Ruskin and Gender
Edited by Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman
Ruskin and Gender
W.G. Collingwood, Ruskin in his Stud...
69 downloads
3178 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Ruskin and Gender
Edited by Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman
Ruskin and Gender
W.G. Collingwood, Ruskin in his Study at Brantwood (1882) (by permission of the Ruskin Museum, Coniston)
Ruskin and Gender Edited by
Dinah Birch and
Francis O’Gorman
Selection, editorial matter and Introduction © Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman 2002 Chapter 1 © Francis O’Gorman 2002 Chapters 6 and 7 © Dinah Birch 2002 Chapters 2–5, 8–10 © Palgrave Publishers Ltd 2002 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2002 by PALGRAVE Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N. Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE is the new global academic imprint of St. Martin’s Press LLC Scholarly and Reference Division and Palgrave Publishers Ltd (formerly Macmillan Press Ltd). ISBN 0–333–96897–2 This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Ruskin and gender/edited by Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman. p. cm. Based on contributions presented at a conference held in Trinity College, Oxford University, Sept. 22, 1999. Includes bibliographical references (p.) and index. ISBN 0–333–96897–2 1. Ruskin, John, 1819–1900 – Views on sex role – Congresses. 2. Sex role – Great Britain – History – 19th century – Congresses. 3. Feminism and literature – Great Britain – History – 19th century – Congresses. 4. Masculinity in literature – Congresses. 5. Femininity in literature – Congresses. 6. Sex role in literature – Congresses. I. Birch, Dinah. II. O’Gorman, Francis. PR5267.S48 R87 2002 828⬘.809–dc21 2001058804 10 11
9 10
8 09
7 6 08 07
5 4 3 2 1 06 05 04 03 02
Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire
To Dr James S. Dearden with thanks for a lifetime’s generous contribution to Ruskin studies
This page intentionally left blank
Contents List of Illustrations
ix
Acknowledgements
x
Notes on the Contributors
xi
Textual Note
xiii
Introduction Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman
1
1 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love: Writing Ruskin’s Masculinity from W.G. Collingwood to Kate Millett Francis O’Gorman 2 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’ Catherine Robson 3 The Foxglove and the Rose: Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood Lindsay Smith
10
29
47
4 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice J.B. Bullen
64
5 The Feminist Origins of ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ Linda H. Peterson
86
6 Ruskin’s ‘Womanly Mind’ (1988) Dinah Birch
107
7 ‘What Teachers Do You Give Your Girls?’ Ruskin and Women’s Education Dinah Birch
121
8 ‘Any Day That You’re a Good Boy’: Ruskin’s Patronage, Rossetti’s Expectations Joseph Bristow
137
vii
viii Contents
9
10
Pantomime Truth and Gender Performance: John Ruskin on Theatre Sharon Aronofsky Weltman Images of Proustian Inversion from Ruskin Emily Eells
159 177
Selected Bibliography
201
Index
206
List of Illustrations W.G. Collingwood, Ruskin in his Study at Brantwood (1882) (by permission of the Ruskin Museum, Coniston)
ii
James Northcote, Ruskin, aet 31/2 (1822) (by permission of the National Gallery)
30
Athena, photogravure from a statue at Herculaneum (Library Edition, 19, plate 14)
181
Giotto, Charity, photogravure from the fresco in the Chapel of the Arena, Padua (Library Edition, 27, plate 3)
184
Abraham Parting from the Angels (from Ruskin’s drawing of the fresco by Benozzo Gozzoli) (Library Edition, 4, plate 10)
186
ix
Acknowledgements We thank the delegates of our co-organized Ruskin and Gender conference on 22 September 1999 in Trinity College, Oxford for their contributions to the debate. We are grateful to the following institutions for their financial support for this conference, which was the origin of some of the chapters collected here: Cheltenham and Gloucester College of Higher Education, the English Faculty of the University of Oxford, and Trinity College, Oxford. Additional thanks are due to Professor Robert Hewison, Professor Michael Wheeler, and Professor John Carey. Dinah Birch thanks Sid, Rowena, and Joe for their generosity and patience. Francis O’Gorman thanks Jane for her support and lively interest in the book. Thanks to Oxford University Press for permission to reprint Dinah Birch’s ‘Ruskin’s “Womanly Mind”’ from Essays in Criticism, 38 (1988), pp. 308–24; to the Ruskin Museum at Coniston for permission to reproduce W.G. Collingwood’s Ruskin in his Study at Brantwood (1882); Princeton University Press for permission to publish a version of ‘The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s “Lost Jewels”’ from Catherine Robson’s Men in Wonderland: The Lost Girlhood of the Victorian Gentleman (2001), and the National Portrait Gallery for permission to reproduce James Northcote’s John Ruskin, aet 31/2 (1822). DINAH BIRCH
Trinity College, Oxford School of English, University of Leeds
FRANCIS O’GORMAN
x
Notes on the Contributors Dinah Birch is Stirling Boyd Fellow and Tutor in English Literature at Trinity College, Oxford, and a University Lecturer in English. She has recently edited a selection from Ruskin’s Fors Clavigera (2000), and Ruskin and the Dawn of the Modern (1999). Joseph Bristow is Professor of English at the University of California, Los Angeles, where he edits (with Thomas Wortham) Nineteenth-Century Literature. His recent publications include two edited volumes: The Cambridge Companion to Victorian Poetry (2000) and Wilde Writings: Contextual Conditions (2002). J.B. Bullen is Professor of English at the University of Reading; he has written widely on Ruskin, who plays a significant role in his current study of the history of the Byzantine Revival in Europe and America. Emily Eells is maître de conférences in the English Department of the University of Paris X–Nanterre. Her research on Proust and the Victorians is the subject of her forthcoming book entitled Proust’s Cup of Tea: Homoeroticism and Victorian Culture. Her numerous articles include ‘Ruskin, Proust et l’homotextualité’ (Etudes anglaises, 1999) which presents and analyses Proust’s manuscript pastiche of Ruskin’s style. Francis O’Gorman is Lecturer in Victorian Literature in the School of English in the University of Leeds. He has written widely on Ruskin, including John Ruskin (1999) and Late Ruskin: New Contexts (2001). Linda H. Peterson is Professor of English at Yale University. She first published on Ruskin in Victorian Autobiography: The Tradition of Self Interpretation (1986) and recently has written Traditions of Women’s Autobiography: The Poetics and Politics of Life Writing (1999). Her current project focuses on women’s entry into the profession of letters. Catherine Robson is Associate Professor of English at the University of California, Davis. Her areas of interest include nineteenth-century British literature and cultural studies. Her book, Men in Wonderland: The Lost Girlhood of the Victorian Gentleman, was published in 2001.
xi
xii Notes on the Contributors
Lindsay Smith is Professor of English at the University of Sussex. She works on the intersections between nineteenth-century literature and visual culture, particularly painting and photography. She is the author of Victorian Photography, Painting and Poetry: The Enigma of Visibility in Ruskin, Morris and the Pre-Raphaelites (1995), The Politics of Focus: Women, Children and Nineteenth Century Photography (1998), and essays on Victorian culture. She is currently working on Lewis Carroll as a photographer. Sharon Aronofsky Weltman is Associate Professor of English at Louisiana State University, and has written extensively on Ruskin and gender, including Ruskin’s Mythic Queen: Gender Subversion in Victorian Culture (1998). She has also published on Christina Rossetti, Robert Frost, and Jane Ellen Harrison. Currently she is working on two book projects: first, a new book on Ruskin; second, Victorians on Broadway, a study of the cultural work accomplished by late twentieth-century musical adaptations of Victorian materials.
Textual Note All references to Ruskin’s works, unless stated otherwise, are to The Library Edition of the Works of John Ruskin, ed. E.T. Cook and Alexander Wedderburn, 39 vols (London: Allen, 1903–12), and are given in the main text as volume: page number.
xiii
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman
Ruskin’s identity is always multiple, and so is his gender position. Accounts that do not hear the plurality of his voices, both public and private, miss a crucial dimension. Matters ‘of any consequence’, Ruskin told his audience in his Cambridge Inaugural Address in 1858, ‘are three-sided, or four-sided, or polygonal’ (16.187). The words are peculiarly apt for the subject of this book, which considers afresh aspects of Ruskin’s complex contribution to gender debate. It is only in recent years that ‘Ruskin and gender’ has become a serious subject. Previously – and especially for those readers influenced by Kate Millett’s Sexual Politics (1970) – critics interested in Ruskin were unlikely to be interested in gender, and vice versa. But the last fifteen years have seen important changes. Ruskin’s complicated relationship with Victorian gender politics is now being recognized and explored. Assessments of his interventions that stop at a hasty reading of ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ (1864) are becoming fewer. Ruskin’s polygonal literary persona meant that he was heard and read differently by diverse audiences. He was also peculiarly performative. Sharon Aronofsky Weltman considers a dimension of his response to the theatre. Yet Ruskin was theatrical himself in the strategically various crafting of his persona. Because he was sharply aware of audiences and contexts, and because he enacted different parts of his identity, his work quickly breaks beyond the limits of arguments that try to confine him to single positions. Ruskin had many faces, metaphorically. In portraits, he had many faces, literally. Here, in the visual, is a glimpse of the plurality of his gendered persona. Francis O’Gorman discusses W.G. Collingwood’s masculinization of Ruskin in portraiture. But, prior to Collingwood, there was a substantial body of visual representations that suggested Ruskin’s 1
2
Introduction
femininity or emphasized his composite gender characteristics. The first of Ruskin’s own verbal self-portraits in his autobiography, Praeterita (1885–89), revealingly feminized his childhood. Speaking of the 1822 portrait by James Northcote (p. 30) of Ruskin aged 31/2, Ruskin said that it ‘represents a very pretty child with yellow hair, dressed in a white frock like a girl, with a broad light-blue sash and blue shoes to match’ (35.21). Lindsay Smith and Catherine Robson both consider how this picture connects with Ruskin’s meditations on girlhood in Praeterita. Certainly, the visual association between Ruskin and the feminine, to which Praeterita drew such explicit attention, described other visual and textual representations across his career that imagined him in nonnormative gender terms. John Everett Millais’s sketches, made between 1853 and 1854, emphasized a sensitive and feminized figure, as did George Richmond’s in 1857.1 The caricaturist of Fun in March 1876 saw another side to Ruskin’s apparent femininity. He depicted Ruskin as ‘Saint Rusty’, a high-church priest, affected and snooty, and daintily avoiding looking at the black mass of industrial Sheffield behind him. Ruskin, the caption said, was the exemplum of ‘superfine, often superficial, criticism’.2 The caricature expressed anxieties about the effeteness imagined to be a consequence of Paterian Aestheticism, straightforwardly linking Ruskin to a movement with which his relations were, in reality, complicated.3 It also caught the widespread concern about his religious sympathies in the 1870s, figuring them in culturally commonplace terms of gender dissonance. Ruskin’s pro-Catholic sentiments in the 1870s – he declared in Fors Clavigera (May 1874) that ‘the worship of the Madonna has been one of [Catholicism’s] noblest and most vital graces, and has never been otherwise than productive of true holiness of life and purity of character’ (28.82) – prompted concern among his Protestant readers and friends. For severer critics of his new sympathies, the language of effeminacy was a ready-made weapon. Charles Kingsley’s view in 1851 that ‘there is an element of foppery—even in dress and manner; a fastidious, maundering, die-away effeminacy’4 among Romanists and Tractarians still had pertinence in the 1870s, and it was this unsympathetic gendering that shaped Fun’s visual satire of Ruskin’s effete priestliness. Another anonymous caricaturist played with a more ambiguous gender representation in 1874. This Oxford artist, satirizing Ruskin’s Hinksey Road project and his rhetoric of land reform in the Inaugural lectures at Oxford (1870), offered an image of a spade and pick-bearing Ruskin in labourer’s boots as one of the ‘Great Guns of Oxford’. But the link between Ruskin and normatively masculinist manual work was
Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman 3
blurred by the caption that named him the ‘President of the Amateur Landscape Gardening Society’.5 The caricature poked fun at Ruskin’s road building, and queried his association with straightforwardly strenuous male labour. In his own life, Ruskin maintained a distance from dominant modes of normative masculinity. ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ celebrated a domestic life that was hardly Ruskin’s. Its account of wifeliness was no account of Ruskin’s own experience, as most readers must silently have recognized. The annulment of Ruskin’s marriage on the grounds of nonconsummation had separated him from a familiar ideal of heterosexual manliness; childless, it also deprived him of the securely masculinist position of pater familias and left him vulnerable to accusations of sexlessness. Francis O’Gorman considers the efforts of early biographers to counter suggestions of diminished manliness caused by the marriage’s failure. But even while married, there were elements of unconventionality in Ruskin’s gender position. Especially during the Venetian visits of 1849–50 and 1851–2, he kept out of Effie’s company. He rarely appeared as part of a couple in public. He did not identify normative maleness with heterosexual union. Effie, it might be added, was, if anything, more unorthodox. Independently of her husband, she kept male company, and refused to allow Ruskin’s aloofness to interfere with her visits and socializing. She flirted. She was actively her own woman in Venice. But Ruskin’s gender unorthodoxy extended far beyond his marriage. It is evident in the formulation of his literary authority. Ruskin’s performativity, his capacity to adopt new voices, included his use of female subject positions. As Dinah Birch has pointed out, he defined a woman’s business as praise (18.122) in Sesame and Lilies (1865).6 Yet his whole career as an art critic, in which, he said, he ‘praise[d] without scruple’ (29.586), fulfilled this womanly task. He implied his own calling was distinctively female. More locally, Ruskin used a culturally-determined woman’s place to enable aspects of his literary persona. The Saturday Review complained bitterly of Unto this Last (1860), saying that the world was not going to be ‘preached to death by a mad governess’.7 Ironically, five years later, Ruskin literally adopted a governess’s role, or at least that of a teacher in a girls’ school, to write The Ethics of the Dust (published in 1865 with 1866 on the title page). This text, which has recently begun to attract critical attention, was a series of lectures on the moral lessons of crystallography, partly based on Ruskin’s experience of real teaching at Margaret Bell’s innovative Winnington Hall School in Cheshire.8 In the 1870s, Ruskin continued to explore the possibilities of fresh forms of authority. In the three science textbooks, Love’s Meinie
4
Introduction
(1873–81), Deucalion (1875–83), and Proserpina (1875–86), this included the further appropriation of female subject positions to critique the exclusively male authority of modern empirical science. In Deucalion, for example, which was an attempt to produce an ‘absolutely trustworthy foundation for […] geological teaching’ (26.197), Ruskin challenged one of the most prominent figures in the Victorian scientific establishment, John Tyndall, Professor at the Royal Institution, geologist, physicist, and agnostic. Tyndall’s theories of glacial movement irritated Ruskin, and his apparently materialist explanations of natural phenomena appalled him. Ruskin thought the soulless conclusions Tyndall championed had ‘thrown foolish persons into atheism’ (28.541). Deucalion contested the professional natural philosopher’s glacial science, partly through conventional factual argument, and partly through female role-playing. Ruskin said that he had borrowed Lady Mount-Temple’s kitchen, and, with the help of her ‘infinitely conceding, and patiently collaborating cook’ (26.232), used kitchen implements, blancmange, flour, hot water, sugar lumps, and ice cream to test Tyndall’s supposedly scientific conceptions of glacial movement. Ruskin demonstrated more in this way, he said, than in a ‘year’s worth’ of orthodox empirical investigations (26.177). He criticized modern geology from a woman’s space, acting out a woman’s role, revealing that modern science had missed truths visible in ordinary domestic kitchens. The female subject position did not diminish the authority of the provocatively alternative science: adding another layer to Deucalion’s dissonance, it enhanced it. Ruskin’s literary voice, especially in his later work, was not a solidly masculinist one. In turn, Ruskin, in the second half of his career, was restless about many conventional masculine roles available in nineteenth-century society. In Unto this Last, he urged the competitive capitalist to understand the concepts of service and duty, suggesting an eighteenth-century model of gentlemanly commerce was more admirable than the individualist values of modern political economy. In his Inaugural lectures at Oxford, he bid the aspiring colonialist remember that it was chiefly England that needed to be colonized and made fruitful. While Slade Professor, he disliked the cult of athleticism as previously he had criticized the competitive spirit of the Alpine club in Sesame and Lilies. At Oxford, he used the Hinksey road-building project to divert the muscles of his undergraduates from sport to useful work of benefit to the local community. He was impatient with men who consumed their time rowing on the river, just as he thought little of the conventional upper-class male pastimes of shooting and foxhunting.
Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman 5
Ruskin did not find that many of his culture’s gender roles suited him. He remained in this respect, as in so many ways, on the margin. Ruskin’s physical appearance – his old-fashioned frock coat and blue stock – was always noticed in his later years, by those who met him, as different from that of most men. Such difference was the least important, if the most visible, part of Ruskin’s tendency not to conform, and non-conformity defined his gender position. *** Some of those who were most deeply influenced by Ruskin’s thinking were persistently uneasy about the complexities of his gender identity. Francis O’Gorman’s essay considers the long tradition of biographical interpretations of Ruskin, and traces the legacies of attempts to place him more securely in the cultural boundaries of masculinity. He shows how W. G. Collingwood, the earliest and one of the most significant of Ruskin’s biographers, placed his representations of Ruskin as a Carlylean hero in a tradition of vigorous male public writing, and began the process of repositioning Ruskin in relation to constructions of manliness. Much of this subsequent activity was related to assessments of the failed marriage. Those wishing to defend Ruskin’s reputation from the gossip and speculation that lingered around the annulment often did so by attempting to affirm assertive masculinity. As O’Gorman explains, it was a strategy that turned out to have unforeseen consequences. The rise of feminism in post-war Anglo-American culture meant that Ruskin, if seen as the unqualified voice of Victorian patriarchy, made a tempting target. Kate Millett’s powerful and hostile reading of Ruskin’s lecture ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ in Sexual Politics became for many readers in the academy a central statement of his significance, in terms both of Victorian gender politics, and in the broader sense of his place in twentiethcentury thought. O’Gorman argues for a more clearly focussed overview of the ideologically weighted battles that have been fought over Ruskin’s relations with models of gender, as a means of moving towards a more fully realized understanding of the multiplicity of his work. Catherine Robson’s essay on the concept of the feminized child as it relates to Ruskin’s sense of his own identity investigates one of the areas where these complexities find their subtlest forms. The representations of ideal girlhood in Praeterita, where the death of young girls suggests the closure of his own development, attempts to unite the old man and the young girl into a single image of the lost self. What emerges is a crystallized and prefect figure of femininity, frozen and unreachable,
6
Introduction
alive only in the past. In this way, the memory of Rose La Touche, who died in 1875, becomes the focus of an imaginative pattern that was central to Ruskin’s work. Ruskin’s thinking about his own history, especially as it was expressed in his autobiography Praeterita, is further explored in Lindsay Smith’s essay on ‘The Foxglove and the Rose: Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood’. This considers Ruskin’s images of female children in Praeterita in relation to his wish to ‘botanize’, or ‘to see into the life of things’. Smith argues that Ruskin’s longstanding interest in flowering plants, developed most fully in Proserpina, is inextricably bound up with his experience of a feminized childhood. The perspective of the child, and of the female child particularly, allows for a creative spontaneity lost in adulthood. Ruskin is to some extent inclined to identify himself with this gendered perception of childhood, but the repeated and painfully remembered deaths of girl children in Praeterita, losses which prefigure the later defining loss of Rose La Touche, also suggest an imaginative pattern that assimilates his understanding of memory and mortality into a strangely botanical construction of girlhood. J. B. Bullen expands his consideration of Ruskin and gender to include a comparison with the French poet, novelist and critic Théophile Gautier (1811–72). Both Ruskin and Gautier were in Venice, with female companions, in 1850. Bullen argues that the city, whose image was traditionally feminized and eroticized, played an important part in the sexual identity of both men. Gautier’s life in Venice was one of passionate carnality. But Ruskin, haunted by the sense of elegy that had defined his responses to Venice since his adolescent and Byronic early love for Adèle Domecq, saw Venice in the light of his failing relationship with his wife Effie. Bullen suggests that Ruskin’s writing about Venice was shaped by his anxieties about his marriage, and his readings of Venetian history, with is emphasis on the fall from Gothic virtue to Renaissance vice, and then to eighteenth-century debauchery and corruption, was conditioned by his disquiet about femininity in general, and his marriage to Effie in particular. Despite these anxieties, Ruskin was by no means oblivious to what women were contributing to contemporary intellectual life. Linda Peterson’s essay on ‘The Feminist Sources of “Of Queens’ Gardens”’ argues that the ideas of Ruskin’s lecture, so often cited as antagonistic to progressive ideas about women’s employment and education, were in fact influenced by leaders of the women’s movement in the 1850s and early 1860s – notably Anna Jameson, a prominent figure in a group that included Barbara Leigh Smith, Bessie Rayner Parkes, Adelaide Procter,
Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman 7
and Anna Mary Howitt. These women frequently read and discussed Ruskin’s work, and Ruskin knew many of them both professionally and personally. Peterson shows that the influence of Anna Jameson, whom he had met in Venice in 1845, was particularly important, and can be traced throughout ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’. His thinking about the need for a serious moral education for girls runs parallel to work that other members of the circle published in the 1850s – Bessie Parkes’s ‘Remarks on the Education of Girls’, for instance, which prefigured Ruskin’s wish for a more liberal education for girls, including elements of physical training and unrestrained reading. Peterson demonstrates that progressive Victorian women did not see Ruskin’s position as opposed to their own. We should revise the traditional view of his work being antagonistic to the liberal views of Mill, she argues, replacing the concept of ‘Mill versus Ruskin’ with that of ‘Mill and Ruskin, with Mill as the champion of women’s legal rights and Ruskin, of educational reform’ (p. 102). The idea that Ruskin’s relations with the ideals of femininity, and with the real women whom he knew, were both more complex and more positive than has always been recognized continues to be an important theme in the essays contributed by Dinah Birch. In ‘Ruskin’s “Womanly Mind”’, first published in Essays in Criticism in 1988, she argues that, in addressing the social roles of women in ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’, and their shortcomings, Ruskin is thinking of himself. What he identifies as the proper cultural functions of women – praise, reverence, social responsibility – are also what he perceives as his own duties as a critic. In castigating the weakness of women in failing to move unflinchingly into the world in order to take on the social abuses of the age, he is voicing his own sense of guilt, and nerving himself to confront the difficulties inherent in the public work of social criticism, which was absorbing his time and energy in the early 1860s. Ruskin’s interest in the pre-Christian female divinities of Egypt and Greece – Neith and Athena – was at its most intense at this stage of his career, and helped him to find models for thinking about the authority of femininity in different ways. His friendship with many intelligent and active women, and his collaborative work with a number of them, belies any suggestion that he did not take them seriously. More to the point is the fact that his feminized critical voice made it that much harder for many of his contemporary readers to take him completely seriously. Like Linda Peterson, Dinah Birch focuses on Ruskin’s work for women’s education as being central to his cultural interests. This is the subject of her second essay, ‘“What Teachers Do You Give Your Girls?” Ruskin and Women’s Education’, which examines the nature and extent
8
Introduction
of his contribution to the development of women’s education in the period. His support for the progressive Winnington Hall, and his friendship with its energetic headmistress, Margaret Bell, emerges as a pivotal feature of his life and work in the late 1850s and early 1860s. His knowledge of the school had long-lasting consequences for his writing, not least in the publication of The Ethics of the Dust, a book which reflects the experience of teaching the schoolgirls of Winnington in ways which look forward to the development of new critical strategies in the later 1860s and beyond. His interest in institutions founded to further women’s education was given new impetus with his election as Oxford’s first Slade Professor of Fine Art in 1869. Ruskin performs differing and sometimes troubled gender roles in his life as an art critic, and these are demonstrated in his complex relations with Dante Gabriel Rossetti. Joseph Bristow suggests that differences in cultural influence and financial resources were eventually to come between the two men, wrecking their hopes of building a fraternal homosocial intimacy on their shared interest in new forms of art. The concept of an aesthetic ‘brotherhood’, of the kind that had motivated the heady days in which the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood had been formed, could not contain the deep-seated differences that divided Rossetti’s restless mind from Ruskin’s wish to exercise a directive patronage. Sharon Aronofsky Weltman’s essay, ‘Pantomime Truth and Gender Performance: John Ruskin and Theatre’ shows how an interest in dramatic performances of many different kinds, from pantomime to tragedy, runs through his work. It provides a productive means of approaching his gender identity. Theatre offers what Judith Butler has called ‘morphological possibilities’ for the performance of gender. Ruskin was deeply drawn to the imaginative freedoms suggested by these possibilities, while he was also often repelled by the threat they could represent to the clarity of gender distinctions that he wanted to maintain. His response to troubling dreams, often related to stage performances that he had witnessed, demonstrate an urgent reaction to gender ambivalences that he found both liberating and disturbing. Emily Eells’s essay on ‘Images of Proustian Inversion from Ruskin’ considers the importance of the multiplicity and ambivalence of Ruskin’s images of gender in the formation of the literary identity of one of the most central voices in early twentieth-century fiction – Marcel Proust (1871–1922). Proust’s knowledge and admiration of Ruskin’s work was profound, and it helped to shape his lifelong exploration of creativity and memory. Proust was responsible for the translation of Sesame and Lilies and The Bible of Amiens (1880–85) into French.
Dinah Birch and Francis O’Gorman 9
Eells suggests that, in A la recherche du temps perdu, he persistently associates Ruskin’s work with homosexuality. His homosexuals are often androgynous figures, and his distinctive reading of Ruskin’s criticism, especially his work on the early Italian Renaissance, enables him to find precedent and authority for the construction of complex redefinitions of gender boundaries in his own fiction. The multiplicity of Ruskin’s gender identity was what made Proust’s subtle interpretations of his legacy possible. Proust’s work is a reminder of what generations of readers and critics have affirmed and reaffirmed: that the richness of Ruskin’s thought is inseparable from the fruitful challenges it offers to conventional definitions of gender.
