SPRINGER SERIES IN SURFACE SCIENCES
32
Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York Barcelona Hong Kong London Milan Paris Singapore Tokyo
ONLINE LIBRARY
Physics and Astronomy '---J
http://www.springer.de/phys/
SPRINGER SERIES IN SURFACE SCIENCES
Chunli Bai
Series Editors: G. Ert!, R. Gomer, H. Liith and D.L. Mills This series covers the whole spectrum ofsurface sciences, including structure and dynamics of clean and adsorbate-covered surfaces, thin films, basic surface effects, analytical methods and also the physics and chemistry of interfaces. Written by leading researchers in the field, the books are intended primarily for researchers in academia and industry and for graduate students. 38
Progress in Transmission Electron Microscopy I Concepts and Techniques Editors: X.-F. Zhang, Z. Zhang
39
Progress in Transmission Electron Microscopy II Applications in Materials Science Editors: X.-F. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Scanning Tunneling Microscopy and Its Applications Second, Revised Edition With 208 Figures
Series homepage - http://www.springer.de/phys/books/ssss/
Springer Volume 1-37 are listed at the end of the book
SHANGHAI SCIENTIFIC &TECHNICAL PUBLISHERS
Preface
Professor Dr. Chunli Bai Institute of Chemistry The Chinese Academy of Sciences Beijing 10080, People's Republic of China
Series Editors: Professor Dr. Gerhard Ertl Fritz-Haber-Institute der Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, Faradayweg 4- 6 , 14195 Berlin, Germany
Professor Robert Gomer, Ph.D. The James Franck Institute, The University of Chicago, 5640 Ellis Avenue, Chicago, IL 60637, USA
Professor Dr. Hans Liith lnstitut fur Schicht- und lonentechnik Forschungszentrum Jiilich GmbH, 52425 Jiilich, Germany
Professor Douglas L. Mills, Ph.D. Department of Physics, University of California, Irvine, CA 92717, USA Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data. Bai, Chunli, Scanning tunneling microscopy and its applications I Chunli Bai. - 2nd rev. ed. p. cm. - (Springer series in surface sciences, ISSN 0931-5195 ; 32) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 3-540-65715-0 (alk. paper) I. Scanning tunneling microscopy. 2. Surfaces (Physics). 3. Surface chemistry. I. Title, II. Series. QC 173.4.S94B35 1999 99-34035 502'.8'25-dc21
Revised translation of the original Chinese edition: BAI Chunli: Saomiao suidao xianweishu ji qi yingyong © Shanghai Scientific and Technical Publishers, 1992
ISSN 0931-5195 ISBN 3-54°-65715-0 Second Edition Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN 3-540-59346-2 First Edition Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN 7-5323-2787-6/0'161 Shanghai Scientific & Technical Publishers This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9,1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer-Verlag. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York a member of BertelsmannSpringer Science+ Business Media GmbH © Shanghai Scientific & Technical Publishers and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1995, 2000
Printed in Germany The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting: PS™ Technical Word Processor Cover concept: eStudio Calamar Steinen Cover production: design & production GmbH, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper
SPIN: 10715754
~
.... .. _-
We have witnessed an amazingly fast growth of research related to Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM). The present monograph written nearly five years can clearly not be considered sufficient for researchers in this field. This observation motivated the author to come up with a new edition to include the recent developments. The revisions are focussed on recent advances (mainly since the time progress the first edition has been published) in the field of STM, stressing \ on methodology and impacts on relevant areas. I chose to add the recent results, while largely keeping the original content since it still remains valid in these days. Some of the additions are very brief, as I deem them necessary to reflect on the current status of a subfield; detail introductions can be found there. There are indeed many superb achievements which should be discussed in this new edition, but the author is only able to select a limited number of them. The revised content is increased more than twenty five percent compared to the first edition, and about one hundred new references have been added. A few new sections have been prepared to reflect the progress of the respective topics. I greatly appreciate the efficient and careful editing of this new edition by Dr. Helmut K.V. Lotsch, who was also responsible for the first edition of the book, and Dr. Claus Ascheron for his support. My colleagues at the Institute of Chemistry, CAS, have been of great help in completing this new edition. The effort of Dr. Chen Wang is highly appreciated. Ms. N.X. Wang, Mr. M.Z. Liu. Dr. LJ. Yang have contributed to collecting and organizing the references, and to typing the draft version of the added material. The author also wishes to express sincere gratitude to many fellow researchers in the STM field for supporting the second edition; to name some of them: Drs. Ph. Avouris and N.D. Lang (IBM TJ. Watson Research Center), Dr. RJ. Colton (Naval Research Center), Prof. A. de Lozanne (University of Texas at Austin), Dr. G. Poirier (Nat'l Institute of Standards), Dr. D.M. Chen (Rowland Institute of Science), N.J. Tao (Florida Int'l University), Dr. R.A. Wolkow (Nat'l Research Council of Canada), Prof. S. Morita (Osaka University), Prof. M. Edidin (Johns Hopkins University), Prof.H. van Kempen (University of Nijmegen), Dr. H. von Kaenel ( ETH Zuerich), Prof. R. Berndt (RWTH
57/3144/Xo - 5 4 3 210
v
Aachen), Prof. A.L.V. de Parga (Universidad Autonoma de Madrid), Prof. H.E. Gaub (TU Munich), Prof. c.L. Lieber (Harvard University). They have generously provided original data and granted permission to use them in this new edition. I enjoyed my efforts to prepare the first edition of this book, and I sincerely hope that was able in this second edition to improve the presentation to better serve the readers. Beijing January 2000
Chunli Bai
Preface to the First Edition
This book evolved out of the Chinese version which was published in 1992 by the Shanghai Science & Technology Publishers. The English version was drafted in 1992 when I was worked as a visiting professor at the Institute for Materials Research, Tohoku University, Japan. Since then some new achievements have constantly been added to the English version. In the middle of 1993, I received the computer printouts of the manuscripts of this book from Springer-Verlag, when I was organizing the 7th International Conference on Scanning Tunneling Microscopy in Beijing, China. Later on I participated in the preparation of the First Asian Conference on Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) with Prof. T. Sakurai (Tohoku University, Japan) and Prof. Y. Kuk (Seoul National University, Korea). By the turn of the year, I was again involved in the academic activities of the Third International Conference on Nanometer-Scale Science and Technology. In order to include some of the latest achievements reported to the above three conferences, I have made a great amount of modifications and revisions to the English version. The additions and updates amount to almost one third of the original Chinese version. This book is divided into nine chapters, with the first chapter discussing the basic principles and concepts of STM, and comparing it with electron microscopy and field-ion microscopy. The second chapter talks about the theoretic background and related concept. Experimental modes and applications of tunneling spectroscopy and spectroscopic imaging are presented in the third chapter. The fourth chapter deals with STM instrumentation and STM tip preparations; the fifth chapter includes other related scanning probe microscopes, such as atomic force microscope (AFM), the lateral force microscope (LFM), the magnetic force microscope (MFM), the electrostatic force microscope (EFM), ballistic-electron-emission microscopy (BEEM), the scanning ion-conductance microscope, the scanning thermal microscope, scanning tunneling potentiometry, the photon scanning tunneling microscope, and the near-field scanning optical microscope. Chapters 6 to 9 present some typical examples introducing STM studies of clean metal and semiconductor surfaces (Chap. 6), surface adsorbate and surface chemistry (Chap.7), biological applications (Chap.8), and surface modifications (Chap. 9). VII
VI
My obligations in this endeavor are numerous. I want first to thank my colleagues from the STM LAB of the Institute of Chemistry, the Chinese Academy of Sciences. Their support, help and encouragement made this book a reality. I want to express my gratitude to the following for allowing me to use their high quality pictures and related materials: Prof. P.K. Hansma (University of California at Santa Barbara), Dr. Phaedon Avouris, Dr. C. Julian Chen and Dr. Y.W. Mo (IBM Yorktown Laboratory), Prof. F. Besenbacher and Dr. L. Ruan (Aarhus University, Denmark), Prof. P.S. Weiss (Penn State University), Dr. N.J. Tao (Florida International University), Dr. Y. Strausser (Digital Instrum. Inc.), Prof. Y. Kuk (Seoul National University), Dr. R.J. Colton (Naval Research Laboratory) and Prof. T. Sakurai (Tohoku University, Japan). My special thanks to Dr. R. J. Colton for his carefull reviewing of specific parts of the book and providing valuable comments and suggestions. I would also like to thank Dr. H. Lotsch, senior editor in physical sciences at Springer-Verlag for assisting in the publication of this book. Due to various reasons, I was not able to provide the preliminary camera-ready manuscript of the book. This together with several quite extensive changes and modifications of the manuscripts burdened him with a very time consuming workload. Scanning tunneling microscopy is a fast developing field, with new concepts and new applications appearing everyday. Though I have tried my best to cover all possible major trends and developments of the areas, I still could hardly avoid omissions and uncovered subjects. I welcome any comments and suggestions from readers which will help towards a wellrounded, truthful and more accurate version should this book be reprinted in the future. Beijing February 1995
Chunli Bai
Contents
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
'"
1.1 Advantages of STM Compared with Other Techniques '" 1.2 From Optical Microscopy to Scanning Tunneling Microscopy . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.1 Electron Microscopes . 1.2.2 Field Ion Microscope " . 1.2.3 Scanning Tunneling Microscope.. 1.3 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . '
. . .
3 3 5 5 7
2. The Tunneling Effect . 2.1 Historical Remarks . 2.2 Tunneling-Current Theory. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 2.2.1 Tunneling Current . 2.2.2 Practical Tip and Surface Wave Functions . 2.3 Tip-Surface Interaction Model . 2.3.1 Tunneling Current . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 2.3.2 Tunnel Conductance . 2.3.3 Tunneling Active Orbital at the Tip.. . . 2.3.4 Double-Tip and Interference Effects .
11 12 17 18 22 25 25 29 30 32
3. Spectroscopy, and Spectroscopic Imaging. . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 Concepts of Tunneling Spectroscopies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.1 Solid-State-Barrier Tunneling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.2 Metal-Vacuum-Metal Tunneling. . . . . .. 3.2 Experimental Modes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 3.2.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics. . . . . . . . . . . .. .. 3.2.2 Current-Separation and Separation-Voltage Characteristics . . . . . . . . .... 3.2.3 Constant-Current Topography. . . . . . .. 3.2.4 Current-Imaging Tunneling Spectroscopy. . . . . . . 3.3 Energy Resolution. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.1 Surface States " 3.4.2 Adsorbate-Covered Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.3 Superconductivity....... 3.4.4 Outlook. . . . . .
37 38 38 40 42 43 44 46 46 47 49 50 56 57 60
VIII IX
a) Influence of the Tip , b) Interpretation of Spectroscopy Results . . . . . . . 4. STM Instrumentation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 4.1 The Vibration Isolation System. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 4.2 Mechanical Designs. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 4.2.1 Piezoelectric Ceramics 4.2.2 Three-Dimensional Scanners. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 4.2.3 Coarse Sample Positioning. .. . 4.2.4 STMs for Operation in Various Environments , 4.3 Tip Preparation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 4.3.1 Preparation of Tungsten Tips . .. 4.3.2 Preparation of Pt-Ir Tips , . . .. 4.3.3 Other Ways to Prepare STM Tips. 4.3.4 Tip Treatment. . . . . . . . . . . .. . 4.4 Electronics . . . . . . . . .. . . 4.5 Computer Automation . . . . . . . . .. 4.5.1 Hardware...... 4.5.2 Software . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 4.5.3 Image Processing. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. a) Histogram Equalization b) Convolution Filter. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . c) Statistical Differencing. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . d) Three-Dimensional Representation , ..
60 60 63 63 67 70 71 74 76 80 80 84 87 89 . 92 96 97 98 100 101 101 102 102
5. Other Related Scanning Probe Microscopes. . . . . . . . . . . .. 5.1 Atomic Force Microscope . . . . . . , 5.1.1 The Force Sensor. .. . 5.1.2 Deflection Detection. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.3 Illustrating AFM Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 5.2 Other Scanning-Force Microscopies , 5.2.1 Lateral Force Microscope. . . . . . . . . . . .. 5.2.2 Force Microscope Operating in the Noncontact Mode. 5.2.3 Force Microscope Operating in the Tapping Mode .. , 5.2.4 Magnetic Force Microscope . . . . . . . . . 5.2.5 Electrostatic Force Microscope. 5.3 Ballistic-Electron-Emission Microscopy . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.1 The Principle of BEEM . . . . .. 5.3.2 The BEEM Experiment. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 5.3.3 The Application of BEEM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 5.3.4 Ballistic-Hole Spectroscopy of Interfaces , , 5.3.5 Interfacial Modification with BEEM 5.4 Scanning Ion-Conductance Microscope. . . . . . .. 5.5 Scanning Thermal Microscope '
x
105 105 107 112 114 121 121 112 126 127 130 133 133 135 136 140 144 145 147
5.6 Scanning Tunneling Potentiometry and Scanning Noise Microscopy . 5.7 Photon Scanning Tunneling Microscopy and Scanning Plasmon Near-Field Microscopy . 5.8 Near-Field Scanning Optical Microscopy and Spectroscopy .. 5.8.1 Principles of Near-Field Optics . 5.8.2 Optical Probes for Near-Field Optics . 5.8.3 NSOM Operation . 5.8.4 Near-Field Scanning Optical Spectroscopy . 5.8.5 Near-Field Optical Chemical Sensors . 5.8.6 Scanning Exciton Microscopy . 5.8.7 Single-Molecule Detection by Near-Field Optics . 6. STM Studies of Clean Surfaces . 6.1 Metal Surfaces . 6.1.1 Geometric Structures . 6.1.2 Electronic Structures . 6.1.3 Surface Diffusion . 6.2 Elemental Semiconductor Surfaces . 6.2.1 The Si(ll1) Surface .. a) Si(11l)-7 x7 . . b) Si(lII)-2xl 6.2.2 TheSi(OOI)Surface , . a) Geometric Structure . b) Electronic Structure . c) The 2 Xn Structure . 6.2.3 Other Silicon-Surface Structures . 6.2.4 The Ge Surfaces . a) Ge(l11) . b) Ge(OOl) . 6.2.5 The GeSi(l11) Surface . 6.3 Compound Semiconductors and Layered Compounds . 6.3.1 GaAs Surfaces . a) GaAs(l10) . b) GaAs(lOO) . c) GaAs(lll) and GaAs(II I) . d) GaAs-AIGaAs . 6.3.2 Layered Compounds . 6.3.3 Charge-Density Waves in Compound Semiconductors . . . a) CDW Phases of IT-TaS z . .. b) Charge-Density Wave Defects . 6.3.4 High-T c Oxides .
149 151 153 155 156 157 158 161 162 163 165 165 166 168 172
173 173 173 175 177 178 180 182 183 184 184 185 186 187 188 188 190 191 192 193 195 196 200 200
XI
7. Surface Adsorbates and Surface Chemistry . . . . . . . . . . . .. 205 7.1 Adsorption on Metal Surfaces. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ., 205 7.1.1 Cu(l10)-O 206 7.1.2 Cu(lOO)-O 208 7.1.3 Dynamics · · · · · · · · · · · 209 7.1.4 Ag(l10)-O , , .. , .. , , 211 7.1.5 Ni(110)-H and Ni(l11)-H ' 213 7.1.6 Sulfur Adsorption ' 215 7. 1.7 Cu( 111 )-S. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ., 216 · · · · · · · · · · 219 7.1.8 Ni(lII)-S 7.1.9 Cu(l10)-S , 221 7.1.10 Ni(llO)-S ' 224 7.1.11 Mo(OO 1)-S and Re(OOO 1)-S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 227 7.1.12 Other Non-metal Adsorbates on Metals . . . . . . . . ., 228 7.1.13 Metallic Adsorbates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 228 7.2 Adsorption on Semiconductor Surfaces , 229 · · · · · · · · · · · 230 7.2.1 Ag/Si(111) 7.2.2 Au/Si(ll1) , 231 7.2.3 Cu/Si(111) , 232 7.2.4 Group-III Metals on Si(111). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 233 7.2.5 B/Si(111) · · · · · · · · · · 234 7.2.6 Cl/Si(lll) 235 7.2.7 Bi on Si(lOO) and Si(111) Surfaces. . . . . . . . . . . .. 235 7.2.8 Na/Si(111) , 236 7.2.9 Na/GaAs(110) and Cs/GaAs(llO) , 238 7.2.10 Alkali Metals on Si(100)-2Xl , 241 7.3 Molecules, and Molecular Adsorbates. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 242 7.3.1 Molecular Crystals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ., 242 7.3.2 Chemisorbed Aromatic Molecules in Ultrahigh Vacuum 243 7.3.3 Physisorbed Molecules in Ultrahigh Vacuum. . . . . .. 245 7.3.4 Physisorbed Long-Chain Molecules. . . . . . . . . . . .. 246 7.3.5 Chemisorption of Long-Chain Molecules . . . . . . . .. 249 7.3.6 Fullerenes 252 a) C on GaAs(1lO) , 252 60 b) C 60 on Si(100). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 254 c) C on Si(111) , 254 60 d) C 60 on MoS 2 (000 1) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 254 e) C on Cu(111) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 255 60 f) C on Au(111) and Ag(lll) , 255 60 7.3.7 Langmuir-Blodgett Films , 256 7.4 Observation of Clusters 257 7.4.1 Metal Clusters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ., 257 7.4.2 Semiconductor Clusters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 260 7.5 Nucleation and Growth. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 260 XII
7.5.1 Epitaxial Growth of Metal Films. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 7.5.2 Growth of Si on Si(OOI) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 7.6 Chemical Reactions on Metals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 7.6.1 Reaction on Ni(1lO) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 7.6.2 Reaction on Cu(llO) .. .. .. .. . .. . .. .. .. .... 7.6.3 Chemical Identity with STM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 7.7 Chemical Reaction on Semiconductors . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 7.7.1 Reaction of NH 3 with Si( 111)-7 x7 Surfaces , 7.7.2 Reaction of NH 3 with B/Si(lII)-V3 Xv3 Surface .. , 7.7.3 Reaction of NH 3 with Clean Si(OOI) Surface , 7.7.4 Si(lII)-7x70xidation 7.7.5 Si( 100)-2 X1 Oxidation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 7.7.6 Reaction ofH withSi(111)-7x7 7.7.7 Reaction of Sb4 with Si(100) , 8. Biological Applications I. • • • • • 8.1 Advantages and Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1.1 Substrates........................... 8.1.2 Fixation of Samples onto Substrates . . . . . . . . . . 8.1. 3 Flexibility of Biological Samples. . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1.4 Identification and Interpretation of STM Images . . 8.2 Preparation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.1 Dispersion of Samples on Substrates . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.2 Fixation of Samples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . a) Sample Coatings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . b) Covalently Binding Samples with Strongly Absorbent Groups . . . . . . . . . . c) Binding Samples to the Substrate Covalently. . . 8.2.3 STM Imaging in Acqueous Solutions. . . . . . . . . . 8.2.4 Hopping Technique. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.5 STM Directed by an Optical Microscope . . . . . . . 8.3 Nucleic Acids. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.1 DNA in Air and in Vacuum. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.2 DNA Studies Under Water with an Electrolyte. . . . 8.3.3 DNA-Protein Complex . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.4 DNA Bases. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.5 DNA Sequencing by Scanning-Probe Microscopes . 8.4 Proteins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4.1 Animo Acids and Peptides . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4.2 Structural Proteins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4.3 Functional Proteins. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5 Biological Membranes 8.6 Imaging Cells and Other Applications. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.7 Force Spectrum Analysis of Biological Materials. . . . . . .
261 262 265 265 268 269 271 271 273 274 274 276 276 277
•• 279 .. 279 280 .. 280 .. 281 .. 281 .. 282 .. 282 .. 283 .. 283
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..
283 284 284 284 286 287 287 289 292 292 294 296 296 298 299 301 .. 302 .. 306 XII!
9. Surface Modification. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 9.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ., .. '" 9.2 Direct Indentation with the Tunneling Tip. . . . . .. 9.2.1 Modification of Metal Surfaces , . 9.2.2 Modification of Semiconductor Surfaces . 9.3 Nanolithography on Resist Films . 9.4 Nanofabrication in Solution and in Gaseous Environments. 9.4.1 Nanofabrication in Solution . 9.4.2 Nanofabrication in Gaseous Environments . 9.5 Atomic-Scale Manipulation . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 9.5.1 Manipulation of Atoms . a) Xenon Atoms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . b) Iron Atom . c) Silicon Atom . d) Sulfer Atoms. . .. . . 9.5.2 Manipulation of Molecules and Clusters . a) Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . b) Antimony Molecules . c) Decaborane and Other Organic Molecules. d) H2 0 Molecules. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ., .,. 9.6 Quantization of Conductance in Nano-Contacts Produced by STM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .., 9.7 Fabrication with Other Scanning-Probe Microscopes 9.7.1 Machining Thin Films . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.7.2 Charge Storage . . . . . . . . . .. . . 9.7.3 Magnetic Structures and Writing into an Interface 9.8 The Future , .
309 309 310 311 317
321 324 324 325 327 327 327 330 331 333 333 333 333 336 336 338 339 339 340 343 343
References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
345
Subject Index
367
XIV
.
1. Introduction
In 1981, Binnig and Rohrer [1.1] and their colleagues at the Zurich Research Laboratory of the International Business Machines (IBM) developed a new kind of surface analytical instrument - Scanning Tunneling Microscope (STM). The emergence of STM makes it possible to observe the arrangement of individual atoms on material surfaces, and physical and chemical properties related to the behavior of surface electrons in real space. This technique is revolutionizing surface science and the way we study surface phenomena. G. Binnig and H. Rohrer were awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1986 for their outstanding contribution to science. In the following, we will briefly review the advantages of STM compared with other surface-analysis techniques.
1.1 Advantages of STM Compared with Other Techniques A number of modern instruments for surface structural and chemical analysis [1.2,3] such as the Field Ion Microscope (FIM), the Field Emission Microscope (FEM), Low-Energy Electron Diffraction (LEED), Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES), Electron Spectroscopy for Chemical Analysis (ESCA), Electron-Probe Microanalysis (EPM), etc. have emerged following the invention of the first Electron Microscope (EM) by E. Ruska and M. Knoll in Berlin in 1931. The development and application of these techniques have played an important role in the field of surface science. However, each of these techniques has certain strengths and limitations. LEED and X-ray diffraction techniques rely on large-scale order, and can at best give averaged information about local and defect structure; a Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) requires samples with strong corrugation or mass contrast and its resolutions is not high enough to resolve surface atoms; high-resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) can in some cases resolve features with atomic dimensions of specially thinned samples. In most cases this can be accomplished only by aligning the electron beam with the rows of atoms in a crystalline lattice. FEM and FIM are only able to probe the two-dimensional geometry of atomic structure on the
surfaces of sharp tips with radii less than 100 nm. In addition, sample preparation is rather complicated. For FIM the samples must be stable in high fields, thus limiting its general usefulness. Some other surface analytical techniques, such as X-ray Photoemission Spectroscopy (XPS), Ultraviolet Photoemission Spectroscopy (UPS) and Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (EELS), in fact, can only provide spatially averaged information of electronic structures. Moreover, some of the techniques mentioned above require high-vacuum environment and can only provide indirect results or strongly rely upon model systems for data interpretation. Until the STM was introduced, it still remained a dream to directly observe geometric and electronic surface structures on the atomic level at ambient pressure and at room temperature. Compared with other surface analytical techniques, there are several reasons for the diversity of STM and STM-based technological applications: • STM can achieve atomic-level resolution. The lateral and vertical resolutions can reach 0.1 nm and 0.01 nm, respectively, i.e., individual atoms and molecules can be resolved. Figure 1.1 compares the resolution of STM with that of other kinds of microscopes. The higher vertical resolution of STM relative to other microscopes also offers advantages with regard to qualitative analysis of surface roughness on a nanometer scale . • STM can be performed in different environments, such as vacuum, air, low or high temperature, etc. Samples can even be immersed in water or other solutions under potential control. In most cases, special techniques for sample preparation are not required, and samples remain mostly free of
--,
10
3
HMI
_.:.it
E
I
.s
I
~
os ~ Oi .~
~
I
PC~J
10- 1
10- 1
2
I
10\
10 1 10 3 Lateral scale [nm]
lOS
1.2 From Optical Microscopy to Scanning Tunneling Microscopy Scanning tunneling microscopy is the product of considerable evolution. Microscopy appears to have begun in the 15 th century when simple magnifying glasses were made with which to observe insects. Although tiny objects such as bacteria and cells become visible, the resolution of optical microscopes is limited by the value of the wavelength of visible light. Since the shortest wavelength of visible light is 0.4 /lm, the highest resolution of optical microscopes is only 0.2 /lm. In order to probe atomic structures, a new light source with a shorter wavelength is needed .
lOS
~
damage. With these advantages, STM is especially suitable for in-situ electrochemical studies, biological studies, and the evaluation of sample surfaces under various experimental conditions. • The other unique feature of the STM is its truly local interaction on the atomic scale rather than the averaged properties of the bulk phase or of a large surface area, which allows the study of individual surface adsorbates, surface defects, surface reconstructions, and adsorption-induced surface reconstructions at unprecedented resolution. • Three-dimensional images of the surface and the solid-fluid interface in real space can be obtained in real time, independent of the sample's periodicity. This capability allows in-situ imaging of some dynamical processes taking place on surfaces and at the solid-fluid interface. • Local surface electronic properties such as charge-density waves, the changes of surface barrier and energy gap, as well as spectroscopic images, can be provided by STM performed with related techniques. • STM can be employed for the modification of a surface and for the manipulation of atoms and molecules through tip-sample interactions, opening up the prospects of constructing atomic- or melecular-scale devices.
Fig. I. I. Comparison of the resolution range of STM with that of other microscopes [1.1]. [HM: High-resolution optical Microscope. PCM: Phase Contrast Microscope. (S)TEM: (Scanning) Transmission Electron Microscope. FlM: Field Ion Microscope. REM: Reflection Electron Microscope]
1.2.1 Electron Microscopes The first successful exploration of atomic structures grew out of a basic discovery of quantum mechanics. It is that light and other kinds of energy exhibit characteristics of both waves and particles. In 1927 C.J. Davison and L.H. Germer confirmed experimentally the wave nature of the electron. They also found that a high-energy electron has a shorter wavelength than a 3
low-energy electron. This achievement, together with the establishment of geometrical electron optics, led to the invention of the first electron microscope by E. Ruska and M. Knoll in 1931. Since then several types of electron microscopes have been developed. In SEM an electron probe which has the smallest cross-section of the elctron beam after acceleration, is scanned or rastered over a region of the specimen. The image is displayed on a Cathode-Ray Tube (CRT) deflected in synchronism. The smallest diameter of the electron probe is limited by the minimum-acceptable electron probe current, which is determined by the need to generate an adequate signal-to-noise ratio, and by the spherical aberration of the final probe-forming lens [1.4]. SEM mostly operates in the range E = 10 --;- 20 KeV.I At higher energies, the electron range and the diameter of the electron-diffusion region are larger. Decreasing the electron energy has the advantage that information can be extracted from a volume nearer to the surface, but the diameter of the electron probe increases owing to the decrease of gun brightness. A slowly-moving electron is easily deflected by electrostatic and magnetic fields near the sample surface. Charging effects have to be avoided by coating specimens with a thin conduct ice film, for example, and organic and biological specimens have to be protected from surface distortions by fixation or cryo-techniques. The resolution of SEM is not high enough to resolve atomic structures. In TEM a thin specimen is irradiated with an electron beam of uniform current density emitted from the electron gun; the electron energy is in the range 60 --;- 150 KeV or 200 KeV --;- 3 MeV in the case of intermediate- or high-voltage electron microscopes [1.5]. A two-stage condensor-lens system permits variation of the illumination aperture and an area of the specimen under illumination. The electron-density distribution behind the specimen is imaged with a three- or four-stage lens system onto a fluorescent screen. Electrons interact strongly with atoms by elastic and inelastic scattering. The specimen must therefore be very thin, typically of the order of 5nm --;0.5j.Lm for 100 KeV electrons, depending on the density and elemental composition of the sample and the resolution required. Although TEM has proved to be extremely successful in observing projections of atomic rows and even atomic orbitals in thin crystalline films, it can not resolve surface structures except under very special circumstances. A high-energy electron penetrates deep into the specimen and so reveals little of the surface structure.
