Risk, Governance and Society Volume 14 Editors Jeryl Mumpower, Texas A&M University, College Station, USA Ortwin Renn, Center for Technology Assessment in Baden-Württemberg, Germany
Ann Bostrom · Steven French · Sara Gottlieb Editors
Risk Assessment, Modeling and Decision Support Strategic Directions
123
Ann Bostrom Associate Dean of Research & Associate Professor Daniel J. Evans School of Public Affairs University of Washington 327 Parrington Hall Box 353055 Seattle, Washington 98195-3055 USA
[email protected]
ISBN 978-3-540-71157-5
Professor Steven French Sara Gottlieb Georgia Institute of Technology Center for Geographic Information Systems College of Architecture Atlanta, GA 30332 USA
[email protected] [email protected]
e-ISBN 978-3-540-71158-2
DOI 10.1007/978-3-540-71158-2 Library of Congress Control Number: 2007936685 c 2008 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Production: LE-TEX Jelonek, Schmidt & Vöckler GbR, Leipzig Cover design: WMX Design GmbH, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper 987654321 springer.com
Contents
1 Introduction ............................................................................................ 1 1.1 Roadmap to the Book ....................................................................... 2 2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment ........................................ 5 2.1 Introduction ...................................................................................... 5 2.2 Terminology ..................................................................................... 6 2.3 Overview of Seismic Risk Assessment ............................................ 9 2.4 A Brief Chronology of Selected Events in Seismic Risk Assessment ........................................................................................... 11 2.5 How We Got Here.......................................................................... 11 2.6 Vulnerability................................................................................... 30 2.7 Special Vulnerability Relations...................................................... 40 2.8 Asset Identification and Attributes................................................. 44 2.9 Risk Analysis Methods................................................................... 47 2.10 Assessment ................................................................................... 50 2.11 Current Status ............................................................................... 53 2.12 Concluding Remarks .................................................................... 55 2.13 Acknowledgments ........................................................................ 56 References ............................................................................................ 57 3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment .................. 83 Introduction .......................................................................................... 83 3.1 Lessons Leaned from Current Practice and Future Needs in Regional Loss Estimation..................................................................... 84 3.2 The Dawn of Earthquake Investigations and Cross-Continent Interactions ........................................................................................... 89 3.3 Social Science Perspectives on Seismic Risk Assessment............. 96 3.4 Seismic Risk Assessment: History and Strategic Directions.......... 97 References ............................................................................................ 99
VI
Contents
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling: HAZUS® Development and Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning......................... 101 4.1 Introduction .................................................................................. 101 4.2 HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model Overview ................................... 102 4.3 Use of HAZUS®MH to Support Catastrophe Planning .................. 104 4.4 Use of HAZUS®MH to Link Risk Assessment, Mitigation and Disaster Response............................................................................... 110 4.5 Utilization of a Web-Based Data Management Portal System..... 113 4.6 Conclusions .................................................................................. 115 References .......................................................................................... 115 5 Perspectives on Development and Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning............................................................................ 117 Introduction ........................................................................................ 117 5.1 Recommended Improvements for HAZUS®MH ............................ 118 5.2 User Dynamics and HAZUS® Development................................ 123 5.3 Perspectives from a HAZUS® User.............................................. 127 5.4 Strategic Directions for HAZUS® and Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning.......................................................................... 129 References .......................................................................................... 132 6 Loss Estimation Models and Metrics................................................ 135 6.1 Introduction .................................................................................. 135 6.2 Loss Dimensions .......................................................................... 136 6.3 Components of the HAZUS® Loss Estimation Methodology ...... 139 6.4 Current Limitations ...................................................................... 143 6.5 Loss Calibration Studies............................................................... 145 6.6 General Guidelines on the Use of Loss Estimates........................ 150 6.7 Research Topics ........................................................................... 153 References .......................................................................................... 154 Bibliography of Additional HAZUS® Studies.................................... 156 7 Perspectives on Loss Estimation Models and Metrics..................... 171 Introduction ........................................................................................ 171 7.1 Model Validation and Priorities in Loss Metrics ......................... 172 7.2 Additional Considerations in Loss Estimation ............................. 175 7.3 Social and Economic Considerations in Loss Estimation Modeling ............................................................................................ 179 7.4 Strategic Directions for Loss Estimation Models and Metrics..... 181 References .......................................................................................... 183
Contents
VII
8 Seismic Risk Mitigation Decisions Under Uncertainty ................... 185 8.1 Introduction .................................................................................. 185 8.2 Seismic Risk Analysis for Nuclear Power Plants......................... 186 8.3 Nuclear Power Plant Seismic Design ........................................... 187 8.4 Recommendations for Seismic Risk Mitigation Decisions .......... 193 8.5 Importance of Uncertainties ......................................................... 195 8.6 Summary ...................................................................................... 197 References .......................................................................................... 197 9 Perspectives on Seismic Risk Mitigation Decisions Under Uncertainty............................................................................................. 199 Introduction ........................................................................................ 199 9.1 Perspectives from a Risk Assessment Practitioner....................... 200 9.2 Seismic Risk Assessment and Mitigation: Current Issues............ 208 9.3 On the Importance of Network Considerations in Lifeline Risk Assessment ......................................................................................... 214 9.4 Strategic Directions for Seismic Risk Mitigation Decisions Under Uncertainty ......................................................................................... 222 References .......................................................................................... 224 10 Modeling Seismic Mitigation Strategies ......................................... 227 10.1 Introduction ................................................................................ 228 10.2 Structure of Catastrophe Models ................................................ 229 10.3 A Comparison of Models ........................................................... 230 10.4 The Exceedance Probability Curve ............................................ 233 10.5 Choice of Seismic Mitigation Strategies .................................... 235 10.6 Cost-Benefit Analysis................................................................. 237 10.7 A Mitigation Example Using an Insurance-Based Model.......... 238 10.8 Consideration of Decision Processes.......................................... 242 10.9 Improving the Modeling of Seismic Mitigation Strategies ........ 243 References .......................................................................................... 244 11 Perspectives on Modeling Seismic Mitigation Strategies .............. 247 Introduction ........................................................................................ 247 11.1 Catastrophe Modeling Paradigm Shift ....................................... 248 11.2 A Structural Engineering Perspective on Modeling Seismic Mitigation Strategies .......................................................................... 252 11.3 The Role of Risk Modeling in Mitigation .................................. 254 11.4 Adopting Mitigation ................................................................... 255 11.5 Strategic Directions for Modeling Seismic Mitigation Strategies ............................................................................................ 256 References .......................................................................................... 259
VIII
Contents
12 Visualizing Uncertainty in Natural Hazards.................................. 261 12.1 Introduction ................................................................................ 261 12.2 From Concepts to Representations............................................. 263 12.3 Uncertainty Visualization........................................................... 269 12.4 Task-Oriented Visual Mappings................................................. 282 12.5 Hazards Visualization................................................................. 285 12.6 Challenges .................................................................................. 290 12.7 Acknowledgments ...................................................................... 291 References .......................................................................................... 291 13 Perspectives on Visualizing Uncertainty in Natural Hazards ...... 295 Introduction ........................................................................................ 295 13.1 Preferred Data Visualization Techniques May Not Lead to Comprehension and Use of Hazard Information................................ 296 13.2 Putting Seismic Risk and Uncertainty on the Map..................... 306 13.3 Keep Representations Simple for Effective Communication..... 311 13.4 Strategic Directions for Visualizing Uncertainty in Natural Hazards............................................................................................... 313 References .......................................................................................... 314 14 Conclusion ......................................................................................... 319 Index ....................................................................................................... 323 List of Contributing Authors................................................................ 329
List of Abbreviations
AAL ABAG ABV AEBM ALA ANSI ANSS ANSYS ASCE ASTM ATC AWSS BCA BI BOCA
BPT BSSA BSSC CBA CBC CBRM CDMG CEB CGS CM COSMOS CUBE
Average Annual Loss Association of Bay Area Governments Assembly Based Vulnerability Advanced Engineering Building Module American Lifelines Alliance American National Standards Institute Advanced National Seismic System A suite of software products for engineering simulation by ANSYS, Inc. American Society of Civil Engineers American Society for Testing and Materials Applied Technology Council Auxiliary Water Supply System Benefit Cost Analysis Business Interruption Building Officials and Code Administrators International, Inc. One of three statutory members of the ICC. Producer of the National Building Code (NBC). Brownian Passage Time Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America Building Seismic Safety Council Cost-Benefit Analysis California Building Code. The 2001 CBC is based on the 1997 UBC model code. Consequence Based Risk Management California Division of Mines and Geology, recently renamed as CGS (q.v.) Comité Euro-Internationale du Béton California Geological Survey Catastrophe Modeling Consortium of Organizations for Strong Motion Observation Systems California Institute of Technology-USGS-Broadcast of Earthquakes
X
List of Abbreviations
CUSEC DEM DMA DOE DOI DPM DPRI EAL ECHO EERI ELF EOC EP EPEDAT EPRI ETABS EQE ERI FEM FEMA HMGP FRISK
GIS GPS GSHAP GSN HAZMAT HAZUS® HAZUS®97 HAZUS®99 HAZUS®99-SR1 HAZUS®99-SR2 HAZUS®MH HAZUS®MH-MR1 HAZUS®MH-MR2 HEC HSV
Central United States Earthquake Consortium digital elevation model Disaster Management Act of 2000 Department of Energy Department of Insurance (California, aka CDI) Damage Probability Matrices Disaster Prevention Research Institute (Kyoto University, Japan) Expected Annualized Losses Earth Change and Hazard Observatory Earthquake Engineering Research Institute Equivalent Lateral Force Emergency Operations Center Exceedance Probability Early Post-Earthquake Damage Assessment Tool Electric Power Research Institute Software for Integrated Analysis, Design and Drafting of Building Systems by Computers & Structures, Inc. (CSI) EQE International, Consulting Company Earthquake Research Institute, founded 1923 from IEIC Finite Element Method Federal Emergency Management Agency Hazard Mitigation Grant Program A Windows-Based Program for Seismic Hazard Evaluation, developed by Robin McGuire, Risk Engineering Inc., Boulder, Colorado Geographic Information Systems Global Positioning System Global Seismic Hazard Assessment Program Global Seismic Network Hazardous Materials Hazards U.S. Hazards U.S. 1997 Release Hazards U.S. 1999 Release Hazards U.S. 1999 Service Release 1.0 (2001) Hazards U.S. 1999 Service Release 2.0 (2002) Hazards U.S. Multi-Hazards Hazards U.S. Multi-Hazards Maintenance Release 1.0 (2005) Hazards U.S. Multi-Hazards Maintenance Release 2.0 (2006) Hydrologic Engineering Center (USACE) Hue, Saturation, Value
List of Abbreviations IAEE IBC ICBO
ICC
ICES
ICMA IDNDR IEIC InSAR IRIS ISC ISDR IT JMA LRFD LessLoss LFRS LIDAR LLNL LRFD LUPM M MAE Center MAEViz
MBT
XI
International Association of Earthquake Engineering International Building Code. Published as a model code by ICC since 2000. International Conference of Building Officials. One of three statutory members of the ICC. Producer of the UBC. International Code Council. Formed from three statutory members: BOCA, ICBO, and SBCCI. Producer of the IBC. Integrated Civil Engineering System, a visionary project at MIT in the 60s to develop an integrated system of software – included COGO, STRUDL, BRIDGE, LEASE, PROJECT, ROADS and TRANSET (only STRUDL is explained in this Glossary). Internal languages include ICETRAN and CDL. See "An Integrated Computer System for Engineering Problem Solving", D. Roos, Proc SJCC 27(2), AFIPS (Spring 1965). International City/County Management Association International Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction Imperial Earthquake Investigation Committee (Japan), founded 1892 following Nobi Earthquake Interferometric synthetic aperture radar Incorporated Research Institutions for Seismology International Seismological Centre International Strategy for Disaster Reduction Information technology Japan Meteorological Agency Load and Resistance Factor Design EU project for Risk Mitigation for Earthquakes and Landslides (http://www.lessloss.org) Lateral force resisting system Light detection and ranging Lawrence Livermore National Lab First-Generation Limit States Land Use Portfolio Modeler Moment magnitude Mid-America Earthquake Center A joint effort between the Mid-America Earthquake (MAE) Center and the National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA) to develop the next generation of seismic risk assessment software using consequancebased risk management methods. Model Building Types
XII
List of Abbreviations
MCEER MFL Mmax MMI MSK
MULTIFRAME Mw NASA NCEER NCSEA NCGIA NEES NEHRP NEIS NERIES NFIP NFPA NGDC NIBS NISEE NIST NOAA NOLA NORMA NPP NPV NRC NSF NSMP OES
Multidisciplinary Center for Earthquake Engineering Research (State University of Buffalo) Maximum Forseeable Loss Maximum magnitude Modified Mercalli Intensity Medvedev-Sponheuer-Karnik or MSK64 seismic intensity scale (evolved into the European Macroseismic Scale) Software for 2D and 3D modeling and simulation by Daystar Software, Inc. Moment Magnitude National Aeronautics and Space Administration National Center for Earthquake Engineering Research National Council of Structural Engineers Associations, of which SEAOC is one. National Center for Geographic Information and Analysis Network for Earthquake Engineering Simulation National Earthquake Hazard Reduction Program National Earthquake Information Service Network of Research Infrastructures for European Seismology National Flood Insurance Program National Fire Protection Association National Geophysical Data Center National Institute of Building Sciences National Information Service for Earthquake Engineering National Institute of Standards and Technology National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration New Orleans, Louisiana Nonprofit Risk Management Center Nuclear Power Plant Net Present Value National Research Council or Nuclear Regulatory Commission National Science Foundation National Strong-Motion Program Office of Emergency Services
List of Abbreviations OpenSEES
OpenSHA
PARMA PBEE PBO PDE PEER PERI PGA PGV PHIVOLCS P[LS] PMF PML PRA PREC8 PRIMA PSHA RANN RAMP RIMS RISA3D RSM Sa SAFERR SAP2000 SBCCI
SCDF SCEC SDC
XIII
Free open-source software developed by the Pacific Earthquake Engineering Center (PEER) to simulate the performance of structural and geotechnical systems subjected to earthquakes. Open Seismic Hazard Analysis – an effort to develop object-oriented, web- & GUI-enabled, open-source, and freely available code for conducting Seismic Hazard Analyses (SHA) sponsored by the Southern California Earthquake Center and USGS http://www.opensha.org Public Agency Risk Management Association Performance-Based Earthquake Engineering Plate Boundary Observatory Preliminary Determination of Epicenters Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Public Entity Risk Institute Peak ground acceleration Peak ground velocity Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology Limit State Probability Probable Maximum Flood Probable Maximum Loss Probabistic Risk Analysis Prenormative Research in Support of Eurocode8 Public Risk Management Association Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis Research Applied to National Needs, a program at NSF in the 1970s Regional Assessment of Mitigation Priorities Risk and Insurance Management Society 3D Structural Engineering Software by RISA Technologies Regional Spectral Model Spectral acceleration Safety Assessment for Earthquake Risk Reduection Integrated software for structural analysis and design by Computers & Structures, Inc. (CSI) Southern Building Code Congress International. One of three statutory members of the ICC. Producer of the Standard Building Code (SBC). Seismic Core Damage Frequency Southern California Earthquake Center Seismic Design Category
XIV
List of Abbreviations
SDDA SEAOC SFFD ShakeMap
SHA SIC SQUG
SRA SSA SSJ SSHAC STAAD
STRUDL ST-RISK TCLEE UBC UNAM UMB URM USACE USAR USCGS USGS USQUAKE Vis5D
WASH-1400 WWSSN ZEUS-NL
Seismic Design Decisions Analysis – a project at MIT 1973-78 (R.V. Whitman, PI) Structural Engineers Association of California San Francisco Fire Department A product of the U.S. Geological Survey Earthquake Hazards Program in conjunction with regional seismic network operators. ShakeMap sites provide near-realtime maps of ground motion and shaking intensity following significant earthquakes. seismic hazard analysis Standard Industrial Classification Seismic Qualifications Utility Group – an owners group that collects, evaluates, and facilitates the use of earthquake and testing experience data on behalf of its member companies. The group is organized under the auspices of the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI). Seismic Risk Assessment Seismological Society of America Seismological Society of Japan Senior Seismic Hazard Analysis Committee Structural engineering software product for 3D model generation, analysis and multi-material design by Research Engineers International. STRUctured Design Language Software Tool for Site-specific Earthquake Risk Management by Risk Engineering, Inc. Technical Council on Lifeline Earthquake Engineering Uniform Building Code Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México Unreinforced Masonry Building Unreinforced Masonry U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Urban Search and Rescue U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey U.S. Geological Survey Software for risk analysis, by EQECAT, Inc. A software system for interactive visualization of large 5-D gridded data sets such as those produced by numerical weather models Reactor Safety Study (1975) aka Rasmussen Report World Wide Standardized Seismographic Network Analysis and simulation platform of the MAE Center
1 Introduction
Ann Bostrom1, Steven P. French2 1,2
Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA
The first years of the 21st century brought horrific loss of life and property from earthquakes and tsunamis worldwide. Briefly, the world focused on international disaster prevention, response and recovery. Terrorism loomed large as well, after 9–11, leading to the creation of the Department of Homeland Security in the United States, and a plethora of related efforts globally. Many of these focus on the built environment. In the U.S. and elsewhere, large-scale infrastructure is stressed; roads, bridges, sewers, and dams built in the last century are deteriorating. Rising population is taxing existing infrastructure more and more as its reliability declines. As a society, we are developing dependencies on new kinds of infrastructure; these too are fragile and may age even less gracefully than sewers and roads. Our infrastructure – including human services, financial, and information – is both increasingly vulnerable and increasingly critical to society. Around the world, we are extending the built environment into increasingly fragile natural environments, raising the potential for catastrophe from natural disasters. Social, economic and environmental disparities are also growing between groups, both within the U.S. and between developed and developing countries, putting vulnerable groups even more at risk from extreme events. In the United States, recognition of these vulnerabilities has led to renewed efforts to develop risk and loss assessment tools, in particular HAZards US-Multi-Hazard (HAZUS®MH). HAZUS® is a federally funded GIS-based risk assessment tool for losses from winds, floods and earthquakes. Mandated for use by communities in the U.S. for loss assessment, HAZUS® is now being applied internationally as well, in response to the wide-felt need for improved information and decision support. This vol-
2
Ann Bostrom, Steven P. French
ume addresses strategic directions for developing HAZUS® and related tools. While there is a significant body of research on related topics, there is no single source summarizing the state of seismic risk assessment modeling and decision support. This volume summarizes the current status of risk assessment, modeling and decision support, its history and current status for seismic risks, and future directions. The authors provide a positive vision of what the next generation HAZUS® could be (especially with regard to earthquakes) and how natural hazard modeling can be used to communicate risk and support individual and public decision making more effectively. They go beyond providing a guide for software development, however, and suggest the emergence of a new discipline from the confluence of ideas from modeling, engineering, sociology and psychology. The volume is the product of a workshop held in Boulder, Colorado in July 2006, enhanced by lively discussion at the workshop. This format allowed for a great deal of synthesis and cross-pollination between experts from a wide variety of disciplines all working in the areas of natural hazards and risk communication. The resulting synthesis defines ways to improve the applications and uses of natural hazards modeling. While the papers and discussion focus primarily on HAZUS® for earthquakes, the material is applicable to other extreme events, including floods and hurricanes.
1.1 Roadmap to the Book The collected papers in this volume integrate the results from current research efforts in earthquake engineering with research from the larger risk assessment community. The authors include researchers from the major U.S. earthquake centers and some from abroad as well as programmers and analysts from leading insurance and risk assessment firms. Four key components of risk assessment and decision support software are analyzed in detail in the papers: treatment of uncertainty, loss assessment, modeling of seismic mitigation strategies, and visualization of risk and uncertainty. Contributions come from senior experts in the natural hazards research community, as well as from senior scholars from other related fields. The volume lays out a road map for future developments in seismic risk modeling and decision support and helps earthquake engineering researchers position their work within the family of risk analysis tools and techniques. After this brief introductory chapter, the volume opens with a comprehensive historical account of the emergence of seismic risk modeling and
1 Introduction
3
decision support, by Charles Scawthorn, followed by additional perspectives on that history from Dennis Mileti, Robert Whitman and Amr Elnashai in Chapter three. The fourth Chapter is authored by key developers of HAZUS®, Tom Durham, Pushpendra Johari, and Doug Bausch and describes the current status and directions for HAZUS®. The following chapter, with contributions from Rachel Davidson, Phil Schneider and Subramanyam Muthukumar touches on the role of HAZUS® in planning and directions for future development and uses of the software. Ron Eguchi and Hope Seligson, two veterans of loss estimation modeling, are the authors of Chapter six. This chapter focuses on earthquake loss estimation modeling, including the history of the development of these tools, summaries of several case studies that have been used to calibrate and validate specific models and general guidelines on the use of loss estimates. The subsequent commentaries by Stephanie Chang, Walter Peacock and Steve French in Chapter seven outline the limitations of loss estimation modeling due to lack of empirical data and complex linkages between physical and social damage, and emphasize the importance of setting appropriate priorities in loss determination. In Chapter eight, Robin McGuire proposes the use of Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis for seismic risk mitigation decisions, and includes analysis of the effectiveness of this approach in the context of nuclear power plant design Mitchell Small, Bruce Ellingwood and Leonardo Dueñas-Osorio put McGuire’s analysis into context in Chapter nine, highlighting the decision context, particular analytical challenges, and the importance of continuing to press on system-level social and network analyses, and on analyzing and communicating risks and uncertainties for policy makers and general audiences. Patricia Grossi provides an overview and comparison of proprietary insurance-based models and the federal government’s model for assessing hazard risk exposures from an economic perspective in Chapter ten. Lively discussion of this paper in Chapter eleven by Laurie Johnson, Mary Beth Hueste, Robert Olshansky and Yang Zhang touches on the limitations of mitigation modeling including the inability of economic models to fully account for social losses and loss of life and how risk perception affects users’ willingness to adopt recommendations implied by the models. As many of the earlier chapters make clear, models, metrics, and mitigation strategies are of little use to society if a strong case is not made for the high level of risk in natural hazards, taking into account their high level of uncertainty. In Chapter twelve, Alex Pang provides a visually rich discussion of different ways to present complex, multi-dimensional data in ways that are sensitive to user needs. The commentaries in Chapter thirteen by
4
Ann Bostrom, Steven P. French
three experts in the area of risk communication, Ellen Peters, Ann Bostrom and Susan Cutter, provide insight into the ways that the lay public perceives numeric, geographic and graphical information – a perspective that is essential to the acceptance of any decision support system. The volume concludes with a proposal for strategic development of seismic risk modeling and decisions support, in the context of multi-hazard software tools like HAZUS. Open source software, internet access for users, transparency regarding the sources and quality of data, and advanced data collection through sensors, linked to adaptive data analysis and visualization techniques are among the recommendations emerging from the volume. We hope this work will be useful not only to professionals and students in earthquake engineering, but also to readers from the larger natural hazards and risk assessment research communities. Those of you with a more general interest in science and technology policy and risk communication may find herein insights on the relationship between earthquake engineering analyses and support for earthquake policy and mitigation decisions. This volume would not have been possible without the support of the National Science Foundation (Award Number 9701785), the Mid-America Earthquake Center, Georgia Institute of Technology, the generous contributions of the contributing authors and other workshop participants, and Sara’s outstanding coordination and editing. Thank you.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
Charles Scawthorn1 Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
2.1 Introduction Seismology and earthquake engineering have rich histories, perhaps due to the fact that earthquakes tend to affect almost everything around us – after all, one can take shelter from a storm, but not from an earthquake. Great minds – Aristotle, Plato, Da Vinci and Kant to name a few – have grappled with the problems of earthquakes. When issues of risk are added to those of earthquakes, the field and history are further enriched (think of adding Pascal, Fermat, Bernoulli, Keynes, etc.), and the challenge of writing a history increased commensurately. The task is daunting – Housner (1984) observed: “Earthquake engineering is a 20th Century development, so recent that it is yet premature to attempt to write its history … Although 1984 is too soon to write a definitive history, it is an appropriate time for an historical view of earthquake engineering development to see where we were, where we now are, and where we are going…”
This writer agreed entirely when he heard those words in 1984, but two more decades later the perspective is greatly improved, at least as regards seismic risk assessment. In fact, as we shall see, in many ways we were just on the verge of seismic risk analysis and assessment in 1984, whereas today we have very significant capabilities.
1
© C. Scawthorn, 2006.
6
Charles Scawthorn
This paper addresses developments in seismology, engineering and related fields narrowly, and only to the extent that the development of seismic risk assessment was directly affected. We stop at seismic risk assessment, and do not discuss seismic risk management. We begin by defining selected terms, since some confusion still lingers in that regard, and provide a very brief overview of seismic risk assessment. We then get to the heart of the matter – the key historical events, developments and influences by which seismic risk assessment came into being. This discussion is broadly structured according to Hazard, Vulnerability, Assets, and Methods. Following is a summary assessment, selected references, tables and figures. An exhaustive bibliography is available from the author.
2.2 Terminology Seismic risk is the potential or probability of a loss due to the occurrence of an earthquake. The risk is the combination of three main elements – the earthquake hazard, the assets at risk (i.e., the value that is threatened by the earthquake), and the vulnerability of the assets to the effects of the earthquake. Figure 2.1 depicts this conceptually. While earthquake hazard has a relatively narrow scope of simply the physical effects (faulting, shaking, liquefaction, landsliding, tsunami etc.) of the earthquake event on the natural environment, whether defined deterministically or probabilistically, the elements of assets at risk and vulnerability need explanation. Assets at risk is used here in the broadest sense – it includes not only those physical items that have financial value, but also non-physical items that have financial value (e.g., business interruption, reputation) and very importantly, those items more intangible yet of great value, such as social cohesiveness and peace, public confidence, political union, education, mental health and so on. There are not a few instances of governments overthrown due to their inadequate response to a great earthquake (e.g., 1755 Lisbon, 1972 Managua). Vulnerability is the susceptibility of the assets to the hazard, so that vulnerability is defined here just as broadly as assets, although in most usage throughout this paper a somewhat narrower more technical meaning is employed.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
7
Fig. 2.1. Elements of Seismic Risk
The process of analyzing the risk involves a fourth crucial aspect – the mathematical and theoretical methods by which the three elements are combined to more or less rigorously and accurately estimate the risk. Seismic risk analysis is not an end in itself – rather, the risk must then be judged or assessed as to its acceptability, relative to social norms, and to other priorities. Seismic risk assessment is still not the end – rather, it is the foundation for seismic risk management, the appropriate and efficient allocation of resources for reducing the risk to acceptable levels. While we begin by defining some terms, and other terms where used, we assume a knowledgeable reader: x Earthquake: Tectonic movements of the earth’s crust resulting in propagating broad-banded vibratory motion (volcanic earthquakes and human-induced events such as blast are not considered here). x Assets: the humans, animals, property, business operations and other items of value whose reduction in value (loss) is a concern. In general, the economy and built, social and natural environments that may be affected by an earthquake. Similar terms include exposure, inventory, and portfolio. Note that assets include intangibles such as intellectual property, reputation, etc.