Notes 1 See James S. Dearden, John Ruskin: A Life in Pictures (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1999), pp. 50–1, pl. 11. 2 Dearden, p. 102. 3 For a recent analysis of this relationship, see Nicholas Shrimpton, ‘Ruskin and the Aesthetes’, in Ruskin and the Dawn of the Modern, ed. Dinah Birch (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999), pp. 131–51. 4 Charles Kingsley: His Letters and Memories of His Life, ed. Frances Kingsley, 2 vols (London: Kegan Paul, 1881), I.201. David Hilliard considered the dissident gender implications of Anglo-Catholicism in ‘Unenglish and Unmanly: Anglo-Catholicism and Homosexuality’, Victorian Studies, 25 (1981–2), [181]–210. Lori M. Miller revised some of Millard’s ideas in ‘The (Re)Gendering of High Anglicanism’, in Masculinity and Spirituality in Victorian Culture, ed. Andrew Bradstock, Sean Gill, Anne Hogan and Sue Morgan (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 2000), pp. 27–43. 5 Dearden, John Ruskin, p. 96. The unidentified caricaturist worked under the name ‘INO’. 6 See pp. 110–11 below. 7 Quoted in 17. xxviii. 8 The Winnington context is further discussed in Dinah Birch, ‘The Ethics of the Dust: Ruskin’s Authorities’, Prose Studies, 12 (1989), 147–58. A fresh contextual dimension is suggested in Francis O’Gorman, ‘“To see the finger of God in the dimensions of the Pyramid”: A New Context for Ruskin’s The Ethics of the Dust (1866)’ forthcoming in Modern Language Review. Both these essays consider different ways in which The Ethics tested ideas and practices of writing that Ruskin fully developed in the 1870s.
1 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love: Writing Ruskin’s Masculinity from W.G. Collingwood to Kate Millett Francis O’Gorman
W.G. Collingwood’s portrait of Ruskin in his Study at Brantwood (1882, p. ii) is at once a thoroughly detailed painting of Ruskin’s writing room, a study in greens and browns, and a painterly construction of Victorian literary manliness. The setting is, as Collingwood noted, some time before breakfast, but Ruskin sits already well into the morning’s labour, the signs of his literary energy lying in the wastepaper basket behind him, and carefully arranged on the floor beside it. On the left, the second drawer of the chest is open, containing business papers – this is where Ruskin filed them – of the Guild of St George.1 Ruskin’s writing on this early winter morning concerned his public work with social reform. Although he sits solitarily, with a favourite tortoise-shell and white cat for his only audience, he is engaged, through the Guild, with the wider world. The globe in the corner hints the furthest extent of his grasp. Ruskin, whose white-bearded presence is repeated by the whitecapped Old Man of Coniston visible through the window, is a figure of rocky strength. His sitting position is almost a running one. He is not lost in dreamy thought, nor racked by the pains of authorship, but writing firmly and confidently on matters of national policy. ‘I’m working vigorously,’2 Collingwood told his fiancée as he painted the picture on 17 February 1882, and he was portraying Ruskin in the same way. Collingwood, who served as an assistant at Brantwood 1881–2, offered a visual image of the Professor as a spirited, Carlylean figure, a hero-as-man-of-letters, energetic and confident, intervening in the social and spiritual organization of the nation. His image employed distinctly masculinized codes. Yet it is almost certain that Ruskin never sat 10
Francis O’Gorman 11
for this portrait. The end of 1881 and beginning of 1882 had seen Ruskin severely depressed: in February 1882 he went to Herne Hill and was away from Brantwood until 4 January 1883. In the meantime, Collingwood had planned the portrait as a surprise. Undaunted by the absence of his subject, he used Laurence Hilliard, who had become Ruskin’s secretary at Brantwood at the end of the 1870s, as a model. ‘Hilliard[,] who is such an actor,’ he told his fiancée in February, ‘is going to sit for the Professor – and I’ll do the face out of my head – I think I can.’3 The vigorous man at the study desk was almost certainly a stand-in, and Collingwood’s codes of masculinity gathered around a figure of heroic literary labour that was not Ruskin. W.G. Collingwood is the villain of this chapter. His picture lingers over my argument as a visual allegory of what happened to the matter of Ruskin and gender in print, from Collingwood’s extensive writing on Ruskin and onwards, through to the women’s movement of the 1960s. He is responsible for commencing a process of aggressive masculinization of Ruskin, spurred partly by his own difficult ideas of masculinity, which has worked both directly and indirectly against a full understanding of Ruskin’s gender position, sometimes disastrously. Collingwood’s legacy and its various consequences are still with us, and still in need of revision. My focus throughout this essay is the subject of Ruskin’s marriage to Effie Gray, which suggested to Collingwood and other early writers, in the most forceful way, his distance as an individual from orthodox models of manliness.4 My chapter starts by surveying Collingwood’s rhetoric for the representation of Ruskin’s gender position, considering its relation to the assumptions about manliness evident in Collingwood’s fiction. An account of the speculation about Ruskin’s marriage from the 1920s to the 1940s – well after the decline of Ruskin’s public reputation as a thinker – follows and I propose this ultimately produced a new debate that revived Collingwood’s masculinizing terms as a form of defensive rhetoric. Cumulatively, this protective language left a troublesome heritage for later readers of Ruskin. It formed the context in which Kate Millett read Ruskin in the 1960s and assisted in urging her feminist critique of a small sample of his work taken as representative both of his attitudes about gender roles generally and of ‘patriarchal’ Victorian culture altogether. Millett’s analysis of Ruskin, while important in itself, added to the problematic legacy for readers of the present and continues to influence contemporary efforts to decode the subject of Ruskin and gender. Collingwood’s response to Ruskin and gender proved a factor, via a Darwinian set of links, in building the context that eventually gave energy to feminist outrage in the 1970s
12 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love
over what was taken to be the sum of Ruskin’s gender politics. What is needed now is an effort to banish this difficult discourse, with Collingwood at its point of origin, and begin to think of Ruskin’s complex position as man and writer in relation to models of masculinity afresh. *** Ruskin’s gender position, as early critics and biographers implicitly recognized, chafed against acceptable and conventional models of manliness in a number of ways. As an art critic, and later a Professor of Art, he championed a subject that was by no means clearly defined as masculine.5 His intensely affective and richly autobiographical prose, placing in the foreground a subjectivity that constructed arguments from intuition and feeling, not from unimpassioned reason, struck many early biographers as more female than male, and Ruskin was often described in early accounts as a gender composite. J. Marshall Mather, in his popular Life and Teaching of John Ruskin (1884), was not alone when he presented his subject as an amalgam of knightliness and Nightingale: ‘In him’, Mather said, ‘is the spirit of chivalry: fearless when fronting or exposing wrong, he is tender as a child to all in weakness, sympathetic as a woman to all in pain.’6 Moreover, even within the boundaries established by his own definitions of manliness, in, for example, Unto this Last (1860), Sesame and Lilies (1865), Fors Clavigera (1871–84), A Knight’s Faith (1884), and Valle Crucis (written in the early 1880s but published in 1896), Ruskin was suggestively dissonant, transgressing those borders that his own culturally prestigious words were endeavouring to enforce.7 But it was the question of sexuality and gender (and their relationship) that caused the most significant difficulty for both early and later critics of Ruskin. His failed and sexually inactive marriage (and chaste, emotionally destructive love for Rose La Touche, a girl nearly thirty years younger) were episodes that challenged the masculine identity of their subject and energized efforts to frame him in culturally secure gender terms.8 W.G. Collingwood’s compensating endeavours to hail Ruskin in a rhetoric that was confident in its masculine credentials, and, in particular, to affirm his life’s labour in the language of manly exertion, were visible in paint in 1882. They were also visible in prose from his very first essay in Ruskin biography, John Ruskin: A Biographical Outline (1889). This pamphlet, in Virtue’s, the London publisher’s, ‘Celebrities Series’, set some of the defensive masculinizing terms that were generously amplified in his later The Life and Work of John Ruskin (1893), a highly
Francis O’Gorman 13
influential biography that would prove consequential in the twentieth century. The pamphlet also extended, or at least translated into the verbal, the painterly vocabulary of the 1882 portrait. Collingwood began with a description of Ruskin (as well as a preliminary etching)9 that strengthened the reader’s sense of the heroic energy he had suggested in the 1882 painting. He observed that Ruskin, like a new Moses, had ‘the still undimmed fire of eyes which, from their overhung caverns, seem to miss nothing’, as well as the ‘unabated vigour in hair … and … the spring and strength of a frame which, though stooped and bent as if with poring over papers always laid flat upon his table, is competent even now for cutting faggots in the wood, or rowing his boat across the lake in half a gale of wind.’10 This verbal portrait of masculine energy and physical vitality (Ruskin was 70 in the year the pamphlet was published) is an unsurprising prose gloss to the gender rhetoric of the portrait, as, indeed, the Outline is more generally. Collingwood’s first biographical approach presented the narrative of a conflictual life, in which Ruskin, who ‘naturally provoked opposition’11 in his radical views, was situated in an explicitly masculinized scene of conflict. The language of war served Collingwood as a serviceable rhetoric for his gender claims. Ruskin ‘busied himself in the pursuit and defence of truth’,12 he concluded, framing his subject as a chivalric warrior who fought many ‘Battles … with crass Boeotians’.13 This presentation of a combative life, where Ruskin periodically ‘came into collision with everybody’,14 was fashioned as replete with heroic labour. Social action and altruistic reform, rather than art, were affirmed by Collingwood as the real centre of Ruskin’s heavily masculinized work. Illness, and in particular the periods of Ruskin’s depression and insanity, were emphasized as the result of great physical outlay. The ‘enormous press and variety of work he had undertaken’ was always public-spirited and altruistic. The illness at Matlock in 1871 was ‘a consequence of the distressful exertions of mind he had undergone when on the Mansion House Committee for the victualling of Paris after the siege’.15 Ruskin was manfully spending his life for others. Collingwood’s approach to the key stories of Ruskin in love in the Outline, with their potentially troubling implications for normative masculinity, was simple: he entirely ignored them. Of Effie and Rose he said nothing, though he briefly noted that, when Ruskin’s ‘nursery was invaded by a bevy of pretty girls’ (that is, when he was visited by the Domecq daughters, though hardly in his nursery), he ‘of course … fell in love’.16 The only indication of sexual desire permitted in the text plainly stressed heterosexual normativity. Language that affirmed this – where it
14 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love
was possible – was extensively marshalled in Collingwood’s other biographical accounts of Ruskin’s youthful love in both the Life and Ruskin’s Relics (1903). In the former, for instance, he preserved his image of Ruskin the heroic champion, calling him an art critic who had ‘beaten down opposition, risen above detraction, and won the prize of honour’,17 while narrating the story of Adèle Domecq in a way that amplified the strategy of the Outline by stressing Ruskin’s healthy sexual desire. Collingwood presented him as a young man ardently intense about Adèle, falling ‘passionately in love’ with her ‘graceful figure and that oval face’.18 The end to his hopes, which Collingwood indicated was chiefly due to parental influence, not to any fault in his own attractiveness, did not dispirit him utterly. He ‘[took] his punishment like a man’, he concluded.19 Collingwood’s efforts to insist on healthy manliness and sexual desire, visible in his use of the Adèle Domecq story, aimed to detract from the problems generated for a biographical representation of masculinity by Ruskin’s dissonant gender position and, especially, the implications of his marriage. This latter was a problem E.T. Cook solved in his influential two-volume The Life of John Ruskin (1911) by taking a hint from the Outline and barely mentioning the subject of Ruskin and Effie at all. But Collingwood’s approach to the sexual life of Ruskin, his attempts to defend any implication of unmanliness by hearty masculinization, sit uncomfortably, or so it first appears, besides the implications of his surprisingly frank exploration of sexuality and sexual relationships in his now forgotten fiction. Collingwood’s scholarly interests in Old Norse culture resulted partly in two historical novels, now lost in the oubliette of Victorian literature, Thorstein of the Mere: A Saga of the Northmen in Lakeland (1895) and The Bondwoman: A Saga of Langdale (1896). The second of these has implications for his work on Ruskin.20 Set in the Lake District and reissued in 1932 with the pluralized title of The Bondwomen, the novel candidly explored a sexual triangle between Oddi, a statesman and Lakeland settler of northern origin, his wife Groa, and a beautiful Saxon captive called Deorwyn. Groa, unhappy with her husband’s sexual longing for his expensively bought domestic slave, eventually decides to allow him to sleep with her and agrees to let them live together in a threesome to preserve domestic harmony. ‘So master Oddi’, Collingwood wrote, ‘had his heart’s desire, and a bit over; and a proud and happy man he was.’21 This remarkable arrangement (remarkable, that is, for respectable fiction of 1896), which began with a ‘honeymoon of three’,22 lasts for some time before Deorwyn sets up a new home with a separate partner. Such controversial exploration of the
Francis O’Gorman 15
pleasures of bigamy perhaps suggested Collingwood’s view of sexuality was liberal. The book caused a storm for this reason23 and it might have indicated a willingness to read another man’s ‘unorthodox’ sexual history, however that unorthodoxy was enacted, more openly and less defensively. But The Bondwoman in fact suggests nothing of the sort, and its depiction of masculinity clearly indicates the roots of Collingwood’s gender politics and provides part of the explanation for his aggressive masculinization of Ruskin. Collingwood’s notion of masculinity in The Bondwoman was focused on Oddi as uncompromising sexual predator, and sexual desire and performance were precisely the indices of his manliness. Masculinity emerged in The Bondwoman as a category primarily suggestive of barely containable sexual desire where women were literally a commodity (Oddi buys Deorwyn), as well as the passive and voiceless object of male aggression, physical violence, and murder. The book makes uneasy reading in its privileging of male sexual potency with disregard for the woman’s perspective. The fact that unrestrained penetrative sex, apart from anything else, was such an obvious and emphatic indicator of masculinity in The Bondwoman is entirely consistent with Collingwood’s defensive strategies in his biographical work on Ruskin to preserve a sense of his vigorous manliness in the absence of sexual performance.24 While Collingwood’s fictional explorations of masculinity were peculiar to him, his visual and verbal portraits of Ruskin in masculinized terms and his efforts to erase implications of aspects of his dissident gender position determined many early approaches, a plurality of turnof-the-century efforts, to protect Ruskin with a manly vocabulary. Collingwood’s Outline began a powerful biographical practice. And as that practice developed, embracing writers including Frederic Harrison, J. Marshall Mather, Alice Meynell, R.E. Pengelly, and Ashmore Wingate, an especially sensitive issue continued to be Ruskin’s gender position in the light of his sexual history. A sustained correspondence was silently made between sexual activity and gender, where success in one correlated with normativity in the other. I have discussed these writers and their defensive gendering strategies in Chapter 5 of my Late Ruskin: New Contexts (2001). The subterranean anxieties about Ruskin’s gender position went beyond Collingwood’s generation into the new century. But the unconsummated marriage, as the century moved on, became a subject of more open discussion, long after the decline of major interest in Ruskin’s life and work, and it began to form the focus of increasingly obvious gender
16 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love
claims. Various debates, after the Library Edition, were sustained about responsibility and blame, and they went on for years. Kenneth Clark noted wearily as late as 1964 that concern about Ruskin had long been only a ‘malicious interest in the story of his private life’.25 Ruskin’s marriage was, at a popular level, what was chiefly known about him, just as, now, with a different sense of what is sexual scandal, Ruskin’s relationship with Rose dominates one picture of his sexuality. The interest in the marriage and the scandalous claims it prompted in the years between the two world wars eventually caused the intervention of Sir William James and John Howard Whitehouse at the end of the 1940s and the beginning of the 1950s. Their bitter argument – Whitehouse was ‘incandescent’26 about James’s views – involved Whitehouse’s re-activation, with a new force, of the defensive gender terms that had been given wide currency by Collingwood and absorbed by his generation. After Ruskin’s death (Effie had died in 1897), some who had known Ruskin, or had been loosely connected with the Ruskin–Effie circle, commented on the collapse of the marriage and variously laid blame, implied improper action, or suggested a frisson of scandal. Ruskin’s marriage was a subject for public debate in the twentieth century to a greater extent than, say, Emilia Dilke’s (first) or Carlyle’s problematic marriages were, and a considerable corpus of opinion was gradually constructed that would provide the tinder for a conflagration in the mid-point of the century. An early contribution to the debates about the rights and wrongs of the two partners before or after the annulment was William Michael Rossetti’s important Rossetti Papers 1862 to 1870 (1903), which, while not devoting a great deal of space to the Ruskin marriage, did include a potentially damaging statement about Effie. Rossetti, repeating the evidenceless claim he had heard from the unreliable Charles Augustus Howell,27 wrote that at Ruskin’s marriage £40,000 was settled on Mrs R[uskin]; and that, as far as he [Howell] can trace out in the accounts, this sum has remained with her, spite of the nullity-of-marriage suit. He regards this as intentional generosity on R[uskin]’s part, but does not seem to have ascertained whether R[uskin] had really any power of revoking the settlement.28 The clear implication of this narrative, intended or not, was that there had been a degree of injustice on the part of Effie, tactfully indexed as Lady Millais throughout the book. Rossetti implied that she had profited financially by the marriage and acted dishonourably by keeping the
Francis O’Gorman 17
huge sum of money settled on her in 1848. This was a claim that greatly annoyed the Gray family. In 1912 the Effie–Ruskin marriage became the subject of a more remarkable claim, emphasizing the sexual strangeness of Ruskin and the emasculating effects of literary labour. This view of Ruskin’s wasted manliness, together with other versions of his sexual ‘abnormality’, began to grow alongside the Collingwood-inspired defensive rhetoric, to be finally assimilated in Millett’s attack in 1970. The original suggestion was made in the new medium of black and white moving film: a silent movie from the Vitagraph Company of America, starring Earle Williams as Ruskin, called The Love of John Ruskin. This cinematographic work, now lost, from the most successful US film producer in the early years of silent movies, apparently represented Ruskin as a man who was unable to give Effie the affection she deserved because, as the advertisement phrased it, ‘His mind was absorbed in his literary effusions’29 too much to notice her. Work impeded sexual fulfilment in this reading, and it turned Ruskin into a erotically diminished man. The advertisement claimed that he ‘loved his wife intensely, but he was not demonstrative. His heart was bowed down with a great sorrow, he would not deny his wife that love which he could not enjoy himself. He willingly gave her freedom and released her from her marriage vows. He not only consented to the marriage with Sir John Millais, but acted as best man at their wedding.’30 Clearly, while the film was broadly sympathetic to Ruskin, it constructed him as a sexually and emotionally enfeebled (and actually impotent?) man, whose passion for a beautiful woman was withered by his commitment to writing and his lack of sexual drive. The film’s absurd claim that Ruskin was the best man at Millais’s wedding was to prove only one of the extraordinary statements made in twentiethcentury efforts to tell the history of Ruskin in love. Vitagraph’s view of an emasculated Ruskin was one of the perceptions Collingwood had wanted to counter. It would dramatically reappear in the work of Admiral James in 1948. In print, some biographers discussed the relationship on both sides of E.T. Cook’s and Alexander Wedderburn’s Library Edition of the Complete Works of John Ruskin (1903–12). Amid conflicting claims, they found this remarkably difficult to do. Eda Earland in her Ruskin and His Circle (1910), for example, noted with surprise Ruskin’s friendly support of Millais’s art even after he had become the lover and later the husband of Effie. ‘What were his real feelings in the matter?’,31 Earland asked with some incredulity. The Love of John Ruskin had been intended as a cinematographic reply to precisely such a question. After the Library Edition,
18 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love
when the first phase of Ruskin enthusiasm and scholarship had passed, speculation continued among those who were still writing on him about the details of the unconsummated marriage. Amabel Williams-Ellis, in The Tragedy of John Ruskin (1928), lamented the ‘difficulties in the way of a biographer’s finding out what really happened and why’.32 She noted with frustration that different commentators took different lines, with Collingwood regarding Effie as ‘reprobate’33 and John G. Millais, in his two-volume life of his father, The Life and Letters of Sir John Everett Millais (1899), endeavouring to erase the figure of Ruskin-as-husband altogether by never mentioning that his mother had previously been married to him.34 Despite her comments on the difficulties of discerning fact from fiction in the story, however, Williams-Ellis added in a small way to the myths that were growing around the relationship herself, declaring, with no stated evidence, that Effie’s way of leaving Ruskin was not a little heartless. ‘Effie left without a word’, she wrote, ‘save the traditional note on the pincushion.’35 Sir William Rothenstein made a more dramatic claim in his account of the marriage in 1931, continuing to add to the pile of imaginative and salacious speculation. Rothenstein’s Man and Memories (1931–2) repeated a story apparently from F.J. Furnivall, who regarded Ruskin as having wickedly endeavoured to trap Effie into adulterous falsehood. ‘There was no pretence of affection,’ Rothenstein wrote, recalling Furnivall’s words, ‘or of sympathy even, betwixt Ruskin and her. Ruskin, according to Furnivall’s story, had hoped that she would elope with an Italian count who had stayed in the house; but it was the count who eloped, not with Mrs Ruskin, but with all her jewels.’36 This narrative is confusing. The ‘Italian count’ is not identified, and perhaps Furnivall referred to Effie’s friendship with Charles Paulizzi, an Austrian first lieutenant, on her and Ruskin’s first trip to Venice during the winter of 1849–50. If this is so, then Paulizzi is perplexingly misidentified in Furnivall’s or Rothenstein’s mind, firstly as a count, and secondly because he merges with Captain Foster, an Englishman in the Austrian service, who actually was suspected of stealing Effie’s jewels from a Venetian hotel room at the close of their stay in 1852.37 Whatever the case, Rothenstein’s contribution to the debate about the marriage fanned flames. Among Ruskin biographies, there can be few so unpopular as R.H. Wilenski’s judgmental and begrudging volume, a study of a ‘manicdepressive invalid’,38 published as John Ruskin: An Introduction to Further Study of His Life and Work (1933). Wilenski’s approach to Ruskin, whom he saw as having ‘an abnormal constitution of … mind’,39 was relentlessly to
Francis O’Gorman 19
