Ring Theory Volume I1
This is volume 128 in PURE AND APPLIED MATHEMATICS H. Bass and S. Eilenberg, editors A list of ...
22 downloads
1327 Views
23MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Ring Theory Volume I1
This is volume 128 in PURE AND APPLIED MATHEMATICS H. Bass and S. Eilenberg, editors A list of titles in this series appears at the end of this volume.
Ring Theory Volume I1
Louis H. Rowen Department of Mathematics and Computer Science Bar Ilan University Ramat Gan. Israel
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
Boston San Diego New York Berkeley London Sydney Tokyo Toronto
Copyright 0 1988 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. 1250 Sixth Avenue, San Diego, CA 92101
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24-28 Oval Road, London NW1 7DX
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Rowen, Louis Halle. Ring theory. (Pure and applied mathematics; v. 127-128) Includes bibliographies and indexes. 1. Rings (Algebra) I. Title. 11. Series: Pure and applied mathematics (Academic Press); 127- 128. QA3.P8 VOI. 127-128 510 s [512’.4] 87-14536 CQA2471 ISBN 0-12-599841-4(v. 1) ISBN 0-12-599842-2 (v. 2)
88899091 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America
Contents Introduction To Volume I1 Table of Principal Notation for Volume I1
xi
...
Xlll
Chapter 5 Homology and Cohomology
1
5.0 Preliminaries about Diagrams
1
5.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension Projective Resolutions Elementary Properties of Projective Dimension The (Left) Global Dimension Stably Free and FFR 0 Supplement: Quillen’s Theorem Euler Characteristic 0 Supplement: Serre’s Conjecture M Supplement: Cancellation and Its Consequences Large Projective Modules are Free
7 7 9 13 17 22
5.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors Homology The Long Exact Sequence Cohomology Derived Functors Tor and Ext Digression: Ext and Module Extensions Homological Dimension and the Derived Functors Dimension Shifting Acyclic Complexes
38 40
25 26 30 36
41
42 43 48 52 53 55 57 V
vi
Contents
5.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras Separable Algebras Hochschilds Cohomology Azumaya Algebras
59 62 67 70
Appendix to Chapter 5 : The Grothendieck Group, and Quillen’s Theorem Revisited
74
Exercises
77
Chapter 6 Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
87
6.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
Central Polynomials and Identities of Matrices Structure Theory for PI-Rings The Artin-Procesi Theorem The n-Spectrum The Algebra of Generic Matrices The Identities of a PI-algebra Noetherian PI-Rings Digression: Verifying PI-Rings Digression: Generalized Identities and Rational Identities P Supplement: Identities and Generalized Identities with Involution 6.2 Affine Algebras
Kurosch’s Problem and the Golod-Shafarevich Counterexample Growth of Algebras Gelfand-Kirillov Dimension Low GK Dimension The GK Dimension of a Module 6.3 Affine PI-Algebras
The Nullstellensatz Digression: The Embedding Question for Affine PI-Algebras Lewin’s Embedding Procedure Shirshov’s Theorem The Theory of Prime PI-Rings Nilpotence of the Jacobson Radical Dimension Theory of Affine PI-Algebras Digression: Noetherian PI-Rings Digression: Localization in PI-Rings
88 93 97 101 104 105 106 108 110 111 112 114 116 120 123 127 130 132 132 134 136 141 145 150 156 159 160
Contents
6.4
Relatively Free PI-Rings and T-Ideals Digression: Relatively Free PI (*)-Rings The Structure of T-Ideals Homogeneous Identities The Quantitative PI-Theory Trace Identities Invariant Theory
vii
162 164 165 166 168 170 171
Exercises
172
Chapter 7 Central Simple Algebras
187
7.1
Structure of Central Simple Algebras Centralizers and Splitting Fields Examples of Central Simple Algebras Symbols Overview of the Theory of Central Simple Algebras The First Generic Constructions Brauer Factor Sets Noether Factor Sets Algebras of Degree 2,3,4 Infinite Dimensional Division Algebras
187 188 193 194 197 198 202 208 209 210
7.2
The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem General Properties of the Brauer Group First Invariant of Br(F): The Index The Identification with H 2 Second Invariant of Br(F): The Exponent Outer Automorphisms The Corestriction Goldman’s Element Basic Properties of the Corestriction The Corestriction of a Symbol Interpretation of the Rosset-Tate Symbol Central Simple Algebras with Involution The Merkurjev-Suslin Number “Proof” of the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem (onto part) Digression: p-Algebras
211 212 212 213 214 217 219 222 223 225 229 232 236 24 1 243
7.3
Special Results Brauer’s Algebra p-Central Sets
244 244 248
viii
Contents
The Leading Monomial Technique Noncrossed Products of Prime Exponent
25 1 257
Appendix A: The Arithmetic Theory and the Brauer Group Particular Brauer Groups The Brauer Group of a Commutative Ring
258 260 26 1
Appendix B: The Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem and K-Theory
26 1
Appendix C: Generics Generic Splitting Fields and Schofield’s Method
265 267
Exercises
268
Chapter 8 Rings from Representation Theory
283
8.1 General Structure Theory of Group algebras An Introduction to the Zero-Divisor Question Maschke’s Theorem and the Regular Representation Group Algebras of Subgroups Augmentation Ideals and the Characteristic p Case Major Digression: The Structure of Group Algebras of Finite Groups The Kaplansky Trace Map and Nil Left Ideals Subgroups of Finite Index Prime Group Rings Primitive Group Rings F Supplement: The Jacobson Radical of Group Algebras Polynomial Identities Digression: Related Results from Character Theory The Reduction Techniques Q Supplement: A Prime but Nonprimitive Regular Group Algebra
283 285 286 289 290
8.2 Noetherian Group Rings Polycyclic-by-Finite-Groups Digression: Growth of Groups Homological Dimension of Group Algebras Traces and Projectives The Zero Divisor Question Digression: The Structure of Polycyclic-by-Finite Group Algebras
3 10 310 313 315 317 319
29 1 295 297 299 30 1 302 303 304 306 308
323
ix
Contents
8.3 Enveloping Algebras Basic Properties of Enveloping Algebras Additional Theory for Characteristic 0 Nilpotent and Solvable Lie Algebras Solvable Lie Algebras as Iterated Differential Polynomial Rings Completely Prime Ideals (Following BGR) Dimension Theory on U ( L ) Examples Digression: A Sketch of Some of the Deeper Results Digression: The Restricted Enveloping Algebra
325 328 331 333
8.4 General Ring Theoretic Methods Vector Generic Flatness and the Nullstellensatz Digression: Subalgebras The Primitive Spectrum Reduction Techniques An Additivity Principle for Goldie Rank Stably Free Modules and Left Ideals Lie Superalgebras R Supplement: Hopf Algebras
352 352 358 358 361 365 369 373 374
Appendix to Chapter 8: Moody's Theorem
379
Exercises
38 1
Dimensions for Modules and Rings
397
Major Theorems and Counterexamples for Volume I1
399
References
409
335 338 339 340 342 35 1
Bibliography of Books Collections of Papers Bibliography of Articles
409 413 415
Index of References According to Section
447
Cumulative Subject Index for Volumes I and I1
45 1
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Introduction to Volume I1
A comprehensive introduction was furnished in Volume I, but a few comments are in order about the specific nature of Volume 11. After a brief treatment of those techniques of homology and cohomology needed for rings, the book turns specifically to certain types of rings that have been objects of intense investigation in recent years-Azumaya algebras (5.3), rings with polynomial identity (Chapter 6), division rings, and, more generally, (finite dimensional) central simple algebras (Chapter 7), group rings (8.1 and 8.2), and enveloping algebras (8.3). Since the group ring contains all possible information about group representations and the enveloping algebra contains all possible information about Lie representations, these two types of rings have been unified in Chapter 8 under the heading, “Rings of Representation Theory.” These rings often are Noetherian, and the last part of Chapter 8 deals with general aspects of Noetherian theory that have been used in studying these rings (and also with Hopf algebras, another generalization). Although the general setup is the same as in Volume I, the pace of the text is somewhat faster than in the first volume. Indeed, the subjects of each chapter have had books devoted exclusively to them in the past, and to deal adequately with current research in any of these subjects would require several volumes. The goal in this volume has been to present a unified treatment to the reader and to give the reader some idea, at least, of research in ring theory of the 1980s. In certain fast-moving areas, such as polycyclic group algebras and primitive ideals of enveloping algebras, only a brief sketch has been given of recent advances; fortunately, excellent surveys in both subjects have been published within the last five years by Farkas and Passman (for the former); and by Borho, Joseph, and Rentschler (for the latter).
xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Table of Principal Notation for Volume I1 Note: ! after a page reference means the symbol is used differently in another part of the text. 9 13 14 14 17 18 31 32 39 39 41 44 47 48 48 54 60 60 60 61
61 61 62 74 90 96 104 105 106 114 120 121 123 134 146 164 164 169 188 193
xiii
xiv
Table of Principal Notation for Volume I1
193 194 195 200 21 1 212 214 214 218 218 220 220 227
285 285 285 288 290 290 292 299 D G O = ( ] ) 310 312 314 318! 319 325 325 329 330 333 336 342 343 347 353 358 365 375 375 375 379 379
5
Homology and Cohomology
One of the major tools of algebra is homology theory and its dual, cohomology theory. Although rooted in algebraic topology, it has applications in virtually every aspect of algebra, as explained in the classic book of Cartan and Eilenberg. Our goal here is to develop enough of the general theory to obtain its main applications to rings, i.e., projective resolutions, the ~ d, and the cohomology homological dimensions, the functors F u and groups (which are needed to study division rings). Duality plays an important role in category theory, so we often wish to replace R - A W by a self-dual category, i.e., we use only those properties of R-Jhod whose duals also hold in R-.Mud. For the most part, it is enough to consider abelian categories with “enough” projectives and injectives, i.e., for each object M there is an epic P -,M for P projective and a monic M -+ E for E injective.
85.0 Preliminaries About Diagrams Certain easy technical lemmas concerning diagrams are used repeatedly in homology and cohomology. For the sake of further reference we collect them here. We shall assume all of the diagrams are commutative, with all 1
Homology a d Cdromology
2
rows and columns exact; as usual a dotted line indicates a map to be found. Also please see the remark at the end. (1) T h e j v e lemma (repeatedfrom proposition 2.1 1.15). In the diagram
f
A-B-C-D-E
if
B
h
J
every vertical arrow but y i s an isomorphism then y is aIso an isomorphism. (2) Given
M-N
B
N”
M“
then f restricts to a map f ker /3 + ker y, and g induces a map S: coker p -+ coker y yielding the commutative diagram
0 --+
I?
ker p _c* M
0 L_* ker y
-B
N
coker p-0
IJ
M ----*N -
coker y
-
0
If f and g are isomorphisms thenf”and 9 are also isomorphisms. Proofi If Bx = 0 then yfx = gpx = 0 implying f(ker /3) G ker y. On the other hand, f(PM) = yfM E yM”, so g induces a map S : N / / 3 M -+ N”/yM”. The commutativity of the ensuing diagram is obvious. The last assertion is a special case of the five lemma. To wit, adding 0 at the right so that S is in the middle of the appropriate diagram (with f at the left side) shows is an isomorphism; adding, instead, 0 at the left so that is in the middle shows ?is an isomorphism. Q.E.D.
7
3
g5.0 Preliminaries About Diagrams
( 3 ) The snake lemma. Given
(i) ker a 4 ker p -+ ker y is exact, where the maps are obtained as in (2). (ii) Iff is epic then there is an exact sequence
7 ker p + i ker y 4 coker a 4 coker /?-+ coker y ker a + where
a is dejned in the proof, and the other maps are in (2).
Proofi
(i) The composition is certainly 0. On the other hand, if z E ker p and fz = 0 then z = f ‘ x ’ for some x’ in M’; then 0 = pz = g’ax‘, so ax’ = 0 and x’ E ker a as desired. (ii) Define 8 as follows: Given x” in kery we take x in M with f x = x ” ; then gpx = 0 so px E kerg = g ’ N ’ , yielding y’ in N ‘ with g’y’ = px, and we To check a is well-defined, suppose we took instead take ax” to be y‘ + aM’. x1 with f x l = x“ and we took y’, with g’y; = px,. Then f(xl - x) = 0 so x , - x E f‘M’, and thus g‘(y‘,
- y,)
= p(x, -
x) E Pf’M’ = g’aM’.
Hence y; - y, E aM’since g’ is monic. Having defined a, which is surely a map, we note that the hypothesis is
?; ker p -+r’ ker y % coker a is exact; self-dual, so it is enough to show ker a 4 r’ ker y 3 coker a is exact. We shall use in view of (i) we need only show ker p-+ throughout the notation of the previous paragraph. First note that if x” E j(ker p) then in the definition of ax‘’ above we could take x in ker p, so g’y’ = fix = 0 and thus y’ = 0, proving df’ = 0. On the other hand, if dx” = 0 then y’ E aM’ so writing y’ = ax‘ we see x - f ’ x ’ E ker and T ( x - f x )= f ( x - f ‘ x ’ ) = f x = x” proving x” E r(ker p). Q.E.D. (4) The nine lemma (or 3 x 3 lemma). Given
Homology and Cohomology
4
0
0
0
0
0
0
i i i
one canfind dotted arrows making an exact row such that the above diagram is commutative.
Proof:
Immediate from the snake lemma, since keru -Pi kero + kery -+a cokcl= 0
is exact and f is monic, yielding 0 -+ A’ --t A
+ A”
0 as desired.
4
Q.E.D.
( 5 ) The horseshoe lemma. If P’ and P” are projective then the following diagram can be ‘tfilled in” where p: P‘ + P‘ @ P“ is the canonical monic and n: P’ 0 P” --P P” is the projection:
0
0
I
I
I I
I I
I
.1
0 -K’-pI-M’-O
I I I I
I
0
4.
a’
5-
I
0
I
S’
I I
Ifl
5-
_____ + K -----,pf@p“--!-+M-O I I I
0 -K”
i
0
0
0
$5.0 PreliminariesAbout Diagrams
5
(You get the horseshoe lying on its side by erasing the dotted lines and the maps to and from 0.) There is a map h: P” -+ M lifting f , i.e., P” = f h . Defining B by ’P’x’ + hx” one sees at once that the top right square is commutative. Moreover, fP(x’, x ” ) = fs‘b’x‘ + P”x” = 0 b”x(x‘, x”) so the bottom right square is commutative. Taking K = kerP we can draw the upper row Q.E.D. by means of the nine lemma (turned on its side).
Pro03
P(X’,X’’) = f
+
( 6 ) Turning the corner Given 0
0
0
Ig I I
Proofi kerf = iK” = ihK since h is epic; moreover, since i is monic we Q.E.D. have ker ih = ker h = gK’. (7) The pullback and pushout have been introduced, respectively, as inverse and direct limits in exercises 1.8.1 and 1.8.1‘. We start over again here, obtaining some obvious properties. First, given
6
Homology pnd Cobontow
we define the pullback P to be { ( a , , a , ) ~A, 0 A,: fa, =ga2), and let n,:lp;. -+ Ai be the restrictions of the projection maps from A , 0 A , to Ai.Note ker n, = { (0, a2):a2 E ker g } x ker g, yielding a commutative diagram
0 - K - P A A ,
Furthermore, if g is epic then nl is epic for if a , a2 in A, implying a , = 7r1(al,a2). Dually given
B‘-
I.,
f
E
A, then f a , = ga, for some
A;
A2,
we define the pushout P’ = (A‘, 63 A ; ) / N where N = { f ‘ b , -g’b): b E B’}, and let p1,p2 be the compositions of the canonical injections into A’, Q A; with the canonical map factoring out N. Then cokerp, x cokerg’ (proof dual to the dual assertion for the pullback), and i f g’ is monic then p, is monic.
( 8 ) The projective lifting lemma. If P is projective and
is exact with V T = 0 then z = ILa for some ts:P $A“. Since ZP c ker tp E $A” we see $ lifts.)
+
A”: (Indeed, replace A by
Remark: Although for concreteness we have framed the proofs in the category R-Aod,the proofs could be given in any abelian category. Indeed, the five lemma was already proven in general (exercise 1.4.21), and it is quite straightforward to modify the other diagram-chasing lemmas accordingly. The general pullback for abelian categories was described in exercise 1.4.22, and the general pushout is its dual. The facts concerning projectives were proved directly from the lifting property, which is categorical. Since “abelian” is self-dual we shall also claim the dual results of any theorems based on these facts.
7
55.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
85.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension In this section we introduce two new important dimensions, the projective dimension and its dual, the injective dimension. It turns out these dimensions have immediate application to ring theory, and we shall use these to develop the motivation of the subject.
Projective Resolutions Definition 5.1.1: A projective resolution 9 of a module M is an exact sequence of the form
f"
-+ P, + P,-,
-+
. ' . + PI -+f, Po -$ M -+O
where each 8 is projective. We say 9 is f.g. (usually called Jinite in the ' is free if each 8 is free. The smallest n for literature) if each & is f.g.; 9 which P, = 0 is called the length of the resolution 9. Several immediate observations are available. Remark 5.1.2: (i) Every module M has a free resolution. Indeed, take an epic fo: Fo + M with F, free and, inductively, given fi-+ &-, take an epic fi: Fi+ kerf;- We could view fi: & + 6 -1; then JF, = ker A- so the sequence f2 fl . . . + F, + Fl + F, + M -+ 0 is exact. (ii) If M is f.g. then we could take Fo f.g. as well as free. If R is left Noetherian then kerf, IF, is f.g., and, continuing by induction, we may assume each 4 is f.g. Thus every f.g. module over a left Noetherian ring has an f.g. free resolution. In order to study a resolution we shall repeatedly use the observation that we can ''cut'' an exact sequence ... -,M" M -% M’ -+ .... at g to produce exact sequences
c-,
-+
f M M" +
-+
gM
+0
and
0 -+ kerg
-+
M 4 M’ -+... .
In particular, any projective resolution 9can be cut at f n to yield O+ K
-+
f" P , - l P, 4
+'..
4
Po + M 3 0 ;
K = kerf, is called the n-th syzygy of M . If 9 has length n + 1 then K % P,+ is projective. Conversely, if K is projective then we have produced a new
Homology and Cobolnology
8
projective resolution of length n of the next result.
Proposition 5.1.3:
+ 1, which we shall compare to 9 by means
(Generalized Schanuel’s lemma) Given exact sequences
Proofi We cut (1) at f,t o get 0 +K
+
Pz + PI + kers + 0
-+
0 -+ kerc + Po
M
+0
(3) (4)
and cut (2) at g1 to get
Let M ‘ = Pb 0 kers z Po 0 kerd by Schanuel’s lemma (2.8.26) applied t o sequences (4) and (6). Then we can modify (3), ( 5 ) t o get 0 -+ K + * . . + P2 + PI 0 Pb
0 +K ’ + - . . +
+p;
@
Po
M ’ +0 ’IQ1,
M’+O
and by induction on the length we get the desired conclusion.
Q.E.D.
Definition 5.1.4: Two modules N, N ’ are projectively equivalent if there are projectives P, P’ such that N @ P z N ‘ 0 P’; if, furthermore, P, P’ are f.g. free then N, N‘ are stably equivalent. N is stably free if N is stably equivalent to a free module, i.e., N 0 R(”)is free for suitable n.
Note that any module M projectively equivalent to a projective module is itself projective since M is a summand of a projective module. In particular, all stably free modules are projective. (Compare to remark 2.8.4’ and exercise 10.)
$5.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
9
Corollary 5.1.5: For any n the n-th syzygies of any two resofutions of M are projectively equivalent; the n-th syzygies of any two f.g. free resolutions of M are stably equivalent. We are ready to open an important new dimension in module theory.
Definition 5.2.6: M has projective dimension n (written pd(M) = n) if M has an f.g. projective resolution of length n, with n minimal such. In the literature the projective dimension is also called the homological dimension.
Remark 5.2.7:
pd(M) = 0 iff M is projective.
Proposition 5.1.8: The following are equivalent:
+
(i) pd(M) In 1. (ii) The n-th syzygy of any projective resolution of M is projective. (iii) Any projective resolution d of M can be cut at f . to form a projective resolution of length n + 1. Proof: (i) 3 (ii) By corollary 5.1.5 the n-th projective syzygy is projectively equivalent to a projective module and thus is itself projective; (ii) 3 (iii) clear; (iii) e-(i) by definition. Q.E.D. Proposition 5.1.9: The following are equivalent:
(i) M has a f.g. free resolution of length In + 1. (ii) The n-th syzygy of any f.g. free resolution is stably free. (iii) Any f.g. free resolution can be cut and modijied to form a f.g. free resolution of length n + 1.
-
Proof: (iii) (i) 3 (ii) is clear. To see (ii) (iii) note that if P @ R'"' is free and 0 -+ P -+ F -+ F' is exact with F, F' free then the sequence 0 -+ P @ R(")-+ F @ R("'-+ F'
is exact.
Q.E.D.
Elementary Properties of Projective Dimension Let us now compare projective dimensions of modules in an exact sequence. This can be done elegantly using the functor Ext of 55.2 or in a simple but ad hoc fashion by means of the following result:
Homology and Cohomology
10
Proposition 5.1.10: Suppose 0 M' + M + M" -+ 0 is exact. Given projec9"of M ' , M" respectively, we can build a projective tive resolutions Y, resolution 9 of M where each P, = Pk 0 P i and, furthermore, letting K b , K l denote the n-th syzyyies we have the following commutative diagram for each n, obtained b y cutting 9',%and 9" at f:,f., and f:, respectively: 0
I I
0
l l
0
0
l l
0
l I
i 1
Proofi By induction on n. Suppose for i In - 1 we have together with the diagram 0
Note that K b - , = ker
0
0
= fbP;
0
and K f - l
q = P:0 P y
0
= ker f f - , = ffPf.
Cutting
$5.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
11
the resolutions 9', 9"at f b, f yields the diagram
::
0
0
where the column is the n - 1 - syzygy column from above. Now the horseshoe lemma enables us to fill in the diagram 0
0
I
I I I I
I I I
1
P:, I
I
I I
.LI
I
I I I I
.1
I 0
1
fPb-0
I
I
I I I
J.
0
where P.
=
0
P i 0 P;, and we get (7) by pasting (9) to (8).
Q.E.D.
12
Homology a d Cohomology
Corollary 5.11: Suppose 0 M’ + M + M” + 0 is exact. If M’, M“ have projective (resp. f.g. projective, resp. free, resp. f.g. free) resolutions of length < n then so does M. In particular, pd(M) Imax{pd(M’), pd(M”)}. If pd(M‘) > pd(M”) then pd(M) = pd(M’). -+
Proof: The first two assertions are immediate since 0 0 0 x 0. For the last assertion let us examine the exact sequence of n-th syzygies 0 + K ; -+ K , -+ K : -+ 0 for n = pd(M”). This splits since K: is projective, so Kk is Q.E.D. projectively equivalent to K,, and we apply proposition 5.1.8.
Corollary 5.1.12: Suppose 0 + M‘ + M + M” + 0 is exact. Suppose 9’,P are projective resolutions of M’, M “ and let 9 be built as in proposition 5.1.10. Let K L , K,, K i denote the respective rnth syzygies. Then for any m there is an exact sequence O+KL-,
+ K,-
-+
Pi-
-+
Pi-2-+ ... + P i
+ M” + 0.
This displays K L - , as an m-th syzygy of a projective resolution of M“, if K , - is projective. Writing n‘,n,n” for the respective pd of M’, M, and M“ we then have n” 5 max{n’, n } + 1. Furthermore, n“ = n if n‘ < n, and n” = n’ + 1 if n’ > n.
,
Proofi The first assertion is obtained by “turning the corner” in (7). Everything else follows by choosing m properly. Taking m = max{n’,n} we see K L - l and K,,-l are projective so n 5 rn + 1 = max{n’,n} + 1. I f n’ < n then we could choose 9’ so that Kk = 0; taking m = n + 1 we have n” < n and thus n” = n by corollary 5.1.1 1. I f n‘ > n then taking rn = n’ we see K,- is projective but K L - is not, so n“ > m by proposition 5.1.8, i.e., n” 2 n‘ + 1; hence n” = n’ + 1 since Q.E.D. n” 5 max{n’, n } + 1.
Summary 5.1.13: Suppose 0 + M’ + M + M“ + 0 is exact. Recapitulating corollary 5.1.12 where n‘ = pd(M’), n = pd(M), and n“ = pd(M”) we have the following possibilities: Cuse I. n < n’. Then n” = n‘ + 1. Case 11. n
=n
. Then n“
< n + 1.
Case I l l . n > n’. Then n = n.
85.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
13
These formulas could be proved directly using induction, cf., Kaplansky [72B, p. 1691; we shall give a less ad hoc proof in $5.2. Example 5.1.14: Suppose f:F + M" is epic with F free and M" not projective. Then pd(F) = 0 so pd(M") = pd(kerf) 1. In particular, if Rr is not projective then pd(Rr) = pd(Ann r ) + 1.
+
The (Left) Global Dimension Definition 5.1.15: The global dimension
gl. dim(R) = sup{pd(M): M E R-Aud}. Example 5.1.16: (i) R is semisimple Artinian iff every module is projective, iff gl. dim(R) = 0. (ii) If R is hereditary then gl.dim(R) I 1. (Indeed, every submodule of a projective is projective, so the first syzygy is always projective, implying pd(M) I1 for any module M.)
There is another way of viewing the global dimension, by dualizing everything. Definition 5.1.17: An injective resolution iE of a module M is an exact sequence 0 + M E, k El -+... with each Eiinjective; the n-th cosyzygy is coker f,. IE has length n if Ei= 0 for all i 2 n, with n minimal such. The injective dimension id(M) (if it exists) is the smallest n for which M has an injective resolution of length n.
5
Dually to proposition 5.1.8 we see id(M) = n iff every injective resolution can be cut to a resolution of length n. In the next section we shall see gl. dim(R) = sup{id(M): M E R - A d } , which is easy to believe since it holds for R semisimple Artinian (gl. dim 0) or hereditary (gl. dim 1). Kirkland-Kuzmanovich [87] have constructed examples of Noetherian R with gl. dim R < gl. dim R/Nil(R). Our present interest is to see the connection between R and R[I] for a commuting indeterminate 1. If R is a field then R[A] is a PID and thus hereditary, so gl. dim R[I] = gl. dim(R) + 1. Actually, this relation holds much more generally, and we shall verify it for the skew polynomial ring R[;I;o] where R is arbitrary and o is an automorphism of R. (In particular,
Homology and Cohomology
14
one could take a = 1 and obtain the ordinary polynomial ring.) To see this we need to introduce some new module structure. If M is an R-module then we define M [ I ; a ] to be R[I] 8, M as an additive group, i.e., the elements of M[I;a] have the unique form c I i x i where x i E M. M [ I ;a] is made into RCI; a]-module via scalar multiplication
Remark 5.2.28: Since R [ I ;a] is free over itself we see that F [ I ; a] is a free R [ I ; a]-module for any free R-module F; consequently, any projective (resp. free) resolution 0 + P, + ..* -+ Po M -+ 0 of M in R-Aod yields a projective (resp. free) resolution 0 + P,[J.; a] -+ * * -+ Po[A;a] -+ MIA; 03 + 0 in R [ I ;a]-Aod. (This is really a fact about graded modules.) In particular, pdRI1;,,J M [ I ; a] 5 pd, M; in fact, equality holds by exercise 2. -+
On the other hand, any R[n;a]-module M is viewed naturally as R-module by forgetting 1, and then we can form M [ I ; a ] as above. To distinguish between the two R [ I ; a]-module structures we write Ax to denote the original product in M , and 1 x to denote the new product in M[A; a]. We need one more module. Define a M to be the set of formal elements { a x x E M } made into a module under the operations a x 1 + a x 2 = a ( x l + x 2 ) (so that a M z M as abelian groups) and r a x = ax' where x' is the product ( a - l r ) x in M.
-
Lemma 5.1.18':
(Hochschild's trick) For any R[I;a]-module M there i s an
exact sequence O + ( a M ) [ J ; a ] - + M [ I ; a ] -f+ M - t O
-
where f ( I i x ) = I i x .
$5.1 Resolutiols and Projeetive and Injective Dimension
xi,
15
proving g is indeed a map. Moreover, we can rewrite g ( 1 I ' axi) as 1 Axo + Ii (Ax, - xi-l). Hence A' ox, E ker g iff xo = 0 and Ax, = =xi-2 = for all i 2 1; but one has x i = 0 for large i, so 0 = implying g is monic. Finally suppose x' = 1,- xi E kerf. Put x, = 0, x,- = -xa, and given xi put xi- = Axi - xi. Then g ( c i z 0 1’ axi) = x', proving exactness. Q.E.D.
-
1-
a * . ,
-
We are ready for the first inequality. Proposition 5.1.19: gl.dim R [ I ; a ] Igl. dim R pd, o M 1 for any RIA; o]-module M.
+
+ 1.
In fact, pdRIA;al M I
Proof: Let n = gl. dim R. For any R [ I ;u]-module M we have
P~R[,;,]M[n; D l I pd, M 5 n, and pd,,,,,,(aM)[I;o] Ipd,oM I n. Applying corollary 5.1.12 to lemma 5.1.18'thus shows pd,[,;,,M I n + 1. Q.E.D. Our next goal is to see, in fact, that equality holds. Proposition 5.1.20: pd(@,,, Mi) = sup{pd(MJ: i E I}.
Proof: Write n, = pd(Mi) and n = pd(M); take projective resolutions 3 of Mi of respective lengths n,, and let 9 = @?, i.e., 9 is formed by taking the direct sum of the respective terms. Then, clearly, length (9)= sup(n,), proving n Isup(n,). On the other hand, the (n - 1)-st syzygy of 9is projective, so the ( n - 1)-st syzygy of each is a summand of a projective and Q.E.D. thus projective, proving each n, 5 n. Corollary 5.1.21: pd(M")) = pd(M) for any index set I. Proposition 5.1.22: Suppose 9:R + T is a ring homomorphism. Viewing any T-module M as R-module by means of cp we have
pdR M I pd, M
+ pdR T.
Moreover, if equality holds for all M such that pdT M I 1 then equality holds for all M having jinite pd.
Homology and Cohomology
16
Proofi Induction on m = pd, M . Write n = pd, M and t = pd, T; we want to show n Im t . For m = 0 we have M projective as T-module so M 0 M ’ = F for some free T-module F. This is also a direct sum as R-modules, so applying proposition 5.1.20 twice yields n I pd, F = t, as desired. For m > 0 take 0 + M ‘ + F + M -+ 0 exact where F is free. Then pd, M‘ = m - 1 by summary 5.1.13, so pd, M’ I (m - 1) t by induction. Thus
+
+
+
n I 1 + maxtpd, F, pd, M ’ } I 1 + max{t,(rn - 1) t } = 1
+ m - 1 + t =m +t
proving the first assertion. To prove the second assertion we note the same induction argument works if we have the case m = 1. Q.E.D. Remark 5.1.23: Suppose Ra = aR. Any M in R - A u d has the submodule a M , and @ M i l a ( @ M i ) z @(Mj/aMi). In particular, if F is a free (resp. projective) R-module then F / a F is a free (resp. projective) RIRa-module.
Theorem 5.1.24: (“Change of rings”) Suppose a E R is a regular noninvertible element, and Ra = aR. If M is an RIRa-module with pd,,,, M = n < 00 then pd, M = n + 1. In particular, gl.dim R 2 gl.dim(R/Ra) + 1 provided gl.dim R/Ra is jinite. Write R = R / R a . First we show pd, R = 1. Right multiplication by a gives an isomorphism R + Ra, so applying summary 5.1.13 to the exact sequence 0 + Ra -+ R -+ R + 0 we see pd, R I 1. But R is not projective (for otherwise Ra would be a summand of R, implying Ra = Re for an Proof:
idempotent e # 0, and then a(l - e) = 0, contrary to a regular.) Thus pd, R = 1. By proposition 5.1.22 we have pd, M I n + 1, and we need to show equality for the case n 5 1. Assume M is a counterexample; we may assume pd, M I 1. By definition a M = 0. Hence M cannot be a submodule of a free R-module. In particular, M is not projective so pd, M = 1. Hence n = 1 (since M is a counterexample). Any exact sequence of R-modules 0 +M’ +F +M
sends aF to aM
= 0, so
-+
0
( F free)
we get the exact sequence
0 + M‘/aF -+ F/aF -+ M
+ 0.
(10)
But this can be read in R-dod, in which F / a F is free. Also we have 0 + a F / a M ’ + M ’ / a M ’ + M’/aF
+ 0.
(1 1)
55.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
17
Applyingexample5.1.14 to(lO),(l Ifwehavepd, M‘=Oandpd, M’/aF=O. But then M‘/aM‘ and M’laF are projective R-modules. In particular, (11) splits, implying aF/aM’ is a projective R-module. Thus M % F / M ’ z aF/aM‘ is projective. Q.E.D.
Corollary 5.1.25:
gl. dim R[A;a ] = gl. dim R
+ 1.
Proof: Apply the theorem, with R [ A ; a ] and A replacing, respectively, R and a. Q.E.D.
(For gl. dim R = co a separate argument is needed, which is an instant application of exercise 4.In fact, infinite gl. dim has led to serious errors in the literature, cf., exercise 16 and McConnell[77].) It is also useful to have a localization result.
Proposition 5.1.26: If S is a le) denominator set for R and T = S-’R then pd, S-’M I pd, M for M in R - A o d . In particular, gl. dim T I gl. dim R . Proofi Since the localization functor is exact (theorem 3.1.20), any projective resolution of M can be localized to a projective resolution of S-’M as T-module. Q.E.D.
There is a right-handed version of projective dimension and thus of gl. dim, which also is 0 if gl. dim R = 0 since “semisimple Artinian” is leftright symmetric. However, for gl. dim R = 1 the symmetry fails because left hereditary rings need not be right hereditary, and Jategaonkar’s example in $2.1 can be used to find rings of arbitrary left and right gl.dim 2 1. A thorough discussion of global dimension and its peculiar connection to the continuum hypothesis can be found in Osofsky [73B].
Stably Free and FFR Definition 5.2.27: A module M has FFR (of length n) if M has an f.g. free resolution of length n. (In particular M is f.g.)
Our interest in FFR is derived from the next result. Lemma 5.1.28:
If P
i s projective with FFR then P is stably free.
Homology and Cohomology
18
f" Proof: Take an f.g. free resolution 0 -+ F, -+F,... F , fi Fo 5 P 0. Since E splits we can write Fo = P 0 P' with flFl = ker E = P', so P' has a f.g. free resolution 0 -, F, + F,- -+ F, -+ P’ + O of length n - 1. By induction P' is stably free; write P' 0 R(")w F for F free. Then P 0 F P @ P ' @ R(")w Fo 0 R(") is f.g. free, proving P is stably free. Q.E.D. -+
-+
-+
+
Conversely, we have
Zf M has an f.g. projective resolution of length n, with each pi stably free then M has FFR of length In 1.
Lemma 5.1.29:
+
Proofi Take f.g. free F, F' such that Po Q3 F' w F. If n = 0 then M x Po so 0 + F' -+ F -+ M -+0 is the desired sequence. In general, we break the resolution O-+P,-+...-+Po-+M-+O at E to get O-+Pn+-..-+P,-+Pl+kerf -+O and 0 -+ kerf + Po + M -+ 0. By induction kerf has an f.g. free resolution 0 -+ F, -+ .* * + F, 4kerf -+ 0; piecing back together yields
0
-+
F,
-+
---
-+
Fo -+ Po + M -,0,
or better yet
0 -+ Fn *..-+ Fl + Fo @ F' -+ F + M -+
+ 0.
Q.E.D.
Dejinition 5.1.30: Ko(R) = 9192, where 9 is the free group whose generators correspond to the isomorphism classes of f.g. projective R-modules, and B is the subgroup generated by all [P @ Q] - [PI - [Q] for P,Q f.g. projective. Since z[pi] = [@pi] we see every element of K,(R) can be written in the form [PI - [Q] for P, Q f.g. projective. Remark 5.1.30': P is stably free iff [PI = [Rlk for some k. (Proof (3) If P 0 R("') w R(") then [PI = [R]"-". (t) If [PI = [RIk then P 0 Q % Rtk)0 Q for a suitable fag. projective module Q; writing Q 0 Q' z R(m)we
see P 0 R(m)x R("+lr).) In view of remark 5.1.30' we see every projective is stably free iff K o ( R ) = ([R]), and we shall use this characterization from now on. Proposition 5.1.31: Suppose R is left Noetherian and gl.dimR < 00. K o ( R ) = <[R]) iff every f . g . projective R-module has FFR. Proofi (a) by lemma 5.1.29. (e) by lemma 5.1.28.
Q.E.D.
$5.1 Resolutiom and Projective and Injective Dimension
19
Our principal interest here is when K , ( R ) = ([R]). One way of proving this is to show that every f.g. module has FFR. Thus we might hope for an analog of corollary 5.1.25, to tell us that K,(R[I]) = ([R[A]]) if K,(R) = ([R]). Unfortunately, we lack an f.g. analog of proposition 5.1.22, so we start over again. Proposition 5.1.32: Suppose R is left Noetherian and gl.dimR < co. If K,(R) = ([R]) then Ko(S-'R) = ([S-'R]) for any left denominator set S sf R.
Proofi By lemma 5.1.28 it suffices to show every f.g. projective S-'R-module P has FFR. P is naturally an R-module; take an f.g. R-submodule M with S-'M maximal. If S-'M < P then taking x in P - S-'M we would have S-'(M + Rx) > K I M , contrary to choice of M; thus S-'M = P. But now take an FFR for M. Tensoring each term by S-'R yields an FFR for S-'M = P. Q.E.D. This argument actually yields an epic K , ( R ) -+ Ko(S-'R), cf., exercise 12. Proposition 5.1.33: Suppose R is left Noetherian and 0 + M' + M is exact. If two of the modules have FFR then so does the third.
-+
M" -+ 0
Proof: In view of remark 5.1.2(ii) there are f.g. free resolutions P , P " (of possibly infinite length) of M', M", and we form the f.g. free resolution 9 of M as in proposition 5.1.10. By lemma 5.1.29 it suffices to find some n for which the n-th syzygies Kb,K,,,and K i are stably free. Recall 0 K ; -+ K,, K i -+ 0 is exact. If M', M" have FFR then we may assume 9',9'' are f.g., so for large enough n we get KL = K i = 0 and thus K,, = 0. Therefore, we may assume one of the two modules with FFR is M. Now the generalized Schanuel lemma implies K , is stably free for large enough n. But M' or M" has FFR so for n large enough we may assume K ; = 0 or K i = 0; thus K,, is isomorphic to the other syzygy which is thus stably free. Q.E.D. -+
-+
Theorem 5.1.34: (Serre's theorem) Suppose R is a ldt Noetherian N-graded ring, with gl. dim R < 00. If K,(R,) = ([R,]) then K , ( R ) = ([R]). Before presenting the proof of this important result, we should note the same proof shows K , ( R ) % K,(R,). This result will be generalized further in appendix A. We follow Bass [68B] and start by noting various properties
20
Homology and Cohomology
R,, an ideal of of graded modules, of independent interest. Let R+ = R/R+. We consider the category R-9r-Jtibd of definition 1.9.1.
R. Then R ,
Remark 5.1.34‘: If M E R-Y#-Mod and R+M = M then M = 0. (Indeed, otherwise, take n minimal such that M, # 0. Then M n n R + M= 0, contradiction.) Remark 5.1.34”: If a projective module P happens to be in R-Yh-MoA then there is an epic F + P in R - 9 r - M ~ dfor F a suitable graded free G(R)-module (cf., remark 1.9.7), and the epic splits in R-Yt-Aod by remark 1.9.6. In view of remark 1.9.5 we see if p.d. M = t < cc and M is graded then M has a projective resolution of length t in R-%-Aod.
In view of remark 5.1.34” there is no ambiguity in talking about the graded f.g. projective R-modules, which we call Y r - f i r ~ j ( R viewed ), as a full subcategory of R-%-Aud. Claim 1: The functor F = R BRo- (c5, remark 1.9.1 1) is a category equiualence 9r-#mj(R0) -+ Yt-&j(R). Proof of Claim 1: Take the functor G = R, OR-: R-Yt-Aud -+ R,-YaMod. Since GF is naturally equivalent to 1 it suffices to show P z FGP (graded) for every P in Yr-fiwj(R). Let Q = GP x P/R+Pby example 1.7.21’; since Q is projective the epic P 4Q splits in R,-Aod, and thus in R0-Ya-&~d by remark 1.9.6. Hence there is a graded monic f: Q 4 P. Now FGP = R ORoQ so we can define a graded map cp: FGP + P such that cp(r 0 x) = r f x for r in R and x in Q. Since G right exact and Gcp is an isomorphism we see G(coker cp) = 0, i.e., coker cp = R, coker cp, implying coker cp = 0 by remark 5.1.34’. But then cp is epic and thus split, so G(ker cp) = 0, likewise implying ker cp = 0. Thus cp is an isomorphism, proving claim 1.
The next part of the proof of the theorem involves two clever tricks, the first of which is very cheap. Grade R[L] by putting R[IL], = RiL“-i. Then R [ I ] , = R,, so R is replaced by the larger graded ring R[I]. The second trick is a “homogenization map” @d, given by tjdr = rid-" for any r in Rn. This defines the map tjd:OnsdRn -+ R[I],, so t+bd homogenizes all elements of degree I d. Now define the functor H : R[I]-Yt-9imod.+ R - 9 i m o d given by HM = M/(1 - I ) M , i.e., we specialize I to 1. Then H is given by R where we view R as the R[I]-module R[I]/R[I](l - A) as in example 1.7.21’. In particular, H is right exact.
85.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
21
Claim 2: For every f.g. R-module N there is an f.g. graded R[I]-module M with H M = N .
If=,
Proof of Claim 2: Write N z R'"'/K where K = Rxi. Writing x i = ( x i l ,..., xi,,) in R'"), we take d greater than the maximum of the degrees of all the x i j , and define x f = ($&lr.. . ,$&in) E (R[IId)('). Letting K' = R [ R ] x i , a graded submodule of R[I]'"', we have H(R[A]'"'/K') z H(R[I]("))/HK' z R(")/Kz N since H is right exact.
xi=,
Claim 3: H is exact.
Proof of Claim 3: We need to show H is left exact, i.e., given a monic f : N -, M in R[A]-%-Fimud then HJ H N --t H M is monic. But the canonical map N -,H M = M/(1 - I ) M has kernel N n (1 - I ) M , so it suffices to show N n(1- 1)M I ( 1 - 2)N. Suppose x = E x , E M with (1 - A)x E N , where the x, are homogeneous. xo = ((1 - A)x), E N , and xi - Axi- = (( 1 - 1 ) ~E N ) ~ for each i 2 1, so by induction we see each x i E N . Thus x E N , so (1 - A)x E (1 - I ) N as desired. Proof of the Theorem: Suppose N is an f.g. R-module. Write N = H M for M E R[2]-%-A%d, by claim 2. R[A] is Noetherian of finite gl.dim, by proposition 5.1.19. Thus M has an f.g. projective resolution
0 -+ P, -, ... 3 Po + M + 0, which by remark 5.1.34"can be taken to be graded. Then 0 + HP, -+. * . -+ HP, -, N + O is a projective resolution of N by claim 3. O n the other hand, R[i], = R, so claim 1 shows each P z R[I] &,Qi for suitable f.g. projective R,-modules Qi, which by hypothesis are all stably free. Then HP, z R OR0Qi are stably free. Thus K o ( R ) = ([R]) by proposition 5.1.31. Q.E.D. We now have quite a wide assortment of rings R with K o ( R ) = ( [ R ] ) . Corollary 5.1.35: Suppose R is left Noetherian, gl. dim R < 00. The hypothesis "every f.g. projective is stably free" passes from R to the following rings:
(i) R[A; 01 for any monic CT:R -,R . (ii) R[I,. . . . ,At] for commuting indeterminates I,,.. . ,A,. In particular, if R is a PLID then every f.g. projective R I I l , . . . ,I,]-module is stably free.
Homology and Cohomology
22
Proofi (i) R[A;o] is N-graded according to degree and is left Noetherian (proposition 3.5.2) of finite gl. dim (corollary 5.1.25). (ii) Apply (i) t times. To see the last assertion note K,(R) = ([R]) and gl. dim R = 1 since R is Q.E.D. hereditary. The hypothesis R left Noetherian of finite gl.dim could be weakened throughout to “Every f.g, R-module has an f.g. projective resolution of finite length,” without change in proof. Such rings are called (homologically) regular.
0 Supplement: Quillen’s Theorem One good theorem deserves another, and Quillen [73] proved a startling extension of Serre’s theorem. Before stating Quillen’s theorem let us make another definition. Definition 5.1.36:
groups R,
5
R,
A ringR is filtered if R has a chain of additive subsuch that RiRj G R i + j for all i, j and UieN Ri= R.
E-**
Note that this concept is not new to us; R is filtered iff R has a filtration over (Z, +) for which R ( l ) = 0. (Just take the new Ri to be the old R - i ) .Thus example 1.8.14(i) and the results applicable to that example can be used here, and, in particular, we can form the associated graded ring G(R); also note that R, is a subring of R. The terminology introduced here has become standard when applied to enveloping algebras, and the results to be given here are fundamental in the theory of enveloping algebras, cf., $8.4. Quillen’s Theorem: Suppose R is filtered, such that the graded ring G(R) i s Noetherian and of finite gl. dim. If G(R) is pat as R,-module then the natural injection R , -+ R induces an isomorphism q :K,(R,) -+ K,(R).
Quillen actually proved a much stronger result, that the corresponding isomorphism also holds in the “higher” K-theories. Our exposition (also, cf., the appendix and exercise 13) follows the very readable account of McConnell [ S S ] , which in turn relies on Roy [ S S ] . The main object is to develop the homological module theory of filtered rings to the same stage that we developed the module theory of graded rings. To this end we assume throughout this discussion that R is a filtered ring; we
85.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
23
say an R-module M is filtered if M has a chain of subgroups M , C M I E ... such that RiMj I Mi+jand M i = M . R is itself filtered as R-module in the natural way; on the other hand, any R-module M can be trivially Jiltered by putting M, = M. A map f: M + N of filtered R-modules will be called Jiltered if f M i G Ni for all i; f is strictly Jiltered if f M i = Ni nf M for all i. If N is a filtered module and f:M + N is an arbitrary map then M can be filtered in such a way that f is strictly filtered; namely, put Mi = f - ‘N. If M is a filtered R-module we define the associated graded module G ( M ) = @(Mi+JMi), viewed naturally as G(R)-module by the rule
UitN
(Ti
+ Ri+l)(xj+ Mj+1)= rixj + Mi+j+l
for ri in R, and xi in Mi. Given x in Mi we shall write X for the corresponding element of G ( M ) . Any filtered map f: M -+ N gives rise naturally to a map C ( f ) : G(M) -+ G ( N ) ,so G is a functor. The point of strictly filtered maps lies in the following “exactness” feature of this functor: If M “ M 3 M’ is exact with f ,g strictly filtered then
We say M is Jiltered-free if G ( M )is graded free over G ( R ) ,cf., remark 1.9.7. Any filtered-free R-module is free, for if {Fi: i E I > is a base of homogeneous elements of G(M) then {ei:i E I } is a base of M; in fact, writing ei E M,,,i,we have
Remark 5.1.37:
Conversely, any graded free G(R)-module T gives rise to a filtered-free Clearly the above holds for R-module F such that G ( F ) = (Proof. (a) k = 0, and thus is easily seen to hold by induction for all k, by passing to G(M) at each step; likewise, any dependence would be reflected in some Mk and thus pass to G(M),. (t) Let {Pi:i E I ) denote a base of F over G ( R )and define F = R(”. Labeling a base of F as {ei:i E I ) use the above equation to filter F ; then G ( F ) = F by inspection.) Now that we want to see that our object is really “free”. Lemma 5.1.38: Suppose M is a Jiltered R-module.
Homology and Cohomology
24
3
(i) l f F is a Jiltered-free module then for every graded map G ( F ) -+ G ( M ) there is a jiltered map f : F M such that G ( f ) = (ii) There exists a filtered-free module F and a strictly Jiltered epic F -+ M . (iii) lf P is Jiltered and G ( P )is G(R)-projective then P is projective.
f
-+
Proof.(i) Let { e i : iE I} be a base of F taken as in remark 5.1.37, and define f:F -,M by pi= T F i . Then G ( f ) = by construction, and, obviously, f is filtered. (ii) Let F be a graded-free G(R)-module, together with a graded epic f F + G ( M ) . By remark 5.1.37 we can write F in the form G(F),so by (i) we have a filtered epic fi F -+ M . It remains to show f is strictly filtered, i.e., $6 -+ M iis epic for each i; we do this by induction on i, noting it is clear for i = 0 and thus follows for general i by applying proposition 2.1 1.15 to the diagram
7
0 ---+Mi-
- - -,-
,
Mi
MJM,
0
j (iii) By (ii) we have an exact sequence 0 + N -+ F s P 0 where F is filtered-free and f , g are strictiy filtered. Applying G( ) yields an exact sequence 0 -,G ( N )-,G ( F ) G ( P )-+ 0 which splits by remark 1.9.6. -+
-+
-+
PJe-
We need to show g is split, i.e. gp = 1, for some p: P + F. Note is a summand of G ( P )and thus is projective; hence the epic fi -+ Pi/e- splits. But then Pi z pi - I 0 (pi/pl,- I), so we can build p inductively on i (i.e., piecing to get pi c, fi). Q.E.D. together elpi- I 4 &IF,- and pi-, 4 Proposition 5.1.39:
For any filtered module M we have pd, M Ipd,(,, G ( M ) .
Proof.- Let n = pdGo, G(M). There is nothing to prove unless n is finite, so we proceed by induction on n. Lemma 5.1.38(iii) gives the result for n = 0. For n > 0 take an exact sequence 0 -+ N -+ F -+ M -+ 0 where F is filteredfree and the maps are strictly filtered, cf., lemma 5.1.38(ii). Then we get an exact sequence 0 -+ G ( N )-+G ( F )-+ G ( M ) 0. But pd,,,, G ( N ) 4 n - 1 by summary 5.1.13, so pd, N In - 1 by induction, implying pd, M In by Q.E.D. summary 5.1.13. 4
55.1 Resolutions and Projective and lnjective Dimension
Corollary 5.1.40: ff R is a jiltered ring then gl. dim R
25
gl. dim G(R).
Proofi Any R-module M can be filtered trivially, and then by the proposition pd, M Ipd,,,, G ( M )I gl. dim G(R). Thus gl. dim R I gl. dim G(R). Q.E.D. Digression: These results actually yield more. We could define the graded pd of a module and graded gl.dim of a ring, in terms of graded projective resolutions. Then we see at once the graded gl.dim of a graded ring equals its usual gl. dim.
We are ready for our watered-down version of Quillen’s theorem. Theorem 5.1.41: Suppose R is jiltered and G(R) is Noetherian of Jinite @.dim. ff Ko(R,) = ([Ro]) then K , ( R ) = ([RI). Proofi R is Noetherian by corollary 3.5.32(i), and has finitely gl.dim by corollary 5.1.40. We want to show that every f.g. projective R-module P is stably free. Viewing P as filtered trivially, we see G ( P ) is f.g. over G(R) and thus we can build a graded resolution of f.g. graded free modules, as in remark 5.1.34”. By hypothesis the n-th syzygy K , is projective and is the kernel of a graded map, so is graded projective. By claim 1 (following remark 5.1.34”) there is a projective R,-module Qo with K , z G(R) OR,,Qo. But Qo is stably free by hypothesis, so K , is stably free as G(R)-module. Thus K , is “graded” stably free by remark 5.1.34”, so just as in lemma 5.1.29 we have a graded FFR of G ( P ) having finite length. Using lemma 5.1.38 we have the resolution in the form 0 + G(F,) + G(F,- I ) + ... -+ G ( P )+ 0, and this “pulls back” to an FFR 0 + F, + F,-, -+ * . . -+ P 40 in R-Aud, as needed.
Euler Characteristic The FFR property has an important tie to topology. Definition 5.1.42: Suppose R has IBN. The Euler characteristic of a module M with an f.g. free resolution 0 F, + ... + F, + M + 0 is defined as x ( M ) = CY=,(- l)irank(&). --f
Remark 5.1.43: x ( M )is independent of the FFR because of the generalized Schanuel lemma. In particular, if 0 + F, + ... + F, + 0 is exact then - l)irank(4) = 0.
c(
26
Homology and Cobomology
Remark 5.1.44: Suppose S is a left denominator set of R and S-‘R also has IBN. If an R-module has FFR then S - ’ M has FFR in S-’R-&O~,and x ( S - ’ M ) = x ( M ) . (Just localize the resolution, since the localization functor is exact and preserves “free” and the rank.) The name “Euler characteristic” comes from Euler’s observation that #faces - #edges + #vertices of a simplicia1 complex is a topological invariant. The standard reference on properties of the Euler characteristic is Bass [76]. Theorem 5.1.45: (Walker [72]) If R is a prime l@t Noetherian ring of Jinite gl. dim with K,(R) = ([R]) then R is a domain. Proofi By Goldie’s theorem R is a left order in a simple Artinian ring S ’ R x M,,(D). We claim n = 1, which would prove R is a domain. Indeed, L = R n Mn(D)el, is a left ideal of R which is nonzero since M,,(D) is an essential extension of R; thus S-’L 5 M,,(D)e,, so 0 < [S-’L:D] In. On the other hand, take an FFR 0 + F, -+ ... -+ F,, L -+ 0. Then each S-’F, is a free S-’R-module so n2 divides [S-’F,:D]. Hence remark 5.1.43 Q.E.D. shows n 2 divides [S-’L: D], a contradiction unless n = 1. -+
Walker’s theorem is more general, with “semiprime” replacing “prime”, cf., exercise 14. However, the proof given here will be relevant when we consider group rings later.
0 Supplement: Serre’s Conjecture One of the outstanding recent problems in algebra has been to verify Serre’s conjecture: Every f.g. projective module over the polynomial ring R = F [ I , , ... ,At] is free, for any field F. This is trivial for n = 0 and is easy for n = 1 since R is a PID (and so every submodule of a free module is free, by corollary 2.8.16). Attempts to verify Serre’s conjecture for larger n spurred the development of algebraic K theory, a deep and useful subject which also ties in to results about division algebras; Serre’s conjecture was finally established by Quillen [76] and Suslin [76], two masters of K-theory, although the solutions were (surprisingly) not so difficult. Following Rotman [79B] we present Vaserstein’s simplification of Suslin’s proof. The solution is comprised of two parts: (i) f.g. projective modules are stably free (by corollary 5.1.35); (ii) Stably free modules are free, which we consider now.
55.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
27
The techniques are not homological, but instead involve linear algebra over PIDs. Thus this part of the proof lies in the realm of noncommutative algebra, although the theorem itself is over a commutative ring. We say a r,ri = 1 for suitable ri in R ; vector u = ( I l , . .., r n ) E R'") is unimodulur if u is strongly unimodufur if u is the first row of an invertible matrix (in GL(n, R)). Any strongly unimodular vector certainly is unimodular, and we are interested in the converse. In the following discussion let e, ,.. . ,en be a standard base of R'").
cf=
Remark 5.1.46: (i) v = (rl, ...,r n ) is unimodular iff there is an epic f : R ( " ) +R with fu = 1. (Proof (-) Given r l , . ..,rk with x r i r i = 1 define f:R("' --t R by f ( x , , ..., x,) = E x i ( . (e) 1 = f v = f ( C r i e i ) = C r i f e i , so take r: = fei.) (ii) u is strongly unimodular iff there is an invertible transformation T :R(")-,R'") for which Te, = u (seen at once by viewing T as a matrix). Digression 5.1.47: Remark 5.1.47(i) enables us more generally to define an element x of an arbitrary R-module M to be mimodular iff R x is a summand of M isomorphic to R.
We shall describe "stably free implies free" in terms of the unimodular vector property, which is defined as the property that all unimodular vectors are strongly unimodular. Remark 5.1.48: Suppose P = R(")/Ruwhere v is a strongly unimodular vector of R(").Then P z R("- ". (Indeed, take an invertible transformation T:R @ 4 ) R(")with Te, = u. Then P = R(")/Ru= TR'"'/T(Re,) % T(R(")/Re,)z R(n-1)-1
Proposition 5.1.49: Suppose R has IBN (invariant base number). Every f.g. stably free R-module is free iff R has the unimodular vector property. (Note: 'Yg." actually is supeJfluous by exercise 10.) Proof: (a) Suppose v , is a unimodular vector. Taking f:R("' + R epic with ful = 1 we note R'") z R 0 kerf since R is projective; by hypothesis kerf is free with some base { u2,.. .,v,}. Thus we have an invertible transformation T:R'"' + R'") given by Te, = ui, corresponding to an invertible matrix whose first row is u l . (e) First assume P 0 R z R("),i.e., the canonical map f:R(")+ P has kernel Ru z R for suitable v in R(").Since f splits we see by remark 5.1.46 that
28
Homology and Cohomology
v is unimodular and thus strongly modular, so P is free by remark 5.1.48. By
induction on m we now see that if P 0 R(m)z R(")then P is free.
Q.E.D.
We see from proposition 5.1.49 (*) that local commutative rings have the unimodular vector property, since all projectives are free. Proposition 5.1.50: (Horrocks) Suppose C is a local commutative ring, and u = (fi, . . .,f,) is a unimodular vector in C[A]'"'.If some 1;. is monic then u is strongly unimodular.
Proof: Reordering the 1;. we may assume f l is monic. Suppose m = deg(f i ). We can use f l to cancel higher degree terms in the other entries; since this involves elementary transformations and thus affects neither unimodularity nor strong unimodularity, we may assume deg(f,) < m for all i > 1. For m = 0 we have u E C(")is strongly unimodular. Thus we may induct on m > 0. For n = 1 the assertion is vacuous. For n = 2 we have ( g 1 , g 2 )in C[%]"' such that figl
+ f z g 2 = 1, so
is invertible. For n 2 3, letting-
c
= (C/Jac(C)), we see V is denote the canonical image in the field unimodular in But f, = 1" + ... is not invertible in since m > 0, so # 0 for some i 2 2. Assume f, # 0. Then some coefficient of f2 is not in Jac(C) and thus is invertible. If C I A ] f l + C [ A ] f i contains a monic polynomial of degree m - 1 then using elementary transformations we can change f3 to a monic of degree m - 1, and are done by induction. Thus it remains to prove the next result. Q.E.D.
c[A]("'.
c[A]
xy=+
Lemma 5.1.51: (Suslin) Suppose f = A"' + in C[A]. Then for any j -= rn the ideal C [ i . ] f degree s m - 1 and leading coeficient bj.
and g = bil"-j C [ 1 ] g has a polynomial h of
Proof: Induction on j . For j = 1 we take h = g . In general, let A = C [ A ] f + C[A]g and define g' = 1 g - b,f = b:Am-'E A, where b: = bi+ - blai. By induction b J - , is the leading coefficient of a polynomial h' in A having degree rn - 1, But now h' + a j P 1 g has leading coefficient bj - bluj- + a j - ,bl = bj, as desired. Q.E.D.
xy=l
Next we need the following passage from C[1]'")to C [ 1 ] .
29
g5.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
Lemma 5.1.52: (Suslin) Suppose u = (f,(A),. . .,f,(A)) is a unimodular vector with some f;. monic. Then, uiewiny u as 1 x n matrix, we have u = wA for some A E GL(n,C [ l ] )and w E Cfn). Proof: Write G = G L ( n , C [ A ] ) .Given any h in C [ A ] let u(h) denote the vector (f;.(h))E C[A](").(Thus u = u(I).)Clearly u(0) E C'"), and we shall prove the result by showing u E u(0)G.Let I = (c E C :u E u(g + cAh)G for all g, h in C [ A ] ) , an ideal of C . If I = C we are done by taking g = A, c = 1, and h = - 1. Thus we assume I # C and aim for a contradiction. Taking a maximal ideal P 2 I of C we work in Cp[A,p ] where p is another indeterminate commuting with A and C . By proposition 5.1.50 u(A + p) is the first row of some matrix A = A ( I + p) in GL(n, Cp(A+ p)),i.e., u(A p) = e l A. Write A , for the image of A under p + 0, also an invertible matrix. Then B = A-'A, E GL(n, C,[A,p]) satisfies
+
u ( A + p ) B = e , , A , = u.
