Robert Owen and his Legacy
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 1
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
In Memory of Nina Fishman ...
99 downloads
2239 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Robert Owen and his Legacy
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 1
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
In Memory of Nina Fishman (1946–2009)
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 2
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
Robert Owen and his Legacy
Edited by
Noel Thompson and Chris Williams
Cardiff University of Wales Press 2011
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 3
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
© The Contributors, 2011 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any material form (including photocopying or storing it in any medium by electronic means and whether or not transiently or incidentally to some other use of this publication) without the written permission of the copyright owner. Applications for the copy right owner’s written permission to reproduce any part of this publication should be addressed to the University of Wales Press, 10 Columbus Walk, Brigantine Place, Cardiff CF10 4UP. www.uwp.co.uk British Library CIP Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 978-0-7083-2442-4 (hardback) 978-0-7083-2443-1 (paperback) e-ISBN 978-0-7083-2444-8 The rights of the Contributors to be identified as authors of this work have been asserted by them in accordance with sections 77 and 79 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
Typeset in Wales by Eira Fenn Gaunt, Cardiff Printed by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham, Wiltshire
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 4
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
Contents List of Abbreviations List of Contributors
vi ix
Introduction1 Noel Thompson and Chris Williams ╇ 1 Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues Ian Donnachie
13
╇ 2 Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists Gregory Claeys
33
╇ 3 The Great Experiment: New Lanark from Robert Owen to World Heritage Site Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
55
╇ 4 Robert Owen and Education Francis J. O’Hagan
71
╇ 5 Robert Owen and Religion Robert A. Davis
91
╇ 6 Owen and the Owenites: Consumer and Consumption in the New Moral World Noel Thompson
113
╇ 7 Robert Owen as a British Politician and Parliamentarian Margaret Escott
129
╇ 8 Robert Owen’s Unintended Legacy: Class Conflict Ben Maw
155
╇ 9 Robert Owen and ‘The Greatest Discovery Ever Made By Man’ Geoffrey Powell
175
10 Exporting the Owenite Utopia: Thomas Powell and the Tropical Emigration Society Malcolm Chase
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 5
197
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
11 Robert Owen and Wales Chris Williams Afterword: Looking Forward: Co-operative Politics or Can Owen Still Help? Stephen Yeo
219
239
Select Bibliography 259 Index261
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 6
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
Abbreviations
AACAN BL CJ CM GNCTU LJ LRS MC MS NAS NLW NMW NS NUWC OSPC PD PMG PP SWRO TES TNA UCL
The Association of All Classes of All Nations British Library Commons’ Journals Caledonian Mercury Grand National Consolidated Trades Union Lords’ Journals Leeds Redemption Society Morning Chronicle Morning Star National Archives of Scotland National Library of Wales New Moral World Northern Star National Union of the Working Classes Owenite Socialism: Pamphlets and Correspondence, ed. Gregory Claeys (London, 2005), 10 vols Parliamentary Debates Poor Man’s Guardian Parliamentary Papers Selected Works of Robert Owen, ed. Gregory Claeys (London, 1993), 4 vols Tropical Emigration Society The National Archives University College London
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 7
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 8
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
The Contributors
Jim Arnold
Formerly Director of the New Lanark Trust
Malcolm Chase
Professor of Social History, University of Leeds
Gregory Claeys
Professor of the History of Political Thought, Royal Holloway, University of London
Lorna Davidson
Director of the New Lanark Trust
Robert A. Davis
Professor of Religious and Cultural Education, Glasgow University
Ian Donnachie
Emeritus Professor in History, The Open University
Margaret Escott
Honorary Research Fellow, Swansea University, formerly Senior Research Officer, History of Parliament
Ben Maw
Tutorial Assistant in History, Swansea University
Francis J. O’Hagan Formerly Lecturer in the Faculty of Education, Glasgow University Geoffrey Powell
Formerly Lecturer in Education, Keele University and Tutor in Philosophy, Coleg Harlech
Noel Thompson
Pro Vice-Chancellor and Professor of History, Swansea University
Chris Williams
Professor of Welsh History and Director of the Research Institute for Arts and Humanities, Swansea University
Stephen Yeo
Formerly Principal of Ruskin College, Oxford
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 9
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
00 Prelims_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 10
10/17/2011 4:04:14 PM
Introduction
Noel Thompson and Chris Williams
The present volume comes from papers given at a colloquium held to com memÂ�orate the 150th anniversary of the death of Robert Owen at the Uni versity of Wales’s Gregynog Hall in August 2008. Gregynog is just six miles from Newtown, Montgomeryshire, where Owen was born and brought up and where he died at the Bear’s Head Hotel on 17 November 1858 and was buried with his parents beside the abandoned church of St Mary. With the possible exception of New Lanark there could have been few more appro priate venues for such a conference, and ambience, papers and personalities comÂ�bined to do justice to the life and work of this remarkable man. The colloquium papers illustrate both the complex character of his achieve Â�ment, legacy and personality and how he in turn both shaped and reflected the spirit of the age in equally complex ways. New Lanark is the most power ful physical legacy of that shaping. Like many in this volume Davidson and Arnold argue for the centrality of New Lanark to what Owen achieved and what he communicated to future generations. They tell the story of its physical retrieval from dereliction to the status of a world heritage site in 2001; a trans formation that required the same combination of business skills, idealism and perseverance that Robert Owen himself deployed in his original trans formation of the New Lanark community. It is a retrieval of this monument to Owen’s achievement which also keeps alive, in its rejuvenated and living community, many of the ideals which Owen himself embraced. New Lanark, as it was and as it is, reminds us of the potent forces un leashed by the revolution in industrial organization and technologies that drove the rapid industrialization of this period and the genius of Owen in
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 1
10/3/2011 7:49:14 PM
Noel Thompson and Chris Williams
harnessing them both for the conventional purpose of profit but also the concomitant creation of what might be termed a welfare community. For if profit was a consequence it was not the motive force of what he did. Similarly if New Lanark, as the world heritage site it has become, now aims to pay its way in a demanding world, its restoration has been driven by other ideals, and other imperatives; ideals manifested in New Lanark’s social enter prise and social housing. Its status as a site of global historical significance has enÂ�capsulated and preserved for the future the physical embodiment of what it sought to achieve: a living community where the social takes prece dence over the acquisitively individual. The inspiration which Owen gave reconfigured the way in which many viewed the world; what it was and, more importantly, what it might become. And not only did it inspire many who sought to create a new moral world at home but also those, like Owen himself, who sought to transplant the moral values of communitarianism, often with disastrous consequences, to the New World of the Americas. Chase’s essay focuses on the export of Owenism to South America through the agency of Thomas Powell (like Owen a native of Newtown) and the Tropical Emigration Society (TES). Drawn by prospects of abundance, despair at what could be achieved in the old immoral world and frustration with the authoritarianism of Owen, the society looked to Venezuela as a suitable location to realize their aspirÂ�ations. Powell had been involved in the early co-operative phase of Owenism and then went on to play a prominent role in Montgomeryshire Chartism in the late 1830s. Following a period of imprisonment for his political activities, he threw his energies into the TES as its founding secretary and editor of its journal the Morning Star, and shortly after, in 1845, a colony was founded with a population of around 250. As Chase makes clear, the disaster which followed was as total as it was predictable: a hostile climate, lack of resource, virgin forest and an absence of effective leadership made for death, despair and dissension. Broken by the experience Powell himself stayed on in Trinidad, dying there in 1862. Chase’s chapter tells us much about the nature of Owenism and its appeal: its millenarian nature, the desire for a new world in the physical as well as the figurative sense; the failing faith in the capacity to build a New Jerusalem in a land that seemed neither green nor pleasant and lacking the potential to be either (particularly for those artisans in declining trades); the importance it gave to the acquisition of land and, above all, the appeal to many wouldbe communitarians of the exotic, the other, where with the constraints of 2
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 2
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Introduction
the old had been removed and all things became possible, at least in the imagination. As Chase shows these were the psychological, political and socio-economic imperatives which fuelled an interest in emigration, and the possibilities it held out, throughout Owenism’s history. Less dramatically, but in many ways more constructively there was what Owen contributed to the social reforms of the period. Marx and Engels might use the epithet of ‘utopian’ but the former in Capital, with more than a touch, surely, of self-directed irony, acknowledged what Owen had con tributed in a very real and practical sense. Not only had he ‘maintained the necessity of the limitation of the working day in theory but actually intro duced the 10 hours’ day into his factory at New Lanark. This was laughed at as a communistic utopia; so where his “Combination of children’s education with productive labour” and the Co-operative Societies of working-men, first called into being by him. To-day the first Utopia is a Factory Act, the second figures as an official phrase in all Factory Acts, the third is already being used as a cloak for reactionary humbug.’1 And in particular there was what he achieved as an educationalist and the inspiration that this gave to others. O’Hagan in his essay discusses the educational legacy of New Lanark where Owen demonstrated a new and potent relationship between education, work and society; something which, for many commentators, represents his most significant and lasting achievement. Certainly, for Owen, education was seen as the primary driver of the social transformation he hoped to effect. As O’Hagan points out, ‘at the heart of Owen’s educational programme . . . was the determination to create a disciplined “docile” population for factory, home and the shared spaces of social circulation.’2 And this he argues explains its appeal to those concerned with the fundamental tensions which industrialization was creating in the new social order. A New View of Society was, after all, aimed at political and cultural elites. This is in no way denies the radical nature of what Owen proposed: an education that integrated the utilitarian and instrumentalist with the pro moÂ�tion of self-knowledge and self-realization and, in consequence, the develop ment of a curriculum that embraced natural history and science together with music and dance. And Owen’s was a legacy which influenced, and had significance for, adult, early and citizenship education. If Owen was, as Hazlitt has suggested, a man of one idea, or in the patois of Isaiah Berlin a hedge hog rather than a fox; then that idea was one which profoundly shaped the thinking of many about what humankind was and what it might be made 3
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 3
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Noel Thompson and Chris Williams
to become. Just how profoundly revolutionary was this vision of what edu cation might be was again something specifically recognized by Marx. Writing in Capital he opined that Owen had ‘shown us in detail, the germ of the education of the future, an education that will, in the case of every child over a given age, combine productive labour with instruction and gymnastics, not only as one of the methods of adding to the efficiency of production, but as the only method of producing fully developed human beings.’3 As Escott’s contribution makes clear, Owen was not someone who stood aside from politics and the political process where he felt it might be used to practical, legislative or proselytizing effect to advance the cause of social reform. This essay looks at Owen’s engagement with British parliamentary and electoral politics, both as a lobbyist and as a putative parliamentary candidate – an experience which largely served to confirm his underlying belief that ‘any government founded upon popular elections has within it the seeds of continued irritation, divisions and corruption’.4 It was, though, in his capacity as lobbyist that this engagement was most intense and ap parent: involvement in the movement for factory reform; petitioning of the House of Lords to create model communities similar to New Lanark; petitions in relation to the distressed condition of Ireland in the early 1820s; contributions to the deliberations of select committees; interventions in debates surrounding the key political issues of the day – grain shortages, high prices and the restoration of cash payment. All provided an opportunity not just to mark out his position on these matters but also to advance his own more general plans as to how a new society might be created. Elections and electoral politics in particular furnished a variety of platforms and media to engage with the political community and to disseminate his ideas beyond the circle of the Owenite faithful. These Owen used to the full. But it was on the minds of men and women that Owen left the most lasting imprint; an imprint sufficiently profound to provoke the critical categorization of ‘utopian’ which Marx and Engels bestowed. Most obviously there was the efflorescence of Owenite socialist political economy in the 1820s and 1830s and the practical expression of this in co-operative societies and labour exchanges. This was an ideological awakening that found expres sion in tracts, pamphlets, books and above all the working-class press and, for a period, posed one of the most formidable and profound challenges to classical political economy that it was to experience before the last quarter of the nineteenth century. Not until the late-nineteenth-century socialist revival was there such an upsurge of critical and constructive thinking that challenged 4
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 4
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Introduction
the fundamentals of capitalism’s economic rationale and its associated value system. Aspects of this challenge are considered in Maw’s contribution, in which he discusses what he sees as the unintended aspects of Owen’s ideo logical legacy. Thompson also looks at the impact that Owen had on con temporary socialist thinking on how it negotiated the perils and sought to exploit the possibilities of abundance. Maw’s essay focuses on one of the pivotal periods in Owen’s career, when he assumed de jure if not de facto leadership of the upsurge in working-class Radicalism of the late 1820s and early 1830s. Often seen, not least by Marx, as someone who failed to grasp the irremediable nature of class antagonism under capitalism, Maw sees Owen’s thought as nonetheless establishing the ‘key building blocks of new ideas about class and class conflict’.5 Thus his environmentalism and moral determinism and his thinking in terms of systems and the actions of social groups rather than individuals could be, and were, articulated in social analyses with class at their core: analyses that were to be developed and disseminated by organizations and media associated with Owenism and co-operation in the politically and economically charged atmosphere of the early 1830s. What emerged in consequence, as Maw sees it, was what can legitimately be termed a popular, anti-capitalist political economy that found expression in the working-class press and through trade unions and co-operative societies. Such a political economy was articulated with particular force and coherence by figures such as Bronterre O’Brien and James Morrison, and in papers such as the Poor Man’s Guardian and the Pioneer, whose direct experience of working-class organizations was to give both an edge to their class analysis and a more determinedly and rounded democratic view of their role in transforming the existing order than that of Owen himself. Thompson’s contribution considers the place of consumption in early nineteenth-century socialist thought, and in particular that of Robert Owen. Like later writers the Owenite socialists sought to reconcile the socially atomizing potential of private consumption with the desire to improve the material well-being of the working classes. Mechanization, and the industrial expansion which it fuelled, had persuaded Owen that the age of scarcity had ended and that of abundance had dawned. What was needful were social and economic arrangements which would allow the realization of its potentialities in ways that would not be divisive, self-serving or self-regarding. The resolution of this tension was to be effected by way of the prioritization of social consumption. Social opulence was to be the counterpart of personal 5
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 5
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Noel Thompson and Chris Williams
restraint; something that was to be reflected in the quality of the social and cultural infrastructure which characterized socialist communities, both real and imagined. In an age whose priorities are quite the opposite, with material consequences with which future generations must live (or die), Thompson argues the need for a return to the Owenite vision of a social opulence that a prioritization of social consumption might deliver. But of course the influence of Owen’s ideas has extended far beyond the early part of the nineteenth century and their longevity, impact and con temporary relevance are discussed in two essays in this volume. Claeys examines how, in the light of the collapse of Marxian socialism, we should view Owen’s reputation vis-à-vis the later socialist movement and where this leaves the binary divide between ‘utopian’ and ‘scientific’ socialism. Here Claeys challenges the Marxian critique of Owen’s political economy: in particular its unhistorical character, its inability to elucidate the nature of capitalist exploitation and its failure to recognize the irremediable nature of class antagonism. As Claeys notes, despite this critique, all shades of socialist opinion in Britain, from MacDonald to Cole to Hyndman, acknowledged the remark able and distinctive contributions which Owen had made to the cause of the working class. And, if later British commentators made a distinction between their socialism and that of Owen and the Owenites, it was not with reference to any ‘utopian’/‘scientific’ dichotomy but with regard to the different explanatory and conceptual frameworks which they used and the different modus operandi they proposed for the delivery of socialist progress. This is made particularly evident by Claeys in his discussion of Alfred Russel Wallace and the latter’s view of Owen. Claeys also, and rightly, raises the issue of the relevance of community and scale to our society, with its present discontents, threatened public services and threatening public space. Owenite communitarianism celebrated the virtue of civic responsibility, public service and fellowship. Like Morris some fifty years later, Owen saw fellowship as creating the possibility of a full and rounded existence, while its absence made for social death. Yeo’s ‘Afterword’ seeks to do two things: to mediate a political conver sation between the early nineteenth and early twenty-first centuries and to consider critically the traditional historiographical view of the third quarter of the nineteenth century as a a particularly flat plain between two peaks. As to the first, he illustrates how the power of the co-operative movement as a set of associations has remained recognizable across time; a power which, 6
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 6
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Introduction
along with its associational ethos makes possible and legitimate the explor ation of a contemporary co-operative politics and what it might look like; a politics (emphatically lower-case) that could be used to challenge the acquisi tive culture of contentment that has taken us to within a few steps of the abyss. It is in this context that Yeo celebrates the intellectual achievement of Greg Claeys in having made more accessible and usable the Owenite inheritance upon which those who would forge a co-operative politics can draw. As to the flat socialist landscape of third-quarter Victorian Britain, this can now be seen as populated by a rich associational culture; one embraced and developed by those drawing on an Owenite legacy or inspired by its values to engage in active, working, productive and above all ‘social’ associ ations – trade unions, co-operatives, friendly and building societies and educational associations. This is something which Yeo sees as carried forward, in muted and transmuted forms, through the twentieth century into the growth of the New Mutualism of the New Labour years; and views it too as an Owenite-rooted legacy whose retrieval could lay the basis for aspirations for a fully social life. But if we are to take seriously Owen’s own emphasis on the determining influence of upbringing and environment, we must touch base, as we did in the conference, with Wales, the market town of Newtown and the rolling hills of Montgomeryshire. For only by doing so can we fully appreciate the early influences that helped shape his personality and thinking. Williams’s essay examines Owen’s relationship with Wales during his lifetime: the impact of Owenite communitarianism on Wales, which inspired amongst other developments the communities of Garn Lwyd and Pant Glas, and the evolving relationship between Wales and Owen or, perhaps more accurately, the changing Welsh perception of Owen, in the 150 years since his death. Building on the work of Donnachie, Powell and others he seeks to identify the nature of Owen’s intellectual and other debts to the town and rural community in which he was born and brought up and the nature of any distinctively Welsh cultural imprint which this left. The significance of this is difficult to gauge but certainly neither Owen nor, more interestingly, his subsequent critics, were to make much of it. Moreover Newtown, his birthand last resting-place was slow to acknowledge and embrace his memory. In significant part, it would seem, as a consequence of his perceived atheism. However, that was to change at the turn of the century when New Liberals, Welsh nationalists and the Labour movement were able to unpack Owen’s 7
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 7
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Noel Thompson and Chris Williams
social thinking in ways consistent with their respective political credos. Sub sequent generations have done likewise; the multifaceted character of Owen’s political economy lending itself to such ideologically disparate appropriations of his legacy. Williams, like others before him, rightly notes Owen’s Nonconformist roots. And religion and the Bible had a particular place in his early life. Just how profound that influence was and how Owen subsequently engaged with religion, religious practice and religious institutions is considered by Davis. His discussion of Owen’s position on religion is set in the context of the historiographical reassessment of religious institutions and practice of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain that has occurred in the last four decades; something which has involved a more nuanced treatment than has previously been the case. Discussion of this aspect of Owen’s life and thought has portrayed him as a figure in the traditional narrative of the inexorable progress of Enlightenment rationalism; a reading to which his autobiographical Life lends credence. For Davis, however, Owen’s thinking can be seen rather as the product of a complex interaction with the language and habits of religious adherence. Certainly, as Davis makes clear, Owen was profoundly influenced by his exposure to Enlightenment thinkers, particu larly in the context of the Manchester Literary and Philosophical Society. Moreover his rejection of the notion of free will and therefore of the concept of moral responsibility represented an attack on religious systems that have that as their core. Further, in the 1820s he began to attack more overtly the philosophical assumptions of religious belief and to see it as a fundamental source of sectarianism and intolerance. Yet as Davis sees it, Owen, from an initial deism, ultimately looked to the renovation of religion and the accomÂ�modation of the religious impulse within a rational belief system – ‘a religion of truth’ – scientifically grounded in an understanding of nature; one ultimately yielding a signal improvement in the human condition. More over the religious language of conviction, conversion and millenarian trans formation came to be secularized and rationalized and then used as a means of articulating Owen’s social philosophy. In such a context Davis sees his final embrace of spiritualism not as an aberration but as a naturalistic and scientific explanation of religious claims to the existence of an afterlife. Powell’s chapter also touches on Owen’s understanding of the nature of religion and religious thought but with a specific consideration of his epistemology. His focus is on Owen’s understanding of the misconception of reality, and the more general bearing this had on his thinking. For Owen, 8
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 8
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Introduction
the existing order was characterized by misconceptions consistent with the ‘rank insanity’ of those who possessed them. Religion, private property and marriage were at the root of these. They generated the contradictions that characterized modem industrial society: private property was at the root of poverty in the midst of plenty and religion preached love but engendered hatred amongst those of differing religious persuasions. Reconciling such contradictions required a distortion or occlusion of vision that represented a form of insanity. How then could the capacity to see things as they were be restored, insanity dispelled and the possibility of a new order created? That was the role of Owen. A man who saw the world clearly as it was and as it might become; a secular Messiah who used millenarian and religious language to envision a material world characterised by abundance, from which the socially and morally corrosive effects of poverty could be removed. As Powell points out, despite the millenarian rhetoric of total transformÂ�ation, Owen was concerned that the new moral world must emerge from a trans formation of humanity’s perception of the world rather than the revolutionary overthrow of existing institutions; a transformation of perÂ�cepÂ�tion that would involve, in the terms of Piaget, the elimination of a pervasive egocentrism. Humanity must see the world clearly and not through a glass darkly. But achieving this, as Owen increasingly recognized, was profoundly problematic. Marx saw the clarification of vision as coming pari passu with the unfolding of the historical process itself. But it is to Piaget that Powell looks and to his ‘decentred thinker’ with the capacity to think rationally, to understand the interests of the community and live by internalized principles; a capacity hardwired into the psyche through the child’s experience of social groups where there is mutual respect and the recognition of a common interest. For Powell it is Piaget who points the way ‘to secur[ing] Owen’s educational route to restoring the clarity of vision’ upon which his new moral world was predicated.6 While this book begins with the contribution of Ian Donnachie, whose splendid volume provides the most recent biographical treatment of Owen, and one that does full justice to his Welsh roots, it could equally well have ended with it. This essay both assesses our current understanding of some of the controversies and issues surrounding Owen and also points to the oppor tunities for future scholarship in its assessment of those that have yet to be resolved. More specifically Donnachie addresses the multiple reputations which have been constructed for Owen. There can be little doubt that the substance 9
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 9
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Noel Thompson and Chris Williams
of his reputation was created at New Lanark; a reputation, indeed an inter national one, that derived from its social transformation in microcosm at a time when turbulent economic times, and a prolonged conflict with revoÂ�lutionary and Napoleonic France, threatened social destabilization. It was New Lanark that attracted the attention of the elites but it was also this that laid the basis for his ideas on educational and factory reform which were in turn to establish a reputation with which those social elites came to be less at ease. This was the reputation that attached to Owen the advocate of communities and producer co-operatives and the Owen who excoriated the prevailing ethos of competition. This was a reputation which, whether legitÂ�imÂ�ately or not, was to see Owen transmuted into the ‘Father of Socialism’ by later generations of socialist and other writers and into someone whose ‘socialism’ was to receive the sustained critical attention of other socialists. Donnachie’s essay raises some of the unresolved and important issues still surrounding Owen’s career. How for example to explain his undoubted success in Manchester as manager of the Drinkwater mills? What explains the speed with which his career progressed on arrival at New Lanark: power, sex and money were, as Donnachie sees it, germane to this but in what ways and in what combinations? What allowed, and continued to allow him access to political and social elites? What prompted his attack on religion or rather sectarianism? Was it the inevitable corollary of Enlightenment rationalism or fired by other pressures and considerations? And then there is his stance on the position of women and gender equality. As Donnachie’s piece makes plain, there are, for the future, still many questions to be answered if a more complete picture and understanding of Owen is to be furnished. But if the flow of scholarship which characterizes the volume continues unabated, we can confidently anticipate that such a picture will have emerged when we come together, as some of us shall, and perhaps at Gregynog, to celebrate the 250th anniversary of Owen’s birth in 2021.