1.2.2 Field Ion Microscope In 1951, E.W. Muller made some progress when he invented the Field Ion Microscope (FIM), an instrument that is highly sensitive to surfaces [1.6, 7]. In this technique gas atoms (H2 , He) are field-ionized near the tipshaped sample at a high positive voltage, accelerated by an electric field, then fly to the cathode screen along the direction of electric field lines. Thus a so-called field-ion image corresponding to the atomic arrangements on the tip surface is displayed on the screen. In order to achieve a strong electric field on the surface, the sample must sit on a fine tip, or be prepared in the shape of a tip with radius of curvature ranging from several ten to several hundred Angstroms. This rather complicated sampte-preparation technique, as well as the characteristic of the technique that the sample must be stable against the high electric fields limit the broad application of FIM.
1.2.3 Scanning Tunneling Microscope The principle of operation of the STM makes it possible to avoid the aforementioned difficulties. The main differences between the STM and all other microscopes is that there is no need for lenses and special light or electron sources. Instead the bound electrons already existing in the sample under investigation serve as the exclusive source of radiation [1.8,9]. Conventional STM is based on the control of the tunneling current I through the potential barrier between the surface to be investigated and the probing metal tip. If a small bias voltage is applied between the sample surface and the tip (in the best case, an atomically sharp tip), a tunneling current will flow between the tip and sample when the gap between them is reduced to a few atomic diameters. It takes advantage of the strong dependence of the tunneling probability of electrons on the electrode separation. There it is well known that the tunneling current (at a low bias voltage VT and low temperature) behaves as
z
18~k eff 2kd 10 4 0 d A e-
(1. 1)
where 2k [A-I] = 1.0254>1/2 reV], 4> is the average work function, assumed equal to the mean barrier height between the two electrodes. Aeff = 7r X (l/2L eff )2 is the effective area determining the lateral resolution L eff z 2 X [(R t +d)/k]l/2 which applies when the separation d becomes smaller than the radius R( of the tip. For typical metals (4) z 5eV) the predicted change I The symbol --;- is used throughout the text as a shorthand for "from -to" or "between ". 4
5
(b)
~a)
Vz (Vx• V y) --> z (x, y)
yD
InI (Vx' Vy) --> ,f(p. z (x, y)
Fig. 1.2a, b. Schematic view of two modes of operation in STM [1. 10]. S is the gap between the tip and the sample, I and VT are the tunneling current and bias voltage, respectively, and Vz is the feedback voltage controlling the tip height along the z direction. (a) constant-current mode and (b) constant-height mode
in I by one order of magnitude for the change Lld :::::; 1 A has been verified. If the current is kept constant to within, e.g., 2 %, then the gap d remains constant to within 0.01 A. This fact represents the basis for interpreting the image as simply a contour of constant height above the surface. The STM can be operated in either the constant-current mode or the constant-height mode, as shown in Fig.l.2. In the basic constant-current mode of operation, the tip is scanned across the surface at constant tunneling current, which is maintained at a preset value by continuously adjusting the vertical tip position with the feedback voltage Vz' In the case of an electronically homogeneous surface, constant current essentially means constand d so the topographic height of surface features of a sample can be measured by raster scanning the tip in an x-y scan over the surface and deriving the height of the surface from Vz . The height of the tip z(x, y) as a function of position is read and processed by a computer, and displayed on a screen or a plotter. Alternatively, in the constant-height mode a tip can be scanned rapidly across the surface at nearly constant height and constant voltage V z while the tunneling current is monitored, as shown in Fig. 1.2b. In this case the feedback network is slowed to keep the average tunneling current constant or turned off completely. The rapid variations in the tunneling current due to the tip passing over surface features are recorded and plotted as a function of scan position. Each mode has its own advantages. The basic constant-current mode was originally employed and can be used to track surfaces which are not atomically flat. The height of surface features can be derived from Vz and the sensitivity of the piezoelectric driver element. On the other hand, a disadvantage of this mode is that the finite response time of the feedback network and of the piezoelectric driver set relatively low limits for the scan 6
speed. The constant-height mode allows for much faster imaging of atomically flat surfaces since the feedback loop and the piezoelectric driver do not have to repond to the surface features passing under the tip. Fast imaging is important since it may enable researchers to study dynamic processes on surfaces as well as reducing data-collection time. Fast imaging also minimizes the image distortion due to piezoelectric creep, hysteresis and thermal drifts (Sect.4.2.1). In contrast to the constant-current mode, however, deriving the topographic height information from the recorded variations of the tunneling current in the constant-height mode is not easy because a separate determination of <1>1/2 is required to calibrate z. In both modes, the tunneling voltage and/or the z position can be modulated to obtain, in addition, information about local spectroscopy and/or the spatially resolved local tunneling barrier height, respectively (Sect.3.2). For a more detailed description of other modes of operation, such as various tracking modes and differential microscopy, the reader is referred to the books [1.11-14].
1.3 Overview
When an atomically sharp tip is scanned across a plane of atoms in the constant-current imaging mode yielding an image with sub-Angstrom corrugations, it is not known exactly from experiments what distance might play the role of d in (1.1). Moreover, since tunneling involves states at the Fermi level, which may themselves have a complex spatial structure, we must expect that the electronic structure of the surface and tip may enter into the equation in a complex way. Equation (1.1), based on analogy with the onedimensional tunneling problem, is rather simple and therefore the full threedimensional tunneling problem as it relates to STM must be considered. These theoretical concepts will be described in Chap. 2. In addition to delineating the atomic topography of a surface STM has made it technically possible for scientists to probe directly the electronic structures of materials at an atomic level by spatially resolved tunneling spectroscopy. Spectroscopy and spectroscopic imaging of STM will be introduced in Chap.3. The lateral resolution of the surface is limited by the sharpness of the tip. What should be the shape of the tip and how is it achieved? How can one avoid mechanical vibrations that move the tip and sample against each other? How can a tip be moved with respect to the sample on a fine scale over long distances? These main instrumental problems and their solutions will be discussed in ChapA. 7
STM has shown that it is possible to control and scan a tip over a conducting surface with Angstrom precision. This same generic principle of STM has been applied to many other novel Scanning-Probe Microscopes (SPM). In Chap.5, the developments in the areas of atomic-force microscopy, lateral-force microscopy, magnetic-force microscopy, bal1istic electron-emission microscopy, electrostatic-force microscopy, scanning ionconductance microscopy, scanning thermal microscopy, scanning tunneling potentionmetry, photon scanning tunneling microscopy, and near-field scanning optical microscopy will be highlighted by results from each area which illustrate the potential of these techniques to provide new information about the physical properties of surfaces on an atomic or nanometer scale. At the early stage of the development and application of STM, mainly surface physicists were engaged since they knew how to built such instruments. In the meantime, STM and related techniques have enjoyed a rapid and sustained growth that is phenomenal for a new branch of science. As of summer 1999, numerous papers and books [1,15-21] on the theories, techniques and applications of STM and SPM have been published, and over 30 companies have manufactured and marketed SPMs and parts of it. Ten international STM conferences have been held since 1986 (Table 1.1). The STM and related techniques have entered many disciplines in physics, chemistry, biology, metrology and materials science. STMs not only allowed the study of surface structures, but also modify surfaces from one micrometer down to the atomic scale. The application of the surface structure of metals, semiconductors, surface adsorption, biological materials and nanofabrication will be outlined in Chaps.6-9. Further details on STM theory and applications can be found in those books and proceedings of STM conferences which have already been mentioned above. Table 1.1. Number of paper presentations at early conferences
Year Date
Location
Country
Number
Ref.
1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999
Santiago de Compostela Oxnard. CA Oxford Oarai Baltimore, MD Interlaken Beijing Colorado Hamburg Seoul
Spain USA UK Jap.:m USA Switzerland China USA Gennan)' Korea
59 110 157 213 357 580
12L
July 14-18 July 20-24 July 4-8 July 9-14 July 23-27 August 12-16 August 9-13 July 23-28 July 20-25 July 18-23
464
1.23 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.27 1.28
Fig. 1. 3. Observation of ultra-fine metal panicles in the constant current mode
dT
--..."
/-,
~h I
-_/
//
,_
.----........ ......
~ '~\ partIcle
r--2nm--+--lnm-l
'
_
Substrate
In its brief history, STM has developed into an invaluable and powerful surface and interface analysis technique. However, STM has certain limitations and its operation at the atomic resolution is far from routine. A better knowledge of the role played by the microscopic structure of the probing tip is needed. The size, nature and chemical identity of the tip influence not only the resolution and shape of a STM scan but also the electronic structure to be measured. Although the well-defined tip at the end with one atom can be achieved, a tip with known geometry is not available by a convenient technique, such as electrochemical etching or grounding. The apex of such a tip is also limited by the mechanical stability of th~ tip during the STM scanning process. Moreover, as we can see from the principles of STM, it cannot probe precisely the shape and depth of narrow grooves on the surface in the constant-current mode of operation. This problem is illustrated in Fig. 1.3 for the study of ulrrafine metal particles. The broken line followed by a tip presents a rather narrow separation of particles, and the diameter of the metal particles appears enlarged in the STM topographic Image. Another limitation of the STM technique is its lack of chemical sensitivity although several routes have been proposed to attack this problem [1.29-31 ]. There is already a shift from unreliable instruments to STMs routinely usable by laboratory technicians, allowing researchers to concentrate on the physics of the surface of interest rather than on the instrument itself. The prospect for the future of STM and related SPMs is sure to be as exciting as that of the past decade.
478 826 372
8 9
2. The Tunneling Effect
The tunneling effect originates from the wavelike properties of particles in quantum mechanics. When a particle is incident upon a barrier with a potential energy larger than the kinetic energy of the particle, there is a non-zero probability that it may traverse the forbidden region and reappear on the other side of the barrier; in the classical case the result can be zero (Fig. 2.1). If the lion shown in Fig.2.l is replaced by a wave function of a particle with mass m (Fig.2.2) the tunneling effect becomes more pronounced. In Fig.2.2a, 4>0 is the potential of a simple rectangular barrier and E is the kinetic energy of the particle, and the probability P for the particle to traverse the barrier with thickness d (Fig.2.2b) is given by P cc e- 2kd
(2.1)
,
where k
=
J2m(4)0 - E)/fz 2
.
The physical picture of the tunneling effect is illustrated in Fig.2.2.
Impenetrable barrier
Tunnel effect
Classical mechanics
Quantum mechanics
Fig. 2.1. The difference between classical theory and quantum theory, illustrating tunneling through a potential barrier [2.17) 11
(a)
(b)
:I
1\ !\
0..
~'I
I
I
I
I\!
(b)
.
I
-<
-Sl
(a)
I
I
'"0.. E
8
1"---+1_I I ~
o
10
'"2
u
7
<'6
d
-
~ 2'" u
Fig.2.2. (a) A simple rectangular barrier potential of height <1>0' (b) The probability density function P for typical (rectangular) barrier penetration [2.17)
~
6 5
0.1
4 3
~ 2 I 0"""""'--
2.1 Historical Remarks
I
I
10
I
I
40
50
I
20 30 Millivolts [mV]
0.01' 0
I
I
2
4
,
,
I
6 8 10 Millivolts [mV]
I
I
12
14
Fig. 2.3. (a) At low voltages, the current through a thin oxide film is proportional to both the voltage and the film area. Curves shown are for five films with areas in the proportions of 5: 4: 3: 2: 1. (b) At higher voltages. the current increases exponentially with voltage [2. 5)
The tunneling effect is often said to be as old as quantum mechanics, and has, indeed, offered a theoretical foundation that successfully explains a lot of physical phenomena. Its earliest application of importance in the history of quantum mechanics was the interpretation of nuclear a-decay. Although the kinetic energy of a-particles emitted from a nucleus in a radioactive decay may vary by a factor of only 2 or 3, the decay probability can span a range of 24 orders of magnitude. Gamow [2.1], and Gurney and Condon [2.2] solved this problem independently in 1928. In accordance with the theory of the tunneling effect, the dependence of the lifetime T of the radioactive particles, and the energy E of the emitted a particle is given by
10 4
10 3
~
/
.- /
b-
/
/. V=O
I /
N
148 _ 53.5 . Ig(T [s]) ::::: VE [MeV]
E
(2.2)
u
c::: 8 10 2
/
c::
This equation has successfully been applied to the problem of nuclear a-decay. In the mid-fifties [2.3,4], further studies on the conductivity of MetalInsulator (quite thin)-Metal (M-I-M) samples were reported. The tunneling current should be measurable when the intermediate insulating layer (usually an air-oxidized metal layer) is thin enough « 10nm). The current-voltage relationship is linear at low bias «50mV) and grows exponentially at high bias, as depicted in Fig.2.3 [2.5]. The resistance increases roughly exponentially with the oxide thickness (Fig. 2.4). When a bias is applied to a MIM structure such as that sketched in Fig. 2.5, the tunneling probability should be considered in the calculation of the net current flow for all conduction electrons above the Fermi energy. The 12
'" '"
.;'
'"
/
/
.
e.
• I· · •
'"
cG
·1 10 I
b-
I
,,"/ V=I.O
/
/
/"
/
/ Fig.2.4. The resistence of oxide films tends to increase exponentially with the thickness. (Films formed in air at room temperature)
/,g
"" "t/''' I , 10 01 4
!
5
[2.5) 6 7 Thickness [nm)
8
13
(3)
(b)
Elastic tunnel current
Fig. 2. 5. Metal-insulator-metal tunnel junction. Two metal electrodes at T = 0 K. The electron energy levels are filled up to the Fermi energy. Electrons in the occupied states of the left electrode may tunnel elastically to the empty states of the right electrode
tunneling probability depends on the kinetic energy of the motion perpendicular to the barrier. In the simple free-electron model the current density J takes the form
J
=
h2e
I J P(Ez)[f(E) - f(E +eV)]dE z ' k
(2.3)
Ez (
where the tunneling probability P depends on the kinetic energy E z associated with the motion perpendicular to the barrier, and the Fermi occupation function f depends on the total energy of the electron E and the applied bias V. Summation over k( determines the total contribution of the electrons with the same E z and hence the same P(E z). These states may lie on an annulus or disc in k-space, as shown in Fig. 2.6, and the total current density at T = 0 K becomes
2
J(V) -
J
h
become a significant fraction of the barrier height
EF-eV
47rme V h3 0
47rme +-3
Fig.2.6. States of constant tunneling probability for (a) k z :5: k :5: k ::;; ; (b) k min min z k max [2. 17]
J
P(E , V)dE z z
Metal
~
EF
(E F -E) z P(E z' V)dE z ' EF-eV
tOrganiC
~'5'f Oxide
(2.4)
Metal
Fig. 2.7. Schematic diagram of a tunnel sandwich with organic dopant chemisorbed on oxide barrier
where the probability P is virtually constant. This gives a linear dependence of the current on the applied bias at low voltages. If the bias is increased to 14
15
10
JO
I
I I I I
_ _ _ p - Acetylbenzoic acid 1050n - - - - Perylene carboxylic acid 1570n
8 6
4.3~
I
:> ~
I
4
AI-AIOx-Pb
.//<'/ ..:.:.:::-::=--
2 ~
.§. 0
.,
.L:
~
2.9r
...
"E
co '"
-4
Perylene 1790 n
-6
2 - Nitronaphthalene 2000n
6.1
4.8
4.8
~
3.2
3.0
2.3
---VA-- 2.5
I
2.1
m-Dinitrobenzene
..c
-2
~
8.4
8.1
0
.00
~
-
6.9
lOr 4.8 2.8
~
0- Dinitro-
benzene
~
O.lnm
3,4-Dinitrobenzoic acid
9.1 ~
7.5
6.7
/ ~2.5
-8 -10--1.6 -1.2 -0.8 -0.4
0 0 0.4 U (V]
0.8
1.2
1.6
Fig.2.8. Characteristic I-V curves recorded for four different ring compound doped on AIO ' The resistances are in the range of 1000 +2000 and all junctions have the same area x (=0.015mm2) so that the large differences in nonlinear behavior are intrinsic to the dopant
n
compound [2.6)
I,F
cI»
>
p - Chlorobenzoic acid
10
~
6.6
.L: 00 '03 .c
... ......'" co '"
..............
f
(b)
cl>3
:...= 2il
Metal B
Fig. 2.9. TRAPSQR barrier used to model the combination aluminum oxide-<Jrganic tunneling barrier. Five parameters have been used, the barrier heights ell I . ell 2 , ell 3 and thicknesses dands [2.6]
(a)
O.lnm Coronene
CyclohexaneCOOH
3.6
oI
)
•..
VA
I
I V.J
V/-O.'
I ' v..
-Y/d-
O. I nrp
I-Pyrene ca-rboxaldehyde
Fig. 2.10. (a) Representative TRAPSQR barriers resulting from computer fits for various organic dopants. These compounds all show a relatively high effective organic barrier heights ell 3 . (b) Calculated barriers for the three dopant compounds which show low effective barrier heights, strong nonlinear behaviour and high asymmetries at high bias voltages [2.6]
2.2 Tunneling-Current Theory
Many articles about the tunneling theory have been published since the appearance of STM. All those theories are based on Bardeen's tunneling current formalism [2.7]. It is given by [2.8]
27fe '\"' -11- L f(EI-')[1 - feE. +eV)] !MI-"
2
I
o(EI-' -E.) ,
(2.5)
1-'-,11 16
17
where f(E) is the Fenni function, V the applied voltage, MI-'" the tunneling matrix element between states 1/;/l of the probe and 1/;" of the surface; E/l and E" are the energies of states 1/;1-' and 1/;" ' respectively, in the absence of tunneling. M/l" is detennined by [2.~]
M/l V
=
f/2
2m
I
* dS'(1/;/l* V1/;" - 1/;v V1/;/l) ,
(a) (b)
Ve(x)
(2.6)
where the integral is over any surface lying entirely within the vacuum (barrier) region separating the two sides. Almost all the theories for the tunneling current are based on (2.5,6), but they describe some elements such as the eigenstates 1/; /l and 1/;" of the barrier of a tunneling junction, and the influence of temperature and bias in different ways. At elevated temperatures there is a corresponding tenn for reverse tunneling; generally, however, we consider the cases at a small voltage and a low temperature.
x,(E)
8(x) =
1/;E (r)
The dynamics of the free-electron model of a metal-vacuum contact are described by the SchrOdinger equation
E
f/2 \72
2m
]
+ V e (x) - E 1/;E (r)
=
0 .
8(x)(~
+
Fx)
1 (x > 0) (x::; 0) .
o
x
(2.9)
exp(ik · p) tl AI/2 XEx(X),
XE (x)
{
(2. lOa)
f/2
~+Ex 2m x
Ve(x)
{+
f/2k 2
(2.7)
The direction nonnal to the planar surface of the metal-vacuum contact is taken to be the x axis and the potential V e (x) is that indicated in Figs. 2.IIa,b. The Fermi energy of the free-electron model denoted by t and
x2 (E x )
Inserting the potential function into (2.7) gives the relevant solutions
2.2.1 Tunneling Current
[ -
xl(E x )
Fig. 2.11. (a) Schematic illustration of the potential energy at a metal-vacuum interface. The Fermi energy of the free-electron metal is denoted by f (b) Classical turning points xI (Ex) and x2 (Ex) of an electron energy Ex < Vm incident on the potential barrier at a metallic interface
2m (k 11 2
+ kx2 ),
(2. lOb)
exp(ikxx) + Rexp(-ikxx) (x < 0) T[B i (7/) + iA j (7/)]
(x
>
0)
(2.11 )
with _ [ 7/ - - K F X
+
Ex-~-
,KF
_ [2mF]I/3
-
f/2
.
In (2.10) A denotes the area of the planar contact, p is a vector in the plane of the contact, and the functions Ai (7/) and Bi (7/) are the two linearly independent solutions to Airy's equation. These functions oscillate in the region x > Xl (Ex) (Fig. 2.lla) with the asymptotic form A j (7/) ~ (-n-- 2 17/D-I/4 s in(-Y+7r/4),
(2.8)
Bi (7/)
~
(7r217/D-I/4cos(r+7r/4),
(2.12a) (2.12b)
with with 18
19
'Y
=
(2/3)( MD312
(2.12c)
.
Therefore, X shows the asymptotic behaviour for x
»
XE (x) ~ T(-1l, z l77D- I/4 exp[i('Y+?r/4)],
XI (Ex) (2.13)
x
which represents an outgoing wave. The probability current normal to the interface is expressed as
1
iii [d'.j;*
d1/;)
2m
dx
= -1/;--1/;*dx
liK F =-ITlz. ?rm
(2.14)
The transmission probability D of the barrier is defined as the ratio of the current 1 to the probability current 10 = (lik/m) of the "incident" plane wave Xo = exp(ikx). For the triangular barrier discussed D(Ex,k ll )
=
D(E x)
D(EJ
=
= llJ o '
I
+ Xz, Z)
=
B j (77o) - vA/(77o) ,
(2.15c)
Xz
=
Ai (770) + VW(77o) ,
(2.15d)
with 770
=
Kp(cp +~-EJ/F.
The usual exponential barrier penetration probabilities may be obtained from (2.15) by using the asymptotic forms for the Airy functions valid when 770 » 1. It is given by [2.10]
D(E x)
=
4(~
+ cP
- E
)I/Z
x
~+cP
20
'Y(770)
=
~ (I
K
F
(2.19)
,
x
=
(2s+l)eI 3
(2?r) Ii
[aE] dk
f(E) D(E x) ak
x
Z xd k II '
(2.20)
supposing that all electrons (of spin s and charge -e) which escape from the metal are swept away by the external field so that no space charge accumulates near the interface. For the free-electron model, the dependence of D upon Ex can be utilized conveniently by noting that, as
aE ak x
-z"o
(2.16)
e,
aE x =
ak x
00
J
=
exp[(E-~)!KT]
for this model, (2.20) can be written as
E I/ z
in which 'Yo is defined by substitution of 770 in (2.12c)
'Yo
I +
(2.15b)
XI
Kp/k,
=
where K is Boltzmann's constant, and T denotes the temperature. Therefore, the current per unit area may be written as
1
=
(2.18)
For example, from the phenomenological point of view, EII(k ) = liZ z ll xk ll /2m*, and m* in the metal is not equal to m in the vacuum. Hence, the dependence of D upon E and k ll (rather than upon Ex alone) must be recognized explicitly in calculations of the emission current. The general expression for the emission current is obtained by summing the expectation values of the current operator in the eigenstates of (2.7) over the occupied electronic states. The thermal occupation probability of a state with energy E relative to the minimum of the conduction band is
(2.15a)
where
v
Ex = E - E11(k ll ) .
f(E)
and 4v -(X ?r I Z
A major consequence of the free-electron model is the dependence of D only on Ex· More generally, D is taken to be a function of k , both of ll which are conserved in the tunneling transition and related to Ex via
(~ +; -
Ex)
r
I
~
e
fa OrE,) N(E,)dE, '
(2.2Ia)
z (2.17)
21
I I 00
+
2s- 3 1 -
N(EX>
(2 7r ) fJ
=
(2s +
_
dk y
00
00
Fig. 2.12. Schemalic picture of tunnel ing geomelry. The probe tip has an arbilrary shape, but il is assumed 10 be locally spherical with a radius of curvature R where it comes c10sesl to lhe surface (shaded). The dislance of neareSl approach is d. Cemer of curvature of lhe lip is labeled as rO [2.8]
dkzf(E)
_ 00
1)27rm[~:}n[1 + eXP[~=TEx]]
.
(2.21b)
The quantity N(E x) is calIed the supply function, and the product
P n (Ex>
=
(2.22)
D(E x) N(Ex> '
is referred to as the normal energy distribution. Now let us discuss the relation between the result of the metal-vacuum structure and the general equations (2.5,6). The crux of the matter is what to assume for the wave functions ¢til. and ¢tv appearing in (2.6). In the metal-vacuum structure discussed before, we obtain the wave function by solving (2.7) with the condition that the form of the potential barrier Ve (x) in (2.7) is assumed to be in the form of (2.8), and ¢til. and ¢tv are combined as one function, namely (2.10). Then the general expression of the emission current is obtained by summing the expectation values of the current operator in the eigenstates of (2.7) over the occupied electronic states.
2.2.2 Practical Tip and Surface Wave Functions The forms of the wave functions of both the tip and the surface are important. The sample wave function may be expressed by the expansion [2.8]
¢tv
= 0;1/2
L aG exp[-(k2 + Ik G I2)1/2
Z]
exp(ikG'x),
proaches closest to the surface, as illustrated in Fig.2.12. R is the local center of the radius of curvature, and d is the distance of the closest approach to the surface. In the region of interest, the wave functions of the tip are taken to have the asymptotic spherical form
=
(If
I
[
r - ro
I
exp(-klr-rol),
(2.24)
where Or is the probe volume, and k is defined as above. (For simplicity, the work function lp for the tip is assumed to be equal to that of the surface). Nonnalization requires that the parameter C[ (which is determined by the tip geometry, the detailed electronic structure, and the tip-vacuum boundary conditions) is of the order 1. The possible angular dependence of ¢til. is neglected in (2.24). Since
e- k Ir I
(2.23)
I
2 d qb(q) exp[ -(k 2 +q2)1/2/ z
klrl
G
which represent a general expression for ¢t in the region of negligible potential. Here Os is the sample volume, k = fJ- I (2mlp))/2 is the minimum inverse decay length for the wave functions in vacuum, lp is the work function, and kG = kll+G, k ll being the surface Bloch wave vector of the state, and G a surface reciprocal-lattice vector. The first few factors a G are typicalIy of the order unity. For a non-periodic surface the sum over G becomes an integral. Since the microscopic structure of the tip is not yet known, we choose a form for the tip wave function given by Tersojj and Hamann [2.8]. They assumed that the tip structure is 10calIy a spherical potential welI which ap-
kRe kR
o-I/2 C
¢tIL
IJ eiq'x ,
(2.25)
with b(q)
=
_1_[1 + q2]_112 27rk 2 k2
(2.26)
the wave function of the tip, (2.24), can be expanded into the form of the wave function of the sample surface, (2.23), by using (2.25 and 26). Then the matrix element can be evaluated almost trivialIy. Substituting the surface and the tip wave functions into (2.6) one finds
22 23
M IlV
=
112 1 n- 1/ 2kRe kR .J. (c ) -41rk2m ( 'f'v 0
(2.27)
'
with
21r
-,;-e
2
y
L IMllvI2o(Ev-EF)O(EIl-EF)'
(2.28)
where a is measured in 0- 1 , the distances in a.u., and the energy in eY. Since
It/tv (CO)/2
Substituting (2.27) into (2.28) yields the desired result
L It/t v (c )/2 o(E v -E O
F) ,
(2.29)
(2.30b)
II
/l,1I
321r 3 11- 1 e2 Y (f'2 D t (E F )R2 k- 4 e 2kR
L It/tv(co)12o(Ev~EF)'
8(co ,E F )
where Co is the position of the center of curvature of the tip. If the applied bias and the temperature are very small, (2.5) can be written as
ex e- 2k (R +
we see from (2.30) that a ex e- 2kd as expected, and the other factors in this formula can be regarded as a coefficient. Due to the conductance's exponential dependence on distance, it is not essential to know the coefficient in (2.30) accurately.