(12)
View B = B(A,p) as a matrix whose entries are functions in A,p; and likewise for B-' = B-'(A,p). Then B(I,O) = A i ' A , is the identity matrix, so the coefficients for Ai for i > 0 must all be 0. There is some c 4 P such that cB and cB-' are in C[A,p]. It follows that B(A,cp)€ M,(C[A,p]) with inverse B-'(A,cp), and (12) implies u = u(A + cp)B(A,cp). Specializing A -,g and p -,hA shows c E I , contrary to c 4 P, the desired contradiction. Q.E.D. Theorem 5.1.53: Euery f.g. projective FIAl,.. . ,A,]-module is free for any field F. Proof: Induction on t ; E = 0 is obvious. We need to verify the unimodular ..,A,)) be a unimodular vector with fi # 0. vector property. Let u = (f;.(ll,. By the Noether Normalization Theorem (cf., Lang [64B, p. 2601) we have some ct in F such that a f i is monic over pi,.. . ,p, - where the pi are algebraically independent polynomials. By Suslin's lemma au E GL(n,KIA1,. ..,A,])w for some w in F[pl, . . . ,p,- , I . Clearly, w is a unimodular vector and thus by induction is strongly unimodular. Hence uu is strongly unimodular, and so u also is strongly unimodular, as desired. Q.E.D.
Of course, theorem 5.1.53 is the solution to Serre's conjecture. This proof illustrates one of the features of the Russian school-translate a problem to matrices and tackle it there. Quillen's solution is more structural and also
30
Homology and Cohomology
has several very interesting ideas, cf., Quillen [%I. An excellent treatment of Serre's conjecture is to be found in Lam [78B].
M Supplement: Cancellation and Its Consequences Unfortunately, the Quillen-Suslin theorem does not generalize directly to noncommutative rings, in view of the fact that D[A,, I, J has nonfree projectives for any noncommutative division ring D (cf., exercise 9). Nevertheless, there are noncommutative results to be had, when the projective module is required to have sufficiently large rank. Suslin [79] lists a host of interesting theorems, including the following: Suppose R is f.g. as a module over a central Noetherian ring C of classical Krull dimension n. Let T be any ring obtained by localizing RCA,, ...,,I,] by a submonoid generated by various Ai. Then any projective T-module of rank > max( 1, n) has the form T B RM for a suitable R-module M . In particular, if D is a division algebra of dimension 22 = 4 over its center then every projective D[,ll,. . .,I,]-module of rank 2 5 is free. Actually, by using theorem 3.5.72 we can obtain some rather sweeping results which imply, for example, that "big enough" f.g. projective modules over are free. Recall s ( R ) from any Noetherian ring R with K,(R) = ([R]) definition 3.5.71. Lemma 5.1.54:
Suppose P 0 R z R(") and s(R) < n. Then P is free.
Proofi More precisely, P 0 Ru = R(") where u is unimodular, cf., the proof of proposition 5.1.49 (F). Writing u = (a,,. .. ,an) in R(") we thus have Ra, = R, so the stable range condition yields ri in R for which
1
1 R(ai + ria,,)= R ,
i
i,e., v is a unimodular vector in R'"- l ) (viewed in R'"))under the corresponding change of base. Hence Rv is a summand of R'"- '), so writing R'"- ') = Rv @ P' we get R(")z (Ru@ P ' ) 0 R = RU@ (P' @ R) = Rv @ R("-'). Factoring out Rv yields P = R'"'/Rv
%
R("-').
Q.E.D.
(This is sharp even for R commutative.)
Proposition 5.1.55: Suppose s ( R ) = k. If P is an f.g. stably free module which cannot be generated by k elements then P is free.
gS.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
31
Proofi Write P Q R('")FZ R(") and induct on m, the case m Q.E.D. the lemma (since, clearly, n > k).
=
1 given by
Corollary 5.1.56: If R is lefr Noetherian with K,(R) = ([R]), and if K-dimR = k, then every f g . projective which cannot be generated by k elements is free.
Proof: Apply theorem 3.5.72' to the proposition.
Q.E.D.
Projective modules of low rank need not be free, as we mentioned earlier, also, cf., $8.4. The following two properties obviously are related to the freeness of projectives: Property I . (Cancellation) I f M 0 R(") z N 0 R(")then does M z N? Property 2. Does a given module have R as a summand? These properties hold under much more general conditions than the Quillen-Suslin theorem. The exposition here follows Stafford [82]. We recall the notation of the normalized reduced rank
&M,P ) = p ~ , ~ ( M / P ~ ~ / p ~ ~where ~ ( Rp/ isP the ) reduced rank. Lemma 5.1.57: Suppose M , N are modules over a left Noetherian ring R, and K is an f.g. projective R-module such that @(K,5)2 @(M,5)for given prime ideals PI,..., P, of R. Given maps f: I< -+ M and f’:N + M we can find h: K + N for which
g(M/(f
+ f ' h ) K , 5 ) = @ ( M / ( f K +f ' N ) , q )
foreachlsjsm.
First assume m = 1 and let P = PI. Since K is projective any map h:K / P K + N / P N lifts to a map h: K + N via the diagram
Proofi
K
Homology and Cohomology
32
Thus we can assume that P = 0, i.e., R is prime left Noetherian and so an p ( K ) and, order in a simple Artinian ringQ. Thus we are given p ( M ) I letting M ‘ = f K + f ‘ N we want to find h: K + N for which p ( ( f + f ’ h ) K ) = p ( M ’ ) .Since (f + f ’ h ) K IM‘we can find h: K + N such that p ( ( f + f ’ h ) K ) is maximal. Replacing f by f f ’ h we may assume p ( f K ) 2 p ( ( f + f ’ h ) K ) for all h: K + N ; we want to show p ( f K ) = p ( M ’ ) , or by proposition 3.5.7 that M ’ / f K is singular. First assume p(kerf) > 0. If, on the contrary, M ’ / f K is nonsingular then there is some x in f ” such that (1K)x-l is not large and thus misses a left ideal L of R; in other words, L x (Lx + fK)/fK. Since K is a summand of R(”) for some n we see by means of tensoring by Q that there is a nonzero map h,: K -+ L such that hotkerf) # 0. Writing x = f ’ a for suitable a in N we have a map h: K + N given by hy = (h,y)a. Note f ’ h K = f ‘ ( ( h , K ) a )= ( h 0 K ) f ’ a = h0Kx; thus p ( f ’ h K ) = p ( h 0 K x ) = p ( h 0 K ) > 0. We claim the contradiction p((f + f ’ h ) K ) > p ( f K ) or, equivalently, p(ker(f f ‘ h ) ) < p(ker f ) . Indeed, if y E ker(f + f h) then fy = f hy E fK n Lx = 0 so y E kerf. Thus ker(f + f’h) I kerf. On the other hand, ( f + f’h)kerf = S’h kerf = h,(kerf)x and so by construction
+
+
0 f p(ho(kerf)) = p(h,(kerf)x)
=p((f
+ f”kerf),
proving p(ker(f + f’h)) = p(ker f ) - p((f + f’h)ker f ) < p(ker f ) , as desired. This contradiction arose from the assumption p(kerf) > 0, so we have p(ker f ) = 0. But now by hypothesis p ( M ) I p ( K )= p(f K ) I p(M’)I p ( M ) , so equality holds and we are done for m = 1. In general we apply the same argument inductively. Namely, we arrange the primes Pl, ..., P,,, such that if i < j then pi $ 8 (by starting with the largest ones and working down) and assume by induction the result has been proved for m - 1. Let A = PI n ... n P,,, - 1. Now A $Z. P,,, by arrangement of the Pi, so the canonical image A of A in RIP, is nonzero. But now we reduce to the case m = 1 by passing to RIP,,,, K/P,,,K, MfP,,,M, and AN/P,,,N since this has the same reduced rank as N/P,,,N. Q.E.D. Recall b ( M , P ) and b ( M , S ) from definition 3.5.67, and define b ( M ) to be b(M,J-Spec(R)) where J-Spec(R) is the set of prime, semiprimitive ideals of R. Remark 3.5.68(iii) shows b ( M ) I max {K-dim RIP g ( M , P ) :P E JSpec(R)).
+
Proposition 5.1.58: Suppose R is left Noetherian with n = K-dim R < CC, and K is an f.g. projective R-module for which g^(K,P)2 K-dim R I P 1
+
33
55.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
for all P in J-Spec(R). If b(R/f,K) In for some fl:K R then there are f2,. . . , f n + in Hom(K, R) such that b(R"+"/(f;)K) I n (viewing (h) as (f,?. . f n + 1): K -+ R("+I ) ) . -+
,
.?
froofi We shall prove by induction on t that for all t I n + 1 there are f i , . . . ,f, for which b(R")/(f,)K) I n, where ( A ) = (fl,. . .,f,);the assertion is given for t = 1. Let N = R(f)/(A)K.By induction we may assume that we have f2, ...,f,with b ( N ) I n; our first task is to find f,+l. Let Y = { P E J-SpecfR):b(N,P ) = n or K-dim R I P = n). Y is finite by proposition 3.5.70 and corollary 3.5.45'. Let R,+, denote thesubmodule(0, ..., 0,R)of R"+')andview R ( ' k R('+') via the first t coordinates. Letting f be the composition ( J ) :K 4R(') < R('+') and letting f’:R,+ R('+" be the canonical inclusion, we have by lemma 5.1.57 some map h: K -+ R, + for which
,
-+
g^(R"+"/(f
+ f ' h ) K , P ) = ij(R"+"/(fK + f ' R , + , , P ) =
for all P in 9 We take f,+
7=(L...,f,+J = f +f'h.
, to be
cj(R'"/fK, P ) = g^(N,P) the composition K
-+
R,+
-+
It remains to show b(R('+')/fl<, P ) I n for all P in J-Spec(R). If P have b(R"+"/TK, P ) Ig(R('+l)/fK, P ) + K-dim(R/P) = g ( N , P )
R and
E
Y we
+ K-dim R I P I n.
(The last inequality is clear if g ( N , P ) = 0, and if g ( N , P ) > 1 then y(N, P ) + K-dim R I P = b(N, P ) I n.) O n the other hand, if P $9'we use the exact sequence 0
+
-+
Rf+l/(Rl+I n (
f+~PR"+ I ) ) )
-+
+ PR('+'))
~('+l)/(flY
R(')/((L)K+ PR'") -+ 0;
since ij(M,P ) I 1 for any cyclic module, the additivity of reduced rank yields
+ g^(N,P ) . 2 K-dim(R/P) + g ( N , P ) + 1 I b ( N , P ) + 1 5 n g^(R"+"/TK, P ) I 1
Thus b(R"+"/fK,P) P $ X so we have proved b(R"+ "/fK) I n as desired.
since
Q.E.D.
We are finally ready for our main result, followed by the promised applications.
34
Homology and Cohomology
Theorem 5.1.59: Suppose R is a left Noetherian ring of K-dimn < a, and K is an f.g. projective R-module with g^(K,P) 2 K-dimR/P + 1 for all P in Spec(R). Given r E R and f:K + R for which R = f K + Rr, we can find some h': K + R such that R = (f + Fh')K, where ? denotes the right multiplication map by r. Proofi Let Pl,. . .,P, be the primes of R for which K-dim R / e = n, cf., corollary 3.5.45'. By lemma 5.1.57 there is h in Hom(X,R) for which g(R/( f Fh)K, 5)= g(R/( fK Rr), 6)= 0 by hypothesis. Let fl = f Fh. Note g(R/flK,P) I 1 for each P in Spec(R), since R/flK is cyclic. Hence proposition 5.1.58 gives us f 2 , . . . ,f n + in Hom(K, R) such that b(R("+')/Z?)I n, where Z?=(fi)K ={(fix ,..., f . + l ~ ) : ~ ~ Let K } el . ,..., en+lbe the standard base of R("+l),and write = (A). Clearly Re, = flKe, + Rre, so
+
+
7
R("+l)= d
+
+ Rre, + 1 Rei. n+ 1
i=2
But S ( R ( " + ~ )I / ~n )by theorem 3.5.72. Hence we have ri in R such that =
d+
n+ 1
i=2
R(e, + rirel).
In particular, el = (X)x + 112: ai(ei + rirel) for suitable x in K and a, in R. Matching coefficients of e, shows
O=fix+ai 1 = fix
= (fx
for2
n+l
+ C airir i=2
n+l
+ (hx)r) - i =
Putting h' = h - Cy2: Fifi we have 1 = (f as desired. Q.E.D.
2
(fix)rir.
+ Fh')x, implying R = (f + Fh')K
Corollary 51.60: (Serre's theorem generalized) Suppose R is a lejl Noetherian ring, and K is an f.g. projective R-module satisfying G(K, P) 2 K-dim R I P 1 for each P in J-Spec(R). Then R is a summand of K.
+
Proofi Taking f = 0 and r = 1 in the theorem, we have an epic K Q.E.D. which splits since R is projective.
.+ R
$5.1 Resolutions and Projective and Injective Dimension
35
Corollary 5.1.61: (“Cancellation”) Hypotheses as in corollary 5.1.60, any isomorphism a:K 0 R + M 0 R yields an isomorphism K -+ M . Proofi Let x , : M 0 R + R be the projection; then there are f l in Hom(K, R ) and f2 in Hom(R, R ) for which x 2 a ( k , r )= f , k f 2 r for all k in K and r in R. But f2 = F2 for some r2 in R and R = flK Rr, since no is onto, so theorem 5.1.59 provides h’: K -+ R for which R = (fl F2h’)K.In particular, there is x , in K such that 1 - r2 = ( f l + Fh’)x,. Define h: K 0 R + K 0 R by
+ +
h(x,r) = ( x
+
+ r x l , r + h’(x + r x l ) ) ,
an isomorphism since h-’ is given by h - ’ ( x , r) = ( x - r x l + (h’x)x,,r - h‘x). Then x,ah(O,r) = x z u ( r x l , r + h ’ ( r x l ) )= f l ( r x l ) + f i r + f 2 h ’ ( r x l ) = r(j,x,
+jih’xl)
+ f i r = r ( l - r 2 ) + rr2 = r,
implying ah(0, r) = (vr,r) for some v : R + M. Defining an isomorphism + M 0 R by j ( x , r ) = ( x - vr, r ) we see j a h restricts to the identity on 0 0 R, so we have a natural chain of isomorphisms
j: M 0 R
This result should be compared to exercise 2.9.16. In certain instances the bounds can be lowered, e.g., polynomial rings over simple Noetherian rings and Weyl algebras. The interested reader should consult Stafford [77, Sections 5,6,7] for such results. As mentioned earlier, more sweeping results are to be found in Stafford [81] and in Coutinho [86]. One of Coutinho’s results involves a sweeping generalization of the Eisenbud-Evans “basic element” theorem. Write M * for Hom(M, R). An element x of M is called pre-basic if the left ideal { f x :f E M * ) of R contains a nonzero ideal; x is basic if its image in the RIP-module M / P M is pre-basic for every P in J-Spec(R). Also we say r-rk(M) 2 n if for any given x,,. . . , x . - ~ in M and P in Spec(R) there are x , E M and f E M * such that 0 = f x , = ... = f x , - but f x , is regular modulo P. Coutinho [86, theorem 4.6.11 proves a “descent” for basic elements which yields the conclusions of corollaries 5.1.60 and 5.1.61 under the weaker hypothesis that r - r k ( K ) 2 K-dim R + 1. His result is very strong in view of the following: (i) K is not required to be f.g. (ii) K is not required to be projective!
36
Homology and Cobomology
(iii) The group K,(R) is easily seen to be generated by those projectives whose r-rk 5 K-dim R. As the reader can readily surmise, Coutinho’s dissertation is requisite for anyone interested in projective modules over noncommutative rings.
Large Projective Modules are Free Since the theory of f.g. projectives is so complicated, one might consider it even harder to study non-f.g. projectives. However, the opposite is true, as Bass [63] so skillfully pointed out. Remark 5.1.62: Suppose there is some infinite cardinal X for which the projective module M is generated by X elements and contains a summand isomorphic to R“’. Then M is free. (Indeed, writing M z M , 0 R“’ we have M , 0 M’ = R“) for some projective M‘, so M o 0 R‘” is free by Eilenberg’s trick (remark 2.8.4‘))
Thus to prove M is free we need merely find a “big” free summand R‘”. The first step, of course, is to find when R is isomorphic to a summand of M; since R is projective it suffices to find an epic f :M -+ R. This implies the trace ideal T ( M )= R, and we have the following converse.
OiEI Mi is
Lemma 5.1.63: Suppose R/Jac(R) is left Noetherian. Ij M = projective with I injinite and T ( M ) = R then R is a summand of M .
Proofi Let J = Jac(Rf. Given L, < R there is ft:M -+ R with f t M $4 L,; hence f, Mi $ L , for some i = i(t). Now we define the L, inductively by Lo = J and L , , = L , + LMi(,).Then Lo < L , < . . . so some L, = R since, otherwise, R/J has an infinite ascending chain of left ideals, which is impossible. Thus 1 = a + rr for suitable a in J and r, in f,Mi(,),implying r, is Q.E.D. invertible so @ A : By=, Mi,,)-+ R is epic, as desired.
c:=
Recall a module is said to be countable if it is generated by a countable set of elements. Corollary 5.1.64: Suppose R/Jac(R) is leff Noetherian and T ( M ) = R for every projective R-module M . Then every infinite direct sum of countable projectives is free.
$5.1 Resolutions and Projective and lnjective Dimension
37
Proof: Take an epic n: M + R. Writing 1 = nx we see x Iies in M ' = Bic, Mi for some finite I' c I; letting I" = I - I' and proceeding inductively in M" = @ i e l , , M i we have T ( M " ) = R by hypothesis, and continuing inductively we have R"' is a summand of M , where X = 111, so M is free by Q.E.D. remark 5.1.62. Note the hypothesis of corollary 5.1.64 was rather stronger than needed. We say a module M is uniformly big if M is generated by X elements for some cardinal X such that for all A 4 R, M / A M is nor generated by < X elements. Clearly, if M z F 0 N where F is generated by < X elements then N is uniformly big also. Furthermore, any uniformly big projective has T ( M ) = R since T ( M ) M = M by the dual basis lemma. Thus the argument of corollary 5.1.64 yields Proposition 5.1.65: Suppose R/Jac(R) is left Noetherian. Then every uniformly big projective which is an injinire direct sum of countable projectives is free. This result gains power when confronted with a theorem of Kaplansky that every projective M is a direct sum of countables. (Kaplansky's theorem is an immediate consequence of exercise 2.9.2.) If M is not countable then by matching cardinality we see M is an infinite direct sum of countables, yielding
Proposition 5.1.66: Suppose R/Jac(R) is left Noetherian. Any uniformly big projective M which is not countable is free.
To show any uniformly big projective M is free, we may therefore assume M is countable, and need find a summand R") of M. Bass [63] accomplishes this for R/Jac(R) left Noetherian, by a delicate manipulation of infinite matrices. His argument becomes much clearer if we d o not have to worry about Jac(R), so we prove the result for left Noetherian rings, leaving the more general case for exercises 25ff using an elegant reduction of Beck. When K-dim R is finite the next theorem also follows from Coutinho's work cited above. Theorem 5.1.67: M is ,free.
If R is leji Noetherian then every uniformly big projective
Proof: By proposition 5.1.66 we may assume M is countable. Write M 0 M ' = R'"' which has a standard base { e 1 , e 2...}, , and write the
38
Homology and Cobomlogy
generators of M as xi = c r i j e j for i = 1,2,.. . . Given any x = c r j e j in M we define suppx = ( j : rj # 0), a finite subset of N.1 Rri, is a left ideal of R and thus f.g. by elements of the form b, = x i a i k r i lwhere ai, E R. Note that only a finite number of i are involved in the b,; i.e., there is n = n(1) for which bk is the coordinate of e, in c f f i k x i .Thus subtracting R-linear combinations of the x i for i < n from the other xi we may assume 1 4 supp(xi) for all i 2 n. Continuing in this way for each j we have n(j) for which supp(x,) A { 1,. ..,j ) = 0 for all i 2 n(j). We now modify the idea of lemma 5.1.63 to build elements y, in M, left ideals L,, and maps f,:M -,R for t E N, by induction on t as follows: Suppose we have y, and f, for all u < t . Let L, = ~ : ~ ' , R f , y ,Let . t' be the largest number in ~ , ~ r ~ ~ and p plety nU= n(tr). Then suppy, n supp xm= @ for all u < t and all m 2 n. For each rn 2 n let A, = RrmjR,and A = cm2nA,.Then M J A M is(finite1y)generated by theimagesof x l r . . . , x n , so A = R since M is uniformly big. Hence A, $ L, for i some m 2 n, implying I j r m j R$tL, for suitable j, none of which is in supp y, for any y I t. Pick elements aj in R for which rmjaj4 L,, and let pj denote the right multiplicap j x j where nj:R'"' -+ R is the projection tion map by aj. Taking f, = onto the j-th coordinate, we have
cj
xfini,e
Efinite
A x , = A(
1rmjej) = C
Pjrmj
=
C rmjaj 4 Lt
and we take y, = x,. By construction fiy, = 0 whenever i # u. Also the Li are a strictly ascending sequence so some L,, = R and thus 1 = r&y, for suitable r, in R. But taking f = f, + ... + fi we then have 1 = f ( ~ : , O r U y so U) Ry, contains a copy of R which is a summand of M. Now we could repeat the whole procedure starting with j greater than any element in u u s i s u p py, and get a new copy of R which is a summand of M and independent of the first copy; continuing in this way we see inductively that R(") is isomorphic to a summand of M , so M is free by remark 5.1.62. Q.E.D.
cI=o
Bass' results are applied to commutative rings in exercise 32.
55.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors In this section we develop (as quickly as possible) the theory of derived functions with special emphasis on .%. and &xL, the derived functors of @ and *urn. Our reason is twofold: (1) We get much deeper insight into homological dimensions; (2) tools are forged which apply to diverse subjects in the
39
55.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
sequel. To do this we view projective resolutions more categorically, building homology and cohomology. We shall draw on the basic results of 55.0. To keep the discussion explicit, we work in the category R - A u d ; however, see note 5.2.5.
Definition 5.2.2: exact) of maps
A (chain) complex (A;(&))is a sequence (not necessarily
for all n in Z, such that d,d,+ = 0 for all n. The maps d, are called differentiations; when unambiguous A is used to denote the compkx (A; (d,)). We call the complex A positive if A , = 0 for all n < 0; A is negative if A , = 0 for all n > 0..We shall also find it convenient to call a complex almost positive if A, = 0 for all n < - 1; in this case the map d o : A o+ A - 1 has a special role and is called the augmentation map, designated as E. To unify notation we shall retain do. There is a category Vumfi whose objects are the complexes and whose morphisms f: A + A‘ are Z-tuples (fi) of morphisms f ; : A i + A : for each i, such that the following diagram commutes: d”+ I
. .. - A , +
d
A A , -
----*A, I.f”+.
... ---Ai+I
...
__I,
If”
4 + ,A:,
d:,
,A : , - , - . -
These morphisms f are called chain maps.
Example 5.2.2: Suppose (A; (d,)) is a complex. We can form a new complex (A’; (d;)) where A: = A,- and d i = d, - we can view d: A 4 A’ as a chain map. Note that A‘ here is almost positive iff A is positive.
,;
Although originating in topology, complexes are very relevant to the study of sequences of modules. Every exact sequence is obviously a complex. In particular, any projective resolution is an almost positive complex, and any injective resolution is an almost negative complex. Although functors do not necessarily preserve exactness they do preserve complexes. Thus if A is a complex and F:V + $9 is a covariant functor then F A is a complex of 9 given by
..--+ FA,+
- Fds+ I
FA, Fd” FA,-
+ ...,
There is a more concise way of describing complexes, in terms of graded objects. Suppose G is a given abelian group and M,M’ are G-graded
Homology and Cohomology
40
modules. A map M + M ' has degree h for suitable h in G if fM,E M i + , for all g in G. Taking G = H and A = A, in definition 5.2.1 we see d:A - + A is a map of degree - 1, leading us to the following alternate definition:
oiSz
Definition 5.2.3: A complex is a Z-graded module A together with a map d: A + A of degree - 1 satisfying d2 = 0. %OW+’ is then the category of H-graded modules, whose morphisms are those maps f:A + A' of degree 0 satisfying fd = d'f. As we just saw, any complex (A;(dn))of definition 5.2.1 gives rise to the complex (A;d) of definition 5.2.3 where A = @A, and d = @d,; and conversely. Thus %urn+ and %%m+’ are easily seen to be isomorphic categories, and we shall use the definitions interchangeably. One should note that definition 5.2.3 can be easily generalized, using different groups G in place of (H, +); G = (H('), +) is a useful candidate.
Definition 5.2.4: Dually to definitionn- I5.2.1, define a cochain complex A' to be a sequence ".cA"+l A"&-- A " - ' + " ' with each d"d"-' = 0 where, by convention, one writes superscripts instead of subscripts. Then one can define %?MU++ analogously.
-
In fact, there is an isomorphism %um/i.-+ %u~um+!i given by sending the complex . . . -+ A, + A + , A, + . . . to the cochain complex A' obtained by replacing n by -n, i.e., (A')" = A _ , and (d')" = d-". Note 5.2.5: If one worked with an arbitrary abelian category V instead of R - A u d one could formally define the corresponding category %'urn#@?) of and chain complexes. There is a formal isomorphism between %um/i.(%'OP) %ucum+!i(%)Op given by reversing arrows, so we see that V~m/i.(%)'~ and V O ~ + ( % are ' ~ ) isomorphic categories. Aiming for the best of both worlds, we work in R - A u d but keep the duality in mind, often skipping dual proofs (which can be filled in easily).
Homology We saw before that functors preserve complexes, and this is a good reason to consider complexes in preference to exact sequences. But then we should know when a complex is exact (as a sequence). Obviously the complex ... + A , + l -4, A I~ ~ A , _ I + . . . i s e x a c t at A n i f f kerd,/imd,+, =O,leading us to the following important definition:
$5.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
41
Definition 5.2.6: Suppose ( A , d ) is a complex, notation as in definition 5.2.3. Define Z = Z ( A ) = kerd, B = B(A) = dA (the image of d), and H = H ( A )= Z / B . B is called the boundary and Z the cycle, and H is the homology of A. Remark 5.2.7: Z and B are graded submodules of A , where Z,, = kerd, and B,, = d,, A,,+ Moreover, since d2 = 0 we have a canonical injection i: B + Z , so H is a graded module and is coker i. Dually one can define the coboundary Z’ = cokerd = A/B, and the cocycle B‘ = A/Z (the coimage of d). Then there is a canonical epic p : Z ‘4 E‘, and kerp z Z / B = H. Thus H is “self-dual.” Moreover, d induces a map d: Z ’ + Z, and we have the exact sequence -
o + H + 2 1 %z+ H + 0.
(1)
In view of the above discussion we have H z @,,EN H,, where H,,= ZJB,,. Thus H, = 0 iff the complex is exact at A,. We write H,(A) for H, when A is ambiguous. Actually Z ( ) and B( ) can be viewed as functors. Indeed if f : ( A ; d ) + ( A ‘ ; d’) is a map of complexes then f restricts to graded maps Zf:Z + Z’ and Bf: B -, B‘, by fact 5.0.2 applied to each f,,.Consequently we get a graded map f, : H ( A )+ H ( A’).
The Long Exact Sequence We will often want to compare the homology of different modules, especially those in an exact sequence.
Proposition 5.2.8:
The functor Z ( 1 is a left exact functor.
f A+ s A” is exact then ZA‘ --* Zf ZA + zg Proofi If 0 + A’ + ZA” is exact by the snake lemma (5.0.3(i));applying the same argument to 0 + 0 -+ A‘ + A shows Z f is monic. Q.E.D. Remark 5.2.9:
By duality Z’ is a right exact functor.
Now we have all the necessary requirements for a focal result.
J A 4 A”+ 0 is Theorem 5.2.10: (“Exact homology sequence”) If 0 + A’+ an exact sequence of complexes, then there is a long exact sequence ~ . ~ ~ ~ , , + ~f* ( A ’ ) ~ H , , + , ( A ) ~ H , , + , (/*A H“ ,) ,~( AH) ,2H,,(A”)A (A’)+ H, - ,(A’) + . . .
Homology pad cobomology
42
where a: H,,+ ,(A") --* ff,,(A') is obtained by applying the snake lemma to the exact sequence f"+1 Z;+l(A')-z:+l(A) *z:+l(A") -0
The rows of the sequences are exact by proposition 5.2.8 and Q.E.D. remark 5.2.9, so we are done by the snake lemma and (1).
Proof:
One could rephrase the conclusion of theorem 5.2.10 by saying the following graded triangle is exact:
Cohomology The same procedure applied to cochain complexes yields a cohomology functor from W O W + ( R - A O ~ ) to (72-graded R-modules}, and theorem 5.2.10 has the following dual theorem:
f A+ s A" + 0 is Theorem 5.2.11: (Exact cohomology sequence) r f 0 + A'+ an exact sequence of cochain complexes then there is a long exact sequence + H"(A')ff H " ( A ) Bf H"(A")4 H"+I(A') j* H n + l ( A )-+.. . --+
where the maps are deJined as in theorem 5.2.10. Cohomology turns out to be particularly useful in algebra, and we digress a bit to present an example of paramount importance for 97.2. First we transfer some terminology from algebras to groups. Suppose G is a group. A G-module is an abelian group M together with a scalar multiplication G x M --* M satisfying the axioms g ( x l x 2 ) = g x , gx,, ( g 1 g 2 ) x= g 1 ( g 2 x )and , l x = x, for all g iin G and x i in M .
ttefinition 5.2.12:
+
+
Formally we have merely written down whichever module axioms make sense. Looking at the G-module axioms from a different perspective, we could view the elements of G as maps from M to itself. In particular, any
$5.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
43
group M has the trivial G-module action obtained by taking gx = x for all g in G. A deeper example: If G is a group of automorphism of a field F then the multiplicative group M = F - ( 0 ) (rewritten additively) is a G-module under the given action of G. Example 5.2.13: Suppose M is a G-module. There is a very useful positive cocomplex A of abelian groups (i.e., Z-modules): A" = {functions f: G(")-+ M} where G'O' = { l}, and d":A" + A"+ is defined by
( d " f ) ( g i.,. .,g,,+ 1)
= Sif(Sz
1
+ i1 (= 1
...*g n + 1)
+ (-
1 ) " + Y ( g i , . . .9") ,
fl
I)Y(gl,
... ,gigi+ 1 , . . g n + 1). * 7
(2)
The cohomology groups are denoted H"(G, M), and are torsion if G is a finite group, cf., exercise 2. A key example: Any exact sequence of groups 1 -+ M + E -+ G -+ 1 with M abelian determines a G-module structure on M, by the following rule: Suppose x E M and g E G. View M E E (and thereby use multiplicative notation). Letting h be a preimage of g in E, define gx to be h-'xh (which is clearly in M). Note that this action is independent of the choice of h, for if h , E Mh then writing h , = hx, we have h i l x h l = x;'(h-'xh)x, = K ' x h since M is abelian. This set-up is called a group extension of G by M, and there is a correspondence given in Jacobson [80B, pp. 363-3661 between these group extensions and H 2 ( G ,M). In exercises 8.2.7ff. we shall see how group extensions tie in with division algebras.
Derived Functors f" P,, - --t . ' ' -+ Po + fo Proposition 5.2.14: Suppose P = . . . P,, + M -+ 0 is a 4 do projective resolution, and A = . . . -+ A,, + A,, - + . . . -+ A, -+ A - + 0 is an arbitrary exact sequence. %en any map g : M A _ , can be lijted to maps g i : 4 A i such that (g,,): P + A is a chain map, i.e., there is a commutative diagram -+
,
,
-+
-+
... -P,,-
f.
...-Po
fo ----+M-O
44
Proofi do:A, A, such that
Homology snd Cobomoiogy -+
A _ , is epic so we can lift gf,: Po + A _ , to a map go: Po
-+
= d,g,. commutes, i.e., gf, = dogo. Now, inductively, suppose we have 9,Applying 5.0.8 with P = Pn+l,T = g n f n + l , cp = d,, and JI = d,+l, we see = d n g m f n + 1 = 9.- Ifnf.+l = 0, so gnfn+ 1 = 7 = d,+ 10 for some Q: P,+ 1 A, + and we are done taking g, + = c. Q.E.D. -+
Dejinition 5.2.15: The n-th derived functor L,T of a given functor T: R-Mud + R'-Aud is defined as follows: Take a projective resolution f" P,_ + f.-1 P = . * * + P, -+ -+ M + 0
,
a * *
viewed as an almost positive complex, and put (L,T)M = H,(TP) = ker TfJim Tfn+l; given g:M -+M' define (L,T)g as follows: First take a projective resolution A of M', i.e., A _ , = M'; extend g to a chain map as in proposition 5.2.14, then apply T, and finally take the n-th homology map. We need to prove this is well-defined, i.e., independent of the choice of projective resolution. To this end we make the following definition:
Definition 5.2.16: Suppose (A; (d,)) and (A'; (di)) are complexes. Two chain maps g : A' -+ A and h: A' -+ A are homotopic if there are s,: A; + A,+ for each n such that h, - g,, = d,+ls, s,-
+
Proposition 5.2.17: Homotopic chain maps induce the same maps on the homology modules.
Proofi Suppose g : A' -+ A and h: A' -+ A are homotopic. For any cycle z in 2, we have h,z - g,z = d,+ls,z s,_,d:z = d,+ls,zE B,, so the induced Q.E.D. are equal. actions on H,,
+
One easy application of this result is a method of checking that a given sequence is indeed exact. Proposition 5.2.18: Suppose we are given a sequence of R-modules d,
d
A =...-+A,~A,_l-,...-rAo~A_l-,O
55.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
45
with do epic and d o d , = 0. I f there are group homomorphisms si:A i -+ A i + , such that each siAi spansAi+, and dos-, = l A - , and di+,si + s i - , d i = l A , for all i 2 0 then A is exact. Proofi didi+,si = di(l - si-,di) = di - ( 1 - si-,di-,)di = si-2di_,di= 0 by induction, so d i d i + , = 0 by hypothesis on si. Thus A is a complex. Now we see the chain map 1,: A -+ A is homotopic to the zero chain map, implying Q.E.D. the homology of A is 0, i.e., A is exact.
We are also interested in the opposite direction. To illustrate what we are aiming for, here is a partial converse to proposition 5.2.18. d
,
d
Proposition 5.2.18': Suppose . . . + P, 4 P,- --* * * * Po 3 P - -+0 is an exact sequence of projective R-modules. Then there are maps si:pi -+ P, + such that dos-, = 1 , - , and di+,si+ si- ,di = l p i for all i 2 0. -+
,
Proof: Since d o is split epic we can find spl with dos-, = l p - , . Now we merely proceed by induction on i, applying 5.0(8) to the diagram
to obtain si:&-+ pi+, satisfying di+,si = 1 - si-,di, or di+,si + si-,di = 1. Q.E.D. The same idea applies to homotopy.
Lemma 5.2.19: (Comparison lemma) Notation as in proposition 5.2.14. Suppose P is a projective resolution of an R-module M , and (A;(d,))is exact and almost positive. I f 9: M -+ A _ , is lgted to chain maps (g,),(h,): P + A as in proposition 5.2.14 then (g,) and (h,) are homotopic. Proof: Let qn = gn - h,, which lifts g - g = 0. We use 5.0.8 repeatedly. First note doqo = ( 9 - g ) f o = 0,so qoPo c d,A,, and thus there is so:Po + A , such that qo = d,so. Inductively, suppose we have defined s n - * :P,-, + A , suchthatq,-, =d,s,-, +s,-,S.-,. Weneedtodefines,suchthatd,+,s, = q, - s,- f,. To do this it suffices to show d,(q, - s,- ,f,)= 0. But d,q, d,sn- If = 4,- f , - (qn - s,_ zfn- ,) f , = s,- f,- f , = 0, as desired. Q.E.D.
,
~
, ,
46
Hornlogy and Cobornology
Proposition 5.2.20
Definition 5.2.15 is Well-defined.
Proof;. First (L,T)M is well-defined since for any two projective resolutions P, P’of M we have chain maps (gn):P + P’ and (h,,):P’-,P lifting l,, implying (hngn):P + P lifts 1,. But the identity map 1, lifts l,, so h,g, is homotopic to 1 by lemma 5.2.19, implying Th,Tg, is homotopic to TI = I, and thus (Tg,) induces an isomorphism of the homology modules, by proposition 5.2.17. The well-definedness of (L,T)g is proved analogously. Q.E.D. There is one case in which it is easy to determine L,T.
Remark 5.2.22: If P is projective then (L,T)P = 0 for all n. (Indeed, 0 -+ P -+ P 0 is a projective resolution where Po = P, and 0 + TP -+ TP + 0 is exact.) Let us now restate theorem 5.2.10 for left derived functors. If T is a right exact functor from R - A d to R’-Aud f M -Bf M “ + 0 there is a corresponding then for any exact sequence 0 + M‘ -+ long exact sequence
Theorem 5.2.22:
- -
( L T)f ... -+(L,+,T)M” + ( L , T ) M( L’ hT)f’ (L,T)ML (L,T)M” -+
(L,- 1 T ) M ’+ .. . -+ ( L ,T )M”
+ TM‘
Tf TM Tf TM“
+ 0.
Note: If T is not right exact then the conclusion becomes true when we replace TM’, TM, and TM” by (L,T)M’, (LoT)M,and (LoT)M”, but we shall not have occasion to use this generality. Before applying the theorem let us discuss it briefly. As usual we note that had the results above been stated more generally for abelian categories, the dualization would be automatic, so let us indicate briefly how this could have been done. As remarked at the end of 45.0 the results there hold for any abelian category 9.Assuming 9 has “enough projectives”, which we recall means for any object A there is an epic P + A with P projective, we can form projective resolutions for any object. On the other hand, the definition of homology is applicable in any abelian category (and actually could be formulated in terms of “graded objects” by means of coproducts). Thus the left derived functors could be defined for any abelian category with enough projectives, thereby yielding a general version of theorem 5.2.22. We leave the details to the reader, although we shall need the following consequence.
55.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
47
Corollary 5.2.23: Suppose T :59 -+ 9 is a right exact (covariant) functor of abelian categories, and % has enough projectives. T is exact iff the left derived functor L , T = 0.
f M' ' + f M + M" + 0 we have Proofi (e) For an exact sequence 0 + - - . + ( L I T ) M + ( L , T ) M " + T M ' Z T M +TM"+Oexact.Byhypothesis ( L I T ) M " = 0 so clearly T is exact. (a) Given any M" we could take an exact sequence with M projective; then ( L , T ) M = 0 and T f ' is monic by hypothesis, implying ( L , T ) M " = 0 for all M". Hence L I T = 0. Q.E.D. There are two ways to dualize the discussion; we could either switch the direction of the resolution or replace T by a contravariant functor. Let us describe these procedures respectively, assuming the underlying category has "enough injectives." Definition 5.2.24: The n-th right derived functor R " T of the functor T is given by ( R " T ) M = H"(TE), the n-th cohomology group of T applied to an injective resolution E of M ; likewise, ( R " T )f is the n-th cohomology map of T (f"), where (f ") is the extension of f: M + M' to injective resolutions of M and M'.
Theorem 5.2.25: If T is a left exact functor then for any exact sequence 0 + M ' + M + M" + 0 there is a long exact sequence O+TM'+TM
+
TM"+(R'T)M'+(R'T)M+...
( R ' T ) E = 0 for every injective E ; T is exact iff R'T Proof:
Dual to corollary 5.2.23.
= 0.
Q.E.D.
Definition 5.2.26: The n-th right derived functor R " T of a contravariant functor T is defined by ( R " T ) M = H"(7'P) where P is a projective resolution of M. (Note we use cohomology since T P is a negative complex.) Given f:M + M' we lift f to a map (fJ: P + P' of projective resolutions and define ( R " T )f to be the n-th cohomology map of T (f.).
Theorem 5.2.26': If T is a left exact contravariant functor then for any exact sequence 0 + M ' + M + M" + 0 there is a long exact sequence O+TM"+TM+TM'+(R'T)M"+(R'T)M+'.. T is exact iff R ' T = 0.
.
Homology and Cohomdogy
48
Proofi As in theorem 5.2.25.
Q.E.D.
Tor and Ext At last we are ready to define the functors which will help us to measure homological dimensions of rings. Definition 5.2.27: T =--OR M.
Tor:(-,
M) is defined as L,T: do&-R
Ext",(M,-) is defined as R"T:R-&od Exti(-, M) is defined as R"T: R-d'od
-+
-+
-P
d b where
d b where T = Hom,(M,-). d b where T = Horn,(-, M).
We delete the "R" when the ringR is understood. These definitions make sense because -0 M is right exact, Hom(M,-) is left exact, and Horn(-, M) is contravariant left exact. Let us review theorem 5.2.22, 5.2.25, and 5.2.26' for these particular functors. Summary 5.2.28: If 0 -+ N' + N + N" + 0 is exact in d 0 d - R or R-.Mud according to the context then there are long exact sequences
(i)
4 . -
3
Tor2(N",M) -P Tor'(N', M ) + Tor'(N, M )-+ Tor'("',
M)
+ N ' @ M + N @ M - , N"@ M 4 0
(ii) 0 Horn(M, N ' ) -+ Hom(M, N) + Hom(A4, N") + Ext'(A4, N') -+Ext'(M,N)+ Ext'(M,N")+ ExtZ(M,N')+*-*
(iii) 0 -+ Horn("', 3
M) -+ Hom(N, M) + Horn(",
M) -+ Ext'(N", M)
Ext'(N, M) + Ext'(N', M) -+ Ext2(N",M) + ...
There is a fundamental tie from Ext' to projectives and injectives. Proposition 5.2.29: Ext'(P,-) iff E is injectiue.
=0
iff P is projectiue; dualty Ext'(-,
E) = 0
Proof: We prove the first assertion. Let T = Hom(P,-). In view of corollary 2.11.6 we want to show R'T = 0 iff T is exact. (3) is immediate by theorem 5.2.25. (e) For any module N we can take an exact sequence 0-r N -+ E+ E/N -0 with E injective, so o+TN+ TE +T(E/N)-r(R'T)N+ (R'T)E = 0 is exact. Hence (R'T)N 'x coker(TE -+ T(E/N)) = 0 since T is Q.E.D. exact, proving R'T = 0.
$5.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
49
There is some ambiguity in notation since Ext"(M,N) could denote either Ext"(M,-) applied to N or Ext"(-,N) applied to M. We have seen these are both 0 for n = 1 when M is projective (by proposition 5.2.29 and remark 5,2.21), thereby motivating the next theorem, that the two interpretations of Ext"(M, N ) are the same. First we show this for n = 1. ~
Proposition 5.2.30: For this result write Ext(M,-) instead of Ext(M,-). Then ='(M, N ) % Ext'(M, N ) for all modules M , N .
Proof;. Take exact sequence 0- K + P-+ M - 0 and O-+ N + E + K'+O with P projective and E injective. Then we have the commutative diagram 0
I
0 -+Horn( M , N )
0 +Hom(F(,
I I
N)
Ext'(M,N)
1
0
-
0
I
Hom(M , E )
1
-
0
1 -=
'( M J )
I
' ( K , N ) -0
Hom( M , K')
Horn( K , E ) --* Hom(K, K ' )
1
0
1 1 0
-+0
Ext ' ( M ,K ' )
The zeros appear on the right and bottom because of remark 5.2.21 and proposition 5.2.29. Applying the snake lemma to the second and third rows gives the exact sequence Hom(M, N ) + Hom(M, E ) + Hom(M, K') + Ext'(M, N ) + 0. Thus Ext'(M,N)ecoker(Hom(M,E)+Hom(M, K'))%Ext'(M,N) as desired. Q.E.D. Remark 5.2.31: In the lower right-hand corner of the above diagram there is an isomorphism f : = ' ( K , N ) + Ext'(M, K'), sending any x in K ' ( K , N ) to its preimage in Hom(K, K ' ) and then to the image in Ext'(M, K ' ) . (The proof is by diagram chasing. First note that if y,y' are both preimages of x in Hom(K,K') then y - y' has a preimage in Hom(K, E ) and thus in Hom(P, E ) ; travelling down the other side of the square shows y - y' goes to 0 in Ext'(M,K'). This proves f is well-defined, and the same analysis going in the other direction enables us t o construct f - .)
'
Homology and Cohomology
50
In order to generalize proposition 5.2.30 to arbitrary n we need a way of shifting down. Lemma 5.2.32: If P is a projective resolution of M and K , is the n-th syzygy for each n then (L,+,T)M x (L,T)K,-, for any right exact functor T, for each 1 5 i 5 n. Proof: By induction it suffices to prove (L,+,T)M sz (L,T)K,. But we can cut P at Po to get a projective resolution... -+ Pz .+ Pl + K O-+ 0 of K O , which we call P'. By definition (L,T)K, =H,(TP')=H,+,(TP)=(L,+,T)M as desired. Q.E.D.
Proposition 5.2.33: Suppose K i is the i-th syzygy of some projective resolution of M. Then Tor,,+1(-, M) and Tor,,-i(-,Ki) are naturally isomorphic functors; also Ext"+'(-, M) and Ext"-'(-, Ki) are naturally isomorphic f lEl ... and functors. Dually suppose M has an injective resolution 0 -+ M -+fo E, let K f = cokerfi = E,/fEi-,, called the i-th cosyzygy. Then Ext"+'(M,-) and ExYi(Ki,-) are naturally isomorphic functors. Apply the lemma and its analog for maps; this yields the first asserQ.E.D. tion, and the others follow in the same way.
Proofi
instead of Ext(M,-). Theorem 5.2.34: For this result write %(M,-) Ext(M, N) x E ( M , N ) for all modules M, N , and all n.
Then
Proofi (Zaks) For n = 0 this is obvious and for n = 1 it is proposition 5.2.30. In general, take a projective resolution P of M, denoting the n-th syzygy by K,, and take an injective resolution IE, denoting the n-th cosyzygy as K b . Applying remark 5.2.31 to the exact sequences 0 -+ K O -+ Po + M -+ 0 0 yields Ext '( M, K ; - ') x Extl(Ko, Kb - 2). and 0 -+ Kb - -+ E ; - + K Iterating remark 5.2.31 we have Ext'(M,Kb-,) x Ext'(K,, K b - 2 ) % Ext'(K,,K:- 3) x ... x Ext'(K,- ',N). Applying proposition 5.2.33 at both ends yields -+
Ext"+'(M,N) x E x t ' ( M , K ; - , )
as desired.
Q.E.D.
We are now in a position for a basic result.
%
Ext'(M,K;-,)
85.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
Corollary 5.2.35:
51
The following are equivalent for a module P :
(i) P is projective. (ii) Ext'(P,-) = 0. (iii) Ext"(P,-) = 0 for all n. Proofi (ii) +(i) by proposition 5.2.29, and (if a (iii) by remark 5.2.21. (iii) a (ii) is obvious. Q.E.D.
Let us dualize all of this for Tor. Given a right module M we can define By Torf(M,-) as L , T : R - A o d + d d where T is the functor M&-. definition M is flat iff T is exact. Thus proposition 5.2.29 dualizes to Proposition 5.2.36: Tor,(F,-) = 0 iff F is a p a t right module; analogously, Tor,(-, F) = 0 iff F is a $at left R-module.
But any projective module P is flat, so an analogous proof to proposition 5.2.30 (but now using projective resolutions on both sides) shows T o r , ( M , N) is well-defined for any right module M and left module N. The analogous use of proposition 5.2.33 enables one to prove
Theorem 5.2.37: Tor,(M, N) is well-defined for any right modute M and lefi module N . Tor has fundamental connections to tensor products, and we shall need the following one in Chapter 6: Example 5.2.38: (i) Suppose 0 + K + F + M + 0 is an exact sequence of R-modules with F free, and A 4 R. Then T o r : ( R / A , M ) is canonically identified with ( K n AF)/AK. Indeed, applying T o r , ( R / A , - ) yields the exact sequence 0 = Tor,(R/A, F ) .+T o r , ( R / A ,M ) + K / A K + F/AF + M / A M
since K/AK FZ ( R / A )0 K and F/AF z ( R / A )0 F by example 1.7.21'. Hence we can identify Tor,(R/A, M ) with ker(K/AK -+ F / A F ) = ( K n A F ) / A K , as needed. (ii) If A , B 4 R then Tor,(R/A, R I B ) is canonically identified with A n B/AB, as seen by taking K = B and F = R in (i).
Homology aad Cobomobgy
52
Digression: Ext and Module Extensions Our objective in introducing Ext and Tor was to understand the homological dimensions better. However, there are more concrete interpretations of these functors, and we shall digress a bit to discuss Ext, leaving Tor for exercise 8ff. Given modules K, N we say an extension of K by N is an exact sequence f M 4 N -+ 0. Sometimes we denote this extension merely as M, 0 -+ K + with f,g understood. Two extensions M,M' of K by N are equiualent if there is a map cp: M -+ M’ such that f 9 0-K-M-N-0
commutes. Note by the 5 lemma that cp must be an isomorphism. The set of equivalence classes of extensions of K by N is denoted e(N, K). There is
Proposition 5.2.39:
Q
1 - 1 correspondence efN,K) -,Ext'(N, K).
Proof;. Given an extension 0 + K + M -+ N + 0 we shall define an element of Ext'(N,K) as follows: Take a projective resolution P of N, and using proposition 5.2.14 build the commutative diagram . .. -pz
- Ld p l
d A Po
do
0
AJ-
(1)
Now O=fld,=dzf, so f, yields an element in kerd:/imd:EExt'(N, K), and this is the element of Ext'(N, K )corresponding to our original sequence. By lemma 5.2.19 and proposition 5.2.20 this is well-defined and sends equivalent extensions to the same element of Ext'(N,K). Thus we have a functor @: e(N, K ) Ext'(N, K). Now we want to determine 0-l. Given a cocycle fl:Pl K we want to define a suitable extension. This will be done by means of the pushout (cf., 5.0.7). We are given 0 = d:fl = fldz, so we have a map 3 Pl/d,Pz + K, giving rise to the sequence -+
--f
0-Pi
d,
fd2P2-Po-N-
K
0
85.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
53
-
with d, monic. Taking M to be the pushout of the upper left corner yields -
0 -P,/imd2-
0-K-M-MK / -0
d,
Po -N
l7
i
do
I'
0
But (2) could also be rewritten as
O-K-M-M~K-o which is the same as (1). Any extension satisfying (1) could be viewed in this manner as a pushout, so the universality of the pushout shows the extension is determined uniquely up to equivalence. Thus we have, indeed, created W1. Q.E.D. Corollary 5.2.39':
Ext'(K, N )
=0
fi
every extension of K by N splits.
Proof: Every extension must be equivalent to the extension 0 + K 3 K 0 N 3 N +O. Q.E.D.
Homological Dimension and the Derived Functors We are finally ready to apply all this machinery to homological dimension; the proofs become much clearer intuitively. Theorem 5.2.40:
(i) (ii) (iii) (iv)
The following are equivalent for a module M:
pd M In; Extk(M,-) = 0 for all k > n; Ext"+'(M,_) = 0; The (n - 1 ) syzygy of any projective resolution of M is projective.
Proof: (i) =(ii) By definition of Extk(-, N ) we see Extk(M,N) = 0 for any k > n since M has a projective resolution of length n. Hence Extk(M,-) = 0 by theorem 5.2.34. (ii) + (iii) is a fortiori. (iii) + (iv) Let K,- be the (n - 1)" syzygy. Proposition 5.2.33 shows Ext'(K,% Ext"+'(M,-) = 0, so K,is projective by corollary 5.2.35. (iv) (i) By proposition 5.1.8. Q.E.D.
Homology and C -
54
One has the dual theorem for injective resolutions: Theorem 5.2.40':
The following are equivalent for a module N :
(i) N has injective dimension In; (ii) Extk(-, N ) = 0 for all k > n; (iii) Extn+l(-, N) = 0; (iv) The (n - 1) cosyzygy of every injective resolution is injectiue. @.dimR = sup{injeetive dimensions of the R-modules).
Corollary 5.2.41:
Proof: Each side = sup{k:Ext'(M, N) # 0 for all R-modules M and N}, Q.E.D. by theorem 5.2.40(ii) and 5.2.40'(iii). Using Ext one can show @.dim depends only on the cyclic modules.
Theorem 5.2.42:
(Auslander)gl. dim R = sup{pd R/L: L < R}.
Proof: Let n = sup{pd R/L: L < R ) ; then Ext"+'(R/L,-) = 0. We need to show for any injective resolution IE that the ( n - 1) cosyzygy K is injective. Well, Ext'(R/L, K )% Ext"+'(R/L, N) = 0, so Hom(R,K) -+ Hom(L,K) + Ext'(R/L,K) = 0 is exact by summary 5.2.28(iii). By Baer's criterion K is injective, as desired. Q.E.D. Corollary 5.2.43:
R is left hereditary ifl gl. dim(R) = 1.
Treating Tor analogously we discover a new dimension. In view of proposition 5.2.36 it makes sense to work with flat modules. Dewtion 5.2.44: A pat resolution of a module M is an exact sequence d d . + Fn2 Fm- 4 - , * . * + Fo 3 M =0 __+
where each Fnis flat. The p a t dimension of M is the smallest n for which M has a flat resolution of length n; the weak dimension, written w. dim R, is the supremum of the flat dimensions of all R-modules.
Proposition 5.2.45:
For any ring w. dim R Igl. dim R.
Proof: Any projective resolution is a flat resolution, since projective modules are flat. Q.E.D.
55.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
55
Of course w.dim R = 0 iff every R-module is flat, iff R is (von Neumann) regular. Since left Noetherian regular rings are semisimple Artinian, this raises the hope that w.dim R = gl. dim R if R is left Noetherian. In fact this is true, and implies gl. dim is left-right symmetric for Noetherian rings. These are other basic facts about w.dim are given in exercises 13Q of course YU.L enters heavily in the proofs.
Dimension Shifting Dimension shifting is a rather straightforward technique which lifts properties from Ext" to Ext"" and from Tor,, to Tor,+1 and thus transfers properties of Hom to Ext, and of @ to Tor. The idea is rather simple. Remark 5.2.46: "Dimension shifting". Suppose K 5 M. If Ext"(M,-) = 0 (for example, if M is projective) then Ext"+'(M/K,-) z Ext"(K,-) in the sense they are naturally isomorphic functors. (Indeed, Ext"+ '(M,-) = 0 by theorem 5.2.40, so summary 5.2.28(iii) yields the exact sequence
0 = Ext"(M, N) -+ Ext"(K, N) + Ext"+'(M/K, N) +. Ext"+'(M, N) = 0, implying Ext"+'(M/K, N) z Ext"(K, N) for all modules N.) Similarly, if Ext"(-, M) = 0 then Ext"+'(K,-) x Ext"(M/K,-). If Tor,(-, M) = 0 then Tor,+ ' ( M / K , - ) x Tor,(K,-). The principle of dimension shifting has already been used implicitly; this simple technique produces instant results. Remark 5.2.47: Reproof of summary 5.1.13. Suppose O+M'+M+M"+O is exact and n = pd M . Ext"+'(M,-) = 0, so by dimension shifting for all m > n. This yields cases I and I1 Ext"+l(M",-) x Ext"(M',-) ( n In') at once. For case 111 ( n > n') we need a similar but modified argument. Taking m > n’ we have 0 = Ext"(M’,N)-,Ext"+’(M",N)+Ext"+'(M,N)+Ext"+'(M',N) = O
for all N, so Ext"+'(M,-)
x Ext"'+'(M'',-).
Thus n
= n".
Our immediate interest in dimension-shifting is to extend certain basic properties from Hom to Ext, and from @ to Tor. Theorem 5.2.48:
Suppose F : R-Aod'
+ R-Mod
and G :d&+ d 8 is a pair
Homology and Cobomology
56
of right exact functors which commutes with Hom in the sense that there is a natural isomorphism Horn(-, F(Ni))z G(Hom(-, (Ni)) (as functors from R - A d to at&). Then F and G commutes with Ext" for all n E N, in the same sense. Proof:
Ext",P,-)
-
Take an exact sequence 0 -+ K -+ P 3 M --* 0 with P free. Since = 0 for all n 2 1 we have the commutative diagram
-
Ext"(M, F(N,))
Ext"-'(P,F(Ni)) -Ext"-'(K,F(N,))
1
0
I
Identifying Ext' with Horn we may assume by induction on n that the first two vertical maps are isomorphisms. (In fact, for n > 1 the left-hand terms are 0.)By property 5.0.2 the right-hand map exists and is an isomorphism, as desired. This is all natural, by inspection. Q.E.D.
R - A u d and G:d& -+ d i is a pair of left exact functors for which there is a natural isomorphism of functors -@ F(Ni) and G(- 63 (Ni)).Then there is a natural isomorphism of functors Tor,(-, F(N,)) and G(Torn(-,(Ni)).
Theorem 5.2.49: Suppose F : R-Aod"'
Proof:
Dual to theorem 5.2.48.
--+
Q.E.D.
Corollary 5.2.50: Suppose Ni are R-modules. Ext"(M,n N i ) z nExt"(M, 4) for every R-module M , and Tor,(M,UNi) z UTor,(M,Ni) for every right R-module M. (We write instead of @ to stress duality.)
n
1l
It suffices to prove is right exact, and dually is left exact. But given Ki --+ Li-+ Ni-+ 0 exact we see at once Li -+ & is epic with kernel Ki. Q.E.D. Proof:
Let us improve this result.
5
If I is a directed set then is left exact, in the sense that if ( A ; ;pi,), ( A i ;cpiJ and (A;;cpij) are systems indexed by I and 0 -+ A; + Ai -+ Af' is exact then 0 -+ & A: -+h Ai --+ l &A;' is exact. A: be the given map. Obviously, A: c kerf. Indeed, left f: I& Ai --* Conversely, suppose ( d i )E) kerf. By the construction in theorem 1.8.7 this Lemma 5.2.5Z:
5
5
55.2 Homology, Cohomology, and Derived Functors
57
means for suitable k 2 i we have qra(')E A ; . But defining a'"' to be pfa"' we see easily that (a'(i))equals (d') in A i , proving kerf = l& A:.
5
Proposition 5.2.52: set is directed. Proof:
Tor,(M,%
-
Nilz Iim Tor,(M, 4)whenever the
Apply lemma 5.2.51 to theorem 5.2.49.
index
Q.E.D.
We should record some variants of these results; the proofs
Remark 5.2.53: are analogous.
(i) Ext"(H M i , N ) z
n
Extn(Mi,N).
(ii) Torn(uMi, N ) zz UTor,(M,, N ) . (iii) T o r , ( 9 M i , N ) z
5 Tor(Mi,N ) for any directed index set I.
Other results of this genre are given in exercises 29-35; a detailed treatment is given in the classic Cartan-Eilenberg C56BJ. There are many papers in the literature which study the homology of particular rings, but we should like to point the reader to Rinehart-Rosenberg [76] and RosenbergStafford [76], who by a careful use of projective resolutions calculate explicitly the homological dimensions of modules over rings of differential polynomials and over Weyl algebras.
Acyclic Complexes Homology gives us an important connection between complexes and projective resolutions by means of the following definition: Definition 5.2.54: n > 0.
A positive complex ( A , d ) is acyclic if H,(A) = 0 for all
-
Remark 5.2.55: The acyclicity condition means -+
A,,
dm+i
4 ' .. f d A, + A.
+0
is exact at A, for each n > 0. On the other hand, H o ( A ) = A o / d , A , , SO we have the exact sequence
... + A , ,
,%A , 4 ... 5 A , + H , ( A ) + 0.
(This is why we have been considering almost positive complexes). Thus we
Homology and Cohomology
58
have a projective resolution of H,(A) if A , is projective for each n 2 0, or, equivalently, if A = A , is projective. Reversing the argument shows a projective resolution can be viewed as a positive acyclic complex which is projective. Proposition 5.2.56: Suppose ( A ,d ) and (A', d ' ) are complexes of vector spaces over a field F. Let A = A @FA', which is graded via A, = @,,+"=,A , OFA:, and define a dfleerentiation d' by &(a 0 a') = d,a 0 a' + ( - 1)'a 0 d:a' for a E A , and a' E A : . Then (i) (A, 2) is a complex. (ii) If A and A' are acyclic then so is canonically.
