basin Sediments in Relation to Origin of Oil. Bulletin of American Aseociation for PetrolGeology. ENOELHILBDT, W. (1960): Porosity of Sediments (in German). Springer, Berlin, Gottingen, Heidelberg. FEKETE, Z. (1960): Comparative Analysis of Parameters Describing the Water Content of Soils (in Hungarian). HidroMgiai Kodiiny, No. 7-8. FOROHHEIMER, PH.(1924): Hydraulics (in German). Teubner, Leipzig, Berlin. FRASER, H. J. (1935): Experimental Study of the Porosity and Permeability of Clastic Sediments. J o u m l of Ueology. FUCHTBAUER, H. and REINECK, H. (1968): Edoggze geologiae. Helv., (in German). GOLDSTEIN,S. (1938): Modern Developments in Fluid Dynamics. Oxford University Press, Vol. 11. London. HAOERB~AN, T. H. (1938): About the Relation between the Distribution Field of the Relative Width of the Particles and the Genesis of the Sediment. UeologdskaForeningens F o r h a d . , No. 3. HAMILTON, E. L. and MENARD,H. W. (1966): Density and Porosity of Sea Floor Surface Sediments of San Diego, California. B d e t i n of A m e r k n Aeeociation for Petrol -Ueology HAZEN,A. (1896): The Filtration of Public Water Supplies. New York. HERCZOO, H., Kovdcs, G., NAOY,L., PAPR~LVI, F. and C)LL&, G. (1966): Applied Soil Mechanics in Hydraulic Engineering (in Hungarian). M6rnoki TovtibbkBpz6 I n 6 zet, Budapest.
.
96
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
HEYWOOD, H. (1938): Measurement of the Fineness of Powdered Materials. Proceedinga of Instdute of Mechanical Engineers. IVICSICS, L. (1967): Hydraulic Design of Sedimentary Basins and Determination of Velocity of Sedimentation (in Hungarian). ViziiglJi Kodemknyek, 3. J ~ YJ., (1944): Soil Mechanics (in Hungarian). Egyetemi Nyomda, Budapest. J T J H ~ Z , J. (1966): Available Deep Ground Water (in Hungarian). Doctoral Thesis (Manuscript). Budapest. J u ~ h z , - J(1967): . Hydrogeology (in Hungarian). Tankonyvkiadb, Budapest. BZDI, A. (1972): Soil Mechanics (4th edition in Hungarian). Tankonyvkiad6, Budapest. KINQ,F. H. (1899): A Study on Porosity and Grain Relationship in Experimental Sands. U . S. Geological Survey. KLEB,B. (1968): Geological Investigation of Pliocene Formations Southwards from Mecsek Mountains (in Hungarian). Foldtani K o d h y , No. 2. KOVACS,G. (1966): Hydraulics (in Hungarian). VITUKI, Budapest, Vol. 3. KovAas, G. (19688): Characterization of Shape of Grains in Seepage Hydraulics (in Hungarian). g p i t h - 6s Kozlekedkatudomanyi Kozlemknyek. No. 1-2. KovAcs, G. (196813): Characterization of the Molecular Forces Influencing Seepage with the Help of the p P Curve. Agrokkmia ks Talajtan, (Supplementum). KovAcs, G. (1971): Relationship of Plasticityand Clay content of Soils (in Hungarian). Agrokkmia ks Talajtan, No. 1-2. K O ~ N YJ. , (1953): Hydraulics (in German). Springer, Wien. KREYBIQ, L. (1951): Heat and Water Balance of Soils (in Hungarian). Budapest. K R I V ~P., (1957): Geological Evaluation of Hagerman's Grainshape Method (in Hungarian). Poldtani Kodony, No. 3. KUHN,A. (1963): HBndbook of Colloid Chemistry (in Hungarian, translated from German) MGszaki Konyvkiad6, Budapest. KURON,H. (1932): Zeitschrift fiir PfleJlzen (in German). Berlin. Vol. 24A. LEBEDIEV.A. F. f19631: Soil Moisture and Ground Water (inRussian). I d . Akad. Nauk SSSR; Moscow. LINDOUIST. E. 11933): On the Flow of Water through ., Porous Soil. 1st C w r e a 8 of ICOLD,- Stockholm, 1933. Lo, K. Y. (1961): Secondary Composition of Clays. Proceedings of ASCE, SM. 6. LOUIS,C. (1970): Three-dimensional Flow in Fractured Rocks (in French). Comitk FranprLis de Mkcunique des R o c k , Paris. MADOS,L. (1939): Studies Related to Irrigation and Water Management in the Area of the Irrigation Scheme of Tiszafured (in Hungarian). dntozhi Kodemdnyek. MADOS,L. (1941): Application of Soil Science in Connection with Drainage (in Hungarian). dntozksi Kodemdnyek. MELENTEV. V. A. f19601: Hvdraulic Dams from Gravels and Sands (in Russian). Gostekhizdat; Moscow. MIHALTZ.J. and UNQAR.T. 119541: SeDaration of Alluvial and Wind-borne Sands (in Hungkian). Foldtani Kodony, No. 1-2. MIJATOVI~, B. F. (1970): Hydraulic Mechanism of Karst Aquifers in Deep L e g Coastal Collectors. Bulletin of Institute fw Geological and Geophyeical Reaeurch, Beograd, Series B. No. 7. MITSCHERLICH,E. A. (1932): Soil Science for Agriculture and Forestry (in German). Berlin. PALADIN, J. A. (1964): Determination of Permeability of Grained Non-cohesive Soils (in Russian). Gkhotechnkheskoye Strodektvo, 3. R ~ T ~ TL.I (1971): , Correlation Associated with Liquid and Plastic Limits of soils. Proceeding8 of 4th Conference of SMFE, AkadBmiai Kiad6, Budapest. RODIE,A. A. (1962): Soil Moisture (in Russian). Izd. Acad. Nauk SSSR, MOBCOW. ROSE, D. A. (1966): Water Transport in Soils by Evaporation and W t r a t i o n . Symposium on Water in the Ulzllaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. SCHEIDEQQER, A. E. (1963):Theoretical Models of Porous Matter. Producere Monthly, No. 10, 17. SCHEIDEQQER, A. E. (1960): The Physics of Flow Through Porous Media. Univereity of Toronto Press, Toronto. SCHLICHTER, C. S. (1899): Annual Report of the US. Geological Survey. I
"
References
97
SCHAUCRTMANN (1962): Comparison of One and Two-specium CFS Tests. Proceedings of ASCE, SM. 4. SEED H. B., WOODWABD R. J. and LTJNQEN R. (1964): Clay-Mineralogical Aspecte of the Atterberg's Limits. Proceeding8 of ASCE, SM. 4. SINE,L. and BENTZ,A. (1966): Differences between Experimental and Theoretical Values of Capillary Diffusivity (in French). Symposium on Water i n the Unaaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. STAKMAN,W. P. (19668): The Reletion between Partiole Size, Pore Size and Hydraulic Conductivity of Sand Separate. Symposium on Water in t k Umaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. STAKMAN,W. P. (196613): Determination of Pore Size by the Air Bubbling Pressure Method. Symposium on Water i n the Unaa4urated Zone, Wagdngen, 1966. STELCZER, K. (1967): Abrasion of Bed-load Material (in Hungarian). VCzQigyi KWemknyek. No. 2. SZADECZKY-KARDO~~, E. (1933): Determination of the Coefficient of Roundness (in German). Centralblatt fiir Minerdogie. SZILVBQYI,Z. (1966): Experiments to Characterize the Rheological Behaviour of Clays (in Hungarian). F&&aniKukz&, No. 4. S Z I L V ~ YI. I , (1967): T h e Stability Problems of Clayey Valley Slopes in North Hungary. 9th Congrese of ICOLD,Iatambul, 1967. TERZAQHI, K. (1943): Theoretical Soil Mechanics. John Wiley, New York. THOMPSON (1966): Lime Reaotivity of Illinois So&. Proceedings of ASCE, SM. 6. VAaHAm, G. (19668): General Verification of Deroy's Law and Determinetionof Capillary Conductivity (in French). Symposium on Water i n the Unaaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. VAamuD, G. (1966b): Study on Soil-moisture Distribution after stopping Horizontal Infiltration (in French). Symposium on Water i n the Unaaturated Zone,Wapningen, 1966. V ~ R W Y A IG. , (1942): Experiences on Irrigation at Mkrialiget (in Hungarian). ~ntozksiiyyiKozlemdnyek, No. 2. WARD, J. (1964): Turbulent Flow in Porous Media. Journal of ASCE, HY. 6 . WENTWORTH, CH. (1922): A Scale of Grade and Clam Terms for Clastic Sediments. Journal of Geology. WESSELTNG, J. and WIT, K. (1966): An Infiltration Method for the Determination of the Capillary Conductivity of Undisturbed Soil Cores. Symposium on Water in the Unsaturated Zone, Wageningen, 196% ' WESTMANN, A. E. R. and HIJQIZL,H. R. (1930): The Packing of Particles. Journal of American Qeran-Society. WILLIAXS,N. M. (1966): A Method of Indicating Pebble Shape with one Parameter. Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, No. 4. WIND. G. P. 11966): CaDillftrv Conductivitv D a t a E s t h t e d bv a Simple Method. Symposium on lVa8er'in th> U&durdtd Zone; Wagencngen, 1966. " WYLLIE,M. R. J. and SPANQLER, M. B. (1962): Applioetion of Eleotrical Resistivity Measurements to Problem of Fluid Flow in Porous Media. Bulletin of American Assock~iwnfor Petrol-Chlogy, No. 36. WYLLIE,M. R. J. and GARDNER, G. H. F. (1968): The generalized Kofeny-Carman Equation. World Oil Prod. Sect., 11, No. 4. ZINQQ,TH. (1936): Characterization of Claatio Sediments According to Grain-size Distribution (in German). Schweizcrkche Mineralogkche und Petrographkchc Mdteilungen, No. 36. ZUNKER, F. (1930): Behaviour of Soils Related to Water (in German). Springer, Handbook of Soil Science, Berlin. Vol. VI.
7
98
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Chapter 1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture above the water table The investigation of hydrological processes occurring in the soil above the water table concerns a boundary field of surface-water hydrology, groundwater hydrology (hydrogeology) and pedology boil science and agronomy). This series of related sciences has t o be supplemented by seepage hydraulics, which investigates the flow of water through the very complex system of the unsaturated soil. Knowledge of the dynamic characteristics of water movement provides a firm baais for the study of the other sciences, as all the phenomena have to be analyzed as a continuous process, and hence, seepage hydraulics plays an important auxiliary part in any kind of investigation of the top soil. Although the thickness of the soil-moisture zone is relatively negligible when compared to 'the entire thickness of the crust of earth, its hydrological importance is extremely high. The amount of water stored in this zone is easily accessible, and the water-conveying ability of this layer influences the ratio of actual and potential evapotranspiration (the latter is a function of climatic and surface conditions only). Surface run-o# and infiltration depend on the actual condition of the soil-moisture zone (on its storage capacity and permeability influenced by the moisture content of the soil at any instant). Thus, the behaviour of this zone af€ects the water regime of both surface and ground water. Apart from the hydrological role mentioned in the previous paragraph, the investigation of the zone of soil moisture also provides valuable information on the study of seepage hydraulics. Hence, there is the potisibility of recalculating hydraulic parameters from observed moisture content and its change. Thus, knowing the dynamic equilibrium of the vertical distribution of the soil moisture, it is possible to determine the forces of attraction between the grains and water aa well as the negative capillary pressure and, from this value, the probable pore distribution. The process of soil-moisture redistribution after a rapid change in moisture content (e.g. infiltration of precipitation) can be used in the determination of soil permeability. Owing to the close relationship between parameters characterizing the soil-moisture zone, and those influencing flow through the unsaturated medium, the hydrological investigation of this zone will be dealt with in detail in this chapter. From this very large field, those phenomena, which assist in the understanding of the hydraulic processes above the water table will be analyzed first. The reader is referred to a recently published glossary (IASH, 1974) for the interpretation of other basic terms.
99
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
1.3.1 General characterization of soil moisture and processes acting in the soil-moisture zone To simplify further explanations, the various processes influencing water movement through and acting i n the unsaturated zone are grouped and claasified. For this grouping the model sketched in Fig. 1.3-1 can be used. This model includes not only the unsaturated zone, but also the plant zone overlying it. I n addition, part of the gravitational ground-water space, which is the lower boundary of the zone of aeration is included. The path of the
.Sa
F
Fig. 1.3-1. Model for representing hydrological processes in the soil-moisture zone 7*
100
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
water moving in, or through the unsaturated zone can easily be followed in the sketch. Regarding the model as a closed system, the amount of water moving through the boundaries of the separate columns is the input and output of the system. These effects, which can be regarded as the boundary conditions of the model, are indicated by mrows in the figure. The volume under investigation is divided into three main subsystems: i.e. m e occupied by air, soil-moisture zone and ground-water zone. Two further subsystems may also be distinguished, i.e. the soil surface and the active root zone, the latter being part of the soil-moisture zone. (The soil surface has a special role in the system, being the boundary between the atmospheric and soil-moisture zones, although roots do cross it. At the same time, part of the precipitation reaching the surface is returned t o the atmospheric zone by evaporation, and surface run-off represents special input or output amounts. For this reason, the surface has to be regarded aa an independent subsystem. The separation of the root zone as a H t h subsystem is justified, because its structure differs from that of the remaining part of the soil-moisture zone.) Apart from input and output, a system is characterized by the operation within the system itself. The storage within the zones of plants and soil moisture as well as the fluctuation of the water table (which represents the storage in the ground-water zone) are indicated in the figure as internal operations. Some characteristic values governing the operation of the system are also represented (i.e. soil-moisture retention curve, actual moisture distribution, etc.). The column investigated is in contact with the atmosphere at its upper boundary. The input through this surface is precipitation (either liquid or solid), while the output is considered under the term of actual evapotranspiration. Along the vertical faces, the model is bordered by the same zones, which are also included in the volume under investigation: i.e. atmospheric zone, the lower part of which is the vegetation zone above the surface, soilmoisture zone between the surface and the water table, and finally, the gravitational ground-water space below the water table. The lower horizontal boundary of the column is similar t o the lower part of the vertical face, and is in contact with the ground-water zone. By separating the model from its surroundings a discontinuity is created along the boundaries, which has to be replaced by the inputs and outputs acting on and originating from the system. Such replacement factors are as follows: (a) Horizontal vapour movement in the atmospheric zone; (b) Horizontal moisture movement in the soil-moisture zone; (c) Surface run-off (d) Ground-water flow.
Further groups of processes can be distinguished according to the subsystems mentioned previously. Storage of water in the vegetal zone and its evaporation may be included in the investigation of interception. The
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
101
storage on and the direct evaporation from the surface is closely related to the former group, although these processes belong to the next subsystem (i.e. to the surface itself). This is characterized by surface run-off as an input (inflow from the surface to the investigated space) and also as the output of this subsystem (outflow on the surface). Water exchange between the atmospheric and soil-moisture zones is the result of infiltration through the surface, as well as evaporation and transpiration from soil moisture. The two depleting processes mentioned (i.e. evaporation and transpiration from the soil moisture) are only part of the actual evapotranspiration, because the latter includes the direct evaporation from the surface of both plants and the earth. The next subsystem is the soil-moisture zone, where the storage process is governed by direct evaporation from soil moisture, transpiration of plants from the root zone, and the water retaining capacity of the unsaturated soil, which can be characterized by the soil-moisture retention capacity compared to the actual moisture content of the layer. As already mentioned, the structure of the top layer (root zone, or cultivated zone) has to be dealt with separately because its structure differs basically from that of the remaining part of the soil-moisture zone. Thus, the soil-moisture retention curve cannot be applied here, viz. the secondary porosity created by the large channels produced by roots and ploughing maintains the atmospheric pressure in deeper levels aa well. The h a 1 group of phenomena creating a link between the subsystems is the water exchange between ground water and soil moisture (accretion). Vertical recharge and drainage of ground water are the components of this group, and their results may be indicated by the change in the amount of stored ground water indicated by the fluctuation of the water table. Surveying these processes, those most closely related to the hydrological investigation of the unsaturated zone are: (a) Infiltration through the surface; (b) Evapotranspiration from soil moisture; (c) Storage in the unsaturated layer; (d) Water exchange between soil moisture and ground water.
After giving a general picture of the whole model and surveying the processes acting in the soil-moisture zone, a more detailed analysis of the various forms of soil moisture is given and further subzones between the cultivated zone and the water table are distinguished. This classification can be based either on consideration of the forces in action, or on the rate of saturation of the pores. Because the dynamics of soil moisture and the saturation of the soil axe closely related to each other, the two aspects result in the same subdivision of the soil-moisture zone. Near the surface the water is kept in an elevated position, against gravity, by adhesion, which develops between the solid matrix and the water molecules at the surfaces of contact between the solid and liquid phases (Fig. 1.3-2). In loose clastic sediments this force creates a film of water around the grains, which may be divided into t w o parts. The inner layer is the adsorbed film, the tension of which is so high that the suction of the roots is not able
102
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Fig. 1.3-2. Various forms of soil moisture above the water table
to draw off the water molecules from the grain surface. The adhesive force decreases with increaing distance from the surfaces of contact and, therefore, the upper layer of the film is bound to the grain by a lesser force. At the point of contact of two neighbouring grains - or, more precisely, of their water films - the effects of the adhesive forces are superimposed and a thicker water film is formed. This is the pellicular water or intergrenular water film. I n the interstices the surface tension of the water increases the amount of stored water, but this influence (capillarity) becomes dominant only near the water table. The upper part of the soil-moisture zone is the zone of adhesion, because adhesion is the dominating force acting against gravity as explained in the previous paragraph. Another common condition prevailing in this zone is that soil moisture occurs only in the form of films of water, and in dynamic equilibrium, few pores are completely filled with water. Considering the aspect of saturation this domain is therefore called the unsaturated zone.
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
103
Moving further downwards, the pores are under the influence of different forces and from the point of view of saturation their condition may be regarded as a transition form between the saturated and unsaturated state (transition zone). Some of the pores are completely filled with water, and in others water films develop under the influence of adhesion, similar to those in the unsaturated zone. This change in the character of saturation is caused by the fact t h a t in this zone the other molecular force also becomes dominant: i.e. capillarity (the more detailed dynamic interpretation of both adhesion and Capillarity will be given in Chapter 2.1).The effect of capillarity is proportional to the elevation of the point of investigation above the water table. The transition zone (capillary zone) can be divided, therefore, into two parts. Its upper part is known as the open capillary zone, where only the narrow pores are completely filled with capillary water, while in the other pores only the walls are covered by adhesive water. The upper boundary of this zone (which also divides the adhesive from the capillary zone) is the maximum capillary height (see Section 1.3.4).Below this zone and above the water table lies the closed capillary zone, where all the pores (or almost all) are completely filled with water by capillarity. The thickness of this zone is equal to the capillary height belonging to the diameter of the largest pores. The method of determining this minimum capillary height will be explained in Section 1.3.4. The lower boundary of the capillary zone is the water table, below which the pores are completely filled with water (zone of saturation). As already mentioned, the pressure of water is higher here than that of the atmosphere. Capillarity does not act in this zone because its existence is closely related to the boundary of the liquid and gaseous phases. The influence of adhesion hinders the flow only in the close vicinity of the walls of the solid matrix, whilst inside the pores water can easily be mobilized by gravity (or, more precisely, by its gradient). For this reason this part of the model may be called a gravitational ground-water zone as well. Both the dynamic characterization of soil moisture and the zoning of the layer lying between the soil surface and the water table is based on the supposition of a dynamic equilibrium. External influences can however, disturb this balanced condition, causing temporary changes in the soil-moisture conditions. Infiltration of water (precipitation, irrigation) can completely f2.l the pores near the surface and in this cme capillarity also acts in the unsaturated zone (pending capillary zone). As a result of evapotranspiration, the amount of soil moisture may be less than that belonging to the dynamically balanced state. In both cases there exists a vertical gradient of the total energy (Buckingham’s potential), the latter being composed of the gravitational (potential) energy and the difference in tension of the neighbouring points of the surface of the water film (Buckingham, 1907; Richards, 1931; De Wiest, 1969).The gradient creates a flow causing the redistribution of soil moisture which results in the development of the dynamic equilibrium described above (Fig. 1.3-3). Naturally, the balanced state can only be achieved if there is no new external action which may disturb the equilibrium of the internal forces. Buckingham’s potential is always related to the position of the water table. It is natural, therefore, that the change in depth of
104
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
percent of volume 1- 5 distribution of moisture content with depth at varlous tirn~,mflAFig. 1.3-3. Change in the vertical distribution of soil moisture in time (soil-moisture redistribution)
the water table has to be regarded as an external influence similar to infiltration or evapotranspiration, and also followed by the redistribution of soil moisture.
1.3.2 Parameters characterizing the various moisture contents of soil samples As mentioned before, the pores of loose claatic sediments are filled with water either completely (saturated system) or partially (unsaturated system). It is necessary, therefore, t o define numerical parameters for the quantitative characterization of the amount of stored water and for the rate of saturation of the layer. The amount of water stored in a unit volume of the sample is called the specific water or moisture content. According to its definition, water content is the weight or volume of water related to the weight of the dried sample or its total volume. To standardize the measurement, the sample should be kept at a temperature of 105OC, until no alteration in its weight can be observed. The water content expressed atj the ratio of weights can be calculated from the following equation: W =
Rv
-Go. Y
QO
(1.3-1)
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
105
where Q, is the wet weight of the sample in its original condition and Qo is the weight of the same sample after drying. To calculate the water content as a percentage of the volume, the specific weight of the dry sample must be known:
W=
Q, - Qo Yw
.. c, - Qw Yo
-00
Yo =w Yo ;
(1.3-2)
QO
where yw is the specific weight of water, which is unity, and y o = ys (1 - n ) , if the specific weight of the solid grains is indicated by ys. This method of measurement requires a sample from the layer, which disturbs the upper layer and excludes repetition at the same point of both single measurement and the continuous observation of the change in soil moisture. Equipment can be obtained which measures soil moisture, thus eliminating these disadvantages. The various types of equipment are based on electrical resistivity or capacity (e.g. gypsum block); on the direct measurement of the properties of soil moisture using the absorption of radioactive rays by hydrogen atoms or by the maas of grains and water (neutron or gamma probes); and on the me of infra-red photographs. None of them can be regarded aa a fbal solution for the following reasons. Electrical measurements are disturbed by the change in temperature and chemical composition of water. The operation of tensiometers is hindered by various uncertain phenomena. Neutron probes measure hydrogen ions and hence the results are influenced by the organic content of soil, especially in the root zone. Gamma rays measure the total mass, and hence their sensitivity is relatively low, and the correct quantitative evaluation of airborne infra-red photographs has not yet been completely solved. It can be stated, however, that these methods indicate very important developments in the continuous observation of soil moisture and also in the general characterization of large areas. Discussion on the methods of measurement of soil moisture would, however, digress from the original topic-the hydrological investigation of the water retention capacity of the soil. It is necessary, therefore, to continue the discussion of the physical interpretation of water content. The water content determined by the method explained in Eqs (1.3-1) and (1.3-2) represents the amount of water present in the sample at the time of the investigation. This value cannot be regarded, therefore, as a physical parameter of soil. It only gives information on the instantaneous condition of the sample. When determining the water content related to a given condition of the sample, this value becomes a parameter suitable for the classification of soils. Examples of such parameters are found in the various values of moisture content used to characterize the cohesive samples in soil physics such as the liquid limit (w,; or W,) and the limit of plasticity ( w p ;or W p ) ,or the index of plasticity, which is the difference between the two former values expressed BB the ratio of weights ( I p = wL - y p ) . Although these parameters belong to arbitrarily chosen con&tions (the liquid limit based on water content measured in Casagrande’s apparatus, in which a cut sample is made to close again by a series of small physical shocks, and the limit of plwticity, when a string of 3 mm diameter can be
106
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
rolled from the sample) they were proved to be useful by means of comparing various cohesive soils. The maximum molecular water capacity (w,,,, or Wmol)is also an arbitrary parameter (viz. the water content of a sample the measurement of which is achieved if the diameter of the sample is 50 mm, its thickness is 2 mm and it is loaded by a pressure of 6.55 N/mm2after the development of consolidation). This method of measurement, however, is only an approximation to standardize the parameter. According to the original concept, maximum molecular water capacity is the water content of a soil column remaining after drainage by gravity and, therefore, it characterizes a general physical property of the soil (see also Chapter 1.4, Lebediev, 1936). [It is necessary to note, that the symbols applied here to indicate the two different types of moisture content (i.e. the amount of water stored in the sample and expressed aa the ratio of weights, or that calculated as the volume of the stored water related to the total volume of the sample) are different from those generally used in the literature. It was felt that the similar character of both parameters has to be emphasized by being represented by the same letter. At the same time, the necessary distinction can be ensured by using small and capital letters, respectively. It was decided, therefore, that the symbol of gravimetric moisture wntent should be a small w , while the volumetric moisture wntent should be represented by a capital W.] The pores below the water table are completely saturated ( n = W ) . Above this surface (where 0 < W < n ) , the water content indi,cates the degree of saturation. Two samples having the same water content have differing rate of saturation when the porosity of one of them is high and that of the other is low. For this reason, the weflcient of saturation (or the rate of saturation) is also used to characterize the condition of the sample. This parameter is the quotient of the volumetric moisture content to porosity:
H'
s=-;
n
(1.3-3)
the value of which is unity in a saturated sample (9, = 1) while in a completely dry sample, it is zero. The total range of saturation lies, therefore, between zero and unity (0 < s < 1). The practical lower limit however, differs from the theoretical value, because a completely dry sample does not occur in Nature. If the minimum natural water content (the volumetric moisture content of a so-called air-dry sample) is W,, the possible range in variation of the coefficient of saturation is so < s < 1 , where the lower limit is so = Wo/n. One can e a d y argue that knowledge of the ratio of saturation still gives insufficient information as to the expected behaviour of the soil, as the change in saturation in a sand does not involve much modification, whilst in a clay soil considerable modification may occur. Measuring the water content for a given state of the sample facilitates the complete understanding of the effects of the actual or instantaneous moisture content of the soil. Knowing the specific values of water content of the soil, and comparing
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
107
them with the actual amount of soil moisture, the behaviour of the soil can be estimated. When selecting the specific parameters, the most important requirement is that the state they describe should be characteristic and easily repeatable. In thia respect, the parameter of plasticity used in soil physics is a useful value to determine, although it belongs to arbitrarily chosen states of the sample as already explained. At the same time, the index of consistency, which is the ratio of two differences (that between the liquid limit and instantaneous water content related to the difference of w L and w p ) : (1.34)
iu a good example of how to compare the actual water content to the selected limit values. Although the specific soil moisture values generally used as parameters in soil science belong to more natural conditions (describing the real physical character of the sample), than the physical parameters of soil, their determination causes some difficulties, because the conditions described are not known precisely enough. The parameters generally applied in soil science are as follows: (a) Field capacity (wre, or Wre)is the water content retained against gravity in the sample. Thus, the value is approximately equal to the difference between the total porosity and gravitational pores; (b) Wilting point (wwp,or W w p )is the amount of water which cannot be used or removed by the roots of plants; (c) Usable (disposable) water (wd, or W,) is the difference between the two parameters mentioned above.
Field capacity is a very important parameter, but it is influenced by numerous undetermined factors (e.g. temperature, relative humidity of the air, etc., among which the position of the point of investigation related t o the actual water table is perhaps the most important, aa will be demonstrated later on). This can hardly be reproduced, or physically interpreted. The same statement can refer to the wilting point as well, because the water, not freely available for the plants depends on the suction of the roots, which differs from plant to plant, and also changes according to the growth phase. The most stable and repeatable parameters among the specific moisture content values used in soil science are the various types of hygroscopic moisture content (or hygroscopicity), which meaaures the water content retained by the sample against the suction of sulphuric acid of different concentrations in a closed space at a given temperature. Thus, Mitscherlich’s hygroscopicity ( w H y , or W H Y )is determined with sulphuric acid of 10% concentration, while Kuron’s hygroscopicity (w,,, or Why)is measured with sulphuric acid of 50 % concentration (Mitscherlich, 1932; Kuron, 1932). Because of the high stability of these parameters (assuming that a constant temperature, 2OoC for example, is ensured for all the measurements), it is reasonable in future, to accept their general use and to regard the others
108
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
only aa rough approximations, which can be estimated aa the functions of hygroscopicity using linear relationships. According to Mados’ investigations, the characteristic values of moisture content mentioned previously can be approximated aa the functions of Kuron’s hygroscopic moisture content by the following equations (Mados, 1939; 1941):
+ 0e.12; w w p = 4why + 0.02; uyc= 4why
(1.3-5)
w, = wf: - wwp= 0.10.
According to these relationships, the usable water content is 10% of the weight, independent of the type of soil. Excluding very extreme cases (coarse sand and very cohesive clay) this average value can be accepted a~ a rough approximation. Similar relationships were determined between Mitscherlich’s hygroscopic moisture content and the various water contents used aa parameters in soil physics and soil science (JuhQsz, 1967): wg
= 0.54 WHY;
wWp= 1.44 WHY
+ 0.02; (1.3-6)
wp = 1.7 WHY
+ 0.065.
On the basis of Fekete’s (1950) measurements shown in Table 1.3-1, a further relationship can be established to connect Mitscherlich’s and Kuron’s hygroscopicities and to construct a transition between Mados’ and Juhbz’ equations w follows: why = 0.45 WHY.
(1.3-7)
Apart from his own observations and measurements, Juh&sz bwed the relationships given in Eq. (1.3-6) partly on previously published data in various papers (Dolgov, 1948; Fekete, 1950; Rodie, 1952; Kreybig, 1951; Lebediev, 1963) and also on formerly established relationships such ah( those published in papers by Procerov and Karasev (1939), Kreybig (1951), Vhrallyai (1942) regarding wilting point, and Kreybig (1951) on field capacity. Comparing Mados’ and JuhBsz’ equations their good accordance can be seen. Naturally, these linear relationships cannot substitute direct measurements. They give, however, very useful information on the contact between the parameters characterizing the various states or conditions of soils. Thus,
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
109
Table 1.3-1. Some data characterizing the relationship between the moisture content of air-dry samples and Kuron’s hygroscopicity (after Fekete, 1960)
Type of the sample
i
as percentage of weight
w.
Send
0.6
Fine sand
1.2 1.8 2.6
Rock flour (loess)
3.1 3.6
Silt
4.2 4.8 6.4
I
6.0
Heavy clay
6.6 7.8
why
0.6 1.0 1.6 2.0 2.6 3.0 3.6
4.0 4.6 6.0 6.6 6.6
it can be recognized that the limit of plasticity and maximum molecular moisture content are very similar parameters, and the liquid limit and field capacity are also almost identical characteristics.