Notes 1 2 3 4
Karl Marx, Capital (London, 1976 edition), Vol. 1, p. 413n. P. 81 below Marx, Capital, p. 614. P. 138 below 10
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 10
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Introduction 5 6
P. 156 below P. 192 below
11
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 11
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 12
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues Ian Donnachie
Reputations Robert Owen is an iconic figure in the annals of social reform and is widely celebrated in many parts of the globe where his ideas, transported from New Lanark, took root. In his time Owen was highly controversial, a situation partly of his own making. Thanks to a flood of speeches, pamphlets, books and other propaganda, allied to his numerous interventions in issues of the day, he was often victim to extreme responses from his audience. Indeed, after he went public and became a personality on the national and then international stages, he was endorsed or vilified in equal measure for nearly half a century until his death in 1858.1 Whatever we say about Owen, whatever burning issues we raise about his ideas and agenda there is no question he had a reputation, indeed reputations, for an enormous variety of ideas and schemes in many contexts throughout Britain, Ireland, continental Europe, the USA, and even in Latin America. The continuing contemporary interest in Owen is reflected in ongoing scholar ship and a continuous stream of publications revisiting and reassessing his remarkable career.2 First, it can reasonably be claimed that Owen was most famous for New Lanark and, apart perhaps from his more dubious sobriquet, particularly in library catalogues, as the ‘Father of Socialism’ (to which we will come), or his association with infant schools, this was the greatest of his accomplishments. While there are major questions to be asked about what Owen actually achieved at New Lanark given that much was already in place from the
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 13
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Ian Donnachie
regime of his father-in-law David Dale, there is no question that his twentyfive years there helped make him an international celebrity. He was director of one of the largest factories in the world and, more to the point in Scottish parlance, the laird of New Lanark. In fact, he was a great deal richer and more powerful than most lairds. Indeed, such was his fame within a few years of publishing A New View of Society (1813–16) that he was telling people anxious to contact him, including John Quincy Adams, the future President of the United States of America, that letters addressed simply to Mr Owen of Lanark, North Britain, would readily reach him. Such renown is no surprise given the apparent success of the workplace and community reforms Owen claimed to have instituted on the back of the paternalistic Dale management. The point was not lost on others that he did not start ab initio, and this ultimately raised problems for Owen. However, as a test bed for a broader social agenda New Lanark proved ideal and this was why it came to be so closely identified with Owen and his achievements.3 Before A New View there was much else that helped to raise his profile. He had quickly become a member of the Glasgow mercantile and intellectual elite; he had contributed, like Dale, to worthy causes; he had promoted popular eduÂ�cation, notably the monitorial system of Joseph Lancaster; he had skir mished with a series of partners; and he had already published a Statement Regarding the New Lanark Establishment (1812), which gave some insight into his thinking in advance of the more substantial essays. Much of this, like the tables and chairs on pulleys that he suggested could be raised to the ceiling in the Institution (a device also adapted to raise and lower the famous visual aids in the classrooms) was highly practical as well as ingenious.4 These qualities of practicality and ingenuity were also characteristic of the essays in A New View. These were published initially as pamphlets rather than in one volume, which may have been Owen’s ploy to monitor the reception of his ideas as they developed. On the other hand, he might have been trying to avoid prosecution for sedition, for which he would have been an easy target had the authorities decided to act. Owen would have known that some outspoken Scottish kirk ministers, including the Revd Henry Duncan, a regular visitor to New Lanark and famous for promoting savings banks and other initiatives to aid the poor, were under suspicion.5 Owen was, therefore, careful to put his proposals to Vansittart, Chancellor of the Exchequer, to Sidmouth, the Home Secretary, and ultimately to Liverpool, the Prime Minister.6 Like much else Owen wrote in this period his essays were extensively circulated, suggesting a self-financed publishing project, 14
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 14
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues
and the use of his contacts among the political and intellectual elite. A New View brought Owen instant fame, since anyone promising solutions to the dire economic and social problems at the end of the Napoleonic Wars was likely to command attention. The essays stated his opinion that education held the key both to social progress and at the same time to social renewal with strong moral undertones. This was exemplified in the second and third essays by reference to New Lanark, apparently transformed by his presence and ideas, and then everything was elevated in the fourth essay to a scheme of national, even international, regeneration.7 However, it should be noted that at this stage there was no mention of egalitarianism, if that was ever part of Owen’s agenda. Since Owen had apparently proved that defective characters could be reformed, his ideas had an immediate appeal to the elites, who felt threatened by potential disorder. Owen claimed that within the gates of New Lanark there were no fears, no resort to the law. And, despite rumours to the contrary, not only was religion tolerated; it was even promoted, possibly as another means of social control, though Owen was careful to avoid suggesting this.8 There was much more in the essays of A New View that went beyond the questions of character formation and popular education. They included extended discussions on factory issues and the attack on poverty, a major problem accompanying rapid industrialization, rural–urban migration and mushrooming towns and cities, both Manchester and Glasgow being good examples of the latter. While slavery, on which the whole edifice ultimately floated, was not at this point mentioned, though Dale at least had abolition ist sympathies, other humane issues commanded Owen’s attention. In advance of Shaftesbury, who as the young Ashley also visited New Lanark, Owen was one of a group of reformers involved in the fight against the exploitation of child labour. His concerns were probably first raised in Manchester, find ing expression through his involvement with the Manchester Board of Health, which promoted the cause in and beyond the town. Humanitarianism and health issues certainly played a part in his thinking at New Lanark, for there he was confronted with the problem of several hundred child apprentices recruited by Dale as well as numerous other village children and some from Old Lanark who also worked in the mills. Owen again led by example, highlighting the plight of factory children as early as 1812.9 A New View had much to say about conditions in the factories, a cam paign Owen took up after 1816. Whether or not he later exaggerated his role is hard to determine, but he and young Robert Dale Owen went round 15
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 15
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Ian Donnachie
gathering data and trying to see what was going on in other mills, in both Scotland and England. Giving evidence to a parliamentary inquiry, Owen certainly put up a bold challenge to the reactionary mill masters who at tempted to dismiss his views. His plausible account of what had been achieved at New Lanark by de-committing from the apprenticeship system, placing age restrictions on child labour, limiting hours of work, and providing nearcompulsory education undoubtedly justified the moral indignation evident in his stance. So factory reform, promoted again by a vigorous propaganda campaign before and after the first parliamentary Act in 1819, brought Owen widespread recognition. Owen’s contribution to the debate was longlasting: it was revisited by the Factory Commissions of the 1830s, and many later investigations also acknowledged his contribution to reform.10 Education was another important platform for Owen’s campaigns, but like factory reform it had much wider implications given the crusade for social and moral regeneration signalled in A New View. If character formation was to work it would be most effective from infancy, hence the importance attached to early childhood education in and beyond what John Griscom, one of numerous distinguished American reformers seen at New Lanark, called the ‘baby school’.11 But, as David McLaren has shown, Owen’s interest extended to all ages, ultimately delivering a progressive curriculum with in novative methods derived partly from Joseph Lancaster and Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi. The evening schools and uplifting lectures were also open to adults, in order that the reforming of character started in infancy and childhood could be pursued into adult life. Interestingly Owen himself, when called upon much later in life to reflect on his career, said that the schools were his biggest achievement at New Lanark. His reputation as a formidable contributor to the promotion of early-years education, while raising many issues about what he anticipated it would bring about, is well deserved.12 However, although education was important, wider social reform issues raised Robert Owen to even higher platforms, first national, then inter national. Again the essays of A New View and the many pamphlets that came in their wake held the key. If at New Lanark workplace and community reforms could turn round a drunken, corrupted and undisciplined society and set it on the road to moral reform and economic recovery, then New Lanark itself could become a template for a national and international programme of social renewal. From this period, fraught with economic and social problems, emerged Owen’s ‘Village Plan’ which he insisted had wide spread application. From 1817 onwards, and deploying millennial discourse, 16
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 16
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues
he refined his plan, attempted to justify his case and raise government support. His efforts were informed by what he was able to find out about existing communities that seemed to fit his agenda. These included the planned estate and industrial villages common in the Scottish Lowlands, workhouse schemes in Bavaria, villages for the poor in the Netherlands, and several religious communities in the USA. He almost certainly knew about the American communities when he was writing the essays, and was in touch with George Rapp at Neu Harmonie by 1820, possibly earlier. Owen’s com munities, transformed into ‘Villages of Unity and Mutual Co-operation’, acquired potentially complex social and class structures and embraced the then fashionable spade husbandry advocated by the horticulturalist William Falla, an early promoter of self-sufficiency in industrial society.13 This initiative was soon followed by another major policy document, the Report to the County of Lanark (1820), which sustained the argument for social regeneration enhanced by the community scheme, the focus of which remained the central message of Owen’s attack on poverty for the rest of his career.14 Owen of course thought poverty inexcusable given the vast resources and manu factures industrialization had released. He repeatedly returned to that theme, especially after 1817, said by some to have been his ‘millennialist moment’.15 He began to attack competition and promote co-operation. But his reputation as a pioneer in the field of battling poverty (and thereby bettering the poor) remained critical. Owen was closely identified with co-operation in its many forms. While this could be said to have begun with the attack on poverty, co-operation became more important to Owen through the community schemes. Com munitarians would not compete but theoretically contribute to the common wealth in which they would all have a stake. While the arrangements about labour value, shares and rewards remained confused, Owen saw the com munities as something like modern public–private partnerships promoted by capitalists who would get a return on their investment, but with the members ultimately becoming shareholder-owners of their communities.16 Co-operation also found its expression in the early co-operative associations which sprang up in the 1820s, not consumer co-operatives, but groups drawn from the middle classes and artisans, including many women, interested in promoting communities. Many Owenite organizations had communal and co-operative aspirations, notably the Owenite Labour Exchanges, based again on labour value, and the Association of All Classes of All Nations, one of several promoting popular education and community with millennial 17
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 17
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Ian Donnachie
undertones. Of course, the long story of the Owenite community experiments from the 1820s to the 1840s also gave expression to co-operative principles, though we may note that Owen’s links to consumer co-operation, while widely celebrated, are more tenuous.17 Owen also has enjoyed a reputation, whether deserved or not, as a socialist. Here, as in everything else, we need to be on our guard about what that word meant in its early usages and in his lifetime, rather than the associations it came to have later in the nineteenth century. In the 1820s ‘socialist’ meant the promoter of a ‘social system’, a system of society, mainly but not ex clusively based on Owen’s principles and plans. Whether or not the Villages of Unity and Mutual Co-operation or the Community of Equality introduced with such speed at New Harmony and at Orbiston around the same time could be described as ‘socialist’ is debatable. Certainly the social and cultural dimensions of Owenism were much more robust than their economic frame work, about which Owen was consistently woolly. Back in Britain in 1829 after his North American and Mexican ventures, Owen found himself head of an Owenite Social System with myriad platforms and organizations which he periodically headed as ‘Social Father’. The man had become a movement, sustaining a multifaceted propaganda campaign and being associated with practically every popular movement of the 1830s through to the 1850s. The charismatic leader who was ‘Social Father’ and who blessed couples and named children brought forward at lectures and soirées was readily transformed by his early biographers and hagiographers into the ‘Father of Socialism’ after his death in 1858.18 Owen in due course became less cele brated in this regard by the left than Marx or Engels, but they both recognized his formidable contribution to early socialist thought. However, it was as a promoter of a social system that he was known in his lifetime, not as an advocate of what came to be understood as socialist ideology from the late nineteenth century onwards.
Burning Issues How did Robert Owen’s background help bring him to the position of a leading capitalist in the Industrial Revolution and a potential reformer of its excesses? While we are on safe ground on his early adulthood, knowledge of his childhood is something of a grey area, relying mainly on an auto biography written in his eighties. His family background and boyhood in 18
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 18
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues
Newtown, Montgomeryshire was almost certainly very influential. Kin, class, education, language and culture generally had considerable impact on the personality and thinking of a highly precocious child. The skills Owen acquired in Newtown were essentially practical: reading, writing, simple accounts, shop work, potential social skills and, it seems, monitorial duties at school supervising younger pupils on behalf of the master. Owen read widely and in this was supported by his teacher and one of the local clergy, who lent him books – of which some conveyed enlightened messages. There were also interesting religious and linguistic influences. He was apparently highly religious and, while the family were Anglican, perhaps touched by evangelical Methodism, though he claims otherwise. The millen nial tone that characterized much of his later writing is likely to have come from this background, supplemented by his exposure to Unitarianism in Manchester. Since Newtown was a bilingual town in a sea of Welshness did he also understand or speak Welsh? Although the language was different, might he even have understood some of the Scots Gaelic he heard spoken by the New Lanark Highlanders, hence enjoying a rather different relation ship with them than the picture he sometimes painted? Both religion and language were certainly to become significant issues later in his life.19 Kin connections were very important: his mother, his father, and his brothers all aided his start in life. He might not have shifted so far if his brother had not already been established in London, as out-migration from mid-Wales over such a distance was uncommon. His subsequent apprentice ships were also fortunate for young Owen, who always seemed to land on his feet, acquiring useful and varied retail experience in the drapery trade as well as continuing his education in works of the Enlightenment. The places where he worked – London, Stamford, and Manchester – represented interesting contrasts of size, location and function, but all three reflected in different ways the economic and social turmoil of the period. Owen was also astute enough to learn how to deal with different classes of customer, deferring to his betters as seemed appropriate. Mentors were always critical, the most interesting being James McGuffog, the successful Scottish linen draper and a leading citizen of Stamford, a possible prototype of David Dale in both business and moral ethics.20 Owen’s Manchester period was enormously important to his future career. His success there was remarkable by any standards and demands scrutiny. But Owen was at the centre of a boom town in a dynamic textile industry being transformed by new technology. His rapid shifts and promotions, 19
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 19
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Ian Donnachie
often at the cost of edging out rivals and overcoming other threats, suggest an ability to absorb new ideas, enhance skills and deploy a ruthlessness to advance in an environment where high risks and potentially high returns prevailed. Maybe too he had a glib tongue, an eye for the opportunity, and a great deal of luck. Religion was used for social advancement though apparently his church attendance also gave him the opportunity to meet women. Beyond the church, his employment with Peter Drinkwater, another successful cotton master, and his connection with young men anxious to improve themselves, helped ease his way into the intellectual elite of Man chester which, like Birmingham and Glasgow, was becoming a centre of educational and scientific progress, as well as an industrial powerhouse. The Manchester Literary and Philosophical Society, which Owen joined, had many distinguished members, including evangelical clergy, scientists, scholars, reforming doctors, and teachers. Once again Owen used this intellectual environment and these people to advantage. He soon delivered papers, several of which seem to point to future ideas about education and social reform issues generally. He also claimed to have disarmed critics, who were sidelined either by his charisma or his personal knowledge of industry. Owen absorbed more enlightened ideas and saw them put to practical use in another body, the Board of Health, one of the earliest such organizations promoting medical and sanitary reform in the fight against disease in the new industrial towns. Some of its recommendations were evidently applied in Drinkwater’s factories, and it also made Owen think about factory conditions, particularly those in which he was to be found. But it is the business success that was most critical: by his mid- to late twenties Owen was one of the most successful managers in the cotton industry. While there were many other people in his situation who were young, his success and potential were already remarkable before he ever set eyes on New Lanark.21 Like other Manchester cotton masters and merchants, Owen certainly knew what was going on in Scotland and may well have been acquainted with Dale’s numerous enterprises. He had the opportunity to learn more through his business connections and the fact that the Board of Health, surveying the views of factory masters, actually elicited information about child labour in the mills by the Clyde. Indeed, Dale’s philanthropic regime at New Lanark was already nationally and even internationally recognized through newspaper articles, travelogues and reports of visiting reformers.22 The long story of Owen’s acquaintance with New Lanark and his ultimate arrival there contains many puzzles and raises interesting and intriguing 20
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 20
10/3/2011 7:49:15 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues
issues as to how he again struck lucky as entrepreneurial heir to the wealthy Dale. Certainly power, sex and, above all, money have their part in the story. Owen was an enormously astute and successful businessman, apparently charismatic, not lacking in looks and, for his age, already rich. His marriage in 1799 to Caroline Dale and her father’s generosity, brought Owen not only New Lanark’s management but also access to resources and influence on a substantial scale. In Glasgow, as before in Manchester, he was intro duced to the mercantile and intellectual elites, including some of philanthropic and reforming views. The way doors were opened to Owen at every turn suggests a possible Masonic connection, though no evidence has so far been found of this and he himself denied membership of the order.23 Wealth itself was a great lever, as it proved in his subsequent career, and elites every where were prepared to listen to a wealthy man who might well hold the key to deflecting threats to their own property and persons. However, this lay in the future: first he had to turn New Lanark around and make it a more profitable enterprise for himself and his partners. Quite how he achieved this raises many more interesting issues. Like Owen’s beginnings in Newtown, there is also something of a blank in the story of his early management at New Lanark. It is important to remember that the holding company was being run from Manchester and the Lanark Twist Company mainly from Glasgow, where Owen spent much of his time. While Owen later criticized Dale (though not in his lifetime, I suspect) for his failure to visit his factory with sufficient regularity, it is hard to tell how much time he himself actually spent in the mills and how much of the day-to-day management was delegated to overseers. In moves replicating those he had made in Manchester, he wasted little time getting rid of Dale’s managers, apparently because they got in the way of his plans. There may well have been other reasons, such as challenges to his authority, or in the case of William Kelly, who made notable improvements to the spin ning machinery, the potential threat of an inventive genius. The reforms in workplace and community enacted by Owen are well known, and the new order found expression as early as 1800 in his rules and regulations designed to enhance order. These were soon followed by gradual de-commitment from the apprenticeship system, with labour being replaced by families recruited locally or through migration. This was, clearly, much less bother, reduced discipline problems and saved money. Young children, in any case, did not make very effective workers, especially if they took up living space in buildings that could be filled with machinery and made productive. The 21
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 21
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Ian Donnachie
factory itself seems to have been partly retooled with new water-wheels and more modern equipment. All of this was observed by visitors, some on spying missions from the USA and the Continent. But visitors seem to have been actively discouraged then, since, it was said, they took up too much time, though the threat of espionage seems equally convincing. Most, as in Dale’s time, praised the philanthropy of employing pauper children, though some were critical. In correspondence with the Stanley management Owen hinted at what he was achieving, albeit at the expense of a great deal of trouble, caused by resistance to his innovations. However, the workers and the women who complained most about his new discipline were ultimately tied to the place, and so as far as is known, few left. Despite various owner ship problems, the business history of New Lanark suggests that Owen was highly effective in raising both productivity and profits. His personal stake in the business was greatly enhanced in 1806 following Dale’s death, giving access to funds via the Dale Trust that could help the enterprise grow still further.24 At the same time Owen clearly had the leisure to involve himself in intellectual and reform issues, notably the subject of popular education – his first utterances beyond those on the cotton trade. It was this issue that opened the way to his more detailed thinking about social reform issues and New Lanark’s potential as a test-bed for his ideas. As noted above, Owen later claimed that educational innovation was his greatest achievement and represented an acknowledgement of its role in his own life. The Statement Regarding the New Lanark Establishment of 1812 indicated how all this might progress once Owen had the opportunity to act. The more sympathetic partnership of 1814, including the wealthy and brilliant Quakers, John Walker and William Allen, and the famous thinker, Jeremy Bentham, plus Owen’s enormously enhanced stake in the operation, was to make this possible. Once A New View was published and the institute and schools up and running, there was a great deal more interest in Owen and his ideas. As he widened his campaign to embrace the children and the poor, New Lanark attracted growing numbers of visitors, anxious to see Owen and his community. Owen seemed to hold the key to the problems of the day, and the visitors, beyond those coming to see the Falls of Clyde, represented a huge range of enlightened, intellectual and reforming interests from all over Europe, once more opened up to travel after the defeat and fall of Napoleon. All of these people, and in addition many Americans, interacted and opened doors to others. When Owen himself visited Europe in 1818 he was lauded to the skies. How else could he be bold enough to 22
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 22
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues
present memorials to the sovereigns at the Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle in the expectation that his ideas would be taken up? There are many interesting questions about the European tour, highly influential for his educational agenda, which remained the most practical of his plans beyond New Lanark. When translated to New Harmony and other Owenite communities, the schools again and again proved the most successful aspects of the social reform programme.25 After his campaigns of 1817 and the European tour of 1818 Owen devoted himself and his vast resources to promoting the village scheme. How much did this derive from New Lanark and A New View? Their population was to be much the same, the architecture of the earliest designs similar, but the planning and layout were very different. The social arrangements might be comparable but the economic structure differed substantially. Unfortunately Owen was at his weakest in explaining the transposition of capitalism into co-operation, assuming such a shift was then possible. How would all this work, people asked, how would labour be valued, how would property be shared, if at all? What would happen if people wanted to leave?26 Given the contemporary obsession with the poor reproducing themselves in great numbers and the interests of Malthus and others in this debate, could Owen explain how numbers would be regulated in his communities? What about religion and class? How were differences to be accommodated? If the poor were to be educated, to what purpose? Such issues were inescapable, suggest ing that Owen failed to grasp the fact that a community sustained by profits (and huge profits at that) could readily support corporate philanthropy, but that it would be very difficult to maintain this in an enterprise where cooperation rather than competition prevailed. As events at New Harmony, Orbiston and later Queenwood proved, New Lanark was in many ways an inappropriate model. However, as with much else we need to see this in the context of the time and remember that Owen spoke of ‘trials’ or ‘experiments’ that might alleviate distress and at the same time promote social and moral regeneration.27 There are inevitably numerous issues swirling about Owen that take us beyond New Lanark, although in speculating about them many times we are returned there. The rejection of organized religion was not unusual for someone who had been personally touched by Enlightenment thinking, who had become effectively a deist (rather than an agnostic). Owen believed he had been called by some divine force to lead a crusade of social and moral reformation. He continued to use religious and millennial language. His 23
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 23
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Ian Donnachie
attack, more specifically, was not on religion but on sectarianism, as he was generally careful to make clear, since the clergy remained highly influential and he needed their support as much as that of other elites. And while local ministers of the Scottish Kirk pursued Owen because they thought he was treading on their toes, many clergy seemed to have been interested in his ideas about the treatment of the poor and parochial education which, beyond the gospel and moral order, were the prime concerns of their parish ministries. Owen’s clerical connections were themselves of a high order in cluding proÂ�fessors of theology in the Scottish universities, the archbishop of Canterbury, many senior bishops, leading dissenters, even the members of the Irish Catholic hierarchy whom he addressed at Maynooth during the Irish tour of 1822–3. However, there is no question that, after 1817, when he first pronounced on religion, the issue of secularism constantly got Owen into trouble and muddied the waters of Owenism during his many campaigns.28 Owen’s emphasis on education was another key issue around which debate inevitably arose. If society was to be made moral, then character formation was a key educational aim. But beyond that what was the working class to be taught and to what purpose? Despite the interest the schools and the curriculum at New Lanark and in the later communities generated, these questions remained unanswered. Even more puzzling was Owen’s view that the working class was too ignorant to vote, when the implementation of a scheme of popular education he was actively promoting as early as 1815 might overcome that impediment. Owen is often said to have avoided political action, at least before the 1830s. But in the dangerous times after 1815, even if he had been inclined towards political intervention, it would have made little sense for him to pursue this avenue. As it was, he made extensive use of parliamentary connections through sympathetic MPs, members of the House of Lords and his parliamentary candidature of 1820 which, although he failed to get elected, garnered him additional publicity. His connections with the political elite were extensive not only in Britain and Ireland but also in Europe and above all in the USA, where even Owen’s manservant was said to have shaken hands with every living president. This story reminds us of Owen’s remarkable ability to ease his way into the salons of the political elite, the great and the good. Was it wealth, charisma and benevolence that made this possible? Always one returns to the notion of an enormously successful and wealthy businessman with solutions to the problems of the time, none of which necessarily negate his genuine benevolence. Even though 24
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 24
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues
his ideas were sometimes overambitious and unrealistic, people regardless of class would listen if it suited their own interests. Gender issues also became increasingly important in Owenism. At New Lanark, they are seen in the central role women played in both the work force and the home, and in their participation in many community activities. In the schools the infant provision, the openness of the curriculum to girls as well as boys, the evening schools, and the women engaged in classroom teaching and lecturing, were all exceptional for the time. Catherine Whitwell, sister of the Owenite architect Stedman Whitwell, was clearly highly in novative in her use of visual aids and teaching of natural history, one of several subjects not seen in school curricula for several generations.29 Owen was a promoter of equality so far as it could be taken at the time. He decried the marriage laws, and especially the married property laws, as further means of victimizing women (though it has to be admitted he had been a bene ficiary of Dale’s fortune). His promotion of birth control as a means of checking population, as well as easing the lot of women, was always discreet. Indeed he never spoke openly, but always in riddles and made much of his knowledge, claiming to ‘possess the means’ or ‘know a secret’ which would solve the problem of poverty. It is an interesting speculation that he was as widely recognized for his covert promotion of contraception as for his championÂ�ing of reform generally, and that this gave his message a particular appeal to women. Certainly huge numbers of the female sex flocked to his meetings, some in Dublin being so overcome by the crowd (rather than the charisma of Owen himself?) that they had to be passed through windows to recover their composure. Even larger numbers of women, and of all classes, visited the New Lanark schools, particularly to see the infant school and the famous dancing children. Owen and his relationship with and to women beyond their roles in the communities is a subject that merits more detailed investigation. Although it is notoriously difficult to decode, Owen certainly seems to have had an enormous appeal to women. Social reform, rather than politics or civil life, was one of the few fields in which women could be involved, and this might well explain the importance of the man as much as his message. What of Owen’s leaving New Lanark behind for the New World and New Harmony? There is no doubt that after the failure of his efforts to get govern ment support in Britain and then in Ireland Owen became increasingly dis illusioned. The odd thing is that, even on the basis of his own calculations, he could well afford his own community and the evidence points to the 25
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 25
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Ian Donnachie
failed Motherwell Scheme actually bringing him a profit when he sold the land back to General Hamilton of Dalzell. Owen had become acquainted with many Americans and was very well informed about the United States, where he knew land was cheap and the costs of setting up any venture poten tially lower than they would be in Britain. Thanks to this association with American reformers, he gained the impression that the US government was likely to be more susceptible to his powers of persuasion and the potential of his plans than the reactionary politicians he had dealt with in Britain, all of whom gave him polite attention but were evidently not prepared to act. The post-war economic slump had hurt New Lanark and the partnership’s profits, though all the partners including Owen were still enormously rich. Further, the attacks against him by some of the clergy seemed to suggest that his own glowing reports of labour and community relations at New Lanark were not the complete truth.30 In the summer of 1824 the potential of the US was confirmed by another reformer and educationist, William Maclure, who may well have raised the possibility of a prospective partner ship in an American community. The fact that the Harmonist’s agent, George Flower, appeared at New Lanark soon after Maclure’s visit suggests an orchestrated campaign to persuade Owen into inspecting Harmonie. Contrary to the advice of another American, the artist Chester Harding, who thought a community was more likely to succeed in the eastern states rather than the wilds, Owen quickly decided to cross the Atlantic to inspect the community on the Indiana frontier. Given that the Scottish Owenites Abram Combe and Archibald James Hamilton seemed likely to make progress with their revamped Motherwell Scheme at Orbiston, only fifteen miles from New Lanark, there are more interesting questions about Owen’s position. Why did he not link up with Combe and Hamilton, since they had been loyal supporters for years? Hamilton had even accompanied him to Ireland and Combe had begun publishing works about Owen’s ideas. Did Owen have to be the first and have to prove he could do it himself? Did he want to avoid the risk of others taking the credit? Did he know he would probably lose money in Britain and stood a better chance of making a profit in Indiana even if the com munity scheme did not succeed? Beyond Harding many others were puzzled, from the British and Irish supporters left behind to those Owen and his party later encountered on board ship or on arrival in the States. Limitations of space make it impossible to relate the remarkable story of New Harmony, but it certainly throws up numerous issues as well as points of comparison and 26
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 26
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues
contrast with New Lanark and the British communities, notably Orbiston, another victim of dystopian confusion. New Harmony may have been an economic failure but Owen retained substantial assets there, and socially and culturally it was an interesting experiment in Owenism. Indeed Owen’s activities in the US and later in Mexico surely indicate the huge reach and influence of this remarkable individual who had learned so much at New Lanark. Owen’s later record as ‘Social Father’ reveals nearly thirty years of un remitting efforts to sustain the proposals set out in A New View of Society and other works of the 1800s. How could Owen jump from one platform to another and adapt the message to suit the context? How could he remain so consistently optimistic in the face of all the odds? The term ‘failure’ is not used, because Owen did not fail. His message was appropriate for the time and, like both factory reform and popular education, eventually brought results. The man and the movement he inspired were wholly committed to social betterment and driven by ideals which challenged the inequalities of late Georgian and early Victorian Britain. The fact that it took so long to effect real social change, beyond the modest changes we have reviewed in Owen’s lifetime, may be explained by the prevalence of notions of laissezfaire that were rejected by Owen and the Owenites. In common with other liberal and radical thinkers, they were struggling against an established order that proved highly resistant to change. Reform was a long-term business.31 So, what did Robert Owen actually achieve at New Lanark? He made New Lanark world famous, a focus of fair treatment for workers and for the promotion of a raft of pioneering educational and environmental ideas linked to social and moral regeneration. Owen had enjoyed many advantages in the place, its single industry focus, its distinctive, even unique, location, its relation to an established community, the support of local elites plus the tacit approval of the civic authorities in Old Lanark and the county, to make it an ideal test-bed for his ideas. He found in David Dale’s New Lanark further confirmation of general notions developed earlier in Manchester, and there was much that was circumstantial in the course of events. With the help of others like Godwin and Place, to name but two, Owen while at New Lanark developed his insights into a social system and then a plan of regeneration apparently appropriate to the time, but in reality timeless in its application. Working on the principles of character formation Owen made famous, New Lanark could be said to have influenced him more than he did it. Nevertheless the achievement was undoubtedly of unusual significance 27
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 27
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Ian Donnachie
for the development of his ideas and his influence on issues of workplace relations, community, citizenship, co-operation and the environment – that resonate powerfully to this day. While there is much that Owen left unsaid and much that continues to puzzle us about his ideas and motives, they remain strikingly modern in their potential application. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation recently reported that society had lost its ‘moral compass’, with government, the media, big business and religion sharing the responsibility. In 1904, the founder of the social policy charity had identified poverty, war, slavery, intemperance, the opium trade, impurity and gambling as the ‘great scourges of humanity’. According to the study of a century later the top ten evils were: the decline of community, indi vidualism, consumerism and greed, a decline of values, the decline of the family, young people as both victims and perpetrators, drugs and alcohol, poverty and inequality, immigration and responses to it, and crime and violence. The report concluded that people felt a strong sense of unease about some of the changes shaping British society. ‘People are concerned about the way our society has become more individualistic, greedy and selfish, seemingly at a cost to our sense of community.’ The media were criticized for propagating negative and damaging attitudes, and religion was identified as a cause of conflict and confusion. Big business was blamed for fuelling inequality and consumerism (its culpability exacerbated by global financial crises).32 Sadly all of this suggests that despite rapid economic and social progress the problems Owen confronted are still with us. More than a century and a half after his demise his message rings out loud and clear from the place he made famous in A New View of Society, essays remarkably still in print two centuries after their publication.