2, and H o ( i ) = H,(A) 0 Ho(A')
Proof? For purposes of calculation we shall take a E A , and a' u+v=n. (i)
2,- l&(a 0 a') = d,= d,- ld,,a
0 a'
,(d,a 8 a'
+ (-
+ (-
E
A:, with
1)"a@ dka')
+ (-
1)"- ' d Y a@I d:a'
l)"d,a 0 dka'
+(-l)"a@d:-1d:a'=O since the middle two terms cancel and the end terms are each 0. (ii) We verify the condition of proposition 5.2.18 for 2. Let E : A , + H,(A) and E ' : A; -+ Ho(A') be the canonical maps, and = E C3 E'. By proposition 5.2.18' we have s-,: Ho(A)+ A , and si:Ai -+ A i + , for i 2 0 satisfying E S - ~ = -1, dlsO + S - , E = 1, and di+lsi + ~ ~ = -1 for~ all di > 0. ~ Likewise, -I 1, ~ we have sLl: H,(A') + Ah and si: A: + A : + , for i 2 0 satisfying E '=s dish + sL1d = 1 , and d:, ,s: + si- I d ; = 1 for all i > 0. Define
a.
n
F-,=s-,@sl,
-
and
T,,=S-,E@S:,+ C s i @ l
-
i=O
Then do?-, = 1 0 1 = 1. It remains to show d,+lF, n 2 0, which will be seen by evaluating it on a, 8 a,. Case I. u > 1. Then
-
(d,+
-
+ F,,-,&)(LI @ a ' ) = d,,
,s,a
-
+ T,-,d,
8 a' + F,- ,(d,a 8 a'
+ (-
forn20. =
1 ) " @~J dka')
+ ( - l ) y +@ld:a' ~,~ + s,- ldua 8 a' + ( - l)"s,a @ dka' @ a' = a @ a'. = (dU+ls, + s,= d,, ,s,a @I a'
1 for all
59
55.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras
Case II. u = 1 . Same calculation as in case I, except with the extra term s-,&d,a0sia' = 0 (since &dl = 0). Case I I I . u = 0.
-
-
(d,,+lF,,+ F,,-,d,)(aQa') = d , + l ( ~ - l ~ a Q s ~ a ' + s o ~ ~ ~ ' ) + F n _ l ( ~ ~ d I
= s-
+
,&aQ d l , Isha' + d,s,a Q a' S-
+ sou 0d i d + sL- ,db)a' + d,soa Q a'
,&aQ sk - , d i d
= S - ,&a 0 (dL+ = (s-
- sou Q dka'
+ d,so)aQ a'
=
u Q a'.
Q.E.D.
If R is an F-algebra and P, is a projective resolution of Mk for k = 1 , . . .,m then M , OF.. . QFM,, has the projective resolution F- = @ r = , P k where F,,= . . . + u , = n ( P l ) y l Q ~ ~ ~ Q (and P , ) u;,,:F,,+ , Pn- is given b y
Corollary 52.57:
o,,+
where each a, E (Ai),$and u(i) =
uk.
Proofi View each P, as a direct sum of projectives, which is thus projective; hence P is projective by the easy remark 5.3.0. Furthermore, P is a projective OFM,, by the proposition (since everything can be resolution of M , OF... viewed naturally as vector spaces over F.) Q.E.D.
Some remarks about these results. Proposition 5.2.56 is a special case of the Kunneth formulas of algebraic topology. The reader's eyebrows may have been raised by the sign in the formula for the differentiation. This sign arises naturally in the definition of tensor products of morphisms of Z-graded modules and is discussed in detail in MacLane [63B, Chapter VII, esp. pp. 190-1911.
$5.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras As noted several times earlier, one can bypass the asymmetry between left and right modules by dealing with bimodules. On the other hand, we want the powerful techniques of module theory at our disposal, so we view R - R bimodules as R Q RoP-modules, cf., proposition 1.7.31. Rather than taking
60
Homology and Cohomology
tensors over Z,we shall consider the more general case where R is an algebra over an arbitrary commutative ring C , and shall write Re for R OCRoP. Furthermore, we assume throughout that M is an R - R bimodule respecting the algebra structure, i.e., c x = xc for all c in C , x in M . Thus we shall view M canonically as Re-moduie, by the action (rl 0 r z ) x = r 1 x r 2 ;also (c 0I)x = (1 Q c)x for all c in C. Now we can define the Hochschild homology and cohomology groups HJR, M ) = Tor,(R, M )
and
H”(R, A4) = Ext”(R, M )
where the base ring is Re. Although there is a lovely theory developed in Hochschilds articles, Cartan-Eilenberg [56B], and the series “On the dimension of modules and algebras” in the Nagoya Journal (1950s), we focus on the special case where R is a projective Re-module. This provides a modern and natural setting for the classical theory of separable algebras, cf., definition 2.5.28, and, in particular, for Wedderburn’s principal theorem. We shall also deal with “Azumaya algebras,” in preparation for Chapters 6 and 7. Our treatment follows Knus-Ojanguran [74B], Jacobson [SOB], and DemeyerIngraham [71B]. Remark 5.3.0: If P; are projective C-modules then PI OcP2is projective. (Indeed, if 6 z pi 0 Pi is free then
PI 6 Pz @ ( P i 0 Pz 0 PI 0 P ; 0 P ; 0 Pi) = (PI 0 p ; ) B ( p z 0 Pi)
= F, 0Fz is free.) Remark 5.3.0‘: If P is a projective C-module and R is a C-algebra then R Qc P is a projective R-module. (For if P @ P i = F then R 0 P 0 R 0 P’ z R 0F is free by corollary 1.7.16.) Remark 5.3.2:
R is a cyclic Re-module (spanned by l), and there is an epic
p: Re + R in R ‘ - d ~ a ! given by p ( z r l i 0 rZi)= x r l i r 2 i . Letting J = ker p
we have the exact sequence of Re-modules 0 -P J + Re --+ R -+ 0. The notation J and p has become standard, and we shall use it without further ado.
Proposition 5.3.2:
J = ErrR Re(r 0 1 - 1 0 r).
Proofi ( 2 )is clear. ( C ) If a = x r i , 0 ri2 E J then x r i l r i z = 0 so Q.E.D. a = x i ( r i l 0 1)(1 0 r i 2 - ri2 0 1) as desired.
g5.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras
61
The exact sequence of remark 5.3.1 yields an exact sequence HOmRe(R,M) HomRe(R', M) + Horn,@, M) -+ ExtA,(R, M) + 0
Remark 5.3.3:
0 -+
-+
since Ext;.(R', R) = 0. To interpret the other groups we need some definitions. First define M R = {x E M: rx = xr for all r in R}, viewing M as R - R bimodule; translated to R'-MuLL the condition reads (r @ l ) x = (1 @ r)x, i.e., J x = 0. Next define Der(M) = i d : R -+ M: d ( r 1 r 2 = ) (dr1)r2+ r l d r 2 ) , the set of derivations of R in M. Translated to R'-Aud this condition reads as 8 ( r 1 r 2 )= ( 1 0 r2)dr1 (rl 0 l)dr2. We can view Der(M) as C-module by defining (cd)x to be c(dx). For any x in M we define the inner derivation 8, by d,r = (r @ 1 - 1 @ r)x. When M = R e we write 6 for 8,w l , i.e., 6r = r @ 1 - 1 0 r. In fact, 6 E Der(J) by proposition 5.3.2. Let us view this fact in context.
+
Proposition 5.3.4: HOmR.(R,M ) % MR via f I-+ f l ; HOmRe(J,M ) % Der(M) via f H fS. Consequently, we have an exact sequence 0
-+
M R -+ M -+ Der(M) -+ ExtA.(R, M) -+ 0
Proof: The last assertion is obtained by matching the given isomorphisms to remark 5.3.3, noting also Hom(R', M) % M by f H f l . Thus it remains to verify the two given isomorphisms. Define cp: HomRe(R,M) -+ M R by cpf = f l ; note f l E M R since ( r 0 1 - 1Or)fl =f(r-r)=fO=O. Thus cp is a map whose inverse M R -+ HomR,(R, M) is given by sending x to right multiplication by x. Next define II/:HornR@, M ) -+ Der(M) by II/f = fS; f6 is in Der(M) since f S ( r 1 r 2 )= f((1 @ r2)8r1
+ (rl @ 1)SrJ = ( 1 0 r 2 ) f 6 r , + (rl 0 l ) f 6 r 2 .
kertj = 0 since f6 = 0 implies f J = 0 by proposition 5.3.2. It remains to show t,b is onto. Given d E Der(M) we define Re -+ M by means of the balanced map g: R x RoP.+ M given by q(a, b) = - ( a 0 l)db, and let f be the restriction of to J . Then f E Hom(J, M), for if a, @ bi E J then
a:
c
a
f((r1 0 r2)C.i 0 bi) = C f ( r , a i 0 bir2)= - C ( r l a i @ l)d(bir2) =
+
-c((rlai 0 1)(1 0 r2)dbi (bi0 1)8r2)
+ ( r IC a i b i 0 l ) d r 2 ) (rl 0 r,)c(ai 0 l)dbi + 0 = (r 0 r 2 ) f ( 1ai 0bi).
= - x ( ( r l a i 0 r2)dbi =
-
Homology and Cohomology
62
But f a r = f ( r @ 1 - 1 @ r )= - ( r @ l ) a l + ( l @ l)dr=O+ dr, proving fh = d as desired. Thus $ is onto. Q.E.D. Corollary 5.3.4’:
(i) Hom,,(R, R) x Z ( R ) . (ii) HornR@, Re) x Ann’ J , the right annihilator of J in Re, under the correspondence f H f 1 . (i)Take M = R. (ii)Take M = Re. Then Hom,.(R, M) x M R { x E M : ( r @ 1)x = (1 @ r)x for all r in R ) = Ann’(r@ 1 - 1 @ r:r E R ) = Ann’J. Q.E.D.
Proofi
Remark 5.3.5: In the exact sequence of proposition 5.3.4 the map M Der(M) is given by sending x in M to the inner derivation a,. Thus Ext’(R, M) 3 0 iff every derivation of R in M is inner. --$
Separable Algebras Definition 5.3.6:
R is a separable C-algebra if R is projective as Re-module.
There are several nice criteria for separability. Theorem 5.3.7:
The following conditions are equivalent:
(i) R is separable. (ii) Extk.(R, M ) = 0 for every R-module M. (iii) There is an element e in (Re), such that pe = 1 where p : Re canonical epic. (iv) The epic p : Re -+ R restricts to an epic -+ Z ( R ) , (v) Every derivation of R in M is inner, for every module M.
-+
R is the
Proofi (i) e (ii) by corollary 5.2.35. (i) => (iii) p splits so there is a monk f: R Re for which pf = 1,; take e = f l . (iii) (iv) p((z 0 1)e) = z for any z in Z(R). (iv) => (iii) trivial. (iii) 3 (i) Define f: R + Re by f r = (r @ 1)e; we see f((rl @ r z ) r )= f (r1rr2)= (rlrr20 1)e = ( T I T 0 1)((r20 114 = (r,r 0 r2)e = (rl @ r 2 ) f r ,proving f is a map. Hence p is split so R is a summand of R e and thus projective. (ii) e (v) by the exact sequence of proposition 5.3.4. Q.E.D. --$
63
$5.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras
I hope no confusion will arise from the use of the symbol e both as part of the notation Re and as an element thereof.
xijl
Remark 5.3.8: The element e of theorem 5.3.7(iii) is called a separability idernpotent of R and is indeed idempotent since writing e = 8 rj2 we have e2 = C(rjl o 1)(1 O rjz)e= =
(crjirjz
C(rjl o l)(rjzo 1)e.
Q 1)e = (1 @ 1)e = e.
Obviously C is separable over itself since C z C'. MJC) is separable since M,,(C)0 M,(C)OPw M,,(C)8 M,,(C)w MJC) where t = n 2 . Other examples are had by means of the separability idempotent, so let us record some of its properties. Remark 5.3.9: Suppose e is a separability idempotent of R and let Z = Z ( R ) . (i) eRe G since ( r 0 1)ex = ((r 0 1)e)x= ((1 0 r)e)x = (1 0 r)ex for x in Re; (ii) p(eRe)= Z by (i) and theorem 5.3.7(iv); in fact p(e(z0 1))
= p((z O
1)e)= z
for z in Z; (iii) Z is a summand of R as Z-module since r H p(e(r 0 1)) defines a projection R + Z fixing Z , by (ii); (iv) If A 4 Z then A = Z n A R by (iii) and sublemma 2.5.22'
Proposition 5.3.10: (i) If Ri are separable C-algebras then R , x R , is a separable C-algebra. (ii) If R,are separable C,-algebras where Ciare commutative C-algebras then R , OCR , is a separable C , Qc C,-algebra and Z ( R i 0 R2) = Z(R1)0 Z(R2).
Proofi
Let e, be a separability idempotent of R , .
(i) Viewing R', x R$ c ( R , x R,)" canonically we see by inspection (e,,e,) is a separability idempotent. (ii) R , @ R , has the separability idempotent e = el O e,, and thus is separable. Let Z = Z ( R , @ R z ) . Clearly Z ( R , ) 0 Z(R,) c 2. Conversely, if
64
Homology and Cohomology
Exumple 5.3.11: (i) The direct product of copies of C is separable. (ii) If S is a submonoid of C and R is separable then S-'R z S-'C Q c R is separable (with the same separability idempotent). (iii) If R is separable then M,(R) z M,(C) 0 R is separable. (iv) (extension of scalars) If R is separable and C, is a commutative C-algebra then C, OCR is a separable C,-algebra.
Proposition 5.3.12:
If f: R R' is a surjection of C-algebras and R is separable then R' is separable and Z ( R ' ) = f Z ( R ) . -+
7
Proof: Let p : R e -+ R and P ' : ( R ' )-, ~ R be the usual epics. Let = f Q f: R e -+ (R')e.Then fp = p'f Letting e be a separability idempotent of R, we see r e is a separability idempotent of R', proving R' is separable. Further' ) remark 5.3.9(ii). more f ( Z ( R ) )= fp(eR')= p f ( e R ' ) = p ' ( ( ~ e ) ( R ' ) " ) = Z ( Rby Q.E.D.
Proposition 5.3.13: C'-algebra.
Suppose C' i s a commutative C-algebra and R is a
(i) If R is separable over C then R is separable over C'. (ii) If R is separable ouer C' and C' is separable ouer C then R is separable over C. Proof;.
(i) The canonical epic R OCRoP-+ R factors through R Qc. RoP,so we get a separability idempotent. (ii) By definition 5.3.6 C' is a summand of (C')' = C' OCC'. Tensoring by Re over (C')' yields R 0,. ROP is a summand of Re.But R is a summand of R OC.RoPby hypothesis, so R is a summand of Re. Q.E.D. To make separability "descend," we consider the following set-up: C' is a commutative C-algebra and R, R ' are algebras over C, C', respectively, such that C' is a summand of R'. Write (R’)’ for R'O,.(R')"*. As C'-algebras
$5.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras
65
(R OcR'y z Re Oc(R')' so any (R 0 Rt)e-modulecan be viewed naturally as Re-module via the map Re + R e 0 I . In particular, if R 0 R' is separable as C'-algebra then R 0 R' is a summand of (R 0 R')e as module over (R 0 R')' and thus as Re-module. To conclude R is separable over C we merely need to show
(if R is a summand of R 0 R', and (ii) (R 0 R')' is Re-projective.
-
(i) is clear if C 1 is a summand of R' as C-module, since then we tensor on the left by R. O n the other hand, (ii) follows if (R')e is projective as C-module since then we tensor on the left by R e . In case R' is projective as C-module we thus have (ii) if R' = C' (trivially), or if C' = C by remark 5.3.0. This provides the following two important instances of descent:
Proposition 5.3.14: (1) If R OcR' is separable over C and R' is faithfully projective over C then R is separable over C . (2) l f R OcC' is separable over C' for a commutative algebra C' which is faithiilly projective over C then R is separable over C .
-
Proof: By proposition 2.1 1.29 if R'is faithfully projective over C then C 1 is a summand of R'. Hence (i) of the above discussion is satisfied, and (ii) also Q.E.D. holds since C = C' in (1) and R' = C' in (2).
Proposition 5.3.15: If R is separable over C and R is faithfully projective over a commutative C-algebra C' then C' is separable over C. R is a summand of R e which is projective over (C')e,so R is projective over (C')e.But by proposition 2.1 1.29 C' is a summand of R as C'-module and thus as C'-bimodule since C' is commutative (so we copy out the same scalar multiplication on the right also), and thus as (C')'-module. Hence C' is Q.E.D. projective over (C')'. Proofi
We are ready to justify the name "separable", also, cf., theorem 5.3.18.
Proposition 5.3.16: Suppose R is a jinite jield extension of a subjield F. This field extension is separable iff R is separable as F-algebra. Proof: In view of propositions 5.3.1 3 and 5.3.15 we may assume R is a simple
66
Homology snd Cohomology
field extension, i.e., R = F [ r ] x F[A]/(f ) for some irreducible polynomial f in F[A]. (+) Let K be a splitting field of f over F. Then K 8 R x R(")where n = deg f, by the Chinese Remainder Theorem, cf., after remark 2.2.7, so K 0 R is separable as R-algebra, implying K is separable as F-algebra by proposition 5.3.14. (I) Suppose the field extension were not separable. Then char(F) = p > 0 and R x L[L]/(A"- a ) for some field L c R and a E L. Then differentiation with respect to 1 yields a nontrivial derivation of R, which cannot be inner since R is commutative, so R is not separable by theorem 5.3.7(v). Q.E.D. Proposition 5.3.17: Suppose R is a separable C-algebra and is projective as C-module. Then R is f.g. as C-module. Proofi Take a separability idempotent e = x f i n i t e r j0 l r j z . Picking a dual base { ( x i , J ) i: E I } of R we have J r j l = 0 for almost all i, and we claim the xirj2span R. Indeed, for any r in R we have
as desired.
Q.E.D.
Theorem 5.3.18: An algebra R over a field F is separable in the sense of this section i f f it is separable in the sense of definition 2.5.38. Proof: (a) First we show R is semisimple Artinian. It suffices to show Hom,(M,-) is exact for any R-module M, by corollary 2.11.6. But Hom,(M,-) is exact. Furthermore, Hom,(M, N) is an Re-module (i.e., R - R bimodule) by remark 1.5.18; the explicit action is ((rl 0 r 2 ) f ) x = r l f ( r 2 x )for f in Hom(M, N). Then Hom,(M, N ) = (Hom,(M, N ) ) , x HOm,,(R, HOm,(M, N ) ) by proposition 5.3.4. Thus Hom,(M,-) is the composite of the exact functors Hom,(M,-) and Hom,,(R,-) (noting R is Re-projective), so R indeed is semisimple Artinian. Let K be the algebraic closure of F. Then R OFK is separable, so by the first paragraph is semisimple Artinian and f.d. over K by proposition 5.3.17 implying R BFK is split. Now for any field extension L of F let L’ be the composition of K and L; then R 0 L’ is split, so R OFL is semisimple Artinian. Hence R is separable in the sense of definition 2.5.38.
67
$5.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras
( G ) Let K be a splitting field of R. Then R OFK is separable over K by example 5.3.11, implying R is separable over F. Q.E.D.
Hochschild's Cohomology Having seen that this notion of separable generalizes the classical notion and is more elegant, our next objective is to redo the classical theory of separable algebras in this context, in particular to recast Wedderburn's principal theorem in this setting. First we want Hochschild's explicit description of his cohomology groups. Construction 5.3.19: Assuming R is projective as C-module, we shall construct an explicit cochain complex for any Re-module M . Define C"(R, M ) = Homc(R("),M ) (so Co(R,M ) = M ) and define the cochain map 6": C"(R, M ) + C"+'(R, M ) by
6"fr1, * * *
9
rn+ 1)
= r l f ( r 2 9 . ..3 r n +
1)
for ri in R. Let B" = 6"-'C"-'(R, M ) and Z" = ker6".
We want to identify H"(R, M ) with Z"/B".To do this we must identify this cochain complex with a cochain complex arising from Horn(-, M ) applied to a projective resolution of R in R e - 4 u d . Define P, = R@("+,)for each n 2 - 1, viewed naturally as R - R bimodules (i.e., R'modules). Then Po z R e and the P, are all projective C-modules by remark 5.3.0, implying P, z R'O,P,_, is a projective Remodule, by remark 5.3.0’.Now by the adjoint isomorphism HOmR.(P,, M ) % HO~R.(P,- 2
z Hom,(P,
- z,
Re, M ) Z Hom,(P,
- 2,
HOmRe(Re,M ) )
M ) z C"(R, M )
the last isomorphism arising from viewing an n-linear map as a balanced map. It remains to define the differentiations a,: P, -+ Pn- 1, by "+I
We have a diagram
Homology and Cohomology
68
where p is as in remark 5.3.1. Define s,: P, + P,+ by s,(xI @ ... @ x , + ~ )= 1 O x , @ . - . @ x n t 2 .Clearly s,P, spans P,+*, p s - , = l R , and a,,,s, s,- ,a,, = 1 on each P,,, by direct computation. Hence P is a projective resolution by proposition 5.2.18. Moreover, we have a commutative diagram
+
Horn,,(!',,
M)
?I
HOmR,(P,+ 1, M )
which yields the desired isomorphism of H"(R,M )with the cohomology group of ( P ;a), i.e., with Z"/B". Let us look at certain relevant cocycles and coboundaries. A map f:R + M is in B’ iRf = h 0 x for some x E Co(R,M ) % M, i.e., f is the inner derivation with respect to x.
f: R
+M
is in Z' iff r J r 2
-
f ( r l r 2 )+ ( f ' r l ) r 2= 0
for all ri in R ,
i.e.,f is a derivation of R in M. This shows H ' ( R ,M )is the derivations modulo the inner derivations, a result implicit in the proof of proposition 5.3.4. A map f:R'" + M is in B 2 iff there is g: R + M for which f ( r 1 , r 2 )= rlgr2 - g ( r 1 r 2 ) ( g r 1 ) r 2for all ri in R . Now we have a much more intuitive proof of a strengthening of Wedderburn's principal theorem (2.5.37).
+
Theorem 5.3.20: (Wedderburn's principal theorem revisited) Suppose R is a finite dimensional algebra over a j e l d F, with H z ( R , - ) = 0. Then R has a semisimple Artinian subalgebra S for which R GZ S 0 Jac(R) as vector spaces over F.
Proofi As in the"genera1 case" of the proof of theorem 2.5.27 we can reduce readily to the case N 2 = 0 where N = Jac(R). Let V be a complementary vector space to N in R . Then V % R / N as vector spaces, and this would be an algebra isomorphism if V were closed under multiplication in R , implying V were semisimple Artinian, as desired. Hence we want to modify V by suitable elements of N to make V multiplicatively closed. Letting TL: R -+ V be the vector space projection define f : R'') -+ N by
$5.3 Separable Algebras and Azurnaya Algebras
69
Then df(r17 12 > r 3 ) = r l f ( r 2 > r 3 )
- f(r1 r 2
> r3)
+f(rl
9
r2r3)
-
f(rlr 2 ) r 3 9
+ n(rlr2)nr3 + nr1n(r2r3)-n(rlr2)r3+ l i r 1 ( m 2 ) r 3 = (rl - nr1)(n(r2r3) + (7crlnr2- 1 t ( r t r 2 ) ) ( ~-3 nr3)= 0 = ~ 1 n ( r Z r 3) r
1 7 ~ ~ 2 ~n (3r l r 2 1 3 )
n ( r 1 ~ 2 r 3)
-~ ~ 2 7 ~ r 3 )
since N 2 = 0. Thus f E Z 2 ( R ,N ) = B 2 ( R ,N ) by hypothesis, so there is some + N for which f = dg. Hence f ( r 1 , r 2 ) = r l g r 2 - g ( r 1 r 2 ) ( g r 1 ) r 2 Let . S = { n r + g r : r E R } . R = S + N , so [ V : F ] = [ S : F ] and R = S @ N as vector spaces. Furthermore, nr,gr, = r1gr2since(r, - 7cr,)gr2 E N 2 = 0, and, likewise, gr1nr2 = ( g r 1 ) r 2 ,yielding
+
g: R
(nrl
+ grl)(nr2 + g r , ) = 7rrlnr2+ gr17cr2 + n r l g r 2 + 0 = 7dr1r2)
- f(r13r2)
= 7-4J-1r2)
+ g(r1r2)
proving S is multiplicatively closed, as desired.
+ k?r1)r2 + r19r2 Q.E.D.
This also yields a direct approach to a theorem of Malcev concerning the uniqueness of S. Note first by proposition 2.5.6(i) that for any unit u in R we have u-'Nu = N where N = Jac(R), so whenever R = S 0N we also have R z u-'Su @ N .
Theorem 5.3.21: Suppose R is a finite dimensional F-algebra with S @ N = S ' @ N = R as vector spaces, where N = Jac(R) with R / N separable and S z R / N z S'. Then there is c( E N for which S' = (1 + a)-'S(l + a). Proofi Let cp: S + S' be the composition of the isomorphisms S z R / N = S'. Let F E (R/N)" be a separability idempotent of R / N , written as the image of a suitable element e of R e (not necessarily idempotent), and let e' E S 0 (S')Op be the image of F under the isomorphism (RIN)' + S 0(Slyp.Then for any s in S we have (s 0 1 - 1 0 cps)e' = 0. Passing up to Re and applying the canonical maps p : R e + R and R + R / N gives spe = (pe)cpsfor all s in S. Since the image of e' in R / N is 1 we see pe E 1 + N is invertible and thus 9 s = (pe)-’spe- for all s in S , as desired. Q.E.D.
This result can be formulated in the much broader scope of "inertial subalgebras," cf., Ingraham [74].
70
Homology and Cohomology
Azumaya Algebras Separable algebras have been seen to have many properties in common with simple algebras. The next one is particularly noteworthy. Lemma 5.3.22: Suppose R is a separable Z(R)-algebra. Then any maximal ideal A has the form A,R for suitable maximal A , 4 Z ( R ) . In fact A, = A n Z(R).
Proofi Let Z = Z ( R ) and A, = A n Z . By proposition 5.3.12 RIA is separable with center ZIA,. But RIA is simple so ZIA, is a field and A, is a maximal ideal. But now RIAORis separable over the field ZIA, so is central simple by theorem 5.3.18. Hence A,R is already a maximal ideal, implying AoR = A. Q.E.D. Definition 5.3.23: are satisfied:
A C-algebra R is Azumaya if the following two conditions
(i) R is faithful and f.g. projective as C-module, and (ii) R' z End, R under the correspondence sending rl C3 r2 to the map r -+ r,rrz.
By theorem 2.3.27 every central simple algebra is Azumaya, and this is the motivating example of our discussion. In fact, we shall see that Azumaya algebras possess properties in common with central simple algebras, because of the following connection to separability. Theorem 5.3.24: The following are equivalent for a C-algebra R : (i) R is Azumaya. (ii) C = Z f R ) and R is separable over C. (iii) There is a category equivalence C - A o d -+ R e - A o d given by R @ _ . (iv) Re !z End, R and R is a progenerator of C-Mud. (v) Re z End, R and R is a generator of Re-Mod. (vi) Re z End,R and R e Ann'J = R' (where Ann'J denotes the right annihilator of J in Re).
Before proving this theorem let us note that conditions (i), (ii), (iii) interconnect Azumaya algebras with separability theory and Morita theory: furthermore, we shall tie Azumaya algebras to polynomial identity theory in theorem 6.1.35. Conditions (iv), (v), (vi) are more technical, and all involve Re z End, R plus another condition. It may well be that R e x End, R already
95.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras
71
implies R is Azumaya! Indeed Braun [86] has shown this is the case if R has an anti-automorphism fixing Z(R), cf., exercises 6-9. Another criterion for R to be Azumaya is given in exercise 11.
-
Proof of Theorem 5.3.24: We show (i) * (iv) (iii) * (ii) * (i) and (ii) * (vi) =.(v) =.(i). (i) (iv) by remark 4.1.9 (since Re = R @ Rap). (iv) * (iii) by Morita's theorem. (iii) * (ii) R = R @ C is a progenerator in Re-Aod. By proposition 4.1.19 we can build a Morita context, thereby yielding a category equivalence in the other direction given by the functor Hom,,(R, Re) OR=-, which by the adjoint isomorphism is naturally equivalent to HomRe(R,-). Thus C z HOm,,(R, R) z Z(R) by corollary 5.3.4'. (ii) *(i) C = Z(R) z Hom,,(R, R) so applying example 4.1.16 to the projective R'-module R gives the Morita context (Re,C,R, HOmR.(R, Re),z,T’)
(1)
where z' is epic by proposition 4.1.19 since R is cyclic projective. To conclude by Morita's theorem we need to show z is epic; by remark 4.1.9 and proposition 4.1.19 it is enough to show R is faithfully projective over Re. Suppose A U R e and A R = R. We may assume A is maximal. By proposition 5.3.10 R e z R 0 RoP is separable with center C,so A = A,R'for some maximal A, U C, by lemma 5.3.22. Now AoR = R, which is impossible Q.E.D. by remark 5.3.9(iv). (ii) (vi) As in the proof of (ii) (i) we can set up the Morita context (1) with z' epic. Thus Re z End, R and we need to show Re Ann'J = Re. z'epic implies every element of R e has the form c i f i r i = c r i f i l = x ( r i @ 1)Jl E R e Ann'J since each f;l E Ann'J by corollary 5.3.4(ii); here each f ; E Hom,,(R, Re). (vi) * (v) Reverse the previous argument to show T’ is epic in (l), so R is a generator in Re-&ud by Lemma 4.1.7. (v) =.(i) Setting up the Morita context (1) we see R is f.g. projective over End,, R z Z(R) by remark 4.1.1 7'. Q.E.D.
-
Remark 5.3.24': The reverse equivalence R "-Ad-+C-Aod is given by M H M R . (Indeed, as shown in the proof of (iii) *(ii) it is given by Hom,.(R, -), so we appeal to proposition 5.3.4.) Corollary 5.3.25:
If R is an Azumaya C-algebra then there is a 1:l
Homology and Cohomology
72
correspondence between {ideals of C} and (ideals of R ) given by A, (and the reverse correspondence A H A n C ) .
H
A,R
Proofi Apply proposition 4.1.18, noting the Re-submodules of R are the Q.E.D. ideals of R .
On the other hand, let us consider the consequences of viewing R as a Ci projective C-module. In view of theorem 2.12.22 we can write C = where each Ci= Cei for a suitable idempotents ei of C, and Ri = Re, has constant rank as projective module over C e i . But each R iis Azumaya as C,-algebra by theorem 5.3.24(ii), and R = R , , so we have proved
n:=
n
Proposition 5.3.26: Every Azumaya algebra is a j n i t e direct product of Azumaya algebras of constant rank (as projective module over the center). One further reduction is worth noting, for this is what gives Azumaya algebras the connection to the original definition of Azumaya [50]. We say R is proper maximally central of rank n over a subring C of Z ( R )if R is a free C-module of rank n and R e x End,R. Proposition 5.3.27: Suppose R is Azumaya over C of constant rank n.
(i) R , i s proper maximally central over C, of rank n, for euery P E Spec(C). (ii) RIP‘ is central simple of dimension n over C / ( P ’n C), for every maximal ideal P‘ of R. In particular, n is square. Proof:
(i) By proposition 5.3.10(ii) R, x C,QcR is separable over C, with Z ( R , ) = C,. C, is local so R , is free of rank n by definition 2.12.21. (ii) Let P = P’ n C . Then P’ = PR by lemma 5.3.22, so P’p = P p R p .Thus by Nakayama’s lemma the image of a base of R , (over C,) must be a base of RplP)p over C,JP,, the center of RplP’p by proposition 5.3.12. We conclude by remark 2.12.12, which shows R,JP)pxR/P’ and C , / P , z C / P . Q.E.D. The converse results are in Knus-Ojanguren [74B, pp. 79 and 951, and reduce the study of Azumaya algebras to the local case. Recently Azumaya algebras have become a key tool in PI-theory, and we close this discussion with results of Braun to be used in 46.3. Remark 5.3.28:
If R
=
C { r l , .. . , I - , > and S is a submonoid of Z ( R ) then
$5.3 Separable Algebras and Azumaya Algebras
73
Z ( S - ' R ) = S - ' Z where Z = Z ( R ) . (Indeed if s f l r ~ Z ( S - ' Rthen ) s-'[r,rj]=O for 1 I j 5 t so there is s' in S for which 0 = s'[r,rj] = [s'r,rj] for each j , implying s'r E Z ; thus s - ' r = (s's)-'s'r E S - ' Z . ) Hence ( S - ' R ) e z S I R ' . Proposition 5.3.29: ( R arbitrary) Suppose x
=x
u i 0bi E Re.
(i) If x E Ann'J then x a , r h i E Z ( R )for all r in R. (ii) If R = C{rl, ..., r t ) and { r , @ 1 - 1 @ri)x = 0 for all 1 5 i 5 t then x E Ann'J (so the conclusion OJ ( i ) holds). Proof:
For all r' in R we have r' 0 1 0 = (r' @ 1 - 1
-
1 0i-'
E
J
SO
0r’)x = x ( r ' a i0bi - ai 0bir').
Taking the image under the canonical map Re -+ End, R and applying it to r yields 0 = x(r'airbi - airbir')= [ r ' , C a i r b i ]
for all r' in R,
i
1
implying airbi E Z ( R ) . (ii) By proposition 5.3.2 it suffices to prove ( r 0 1 - 1 0r ) x = 0 for all r in R. By hypothesis we may assume r = ril . . . r i t for some t. By induction on t @ 1 - 1 0ril -'rir.. ,fx = 0, for all i,, ...,i,Hence we have (ril.. (ri, . . . ri, @ l)x = ( r i ,0 l)(ri2.. . rit 0 l)x = (ril 0 1)(1 0 r i 2 . .. riJx =(1
0r i 2 . ..rit)(ri,0 1)x
=(1 @
as desired.
= (1
0 Ti> . . .Tit)( 1 0r i l ) x
ri,ri2. . . ri,)x
Q.E.D.
Corollary 5.3.30: Suppose R = C{rl,. . . ,r , } and S-'R is Azumaya for a given submonoid S of Z ( R ) .If 1-' C i a i r b iE Z(S-'R)far all r in R then there is s in S satisfying sairbi E Z ( R )for all r in R .
c
Proofi Let I,$: ( S - ' R ) e -+End S-'R be the canonical isomorphism. For any s-lr in S-'R and any 1 Ij 5 t we have 0 = s-’ r j , C a i r b i [
i
= $((l-'rj@
]
= s-'
c ( r j a i r b i- airbirj) i
1
1 - 1 0 l - ' r j ) ~ ( l - ' a i @l - ' b i ) s-'r. i
Thus 1 - '(rj@ 1 - 1 @ rj)x(ai0bi)= 0 in ( S - 'R)' z S - *Re(cf., remark 5.3.28)
Homology and Cohomology
14
so for some s in S we have
0 = (sol ) ( r i @ 1
- 10
r j ) C u i @bi
=(rjO1-l@rj)~sai@bi
for1 < j < t .
Now proposition 5.3.29 implies z s a i r b i E Z ( R ) for all r in R .
Q.E.D.
In analogy with the results presented earlier, one can use Tor to define the weuk dimension of an algebra. This was.carried out by Villamayor 11593 who managed to find an intuitive proof of a strengthened version of corollary 2.5.33. Let us briefly sketch his approach. Noting that M is flat iff Tor(N, M ) = 0 for every cyclic right module N , he determines an elementary condition for a cyclic left module to be flat, and deduces that R is flat as Re-module iff for every finite subset { r l , . . . ,r n }of R there is a suitable element e of R e satisfying (ri 1 - 1 @ ri)e = 0 for each i, such that pe = 1. Thus for finite dimensional algebras over a field this notion corresponds with separability. He proves finally that Jac(R, O p R z )= Jac(R,) BFR , whenever Ri are algebras over a field with R 2 flat as R',-module. He also characterizes which left Artinian rings satisfy this property and, as another application, completes a characterization of regular group rings.
Appendix to Chapter 5: The Grothendieck Group, and Quillen's Theorem Revisited Definition 5A.I: Let %? be an abelian category. The Grothendieck group go(%?) (also denoted KO(@)in Bass [68B, Chapter 81 and in exercise 5.1.1 1) is the abelian group F l H , where F is the free abelian group whose base is the isomorphism classes of objects of g ,and H is the subgroup of F generated by all [ M ] - [M"] - [M'] for all exact sequences 0 M" --+ M -+ M ' -+ 0. Thus in %o(U)we have [ M ] = [ M " ] [ M ' ] . Write %(R) for go(%?) when 3 ' = R-9inzod. Since any exact sequence of projective modules splits, we have a natural map K o ( R )-+ $,(R), which turns out to be an isomorphism when R is left Noetherian of finite gl. dim., by the resolution theorem, cf., exercise 5.1.1 1. In fact, the results of 5.1.34ff can be formulated more generally when we replace K O by go,and we shall now give this more general version, for the graded case, following an exposition of Cliff (as recorded and kindly provided by Passman); we shall want this result in appendix 8B.
+
--+
Appendix to Chapter 5
75
Theorem 5A.2: Suppose R is left Noetherian and N-graded, R is flat as right R,-module, and R, has finite pd as right R-module. Then R OR0 - induces an isomorphism $: g,(R,) + %,(R). Proofi We give Cliffs short proof. All undecorated tensors are to be taken over R , . Note the functor R 0 - is exact since R is flat over R,; hence $ is a well-defined group map. Let m = pd, R, (as right module). Step I. Tor;(R,, M ) = 0 for all n > m and all M in R - A d , in analogy to theorem 5.2.40 (or by exercise 5.2.13, noting all projectives are flat).
Step II. If N E R,-Aud then Tor:(R,, R @ N ) = 0 for all n 2 1. (Indeed take a projective resolution P of N . Tensoring each term in P by R, we obtain a projective resolution P' of R 0 N since R 0 - is exact. Now applying R, O R - to P' gives P again since any R,-module M satisfies R, OR (R OR0M ) z (Ro ORR ) OR0M x M canonically; hence the homology is 0 on P' as a complex, implying Tor:(R,, R @ N ) = 0 for all n 2 1.)
x:=,( -
Step ZII. II/ is 1 : 1. (Indeed define cp:%,,(R) -+ %?,(R,) by [ M I -, - 1)' [Torf(R,, M ) ] . cp is a homomorphism, as seen by the long exact Tor sequence. Furthermore, cp$[N] = cp[R 0 N ] = [N] by step 11, for all N in R,-Aud, proving $ is 1:1.)
At this stage it only remains to prove
is onto.
Step IV. (Serre's reduction) It is enough to show R 0 -induces an onto map $: g0(R,)-+ ~ , ( R - ~ . L - F ~ ~ (Indeed, u L L ) . as in the proof of theorem 5.1.34 we grade R[A] by putting R[A], = RiAnPi. R[A] is left Noetherian and free as module over R [ I ] , = R, and pdR,,,R I 1 in view of proposition 5.1.19 (taking (T = 1 and M = R, viewed as R[;i]-module by annihilating A). Hence by hypothesis %,(R,) FZ 9 , ( R [ 1 ] - % - 9 i ~ ~ d ) . Now specializing A +P 1 sends % ? , ( R [ ~ ] - % . L - ~ ~onto W Z~U,~( )R - @ ~ w zbyu ~claim ) 2 of the proof of theorem 5.1.34). Having proved step TV, we put %? = { M ER-Y.~-9imod: Tor:(R,, M ) = 0 for all n 2 l}. By step I1 we see II/(9,(R0)) G V.
of,,
Step V . Suppose M ~ R - Y t - F i m u d . If M = RMt for some t and TorF(R,, M ) = 0 then M z R 0 M,. (Indeed, let f:R O M, + M be the natural graded map. Take any x # 0 in kerf. Writing x = xnENxirin 0 xi,,
76
Homology and Cohomology
where rinE R,, and xinE M,, we have
0 =f x
= x r i n x i nE
M,,,,.
The component in M, is 0 = x r i O x i Oso , 0 = 1 0 c r i o x i o= x r i o 0 xio. Let R+ = We have proved x E R + Q Mt; thus kerf E R + 0 M,. Applying R , OR- to the exact sequence 0 + kerf + R Q M, + M + 0 and using example 1.7.21' yields . . . + Torf(R,, M ) +
kerf Ri kerf
R Q Mt + M / R C M + O . R + Q M,
Since Torf(R,, M ) = 0 by hypothesis and kerf c R + 0 M, we conclude ker f / R + kerf = 0, i.e., kerf = R+ kerf, which implies kerf = 0 as desired.) Step VI. If 0 --t M' + M + M" -P 0 is exact and M , M" E W then M' via the long exact sequence for Tor (5.2.28).
E
%', seen
cz=,
Step VII. $(go(R0))= %'.(Indeed, suppose M E W. Write M = RM,, for RM,,. If M' = 0 then M = RM, zz R Q M, by suitable t, and put M' = step V, so we are done. Thus we may assume M ' # 0. Let M" = M / M ' . Applying R , Q R - to the exact sequence 0 + M ' + M + M" + 0 yields the long exact sequence
x:
**.
+ Torf(R,,
M ) + Tor;(R,, M " ) + M ' / R i M' + M / R +M + M " / R +M" + 0.
But it is easy to see R'M' = M' n R'M, by writing M' = X : I k ( R o + R+)Mn and matching components. Thus the map M ' / R + M ' + M / R + M is monic; furthermore, Torf(R,, M)=O by hypothesis, so we must have Torf(R,, M")=O. Clearly M" = RMI', so step V implies M" E %'.Thus M' E W by step VI, so by induction on t we see [ M ' ] E $(go(R0)). It follows that [ M I = [ M ' ] [ M " ] E $(9,(R0)), as desired.)
+
Step VIII. $ is onto. By step I it suffices to show for all t that if Tor!(R0, M ) = Ofor all n > t then M E t+b(%,(RO)).The proof will be by induction on t ; the case t = 0 is step VII, so assume t 2 1. Take 0 --t K + F + M + 0 with F f.g. free. Then Torf(R0, K ) = Tor!, I ( R o ,M) = 0 for all n > t - 1, so by induction [K]E$(%,(R,)). Thus [ M I = [ K ] - [F]E$(%~(R,)), as desired. Q.E.D.
Remark 5A.3:
If S is a left denominator set of R then there is an epic
77
Exercises
g0(R)+.g0(S-'R) given by [MI tion functor is exact.)
H [S-lM].
(This is clear since the localiza-
Exercises $5.1 1. Schanuel's lemma fails for flat modules. (Hint: Let F, be any localization of Z;
take F free with J F + F o / Z epic. Then O+Z+F,+F,/Z+O but F o @ ker j z Z @ F unless F, is projective.) 2. pdRI,,M [ A ] = pdRM . (Hint: corollary 5.1.21, viewing M [ A ] as R-module.) 3. If each R-module has finite pd then gl.dim R < GO. (Hint: proposition 5.1.20.) 4. (I. Cohen) If R is a subring of T such that R is a summand of T in R - A d - R then gl. dim R < gl. dim T + pd,( T ) .In particular, if T is projective as R-module then gl. dim R I gl.dim T. (Hint: Writing T = R @ N as bimodule yields Hom,(T, M ) = M @ Hom,(N, M ) for any R-module M . Let M' = Hom,(T, M ) . Then pd, M I pd, M ' . Apply proposition 5.1.22 to M'.) 5. gl. dim M,(R) = gl. dim R . (Hint: Morita.) 6. If R is left Noetherian and 0 - M ' + M + M " + O is exact with two of the modules having Euler characteristic then so does the third, and x ( M ) = z ( M ' ) X(M"). 7. If M > M I > ... > M, = 0 and each factor has FFR then M has FFR. 8. Fields [70] Prove proposition 5.1.19 under the weaker assumption u:R + R is an injection. (Hint: Consider OR-modules.) Thus gl. dim R I gl. dim R[L;a] I 1 gl. dim R . There are examples for strict inequality at either stage. Furthermore, these results hold for R[L; u,S].
+
+
F.g. Projectives vs. Free 9. (Ojanguren-Sridhan) For any noncommutative division ring D there is an f.g. projective D[A,,I,]-module which is not free. (Hint: Pick a, b in D with ab # ha. The vector u = (A, + a, -A, + b) in D[A,, is unimodular since (A, - b) * ( A , + a) + ( A , + a)( - A 2 + b) = [a, b], but u is not strongly unimodular.) 10. (Gabel) If P is stably free and not f.g. then P is free. (Hint: Suppose P 8 R(") = F is free, and n:F + R('") be the projection with nxj = ej where e l , .. .,em is the standard base. Take a base {yi} and let F' be the f.g. free module spanned by all yi involved in x ,,.. . , x,. Let P' = P n F'. Then P/P' is free, so 0 P' + P + P / P ' + O and 0 - P ' + F ' + R("'+O are split; also there is a (split) epic P ' / p + R(") whose kernel F" is free; conclude P z P' @ ( P / P ' ) % F' @ F".)
-
KO-Theory 11. Define more generally K , ( R - F i ~ z o d to ) be the free abelian group whose genera-
tors are isomorphism classes of f.g. R-modules, modulo the relation [ M I = [ M ' ] [ M " ] if there is an exact sequence 0 + M" + M + M ' + 0. If R is left
+
Homology and Cobornology
78
12.
13.
14.
15.
Noetherian of finite gl. dim show K o ( R - 9 ~ m o dz) K,(R) canonically. (Hint: Split an f.g. projective resolution into short exact sequences.) Using exercise 11 and the proof of proposition 5.1.32 show there is a canonical epic K,(R-Fimod) + Ko(S-lR-Fimod) whose kernel is generated by those modules with S-torsion. Prove that tp of Quillen’s theorem is epic. (Hint: Let R’ be the “Rees subring” X n e N R J n of R[1], which takes the place of R[1] used in proving Serre’s theorem. Grading R‘ according to degree in 1 one has R, = (R‘),. But the summands R , , JRn of G(R) are flat as Ro-modules so each R,, R , , . .. is flat. Hence R is flat; also R’ is flat since Rk z R, is flat. On the other hand, R’ is also filtered by (R’),,= R,,[1] n R’; the associated graded ring is isomorphic to G(R)[1] under the grade G(R)[1],, = @ i l n R i l n - i so is left Noetherian with finite gl. dim. Thus these properties pass to R’. Now factor q as K,(R) -+ K,(R’) + K,(R), the first first arrow of which is an isomorphism by Serre’s theorem. It remains to show the second arrow is onto, seen just as in the proof of Serre’s theorem by viewing R as R’-module via specializing A to 1 and applying the functor H given by H M = M / ( 1 - 1)M.) (Walker [72]) If R is semiprime Noetherian and gl.dimR < m and K,(R) = ([R]) then R is a domain. (Hint: Use the uniform dimension instead of the Euler characteristic in the proof of theorem 5.1.45.) State and prove explicitly the dual to Schanuel’s lemma.
Change of Rings 16. Theorem 5.1.24 can fail if gl.dim R/Ra is infinite. (Example: R = Z and a = 4.) 17. Suppose a is a normalizing element of R and M is a module with ax # 0 for f M + 0 yields an exact all x # 0 in M . Then any exact sequence 0 + K 2 L -+ sequence (of R/Ra-modules) 0 -+ K / a K + L/aL M / a M + 0. (Hint: k e r j = (K + aL)/aL z K / ( K n a L ) so it suffices to show K n aL = a K . But if ax E K
4
then 0 = / ( a x )
= aJx.1
18. Second “change of rings” theorem. Hypotheses as in exercise 17 we have pdRIDR M/aM I pd, M . (Hint: Induction on n = pd, M . For n > 0 take 0 -+ K + F -+ M -+ 0 exact, with F free. Then pd, K / a K <: n - 1 by induction; conclude
using exercise 17.)
19. Third “change of rings” theorem. Hypotheses as in exercise 17, if, moreover, R
is left Noetherian, M is Lg. and a E Jac(R), then pd,,., M / a M = pd, M . (Hint: Using an induction procedure analogous to that of exercise 18, one is left with the case pdR,,,RM / a M = 0. Take 0 K + F + M + 0 with F free. By exercise 17 one has 0 + K / a K + F / a F + M / a M -+ 0 which thus splits. It suffices to show K 0 M is free; replacing M by K @ M assume M / a M is free. But any base x , + a M , . ..,x, + a M of M / a M lifts to a base of M . Indeed, the xi span by Nakayama; if x r i x i = O take such ri with Rr, maximal and note each ri E Ra =aR, and writing ri = ar; conclude r , E Rar‘,, contrary to a E Jac(R).) A more homological approach taken by Strooker [66] is given in Exercise 5.2.24l-T. 20. If gl.dim R I 2 then R is a PP ring. (Hint: By exercise 3.1.20 it suffices to show Ann a is projective for any a in R. But 0 -+ Ann a + R + R 4R/Ra + 0 is exact where the second arrow is given by right multiplication by Q.) -+
79
Exercises
21. Generalizing the argument of exercise 20, show that if gl. dim R
2 then every left annihilator of R is projective. This result is used by Faith [73B] to characterize simple Noetherian rings of gl.dim I2; in fact, Bass [60] characterized Noetherian rings of gl. dim 5 2 along these lines. 22. (Zaks [71]) Suppose L is a left ideal containing Pl . . . P , such that each a R is f.g. projective as left module and each R/& is simple Artinian. Then L is projective. (Hint: Suppose L is not projective. Let A = PI . . . P , . RIA is Artinian, so one may take L maximal with respect to not projective, and also there is L c L' 5 R with L'/L simple. Hence Ann(L'/L) is some 4. But pd,R/s 5 1 so pd L'/L 5 1. L is projective; hence L is projective.) 23. (Zaks [71]) Suppose R is left bounded, all proper images are Artinian, and all maximal ideals are projective as left modules. Then R is left hereditary. (Hint: If L c R then exercise 22 shows L @ L is projective where L' is an essential complement of L) This is one of a host of his results about when a ring must be left hereditary. 24. If R is left Noetherian then the direct limit of modules of injective dimension In has injective dimension In.
s
Free Summands of Large Projectives The following results of Beck and Trosberg give interesting criteria for a module to have a free direct summand and lead to a reduction result strengthening parts of Bass [63]. 25. Suppose I is a set. Given S E I x I there is I' E I with a well-ordering such that (i) if i, < i, in I' then ( i l , i 2 ) E S ; (ii) if I' x {i} E S then i E 1'. (Hint: Consider all sets I' with well-orderings satisfying (i), and apply the maximal principal.) 26. Consider F = R(') with the canonical base {e,: i E I} and projections n,:F + R, with I infinite. If there are xi in F which satisfy nixi = 1 for each i in I then there is some I' E I for which 11'1 = 111 and {xi:i E 1'}u { e i :i E I - 1'} is a base of F. (Hint: Take T = {(i, j ) E I x I:j # supp(x,)}. Take I' as in exercise 25, and let Ijl:F -' Re, be the canonical projection. If r i x i E ker Ijl then applying Ijl shows each r , = 0, so the xi are independent for i E I' and ker Ijl n Rx, = 0. But an easy transfinite induction now shows ei E R$xi for each i in I', so ker Ijl Rxi = F.) 27. If F is a free module and M 5 F with M + Jac(R)F = F then M has a summand isomorphic to F. (Hint: Let F have a base { e i :i E I}; one may assume I is infinite. Write e, = y, + y; for y, in Mi and yi in Jac(R)F. Then y, = c r i j e j where r,, is invertible, so apply exercise 26 to the xi = r i l y i to get a free submodule F' of M. The projection F + F' restricts to an epic M + F'.) 28. If R/Jac(R) is left Noetherian then every uniformly big projective R-module is free, by applying exercise 27 to theorem 5.1.67. 29. Over any ring R, a non-f.g. projective P is free iff there is a dual base { ( x i , f i ) :i E I} such that there is I' s I with 11'1 = 111 and f i epic for all i in 1'. (Hint: (=) Define f: P + R"' by fx = C ( f i x ) e , where { e i : i E I} are the standard base for R("; as in exercise 26 show R(') is a summand of P.)
xiel,
+ Xiel,
xiE,,
xiE,,
cis,,
80
Homology and Cohomology
Big Projectives are Free (Bass) 30. If R = R, x R, then R\'I x 0 is a non-f.g., non-free projective. 31. Say R is S-connected if for any prime ideals P,Q there is a sequence Po = P , P , , . ..,Pk= Q such that 6- I E P;: or pi E P;.- I for each i. Show R/NiI(R) is a finite direct product of S-connected rings if there are only a finite number of minimal primes. (Hint: Let Ai be the intersection of all minimal primes in the i-th S-connected component. The A i are comaximal, so apply the Chinese Remainder Theorem.) 32. If R is commutative Noetherian and Spec(R) is connected then every non-f.g. projective M is free. (Hint: One may assume M is countable by Kaplansky's theorem. R is S-connected, so the rank function o n M is constant, cf., 52.12. If M / P M were f.g. for each minimal prime P then building a chain M > P,M > P z P I M > ... > 0 would show M is f.g. Hence some M / P M is not f.g. One wants to show M is uniformly big. Otherwise, passing to RIP and M I P M one may assume R is an integral domain, and M / A M is f.g. for some maximal ideal A. Let n = [ M / A M :RIA] = rank(M). M has a free submodule F of rank n since R is a domain. Hence M / F is singular. Write M @ M ' = F' free, and write F' = Fa @ F, where Fo is f.g. free containing F. Then M / F < Sing((Fo @ F , ) / F ) = Sing(F,/F) so M < Fa. Hence M is f.g., contradiction.)
85.2 1. The ring of dual numbers r? is defined as R[l]/(lz) (also, cf., exercise 1.9.7). Any R-module M can be viewed as r?-module since R is a homomorphic image of r?. Thus Z ( ) x Homi(R,-) which also proves left exactness of 2.
Group Cohomology 2. If t = IGI is finite then each H"(G,M) is t-torsion (notation as in example 5.2.13). (Hint: Let h ( g , , . . .,gn- ,) = x S , C f ( g I r ..., g n - ,,g). Summing over (2) of example 5.2.13, as gn runs over g yields ~ , , , ( d " f ) ( g , , ...,gn)= ( - I)"+’tf(gI,. . . ,g,) (d"h)(g,,. .. ,gn). If d"f = 0 then t f E B" as desired.) 3. Let G be a group. Define Po = Z[G] and inductively P,+ = P, @ ZCG], a free Z[G]-module with base { I @ g1@ ... @ g,: gr E G f . Also define maps d,: P, O...@gs,-I + Pn-1 by dn(l Ogl ~ , s i s n - l ( - l ) i @ g@"'@gigi+l l @ . . . @ g n . Then (Pn,dn) is a projective resolution of Z as Z[G]-module with the trivial G-action. (Hint: Define s - ~ Z : + Po by s - , l = 1 and s , : P , + P , - , by s,(g,@...@gy,)= 1 O g O @ . . . @ g nand r use proposition 5.2.18.) Conclude that H"(G, M ) Ext'&(Z, M ) for any Z[G]module M by looking at the isomorphisms Hom(P,, M ) H"(G, M ) . 4. Prove in detail the assertions made after theorem 5.2.22 concerning derived functors of Abelian categories, to obtain corollary 5.2.23. --f
=
=
Basic Properties of FO.L (also, cf., Exercises 23ff.) 5. Use Tor to prove quickly the following facts about an exact sequence 0 + M '
+
Exercises
81
M -+ M" -+ 0: (1) If M', M" are flat then M is flat; (2) If M" is flat the sequence is pure. 6. Suppose 0 + K + F -+ N -+ 0 with F flat then Tor,(M, N) z Tor,+ ,(M, K). 7. If M is a T-,&d-R bimodule then Torf(M,-) can be viewed as a functor from R - A d to T-Aod. Verify similar assertions for Tor(-, M) and for Ext. 304
as Torsion Module
8. Define the torsion submodule t M = { x E M: Ann, x contains a regular element}. If R is left Ore then tM I M and t ( M / t M ) = 0; we say M is torsion if tM = M. If R is semiprime Goldie then t M = Sing(M). In Exercises 9 through 12 we assume R is left Ore with ring of'fractions Q, and M is an arbitrary R-module. 9. Q ORtM = 0. Conclude Tor,(Q/R, t M ) = t M . (Hint: Apply Tor(-, t M ) to 0 + R Q -+ QIR -+ 0, noting Q is R-flat.) 10. Tor,(Q/R, M) = 0 for all n 2 2. (Hint: As in exercise 9, noting Q and R are flat.) 11. The functors t( ) and Tor,(Q/R,-) are naturally isomorphic. (Hint: Apply Tor(Q/R,-) to the exact sequence 0 -+ t M 4M M / t M -+ 0 to get 0 Tor,(Q/R,tM) 3 Tor,(Q/R, M ) 0 by exercises 9, 10. Conclude by composing i, with the isomorphism t M -+ Tor,(Q/R, t M ) of exercise 9.) 12. If R is an integral domain then Tor,(M, N ) is torsion for all R-modules M, N and for all n 2 1, and Tor,(M, N ) also is torsion if N is torsion. (Hint: First assume N is torsion. Then Tor,(M,N) = M 0 N is torsion. For n 2 1 apply Tor(-, N) to a sequence 0 + K + F -+ M 0 with F free and thus flat. Finally f for arbitrary N apply Tor(M,-) to 0 -+ t N + N -+ NItN -+ 0 to get Tor,(M, t N ) + -+
-+
-+
-+
-+
Tor,(M, N) 3 Tor,(M, N / t N ) exact, and note kerf and im g are torsion.
Weak Dimension and G1. Dim 13. In analogy to the syzygy of a projective resolution define the n-th yoke of a
flat resolution of M to be kerd, and prove the following are equivalent: (i) M has a flat resolution of length n. (ii) Tor,(-,M) = 0 for all k 2 n + 1. (iii) Tor,+ ,(-, M) = 0. (iv) The ( n - 1) yoke of any flat resolution of M is flat. 14. Show w. dim R is the same as the right-handed version, by applying theorem 5.2.37 to the right-handed version of exercise 13. In this way w.dim is "better" than gl. dim, which is not left-right symmetric. 15. If R is left Noetherian then pd M = the flat dimension of M, for any f.g. module M. (Hint: Suppose M has flat dimension n. We need to find a projective resolution of length n. Take any f.g. projective resolution. This is also a flat resolution so the (n - 1) syzygy K is flat. But K is f.g. and thus finitely presented, and so K is projective by exercise 2.1 1.8.) 16. If R is left Noetherian then g1,dimR = w.dim R. (Hint: By theorem 5.2.42 one need only check the f.g. modules, but this is exercise 15.) Consequently, gl.dim R is left-right symmetric for Noetherian rings. For non-Noetherian rings one can sometimes find a bound for the difference of the left and right gl. dim, as shown in Osofsky [73B, p. 571.
Homology and Cohomology
82
17. (i) A module F is fiat iff Tor,(R/I,F) = 0 for every right ideal I. (Hint: Use 0 + I 4 R + R / l + 0.) (ii) w. dim(R) is the supremum of the flat dimensions of the cyclic modules. (Hint: Dual of Auslandler's theorem.) 18. The following are equivalent for a ring R: (i) Every left ideal is flat. (ii) w. dim R I 1. (iii) Every right ideal is flat. Consequently, if R is left or right semihereditary then w. dim(R) I1 and every submodule of a flat module is flat.
Global Dimension for Semiprimary and/or Hereditary Rings 19. (Eilenberg-Nagao-Nakayama [56]) Suppose R is hereditary and A 4 R such that A" = A"". Then gl,dimR/A 1 2 n - 1. (Hint: Let B/A 4 R/A. The series B 2 A 2 AB 2 A 2 2 A2B 2 ... yields an exact sequence
... -+ AB/A2B
A/A2 + B/AB + B/A
+
0.