II
where D( is the density of states per unit volume of the probe tip. Note that (2.28) does not imply that the value of the surface wave function t/t v at Co is physically relevant. The matrix element is determined by an integral entirely confined to within the gap region. However, because of the analytic properties of (2.23,24), the formal evaluation of t/t v at the distance R+d correctly describes the lateral average due to the finite tip size. The spherical-tip approximation has only entered into the normalization, see (2.24). The crucial matter was the evaluation of the matrix element for an s-wave tip wave function. The q dependence of b(q) in (2.26) then cancels that of the z derivative in the matrix element of (2.6), so that (2.29) involves only undistorted wave functions at the surface. For tip wave functions with angular dependence (L ;r. 0), it is sufficient to include the corresponding angular quantum number M = 0 term (other M's give a node towards the surface). In this case the terms in the Fourier expansion of t/t are weighted by a factor ex (l +q2/k 2)1/2 in the matrix element, which for relevant values of q can be approximated by one for small L (in the example below the relevant q2/k 2 :::::: 0.1). The tip model therefore becomes less accurate for large R, where higher L values become more important. An exact treatment would probably be far less useful since it would require more specific information about the tip wave functions, and would not reduce to an explicit equation such as (2.29 or 30) below. Substituting typical values for a metal into (2.29), one obtains for the tunneling conductance a :::::: 0.IR2e2kR8(co,EF)
(2.30a)
2.3 Tip-Surface Interaction Model 2.3.1 Tunneling Current
If the distance d between the tip and the surface is not very large (d :::::: several Angstroms) and the bias voltage is small, the tunnel Hamiltonian method [2.7J is valid for the description of the tunneling process [2.11]. In the independent-particles model, the tunneling current I is approximated as
I
=
21re
h
f
dE[f(E)- f(E+eY)JA(R,E,E+eY),
(2.31)
A (R,E, E')
: : : f dp f 0T
dp'YT(p)YT(p')gS(p+R,p'+R;E)gT(p',p;E')
(2.32)
0T
where gS and g T are the imaginary part of the Green's function of the surface and the tip, respectively:
S
gS(c,c';E) :::::
L t/t1l(c)t/t:(c')O(E-EI')
(2.33)
/l 24
25
Fig. 2.13. Geometry of the sample surface/tip system and potentials V s , V T defining the eigenfunctions 1/;JJ.' 1/;. of each system [2. 11)
so....... ----
/'
/ /
.-r
Tip
tion for the surface electronic state, the current contribution A(R, E, E + eV)dE from E to E+dE is expressed as
/
L L [ L C;p(R)Cjq *(R)o(E +eV -E.)] G(p,jq(E)
A(R,E,E +eV)
z Qr
ij pq
lJ
(2.35) with
--
G(p,jq(E)
V,Ol. I
(1/;p (r- R)I o(E- Hs )l1/;q (r-Rj ))
(2.36)
dp1/;:(p+R-R)V T (p)1/;.(p).
(2.37)
z
and
C~p(R)
E~ f\ f\ ~ t=l~===-~~ r----
=
j
°T
In the formulation above 1/;p (r-R j ) is the p-th atomic orbital on the site i. The tunneling matrix element C ip (R) reflects the geometrical relationship between the tip and the surface. The tunnel current is determined to by all the terms being the product of the tunneling matrix elements and the imaginary part of the surface Green's function, as displayed in Fig.2.14. For a large distance d between the tip and the surface, the tunnel current I is given by a large number of surface atoms whereas in the case of small d, I results only from a few atoms. This is due to the fact that the
1jI~
Vr z
E.
Tip
and T
gT(r,r';E)
=
L 1/;. (r)1/;:(r ' )o(E-E.) .
(2.34)
lJ
The integration of (2.32) is performed over the volume 0T of the tip, p and pi are the internal coordinates of the tip measured from the fixed point R, describing the relative position of the tip with respect to the surface. VT (p) represents the potential within the tip region. In (2.33,34), 1/;JJ.' EJJ. (1/;. ,E.) are, respectively, the eigenfunction and the eigenenergy of the electron on the surface (tip). They are defined in the potential field without the attractive part of the tip (surface), as shown in Fig. 2.13. A(R,E,E+eV) is calculated by solving (2.32) over the integral region E < E < E +eV (V > 0 case) to get the tunnel current for the tip posiF F tion R. In the LCAO (Linear Combination of Atomic Orbitals) representa-
~////~
\
~/)(E'-E.)/
\
/
vUrY
\
Q
/
r
/
\ \, e·(R)
,\:J
"
e·'(R) /
/
J/
Fig. 2.14. Schematic representation of factors composing the terms of A(R, E, E') [2. 11) 27
26
0
d(A) z
Lx
(0)1
c
~
T' : ' ' ' J t •
,-,
8
~
•
IC
i
I
J
L
I
2.3.2 Tunnel Conductance 7
5
3
i
I
I
(b)., 0.2 1
The derivative of (2.31) with respect to the bias voltage reads
:>
0
dI dV
1\ /]-02;
I
W ,
I
=
...,-0.4 I
I
21re 2 IiA(R, E F -e V, E F ) 2
- 21re Ii
I
J
E -eV F
dE
aA(R, E', E+eV) aE
EF
j
(d)
IE'=E
(2.38)
or dI
. . .. ...... .. .. ..
--
•
.... .. .. . . . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . .
I
I
~
,
d
dV
=
21re 2 IiA(R, E F , E F +eV)
E -eV
I
Fig. 2.15. (a) Contour plot of constant local density of states(dashed line) and contour of total charge density (solid line). Filled circles indicate the positions of carbon atoms of the top two layers. (b) Potential used for the interaction of tip and surface (schematic). (c) Compress and (d) expansion of graphite for the tip at points A and C of (a), respectively [2.131.
resolution of an STM device reduces with increasing d. In numerical simulation, more and more distant sites are involved in the summation in (2.35) with an increase of d. Then, the LCAO construction of the surface wave function becomes inappropriate. Methods should be developed to calculate the surface wave function in the far-tail region more efficiently. It is worth mentioning here that another important aspect of tip-sample interaction involves forces of various origins, which could lead to variations of the measured corrugations at high tunneling current, and induce photon emissions for some materials. Clark et al.[2.12] carefully examined the tipsample interactions on Cu(lOO) surfaces and concluded that the interaction has atomic site dependence. In addition, the impact of the interacting force on the corrugation measurement is more pronounced on soft material surfaces, such as graphite [2.13] (Fig. 2 .15).
+ 21re
2
aA(R, E', E+eV)
F
1i
JEF
dE
aE' E'=E
(2.39)
If g T , the imaginary part of the Green's function of the tip, does not highly depend on energy, the second term of (2.38) can be neglected. Then the tunnel conductance is given by 21re 2 IiA(R, E F -eV, E ), which stems from F the electronic states of the surface and the tip, where the energy is measured with respect to the Fermi level (Fig. 2 .16). It is in proportion to the surface Density of States (DOS) 9(R, E F -eV). For simple cases, see (2.30),
Sample surface
peR, EF-eV)J----t~ --=--::'~~E~= EF-eV E F .1-:/,,-,-,-,-,..--,
PT (E) P (E)
Fig. 2.16. Offset of the Ferm i level of the surface (E ) and that of the tip (E -eV) [2.111 F F 28
29
dI dV oc
4.0 ,
(2.40)
8(R,E F -eV).
I
(a)
i
I
I
.I"-..
I
30
If a cluster of atoms is used as the model of a protrusion on the tip, the width of the cluster energy levels should be introduced to take into account the embedding effect of the cluster on the remaining part of the tip. Thus the () function in (2.35) is replaced by the Lorentzian function
'
1.0
(2.41)
in the simulation. For a more sophisticated treatment the width ~(Ey) should be determined by the Green's function theory, but for most cases a constant value ~ may be substituted. Kobayashi and Tsukada [2.14] used a W 10 cluster as a model for the (Ill) protrusion of a tungsten tip and simulated STM/STS on a graphite surface. If the width ~ is assumed larger than 1 eV, good overall agreement between the calculated and the observed STM/STS data is obtained. In this case the simulated STM image shows the normal triangular lattice pattern [2.15]. This would mean that the tip has unlocalized electronic states on its protrusion for normal cases. On the other hand, if the width ~ is reduced below 0.1 eV the (dIldV)/(l/V) curve shows rather complicated structures reflecting the discrete levels of the cluster [2.14]. The remarkable point of this model is that various types of the abnormal patterns often observed by STM of graphite are reproduced. Presumably a localized bound states exists on the protrusion of the tip in cases where abnormal STM images are noted. Simultaneous STS measurement should be performed to clarify the nature of the tip state. Recent STS studies revealed characteristic resonance peaks in dIldV versus V curves due to bcc and fcc W (Ill) surfaces, respectively [2.16]. This observation points to the differences in tip geometry effects to image recording and spectroscopic analysis (Fig. 2.17). Similar discussions have been seen in the analysis of imaging atomic structures with an AFM tip in non-contact mode [2.17]. Covalent bonding is proposed to be responsible for enhancing the imaging contrast.
2.3.3 Tunneling Active Orbital at the Tip It is an important problem to clarify what kind of tip orbital dominantly contributes to the tunnel current. Ohnishi and Tsukada [2.18] performed the LDA (Local Density functional Approximation) calculation for the elec-
~
2O
0.0 I ·1.0
~l7r
{)(E+eV-E y) =* (E+eV-E y)2 + ~2
i f'J I
'l
I
!
·0.5 0.0 0.5 sample voltage (V)
I 1.0
15.0
j (b)
~ 10.0 oS
>
J2 '0
5.0
0.0
0.5
1.0
Fig. 2. 17a, b. Experimental differential conductivity for Cu (111). (a) and (b) represent two kinds of spectra that are reproducibly obtained after cleaning the W tip by field emission corresponding to a tip apex with a bcc and a fcc pyramid, respectively [2. 16]
(a)
(b)
Fig. 2. 18. Single-state charge-density contour map for the tunneling active orbital of (a) W 4 (HOMO) and (b) W5 (level just below HOMO) cluster [2. II]
tronic states of the W 4' W 5 and W 8 cluster modes of the tip. The results indicated that tipe states with the large d/ component of the tip's apex atom mainly determine the tunnel current. They are the Highest-Occupied Molecular Orbital (HOMO) for the W 4 cluster and the level just below HOMO for the W 5 cluster. The contour maps of these states are displayed in Fig.2.18. The shape of the tip orbital is sensitively reflected by the STM image. This is, for example, found for the image of C H chemisorbed on a sub6 6 strate, as shown in Fig. 2 .19. The tunnel current is calculated by the level just below HOMO of the W5 cluster. The simulated STM image does not show any distinct shape of individual atoms, but rather the 1r electron cloud swelled over the whole molecule. Contour lines around the neighbouring carbon atoms behave somewhat differently. This is because the orbital of
30 31
,
Fig.2.19. STM current image of C 6 H 6 molecule scanned by a W5 tip. The height of the apex atom of the W5 cluster is fixed at 0.4 nm above the molecular plane [2. 11]
Tip I I I
°1
Surface Fig. 2.20. Geometry of a tip with two protrusions [2.llJ
A(R,E,E') the tip is not axially symmetric, and therefore the two C sites are not equivalent in the whole C6 H6 /W 5 system. With the increase of the cluster size the component of the particular tunneling-active orbital becomes distributed over many levels. The width of these lev~ls governs the features of the STS, as discussed in the previous subsection. For example, if the energy spreading of the tunneling-active orbital is very narrow, the STS spectrum is proportional to the derivative of the surface DOS. On the other hand, if the component of the tunneling-active orbital is distributed over a wide energy region, a simple simulation of (2.40) is appropriate.
2.3.4 Double-Tip and Interference Effects
If the tip has two protrusions contributing equally to the tunnel current, the STM image will be distorted considerably. For distant protrusions, the current image would be the overlap of the two images contributed by the respective protrusions [2.19]. This might correspond to images with ghosts which were often reported in the literature. If the distance between the two protrusions is short, a significant interference effect is expected. To see this we notice that the current contribution A(R, E, E')dE = (E' = E-eV) can be written as
I
=
J
i =1 , 2
OJ
J
dp'V T CP+T)V T (p'+T)Y(Pz;E)y(p;;E)
OJ
X
gS(p+Rj ,p' +R j ;E)g T (p' +Tj,P+Ti ;E')
+
[J
X
dp
O}
J
02
dp'V T (P+T1)V T (P'+T2)Y(Pz;E)y(p;;E)
gS(p+R 1 ,p' +R 2 ;E)gT (p' +T2 ,P+T} ;E') + (1- 2)J .(2.42)
Here, T[, T2 are the relative coordinates to the center of the mass; R} and R2 are the coordinates of these centers-of-mass points with respect to the surface (Fig.2.20). The weight factor used for the definition of the center of the mass is the product of the tip potential VT by J/;p (E-E p) and the decay function y(pz;E) = ex p [- : zY2m IE
I] .
(2.43)
In (2.42) 0i is the spatial region assigned to the protrusion i and gS is defined as gS(p+R j ,p' +Rj ;E)
32
dp
_
gS(p+Rj,p'+Rj;E)
-
y(pz;E)y(p; ;E)
(2.44)
33
The first term of (2.42) is just the simple overlap of the current images contributed by the relevant protrusions. If one takes the zeroth-order terms of the moment expansion [2.20] around the point R j and sums up, we obtain
(a)
(b)
}
r\
'V
V
A(R,E,E') =
L
I
/,
(2.45)
C j (E')8(R j ,E),
\ 1\
i=I,2 as discussed in [2.19]. The above result is just the extension of the theory of Tersoff and Hamann for the noninterfering double-tips case. The second term of (2.42) represents the interference effect. The order of magnitude of this term is estimated as Ainrerference :::: ,,2IvT/2 [gS(R 1 ,R 2 ;E)gT(T2,Tl;E')
+ (1-2)]
" (c)
/,
r\
(d)
.(2.46)
If there is no coherence between the electron wave functions on the two protrusions, the interference term vanishes. This case assumes that the tunneling-active orbital at one of the protrusions does not extend to the other protrusion. _ A numerical simulation of the STM current image of graphite by the antibonding orbital of the H2 molecule, as the tip orbital, distinctively shows the drastic effect of the interference. As depicted in Fig.2.21a, the STM image formed by the tip orbital with an axis in the x direction exhibits an abnormal ridgelike shape running in the y direction. The tip orbital is placed 0.6 om above the graphite surface. Such an unusual image is due to the interference effect of the current components through each tip hydrogen atom, and it is verified by looking at the tilt-angle dependence of the STM image. The images of Fig.2.21b-d correspond to the tip orbital tilt angle 15°,30°,90°, respectively. It is found that the image changes to that of a normal triangular lattice with increasing tilt angle. This is explained by the weakening of the interference, because the current due to the raised hydrogen atom is reduced by the increasing tilt angle. Kobayashi and Tsukada [2.14] demonstrated that the STM image of Fig.2.21a changes drastically when the tip orbital axis is rotated from the x direction parallel to the plane of the graphite surface. This fact is also an evidence of the interference effect, as shown analytically in [2.14]. It is important to note that the STM images (Fig.2.21) are often observed in experiments.
Fig. 2. 21a-d. The STM image of graphite using the antibonding orbital of H as the tunnel2 ing active orbital of the tip. The tilt angle of the axis of the tip orbital is 0 0 . 15 ° . 30 ° and 90° for (a), (b), (c) and (d), respectively [2.11)
34
35
3. Spectroscopy, and Spectroscopic Imaging
In the last chapter, the theoretical concepts of STM were reviewed. The previous description focused on the capability of an STM device to scan a surface and to provide data on its atomic-level topography. This capability is only part of the story; STM also opens up new possibilities in spectroscopy. To first approximation, measurements of the electron density across a surface correspond to the topography of the surface, showing the actual positions of atoms or atomic steps on surfaces. However, this description merely serves as a useful starting point. On an atomic scale, surface atoms are not hard spheres with distinct boundaries. While the STM image usually corresponds to surface corrugations or contours of atoms, STM measurements are actually based on the electron density of states. Electrons exist at specific values of energy, called electronic states. Since the tunneling current reflects the Local Density Of States (LDOS) of the sample's surface, STM can be utilized for atomically-resolved spectroscopy, that is, Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy (STS). Richer than a mere topographic profile, tunneling spectroscopy provides a wealth of information about which electron energy states are occupied (filled) as well as unoccupied (empty). Detailed information that can be inferred from these measurements includes data on chemical composition, bonding, the energy gap, band-bending effects and adsorption at the surfaces or objects under investigation. The main merits of tunneling spectroscopy performed with an STM device are the following: (i) It is local (here, "local" is equivalent to "atomic ") and can be used to probe the electronic properties ranging from individual adatoms on a surface to spatial properties of vortex states of superconductors; (ii) it can be performed at preselected positions by using the scanning ability of the STM; (iii) it can be performed under well-defined conditions. For example, perfect surfaces with known composition can be examined under ultra-highvacuum conditions; (iv) it can be combined with other methods; and (v) it can provide spectroscopic images.
37
3.1 Concepts of Tunneling Spectroscopies 3.1.1 Solid-State-Barrier Tunneling Historically tunneling spectroscopy with the Metal-Insulator-Metal (MIM) tunneling junctions was first demonstrated by Giaever [3.1]. A common feature of solid-state-barrier tunneling structures is that the application of a bias voltage Y leads to tunneling of electrons with a well-defined range of energies 0 < E < 1 eY. This feature makes possible several versions of classical spectroscopy of the solid electrodes and of the barrier with energy resolution of a few times the thermal energy kT. These versions include spectroscopy of the superconducting state, which probes the details of both the energy-gap structure and the phonon spectrum that produces the pairedelectron system. The second major area of spectroscopy, known as lETS (Inelastic Electron Tunneling Spectroscopy), involves the measurement of inelastic excitations of the electrodes (usually in the normal state) and of the barrier. An example is the threshold for phonon generation in an Esaki diode at a bias of Y = nw/e, which is detected by an accompanying step in dIldY and thus a peak in dI2 Idy2. In a similar fashion, energies of plasmons, of spin waves, of spin-flip transitions of paramagnetic ions. and of a variety of other excitations occurring in or near the barrier in various tunneling structures, have been measured. A related area of particular activity in lETS is the measurement of vibrational frequencies of molecules, including large organic molecules, utilized in a MIM tunneling junction by adsorption to the barrier oxide. Consider an idealized tunneling junction in which the molecules with vibrational level spacing nw are sandwiched between two metal electrodes. If we measure the current as a function of voltage, we will find two components: (i) A steadily increasing current due to elastic electron tunneling, and (ii) a current which has the threshold voltage nw/e and increases steadily thereafter due to inelastic electron tunneling. This threshold is set by the requirement that the electrons must give up the energy nw to excite the molecular vibration. Figure 3.1 shows the total current I which is the sum of the currents through the elastic and inelastic tunneling channels. It has a kink at Y = nw/e which becomes a step in dIldY versus Y, and a peak in dI2/dy2. A plot of dI2/dy2 versus Y is called a tunneling spectrum. Thus, measurements of the spectrum yield a series of peaks appearing at bias voltages simply related to the phonon frequencies by the threshold relation eY = nw. This provides information about the bonding of molecules to solid surfaces and about the interactions or reactions, which adsorbed molecules may undergo. The third class of spectroscopy in junction tunneling is associated with the distribution of electron energy states either in the final electrode or, oc-
....- ...-
Fig. 3.1. The current versus voltage curve has a kink in it when the inelastic electron tunneling channel opens up. This kink becomes a step in the first derivative and a peak in the second derivative
T-r .~~ :
dIldV
o
d'"dV'1 o
I
nw/e
~
nw/e
V
: V
casionally, in the barrier. In classical planar MIM tunneling, the electronic states of a metal electrode may be observed in the current-voltage spectrum characteristic of the tunneling junction. This occurs because the current is determined by the availability of electronic states within the metallic electrodes; specifically bulk states such as the energy band, quantum size effects and surface states with wave functions which are confined mainly to the immediate surface of the metal. A similar dependence of the currentvoltage spectrum characteristic on surface electron structure is expected for the STM geometry. Useful spectroscopic information about energy-band positions in semiconductors and metals can be provided by this class of spectroscopy. Measurements of the current-voltage characteristics of tunneling junctions outlined above have had an important history in solid-state physics. A major disadvantage of conventional planar structures is that the desired spectroscopic information is spatially averaged over the full size of the junction. While junctions as small as 1200 x 3000 A2 have been fabricated, this is still considerably larger than the characteristic length over which the properties of interest might be expected to vary. For the case of superconductors, the relevant length scale is set by the coherence length, which can range from thousands to tens of Angstroms. For resonant or inelastic tunneling, large variations can be expected to occur over a single molecule. Conventional tunneling junctions also suffer from the disadvantage that the interpretation of results can be confused by unwanted effects of the nonideal solid tunneling barrier.
38
39
Fig.3.2. Graph of tunneling currenl vs. distance
4
Fig.3.3. Calculaled vertical lip displacemenl for a Na tip scanning over aNa, S and He alom, respeclively [3.2J
(different bias) and lhe calculaled lunneling currenl 105
(solid lines)
3
E: C
2
..c
~ 10
0
3
e:
"u
'"
<]
00
.::
vc
§ 10 1
f-
- - computed - - - measured
0
Vbias=O.IV
1
Vbias=O.OI V ~2
0.4
~6
.J -20
0.8
-10
Tunneling gap [nm]
20
stant tunneling current. He is different in that it screens the DOS of the electrode substrate and forces the tip to approach the sample more closely in order to maintain a constant tunneling current. The theoretical studies also show that the quantity d(lnI)/d(ln V) closely resembles the combined DOS of sample and tip in the tunneling region. Figure 3.4 depicts the density of states induced on a planar metal electrode by the adsorption of Na and Ca. The energy scale for Na is reversed so that it can be interpreted as the tip. Figure 3.4b (solid curve) presents a calculation of d(lnI)/ d(ln V) versus V for the Ca/Na tunneling system. The peaks
3.1.2 Metal-Vacuum-MetaI Tunneling The demonstrated capability of forming control1able vacuum-gap junctions between any two conductors using STM has led to a number of interesting new results. STM brings a unique advantage to spectroscopic studies. Where other spectroscopic methods provide results averaged over an area of the surface, STM can provide spectroscopic data with a lateral resolution approaching atomic dimensions. This enables close studies of surface irregularities, defects, dopants (used in semiconductors) and other local surface phenomena of a smal1 scale where spatial1y averaged data are not useful. STM provides spectroscopic data by utilizing its sensitivity to the electron energy states of the sample. In examining these data, it is useful to sort out characteristics that do not depend directly on the electron Density Of States (DOS) so that sample-specific structure in the sample DOS can be extracted. In principle, the tunneling current at an arbitrary voltage (below the field-emission threshold) can be calculated from (2.5 and 6). Figure 3.2 shows how a change in bias voltage affects the calculated tunneling current value for the same sample. By modeling the tip as a Na atom weakly adsorbed on a jel1ium surface, Lang [3.2] calculated tunneling current in the vacuum region between two planar metal electrodes, on each of which is an adsorbed atom. The tunneling image of the STM is generated numerically. Scanning of one atom (taken as the tip) past the other (the sample) permits plotting of tip displacement versus lateral separation for constant current. The result of such a study is depicted in Fig.3.3, where a Na tip scans over various sample atoms (Na, S and He) at a small bias voltage. Na has a DOS at the Fermi level higher than S and gives rise to_a larger displacement of the tip at con-
0 10 Y [Bohr)
(a)
2.0 2.01
>
~
I
Na energy rei alive 10 Fermi level reV] for Na 1.0 0 -1.0 I
I
I
I
-2.0
3.5
1.5
:> .....
"'"
'"
;;; '-
(b)
I
I
2.5
I I
Ca/Na
2.0
.....
1.0
:>
0
~
.':'
~ 0.5
~
"
Q
.......... ,
1.0
0
"""------
-1.0
1.5
0.5
,
0 -2.0
3.0
0 1.0 Energy rei alive 10 Fermi level reV) for Ca
2.0
-0.5 -2.0
'-\
I I
'\J
I I I
-1.0 0 1.0 Bias vollage [V]
2.0
Fig. 3.4. (a) Densily of Slales induced by lhe adsorplion of a Na and a Ca atom on two planar metal eleclrodes, respeclively. The horizontal axis is inverted for lhe Na alom, which is interpreted as the lip. (b) (dIldV)/(I1V) as a funclion of applied bias for the Na-Ca lunnel junction. The full curve is an exaCI calculalion; lhe broken curve is lhe result of a simple model [3.2J
40 41
observed in this spectrum bear a close relationship to the peaks seen in Fig. 3.4a. There are two important implications. First, the tunneling signal contains information that is, to a large degree, representative of the electronic structure of the tunneling electrodes. Secondly, the tip electronic structure is just as prominent in the data as in the sample's electronic structure. This result shows clearly that the microscope does not know which is tip and which is sample, and all wave functions are equal. This is one of the major reasons for the irreproducibility of spectroscopic data. We can conclude from the above discussion that current-voltage spectra may be obtained by varying the tunneling voltage at specific points on the surface. Peaks in d(1nl)/d(1n V) vs V in the low-voltage limit are interpreted as corresponding roughly to resonances in the tip and sample's densities of states, although their exact heights and positions also depend on the gap distance. At higher voltages, however, the current depends nonlinearly on the voltage. Further, electronic-structure effects and inelastic processes may introduce rich structure into the current-voltage characteristics. Alternatively, STM images obtained in the topographic mode at different voltages (described in Chap. I) contain geometric information about the sample (such as the presence of atomic steps), but also contain information on surface electronic structure (such as the presence of localized surface states, band bending, the energy-band gap of semiconductors or superconductors, or work-function variations). Spectroscopic images (or voltage derivatives of images) taken at specific bias voltages may be used to highlight the spatial distribution of particular states. The theoretical results derived from (2.40) for graphite at several bias voltages have subsequently been confirmed experimentally. This theoretical study assumed that the voltage dependence of the transmission coefficient through the barrier can be neglected relative to the voltage dependence of the density of states, and that the density of states at the tip is sufficiently featureless in the low-bias-voltage limit. Of course, the precise relationship between dlldV and the spectra or images depends on the experimental mode employed in taking the data.
3.2 Experimental Modes One can precisely vary the bias voltage and tip-to-sample distance of an STM for measurement at any point. Therefore, an STM device can be used in four related spectroscopy-like modes: (1) Current-voltage spectroscopy (1-V curve), (2) current-separation characteristics, (3) constant-current topography, and (4) current imaging tunneling spectroscopy.
3.2 .1 Current-Voltage Characteristics 1-V curves for fixed separations are obtained by measuring the variation of the tunneling current as a function of voltage at a constant tip-sample separation. This measurement requires the addition of a sample-and-hold circuit to the feedback loop, as discussed in ChapA. This circuit holds the tip position stable for a given time of the measurement and its response time should be fast enough. The feedback loop is interrupted for a few milliseconds by closing the integrator gate without resetting the integrator. Then the tunneling bias voltage is ramped under computer control while the tunneling current is simultaneously measured. In this scheme the sample-tip distance does not change with voltage and the tunneling current is allowed to vanish because the feedback circuit is inactive. The tunneling bias voltage is then reset to its original value and the integrator gate is opened, re-establishing feedback. Typically, a few hundred such current-voltage spectra are averaged to increase the signal-to-noise ratio, and the dlldV curve can be constructed afterwards. Normalizing the dynamic conductance dlldV to the DC conductance I/V can be used to eliminate the dependence of the tunneling signal on the value of the DC tunneling conductance. It is also possible to measure individual I-V spectra at regular intervals during a scan and correlate the I-V characteristics with the scan. Such spatially resolved I-V curves have been used to elucidate the electronic structure of some semiconductor and metal surfaces. For small voltages, < I V, the I-V curves show a linear voltage-dependence characteristic of ohmic behavior. For larger voltage, the exponential dependence dominates the I-V characteristic, and no current density is observed at low voltage for separations larger than 7 A. The implications of this distance dependence on acquiring spectroscopic data are that the data can only be obtained over a limited voltage range for a fixed separation. To achieve a wide dynamic range of tunneling current and conductivity, the tip-sample separation can be varied by adjusting the initial reference tunneling voltage while the feedback is active, in which the tunneling current at low bias voltage is amplified by reducing the separation. Subsequent normalization of the spectrum is performed to remove the effects of varying the tip-sample separation. The I-V curves for the Si(III)-2x I surface [3.4,5] have been acquired in this fashion, i.e. a series of I-V curves is obtained at various fixed tip-sample separations, which are then normalized. Another STM operation mode measures dlldV by adding a small AC component to the DC bias voltage. The frequency w is chosen to be sufficiently high that the feedback cannot respond to it. The tunneling current will contain an in-phase modulation of the frequency w that is the derivative of I with respect to V, at the DC bias voltage V at which the feedback circuit operates. By sweeping V, dlldV can be measured as a function of V. 43
42
Care has to be taken to pick up only the in-phase modulation of the tunneling current with a lock-in amplifier. Displacement currents can give rise to strongly phase-shifted signals. There are three problems with this scheme: (i) The sample-tip separation varies with V, because I is kept constant by the feedback circuit. With increasing voltage and distance, the lateral resolution is degraded; (ii) the DC tunneling resistance is not constant during the measurement, again because I is kept constant. At decreasing bias voltages the DC conductance increases (by decreasing the tip-sample separation) and diverges as the zero bias voltage is approached. Likewise dl/dV diverges. In practice, useful data have not been obtained below 1 V, which for many structures is the most interesting region; (iii) this approach requires that a tunneling current can be maintained over the voltage range of interest. This is not always possible. If there is a band gap, a stable tunneling current can often not be maintained if the bias voltage is set within the gap, and the tip will crash into the sample. Nevertheless, this method has been used to study the electronic structure of surfaces such as Si (111)-7 x7, etc. The third method for improving the measuring procedure is to first set the bias voltage at a relatively large value, typically ±2 V, for inducing a sizeable tunneling current while the tip is stabilized by the active feedback loop. Then the feedback is disabled, and a V-shaped voltage is added to the Z piezo voltage, synchronized with the bias ramp. The tunneling current as a function of the bias voltage is recorded. Using a modulation frequency of about 1 kHz with a lock-in amplifier leads to a measurement time for the spectrum of a few seconds. Thus, this method is only possible for a very stable mechanical system and a very long holding time of the Z position. Generally, the residual thermal or piezoelectric drift rate of the STM should be less than 0.1 A/s. An example of this type of data is the spectroscopic measurements on a monolayer of Sb on the GaAs(l10) surface [3.6).