8
Charles Scawthorn
x Damage: Death, collapse, physical injury or other degradation in condition of assets. x Seismic hazard: The phenomena and/or probability of an earthquakerelated agent of damage, such as fault rupture, vibratory ground motion (i.e., shaking), inundation (e.g., tsunami, seiche, dam failure), various kinds of permanent ground failure (e.g., liquefaction, landsliding), fire, or hazardous materials release. x Seismic Intensity: A metric of the effect, or the strength, of an earthquake hazard at a specific location, commonly measured qualitatively using scales such as MMI, MSK, and JMA, or quantitatively with measures such as Peak Ground Acceleration (PGA), response spectral acceleration, etc. x Loss: the decrease in asset value resulting from damage. Loss may be direct, or indirect (the terms ‘direct’ and ‘indirect’ loss are used variously – see Table 3 for an example, and concordance of usage). x Vulnerability generically refers to the probability of damage given the occurrence of a hazard. If damage is defined as the median damage, the relation with hazard is termed a vulnerability function or curve. In some cases damage and loss are combined, so that vulnerability can be the probability of loss given the hazard. Note also that in the social domain vulnerability has a somewhat different meaning, referring more to the lack of capacity of populations and social systems to cope with disasters. x Fragility: complementing vulnerability is the concept of fragility, which is the probability of being in a damage state (e.g., “1%” damage, or “light” damage) given the hazard. x Seismic risk: potential or probability of a loss due to the occurrence of earthquakes and associated hazards. x Risk analysis: Systematic use of information to identify sources and to estimate risk. Information can include historical data, theoretical analysis, informed opinions, etc. x Risk assessment: Overall process of risk analysis and risk evaluation. x Risk evaluation: Process of comparing the estimated risk against given risk criteria to determine the significance of the risk. Risk evaluation may be used to assist in the decision to accept or to mitigate a risk. x Risk management: the process and acts to reduce risk in an orderly, efficient and desirable manner. Appendix 3 provides an example of some of these terms, and other terms, and also shows that there is still some confusion in terminology in the indirect loss arena.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
9
2.3 Overview of Seismic Risk Assessment As shown in Fig. 2.1, seismic risk analysis is the combination of three main factors – hazard, vulnerability, and asset value. Seismic hazard is the result of a process combining the probabilistic occurrence of one or more earthquakes (the ‘source’), with the estimated effects of the earthquake at a site (‘attenuated’ to the site via the ‘path’), considering the specific conditions at the site (‘site-effects’). While the hazard is what ‘nature does’, assets are generally what humankind ‘puts in the way of nature’, although even the natural environment will be disturbed by an earthquake and may lose ‘value’ from a scenic or other perspective. Assets are people, buildings, contents, communications, organizational operations, etc. Any asset will have many relevant attributes, such as the age, health and income of a person, the location, age, size, materials of construction, lateral force resisting system and occupancy of a building, the location, size etc, nature and criticality of operations, and redundancy, of a financial data center, or water or other lifeline system. Vulnerability or fragility functions are developed for each asset based on the general or specific seismic resistive characteristics of the asset. In general, one or both of two methods are employed (see Fig. 2.2): 1. empirical, in which observations of the performance of similar assets are implicitly or explicitly assessed. Empirical sources can further be divided into three important sub-classes: a) Field survey data – that is the qualitative and statistical record of observed damage in actual earthquakes. b) Experimental and laboratory data, derived from tests of components and/or small scale models (although recently full scale model testing is becoming more feasible). c) Expert opinion-derived, which is the estimate by knowledgeable persons with first-hand experience observing earthquake performance of structures. The expert opinions may be derived and expressed by more or less rigorous methods. 2. analytical, in which the properties of the asset are analyzed using a theoretical model based on a mechanics of materials or other theoretical framework. Ideally, the two methods should agree, or be used in conjunction in a vulnerability function.
10
Charles Scawthorn
Fig. 2.2. Vulnerability Development Methods
If empirically-derived data are employed to calibrate an analytically-based model, the result is termed a hybrid or correlative model. Relatively few hybrid models have been developed. Seismic risk assessment takes the results of a seismic risk analysis (SRA) and compares it against societal, organizational or personal norms.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
11
These norms vary with each situation – they may be legally mandated, or may be decided on the basis of more or less rational decision making criteria, such as benefit cost analysis.
2.4 A Brief Chronology of Selected Events in Seismic Risk Assessment Appendix 1 presents a chronology of selected events key to the development of seismic risk analysis. The column headings Hazard, Vulnerability, Assets and Risk are rubrics, intended generally to refer respectively to developments in the Earth Science, Built Environment and Socio-Economic spheres, and to those developments that contribute to integrating or analyzing those three spheres into an assessment of the likelihood of loss – that is, seismic risk. Many events cut across more than one of these spheres. An example is seismic intensity – quantification of damage can be a measure of shaking intensity, or a measure of structural integrity, depending on what one regards as the independent variable. That is, one measures the strength of shaking at various sites by observing damage to similar construction at those sites (intensity is the independent variable), or one takes the intensity of shaking as given (dependent variable), and judges the relative seismic resistiveness of structures (damageability is the independent variable) subjected to the same intensity. Historically, and confusingly, seismic intensity has been used both ways – isoseismals are mapped and earthquake magnitudes thereby estimated, and damage is estimated based on intensity (e.g., ATC-13 1985). There is a significant although not complete tautology in this usage – the tautology is diluted in that human reactions and natural phenomena (e.g., liquefaction) are also used in estimating intensity, but not typically vice-versa. In Appendix 1, developments with respect to intensity cut across Hazard and Vulnerability. By allocating the space in the table in this way, large empty swaths show lagging development.
2.5 How We Got Here In his keynote speech to the 1984 8th World Conference of Earthquake Engineering in San Francisco, George Housner also noted “… there are still many people that remember relevant information and would be severe critics of a history. To write an acceptable history, it is necessary to wait till most of the poorly known facts have disappeared from memory and litera-
12
Charles Scawthorn
ture, then, with a coherent blend of fact and fiction, history can be written.” (Housner 1984). So, let us attempt a “coherent blend of fact and fiction”, knowing full well that “there are still many … critics of a history.” 2.5.1 Hazard and Some Related Matters – Early Days The history of seismology, and earthquake engineering, begins with Robert Mallet (1810–1881). His interest was two-fold – the pursuit of pure knowledge, but also the reduction of death and destruction – embodying the complementary natures of the scientist and the engineer. Space does not permit a full discussion of his accomplishments, but his Catalogue of global seismicity and 1857 map, Fig. 2.3 (Mallet and Mallet, 1858) foresaw truths painfully learned much later – plate tectonics, seismic zones, microzonation, seismic risk. He was followed by Rossi, Forel, Mercalli, who in the same spirit developed scales that serve to both measure the size of the natural event, and the effects of that event on humankind. Milne went to Japan, experienced an earthquake and never went back to geology. With Ewing and Gray he immediately developed excellent seismographs and the network infrastructure they demand, and founded the Seismological Society of Japan (his perspicacity can be judged by the fact that the Seismological Society of America (SSA) was not founded until 25 years later). Japan was fertile ground, not only in its seismicity but in the expansive energy of a people recently released from feudal bonds. Spurred by the Nobi earthquake of 1891, within a few years a large cadre of solid scientists and engineers (Omori, Suyehiro, Sano, and others) had built a solid understanding of earthquake mechanics and seismic design. (It should be noted that the Seismological Society of Japan was dissolved in 1892, the year after the Nobi earthquake, perhaps due to the establishment of the Imperial Earthquake Investigation Committee. SSJ was re-established in 1929). The 1906 San Francisco earthquake was not the seminal event it should have been. Much storied and gloried, it allowed Reid to recognize elastic rebound, but not much else of value – seismological, engineering or seismic risk – emerged. SSA was established, but it had been the fire, and seismic considerations did not make their way into San Francisco’s, or any US, building code. This is particularly ironic given the solid risk management that was emerging in the fire insurance field – since the civil war, Sanborn and others had been developing detailed risk data, and US cities, tired of their conflagrations, were spending big money to build special high pressure water systems. The 1908 Messina (Italy) earthquake, with 70,000 dead, was much more of a seminal event. The Italians appointed an
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
13
excellent commission, who developed principles of seismic design still in use today (the Japanese did the same contemporaneously and independently). It was in Southern California where the next progress was made. In 1920 there was no seismological observatory in Southern California. Harry Wood was brought to the California Institute of Technology by Robert Millikan to fill that vacuum. Wood was a pragmatic fellow who was more interested in studying earthquakes in his backyard rather than from thousands of miles away, since the local events were potentially damaging. He and John Anderson immediately built a practical seismograph which began to generate good quality data which Charles Richter, when he arrived in 1925, began to analyze. In 1923 the Tokyo earthquake had motivated Japan to adopt a rational seismic design procedure in its building code, using the Equivalent Lateral Force (ELF) method developed by Sano early in the century (and independently, by the Italians). The 1925 Santa Barbara earthquake, combined with a seminal series of papers in 1923–1924 by Stanford professor Bailey Willis in the Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, led to adoption in 1927 of a similar provision in the first Uniform Building Code. The Italians, Japanese and American engineers all agreed that an ELF of about 10%, adjusted for soils and transient stresses, should suffice, due in part to the successful performance of buildings in the 1923 Tokyo earthquake that had been designed in this manner by Tachu Naito. Independently, insurance companies had ‘taken a beating’ in the 1925 Santa Barbara earthquake, which caught the attention of a remarkable engineer and insurance executive named John Ripley Freeman. Space does not permit telling of the full story, but suffice it to say that Freeman (1930) looked into the situation and was shocked: The American structural engineer possesses no reliable accurate data about form, amplitude, or acceleration of the motion of the earth during a great earthquake to withstand which he must design a structure. Notwithstanding there are upward of fifty seismograph stations in the country and an indefinitely large number of seismologists, professional and amateur; their measurements of earthquake motion have been all outside of the areas so strongly shaken as to wreck buildings … Most of the prominent American textbooks on theory of structures say nothing about earthquakeresisting design.
Freeman decided the US needed a strong motion program, started with the local officials and went up the ladder to the Secretary of Commerce and even President Hoover. The National Bureau of Standards was put on the job, and designed and built a standard instrument for the US Coast and
14
Charles Scawthorn
Geodetic Survey, who deployed it, all within a year or so and just in time to catch the strong motions from the 1933 Long Beach earthquake. Engineering seismology was born, a prerequisite for seismic design. The maximum PGA recorded in 1933 was 280 gals, several times greater than the recently promulgated ELF requirements in the UBC and Japanese codes. Inexplicably given this evidence, California passed the Riley Act, requiring buildings to be designed for a minimum lateral force (quite small, in practice). Also passed was the much more influential Field Act, which required all K-12 public schools in California to be designed under the supervision of the State Architect. Following 1933, the growth in strong motion observations (Fig. 2.4), was very slow, from 27 in 1933 to a total of about 1,000 in 1971, when the total was doubled by the 1971 San Fernando earthquake. Figure 2.5 shows the global growth since – today, there are an estimated 150,000 records worldwide (author’s estimate), which have shown that PGA of 0.7g is not unrealistic for sites close to a fault in a large earthquake. Figure 2.5 also shows the geographic distribution of those records – Japan’s strong motion programs today dwarf those of most of the rest of the world, and Japan has recorded about 60% of the global archive2. In 1935 Richter, who had been struggling with the growing body of data that the Wood-Anderson seismographs were generating, read a paper by Wadati which suggested that the maximum amplitude of a seismograph correlated with the size of an earthquake. This led to Richter defining earthquake magnitude as the maximum amplitude of the Wood-Anderson seismographs at a standard distance. The concept of magnitude, although simple and borrowed from astronomy, was very powerful, not only for communicating to the public but also as a simple measure that could be employed in statistical studies. By 1941 Gutenberg and Richter had accumulated enough data to sort out global seismicity and publish “Seismicity of the Earth”, on the basis of which they could state a power law for earthquake occurrence – the well-known Gutenberg-Richter magnitude frequency relations log N = a – b M, where N is the number of events greater than magnitude M3. They had also developed relations between magnitude, energy, acceleration and intensity, which allowed estimation of the strong motion given the magnitude and distance, and estimation of the in-
2 Actually, there is no single global archive, although COSMOS and NOAA’s National Geophysical Data Center are relatively large useful international archives. 3 Ishimoto-Iida (1939) had independently found a comparable relation, but it wasn’t widely known.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
15
tensity given the acceleration4. Wood and Neumann in 1931 had modified the Mercalli Scale for US construction, so that a correlation between intensity and damage was also now at hand.
Fig. 2.3. (This figure also appears in the color insert) (a) Mallet’s 1857 map; (b) Global Earthquakes 1900–1990 (Agnew 2002); (c) Global Seismic Hazard Analysis Project Map (GSHAP 1998)
4 They noted the possibility, but declined at that time, to define magnitude in terms of total event energy. That would wait for Kanamori (1978), and Hanks and Kanamori (1979), to define moment magnitude.
16
Charles Scawthorn
Fig. 2.4. Cumulative number of strong motion records in the COSMOS database, from 27 in 1933 to 27,000 today. COSMOS is probably the most complete and representative database of strong motion records, although an estimated 150,000 strong motion records are estimated to have been recorded (author’s estimate). Also shown in the graph is the maximum peak ground acceleration (PGA) by decade – the more observations, the greater the maxima. The highest recorded PGA was 2,322 gals in the 1985 Nahanni (Canada) earthquake.
Fig. 2.5. Number of Strong Motion records by country (compilation by the author). Japan has almost 100,000 records, or about 60% of the world total.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
17
Therefore, by about 1940 seismology was able to instrumentally estimate the size of earthquake on a defined scale (magnitude), and estimate the probability of various size events in a future period (log N = a – b M, with a and b defined for different regions). There were about 100 strong motion recordings which had been used to develop estimates of acceleration, and intensity, as a function of magnitude and distance. And, intensity defined damage. Therefore, all the elements were at hand for estimating the probability of damage. However, perhaps due to World War II, no one seems to have made that leap. At about the same time, also at the California Institute of Technology, Biot and Housner developed the concept of response spectra, which was immediately recognized as of great value as it permitted consideration of multiple modes of vibration in earthquake response. 2.5.2 1950’s During most of the 40s, ‘seismologically speaking’ not much seems to have happened, undoubtedly due to World War II. Following the War, the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute (EERI) was founded in 1949 to promote research. Research was needed – in 1948 the US Coast and Geodetic Survey issued the first national seismic ‘probability’ map, although the map was not probabilistically based. Rather, it was a mapping of the maximum observed intensities, clustered into ‘zones’. The map had problems – Zone 3 was contiguous with Zone 1 in some places, Zone 2 with Zone 0 – but its main problem seems to have been resistance to designing for earthquakes. The map was revised the following year, so that Charleston, South Carolina moved from Zone 3 to Zone 2, and then the following year the map was withdrawn. As Beavers (2002) relates: “… the USCGS made the following official statement: ‘The Seismic Probability Map of the United States, SMC-76, issued by the US Coast and Geodetic Survey in 1951, has been withdrawn from circulation because it was found to be subject to misinterpretation and too general to satisfy the requirements of many users.”
And, quoting a 1996 study (Mittler, as quoted in Beavers 2002): “... the United States Geodetic Survey retracted a map in the 1950’s because business and scientific interests applied pressure on the grounds that the map (like all science) was subject to misinterpretation. There also appears to have been resistance by the public and other federal agencies to design buildings and facilities
18
Charles Scawthorn to earthquake loads where earthquakes were not generally known to occur.”
Nevertheless, the map was adopted for the 1949 edition of the UBC, and served as the national seismic zonation map until 1970. In contrast, in Japan in 1951 Kawasumi put the elements of earthquake magnitude, frequency and strong motion attenuation together, to produce a probabilistic acceleration map of Japan, Fig. 2.6. In his paper, Kawasumi (1951) stated: “… and if we want to know, for example, expectancies of … total amount of damage in current price or number of casualties etc., they may be determined from this mean frequency, since these damages are respectively functions of the intensity of an earthquake. These expectancies themselves also serve as the practical indices of earthquake danger. It is also to be noted that we can also derive a physical index of earthquake danger.”
It is interesting to compare seismic hazard maps in use in the Japan and the U.S. in 1951, Fig. 2.6 and 2.7. The Japanese map is probabilistically based and offers substantial detail, clearly reflecting significant variation in seismic hazard. The US map, not probabilistically based, divides California, roughly the same size as Japan, into three zones, with Zone 3 covering more than half of the state. Housner in 1952 developed an approach for probabilistic seismic mapping similar to that of Kawasumi, in a report for the Office of Naval Research which however doesn’t seem to have been widely used or published. Liquefaction had been noted in many earthquakes (e.g., by Dutton in the 1886 Charleston event) but it was only in the 1950s that Mogami and Kubo (1953), noting the virtually total loss of strength of vibrated sands, coined the term liquefaction, and Housner (1958) wrote a beautiful analysis of the ‘mechanics of sand blows’. However, as Housner noted in 1997 in reference to his own paper “neither I nor anyone else…seemed to grasp the practical significance of the phenomenon …” When buildings overturned in the 1964 Niigata (Japan) earthquake, liquefaction was ‘discovered’ and became the subject of intensive and extended research.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
19
Fig. 2.6. Expected maximum acceleration in 200 years (reproduced from Kawasumi 1951)
Fig. 2.7. Seismic ‘probability’ map, 1949 Uniform Building Code (Roberts and Ulrich, 1951) – this map, which is not probabilistically based, was retracted by the US Coast and Geodetic Survey in 1952, but remained in the UBC until 1970.
20
Charles Scawthorn
An outgrowth of the organization of EERI was the World Conference of Earthquake Engineering, held at Berkeley in 1956, on the 50th Anniversary of the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake. While the 1929 World Conference of Engineering in Tokyo had had the 1923 earthquake as one of its foci, the 1956 conference was the first conference focused solely on earthquakes. Forty papers were presented in 1956, the participants found the event very valuable, and it has led to a series of World Conferences of Earthquake Engineering, the 13th of which was held in Vancouver, B.C. in 2004. Figure 2.8 shows the growth in World Conference contributed papers, the fraction of such papers related to hazard or risk, and in (b) the number of peer-reviewed journal papers with titles relating to earthquake hazard or risk. Starting with work at Stanford and the California Institute of Technology in the 1920s and 30s, earthquake structural dynamics had developed in the US to the point where John Blume, Henry Degenkolb and other leading post-WW2 ‘second generation’ earthquake engineers wanted to introduce those concepts into the design practice. A group gathered in San Francisco and in 1952 produced “Lateral Forces of Earthquake and Wind” which by the end of the decade had developed into the SEAOC “Blue Book” (Recommended Lateral Force Requirements), which for the next 40 years was the earthquake section of the UBC, used by virtually most of the rest of the world (excepting Japan and the Soviet bloc). The Blue Book was a good code, influential and representing the best thinking of the time. Not in the Blue Book itself, but contained in its supporting materials was a statement that structures designed in accordance with the Blue Book should: x Resist minor earthquake shaking without damage x Resist moderate earthquake shaking without structural damage but possibly with some damage to nonstructural features x Resist major levels of earthquake shaking with both structural and nonstructural damage, but without endangerment of the lives of occupants This came to be known as the life-safety criterion and it became common knowledge among engineers, but not the public, that the intent of the code was to protect life safety, and that it did not prevent damage or protect investments or operations – that therefore the code was a minimum standard. The author should note at this point that the first time he read this statement, about 1973, he was immensely struck with its absurdity. The statement was one of the primary reasons his career shifted from structural design to risk analysis. The third bullet in the Blue Book philosophy provides for life-safety. However, it also provides for the situation that, if all buildings in a major city (like San Francisco) are designed per these provisions, then all buildings – the entire city – would sustain structural
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
21
damage when subjected to major levels of earthquake shaking. What was the basis for that decision? How would an entire city cope with all buildings being damaged? Why design for that to happen? There were no satisfactory answers.
Fig. 2.8. (a) World Conferences, growth of papers; (b) Journals with paper titles containing the words ‘risk’ or ‘hazard’
And, other issues and questions were emerging – during the 50s and 60s society was being fundamentally transformed:
22
Charles Scawthorn
x The digital computer came into existence (see Appendix 1 for some key dates), allowing increased analytic capability. x Like the digital computer, Operations Research was developed during World War II, and its statistical, probabilistic and structured approach was seeping into many areas of technology. x Another product of the war, atomic power, was being converted to ‘atoms for peace’. In the 50s only a few nuclear power plants were built, but construction accelerated quickly in the 60s, Fig. 2.9. x The 1927 Mississippi and other floods led to the Navigation Act of 1936, which introduced cost-benefit analysis, including the discounted cost of damage, into engineering and federal thinking (but in the flood arena, not seismic). There was a hiatus during the War, but by the 50s flood protection was a major effort, which had to be justified. To support this, the US Army Corps of Engineers formed the Hydrologic Engineering Center in 1963, to develop tools for estimating flood probability and avoided damage. x The fire insurance industry, which had led the way in accumulating detailed accurate exposure data (and loss statistics) since the Civil War, came to the conclusion that their loss statistics were probably adequate for future underwriting, and the legions of surveyors compiling Sanborn maps were no longer necessary. x Also in the insurance industry, Thomas F. Malone and Don Friedman brought the science of meteorology and risk analysis to Travellers Insurance, to model hurricane losses for the insurance industry. They came to Hartford from MIT to develop data and probabilistic estimates with enough rigor for the actuaries. x Ian McHarg taught ‘design with nature’ at the University of Pennsylvania. He and urban planners everywhere were struggling with how to rationally and efficiently process the many factors they recognized as important. Towards the end of the 60s, Geographic Information Systems emerged, with the development of Canadian GIS in 1967, and the founding of Environmental Systems Research Institute, Inc. (ESRI) in 1969. x Vance Packard wrote The Hidden Persuaders (1957) showing the manipulative tactics of Madison Avenue; Jane Jacobs in The Death and Life of Great American Cities (1961) critiqued isolated, unnatural urban spaces; Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring (1962) gave birth to the environmental movement; the outrageous demolition of New York’s Penn Station (1964) spawned the conservation movement; and Ralph Nader’s Unsafe at Any Speed (1965), started the consumer movement. These statements and the heartfelt public responses were indicative of an erosion of faith in U.S. institutions and their ‘trust me’ paternalism, and of
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
23
an aversion to risks that unconsidered growth was creating. There arose a demand for demonstrable safety, which Carson, Nader and others showed Americans weren’t getting.
Fig. 2.9. U.S. Nuclear power growth and some related events
Technical demands – the risk of nuclear power, investment in offshore platforms – and a growing consciousness that explicit consideration of risk was both possible and desirable combined to set the stage for a new model. Steinbrugge (1968) spoke for the earthquake community in a landmark monograph Earthquake hazard (sic) in the San Francisco Bay Area; a continuing problem in public policy, which brought the discussion of earthquake risk into the public forum. The changing focus was signaled by the creation of the first center to provide research into the social science aspects of disasters, the Disaster Research Center at Ohio State University founded by Russell Dynes and Enrico L. Quarantelli in 1969.
2.5.3 1968 And then, in 1968, there appeared C. Allin Cornell’s paper Engineering Seismic Risk Analysis. In the field of seismic risk, no paper has had the impact that Cornell’s did. Perhaps Richter’s definition of magnitude had a
24
Charles Scawthorn
similar impact on seismology in 1935. It was a breakthrough publication – everyone got it, the paradigm shift in earthquake engineering to a probabilistic way of thinking. Although it appeared to come out of the blue, it hadn’t. At UNAM, Luis Esteva and Emilio Rosenblueth (where Cornell had been a visiting professor) were working on similar lines, Kawasumi had produced national maps 17 years earlier, and Housner had been there, in a 1952 paper. In fact, Cornell in the first sentence of the paper cites Blume, 1965; Newmark, 1967; Blume, Newmark and Cornell 1961; Housner, 1952; Muto, Bailey and Mitchell, 1963; and Gzovsky, 1962. But the Cornell paper nailed it. The next sentence goes on to say, “The engineer professionally responsible for the aseismic design of a project must make a fundamental trade-off between costly higher resistances and higher risks of economic loss”. Simply put, the paper laid out a transparently clear, reproducible algorithm for integrating the probabilistic contributions of any number of faults (‘sources’), to determine the total ‘risk’ at a site – that is, the probability distribution of ground motion (an irony of the paper is that the risk in Cornell 1968 refers to hazard, as commonly used today). While the paper strives to provide a closed form solution, in general it couldn’t do that, and to this day virtually all seismic hazard estimates are developed via numerical integration using special purpose codes (discussed further below). Others soon followed – W.G. Milne and A.G. Davenport in 1969 used a similar methodology to develop a complete seismic hazard mapping of Canada, similar to Kawasumi’s mapping of Japan (Milne and Davenport submitted their paper seven months after Cornell, but before his appeared. This writer does not know if they were aware of Cornell’s work. However, while their paper is very good, it’s an application, and doesn’t read with the same clarity and impact as Cornell’s). Also in 1969, S.T. Algermissen, in the first sentence of his paper on page one of the 4th World Conference of Earthquake Engineering, observed “The zoning of the United States for seismic risk has not received the attention … that the subject has enjoyed in other parts of the world, notably in countries such as Japan, the U.S.S.R and New Zealand.” His paper went on to present a “seismic risk map” [Algermissen’s quotes] of the United States, Fig. 2.10a, which however he was careful to point out was not frequency (i.e., probabilistically) based and which was an interim map – more work was in the offing. Nevertheless, it was quickly adopted by the UBC, replacing the 1949 ‘withdrawn’ map. In 1976 a fully probabilistic map was released, Fig. 2.9b, using attenuation equations for hard rock developed by Per B. Schnabel. and H. Bolton Seed in 1973, modified for slower attenuation in the Eastern and Central US. The level of detail for California shown in the inset in Fig. 2.10b (not unlike the detail of Ka-
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
25
wasumi’s 1951 map), when compared with the 1970 map, shows the analytical capability the Cornell method provided.