Each term has the form P/AP where P Q R and is thus projective, so P/AP is projective as RIA-module. Since A"IA"+I = 0 conclude pd(B/A) < 2n - 1 as desired.) Using exercise 2.7.17 conclude every homomorphic image of a hereditary semiprimary ring has finite global dimension, bounded by twice the index of nilpotence of the radical. R M 20. If T = (o R,) then gl.dim T Imax{gl.dimR, gl.dimR'} + 1. (Hint: By exampie 1.1.9 p d L Imaxigl. dimR, gl. dim R') fur L IT.) 21. (Mostly Chase [61]; also, cf., Zaks [67]) Suppose R is semiprimary with J = Jac(R). We say R is generalized upper triangular with respect to a complete set of orthogonal idempotents { e , , ... ,en) if eiJej = 0 for all i 2 j. (In particular, eiRei is a division ring.) Prove the following are equivalent: (i) R is generalized upper triangular with respect to eoery complete set of orthogonal idempotents. (ii)R is generalized upper triangular with respect to some complete set of orthogonal idempotents. (ii) R is either semisimple Artinian or has the form
(0"' Zf)
where R' is generalized upper triangular (with respect to a smaller complete set of orthogonal idempotents) and R" is semisimple Artinian. (iv) R is the homomorphic image of a hereditary semiprimary ring. (v) gl. dim RIA < 00 for every A 4 R. (vi) gl.dimR/J2 < m. In each case if t is the number of isomorphism classes of simple R-modules we have &dim R < t and Jac(Rf' = 0. (Hint: Use exercise 2.7.17. (ii) (iii) If t = 1 then J = 0 and R is semisimple Artinian. For t > 1 take u minimal possible for which e,J = 0 for u < i In. Let e = e,, + . . . + e, and e' = 1 - e. Then eRe' = 0 by exercise 2.7.1 1, and eRe is semisimple Artinian. Note that (iii) implies the last assertion since R' has 5 t - 1 classes of simple modules so we can apply induction to R'. (iii) (iv) Let T be the tensor ring of J / J 2 as R/J-module. T is hereditary semiprimary, and by induction applied to R' one sees R is an image of T. (iv)-(v) by exercise 19. (vi)-(i) First assume J 2 = 0. Let Ni = Rei/Jei. Each Jei is simple since J 2 = 0. If eiJei # 0 then Ni is a summand of N, so pd N,< pd 4. Thus one merely need arrange the ei such that pd Ni are increasing. For 5 ’ # 0 show by induction that eiJej E eiJ"ej for all i 2 j ; the induction step is eiJej E eiJ'ej = eiJ"- 'e,Jej c eiJu+'ejsince i 2 k or k 2 j . )
,
-
-
1
83
ExerciRs
22. (Auslander [ 5 5 ] )If R is semiprimary and not semisimple Artinian then gl. dim R = pd, R I J = pd, J 1 where J = Jac(R). (Hint: Let n = pd, R I J and suppose M 2 R-Aod. Every simple R-module is a summand of R / J so Exti(N, M) = 0 for all simple N, implying Ext{(N, M) = 0 for all N satisfying J N = 0. Thus Exti = 0 by exercise 2.1 1.1 proving the first equality.) Auslander also showed this is the weak global dimension of R, thereby achieving left-right symmetry.
+
Tor Module Theory 23. If 0 -P K -+ F 4 M -+ 0 is exact and Tor:(R/A, M ) = 0 then 0 -+ K / A K -+ F/AF + MIAM --+ 0 is exact. 24. (Strooker [66]) Covers of projectives are projective. Explicitly suppose R is left Noetherian and J E Jac(R). If P is an f.g. projective RIJ-module and M is a cover of P with Torf(R/J,M) = 0 then M is uniquely determined up to isomorphism, and M is f.g. projective with M/JM x P. (Hint: Part of this is exercise 2.8.19. Finish by chasing diagrams using exercise 23). 25. If R is left Noetherian and semilocal and Tor:(R/Jac(R),P) = 0 then P is projective. 26. View exercise 5.1.19 as a corollary of exercise 24. 27. Suppose R is left Noetherian and a is a regular normalizing element of R with a E Jac(R). If gl.dimR/Ra = n < 03 then gl.dimR = n + 1. (Hint: It suffices to show pd M 5 n 1 for every Lg. module M. Take 0 K -P F + M -+ 0 with F f.g. free. Then pdR K = pd,,,, K I a K < n by exercise 5.1.19, so pd, M 5 n + 1.)
+
-+
Functorial Properties of Tor 28. Suppose R , T are rings and F is a flat right R-module and M E R - A o ~ - T . Then TorT(F @, M,-) z F 0, TorT(M,-), cf., exercise 7. (Hint: It holds for Tor, = 29. If S is a submonoid of Z(R) and T = S-'R then S-'Tor;(M, N) x Tor;(S-'M, S - l N ) as S-'Z(R)-modules. If M, N are f.g. and R is left Noetherian then S-'Ext",M, N) x Ext",S-'M, S - l N ) . (Hint: exercise 2.1 1.15.) Improve this for left denominator sets. 30. If M is f.g. and R is left Noetherian then Tor,(M,n 4)z nTor,(M,Ni). (Hint: Take 0 -P K --* P -P M -+ 0 with P f.g. projective.) 31. If gl. dim R = d then the functors Tor,(M,-) and Tor,(-, N) are left exact for any M in Aod-R and N in R-Aod. 32. (Rosenberg-Stafford [76]) Suppose R is left Noetherian and gl. dim R = d. Then the canonical map cp: TOr,(M, Ni) -P Tor,(M, N,)is monic. (Hint: By proposition 5.2.52 one may assume M is tg., so use exercise 30.) 33. (Rosenberg-Stafford [76]) Hypotheses as in exercise 32, if each Ni N then Tor,(M, N,) = TOrd(M, Ni). (Hint: Let F denote the left exact functor Tor,(M, -) and consider the commutative diagram
0-.)
n
0
fl
- --
0-
F( (INi)
FN, -FN-
FN
I-
F n(N/"i)
n
F(k/Ni)
Homology and Cohomology
84
55.3 8 E Der(M) and f: M + N is a map in R'-.ni~d then f a E Der(N), so we have a commutative diagram each of whose vertical arrows arises from J
1. If
o-NR-N-D~~(N)-H~(R,
N ) -0
2. A map f:J + M extends to a map R e M iff fa is a n inner derivation of R in M). 3. If G is a group of order n and l / n E C then the group algebra C [ G ] is separable over C. (Hint: cb,,(l/n)a Q u-l is a separability idempotent.) --f
4. Re has an involution given by r l @ r 2 H r 2 Q r l .
Braun's Characterization of Azumaya Algebras Assume in exercises 5- 8 that Re z End, R canonically.
5. Z(RP)= C & C 2 C.(Hint: If E x i Q yi E Z(Re)then ( r 8 l ) c x i Q y i = ( c x i 0 y i ) ( r0 1) implying r x i y i = x i r y i = c x i y i r ; so xiyiE C, thereby yielding E x i @ y i = c x i y i o l ECOCC.) 6. If R has an anti-automorphism (*) fixing C and v( x i @ y i ) = (*) then x i €3y i ) ( c y i @ x i ) is an invertible element c of C, and (*)-' = v ( c - ' y , @ x i ) . (Hint: Compute rTr;r: = ( r 3 r 2 r 1 ) *to get v((r: 0 r : ) ( c x i @ yi))r2= v ( ( c x i0 yi)(r38 rI))r2and thus (r: Q r T ) C x i @ yi = ( E x i Q yi)r30 r l . Using the "switch" of exercise 4 conclude ( E x i Q y i ) ( c y i@ x i ) E Z(Re) 2 C. Identifying c with c ( x i 8 y i ) c (y i 0 x i ) one sees 1 E Rc so c is invertible.) 7. Notation as exercise 6, and writing (*') for ( * ) - I show c y i Q x:' and E x i @ y : are in Ann'J. (Brief hint: This follows from computing (TIT*')* = r2r: and manipulating with the maps a: R Q R + Re and 8:R @ R + Re defined by a(rl @ r 2 ) = rl @ r2 and P(rl 0 r z ) = rl 0r ; . ) 8. Applying theorem 5.3.241vi) to exercise 7 and similar manipulations, show that if R has an anti-automorphism (*) fixing C and Re z EndcR then R is Azurnaya. 9. R is Azumaya iff the canonical map Re 8(Re)OP+ Hom(R', Re) is an isomorphism. (Hint: Re is Azumaya by exercises 4,8; thus R is Azumaya.) 10. (Schelter [84] Suppose cp: C ' + C is a surjection of commutative rings with (ker cp) * = 0, and C is local. Given an Azumaya C-algebra R there is an Azumaya C-algebra R' and a map R' -+ R which extends cp. (Hint: R zz C'") as C-module, so let R' = (C')(")and extend cp t o g: R' + R componentwise. It suffices to find a multiplication on R' for which rjj is a ring homomorphism. Letting e l , .. .,e, be the canonical base of R write eiej = c c i j k e , and picking c:jk in C' such that cpcijk= cijk define multiplication on R' by eiej = ccijke,. Let N = (ker 9)'"' c R'. Then f:(R')'') + N defined by f(r'l,r>,ri) = r',(r>r'J - (rflr;)ri induces a map RI3' -+ N obtained by defining f(@r',,G r i , @r\) = f ( r ' , ,r ; , I;) because N 2 = 0; Z3(R, N ) = B3(R, N ) so = 6g. Use g to define a new multiplication.)
1
TE
E
7
c
1
(c
Exercises
85
11. (Braun) R is Azurnaya iff there are elements a , , . . .,a,, b , , . .. , b , in R such that z a i b i = 1 and Ca,rb, E Z(R) for all r in R. [Hint (Dicks): ( a Write ) a separability idempotent e as c a i 0 b, and apply proposition 5.3.29(i). (t) Let e = c a i 0hi in Re. First prove R'eR' = Re. For, otherwise, let P be a maximal ideal of R containing { r E R : r 0 1 E R'eR"} and let R = RIP; then 0 # F in R @ RoP, a simple ring, but F generates a proper ideal, contradiction. Now check for any Dew in R'eR' that C a , 0fuew b,)E Ann'J implying e = x u i @ bi E Ann'J so e is a separability idempotent.)
-
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
6
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
In this chapter we shall treat two theories each of which in recent years has served as a way of attracting directly some of the techniques of commutative algebras to study suitably conditioned noncommutative algebras. Both theories have their roots in specific questions outside of “pure algebra” but have blossomed spectacularly in recent years. The two subjects complement each other beautifully and often intertwine both in hypotheses and in mathematical history, so we shall treat them together. $6.1 is a resume of “elementary” theory of rings with polynomial identity (PI), focusing on central polynomials and their most direct applications. In $6.2 we introduce afJine algebras and the Gelfand-Kirillov dimension, which perhaps has become the most prominent dimension of recent research; the springboard is the Golod-Shafarevich counterexample to Kurosch’s problem. In $6.3 we study the structure of affine PI-algebras, including the positive answer to Kurosch’s problem using Shirshov’s techniques; one of the key features is Schelter’s important “trace ring” construction which has been the arena of many significant recent advances. In $6.4 we consider relatively free PI-algebras, both as examples of rings and as a launching pad for the “quantitative” PI-theory. However, we barely scrape the surface of this area.
87
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
88
N.1
Rings with Polynomial Identities
Suppose one were to look for the most naive way possible to generalize the property of commutativity of rings. One might begin by observing that the commutative law for R reads “ X , X , = X , X , for all substitutions of X , , X , in R,” or, equivalently, X , X , - X 2 X , is “identically” 0 in R. Similarly, we could view the associative law as ( X , X , ) X , - X,(X,X,) vanishing identically, and likewise for the distributive law. Thus it is natural to examine formal polynomials, say as element of Z ( X ) , and see what happens when some polynomial vanishes for all substitutions for R . Some immediate examples: Example 6.1.1:
(i) Any Boolean ring satisfies the identity X : - XI. (ii) Any finite field having m elements satisfies the identity X y - X , by Fermat’s little theorem. (iii) The algebra R of upper triangular n x n matrices over a commutative ring satisfies the identity [X,,X,][X,,X,] . . *[X,,_ IX2,J.
These examples are not nearly as important as two deeper examples, finite dimensional algebras and algebraic algebras of bounded degree, which will be discussed a bit later. There is another obvious example-any algebra of characteristic p satisfies the identity pX,. In order to exclude such a huge class of algebras, we want to dismiss such an identity as “trivial.” We are ready for a formal definition. Throughout X = { X , ,X,, ...) is a countable set of noncommuting indeterminates over a commutative ring C, and a polynomial is an element f of C{X1, written f ( X , ,. . .,X,) to indicate that no X i occurs in f for i > m. But now f can be viewed as a function f : R ( ” ) -,R acting by substitution, i.e., f(R‘”)) = ( f ( r , , . . . , r m ) : r iE R ) . When rn is not of concern to us we shall write f (R)in place of f(R‘“’). It is also convenient to deal with { ( R ) ’ , defined as the additive subgroup of R generated by f ( R ) .Obviously, f ( R )= 0 iff f ( R ) + = 0. Remark 6.2.1’: If f is a polynomial and o is a C-algebra autornorphism of R then j ( a r , ,... ,or,) = of@,,. . . ,rR); consequently, f ( R ) and {(R)’ are invariant under all automorphisms of R. Definition 6.1.2: f is an identity of R if f ( R ) = 0; an identity
f is a poly-
nomial identity if one of the monomials of f of highest (total) degree has coefficient 1. R is a PI-algebra if R satisfies a polynomial identity; R is a PI-ring if R satisfies a polynomial identity with C = Z.
56.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
89
The reason for the somewhat technical definition of polynomial identity is to exclude identities such as [ X , , X , ] + 2[X:, A’,], since one usually wants to work with the monomials of highest degree. The subject of most of this chapter is the “qualitative” PI-theory, i.e., the structure theory that can be developed for a ring on the mere assumption that it satisfies a polynomial identity. PI-rings were introduced by Dehn [ 2 2 ] who was searching for an algebraic framework for axiomatic Desargiuan geometry. He was missing a key ingredient, the use of inverses, and his project receded into oblivion until Amitsur [ 6 6 ] brought it to a successful completion. With a few exceptions mostly of historical interest, Pt-rings remained in a state of suspended animation until Jacobson, Kaplansky, and Levitzki became interested in them, largely in connection with Kurosch’s problem (to be discussed in $6.2). When Kaplansky proved every primitive PI-algebra is simple and finite dimensional over its center, the PI-theory began to breathe anew, especially in the hands of Amitsur. Another breakthrough came when Posner [60] proved every prime PI-ring is Goldie, yielding an instance where Goldie’s theory could be applied to non-Noetherian rings. Deep applications were found to Azumaya algebras, geometry, and division algebras. But the best was yet to come. In response to an old problem of Kaplansky, Formanek [72] and Razmyslov [733 constructed polynomials on arbitrary n x n matrices which are not identities yet take only scalar values. Although the question had at first been considered mostly as a curiosity, it soon became clear that these “central polynomials” provided enough commutativity to permit direct application of standard techniques from the commutative theory, and the entire PI-theory was reworked from the bottom up to give central polynomials their proper dominant role. During the 1970s researchers began to turn to basic matrix theory techniques to study PI-rings and expanded the rings under consideration by adjoining coefficients of the characteristic polynomials of various elements. On the one hand, this tied PI-theory to classical invariant theory, and brought in the “quantitative” PI-theory; on the other hand, Schelter and others used this technique to prove striking new results about prime PI-rings and later to develop the rudiments of a noncommutative algebraic geometry, cf, the papers of Artin-Schelter. This section concerns that part of the PI structure theory which is obtained as a direct consequence of the existence of central polynomials for matrices. In the later sections we shall obtain the other basic PI-structure theorems, concentrating on the deeper theory of prime PI-rings. As hinted in the previous paragraphs, the structure theory hinges on what can be said about matrices, in particular on the two most basic properties of matrices-the
90
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affiw Algebras
determinant and the Hamilton-Cayley theorem. The determinant is linear and alternating in its rows; to study the analogous situation for polynomials we introduce the notation $(Xi H h) to denote that h is substituted throughout for X i : an alternate longer notation is f ( X , , . . .,X i - 1, h, X i +l , . . .,X,,,). Definition 6.2.3: A polynomial f is linear in X i if X i occurs exactly once (of degree 1) in every monomial of f; f is t-linear if f is linear in X , , . . .,X,. f is t-alternating i f f ( X i H X j ) = 0 for all 1 Ii c j I t. A polynomial which is t-linear and t-alternating is called t-normal. For example [X,,X,] = X , X 2 - X 2 X , is 2-normal. The value of t-linear polynomials lies in the following observation: Remark 6.1.4:
I f f ( X , , . ..,X,,,) is t-linear then
=
C
i I ,....it
cil1. . .Ciltf(ril
1
,. . * ,rirt,rr +
13..
* 9
rm)
for all cii in C and rij in R. In particular, if B spans R as C-module = f ( B ( ' )x R("-,)). Likewise, if f is I-linear then f(R)+ is a then f(R(")) C-submodule of R. Example 6.2.5: The 3-linear polynomial [[X,,X,],X,] each exterior algebra, seen by checking monomials.
is an identity of
Proposition 6.1.6: If f ( X l , . . . ,X,,,) is t-normal and R is spanned by fewer than t elements over C then f is an identity of R. Proofi Suppose R = C B where I B l l t - 1. Then f(bl,...,bf,rf+l,...,rm)=O by definition whenever the bi E B, since two bi must be the same. Consequently f(B(’)x R("-')) = 0, so f is an identity by remark 6.1.4.
It is a simple enough matter to construct normal polynomials. Dejinition 6.1.7: Define the Capelli polynomial
and the standard polynomial S,(X,,. . . ,X , ) = C J X 1 , . .. , X I , 1,. ..,1)
=
1
II E Sym(r)
(sga)X,, ... x,,
$6.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
91
Czt and S, are t-normal and thus are identities of any C-algebra spanned b y < t elements.
Proposition 6.1.8:
Proofi The terms in C,,(Xj ++ X j ) (or S,(Xi H X j ) ) subdivide into pairs of the same monomials appearing with opposite sign (one corresponding to a permutation n and the other corresponding to n composed with the transposition ( i j ) and thus having opposite sign), so the polynomial is sent to 0. Q.E.D.
For our final example we say R is integral of bounded degree n if every element of R is integral of degree i n over C, with n minimal such. Example 6.1.9: If R is integral of bounded degree In and f ( X , , . . . ,X,) is n-normal then S,,([X;, X,], . . .,[ X , , X , ] ) is a 2-variable identify of R .
xyii
c?S:
cir: so [r;,r.,] = Indeed, for any ri in R we can write r: = cj[r:,r,] implying Sn([r’;,r2],. . . , [ r l , r , ] ) = 0 by remark 6.1.4, so f is an identity. As a special case, consider M n ( C )over an arbitrary commutative ring C. On the one hand, taking t = n2 1 we see S, and C, are identiities of Mn(C) by proposition 6.1.8. On the other hand, by the Hamilton-Cayley theorem (which holds for arbitrary commutative rings, cf., Jacobson [85B,page 2033) we see M,,(C) is integral of bounded degree n so S , ( [ X ; , X 2 ] ,. . . ,[ X I ,X , ] ) is an identity of M J C ) . Given these basic examples of PI-rings, we want to see how broad the class of PI-rings really is.
+
Remark 6.1.10: (i) If f is an identity of R then f is also an identity of every homomorphic image of R and of every subalgebra of R. (ii) I f f isanidentityof R,foreachiinl thenfisanidentityof n ( R j : i €I ) , and thus of any subdirect product of the R i . (Indeed (i) is a fortiori and (ii) is by checking components and then applying (i).)
A polynomial f ( X , , ...,X,) is multilinear if X i has degree 1 in each monomial off, for each 1 < i I rn. Multilinear identities play a special role because of the next observation (compare with theorem 6.1.44 on page 106).
Rings with Polynomial Identities and A
92
h Algebras
Proposition 6.1.11: Any multilinear identity f of R is an identity of each central extention R’ of R. Proof:
If R’ = R Z then remark 6.1.4 shows f ( R ’ ) = f ( R ) Z = 0.
Q.E.D.
To utilize this result we need a method of multilinearizing polynomial identities. Given f (XI,. . .,Xm) define A J ( X , , . . . ,X,+ ,) for 1 Ii I n by Aif
=
f ( X i H (Xi + Xm+ 1))
-f -f
( X i H Xm+ 1).
For example, if f = X : X 2 then Af = ( X , + X,)’X2 - X : X 2 - X : X , = X , X , X 2 + X , X , X 2 and A2f = X : ( X 2 + X,) - X i X , - X 4 X 3 = 0. The multilinearization process only works on the assumption that any X i appearing in j” appears in all the monomials of f; such a polynomial will be called “blended.” All the polynomials we wrote down thus far are blended, and exercise 1 shows any identity is a sum of blended identities, so this assumption is very mild. Remark 6.2.22: Suppose f ( X I ,. . . ,X,) is blended. Then Aif is blended (in X , , . . . ,X m +,). Furthermore, any monomial h in f of degree d 2 1 in X i produces 2‘ - 2 monomials in A if , each having the same coefficient as h and of degree < din X i . Iff is an identity then A i f is identity. (Indeed, the last assertion is obvious; furthermore, h(XiH X i + X m + i )produces 2d monomials, all of which are blended except h and h(Xi H X m + J ,and these two drop out by definition of Ai.) Remark 6.2.23: Using remark 6.1.12 one can turn any blended polynomial identity into a multilinear polynomial identity of the same degree. (Indeed, take a monomial h of highest (total) degree having coefficient 1. If h is linear in each X i then f is multilinear since f is blended. If h is not linear in X i then A,h is blended and has smaller degree in X i ; repeating the procedure we eventually reach a multilinear identity. Note that all monomials of smaller degree than h have vanished in the multilinearization procedure.) To see how this works let us consider the identities of example 6.1.1.
+
(i) A , ( X ; - X , ) = Al(Xf)= X , X 2 X , X , which is thus an identity of every Boolean algebra. (ii) Applying A, (m - 1) times to X T yields ~ n E S y m ( m ) X n l . . . Xwhich n m , is a multilinear identity of any field of m elements and is called the symmetric identity. (iii) [X,X,]. . . [ X , , - X,, J is already multilinear.
$6.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
93
Central Polynomials and Identities of Matrices We want now to examine identities of matrices more carefully, for this will pay handsome dividends in structure theoretical applications. If x 1 and x2 are in M 2 ( C )then [xl,x,] has trace 0 so [x1,x2]' is a scalar matrix by the Hamilton-Cayley theorem. This led Kaplansky to ask whether arbitrary n x n matrix rings have nonidentities taking on scalar values. We shall see soon the answer is "yes." (Also see exercise 22.) Dejinition 6.1.14: f(Xl,.. .,X,) is a central polynomial for R, otherwise called R-central, if 0 # f ( R ) 5 Z ( R ) , i.e., if f is not an identity of R but [Xm+l, f ] is an identity of R. Example 6.1.15: [X,, X,]' is M,(C)-central for any commutative ring C , as we just saw. [ X , , X2] is a central polynomial for the exterior algebra, in view of example 6.1.5.
Our aim is to construct multilinear M,,(C)-central polynomials. We follow the exposition of Rowen [80B] (based on Razmyslov-Bergman-Amitsur) since the ideas also apply to $6.3. The study of identities and central polynomials of matrices are closely related. Our first concern is to distinguish M,(C) from Mnpl(C)by means of their identities. Proposition 6.1.16: For t = n', the Capelli polynomial C,, is not an identity of R = M n ( H )for any commutative ring H (although CZ(,+,) is an identity, as noted earlier). In fact C2,(R)+= R . Proof;. Order the matric units {eij:1 I i , j I n} lexicographically on the subscripts, i.e., e l , < eI2 < ... < el, < e,, < . ' . < en,, and write rk for the k-th matric unit on this list. Let us evaluate C2,(r1,... , r , , r l , . ..,r,). Taking E in Sym(t) let a , = r , 1 r 1 r , 2 r 2 - * - r ~ tThen r t . rlrn2r2= e,,r,2e12 so a = 0 unless rn2 = e l l ; likewise, r2rK3r3= eI2rn3el3 is 0 unless rn3 = e 2 , . Continuing in this way we have precisely one choice of r n 2 , .. .,r,, for a to be nonzero. Since enl has not yet been selected we take rK1= en1; then a , = en,,for this particular n, and all other a , = 0; proving C2t(rl,.. . , r , , r , , . . . , r , ) = &en". By symmetry each eii E C,,(R). For i # j we have (1 + eij)-' = 1 - eij so (1 eij)-'eii(1 + eij) = eii eij E C 2 , ( R )by remark 6.1.1'. Hence each eij E C,,(R)+, proving C,,(R)+ = R . Q.E.D.
+
+
Remark 6.2.16': For any field F, elements {bi: 1 Ii 5 n'} of M,,(F) form
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
94
a base iff there are {r,: 1 5 i I n’} c M,(F) such that C,,(b, ,..., bf,rl,..., r f ) # 0 where t = n2.(Indeed by remark 6.1.4 we may assume the bi are matric units, so apply the proposition.) Digression 6.1.17: The standard polynomial S,, actually is an identity of M,(C) for any n. This celebrated theorem of Amitsur-Levitzki is proved in exercise 10 as a fairly direct consequence of the Hamilton-Cayley theorem, translated to traces by means of “Newton’s formulas.” Actually Razmyslov [74] has proved that all identities of n x n matrices can be obtained from the Hamilton-Cayley theorem by using traces formally in PI-theory. Nevertheless, S,, has the smallest degree of all the identities of M,(C), as we see now. Remark 6.1.18: No polynomial f # 0 of degree 5 2n - 1 is an identity of M,(C). (Indeed, by multilinearizing we could assume f = x a n X n , *..X,,,, withq,, # 0; thenf(e,l,e,2,e,, ,...) = a ( , ) e l l e l ZZO.) ~-~
One might have hoped S,( [ X l ,X,]. . . . ,[ X , , X,]) to be the minimal 2-variable identity, but for n 2 8 the polynomial identity S,,(X,, X,, X,X,, X , X , , X : X , , . ..) has lower degree. Our key to finding centra1 polynomials for M,(C) is the following lemma whica mimics the known properties of determinants.
Proposition 6.1.19: Suppose R E C - d & x l , . . .,x , are arbitrary elements of R, and T:C:=,Cx, + C x , is a map (in C-Mod). Viewing T as an image of a t x t matrix T (cf., theorem 1.5.13) we have the following formulas, for any t-normal polynomial f ( X ,,...,xk):
c:=,
0) (det W t x , , . . .,X A = f W , , ...,Tx,,x,+ ,,. ..,x d , (ii) det(L - T’)f ( x l , . . . , x k ) = f ( L x , - T x , , . . .,Axf - T x , , x , +
,,.. . ,xk)l
for a commuting indeterminate L (viewed as a scalar t x t matrix) (iii) If I’ + each
1( -
l)iciL1-iis the characteristic polynomial of T’ then
f (Tj’x,,. . ., Tj‘Xf,x,+1 , . . . xk)
c i f ( x l , . . . xk) =
9
9
summed over ( j , , . . .,j , ) in (0,l)‘” such that jl + . . . (iV)
( t r T ‘ ) f ( X ,..., , Xk)=
I
+ j , = i;
C f ( x 1 ,...,x i - ~ , T X i , x i + 1..., , xk). i= 1
95
$6.1 Rings with Polynomial identities
Proof:
cijxi.Using the t normality of f we have
(i) Write Txj =
=
C
x E Sym(r)
c n I , 1 . * .cnr,r
f(xx17. * . ,~
xt+ 1,. . x d
n t ,
=C(sg~)c,,,i".c,,,tf(x,,..-,xk) R
. 9
=(det T')f(Xi,...,Xk)
(ii) Follows from (i), working in R [ L ] and using 1 1 - T in place of T (where 1 is the identity map). (iii) Match coefficients of , I p i in (ii). Q.E.D. (iv) Take i = 1 in (iii).
Theorem 6.1.20: There is a multilinear polynomial which is M,,(H)-central for every commutative ring H.
Put t
Proofi
=
i= 1
n2, and write
c,r(x,
9 . .
. +xi - 1, x2r + lxix,t+2
7
xi+
1>
>
x2r)
,,
for suitable m and multilinear monomials h,,, h,, (in XI,.. . ,Xi- Xi+l,. . ., X2J. Pick arbitrary ~ , b , r ~ , . . . in , r ~M,,(H); ~ viewing M,(H) as an n2dimensional module over H having base eij, 1 I i,j I n, we define the map T: M,,(H) + M , ( H ) given by Tx = axb. Writing a = (aij) and b = (b,) we have Te, = auibjo~uv, whose coefficient of eii is aiibjj. Hence as n2 x n2 matrix, T has trace v = aiibjj = tr(a) tr(b) so by proposition 6.1.19(iv), putting wiju= hiju(rl,.. . ,ri- Ti+ . . ,rzr) we have
Cz,.,=,
tr(a)tr(b)C2r(rl,...,r2r)=
Put w
=
c:,
r
C C2r(r1,...,ri-l,arib,ri+l,...,r,,) i=l
Czr(r,,. . .,rZr).Taking traces of both sides yields
tr(wijlaribwij2) tr(tr(a)tr(w)b) = tr(a) tr(w)tr(b) = tr(tr(a)tr(b)w) = 1 i.j
= ~tr(wij2wij,arib) = tr i.i
96
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affiw Algebras
implying tr((tr(a)tr(w) wij2wijlari)b)= 0 for all b; nondegeneracy of the trace yields tr(a) tr(w) - xi,jwij2wijlari= 0, i.e., 1 wij2wij1ariequals the scalar tr(a)tr(w). By proposition 6.1.16 we can pick r l , . ..,rZ1 such that tr(a) tr(w) # 0. Thus we define f = hij2hijlX2[+lXi, which takes Q.E.D. only scalar values and is not an identity, i.e., f is M,,(H)-central.
x7=l
Actually we want an n2-normal central polynomial, but this is rather easy to find. Definition 6.1.21: gn = f ( C2,,2(X1,.. . ,X2,,z)X2,,z 1, X2,* + 2 , . . ., X,,,* + z1 + 1 ) where f(Xl, . . . ,XZt+ is the central polynomial for n x n matrices we found in the theorem.
Corollary 6.1.22: g,, is an n2-normal polynomial which is M,,(C)-central for all commutative rings C. Proofi Clearly, g,, is n2-normal and is either M,,(C)-centralor an identity. But f is not an identity, so g. is not an identity, by proposition 6.1.17. Q.E.D. We carry the notation g,, throughout this chapter and shall denote its degree as m. Digression 6.1.23: We made little effort to limit the degree, and indeed there are multilinear polynomials of considerably lower degree. Formanek’s central polynomials have degree n2, but this is not the best possible. Also Formanek [86] verified a central polynomial of degree 2n2 (conjectured by Regev) which is of considerable importance in the quantitative theory, cf., 96.4.
Halpin [83] has simplified Razmyslov’s original construction of a central polynomial. Let us outline the main ideas, which are of considerable interest. We say f is a weak identity of M,,(C)if f vanishes on all matrices of trace 0. The connection between identities and weak identities is found in the Razmyslou transformations G and T i defined on multilinear polynomials as follows: It is enough to define them for multilinear monomials h = hIXkh2; define T,h = h2Xkhl and T;h = h2h1 = qh(Xk H 1). One verifies at once (i) T,2f
(ii) (iii)
=f
.
5.f = (T;(Xm+ l f ) ) ( x m t Tk[Xm+l,f]
= (Tkf)(xk
1
xk).
[xk,xm+ll).
97
86.f Rings with Polynomial Identities
By a careful accounting of the diagonal contributions, one can show if a multilinear polynomial f is a weak identity of Mn(C)then Tkf is either R-central or an identity; i f f is an identity then T;f is an identity. Applying (ii), one sees fis an identity iff TJ is an identity. Using commutators, it is now easy to show that any weak identity of degree d which is not an identity produces a central polynomial of degree I2d. The obvious such weak identity is the Capelli polynomial CZn2. However, noting the trace is the second coefficient of the Hamilton-Cayley polynomial, one sees the multilinearization of S n - 1(CXl,X2I9
'7
X2I, [ X ; Y 3 ,XZI,... [Xl>X2I) 9
is a weak identity which is not an identity, cf., exercise 11. Here is another result used in verifying identities and central polynomials.
Remark 6.1.23': Suppose R is central simple over an infinite field F. To prove a continuous map f: R(,) + T satisfies f ( r ,r 2 , .. . , r m )= 0 for all r in R (where r 2 , .. .,r, are fixed) it suffices to show this holds for a Zariski open subset. Using proposition 2.3.35 we may assume deg r = n and the roots of the minimal polynomial are distinct. Thus r is diagonalizable in M,,(F) = R @ F, where F is the algebraic closure of F. Suppose f ( a r a - ' , a r 2 a - ' , . . .,arms-') = uf(r,r 2 , .. . ,r,,,)a-l (e.g., f is a polynomial or a trace polynomial). Diagonalizing r, it sufices to assume r is diagonal with distinct eigenualues (in M,,(F)).
Structure Theory for PI-Rings We can now build a structure theory for semiprime PI-rings. The cornerstone is Kaplansky's theorem, that any primitive PI-ring R is simple and finite dimensional over the center. The proof is twofold. First one notes R is simple Artinian by Jacobson's density theorem, and then one shows the underlying division ring is finite dimensional by means of some splitting technique. The splitting technique used here is a special case of example 2.12.28, spelled out for the reader's convenience. Proposition 6.1.24: Suppose D is a division algebra over an algebraically closed field F and D has a (possibly infinite) base over F of cardinality < IF( - 1. Then D = F. (More generally, i f F is not algebraically dosed then D is algebraic over F.) Proofi If d E D were not algebraic over F then ( ( d - a)-':@E F ) is F independent by proposition 2.5.21, contrary to hypothesis. Thus F [ d ) is a finite field extension of F, so d E F, i.e., D = F. Q.E.D.
98
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
We say R has PI-degree n if R satisfies all multilinear identities of M,,(Z) and gn (of corollary 6.1.22) is R-central. This was called PI-class n in Rowen [SOB] to avoid confusion wih the degree of a minimal polynomial identity, which is 2n by the Amitsur-Levitzki theorem, but the terminology PI-degree has become standard. Theorem 6.1.25: (Kaplansky’s Theorem) Suppose R is a primitive ring satisfying a polynomial identity f of degree d. Then R has some PI-degree n I[d/2], and R z M , ( D ) for a division ringD (unique up to isomorphism) with n2 = [ R :Z ( R ) ]= t 2 [ D :Z(D)]. We may assume f is multilinear and xd... X , has nonzero coefficient a in f. Let M be a faithful simple R-module, and D = End, M. We claim R z M,(D) for some t I d. Otherwise, taking any x 1 in M we take r , such that r l x l $ x , D , and put x 2 = r,x,; inductively, given r l , . . . , r i - , and x l , . . ., x i - take ri such that rixj = 0 for all j < i and rixi $ xiD, and put x i = rixi. Then f ( r , , . . .,rd)xl = a r d ~ ~ ~ = r l XxX ld # 0. Let F = Z ( D ) = Z ( R ) and take an algebraically closed field K of cardinality > 1 + [ R : F ] (possibly infinite). Then R , = R BFK is a simple K-algebra and satisfies the identity by proposition 6.1.11, so as above R , z M,,(D,) for some n and some K-division algebra D , with [ D , : K ] I [ R , : K ] = [ R : F ] < lKl - 1. Hence D, = K by proposition 6.1.25 so R , x M J K ) and n I [ d / 2 ] by remark 6.1.18. But then n = [ R : F ] = t 2 [ D : F ] and , Q.E.D. clearly R has PI-degree n. Proofi
cj<,
To utilize Kaplansky’s theorem most effectively we need an embedding procedure into nicer rings. We say R is embeddible in n x n matrices if there is an injection from R into Mk(Hk)where Hk is commutative.
nk<,,
Theorem 6.1.26: I f R satisfies a polynomial identity of degree d then R / N ( R ) is embeddible in n x n matrices for n = [d/2]. (Recall N ( R ) from definition 2.6.25.) In fact, each Hk can be taken as a direct product of fields. Proofi In the notation of theorem 2.6.27 we have an injection of R / N ( R ) into R , with Nil(R,) = 0. Multilinearizing we can pass the PI to R,. But RIIA] is semiprimitive by Amitsur’s theorem 2.5.23, so can be injected into a direct product of primitive rings, each of which by Kaplansky’s theorem is simple of dimension I n2 over its center. Splitting each of these primitive components to inject it into h f k ( & ) for a suitable field &k and k I i, we conclude by taking Hk = Q.E.D.
nick.
$6.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
99
This embedding procedure, foreshadowed in $2.6, is extremely useful. We give the principal application here and leave the others for exercises 14, 15. (Note that an arbitrary PI-ring need not be embeddible in matrices, by example 3.2.48. We pursue this question further in $6.3.)
Theorem 6.1.27: Suppose R satisfies a PI of degree d. If R is semiprime then NiI(R) = 0. In general, for every nil weakly closed subset A of R we have G N(R). Proofi Let 2 be the image of A in R / N ( R ) . By theorem 6.1.26 R / N ( R ) is embeddible in n x n matrices for n = [ d / 2 ] , so A" = 0, i.e., A" G N ( R ) , proving the second assertion. In particular, Nil(R)" E N ( R ) = 0 for R semiprime, so Nil(R) = 0. Q.E.D. Although exercise 12 shows this theorem is sharp insofar as n is concerned, one can replace N ( R ) by L,(R), the sum o f the nilpotent ideals, as expounded in Rowen [80B, theorem 1.6.36(i) and exercise 1.6.6); consequently the nilradical is reached in only two steps. Instead of pursuing this matter further, we push on to a central result.
Lemma 6.1.27': Iff is an identity or central polynomial of M,,(C)then f is an identity of M,- l(C). Proofi Matrices x i = C;.jf cijeijcan be reread as elements of M,(C) so f ( x , , . . .,x,,,) is some scalar a; but ae,, = f ( x , , . . .,x,,,)e,, = 0 so a = 0. Q.E.D. Theorem 6.1.28: Every semiprime PI-ring R has PI-degree n for suitable n, and every ideal of R intersects the center nontrivially. Proof: Let d be the degree of a PI of R ; let Z = Z ( R ) and 0 # A Q R. We shall show R has PI-degree n I [d/2], and A n Z # 0. Case 1. R is semiprimitive. R is a subdirect product of primitive { R i :i E I } , and by Kaplansky's theorem each Ri is central simple over Z ( R i )of degree n, I [ d / 2 ] . Let n: R +. R, denote the canonical projection and let Ai = nA,. Each Ai is an ideal of Ri so A , = 0 or Ai = R,. Let I ' = { i E I : A i # 0) and n = max(ni: i E 1 ' ) . Then g,(A,) c_ Z ( R , ) for i E I ' and g,(A,) = 0 for i $ I' by lemma 6.1.27'. But g,(A,) # 0 for i such that n, = n, so 0 # g,(A) G A n Z. Furthermore, taking A = R we have each A i= Ri so I' = I and gn is R-central, proving R has PI-degree n.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affiw Algebras
100
Case 11. R semiprime. Then NiI(R) = 0 by theorem 6.1.27 so R[l] is semiprimitive by Amitsur's theorem. Now case I is applicable. 0 # A[l] nZ[A] = ( A n Z)[A], proving A n Z # 0; also R[l] has some PI-degree n, implying R also has PI-degree n. Q.E.D. Corollary 6.1.29: If R is semiprime PI and Z(R) is a field F then R is a central simple F-algebra. Proof: Every nonzero ideal of R contains a unit in F, so R is simple, and Kaplansky's theorem is applicable. Q.E.D.
Theorem 6.1.30: If R is a prime PI-ring and S = Z(R) - (0) then S-'R is central simple over S-'Z(R) of degree n, where n = PI-deg(R). Proof: Let Z = Z(R). S-'R is prime by proposition 2.12.9' and has PIdegree n since S-'R is a central extension of R . But proposition 1.10.13 shows Z(S-'R)=S-'Z, a field, so S ' R is central simple by corollary 6.1.29. Q.E.D.
Corollary 6.1.31: If R is a semiprime PI-ring then Sing(R) = 0. Proof: If L is a large left ideal of R and Lz = 0 for z in Z(R) then z Q.E.D. Ann L = 0. Thus Z ( R ) n Sing(R) = 0, implying Sing(R) = 0.
E
Digression: We now see the theory of nonsingular rings is applicable to semiprime PI-rings. An alternate proof of theorem 6.1.28 comes by means of rings without 1, cf., exercises 18-20, and shows, furthermore, that L < R is large iff L n Z(R) is large in 2 (exercise 21), leading to an easy description of the maximal quotient ring, cf., Rowen [74]. Continuing in the general structure theory, let us exploit the n2-normality of g n .
Lemma 6.1.32: Suppose R has PI-degree n. For each r l , . . . ,rm+ in R we have g n ( r l , . .,rm)rm+1 = where
t =
1( 1
i= I
'gn(rm+ r i , . . ., T i - 1, ri+ I , . . . , rm)ri 1 9
n2.
I:’:(-
Proofi Define $(XI,...,X,,,+,) as l)'yn(X,,...,X i - l , X i + ,..., l Xm+,)Xi. Then is ( r + 1)-alternating by inspection since $(Xi H X j ) has exactly two
36.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
101
nonzero parts, which appear with opposite signs. Hence g'is an identity of R, Q.E.D. so in(r,,,+ 1 , r I ,. . . ,r,) = 0 yielding the desired equation, Theorem 6.1.33: Suppose R has PI-degree n. If there are elements r l , . .. ,r, in R f o r which gn(rl,..,,r,,,) = 1 then R is a free Z(R)-module with base rl,.. ., I , where t = n2.
xf=
Proof;. Let Z = Z ( R ) .By lemma 6.1.32 we have r = 1( - l ) i + l g ( rr, l , . . . , ri- 1, ri+ i , . . .,r)ri E X Z r , for each r in R, so r l , . . .,r1 span R. If ziri = 0 for zi in Z then for each j I t we have
2 gn(rl,... ,rji= 1
=
If=
ziri,rj+l,. . . ,r,)rj
1
= gn(rl,.. . ,zjrj,.. . ,r,) = zj
proving r l ,. . . ,r, are independent.
Q.E.D.
The Artin- Procesi Theorem The last result hints R may be Azumaya over Z ( R ) ,leading us to another major result; the equivalence (i') o (iv) below is called the Artin-Procesi theorem. Lemma 6.1.34: Suppose R has u muttitinear central polynomial g. Then g(R)' is an ideal of Z ( R ) ;furthermore, if g(R)R = R then g(R)+= Z ( R ) . Proof: Let Z = Z ( R ) . If z E 2 then zg(rl,. ..,rm) = g(zrl,. . . ,r,) E g(R), proving g(R)+is an ideal of Z. Suppose g ( R ) R = R. If g(R)+# Z then take a maximal ideal P of Z containing g ( R )and let R = R,/B where B is a maximal ideal of R,. Then 1 E g(R,)R, and g ( R p )E g ( R ) , c Z,, implying g is R-central. Since R is simple we see g(R)+= z(R), so
+ B ) / B G Z ( R ) = y ( R ) + = ( g ( R p ) ++ B ) / B G (2, + B ) / B so equality holds and 1 = s-lz + h for suitable z in y( R) +,s in 2 - P, and b (Zp
in B. Thus b = 1 - s - * z E B n Z, E Pp since 2, is local, implying the absurdity 1 E P p . The only way out is g(R)+= 2. Q.E.D.
For the purpose of the next result we say an identity f of Mn(Z)is critical if f is not an identity of Mn+, ( F ) for any field F.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
102
Theorem 6.1.35:
The following conditions are equivalent:
(i) R satisfies all the multilinear identities of M,(h), and each critical multilinear identity f of M,is not satisfied by any homomorphic image of R. (i’) R satisJies all the multilinear identities of M,(Z), and there is some multilinear identity f of M,-,(Z) not satisfied by any homomorphic image of R. (ii) R has PI-degree n and 1 E g,,(R)R. (iii) R has PI-degree n and 1 E g,(R)+. (iv) R is Azumaya of constant rank n2. Proof: Let Z = Z ( R ) .(i) =(if) is obvious. (i’) *(ii) Otherwise, take a maximal ideal P containing g,(R)R. Then g,, is an identity of RIP, implying R I P has PI-degree < n, and thus RIP satisfies f , contradiction. (ii) (iii) by lemma 6.1.34. (iii) + (iv) Write 1 = C:= gn(ril,.. . ,rim).First we show R is an f.g. projective Z-module by means of the dual basis lemma. Indeed, define Aj: R -,Z by
Ajr = ( - I)’+ ‘g,,(r,ril,. . . ,ri.j - ,,ri, j +
,,... ,rim).
Then lemma 6.1.32 implies r = cy:l(Ajr)rij,so {(rij,Jj):1 I j 5 n } is the desired dual basis. rank(R) = n2 by theorem 6.1.33, since g,,(RP)contains an invertible element of Z, for any P in Spec(Z). Clearly R is faithful over 2 since 1 E R, so it suffices to prove the canonical homomorphism +: R @ RoP -+ End, R is an isomorphism. To this end hU1Xlhu2for suitable polynomials hU,(X2,.. .,X,,,). Let aiiu= write g , = ( - 1)j h, l(ri ,...,ri, - ri, + 1,. ..,rim) and bij, = hu2(ri,,...,ri. j - 1 , ri,j + 1,. ..,rim). To show @ is onto let p E End, R. We shall show p= @(~ i , j , uaijy0 bijuprij). Indeed. 2
+
as desired.
xu
103
96.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
To show $ is 1:l suppose C x u O yu =
c
1,
(1
i.o
cl.x,, 0y ,
E ker $ for
suitable .xu in R, y, in
ROP.
.. *rim)Xw o yu
gn(ri, *.
since xUbijuy,= xu0 y,,)bijU= 0. Thus ker $ = 0. (Once upon a time this was the “hard direction” of the Artin-Procesi theorem; see exercise 13 for an even shorter proof.) (iv)*(i) First we claim no hornomorphic image RIA of R satisfies f . Indeed, otherwise, taking P maximal containing A we see R I P satisfies f; but R I P is central simple over its center and splitting by a maximal subfield we see f is an identity of M,.(F) for some field F, where n’ is the PI-degree of RIP. Since f is critical we have n’ < n, so R I P has dimension I( n - 1)2 over its center Z / ( Z n P), contrary to proposition 5.3.27. It remains to show R satisfies all identities of M,,(Z). In view of proposition 2.12.15(i) we may assume Z is local, with maximal ideal P ; then PR is the unique maximal ideal of R , and R = R / P R is simple of dimension n 2 over ZIP, by proposition 5.3.27. We need to quote the following fact from the theory of central simple algebras, to be proved below as proposition 7.1.22. There are elements rj, a in R for which (ai-‘5:1 s i, j I a> are a base for R over where denotes the canonical image in R . Now {ui-’rj: 1 I i , j I n> span R over Z by Nakayama’s lemma, implying r l , ...,r, span R as module over the commutative ring ZCa]. The regular representation enables us to embed R into EndzIalR, which by theorem 1.5.13 is a homomorphic image of a subring of M,,(Z[a]); since Z [ a ] is a homornorphic image of the free commutative ringZ[E.] we see R satisfies all multilinear identities of M,,(Z[1]) and thus Q.E.D. of M,,(Z).
z,
The critical identity of M,, usually used in (i’) is S2,,- 2 , in view of the Amitsur-Levitzki theorem. The Artin-Procesi theorem is a very explicit computational tool for studying Azumaya algebras of rankn, and actually
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
104
c:=l
provides a new invariant, the minimal number k for which 1 = zifor suitable zi in g,(R). If k = 1 then R is free over Z(R), by theorem 6.1.33. Remark 6.1.35': Examining the proof of lemma 6.1.32 and theorem 6.1.35, we see that the condition in (iii) that R has PI-degree n could be weakened to ''ij is an identity of R."
The n- Spectrum One way to achieve I
E g,(R)
is by localization.
Corollary 6.1.36: Suppose R has PI-degree n with center Z and s E g,(R). Then R[s-'] is Azumaya of rankn2 over Z[s-'], and, in fact, is free over Z[s-']. Proof: 1 E g,(R[s-']) so lemma 6.1.34 shows Z(R[s-'])=g,(R[s-'])+ Z[s-'] G Z(R[s-'I); thus equality holds throughout. Now R[s-'] Q.E.D. Azumaya by theorem 6.1.35 and is free by theorem 6.1.33.
E
is
This provides a most powerful tool, since it is applicable whenever g,(R) $ P. Accordingly we make the following definition. Definition 6.1.37: Suppose Z = Z(R). Spec,(R) = { P E Spec(R):g,(R) $ P } and Spec,(Z) = { P E Spec(Z):g,(R) $ P } .
g,(R) is often called the Formanek center; the primes in Spec,(R) are called identity-faithful or regular. The following theorem and subsequent results have more elementary proofs in Rowen [80B, p. 76-78]. Theorem 6.1.38: Suppose P E Spec,(Z(R)). There is a unique P' in Spec(R) lying over P, and P' contains every ideal A of R for which A n Z(R) E P. In other words, R, is local with maximal ideal PpRp. Proof: Pass to R,, which is Azumaya and thus local with maximal ideal PpRp,and translate this back to R. Q.E.D. Corollary 6.1.39:
LO, C U , and INC hold from Z(R) to R in Spec,.
This permits us to build an inductive procedure on the PI-degree, and there is also a pleasant correspondence of maximal ideals.
$6.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
105
Lemma 6.1.40: lf P‘ E Spec,(R) is a maximal ideal of R then Z ( R )n P‘ is a maximal ideal of Z(R). Proofi Let Z = Z ( R ) and R theorem 6.1.34 so
=
R / P ‘ , a simple ring. Then 1 E g , ( R ) + by
Z ( R ) = g ( R ) + = gof !z 2 G Z ( R )
implying Z ( R ) = 2 % Z / ( P ’ n Z ) .
Q.E.D.
These results show that the “difficult” part of Spec(R) is the complement of the n-spectrum. Nevertheless, there are some interesting results, most notably the Bergman-Small “additivity principle” to be discussed in $6.3.
The Algebra of Generic Matrices We shall now deal with a PI-ring which is a very important “test ring.” Given a commutative ringC we let A = {i1: I; i,) j I: n, k E N } be a set of commuting indeterminates over C, and let & denote the matrix (A:;)) in M,,(C[A]).Each entry of Y, is a different indeterminate; accordingly, we call & a generic matrix and define the algebra of generic matrices, denoted C,{ Y } , to be the C-subalgebra of M,,(C[A])generated by the &. Proposition 6.1.41: lf C is an integral domain then the algebra of generic matrices C,,{Y ) is prime. Let K be the field of fractions of C[A] and let R‘ = C,{ Y ) K G M , ( K ) . Clearly the Capelli polynomial of degree 2n2 is nonvanishing on generic matrices (seen by specializing the indeterminates), so [R‘:K] 2 n 2 . But this means R’ = M,(K); hence M,,(K) is a central extension of C,{ Y } , which thus is prime by proposition 2.12.39 (taking P’ = 0). Q.E.D. Proofi
The significance of C,{ Y } lies in the following result: Proposition 6.1.42: (i) There is a canonical surjection cp: C { X } + C , { Y } given by cpX, = yI, and ker 40 = (identities of M,(C[A])). (ii) C,{Y} is free in the class %? of algebras satisfying the identities of MAC CAI).
Rings with Polynomial Identities and A
106
h Algebras
Proof:
(i) cp exists because C { X ) is free. If f ( X , , ..., X,) is an identity of M,,(C[A])then f ( Y,, ..., Y,) = 0 so f E ker cp. To finish the proof of (i) it suffices to prove if f ( Y , , . .., Y,) = 0 then f ( X , , . . .,X,) is an identity of M,,(C[A]). Given any matrices ak = (c!;’) in M,,(C[A])we could extend the map 1;;’ H cG’ to a homomorphism C [ A ] -,C [ A ] and thus to a homomorphism M,,(C[A])+ M , ( C [ A ] ) sending % = (A!;)) to a k ; then f ( a l , . . , a , ) is the image of f ( Yl ,. . ., Y,) = 0. (ii) This argument will be repeated more generally in $6.4. Suppose R E W. Given any map H ri for i = 1,2,. .. we have a homomorphism I): C { X }+R sending Xi H ri for each i . We shall show ker IJ 2 ker 50, for then we can C,,{ Y } + R factor IJ through C,,{Y } to get the desired homomorphism satisfying $ = r i , and clearly is unique such. If f E ker cp then f is an identity of M , ( C [ A ] ) by (i), so f ( r l , .. . ,r,) = 0 since R E ‘if?, implying f~ ker $. Q.E.D.
x
x
6
6:
The Identities of a PI-Algebra Proposition 6.1.42 heightens our interest in which rings satisfy all the identities of M,,(C[A]). Accordingly we define Y ( R )= {identities of R } , and we say C-algebras R and T are PI-equivalent if Y ( R )= Y ( T ) . Let us start by asking when R and R Oc H are PI-equivalent, recalling proposition 6.1.1 1. Now we must require some restriction on C , as evidenced by the example that Z / 2 B satisfies the identity f = X : - X , but no other field satisfies f. Lemma 6.1.43: Suppose C is an injinite integral domain, and the polynomial p E C[A,,. . . ,i k ] satisfies p ( c , , . . . ,ck) = 0 for all ciin C . Then p = 0. Proof: This is well-known, but we review it here. The case k = 1 follows at once from the fact that any nonzero p(iLl)has only a finite number of zeroes in the field of fractions of C , so some p ( c ) # 0. In general, p = C : = o p i ( A l,..., i k -,)A: and for each c = ( c l ,..., in C(‘-l’ write p , = pi(c,,. . . , c k - ,)At,E FCA,]. Then as seen above p , = 0 so p , = 0 for each i and all c in C I k - ’ ) ,implying each p i = 0 by induction on k ; hence p =O. Q.E.D.
I:=,
Theorem 6.1.44: Suppose R is torsion-free over an injinite integral domain C. Then R is PI-equivalent to R OCH for any torsion-free commutative Calgebra H .
$6.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
107
Proof: Identify R with R 0 1 G R 0 H. Then every identity of R 0 H is an identity of R, so it remains to show every identity f of R is an identity of R 0 H . Let F be the field of fractions of C . Replacing H by H OcF we may assume H is an F-algebra. R 0 F has a base {ri:i E I } over F, where each ri E R. Given x l , . . .,x , in R 0 H write x j = c i r i 0 aij where the aij E H. Then f ( x l , .. . ,xm)= ri 0 pi(a) where each p i E C[ii,,. .. ,Am] and p,(a) is the evaluation at various aij. If all our aij E C then each x l , . . . , x m E R so f ( x l , . . . ,x,) = 0 and thus each pi(a)= 0; therefore, each pi = 0 by lemma 6.1.43.But then pi(a) = 0 for arbitrary aij in H , implying f ( x l , . . .,x,) = 0 Q.E.D. for all x l , . . . ,x, in R 0 H .
xi
Corollary 6.1.45: If R is a torsion-free algebra over an inJinite integral domain C then R is PI-equivalent to any central extension T of S-’R, where
s = c - (0).
Proof: Let H = Z ( T ) .Then R is PI-equivalent to R OCH . But T is a homomorphic image of R Or €€ so using the theorem we have
T(R) = T ( R O c H ) E T ( T )G T f R ) since R
G
T ; hence equality holds and R is PI-equivalent to T.
Q.E.D.
Corollary 6.1.46: Suppose R is a semiprime PI-algebra over an infinite Jield F. Then R is PI-equivalent to Mn(F)for some n.
Proof: R is PI-equivalent to R[A], which is semiprimitive by Amitsur’s theorem since Nil(R) = 0. Hence we may assume R is semiprimitive, by theorem 2.5.23. But .2’(Mn-l(F))2 T ( M n ( F ) )by lemma 6.1.27’, so passing to primitive images we may assume R is primitive and thus central simple by Kaplansky’s theorem. Taking a splitting field K we see R is PI-equivalent to R 0 K z Mn(Kz ) M,(F) OFK , which is PI-equivalent to Mn(F). Q.E.D. Corollary 6.1.46‘: Suppose F is a fteld, and R is a simple F-algebra of PI degree n, with Z = Z ( R ) injinite. Then R is PI-equivalent to Fn{Y } .
Proof: We have the following sequence of PI-equivalent algebras: R, Q.E.D. Mn(Z),Mn(Z[Al),Mn(F[’l), Fn{ Y } . Corollary 6.1.47: Suppose C is an integral domain. Every semiprime C-algebra R of PI-degree n satisfies all the identities of Mn(C[h]) and is thus a homomorphic image of the generic matrix algebra Cn{Y } .
108
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affiw Algebras
Proof: By proposition 6.1.42(ii)it is enough to show R satisfies all identities of M,(C[A]);since R is a subdirect product of prime images we may assume R is prime. Replacing C by its image C 1 in R , we may assume C G R. We may replace R by R [ A ] , which in turn is PI-equivalent to its algebra of central quotients, which is an algebra over the (infinite) field of fractions of Q.E.D. C[A], so we are done by corollary 6.1.46.
.
Remark 6.2.47': The same proof shows: If every prime homomorphic image of C is infinite then every semiprime C-algebra R of PI-degree n satisfies all identities of M,,(C).
Noe t her ian PI-Rings The subject of Noetherian PI-rings relies heavily on the following observation, which permits us at once to lift many of the results directly from 83.5. Proposition 6.1.48: Every PI-ring R is left and right fully bounded. Proof: We may assume R is prime, and by symmetry need to show any large left ideal L contains a two-sided ideal. But letting S = Z ( R ) - {0} we show S-'L is a large left ideal of the simple Artinian ringQ = S ' R , so S-'L = Q and thus some s E S n L. Now 0 # Rs Q R , and clearly every nonzero ideal of a prime ring is large. Q.E.D. Theorem 6.1.49: If R is a Noetherian PI-ring then all f.g. R-modules M .
niEN Jac(R)'M = 0 for
Proofi By theorem 3.5.28, noting the hypotheses hold by proposition 6.1.48 and Kaplansky's theorem. Q.E.D. Theorem 6.1.50: In a lefi Noetherian PI-ring every prime ideal has finite height. Proof: By theorem 3.5.13,noting that every nonzero ideal of a prime PI-ring Q.E.D. has a nonzero central element which thus is normalizing.
To determine when R is Noetherian we can use the following property of arbitrary prime rings of PI-degree n. Proposition 6.1.51: Suppose R is prime of PI-degree n. Then any lefi ideal L
96.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
109
is isomorphic to a Z(R)-submodule of a free Z(R)-module M of rank 5 n 2 contained in L . Explicitly there is z # 0 in Z(R) for which Z L E M G L . Proof: Let Z = Z(R) and take k maximal possible for which there are r l , . . ., r m such that z = g n ( r l , . . ,r,) # 0 with k of the ri from L . Passing to the ring of fractions of R we see the ri are 2-independent; relabeling the ri from L as a l , .. . , a k we take M = k Zai z Z‘k’. It remains to show Z L E M. But lemma 6.1.32 yields
xi=
,
za = C ( - l ) j + 1 gn(a,rl,..., r j - l , r j + l , . .. , I m~)r. j= 1
and the j-th summand is 0 by maximality of k unless rj E L , implying each Q.E.D. nonzero summand is in M . Corollary 6.1.52: (Formanek) Suppose R is prime PI. If ZfR) is Noetherian then R is f . g . as Z(R)-module and hence is Noetherian. I f Z(R) has Krull dimension a then R has Krull dimension 5 a.
Proof: R is a submodule of an f.g. Z(R)-module.
Q.E.D.
A cute variant of this idea yields Cauchon’s theorem, that any semiprime PI-ring with ACC(ideals) is Noetherian, cf., exercise 24. Formanek’s result raised the hope that the structure of a prime Noetherian PI-ring is closely tied to the structure of its center. Although this is true in certain special cases, e.g., when R hereditary (cf., Robson-Small [74]), the general situation is the opposite; the center of a prime Noetherian PI-ring can be rather different. Perhaps the most efficient counterexample (i.e., most pathology for least work) is exercise 27. In desperation it was asked whether a prime PI-ring must be f.g. as module over a suitable commutative subring. Building on examples by Cauchon and Bergman, Sarraille [82] produced a counterexample, cf., exercise 6.3.2. If R is Noetherian PI then K-dim(R) 5 gl.dimR when the latter exists. This was proved more generally for fully bounded Noetherian rings under the restriction that the center contains an uncountable domain, by BrownWarfield [84]; Goodearl-Small [84] finished the result for Noetherian PI-rings by passing t o the Laurent series ring R((k)),whose center Z((k)) is uncountable. To accomplish this reduction they had to show gl. dim R((1)) = gl. dim R and K-dim R I K-dim R((1)).The latter fact is easy since there is a lattice injection Y(R((1))+ Y(R) given by L H L’, where L’ = { a E R: n is the lowest order coefficient of some element of L (viewed as Laurent series)}.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
110
Vamos [77] showed the completion k of a semilocal Noetherian PI-ring R is Noetherian, and I? 6- is an exact functor which on R - F i m ~ dis naturally equivalent to the I-adic completion. Much recent work on Noetherian PI-rings has focused on the “trace ring” T(R), so we postpone the continuation of this discussion until proposition 6.3.45ff.
Digression: Verifving PI- Rings How does one spot that a ring is PI? This is usually obvious, for we are usually given the polynomial identity. However, there are instances when the PI is not clear. Usually it is easy to determine whether or not a semiprime ring is PI, for this is equivalent to its being embeddible in matrices, cf., theorem 6.1.26. The reduction to the semiprime case is given by the following useful result of Amitsur. Theorem 6.1.53: Suppose % is a class of algebra closed under direct powers, RiE W whenever each R, = R. If f is an identity of i.e., if R E W then R/Nil(R) for each R in % then every R in V satisjes a suitable power off. If, furthermore, % is closed under direct products then there is k in N such that f Ir is an identity of all R in %.