blame John James and Margaret – ‘a religious bigot’40 – for Ruskin’s problems. The man who emerged from this volume was a mixture of dandy, genius, eccentric, and depressive, who was unable to stand up to parental interference in his life: he was also profoundly self-indulgent. On the question of Ruskin and love, Wilenski saw his subject as characterized by unspecified ‘Sexual obsessions of a personal kind’ that ‘were persistently with him in adolescence and from just before forty to the end.’41 These apparently inhibited his relationships and his sexual maturity. Wilenski’s interest in Ruskin’s sexual nature led him to offer some hints of secret sexual liaisons, and to suggest that Ruskin pursued his self-indulgence in a new direction around the time of his unconversion. In Turin in 1858, Wilenski said, Ruskin enjoyed the ‘pleasures of urban life’: he ‘gave a £5 tip to a ballerina; he nearly ogled the Italian ladies round the bandstand on a Sunday morning; and there possibly (and elsewhere possibly in the next few years) he indulged himself in other pleasures of which we have no records and which possibly he never confessed.’42 The freely acknowledged absence of evidence for the last point did not inhibit Wilenski from adding a remarkable hint of what he presumably meant his readers to believe was secret sexual activity to his view of Ruskin as wayward and self-indulgent. The distinctive representation of the sexually unorthodox (though far from impotent) Ruskin in Wilenski’s Introduction encouraged the notion of his apparently malformed sexual nature. Here, one sees the blossoming of the gender discourse that Collingwood had tried so vigorously to oppose and that would infuriate Whitehouse. Ruskin was variously being understood, by those who configured him as abnormal, as imperfectly male because he did not enjoy normative heterosexual pleasures in a sustained relationship. Amabel Williams-Ellis had put the gender question in her study, writing with the full force of early twentieth-century heterosexual notions of middle-class gender roles, in plain terms. Ruskin’s separation from Effie was, she said, nothing other than ‘an ever-present symbol of his inability or unwillingness to live the life of normal men.’43 Such judgements, grounding admirable manliness in domestic and long-term sexual union, were made in various biographical accounts of Ruskin in love and appeared as late as Lord Clark’s assertion in Ruskin Today (1964) that one of Ruskin’s problems was that he was ‘incapable of normal relations with a grown-up woman’.44 These statements powerfully occluded any more serious thinking about Ruskin’s gender position and they are still present in popular perceptions of it today. But the gender issues that were sustained, though often hidden, beneath the narrative surface of biographical accounts of the
20 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love
1920s and 30s became prominent in the conflict over Ruskin’s married life enacted in print between Admiral Sir William James in The Order of Release (1948) and John Howard Whitehouse in Vindication of John Ruskin (1950). This was a clash about Ruskin’s role in the breakdown of his marriage that gave central place to the matter of gender, though this has not been recognized. Connecting with Collingwood’s strategies of masculinization at the end of the nineteenth century, this remarkable instance of attack and defence – the military metaphor is more than appropriate – gave, in Whitehouse’s book, additional force to what would prove a problematic legacy for readers of Ruskin in the second half of the twentieth. Admiral Sir William James (1881–1973) was Effie’s grandson and the boy in Millais’s A Child’s World, later Bubbles (1886). This picture suggested a form of effeminate masculinity from which James himself, as an adult, consistently endeavoured to escape. Looking over the biographical accounts of his grandmother’s first marriage, Sir William concluded, unsurprisingly, that there had been a good deal of unwarranted speculation and a large number of ‘fantastic stories’.45 The film, W.M. Rossetti, and William Rothenstein struck him particularly as offering indefensible fictions about the sensitive history of his own family. Sir William’s The Order of Release, rather ironically taking its title from Millais’s 1853 picture of Effie as a highlander’s wife securing the release of her husband and their consequent reunion, offered, he said, ‘The true story … for the first time’.46 James defended Effie’s name, portraying her as dignified throughout the break-up of the marriage, and a beautiful woman, enduring with superhuman self-control until the end a ‘martyrdom’47 of sexless union. Ruskin, while a ‘genius’,48 was an unnatural man for James, and James’s defence of Effie, which involved a good deal of unprincipled editing of documents, sponsored recurrent criticism of his sexual nature. Where Collingwood and others had endeavoured to distract from any querying of Ruskinian manliness as a result of what James called the ‘unnatural’49 marriage, James himself continued much more bluntly: Ruskin’s biographers, Cook and Collingwood, were not incompetent; on the contrary, they understood their work only too well. They realized that the British public are exceedingly frightened of any form of sexual abnormality and that to admit that Ruskin lived for six years with a beautiful woman, in intimacy at first lover-like, and yet refused to consummate the marriage, would be presenting him as an abnormal being and probably frighten away a large number of readers and damage his publicity value.50
Francis O’Gorman 21
James’s attack on Ruskin corralled elements of previous rhetoric about sexual irregularity from the biographical tradition and fashioned them into an onslaught, a portrait of sexually impoverished manhood. Against the standard of normative heterosexual masculinity, Ruskin emerged as an emasculated figure, whose sexuality – James assumed there should be a straightforward link between physical beauty and physical desire – could not be stirred even by Effie’s notable beauty. John Howard Whitehouse repudiated James’s book and in doing so revived Collingwood’s discourse, reproducing with a fresh urgency the pattern indicated by the Outline and the highly popular Life. Whitehouse, a major force in the preservation of Ruskin’s papers, house, and reputation in the first half of the century, proposed in his Vindication of Ruskin (1950), published two years after The Order of Release, that James was misled and grossly unfair, that his facts were erroneous, and that he had made an error in failing to discuss Ruskin’s own Statement to his proctor in the nullity suit (this was printed in the Vindication). Whitehouse was courteous to James, but highly critical of the biases in his narration, his omission of details from letters, and of the ‘multitude of offensive epithets’51 used to describe John James and Margaret. He defended Ruskin’s name as James had defended Effie’s, and as he did so he contested the emasculated image of the ‘abnormal’ Ruskin by reaffirming the masculinizing language he had been applying to Ruskin for more than half a century. Whitehouse’s Vindication – more or less his last work on Ruskin52 – was the conclusion of fifty years of rhetorical masculinizing of the man whom, with characteristic military vocabulary, he called the ‘solitary warrior’.53 Whitehouse’s version of Ruskin’s manliness was articulated in poetry and prose and continually mobilized tropes of knightliness. Ruskin was a chivalric figure in his many works, his labours framed in terms of the knight’s selfless and noble endeavours. Whitehouse, as a young man, had established and edited what was initially the journal of the Birmingham Ruskin Society in 1898 and named it Saint George: the association between Ruskin and the paragon of (supposedly) English knightliness – obviously invited by Ruskin himself – was characteristic and it set a model for Whitehouse’s life’s energies. In The Solitary Warrior, he fashioned his image of Ruskin, like Collingwood, as a new knight, speaking of him as ‘the most chivalrous of men’,54 and imagining him as a soldier fighting against the unreceptive world. ‘The appeal of “Fors Clavigera”’, he said ‘is the appeal of one splendid soul addressed to a world mainly hostile.’55 Whitehouse also imagined Ruskin’s social and educational policies in terms of a revived chivalry (spurred by this he
22 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love
tried to put into practice chivalric ideas in his own extensive educational work),56 and had typically declared in a centenary memorial address in 1919 that, for Ruskin, ‘Education was not the acquisition of knowledge; it was primarily the cultivation of noble character’.57 The vocabulary of chivalric manliness served Whitehouse throughout his career. Aspects of it were operative in the Vindication and readers who knew Whitehouse’s earlier work would have found it entirely familiar. Whitehouse was defensive about Ruskin’s sexuality and unsurprisingly presented it in a totally different light from The Order of Release. Far from offering an account of ‘abnormality’, Whitehouse, trying to use Ruskin’s and Effie’s own words as far as possible, denied any sense of sexual strangeness, cruelty, or failure of desire. He emphasized how content the couple were at the beginning, quoting Effie’s letter written the day after their wedding night (‘John and I are as happy as two people can possibly be and he is exceedingly kind and thoughtful’)58 and, while not denying the marriage had been unconsummated, robustly contested the claim of the nullity suit that Ruskin was incurably impotent. Ruskin’s sexuality was affirmed in the Vindication as healthy, and no sexual querying of normative heterosexual manliness was allowed.59 The impotence charge was, Whitehouse said, ‘false’,60 but since it was better for both if the marriage was annulled, Ruskin ‘had … no option except to withdraw his opposition to the suit’ though it ‘prevented him from disproving the allegation upon which the suit was based’.61 Ruskin emerged in this rebuttal of James as sexually ‘normal’ and admirably noble in his acceptance of a bogus claim that permitted the best decision to be made about the annulment. Whitehouse, approvingly quoting Clement Shorter’s words, reaffirmed more characteristic knightly language when he observed that Ruskin had generously ‘“permitted – out of chivalry to the woman he had married – his reputation to be traduced on all hands for the whole period of his life, whereas his intrinsic nobility of nature at no point shines more brightly than in his own attitude towards his ill-fated marriage”’.62 Chivalry, nobility, and knightly courtesy, as well as sexual potency, were the terms set to work in defence of Ruskin’s gender identity in the Vindication, articulating Whitehouse’s conception, once again, of what was dependably male about the man he called, with language suitable for an Arthuriad, his ‘Noblest friend’.63 The Vindication intervened in the debate about the marriage, and gave new life to the defensive masculinizing rhetoric that had been a feature of Ruskin biography since Collingwood inaugurated it. These biographers, across more than half a century, had aimed to defend Ruskin as securely male, to protect his reputation by guarding his manliness. They
Francis O’Gorman 23
were resolutely on his side. But history had a surprise in store that would see the language employed to defend Ruskin become part of a reason for assailing him. Via a major change of perspective, the terms aggregated by this corpus of writers, given fresh prominence in 1950, helped fashion the context in which feminists would unsympathetically read Ruskin in the next decades. The Ruskin who had been protectively imagined as an exemplum of nineteenth-century chivalric manliness, an epitome of admirable masculinity, became, when seen from the perspective of the women’s movement of the 1960s and 1970s, the Ruskin who was the eloquent spokesman of unadmirable masculinity, of Victorian middle-class patriarchal subjugation, the voice of an oppressive gender politics, a deplorable archetypal Victorian man. At the edge of this was the shadow of Collingwood, author of The Bondwoman with its aggressive sexual politics, and the first architect of the defensive rhetoric of Ruskinian manliness. It was, of course, Kate Millett in Sexual Politics (1970) who found Ruskin the most unpardonable of Victorians. In her influential work, the relevant part of which was also published in Victorian Studies in 1970,64 Ruskin was presented as the spokesman of patriarchy par excellence. The text on which Millett concentrated was ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’.65 Her analysis of it framed Ruskin as the voice of an oppressive national ideology of gender, understanding him to speak the ‘normative beliefs of the Victorian middle class’.66 ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ presented a view of female duty and education as well as the doctrine of separate spheres that comprised, to Millett’s mind, a ‘compulsive masculine fantasy one might call the official Victorian attitude’.67 The ideology articulated there dramatically restricted the power and freedom of women, while, in a ‘tidy duplicity’ of rhetoric, she said, insisted that they were ‘“better” than men’.68 It was a dangerous mixture of oppressive politics eloquently disguised in ‘chivalrous posture[s]’.69 Chivalry, the word so often applied to Ruskin by Collingwood and his tradition, now became in Millett’s critical discourse a focus for antagonism. As David Sonstroem rightly remarked, ‘To [Millett] “chivalry” [was] a pejorative term, implying only “nostalgic mirage” or “sentimental vapors”’.70 Millett’s critique of Ruskin hailed him as a spokesman for patriarchal society at large, and Sexual Politics acknowledged that his position in Victorian gender politics was clear: he was, as Collingwood had tried to suggest, a sure representative of the middle-class male. But, for Millett, this meant that he was espousing a gender ideology that led to the confining of women through narrowing doctrines of cramped education and limited public power. Ruskin in Sexual Politics was once more
24 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love
situated firmly again in a hegemonic model of masculinity – and deplored. Millett’s denunciation of Ruskin included yet another an attack on his sexuality. At one level, Millett associated him with dominant modes of Victorian masculinity, but at another she deployed the rhetoric of sexual abnormality prominent in the film and Sir William James’s reading, to discredit his aims and expose the seemingly dubious nature of his regard for women that infected his utopian writing. Speaking on behalf of ‘normal’ men in one way, he was imperfectly male in others. Millett was scornful of Ruskin’s ‘middle-aged infatuation over Rose La Touche’, for instance, and thought it gave a tint of ‘senile eroticism’71 to the plans in ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ (Ruskin was 39 when he met Rose and 45 when he delivered Sesame and Lilies). Such language of sexual shortcoming came to a dramatic conclusion in Millett’s final words about the ideals represented in the Rusholme lecture. Ruskin’s notion that the ‘salvation of the world’, she said, ‘… should come from its subject women is a concoction of nostalgic mirage, regressive, infantile, or narcissistic sexuality, religious ambition, and simplistic social panacea.’72 The discourses I have been tracing in eighty years of Ruskin criticism and biography thus formed themselves into a new shape in the rhetoric of this influential text from the Woman’s Movement. One of those discourses had energetically hailed Ruskin as securely masculine and an embodiment of forms of normative Victorian manliness. In Millett, such a claim gave energy to her view of Ruskin as the spokesman for patriarchy and hegemonic male middle-class gender values. The other discourse censured him by revealing his emasculated sexuality, writing a question mark over his manliness as it was enacted (or not) in sexual performance. In Millett, this strategy was revised and put to her own purposes, as she disclosed her preconceptions of what normal heterosexual relations should be, suggesting that patriarchy was built in Ruskin’s case on infantile sexuality and revealing that the supposedly regressive nature of his love was one of the contaminating forces of his generally intolerable views of women’s place. Millett’s analysis mattered, and no one could deny the challenges for modern readers considering aspects of the gender politics of Sesame and Lilies. Nonetheless, her case has, of course, been rethought, by David Sonstroem (1977),73 Elizabeth K. Helsinger, Robin Sheets and William Veeder (1983),74 as well as by Dinah Birch in ‘Ruskin’s “Womanly Mind”’ (see pp. 107–20 below), and by my chapter in Late Ruskin.75 Yet specifically revising Millett’s reading of Sesame and Lilies in such ways is only part of the task of contemporary Ruskin readers looking for the
Francis O’Gorman 25
fuller picture of Ruskin’s complex and complicated relationship with ideas and ideals of gender. Millett was significant but not alone in helping skew the picture of Ruskin and gender. Behind her was a substantial tradition that she had silently absorbed and reconfigured, a view of Ruskin in terms of normative Victorian manliness that emerged from a tradition of over half a century of writing and which had Collingwood at its root. What is now needed is to recognize this tradition and, in naming it, to begin to defuse its power. Collectively, it has put major impediments in the way of grasping the complexity of Ruskin’s gender position and its consequences for understanding his life and writing.
Notes This chapter is something of an answer to a question Professor Andrew Wawn asked me on 23 April 1999. 1 Collingwood noted ‘The open drawer holds the St George’s Guild business papers (in connection with which he was then at work)’, quoted in James S. Dearden, John Ruskin: A Life in Pictures (Sheffield: Sheffield University Press, 1999), pp. 131–2. 2 Quoted in Dearden, p. 132. 3 Ibid. 4 The argument of this chapter builds on the ground I covered in ‘“Just the thing for Girls – Sketching, Fine Art and So On”: Ruskin and Manliness (1870–1920)’ in Francis O’Gorman, Late Ruskin: New Contexts (Aldershot and Burlington VT: Ashgate, 2001), pp. 118–42. See also my ‘“Do what you can, and confess frankly what you are unable to do”: Ruskin’s Aesthetic of Failure in The Stones of Venice’, forthcoming in Review of English Studies. 5 See O’Gorman, Late Ruskin, pp. 59–60. 6 J. Marshall Mather, Life and Teaching of John Ruskin (Manchester: Tubbs, Brook & Chrystal/London: Simpkins & Marshall/Hamilton & Adams, [1884]), p. 23. 7 See O’Gorman, Late Ruskin, pp. 120–4. 8 Historians have commented on the increasing scrutiny of male behaviour in marriage towards the end of the nineteenth century. A. James Hammerton, the most authoritative writer on this subject, has argued that, following the 1857 Divorce Act, male conduct was increasingly spotlighted in marriage breakdown and that ‘by the late nineteenth century men’s unreasonable and selfish behaviour was being identified and debated as the chief cause of failing marriages’, Cruelty and Companionship: Conflict in Nineteenth-Century Married Life (London: Routledge, 1992), p. 166. See also John Tosh, A Man’s Place: Masculinity and the Middle-Class Home in Victorian England (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1999), 145–69. This changed legal climate put an additional pressure on Collingwood and others to defend Ruskin’s own position in his marriage. 9 It is an etching that, again, reveals the active man of letters: Ruskin at his desk, pen in hand.
26 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love 10 W.G. Collingwood, John Ruskin: A Biographical Outline (London: Virtue, 1889), p. 5. 11 Ibid., p. 4. 12 Ibid., p. 29. 13 Ibid., p. 32. Boeotians were legendarily dull and stupid. 14 Ibid., p. 11. 15 Ibid., p. 20. 16 Ibid., pp. 8–9. 17 W.G. Collingwood, The Life of John Ruskin, 7th edn (London: Methuen, 1911), p. 147. 18 Ibid., p. 48. 19 Ibid., p. 65. 20 W.G. Collingwood, The Bondwoman: A Saga of Langdale was first published by Edward Arnold in 1896 and re-issued as The Bondwomen: A Saga of Langdale by Heinemann in 1932. I quote from the re-issued text. 21 W.G. Collingwood, The Bondwomen: A Saga of Langdale (London: Heinemann, 1932), p. 117. 22 Ibid., p. 118. 23 Collingwood’s ‘Preface’ acknowledged ‘the little stir it made among a few friends’ (ibid., unnumbered front papers), and Andrew Wawn, discussing the hostile critical reception of the novel in The Vikings and the Victorians: Inventing the Old North in Nineteenth Century Britain (Cambridge: Brewer, 2000), pp. 337–41, notes that the Spectator called it ‘a book which ought never to have been written’ (p. 338). 24 Collingwood’s Thorstein of the Mere was less focused on sexual gratification but it did emphasize another descriptor of masculinity that excluded Ruskin, namely fatherhood. The book is about the establishment of a family line of succession in the Lakes – Thorstein is Thurston Water, which is, appropriately enough, the modern Coniston Water – from the medieval to the present. The Blawith house, Collingwood says at the end, endured at Coniston as ‘a great family, for many generations, and thereabouts they dwell even to this day’ (W.G. Collingwood, Thorstein of the Mere: A Saga of the Northmen in Lakeland (London: Arnold, 1895), p. 304). Collingwood accented the book’s focus on paternity by dedicating it to Robin, his five-year-old son, with a tribute to his youthful combative manliness: ‘Thorstein is yours. You’ve made him yours/By masterful appropriation:/As long as right of might endures/I dare no other dedication,/Whatever name allures’ (ibid., unnumbered front papers). Robin (R.G. Collingwood (1889–1943)), was later a distinguished Idealist philosopher at Oxford University. 25 Kenneth Clark, Ruskin Today (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1982, first published 1964), p. xii. 26 Letter from James Dearden to the author, 8 March 2001, recalling memories of Whitehouse. 27 Ruskin employed Charles Augustus Howell as secretary and assistant for some years after 1865. Cook observes politely in the Introduction to vol. 36 of the Library Edition that Howell’s tales from his adventurous life, which included, Howell claimed, living in Morocco as the sheik of an Arab tribe, ‘lost nothing in his telling of them’ (36. li).
Francis O’Gorman 27 28 William Michael Rossetti, Rossetti Papers 1862 to 1870, first published 1903 (New York: AMS, [1970]), pp. 225–6. This is a diary entry from W.M. Rossetti’s diary, 5 March 1867. 29 Quoted in Sir William James, ed., The Order of Release: The Story of John Ruskin, Effie Gray and John Everett Millais Told for the First Time in Their Unpublished Letters (London: Murray, 1948), 2. I have been unable to find any other printed material from this film and William James was no accurate transcriber, so there must be some doubt as to the exact wording of this advertisement. 30 Ibid. 31 Eda Earland, Ruskin and His Circle (London: Hutchinson, 1910), p. 82. 32 Amabel Williams-Ellis, The Tragedy of John Ruskin (London: Cape, [1928]), p. 171. 33 Ibid. 34 See ibid. 35 Ibid., p. 170. The most famous speculation about the marriage – that Ruskin was so shocked by Effie’s pubic hair that he could not consummate the marriage – was made much later than Williams-Ellis’s book. As far as I can see, it first occurs in print, though somewhat coyly expressed, in Effie in Venice: Unpublished Letters of Mrs John Ruskin between 1849 and 1852, ed. Mary Lutyens (London: Murray, 1965), pp. 20–1. Lutyens made her point plainer in her The Ruskins and the Grays (London: Murray, 1972), p. 108. There is no evidence for this view (it is difficult to imagine what might constitute evidence), and it has been contested. See, for instance, Tim Hilton, John Ruskin: The Early Years (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1985), pp. 119–20. 36 William Rothenstein, Men and Memories: Recollections of William Rothenstein, 2 vols (London: Faber, 1931–2), I.367–8. 37 Details of this crime are given in Derrick Leon, Ruskin: The Great Victorian (London: Routledge, 1949), pp. 166–8. 38 R.H. Wilenski, John Ruskin: An Introduction to Further Study of His Life and Work (London: Faber, 1933), p. 11. 39 Ibid., p. 29. 40 Ibid., p. 38. 41 Ibid., p. 32. 42 Ibid., p. 35. 43 Williams-Ellis, The Tragedy of John Ruskin, p. 174. 44 Kenneth Clark, Ruskin Today, p. 8. 45 James, The Order of Release, p. 2. 46 Ibid, p. 1. 47 Ibid., p. 3. 48 Ibid., p. 6. 49 Ibid. 50 Ibid., p. 2. 51 J. Howard Whitehouse, Vindication of Ruskin (London: Allen & Unwin, 1950), p. 35. 52 Whitehouse died in 1955. Between 1956 and 1959, Clarendon Press published the three volumes of The Diaries of John Ruskin, as edited by J.H. Whitehouse and Joan Evans. Whitehouse’s involvement in their
28 Manliness and the History of Ruskin in Love
53 54 55 56 57 58 59
60 61 62 63 64 65
66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74
75
preparation was minimal: his contribution was chiefly in buying the mss on which the text was based in the 1931 Brantwood sale. See the title of his letter collection The Solitary Warrior: New Letters (London: Allen & Unwin, [1929]). Ibid., pp. 13–14. Ibid., p. 24. See O’Gorman, Late Ruskin, pp. 127–8. J. Howard Whitehouse, ed., Ruskin Centenary Addresses: 8 February 1919 (London: Oxford University Press, 1919), p. 49. Whitehouse, Vindication of Ruskin, p. 19. George Allen & Unwin, the pro-Ruskin publishers who published the Vindication, assisted Whitehouse’s defence of Ruskin’s sexual potency by publishing, three years later, a special edition of The Gulf of Years: [Love] Letters from John Ruskin to Kathleen Olander (London: Allen & Unwin, 1953), edited by Rayner Unwin and with a commentary by Kathleen Olander, now Prynne. Ruskin proposed marriage to Kathleen in 1888 and she certainly had no doubt that this meant children (see p. 80). Whitehouse, Vindication of Ruskin, p. 18. Ibid. Ibid., p. 31. J.H. Whitehouse, ed., Poems to Ruskin (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1941), p. 23. Kate Millett, ‘The Debate Over Women: Ruskin Versus Mill’, Victorian Studies, 14 (1970), 63–82. Millett mis-punctuates this as ‘Of Queen’s Gardens’ throughout Sexual Politics. She also says it was delivered in Manchester Town Hall (it was Rusholme Town Hall). Kate Millett, Sexual Politics (London: Virago, 1977, first published 1970), p. 89. Ibid. Ibid., p. 102. Ibid., p. 97. David Sonstroem, ‘Millett Versus Ruskin: A Defense of Ruskin’s “Of Queens’ Gardens”’, Victorian Studies, 20 (1977), 289. Millett, Sexual Politics, p. 90. Ibid., p. 107. Sonstroem, ‘Millett Versus Ruskin’, 283–97. See ‘John Ruskin and “Of Queens’ Gardens”’, in The Woman Question: Society and Literature in Britain and America, 1837–1883, ed. Elizabeth K. Helsinger, Robin Lauterbach Sheets and William Veeder 3 vols (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1983), I.77–102. See O’Gorman, Late Ruskin, pp. 31–49.