Fig. 2.10. (a) Algermissen (1969) map; (b) Algermissen (1976) map
26
Charles Scawthorn
2.5.4 1970’s to Today From the early 70s to today, the seismic hazards field has generally been one of consolidation, with much effort on more and better data, and refinement of concepts and models. The basic elements for seismic hazard analysis are sources (derived from geological and seismological data), strong ground motion attenuation, site effects, and methods to analytically integrate the data. We summarize source, attenuation and analysis here, omitting site effects due to space. Source data availability has advanced enormously since Cornell’s paper. Plate tectonics emerged in the 60s and that framework has guided much source identification. Hanks and Kanamori (1979) reduced the plethora of magnitude scales that had developed following Richter in 1935, to the moment magnitude scale, Mw, that is increasingly the international standard. Global catalogs have been compiled from the various national catalogs, and much work has been done to remove duplicate entries and correct other errors. “The International Seismological Centre is a nongovernmental organization charged with the final collection, analysis and publication of standard earthquake information from all over the world. Earthquake readings are received from almost 3,000 seismograph stations representing every part of the globe. The Centre's main task is to redetermine earthquake locations making use of all available information, and to search for new earthquakes, previously unidentified by individual agencies.” (http://www.isc.ac.uk/). An issue for probabilistic hazard estimates like Milne and Davenport’s or Algermissen’s is how complete and homogeneous is an earthquake catalog? In 1972 Carl Stepp developed a useful test for catalog homogeneity, which has improved the quality of seismic hazard estimates. The problem is that a catalog may contain large events from long ago, but smaller events from that far back in history will likely be missing, due to lack of instrumentation, or simply lost records. For more recent periods, larger events will likely not yet have occurred. These gaps in the record result in underestimates of seismicity, relative to the long term record. To fill these gaps, many of the most famous names in seismology, such as Robert Mallet, Comte Montessus de Ballore and Charles Davison to name a few, have pored over historical documents to rediscover ancient earthquakes. One of the most diligent of modern investigators in this regard has been Prof. Nicholas Ambraseys of Imperial College (UK) who since the 60s has carefully researched the historical record, particularly in the Trans-Alpide belt (ie, from the Mediterranean through to the Himalayas). Careful examination of ancient documents can date an event and, by ascribing intensities to the descriptions, draw approximate isoseismals
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
27
from which earthquake magnitude for the event can be back-calculated. The result of the effort of the many investigators doing this work is that the historical record of seismicity now dates back about 3,000 years, albeit very incompletely in the early period. To go back beyond the historical record, beginning in the 60s Wallace and co-workers began using paleoseismological techniques to extend earthquake catalogs back to prehistoric times. Examples of such techniques include dating of C14 deposits in ancient liquefaction sites, or in drowned forests, and dendrochronology (dating of tree rings). In 1984 these techniques were dramatically rewarded when evidence was found near Los Angeles by Kerry Sieh of repeated Ft. Tejon-like earthquakes going back a millennium. Another effort has been the patient mapping of earthquake faults by geologists over many decades. The result is that many regions now have detailed fault maps (http://earthquake.usgs.gov/regional/qfaults/ for the entire US; http://unit.aist.go.jp/actfault/english/products/index_e.html for parts of Japan). A large amount of effort has been spent on building strong motion networks – the first as discussed above was in Southern California in 1933, and the Japanese followed in the 1950s. Networks were established in the 1960s in Mexico, Europe, New Zealand, India, and in the 1970s in Turkey, Iran, the Philippines and Taiwan (where a very large amount of data was recorded in the 1999 ChiChi earthquake), and exist in many other countries. Figure 2.4 shows the growth in number of recordings, and Fig. 2.11 shows two of the larger strong motion networks in Japan, which, in sheer number of instruments, appear to dwarf networks anywhere else.
Fig. 2.11. (This figure also appears in the color insert) Two of the larger Japanese Strong Motion Networks. Reprinted with permission from Kashima (2000)
28
Charles Scawthorn
With increasing numbers of strong motion recordings, better and better attenuation equations have emerged. A relation developed by Donovan (1973) was one of the first to use the data from the 1971 San Fernando earthquake, and was widely used until well into the 80s. Douglas cites 121 relations developed between 1969 and 2001 for PGA, and 76 for spectral ordinates – key workers in this field have been Esteva, Blume, Donovan, Ambraseys, Trifunac, McGuire, Idriss, Milne, Faccioli, Campbell, Joyner, Boore, Bolt, Abrahamson, Crouse, K. Sadigh, Annaka, Somerville, Youngs, Yamazaki, Bommer, and Bozorgnia, approximately ordered according to their earliest contribution. The great majority of strong motion attenuation relationships developed to date have an empirical basis. In the 80s and 90s a few attenuation relations were developed based on theoretical / analytical considerations (e.g., relations by David M. Boore, Otto W. Nuttli and Robin K. McGuire), and there is now an increasing trend toward analytical or “physics-based” models. In 1976 McGuire, a student of Cornell’s and then at the USGS, published open source software (McGuire, 1976, 1978) which greatly facilitated the numerical integration of the Cornell methodology. The freely available FRISK (Fault Risk) code was quickly used by many researchers and engineers around the world as the core of numerous computer codes, and greatly stimulated high quality seismic hazard analysis. To this day, pieces of the FRISK code are buried deep within many codes. The HAZUS® software (discussed in more detail below) is free GISbased software available from FEMA that permits the estimation of seismic intensities for scenario events anywhere in the US. The project to develop the current US National Seismic Hazard Maps developed a new generation of software5, and there is now a project led by Ned Field at USGS to develop an open source distributed hazard software code, OpenSHA6. Many advances in seismic hazard analysis arose from the needs of the nuclear and offshore industries for state-of-the-art analyses. With the ability to better quantify seismic hazard, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) realized that there were many unknowns with the increasing number of nuclear power plants, particularly after WASH-1400 (discussed below), the 1975 Brown’s Ferry near-disaster and the 1979 Three Mile Island disaster. From 1981 to 1989, the NRC funded the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) to develop a Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis (PSHA) method for the eastern United States, which was paralleled by a utilities sponsored study. A key development 5 6
http://earthquake.usgs.gov/research/hazmaps/publications/docmaps.php http://www.opensha.org/
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
29
was more rational and accurate treatment of uncertainties, beginning by distinguishing between epistemic and aleatoric uncertainties. Epistemic or ‘modeling’ uncertainties are based on a lack of scientific understanding that may be reduced in the future, and exemplified by different results from two models using the same basic data. Aleatory or “random” uncertainties are typified by the inherent variability in seismicity or other phenomena, and cannot be reduced for all practical purposes (National Academy Press 1997). The use of large logic trees simplified the task of treating uncertainties, such as whether a traditional Gutenberg-Richter or other magnitude-frequency relation (e.g., “characteristic earthquake”) was most appropriate. In a sense, Cornell’s (1968) paper marked the end of one chapter, and the beginning of the next. The chapter that ‘ended’ was that of seismic hazard, which in another sense had just begun. This may sound contradictory, but with Cornell’s paper the problem of determining the probability distribution of the hazard had been solved, particularly given the concurrent emergence during the 60s of the theory of plate tectonics. The earth sciences now had a complete framework, of sources (i.e., faults), ground motion and the theoretical framework to link them. The next several decades saw exciting work, as better ground motion models, magnitudefrequency relations, other work and data, data, data filled in the framework. The ground motion modeling was largely empirical, and it was only in the 90s that analytical strong ground motion modeling began to emerge. The US seismic hazard mapping program continued its development to where today it is by far the most advanced in the world. During the 90s, an international team (key members included D. Giardini, H. Gupta, K. Shedlock, G. Grunthal, M. Garcia, B. Iben Brahim, D. Slejko, C. Pannonian, R. Musson, S. Balassanian, V. Ulomov, M. G. Ashtiany, K. Atakan, I. Nyambok, P. Zhang, K. McCue, E. Engdahl, R. McGuire, and D. MayerRosa) developed a global seismic hazard map (GSHAP 1998), Figure 2.3. The effort not only produced the first consistent global estimate of seismic hazard, but had many derivative positive effects in promoting international cooperation and enhancing standards and capabilities. It is based on 150 years of hard work and advances in the seismological, geological and other sciences. And yet, Mallet’s map comes off rather well. The difference is we now understand, at least to a better extent, many of the things that Mallet could only see as a glimmer.
30
Charles Scawthorn
2.6 Vulnerability The chapter that now began had to do with vulnerability. This is ironic, in that most people’s expectations, including the expectations of those in earthquake engineering, is that the engineers can analyze structures to an infinitesimal degree, whereas it’s the earth scientists that are always in the ‘discovery’ mode. And yet, in a very real sense and from the perspective of seismic risk analysis, we know more about the earth than about what humankind has built. A note on the rubric of vulnerability – first, it refers to both vulnerability functions (i.e., functions directly relating hazard to final loss or consequence, such as a curve of repair cost as a function of MMI for a selected structural type), and fragility functions (which provide a damage state conditioned on hazard, such as Heavy Damage as a function of PGA – the fragilities can then be related to consequences, such as business interruption). Second, we also include under the heading of Vulnerability advances contributing to vulnerability and fragility function development, particularly structural engineering analytical techniques, although we keep discussion of the contributing advances as brief as possible. Just as with ground motion and many other phenomena, there are two fundamental approaches to vulnerability – analytical, and/or empirical. Ideally, the two approaches are employed in a complementary manner to arrive at a hybrid model, but in seismic risk this has rarely been attempted. Regarding the analytical approach, consider what is involved if one is asked to estimate the seismic risk of a building: x In a few moments, for any site in the US, one can access the USGS website and obtain key points on the site’s hazard curve, in terms of PGA, spectral acceleration, etc. If the site is not in the US, there is still an extensive global literature of earthquake faults, as well as earthquake catalogs, which can be employed in FRISK or other codes to estimate the hazard. Or, admittedly with less confidence, one can access GSHAP and obtain an approximate estimate of the hazard. In either of the above cases, the hazard will need to be adjusted for site specific soil conditions but readily available geologic maps for most of the US and many other localities often will provide sufficient information for at least a preliminary adjustment. x However, regarding the building structure, if the engineer is lucky drawings will be available. Even with drawings, the engineer will still have to make a site visit to ascertain if the building today is the building the drawings show – every engineer has had the experience of finding seismic bracing cut for a new door. The drawings will provide limited
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
31
information on the nominal material strengths but, for structural analysis material samples (particularly of the concrete) will typically be taken, as well as non-destructive confirmation of reinforcing bar location (similar investigations would be made for wood or other structural materials). x With the drawings, all that an engineer can do at first is identify whether a lateral force resisting system (LFRS) was incorporated by design. If there is no LFRS, then in a sense the job is easy – the building can probably be judged to be a high risk, and the engineer can proceed to design of strengthening (or other measures) to reduce the risk. However, if an LFRS is found to exist, by design or imputed, then the engineer has several choices – several increasingly complex ELF type analyses, or increasingly complex dynamic structural analysis. The decision as to what level of analysis to employ depends on the client’s need for accuracy and confidence, and the potential liability involved in rendering a professional opinion. However, any analysis involves a considerable level of effort. To begin with, there is the data acquisition and reduction effort – the masses of parts of the structure must be estimated, and the structural stiffnesses of each structural member must be determined. When this data is compiled, it must be built into a structural model, and that model analyzed. Until the 1960s a dynamic structural analysis was infeasible for ordinary practice. The advent of the Finite Element Method (FEM), which had its roots in the 1920s but didn’t develop into a usable tool until the 1960s, and the advent of a modicum of computing power, permitted the development of software that made linear dynamic structural analysis feasible, particularly with the invention of the Fast Fourier Transform. However, generally speaking, linear analysis is not an analysis for structural damage which by definition is an excursion of the structure into the nonlinear range. Nonlinear dynamic analysis, typically performed in the time domain, only became feasible in the late 80s, and is still today an advanced method infrequently employed. Today, commercial software such as ETABS, SAP2000, ANSYS, STRUDL, RISA3D, STAAD and MULTIFRAME permit linear and nonlinear analysis and are integrated packages with visualization, Figure 2.12, section properties, CAD and other features. There are a surprising number of free software packages available (see http://www.structuralengineering.fsnet.co.uk/free.htm for an extensive list). OpenSees (http://opensees.berkeley.edu/) is a free open-source software developed by the Pacific Earthquake Engineering Center (PEER) to simulate the performance of structural and geotechnical systems subjected to earthquakes. The Mid-America Earthquake Center (MAE) has developed ZEUS-NL a free
32
Charles Scawthorn
3D static and dynamic analysis platform for earthquake engineering applications (http://mae.cee.uiuc.edu/software_and_tools/zeus_nl.html).
Fig. 2.12. Example of visualization of deformed structure (from ETABS, reprinted with permission from CSI, Inc.)
So, while seismic hazard is available literally at one’s finger tips today (at least for the U.S., via the USGS website), the determination of the potential damage given that hazard (i.e., the vulnerability) of a structure is still a time-consuming process, with substantial effort for data acquisition and preparation, and still significant effort for analysis, in which substantial approximations are more the norm than the exception. And, the above discussion has been for one defined building where the engineer has access to all the available information. If a vulnerability estimate of a portfolio (i.e., a collection of facilities, such as all the schools in a city), or of a region (i.e., just a larger portfolio, but involving all the buildings, plus perhaps some or all other infrastructure such as water, wastewater, power, transportation, telecom etc, collectively referred to as lifelines) is required, then the determination of vulnerability using traditional detailed structural engineering techniques is often impractical (for a portfolio), and simply not possible at the regional scale. Other means for development of vulnerability functions must be resorted to. Thus, there are two approaches for development of vulnerability functions – empirical, and analytical. We next briefly review (non-exhaustively) some key events in the development of each.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
33
2.6.1 Empirical Approaches Empirical development of vulnerability functions involves the collection of damage observations and data for variety of structures or other assets at risk, the organization before or after collection of the variety of assets into some schema, and the processing of the observations and data for each category within the schema to determine a relation for vulnerability as a function of a measure of hazard. As noted earlier, vulnerability is a general term – when used in the specific, measures of vulnerability are one of the three D’s (Deaths, Dollars or Downtime – that is, human injury, financial loss, or temporal disruption). The general term vulnerability also refers to fragility, meaning a relation for damage state (Light, Heavy, Collapse, etc) as a function of a measure of hazard. Measures of hazard range from qualitative intensity (MMI, JMA, etc.) to quantitative (PGA, Sa, Sv, etc.). The first empirically-based vulnerability functions were the intensity scales themselves, as developed by Rossi, Forel, Mercalli and others although as discussed above there is some circular reasoning in their usage. The investigations following the 1906 San Francisco earthquake and 1923 Tokyo earthquake included detailed examination of structures but this data does not appear to have been processed in any manner for development of a vulnerability function. Freeman (1932) presents some general estimates of damage based on a review of the 1906, 1923 and other events for several categories of buildings, Table 2.1. Chick in 1934 presented very similar ratios following the 1933 Long Beach Earthquake. Martel in 1936 investigated “if significant differences in damage [in an earthquake] resulted from differences in the building’s subtype, occupancy, or adjacency to other buildings” by looking at 1,261 unreinforced-masonry buildings (UMBs) in Long Beach, CA, and a number of woodframe residences in Compton, CA, shaken by the 1933 Long Beach earthquake. Following World War II, Japanese investigators and the US Army documented the 1948 Fukui (Japan) earthquake, but the data doesn’t seem to have been employed for any statistical purposes. The 1952 Kern County (California) earthquakes seem to have been the first US field investigation of earthquakes since the 1933 Long Beach earthquake, and involved a ‘new generation’ of investigators (e.g., Steinbrugge, Degenkolb, Moran), who did a good job of documenting the earthquake and its aftershocks. However, the 1964 Prince William Sound (Alaska) earthquake was extensively documented (US Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1966–1969. A number of engineers from California (Henry J. Degenkolb, Karl V. Stein-
34
Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.1. Building Earthquake Loss Ratios (after Freeman 1932)
Class of construction 1. Steel-frame buildings on reinforced concrete mat foundation, having rigid cross-bracing, with strong gusset plates uniting columns to strong horizontal girders between windows, with curtain walls or reinforced concrete poured around the steel frame, and with ordinary interior finish. Not more than 100 feet tall. (Expected damage, chiefly cracked plaster.) 2. Tall steel-frame buildings with less-rigid crossbracing than Class 1, with ordinary brick curtain walls and rock-concrete floors and uncertain foundations. Not more than 100 feet tall 3. Tall reinforced concrete buildings without riveted or welded structural steel-frame and with ample strength at column connections and having ample horizontal cross-bracing by walls around windows, particularly in first story. Not over 100 feet tall. 4. Wood-frame dwellings, set on good foundation walls (not on posts or slender piers), not above 2 ½ stories high, excluding stucco exteriors. (Expected damage chiefly cracked plastering and chimneys.) If on tall posts or slender piers the loss ration will probably be 5 to 10 times as great 5. Factory buildings of good design having bearing walls of brick in cement mortar, or of reinforced concrete. Strong wood floors, with little expensive interior finish. No plastered walls or ceilings. Not more than 4 stories tall 6. Ordinary brick residence, mercantile and office buildings, of excellent design with brick bearing walls and wood floors. General average of unrated risks not exceeding 2 ½ stories 7. Same as Class 6, but for general average of unrated risks, not exceeding 4 stories 8. Brick veneered, wood-frame or concrete-frame residence, mercantile and office buildings, or stucco exterior on wood lath, or with hollow-tile partitions. 9. General average of commercial buildings with reinforced concrete frames and columns, (no steel frame) with curtain walls and partitions of hollow-tile, and large window openings in lower story 10. Buildings of doubtful quality of design and construction, uncertain wall ties, unanchored parapets, uncertain quality of mortar 11. Concrete-block and hollow-tile buildings
Expected Average Loss Ratio Per cent. of Sound Value
Soft Ground Factor Add nothing
Bed Rock or Stable Ground Factor Deduct nothing Perhaps Add?
3% “
“
“
“
2 to 4 times average loss Ratio.
¼ to ½ average loss Ratio.
5%
8%
3%
5%
6% 10% 25% 10% to 20% 20% to 40% 50%+
To be modified by structural conditions
To be modified by structural conditions
“
“
“
“
“
“
“
“
“
“
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
35
brugge, among others) surveyed the damage to modern construction, and were shocked: “I know when I came from Alaska, I figured from now on we’re designing buildings as if the earthquake is going to happen in another five years, and we’re going to have to answer for all the mistakes. It sure stiffens up your back.” (Degenkolb, EERI, 1994)
The next year Karl V. Steinbrugge wrote Earthquake Hazards in the San Francisco Bay Area: A Continuing Problem in Public Policy (Steinbrugge, 1968). That publication was very influential – it caught the attention of State Senator Alfred E. Alquist and contributed to the establishment of the California Seismic Safety Commission, for example. However, from our perspective, it started a series of investigations into what a large earthquake might do in a US urban center. A small group including Karl Steinbrugge, Frank McClure, Henry Lagorio, Henry Degenkolb and others were motivated to develop loss estimates for U.S. urban areas (discussed below). In the first of numerous studies on earthquake damage and potential losses, they laid the basis for probabilistic earthquake hazard estimation and, particularly Frank McClure in Chapter III of that report, gathered dollar value loss, by class of construction, for 1,139 buildings that were reported as damaged by the M7.6 Kern County earthquake of July 21, 1952, and its aftershocks. The objective was to estimate the fraction of all structures, by class of construction and “amount of lateral bracing,” that were demolished, repaired, or undamaged as a result of the earthquake. A matrix relating 24 dwelling construction classes with the 12 Modified Mercalli intensities is used; each of the boxes in this 24 × 12 matrix contains a damage ratio (cost of repair as a percent of replacement cost) and a damage factor (the percentage of buildings of this class and located in that intensity zone that would actually experience the specified damage ratio). Seed investigated the July 29, 1967 Caracas Venezuela earthquake (M6.4), in which four 10- to 12-story buildings totally and one l2-story building partially collapsed (over 200 lives lost). His basic finding was that damage could be approximately correlated with spectral velocity normalized by the building’s lateral design coefficient. The 1971 San Fernando (California) earthquake then occurred and caused a significant amount of damage to low- and high-rise buildings, collapsing the Veterans and new Olive-View hospitals. McClure did a detailed study of 169 single-family dwellings in the epicentral region of the 1971 San Fernando earthquake (i.e., PGA 0.25g to 1.0g), almost all of which experienced damage in excess of $5,000 (1971$). Hafen analyzed the 1971 San Fernando earthquake for low and high-rise damage data, correlating it with Blume’s Engineering Intensity Scale. Rinehart estimated
36
Charles Scawthorn
earthquake losses to single-family dwellings on a detailed empirical basis. Scholl examined the 1971 San Fernando earthquake and several underground nuclear explosions to correlate low-rise building damage with an envelope of spectral accelerations in the 0.05 to 0.2 second range (this being the range of natural periods of USA low-rise buildings). Whitman developed the Damage Probability Matrix (DPM) based on the 1971 San Fernando (and other) data. These correlate discrete damage states with MMI (which are discrete ground motion states). Part of the same Seismic Design Decision Analysis (SDDA) project later attempted correlations of the San Fernando damage experience with response spectral measures, finding spectral acceleration or velocity to be satisfactory, though no measure of the correlation is given. Algermissen employed MMI, 5 classes of buildings, oval isoseismals and judgmental intensity-loss relations to develop an estimation methodology for mid-rise buildings. This last study was probably most significant for its use of a detailed building inventory. The MIT Seismic Design Decision Analysis (SDDA) project deserves special mention, as it was an extensive integrated approach to the entire issue of seismic design. Led by R.V. Whitman, it produced at least 33 reports over five and a half years (Appendix 2). The program’s contributions went beyond the topic of this subsection, and included more sophisticated seismic studies, introduction of Damage Probability Matrices (DPM), seismic design cost studies, incorporation of incident losses (e.g., lives lost, business interruption), and the introduction of multi-attribute decision making. Many of the project’s studies continued the practice of using MMI as the intensity parameter (but not all – Wong used response spectra) while recognizing that more objective measures would be better. Overall, the project was a very significant step forward in many areas, including seismic risk analysis. In Japan, an extensive literature has been built up describing earthquake damage. Mochizuki surveyed existing structures in Tokyo and related these to damage ratios providing a good match with the 1923 Kanto earthquake. Shiga, for 1 to 5 story Japanese RC buildings, related damage in the 1968 Tokachi-oki earthquake to wall ratio and nominal shear stress in columns and walls, providing a probabilistic estimate for building damage. In 1985 the Applied Technology Council (ATC) published ATC-13, Earthquake Damage Evaluation Data for California, which has been a major influence ever since. The study used a modified Delphi process for expert opinion elicitation to poll 85 experts on their estimates of damage to 78 different classes of buildings and infrastructure. Building stock was categorized by material of construction (e.g., W = Wood) and lateral force resisting system (e.g., W1 = single family dwellings, S5 = low-rise light
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
37
metal steel buildings). Derivatives of this categorization, not changed very much, have continued through two decades of work in the US, including HAZUS®, and are the model building types (MBT) likely to continue in use for much longer. The experts’ opinions were fitted to beta distributions and presented in the form of Damage Probability Matrices. The resulting ground motion-loss vulnerability functions were not explicitly derived from statistical data, but were still empirical in that they were based on the observations of the experts. Substantial guidance was given on compilation of building inventories and related matters. The ATC-13 report has stood the test of time very well. Key persons leading the effort included Chris Rojahn, Roland Sharpe, Anne Kiremidjian, Roger Scholl and Richard Nutt, and the Project Engineering Panel consisted of Milton A. Abel, J. Marx Ayres, John A. Blume, George E. Brogan, Robert Cassano, Ted M. Christensen, Henry J. Degenkolb, Homer H. Given, Henry J. Lagorio, Le Val Lund, Ferd F. Mautz and James L. Stratta. Following the 1994 Northridge earthquake, a project (ATC-38) gathered data on 530 buildings located within 300 meters of strong-motion recording sites that were strongly shaken by the earthquake, with the goal “to correlate the relationship between recorded ground shaking”. The resulting data did not achieve its purpose of developing new correlations, in part due to the relatively light damage of many of the buildings in the vicinity of the seismographs. One lesson that was learned is that the placement of seismographs needed to be reviewed, so as to place more in areas of anticipated higher damage. Schierle also examined woodframe dwelling losses of the 1994 Northridge earthquake, with the objective to create seismic vulnerability functions for six categories of dwelling, but with similar lack of dramatic new findings. The above discussion has focused on buildings, and lifelines will be discussed below. A third important class is equipment, since industrial and critical facilities are often more dependent on their equipment functionality than building functionality (short of collapse). A major effort to develop empirically-based equipment fragility functions was funded by the nuclear industry’s Seismic Qualifications Utility Group (SQUG) during the 80s and 90s. Yanev summarized the extensive database of the observed seismic performance of industrial equipment and nonstructural components that was developed under the auspices of the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI). The focus of the database is on facilities related to electric power, including power plants, electrical-distribution substations, oil refineries, and natural-gas processing and pumping stations. There are also extensive entries related to the earthquake performance of water-treatment and pumping facilities, large commercial facilities, hospitals, and conven-
38
Charles Scawthorn
tional buildings. By 1990, the database reflected equipment performance at more than 100 major facilities, many smaller facilities, and hundreds of buildings that experienced strong motion (typically peak ground acceleration of 0.15g or greater). Surveys at that time included experience in 42 events since the 1971 San Fernando Earthquake. 2.6.2 Analytical Approaches Until very recently, there have been fewer attempts at developing analytically-based vulnerability functions, for some of the reasons discussed above, and due to the recognition that empirically-based functions would more likely reflect actual built conditions and have more credibility. Friend and Blume (1975) summarized and compared three damage prediction techniques: the spectral matrix method (an analytical probabilistic method), the seismic element method (‘an eclectic method using a theoretical basis but modified to include observed behavior’) and the decision analysis method (empirical) finding advantages in each, depending on application. Czarnecki for the SDDA project at MIT, found that building component energy absorption over energy capacity roughly measured damage. Design level didn't seem to affect the damage level greatly. Kuribayashi in 1978 used an average seismic coefficient dividing elastic from elastoplastic behavior, together with a normal distribution, to provide a damage estimator, although not relating it to the structural system. Sakamoto in l974 used a trilinear force-displacement curve together with standard displacement response spectra to determine a maximum acceleration for wooden houses. Scawthorn et al. (1982) developed relatively simple but nonlinear dynamic models for low- and mid-rise buildings in Japan, and used empirical data from the 1978 Miyagiken-oki and other earthquakes to calibrate the models, marking one of the first attempts at a hybrid model. Kustu, Scholl and co-workers at J.A. Blume and Associates employed a similar technique but de-aggregated the building into its sub-components. Most recently, Porter has extended that approach and developed the Assembly Based Vulnerability (ABV) method, which is the first fully rational approach to vulnerability. It consists of a detailed nonlinear dynamic analysis of a building, the results of which are employed to determine damage states for the structural and all significant non-structural components (e.g., gypsum wall board, windows, suspended ceilings, mechanical and plumbing). Detailed cost data is then used to estimate all contributing repair costs for each component. While it can be applied to an individual building, it also can be used for classes or model building types, by defining
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
39
‘index buildings’ – in this mode it was used to examine the benefits and costs of retrofitting wood frame construction in California. The methodology is used by the California Earthquake Authority (i.e., the state insurance company). The HAZUS® software uses a semi-hybrid approach, in that it employs the Capacity Spectrum method developed by S. Freeman in 1998 to estimate the non-linear behavior of the structure, to determine a fragility curve for the structure. Many of the parameters for the structural capacity however can be traced back to ATC-13, which means the methodology has an empirical basis. The translation from fragility to cost is at the overall structural, not component, level, although the method could easily be extended to the component level. Lastly, for equipment, it should be mentioned that analytical techniques have also been developed, which are mostly applied in nuclear power and other applications where high reliability is required. Kennedy, Ravindra, Campbell, Short, Hardy, Reed and co-workers have led the field in developing these methods. 2.6.3 Lifelines The foregoing discussion has focused on building structures. Lifelines are much more varied than buildings, and space does not permit a review of all the work done in that regard – suffice it to say that lifelines emerged as a separate seismic field following the 1971 San Fernando earthquake, due in particular to efforts by Prof. C.M. Duke at UCLA, who was instrumental in founding ASCE’s Technical Council on Lifeline Earthquake Engineering (TCLEE). TCLEE has led the field in the US since that time. Key leaders of TCLEE have included Hall, Schiff, Lund, Eguchi, T.D. O’Rourke, M. O’Rourke, Taylor, Tang, Werner, Elliott, Cooper, Ballantyne, Shinozuka, Kiremidjian, and many others (see http://www.asce.org/community/ disasterreduction/tclee_home.cfm). Most non-US contributions in the lifelines area have come either from New Zealand and especially Japan, where Kubo, Toki, Kameda, Katayama, Hamada, Sato and Takada have been key leaders. A noteworthy venue for developments in this arena has been a series of U.S.–Japan meetings since about 1980 on the topic of lifelines seismic risk, led by the above-named Japanese and US researchers. Several studies regarding lifelines vulnerability functions are worth noting: x In the early 1990s FEMA authorized a major study of the seismic vulnerability of the US national infrastructure (FEMA, 1991). The scena-
40
Charles Scawthorn
rio-based study by the Applied Technology Council (ATC) examined 489,892 km of highways, 144,785 highway bridges; 270,611 km of railroad right-of-way), 17,161 civil and general aviation airports, 2,177 ports, the national electric power grid (4,551 substations; 441,981 km of transmission lines), gas and liquid fuel transmission systems (77,109 km of crude oil pipelines; 85,461 km of refined oil pipelines; 67,898 km of natural gas pipelines.); 29,586 emergency broadcast facilities, 6,973 medical care centers, and 3,575 km of water aqueducts. Scenario earthquakes considered were Cape Ann M7, Charleston M7.5, New Madrid M7, and M8, Mountain Wasatch Front M7.5, Puget Sound M7.5, Southern California Fort Tejon M8, Northern California Hayward M7.5. The study estimated both direct damage and indirect economic effects, which were modeled using an economic Input-Output (I-O) model for the US. The results guided FEMA’s seismic lifeline program during the 1990s. x Lund and Schiff in 1991 developed a database for recording and compiling pipeline damage records. The database is composed of records, one record for each pipe failure. Each record consists of 51 data fields, indicating the associated earthquake, the pipeline owner, pipe break location, soil condition, details of construction and installation, and nature of the break. The database, which contains information about 862 pipe breaks in the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, is defined to facilitate appending pipe-break data from future earthquakes. Similar, larger, databases have been developed in Japan by Takada, Hamada and others. x An analytically based approach to the vulnerability of buried pipe (O’Rourke and Liu, 1999).