Hie,
Proofi
(i) Write f = f(X,, . . . ,X,,,). For each r = ( r l , .. .,rm) in R(”’) let R, deLet ;ibe the element of R, whose note a copy of R and let R, = r-component is r , . Then f (F1,. . . ,Fn)E Nil(&) by hypothesis so matching the r-components shows f ( r l , .. .,r,,,)‘ = 0 for each r, i.e., f Ir is an identity of R. (ii) So far k depends on R. Suppose % is closed under direct products. We are done unless for each k in N there is some R , for which f k is not an identity of R,. Then no power of f is an identity of n k e N R kcontrary , to (i). Q.E.D.
n,.,.
Corollary 6.1.54:
If R is a PI-ring then M,(R) is a PI-ring for any t .
Proofi First note if R is semiprime of PI-degree n then R is embeddible in n x n matrices so M,(R) is embeddible in tn x tn matrices and thus has PI-degree tn. Letting % = (M,(R):R satisfies a given polynomial identity f >, we see % satisfies the criteria of the theorem. Q.E.D.
There are many similar uses, cf., exercises 28,29, 34,35.
$6.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
111
Digression: Generalized Iden tities and Rational Iden tities The polynomial identity is an example of a universal atomic sentence and has rather powerful consequences as we have seen. This raises the question of whether weaker atomic sentences would also be of use. There is an assortment of such results in the literature, but many are of limited use because of the difficulty of verifying the given condition. However, one such theory has proved applicable in a variety of situations and, not surprisingly, is related to the PI-theory. Logically it involves universal atomic sentences which arise when we permit assignment of constant symbols to elements of the ring. For example M,(F) satisfies the sentence VxlVx2([ellxlell,ellx2~lll = 0). The correct algebraic framework is to fix a ring W and deal with the category of W-rings, i.e., those rings R for which there is a ring homomorphism cp: W -,R such that cp(Z(W))G Z(R). Writing Z for Z(W) we see the free W-ring is merely the free product of W and Z{X> as Z-algebras; its elements are called generalized polynomials, or W-polynomials, and are sums of terms of the form w ~ X ~ ~ W ~ X ~ ~ .where . * Wthe ~ Xw ~j e~W.WNormally ,+~ one takes W = R. Definition 6.1.55: A generalized identity (or GI) of a W-ring R is a generalized polynomial which vanishes for all substitutions in R.
The multilinearization procedure enables us to reduce to the case of multilinear GI’s. However, it is not immediately apparent what kind of GI is appropriate to require for a ring; any nonprime ring R satisfies the GI aX,b for suitable a, b (viewed as R-ring). The key lies in defining a generalized monomial to be a generalized polynomial in which the indeterminates of each monomial occur in the same order, e.g., X2wlX,X, - X2X,w2X3w3. Every multilinear generalized polynomial can be written uniquely as the sum of generalized monomials. Definition 6.1.56: A multilinear GI of R is improper if its generalized monomials each are GI’s of R . A GI is proper if it is not improper.
We say a primitive ringR is strongly primitive if R is dense in EndM, where the division ring D is PI, and soc(R) # 0. Remark 6.1.57: Any strongly primitive ring R satisfies a proper GI. (Indeed let e be a primitive idempotent of R. Then D = eRe satisfies some standard identity S,, and S,(eX,e,. ..,eX,e) is a GI of R which is proper since R is prime.)
112
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
This remark motivates the two main structure theorems of the subject: Amitsur’s Theorem for GI’s: satisfies a proper GI.
A primitive ring is strongly primitive fi
it
Martindale’s Theorem: If R is prime with proper GI then its centra[ closure is strongly primitive. Full accounts of these theorems are given in Rowen [80B, Chapter 71; we shall indicate a fast proof of Amitsur’s theorem in exercises 30,31. However, the full power of the GI lies in the more technical fact that the GI can be rewritten such that each of its monomials contains a coefficient in the socle, cf., Rowen [80B, theorem 7.2.21. Multilinear GI’s are very effective in the study of “elementary” properties, because they pass to tensor extensions (as in proposition 6.1.1 l), and thus often permit one to pass to matrices over an algebraically closed field. An example of their application is the Martindale-Miers [85] exposition of Herstein’s theorem on Lie and Jordan structure. Note also that exercise 5.3.1 1 is really a theorem concerning GI’s. A different universal atomic sentence is obtained if instead of expanding the assignments of constants we expand the unary operations of the language. One possibility is to allow the formal introduction of inverses into the identities; this defines rational identities. One example of a rational identity is Hua’s famous identity (X-l + (Y- - X)-’)-l - ( X - X Y X ) which arises in the fundamental theorem of projective geometry. But Hua’s identity vanishes for all substitutions in every ring (whenever one can take the inverses), so must be called “trivial”; we see that it is difficult to identity the “nontrivial” rational identities. Amitsur [66] showed that rational identities are precisely what we get from intersection theorems in Desarguian geometries and proved that any division algebra satisfying a nontrivial rational identity is actually a PI-ring. The theory of rational identities is treated in Rowen [80B, Chapter 81 and relies heavily on applications by Bergman [76] of the Bergman-Small theorem discussed in 56.3.
P Supplement: Identities and Generalized Identities with Involution One can handle identities in rings with involution, called (*)-identities merely by expanding the language to include the involution. Thus we say
56.1 Rings with Polynomial Identities
113
f ( X , , X : , . ..,X,,Xz) is an idenrity of ( R ,*) if f(r,,rT,. . .,rm,r:) = 0 for all ri in R. More generally, one can define (*)-GI's. The question arises at once if this theory is any richer than the theory without (*). To this end we say a (*)-identity f ( X , , X : ,...,X,,Xt) is (R,*)-special if f ( X , ,X , ,...,X2,- I ,X2,) is an identity of R ; likewise for (*)-GI's.
Example 6.1.58: (i) Let (*) be the transpose involution on R = M,(F). Then [ X , - X:, X , - X : ] is a non-special identity of ( R ,*). (ii) Let (*) be the symplectic involution on M,(F). Then every symmetric element is central, so [ X , + X : , X,] is a non-special identity of ( R , *). (iii) If R 0 RoP has the exchange involution (*) then every (*)-identity is special, for if f ( X l , X T , . . . ,X,, X:) is a (*)-identity we have ( f ( l l 7 .
r,?m)?
..?
O)
= ( l ? o ) f ( ( r l ?r 2 ) 7 ( r 2 7 r 1 ) , ( r 3 r = (1,0)f((r1, r,),
r4),(r47
r3)?.
. .)
(r1,r;), . . .) = (070).
Note that the minimal degree of a (*)-identity might be smaller than the minimal degree of a PI, so one may wonder whether the existence of a (*)-identity implies the ring is PI. This is true by a theorem of Amitsur, cf., exercise 36. Theorem 6.1.59: Suppose R is a semiprime PI ring which has an involution (*). Then every nonzero ideal A of ( R ,*) intersects Z ( R ,*) nontrivially. Proofi By theorem 6.1.28 there is 0 # z E A n Z ( R ) . Then z + z* E A n Z(R,*)sowearedoneunlessz= -z*. But n o w O # - z 2 = z z * E A n Z ( R , * ) . Q.E.D. Corollary 6.1.60: If R is a semiprime PI-ring with involution (*) and Z ( R , * ) is a field then (R,*) is simple. Theorem 6.1.61: If R is a PI-ring and ( R ,*) is prime then taking S = Z ( R , *) ( 0 ) we have S is regular and (S-'R, *) is simple. Proofi Apply proposition 2.13.35 and corollary 6.1.60 to (S-'R, *), noting Z(S-'R, *) = S-'Z(R, *). Q.E.D.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affiw Algebras
114
56.2 Affine Algebras Definition 6.2.1: R is an afJine C-algebra if R is generated as algebra by a finite number of elements r l , . .. ,rt; in this case we write R = C { r l , . . , r , } . (In the literature C is often required to be a field.) Commutative affine algebras over fields are obviously Noetherian, and we record the following useful result. Noether (-Bourbaki) Normalization Theorem: (cf., Bourbaki [72B, theorem v.3.11) Suppose A , G ... E A, are ideals in a commutative afJine algebra C over a j e l d F. There is a transcendence base cl,. ..,c, of C for which C is integral ouer F [ c , ,. . . ,c,], and such that there are n( 1 ) I n(2) I ... I n(k) such that Ai n F[c,, . . . ,c,] = n(i) Ccufor 1 I iI k.
xu=,
On the other hand, the free algebra in two noncommuting indeterminates is far from Noetherian and so affine algebras offer an alternative to Noetherian rings in building a general geometric-flavored ring theory. We shall start with some general results concerning affine algebras and then delve into the Gelfand-Kirillov dimension. Remark 6.2.2: C/(C n A ) .
If R is an affine C-algebra and A 4R then RIA is affine over
Recall from theorem 2.5.22 that the weak Nullstellensatz holds for affine algebras over uncountable fields, so the starting point of our inquiry might be whether this is true in general, i.e., if Jac(R) is nil for R affine over a field. This question was open for a long time but was settled negatively by Beidar using a very easy method which we describe below now (with some Small modifications). Note f.g. always means as module in what follows. Example 6.2.3: (Affinization) If T is an affine C-algebra and L is a f.g. left ideal of T then
-
C+L '=(L
T T)
is affine over C 1, and Z ( R ) E C + L. Indeed if T = C{al, ...,a t } and L= Tai for a:,aj in T then R = C { e l , , e , , , a ~ e , , , a j e , , 1: i I n, 1I j It } .
56.2 Affine Algebras
115
Note Z(R) can be very poorly behaved, and even not affine, e.g., take T = O[A] and L = TL. A related instance was given in exercise 6.1.28. This example also is used in exercises 3,4. However, we want to see what happens when T is the free associative ring. Example 6.2.4: (Failure of the Nullstellensatz for affine algebras.) Build R as in example 6.2.3, where C is a countable field F, T = F { X I , X 2 } ,and L = TX,. Then R has a prime ideal P for which R / P is right Noetherian affine over F but Jac(R/P) # 0 = Nil(R/P). To see this let
which is isomorphic to the free algebra in countably many indeterminates. Let H be a countable Noetherian local integral domain, such as the localization of F [ L ] at the prime ideal 1. Then H = T'/A for some A in Spec(T').
R
=(
'1;
T:J
T hence RAR = ( f A is contained in an ideal P of R L T maximal with respect to P n ff= A, and P E Spec(R) by remark 2.12.42. Let R = RIP and let e denote the image of e l , in RIP. Then eRe x T / A x H so 0 # Jac(eRe) = e Jac(R)e by proposition 2.5.14, proving Jac(R) # 0. R is left Noetherian since right multiplication by the image of X , 1 gives a lattice injection from the left ideals 9 ( R ) to Y ( M , ( H ) ) . In particular, Nil(R) = 0 since R is prime and left Noetherian.
-
In practice many affine algebras do satisfy the weak Nullstellensatz and more, as we shall see in 86.3 and 86.4, and there is no known answer to If R is Noetherian and affine over a field then is Jac(R) necessarily nil? (An affirmative answer would imply R is Jacobson by passing to homomorphic images.)
Question 6.2.4':
Incidentally, the relationship between affine and Noetherian is mysterious; it is not even known if every affine subalgebra of the Weyl algebra A,(F) is Noetherian.) Let us try to salvage something concrete from the wreckage of exarnple 6.2.4. First we note that there are cases when the center is affine. Proposition 6.2.5: (Artin-Tate) l f C is commutative Noetherian and R is an afine C-algebra and Z is a C-subalgebra of Z ( R ) over which R is fg. then Z is also ajtine.
116
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
Proof: WriteR = C { r , ,..., r , } andR = ~ : = , 2 x k f o r s u i t a b l e x k iR.Then n we have elements Zijk, ZLk in 2 for which
Let 2, = C[zi,k;Z:k: 1 I i, j , k I m and 1 I u I t ] , which is commutative Z,x, is affine and thus Noetherian. Then one can check at once R = f.g. over Z , , so R is a Noetherian 2,-module and thus its submodule Z is f.g. over Z , , implying 2 is affine. Q.E.D.
zr=,
Other results verifying when an algebra is affine are given in exercises 1,2; a sweeping result can be found in Lorenz [84].
Kurosch ’s Problem and the Golod-Shafarevich Counterexample Having seen that affine algebras exist in abundance, we might wonder whether something can be said if extra restrictions are imposed. Problem 6.2.6: (Kurosch’s problem) If R is affine over a field F and algebraic over F then is R finite dimensional as a vector space over F? This famous problem has two key special cases: Kurosch’s Problem for Division Rings: If a division algebra D is affine and algebraic over F then is D central simple? (If so then D is f.g. over Z(D), implying Z(D) is affine by Artin-Tate and thus [Z(D):F] < 00 by corollary 6.3.2 below, and thence [D:F] < 00.) Leuitzki’s Problem: If N is a nil, affine F-algebra without 1 then is N nilpotent? This is cleary a special case of Kurosch, since adjoining 1 formally would give an affine algebraic algebra R and if [ R :F] < 00 then N = NiI(R) is nilpotent.
There is a cute reduction of Kurosch’s problem to the prime case, cf., exercise 5. Kurosch for division rings is still open in general, but has a positive solution for F uncountable, by proposition 6.1.24; Levitzki’s problem, however, is false even for F uncountable, by a celebrated example of Golod [64] and Shafarevich. Recently Bergman [86] has studied local finiteness (and the Golod-Shafarevich example) in terms of the Jacobson radical of extension rings, and sharper examples have recently appeared. Let us study the original Golod-Shafarevich example.
$6.2 Affine Algebras
117
Main Computational Lemma 6.2.7: Grade the free associative algebra F t X , , . . . , X , ) by the (total) degree. Let A be an ideal generated as an ideal by a countably infinite set S of homogeneous elements of degree 2 2. Writing s k = (elements of S of degree k f , suppose there are numbers m, 2 I&l for which the coeficients of the power series
are all non-negative. Then R = F { X I , .. . ,X,,,}/A is infinite dimensional over F. Proof: (Vinberg) We write power series C a j l j < c b j l j to indicate that each aj bj. Let nj = [R,:F]. The aim o f the proof is to show the series njAJ 2 p(A). This would finish the proof since p has infinite support, is., an infinite number of nonzero coefficients. (Indeed, if p had finite support then (1 &>2mkAk)p would have infinite support since all the coefficients of p are non-negative; but (1 - mL + m,Ak)p = 1, so -mAp must have infinite support, implying p has infinite support.) Write T for Fix,,. . . ,Xm>,and 7;- for the homogeneous part of degree j. Then TI = X F X , and T T , = @j,o so T = TT, 0 F. Let Bj be a vector subspace of T j complementary to A j , and B = @B,. Then T = A 0 B so
xi.
5
+
A
=
TST = 'TSTT,
+ TSF = AT, + T S = AT, + ( A + B ) S = ATl + BS.
3+
Taking homogeneous parts yields A, = A,x j B , - j S j ; computing dimensions (noting [ A j : F ] + [ B j : F ] = [ T , : F ] = r n J and [ B j : F ] = [ R j : F ] = n j ) we have mk - nk 5 ( m k - l - n k - l ) m
+ Cnk-jdj j
where dj = [Sjl,implying
0 In, - n k - l m -tIn,-,dj I n, - n k - l m +Cn,-,mj j
+ c,,
Cj
I
for all k 2 1. Letting h ( i ) = ( njA')( 1 - m l munu) our inequality shows h 2 1. But then CjnjAi = hp = p + (h - l ) p 2 p as desired, since (h - 1)p has only non-negative coefficients. Q.E.D. As final preparation we need a standard observation about counting.
'>
Remark 6.2.8: The number of ways of selecting n objects from q allowing q+n-1 (Indeed, since is the number of repetitions is
(
).
("
+
118
Rings with Polynomial Identities and AfRae Algebrss
ways of selecting n from 4 + n - 1 without repetition, we wish to find a 1: 1 correspondence between these selections and selections of n from 4 with repetitions. Arranging selections in ascending order, we define the “bottom” of a selection of n from 4 + n - 1 to be those numbers I 4. We shall conclude by showing for any t that the number of selections of n from q + n - 1 having a particular bottom ( i , , . . . , i t ) is the same as the number of selections of n from q which are i, ,. ..,it with repetitions. Indeed, in the first case we are selecting n - t objects from the n - 1 objects 4 + 1,. ..,q + n - 1 without repetition, and in the latter case we are selecting n - t objects from the t objects i,, .. .,it with repetition, which by induction on n has (t
(z 1:)
+;I;-1)
=
possibilities, so indeed these numbers are the same).
Theorem 6.2.9: (Golod [ 6 6 ] ) Given any field F and any n 2 2 there is an infinite dimensional graded F-algebra R , without 1, generated as algebra without 1 by m elements, such that every subset of c m elements of R , is nilpotent. I n particutar, R , is nil and is a counterexample to Levitzki’s and R: = 0. Kurosch‘s problem. Furthermore
nncN
Proofi Since we want to use lemma 6.2.7 we first look for a general instance for which the coefficients of the power series (1 - mR + ~ ~ = = 2 m k A are k)-1 non-negative. We claim this holds for
mk = E’(m - 2&)k-2
where 0 < 2~ < m.
Indeed we compute 1-mi
+ k1 E2(m - 2 ~ ) ~ - ’ ;= 1 ~1 - m l + >2
E2R2
1 - (m - 2 ~ ) i
- (1 - ( m - ~ ) i ) ’ 1 - (m - 2E)i ’ so its reciprocal is
119
$6.2 Affine Algebras
=1
+ x ( ( k + I)(m
-E ) ~
(m - 2 ~ ) k ( m- ~ ) ~ - ' ) l &
and the coefficients are visibly positive. Next we shall construct inductively a set S of homogeneous elements Is1,s 2 , . . ,) c T having the following properties: (i) There are IE2(m- 2~)'-' elements of S having degree k, for each k ; (ii) If fi,,..,fmt-l are arbitrary in T having constant term 0 then if1,. .. ,fm- I}" G ( S ) for suitable n = n ( f l , ...,fm- )).
Clearly R , = TIT / ( S ) would be the desired algebra. Assume by induction that for given k , there is d = d ( k , ) for which homogeneous sl,.. . ,s d of degree k , have been selected and such that whenever each f;: has degree 5 k , we have ifl,. . . ,fm- 1 } " !z (sl,. . .,s,) for suitable n depending on fl,. . . ,fmWe want to select the next bunch of s j , each of degree > k , . To do this formally write
fi = l a i w w
for 1 I i Im
-1
where aiuE F and w runs over the words in X1,. ..,X,,, having degree between 1 and k,. Now any product of length n (to be determined) of the J;: has total nk, and is a linear combination of homogeneous elements whose degree I coefficients are products of the aiu.Taking s d + sd+ ... to be these homogeneous elements we formally have satisfied condition (ii). It remains to verify (i), which we claim is automatic if n is large enough. First of all taking n > d we see that each of the new sj have degree > d ; the number of possible new sj is at most the number of commutative monomials in the aiw,and this can be estimated as I d'd" where d' is the number of commutative monomials having length n in the a l W ; d" = (m - 1)" is the number of possible ways to replace a product ... where 1 5 i, Im - 1 for each u. alwr a,," by ai,wl.--ainwn Note d' is the number of ways of choosing n from q
= (m -
I)(m + m2
+ + mko)
(the number of words of degree I k,) allowing repetitions, which by remark 6.2.8 is
(" ; +
- 1) I (q
+ n - 1y-1.
Let c = ( m - 2 ~ ) / ( r n 1). Taking E < we may assume c > 1. For sufficiently large n we have (q + n - 1)q- IE2cn/(m- 24' since the exponential
120
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
rises faster than the polynomial; thus for such n we see d'd" 5 ( q
+n
-
l)qpl(m- 1)" 5 (cZc"/(rn - 2c)')(m - 1)"
= c2(m - 2&)"/(m-
2 ~ ) '= c Z ( m- 2~)"-'.
Since the new monomials all have degree 2 n > k, we see (i) holds, as desired. Q.E.D. Note 6.2.9': The algebra of theorem 6.2.9 is considerably more than a counterexample to Kurosch's problem. For example, taking m = 4 we get a counterexample R, for which M , ( R , ) also is nil. If we are interested in finding the quickest counterexample to Kurosch's problem we could require merely that each sj has a power in (S); thus one can work with one j at a time and streamline the above proof considerably, cf., Herstein [69B] which produces a quick application of lemma 6.2.7 for F countable and m = 3.
Growth of Algebras The crux of the Golod-Shafarevich example is that S was "sparse" enough that the algebra R although nil grew exponentially in terms of the generators. Thus it makes sense to require that our algebras do not grow so fast. This leads us to the following situation. For the remainder of this section we assume R is an algebra over a Jield F. If S = { T I , . . . , r , } we write F { S } for F { r l , . . .,r,,,}. Definition 6.2.10: Suppose R = F { S } . Let VJS) be the subspace and define the growth function Cs(n) of R by
c:==,
FSk,
Gs(n) = [ V , ( S ) :F ] . We say R has exponential growth if G,(n) 2 t" for some t > 1 and all n E Z; otherwise, R has subexponential growth. R has polynomially bounded growth if Gs(n) 5 cn' for suitable c, t in N, for all n in N. Examples 6.2.11:
(i) If R is the free algebra F { S } where S = {XI,..., X,} then CJn) EL=,mk so R has exponential growth. (ii) If R = F[A,, . . .,A,] elements in {Al,...,&}",
then as noted in remark 6.2.8 we have
(" ;
and thus GJn) = xi=,
+
- 1) =
=
(" ;n j
121
$6.2 Affine Algebras
(since
(“ ”) (“ =
,”
i- -
*)+ (“ l: ’)
and apply induction to
sequently G,(n) has polynomially bounded growth. Note for m 2 1 and n > 4 that GJm) Inm. (iii) The Weyl algebra A,(F) “grows” at the same rate as F [ A , , . . .,A,,],so Gs(n) I 2n”. It would be rather embarrassing if the type of growth changed according to the generating set, so we need the following fact.
Remark 6.2.12: If R = F { S } = F { S ’ } for S’ finite then S’ E S”‘ for some n‘. (Each element of S’ lies in suitable c r ( S ) so take the maximal such n’.) Consequently G,.(n’n) 2 Gs(n)for all n, thereby implying exponential, subexponential, and polynomially bounded growth are each well-defined. This remark leads us to the following definition.
Definition 6.2.13: Suppose R, R’ are affine F-algebras where R = F { S } and R‘ = F { S ’ } . R‘ grows ur leust as fast as R, written G ( R )IG(R‘),if there are positive integers n , , n , for which Gs(n)I n,G,.(n,n) for all n in N.We say R and R‘ have the same growth if G(R‘)IG ( R )and G(R’) I G(R). In view of remark 6.2.12 this definition is independent of the choice of generating sets S and S’. Thus we have the following observations.
Remark 6.2.14: (i) If R is a homomorphic image of R‘ then G ( R ) I G(R’). In particular, if R = F { r l , .. ., r m } then G ( R )5 G ( F { X , ,. . .,X,,,}). (ii) If R is an affine subalgebra of R’ then G ( R )IG(R’). (Indeed, if S , S ’ are generating sets of R, R‘, respectively, then replace S‘ by S u S‘ and the assertion is obvious.) (iii) If R = F { S J and R’ = F { S ’ ) then R O F R ‘has generating set S” = (SO I)u(l 0 S’), so Vn(S)0 VJS’) E V2,,(S”) E V2,,(S)0 V2,,(S’). In particular, if [ R ’ : F ] < co then R O F R ’ and R have the same growth. As a special case R and M,(R) z R OFM,,(F)have the same growth. (iv) If R E R‘ and R‘ is f.g. as R-module then R‘ and R have the same growth, by (iii) and the regular representation of R‘ as an F-subalgebra of Mm.
122
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
(v) The Noether normalization theorem shows if C is F-affine commutative of transcendence degree t then C has the same growth as F [ I , , . . .,A,]. (vi) Viewing the { V,(S):n E N) as a fiItration of R, we see by comparing dimensions that R has the same growth as the associated graded algebra. There are domains having subexponential but not polynomially bounded growth, cf., exercise 8.3.14. Having various examples at our disposal, let us now show that subexponential growth has important structural implications.
Proposition 6.2.15: (Jategaonkar) Suppose R is a domain not necessarily with 1, and R does not contain a copy of the free algebra F { X , , X , } without 1. (In particular, this latter hypothesis holds when R has subexponential growth). Then R is left and right Ore. Proofi Given 0 # r1,r2 in R take f E F { X , , X , } of minimal total degree such that f(r,,r,) = 0. Writing f = f,(X,, X , ) X , + f,(X,,X,)X, we have f;(r,,r,)#O for i = 1,2 by assumption on i, so f l ( r l , r 2 ) r 1= -f2(r1,r2)r2ZO, proving Rr, n Rr, # 0. The right Ore condition is proved analogously. Q.E.D. This does not generalize to arbitrary prime algebras of subexponential growth, cf., exercise 7. However, Irving-Small [83] do have a generalization.
Corollary 6.2.16: Suppose R is an aJine prime F-algebra having subexponential growth. If R has a left ideal L for which Ann' L is a maximal right annihilator then L is uniform. Proof;. Let I = Ann' L. Then I n L 4 L as mg, and L = L/(I n L) is a domain; indeed, if a1,a2E L - (I nL ) then La, # 0 implying ( t a , ) a , # 0 (for, otherwise, Ann' La, 3 I) and so ala24 I n L. By the proposition is left and right Ore. To prove L is uniform suppose 0 # L,, L, L. Then their and in t are nonzero since L,L # 0 (forR is prime). Hence L , images and L, have a common element ii # 0, and 0 # La 5 L, n L,. Q.E.D.
z, z,
-=
z
Theorem 6.2.17: (Irving-Small) Suppose R is an aJine, semiprime F-algebra satisfying ACC on left and right annihilators. If R has subexponential growth then R is Goldie. Proofi By theorem 3.2.27 we may assume R is prime. But ACC(right annihilators) implies DCC(1eft annihilators). Let L be a minimal left annihi-
56.2 Affine Algebras
123
lator. By corollary 6.2.16 L is uniform. R is prime so Ann L = 0 and consequently there are u l , . . .,u, in L for which Ann{a, ,..., a,} = 0. The map r H ( r u l , .. .,run)gives us a monk R -+ @:= Rui c L'"' implying R has finite uniform (=Goldie) dimension. Since R has ACC(Ann) by hypothesis Q.E.D. we conclude R is Goldie. (The hypothesis ACC on left annihilators is superfluous, cf., exercise 8; however, some chain condition is needed in light of exercise 7.) Having whetted our appetites for studying subexponential growth and, in particular, polynomially bounded growth, we want a more precise measure of growth.
Gelfand-Kirillov Dimension Definition 6.2.18: The Gelfand-Kirillov dimension of an affine algebra R, written GK dim(R), is K,,4m log,(Gs(n)) = lim,,,(log G,(n)/log n). The point of this definition is that if Gs(n) I cn' then GKdim(R) I lim,,,(log,c t ) = t . Thus one sees R has finite GKdim if R has polynomially bounded growth. Similarly we have
+
-
Remark 6.2.28': lim log, Gs(n) = limlog, Gs(non), for fixed no > 0, since log, G,(n,n) = log Gs(n,n)/log n = (log Gs(non)/log n,n)((log n,n)/(log n)) and (log n,n)/log n = 1 + (log n,/log n) + 1 as n + co. Consequently if G(R) I G(R') then GK dim R I GKdim R'. When R is not affine we could still define G K dim(R) as sup(GK dim(R'): R' is an affine subalgebra of R}. A related notion (nowadays called GK tr deg) was introduced by Gelfand-Kirillov [66] to show that the Weyl algebras A,(F) and A,(F) have nonisomorphic rings of fractions for n # m and to frame the Gelfand-Kirillov conjecture (cf., g8.3). Within a decade G K dim was seen to be a general tool in ring theory. A thorough, readable treatment of GK dim is given in Krause-Lenagan [SSB], which is the basis of much of the discussion here. By example 6.2.11 we see that GK(F[A,, . . .,A,,,]) = m, and GK(A,,,(F)) = 2m. On the other hand, K-dimF[A,, . . . ,A,,,] = m by exercise 3.5.23, but K-dim A,(F) = m by exercise 3.5.25. See exercise 9 for a worse example. Remark 6.2.19: If R E R' or R is a homomorphic image of R' then GK dim(R) I G K dim(R') by remark 6.2.14(i),(ii).
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
124
Remark 6.2.20: If R’ is f.g. as module over a subring R then GK dim(R’) = GK dim(R) by remark 6.2.14(iv).This simple observation has the following consequences: (i) If C is commutative and F-affine then G K dim C = tr deg(C/F) by Noether normalization and example 6.2.1 1(ii). (ii) G K dim(M,,(R)) = GK dim(R). (iii) If R is locally finite over F then GK(R)=O. (Indeed one may assume R is affine and thus finite dimensional over F, so GK dim(R) = GK dim(F) = 0.)
As typified by these results, the GK dimension is usually difficult to compute from scratch but is very amenable because closely related rings often have the same GK dimension. Another instance is Proposition 6.2.21: I f R is a subdirect product of R,, ...,R, then GK dim R = max{GKdim(R,): 1 I i I r).
Proof: 2 is clear by remark 6.2.19, and to prove 5 we note R c Ri, so it suffices to assume R = Ri. Let Si be a generating set for Ri, with 1 E Si for each i. Then S = S , x ... x S,, is certainly a generating set for R, and V,,(S)= V,(S,);writing Gi(n) for the generating function of Si in Ri we have
,
n
n
f
GJn)
= i= 1
Gi(n) I t max{Gi(n):1 I i It ) .
Since log,, t --t 0 we see GK dim(R) = max GK dim(R,j, as desired. Q.E.D. Proposition 6.2.22:
GK dim(R[k])
=
1 + GK dim(R).
Proof: Given S = { l r r l ,..., r t ) let S’=Su{A}cR[A]; V,(S)i‘soin view of remark 6.2.18’ we see
GK dim(R[A]) 2 lim log,,(n + l)Gs(n) = 1
then V 2 , , ( S ’ ) ~
+ ihlog,,G,(n)
proving ( 2 ). To prove ( I ) note that any affine subalgebra T of R[A] is contained in R, [A] where R, is the affine subalgebra of R generated by the coefficients of the generators of T. Thus we may assume R is affine. Now taking S,S‘ as above we have V,,(S‘)c C:=, \(S)Aiso GK dirn(R[A]) I hlog&
+ l)Gs(nj = lirn log,(n + I j + lim log,, GJn) L
= 1
+ GKdim(R).
Q.E.D.
125
46.2 A%ne Algebras
Remark 6.2.22': The same proof shows that G K dim(T) 2 1 + GK dim(R) whenever there is x in T such that {xi:i E N} are R-independent.
The opposite inequality is trickier and can fail for Ore extensions; cf., theorem 8.2.16 and exercise 8.3.13. However, it holds for differential polynomial extensions which are affine, cf., exercise 10. Proposition 6.2.23: monoid S of Z ( R ) .
GK dim(S-'R)
= GK dim(R)
for
any regular sub-
Proof: Any finite subset of S-'R can be written in the form s F 1 r 1 ,... ,s- 1 r r , and thus sn{s-lrlr... , C ' r t } " C { r l , .. . , r , } " ,from which we see at once that R grows at least as fast as S--'R. Thus GK dim(S-'R) IGKdim(R), and equality follows by remark 6.2.14(ii) since R E S-'R (because S is regular). Q.E.D. On the other hand, this result does not hold for arbitrary Ore sets S, in view of Makar-Limanov's result that the division algebra of fractions of Al(F) does not have G K dim, cf., example 7.1.46. Proposition 6.2.24: Suppose aa ideal A of R contains a !efi regular element a. Then GK dim(R) 2 1 GK dim(R/A).
+
Take any finite set S of R containing 1 and a. Let V ; = A n K(S) and let Vn'be a complementary subspace of VL in V,(S).Since Vy n Ra = 0 we see Proof:
are independent subspaces all contained in V J S ) , so Gs(2n) 2 n[Vy:F ] = nGg(n) where
s is the image of S in R I A . Thus by remark 6.2.18'
GK dim(R) 2 lim log,Gs(2n) 2 lim log,(nG*(n)) =
1
+ lim logn(Gs(n))= 1 + GK dim(R/A).
Q.E.D.
Theorem 6.2.25: Suppose the prime images of R are leji Goldie. (In particular, this is true if R is PI or fi R is leff Noetherian.) Then GK dim@) 2 GK dim(R/P) + height(P)
for any P in Spec(R).
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
126
For any chain P = Po 3 P, 3 . . P,,, we need to show GK dim(R) 2 GK(R/P) + m, which would certainly be the case if G K ( R / e ) 2 GK(R/ pi - 1) + 1 for each i; but this latter assertion follows from proposition 6.2.24 is a nonzero ideal of the prime Goldie ring R / c and thus since contains a regular element. Q.E.D. Proofi
c-l/c
Note: It follows that if GK dim(R/P,) = GK dim(R/P,) for P,, P2 in Spec(R) then Pl and P2 are incomparable.
Corollary 6.2.25’: Under hypothesis of theorem 6.2.25, the little Krull dimension of R i s at most GK dim(R). Proposition 6.2.26:
GK dim(R, 0 R2) I (GK dim Rl)(GK dim R 2 ) .
Proofi We may assume R,, R, are affine. Then the inequality follows from remark 6.2.14(iii). Q.E.D.
A useful related result involves changing the base field. Remark 6.2.26’: If K is a field extension of F then GKdimR = GKdim R K (as K-algebra) for any affine F-algebra R. (Indeed, if S generates R then S @ 1 generates R O F K ,and GJn) = x k s , [ F S k : F ] = Ck5n[FSk 0 K : K ] = Gs, l(n), so appeal to the definition.)
One may wonder, “When does equality hold in proposition 6.2.26?”, i.e., when does ala2 IG K dim(R, 0 R,) when a, = G K dim R,? The hitch in proving equality in general via remark 6.2.14(iii) is that when taking a sequence n,, n,. . . such that log G,,(n,)/log n, + a,, one need not have log G,,(n)/log n, log Gs,(n,)/logn, -,ai.Of course, this occurs if also ai= !ir~ which we shall temporarily call the lower GK-dim of R,. In certain cases the GK-dim and lower GK-dim agree and are integervalued; for example, when R, is either commutative (remark 6.2.20(i)), affine PI (theorem 6.3.41), or the homomorphic image of an enveloping algebra of a finite dimensional Lie algebra (remark 8.3.37). Also see exercise 6.3.24. Indeed, it is not easy to come up with an example for which G K dim R is not an integer, but Borho-Kraft [76] showed for any real a between 2 and 3 that there is a homomorphic image of F { X , , X , } / ( X : ) which has GK dim a. In view of proposition 6.2.22 G K dim R thus can take on any real value 2 2. Warfield [84] showed equality need not hold in proposition 6.2.26, and
127
56.2 Affine Algebras
Krempa-Okninski [86] extend Warfield's example to an algebra R whose GK-dim and lower GK-dim take on arbitrary values a > a' 2 2. For GK-dim 5 2, however, the story is completely different, as we shall now see.
Low G K Dimension Remark 6.2.27:
The GK dimension of R cannot be strictly between 0 and 1; in fact, GK(R)2 1 if R is not locally finite over F. (Indeed, by remark 6.2.201iii) we may assume R is affine but not finite dimensional over F. Then K(S) # R for any n, where S is a generating set; hence K(S) c V,, l(S) for each n, implying C,(n)2 n and thus GK(R) 2 1.) Bergman showed that the G K dimension also cannot be strictly between 1 and 2. His technique shows how words affect the study of affine algebras, and so we make a slight digression to study them. Let M denote the word monoid in { 1,. . .J } , cf., example 1.2.4, and given the total order of example 1.2.18. We say w' is a subword of w if there are words u', u" (possibly blank) for which w = u'w'u";w' is initial if u' is blank; w' is terminal if u" is blank. Definition 6.2.28:
Given R = F{rl,. ..,r , ) define the monoid homomorphism M -+ R given by i M r i , and write-for the canonical image. For example, if w = 231 then W = r 2 r 3 r 1 .It is convenient to define the set W = W ( R )c M as follows: List the elements of M in ascending order w1 = 1, w2 = 2, ..., w, = t , w , , = 11, etc., and, inductively, say wk E W iff Zk$ FWj. Then @ is an F-base of R. (Indeed, obviously W spans. But also W is F-independent for, otherwise, take ajWj = 0 with ak # 0, where we FWj, contrary to took wj only from W ; then W, = - x j < k a ; l a j w j E definition of W.) In the foregoing write q ( n ) for the number of words of W ( R )having length n. Remark 6.2.29:
xj
zjsk
xi<,,,
Remark 6.2.30: If wk E W then every subword of wk is in W. (Indeed, otherFGj note wk E FW'ZjW G wise, writing wk = w'wmw where W m E
xj
=
wk.)
zjCm
We need some facts about repeated words. Lemma 6.2.31: Given a word w = i , - - . i n suppose for some n’ I n that i , . ' . ini, . . . in. = uku' where u is an initial subword of w and length(u)= m I n'.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
128
Then u = i7 for a suitable word i7 whose length divides both m and n, where
t = m/length(iT).
+
Note ij = i j + , for all j . Taking k minimal for which j km > n we see - ij+km-n;but the greatest common divisor d of m and n can be written in the form k,m + k2n and working back and forth we see ij = ij+a for all j . Letting i7 = i, . . . id we have u = 5‘ where t = m/d. Q.E.D. Proof:
., .
2 . = [, .+ k m
Lemma 6.2.32: Assume there is no in N fur which cp(no)5 no. Then ~ ( nI )ni for all n > no. Proof: Claim. Any w in W ( R )of length 2 2n0 has the form w’u~u’w’’where length(u) Ino, w‘ and w” have length Ino - length(u), and u’ is an initial subword of u. Before proving the claim let us show how it implies the lemma. Note any word in W ( R )of length I 2n0 is determined by its initial and terminal subwords of length no, each of which is in W ( R )by remark 6.2.30 and thus has I no possibilities, implying q ( n ) I n; for n I 2n0. Thus we may assume n 2 2n0. We shall now show any word w of length n is determined by its initial subword y of length 2n0 and its terminal subword 3 y’ of length no; thereby implying q ( n ) 5 .ino = no. For n I 3n0 this is obvious, so assume n 2 3n0. By the claim write w = w’ul‘u’w“. We see y has a terminal subword of the form uku‘ where length(uku’)= 2n0 - length(w’) 2 no length(u), and u‘ is an initial subword of u; we choose this terminal subword of y such that first u and then u‘ have minimal possible length. Now u is uniquely determined by y, and we “fill in” the missing entries of w by repeating u. (This procedure determines w uniquely in view of lemma 6.2.31.)
+
Proof of Claim. We shall actually prove the additional conclusion that k 2 2 and length(uku’)2 no length(u).
+
Case I. n = 2n0. Note w has no + 1 subwords of length no, so two must be equal, i.e., w = w‘uu‘ulw‘‘where uu‘ = u‘ul has length no. Thus w = w’u2u‘w“ and length(w’) + length(w“) = 2n0 - length(u2u‘)= no - length(u), so we are done. Case 11. n > 2n0. Write w = ulu where u1 has length 1. By induction u = U’U~U’U’’ where k 2 2, and letting m = length(u), we know u’ and u” have length 2 no - m and length(uku’)2 no + rn. Now w = uIu’uku’u” so we are done unless length(u,u’) > no - m, i.e., length(u’) = no - m. Applying case I
$6.2 Afine Algebras
129
to the initial subword of u of length 2n0 yields = q’pk.p”q“
+
where length(q’) Ino - length(p), length(pk‘p”)2 no length(p), and p“ is an initial subword of p. Note we have copies of u appearing in w, starting in positions no - m + 2 and no + 2, and one of these two appears as a noninitial subword of pk’p”. On the other hand, letting rn‘ = length( p ) we see pk’p” starts no earlier than position 2 and extends through position no m‘ 1. Thus there are rn‘ positions of pk’p” which occur in the subsequent copy of u, and lemma 6.2.31 implies that p can be written in the form (p )j where length( p) 1 rn. Hence the last digit appearing in u is clearly the last digit of u’. Writing ulu’ as iii and u = i7i for suitable i, we see
+ +
w
= uIu1uku‘u‘’ = Pi(V‘i)‘u’u” = ii(i~k(iu‘)u’’.
Now length@) = no - rn and length(ii7) = m, and iu’ is an initial subword of ii7, so we are done. Q.E.D.
Theorem 6.2.33: integer.
(Bergman) If 1 I GKdim(R) I 2 then GKdim(R) is an
Proof: WemayassumeR = F { r l , . .. ,r,,} isaffine.TakingS = { r l , . . .,r,,} we have [FS“: F ] I n for some n, for, otherwise, G,(n) 2 k = n(n 1)/2 for all n, implying G K dim(R) 2 log,(n2/2) = 2, contrary to hypothesis. But [ F S “ : F ] = ~ ( n ) as , defined above, so some cp(no) Ino implying q ( n ) I ni for all n no, by the lemma. Hence
+
=-
G&) 5 Gs(n0) + (n - n 0 ) d which is linear in n, so G K dim(R) I 1.
Q.E.D.
Small-Stafford-Warfield [84] continue this analysis and show that if R is affine and GKdim(R) = 1 then R is f.g. over Z(R), and, in particular, is a PI-ring. Then Artin-Tate says Z(R) is commutative affine of GK dimension 1, so we know by remark 6.2.20(i) that Z ( R ) is integral over a subring isomorphic to F [ A ] . Recapitulation 6.2.34: Let a = GK dim(R) for R affine. a = 0 iff R is finite dimensional over F. a = 1 iff R is f.g. over a central subring isomorphic to F [ i ] . Otherwise LY 2 2, and any such a can appear.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and A
130
h Algebras
Returning to Kurosch's problem, we see that if GK dimension = 0 or 1 then Kurosch's problem has a trivial solution. Thus we are led to ask, Question 6.2.35: If R is algebraic over F and GKdim(R) < cc then is GK(R)= O?
The GK Dimension of a Module Although the GK dimension is used predominantly for algebras, it is also applicable to modules.
I:=
Definition 6.2.36: If R is affine and M = Rxi E R-Fiwzod then GKdim(M) = G,+m log,[c V,(S)xi:F], notation as in definition 6.2.10. More generally, for any module M over an F-algebra R define GK dim M = sup{GK dimension of f.g. submodules over affine subalgebras of R ) . It is not difficult to show this definition is well-defined. Clearly GK dim(R) as R-module reduces to the definition of G K dim(R) as algebra, and the GK module dimension has ridden on the shoulders of the algebraic-theoretic dimension. Its main disadvantage in general is that is not exact, i.e., one does not always have the formula GK dim M =max{GKdim(N), GKdim(M/N) for N < M, cf., exercise 13. We do have the following partial results. Remark 6.2.37: GK dim M 2 max{GK dim(N), G K dim(M/N)} for any N < M , as an immediate consequence of the definition. Furthermore, GK dim M = GK dim(M"') for any t since taking xi = (0,.. ., 1 , . . . ,0) GK dim M(') = i61 log, -
[irt
= lim(log, t
]
V,(S)xi:F
=
+ log,[K(S)x,:
lim log,(t[V,(S)x,: F ] )
F]
= GKdim M.
In particular, for any f.g. R-module M we have G K dim M I GK dim R(') = GK dim R (for suitable t). There are two instances when the GK module dimension is exact. The first is when R is Noetherian PI, cf., exercise 6.3.27, although in this case there are other dimensions and techniques readily available. The second, more significant, instance is when R is an enveloping algebra. The exactness of the GK module dimension then follows from the next result.
56.2 Affine Algebras
131
Theorem 6.2.38: Suppose R is a jiltered afine F-algebra such that the associated graded algebra i? is afine and left Noetherian. Then GK module dimension is exact f o r f . g . R-modules.
Proofi Suppose M = Rx,. We modify the associated graded module construction as follows: Let Mi = R ( i ) x , and fi = M i / M i - l , viewed naturally as module over = @R(i)/R(i - 1) by
OitN
(ri
+ R(i - l))(yj + M j -
c,
I)
= riyj
+ Mi+j-
I
for ri in R(i),yj in Mi.
(Note M ( 0 ) = 0 and Fx, s M ( 1) so we can view the x k in fi.) Suppose now K I M and N = M / K . Defining Ki = K n Mi and Ni = ( K Mi)/K for i in N we also can form R-modules R = @ K i / K i - , and fi = @ Ni/Ni ,and have an exact sequence
+
-,
o-+R
+
fi +fi+o.
Of course fi is generated by x I , . . .,x , so is Noetherian, implying I? and fi are Noetherian and thus f.g. Taking appropriate generating sets of homogeneous elements and noting [Mi: F ]
=
[ K , :F ]
+ [ N , :F ] ,
- GKdim M=lim,,,log,,[M,,:F]=lim,,,log,([K,:F]
we see +[N,:F])s max{GKdim r?, GK dim fl}. But comparing dimensions in definition 6.2.36 we see at once GK dim fi = GK dim M,and, likewise, G K dim I? IGK dim K and GK dim fi IGK dim N so we conclude GK dim M Imax { GK dim(K ) , GK dim(N)}, as desired. Q.E.D. There is a way of making this result even more explicit. Definition 6.2.39: Suppose R is an N-graded algebra over a field F, and M is a graded R-module. The Hilbert series is XiEN[Mi: F]Ai. This is also called the Poincare series, and has arisen in the GolodShafarevich example (lemma 6.2.7);for this reason Cohn calls it the Gocha. One of the goals of current research is to determine the Hilbert series of a graded algebra as a closed rational expression; for example, the Hilbert series of F{X1,..., X , } is CiENrnilli = (1 - mil)-'. See exercise 16 for another example. Hilbert proved the Hilbert series has a closed expression in case R is commutative Noetherian (cf., Jacobson [80B, p. 4421). In fact, it is enough
132
Rings with Polynomial Identities and A f i e Algebras
to have d commutative, as explained in [Krause-Lenagan 85B,Chapter 71, and this is the case for enveloping algebras, cf., g8.3. Hilbert series have also come into prominence in the study of relatively free PI-algebras, as we shall indicate in $6.4.
56.3 Affine PI-Algebras We start this section by verifying that for affine PI-algebras the general questions raised in 96.2 actually have positive solutions. In fact, using Shirshov's positive solution to Kurosch's problem we can describe the structure of prime affine PI-algebras extremely precisely, leading to many important results such as the catenarity of affine PI-algebras and the nilpotence of the Jacobson radical. Several techniques obtained thereby, most notably the use of the trace ring, are applicable for arbitrary prime PI-rings, and we shall note their impact on the Bergman-Small theorem and on localization (but without proof). Often the base ring C is required to be Noetherian and/or Jacobson; this is certainly the case when C is a field.
The Nullstellensatz There are several ways of proving the Nullstellensatz for affine PI-algebras, as we shall see; possibly the fastest method is Duflo's proof using generic flatness. In order to achieve the result when the base ring is arbitrary Jacobson we need another version of the Artin-Tate Lemma. Proposition 6.3.1: Suppose R is C-afftne and is f.g. free as Z-module with a base containing 1, for suitable Z E Z ( R ) .Then Z is afJine.
Proof: Let R = C ( r ,,..., r , } and let h , = 1,..., b, be a base of R as Z-module. As in the proof of proposition 6.2.5 write bibj = EL=,zijkb, and ru = E k z U k b kand , let C' = C [ z i j k , z u k1:Ii, j , k 5 t ; 1 5 u I n]. Then C' is affine. Moreover, C'b, is a subalgebra of R containing each ri and so equals R . It follows C' = 2, for if z c i b , = z E Z then matching coefficients Q.E.D. of 1 shows z = c; E C', as desired. Corollary 6.3.2: Suppose R is C-a@ne primitiue P i . Then C is II G-domain, i.e., there i s s # 0 in C for which C[s-'] is a field F ; furthermore, [ R : F ] < a.
Let F be the field of fractions of C . By Kaplansky's theorem R is finite dimensional over Z ( R ) , which is affine over F by proposition 6.3.1. WriteZ(R) = F[zI, ...,z l ] . Proof:
g6.3 Affine PI-Algebras
133
We claim any field of the form F [ z , , . . . ,z,] is algebraic over F. This is seen by induction on the transcendence degree over F. Suppose, on the contrary, z, is transcendental over F, and let F , be the field of fraction of F [ z , , .. .,z,taken inside Z(R). Then Z(R) = F,[z,] is a field, implying z, is algebraic over F , (for, otherwise, F,[z,] % F,[h] is not a field) and thus [Z(R):F,] < cu implying F , is affine by proposition 6.3.1. But tr deg(F,) < tr deg Z(R) so by induction F, is algebraic over F, yielding the claim. Thus [Z(R):F] < a3 so [R:F] < co. Hence F is C-affine by proposition 6.3.1. Write F = C [ s - ' c , , ..., s-'c,] for s, ci in C; then F = C[s-'] as desired. Q.E.D. Theorem 6.3.3: (Amitsur-Procesi) Suppose R is an afJine PI-algebra over a commutative Jacobson ringC. Then the generic patness hypotheses of theorem 2.12.36 are satisfied, and consequently (i) R is Jacobson. (ii) R satisJies the maximal Nullstellensatz. (iii) If P is a primitive ideal of R then C n P is a maximal ideal of C , and RIP is simple and finite dimensional over C / C n P. Proofi (Duflo[73]) Since any image of R[k] is also affine PI, we need only to show that R / P R satisfies generic flatness over C / P for every P in Spec(C); passing to P / P R over C / P we may assume C is a domain. Let M be a simple R-module; by remark 2.12.33(i)we may assume M is faithful over C. But then R/Ann, M is C-affine, so C[sK'] is a field for some s, by corollary 6.3.2. M[s-'] is free over this field, so we have verified generic flatness. Now conditions (i) and (ii) follows from theorem 2.12.36. The first part of (iii) comes from remark 2.12.33", taking P the annihilator of a suitable simple module. But then RIP is affine over the field F = C / C n P and is primitive PI so we are done by corollary 6.3.2. Q.E.D.
Another proof of theorem 6.3.3 comes from the powerful "trace ring" techniques of the latter part of this section; a far-reaching generalization of McConnell [84a] is discussed in $8.4. The weak Nullstellensatz shows Jac(R) is nil for an affine PI-algebra R over a field, so the next question is whether NiI(R) is nilpotent. The story of this question involves most of the important ideas of affine algebras. Razmyslov [74] (and later Schelter who had been unaware of Razmylov's work) proved the nilpotence of the radical for homomorphic images of prime affine PI-algebras. To obtain the maximal value from this result we need an
134
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Atline Algebras
affine version of generic matrices. Let F,{ Y,, . . ., Y,} denote the subalgebra of the algebra of generic matrices Fm{Y ) . Remark 6.3.4: Fn{ Y,, ... , Y,} is F-affine and PI, and is prime by the argument of proposition 6.1.41. If R satisfies all the identities of M,(F[A]) then R is a homomorphic image of Fn{ Y,, . .., Y,}, by proposition 6.1.42(ii). Thus Razmyslov’s theorem (once proved) yields the nilpotence of the nilradical for every affine PI-algebra which satisfies the identities of n x n matrices. Since virtually all affine PI-algebras are visibly seen to satisfy the identities of n x n matrices, this formulation is quite satisfactory; furthermore, Lewin proved the converse, that nil potence of the nilradial implies satisfaction of the identities of n x n matrices. Razymslov also showed in characteristic 0 that it is enough to assume the affine algebra satisfies a Capelli identity. Kemer showed that every affine PI-algebra of characteristic 0 indeed satisfies a Capelli identity, thereby verifying the nilpotence of the radical of arbitrary affine PI-algebras in characteristic 0. Nevertheless, the PI community was relieved when Braun proved the nilpotence of the nilradical in complete generality, in arbitrary characteristic, using a different technique. We shall discuss this subject rather leisurely, following a semihistorical trek along the main directions of inquiry concerning the affine PI-theory. Since most problems of structure become rather easy for rings embeddible in matrices (over a commutative ring), the first question one might ask is, “Which affine rings are embeddible in matrices?” This ultimately turns out to be a blind alley, but, nevertheless, is an interesting excursion.
Digression: The Embedding Question for A@ne PI- Algebras There has been considerable interest in finding “reasonable” conditions which would characterize embeddibility into matrices, i.e., R c M n ( C ) for suitable C . (One could match this with the definition preceding 6.1.26 by Mk(Hk)then R E MJC) where c = n! and C = H k . ) noting that if R c Hksn Theorem 6.1.26 showed any semiprime PI-ring is embeddible in matrices. O n the other hand, arbitrary PI-rings need not be embeddible, cf., example 3.2.48, so we are led to narrow the scope to affine PI-algebras. Even in this restricted case we shall see that there is no obvious necessary and sufficient criterion for embeddibility in matrices, but as consolation we shall find a different kind of embeddibility, due to Lewin, which is quite satisfactory. Let us start by listing criteria for embeddibility. We assume throughout that F is a field and R = F { r l , .. . ,r,} is affine PI.
n
$6.3 Affine PI-Algebras
135
Reduction procedure 6.3.5: Assume R E M,(C) for suitable commutative C. Then we may further assume either (but not both) of the following:
(i) C is an affine (commutative) F-algebra. (Indeed, F L R so C contains a subring H isomorphic to a subring of F ; replacing C by C OHF we may assume C is an F-algebra. Write each rk as a matrix (c:;’) for 1 I k 5 m. Replacing C by F[c:;’: 1 < i, j 5 n, 1 I k I rn] we may assume C is afine.) (ii) C is an Artinian F-algebra. (Indeed, by (i) we may assume C is F-affine and thus Noetherian; but then C is embeddible on an Artinian ring, by theorem 3.2.53.) Remark 6.3.6: Any R embeddible in matrices satisfies the following properties not necessarily holding in arbitrary PI-algebras: (i) R satisfies all multilinear identities of M,,(E) (since these pass to M,,(Z[A,: i E I ] )and thus to M,,(C)); (ii) Every nil subring of R is nilpotent of bounded index, by theorem 3.2.38 and reduction 6.3.5; (iii) There is some k E N which bounds the length of any chain of left (or right) annihilators (since this condition is inherited by subrings of Artinian rings, and we may assume by reduction 6.3.5(ii) that M,,(C) is Artinian). (iv) Any condition necessary for embeddibility must also be satisfied by M,(R) for all t , since M,(R) is embeddible in M,,(C). Suppose a ring R satisfies conditions (i)-(iv) of remark 6.3.6. Can R be embedded into a simple Artinian ring? One method to answer this question negatively would be to dredge out another sufficient condition not dependent on (i)-(iv); however, we could then throw this condition into the list and ask the same question again. A different approach initiated by Lewin is a counting argument. If LY = max(lFI,K,) then l F I A l , . . . ,A,,,][Io! for any m; since each ideal of F[A,, . , . ,A,,,] is f.g. there are at most o! ideals and thus at most o! homomorphic images C of F I A l , . . .,A,, ]. Summing over all m in N there are at most LY commutative affine F-algebras C , up to isomorphism. For any of these C we have IM,,(C){Ia, so there are at most a finite subsets and thus there are I a affine subalgebras of M,,(C). This proves that the number of embeddible affine F-algebras (up to isomorphism) is < a.
Proposition 6.3.7: (Lewin) Suppose { A , : i E Z} are ideals of an F-afine algebra R with ( I (> 0: = max((F(,K,).Then there are ( I (nonisomorphic RIA, which are not embeddible in mutrices.
136
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
Proof: We claim that at most a of the RIA, are isomorphic to each other; this would yield I!( isomorphism classes of n nonisomorphic RIA,, only a of which are embeddible, so throwing these away would yield the proposition. The claim follows at once from Remark 6.3.8: There are at most a algebra endomorphisms of R = F { r l , . . . ,rz}, since any algebra endomorphism is defined by sending ri H ~ f i n i t e ~ i , p.(.r. ,,r,m ) where p ranges over the monomials of F { X , , . . .,X,,,); we are choosing a finite set of c,, from F, and so there are at most a choices. By constructing R satisfying proposition 6.3.7 one easily concludes there are an uncountable number of nonembeddible affine algebras, cf., exercise 5. Furthermore, applying proposition 6.3.7 to the affine algebra R = Q { X , , X , } / ( X : , X,X,X,), Irving-Small [86] proved that there are an uncountable number of nonembeddible homomorphic images of R each satisfying all the conditions of remark 6.3.6;cf., exercise 6 for details. Lest the reader think that the subject of embeddibility is finally closed, let us consider
Question 6.3.9: Is every Noetherian affine PI-algebra embeddible in matrices? (The counting technique fails in this case, by exercise 8.) There is a positive result for f.g. modules over the center, cf., exercise 3. Nevertheless, the embeddibility theory of affine algebras into matrices has proved a disappointment except as a source of interesting counterexamples.
Lewin ’s Embedding Procedure The “correct” kind of embedding procedure turns out to be a general method of Lewin [74] which deals with the generalized triangular matrix rings of example 1.1.9. In the following discussion we assume A, B are given ideals of a C-algebra R, and M is an R I A - R / B bimodule (and, in particular, a C-module). We want to embed R into T
=
(:’*
:B).
First we consider
arbitrary homomorphisms cp: R + T and then ask when ker cp ment stems from Bergman-Dicks [75].
= 0. Our treat-
r + A 6r where 6: R + M (0 r+B is some C-module map. cp is a C-algebra homomorphism iff 6 is a derivation,
Remark 6.3.10: Define cp: R + T by cpr =
137
$6.3 Affine PI-Algebras
where F1 = r l + A and F2 = r z + B; this is seen i.e., 6(rlrz) = (6r1)F2 + by computing cp(r,rz). Now assume M is a homomorphic image of M as bimodule. Then we have a derivation R + M composing- 6 with M M,and thus we have a -+
homomorphism Cp: R
-+
T
. Clearly kercp 3 kercp, so kercp
=
is expected to be smallest possible when 6: R + M is “initial,” in the sense that any derivation from R to an RIA - RIB bimodule factors through 6. Lewin calls M the universal bimodule and 6 the universal derivation. The universal derivation can actually be described in terms of tensor products. Let K G R OCR be the kernel of the canonical map R OCR + R defined by multiplication in R , and M Let 6: R
-+
=
RIA @ R K
RIB.
@R
M be given by
It is enough for us to have this M in our hands, although one can readily check 6 is indeed the universal derivation, cf., exercise 10. The neatest way to describe kercp is by means of Tor: of homology (denoted below as Tor,); in fact, Tor, is a natural and useful tool in connection with tensor products, and we need hardly more than its definition.
Theorem 6.3.1 1: Let K , M , 6 be as in (l), and let cp: R
-+
(n”,
;B) be as in remark 6.3.10. Then A B E ker cp G A n B, and ker cp = A B if C is a ,field.
Proof: Obviously A B c ker cp G A n B, so it remains to prove ker cp = AB when C is a field. Note ker6 2 A B since S(ab) = a66 (6a)b = 0 0 = 0, so 6 induces a derivation 6: R / A B - + M . We aim to show ( ( A n B ) / A B ) n ker = 0 for then ker cp = A n B n ker 6 = AB. First we use the canonical epic R Or R R to build the exact sequence of bimodules
+
+
s
-+
O + K -$
R
-+
(2)
R -0.
R is projective as right R-module so (2) is split in &ud-R; tensoring by RIB yields the exact sequence. 0
-+
K ORRIB A R Q c R / B
+ R / B -+O
and this can also be viewed naturally in R-&,d.
(3)
Note i’ is given by
Rings with Polynomial Identities and A f w Algebras
138
(rl 0r z ) 0T H r , 0F2 where - denotes the canonical image in RIB. Applying Tor(R/A,-) yields
Tor,(RIA, R OCRIB) + Tor,(R/A,RIB) 1:M
+
RIA QcRIB
(4)
+ R I A @ , RIB + O
Note Tor,(R/A,RIB) = ( A n B)/AB by example 5.2.38(ii). On the other hand, applying Tor(-, R OcRIB) to the exact sequence 0 - A + R - + R/A+O
yields (cf., proposition 5.2.36) 0 + Tor,(R/A,R OCRIB) -+ A OCRIB + RIA
+R
o c RIB
Oc RIB + 0.
(5)
Since C is a field we see A OCRIB + R &RIB is monic so Tor,(R/A, R OcRIB) = 0. Making these two substitutions in (4)yields
(6)
O-,(A~B)IAB%M+RIA@,RIB+RIAQ,R/B+O.