Notes This chapter is based on ideas presented in the Robert Owen Commemorative Lecture at New Lanark, May 2008 and in the Robert Owen and His Legacy Conference, Gregynog, August 2008. ╇2 In addition to the seminal study by J. F. C. Harrison, Robert Owen and the Owenites in Britain and America: The Quest for the New Moral World (London, 1969), the two bicentenial collections by John Butt (ed.), Robert Owen: Prince of Cotton Spinners (Newton Abbot, 1971) and by Sidney Pollard and John Salt (eds), Robert Owen: Prophet of the Poor (London, 1971), see inter alia R. G. ╇1
28
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 28
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Robert Owen: Reputations and Burning Issues
╇
╇
╇
╇ ╇
╇
╇
3
4
5
6 7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Garnett, Co-operation and the Owenite Socialist Communities in Britain, 1825-45 (Manchester, 1972), Anne Taylor, Visions of Harmony: A Study in Nineteenth Century Millenarianism (Oxford, 1987), Edward Royle, Robert Owen and the Commencement of the Millennium: A Study of the Harmony Community (Manchester, 1998), Ian Donnachie, Robert Owen: Owen of New Lanark and New Harmony (East Linton, 2000; 2nd edn as Robert Owen: Social Visionary, Edinburgh, 2005), and the collections by Chushichi Tsuzuki (ed.), Robert Owen and the World of Co-operation (Tokyo, 1992) and Chushichi Tsuzuki, Naobumi Hijikata and Akira Kurimoto (eds), The Emergence of Global Citizenship: Utopian Ideas, Cooperative Movements and the Third Sector (Tokyo, 2005). For major publications by Owen and the Owenites see SWRO and OSPC. On New Lanark’s history and its role in Owen’s promotion of his views see Ian Donnachie and George Hewitt, Historic New Lanark: The Dale and Owen Industrial Community since 1785 (Edinburgh, 1993; 1999). Robert Owen, A Statement Regarding the New Lanark Establishment (Edinburgh, 1812) [SWRO, 1, pp. 13–21]. Beyond his parish and interest in poor relief issues, Duncan was a proprietor of the Dumfries and Galloway Courier. SWRO, 4, pp. 162–4. For modern editions of the essays with contextual commentaries see Robert Owen, A New View of Society and Other Writings (ed. Gregory Claeys, Harmondsworth, 1991); SWRO; and Ian Donnachie and Carmen Lavin (eds), From Enlightenment to Romanticism: Anthology II (Manchester, 2004). See SWRO, 4, p. 114, the first of many references in his autobiography to the role of religion in his thinking; Donnachie, Robert Owen: Social Visionary, pp. 83, 118, 180 on religion at New Lanark. On Dale and his regime see Donnachie and Hewitt, Historic New Lanark, pp. 17–58; David MacLaren, David Dale: A Bright Luminary to Scotland, 2nd edn (Glasgow, 1990). Donnachie, Robert Owen: Social Visionary, pp. 121–31. The best single account of his participation in the factory movement at the time is still J. T. Ward, ‘Owen as factory reformer’, in John Butt (ed.), Robert Owen: Prince of Cotton Spinners (Newton Abbot, 1971), pp. 99–134. On factory children generally a recent excellent study is Peter Kirby, Child Labour in Britain, 1750–1870 (London, 2003). John Griscom, A Year in Europe (New York and London, 1823), II, pp. 385–6. Griscom’s account of Owen’s educational system proved highly influential in both Britain and the US. David J. McLaren, ‘Education for citizenship and the new moral world of Robert Owen’, Scottish Educational Review, 32 (2000), 107–16; Donnachie, Robert Owen: Social Visionary, pp. 149–50, 165–70. Falla merits further research as he clearly played a critical role in Owen’s thinking about the agricultural basis of the proposed communities, evidently touring Ireland with Owen and visiting Orbiston. 29
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 29
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Ian Donnachie 14 15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
SWRO, 1, pp. 287–332. Owen, it has to be said, experienced many such moments, but the apposite phrase was coined by W. H. Oliver, ‘Owen in 1817: the millennialist moment’, in Sidney Pollard and John Salt (eds), Robert Owen: Prophet of the Poor (London, 1971), pp. 166–87. Gregory Claeys, Machinery, Money and the Millennium: From Moral Economy to Socialism, 1815–1860 (Princeton, 1987), provides a detailed discussion of Owen’s thinking in relation to the then current orthodoxy and other views; see also his introductions to the two collections cited above. A concise overview of Owen’s economic ideas is found in Ian Donnachie, ‘Robert Owen’, in David Rutherford (ed.), The Biographical Dictionary of British Economists (London, 2004), pp. 887–91. Owen’s links to co-operation have generated a substantial literature, partly of a historical nature, partly positioning Owen’s views in the modern co-operative movement. Recent contributions include Stephen Yeo (ed.), New Views of Cooperation (London, 1988); Tsuzuki (ed.), Robert Owen and the World of Cooperation; and Richard Bickle and Molly Scott Cato (eds), New Views of Society: Robert Owen for the 21st Century (Glasgow, 2009). On the labour notes see Takashi Maruyama, ‘The local currencies and Robert Owen’s Labour Notes’ in Chushichi Tsuzuki, Naobumi Hijikata and Akira Kurimoto (eds), The Emergence of Global Citizenship: Utopian Ideas, Co-operative Movements and the Third Sector (Tokyo, 2005), pp. 111–27. For early biographies see Harrison, Robert Owen. Frank Podmore, Robert Owen: A Biography (2 vols, London, 1906) remains a key source, as does Alexander Cullen, Adventures in Socialism: New Lanark Establishment and Orbiston Community (Glasgow, 1910; new edition 1972). Ian Donnachie, ‘Robert Owen’s Welsh childhood: kin, culture and environment 1771–c.1781’, Montgomeryshire Collections, 86 (1998), 81–96. On the Highlanders see Margaret Nicolson and Ian Donnachie, ‘The New Lanark Highlanders: migra tion, community and language 1785– c.1850’, Family and Community History, 6 (2003), 19–32. Donnachie, Robert Owen: Social Visionary, pp. 20–36, on his apprenticeship and retail background. There is undoubtedly scope for further discoveries on Owen’s business history and his interest in reform issues. Ian Donnachie, ‘Historic tourism to New Lanark and the Falls of Clyde 1795– 1830’, Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, 2 (2004), 145–62. This has been investigated in both England and Scotland, but not as far as I know in the US. I suggest money was the great lever, though the power of his personality was considerable. John Butt, ‘Robert Owen as a businessman’, in idem (ed.), Robert Owen: Prince of Cotton Spinners (Newton Abbot, 1971), pp. 168–214, remains the best account of his business acumen. 30
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 30
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Introduction 25
26 27
28
29
30 31
32
There is a substantial literature on the educational and social aims of Owenism. Valuable reviews are David McLaren, ‘Robert Owen, William Maclure and New Harmony’, History of Education, 25 (1996), 223–33; and idem, ‘Education for citizenship’, Scottish Educational Review, 32 (2000), 107–16. See also Ian Donnachie, ‘Education in Robert Owen’s New Society: The New Lanark Institute and Schools’, the encyclopaedia of informal education (2003) www.infed.org/thinkers/et-owen. htm; and for wider perspectives Harrison, Robert Owen, and Taylor, Visions of Harmony. These were the major issues underpinning the economics of the communities. Ralahine has been the object of recent research, including Vincent Geoghegan, ‘Ralahine: Ireland’s lost utopia’, Communal Studies, 9 (1989), 91–104. A recent contribution is Richard J. Cherok, Debating for God: Alexander Campbell’s Challenge to Skepticism in Antebellum America (Abilene, TX, 2008). Some further information has come to light on Catherine Whitwell, but she would repay investigation. There is a growing literature on gender issues in Owenism, most recently Catherine Durieux, ‘Marriage as seen by Robert Owen and the Owenites’, in Chushichi Tsuzuki, Naobumi Hijikata and Akira Kurimoto (eds), The Emergence of Global Citizenship, pp. 95–109. Donnachie, Robert Owen: Social Visionary, pp. 195–9. It is often forgotten that while Owenism faded, the ideas continued to influence reform and many Owenites occupied important positions in later popular move ments in Britain, the US and elsewhere. Beth Watts, Charlie Lloyd, Alice Mowlam, and Chris Creegan, Modern-Day Social Evils: The Voices of Unheard Groups (York, 2008).
31
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 31
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 32
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
2
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
Gregory Claeys
This volume commemorates the 150th anniversary of the death of Robert Owen, born at Newtown on 14 May 1771, who returned to expire gently at the Bear Inn, near his place of birth, 87 years later, on 17 November 1858.1 It is also very slightly over one hundred and ninety years since, on Graham Wallas’s admirably precise reckoning, Owen began to preach socialism, at that memorable meeting at the City of London Tavern, at a quarter to one on 21 August 1817, when he first publicly announced his disrespect for all established religious opinions.2 By coincidence, it is also thirty years since I became a historian of socialism and began to plough in Owen’s field. It may be, therefore, that this is an appropriate occasion to consider how much the historiography of socialism has altered in principle as a result of the failure over the past twenty years of its most famous experiment, the inter national communist state system. Owen remained throughout his life, after that August afternoon, a controversial figure, in his views on education, religion, politics, socialism, the malleability of human behaviour, and much else. How we view these issues, however, has altered greatly over the decades. I have elsewhere considered how Owen’s late Victorian reputation was expressed in biographies.3 This essay examines how, in the light of the collapse of Marx ian socialism, we should view Owen’s reputation vis-à-vis first, the later socialist movement and then, in reference to some more contemporary concerns. For about a century, from the 1880s to the 1980s, the historiography of socialism was dominated by a binary, teleological division between the ‘utopian’ socialists, principally Owen, Fourier and Saint-Simon, who were
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 33
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Gregory Claeys
rather awkwardly mustered together, and their ‘scientific’ successors, Marx, Engels and Co. This juxtaposition was of course imposed upon the histori ography by Marx and his disciples, who, while they have made many notable contributions to historiography, could never be accused of writing without an ill-disguised contempt for their deluded socialist forebears, and accordingly, in this field at least, have much to answer for. From the Manifesto of the Communist Party (1848) onwards, we have been persistently told that ‘utopian’ socialism was both pre- and unscientific, that it had been superseded by its Marxian successor, and that what remained was of largely idle historical interest, fit for the socialist equivalent of boy scout character-building tales and not much else. Not all Owen scholarship has been dominated by these categories; the more incisive studies of Owenism, notably those by J. F. C. Harrison and Edward Royle, do not deploy this scheme, preferring an emphasis on Owenite ‘communitarianism’ and abjuring comparisons with most forms of later socialism.4 Nor, though my own starting-point as a historian was partly Marxist, did I ever feel much sympathy for the propositions this dichotomy implies, my own preference being for a simple chronological distinction between ‘early’ and ‘later’ socialism. Yet the dichotomy remains surprisingly resilient in the literature of socialism as a whole, as well as in that of utopianism. This is lamentable and requires redress. This essay asks how far the narrative framework of the above categories actually accounts for the development of later Victorian and Edwardian socialism. Was there a ‘break’ between ‘utopian’ and ‘scientific’ socialism, or do these labels describe contending traditions within socialism which never disappeared, but remained juxtaposed, side by side, up to the present? The question will be addressed in four stages: first looking briefly at the ‘utopian–scientific’ nomenclature; then considering how a number of later socialist writers viewed Owen, giving (thirdly) a special precedence to one case, that of Alfred Russel Wallace, about whom little has been written. Finally the merits of the ‘utopian’ label today will be assessed by looking specifically at three interrelated areas: the question of the scale of life, the meaning of socialism when defined as ‘community’, and the issue of socialist cosmopolitanism, and asking what resonances, if any, these quintessentially Owenite themes retain for us in the twenty-first century.
34
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 34
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
The Emergence of ‘Utopian’ vs. ‘Scientific’ Socialism First, we need briefly to be reminded how Owen came to be categorized pejoratively as a ‘utopian’ socialist. In the Manifesto of the Communist Party Marx distinguished between ‘Critical-Utopian Socialism and Communism’. Here it is ‘the undeveloped state of the class struggle, as well as their own surroundings’ which ‘causes Socialists of this kind to consider themselves far superior to all antagonisms’, which in turn leads them to ‘reject all political, and especially all revolutionary, action’ in favour of attaining ‘their ends by peaceful means, and small experiments, necessarily doomed to failure’. What gives their critical component ‘a purely utopian element’ is thus in particular the extent to which their ‘proposals point solely to the disappearance of class antagonisms which were, at the time, only just cropping up, and which . . . are recognised in their earliest indistinct and undefined forms only’.5 The lack of recognition of the agency of the proletariat in effecting the overÂ�throw of capitalism, in other words, the seeing it solely as ‘the most suffering class’, was crucially ‘utopian’.6 In the later pamphlet, Socialism: Utopian and Scientific, Engels also lent weight to the ‘discovery’ of the ma teriÂ�alÂ�ist conception of history, or the analysis which predicted the inevitability of capitalist crisis and proletarian revolution, and to the ‘revelation of the secret of capitalist production through surplus value’. He was willing to acknowledge that ‘Every social movement, every real advance in England on behalf of the workers links itself to the name of Robert Owen’. But he would not admit that he had done Owen an injustice in insisting that the latter believed that ‘Socialism is the expression of absolute truth, reason, and justice, and has only to be discovered to conquer all the world by virtue of its own power. And as absolute truth is independent of time, place, and of the historical development of man, it is a mere accident when and where it is discovered.’7 The concept of ‘scientific’ socialism, then, rested on the claim of the un historical nature of the ‘utopians’. Such a claim was itself founded upon three premises: the necessity of violent class struggle by the proletariat, the veracity of Marx’s predictive capacity, and the concept of surplus value. Lenin would reduce these formulae to the simpler description of the ‘utopian character of the plans of the old advocates of co-operation, beginning with Robert Owen’s failing to take ‘into account such basic questions as the class war, the conquest of political power by the working class and overthrow of the rule of the class exploiters’.8 35
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 35
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Gregory Claeys
To examine these premises in adequate detail would take us far beyond our concerns here. There are, however, serious misconceptions both in the delineation of the supposedly ‘utopian’ qualities of Owen, and the superior ‘scientific’ insights of Marx. In particular, Owen did not believe that the system could be transformed at any possible time, but in fact built upon a stadial concept of social development which proclaimed that the advent of commercial society, as the leading Scottish theorists termed it, coupled with industrialization, alone provided the means of securing an adequate standard of living for the majority. Owen’s theory of the unequal exchange of labour between capitalist and labourer also accomplished, albeit in cruder form, much of what would be described in Marx’s theory of surplus value. Owen ism developed a relatively sophisticated theory of capitalist crisis, and so sophisticated a theorist as John Hobson, thus, would later write that ‘The Owenite and early Socialistic analyses and proposals presented a powerful and various challenge to the theory and accepted practice of the capitalist control of industry for private profit, anticipating almost all the valid critic ism of the later socialism.’9 Owen notably in 1833–4, also attempted to utilize proletarian power to engineer a fundamental shift in the capitalist system. There also remains the counter-charge that it was Marx, rather than Owen, who was the more utopian, in proposing a world-historical revoÂ�lution occurring throughout the advanced capitalist countries and accompanied by a substantial improvement in human behaviour, not to mention the later vision of communist society which was to follow the dictatorship of the prole tariat. And Marx’s predictive capacity respecting the inevitability of capitalism’s demise hardly inspires confidence in 2008, when, while the system indeed retains the instability and destructiveness which marked its nineteenth-century emergence, we had a New Labour government willing to forestall the Apoca lypse by spending £50 billion to bail out only one immiserated bank. Let us turn, however, to see what validity this utopian/scientific polarity may possess as a way of reading the transition from early to later nineteenth-century socialism.