1.3.3 Interpretation of field capacity, gravitational porosity and soil-moisture retention curve
As already mentioned, the water retention capacity of a soil prism depends on the position of the investigated sample. It is necessary to know, therefore,
whether the sample to be characterized is separated from its surroundings, or if the prism is situated as part of a continuous soil profile. I n the latter case, its elevation above the water table also influences the moisture retention capacity. The reliability of this statement can easily be understood. I n the case of a sample separated from its surroundings, the eflect of gravity i s expressed by the weight of water incorporated in the pores. If the soil prism (the water retention capacity of which is under investigation) is a part of a continuous soil profile, the sample id fitted into a space of gravitational potential, the datum (reference level) of which is the water table, where the surplus pressure is zero (the gravitational potential is zero at this level). Everywhere in this space, the effect of gravity should be expressed with reference to this datum. Thus, above the reference level, gravity m w e s suction proportional to the height of the investigated point above the water table. Physically this process can be explained by imagining that the continuous chain of water films composes a closed system, in which the pressure on a water particle (in this case, negative pressure, i.e. suction, because the particle is
110
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
above the water table with a zero pressure) is proportional to the weight of a straight water column between the particle and the reference level, and independent of the form of the container (the form of the chain composed of water films). For this reason, the point value of field capacity will be larger near the water table where the suction caused by gravity is smaller, than at a higher point of the profle, and the water retention capacity measured in a separated sample can be regarded as a meaningless parameter when investigating the field condition of a complete soil profile. There is another parameter generally used in the investigation of the Unsaturated zone, which becomes questionable if we accept the interpretation of field capacity given previously, and when determining the latter as a function of the elevation above the water table. This parameter is the free or gravitational porosity (generally indicated by the symbol no ).Its clavaical definition indicates that it is part of the total porosity, where, under the given conditions the water is not bound to the grains by adhesion or under the influence of capillarity, and therefore, moves freely. Consequently, it was previously proposed that gravitational porosity should be calculated as the difference between total porosity and field capacity, the latter expressed as the volumetric ratio. Accepting that field capacity is a function of the podtion of the investigated point, it has to be stated that the gravitational porosity can also be expressed only as a function of the elevation above the water table. In all types of soil profile, a line can be determined which divides the total porosity into two parts: one is field capacity and the other is gravitational porosity. It is evident that field capacity is relatively larger near the water table and its value decreases moving upwards in the profile, while gravitational porosity changes inversely. It is also obvious that the sum of the two parameters at a given elevation is equal to total porosity and is conxtant if porosity does not change in the profile (Fig. 1.3-4). There is a further condition which has also to be considered when determining the position of the line dividing the porosity of the soil profile into two parts. If the part covered by field capacity is filled with water and the remaining part is occupied by air, the soil moisture i n the profile is i n dynamic equilibrium. There is no water movement, except in the case where i t is induced by an external force (e.g. evaporation from or infiltration to the top soil, change in the position of water table, etc.). Dynamic equilibrium can develop only when the acting internal forces are balancing each other. Investigating the adhesive (unsaturated) zone the internal force8 are the tension ( p ) on the surface of water films, and gravity. Their balanced state can be expressed by equalizing the total hydraulic gradient ( I )to zero (both the horizontal and vertical components of the gradient should be equal to zero). Investigating the process in a horizontal plane, this condition requires that the vertical moisture distribution should be identical at each profile in a homogeneous medium, while in the vertical direction, the condition gives a relationship between tension and gravity:
+
I = d ( h Y ) - dy dx dx
dy d W dW dx
1 =---
1 =0 ;
(1.3-8)
111
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
1
n
__c
fotal porosity Fig. 1.3-4. Graphical representation of the vertical distribution of field capacity and gravitational porosity
considering that h = H - x and the tension divided by the specific weight of water gives the potential caused by suction (y, = p l y ) . The total (Buckingham's) potential ie achieved by adding the gravitational and suction-potential (Richards, 1931). From Eq. (1.3-8), field capacity (water content belonging to the state of dynamic equilibrium at different elevations in the profile) can be calculated as a function of the height of the investigated point above the water table ( k ) or that of the depth below the surface (2)if the relationship between tension and moisture content ie known. The equation (1.3-9)
W j , = f ( h )= f ( H - 2)
describes the position of the dividing line above the lower boundary of the unsaturated zone. This relationship is valid, where h h,, max. Among the symbols h, max is the capillary rise and W j , indicates the field capacity in the unsaturated zone (in the closed and open capillary zones, this parameter will be indicated by the symbols W{ and W$ respectively, see Fig.
>
1.34).
-
The conditions in the transition zone differ from those in the unsaturated zone, because gravity is here balanced by two forces (adhesion end capillarity). As already mentioned, the closed capillary zone is al.most completely
112
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
saturated, because capillarity causes the water to rise in all the pores to the top of this zone. The vertical distribution of field capacity in homogeneous media (having constant porosity) can be characterized, therefore, by a constant value equal to porosity
W;,= n = const.,
(1.3-10)
instead of the solution found in Eq. (1.3-9). The assumption of the equality of field capacity and porosity is valid theoretically only if h = 0, but it is is the miniacceptable aa a good approximation if h < h, &, where h, mum capillary rise belonging to the diameter of the largest pores. The dynamics of the movement also differs from that in the zone of adhesion. The balanced condition cannot be described by Eq. (1.3-8). I n a capillary tube having a capillary rise h, (which is inversely proportional to the diameter d of the tube) and filled with water to a level h above the water table, the gradient is proportional to the difference between the gravitational and capillary forces expressed by the height of the water columns: (1.3-1 1)
where p is the pressure created by the weight of the water column having a height h, and p , is the capillary suction (the capillary pressure is regarded here as constant, although its value may change as the meniscus is raised or lowered as will be explained in Section 2.1). The same relationship can be accepted for the characterization of the closed capillary zone, because the influences of adhesion compared to that of capillarity can be neglected. If the gradient expressed in Eq. (1.3-1 1) is zero, the system is in a state of equilibrium, while if it is positive (the effect of gravity surpasses the capillary force), the draining of the tube to the gravitational ground-water space starts at its lower end and the water level in the tube sinks immediately until reaching the balanced conditions. Similarly, in the case of negative gradient, the water rises in the tube are recharged from the gravitational ground water. some of the pores are Within the open capillary zone (h, m,n < h h, under the influence of capillarity (e.g. those pores at an elevation which are smaller than the diameter of a capillary tube having a capillary rise, h ) . In this fraction of pores, the water content is equal t o the total volume of these pores, and the dynamics of flow is characterized by Eq. (1.3-11). In larger pores, water fllms can develop around the grains under the influence of adhesion, and both the vertical distribution of moisture content and the balanced condition can be described in a manner similar to that in the unsaturated zone [Eqs (1.3-8) and (1.3-9)]. The ratio (R)of capillary fllled pores (V,) related to the total volume of pores ( V p ) can be determined as a function of the elevation above the water table ( h ) .The same ratio can be achieved by using porosity instead of the volumetric values of pores, since porosity is the specific value of pore volume related to the total volume of the sample. Thus the ratio R of capillary filled pores can be calculated
< A,),
113
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
as the quotient of capillary porosity (n,) and total porosity ( n ) :
where
R and
N
0
R
at the level N
h = h, max ;
1 if h = h, ,,,
.
(1.3-12)
Hence, the vertical distribution of moisture content in the open capillary zone can be determined by combining Eqs (1.3-9),(1.3-10) and (1.3-12)(see Fig. 1.3-23);
W;: = R(h) W;c+ [l
- R(h)]Wj,= n,(h)
+ [l-
-]Ah) n (h) n
if
;
(1.3-13)
hc min
< h < hc max.
The interpretation of capillary porosity used in Eq. (1.3-12)can be given as follows. At an elevation h, the total pore volume (V,,.)can be divided into and those remmming under the sole two parts: capillary filled pores (7,) influence of adhesion (Va).Any partial value divided by the total volume of the sample (V,)gives a parameter similar to porosity. The first is called cupillury porosity (n,) and the second adhesive porosity (nu): v c -n,;
therefore
vt
Va-na ;
vt
n = n,
v, = vc+ v u ;
+ na.
(1.3-14)
As already mentioned, the water content does not yield sufficient information on the behaviour of the soil. It is necessary to compare these data to parameters belonging to special conditions in the sample. This restriction should be enlarged upon now, showing that the point measurements - even compared to such specific characteristics as hygroscopic moisture content, liquid limit, or limit of plasticity - are insufficient t o describe field conditions. The complete vertical distribution of moisture content has always to be determined in a profile and compared to soil-moisture distribution belonging to the dynamic equilibrium. Only the differences between the actual distribution and the matching curve shows where water is deficient or where excess water occurs in the profile. The only remaining problem is the numerical determination of the equations [Eqs (1.3-9),(1.3-10) or (1.3-13) which gives the superposition of the other two]. These describe the position of the line dividing the field capacity and gravitational porosity, which characterizes the state of equilibrium of soil moisture in a profile as proved earlier. It can be called the characteristic vertical distribution of soil moisture belonging to the dynamic balance of water content, or the soil-moisture retention curve. As already 8
114
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
shown in the unsaturated zone of homogeneous media, this problem can be reduced to the investigation of the relationship between tension and water content [Eqs (1.3-8) and (1.3-91, while in the transition zone, the analysis haa to be supplemented by the determination of the ratio of the capillary influenced pores to the total pore volume [Eqs (1.3-12) and (1.3-13)]. This condition immediately gives rise to the idea that a p F curve could be used pF= log W
U
lU
20
7
30
moisture in percent by volume, W
[%I
Fig. 1.3-6. Characteristic form of p F curves determined from large number of measurements (after Wind)
to determine sought after matching curve, since - according to its definition - a pF curve also represents the relationship in question. The usually accepted method of determining a pF curve is to apply vacuums of various values to the investigated sample, and to meaaure the retained soil-moisture values against the pressure in the pores. After plotting the points of vacuum vs. water content t h e p F curve can easily be constructed (Fig. 1.3-5; Wind, 1966). Different types of equipments have been proposed t o create suction on the sample, the construction of which depends mostly on the range of pressures to be applied. The two curves (i.e. p F and soil moisture retention) are identical if the osmotic forces (chemical-, electro-, or thermo-osmosis) are negligible, because the pF curve expresses the relationship between water content and tension, the latter including the effects of all the forces. Neglecting osmosis, the remaining acting forces are gravity and adhesion supplemented by capillarity in the partially saturated transition zone. Gravity, adhesion and capillarity are also forces, the balanced condition of which (or more precisely the water content belonging $0 this condition) is characterized by the water retention curve as well.
115
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
Differences occur only in the determination and the interpretation of the two curves. The p F curve describes the relationship of tension and water w n tent of a sample determined by applying various tensions to a separated soil sample. Considering that the tension expressed in an equivalent water column is the same as suction caused by gravity at an elevation above the water table equal to the water column mentioned, i t is evident that the two curves have to be identical if the profile is homogeneous and composed of the same material (with the same porosity) aa the sample invetitigated (supposing, once again, that osmotic forces are negligible). For this reaaon, the physical interpretation of the p F curves is dealt with in detail further on, which gives - at the same time - the explanation and understanding of the physical character of the soil-moisture retention curve. There are two special problems to be discussed in connection with the proposed application of p F curves: (a) The change in the bulk volume of the investigated sample aa a result of increasing moisture content; (b) The structure of the cultivated layer (root zone) which makes dificult the interpretation of the water retention capacity on the basis of the p F curve. A common feature of the soil-moisture retention curves is that they are composed of three clearly recognizable sections (Kovkcs, 1968; Fig. 1.3-6a). The upper part of the curves is almost vertical (zone of adhesion) which is followed by a nearly horizontal section, where the water content increases rapidly with decreasing tension (open capillary zone). Finally, the curves have to be closed by a vertical line where the moisture content equals porosity ( W = n ; s = l),this value being the upper limit of the amount of titored
I
0.5
l.0
s=W n
Fig. 1.3-6. Characteristic stretches of p P curves (a) General form; (b) Curve representing very fine-grained sample
8*
116
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of secpage
water in the pores (closed capillary zone). There are only a few exceptions, always in the case of very fine material when the first two sections are substituted by a line evenly curved with a decreasing slope as the water content increases (Fig. 1.3-6b). However, the vertical closing section below the minimum capillary rise intersects the horizontal axis a t W = n in this case as well. In contrast to this concept based on the physical upper limit of the water retention capacity (which states that the moisture content cannot be higher than that belonging to total saturation), most of the p F curves published in the literature show gradually increasing water contents, considerably exceeding the original porosity of the sample, as the tension approaches a zero value. The sloping character of the closing part of the p F curve is especially characteristic in cohesive materials (clay, silt), but many similar curves are also published for fine sand. The theoretically correct, vertical, closing part is generally measured only for coarse grained sands. Instead of repeating these curves from other publications (Klute, 1952; Sudnitsin, 1966; Vkallyai, 1974), three p F curves were carefully measured and these are shown in Fig. 1.3-7, together with the original porosity of the samples. It can clearly be seen that the total moisture content belonging to a low tension is higher than the original porosity of the samples. This contradictory result can only be explained by the fact that the bulk volume of the samples, and thus their porosity as well, increased considerably as the moisture content was increased. In Fig. 1.3-8, the observed change in volume of the three samples is also presented to prove the reliability of the previous statement (Zotter, 1975).These measurements indicate that in the '
0
02
0.4
06
0.8 W ( 0
Fig. 1.3-7. p F curves with increasing moisture content in the close capillary zone
117
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
case of cohesive samples, the change in porosity could also cause some uncertainties, even in the zone of adhesion. The porosity of the material can only change if the investigation is carried out on a separated sample because, in a soil profile, the weight of the overlying layer hinders the expansion of the medium. It is also evident that p F values belonging to different porosities must not be used for the construction of a unified soil-moisture retention curve. The basis of this statement 07-
9 0.003-
*.P.
116- \*
.s 0.NlZ-
i2 F
115-
9,
s. 9
s8
\
Q
s
8
i
'?
F!$
i
k
how
& 04-92
0.001--
.' \.
,.'
',
0.1-
1 2
\
-.-. ------------_____ .---.
.- ._
4.5
I
I
I
I
1
50
55
80
65
70
PF
clay
.,' -. -.
. * .
*\.
sand
1
u
clay
--. ---------___
loess
'-+
-.
\.
-*-
Q g
0.2 - '\
\.\.
0 *\.
,sQJ
8h
\.
loess .-*.
*\
PL Q F J8 0.3-
s
.'
a 45
I
I
1
I0
. 6 ,.a6
60
I
~75of
1
ZD
Fig. 1.3-8. Change in the volume of the samples with increasing moisture content
is the fact that the relationship between tension and water content includes porosity as an independent variable, because both the size of the pores (capillarity) and the relative internal surface (adhesion) change with the relative pore volume. The physical interpretation and the mathematical approximation of the dependence on porosity of the relationship in question will be discussed in detail in the next Section. It is advisable, therefore, either to ensure a constant pore volume of the sample when measuring p F values, or to correct the observed data on the basis of the measuredchange in pore volume in the open capillary zone and to close the soil-moisture retention curve with a vertical face in the closed capillary zone at values of W = n (Fig. 1.3-9). It is necessary to note here that there is a special structure of soil, which may result an elongated closing part of the retention curve: i.e. the secondary pores enclosed by aggregated particles. In such soils the p F curve developes according to the pattern characteristic for the evenly distributed pores ehowing an almost vertical section, where water content is equal
118
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
to the primary pores. Lowering the suction the saturation of the secondary pores starts; this process raises the water content until total porosity, and results in the development of a second sloping strech of the curve. Another problem arises when the p F curve is applied to the determination of the soil-moisture retention capacity. This is caused also by the fact that the cultivated zone has a special structure composed of aggregates, while at a greater depth the layer is generally built up from evenly distributed, indichange in Porosity, An
Fig. 1.3-9. Correction of meaaured p P values considering the change in pore volume
vidual grains and pores. The development of primary porosity created inside the aggregates and secondary porosity created by the large channels between the clods is represented in Fig. 1.3-10. It is the general opinion that the physical investigation of the unsaturated zone has to exclude the analysis of the processes occurring in the root zone, because physiological processes are there predominant, whereas below the layer affected by roots the water movement is solely a physical process (van Bavel, 1966). Some investigations have proved that the channels of earth-worms could also modify the water movement through the top soil (Peterson and Dixon, 1971). Apart from these influences of biological origin, the development of the normal soil-moisture retention curve is also disturbed by the special structure previously mentioned, which is created partly by
119
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
roots and the aggregation of grains influenced by the organic content of the soil, and partly by ploughing. Thus, the separation of the root zone, or the cultivated zone, from the other part of the unsaturated zone is absolutely necessary from the physical aspect as well, was the case in the construction of the model represented in Fig. 1.3-1. The comparison of grain-, aggregate-, and pore-size distribution in the different soil layers (horizons) can be used to demonstrate and characterize the structural differences resulting from cultivation and the activity of roots. In the case of the example represented in Fig. 1.3-11 a chernozem soil developed on a loess terrace was investigated (VuEic, 1966). The almost aggregate romposea ofgrains end enclosed primary pores
7
secondary pores
u---aggregates Fig. 1.3-10. Primary porosity of aggregates and secondary porosity composed of the channels between the clods identical granular composition of the Iayer was indicated by the grain-size distribut'ion. Thus, their similar physical behaviour could be expected. There was only a slight difference between the lowest layer and the others, showing that the former was somewhat finer. This was probably caused by the irreversible aggregation of fine grains in the upper part of the profile where the physico-chemical properties of the particles had been influenced to a greater extent by drying and wetting or freezing and thawing. The distribution of the aggregate-size was determined only for the A horizon (where the aggregates could be well distinguished), by sieving the samples in both wet and dry conditions. The wet sieving did not show any difference between the ploughed Iayer and that beneath it, while in the dry sieving, the aggregates of the ploughed layer were considerably coarser indicating that the large clods created by ploughing are less stable. The most important information was provided by the pore-size distribution curves. The probable maximum and minimum pore sizes were calculated from the physical characteristics of soil in the samples [Eqs (1.2-19 and (1.2-22)J It was found that the diameter of the primary pores is smaller than 3 p and their total volume is about 30-32% of the bulk volume (pri0.32), which agrees well with the measured mary porosity n, = 0.30 data. The measured total porosity of the ploughed layer is n 0.55, that
-
-
,
120
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
aggregate diameter CcmJ 4,
F 50P
'i
POre-sile
calcuJafed from grain-size __ ~
x
pore-size disfributiun I
1 Z
2
A Z
f
h$iiii7-3 A;iiio-2 pore diameier [ e m ] Fig. 1.3-11. Grain-, aggregate- m d pore-size distribution of the different horizons of chernozem soil developed on a loess terrace 10-4
2
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
-
--
121
of the A and AC horizon is n 0.5, that of the C horizon is n 0.45, while 0.38.Thus, secondary porosity (n,= n - n,) in the basal layer (CQ), n decreases with depth. Ploughing raises this value from n, 0.18-0.19 to n2 70.24, a parameter which is characteristic of the top soil. At the C horizon, a secondary porosity of n, 0.16 was found. I n the basal layer the secondary porosity is only a few percent and itsdevelopment is probably due to the deeply penetrating roots. According to thlt continuum approach, porosity (more precisely its change) can be characterized by selecting a suitable representative elemen, tary volume (see Chapter l . l ) ,and most of the hydraulic processes can be described (even in the case of a porous medium having a special structure) in a macroscopic way by applying this parameter. The relationship between tension and moisture content is, however, an exception because its development is basically influenced by the structure of the pores as well. The process has to be investigated, therefore, on a microscopic level, and the macroscopic approach is not applicable. The channels composing the secondary pores are generally large and capillary menisci cannot develop in them. Hence, atmospheric pressure prevails throughout the aggregates. For this reason all the clods have to be regarded as a separated system in which the relationship between tension and moisture content develops independently of the others, influenced only by the boundary conditions of the clod under investigation. As already mentioned, the boundary condition along the large secondary channels is characterized by atmospheric pressure. Only a small fraction of the surface is in contact with other aggregates where different boundary conditions prevail, governed by the moisture content and tension condition of the neighbouring clods. The aggregation of the particles usually occurs only in very fine grained (cohesive) soils. Thus, the tension belonging to the saturated condition (height of the closed capillary zone) is considerably greater than the size of the clods and, therefore, the complete saturation of the primary pores is expected if the boundary condition is described by p = p , on the surface of the clod (even if there is a small suction caused by other clods in contact with the one under investigation). Only a few pores contain trapped air, which slightly decreases the water content of the aggregates (see Fig. 1.3-10). From this condition the moisture content of the structured top layer ( W s l ) can be calculated assuming that suction on the surface of the clods is smaller than the air entry pressure at that point (which is approximately equal to the height of the closed capillary zone):
-
W,, = VPl--n, ;
vt
SSl=
~
WSl n
n1 n1+ n2
(1.3-15)
If the moisture content is higher than this limiting value, the secondary pores also contain water, a condition which causes the disaggregation of the clods and destroys the structure of the soil. The moisture content of the aggregates is constant until the pressure on their surfaces is smaller than a given limiting value characterizing the porous medium of the clods. The pressure determining the boundary condition can be raised above the given
122
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
limit either by evaporation (around the clods near the surface), or by the roots encircling the aggregates and even penetrating into them. Because the maximum pressure created by the usual growth of crops is about 16 atm ( p F = 4.2), water will be avdlable for the plants if the water content is higher in the clod than that belonging to p F = 4.2. Thus, the lower limit of moisture content ( W,), below which agricultural production requires artificial water recharge, can also be calculated:
where qaa2) is the saturation of a homogeneous sample from the material of the clods under the influence of pressure described by the p F = 4.2 value. Using Eqs (1.3-15) and (1.3-16) in addition to Fig. 1.3-11 in Table 1.3-2, the probable characteristic values of the porosities of the different horizons in the chernozem soil under investigation are summarized, together with the range of moisture contents within which saturation has to be maintained in arable land. The last line of Table 1.3-2 [which was calculated Table 1.3-2. Porosity and characteristic moisture content of structural chernozem soil (as percentage of volume) (saturation belonging to p F = 4.2: S(4.2)
DiEerent horisoiis of chernmem mil covering loess terrace
I
= 0.40)
I
Porosity
upper limit
secondcontent
A (ploughed) A AC C
CG
I
Required
0.66 0.60 0.60 0.46 0.38
0.31 0.31 0.32 0.29 0.32
0.24 0.19 0.18 0.16 0.06
CB (assuming that the structure can be neglected)
ration
0.31 0.31 0.32 0.29 0.32
0.66 0.62 0.64 0.64 0.84
0.12 0.12 0.13 0.11 0.12
0.22 0.26 0.26 0.26 0.32
0.19 0.19 0.19 0.18 0.20
0.38
1.00
0.16
0.40
0.23
assuming that the basic layer hae no special structure (secondary porosity, large channels), but that the total porosity ( n = 0.38) is evenly distributed in the layer] shows that in this very fine material, agricultural production can hardly achieve good results without secondary porosity because total 1.8 2.0. Hence, plants cannot be provided saturation occurs at the p F with the necessary air.
<
'V
123
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
1.3.4 Description and determination of the soil-moisture retention curve
In the unsaturated zone, the water in the form of a thin film covers the solid wall ,formed of grains. The force, retaining this water against gravity, is adhesion. Without investigating the character of this force in detail (which will be given in Chapter 2.1), its existence can be explained by the attraction between the wall of the solid skeleton and water molecules. This force is created by the electrostatic charges of the graim, and the orientation of water molecules having dipole character (Van der Wads force). These types of forces are generally approximated in theoretical physics by relating the tension at the surface of the water film ( p ) to the thickness of the film ( 6 ) in the form of a hyperbola of the sixth order:
.=It) 6
(1.3-17)
It ie quite evident that the thickness of the water film is closely correlated to the water content of the sample. As a first approximation of the dynumic equilibrium of the moisture content of a sample in the zone of adhesion ( W;) can be determined by multiplying the grain surface ( A )by the thickness of the water film and by forming the ratio of the obtained value to the total volume: A6 A a C (1.3-18) w;;=-= -6(1 - n ) = -__ (1 - n ) ; Vt V D,, P1lS because the ratio between the volume of the solid grains ( V ) and the total volume of the sample ( V , ) is equal to (1 - n ) , and the ratio of the grain surface to the grain volume can be expressed as the ratio between effective diameter and shape coefficient [see Eq. (1.2-l)]. A similar result can be obtained by calculating the moisture content adsorbed to the walls of the pipes composing the physical model of the water transporting channels (see Section 1.2.5). In a pipe having a length 1 and a radius ro, the amount of water stored in a film of thickness 6 is
W, = In($ - r2) = h 6 ( d 0 - 6);
(1.3-1 9)
became the internal radius of the water film can be calculated as the difference between the radius of the pipe and the size of the water film ( r = ro- 6 ) and double the value of the pipe radius is equal to the average diameter (2r0 = d o ) which can be calculated from Eq. (1.2-19). The number of pipes crossing the unit area of the sample ( N ) is determined by Eq. (1.2-20). The water content of a sample with a cross section of unity and a length I (the total volume of which is, therefore, V t = I ) is the product of the W ,value and the number of model pipes. This product divided by the total volume of the sample gives the moisture content, being in a balanced condition under a pressure of p . Thus, the second approximation of the balanced moisture content in the zone of adhesion (W$*) aa the func-
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
124
tion of the physical parameters of soil can be estimated on the bwis of the proposed physical model of samples composed of individual grains: ~
~
NW 6 n = 2 = 4 I-v* d0
~
( d”,)
=--(l-n)
;hpt6
[
1
_ _1_a_ _C _1 _- n 4 Dhp116
n (1.3-20)
From Eq. (1.3-20), the rate of saturation in a balanced state can also be determined for the zone of adhesion, depending on the prevailing tension and the physical parameters of the soil. According to the definition of the coefficient of saturation, this value can be achieved, if the volumetric moisture content is related to porosity:
As already mentioned in the state of dynamic equilibrium the tension on the surface of the water film balances the effect of gravity which is proportional to the elevation of the investigated point above the water table: (1.3-22) p = yy = h y . Substituting this value into Eqs (1.3-20) and (1.3-21), the vertical distribution of soil moisture belonging to the balanced condition ( W, or ajc) can be determined in the unsaturated zone, giving the correct form of Eq. (1.3-9):
(1.3-23)
where the constant Co is composed of the Cconstant of Eq. (1.3-17) and the specific weight of the water. It is necessary t o note that accepting Eq. (1.3-20) as a basic principle, any kind of y = f ( W) function will obviously satisfy the condition given in Eq. (1.3-8). This equation cannot serve, therefore, as a control and the reliability of the proposed relationship between tension and water content has to be checked by measurements. For this reason, measured data which gave the related values of porosity, effective diameter, shape coefficient, water content and tension were collected from the literature (Table 1.3-3). Following the structure of Eq. (1.3-20), some of the measured parameters were combined into one characteristic value ( Wy116/l - n ) and this is listed in the last but one column of the table. The fact that the Wy1/6 product calculated for a sample from several measurements (sometimes the number of data concerning one sample was as high as 9 or 10) shows only a random fluctuation, justifies the approximation used to characterize the relationship between the balanced tension and the thickness of the water film [Eq. (1.3-17)].
125
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
Table 1.3-3.
Data characterizing the relationship between moisture content and adhesion
I I
Dh
Porosity
Material
1
Effective diameter DhIcml
I 1 1 shape caW$'* cirt
1-n
Referenoes ~-
Glass beads Glass beads Sand Sand
0.37 0.40 0.38 0.36
7.26 x 4.36 x 2.00 x 10-3 1.20 x 1 0 - 2 3.16~ 2.60~ 6.87~10-~6.87~10-~
Glass beads
0.38
2.00 x 10-3
Sandy, clayey loam
N
0.G
N
6 x 10-5
1.20 x
N
6 6
7.6 x
10 6
0.130
Peck, 1966
16
1.676
Rose, 1966
8
10-2
-
Johnson etal.,
0.062 0.076 0.200 0.110
1963;
PrillUaZ., 1966
Sand Sand
0.467 0.382
6 . 8 0 ~ 1 0 - ~ 6.6 x ~ O - ~ 1.92~ 1.6 x
8.1 8.3
0.380 0.233
Wind, 1966
Coarse sand Sand Sand Fine sand Fine sand Loess Light clay Fine sand Sand
0.363 0.363 0.386 0.404 0.434 0.490 0.430 0.360 0.340
3.96~10-~ 2.30~ 1 . 4 5 ~10-3 6 . 0 0 ~10-4 6.22 x 10-4 9.30 x 10-5 6.70 x 10-6 8.00~10-4 3.10~10-~
10
Wesseling and Wit, 1966
6.0 x 10-3 4.16 x 1.4 x 10-3
0.107 0.167 0.208 0.243 0.276 1.600 1.170 0.381 0.129
Fine sand Sand separates Sand separates Sand separates Sand separatet Sand separates Sand separates Sand separates Sand separates Sand separates Sand separates Sand separates
0.460 0.440 0.440 0.450 0.440 0.410 0.430 0.360 0.360 0.360 0.340 0.340
2.57 x 10-4 2.60 x 1 0 - 4 4 . 6 4 ~10-4 8.18 x 10-4 1 . 1 10-3 ~ ~ 1.64~ 2.32 x 10-3 4.00 x 10- a 5.11 x 10-3 6.67 x 10-3 8.33 x 10-3 1.67 x
2.67~10-3 3.00~10-~ 6.60~10-~ 9.00~10-3 1.27x10-* 1.80~10-~ 2.66~10-~ 3.60 x 4.60 x 6 . 1 0 ~lo-* 7.60 x lo-* 1.60 x lo-'
Stakman, 1966
9 9 9 9 9
0.396 0.679 0.268 0.238 0.179 0.163 0.140 0.109 0.097 0.096 0.064 0.046
Sand
0.372
2.76 x
2.20 x
8
0.148
Kastanek, 1971
Very fine sand Fine sand
0.438 0.438
6.80 x 1.45 x
6.80 x 10-4 1.46 x
10 10
1.207 0.961
Sand
0.420
1.45 x 10-3
1.76 x
12
0.369
Vachaud, 1966 Boreli and Vachaud, 1966 Vachaud et a1 ,
Sand
0.400
2.48 x 10-3
2.48 x
10
0.160
Vachaud and Thony, 1971
Silty loam
0.6000.678 0.440 0.470 0.390
6.30 x
7.67 x
12
Elric, 1966
9.98 x 8 . 6 4 ~10-5 8.21 x 10-5
9.98 x lo-' 8 . 6 4 ~10-4 8.21 x 10-4
10 10
1.761.94 1.143 1.396 1.041
10-4
4.0 X ~ O - ~ 1.8 x lo-* 1.2 x 1 0 - 2
1.0 x 1 0 - 3 8.0 ~ 1 0 - 3 3.1 X ~ O - ~
8 8 8 8
16 16 10 10 10 12 11 11 11 11 11
1974
Sandy loam Silty loam Fine sandy loam
10
126
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Table 1.3-3. (cont.)
Sand
0.380
2.75 x
2.20 x
Sand
0.29
1.91 x 10-3
Send
0.36
Send Loess
0.36 0.40
8
0.113
Abmmova et al., 1966
2.10~ 10-2
11
0.148
1.91 x
2.10 x 10-2
11
0.176
Watson and Whialer, 1969 Wetson, 1967
1.79~ 1.22~
2.16~ 1.46~
12 12
0.177 0.217
Zotter, 1976
Continuing the theoretical analysis, the constant of Eq. (1.3-23) can be expressed 88 the function of the physical parameters of soil (Dheffective diameter; a shape coefficient of grains; n porosity). This theoretical relationship agrees well with the empirical result gained from the measurements (Fig. 1.3-12).