In fact, h: ( A n B)IAB + M is given by h(x + AB) = 1 Q (x 0 1 - 1 0 x) 0 1. This can be seen computationally or by the following easy homological argument: Defining f:B+K @ RIB by f b = ( b Q 1 - 1 Q b) 0 7 and 9: R+R Qc RIB by gr = r 0 i,we have the commutative diagram 0-B
o
*R-RIB-
0
- I] - - K
o,, RIB
. I
R
oCR 1B
(7)
o
R/B
where the bottom row i s (3); the diagram is commutative since ( i ' f ) b = i'((b@ 1 - 1
b)@ T) = b @ T - 1 @ b = b @ T - 0 = gb
for all b in B. Applying Tor(R/A,-) as above we have T o r , ( R / A ,R I B ) = ( A n B ) / A B -RIA c
T o r , ( R / A ,RIB) -M
h
@B =
BIAB
c
=
RIA 0K @ RIB
where the bottom row is from (4). But 1, Q f is the restriction o f 8 to BIAB
56.3 Affine P1-Algebras
139
by (l'), so we have factored the monic h as -
( A nB)IAB4 BIAB 4 M .
This proves the restriction of 8 to ( A n B ) / A B is monic, as desired.
Q.E.D.
Digression 6.3.12: The only place in theorem 6.3.1 1 we used that C was a field was in showing T o r , ( R / A ,R OcRIB) = 0. Thus one can generalize theorem 6.3.1 1, cf., exercise 11. As usual, Bergman-Dick's paper delves even deeper into the result and its ramifications.
Corollary 6.3.13: Suppose R is an algebra over a field and A , B d R with A B = 0. Then there is an R - R himodule M and an injection RIA M (0 RIB). Proofi
Immediate from theorem 6.3.11.
Q.E.D.
In order to obtain full mileage from this result we shall now take R to be the free algebra F { X } .
Theorem 6.3.14: Suppose A , B 4 F { X } , F a field, such that F { X } / A and F { X } / B are embeddible, respectively, in m x m and n x n matrices. Then F { X } / A B is embeddible in (m + n) x (m n) matrices.
+
Proof;. Taking R
=F{X)=
F{X,:k
E
I ) we have an embedding
as in corollary 6.3.13. We want to embed this further into matrices. Let M be the free RIA - R / B bimodule fie., free (RIA) 0 (R/BPP-module) with base which we denote as { & : k E I } . There is a derivation 8:R M given by 6X = 2;thus we could replace M by M.But now M is flat as RIA - RIB bimodule. View RIA s M,(C,) and RIB E M,(C,). Letting C = C , OFC, we can embed RIA in M,(C) and RIB in MJC), so letting N=Mm(C)OR,,.,M@,,,M,(C) we see R / A h? (0 R/S)
(?(')
:,,(C,>.
(8)
Rings with Polynomial Identities and AfGrw Algebras
140
Let A be a set of commuting indeterminates {At! m < i Im + n, n <j Im + n, k E I } . Writing M,,,,,(C[A])for the set of m x n matrices with entries in the polynomial ring C[A], viewed naturally as M,,(C) - M,,(C) bimodule we let N' be the submodule generated by the "generic" elements X i = {(A$)): m < i I m n, n < j I m n}. N ' is readily seen to be free as M,,,(C) - M,,(C) bimodule since any dependence relation translates to linear equations in the I$', which can only have a trivial solution. On the other hand, there is a homomorphism
+
given by X ,
+
:(
+ AB +
-!- A
;:
+
B), and whose kernel is 0 in view of (8)
since N ' is free. The right hand side of (9) is visibly in M,,,+,,(C[A]),so R/AB is embeddible in M,,,+,,(C[A]). Q.E.D.
Corollary 6.3.15: If F { X } / A is embeddible in n x n matrices then F ( X } / A ' is embeddible in nt x nt matrices for all t in N. The reader should note this result cannot be generalized to arbitrary affine PI-rings; any nonembeddible affine PI-algebra would be a counterexample, since we shall prove the nilpotence of its nilradical. Although involving neither affine nor PI explicitly, the corollary has the following immediate application:
Theorem 6.3.16: Suppose R is a PI algebra over a field F. If NiI(R) is nilpotent then R satisfies the identities of k x k matrices for some k. Explicitly if R/NiI(R) has PI degree n and Nil(R)' = 0 then R is a homomorphic image of an algebra embeddible into nt x nt matrices, and R satisjes all the identities of M,,,(F[A]). Proofi Let A = {identities of R/Nil(R)}. Take a surjection cp: F { X } -+ R, and let II/: F { X } -,R/Nil(R) be the composite of cp with R + R/NiI(R). Then cpA E NiI(R) so cpA' = 0, yielding a surjection F { X } / A ' 4 R. On the other hand, by proposition 6.1.42 F ( X } / A is the algebra of generic n x n matrices and thus embeddible in M,,(F[h]), so F { X } / A ' is embeddible in nt x nt matrices and thus satisfies all its identities; therefore, R also satifies these identities. Q.E.D. Corollary 6.3.17: If we can prove the radical of an afine PI-algebra R over a field is nilpotent then R satisfies the identities of n x n matrices for suitable n.
86.3 Affine PI-Algebras
141
Shirshov’s Theorem Having established an interesting converse to our question of nilpotence of the radical, we return to our casual pursuit of the original question (or better, its solution). There is a surprising connection to Kurosch’s problem, which has a positive solution for affine PI-algebras; in fact, the solutions by Kaplansky and Levitzki were the first in the long list of major theorems in PI theory. There is a fast structural solution, cf., exercise 12, but we shall use a solution of Shirshov [57] based on combinatoric techniques on words which only requires the algebraicity of a finite (albeit huge) number of elements; this becomes very important in the applications. We start with definition 6.2.28 and its total order on words; the idea is to use remark 6.2.29 to pass from words to monomials in the generators r l , . . . ,rl. Definition 6.3.18: A word w is m-decomposable with m-decomposition w = w 1. . * w, for suitable words w,, . . . ,w, if w,, . ..w,, < w for each a # 1 in Sym(m). The m-decomposition will enable us to utilize a polynomial identity f ( X , , . . . ,X,) to provide an inductive procedure based on the order of words. Remark 6.3.19: If w = w1w‘ and w’ has an (m - 1)-decomposition w 2 ... w, where wj < w , for each j 2 2 then w , w2 ... w, is an m-decomposition of w.
Now for our main tool.
Lemma 6.3.20: There is a function P: N(3)+ N such that for every k 2 P(t, u, m), every word of length k and height t has either (i) an m-decomposable subword or (ii)a subword of the form w; for suitable w o . Proof: Induction on m and r. Every word is 1-decomposable so take P(t,u, 1) = 1; on the other hand, we can take B(l,u,m) = u since lk is the only word of height 1 and length k. Fixing u,m and t , suppose we have found fl(t’,u,m - 1) for all t’ in N, and also P(t - l,u,m). Putting t‘ = U f b ( t - 1, u. 4 define
We shall show any word w of height t not satisfying (i) or (ii) has length I P(t, u, m). Write w as 1(p(l)vl 1‘p(z)v2...1 p ( j ) v jwhere each p(i)E N,p ( i ) > 0 for i 2 2, and 1 does not occur in any vi. For example, i f w = 541 12314 then q(1) = 0,
Rings with Potynornial Identities and Aane Algebras
142
u1 = 54, ( ~ ( 2= ) 2, u2 = 23, ( ~ ( 3= ) 1, and uj the following two properties:
= 4.We are done unless w satisfies
length(ui) < /?(t - 1, u, m) for each i q(i)< u for each i In general, there are t S ( r - l * u * mways ) of building a word u of length I &t - l,u,m) in the “letters” 2, ... , t , since in each position we could put 2,. ,,,t or nothing at all. Thus there are t‘ possibilities for a word ij = 1... 1u where 1 occurs at most u times at the beginning. We order these t ’ words lexicographically and name them GI, ij2,. . .,V;. . Thus each l’p(i)ui= ij$(i, where 1 5 $ ( i ) It’. Consider the word 6 = 1/42). . . $(j),and suppose j 2 /.?(t’, u, m - 1) 1. By the induction on m, 6 satisfies either (i) or (ii), as a word of length j - 1 and height t’. But (ii) says 6 has a subword 6;which, when translated back to w
+
by means of 5, gives a subword w; of w, so we would be done. Thus we may assume 6 has an (m - 1)-decomposable subword $ ( i ) . . . $(i’) for suitable 2 Ii < i’ Ij, i.e., the word l’p(i)ui ... lQ(i’)ui.has an (m - 1)-decomposition w 2 - - - w ,where w 2 , ..., w,each starts with I. But z ) i - I does not start with 1 so is greater than each of w 2 ,..., w,; hence by remark 6.3.19 is an (m- 1)-decomposition of ui- 1‘ p ( i ) u i.. . 1‘ p ( ” ) u i , . Thus we are done unless j IP(t’,u,m - 1). But each ui was assumed to have length < P(t - 1, u, m), implying
k < ( B ( t - 1,u,m) + u - l)/?(t’,u,m - 1) = /?(t,u,m).
Q.E.D.
We can improve this further.
Lemma 6.3.21: If w has length 2 rn and w is not of the form ijk for any k > 1 then w 2 , has a terminal m-decomposable subword. Proof;. Writing w = i , . . . i , w ’ for suitable w‘ define uj = i j + l . - . i n w ‘ i l . . . i j for 1 Ij < m, and u, = w. We claim u l , . .. ,v, are distinct. Indeed, if uj = uj. for j < j’then putting u = j ‘ - j we have w = u, = i u + l . ~ . i , , , w ‘.-.i, i l and so i, + ...i , is an initial subword of w; cancelling i, + .* * i , repeatedly and applying lemma 6.2.31 we get i,+ *..i,,, = 6‘ for some 6 of length dividing m, implying w = Gk for some k, contrary to hypothesis. Thus the claim is established, so for some n in Sym(m) we have unl > uZ2 > ... > unm. Each uj is obviously a subword of w2.Writing w 2 = w;ujw~
$6.3 A f b e PI-Algebras
143
we have the m-decomposition
of a terminal subword of w, as desired.
Q.E.D.
Proposition 6.3.22: (Shirshov) There is a function p: NC3) + N such that for all u 2 2m and all k L Pft, u, m), every word of length k and heighr m has either (i) a subword of the form u" with length (u) < m or (ii) a d-decomposable subword. Proof: Assume (ii) fails. By lemma 6.3.20 w contains a subword w i ; taking wo of minimal possible length n we have n < m for, otherwise, wo = vk by lemma 6.3.21, so w; = uk" with length(v) < n, contradiction. But this is (i). Q.E.D.
Theorem 6.3.23: (Levitzki-Kaplansky-Shirshou) Suppose R = C { r l , . . .,r,> satisjes a multilinear polynomial identity f ( X , ,...,Xm),and each monomial in the ri of length < m is integral over C. Then R is f.g. as C-module, spanned by the monomials in the x i of length I B(t,u,m) where u = max{2m, degree of integrality of each monomial in the ri of length I m}. Proof: Let E = {monomials in the ri of length I p(t,u,m)}.We shall prove the theorem by showing in the notation of remark 6.2.29 that each W k is spanned by B. We shall prove this by induction on k. We are done by hypothesis unless length ( w k )> p(t, u, m), since otherwise k k E B. Thus (i) or (ii) of proposition 6.3.22 holds. If (i) holds then wk has a subword v". By induction hypothesis V" = -1-i ciUi. Writing wk = W ' U " ~ 'we ' have W, = ciw u w ; but each w'vi"' < wksince the length is smaller, so by induction each W'0"iC"is spanned by B, so W kis spanned by E . If (ii) holds then wk = w'uw" where v = u1 . . . u, is an m-decomposition of u. We may write
I;:,’
CT:,'
f
1,
= XI...& -
+
c CxXnl
xf I
-,I
..ex,,.
,
Then U = c, 5, . . . vnm so W = Ex c, W'U,, . .. 5,,,,E". But each w ' y I - . . u x m w f '< w ' v I ~ ~ ~ v , , ,= w iW' k , so by induction each W'iFr, -..V,,,,W" is spanned by B; hence W k is spanned by B. Q.E.D.
Rings with PoIynomial Identities and A
144
h Algebras
Schelter noted that the same combinatorial argument actually gives a stronger result, cf., exercise 14 and Rowen [SOB, theorem 4.2.83. Shirshov proved the following stronger result than theorem 6.3.23. Theorem 6.3.24: (Shirshou) Suppose R = C{rl,.. . ,r , } satisjies a multilinear polynomial identity f ( X I , . . ,Xm).Let wl,. .. ,w,. denote the words of length I m, and let Wkdenote the image of a word w in R, as in remark 6.2.29. There is a number k = k(m, t) such that for any word w of length 2 D(t, m, m) we have
wE
c cvi,. vi, '
'
where each ij E { 1,. . . ,m'}, ui denotes a power of wi, and each word uil . . .uir is a rearrangement of the letters of w. Let k = (m')'mp(t,m,m). Proof is by induction on the order of w (cf., example 1.2.18). In particular, we may assume w does not have an m-decomposable subword since then we could use the identity f to express W in terms of lower order monomials, just as in the proof of theorem 6.3.23 case (ii). Write Proof:
where each vi denotes a power of wi and each ij E { 1,. ..,m'), such that d is minimal possible, temporarily we call d the breadth of w. We are done unless w has breadth > k, so, in particular, length(w) > k. Claim. Any subword u of w of breadth > P ( t , m, m) contains a subword Gm3' where 3,3' have length I rn and each of 3, 3' is nor an initial subword of the other. Proof of claim. A fortiori u cannot have an m-decomposable subword, so by proposition 6.3.22 u contains a subword G m with length(6) Im. We choose 3 such that the initial subword v'Gm has length(u') minimal possible. Write u = u'6"u'' for u 2 m,such that 3 is not an initial subword of u". We are done unless u" is an initial subword of 3,Write 6 = u"a for a suitable subword a, and note length(u") < length($) I m. Now u = u'u"(au'')".
Since length(au") = length($) m we see breadth(u'u") 2 breadth(u) - 1 2 P(t,m,m), so again proposition 6.3.22 shows u'u" has a subword r3" for suitable 6 of length < m. But then u'u" has an initial subword a ' P where length(a') I length(u') length(u") - m < length(u'); since a'Gm is also an initial subword of u we have contradicted the minimality of length(o').
+
$6.3 Aane PI-Algebras
145
Having established the claim we have a subword Gm3' where neither 3 nor 3' is initial in the other. But the number of choices for the pair ( G , 3 ' ) is 5 since k = (rn')2mB(t,m,m) we can apply the claim successively to the remaining subwords to assure that some G"G’ recurs in m distinct places. Thus w has a subword
,
- m -I G m , i y a , ~ m G ~ a 2 ...GmE!am- w w.
If 3 > G’ this has an rn-decomposable subword (GmG'alG)(Gm'%'a2E2)...(GEL'); if C < 3' we use instead the m-decomposable subword
( ~ ' ~ ~l )6( "~ -f
.
i ' ~ 2~) .p .- ( G m - 2
~
'
, G~) ( G~ m --
1~’).
In either case w has an m-decomposable subword, so as noted above, we are done. Q.E.D. This result is rather technical and was slow in being incorporated into the theory. However, it has some far-reaching consequences. The first one is due to Berele, using a different proof. Theorem 6.3.25: Any afJine PI-algebra over a jield has Jinite GelfandKirillov dimension.
Proof: (Amitsur; Drensky) Take S = { W,,. . .,W,.} of theorem 6.3.24. In calculating Gs(n) of definition 6.2.10 for n large we see V , ( S ) is spanned by the Fi, '"V;.,. One could formally replace ij by j and obtain El ... Uk,in this way creating a monomial which could be viewed in the commutative polynomial ring C [A,, . . . ,A,]. Since at most k k monomials iji1. . . Gi, correspond to U1 . . . Fk, we see by example 6.2.11(ii) that G&) I k k
(t
+
')
I kknk = (kn)k.
Hence the GK-dimension is bounded by limn+mlog,((kn)k) = lim k( 1
+ log, k) = k.
Q.E.D.
The Theory of Prime PI-Rings Many problems about an arbitrary PI-ring R can be reduced to the prime case by means of the structure theory. Furthermore, prime PI-rings occupy a position of prominence because of
146
Rings with Polynomial Identities aod Atline Algebras
Remark 6.3.26: If R satisfies the identities of n x n matrices then R is a homomorphic image of the algebra of generic matrices, which is prime (cf., proposition 6.1.41 and 6.1.42).
Thus the theory of prime PI-rings should bear heavily on the PI-theory in general. So far we have several powerful tools at our disposal. Summary 6.3.27: Z - {O). Then
Suppose R is a prime PI-ring with center 2, and S =
(i) R has some PI-degree n (theorem 6.1.28) (ii) S I R is central simple over S-’Z of degree n (theorem 6.1.30) (iii) There exists z in Z for which R , , , is a free Z,,,-module with a base of n 2 elements, and R , , , is Azumaya over Z , , , . (In fact, any z # 0 in g,,(R) will do; corollary 6.1.36.) Despite these results, Z ( R ) can still be rather poorly behaved, as we shall see when studying Noetherian PI-rings, and even localizing at a single element can be too crude a tool to work with certain delicate questions. There is one more construction which can be used in aimost every situation. Construction 6.3.28: (Schelter’s Trace Ring) Let a C-algebra R be prime of PI-degree n and Q = S ’ R where S = Z ( R ) - (0). We shall expand R to a certain subring T ( R )of Q satisfying the following properties:
(i) T ( R )= RC‘ for a suitable C-subalgebra C of Z(Q);in particular, T ( R ) is prime. (11) Rg,,(R)#O is a common ideal of R and T(R).In fact C’g,,(R)=g,(R)+. (iii) T ( R )is integral over C’. (iv) If R is C-a@ne then C‘ is C-aflne and T ( R )is f-g. over C’;in particular, when C is Noetherian C’ and T ( R )are Noetherian. To construct T ( R )we first embed R in M,(F) by splitting Q, and taking a base b , , . . .,bk of M,,(F) where k = n 2 we view R c M J F ) by the regular representation. Writing r^ for the k x k matrix corresponding to r we have the Hamilton-Cayley polynomial d e t ( l - 1 - F) = C(- 1)’ailk-’ for suitable ai, 0 5 i k, where a,,= 1. We shall call these ai the characteristic coefficients of r. Note ai are independent of the choice of the base b , , . . . ,b,. Furthermore, choosing the base b ..,bkin Q it is easy to see that each ai E Q. Let c be the C-subalgebra of Q generated by the characteristic coefficients of “enough elements of R, and let T ( R )= RC‘ c_ Q. “Enough” means “all”
$6.3 Affine PI-Algebras
147
unless R is affine, i.e., R = C { r l ,..., r r ) in which case the monomials in r l , .. . ,r1 of length IP ( t , 2n2,d ) are “enough” (where d is the degree of a PI of R ) . We now have (i) and shall prove (iii), (iv), and (ii). Any element a of T ( R )has the form Proof of (iii): aici where a, E R and c, E C‘. Hence a E C ’ { a , ,. ..,a,}. But all the monomials in the a, are in R and thus integral over C’ since C’ contains enough characteristic coefficients. Thus a is integral over C’, by theorem 6.3.23.
Proofof (iv): As in proof of (ii), since now each ai can be taken to be a monomial in r l , . . .,r r , and C‘ contains enough characteristic coefficients by construction; the last assertion follows from elementary properties of Noetherian rings. Proof of (ii): It suffices to show for any characteristic coefficient u of r and any b l , . . . ,b, in R that crg,(b,, . . . ,b,) E g,(R)+ where m is the degree of g,,. This is obvious unless z = g,(b,, . . . ,b,) # 0, in which case b,, ... ,b, is a base of M J F ) , seen by applying theorem 6.1.33 to z - l b , , . . . , b k .Thus we could use b l , ...,b, as our base in forming t. By proposition 6.1.19(iii) we have agn(bl,.. ., 6,)
E
gn(R)’, proving (ii).
Q.E.D.
This construction was called the characteristic closure in Rowen [SOB], but the misnomer trace ring has stuck since for Q-algebras all the characteristic coefficients can be obtained from the traces. Technically our ring T ( R )might be called the n2-trace ring since we took the n2-HamiltonCayley polynomial; Amitsur-Small [SO] analogously built the n-trace ring using the n-Hamilton-Cayley polynomial. One advantage of the n2-trace ring is that proposition 6.1.19 is itself a useful tool; for example, it could be used in the proof of exercise 15, due to Amitsur, which implies that if T ( R ) is defined functorially by adjoining all characteristic coefficients of elements of R then T ( T ( R ) = ) T(R). When R is a @algebra the n-trace ring and n2-trace ring are the same. A detailed proof of this fact would rely on the reduced trace (cf., definition 2.3.32 ff), but essentially boils down to the observation that if a is an n x n matrix then the trace of the n 2 x n 2 matrix ( a . . .a) is n tr(a),
and n-
E
Q.
148
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
Remark 6.3.29: T(R) is isomorphic to an R-submodule of R. (Indeed, take 0 # z E g,(R) and note T(R)z c Rg,(R) E R, so right multiplication by z embeds T(R) into R.) In order to utilize T(R) we must be able to pass prime ideals from R to T(R) and back, so the following observations are crucial: Theorem 6.3.30: Suppose a PI-ring R is integral ouer C L Z(R). Then GU, LO and INC hold from C to R.
Proofi Any C-affine subalgebra of R is f.g. by theorem 6.3.23, so satisfies G U and L O by theorem 2.12.48 and INC by theorem 3.4.13. Hence C C_ R satifies G U and LO by proposition 2.12.49. To prove INC suppose PI c Pz in Spec(R) lie over the same prime ideal of C. Passing to RIP, and C/(P,nC) we may assume PI = 0 and P2 n C = 0. In particular, Z(R) is a domain. Take an affine subalgebra Z’ of Z(R) containing some 0 # z E Pz n Z(R). Then Z‘z n C = 0 so Z’z is contained in a prime ideal of 2’ lying over 0, by remark 2.12.42. This contradicts INC for Z‘ over C. Q.E.D. Theorem 6.3.31: Suppose R is prime of PI-degree n. (i) LO(P) and GU(-, P ) hold from R to T(R), for all P in Spec,(R) and f o r all P minimal ouer a prime in Spec,(R) (i,e., for which there is Po in Spec,(R) satisfying height (PIP,) = 1 in RIP,.) (ii) The strong uersion of INC(P) holds from R to T(R) for all P in Spec,(R), in the sense that if P i , P i E Spec T(R) with P i n R G P i n R = P then P i G P i . (iii) LO, GU, and INC hold from C’ to T(R). Proof:
(i) Let A = Rg,(R) and apply proposition 2.12.45 to 6.3.28(i),(ii). (ii) By proposition 2.12.46, as in (i). (iii) Theorem 6.3.30 is appficable by 6.3.28(iii). Q.E.D.
Thus many questions about SpecfR)can be translated to T(R), which can be a suitable arena for computation even when R is not affine. One of the key computations, due to Braun [MI, is a Hamilton-Cayley type expression for T ( R )which passes to certain homomorphic images; Braun uses this in a short proof of
56.3 Affine PI-Algebras
149
Theorem (Bergman-Small): Suppose R is prime of PI-degree n, and P E Spec(R). lf m = PI-degree(R/P) then n - m is a sum of PI-degrees (with possible repetitions) of simple homomorphic images of R.
I
In particular, if R is local and P is the unique maximal ideal then m n. The reduction to T(R) is easy, and is given in exercise 17. We shall use T(R) here to polish off much of the theory of affine PI-algebras and then discuss its use for Noetherian rings. Let us start by reproving the weak Nullstellensatz. Remark 6.3.32: If r E R is regular and is algebraic over a central subringZ then Z n Rr # 0. (Indeed, take = ziri = 0 with z, # 0, t minimal such, and let r' = ziri - 1 # 0 by minimality of t. Then 0 # -r'r = zo E Z n Rr, as desired.)
I:=,
c:
Application 6.3.33: Easy proof of the weak Nullstellensatz for affine PI-algebras over Jacobson C : It is enough to assume R is prime and to prove Jac(R) = 0. Using construction 6.3.28(iv) we see C' is Jacobson, by the commutative Nullstellensatz, so Jac(C') = 0. By proposition 2.5.33 we have O= C'nJac(T(R)); but Z(R) is integral over C' and so Z(R)nJac(T(R))= 0 by remark 6.3.32 (since all of its elements are central and thus regular). Hence Jac(T(R)) = 0 by theorem 6.1.28. Now g,(R)Jac(R) G Jac(R) so is quasi-invertible and is an ideal of T(R) by 6.3.28(ii), implying g,(R)Jac(R) = 0. Since R is prime we conclude Q.E.D. Jac(R) = 0.
Theorem 6.3.34: (Schelter) If R is a@ne PI over a Noetherian ring C then R satisfies ACC( prime ideals)
Proofi Take a chain PI c Pz c ..., and take m for which PI-deg(R/Pm)is minimal. Replacing R by RIP, and replacing the original chain by the chain Pm+l/Pmc Pm+2/Pm c ... we may assume R is prime of some PI-degree n, and each E SpecJR). But by theorem 6.3.31(i) T(R) has an infinite ascending chain of prime ideals, contrary to T ( R ) being Noetherian by 6.3.28(iv). Q.E.D. Of course when C is a field the previous result follows from theorems 6.2.25 and 6.3.25. We shall obtain a stronger result in corollary 6.3.36', to follow.
150
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
Nilpotence of the Jacobson Radical Theorem 6.3.35: (Razmyslov) Suppose R is ajjine over a Noetherian Jacobson domain C . (In particular, one could take C to be a field.) If R satisfies all the identities of M , , ( C [ A ] )where A is an infinite set of commuting indeterminates then Jac(R) is nilpotent. Proof.- Since R is a homomorphic image of an affine algebra of generic matrices, which is prime by remark 6.3.4, this follows at once from the weak Nullstellensatz and the following result:
Theorem 6.3.36: (Schelter) Suppose R is prime PI and a@ne over a Noetherian ring C . If A Q R then Nil(R/A) is a finite intersection of prime ideals of RIA and is nilpotent in RIA. Proof.- In view of theorem 6.3.34 we may apply Noetherian induction to the prime images of R and thereby assume the theorem is true in RIP for every 0 # P E Spec(R). Pass to T(R), which is Noetherian by 6.3.28(iv). Let n = PI deg(R). Then g,(R)A Q T(R) by 6.3.28(ii), so there are a finite number of prime ideals Q I ,. . . , Q t of T(R) minimal over g,(R)A. Since Q,)/q,(R)A = Nil(T(R)/g,(R)A) is nilpotent, we have Q i ) k c_ g,,(R)A for some k. Let pi = Q i n R # 0. Then R I ( 4 + A ) is an image of Rlpi so there are a each containing pi + A, for which finite set of prime ideals 41,...,c,,, pijv’5 4 + A; technically m and k‘ depend on 4 but there are only a finite number of the pi, so we can take m and k’ to be the same for all i. Now
(n
(n
(n
implying at once Nil(R/A) =
(n:=,ny= q j ) / Aand is nilpotent.
Q.E.D.
Corollary 6.3.36’: Any semiprime PI-algebra a@ne over a Noetherian ring C has a finite number of minimal prime ideals and satisfies ACC(semiprime ideals). Proof.- This is shown directly in Rowen [80B, $4.53, but our proof here is based on a reduction to theorem 6.3.34. By exercise 3.5.34, it is enough to prove 0 is a finite intersection of prime ideals (for by passing to homomorphic images we may then assume any semiprime ideal is a finite intersection of prime ideals.) Since C has only finitely many minimal primes PI,.. .,P, we may pass to C/pi and assume C is prime. But by corollary 6.1.47 R is now a
$6.3 Affine PI-Algebras
151
homomorphic image of the generic matrix algebra, which is a prime ring, so Schelter's theorem applies. Q.E.D. We now aim for the nilpotence of the radical in general. Lemma 6.3.37: (Latysheu) Suppose R = C{rl,. . . ,rf} is PI. If N 4R is nil and f.g. as two-sided ideal, then N is nilpotent.
c:=
Proof: Writing N = RaiR, we incorporate {a,, . . . ,a,) into the generating set ( r l , . . . , r t ) for R. We shall appeal to theorem 6.3.24, with its notation. Let n be the largest index of nilpotency of {monomials in r l , . . . ,rf of length I m which contains some ai}. (Certainly these are all elements of N and are thus nilpotent.) Let n' = max(P(t,m,m), kmn + 1) where k = k(m, t ) was obtained in theorem 6.3.24. We shall prove N"' = 0 by showing any monomial W in N"' is in fact 0. By theorem 6.3.24 we may assume iV = Vi, . . . Vi,,and n' elements of N appear in Ui, ... Vi,. But n' > kmn so one of these Vicontains > mn elements of N . On the other hand, theorem 6.3.24 also says ui = w; for some u and u 2 n since length wi I rn. Hence V = W; = 0. Q.E.D. Latyshev's result already shows that NiI(R) is the sum of nilpotent ideals of R since NiI(R) = xaPNil(R)RaR. Remark 6.3.37':
Remark 6.3.38: Suppose R is affine over Noetherian C and f.g. as Z(R)module. Then R is Noetherian so Nil(R) is nilpotent. (Indeed Z ( R ) is affine over C by Artin-Tate (proposition 6.2.5) so is Noetherian by the Hilbert basis theorem; thus R is Noetherian.fl
Theorem 6.3.39: (Braun [84]) lf C i s a commutative Noetherian ring then NiI(R) is nilpotent for any PI-algebra R = C ( r . .,rl ). Proof: Let C' be the localization of the polynomial ringC[R] at the monoid generated by all Ai - AJ for i > j . Since NiI(R) is locally nilpotent we may replace R by R 0 C' and C by C', and thereby assume each homomorphic image of C has an infinite number of distinct elements (the images of the powers of I). Let us collect some reductions which will be needed throughout. Write N = Nil(R) and Z = Z ( R ) . We reformulate the theorem as: For any A 4R and any semiprime ideal B of R such that B / A = NiI(R/A) we have Bk c_ A for suitable k (depending on A , B).
152
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
Suppose this assertion is false. Take a counterexample R for which R/N has minimal PI-degree; by corollary 6.3.36‘ there is a semiprime ideal B maximal with respect to B / A = N i l ( R / A ) and Bk $ A for all k. Passing to RIA we may assume A = 0 and B = N. Reductions: (1) (Amitsur) By the last paragraph, if B 3 N is a semiprime ideal and A 4R with B / A nil then Bk c A for some k. (2) If A is a non-nil ideal then taking B = A + N in (1) we see ( A + N)‘ G A for suitable k. (3) If z + N is central in R/N then we may assume z E Z. (Indeed, each [z,ri] E N so N, = R[r,,z]R is nilpotent by Latyshev’s lemma; we obtain the desired reduction when we replace R by RIN, .) (4) If z E Z - N then it is enough to prove the theorem for RIAnnz. (Indeed, suppose Nk(” E Annz. By reduction 2 we have Nk(2)E Rz for some k(2), so N‘(1)+k(2) G (Annz)Rz = 0.)
Case I . (Folklore). RIN is commutative. Applying reduction 3 to each of r , , . . .,rt in turn, we may assume each ri E Z(R), i.e., R is commutative, so we are done by remark 6.3.38. Case II. RIN is not prime, i.e., there are ideals A , , A 2 3 N with A , A , C _ N. Since R/N is semiprime we can take zj for j = 1, 2 such that 0 # zj + N E ( A j / N )n Z(R/N). By reduction 3 we may assume each zj€Z so by reduction 2 there are numbers k(l),k(2) such that N k ” ) s Rzj. But zlz2 E A , A 2 E N so 0 = ( Z , Z ~ ) ” ’ = zyz’; for some m, and we are done by reductions 1 and 4.
Case Ill. Thus we may assume R/N is prime of PI degree > 1. Write - for the canonical image in R = R/N. Then C _ Z(R) is an integral domain, so N n C = NiI(C) is nilpotent. Replacing R by RINiI(C)R we may assume C is an integral domain, which as noted above is infinite. Our object is to prove “enough monomials” in r l , . . . ,r, are integral over Z to permit us to apply Shirshov’s theorem (6.3.23), for then we would be done by remark 6.3.38. In the above paragraph it is important to note “enough” is finite. Thus we want a procedure of modifying R such that a given monomial in r l , . . . ,rt is integral over Z. Such a procedure for prime affine algebras was in fact the key in constructing T ( R ) ,but now R need not be prime. However R is prime, and we want to find some way to adjoin characteristic coefficients in this slightly more general setting. The hurdle is that we do not know that the map from R to its localization need be 1:1, and the kernel may contain a non-nilpotent part of N. The remainder of the proof will be to use several
c
56.3 Affine PI-Algebras
153
high-powered techniques to "create" enough characteristic coefficients to show {evaluations of the identities of M d ( C ) in R ) is nilpotent, so that we can then appeal to theorem 6.3.36 by means of the algebra of generic matrices. Our first task is to carry central localization as far as we can. Take x1,..., x, in R such that z = g,,(x, ,..., x,)$ N. By lemma 6.1.32 we have
zr =
c "2
u=
1
(-
I)U+
-
-
-
-
1g,,(Ki1,.. . , x u - l , x u +1 , . . .,X,)X,
(10)
for any r in R. Writing ziju = ( - l)u+lg,,(xixj,xl,.. . , x u -l,xu+l , . . ., x m ) we see Ziju E Z(E) so by reduction 3 we may assume z E Z and each ziju E Z. Furthermore, zxixj - c z i j u x uE N so modding out by R ( z ~ ~ x ~ - ~ z ~ ~ , x , ) R we may assume by Latyshev's lemma that
c
zxixj = c z i j u x u U
for each 1 I i, j I n 2 . Likewise, we may assume zri = x u z i u x ufor ziu in Z. Let B = { x l , . . .,x,,} and let i j be as in the proof of lemma 6.1.32. By Latyshev's lemma we also assume i ( B ) = 0 and [g,(B),x,] = 0 for each u. But R [ z - ' ] = Z[zf1]xU, so i j is an identity of R [ z - ' ] and g,, is R[z- ']-central, yielding
~~~,
c
We aim for a similar equation in R itself. To this end write g,, = h1iX1h2i where the indeterminate X, appears in neither h I i nor h Z i . Letting a, = h l i ( x l , .. ., x u - 1, x u +l , . . .,x,) and biu= hzi(xl,.. . , x u - l,xu+ . ,x,) we see g,(r,xl ,..., x U ~ l , x U + , , . . . , x m ) = ~ i a i u ~ ~ i U = I C where I ( ~ i$~:iRuOO ~ i u ) ~ R OP + End R is the canonical map. Thus ( 1 1) becomes
1-'z01 =~l-l(-l)~+laiuOl-'biu u,i
in R[z-']'
= R'Cz-']
(cf., remark 5.3.28),so there is some d such that Zd+
0 1 = C(- l ) U + i,u
1ZdUiu
0 biu
in Re, and thus, for all r in R,
zd+'r
=I(l)'+lzdaiurbiu -
i,u
= zd
1( n2
u=l
l)Uflgn(r,x l , . . . ,xu- l , x u +l , . . . ,x,)x,.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
154
Increasing d if necessary, we may also assume by corollary 5.3.30 for all r in R that zdg,(r,xl,... . ~ ~ - ~ , . q..., , +x ~, ) , E Z .
(13)
Just to clean up notation, we may assume d = 0 by passing to R/Annzd (by reduction 4, noting by (13) that [ g n ( r , x l r. ,. xu- l,xu+ I , . . . , x m ) , R ]G u+ 1 Annzd.) Thus (12) becomes zr=C::,(-l) g n ( r , x l,..., ,,...,x , ) x u , and (13) becomes g n ( r , x l , . . , x u - I r ~ u + . . , x m )E 2. Reduction 5 . Any jinite set of homogeneous identities of R may be assumed to be identities for R . (An identity is homogeneous if the total degree of each monomial is the same.) Indeed suppose f ( X l ,..., X") has degree j in each monomial. Let B = {Xi:1 Ii I n ' } ; passing to R / R f ( B ' " ' ) R via Latyshev's lemma we may assume f ( E ' " ) )= 0. But for any 1-1.. . . ,r: in R we have each zri E Z B , so
z y ( r \ , . . . ,I-:,) = f(zr\.. . . , z r i , )E Z f ( B ' " ' )= 0, i.e., f ( R )E Ann zj, which by reduction 4 we may assume is 0. One particular identity of R actually contains enough information to encode the Hamilton-Cayley theorem. Let n' = n 2 and, taking the Capelli polynomial C,,. define
..
. f ( x l , . > X 2 n ' + 1)
= =
Xn*+ IC2n,(X1,.. . > Xn,, Xn*+2 ., X2n'+1 ) 9 . .
C
n t Sym(n')
(sg n)Xn' + IXnlXn' + 2 . ' . Xnn'X2n,+1 .
Consider n'-tuples j = ( j (l), . . . ,j ( n ' ) ) where each j ( u ) E ( 0 , l ) for 1 I u 5 n’, and write ljl for the number of j ( u ) which are 1, i.e., ljl = j ( l ) + . . . + j ( n ' ) . Picking yj in R and letting y = f ( y , , . . .,y2,, + 1 ) we have
for any r in R by proposition 6.1.19, where ( - 1)"cUdenotes the appropriate "characteristic coefficient" of the matrix T corresponding to left multiplication by Fin R . But - l)ucuT'"u = 0 so we have
c(
Thus R satisfies the identity
7
=
F
u lj = u
( - 1)UX.d- y s ( X p x 1 , .. . ,Xjd""X,.,
which is homogeneous of degree 3n' + 1 .
x,.
+
,,. ..,x2n, +
1)
96.3 Affine PI-Algebras
155
Reduction 6. We may assume is an identity of R , by reduction 5. The last ingredient in the proof is based on an ideal of Razmyslov. Since we have trouble working in R , we switch to the free algebra C { X , Y ) = C I X , , . . . , X , , Y,, . . . , Y,,} in noncommuting indeterminates X,, over C, and let W = C(X,, . . . ,X,} c C ( X ,Y). We want to “create” characteristic coefficients of the elements of W. Namely, let p = {P,,~: 1 I u I n’,h E W ) be a set of indeterminates which commute with W but not with each other. (The reason the pu,hinitially are not to commute with each other is to ensure that (16) below is well-defined.) Let A be the ideal in W { p } generated by l)”pu,hhn’-u: h E W }u ( [ p U . h , p U , , h1, ]I : u, u’ I n and h, h’ E W } .Note the p are commutative modulo A. Thus (W A ) / A is integral of bounded degree I n’ over the integral domain which is the image of C { p } ,and thus by example 6.1.9 satisfies some PI of some degree m ,which we multilinearize. Let ,ii = { P,,~:1 I u I n’, h is a word in the Xiof degree I m },and let T = W { j i } / ( An W { j i } )Then . T satisfies the same PI, so by Shirshov’s theorem is f.g. over the Noetherian domain C { f i } / An C { f i } .Hence T is Noetherian by remark 6.3.38, implying Nil(T)k= 0 for some k. T/Nil(T) has some PI-degree d . Let Sbe the set of identities of Md(C).2T are all identities of T/Nil(T) by remark 6.1.47’; letting %”(W)be the set of evaluations of S in W we see 2T(W)kG A . To utilize this result we let L be the C-submodule of C { X , Y } spanned by all {f(Yl ,..., & , h , ,..., l ~ , . + ~ ) : hj E W } .L is naturally a W-module since
[xu(-
+
Xuf(Yl,.. ., K,, h i
5 . .
., hns+ 1 ) = f(Y1,. . . , &, X u h l , .. . ,h,.+ 1).
(1 5)
On the other hand, each pu.h acts on L via pUJ( Y,,
. . . , &.,h,, . . . ,h,. +
)=
x f(h””Y1,
ljl = u
. . . ,h’(”‘)Y,.,h l , . . . ,h,. +
( 1 6)
To see the right-hand side is indeed in L we must observe
=
c
1(sgn)h,h””Y,,
nESyrn(n’) I j [ = u
=
“.h,.hjf”’)Y,,.h,.+l
1f(Yl ,..., Y,.,hlhj(’) ,..., hn.hj(”‘),h,.+l)~ L
ljl = u
(The middle equality is obtained by noting that ( j ( n l ) , . . . ,j(nn’)) and
( j ( l), . . . ,j(n’))each have precisely u entries which are 1.)
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
156
By iterating (16) we extend the action to monomials in p and thus get a W{p}-module action on L . Also note ( - 1)’pU,hf ( Yl,. . ., &, h , , . . . ,h,. + ,) is the coefficient of A’”” in f ( ( A - h)Y,,. . .,(A - h ) Y , . , h , , .. ., f ~ , . + ~ ) . There are a finite number of polynomials [,u,,hrpU..h.]f for pu,h,pL,,h’E P; by reduction 5 we may assume they all are identities of R. Now let 1 be the ideal of C{X,Y ) generated by all evaluations of and all evaluations of Then (15) shows 1 1 A L ; we saw above AL 2 S ( W ) k L . these [pL,,L,p,,.,h~]f. Hence 1 2 b ( W ) k L .Specializing down to R then yields 0 2 F(R)kf(R)2 I(R)’q,(R), since gn is clearly a formal consequence of the Capelli polynomial, cf., exercise 6.1.4. But g,(R) $Z N, so by reduction 4 we may assume 2.?’(R)k = 0. On the other hand, R/%”(R) satisfies the identities of d x d matrices, so N/%”(R)is nilpotent by theorem 6.3.36. Hence N is nilpotent, as desired. Q.E.D.
7
Crucial ingredients in this proof were Shirshov’s theorem, the ArtinProcesi theorem, the properties of the Capelli polynomial which lead to the construction of the central polynomial, the Razmyslov-Schelter theorem (6.3.36), the construction of to incorporate a Hamilton-Cayley theorem into a polynomial identity, and the generic matrix algebras. It is safe to say this proof requires all the machinery of PI-theory developed here.
7
Dimension Theory of Afine PI- Algebras Although we have so far obtained a considerable amount of information about affine PI-rings, we have not yet built up a dimension theory. One obvious candidate is the GK dimension, which we have seen exists, by theorem 6.3.25. Thus we can draw on the theory of GK dimension, especially in view of the following result: Proposition 6.3.40: lf R is a prime PI-algebra (not necessarily aflne) over a jield F then GK dim R = tr degZ(R)/F (the transcendence degree).
Proofi By proposition 6.2.23 we can pass to the ring of central quotients of R, and assume R is central simple over the field Z = Z(R). But then Q.E.D. GK dim R = GK dim Z = tr deg Z / F by remark 6.2.20. When R is affine as well this is an integer by theorem 6.3.25; however, GK dim R need not be an integer for R non-semiprime affine PI. Let us bring in now the classical Krull dimension (the maximal length of a chain of primes), which is always an integer.
56.3 Affine PI-Algebras
157
Theorem 6.3.41: If R is prime affine PI over a field F then GK dim R = cl. K-dim R = t r deg Z(R)/F. Furthermore, a chain of prime ideals of maximal length can be obtained from Spec,(R) where n = PI deg R. Proof: Induction on d = GKdim R. We just saw d = trdegZ(R)/F, and d 2 cl. K-dimR by theorem 6.2.25. It remains to show that there is a chain 0 c Pl c ... c Pd in Spec,(R). If d = 0 then there is nothing to prove, so assume d I 1 . We claim gn(R)contains an element z1 transcendental over F. Indeed, this is clear unless each r in g,(R) is algebraic over F ; but then F n ( r ) # 0 by remark 6.3.32 so r invertible and thus 1 E gn(R),so g,(R)+ = Z(R) and the claim follows at once. Expand z1 to a transcendence base zlr...,zd of Z(R) over F, and let S = { p ( z ,,..., z d - ’ ) : O # p E F [ A , ,..., Then S-’R is affine over the ringS-’F. If S - ’ R were simple then by corollary 6.3.2 S-’R would be algebraic over S-’F, contrary to d 2 1. Thus S-’R has a nonzero maximal ideal S-’P, where P E Spec(R) with P n S = 0. In particular, P E Spec,(R). Let R = RIP, which contains the algebraically independent elements Tl,. .. ,ZdThus
‘.
d - 1 5
t r deg Z(R)
F
=GKdirnR
by induction and prosition 6.2.24. Hence equality holds, and by induction there is a chain 0 c PI c ... c in Spec,(R). This lifts to a chain 0 c P c Pl c . . c Pd- in SpecJR), of length d as desired. Q.E.D.
c-
Corollary 6.3.42: ( R prime arFJine P I ) cl K-dim R T ( R )i s as in 6.3.28(iv).
= cl K-dim
T(R) where
Proofi Chains from Spec, lift, by theorem 6.3.31(i), and these determine Q.E.D. cl K-dim, by the theorem.
Let us apply these results to obtain a lovely theorem of Schelter. Theorem 6.3.43: (Schelter) Catenarity of afine PI-algebras. If R is affine PI over a field F, and P E Spec(R) then cl. K-dim R
(3
= cl. K-dim -
+ height P,
i.e., P can be put into a chain of primes of maximal lengrh
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
158
Proof: Note 2 is clear, so we only need to prove I. Let d = cl. K-dim R, and h = height(P). If P contains a nonzero prime ideal PI then by induction on d applied to R = R/Pl we would have
cl. K-dim R
-
height p = cl. K-dim
R
and by induction on h we would have cl. K-dim R = cl. K-dim R
R
Icl. K-dim -
P
+ height PI + height P
as desired. Thus we may assume P is minimal prime, i.e., h = 1, and we want to prove d 5 cl. K-dim RIP + 1. Now either P is in Spec,(R) where n = PI degree(R), or P is minimal over g,(R); thus there is P’ in T(R) lying over P, by theorem 6.3.31(i). Take P‘ maximal such. Then every nonzero ideal of T(R)/P’ intersects RIP nontrivially. We claim cl. K-dim T(R)/P’ = cl. K-dim RIP. Indeed letting R’ = T ( R ) / P ’ and S = Z(R/P) - (01, we see any nonzero ideal of R’ intersects S nontrivially, so S-‘R‘ is simple and by construction is affine over the field F‘ = S- Z(R/P). Hence S I R ’ is algebraic over F’ by corollary 6.3.2, so tr degZ(R’)/F = tr deg Z ( R / P ) / F and hence cl. K-dim R‘ = cl. K-dim R I P by theorem 6.3.41, as desired. In view of the claim we need to show d I cl. K-dim T(R)/P’ 1. Note T(R) is integral over C’ which is affine over F. Let A , = P ’ n C’ and A , = A , ng,(T(R))+, nonzero ideals of C‘ since Z(T(R))is integral over C‘. By the Noether-Bourbaki normalization theorem quoted at the beginning of 56.2, we have a transcendence base cl,, . . ,cd of C’ over F and n( l), n(2) in N, such that taking C , = F[c,, ...,cd] we have A in C, = Cocy for i = 1,2, and C’ is integral over C , . T(R) is integral over C , , which is “normal” in the terminology of commutative algebra, so one can modify the standard commutative proof to obtain Cot, we a version of “going down,” cf., exercise 18. Hence taking A , = have some Pb # 0 in Spec(T(R)) lying over A , with Pb c P’. Moreover,
+
x:L’l ~~~~
$6.3 Affine PI-Algebras
159
Pb E Spec,(T(R)) since c1 $ P b , and using theorem 6.3.30 we have cl. K-dim- T ( R ) = cl. K-dim Pb = cl. K-dim-
c* + 1 = cl. K-dim-T ( R )+ 1. P'
C , nP
Thus it remains to show d I cl. K-dim T ( R ) / P b . But R n Pb is a prime ideal of SpecJR) contained in P ; applying theorem 6.3.31fii) (strong INC) to R n Pb we see R n Pb c P, so R n Pb = 0 implying Pb = 0. Hence cl. K-dim T(R)/P',= cl. K-dim T ( R )= d by theorem 6.3.40, as desired. Q.E.D. Having seen that the affine PI-theory is so close to the commutative theory, one might wonder whether a meaningful algebraic geometry can be developed for affine PI-algebras. This has been accomplished to some extent in a major series of papers of Artin-Schelter. Digression 6.3.44: Gabriel dimension. Suppose R is prime PI of Krull dimension a. Then K-dim T ( R )i o! by remark 6.3.29, and for R affine we thus have K-dim T ( R )= K-dim C' = cl. K-dim C' = tr deg C ' / F = tr deg Z ( R ) / F= GK dim R . Thus one might expect the noncommutative Krull dimension to be a useful tool for studying affine PI-algebras. Unfortunately it may fail to exist! Indeed we saw in exercise 3.5.29 that an affine PI-algebra satisfying the identities of 2 x 2 matrices may lack K-dim, and thus the affine algebra of generic 2 x 2 matrices is prime PI but lacks K-dim. When R is affine PI and has K-dim then applying exercise 3.5.33 to the proof of proposition 3.5.51 one has K-dim R =cl. K-dim R = cl. K-dim T ( R )= cl. K-dim C' = G K dim R as above, so we have the peculiar situation that K-dim may fail to exist, but equals GK dim when it does exist. Of course this motivates us to consider the Gabriel dimension, which we recall is very close to K-dim except that it exists more often. Gordon-Small [84] proved every affine PI-algebra over a field has Gabriel dimension, by reducing to the prime case and using the theory of left-bounded Goldie rings, cf., exercise 19.
Digression: Noetherian PI- Rings For the remainder of this section we survey some of the recent research in (non affine) Noetherian PI-rings. We start by considering T ( R )for R prime.
160
Rings with Polynomial Identities pad Affine Algebras
Proposition 6.3.45: If R is left Noetherian, prime PI then T(R) is a finite central extension of R and thus is left Noetherian. Proof;. T(R) is Noetherian as left R-module by remark 6.3.29, so T(R) = X R a summed over a finite number of characteristic coefficients a of elements of R, i.e., T(R) is a finite central extension of R. Q.E.D.
In particular, LO, GU, and INC hold from R to T(R), so R and C‘ (cf., construction 6.3.28) are intimately related, and the theory of Noetherian PI-rings has been seen recently to be an arena where a suitable general Noetherian structure theory can be developed. Before discussing this further, let us glance at noncommutative Krull dimension for arbitrary PI-rings. Digression 6.3.46: Dimension Noetherian PI.
theory. We assume throughout R is
(1) Recall from proposition 3.5.5 1 that K-dim R = cl. K-dim R. (2) (Brown-Warfield [84]; Goodearl-Small [84]) K-dim R I gl. dim R. Inequality need not hold, cf., Resco-Small-Stafford [82, example, 1.81. We discussed this result in $6.1, but would like to add that some useful partial results are readily available using T(R), cf., exercises 20-23. (3) (Lorenz-Small [82]) If R is an algebra over a field then there is P in Spec(R) for which GK-dim R = GK-dim RIP.
The Lorenz-Small theorem is proved in Krause-Lenagan [85B,pp. 1501541 and has the following consequences, proved in exercises 24-27: (i) GK-dim R is an integer if it is finite (this is obvious). (ii) GK-dim R @ T = GK-dim R + GK-dim T for any F-algebra T. (iii) If A , , A , a R with A , A , = 0 then GK-dimR = max{GK-dimR/A,, GK-dim RIA,}. (The following results concern GK module dimension.) (iv) GK-dim M = GK-dim(R/Ann M ) for any f.g. R-module M. (v) GK-dim M = max(GK-dim N, GK-dimM/N} for any N I M in R-Fimod.
Digression: Localization in PI- Rings A classical question due to Goldie is, “Which prime ideals of a PI-ring are (left) localizable,” i.e., letting % ( P ) = {elements regular modulo P } , when is % ( P ) a left or right denominator set? When R has PI-degree n and P E
06.3 Affine PI-Algebras
161
Spec,(R) then we only need central localization, cf., theorem 6.1.38. Thus we are first led to check whether there are other cases in which central localization is “good enough”: The first case one might check is when R is f.g. over Z = Z(R). Note R is a PI-ring. Clearly Rp/PpRp is finite dimensional over the field Z,/P, so is Artinian.
Proposition 6.3.47: Suppose R is f . g . over Z = Z(R) and P E Spec(Z). Then N= primes of R containing P } is localizable, in fact, by central localization in the sense that any element in %(N) is invertible modulo R,R, in R,.
n{
Proof.- Rp/Np is Artinian. We shall conclude by showing every element of %(N), is invertible. Suppose a E W ( N ) . First we claim 1-’a E V(N,).Indeed, if (sC’r)(l-’a) E Np then ra E N, so s‘ra E N for suitable s’ in Z - P; hence s‘r E N implying s - l r E N,, proving the claim. Thus 1 - ‘ a Np is regular and thus invertible in Rp/Np. But Np/PpRp = Jac(Rp/PpRp) SO 1-’a is invertible in Rp/PpRp. Q.E.D.
+
Mueller [76, theorem 71 goes on to prove that the following assertions are equivalent for R f.g. over Z and P’ E Spec(R) (i) P’ is the unique prime ideal of R lying over P’ n Z. (ii) P’ can be localized by central localization. (iii) P‘is left and right localizable. Mueller’s proof involves building a convergent sequence of idempotents in the completion R, which thus must converge to 0 or 1. The reader is invited to simplify the proof. Of course the question remains how to verify these conditions. In this regard some examples of Small-Stafford [81] are relevant, in which R is actually f.g. over its Noetherian center: A prime ideal can be left but not right localizable, cf., exercise 30. Even when R is prime, a prime ideal need not be localizable, cf., exercise 29. Given these negative results, it is surprising that Braun-Warfield [86] found a localizability criterion for arbitrary prime Noetherian PI-rings.
Braun-Warfield Theorem: Suppose R is prime Noetherian PI, and B is an arbitrary semiprime ideal of R. Write L? = PI n ... n P, where & are the B-minimal prime ideals of R . The following are equivalent: (i) B is left localizable. (ii) B is right localizable. (iii) B is left and right localizable (so that Mueller’s results are applicable).
162
Rings with Polynomial Identities and A
h Algebras
(iv) Braun- Warfield localizability criterion. Let Y = {prime ideals obtained by lifting the fi to T(R)} If Q E Spec( T(R)) and Q nZ( T(R)) = Qj nZ( T(R)) for some Qj in Y then Q E 9 Of course, everything would follow from proving (i) o (iv) since (iv) is left-right symmetric. The hard direction (iv) * (i) is shown by means of T(R) with an application of Jategaonkar’s localization techniques to finite centralizing extensions of Noetherian PI-rings. Braun-Warfield also showed their localizability results hold for f.g. height 1 primes in prime affine PI-rings. When P is a maximal ideal, Braun has found a trace ring criterion, formally weaker than (iv), which characterizes when P i= 0.
niSN
56.4 Relatively Free PI-Rings and T-Ideals Until now we have largely studied the properties of rings satisfying one polynomial identity. In this section we shift emphasis to the set of all identities of a given ring (or class of rings). This is best done by studying the relatively free, or generic, ring with respect to these identities. Relatively free PI-rings often serve as “test cases” for many proposed theorems, either yielding short proofs or providing counterexamples. This theory applies, in particular, to the generic matrix rings of $6.1. We start by examining the structure of the set of identities of an algebra. Definition 6.4.1:
A U R is a T-ideal if cpA
c A for every surjection cp: R + R.
Remark 6.4.2: If A Q R and cp is a surjection then cpA Q R. Hence Jac(R), Nil(R), NJR) for all a, and Prime rad(R) are T-ideals of R. (Indeed, Jac(R) is a T-ideal by proposition 2.5.6(i); the other assertions follow from the properties of nil sets.) Remark 6.4.3: If A is a T-ideal of C { X ) where X is an infinite set of indeterminates then cpA c A for every homomorphism cp: C { X } + C { X } . (Indeed, suppose f ( X , , . . . ,X,) E A. Define $: C { X } -+ C { X } by $Xi= cpXi for 1 I i I n and $Xi= Xi ~n for i > n. Then $ is a surjection so cpf = $f E A.) Definition 6.4.4: Let 2 ( R ) = {identities of R}. A C-algebra U is relatively free if U is free in the class of C-algebras R for which 2 ( R )2 a ( U ) . The relatiuely free PI-algebra of R is C { X ) / 9 ( R ) (terminology to be justified presently).
163
$6.4 Relatively Free PI-Rings and T-ldeals
Of course any free object also requires a designated set. Writing U = C(XJ/A and letting-denote the canonical image from C { X ) to U, we propose for this set. Note that if f E C ( X } and cp: C { X } + C ( X } is a polynomial then cpf(X,, . .. ,Xm) = f ( c p X , , . . . ,cpX,) since f is formed from multiplications and additions.
x
Theorem 6.4.5: The following statements are equivalent for A 4 C f X ) and U =C{X}/A:
(i) A is a T-ideal of C { X ) . (ii) (u,X )is relatively free. (iii) A = .T(U). (i) => (iii) Clearly 2( U ) L A , since f ( x , .,. . ,X,) = 0 implies f E A . It remains to show for every f E A that f ( K , , . ..,6,) = 0 for all h;- in U. But there is a homomorphism cp: C { X } C { X } given by cpX, = hi for 1 5 i I m; then f ( h , , . . . , h , ) = f ( c p X , , . . ., cpX,)=cpf(X,,. . . ,X,) E A since A is a T-ideal. (iii) 3 (ii) We need to show that every map CT: X R can be extended to a unique homomorphism I):U -+ R, for any C-algebra R satisfying the identities of U. Uniqueness is clear since the Xi generate U. It remains to verify existence. Define cp: C {X j -+ R such that cpX, = oZi for each i. Then ker cp 2 Z ( R )2 Z ( U )= A so we have a homomorphism Cp: C{X}/A -+ R satisfying @Xi = cpX, as desired. (ii) * (i) Given a surjection cp: C { X > 4 C { X } we need to prove cpA E A . By hypothesis we have a homomorphism $: U -+ U such that $ X i = for each i, so for any f in A we have Proof;.
-+
-+
a
-__
0 = I).?= ?($XI,. . . ,$Xm)= f'(cpX1,.. . , implying cpf
E
A as desired.
cpx,)= cpf
Q.E.D.
Remark 6.4.6: T ( R ) is a T-ideal of C ( X } ,for any C-algebra R. Thus the study of identities is equivalent to the study of T-ideals, which is equivalent to the study of relatively free algebras.
By corollary 6.1.46 { 2 ( M n ( F ) )n: E N } are the only T-ideals which are semiprime as ideals when F is an infinite field. We shall study their relatively free PI-algebras, which turn out to be domains, as focal examples in Chapter 7.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
164
Digression: Relatively Free PI(*)-Rings The results obtained so far can be obtained analogously for identities of rings with involution by means of the structure theory of 92.13. We discussed identities of rings with involution at the end of $6.1 but did not bother with the free ring in this category. The easiest way of describing it is to start by noting that if X , Y are sets of indeterminates in 1 :1 correspondence then the free algebra C { X ; Y } has the reversal involution (*) given by X : = and Y: = X i , e.g., ( X , X , Y , + X 3 Y : X 1 ) * = Y l X : Y 3 + X 3 Y z Y l . Rewriting as X : permits us to denote this ring as ( C { X } ,*). Clearly ( C { X } ,*) is the free algebra with involution, in the sense that given any (R, *) and any map f:X -+ R there is a unique homomorphism f:(C{X},*)+R,*)extendingf. (Indeed, takea homomorphism C { X ; Y } + R given by X i H f X i and H (f X i ) * . ) An identity of (R, *) can now be viewed as an element of ( C { X } ,*) which is in the kernel of every homomorphism to (R, *). Write Z(R,*)for {identities of (R, *)}. A T-ideal of (R, *) is an ideal of (R, *) invariant under every surjection cp: (R, *) + (R, *). The (*)-version of theorem 6.4.5 is now
x
x
x
Theorem 6.4.7: The following statements are equivalent for A Q ( C { X } ,*) and (V, *) = ( C { X } / A *): , (i) A is a T-ideal of ( C { X } ,*). (ii) ((v,*); X)is relatively free. (iii) A = ( T ( V ) *). , Proof:
As in theorem 6.4.5.
Q.E.D.
Theorem 6.4.8: If ( R , * ) is an algebra over an infinite field F then 2 ( R OFH , *) = Z(R,*) f o r any commutative F-algebra H. Proof:
As in theorem 6.1.44.
Q.E.D.
A complication arises when attempting to lift corollary 6.1.46.
I f R is prime PI and ( R , *) is an algebra over an injnite field F then one of the following three cases holds:
Corollary 6.4.9:
(i) 9 ( R R , *= ) T ( M , , ( F )0 Mn(FyP,0). (ii) T ( R ,*) = ZZ(M,,(F),t ) where ( t ) is the transpose. (iii) P ( R , *) = Z ( M , , ( F ) ,s) where (s) is the canonical symplectic involution.