Remembering Owen c.1870–1914 How far, then, do later nineteenth-century acknowledgements of Owen’s pioneering role shed light on the utopian/scientific categorization? The case presented here is that Owen’s legacy clearly remained relevant to socialists through the First World War, but that many conceded that developments since 36
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 36
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
his death meant that this inheritance had to be understood in a new way and, for many, not in the terms suggested by Marx and Engels. The remem brance of Owen in the decades after his death mainly took the form of annual birthday celebrations, which were regular and well attended down to the end of the century. The socialist press of this period was also full of tributes to Owen’s impact. To take only a few instances: in 1901 the Labour Leader praised Owen as ‘the beloved apostle of the working classes although he was a Tory’, and insisted that he had been ‘the first to discover that pro duction and distribution for profit were the causes of the misery of the poor and the selfish luxury of the rich’.10 A discussion in the same year respecting the erection of a memorial to Owen noted that he had ‘conclusively proved that a rough and unruly class can, by altering their surroundings, have their character entirely changed’.11 Lecturing at Leicester in 1907, the rationalist John M. Robertson praised Owen’s ‘benevolent temper’ compared with the ‘ill-will and class animus of the Marxians and the Labour Party’.12 During the development of enthusiasm for Guild Socialism, too, various commen tators noted the ‘striking similarity’ between Guild ideas and those of Owen, with one asserting that ‘Owen’s proposals were akin to Syndicalism, as he intended the land and instruments to be owned by their users. The Trade Unions, as “national companies”, were to control industry very much as is contended by the Syndicalist of to-day.’13 And yet we should acknowledge contemporary criticisms, too. A review of Frank Podmore’s biography of Owen in 1906 noted that Owen was: a stupendous bore . . .what was evidently at the root of many of his deficiencies [was] that he had no touch of artistic genius . . . This absence of artistry explains why his voluminous writings are unreadable and unread; why his quadrilangular paradises, modelled on Lancashire cotton-mills, appear to us not only impossible, but detestable as modern ‘model dwellings’ for the working classes; why his ideal – for others – of simple material comfort, communities of well-fed, well-housed artizans living in compounds, seems inadequate and unattractive.14
Podmore himself, too, offered a critical judgement on Owen in concluding that he had failed: to celebrate the sterner virtuesâ•‚justice, fortitude, chastity, reverence. Under the Social System there would be, Owen and his followers held, no room for such virtues, no need for struggle and endurance, for heroism and fruitless 37
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 37
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Gregory Claeys
self-surrender; but also no wide horizons, no insatiable hope or celestial ardours. To eat and drink and be clothed, and therewithal to be content – such is the Paradise to which he invites us.15
And, in another critical aside, in 1910, Walter F. Roch MP suggested that Owen ‘passed quickly from one thing to another, swayed by emotion rather than passion. He dreamt dreams but he saw no visions’ and was ‘one-fifth businessman and four-fifths mystic’.16 There were grander commemorative occasions in which it was Owen’s virtues that were recalled. The most important of these occurred a century ago on the occasion of the fiftieth anniversary of Owen’s death, when a large meeting was held in Lanark, in June 1908. The principal speakers were Keir Hardie and James Ramsay MacDonald. Large numbers of people arrived by special trains (the Glasgow train was late). Many of the men wore red ties, and the women red rosettes. Hardie said of Owen on this occasion that ‘nearly every great idea of advancement or progression in our own time had been inspired by him’. This ‘great and god-like man’, he said, ‘had appeared to the people with a message, and the message was that the business of the child was not to make profits, but to enjoy this life’. He added: The great merit of Robert Owen’s work consisted in the fact that whilst he was environed by an atmosphere of selfishness, he proclaimed that Altruism – not each for self but each for all – was the true law of life and progress. Robert Owen’s central thought had been this – that the business of teachers and statesmen and all who were able to influence the life of the people, was to assist each individual in developing his life along joyous lines.17
Ramsay MacDonald’s view was that they were celebrating the memory of Robert Owen because he was a great personality – a man who saw more clearly than any other of his time, what the permanent elements of human society were going to be. Owen was a man of a heart, a man of an aspiration, a man of the inner light, at a time when everybody was seeking to pile up wealth, trying to satisfy themselves with things that perish. Before Ruskin wrote, before Carlyle was in his cradle, Robert Owen was telling men that there was no wealth but life.18
Another meeting later in the same year described him as ‘the great pioneer’ in the fields of ‘rational education, factory legislation, trade unionism, co38
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 38
10/3/2011 7:49:16 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
operation, labour exchanges, work for the unemployed, the emancipation of women, penal reform and international peace’.19 If we consider the twenty or so years preceding this, we may note that from the socialist revival of the early 1880s onwards acknowledgements were made of the links between earlier and later forms. From the leaders of the movement we may cull only a few comments on Owen. The Social Democratic Federation’s controversial founder, H. M. Hyndman praised Owen for having produced ‘not only some of the most luminous thoughts on political economy ever met on paper’, but also an important ‘proposal for the formation of a Federation of the civilized powers of Europe’.20 He conceded that Owen had demonstrated that machinery produced a glut of commodities and consequent working-class unemployment, and praised him for having shown ‘the right path towards education and industrial organ ization for the young’, even terming the system of education at New Lanark ‘the most successful ever seen’.21 The Socialist League lecturer, famed designer and poet William Morris, though he evinced some sympathy for Owen, also condemned his ‘shortcoming’ as ‘the necessary one of the utopist, a total disregard of the political side of progress; he failed to see that his experiments, useful as they were from that point of view, could never develope [sic] out of the experimental state as long as the governors of Society forcibly uphold the so-called “rights of property”.’22 The leading Fabian Sidney Webb said that Owen’s ‘constant insistence on the corporate duty of the community to its individual members was really the forerunner of the successful “municipal Socialism” which our great cities have since taken up’.23 His fellow Fabian Graham Wallas insisted that ‘It is difficult to exaggerate the influence of Robert Owen on the more thoughtful working men during the first half of the century’. The Independent Labour Party activist and later Labour Party prime minister Ramsay MacDonald also referred to Owen on many occasions besides those already noted. To MacDonald, writing in 1919 in his very influential account, The Socialist Movement, socialism was to be built on public opinion, and: The idea of a revolution transforming the structure of Society by the will of a minority must seem as Utopian to it as the ideas of the Owenites and of all who sought to create an oasis of peace in the wilderness of the capitalist system. It believes in democracy, not only as a moral creed which alone is consistent with its views of humanity, but because it is the only practical creed. It knows that, revolutions or no revolutions, public consent is the basis 39
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 39
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Gregory Claeys
of all social order and that the good builder makes his foundations sound before he puts up his storeys.
MacDonald thus agreed that it was correct to categorize as ‘utopian’ the Owenite phase of socialism. But he altered the way in which this terminology was deployed in a significant way. Owen had been ‘utopian’ because he had believed that ‘Man was assumed to be a fixed entity of desires and modes of action, and not an organism subject to historical change’. The utopian method was, therefore, ‘not organic progress but mechanical renovation’. It was a ‘pre-scientific phase, when Socialism added to a perfectly sound criticism of the present and a pretty clear insight into the future, methods of reconstruction which were inadequate and unsuitable to society’, and because it ‘saw social regeneration coming through the commune’, while ‘the new sees it coming through the state’.24 But elsewhere he saw Owen as having made a contribution here, too. For Owen had provided a ‘positive view of the state as a protector of the weak – and particularly our code of factory legislation; the co-operative movement is its direct fruit; public education and trade unionism owe it much.’25 Keir Hardie, too, writing with MacDonald in 1899, was willing to draw a line between the Independent Labour Party and its early nineteenth-century predecessors, insisting of the former that: British Socialism is not Utopian. It has nothing to do with the founding of ideal communities cut off from the general life of society, taking no part in the great reforming efforts of its time in politics, in social life, and in religion, finding peace in an exile from heroic human effort, and in a divorce from the historical growth of the nation. Even if the success of those communities were more indisputable than it is, they are alien to the spirit of British Socialism, which regards its mission to be the transformation of the whole social fabric.26
Here, then, we have a new definition of the later phase, but one quite different from, indeed often hostile to, the Marxian categories of analysis. This suggests that while earlier nineteenth-century socialism indeed needs to be sharply distinguished from its successors, the terms of this distinction for most mainstream socialists were not those offered by Marx and Engels. The differ ence lies chiefly in attitudes towards centralized political power, towards politics as a matter of principle and towards the state in particular, and towards an ‘organic’, evolutionary or developmental approach to both human 40
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 40
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
nature and social development. The state and Darwin, then, divide the earlier from the later socialists, not revolutionism and class struggle; to most later socialists a minority revolution and dictatorship of the proletariat were, in MacDonald’s terms, ‘utopian’ because any other road than that of democracy was bound to end in ruin. And this plea for ‘public consent’ was clearly nearer to Owen’s vision than that of Marx.
The Legacy of Owenite Socialism: The Case of Alfred Russel Wallace It is worth giving particular attention to Owen’s influence upon one leading later Victorian writer, the naturalist and co-discoverer of the theory of natural selection, Alfred Russel Wallace. This is, first, because little has been written about him in relation to the socialist tradition and, second, because he illus trates the main theme of this essay, that later Victorian socialism in fact exhibits a considerable degree of continuity with Owenite themes, rather than anything like the break implied by the categories of ‘utopian’ and ‘scientific’, and that where such a breach does appear it is along dissimilar lines from those proposed in the original distinction, namely in relation, as seen above in reference to Ramsay Macdonald, to evolutionary theory and to the state. A connection with Robert Owen and Owenism runs through much of Wallace’s long life, starting in early adolescence. In My Life Wallace tells us that he had ‘always looked upon Owen as my first teacher in the philosophy of human nature and my first guide through the labyrinth of social science’, since his first encounter with Owenism at the John Street Institute near Tottenham Court Road in London.27 The initial effect of his encounter with Owenism was, in the first instance, to challenge, and then destroy, Wallace’s religious beliefs. Wallace was also profoundly influenced by the central prin ciple of the Owenite system, the notion that the character of every individual was, as Wallace put it: formed for and not by himself, first by heredity, which gives him his natural disposition with all its powers and tendencies, its good and bad qualities; and, secondly, by environment, including education and surroundings from earliest infancy, which always modifies the original character for better or for worse.28
Readers of Wallace’s Life will also recall its extended discussion of Owen’s mill and schools at New Lanark, much of which was taken from Owen’s 41
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 41
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Gregory Claeys
own Life (1858) and W. L. Sargant’s Robert Owen and His Social Philosophy (1860). Wallace commented extensively on the kind treatment of the workers in Owen’s New Lanark mills, and Owen’s success in reducing hours of labour, improving conditions of work, and fostering child education. He was deeply impressed by the fact that Owen had managed to: transform a discontented, unhealthy, vicious, and wholly antagonistic population of 2500 persons to an enthusiastically favourable, contented, happy; healthy, and comparatively moral community, without ever having recourse to any legal punishment what ever, and without, so far as appears, discharging any individual for robbery, idleness, or neglect of duty; and all this was effected while increasing the efficiency of the whole manufacturing establishment, paying a liberal interest on the capital invested, and even producing a large annual surplus of profits which, in the four years 1809–13, averaged £40,000 a year . . .29
He later wrote, too, of New Lanark, that he knew ‘of no more wonderful example in history’.30 This application of socialist principles, however, Wallace recalled, was in reality only the ‘partial application of Owen’s principles of human nature’: Owen used always to declare that the beneficial results at which all visitors were so much astonished were only one-tenth part of what could and would be produced if his principles were fully applied. If the labour of such a com munity, or of groups of such communities, had been directed with equal skill to produce primarily the necessaries and comforts of life for its own inhabitants, with a surplus of such goods as they could produce most economically, in order by their sale in the surrounding district to be able to supply themselves with such native or foreign products as they required, then each worker would have been able to enjoy the benefits of change of occupation, always having some alternation of out-door as well as indoor work; the hours of labour might be greatly reduced, and all the refinements of life might have been procured and enjoyed by them.31
Wallace’s main criticism of Owen was that he had changed the manner in which his principles were applied: ‘The one great error Owen committed was giving up the New Lanark property and management, and spending his large fortune in the endeavour to found communities in various countries of chance assemblages of adults, which his own principles should have shown him were doomed to failure.’32 42
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 42
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
In the second phase of Wallace’s intellectual development, which occupied most of his middle life, such scepticism about the possibility of great moral improvement of ‘chance assemblages’ of people produced an evident rejection of socialist solutions to poverty. But then his views underwent profound alteration once again, in large part through the influence of Edward Bellamy’s Looking Backward 2000–1887 (1887). Wallace tells us that at length, in 1889, my views were changed once for all, and I have ever since been absolutely convinced, not only that socialism is thoroughly practicable, but that it is the only form of society worthy of civilized beings, and that it alone can secure for mankind continuous mental and moral advancement, together with that true happiness which arises from the full exercise of all their faculties for the purpose of satisfying all their rational needs, desires, and aspirations.33
He added elsewhere: Mr Bellamy has completely altered my views on this matter. He seems to me to have shown that real, not merely delusive liberty, together with full scope for individualism and complete home privacy, is compatible with the most thorough industrial socialism.34
Wallace often acknowledged this debt to Bellamy. He also gave publicity to Bellamy’s scheme for the means of effecting a transition from capitalism to socialism, which included a mixture of the nationalization of chief public services, such as railways, and the municipalization of others, like electricity, gas and water supply. Crucial to the transition was also to be the abolition of all inheritance of property by those not directly heirs of its owners, a principle Wallace had accepted many years earlier.35 He also accepted Bellamy’s principle of ‘coupons’, in which money which alone was capable of ‘represenÂ� ting productive work’ was the ‘only true standard of value and the best instrument of exchange’ – which was a wholly Owenite ideal as well.36 With this alteration in the currency mechanism, Wallace anticipated that those employed in government service would alone enjoy the advantage of having their wages exchangeable at government shops and for government services. Increasingly, those possessing the old gold and silver currency would find themselves at a disadvantage; the old currency would become devalued, and its possessors would increasingly enter the government service.37 This is nothing like Owen’s ‘Plan’, although it bears some resemblance to proposals 43
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 43
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Gregory Claeys
by writers like John Gray in the 1820s and 1830s, who had been inspired by Owen and by some labour exchange proposals in the early 1830s. If a more statist approach to socialism demarcates Wallace’s later socialism from his earlier sympathies, his co-discovery, with Darwin, of the theory of natural selection also played a vital role in defining his socialist outlook. The starting-point of Wallace’s Bellamy phase was thus partly ‘to reply to the common objection against Socialism, that it would lead to a too rapid increase of population’.38 This defined the specific perspective which Wallace would adopt towards socialism in this period. He was clearly aware that the principles of natural selection were widely perceived as having a human and social application, and that this had been broadly (indeed was increasingly) construed as supporting the virtues of individual economic competition as the principal means of weeding out the human ‘fit’ from the ‘unfit’. This conclusion Wallace would resoundingly dismiss, but without rejecting the case for a necessary improvement in human type, and this, too, in the rela tively short term. The question was how to reconcile this with a desire for a more just and egalitarian society. To Wallace the ‘first scientific application of my conviction’ entailed the proclamation that socialism alone could provide the means for regulating both the size and the quality of the human population. Thus he was able to refute, or at least to evade, the ‘gloomy’ conclusion Darwin himself had drawn about the future of human evolution on the basis of the fact that ‘in our modern civilization natural selection had no play, and the fittest did not survive. Those who succeed in the race for wealth are by no means the best or the most intelligent, and it is notorious that our population is more largely renewed in each generation from the lower than from the middle and upper classes.’39 Wallace also thought that women would play a crucial role in the improved process of sexual selection in the future, choosing their mates with evolutionary progress in mind, at least some of the time. Hence, Wallace contended, ‘when the course of social evolution shall have led to a more rational organization of society, the problem will receive its final solution by the action of physiological and social agencies, and in perfect harmony with the highest interests of humanity.’40
Owen’s Ideal of ‘Community’ as an Enduring Concept Let us now turn to evaluate Owen’s legacy from a more contemporary view point. We have seen that historians often refer to the Owenite movement, 44
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 44
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
by contrast with Marxism, as one of ‘communitarian’ socialism; that is to say, one in which the small-scale community is enjoined as providing a superior mode of life by contrast with either an exclusively urban or rural existence. After some initial flirtation with this ideal, particularly on Engels’s part, in the middle and later 1840s, Marx and Engels abandoned their sympathy for it thereafter, and it is difficult to imagine a day spent alternately engaging in hunting, fishing, herding cattle, and critical criticism, in the famous image of the German Ideology, in any of the later Marxist portrayals of the future communist society. What, then, are the resonances of the communitarian ideal today? Does it retain any relevance at all to the wider world or is this, too, a ‘utopian’ legacy now long surpassed? To many such an ideal is likely to be dismissed as archaic in a world in which half the population now lives in overcrowded cities. Moreover, the pressure of conformity, and the suppression of indi viduality entailed, which are associated with the original communitarian ideal, find scant appeal outside intentional communities, which are often religious, or suit those seeking voluntary subordination to some form of charismatic higher authority. The extreme magnification of these demands in totalitarian form has made us rightly wary of enforced sociability on an enlarged scale, and of the subordination of the individual to the communal as an ideological ethos. We must admit the possibility that it may well, indeed, have killed off the socialist idea in principle. Yet the problem of the scale of life was recognized by later nineteenth-century socialists as remain ing crucial to defining the quality of life. We should not, in this sense, insist that a communitarian response was simply abandoned after the socialist revival of the 1880s. Three brief examples indicate that it was not. First, we should recall that on its original formation in 1883 the Fellowship of the New Life, the parent organization of the Fabian Society, considered forming a utopian community, possibly along the lines of Owen’s New Harmony, in South America.41 The dominant member of the Fabian group at this time was Frank Podmore. Secondly, William Morris, commenting on Owen in 1889, noted that while ‘the living in small communities is not in theory an essential of this great change . . . I have little doubt that it would bring about such a way of living and abolish big cities, which . . . I think much to be desired’.42 Thirdly, and perhaps from a more unexpected source, and in a very different way, we have H. G. Wells’s extensive comment of 1905, describing the housing of the future. The universal landowner, the state, has contracted private companies to build public housing. Here Wells observed: 45
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 45
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Gregory Claeys
Isolated single houses for poor people . . . scarcely exist at all; the common form of residence is in a club building or college, and the rent paid covers not only the private apartments of the tenant, but the club subscription. The residential club is controlled by a committee representing the occupiers and the owners in variable proportions.
The commonest shape, Wells noted, was ‘in the form of a large quadrangle, containing a finely-kept grass plot, and a paved covered passage about it’, like an Oxford college, in the centre of which were ‘a sundial and four little beds of flowers; nearly a thousand feet in total’. Here the town where work took place was thirty minutes away by train. The quadrangle included kitchens and dining rooms, crèches and kindergartens, recreation rooms, a gym, a library and an infirmary. Movable partitions in bedrooms allow regrouping; there are no fireplaces; hot water is used for heating; and ‘better class houses had a dressing-room with a bath and so forth, connected with each bedroom.’43 To emphasize his theme, ‘A woman’s day in Utopia’, Wells stressed the fact that ‘a working woman’s life was infinitely easier and more refined’ in these improved circumstances than it was ‘in the horrible little independent houses’ of his time. To those, then, who had assumed that a parallelogram ideal could never appeal to later urban dwellers, Wells clearly offered a resolute ‘no’: the problem lay not in the design as such, nor the communitarian content, but in the degree of regimentation the scheme demanded, or alternatively, the degree of privacy and individuality it permitÂ�ted, which is the same point Wallace had made. Nor is this an image of parallelograms for paupers: this is a solidly bourgeois conception of collective life, a ‘decent life for common people . . . nothing more than what we have in our present world’, to use Wells’s words, ‘except a better arrangement’. What bearing, then, does this communitarian legacy have upon some of our present critical social problems? We should first consider the question of our degree of identity with and duty towards the public, which in a sense goes to the core of the original socialist vision of ‘the social system’ in which harmony and co-operation were to supersede competition. We live commonly now in what is increasingly regarded as a degraded public space, in which not only the canons of politeness and mutual respect, but the very concept of the res publica, or what Margaret Thatcher infamously dismissed as ‘society’, are under threat. Respecting our public services, every question of what is euphemistically called ‘reform’, turns on issues of cost and profitability rather than public service or human utility. Post Office closures, the abandonment 46
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 46
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
of local medical services, the creeping sell-off of the National Health Service, the privatization of ‘public’ transport, the private funding even of state schools, all reflect a neo-liberal profit-oriented political philosophy in which human consequences, particularly for the poor, are never a central consideration. To its critics, this path, scouted by Thatcher but followed enthusiastically by successive neo-liberal prime ministers of both major parties, including the Blair and Brown governments, is an extraordinarily dangerous road down which to travel. Coupled with a marked growth in social inequality, which again promotes private-sector solutions for the needs of the well-to-do, and degrades the public sector as fit only for the poor (try an extended stay in an National Health Service ward), it markedly devalues our perception of the public sector as such.44 And it is not only services, but our sense of the common space we share, that is becoming degraded. A healthy society requires a healthy sense of respect for what makes its public space not merely inhabitable but pleasant. Mark the difference between traversing the litterstrewn streets of a British town after the Saturday-night debauch which has made many of our inner cities no-go areas for large numbers of the popuÂ�lation, by comparison with a Sunday morning in Paris, Amsterdam, Copenhagen or Berlin. Once our common space is lost, it is notoriously difficult to regain. Yet we recognize in Britain that we are indeed in danger of losing what the United States ceded over half a century ago in many of its cities, a sense of common life and shared space, surrendered in particular by white flight to the suburbs and the resulting concentration in ghettoes of an increasingly impoverished non-white population. Part of the cause, at least, of this atrophy of public-mindedness lies in the fact that successive generations of so-called ‘leaders’ have encouraged us to believe that greed and selfishness are good for us, both individually and collectively. The Owenite ideal, of course, was very different, and so too was the later nineteenth-century and early twentieth-century sense among socialists of the need to promote our sense of commonality by reinforcing what seems now so quaintly and archaically Victorian, our sense of public duty. Consider the Independent Labour Party anti-conscriptionist J. Bruce Glasier’s 1915 pronouncement that ‘the true roots of British greatness’ lay ‘in the love of freedom – personal and political – in the liking for con stitutionalism, and the sense of civic fellowship, together with the hatred of lawlessness, autocracy, and servility’.45 Recall H. G. Wells’s attempt in A Modern Utopia (1905) to define an ethos of public service around the order of the Samurai, an effort he would rebrand as ‘republicanism’. Reflect on 47
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 47
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Gregory Claeys
Ramsay MacDonald’s insistence (in 1936) that socialism rested on ‘the comÂ�munity spirit, upon individual devotion to common service, upon the cohesion that is destroyed by class, the military spirit, and an economic system that breeds poverty and dependence’.46 Readers of Orwell’s The Lion and the Unicorn (1941), too, will recognize a kindred set of themes. We are all aware of how the most extreme forms of coercive communitarianism went tragically wrong in totalitarian systems, creating class hatred and classoriented violence on an unprecedented scale, inviting mass murder of the well-to-do, the educated and all political deviants. Yet the same principle of community and sociability can also provide a vital counterbalance to the corrosive qualities of excessive selfish individualism and hedonistic con sumerÂ�ism which threaten to prove the undoing of liberal capitalist societies. This clearly has a bearing upon the catastrophic environmental scenario we now face. The Owenite ideal, at bottom, was one of autarkic self-sufficiency and the exchange of quality of life for consumption of commodities. So long as this was offered as a straightforward choice to a relatively uneducated population hungry for consumer goods it was unlikely to prove an attractive proposition. Now, however, such a choice is no longer available: we must limit consumption or we will destroy our planet. This sense of public duty and community spirit, sometimes termed ‘republican’ and ‘communitarian’ with the liberal tradition, are essential to achieving this goal. A third aspect of the relation of Owenism to later nineteenth-century socialism respecting the scale of life concerns the ultimate form of worldgovernment to which we should aspire. We should recall here that Owen aimed at a form of anti-nationalist socialist cosmopolitanism in which all national barriers were to be superseded and one language alone would remain – yes, English. The overt chauvinism of such a proposal, despite its supposed federative safeguards, was matched by a variety of later nineteenth-century socialist proposals, not least those mooted by Marx and Engels, for super seding those ‘historyless’ smaller nations, like many of the Slavic peoples, or amalgamating much of the world into an expanded and glorified British empire, such as the Fabian George Bernard Shaw proposed in 1900. Against this trend a variety of later socialists insisted that a non-chauvinistic form of nationalism not only could but had to form the basis for international co-operation between nations. Nationalism and socialism, in other words, were not merely not antithetical, but were complementary: a nationalist aspiration to be free of subordination to larger and more powerful races and nations exhibited the same legitimate desire for freedom and autonomy which 48
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 48
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
socialism upheld on behalf of the working class from an economic stand point. The post-colonial era and later twentieth-century history generally provide abundant evidence that individuals persistently and, indeed, increas ingly want national sovereignty to accord with ethnic, linguistic, religious and cultural identity. They also want to be integrated into viable forms of international government – witness the relative success of the European Union in this regard – but only when their independence is preserved. They do not want Russian, British, French, American or Chinese masters. They do not want to be compelled to speak someone else’s language, or to abandon their national identities. They do want to be differentiated from other nations in a positive but also a critical sense – what Scot wants to be identified as English? Or Canadian as American? – the list is endless. People’s legitimate aspirations for independence, the legacy of some of the romantic national isms of the earlier nineteenth century, of Mazzini, Kossuth, Parnell and others, must clearly be heeded, and integrated into a structure of inter national co-operation. Here Owen, Marx and many later socialist opponents of nationalism have clearly been proved wrong. They not only missed the strength and appeal of contemporary nationalism; they missed the positive value of forms of local identity which make it possible to focus and act locally and regionally while thinking globally. We do not here lose, collect ively, by encouraging the proliferation of such forms of identity. We are much more likely to lose by fomenting a single, procrustean, collective identity which fosters homogeneity and uniformity, whether it be forged by a capitalist consumer culture or any alternative. Diversity is an indication of strength rather than weakness. Getting the balance of individualism and collectivism right rather than enduring the extremes of either is the real issue. Here the anarchists had something to teach the more collectivist communitarian social ists, which is one reason why the most anarchistical communists of the late nineteenth century, notably William Morris, remain appealing today, when so many of their comrades – Hyndman, Blatchford, Bax, Hardie – are now long-forgotten names. This brings me to a fourth aspect of Owen’s communitarian vision, carried forward into the late nineteenth century, which not only retains a contem porary application but is in fact much more important than ever, and that is neo-Malthusianism. You may recall that Owen was – in his view quite necessarily – rather coy about how population growth was to be stabilized in the ideal community. We have seen that amongst late nineteenth-century socialists Alfred Russel Wallace was much more direct about the inevitability 49
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 49
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Gregory Claeys
of population control. The problem of demographic growth is of course vastly more pressing today than it was in the late nineteenth century. Yet we still face a formidable conspiracy of Christian zealots in particular, Protestant and Catholic alike, who insist that God alone possesses the right to prevent births from occurring. This problem is every bit as serious as, and deeply interÂ�twined with, that of global warming. Yet it receives negligible attention in the world’s press, and what limited efforts might be made to at least depress the rate of growth through both birth control and the provision of positive incentives to restrain births, are scarcely entertained by many nations. The result, predictably, is bound to be catastrophic. We do not, perhaps, like Owen, have to proclaim ourselves secularists in order to condemn the role that religion plays in exacerbating this problem. But neither does it hurt to do so, in an age when religious self-promotion has been lent ever greater credence by government and public opinion alike. If talking to God has confirmed two prominent leaders in their view that the Iraq war was correct, perhaps talking against God might bring a more desirable outcome on this issue. Let me conclude by returning to my starting-point: how then ought we to view the ‘utopian/scientific’ model today? In terms of the ways of assessing earlier versus later nineteenth-century socialism, what else should be added or subtracted to this model? Let me make two suggestions. The first is that, as we have seen in the instance of Alfred Russel Wallace, the impact of natural selection constitutes an important watershed in socialist thought. Owen grappled with Malthusianism, but in terms of the population problem, not eugenic, or as we would term it today, genetic engineering. All socialists after Darwin, until at least 1914, were forced to think in the latter terms, and many – the Webbs, Shaw, Wells – did so in depth and at length. As we have seen, an ‘organic’ perspective – society and the individual in evolution – was central to writers like MacDonald. Secondly, by the beginning of the twentieth century socialists began to win electoral victories and to prove that market regulation, and particularly the restraint of damaging speculative investment, could prove viable. In certain autocracies like Russia revolution still, with hindsight, appears to have been the only means by which fundamental change could have taken place. But in many others this was not the case. Socialism in Europe, in the form of the social-democratic welfare state, has been successful in part because it decoupled itself from the revolutionary compulsiveness of Marx, and recog nized that a compromise with liberalism had to occur both in terms of first 50
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 50
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists
principles – the acknowledgement of rights to autonomy, both individual and national – and the concession that political compromise, electoral loss, the folly of the ignorant masses, all had to be taken on board by socialists as well as others. This has meant recognizing, again as MacDonald reiterated, that the state was not something to be superseded, wished away or regarded as the epitome of evil, but treated as a mechanism, like the nation, to be used for socialist ends. The successes of social democracy, in this respect, are mostly post-totalitarian, and date from the 1950s onwards. They are not utopian successes in the sense of implementing a grand revelation, but result instead from painstaking attention to the detailed hammering out of a dual economy in which the public and private sectors each play a crucial strategic role. They are eutopian, in the sense in which the Scottish soci ologist Patrick Geddes used the term, to denote realizable local changes for the better. Socialism’s contribution to this formula is the recognition that a higher human life for the majority requires public control and manage ment, if not ownership, over key areas of activity affecting welfare: transport, medical care, the exploitation of key national resources, the planning of long-term environmental objectives, the restraint of war, and, as we have yet again been recently reminded, the regulation of the international financial system. In all of these areas we have seen a succession of governments from Thatcher to Brown committed to neo-liberal economic policies in this country, with the consequence that we have been repeatedly pillaged by rapacious corporations. At the moment this seems, still, to be a losing battle, for the plunder continues with reckless abandon. But ‘utopian’ socialism also represents, as we have seen, the principle that, over the long run, private profit cannot ever provide an adequate substitute for the public provision of well-being. That was Owen’s original premise, as stated in the Report to the County of Lanark. If we want to recapture that sense of the virtue of preserving that shared or collective dimension of our lives that Owen called ‘community’, we could certainly do worse than remember his message.