Fig. 1.3-12. Relationship between grain diameter and the parameter including moisture oontent, tension and porosity
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
127
When the data from Wy1/8/1- n in Table 1.3-3 was previously analyzed as a function of the effective diameter (KOV~CS, 1968), only some discrepancy waa found between the theoretical and the measured data. In theory, the power of D , is 1 but the experiments gave a value of 0.8. This discrepancy was explained by the fact that the shape coefficient was neglected. For this reaaon, some further data with known shape coefficients were collected, and in other cases the parameter waa estimated on the bwis of the physical description of the samples. According to Fig. 1.3-12, the theoretical curve lies along the measured points, although the scattering of the points is considerable. It is acceptable, therefore in practice, to substitute the theoretical relationship with an equation having a more simple form (which is represented in Fig. 1.3-12 by a dotted line): 1/6
wy = 2 . 5 ~ 1 0 - ~ 1-n
. ..
valid if 4~
Dh << 2~
a
(1.3-24)
To indicate the reliability of this relationship, the curves lying 30 % above and 30% below the original curve were also represented in the figure. They prove that by using a numerical factor in Eq. (1.3-24) ( 1 . 7 5 ~ or 3.25 x the probable extreme position of the soil-moisture retention curve can be determined with a probability of 90% in the zone of adhesion (only 4 data have larger scattering than *30% from the total number of 44). The indicated width between the limits of confidence is relatively low if the uncertainties influencing the process are considered. In the empirical formula, the numerical factor and the limits of the validity zone have certain dimensions, and the effective diameter has, therefore, to be substituted in cm to obtain the tension expressed by the height of the equivalent water columns also measured in cm. On the basis of the equations given, the position of the upper part of the soil-moisture retention curve can be determined, knowing the physical soil parameters of the sample or alternatively these parameters can be calculated from the measured upper section of the curve. Considering that two unknown parameters (n and the ratio of D&) have t o be determined, it is sufficient to have two measured points, or if more, there is a possibility of a control as well. The number of measurements necessary, immediately suggests the use of Kuron’s and Mitscherlich’s hygroscopic moisture content to characterize the upper part of the curves. Knowing that the suctions created by sulphuric acid (ensuring a constant temperature of 20°C) in concentrations of 10 and 50% are pF=4.62 and pF=6.16, respectively, and the measurement of the water content belonging to these conditions is accurate and easily repeatable, the curve and the characteristic physical parameters of soil can be measured using simple instruments. For a control, the use of concentrations of 20 or 30% can be proposed, which give points at pF = 5.28 or 5.62, respectively. Chemicals other than sulphuric acid can similarly be used. The relationship between tension and moisture content for the three
128
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Table 1.3-4. Interrelated p F values and moisture contents determined as hygroscopic moisture in the zone of adhesion (after Zotter, 1976) p P value
0 0.4 1.0 1.6 2.0 2.3
I-
Measuring method
Box with sand plate
Box with kaolinite plate
2.7
3.4 4.2
High pressure equipment
Measured soil moistum in cluy
80.7 74.1 74.1 71.0 68.4 66.0 63.1 62.6 36.2
I
loess
1
send
46.64
31.8
-
30.9 30.1 28.3 20.1 6.9 4.0 2.9
-
39.67 32.81 28.77 16.3 11.6
Exsiccator Applied chemical
Relative moisture content of air
[%I
materials (the p F curves of which are represented in Fig. 1.3-7) was determined in this way and the results are listed in Table 1 . 3 4 (see also PBczely and Zotter, 1973). There are a few cases where the curve described by the equations previously listed remains valid in the whole zone of 0 < W < n. Examples of these are of very fine grained samples having a monotonously decreasing pF curve (see Fig. 1.3-6b). The intersection of the y = f ( W ) curve with the vertical W = n indicates the limiting value of tension ( y , ) . If the suction caused by gravity (hy,) is smaller than p , = ynyu;( h < y , ) , the soil remains saturated because the tension (even in the centre of the pores) is greater than the suction created by the weight of the water column:
In a layer composed of coarsergrains (which is generally the characteristic condition) complete saturation can alao occur in the cwe of higher suction than the limit given in Eq. (1.3-25). The new upper limit of this saturation
129
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
is the height of the water column equal to that of the closed capillary zone. The physical cause of this phenomenon is the existence of another molecular force acting against gravity i.e. capillarity. The character of this force is well known. Attraction between water molecules is balanced in the interior of the medium, because the same forces act on a molecule from each direction. The unbalanced mass-attraction caused by the asymmetrical position of water molecules at the surface, however, creates stress (surface tension), which becomes observable in the form of a curved surface where the water surface is in contact with the solid wall. If the horizontal section of the container of water is small enough, the unbalanced surface stresses around the solid wall can be summarized in the form of suction acting against gravity and raising the water above the water table of zero pressure (i.e. capillary suction). For the numerical characterization of the capillary force (the detailed analysis of which is given in Section 2.1.1) the capillary height is generally used, which is linearly proportional to the surface tension (u) and inversely proportional to the horizontal size of the capillary pore (in the case of a circular cross section, to its diameter). Both the surface tension and the coefficient of proportionality depend on the nature of the materials in cohtact. Thus, in the case of the contact of quartz, water and air as solid, liquid and gaseous media respectively, (and this is the general case in soils), the capillary height in a tube of d diameter can be calculated from the following simple equation [neglecting the dependence of surface tension on temperature and using average parameters acceptable in the most probable range of water temperatures ( 10-20°C)]: 0.30 [cm2] (1.3-26) hc [cm] = -d [cml Substituting the probable small and large pore sizes [d, and d2 on the basis of Eq. (1.2-21)] as well as the mean diameter [do from Eq. (1.2-19)] into Eq. (1.3-26), the maximum, minimum and average expected capillary heights can be calculated: Height of the open capillary zone:
.
h,,,,
0.30 =--0.11--.
1-n
a Dh
dl
Height of the closed capillary zone:
h,
=
-0.30
1-n u 0.06 -_ . Dh
d2
Average capillary height: 0.30
1-n
u
hCo= -= 0 . 0 7 5 ~ -
.
(1.3-27)
n Dh do Stakman’s air bubbling pressure data can be used to check the reliability of Eq. (1.3-27) (Stakman, 1966). The measured data (already represented 9
130
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
in Fig. 1.2-26), and the probable maximum and minimum capillary heights calculated from the physical parameters of soil me compared in Table 1.3-5. Considering Whisler and Bouwer's (1970) results which showed that air entry pressure is roughly equal to half the minimum 'capillary height, the Calculated parameters seem to agree well with the meaaured values. Table 1.3-6. Comparison of Stalnnan's air bubbling data and the probable minimum and maximum capillary heights calculated from physical parameters of soil Physlcal parameten ot soil
D~[cm]
3 . 0 0 ~10-3 6 . 6 0 ~10-3 9.00 x 10-a 1.27 x 1.8OX 10-2 2.66 x 3.60 x lo-* 4.60~ 5.10 x 7.60 x 1.60 x 10-l
I
a
n
12 11 11 11 11 11 9 9 9 9 9
0.44 0.44 0.46
0.44 0.41 0.43 0.36 0.36 0.36 0.34 0.34
I
[cm water] sampleheight lmm asmm
I
160 76 60 39 27 16 13 9 7 6 4
190 126 88 66 54 39 23 18 16 13 6
I
Minimum
306 129 90 66 67 34 28 21 20 14 7
I
hlaximum
660 337 164 121 97 63 51 38 36 26 13
The dependence of the probable maximum and minimum cupillary rise on porosity wm previously investigated in a more detailed form (Smith et al., 1931; Smith, 1933). The theoretical basis of his analysis was built on the probable structure of spherical particles with different porosities. The experiments were carried out with glass beads and sand separates using various fluids. For this reason, the results were expressed as a product of capillary height, grain radius (Rh)and the specific weight of the fluid ( yr) divided by surface tension (u),the latter parameter being related to porosity. The same parameter can also be expressed from Eq. (1.3-27) as the function of porosity ( n ) and the shape coefficient ( a ) : yf
hc max Rh,., 0.75 a 1-n, . _ Yf hCrnI"Rh _ _ U n a
~
0.40 a
1-n
n
.
(1.3-28)
Smith's measured data and the results of his proposed equation- are compared to the probable maximum and minimum capillary heights calculated from Eq. (1.3-27) in Fig. 1.3-13. The comparison proves that the dependence of the capillary height on porosity and shape coefficient is adequately considered in Eq. (1.3-27). The minimum value isin good accordance numerically with the observed data while the calculated maximum capillary rise 20% than the measured one. This difference is seems to be higher by 10 regarded aa acceptable, considering the uncertainties of the observation of the actual capillary height in a granular sample.
-
131
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
curves calculatedusing
+ I
0.33
035
037
039
0.41
043
0.45 .33
035
I
037
I
I
l73g
0.41
Oh3
*
0.45
porosity> n porosity, n Fig. 1.3-13. Comparison of Smith's data and capillary height calculated from Eq. ( 1.3-27)
The size of the pores can be considered as a random value. A given probability can be attached, therefore, to both d , and d,, while the ratio of the various pore-sizes to the average value can be characterized by a probability distribution curve. From the measured values of the cross-sectional area of every pore in various samples a statistical analysis was made proving that the ratio of the individual areas ( f ) to the average value ( f o ) can be well approximated by a distribution function. The frequency distribution and its integral form determining the probability of the number of pores having a given pore-size is as follows:
r
and (1.3-29)
The particular character of the function applied to the description of poresize distribution can be expressed by considering special parameters : (a) The smallest possible area tends to zero, and thus the lowest limit of the distribution curve is zero (xo70); (b) T h e random variable is the ratao of the area of pores related to their mean d u e (x = f / f o ) . The mean of this variable is, therefore, equal to unity ( G l e a n = 1); (c) I t follows from the previous condition that the two further parameters of the functional are equal to one another (k/A= m; m = 1; and k = A). Hence, the final form of the frequency distribution function is
9*
132
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
where
x = f/f,.
(1.3-30)
I n this special caue, direct relationships exist between the I and k parameters of the distribution function and the m and u parameters of the normal distribution
r
Thus, not only the author’s own measurements (four different samples and from each more different packing, namely, 7, 6, 8 and 4 measurements respectively) were available for further analysis but also the data of a previous publication which summarizes the mean value and the variation in the pore-size distribution measured on seven different samples and approximated with the normal distribution function (Murota and Sato, 1969). The graphical representation of the measurements in the I , vs. n coordinate system (Fig. 1.3-14) and the statistical investigation of the data have shown that the mean value of I , is 1.14 with a variance of o = 0.42 (this variance being 37 %). Considering the observed relationship between porosity and the 1, parameter, the variance can be slightly reduced (a, = 0.34), proving that the use of the equation determined by regression analysis
I,
= 2.19 - 3.75n & 0.34
(1.3-31)
can eliminate only about 20 yoof the uncertainties. The scatter of the points belonging t o the same sample with different porosities indicates that the remaining variance is caused mainly by sorne physical parameter of the soil not considered in the investigation (lines joining the points have similar slopes
4l 2.3 -
15 -
4.g -
c.5-
0-
Fig. 1.3-14. Relationship between porosity end the 1, parameter of the I’distribution function
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
133
to each other in the direction of increasing porosity and intersect the vertical axis at different heights). Considering the relatively small discrepancy between I, mean and unity and also the position of the line representing Eq. (1.3-31) in the range of the most probable porosity (0.3 < n < 0.4), the simplification by applying the I , = 1.0 value seems to be acceptable. In this case the r distribution function is reduced to an exponential function:
I(1.3-32)
and
Representing the P ( z ) functions belonging to ‘various I, values (0.5; 1.0; 1.5 and 2.0, Fig. 1.3-15), it can be seen that the probability of pores having a diameter of d , is between 20 % and 30 %, while the same parameter characterizing the pores with a diameter of d, is 80%. Thus, half of all the pores are those having diameter between the small and large diameters calculated from Eq. (1.2-12), the sample hawing about 30% smaller and 20% larger pores than those represented in the hydraulic model. Knowing the probable number of pores of various sizes, the total area of the pores having a smccller area than a given limit can easily be calculated. within a unit section of the sample can be The total number of pores (N) divided into m groups, according to the size of the pores. The basis of all intervak is df and the average area of the i-th interval (in which there are m
N I number of pores) is f i ;
2 N i= N lkl
1
.The specificfrequency distribution
can be characterized by dividing the number of the pores in each interval by the total number of the pores. When approximating the experimental
Fig. 1.3-16. Probable distribution of the number of pores as a funct)ionof the specific surface
134
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
frequency distribution by continuous function, the parameters of the latter can be calculated as the area above the horizontal axis and below the graph which is equal to the area below the curve (Fig. 1.3-16):
mAf Fig. 1.3-16. Theoretical sketch represent.ing the frequency distribution of the pore size
and
-
[ v(f; df)df = Of where
0
(if d f
-
0);
(1.3-33)
and v ( f ; df)is the continuous approximation of the frequency distribution. If the df interval is small enough, the total area of pores (which is equal t o the areal porosity where the total cross section of the sample is unity) can be expressed as the sum of the fiNi product:
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
135
therefore (1.3-34)
and
-
J ’ f v ( f ; A f ) d f = 1N2 A A f = f O A f ; 0
because the areal porosity can also be determined as a product of the total number of pores and their mean value (nA= Nf,). Further investigations can be simplified by introducing dimensionless variables. This goal can be achieved if the variables having an areal dimension are divided by the mean value of the measured pore sizes
The function describing the frequency distribution of the number of pores of different sizes has also to be transformed using the E(z;As)function instead of v(f; df). Introducing the new variables, the integrals in Eqs. (1.3-33) and (1.3-34) are as follows:
-
J E(s;
dx)dz = AS;
(1.3-35)
0
~ z [ ( z ;AX)& = AS.
0
Considering the results of the statistical analysis of the measured data, and accepting the simplified form of the distribution functions [see Eq. (1.3-32)], the mathematical description of the E(z;dz) function satisfying the conditions specified in Eq. (1.3-35) can be given in the following form: t ( z ; Ax) = Ax exp (-x)
.
(1.3-36)
Investigat,ing the rate of capillary saturation of a sample, the network of pores can be substituted b y vertical straight capillary tubes as a fist approximation. The distribution of the number of tubes with different diameters is the same as that determined by Eq. (1.3-30) [or by its simplified form - i.e. Eq. (1.3-32)]. In this case at an elevation of h, above the water table all the tubes having smaller cross-sectional area than f, are completely saturated, while the larger sections are sled with air. The rate of capillary saturation can be determined, therefore, by relating the sum of the area of pores having a smaller area than fc to the total free area in the cross section of the sample:
where
136
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Substituting Eq. (1.3-36) and integrating the rate of capillary saturation is expressed as the function of the limiting vdue of the pore size:
+
(1.3-38) = 1 - (fdfo 1) exP ( I - f J f o ) * The ratio between the cross-sectional areaa of two circular tubes is equal to the square of the rate of their diameters. Thus, the coefficient of capillary saturation can be expressed aa the function of a given limiting value of the diameter related to the average pore diameter: sc
because
sc = 1 -
+ 11exp [-(dJdo)21;
[(dJdo)a
(1.3-39)
fdfo= (dc/~o)a. The soil-moisture retention curve describes the relationship between suction (elevation above the water table) and the water content. If it is divided into two parts (i.e. the rate of capillary and adhesive saturation, respectively) and only the effect of capillarity is investigated, the interrelation indicates which part of the pores can be saturated by capillarity at a n elevation of hc. This is the ratio of pores having a capillary height equal to or greater than he [see Eqs (1.3-12) and (1.3-13)]. Considering Eq. (1.3-26), this ratio depends only on the pore diameter and, therefore, the capillary component of the soil-moisture retention curve can also be approximated by a probability distribution function (Rbthgti, 1960). The distribution function describing the relationship between the rate of capillary saturation and capillary height can be characterized mathematically by applying a further transformation in Eq. (1.3-39). Considering that the capillary height is inversely proportional to the pore diameter, the ratio of the limiting diameter to the average value can be substituted by the quotient of the average capillary height and the height of the investigated elevation above the water table: 8,
because
=I1
-
+ 11exp [ - ( ~ c d h J 2 1 ;
( 1.3-40)
-=dc hco do hc
The curves described by Eqs (1.3-38), (1.3-39) and (1.3-40) arerepresented in Fig. 1.3-17. The figure shows that among the three capillary heights calculated from Eq. (1.3-27) one belongs to the s = 0.5 value of the rate the second to s = 0.01 0.05 (h, while the third of saturation (he (hcocalculated from do average pore diameter) gives the position of the capillary component of the soil-moisture retention curve where the rate of saturation is equal to s = 0.25. The basis of the previous derivation is a model composed of straight capillary tubes having different diameters, though the diameter of each tube is constant. The network composed of the pores is, however, a system of channels with a changing cross section and not that of straight pipes with constant diameters. The capillary height is influenced, therefore, not only by the
-
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
137
Fig. 1.3-17. Distribution of pore size, pore diameter and capillary height determined by applying a model composed of capillary tubes of constantfdiameters
distribution of the pore sizes in a horizontal section but by the vertical change of the pore diameters as well. For this reaaon some pores are not saturated when the dry sample is made wet from the direction of the water table, while the same pores can retain capillary water when the process starts with the complete saturation of the sample and dynamic equilibrium is achieved by drainage. This phenomenon is the hysteresis of the soil-moisture retention curve (the nearly horizontal section of the curve haa a lower position if i t is determined by wetting and a higher one in the case of drainage). In the literature, the phenomenon of hysteresis is generally explained by two different physical causes (Bear, 1972). The f i s t possible reason may be the rain drop egect, according to which the angle of contact of the meniscus with the wall of the capillary tube (8,) is larger when the water advances and the decreme in the in the tube than when in a static condition (8,) angle can be observed (0, < 0,)in the case of a receding water column (see Fig. 2.1-17). The same difference in the contact angles can be observed between the front and the rear of a rain drop moving along a sloping glass plate (the name of the phenomenon is based on this similarity). The water level may remain a t a higher position when a capillary tube with changing diameter is drained, compared to the rising condition, because the downward movement can be stopped when the meniscus reaches a small cross section (where capillarity can balance the weight of a relatively higher water column), while, similarly, the rise of the meniscus stops at a large diameter. This phenomenon is called the ink-bottle egect, because in old ink bottles this effect was used to keep the level of ink near the mouth of the bottle. From the two possible causes, the rain drop effect cannot be accepted as an explanation of hysteresis. The soil-moisture retention curve represents the vertical moisture distribution in a static condition. On the contrary, the
138
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
rain drop effect is a process occurring only in the case of flow in capillary tubes. Thus, a phenomenon characterizing the movement of water cannot be the cause of a phenomenon (the two possible positions of the retention curve) which describes the static condition of the moisture distribution.
i Fig. 1.3-18. Distribution of capillary height in the case of a bundle of identical wavy capillary tubes
For this rewon, the change i n diameter of the chccnnels will be used to explain the existence of hysteresis. It is necessary, therefore, to use a model composed of tubes, the longitudinal section of which is represented by two undulating lines having a minimum distance of d,, a maximum one of d2, and a wave length of 2a (Figs 1.3-18 and 1.3-19), instead of the straight capillary tubes mentioned previously. Even if the wave length is constant (all the tubes are identical with each other as in Fig. 1.3-18), the pore-size distribution previously described in a horizontal cross section can eaaily be ensured by placing the sections of tubes of different diameters at the level of the water table. The same result can be achieved with the other model, where the amplitude (the fluctuation of the diameter of the tubes) is the same as in the previous case, but the wave length varies from tube to tube (the parameter of a is also a random variable, described by a distribution function; Fig. 1.3-19). Investigation of the model represented in Fig. 1.3-18, shows that the maximum capillary height (belonging to diameter d,) can never be achieved by wetting the tubes from the direction of the water table, if the difference between the maximum and minimum capillary rise is greater than the wave h, < (h, min 2a), all the tubes length. This is because in the zone of h, and the have a section of diameter d, whose capillary rise is equal to h,
<
+
1.3 D y n d a of soil moisture
139
t
wetting
draining Fig. 1.3-19. Distribution of capillary height in a group of different wavy capillary tubes
rising water, therefore,cannot surpass the level of the cross section of diameter d2. The opposite process occurs in the system when it is saturated and the dynamic equilibrium is achieved by drainage. I n this caae, the capillary level should be i n the zone h, > h, > (h, - 2a) because all these tubes have a section of diameter d,, where the capillary tension can balance a water column of 11, max. In the case of the more realistic model composed of diflerent wavy tubes, the wave length is a random variable (Fig. 1.3-19). In investigating the wetting process of the sample, the water can be raised by capillarity to the level of h, max in some of the tubes [the wave length of which is greater than the difference of (h, max - h, mln) and if the capillary rise is unaffected by a large section of the tube below the maximum level]. In the tubes having shorter wave lengths, the capillary rise is limited to the level (h, mln+2a)tm described in the previous' paragraph. If the wave length is long enough but has a large diameter below the highest capillary rise, the elevation where the weight of the water column is balanced by capillarity depends on the diameter at this level. In this case, the average (mostprobable) capillary height is between the minimum capillary rise and the level characterized by the sum of the former and the most probable wave length (2a). Only the vertical shifting of the nearly horizontal stretch of the soilmoisture retention curve can be explained by the ink-bottle effect. The
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
140
observations have shown, however, that the y vs. W relationship is not a single-valued function in the zone of adheeion either. One of the remons for the different water contents at a given elevation above the water table is the d e r a b l e time lug between the time points of the change of the position
(b)
10
-
0
I
0
1
0.1
1
I
I
0.2
1
I
0.3
water content, W Fig. 13-20. The development of the soil-moistureretention curve in time
of the water table and the development of the dynamic equilibrium. Figure 1.3-20 .
shows the refjults of an experiment illustrating the observation of the process in time. The data indicate the extremely slow development of equilibrium in the adhesive zone when the column is drained, viz. in this case, the upper part of the sample has very small hydraulic conductivity because of the low
141
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
water content, and thus, the excess water percolates downwards with a very small velocity. The wetting is generally a faster process, but a considerable difference can be observed between the initial wetting (when the process starts with a completely dry sample) and rewetting (when the sample waa previously drained and some soil moisture was retained in the pores). In the first caae, the development of the dynamic equilibrium in the adhesive zone has, perhaps, a greater time lag than that of the column drainage. Thus, (b)
variation of moisture content
v s. sucfion bead relatiunship with
time on the basis of fteld measurements at a given depth (Bourm, z = 40 cm)
0
0.l0
0.20
0.30
water confeflf, WI
1 '
0
0.1
water
I
I
0.2
a3
content, W
Fig. 1.3-21. Characterization of hysteresis by laboratory and field meaaurementa (after Vachaud and Thony, 1971; Royer and Vachaud, 1975)
in many cmes the difference between the water contents observed at the 8ame elevation in a wetted and drained column respectively can be explained by the insufficient length of the observations. The horizontal shifting of the vertical stretch of the retention curve is, however, also indicated by data determined directly from simultaneous measurements of tension and soil-moisture values (Fig. 1.3-21). In this case the corresponding data are not influenced by the time-dependent develop- . ment of the dynamic equilibrium. The cause of hysteresis is the water retained in the corners of the pores after draining. The explanation of the phenomenon of hysteresis indicates many uncertainties influencing the form of the soil-moisture retention curve and cause its multi-valued character. It is not expected, therefore, that the history of
142
1 Fundamentals for the investigetion of seepage
Toucbetsilty loam
a
az
0.4
06
I
1
1
1
02 n.4 06 .a3 Fig. 1.3-22. Comparison of the theoretical soil-moisture OR s
{a a
1 , -
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
0
0.4
D.6
143
00 s lo 0
3.0h -
3.0.
(h) sand
nco 2.5 n
=
o m
n
= 0.346
2.0 -
1.5 -
1.0 -
0.5 0
P
D-
o
02
04
06
20
retention curve with measured data
s
ID
o
02
ao
05
JB s
/c
144
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
the wetting and draining processes can be followed theoretically. The random position of the retention curve can be characterized only by comparing the calculated average curve and measured data. For this comparison observations published by three different laboratories supplemented by the author’s own measurements were used (Figs 1.3-22a and 1.3-22b, Johnson et d., 1963; Prill et al., 1965; Figs 1.3-22c and 1.3-22d, Ldiberte et al., 1966; Figs 1.3-220 and 1.3-22fJ Vachaud et aZ., 1975; Vauclin, 1975; Khanji, 1975; Vachaud et al., 1970; Vachaud and Thony, 1971; Figs 1.3-22g and 1.3-22h the author’s own measurements). The measured data prove the reliability of the theoretical relationships [Eqs (1.3-24) and (1.3-40)] and considering the composition of adhesive and capillary retentions (Fig. 1.3-23), the final form of the equation describing the average retention curve is as follows:
(1.3-41) To characterize the probable zone of hysteresis, it can be proposed that separate enveloping curves should be applied along the capillary and adhe-
Fig. 1.3-23. Composition of soil-moistureretention curve from adhesive and capillary retention
145
1.3 Dynamics of soil moisture
sive stretches respectively. The scattering of data in the zone of adhesion has already been discussed in connection with Eq. (1.3-24). Considering uncertainties explained there, the enveloping curves can be given in the following: form: ( 1.3-42)
In the capillary zone the enveloping curves can similarly be given by using a multiplying factor in the distribution fnnction which characterizes the rate of capillary saturation
sc2= 1 -
[i z I : 1.5-
+1
1
[[
exp - 1.5-
,
These curves are also represented in Figs 1.3-22g and 1.3-22h. Their position proves that Eqs ( 1 . 3 4 2 ) and (1.3-43) are suitable to characterize approximately the expected scattering caused by hysteresis. References to Chapter 1.3 BEAR,J. (1972) Dynamics of Fluids in Porous Media. Elsevier New York, London, .Amsterdam G. (1966): Certain Problems of Infiltration in Unsaturated BORELI,M., VACHAUD, Porous Media. Saopstenja Inetittda za VodorpriiVp.eduJaroslav Cerni,N o 38. BncKwaHAM, E. (1907): Studies in the Movement of Soil Moisture. USDA Bureau of So& Bulletin, No. 38. L)E WIEST,J. M. (1969): Flow through Porous Media. Academic Press, New York, London. DoLaov, S. I. (1948): Investigation of the Movement and the Availability of Soilmoisture (in Russian). Izd. A d . Nauk SSSR, Moscow, Leningrad. ELRICK, D. E. (1966): The Microhydrologic Characterization of Soils. I A S H Symposium on Water i n the Unaaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. FEKETE, Z. (1950): Comparative Investigation of Parameters Characterizing the Water Balance of Soils (in Hungarian). Hidroh5qiai Kozlony, No. 7-8. IASH (1974): Hydrological Investigation of the Unsaturated Zone (Second circular). Budapest. JOHNSON, A. I., PRILL,R. C. and MORRIS, D. A. (1963): Specific Yield-column Drainage and Centrifuge Moisture Equivalent. Qeologiccrl Survey Water Supply Paper, 1662-A. JwAsz, J. (1967): Hydrogeology (in Hungarian). Tankonyvkiad6, Budapest. KASTANEK,F. (1971): Numerical Simulation Technique for Vertical Drainage from a Soil Column. Journal of Hydrology. p. 213. KHANJI,J. D. (1976): Investigation of the Recharge of Ground Water with Free Water Table by Infiltration (in French). Doctoral Thesis Univereity o f arenoble. 10
146
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
CUTE, A. (1962): Some Theoretical Aspects of the Flow of Water in Unseturated So&. Proceedings of American Sod SciencS Society, Vol. 16, No. 2. KOVAOS,G. (1968): Cheraoterization of the Moleoular For- Muencing Seepage with the He1 of the p F Curve. Agrokhia b Tdajtan, (Supplementum). KOVAOS, (19718): Seepage through Unsaturated Porous Media. 14th Uongrei?s of IAHR, Pa&, 1971.
Cf
KOVACB, G. (1971b): Seepage through Saturated and Unsaturated Layers. Bdletin of IASH, No. 2. KREYBIU,L. (1961): Heat- and Water-balanoe of Soils (in Hungarian). Budapest. KWON, H. (1932): Characterization of SoilMoisture (in German). Zeitschrijt fiir Pflanzen, Berlin. LALIBERTE,G. E., COREY,A. T. and BROOKE,R. H. (1966): Properties of Unsaturated Porous Media. Hydrology Papers, Colorado State University, November, No. 17. LEBEDIEV,A. F. (1963): Sog Moisture and Ground Water (in Russian). Izd. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Moscow. LUTZ,J. F. (1966): Proceeding of American Soil Science Society, pp. 330-361. MADOS, L. (1939): Studies Related to Irrigation and Water Management in the Irrigation Scheme of T i e z a f i i (in Hungarian). hiidaiigyi Kiizikrnknyek. MADOS, L. (1941): Use of Soil Moisture Related to Surface Drainage (in Hungarian). c)ntGz&i&yi K6demdnyek. MITEIOHERLIOH, E. A. (1932): Soil Scienoe for Agriculture and Forestry (in German). Berlin. MUROTA, A. and SATO,K. (1969): Statietical Determination of Permeability by the Pore-size Distribution in Porous Media. 13th Congress of IAHR, Kyoto, 1969. P E ~A., J. (1966): Diffueivity Determination by a New Outflow Method. IASH Sympeeium on Water in the Uneaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. P~OZELY, T . and ZOTTEB, K. (1973): Summary of Inte mtation and Measuring Methods of p F Curve (in Hungarian). (Manuscript). V d , Budapest. PETERSON, A. E. and DIXON,R. M. (1971): Water Movement in Large Soil Pores: Validity and Utility of the Channel SMem Concept. Reaearch Report University of WieconSin, June, No. 76. A. J. and MORRIS,D. A. (1966): Specific Yield-laboratory PRILL, R. C., JOHNSON, ExDerimenta Showinn the Effect of Time on column Drainage. Geoloaical survew. "W&er Supply Paper,"l662-B. PROOEROV. A. V. and KARASEV.N. K. 11939): Land Reclamation and Water Control (in Russian): MeZior a i gidrotekhniki, No: 12. RbTHdm, L. (19603ngineering Aspects of the Capillarity of Soils (in Hungarian). Vcziisyi Kodemknyek. No. 1. RICEARDB, L. A. (1931): Capillary Conduction of Liquids through Porous Media. PhyeicS, Nov. RODIE,A. A. (1962): Soil Moisture (in Russian). Izd. Acad. Nauk SSSR, MOSCOW. ROSE, D. A. (1966): Water Transport in Soils by Evaporation and In6ltration. IASH S y m p o h m on Water in the Unsaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. ROYER,J. M. and VAOHILUD, Q. (1976): Field Determination of Hysteresis in Soil Science Characteristics. Proceeding8 of Soil Science Soc&ety of America, No. 2. SMITE, W. 0.(1933): Minimum capillary Rise in an Ideal Uniform soil. Phyeics, May. SMITE,W. O., FOOTE, P. D. and BUBANU, P. F. (1931): Capillary Rise in Sands of Uniform Spherical Grains. PhyeicS, July. STAKBUN,W. P. (1966): Relations Between Partiale Size and Pore Size and Hydraulio Conductivity of Sand Separates. IASH Symposium on Water in the Unsaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. SUDNITBIN,L. I. (1966): Soil-moisture Pressure in Some Climatic Zones. IASH Sympeeium on W&r in the Uneaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. VAOEAUD, G. (1966): Study on Redistribution after Stoppin Horizontal Infiltration (in French). IASH Sympoeium on Water in the Unsaturated &me, Wageningen, 1966. VACJUUD,G. (1966):Verification of Generalized Darcy's Law and the Determination of CapilLary Conductivity by Analysing Horizontal Infiltration (in French). IASH Sympoeium on Water in the Uneaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966.