2 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’ Catherine Robson
Ruskin’s Praeterita (1885–9) devotes much of its early energy to the depiction of a secure, protected, and enclosed childhood. The passive child at the centre of this high-security Eden is, not surprisingly, frequently feminized. Although no special pains are taken to avoid masculine nouns in the references to his younger self, Ruskin draws attention to the fact that both his natural sensibilities and his sequestered upbringing made him different from other boys. The difference is apparent both to his own eyes – ‘I don’t know what delight boys take in cricket, or boating, or throwing stones at birds, or learning to shoot them’ (35.293) – and to the eyes of his few male associates in childhood, who, ‘[f]inding me in all respects what boys could only look upon as an innocent, … treated me as I suppose they would have treated a girl’ (35.83). This last quotation includes a feature which appears often enough in Praeterita to constitute a stylistic tic: the expression ‘as … a girl’ and its variant ‘like a girl’ are frequently drafted into service in Ruskin’s representations of his child self. The earliest instance occurs in the description of Mr Northcote’s painting of the three-year-old Ruskin, which provides the first, and practically the only, picture we are granted of his physical appearance: ‘The portrait in question represents a very pretty child with yellow hair, dressed in a white frock like a girl, with a broad light-blue sash and blue shoes to match’ (35.21, p. 30). Given that boys of Ruskin’s age and class were habitually dressed in frocks at this period, the simile ‘like a girl’ here is by no means as significant as later rhetorical turns, which find the author repeatedly comparing himself to girls, and indeed, intensifying the construction by placing himself in the more feminine than feminine position. For instance, when the teenaged Ruskin is brought into relation with the entrancing French Catholic daughters of his father’s business partner Juan Pedro Domecq, his 29
30 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’
James Northcote, Ruskin, aet 31/2 (1822) (by permission of the National Gallery)
unworldly ways are attributed not, as they could have been, to a masculinized monastic existence, but to his being ‘[v]irtually convent-bred more closely than the maids themselves’ (35.179). Similarly, in order to represent his first tentative days of social acclimatization at Oxford, Ruskin makes use of a comparison drawn from the world of débutantes or the pages of a genteel novel and once again renders himself more girlish
Catherine Robson 31
than the girl described: ‘[P]oor Clara,’ we read, ‘after her first ball, receiving her cousin’s compliments in the cloak-room, was less surprised than I by my welcome from my cousins of the long-table’ (35.196). Such rhetorical constructions, intriguing though they are, are perhaps less significant in their contribution to Praeterita’s feminization of Ruskin’s childhood self than the vividly remembered girls who people the text. Ruskin said in the autobiography that he was ‘in nothing whatsoever changed ’ (35.220, italic original) from his earliest youth. The denial of the possibility of maturation that Ruskin insists on here is made real in Praeterita by a seemingly endless procession of lovely young lasses who fail to make it across the river to adulthood. Dark-eyed little Jessie, Ruskin’s vivacious Scottish cousin, is the first to go, when she and John are ‘about eight or nine,’ and she is soon followed by a host of others. Sometimes the deaths are imagined, rather than literal: the lives of formerly beloved girls who are lost to Ruskin in one way or another are effectively truncated by Praeterita’s refusal to grant their adulthood any representation. Thus Ruskin’s wife Effie appears only parenthetically as the ‘little girl’ for whose amusement The King of the Golden River was written (35.304). In a similar fashion, Adèle Domecq, his first love, ceases to have any real existence after the incandescent presence of her fifteen-year-old self had reduced young Ruskin ‘to a mere heap of white ashes’ in his seventeenth year (35.179). On occasion, even when the beloved female does indeed die at a relatively early age, she is remembered and depicted primarily as a much younger being. Here the most important figure is the love of Ruskin’s middle age and early old age, Rose La Touche, through the lens of whose loss all the girl-deaths of Praeterita are filtered. Although Rose died at twenty-seven of brain-fever, she lives in the autobiography primarily as a highspirited nine-year old, even commandeering the text with her own precocious expressions and orthographical oddities when Ruskin reproduces her first cherished letter to him in what ended up being Praeterita’s penultimate chapter. Most often, however, death comes to the maiden just as she gives up that maidenhood: we only have to learn that some delicate blossom is to be swept up into an ill-advised marriage, or otherwise oppressed by the demands of adulthood, to know that in a few lines’ time, she will be gone. ‘Roslyn Chapel’ provides us with three examples of this phenomenon. The aptly named Miss Withers is ‘a fragile, fair, freckled, sensitive slip of a girl about sixteen; graceful in an unfinished and small wildflower sort of a way, extremely intelligent, affectionate, wholly rightminded, and mild in piety’ (35.222). Yet instead of being allowed to
32 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’
bloom in the young Ruskin’s presence, Charlotte Withers and the ‘possibility of meek happiness vanish[ ] forever’: her coal-merchant father ‘“negotiated” a marriage for her with a well-to-do Newcastle trader, whom she took because she was bid. He treated her pretty much as one of his coal-sacks, and in a year or two she died’ (35.222). Nine pages later we encounter Miss Wardell, ‘an extremely accomplished, intelligent, and faultless maid of seventeen; fragile and delicate … a slender brunette, with her father’s dark curling hair transfigured into playful grace around the pretty, modest, not unthoughtful, gray-eyed face’ (35.231). This time the girl is carried off by over-zealous education rather than matrimony, but the outcome, as we learn in this deliberately exhausting sentence, is just the same: [A]t Hampstead they went on teaching the tender creature High German, and French of Paris, and Kant’s Metaphysics, and Newton’s Principia; and then they took her to Paris, and tired her out with seeing everything every day, all day long, besides the dazzle and excitement of such a first outing from Hampstead; and she at last getting too pale and weak, they brought her back to some English seaside place, I forget where: and there she fell into nervous fever and faded away, with the light of death flickering clearer and clearer in her soft eyes, and never skipped in Hampstead garden more. (35.232) With a brief mention of the ‘loss of the sweet spirit’ of yet another graceful maiden, Miss Sybilla Dowie (35.232), Ruskin concludes the chapter and the volume. The opening of the next volume of Praeterita would appear to announce a new era in the writer’s existence: the first chapter is entitled ‘Of Age’. Ruskin may literally have attained his majority, but it has already been made clear that his development, as surely as that of the three lost misses, has come to a definite full-stop.1 Praeterita, then, seems to provide the case-book example of a Victorian fantasy of original femininity: Ruskin not only represents his childhood as if it had been a feminine, rather than a masculine, era in his existence, but also, through the repeated invocation of truncated feminine lives, implies that this girl self does not evolve in or into adulthood. *** But girls do not play a part in Praeterita alone. By considering the full implications of the representations of girls in texts other than the autobiography, we extend our appreciation of their significance to Ruskin
Catherine Robson 33
and the gendering strategies of his self-writing, as well as revealing how his modes of representation are in accord with the symbolic meanings that the Victorian age was generally attributing to the figure of the little girl. As we shall see, the girl and the perfect past she represents in the autobiography cannot be properly understood without reference to the oppositional figures of the old man and to the desolate present day. The most relevant text is The Ethics of the Dust, published in 1865 with 1866 on the title page. As Dinah Birch has discussed on pp. 123–6 below, the immediate context of this was Winnington Hall in Cheshire, a school for well-to-do girls. Even in the company of the many genredefying oddities of Ruskin’s oeuvre, The Ethics of the Dust makes a strong claim to be the most curious work of all. Subtitled ‘Ten Lectures to Little Housewives on the Elements of Crystallisation’, The Ethics was intended, Ruskin maintained, to function as a gloss on the chapter entitled ‘Compact Crystallines’ in the fourth volume of Modern Painters (1856). The work, however, is both more and less than a mineralogical treatise. Carlyle, one of the few admirers of the text in its own time or any other, attempted to give an idea of its range by claiming that the author ‘twisted geology into morality, theology, Egyptian mythology, [and made] fiery cuts at political economy’.2 The form of this work, moreover, is just as strange at its content: The Ethics of the Dust is written as a series of quasi-Socratic dialogues between an ‘Old Lecturer’ (a figure who is never named ‘Ruskin’ in the text but who is self-evidently the author of Modern Painters and his other books) and twelve ‘girls’ between the ages of nine and twenty. Yet if its scope is broad and its form unusual, the central conceit of The Ethics of the Dust can be expressed quite simply: girls are crystals and crystals are girls. ‘My dear children,’ pronounces the Lecturer, ‘if you knew it, you are yourselves, at this moment, as you sit in your ranks, nothing, in the eyes of a mineralogist, but a lovely group of rosy sugarcandy, arranged by atomic forces. And even admitting you to be something more, you have certainly been crystallising without knowing it’ (18.221). Pinning in their crinolines the better to approximate the form of rose quartz as they dance the Lecturer’s ‘Crystal Quadrille,’ Ruskin’s young ladies, at their best, share the finest qualities of jewels, just as ‘a well-brought up mineral,’ in ‘its pretty ways of behaving’ is imagined to emulate the high standards of English girlhood (18.314–5). As Paul Sawyer notes in his excellent chapter on this work,3 The Ethics of the Dust organizes itself around a series of connected antitheses that ultimately reduce to the opposition between active purity and the foulness of decay. As the highest type of active purity in the world of minerals,
34 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’
crystals, formed from the co-operation of innumerable atoms, parallel the potential excellence that is to be aspired to both by individual human beings, formed from particles of dust, and by societies, ideally composed, like the perfect girls’ school, of mutually considerate members. For Ruskin, girls and rocks are identical in their purity of energy and the resultant beauty of their form. Maintaining that ‘[i]t is just as true for us, as for the crystal, that the nobleness of life depends on its consistency, – clearness of purpose, – quiet and ceaseless energy’, Ruskin insists that girls are ‘crystalline in brightness’ and ‘charm infinitely’ (18.264, 311). If both his wide-eyed pupils and the crystals of which they are the type stand for pure and active beauty, the Lecturer and the sin-blemished vacillations of his own damaged maturity represent the loss of the principle of straightforward vitality: ‘[A]ll doubt and repenting, and botching, and retouching, and wondering what it will be best to do next, are vice, as well as misery’ (18.264). As it is worked out in the text, this formulation relies heavily on a double conception of age. While The Ethics of the Dust takes great pains to point out the difference between the vivacious newness of its twelve young girls and the weary elderliness of the Lecturer, it nevertheless associates the former with antiquity, and the latter with the present day. Ruskin deliberately widens the gulf between the students and their teacher: although the age distribution of the girls in The Ethics of the Dust exactly reflects that of the pupils at Winnington Hall, the Lecturer appears to be freighted with many more years than the writer himself, who was only forty-six at the time of composition. Listed in the ‘Personae’ as ‘OLD LECTURER (of incalculable age)’, the male presence in the text is doubly superannuated. In a letter to his father written from the school two years before he began The Ethics of the Dust, Ruskin had commented that his association with these young girls gave him an exaggerated sense of his own elderliness: It is curious that I feel older and sadder, very much, in now looking at these young children—it is especially the young ones between whom & me I now feel so infinite a distance,—and they are so beautiful and so good, and I am not good, considering the advantages I’ve had, by any means. The weary longing to begin life over again, and the sense of fate forever forbidding it—here or hereafter—is terrible. I daresay I shall get over it in a day or two, but I was out in the playground with them this afternoon, and the sun was on the grass, and on them— and the sense of loveliness in life, and of overbrooding death, like winter, was too strong.4
Catherine Robson 35
Ruskin’s enervated conviction here of the opposition between blighted maturity and the girls’ spring-like perfection pervades the world of The Ethics of the Dust: for the Lecturer, who claims to be perpetually ‘tired, and cross’, the girls in all their morning gaiety are unlikely to be able to comprehend the miseries of old age. The radical difference of perspective is revealed in a conversation ostensibly about an imperfect crystal, described by the Lecturer as ‘sadly tired’. When one of the girls asks what events have led to this pass, the dialogue runs as follows: L. Trials much like our own. Sickness, and starvation; fevers, and agues, and palsy; oppression; and old age, and the necessity of passing away in their time, like all else. If there’s any pity in you, you must come to-morrow, and take some part in these crystal griefs. DORA. I am sure we shall cry till our eyes are red. L. Ah, you may laugh, Dora; but I’ve been made grave, not once, nor twice, to see that even crystals ‘cannot choose but be old’ at last. It may be but a shallow proverb of the Justice’s; but it is a shrewdly wide one. DORA (pensive for once). I suppose it is very dreadful to be old! But then (brightening again) what should we do without our dear old friends and our nice old lecturers? (18.324) ‘I am not myself afraid of death – but I am afraid – bitterly afraid of old age,’ wrote Ruskin to a correspondent in 1861.5 In choosing to endow the Lecturer with the decrepitude he dreads, Ruskin consigns man and girl, the only two categories of human beings The Ethics of the Dust really recognizes, to wholly incommensurate universes. Diagnosis of decay is not limited to the Lecturer’s own personal condition in the text. The Ethics of the Dust takes considerable pains to show us that the present day world is a tawdry affair, a sadly diminished version of an earlier splendour. Ruskin evokes a familiar mid-Victorian nostalgia for the bygone idyll of rural England; the meretricious glitter of Crystal Palace, for example, is invidiously compared to the simple neighbourhood fairs of the Lecturer’s youth. Elsewhere, summoning up the classical, rather than a personal, past, the Lecturer tells the girls that contemporary urban depredations plumb depths that would be almost unimaginable for the ancients: ‘[T]he vice existing among certain classes, both of the rich and poor, in London, Paris and Vienna, could have been conceived by a Spartan or Roman of the heroic ages only as possible in a Tartarus, where fiends were employed to teach, but not to punish, crime’ (18.355). Citing newspaper stories about child-murderers
36 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’
like Charlotte Winsor, and ‘sons like that one who, the other day, in France, beat his mother to death with a stick,’ the Lecturer seems convinced that in today’s world ‘[t]here is a peculiar horror about the relations between parent and child, which are being now brought about by our variously degraded forms of European white slavery’ (18.354). Whichever way we turn in The Ethics of the Dust, the immorality of modern life captures our attention. As the work draws to its close, the Lecturer tries to introduce a more uplifting perspective, claiming that ‘the great laws which never fail, and to which all change is subordinate, appear such as to accomplish a gradual advance to a lovelier order’ (18.357). Altogether too much has been said on the other side, however, for this to ring true. Although a pessimistic opinion from the fourth volume of Modern Painters is called up only to be negated, its sentiments, and the Lecturer’s explanation of their origin, still seem to express an abiding conviction that the incremental degeneration of the world is readily apparent to the eye: L. … I said that the earth seemed to have passed through its highest state: and that, after ascending by a series of phases, culminating in its habitation by man, it seems to be now gradually becoming less fit for that habitation. MARY. Yes, I remember. L. I wrote those passages under a very bitter impression of the gradual perishing of beauty from the loveliest scenes which I knew in the physical world; not in any doubtful way, such as I might have attributed to loss of sensation in myself—but by violent and definite physical action … I am still under the same impression respecting the existing phenomena; but I feel more strongly, every day, that no evidence to be collected within historical periods can be accepted as any clue to the great tendencies of geological change. (18.357) Belief that ‘the great tendencies of geological change’ are actually moving the world towards a higher perfection for the generations yet unborn requires an act of faith: a simple act of observation tells a completely different story. In the book’s last pages, when the Lecturer has Mary read aloud seven paragraphs from the fifth volume of Modern Painters (1860), he is once again illustrating the difference between ‘government and co-operation,’ which are ‘the laws of life’ and ‘anarchy and competition,’ which are ‘the laws of death’ (18.359). This has been the work’s organizational antithesis. At first glance, we imagine that Ruskin is ordering us to perform an experiment, the results of which we
Catherine Robson 37
ourselves will be able to observe. ‘Take,’ we are told, ‘merely an ounce or two of the blackest slime of a beaten footpath, on a rainy day, near a manufacturing town. That slime we shall find in most cases composed of clay, (or brickdust, which is burnt clay), mixed with soot, a little sand, and water. All these elements are at helpless war with each other, and destroy reciprocally each other’s nature and power: competing and fighting for place at every tread of your foot; sand squeezing out clay, and clay squeezing out water, and soot meddling everywhere, and defiling the whole’ (18.359). So far we may follow in our imaginary laboratories. But as the passage proceeds, the time-frame of observation undergoes infinite expansion: Let us suppose that this ounce of mud is left in perfect rest, and that its elements gather together, like to like, so that their atoms may get into the closest relations possible. Let the clay begin. Ridding itself of all foreign substance, it gradually becomes a white earth, already very beautiful, and fit, with the help of congealing fire, to be made into the finest porcelain, and painted on, and be kept in kings’ palaces. But such artificial consistence is not its best. Leave it still quiet, to follow its own instinct of unity, and it becomes, not only white but clear; not only clear, but hard; not only clear and hard, but so set that it can deal with light in a wonderful way, and gather out of it the loveliest blue rays only, refusing the rest. We call it then a sapphire. (18.359) As the clay turns into a sapphire, so the sand ‘proceeds to grow clear and hard’ and transforms itself into an opal, the soot becomes a diamond, and the water crystallizes into a star of snow. The achievement of such perfection of form may be projected into the future here, but the condemnation of the present moment that has been such a besetting tendency of The Ethics of the Dust (and, indeed of all Ruskin’s writing from the 1860s onwards) makes it hard to imagine that such beauty can originate in the midst of the contemporary industrial pollution belched forth from that ‘manufacturing town’. The diamonds and sapphires, the flawless crystals that the Lecturer’s girls have examined in the preceding nine lectures, have been explicitly presented as the creations of a longlost past, the distant triumphs of a process of temporal change that has now foundered into decay, corruption and confusion. The Lecturer may maintain in his final words that ‘the seeming trouble,—the unquestioned degradation,—of the elements of the physical earth, must passively wait the appointed time of their repose,’ but the energies of the
38 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’
text as a whole affirm that the time of crystals, the time of ‘perfect peace,’ is securely in the past, not the future (18.360). The Ethics of the Dust, then, a work specifically organized around the encounter of young girls and an old man, not only insists upon an absolute split between these two parties, but also extends the terms of this division to radically opposed conceptions of past and present. The beginnings of time radiate the light and purity of the perfect crystal, while the corruption of the present day can only look back in wonderment to the glory of long ago: sin is not to be found in our origins but in the world’s contemporary maturity. Inasmuch as it unequivocally links girls with a perfect lost past, then, this text quite clearly follows the line I have discussed at greater length elsewhere.6 And yet the gemmological presentation of this familiar formula subtly alters the exact placement of its elements and demands further attention. For Ruskin and The Ethics of the Dust, the girl is the past and the crystal even as she is physically present. But what happens when the lovely young girl is close enough to touch? *** Up to now this consideration of Ruskin’s girls’ school book has evaded any real examination of the erotics of the text. Material for such a discussion is, however, not hard to find: nine-year-old Florrie, eleven-yearold Isabel, and twelve-year-old Lily may be diamonds and sapphires and crystals of quartz, but they are also living, breathing, squirming little girls. Not only teasing exchanges, but stage directions indicating physical contact between the girls and the Lecturer punctuate the text with regularity: on the very first page we read that ‘FLORRIE reappears, gives L. a kiss’; fourteen-year-old Kathleen is caught in the act of ‘stopping his mouth’; Isabel ‘climbs on his knee’ as she utters the words ‘Oh you naughty—naughty’ (18.292). The girls that Ruskin creates in The Ethics of the Dust are completely fascinated by the Lecturer, not only hanging on his every word, but often, in the case of the younger girls, hanging off his person too. Although it is always quite clear who is in control – a desire to supplicate, never to challenge, underlies every advance made by Ruskin’s fantasy children – the text presents us with girls who continually initiate moments of touching even as the uncertainty in their half-sentences displays their subjugation. Furthermore, while the Lecturer is largely unviewed himself, we witness him in the act of scrutinizing the girls’ physical features – ‘Nay, if you blush so, Kathleen, how can one help looking?’ and ‘You want to ask something, Florrie, by
Catherine Robson 39
the look of your eyes’ are but two of the many instances in which we see the pupils through the eyes of their male observer (18.222, 223). The pleasure of looking, and sometimes even of being touched, is also apparent in the letters Ruskin wrote from Winnington. As he tells his father, the girls’ dancing is ‘a beautiful thing to see’7 while the arrangement of the students at dinner, the sober shades of their dresses contrasting nicely with the white of the tablecloths, puts him in mind of certain beloved works of art: the scene is ‘like one of the pictures of a “marriage in Cana,”’ and ‘gives the kind of light and shade one sees in the pictures of the Venetians’.8 In letters to his mother, Ruskin conveys considerably more excitement, as the following description of a wild romp in the ‘new playroom’ reveals: [T]he little ones had determined to wait for me to have the first game with them in it. So we began with a grand game at cat and mouse— and then at dropping the handkerchief and then we had Irish quadrilles, which end with a wonderful dance in a labyrinth of rings, and as I was to have Lily for a partner, I put my coat on wrong side before, to look like an Irishman; Lily highly approved of this arrangement, and was buttoning it for me as far awry as she could at the back; but Maud and Isabelle wouldn’t have it awry, and buttoned it right, as fast as she put it wrong; so Lily at last pulled it off me altogether, and put it on herself over her frock, and tied her hair up in a hard knot, and then we had an Irish quadrille to purpose, till I had no more breath left.9 At other times, the mood is calmer as he tells her how much he enjoys sketching the girls (‘I told her she must not stir for ten minutes till I had drawn a curl of hair by chance astray’),10 or watching them as they listen in rapt attention to Charles Hallé’s piano performance of a variation of ‘Home, Sweet Home’: ‘It was beautiful too to see the girls’ faces round, the eyes all wet with feeling and the little coral mouths fixed into little half open gaps with utter intensity of feeling.’11 A few months later, in a work entitled The Cestus of Aglaia, he was to write of this vision again: The wet eyes, round-open, and the little scarlet upper lips, lifted, and drawn slightly together, in passionate glow of utter wonder, became picture-like,—porcelain-like,—in motionless joy, as the sweet multitude of low notes fell in their timely infinities like summer rain. Only La Robbia himself (nor even he, unless with tenderer use of colour
40 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’
than is usual in his work) could have rendered some image of that listening. (19.78–9) Ruskin may make frequent gestures in these passages towards aesthetic appreciation (the implied reference to Veronese, the direct one to Della Robbia, even to ‘coral’ and ‘porcelain’), but the erotic charge of these moments is nevertheless unmistakable. Endless gazing and coquettish conversations; kisses, laps and wriggling; the breathless excitement of the playroom; little fingers and buttons; most of all, perhaps, the wetness of those eyes and those ‘little scarlet upper lips,’ ‘halfopen gaps with utter intensity of feeling’ – all of these elements have enormous power to disturb, to alert our already highly attuned sensibilities to the unacceptable presence of the pervert. It is of course an open secret that Ruskin the famous Victorian sage is also Ruskin the infamous Victorian paedophile, but quotations like these make it all too naked. There is no evidence that Ruskin sexually abused little girls: the exact dynamics of his historical encounters with real girls – with Rose La Touche, with the pupils at Winnington, with girls in London, France, Italy, Switzerland, the Lake District – remain essentially unknowable. All that we can do at this distance is understand a little more clearly the lineaments of the fantasies which manifest themselves in Ruskin’s writings. Such an investigation reveals not only that Ruskin participates in a cultural myth about one sort of relationship between adult men and little girls, but also that the depictions of his desire for girls demonstrate a very particular form of erotic attraction. The world of soft and flexible moistness which I have summoned up in the last few pages would appear to confirm everybody’s worst fears about Ruskin’s delight in the loveliness of little girls. Such representations, however, are in the minority in his writing, in fact are hugely outnumbered by evocations of rock-like impenetrability and adamantine brilliance. I make this point not to mount a desperate rearguard defence of the great man’s reputation, nor to close down the discussion of desire in Ruskin’s writings about girls, but to extend it. As we shall see, this writer’s besetting habit of viewing the beloved as both a hard and an aesthetic object is not a defence against the erotic, but a component of it. Reversing the Pygmalion myth, Ruskin transforms the mutable girl into stone. Though its examples are particularly clear-cut, The Ethics of the Dust is by no means the only text in Ruskin’s œuvre that illustrates this tendency: both published works and private writings persistently relate girlish beauty to unyielding stone. Most notable are the depictions that ally the living, breathing form to the snowy marble of classical statuary.
Catherine Robson 41
As might be expected, the bodies in question are often naked, but the introduction to Rose La Touche’s older sister from the third volume of Praeterita forms a Ruskinian paean to stony loveliness which falls securely within the realm of well-dressed decorum: Emily was a perfectly sweet, serene, delicately-chiselled marble nymph of fourteen, softly dark-eyed, rightly tender and graceful in all she did and said. I never saw such a faculty for the arrangement of things beautifully, in any other human being. If she took up a handful of flowers, they fell out of her hand in wreathed jewellery of colour and form, as if they had been sown, and had blossomed, to live together so, and no otherwise. (35.526) Here two arresting conjunctions – the sculptor’s chisel on white marble and that soft, dark eye; static serenity and graceful movement – set the tone for the subsequent movements between artifice and nature in the celebration of the artless art of Emily’s flower-arranging: the ‘wreathed jewellery’ she creates (itself a combination of the organic and inorganic) paradoxically displays the blooms at their most natural, inasmuch as they appear to have simply grown into form. Similar combinations are created when Ruskin defines his favourite type of feminine beauty elsewhere in Praeterita: ‘I like oval faces, crystalline blonde, with straightish, at the utmost wavy, (or, in length, wreathed) hair, and the form elastic, and foot firm’ (35.231). Recognizing that these descriptions are characterized by complex interconnections of apparently oppositional terms serves a useful purpose when we turn to more problematic passages from the same pen. Consider, for example, the following words from The Cestus of Aglaia which record a moment from 1858: Ruskin saw a dark-haired Turin girl of around ten years old, ‘half-naked, bare-limbed to above the knees, and beautifully limbed … her little breasts, scarce dimpled yet,—white— marble-like—but, as wasted marble, thin with scorching and rains of Time’ (19:83). If one were analysing this sentence-fragment in isolation, it would seem plausible to argue that the relatively late introduction of ‘marble-like’ into the description functions as a defence against the troublingly erotic implications of the sight of naked flesh: the aestheticization of the vision, the transformation of the body into a marble statue, appears to allow Ruskin to move from the dangerous position of a man talking about a particular girl, to the safe haven of an art historian who is musing generally on the relative qualities of sculptors’ materials, and on Time. Arousing natural flesh, in this reading, would thus
42 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’
be exchanged for unarousing artistic stone. The fact, however, that the girl’s attractiveness elsewhere in Ruskin’s writing is so definitively intertwined with her identity with the most beautiful stones of the earth, and that the natural and the artificial are so frequently wreathed together, should make us suspicious of any simple antitheses here. Far from being a defence against arousal, imagining the girl’s naked body in rocklike terms is often a necessary condition of the erotic in Ruskin’s vision. One last example, drawn from an unpublished letter, brings together these same components in a markedly different stylistic form. In 1869 fifty-year-old Ruskin is writing from Italy to Joan Agnew, his twentytwo-year-old second cousin: Mammy di—the wee girlies must have looked very fit, in Verona in tummer time—me see by itty tat-tatues and me wish ice statues would come ive again—They haven’t got anything on ta speak of mammy di—dust a wee Bedgowny tied about waisty with a band of jewels. If me get oo nice band of boo beads, mammy, will oo let me see oo wear oos bedgowny ike at?—12 Such regressive baby-talk, in all its mock-Scottish tweeness, invokes a welter of responses: this is of course private correspondence, never intended for the scrutiny of eyes other than Joan’s, but it is startling, to say the least, to know that the author of some of the most challenging and beautiful passages of Victorian prose also wrote these sentences (and indeed many others like it in this period). More germane to the present discussion, however, is the recourse, once again, to ‘itty tat-tatues’ and bands of ‘jewels.’ This time the movement is properly Pygmalion-like, from the stone art object to the imagined naked body of the real girl (who, in this case, is actually a young woman), rather than vice versa, but the juxtaposition of elements remains the same. Ruskin’s favourite things – girls, precious stones, and frequently precious stones as art objects – are bound up into a single tantalizing form. In Ruskin’s particular case, the paedophile and the petrophile are one. *** To return to our starting point and Ruskin’s final work, Praeterita: the lovely girls who drop out of life before maturity also tend to be seen in some relation to the precious crystal. Indeed, when Ruskin first wrote of the tragedy of these extinguished lives in the autobiographical passages of Fors Clavigera, he called them so many ‘Lost Jewels’. In the letter bearing
Catherine Robson 43
this title, Ruskin holds forth in an unsettling amalgam of maudlin selfpity and strained comic bitterness on the problem of ‘the annual loss of its girl-wealth to the British nation’: I think the experience of most thoughtful persons will confirm me in saying that extremely good girls, (good children, broadly, but especially girls,) usually die young. The pathos of their deaths is constantly used in poetry and novels; but the power of the fiction rests, I suppose, on the fact that most persons of affectionate temper have lost their own May Queens or little Nells in their time. For my own part of grief, I have known a little Nell die, and a May Queen die, and a queen of May, and of December also, die;—all of them, in economists’ language, ‘as good as gold’, and in Christian language, ‘only a little lower than the angels, and crowned with glory and honour’. And I could count the like among my best-loved friends, with a rosary of tears. (29.424–25) It is Ruskin’s habit in Praeterita not only to feminize his childhood, but to use the death of young girls to represent the cessation of his development. Given that girls in this man’s imagination are frequently associated with jewels and rocks, it comes as no surprise to find that Ruskin’s young self is as stony as it is girlish: the lost jewels strung throughout the autobiography symbolize Ruskin’s own crystallized identity just as much as they commemorate Jessie, Rose, Charlotte, Sybilla and all the other Little Nells. One of the clearest images of the gemlike quality of Ruskin’s childhood appears in the description of his childhood’s Edenic garden: the hard-edged brilliance of this retrospectively constructed idyll finds apt representation in its sparkling fruit. Gooseberries, pears, white-currants and cherries are not tender, succulent consumable foods but rather transfigured jewels, ‘fresh green, soft amber, and rough-bristled crimson bending the spinous branches; clustered pearl and pendant ruby joyfully discoverable under the large leaves that looked like vine’ (35.36). Elsewhere, a ‘spring of crystal water’ (35.19) often accompanies the depiction of the childhood self. It should never be assumed, however, that Ruskin’s celebration of rushing waters reveals a fondness for spontaneous motion: as The Ethics of the Dust rejoices in what it calls the ‘active purity’ of the perfect jewel, so Praeterita’s rivers combine movement and stasis to form a ‘perpetual treasure of flowing diamond’ (35.66). Vital energy always crystallizes into tangible form, and fluidity is frozen into a single moment of beauty.