3.2.2 Current-Separation and Separation-Voltage Characteristics Equation (1.1) may be considered a first approximation for the tunneling current. Making use of the variables in the equation, the local work function
or, correctly speaking, the effective tunneling barrier height between the tip and the sample can theoretically be derived from tunneling current I(s) at constant V or from the separation s(V) (we use s instead of d to represent the tip-sample separation hereafter) at constant I. Experimentally, d(1nI)/ds can be measured in STM experiments by a modulation of the gap separation with phase-sensitive detection of the current at the modulation
The modulation signal divided by the current is, neglecting logarithmic terms in s, - d(lnl)/ds
= V + (lIzV <1»
xd/ds .
(3.1)
The effective barrier height in (3.1) generally differs from the work function. The former is some average over the actual barrier height across the gap between the tip and the sample. The latter is equal to this actual height only at infinite distance from the surface, i.e., at the distance s where the second term in (3.1) becomes negligible. The work function of a metal surface is defined as the minimum energy required to remove an electron from the bulk to the vacuum level. The barrier height is a local electronic parameter. It is closely related to the local electronic charge, i.e., the barrier is enhanced if excess electronic charge is present and lowered if there is a charge deficency. The image potential [3.7], a general aspect of an electron moving to or from the surface, has an influence on d(1nl)/ds, but this influence can be reduced by performing the experiment at a separation larger than 4 A [3.8]. We should like to stress at this point that "barrier-height images" also contain topographic features, and the magnitude of the experimentally determined values are often considerably smaller than expected. Some questions relating to barrier height have so far remained unexplained, so great care needs to be taken in performing experiments to measure refined changes of tunneling barriers [3.9]. A related method for measuring spectroscopic data is to keep the feedback loop active while varying the bias voltage at a fixed tunneling current. In this way the tip-sample separation is constantly adjusting itself, and the tip is following a separation-vs-voltage curve at constant current, getting the s-V data. When the applied potential exceeds the work function, there is a transition from the vacuum-tunneling regime to the field-emission regime where the electron experiences a positive kinetic energy. In this range, quantum interference effects can occur, leading to barrier resonances in the electron transmission at certain energies. These transmission resonances show up as wiggle's in the s-V data or as kinks in the constant-distance I-V data [3.4,5]. The position and strength of the resonances are sensitive to the shape of the potential barrier at the sample surface. Due to the difficulty in realistic calculations of the tunneling process, it is difficult to extract quantitative characteristics of the barrier potential from the barrier resonance [3.10]. Barrier-height images and barrier resonances have been used to study some biomaterials [3.11,12], and metal and semiconductor surfaces [3.5, 13, 14).
frequency. 45 44
3.2.3 Constant-Current Topography Constant-Current Topographs (CCTs) are obtained by keeping the tunneling current constant and measuring the voltages controlling the tip height at different bias voltages. This method for revealing real-space surface-state images relies on the fact that at many bias voltages only the electronic states between the Fermi levels of the tip and the sample contribute to the tunneling current. The CCT method is experimentally very simple and often provides a quick way to assess if there are any interesting differences between different polarities. As a spectroscopic tool, however, it is rather limited.
3.2.4 Current-Imaging Tunneling Spectroscopy Combining the spectroscopic capabilities and the scanning ability of an STM device allows for high-spatial-resolution spectroscopy measurements, essentially on an atomically-resolved basis. There are two methods for obtaining Current-Imaging Tunneling Spectroscopic (CITS) data. One of them is measuring a full I-V curve at each pixel of a topographic image, A tunneling bias voltage is applied between the sample and the tip for about 0.1 ms, During this time the feedback circuit is activated by opening a gate. In the next 0.4 ms the feedback circuit is interrupted and the position of the tip held fixed. The bias voltage is ramped under computer control while the tunneling current is measured at a number of voltages during this ramp. Thus, one can create an image of the tunneling current at different voltages, while the STM progress along the raster scan with the tunneling current is stabilized at the preset bias voltage. The I-V curves can be seen in real time on an oscilloscope and may display very strong variations with position, The variation of tunneling current at a specific bias voltage can be visualized as an image. This method can provide sufficient data to construct real-space images of the surface states. Another method for obtaining CITS is measuring dIldV at the fixed bias voltage V in a raster scan. A small voltage modulation is superimposed on the DC bias at a frequency w, which is too fast for the feedback circuit to follow. The current modulation at frequency w is measured with a lock-in amplifier and used to form an image of dlldV. Two disadvantages of this method are: (i) Spectroscopic information is obtained at a single bias voltage only, If one wants spectroscopic information over a larger range of bias voltages. the experiment has to be repeated for every bias voltage. Problems associated with drift of the sample during the measurement and with variations of the geometric and electronic struc46
tures of the tip tend to make this experiment very troublesome, (ii) The tip follows a different contour for each bias voltage, because different sample and tip states contribute to the tunneling current at different voltages. This may affect the lateral resolution, in particular for features close to the resolution limit of the experiment. In addition, it has been shown that, in the absence of any electronic structure variation across the sample, the dIldV image is not featureless but presents an inverted topographic image, This is because the transmission-probability density depends on the local radius of the curvature of the electrodes, The major advantage of the CITS technique is that all spectrosopic information is obtained simultaneously, thus eliminating problems associated with sample drift and tip instabilities. Also, spectroscopic images at different bias voltages are obtained along identical spatial contours of the tip, thus removing ambiguities arising from possible variations in lateral resolution with tip-sample distance. The CITS technique demands a laboratory automation system to drive the microscope. At present it is possible to record a 256-point I-V curve in each pixel of a 256 X 256 topographic image. In each pixel the computer triggers a transient recorder, which acquires the I-V information, provides hardware averaging of multiple I-V curves at each location, and then sends the data to a second computer which stores the results directly on a highdensity disc. The data can be analyzed either on-line or off-line on a larger mainframe computer,
3.3 Energy Resolution
The resolution of the STM, operated in the spectroscopic mode, involves several factors as follows: • There will be a thermal limit determined by the width of the edge of the Fermi distribution of the electrons in the metal electrodes. This amounts to approximately 2kT (about 50meV at room temperature), and is small enough to allow resolution of most features of interest on metals. For an inelastic process the limit should be 5.4 kT, or about 150 meV at room temperature, which should be adequate for many electronic excitations. This resolution would not be sufficient, however, for superconductivity and other inelastic processes associated with photons or excitation of vibrational modes of adsorbed molecues, which have a width of about 5 meV. It is necessary to use low-temperature STMs for reducing thermal smearing to an acceptable level.
47
E'
Fig. 3. Sa, b. Band structure of nearly free-electron dispersion for a two-band model. The band structure along the k perpendicular direction is shown in (a) with energy resolution. The measured densities of states for a full tip (broken line) and a sharp tip (solid line) are shown on (b) [3.3]
(a)
Vg
0
sharp lip
1
I
/
n/a
with a dull tip. Figure 3.5b depicts the measured densities of states using dull and sharp tips for a two-band model of nearly free-electron dispersion. For a sharp tip, the measured density of states does not reveal a detailed structure due to its poor energy resolution. Kuk and Silverman [3.15] concluded therefore that a sharp tip is desirable for topographic scanning but undesirable for tunneling spectroscopy on a surface with a dispersive band structure. Most successful STM-spectroscopic measurements have been done with surfaces of single crystals prepared in high vacuum. This is in part due to the difficulty of obtaining stable STM operation free of excess noise in the presence of impurities and unstable surface layers and oxides.
k
N(E)' (b)
3.4 Examples
E
• A modulation amplitude of sufficient size is required to observe a derivative spectrum, a consideration closely related to the time needed to acquire a reasonable noise-free spectrum. Typically, a modulation of at least 0.1 V is required to obtain a spectrum in a few minutes. • Electronic states in metals are lifetime-broadened by an amount which is energy dependent but can be several tenths of an eV or more in width for energies of one electron volt and larger. • The uncertainty principle may play a role in determining the energy resolution of the spectroscopy since the area through which the tunneling current passes is so small, typically of the order of one nanometer or less. Assuming that the radius and the lateral resolution of a tunneling tip are roughly equal, the relation LlkLlx :::::: 1 indicates that a tip of radius 2 A will have a momentum uncertainty of 0.5 A-I. (Although the crystal momentum in a solid is not a physical momentum, a resolution limit can be defined). Figure 3.5a shows the energy-band structure of nearly free electrons in a periodic potential. A sharp tip is indicated by the heavy line spanning the first and the second Brillouin zone; poor momentum resolution results in poor energy resolution around the probing energy V g' The broken line in the figure indicates the better momentum and energy resolution attained
48
Above we have reviewed some ways of obtaining spectroscopic information with STM. In this section we will give some examples of the most notable achievements of scanning tunneling spectroscopy. Classical spectroscopies are conveniently classified by the energy range as follows [3.16]: • Superconducting energy-gap spectroscopy (0-7-20meV). • Electrode phonon spectroscopy (5-7-50meV). • Barrier and semiconductor phonon spectroscopy (30 -7- 100 meV). • Molecular vibrational spectroscopy (30 -7- 500 meV). • Molecular electronic spectroscopy (500meV -7-2eV). • Electrode plasmon spectroscopy (1.5-7-5eV). For a bias voltage of no more than a few volts, electrons tunnel directly through the vacuum space from one electrode to the other. This mode is clearly analogous to the classical tunneling experiments in which a MIM thin-film structure is employed and tunneling takes place between the metals through the thin oxide insulator. With STM, however, tunneling occurs through a thin vacuum gap. In contrast, STM-spectroscopic experiments, in which image states and other electronic reflection effects at surfaces are observed, operate in the voltage range of about 5 eV. For this large-voltage case electrons tunnel through the barrier immediately in front of the emitting surface and can occupy real states in the gap between tip and metal surface.
49
5
,2.5
0
(a)
••
.~ 00
o
4
I
•
I
unfaulted • faulted o
~
o
o
"uc: '" U ""oc:'"
0
I" 1.0
2.0
•
0 0
, : /\·~II • I I \ I I
er.."'~~q,~ I
2
-~.
"
1/
0
. Y
U
/
'-'
I
__ -
o
I
2
./
4
I
•
\
v
I
I
r
6
8
I
ex
ci
1.0 01]
coOo ~
)t
"
\I
,
01.
0
10.5 10
,~
I
~
'Vi
I
c:
Fig. 3.6. dI/dV spectra measured in the two halves of the Si (111)-7 x:J unit cell. Also shown is the variation of the sample-tip spacing with bias voltage, while the DC tunnel ing current is held constant. The solid line represents the tip height vs bias voltage during the conductance measurements. The dashed curve shows the theoretical calculations of the contribution of standing-wave states to the tunneling conductance [3.17]
e.x:
,I
/
" C
•• x
)(
• •• 'l()(
x
)(
.•"
jO.
v
Bias voltage [Vj
CO
e.
•
11 \
\,
a
•
t=:
1\
Theory (arbitrary units)
I I
I
-
0..
I I \ '\ T
I
~o
'iii
c
•
••••• •• •
>
.<=
1\ I I
\
\,,!
I
1.5
I'"
/ \
I
Ec:
~ ~ V;~
I ·"0 ~· ~o
3
....
(b) ,
"
,
,
'..,
--(c)
2
>
3.4.1 Surface States
-"" ~
>
While an STM is capable of atomic-resolution images and of spectroscopy of surface electronic structure, the imaging of surface states in real space has provided a major, nontrivial challenge. Figure 3.6 displays two dIldV curves obtained in the two halves of the Si (111)-7 x 7 unit cell. Between 1 and 3 V (no data were obtained below 1V), differences are seen between the two curves due to differences in the electronic structure in the two halves of the unit cell. Also shown is the variation of tip height above the surface, which increases with increasing voltage, as expected. The regular series of peaks observed at higher voltages are not due to surface electronic structure, but are due to standing-wavelike states between tip and sample. The broken curve exhibits a theoretical prediction of these states, in good agreement with the data. By combining scanning-tunneling microscopy and spectroscopy, surface states of the Si(111)-7x7 with specific atomic sites have been identified. In the first step of the analysis the I-V characteristics were plotted at a number of different positions inside the (7 x 7) unit cell (Fig.3.7). Strong differences are seen between the various locations. For instance, a strong 50
~
-2
-I
o
2
Energy leV] Fig. 3.7. (a) Tunneling conductance (IIV) measured at several locations inside the (7 X7) un it cell: ( ) adatom; (.) rest atom ; ( X) center position . (b) Surface states on Si (lll)-7 X7 observed with photoemission (solid line) and inverse phocoemission (dashed line). (c) Areaaveraged tunnel ing spectra [3. 18]
increase in conductance at -0.8 V observed on the rest atoms (rest-atom sites are dangling bonds in the second layer of the crystal) is absent on the adatoms, even though they are separated by only 0.443 nm. The steps in the DC conductance correspond directly with the surface states long known from photoemission and inverse photoemission experiments [3.19]. Thus, this measurement can be used to identify these states with specific features of the structure of the (7 x 7) surface. Real-space images of these states 51
were subsequently obtained by taking the difference between current images just above and below the observed onsets in conductance. Such difference images, between 0 and -0.35 V and between -0.6 and -1.0 V, are depicted in Fig.3.8, together with a schematic view of the Dimer-AdatomStacking (DAS) fault model in the 7 x 7 symmetry (Fig. 3.8a) and a topographic image obtained at +2 V (Fig.3.8b). A different image centered at 0.35 V (Fig.3.8c) reveals an electronic state which is localized on the 12 adatoms but which has a different DOS on each of four types of adatoms. The state is stronger in the faulted than in the unfaulted half of the cell, and in each half the stage is stronger on the three adatoms adjacent to a corner hole than on the three. Figure 3.8d depicts a difference image centered around -0.8 V. This state is localized at three spots within each half of the unit cell, exactly where the DAS model predicts dangling bonds on the "rest atoms" in the first full atomic layer. The current images contain information not only on the electronic structure for the voltage at which they are obtained, but also on the electronic states contributing to the tunneling current at the feedback voltage. Current images of the Si (Ill) -7 x 7 surface obtained at - 2 and +2 V applied bias (tip ground) will look different because the tip follows a different contour. An image obtained at +2 V reveals mirror symmetry of the unit cell across the short diagonal (all bumps look the same), whereas an image obtained at -2 V indicates a pronounced asymmetry with one half of the unit cell apparently higher than the other half, and the bumps near the corner holes higher than the bumps between them. Thus, in general, it is difficult to interpret a current image directly. Trump et al. [3.20] eased this problem substantially by taking the difference between two current images and normalising this difference image to the DC conductance. The created d(1nI)/ d(1n V) image by this method would be qualitatively similar due to the very pronounced nature of the surface states. Figure 3.9 shows the constant-current image of the GaAs(l10) surface obtained simultaneousl at (a) + 1. 9 V and (b) -1.9 V, representing empty and filled states of GaAs (110)-1 x 2 surface, respectively. On this surface the filled states are localized on the As atoms; the empty states are localized on the Ga atoms. As a result, either the Ga atoms or the As atoms are imaged, depending on the bias voltage. Figure 3.9a represents an image of the Ga states, Fig.3.9b of the As states. Ga and As form zig-zag chains, alternating between Ga and As. By comparing the measured images with theoretical predictions, the buckling angles of the Ga and As bonds was estimated. Figure 3.9c illustrates a schematic top view of the surface atoms. Si (111)2 x 1 surface structures characterized by quasi-one-dimensional zig-zag chains of Si atoms in the so-called 7r-bonded chain model. The voltage-dependent images [3.22] show that a maximum in the image taken at + 1 V appears as a minimum at -1 V. Considering the electronic struc52
~
~~AA~A ~
.'~~'~~"'~""~1.," ®.~.
•••• ...... ~
.~ • ,6'.'
•
••
•. ~
.
t\ ·M.~ ,- .'~
.~'+ • ~o··
~·.~J~"A~~
~
E')~ •
..
•••
• ~~*e}."~~
~.
- ••' ~ ®e>.. ~~ •.O~~.'. ~ 1'5";0. .•, w• • ~~~~~~W~". ~ \SJ
..
'·.~·~."dl~ ~~~;,~ .~.,•• ~ .~ ~ fj.~ .""
•. ~ ~ ~ .....-
,.~. •,~I# .~
(a)
.....
'
~
••®.®. •• •••
0
•
Adatom ReSlalom layer Second layer Bulk layer
Fig. 3. 8. (a) A schematic view of the DimerAdatom-Slacking (DAS) model in the 7 X 7 symmelry. (b) Topographic image obtained at +2 V. (c) Adatom Slale al -0.35 V. And (d) dangling-bond state at-0.8 V [3.18] 53
!
~~(;~~~--j o
20
Distance
(c)
.~
.0
• 0
<[liOI
o I
S
80
(A)
40
Its
2.0"'
:.
60
80
~
'Ii
t
0.5
O~m
[001]
.0 Fig. 3.9. (a) Empty-state (+ I. 9V) and (b) filled-state (-I. 9V) topographies of GaAs (110) taken simultaneously. Positions of surface atoms are schematically shown (c), where open circles indicate As atoms and closed circles represent Ga atoms [3.21]
ture of the 71"-bonded chain model one can understand that the maxima do not correspond simply to atomic locations, but are intimately related to the details of the bonding between the atoms and, hence, the surface band structure. Tunneling at positive voltages accesses the empty 71"* band, while at negative voltage the tunneling current is probing the filled 71" band. At low voltages the states primarily contributing to the tunneling process are from states near the surface Brillouin zone edge. This method relies on the fact that at any bias voltage only the electronic states between the Fermi levels of the tip and the sample contribute to the tunneling current. Thus one obtains implicitly an image of those states, as is apparently the case in Fig.3.9. However, it seems to be somewhat more problematic if both geometric and electronic structures contribute to both images, such as in the case of both current images of the Si (1ll) -7 x 7 surface obtained at - 2 V and +2 V applied bias. This would also be true if one images a region containing an atomic step where, in addition to the electronic structure, one would observe the purely geometric features associated with the step. The surface states of low miller index surfaces of a number of metals, such as Au(1ll), Fe(OOl), Cr(OOl), etc, have also been identified by STS method [3.23-25]. Moreover, quantizations in the surface state spectrum, seen as oscillatory behavior in conductance curves, was observed at the
54
20
60
40
8
25
>-
E!'
50
75
100
125
Distance (A)
(J)
c
W
Fig. 3. lOa, b. Distribution of the confined electron states of a 36 AAu (Ill) terrace. (a) 3D map of dIldV as a function of the distance perpendicular to the steps and of the vollage appl· ied to the sample(energy). The bias ranges from -0.47 V (bottom) to +0.38 V (top). (b) Individual dIldV line scans for different sample voltages. The dOlled line is a constant-current STM Iine scan, step edge peaks are marked by S [3.26]
monatomic step sites [3.26]. In this case, the steps sites are served as the dimensional restrains and resulted in the energy levels for electronic states (Fig.3.1O).
55
3.4.2 Adsorbate-Covered Surfaces Measurement of I-V curves at constant tip-sample separation has found wide application in spatially-resolved studies of adsorbate-covered surfaces. The most notable cases are the study of the interaction of NH 3 [3.27], Cl [3.28] and 0 [3.29] with Si (111) and the study of localized atomic scale defects. STM images of a clean Si(111)-7x7 surface clearly show two inequivalent types of surface Si adatoms, called "corner" adatoms and "center" adatoms. Upon exposure to NH" individual adatoms disappear from the images as their dangling bonds are passivated by reaction with NH 2 or H. Curves of d(lnI)/d(ln V) were measured on a dense grid, allowing a detailed study of the interaction (Fig. 3.10). Spectroscopic measurements provide further insight into charge transfer and energy-level shifts associated with the reaction. It is found that the so-called rest-atom sites are the most reactive of all. Reaction with H gives rise to significant charge transfer to neighboring adatoms, which react next. Results from the Si(111)-(V3 x V3)AI surface are exhibited in Fig. 3.11. Images in Fig.3.11a,b were obtained with +2 V and -2 V bias, respectively, and show the (V3 XV3) lattice, with some defects. The defects appear as reductions in Fig. 3. 11 a and as elevations in Fig. 3.11 b. Figure 3.11c displays d(lnI)/d(ln V) curves taken on a regular lattice position and on a defect position. In a detailed comparison with theory, Hamers et al. [3.30] demonstrated that the regular lattice positions correspond with an Al atom adsorbed on the top of three-layer Si atoms. The three Al valenceelectron pair with the three Si dangling bonds. These back-bonds are imaged in Fig. 3.11 b. An empty P z orbital protrudes into the vacuum and is imaged in Fig.3.11a. The defects are due to Si atoms substituting for Al atoms. Si has one more valence electron than AI, and the Pz orbital is therefore not empty, giving rise to the extra electronic state at -0.5 eV seen in Fig.3.11c. In the STS measurements of oxygen adsorption on GaAs (110) J .A. Stroscio and co-workers observed both short-range effects due to adsorbateinduced changes in the local density of states as well as long-range effects due to surface band bending. It was noted that the oxygen-GaAs complex displays a positive STM contour when sampling the filled electronic state, while a negative STM contour is observed when sampling the unoccupied states. This striking voltage dependence observed in the STM contours results from the energy dependence of the local density of states. The oxygen data verified the prediction from a theoretical analysis based on a negatively-charged adsorbate. The negative charge can be associated with a filled surface acceptor state on p-type material. The oxygen appears neutral in the
56
--;;;;-"" ~
~
-2
-1
0
1
2
Energy reV]
-2
-I
0
1
2
Energy reV]
Fig. 3.11. (a) Empty-state topography of the Si (111)-7 X7 surface. The spatially resolved tunneling spectra shown below were obtained while in the positions indicated by arrows for the restatom site (A), an adatom next 10 the corner hole (B) and a center adatom (C). (b) Empty-state topography of the Si (111)-7 X7 surface after reaction with NH 3 . Curve A was laken over a reacted restatom, curve B (broken) over a reacted corner adatom, curve B (solid) over an unreacled corner ada 10m and curve C over an unreacted center atom. The reaction leads to readily observable changes in local electronic structure at reacted sites; compare spectra B (left) and B (right, dashed line). In addition, the effect at unreacted sites as a result of a reaction at neighboring sites is apparent; compare spectra C (left) and C (right) [3.27]
images, indicative of the acceptor state being unfilled, which agrees with the lack of band bending observed in spectroscopic measurements.
3.4.3 Superconductivity One of the many promising applications of the combined STM and spectroscope is in the field of superconductivity, especially since there is the possibility of spatially resolving the energy gap in superconductors on the scale of a few Angstroms. Real-space images of variations of the superconducting energy gap have been obtained from Nb foils, NbN films, Nb 2 Sn, Nb 3 Sn, organic su57
perconductor (BEDT-TTFh Cu(NCSh and a number of high-T c oxide superconductors. The comparison of the surface topography and gap distribution permits the detection of possible correlations between local variations in superconductivity and topographic features. One example of the applications of spectroscopic methods to the surface electronic states of superconductors is to clarify the origin of the conductance plane of Bi 2 Sr 2Ca . CU 2 8 , From the results obtained by resonant photoemission (PES), Inverse PhotoEmission Spectroscopy (IPES), X-ray absorption and electron energy loss spectroscopies, it has been proposed that the electronic states at the Fermi level consist of mainly 2p atomic orbitals with x-y (in plane) symmetry. A critical problem in modeling the high-T c mechanism based on these experimental results is which plane in the crystal, BiO or Cu0 2 , provides the 02p orbitals at the Fermi level. Figure 3 .12a shows the normalized differential conductance curve [(dIldV)/(I1V)] of the surface of Bi 2 Sr 2 Ca' CU 2 8 , This curve has a gap of about 0.3 eV at E F , suggesting a nonmetallic nature of the BiO plane (STM and TEM studies of a cleaved surface of a single-crystal sample indicate that the topmost cleaved surface is a BiO plane). Figure 3.12b displays the PES and IPES spectra of the same sample which represent the occupied and unoccupied electronic density of states, respectively, the PES and IPES spectra reveal a clear Fermi edge leading to a substantial density of states at E F , taking into account the effects of energy resolution: 0.2 eV for PES and 0.4 eV for IPES. Considering the differ-
°
°
81
f
~
I
I
AI
AI
:::'0 ;:.
-2
-1
~ 6
--
~
~
°
1
2
1
2
Si
4
°. 2 (c)
·1
0 Energy leV]
3
I (a)
Fig.3.13. (a) Tunneling spectrum of a cleaved surface of a Bi 2 CaSr2 CU2 08 single crystal. The STS spectral intensity (dIldV)/(lIV) represents the local density of states and (dIldV)/(I1V) = 1 corresponds to zero density of states. (b) Photoemission and inverse photoemission spectra in the vicinity of the Ferm i level (E F ) [3.31)
STS
;;-
--
-'
;:'2
> '0
--
§
IL
~)
~
'c::l
-e '"
~
'Vi c:
;":
- l= -1.0
EF
1.0
Energy relative to E F leV]
ence in probing depth between the photoemission (probing a few atomic layers) and the tunneling spectroscopy (probing a topmost atomic layer), the tunneling spectrum presents the electronic density of state of the BiO plane, while PES and IPES spectra probably correspond to the electronic density of states involving both the BiO and the Cu0 2 planes. Thus, Tanaka et al. [3.31] concluded that the BiO planes have a nonmetallic nature and the Fermi liquid states observed by PES and IPES are spread on Cu0 2 planes. A Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu2 08 crystal may be composed of alternating stacking of metallic (Cu0 2) and nonmetallic (BiO) planes, as sketched schematically in Fig.3.13. This mode is also supported by resonant Raman spectroscopy data. In addition, an energy gap of 20 meV was identified in association with CuO chains in YBa 2 CU 3 7 , The origin was related to either CDW transition or proximity coupled superconductivity [3.32]. Using STM has enabled researchers to find the quasiparticle bound state in type-II superconductor 2H-NbSe 2 [3.33]. It has been further proposed that STM could be used to probe the impurity-induced resonances and the superconducting order parameter symmetry [3.34].
°
Fig.3.12. Si (111)-(''; 3 X V 3)AI: (a) empty-state image; (b) filled-state image; (c) (dIldV)/(IIV) taken on an AI adalOm (top) and a Si adalOm (boltom) [3.30) 58
59
3.4.4 Outlook As outlined above, the capability to measure the spatial variation of the tunneling spectra with the resolution of STM has proved especially fruitful. However, there are still some problems to be resolved in the future.
a) Influence of the Tip The size, shape and chemical identity of the tip influence not only the resolution and shape of a STM scan but also the measured electronic structure. It was shown that the wave functions of well-prepared, clean and stable tips (for instance, prepared by FIM) are apparently sufficiently featureless so as to be indistinguishable in the data. However, such well prepared tips have not been utilized in most STM and STS experiments. In general, the tip DOS does not resemble that of a free-electron metal. To have meaningful STS measurements, the tip DOS must be determined independently. Two methods have been proposed for determining the energy spectrum of a sharp metal tip. For a free-electron metal tip, the Field Emission Spectroscopy (FES) is described by the Young formula [3.35]. A deviation from the formula indicates a deviation from a free-electron metal behavior [3.36]. The other method is known as the marching method, measuring the dynamic conductasnces on the same sample using a free-electron-metal tip and another tip of unknown DOS [3.36].
b) Interpretation of Spectroscopy Results There is no sure and simple way to understand spectroscopic information. For example, the image of the Si (111)-("v'3 XV3) Ag surface contains two maxima in the unit cell, with the maxima arranged in a honeycomb structure. Loenen et al. [3.37] argued on spectroscopic grounds that these have to be Si atoms, but Wilson et al. argued on the basis of essentially identical data that the maxima must be Ag atoms [3.38]. The simple fact suggests, no matter how many I-V curves one measure, that STM is not going to tell us whether the bumps are Ag or Si.