-
1.4 Balance of the ground water
147
VACHAUD, G., CISLER, J., THOM, J. L. and DE BACKER,L. (1970):Utilization of Gamma Emission of Americium-241 for Measuring the Soil-moisture Content of Unsaturated Soils (in French). Isotope Hydrology - 1970. I A E A . VACEAUD, G. and THONY,J. L. (1971): Hysteresis during Infiltration and Redistribution in a Soil Column of Different Initial Water Contents. Water Resources Reeearch. No. 1. VACHAUD, G., GAUDET, J. P. and KURAZ, V. (1974):Air and Water Flow during Ponded Infiltration in a Vertical Bounded Column of Soil. Journal of Hydrology, NO. 1-2. VACEAUD, G., VAUCHIN, M. and HAVERKAMP, R. (1976):Towards a Comprehensive Simulation of Transient Water Table Flow Problems. Seminar on Modeling and Simuldion of Water Reaourcea System, 1975. VAN BAVEL,C.H.M. (1966):Three-phase Domain in Hydrology. IASH Symposium on Water in the Uneaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. V-YAI, G. (1942): Experiences in Irrigation a t MAtraliget (in Hungarian). C)ntoz&igyi Kodemdnyek, No. 2. V ~ L L Y A G. I , (1974):Investigation of Water Movement Developing in Unsaturated Soil Layer (in Hungarian). Agrokkmia 6s Talajtan, Vol. 23, No. 3-4. VAUOLIN, M. (1976):Experimental and Numerical Inveatigation of the Drainage of Ground Water with Free Water Table. The Infiuence of the Unsaturated Zone (h French). University of Grenoble (Dootoral Thesis), A ril VTJ~IC, N. (1966): M u e n o e of Soil Structure on h t r a t i o n and p P Values of Chernozem and Chernozem-like Dark Meadow Soil. IASH Symposium on Water in the Uneaturated Zone, Wagewingen, 1966. WATSON,K. K. (1967):Experimental and Numerical Study of Column Drainage. P r o d i n g s of ASCE, ELY.2. WATSON,K.K. and WHIBLER, F. D. (1969):Analysis of Infiltration into Draining Porous Media. Proceedings of ASCE, IR.4. WESSELINU, J. and WIT, K. E. (1966):An Infiltration Method for the Determination of the Capillary Conductivity of Undisturbed Soil Cores. IASH Symposium on Water in the Unaaturated Zone, Wageningen 1966. WHISLIER,F. D. and BOUWER,H. (1970):Comparison of Methods for Calculating Vertical Drainage and Infiltration for Soils. Journal of Hydrology. No. 1. WIND, G. P. (1966):Capillary Conductivity Data Estimated by Simple Method. IASH Sympoeium on Water in the Unaaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. ZOTTER, K. (1976):An Instrument for Determining the Upper Stretch of the PP Curve (in Hungarian). (Manuscript). VITUKI, Budapest.
Chapter 1.4 Investigation of the balance of the ground-water space In the previous chapter the hydrological processes occurring in the soilmoisture zone were analyzed. It has been shown that infiltration and evapotranspiration through the surface (both modified by the change of storage in the unsaturated pores) affect also the regime of the gravitational ground water. The resultant of these influences can be summarized aa the water exchange between soil moisture and ground water (accretion). This combined effect can be divided into two vertical components. The first is directed downwards, and it is that part of infiltration which reaches the water table. The second component is the vertical natural drainage of the ground-water space through the water table, which raises water from a deeper posit,ion by capillarity and tension difference to replenish the storage capacity of the soil-moisture zone emptied by evapotranspiration. The interaction between the two zones in question can be investigated as a pure hydrodynamical process, when the instantaneous water transport has 10*
148
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
to be calculated, convidering the actual flow conditions. For such an analysis, detailed knowledge of the acting forces, as well as that of the resistance of the unsaturated porous medium is necessary and the prevailing boundary conditions have to be taken into account. These aspects will be summarized later on in this book; therefore, the hydrodynamic investigation of flow through an unsaturated zone will only be discussed after the explanation of all the necessary basic concepts. There is, however, a more general way of investigating the water exchange between soil moisture and ground water, when this process i s regarded as a part of the hydrological cycle, and its average numerical parameters are determined from the water balance equations of the relevant water bodies. This hydrological analysis provides important information also for solving numerous hydraulic problems; the average parameters obtained in this way can be used for checking the hydrodynamic calculations, st8 the amount of water transport integrated for a longer period has to be equal to the result determined from the water balance equations. Another important field of application of the hydrological parameters in seepage hydraulics is the investigation of the horizontal flow of the shallow ground water, when accretion influencing the flow field through the water table has to be considered. I n this case the average parameters calculated from the balance equations can be used as independent variables describing this special boundary condition. This close contact between hydrodynamic and hydrological investigations gives ground for including the hydrological analysis of the ground-water balance in a book dealing with seepage hydraulics, as it is done in this chapter.
1.4.1 General hydrological characterization of water exchange between soil moisture and ground water
The basis of the present investigation is the model of the soil-moisture zone represented in Fig. 1.3-1 ; the same symbols are used here as those indicated there (Kovbcs, 1959a, 1959b, 1971). Let us &st consider a limited soil column in the vicinity of the surface, where evapotranspiration can affect the gravitational ground-water space owing to capillarity and the suction of the roots of vegetation. The column includes a part of the ground-water space (below the phreatic ground-water surface) and the soil-moisture zone (both the unsaturated and the transition zones between the water table and the soil surface) (Fig. 1.4-1). The equation of continuity can be determined for this column by considering the recharging and draining processes. The amount of water contained within the investigated column is increased by infiltration through the surface ( I , ) . Evapotranspiration, which includes direct evaporation from the soil moisture (Em)and transpiration by plants (T,)causes losses in the column. Ground water may flow either in or out of the space observed, recharging or draining it (Diand Do). Horizontal moisture flux, either into
1.4 Balance of the ground water
149
Fig. 1.4-1. Sketches representing the components of the water balance equations characterizing the hydrological processes in the soil-moist,urezone
the column (Mi), or directed out of it ( M o ) ,is usually very small compared with the other recharging and draining processes; it is, therefore, neglected in the following discussion. The sum of water transported through the boundaries of the column is equal to the change of the water content stored within a given period (T) in the soil column. The latter includes the change i n amount of both soil moisture ( A W ) and ground water ( A V ) from the beginning to the end of t,he period (0 < t < T ) : T
2 [+ I,(t) + D,(t)- E,(t) - T,(t)
-
Do(t)]At = [-+AM'& AV],T. (1.4-1)
n
The members on the left-hand side of the equation are functions of time, and they are expressed the water amount related to the surface of the column and to the unit of time. Thus their dimension is equal to that of velocity [LT-11. Infiltration through the surface originates from precipitation, and it can be betermined by subtracting from the total precipitation both surface run-off dnd the amount of water evaporated directly from the surface, or retarded ay the vegetation. Apart from climatic parameters (amount and distribution
150
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
of precipitation, factors affecting evaporation), this value depends on the condition of surface (degree and direction of slopes, covering vegetation), as well as on the type and condition of soil influencing the process of infiltration. One part of the infiltrating amount is stored in the unsaturated zone (Iw) filling this layer up to its water retention capacity (or sometimes, temporarily, above this limit). The other part reaches the gravitational ground-water space ( I , ) , either during the rain, or with a time lag (Fig. 1.4-lb):
Irn(t) = Iw(t)
+ Ig(t).
(1.4-2)
As it has been mentioned, evapotranspiration is composed of direct evaporation ( E m ) and transpiration through plants (T,,,).Although both draining processes reduce the moisture content in the unsaturated zone, the total amount of water subtracted from the soil may be divided into two parts: the first is the prolonged decrease of the moisture content ( E , and T,, respectively), while the second part is replenished from the water table below; thus this amount ( E g T , = ET,) is a negative component of the ground-water balance (Fig. 1.4-lb):
+
Ern(t)
+ Trn(t)= E d t ) + Tw(t) + Eg(t) + Tg(t)= ETw(t) + ETg(t)* (1.4-3)
The amount of the soil moisture evaporated and transpired depends on the potential evapotranspiration (temperature, moisture deficit of air, wind velocity), on the parameters characterizing the evaporating surface (mostly conditions of vegetation, such as depth of the root zone, total surface of leaves, water consumption of the plants) and on the type and condition of the soil. The third group of the influencing factors is the ground-water flow rechargand outflow (Do) ing or draining the gravitational space. Both inflow (Di) depend on the hydraulic gradient developing in the vicinity of the column investigated and on the transmis8ibiZity (the product of thickness and hydraulic conductivity) of the water conveying layer. The two processes may by investigated jointly, by considering their difference:
*AD(t) = Dj(t) - D,(t).
(1.44)
Although the listed components of the balance equation are time-dependent variables, when the period investigated is long enough, their average multiplied by the length of the period can be used instead of their integrated value. _
m
1 "
- J E,(t) dt = Em ; T i 1 T -J T,,,(t) dt = F,,, ;
TO
1.4 Balance of the ground water
151
1 T J AD(t)dt = AD ;
TO
(1.4-5) 1 T J ET,(t) dt = EF,,, ;
TO
1 T J I,(t) dt = 1,;
TO
1 T
- J ETg(t)dt = ETg.
TO
Substituting these averages into Eq. (1 4-1), the simplified balance equation, valid for a long period, can be written in the following form:
[ ( I g- ET,)
+ ( I , - ET,)
f ADIT = [ f d V f AW):.
(1.4-6)
The two members on the right-hand side of the equation express the change of the water amount stored in the column between the beginning and the end of the period investigated, indicated by 0 and T s u f i e d outside the bracket. The first symbol (dV) refers to the change of the stored gravitational ground w t e r , while AW indicates the diflerence i n the soil moisture. These two values are closely interrelated, because if the change i n gravitational storage is calculated as the product of the change of the water level ( A H ) and t,he effective porosity of the layer ( n ) (Fig. 1.4-lc)
f AV = f d H n ,
(1.4-7)
this parameter includes a part of soil-moisture storage aa well, while the stored amount of soil moisture also depends on the position of the water table. According to its definition, the change of storage in the soil-moisture zone is equal to the difference of the amount of moisture above the water table at t w o subsequent points of time. Thus the change may be caused not oiily by the variation of the point values of moisture content, but also by the change of the position of the water table, because the thickness of the .soil-moisture zone changes in this case as well: 0
0
f A W = J J W ( t = 0 ) dA dm - J J W ( t = T)dA dm = W 1- Wz; (1.4-8) mi ( A )
m (4
where A is the area of the horizontal cross section of the investigated column (which is supposed to be unity) and dA is its elementary part. In most areas the water table shows a regular annual fluctuation, and generally still another one, with a longer period. Under natural conditions, Iwwever, a state of equilibrium can be expected, if the period considered is long
152
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
enough. (Here all effects caused by human activity, excluding direct artificial recharge and pumping, are regarded as “natural”; e.g. change of cultivation, control of surface run-off, etc.). This assumption is evidently correct, because these effects act continuously over a number of decades, even centuries, almost without m y considerable changes, thus providing enough time for the development of a dynamic equilibrium. The average elevation of the undisturbed water table is, therefore, at a level, where all the recharging effects are balanced by the various draining actions. The equlibrium of the natural influences (and those acting indirectly over a long period) can be characterized with a time-invariant average depth of the water table (mav). This is the reason why the hydrographs of such water tables (the graphs representing the change of the position of the water table in time) are generally closed, if the period is long and its limits were properly chosen. (The closing of the hydrograph means, that the initial and end points are at the same elevation). Assuming the soil column t o be i n a state of equilibrium, and supposing that the determination of the investigated period satisfies the conditions mentioned in the previous paragraph, the change of the amount stored i n the gravitational ground-water space is zero (AV = 0 ) , because the position of the water table at the end of the period is the same as it was at the beginning ( A H = 0). If the starting and closing time points are in the same season, the change of the stored soil moisture m y also be neglected (AW = 0). In this special case the water balance can be limited to the gravitational ground water below the average water table (mav)(Fig. 1.4-Id). The equation of ground-water balance [Eq. (1.4-1) or (1.4-6)] remains valid also for this case, but the recharge from infiltration refers to the amount of water which reaches the water table (I,), and not to that crossing the surface. Similarly, the amount drained from the system has to be considered as the water raised from the gravitational ground water (ET,) to replenish evaporated and transpired soil moisture, and not the total amount of the latter. This modified form of the balance equation expresses that the vertical water exchange between soil moisture and ground water is eqml to the total effect of ground-water flow (the difference of outflow and inflow), if the position of the water table is practically the same at the beginning and the end of the period used for the calculation of the averages of the parameters in question: (1.4-9) I , - ETg = Do - Di. There are many cases, however, when a shorter period has to be analyzed (e.g. when studying the seasonal fluctuation of water exchange between ground water and soil moisture) and, therefore, storage cannot be neglected. The investigation can yet be limited to the balance of the gravitational space in this case as well, but the changing volume of the investigated column has to be considered; this can be expressed in the form of the change of the stored amount of ground water : (1.4-10) ( I , - ET,) (Di- Do) f AVO = 0.
+
It is necessary to note here that the AVO value is not equal to A 7 in Eq. (1.4-7), because the latter gives a part of the total change of both ground
1.4 Balance of the ground water
153
water and soil moisture, which can be determined arbitrarily, considering that the calculation of the other part ( A W ) is suitable to supplement the first part and to give the correct amount of the total change. If the investigation is limited to the gravitational space, the physically correct interpretation of the storage capacity of the layer has to be determined. I n the literature the storage coeficient (storistivity, S ) or specific storage (S,) is generally used to characterize this property of confined aquifers, and the specific yield (n,) is the accepted parameter for unconfined layers. In addition to the topic discussed here, the characteristics listed have an important role in many other fields of seepage hydraulics. Their detailed analysis is given, therefore, in the next section, together with the methods proposed for their numerical determination. Supposing that the column, whose balance is investigated now, is separated from an unconfined aquifer, its storage capacity will be characterized by the specific yield (n,) of the layer in this analysis; thus the change of storage as a result of the modification on the position of the water table ( A H ) can be expressed as A V O = AHn,. ( 1.4-1 1) Finally, it can be stated that the balance equations describe the relationships between two [Eq. (1.4-9)] or three [Eq. (1.4-lo)] independent processes occurring in the gravitational ground-water space (i.e. vertical water exchange, horizontal flow and change i n storage). Owing t o the numerous uncertainties generally associated with the determination of hydrological parameters, i t is advisable to measure, or calculate, all the members of the balance equations separately, and to use the formulae only for checking the reliability of the measurements, or for determination of the closing errors (use of the implicit form of balance equations). It is also possible to express one member of the equation as a function of the others (explicit form),and calculate the former from the measured data of the known parameters. It is necessary, however, to consider in this case that all errors in the measured data are burdens to the calculated value. Considering the required implicit use of balance equations, the three processes listed previously will be analyzed separately in the following, starting with the storage in both confined and unconhed layers.
1.4.2 Storage capacity of aquifers The storage capacity of a layer is characterized i n general by the volume of water released from, or taken into storage as a result of a unit change i n pressure, or piezometric head. The volume is related to the horizontal arm of the layer, and thus it has a dimension of length [L]. This amount depends on - The compressibility of solid grains; - The compressibility of water; - The change of porosity of the saturated layer; - The change of the ratio of the saturated and unsaturated thicknesses. The f i s t component is very small in comparison with the others, therefore it is negligible. In confined aquifers (theoretically, only if it is covered with
154
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
aa absolutely impervious formation) the system will remain always saturated, thus the fourth effect does not influence the process. In the investigation of shallow ground water with a phreatic water table, the change of the thicknesses of the saturated and unsaturated zones has the most pronounced role. The effect of consolidation and water compressibility can therefore be neglected in this case. It is the reason why the characterization of a confined aquifer differs basically from that of unconfined water-bearing layers. In the first case the parameter defined previously is called storage coepient (S), and it d e p e d on the consolidation of the layer and on the cumpressibility of water. This value represents the total storage capacity of the layer having a thickness of b. Sometimes this parameter is related to the unit volume of the aquifer (water released from, or taken into storage in a volumetric unit of the layer). This specific storage (S,) multiplied with the thickness provides the storage coefficient:
S = bS,.
(1.4-12)
The specific yield (n,) characterizing the storage capacity of an unconfined aquifer is generally determined as the volume of water drained from a completely saturated sample related to the bulk volume of the latter. It is supposed that this parameter is equal to the amount released or stored in a column of unit horizontal cross section, if the position of the water table changes by a height of unity. The process occurs at the surface of the gravitational ground-water space, therefore, this parameter cannot be related to the thickness of the aquifer. According to its definition, the storage coefiient is composed of two parts: the change of the volume of water caused by the modification of pressure, and the change of the pore volume, where the water is stored:
s = s w + s,.
(1.4-13)
The compressibility of water is expressed by the change of density with pressure, which is proportional to the density itself (1.4-14) where B ( w e f i i e n t of compressibility) is the proportionality factor; for pure water having a temperature of 2OoC at atmospheric pressure, its numerical value is /3 = 4.6 x lo-* mm2/N.The maw being unchanged, the modification of V, volume of water can be expressed from Eq. (1.4-14):
The volume of water in a saturated layer is equal to the volume of the pores; thus in a unit volume of the aquifer it is equal to the numerical value of porosity. In a column of unit area of a homogeneous layer having a thickness of b, the total change of the water volume can be calculated con-
1.4 Balance of the ground water
155
sidering the total pore volume nb, because all the parameters are constant:
r31=
- Bnb ;
[dV,]:
= - Bnbdp.
(1.4-16)
The storage coefficient meaaures this change if the pressure difference, expressed in equivalent water column, is unity: dp/r = dh = 1 [L]. Combining this condition with Eq. (1.4-16), the first component of the storage coeflcient can be determined Sw = - - y n b .
(1.4-17)
The process of compression, which is well known in soil mechanics, may be used for the determination of the second component of the storage weflcient. For simplifying the mathematical description of the phenomenon, some approximative hypotheses have to be accepted. The first is the supposition of the linear vertical compression of the layer, neglecting the possible horizontal displa,cementof particles, aa well aa the shearing stress caused by unequal comprevsion along two neighbouring vertical sections. Loading the sample gradually, relationships between the load and various physical parameters of the soil (specific linear compression, dry specific
Fig. 1.4-2. Graphs representing the results of experiments investigating compression (KBzdi, 1972)
156
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
weight, water content, porosity, void ratio) can be observed and represented (Fig. 1.4-2) (KBzdi, 1972). (Itis necessary to note here that the pore volume is generally characterized in this investigation with the void ratio instead of porosity, because the latter is given aa the ratio of pore volume related t o the bulk volume, and thus compression modifies the basic value aa well; void ratio, on the other hand, is the ratio of pore volume and the volume of
I
-\
Fig. 1.4-3. Sketch showing the symbols used in the interpret,ationof the relationship between load and compression
solid matrix, the latter remaining unaffected by compression.) Terzaghi (1926, 1943) established an empirical relationship, according to which the change of void ratio over the change of load is inversely proportional to the value of load ( p ) increased with a surplus load ( p o ) ,determined experimentally (Fig. 1.4-3): Ae - de 1 -- - - = = a =
4
dP
C(P
+ Po)
(1.4-18)
*
The coefficient of consolidation a can be expressed as a function of the modulus of compressibility
(a):
(1.4-19)
dP Ah where M = - , and E = - is the relative change of the vertical length of de h the loaded sample (the interpretation of Ae and Ah, as well as a comparison of the two types of compression curves is shown in Fig. 1.4-4; some informative values of M are given in Table 1.4-1). The integration of Eq. (1.4-18) gives Z’erzughi’s equation of compression [Eq. (1.2-16)].
1.4 Balance of the ground water
157
Table 1.4-1. Informative values of the modulus of compressibility (KBzdi, 1972) M [kp/cm'I
I
Type of the sample
1
A) Coarse grained sPdiments
Sandy gravel Sand Very fine sand (mo)
Condition of the sample
I
IOOSe
300-800 100-300 80-120
I
(B) Cohesive sedimenls
Silty very fine eand silt Light clay Heavy clay Organic silt Organic clay Peat
800-1000 300- 600 120- 200
compacted
1000-2000 600- 800 200- 300
Condition of the sample
soft
1
I
plastic
60-80 30-60 20-60 16-40
100-160 60-100 60- 80 40- 70 6- 60 6- 40 1- 20
hard
160-200 100-160 80-120 70- 120
pressure, p [ k N / m 2 ] 200 300 400
500
pressure, p [ k N / m 2 J 200 300 400
500
400
0
I
medium
1
very hard
200-400 160-300 120-200 120- 300
0.8 t
0
m I
I
I
I
I
I
I
--+-+---Fig. 1.4-4. Comparison of the representation of compression as a function of the void ratio or the change of linear size
158
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
The next problem to be discussed is the way of application of the listed equations to calculate storistivity. I n a loose clastic aquifer the weight of the overlying layers (the latter related to a unit horizontal area is characterized with the total vertical stress a) is transferred only partly grain by grain (this part of the total stress is the eflective stress, a);the other part is balanced by water pressure (neutral stress, u). Creating depression ( A h ) by draining the layer, water pressure decreases, and therefore the effective stress will increase, while the total stress remains unchanged: UZ=U~-YA~; a = u1
+ al = ug+ ZZ;
(1.4-20)
+ ydh;
-
az = Z1
(sufbes 1 and 2 indicate the condition before and after draining, respectively). Eq. (1.4-20) shows that the decrease of the pressure head of water increases the eflective vertical stress and this change can be regarded as a n external load causing compression : d p = da = y d h .
(1.4-21)
According to the definition, the second component of the storage coeficient is the change of the total pore volume in a column having a unit horizontal area and a height equal to the thickness b of the layer, if the pressure head is modified with unit height. In a unit volume of the layer, the pore volume is equal to porosity. Its change over the change of pressure can be expressed from Eq. (1.4-18): dn - - dnde __-
-
dP
dedp
dn =
(1-n)2
.
C(P+PO)’
(1 - n)2
+
d p;
(1.4-22)
C(P Po) or for unit change of the pressure head:
where the pressure is equal to the effective stress ( p = Zl)in the initial state. Thus the final form of S, is b
where
b
1.4 Balance of the ground water
159
is a special variable, combining all the depth-dependent parameters in one factor. Considering the numerous uncertainties influencing both the process itself and the parameters, as a &st approximation it is a generally accepted supposition that this factor is independent of the depth. The form of the storage coefficientusually published in the literature (Bear et al., 1968; Bear, 1972) is based on this hypothesis: S = y b(a - np). (1.4-24) I n highly compressible layers the effect of water compressibility can be neglected, but the change of both porosity and effective stress along a vertical section has to be considered, This can be done either by integrating Eq. (1.4-23), or in tabulated form (see Table 1.4-2), supposing the constancy of the parameters within short stretches of the vertical section (Kovhcs, 1972b).
Q6
D
I
ZDO
400
EUO
BOO
,
ill00 0 20
50 /OO 200 500 U80 effective pressure, d [kiV/m2J effective pressurer B [kN/mzJ Fig. 1.4-6. Compression curves represented on arithmetic and logarithmic scales
A further problem is caused by the fact that the layer is not completely elastic. Thus the extension following the increase of neutral stress is not equal to the compression caused by the decrease of water pressure of the same size, and the first loading creates greater compression, than reloading (Fig. 1.4-5). Although the definition of the storage coefficient supposes that the amounts of water released from, or stored in the layer as a result of a unit change in the pressure head are equal t o each other, it is quite evident from the figure that this statement is only a very rough approximation. When solving practical problems in seepage hydraulics, it is impossible to analyze the whole history of loading and reloading of the layer, therefore, a.n average parameter is acceptable to characterize the storage capacity of aquifers. Detailed analysis of compression and the direct application of soil mechanical results are also hindered by the time lag occurring between loading and the total development of compression. The curves representing the relationship between changes of both load and void ratio (see Figs 1.4-2 - 1.4-5) were
160
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
obtained with gradual loading, waiting after all changes of the load until no further compression or extension could be observed. When investigating the time-dependent process called consolidation, many further parameters and conditions have to be considered. A mathematical treatment of the problem needs therefore the application of further simplifying approximations. For showing the complexity of the problem to be solved, the representation of the most simple example of linear vertical compression will be continued here, supposing that the a parameter in Eq. (1.4-23) is constant, and thus the relationship between the change of porosity and that of effective stress can be expressed from Eq. (1.4-22), also considering Eq. (1.4-20): dn _ _- _ _dn = a . d3 du
(1.4-25)
Accepting the validity of Darcy’s law the specific flow rate i n verticul direction crossing a horizontal area of unity can be calculated as follows: (1.4-26)
because the hydraulic gradient can be determined as the change of pressure and potential energy along the z axis (the negative sign indicates, that the flow is directed upwards, while the z axis downwards). The modification of the flow rate within an elementary dz stretch expressed from Eq. (1.4-26) is (1.4-27)
The flow rate can increase only if there is a source in the elementary volume, and in the present case only the decrease of the pore volume can be such a source. Thus the change of porosity i n time should be equal to the change of flow rate along an elementary length. This condition combined with Eq. (1.4-25) provides the following relation: aq -
K 8%
a2
y
a22
- -an - . - -ap;
au
at
at
8% c-=--.* a22
au at ’
where c=-*
K
(1.4-28)
YQ
Thus finally a differential equation is obtained for describing the change of neutral stress and consolidation, which can be solved by integration, if the
boundary conditions are known at both horizontal boundaries of the layers. This condition adds to the compleJrity of the process, indicating that the investigation of consolidation together with that of storage capacity cannot be limited to one layer, because the neighbouring formations may recharge or drain also the aquifer in question.
1.4 Balance of the ground water
161
This short summary of consolidation clearly indicates that the storage coeficient, influenced by the compressibility of the layer, depends mainly on the following factors: (a) Compressibility of water (B); (b) Compressibility of the solid matrix ( a , being the function not only of materid constants, but also of parameters describing the initial state of the layer, which may change with the depth of the point investigated; thus the
time. t
Fig. 1.4-6. Characteristic curves showing the development of consolidation u = const. hypothesis is only a rough estimation);
(c) History of previous loadings of the layer; (d) Time elapsed between the start of consolidation and the time point for which the storage capacity is qletermined; (e) Hydraulic conductivity of the layer ( K , the effect of which can be characterized with the time dependency of the absolute or relative compression, the former being the change of the height of the investigated ssmple, and the latter is the same value related to the total compression after the completion of consolidation. Fig. 1.4-6); (f) Boundary conditions (hydraulic conductivity and pressure conditions of the neighbouring layers) and initial condition (pressure distribution in the layer in question) prevailing along the boundaries of and within the investigated layer [for demonstrating this influence Fig. 1.4-7 shows the dependence of relative compression on time, considering three different boundary and initial conditions; after KBzdi (1972)].
As it has been mentioned, when the storage capacity of a shallow unconfined uquifer is investigated, the effect of compressibilities of both water and the solid matrix can be neglected, compared with the amount of water released from, or stored in the pores following the change of the position of the water 11
162
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
time farfor 3 O ! r
0.2
0.4
I
I
0.6 I
oe
LO
I
I
T= Ct h2 1.2 14 I J
layer drained synmetrical/y at bffofh sides
x
lagers drained on& along
n.
'
e-
.? 40 h
I
\x
initial candii'ion :
triangular pressure diStribuTiffn.?empressure
zero-pressure at tbe basis Fig. 1.4-7. Relative compressionas a function of time for different boundary and initial conditions (KBzdi, 1972)
table. To justify this statement, the values of the two components were calculated, supposing that a depression of 10 m is created in a layer, 200 m deep, bordered below by an impervious, non-deformable formation (KovAcs, 1972a). Two different sediments were considered (loose fke sand, and very compressible clay) and the physical parameters of soil were selected accordingly. The results are shown in Table 1.4-2. Although it is seen that the volum e of water released from the pores immediately after drainage is less than the total amount stored above the level of depression, the numbers indicate that - even in a thick layer, such as the one investigated - the effect of consolidation is relatively small, especially in the case of pervious formations, which are important in practice.*The statement according to which the storage capacity of unconfined aquifers should be characterized with the specific yield, seems to be acceptable. Considering the definition of specific yield, this parameter can be calculated aa the difference between porosity ( n ) and the volumetric water content retained i n the sample against gravity ( W , ) [the latter used to he a1)proximated with Lebediev's maximum molecular water capacity ( Wmol),or field capacity (WfJ as well]: (1.4-29) n, = n - W,. The difficulties arising in connection with the application of this concept are caused by the incomplete physical interpretation of the water content in question, and by the uncertainties of the respective memuring methods. The most commonly applied method of determining both specific yield and water retention capacity of the sample is column drainage, when a column composed of the material to be investigated is completely saturated,
1.4 Balance of the ground water
163
Table 1.4-2. Comparison of water amounts gained by water releatie from the pores and by consolidation, respectively
(a: natural condt tion
(0)
drained condfflon
surface wafer ladle
I Total available water Water stored above the level of depression
Water gained by consolidat ion
in [ml
in [ml in [yo] of the total available water
I 4.00 3.71
93.2
6.26 4.88
78. I
in [m]
0.29
1.37
in [yo]of the total available water
7.2
in [m]
0.35
21.9 __ 1.60
__
Expected land subsidence
may
and the volume of water drained from the sample is then measured, determining the water content retained by the sample as well. Schoeller (1962) collected numerous data from the literature representing the results of such measurements. This information together with some recently published materials are summarized in Table 1.4-3. Representation of the data in the form of graphs (Fig. 1.4-8) clearly indicates the tendency of the relationship between water retention capacity and grain diameter (the former slightly increases with decreasing diameter t o D , 2 0.02 em, and below this limit the increase is more rapid), although the scattering of the points is very large. The data, especially those measured by Hazen, also indicate the influence of porosity (or uniformity, which is closely related t o poroHity), but the uncertainties hinder the numerical evaluation of this relationship. 11*
Table 1.4-3. Specific yields of various samples determined by column drainage Diameter given by
Effective diameter
(loefflcierltof
Porosity
unirormity
dcalated orestimated
[=I
4 [=I
0.003
Weter retention
specie0
field
-pacity
w,
References
n
U
0.0061
0.44
2.3
0.19
0.26
0.006 0.017 0.036 0.048 0.14 0.6
0.0102 0.0272 0.0876 0.0864 0.252 0.760
0.42 0.42 0.326 0.40 0.416 0.46
2.3 2.0 7.8 2.4 9.4 1.8
0.16 0.11 0.096 0.080 0.076 0.070
0.26 0.31 0.23 0.32 0.34 0.37
0.0204 0.036 0.009 0.139
0.020 0.036 0.070 0.140
0.413 0.406 0.391 0.382
near unity
0.061
0.302 0.362 0.360 0.346
Wollny (1886)
0.0082 0.0118 0.0166 0,0186 0.0473
0.008 0.012 0.016 0.018 0.060 0.008 0,012 0.016 0.018 0.060
0.397 0.406 0.408 0.401 0.389 0.397 0.406 0.408 0.401 0.389
nearunity
King (1898)
0.069
0.331 0.366 0.367 0.366 0.366 0.208 0.268 0.294 0.330 0.320
0.014 0.03 0.07 0.14 0.30
0.404 0.406 0.418 0.404 0.401
near unity
0.061 0.048 0.040 0.028 0.032
0.363 0.367 0.378 0.370 0.369
Atterberg (1911)
Comments
na
Haeen (1892)
The characterktic diameter k gken in the form of D,,
0.0139 0.0306 0.0094
0.139 0.303
0.044
0.041 0.037 0.066 0.060 0.041 0.035 0.034 0.180 0.148 0.114
0.080
The e*perimenb were made with elmoat homodisperee samples
IF
zB
?i
t 5'
The experiments were made with almost homodisperse samples
Directly published values for specific yield and water retention capacity Parameters recalculatedfrom dstapubliehed for the ahracterimtion of timedependency of the process
The experiments were made with almost homodisperse eamples
d
6w-
g @
9
s
H
7i 9%
0.0014 0.0047 0.0067 0.022 0.046 0.072 0.112
0.0016 0.0060 0.0060 0.022 0.046 0.072 0.112
0.422 0.406 0.381 0.372 0.362 0.360 0.366
0.0436
0.36-0.38
near unity
0.282 0.174 0.134 0.062 0.043 0.040 0.038
0.140 0.292 0.347 0.320 0.309 0.310 0.317
Zunker (1930)
The experiments were made with elmoet homodisperse samples, although the smaller porosity of more coarse materials indicates thet their coefficient of uniformity was higher than three
Johnsonetd.