44 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’
Nowhere is this more apparent than in Ruskin’s description of the improvements he worked upon his Denmark Hill garden, ostensibly for the delight of his cousin Joan and Rose La Touche, then eighteen and seventeen years old respectively. As he explains in the penultimate paragraph of Praeterita, a feat of engineering enabled him to bring a sparkling river into his domain: I draw back to my own home, twenty years ago, permitted to thank heaven once more for the peace, and hope, and loveliness of it, and the Elysian walks with Joanie, and Paradisiacal with Rosie, under the peach-blossom branches by the little glittering stream which I had paved with crystal for them. I had built behind the highest cluster of laurels a reservoir, from which, on sunny afternoons, I could let a quite rippling film of water run for a couple of hours down behind the hayfield, where the grass in spring still grew fresh and deep … And the little stream had its falls, and pools, and imaginary lakes. Here and there it laid for itself lines of graceful sand; there and here it lost itself under beads of chalcedony … ‘Eden-land’ Rosie calls it sometimes in her letters. Whether its tiny river were of the waters of Abana, or Euphrates, or Thamesis, I know not, but they were sweeter to my thirst than the fountains of Trevi or Branda. (35.560–1) Ruskin’s conception of the vital yet circumscribed childhood he experienced in his other South London garden thus finds representation not only in his crystalline prose, but also in a rippling brook – no natural, uncontrollable torrent this, but a constructed and contained stream, which courses, under his control, over an artificial bed of quartz. In this instance, the child seen in relation to the garden she dubs ‘Eden-land’ is not the young Ruskin, but the young Rose, captured in all the poignant immediacy of the present tense, though she had been dead for many years when these lines were written. Here, as at so many points in the autobiography, the most vital being is a child in a jewel-like setting, a young girl who is present and lost at the same time. If we cast our minds back to another key image of waters in Praeterita, to that ‘brook shore of 1837’ at the close of volume I, we remember that Ruskin not only insisted that all significant development ceased before he attained maturity, but that the crystallized identity of childhood persisted as the true self throughout his life and into old age. Just as the perfect maidens who failed to live beyond their teens stand as so many examples of Ruskin’s essential, end-stopped being, so too does the continuing existence of this self find representation in a young girl. Once the childhood
Catherine Robson 45
years are past, Praeterita would much rather scrutinize a beloved landscape than the man who is perceiving it. However, on the very few occasions that the autobiography does allow brief sights of an adult Ruskin who is in a rare state of happiness or contentedness, Praeterita once again makes use of the ‘feminine simile’ it employed in its depiction of the child-self. When the forty-one-year-old man becomes the owner of a fourteenth-century missal, ‘no girl of seven years old with a new doll is prouder or happier’ (35.491). Perhaps the most fascinating of these moments occurs when Ruskin represents his own creative process: My own literary work … was always done as quietly and methodically as a piece of tapestry. I knew exactly what I had got to say, put the words firmly in their places like so many stitches, hemmed the edges of chapters round with what seemed to me graceful flourishes, touched them finally with my cunningest points of colour, and read the work to papa and mamma at breakfast the next morning, as a girl shows her sampler. (35.367–8) Here, on the sole occasion in Praeterita when the author presents himself as an author, the adult writing self is not only depicted as a child, but very specifically as a little girl, the competent and compliant daughter. Ruskin makes a thorough-going and heart-breaking investment in the myth of original girlhood. Although any dalliance with the paradigm obviously involves a wilful disregard for objective, logical ‘truth,’ Ruskin, in the last years of his writing life, attempts to hold together a truly impossible vision which refuses to countenance the unbridgeable distances between self and other, the living and the dead, and the bodies of the mature male and the immature female. The structure of The Ethics of the Dust at least allowed the writer to keep a safe distance between the constituent parts of his identity, but Praeterita’s attempt to conjoin the little girl and the old man, the past and the present, into a single figure is ultimately unbearable. In the final estimation, Ruskin’s extension of the Victorian fantasy of the gentleman’s lost girlhood into a fantasy of the essential girlishness of the true self proves not to be a source of sentimental solace, but a torment.
Notes 1 For more discussion of these lost girls, see pp. 50–60 below. 2 J. A. Froude, Thomas Carlyle: His Life in London, 2 vols (London: Longmans, Green, 1884), II.298.
46 The Stones of Childhood: Ruskin’s ‘Lost Jewels’ 3 See Paul Sawyer, Ruskin’s Poetic Argument: The Design of the Major Works (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1985). 4 The Winnington Letters: John Ruskin’s Correspondence with Margaret Alexis Bell and the Children at Winnington Hall, ed. Van Akin Burd (London: Allen & Unwin, 1969), pp. 438–40. 5 Ibid., p. 338. 6 In Catherine Robson, Men in Wonderland: The Lost Girlhood of the Victorian Gentleman (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2001). 7 Winnington Letters, p. 104. 8 Ibid., 104, 105. 9 Ibid., p. 500. 10 Ibid., p. 518. 11 Ibid., p. 527. 12 Letter to Joan Severn, 29 July, 1869. Ruskin Library, University of Lancaster.
3 The Foxglove and the Rose: Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood Lindsay Smith
Towards the beginning of Praeterita, published in twenty-eight parts between 1885 and 1889, Ruskin reflects on an instance of his extreme acuity of vision as a young child. He relates how in 1822, on the occasion of going to have his portrait painted at James Northcote’s studio, he questioned the artist about holes in his carpet (35.21). Ruskin sets this memory of the three-and-a-half year old child alongside his deprivation of having virtually no toys to play with and thus introduces a specific character of his exceptionalism. Such a denial of amusements, he believes, led not only to his contemplation of the visible world but to his routine scrutiny of it. As imaged by Northcote (p. 30) in white frock and blue sash, the boy is set in a landscape with two blue hills that Ruskin tells us are there as the result of his own request to the painter. Northcote’s painting encapsulates for Ruskin a certain artifice together with a brief period of self-conscious narcissism prior to the infamous dog-bite. Here in the portrait, landscape replaces the studio furnishings of Ruskin’s memory and the scampering dog in the foreground, traditionally in portraits of children a symbol of levity, could not be more unlike that inauspiciously named dog ‘Lion’ that will shortly afterwards ruin what Ruskin refers to as the ‘pretty’ mouth.1 We might read Ruskin’s rhetorical device of fixing the reader’s attention on the humble materiality of a carpet as a way of demystifying the genre of eighteenth-century portraiture by making familiar ‘old Mr. Northcote’ (28.273), as Ruskin calls him. After all, not only was Northcote Joshua Reynolds’s assistant but also his biographer. But equally, the singling out by Ruskin of an everyday domestic object, a carpet, as signalling the artifice of the studio environment, is significant in another sense since it introduces the different perspective of the child as prior to culture; the child as representative of a spontaneity lost, or attenuated in adulthood. 47
48 Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood
When Ruskin thinks about his childhood he thus tells the reader about his precocity with regard to visual matters. Ruskin’s memory of himself as a child sitting for this painting is one in which an almost hallucinatory relationship to vision constitutes also an undoing of its mystique. Yet, perhaps most crucially, his account of Northcote’s portrait marks out Ruskin as feminized; he dwells on the significance of the mouth here, recorded, for posterity, and thereafter spoiled by a dog-bite. He regards the image of himself in idealized terms as if situated prior to a fall from grace. In a general sense this fall represents a loss of the perceptual processes of childhood, what he famously refers to as the innocent eye, an eye that is undaunted by the possibility of error, an eye that can be irreverent or indeed frankly impertinent as in its assessment of Northcote’s carpet. But in a more specific one it involves a loss of, or a distance from, a fundamental desire to botanise that is in an important sense to see into the life of things. For Ruskin, essentially these are childish qualities, capacities lost on the educated adult, but he believes they are consummately developed in female children. In Ruskin’s aesthetic the innocence of the eyes belongs most specifically to a condition of girlhood. An aptitude for studying botanical specimens acquires a complex feminine association in Ruskin’s work such that the flowers of his narratives and Ruskin’s dissections of plants, that represent his profound impulse to scrutinize them, undergo a process of gendering. Big, as well as little, girls become intervolved with flowers. At its most overt level in Ruskin’s writing the connection of flower with girl child is played out in the symbolism of Rose La Touche’s name as it permeates his writing following their meeting in 1858. Yet, by the time of the composition of Praeterita, what has become in the case of Rose La Touche a familiar symbolic, emotional and intellectual correspondence between a flower and the loss of a girl/woman, has acquired a troubled history in Ruskin’s life. A connection of flower and girlhood that might seem to have begun with the child Rose, who bears that most beautiful of flower names, has a perplexing origin in Ruskin’s autobiographical account of his childhood in relationship to a different flower. That connection arises in a powerful conjunction of the death of his young cousin Jessie and the symbolically over-determined foxglove plant. From early in his life, Ruskin’s experience and understanding of childhood is linked with flowering plants (or so the narrative of Praeterita would have us believe). There exists an irrefutable connection for him between flowers and childhood as expressed, for example, in its most general terms, in his references to the influences of wild flowers ‘on childish and innocent life’ (19.374). But there also develops a very personal and idiosyncratic
Lindsay Smith 49
relationship between Ruskin’s childhood, as he articulates it, girlhood and flowers. For his own conditions of adversity and prosperity are signalled in the conjunction of flower with girl child. In the autobiography Ruskin records what appears to be a rather unremarkable incident of a childhood fever believed to have been caused by the dissection of foxgloves. More tellingly, Ruskin’s memory of this illness as brought on by an association with foxgloves, comes to him entangled with the death of his Scottish cousin Jessie (35.70–71). Ruskin’s rather ill-defined malady that shortly preceded Jessie’s death from hydrocephalus, his sense of the chronology of these events, is vital to the way in which memory works in Praeterita. It suggests larger patterns for the inter-relationships among recollections in Ruskin’s mind. In the manner of the involute, as earlier defined by Thomas De Quincey,2 the Jessie incident sets up a paradigm for understanding the ellipses and veiled dealings of Praeterita. In so doing, it provides a way of approaching difficult questions of the gendering of the child in Ruskin’s autobiographical narrative. Indeed, his construction of girlhood provides a shape for the larger ways in which connections form themselves in Ruskin’s aesthetic theory. The tragedy of Rose La Touche becomes in retrospect one that repeats those of other girls in the autobiography: Adèle Domecq, Charlotte Withers and Miss Wardell.3 In Ruskin’s story of his life we find a perplexed combination of the deaths of girls with flowering plants in a representation and a simultaneous displacement of a particular version of childhood. He keeps coming back to the figure of a child who, like Rose, is without agency. It is a child with whom Ruskin identifies and the threat to whose precarious safety is linked with a threat to his own. His relationship to such a girl is characterized not only by a failure to save her but also by the fact that she will be one whom, in memory, he has already failed to save. Botanising, in the form of dissecting flowers, becomes linked in complex ways in Praeterita with the appearance and disappearance of girl children. Botany was often seen to be a feminine science. Ruskin, aware of this fact and fond of referencing sources of scientific enquiry outside those of the mainstream, self-consciously registers this gendering of the discipline when he praises Dr Lindley’s Ladies’ Botany (1834), expressing the hope that a text intelligible to ladies may also be clear to him ‘their very humble servant’ (25.272).4 As scholars are aware, the rose, in particular, as connected with the girl child, has potent associations for the author of Praeterita as it did for Wordsworth in his ‘Lucy’ poems, and there exists for Ruskin in the myriad representative potentialities of the rose a happy coalescence of his deepest love and that most lovely of flowers. According to his classification of flowers, Ruskin’s wild rose could not
50 Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood
have been blessed with a more appropriate name, but the symbolism of that name gains in complexity following Rose’s premature death in 1875.5 By the time of the composition of Praeterita the rose has found a malign counterpart in the foxglove; the two flowers have become intervolved. In Praeterita, we can further pare down that feminized quality of sight as encapsulated in botanizing, as a renewed sense of the mystery of empirically observable phenomena. Ruskin exercised the impulse to botanize throughout his work but in relatively late texts such as The Queen of the Air (1869) and Proserpina (1875–86) we find a complex interest in botany resolving itself into intricate narratives about the lives of flowering plants. Such narratives have a spiritual emphasis, with plants existing, Ruskin writes, under conditions ‘representative’ of those which ‘induce adversity and prosperity in the kingdoms of men’ (25.294). In The Queen of the Air, what Ruskin calls ‘the breathing of spirit’, which is ‘continually creating its own shell of definite shape out of the wreck round it’, is ‘strongest’, he maintains, at the moment of a plant’s flowering, such that ‘the flower is the end or proper object of the seed, not the seed of the flower’ (19.357). Ruskin concludes, ‘the reason for seeds is that flowers may be; not the reason of flowers that seeds may be’ (19.357). Ruskin’s bold resolution of the chicken and the egg is instructive; he privileges the decorative bloom over the perpetuation of a species through its seeds. He is largely interested in reading and interpreting the most obviously visual metamorphosis of the flower as a manifestation of invisible spirit. But in the second chapter of Praeterita that ends with the familiar image of Herne Hill almond blossoms, Ruskin reflects on this principle of preferring flowers over fruit as justifying a larger autobiographical narrative whose seasonal change is marked out most intensely by its flowers: ‘the first joy of the year being its snowdrops, the second, and cardinal one, was in the almond blossom,— every other garden and woodland gladness following from that in an unbroken order of kindling flower and shadowy leaf’ (35.50). In keeping with The Queen of the Air and Proserpina that combine, in so many discursive forms, social and psychological issues, the tale of Ruskin’s childhood so artfully shaped by Praeterita, and the value it places on seeing with the eye of the child, has, as a psychic pivot, a correlation between flowers and the loss of girls. When, early in Praeterita, Ruskin documents the death of Jessie, of whom he was very fond, he alludes to her slow death from water on the brain as foreshadowed by his aunt’s dream, a portent of tragic events: Before her illness took its fatal form,—before, indeed, I believe it had at all declared itself—my aunt dreamed one of her foresight dreams,
Lindsay Smith 51
simple and plain enough for any one’s interpretation; that she was approaching the ford of a dark river, alone, when little Jessie came running up behind her, and passed her, and went through first. Then she passed through herself … And so it was, that Jessie immediately afterwards, sickened rapidly and died; and a few months, or it might be nearly a year afterwards, my aunt died of decline. (35.70) The memory of his aunt’s prophetic dream links in turn with Ruskin’s recollection of his own aforementioned feverish illness, which occurred a little while before Jessie’s hydrocephalus, and which he recalls as connected with the foxglove plant. The fever came on, he writes, ‘after a long walk in which I had been gathering quantities of foxgloves, and pulling them to pieces to examine their seeds; and there were hints about their having poisoned me, very absurd, but which extended the gathering awe from river eddies to foxglove dells’ (35.70). In the process of remembering it, there is a sense in which Ruskin regards his inexplicable fever (even while signalling the absurdity of such a suggestion) as the price paid for the violation (dissection) of a wild flower. The relationship between cause and effect in Ruskin’s memory clearly is not a simple one, but it emerges here in a structure that will repeat itself throughout the autobiography. It is a structure that brings together in various configurations the death, or loss of a girl, a flowering plant, and a threat to himself, with his own lack of agency in a girl’s fate. Bearing in mind this pattern, the links between the death of the nineyear-old Jessie from hydrocephalus, his own illness, and the foxglove flower are not as tenuous as first they might seem. Hydrocephalus is a disease of the brain, and not only was the poisonous purple foxglove used in the treatment of the disease, but also from the decades around 1800 death from hydrocephalus seems invariably to have been followed by dissection.6 Digitalis, a medicine prepared from the leaves of the foxglove, situates the plant within scientific practice,7 but a reference to the foxglove in Walter Scott’s Lady of the Lake (1810) anticipates the troubled symbolic status it will acquire for Ruskin: Foxglove and nightshade, side by side, Emblems of punishment and pride, Grouped their dark hues with every stain The weather-beaten crags retain. (Canto 1, xii.7–10) Here, Scott’s reference to the flower as an emblem of punishment makes vivid the association between foxglove and loss realized in Ruskin’s
52 Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood
autobiography. The concurrence between foxgloves and child death is established as having a powerful psychic status for Ruskin from the point of Jessie’s death. As a consequence, foxgloves become one of the most vilified of flowers. Or, we might say that, having studied plants in so much detail, and in the light of his intense investment in the Rose, when Ruskin comes to write Praeterita, he realizes, as if for the first time, the significance of the foxglove as a negatively emblematic flower that finds in the death of Jessie its negative origins. It is as if in recalling his childhood he sees in the oblique connection of the foxglove with Jessie’s end a prophetic conjunction, the existence of which had always been there, if he had only been alert to it. The coming together of foxglove and Jessie suggests larger patterns for the ways in which inter-relationships come to Ruskin’s mind, but especially for the way in which he reads his personal development through a narrative of girlhood. Of course, perhaps more than any other incident in his life, the death of Rose La Touche comes to inform in all sorts of complex ways Ruskin’s relationship with retrospection. And the prophetic nature of his aunt’s dream becomes all the more significant when interpreted in the context of Ruskin’s later loss of Rose. It is as if Ruskin cannot accept that there was not some equally prophetic sign of her impending death. In ‘The Nature of Gothic’ chapter of The Stones of Venice (1851–3) Ruskin had been drawn to the imperfection of the foxglove as a symbol of natural process, in which one may perceive, simultaneously, states of decay and nascence: ‘the foxglove blossom,—a third part bud, a third part past, a third part in full bloom,—is a type of the life of this world’, he writes (10.203). In Modern Painters IV (1856), in the chapter ‘Of Turnerian Light’, Ruskin had found the foxglove a problematic flower in his desire to prove that nature presents the best things in the brightest colours. For the ‘gay [poison]’ (6.68) did not confirm but rather confounded such a rule. Later, and most strikingly, in the ‘Athena in the Earth’ chapter of The Queen of the Air Ruskin singles out the foxglove as one of ‘a great tribe of plants separate from the rest’, which ‘give the impression, not so much as having been developed by change, as of being stamped with a character of their own, more or less serpentine or dragon-like’ (19.376). These draconidae, he writes: All agree in a tendency to decorate themselves by spots, and with bosses or swollen places in their leaves, as if they had been touched by poison. The spot of the Foxglove is especially strange, because it draws the colour out of the tissue all around it, as if it had been
Lindsay Smith 53
stung, and as if the central colour was really an inflamed spot, with paleness round. Then also they carry to its extreme the decoration by bulging or pouting the petal;—often beautifully used by other flowers in a minor degree, like the beating out of bosses in hollow silver, as in the kalmia, beating out apparently in each petal by the stamens instead of a hammer; or the borage, pouting inwards; but the snapdragons and calceolarias carry it to its extreme. (19.376) In this extract, Ruskin is seeking evidence of the poison of the plant as visible in its colour and markings. He is fascinated by the physical makeup of the flower. This meditation on the ‘spot’ as having the appearance of a ‘sting’ is remarkable not only in the vehemence of Ruskin’s reaction to the flower, and in the extreme length to which he goes to interpret it, but in the author’s attribution to the foxglove of a familiarly childish tendency to pout. Ruskin’s reference to ‘the bosses or swollen places’ in the leaves of foxgloves, which look ‘as if they had been touched by poison’, suggests an oblique connection to the swollen brow caused by hydrocephalus. But, equally, it implies an extreme antipathy to the sexual nature of these ‘swollen’ parts of the plant. Although such pestilent spirit of the draconidae may affect other flowers to differing degrees, ‘it never strongly affects the heaths’, Ruskin maintains, and ‘never once the roses’ (19.376). Even though it might have been in the retrospect of adulthood that Ruskin had knowledge of the medicinal application of foxglove to hydrocephalus, it becomes a potent connection which informs his study of plants and binds itself in his mind both with the premature loss of girls, and with a threat to himself. This is a key point throughout the autobiography, namely, that he cannot separate the premature loss of girls from a fear of a threat to himself, and from a sense of complicity in their fates. Praeterita is full of the loss of young girls. Jessie is the first, followed by Adèle Domecq, and differently by Charlotte Withers and Miss Wardell. In one important sense and through Jessie, flowering plants and girl children are forceful reminders of Ruskin’s own mortality. His aunt’s dream, ‘simple and plain enough for any one’s interpretation’ (35.70), as he describes it, is clearly about children predeceasing parents and about a lack of agency on the part of the subject to avert premature death, to save the child. Ruskin’s aunt does not prevent her daughter from passing her. She thus countenances, in the dream state, a negligence, which results in her child’s death. That death represents an unnatural order where children predecease parents. Yet, there is more than a touch of irony in Ruskin’s comment here; the dream proves far
54 Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood
from ‘simple and plain’ in its later incarnations. Ruskin is clearly affected by the apparent significance of his aunt’s dreams as related to him by his mother. It is not the first of her dreams to have such significance: a previous one, Ruskin notes, had prefigured the deaths of two more of her children. The impact of these earlier losses, together with that of a third child, make the death of Jessie, as a further repetition, much more tragic, and ripe for symbolic interpretation. As Ruskin relates the trauma, trying to account for the unexpected death of his cousin, he experiences, in memory, the inexplicability of it as a threat to himself in the form of the canker of the foxglove. His autobiographical narrative obliges its readers to connect girls with flowers. Ruskin’s inability, like that of his aunt, to prevent Jessie’s death returns in various ways, much as the circumstances of Thomas De Quincey’s sister Elizabeth’s death return to him. She too died of hydrocephalus, in 1792, and De Quincey believed she had contracted the illness while walking in a field from which the dew had not yet evaporated. For De Quincey, it was as if his sister’s swollen cranium had been caused by the direct absorption of moisture. As John Barrell has shown, De Quincey is haunted by the loss of his sister and by his belief that the disease would have meant the dissection or, what De Quincey refers to as, ‘the laying into ruins’ by physicians of her skull.8 The loss of Elizabeth in childhood returns to De Quincey entangled with other experiences, though it acquires the recognizable status of a repetition. In his autobiographical work, Suspiria de Profundis (1845), De Quincey coins the term ‘involute’ to account for the way in which ‘our deepest thoughts and feelings’ pass to us ‘through perplexed combination, of concrete objects … in compound experiences incapable of being disentangled’, rather than reaching us ‘directly’.9 Ruskin forges an autobiographical narrative that draws on a series of conglomerate forms corresponding with those of the involute. While Ruskin interprets his fever as an effect of dissecting foxgloves, there is the further oblique suggestion of an undeveloped connection between his destruction of the plant and the death of his cousin. Such a perplexed combination, to use De Quincey’s phrase, suggests a shape for the larger ways in which connections form themselves in Ruskin’s aesthetic, especially in the later works, and provides a way of newly thinking about his own story of childhood, and how that story is inseparable from an account of girlhood. It is popular to speak of the omissions in Praeterita, to stress its frequently guarded tone, and to suggest that the key to understanding Ruskin might be attempt to retrieve those things omitted. But equally, if
Lindsay Smith 55
not more interesting, are those processes by which, in the autobiography, Ruskin constructs memories of formative experiences. Such processes are compromised or made difficult by Ruskin in Praeterita by his claim that he will only remember or include those ‘outlines of scenes and thoughts’ that to his mind are ‘perhaps worthy of memory’.10 Such an admission of self-consciously controlled editing, which is at the same time marked paradoxically by hesitancy and deferral of intention, puts the reader in a difficult position with regard to what Ruskin includes and what he omits. Such admission raises the question as to whether or not we should take Ruskin at his word. Or rather, of what it would mean to do so in this context. Remembering the good times only would be a little like having dreams which were always wishfulfilments; but dreams do not comply so easily and neither does memory. Ruskin knows this well, hence the extremely provisional tenor of the subtitle of Praeterita. The Jessie/foxglove incident, however, offers a way of approaching Ruskin’s autobiographical narrative that is faithful to its hesitant nature, and that allows us to ask different questions. What we find in the conglomerate form of the foxglove and the death of a girl is the key to a representation and a simultaneous displacement of particular attachment to girlhood. If we approach the text in this way, we find in the place of that most conspicuous textual absence (Ruskin’s relationship with and six-year marriage to Effie Gray) an involuted presence of Effie. Retrospectively the threat to himself that Ruskin articulates in Praeterita, as mixed up with endangered girls, comes in the form of Effie Gray. For she too has been touched by the foxglove. On 21 June 1853, Ruskin, Effie, John Everett Millais and his brother, and Crawley, Ruskin’s new servant, set off on the Scottish visit during which Millais began the portrait of Ruskin at Glenfinlas while simultaneously beginning a close emotional association with his wife. Millais also started to paint Effie, sitting on rocks downstream from the place at which he posed Ruskin, but in place of jewels she wears wild flowers. In one portrait, she appears in a hat, sewing; in another, in which the figure is presented in greater close-up, she wears a rather subtle dogrose along with blue harebells at her neck. But her hair is garlanded with a stem of purple foxglove blossoms that curves around her head. What might at first appear a seemingly benign image, a portrait of contentment, is compromised by the appearance of the foxglove. The symbol of punishment worn by arguably the major, though absent, female protagonist of Praeterita (Effie Gray is present only in passing as the girl for whom he wrote the fairytale The King of the Golden River), is deeply troubling, the portrait originating as it does, in Scotland, a key point in the
56 Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood
break-up of the marriage. In thinking about his past life Ruskin would require little more than rudimentary training in symbolism in order to read this portrait as already foreshadowed in his childhood. We should recall that Scotland was the home of Jessie and the place where she died. That Millais paints Effie in 1853 with foxgloves in her hair must represent for Ruskin, if only in a moment of passing association, the trouble with foxgloves. Seen in retrospect, a foxglove could not be further from his wild rose. In sexual terms, the foxglove appears overly fecund, swollen in its potency/pregnancy. But it is also an ambiguous plant in terms of gendering – the draconidae are troubling because they are overtly masculine flowers yet feminine in their habit of temporarily engulfing insects. In The Queen of the Air, some flowers are corrupted by ‘serpent nature’ and take on serpentine qualities and in that text, as Sharon Aronofsky Weltman has written, ‘Ruskin details the serpent as a symbol of degeneration or devolution’.11 Encapsulated in this portrait is that prospective (and now already past) threat of draconidae to the rose. There reverberates throughout Praeterita a retrospective interpretation of the troubling significance of Ruskin’s dissection of foxgloves in Scotland as a child. But what happens to this association in thought is further indicative of the inseparability of girlhood, memory and flowering plants. The foxglove is deeply symbolic by the time of the autobiography, but its malignant, serpentine qualities cannot be thought or written outright, or acknowledged in an adult context so they are consigned to the realm of childhood or, more accurately, to that provisional realm of the recollection of childhood, to those ‘outlines of scenes and thoughts’ that might be ‘worthy of memory’. Ruskin uses this method to deal with other troubling instances in adulthood, consigning them to childhood as a mental space exempt from the status of determinacy he would find disturbing. The symbolism of the foxglove is part of what Dinah Birch in her discussion of Ruskin’s myth-making has termed an ‘obsessive inward language’.12 We know that as early as 1864 Ruskin began a process of writing to Rose, composing his works in an allegorical language with her readership in mind. Following Rose’s death in 1875 and in the writing of Praeterita he reads back his past relationships with little girls as a consequence of this later tragedy. In retrospect, Ruskin finds the death of Rose already writ large. Praeterita has as an anchor-point the loss, in childhood, of a girl child and the displaced implication of Ruskin in that death. The representation cannot but require a displacement, it seems, such is the vague dream-like connection which cannot be spoken for what it is. In this context, the difficulty for Ruskin of the later death of