-
.~
'"
U
'0
..--°2
SrO
E
Cu02 Ca
;0
Cu02
'c
SrO Bi ___
~
a.
::J
Bi"--
60
I
Bi ___ Bi
} ) O
2
~
The other note of warning is that, although the (dIJdV)/ (IN) (or d(ln 1)/ d(ln V» corresponds closely to the sample density of states, it is not related directly to the density of states of both sample and tip. Remember that the tunneling current is also determined by the tunneling transmission probability density. If the sample has a large density of states, but these states do not overlap with the tip, these states are inaccessible in a tunneling experiment. One example may be the d band on Ag. In a photoemission experiment, the d orbitals will be the dominant feature in the electron energy distribution curve. However, the d orbitals are too small to be visible in a tunneling experiment. In addition, one has to be careful that the apparent location of an electronic orbital is not the same as the location of the atomic core. In most cases it would be difficult to figure out what is going on without the help of theory [3.39]. In order to fully understand the STM results, Ding et al. [3.40] have investigated this surface using first-principles total-energy calculations. The lowest-energy configuration consists of a top layer of Ag atoms arranged as honeycomb-chained trimers lying above a distorted "missing-top-layer" Si (111) substrate. It is found that the honeycomb structure observed in STM images arises not from the top-layer atomic positions but rather from the electronic charge density of an empty surface band near the Fermi level. The maxima of the electronic distribution for the empty states occur at the center of the Ag trimers, and are situated over the fourth Si layer, in agreement with the result obtained by Wilson and Chiang [3.41]. In this chapter we have reviewed the concept of tunneling spectroscopy and some ways to obtain spectroscopic information with STM. In spite of some limitations mentioned above, scaning tunneling microscopy and spectroscopy will continue to make many important contributions to surface science in the years to come.
_7.
-~ Non·metal
Non-metal
/
~Non-metal
Fig. 3.14. Schematic view of alternating metallic Cu02 and nonmetallic BiO planes derived from Fig. 3. 12 61
4. STM Instrumentation
Even though the principle of a scanning tunneling microscope is not very complicated, many factors must be taken into consideration in the design to ensure a stable and reliable instrument. Optimum functioning of an STM device requires tip-to-sample position control with picometer precision, a rough and fine positioning capability in three dimensions, a scanning speed as high as possible, and also, preferably, simplicity of operation. These requirements have to be satisfied in the presence of building vibrations with up to micrometer-size amplitudes, electric noise, thermal drift, creep and hysteresis of piezoelectric translation elements and other perturbations. Some design rules are discussed in this chapter with emphasis on the vibration isolation, stiffness, electrical control circuitry, tip preparation and computer control system.
4.1 The Vibration Isolation System The frame of the instrument is always subjected to vibrations transmitted from the ground or the air. As indicated in (1.1), the tunneling current depends exponentially on the gap between tip and sample, even the smallest vibrations, such as those caused by sound in air and by people walking around a building, can affect the stability of the instrument. For many materials, especially metals, the atomic corrugations observed in the constantcurrent STM mode will typically be 0.01 nm. Therefore, a good vibrationisolation system is very important for a well-functioning STM, and the changes of the gap distance caused by vibrations must be kept less than 0.001 nm [4.1]. There are two types of disturbance from which an STM device must be isolated: vibration and shock. Vibrations are generally repetitive and continuous, while shock is defined as a transient condition whereby kinetic energy is transferred to a system in a short period of time. Of them, vibration isolation is most critical. Machines running at or near laboratories excite vibrations of the building at frequencies typically between 10 and 100 Hz. The frame, walls and 63
floors of a building undergo mostly shear and bending vibrations which usually resonate at frequencies between 15 and 25 Hz. Vibrations originating from ventilation ducts, transformers and motors are at frequencies between 6 and 65 Hz, while those caused by people walking and working in laboratories typically are in the range of 1 to 3 Hz. Hence, in the process of minimization of the sensitivity of an STM to building vibrations, primary attention has to be given to the frequency range between 1 and 100 Hz. Increasing the inherent resonance frequency of the STM body and employing a vibration damping system are two major ways to isolate vibrations. Viton, metal springs and magnetic eddy-current damping can be utilized for damping components. For an UHV-STM assembly a widely used vibration-isolation scheme which adopts these components is illustrated in Fig.4.1. The vibration isolation consists of two sets of stages which, suspended from springs, nestle within the stainless-steel cylindrical frame of the microscope. The inner stage slips into the outer stage, from which it is suspended by three springs. The inner stage carries the multi-stacked metal plates separated by Viton spacers. The heart of the microscope containing both the scanning tip and the sample sits on the top of the plates. When the
entire microscope resides in vacuum, air resistance is minimum, and the outer and inner stages could, if they were disturbed, bounce up and down almost indefinitely. To stop this motion, permanent magnets mounted on the bottom of the outer stage slide between copper plates attached to the support frame and the inner stage. As each plate slides up and down, the magnetic field induces an eddy current. The interaction between the eddy current and the magnetic field retards the motion of the plate and thereby damps the STM. The Viton spacers between the metal plates are used mainly for the purposes of damping the vibrations propagating along the springs and reducing the effects caused by a large-amplitude shock, although they exhibit pronounced creep. They are substantially incompressible. When strained under compression, their compression stiffness (equivalent to the spring constant) is often large, resulting in a rather high (> 10 -:-100Hz) resonance frequency. However, they have inherent damping of a tenth or a hundredth of the critical damping. Metal springs can have smaller spring constants, resulting in low resonance frequencies (5 -:- 0.5 Hz), but they provide little damping and require additional damping components. The eddy-current damping systems, on the other hand, can easily have varied damping coefficients and be compatible with an UHV system. The eddy-current damping coefficient [g/sJ is equal to 'Y = 9.69' 10- 9 B2 eslp ,
D
Stainless steel
CJ
Magnet
~ Copper
I!'JI
First stage 64
Viton
Fig. 4. l. Schematic diagram of the assembly of a STM instrument and its vibration isolation system.
(4.1)
where B is the magnetic field [GaussJ, e is the thickness (in the direction of B) of the conductor [cm], S is the cross-sectional area [cm2 ], and p is the resistivity [0' cm]. In general, the eddy-current damping with permanent magnets is useful only in the case that the mass and natural frequency of the system are relatively low. Commercially available vibration-isolation systems employing pneumatic springs are often used as the support for a STM. Some of them can have a resonant frequency as low as 0.5 Hz with a variable damping constant. The more rigid the construction of an STM is, the fewer requirements it has for the external vibration-isolation system. Hansma et al. [4.2J described a vibration isolation system that consists of only a concrete block hung from the ceiling with rubber tubes which are at the same time springs and dampers. The very rigid STM unit is placed directly on the concrete block. Vibrations are dissipated by hysteresis losses due to the inherent structural damping of a rigid body. In the construction of a rigid STM body, the resonant frequency of piezo drivers as well as joints tightened by screws, epoxy junctions, three-point contacts and loose spring connectors will have serious effects on the resonant frequency of the constructed STM and the quality factor Q' of the tip-sample junction. 65
The vibration amplitude transfer expression proposed by Kuk and Silverman [4.3] for a spring-viscous damping system under the condition of structural damping P~ » Po (p~ being the resonant frequency of a rigidly constructed STM, and Po is the resonant frequency of a vibration isolation system) is given by
T
=
1 + (~plpo)2 ] 1/2 [ (1-1' 2 /1' 2)2 + (2~plpo)2 [(1-1'2 0
(plp~)2
Ip~2)2 + (plp~Q')2]112 .
(
4.2
)
The first term represents the amplitude-transfer term of a spring's viscous damping system and the second term is the damping-transfer function for a hysteresis loss due to the inherent structural damping of a rigid body. In addition, I' is the external exciting frequency, ~ (= y/y c) is the damping ratio, y is the damping coefficient of the system, and Yc (= 4m7rp o) is the critical damping coefficient. The amplitude transfers calculated for four STMs are shown in Fig. 4.2. The solid line corresponds to a system with Po = 2 Hz, P~ = 2 kHz, ~ = 0.4, and Q' = 10. With a floor-vibration amplitude of a few thousand Angstroms, the gap stability for this system will be better than 1 A. For a very rigid STM assembly (shown by a dotted line in the figure where P~ = 12kHz and Q' = 50), the amplitude transfer is still too large (higher than 1 A. at 200 Hz) for a stable STM junction. With the addition of a vibrationisolation table (po = 1Hz and ~ = 0.4), the amplitude transfer (shown by 10°
"
,,
10- 2 ~
~ '"c::
g "0 '" i= .
10- 4
./' ./"
10- 6
"
E
-<
./ 10- 8
~,
1,/ 10- 1
',
f' 10- 10
./"./"
---,"":-°7-'-'''/
/
/\
/
\ ~
~
I
10°
/"
\
~
~
I !
10 1
10 2 10 3 Frequeocy [Hz]
10 4
\..1 10 5
Fig. 4.2. Total amplitude transfer for four systems with different vibration isolations and structural dampings [4.3] 66
the broken line) is < 10- 6 and the tunneling gap will be stable to <0.01 A. at 200 Hz. For a two-stage vibration isolation system: one with an internal spring system (po = 1.0Hz, ~ = 0.4) and another with an external table (po = 1.1 Hz, ~ = 0.5), the amplitude transfer (shown as a chained line) indicates that the estimated vibration amplitude is less than 0.001 A. in most of the frequency range when the structural damping for the STM assembly is P~ = 2 kHz and Q' = 10.
4.2 Mechanical Designs The following criteria must be satisfied in the design of an ideal STM [4.4]: • • • •
•
The z-scanning range is at least 1 /-Lm with an accuracy of 0.001 nm. The x- and y-scanning capability must be of the same range with an accuracy of 0.01 nm. The scan window (x, y) should be selectable in the same range. The coarse sample-approach system should be smooth without rocking motion or backlash, and should move in the 1 mm to 100 nm range with <0.1 /-Lm accuracy, or at least less than the z-piezoelectric driver range, depending on the driving voltage and the piezoelectric expansion coefficient. The gap between the tip and the sample should be as rigid as possible, i.e., a high mechanical resonance frequency and a low Q-factor of the tip-sample junction.
The first two requirements result from the need for a three-dimensional tip-translation capability that is necessary to record surface topography with atomic resolution in a reasonable scanning range. For samples which need a large scan range (for example, O.lmmxO.lmm), different scanners should be used due to the fact that the same three-dimensional scanner is not capable of achieving atomic resolution over such a large-scan range. The third requirement is for the purpose of selecting an area of interest on the sample surface, for example, to localize the details of surface defects or adsorbed atoms and molecules which have been found in a largearea scan. The fourth requirement emerges from the need for the capability of convenient sample loading and tip exchange, for efficient reduction of tip-to-sample separation from macroscopic to tunneling distances and to avoid accidental contact of the tip with the sample. The last requirement, as described previously, is for dissipating external vibrations. In general, the trend has been toward compactness and simplicity since it has become clear that increasing the rigidity of microscopes can be more conveniently achieved than perfecting a vibration isolation system. 67
An air-STM is often used for inert samples, and the construction and operation is simpler compared to the UHV-STM which is required for accurate and reliable studies of clean surfaces. The design concepts of the two instruments are quite similar but the desorption rate of the materials, a capability for in-situ tip exchanging and sample loading, and for convenient sample treatments must be taken into consideration in the UHV-5TM design. The rather large devices for mounting and changing the tip and sample in the UHV-STM reduce the mechanical rigidity of the microscope and lower the mechanical resonant frequencies. The design of an UHVSTM is further complicated by the backe-out that is required for outgassing the entire vacuum system and by the sample-cleaning procedure that usually involves heating and sputtering. The mechanical design of the STM for operating at low temperature also represents a considerably greater challenge because of the difficulties of vibration isolation, in-situ surface preparation and characterization, the problems of dimensional contraction, and reduced piezoelectric response under cryogenic conditions.
high-temperature applications. The PZT-5A type has a high sensitivity, a high dielectric constant and a good time stability; it can be used in transmitters. Compared with PZT-5A, PZT-5H with a higher dielectric constant can find its best application at low frequencies, but functions only in a limited temperature range. Both of the PZT-5 types have high mechanical motion sensitivity, therefore they are suitable for three-dimensional scanners in the STM for operation in room temperature. The PZT ceramics are available from many manufacturers in a variety of shapes and configurations, including strips, plates, bimorphs, stacks and tubes, as shown in Fig.4.3. The directions are identified by the subscripts 1,2,3, representing the cartesian coordinates x,y,z, respectively. By convention, the polarization direction is 3, pointing from the positive to the negative electrode. For a strip of length eand thickness t, a displacement in the I-direction is produced as a result of the electric field V in the 3-direction. The magnitude of the displacement is given by (4.3)
M = (f/t)d 31 V
4.2.1 Piezoelectric Ceramics where d [mlY] is the piezoelectric strain coefficient for a particular materiAs discussed above, for high-performance STMs, a resolution is sought of about 0.01 om normal to the sample surface (z direction), and about 0.1 nm laterally (x, y directions). This results in very narrow tolerance requirements for controlling the tip, which cannot be satisfied by using the usual mechanical devices. Piezoelectric ceramics are therefore widely employed as an electromechanical transducer to obtain the accurate x,y,z motion and the tip approach. A piezoelectric actuator is an electromechanical device that undergoes a dimensional change when an electric voltage is applied. Single crystals of many compounds, quartz for instance, possess piezoelectric properties. More recently, polycrystalline ceramic materials such as lead zirconate titanate [Pb(Ti. Zr)03] (PZT) and barium titanate have been extensively developed for their piezoelectric properties. Piezoelectric ceramics differ from crystals in that they must undergo a poling procedure for the piezoelectric phenomenon to occur. These materials can convert electric potential signals of 1 mV to 1000 V into mechanical motion in the range from less than one Angstrom to a few micrometers. PZT piezoelectric ceramic material is available in a variety of properties and compositions with different dopants. PZT-4 and PZT-8 types of piezoceramics can be applied to high-power acoustic transmission and highvoltage generators for their high-power capability. At cryogenic temperatures, PZT-8 has the lowest temperature variations. In addition, PZT-8 has a high depoling field and a high Curie temperature, which is suitable for 68
Ca) PZT strip Contraction
1/
tL pI
r
.
~+
,-
"
Cd) Bimorph
----
.-/
+. I I
pI pI
./
./ ....... /\. ./ )
./
;>
..... .-.-
./
.-
(b) PZT laminate Contraction
f:lW (c) PZT stack assembly . - - - - Insulator
(e) PZT tube
I~+
Fig. 4.3. Several shapes of PZT piezoelectric ceramics 69
ai, expressing the ratio of strain developed along one axis to the electric field strength along the same or a different axis, assuming all external stresses are constant. The first subscript of d indicates the direction of the applied electric field and the second is the direction of the induced strain. The strain coefficient d is negative representing contraction perpendicular to the field; and positive for stain measured along the 3-direction (along which the thickness t is measured) representing expansion parallel to the electric field direction: (4.4)
Lit = d 33 V .
Although there are many ceramic compositions used today, most can be placed into two general categories: hard and soft PZT materials. Typical d coefficients for hard PZT materials are
Stack extension: d 33 Nd V
where Nd is the number of disks. As implied by the equation above, large displacements can be achieved by a small stack as long as each disk is sufficiently thin. As indicated in (4.3) for a strip geometry, the largest extension per one volt is obtained when the ratio elt is maximized. Unfortunately, making very thin strips results in actuators that are compliant and prone to buckling when loaded lengthwise. To improve their strength and rigidity, strips can be bonded side by side with opposing poling directions to form laminated structures (Fig.4.3) with the same extension per one volt as the individual strips. The changes along its length of such a laminated structure can be expressed by Lix
d 33
250.10- 12 m/V, d 31
=
= -
110.10- 12
600'10- 12 m/V, d 31
=
- 270 .10- 12 mlY .
d 31 = - 273.10- 12 mlY .
A bimorph represents a sandwich structure with a thin metal strip bonded in between two PZT strips, as shown in Fig.4.3. When held at one end in an external electric field, bimorphs bend with a displacement at the other end, reaching 100 14m due to the lengthwise expansion or contraction of the PZT elements. However, such devices lack mechanical strength and inherently have low resonant frequencies. Increased mechanical strength is possible by supporting the bimorph at both ends and utilizing the displacement at the center of the strip. In this case, the expression becomes Lix
=
(3/8)d 31 V(elt)2 .
(4.5)
It is apparent from (4.4) that the change in thickness of a PZT material in any of the three directions is only a function of the voltage applied. No matter what thickness, the absolute extension Lit depends only on the voltage V for a given d constant. Therefore, to obtain a larger displacement in the direction in which either t or e is measured, it is necessary to assemble a stack of disk-shaped or strip piezoelectric elements, as sketched in Fig.4.3. The total extension is thereby the sum of the individual elements and given by
70
d 31 Vee/t) .
(4.7)
The choice between a strip or laminate assembly for a particular application will be determined by the need for the load-bearing capability if a thin strip is required to achieve sufficient extension. A tube with electrodes on its inner and outer surfaces is a very common structure for a single piezoelectric element, and the poling direction is right through the wall. Consequently, the axial extension is given by
For PZT-5H d 33 = 593.10- 12 m/V,
=
m/V;
and for soft PZT materials d 33
(4.6)
ve Lie
=
d31 OD _ ID
(4.8)
where e is the length along tube axis, OD and ID are the outer and the inner diameters of the tube, respectively. The radial extension is Llr
=
d 33 V .
(4.9)
A tubular piezoelectric element is required to have higher uniformity of the wall thickness. Otherwise, unequal wall thickness around the perimeter of the tube will cause a bending motion as one side of the tube extends farther than the other.
4.2.2 Three-Dimensional Scanners The 3-dimensional scanner is a device that moves the tunneling tip across the sample surface (x,y) and controls the tip-sample separation (z). BasicalIy, the designs of 3-dimensional scanners made of piezoelectric ceramic materials include the tripod, the single tube and a cross combined with a 71
(3)
Jf
(b)
________l z offset voltage
----r
Teipod
controls tip height
z Electrode
Common
z + YElectrode
_ y Electrode
+ YElectrode
+ y Offset
- x Electrode (hidden)
x Offset
+ x Electrode + x Electrode
x
Fig. 4.5. lIJustrating the voltages applied to the electrodes of the single-tube scanner
x
+ Fig.4.4. Common three-dimensional scanners: (a) tripod, (b) single tube, and (c) a cross combined with a single tube
single tube. The earliest design of a scanner is a tripod of three orthogonal piezo "sticks" (Fig.4.4a). The STM tip is placed on the top of the tripod, and the independent extension and contraction of the three "sticks" make the tip move along the x,y,z directions. The response of the tripod made of three PZT-5H piezo sticks being 13 mm long, 2 mm high and 2 mm wide is generally 1.5 nm per volt in each direction, and the maximum mechanical resonant frequency is 5 kHz. Replacement of the "sticks" by tubes can reduce the cross talk and raises the resonant frequency. As a simple piezoelectric element, the big advantage of tubes over strips is their structural rigidity. A compact, single-tube scanner was first employed in an STM by Binnig and Smith [4.5]. The outer electrode of a PZT tube is divided into four equal quadrants, the inside electrode being not separated. By applying different voltages to opposite quadrants, the tube is made to bend perpendicular to the tube axis. Orthogonal x-y motion is obtained by controlling voltages on quadrants 90 degrees apart, while the contraction of the whole tube along the tube axis by applying a voltage on the inner electrode leads to the movement in the z direction. The other two outer electrodes can be either at ground, or a bias DC voltage can be applied for the purpose of scan-window selection. Figure 4.5 illustrates several schemes for applying voltages onto the electrodes of the tube scanner. The tube scanner exhibits large displacements, a low cross talk and a high resonant frequency. The resonant frequency [Hz] of the single-tube design can be estimated by 72
f r = 1.08·10 5 e- 2
Jro 2 + r2 j
(4.10)
where r i , r a are the radius of the inner and outer wall, respectively, and e is the length of the tube in cm. For a PZT-5H tube of 12.7 mm in length, 6.35 mm in diameter and 0.51 mm in wall thickness, the response in the x, yand z directions is 5 nm/V, and the inherent resonant frequencies parallel and perpendicular to the tube axis are 40 and 8 kHz, respectively. This design has become popular owing to its small size and high resonant frequency. Unequally divided outer electrodes of the tube, unequal wall thickness and the deviation of the tip position from the center of the tube axis will result in nonorthoganl x-y motion. Therefore, only accurately manufactured piezoelectric ceramic tubes can be used for the scanner. There is another design of an x-y scanner employing a cross-shaped piezoelectric ceramic material. The motion in the z direction is accomplished by a piezoelectric tube mounted at the center of the cross. The controlling voltages with the same magnitude but opposite signs are applied to the x,-x and y,-y electrodes, respectively (Fig.4.6). This design with sym-
Fig. 4.6. Illustrating the voltages applied to the electrodes of a cross single-tube scanner 73
metrically arranged piezo blocks has been successful in reducing the effects of thermal drift. The primary design goal is for a scanner to be as rigid as possible for a given scan range. Specifically, the figures of merit are the resonant frquencies of the scanner in each orthogonal direction. It is important to have the resonant frequencies high, not only because they fix the scanning-speed (feedback performance), but also because they determine its rigidity against vibration. Other requirements of a good scanner are high resolution, orthogonality and linearity - the amount of movement should be proportional to the applied voltage. The problems of nonlinearity, hysteresis and creep become more serious for large area scans, where the electric field is large. These effects can be minimized by controlling the total charge applied to the piezoelectric rather than the voltage [4.6], by taking an image of a standard sample to find the amount of distortion and re-map the image with software in a way that removes the distortion, or by using independent position sensors for the x and y axes, such as an optical sensor or a capacitance probe [4.7,8].
age between MF and GP, and are released when the voltage is removed. Elongating and contracting the body of the louse with the appropriate clamping sequence of the feet moves the louse in any direction in steps between 10 nm and I !-,m, and up to 30 steps/so In this way, sample and tip can be approached vibration-free to within the working range of the piezo drivers to avoid accidental contact of tip and sample. The rough drive also serves for separating the sample (ca. I cm) in the cleaning procedures and to compensate for thermal expansions when working at elevated temperatures. Burleigh Instruments has developed a unique piezoelectric linear motor called the Inchworm Motor. The principle of operation is depicted in Fig. 4.8. The Inchworm Motor consists of a piezoelectric ceramic tube and a shaft that closely fits the tube. The outer electrode of the tube is divided perpendicularly to its length into three PZT elements. Two of them serve as clamps and a center one is the PZT actuator that does not touch the shaft. When a voltage is applied to the end element 1 or 3, it is made to clamp tightly to the shaft due to the contraction of the circumference of the tube governed by d 33 , and to release when the voltage is removed. When a voltage is applied to the first PZT element, it clamps the shaft. Then, a vari-
4.2.3 Coarse Sample Positioning The z-piezo range is limited in the STM for which the recognition of individual surface atoms is the key design objective. Therefore, a means of reducing the gap distance between tip and sample to within the working range of the z piezo, known as the coarse-approach system, is required. Such a device also needs to be able to move the sample far enough away from the tip to allow sample transfer. A coarse approach to such a device is called "louse" sketched in Fig. 4.7. It was used in the early STM designed by G. Binnig and H. Rohrer at the IBM ZOrich Laboratory. The louse (L) body consists of a piezoplate with a sample holder on top and resting on three metal feet (MF), separated by high-dielectric-constant insulators from the metal ground plates (GP). The feet are clamped electrostatically to the ground plate by applying a volt-
I
+ 100 -IOOOY
Extend 2
74
I
Cf ==l:=J L..F
I
I
•
I
3 JD § JD ~
Clnmpll
~
I
I
p
Contract 2 «
Unclamp 3 Fig. 4.7. Sketch of the "louse"
I_.,...=::=~=!....
Clnmp I
Unclnmp I
~GP
l~
off
Clnmp 3
2
~
I
I
I
I
I
Fig. 4. 8. The principle of operation of the piezoelectric Inchworm Motor 75
able-rate staircase voltage is applied to the center PZT element causing it to change length in discrete steps of approximately 4 nm each. The staircase may be stopped or reversed at any step. At the end of the staircase a voltage is applied to the third PZT element causing it to grip the shaft. Then, the voltage is removed from the first PZT element, releasing the shaft. The staircase starts downwards until it reaches its lower limit, at which point the first PZT element is activated again, the third PZT element released, and the staircase starts again. If the center PZT element is fixed to a support, the above manipulation will make the shaft move along one direction. This sequence can be repeated any number of times or reversed to make the shaft move in the opposite direction. The total travel distance of the shaft is limited only by the length of the shaft. By employing piezoelectric ceramic materials with different stress coefficients, changing the amplitude and frequency of the voltage applied, the precision and speed of the shaft motion can well be controlled. The Inchworm Motor has successfully been utilized in the sample coarse-approach system of the STM. There are several factors to be considered in selecting a sampleapproach mechanism: reliability, geometry, rigidity and speed. The selection of any kind of sample-positioning device should be based upon the unique requirements of the particular microscope design. Three useful techniques for coarse sample positioning are: •
• •
A walker which moves by piezo expansion and using electrostatic, mechanical or magnetic clamping. Both the louse and the Inchworm Motor belong to this category. A differential screw micrometer pushing on a reduction lever. The differential screw can be driven either manually or by a stepping motor. A lead screw pushing against a differential spring.
Each design has its own advantages: the first design is often used in vacuum chambers, the second in the atmosphere, and the third at low temperature. Lever or differential screw mechanisms have been employed for a fast approach and easy manipulation of the sample holder, which can usually be detached or flipped away from the STM assembly.
4.2.4 STMs for Operation in Various Environments Due to different three-dimensional scanners and sample coarse-approach mechanisms employed in STM, hundreds of types of STMs have been designed to date. The smallest STM is only 1000 x 200 x 8 ~m3 in size; the maximum scanning range can reach 200 ~m. Some of them are designed for operating in an UHV chamber equipped with standard surface characterization tools such as AES, LEED, HM, SEM, etc. (Chap. I). 76
(b)
(3)
Rod connected to linear motion feedthrough Coarse adjust beam (B) .....--'"11'""
Steel ball (B)
I
Slide (S)
I
;'
'II
I
I
I I
Flexible joints Shifter (Sh) connected to linear motion feed through
I
Piezo-tube for z motion
I
t . = ;:::l I
Tunneling tip Cantilever support plate (Csp)
I llr J
-tjf;1J~ UI 'CI
Cantilever Spring loaded screw (Sc) Fig. 4.9. The mechanical adjusting mechanism of the low-temperature UHV AFM/STM
[4.9J
Giessibl et al. [4.9] built an UHV atomic force/scanning AFM/STM which can be operated at 4.2 K. The microscope, of only 20 x20 x70 mm 3 in size, is incorporated into a very small chamber (100ml) which can be evacuated and baked to UHV within a few hours via a specially designed valve. Figure 4.9 illustrates the principle of the AFM/STM system. Figure 4.9a is a sketch of the approach mechanism for the z distance between sample and AFM cantilver. The slide (S) carrying the sample is pressed onto a steel ball (B) and an axle (A) by a spring (Sp) which acts on a ball bearing. The slide is held in position by friction between the slide, the axle (A) and the block that holds the entire instrument. Thus, by turning the axle (A) the slide is rolling gently in the vertical direction. The approach is done as follows: The shifter (Sh) is moved upwards until the lower end of its gap (ca. 4mm wide) touches the axle (A). Then, the entire slide is moved upwards until the sample is about 200 ~m away from the cantilever. Thereafter, the shifter is pulled downwards, setting the axle (A) free and turning the lever (L). By turning the lever, the axle (A) is rotating and thereby further approaching the slide (S) towards the cantilever. The lever and axle are made of I mm steel wire, the length of L is 10 mm, so the motion of the shifter is demagnified by a factor of 10. The flexible joints are made by spot-welded sheet metal. Figure 4.9b depicts a sketch of the approach mechanism for the z distance between the cantilever and the tunneling tip. The tunneling tip sits at the end of a piezo-tube. The microfabricated cantilever is held on its sup77
port plate (Csp) and pivots around a spring-loaded screw (Sc). The coarseadjust beam (B) demagnifies the motion of the rod which is connected to one of the linear feedthroughs. By pulling the linear feedthrough, the coarse-adjust beam pulls the cantilever support plate against the tunneling tip. The cantilever is plated with chrome and gold; the tunneling tip is made of tungsten. The z distance between the lever and sample, and the z distance between the tunneling tip and lever can be controlled mechanically from the outside while the instrument can be operated in UHV and submersed into the liquid-helium dewar. To reduce the effect of thermal drift, the AFM itself is made mainly of Invar. Because the sensitivity (displacement per volt) and thus the full-range motion of the piezoelectric-tube scanner at 4.2 K is only about 25 % compared to that at 300 K, the precision of the mechanical approach has to be even better at liquid-helium temperature than at room temperature. Owing to the small size of the instrument and the use of Invar the cantilever and the tunneling tip remain aligned as the instrument is cooled to liquid-helium temperature. However, stress relief in the tunneling-tip mount during bakeout can move the tunneling tip up to 50 /Lm sideways, so care has to be taken when mounting the tunneling tip. PZT-5A is chosen as piezoelectric material for this design because it has a fairly high Curie temperature (i.e., the temperature at which it becomes unpolarized and therefore loses sensitivity) and thus can be soldered. The tube scanner and the piezoelectric tube that controls the distance between the tunneling tip and cantilever are soldered to metal plates at one end with a lead-free solder. The other end is soldered to a slab of metalcoated alumina. This AFM/STM has been tested by imaging Highly Oriented Pyrolytic Graphite (HOPG) in the STM mode and KBr in the AFM mode at 4.2 K and 300 K in UHV. Atomic resolution has been achieved on HOPG, and both the potassium and the bromium ions on the KBr (00 1) cleavage plane have been resolved. Apart from the criteria listed at the beginning of this section, special requirements have to be satisfied in the design of an STM for in-situ electrochemical studies. First, only the very end of the tunneling tip and the sample can take part in chemical react ions with solut ions. Secondly, unwanted Faradaic current has to be minimized because the large Faradaic leakage current will cause difficulties to the feedback control. In order to reduce the Faradaic leakage current, the ideal tip should have a chemically and electrochemically inert insulation except for the very end of the tip. In the next section, some simple techniques for coating the tip with insulating materials are introduced.