Notes I am grateful to Lorna Davidson for assistance with references, and to the Cooperative Union for its financial support. ╇2 Graham Wallas, Men and Ideas (London, 1940), p. 65. ╇3 See my ‘The revival of Robert Owen: recrafting a Victorian reputation, c.1870– 1900’, in Chushichi Tsuzuki, Naobumi Hijikata and Akira Kurimoto (eds), The ╇ 1
51
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 51
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Gregory Claeys
Emergence of Global Citizenship: Utopian Ideas, Co-operative Movements, and the Third Sector (Tokyo, 2005), pp. 29–44. ╇4 J. F. C. Harrison, Robert Owen and the Owenites in Britain and America: The Quest for the New Moral World (London, 1969); Edward Royle, Robert Owen and the Commencement of the Millennium: A Study of the Harmony Community (Manchester, 1998). ╇5 I cite here from my ‘The political ideas of the young Engels, 1842–45’, History of Political Thought, 6 (1985), 455–78. ╇6 Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, The Communist Manifesto, ed. Gareth Stedman Jones (London, 2002), p. 254. ╇7 Friedrich Engels, Socialism: Utopian and Scientific (Moscow, 2007 edition), pp. 76, 77, 94. ╇8 Lenin, ‘On co-operation’ (originally in Pravda, 1923). ╇9 J. A. Hobson, Democracy after the War (London, 1917), p. 119. 10 Labour Leader, 19 July 1901. 11 Justice, 13 April 1901. 12 Ibid., 5 January 1907. 13 The New Age, 6 August 1914, 15 April 1915. 14 Fabian News (August 1906), 34–5. 15 Frank Podmore, Robert Owen: A Biography (London, 1906), II, p. 649. 16 Walter F. Roch, ‘Robert Owen’, The Socialist Review: A Monthly Review of Modern Thought, 5 (1910), 335–40: 339. 17 Labour Leader, 12 June 1908; Carluke and Lanark Gazette, 13 June 1908. 18 Carluke and Lanark Gazette, 13 June 1908. 19 Labour Leader, 20 November 1908. 20 H. M. Hyndman, Commercial Crises of the Nineteenth Century (London, 1892), p. 85. We frequently encounter praise for Owen’s views on education elsewhere. 21 Ibid., p. 23; idem, The Social Reconstruction of England ([1884]), p. 14; idem, The Historical Basis of Socialism in England (London, 1883), p. 456. 22 William Morris, Political Writings: Contributions to Justice and Commonweal 1883–1890, ed. Nicholas Salmon (Bristol, 1994), p. 565. 23 Sidney Webb, English Progress towards Social Democracy (Fabian Tracts, no. 15, 1890), p. 10. 24 James Ramsay MacDonald, The Socialist Movement ([1911]), p. 100. 25 Ibid., p. 204. 26 J. Keir Hardie and J. R. MacDonald, ‘The Independent Labour Party programme’, The Nineteenth Century, 45 (1899), 20–38: 25. 27 A. R. Wallace, My Life (1908), p. 57. 28 Ibid., pp. 46–7. 29 Ibid., p. 48. 30 A. R. Wallace, The Remedy for Unemployment (London, [1909]), p. 22. 31 Wallace, My Life, pp. 55–6. 32 Ibid., p. 56. 52
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 52
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Robert Owen and Some Later Socialists 33
34
35
36
37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44
45 46
Ibid., pp. 326–7. Nevertheless, although Wallace (ibid., p. 319) claimed that Herbert Spencer propelled him towards individualism, he also noted that Spencer’s view of the land ‘made a permanent impression on me, and ultimately led to my becoming, almost against my will, President of the Land Nationalization Society’. New Nation (1891), quoted in Martin Fichman, An Elusive Victorian: The Evolution of Alfred Russel Wallace (Chicago, 2004), pp. 251–2. On Bellamy and his fol lowers see in particular Sylvia E. Bowman, Edward Bellamy Abroad: An American Prophet’s Influence (New York, 1962), which notes Wallace’s praise (pp. 111–12). and Arthur Lipow, Authoritarian Socialism in America: Edward Bellamy and the Nationalist Movement (Berkeley, 1982). A. R. Wallace, ‘If there were a socialist government – how should it begin?’, Clarion, 18 August 1905, 5. Ibid. On Owen’s view of the exchange mechanism, see my Machinery, Money and the Millennium: From Moral Economy to Socialism, 1815–1860 (Princeton, 1987), pp. 34–60. Wallace, ‘If there were a socialist government’, 5. The Humanitarian, ns 4 (April 1894), 315. A. R. Wallace, Studies Scientific and Social (London, 1900), I, 509. Ibid., pp. 509–10. Henry Pelling, The Origins of the Labour Party, 1880–1900 (Oxford, 1965), p. 33. Morris, Political Writings, p. 466. H. G. Wells, ‘A woman’s day in Utopia’, Daily Mail, 7 June 1905. Although, in the UK, both the Scottish Parliament and the Welsh Assembly have expressed resistance to these trends. J. Bruce Glasier, The Peril of Conscription (London, 1915), p. 7. Ramsay MacDonald, At Home and Abroad: Essays (London, 1936), p. 222.
53
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 53
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 54
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
3
The Great Experiment: New Lanark from Robert Owen to World Heritage Site Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
This chapter examines the lasting legacy and achievements of the quartercentury (1800–25) when Robert Owen was owner and manager of the New Lanark cotton mills in Scotland. This was the period when he was at his most focused, enterprising and successful, making a real difference to the lives of ordinary working people through his enlightened social and edu cational policies, despite opposition and even alarm, engendered by his un orthodox views, not least his denunciation of organized religion. Many initiatives which Owen pioneered – such as free infant education and free medical care – are now provided by the state, at least in the United Kingdom. As a result, it is New Lanark that is arguably Owen’s greatest legacy. Here the buildings can still be visited which were the physical expression of his ideas and aspirations for society, notably the Institution for the Formation of Character and the School for Children. Following the closure of the cotton mills in 1968, the population of New Lanark had dwindled and the neglected buildings were falling into dereliction. In 1974, Jim Arnold was appointed as Village Manager by a newly formed Trust, established to attempt the restoration and regeneration of the historic mill community. This was a challenging project and required the deployment of a mixture of business management skills, idealism and sheer persistence, not dissimilar to Robert Owen’s. New Lanark is now recognized as a site of outstanding universal value and was inscribed on UNESCO’s list of World Heritage Sites in 2001. The New Lanark Trust strives to keep the Owenite dream alive, supporting social enterprise, local employment, social housing, fair trade and using renewable energy. Above all, it maintains a strong commitment to education,
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 55
10/3/2011 7:49:17 PM
Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
introducing as many people as possible to Owen’s ‘new view of society’ and his enduring belief in the transformative power of environment and education. The village of New Lanark was founded in 1785, in an age of innovation and enterprise, in the earliest period of the Industrial Revolution. Founded by a Scots entrepreneur and philanthropist, David Dale (1739–1806), New Lanark was a factory community designed for the spinning of cotton thread, utilizing Richard Arkwright’s water-frames, the most advanced technology available at the time. Built in the valley below the old market town of Lanark, an Ancient and Royal Burgh of Scotland, New Lanark’s location was dictated by the availability of water-power, and here the Falls of Clyde, long reÂ�nowned as a beauty spot, provided abundant natural energy to drive the waterwheels. Work began in 1785, and the first cotton mill started production in 1786. By 1793, four mills had been erected, and there were 1,334 people employed at New Lanark. The youngest workers were just six years old. In September 1799, David Dale’s eldest daughter Caroline married the Welsh-born Robert Owen who, with two Manchester-based partners, had purchased the New Lanark cotton mills. A few months later, on 1 January 1800, Robert and Caroline took up residence in New Lanark, where Owen was to be the managing partner of the business. He went on to carry out what he later described as the ‘the most important experiment for the happi ness of the human race that had yet been instituted at any time in any part of the world’.1 Under Owen’s enlightened management between 1800 and 1825 New Lanark was to gain a reputation as a model industrial comÂ�munity. To Dale’s mill buildings and millworkers’ housing, in addition to expanding the manufacturing capacity with the construction of a new Mechanics’ WorkÂ�shop, an iron foundry and extra buildings for spinning, Owen added important community buildings, specifically designed to further his wider social agenda. Notable among these were the Institution for the Formation of Character and the School for Children. During the first quarter of the nineteenth century, New Lanark illuminated the darkness of the Industrial Revolution Â�– as the very antithesis of ‘dark Satanic mills’. Although the main interest in terms of Owen’s legacy tends to focus on the philosophical aspects of the New Lanark community, we should not forget the impressive physical aspects of what was an enormous enterprise at the forefront of eighteenth-century technology. Industrialization on a grand scale was represented by the site. Revolution in economic organization was illustrated by its massive stone buildings and the very large workforce of 56
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 56
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
New Lanark from Robert Owen to Heritage Site
around 2,000 people. Technological change was represented by the sophisti cated use of water-power and machines, and all the support activities which were required to sustain and develop what was, for a time, the largest factory in the world on a completely new and relatively isolated rural site. The village itself made a strong visual impact on visitors who, as evidenced by their accounts, were fully conscious of a very strong sense of place. Owen’s achievements were based on manufacturing success and wealth. In the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries in Britain the cotton spinning industry was a revolutionary way of making money, and Owen was exceptionally talented as a manufacturer. It should not be forgotten that not every cotton business was a success. Many struggled and failed, but Owen was an astute and energetic businessman, and it was this economic success at New Lanark, and his willingness to fund social innovation and experimentation, that provided a solid foundation for his ambitions to change the new industrialized society. On first visiting New Lanark in 1798, Robert Owen characterized it unflatteringly as ‘a primitive Scotch manufacturing village’.2 Nevertheless, he saw it as the opportunity to put into practice an experiment he claimed to have long contemplated, as a response to the chaotic social conditions which prevailed in Britain as the Industrial Revolution gathered pace, and of which he had first-hand experience in Manchester as a young mill manager in charge of a workforce of some 500 people, many of them women and children, at Drinkwater’s Bank Top Mill. Rapid industrialization and un planned urbanization had resulted in appalling living and working conditions for many people. They were working long hours in factories, with no care or attention paid to their health, welfare or education. The social fabric was threatening to break down. When Owen became the managing partner of the New Lanark Mills, he set out quite consciously, therefore, to demonÂ�strate that society could become better, fairer and more harmonious. He put into practice radical economic, social and educational reforms which he believed would demonstrate to the wider world how such a society might be created. It is undeniable that, by the 1820s, New Lanark was widely regarded as a model community, and attracted thousands of visitors – sceptical, curious, admiring and incredulous – and twice as many people were applying for jobs there as they were able to take on. How did Robert Owen achieve this not inconsiderable feat? There are, of course, many complex contributing factors, but two extremely important ones were those of organization and education. 57
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 57
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
The New Lanark community consisted at that time of about 2,000 ordinary working people, mostly from Lowland Scotland, but also from the Highlands and Islands of Scotland. A large number of these last were what we would today call ‘economic migrants’, forced by extreme poverty to seek a better life and new employment opportunities by leaving their homeland, to embark on a dangerous and uncertain journey into the un known. Many did not speak English or even Lowland Scots; their native language was Scots Gaelic and they had few of the skills required for cotton manufacturing. There were also hundreds of orphan or pauper children, who had been apprenticed to work in the cotton mills, where they were provided with board and lodging in lieu of wages. This was a community, then, of people thrown together by force of circumstances, who unexpectedly and un intentionally found themselves the subject of Robert Owen’s social experiment. Organization was a key factor in Owen’s strategy. He had an agenda to improve the standard of living and the quality of life for his millworkers; he was strongly opposed to child labour, believing that everyone had a right to education, but he had to have a profitable business to finance his radical plans; for if he did not succeed in running the company well, he would lose his chance of carrying out his great experiment. According to him, the manage ment of the business at the point when he took over was very lax, with pilfering and other sharp practices going on. He introduced a much stricter regime in the cotton mills, with timekeeping, stock-counting, production costs and so on carefully recorded and scrutinized. Drunkenness was tackled, with the ultimate sanction, dismissal, exercised only after three warnings. Sanctions were otherwise in the form of fines, which were paid into the Community Fund. Owen was also decidedly uncomplimentary about the way in which at least some of the population behaved, describing them as ‘lawless, – getting into debt, – burning their window shutters and inside doors, – and then removing in the night, – and committing all kinds of depredations’. Accord ingly, he drew up a list of nineteen Rules and Regulations for the Inhabitants, designed to help towards the creation of a healthy and harmonious com munity.3 Some of these rules were aimed at improved health and hygiene, such as those concerning the cleaning of windows and of common stairs, and refraining from throwing rubbish into the streets. Others were designed to assist the establishment of friendly and co-operative relationships, for example with parents taking responsibility for the behaviour of their children and everyone respecting each other’s property, as well as that of the company. 58
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 58
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
New Lanark from Robert Owen to Heritage Site
Perhaps the most important of all was the exhortation to exercise religious tolerance and respect the religious opinions of others. Crucially, Owen wanted to encourage community responsibility, and he worked with a democratically elected village council to make progress towards his social revolution. New Lanark was divided into twelve ‘neighbour divisions’ from which the residents chose a representative to sit on the village jury. This, it should be noted, was long before universal suffrage was achieved. These elected representatives met monthly with Robert Owen or, if he was away, with his senior managers, to discuss village affairs, adjudicate in cases of neighbour disputes, and so on. They also formed a committee to oversee the attempts to clean up the town, earning them the nickname of the ‘Bug-Hunters’.4 Unsurprisingly, the initial reaction from the villagers was hostile. But Owen, at best regarded as strict but fair, was nothing if not quietly persevering, and the practical benefits provided in return for co-operation with this new regime were con Â�siderable. They included free medical care and medicines, cheap nutritious food and household goods, allotments, a sickness fund from which they had payments in time of illness or hardship, and a savings bank. Gradually he won them over, and by December 1813 when he succeeded in retaining ownership of the mills in the face of an attempt by his then business partners to buy him out, the villagers celebrated. As the Glasgow Herald of 10 April 1814 reported, ‘The houses were all illuminated at New Lanark on Friday night when the news came, and all has been jubilee and animation with them ever since.’ Following this triumph, and with the support of his new partners, who included Jeremy Bentham, Michael Gibbs and four members of the Society of Friends, William Allen, John Walker, Joseph Fox and Joseph Foster, he was able to embark on the next more idealistic and innovative part of his experiment, which relied on his unshakeable belief in the power of edu cation and environment to form character and create rational, well-adjusted citizens. By the end of 1815, he had completed the construction of what he called his New Institution for the Formation of Character, the first of two large new buildings, designed to provide generously provisioned edu cational and recreational facilities for the whole community. In doing so, Owen made a huge statement in favour of education. At that time, the cotton industry was booming. The last remaining building land on the hilly riverside site could have been used to erect another cotton mill and further increase the profit-making capacity of the business. Instead, it was devoted to community education in its broadest sense. Committed to phasing out 59
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 59
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
the use of child labour, Owen campaigned against the pernicious effects of such a practice: ‘. . . turn your eyes to the feeble, pale, and wretched flax- or cotton-spinning children, who, at an early age are doomed all the year round to one unvarying occupation for fourteen or fifteen hours a day, going to their work in winter before it is light in the morning, and returning long after dark.’5 Now Owen was able to complete the implementation of his policy to ensure that no child under the age of ten was employed in the factory, and indeed he encouraged parents to leave their children at school until they were twelve. At the earliest opportunity, they were to be the subject of the new character-forming environment and his rational system of education. As soon as the children were able to walk, they were taken into what today we would call a crèche or workplace nursery. At the age of three they entered the Infant School, the first free Infant School in the world for the children of ordinary working families. At six, they progressed to the day schools, and even once they had started work in the cotton mills they could continue their education by attending evening classes which were open to any member of the community. To encourage attendance, Owen reduced the working hours to ten and a half per day. The classrooms were spacious, light and airy. The curriculum was wideranging and child-centred. No punishments were allowed – not even harsh words – and the teachers were specifically instructed to be kind and en couraging. The children were taught to read, write and do arithmetic, of course, but at least as much emphasis was placed on musical activities – choral singing, dancing and instrument playing – with natural history, geog raphy, history, drawing and needlework also playing a large part. Owen’s educational establishment at New Lanark attracted international attention, and is fortunately extremely well documented. The cash book for the Insti tution, which provides a detailed monthly expenditure account for the years 1816–25, has survived.6 It contains a wealth of information, including the names of the teachers and the school cleaners, their wages, lists of the equip ment purchased for the schools. Day to day items like slates, pencils, pens and ink are itemized, as well as the extensive collection of teaching materials, coloured pictures of animals, fossils, maps, and painted canvases on rollers. Items connected with the children’s health and welfare also feature, such as the making of dresses, as the children were provided with cotton tunics, which were washed and changed three times a week. There are costs for repairs to the bath pumps – ‘Usefully-constructed bathing machines’ were installed – and 400 children’s haircuts were secured at a cost of 4 guineas. 60
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 60
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
New Lanark from Robert Owen to Heritage Site
Musical instruments feature frequently – bassoon reeds, violin strings, flutes, a clarinet, trumpet, drums etc. are all mentioned, as are printed song-sheets, and pumps for the dancing-teacher. Art materials, paints in an array of colours from Prussian blue to Chinese vermilion are there too, and every now and then a special item, including intriguing entries such as the ex hibition of a crocodile at 5 shillings, a payment to James Earl for exhibiting wild beasts to the children, and a performance on musical glasses. Concerts and balls were held regularly; dancing was considered by Owen to be a healthy, social and pleasurable form of exercise. One poster, advertising a concert and children’s ball in April 1821, has survived; this was a fundraising event, in aid of efforts to build a new school in a neighbouring village. The New Lanark instrumental band played a starring role, as did the dancing children, and as well as being a testament to the social and recreational life of the village, it demonstrates Owen’s desire to help improve educational facilities in the wider community. Apart from such documents, there are dozens of accounts left by visitors to New Lanark, from many different backgrounds and from many different countries. To mention but two, there are detailed descriptions of the schools in the travel journals of John Griscom, an American professor of chemistry and natural philosophy in the New York Institute, who visited in 1819, and Dorothy Wordsworth, sister of William. Griscom wrote: I found there a music school. Half a dozen or more little fellows had each a flute, and were piping it away in notes that did not preserve the strictest tunefulness. The next apartment we entered was a large room for reading, writing, and arithmetic. Some of the pupils in this room were pretty well advanced in age. From this we went into a large room above-stairs where there were fifty or sixty young people, both boys and girls, attending to the lessons of a dancing-master. These young students of the ‘merry mood’ were not equipped in all the gaiety of a fashionable ball-room; though there was a great diversity of costume. In fact, they were in much the same style as that in which they had left the manufactory, – some with shoes, and others bare foot.7
Dorothy Wordsworth was equally observant in 1822: I was too late for the singing, but not for the dancing, a curious and pretty exhibition. The dancing-master’s daughter, the leader of the performers, neatly dressed like a wealthy tradesman’s child. All had clean hands and faces – some 61
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 61
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
with shoes and stockings – many without either – several in Mr Owen’s adopted dress after the Roman costume, and made of Tartan. The dancing would not have disgraced the Ambleside quality children at Mr Lishman’s Ball . . . The Geography lesson was now to be exhibited & it was surprising to hear with what readiness Boys of from seven to ten years old gave the names of rivers with uncouth names of distant seas and countries, at the pointing of a Wand over a large map of the world placed on a frame near the head of the room, the class standing in a semi-circle before it. The room is hung round with materials for study – paintings of beasts and birds, fossils and flowers. The flowers (with all their parts according to botanical arrangement) are painted on a great length of canvas, which is unrolled for exhibition, at the same time winding up again from the bottom. The walls of another apartment are hung with symbolic representations of the origin, genealogies and outspreading of Nations and People, beginning at the source of a great central River that sends out streams in all directions over a space of canvas, I am afraid to guess how many feet in length and breadth.8
In the 1820s, then, Owen’s New Lanark was generally hailed as a success. What were the key factors in this success? Unusually for an industrial philan thropist, Owen was not motivated by religion; indeed he was famously anticlerical. This, it need hardly be said, did not endear him to the Establish ment, and he was under continual fire from the local parish minister in Lanark, and others further afield, because of his unorthodox views. Underpinning everything he did was his unshakeable belief in the trans formative power of education, but much depended also on Owen’s business management skills. Successful communities – monasteries, for example – are generally very structured. This underpinning framework makes people feel secure, and supported; everyone has a role and gains confidence from this. Owen made his reputation as a successful cotton-mill manager, and is often accused of acting purely out of commercial self-interest, being astute enough to realize that an educated, well-fed and docile workforce would make for a more successful business. So was he an enlightened capitalist or a utopian socialist? If we consider the detail of what he actually did, and the scale of it, his idealism shines through. The liberal education he provided was just as likely to encourage people to leave the cotton mills behind, and indeed we do know of a few examples where this actually happened. Commercial success was not what drove him. It was a means to an end, and he was prepared to live modestly and to spend a fortune in pursuit of his dream. Paternalistic – yes; patient and persistent – yes; stubborn – yes; but hugely 62
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 62
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
New Lanark from Robert Owen to Heritage Site