$6.4 Relatively
Free PI-Rings and T-Ideals
165
Proof: By theorem 6.1.59 and theorem 6.4.8 we may pass to the ring of central fractions and thus assume ( R , *) is simple; tensoring by the algebraic closure K of Z ( R , * ) we may assume K is algebraically closed. If R is not simple then proposition 2.13.24 yields ( R ,*) z ( M J K ) 0 Mn(K)OP,0)w K 0 (M,,(F)0 Mn(F)OP,0)and we have (i). Thus we may assume R is simple; then R = M,,(K)so corollary 2.13.30 says ( R ,*) = (M,,(K),t ) = K 0 (M,,(F),t ) or ( R ,*) w ( M n ( K ) , s )= K 0 (M,,(F),s), thereby yielding (ii) and (iii) respectively. Q.E.D.
(i) implies every identity of ( R , * ) is special and thus reduces to the noninvoluntary case. However (ii) and (iii) yield genuine new examples. There are involutory analogs to the algebra of generic matrices, which give the explicit constructions of relatively free PI-algebras with involution, cf., exercise 3.
The Structure of T-Ideals Various interesting questions belong properly to the realm of T-ideals. To start with, when does an identity f l “imply” an identity f2, i.e., when is f2 in the T-ideal generated by f;? In this sense the Capelli polynomial Cztimplies the standard polynomial S, when we substitute 1 at the appropriate positions. Example 6.4.20: (P. M. Cohn) The identity f = [ [ X , , X , ] , X , ] does not imply any standard identity. Indeed f is an identity of the exterior algebra A ( V ) on an infinite dimensional vector space V over Q, cf., example 6.1.5, but Sk(xl,..., x k )= k ! x , . . .x k # 0 when xl,. . . , x k are independent elements of V. In fact the exterior algebra plays an important role in the theory of T-ideals, as we shall see. Recently Kemer [84] developed a structure theory for T-ideals as T-ideals rather than as ideals. He showed that any relatively free ideal has a maximum nilpotent T-ideal, and also characterized those T-semiprime relatively free rings (Le., those which have no nilpotent T-ideals), as either F { X ) , F , { X } (the algebra of generic matrices), F , { X } 0 A(V), or a certain kind of algebra of matrices whose entries are in the (H/2Z)-homogeneous components of the exterior algebra A ( V ) (his theorem 5). In this sense Kemer has determined all the T-ideals, although computing in T-ideals remains very complicated. One obvious question in a T-ideal theory would be to find a minimal set of generators of a T-ideal (as T-ideal). For example, Latyshev proved that any T-ideal of Q { X } properly containing f = [ [ X l , X 2 ] , X , ] is generated
Rings with Polynomial Identities and A m Algebras
166
,,
by f and a polynomial of the form [ X , , X , ] . . . [X,,, - X,,], cf., Rowen [80B, exercise 6.3.41. In particular there is Specht’s Problem 6.4.21: T-ideal)?
Is every T-ideal of Q { X } finitely generated (as
Three comments: (1) Specht’s problem is false in general if one can show there are uncountably many distinct T-ideals of Q{X}. (2) On the other hand, Kemer [85, corollary 13 reduces Specht’s problem to T-ideals of the T-prime relatively free algebras Q , { X } 0 A(V); he refines this result further using (Z/2Z)-grading in his theorem 2. (3) One might try further to show any maximally non-finitely generated T-ideal is prime as an ideal, for this would reduce the conjecture to T-ideals of matrices. Even for 2 x 2 matrices Specht’s problem is difficult and was solved in this case by Razmyslov [73a]; Drensky [82] has proved that S, and [ X , , X , ] 2 , X 1 ] in fact generate. This still leaves open the question of how to determine effectively (without substituting) whether a given polynomial is an identity of 2 x 2 matrices. Another motivation for information about T-ideals was in Razmyslov [74] in considering the nilpotence question (of the nilpotence of the nilradical of an affine PI-algebra); in characteristic 0 he reduced it to, “Does every affine PI-algebra over Q satisfy a Capelli identity of suitable size?” Note “affine” is necessary, in view of example 6.4.10. Kemer proved this in the affirmative and thus has priority over Braun in answering the nilpotence question in characteristic 0. However, Braun’s proof is more understandable than the Razmyslov-Kemer proof. We shall give a related result in exercise 11.
Homogeneous Iden riries The reader may have noted that we have shifted perspective to algebras over Q. There are several reasons for this, which we preface with some general observations. Remark 6.4.12: The free algebra C { X l ,. . . ,X , } is canonically isomorphic to the tensor algebra T ( M )where M = C(”’)is given the base X , , . . . ,X,; the isomorphism T ( M )+ CjX,, . . .,X,,,) is given by
xi,0 .. . 0 Xit H xi... xi,.
56.4 Relatively Free PI-Rings and T-Ideals
167
Thus we can transfer the graded structure of T ( M ) , and, in particular, view C { X , , ..., X m } as an ““’-graded algebra, graded by the degrees in
x,,...,x,
‘
Using this point of view we call a polynomial f homogeneous if it is homogeneous under this N‘“’-grading, i.e., for every i each of the monomials of f has the same degree in X i . We shall now see there are “enough” homogeneous identities by means of a very useful matrix. Remark 6.4.23: “The Vandermonde matrix” If cl,. . . ,c, are elements of a commutative ring C then the Vundermonde matrix
n15i5k5n
has determinant (ck - ci),which is nonzero if C is a domain and the ci are distinct. (Indeed, it is enough to prove this formula in Z[5,, . .. ,5,] for the Vandermonde matrix ([(- I ) since then we can specialize i i H ci for each i. Let p(C1,...,[”) be the determinant of ([!-I). Specializing i k H i i makes two rows of the matrix equal, and thus sends p H 0; hence ( [ k - li)1 p for all k > i, implying < ([, - i i )divides p . But the total degrees are equal, as are the coefficients of li, ... [i- (the contribution of the diagonal), so we conclude p = S i < k c n ( [ k - ti)as desired.)
n n,
, ~
The Vandermonde matrix is used in field theory to compute discriminants, cf., Jacobson [85B,p. 2581. Our use here is different. Proposition 6.4.14: Suppose R is a torsion-free algebra over an integral domain C having > n elements. Then every identity of R having total degree n can be written naturally as a sum of homogeneous identities of degree n.
Proofi Suppose f ( X I , .. .,X,) is an identity of R. We are done unless f is not homogeneous in some indeterminate, say X , . Write f = where each is the sum of all monomials of f having degree j in X I . If we can show each J is an identity then we can conclude by repeating this procedure for each X i .
c4=o&
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
168
(d
Take distinct cl,. . ., c d + in C and let c be the determinant of the (d + 1) x 1) Vandermonde matrix (c:- ’). Then
+
0 = f ( c j r l , r Z ,...,r,) =
d
C c j d ( r l , .. .,r,)
k=O
for any r l , . . .,r, in R . Letting u be the column vector whose entries are f o ( r l , . . r,), . . . , f d ( r l ,..., I , ) , we have the matrix equation (cr-’)o = 0. Left multiplication by the adjoint of ( c j - ’) yields 0 = cv so v = 0 since R is torsion free. Q.E.D.
Corollary 6.4.15: Proof.-
Over an injinite jield every T-ideal is homogeneous.
Every identity is a sum of homogeneous identities.
Q.E.D.
Remark 6.4.16: If f is homogeneous and h is a multilinearization of f (cf., $6.1)then there is k in N - ( 0 )for which kf is obtained by suitable substitution into h. (Indeed if f has degree d in X , then Alf(X,, . . . ,X,,Xl) = (2d - 2)f, so the result follows by induction on the number of times we apply A.) Combining corollary 6.4.15 and remark 6.4.16 we see for a field of characteristic 0 that the T-ideals are generated by multilinear polynomials, which are the most amenable to computation. Another reason for studying 7’-ideals of @algebras is the surprising Nagata-Higman theorem that any nil @algebra (without 1) of bounded index is nilpotent, cf., exercise 2. This result pops up in many proofs and was improved by Razmyslov [74] using trace identities. Kemer [84, theorem 61 proves a broad generalization of Nagata-Higman using his theory of T-ideals.
The Quantitative PI- Theory The “quantitative” PI-theory may be defined as the computations of various invariants of T-ideals. Although we have already seen several significant attributes of T-ideals, the major impetus to the quantitative theory came from a different quarter. One of the early unsolved questions in PI-theory was the tensor product question: Need the tensor product of PI-algebras be a PI-algebra? The tensor product question has the following easy reduction to relatively free algebras:
g6.4 Relatively Free PI-Rings and T-fdeals
169
Remark 6.4.27: Let @ ( R i )denote the relatively free PI-algebras of R i . Then R , & R , is a homomorphic image of 42(RI)&@(R2), and in particular satisfies all of its identities. Applying this observation to the structure theoretic results of 96.1 one can obtain rather easily an affirmative answer to the tensor product question whenever R , satisfies all the identities of n x n matrices, cf., exercise 4. On the other hand, Regev found a quantitative approach which still is the only method known for solving the tensor product question in full generality. E Sym(k)}, Let v k denote the C-subspace of C { X } spanned by {Xnl.XXk:x a free C-module of rank k ! Given a T-ideal 1 of C ( X } , let 1, = 1 n V, and let ck(V) denote the smallest number of elements which can span %/Ikas C-module; c,( V )is called the k-codimension of I. Lemma 6.4.18: (Regeu) If 1 , , 1 2 are T-ideals of Z{X} such that cn(I1)cn(l2)< n! then R = ( Z { X j / r , ) o , ( z t X } / 1 2 satisfies ) a multilinear identity of degree n whose coeficients are relatively prime, so R is a PI-ring. Regev’s lemma is proved in exercise 5. In view of remark 6.4.17 an affirmative solution t o the tensor product question lies in proving the “codimension sequence” is exponentially bounded in the following sense: If 1 is a T-ideal containing a multilinear polynomial of degree d, one of whose coefficients is & 1, then there is m = m ( d ) such that c,(l) I m” for all n. Regev showed that the codimension sequence indeed is exponentially bounded, and Latyshev [72] produced the result c,(I) < (d cf., exercises 7 and 6; this is called the Latysheu bound. Putting everything together yields Theorem 6.4.19: (Regeu) The tensor product of any two PI-algebras is a P1-algebra. These results indicate that any polynomial identity requires a lot of room in V,, and one of the major goals of the quantitative theory was to obtain explicit asymptotic formulas for the codimensions; in particular, cf., Regev [SO] and Amitsur [84] and Drensky [84]. The codimension is a rather crude invariant. More precise information can be obtained by giving V, extra structure, where C = F is any field of characteristic 0. First note there is a vector space isomorphism from the
170
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Amne Algebras
c
c
group algebra F[Sym(k)] -+ V,, given by a,n -+ a,XnI .. xnk.This identification makes V, a left and right Sym(k)-module,under the action ’
af(X,,...,Xm) = f(Xo1T...>Xom). Given a T-ideal I we see I, = I n V, is a left submodule of V, and thus can be studied in terms of the character theory of representations of the symmetric group. The focus is on the character of %/&, called the cocharacter of 1,‘. An alternate method is by means of GL(n,F). Let W = c I = F X i z F‘”). Any T in GL(n, F ) acts as a transformation on W, and thus extends “diagonally” to a transformation on wQkgiven by T ( w , @ . . - @ w , ‘ ) = T w , @...@ Twk. Now identify F ( X } with the tensor algebra F @ W @ W@’ @. . . . Clearly I n W @ kis invariant under the action of GL(n,K) and so can be studied via the representation theory of G ( n , F ) . As before, attention focuses on W B k / ( 1n W @ k )This . approach has become increasingly popular in recent years and does not require the restriction to multilinear identities; also work of Drensky [84] and Berele [82] show this theory includes the Sym(k) = cocharacter theory. Suppose F is infinite. By corollary 6.4.15 corresponding relatively free PI-algebra inherits the N-grading. On the other hand, theorem 6.3.25 shows the dimensions of { W B k / n l W Q kk: E N} have polynomially bounded growth, so there is an attached Hilbert series. Computing this series is possibly the most pressing problem in the quantitative theory but is very hard to accomplish.
Trace Identities Let us bring the good old Hamilton-Cayley theorem into this discussion. Any generic n x n matrix Y, satisfies f ( Y,) = 0 where f(Y,) = Y l + a,Y;, and the ai are the suitable elementary symmetric functions of the eigenvalues of Y l . Thus M J F ) satisfies a “characteristic coefficient identity” of degree n. These are usually called “trace identities” because if F is a Q-algebra Newton’s identities permit one to express the characteristic coefficients of Yl as polynomial expressions in traces of powers of Y, . For example if n = 2 then det( Yl) = $(tr(Y,)’ - tr(Y;)). Razmyslov [74b] and Procesi [76] (also, cf., Helling [74]) proved every identity f of M,,(Q) is a “consequence” of this Hamilton-Cayley trace identity, by showing that f ( X , , . . .,X,) is a consequence of the trace identity tr(X,+,f), and this is a consequence of the Hamilton-Cayley trace identity. There is a “generic” ring for trace identities, namely the “trace ring” for the generic matrix algebra, and Amitsur-Small [SO] showed thereby that any trace identity for M,,(F) is also a trace identity for I V “ - ~ ( F ) .Nevertheless,
xyLi
$6.4 Relatively Free PI-Rings and Tldeals
171
there still does not seem to be an effective procedure for verifying identities, as witnessed by the difficulty of Formanek’s verification of Regev’s central polynomial
f
=
1 .a E
1
(sg m g O
Sym(n2)
x; x,2 xn, x,,xi2 xi, xi4 . . .
K1
1
where X, ,..., X , , , , X ; ,..., X i l are indeterminates, cf., Formanek [86]. It is relatively easy to show f takes on only scalar values, but the hard part is showing f is not an identity; f’ is very useful in the quantitative theory.
Invariant Theory Procesi [76] tied the trace identity theory to the classical invariant theory and thereby extended the roots of PI-theory. The thrust of modern research in the quantitative PI-theory is to explore this relationship and thus learn more about both subjects.
Definition 6.4.20: Letting F,{ Y } denote the algebra of generic n x n matrices (i.e., =([:)) for k = 1,2,. . . , and the):[ are each commuting indeterminates over F ) , write F [ r ] for the commutative polynomial ring F[(:): 1 Ii , j < n, k = 1,2,. . . ] . Given a E GL(n, F ) write aKa-’ = ($)) for suitable pi:) in F [ [ ] ; define a * l::’ to be pij(k).This action extends naturally to an automorphism $o: F [ [ ] + F [ c ] for each a in GL(n, F). A (commutative) polynomial p([) E F [ ( ] is an inuariant of n x n matrices if a . p = p for all a in GL(n,F), i.e., p is invariant under all elements of GL(n,F). The set of invariants of n x n matrices is called the ring of inuariants (of n x n matrices). Remark 6.4.21: Any central polynomial f(X,, . . . ,X,) is an invariant, for noting f is a suitable scalar matrix p([)l we have (a.p)l
=
f(aYla-’ ,,..,aY,a-’) = af(Yl ,..., Ym)a-’= f(Y,,..., Y,)
= pl
Thus the ring of invariants contains Z(F,{ Y } ) . Procesi [76] showed that the ring of invariants is generated by traces of monomials of generic matrices of degree < 2” - 1; later this was seen to follow from a classic theorem from invariant theory first proved in full by Gurevich. Using this theorem we see the ring of invariants is merely the center of the n-trace ring of F,{ Y } . Artin and Schofield have shown the n-trace ring is in fact a “maximal order” in the sense of Auslander and Goldman, cf., Le Bruyn [86], who also derives consequences of this fact.
Rings with Polynomial Identities and A f h e Algebras
172
Thus writing R = F,{ Y}, 2 = Z ( R ) , T = T ( R ) ,and 2’ = Z ( T ) , we see 2’ is the ring of invariants, and Z and 2’ have the same field of fractions. One of the classic questions in invariant theory is to present 2’ efficiently in terms of generators and relations: in particular one has Question 6.4.22:
Is the field of fractions of Z purely transcendental?
There is very explicit information for n = 2. First of all the ring of invariants Z’ is generated over F by tr Y, , tr Y,, det Y, , det Y,, and tr( Y, Y2), and thus is a polynomial ring over F, cf., exercise 9. Furthermore, letting C, = F[Y,,tr Y,,tr Y,,det Y,]
C,
=
F[Y,,tr Y,,tr Y,,det Y,]
C = F[tr Yl,tr Y,,det Y,,det Y,],
Formanek-Schofield [SS] prove T is the free product of C, and C, over C, cf., exercise 10, and conclude T has global dimension 5. (This latter fact had been proved by Small-Stafford [85], who also display T as an iterated Ore extension.) Formanek showed the answer to question 6.4.22 also is “yes” for n = 3 and n = 4 (cf., Rowen [SOB, p. 197ffl and Formanek [82]). However, Formanek’s method increases in complexity with n and is not likely to be applicable for n = 5. A positive solution to question 6.4.22 for arbitrary n would have far-reaching applications in the theory of division algebras, as we shall see in the next chapter. There is yet another method of studying T-ideals, using the ring of symmetric functions, defined as the fixed ring of Z [ I , , . . . ,I,] under the action of Sym(m). This brings in the theory of fixed subrings under group actions. Formanek [84, theorem 71 shows this method is equivalent to studying the GL(n,F)-modules and is also equivalent to studying the Hilbert series of the relatively free PI-algebras of T. Formanek [84] is a “must” for anyone interested in entering the quantitative theory; a shorter survey is given in Formanek [85].
Exercises 96.I 1. Every identity is a sum of blended identities. (Hint: Induction on the number of indeterminates in which f is not blended, applied to the identities f(X, I-+ 0) and f - f(X, O H 2. If h is a monomial of degree d > 1 in X i then (2d- 2)h = Aih(Xl,... , X , , X , ) .
Exercises
173
Hence some multiple of h can be recovered from a multilinearization of h. Conclude from this that in characteristic 0 any central polynomial can be multilinearized to a multilinear central polynomial, and any identity can be recovered from multilinear identities. 3. Write Aij, for the polynomial in which Xi and Xi are interchanged. Show that f is t-alternating iff hij,= -f for all 1 I i < j I t, iff hi,i+ ,) = - f for all 1 I i < t. 4. Write f for the sum of those polynomials of f for which Xi,. ..,X, occur in ascending order. f is t-alternating iff = ~ n E S y m ( , ) ( s g ~ ) f ( X. .n,X,,), l , . by exercise 3. Conclude that every t-normal polynomial can be written in the form hioC2,(X,,.. . ,X,, h i , ,. . . ,hit) for suitable monomials h,. Thus Capelli identities are "initial" in the sense that if C,, is an identity of R then every t-normal polynomial is a n identity of R . 5. For any commutative ring C every identity f of M,,(Z) is an identity of M,(C). (Hint: f is a n identity of M,,(Z[l,,L,, ...I) by corollary 6.1.45, and M,,(C) is a homomorphic image.) 6. Arguing as in remark 6.1.18 show the only possible multilinear identity of M,(C) having degree n is S,, . 7. The polynomial ~ n , a ~ S y m ( ~ ) ( ~ g ~ ) ( ~ g ~ ) C X n l ~ X is r +aa nonzero ll~~~CX~,~X~ multiple of the standard polynomial S2,. (Hint: It is t-normal, with no cancellation of terms.) 8. S , = ~ ; = , ( - l ) i - l x i S , - l ( x l,..., x i + , ,xi+l ,..., x , ) = ~ ; ~ , ( - l ) ' - ' S , ~ , ( x,..., l Xi- ,Xi+,,. . . ,Xt)Xi.Consequently if S,- is an identity then so is S,. 9. 2trSz,(x1,...,xZr)=Ofor all xi in M,(C).(Hint: Exercise 8 shows 2trS2,(x,, ...,x,,)= ~ ( - I ) ' - ' t r [ x i , S 2 r - 1 ( ~,..., 1 x ~ - ~ ,..., ~ x,,)] x ~ =+ 0.)~ 10. (Amitsur-Levitzki theorem.) S2, is an identity of M , ( C ) for every commutative ring C. (Hint (Razmyslov): By exercise 5 take C = h.Any matrix x satisfies the Hamilton-Cayley equation x" a i x i = 0 where z i can be written in terms of traces by Newton's formulae (cf., Rowen [80B, p. 183). The multilinearization technique can be applied to this equation to yield 0 = xnl. ' . xnn+ terms involving traces, for all x i in M,(Z). Now substituting commutators [x~,x.+,~]in place of the x, and summing over suitable permutations 0 , one obtains standard polynomials by exercise 7, and the terms involving traces drop out by exercise 9. Thus 0 = ~n.o[~nI,xn+al]... [.X,~,X~+~,,] = mS2n(x,,....x Z n ) for some rn, so S,, is an identity.) 11. Sn-l([X~-l,X,],...,[Xl,Xz]) is not a n identity of M,(C) for any commutative ringC. (Hint: Passing to homomorphic images one may assume C is a field. If JCI2 n take a diagonal matrix x 1 having distinct eigenvalues and x2 ei.i+ Even when ICI < n one can maneuver into a position to use this substitution by means of "companion matrices." 12. (Amitsur) A PI-ring R satisfying the identities of n x n matrices with NiI(R)"N(R). Let C be a commutative ring containing a nil ideal I which is not of bounded index, e g , C = H / c i e N H A jwhere H = F [ l l , 1 2 , ...I. Let R = { ( c i j ) e M,(C):c, E I for all i > j ) , a subring of M J C ) containing the nil ideal A = {(c,) E M n ( C ) : c i1j ~ for all i 2 j } . Then el, = e,,e,,...e,-,,, E An-' but el, $ N(R) since 1 z Ie,, = (Ienl)elnE Re,,. Thus A"-' N(R).) 13. Quicker proof of (iii) *(iv) in theorem 6.1.35. Write g, = ~ h , , X 1 h Uand 2 apply exercise 5.3.1 1, letting aijy= hul(r,,. . . , r m ) and bij, = rlhu2(r2,. .. ,i-,,,).
xi
,
,
+
cnESym(n) c
=cIii ,.
174
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
Applications of the Embedding Procedure 14. If R/NiI(R) is PI and S E R is a multiplicatively closed set each of whose elements can be written as a sum of nilpotent elements from S then S is nil. 15. If R/Jac(R) is PI then R is weakly finite. (Hint: See proof of theorem 3.2.37; M,(R/Jac(R)) is embeddible in matrices for all n.) 16. If R is prime and satisfies an identity, one of whose coefficients does not annihilate R, then R is a PI-ring. (Hint: Assume the identity f is multilinear; then using corollary 3.2.46 assume R is primitive and reprove Kaplansky’s theorem.)
PI-Theory Via Semiprime Rngs In the following exercises R, is a rng, i.e., without 1.
17. Suppose R, is prime and satisfies a multilinear identity f; write f ( X , , . . .,X,,) = f ’ ( X , , . . .,X,- , ) X n + 1 where no monomial of f ends in X,. Then f is a PI of L = L / L n A n n ‘ L for any L < R . (Hint: O = S ( a , , ..., a,,_,,r)a’= f’(a,, . . .,a,,- , ) r d for a, E L, a’ E Ann‘ L.) 17’.Applying PI-induction to of exercise 17 (also, cf., exercise 2.1.3) prove Kaplansky’s theorem directly; also prove Posner’s original theorem, that all prime PI-rings are Goldie, by verifying the Goldie condition. 18. If L is a left ideal of R, then [Z(L),R,]L = 0. Hint: [z,r]a = [z,ra] r[a,z] = 0 for a in L and z in Z(L).) 19. If R, is semiprime and L is a left ideal of R, then L is semiprime as a rng and Z ( L ) s Z(R,). (Hint: [z,r]R[z,r] = 0 for z in Z(L) by exercise 18.) 20. If R, is semiprime PI and A a R, then 0 # Z(A) E A n Z(R). (Hint: Apply a central polynomial to exercise 19.) This alternate proof of theorem 6.1.28 is due to Martindale. 21. A left ideal L of a semiprime ringR is large i K L n Z(R) is large in Z(R). (Hint: (-) Z ( L ) E Z ( R ) by exercise 19, so apply a central polynomial.) 22. (Braun, Schofield, and others?) A short, nonconstructive proof of the existence of central polynomials. (This requires Posner’s theorem, cf., exercise 17’.) Let D be the central simple ring of fractions of the generic matrix algebra H,{ Y). Taking a base of D over Z(D) containing 1, define the projection n: D -+ Z ( D ) . Viewing n E End,,,,D E D Q D O p , write n as C,f;/-’ Q h-’hi for f i , f , h, hi E Zn{Y). Then ~ f ; - Y k h , = n ( f Y k Eh Z) ( D ) so Z,{ Y] has a nontrivial central element!
+
PI-Rings Satisfying ACC 23. If R is semiprime PI with the ACC on annihilators of ideals then R is semiprime Goldie, and its semisimple Artinian ring of fractions can be had by localizing at the regular elements of Z(R).) (Hint: A finite intersection of primes is 0, so use the results of 53.2.) 24. (Cauchon) If R is a semiprime PI-ring satisfying ACC(idea1s)then R is Noetherian. (Hint: Reduce to the prime case. Pick z = gn(rl,.. .,r,) # 0 and let t = nz. Given L < R and a in L let z(a) denote the vector (z,, . . .,zr) E Z“) where za = ziai. Then RM R(‘)is generated by {z(a”):1 2 u 5 k ) for suitable a, E L and suitable Ray. Here M is as in proposition 6.1.51.) k; show L =
XI-;
,
Exercises
175
ni,, ni,,
24’.(Cauchon) If R is a PI-ring satisfying ACC(idea1s) then Jac(R)” is nilpotent. (Hint: One may assume R is semiprime b y lemma 2.6.22; then apply exercise 24.) Of course, this is sharp in view of Herstein’s counterexample. 25. If R is prime of PI-degree n satisfying ACC(idea1s) then Pi= 0 for all P in Spec,(R). (Hint: Pass to the Azumaya algebra R [ s - ’ ] . ) Using induction, conclude that there are only a finite number of idempotent prime ideals in any PI-ring satisfying ACC(ideals), where we say A U R is idempotent if A 2 = A . 26. (Robson) Let C be a local Noetherian integral domain with J = Jac(C) # 0. Then
(5 E)
is prime Noetherian but
(:
s)
is an idempotent maximal ideal.
Thus exercise 25 is sharp. 27. (Schelter) Working in C = Q ( f i , f i ) [ k , , i 2 1 let C, =QC&,,h+l,,&,A2&l and C2 = a[&, 1,,i, E.,, and A = CIA2 C,&& Then A = i,C = Czl, C z A 2 f i , and C, n C 2 = Q( &) A, which is not Noetherian. Let R =
+
I:(
g2)
+
c M 2 ( C ) .R is f.g.
A],
+
+
as C, x C2-module so is Noetherian, and every
prime ideal of R has height 5 2. But the “principal ideal theorem” fails for Z ( R ) since A is A2-minimal but not minimal. In particular Z(R) is not Noetherian. 28. (Amitsur) Say a polynomial f is R-correct if for each 0 # r E R there is a coefficient of f which does not annihilate R. Any ring R satisfying an R-correct identity is a PI-ring. (Hint: By theorem 6.1.53 one may assume R is semiprime. Then n ( P E Spec(R):f is (RIP)-correct) = 0, so pass to the prime case and apply exercise 16.) 29. If R satisfies an R-correct identity f of degree d then S&,21is a PI of R for some k dependent only on f,and k = 1 if R is semiprime. (Hint: This comes from the proofs of exercises 28 and 16, in view of the Amitsur-Levitzki theorem.)
Theory of Generalized Identities 30. If R satisfies a proper multilinear G I then R satisfies a proper multilinear GI in two indeterminates. (Hint: Take f ( X , , . . . ,X,) a proper GI of R, such that f can be written as a sum of k monomials with k minimal possible. Let f i be the sum of those generalized monomials of f in which X , precedes X 2 ; one may assume f, is not a GI of R. But then taking r , , . . . ,rmfor which f,(r,,. . . ,rm)# 0 one has f ( X , , X 2 ,r 3 , .. .,r,) is proper.) 31. Prove Amitsur’s theorem for GI’s. (Hint: (=) By exercise 30 one may assume R satisfies a G I f = f l + f 2 where f l = ~ r , ~ X l r 2 i X 2 and r 3 i f2 = x r ‘ l j X 2 r i j X l r > j and /, is not a G I of R. Write R as a dense subring of End M D .Taking a maximal subfield F of D let R‘ = R F as in construction 3.2.46. Then R’ is dense in End MF and F = Z ( R ‘ ) . It suffices to show some 0 # r E soc(R’) for then [ r M : F ] = [ r M : D ] [ D : F ] .But f is a proper GI of R’, so one may write f, over R‘ such that the r l i are linearly independent over F. Fix any x in M and let V = x j F r i j x , a finite dimensional subspace of M . For all r in R’ and any r , in R’ such that r I V = 0 one has 0 = f ( r , , r ) x = ~ r l i r I r 2 i r r 3 iBy x . the density theorem there are ai in F such that for any y in M there is r in R for which rr3ix = z i y ; hence x q r , i r l r 2 i= O for all r , such that r , V = O . If some r,,M $ V then
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
176
repeating the application of the density theorem one can find a: in F for which E a , a f r , , = 0, contrary to the independence of the r l i . )The proof actually shows that some coefficient of each monomial of f lies in soc(R’). 32. A (*)-GI is multilinear if Xi or X : (but not both) appear exactly once in each monomial. Any *-GI can be multilinearized. If ( R ,*) is prime of the second kind then every multilinear GI is special. (Hint: Otherwise take f ( X , , X : , . .. , X , , X : ) a multilinear GI which is not special, with m minimal. Write f = fl + f2 where X : does not appear in , f 2 , and XI does not appear in f,, and take z # z * E Z ( R ) . Then
(z - Z*)fI=
zfcx,,x:,. . . ,x m X : ) - f(ZX,,(ZXI)*,. .. ,X,, x :)
i s a G I of ( R , * ) s o f , = , f , ( X : , X , , X *2 , . . .) is a GI of ( R , * ) .But f l ( r , X 2 , X ; , .. .) is a special G I for any r in R, so f , special G I ; likewise, f2 is special.) 33. Suppose ( R , * ) is primitive and satisfies a proper GI. Then either (i) every GI of ( R , * ) is special, or (ii) R is strongly primitive. (Hint: If R is not primitive then take a primitive ideal P # 0 with P n P * = 0 as in proposition 2.13.32. If f ( X , , X : , . . .,X,,,,X:) is a GI of (R, *) then f ( X l , .. . , X Z m )is a GI of the rng P 0 P* as in example 6.1.58(iii), so is a GI of P * z (P 0 P * ) / P , a nonzero ideal of RIP, so f ( X , , . . . ,XZm) is a GI of RIP by identity; analogously f(X,, .. . ,X 2 , ) is a GI of RIP* so is a GI of R . Thus one has (i) unless R is primitive. Also one may assume f = fl f 2 where X : does not appear in fi and X , does not appear in f 2 , and f, and f2 are nof GI’s of (R, *). Thus there are r , , r 3 , .. . in R for which fl(Xl,r2,rz,...) is not a GI of R. Thus one may assume f = ~ r i l X , r , + , x r l l X : r i 2 . Replace X , , X : , respectively, by X : X , , X : X , , and repeat the argument of exercise 31 to show soc(R) # 0. But now theorem 2.13.21 is applicable and permits us to pass to RF where F is a maximal (*)-symmetric subfield of D ; thus one concludes as in exercise 31 that D is PI.) 34. (Amitsur) Suppose ( R ,*) satisfies an identity f of degree rn, which is R-correct in the sense that for any r in R there is a in f for which ar # 0. Then R is a PI-ring, and has PI-degree I rn if R is semiprime. (Hint: I n analogy to exercise 33, one can reduce to the case ( R ,*) is primitive by means of the (*)-structure theory of $2.13. By exercise 33 one may assume R is strongly primitive, so conclude using exercise 2.13.4 as in the proof of Kaplansky’s theorem. 35. Hypotheses as in exercise 34, Sl, is an identity of R by Amitsur-Levitzki.
+
Amitsur’s (*)-identity theorem can be applied to Herstein’s theory (exercises of 32.13), as exemplified in the next exercise.
36. If ( R , *) is semiprime with ( R , *)’ E Z ( R ) or ( R ,*)- G Z ( R ) then R has PIdegree S 2. (Hint: ( R ,*) satisfies [XI + X : , X , ] or [XI- X:,X,] so apply exercise 34.)
96.2 Some results of Montgomery-Small [81] when a ring is affine 1. Suppose R is affine over a commutative Noetherian ringC. Then eRe is affine
Exercises
177
over eCe under either of the following conditions: (i) eR is f.g. as eRe-module; (ii) ReR is f.g. as R-module. (Hint: (i) Write R = C { r , , .. . , r , } let eR = eReri with r', = 1, and erierj=xeaij,er;. Then the {er;e,eaijke}generate eRe. (ii) Write ReR = C R x i and xi = x i j r ; e r : , for r'..,d' IJ V in R. Then the er:j generate eR as ReR-module, so concude by (I)). 2. Suppose R is left Noetherian and affine over a commutative Noetherian ring C . If G is a finite group of automorphisms on R with [GI-’ E R then the fixed ringRG is affine. (Hint: The skew group ring R*G is affine Noetherian, so RG is affine by exercise 1 and exercise 2.6.14.) 3. If T is an affine algebra over a commutative Noetherian ringC and L < T satisfies LT = T then C + L is affine over C. (Hint: Apply example 6.2.3, noting Re,,R = R so that exercise I(ii) applies.) In particular, this provides a host of affine algebras when T is simple, such as the Weyl algebra A,. It is a n open question if every affine subalgebra of A is Noetherian. 4. (Resco) An affine domain which is left and right Ore, and left but not right Noetherian. Let A, be the Weyl algebra F { I , p } satisfying pI - I p = I ; then R, = F + A l p is left and right Noetherian and affine by exercise 3. Let t denote a commuting indeterminate over A , and let R = { p E A I [ t ] : the constant coefficient of p is in R,}. Then R is affine and left Noetherian since R is a submodule of A which is f.g. as R,-module; however, R is not right Noetherian since A is not tg. as right R,-module.) 5. (Small) Suppose R is affine over C but not tg. over C. Then there is P in Spec(R) for which R I P is not f.g. over C / ( P n C). (Hint: Write R = C { r ,,..., r n } .{ A a R: RIA is not f.g. over C/(A n P ) } is Zorn, arguing as in Artin-Tate. Thus there is P 4 R maximal with respect to R I P not f.g. over C / ( P n C ) .To show P is prime suppose P c A 4R and A r E P. Then RrR is cyclic over (RIA) 0 (R/A)OPwhich is f.g. over C; hence RrR is f.g. over C implying R/(P RrR) is not f.g. over the image of C, and therefore r E P.) 6. (Martindale) Applying example 2.1.30 to Golod-Shafarevich yields a primitive algebraic algebra which is not locally finite. 7. (Irving-Small [83]) A primitive, affine algebra R with GK-dim 2, having socle # 0 and failing ACC(Ann). Let R = F { r l , r 2 }where r 1 , r 2 satisfy the relations r: = 0, r,r?r, = 0 for rn not a power of 2, and r l r T r , = r , for rn a power of 2. Let M be the F-vector space with base {x,, x , , . . .}, made into R-module by the actions rzxi = xi+, , r I x i= 0 for i not a power of 2, and rlxi = x,, for i a power of 2. Then M is faithful and simple since any submodule contains x, and thus M . Hence R is a primitive ring. Also {Annr?r,:rn is a power of 2) is an infinite ascending chain of annihilators. Furthermore Rr, is a minimal left ideal since Rr, z M under the correspondence r i r , H xi. 8. Prove theorem 6.2.17 without the hypothesis ACC(Ann). (Hint: Continue the given proof. By exercise 3.3.14 it is enough to show Sing(R)=O. But if z E Sing(R) then 0 # L n Annz E L so L n Ann z = L and thus L Sing(R) = 0, implying Sing(R) = 0.) 9. An affine F-algebra of G K dim 2 and ciassical Krull dimension I, but not having K-dim. Let R = F{X,,X,J/(X,)Z. Then taking S = we have G,(n)= (n + I)(n + 2)/2 so GKdim(R) = 2, but R has infinite uniform dimension and thus lacks K-dim. Also note G K d i m R I N = 1 where N = (X,) is nilpotent.
xy=,
,
,
,
+
{xl,x2}
Rings with Polynomial Identities nnd Affiw Algebras
178
Gelfand-Kirillov Dimension 10. If T is the ring of differential polynomials R[I;6] with R affine then Note that if GKdim(7') = 1 + GKdim(R). (Hint: ( 2 )as in remark 6.2.22'). ( 5 ) 6s E V,(S)then 6K(S) E K+'(S).) 11. If GK dim(R,) 5 2 then GK dim(R, @ R 2 ) = G K dim(R,) GK dim(R,). If GK dim(R,) 2 2 then G K dim(R, @ R,) 2 2 + G K dim(R,). (Hint: Enough to show (2). For GKdim(R,) = 1 then Gs(n)2 n; for GKdim(R,) > 1 then by
+
Bergman's theorem G,(n)> n 2 / 2 . )
12. Suppose S is a commutative, multiplicatively closed, left and right denominator set of regular elements of R, generated by elements s for which the derivation [s, 3 is nilpotent on every finite dimensional F-subspace of R. Then
GKdim(S-'R) = GKdim(R). (Hint: Let V be an Ed. subspace of S-'R, and take s1 . . . s r V sR for which each [si, 3 is nilpotent on V. Inverting the si one at a time reduces to the case where S is generated by a single element s. Take an Ed. subspace V' of R such that 1,s E V', Vs' G V', and [s, V'] G V'. Letting 6 = [s, ] one has 6"V' = 0 for some m, and so V" G (V's-')" E s - " " + " ' ) ( V ' ) ~ ~yielding +" GK dim(S-'R) 2 GKdim(R).) Incidentally the hypothesis that S is a left and right denominator set is superfluous since S is locally triangularizable, but this requires a careful argument, cf., Krause-Lenagan CUB, proposition 4.61. 13. (Bergman [81]) An affine PI-algebra R with an f.g. module M of GK-dim2, having submodule N for which GKdim(N)=GKdim(M/N)= 1. Let R = F{rl,r2} where rZrl= 0 and let M = Rx + Ry satisfy the relations r;' 'r;x = 0 and r,r?y = O unless n is a square m z in which case r l r ; y = rlrTx. Let N = Ry. Taking S = { l , r l , r 2 } note S"x + S"y has base {rlr{x and r i y : i 5 j and i j 5 n} so GKdim(M) = 2. But every r , r l x E N so GKdim(M/N) = 1. On the other hand, GK dim(N) = 1 since to get r f r i x in S"y one needs only i j 2 I n. R is PI since [R, R I 2 = 0. Bergman also shows how to modify this example to get M arbitrary. 14. (Lenagan) If R is a fully bounded Noetherian ring then GKdim(M) = GKdim(R/Ann, M). (Hint: By exercise 3.5.13 R is an H-ring. Let A = Ann, M = AnnR{xl,..., x,}. Then RIA 4 @ Rxi E M") so GKdim(RI.4) 2 GKdimM.) 15. G,(n)"" always exists. (Hint: If n = p q r then Gs(n)""5 Gs(p)q’nGs(r)l’" 2 Gs(p)"PG,( p)""; take limits.) 16. If y(R) denotes the Hilbert series of a graded algebra R then y(R @ T ) ,= y(R)y(T) since (R @ T), = Rj @ q -j . In particular y ( F [ I , , ...,At]) = (1 - A)-'. 17. If R is prime Noetherian then GK dim R = G K dim L for each 0 # L R. (Hint: Analogous to the proof of proposition 3.5.46.)
+
+
+
The Bergman-Sarraille Counterexample 1. (Bergman) Let R = Q(~,y)/([x,t],[y,z],z~) where z = [x,y]. R is an affine
Noetherian PI-ring not f.g. over any commutative subring. (Hint: z E Z(R), (Rz)' = 0, and R/Rz is commutative Noetherian. Hence [X,,X,]2 is a PI of R, and R is Noetherian since Rz is an f.g. module over R/Rz.
Exercises
179
T o get the negative properties let T be the subring of M 3 ( Q [ , i 1 , R 2 ]generated ) by x = e I 2 A, 1 and y = e23+ L 2 1. Then [ x , y ] = e l 3 E Z ( T )and [x,yI2 = 0, so there is a n obvious surjection cp: R T which is shown to be an isomorphism by describing Texplicitlyas ( p - 1 + p l e l 2 + p 2 e , , + s e l , : p , s ~ Q [ R , , A 2 ] ) where pi denotes dp/dLi. One can now show that R cannot be f.g. over a commutative subring H. For l? = R/Rz would be f.g. over H = ( H + R z ) / R z , so is affine by Artin-Tate; then H is f.g. over a subalgebra Q [ f , S ] where E S are algebraically independent over Q. But taking f = p 1 + ... and g = q 1 ... in H c T one sees the derivation 6 = p l ~ / d 2- pzd/dl is 0 on Q[T,g] and thus on R, since I? is integral over Q [ x g ] . Then 0 = 6Al = 61, implying p1 = p 2 = 0 so 7s Q, contradiction.) Actually this argument shows R is not integral over any commutative subring. 2. (Sarraille) A prime affine Noetherian PI-ring not f.g. (or even integral) over any commutative subring. Let R' = R[A,] where A, is a new commuting indeterminate, and R is as in exercise 1, and let R" = R' + A,M,(Q[L,,A,,A,]) using the description of R' as a subring of M 3 ( Q [ 4 , R , , R 3 ] ) of example 1. Then R" is a prime PI-ring since localization gives M3(Q(A,,A2,R3)); however R is a homomorphic image of R", so R" cannot be integral over a commutative subring. To prove R" is affine and Noetherian it suffices to show A3M3(Q[A1,A,, A,]) is an f.g. R'-module, as in example 6.2.3.This is done by showing the A,eij span, by a straightforward computation.) Sarraille's example has K-dim 3. This is the lowest dimension for a counterexample, in light of Braun [Sl].
+
-
-+
a
+
Embeddibility into Matrices 3. If R is affine over a field F and f.g. over C E Z ( R ) then R is embeddible into matrices. (Hint: C is affine. Furthermore, one may assume R is irreducible, so every element of C is regular or nilpotent. But Noether normalization says R is f.g. over a polynomial ringC,; localizing at C, - ( 0 ) embeds R into a finite dimensional algebra over the field of fractions of C , and thus into matrices.) The hypothesis "affine" can also be removed from the hypothesis, using a theorem of Cohen from commutative algebra instead of Noether normalization. 4. (Malcev) An affine F-algebra R is embeddible in matrices iffR is a subdirect product of finite dimensional algebras over fields, each of which is embeddible in n x n matrices for some fixed n. (Hint: (-=)Clear. ( a One ) may assume R E M,(C) with C affine over F and then assume R irreducible. By Noether normalization C is f.g. over a polynomial ring C,. If pi is a maximal ideal of C , then P;.C # C by Nakayama so P,R # R; pass to R/P;R and C/qC which is f.d. over the field COIP;..) 5. (Lewin's original example) Let C = Q [ i , p ] for commuting indeterminates L,p. + (')
c)
((A)
is affine by example 6.2.3 but has an uncountable number of
ideals. Thus there are an uncountable number of affine algebras satisfying the identities of 2 x 2 matrices, which are not embeddible in matrices. 6. Details of the Irving-Small counterexample. Let R = F{Xl,X 2 } / ( X ; , X 2 X , X 2 ) . Write Xifor the image of Xiin R. Taking a base u,, u2 of V = F[A](2' one can identity with fi: V V given by f,u2 = f 2 u 2 = 0,flat = u2 and f2u1 = l o , . Thus R c M , ( F [ I ] ) by the regular representation and satisfies the identities of
xi
-+
180
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
2 x 2 matrices. Given any subset I = { i , , i,, . . .} of N written in ascending - -order, . let I‘ = { i , , i , i2,2il i2 i3,4i1 2i, i, i 4 , ...} and A, = ( X , X ’ , X , : i E Z’) Q R. It remains t o show each RIA, has no chains of annihilators of length > 4. Write T for RIA,, and x i for the image of in T. Any left annihilator in T is contained in Tx,+ Tx,;since (Tx,+ Tx2)x,x2= 0 we see Tx,+ Tx, is the unique maximal left annihilator. Likewise x, T + x, T is the unique maximal right annihilator, implying Tx,x,= Ann(x,T x2T)is the unique minimal left annihilator. Now suppose L is a left annihilator with Tx,x,< L < Tx,+ Tx,. Then L has some element a = x,p,(x,) p2(x2)x, x,p,(x,)x, where the p i are polynomials in x 2 and p1 # 0. Then Ann’a = x,x,T + V(a) where V(a)= {q(xz)xl:xlpl(x2)q(xz)x, = 0). It suffices to prove that if [ V ( a ) : F ] > 1 then L = Tx2xI+ Fa. So assume [ V ( a ) : F ] > 1. In the above notation if degq I degp, then one can solve for the coefficients of q in terms of the coefficients of p l , so by assumption there is q for which degq > degp,. But fixing q and performing the same argument on Ann‘(x,x,T + q(x,)x,T) we have L = Tx2xI + Fa unless there is some a’ in L for which the corresponding p’, has degp‘, > degq. Now again one has some q (x2)xlin V(a)for which degq‘ > degp‘,. I ‘ must contain m,=degp,+degq, m,=degp‘,+degq, m,=degp, +degq’, and m4=degp’,+ deg q’, and rn4 - m, = m2 - m,. By construction of I’ one has rn, = m3 and m, = m4, contradiction. 7. The tensor product of affine Noetherian PI-algebras over a field is affine Noetherian (and PI by theorem 6.4.19 or the easier exercise 6.4.4). (Hint: Let Ni = Nil(Ri) which are nilpotent, and let R = R, @ R, and N = N , @ R, + N, @ R,, a nilpotent ideal. Then each of the factors of the chain R > N > N 2 > ... is an f.g. RIN-module, so replacing Ri by Ri/Ni one may assume the Ri are semiprime. Then one may assume the Ri are prime. Pass to the “trace rings” and work there.) 8. (Amitsur-Small) There are only a countable number of Noetherian Q-affine PI-algebras. (Hint: There are only a countable number of semiprime ones, since these are embeddible. Thus fix T = R/N where N = NiI(R) and argue by induction on the index t of nilpotence of N. Letting W = R/N‘-’ one can embed R in
+
+ +
+
+ +
xi +
+
+.
where M is an f.g. R - W bimodule; applying induction to W it suf( 0 w) fices to prove there are a countable number of f.g. T - W bimodules, i.e., f.g. T @ WoP-modules. But T @ WDpis Noetherian (and countable).
Lewin’s Embedding 9. Write M(R; A, B ) for the universal RIA - RIB bimodule, cf., after remark 6.3.10.
This is unique up to isomorphism by “abstract nonsense,” and can be defined explicitly as the free birnodule with formal generators { 6 r : rE R f modulo the sub-bimodule generated by all b(c,r, +c,r,)-c,dr, -c&, and b(rlr2)-(brl)fzF,br, for r i in R. Consequently M(R; A, B) % RIA BRM(R;O,O) RIB. 10. (Bergman-Dicks 1751) Using exercise 9 show M(R; A, B) z R/A @ K @ RIB where K = ker(R OCR 4 R). (Hint: One may assume A = B = 0. Given any
Exercises
181
derivationd: R + Ndefine K + N b y x r i 0 ri e+& f r i ) r : = - z r , d r t , a bimodule map.) 11. Applying Tory(-,R/B) to 0 A + R R/A + 0 and comparing to ( 5 ) shows Tor,(R/A,R @,RIB) is an image of Torf(R/A,R/B). In view of digression 6.3.12 conclude that ker cp = AB whenever Tory(R/A, RIB) = 0. -+
-+
Kurosch’s Problem and the Trace Ring 12. Fast PI-solution to Kurosch’s problem (Small). By exercise 6.2.5 one may assume R is prime. Then Z(R) is affine algebraic so is a field, and thus R is simple. Conclude with corollary 6.3.2. 13. (Schelter) Suppose W is a given subring of R. We say r E R is integral ouer W of degree u if there are generalized W-monomials f . ( X , ) of degree i for 0 Ii < u such that r” fi(r).R is W-integral if each element of R is integral over W. Prove the more general version of theorem 6.3.23 where R is a centralizing W-integral extension of W. 14. (Schelter) If R = W { r , ,..., r t } is a prime centralizing extension of W then modifying construction 6.3.28 build a “trace ring” T ( R ) which is f.g. over WC‘. (Hint: Use exercise 13.) Thus R and T(R) have the common ideal RgJR), and T ( R ) inherits many of the properties of W via WC‘,including the analogue of theorem 6.3.3 1. 15. Notation as in construction 6.3.28, suppose A,, . . . , i fare commuting indeterminates over R and a , , . . . ,a, E R are arbitrary. Then each characteristic coefficient of = , aiAi (as an element of R[I,, . . . , i t ]can ) be expressed as a polynomial in I., ,...,I, and the characteristic coefficients of the ai. (Hint: This can be read off as a special case of Amitsur [80], but seems to have an easier proof in this special case by multiplying by any z in g,(R) and applying proposition 6.1.19 and the theory of elementary symmetric functions.) 16. If R is a domain and W E R then PI-deg(W) divides PI-deg(R). (Hint: Passing to ring of fractions of R one may assume R is a division ring; replacing W by Z(R)W one may assume W is a division ring. Take a maximal subfield E of W and a maximal subfield F of R containing E . Then PI-deg(R)/PI-deg(W) = [F:E][Z(W):Z(R)].) 17. The reduction of the Bergman-Small theorem t o T(R). Step I. It suffices to prove the weaker assertion
=IT:,’
c:
(*) n
-
m
=
kin,
where ki E N and ni = PI-deg(R/P,) for -P, E Spec(R).
(Hint: Take this such that the subsum over the maximal ideals P, is as large as possible. If there is some nonmaximal P, then taking a maximal ideal Qi 3 & and letting m‘=PI-deg(R/Q)= PI-deg(R/Q) where R = R / q , one has n i - r n ‘ = x k i n i so substitute back ni = rn’ + kin: to get a contradiction.) S t e p 11. Take P minimal with respect to PI-deg(R/Pf = m. Arguing inductively on n - rn one may assume PI-deg(R/Q) = n for all prime ideals Q c P. But then LOjP) holds from R to T(R) by theorem 5.3.31(i), so the passage to 7(R) can be made. 18. (Going Down) Suppose R is a prime PI-ring and is integral over an integral domain C E Z ( R ) , with C “normal” in the sense that C is integrally closed in
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
182
its field of fractions. If Po c P, in Spec(C) and P', E Spec(R) lies over PI then there is some Pb E Spec(R) lying over Po, with Pb c P',. (Hint, cf., Rowen [SOB, theorem 4.4.243: Let R, = { r E R:O # r + P', E Z(R/P',)} and S = C - Po, and let S , = { r s :r E R,,s E S J ,a submonoid of R. It is enough to show S , n PoR = 0. Otherwise, rs E PoR for some r in R,, s in S . The minimal m o n k p(1) for rs over C is irreducible by Gauss' lemma. O n the other hand, write rs = c a i r i for ai in Po and r, in R. C { r , ,..., rt] is f.g., so using the regular representation and taking determinants show rs satisfies a m o n k polynomial q(L) all of whose non-leading coefficients are in Po.Hence p I q by Gauss' lemma. Write p = id ciE.'. Passing to the domain = C/Po note is a power of 1,so ?j = Id and hence each ci E Po. Now pass to S - ' C , which is also normal. Id is the minimal polynomial of r; since r is integral over C each c i C d E C, and thus E Po. Thus rd E PoR c P', so r + P', is nilpotent, contradiction.) 19. (Gordon-Small) Every affine PI-algebra over a field has Gabriel dimension. (Hint: By 6.3.36' and 6.3.39 there are prime ideals P , , . . . ,P, with P, .. . P, = 0. Considering each Pi+,. . . . P, one may pass to R / e and assume R is prime. By induction on cl. K-dim one may assume G-dim RIL exists for every large left ideal L of R. Thus it suffices to show G-dim U exists for each cyclic uniform left ideal U. For any 0 # U' < U note U/U' is torsion so has the form R/L' for L' large, implying G-dim U / U ' exists; conclude G-dim U exists.
+ I::,'
c
+
P,/e..
Noetherian PI-rings (following Resco-Small-StaKord [82]) 20. If R is left Noetherian PI and P E Spec(R) has height > 1 then P contains
infinitely many height 1 primes. (Hint: Pass to T(R) using proposition 6.3.45. Thus R is integral over C. Localizing at P n C assume C is local. For each c E P n C there is a prime P(c) c P minimal over c and thus of height 1 by the principal ideal theorem. Hence P(c) n C # P n C, so by prime avoidance there are an infinite number of these P(c).) 21. If R is prime Noetherian Jacobson of PI-degree n then for every t S K-dimR there is P in Spec,(R) of height t. (Hint: Induction o n t; clear for t = 0,l. Using exercise 20 show (){height 1 primes contained in P) = 0. Thus there is Q in Spec,(R) of height 1 contained in P. Pass to RIQ.) 22. If R is prime Noetherian of PI-degree n and P E Spec,(R) then height P Ipd RIP. (Hint: Let S = Z(R) - P. Then S-'R is local so gl.dimS-'R = pd(S-'R/S-'P) pd, RIP. But height(P) = K-dim S-'R = gl. dim S-'R since S-'R is Azumaya.) 23. If R is prime Noetherian Jacobson PI of finite gl. dim then K-dim R 2 gl. dim R. (Hint: exercises 21 and 22.) Resco-Small-Stafford [82] extend this result to the case of an arbitrary semiprime Noetherian ring, by passing to R[1] and localizing at the monic polynomials. In the following exercises assume the Lorentz-Small theorem (c.f., digression 6.3.46(3)) and refer to assertions (ii)-(v) following it. 24. Prove (ii). (Hint: One needs only show ( 2 ) .Take P E Spec(R) with GK dim R =
GK dim RIP, and let R = R/P and 2 = Z(R/P). Then G K dim R so taking a transcendence base one can show ( 2 ) explicitly.
= tr d e g z / F
Exercises
183
25. Prove (iii). (Hint: Take P as in Lorenz-Small and note A, E P or A, z P.) 26. Prove (iv). Hint: ( < ) clear. ( 2 )By exercise 3.5.13 there are x,, ..., xr in M for which Ann M = Ann{xl,. . . ,x,}, so RIAnn M 4 @Rxi 5 M‘r’.) 27. Prove (v). (Hint: By (iv) assume M is faithful and G K d i m M = G K d i m R. Let A , = Ann N and A, = Ann M / N . Then A, A, = 0 so conclude by (iii), (iv).) 28. If R is Noetherian PI and the reduced rank p ( M ) = 0 then G K d i m M < G K dim R. (Hint: Noetherian induction and exercise 27, as with K dim.) 29. (Small-Stafford [81]) A prime Noetherian ring R having precisely two maximal P,,P2 such that P : = P I , n i E N P ;= 0, such that P2 is neither left nor right localizable but the completion of R at P, is Noetherian. (Moreover Z(R) is Noetherian.) As with several noncommutative affine counterexamples, this relies heavily on a famous example from commutative ring theory. Nagata found an example of a commutative ring H f.g. over a local ring C such that H has two maximal ideals M’ and M ” of respective heights 1 and 2, with M ’ n M” = Jac(C), cf., Zariski-Samuel [60B, p. 3271. Let M = Jac(C) = M ’ n M ” Q H. Let R =
{(f: !):
I
h E H, a E M , c E C, h E M ’ , and h - c E M ‘ . R is an order in M 2 ( H ) ,
for
(E E)
c R. Hence R is a prime. Also Z(R) z C is Noetherian, so R is
Noetherian. J =
M ’ is a quasi-invertible ideal of R, seen by taking deter(M M ) minants. Also RIJ z HIM is a direct product of two simple rings, by the Chinese Remainder Theorem. Hence J = Jac(R). Writing 1 = a’ + a” where a ’ € M ’ and a“ E M ” , let s =
Define Pl
=J
:( :).
+ sR and P2 =
(E’z).
Pl and P2 are distinct ideals properly
containing J ; conclude P I ,P2 are the unique maxima1 ideals of R and P, n Pz = J. To see P : = P , show P : z J ’ + ( s J + J s ) = J since M ’ + C a ” = H ; but s 2 € P : - J so J c P : implying P : = P I . O n the other hand, Pi = 0 since O M ’ ) ’ = 0 by Krull’s intersection theorem, and P, c M , ( M ’ ) . Let S = {elements regular modulo PI. Then s E S. Take x in M ‘ - a“M’. I f S were right Ore then there would be s in S for which (xe,,)s’ = sr’ for suitable r’ = (rij)and s = (sij). Now s E S requires s, 4 M and thus s,, is a unit (in C), but xs,, = sa”r,, E a ” M ’ , contradiction. This proves S is not right Ore, and similarly S is not left Ore. It remains to show the completion of R at P, is Noetherian. By exercise 3.5.14 it suffices to show there is an ideal A polycentral modulo A’, for which P : c A E P2, for then the completions of R at P, and at A are isomorphic. Take A =Pi RM and show A’ + RM = A by computation. 30. In the above notation if R’ = {(rij)E R: r 2 1 = 0} then P, n R’ is a prime ideal of R‘ the intersection of whose powers is 0, and is not right localizable, as above. However, P’ n R‘ is left localizable by direct computation. Note R‘ is f.g. as C‘-module. These examples have been extended further by Beachy-Blair [86], to provide pathelogical examples of completions of Noetherian PI-rings.
+
Rings with Polynomial Identities and Affine Algebras
184
w.4
w,
-X:)",XZI, -X:In-,,X,],[(X,-X:)n-3, X,],...,[ x,-x:, X2])is a nonspecial identity of ( M , ( F ) , * ) for any n, because the trace of any
1. S,-,"(X,
skew-symmetric matrix is 0.
2. (Nagata-Higman) Suppose R , is a Q-algebra without 1 satisfying the identity X;. Then R t = 0 for some m. The Nagata-Higman bound is m = 2" - 1; the Razmyslov
bound is rn = nz. (Hint for Nagata-Higman bound: Let f = XiX,X:-i-l, an identity of R , since ( r , ar2)"= 0 for all ri in R , and 01 in Q. But then o= f ( r , ,rri)r:-j- = nr: 'rr;- ' + Cnzir i r f ( r 2 ,r l - i - '1 so rI- 'rr;- = o and thus ARoA = 0 where A, is the ideal generated by { r " - ' : r E R ) . But R , / A is nilpotent of index 2"-' - 1 by induction.) 3. (Generic matrices with involution.) Let {[i,"': 1 5 i, j In} be a set of commuting indeterminates. Define ( F , { Y } , t ) to be the subring of M , ( F [ [ ] ) generated by the generic matrices % = and their transposes Y : = ([f').The transpose restricts to an involution (t) on ( F , { Y } ,t), which also is a prime ring. Show it is the relatively free ring with involution corresponding to I ( M , , ( F ) , t ) for any infinite field F. Perform a similar construction for the canonical symplectic involution when n is even. 4. (Easy special case of Regev's theorem) If R2 satisfies all identities of Mn(C[A]) and R, is a PI-algebra over C then R , BcR2is a PI-algebra. (Hint: One may replace R, by the algebra of generic matrices and thus by M,,(C[A]),so apply corollary 6.1.54.) 5. Prove Regev's lemma 6.4.18. (Hint: One wants to find suitable relatively prime t, in Z for which f ( X , , . . .,Xn)= tnXnl...X X n is an identity. Formally equations evaluate f ( r l l @ r 1 2 , . .. , r , , @ r,,,) and obtain a system of cn(ll)cn(12) in n! indeterminates.) 6. Given any permutation n in Sym(n), construct tables T,(n)=(tij)and T2(n)=(uij) as follows: t , = 1 and u, = n1. Inductively t l j is the smallest m (if there is one)
+
C,":
~~~~
([i,")
CIESyrn(,)
,
,
such that^,,^-, <m~nandnm>u,,~-,;thenu,~=nt,~.Whenitisimpossible
to continue on the first row start on the second row. Then a can be reconstructed uniquely from T,(n) and T,(n).Defining d(n) = number of rows in T,(n) prove d(n) is the largest number d for which there are 1 i, < ... < id 5 k such that xi, > ni, > ... > ni,. 7 . Prove c,(I) I(d - l)zk if I is a T-ideal containing a multilinear PI f of degree d. (Hint: Notation as in exercise 6 and preceding lemma 6.4.18. Let V; be the subspace of V, spanned by those X,,...X,, for which d(n) c d. Suppose there is n such that h = X,,...X,,$V ; 1,; choose n such that the word nl ...nk is minimal possible and obtain a contradiction by writing h = h,X,ilh2X,i,... hdXniahd+ with i , < i, < ... < id and ni, > xi, > ... > xidand applying f. Thus V ; + I* = V, so c,(l) is bounded by the number of tables T,(K) having < d rows. But n is determined by T,(n) and T2(n),each of which are functions { 1,. ..,k } + { 1,. .. ,d - l}, so there are most (d - l),' such tables.) 8. Multilinearize the Hamilton-Cayley polynomial for 2 x 2 generic matrices to get the 2 x 2 trace identity
+
,
Yl Y,
+ Y, V, - (tr Yl)Y2 - (tr Y,)Y1 + tr Y, tr Y, - tr( Y, Y2) = 0.