78
Single tube xyz~~
translater
Sample ~ /'0.---"
Fig. 4. 10. Schematic diagram of the STM proposed by Sonnenfeld and Hansma for the operation in solution [4.10)
Stepper motor Insulated sample wire -----..' Vibration isolation: I
MACOR-fJr base
samPle~
Pytex sample holder
~
Pyrex base Teflon base
E
Teflon
~
''''''';00
u
I
Bias wire
I It Piezo-tube
~MACOR
. RTV _ O-ring Insulallon Brass'·:- .•..:.. MACOR Tip
Fig. 4. 11. Schematic diagram of the STM capable for the automatic approach [4.11). The insulated tip is shown
Two designs of the STM that can be operated in solutions are depicted in Figs.4.10 and 11. Both of them use piezoelectric ceramic tubes as the three-dimensional scanner. The later design adopts an automatic approach mechanism, permitting the approach in a glove box under N2 atmosphere.
79
4.3 Tip Preparation A frustrating aspect of STM operation is the reliable formation of tunneling probe tips. The size, shape and chemical identity of the tunneling tip influence not only the resolution and shape of an STM scan, but also the measured electronic structure. Three features of probe tips seem to be most important for reliable STM operation [4.12]. First, blunt macrostructuring leads to high flexural resonant frequencies, thus minimizing phase hysteresis and allowing higher data rates to be achieved. Secondly, the atomic microstructure of the tip is the key to image resolution because the tunneling current depends exponentially on the gap distance. It is necessary for stable operation to have a single site of closest atomic approach, which is well supported, i.e., not a whisker. Anomalous imaging artifacts will appear when simultaneous tunneling occurs through multiple atoms on the tip. This is commonly referred to as double-tip imaging. Finally, tip purity is important so that a series barrier is not present. For example, the effective resistance of a tungsten-oxide layer can easily be much higher than the desired tunneling gap resistance. Therefore, mechanical contact of tip and sample would occur before the required tunneling current can be obtained. A nonmetallic tip may also make the STM tunneling spectrum not represent the true electronic structure of the sample surface. STM tips are typically fabricated from metal wires of tungsten (W), platinum-iridium (Pt-Ir), or gold (Au) and sharpened by mechanical grinding, cutting with a wire cutter or razor blade, "controlled" crashing, field emission/evaporation, ion milling, fracture, or electrochemical etching. W tips which fulfill the requirement of being stiff, have been used to a great extent to image specimens. However, an oxide layer may exist on the surface of the tip and sometimes makes it difficult to acquire STM images. Platinum, although a soft metal, is a material preferred over W because it is inert to oxidation. The addition of Ir to form a Pt/Ir alloy adds stiffness while maintaining a chemical inert material. Pt-Ir tips are widely employed, too, particularly in atmospheric and electrochemical environments.
(a)
(b)
-
OW
:N.OH
~
-Stainle~- ~
/(~l
_steel __-
OW
WO~- flow
Fig.4.12. (a) Schematic diagram of the electrochemical cell showing the tungsten wire (anode) being etched in NaOH. The cathode consists of a stainless-steel cylinder which surrounds the anode. (b) Sketch of the etching mechanism showing the "flow" of the tungstate anion down the sides of wire in solution (4. 13]
potential. Each procedure gives a different tip shape; the AC etched tips have a conical shape and much larger cone angles than the DC etched tips. The DC etched tips in the shape of a hyperboloid, on the other hand, are much sharper than AC etched tips and are preferable for high-resolution STM imaging. Figure 4.12 shows the details of the electrochemical cell used in DC etching, which contains 100 ml of 2M NaOH or KOH. The W wire to be etched is placed in the center of the cell and serves as the anode. It is mounted on a micrometer so that its position relative to the surface of the electrolyte can be adjusted more precisely. The counter electrode (or cathode) consists of a stainless-steel cylinder which surround the anode. When a DC voltage of 13 V is applied to the anode, bubbles are observed emerging on the cathode/solution interface. The overall electrochemical reaction is
W(s)
+ 6e+ 80H-
anode:
W(s)
+ 20H- + 2H 2 0 ~ WO~ + 3H2 (g)
4.3.1 Preparation of Tungsten Tips
80
-- - I - I I
-
cathode: 6H 2 0
The preferred method for preparing tungsten tips is the electrochemical etching method which was developed for preparing samples for FIM and FES (Field Electron Spectroscopy). The electrochemical etching procedure usually involves the anodic dissolution of the metal electrode; tungsten in this case. There are two ways in which this can be done: An AlternatingCurrent (AC) etch or a Direct-Current (DC) etch according to the applied
w
w
+
~
+ 60H+ 4H2 0 + 6e-
3H2 (g)
~ WO~
SRP = - 2.45 V SOP
= + 1.05 V
EO = - 1.43 V .
The above reaction involves the oxidation dissoluation of W to soluble tungstate (WO~-) anions at the anode, and the reduction of water to form bubbles of hydrogen gas and OH- ions at the cathode. EO is the standard elec81
trode potential given by the sum of the Standard Reduction Potential (SRP) for water and the Standard Oxidation Potential (SOP) for tungsten. Actually, the reaction mechanism is much complexer than indicated by the above equations, and the potential required to drive an electrochemical reaction is usually higher than that calculated from standard electrode potentials. The excess potential is called the electrochemical polarization, which is affected by changes in the concentration of the reactants and products, and other mass transfer processes; the rate of the reaction or the current density is an exponential function of the polarization. Several factors affecting the etching process have been studied by [be et al. [4.13]. Due to the surface tension of the aqueous solution, a meniscus is formed around the wire once it is placed into the electrolyte, as sketched in Fig.4.l2b. It is primarily the shape of the meniscus which determines the aspect ratio and overall shape of the tip. The shorter the meniscus is, the smaller the aspect ratio becomes. A low aspect ratio is important in reducing vibration in the tip during scanning. With the reaction going on, the change in the surface area of the wire and in the fluid disturbances may result in the variation of the meniscus height. To avoid oddly shaped tips, the meniscus height should be kept at the same position by adjusting the micrometer during the etching. The current density of the reaction is limited by the surface area of the working electrode (tungsten) and is also dependent on the concentration and activity of OH- ions. The portion of the tip below the meniscus would normally be etched away without the denser tungstate layer flowing down along the sides of the wire to protect the lower end. Therefore, due to the protection of the tungstate layer over the W wire below the meniscus, the DC drop-off method will, in fact, produce two tips simultaneously: the part dropping off to the cell bottom after being etched, and the part above the meniscus. Usually, a quick automatic cutoff circuit is used to cut off the potential to avoid over-etching because any part of the wire (usually the very end of the tip) remaining in the solution will continue top-etch as long as there is an applied voltage. Figure 4.13 illustrates a simple automatic cutoff circuit, where "Load" denotes the electrochemical cell (Fig.4.l2). A variable resistor R b has a significant effect on the potential across the load. The voltage Vb is compared to a reference voltage for the accurate setting of a low cutoff voltage. The cutoff time of the etch circuit has a significant effect on the radius of curvature of the tip: the shorter the cutoff time, the smaller both the radius of curvature and the cone angle of the etched tip; i.e., the faster the cutoff time, the sharper the tip. The etching circuit shown in Fig.4.13 has a minimum cutoff time of 500 ns. If the part of the W wire above the drop-off point is desired, the tip should be raised up quickly and rinsed in distilled water to remove the residual etchant solution after etching. If, on the other hand, the drop-off part is desired, protecting 82
~ + 12 V <>-=-i--il G
I
Optional capacitor
R ,Vb 50~ + 5V
SW I
~
1.
V'ef
I
Comparator
I
Etch status LEDs Green=ON Red=OFF
~+12V
1
Rref Etch (lOkQ) enable/disable switch
13kQ
Fig. 4.13. Block diagram of the electronic control circuit to minimize the electrochemical reaction cutoff time following dropoff. R Joad denotes the electrochemical cell illustrated in Fig. 4.12 (4.13]
solutions (for example, trichloromethane) should be placed below the electrolyte to avoid further etching by the electrolyte. It was found that the length of the wire in the solution has a direct effect on the tip, with a longer wire causing the stub to drop off much sooner due to the increased weight. When the weight of the stub exceeds the tensile strength of the neck or the drop-off portion, the stub breaks off, leaving a rough surface or a slight recoil at the end of the tip as the result. These tips have a larger radii of curvature than those of a shorter length in the solution. If the tip above the meniscus is desired, the length of the wire in solution in the range of 1--:-3 mm is most appropriate for a 0.25 mm diameter W wire. The electrolyte concentration is another factor affecting the etching process. Because OH- is consumed in the reaction, it is necessary to replace NaOH solution periodically. The drop-off time increases with the decrease of the OH- concentration. Figure 4.14 exhibits the detailed electrochemical cell used in AC etching. In this method, the AC voltage is much lower than the DC voltage, and a shorter drop-off time can be expected. Either the upper portion or the lower portion which drops off, can be adopted as the tip. If the latter is desired, a shielding solution is also needed to protect the tip.
83
Fig. 4.14. Schematic diagram of the electrochemical cell used in AC etching
Tip holder
T shaped stainless steel fixture Tip
2V
AC
Gold wire loop 2 mm in diameter Fig. 4.16. Schematic diagram of a micropolishing setup to etch Pt-Ir tips by volume: 60% saturated CaCI 2 , 36% H2 0, and 4% HCI. Etching conditions: 2 V rms AC against aAu electrode [4. 14) Micropositioner
4.3.2 Preparation of Pt-Ir Tips Mechanical shearing is a common approach for fabricating Pt-Ir tips. In spite of the variation in shape, many experiments have proved that atomic resolution can be reached by using the mechanically fabricated Pt-Ir tips. Additionally, Pt-Ir tips can electrochemically be etched in several solutions: CaCI 2 /H 2 O/HCI, NaCN/NaOH, KCIIH 2 0/HCI, NaCN/KOH, and molten NaNO) /NaCI. Although resolution requirements are usually not as stringent for highly topographic samples, wide-area scans place unique restrictions on tip morphology. For such samples, symmetric, controlled-geometry tips with small radii of curvature and high aspect ratios are necessary to minimize the convolution of the tip shape into the acquired image. For example, Fig.4.15 illustrates the effect of the tip geometry on the imaged profile of grooves 0.75 f-tm wide and 1 f-tm deep. As indicated in the figure above, a tip of 50 nm in radius and a 15 0cone half angle is shown schematically to be too broad to resolve the square bottomed sample feature; while a more accurate profile of the samesize groove is given by using a tip of 50 nm in radius and 50 cone half
(a)
VIS'
---=-=-=,\ \
"n----\
I
\ I I
\
\ \
I
(b)
.----.-----
\
----.\
t~·_ , ,
I
II \
I \
I
\_'
1
1__
J
I I I
Fig. 4. 15a, b. Effect of tip geometry on the measured STM profile of grooves 0.75 f-tm wide and 1 f-tm deep using: (a) a tip with a 50 nm radius of curvature and 15 0 cone hal f angle, (b) a tip with a50 nm radius of curvature and 50 cone half angle 84
angle. From this example it is clear that a proper tip geometry is crucial to obtain the STM image that represents the sample surface. In order to fabricate specially shaped tips suitable for observing narrow and deep grooves on surfaces, Musselman and Russel [4.14] have developed a technique to fabricate Pt-Ir tips having small radii of curvate and high aspect ratios in a two-step process. In the first etching step, a 1.25 cm long piece of 0.2 mm 80:20 Pt/lr wire is etched in bulk etchant solution consisting of saturated CaCI 2 /H 2 0/HCl (60%/36%/4% by volume) against a C rod at 25 V rms AC for about 5 minutes, producing a tip comprised of a rigid structure with a long slender region just prior to the tip end. The second step involves precision micropolishing of the tip in a thin film of etchant held in a Au wire loop (Fig.4.16). With the help of a stereo-microscope and a mechanical micropositioner, the long slender region at the tip end can be thinned by moving it through the film, or sharpened by making brief contact with the film. The tip fabricated in this way can have a small radius of curvature «50nm), a high aspect ratio (8 0 cone half angle) and a smooth surface (Fig.4.17). Figure 4.19 depicts STM images of an Au-coated PMMA lithographic test pattern obtained by using a chemically etched Pt-Ir tip in the two-step process described above and a mechanically cut Pt-Ir tip, an image of which is presented in Fig. 4 .18. The grooves are 0.75 f-tm wide and 1 f-tm deep. The top view and line scan (Fig.4.19a, b) acquired by an electrochemically etched Pt-Ir tip illustrate that the widths of the groove (top and bottom) are approximately equal. In contrast, the top view and line scan (Fig.4.19c, d) acquired using a mechanically cut Pt-Ir tip demonstrate that although the cut tip can reach the groove bottom, providing an accurate measurement of groove depth, the irregular shape and broadness of the cut tip is clearly incorporated into the STM image of the test pattern, and the width at the bottom of the groove is only one third of the actual width of 0.75 f-tm. This striking comparison of STM images acquired from a highly topographic sample using Pt-Ir tips with dramatically different geometries clearly illus85
Fig. 4.17. SEM image of a Pt-Ir tip with a radius of curvature <50 nm and a cone half angle of 8 0 fabricated in the two-step process [4.14)
Fig. 4.19a-d. STM image of an Au-coated PMMA lithographic test pattern. Grooves are 0.75 p.m wide and I p.m deep. (a) Three-
the contamination following etching. With limited success, the thickness of the C layer can be reduced using an ion mill or an oxidizing oxygen acetylene flame. Unfortunatley, ion milling is a slow process requiring at least 30 minutes per tip. Even with careful calibration of the flame temperature, it is difficult to consistently oxidize the C layer without altering the tip shape via melting and recrystallization. Thus, carbon contamination must be reduced as much as possible during the electrochemical etching process. Carbon dioxide, which readily dissolves in water to form carbonic acid, has a higher vapor pressure than water and can therefore be eliminated by boiling and subsequently cooling all water used to rinse the tips and to prepare the etchant. During the micropolishing step, the contact of CO 2 in the air with the tip and with the thin film of etchant makes it necessary to polish in a glove box under N2 atmosphere. Fig. 4.18. SEM images of a mechan ically cut Pt-Ir tip.
4.3.3 Other Ways to Prepare STM Tips trates the importance of using a controlled geometry tip for the acquisition of reliable and reproducible images. An analysis of the surface chemical composition of either electrochemically etched or mechanically cut tips indicates that the tip surface is often covere.d with a carbon contamination layer which is tens of Angstroms thick. Therefore, the initial fabrication procedure should be carefully done to improve the surface chemistry either by inhibiting the formation of carbon contamination layers during electrochemical etching or by removing 86
Other methods for preparing STM tips have been reported. Reproducible sharply-pointed Mo tips can be fabricated by controlling the applied AC voltage, wave shape, phase angle, frequency, and number of waves. Ion milling and FIM techniques have been used to prepared tips from singlecrystal W. Tips capable of achieving atomic resolution on graphite include pencil lead [4.15] and colloidal graphite-coated tungsten. A gold wire is usually etched in an etchant containing 50 % HCI, 25 % high-purity ethyl alcohol and 25 % glycerin, where the gold wire acts as the anode and another 87
piece of gold wire or stainless steel as the cathode. A DC voltage of 7 V is applied to the electrodes. In the case of operating the STM in an electrochemical environment to study solid/liquid interfaces, the overall current between the tip and the sample mainly consists of Faradaic charge-transfer current. The ideal tip for electrochemical studies should have a chemically and electrochemically inert insulation except for the very end of the tip. Good insulation reduces the Faradaic leakage current and, consequently, noise. The leakage current depends on such factors as tip bias, and the nature and the pH value of the solution. The use of glass, poly(a-methylstyrene) and Apiezon wax as the insulating materials have been reported. Heben et al. [4.16] put glass on a Pt wire shaped as a tear drop of 1.5 mm inner diameter and heated it to the melted state. They then inserted the electrochemically etched Pt-Ir tip into the melted glass and obtained the glass-insulated tip by controlling the melting temperature and the inserting speed. The area of the bare metal at the very end is < I nm 2 . In the same way, the tip can also be insulated when poly(a-methylstyrene) is heated to its melting point or above (483K). They tested the insulation of the tip in 1.0 M NaCI solution and 1.0 M NaCI aqueous solution containing 0.1 M(Fe)CN~- and 0.1 M(Fe)CN~-, and found that the Faradaic leakage current was efficiently reduced. Atomically resolved images of graphite were also obtained under solutions. However, both of these materials crack easily, resulting in increased Faradaic current. In addition, glass-insulated tips cannot be employed in concentrated alkali solutions. Another promising insulating material appears to be Apiezon wax [4. I7]. The apparatus/technique for the tip insulation with this material is illustrated in Fig A .20. A 1 cm 2 copper plate (1.5mm thick), held horizontally, as shown in FigA.20, is heated by means of soldering iron to melt the Apiezon wax. A 1 mm wide rectangular slit extends from one side to the center of the copper plate, providing a temperature gradient (colder at the open end and hotter at the closed end) for the melted wax. A electrochemically etched tip is brought from underneath the slit by means of a manipulator. The tip is first moved slowly into the hot wax and allowed to attain a thermal equilibrium and uniform welting. The tip is then raised through the wax and allowed to break the top surface of the melt. If the tip breaks the surface at too hot a region, it is mostly bare. If the tip breaks at the colder region of the melt, it raises a blob of wax above it. In between these two regions exists an optimum point where the wax insulates the tip almost completely. The insulated tip is moved sideways out of the groove so as to leave the very end of the tip unperturbed. These wax-coated tips are much less fragile than glass or polystyrene-coated tips and appear to be inert in most electrolytes. 88
2
~a 4
5
~b
Fig.4.20a-c. II1ustration of the apparatus used for tip insulation. (I - soldering iron, 2 - copper plate, 3 - I mm wide sl it, 4 - STM tip, and 5 - holder for manipulator). The point where the tip penetrates the Apiezon wax along the slit determines how much of the tip gets insulated. (a) At a too cold region, the tip is completely covered with Apiezon wax. (b) Optimum point allowing only the extreme end of the tip to be exposed. (c) At a too hot region, the tip receives little insulation and is thus mostly bare [4. 18)
~c
Only 100 pA of Faradaic leakage current are detected in 0.1 M HCI0 4 with a tip bias of 0.1 V. Other types of tips have greatly enriched the probing capability of STM. In fact, novel tips can lead to substantially new research directions. For example, the wiskers of Cr0 2 provided tunneling electrons with selected spins [4.19], making it possible to retrive informations associated with spins of electrons such as spin density waves which is a very interesting topic. The breakthroughs in the research of nanotubes have provided an alternative for preparing tips for SPM [4.20]. By attaching a single nanotube to the probe apex, one can truly have a multifunctional tip with high reproducibility, which can also be used to study the electrical conductivity, flexibility of the nanotube, etc. (Fig.4.2l).
4.304 Tip Treatment Almost all experiments to date have been done with metal tips sharpened by electrochemical polishing/etching or by mechanical shearing. These tips sometimes produce atomic-resolution images with no further treatment indicating that there was at least one atomically sharp tip projecting out from the (relatively dull) end. However, most tips would not provide atomic resolution immediately. A further tip treatment can be done during actual tunneling. The effect of the in-situ tip treatment can be verified by immediate imaging. Several in-situ tip treatments were already used at the birth of STM by the inventors (G. Binnig and H. Rohrer): by gently touching the tip 89
"'8/
Fig.4.21. TEM images showing a single nanotube attached to the pyramidal tip of a silicon cantilever for scanning force microscopy [4.20]
O.2nm [001]
O.4nm [001]
[11~1O Inm I nm
[110]%10] Inm Inm
IJI1l
0.2
0.1
o
with the sample surface, the resolution was often improved. By exposing the tip to high electric fields, of the order of 10 8 V fcm, the tips are often sharpened. After the tip is formed by an in-situ treatment it is prudent to move it laterally to a new region of the sample since these methods for tip forming could modify the surface directly under the tip. The high-electric-field and high-tunneling-current techniques are supposed to either clean or sharpen the tip. Clearly, however, asymmetric or double tips are often formed, resulting in misleading sample topographs. Several groups are working with instruments to do tip characterization with Field Ion Microscopy (FIM) and STM in the same vacuum system (called FI-STM). The oriented tips (single-crystal wires) can be sharpened by annealing in the presence of a high electric field, producing a pyramid shape of certain facets. These monatomic tips are so stable that the tips can be used continuously in vacuum for several months. By taking the FIM image of the tip before and after a STM scan, the character of the STM topograph 90
(e)
Fig. 4.22. (a) FIM image of a well-defined W (100) tip before and after the STM scan. The arrow indicates the scanning direction with respect to the tip. Filled circ1~s are the first layer atoms. (b) STM topograph of Au (00 I). Rows along the close-packed [110] are separated by 1.4 nm. Scales along [110], [110] and [001] indicate I, I and 0.2 nm. respectively. (c) FIM image of a blunt W (100) tip. (d) STM topograph of the same sample scanned by the tip shown in (c) [4.21]
can be correlated to the tip structure. The dependence of the measured corrugation amplitude on the size of the tunneling tip has experimentally been examined by Kuk and Silverman [4.21]. Figure 4.22a shows a FIM picture of the tunneling tip used in the STM scan of a clean Au (00 1)-5 x 1 surface with a corrugation width of 1.44 nm (Fig.4.22b). The corrugation amplitude can be estimated theoretically by ~
oc
e-13(R
+ d)
(4.11)
where {3 "" 'A G2 fK, R is the radius of curvature of the tip (being approximately a hemisphere), d is the gap distance, K -I is the electron decay length in vacuum, and G is the smallest surface reciprocal wave vector (27f f ai' a j being the largest corrugation width). Figure 4.23 depicts the average measured corrugations of the Au (001)-5 x 1 and the Au (110)-1 x 2 reconstructions as a function of the tip size. The measured {3's for the Au (00 1) and the Au (110) are in good agreement with the values predicted by (4.11). The tip size versus measured corrugation for several other surfaces is shown. Two broken horizontal lines in Fig.4.23 indicate STM noise levels, typically due to mechanical vibration or electronic noise, for two hypothetical STMs. The significance of the tip size is now apparent from Fig.4.23. For a noise level corresponding to 0.05 nm, the tip must be terminated by a single atom in order to detect any reconstruction. On the other hand, the 91
In the constant-current scan mode, the gap separation between tip and sample is set by comparing the tunneling current with the set-point current (reference current); thereafter it is regulated by a negative feedback loop. Since the STM is a sub-Angstrom servo device, the electronic design should closely be coupled to the mechanical design. Kuk and Silverman [4.3] have performed a feedback-circuit analysis by using the following relations for the response function of each component:
0.1
E
" 0.05 ;;' .S c;;
"". ..... .....
00
t
\.. ' '\
o
u
-0
" ~ "'"
.
0.01 ,
\l,
:E 0.005
,
"
..... ,
\..
--"'l(.--.....
'\-
,
'
~MOS~\--- .~-~~~_~;Ymetals
o
G I (s)
Kp Srp + 1 '
(4.12)
Gz(s)
Ki Sri +
(4.13)
_
\Si(l I I) - (Zx 1) ',<"Si(l I I) - (7x7) Z
3
1'
Size of cluster on tip [nm]
Fig. 4.23. Dependence of measured corrugrations on the size of the tip for Au (001)- 5 X I (solid and filled circle), Au(iIO)-IX2 (broken line and triangle), Si(lII)-7X7 (_. -), Si (I I 1)-2 XI (dotted line), and most metals without reconstruction (- .. -) [4.21]
G 3 (s)
K hv
W
corrugations of the Au (00 1), Au (110), and Si (111)-7 X 7 surfaces could be detected by a 2 nm tip with the STM noise of 0.005 nm. Most metal surfaces with small reconstruction unit cells or 1 X 1 surfaces require a very sharp tip and a low STM noise level, making atomic resolution difficult to achieve without special treatment of the tip. Recently, it has been proposed that a molecular chain could be jointed to the STM tip made of a single crystal with the expectation of controlling precisely chemical and mechanical properties of the tip.
HI (s)
Basically, the electronics for an STM device consits of the following equipment: (1) A source for the x and y raster voltages, (2) high-voltage amplifiers to drive the piezoelectric elements, (3) a voltage source and current sensing amplifier to establish and sense the tunneling current between the tip and the sample, (4) an error amplifier to amplify and (usually) integrate the difference between the tunneling current and some set-point current, and (5) a display device for the images. Most of the pieces are commercially available. However, many STMs have used a computer for (1) and (5), and also for determining the bias voltage, tunneling current, controlling tip advance, even for replacing the analog feedback by a digital one. 92
n
zK T
(4.15)
+ wns/Q + wzn '
SZ
K£ Hz(s) = Sr£
(4.16)
+1
The resultant transfer function T s for the feedback system depicted in Fig. 4.24 can be expressed as
Ts 4.4 Electronics
(4.14)
Srhv + 1 '
+ GZ (s)]G 3 (s) 1 + [G I (s) + Gz (s) HI (s) Hz (s)] , [G I (s)
(4.17)
z-Piezo position
Hz
Gap distance -i
Fig. 4.24. Block diagram of the STM negative feedback-control system 93
3I
I
, Tip p05ilion ADC
I
I
A=1000
,.
-----,
Current
..I ~.M I I ADC
,.
Prop amp
'" z
~ o
~ ~
c
.~ c
'" ~
STM lip
driver Tip I vollage
or o
I
I
I
Z 3 Time [x 10- 3 5]
I Z? I
I
I
I
4
5
Fig.4.25. Transient response of lhe STM control system depicled in Fig. 4.23. The resull for lhree different loop gains are presented [4.3] Fig. 4.26. Block diagram of a compuler-conrrolled STM
where G 1 , G z , G 3 are the transfer functions of the proportional feedback (subscript p), the integral feedback (subscript i) and the high-voltage amplifier (subscript hv), respectively. HI and Hz are the transfer functions of the tunneling gap and the preamplifier (including a logarithmic amplifier if there is one), respectively. K and T stand for the gain and time constants of each system. The resonance frequency and the Q factor of the tunneling gap can be measured experimentally. Although the settling time of a feedback system can be shortened with a proportional feedback component, K p = 0 for many existing STMs. From (4.17), Kuk and Silverman calculated the transient respone of the feedback system for an STM with wn "'" 1.2' 10 4 , Q "'" 10, Te "'" 3,10- 4 , and Ti "'" 0.11. The results shown in Fig.4.24 indicate three cases with three different loop gains. The response is overdamped with a gain of 100, critically damped with 200, and underdamped with 1000. Therefore, once the gain is here set at 200, the circuit is optimized [4.22,23]. The frequency response of the feedback system can be derived from (4.17) by replacing s by !W.