idealistic also, and never short of ambitious ideas. It was while he was in New Lanark that he wrote some of his most important works, notably the series of essays entitled A New View of Society. In his Address to the Inhabitants of New Lanark, the speech he made to the villagers on 1 January 1816, when the new Institution for the Formation of Character was officially opened, Owen said many remarkable things. He talked about the new opportunities that were to be offered to his community, and the resources that were to be committed to it. It was a long and wideranging address (mercifully punctuated by a musical interlude) covering education, religion, justice, health, industry, society, to mention just a few of its themes. He prefaced it by explaining the objects for which his new Institution had been founded and the intended effects of his New System: [First] The immediate comfort and benefit of all the inhabitants of the village of New Lanark. [Second] The welfare and advantage of the neighbourhood. [Third] Extensive ameliorations throughout the British dominions. [Fourth] The gradual improvement of every nation in the world.9 There are some wonderful quotations scattered through the address, but two stand out. The first is a very secular vision of the New Millennium, set in deliberate opposition to the religious visions which were prevalent at the time: What ideas individuals may attach to the term Millennium, I know not; but I know that society may be formed so as to exist without crime, without poverty, with health greatly improved, with little, if any misery, and with intelligence and happiness increased a hundredfold; and no obstacle whatsoever intervenes at this moment except ignorance to prevent such a state of society from becoming universal.10
The second is indicative of Owen’s huge humanity, and his awareness of the world beyond New Lanark: That charity and that kindness admit of no exception. They extend to every child of man, however he may have been taught, however he may have been trained. They consider not what country gave him birth, what may be his complexion, what his habits or his sentiments.11 63
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 63
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
What Owen achieved in New Lanark went far beyond organizing and edu cating simply to improve the efficiency of his business. His approach shares many of the characteristics of what two centuries later, we call social enterprise, or corporate social responsibility. Arguably, it was utopian socialism in practice. General economic success for the developed world in the last couple of centuries has generated the surplus to allow the social and educational re forms introduced by Owen in New Lanark to become widely accepted and frequently implemented – free education for all, free healthcare, fair working conditions and shorter working hours, decent housing, unadulterated food, abolition of poverty. If you take just one theme you can follow how this process has worked. New Lanark had a world first in child nurseries, where children went to a dedicated building from the age at which they could walk. They were taught by a growing band of specialist teachers. There was no corporal punishment. Children were brought up in an atmosphere of love and kindness. There was equality of education between girls and boys. There was a revolutionary child-centred curriculum. This pattern of infant education has become fairly normal, both actual and aspirational, in many countries. In the United Kingdom it has become a main element in govern ment educational policy. By the 1990s there was no corporal punishment. Gender differences are consciously addressed. Nursery teachers are specially trained. Special efforts are made for single mothers. Owen’s system of edu cation pioneered at New Lanark represents one of the strongest roots of this developing movement, which has changed the way we operate our society. Interestingly he had a relatively mechanistic view of society, and thought of it as a machine which could be altered and adjusted. Thus did ‘social engineer ing’ become an especially purposeful activity and a systematic way of creating Owen’s ‘New Moral World’. This general way of examining the impact of Owenism leads into an interesting line of potential investigation about the future development of society and whether the specific example of New Lanark could continue to contribute to the development of social thought. Some of the Owenite activities carried on after Owen left the village after about 1825, and the ownership of the cotton mills passed to Charles and Henry Walker, the sons of one of Owen’s Quaker partners, John Walker. Under their management, the company continued to provide medical care and a Sickness Fund. They also continued to run the school until the state took over responsibility for education in the 1870s. We have the records of the village children being transferred to the new Board school which had 64
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 64
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
New Lanark from Robert Owen to Heritage Site
been built on the edge of the historic village in 1884. From then the children linked into the standard state education system, which existed for quite a long time before it was able to replicate all the Owenite benefits. New Lanark itself remains fundamentally unchanged since the days of the original founders. If Robert Owen were able to return he would recog nize his buildings, and he would have no difficulty in finding his way through the village. The flagship buildings of the utopian experiment still stand, and from the windows of his Counting House he would be able to see them as before. Nursery Buildings was where the young pauper apprentices were accommodated alongside the other village families after Owen removed them from their dormitories in one of the mills, as part of the process of phasing out this particular system of child labour. The substantial Village store was constructed to provide quality goods and foodstuffs, available at low prices, while the profits from this trading enterprise were reinvested in the community, being used to defray the expenses of the education system. The impressive Institution for the Formation of Character, and its generous forecourt, which was originally set aside as a children’s playground, occupies, significantly, a central position in the village. In its companion building, the School for Children, overlooking the river, the original stone stairway can be climbed, the treads worn by thousands of footsteps, and the original Musicians’ Galleries with their delicate wrought-iron balustrades are still there too. But by the 1970s, the cotton mills had closed down. The village was shabby and semi-derelict with a declining population. People had moved away in search of work. The industrial area, including the mills, the Institution and the School, had been sold to a scrap metal company, and the grand old buildings were becoming seriously degraded. Was this beacon of utopian socialism to be demolished and forgotten? Deserted villages have a fascination. On Easter Sunday, 1974, Jim Arnold visited New Lanark. Following the closure of the cotton mills after nearly 200 years in March 1968, the population had dwindled to a handful, and the buildings were gradually falling into dereliction, though the riverside village retained its idyllic atmosphere, even in decay. Later that summer, Arnold was appointed as Village Manager by a newly formed Trust, set up to attempt the regeneration of the historic mill community. Arnold was acutely aware that he was following in a historic tradition. By coincidence he was twenty-nine years old – the same age as his most famous predecessor, Robert Owen, when he came to take up residence as village manager in 65
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 65
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
1800, facing a very different challenge, but, interestingly, one which in some respects required a similar mix of skills and perseverance. The formation of the New Lanark Trust as an independent charity meant that the conservation effort was outside the state system and had no dedi cated source of funds. The state did not wish to allocate significant resources for this project, probably because it was a very large and expensive under taking, an industrial heritage site at a time when these were not at all fashionable, and also because Robert Owen was neither a member of the nobility nor a warrior. Generally the United Kingdom has found it easier to honour a hierarchy of nobility and aggression. Thus one tends to find that ancient castles, warrior kings, tribal chiefs and stately homes are easier to save for posterity than large-scale industrial sites where the common man is the key component. New Lanark in the 1970s was like many utopian projects: it had a built-in programme for failure. A long restoration and development struggle ensued – a struggle for funding, and for credibility. It was hard to convince a cynical society that this small and derelict indus trial village, in a rural part of southern Scotland, still had something important to say to the world, and that it could claim to represent a significant part of our international cultural heritage. Above all, it was decided that the village, if it could be saved, should not live on simply as a museum, a fossilized piece of the past. Born of a spirit of enterprise allied to a vision for the future of society, New Lanark should survive as a living, working community, where the values and principles of its founders were respected, and reinterpreted for the twenty-first century. Owen’s aforementioned aspirations for the next millennium remained an inspiration for the project. We did not want one of the best examples of a utopian site to end up as a heap of rubble, a demolished testament to a failed dream. The next quarter-century could be seen as equally significant a period in the history of the village as the twenty-five years of Owen’s regime. During this period, enormous amounts of work were carried out, and New Lanark became once again, a source of employment for hundreds of people, as in the first years of its existence. Teams of local workmen applied their skills and strength to the task of restoring the massive sandstone buildings. The project provided meaningful work and practical training at a time of high unÂ�employ ment, and gradually the vision of regenerating the community became less fanciful, more credible. The housing restoration came first, and new families moved into the former millworkers’ houses, internally refurbished to meet 66
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 66
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
New Lanark from Robert Owen to Heritage Site
modern living standards, but preserving the character of these historic buildings, now granted statutory protection at the highest level available in Scotland, Category A Listing. The cotton mills, Institution and School were finally recovered by means of a Compulsory Purchase Order in 1983 from the scrap metal company which had bought them in 1970, and the final phase began. All the buildÂ�ings were gradually restored and brought back into use, adapted for sustainable new economic uses, and facilities were developed by which visitors could share the New Lanark experience, and learn of its special history through im aginaÂ�tive exhibitions and interpretation. New Lanark now boasts a hotel and Youth Hostel, as well as a Visitor Centre, while other buildings are occupied by a variety of modern enterprises. Well over 200 people are now employed in the community, and nearly 200 people live there, mostly in good-quality social rented housing. The river still provides energy, in the form of hydroelectricity, and the surrounding landscape is still beautiful and green. It is difficult to measure success, but the village has won virtually every major tourist and conservation award available to it. Also, in 1988 the Utopian Studies Society was founded when the village was host to a con ference organized by the International Communal Studies Association. There were intellectual milestones as well as physical achievement. Arguably the most significant, however, was the inscription of New Lanark as a World Heritage Site. The identification of sites of such universal importance that they are included in a world list has become the responsibility of the United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), and the process is based on the 1972 Convention for the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage. The concept is to assist member states to identify and protect specified sites that make a significant contribution to the world. It took a little while to become operational, and administrative systems were pretty vestigial, but by the mid-1980s the first nominations were coming through and a world list was beginning to develop. New Lanark was officially designated as a World Heritage Site on 14 December 2001, at the meeting of the World Heritage Committee held in Helsinki, Finland. This placed New Lanark on the list of sites which ‘can be considered to be of outstanding universal value and as such worthy of special protection against the dangers which increasingly threaten them’. Helsinki resounded to the cheer of at least one member of the Utopian Studies Society and a toast was drunk to the memory of Robert Owen. Had 67
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 67
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
he been present he would have been rich and generous enough to have addressed the whole assembly and to have bought them all champagne. The basis of New Lanark’s inscription is unusual for an industrial heritage site in that it includes a recognition of Owen’s influence. It is inscribed on the basis that it is, first, an important interchange of human values on de velÂ�opments in architecture, or technology, monumental arts, town planning or landscape design; second, an outstanding example of a type of building, or architectural or technological ensemble or landscape which illustrates a significant stage in human history; and finally, directly or tangibly associated with events or living traditions, with ideas or with beliefs, with artistic and literary works of outstanding universal significance. The first two are recognition of the site’s universal physical significance in terms of the Industrial Revolution and the development of factory com munities, and the third recognizes ‘Owenism, Utopianism, cooperation, communitarianism, industrial capitalism, concepts of the sublime landscape and models for modern conservation partnerships . . .’.12 This cultural element is relatively unusual and is certainly not included in other industrial sites. There are no World Heritage Sites with any sign of utopian socialist influence, other than perhaps Westminster and an associ ation with the growth of democracy. Sites relating to the Diggers, or the English Revolution, or St Peter’s Fields, or the Chartists, or William Morris, or other similar individuals or places are not included on the World Heritage List. New Lanark is the only World Heritage Site which even begins to approach a celebration of utopian socialism and the values of communi tarianism. World Heritage status represents a significant leap forward for New Lanark, and for the public understanding of the concept of utopia, and what it means for us as a society. New Lanark is still a small village in rural Scotland, but now it welcomes visitors from all over the world, to share in the beginning of understanding a dream of utopia. It provides a physical example of what, for most people in our society, is an extremely difficult intellectual concept. It is helpful that it is a dramatic site, because the concepts and challenges are also dramatic. It is helpful that the site has retained its historic integrity, has not been despoiled by later development, and is relatively isolated in a surrounding of natural woodland. You can see as clearly as possible the interface between a historic utopian and the location which made him famous. Much of the site interpretation focuses on this issue, because it is the element which makes New Lanark so different. You can encounter the ‘spirits’ of Annie McLeod, a young mill-girl from 1820 68
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 68
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
New Lanark from Robert Owen to Heritage Site
and Harmony from the year 2200, linking the past to the future of our society. We hope that it stimulates thought and even makes a few converts. The village continues to shine as a beacon of light for the ideals of utopian study and World Heritage status carries this concept to a new level of ‘uni versal and outstanding value to humanity’. A new generation with new opportunities has grown up since 1974, taking for granted many things which Owen pioneered – such as free infant edu cation and free medical care – and which are now provided by the state, at least in the United Kingdom. We strive, however, to keep the utopian dream alive, supporting social enterprise, social housing, local employment and fair trade. New Lanark Trading Ltd and New Lanark Hotels Ltd, both wholly owned subsidiaries of the New Lanark Trust, continue the village’s tradition of commerce, while our Village Group, and Management Committee of New Lanark Homes, are the twenty-first-century successors of Robert Owen’s village jury (if not now nicknamed the Bug-Hunters!). In addition, we respect and care for the natural environment which first gave impetus to the New Lanark project, continuing to use the clean, green renewable energy by util izing the original water-power systems to produce hydro-electricity on site. Above all, we maintain a strong commitment to education, and in particular to introducing as many people as possible to Owen’s ‘new view of society’. New Lanark bears witness to the most successful period of Robert Owen’s long life, and it continues to inspire admiration and amazement. The legacy is tangible. Visiting New Lanark, you can walk in Robert Owen’s footsteps, pass through the doorway of the Institution for the Formation of Character, or the village store, stand in the room where he made his Address to the Inhabitants of New Lanark on New Year’s Day, 1816. You can walk by the River Clyde as it plunges down through the gorge which provided both the water-power and the sandstone for this amazing enterprise. To quote again from the World Heritage nomination document: New Lanark is a unique reminder that the creation of wealth does not auto matically imply the degradation of its producers. The village offers a cultural response to the challenges presented by industrial society, and was the test-bed for ideas that sought to reform humanity. Today the village provides physical evidence of Owen’s model for a New Moral World.
Can we truly say New Lanark is Robert Owen’s greatest legacy? Visit it and judge for yourself. 69
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 69
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Lorna Davidson and Jim Arnold
Notes SWRO, 4, p. 112. Ibid., p. 99. ╇3 Robert Owen, The New Existence of Man upon Earth, 5 (1854), Appendix. ╇4 One Formerly a Teacher at New Lanark, Robert Owen at New Lanark (Manchester, 1839). ╇5 SWRO, 1, p. 273. ╇6 Edinburgh University Special Collections, Cash Book of the New Lanark Institution, 1816–25. ╇7 John Griscom, The Contrast: Or Scotland as It Was in the Year 1745, and Scotland in the Year 1819 (London, 1825), pp. 253–4. ╇8 Dorothy Wordsworth, Journals of My Second Tour in Scotland, ed. Jiro Nagasawa (Tokyo, 1989), p. 156. ╇9 SWRO, 1, p. 120. 10 Ibid., p. 131. 11 Ibid., p. 136. 12 Nomination of New Lanark for Inclusion in the World Heritage List (Edinburgh, 2000). ╇ 1 ╇2
70
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 70
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
4
Robert Owen and Education
Francis J. O’ Hagan
Introduction The educational and social theories of Robert Owen emerged very distinct ively from his own direct experiences and from the practical improvements over which he presided as a factory owner and philanthropist. Although he developed in an extended series of writings an elaborate and reformist understanding of education of considerable importance to the progress of popular schooling, his social experiments at the village of New Lanark represented to both Owen and to the world at large observing his efforts the cornerstone of his educational thought. It is therefore repeatedly to New Lanark that the attention of the historian must turn in order to evaluate Owen’s contribution to educational theory and practice. Realizing from apparently quite early in his life that he was living through a revolutionary epoch, where the old certainties of the past were being swept away by the forces of unprecedented economic, technological and social change, Owen devoted much of his creative energy – as well as considerable proportions of a growing personal fortune – to the implementation at New Lanark of an ambitious programme of social and educational innovation designed to harness the increasing energies of industry and commerce to the improvement of the living conditions of the masses. As his schemes developed, and his reputation soared internationally, Owen was prompted by his successes to go still further, arguing that a reorganized society, with cradle-to-grave education for all at its heart, could inaugurate a new age of egalitarian prosperity and progress for the whole human race, the ultimate
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 71
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
potential of which was beyond imagining. Throughout all of his many ambitious schemes, Owen insisted – in terms familiar from classical En lightenÂ�ment theory – that the life of the mind and the content of the individual character were shaped decisively by experience and environment. This fundamental assumption of course accorded potentially great inter ventionary power to education, especially when this was applied to the decisive period of early childhood. It helped place the promotion of popular education at the heart of a programme of political and social renewal and an overarching vision of the development of civil society. While little of the underlying empiricist philosophy was original, Owen was certainly one of the first educationalists to recognize its social and political possibilities as a theory of character formation and to attempt to found local, com munally based educational initiatives upon its central premises. Resourced from the wealth and prosperity generated by the alignment of theory and practice, Owen came to believe that in the virtuous circle of New Lanark he had demonstrated the merits of a completely new conception of the relationship between education, work and society. This breakthrough, many of his followers subsequently contended, represented Owen’s most signifi cant contribution to the material advance of working people, furnishing progressive education in the United Kingdom and beyond with a blueprint for social transformation.
Owen’s Early Education Owen himself appears to have been sent unusually early to school (perhaps as young as four years), and while the education available at his local school, Newtown Hall, was by all accounts basic, its influence on Owen seems to have been vital in two respects. First, it convinced him of the value of children attending school per se at a time when the education of the young was still in many quarters viewed sceptically. Secondly, it introduced him first-hand to the then increasingly fashionable model of learning and teaching sub sequently known as the monitorial system, the key feature of which was the employment of older, talented pupils to teach younger children in return for fee exemptions. Developed in the following decades by Andrew Bell and Joseph Lancaster into a fully fledged pedagogical method, the monitorial principle was essentially an application of the factory system to education, whereby the more able senior pupils passed on their learning by rote to their 72
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 72
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Robert Owen and Education
juniors, often in very large classrooms. Owen encountered an early version of the monitorial system directly under the tutelage of his teacher, William Thickens, who, despite his obvious limitations as a provincial educator, recognized the academic potential in Owen and made him an ‘usher’ or monitor from the age of eight. We can perhaps see in his acceptance of this early role Owen’s first formal involvement in the instruction of others, a task to which he took enthusiastically and which in many ways formed a template for many of his later approaches to education.1 His early literary, religious and social education also developed auto didactically beyond the confines of the classroom, and he noted that as a youth ‘ . . . I was fond of and had a strong passion for reading everything which fell in my way.’2 In the light of this early enthusiasm for reading, it is curious that the later curricular reforms at New Lanark implemented by Owen exhibited a strong disdain for the use of books. Donnachie makes the observation that this possibly reflected impatience over the time it actually took to read books, a trait common in busy, self-made individuals. Alter natively, it may represent a fundamental suspicion in Owen’s make-up of any subject matter or received authority that did not accord directly with his own first-hand experience.3 The deep roots of this scepticism in all probability lay in the fact that for Owen, from his earliest years and despite his undoubted talent for learning, education both formal and informal was unavoidably accompanied by the experience of work. The rhythms of intellectual and physical labour in textile retailers and cotton workshops from childhood to early manhood formed the backdrop to all of his learning and self-teaching. This in turn conditioned sustained reflection upon the relationship of education to the principles of work, employment and leisure that was as a consequence to remain a constant theme both of his writings and of his later experiments in the education of children and adults. Even when precocious economic success as a cotton producer elevated him in his early twenties through the ranks of Manchester commerce, exposing him to the currents of radical Enlightenment thought then fuelling debate among the industrial elites whose circles he had succeeded in entering, Owen seems always to have been impatient of ideas and book learning pursued for their own sake. He preferred instead to deliberate questions where the practical application of abstract principles contained the prospect of meaningful social change and the extension of economic prosperity. It was precisely just such a combination of motives that appears to have first stimulated the young Owen’s interest in the commercial and community experiments being 73
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 73
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
conducted by the Scottish cotton magnate David Dale at his model village of New Lanark on the banks of the River Clyde in Scotland.