2.7 Special Vulnerability Relations The above discussion has focused on vulnerability of typical engineering topics – buildings and infrastructure. Because earthquakes affect virtually all aspects of society, a number of relatively specialized vulnerability relations have been developed, dealing with injuries, ground failure, Fire Following Earthquake, liquefaction and other aspects, for which we highlight some of the key developments.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
41
2.7.1 Injuries The estimation of human injuries is a key task for risk analysis. Steinbrugge had provided estimates of injuries in the USGS and NOAA studies in the 70s, but based only on a simple rule of thumb. Mitchell was one of the first to seriously consider this issue, based on Turkish earthquakes. The 1985 Mexico City earthquake had a particular impact on this topic, due to (a) the large number of high-rise building collapses, resulting in an extended period of search and rescue for the large numbers of trapped victims, with tragically little to show in the end, and (b) the large number of hospitals that had collapsed, doubly compounding the disaster medical response. The US and other countries began to examine issues of search and rescue, and there was a large amount of activity internationally having to do with search dogs and many kinds of technology (infrared, sound, heartbeat detectors, micro-cameras, etc.). FEMA sponsored work on heavy search and rescue (FEMA, 1988), and developed the USAR (Urban Search and Rescue) team concept in place today. Friedman in 1988 developed an estimate of Workers Compensation losses for a “Worst Case” event in Greater Los Angeles, for the insurance industry. Durkin and Thiel (1992) collected injury data and examined the damage to health care facilities. Jones, Noji, Krimgold, and Smith convened a key workshop in 1989 on the topic, which was followed a year later on the other coast by a second workshop – these two workshops were the state-of-the-art at the time, although the field was still developing. They were followed in 1992 by an international conference on the topic. The HAZUS® software contains an injury module. Most recently, Shoaf, Seligson and co-workers have been working on a complete injury model, including valuing the cost of injuries, and various investigators have been collecting injury-related data. 2.7.2 Liquefaction While a large effort has been spent on liquefaction since its ‘discovery’ in the 1964 Niigata (Japan) earthquake, almost all the effort has focused on either estimating the potential for liquefaction, or mitigating it, for specific conditions. Almost no work has been done on developing functions to estimate the distribution of damage to a class of buildings in a locality given the occurrence of liquefaction. In fact, one might say that most of the liquefaction related work has been at the “hazard” or “micro” scale. The first research this writer is aware of regarding estimation of damage to buildings given the occurrence of liquefaction was by this author (in 1981) who investigated the probability of damage to Japanese low-rise wood build-
42
Charles Scawthorn
ings given the occurrence of significant liquefaction, finding that about 10% are destroyed and 25% damaged. 2.7.3 Fire Following Earthquake The problem of fire following earthquake is a potentially very serious earthquake problem in regions with large wood building inventories, as the 1906 San Francisco, 1923 Tokyo and 1995 Kobe earthquakes show. The insurance industry had long been concerned about this issue and the problem had been addressed in Japan, although only in piecemeal manner. The problem was unaddressed in the US until the early 80s, when a stochastic model of the Fire Following Earthquake process was developed by Scawthorn. Steinbrugge highly evaluated the model for insurance applications, and it was subsequently widely adopted by the insurance industry. Fire Following Earthquake modeling in Japan improved dramatically in the 80s, and recent researchers in Japan include Sekizawa, Murasaki and Tanaka, as well as on-going work by the Tokyo Fire Dept. and Japan’s National Fire Research Institute. New Zealand is also concerned about the problem, and investigators there include Cousins and the New Zealand Fire Service. 2.7.4 Hazardous Materials Environmental impacts resulting from release of hazardous materials (HAZMAT) in earthquakes have received relatively little attention. Preparedness and response to natural hazards have tended to focus on human casualties, structural damage, and property losses, and environmental impacts have only been reported when they have resulted in major incidents, such as the petroleum fires that followed the 1964 Niigata earthquake. This situation is changing, due to a number of factors, including better recording of HAZMAT incidents in natural hazards (e.g., 387 such incidents in the 1994 Northridge earthquake, not to mention the enormous environmental impacts of Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans), and more stringent standards for environmental liability. Reitherman was perhaps the first in the US to look at the problem of hazardous materials releases in earthquakes, in 1982, and he, Selvaduray and Perkins have developed databases and methods for the problem. The HAZUS® project reviewed the state-of-the-art as of 1992 and found three models as of that time. The model developed by Tierney et al. focused on the likelihood of gaseous releases, and its potential effect on surrounding populations. However, it was not found to be suitable for risk assessment
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
43
efforts by local jurisdiction personnel due to the level of detailed analysis required. The study by Ravindra (1992) was very similar to the Los Angeles County Fire Department methodology, and was really intended for seismic vulnerability analysis of individual facilities, requiring significant expert input. The HAZUS® model provides a listing and mapping of HAZMAT facilities vs. seismic intensity. More recently, Steinberg and Cruz have closely investigated the 1999 Marmara Earthquake (Turkey), where a number of hazmat releases occurred. 2.7.5 Socio-Economic Impacts and Business Interruption While estimates of casualties, cost of repair and other ‘direct damage’ measures come first to mind for most applications, the economic impact of an earthquake on a business, and the economic impact of a great earthquake on the overall regional economy, are important issues. Dacy and Kunreuther in 1969 and Mukerjee in 1971 were probably the first to examine the broader economic impacts of natural hazards, while Cochrane in1974 was the first to quantify the economic impacts of a large regional earthquake, in this case the ‘coming San Francisco earthquake’, for which he found about half the overall economic impact was ‘secondary’: “A reoccurrence of the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake in 1974 would likely cost the Bay area in excess of $13 billion, approximately one half of which would take the form of lost income due to a regional economic recession. The unemployment rolls would be swelled by as many as one quarter million. The probability of such large scale social disruption following an extreme geophysical event signals the need for a broadened perspective in planning for such potentialities, and the need to review the choice of adjustments to mitigate these effects. Concentration on mean annual damages or direct damage ensuing from disaster may not take into consideration the social benefits of measures pursued to affect damage reduction. The importance of these findings lies in the implications for public policy which may need some rethinking if the potential for large scale economic chaos is to be avoided.” (Cochrane, 1974)
The economic aspects received further attention in the 80s, as Rose and coworkers examined the economic costs of loss of infrastructure, and Ellison, Milliman and Roberts (1984) examined the regional economic effects of earthquakes and earthquake prediction. Another aspect of considering economic impacts was at the ‘micro-scale’, where FEMA funded development of methodologies for assessing the cost-benefit of seismic retrofit-
44
Charles Scawthorn
ting. Beginning in the mid-90s, Rose, Chang and co-workers for the HAZUS® project developed a well-founded model of the regional economic impacts of a large earthquake, which employs a computable general equilibrium model designed to rebalance a region's inter-industry trade flows based on discrepancies between sector supplies and demands. Modeling of economic impacts, like the other aspects of modeling discussed here, must be based on good data. A number of investigators have collected data from various earthquakes, but two efforts were particularly important: x Tierney and Dahlhamer (1998) performed surveys of disaster-related business impacts of the 1994 Northridge Earthquake (as well as 1993 Midwest floods), focusing on eight aspects related to determining business interruption: business characteristics, nature of physical damage, lifeline service interruption, business closure, business relocation, insurance and disaster-assistance programs, disaster preparedness, and losses. These studies contributed to understanding the particular vulnerabilities in natural disasters of small and mid-sized businesses. x A study of the Northridge Earthquake by Eguchi and co-workers at EQE International, Inc., and the Governor’s Office of Emergency Services was perhaps the most-thorough effort to collect data and compile a database of the effects of an earthquake. The data included the seismological and geotechnical aspects of the earthquake; the charac-teristics of the building stock exposed to strong motion; building damage data including ATC-20 safety evaluations and repair-cost estimates; coroner data on earthquake-related fatalities; relocation and injury data from cities, the Red Cross, and the Salvation Army; and insurance losses reported by the California Department of Insurance.
2.8 Asset Identification and Attributes The third ingredient for a seismic risk analysis, beyond the hazard and a vulnerability function conditioned on the hazard, is the identification of and attributes of the assets at risk. As noted earlier, over 100 years ago, detailed fire insurance maps were available for all major urban areas of the US – an underwriter literally had at his fingertips up to date information on the size, occupancy, materials of construction and protective features (for fire) for every building in a city. That was lost in the mid 20th Century. Steinbrugge and succeeding investigators trying to develop accurate informative loss estimates from the 70s until very recently have struggled with trying to determine what is out there?, and what are its attributes
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
45
relative to seismic vulnerability? (and, where is it?). For an individual structure, drawings will typically be available, but for a regional loss study, similar information on the ‘portfolio’ or ‘inventory’ is typically so widely dispersed as to be inaccessible. Tax assessor records have been a chimera – they are difficult to acquire, are different in every county, and in most counties don’t contain much reliable information on structural attributes. Selected counties’ assessor records (e.g., Los Angeles, San Francisco) have relatively useful amounts of structural information (although still with significant errors), but still require significant processing. Perhaps the only academic pursuing the problem of built inventory in the 70s and 80s was Barclay Jones, at Cornell University, who investigated relationships between population size and techniques for estimating size and characteristics (floor area and height) of building stocks in urban areas – case studies were cities in Colombia and Turkey as well as the boroughs of New York City. Jones et al. (1987) addressed losses from earthquakes, noting that estimating elements at risk had received less attention to date. A complete enumeration of the building stock of a moderate-sized metropolitan area in the United States, Wichita, Kansas, was compared to previous and less complete studies. The number and area of buildings disaggregated by use was given and replacement costs calculated. The spatial distribution of buildings by rings outward from the center was also determined. The techniques developed were shown to approximate existing building stock of a metropolitan area in greater detail than previous work, and regularities in the composition and distribution suggested that the techniques were generally applicable. In the early 80s, a study by Scawthorn and Gates (1983) of earthquake losses was one of the first to develop ‘proxy’ measures of many attributes, and in 1985 the ATC-13 study provided an excellent survey of practices to date, and guidance for filling in the gaps in data. The FEMA 224 study (FEMA, 1991) benefited from better information on infrastructure. Since that time, GIS has penetrated most municipalities, who are tending towards integrated databases of all facets of their operations. However, the detailed structural attributes desired by risk analysts is still lacking. The insurance industry, under the influence of the modeling companies, has improved its data enormously. Most recently, remote sensing and related techniques hold out some hope of providing automated data acquisition at the regional level. The one major advance has been the development of a national database of assets at risk, by the HAZUS® project. The specific inventory provided for the general building stock are (FEMA 2006):
46
Charles Scawthorn
x Square footage by occupancy. Estimated floor area by specific occupancy (e.g., COM1). x Full Replacement Value by occupancy. Estimated replacement values by specific occupancy (e.g., RES1). x Building Count by occupancy. Estimated building count by specific occupancy (e.g., IND1). x General Occupancy Mapping. A general mapping of the inventory data from the specific occupancy to general building type (e.g., wood). x Demographics. Housing and population statistics for the study region. These data were compiled from various sources (2000 Census of Population and Housing, U.S. Census Bureau 2002: Summary Tape File 1B Extract; 2000 Census of Population and Housing, U.S. Census Bureau 2002: Summary Tape File 3; Dun & Bradstreet, Business Population Report aggregated by Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) and Census Block, 2002; Department of Energy, Housing Characteristics 1993 and related 1995 and 1997 data). This data is then mapped to Model Building Types using a pro ration scheme. While proxy-based and no substitute for detailed local information, the resulting inventory data appears reasonably correct in the mean, is consistent across a region, in fact nationally, and is freely and readily available on the HAZUS® CDs. The HAZUS® database is an enormous advance, at least for a first approximate analysis (useful for determining the overall magnitude and significant of the earthquake risk, and for planning more detailed studies), which is the primary purpose of HAZUS®. Outside the U.S., the issue of developing a portfolio generally still remains although in selected regions excellent databases have been developed. A surprising number of municipalities in developing economies tend to have relatively sophisticated GIS systems. Some regions (e.g., parts of Japan) tend to have better building data (relative to the U.S.). The problem can be tackled head-on – an impressive recent effort was Istanbul, where over one summer, school teachers (who were on summer vacation) were hired, trained and then surveyed every building in the City, to compile a database for earthquake loss estimation purposes (M. Erdik, personal communication). This data was all loaded into an existing high-quality municipal GIS system. A recent contribution to the problem of asset attributes has been the World Encyclopedia of Housing, developed by a global group lead by EERI members and sponsored by the IAEE. The WHE contains a wealth of information on the construction and seismic resistive aspects of housing and other building types around the world, including information on seismic strengthening of various building types specific to the region.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
47
2.9 Risk Analysis Methods The fourth aspect of a seismic risk analysis, beyond the hazard, vulnerability and asset attributes, is the mathematical and theoretical analysis methods by which the three elements are combined to more or less rigorously and accurately estimate the risk. Willis in 1923 compiled some loss ratios but Freeman (1932) was probably the first to systematically compile damage data and develop economic loss ratios for a wide variety of building types (reading the literature, it would appear that insurance underwriters had compiled and used loss ratios prior to 1932, but Freeman would have been very familiar with such work, and clearly felt the information he offered in his book was badly needed). The concept of Probable Maximum Loss (PML, also variously referred to as Maximum Probable Loss, and other variations) has long been used in the fire insurance business, probably since the 19th century. PML is actually one of three ‘levels’ for consideration while underwriting for fire: Probable Loss, PML, and Maximum Foreseeable Loss (MFL). As of 2006, the Insurance Services Office defines PML for fire as: “PML (Probable Maximum Loss) is an estimate of the largest loss that a building or a business in the building is likely to suffer – considering the existing mitigation features – because of a single fire. The PML is the maximum expected loss, expressed as a percentage of the building’s value, when critical protection systems are functioning as expected. The Maximum Foreseeable Loss (MFL) is an estimate of the largest fire loss likely to occur if a key loss-reduction system fails. The PML and MFL percentages depend on many factors, including: construction of building combustibility of contents susceptibility of contents (likelihood of damage from fire, smoke, and water) private and public fire protection For example, in a fire-resistive building with a fire-division wall between each occupant, chances are the entire building wouldn't burn if a fire broke out. But in a building without adequate protection features, a single occurrence might involve a significant loss, and the probability is high that both the building and its occupants would experience extensive damage in the same occurrence. And occupants such as flower and pet shops can experience severe
48
Charles Scawthorn losses even in small, quickly extinguished fires”. (Insurance Services Office, 2006)
Guy Carpenter, the leading reinsurance broker offers: “MFL (Maximum Forseeable Loss) The anticipated maximum property fire loss that could result, given unusual or the worst circumstances with respect to the nonfunctioning of protective features (firewalls, sprinklers, a responsive fire department … as opposed to PML (Probable Maximum Loss), which would be a similar valuation but under the assumption that such protective features function normally.” (Strain 1997)
Other authorities defining PML can be cited – today, it is still a widely used term in the insurance and related industries, for fire. Regarding earthquake, on the other hand, Freeman (1932) did not use the term, and the concept of PML was long recognized as problematic. McGuiness (1969) observed: The term “PML” or “probable maximum loss” is one of the most widely used terms in property insurance underwriting. But it represents one of the least clear concepts in all insurance. This fact is reflected by the results of a four-year study that involved collecting the personal and company definitions of PML from over one hundred underwriters and underwriting executives. No two of their definitions fully agree.
However, despite problems for using the term in regard to earthquake, it was used by McClure in 1969, probably due to the influence of Steinbrugge, who worked in the insurance industry. In the aftermath of the San Fernando earthquake in 1971, concern about the exposure of the insurance industry to earthquakes greatly increased, leading the California Insurance Department to issue Rule 226, which requires all licensed insurers to report each year their insured exposures for earthquake shake damage on residential and commercial structures in California. To assist insurers in complying with Rule 226, the California Insurance Department developed a simple but useful method for insurers to estimate their probable maximum loss (PML). While it was recognized by the Department that definitions of PML varied widely within the industry, the methodology developed by the California Department of Insurance and its consultant K.V. Steinbrugge has been used by the State of California since about 1980 to monitor insurance industry exposure. In that methodology: x Building Class PML (i.e., for an individual building of a specific class, such as wood frame, see Tables 32.3 and 32.4) is defined as the expec-
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
49
ted maximum percentage of monetary loss which will not be exceeded for nine out of ten buildings, where the building is located on firm alluvial ground, subjected only to the vibratory motion from the maximum probable earthquake (i.e., not astride a fault or in a resulting landslide). x Aggregate PML is the sum of all of the PML values in a PML zone, plus factored PML values for buildings located outside of the PML zone but still within the earthquake underwriting zone. A factored PML is a reduced PML value based on reduced intensity (i.e., damage) with increasing distance away from the causative fault. Using this methodology, insurance companies in California are required to report their aggregrate PML each year to the California Department of Insurance. This is of interest to the department, as it wishes to assure adequate company surplus to assure payment of claims in the event of a large earthquake. Almost from the same time, however, others have all strongly discouraged use of the term, with ASTM (1999) stating: “The long used notion of “probable maximum loss” (PML) has become, for many, a catch phrase to encapsulate all earthquake issues into a simple number that can be used to qualify or disqualify a potential commitment. Unfortunately, there has been no previous industry or professional consensus on what PML means or how it is computed … use of the term Probable Maximum Loss (PML) is not encouraged for future use”.
and have proposed alternative measures. In the 1970s the SDDA project, discussed above, was developing a fully probabilistic methodology for integrating vulnerability over hazard, accounting for uncertainty. This methodology, in varying forms, is the standard model used today, although all forms don’t necessarily derive directly from the SDDA project – that is, the methodology was developed concurrently by others. For example, Oliveira considered the seismic risk of a site and a metropolitan area and determined the final probability distribution of the maximum response of a single-degree-of-freedom (SDOF) system which, when related to damage through a damage ratio function (characterized by random variables yield and collapse) and integrated over the region gave the global loss.
50
Charles Scawthorn
2.10 Assessment Having traced the history of seismic risk analysis, the next step would be to trace the corresponding development of assessment of the analytical results – that is, the norms and criteria by which the analytical results are assessed. However, space does not permit an adequate discussion of this aspect, so the following thoughts will simply be noted. First, seismic risk assessment would appear to be a natural development of a society less interested in risk-taking, and more interested in assuring safety. This would appear to be a development paralleled in many fields, such as consumer safety, environmentalism, etc, as briefly discussed above. Whether this is a long-term trend, or a temporary (but influential) movement à la the Progressive Era (ca. 1900–1917), remains to be seen. Second, generally speaking, there would not appear to be any explicit specific norms or standards for seismic risk assessment, in California or, in this writer’s experience, anywhere else, with the probable exception of California standards for public K-12 schools, and hospitals. A study of various laws and programs would provide inferences as to patterns of norms and standards for seismic safety. Examples of items for study would include: x Seismic provisions in the 1927 UBC and subsequent building codes (which were not mandated in the UBC until 1960, and not until later in other model codes). x 1933 Field and Riley Acts (school standards strict and effective; building standards lax and ineffective). x 1959 Blue Book (tolerates widespread structural damage). x 60s requirement for seismic safety elements in California. x 1972: Alquist Priolo Act, requiring Special Studies in fault zones. x 1986: SB 547 (section 8875 of the California Code, setting ‘soft’ standards for URM mitigation, but ultimately generally effective. x 1983: California Hospital Seismic Safety Act, SB 1953, and its varied path and effectiveness. x Caltrans bridge seismic retrofit program – started following 1971 San Fernando earthquake, but it took another two earthquakes to finally complete it (generally speaking). x Bay Bridge – the delays in retrofitting and replacing these spans deserve a careful study. x Record of the Insurance Industry in California (and elsewhere) – 1983 Coalinga earthquake and ‘concurrent causation’.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
51
– 1994 Northridge earthquake and the effective industry withdrawal from market due to the requirement for a mandatory offer of earthquake insurance. – The first attempt at a California state earthquake program under Commissioner Garamendi, and its failure. – The second and successful attempt under Commissioner Quackenbush, and the establishment of the California Earth-quake Authority.
Fig. 2.13. Vision 2000 Performance Levels (reprinted with permission from Structural Engineers Association of California 1995)
Perhaps the best attempt by the profession to codify an acceptable standard for seismic performance was the Vision 2000 report by the Structural Engineers Association of California (1995), in which several performance levels were defined, Fig. 2.13. The Performance-based earthquake engineering tools needed for implementation of Vision 2000 are however still emerging, and the real impact of Vision 2000 still remains to be seen. Third, there don’t appear to be any explicit frameworks for assessing seismic risk. Various decision-making frameworks are employed, including benefit cost analysis, life cycle cost analysis, internal rate of return, and least regret. These are all relatively fixed frameworks, and other paradigms are probably more appropriate. Fourth, seismic risk assessment cannot be seen in a vacuum – there are other developments which directly influence seismic risk assessment – to name a few: x NRC – the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission has been deeply influential in the development of seismic risk methods and, by its example, in influencing the assessment of the results of those methods in non-nuclear arenas. The nuclear field is currently on the verge of an apparent renaissance – what effects might that have?
52
Charles Scawthorn
x Basel II requires reliability standards for financial institutions, including for natural hazards. The impacts of those requirements or their example on other institutions has not been felt, but may occur in the future. x Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 requires considerable transparency in corporate management. This transparency should extend to manage-ment of natural hazards, but doesn’t seem to have had an impact yet. Will it? x Deregulation – the deregulation of the telephone, airlines and electric power industries (with the catastrophic experience in California and with Enron) raises issues as to their robustness for large natural hazards. How should that be assessed? x Gramm-Leach-Bliley Financial Services Modernization Act of 1999 repealed Glass Steagall, so that banks, insurance companies and securities firms can cooperate and compete. Does this potential concentration of capital imply greater vulnerability? including to natural hazards? Might standards emerging from these new conditions offer insights for seismic risk assessment and decision-making? Similar questions arise when consumer safety, product liability and trans-portation safety norms and standards are considered. That such seemingly distant examples might have influences in seismic risk assessment is not implausible. Conversely, consider examples much closer to home: x In the earthquake strong motion field, there is a long history of institutional cooperation and archiving of data. COSMOS, NGDC, and the International Seismological Center are just three of the most prominent examples. Yet, complementing the hazard arena, there is no cooperation or archiving of vulnerability data. Why not? The root cause probably lies in an identified and vital earth sciences agency (the USGS) but comparable national engineering agency. Dishearteningly, in this regard, EERI recently had its reconnaissance funding (the Learning from Earthquakes program) drastically cut. x In the 1960s the National Flood Insurance Program emerged, as a model coordinated approach to flood mitigation. Communities are provided insurance, but levees and other flood protection measures are required. About the same time, the California Dept. of Insurance began monitoring insurance company exposure via its Probable Maximum Loss (PML) reporting requirements. Recently, the California Dept. of Insurance seems to have relaxed its vigilance. Yet, the Florida Hurricane Commission, as compared with California, strictly monitors its insurance companies, and requires full confidential disclosure of all
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
53
insurance modeling software employed in the state. These disparities need examination. x Hurricane Katrina is an object lesson in what not to do. The community had been warned many times, with articles about the risk in scientific and popular magazines years and months prior to the disaster. What does this tell us about people’s perceptions and attitudes toward natural hazards? About the value of risk assessments? About how to plan for recovery and reconstruction, should San Francisco or Los Angeles be devastated by an earthquake?