A typical block diagram of a feedback circuit is presented in Fig.4.26. The tip voltage can be supplied by a battery or computer Digital-to-Analog Converter (DAC). The tunneling current can then be measured by a preamplifier with a gain of 10 6 -:- 10 9 V/ A. The preamplifier itself can either be a commercial unit or built around an operational amplifier (such as the AD529 or OPAI28). Special care must be taken in the design of the preamplifier, since the high source resistance makes the circuit particularly susceptible in electrostatic coupling. To limit interference, the current wire 94
should be kept short. A compact preamplifier can be mounted very close to the tunneling junction to minimize the capacitance. The signal output from the preamplifier can then be linearized by a logarithmic amplifier to improve the dynamic range since the tunneling current is exponentially dependent on the gap distance. However, the logarithmic amplifier is not necessary and a linear approximation of the exponential dependence can be used in the case of scanning a flat surface. The measured tunneling current is compared with the reference current, and the resultant error signal is fed into the main feedback amplifier, consisting of an analog integrator with a variable time constant and a proportional amplifier. The integrator has infinite gain at DC so there will be no net, long-term difference between the operating current and the demanded current. The feedback signal is then applied to the z-piezoelectric driver for adjusting the tunneling gap spacing. For the x-y piezos, separate high-voltage amplifiers controlled by DACs or function generators are utilized for controlling the scan area. A sample-and-hold amplifier, inserted in the circuit just ahead of the proportional and integral amplifiers, permits the measurement of the I-V characteristics and other spectroscopic data at a constant gap distance. Dur· ing the hold period, the error signal is set to zero so that the z-piezo voltage does not change, maintaining a fixed tunneling gap. The bias voltage can be varied at the same time, and the resulting current can be measured by an Analog-to-Digital Converter (ADC). Care needs to be taken to make sure that the system responds smoothly when the hold of the sample-and-hold
95
amplifier is turned off. The I-V relationship gives information about the electronic structure of the surface, as described in Chap.3. In practice, the overall gain is adjusted to be as high as possible without causing oscillation. Here again, the more rigid the microscope and the higher its resonant frequencies, the higher the gain can be set. This adjustment should be easily accessible and adjustable over a wide range since the optimum setting changes with the tip condition and an effective work function. Sometimes a small additional increase in gain and hence speed of response can be obtained by putting a low-pass filter with a cutoff frequency of above the unity-gain point but below the resonant frequency. In a typical STM using a current preamplifier with a gain of 10 MO, the proportional signal can have a gain adjustment that varies from 0.01 to 100 and a variable cutoff frequency that can be adjusted from 10 Hz to 10 kHz. In addition, since the feedback is a high-gain circuit, electrical noise and pick up can be a problem in some environments. Shielding signal and control wires is important. However, sometimes this may introduce undesirable capacitive effects. When the tip is scanned faster than the feedback can respond, the feedback-loop gain will be smaller than 1, and the signal applied to the z piezo cannot follow the topography of the surface. If the response of the preamplifier of the system is faster than the scanning speed, the measured tunneling current will reflect the surface topography. This is the constant-height scan mode that has been discussed in Chap. 1.
4.5.1 Hardware The equipment used for control, data acquisition, and image display of an STM differ from one installation to another. However, the basic hardware is similar in most cases. A basic approach to a computer-control system is exhibited in Fig.4.27. A personal computer is required for control, data acquisition and display. If STM images are directly stored on a hard disk. no special memory is required but, if they are stored in the random access memory in order to increase the data acquisition speed, a large extended memory is required. In order to optimize the performance and accuracy of all arithmetic computation for data processing, it is necessary to install a math co-processor. The Analog-to-Digital Converter (ADC) and the Digital-to-Analog Converter (DAC) cards used for data acquisition and microscope control must provide high precision and speed. The 12-bit DAC can resolve 5 mV differences in a ± 10 V range. Using a 16-bit ADC, each step is 0.305 mY. The dynamic range of inputs and outputs should be switch-selectable, for example from 0 to +10 volts, from -5 to +5 Volts, and from -10 to +10 volts. It is best to have a software-selectable ADC gain for data acquisition. If a digital feedback circuit is utilised, a special-purpose high-speed signal processor is required to ensure the fast response of the feedback loop. Basically, at least two analog inputs are required for determining the tunneling current I and the voltage V z applied to a z-piezoelectric element.
Control unit
Computer workstation ------, i
4.5 Computer Automation
I I
;1'\ ':W.;( ,,-n\VJ\4' ll.·~ n' OIl) I";·.·:'''''.....·<... ~'''"O.', 1)':<11 \)' II 'I \'IIl\V~
!~
1:
High-voltage power supplies
:1
~"
~...,:,,:.;, 'U"j':'r:.":.\"1.'.\"1 '~;.\«"-' ·u.'!/.\\~.'~' 'i'"i,' ~.'; .".:-'".::' tI :;~:,,·:.·:I:·~i
The early STM experiments were performed only with function generators for the x-y scan signals and a pen plotter to record data. The recorded images were either analyzed visually or, in a more sophisticated process, read by an optical scanner connected to a host system. However, for more precise image processing, this simple method could no longer satisfy increasing demands on the picture quality. Furthermore, the image data acquired are not in a computer-like format. Therefore, fast data handling, such as archiving, retrieving, and transfering between computers is too difficult to be realized with this system. In this section we deal with the development of computerized systems for STM control, data acquisition and real-time display and, moreover, the development of image processing techniques applicable to the restoration and analysis of STM images.
IUI!'. ,'..
x-y board
l r:.•,"':.V.-:......." l\./t.';\'J';("...~.•~"',I'J.~\\';.:.;,>:/; ;~':J~~
:>.....:"-'-',-O-;:."'+-+I------1I>-"1--tr
§
~
High-speed special- purpose digital signal processor
I
Hard drive
I
I
RAM
I
I
80386 microprocessor
z
~L.B
t.~,.
Bias
'.r,·'·.'·,.·.",·.. ,·,.',·".,"'.•'.'.'.·,····,"·,",".· ,.,.,..
!:~~ I
Base support
" .~ j .
Fig. 4.27. Block diagram of the STM control, data acquisition and display system indicating all of the equipment connections 96
97
For more efficient and precise instrumental control, the computer may need more analog inputs to measure some other parameters such as the tunneling bias Vb' the voltages V x ' V y applied to the x-, y-piezoelectric elements, and the offset voltages for selecting the scan window. In this way, data acquired are recorded automatically, and changes of each parameter can be monitored during scanning. It is important to note that connections to the ADCs have to be carefully made in order to avoid electric noise. As discussed above, the x- and y-raster voltages can be supplied by a function generator, but in many cases DACs are used instead. Therefore, at least two D/ A channels are required to generate x and y signals. Furthermore, in order to acquire the STS and work function information, other DACs for controlling the bias voltage Vb between the tip and the sample and a digital input are needed. The latter is used to trigger and turn off the feedback loop many times during the data acquisition process. Of course, offset voltages can also be controlled by DACs. In addition, if automaticapproach devices such as a louse or an Inchworm Motor are employed, it is possible for a computer to control the approach. Some kind of device is always needed to visualize the values of the zpiezoelectric voltage V z, while data are being collected. An analog x-y pIotter was traditionally employed by STM to graphically represent the modulation of Vz' These line scans separated by a fixed distance provide an illusion of three-dimensional surface topography. However, the slow motion of its pen sets a very restrictive limit on the scanning frequency and this kind of presentation provides limited image quality. To fully analyze the scanned-image data and resolve spatial information, gray-scale or top-view images should be generated. For these reasons, digital graphic display devices, such as color graphic controller cards and high-resolution graphic monitors are now widely used. Ideally, graphic display devices are expected to have the resolution of 1024 pixels and 256 levels of gray to enhance image processing.
(3) file management, and (4) some processing tools for postacquisition image processing. The following items are usually included in a parameter setting: an experimental identification name and descriptive text, the number of points per x scan (this number should be a power of two to facilitate the computation of the discrete Fourier transform), the maximum number of x scans (the actual number of scans may be smaller if the experiment ends prematurely), the size, color and position of the image to be displayed, the ranges of the DAC and ADC (if any), and the conversion factors of the digital counts to the real values of the voltages applied to the x-, y- and z-piezoelectric elements so that coordinate data can be given in Angstroms or nanometers. Default values of these parameters can be obtained from a program profile, which allows the investigators to avoid going through several menus. In addition, in order to save storage space and time, data have to be stored in binary format. However, the program should incorporate the possibility of converting STM image files from the binary format to character format. The following techniques can be utilized in the software for immediate data analysis: • Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) of each scan is performed in order to find its frequency spectrum. This information is relevant in that it permits the microscopist to see whether there is any periodicity in the data, whether there exists any periodic noise that the system is getting, or whether the signal-to-noise ratio is too small. The DFT is computed with the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) algorithm for a number of data points that is a power of 2. • Root-mean-square noise of the samples per scan is defined as I/NJE[Vz(X)-(V z)]2 ,
4.5.2 Software The computer software that performs instrumental control, data acquisition, and image display is usually written in a high-level language except for some subroutines written in an assembly language for critical tasks in order to get a fast and compact executable module. All the programs should be executed in a user-interactive way through menus. Generally, the program can be organized in four well-defined parts: (1) Setting of parameters that determine the operation of the microscope, (2) STM control, data acquisition and real-time display, 98
where Vz(x) represents the N samples of Vz collected in a scan, (V z) is the mean value of Vz' This value gives information about the reliability of the data. • Real-time display paramters are used to increase the dynamic range of the STM image displayed on the monitor. The image actually displayed in real time is [4.24] V;(x,y)
=
C[Vz(x,y) - (A+Bx)],
(4.18)
where C is a scaling factor, and the parameters A and B are obtained by a 99
least-squares fit of the values Vex, Yo) collected in a test scan. What should be taken into account is that the values v; (x, Yo) should range between a minimum (greater than 0) and a maximum (less than 255) selected by the microscopist to have a reasonably good probability that v; (x, y) does not fall out of the range of possible pixel values. • Real-time digital filtering can be performed within the program on each STM line scan. There are sources of acoustic and vibrational noise that can be filtered very efficiently by using a Finite Impulse Response (FIR) filtering relation [4.25] of the form: x(l) = ax(l) + bx(l-l)
+ cx(I-2) + dx(I-3) + ex(I-4)
,
(4.19)
where a, b, c, d and e represent the coefficients of a 5-tap FIR filter. The real-time filter windows over each data point I in the line scan range from 4 < I < N pixels per line. Software signal averaging is also utilized to improve the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) of the acquired images. • Since generally the surface normal is not parallel to the tip, the structures we are interested in are in an inclined plane. It is difficult to see details if we look at such pictures in a top-view presentation. In order to correct the microscope image that results due to this sample tilt, a plane must be fit and substracted from the image. An interactive subroutine uses a window (usually of ten previously acquired line scans) to compute a plane that can be written as Zplane
-
ax + {3y + 'Y
are difficult to visualize in the top-view image. A magnified image on the selected area produced by software zoom techniques with interpolation can help reveal detailed features on the surface. Additionally, some other tools which can be included in the software are listed below. a) Histogram Equalization
It is desirable for all surface features to be displayed within all of the available (256, for instance) gray levels. The plane subtraction algorithm described earlier can be used to approximate this condition during real-time image acquisition. During post-acquisition image analysis, the microscopist can expand the dynamic range of the image by performed histogram equalization. This requires the use for a new minimum and maximum pixel values in the range (0--:-- 255) to adjust the contrast of the image. The image pixels can then be adjusted in the following manner: All pixels < minimum are set All pixels
= 0 ;
> maximum are set = 255 ;
Remaining pixels =
(Old pixel value - minimum) x (maximum) (. ..) (4.21) maximum - mlOlmum
where maximum and minimum are the gray-scale limits specified by the user.
(4.20) b) Convolution Filter
where a, (3 and 'Yare computed coefficients. By using the computed plane, slope and offset values are computed to correct the current line scan from the sample tilt.
4.5.3 Image Processing Image processing can include algorithms for systematic data correction, such as a change of scale and a correction of the thermal drifts of the scan origin and of Vz' Two-dimentional fast Fourier transform is very useful for periodic images, and can be applied to a periodicity analysis of the image. Images can be displayed using the same color coding. However, a better matching of the dynamic range of the data to the set of colors can be achieved, in order to optimize the visual interpretation of the images, either based on the image histogram or done directly by the microscopist. Using the cross-sectional cut tool to display the height values of a topography in any direction is valuable for analyzing the detailed surface features which 100
STM images typically contain noise. Space-domain filters are available for smoothing (variable-size window averaging), sharpening (Laplacian filter), and edge detection (gradient filter using Sobel kernels). Although convolution filters do not provide an ideal frequency filter, they are often used as low-pass or high-pass filters. The following algorithm describes the 3 x 3 convolution of image pixels [4.26]:
Updated pixel valuex,y
x+l
y+l
L
L
W(i+x+2,j+y+2) Z(i,j)
i=x-l j=y-l 3 3
L L
(4.22) IWCi,j)1
i=1 j=1 where ZCi,j) are pixel values, and the W(i,j) are the window coefficients. 101
The values in the 3 x 3 matrix of window coefficients are integers, and can be set by the users to implement other filter types. The convolution algorithm requires nine multiplications, nine additions, and one division for each pixel in the image. This process is repeated for each pixel in the N x N image. The edges of the image are handled as special cases since there are no data beyond the edges with which to perform the convolution.
Fig. 4.28a,b. STM image of a Si (111)-7 X7 surface coated with Ag at low coverage. (a) Grey scale rendering of unprocessed data, (b) having been obtained from (a) by statistical differencing [4. 27J
c) Statistical Differencing Statistical differencing is a standard technique which attempts to make the corrugation uniform throughout the image by determining a local corrugation for the input data and empirically choosing a transformation. This method is suitable for boundary enhancement in cases where STM images simultaneously show two different structures. The transformation employed is
o
85 =
(D - A) a
+
A
17
+ "2 + 64
,
(4.23)
where 0 and Dare 8-bit output and input data for a given pixel, respectively. A is a local average, defined over an 8 x 8 array of surrounding pixels, and a is the variance of the data for the given pixel from the local average. The first term is designed to result in a uniform corrugation, the denominator contains an additional term to limit the enhancement in the regions where the corrugation is small. The second term preserves, but reduces, the effect of steps or average height changes. It can be eliminated to equalize the corrugation if desired. The last term simply sets the grey scale value to mid-range for a constant mid-range input image. It is important to note that the choices of the neighborhood size used in computing the local average is important, especially since the lateral extent of the features in the STM image are different for the two domains. The trial-and-error method is usually applied for choosing parameters. Figure 4.28 shows the Si (111) surface processed by means of this method by Wilson and Chiang [4.27]. d) Three-Dimensional Representation STM images can also be displayed as three-dimensional surfaces. Threedimensional perspective images offer additional clarification. especially when complex structures are present. The use of the contours, together with shading is also helpful for rendering images when image display formats have good resolution but few gray levels. The orientation of the surface can be chosen by the users, as well as the point from which the surface is illuminated and the relative proportions of direct and the isotropic diffuse light applied. Figure 4.29 exhibits a three-dimensional representation of the Si (111)-7 x7 surface. 102
Fig. 4.29. Three-dimensional representation of the Si (111)-7 X7 surface
103
50 Other Related Scanning Probe Microscopes
The successful achievement of G. Binnig, H. Rohrer and their colleagues at the IBM Zurich Laboratory initiated a surge of research and engineering activity. This brought about rapid advances in STM technology and led to the development of many other novel scanning probe microscopes, such as the Atomic Force Microscope (AFM), Lateral Force Microscope (LFM), Magnetic Force Microscope (MFM), Ballistic-Electron-Emission Microscope (BEEM), Scanning Ion-Conductance Microscope (SICM), Near-field Scanning Optical Microscope (NSOM), scanning thermal microscope, and Scanning Tunneling Potentiometry (STP). These microscopes take advantage of the remarkable ability to control the spatial position of the tip relative to the sample, and provide new information about the physical properties of surfaces on an atomic or nanometer scale. This chapter is devoted to brief descriptions of the operational principles and some applications of these new types of microscopes.
5.1 Atomic Force Microscope With regard to the operational principle of the STM described in ChapA it is important to note that the "tunneling" phenomenon utilized by STM requires that this instrument be used only for conductors or semiconductors. For a non-conducting material, its surface must be covered with a thin conducting layer. However, the existence of conducting film often lowers the resolution and thus limits the usefulness of the STM. It was chiefly this limitation that prompted the development of Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) in 1986 [5.1-3], which can be applied to image conductors and non-conductors in air, liquids or vacuum. The operational principle of AFM is explained in Fig.5.!. The cantilever which is extremely sensitive to weak forces is fixed at one end; the other end has a sharp tip which gently contacts the surface of a sample. When the sample is being scanned in x-y direction, because of the ultrasmall repulsive force existing between the tip atoms and the surface atoms of the sample, the cantilever will move up and down in the direction vertical 105
(a)
5.1.1 The Force Sensor
B 1
E
u
1.
I
I
Block (Aluminium)
(b)
A: AFM sample B: AFM diamond tip C: STM tip (Au) D: Cantilever, STM sample E: Modulating piezo F: Viton
251lm1 Diamond tip
B
y
z
·.?S
~
Lever (Au-Foil)
k
TE
Mil}
c:;
6
1
Fig. 5.1. The principle of an AFM [5.1]
to the surface of the sample, corresponding to the contours of the interaction force between the tip and surface atoms of the sample. The topographic images can be obtained either by recording the deflection of the cantilever at each point (variable deflection mode) or by keeping the force constant. using an integral feedback loop and recording the z-movement of the sample (constant-force mode). While the STM yields images related to surface electronic energies near the Fenni level, AFM images are related to surface electronic energies up to the Fenni level. The AFM tip may be kept in direct contact with the surface (contact mode) or it may be vibrated above the surface (non-contact mode). For high-resolution imaging and most routine topographic profiling, the repulsive-force (10- 9 --:- 10- 8 Newton) or contact mode is usually used. In the non-contact mode, the van der Waals force, the magnetic force, or the electrostatic force is detected. The non-contact mode has been employed in other scanning force microscopes which will be reviewed in the next section. An application of STM and AFM of particular interest is the in-situ study in electrochemistry. As discussed in Sects.4.2.4 and 4.3.3, special requirements have to be satisfied in the design of an STM for in-situ electrochemical investigations because the electrolyte is highly conducting, which makes the detection of tunneling current difficult. With the advances in AFM, especially the non-conducting AFM tip (Sect.5.1.1) and the optical-beam-deflection technique (Sect. 5.1.2), the AFM has been used successfully to study the electrode surfaces under potential control in a fluid electrolyte. One example will be given in Sect.5.1.3.
106
An AFM can be designed to look very similar to the STM. The primary difference is that it is convenient to have the sample move rather than the delicate, and sometimes bulky, force sensor (composed of tip and cantilever). Much of the technology for implementing the AFM is now well developed. Techniques for vibration isolation, scanning, sample approach, feedback control and image processing are taken with little modification from the STM. Construction of the force sensing cantilever stylus and the measurements of the deflection of the cantilever still need careful consideration. The force sensor is a crucial component for the AFM, detennining its sensitivity and resolution. While the force sensor senses the forces across a sample, the role of the cantilever is to communicate this infonnation to the outside world. When the AFM is operated in the contact mode, in order to register a measurable deflection with small forces, the cantilever must flex with a relatively low force constant. The data acquisition rate in the AFM is limited by the mechanical resonant frequency of the cantilever. To achieve an imaging bandwidth comparable to that obtainable in the STM, AFM cantilevers should have resonant frequencies > 10 kHz. Fast imaging rates are not just a matter of convenience, because the effects of thermal drift are more pronounced with slow scanning speeds. If the scanning rate is too high or the cantilever resonance is too low, the inertia of the cantilever will cause the stylus tip to exert large forces on steeply sloped protrusions, and prevent the stylus tip from tracking steep downward slopes. The combined requirements of a low spring constant and a high resonant frequency can be met by reducing the mass of the cantilever stylus assembly. High lateral stiffness in the cantilever is desirable to reduce the effects of lateral forces in the AFM. Frictional forces can cause appreciable lateral bending of the cantilever, leading to asssociated image artifacts. Investigations have indicated that choosing a "V" or "X" shape of the lever can yield substantial lateral stiffness. When optical beam deflection is used to measure cantilever deflection, the sensitivity of the detector is inversely proportional to the length of the cantilever, since greater angular bending occurs for a given linear displacement of the end of the cantilever when the length of the cantilever is reduced. Reducing the length of the cantilever is an additional motivation for microfabricating the cantilever stylus. Provision must be made for the operation of the detector used to measure the cantilever deflection. If tunneling is utilized, a metal electrode should be fabricated on the back of the cantilever. If optical methods are applied, a reflective surface is needed. For optical beam deflection, the reflective surface should also be as flat as possible. The microscopic structure of the point of the tip is important for high-reso-
107
lution contact profiling, where the contact area between the tip and sample may involve only a few atoms. For high-resolution topographic imaging, the cantilever stylus used in the AFM should satisfy the following criteria: (1) A low force constant, (2) a high resonant frequency, (3) a high mechanical Q, (4) a high lateral stiffness, (5) short lever length, (6) incorporation of a mirror or electrode for deflection sensing, and (7) a sharp protruding tip. The force sensor used in the first AFM was a gold foil of 0.8 x 0 .25 x 0.025 mm 3 carrying a diamond stylus. The gold foil served as a lever and the diamond fragment attached to one end of the gold foil as the AFM tip. The observations of a ceramic (Al z 03) surface in air demonstrated a lateral resolution of 3 om and a vertical resolution less than 0.1 nm. Thereafter, force sensors have been constructed from thin metal foils (Au, W) or formed from fine metal wires (Au, W). Carbon and fused quartz fibers have also been used as the force sensor. Atomically resolved force maps of graphite were obtained utilizing AFMs equipped with these sensors. It has been shown, however, that microfabricated cantilevers are ideal since they have both low force constants and high mechanical resonance frequencies. The microfabrication technique developed by Albrecht et al. [5.4] (indicated in Fig. 5 .2) has been employed to produce cantilevers from thermally grown SiO z and Si 3 N4 by means of Low Pressure Chemical Vapor Deposition (LPCVD). The fabrication process begins with the deposition of the desired film on both surfaces of a (100)Si wafer. The thickness of the Free cantilever
------>...--
( c) (a)
Top '-----------' VIew
/
se~~i~n~""::':B~:?~4or (lll)plane in Si Fig. 5. 2a-d. Fabrication of thin-film microcantilevers. (a) A thin film of SiOZ or Si 3 N 4 is formed on the surface of a (100) Si wafer and patterned to define the shape of the cantilever and to create open ings on the top and bottom of the wafer. (b) The windows are al igned along (III) planes. (c) Anisotropic etching of the exposed Si with KOH undercuts the cantilever and self-terminates at the (III) planes as shown. (d) A small Si chip is cut from the wafer to serve as a pedestal for mounting the cantilever in the AFM [5.4] 108
Fig.5.3. SEM micrographs of SiOz microcantilevers. (a) Rectangular cantilevers. The shorter of the two has dimensions of 100 X20 XI. 514m3, with a force constant of I N/m and a resonant frequency of 120 kHz. The V-shaped cantilever shown in (b) has increased lateral rigidity which reduces its sensitivity to frictional forces [5.4)
film determines the thickness of the finished cantilever. The film is patterned photolithographically to form openings on the top and bottom of the wafer, with the cantilever protruding into the top opening (Fig.5.2a). The geometry and registry of the top and bottom patterns are chosen so that the edges of the openings lie approximately along common (111) planes in the Si lattice. The EDP (ethylenediamine/pyrocatechol/water) Si etchant selectively etches Si rapidly in the (100) direction, but is inhibited when the region etched away is bound by (Ill) planes. EDP does not attack SiO z appreciably. The bottom side of the cantilever and the surrounding Si is then coated with a thin film of metal for the deflection detector in the AFM. The finished structure is shown in Fig.5.2d, and SEM micrographs of finished SiO z cantilevers are depicted in Fig. 5.3. For imaging atomically flat samples one can simply use the end of a cantilever to act as an effective local tip. For imaging rougher samples, however, one desires a sharp, protruding tip of known shape so that the interaction between the sample and the cantilever can be characterized more precisely. A fabrication-process produced Si 3 N4 cantilevers with an integrated pyramidal tip is presef.ued in Fig.5.4. The first step is the formation of a pyramidal pit on the surface of a (100)Si wafer (Fig.5.4a). The wafer is coated with a suitable masking material, such as a thin film of thermal SiO z , and a small circular or square opening is etched in this film. The exposed Si is etched with an anisotropic etchant. After the pit has been formed, the masking material is removed from the wafer. The Si 3 N4 film from which the cantilevers will be made is then deposited on the wafer surface and conforms to the shape of the pyramidal pit (Fig.5.4b). Annealing in an oxidation furnace follows to prepare the surface of the nitride for the later step of anodic bonding. The Si 3 N4 film is patterned into the shape of a cantilever and aligned so that the end of each lever lies over a pit. All Si 3 N4 109
,,)
181
J,m:::::s<
C
Saw cut -+--
(e)
Cr
AJlastf , /
Si Masking material (Si0 2 )
(b)
,
(d)
Saw cut -:
Glass and Cr removed
l/f /' ,/ tr -- j ----: C'::)
Si 3 N4
c=
I
i
::J '~,;/
r-100!Jrn-1
I
~.
fueC:::
1P
Fig.5.4a-e. Fabrication of Si 3 N4 microcantilevers with integrated pyramidal tips. (a) to (e) illustrate the steps in the fabrication process, see text [5.4)
is removed from the bottom surface of the wafer so that all of the Si can later be etched away. A glass plate is prepared with a saw cut and a Cr-bondinhibiting region, and is then anodically bonded to the annealed nitride surface (Fig. SAc). After the bonding is complete, a second saw cut from the top of the glass surface is made, which intersects the previous cut. This releases the bond-inhibited part of the glass plate and exposes the cantilever (Fig.5Ad). All Si is etched away, leaving the Si 3 N 4 microcantilever attached to the edge of a glass block. The back side of the cantilever is coated with metal for the deflection detector. Complete cantilevers with integrated tips formed by the above process are shown in Fig.5.5. The tips are highly symmetric and have a tip radius of less than 30 nm. These Si 3 N4 cantilevers are mechanically more robust than Si0 2 ones, and have a well defined smooth tip shape although this fabrication process is relatively complicated and time consuming. Similar fabrication processes have been developed to produce Si02 cantilevers with integrated conical tips or tetrahedral tips [5 A]. The low mass of these cantilevers allows them to have high resonant frequencies (l0 -;- 100 kHz) with force constants (typical 0.0006 -;- 2N/m) small enough to detect forces of less than 10- 8 N. Images which show atomic periodicity of several types of crystalline samples, including graphite, MoS 2 , WTe 2 , TaSe 2 , and boron nitride (BN) were obtained applying the cantilevers described above. Wolter et al. [5.5] have pursued another method for the microfabrication of silicon force sensors. This method, which mainly involves a com110
/"
3!Jrn
I
Fig. 5. 5a-d. SEM micrographs of Si 3 N4 cantilevers with integrated pyramidal tips. (a) The Si 3 N4 film is attached to the surface of a glass block with dimensions of 2 X3 XO. 7 mm 3 . Four cantilevers protrude from the edge of the block. (b) Four pyramidal tips can be seen at the end of this V-shaped cantilever. (c) The pyramidal tips are hollow when viewed from the back side. (d) Each tip has very smooth sidewalls, and the tip appears to terminate virtually at a point, with less than 30 nm radius [5.4)
bination of wet and dry etching techniques, differs substantially from the fabrication processes described above and offers the following advantages: •
•
•
The tip of the sensor is pointing out of the silicon wafer surface rather than pointing into the silicon wafer as in the thin-film tips. Thus the use of silicon tips avoids the rather complicated process of bonding the sensor to a glass body, as described above. Tip, cantilever, and holder are made out of one piece of material. This avoids any strain due to thermal mismatch of bonded parts or stress associated with deposited thin films. All parts are single crystalline which yields exceptional mechanical properties.