The New Lanark Reforms When Owen came to New Lanark in 1800 as co-owner, manager and sonin-law of its founder, he was placed in charge of the largest cotton mills complex in Scotland with a labour force of around 2,000 people. This thriving business had been created over a sixteen-year period by David Dale, and was already considered to be ‘ . . . one of the most humanely conducted factories in the Empire’.4 Owen’s debt to Dale was perhaps greater than he would imply in his later writings and particularly in his late autobiography, The Life of Robert Owen (Written by Himself ).5 While it is evident that he initially formed a very mixed opinion of the village and its inhabitants, it is equally clear that Owen swiftly internalized some of the defining features of Dale’s model of community and went on to replicate and adapt them as his own ideas developed. Owen echoed the perception of other visitors to New Lanark in immediately recognizing the distinctively benevolent regime under which Dale managed his apprentices, including the care taken to provide for their education as children. This included the teaching of literacy, numeracy and religious instruction, the employment of a significant number of experienced peripatetic teachers and the organization of a formal timetable of classes, including some scope for recreational activities such as music and dance. In addition, the commitment to the schooling of the young was emÂ�bedded in wider attempts by Dale to provide the community with basic welfare services and moral direction, in the spirit of the Dissenting Christian ity from which Dale’s own personal values sprang. Owen seems immediately to have judged that the employment of children at the unduly young age of eight was a real weakness in Dale’s educational policies, regardless of their other merits. By refusing to employ any child under the age of ten, and by improving the conditions for adult workers, Owen swiftly set out to introduce change into the structures established by his father-in-law. This proved a more intractable task than he at first imagined. The difficult first decade of Owen’s tenure, complicated by the adverse effects on trading conditions occasioned by the Napoleonic Wars, was further exacerbated by the declining health of Dale and the inveterate scepticism of Owen’s Manchester business partners, who looked askance on many of his expensive 74
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 74
10/3/2011 7:49:18 PM
Robert Owen and Education
philanthropic ventures. Owen’s educational plans for New Lanark as a result progressed only very slowly, until an ownership crisis in 1812 at last pro vided him with the opportunity to reconstitute the partnership controlling the cotton-production enterprise, establishing within it a contractual com mitment to high-quality educational and social welfare provision as an integral feature of the development plan for the business itself. From the 1812 watershed onwards, Owen at last felt sufficiently empowered by his new partnership agreement to move forward with his major programme of educational reform, symbolized in the village by the renovation of the school and, even more importantly, by the inauguration of an entirely new concept in community education, the Institution for the Formation of Character. This building, taken over from premises Dale seems to have intended as a multipurpose village amenity, came to represent all that was truly ground breaking in Owen’s prolonged educational experiment, evolving into a lasting monument to the distinctive philosophy of education practised at New Lanark. Although it is sometimes difficult to know from the records which of the educational innovations were introduced through the school and which through the Institute, their effects swiftly became obvious to the population of the village and to the increasing numbers of international visitors drawn to the site by its reputation for educational radicalism. Chief among the changes overseen by Owen was a shift in classroom learning away from formal instruction and towards the direct engagement of the mind of the pupil with the external environment. In this pedagogical reorientation lay the apparent eschewal of books, much commented upon by observers, and the dramatically increased emphasis on classroom familiarity with pictures, charts, plants, animals and inanimate man-made objects, around which exploratory interactive discussion took place. Many visitors to the New Lanark schoolrooms were struck by the general openness to talk and discussion in evidence, their surprise proportionate to the contrast with the infamously coercive methods favoured in most of the schools of the period. Owen knew that the radicalism of his educational goals, and the moral feelings around which it revolved, would require a redefinition of the role of the teacher if this essential climate of conviviality were to flourish in his classrooms. In some respects, the initial expectations placed upon his teaching staff were as a result more concerned with conduct and manners rather than academic qualifications. Owen needed younger, more flexible teachers than was com mon in Scotland if his understanding of the classroom as a place of genuine 75
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 75
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
rational inquiry was to be realized. New Lanark teachers were required to be more resourceful than their counterparts in the surrounding parish system, committed to outdoor education, for example, and continually open to the unexpected in their dealings with young children. This was a particularly acute issue in the area of pupil discipline, where some of the methods encouraged by Owen seemed to invite the forms of misbehaviour on which the established system came down so harshly. Pro ponents of the relatively enlightened monitorial method – by now led by the educationalist Joseph Lancaster – had tried to mitigate the often violent practices of the parish classrooms by the introduction of their trademark schedule of rewards and penalties, moving away from excessive physical chastisement to a more complex reinforcement routine of praise and ad monishÂ�ment. Owen, however, grew vehemently opposed to the underlying psychology of this approach, arguing that rewards and penalties simply bred in children a prudential calculation incompatible with the enthusiastic embrace of education for its own sake. Recalling as an adult the atmosphere of the New Lanark classrooms of his youth, Owen’s son, Robert Dale Owen, stressed the centrality of this principle to the whole ethos of the school. Rewards, Robert Dale argued, were rejected because of their dangerous tendency to breed in their recipients ‘pride, vanity and inordinate ambition.’ Penalties were equally unacceptable because of their effect of ‘debasing the character, and destroying the energies of the individual’.6 In their place, Owen boldly asserted that ‘every child will always be treated kindly, what ever his natural character, physical or mental, may be’.7 Misbehaviour, he argued, was the product of miseducation, and the words and actions of tolerant, compassionate teachers were much more likely to produce amenable children than any measures, physical or emotional, taken against them. Referring in his autobiography to the first teachers he had hired, James Buchanan and Molly Young, Owen recalled: ‘The first instruction which I gave them was, that they were on no account ever to beat any one of the children, or to threaten them in any manner in word or action, or to use abusive terms.’ When a response to inappropriate behaviour became necessary, it was to be offered, Owen insisted, ‘in the spirit of kindness and of charity, as from the more experienced to the less experienced’ avoiding any hint of retribution likely to induce feelings of guilt or humiliation.8 The rationale for this fresh approach to the motivation of the young stemmed from Owen’s fundamental belief that the distasteful, offensive or violent behaviour for which sections of the impoverished working classes were rightly feared in 76
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 76
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert Owen and Education
his society originated in a cycle of intergenerational deprivation and despair from which only education held the prospect of release: ‘The infants and children of every generation have been the mental slaves of the preceding generations . . . they have been compelled to become – what their fathers had been previously compelled to be – slaves to the most gross and in consistent errors.’9 We are fortunate to possess, in the form of Robert Dale Owen’s short memoir of 1824, An Outline of the System of Education at New Lanark, an illuminating guide to the curriculum of the New Lanark school and Institution in the period of Owen’s greatest autonomy as their owner and manager. Steadfastly opposing the dominant teaching strategies of the parishes and the Lancastrians, with their reliance upon the memorization of what his magnum opus, A New View of Society, termed ‘precept upon precept, line upon line’, Owen made the central driver of his curriculum a special syn thesis of applied knowledge and spontaneous discovery.10 To some cursory observers, the impression created was of an essentially utilitarian approach to practical learning, embedded in the vocational needs of a manufacturing community. It is clear, however, from Robert Dale’s account and from Owen’s own pronouncements that the economic foundation of the New Lanark community in no way restricted the curriculum to a functional understanding of educated competence. In a later work of 1841, A DevelopÂ� ment of the Principles and Plans on which to Establish Self Supporting Home Colonies, Owen itemized the subjects, skills and – most importantly – dispositions that should inform the schooling of the young in the ideal society. As well as emphasizing ‘Reading, writing and accounts’, Principles and Plans also lists ‘mechanics and chemistry’ and ‘A practical knowledge of agriculture and domestic economy’ as important subjects of study. Even the stress on ‘knowledge of some one useful manufacture, trade, or occupation’ is high lighted for its contribution to self-fulfilment as well as to employability, undertaken by the pupil ‘for the improvement of his mental and physical powers.’ Technical mastery is carefully subordinate in Owen’s thought to what he here terms ‘knowledge of himself and of human nature, to form him into a rational being, and render him charitable, kind, and benevolent to all his fellow-creatures’.11 This integrated understanding of the purposes of education shaped decisively the day-to-day content of learning and teaching at New Lanark. The natural and social sciences enjoyed a particular prominence in the New Lanark curriculum, almost as if their position at the cutting edge of 77
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 77
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
‘modern’ rationality resonated especially aptly with the larger social and intellectual objectives of the school. It was to Buchanan and Young’s cele brated lessons in natural history and geography that visitors were most often invited by Owen, allowing him to showcase the discovery methods of these disciplines in ways that echoed the increasingly scientific procedures by which they were beginning to be pursued in the wider community of scholarship. Much class time was as a result devoted to the handling of maps, almost as if the cartographic mentality had become somehow emblem atic for Owen of the new empiricism by which proper education was now to be characterized and which placed inherited lore and dogmatic assertion very firmly below the fruits of guided but independent scientific scrutiny in the hierarchy of truths. This approach to geography was, for Owen, vital to the defeat of prejudice and to the promotion of the insight that no cultural or social system, whether at home or abroad, was to be regarded as immut able or beyond the reach of human dominion, provided the relationship of place to behaviour was properly understood. In an intriguing adaptation, Owen also applied the ‘cartographic’ method to the teaching of history. Historical facts were arranged in a chronological sequence, so that events recorded in them could be studied in conjunction with the geographical locations, resources and conditions against which they took place. Behind this ‘Streams of Time’ approach lay yet again Owen’s perception of the role of environment in the shaping of behaviour and the corresponding need for education to accord more significance that in previous eras to the con straints placed by time and circumstance on the destinies of human societies. ‘The minds of the children are thus opened’, noted Robert Dale: ‘and they are prevented from contracting narrow, exclusive notions, which might lead them to regard those only as proper objects of sympathy and interest, who may live in the same country with themselves.’12 The social harmony and renewed sense of the common good for which Owen wished New Lanark as a whole to be acclaimed were most publicly expressed in the celebration at both school and Institute of the arts of music and dance. As well as di verging from the censorious gender divisions prevalent in the surrounding parish schools, which rarely would have countenanced such contact between boys and girls, the prominence of music and dance at New Lanark was a potent metaphor for Owen in conveying his passionate understanding of the contribution of education to the cultivation of the good life. In music and dance, individual talent and self-expression were affirmed, but always inseparably from co-operation with the group. In the children’s dancing, 78
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 78
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert Owen and Education
Robert Dale pointed out, ‘Their own improvement is not their only source of enjoyment. That of their companions they appear to witness with pleasure, unmixed with any envious feeling whatever.’13 Dance and music also figured prominently in the educational programme planned for the Institution for the Formation of Character which had a major role to play in the implemen tation of Owen’s vision of a new view of society.
A New View of Society In his most influential and extensive piece of writing, the four essays which constitute A New View of Society (1813–16), Owen advocated the reform of mankind through a planned scheme of education, and his utopian plan has come to be regarded as a general treatise on education which sets out and promotes Owen’s visionary hopes of a society completely transformed by education. As has been discussed above, his social experiments at the village of New Lanark represented both to Owen and to the world at large observing his efforts the cornerstone of his educational thought, and it is in A New View of Society that we can decipher Owen’s blueprint for his utopian society underpinned by social amelioration through a programme of education for all. It is important to emphasize the interconnection between education, the concept of the improvement of society at large and the social, economic and political problems which were facing the British government during the first two decades of the nineteenth century. The central idea of the first essay in A New View of Society is that ‘the character of man is made for him not by him’ and it is the focus on the importance of experience and environment or ‘circumstances’ that shape the life of the mind and the content of the individual character which was central to Owen’s vision. Indeed the alternative title of A New View of Society is Essays on the Formation of the Human Character, and it deals mainly with general principles about character and environment, the importance of proper education and the advantages of humane treatment of people in the work place. Owen formulated his humanitarian, social and educational ideas, advo cated and promoted them universally in A New View of Society and used New Lanark as a test-bed for his theories. Although Owen may not trad itionally have been recognized as a prominent figure in the history of edu cational thought, he has earned a place there not only because he made 79
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 79
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
education a ‘mass issue’ but also because his schemes for education were essentially pragmatic: ‘. . . children can be trained to acquire any language, sentiments, belief, or any bodily habits and manners, not contrary to human nature, even to make them, to a greater extent, either imbecile or energetic characters.’14 It was precisely because Owen had practical experience of indus trial conditions and also had a practical plan contained in the document entitled Report to the Committee for the Relief of the Manufacturing Poor (1817) that he and his ideas were taken so seriously at a time when the government and the ruling classes in Britain had real concerns about the social problems related to the rising number of poor and unemployed in Britain. The second essay in A New View of Society also seeks to examine further the causes of the ‘circumstances’ currently constraining the human capacity to grow in rationality and conditioning the fundamentally punitive culture in which the very poor and the very young find themselves trapped. For Owen, the errors of the present moral order are inherited and replicated in precisely the manner predicted by the empiricist template. When, in April 1812, at a dinner in Glasgow in honour of the education ist, Joseph Lancaster, Owen made his first public statement that ‘we can materially command those circumstances which influence character’, it is clear from the context that he was referring to the effects of education on a community.15 Similarly, the famous passage in the first essay of A New View of Society referred to the influence of the environment on a community: Any general character, from the best to the worst, from the most ignorant to the most enlightened, may be given to any community, even to the world at large, by the application of proper means; which means are to a great extent at the command and under the control of those who have influence in the affairs of men.16
These words have an obvious resonance with an understanding of citizenship that looks both backwards and forwards. During the nineteenth century in Britain, it became increasingly recognized by employers, churchmen, edu cationÂ�ists and politicians that the Industrial Revolution had created, what Owen referred to as, a ‘ferocity of character’ among the labouring classes, and Owen was particularly determined to moderate this. To Owen, en lightened reform and mechanisms of social control were not mutually exclusive. They could in fact be complementary. One way to mitigate the 80
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 80
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert Owen and Education
‘ferocity of character’ was to change the forms of industrial schooling so that the younger generation would be brought up in new ways. In Owen’s view, the problems of mass production and mass schooling were essentially the same. They were concerned with balancing productive efficiency with forms of social regulation from which all would derive material security and moral fulfilment. At the heart of Owen’s educational programme therefore was the determination to create a disciplined, ‘docile’ population for factory, home and the shared spaces of social circulation. Initially, Owen saw the problem in broadly Aristotelian terms, simply as one of establishing habits suitable for social and factory life, but increasingly – and in a departure from the Aristotelian conception of the polis analogous to Adam Smith’s – he also came to believe that it was necessary to establish a certain mental outlook on the part of the children in particular and the workers in general in order to achieve this. His experiments or innovations in education are a response to this challenge. Owen believed that if children could understand their place in the world through, for example, history or geography lessons, they would be better prepared to appreciate and understand their role in the world as, in his words, ‘workpersons’ or ‘domestics’. This is evident in sentiments such as: The children are, without exception, passive and wonderfully contrived com pounds; which, by an accurate and previous subsequent attention, founded on a correct knowledge of the subject, may be formed collectively to have any human character. And although these compounds, like all the other works of nature, possess endless varieties, yet they partake of that plastic quality, which by perseverance and judicious management, may be ultimately moulded into the very image of rational wishes and desires.17
Heavily influenced by the writings of William Godwin (1756–1836) when he described young children as being ‘passive and wonderfully contrived compounds’ and as containing a ‘plastic quality’ which could be moulded at will, Owen’s theory earned him considerable support since he was arguing that education would solve the social problems which were causing alarm to Lord Liverpool’s Tory government at that time. The central design of the third essay of A New View of Society was to set out the moral and developmental implications of the collection’s perspective on the acquisition of enlightened rationality and to examine further the role of education within this. With his New Lanark experience once again 81
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 81
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
providing the context for his reflections, Owen turns his attention to themes such as infancy, family, recreation and sociality in an effort to capture the full, lived possibilities of his vision of reformed community seen in some thing approaching its totality. To this end, the child had to be educated as far as possible in a rational environment away from the harmful influence of unenlightened parents. This education should begin as early as possible – as soon as the child could walk. In considering the part played by infancy in his scheme, Owen’s purpose was to reiterate that the formation of char acter is a process embedded in the most fundamental ties of family and community interdependence. It must be evident to those who have been in the practice of observing children with attention, that much of good or evil is taught to or acquired by a child at a very early period of its life; that much of temper or disposition is correctly or incorrectly formed before he attains his second year . . .18
The training or education of a suitably qualified teaching force was prominent in Owen’s plans also. When, in 1816, Owen published the full version of A New View of Society, it proclaimed (among much else) that ‘. . . the best state will be that which shall possess the best national system of education’. By this time Owen had concluded that the whole platform of popular edu cational reform depended upon the preparation of a better-educated teaching force, confidently equipped with knowledge of the natural and human sciences and morally committed to the tenets of the new rational pedagogy, and he spoke scathingly about the standard of those people charged with the responsibility of educating the new generation: At present there are not any individuals in the kingdom who have been trained to instruct the rising generation as it is for the interest and happiness of all that it should be instructed. The training of those who are to form the future man, becomes a consideration of the utmost magnitude; for, on due reflection, it will appear, that instruction to the young must be, of necessity, the only foundation upon which the superstructure of society can be raised.19
In this, as well as other respects, notably infant education, Owen anticipated and inspired the crucially important and significant work of David Stow who, in 1827, having converted a house and garden in Glasgow’s Drygate into a school for a hundred scholars, founded the Glasgow Educational Society and, in 1836, laid the foundation stone of the first Normal School 82
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 82
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert Owen and Education
in Dundas Vale, Glasgow, the first teacher training college in Scotland. Owen’s intention in the fourth essay of A New View of Society was to bring to its culmination a theme present throughout the work: galvanizing the decision-makers and opinion-formers among his readership in order to secure the sorts of changes in government policy that would enable the expansion across Britain of the social and educational innovations intro duced at New Lanark and urgently needed by the whole country. In the fourth essay therefore Owen stated that education was a means to national moral regeneration and his aim was to develop collectivists as opposed to individualists. A New View of Society was essentially a manifesto by which Owen sought to circulate his ideas for social and educational reform among influential political and cultural elites likely to promote the expansion of his achieve ments at New Lanark to wider British society; but, like much of Owen’s writing, it was not without its critics. The great English social reformer, Francis Place (1771–1854), who offered Owen guidance and support in the drafting of A New View of Society, none the less remained incredulous that Owen could sincerely believe that the views of character formation on which his educational schemes rested were entirely original and that ‘on this supposed discovery he founded his system’.20 Ian Donnachie has suggested that Place, together with his friend James Mill, with whom Owen had also become acquainted at this time, helped edit A New View of Society, lending it a lucidity of thought often absent from Owen’s later publications.21 The essayist, William Hazlitt (1778–1830) attacked Owen’s rhetorical obsession with the ‘new’ – from new views to New Lanark: ‘It is not new. It is not coeval, whatever the author and proprietor may think, with the New Lanark mills, but it is as old as the royal borough of Lanark, or as the county of Lanark itself.’22 Hazlitt also criticized Owen’s outlook as being fundamentally incompatible with educated rationality even if it often tricked itself out in the clothing of reason, and he states in his essay of 1822, ‘On People with One Idea’ ‘Mr Owen is a man remarkable for one idea’: It is that of himself and the Lanark cotton-mills. He carries this idea backwards and forwards with him from Glasgow to London, without allowing anything for attrition, and expects to find it in the same state of purity and perfection in the latter place as at the former. He acquires a wonderful velocity and impenetrability in his undaunted transit. Resistance to him is vain, while the whirling motion of the mail-coach remains in his head.23 83
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 83
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
A New View of Society remains Owen’s clearest declaration of principles and the blueprint for his schemes for the education of his workpeople as pro claimed at the opening of the Institution for the Formation of Character in 1816. According to the virtually unanimous testimony of all who visited New Lanark, Owen’s educational objectives were realized. The children were content, well-mannered, unconstrained and healthy. Drunkenness was almost unknown and illegitimacy occurred extremely rarely. There was a good relation ship between Owen and his workers, and the business was a great commercial success. As Butt says of Owen: ‘. . . business efficiency and good morals went hand in hand!’24
Early Education Owen’s writing emphasized the importance of having a deep understanding of children’s emotional states and the importance of early education which was suited to the growth and development of the child’s mind and body. The child attended nursery school from two to six years old, followed by elementary school from six to ten or twelve, with adult education after that. As was the case in other Owenite institutions, practical considerations were of paramount importance. Owen recognized that while the children of two years and over were being cared for in school, then their mothers ‘would be enabled to earn a better maintenance and support’ for them and they would have ‘less care and anxiety about them’. Famously, New Lanark had the first nursery school in the world and a crèche for working mothers. The New Lanark infant school consisted of one room on the ground floor of the Institution for the Formation of Character, and a playground laid out in front of it where it was intended that the children would spend most of their time. Owen did not advocate the use of books with the very young children but, instead, they were to have freedom to play and run about, and were encouraged to learn to live peacefully with one another, and to be kind and polite. The appointments of James Buchanan, a former cotton weaver, and the seventeen-year-old Molly Young as teachers in the infant school appear to have been based largely on their kindly disposition and good character, personal traits reminiscent of those so highly recom mended by the ancient Roman rhetorician, Quintilian (AD 35–96) whose main aim in education was to mould the student’s character as well as to develop his mind. 84
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 84
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert Owen and Education
Influenced by Rousseau in the importance of educating the senses and the importance of early experience, Owen recommended that music teachÂ�ing was to begin in the nursery so that the child would learn to distinguish sounds and develop his or her musical talents and in line with Owen’s insist ence that natural surroundings were more important than books, Buchanan followed a programme for the amusement of the children based on singing, dancing and an appreciation of natural objects. The fact that he was en couraged by Owen to take the children for short walks so that their attention would be drawn to the beauty and uses of nature is also indicative of Rousseau’s influence. Children under the age of ten were not allowed to work in the mills and, instead, what would be considered in modern educational theory and practice for the early stages of childhood as a progressive education was provided for them. In the elementary stage of the school, the children attended for five and a half hours per day, lessons lasted no longer that forty-five minutes and the boys and girls, numbering around 300 were educated together. No corporal punishment was allowed, and lessons were to be interesting and enjoyable. Owen himself supervised the curriculum which included nature study, history, geography and drawing as well as reading, writing and arith metic, and in which music and dancing played an important part. The children were supplied with a special tunic to wear to school. This was made of white cotton and was ankle-length for the girls and knee-length for the boys. The tunics were changed three times a week. The children were kept clean and neat; ‘bathing-machines’ were installed, and the account books for the Institution record a payment for 400 children’s haircuts. The famous picture of a dancing class was of one in the upper rooms of the Institution which was open for evening classes, balls, lectures and a weekly concert. The galleried room was also used for religious services. The upper rooms have a double row of windows and are light and airy in line with Owen’s belief in the importance of a pleasant environment for work and recreation. During his lifetime, it was hardly surprising that the Owenites com mented persistently on Owen’s role as the pioneer of infant education, which they saw as a necessary preliminary to an advance towards a new society. The tone of their comments can be judged from an example of a letter to Owen, written in 1854 when he was planning to use a ‘panorama’ the following year to demonstrate how the human mind could be formed from birth: 85
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 85
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
How extremely necessary it is that the epoch which commenced infant teaching as a science should be represented in the panorama; therefore your Colony of New Lanark, exhibiting the infant school teaching, begun by yourself, surrounded with those superior conditions, as far as the state of things and of times could permit, should be the starting point . . .25
Owen’s Legacy Owen’s fundamental belief and philosophy that a controlled environment was the formative influence on character has had an enduring legacy and there can be no doubt that his influence on education both during the period of his lifetime and since has been considerable. This legacy is evident in a number of areas of education including adult education, early education and citizenship education. The Institution for the Formation of Character was designed as what could be accurately described as a community education centre for the people of New Lanark who numbered around 2,500 at that time, and it serves to illustrate Owen’s belief not only in the importance of education but in the importance of the benefits of leisure and recreation too. It could therefore be seen as the predecessor of adult education and leisure classes with the emphasis on self-improvement through reading, and learning new skills in an environment conducive to personal and social amelioration. The spec tacular nature of the experiment at New Lanark, the advocacy of a nonviolent and widely acceptable method of social change, and Owen’s repeated emphasis on the importance of education in character formation all con tributed to a focussing of attention on this aspect of his achievement. Owen’s role in the founding of nursery education has never been properly acknowledged, mainly because his groundbreaking methods were initially altered beyond recognition by some of his own followers and then assimi lated to a national system of infant education in many respects remote from his original values. The re-emergence of a progressive pre-five educational ethic in the later nineteenth century in the English-speaking world then turned to Froebel and Pestalozzi for inspiration, largely sidestepping Owen’s example. Browning points out, however, that many of the methods, particularly the object lessons, set out in the Glasgow Infant School Instructor were based on those of the infant school in New Lanark and that David Stow 86
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 86
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert Owen and Education
(1793–1864) was inspired by Owen and subsequently spread his ideas through the Infant School Society, which was founded in Glasgow in 1825. More globally, Owen’s educational methods reached London and later South Africa, where the Buchanan family set up infant schools, and through other Owenites to the United States and Canada. In this way many of the prin ciples that underpinned Owen’s schemes for education influenced not only the foundation of schools in Owenite communities but more especially the whole infant school movement. When the British biologist and diarist, T. H. Huxley, not generally known for his support of Owen, was invited to take the chair at a centenary cele bration of Owen in 1871, he said appropriately of Owen and his crucially important and lasting legacy to early education: I think that everyone who is compelled to look closely into the problem of popular education, must be led to Owen’s conclusions that the infants’ school is, so to speak, the key of the position. Robert Owen discerned this great fact, and had the courage and patience to work out his theory into a practical reality. That is his claim – if he had no other – to the enduring gratitude of the people.26
In an assessment of Owen’s contribution to the history of education, Huxley stated that it was due to Owen’s preliminary propaganda and example that infant schools became an accepted part of the national system in the Education Act (1870).27 The epitaph on the Owen Memorial in Kensal Green Cemetery, London reads: He organised infants’ schools. He secured the reduction of the hours of labour for women and children in factories. He was a liberal supporter of the earliest efforts to obtain national education. He laboured to promote international arbitration. He was one of the foremost Britons who taught men to aspire to a higher social state by reconciling the interests of capital and labour. He spent his life and a large fortune in seeking to improve his fellowmen by giving them education, self-reliance, and moral worth. His life was sanctified by human affection and lofty effort.