GMeSs beads
~~
Given in the form of grain-size distribution
0.0120
0.39-0.41
0.0016
0.40-0.42
0.0687
0.36
0.016* 0.031** 0.120*** 0.030* 0.043** 0.280** * 0.062** 0.290*** O.W* 0.003** 0.186***
0.0212
0.37
0.0114
0.40
O.OSl* 0.090** 0.142*** 0.076* 0.100** 0.213***
0.36 0.36 0.33 0.36 0.24 0.26 0.36 0.38 0.36 0.37 0.11 0.13 0.36 0.38 0.11 0.13 0.310 0.287 0.164 0.289 0.280 0.228 0.326 0.300 0.187
(1963) Prill d al. (1906)
* at the top of sample ** around the top of the open capillery Zone *** average for the column
20 Del Monte sand
Fresno medium sand ~ ~ t u ralluviei el send (Holbrook, Arizona)
166
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
a32 4r sF2 aze
0.24
B P J2 5 0.20 %
s
* % s
,
I
de t P r m in P d an average as the moisture mffted of of the column the dry part ofthe rofumi
+ o.--- .-o
A----A
++ .-.-.0
0
.............x
Johnson ef al. King
Hazen
x
...-..-..+
0.16 0.12
2 c2
2
y
am
L
2
0.04
0 effective diameter, --cirFig. 1.4-8. Relationship between water retention capacity and grain diameter
The most probable reason causing the large discrepancy between the meavured data, is the development of the soil-moisture retention curve i n the drained sample. The U.S. Beologicul Survey, in cooperation with the California Department of Water Resources, made a series of experiments (Johnson et al., 1963; Prill et al., 1965), the results of which are also listed in Table 1.4-3, showing the possible large differences between the parameters determined in different ways from the same observations. The soil columns were drained either by gravity or by suction. (In the latter case a semi-permeable film was placed below the column, the water level was maintained at a given height, and it was connected with the experimental column with a tube). I n Fig. 1.4-9 the results are compared, showing the correctness of the previous statement, t h a t field capacity (in this case water retention capacity, being here equal t o field capacity) is the function of the elevation of the investigated point above the water table. The development of the soilmoisture retention curve is also well demonstrated in the figure. The time-dependent character of the specific yield was also investigated in the framework of USGS’ experiments. It was found that even 100 hours were not enough for the attainment of complete dynamic equilibrium, which can be characterized with hydrostatic tension distribution (the tension being everywhere equal t o the product of the height above the water table and the specific weight of water). Figure 1.4-10 shows the change of tension as
167
1.4 Balance of the ground water
p..2,?
g 220
$& 0
5
280
10 /5 20 25
moisture contentin percentayeof r o h e
5
moisture content in percentage of volume
10
i5
20
25
moisture content in percentage of mlume
Fig. 1.4-9. Development of soil-moistureretention curves in drained soil columns
time elapsed ChoursJ I 2 5 /0/53i 7099
20
40
60
80
i00
i2G
lension in cenfimeiersof wafer Fig. 1.4-10. Graphs showing the distribution of tension during drainage of 0.12 mm glass beads (Johnson el al., 1963)
168
1 Fundamentala for the investigation of seepage
a function of time, by way of example, as memured in one of the experimental columns. It can be seen that in a very f i e sand dynamic equilibrium is achieved only in the lower 80 cm after 100 hours, while at the top-of the column (about 150 cm above the water table) the hydraulic gradient remdns almost unity. At the same time, saturation of the sample is very OW at this elevation and, therefore - aa it is well known and will be proved later on in Chapter 2.3 - unsaturated conductivity is also very low. Thus the IOU
eo 60 1532rm long column
+
40
20 0
fo
130 Ma {jo time ChuursJ Fig. 1.4-11. Relationship between speoific yield and drainage time on the basic of USOS data
a
lo
20
30
40
50
70
ED
90
IOO
iiu
120
amount of water transported by this gradient is negligible. This supposition can also be substantiated by the graphs showing the rehtionship between the drained amount of water and the time elapsed from the beginning of drainage (the graphs were constructed also from the data of USGS’ experiments; Fig. 1.4-11). Among the previous investigations, King’s measurements also afforded data representing the dependem of 8pecific yield on time (Fig. 1.4-12). The length of his experiments waa two and a half years, and water wa,s still released from the sample at the end of this very long period. The result is in good agreement with the conclusions mentioned previously, showing that the process is very slow, but the amount drained at the end of the prolonged experiments is almost negligible. Another interesting experience can be gained from King’s data as well: i.e. about 13-18% of the total stored water was lost during the long experiments, probably through evaporation (the sum of the drained water and the soil moisture retained at the end of the investigation in the sample is smaller than the total pore volume). As a consequence of the numerous uncertainties, occurring in connection with the determination of both specific yield and water retention capacities, as noted previously, there have been attempts in the literature to give average figures as rough estimations for the parameters in question. Such
169
1.4 Balance of the ground water
proposah are summarized in Fig. 1.4-13 (Castagny, 1967; Major, 1972b; De Wiest, 1968). Another way to avoid the uncertainties caused by both the development of the soil-moisture retention curve and the slow process of drainage, is the use of a centrifuge for dewatering the sample. The retained moisture content may be numerically different from water retention measured with column drainage, thus i t is called centrifuge moisture equivalent. This parameter is also influenced by many factors. It was necessary therefore to standardize 0.5 9,
B E?
B
R s?
0.4
porosity
0.3
specific yield
s?
0.2
2
0.1
wafer retention capacity ,
chg fine sand sandy grave/ boulder silt sand marel Fig. 1.4-13. Average porosity, water retention capacity and specific yield as a function of grain size
170
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
its measurement. The American Society for Testing Materials (1958) defked the centrifuge moisture equivalent, it8 follows: “water content retained by a soil, which has been first saturated with water, and then subjected to a force, equal to one thousand times the force of gravity for one hour”. The detailed investigations performed by USGS (Johnson et al., 1963) also included an analysis of the moisture content measured by centrifuging. They have found that this parameter depends on the
farce times gravity
o
300
600 goo m a 1500 force Times gravflg
i000
z
90
Fig. 1.4-14. Effect of the acting force on the centrifuge moisture content (Johnson et al., 1963)
Temperature ; Length of period of centrifuging; Size and structure (porosity) of the sample; Size of the acting force (angular velocity); and, since the iorce changes with the distance from the centre of rotation, the moisture content also changes within the sample. This latter effect can be well demonstrated if the meaaured moisture content is represented as a function of the acting force (Fig. 1.4-14). The relationship can be characterized by considering that the tension created by rotation (hCR)expressed in centimeters of the equivalent water column depends on the angular velocity ( 0 ) [T-l], it8 well aa on the distances of both the bottom of the sample ( r l )and the specified point (r2)from the centre -
171
1.4 Balance of the ground water
of rotaticm measured in centimeters: (1.4-30)
In Table 1.4-4 the centrifuge moisture equivalents (data measured with the standardized method) are listed for each sample investigated, and in the further columns the range of moisture content is given within which the parameter was found, when one of the influencing factors waa modified. The data listed in Table 1.4-4 are also graphically represented in Fig. 1.4-15, similarly to the water retention capacity. The relationship with grain diameter shows the same tendency, although the numerical values are different. The advantage of the use of a centrifuge is that the process is much quicker than column drainage, although the scattering of the measured data cannot be decreased considerably. At the same time, the real physical meaning of specific yield is lost in this way. After demonstrating all the difficulties in connection with the determination of the specific yield, it is necessary to recognize that most of the problems are caused by the insufficient physical interpretation of the term. In an unconfined system, the capillary zone develops always above the water table, hence the dynamic balance i s characterized by the soil-moisture retention curve. The correct way of determining the specific yield i s , therefore, to calculate the diflerence of the amount of water stored above a reference level (chosen arbitrarily, lmt below both the original and the modified water table), if the change in the elevation of the phreatic surface is unity, according to the definition of specific yield. Redistribution of the soil moisture following a change i n the position of the water table needs some time, the length of
g
70
6 ,$D
o
8 &, 50
+ uncontrolled temperafure
%
s
. B %
standard measurement
I scattering caused bg the modification of some of the influencing condltions
40 1
B
9 39 b
1
3.% zn B
Q
3 I0
~
5
&
s o
~
8
Range of ds*r scattering under vdoas hiSki8l
Db
la1
(I
modllied conditions
ZZ?
U n C o n W d
equivalent
Mpsnave
-
Del Monte send 80 meah 30 meah 20 mesh
0.0166 0.0300 0.0687
2.42 1.40
Glese be& 0.47 mm 0.12 m m 0.036 m m
0.0436 0.012 0.0016
1.11 1.30 1.90
69 CAL 191-244
0.0212
4.0
67 CAL 122
0.0026
6.43
4.0
67 CAL 66
0.0045
2.66
4.2
67 CAL 110
0.0030
26 00
6.4
67 CAL 118
0.0022
8.00
6.0
59 CAL 268-261
0.0017
16.66
9.8
13.0
69 CAL 261-262
0.0013
22.60
10.6
13.1
11.0
1.4 0.4 0.6 1.2 1.3 3.4
1.4 0.5
1.3 1.9
N
-
1.2 0.3 0.4
1.6 0.6
1.8 0.6 0.6
1.9
0.9 N 1.3 1.0 1.7 3.1 3.9
2.2
1.6
--
6.0
7.0
13.6
69 CAL 263-264
0.00084
61.11
59 CAL 137-138
0.00071
33.00
13.2
14.4 N 16.1
67 CAL 72
0.00227
66.00
14.1
68 OKL 16
0.00067
26.66
16.6
-
Loess (Bonny Dam, Colo.)
0.00074
6.16
17.3
67 CAL 106
0.00071
30.86
17.G
18.0
-
2.0
13.6
12.4
17.3
---
14.6
8.0 21.1
Loess (Trenton, Nebr.)
0.00076
14.0
4.69
19.0 20.6 18.8
N
20.0
69 CAL 248
0.00070
30.00
20.2
68 OKL 42
0.00091
18.76
20.4
67 CAL 166
0.00092
30.40
21.6
69 G A L 130-131
0.00038
16.00
23.1
67 G A L 139
0.00149
16.66
24.8
26.6
67 CAL 162
0.00061
38.88
28.8
21.1
67 GAL 162
0.00029
66.66
30.0
20.2
;P
67 CAL 173
0.00048
13.33
32.3
27.2
F
68 ARK 146
0.00014
4.16
37.2
67 CAL 112
0.000 17
6.43
40.9
34.6
%
67 CAL 123
0.00063
11.10
43.2
32.8
67CAL
2
0.00020
8.33
46.4
41.4
f 3
67 CAL 206
0.00013
8.33
49.3
46.9
Kaolin (N.F)
0.00029
3.36
49.6
Kaolin (EPK)
0.00007
2.86
61.2
42.0
N
48.0
Fuller's mirth
0.00048
16.66
109.0
76.0
N
80.0
N
23.4 12.4
21.9
N
26.9
F
31.0 29.4
N
N
36.0
33.6
f
5a
174
1 Fundamentals for t,he investigation of seepage
which depends on the hydraulic conductivity of the 1ayer.Thus the comparison of the stored amounts has to be made after the development of the dynamic equilibrium, hence the determination of specific yield can be reduced to the calculation of the difference between the areas of two soilmoisture retention curves (Fig. 1.4-16). Let us indicate two positions of the water table with sufhes 1 and 2, respectively. It is quite indifferent, which is the original condition, because the specific yield must have the same numerical value whether lowering or raising the water table. To f d i 3 the condition required by the definition, the distance between the two water tables is equal to unity. The stored amount of water in a column having a cross section of unit area can be easily calculated above the datum. Executing the calculation for both positions of the water table, and forming the difference of the two determined values, the physically correct specific yield is obtained:
because 21
- z2 = 1.
Comparing Eq. (1.4-31) with Eq. (1.4-29), i t is readily seen that t,he difference of the two expressions to be integrated is equal to the water retention capacity. Although this concept is theoretically correct, difticulties are raised, however, when it ix applied in the practice. The t w o most important diffi-
c Fig. 1.4-16. Calculation of the specific yield from the difference of two soil-moisture retention curves
1.4 Balance of the ground water
175
culties are caused by the hysteresis of the soil-moisture retention curve and by the time lag between the modification of the water table and the final development of the dynamic equilibrium. Further problems are encountered when the unsaturated zone is layered, but details of this will not be discussed now. As it was explained in Chapter 1.3, the relationship between tension and water content is not unambiguous, owing to the phenomenon called hysteresis. Dynamic equilibrium develops at a lower position, if the soil-moisture zone is wetted from the direction of the water table, while the highest curve can be achieved if the zone had been completely saturated previously and drained vertically later. Between these extreme positions the balanced condition can develop a t any elevation. In Fig. 1.4-17 four different cases are represented:
Fig. 1.4-17. Influence of hysteresis on the specific yield
176
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
(a) A wetting process is followed by further riee of the water table, thus both balanced conditions are characterized by the lower stretch of the hysteresis loop. The curves are pardel, and their distance is unity, equal to the modification of the water table. (b) The original wnditwn w m achieved by drainage, and the lowering of the water table is investigated. Both soil-moisture retention curves follow the upper branch of the hysteresis loop, thus their distance is equal to case (a). (c) After wetting the soil-moisture zone,the water table is lowered once again. The lower limit of hysteresis describes the initial condition, and the upper one characterizes the final state. Thus the difference between the two areas of the retention curve is smaller than that calculated from the average curves. Theoretically the difference can also be negative, but in this case the upper stretch of the hysteresis curve is never achieved; the dynamic equilibrium develops at an intermediate position, hence the lower limit of the calculated difference is zero. (d) The case opposite to (c) is the rise of the water table in a previously drained system. Now the final state is characterized with a low retention curve, and the initial condition with a high one. The result is also a decrease of the difference between the two areas, and its lower limit can be again zero.
Further special cases may also be expected (e.g. wetting of the soil-moisture zone previously, and rise of the water table afterwarrds due to infiltration from the surface) when the distance between the initial and final retention curves is greater than unity, its upper limit being the sum of the change of the water table and the thickness of the hysteresis loop. It is obviously very difficult to investigate each of the above processes separately, when the difference between the actual and average values of the specific yield is to be determined. Only one possible way can be proposed: to accept the specific yield calculated from the average soil-moisture retention curves, and to neglect the influence of hysteresis. Realizing the uncertainty introduced in this way, some further approximations can be applied to derive a formula amenable to mathematical treatment, and suitable for describing the relationship between water retention capacity and the physical parameters of soil. When analysing the soil-moisture curve, it was shown that the relationship between tension and moisture content in the adhesive zone can be well approximated with a hyperbola of sixth order [see Eq. (1.3-24)]. At this very steep stretch, the curves belonging to theinitial and the final state practically cover each other (Fig. 1.4-18). Accepting the use of the average curve (without hysteresis) for the characterization of both conditions (before and after the modification of the water table), the difference of the area8 covered by the retention curves can be calculated a,s the free gravitat i m l porosity at the adhesive zone multiplied with the change of the elevation of the water table. The latter being equal to unity, if the purpose is the determination of the specific yield or water retention capacity, the only remaining problem is to select the numerical value suitable for the characterization of both water content and gravitational porosity at high tension.
1.4 Balance of the ground water
177
. surface
Fig. 1.4-18. Sketch for the interpretation and calculation of the water retention capacity
It can be proposed that the parameter considered in the calculation should be that specific amount of adhesive soil moisture, which belongs to the highest capillary rise. The water retention capacity can thus be calculated by substituting the possible highest capillary rise [see Eq. (1.3-28)] into Eq. (1.3-25):
because
h,,,,
1 - n a . = 0.11 --, n Dh
I%(
or the same parameter expressed with the rate of saturation: so = 3.6 x 10-3
;
[l n)518
-
(1.4-33)
In Fig. 1.4-19 the relationship given by Eq. (1.4-32) is compared with the measured data listed in Tables 1.4-3 and 1 . 4 4 , and represented in Figs 1.4-8 and 1.4-15. The comparison shows that the proposed equation provides an acceptable and reasonable compromisebetween the various meaaurements, giving the lower limit of data measured with column drainage (which is acceptable considering the development of the capillary zone), but running above the centrifuge moisture equivalent. At the same time it affords an easily applicable method for the calculation in practice of the water retention capacity and specific yields as the ficnction of the physical parameters (n,Dh, a) of soil. 12
178
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
effective diameter, Dh [em/ Fig. 1.4-19. Comparison of the proposed theoretical value of water retention capacity with meesured data
Naturally, the time lag preceding the development of the dynamic equilibrium also disturbs the direct application of the parameter calculated from Eq. (1.4-32). I n a permeable layer, the ratio of the amount of water drained or stored at the beginning of the process is relatively high; only a few percent of specific yield occurs in the later period, when the water has t o be transferred through the upper part of the column, where the unsaturated conductivity is very small owing to the low saturation. In fine grained material the hydraulic conductivity is relatively low, therefore the whole process is considerably prolonged. Figures 1.4-1 1 and 1.4-12 give sufficient information about the magnitude of the expected time lag, although it is also mentioned in the literature that the delay will be longer if the balance is achieved by wetting the unsaturated zone than in the case of drainage (Smith, 1933).
1.4.3 Analysis of horizontal ground-water flow for the determination of the vertical water exchange The second component of Eq.(1.4-10) to be investigated is the horizontal ground-water flow. For a complete study of this movement, the knowledge of some basic concepts of seepage hydraulics is necessary, which will be dis-
1.4 Balance of the ground water
179
cussed only later on in this book. This very simple form of flow can be analysed, however, if some approximative hypotheses are accepted as starting conditions: 1. Seepage velocity is linearly proportional to the hydraulic gradient [Darcy’s law, see Eq. (1.1-9)]; 2. The flow is horizontal, therefore, the velocity is constant along a vertical section, hence the numerical value of velocity can be calculated as a function of the slope of the water table (Dupuit’s hypothesis). Following Kamensky’s (1940, 1943) investigations, let us consider the water balance of an elementary part of the gravitational ground-water space, whose lower boundary is a horizontal impervious layer, and which is bordered in the horizontal plane by a rectangular oblong (Fig. 1.4-20). There are five observation wells for recording the position of the water table, one inside the oblong, and four outside its borders. The wells form a rectangular cross, and the borders are fixed that way that they divide the
12*
180
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
distances between the internal and external wells into halvee. Let b, indicate the length of the different sides [ b , = b, = 1
L
1
1
. . . b,
(Ax, + Ax4) ;
Y
b, = b, = - ( d X , + dX,) the time dependent areas of the vertical cross 2
sections at the borders are then
where H,(t) indicates the elevation of the water level in the i-th well above the impervious lower boundary at the time t. The average slope of the water table can also be calculated from the data of the observation wells:
I , = AHlX ( t ) ; I , = AH,, ( t ) . 4 A% ’
(1.4-351
where dHi,(t) is the difference of water levels registered at time t in the i-th well and in the centre well, respectively [AH,(t) = H,(t) - H,(t); . . . * * AH444 = H4(t) - Hp(t)l. Accepting the two basic hypotheses mentioned previously, the flow rates crossing the vertical boundaries of the investigated prism can be calculated a5 follows:
-
There is, however, a H t h bordering surfme of the prism, through which a flow can develop, i.e. the waater table. Its area is
A = b, b, ;
(1.4-37)
and the flow rate can be expressed here as the product of the area and the specific vertical water exchange [ ~ ( t ) ] :
&o(t)= Ae(t)*
( 1.4-38)
Investigating a finite time period (At = t, - t,; and t, > t,), the water balance of the prism requires that the product of the elementary time unit (dt) and the sum of flow rates summarized for the entiretimeperiod, At, should be equal to the change of the stored water amount, which is equal to the change of the position of the water table [characterized with the recorded water level (or ground-water depth) in the central well AHot = HO(t3)- Ho(t,)] mul-
181
1.4 Balance of the ground water
tiplied with the horizontal area of the prism and the specific yield of the layer:
%[ &o(t)+ Z & i ( t )1dt 4
tl
= m o t An,
-
(1.4-39)
4-1
[Eq. (1.4-39) is a special form of Boussinesq's differential equation (which will be discussed in detail in Chapter 5.4) expressed with bite differences.] Substituting the time-dependent variables with their averages, which can be regarded aa the values of the function in question belonging to a point of time tz within the investigated period (tl < tz < t3), and applying transmissibility [which parameter is equal to the product of the depth of flow and conductivity
the simplified form of Eq. (1.4-39) can be given as follows:
The geometrical parameters (bi and x l ) and those calculated from water level records ( H , and H o t )can be determined with relatively high accuracy. The methods applicable for the calculation of the specific yield were already discussed in the previous section. Thus transmissibility is the remaining variable the knowledge of which is necessary, if Eq. (1.4-40) is to be used for the direct calculation of the time-dependent water exchange through the water table. If the position of the impervious lower boundary is known, only hydraulic conductivity has to be determined as a basic data. The equation can be also used for the calculation of transmissibility by substituting recorded water level data of a period when the vertical flow was surely negligible, E(t) = 0, (e.g. in winter, when frozen top layer hindered both infiltration and evaporation). If the cross of the observation wells is fixed so that one line of wells (1, 0, 3) is parallel to the dip of the water table, and the other (2, 0 , 4 , being perpendicular to the former) is parallel to its strike, there is no flow in the second direction. The data of the wells with even numbers (2, 4) need not be taken into account, and the investigation can be restricted to the analysis of the water balance within a stripe of unit width:
There are several other proposals to simplify the calculation, e.g. to choose very short At periods and substitute the time-dependent variables with their values belonging to the beginning of the period (Kamensky, 1943); to use
.
182
1 Fundementah for the investigation of seepage
continuous time-dependent functions and divide the solution into three parts, because in this case the mathematical functions approximating the separated parts can be determined in closed form by integration (Szdkely, 1973); to give graphical interpretation of the solution with finite differences (Lebediev, 1963), etc. Other authors have made efforts to generalize the
Fig. 1.4-21. Map of the Koml6si Imre Ground-waterResearch Station
method, making it applicable for an existing irregular network of observation wells, when the geometrical conditions used as the basis of the derivation are not satisfied (Rowe, 1955; Major, 1972b). It is a general opinion that the solution of water balance equations of this type with computers does not raise any special problem and, therefore, the most suitable form of the relationship has to be determined always according to the local conditions (distribution of wells within the network, type and reliability of the recorded data, information concerning the depth of flow, hydraulic conductivity and transmissibility, etc.). This is the reavon why the theoretical basis of this method will not be dealt with further on, but a practical example will be presented here, to illustrate the special features of vertical water exchange between soil moisture and gravitational ground-water zones.
183
1.4 Balance of the ground water
In an experimental area (KomMsi Imre Ground-water Research Station, Hungary), where long ground-water records were available from several wells, detailed investigations were made by applying the method described in the previous paragraphs (Major, 1972b). The layer containing the shallow ground water is a relatively homogeneous h e sand, the transmissibility of which is known from pumping tests. The specific yield of the sand was estimated on the basis of the water retention curves measured in the field with neutron probes. The surface is plain, covered partly with forest surrounding grassy clearings, as indicated in the map (Fig. 1.4-21). Four areas were chosen, for which the water balance of six-day intervals were determined from the records covering a period of 18 years (1954-71). Some characteristic data of the areas and the annual sums for the decade 1961-70 of the two components of vertical water exchange (i.e. I , infiltration to the groundwater and ET, evapotranspiration replenished from the ground water) are listed in Table 1.4-5. Table 1.4-5. Annual values of the components of vertical water exchange, determined for various areas by using the water balance method
I B l c
Denotation of the arem
Extension of the area [m2]
10 000
260 000
13 640
9 200
89
78
68
43
Rate of the forested area
1% 1
1961 1962 1963 1964 1966 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970
188 88 148 66 131 261 163 4 137 191
319 303 287 242 199 264 346 384 366 330
196 112 183 103 191 313 231 30 188 292
260 196 196 146 146 230 286 226 219 266
346 236 319 307 460 632 472 212 291 386
139 27 19 13 16 43 37 32 60 89
277 260 347 362 669 604 611 306 346 386
40 22 18 16 0 30 14 16 36 62
42 1 478 616 669 662 844 618 384 693 690
To characterize the seasonal fluctuation of the components of the vertical water exchange, the monthly averages of both I , and E T , were calculated from the data. As an example, the parameters determined for area A using a period of twelve years (1960-71) are represented in Fig. 1.4-22. As a further example, the monthly data of an arbitrarily chosen year (1963) are listed in Table 1.4-6 for the areas A and B, and the basic data of the same year, calculated for six-day intervals, are also represented in Fig. 1.4-23 for the area A .
184
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage 60 50
40
30
za la
0
Nor Jan. March May July Sept Fig. 1.4-22. Monthly averages of I , and ET, calculated for a 12-year period (1960-71) from the data of area A
There is a special condition characterizing the area investigated: just before the beginning of the recorded period a young forest was planted there, thus the influence of the growing trees on the hydrological cycle can be well observed. Since practically there is no surface run-off from the area because of the very flat and sandy surfwe, and since the change of moisture content Table 1.4-6. Monthly values of the components of vertical water exchange for 1963, determined for areits A and B Month
Monthly preoipiestion
Positive monthly amretion 1,
forarea A
1962
November December
[-I
I
forarea B
-
-
0.76
2.24
72.2 66.2 46.7 36.6 39.9 44.8 30.7 76.3 80.8 26.2
16.10 17.08 76.97 37.09 0.74
21.43 24.66 78.68 49.99 3.47
616.6
147.74
86.6 24.0
Negative monthly accretion ETI C m l
for area -4
13.67 7.43
I-KEZT 2.80 2.46
1963
JmUery Februery March April
W Y June JdY Ausust Ekptember October hnUd
EUm
2.60
182.94
-
0.86
1.26
-
-
-
14.94 66.77 76.03 61.27 33.63 22.19
8.99 67.37 69.19 32.81 20.67 10.12
287.18
195.26
1.4 Balance of the ground water
Fig. 1.4-23. Annual tluctuation 01 I g ana
~
2 CaiCuIaTda ' ~
185
xor six-aaymmrvmu (ivoo;
area A )
over a year-long period is negligible, it can be supposed that the difference of annual precipitation and the yearly sum of infiltration to the water table is equal to the amount of water stored temporarily either by interception, or in the soil-moisture zone, and evaporated from this position. Thus the annual actual evapotranspiration can be calculated as the sum of this difference and the vertical withdrawal from the ground-waterspace. These parameters are listed in Table 1.4-7 together with their averages calculated for periods of six years. The averages clearly indicate the increasing trend of actual evapotranspiration, corresponding to the growth of the forest.
186
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
Table 1.4-7. Annual values of precipitation and actual evapotranspirationfor a period of 18 years A
m
water level in the central obl3ervation well below the wvface
Year
€ I
I4 Ann.
1964 1966 1966 1967 1968 1969
683 614 664 622 491 626
1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1966
662 421
1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971
844 618 384 693 690 429
778 616 669 662
2 g
146 184 208 178 146
2 2
83
2
4
132 188 88
148 66 131 261 163 3 137 191 69
2
2
2 $:
436 430 346 444 346 442 432 233 390 468 603 621 683 466 381 466 499 370
2
3
3
2
$!
189 160 240 187 2 34 162 219 319 303 287 242 199 264 346 384 366 330 411
2
2
2
'?
$$
626 690 686 631 679 604
I
Av.
392 382 362 369 378 409
4
*
846 720
422 399 431 429 436 403
847 811 766 821 928 781
362 316 376 390 348 37 1
661 662 693
2 8
2
766
2 3
cI)
Some conclusions which can be drawn from the summarized data of the analyzed example are the following: It is desirable to select a homogeneous area for the investigation of the ground-water balance. Homogeneity should be ensured for each element of the processes affecting the regime of the ground water [structure of the water bearing layer (permeability, transmissibility, specific yield); surface conditions (type of soil, covering vegetation, slopes influencing the development of surface run-off); climatic factors (precipitation, temperature, radiation, wind velocity), etc.]. In areas covered by inhomogeneous vegetation, only the average characteristics of the vertical water exchange can be determined instead of the actual influence of the different plants. At the same time, if these average values can be correlated with the ratio of the areal extension of the various types of vegetation, the data can be used to characterize the effect of a special cover (in the example presented the influence of forest can be investigated). The water balance is influenced not only by the type of the covering plants, but also b y their phase of growth. Thus the development of trees gradually
1.4 Balance of the ground water
187
decreases the vertical recharge of the ground water; this is the result of the increase of interception and soil-moisture storage. These two components are readily available for evaporation and transpiration, thus the part of evapotranspiration originating from interception and soil moisture is increased by the growth of trees. At the same time, the amount of water withdrawn from the gravitational ground water to replenish the evaporated and transpired soil moisture is also increased, probably aa a result of the development of the root structure. Hence the increase of the actual evapo15 transpiration is very rapid (in the example it surpaases the value of 10 mm/year). At the beginning of the investigated period the yearly amount of precipitation was equal to the actual evapotranspiration, but (owing to the increase of the latter) at the end of the period the average yearly deficit was greater than 200 mm. I n the investigated area, where the water table practically had no slope at all, and thus there had been no horizontal groundwater flow, the development of the forest lowered the water table and created a depression cone. The deficit i n water balance of the forest is replenished now by the ground-water flow developing along the slopes of the cone, and the surrounding arem recharge the ground water of the forest. A very rapid decrease of ET,.can be observed as the ratio of the forested area decreases within the investigated area. Such very strong effect can only be expected, if there is no ground-water withdrawal at all under the clearings. This supposition is supported by the circumstance described in the previous paragraph: the water table is considerably lowered under the forest, and thus the vertical flow directed upwards can convey only negligible amounts of water from the ground water to the shallow root zone of the clearings. It can be stated, therefore, a~ a general rule, that the depth of the water table (measured from the lower boundary of the active root zone) is one of the most important factors influencing the amount of water withdrawn vertically from the ground water. Infiltration reaching the water table shows an increasing trend with the decrease of the rate of forested areas. The most likely cause of this change is the smaller interception at clearings. At the same time, it is also probable that the moisture content is generally smaller at the end of dry periods under a forest due to greater evapotranspiration by the trees; thus, during a rainy period, a larger soil-moisture storage occurs above the water table in the forest, than outside. It can be concluded that I , is a function of both the infiltration through the surface and the available storage capacity of the soilmoisture zone. A regular seasonal fluctuation of both infiltration and ground-water withdrawal can be observed, which naturally follows the fluctuation of the climatic 1)arameters.Under the conditions of the investigated area, there is practically 110 vertical ground-water recharge during the summer half-year (from May to October). Infiltration to the water table originates mostly from autumn and winter precipitation, and reaches its maximum with a time lag after the melting of the snow. The seasonal fluctuation of vertical drainage has R more regular pattern, than infiltration. The difference between the actual graph in Fig. 1.4-22 and a sine curve used generally to describe the fluc-
-
188
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
tuation of climatic parameters (which has its maximum in June and its minimum in December) can be.wel1 explained by the fact that before the maximum of potential evapotranspiration the water table has a higher position than its average, therefore, a surplus withdrawal occurs as compared with the sine curve. Similarly, a deficit can be observed at late summer, because of the greater depth of the water table. It has to be emphasized that both the amount and the seasonal pattern of I, and E T , also depend on the type and the phase of growth of the ctovering vegetation. Thus the conclusions (especially quantitative statements) are valid only for the investigated case (a gradually growing forest with a few percent of clearings). For other surface conditions only rough qualitative approximations can be given on the basis of the example analyzed. However, several of the results summarized here may be applicable for the better characterization of hydraulic processes developing in flow fields influenced by accretion.