Lindsay Smith 57
Rose la Touche derives not only from the loss of the beloved object but from the guilt attached to it in the form of a repetition of this earlier incident. The memory of the loss of Jessie returns to him bringing with it strategies acquired to effect its displacement. Ruskin implies that the reliability of his aunt’s prophetic dreams ought also to have been available to him in adulthood in some form, such it appears has been the predictability of the pattern of his loss. That pattern begins with the death of Jessie and is followed fairly closely in the autobiography by the appearance of three other young girls, two of whom die young. There is a suggestion that the deaths of these young women are a consequence of Ruskin’s failure to act, or to realize his potential to save them. They are Adèle Domecq, Charlotte Withers and Miss Wardell. Considering them in turn, I point out their intervolvement for Ruskin as involute. Adèle Domecq is a major disappointment in Ruskin’s life, and she comes to occupy, through later losses, a key place in his childhood development. Though she does not die, it’s as if, in the narrative of his recollection, the misplaced affection or worship of Adèle (she is never described as possessing the warmth of her sisters) results in the death of more worthy child subjects with whom he subsequently associates. Ruskin’s account of his first meeting at the age of fourteen with Adèle Clotilde Domecq, inserted in the midst of a description of her four sisters, is distinguished by its brevity and want of affection (35.178). In spite of the fact that we later learn, in the description of the dark looks of Miss Wardell, that Ruskin prefers oval faces and what he refers to as ‘crystalline blondes’, (35.231) the account of Adèle as a ‘graceful and oval-faced blonde’ (35.178) appears oddly codified beside the more individually affectionate descriptions of her sisters. Of course, in Ruskin’s memory Adèle would come to embody the prototypical qualities of idealised beauty as later realized in Rose La Touche, and Adèle’s place and persona in the story of Praeterita are inextricable from those of Rose. Ruskin’s relationship with Adèle is characterized by an extreme desire to please her in spite of her contempt or indifference towards him. From the first, his preference for one of her forenames over the other might be seen to distinguish Ruskin’s affection for her from that of her siblings. But the reasons he gives for favouring the name ‘Adèle’, notably, ‘because it rhymed to shell, spell, and knell’ (35.180), signal more profound and inscrutable interconnections. The rhyming relationship of these three evocative words reveals Ruskin’s mind as partial to the form of the involute, quite consciously so, here, it seems. An involute suggests complexity in the form of that which is ‘rolled or curled up spirally, an interwoven manifold’.13 De Quincey took the term originally from
58 Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood
conchology, and such an origin, describing the complex forms of shells, makes it all the more apt a term for articulating what for Ruskin has the resonance of an unconscious, or profoundly dreamlike association. Since the unhappy story of Ruskin’s unrequited love for Adèle is a familiar one it is unnecessary to rehearse it. Instead, we might consider two incidents, which demonstrate the ways in which memories or thoughts of his relationships with girls are passing as involutes for Ruskin in the recording of his life story. The first is that of the return of the Domecqs to England and Ruskin’s visit to them at the convent with his mother. The second concerns the Christmas visit of the Domecqs to Herne Hill, which extends to a torturous five weeks. Of the first occasion Ruskin writes: ‘And so began a second æra of that part of my life which is not “worthy of memory,” but only of the “Guarda e Passa”’ (35.228, italic original). Of the second he remarks: And day followed on day, and month to month, of complex absurdity, pain, error, wasted affection, and rewardless semi-virtue, which I am content to sweep out of the way of what better things I can recollect at this time, into the smallest possible size of dust heap, and wish the Dustman Oblivion good clearance of them. (35.229) The image of ‘Oblivion’ as dustman here, clearing up the refuge of the Adèle episode directly prefaces the introduction of Mr Wardell and his daughter. Miss Wardell, in turn, recalls Charlotte Withers whose father returns to the Ruskins’ neighbourhood on what he refers to as ‘some small vestige of carboniferous business’ (35.221). In the form of an involute, coal and dust come to Ruskin associated with Adèle Domecq, Charlotte Withers and Miss Wardell. The smallest possible dust heap in Ruskin’s memory of Adèle provides an involute for the wasted possibility he enjoyed with Charlotte. Charlotte Withers entered Ruskin’s life in the ‘Spring of 38’ for a week when she stayed with the Ruskins while her widowed father attended to his coal business: Ruskin introduces her into Praeterita with a botanical allusion: ‘Charlotte Withers was a fragile, fair, freckled, sensitive slip of a girl about sixteen; graceful in an unfinished and small wild-flower sort of way’ (35.221–22). Relating the deep affection that developed between them during the course of her stay Ruskin dwells on the pain of their parting and on his utter lack of agency in the situation: And, as I said, if my father and mother had chosen to keep her a month longer, we should have fallen quite melodiously and quietly
Lindsay Smith 59
in love; … I don’t suppose the idea ever occurred to them; Charlotte was not the kind of person they proposed for me. So Charlotte went away at the week’s end, when her father was ready for her. I walked with her to Camberwell Green, and we said good-bye, rather sorrowfully, at the corner of the New Road; and that possibility of meek happiness vanished for ever. (35.222) Their parting results indirectly in her premature death: ‘A little while afterwards’, Ruskin tells us, ‘her father “negotiated” a marriage for her with a well-to-do Newcastle trader, whom she took because she was bid. He treated her pretty much as one of his coal sacks, and in a year or two she died’ (35.222). Parental control results in tragic loss here, just as it does in the slightly later case of Miss Wardell, an account of whom Ruskin introduces as ‘the epitaph of one of the sweetest shadows of the field of romance’: Miss Wardell was everything that a girl should be … She herself had been brought up in a way closely resembling my own, in severe seclusion by devoted parents, at a suburban villa with a pretty garden, to skip, and gather flowers, in. The chief difference was that Miss Wardell had had excellent masters, and was now an extremely accomplished, intelligent, and faultless maid of seventeen; fragile and delicate to a degree enhancing her beauty with some solemnity of fear … I very heartily and reverently admired the pretty creature, and would fain have done, or said, anything I could to please her. Literally to please her, for that is, indeed, my hope with all girls[.] (35.230–31, italic original) After a second meeting with her at Herne Hill, Ruskin writes: my father and mother asking me seriously what I thought of her, and I explaining to them that though I saw all her beauty, and merit, and niceness, she yet was not my sort of girl,—the negotiations went no farther at that time, and a little while after, were ended for all time[.] (35. 232) Ruskin goes on to explain how in pursuit of a fine education her parents took her to Paris and ‘she fell into a nervous fever and faded away, with the light of death flickering clearer and clearer in her soft eyes, and never skipped in Hampstead garden more’ (35.232). He then proceeds to link the deaths of the two young women in a more general reflection
60 Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood
on his relationship to such loss: I cannot be sure of the date of either Miss Withers’ or Miss Wardell’s death … I had never myself seen Death, nor had any part in the grief or anxiety of a sick chamber … But I had been made to think of it; and in the deaths of the creatures whom I had seen joyful, the sense of deep pity, not sorrow for myself, but for them, began to mingle with all the thoughts, which, founded on the Homeric, Aeschylean, and Shakespearean tragedy, had now begun to modify the untried faith of childhood. The blue of the mountains became deep to me with the purple of mourning … and all the strength and framework of my mind, lurid, like the vaults of Roslyn, when weird fire gleamed on its pillars, foliage bound, and far in the depth of twilight, ‘blazed every rose-carved buttress fair’. (35.232–233) In one sense, the losses experienced by Ruskin in the early part of his autobiography, these pitiful deaths of young women, operate as a means by which he maintains the centre of his narrative. Not only do they compound Ruskin’s sense of his own lack of agency in the parental home, but they feminise him by attributing to him the status of the lover who must wait and who is acted on. These remembered incidents of his own powerlessness allow Ruskin vicariously to experience a legitimate feminine position of the lover who waits. But it is precisely the appearance of such examples in the form of the involute that encapsulates Ruskin’s psychic investment in particular formal structures which themselves signal the difficulty of representing, in narrative, such an investment. John Barrell puts this well in relation to De Quincey when he writes: If narrative could always repair our psychic wounds simply by telling the story of our sufferings in the way we would like them to be told, we would hardly need to tell them, or never the same one twice. But we cannot be sure what story it is that we ‘want’ told, and if we could be, narrative could never tell it ‘simply’.14 Such difficulty of ‘telling the story’ arises from the fact that the parts of agent, victim, and spectator constituted by narrative do not remain static but shift their positions. This mobility is characteristic of Praeterita, and of Ruskin’s attempts to realize psychic wounds by telling a particular story of suffering. It is perhaps for this reason that Effie is so absent in terms that we would expect to be able to locate her. She could
Lindsay Smith 61
not be made to occupy a simple position of agent or victim in Ruskin’s story of his life but she is inseparable from the complex pattern of recollection I am describing. The form of the involute helps us to read those shifting patterns within which work and life are intricately inscribed by Ruskin. Ruskin’s life remembered becomes such a vivid account of childhood not only because it is within a nineteenth-century literary tradition that placed a great premium on childhood as a state prior to civilising education, prior to reason. But also because the psychic wounds, which shaped his adulthood, promise to find a convincing story in childhood, as a realm that countenances the production of different versions of a story. Childhood is a legitimate phase in which to test out the feasibility and attractiveness of different stories, or more specifically a phase of development in which it is acceptable to maintain an imprecise hold on language. The foxglove and female child come together in Ruskin’s memory, oddly mixed at a formative time in his development. The admixture of foxglove and little girl is presented as resisting childish understanding at the time of its occurrence, just as the involute perplexes an adult consciousness. Flowers like shells conform to curled and rolled structures. One only has to think of Ruskin’s description in Proserpina of the poppy’s crumpled petals, which never manage to shake off their creases but bear evidence of their complex folding as they bloom, to find a perfect type of the way thoughts pass for Ruskin: Gather a green poppy bud, just when it shows the scarlet line at its side; break it open and unpack the poppy. The whole flower is there complete in size and colour,—its stamens full-grown, but all packed so closely that the fine silk of its petals is crushed into a million of shapeless wrinkles. When the flower opens, it seems a deliverance from torture: the two imprisoning green leaves are shaken to the ground; the aggrieved corolla smooths itself in the sun, and comforts itself as it can; but remains visibly crushed and hurt to the end of its days. (25.260) It is tempting to read the poppy as Ruskin himself. He regularly anthropomorphises flowers15 and certainly this extract provides an allegory of his troubled upbringing, but I’d rather read it, here, as an emblem of the ways in which thoughts and feelings come to Ruskin. That is to say, as a revelation of the indelibility of hidden, or unconscious, processes, not simply of conscious ones. Ruskin’s point is that there is a time in the stage of the poppy’s development when the crushed petals are invisible,
62 Ruskin’s Involute of Childhood
prior to what he calls ‘a deliverance from torture’, but they are crushed none the less, and the flower ‘remains visibly crushed and hurt to the end of its days’. To break open and unpack a green poppy, a premature flower, is to make visible the incipient nature of childhood, to make visible the full indelibility in later life of the infant state. And so the conjunction of child and flower comes to occupy a crucial symbolic space in the narrative strategy of Praeterita, not simply because memories of childhood are so central to autobiography as a genre, but because in their entanglement they provide for Ruskin a type of the complexity of memory. In the story Ruskin makes of his life, the object changes, if only in the sense that every object is an obscure object of desire. But the entanglement of the involute comes forth again and again in the autobiography. It provides for Ruskin a tantalising sense of the possibility of recapturing childish feelings while simultaneously signalling, afresh, his repeated loss of them. The involute encapsulates thoughts in outline that assume the rolled or curled structure of the shell. Unlike the vulnerable poppy, the involute adopts a form that refuses to display on its surface the complexity of its internal regions.
Notes 1 Ruskin relates the way in which the servant Thomas disobeyed ‘strict orders’ that Ruskin, a child of five, ‘was not to be allowed within stretch of the Newfoundland’s chain’. As a consequence, ‘the bitten side of the (then really pretty) mouth, was spoiled for evermore’ (35.67–8). 2 Thomas De Quincey, Suspiria de Profundis in The Collected Writings of Thomas De Quincey, ed. David Masson, 14 vols (Edinburgh: Black, 1889–90), I.39. 3 Catherine Robson makes good use of Kenneth Clark’s original observation about the persistence of girls in Praeterita. Her book explores the larger questions of the investment in little girls of middle-class Victorian gentlemen such as Ruskin, and their desire to re-locate in female children those feminine selves they have had to abandon in order to enter adulthood. See Men in Wonderland: The Lost Girlhood of the Victorian Gentleman (Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 2001), and Chapter 2, above, pp. 29–46. What interests me most about the premature deaths of girls in Ruskin’s narratives are the links of those deaths with flowering plants, and with what becomes more emphatically in his aesthetic classification a contest between a foxglove and a rose. In his first reference in Proserpina to foxgloves Ruskin writes: ‘Don’t confuse the beautiful consent of the cluster in these sprays of heath [the cistus and wild rose] with the legal strictness of a foxglove’ (25.253). 4 See Dinah Birch, Ruskin’s Myths (Oxford: Clarendon, 1988), in particular, the discussion of the hawthorn blossom, pp. 177–8. 5 Ruskin found many ways in which to weave complex associations with Rose La Touche’s name. For a discussion of Ruskin’s infantilization of Rose
Lindsay Smith 63
6
7
8
9 10
11
12 13 14 15
through the figure of St Ursula, see Lindsay Smith, ‘Infantia’, New Formations, 42 (2000), 85–98. See John Barrell, The Infection of Thomas De Quincey: A Psychopathology of Imperialism (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1991), esp. Chapter 2: ‘Hydrocephalus: The Death of Elizabeth’, 25–36. See Abraham Rees et al., The Cyclopaedia; or, Univeral Dictionary of Arts, Sciences, and Literature, 39 vols (London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme & Brown, 1819), article 18. There is a further pertinent connection with De Quincey here. Following Kate Wordsworth’s death, De Quincey in his grief-sticken state ‘continued to see her usually emerging out of “wild plants, such as tall ferns or the purple flowers of the foxglove”’, Barrell, The Infection of Thomas De Quincey, p. 40. De Quincey, Suspiria de Profundis, The Collected Writings of Thomas De Quincey, I.39. The sub-title of Praeterita, ‘Outlines of Scenes and Thoughts Perhaps Worthy of Memory in my Past Life’, is interesting not only for the way in which it defers the object of its study but also for its syntactical ambiguity. Those ‘thoughts perhaps worthy of memory’ to which the author alludes could be both ‘of’, in the sense of thoughts about Ruskin’s past life, or ‘of’ as implying ‘at the time of’ his past life. Sharon Aronofsky Weltman, ‘Myth and Gender in Ruskin’s Science’, Ruskin and the Dawn of the Modern, ed. Dinah Birch (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999), p. 170. Birch, Ruskin’s Myths, p. 4. Barrell, The Infection of Thomas De Quincey, p. 32. Ibid., p. 80. Dinah Birch discuses in detail Ruskin’s relationship to the poppy as Proserpina’s flower. See Ruskin’s Myths, pp. 181–4.
4 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice J.B. Bullen
Venice is one of the most written-about cities in the world. It has been constructed, deconstructed, represented, and mis-represented many times, but never more so than in the nineteenth century. The power of the nineteenth-century vision of Venice derived from the fact that it united the romantic and the scientific. It inherited from Byron an image of Venice imbued with magical decay and combined it with the scientific historicism and the empirical observation of the mid-nineteenth century. The two texts which most intensified the Venetian myth were Ruskin’s The Stones of Venice and Théophile Gautier’s Italia which appeared in 1851–3 and 1852 respectively, and which were written or begun in visits made between 1849 and 1852. Speaking of St Mark’s in particular, Henry James told the readers of Italian Hours (1909) that it is ‘surely the best-described building in the world. Open the Stones of Venice, open Théophile Gautier’s Italia, and you will see.’1 Ruskin, who was thirty-one, had been to Venice several times; Gautier, who was thirty-nine, was making his first visit. Both men had with them female companions and their response to Venice was coloured by the preexistent myths about Venice and by their relations with their respective women. In 1850 Gautier was the unofficial poet-laureate of French aestheticism. He was the flamboyant author of the notorious Mademoiselle de Maupin (1835), he was known as the eccentric poet who would have no truck with the explosive politics of the French state, he was the author of the libretto of a well-known opera Giselle (1841), but above all he had a huge reputation as a critic and reviewer of art, theatre, and ballet. In spite, however, of his public standing he was not well off, and one of his motives in going to Venice was to make money by sending back a series of letters about his travels to La Presse. His other and more urgent 64
J.B. Bullen 65
motive was to meet a woman, Marie Mattei. The history of Théophile Gautier’s private life, even by French standards, was chequered. His first partner, Eugenie Forte he had abandoned after the birth of their child in 1836. He finally left her in 1841, having fallen in love with Carlotta Grisi as she danced her way through the first performance of Giselle. He also admired the beauty of her cousin, Giulia, but it was Ernesta, Carlotta’s sister, who remained with him for two decades, and by whom Gautier had two more children. By 1844 he had become the lover of this passionate contralto, who offered him not only Italianate beauty but also domestic security. Judith was born in 1845; in 1849 his second daughter, Estelle, was born. Restless, romantic and faithless, in 1849 Gautier was swept off his feet by another Franco-Italian beauty, Marie Mattei. He met her in London when she was recovering from an unhappy marriage and was wandering rootlessly around Europe. Elegant, intelligent, and religious, she threw herself into a liaison with Gautier, and after many secretive meetings in Paris in that year the couple agreed to spend time together in Venice. She left Paris sometime before him, and went to stay with her father in Marseille. During the period of separation they exchanged many letters charged with sexual longing, frustration, and the anticipation of relief. ‘Tell me that when I come back,’ Marie wrote from Marseille, ‘that you will stay all night until morning so that you can sleep beside me! It is so good to be next to your body, the very idea troubles my mind and my vision. … In spite of myself I feel a desire, and inexplicable thirst to see you again. … all my life I have dreamed of love and its pleasures …’2 They met in Venice in August 1850. The period of hectic sensual abandon was accompanied by a series of vivid, vibrant, and powerful essays from Gautier. Henry James, who was full of admiration and praised Gautier’s ‘appetite’, said that his account of Venice was marked by its ‘unfaltering robustness of vision’, making him, in James’s eyes, ‘not only strong but enviable’.3 Gautier’s arrival in Venice was dramatic. He loved train journeys, and often volunteered to cover the opening of new lines in the press, but this was indeed an exceptional one. A storm was blowing hard as the engine pulled the carriages uncertainly across the newly opened Ponte della Libertà like a ‘hippogriff in a nightmare’.4 Venice was illuminated like a city in a Gothic novel ‘by Lewis or Ann Radcliffe, illustrated by Goya’, as Gautier put it.5 He was soon in the arms of Marie Mattei in the palazzo Vendramin-Calergi6 and was shortly to begin his account of the art, architecture, and the life of Venice suffused with its carnal intensity. He asked the readers of La Presse: ‘How can we express the rosy shades of the ducal palace that seems like living flesh; the snowy whiteness of
66 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
statues, drawing their contours in the blue of Veronese and Titian; the blushes of the Campanile caressed by the sun; the flashes of distant gold, the thousand aspects of the sea, sometimes mirror-clear, sometimes seething with sequins like a dancer’s dress?’7 ‘Who’, he continued, ‘will paint this vague, luminous atmosphere filled with sunshafts and vapours?’ The answer, for Gautier, was the masters of the Venetian Renaissance augmented with images from Canaletto. Only they could replicate the kaleidoscopic profusion of human life which filled the quays and canals – ‘the coming and going of gondolas, barges, argosils, galiots; the red or white sails … the sailors loading and unloading boats, the crates being carried, the barrels rolled, the motley strollers on the moles, Dalmatians, Greeks, Levantines and others, that Canaletto would indicate in a single stroke’.8 Marie remained with Gautier from 17 August to 4 September, and in Gautier’s mind her identity merged with that of the city and its artistic treasures. The palazzi and museums of Venice glowed with the naked flesh of paintings by Titian; ‘Le Musée Secret’ of their liaison glowed with the power of Marie’s body. Gautier confesses in this poem that he loves the naked women of Titian, but points out to the painter: Maître, ma gondole à Venise Berçait un corps digne de toi. [Master, my gondola in Venice Cradled a body worthy of you] Gautier offers to ‘paint’ this mistress in verse. He details her corporeal attractions but dwells with special delight on her pubic hair. Addressing that ‘sweet feminine beard,’ as he calls it, ‘which art always wishes to erase’, he implores it to, ‘take [his] verse like a kiss placed on your delicate and bristling silk’.9 As September approached Gautier was forced to part from the mistress and the place. ‘Some towns’, he said, ‘one leaves like a beloved mistress, one’s breast heaving, and tears in one’s eye’; in Gautier’s response the city and the mistress are charged with a similar erotic power and the legacy of the interval of passion with Marie is contained in the text of Italia. The departure from Venice of Théophile Gautier and Marie Mattei was preceded five months earlier by another departure from the same city – that of John Ruskin and Effie Gray. The Ruskins had spent the winter of 1849–50 in Venice while he collected material for The Stones of Venice, and as Gautier’s experience of the city and his record of that experience had been strongly coloured by his liaison with Marie, the
J.B. Bullen 67
language and structure of The Stones of Venice was as deeply affected by Ruskin’s relationship with his wife, Effie. Gautier’s affair with Marie predated (if only by a short while) his visit to Venice; Ruskin’s ‘affair’ with Venice began long before he met Effie Gray. When he first visited the city with his parents in 1835, Byron’s image of Venice as ‘a paradise now lost’10 was firmly implanted in his adolescent mind. He tried writing about the city in a Byronic manner,11 and his response to Venice, even at this early stage, was closely linked in his mind with erotic experience. In 1836 he fell in love with Adèle, the fifteen-year-old daughter of his father’s Spanish colleague, Pedro Domecq, who was visiting the Ruskins in London. When the Domecqs left, the young Ruskin immediately wrote Marcolini, a play set in Venice, full of violence and passion and centred around a heroine, Bianca de Carrara, whose love, says the eponymous hero, ‘is to my spirit as the breath to the body’ (2.479). The conventional conjunction of love and death is developed in a conversation between Marcolini and his servant Maso. When questioned as to why ‘place you love so near to death … ?’ Maso replies: ‘and if it be akin to death on the one hand … it is akin to folly on the other’ (2.477). In the light of subsequent developments in Ruskin’s life, Marcolini also makes a sinister, if less conventional, connection between marriage and death in Venice: Upon my marriage day, lady Upon my marriage day, My couch will be of clay, lady, Cold, cold clay. When the hymn is chaunting slow Through the abbey door, lady, I shall go, I shall go, With my feet before, lady. (2.493) Ruskin idealized Adèle Domecq and his experience with her was extremely painful. She was physically near and in every other way remote. Able to address him only in broken English, she was a girl who, as Ruskin himself put it, was ‘Spanish-born, Paris-bred, and Catholichearted’ (35.180). ‘It was a pity,’ said his mother, that he had not ‘seen enough of Adèle to cure the romance and fever of the passion’,12 but at this stage in his life, Ruskin knew romantic love, as Tim Hilton puts it, ‘only as a literary convention’.13 During a second visit of the Domecqs in 1838, Adèle rejected him and shortly after married a Spaniard. This threw Ruskin once again into
68 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
frustrated despair and the effect upon him was psychologically and physically damaging; he became depressed and, much to the consternation of his parents, began to spit blood. A convalescent holiday in 1841 took him back on a second visit to Venice where the passion for Adèle was displaced onto the city itself. ‘Thank God I am here!’ he wrote in his diary, ‘It is the Paradise of cities.’ The ‘folly’ of Marcolini now becomes a healing madness: ‘there is a moon enough to make half the sanities of the earth lunatic … I am happier than I have been these five years’ [i.e. from the date he met Adèle].14 For Byron Venice had been created by an ‘enchanter’: ‘I saw from out the wave her structures rise/As from the stroke of the enchanter’s wand’,15 but, for Ruskin, the creator is the enchanting but idealized woman. ‘The outlines of St Mark’s’, he wrote, ‘thrill me as if they had been traced by A[dèle]’s hand,’ adding: ‘This and Chamonui are my two bournes of earth; there might have been another but that has become all pain. Thank God I am here!’16 The ‘home’ that he failed to find with Adèle he found in Venice, and he thought that he had found Paradise. Though the ‘hand’ of the woman who seemed to have traced the lineaments of St Mark’s was lost to him for ever, Ruskin eventually sought and obtained the hand of another woman, Effie Gray, but not before he had extended and deepened his experience of the body of that other mistress, Venice. He returned there in 1845, but the experience was one of disillusion rather than fulfilment – Paradise had been lost. ‘I cannot draw here for the tears in my eyes,’ he wrote to his father. ‘Tyre,’ he added, echoing Byron, ‘was nothing to this. I was never so violently affected in all my life by anything not immediately relating to myself … Venice is lost to me.’17 His mood of 1841 had changed. Italy itself was no longer ‘a dream to be interpreted’, since, ‘all the romance of it is gone …’ 18 Romance had gone too, from Venice. The reconstruction of the city, the opening of the Ponte della Libertà, the building of the railway station, the introduction of gas light but above all the demolition of ancient buildings had maimed the Venetian body for ever. ‘The decay of the city of Venice’, Ruskin said, ‘is, in many respects, like that of an outwearied and aged human frame’ (10.36) and ‘there is no single spot east or west, up or down, where her spirit remains—the modern work has set its plague spot everywhere.’19 What had happened to Venice, the Paradise of his late adolescence, now the leperess of his manhood? Certainly it had changed materially during a brief period of prosperity in the 1840s, but historians agree that Ruskin exaggerated.20 The greater change had taken place in Ruskin himself, and in the first volume of Modern Painters (1843) he formulated
J.B. Bullen 69
the Venetian decline in a telling series of images. ‘Let the reader’, he urged, ‘restore Venice in his imagination to some resemblance of what she must have been before her fall.’ This ‘restoration’, however, is not material but moral and the symptom of that ‘fall’ is couched in language suggestive of her gaining sexual experience: ‘Let him sheet her walls with purple and scarlet’ he tells his reader, in order to ‘cleanse from their pollution those choked canals’ and to ‘withdraw from this scene … such sadness and stain as had been set upon it by the declining energies of more than half a century’ (3.213–4). Many critics have noticed that Ruskin follows in a tradition that feminizes and eroticizes Venice.21 In the mid seventeenth century, for example, James Howell wrote of how ‘this beauteous Maid had bin often attempted to be deflowrd, som have courted Her, som would have bribd Her, and divers wold have forcd Her, yet she still preserv’d her chastity entire.’22 In the eighteenth century the tradition was continued in the writing of Addison, of Mrs Piozzi, of William Beckford, of Goethe23 and into the nineteenth century with Wordsworth’s ‘maiden City, bright and free’.24 But it was Byron’s account of Venice which most affected Ruskin. ‘My Venice’, he said, ‘had been chiefly created by Byron’ (35.295), and it was Byron, who in the words of Childe Harold, claimed to have ‘lov’d her from [his] boyhood—she to [him]/Was a fair city of the heart.’25 ‘To Ruskin’, Richard Ellmann pointed out, ‘Venice is always she … and the gender is not merely a form of speech but an image to be enforced in detail.’26 Only Ellmann and Cosgrove have attempted to link Ruskin’s compulsive feminization of the city with some of the irrational elements in The Stones of Venice. Cosgrove notes how Ruskin wrote of Venice ‘with a passion which betrays more than an intellectual interest’ and how ‘the organic, pulsing, female nature of Venice communicated itself strongly to him’.27 Ellmann suggests a connection between the failure of Ruskin’s marriage and the writing of The Stones of Venice. He speaks of how Ruskin, in the course of his history, ‘dwells … on the virtues and defects of the feminine character’ and of his insistence on medieval Venice as virgin and Renaissance Venice as whore.28 Though Ruskin has not yet identified the Renaissance as the seducer of Venice, he has begun to construct a binary typological history for the city which involves a period of purity followed by a sudden decline from grace, and it was at this point he becomes involved with Effie Gray. Ruskin fell in love with Effie when she came to stay with the Ruskins in the spring of 1847: she was nineteen and he was twenty-eight. Like Adèle, she was connected to Ruskin through the parents. She was a
70 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