2.11 Current Status As of this writing (June, 2006), the status of seismic risk assessment is that the US remains the center of innovation and almost the center of application, although that is rapidly changing. The global insurance industry is served basically by the three modeling firms, all of which are based in the US, with some significant contribution from London. These three firms however are fiercely competitive and closely guard their technology, so that while innovation occurs it is closely held and the merit is difficult to judge. This is partially compensated by rating agencies such as Moodys and Standard & Poor’s requiring confidential disclosure from the modeling firms, and the Florida Hurricane Commission’s detailed inquiries into the hurricane models. A major development in the US has been HAZUS®, which has funded an extensive collation of technology, so that methods for earthquake, hurricane and flood loss estimation are clearly laid out. However, while the software is distributed free of charge, the source code is closed, so that it is regarded as something of a ‘black box’, and has had limited acceptance. As a result, while to some extent serving risk-based mitigation, HAZUS® has also tended to stifle innovation, in that potential supporters of new risk-based software question why they should compete with ‘free’ software; while at the same time the inaccessibility of the source code precludes its free and open enhancement. This is a typical defect of any attempt to have an ‘authorized’ version (viz. parallels in IBM-Apple, and Windows-Linux). In contrast, probably the most successful series of risk models anywhere has been the flood frequency and loss estimation software developed by the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), at the Hydrologic Engineering Center (HEC). HEC-RAS and similar programs have succeeded by being free, with source code available to many users. Therefore, independent
54
Charles Scawthorn
vetting has occurred. It helped that flood modeling was required by the NFIP, and that USACE had something of a monopoly on this, in the US. This situation is now changing however, with DHI’s Mike series of software making significant inroads in the US, based on more advanced dynamic flood modeling, versus the ‘static’ modeling in the HEC software. Outside of the US, some national authorities have embraced risk-based modeling and the UN’s ISDR, the World Bank and other institutions are strongly encouraging a risk-based approach to disaster risk management. An interesting observation is the place of Japan in this development. Arguably, Japan should be the leader in earthquake engineering worldwide, due to the size of its earthquake risk and its technological capabilities. From 1880 to 1930 it was the leader, which Freeman and Martel very clearly observed in the late 20s, leading Freeman to push for the strong motion program in California, and to invite Suyehiro to lecture at Berkeley, Stanford, California Institute of Technology and MIT. From that moment, the US surpassed Japan, developing the first strong motion program, the magnitude scale, the magnitude frequency relation, response spectra and other innovations. Admittedly, many of these innovations were developed independently in Japan about the same time, but their visibility and application were much lower. Following World War 2, Kawasumi published his probabilistic hazard map of Japan (1951), about two decades ahead of its time. But, while many innovations still continued in Japan, Kawasumi’s map seems to have been the end of probabilistic and risk thinking in Japan. When this writer was at Kyoto University in the late 70s, some work was being done in Japan on hazard analysis, but risk analysis was almost unknown. As the WASH-1400 report introduced probabilistic analysis to engineers in general, and Wiggins, Blume, Whitman and then Yanev and colleagues, introduced seismic risk management in the US in the 70s and 80s, this writer’s observations and recollections for the 70s to 90s is that the field was totally ignored in Japan. Seismic design was very advanced in Japan, but it was deterministic in nature, and systems or enterprise risk management approaches just did not exist, despite their burgeoning development in the US. It was only following the 1995 Kobe earthquake and the demonstrated seismic vulnerability of even ‘modern’ Japanese construction, that interest in risk management in Japan emerged. The first seismic retrofit of a high-rise building in Japan was designed by a US consulting firm, in 1997.
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
55
2.12 Concluding Remarks The rational analysis and mitigation of risk due to natural and other hazards is founded on a large body of work developed over the last 150 years. If one were asked to list some contributions essential to the development of seismic risk assessment, the list might be something like: 1. Mallet – his investigations and founding of seismology in the UK about 1850. 2. Milne – his arrival in Japan in 1880 and development of seismology and training of seismologists in Japan, development of the first practical seismograph, and the founding of the Seismological Society of Japan. 3. Reid’s Elastic Rebound Theory (1910) and Wegener’s theory of continental drift (1913); however, Wegener’s ideas were rejected at the time, and not accepted until the 1960s with the theory of plate tectonics. 4. Freeman – in the few short years of about 1927 to 1932, his strong encouragement of earthquake engineering in the USA, role in founding the US strong motion program, and book laying out building damage experience and reduction of that experience to loss ratios – and Neumann and colleagues for translating Freeman’s ideas into actual deployed instruments in time for the 1933 Long Beach earthquake. 5. Caltech – does credit go to Millikan for gathering Wood, Richter, Martel, Gutenberg, Benioff, Housner and Hudson? or do they get the credit for development of the – Magnitude scale (Richter 1935) – magnitude-frequency relation, log N = a – b M (Gutenberg and Richter 1941) – response spectra (Biot 1940; Housner 1941). 6. Cornell’s 1968 BSSA paper on engineering seismic risk analysis. Items 1–6 are necessary and sufficient for estimation of seismic hazard. Freeman laid the basis for a rational approach to seismic risk assessment, including vulnerability functions. The proper development of vulnerability functions however still required: 7. The Finite Element Method (Argyris, Turner, Clough et al., 40s to 60s), and development of associated structural analysis software (e.g., Wilson, 60s to now).
56
Charles Scawthorn
8. Karl Steinbrugge and the group around him, Algermissen, McClure, Lagorio and others, for focusing on the goal of assessing (and reducing) the risk (60s to 80s). 9. The SDDA project at MIT (1973–78, Whitman, Cornell, Vanmarcke, Veneziano et al.), for a consistent approach to the entire problem, and 10. ATC-13 (1985) for developing a consistent open set of vulnerability functions (Rojahn, Sharpe, Kiremidjian et al.). These and selected other developments are shown in Fig. 2.14, overlaid on a background of the global growth in natural hazards loss estimation. While much more remains to be done, recent developments in information technology permit leveraging of this body of knowledge in ways not previously possible. Key to enhanced seismic risk mitigation is dissemination of the capability to analyze risk, in an open and transparent manner, and better doctrine on using the results.
Fig. 2.14. (This figure also appears in the color insert) General developmental trend of seismic risk assessment 1950–2000, overlaid on natural hazard losses and also showing selected related trends (background: Munich Re)
2.13 Acknowledgments The support of the Mid-America Earthquake Center in inviting this paper is gratefully acknowledged. Too many persons to acknowledge here have educated me over the years on the various topics discussed above – while
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
57
not named, all their efforts have been highly appreciated. The formal reviews of this paper by Profs. Robert Whitman (MIT), Amr Elnashai (U. Illinois) and Dennis Mileti (U. Colorado) were most helpful and much appreciated, as was their kindness. Dr. Keith Porter (Caltech) is thanked for his reading of an early draft and many helpful comments. I leaned heavily on several papers for historical information, especially Ben-Menaheim (1995), various writings of Steve Tobriner (U. California at Berkeley) and Bob Reitherman (CUREE Exec. Director), the Oral Histories published by EERI, and Lee’s two volume International Handbook of Earthquake & Engineering Seismology (esp. the Japan national report, App. 79_33).
References Gov. Wilson puts cost of earthquake in Los Angeles as high as $30 billion. (1994, 21 January 1994). Wall Street Journal, p 3 Agnew DC (2002) History of seismology. In: Lee HK, Kanamori H, Jennings PC, Kisslinger C (eds.), International handbook of earthquake and engineering seismology. Academic Press, New York, pp 3–12 Algermissen ST (1969) Seismic risk studies in the United States. In: Proceedings of the Fourth World Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Santiago de Chile, pp A1: 14–27 Algermissen ST, Hopper M, Campbell K, Rinehart WA, Perkins D, Steinbrugge KV, Lagorlo HJ, Moran DF, Cluff LS, Degenkolb HJ, Duke CM, Gates GO, Jacobson NN, Olson RA, Allan CR (1973) A study of earthquake losses in the Los Angeles, California area. The Federal Disaster Assistance Administration, Washington, DC Algermissen ST, Perkins DM (1976) A probabilistic estimate of maximum acceleration in rock in the contiguous United States (Open-File Report 76–416). USGS Algermissen ST, Riehart W, Dewey J, Steinbrugge KV, Lagorio HJ, Degenkolb HJ, L SC, McClure FE, Scott S, Gordon RF (1972) A study of earthquake losses in the San Francisco Bay area: Data and analysis. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), Washington, DC American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) (1952) Lateral forces of earthquake and wind Applied Technology Council (1978, amended 1982) Tentative provisions for the development of seismic regulations for buildings (ATC-3-06). Applied Technology Council, Washington, DC Applied Technology Council (1985). Earthquake damage evaluation data for California (ATC-13) Redwood City, CA ASTM (1999) ASTM E2026 Standard guide for the estimation of building damageability in earthquakes. ASTM International
58
Charles Scawthorn
Beavers J (2002). A review of seismic hazard description in us design codes and procedures. Progress in Structural Engineering and Materials 4:46–63 Ben-Menahem A (1995) Review, a concise history of mainstream seismology, origins, legacy, and perspectives. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 85:1202–1225 Bernstein PL (1998) Against the gods: The remarkable story of risk. Wiley, New York Biot MA (1933) Theory of elastic systems under transient loading with an application to earthquake proof buildings. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 19:262–268 Biot MA (1940) A mechanical analyzer for the prediction of earthquake stresses. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 31:151–171 Blume JA (1965) Earthquake ground motion and engineering procedures for important installations near active faults. In: Proceedings of the Proceedings of the Third World Conference on Earthquake Engineering. New Zealand, p 53 Blume JA, Newmark NM, Cornell CA (1961). Design of multistory reinforced concrete buildings for earthquake motions. Portlant Cement Association, Chicago Carson R (1962) Silent spring. Houghton Mifflin, Boston Chen WF, Scawthorn C (2003) Earthquake engineering handbook. CRC Press, Boca Raton Chick A (1934) Discussion of fundamental factors involved in underwriting of earthquake insurance. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 24:385–397 Coats RR (1962) Magma type and crustal structure in the aleutian arc. The crust of the Pacific Basin: Am Geophys Union Geophys Mon 6:92–109 Cochrane H (1974) Predicting the economic impact of earthquakes. In: Cochrane HC, et al. (eds.), Natural hazards research paper no. 25, Social science perspectives on the coming San Francisco earthquake. University of Colorado, NHRAIC, Boulder, Colorado Cornell CA (1968) Engineering seismic risk analysis. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 58:1583–1606 Dacy D, Kunreuther H (1969) The economics of natural disasters. The Free Press (Macmillan), New York Donovan NC (1973) A statistical evaluation of strong motion data: Including the February 9, 1971 San Fernando earthquake. Dames & Moore, Durkin ME, Thiel CC (1992) Improving measures to reduce earthquake casualties. Earthquake Spectra 8:95–113 EERI. (1994) Henry J. Degenkolb, interviewed by Stanley Scott. Connections, The EERI Oral History Series, from http://www.eeri.org/cds_publications/oral_histories/0-943198-42-9_Degenkolb.pdf EERI (2005) Scenario for a magnitude 6.7 earthquake on the Seattle fault. Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, Oakland CA EERI (Earthquake Engineering Research Institute). (2004) World housing encyclopedia. (available electronically at http://www.world-housing.net/index.asp)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
59
Eguchi RT, Goltz JD, Seligson HA, Flores PJ, Blais NC, Heaton TH, Bortugno E (1997) Real-time loss estimation as an emergency response decision support system: The early post-earthquake damage assessment tool (EPEDAT). Earthquake Spectra 13:815–832 Ellison R, Milliman J, Roberts R (1984) Measuring the regional economic effects of earthquakes and earthquake predictions. Journal of Regional Science 24:559–579 FEMA (1988) Earthquake Damaged Buildings: An Overview of Heavy Debris and Victim Extrication, prepared by C. Scawthorn for the Applied Technology Council under sub-contract to the Federal Emergency Management Agency (ATC 21-2; FEMA 158), Washington. FEMA (1991) Seismic vulnerability and impact of disruption of lifelines in the conterminous United States, prepared by C. Scawthorn and M. Khater for the Applied Technology Council (ATC-25). Federal Emergency Management Agency, Washington, DC FEMA (2006) Multi-hazard loss estimation methodology, earthquake model, HAZUS®MH MR2, technical manual, developed by Department of Homeland Security, Federal Emergency Management Agency, Mitigation Division. National Institute of Building Sciences, Washington, DC Freeman JR (1930) Engineering data needed on earthquake motion for use in the design of earthquake-resisting structures. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 20:67–87 Freeman JR (1932) Earthquake damage and earthquake insurance. McGraw-Hill, New York Friend I, Blume ME (1975) The demand for risky assets. American Economic Review 65:900-922 Gallagher RB (1956) Risk management: A new phase of cost control. Harvard Business Review GSHAP (1998) Global seismic hazard assessment program, closing report to the IDNDR/STC, 1992 – 1998 Gutenberg B, Richter CF (1941) Seismicity of the earth (Vol. 34). Geological Society of America, New York Gutenberg B, Richter CF (1942) Earthquake magnitude, intensity, energy, and acceleration. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 32:163 Gzovsky MV (1962) Tectonics and earthquake forecasting. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 52:485–505 Hanks TC, Kanamori H (1979) A moment magnitude scale. Journal of Geophysical Research 84:2348–2350 Hess HH (1962) History of ocean basins. Petrologic Studies: A 599–620 Housner G (1952) Spectrum intensities of strong motion earthquakes. In: Proceedings of the Proceedings of a Symposium on Earthquakes and Blast Effects on Structures. Los Angeles, pp 21–36 Housner GW (1941) Calculating the response of an oscillator to arbitrary ground motion. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 31:143-149 Housner GW (1952) Intensity of ground motion during strong earthquakes, second technical report under office of naval research contract N6ONR-244, Task
60
Charles Scawthorn
Order 25, Project Designation NR - 081 – 095. Earthquake Research Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena Housner GW (1958) The mechanism of sandblows. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 48:155–161 Housner GW (1984) An historical view of earthquake engineering. In: Proceedings of the 8th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering. San Francisco, pp 25–38 Insurance Services Office. (2006) Definition of probable maximum loss. from http://www.iso.com/products/2400/prod2453.html Isacks BL, Oliver J, Sykes LR (1968) Seismology and the new global tectonics. Journal of Geophysical Research 73:5855–5899 Ishimoto M, Iida K (1939). Observations of earthquakes registered with the microseismograph constructed recently. Bulletin of the Earthquake Research Institute of the University of Tokyo 17:443–478 Jacobs J (1961) The death and life of great American cities. Random House, New York Jones BG, Manson DM, Hotchkiss CM, Savonis MJ (1987) Determination of building stocks for urban vulnerability analysis and earthquake loss estimation. Cornell Institute for Social and Economic Research, Program in Urban and Regional Studies, Ithaca Jones NP, Noji EK, Krimgold F, Smith GS (eds) (1989). Proceedings of the international workshop on earthquake injury epidemiology for mitigation and response. Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore Kashima T (2000) Strong earthquake motion observation in Japan. Building Research Institute, Tsukuba, Japan Kawasumi H (1951) Measures of earthquake danger and expectancy of maximum intensity throughout Japan as inferred from the seismic activity in historical times. Bulletin of the Earthquake Research Institute 29:471–482 Knight FH (1921) Risk, uncertainty and profit. University of Chicago Press, Chicago Kornfield L, Rojahn C, Scawthorn C (2006) Estimated losses from scenario earthquakes affecting San Francisco: CAPSS – part 2. In: Proceedings of the 8th US National Conference on Earthquake Engineering. San Francisco Law DG (1997) Chapter 6.0 seismic risk models, part 4: Computer models of probable maximum loss. In: Brun SE, Etkin D, Law DG, Wallace L, White R (eds.), Coping with natural hazards in Canada: Scientific, government and insurance industry perspectives, a study written for the round table on environmental risk, natural hazards and the insurance industry. Environmental Adaptation Research Group, Environment Canada and Institute for Environmental Studies, University of Toronto, Toronto Le Pichon X (1968) Sea-floor spreading and continental drift. Journal of Geophysical Research 73:661–697 Le Pichon X, Heirtzler JR (1968). Magnetic anomalies in the indian ocean and sea-floor spreading continents. Journal of Geophysical Research 73:2101 Lee HK, Kanamori H, Jennings PC, Kisslinger C (eds) (2002). International handbook of earthquake and engineering seismology. Academic Press, New York
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
61
Mallet R (1862) Neapolitan earthquake of 1857. The first principles of observational seismology. Chapman and Hall, London Mallet, R and Mallet, JW (1858). The Earthquake Catalogue of the British Association, with the Discussion, Curves, and Maps, Etc. (Including Seismographic Map of the World, Dated 1857), Taylor and Francis, London. Markowitz H (1952) Portfolio selection. The Journal of Finance 7:77–91 Martel RR (1936) A report on earthquake damage to Type III buildings (Special Publication No. 201). U.S. Department of Commerce Coast and Geodetic Survey, Washington, DC McGuinness JS (1969) Is “Probable Maximum Loss” (PML) a useful concept? In: Proceedings of the Proceedings of the Casualty Actuarial Society, pp. 31–39 McGuire RK (1974) Seismic structural response risk analysis incorporating peak response regressions on earthquake magnitude and distance (Pub. R74-51). MIT, Cambridge, MA McGuire RK (1976) Fortran computer program for seismic risk analysis (USGS Series Open-File Report Number 76-6) McGuire RK (1978) FRISK-computer program for seismic risk analysis using faults as earthquake sources, (U.S.G.S. Open-File Report, 78–1107) Milne J (1888) The movement produced in certain buildings by earthquakes. Transactions of the Seismological Society of Japan 12:67–75 Milne J (1898) Seismology. Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner and Co, London Milne J, Burton WK (1892) The Great Japan Earthquake of 1891. Lane, Crawford & Co, Yokohama Milne WG, Davenport AG (1969) Distribution of earthquake risk in Canada. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 59:729 Mogami T, Kubo K (1953) The behavior of soil during vibration. In: Proceedings of the Third International Conference of Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering, pp 152–155 Morgan WJ (1968) Rises, trenches, great faults, and crustal blocks. Journal of Geophysical Research Morgenstern O, Von Neumann J (1953) Theory of games and economic behavior. J. Wiley and Sons, New York Mukerjee T (1971) Economic analysis of natural hazards: A preliminary study of adjustments to earthquakes and their costs, working paper 17. Natural Hazards Center, University of Colorado, Boulder Muto K, Bailey RW, Mitchell KJ (1963) Special requirements for the design of nuclear power stations to withstand earthquakes. Proceedings of Institutional Mechanical Engineering 117:155–203 Nader R. (1965) Unsafe at any speed. New York: Knightsbridge Publishing Co. National Academies Press (1999) The impacts of natural disasters: A framework for loss estimation. National Academies Press, Washington, DC Newmark NM (1967) Design criteria for nuclear reactors subjected to earthquake hazards. Urbana, IL Nigg JM, Eisner RK. (1997) Earthquake response: Intergovernmental structure and policy innovation (keynote paper). Paper presented at the 5th U.S.-Japan Workshop on Urban Earthquake Hazard Reduction, Pasadena
62
Charles Scawthorn
O'Rourke, MJ and Liu X (1999) Response of Buried Pipelines Subject to Earthquake Effects, Monograph, Multidisciplinary Center for Earthquake Engineering Research, State University of New York, Buffalo Packard V (1957) The hidden persuaders. Penguin, London Petak WJ, Atkisson AA (1982) Natural hazard risk assessment and public policy. Springer-Verlag, New York Press NA (1997) Review of recommendations for probabilistic seismic hazard analysis: Guidance on uncertainty and use of experts. National Academy Press, Washington, DC Rasmussen NC (1975) Reactor safety study: An assessment of accident risks in us commercial nuclear power plants. National Technical Information Service Ravindra M (1992) Seismic assessment of chemical facilities under California risk management and prevention program. In: Proceedings of the Proceedings, International Conference on Hazard Identification and Risk Analysis, Human Factors and Human Reliability in Process Safety Reid HF (1910) Elastic rebound theory. Bulletin of the Department of Geological Sciences, University of California 6:92–120 Reitherman RK (1982) Earthquake-caused hazardous materials releases. In: Proceedings of the Hazardous Materials Spills Conference. Milwaukee, WI Richter CF (1935) An instrumental earthquake magnitude scale. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 25:1–32 Roberts EB, Ulrich FP (1951) Seismological activities of the U.S. Coast and geodetic survey in 1949. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 41:205–220 Scawthorn C, Gates WE (1983) Estimation of earthquake losses in Los Angeles: Damage scenarios under varying earthquake research effort. Dames & Moore, Sponsored by U.S. Geological Survey Contract No. 14-08-000119822, San Francisco Scawthorn C, Yamada Y, Iemura H (1982) A model for urban post-earthquake fire hazard. Disaster: The International Journal of Disaster Studies and Practice (London) 5:125–132 Schnabel P, Seed B (1973) Accelerations in rock for earthquakes in the western united states. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 63:501 Schneider PJ, Schauer BA (2006) HAZUS® – its development and its future. Natural Hazards Review Special Issue: Multihazards Loss Estimation and HAZUS® edited by C Scawthorn, PJ Schneider, and BA Schauer 7: 40–45 Scholl RE (1974) Statistical analysis of low-rise building damage caused by the San Fernando earthquake. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 64:1–23 Seismology Committee SEAoC (1959) Recommended lateral force requirements and commentary. Structural Engineers Association of California, Sacramento Spangle WE (1987) Pre-earthquake planning for post-earthquake rebuilding (pepper). Southern California Earthquake Preparedness Project, Los Angeles, California
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
63
Steinbrugge KV (1968) Earthquake hazard in the San Francisco Bay area: A continuing problem in public policy. University of California Institute of Governmental Studies, Berkeley Steinbrugge KV (1982) Earthquakes, volcanoes, and tsunamis: An anatomy of hazards. Skandia America Group, New York Steinbrugge KV, Moran DF (1954). An engineering study of the southern California earthquake of July 21, 1952 and its aftershocks. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 44:201–462 Stepp JC (1972) Analysis of completeness of the earthquake sample in the Puget Sound area and its effect on statistical estimates of earthquake hazard. In: Proceedings of the First Microzonation Conference, Seattle, WA, pp 897–909 Strain RW (1997) Reinsurance. Strain Publishing, Inc., Athens, TX Structural Engineers Association of California (SEAOC) (1995). Performancebased seismic engineering of buildings. Vision 2000 report (OC #95-9) Sykes LR (1971) Aftershock zones of great earthquakes, seismicity gaps and prediction. Journal of Geophysical Research 76:8021–8041 Tierney KJ (1997) Impacts of recent disasters on businesses: The 1993 midwest floods and the 1994 Northridge earthquake. In: Jones BG (ed), Economic consequences of earthquakes: Preparing for the unexpected, NCEER SP-0001. Multidisciplinary Center for Earthquake Engineering Research, Buffalo, NY, pp 189–222 Tierney K, Dahlhamer, JM (1998) Business disruption, preparedness and recovery: Lessons from the Northridge earthquake. In: Proceedings of the NEHRP Conference and Workshop on Research on the Northridge, California Earthquake of January 17, 1994, pp IV-171 – IV-178 U.S. Census Bureau (2002) 2000 census of population and housing. Retrieved from http://www.census.gov/prod/cen2000/index.html. Wadati K (1933) On the travel time of earthquake waves. Geophysical Magazine 7:101–111 Wegener K (1913) Die seism registrierangen am samo-observatorium etc. Nachr Koniglichen Akad Wiss Gottingen, Math-Phys 3 Weigel RL (ed) (1966). Earthquake engineering. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ Willis B (1923) Earthquake risk in California. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 13:89–99 Willis B (1923) A fault map of California. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 13:1–12 Wilson JT (1965) A new class of faults and their bearing on continental drift. Nature 207:343–347 Wood HO, Neumann F (1931). Modified Mercalli Intensity scale of 1931. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 21:277–283 Yanev PI (1975) Peace of mind in earthquake country. Chronicle Books, San Francisco
64
Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.2. Chronology of Seismic Risk Assessment
Appendix 1. Chronology of Seismic Risk Assessment
Table 2.2. (continued)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
65
Table 2.2. (continued)
66 Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.2. (continued)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
67
Table 2.2. (continued)
68 Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.2. (continued)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
69
Table 2.2. (continued)
70 Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.2. (continued)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
71
Table 2.2. (continued)
72 Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.2. (continued)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
73
Table 2.2. (continued)
74 Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.2. (continued)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
75
Table 2.2. (continued)
76 Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.2. (continued)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
77
78
Charles Scawthorn
Appendix 2. Reports from MIT SDDA (Seismic Design Decision Analysis) Project
Ackroyd MA, Biggs JM (1974) The formulation and experimental verification of mathematical models for predicting dynamic response of multistory buildings.1 Cornell CA, Merz Cornell HA (1974) A seismic risk analysis of Boston. MIT-CE R74-2 1 Whitman RV (1973) Damage probability matrices for prototype buildings. MITCE R74-8 1 De Neufville R (1975) 1939- How do we evaluate and choose between alternative codes for design and performance? 1,2 Heger FJ, Luft RW (1977) Structural evaluation of existing buildings in Massachusetts for seismic resistance MIT-CE R77-44 1,2 Hein KH, Whitman RV (1976) Effects of earthquakes on system performance of water lifelines, MIT-CE R76-23 1,2 Isbell JE, Biggs JM (1974) Inelastic design of building frames to resist earthquakes 1,2 Krimgold F (1977) Seismic design decisions for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts state building code 1 Larrabee RD, Whitman RV (1976) Costs of reinforcing existing buildings and constructing new buildings to meet earthquake codes 1,2 Munroe T, Blair C (1975) Economic impact in seismic design decision analysis: a preliminary investigation 1,2 Panoussis G (1974) Seismic reliability of lifeline networks. SDDA Report No. 15. MIT-CE R74-58 1 Schumacker B, Whitman RV (1977) Models of threshold exceedance and loss computations of non-homogeneous spatially distributed facilities 1,2 Taleb-Agha G, Whitman, RV (1975) Seismic risk analysis of discrete systems 1,2 Taleb-Agha G (1975) Seismic risk analysis of lifeline networks 1,2 Taleb-Agha G (1974). Sensitivity analyses and graphical method for preliminary solutions 1 Tong, W-H (1975) Seismic risk analysis for two-sites case 1,2 Unemori AL, Whitman RV (1976) Nonlinear inelastic dynamic analysis with soilflexibility in rocking. SDDA Report No. 25. 1,2 Veneziano D (1975) Probabilistic and statistical models for seismic analysis 1,2
1
M.I.T. Dept. of Civil Engineering, Cambridge, MA. Available from National Information Service, U.S. Dept. of Commerce, Springfield VA. 2
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
79
Whitman RV, Protonotarios JN (1977) Inelastic response to site-modified ground motions 1,2 Whitman RV et al. (1973) Summary of methodology and pilot application. SDDA Report No. 9. 1 Whitman RV et al. (1974) Ground motion amplification studies, Bursa, Turkey 1 Whitman RV et al. (1974) Methodology and pilot application 1 Whitman RV et al. (1974) Seismic design decision analysis 1 Whitman RV, Aziz TS, Wong EH (1977) Preliminary correlations between earthquake damage and strong ground motion 1,2 Wong EH (1975) Correlations between earthquake damage and strong ground motion. MIT-CE R75-23 1,2 Yegian MK (1976) Risk analysis for earthquake-induced ground failure by liquefaction 1,2
1
M.I.T. Dept. of Civil Engineering, Cambridge, MA. Available from National Information Service, U.S. Dept. of Commerce, Springfield VA. 2
80
Charles Scawthorn
Table 2.3. Terminology and Concordance
Appendix 3. Terminology and Concordance
Table 2.3. (continued)
2 A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment
81
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
Responses to Scawthorn’s paper “A Brief History of Seismic Risk Assessment”
Introduction Each of the following authors brings his own distinguished viewpoint on the history and future directions for [seismic] risk assessment. Robert Whitman focuses on the lessons learned from regional seismic risk assessments, including the need for clearly defined objectives for successful outcomes; accounting for user needs in loss estimates; assessing uncertainty; including lifelines in analyses; and developing a meaningful inventory prior to analysis. Amr Elnashai extends the history of scientific inquiry into earthquakes back to the 1600’s and fills in some important events, while emphasizing how Europe, Japan, and the United States interacted in the development of seismic research and building codes. Finally, Dennis Mileti urges practitioners to take sociological perspectives into account, as losses that extend beyond traditionally assessed risk are harder to quantify, but no less important. Scawthorn’s history makes an important contribution to our understanding of the field of risk assessment. Further consideration of the historical context highlights the importance of considering how loss estimation tools developed for applications in the past need to be better customized to appeal to current audiences. Although they are costly, there is still a need for more on-the-ground sensors, using multiple technologies to provide better base data for predictions about earthquakes. Lessons learned in the development of seismic risk assessment are broadly applicable to the assessment of risk due to other natural hazards. Indeed, the primary tool used by the U.S. disaster management agencies,
84
Robert V. Whitman
HAZUS®, brings together models for earthquakes, wind and floods under one umbrella to help communities estimate potential losses from all of these hazards. In all areas of risk analysis, broadening analyses will likely produce more useful outcomes.