1.4.4 Interpretation and determination of the charaderistic curve of the ground-water balance
Returning to Eqs (1.4-9) and (1.4-lo), the remaining component to be investigated is the vertical water exchange between the soil moisture and ground-water zones. It wm already shown in the previous section, that its components (infiltration to, and vertical withdrawal from, the ground water) is a function of the depth of the water table below the surface. In addition to this parameter, both I, and E T , depend on some other variables, which can be divided into three main groups: (a) Climatic conditions: amount and annual distribution of precipitation and potential evaporation. The latter includes the effects of temperature, humidity, wind velocity, etc. (b) Characteristics of the surface: angle and direction of slopes, method of cultivation, vegetation covering the surface, etc. The resultant of some of these effects can be measured by surface run-off. (c) Behaviour of the soil within the unsaturated zone: geological character and structure of the upper lying layer, water retention capacity and the instantaneous soil-moisture content of the top soil. Thus the two function, in general form, characterizing the parameters in question are as follows:
Ig=
( m ; climate; surface; soil);
(1.4-42)
E T g = G2 ( m ; climate; surface; soil). The factors describing the influence of climate, surfaee and soil are timeand space-dependent variables. It has been mentioned that instead of the examination of their modification in time the values averaged for a suficiently
189
1.4 Balance of the ground water
long period are used. Similarly, equalization of local effects can be assumed in a large area, thus the individual parameters cun also be averaged over the area. Regarding all variables, except the depth of the water table, 88 constants for a given area, and describing these by their average over the period investigated, Eq. ( 1 . 4 4 2 ) can be simplified: 1, = f Am); ET, = fi(m).
(1.4-43) '
These two relationships - their parameters in any case, but perhaps their structure as well - are functions of the natural conditions (climate, surface, soil), which were regarded as constants for a given site. Some general rules describing the character of the functions can be, however, determined. Infiltration through the surface is the difference of precipitation and the sum of evaporation, run-off and retention on the surface. According to Eq. (1.4-2), i t can be divided into two parts, one stored above the water table, and the other part reaching the ground water. The ratio of these two values depends on the storage capacity of the unsaturated zone influenced by the physical parameters of the soil and the instantaneous water content of the upper layer at the time of infiltration. Although the amount of the stored water changes from case to c a e and, therefore, the amount of water stored in a year also varies every year, an average of the yearly retention of water in the soil-moisture zone can be calculated. Thus graphs can be constructed representing the average yearly storage for various soils as a function of the depth of the water table (Fig. 1.4-24).
For a given soil and in an average year a series of parallel curves can be obtained graphically to represent the relationship between infiltrating recharge storage rapacity of the dry layer rm3/m3J 0
0.0J
alo
at5
azo
0.25S(Z)
Fig. 1.4-24. Characterization of the storage capacity of the soil-moisture zone function of depth
190
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
and the depth of the water table. The parameter of the individual curves is the infiltration through the surface, which value gives the intersection of the inEltration curve with the horizontal axis (Fig. 1.4-25). To make the mathematical treatment of the relationship more convenient, the curve can be approximated by an exponential function, whose mymptote is parallel to the vertical axis; the position of the asymptote depends
m#z Fig. 1.4-25. Relationship between idltration and the depth of the water table
on the infiltration through the surface. I n a special case (indicated in the figure with a dotted line) the asymptote is the vertical axis itself. The water balance of ground water is very complicated when the water table is near the surface, since very small precipitations may also exert an influence. Another reason why the upper few decimeters of the soil should be disregarded in the characterization of the process of infiltration is the undisturbed structure of the cultivated and the active root zone, as mentioned already in Chapter 1.3. It is advisable, therefore, to fix another point of the curve, than its intersection with the surface. For this purpose the average infiltrating yearly recharge ( I , ) has to be determined at a given level (m,). Thus the final mathematical form of the investigated relationship is ( 1.4-44) I g ( m )= ( I , - a ) exp [ - a ( m - m , ) ] + a ; where the parameters ( I , , m,, a , a ) are functions of the natural conditions. The curve representing the relationship between the amount of ground-water withdrawn and evaporated or transpired, and the depth of the water table is very similar to the curve described previously. This also decreases monotonously with depth. It is evident that the amount is approximately equal to the potential evapotranspiration originating below the land surface, when the water table is near the surface (its average depth 1)eing practically zero).
1.4 Balance of the ground water
191
Actual evapotranspiration (ET,+ ETg)decreases with increasing depth of water table, and i t becomes constant at a given depth, supposed to be 2-3 m. under temperate conditions. In the case of such a water table, actual evapotranspiration is only 50-70% of the potential value, depending on the type of soil and vegetation. The total actual evapotranspiration must be divided into two parts; one supplied from the soil moisture and the other
/
/ /
I I ETw+ E G
I
I
pP
i
41
I
6
I
-X-
0
++
calculated from /ysimeefer dar3 (Najor) Blaney bare steppe oasis Kovda steppe Altovszkij Konopljancev W. Friedrich Juhisz J. (ralrulated)
1
Fig. 1.4-26. Relationship between the amount withdrawn from ground water to replenish evaporated and transpired soil moisture and the depth of t,he water table
from ground water (Fig. 1.4-26). The latter, being of interest from the mpect of the present investigation, is also a function of the depth of the water table, and there exists a level from where no water can rise to the root zone. The relationship between the depth of ground water and evaporated losses can also be approximated with an exponential function of a structure similar to Eq. (1.4-44): ETg(m)= ETo exp [ - p ( m - m,)]. (1.445) The process of evaporation depends on the capillarity of the soil, the tension between its grains and water, and the influence of vegetation. Thus the parameters of Eq. (1.4-45) (ET,, m,, p) are also functions of the natural conditions. It is necessary to note here that in lysimeters with constant water table a different character of the ET,(m) function was observed (Fig. 1.4-27) (Major, 1972a). In this case, however, the influenceof the fluctuating water table and the relationship between this latter process and the seasonal variation of ET, is left out of consideration. Supposing a regular fluctuation
192
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
0
20
Fig. 1.4-27. The ETg(m) function determined from date measured in lysimeters with constant water table
in both the position of the water table and evapotranspiration, which can be approximated with a sine function, the expected ETg(m)function was recalculated from the lysimeter data, and is also represented in Fig. 1.4-26. In this investigation it was also considered that the lysimeter was not covered by vegetation, thus the depth had to be measured below the root zone, and the thickness of this zone also increased with the depth of the water table. The agreement between this curve and that calculated from Eq. (1.445)is acceptable. It must be mentioned that the basic idea of the present analysis is only the qualitative characterization of the processes. The principles concluded in this way do not alter, if another equation is used for the description of the relationships existing between the variables. The character of the relationship supposed to exist between the average depth of the water table and the anwunt of ground-water withdrawn vertically is also supported by the water quality data. It is evident that in a ground-water basin the concentration of salts dissolved in the ground water is higher if the water table is near the surface, because the horizontal inflow is balanced by vertical drainage, and the salts transported by the water there accumulate. It is also expected that the salt concentration has to be proportional to the amount of water drained vertically. Indeed, the data collected by Hazen (1892) at Tafilalet in Morocco fit a very similar curve (Fig. 1.4-28) as the one shown in Fig. 1.4-26. Hazen’s data also indicate that the thickness of the layer influenced by evaporation is greater in the arid zone of Morocco, than it is in the temperate climatic zone, although it is also known that this depth depends not only on the climatic conditions, but also on the capillary properties of the soil.
1.4 Balance of the ground water
193
concen:rs?ml; grams uer llfer ll?
0
10
( total oissolved sohds) 20 30 40 50
60
Fig. 1.4-28. The amount of total ealt content in the und water aa a function of the depth of the water ta%
According to Eqs (1.4-9) and (1.4-lo), vertical water exchange is characterized by the difference between recharge and water withdrawal. Both variables are given aa a function of the average ground-water depth, thus their difference can also be plotted against the same depth. This is the characteristic curve of the ground-water balance (Fig. 1.4-29). At the level where the curve intersects the vertical axis, recharge is equal to vertical drainage (equilibrium level). The water table can only develop at this level if there is no horizontal flow, or the inflow is q w l to the outflow. Above this level the zone of horizontally recharged ground water can be found. In the case of such water tables vertical drainage is grbater than recharge, and the differenceis balanced by the surplus of horizontal inflow compared with the outflow. Reversed, when the invwtigatd column i s drained by horizontal flow (outflow being greater than inflow), this difference should be balanced by the surplus of recharge from infiltration compared with the amount of ground-water withdrawn vertically; thus the water table can only develop below the equilibrium level. If ground water had no horizontal movement, its table would develop everywhere at the equilibrium level, thus approximately parallel to the 13
194
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
infiltration [mm] to0 1-
vertical drainage [ m m l
300 400 500 I I I difference of infitration and vertical drainage C mmJ + 5a a -50 -{an -150 -200 -250
50
100.
0
I
200 I
-
Fig. 1.4-29. Characteristic curve representing ground-water balance as a function of the depth of the water table
surface
I
At
Fig. 3.4-30. Development of water table under a sloping surface
195
1.4 Balance of the ground water
surface. The terrain, however, is not a horizontal plain, hence the ground water would have a gradient, if its table were parallel to the slope of the surface. A horizontal ground-water flow would then be started by this gradient in accordance with the permeability of the layers involved, rising the water table in the valleys and lowering it under the hilly areas. Regarding this process in a static way, it would be expected that the water table becomes horizontal in every ground-water catchment. Water tables are actually neither parallel t o the surface nor horizontal, but rather follow the slope of the terrain; thus a dynamic balance develops as shown in Fig. 1.4-30. At higher areas the water table sinks below the equilibrium level, thus fotal salt content 0 0
,
~
"
"
"
/ "
"
'
"
'
2 " "
L %J 3
tbe iota1 salt confenfis negltgible in profiles 0 and @ in profi/e I, @ it is pracfica/lly fbe same as in @ %nd Q
0
- i
140-
: :
i
0@ @
CaCO, content in % of the fofal amount of salf 20 30 40 50
I I I
1' p
---.-.-.
e
65 150
490
........... 230 0300 @ --- 300 @
1 3 (8
450 700
Fig. 1.4-31. Relationship between the salt content of the soil and t,he position of the wmter teble
13*
196
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
ground water is recharged by surplus infiltration. This amount of water will be transported by horizontal ground-water flow towards lower situated areas, and a dynamic balance will develop a t the levels where the recharge and discharge summarized within the catchment are equalized. The development of this dynamic balance is also indicated by the chemicd composition of the soils. Where the water table lies a t a great depth, the soil is leached, the total amount of salts is very low and none of the well soluble sodium is found in the soil profile, whereas above a high water table surplus evaporation causes salt accumulation, as shown not only by the high salt content, but also by the high Na/Ca ratio (Fig. 1.4-31) (Vhrallyai, 1967, 1970).
A further special point of the characteristic curve of ground-water balance i s its maximum, which divides the range of the possible water table into two zones. Utilizing the ground-water resources continuously a new equilibrium
rn depth b l o w the surf&e K m l Fig. 1.4-32. Classification of shallow ground water according to the iduencing effects
1.4 Balance of the ground water
197
can only develop in such cases when the original water table was above this level, because at greater depths the difference between natural recharge and vertical drainage decreases with depth. Assuming the m, parameter in Eqs (1.444) and (1.4-45) t o be equal to the depth of the equilibrium level, the depth of the maximum point can also be calculated (Fig. 1.4-32): 1 BET, m=m,+In 8-a aI,-a or (when a = 0 and therefore ET, is equal to I, a t the equilibrium level): ml=m,,+-ln-. 1 B-a
B a
(1.4-46)
The numerical data of the characteristic curve of the ground-water balance can be determined by lysimeters, measuring the recharge infiltrating to various levels and also evaporation from the water tables of M e r e n t depths (Altovsky and Konopljancev, 1954). When using lysimeter data, the fluctuation of the natural water table should also be taken into consideration. Another possible method of measuring the characteristic curve is the construction of closed ground-water columns (Kovhcs, 1966a). I n the absence of measured data, the curve can be approximated by the use of the relationship representing the connection between the depth and the fluctuation of ground-water (Kovhcs, 195%). Comparing the data collected from semi-arid moderate climatic zones (see Fig. 1.4-26), the average depth of the equilibrium level (naturally influenced by the local climatic, soil and surface conditions) was estimated to be around 2 m in Central Europe (Hungary). This value is in good agreement with the observations of the salt content of soils showing that salt accumulation can be expected in this area, if the average depth of the water table is less than 2 m from the surface (Vhrallyai, 1967, 1970; Szabolcs et al., 1969a, 1969b). It has been mentioned that this characteristic depth is probably greater in arid zones (see Fig. 1.4-28), whereas in humid regions the same parameter may be considerably smaller. This latter supposition is proved by Fig. 1.4-33, which represents a characteristic curve of groundwater balance determined for a swampy area in Byelorussia (Lavrov et al., 1972). Ground-water balance was characterized by the yearly averages in the foregoing. Sometimes the analysis of periods shorter than a year may become necessary. I n such cases the monthly or seasonal mean values of the parameters (depth of water table, evaporation, infiltration) must be determined. Assuming that the general character of the relationship does not vary with the specified part of the year investigated, only the numerical values of the parameters do, the same equation can be used applying a factor expressing the ratio of the parameters (infiltration and evaporation) belonging to the investigated interval (e.g. a month) and the yearly average (Fig. 1.4-34). The final point in the present discussion is the explanation of the way of application of the characteristic curve in seepage hydraulics.
198
1 Fundamentals for the investigation of seepage
inflltra fion to grotind water
I-
tflfll
vertical drainage of grotind wd:er EG t m m l
Fig. 1.4-33. Characteristic curve of ground-water balance for a swampy area in Byelorussia
difference between infiltration and evaparation (Is- E 51 5
B 8 lE
b P
1
0
sa
1.0
3
20
9
L
-2
P
k
sQ
3.0
%
4.0
Fig. 1.4-34. Seasonalfluctuationof the characteristiccurve of ground-waterbelance
When facing the task of the investigation of a ground-water flow influenced by accretion, a method must be found for the numerical determination of the E ( X ) function describing the surface effects. It is already evident from the foregoing that both infiltrating recharge and vertical drainage caused by evapotranspiration and, consequently, also their resultant are functions of the depth of the water table below the surface. It is also an obvious statement that the change of the water table
1.4 Balance of the ground water
199
produced by the artificial recharging or draining of a system cauyes surplus evaporation and infiltration, respectively, along the influenced flow space, and these surplus surface effects are proportional to the change of groundwater depth. The surplus surface effects can be numerically determined using the characteristic curve of ground-water balance. The latter represents the relationship between accretion and, the depth of ground water. Thus the difference of the values belonging to the original and the modified water tables yields the surplus effects in question. This way of calculation is valid in both cases, if the water table was originally at equilibrium level and, therefore, the surface effect pertaining to the Btarting condition was zero, and if there was already some surface effect present influencing the groundwater space tjefore the changing of its level, and the original ground-water table wazj at tin elevation different from that of the equilibrium. The detailed description of the method proposed for the hydraulic consideration of accretion will be discussed in Section 4.1.3,where the practical hydraulic application of the characteristic curve derived now from hydrological data will be presented. References to Chapter 1.4 ALTOVSICY, M. E. and KONOPLANCEV, A. A. (1954): Methodological Handbook for the 1nvestigat)ion of the Ground-water Regime (in Russian). Gosgeoizdat, Moscow. ASTM (1958): Procedures for Testing Soils. American Society for Testing Materkk, Philadelphia. A. (1911): Plasticity of clays (in German). Overeatt fr. evemka UT ATTERBERO, Kungl. Lantbruksakademkm Handlinger och Tidakon, 60. 1911. BEAR, J. (1972): Dynamics of Fluids in Porous Media. Elsevier, New York, London, Amsterdam. BEAR,J., ZASLAVSKY,D. and IRMAY, S. (1968): Physical Principles of Water Percolation and Seepage. Arid Zone Research, UNESCO, Paris. G. (1967): Practical Investigation of Subsurface Waters (in French). CASTAQNY, Dunod, Paris. DE WIEST, J. &I. (1968): Flow through Porous Media Chapter 2. Porosity and Permeability of Natural Materials by S. N. Davis. Academic Prees, New Ymk-London. HAZEN, A. (1892): Experiments upon the Purification of Sewage and Water at Lawrence Experimental Station. Health Publication of Ma.gaachueetta State Board, NO. 1. 1889-1891. JOHNSON, A. I., PRILL, R. C. and MORRIS, D. A. (1963): Specific Yield-Column Drainage and Centrifuge Moisture Content. Geological Survey, Water-mpply Paper, 1662-A. Washington. KAMENSKY, Q. N. (1940): Differential Equations of the Nonsteady Ground-water Flow and their Application to Calculate Backwater Effects (in Russian). Izvestiia of Akademii Nauk, USIS'R, No. 4. KAMENSKY.0. N. f1943): PrinciDles of Ground-water Dvnamics lin Russian). Gosgeoltekljz;lat, Modow. ' ~ Z D I A. , (1972): Soil Mechanics (4-th edition) (in Hungarian). Tankonyvkiad6 Budapest. KI~ZDI, A. (1974): Handbook of Soil Mechanics Vol. I. Soil Physics. Elsevier-Akad6miai Kiad6, Amsterdam, Budapest. KINQ,F. H. (1898): Principles and Conditionsof theMovements of Ground Water. 19th Annual Report of US. QS. 1897-98. Koviics, G. (1959a): Determination of the Flow Rate of Ground-water flow on the Basis of Analizing Water Balance (in Hungarian). V'iziigyi Kozlemdnyek, No. 3. KovAcs, G. (1959b): Ground-water Household. ICID Annual Bulletin, New-Delhi,
200
1 Fundamentals for the inveetigation of seepage
KOVACS,G. (1971): Salt Accumulation in Ground Water and in Soil. I A H S Sympoeium cm Qrcyund-wder Pouution, Moecow. KOVACS,G. (1972a): Ground-water Reeources and their Contact with Surf..-water Resources. EUE Seminar on Methodology for the Compilation of Balancse of Water Resources and Needa, B u d a p t , 1972. KOVACS,G. (1972b Asseamnent of Ground-water Re~ources.Sympoeium on Water Resources Planning, e x k o City, 1972. LAVROV,A. P., FADEJEVA, M. V., SACEOK, 0. I. VAXHOVSKY, A. P. and VASILJEV, V. F. (1972): Problems of Underground Water Regimea in Byelorueeian P o W c . UNESCO-IAHS Sympoeium on the Hydrology of Mamh-ridden A r e a , Minek, 1972. LEBEDIEV,A. V. (1961): Investigation of theRegimeand Balance of Ground Water on the Basis of Continuous Observations (in Run~im).Paper in the Volume: Methods of I n v e a t i g a t k and 0 - k in Engineering Geology and Hydrogeology, Gosgeoltekhizdat, M m w . LEBEDIEV,A. V. (1963): Method6 to Inveetigate the Balance of Ground Water (in Russian). Gosgmltekhkdat, Moscow, 1963. MAJOR, P. (1972a): Determination of Infiltration and Evaporation Considering the Capillary Condition of the Covering Layer (Manuscript in Hungarian). SciSntifiO Conierenm of V I T U K I . 1972. &OR, P. (1972b):'Investi ation of Balance Parametere of Ground Watere in Plain6 (in Hungarian). Scientific Repor&, No. 2162. (Manuscript). PRILL, R. C., JOHNSON,A. I. and MORBIE,D. A. (1966): Specso Yield - Laboratory Experiment8 Showing the Efleot of Time on Column Drainage. Geological Survey, Water-eupplyPaper, 1662-B. Washington. ROWE,P. R. 1966): Differenae Approximations to Partial Derivative for Uneven Spacings in the etwork. T r a m a d o m of AGU, 36. SCEOEI&ER, H. (1962): Ground Watere (in French). Masson, PEL&. Srdrr~,W. 0.(1933): Minimum Capillary Rise on Ideal Uniform Soil. P h y s b , May. SMITE, W. O., FOOTE, P. D., BUSANU,P. F. (1931): Capillary Raise in Sands of Uniform Spherical grain^. P h y s b , July. SZABOLCS, I., DARAB,K. and V~ALLYAI, G. (1969a): T h e Tisza Irrigation Syetema and the Fertility of the Soils in the Hungarian Lowland (in Hungarian). Agrokdmiu 4% Talajtan, No. 2. SZABOLCS, I., DAEAB,K. and V~ALLYAI, G. (196913): Alkalization Process Due to Irrigation on the Hungarian Plain. A p k d m i a 4.8 Talajtun, Supplementum. S ~ L Y F. , (1973): Determination of Ground-water A m t i o n and Seepa e Parameters on the Bask of Ground-water Obeervations (in Hungarian). Hidro&iai Rozl h y , No. 6 . TERZAUHI, I(. (1926): Soil Physical Basis of Mechanics of Earth Structures (in German). F. Deuticke, Wien. TERZAunx, K. (1943): Theoretied Soil Mechanice. John Wdey, New York, London, 1943. V~ALLYAI,G. (1967): Salt Acoumulation P'rocea in Soils in the Danube Valley (in Hungarian). Agrokdmia ke Talajtan, 1967. No. 3. VARALLYAI, G. (1970): Salt Movement, Salt Balance and their Importance on Irrigation S tmm on Lowland6 (in Hungarian). Agr6rtudomdnyi Kodemknyek. WO-,~. (1886): Investigation of Water Retention Capacity of Soils (in G m a n ) . Formhungen auf dem Gebiete der Agrikdtur Phyeik.. ZWNXER, F. (1930): Behaviour of Soils in COMection with Water (in German). Handbook of Soil Sciences, Springer, Berlin. Vol. VI.
li
d,
b
Part 2
Dynamic interpretation and determination of hydraulic conductivity in homogeneous loose clastic sediments
I n every case, where the purpose is to describe a special type of movement and to discover the interrelationships of physical processes for the mechanically correct (so-cdled deterministic) characterization of the motion, the detailed investigation of the acting forces is necessarily the first step. There are accelerating and retarding forces forming a balanced system in the case of steady movement. Distinguishing the various types of movement so that in each group the same forces have a dominating role, the limits of the validity zone can be determined, outside of which the motion is affected by other forces. The equilibrium of the accelerating and retarding forces gives an equation in each zone, on the basis of which the correct form of the movement equation can be constructed and even some numerical factors of the latter can also be calculated. The other important step in the theoretical investigation is to find a physical (geometrical) model of the analyzed system. When selecting this model, two contradictory aspects act against each other. The boundaries and structure of the model should be as simple aa possible, t o ensure the mathematical solution of the relevant movement equations. On the other hand, it is necessary to include in the model the largest possible number of parameters from the actual system, because each parameter may describe a special feature of the prototype. Following the determination of the acting forces and the geometrical model, the combination of results provides a conceptual model, which is suitable for the theoretical analysis of the process under investigation. The basic relationships between the interrelated variables may be determined in this way, and the variables having negligible effects can also be selected. The investigation has always t o be finalized with carefully executed experimental research, which serves a dual purpose: firstly it is necessary for the verification of the theoretical relationships, together with the indication of their validity zones, and, secondly some numerical constants of the formulae have to be determined from the data measured. The theoretically derived equations include some experimentally determined components, and thus these relationships are semi-empirical formulae. They have, however, many advantages compared with the purely empirical methods. They are based on the actual dynamic character of the motion
202
2 Determination of hydmdk conductivity
and their application, therefore, reflects the real physical contacts between the variables under consideration. The use of these formulae prevents particular mistakes which are very often caused by applying empirical equations t o practical situations. An example of such a mistake is where an equation derived for a given character of movement is applied in another zone without considering the basic differences between the physical processes and using only some corrective factors, which, though valid in the vicinity of the measurements used for their calculation, are not so in the whole zone. This possible mistake can well be illustrated by an example taken from seepage hydraulics, i.e. where Darcy’s equation is used to describe all types of seepage. Although it is clearly proved that the linear relationship between velocity and gradient is valid only in the case of laminar movement (when the dominating forces are gravity and friction), the same function is very often applied to describe other types of movement as well, using only a numerical factor to correct the resulting error. Naturally, this factor differs from cam to case and investigations determining a factor from a limited number of measurements cannot, therefore, generally be accepted. The method of investigation previously explained, and proved to be physically correct, will be appliedin this part of the book for the characterization of seepage through an homogeneous porous nzedium, the solid m t r i x of which is composed of evenly distributed grains of loose clastic sediments. Using the continuum approach the main aspects in the determination of the geometrical model were explained in Section 1.1.3. It was followed by the analysis of the physical parameters of soil in loose clastic sediments, on the bmis of which the effective diameter ( D J , the shape coefficient of grains (a) and the effective porosity ( n ) were selected as the most important characteristics to be incorporated into the model as parameters. Comparing the various possible types of models, it was found that a bundle of straight tubes lying parallel to the direction of flow and composed of small sections of two different diameters, is simple enough t o be amenable to mathematical treatment, and at the same time is suitable for the accurate reproduction of the most important hydraulic processes occurring in homogeneous loose clastic sediments. The h a 1 result is summarized in Section 1.2.5 where all the equations, from which the model-parameters can be calculated aa functions of the characteristic physical soil data are listed. After having determined the geometrical model, the next step necessary to complete the conceptual model, is the selection and characterization of the acting forces. It has to be followed by the experimental verification of the model. This dynamic analysis and experimental research is discussed in the following part of the book.
Chapter 2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage As already stated, the creation and maintenance of movement requires the action of an accelerating force, or of a system of such forces. The retarding forces act against the accelerating ones, and they generally increase with the
203
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
velocity of the motion. Thus, there is a limit where the two groups of forces reach a state of equilibrium and a steady movement develops. When investigating the dynamics of seepage, the fist task is to analyze the acting forces. It is necessary t o determine their physical properties and to find the most suitable way of incorporating them in the conceptual model. There are many cases where the dynamic laws established in theoretical physics are not suitable for direct application, because the model would be too complicated, making the mathematical solution more difficult. Acceplable approximations have to be determined in these cases, which ensure both the necessary simplicity and the accuracy required in practice. One important method of approximation is to dbthguish between the dominant and the negligible forces. The ratio of the considered and neglected forces gives numerical values which indicate the limits of the validity zones of the various approximations applied by neglecting certain factors. Similar dimensionless quotients can be derived as the ratios of the accelerating and retarding forces. These parameters provide the theoretical form of the bwic movement equations, which will later be verified by experiments. The stages in the dynamic investigation laid down in the previous paragraphs will be discussed in detail in this chapter.
2.1.1 Forces influencing the flow between grains In seepage hydraulics the most important accelerating force is gravity and in most cmes i t is sufficient to consider only this force, as indicated in connection with the definition of seepage. Apart from this force the pressure of the covering layer may be a dominant factor in deeper lying aquifers, if the comprewibility of the latter is significant. I n the vicinity of the water table, capillarity, and in the unsaturated zone, adhesion between water and grains may also have an important accelerating role. The latter should also be included in the group of retarding forces in he-grained sediments, where the ratio of the internal surface related to the volume of the sample is high. Among the retarding forces, three generally become dominant: adhesion, friction and inertia. Hence, there are six forces, detailed knowledge of which is required for the dynamic investigation of seepage. Four of them are well known and generally used in other branches of hydraulics and soil mechanics. These are: gravity, the pressure of the overlying layer, inertia, and friction. The other two forces (i.e. capillarity and adhesion, both created by molecular interaction) have important roles, mainly in the investigation of seepage, and their more detailed discussion is, therefore, justified here. Qravity is a maas-force (body-force) having potential and caused by the attraction of the Earth. Its size (a)is equal to the product of the acceleration due to gravity ( 9 )and the moving mass ( M ) and is directed vertically downwards: (2.14) c)L = Mg = Veg; where V is the volume of the investigated body, and
e is its density.
a04
2 Determination of hydraulic conduotivity
A force has potential when there exists a potential-function - a singlevalued scalar function of the space coordinate system - whose gradient is equal to the force in question (the differential quotient of the potential function in any direction is equal to the component of the force vector in the same direction). I n the case of a mass-force, the potential may be related to the unit of the mass, and thus, the gradient of thepotentialfunction supplies the vector of acceleration. In a gravitational field, choosing one axis of the coordinate system as vertical, the vector of acceleration has no component normal to this axis, and the derivate of the potential-function, therefore, i n a vertical direction is equal to the acceleration due to gravity, and the potential can be calculated from the following equation: and for a unit mma
u = Mzg; u1= zg.