The sensors made by this method have been applied in various microscopes in both attractive and repulsive modes. 111
I
5.1.2 Deflection Detection
The images in the AFM are generated by laterally scanning the sample under a fine tip while simultaneously measuring the displacement of the stylus induced by the interatomic forces. Seven methods have been used for measuring the deflection of a force-sensing cantilever with subnanometer sensitivity. They consist of two electronic ones, tunneling and capacitance, and five optical ones, homodyne, heterodyne, laser-diode feedback, polarization and deflection. In the orfginal AFM design, a tunneling junction was employed to detect the motion of a diamond stylus attached to an electrically conductive cantilever beam (Fig.5.l). Two feedback circuits were used to keep the force acting on the stylus constant. This method is convenient to set up and sensitive to the displacement of the cantilever. The disadvantage of this approach is that contamination on the sensing electrode or the back of the cantilever can prevent electron tunneling or drastically alter its distance dependence. Often erratic jumps in tunneling current are observed. Figure 5.6 shows a force microscope with a capacitively controlled lever displacement. Both the mechanical construction and the electronics are simple and lead to a very compact device. Force-induced lever displacements yield capacitance changes caused by changes in the interelectrode spacing of the control capacitor. The capacitor-control piezo is driven by feedback electronics to hold the capacitance constant. Thus, the driving signal of the piezo depends on lever deflection and is proportional to the acting force.
xyz Piezo
xy Control z Control
Fig. 5.6. Capacitive lever·displacement detection [5.6] 112
0
IL""'H'N"I-[]/
J
Beam splitter
II
Sample Calcite
-0-o/~+c-~~
Linear polarized light with 50% s, 50% P
-
--l I
I
I
'l'
Faraday Isolator
s:n::g" system-
I I I
__ J
~
t:::T;=J Wollaston 1\
I
\
I
\
,
2 Photodiodes
* *; J
A-B A+B
j
---r Electronics
Fig. 5.7. AFM with an optical differential displacement sensor [5.7)
The principle of a differential interferometer (polarization) method is presented in Fig. 5.7. The reference and sensing beams correspond here to two mutually orthogonal polarization states: the linearly polarized p-state with polarization in-plane (relative to the calcite crystal) and the s-state with perpendicular polarization, employing a polarized 7 mW HeNe laser. The beam passes through a Faraday isolator in order to protect the laser against spurious back-reflections from the optical parts. At the exit of the isolator the beam is linearly polarized at 45 0 relative to the s- and p-states, thus providing equal intensity in the reference and sensing beams. After passing through a beam expander, a beam splitter and a focusing lens, the beam is divided into reference (p-state) and sensing (s-state) parts by the birefringent prism, which in this case is a calcite crystal. Both beams are back-reflected from the cantilever. The sensing beam, however, is reflected close to the tip whereas the reference beam is reflected at the side of the shaft on which the cantilever is mounted. The deflections of the force-sensing cantilever are measured by means of the phase shift of two orthogonally polarized light beams, both reflected off the cantilever. This arrangement minimizes perturbations arising from fluctuations of the optical path length and the light source since the measured quantity is normalized versus the reflected intensity. The system is less sensitive to relative vibrations between 113
Light Photodiode
~~
I
<:±>
Lens
Fig. 5.8. The schematic diagram of optical-beam deflection AFM. (Reproduced from [5. 8J with permission)
I I I
.
• Cantilever
I
I--- 0.5 nm--..J
l-o. -i 5nrn
f--Inm
-j
Fig. 5.9. AFM images of (a) HOPG, (b) MoS Z and (c) boron nitride [5.9]
the optical parts (left-hand side of Fig.5.7) and the mechanical part (righthand part of Fig.5.7) of the AFM. In the optical-beam-deflection AFM (Fig. 5 .8) a surface feature deflects the cantilever through atomic repulsion by a distance oz. This deflection causes a laser beam being reflected off the cantilever to deflect by an angle of roughly 2oz1l, where l is the length of the cantilever, usually 100-7200 lLm. This deflection of the reflected beam is seen as a change in the difference between light striking the segments of a two-segment photodiode. Because of the optical lever, the deflection of the laser beam at the photodiode is roughly 1000 times the deflection of the cantilever. The optical detection system is very stable and reliable. The optical AFM has the disadvantage, however, that the cantilever must be large enough to reflect light without introducing too much diffraction. This is not necessary in a tunneling AFM.
5.1.3 Illustrating AFM Applications As the Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) can image conductors and nonconductors, and can image samples in air, liquids or vacuum, it is finding a wide range of applications. The first published atomic-periodicity images were of layered compounds: graphite, molybdenum disulfide, boron nitride (Fig.5.9) and mica [5.9-11]. Subsequently, gold atoms in an epitaxial film on mica were resolved in images obtained both in air and in water [5.12]. The AFM has also been used successfully to image ionic crystals of LiF in air [5.13] and NaCl in ultrahigh vacuum [5.14] with atomic periodicity. Figure 5.10 shows the AFM image of the amino acid D L-Ieucine in which the white dots represent topographic peaks of methyl groups at the end of individual DL-Ieucine molecules. The positions of the methyl groups in this 114
Fig.5.1O. AFM image of DL-Ieucine molecular crystal. (Reproduced from [5.15] with perm iss ion)
115
Fig. 5.12. (a) Crystalline mica covered with an acqueous solution. The image area is 2.6 X 2 2.6 nm . Polyalanine adsorbed on glass and (b) covered with water or (c) dry. Note that the chains appear to pack closer together without water. The image area is 3.4 nm by 3.4 nm. (Reproduced from [5.8] with permission) Fig. 5. I I. AFM image of a polymerized monolayer n-(2-aminoethyl)-IO, 12-tricosadiynamide reveals parallel rows of molecules with a side-by-side spacing of about 0.5 nm. (Reproduced from [5.17] with permission)
molecular crystal agree with the positions predicted from X-ray diffraction analysis of the sample, demonstrating that the surface is a simple termination of the bulk. The ATM also succeeded in resolving individual organic molecules at nitronyl nitroxide single-crystal surfaces [5.16] Besides these atomically flat surfaces, using an AFM, it has been possible to image organic molecules on substrates. For example, the AFM images of polymerized monolayers of AE-TDA [n-(2-aminoethyl)-IO, I2-tricosadiynamide] were observed and the parallel rows in Fig. 5 .11 represent a polymerized molecule with a side-by-side spacing of about 0.5 nm. This image was obtained with a tracking force of about 10- 8 N, which was just small enough to prevent the monolayer from being disrupted. Although the monolayer could be imaged repeatedly, it was eventually damaged after tens of images were recorded. Surfaces in air are typically covered with an adsorbed layer of water and unknown contaminants. When a tip covered with a layer of liquid contaminams comes near a sample that is also covered, there is a capillary force that pulls the tip towards the sample (with a typical value of 1O- 7 N). Operating the AFM within water can eliminate this undesirable and often destructive force and allows better control of the force between the tip and the sample. 116
Figure 5.12 shows AFM images of mica and polyalanine covered with water. The nearly hexagonal array of dark spots in the image of mica (Fig. 5 .I2a) corresponds to holes in the center of hexagonal rings of atoms in the flat plane. The holes in these rings are separated by approximately 0.52 nm. Figure 5.12b depicts the image of the amino acid polymer polyalanine dissolved in 85 % chloroform-I5 % trifluoracetic acid at a concemration of 40 ILg/ml. Operation within water allows not only better control of the applied force, but also physiologically more realistic environments. Drake et al. [5.8] reported a series of ten images of the polymerization of fibrin, the basic componem of blood clots, illustrating the potential of the AFM for revealing subtle details of biological processes as they occur in real time. In this experimem, a few drops of fibrinogen solution were first placed on a mica substrate. After a few minutes of scanning, fleeting images of fibrinogen mole'cules could be seen (Fig.5.I3a). They then removed a set of peptides from the central region of the fibrinogen molecule by adding a few drops of the clotting enzyme thrombin, thereby unmasking polymerization sites, which allows the molecule to polymerize spontaneously. Then follows a series of AFM images (Fig.5.I3b-i) recording the process of the fibrin monomers polymerizing imo larger aggregates, these aggregates growing larger and connecting to each other to form chains, and finally a fibrin net (Fig.5.I3j). For other biological applications, the AFM has also been used 117
40.0
Fig.5.B. Ten AFM images show cloning of lhe human blood prolein fibrinogen in real lime. Each image area is 450 nm by 450 nm. (Reproduced from [5.8] wilh perm ission)
Fig. 5.14. The AFM image of red bloodcells
30.0
20.0
10.0
o
10.0
20.0
30.0 ~m
to image red blood cells (Fig.5.14), crystallized lipid bilayers, DNA and purple membranes. Zeolites are crystalline aluminosilicates that have a regular pore or channel structure with a periodicity on the order of atomic dimensions. These materials, with the appropriate combination of molecularly sized holes and cation exchange ability, have found a great number of uses in the chemical industry. The AFM has been engaged to image the real time interactions of molecules or cations with a zeolite surface. The geometry of the 118
crystal c1inoptilolite is shown in Fig. 5.15a and its AFM image in water in Fig. S.1Sb. Images of the crystal in different liquids revealed that molecules could be bound to the surface in different ways; neutral molecules of tertbutanol formed an ordered array (Fig.5.1Sc), which suggests that the tertbutanol is adsorbed into the 8-membered-rings with its OH group pointing down into the pore, whereas tert-butyl ammonium ions formed clusters (Fig.S.lSd). These adsorbed molecules were not rearranged by the AFM tip when used in an imaging mode. However, when a sufficiently large force (greater than 10- 8 ) is applied while simultaneously oscillating the crystal up and down at a frequency of about 5 kHz, the tip of the AFM could rearrange the tert-butyl ammonium ions on the zeolite surface. Figure 5.15e depicts a cross "X" written in this way. This demonstration of molecule manipulation suggests new applications, including biosensors and lithography. The AFM has also been used successfully to image an Au (Ill) electrode surface showing atomic periodicity while the electrode was under potential control in a fluid electrolyte [5.19]. AFM images in electrolyte taken at +0.7 V prior to Cu deposition showed large areas exhibiting Au (111) structure. By sweeping the potential the Cu can be stripped down to an underpotential-deposited monolayer and finally returned to a bare Au (111) surface. The images revealed that the underpotential-deposited monolayer has different structures in different electrolytes. Specifically, for a perchloric acid electrolyte the Cu atoms are in a close-packed lattice with a spacing of 0.29 nm. For a sulfate electrolyte they are in a more open lattice with a spacing of 0.49 nm. As the deposited Cu layer grew thicker, the Cu atoms converged to a (111 )-oriented layer with a lattice spacing of 0.26 nm 119
demonstrates that the AFM is a valuable technique in studying other electrochemical processes in situ. Although the AFM has been utilized to image some biological samples, a major challenge for researchers is to develop new sample preparation techniques that will allow smaller details to be imaged. The sample must be rigid enough not to be damaged or distorted by the applied force. As mentioned earlier, imaging with the sample in liquid eliminates meniscus forces that can pull the stylus destructively into the sample, and thus makes it possible to use smaller forces, usually in the 10- 9 N range or less. Another possibility is to apply the AFM at very low temperatures to take advantage of the rigidity inherent in frozen biological structures. Additional technological applications for the AFM include imaging integrated circuit chips, optical and X-ray components, data storage media and other critical surfaces. An AFM can also be configured so that it measures the elastic and plastic behavior and hardness via nanoindentation, surface forces, and the adhesion of thin-film and bulk materials [5.20-22].
5.2 Other Scanning-Force Microscopies 5.2.1 Lateral Force Microscope
Fig. 5.15. (a) Tetrahedral framework of clinoptilolite (010). (b) AFM image of clinoptilolite (010) in water with inserted model (c) AFM image oftert-butanol molecules adsorbed on clinoptilolite (010) with an inserted model of one tert-butanol molecules (d) Clustering of tert-butyl ammonium cations. (e) Lithography on a layer of tert-butyl ammonium cations that was adsorbed on clinoptilolite. (Reproduced from [5.18] with permissiuon)
for both electrolytes. Images were also obtained of an atomically resolved Cu monolayer in one region and an atomically resolved Au substrate in another in which a 30 0 rotation of the Cu monolayer lattice from the Au lattice is clearly visible. The observation of a complete adsorption and desorption cycle for a metal onto another metal surface with such high resolution 120
In an AFM operating in the contact mode, the interaction force is manifested as a displacement of a cantilever (with or without a tip), where the magnitude of the force is the product of the displacement and the spring constant of the cantilever. The Lateral Force Microscope (LFM) is an extension of the AFM which allows the measurement of two forces simultaneously through the bending and twisting of the cantilever in the imaging process [5.23-25]. It measures topography just like the AFM but the additional sensor is used to measure frictional forces between the sample and the tip from the same scan. It is instructive to examine briefly the nature of the cantilever response to frictional and surface forces. In the latter case, the direction of the acting force is normal to the surface of the sample, and results in a vertical bending (z-axis direction) of the free end of the anchored cantilever. By contrast, in the lateral or frictional regime, where the cantilever is in presumed contact with the surface, upon scanning, the cantilever undergoes a torsion (twist) motion about its long axis (in the x-y plane). Both motions are orthogonal to each other. This orthogonality is what enables the simultaneous, yet independent, acquisition of topographic images and frictional data. 121
To measure the cantilever displacement, the direction of a laser beam reflected off the backside of the cantilever is monitored with a PositionSensitive Detector (PSD). In the case of surface topography, the bending of the cantilever is recorded with a segmented PSD, typically a bicell, which consists of two photoactive (e.g., Si) segments (anodes) that are separated by 10 Jlm and have a common cathode. Additionally, lateral forces induce a torsion of the cantilever which, in turn. causes the reflected laser beam to undergo a change in a direction perpendicular to that due to surface corrugation. Thus, with a simple combination of two orthogonal bicells, i.e., a quadrant PSD, one is able to measure the deflection of the cantilever independently yet simultaneously in two orthogonal directions [5.23]. This capability is unique to the optical beam deflection method which. due to its very nature, measures the orientation of the cantilever and not only its displacement. It should be noted that the torsion force constant depends critically on the tip length. Additionally, the tip should be centred at the free end of the cantilver. Both factors can be readily controlled with the use of microfabricated cantilevers and tips, as described in Sect.5.1.2. Figure 5.16 shows the AFM and LFM images of Langmuir-Blodgett film 2-(4-hexadecoxypheny1)-4,4,5 ,5-tetramethyl-4 ,5-dihydro-l H-imidazolyl-l-oxy-3-oxide on the surface of a glass substrate. These two images were obtained simultaneously in the same area by our group. The particularly larger grains in the topographic image of Fig.5.l6a reveal lower frictional forces in the LFM image of Fig. 5.16b obtained in the same area. Considering other experimental results we demonstrate that the large grains in Fig.5.16a are the defects on the glass substrate rather than the LB films. The result is in agreement with the well-known fact, namely the surface of a glass substrate should show less frictional force than organic LB films. The recent fast growing advances of nanotribology has largely benefited from the lateral force microscopy or FFM. With several fundamental findings, one can better understand the atomistic friction [5.26,27] and the frictions with solid lubricants [5.28.29]. It is further demonstrated that the friction behavior is closely related to the intrinsic ordering of the molecular layer [5.30.31] (Fig.5.17).
5.2.2 Force Microscope Operating in the Noncontact Mode As mentioned previously, the force microscope can be operated in either contact mode or non-contact mode. The AFM described in the last section and the LFM mentioned above are operated in the contact mode to measure the repulsive forces between the tip and the sample. A force microscope operated with relatively large tip-sample separation can be used to measure 122
Fig. 5.16. Three-dimensional represenlalions of Ihe AFM IOpography (a) and the lateral force properlies (b) of an organic LB film oblained simultaneously in the same scan area
123
~ ~- - - ~ I Las~robe
(a) y
Lx
~T
c:
~ y~_.\--~'I: .--/---
-
I I I I I
y
Lx
'
I /
-
1'-
~
I'"m
xyz Piezo
~ I l I PhotO'detecto~ I Detec!Jon
Polarizing beam splitter / Polarisor /
~
n10
_. _ electronic~ ~
Tungsten tip + leverPiezo
_ ~ _ J
Fig. 5.18. Schematic of scanning force microscope operating in the non-contact mode [5. 33J
~'.
~
fast Hne-scan
25A
i
25A
Fig. 5. 17a, b. Images of frictional force component in X direction (fx) and Y direction (fy )' (a) The fast-I ine scan direction along the cantilever and (b) across the can til ever. Beside each image, schematic views of the lattice structure of MoS 2 (000 I) surface are shown [5. 27J
longer-range interactions between tip and sample across areas that are orders of magnitude larger than that of a single atom. Three basic forces can be mapped across a sample in the noncontact mode by detecting the deflection of the cantilever under the influence of the desired force. These consist of electrostatic, magnetic, and van der Waals forces, in the order of the complexity of the interaction. The first deals with monopoles, the second with dipoles, while the third requires a quantum mechanical treatment. These forces and their derivatives can be as small as 10- 12 Nand 10- 14 N/m, respectively, they are much smaller than those encountered with the AFM operating in the contact mode, requiring resonance enhancement techniques [5.32]. Much effort has been made to investigate magnetic force in force microscope. This kind of microscopy has developed into an independent field and is called magnetic force microscope (MFM) (Sect. 5 .2.4). The electrostatic force microscope for mapping electrostatic forces across the surface of a sample will be presented in Sect. 5 .2.5. For distances of a few Angstroms to a few humdred Angstroms. van der Waals forces are significant. They can be used to measure topography with a resolution of a few nanometers. For instance, Wickramasinghe [5.33] has developed a scanning-force microscope that works with attractive 124
1n;::
Display
._~' ~ -_ _. 1/1 '" --."""~=-~__ _ .• '_'. "*~ .1,~r"'k+1 '=ro.,.. //!' ~, _,_ .,":1''-. __ :"*I::**,J. g':'i;VI: uF"<, : '*= I
- - - l Microscope Quarter I objective . wave plate a.c. vibration I Sample I Laser I
I
faSl Ii nc-scan
(b)
-
: I IL-·--I
/ \;
F- . /\1\
~I-
-
I -
-'f\i;;-'
'" ! \,
-
rather than repulsive forces and scans the tip 3 to 29 nm away from the surface. It allows one to measure attractive forces down to 10- 11 N that are one thousand times smaller than the forces typically encountered with the contact AFM. Figure 5.18 presents a sketch of the scanning-force microscope operating in the noncontact mode. The cantilever (tungsten or silicon) tip is attached onto a vibrating transducer which drives the tip at just above its mechanical resonance frequency (typically 50kHz). The attractive-force gradients encountered by the tip as it approaches the sample surface changes the spring constant of the cantilever and hence its resonance frequency. If the vibrating transducer is driven at a fixed frequency (50kHz) this results in a change in the vibration amplitude of the cantilever. This change is detected by a sensitive laser probe and is utilized in a feedback loop to stabilize the sample to average tip spacing, as the sample is raster scanned in x and y to record an image. The image recorded in this way represents contours of constant force gradient across the sample. In this way the force microscope can detect a surface relief of as little as five nanometers, and because it senses topography from a distance, it can inspect features inside the deep. narrow clefts. It promises to be valuable for mapping rough surfaces and for noncontact examination of finished microcircuits. The noncontact force microscope has also been used to monitor the quality of the silicon surfaces on which they are built. Figure 5.19 shows a typical scan of an anisotropically etched V-groove surface of silicon (l J.Lm period and 1J.Lm deep) clearly demonstrating the ability of the LFM to reproduce both the gross features and the fine terracing structure (down to 5 nm) caused by the etching process. 125
Fig. 5. 19. Scanning force microscope image of an isolropically etched V-grooves in silicon. Enlarged area: IXIJ.Lm 2 (5.33J
0.8 _ 06 ~
~ 04
'0; :I:
0.2 0.0
,~,~~." .:t... .,...." '.. -.
~
•. ' ;r
"&.~
,
~_ .• -# • ;>" ,
.,~ll_ .~.,." .'
. . . .~t...
..
.
.~-: ....
",' l..,
.,
'..
..'
'.
~
.. '
.. ~
.
.
"4
-~""-: '\,'""'. ,~~.:.
..
. - ' .~ < ••
90
-'
,.,..
•
~_.' .~. .,,'
-'
.,. ~: • . .,.~
.,:. ~...~'
......
.;;.•._.~..~
.,;,
... t.,..
The achievement of atomic resolution of AFM in the non-contact, especially on semiconductor surfaces under UHV condition, marked a significant progress of AFM probing capability, leading to minimized interactions and making it practical to direct comparison of STM and AFM results (Fig.5.20). Having the advantage of little electric field induced effects, it can be better used to study the point defects and their motions [5.35].
5.2.3 Force Microscope Operating in the Tapping Mode Applications of the non-contact mode operations are limited due to some fundamental drawbacks inherent to the technique. The tip must be vibrated close the sample surface with low energy because van der Waals forces are relatively weak. However, moving the vibrating tip closer to the surface increases the chances of getting the tip stuck in the water layer which covers the surface of all samples exposed to the atmosphere. Trapping the tip-tosample separation, which is typically between 5 and 10 nanometers, defines 126
Fig. 5.20. The nonCOnlact AFM image of Si (111)-7 X7. In [he upper section of the image, the tip was monatomic for about the width of a cell. The unit cell C indicates all 12 adatoms . The unit cells C and E show two adatoms that are not visible in A and B Unit cell A shows an atomic defect. The right of the two central adatoms is misplaced [5.34]
the lateral resolution of a force microscope operated in the non-contact mode. Due primarily to these limitations, the non-contact force microscope has found only limited applications. To overcome the limitations of the non-contact technique. Digital Instruments has developed a new technique for operating the force microscope, the so-called tapping mode. This technique vibrates the cantilever with a larger amplitude than the non-contact mode operation. In the tapping mode, high-aspect-ratio tips with small radii of curvature are used and the vibrating tip contacts the sample surface many times per data point. The cantilever oscillation is damped when the tip contacts the water layer and the sample surface, but the larger vibration amplitude gives the cantilever sufficient energy to overcome the surface tension of the adsorbed water layer. The force imparted onto the sample by the cantilever can be very small because small shifts in the vibration amplitude can be detected. The tapping mode allows delicate samples to be imaged with normal forces on the order of fractions of a nanoNewton and shear forces that are essentially zero. The applied force is significantly lower than the force applied by the contact AFM. The lateral resolution in the tapping mode compared favorably to the contact AFM because high vibration frequencies allow the tip to Contact the sample surface many times before it translates laterally by one tip diameter. Therefore, the tip shape defines the lateral resolution in the tapping mode just as it does with the contact AFM. In practice, this mode 127
can be used to get a topographic image of any sample regardless of its conductivity or mechanical composition. Tapping mode AFM has been widely used in studying surface properties of biological material and polymers, with great successes.
5.2.4 Magnetic Force Microscope The Magnetic Force Microscope (MFM) is essentially a kind of force microscope operating in the non-contact mode except that the tungsten or silicon tip is replaced by a nickel or iron tip which is magnetized along its length. Tips coated with ferromagnetic thin films were also investigated successfully by several groups and have became commercially available recently. Magnetic thin film tips have the substantial advantage of a significantly reduced tip stray field as compared to bulk-wire tips. Another advantage is that their magnetic properties can be controlled by choosing an appropriate coating material. Thus, it is possible to measure selected components of the sample field by coating tips with high coercivity films and suitably magnetizing them in an external field. The magnetic forces measured in the MFM are purely magnetostatic; they arise from the magnetic dipoles in the tip interacting with dipoles in the sample. When the cantilever which is oscillated at its resonant frequency is brought near, a magnetic sample and the tip encounter a magnetic-force gradient, the effective spring constant and, hence, the resonance frequency is shifted. By driving the cantilever above or below the resonant frequency, the oscillation amplitude varies as the resonance shifts. An image of magnetic field gradients is obtained by recording the oscillation amplitude as the tip is scanned over the sample. Much of the reason for this excitement is the fact that MFM is the only magnetic imaging technique that can provide high resolution (l0 --:- 100 nm) with essentially no special sample preparation. This microscope enables us to look at the structure of materials such as magnetic heads that determine the definition, uniformity and strength of the magnetic disks and other media, giving insight into both head performance and quality of the storage medium. Good-quality images can be taken even when the magnetic material is covered with a thin overcoat, an important feature when imaging many technological samples. Figure 5.21 exhibits a pair of images of a magneto-optical disk taken in two passes over each scan line. On the first pass, topographical information is recorded in the tapping mode where the oscillating cantilever lightly taps the surface, as described in the last section. On the second pass, the tip is lifted to a selected separation (typically 20 --:- 200 nm) between the tip and local surface topography. By using the stored topographical data instead of 128
Fig. 5.21. A pair of images of a magneto-<Jptical disk [5.36)
the standard feedback, the separation remains constant without sensing the surface. At this height, cantilever oscillation amplitudes are sensitive to relatively weak but long-range magnetic forces without being influenced by short-range surface interactions. Two-pass measurements are taken for every scan line, producing separate topographic and magnetic field images. The topographical image on the left of Fig. 5 .21 shows grooves that delineate the recording tracks. The right image shows magnetic force gradients as sensed in the lift mode. The gradient image gives a clear picture of the bits, in which magnetization is oriented perpendicular to the sample plane in a direction opposite to the background magnetization. In this experimental disk, the power of the laser used to write these bits was varied, creating magnetic bits of different sizes. The smallest bit shown in this figure is about 90 nm across. A resolution of 10 nm has been obtained on rapidly quenched FeNdB thin films by MFM [5.37]. By using MFM we have successfully imaged domains in very "soft" magnetic materials such as the organic LB films mentioned in Sect.5.2.I. Figure 5.22 depicts a pair of images of LB film 2-(4-hexadecoxyphenyl)4,4,5, 5,-tetramethyl-4, 5-dihydro-l H-imidazolyl-l-oxy-3-oxide. The topographical image on the left obtained in the tapping mode shows a rough surface of the films. The right image reveals that the LB films form quasi-onedimensional band structures composed of magnetic domains on a large scale up to 30 x 30 J.Lm 2 . The results demonstrate that the MFM is also a promising method for detecting weak magnetic signals originating from as thin as 10 molecular layers. In the short period since the first MFM image obtained by Y. Martin and H.K. Wickramasinghe in 1987, the field has grown rapidly. MFM is al129
'. ·'. ·.. .'. .".-. . ,'. ..'.:';','\ \,t1\.t. ..~.'
:.. • : . I
..
. ','
.
.. - '
....• :: . ~
•
.
•
•
.'.'
'. .... -~ t • , ,~... .., . ....,: 1
,
•••.•.
•
'.
i
.,
.I
~'\'.'it f4
-"1
,.\ "
"
~'.
,
~l -
1'.' .
. . . .1 . , . ~
.'
i
'1
. '. '.~'.'. . .f '. . ~ t>i 1 y\ \ " .•'.:' .. ~. .' .. ~\' t ,~~, r, # . . ' ;'.;' t·. • • • • . • . ~.li ,.1q., \~ . .': '·. '" '".'.' .;:',,i 'Il i * ,-.· t-",' ... !.!Uu.V,~ \"\\''',)1 •
'..
.'
.
.
'
I
.'
•.. : :-:""(:;; o
30.0 IJrn 0
't
f l
\'
30.0 IJrn
Fig. 5 _22. AFM and MFM images of a LB film obtained in the same scan area
ready a powerful tool for magnetic imaging, with many scientific and industrial applications. Future advances in MFM will include improved tips, matching of tip-sample characteristics, and determination of field strengths and domain structure from force gradient images. Much effort has been given to improve the resolution of MFM [5.38, 39]. The ultimate goal is set to use the MFM technique to recognize species at the level of individual atoms [5.40].
5.2.5 Electrostatic Force Microscope Similarly to the MFM, the Electrostatic Force Microscope (EFM) also uses a probe vibrating at its resonance frequency. However, in the EFM, the probe has an electric charge. Its vibration amplitude is affected by the electrostatic forces resulting from electrical charges in the sample. The force sensitivity of the EFM suggests that capacitive variations down to 10- 21 F could be measured in a 1 Hz bandwidth. The EFM has been used to map the electrical properties of the sample's surface. For example, the distribution and concentration of dopant atoms in doped silicon plays a critical role in chip performance. A voltage applied across the gap between the probe of the EFM and the sample will mobilize the conduction electrons or holes beneath the probe leaving a charged region that exerts an electrostatic force on the tip. The consequent movements of the tip provide a precise, finescale measure of the charge and hence of the number of mobilized electrons or holes, and the concentration of dopant atoms. 130
Fig.5.23. Images (2.5X2.5J1.m 2 ) of polished sapphire us