3.1 Lessons Leaned from Current Practice and Future Needs in Regional Loss Estimation Robert V. Whitman Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA
3.1.1 Impacts of Risk Analyses In Section 2.5, Scawthorn lists a number of regional seismic risk assessments, and in almost every case summarizes the impact of the assessment. With just a few exceptions, the impact is “unknown,” “as yet unknown,” or is given in vague, general terms. This summary is in line with that extracted from the user needs questionnaire and workshop conducted during the study for the 1989 “Estimating Losses …” NRC report. In that study, the users questioned were unable to cite specific benefits from the regional loss estimates that had been conducted, but “the most important use of these studies … was … in educating elected officials and the public about the seriousness of seismic threat and the need to take action.” Of the studies cited by Scawthorn, there were specific and tangible impacts only from those with more limited and specific objectives; e.g.: Worker’s Compensation benefits, and Fire Following Earthquake (San Francisco and Los Angeles). These observations emphasize the importance of having clear objectives in advance of a study, arrived at in co-operation with the intended user. The ability to operate in this fashion is one reason for the successful cooperation between insurance companies and private-sector firms performing risk analyses for them. The recent Seattle Fault scenario study should be added to the list of important regional loss estimates (EERI 2005).
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
85
3.1.2 User Needs The aforementioned 1989 NRC study included circulating questionnaires and holding a workshop in an effort to understand what potential users most wanted from a regional loss estimate. The users in this case were primarily officials and workers from smaller cities and, to a lesser degree, from regional and state governments. The following recommendations were gleaned from the results: x Involve the users in the entire loss estimate study process. x Clearly indicate the level of potential error as well as confidence in the loss estimates. x There should be an inventory base that can be disaggregated to the smallest political and geographic unit, and that is in a form that can be used and maintained by local governments. x Loss estimate studies should contain a scenario earthquake that is relatively probable and yet large enough to cause serious loss. x To increase the likelihood of access and use, reports should be as nontechnical as possible. More emphasis should be placed on the implications of the findings for seismic policy and planning adoption. In the 1989 report, credibility and clarity to relatively lay audiences jump out. The Seattle Fault study meets these tests very well. There was also a large effort to ascertain user needs in connection with the development of HAZUS®. A sizable committee, reflecting the same type of users identified for the 1989 NRC study, met several times and developed a long “wish list.” The list covered types of facilities for which losses were desired (e.g. hospitals, fire stations, electric systems, etc.,) and types of losses to be evaluated (e.g. dollar losses, casualties, volume of debris, etc.) This list paralleled that from the 1989 NRC study (with one major exception mentioned in the next section). In particular, this group of potential users strongly wished to have the inventory, and losses associated with that inventory, de-aggregated to the smallest community size possible, which led to the use of a census tract as the basic geographic unit in HAZUS®. These potential users, like those contacted in the 1989 NRC study, strongly desired information concerning the post-earthquake serviceability of utility and transportation lifelines. The HAZUS® leaders and contractors sought to satisfy as many of these user needs as seemed possible at the time, also keeping in mind the needs of the real client – FEMA.
86
Robert V. Whitman
3.1.3 Accuracy and Uncertainty Unlike the potential users in the 1989 NRC study, in my memory the group of potential users associated with the initial phases of the HAZUS® effort were not enthusiastic about being given a realistic range of estimated losses – especially when faced with estimates of how large these ranges might be. They felt such indications of large uncertainty would make it difficult to sell elected officials and the public on the need for actions to reduce losses. This is in stark contrast with the needs of the insurance industry for realistic assessment of uncertainties. Hence, it is not surprising that the greatest impetus for evaluating uncertainty has come from insurers. Hopefully, public users of loss estimates are today better prepared to face the reality of large uncertainties. Achieving realistic evaluation of uncertainties – especially as regard to vulnerability – does appear as an important outstanding challenge. Certainly every opportunity to compare predicted and actual losses – i.e. every significant earthquake – should be pursued to the fullest extent possible – and in detail and not just in aggregated losses. But acquiring empirical information in this way will be a slow process. As described by Scawthorn, multiple theoretical analyses – varying assumed configurations and properties – offer the possibility of better estimates for uncertainties of various classes of buildings and bridges. However, since every analysis must start from assumptions about the proper model for a structure, there will always remain doubts about the size of the model error. 3.1.4 Lifelines Disruptions resulting from serious damage to utility and transportation lifelines may have a greater impact upon a community as a whole than major damage to residential and commercial buildings. This should be of special concern to municipal officials and their planners. Outside help will assist with the casualties and displacements resulting from building damage, but the public will hold local officials responsible for slowness in restoring vital lifeline systems to a functioning state. Despite this need on the part of their potential users, the HAZUS® team concluded that it was only, at that time, feasible to assess damage to components of lifelines (e.g. bridges) – at best a very rough indicator of the operational capability of partly-damaged lifeline systems. Since then, quite a number of software packages for analyzing lifeline systems have been developed. They are complex, in part because of the special problems presented by spatially dispersed and redundant networks. These software
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
87
packages obviously can be of great value to those responsible for the planning and functioning of lifeline systems. Moreover, there potentially are important interactions between utility lifelines and other aspects of disaster mitigation – fire-fighting being the most obvious example. At first sight, it might seem desirable to incorporate one or more such software packages into HAZUS®, so as to permit a more complete analysis of the economic and disruptive effects of an earthquake upon a community or region. Indeed, the HAZUS® team originally hoped that would be possible as part of a “Level 3” analysis. Clearly, the “closed source” policy for HAZUS® inhibits such linkages. With privately-owned utility systems, at least, there may be other obstacles as well. It is pertinent to note that those preparing the Seattle Fault scenario – while emphasizing potential problems with lifeline systems – apparently chose to rely upon engineering experience and judgment rather than running any formal analysis of the systems. Just how to most effectively integrate the analysis of lifelines into a comprehensive risk analysis is certainly is an important question. There are aspects of risk where building damage and lifeline performance overlap; for example, business interruption and fire-related loss. Such overlaps argue for formal linking of building damage and lifeline performance within a single analysis. On the other hand, one should question whether the supposed increase in accuracy is worth the additional complication. It may well be that informal linking of separate analyses in a scenario is usually a better alternative. 3.1.5 Inventory As noted by Scawthorn, developing a meaningful inventory – especially one that includes credible information concerning the seismic resistance of structures and facilities – is an important but difficult challenge. The more detail that is desired in the estimated losses, the more important the inventory becomes. Thus, uncertainty in estimated fatalities (which depend strongly upon the inventory of the most collapse-susceptible structures) is generally greater than uncertainty in gross damage cost (which can be estimated by averaging losses over many, many buildings). Credible estimates for the functionality of fire-fighting systems are dependent upon knowledge of the seismic resistance of fire stations and upon the functionality of water supply systems. The particular soil profile at the location of an essential facility can have an important influence upon the expected performance of that facility. Reliance solely upon default inventories, or any inventories lacking good information about seismic resistance, thus
88
Robert V. Whitman
greatly limits the reliability of detailed loss estimates. The experiencebased judgment of local engineers – even without detailed studies and tabulations – can go a long way in improving upon default inventories – and hence improve estimates for the number of severely damaged structures. However, when a particular structure or facility is very important in a loss estimate, there can be no substitute for detailed knowledge concerning the structural system and the way in which it was designed and built. This will be true when estimated losses can be dominated by those occurring in a single (or a very few) large structures, or when a large facility (dam, LNG plant, etc.) might cause losses so large as to dominate those caused by damage in the balance of the community or region. Such situations should be treated separately from broad loss estimates that inevitably depend upon averaging uncertain losses over many, many entries in an inventory. 3.1.6 Immediate Post-Earthquake Response One offered role for a loss estimate is to provide guidance for responders immediately following an earthquake. Being able to obtain a ShakeMap (USGS) within minutes following an earthquake makes this a potential possibility. Obviously, how meaningful a role there is depends upon a detailed and up-to-date inventory – especially for critical structures (e.g. fire stations and hospitals) and for especially damageable buildings and facilities. 3.1.7 Risk Assessment Scawthorn mentioned the potential role for standards and norms for risk assessment. I particularly feel the need for a multi-attribute measure of the loss and disruption that might result from an earthquake – incorporating measures of direct damage loss, broader impacts on the economy, suffering and disruption. Here clearly is a challenge requiring close cooperation between the engineering and social science disciplines. Of course, standards imply controls over the software used for analyses. The desire to be able to compare loss estimates from various different communities was what drove FEMA to maintain control of the source code for HAZUS®. Here is a suggestion for another entry in the bibliography. Within the past several years, a group in Canada responsible for the safety of hydroelectric facilities has issued a comprehensive and excellent guideline for
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
89
risk assessment (Hartford and Baecher, 2004). Earthquakes are only one of the risks considered. 3.1.8 Concluding Remarks I agree that risk assessment, and in particular risk analysis, has certainly come a long way during recent decades. There also certainly are opportunities for further advances in accomplishing more comprehensive and credible risk analyses. At the same time, perhaps the greatest challenge will be in learning how to effectively use risk assessment to achieve a safer society. It will be important to document applications of risk assessment tools for purposes of earthquake hazard mitigation – what was done and what results were achieved. Stimulating officials and planners to provide such documentation – which can serve as invaluable guides for others planning risk evaluations, as well as suggesting new developments aimed at improving loss estimates – will be a vital task.
3.2 The Dawn of Earthquake Investigations and CrossContinent Interactions Amr S. Elnashai University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, Illinois, USA
Congratulations to Scawthorn are in order, for the excellent information that he has provided and for setting a very ambitious goal that was largely achieved. He could have only reviewed Seismic Loss Assessment, meaning studies that have attempted to estimate the impact of an earthquake on a system or a region, or he could have limited the geographical or temporal coverage of his review. Instead, he attempted to cover the subject from Antiquity to modern day projects, some of which are indeed still underway. He has challenged himself and readers by challenging the statement made by George Housner, who is quoted as saying in 1984 that writing a history of earthquake engineering is premature. The author even delved into other related developments, such as digital computers and finite element methods. This enjoyable chapter reflects the wide and international experience of Scawthorn. Notwithstanding the ‘lack of comprehensiveness’ disclaimer in
90
Amr S. Elnashai
the paper, the contents cover almost every aspect of not only earthquake loss assessment but also its components of hazard and fragility, alongside decision-making and underlying technology and tools. As a consequence, there are large gaps both in time and space, in the chapter. I will attempt below to fill in some important events, and to highlight other gaps that I am not able to fill and leave for others. The four issues I will cover are: (1) the dawn of systematic and scientific research in earthquake causes and effects, (2) interactions between Europe, Japan and the USA in the early days of earthquake research, (3) seismic design code development, and (4) contributions from outside Europe, Japan and the USA, alongside present day projects in Europe. 3.2.1 Landmark Developments in the 17th and 18th Centuries I am sure that George Housner has a good explanation for his statement in 1984 that earthquake engineering is a 20th century subject. As far as my limited investigations indicate, it started three centuries earlier. The origins of modern earthquake engineering may be traced to four geographical nuclei of development, California, Japan, Italy and the British Isles (Housner, 1984, 1989). The earliest formal study was by Robert Hooke (1635–1703) who gave a series of lectures at the Royal Society during 1667 and 1668, which appeared as a book in 1705. These were entitled ‘Lectures and Discourses in Earthquakes and Sub-terranean Eruptions’. This was followed by the work of Thomas Young (1773–1829), who collated a bibliography on earthquake-related publications in Europe, published in 1807. Independently, Robert Mallet (1810–1881) was busy thinking of earthquake processes and the development of measuring devices. In 1847, he presented his paper entitled ‘On the Dynamics of Earthquakes’ at the Irish Academy, which was published subsequently. The paper included a blueprint for a seismograph that may have inspired later developments in Italy, California and Japan. Mallet also invented the term seismology, by joining the Greek words VHLVPRV (earthquake) with ORJLD(suffix meaning talking technically or explaining). However, the real trigger was provided by events elsewhere. In 1880, a small magnitude earthquake hit Yokohama (Kanai, 1989), causing minor damage to houses, but firing the enthusiasm of three English engineers who were visiting Japan. These were John Milne (1850–1913), James Alfred Ewing (1855–1912) and Thomas Gray (1850–1908). The former played a crucial role in the development of the subject and published a landmark book in England (Milne, 1898). There is some conflict in the literature about its formation, but it is likely that the Seismological Society of Japan was founded, at least in part,
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
91
by John Milne and his colleagues, in collaboration with Fusakichi Omori (1868–unknown) and Seikei Sekiya (1855–1896). The latter was the world’s first professor of seismology at the Imperial College of Tokyo and is probably the first to observe the effect of topography on earthquake ground motion (Sekiya and Omori, 1891). Certainly, Milne had not left Japan, as some Japanese references state, by the time of the Great Gifu earthquake of 1891 (magnitude 8.0, 7273 deaths, 17,175 injured). John Milne’s A3-size book on observations from the earthquake is a prime example of his pioneering work and insight. Photographic evidence of high quality was given in the book of the collapse of early steel truss bridges supported on masonry piers, as shown in Fig. 3.1 alongside many other photographs of industrial and residential buildings. The report is comprehensive in its treatment of the event, and would still hold today as a model for investigative, as opposed to observational, earthquake reconnaissance reporting.
Fig. 3.1. Nagara Gawa Bridge damaged in the Gifu earthquake of 1891 (Milne and Burton 1892)
The Japanese nucleus continued to grow further with the formation of the Imperial Earthquake Investigation Committee in 1892, to investigate means of earthquake prediction and to minimize their impact. The Committee was replaced by the Earthquake Research Institute at the abovementioned Imperial College of Tokyo (where, in fact, John Milne was the first professor of Geology who studied earthquakes) in the wake of the Great Kanto earthquake of 1923, which killed 100,000 people. The first di-
92
Amr S. Elnashai
rector of the Institute was Dr. Kyoji Suyehiro, credited with the establishment of the sub-discipline and the term ‘Jishin Kogaku’ or Engineering Seismology (Suyehiro 1932). His lectures at California Institute of Technology (amongst whose academic staff were von Karman and Richter), University of California, Stanford and MIT in 1931 and 1932 stressed the need to obtain recordings of earthquakes, to establish their characteristics, hitherto completely unknown. Indeed, a paper in the proceedings of the American Society of Civil Engineering written by Professor C. Derleth, in the aftermath of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake stated that ‘An attempt to calculate earthquake stresses is futile. Such calculations could lead to no practical conclusions of value’! The cross-over from British to Italian earthquake engineering came in 1855 when Luigi Palmieri (1867–1896) built a seismograph similar in design to that published by Robert Mallet in 1848. Italian giant strides drew further vigor when the Messina earthquake of 1908 (Figure 3.2) caused about 83,000 deaths, thus exceeding the Great All Saints Day earthquake of 1755 which devastated Lisbon, killing 60,000. An Italian government committee of 13 practitioners and engineers wrote a report giving a procedure, for the first time, of applying earthquake forces on structures as a percentage of their weight. It seems that this approach was the work of Professor Modesto Panetti of the Politecnic of Turin who recommended that the first floor earthquake force be 1/12 of the weight above, changing to 1/8 of the weight above for the second and third floors. The method, an equivalent static approach still used to this day in design codes, was explained and articulated by Professor Arturo Danusso of the Politecnic of Milan in his paper ‘Statics of Anti-Seismic Construction’. The method was thereafter widely used in Japan and the USA for earthquake design (Blume 1958).
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
93
Fig. 3.2. Damage to the Palazzo Navigazione Beneraio Italiano, Messina earthquake, 1908
3.2.2 Seismic Design Code Development Although it was the Italians who developed the equivalent static procedure, the first formal code for seismic design was due to the Japanese Building Ordinance, after the 1923 Great Kanto earthquake. The regulations stipulated that buildings should be designed to resist a force equivalent to 10% of their weight applied horizontally. In the US, seismic design became mandatory only after the 1933 Long Beach earthquake, as mentioned in Scawthorn’s paper. A seismic design coefficient of 8% of the weight of the structure was recommended, regardless of earthquake or building characteristics. This event also yielded the world’s first set of strong-motion records, from the newly installed network, at Long Beach, Los Angeles and Vernon (Heck and Neuman 1933). The record at Long Beach showed a peak acceleration of 0.23g, nearly 6 times (in response terms) the recommended design coefficient. Since few buildings collapsed, first evidence of ductile response and the benefits of energy absorption were obtained. Engineering seismology and earthquake engineering, now distinct but interrelated fields, have never looked back. The proliferation of, and indeed the contradictions between, seismic design codes in force around the world is best demonstrated by examining the world list published every four years
94
Amr S. Elnashai
by the International Association of Earthquake Engineering (IAEE). The leading codes that have been widely used and tested are the Uniform Building Code (UBC, mainly developed in California but used on many international projects), the Japanese Building Law (sometimes inspired or augmented by the Architectural Institute of Japan documents) and the New Zealand seismic design code (known to include advanced concepts of ductile seismic response). In recent years, Eurocode8, the pan-European design code of earthquake resistance, has emerged as a force to be reckoned with, and has now been adopted by not only all EU member states, but also several countries in their vicinity. For example, Slovenia, not a member of the EU, has adopted all Eurocodes, whilst the seismic design code of Egypt is a simplified and regionalized version of Eurocode8. The New Zealand seismic design code remains a powerful document that is in many ways distinct from and more advanced than others. In addition to seismic design codes, which are legally binding documents, there are a number of guidance notes that are either used in their own right (e.g. Federal Emergency Management Agency – FEMA – guidelines for assessing and strengthening existing structures) or as source documents for code developments (e.g. Comite Euro-internationale de Beton – CEB – model code 1990, and National Earthquake Hazard Reduction Program – NEHRP – guidelines for seismic design of structures). 3.2.3 Contributions from Other Countries and Recent Developments As discussed above, the main nuclei of earthquake investigations were Italy and Britain in Europe, California in the USA, and Japan. However, in the 20th century, significant contributions were made by other countries, some of which qualify as landmark contributions. For example, the concept of Capacity Design is well and truly a New Zealand contribution. Contrary to popular belief, it was not proposed by Thomas Paulay, but by a practitioner, the name of whom escapes me. It was, however, Thomas Paulay who quantified it especially for reinforced concrete, and used it extensively in his teaching, research and contributions to the practice in New Zealand. Major contributions came from India and Turkey, both of which hosted the World Conference on Earthquake Engineering (1977 and 1980, respectively); Jai Krishna and Refaat Yarar were founding members of the International Association of Earthquake Engineering. I hasten to add that I have not researched this section of my review, but relied on my memory of some notable contributions.
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
95
With regard to the current situation, the author has again challenged established wisdom not to chronicle recent events; he has indeed chronicled current, not just recent, ones. I would like to at least point out that LessLoss is not undertaking earthquake loss assessment as we understand it, but is rather a loose alliance of a very large number of institutions (about 42) that cover almost all aspects of earthquake loss assessment, but without integrating the tools and products. Moreover, LessLoss is the successor of a number of important, and somewhat more focused, European collaborative projects, namely PREC8 (coordinator, Artur Pinto), ICONS (coordinator Gian Calvi) and SAFERR (coordinator Amr Elnashai), in addition to several other projects that were funded earlier in geotechnical earthquake engineering and seismology. Finally, alongside the existing and excellent software packages mentioned in Scawthorn’s paper, there are others that have made giant strides and deserve to be mentioned there. Examples are OpenSHA (from SCEC), MAEviz (from the Mid-America Earthquake Center) and software by ImageCat, RMS and others. 3.2.4 Closure As mentioned in the opening of this section, George Housner often said that it is too early to write an historical review of the development of our interesting and inter-disciplinary topic. This is indeed true, but without contributions along the way, the prospects of writing such a review diminish with time. The endeavor is certainly premature. Notwithstanding, Scawthorn’s paper is such a contribution, and a significant one too. It reminds us of the names of Robert Mallet and John Milne, alongside the early Japanese pioneers Sekiya, Suyehiro and Omori, who featured very strongly in earthquake investigations in the late 1800s early 1900s. The Italian engineers Palmieri, Panetti and Danusso also made essential contributions at a critical time. For reasons that still prevail today, once an idea is implanted in the USA, it takes root so vigorously that its flourishing is attributed solely to the fertility of the medium, not the potency of the cutting. This is not necessarily disputable, but due recognition of the originators would perhaps encourage further cross-fertilization. It is in this spirit that I have added more information and specific details on non-USA earthquake research contributions. Since earthquakes know neither national nor techno-disciplinary boundaries, seismic risk mitigation efforts should also abandon these boundaries and deploy all means and efforts to protect communities threatened by earthquake risk.
96
Dennis S. Mileti
3.3 Social Science Perspectives on Seismic Risk Assessment Dennis S. Mileti University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado, USA
3.3.1 Definition of Seismic Risk Assessment Careful attention should be paid to the definition of seismic risk assessment and/or analysis. It can be cast as a combination of earthquake hazard and assets at risk, but it means so much more to so many others. For example, to many it also includes losses that extend beyond direct losses to include second and third level impacts, societal consequences in their varied forms, and so on (what the author has called “loss studies”). The most inclusive of all views for this paper would include all such items for the earthquake hazard and, thereby, enable the author to catalogue the contributions of all those who have worked in this very diverse field. 3.3.2 Basis for Seismic Risk Assessment Seismic risk assessment is a mixed bag. For example, it can be thought of as map based and linked to shaking intensity, the interplay between shaking intensity and the constructed environment via fragility curves, as a picture of a broken building element that constitutes a lesson learned (which provides risk information regarding like building in other seismic areas) after a post-event field investigation, and so on. This rich variety in the basis of what constitutes a seismic risk and loss assessment might be more interesting to flaunt than keeping to the more straight and narrow definition of the field. 3.3.3 Guideposts The history of anything in general, and the field of seismic risk assessment in particular, are punctuated with significant events that shape and direct the field. These events for seismic risk assessment could be more richly identified to provide the reader with guideposts to the area’s history. One
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
97
way to capture the impact of these guideposts would be, perhaps, to use them as sub-section titles. Although many of these “guidepost events” are now included, others are not. What I mean by guideposts are significant events or documents that impacted the field. Some examples include the risk and losses scenarios written by Karl Steinbrugge, the 1964 Great Alaska Earthquake, Ted Algermissen’s national risk maps, the 1971 San Fernando Earthquake and the reports which followed from it, the California State Geologist’s shaking intensity maps published in the early 1980s, and many others. 3.3.4 Techniques and Applications Intertwine The history and development of seismic risk assessment is intertwined with the history of the application of seismic risk and loss assessment information. The current document might consider clarifying and documenting this relationship. For example, the California Seismic Safety Commission recently published a 100 year timeline of seismic safety legislation in the state that documents over 200 seismic safety laws in the state. Although the adoption of almost every one of these laws is linked to an actual earthquake, many – but certainly not all – are rooted in advances and/or work in risk and loss assessment. 3.3.5 Societal Losses and Vulnerability It is difficult in the year 2006 to accept the absence in the previous chapter of dramatic advances in the social sciences in the sub-fields of vulnerability and loss assessment. Some of these include, for example, those performed by the social sciences component of the MAE Center, and the Social Vulnerability GIS based Index developed by Susan Cutter and her colleagues at the University of Southern California (Cutter’s recent work with the Social Vulnerability Index may be analogous to the emergence of the first shaking intensity map for the nation).
3.4 Seismic Risk Assessment: History and Strategic Directions No forward-looking treatment of a field would be complete without an historical perspective on which to ground it. The previous chapter attempts to present this as comprehensively as possible for the broad field of seismic
98
Dennis S. Mileti
risk assessment. Charles Scawthorn outlined a well-annotated timeline for the major discoveries and developments from many sub-disciplines, including seismology, civil engineering and economics. These were drawn on the backdrop of major seismic events around the world, which spurred societal interest in assessing and mitigating the risk of catastrophic losses due to earthquakes. It is important to view the development of loss estimation technologies through the perspective of the institutions in which they have developed and to consider the appropriateness of these tools to current audiences. What has been the audience for and what has funded loss estimation methodologies developed so far? The drivers/clients for the technology in the past have been the insurance industry, nuclear power, and the federal government. Current audiences for the products of these technologies are less understood and are probably much more diverse than originally intended or designed for. In some cases, the technologies have exceeded the needs of the audiences, and there may be technologies looking for uses. Improving sensor technologies and applying them to broader seismic sensing networks is an essential part of loss estimation. A denser network of earthquake sensors is needed around the world, but this is currently limited by the cost of the sensors. The development of lower cost sensors should be a priority. The demand for sensors is higher where earthquakes are more frequent, more severe, and the potential for financial losses is greater (i.e., Japan). The use of multiple technologies (small sensors, teleseismics, remote sensing, etc.) will all help to develop better ground motion maps for making predictions and estimations of loss. As the field of seismic risk assessment moves forward, its practitioners must stay aware of the history of its major developments, and the environment in which these developments occurred. The evolution of technology and its applications are intertwined, as pointed out previously, and this history has important implications in terms of problem framing and potentially neglected analyses. The well-documented events and outcomes of historical and recent earthquakes provide fodder for improvements to analysis techniques and technology to provide better risk assessments. Finally, as one would expect, many major developments in the history of seismic risk assessment were motivated by earthquakes with major loss of life and high economic consequences, but forward-looking improvements in assessment methods and technologies need not await the next disaster. A theme that was repeated in the reviews and discussion is the importance of considering the audiences for which previous assessments were developed and broadening the utility of the outputs or at least being aware of interests that may be neglected by existing methods. In the future, risk assessment should be based on clearly-defined objectives that include fac-
3 Perspectives on the History of Seismic Risk Assessment
99
tors not historically accounted for (such as disruptions in lifelines and social consequences of disasters) and should produce output that is communicable to an audience that at least includes decision-makers with relatively little technical background. The rational analysis and mitigation of risk due to natural and other hazards has a solid and long-standing inter-disciplinary history that has resulted in significant improvements in risk assessment and mitigation through building design and code regulations in Japan, Western Europe, and the United States. The continued progression of positive impacts on mitigating losses will depend on expanding the factors included in analysis, audiences targeted for outputs, and pre- and post-disaster data collected to improve the models.