distant cousin, and the Ruskins and the Grays had long been known to each other. But in Effie’s case, Mrs Ruskin, seeing what might develop, attempted to thwart the liaison by lying to Ruskin about Effie’s age (she told Ruskin she was seventeen), by exaggerating to Effie Ruskin’s involvement with another woman, and by urging her husband to make Effie return earlier than planned to her parents in Perth. One of the greatest obstacles to Ruskin’s commitment to any other person, friend or lover, was the psychologically vice-like grip of his parents. They were to him what he called ‘visible powers of nature’ (28.350) and the triangle which the three established between them was adamantine in its strength. It was also one which explicitly excluded Effie before and after marriage. Ruskin’s persistent, infantile submissiveness to parental authority was quite extraordinary. ‘I never disobeyed my mother,’ (28.81) he told the readers of Fors Clavigera, and the daily letters from Italy in 1845 bear witness to his unbounded need for parental approval. After his marriage in 1848 their intrusion became even more obtrusive and was exacerbated on all sides by a correspondence between the Ruskin parents and the Gray parents on the state and nature of the relationship of their respective children. The tensions this created first came to a head early in July 1848 soon after their marriage in April, and it produced a response in Effie which Ruskin cited as one of the reasons for the marital breakdown. It happened in Salisbury, where Effie and Mrs Ruskin competed to minister to John who had caught a bad cold. Effie was openly critical of the mother’s behaviour and was sternly rebuked by Ruskin.29 Though Ruskin recognized the interference on his parents’ part he justified it in the most extraordinary terms. ‘Grant they had interfered,’ he wrote to Mr Gray a little later, ‘have they not every right? Having nourished and brought up their child with every care and thought and energy of their lives devoted to him—have they not the right … to be obeyed in such as they may think it wise to command?—have they not every right also to expect that his wife should aid her husband in this, as in every other duty—and to be borne with by both if sometimes differences of temper should render that duty less than a delight?’30 Ruskin wanted a wife who would not challenge the authority of the parental triangle: ‘I look’, he said, ‘for meekness and gentleness in a woman,’31 and he looked, too, for someone like his mother, who did not question a husband’s authority. The terms in which he described Effie’s insubordination, however, are interesting in that they anticipate his account of the rebellion of Venetian Renaissance culture against scriptural authority. Ruskin said of Effie: ‘I hope to see her outgrow with
J.B. Bullen 71
her girls frocks [sic]—that contemptible dread of interference and petulant resistance of authority which begins in pride—and is nourished in folly—and ends in pain.’32 And in The Stones of Venice he claimed that ‘this unhappy and childish pride in knowledge, then, was the first constituent element of the Renaissance mind, and it is enough, of itself, to have cast it into swift decline’ (11.73). In contrast to Effie, Ruskin himself was inclined to comply with parental authority. Much later, in 1851, Effie was still complaining that he saw her as someone who might undermine parental influence. His obedience was, she said, ‘sans bornes’33 and that Ruskin had told her that ‘he never intended as long as they live to consult [her] on any subject of importance as he owed it to them to follow their commands implicitly.’34 When Ruskin first became involved with Effie, however, this was still in the future and what is perhaps of greater importance to our understanding of his construction of femininity is the series of passionate letters written to her between November 1847 and February 1848 during the six-month period of their engagement. These letters suggest that, as in the case of Adèle, he was projecting onto the absent female desires and fears of his own, and out of that correspondence emerge two contradictory images of her. One centres on the notion of the child bride, ‘girlish’ and ‘youthful’ as he calls her,35 innocent, intelligent, and compliant; one who, under his direction would become entirely and unquestioningly absorbed in his own interests and who ‘would gradually be led to examine and to feel the relative beauty—propriety—or majesty’36 of architectural form and historical detail. Though he told her: ‘I must not make an idol of you’,37 he actually constructed an ideal female with her sexuality well under control. Frequently this took the form of long discussions of her sartorial appearance, and in these discussions Ruskin was concerned that she should not appear too obviously attractive to other men. One image must stand for many, but it is a powerful one. He imagines her with him at the opera in a situation where females felt themselves to be the specific object of male observation. ‘Fancy us’, he writes, ‘at the Opera again, together—We two—and you with a little—just a bud—of orange blossom in your hair—no more—And I shall see every one gazing at you—and think—“Yes— you may look as much as you please, but she is mine now, mine, all mine.”’38 In this scene Ruskin dresses Effie in the floral emblems of virginity – buds of white orange blossom – where she is the object of male gaze and envy, but entirely encapsulated within his intense possessive protectiveness. After the breakdown of his marriage Ruskin confessed: ‘I married her, thinking her so young and affectionate that
72 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
I might influence her as I chose, and make of her just such a wife as I wanted.’39 What he wanted was that Paradise which he had first thought he had found in Adèle and he now thought he had found in Effie. In the Venetian section of Childe Harold Byron wrote of such idealization in terms of an unreachable Paradise, but only after six years of marriage to Effie and two winters in Venice did Ruskin arrive at Byron’s maturer, more cynical view. Byron wrote: Of its own beauty is the mind diseased, And fevers into false creation:—where, Where are the forms the sculptor’s soul hath seized? In him alone. Can Nature shew so fair? Where are the charms and virtues which we dare Conceive in boyhood and pursue as men, The unreach’d Paradise of our despair.40 So what Ruskin demanded in Effie was not just a virgin bride, but a virgin wife resembling his mother with her ‘supernatural … purity of heart and conduct’ (35.128). As Richard Ellmann pointed out, ‘in Ruskin’s mind his mother had immaculately passed from maid to mother without ever becoming a wife’.41 That is, she was a wife who had never undergone the violation of the sexual act. Ellmann’s evidence for this lay in the memorial inscription which Ruskin attached to a well formerly named ‘Margaret’s Well’ in her honour. This spring or source had become ‘polluted’ – and one remembers the importance which Ruskin attached in the second volume of Modern Painters (1846) to ‘cleansing’ the ‘polluted’ canals of Venice – so in memory of his own biological spring or source he attached a new epitaph which read, ‘In memory of a maid’s life as pure, and a mother’s love as ceaseless’ (22.xxiv) When he was in Venice Margaret Ruskin wrote to her son ‘in a style almost of amatory tenderness, calling John her beloved and Heart’s treasure and a variety of other terms which’, Effie believed, ‘only a lover would do in addressing a Sonnet to his Mistress’,42 providing him with an erotic life devoid of the shame of sexuality. Dinah Birch points out how many friends Ruskin had amongst women, yet as she notes, they were ‘usually married’ and represented ‘no sexual threat’ to him.43 Consequently the fear of sexuality was displaced onto Effie, and in spite of Ruskin’s attempt to dispel that fear by infantilizing her, his premarital letters suggest that he also saw her as devouring, threatening and resented, a female whose sexuality would not be subject to his control. ‘You saucy—wicked—witching—malicious—merciless—mischief
J.B. Bullen 73
loving—torturing—martyrizing—unspeakably to be feared and fled— mountain nymph’, he called her.44 This and similar outbursts were occasioned by Effie’s male conquests in Perth and the fear that Ruskin, like them, might suffer the betrayal of her sexual rejection. The imagery is telling as he likens her power to a series of traps culminating in an allusion to that myth which Freud and others have subsequently linked with the male fear of castration—the myth of the Medusa and the clothing of Athena.45 ‘You are’, he said, ‘a very sufficient and entire man trap—you are a pitfall—a snare—an ignis fatuus—a beautiful destruction—a Medusa.’46 The potentially castrating power of Effie, however, was most disturbingly and graphically expressed in a letter of 15 December 1847 where Ruskin said: ‘I don’t know anything dreadful enough to liken you to’: You are like a sweet forest of pleasant glades and whispering branches— where people wander on and on in its playing shadows they know not how far—and when they come near the centre of it, it is all cold and impenetrable—and when they would fain turn, lo— they are hedged with briers and thorns and cannot escape, but all torn and bleeding—You are like a wrecker on a rocky coast—luring vessels to their fate—Every flower that you set in your hair—every smile that you bestow—nay—every gentle frown even—is a false light lighted on the misty coast of a merciless gulf—Once let the ships get fairly embayed and they are all to pieces in no time … You are like the bright soft—swelling—lovely fields of a high glacier covered with fresh morning snow—which is heavenly to the eye—and soft and winning on the foot—but beneath, there are winding clefts and dark places in its cold—cold ice—where men fall, and rise not again.47 Now, the virgin buds in her hair have been displaced by flowers which create a deceptive beauty and which, in turn, incites penetration and entry but is essentially cold and brings death and destruction to the male. It is hardly an auspicious beginning to a marriage where Ruskin contrasts the cold but winning appearance of his future wife with the dark places below where ‘men fall, and rise not again’. Yet the ‘cold but impenetrable’ temperament of Effie was endorsed even by her own parents. ‘She never had an endearing manner neither in words nor actions,’ her mother was forced to admit. Mr Ruskin actually admired her ‘coldness’ and her ‘superiority—to all the kissing and flattering nonsense of School Girls’,48 while during Effie’s exploitation of the affection of the
74 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
Austrian Paulizza in Venice, she herself confessed ‘I am a strange person and Charlotte [Ker] thinks I have a perfect heart of ice.’49 Speaking of the ‘character’ of the fallen Venice, Ruskin used terms which were strikingly similar. ‘Venice stands,’ he said, ‘like a masked statue; her coldness impenetrable … she calculated the glory of her conquests by their value … [and] at once broke her faith and betrayed her religion’ (9.24). In this sense Venice is like Athena, who as Dinah Birch points out, is for Ruskin, ‘an authoritative expression of the sexual ambivalence in his own work’,50 and one in Freud’s words who ‘is unapproachable and repels all sexual desires’.51 With his marriage to Effie in 1848, Ruskin was faced with a sexual crisis in contrast to whose proportions the affair with Adèle paled into insignificance. The first few months of that marriage were characterized by outer gaiety and inner stress and it must have become rapidly apparent to the pair that they were incompatible both in temperament and interests. They were rarely alone since the Ruskin parents persistently dogged their footsteps, but eventually in the winter of 1849–50 they went together to Venice. This gesture of independence was not welcome to Ruskin’s mother and father. John James, employing an extraordinary, but revealing metaphor, told his son that ‘the first news of your going … away now for 6 months struck like a Knell on your mother’s heart’, but, he added that the parents could ‘bear any privation’ for their son’s fame and happiness.52 During this visit to Venice, Ruskin familiarized himself with its architecture while Effie was left to get to know the Austrian officers and write lengthy letters home. Ruskin largely ignored his wife. His true labour of love was with the city, and as Tanner points out he ‘seems to have literally crawled and climbed over the whole ruined body’.53 The first volume opens with ‘The Quarry’ which, for all its empirical detail betrays signs of an emotional disturbance which will eventually engulf the whole enterprise. There is a persistent slippage from factual data into personification, and from personification into accusation – accusation charged with sexual innuendo. Venice, he says was historically the centre of a corruption which spread through the whole of Europe. Through her influence ‘mythologies [were] perverted into feeble sensualities’ producing ‘Gods without power, satyrs without rusticity, nymphs without innocence’ all of which gathered ‘into idiot groups upon the polluted canvas’ of western art (9.45). Venice, says Ruskin, ‘as she was once the most religious, was in her fall the most corrupt, of European states; and as she was in her strength the centre of the pure currents of Christian architecture, so she is in her decline the source of the Renaissance … and
J.B. Bullen 75
the dying city, magnificent in her dissipation, and graceful in her follies, obtained wider worship in her decrepitude than in her youth, and sank from the midst of her admirers into the grave’ (9.46–7). Effie’s need for ‘admirers’ in Perth had already caused disquiet in Ruskin before his marriage, but in Venice worse was to come. ‘We get plenty of admiration and attention,’ Effie wrote to her mother about herself and companion Charlotte Ker, ‘and the number of our admirers increases daily and they are extremely polite and don’t make love to us which is a comfort.’54 Inevitably one of them did fall in love with her – the Austrian, Charles Paulizza, First Lieutenant of Artillery. He was unmarried, thirty-eight years old, though, according to Effie, looked thirty and he was, she said, ‘the handsomest man in Venice’.55 He remained her almost constant companion throughout that first winter in Venice; he called regularly at the Ruskin residence, accompanied the couple to balls, to the opera and ballet, and on the frequent occasions when Ruskin was busy on his Venetian field-work would take trips to the islands with Effie. They spoke together not in English or Italian, but in what Ruskin called ‘that very disagreeable dialect’,56 German, thus excluding Ruskin who knew nothing of the language. From Paulizza Effie received some of the sexual attention which Ruskin failed to give her. With her ‘perfect heart of ice’, however, she knew, as she put it, that ‘men are really great fools’57 and on one occasion decided to put what she called Paulizza’s ‘devotion’ to her to practical test. Paulizza broke down in tears before her at least once,58 and when Effie was leaving Venice she feared that he might shoot himself.59 He died, possibly of a stroke, soon after. Effie’s attitude was deeply hypocritical. She defended herself by telling her mother that technically, at least, she had behaved honourably, but her liaison with Paulizza was so blatant that Ruskin accused her of coquetry,60 and the Ruskins’ close friend in Venice, Rawdon Brown, upbraided her with accusations in ‘the gravest colours’.61 Even her brother George in Scotland pointed out that she was compromising herself. Nevertheless, Ruskin did nothing to give Effie what she wanted; the attention which he should have given to his wife was bestowed upon Venice and its architecture, and that attention was obsessive. While Effie was with Paulizza, Ruskin, with ‘pain of frost-bitten finger and chilled throat … examined or drew window-sills in the wintry air’ so that even his gondoliers ‘thought it stupid to be tied to a post in the Grand Canal all day long’.62 It is as though the libidinal energy had been displaced from the body of his wife to the body of Venice; from the body which, as he put it, was ‘not formed to excite passion’ in him63 to
76 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
the body of Venetian ornament which he found sometimes ‘chaste’ and sometimes repellently sexually overcharged. ‘I mean,’ he said, that character of extravagance in the ornament itself which shows that it was addressed to jaded faculties; a violence and coarseness in curvature, a depth of shadow, a lusciousness in arrangement of line, evidently arising out of an incapability of feeling the true beauty of chaste form and restrained power. I do not know any character of design which may be more easily recognised at a glance than this over-lusciousness … We speak loosely and inaccurately of ‘overcharged’ ornament, with an obscure feeling that there is indeed something in visible Form which is correspondent to Intemperance in moral habits … (11.6). In the first volume of The Stones of Venice, emotional uncertainty is compensated for by historical fact, and most prominent amongst those facts is the date which Ruskin ascribes to the fall of the city. He wrote ‘I date the commencement of the Fall of Venice from the death of Carlo Zeno, 8th May 1418’ (9.21). This date punctuates all three volumes. He mentions it in connection with the history of the ‘central building of the world’ – the Ducal Palace – in the second volume, where he was pleased to note that ‘the first hammer’ was ‘lifted against the old [i.e. Gothic] palace in the very year, from which I have dated the visible commencement of the Fall of Venice’ (10.352.n). ‘That hammer stroke’, he said, ‘was the first act of the period properly called “the Renaissance”’, and employing the same word that his father had used to describe the effect of his journey upon his mother, said that it ‘was the knell of the architecture of Venice’ (10.352). Finally, he mentions it on the last page of the last volume when he says that immediately after the fall of Venice the city fell into a year of dissipated festivity. The historical details are ascribed to a number of sources, most prominently Pierre Daru’s Histoire de la République de Venise (1819), but, as Richard Ellmann points out, Daru gives Zeno’s death no such consequence. Ellmann goes on to say that ‘in view of [Ruskin’s] penchant for numerology’ the date ‘invites attention’, as indeed it does because it is an outstanding example of the way in which Ruskin creates a private link between historiography and autobiography. Ellmann explained that ‘if Ruskin had been born exactly four hundred years after this date, in 1818 rather than in 1819, the choice might seem related to his theatrical self-lacerations, as if to regret he had ever been born. But his terrors were for intercourse and conception rather than for birth’. ‘I venture to propose,’ Ellmann continues,
J.B. Bullen 77
‘that the date so carefully selected was, putatively, four hundred years to the day before his own conception – that act so impossible for him to meditate on with equanimity.’64 I venture to propose a further significance for this date, since it coincides almost exactly with a birthday – a ‘naissance’ – which would have struck a knell in Margaret Ruskin’s heart: Effie Gray was born on 7th May 1828. If Ruskin had reason to fear the primal scene of his own conception, he had equal reason to fear the memory of his own falling in love which, the records suggest, coincided with Effie’s nineteenth birthday on 7 May 1847.65 The Renaissance or rebirth was for Venice what the anniversary of Effie’s birth was for Ruskin – a ‘knell’ – and contrary to what Ellmann says, in 1850 the term Renaissance had largely negative associations for Ruskin’s readers. With the foundations of his work laid in 1849–50, Ruskin returned with Effie to Venice in the winter of 1851–2 to complete his book and his account of the birth, youth, and maturity of Venice. The second volume of The Stones of Venice opens with what even Tanner is prepared to call a ‘primal scene’.66 This, Ruskin says is a ‘frank enquiry into the true nature of that wild and solitary scene’ of the ‘birth of the city’ (10.9). As he places his reader amongst the visceral mud flats of the lagoon, and that ‘black desert of their shore [which] lies in its nakedness beneath the night, pathless, comfortless, infirm, lost in dark languor and fearful silence’ (10.13), he apologizes to his reader for the ‘pain’ (10.14) that ‘[watching] the slow settling of the slime of those turbid rivers into the polluted sea’ (10.14) might bring. Venice is born in the same slimy sexual ‘pollution’ into which she is eventually to sink before the watching eyes of her ‘admirers’. The subsequent life of the female Venice divides broadly into two periods. First ‘she rose a vestal from the sea’ but after ‘consummation’ (which as Ellmann pointed out nearly always has negative associations for Ruskin), ‘she became drunk with the wine of her fornication’ (10.177). The last volume of The Stones of Venice, entitled ‘The Fall’, traces the progressive decline of the mature Venice through ‘Pride’ and ‘Infidelity’ under the influence of the Renaissance, and it is in this last volume that the two periods of her existence are thrown into sharp relief one against the other. On the one hand pre-Renaissance Venice is the embodiment of chaste femininity, probably modelled upon the image of his mother and her ‘maid’s life as pure’; on the other hand Renaissance Venice is corrupt, sensual and given over to ‘pleasure’ – pleasure of the kind in which Effie so liberally indulged herself. In the chapter ‘The Grotesque Renaissance’, the idea of vestal purity centres on the piazza of Sta Maria Formosa and the legend of the Brides
78 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
of Venice. Up to the year 943 the day of the Purification of the Virgin on 2 February was celebrated in the piazza; it was also a day settled upon for a curious mass marriage by the Venetian nobility. As Ruskin describes it, this multiple marriage ceremony was not just a personal contract between two people, but was an affair celebrating family solidarity, ‘full not only of the families who that year beheld the alliance of their children … but of all the families of the state, who saw, in the day which brought happiness to others, the anniversary of their own’ (11.139). Though the custom of mass marriage fell into disuse, the anniversary fixed for the 2 February remained important and continued to be celebrated by a feast until 1379. Here we have another date which Ruskin loads with personal significance. It is no coincidence that the Purification of the Virgin on 2 February was the anniversary of the ‘pure’ marriage of Ruskin’s own parents, nor is it a coincidence that it was the 2 February that Ruskin later chose to propose marriage to Rose la Touche. At this point in The Stones of Venice Ruskin asks his reader to ‘fill his mind with the fair images of the ancient festival’ from the past, then instantly replaces them with an image from the Renaissance which still stands at Sta Maria Formosa. It is ‘a head, – huge, inhuman, and monstrous, – leering in bestial degradation, too foul to be either pictured or described, or to be beheld for more than an instant: yet let it be endured for that instant; for in that head is embodied the type of evil sprit to which Venice was abandoned in … her decline’(11.145). Ruskin refers here to a mask which occupies the place once dedicated to St Mary the Beautiful and he says ‘we should see and feel the full horror of it on this spot’ to experience the nature of the change which had come over Venice. That head which cannot ‘be beheld for more than an instant’ is, of course, a version of the Medusa: ‘Venga Medusa; sì lo farem di smalto’/ ‘Hasten Medusa, so shall we change him to adamant’.67 Ruskin immediately quotes from the Inferno and says that ‘the workman indeed saw, and … as it appalled him, will appal us also’ (11.169). Before his marriage to Effie, Ruskin had been appalled by the Medusa in her and had become sexually petrified. ‘You are a pitfall—a snare—an ignis fatuus—a beautiful destruction—a Medusa’,68 and it is not difficult to see how, in Ruskin’s mind, a contrast existed between the purity of his parents’ marriage and the potentially sexually polluting nature of his own.69 In the concluding movement of The Stones of Venice, the authority of Dante is supported by the book of Revelations, as Venice is depicted as city condemned for her libidinous dissipation. Once a ‘vestal that rose from the sea’, Venice becomes simultaneously the classical Medusa and
J.B. Bullen 79
St John’s ‘great whore that sitteth upon many waters’,70 in which sexual infidelity is linked directly to the social pleasures and masked balls of Venetian society. Speaking of the colour on Gothic building, Ruskin says that, ‘the bright hues of the early architecture of Venice were no sign of gaiety of heart’. On the contrary, she was granted these colours ‘not … in the fever of her festivity, but in the solemnity of her early and earnest religion’ (10.177). But after her fall she became ‘the revel of the earth, the masque of Italy; and therefore is she now desolate; but her glorious robe of gold and purple was given her when she first rose a vestal from the sea, not when she became drunk with the wine of her fornication’ (10.177, Ruskin’s emphasis). In the book of Revelations, the kings of the earth ‘have committed fornication’ with the whore, ‘and the inhabitants of the earth have been made drunk with the wine of her fornication.’71 Like that other female ‘with maid’s life as pure, and a mother’s love as ceaseless’ the whore of Revelations is also a mother, but she is an evil one. She is ‘the mother of harlots and abominations of the earth’72 and she is, therefore, ‘desolate and naked’. The Ruskin marriage was desolate and childless. There were, as Ruskin put it, certain ‘points in [Effie’s] character which caused me to regard with excessive pain any idea of having children by her’.73 Those ‘points’ were almost certainly connected with Effie’s personal irresponsibility. From the moment she arrived in Venice she took delight in masques and balls which, for Ruskin, were redolent with associations of sexual titillation and dissipation. Byron, whom Ruskin quotes, had a positive view of the ancient, festive tradition of Venetian masquing. ‘Nor yet forget,’ he wrote in Childe Harold, ‘how Venice once was dear,/The pleasant place of all festivity/The revel of the earth, the masque of Italy.’74 But notions that may have been pleasant for Byron were painful for Ruskin, who, like Othello, had been warned that ‘In Venice they do let God see the pranks/They dare not show their husbands.’75 Iago’s advice to Othello, as Ruskin well knew, derived from the long-standing myth of Venice as a site of unbridled sexual gratification. ‘Tis too well known, ther is no place where ther is lesse Religion from the girdle downward,’ said James Howell in 1651,76 and generations of men of all ranks before and after Boswell in 1765 went to Venice, as Boswell put it, ‘stirred by the brilliant stories [they] had heard of Venetian courtesans’.77 But the idea had been reinforced in Ruskin as recently as 1849 when he was made, as he put it, ‘bitterly melancholy’ by reading in the letters of Lady Wortley Montague of her thoughtless pleasures in this ‘centre of pleasure’ (9. xxiv). Effie confirmed Ruskin’s worst fears in this respect. At Venice, unlike London, she said, ‘one enjoys the greatest freedom of action of any
80 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
place I ever saw.’78 She was, she said, ‘the Belle at all the Balls … and the men adore me, one and all … I have sufficient means and Liberty to do whatever I choose.’79 Venice, for her, was one long carnival. ‘Venice’, she said, ‘is so tempting … at night that it is hardly possible not to be imprudent.’80 All her talk is of social engagements, clothing, and men. She was a lively figure at these gatherings because she liked people, mastered languages readily, and mixed easily. Ruskin did none of these things. He hated society, he hated the inhabitants of Venice, whom he found ‘so filthy that he [could not] bear to touch them or be amongst them’,81 and he fell into a melancholy misanthropy.82 ‘John never speaks to any body or troubles to speak at all unless it happens to amuse him at the moment,’83 Effie wrote to her mother. At the opera and ballet he would often sleep, and when invited to balls would find his way to the library to read. ‘He says he has no friends and that he never will have any and that the world and every body in it are all going wrong but that he is right, and then he sits and writes such accounts to Mr R—of the state of society both here in Venice and in London and thinks himself an excellent judge, although he knows no one and never stirs out.’84 Though he probably felt that Effie had not been sexually unfaithful to him, she had, nevertheless, betrayed the values which he so strongly shared with his parents and which he expressed in those long letters home. ‘I rejoice to see’, Ruskin’s father said to him on his first winter in Venice, ‘your sense of your more important station and calling and distinction as a Writer saves you from the Entanglements and poor attractions and frivolities of Foreign society—and that by God’s goodness you are likely to move unscathed through Carnivals and all manners of Dissipation.’85 For the Ruskin family, such frivolities were intimately connected with sins of the flesh, but Ruskin wrote back assuring his parents that ‘Operas, drawing rooms and living creatures have become alike nuisances to me’ and that they were ‘no entanglement at all’.86 This same ‘unscrupulous and insatiable pursuit of pleasure’ (11.134–5) features prominently in the final sections of The Stones of Venice. Here the grotesque mask and the social masque merge in the figure of the Medusa. He claimed that it was ‘painful to dwell’ on work which represented the ‘consummation’ of the ‘obscene’ spirit of Renaissance Venice and that he was unable to ‘pollute’ the volume with illustrations of this most debased grotesque form. As the volume draws to a close the frivolities of society, past and present, merge into a sickening whirl of sexual degradation. In Ruskin’s account, this dissipated carnival began chronologically with the fall of Venice when ‘sifesteggio dalla citta uno anno intero’/‘the city celebrated for an entire year’ (11.195) and it found its
J.B. Bullen 81
most recent expression in what he called ‘dwarfish caricature, the most disgusting types of manhood and womanhood which can be found amidst the dissipation of the modern drawing-room’ (11.162). Throughout Venice it manifests itself in decorative detail of ‘every species of obscene conception and abominable detail’ (11.162). Venice, he said, surpassed ‘the cities of Christendom’ in dissipation as ‘the youth of Europe’ (his wife prominent amongst them) ‘assembled in the halls of her luxury, to learn from her the arts of delight’(11.195). The last paragraph proper of The Stones of Venice, written on the eve of the final ruin of Ruskin’s marriage, places the responsibility for the fall of Venice firmly upon the curse of sexuality. The context is Biblical but it revives once again the image of the polluted canals of Venice. ‘It is as needless as it is painful to trace the steps of her final ruin,’ he wrote. ‘That ancient curse was upon her, the curse of the Cities of the Plain … By the inner burning of her own passions, as fatal as the fiery rain of Gomorrah, she was consumed from her place among the nations; and her ashes are choking the channels of the dead, salt sea.’ (11.195). Effie Gray was soon removed from her place in Ruskin’s life, and as he finished with her so he finished The Stones of Venice. What he had hoped might be an ideal Paradise had become dust and ashes and Venice, like Effie herself, had become for him, in Byron’s words, the ‘Paradise of our despair’. Gautier’s Italia was published in book form in 1852, and the last volume of The Stones of Venice appeared in 1853. Though the presence of Marie Mattei in Gautier’s is imprinted upon the text, Gautier nowhere personifies Venice in Ruskin’s manner. Ruskin was writing a didactic and eccentric history based upon his scrupulous inspection of Venetian architecture; Gautier, in his way no less observant, was creating an impressionistic kaleidoscope of Venetian life which involved art and architecture. Ruskin’s Venice is mainly an unpopulated city; Gautier’s throbs with human life. The influence of both books derived from the way in which Venice emerges greater than the sum of its parts, mythologized, humanized, and reified in powerfully emotional terms. The female is important to both texts, but as Effie Gray was unable to compete with the maternal power of Mrs Ruskin, so Marie Mattei was equally frustrated by the power of the mother of Gautier’s children, Ernesta Grisi. Within three years of meeting him, Marie realized that there was no real way forward for Gautier and her. So as Effie threw herself upon the bosom of John Everett Millais, so Marie went to Rome and threw herself upon Pius IX and onto the bosom of the Roman Catholic Church.