(2.1-2)
Consequently, the potential is proportional to the distance (21 . , measured from an arbitrarily chosen horizontal plane used as a datum of reference.
unloaded layer
drained layer
Fig. 2.1-1. Hydimstatic pressure distribution and its modification caused by surface load
m5
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
When the total weight of the grains in the layer and that of the covering layer, is transferred from grain to grain at the points of contact, the water in the pores is loaded only by the overlying water body, and hence, the vertical distribution of water pressure can be characterized by the hydrostatic pressure-distribution curve (Fig. 2.1-la). I n this case, the sum of potentialand pressure-energy is constant at each point, and water movement can be created, therefore, only by outside action. The volume of pores in the layer decreases when the latter is d e c t e d by a surplus load placed on its surface. If the loaded layer is drained (a given amount of water equivalent to the decrease of pores can be immediately discharged from the layer), the surplus load is transferred through the grains as well, and hence, the pressure distribution in the water is not modified by this outside load (Fig. 2.1-lb). Another extreme case is, where the borders of the aquifer are impervious, the layer is compressible and the total load has to be taken over by the water itself (Fig. 2.1-lc) (KBzdi, 1963, 1974). I n an aquifer within a stratum composed of pervious and impervious layers, the outside load is created by the overlying layers. Assuming the stratum to be completely filled with water (the water table is at the level of the surface), the probable water pressure can be limited by two extreme vdues (i.e. the hydrostatic pressure and the loaded condition), in the form of the following unequality (Fig. 2.1-2):
(t=
plane 0 I,g+b, T~pV=Zg plane I Zlg+hl 7sQ~ = =ZY+~I crs-rv)PV
1
pressure differem between plane 0 and plane !related to the datum level
Fig. 2.1-2. Water pressure in natural layer influenod by the weight of overlying layere
206
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
(2.1-3)
where yI, is the specific weight of water and ys is that of the solid grains. When the pressure is higher than the lower limit, there is a potential difference between the upper and lower surfaces of the layer covering the aquifer, which may create movement through the impervious, or semiimpervious covering layer (and drain the water from the aquifer). Thus, the upper limit in Eq. (2.1-3) describes the condition at the point of time when the load WM placed upon the layer, while the lower limit characterizes the total consolidation, the development of which can be theoretically expected after an infinite time. The actual water pressure depends on the time elapsed since the loading, the size of the load and the permeability of the layers (that of both the aquifer in question and the bordering formations). A further uncertainty is caused by the fact that many loadings follow each other before the total development of consolidation caused by the earlier loading. A decrease in the load can also sometimes be observed (erosion, exfoliation), and since the layer is not elastic, this is not always followed by complete expansion. For this reason, the expected value of pressure cannot be calculated, only its possible extreme limits can be estimated (Fig. 2.1-3). When calculating the parameters of seepage, the pressure diflerence between the investigated and the draining space can be taken into consideration as an active force. This value divided by the specific weight of water is expressed a.s the equivalent height of a water-column and thus, i t can be taken into account as a supplementary part of gravity. The presence of this type of force requires special investigation, therefore, only in the care of unsteady movement, when the development of consolidation influences the character of movement as well. Inertia is also a body-force similar to gravity. Consequently, it is the product of mass and acceleration. I n this case, the latter is the acceleration of the motion, which is retarded by this force: (2.1-4)
Internal friction is a retarding force i n a viscous fluid, obstructing the relative displacement of two water particles moving along two neighbouring paths (Fig. 2.1-4). This force is directed against the flow and its size is proportional to the surface ( A ) ,parallel to the flow line and perpendicular to the direction of the velocity gradient. The friction acting on a surface of unit size (specific value) is the shearing stress (z), which is the product of dynamic viscosity (7)and the change in velocity in a direction normal to the area investigated (velocity gradient):
S=Az;
z=q-.
dv dn
(2.1-5)
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
207
pressure bead in wafer column CmJ
Fig. 2.1-3. Values of water pressure measured at various depths
g&yq
- --
2
Fig. 2.1-4 Sketch for the interpretation of viscosity and shearing stress
The ideal (non-viscous) fluid is a theoretical concept. Its molecules are absolutely movable, and their displacement related to each other is not affected by any resistance. The actual water molecules are dipoles, the positive and negative charges being located asymmetrically within the molecule
208
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
(Fig. 2.1-5). This structure creates an electrostatic field around the molecules, the find result being the attraction between the molecules and the binding of positive and negative poles (Newtonian fluid). The shearing stress between two layers of molecules acting on a unit area is proportional to the velocity difference of the layers. The factor of proportionality is the dynamic
yofy+ Fig. 2.1-5. Dipole structure of water molecules
viscosity, the technical dimension of which was [kp sec m-2]. I n practice, the physical dimension (poise)was also often used, which is roughly 1/100 of the former: 1 poise = l[dyn sec cm-21 = 0.01019 [kp sec m-2]. I n the S I system the physical and the praotical units are the pascal seconds (Pas) and the Nsm+ (1 Pas = lNsm-'= lop). I n many cams the physical behaviour of the fluid is characterized by viscosity and density. It is reasonable, therefore, to introduce a combined parameter, which is the quotient of dynamic viscosity and density v = q/e;
(2.1-6)
known M kinematic viscosity, and its dimension is [L2T-l]. The orientation of the molecules is not constant. The bonds are disintegrated by Brownian movement and new groups are continually developing. Thus, viscosity is a probability parameter formed by a number of randomly bound molecules, which always represents the equilibrium between attraction and Brownian movement. Thus, viscosity can be regarded aa an example of the application of the continuum approach when an arbitrarily chosen parameter is applied to represent a property of the actual group of molecules and to investigate the continuum of a fluid instead of the real molecular structure. It is evident, therefore, that viscosity decreases with inereusing temperature. The equation generally applied in practice to describe this relationship is as follows: 71 (2.1-7) 1 0.0337 t 0.00022 t2 ' qo
+
+
209
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
where t is the temperature of the fluid at "C, and q,, is the viscosity of the fluid when t = OOC. The latter is the function of the electrostatic field created by the dipole molecules, and hence, this parameter is a material constant of the fluid, which is T o = 1 . 7 7 10-3 ~ [pa 81
in the case of water at a pressure of 1 atm (100 kPa). The theory that viscosity is a result of molecular attraction, is supported by the fact that the relationship between viscosity and absolute temperature ( T ) can be characterized by an equation having the same structure as that between vapour pressure ( p ) and absolute temperature, and thus, viscosity can be directly related to vapour pressure (Madge, 1934):
[:I
In - = A -
BIT;
Inp = A' - B'fT ;
and thus qpB"B
(2.1-8)
c.
1
It is also quite evident that the increasing pressure acting on the fluid decreases the distance between the molecules, and hence, incremes viscosity (although in the case of water some irregularity can be found, as shown in 1.0016 Fig. 2.1-6). Since the compressibility of water is very small (1.0010 times the increase of viscosity as a result of 1 kp/cm2 increase in pressure), this dependence can be neglected in seepage hydraulics. As with the increase of pressure, all kinds of external eflects which increase the probability of the orientation and binding of dipoles, increase the viscosity
-
0.0'
'I 2' 3'
I
4
I
5
pressure lo^
'
6
I
7
'
8
I
'
9 t O
N/mm 2.3
Fig. 2.1-6. Relationship between temperature, pressure and viscosity of water 14
210
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
of the fluid. Among these influences, the most important is the electrostatic charge of the solid wall surrounding the fluid. The investigation of this effect leads to the study of the next influencing force, i.e. adhesion. The solid wall has electrostatic charges related to the water, which polarize the water molecules along the wall. The molecules are fully orientated in the first layer. They are bound by their opposite charge t o the wall and their charge, which is the same as that of the wall, is orientated towards the
(-)
(-1 (-1 (->
(-) (-)
(-1 (-)
Fig. 2.1-7. Distribution of polarized water molecules along the walls of grains
interior of the water body. The effect of polarization can also be observed inside this double-layer within the water body. The number of orientated molecules, however, is inversely proportional t o the distance measured from the wall (Fig. 2.1-7) (Erdey-Grliz and Schay, 1954; Khzdi, 1972, 1974). It is not yet absolutely clear, whether the adhesive force is influenced by the mineralogical and chemical character of the grains forming the solid skeleton of the seepage field. On the basis of the explanation given in Section 1.2.3 concerning the interaction between water and grains, it is very likely that this relationship is determined by the Van der Waub force, the effect of which can be characterized by a tension ( p ) inversely proportional t o the sixth power of the distance from the wall (a), independent of the mineralogical and chemical character of the latter [see also Eq. (1.3-15)]:
C ' 6
p=-.
(2.1-9)
There are, however, a few exceptions, when the presence of some minerals having a special structure (Na-montmorillonite, amorphous colloids) modi-
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
211
fies the normal relationship between the tension in question and the water content of the sample. Another observable phenomenon is that the repulsive force influencing the interaction of colloid grains i n the suspension, isagected by the mineralogical and chemical character of small particles (see Chapter 1.2). Since the repulsive force determines the morphological character of the grains (the ratio of the irreversible bonds to the total amount of colloid particles), the mineralogical and chemical character of the grains indirectly influences the size of the active surface of the sample, and hence, the interaction between the water and grains as well. This influence, however, can be neglected in seepage hydraulics, because the actual active surface is always taken into consideration by the application of the effective diameter. There are some publications which state that adhesion is inversely proportional to the third power of the water content, or sometimes to its second power, when the free charges of the grains are bound by monovalent cations (JuhAsz, 1967; Mattson, 1932; Vageler, 1935). The detailed explanation of the soil-moisture retention curve is given in Chapter 1.3, where the meaning of the two separated sections of this curve is also explained. The validity of Eq. (2.1-9) is also proved for the uppermost section of this curve, where the interaction between the grains and water is influenced only (or more precisely, mostly) by adhesion. The lower power mentioned in the papers, is valid in the open capillary zone, where the water content is jointly determined by capillarity and adhesion. I n this zone, however, the relationship between water content and tension can be described more easily by the use of the probability distribution of capillary head, than by formulae expressed in the form of a direct function. The detailed study of such equations, therefore can be neglected here. The tension is perpendicular to t e solid wall, and hence, it has no component in the direction of flow. It is necessary, therefore, to investigate the way in which the motion of water can be influenced by this action. The accelerating froce displaces polarized water molecules in the electrostatic field of the solid grains, and hence,thepaths of the dipoles cross the forcelines of the electric field. It is well known, that this process consumes energy and can be expressed by the action of a force parallel to the flow line (bimilar to friction). The magnitude of this force naturally decreases with increasing distance from the wall (KovAcs, 1957, 1958). A very similar result can be achieved when the eflect of the adhesive force is indirectly taken into account by considering its influence on the flow as a surplus shearing stress. The application of this method means a deviation from the Newtonian fluid, and requires the investigation of a material having a shearing stress in static condition as well. This kind of medium is called Bingham’s body or Bingham’s plastic (Bingham, 1922; Reiner, 1952). In this cme, the sum of friction and the secondary effect of adhesion acting in the direction of flow (S E ) can be expressed by a common equation using a shearing stress (or yield stress z’) having a member independent of velocity, instead of that expressed by Eq. (2.1-5). The existence of the static shearing stress (zo) is proved by the fact that in cohesive layers (and also in capillary tubesof verysmall diameter), there
+
14*
212
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
is a limiting value of gradient (I,,, threshold gradient), below which there is no movement at all. Thus, zero velocity can occur with a finite gradient. The measured value of the threshold gradient can, therefore, be used to characterize the static shearing stress (Kar&diand Torok, 1955; Kutilek, 1965). Bondarenko and Nerpin (1966, 1967)andBondarenko (1966)havepublished the results of a series of experiments designed to determine the threshold gradient and the static shearing stress. They measured the corresponding velocity and gradient values of the flow of water and ethyl alcohol, respectively, through glass and quartz capillary tubes of known constant diameter. Figure 2.1-8a shows the results measured using water and Fig. 2.1-8b those using ethyl alcohol. The data represented in a v vs. I coordi. nate system prove that the relationship between the two variables cart be well approximated by a linear equution over almost the entire range of velocity. The straight line representing this relationship does not cross the origin of the coordinate system [as it should if Darcy's equation, Eq. (1.1-9) were
(a) wafer
(b) ethyl alcohol 0.3 a2
0.1
0
0
b
r
0.1
I
I
0.2 0.3
d4
a's
d.6
I a'8
d7
0.1
a2
0.3 0.4
0.5 0.6
0.7
b5
LO 0.5 0
2.5
2.0 1.5 1.0
0.5
0
Fig. 2.1-8. Relationship between velocity and hydraulic gradient in the zone of small velocities (after Bonderenko and Nerpin. 1967)
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
213
valid], but intersects the horizontal axis at a point I , . The gradient of I , is not equal, however, to the threshold value, because the movement of fluid also begins under the influence of smaller gradients inthezoneof very low velocities, where the linear relationship is not valid, as shown by Fig. 2.1-8c, which is the enlarged form of the lower parts of a velocity vs. gradient graph. The figure is also supplemented by a theoretical sketch (Fig. 2.1-8d) showing the interpretation of the threshold gradient ( I , ) and the I , value characterizing the position of the linear relationship, and fkally, that of a third parameter ( I , , ) , applied by Bondarenko and Nerpin for the evaluation of the measurements. The basis of the evaluation is the Buckingham-Reiner’s equation, or more precisely, its simplified form, in which the static shearing stress is assumed to be constant. This constant can be calculated from the velocity and gradient data: v =KI
I,,
-
[ 3 M 4
3
4 I,, + 1 3 L i
[
(Buckingham-Reiner’s equation);
- K I 1 - - Lo ; O-
:rII]
(simplifiedform);
(2.1-10)
and the I , , constant proportional to the threshold gradient: 1
to=IryI,,; 2
where K is Darcy’s hydraulic conductivity, r is the radius of the capillary tube, y is the specific weight of the fluid and I , , is the characteristic gradient, the interpretation of which is given in Fig. 2.1-8d. An important result of this analysis is that the tovalue calculated in this way was found to be independent of the material of both the tube and the fluid and of the diameter of the tube, and it is a single-valued function of the temperature. The intersection of the straight line characterizing the v vs. I relationship and the horizontal axis (Il),is proportional to the I , , value. It can be expected, therefore, that the r y I , product behaves similarly, and the data determined from the graphs of Figs 2.1-8a and 2.1-8b prove this expectation (Table 2.1-1). Bondarenko (1973) has also proved that the non-Newtonian behaviour of the fluid is cawed mostly by the hydrogen bounds between the molecules. The comparison of the virtual hydraulic conductivity values (the ratio of corresponding data of velocity and gradient) measured with various fluids (Fig. 2.1-9) testifies the fact that the rapid decrease of this parameter was observed in the zone of small gradientsonly,if the fluid applied during the experiments had dipole molecules. At the same time, the change in concentration of the dissolved material in the water (KC1in the experiments) did not modify the calculated t oparameter as shown in Table 2.1-1. This gives the r y I , products recalculated from the shearing stress given in the original publication. This result is a negative proof of the previous statement,
214
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity Table 2.1-1. The characteristic I , gradient measured I,xlO' parameter if temperatun, is r C ]
Pipe Type of fluid
Distilled water y = l.O[pcm-S]
61 103.6 166 198 266
6.4 -
-
-
4,l 2.6 1.3 1.3 1.0
-
-
-
2.80 1.26 1.76
1.30 0.66 0.26
-
-
0.69
0.16
-
-
0.08 -
-
-
-
-
0.40 0.16
0.00
-
average Ethyl alcohol y = 0.8[pcm'*]
67 109.26 166
-
-
6.4
3.66 2.22
3.3
-
-
-
1.1
-
0.68 0.31
0.75
-
0.10
-
-
-
-
-
average
KC1 solution y = 1.0 [ p ~ r n - ~ ] N N N 1 p = 9.807 X
198 -
1.2 1.3 1.3
-
-
-
-
-
-
average
lo-' N
showing that the dissolved minerals do not influence the behaviour of the fluid. It was also found that the heat value of the H-bonds (a),can be related to the shearing stress in the form of an equation having a similar
0 0.2 0.4 a6 0.6 LO 1.2 64 !.6 hydraulic gradient, I Fig. 2.1-9. Comparison of the virtual h draulic conduotivitiea determined by various fluids (after 6ondarenk0, 1973)
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
215
in capillary tubes by Bondarenko and Nerpin (1967) 1 . ~ ~ 1 0 ~pcm-'] 4
15
3.26
1
20
1
a5 -
-
2.09 2.69 2.14 2.67 2.66
-
3.26
2.41
-
-
-
__ -
1
30
I
40
I
60
1
55
1
58
0.66 0.67 0.41
0.20
0.04
-
-
-
0.00
-
1.43 1.30 1.24
0.28
-
-
1.66
-
0.40
-
-
-
-
-
1.38
0.64
0.24
0.04
0.00
-
2.46
1.66
1.01
-
-
-
0.33
2.88
-
-
-
-
1.47
1.12
0.41
0.13
-
-
2.88
1.97
1.39
0.71
0.23
-
-
-
remlouleted from z,
structure to those giving this parameter as a function of other properties caused by the dipole character of the molecules. The relationship expressing the value of G as a function of zo is the following: (2.1-1 1) where T is the absolute temperature, A and C are constants and the two subscripts ( 1 and 2) indicate the corresponding values of T and zo. Since the G value can be regarded as a constant within a limited range of temperatures, Eq. (2.1-11) can also be used to determine the general pattern of the relationship between the r y I , product and temperature. Choosing a fixed T, value (T,= 273OC, i.e. the temperature in centigrade is equal to can be neglected in the zone of praczero), the dependence of r y I , on TITz tical importance and the (T,*- T,)difference can be supplemented by the temperature expressed in centigrade. The neglect of the T,Tzproduct can be partially compensated by the appropriate selection of the C parameter. Thus, a linear relationship can be expected between the variables under investigation ( t OC and r y 11)in a semi-logarithmic coordinate system. In Fig. 2.1-10 the data summarized in Table 2.1-1 were plotted, resulting in a straight line. The constants and the corresponding basic values of the temperature and the r y I , products, were found to be as follows: C =
216
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
- - 5 x 10-5; G/AT,T, = 1/50; T , = 273OC; (ry I & = 7 x p cm-2. It is also shown in the figure that by shifting the line horizontally by &5OC
two enveloping curves can be achieved, which border a stripe incorporating tmhewhole range of scatter of the measurements. The probable zone of the
3 --
2--
8verage Wues of tbe measurements determibedw#h o wfer + efhjl alcohol KCI S d U f h R I
I
I
points measured and the I, vs. t relationship within the 10°C < t < 6OoC range of temperature can be described by the following equations: tOC
*
5oc
50
1
--
[log ( r y I,
+
+5x
+ 3.1251 ;
(2.1-12)
I, = -{exp [- 4.6(t°C 156.3)10-2] - 5 x 10-5). V Equation (2.1-12) characterizes the flow of fluids having dipole molecules through a capillary tube with a contltant radius r . The application of this dynamic principle to describe low velocity seepage through fine grained, loose, claatic sediments will be discussed in Chapter 2.3. The interrelation between the threshold gradient (I,)and the I, parameter will also be explained.
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
217
It is necessary to analyze here the various opinions regarding the character of the t ostatic shearing stress t o clarify the influence of the non-Newtonian fluid on seepage. Most of the authors dealing with this problem assume that the static shearing stress is a function of the distance ( 6 ) measured from the interface between the solid bordering material and the non-Newtonian fluid (Kovbcs, 1957,1958; J u h h z , 1958; KarM and V. Nagy, 1960; Childs and Tzimas, 1971). On the contrary, Bondarenko (1973) argues that this parameter has t o be a constant throughout the entire interior of the fluid, because he does not take account of any physical influence which may modify the property of the fluid. It appears to be proved that the special behaviour of the fluid is caused by the fact that the chains composed of dipole molecules are longer and more stable in the electrostatic field of the wall than in the interior of the fluid. It is reasonable, therefore, to assume that the physical parameter chosen to characterize this property should be proportional to the attraction exerted by the solid material on the molecules of the fluid. Therefore, the hypothesis of a static shearing stress decreasing with increming distance from the wall [zo(6)] is acceptable. On the other hand, the relationship between the attraction and zo is not necessarily linear and a more gentle decrease than that of the attraction indicated by Eq. (2.1-9), can also be assumed. A suitable approximation can be determined only by experiments (as will be ghown in Chapter 2.3) and it must not be linkedto,or influenced by, the high power usedinEq. (2.1-9) to describe the attraction vs. distance relationship (Thirriot, 1969). On the basis of the dynamic analysis of the non-Newtonian behaviour of water, the total shearing stress can be expressed as the sum of the static value t o , depending on the distance from the wall ( 6 ) and the Newtonian parameter being proportional to viscosity, and the velocity gradient normal to the direction of flow. Applying this total shearing stress, the combined retarding effect of friction and the molecular forces can be described by one equation:
consequently,
(2.1-13)
S
+E =A
[
to(6)
3
+ 7-
.
It is very likely that the second member on the left-hand side of Eq. (2.1-13), depending on viscosity and velocity gradient, is also a function of the distance measured from the wall. As shown, however, in connection with the investigation of friction, the viscosity is doubled when pressure is increased 1000 times. Combining this condition with the relationship between tension and the distance from the wall, it can be proved that the modification of viscosity is insignificant in a very large zone, and hence, this effect can be neglected in seepage hydraulics. The sixth dominant force influencing the flow between grains is capillarity, which occurs on the surface of contact between water and air. The most
218
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
simple explanation of this force can be given by taking into consideration the attraction between water molecules. In the interior of the water body the attractive forces act equally from every direction, and thus, all molecules are in a balanced condition. A molecule on the water surface is attracted only by molecules below the surface. Thus, in an elementarily thin layer along the contacting surfaces of two different media there is free energy, which has to be balanced by pressure differences existing between the two sides of this layer (within the two contacting media). To characterize the amount of free energy its specific value is used, which is equal to the ratio of the surface energy P(A)and the surface ( A ) .Relating this quotient to an infinitely small surface element the interfacial tension is achieved (aik),which is a material constant for any pair of media, i and k, depending only on absolute temperature (T) : ( 2.1-14)
The special value of the interfacial tension developing on the surface of a fluid covered by its own vapour, is called surface tension (a).According to Eq. (2.1-14), its dimension can be calculated as the ratio of energy (work) over surface, which is equal to force over distance. Thus, surface tension can be interpreted m a force acting within the surface along a line having a length of unity [FL-l]. Eotvos law has established a relationship between surface tension and the other molecular parameters of the medium (molecular volume, molecular weight, latent heat, absolute temperature, vapour pressure). The relation between surface tension and temperature can be expressed from this law as follows: (2.1-15) u v213 = c(To- T ) = ct; where v is the molecular volume of the medium and T o is the critical temperature, where the product of av213 becomes zero. Eotvos (1886) proved that the c factor is constant for fluids having R socalled simply composed molecular structure (Table 2.1-2) : (2.1-16)
Some media (especially water, alcohols, fatty acids) exhibit exceptional behaviour. The c factor of ethyl alcohol increases with temperature and only reaches the constant of Eq. (2.1-16) near the critical temperature. The parameter of acetic acid is considerably lower (0.134) than the general constant, but the expected 0.227 value can be achieved if a double molecule (2C2H40,) is considered. The data for water listed in Table 2.1-2 were also calculated assuming the binding of two molecules. As seen in this case, normal behaviour prevails above l O O O C , but below this limit the c factor decreases with decreasing temperature. This relationship also proves the previously mentioned hypothesis in connection with the probable molecular structure of water: i.e. the number of bound water molecules increases with decreasing
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
219
Table 2.1-2. Experimental data characterizing the relationship between surfaoe ternion o f various fluids and temperature (after Eotvos, 1886) Type of fluid
Ethyl ether Ethyl ether Ethyl ether Ethylene bromide Ethylene bromide Chloroform Mercuric methyl Carbon tetrachloride Carbon dioxide Carbon bisulphide Sulfuric acid Ethyl alcohol Ethyl alcohol Ethyl alcohol Ethyl alcohol Ethyl alcohol Ethyl alcohol Water ( 2 S O ) Water Water Water Acetic acid (C,H,O,) Acetic acid Acetic acid Acetic acid (2 C,H,O,)
6- 62 62-120 170-190 20- 99 99-213 20- 60 20- 99 3- 63 3- 13 22- 78 2- 60 21- 78 78-108 108-138 138-168 168-199 199-236 3- 40 40-100 100-160 160-210 21-107 107-160 160-230 21-160
0.228 0.226 0.221 0.227 0.232 0.230 0.228 0.231 0.228 0.237 0.230 0.104 0.136 0.169 0.183 0.202 0.226 0.169 0.180 0.228 0.227 0.132 0.132 0.138 0.211
temperature. As a final result of this discussion the change in the surface tension of water in relation to temperature is given in the form of a graph (Fig. 2.1-11). Let us investigate the points of contact of three immiscible fluids (or gmeous media). I n a section normal to the three surfaces of contact, the balanced condition of the acting interfacial tensions necessitates the closure of the vector triangle formed by the three tensions (Fig. 2.1-12). From this condition, the angles ( aik)of the contact surfaces measured from an arbitrarily chosen axis can be calculated as a function of the numerical values of the interfacial tensions, or - if the axis is equal to the tangent of one of the contacting surfaces - the so-called contact angles (Oik)can be determined (NBmeth, 1963; Bear, 1972):
+
aI2cos aI2 or
023
cos a23
uI2 + a,, cos O,,
+
+ 013 cos a13 = 0; (2.1-17)
613
cos
013
= 0.
This condition indicates at the same time, whether or not the development of the balanced condition is possible. It is evident that if u12 (u23 yU), there is no possibility of fulf3ling Eq. (2.1-17) and, therefore, equilibrtum cannot be achieved at the contact of these media.
>
+
220
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
75
5 70
.$ 65
8
S! 60
& 55 $
50 -10
u
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 i o o m
temperature, t tecl
Fig. 2.1-11. Relationship between the surface tension of water and temperature
Fig. 2.1-12. Balanced condition of surface tensions at the points of contact of three immiscible fluids
Equation (2.1-17) can be simplified if one of the contactingmaterials is solid. The molecular forces do not modify its form, and hence, the interfacial tensions between the solid and the two liquid (or gaseous) media lie along a straight line (Fig. 2.1-13): ~ 2 cos 3
0 + 613 -
= 0;
cos 0 =
- u13
.
(2.1-18)
012
It follows from Eq. (2.1-18) that if a,,
> al3, then
cos 0 is positive and
0 < 5 .Fluid 1 is called the wetting fluid in this caae, while in the opposite 2
case
lz < uI3),cos 0 < 0 and 0 > , and fluid 1 is a non-wetting one.
2
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
221
Fig. 2.1-13. Angle of contact between the surface of two liquid media and a solid wall
Knowing the parameters characterizing the surface tension of a fluid and its contact with the solid wall ( 0 and O ) ,the pressure difference between the two sides of the surface (capillary pressure p,) and the form of the surface near the wall can be determined. The change of free energy when an elementary part of the surface df = = dZ, * dZ, moves in a direction normal to its position by an infinite dC distance, serves as the basis of the derivation of capillary pressure (Fig. 2.1-14) (Levich, 1958). If R, and R, indicate the radii of curvature in the main directions, the modified area of the investigated df element after dC displacement is: (2.1-19)
The total change of free energy can be calculated by integrating individual elements over the whole surface. At the same time, it is evident that equi-
\
Fig. 2.1-14. Sketch for the derivation of capillary pressure
222
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
librium can develop only if the free energy is minimal and, therefore, the elemental change is zero:
Equation (2.1-20) h w a solution for any infinite d5 displacement if (2.1-21 )
$
-
-
c of Q gX Y of == C017Sf.C017Sf.- Q gX Y
Fig. 2.1-16. Vertical section of free water surface near a vertical wall
For simple geometrical forms, the position of the free surface of a fluid (capillary surface or meniscus) can be determined by integration. Along this surface, the pressure of the upper medium is the atmospheric value (p, = = p A = const.). Considering this condition, the pressure of fluid in a static condition can easily be calculated in the force field of gravity: p , = const. - e g x .
(2.1-22)
For example in the vicinity of a vertical, solid wall (the radius of the curvature being infinite in one direction, R, =-), the condition of the equilibrium is (Fig. 2.1-15):
d2Y -
Equation (2.1-23) can be solved by double integration. The two boundary conditions necessary t o determine the two integration constants are given dY = tan 0 ; and if y = at the two extremities of the surface if y = 0, = oo,x= 0
I.
[
dx
I n a space surrounded by solid vertical walls, the develop-
ment of the meniscus is influenced from each direction by the presence of
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
223
a wall. If the distance between the opposite walls is small enough, it can be assumed, that the curvature is constant in the section normal to the walls. Thus, in capillary slits or tubes having regular forms in a horizontal plain, the meniscus can be approximated by a cylinder (in a slit), ellipsoid of rotation (in an elliptical tube) or sphere (in a circular tube) (Fig. 2.1-16). In these cases, the curvature and the capillary pressure can be calculated from the geometrical parameters of the horizontal section of the surrounding space and from the contact angle:
Fig. 1.1-16. Approximative forms of menisci in slits and tubes
224
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
(a) I n a slit having a width of b (Fig. 2.1-16a):
(b) In an elliptical tube the two main axes of which are a and b (Fig. 2.1-14b): a 2
R 1-
l COY
, R , = - -b
1 2 cos
.
0
o
1 ; p,=2a cos 0 -
a
1 +; b
(c) In a circular tube with a diameter of d (Fig. 2.1-16c): d 1 4acosO R , 1R2= R = ; P,= d 2 cos o
(2.1-25)
(2.1-26)
It can be seen that the sign of capillar pressure is determined by the size n of the contact angle: if 0 < - ; p , 2 opposite case 0
> 0 , and, therefore, p 1 > p 2 ; in the
II >-; p , < 0 , and p , < p,;
2
n and finally, if 0 =-,pc= 2
0,
and p 1 = p,. The consequence of the capillary pressure not being equal to zero is that the position of the meniscus i n the mpillary tube or slit will be diflerent from the level of the contacting water body having a large surface. Choosing this latter level as a datum where the surplus pressure is zero, the average height of the meniscus (mpillary rise) above this level can be calculated from capillary pressure:
h, =
4acos @
P
es
; in a circular tube h, = --
Y
.
(2.1-27)
d
Hence, the meniscus is above the reference level if the contact angle is 76
smaller than - , while the surface is lowered in the capillary tube in the case 2
3
of non-wetting fluid 0 >-
[
.
Investigating the contact between water, air and quartz (as fluid, gaseous and solid media), it was found that the contact angle is near zero, although this value changes, t o agreat extent, with the condition of the solid surface. Substituting cos 0 = 1 end the value of the surface tension belonging t o the most commonly occurring temperature (i.e. 15 20°C) into Eq. (2.1-27) a simple approxjmation for the capillary rise of water in a glass tube of diameter d can, in practice be proposed [see also Eq. (1.3-26)]:
-
h, [cm] =
0.30 [cm2]
d [cml
(2.1-28)
225
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
Some observations show that the contact angle depends not only on the quality of the contacting media and the condition of the solid surfaces, but that it is also influenced by the movement of the meniscus and by the pressure conditions prevailing in the capillary tube. This phenomenon can easily be recognized when a raindrop moves along the slope of a glrtss plate, the drop having a large contact angle at its front and an angle approaching zero at the back (Fig. 2.1-17a), the phenomenon is, therefore, called, the raindrop
(a)
(Q7
(b)
raindrop
wetting
drainage
Fig. 2.1-17. Development of different angles of contact in capillary tubes
effect. The same change in 0 characterizes the meniscus of a water column moving in a capillary tube. When the tube is first saturated and the balanced is condition is approached by lowering the meniscus, its contact angle (0,) smaller than that belonging to the static state (B0),while the opposite inequality is valid in the cme when the meniscus advances in the tube (0, > 0,)(Fig. 2.1-17b). The change in the contact angle enables a drop in a capillary tube to equalize the pressure difference without creating mvement, this phenomenon is, therefore, a special type of threshold gradient in a capillary tube. Let us suppose that a pressure of p , prevails at one end of a horizontal tube and p , at the other ( p , < p z ) . The two sections under different pressure are divided by a drop bounded by menisci at both ends (Fig. 2.1-17c). The pressure within the fluid, p , can be determined from the external pressures and the capillary pressures acting on the menisci: 40
p = p , - pc1=p,- -COB 0, ; d and 4a
p = p , - p , = p , -cos d
0,;
therefore,
p, 16
-p, =
40
-(cos 0,- cos 0,). d
(2.1-29)
226
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
Thus, a static balance is achieved if the contact angles can develop so that the difference between their cosine values multiplied by 4a/d is equal to the pressure difference. It follows from the condition where p , < p,, that
0,> 0,.
Considering the same phenomenon in a vertical tube, the conditions can also be determined where a drop, having atmospheric pressure on both sides, does not move downwards under the influence of gravity (Fig. 2.1-17d). The surplus pressure just below the upper meniscus is equal to the capillary pressure belonging to this surface. Moving downwards inside the drop, the pressure increases in proportion to the length measured from the upper surface, [the curvature of the surface is neglected here, because of the very small horizontal area, and the length is measured from the centre of gravity of the meniscus which is approximated as d / 3 above the deepest point of the meniscus (Swartz, 1931)l. The surplus pressures inside the drop can be calculated from two directions (the upper capillary pressure increased by the weight of the water column, or the lower capillary pressure decreased in proportion to the distance from the point), and the two valueb have to be equal. Hence, a relationship can be established between the two capillary pressures: 40
40
pcl = -COB 0,; p,, = - COB 0, ; d d d +pie - l y = p,,; -1y = cos0, - co.0, ; 4a
(2.1-30)
+
where 0, = 0 being the lower limit of the contact angle at the upper meniscus (cos 0, = 1). Movement will not develop if d c o s 8 , ~1 - - 1 y 4a
;
(2.1-3 1)
and
021,mit = arc cos It is necessary to note that this condition indicates only the posbibility of static equilibrium, because the contact angle can develop anywhere in the 8, 021imit aa well, and in this caae the 8, < '8,inequality does range 8 not stop the movement, only decreases its velocity.