References Applied Technology Council (1978, amended 1982) Tentative provisions for the development of seismic regulations for buildings (ATC-3-06). Applied Technology Council, Washington, DC Blume JA (1958) Structural dynamics in earthquake resistant design Coburn A, Spence R (1992) Earthquake protection. John Wiley & Sons, West Sussex, England EERI (2005) Scenario for a magnitude 6.7 earthquake on the Seattle fault. Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, Oakland CA Elnashai AS (2002) A very brief history of earthquake engineering with emphasis on developments in and from the British Isles. International Journal of Chaos Solitons and Fractals 13:967–972 Hartford DND, Baecher GB (2004) Risk and safety in dam safety. Thomas Telford, London Heck NH, Neuman F (1933) Destructive earthquake motion measured for the first time. Engineering News Record 110:804 Housner GW (1984) An historical view of earthquake engineering. In: Proceedings of the 8th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering. San Francisco, pp 25–38 Housner GW (1989) Coping with natural disasters: The international decade for natural disaster reduction, the second Mallet-Milne lecture. Society of Earthquake and Civil Engineering Dynamics, UK Kanai K (1983) Engineering seismology. University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, Japan Milne J (1898) Seismology. Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner and Co, London Milne JB, Burton WK (1892) The great Japan earthquake of 1891, 1st edn. Lane, Crawford & Co, Yokohama National Research Council (1989) Estimating losses from future earthquakes, panel on earthquake loss estimation methodology. National Academy Press, Washington DC
100
Dennis S. Mileti
Sekiya S, Omori F (1891) Comparison of earthquake measurements made in a pit and on ground surface. Journal of College of Science, Imperial University of Japan IV:249 Suyehiro K (1932) Engineering seismology. Proceedings ASCE 58
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling: HAZUS® Development and Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
Thomas S. Durham1 with Pushpendra Johari2 and Douglas Bausch3 1
PBS&J, Inc., Chantilly, VA, 20151 PBS&J, Inc., Atlanta, GA 30328 3 FEMA Region VII Denver, CO 80225 2
4.1 Introduction In the early 1990s, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the National Institute of Building Sciences (NIBS) embarked on an initiative to develop a consistent, standardized approach to estimating losses from earthquakes. In 1997, FEMA released the first HAZUS® (Hazards U.S.) model for earthquakes to “provide state, local, and regional officials with the tools necessary to plan and stimulate the efforts to reduce risk from earthquakes and to prepare for emergency response and recovery from an earthquake” (FEMA and NIBS 2003). Today, HAZUS®MH (multihazards) has evolved into a powerful, GISbased risk assessment tool that estimates potential damage and losses from earthquakes, wind and floods. The latest version – MR2 – was released in June 2006 and incorporates important new enhancements into all three models. As HAZUS®MH continues to mature, new uses are being identified, particularly for risk assessment and mitigation (FEMA 2006). The emergence of catastrophic planning as a national priority under the Department of Homeland Security and FEMA presents a unique opportunity to “harness” the capabilities of HAZUS®MH as a regional loss estimation tool. This paper presents an approach to fully integrating the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model into FEMA’s catastrophic planning initia-
102
Thomas S. Durham with Pushpendra Johari and Douglas Bausch
tive, with specific recommendations on model enhancements that will strengthen this national planning effort. The paper offers a new vision of catastrophic planning that integrates risk assessment and risk reduction with response and recovery planning. The rationale is that preparedness to respond to a major or catastrophic incident is in large part a function of the resiliency1 and capacity of our nation’s emergency management system – including essential facilities and lifelines (transportation and utilities) – to support response and recovery missions. Simply put, if emergency services, medical facilities and lifelines are not available or have limited capacity to support response, then our nation’s operational capability is undermined. As a regional loss estimation tool, HAZUS®MH can both quantify losses from hazard events, and quantify losses avoided through mitigation, and in the process show the role of mitigation in catastrophic planning. The paper is organized into five sections: 1) HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model Overview; 2) Use of HAZUS®MH to Support Catastrophic Planning; 3) Use of HAZUS®MH to Link Risk Assessment, Mitigation and Disaster Response; 4) Utilization of a Web-based Data Management Portal System; and 5) Conclusions.
4.2 HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model Overview HAZUS®MH is a regional loss estimation tool that enables the user to perform a wide range of analyses, from simplified estimates that require minimal input to refined calculations of building damage and loss of functionality. As reflected in Fig. 4.1, the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model utilizes a modular approach to estimating hazard, building and lifelines damage and losses, induced physical damage, direct and indirect economic losses, and social losses. Because data in the earthquake model is aggregated at the census tract level in all 50 states, loss estimates can be generated at virtually any scale. One of the strengths of the methodology is the ability to generate and display GIS-based maps at multiple scales, a feature that is very useful in catastrophic planning. The model incorporates a comprehensive, national inventory of building stock, essential facilities, lifelines and hazard data 1 The need for a regional disaster resilience strategy is the focus of a report that was released in June, 2006 by The Infrastructure Security Partnership (TISP). Regional Disaster Resilience: A Guide for Developing an Action Plan, provides stakeholders with a comprehensive set of guidelines for improving regional preparedness from natural, technological and man-made hazards.
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling
103
that can be enhanced by the user, as discussed in a subsequent section of this paper.
Fig. 4.1. HAZUS®MH Earthquake Loss Estimation Methodology
One of the main components of the HAZUS®MH earthquake methodology is the estimates of the probability of various states of structural and nonstructural damage to buildings. Damage state probabilities are used by other components of the methodology to estimate various types of building loss, social and economic losses. Typically, buildings are grouped by occupancy and model building type and evaluated on a census tract basis. Buildings are grouped into 33 specific occupancies and 36 model building types (and for various combinations of seismic design level and performance) with users having the flexibility to add more model building types. To summarize, the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model incorporates a flexible, standardized, modular loss estimation methodology that can be used in multiple ways to assess damage and loss from earthquakes. In April, 2006 the Earthquake Model was successfully used to estimate and display earthquake damage and loss to a 19 county region in the San Francisco Bay Area from a repeat of the 1906 earthquake. The following section highlights the findings of a study on the current state of practice in catastrophic planning in the U.S., and presents a strategy for using HAZUS®MH to enhance planning and preparedness for catastrophic earthquakes.
104
Thomas S. Durham with Pushpendra Johari and Douglas Bausch
4.3 Use of HAZUS®MH to Support Catastrophe Planning
4.3.1 Catastrophe Planning: A National Priority In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, the Bush administration elevated catastrophic planning2 as a national priority. In a speech in New Orleans following Katrina, President Bush directed the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to undertake a review of emergency and catastrophic plans in the 50 states and 75 urban areas in the United States. The Nationwide Plan Review: Phase 2 Report, released on June 16, 2006 identifies multiple “areas of relative weakness”, measured by the level of action taken by the 50 states and 75 urban areas to develop and sustain preparedness capabilities for catastrophic incidents. Fundamentally, the report concludes that catastrophic planning as practiced in the nation is flawed. As stated in the report: “Current catastrophic planning is unsystematic and not linked within a national planning system. This is incompatible with 21st century homeland security challenges, and reflects a systematic problem: outmoded planning processes, products, and tools are primary contributors to the inadequacy of catastrophic planning” (U.S. Department of Homeland Security 2006, page viii). 4.3.2 Use of HAZUS®MH to Address Gaps in Catastrophic Planning The Nationwide Plan Review: Phase 2 Report (U.S. Department of Homeland Security 2006) identifies several key gaps in the catastrophic planning process, several of which can be addressed in part through the use of HAZUS®MH. Examples of specific weaknesses are highlighted below, with observations on how HAZUS®MH analysis can be used to address these weaknesses. x Few Emergency Operations Plans (EOPs) address the consequences of catastrophic disasters (p. 14). HAZUS®MH outputs (see Fig. 4.2) are uniquely adapted to functional planning under the “Emergency Support 2 Catastrophic disasters are defined as “any natural or manmade incident, including terrorism, that results in extraordinary levels of mass casualties, damage, or disruption severely affecting the population, infrastructure, environment, economy, national morale, and/or government functions” (U.S. Department of Homeland Security 2006).
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling
105
Function” (ESF) system in the National Response Plan (NRP). Several states, notably California, have made significant progress in using HAZUS®MH analysis to “scale mission requirements” for earthquake response. The catastrophic planning initiative provides an opportunity to standardize HAZUS®MH outputs for ESF planning under the NRP. x Assumptions in Basic Plans do not adequately address catastrophic incidents (p. 63). In large part, assumptions flow from an understanding of the consequences of hazards on buildings, lifelines and the population. One of the unique features of the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model is the ability to demonstrate – both qualitatively and quantitatively – the consequences of major or catastrophic earthquakes. x Shelter needs and shelter capacity for catastrophic disasters need to be identified and quantified, and statewide plans developed (p. 26). The shelter module is among the most reliable in HAZUS®MH (in model validation studies, actual shelter requirements match up well with estimated requirements). To support catastrophic planning, the Earthquake Model can be used to estimate the number and distribution of displaced households and shelter requirements, and also characterize the population at risk. x The plans do not compare projected, quantified needs and listed resources that are needed for an effective emergency response (p.18). The ability to estimate damage and loss of functionality with HAZUS®MH enables users to identify and quantify resource require-ments that are needed for scenario events. 4.3.3 Integrating HAZUS®MH into the National Incident Management System (NIMS) Preparations for and response to a catastrophic disaster are guided by National Incident Management System, issued by the Department of Homeland Security on March 1, 2004 to provide a comprehensive and consistent national approach to all-hazard incident management at all jurisdictional levels and across functional disciplines. Key to using HAZUS®MH to support catastrophic planning is the ability to fully integrate the HAZUS® technology and HAZUS®MH team into the Planning Section under the NIMS. A key feature of NIMS is the Incident Command System (ICS), which comprises five functional areas: Command, Operations, Planning, Logistics, and Finance and Administration (Fig. 4.2). The ICS organizational structure is modular, extending to incorporate all elements necessary for the type, size, scope, and complexity of a given incident. The HAZUS®MH
106
Thomas S. Durham with Pushpendra Johari and Douglas Bausch
team should become an integral part of the Planning Section under the Incident Command System, and provide analysis (pre- and post-disaster) on potential consequences of scenario earthquakes on the building stock, essential facilities, lifelines, and population.
Incident Command System Command
Public Information
Operations
Planning
Safety Officer
Logistics
Finance & Admin.
HAZUS-MH
Fig. 4.2. Use of HAZUS®MH in the Incident Command System
The systematic application of HAZUS®MH for catastrophic planning should be guided by two basic tenets: 1. Priorities for the application of HAZUS®MH need to be established by the user of the analysis (e.g., Command staff and Planning Section), with full understanding of the limitations and uncertainties of the model outputs. Experience in the use of HAZUS®MH for disaster operations continues to reinforce the importance of a user driven approach, including training of decision-makers in the potential uses of HAZUS®MH analysis to support decisions. 2. Technical oversight in the use of HAZUS®MH is critical to the effective use of the model for impact assessment and decision-support. In using HAZUS®MH for a major, damaging earthquake, it is important that technical oversight be provided, preferably by a team HAZUS®MH specialists with domain knowledge of the earthquake hazard, the loss estimation methodology, and model outputs.
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling
107
4.3.4 Planning for a Catastrophic Earthquake in the New Madrid Seismic Zone In 2006, FEMA announced the administration’s intentions to implement a 5-year catastrophic planning initiative – funded at approximately $20 million – to better prepare the nation for the consequences of catastrophic disasters. The first scenario to be addressed is a catastrophic earthquake in the New Madrid Seismic Zone (NMSZ). The NMSZ catastrophic planning initiative can provide an important national platform to demonstrate the capabilities of HAZUS®MH. Figure 4.3 highlights key HAZUS®MH outputs that can be used – for pre-disaster planning and post-disaster assessment and response – in a national catastrophic planning initiative.
Fig. 4.3. (This figure also appears in the color insert) Potential Applications of HAZUS®MH to Support Catastrophic Planning in the New Madrid Seismic Zone
108
Thomas S. Durham with Pushpendra Johari and Douglas Bausch
Potential Applications of HAZUS®MH to Support Catastrophic Planning in NMSZ: Rapid Needs Assessment & Response: x Area of impact from ground shaking and liquefaction. x Population at risk, including estimates of casualties, displaced households, and short-term shelter requirements. x Damage and loss of functionality to essential facilities (fire, police, hospitals, schools, emergency operations centers) x Damage and loss of functionality to transportation system, including bridges x Estimates of economic losses x Potential search and rescue missions Recovery Planning: x Estimates of debris (by category) x Loss Ratios x Estimates of residential damage x Estimates of commercial damage x Estimates of business interruption In the context of a New Madrid scenario, there are several important applications of HAZUS®MH to support catastrophic planning. Some of these applications require enhancements to the Earthquake Model. Two potential uses with high potential value to the NMSZ planning effort are highlighted below. 1. Use of HAZUS®MH to identify and quantify the population in the study region with disabilities, defined by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) as a broad range of people, including individuals who use wheelchairs or have other mobility disabilities; individuals who are blind or have low vision; individuals who are deaf, hard of hearing, or deaf-blind; as well as individuals with cognitive disabilities, psychiatric conditions, serious respiratory conditions, or other physical or mental impairments that substantially limit life activities. According to the 2000 Census, nearly 29% of American families include at least one person with a disability. As individuals with disabilities continue to live more independently and are more integrated into society, substantial improvement is necessary to integrate people with disabilities in emergency planning and readiness (U.S. Department of Homeland Security 2006). Acknowledging that special needs populations have significantly
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling
109
greater difficulties in coping with the consequences of disasters, the ability to incorporate this subset of the population into HAZUS®MH inventory and analysis would be an important contribution to emergency management planning. 2. Use of HAZUS®MH to estimate damage and loss of functionality to essential facilities. From a federal and state perspective, an “essential element of information” following a major disaster is the availability and functionality of hospitals and emergency services facilities and systems. A fundamental question becomes – when is it necessary for the federal government or state government to perform basic health and public safety services for an extended period of time because local government has become the victim and there is no capacity to perform essential services? Planning for a catastrophic New Madrid earthquake provides an opportunity to “push the envelope” in estimating the availability of essential facilities and lifelines – before and after a scenario event – and integrating this analysis into NIMS and the National Response Plan. This initiative should consider the following: 1) incorporation of HAZUS®MH analysis into training with Planning Section and Command staff under the NIMS, with emphasis given to treatment of uncertainties; 2) creation of standardized HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model analysis templates which can be used in training and disaster operations; 3) use of grid cells3 (e.g., census blocks) in aggregating data to improve resolution and increase accuracy of analysis; and 4) expansion of essential facility attribute data that is found in the HAZUS®MH inventory (e.g., bed capacity for hospitals), to include information for each essential facility that can be used by emergency managers in characterizing these facilities. Attribute data to be considered: updated contact information, specialized services or capabilities offered by the facility, and specialized resources that can be accessed. There is one major advantage to using HAZUS®MH to support analysis of damage and loss of functionality to essential facilities (and other analyses) – the model incorporates a national, uniform, standardized inventory of essential facilities, which is critical for multi-state analyses. The use of a uniform approach to assessing damage states of essential facilities promotes consistency in the use of the Earthquake Model from one state or Federal Region to another.
3 Wyoming and South Carolina are among the states that have used a grid cell (2 kilometer x 2 kilometer) approach to aggregating data – as opposed to aggregating by census tract – which improves resolution of analysis, addresses the “large census tract issue” (in large census tracts, analysis can appear distorted).
110
Thomas S. Durham with Pushpendra Johari and Douglas Bausch
To summarize, HAZUS®MH is a unique, nationally applicable loss estimation tool that can make a significant contribution to catastrophic planning and disaster response. As a regional loss estimation model, the strength and relative accuracy of HAZUS®MH matches well with analysis that is most needed immediately after an earthquake, including: area of impact; exposure and damage to essential facilities; quantification of population exposed to the earthquake hazard; estimates of shelter requirements; and identification and mapping of areas with moderate to high probability of search and rescue mission requirements (due to high concentrations of unreinforced masonry structures and other vulnerable buildings).
4.4 Use of HAZUS®MH to Link Risk Assessment, Mitigation and Disaster Response FEMA’s catastrophic planning initiative presents an opportunity to reexamine our nation’s approach to planning for and responding to hazard events (natural, technological or human caused) that generate extraordinary casualties, damages and economic disruption. In the final analysis, the ability of our society to respond to and recover from these events – including a catastrophic earthquake – is in large part a function of the disaster resilience of our population and the built environment (buildings, systems, infrastructure) that supports our daily routines at home and the workplace. Investments in stronger buildings, better prepared populations, and disaster resilient lifelines will reduce the burden on government at all levels to respond to major disasters. In essence, mitigation should become an integral component of the catastrophic planning equation. In this context, HAZUS®MH can become an important tool in assessing damage and losses avoided through the adoption of specific mitigation measures for buildings and lifelines, as follows: x Physical Damage - Buildings - Contents - Infrastructure - Landscaping - Site contamination x Loss of Function / Economic Impacts - Loss of business income - Loss of rental income - Lost wages
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling
111
Shelter costs Disruption time for residents - Loss of public services - Economic impacts associated with loss of transportation and utility functions x Casualties - Deaths - Injuries - Illnesses x Emergency Management Costs - Emergency Operations Center costs - Evacuation / Rescue costs - Debris removal and cleanup costs - Temporary measures costs -
-
An initiative to use HAZUS®MH to systematically integrate mitigation into the catastrophic planning process should include the following elements: 1. Formation of a multidisciplinary advisory team with expertise in the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model (including the Advanced Earthquake Building Module), seismic/structural engineering, buildingspecific damage and loss functions, and functional planning under the National Incident Management System. The objective is to provide a forum for HAZUS®MH specialists with domain knowledge of the Earthquake Model and its uncertainties, and key users of the analysis for catastrophic planning for earthquakes. This initiative should be coordinated with: 1) The Infrastructure Security Partnership (TISP) and the Task Force on Regional Disaster Resilience; and 2) the Multihazard Mitigation Council (MMC).4 2. Selection of three pilot sites – California, the Central U.S, and Utah’s Wasach Front – to evaluate and document the use of the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model to support catastrophic earthquake planning, and specifically the value of investing in vulnerability reduction measures to increase response and recovery capacities.
4 The MMC, a council of the National Institute of Building Sciences (NIBS), completed a landmark study, Natural Hazard Mitigation Saves: An Independent Study to Assess the Future Savings from Mitigation, which used HAZUS®MH to estimate direct property damage from earthquakes and hurricanes, and used these estimates to determine future losses avoided through mitigation.
112
Thomas S. Durham with Pushpendra Johari and Douglas Bausch
3. Collaboration with the FEMA catastrophic planning team to identify “most critical” of essential facilities relative to capacity to respond to a major earthquake. The ability of state and local government to effectively respond to a catastrophic disaster will be a function in large part of the availability of hospitals, public health departments, emergency response agencies, shelters and other facilities in the “emergency management system.” The objective of this task is to systematically identify and prioritize facilities and systems that – by virtue of their role and function in urban or regional response to a catastrophic earthquake – are most critical. Collection of this information, which can be incorporated into the HAZUS®MH inventory, should involve federal, state and local emergency managers. 4. Add a display feature to the existing library of capacity curves and fragility curves for the Earthquake Model to enable planners, engineers and others to assess potential losses from earthquakes based on the properties of a specific building type. The HAZUS®MH Hurricane Model, for example, enables the user to view building damage functions for all model building types. The model displays graphs of the probabilities of four different damage states for buildings, contents, or combined ratios for each wind building type as a function of peak gust wind. A similar display feature for the library of building loss curves for the Earthquake Model would be an excellent reference for HAZUS®MH users and emergency managers. A user-friendly collection of building loss curves would provide decision-makers with a readily available reference in identifying most vulnerable structures at specified levels of ground shaking, and to use this information in prioritization of mitigation measures. A library of building loss curves also needs to address the vulnerability of buildings and lifelines to ground deformation. This aspect of the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model needs to be updated in light of the extensive engineering work completed at the Nation’s earthquake engineering centers and under National Science Foundation programs. In addition, the body on knowledge associated with vulnerability of the built environment to ground deformation in a catastrophic earthquake is relatively small compared to the body of research of the interaction of ground motions and the built environment. The level of research that assesses ground deformation influences is out of balance with the large contribution to losses, functionality, and utility and transportation impacts as a result of ground deformation in scenario earthquakes.
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling
113
5. Identify and prioritize mitigation measures to enhance the functionality of essential facilities and in the process increase the capacity of federal, state and local governments to respond to major or catastrophic earthquakes. Ultimately, the goal of this initiative is to provide federal, state and local emergency managers with: 1) HAZUS®MH inventory of “most critical” of essential facilities that are instrumental to urban and/or regional response to a major earthquake or other catastrophic disaster; 2) HAZUS®MH analyses that quantifies losses avoided as a result of the implementation of mitigation measures for high value essential facilities; and 3) analysis of enhancements to local and state capacity to respond as a result of the implementation of mitigation measures. The analysis should follow the functional approach (Emergency Support Functions or ESFs) to planning that is incorporated into the National Response Plan, including: x x x x x x
Transportation (ESF #1) Communications (ESF #2) Public Works and Engineering (ESF #3) Firefighting (ESF #4) Mass Care, Housing and Human Services (ESF #6) Public Health and Medical Services(ESF #8)
4.5 Utilization of a Web-Based Data Management Portal System Although HAZUS®MH was not originally developed as an emergency response tool, important developments have occurred since the 1994 Northridge earthquake to integrate the HAZUS®MH methodology with real-time information technologies to provide decision support following a earthquake (Eisner 2000). The California Office of Emergency Services has developed an interface between HAZUS®MH and ShakeMap, a web-based application that provides shaking intensity and ground motion in near realtime. This interface provides the California OES with a rapid, accurate and useful set of data for emergency response. In the Central and Eastern U.S., where soil and other conditions contribute to a seismic hazard that extends over a much broader region, a different approach to data management and the use of HAZUS®MH is being contemplated. A proposed HAZUS®MH Web-based Data Management Portal System is guided by the following objectives:
114
Thomas S. Durham with Pushpendra Johari and Douglas Bausch
1. To identify, prioritize and incorporate new datasets for User Defined Facilities that will provide a significantly more robust HAZUS®MH inventory. South Carolina, for example, has identified 14 additional categories of facilities and demographic data that the Emergency Management Division intends to add to the existing statewide HAZUS®MH inventory. These datasets will significantly improve risk assessment and planning in high risk coastal areas of the state. 2. To develop a data management system for HAZUS®MH that enables the user to place default and Level 2 inventory data in existing webbased portals for designated users. This will facilitate access to the data from multiple HAZUS®MH users (including state and local governments), and enable users to update the inventory data on a routine basis. 3. To refine the HAZUS®MH data management system to enable users to download and distribute pre-built study regions to federal, state and local governments to facilitate and expedite post-earthquake analysis of damages and losses. This capability is critical to the use of HAZUS®MH for earthquake impact assessment and response planning in the Central and Eastern U.S. Options include the development of a library of “HAZUS®MH runs” for a range of scenarios that can be accessed by FEMA and impacted states following an actual earthquake, and used to estimate casualties, damages and losses. 4. To prepare and test standard operating procedures for uploading, downloading, and managing HAZUS®MH datasets and analyses for disaster operations. To incorporate the HAZUS®MH Web-based Data Management Portal System into the Planning Section under the Incident Command System, and to utilize this capability during disaster exercises. The objective is to ultimately institutionalize the use of HAZUS®MH for risk assessment and emergency management planning. To train HAZUS®MH users to use this system to quickly assess damages and losses from earthquakes, floods and hurricanes. When fully implemented, the proposed HAZUS®MH data management system will provide planners and decision makers with a unique capability for risk assessment and response planning. In the process, the system will address some of the key issues identified in the Nationwide Plan Review (U.S. Department of Homeland Security 2006).
4 Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling
115
4.6 Conclusions HAZUS®MH has two core features that make the model totally unique: 1) the national inventory of building stock, lifelines, essential facilities and population that enable the user to characterize the exposure of our 50 states to earthquakes, hurricanes and flood hazards; and 2) the capability to quantify damage and losses over a multi-state area. There is an unprecedented opportunity to apply the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model and the enhancements that are outlined in this paper to support the catastrophic planning initiative. In assessing and prioritizing the potential uses of HAZUS®MH, a useful starting point is the findings of the Nationwide Plan Review, an excellent baseline study that identifies significant problems, issues and deficiencies in catastrophic planning in the 50 states and 75 urban areas. Finally, the Mitigation Directorate – in coordination with the National Institute of Building Sciences – can play an important role in supporting the FEMA’s catastrophic planning initiative through the use of HAZUS®MH. An understanding of the performance of essential facilities and lifelines in earthquakes, and the role of mitigation in reducing building damage and loss of functionality, can become an important dimension in the catastrophic planning program. The Mitigation Directorate can take the lead in demonstrating the return on investment in mitigation, expressed as the increase in federal, state, and local government capacity to respond and recover from major or catastrophic disasters. HAZUS®MH can become an important tool in this effort.