82 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice
Notes 1 Henry James, Italian Hours (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1992), p. 14. 2 ‘Dis-moi qu’à mon retour tu resteras une nuit tout entière jusqu’au matin pour te faire dormir auprès de moi! C’est si bon d’être auprès de ton corps, l’idée seule trouble ma vue et mes pensées. … C’est malgré moi que je sens un désir, une soif de te revoir inexprimable. … toute ma vie j’avais rêvé l’amour et ses délices … ’ Marie Mattei, 28 Jan. 1850, Lettres à Théophile Gautier et à Louis de Cormenin, ed. Eldon Kaye (Geneva: Librairie Droz, 1972), p. 67. 3 Henry James, ‘Review of Théatre de Théophile Gautier: Mystères, Comédies, et Ballets’, quoted in Italian Hours (1992), p. xix. 4 Théophile Gautier, Italia (Paris: Hachette, 1852), p. 74. 5 Ibid., p. 77. 6 Ironically the palazzo in which the erstwhile lover of Judith Gautier, Richard Wagner, died in 1883. 7 ‘Comment exprimer ces tons roses du palais ducal, qui semble vivre comme de la chair, ces blancheurs neigueuses des statues, dessinant leur galbe dans l’azure de Véronèse et de Titien, ces rougeurs du Campanile que caresse le soleil, ces éclairs d’une dorure lointaine, ces mille aspects de la mer, tantôt claire comme un miroir, tantôt fourmillante de paillettes comme la jupe d’une danseuse? Qui peindra cette atmosphère vague, lumineuse, pleine de rayons et de vapeurs?’ Gautier (1852), p. 86. 8 ‘Ce va-et-vient de gondoles, de barques, d’argosils, de galiottes; ces voiles rouges ou blanches … les matelots qui chargent et déchargent les barques, les caisses qu’on porte, les tonneaux qu’on roule, les promeneurs bigarrés du môle, Dalmates, Grecs, Levantins et autres, que Canaletto indiquerait d’une seule touche.’ Ibid., p. 86. 9 O douce barbe féminine, Que l’Art toujours voulut raser, Sur ta soie annelée et fine, Reçoit mes vers comme un baiser! Théophile Gautier, Emaux et Camées, ed. Madeleine Cottin (Paris: Minard, 1968), p. 212. 10 The words are those of Robert Gleckner in his Byron and the Ruins of Paradise (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins, 1967), p. 310. 11 Ruskin says that he ‘knew … Byron pretty well all through by 1834’ [i.e. by the age of fifteen] (35.142). 12 Quoted in Tim Hilton, John Ruskin: The Early Years (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1985), p. 52. 13 Ibid., p. 36. 14 The Diaries of John Ruskin, ed. Joan Evans and John Howard Whitehouse, 3 vols (Oxford: Clarendon, 1956–9), 1.183. 15 Byron, ‘Childe Harold,’ Canto 4, ll.3–4. 16 Ruskin, Diaries, 1.183. 17 Ruskin in Italy: Letters to his Parents 1845, ed. Harold Shapiro (Oxford: Clarendon, 1972), pp. 200–1. 18 Ibid., p. 143. 19 Ibid., p. 201. 20 See Clegg, p. 57.
J.B. Bullen 83 21 Jeanne Clegg, Ruskin and Venice (London: Junction, 1981), p.110; Denis Cosgrove, ‘The Myth and the Stones of Venice: an Historical Geography of a Symbolic Landscape’, Journal of Historical Geography, 8 (1982), 145–69; Tony Tanner, Venice Desired (Oxford: Blackwell, 1992). 22 James Howell, SPQV: A Survey of the Signorie of Venice … etc. (London, 1651), pp. 1–2. 23 For the myth of Venice in travel literature see Milton Wilson, ‘Travellers’ Venice: Some Images for Byron and Shelley,’ University of Toronto Quarterly, 43 (1974), 93–120. Goethe’s wonderfully indecent remarks about Venice occur in his Venetian Epigrams (1795). 24 William Wordsworth, ‘On the Extinction of the Venetian Republic,’ in The Poetical Works of William Wordsworth, ed. Thomas Hutchinson, new ed. revised by Ernest de Selincourt (Oxford and London: Oxford University Press, 1969), p. 242, l.5. 25 Lord Byron, ‘Childe Harold’s Pilgrimage’, in The Complete Poetical Works, ed. Jerome J. McGann (Oxford: Clarendon, 1980), Canto 4, ll.154–5. 26 Richard Ellmann, Golden Codgers: Biographical Speculations (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1973), p. 46. 27 Cosgrove, p. 164. 28 Ellmann, p. 46. 29 ‘On one occasion,’ Ruskin told his solicitor after the separation, ‘she having been rude to my mother, I rebuked her firmly; and she never forgave either my mother or me.’ J. Howard Whitehouse, Vindication of Ruskin (London: Allen, 1950), p. 15. 30 Mary Lutyens, The Ruskins and the Grays (London: Murray, 1972), p. 234. 31 Ibid. 32 Ibid. 33 Effie in Venice: Unpublished Letters of Mrs John Ruskin Written from Venice between 1849 and 1852, ed. Mary Lutyens (London: Murray, 1965), p. 202. 34 Ibid., p. 264. 35 Sir William James, The Order of Release (London: Murray, 1948), pp. 62 and 63. 36 Ibid., p. 60. 37 Ibid., pp. 53–4. 38 Ibid., p. 61. 39 Whitehouse, p. 15. 40 Byron, ‘Childe Harold,’ Canto 4, ll. 1090–6. 41 Ellmann, p. 47. 42 Effie in Venice, pp. 265–6. 43 See below, p. 109. 44 James, p. 58. 45 Most notably in his paper ‘Medusa’s Head’ (1922), where he speaks of Athena, who, carrying the ‘symbol of horror’ on her dress, ‘becomes a woman who is unapproachable and repels all sexual desires’. Sigmund Freud, Collected Papers, ed. James Strachey (London: Hogarth, 1950), pp. 105–6. 46 James, p. 67. 47 Ibid., p. 68. 48 Effie in Venice, p. 67 and 68. 49 Ibid., p. 149. 50 See below, p. 115.
84 Ruskin, Gautier, and the Feminization of Venice 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69
70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82
See n. 43. Quoted Clegg, p. 74. Tanner, p. 68. Effie in Venice, p. 98. Ibid., p. 105. Ibid., p. 147n. Ibid., p. 99. Ibid., p. 154. Ibid., p. 149. Ibid. Ibid., p. 136n. Clegg, p. 79. Whitehouse, p. 15. Ellmann, p. 48. His first romantic overture to her took the form of a poem, ‘For a Birthday in May’, presented to her in 1847. See Whitehouse, p. 27. Tanner, p. 92. Dante, Inferno, 9,53. Ruskin quotes the line at 11.169. James, p. 67. The Medusa continued to haunt Ruskin, and a dream which he had in 1869 relates the myth explicitly to the horror of the female. He wrote in his diary: ‘Got restless—taste in mouth—had the most horrible serpent dream I ever had yet in my life. The deadliest came out into the room under my door. It rose up like a Cobra—with horrible round eyes and had a woman’s or at least Medusa’s, breasts. It was coming after me, out of one room, like our back drawing room at Herne Hill, into another; but I got some pieces of marble off a table and threw at it, and that cowed it and it went back; but another small one fastened on my neck like a leech.’ Diaries, 2.685; entry for 1 November, 1869. For the further significance of serpent imagery in Ruskin’s writing see Marc A. Simpson, ‘The Dream of the Dragon: Ruskin’s Serpent Imagery’, in The Ruskin Polygon: Essays on the Imagination of John Ruskin, ed. John Dixon Hunt and Faith M. Holland (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1982), pp. 21–43. Rev. 17:1. Rev. 17:2. Rev. 17:5. Whitehouse, p. 12. Byron, ‘Childe Harold,’ Canto 4, ll. 25–7. Othello, iii, 3, 206–7. Howell, p. 8. Quoted Clegg, p. 19. Effie in Venice, p. 150. Ibid., p. 264–5. Ibid., p. 291. Ibid., p. 84. Another dream which Ruskin had in 1869 plays out a phallic strife between man and wife in the context of dancing. In his diary Ruskin dreamt of watching a Punch and Judy show, and was ‘startled by him knocking down his wife without dancing with her first … and then I saw it was an Italian
J.B. Bullen 85
83 84 85 86
Punch, modernized, and that there was no idea of humour in it, but all the interest was in a mad struggle of the wife for the stick, and in her being afterwards beaten slowly, crying out, and with a stuffed body, which seemed to bruise under the blows, so as to make the whole as horrible and nasty as possible.’ Diaries, 2.684; entry for 24 October, 1869. Effie in Venice, p. 260. Ibid., p. 266. Quoted Clegg, p. 79. Effie in Venice, p. 146.
5 The Feminist Origins of ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ Linda H. Peterson
On 6 and 14 December 1864, Ruskin gave two lectures in Rusholme, near Manchester, one to raise money for a library of the Rusholme Institute, another to establish schools in an impoverished section of the city. Published in 1865 under the title Sesame and Lilies, ‘Of Kings’ Treasuries’ and ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ provoked much debate, in Ruskin’s day as in ours, about women’s education and employment. As Elizabeth Helsinger has noted, most Victorian reviewers perceived the lectures to be ‘an angry attack on traditional values’. The conservative Saturday Review called Ruskin’s words ‘the shriekings of a revivalist’, while Blackwood’s Magazine dismissed the lectures as a ‘clever farrago of unmitigated abuse to the one sex, and of sugared abuse and railing flattery … to the other’, full of ‘extravagant charges and impossible remedies’. Only radical periodicals like the Westminster Review attended seriously to Ruskin’s goals, arguing that ‘Utopianism is at times good for us, if only to lift us out of our usual atmosphere of prudence and pence.’1 By far the most favourable notice appeared in the Victoria Magazine, a journal written, produced, and published by leaders of the English women’s movement. In a two-part series, ‘Mr. Ruskin on Books and Women’, the Victoria reviewer admiringly set forth the arguments of Sesame and Lilies, ‘letting the book speak for itself, as much as possible, before we intrude any observations of our own, or notice the points … where we feel ourselves slightly at issue with our teacher’.2 Why was Sesame and Lilies so well-received by progressive English women of the mid-nineteenth century, while it was so vehemently dismissed by others? To address this question, I consider the literary and cultural contexts for its favourable reception among leaders of the women’s movement, taking my cue from an association the Victoria reviewer makes between Ruskin’s educational theories and those of 86
Linda H. Peterson 87
Anna Jameson, the role model and mentor of a group that included Barbara Leigh Smith, Bessie Rayner Parkes, Adelaide Procter, and Anna Mary Howitt. By exploring the intertextuality of Ruskin’s work and theirs, I argue that Sesame and Lilies, particularly ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’, adopts the key principles and rhetoric of Jameson and her circle in their writing on women’s education and work. Indeed, I argue for the feminist origins of Ruskin’s lecture and for his expansion of their goals (with unanticipated effects) to embrace all middle-class women of England.3 Ruskin’s exchanges with key figures of the English women’s movement have been occasionally noted, but incompletely documented. Like their Pre-Raphaelite brothers, the women artists and authors in the circle that included Parkes, Procter, Leigh Smith (later Bodichon), and Howitt (later Watts) read, discussed, and cited Ruskin’s writing in their own works.4 During the 1850s, when Leigh Smith and Howitt began to exhibit paintings at the Royal Academy and other venues, they exchanged letters with Ruskin, mostly about the practice of art. In the mid-50s, for example, we know that Ruskin praised Leigh Smith’s The Cornfield, a picture of a Sussex field with all the shocks tossed over by a gale, whereas he criticized her widely-regarded American landscape Louisiana Swamp, as well as Howitt’s historical oil painting, Boadicea.5 His criticism of Boadicea – ‘What do you know of Boadicea? Leave such subjects alone and paint me a pheasant’s wing’ – was said by Howitt’s mother, the author Mary Howitt, to have ended her daughter’s artistic career.6 Yet, as Jan Marsh has pointed out, in criticizing as well as praising the work of these young women, Ruskin was disregarding a common gender differential ‘which held that women were too sensitive to withstand serious criticism’; his ‘didactic and pedagogic tone towards women artists was … gender free – he behaved the same way to men’.7 The same freedom of expression marked Ruskin’s responses to other projects initiated by this group, such as the reading room Parkes and Leigh Smith established in 1860 at the headquarters of the English Woman’s Journal.8 Not all exchanges were critical. Ruskin praised and financially supported the work of Octavia Hill, a close friend of Anna Mary Howitt and associate of the group – first by providing Hill’s training as an artist with Margaret Gillies, later by supporting her work at the Ladies’ Co-operative Guild and then underwriting her housing project at Marylebone as a social experiment to improve slums.9 Writing to Barbara Leigh Smith on 8 January 1855, Howitt reported that ‘little Ocky Hill … told me the other day that having attended Ruskin’s lectures on Illumination she went and had some talk with him after one of the lectures and asked
88 The Feminist Origins of ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’
him to come and see what they were doing at the Ladies’ Guild’. Howitt added: I wish by the by for the credit of ladies and women that they had had better work and Art to show him!—However he very kindly went and gave them many valuable hints, and ordered three painted tables from them to be done from his designs—He also, I think Ocky says, is helping them to form a class for women to learn painting on vellum [—] Now this really is very admirable in Ruskin—10 Ruskin’s close contact with Hill during the 1850s and 60s kept him well apprised of the work and writings of this group of young feminists. Their mentors, including Mary Howitt and Anna Jameson, were known to Ruskin personally and professionally. For ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’, I believe Jameson’s influence was particularly important. Ruskin had met Jameson in Venice in 1845 while he was studying Tintoretto in the Scuola di San Rocco and making notes for a revised edition of Murray’s 1847 Handbook for Travellers in Northern Italy and she was working on the Venetian sources of her Sacred and Legendary Art. In Praeterita he recalls his evening walks with Jameson and two other Englishmen, William Boxall and J.D. Harding, during which the four compatriots discussed art, architecture, and other subjects. Although Ruskin deprecates her comments about Italian art, saying that she was ‘without knowledge or instinct of painting’, he nonetheless praises her character as ‘candid and industrious’ (35.374). In fact, Ruskin owed more to that Venetian encounter than he perhaps realized, for in ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’, he drew repeatedly on Jameson’s ideas – not only from her early volume Characteristics of Women (later titled Shakespeare’s Heroines) but subsequently from her 1855 lectures on women’s work. We can see this influence in each of ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ three parts – the first addressing the question of woman’s ‘place’ and ‘power’, the second asking ‘What kind of education is to fit her for these?’ and the third introducing the ‘new’ realm of woman, her public duties or ‘queenly office with respect to the state’ (18.123, 136). In attempting to understand what the ‘power of women should be’ (18.111), Ruskin suggests that we turn to books, that we ‘consult with the wisest and the greatest men on all points of earnest difficulty’ (18.112). He first turns to Shakespeare and his heroines and, in so doing, follows in Jameson’s ground-breaking steps. Her 1832 volume, Characteristics of Women, Moral, Poetical, Historical, had contradicted a long tradition of dramatic criticism that viewed Shakespeare’s heroines as inferior in
Linda H. Peterson 89
conception and representation to his heroes and that attributed this inferiority, at least in part, to women’s lesser natures.11 Jameson argued that Shakespeare’s characters ‘combine history and real life; that they are complete individuals, whose hearts and souls are laid open before us’; and thus that they are better than historical figures or ‘real people’ for understanding human nature.12 Although her categories for analysing female characters – ‘Intellect’, ‘Passion and Imagination’, ‘Affections’, ‘Historical Characters’ – seem modest, even unrevolutionary, her book was noted in its day as the beginning of a distinctively ‘female criticism of Shakespeare’.13 In this work, moreover, as Joanne Shattock has noted, ‘her concern for improvements in the position of women was first presented’.14 For in Characteristics Jameson not only analysed Shakespeare’s heroines, but in her introductory dialogue also discussed women’s education, women’s involvement in politics, and their courage in the private and public spheres. It is unclear whether Ruskin read Characteristics of Women or, more likely, discussed Shakespeare with Jameson on his evening rambles in Venice.15 According to his testimony in Praeterita, he took along a ‘pocket volume of Shakespeare’ on his 1845 Italian journey and for the first time read the plays seriously: ‘the attentive reading … meant only the discovery of a more perfect truth, or a deeper passion, in the words that had before rung in my ears with too little questioned melody’ (35.366–7). When in Sesame and Lilies Ruskin attempts to define ‘what womanly mind and virtue are’ and argues that ‘Shakespeare has no heroes; – he has only heroines’ (18.111–12), he is following Jameson’s lead and taking her argument a step further. Whereas Jameson had assumed that Shakespearian plays include moral positives and negatives in both sexes, Ruskin insists that ‘there is not one entirely heroic figure in all his plays’; ‘the catastrophe of every play is caused by the folly or fault of a man’ (18.112–13). Ruskin also asserts that ‘there is hardly a play that has not a perfect woman in it’; ‘the redemption, if there be any, is by the wisdom and virtue of a woman, and failing that, there is none’ (18.112–13).16 Ruskin’s choice of heroic women duplicates, perhaps predictably, the list of heroines whose characters Jameson analyses: Cordelia, Desdemona, Isabella, Hermione, Imogen, Queen Catherine, Perdita, Sylvia, Viola, Rosalind, and Helena (18.113). Less predictably, his examples of redemptive heroinism echo analyses in Jameson’s book, including her treatment of Cordelia’s actions as ‘rest[ing] upon the two sublimest principles of human action, the love of truth and the sense of duty’, of Hermione’s as deriving from ‘composure of temper’, a ‘mild dignity and saint-like patience’, and Volumnia’s as representing a
90 The Feminist Origins of ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’
‘matured and matronly’ version of her son’s pride and spirit and thus having the ‘prudence and self-command’ to check his ‘headlong impetuosity’.17 Perhaps more importantly, both critics use their discussion of Shakespeare’s heroines to introduce the topic of women’s education. In the preface to Characteristics, in a dialogue between Alda, the woman writer, and Medon, her male reader and critic, Jameson blames the ‘forcing system of education’ for its negative effects on modern young women’s character, calling it ‘the most pernicious, the most mistaken, the most farreaching in its miserable and mischievous effects, that ever prevailed in this world’.18 Her metaphors anticipate Ruskin’s argument, as does her emphasis on the role of ‘feelings and passions’ in women’s education. In describing the deficiencies of the modern system, Jameson draws on the common analogy between young women and flowers: ‘the bloom of existence is sacrificed to a fashionable education, and where we should find the rose-buds of spring, we see only the full-blown, flaunting, precocious roses of the hot-bed’. Her critique extends to ‘knowing mothers and allaccomplished governesses’ with whom ‘vanity and expediency take place of conscience and affection’. The result of such an education, she argues, leaves young women with ‘feelings and passions suppressed or contracted, not governed by higher faculties and purer principles’.19 Ruskin echoes Jameson in the second part when he addresses the question of what kind of education will fit women for their place and power. He engages the same figurative language and similarly emphasizes the development of ‘vital feelings’ (18.124) in young women. Ruskin takes his developmental metaphor from Wordsworth’s lyric: Three years she grew in sun and shower, Then Nature said, ‘A lovelier flower On earth was never sown; and uses the lines: And vital feelings of delight Shall rear her form to stately height, – to argue against the too-common suppression of girls’ ‘instincts of affection or of effort’ (18.124). He suggests that girls be given free rein (and reign) in ‘a good library of old and classical books’ and left alone to ‘find what is good’ (18.130). Trying to ‘chisel’ or ‘hammer’ them into shape
Linda H. Peterson 91
will do only damage (18.131): There is not one restraint you put on a good girl’s nature—there is not one check