With his emphasis on the importance of early experience, Owen’s thinking predates some of the most influential thinkers and exponents of educational 87
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 87
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan
psychology such as Sigmund Freud (1856–1939), Jean Piaget (1896–1980) and B. F. Skinner (1904–90), the educationist and sociologist Emile Durkheim (1858–1917), who saw the role of education as methodical social ization and stressed its function as a preparation for adulthood with a strong emphasis on the importance of nurture rather than nature, and later the sociologist Karl Mannheim (1883–1947) and his seminal work on the con cept of utopia. In what would appear to be an ideological paradox Owen has been adopted and praised by commentators from both ends of the political spectrum. He was first championed and hailed as a socialist hero by the Fabian Society in the early years of the twentieth century as they searched for an authentic voice of British socialism in contrast to the German, Karl Marx (1818–83). It is not difficult to decipher the common threads and see the connections, since among the main themes of Marx’s writings were conflict between indi vidual and group interests, a new society-centred model of man, state control of education and social planning. In addition to that, Owen’s qualification for admission to the socialist pantheon was strengthened by the fact that his mills at New Lanark represented an alternative model to the actual dark satanic mills elsewhere that disfigured lives and landscape, and he stood for co-operatives rather than existing capitalist hierarchies. Whereas the Dunfermline-born Victorian philanthropist, Andrew Carnegie (1835–1919), made his vast fortunes and his philanthropic gestures followed, Owen’s fortune-making and philanthropy, like that of John D. Rockefeller (1839– 1937), were virtually simultaneous. Ironically, and perhaps for this reason, Owen has been described both as the ‘Father of Socialism’ and at the same time as the ‘Father of Scientific Management’ as a result of his social experiment at New Lanark, which was also of course a huge financial success and a model of entrepreneurial expert ise. For this reason, among others, his nineteenth-century utopia provides a useful case study for education for global citizenship in the contemporary world as well as a model for effective industrial management. In the twenty-first century, visitors from all over the world are still inter ested in the social and educational experiment that Owen carried out at New Lanark. There is a strong case, therefore, for promoting New Lanark as a venue for field studies for school pupils, students, teachers and educators in general and those with an interest in education in citizenship. It is an interesting fact that the citizenship agenda can be used by different groups for different purposes, and Faulks provides a useful insight into the current 88
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 88
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert Owen and Education
interest in citizenship when he makes the observation that radicals and con servatives alike feel able to utilize the language of citizenship in support of their policy prescriptions.28 Be that as it may, today the community of New Lanark still stands as testament to one man’s vision of creating a better society, and a unique experiment in social engineering through education which was undoubtedly visionary and far ahead of its time. It is hardly surprising that when Owen died in 1858 at the age of eighty-seven, he was in the middle of negotiating the establishment of a new school system in the town of his birth, Newtown, testimony to his lifelong commitment to the promotion and advocacy of mass education.
Notes 1
2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23
Frank Podmore, Robert Owen: A Biography (London, 1906), pp. 4–12; Ian Donnachie, Robert Owen: Social Visionary (Edinburgh, 2005), pp. 6–8. Donnachie, Robert Owen: Social Visionary, p. 8. Ibid., pp. 8–9. Margaret Cole, Robert Owen of New Lanark (London, 1953), p. 44. SWRO, 4, pp. 109–11. Robert Dale Owen, An Outline of the System of Education at New Lanark (Glasgow, 1824), p. 11. Robert Owen’s Journal, 7 February 1852. SWRO, 4, pp. 193–4. SWRO, 1, p. 49. Ibid., p. 63. Ibid., pp. 399–400. Owen, Outline of the System, pp. 47–8. Ibid., p. 73. SWRO, 1, p. 35. Ibid., p. 8. Ibid., p. 33. Ibid., p. 17. Ibid., p. 57. Ibid., p. 93. Francis Place Papers, London, BL (1813), Add. 27,791, f. 268. Donnachie, Robert Owen: Social Visionary, pp. 116–17. William Hazlitt, ‘A New View of Society’ (1816), in Selected Writings, 4: Political Essays, ed. D. Wu (London, 1998), p. 92. William Hazlitt, ‘On people with one idea’ (1822), in Selected Writings, 6: Table Talk, ed. D. Wu (London, 1998), pp. 56–7. 89
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 89
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Francis J. O’Hagan 24
25
26
27
28
John Butt, ‘Robert Owen as a businessman’, in idem (ed.), Robert Owen: Prince of Cotton Spinners (Newton Abbot, 1971), pp. 168–214: p. 195. Letter from Robert Pemberton, 27 November 1854, Co-operative Union, no. 2305. See also no. 1083 (letter from Lord Wallscourt, 1839) and other examples in Harold Silver, Robert Owen on Education (London, 1969), pp. 31–2. Report of the Proceedings, p. 5 in Harold Silver, ‘Owen’s reputation as an educationist’, in Sidney Pollard and John Salt (eds), Robert Owen: Prophet of the Poor (London, 1971), pp. 65–83: pp. 73–4. Marjorie Browning, ‘Owen as an educator’, in John Butt (ed.), Robert Owen: Prince of Cotton Spinners (Newton Abbot, 1971), pp. 52–75: p. 73. Keith Faulks, Citizenship (London and New York, 2000), p. 1.
90
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 90
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
5
Robert Owen and Religion
Robert A. Davis
In recent decades, the role of the institutions and practices of religious belief in general, and the Christian faith specifically, in the processes of British economic and political modernization has been significantly reappraised. From the writings of Raphael Samuel, Lyndal Roper and the History Work shop in the 1970s and 1980s, to the quite contrasting Tory revisionism of Jonathan Clark in the 1980s and 1990s, and on into the recent cultural historicism of Jon Mee and Martin Priestman, the powerful influence of the often contradictory currents of Christian thought and values in the shaping of social and political attitudes across the British Isles in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries has been widely reassessed.1 Adjust ments to an earlier model of historical progress – broadly associated with the secularization hypothesis and often underpinned by generically Marxist materialist perspectives on economic and social change – have redefined both popular and elite expressions of religious practice in ways which allow us to see representative figures from the high industrial period such as Robert Owen in much more nuanced and subtle ways. Previously characterized – most especially by his Owenite followers and disciples – as an archetypal champion of the onward advance of Enlightenment and post-religious rationality, the vibrant thought and lifelong activism of Robert Owen can now be seen to possess an infinitely more sophisticated relation to the religious convictions and sentiment which continued to permeate the society in which he lived and worked throughout his long and eventful career.2 The scope for such a revised judgement of his interaction with the language and habits of religious adherence of course implies no attempt
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 91
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert A. Davis
retrospectively to conscript Owen to any doubtful tradition of anonymous or ‘non-dogmatic’ Christianity, still less to an amorphous heritage of sup posed British ‘Christian Socialism’. As his closest followers correctly recog nized, Owen was fundamentally a materialist, a deist inclining as he grew older more and more certainly towards atheism, and an outspoken contro versialist who expended considerable quantities of his intellectual energy attacking in often the most public and adversarial terms the central dogmas and metaphysical assumptions of the Christian faith (as the paradigm and most familiar manifestation of revealed religion in his time and society). Placing this seemingly uncompromising commitment in a broader historical and cultural context in no way diminishes its polemical edge, but it does help us to understand Owen’s remarkably recurrent – even obsessive – interest in religion as part of a larger pattern of shifting ideas and values in British intellectual life of the period, where faith and unbelief are seen to interact in creative and unpredictable ways – secularism borrowing the prophetic registers of millenarian religious expectation, for example, or evangelical Christianity attempting to argue its case through the methods of the new experimental sciences. Interpreted in these more flexible terms, Robert Owen can be seen as a genuinely transitional figure both in the histories of faith and in the development of a confident, authentically non-religious analytic temper in British public and political life. He stands between the urban Dissenting radicalism of the 1790s London of William Godwin, Francis Place and William Blake (with its ancient roots in the unfinished Puritan revolution of the preceding century), and the more reserved yet equally revolutionary scientific materialism of figures such as Charles Darwin, Herbert Spencer and James Frazer – many of whose later ideas seemed to signal the inauguration of the new era of reason that Owen had striven for decades to proclaim.3 At the very end of his career, and to the lasting embarrassment of many of his friends and biographers, Owen appeared to abandon his life long materialism by joining the Spiritualist Church and making extravagant claims for the veracity of personal survival beyond death and comÂ�muni cation with the minds of the departed. As this essay will show, set in its cultural and intellectual context, Owen’s late embrace of Spiritualism is less an aberration or a symptom of senescence and more a perfectly rational – if misguided – outworking of his unswerving attachment to science, imagination and human progress. Elsewhere in this volume, Geoffrey Powell has characterized some of the youthful Owen’s engagements with religion, most especially his brief 92
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 92
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert Owen and Religion
experience of one of the waves of evangelical renewal that swept the pro vincial Wales of his childhood in the form of a charismatic Methodist mission. In a style typical of his later self-hagiography, Owen’s reconstruction of this memory in his autobiography is contrived to serve the grander narrative pattern of his progressive liberation from the obscurantism and factionalism of religious attachment, leading to his somewhat priggish self-portrayal as a precociously gifted child equipped to see through the metaphysical deceits of religion whilst retrieving from its benighted adherents its worthwhile residue of ethical insight. Powell and others are wisely sceptical of this version of events, pointing to the relatively orthodox piety of Owen’s family and upbringing in the Established Church in Wales and the persistence of an at least notional Christian observance into the years of his teenage apprentice ships in England.4 The Life of Robert Owen, Written by Himself typifies the difficulties attendant upon every effort to reproduce the pedigree of Owen’s opposition to religion, plagued as they are by the author’s self-aggrandizing evasiveness in documenting his academic influences and exacerbated by his mature (if eccentric) ideological hostility to book learning and received opinion. Whether his suspicion of orthodox religion genuinely did germinate in his Welsh childhood, or, as seems more likely, formed in response to his participation as a young man in the intellectual pursuits of the freethinking commercial classes of the city of Manchester in the 1790s, the record we possess of it in both the autobiography and in his early lectures and publi cations locates it firmly in the mainstream of the Enlightenment critique of religious faith by the principles of applied rationality. Scarcely naming a single text, the early chapters of the autobiography tell us that his ‘readings’ ‘compelled’ the youthful Owen ‘to feel strongly at ten years of age that there must be something fundamentally wrong in all religion’, while his shortlived exposure to the Methodist revival sagely forewarned him, he tells us, of the ‘deadly hatred’ of ‘contending faiths’.5 Cautious though we may rightly be towards these expressions of the older Owen’s hindsight, there is no justifiÂ�cation for dismissing his self-narration entirely, if only because his conÂ�clusions sit squarely within the tradition of classical Enlightenment scepticism to which he was most definitely exposed in the libraries of the commercial circles in which he moved as a young man, most especially that of the Manchester Literary and Philosophical Society, to which he was admitted in 1792 at the age of twenty-one. The young Owen’s generally anticlerical and freethinking response to religion echoes a by then well93
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 93
10/3/2011 7:49:19 PM
Robert A. Davis
respected Enlightenment tradition of anti-religious critique associated with venerated philosophical luminaries such as Spinoza, Voltaire, Diderot, Helvétius and, in Britain, David Hume and William Godwin.6 The precise mechanisms by which these specific ideas were communicated to Owen is less important than their role in the creation of a general climate of opinion, which lent them a particular academic credibility even where the governing institutions of Church and society remained implacably arrayed against them. Almost certainly, Owen’s familiarity with this body of thought came in the hybrid forms typical of the British artisan classes of the period, denied entry to a formal classical and university education. While there is strong circumstantial evidence that he gained access to early translations of thinkers such as Helvétius, becoming through this acquaintance for a time an avid disciple of William Godwin, a more important source for his education in Enlightenment rationalism would almost certainly have been the lectures and discussion groups of the Manchester Society itself.7 Here dialogue focused less upon the subversive, dangerous extremes of Enlightenment atheism and more upon the fashionable rational compromise of the period known as deism. The exponents of deism had since the late seventeenth century and the close of the Wars of Religion defended its allencompassing philosophical moderation as the rational successor to the divisive superstition and punitive dogmatism of orthodox Christianity. In place of the unreliable, pessimistic fideism of the so-called ‘revealed religions’ – most particularly biblical Christianity – with their inexorable elevation of the inscrutable authority of sacred text and sacred persons, deism pro posed a ‘natural religion’ of rational observation and scientific deduction. Requiring no intervention of the deity into human history, the deists argued for the evidence of divine purpose in the very design and fabric of the natural order, most clearly exhibited in the moral and intellectual capacities of human beings themselves. Dispensing on the basis of this recognition with creeds and hierarchies and miracles, deism appeared to offer an incontrovertible foundation for religious belief in the principles of reason alone, one on the basis of which humanity could be released from the fatalism of sin and raised to its rightful position of moral excellence as the finest handiwork of the supreme being and architect of the universe.8 By the end of the eighteenth century, deism had come under sustained attack from two contrasting sources: on one side, there had emerged a more aggressive philosophical atheism, associated with David Hume and Immanuel Kant, contemptuous of the supposed evidence of divine design; on the 94
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 94
10/3/2011 7:49:20 PM
Robert Owen and Religion
other, a popular evangelical piety had burgeoned, fully at odds with En lightenÂ�ment materialism and convinced (correctly as history would suggest) that the deistic outlook was but an interim and insidious stage on the journey to unbelief. Despite these potent philosophical and theological challenges to it, deism retained a popular appeal in freethinking networks throughout the period of Owen’s activism and important echoes of it are present in his thought in many of his writings and declarations on religion. His early, and in some ways most digestible, synthesis of Enlightenment social and educational theory, A New View of Society of 1813–16, may read in places like a compendium of unattributed Enlightenment commonplaces on individual psychology and collective social organization, but its argu ments appear generally cautious in the discussion of religion, reflective in part of the deistic ambience in which some of its key ideas were formed. There is, however, another important reason for the relative reticence of A New View in its treatment of religion, indicative of one of Owen’s recurrent dilemmas in the ongoing handling of the faith question. Careful conÂ�sider ation of the intended audience of A New View, together with its declared purpose to solicit active support for the promotion of a new model of indus trial education and community living, entailed for strategic reasons that the author’s growing and instinctive antipathy towards religious belief be restrained. Any support he was likely to receive for the creation of new types of community would require, he knew, the endorsement of leading figures in Church and state. For this reason, it is necessary to sift the text of A New View with some discernment for evidence of Owen’s evolving understanding of religion and its role in both the old and the anticipated social orders with which the text is concerned. When it is approached in this way, it can be seen that the moral psych ology of A New View is profoundly irreconcilable with orthodox Christianity. For political and diplomatic reasons, Owen proves at first reluctant in the four essays which make up the text to name his adversary explicitly, but it is clear upon inspection of the first essay especially that it is nothing less than the Christian doctrine of free will that Owen intends to dispel, through the application of the classical Enlightenment understanding of empiricist psychology and its resultant theory of environmental determinism. If the character of man is, as Owen insists throughout A New View, ineluctably the product of society and circumstance, then there is no meaningful role for free will in the shaping of human destiny. The principle of free will, or the assumption that individuals possess a God-given responsibility for their 95
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 95
10/3/2011 7:49:20 PM
Robert A. Davis
choices and actions and can be rewarded or punished for their behaviour accordingly, lies at the root, Owen suggests, of the corrupt systems of edu cation and government of his day, particularly as these bear down upon the seemingly reprobate conduct of the poor who are thereby always held culpable for their every misfortune. Owen’s opposition to the concept of free will – which he refers to indirectly as a ‘ridiculous and absurd mystery’ – and to the social and ecclesiastical institutions founded upon it, is part of his wider effort to provide an alternative explanation for the pervasive presence of poverty and misery and an alternative remedy for their removal from society.9 The depth of hostility evinced towards free will in the first essay, particularly, is part of a wider anti-religious slant in A New View, which, however obliquely expressed, is more central to Owen’s overall thought than most commentators have hitherto admitted. The juxtaposition of reason and truth against ‘falsehood and deception’ emphasizes that for Owen the exercise of a properly applied critical rationality exposes the philo sophical incoherence of free will as the grounding of human behaviour and encourages in its place the embrace of a fresh way forward for raising the ethical standards of the whole of society.10 Of course the central focus of A New View is Owen’s remarkable experi ment in social and educational philanthropy at his model cotton village of New Lanark in Scotland. As commercial manager and community leader of the New Lanark enterprise, Owen had found himself dealing with a generally pious Scottish Calvinist working population and a generally sus picious and inquisitorial Church establishment worried about the intended improvements of a freethinking incomer. Owen’s reforms at New Lanark undoubtedly raised tensions with the leadership of the Church of Scotland, occasioning sporadic outbreaks of conflict with the local presbytery and with local newspapers which on various occasions his more diplomatic and conventional business partners had to be speedily called upon to resolve. Some of this history is reflected subtly in the lengthy discussions of the New Lanark experiment in A New View. Accentuating the understated yet un doubtedly pervasive anti-Christian sentiment that runs throughout the four essays, Owen is scathing, for example, about the hypocrisies of the Christian Sabbath, which he boldly condemns for its entirely ineffective contribution to working-class rest as well as for its production of ‘superstitious gloom and tyranny over the mind’.11 In its place, Owen advocates what he argues is a much richer philosophy of recreation securely integrated into the textures of working and domestic life. Instead of a desiccated Calvinist 96
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 96
10/3/2011 7:49:20 PM
Robert Owen and Religion
sabbatarianism, he recommends regular participation in recreational and self-improving activities set within the established rhythms of work and rest. The wider rationale for the renewal of society as foreshadowed in his New Lanark innovations – the promotion of what he tellingly refers to as a ‘system without mystery’ – is to be realized, Owen urges in A New View, only by government accepting its responsibility to provide a structure of national education covering all classes and stations of the country’s children.12 Famously, of course, the central concern of A New View is educational reform – a signature Enlightenment theme – but this goal is also pursued through the text with an implicit hostility to the continuing influence of religious authority in the governance and shaping of schools. The aversion extends even to reprimands of fellow progressives in the field of educational reform such as Andrew Bell and Samuel Whitbread, chastised by Owen for the obviously Christian rationales of their initiatives in popular edu cation. It then culminates in some of Owen’s most daring yet artful critic isms so far of orthodox Christian doctrine, on the basis of its fundamental incompatibility with the empiricist truths of character formation and en vironmental determinism – elements seen by Owen as the philosophical cornerstone of a new system of successful and rational instruction: Let us then in this spirit openly declare to the Church, that a national un exclusive plan of education for the poor will, without the shadow of doubt, destroy all the errors which are attached to the various systems; and that, when this plan shall be fully established, not one of the tenets which is in opposition to facts can long be upheld.13
The increasingly impatient mood of these statements is echoed in several of Owen’s other, more occasional utterances on religion from the period of his New Lanark tenure. Perhaps exasperated by his repeated skirmishes with the authorities of the Lanark Presbytery of the Church of Scotland, some of Owen’s popular pronouncements on religion in 1816 and 1817 focus on the relatively obvious target of intolerance and sectarianism – once again, favourite themes of contemporary anticlerical literature. At the formal open ing in the village in 1816 of his celebrated Institution for the Formation of Character, Owen boldly seized the opportunity to dedicate the building to the pursuit of truth, a ‘pure and undefiled religion’, and in resistance to the errors of religious indoctrination, the effects of which, he stated, reproduce 97
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 97
10/3/2011 7:49:20 PM
Robert A. Davis
only ‘ignorance and misery’.14 Riding one of the several waves of fame attendant upon the novelty of his educational and social reforms, Owen gave one of his early important addresses in London the following year on the subject of the ‘New state of society’, again taking advantage of the public platform given to him to identify his plans for the creation of a national netÂ�work of model industrial villages quite expressly with principled opposÂ�ition to ‘religious intolerance, or sectarian feelings of division and separation’: Therefore, unless the world is now prepared to dismiss all its erroneous religious notions, and to feel the justice and necessity of publicly acknowledging the most unlimited freedom, it will be futile to erect villages of union and mutual cooperation . . . Any religion that creates one particle of feeling short of this is false; and must prove a curse to the whole human race!15
At this juncture in his public career, Owen confined most of his louder expressions of anti-religious sentiment to the perceived abuses of religion, rather than to the propositional or theological content of religious doctrine itself. There were, as we have seen, pragmatic reasons for this moderation and it helped sustain support for his schemes amongst radical political sympathizers in the capital and elsewhere still firmly attached to the traditions of Christian Nonconformist and Unitarian devotion. It was clear to discerning readers of his most important works, particularly A New View, that there ran through Owen’s thought a vital seam of anti-religious feeling much more constitutively at odds with dogmatic Christianity than his often highly qualified public comments appeared to suggest. But this was not sufficiently prominent by itself to scandalize his supporters or seriously impede his social and educational undertakings. Nevertheless, it may well have been his increasing frustration with both the inertia of the nation’s political and ecclesiastical elites, and his ongoing low-intensity contests with the authorities of the Church of Scotland, which steadily pushed Owen towards greater and more overt radicalism in his critique of religion. A definite turning-point came in the mid-1820s, as his exasperation with the apparent failure of his schemes beyond the confines of New Lanark caused Owen’s gaze to rove westwards, towards America, in pursuit of a new theatre for the realization of his social and educational dreams. The eventual climax of this dramatic change of outlook was the failed and costly endeavour of the Owenite New Harmony settlement in 98
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 98
10/3/2011 7:49:20 PM
Robert Owen and Religion
Indiana. The New Harmony venture was accompanied, however, by one of Owen’s most dramatic forays into religious polemic: a remarkable public debate in the United States with a renowned evangelical controversialist named Alexander Campbell. Campbell had emerged in the 1820s from immigrant Irish-Scots origins as a skilled opponent of the waves of sceptics and freethinking intellectuals who had eagerly spearheaded the western expansion of the United States in furtherance of what they saw as the Enlightenment values of the Con stitution and in support of a roundly secular view of the destiny of the new Republic. Formed initially in independent evangelical preaching circles in Virginia, Campbell eventually attracted a huge following amongst Calvinists and Baptists all across the nation, around which he soon generated what came to be known as the Second Great AwakeningÂ�Â�– a major, mass- move ment Pentecostal revival that was to play a decisive role in stemming the tide of American secularism and in shaping the politics and consciousness of the antebellum period, from the New England states to the expanding western frontier.16 Owen first came to Campbell’s attention when the newspaper of Owen’s fledgeling community project, the New Harmony Gazette, published the text of an 1826 Independence Day oration given by Owen entitled ‘A declar ation of mental independence’. This was a speech composed in the now familiar Owenite register of public exhortation, announcing to the citizens of New Harmony the dawn of a new age of ‘FULL FREEDOM TO THE HUMAN MIND’ and attacking a ‘trinity of the most monstrous evils that could be combined to inflict mental and physical evil upon the whole race’: the private ownership of property, the institution of marriage and religion.17 It seemed clear from this manifesto of his new community that Owen had finally broken with his enforced habit of temporizing with the sensitivities and patronage of believers. The text of the declaration in fact crystallizes two themes that were to prove enduring in many of his subsequent assaults upon conventional religious faith: that all religion is inherently divisive and that all religion is evil. Conscious of Owen’s growing renown with the East Coast American elites, Campbell issued him with a challenge to defend the propositions contained in the declaration against Campbell’s own account of the reasonableness and reliability of the Christian revelation. Owen cordially accepted the challenge and the result was an astonishing and de finÂ�ing debate between the two protagonists held in Cincinnati, Ohio, in April 1829. 99
01 MainText_ RobertOwen_3_10_2011.indd 99
10/3/2011 7:49:20 PM
Robert A. Davis
It came as some surprise to Owen’s admirers, then and subsequently, to realize that Owen for the most part came off worst in the debates with Campbell.18 Campbell was himself a redoubtable orator, educated at Glasgow University and steeped in the traditions of Enlightenment rhetoric. He was also an erudite biblical linguist, accomplished theologian and graceful inter locutor. Owen was clearly taken aback by Campbell’s skills and was driven to concede at one point that his opponent had succeeded in placing the best possible gloss on Christian belief. But Owen’s relative failure in the Cincinnati debate was attributable less to Campbell’s philosophical abilities, formidable though these were, and more to the constricted and rhetorically frozen pseudo-academic postures Owen chose to assume in their exchanges. Beginning promisingly enough with a written summary of five c