References Applied Technology Council (2003) Guidelines for using strong-motion data and shakemaps in post-earthquake response (ATC-54). Applied Technology Council, Redwood City, California Earthquake Engineering Research Institute (2006) Managing risk in earthquake country. Publication of the 100th anniversary earthquake conference - 1906 San Francisco earthquake. Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, San Francisco Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), National Institute of Building Sciences (NIBS) (2003) HAZUS®MH MR1 Technical Manual. Federal Emergency Management Agency, Washington, DC Goltz J, Eisner R (2003) Real-time emergency management decision support: The California Integrated Seismic Network (CISN). In: Proceedings of the Disaster Resistant California National Institute of Building Sciences (2003) A guide to using HAZUS® for mitigation. NIBS, Washington, DC
116
Thomas S. Durham with Pushpendra Johari and Douglas Bausch
National Institute of Building Sciences (2005) Natural hazard mitigation saves: An independent study to assess the future savings from mitigation activities. Multihazard Mitigation Council, Washington, DC The Infrastructure Security Partnership (TISP) (2006) Regional disaster resilience: A guide for developing an action plan, Reston, VA U.S. Department of Homeland Security (2006) Nationwide plan review: Phase 2 report. FEMA, Washington, DC U.S. Department of Justice (2004) An ADA guide for local governments: Making community emergency preparedness and response programs accessible to people with disabilities. U.S. Department of Justice, Washington, DC
5 Perspectives on Development and Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
Responses to Durham’s paper “Strategic Directions in Seismic Modeling”
Introduction The commentaries in this chapter represent three important perspectives: academic research in earthquake engineering; the federal agency that sponsors and oversees HAZUS®; and expert users. Rachel Davidson fills in some gaps in the background and suggests directions for the development of HAZUS®, including improving its mitigation planning capability and structural inventory data, as well as providing for web-based user overrides based on post-catastrophe observations. Phil Schneider presents several examples of user-driven developments in HAZUS® and the role of users in pushing forward improvements and enhancements that are currently in the works, by members of the self-established user/developer consortia. Finally, Subrahmanyam Muthukumar, an expert HAZUS® user, confirms Schneider’s proposition that user input based on experience with applications of the software provide significant pull for its development. Muthukumar suggests several improvements to HAZUS®, including more dynamic inventory data, better cost-benefit analysis capability, and lifeline/network models integrated into the overall system. In considering these perspectives it helps to keep in mind the purposes for which HAZUS® was developed and the institutional context in which it functions. Future development of HAZUS® and its potentially expanded role in catastrophe planning should proceed with input by the earthquake community.
118
Rachel Davidson
5.1 Recommended Improvements for HAZUS®MH Rachel Davidson Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, USA
5.1.1 Introduction The chapter by Durham, Johari, and Bausch discusses an “approach to fully integrating the HAZUS®MH Earthquake Model into FEMA’s catastrophic planning initiative, with specific recommendations on model enhancements that will strengthen this national planning effort.” In this section, I first comment on the text of the paper directly, then discuss some possible directions for the development of HAZUS®MH, building on ideas from the paper. 5.1.2 Comments on the Paper The ideas presented in the chapter by Durham et al. are useful guides for taking full advantage of HAZUS®MH. In such discussions, it is helpful to clarify definitions of key concepts (e.g., mitigation, resilience) and use them consistently. For example, one might define four main phases of the disaster cycle: (1) mitigation includes efforts to reduce losses long before an event, (2) preparedness includes efforts shortly before an event to reduce losses and prepare for the post-event period, (3) response includes efforts in the immediate aftermath of an event, and (4) recovery refers to post-disaster efforts in the longer-term. Pinpointing more specifically which aspect of the disaster cycle – mitigation, preparedness, response, and recovery – each proposed initiative would address can help tighten and strengthen the arguments. Another approach is to consider resilience as a central term, as is becoming more common. For example, using the Multidisciplinary Center for Earthquake Engineering Research (MCEER) definition of resilience as a function of robustness, rapidity, resourcefulness, redundancy (Bruneau et al. 2003), one could identify which aspect of resilience an effort aims to address. Is its aim to help reduce the immediate loss (improve robustness) or reduce the time to recover from them (improve rapidity)? Linking specific types of HAZUS®MH output to specific users and
5 Perspectives on Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
119
specific uses more directly and comprehensively could similarly clarify the arguments. It is not always clear which features of HAZUS®MH described in the chapter are already functional and which are proposed enhancements. For example, in the NMSZ initiative related to essential facilities and in the initiative to integrate mitigation into the catastrophic planning process, it is not clear which of the items listed are available and which are proposed improvements. The paper covers many topics in a short space, but could be improved with further development of some of ideas. For example, in explaining how mitigation can be integrated into planning in Section III, the authors suggest adding a feature to HAZUS®MH that would allow the user to display the library of capacity and fragility curves. While this would likely be a useful capability, it is but one piece of what would be required to enable HAZUS®MH to be used more effectively for mitigation planning. Perhaps more challenging issues include the current inability of HAZUS®MH to map physical mitigation projects (e.g., adding shear walls to a structure) to changes in the model parameters, to provide information about costs of various mitigation alternatives, or to acknowledge the many competing objectives and constraints that a user may have. In a few places, “unique features” or “advantages” of HAZUS®MH are mentioned. It is never really clear, however, to what alternative HAZUS®MH is being compared. Some of the most important distinguishing features of HAZUS®MH are assumed, such as that it is multihazard, comprehensive in the losses it estimates, in the public domain, and supported by FEMA. In the discussion of essential facilities in the NMSZ initiative, the need to emphasize the treatment of uncertainties and the idea of aggregating data by grid cells instead of census area units are both potentially important, but are only mentioned in passing. In the same section, the need to improve treatment of disabled populations is discussed, but other disproportionately vulnerable populations (e.g., the poor and children) are not. It might help to include a little more background on some topics in the paper, such as, NIMS, the National Response Plan (DHS 2004a), and the New Madrid Seismic Zone initiative. Background on how HAZUS®MH has been used successfully and why some organizations have chosen not to use it, would help motivate proposals for the future. The HAZUS® Annual Progress and Utilization Report for Fiscal Year 2004 offers some information in that regard, although it does not provide much insight into observed impediments to HAZUS® adoption (FEMA 2004).
120
Rachel Davidson
5.1.3 Directions for Development and Challenges Associated with Each
Identifying directions for development
Before discussing possible directions for future development of HAZUS®MH, it is worth commenting on the process used to identify and prioritize those directions. Directions for future development should emerge from the intersection of unmet user needs and technical feasibility. One could systematically consider specific users and the specific decisions they make (e.g., a local government planning identifying shelters for use after a catastrophic earthquake) and identify ways in which their ability to make those decisions could be improved. As before, decisions might relate to any of the phases of the disaster cycle (e.g., mitigation, response), the different dimensions of resilience (e.g., improving robustness or rapidity), and multiple hazards. In addition to improvements in the capabilities of the software itself, directions for development might relate to improvements in the way HAZUS®MH is supported (training, distribution) or used in the catastrophic planning process. Future surveys of HAZUS®MH users and potential users, like that in the HAZUS® Annual Progress and Utilization Report (FEMA 2004), could be used to better understand the users’ perspective on HAZUS®MH and the obstacles to its being used to its full potential. From the technical feasibility point-of-view, the limitations of HAZUS®MH can be identified (e.g., data requirements) and developments can be planned to help overcome them. In the following sections, I present a few potential directions, from the technical feasibility point-of-view and based on my assumptions about users’ needs. No attempt is made to prioritize these suggestions or assess the difficulty of implementing them. They are intended as fodder for discussion. Improve ability of HAZUS®MH to support mitigation planning
The capabilities of HAZUS®MH could be extended to support mitigation decision-making more directly. Mitigation is fundamental to reducing risk. In most cases, mitigation is more cost-effective than waiting until after an earthquake and paying for reconstruction. And deaths and injuries, psychological trauma, and other types of impact can only be lessened by preventing the damage from occurring in the first place. As the previous chapter explains, HAZUS®MH has the potential to help link risk assessment, mitigation, and disaster response. It was not originally intended to support mitigation decision-making, however, so currently HAZUS®MH can only be
5 Perspectives on Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
121
used with a trial-and-error approach to evaluate mitigation alternatives (FEMA 2002). Losses can be estimated with and without implementation of a particular mitigation alternative to evaluate the alternative’s effectiveness. The relative costs of the alternatives, the budget and other constraints, and the specific objectives are not incorporated, and only a small set of pre-defined mitigation alternatives can be considered. It is difficult to directly simulate the implementation of specific mitigation efforts, such as base isolating a steel frame structure or bracing the cripple walls of a wood frame house, in the model. Dodo et al. (2005) summarize different efforts to support mitigation decision-making with engineering models, and with Dodo et al. (2007) and Xu et al. (2007), introduces an optimization-based approach to allocating regional earthquake mitigation resources that builds on the current capabilities of HAZUS®MH. Improve structural inventory data
The structural inventory data used in HAZUS®MH could be improved, in its representation of both the current built environment and the built environment as it will exist at some future time at which the next earthquake occurs. The output of any HAZUS®MH analysis is only as good as the data on which it is based, and at least some portions of that data are known to include substantial errors. The use of remote sensing technology in disaster management has been advancing rapidly in the last several years; one potential use is developing more accurate building inventory data (e.g., Sarabandi et al. 2005). The use of remote sensing for improving inventory data could be explored. Further, the number, locations, value, and vulnerability of structures in a region change over time, sometimes rapidly, due to population and economic growth, urbanization, building code changes, changing construction practices, structural aging, and other factors. All of those changes can affect the losses that will result if the structures are subjected to an earthquake. If mitigation and response plans are developed using a HAZUS®MH analysis based on the current building inventory, the inventory, and therefore the losses, may be very different by the time the next earthquake occurs, say 50 years in the future. Failure to incorporate the dynamics of the built environment may result in loss estimation models that misestimate losses, thereby compromising any risk management plans that are based on those estimates. Focusing on regional hurricane risk, Jain et al. (2005), Davidson and Rivera (2003) and Jain and Davidson (2007a, 2007b) offer one approach to incorporate the dynamics of the built environment that could be integrated with HAZUS®MH. Alternatively, several scenarios of inventory change (e.g., rapid development vs. a static inventory) could be
122
Rachel Davidson
included to provide output that reflects the range of possible losses when changes in the built environment are considered. Develop web-based data management system for HAZUS®MH
As presented in the Durham et al. paper, a web-based data management system for HAZUS®MH could be developed to facilitate sharing of data and analysis results among many participants in all phases of the disaster planning cycle. This could be an excellent way to minimize duplication of data collection effort and improve communication among the participants in the catastrophic planning process. Beyond the technical challenges involved in developing such as system, effort would be required, for example, to develop a protocol to determine who would be allowed to modify the data and to ensure that it would be available immediately after an earthquake to support emergency response activities when electric power service may be interrupted. In using such a web-based system to support real-time catastrophe response (or even in HAZUS®MH as it currently is), one could also consider including a feature that would allow the user to begin with the HAZUS®MH-generated damage and loss estimates, then gradually override those estimates with observations of actual damage from the field as they become available. Updates could continue as subsequent repairs are made, thus capturing the changes in information about the situation as well as changes in the actual situation throughout the post-earthquake period. The HAZUS®MH environment would be used to record damage and loss in addition to estimating it before and immediately after an event. Some type of Bayesian updating features might be possible as well to update the initial HAZUS®MH damage estimates everywhere based on limited initial observations. That type of capability would be more difficult to implement and may not be as useful as the simple ability to override estimates with actual observations of damage and loss. 5.1.4 Present Uncertainties Explicitly The uncertainties in HAZUS®MH loss estimates could be quantified and presented to the user. Because of randomness in earthquake and damage occurrence, and modeling and data uncertainty, there is necessarily a great deal of uncertainty surrounding any loss estimate. While most people probably recognize that to some extent, greater effort could be made to clarify the magnitude and character of the uncertainty to HAZUS®MH users so that it would be more difficult to ignore it when using the results of
5 Perspectives on Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
123
HAZUS®MH analyses in supporting decisions. Such an effort would admittedly be difficult to undertake as it is not straightforward to determine how much uncertainty there is in a given output or to determine the best way to present it in a way that is helpful for decision support.
5.2 User Dynamics and HAZUS® Development Philip J. Schneider National Institute of Building Sciences, Washington, DC, USA
5.2.1 Introduction This review of the paper, HAZUS® Development and Current Directions for Catastrophic Planning, addresses the relationship of user dynamics to HAZUS® development. The HAZUS® program is now 14 years old. HAZUS®MH MR2, the seventh version of the Earthquake Model, was released in June 2006 by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). HAZUS® development, which is managed for FEMA by the National Institute of Building Sciences (NIBS), has involved expert consultants overseen by an Earthquake Committee consisting of nationally recognized experts. Robert Whitman, Professor Emeritus at MIT, was its first Chairman, and is now the Chairman Emeritus. William Holmes, Rutherford and Chekene, is the current chair. PBS&J serves as the principal consultant for the Earthquake Model. 5.2.2 User-Driven Development Within HAZUS® Users have played a central role in HAZUS® development. When HAZUS® development began, a 30-member project oversight committee of stakeholders was convened to define HAZUS® functionality. After the software was developed, two pilot tests of HAZUS® usability were conducted – the first in Portland, Oregon, in 1995 and the second in Boston, Massachusetts, in 1996. Pilot testing also was conducted at a 1996 training workshop for the emergency managers from the 50 states. Since HAZUS® was first released in 1997, technical support and training work-
124
Philip J. Schneider
shops have been ongoing and twenty-one HAZUS® consortia (http://www.HAZUS.org) have formed. Each furnishes an ongoing stream of suggested user improvements for HAZUS® with the most useful comments coming from users involved in HAZUS® applications, especially during the past three years. 5.2.3 Studies for FEMA Examples of these HAZUS® applications include FEMA’s 2001 national annualized loss study (FEMA 2001; Fig. 5.1), which is now being updated using the latest version of HAZUS®. HAZUS® also was used in the NIBS Multihazard Mitigation Council independent assessment of future savings from mitigation activities (Multihazard Mitigation Council 2006), which is notable for determining the metric that every $1 spent in mitigation represents $4 in future savings. HAZUS® was used to estimate losses following earthquakes in Seattle (Nisqually, 2001) and San Simeon (2003).
Fig. 5.1. (This figure also appears in the color insert) State Level Losses map from the annualized loss report (FEMA 2001) showing the relative level of risk across the country based on a standard form of hazard analysis and inventory.
5 Perspectives on Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
125
5.2.4 State Studies A multistate HAZUS® study was conducted in 2005 with the Central U.S. Earthquake Consortium (CUSEC), FEMA, and USGS for catastrophic planning purposes. This study involved simulating the 1811–1812 earthquakes in the New Madrid earthquake fault region (Fig. 5.2). HAZUS® also is being used by many states to develop state mitigation plans as part of the pursuit for funding under the Disaster Management Act of 2000.
Fig. 5.2. (This figure also appears in the color insert) Estimated total county building loss (CUSEC 2005) from an earthquake scenario in the New Madrid Region (reprinted with permission from CUSEC)
5.2.5 Regional Studies A significant study of earthquake risks and mitigation in the tri-state New York City metropolitan area was conducted by Princeton (Tantala et al. 2005). A similar study for the San Francisco Bay area was conducted in 2003 (Fig. 5.3).
126
Philip J. Schneider
Fig. 5.3. Output from the San Francisco Bay earthquake risk and mitigation study meant to raise awareness
5.2.6 New Directions for Development from HAZUS® Applications Lessons learned from conducting the above studies have stimulated improvements in HAZUS® since the multihazard version of HAZUS®, HAZUS®MH, was released in February 2004. The annualized loss studies revealed that the HAZUS® valuation figures needed to be revised on a regional basis, which was accomplished in HAZUS®MH MR2. The rapid loss assessments in Washington and California demonstrated the need to run HAZUS® faster so that an analysis can be completed in a reasonable amount of time for response purposes. As a result, the Earthquake Model now has considerably improved speed. The USGS Shake Maps used in these events can now be ported into HAZUS® with the geodatabase format provided by ArcGIS. The tri-state New York study provided the impetus to customize building types within HAZUS® and to facilitate bringing in new building types, such as those found in New York City, San Francisco, and other large metropolitan areas. Further work in New York since the tri-state study has spurred improvement in the Building Inventory Tool (BIT). A data man-
5 Perspectives on Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
127
agement system has been initiated to improve adding Level 2 user-supplied data in HAZUS®. Grid analysis is an older HAZUS® improvement that resulted from state studies in FEMA Regions VIII and X. For western states with large census tracts, grid analysis more accurately locates ground shaking and losses by assigning values to cells instead of spreading them evenly over a single large census tract. 5.2.7 Conclusion – Push and Pull HAZUS® Development and Current Directions for Catastrophic Planning demonstrates the need for new HAZUS® technology for catastrophic planning – for example, implementing HAZUS® on the internet. The need for a catastrophic planning application and related HAZUS® development to support it represents the push into this new area. HAZUS® applications, once conducted, create the pull by their users for new development in the HAZUS® model that began with the original push by the earlier user groups. A dynamic between the push created by the need for applications and the pull that comes from users in applications continues to create new directions for HAZUS®. FEMA supports changes that are based on user demand.
5.3 Perspectives from a HAZUS® User Subrahmanyam Muthukumar Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA
5.3.1 Current Catastrophe Planning As an experienced HAZUS® user, some of my questions are detail oriented and assume a certain familiarity with HAZUS®. At Georgia Tech, we’ve done some projects looking at emergency response and incident management application software in place at the local and state level. It would be helpful to have an Application Programming Interface (API) where you could send HAZUS® products directly into the incident management ap-
128
Subrahmanyam Muthukumar
plication software to facilitate the distribution of those products to operations and logistics. When we worked in the hurricane section at FEMA in 2004 I made maps and printed labels, used HAZUS® outputs, and transferred them physically – copying and pasting into another folder. Logistics or operations would take it from there and print or email the resulting products. That takes time and is inefficient. Right now we have an extensive default inventory and demographic data based on the 2000 census, but we can’t wait every 10 years for the numbers to change. Mechanisms should be put in place within HAZUS® to allow for projections of demographic data, leading to changes in the buildings and materials in the inventory. 5.3.2 Risk Assessment, Mitigation and Disaster Response – Suggestions for HAZUS® Development A recurring theme in Durham et al.’s chapter is Essential Facilities. Essential Facilities change according to the requirements of the local population, so they are fairly dynamic. There are several comprehensive (and incredibly expensive) databases available that are frequently updated, on a monthly or quarterly basis, and contain information on hospital beds, clinics, location of doctors, etc. One such database is available for $180,000 per year. So such data are available, but how could the federal government obtain these data and make them part of the default inventory? HAZUS® does quantify losses well, but currently does not have the capacity to incorporate costs of mitigation measures, or to perform fullfledged benefit-costs analyses for various mitigation scenarios. How could these capacities be incorporated into HAZUS®? Analyzing the sensitivity of base scenarios to different building inventory characteristics currently takes a long time. One potential solution is to use existing research from insurance companies and come up with a set of parameters for creating fragility curves on the fly. Fragility curve sensitivity analyses would come from changing the inventory scenario; the cost of that change scenario would be incorporated into the cost analysis. Last is the glaring need to incorporate the interdependencies of transportation and lifeline systems into HAZUS®. At present the Transportation and Lifeline Systems are standalone systems. Leonardo Dueñas-Osorio (e.g., Dueñas Osorio 2004; 2006) has done some excellent work in looking at the interdependencies of these systems. Say the electrical system fails, then a pumping station doesn’t work and therefore you don’t get water.
5 Perspectives on Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
129
This all comes together in an earthquake scenario. This is a good opportunity to incorporate outside research into HAZUS®. There is no transportation network capability in HAZUS®, though it exists in ArcGIS. If HAZUS® is sitting on top of ArcGIS as its platform, then there is strong potential to use it, especially for response. If your study region is seven states, of course you can’t have street level for all seven states, but you can incorporate transportation information at the scale of arterials or highways. If you’re looking at a study region of a particular county then you can include street-level detail and use that in a transportation network model. This would be useful for emergency response, to magnify the accessibility of various locations within a study area, and therefore the accessibility of various populations or subgroups of populations to hospitals, fire stations, emergency facilities, during the response phase. The network model would be useful to quantify direct and indirect business interruption losses and long-term losses.
5.4 Strategic Directions for HAZUS® and Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning The open-source, U.S. government-sponsored hazard modeling software, HAZUS® (Hazards U.S.) is the de facto tool for local, state, and federal agencies for catastrophe planning. In the 14 years since its initial release, HAZUS® has grown largely through the input and custom development of its users. In the previous chapter, Tom Durham, along with colleagues who have been closely involved with the development and application of this important tool, provided an overview of the framework and methodologies in HAZUS®, as well as its organizational role in the Incident Command System. Durham also presented examples of potential applications of HAZUS® to support catastrophic planning and several suggestions for improving the software through collaborative, user-driven development. The perspectives in this chapter highlight some of the highest priorities for HAZUS® development. The HAZUS® program is rapidly evolving in response to the needs of and input from its diverse users. In addition to the evolution of the software and technical models, the role of HAZUS® in catastrophe planning has expanded and changed in the years since its initial release. There may be some value in reconsidering the appropriate organizational placement of HAZUS® to more fully utilize its capabilities, but awareness of its original intent and inherent limitations should be taken into account. Nevertheless, there is significant potential for improving
130
Subrahmanyam Muthukumar
HAZUS® by developing the data inventory in HAZUS®, better integrating the core program with modules to address concerns such as network disruptions and the needs of special populations, and developing outputs customized for specific uses and users with varying levels of familiarity with this type of information. The users of HAZUS® provide strong promotion and support for development of the software. An eye toward user needs in catastrophe planning should continue to guide its direction into the future. Although originally designed as a scenario development tool to estimate potential losses from natural hazards, recently HAZUS® has been used for mitigation. HAZUS® could play an important role in mitigating losses by providing cost-benefit analyses for various mitigation alternatives. However, the models in HAZUS® aren’t necessarily in the right form for looking at specific mitigation measures to realize cost savings in a straightforward manner. HAZUS® will have to evolve further in order to be more useable as a mitigation tool. Additionally, HAZUS® may be more appropriate as a mitigation tool at the state level, rather than at the federal level. The most appropriate placement for HAZUS® within organizations – either under Planning in the Incident Command System (ICS) or higher up, directly connected to Command – is an open question. HAZUS® is important and useful for situational awareness in ICS. It is unclear whether the currently limited use of HAZUS® is due to technical or institutional limitations. Those making policy decisions need analytic tools. Probabilistic hazard analysis is not currently being used. The outputs from probabilistic analyses may not be useful to (understandable by) those users who need it for planning. There is an institutional disconnect between mitigation and response in FEMA/DHS; these problems are not primarily technical, but institutional. FEMA has been reduced staff-wise and is a much smaller organization than it was ten years ago. Additionally, HAZUS® hasn’t been marketed well within FEMA itself. There is an effort underway to “spread the word” within FEMA about the types of analyses available through use of the software. Disaster planning focuses more now on response to floods and hurricanes rather than on mitigation, with little focus on earthquake planning. This is due in part to current events (major hurricanes in 2005 and very few large earthquakes in the US in the past decade), but is also institutional. The use of HAZUS® has also expanded into the area of disaster response; key to succeeding with this is increasing the speed at which scenarios can be run. Further, there is a widely recognized need for a greatly improved structural inventory database in HAZUS® to support more accurate analyses. Publicly available sources of data about the built environment are incomplete or infrequently updated, and private sources are expensive. Web-based data management and output delivery could provide a
5 Perspectives on Current Applications for Catastrophe Planning
131
boon to users in terms of improved communication and flexibility to use on-the-ground observations in place of program defaults. Daytime and nighttime population distribution information is available from Oak Ridge National Lab (Landscan – http://www.ornl.gov/ sci/landscan/) but is not currently in HAZUS®. In order to do pre-event planning, this type of information is needed for accurate analyses that account for time of day. This may be an example of another institutional disconnect, since the information is available, but not integrated into HAZUS®, though there are proposals to do so. Use of improved and more realistic data sets makes the output more useful, believable, and accepted. Some consultants have had experience connecting better developed data sets to HAZUS® (as opposed to the default data sets) with success in generating better outputs. It may not be appropriate to mesh other software with HAZUS®, nor to use it for recovery. HAZUS® was developed for and is best used in planning for mitigation, not for human services recovery. It would take a major investment, including major advances in inventory data, in order to make HAZUS® appropriate for those purposes and fully functional for response-focused users. Presenting responders with HAZUS® in the midst of disaster recovery is potentially problematic. Additionally, users who are not familiar with HAZUS® may not trust it (Tom Durham has had this experience with Red Cross, for example) and if not, will not use the outputs. Expanding the role of HAZUS® in catastrophe planning, mitigation, and response must proceed with caution as increasingly sophisticated analyses may not necessarily serve the needs of those decision-makers who are ultimately responsible for using HAZUS® outputs to make choices that affect the lives and assets of many people. In order for HAZUS® to be used effectively for mitigation and response, software development and user training should go hand-in-hand. The appropriate organizational placement of HAZUS® is an important consideration in its effectiveness as well – its current placement within FEMA/DHS may not serve users well. Finally, improving the completeness and accuracy of the structural inventory and population data, implementing mechanisms for future updates, and integrating modules for network capability to better model disaster impacts on transportation and lifeline systems would greatly improve HAZUS® outputs.
132
Subrahmanyam Muthukumar
References Bruneau M, Chang S, Eguchi R, Lee G, O’Rourke T, Reinhorn A, Shinozuka M, Tierney K, Wallace A, von Winterfeldt D (2003) A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities. Earthquake Spectra 19:733–752 Davidson R, Rivera M (2003) Projecting changes in the Carolina building inventory and their effect on hurricane risk. Journal of Urban Planning and Development 129:211–230 Dodo A, Davidson R, Xu N, Nozick L (2007) Application of regional earthquake mitigation optimization. Computers and Operations Research Dodo A, Xu N, Davidson R, Nozick L (2005) Optimizing regional earthquake mitigation investment strategies. Earthquake Spectra 21:305–327 Dueñas-Osorio L, Craig JI, Goodno BJ (2004) Probabilistic response of interdependent infrastructure networks In: Proceedings of the 2nd annual meeting of the Asian-Pacific Network of Centers for Earthquake Engineering Research (ANCER) Dueñas-Osorio L, Leelardcharoen K, Craig JI, Goodno BJ (2006) Failure of interdependent networks. In: Proceedings of the 8th National Conference in Earthquake Engineering (8NCEE) Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) (2001) HAZUS®99 estimated annualized earthquake loss for the United States (FEMA 366). Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), Jessup, MD Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) (2002) Guide to using HAZUS®for mitigation. FEMA, Washington, DC Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) (2004) HAZUS annual progress and utilization report for fiscal year 2004. FEMA, Washington, DC Jain V, Davidson R (2007a) Application of a regional hurricane wind risk forecasting model for wood-frame houses. Risk Analysis 27(1):45–58 Jain V, Davidson R (2007b) Forecasting changes in the hurricane wind vulnerability of a building inventory. Journal of Infrastructure Systems 13(1):1–12 Jain V, Davidson R, Rosowsky D (2005) Modeling changes in hurricane risk over time. Natural Hazards Review 6:88–96 Multihazard Mitigation Council (2006) Hazard mitigation saves: An independent study to assess the future savings from mitigation activities. National Institute of Building Sciences (NIBS), Washington, DC Sarabandi P, Adams B, Kiremidjian A, Eguchi R (2005) Infrastructure inventory compi