>
2.1.2 Dimensionless numbers characterizing the various validity zones of seepage As already mentioned in Chapter 1.1, seepage can be classified according to the accelerating forces and further mb-groups can be determined considering the acting retarding forces. Thus, the following types of movement have to be characterized when seepage through loose claatic sediments is investigated:
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
227
(a) Gravitational seepage through a saturated medium: - Turbulent seepage (retarding force is inertia); - Transition zone (retarding forces are inertia and friction); - Laminar seepage (retarding force is friction); - Microseepage (retarding forces are friction and adhesion); (b) Seepage through a saturated medium influenced by gravity and the pressure of the overlying layers (further sub-groups are the same as those of the previous group) ; (c) Seepage through the unsaturated zone above the water table (accelerating forces are gravity and adhesion, and capillarity has3 to be taken into account as well; retarding forces are friction and adhesion). Considering the fact that the pressure of the overlying layer can be regarded as a supplementary part of gravity (as already mentioned), and because seepage through an unsaturated medium is influenced by numerous forces and, therefore, i t must be investigated separately, the following combinations of dimensionless numbers can be constructed as quotients of the dominating accelerating and retarding forces (KovQcs, 1966; Spronck, 1932; Mosonyi and KovQcs, 1952): Laminar zone
S -
a
Turbulent zone
dv Arl-
dn - v v -
-MK ;
Veg
(2.1-32)
1%
dv
V e-
T
dt - v2 - Fr ;
a Transition zone
dv
T + - S--
(2.1-33)
Is
Veg
dv
ve-+Arldt dn
a
-
(2.1-34)
Veg
(2.1-35)
Microseepage
1, V E + S -- --
es + A r l -
dv
vv dn - I o +-=KO,. 9 Veg la9 When only one retarding force is considered and the others are neglected, similar dimensionless numbers can be constructed as3 the ratio of the forces neglected to the considered retarding force. It is quite evident that these dimensionless numbers can be used, therefore, to characterize numerically the limits of the validity zones of the various types of seepage. The limit between the turbulent and transition zones is evidently characterized by the fact that friction can be neglected as compwed with inertia, ~
16*
228
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
while the lower limit of the transition zone (the upper limit of the laminar zone) falls where friction becomes dominant over, inertia. Thus, both limits can be expressed as a ratio of inertia and friction: dv VeT dt lv -Re. * (2.1-36) A q -d v v dn
The lower limit of the laminar zone can similarly be expressed by the given numerical value of the ratio of adhesion to friction:
E - I-o-V e g- I , - =lag -_ Ko S
a---
I,
-
(2.1-37)
dv vv MK Arldn Finally, there is a further possible combination of the forces in question i.e. the ratio of adhesive force to gravity El@ = I , = KO,. This dimensionless number characterizes a static condition below microseepage, where friction is zero. Some of the dimensionless numbers given are well known from general hydraulics as the bases of the various model-laws, such aa the Froudenumber from Eq. (2.1-33), the Reynolds’ number in Eq. (2.1-36) or the Mosonyi-Kovhcs’ number [Eq. (2.1-32)], which were previously derived to determine the model-law valid for the characterization of seepage models, and for calculating the transforming factors between the corresponding measurements of the prototype and the model respectively (Mosonyi and KovQlcs,1952, 1956). The structure of the other dimensionless numbers is the same, or very similar to those given before. The only significant difference occurs in the numerator of KO, and KO,, where the sum of two forces instead of one is evident. For this reason, these numbers cannot be used as model-laws, because dynamic similarity can only be ensured in the cme of two dominating forces, when the identity of the ratio of these two forces can be represented in the prototype and the model. When there are three dominating forces (i.e. two retarding forces in the numerator and the accelerating gravity force in the denominator), the identity of the dimensionless number for the two systems ensures only the same ratio of the retardingandaccelerating effects. The ratio of the two retarding forces may, however, be quite different in the model from that in the prototype. The dimensionless numbers characterizing the various zones of seepage [Eqs (2.1-32) to (2.1-35)] can also be used to determine the general forms of movement equations, valid for each zone. It is necessary to take into account that seepage is not a free movement. Only a part of the potential energy (increased with pressure energy) accelerates the movement. The actuul accelerating force can be characterized numerically by the product of gravity and hydraulic gradient:
G’= IMg
= IVeg.
(2.1-38)
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
229
The substitution of this value instead of gravity, in the equations in question, is in accordance with the theory of similarity as well. The total mechanical similarity includes both the geometrical similarity and the dynamic one. The former is ensured when the ratio of two corresponding lengths in the two systems is constant. Thus, the gradient determined as a quotient of two lengths (pressure expressed in equivalent water columns and the length of seepage) must be the same in the prototype as in the model. Mechanical similarity in Darcy’s zone necessitates the identity of both Mosonyi-Kovkcs’ number and the hydraulic gradient in the two systems. Thus, the general form of the movement equations can be derived as follows: (2.1-39)
if
K = M K ’ la - .9 V
Similarly, a well-known formula can be derived for the turbulent mne (i.e. Chezy’s equation): (2.1-40)
if
A=-.
2
Pr’
In the transition zone the general form is also the same as that proposed empirically to describe this type of movement (Forchheimer, 1924):
if 1 a = --
K 0; lg
; and b =
Y
Ko; l a g
(2.1-41)
Finally, the general form of the movement equation in the zone of microseepage is:
KO$= I , +l v v ; v = - la (K 9oj;II 1129 V
Io)=C1I-c2I0; (2.1-42)
129
c1 = -Koj; V
la 9 1 and c2 = - = K -. V MK’
The accuracy of such application of dimensionless numbers calculated as quotients of retarding and accelerating forces, is also proved by K a r a ’ s measurements (Kartidi, 1963). The points representing his data were plotted
230
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
on a coordinate system with the logarithm of Reynolds’ number on the horizontal axis and 2/MK‘ on the vertical one (Fig. 2.1-18). The fact that the points lie along a horizontal line in the laminar zone verifies the constancy of the M K ’ value, and also that of Darcy’s hydraulic conductivity.
Fig. 2.1-
-KOV&CB’
2.1.3 Numerical limits of the zones of seepage As already mentioned, the ratio of retarding forces considered and neglected respectively is a suitable parameter to calculate the limits of the validity zones of each movement equation, 88 this quotient meaaures the magnitude of the two forces in question. It is possible, therefore, to determine such fixed numerical values of these dimensionless numbers that indicate where one retarding force becomes negligible compared to the one under consideration. For this investigation, it is necessary to define the characteristic length and velocity from which the dimensionless number in question should be calculated. The Reynolds’ number is proportional to the ratio of inertia to friction. If this number is smaler than a given limit, inertia is small and friction is high. The validity of Darcy’s law can probably be accepted below this limit. When this parameter is above another limit (which is higher than the previous one), the inertia of the numerator is dominant over friction and the
231
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
latter is negligible. This is the turbulent zone. Between these two limits, there is the zone of the transition condition, where both inertia and friction have to be considered. In seepage hydraulics, according to general practice, the Reynoldd number is calculated by using the eflective diameter as a characteristic length, and substituting Darcy’s seepage velocity. The latter is the discharge of flow divided by the total cross section, including the area of both pores and solid grains [see Eq. (1.1-9)]. Consequently, the Reynolds’ number generally used in seepage hydraulics can be calculated from the following formula: R e , = - Dh .V
(2.1-43)
-
Experimental results, give the upper limit of Darcy’s zone as 2 5 expressed by the parameter calculated from Eq. ( 2 . 1 4 3 ) (Lindquist, 1933; Koieny, 1953; Kar&di andV. Nagy 1960; Kar&di, 1963). According to these 200 as measured papers, the lower limit of the turbulent zone is 100 by Re,. There are, however, some explanations in these papers, indicating that this value gives only the lower limit of the second transition zone, and the real turlbulent zone starts at a higher limit. Some of the physical parameters of the soil (porosity, shape-coefficient) are excluded from the Reynolds’ number calculated from Eq. ( 2 . 1 4 3 ) .It is more correct t o use the Reynolds’ number determined for the model pipe rather than Re,. I n this parameter (Re,),the characteristic length i s the average pipe diameter, and the mean velocity %nthe pores (or in the model pipes) is substituted as the characteristic velocity. Thus, the relationship between the two Reynolds’ numbers can be determined as well:
-
Re because
,-
dn -
veff -
v
Dh
l - n a
v
Re,.
- --,4
l-n
u
(2.1-44) 4
n Dh ; and u l-n
=
-.n V
Using this parameter, the following numerical limits between the various zones can he given, as will be proved in detail in the following chapter:
Re, < 10 laminar (Darcy’s) zone; < Re, < 100 first transition (Lindquist’s) zone; < Re, < 1000 second transition zone; 1000 < Re, turbulent (Froude’s) zone. 10 100
The purpose of all the other proposals concerning the calculation of Reynolds’ number, is to select, in a similar manner, the characteristic length and velocity, so that further information can be obtained by including physical data of the soil other than the effective diameter. The velocity value generally used is either the seepage velocity (v) (Ward, 1964; Harleman et al., 1963; Perez Franco, 1973; Collins, 1961) or the effec-
2 Determinetion of hydraulic conductivity
232
tive mean value in the pores (vetf = v/n) (Maasarani, 1967; Kovhcs, 1969a, 196913; Chauveteau and Thirriot, 1967; Thirriot, 1969; Thirriot and Habib, 1970). Considering the possible difference between volumetric and areal porosity, the n value waa introduced,sometimes with a power lower than unity [as explained by Thirriot (1969) the power can be between 1 and 2/3 and Zampaglione (1969) used a characteristic velocity of the Reynolds’ number of vetf= ~ n - ~ l ~ ] . There is an even larger variety of parameters applied as characteristic lengths for the calculation of the numerical value of the Reynolds’ number. Several attempts have been made to find a length directly proportional to the resistance of the solid matrix. The most natural method is to use the square root of intrinsic permeability for this purpose (Ward, 1964; Harleman et al., 1963; Perez Franco, 1973; Valentin, 1970; Massarani, 1967). Some authors have related this parameter to the square root of porosity
(V,
[E)
(Collins, 1961). Thirriot (1969) haa derived a characteristic length,
assuming that the resistance of the porous medium is equivalent to that of a capillary tube having this length as diameter. According to his result, this length (d) is equal to the product of d*=
K
:v
- and a COmhmt (2.145)
32-.
Substituting the value of intrinsic permeability, according to the modified Koieny-Carman equation (the validity of which will be proved in the next chapter), it is easy to prove that the d o average pore diameter, used in Eq. ( 2 . 1 4 3 ) m a characteristic length, is similarly proportional to
k=-
5 (1 - n)a
d-4--01-n
51-n
(2.146) a
-.
D h 80 -rc
a
The characteristic length used by Zampaglione (1969) is similarly derived from the total resistance of the sample. The most important deviation from the other method, is the consideration of the difference between areal and volumetric values of porosity. The square of the length in question ( A 2 ) is defined as a factor of proportionality between mean pore velocity and hydraulic gradient v l f f = C I ; C = - A9’ ; V
and because
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
233
therefore (2.1-47)
A grouping according to the two applied parameters, gives an excellent summary of the various proposals analysed in the foregoing paragraphs (Table 2.1-3). The summarization clearly shows that the proposed dimensionless numbers differ only in the effect due to porosity (in the applied power of this parameter), because the use of various numerical constants Table 2.1-3. Grouping of the various Reynolds’ numbers proposed for the characterization of seepage
Square-mot of intrinaic permeebility
fi
Square-root of the ratio of intrimia permeability and porosity
Harleman et d . Masserani (1967)
Rew = v/v
(1963) Ward (1964) Perez (1973)
ReM = v/v
fi
Collins (1961)
rn
Equivalent tube diameter d* or do Parameter derived from the total resistance of the sample
Thirriot (1969) K o v h (1969)
Rey = f Z v / v
fk/n8
Rep = )I&/v Zampaglione (1969)
Rez = v / v
fw
A Square root of the Kovh product ofintrinsjo (unpublished permeability end result) porosity
fax
does not change the character of the Reynolds’ number. On the basis of the comparison,the transforming factors between the various Reynolds’ numbers can also be determined together with the ratio of these numbers to the classical seepage Reynolds’ number (Re,) (Table 2.1-4).
234
‘
I
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
Relp
Rec
Rex
=
Rez
I
Rer
1
1
1
After comparing the different Reynolds’ numbers, Valentin (1970) proposed that the use of intrinsic permeability should generally be accepted for the calculation of the characteristic length. The only remaining problem is the method of consideration of porosity and the choice of the applied constant. In the first instant, i t seems that this problem is only a question of decision, because knowing the various transforming factors, the numerical characteristics of the limits between the various types of seepage served by the application of Reynolds’ number can easily be transferred from one system to another (e.g. the limits previously fixed in the form of the given Re, values). However, aiming at the establishment of a general seepage law describing the relationship between seepage velocity and hydraulic gradient without any restriction of the validity zone, the power of porosity has to be chosen so that the points representing the measured resistances in a coordinate system based on the applied form of Reynolds’ number, should lie along a curve. Some guidance concerning the constant parameter to be used, can be gained from the constant of the modified Koieny-Carman equation proposed for the calculation of Darcy’s hydraulic conductivity. Considering these objectives, it was found that the multiplication of intrinsic permeability with porosity, is more suitable than the previous proposals, and the application of a constant of 5 is advisable:
Re, = 5-2) V
.
(2.1-48)
Tables 2.1-3 and 2.1-4 are supplemented with this finally proposed parameter.
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
235
the various Reynolds’ numbers Re8
(using the modifled Rep
Rq
n = -Rep
m
1
Kokny-Cannan equation for the calculation of permeability)
Reg
1 1
Rec = - -ReC 6 n
Rep =
,.
16 1
ReK
Rec=--
I
n
1
-Res
61-n
a
4
1
1-n
a
Rep=--
ReS
In the z.o)ie of microseepage, where seepage velocity is smaller than that pertaining to the laminar flow, the water movement i s also influenced by two retarding forces i.e. adhesion and friction. This zone can also be regarded aa a transition one, which develops between laminar movement and the static condition. As in the case of the use of the Reynolds’ number, the limit between the laminar zone and microseepage can be indicated by a given numerical value of the dimensionless number, proportional to the ratio of adhesion and friction [KO,in Eq. (2.1-37)]. Because of the lack of sufficient measured data, this limit can only be determined on the basis of theoretical consideration. Both Eq. (2.1-39) and Fig. 2.1-18 indicate the constancy of the M K ’ value in Darcy’s zone. Substituting the average pipe diameter in Eq.(2.1-39) as the characteristic length and hydraulic conductivity in the form of the modified KoSeny-Carman equation (aa already shown and as will be explained in detail in Chapter 2.2), this constant can be calculated: n MK~=--I (2.1-49) 80 The dimensionless number M K ‘ can also be determined from grain diameter instead of from the diameter of the model pipe: 1
MK:= 5
a2
n3 (1 - n)2
(2.1-50)
As in the various forms of Reynolds’ number, the square root of intrinsic permeahility can also be substituted as a characteristic length. In this ca-ae
236
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
the dimensionless parameter is equal to unity, or using the 5 m v a l u e , is inversely proportional to porosity
or 1 MKk=-. 25 n
(2.1-5 1)
Assuming that porosity, n = 0.40, MK; is approximately for a sample of spheres (a = 6), a value which agrees with Karsdi's data (see Fig. 2.1-18). Combining Eqs (2.1-37) and (2.149),the dimensionless number giving the limit in question can be expressed in Darcy's zone as a product of the ratio of threshold and actual gradient, and a constant depending only on Dorositv: (2.1-52) The same parameter if v k o r 5
v& is substituted for characteristic length is I K o,, = 2 ; I
or (2.1-53) This type of relationship must be valid not only within the laminar zone but also at its lower limit. Thus, the numerical value in question can also be determined by a constant value of the ratio between the threshold gradient and the actual one: I , = 1210; (2.1-54)
is the actual gradient a t the limit between the laminar zone and where microseepage, and the constant of 12 is based on the detailed investigations of microseepage given in Chapter 2.3. Comparing this result with Eq. (2.1-12), it can be seen that this limit is about Ih = 0.003 in sand (Dh > 0.01 cm), while in clay (Dh 2 p ) , the limit gradient is higher, about I , = 0.5, although the effect of adhesion is still very small here - smaller than the probable error in measurement of the gradient. The validity zones of the various types of seepage can be represented graphically as the function of either velocity or hydraulic gradient (Fig. 2.1-19). The first graph shows the laminar zone and the zones having a higher gradient. Here the Reynolds' number is linearly proportional to velocity. Its given numerical values indicate the borders between the subsequent zones. This number being proportional to the ratio of inertia and friction, indicates that the ratio of the two retarding forces can also be
-
2.1 Dynamic analysis of seepage
--
237 3
3
2s I
0 zm2
a
~~
retarding forces
0
retardipQforces Fig. 2.1-19. Graphical representation of the validity zones of the various types of
-age
determined by this parameter. By definition, Mosonyi-Kov4cs' number is independent of velocity in the laminar zone. Its value decreases gradually with increwing velocity in the transition and turbulent zones. The I(v) function is represented in two ways. The solid line shows the connection between dynamically correct relationships in each zone, while the dotted line assumes the validity of the linear function within the whole range of movement. The difference between the two curves indicates the error which may arise by the unjustified application of Darcy's law. The second graph summarizes the validity zones of the types of seepage having small velocity (including the laminar zone as well). Here the w ( l ) function is similarly represented as in the first part but with the gradient now chosen as an independent variable (measured on the horizontal axis). The linear relationship gives a higher velocity than the actual one in this range of seepage. From the dimensionless parameters the Mosonyi-Kov&cs' number is represented as a function of hydraulic gradient. It is nearly constant in the laminar zone and gradually decreases below the lower limit of the latter. It becomes zero at the threshold gradient.
238
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
References to Chapter 2.1 BEAR,J. (1972): Dynamics of Fluids in Porous Media. Elsevier, New York, London, Amsterdam. E. C. (1922): Fluidity and Plasticity. London. BINOHAM, BONDARENKO, N. F. (1966): Nature of Seepage-anomaly in Fluids (in Russian). Symposium on Seepage and Well Hydraulics, Budapeat, 1966. BONDARENKO, N. F. (1973): Physics of the Movement of Ground-water (in Russian). Gidrometeoizdat, Leningrad. BONDARENKO, N. F. and NERPIN,S. (1966): Influence of Viscous-Plastic Properties of Water on its Equilibrium and Transfer in the Unsaturated Zone. Symposium on Water i n the Unsaturated Zone, Wageningen, 1966. BONDARENKO, N. F. and NERPIN, S. (1967): Sheering Stress of Fluids and its Consideration in the Investigation of Surface Phenomena (in Russian). Publication of the Institute of Physico-Chemistry of the Academy of Sciences, USSR. CHAWETEAU, G. and THIRRIOT,C. (1967): Regime of Flow in Porous Media and the Limit of Darcy’s Law (in French). La Houille Blanche, No. 2. CHILDS, E. C. and TZIMAS,E. (1971): Darcy’s Law at Small Potential Gradients. Soil Science No. 3. COLLINS, R. E. (1961): Flow of Fluids Through Porous Materials. Reinhold, New York. DE WIEST, R. J. M. (1969): Flow through Porous Media. Academic Press, New York, London. EOTVOS,L. (1886): On the Itelationship between Surface Tension and Chemical Properties of Various Fluids (in Hungarian). Matematikai 6 Termbzettwlomanyi grtekezkaek, Vol. N ,p. 34. ERDEY-GR~z, T. and SCHAY,A. (1954): Theoretical Physico-Chemistry (in Hiingarian). Tankonyvkiad6, Budapest. FORCHHEIB~ER, PH. (1901): Watermovement through Soil (in German). ZeitschriJt dea Verbundea der deutechen Ingenieurs. FORCHHEIMER, PH. (1924): Hydraulics (in German). Teubner, Leipzig, Berlin. HARZEMAN, D. R. F., MEHLHORN, P. F. and RUDR, It. R. (1963): Dispersionpermeability Correlation in Porous Media. Proceeding of ASCE, HY. 2. JUJL~SZ, J. (1968): Investigation of Seepage (in Hungarian). Hidroldgiai Kiizlii?ay, No. 1. JWASZ,J. (1966a): Dynamic Characterization of Seepage (in Hungarian). Symposion on seepage and Well Hydraulics Budapeat, 1966. J ~ ~ sJ. z(196613): , Calculation of Static Ground-water Resources Available as a Result of Consolidation (in Hungarian). Symposwn on Seepage and Well Hydraulics, Budapeat, 1966. Joadsz, J. (1967): Hydrogeology (in Hungarian). Tankonyvkiad6, Budapest. -I, G. (1963): Hydraulics of Linear Drainage Systems (in Hungarian). (Thesis; Manuscript), Khartum, Budapest. KARADI,G. and TOROX, L. (1966): Applicability of Seepage Law (in Hungarian). HdroMgiai KOd&y, NO. 6-6. KAR-~DI, G. and V. NAGY,I. (1960): Investig&ion ofivalidity of Darcy’s Law (in Hun mian). Conference on Hydradics, Budapest, 1960. ~ Z D I A. , (1963): Neutral Stress and Pressure of Flow (in Hungarian). v k i i g y i Kodemdnyek, 1. K h D I , A. (1972): Soil Mechanics. 4th edition (in Hungarian). Tankonyvkiad6, Budapest. K ~ z D I ,A. (1974): Handbook of Soil Mechanics (Vol. 1. Soil Physics). ElsevierAkademiai Kiad6, Amsterdam, Budapest. KOV~CS, G. (1957): Theory of Micro-seepage (in Hungarian). HidroMgiai KOdizl&ry, No. 3. KOV~CS, G. (1968): Theoretiad Investigation into Micro-seepage. Acta Technica Acudemiae Scientiarum H u n g a r k e , Tom. XXI. 1-2. Kovkcs, G. (1966): Dynamic Investigation of Seepage by Invariant Numbers. Symposium on Seepage and Well Hydraulics, Budapest, 1966.
2.2 Hydraulic conductivity of saturated layers
239
Kovlics, G. (19694: General Characterization of Different Types of Seepage. I A H R Congress, Kyoto, 1969. KovAcs, G. (1969b): Relationship between Velocity of Seepage and Hydraulic Gradient in the Zone of High Velocity. 13th I A H R Congreae, Kyoto, 1969. KO~ENY, J. (1953): Hydraulics (in German). Springer, Wien. KIJTILEK, M. (1965): Influence of Interface on Filtration of Water in Soil (in French). Science du Sol, (Prague), 1. KUTILEK,M. and SUINOEROVA,J. (1966): Flow of Water in clay Minerals as Influenced by Absorbed Quinolimium and Pyridinium. Soil Science, 6. LANDAU, L. D. and LIPSCHZTS,E. M. (1974): Textbook of Theoretical Physics (in German). Akademie Verlag, Berlin. LEVICH, V. G. (1968): Physico-chemical Hydrodynamics (in Hungarian, translated from Russian). Akademiai Kiad6, Budapest. LINDQUIST,E. (1933): On the Flow of Water through Porous Soil. ICOLD let Congreee, Stockholm, 1933. MADQE, E. W. (1934): The Viscosities of Liquids and their Vapour Pressures. PhY8k8, N O . 2. MASSBANI, G. (1967): Critics of the Validity of Darcy's Law in Heterogeneous Porous Media (in French). CRAS, July. MATTSON, S. (1932): Soil Science. Baltimore. MOSONYI,E. and KovAcs, G. (1952): Model Law by Joint Consideration of Gravity and Friction (in Hungarian). Hidroldgiai Kodony, No. 7-8. MOSONYI, E. and KovAcs, G. (1956): Model Law of Filtration (in French). I A H R Congreee, Dijon, 1956. N~METH E., (1963): Hydromechanics (in Hungarian). Tankonyvkiad6, Budapest. PEREZ FRANCO, D. F. (1973):Non-Darcian Flow of Ground Water towards Wells and Trenches. Particularly within the Turbulent Range of Seepage. Technical University of Budapest (Manuscript). REINER,M. (1962): Theory of Rheology (in French). Dunot, Paris. SPRONCK, R. (1932): Hydrodynamic Similarity and the Investigation of Models (in French). Annalea dea Travaux Publiqua de Be2gique. SWAE~TZ, C. A. (1931): The Variation in the Surface Tension of Gas-saturated Petroleum with Pressure of Saturation. P h y e k , vol. l. THIRRIOT, C. (1969): Hydrodynamics of Flow in Porous Media (in French). 13th IAHR Congress, Kyoto, 1969. THIRRIOT,C. and HABIB,J. (1970): Experimental Study of Flow with Low Reynolds' Number in Clays (in French). Sciences Agrmomique, R e n w . VAGELEB, P. (1936): Cations and Water Content of Mineralogical Soils (in German). Berlin. F. (1970): Non-linear Resistance of Porous Media (in German). MitteilunVALENTIN, gen, Inatitut fiir Hydraulik und ae&eeerkzl.n.de, Miinohen, No. 6. WABD,J. C. (1964): Turbulent Flow in Porous Media. PV'OCeedilage of ASCE, H Y . 6. ZAMPAQLIONE, D. (1969): Turbulent Seepage Flow in Filters 13th IAHR Conpeas, Kyoto, 1969.
Chapter 2.2 Hydraulic conductivity of saturated layers The interpretation of Darcy's seepage velocity [Eq. (1.1-9)] and that of hydraulic conductivity [Eq. (1.1-ll)] h w already been discussed. It hw also been stated that the simple v=KI (2.2-1) relationship can be accepted for the characterization of all types of seepage
240
2 Determination of hydraulic conductivity
through saturated media, if the concept of hydraulic conductivity instead of Darcy’s original parameter (KO), is used in a more generalized form. The Darcy coeflcient is composed of two factors: one characterizing the properties of the solid matrix (intrinsic permeability) and the other describing the behaviour of the transported fluid. These two components have to be supplemented by a third one, depending on the condition of the flow. The third factor should be the function of either the seepage velocity or the hydraulic gradient, because the apparently linear relationship between v and I in Eq. (2.1-1) should be modified in such a way and for each zone of seepage that a suitable mathematical expression may be achieved connecting the two basic variables. Investigating seepage through loose clastic sediments, the intrinsic permeability is influenced by two properties of the solid matrix: (a) The size and form of grains from which the layer is built up; (b) The packing of the grains, which determines the size of the pores between the grains.
Thus,four components have to be investigated and determined for the complete characterization of the hydraulic conductivity of saturated, loose claatic sediments: (a) Geometrical parameters of the grains in the layer (size, shape and distribution); (b) Porosity of the layer; (c) Physical parameters of the propagating fluid (the ratio of specific weight and dynamic viscosity, or that of acceleration due to gravity and kinematic viscosity) ; (d) Flow condition of the seepage investigated (considering the dominant forces among those listed in the previous chapter). In Chapter 1.2, a geometrical model waa proposed to characterize the water transporting channels between the grains of the layer. Combining this simplified structure with the movement equations based on the consideration of the acting forces, a conceptual model can be established. According t o the explanation given in the introduction of this part of the book, the next phase is the verification of this model and the determination of its numerical constants on the basis of experimental data to ensure the practical application of the theoretical results. The h a 1 verification, which is the object of this chapter, will be based partly on data from publications, and partly on the author’s own measurements.
2.2.1 Determination of Darcy’s hydraulic conductivity Accepting the hypothesis whereby there are only two main forces to be taken into account in the zone of laminar movement (i.e. gravity and friction), their equilibrium can be expressed in a mathematical form for a model pipe with a diameter of do. The well-known Poiseuille’s equation can be
2.2 Hydraulic conductivity of saturated layers
241
derived in this way. The equilibrium of a cylinder concentric about the axis of the pipe having a radius r and a length bf I , gives the following equation (Fig. 2.2-1):
I y r Z n l + 2 r n l q -d=v O . dr
(2.2-2)
Fig. 2.2-1. Symbole used for deriving Poiseuille's equation
After solving this differential equation with a boundary condition, where the velocity at the wall of the pipe is zero (w = 0 ; where r = ro),the velocity at a point at a distance of r from the axis can be determined: (2.2-3)
Integrating the product of the velocity and an elementary area (U) along the total surface of the cross sect,ion, the flow-rate through one pipe with a radius of ro can be achieved r.
This value, divided by the total area, is the mean velocity:
v = -Qo- - r zI. Y (2.2-5) A 8rl The number of pipes in the model system crossing the unit area of the sample [see Eq. (1.2-20)] is known, and thus, the total discharge and the virtual seepage velocity can also be calculated:
'
vs -- - =
As
Q o N = - *I ;Y
3211 where A , is the total cross-sectional area of the sample. 16
(2.2-6)
242
2 Determination of hydmulic conductivity
Substituting the effective grain diameter of the sample instead of the pipe diameter [see Eq. (1.2-19)], the following relationship can be determined: vS --_1 y n3 [?)'I. (2.2-7) 2 7 (l-nn), The hydraulic conductivity of the model pipes with constant diameter cdculated from Eq. (2.2-7) is 2.5 times greater than the actual value deter-
4
Fig. 2.2-2. Comparison of flow rate in pipes having constant or changing diameter
mined by reliable experiments as mentioned in Chapter 1.2 in connection with the detailed discussion of the establishment of the model system. It was also explained that this difference can be eliminated if the pipe is constructed from short sections with diameters of d1 and d, so that the volume of the pipe remains the same as that of the pipe with a diameter of do, and the 1 : 3.5 [Eq. (1.2-22)]. The aboveratio of df and df is equal to 1 : 3 mentioned increase in flow-resistance or the decrease in discharge can also be proved mathematically (Fig. 2.2-2):
-
Qi = Qz
m(I1
= QI-2 = a&,;
+ I,) = I , 1;
(2.2-8) Q1+
= p I l d : = BIzda = 2 P I ,
2.2 Hydraulic conductivity of saturated layers
243
d, =1 ; 3.5 and d o 1.5 then a
N
0.4
On the basis of this explanation, the determination of the virtual seepage velocity can be based on the proposed geometrical model and can be calculated from Eq. (2.2-7) multiplying its right-hand side by 0.4. Comparing this result to Darcy’s equation, the theoretical value of hydraulic conductivity can be determined, which agrees with the dynamic analysis and includes all the effects of the influencing factors: (2.2-9)
The variables influencing this parameter can be divided into three groups:
”] [I
(a) The parameter expressing the behaviour of the fluid -, or using the
, the equivalent ratio is - ;
kinematic viscosity
V
(b) The characteristics of the grains in the layer (Dh/a) expressing the size, distribution and shape of the grains; (c) The effect of porosity
ns
(1
).
- n)2
To verify the proposed formula, i t is of value to investigate the ways in which these groups of variables were considered in the previously developed equations. If the relationship between the hydraulic conductivity and one of the groups is similarly described in a formula aa in Eq. (2.2-9) all measurements and observations used to determine the formula, also prove the validity of the relationship. The first investigations aimed a t exploring the relationship between permeability and the behaviour of fluids, have expressed their results in a form which illustrates the dependence of the K D parameter on temperature. Thus, Hagen (1869) observed a modification of 3 yoper degree