Exercises
185
9. Using exercise 8 and the Hamilton-Cayley polynomial show the ring of invariants Z' of 2 x 2 matrices (using two generic matrices) is generated by tr Y , , tr Y,, det Y,, det Y2, and tr( Y, Y2),and, furthermore, the trace ring is a free Z'-module with base {l,Yl,Y,,YIY,}. 10. Prove the Formanek-Schofield decomposition of the trace ring T of F, { Yl, Y,} as the free product C , C2 of C , and C 2 over C, where the notation is described in the text. (Hint: First note C , and C, generate T since one gets tr(Y,Y,) using exercise 8. Next let z = YlY2 + Y,Y, - (tr YJY2 - (tr Y,)Yl E Z(T) by exercise 8, and note C, C, = C [ z ] + C [ z ] Y , + C [ z ] Y , + C[z]Yl Y2 zz T by exercise 9. 11. (Kemer) If R is a Q-algebra satisfying a standard identity S, then R satisfies some Capelli identity C,. (Hint: Replacing n by n + 1 if necessary one may assume n is even. Define the associative algebra T by generators e l , ... ,en and x l , x z , .. . and relations eiwej = -ejwei for all i, j and all w in thus T is a generalization of the exterior algebra. Let M be the subspace of F { X } spanned by all C2,(X1,hl,...,Xr,hr) for hj in F { X } and let N be the subspace of T spanned by e,h,(x)e,h,(x)~~~ e,h,(x) where hj(x) denotes the evaluation of hj under the substitution Xi H xi. There is a vector space isomorphism @: M 3 N by @ C , , ( X , , h , , ...,X , , h , ) = e,h,(x)...e,h,(x). Let A be a T-ideal of F I X } , and write A ( T ) = { f ( T ) : f € A } . Then @ ( A n M ) = A ( T ) n N , for if f(X,, ..., X,,) is multilinear with f ( q ,h,(x),. . . ,e,, h,(x)) = w E N then w = (W1
K E
C
(sgn)f(e,,,h,(x), . . . , e , , ,h,(x))E@(AnM).
Syrn(r)
Consequently A contains the Capelli polynomial C,, iff A ( T ) contains all words in which the e, occur rn times, iff Te,T)"' c A ( T ) . Let 1. = {ei;..eiU:1 Ii, ,..., i, < n}. One needs to show that if 1, c A ( T ) then (I,T)" E A ( T ) for some rn. Thus it suffices to show for each k I n that TI,T is nilpotent modulo TIk+,T+ A ( T ) .Write n = 2 j and let f = ~neSym,j)XK1..-Xzj, the multilinearization of Xi.An easy manipulation in T shows
(XI=,
f ( a l w l , . . ., ajw j) aj+I E TI,, , T
+ A(T)
for all aiin I, and wi in
hence TIkT is nil of bounded index modulo TI,+ ,T exercise 2.)
+ A ( T ) , so one is done by
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
7
Central Simple Algebras
This chapter deals with the theory of (finite dimensional) central simple algebras and the Brauer group, in particular, with division algebras. There is some question among experts as to whether this theory belongs more properly to ring theory, field theory, cohomology theory, or algebraic K-theory. Accordingly we give an abbreviated account of classical parts of the subject readily found elsewhere; a very thorough treatment of the subject is to be found in the forthcoming book by Jacobson and Saltman, referred to in the sequel as JAC-SAL; certain key parts of this chapter (such as Brauer factor sets) draw on Jacobson’s notes for that book. There also has been growing interest in infinite dimensional division algebras, which we shall discuss briefly in 7.1.46ff.
$7.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras In this section we develop the tools for studying the basic structure theory of central simple algebras. Let us recall some of the properties already proved about central simple algebras. Any simple ringR can be viewed as an algebra over the field F = Z ( R ) , and we consider the case when [ R : F ] < co, in which case we say R is a central simple F-algebra. Then [R:F] = n 2 for some n which we
187
Central Simple Algebras
188
call the degree of R (cf., corollary 2.3.25), written deg(R). By Wedderburn’s theorem we can write R = M,(D) for a division algebra D and suitable f. Note that D % End, D(‘)from which we see by means of proposition 2.1.15 that D is unique up isomorphism, and t is uniquely determined since D has IBN. In particular, deg D is a uniquely determined integer ( = n/t) called the index of R and is a very important invariant of R. We call D the underlying division algebra of R. A central simple division algebra is called a central division algebra, for short.
Centralizers and Splitting Fields We start off with some fundamental structural theorems describing R in terms of its subalgebras. If R is a central simple F-algebra and R‘ is a finite dimensional simple F-algebra with center F’ then by corollary 1.7.24 and theorem 1.7.27 R @,R’ is a central simple F’-algebra, whose dimension over F‘ is clearly [R: F][R’:F’]. In particular, theorem 2.3.27 says R @F RoP z M,z(F) % End, R. This result has an immediate consequence. Recall CR(A)denotes the centralizer of A in R.
Proposition 7.1.1:
Suppose A is a central simple F-subalgebra of R.
(i) R % A 0, C,(A); in particular, deg(A) I deg(R). (ii) If A’ centralizes A with [ A ’ : FICA: F] 2 [R: F] then R z A 0 A‘ and A’ = CR(A). Proof: (i) Let m = [A: F]. Then AoPOFR is central simple and contains AoPg F A % M,(F), and thus has a set of m x m matric units, implying by proposition 1.1.3 there is an F-algebra R, for which A o p @ R % M,,,(R,) % M,(F) @,R1 z AoP @ A @ R,. By corollary 1.7.29 we see R and A R, are each the centralizer of AoP@ 1 in AoP@ R; hence R z A @ R,; implying R, z C,(A) by corollary 1.7.29 again. Thus R % A @, C,(A) and SO deg R = (deg A)(deg C,(A)). (ii) R z A @ C,(A) and A‘ E C,(A); counting dimensions shows A’ = CR(A). Q.E.D. Of course the isomorphism R @ RoPx End, R pertains to the theory of separable subalgebras, which would permit an even faster proof of proposition 7.1.1. We turn now to the key fact that every maximal commutative
87.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
189
separable subalgebra K of R splits R and [ K :F ] = deg(R). There are several ways of approaching this result: (i) the generalized density theorem (exercise 2.4.l), as utilized in Jacobson [80B, theorem 4.81; (ii) basic properties of tensor products, cf., exercise 4; (iii) properties of separable algebras, which we present here, following Knus-Ojanguren [74B]. Remark 7.1.2: Suppose T is any ring containing R. Viewing T as R - R bimodule we have T % R@,C,(R), by theorem 5.3.24(iii)and remark 5.3.24'. If T c R e = R @ RoP then identifying R with R @ 1 yields T = R @ C,(R). Proposition 7.1.3: CR(K)OFRoP End, R for any subalgebra K of R. Proof: Let T be the centralizer of K Q 1 in Re % End, R ; thus T % End, R. Let R ' = CT(l @ RoP).Then T % R' @ RoP by the opposite of remark 7.1.2. It remains to show R' = CR(K)0 1. ( 2 )holds by inspection. On the other hand, corollary 1.7.29 yields R @ 1 = CRc(l@ RoP)2 R'; since R' E T we have R' c C R ( K )@ I . Q.E.D.
Corollary 7.1.4: I f K is a subjield of R then CR(K) is a central simple K-algebra of degree n / [ K : F ] ,where n = degR. Proof: C R ( K ) is simple since End,(R) is simple, and likewise Z(CR(K)) = K . Finally if m = degCR(K) then m 2 n 2 [ K : F ]= [CR(K)@FRoP:F]= [End, R : F ] = [ R : K ] 2 [ K : F ] = n 4 / [ K : F ] implying , m = n / [ K : F ] . Q.E.D.
Corollary 7.1.5: lf a given maximal commutative subalgebra K of R is a jield then K splits R and [ K : F ] = deg R = [R: K]. Proof: CR(K) = K by remark 0.0.6, so K splits RoP, and thus K O P = K splits R. Furthermore 1 =degC,(K)=n/[K:F], so [ K : F ]= n and [ R : K ]= [ R : F ] / [ K : F ]= n2/n = n. Q.E.D. What if K is not a field? If K is separable over F we have essentially the same outcome, cf., exercise I . However if K is not separable one may have [ K : F ] > degR. Example 7.1.6: Let R = End, V % M,(F) where [ V : F ] = n, and let V' be any subspace of V having dimension [n/2] over F. Taking a complement V" of V ' we define N = {f E R : f V '
5
V" and f V '
= 0)
Central Simple Algebras
190
-
Then N 2 = 0 so F 1 + N is a commutative subalgebra of R whose dimension is 1 [n/2](n- [ n / 2 ] )= 1 [ n 2 / 4 ] .Schur proved this is indeed the maximal possible dimension, and Gustafson [76] found an elegant structuretheoretic proof which we give in exercise 3.
+
+
Of course it may be impossible to find a maximal commutative subring which is a field; if R = M 2 ( @ )then R has no subfields properly containing C. However, we can bypass this difficulty by passing to the underlying division algebra D, for we have Remark 7.1.7: Any commutative subalgebra of a central division algebra D is a field, by remark 2.3.23(ii); consequently, if K is a maximal subfield of D then C J K ) = K and K splits D. Remark 7.1.8: Any splitting field of the underlying division algebra of R splits R (for if DOFK%A4,(K) then M , ( D ) O , K % M , ( F ) @ D O K ~ M , , ( K ) ) . Our final result about centralizers is Theorem 7.1.9: of R then
(Double centralizer theorem) If A is any simple subalgebra
(i) C R ( A )is simple and Z(A)-central; (ii) C,(C,(A)) = A ; (iii) [ A : F ] [ C R ( A )F: ] = [ R : F ] . Proof: (i) Let n = deg(R), K = Z ( A ) , and t = [ K : F ] . Let S = C,(K), which is simple and K-central of degree n/t by corollary 7.1.4. Clearly A c S so S % A @,Cs(A) by proposition 7.1.1, implying C J A ) is simple and Z ( C J A ) ) = K . But C R ( A )c C , ( K ) = S SO C s ( A ) = CR(A)proving (i). (ii) First assume K = F. Write A‘ = C,(A). Then R z A @ A ’ so A = C,(A’) by proposition 7.1.l(ii). In general note CR(A’)c_ CR(K) = S and A‘ = C J A ) 5 S SO CR(A’)= Cs(A’) = Cs(Cs(A))= A as just shown. (iii) (nlt)’ = [ S : K ] = [ A : K ] [ A ’ : K ]= [ A : F ] [ A ’ : F ] / t 2 . Q.E.D.
Another key tool was presaged in corollary 2.9.2: Theorem 7.1.10: (Skolem-Noether theorem) Any isomorphism of simple Falgebras of R can be extended to an inner automorphisrn of R.
$7.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
191
The proof, which can be found in any standard reference such as Jacobson [80B, p. 2223, is sketched in exercise 5. Digression 7.2.20‘: Chase [84] proves in fact that any isomorphism of separable, maximal commutative subalgebras of R can be extended to an inner automorphism. The proof involves a modification of the argument of exercise 5, using invertible projective modules. One useful consequence of the Skolem-Noether theorem is
Theorem 7.1.1 1: (Wedderburn’s theorem) Every finite simple ring R has the form M,(F) for a suitable field F. Proof: It suffices to show every finite division ringD is a field, since we could take D to be the underlying division ring of R. Let K be a maximal subfield of D and assume I K l = m < IDI. The number of subgroups of D - (0) (as multiplicative group) conjugate to K - (0) is at most ID - {O}l/lK- {O}l= (101- l)/(m - 1). But each subgroup contains the element 1 so the number of conjugates of elements of K - ( 0 ) is at most (m - 2)(10( - l)/(m - 1) + 1 < ID]- 1, so some element d of D is not conjugate to any element of K . Let F = Z ( D ) , and let K ’ be a maximal subfield of D containing F [ d ] . Then lK’1 = IFIrK’:F1 = IFldegD = IFIIK:F1 = lKl so K ‘ % K since finite fields of the same order are isomorphic. Hence K ’ - {0} and K - (0) are conjugate by the Skolem-Noether theorem, contrary to choice of d . Q.E.D. This theorem reduces the structure theory of central simple F-algebras to the case F is infinite. This enables us to bring in the Zariski topology and to prove the following important result which ties up some loose ends in our previous discussion. Theorem 7.1.12: Suppose deg(R) = n and F is infinite then {a E R: F [ a ] is separable of dimension n over F } is dense in the Zariski topology.
Proof: Take a splitting field K of R. The generic reduced characteristic polynomials of R and R OFK z M,,(K)are formally the same (since we use the same base); let us call them both m,. But M,,(K)has elements of degree n, so n is the degree of m,. It follows from proposition 2.3.35 that (eIements of degree n} is a Zariski open subset of R. For these elements the minimal and reduced characteristic polynomials are the same.
Central Simple Algebras
192
On the other hand, F(r) is a separable extension of R iff the roots r I , . . . ,r, of the minimal polynomial are distinct, iff the discriminant
n
1 si<jst
(ri - rj)2 z 0.
There is a way of calculating the discriminant from the minimal polynomial (cf., Jacobson [MB, p. 2581. Since M J K ) has elements of degree n of discriminant # 0, we see the discriminant of the generic element is nonzero. Hence {r E R: discriminant(r) # 0} is Zariski open and nonempty and thus dense. Thus {r E R: F(r) is separable of degree n} = {r E R: discriminant(r) #
is Zariski dense, as desired.
0) n {r E R: r has degree n)
Q.E.D.
Corollary 7.1.12' (Koethe's theorem): Suppose K is a subfield of a central division algebra D and is separable over F. Then K is a subfield of a maximal subJield of D separable over F.
Proof: K is infinite by Wedderburn's theorem, so the division algebra C,(K) has a maximal subfield L separable over F, by theorem 7.1.1 1. Clearly L is separable over F and [ L : F ]= [ L : K ] [ K : F ]=(deg C , ( K ) ) [ K : F ]=deg D by corollary 7.1.4. Q.E.D. Note: The proof relied on the fact every central division algebra D contains a separable field extension of F. Another proof was already given in exercise 2.5.10. A very quick proof due to Serre runs as follows: Otherwise F(d) is purely inseparable over F for all d in D so d" E F for n = deg D. But then X" is a central polynomial of D,and thus of M,(F) (seen by splitting D), which is absurd.
We shall also need criteria for R to be split. Lemma 7.1.13: Suppose deg(R) = n.
(i) R is split if R has n orthogonal idempotents. (ii) If there is some r E R whose minimal polynomial over F splits into n distinct linear factors, then F[r] % F(") and R is split.
97.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
193
Proof: (i) R is a direct sum of n left ideals; writing R = M , ( D ) we see t 2 n, so t = n and thus D = F (ii) F [ r ] z F [ A ] / ( f ( A ) ) = F by the Chinese Remainder Theorem; Q.E.D. hence we can apply (i).
fly=
Examples of Central Simple Algebras The first known noncommutative division algebra was Hamilton's quaternians W = aB @ Ri @ Rj @ Rk where multiplication is given by i' = j' = k 2 = - 1 and i j = - j i = k. W is 4-dimensional over R and is a ring because we can identify
(" '),
W as the subalgebra of M,(C) spanned by
(p b)
(;
and (where i is in C),which take on the respective 0 roles of i, j , and k ; W is a division ring since every nonzero element is invertible by means of the "norm" formula -1
(al
+ a2i + a,j + a4k)(al - a2i - u 3 j - a4k) = a: + a: + ui + u:
E R+
for a,, . . . ,a4 in R. Note deg W = 2, and C = R @ R i is a maximal subfield of w. Inspired by this example we say R is a quaternion algebra if R is central simple of degree 2. Quaternion algebras are often studied in the context of the theory of quadratic forms, cf., exercises 1.9.9ff. Quaternions were later generalized to the cyclic algebras ( K , (i, a) of example 1.6.28, for any field K with automorphism (i of order n, and any a in F = K". We recall ( K , 0,a) is formally Kz', satisfying the multiplication rules ~~~~
.
U,Z'U'Z'
.
=
(a10'u,)z'+j
if
(aa,o'a,)z'+J-"
if
i+jn
for a l , a 2 in K . We shall see that this very simple construction can be obtained under quite general circumstances. Under this definition M 2 ( @ )would not be cyclic because it has no maximal subfields! To resolve this difficulty we could study maximal commutative separable subalgebras in place of maximal subfields, and we shall carry out this idea below. However, it is easier (and customary) to pass Nore:
Central Simple Algebras
194
instead to the underlying division algebra, since each of its commutative subalgebras is a subfield.
Remark 7.2.14: By definition the cyclic algebra R = ( K , a,a) contains (i) a cyclic field extension K of F of degree n, and (ii) an element z $ F for which Z" E F. Perhaps surprisingly, it turns out that (i) already ensures R is cyclic, and (ii) by itself ensures R is cyclic when n is prime. The first of these results is easy and will be given now; the second is a theorem of Albert, cf., [JAC-SAL, theorem 2.193. (Note (ii) implies (i) if F contains a primitive n-th root [ of 1; the proof of Albert's theorem in characteristic # n entails adjoining [ and then applying field theory to pass back. When char(F) = n the proof is easy, cf., exercise 8.) Proposition 7.1.15: If R is central simple and has a maximal subfield cyclic over F then R is cyclic.
Proof: Let Gal(K/F) = (c). By the Skolem-Noether theorem there is z in R for which zaz-' = aa for all a in K . Let a = z" where n = [ K :F ] . Then aaa-' = a"a = a so a E C , ( K ) = K ; in fact, a E F since aa = Z Z " Z - = r" =a. We claim R z (K,a,a). Indeed, there is a homomorphism from the skew polynomial ring K [E.;.] + R given by A H z; the kernel contains A" - a so we get a homomorphism (K, a, a) + R which is an injection since ( K ,u,a) is Q.E.D. simple. But [ R : F ] = [ K : F ] ' = n2 = [(K,a,a):F ] so (K,a,a)= R. Corollary 7.1.15': Every quaternion algebra is cyclic (by Koethe's theorem, since every separable quadratic j e l d extension is cyclic).
Symb01s The cyclic algebra R = ( K , a,a) has a better form when F has a primitive n-th root [ = 5, of 1. Indeed, then K = F ( y ) for some y such that p = y" E F, and taking z for which zyz-' = ay = [y we see multiplication in R is now given by the exceedingly simple rules
y" = a,
z"=
/3,
and
zy
= [yz
(0)
Definition 7.1.16: The symbol (a,p), denotes the cyclic algebra described
57.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
195
-
by the equations (0), where r,P E F - {O). Write (a,& 1 if (a,@,, is split. (Strictly speaking, the definition depends on the specific choice of [, but we shall not worry about this matter.) Every quaternion algebra of characteristic # 2 is a symbol by corollary 7.1.15', since - 1 E F. When char(F) = n clearly F cannot have a primitive n-th root of 1, but in this case there is also a version of the symbol, cf., exercise 8. However, we shall assume char(F) is prime to n. Jumping the gun a bit, let us say two central simple algebras R , and R , are similar, written R , R , , if their underlying division algebras are isomorphic. If F has "enough" roots of 1 then the very deep Merkurjev-Suslin theorem says any central simple F-algebra is similar to a tensor product of symbols; thus symbols are the building blocks of the theory, and we would like to see just how easily we can compute with them. To start off, given y , z as in (0)let us compute ( y + z)". Certainly we can write ( y z)" = ~ ~ = , f ; : . , ( y , zwhere ) the .(,. are polynomials in y and z, homogeneous of degree i in y and degree (n - i ) in z. We shall show h,"= 0 whenever 1 I i < n. Indeed let us write a typical monomial of fi,n as u1 .. . u,, where i of the ui are y and n - i of the vi are z. Then u,ul " ' u , , - ~ is also a monomial of A,, and u , , u l ~ ~ ~ u=, [~' u, 1 . . . u , , . (Indeed if u, = z then in moving z to the right we must pass over y i times, each time replacing z y by [ y z and thereby multiplying altogether by ['; if instead u, = y then we replace y z by [ - ' z y a total of (n - i ) times, thereby multiplying altogether by = Ci.) Continuing the process shows
-
+
(c-')'-i U1"'U"
+ U " U ~ " ' U , ~ I +"'+u2"'U,uI
= ( 1 + [ ' + ~ ~ ~ + [ ' " - ' ' ' ) u , ~ ~=~ ou "
so partitioning fi,, in this manner shows J," is a sum of zeroes and is thus O! (This lovely argument of G. Bergman was communicated by P. M. Cohn.) Consequently we have ( y + z)" Proposition 7.1.17:
= y"
+ z" = M + p.
(Basic properties of symbols):
-
(i) (a,P),, 1 if there is r in (a,& such that r" is an n-th power in F and 1, r, . . . ,r"- are independent. (ii) If M is a norm of the extension F( b"") ouer F then ( M , & 1. In particular (l,fl),, 1 (iii) [f c( /3 is an n-th power in F then (a,/&, 1 (iv) ( M , 1 - u)" 1
-
+
-
(v) (a,B ) n 0 (a, Y ) n
-
-
(a, B r ) n
-
Central Simple Algebras
196
Proofi
(i) The minimal polynomial of r is I" - y" where 7" = r", so we are done by lemma 7. I. 13(ii). (ii) Special case of (i) for if a = N ( a ) then (a-'z)"=N(a)-'z"=a-'a= 1 = 1". (iii) Take y,z as in (0). As computed above ( y + z)" = a + fi is an n-th power in F so we are done by (i). (iv) a + (1 - a ) = 1, so done by (iii). (v) Take y , z in (a,& satisfying (0), and take y',z' in (a,?), satisfying z'y' = (y'z' and ( y ' ) " = a and (z')" = y. Working in R = (a,B). 0 (a,y), let R , be the subalgebra generated by y Q 1 and z 0 z', and R , be the subalgebra generated by y-' Q y' and 1 Q z'. Visibly R , and R , centralize each 1, so R = R , 0 R , by propoother, and R , z (a,/??) and R , z (I,?),, sition 7.1.1. (v') As in (v). (vi) Taking y,z as in (0) where p = - a we have (yz-')" = [-n'n+l)yn~-" = -(-n(n+1)i2 = ( - I)" as seen by considering n even and n odd separately. Hence (a, - a ) is split by (i). (vii) If y , z are as in (0) then yz-' = ( z - ' y so we could replace y, z, respectively, by z - ' , y which yield (p-',a),. (viii) Take y , z in (a,B), as in (0), and y', z' such that (y')"' = p, (z')"' = a*, and z'y' = Cnty'z'. Then R = (a,p), 0 (B, has the centralizing subalgebras R, generated by y-' Q z' and 1 Q y', and R , generated by y Q 1 and z-l Q (2')'. Then R , (l,P),,, and R , ( a - ' , I), so R z R , 0 R, is split. The Q.E.D. second assertion follows from (vii).
-
-
Certain of these properties follow formally from others, e.g., the reader might try deriving (vii) from (v), (v'), and (vi). This becomes significant in the K,-theory in $7.2. In fact the converse of (ii) also holds. For convenience we assume F(p"") is a field, although this assumption could be removed if we apply digression 7.1.10' in the proof below instead of the Skolem-Noether theorem. Proposition 7.1.18: (Suppose F(B"") is a field.) (a,p), is split iff a is a norm from F(B'/") to F. (Thisis called Wedderburn's criterion.)
g7.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
--
197
Proof: (e) is (ii) above. (*) Let R = ( L X , ~By ) “ . assumption R 1 (1,8),,, so in addition to elements y , z satisfying (0)we also have y’, 2’ in R satisfying ( y ’ ) “ = 1, (z’)” = 8, and z’y’ = ly’z’. But F(z’) and F ( z ) are each isomorphic to F(/3”“) so by the Skolem-Noether theorem we may apply a suitable inner automorphism of R and assume z’ = z . Now let x = y’y-’ E C,(z) = F(z). Then 1 = ( y ’ ) “= (xy)” = N ( x ) y “ = N(x)cc so LX = N ( x - ’ ) as desired. Q.E.D.
Overview of the Theory of Central Simple Algebras In view of major recent advances by Merkurjev and Suslin the theory of central simple algebras can now be presented in a remarkably clear picture. Let us sketch the picture here and spend the rest of the chapter in elaborating the sketch. The underlying idea is to describe central simple algebras in terms of cyclic algebras. Using “generic” methods one can readily construct a central division algebra which is not cyclic (cf., after remark 7.1.20), leading to the question of whether central division algebras need have maximal subfields Galois over the center. This also has a counterexample, which we shall present shortly. These examples lead us back to matrices over a division algebra, for perhaps some M,(D) will be cyclic even when D is not. Accordingly we define Br(F) as {similarity classes of central simple F-algebras}, where we recall R , R , if they have isomorphic underlying division algebras. Br(F) has multiplication given by [ R , ] [ R , ] = [ R , 0R , ] , and is a group since [ R o p ]= [ R ] - ’ by theorem 2.3.27. Thus [ M J F ) ] = [ F ] = 1 in Br(F). Br(F) is called the Brauer group. The Brauer group turns out to be torsion, i.e., for every [ R ] in Br(F) there is m such that [ R ] “ = 1 or, equivalently, R@’” 1; m is called the exponent of R . If D is a division algebra of degree n then m 1 n and, furthermore, every prime factor of n divides m. Conversely, if m and n satisfy these two requirements then Brauer constructed a cyclic division algebra D of degree n and exponent m to be studied in $7.3. A fundamental property asked of division algebras is decomposability. Namely, if deg(D) = n = n , n , , are there division subalgebras D,of respective degree n, # 1 for which D z D,0D,? If n, and n , are relatively prime the answer is, “Yes,” and we thereby can reduce the theory to the case where n is a power of a prime number p . But now if D z D,0D, and each n, # 1 then n, divides n / p and thus m divides n l p . Hence any decomposable division algebra of degree n must have exponent < n. In fact there are indecomposable division algebras of exponent p and degree p 2 for every odd prime p ; for
-
-
198
Central Simple Algebras
exponent 2 there are indecomposable division algebras of degree 8, but every division algebra of degree 4 and exponent 2 is decomposable. Instead of asking for a division algebra itself to be indecomposable we might instead ask whether it can be decomposed in the Brauer group. This leads us to
Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem: If F has a primitive m-th root [ of 1 then every division algebra of exponent m is similar to a tensor product of cyclic algebras of degree m. ( I t follows that Br(F) is a division torsion abelian group when F has “enough” roots of 1.) Thus M , ( D ) is decomposable as a tensor product of cyclics for suitable t. When deg(D) = p for p = 3 then D is already cyclic; for larger primes p this is unknown, but t I ( p - 1)!/2. Many of the basic results of Br(F) are proved here by means of “Brauer factor sets,” which also serve to identify Br(F) with a certain second cohomology group.
The First Generic Constructions There are two main ways of building and studying central simple algebras. The more classical method is the “arithmetic method” using tools of algebraic number theory such as local field theory. The second method is the “generic method,” which is to attach indeterminates to key quantities and then study leading coefficients of polynomials. Both methods are of the utmost importance. In the text we shall focus on the generic method, which gives quick results. The arithmetic method will be discussed a11 too briefly in Appendix A. The usual way of employing the generic method is to build first a domain of PI-degree n resembling a skew polynomial ring and the passing to the ring of fractions, as illustrated in the following basic example. Example 7.1.19: Let A,,& be commuting indeterminates over a field F, which contains a primitive n-th root ( of 1. Then the symbol D = (i1,A2)n is a division algebra, where F = Fo(Al,i,Indeed, ). let D = ~ ~Fy’z’ ,where~ y” = l , l , ~=nI,, and zyz-’ = [ y . Letting C = F,,[y] a polynomial ring in y one sees easily that D is the ring of central fractions of the skew polynomial ringC[z;a] where o is given on C by o(crxiyi)= c[’rxiy’. But C[z;a] is a domain by proposition 1.6.15 so D is a division algebra by the following observation:
~
o
199
87.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
Remark 7.1.20: If a central simple algebra D is the ring of central fractions of a domain then D is a division algebra. (Indeed, obviously D is a domain, but then D cannot have any nontrivial idempotent so the Wedderburn-Artin theorem says D must be its own underlying division ring.)
Generic methods enable one to readily produce the noncyclic algebra ( I L l , I L 2 ) m0(IL3,&),, of degree mn over the rational fraction field F = F&, I.,, 1,, Ad); this is a special case of theorem 7.1.29(ii).
Digression 7.2.21: (Tignol) Let us modify this example by taking F to be the field of Laurent series in I.,,... ,A4 over F,. Amitsur showed D = (4,i2),,, 0(Ib3,&)" is a noncyclic division ring, cf., Jacobson [75B, p. 1023. But Tignol-Amitsur [84] implies D cannot have a cyclic splitting field, for this would have a subfield isomorphic to a subfield of D (since F is Henselian), contrary to D not cyclic. Thus D is not similar to a cyclic algebra. Historically (in view of Koethe's theorem), the next question was whether any central simple algebra has a maximal subfield Galois over the center; such an algebra is called a crossed product. This has a negative answer, but first we look for a sufficiently general counterexample. We can find a clue by tidying up a loose end from the Artin-Procesi theorem. Proposition 7.1.22: Suppose deg R = n. Then there are elements a, b , ,. . . ,b, in R for which { a i - bj: 1 5 i, j 5 n } are a base for R over F.
Proof: Case 1. R is split, i.e., R = M,(F). Taking bi = e,, and a e i . i + ,we see a" = 1 and each eij = a'-'bj.
= en,
+
Case 11. R is not split. In particular, F is infinite by theorem 7.1.1 1. We shall translate the assertion to one on PI'S. We want to show the a i - 'bj are independent, so, in other words, the Capelli polynomial evaluation C 2 , ( h , , a h , ,... , a " - ' b , , b 2 ., . . , a " - ' b , , , r , , .. . , r l ) # 0
for suitable r , , . ..,r, in R where t
= n2. This means
we want to show
c 2 , ( x * , x ~ x , , . . . ,l xX ,;,-X , ,..., x n1- 1 Xn+
1,
XI + 1 9 ... ,X21)
is a nonidentity of R, or, equivalent, by corollary 6.1.45 that this is a nonQ.E.D. identity of M,,(F). But this is clear by case I and corollary 6.1.45. We shall now introduce the "most general" division algebra of degree n. Let F,{ Y) denote the F-algebra of generic n x n matrices Y , , Y,,.. .. By
Central Simple Algebras
200
proposition 6.1.41 F , { Y ) is prime of PI-degree n, so its algebra of central fractions is a simple algebra which we denote as UD(F,n). UD(F,n) is central simple of degree n over its center, whatever that may be, but even without knowing the center we can study UD(F,n)effectively by means of PI-theory.
Proposition 7.1.23: Fn{ Y } satisfies the same identities as any division F algebra of degree n (ouer its center). Pvoofi Let D be a division F-algebra and Fl = Z ( D ) 2 F. Then Fl is infinite by theorem 7.1.1 1, so by corollary 6.1.46’, D satisfies the same identiQ.E.D. ties as F,{ Y ) . Theorem 7.1.24:
UD(F,n) i s a division algebra of degree n.
Pvoofi Otherwise, by the Wedderburn-Artin theorem, UD(F,n) would have some matric unit e , z ; “clearing denominators” we would have f(Yl,. . ., Y,) # 0 in F,{ Y ) for which f 2 = 0. In other words, f(X,,. . . , X , ) is not an identity of Fn{Y } but f’ is an identity, cf., proposition 6.1.42; transferring this information to any F-division algebra D of degree n (say example 7.1.19) we would have d , , . . .,d, in D for which f ( d , , . . .,d,) # 0 but f ( d , , . . .,d,)’ = 0, an absurdity. Q.E.D. Corollary 7.1.25: The product of nonidentities of Fn{Y } is a nonidentity.
Pvoofi f (Yl,. . . , Y,) # 0 iff f(X,, . . .,X,) is a nonidentity, so apply theorem 7. I .24 which says F,{ Y } is a domain. Q.E.D. We can push this idea still further. Corollary 7.1.26: Suppose f i ( Y, ,. .. , Ym)gi(Y,, . . ., Y ; ’ ) are nonzero elements of UD(F,n) for 1 i 5 t with gi central. Then for any simple F-algebra R of degree n there are r l , . . .,rrn in R for which fi(r,, . . . ,rm)gi(rl,.. . ,r,)-’ #O for 1 I i I r. (Indeed, let f = fl(X,,. . . ,X,)...f,(X,, . . .,X,)gl(Xl,. . . , X , , , ) . - gr(X1,...,X,). Each f i and g i i s not an identity of UD(F,n) so f is a nonidentity of Fn{Y } and thus of R, i.e., there are r l , . . . ,rm in R for which f ( r l ,...,r,)#O. Hence each J ( r l ,..., r,)#O and gi(rl,...,r,) #O so L ( r l,...,rm)gi(rl,...,r J 1 # 0, noting gi(r,, . ..,r,) E Z ( R )and is thus inuertibfe.
This result is applied by encoding structural information into elements.
57.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
20 1
Comparison Lemma 7.1.27: Suppose UD(F, n) has a subjield K Galois over Z(UD(F,n))with Galois group G. Then every division F-algebra D of degree n has a subjield Galois over Z ( D )with Galois group G.
The proof is a rather routine translation of information about UD(F,n) into identities and nonidentities, by means of “clearing denominators” and passing to F,{ Y } ,cf., Rowen [80B, proposition 3.2.101. Having the comparison lemma in our hands we need something to compare. Namely, we want different examples of division algebras whose maximal subfields do not have a common Galois group. This is not difficult if we are willing to manipulate indeterminates; we shall set up the example here and send the reader to Rowen [80B, pp. 189-1911 for the straightforward computational details verifying 7.1.28 and 7.1.29. Example 7.1.28: Suppose C is an integral domain with commuting automorphisms a,, . . . ,a,. Define inductively To = Fo and T = &- [ & ; ak] where a k is extended to an automorphism of T - by the rule OkAj = i.j for all j < k. Then 7; is a domain, and each 0, extends naturally to an automorphism of 7; satisfying CkiLj = l j for all j # k . Theorem 7.1.29: Given n l , ..., n, in N let F, be a jield having a primitive on the commutative polynomial n-th root [ of 1, where n = n , . . ‘ n , . DeJne = jnlnkpk.Building 7; ring C = F o [ p , , . . . ,p,] by akpj = p j for j # k and as in example 7.1.28, let D be the ring of central fractions of 7;.
(i) D is a division algebra of degree n with center F = F o ( p ! ’ ,. . .,p?, A;’,. . . ,Ayt). Furthermore, D has a maximal subfield K = F o ( p l , . . . ,p,,A;’,. . . ,Ayt) and K is Galois over F with Galois group G = (al) x ... x (a,). (ii) Suppose L is an arbitrary subjield of D Galois over F. Then Gal(L/F) is abelian of exponent dividing the least common multiple of n,, . . . ,n,. (iii) On the other hand, if t = 1 and L is Galois over F then Gal(L/F) does not have a subgroup isomorphic to H, x H, x Z,.
Applying the comparison lemma to theorem 7.1.29 gives the following surprising result: Theorem 7.1.30: (Amitsur) Suppose n is divisible by p 3 and p%char(F). Then UD(F, n) does not have a subfeld Galois over Z(UD(F, n)) of dimension p 3 ; in particular, UD(F, n) does not have a maximal subfeld Galois over the center.
202
Central Simple Algebras
Proof;. If UD(F,n) had a subfield Galois over the center with Galois group G of order p 3 then G is abelian of exponent p by theorem 7.1.29(ii) applied to lemma 7.1.27 (taking n, = n, = ... = p ) ; but then G z Z, x Z, x Z,, which is impossible by theorem 7.1.29(iii) (taking n, = n) applied to lemma 7.1.27. Q.E.D. A direct non-crossed product construction has been found recently by Jacob-Wadswort h [861. Note that these counterexamples all have composite degree, leaving open
Question 7.1.31: (The major open question in division algebras) (i) Is every division algebra of prime degree cyclic? (ii) Failing this, is it similar to a cyclic algebra?
Brauer Factor Sets So far we know by Koethe’s theorem that every finite dimensional division algebra D has a maximal subfield separable over the center, but there may fail to be maximal subfields Galois over the center. This leads us to try to describe the structure of an arbitrary central simple algebra R in terms of a maximal separable subfield, but this is complicated by the fact that the maximal subfields might have the “wrong” dimension, e.g., R = M,,(C), where C = Z ( R ) is a maximal subfield! However R always has a suitable commutative separable subring, and we recapture R using Brauer factor sets. Brauer’s construction, treated in van der Waerden [48B], had been overshadowed by Noether’s “crossed product construction” for the case K a Galois field extension of F, but has enjoyed a renaissance, largely because of the excellent exposition in Jacobson [83], which is the basis of our treatment here. We start with a given central simple algebra R = M , ( D ) ,of degree n; thus deg D = njt. By Koethe’s theorem D has a maximal separable subfield K O , and we take K
= K!’
R (viewing K as
c
R ) . Note [ K : F ] = n.
Let E be the normal closure of K O over F. Since K O splits R we can view
R c R OFK O % M n ( K o )G M,,(E). A Zariski topology argument analogous to theorem 7.1.12 shows {a E K o : K o = F ( a ) } is dense in K O . Thus { u E K : K = F(a)} is dense in K , so K = F(a) for some a in K , and the conjugates of a under G are therefore dis-
tinct. Furthermore, K OFK O is a direct product of fields, cf., lemma 7.1.13(ii), so a is diagonalizable in M J E ) by standard arguments from linear algebra.
203
57.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
Proposition 7.1.32:
{ r E R:r
=
K r K } is Zariski dense in R.
Proof: Let E = {a'rau:O 5 u,zl 2 n - 1). K r K = R iff B spans R ; iff B is linearly independent, since B has n z elements. Writing B = { b l , . . . ,b,} where t = nz we see B is independent iff the Capelli polynomial evaluation C,,(b,, .. ., b r , r l , . . , r l ) # 0 for suitable ri in R by remark 6.1.16'. But this is clearly a Zariski-open condition, so passing to R 0 E x M,,(E) we may assume by remark 6.1.23' that a is diagonal with distinct entries. Thus the proposition has been reduced to the following assertion:
Claim 7.1.32': If R = M,,(F) und a is diagonal with distinct entries a , , . . . ,an then there is r E R such that R = Fa'ra'.
x:,:,:,,
Proof of Claim: Take r = x e i j , i.e., each entry of r is 1. Then a u r a u = ( a ~ a ~ ) , so we want to show for any matrix y in R there are auuin F for 0 < u, v < n - 1 such that y = a u u ( a ~= a ~ ) au,,a;a~). Changing point of view let w be the Vandermonde matrix ( a : - ' ) = C!,j=, a i - ' e i j , cf., remark 6.4.13. Then letting a denote the matrix C ~ , ~ ~ o a u , e u + and l . Dw + f denote the transpose of w we would have
(xu,u
c:,if,,
waw'
=
C a,,,aya; = y U.1'
But w is invertible since the ai are distinct, so a Q.E.D. solution.
= w-'y(w')-'
is the desired
Notational Hypothesis 7.1.33: Having proven proposition 7.1.32 we fix the following notation (when relevant): View R c R @ , K o x M,,(Ko)c M ( E ) and take a set of matric units eij in E with respect to which a = aieiiis diagonal; the ai are then distinct. Choosing r in R for which R = K r K we write r = ( r i j )in M,,(E). By choice of r we see M,,(E)is spanned by the aurau= (rijayay) for 0 5 u,v 5 n - 1; in particular, all components rij must be nonzero. Since R = K r K = ~ ~ Fa'rau + we~ can ~ write, any arbitrary element x of R as ~ ~ , ~ ~ O a u , where , a U ra,,,, a uE F are uniquely determined. Viewing x as a matrix ( x , ) in M,,(E)we have x i j = auUrijaYa~ = pijrijwhere
x~,~l~o
n- 1
pij = 1a,,a;ay€ u,u=o
E.
(4)
The bij are the key to the whole theory. E is a Galois extension of F, whose Galois group G permutes the a,. In this way we can view G G Sym(n) by means of the notation aai = aOi for
204
Central Simple Algebras
every D in G. (In other words, we use D to denote both the automorphism and its corresponding permutation of the indices.) Proposition 7.1.34:
(i) The Pij satisfy the conjugacy conditions oPij= & i , a j for all (T in G. (ii) Conversely, suppose we have a separable field extension K O of F, and K = Kg' = F(a), where a has degree n. Let E be the normal closure of K O over F. Given arbitrary /Iij in E satisfying the conjugacy conditions with respect to G = Gal(E/F) one can Jind a,, in F, 0 Iu , v In - 1, for which (4) holds. Proof:
(i) asij = Ca,,oa~aay = C a , , a z i a ~= j /?ui,uj (ii) Let a , , . . . , a , be the conjugates of a, and ( a ! - ' ) be the corresponding Vandermonde matrix (cf., proof of claim 7.1.32'). Defining (a,,,) by the matrix equation (a,,) = b-')-'(Pij)(ay-
'I-',
we obviously have (4) satisfied, so it remains to show each a,, E F, i.e., DU,," = a,,, for all D in G. But (4) yields u.0
auuaU,iazj = B a i , aj = DBij = C ( ~ a u u ) ( ~ a i ) u ( ~ a j ) u
so matching coefficients yields a,,
= DU,,
as desired.
Q.E.D.
Definition 7.1.35: A set { C i j k : 1 Ii, j , k I n } c E is a Brauer factor set of E over F if it satisfies the following Brauer factor set conditions for all i, j , k, m and all D in G = Gal(E/F):
BFS 1:
acijk
BFS2: CijkCik,,,
= Cui, , k,, = Cij,,,Cjk,,,.
(Often We View this as c i j k
= CijmCjkmC&-)
Remark 7.1.36: Setting j = i and rn = 1 in BFS2 shows C i i f = ciil for all i, k. Likewise, setting k = j yields cijj = cjj,,,;thus ciij= ciii = cjii for all i, j . Theorem 7.1.37:
(i) (Notation as in 7.1.33) R gives rise To a Brauer factor set c.. Ilk = r..r. IJ J k r:' rk
{cijk}
defined by (5)
$7.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
205
(ii) Conversely, suppose K = KE' = F[a] where K O is a separable field extension of F, and E is the normal closure of K O ,and let n = [ K :F ] . Given a Brauer factor set { c i j k ) define R = {(pij)E Mn(E):upij = for all u in C } . Endowing R with multiplication n
we have R is a central simple F-algebra, and there is a canonical injection cp(pij)= (flijcijl).K is isomorphic to a maximal separable subalgebra of R. (iii) Constructions ( i ) and (ii) are inverse constructions, as explained in the proof. @ R + Mn(E)given by
Pro08
(i) Any element of R can be written in the form (pijrij)as seen preceding (4). Then the product of two elements (pijrij)and (pijrij)is (pijr,) where by ( 5 ) p:;rik
=
1 PijrijPJkrjk = 1 BijCijkPJkrik,SO n
n
j= 1
j= 1
seen by canceling rik.Now let us take the particular (flijrij)correspond to 1 in R. Then 1 = 1 1 implies pik = pijcijkpjk.Applying the conjugancy conditions on we have
-
Thus 0 =
cy=
pij(cijk- B (Y(i)jk)
)pjk.
- ~ c ~ ~ Consider , ~ ~ , the ~ ~ matrix
= (ril(cijk
- u-lCai,aj,ak)fljk)
where i is fixed. Then 0 = (/lijrij)(y(i)jk) = (y(i)jk)
since (jijrij)= 1.
Hence (cijk- u-lcGi+uj,ak)/?jk = 0 for all i, j , k. The same argument applied on the right shows each cijk - u - l ~ u i , a j ,=a 0, k so applying u gives m i j k = c ~ ~ i.e., . ~BFS1. ~ , To ~ get ~ ,BFS2 note CijkCikm =
c..c. c-lc.rk ck m CT' = c..c. c c: t j j k rk tm IJ j k k m rfnl = CijntCjkm.
Central Simple Algebras
206
(ii) Clearly, R is an F-subspace of Mn(E) and is closed under the given multiplication since
1 ab"ac" n
=
11
uk Op''I k
j= 1
4) is
=
1
bai. ojcai. a j . a k b b j , ak
= Bb'i,o k .
j
a homomorphism since Ciklfl:;
= Cij1'Cj*lC$flf;
= Ccijlcjklcij:Bijcij,SJk j
=c(cijl
b i j ) ( c j k 1b i k ) .
j
Obviously @ is an injection since each cijl is invertible, so we can identify R with R = 4)R G Mn(E).To see K G R we note the diagonal matrix XI= aieii is the image of aici:eii which is in R since c(aic,:) = aaic~ifai,al = aaic;i!ai, by remark 7.1.36. On the other hand, the matrix whose entries are all 1 satisfies the conjugacy conditions and thus yields an element of R whose image under @ is r = ( c i j l ) in M,,(E). Since K @ E splits we see RE contains each eiirejj = ci j l ei j , so each eij E RE. Consequently Mn(E) is a central extension of R , so R is prime and clearly finite dimensional over F, implying R is simple. It remains to show F = Z ( R ) . Suppose z E Z ( R ) . Then z E Z ( R E ) = Z ( M n ( E ) )= E. Hence z = c,:zeii) so by the conjugacy condition and remark 7.1.36
XI=
@(XI=
(Tc:'cz = (T(cr'z) 11 1 = c-.1 U I , U l., 1 z = c-.1 a i , a i , a l ~= ( C C ~ ; ) Z I l l
implying z = (TZ for each (T in G and thus z E F. Hence R (and thus R) is central simple, of degree n since PI deg(R) = n. (iii) Starting with R we can apply (i) to obtain the Brauer factor set ( c i j k ) and then applying (ii) we get an algebra isomorphic to R, seen by confronting (6) with (7). O n the other hand, if we are given (cijk)and build R and R as in (ii) then taking r = (cijl)E R we see from the proof of (ii) that Mn(E)= K r K ; using r as in the discussion preceding (4) we use the procedure of (i) to Q.E.D. obtain a Brauer factor set and find we have recaptured (i). It is useful to remember from the proof of (iii) that the rij and cijl play the same role. Example 7.1.38: If R = Mn(F)then taking r to be the matrix each of whose entries is 1 we get cijk = 1 for each i,j, k; this is called the trivial Brauer factor set. More generally, if R corresponds to the Brauer factor set (cii,) over K then M,(R) corresponds to the Brauer factor set ( c i r f k ? ) over K(", where we define Ci?jPk* to be cijk if i’ = i(modn), j ' = j(modn) and k' = k(modn).
207
87.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
Indeed, write R = KrK in the manner which yields ( C i j k ) and let r' be the tn x En matrix formed by t 2 blocks each of which is a copy of r. Obviously M,(R) = K(')r'K('),viewing K(') as t copies of K along the diagonal, and this yields the desired (ci,j,k,).
Remark 7.1.39: (i) BFSl implies fscijk = Cijk for all a fixing F(ai,aj,ak)and thus by Galois theory cijkE F(ai,aj,a,). (ii) Taking m = 1 in BFS2 we see Cijk = ci,lcjklcli: for all j,k,i, so the (cijk) are actually determined by the (cijl)in this manner. Let us now see when two Brauer factor sets yield isomorphic central simple algebras (with respect to the same K ) . Theorem 7.1.40: Suppose (cijk) and ( z i j k ) are Brauer factor sets of E over F, notation as in 7.1.33, corresponding respectively to central simple algebras R and R as in theorem 7.1.37. There is an isomorphism R -+ R" jixing K f l there is nonzero ( y i j ) in M J E ) satisfying the conjugacy conditions for which I
=
Cijk
c i j k ~ i j ~ j k ~ ~for ' each i,j, k.
(In such a case we say (cijk) and
(zijk)
(8)
are associate.)
Proo$ (e) As in theorem 7.1.37 we write an element of R as (flijrij) where rij = cijl and where the pij satisfy the conjugacy conditons, with multiplication as in (7). Then define $: R -+ R' by $(fl..r..) = (B..y:'r"..) where Fij = Eijl. rJ IJ V Y V Clearly, $ has inverse given by (pijcj) (Pijyijrij)so it remains to show II/ is a homomorphism. Letting = f i i j ~ i j k f l ) k we see / ? L y i l = implying
-
pijyil~ijk~;kyykl
Ijf((Bijrij)(Bikrjk))= $ ( P f ; r i k ) = (P"y"7' i k rk rk ) = ( B "Vy ' V lcj)(piky;l
so $ is indeed a homomorphism. (3) Given an isomorphism $: R 4 R' we may assume $ fixes K O by the Skolem-Noether theorem, and thus $ fixes E in the notation 7.1.33. Writing $(rij)= (Yij) in R' for suitable Fij in E , let yij = rijFil, so that Yij = rijyij'. We claim for any [Pi,rij) in R that $(Pijrij) = (pijyG1cj);indeed (Bijrzj)can be written as arrijar so
xu,+
$(Pijrij) = (C$ay$rij$ay) = (CaYrijyijlay) = (fl..y-'F..) V V 1J
as claimed. In particular, writing 1 as (Bijrij)for suitable
Pij, and
matching
Central Simple Algebras
208
terms in I,$ 1 = 4 1I,$ 1 yields
1 fl""v n
j= 1
1 n
uk P I. k Y G 1
=
j= 1
&jYilzijkfljkYjkl,
x j P i j ( c i j k y i l- Fijkyij -1 yjk - 1 )ajk= 0. Repeating the last paragraph of the proof of theorem 7.1.37(i) we can peel off the pij and then Pjk to get so
CijkyG'
-
- FijkijkYij - 1 Y j- k1 - 0, It., . cijk = CijkYijYjkY;'.
Q.E.D.
Corollary 7.1.41: R z Mn(F) ifl there is a Brauer factor set satisfying cijk = YijYjkYG' for suitable ( y i j ) in Mn(E)satisfying the conjugacy conditions.
Proofi
Apply (8) to the trivial Brauer factor set of example 7.1.38. Q.E.D.
Noether Factor Sets When the maximal subfield K of R is already Galois over F the previous construction becomes considerably more explicit and yields the more familiar "crossed product" construction of E. Noether. The theory is a natural generalization of that of cyclic algebras. Let G = Gal(K/F). For each 0 in G the Skolem-Noether theorem gives an invertible u, in R for which u,au;l = aa where K = F(a). Let c,,~ = u,uru;:. Then c,,~ E C,(K) = K, and obviously
(9)
UuUr = Cu,ruur.
Applying (9) to the associative law (u,ur)up = u,(urup) yields the Noether factor set conditions Cu,rCur.p
= Cu.rp0Cr.p
for all a,z,p in G.
xaeG
(10)
Using a Dedekind independence argument one sees readily that Ku, is a subalgebra of R which is [GI-dimensional over K ,implying R = x a e G K u u . Conversely, any set {c,,~: o, t E G} satisfying (10) is called a (Noether) factor set and gives rise to an algebra R = l a E C K ~under , multiplication
Customarily one proves by direct verification that the multiplication of (11) is associative and furthermore defines a central simple algebra; however, in exercise 10 we shall see this as a special case of theorem 7.1.37. Example 7.1.42: Suppose (K, a, a) is a cyclic algebra. Taking z such that
209
$7.1 Structure of Central Simple Algebras
= a we could take u,, = zi for each 0 5 i c n. Now (9) yields = 1 if i + j < n and a otherwise. Thus cyclic algebras have particularly nice Noether factor sets and permits us to generalize some of the results on symbols, cf., exercise 12. Z"
Algebras of Degree 2,3,4 Proposition 7.1.43: (3rauer) Any central division ufgebra D of degree n has an element d for which tr(d) = tr(d-') = 0. Proof;. Notation as in theorem 7.1.37 we want to find d = (pijcij1)with tr(d) = tr(d-') = 0. We pick a special sort of p,,; let pii = 0 for all i and flij = f(a,)-l where f = ctiAi with the a, to be determined. Clearly the conjugacy conditions hold since = 0 = Dii and flmi,uj = f(uUi)-' = of(ai)-' = oBij for i # j . Furthermore, tr(d) = cfliiciil= 0. Thus far we have made no restriction on the ai. We get tr(d-')=O iff xflfi=O where the pii are the diagonal entries of the adjoint matrix to (flijcijl).But f(a,)...f(a.)~ pii= 0 unravels to a linear condition on the a i , so we can solve for a. in terms of Q.E.D. the other ai, and this solution yields the desired d.
x:
In other words if
C:=,aidi = 0 we have a, = a,-
= 0.
Theorem 7.1.44: (Wedderburn) Every division algebra D of degree n is cyclic.
=2
or 3
Proof;. For n = 2 the assertion is corollary 7.1.15'. For n = 3 we note that by proposition 7.1.43 there is some d # 0 in D for which tr(d) = tr(d-') = 0, implying d3 E F, and thus D is cyclic. Q.E.D. A similar argument also handles degrees 4 and 12. Theorem 7.1.45: (Albert) if index(R) = 4 then R has a splitting field with Galois group (2/2H)'''over F. Proof: We may assume R is a division aIgebra; we shall treat only the char # 2 case. By proposition 7.1.43 fhere is d in R for which d4 + a,d2 + u0 = 0 for suitable ao,az in E Hence ( d 2 + ~ , / 2 E) F,~ proving R has an element d, 4 F whose square is in F. Pick 0 # r in R for which rd,r-' = - d l , by Skolem-Noether. Then rz centralizes d , but r does not, so F(r2)c F(r). If r2 E F then r and d , generate a central quaternion subalgebra Q of R, so R zz Q 0 Q1where Q1= C,(Q). Q , is also quaternion and thus cyclic; taking
210
Central Simple Algebras
a quadratic subfield F(d,) over F we see R contains the subfield F ( d , , d z ) which has Galois group (2/22)(2)over R. If rz 4 F then [ F ( r Z )F: ] = 2 so F ( d , , r 2 ) is the desired subfield. Thus in either case we proved the result for degree 4. Q.E.D. An alternate proof of these results is sketched in exercises 15-20.
InJinite Dimensional Division Algebras The theory of an arbitrary division ring D is much less developed than the finite dimensional theory, but there are certain decisive trends of considerable interest. First of all there is the surprisingly useful Cartan-Brauer-Hua Theorem: (exercise 23). Any proper subring of D which is invariant with respect to all inner automorphisms of D is central. This theorem is used to describe the structure of D in terms of sets invariant under inner automorphisms, such as [ D , D ] , and also has been generalized to rings with involution, cf., Herstein [76B]. Cartan-Brauer-Hua was applied already in, cf., exercises 2.5.3 Iff. Jacobson [64B] incorporates the Cartan-Brauer-Hua theorem into a Galois theory for division rings. Certainly any division ring D can be viewed as a left vector space over a division subring D,. When D, is finite dimensional over its center then [D:D , ] is the same as what one would get by viewing D as right vector space over D,. However, this is not necessarily the case in general as first proved by P. M. Cohn, and Schofield [ S S ] shows for any 1 < m,n Ico there are division rings D, c D such that the left dimension (of D over D l ) is m, whereas the right dimension is n; thus the Galois theory meets a serious problem with its most fundamental invariant. Schofield has produced a rather easy example of this pathelogical behavior, which we give in exercise 41. This leaves us to search for an alternate way to measure the “size” of a division algebra. The most natural candidate may be the GK-dimension. However the GK-dimension is often “too small,” as evidenced by Example 7.1.46: (Makar-Limanov [ 8 3 ] ) The division ring of fractions of the Weyl algebra A,(Q) has a free subalgebra generated by (PA)-’ and (pA)-’(l - p)- , where p , 1 are the generators in example 1.6.32. We do not go into the details here, which involve working in the subring piQ((t)) where t = p 1 and showing the monomials which are strings in t-’ and (1 - p)- are independent.
xiEa
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Susfin Theorem
21 1
Incidentally, Makar-Limanov [84] proved eoery noncommutative division ring with uncountable center contains a free group. Kurosch‘s problem remains unsolved for division rings. One prerequisite for an effective theory is Question 7.2.47: If D is finite dimensional as left vector space over a division subring D , then does GK dim D = GK dim D,? (i.e., if G K dim D1 < co then is GK dim D < co and does equality hold?)
Another useful measure of the size might be by means of maximal subfields, cf., exercises 32, 33 and work of Resco on the transcendence degree. Stafford [83) recently showed the Krull dimension of D 0 D O p can be an important invariant, and in an interesting survey Schofield [84] suggests concentrating on D such that DODOp is Noetherian. This includes the division rings of fractions of the various Noetherian domains studied in Chapter 8, specifically of group algebras and enveloping algebras, and these are explored in depth by Lorenz [84], cf., exercise 34. The particular case of group algebras is discussed at the end of $8.2. Lichtman [84a] has studied the structure of subrings of matrix rings over such division rings. Algebraic elements of arbitrary division rings have certain very nice properties, the foremost of which may well be Wedderburn’s factorization theorem, exercises 15- 18.
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem In the overview in $7.1 we defined the Brauer group of a field, denoted Br(F), as the set of similarity classes of central simple algebras (two algebras are similar if they have the same underlying division algebra); the group operation is tensor product. Our goal in this section is to obtain some of the properties of the Brauer group and to examine the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem, proving some easy special cases. Actually, we shall be interested mostly in the pperiodic part of Br(F);special attention is paid to the case p = 2, for this ties in with the theory of rings with involution. One obvious question to ask is, “What is the group structure of Br(F), for a given field F?” If F is algebraically closed then Br(F) = (1) since there are no nontrivial F-central division algebras. The Tsen-Lang theorem (Jacobson [80B, p. 6493) implies more generally that Br(F) = (1) whenever F is an algebraic extension of F,(A) where F,, is algebraically closed. Another instance of Br(F) = (1) is when F is a finite field, by theorem 7.1.11. It is also easy to check Br(R) z E/2Z, cf., exercise 1. Usually Br(F) is infinite and difficult to ascertain, as one sees when investigating Br(Q), cf., appendix A.
Central Simple Algebras
212
General Properties of the Brauer Group There are three major approaches to the Brauer group. The first is by looking at each algebra individually; the second is by means of crossed products, and the third is via cyclic algebras. So far we have favored the first route, gleaning as much as we can from the Brauer factor set construction. Often one passes to the underlying division algebra, also, cf., exercise 2. The crossed product method relies on the fact that every class in the Brauer group is represented by a crossed product (corollary 7.2.5 below) and ties in with the powerful techniques of cohomology theory since the product in the Brauer group turns out to be compatible with the group operation in H 2 . Finally the approach using cyclic algebras is perhaps both the oldest and the freshest, bringing in algebraic K-theory. Remark 7.2.1: For any fields F E K there is a group homomorphism [R QF K ] . Thus Br resK,FBr(F) -+ Br(K) called the restriction, given by [R] is a functor from (fields) to (abelian groups}. Ker(res,,,) = ([R] E Br(F): R is split by K). Thus the functor Br contains the theory of splitting fields.
One fundamental result needed later to work with restriction is Proposition 7.2.2:
Suppose K 2 F is a subjleld of R. Then R OFK
-
C,(K).
Proofi By proposition 7.1.3 C R ( K )OKK @FROPx End, R is split as K Q.E.D. algebra, SO C R ( K ) R 0 K .
-
First Invariant of Br(F): The Index Recall index(R) is defined as the degree of the underlying division algebra D of R. Note for any field K 2 F that index(R Q K) = index(D Q K) divides degree(D Q K ) = degree(D) = index(R). Theorem 7.2.3: Let t = index(R)/index(R OFK). Then t I [ K :F ] and K is isomorphic to a subfield of MIK:FI,((D),where D is the underlying division algebra of R. Proof; Let k = [K: F]. By the regular representation K E M,(F), so Mk(D)? D @ K =M,(D,)?M,(F) for some division algebra D,. By proposition 7.1.1 there is a division algebra D’ for which Mk(D)x M,(F)@ M,,(D’)x MJD’); hence u = k / t and D’ % D. But K = Z(D Q K ) centralizes M,(F) so K G MJD’) z M,(Df. Q.E.D.
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
213
Corollary 7.2.4: if [ K : F ] and index(R) are relatively prime then index(R 0 K ) = index(R).
The IdentlJication with H 2 The modern way of thinking about the Brauer group is via cohomology of groups; the identification is based on the following result.
Corollary 7.2.5: Every central simple algebra R is similar to a crossed product. Proof.. We may assume R is a division algebra of degree t . Take a maximal separable subfield L of R (over F ) and let K be the normal closure of L . Then K is a Galois extension of F. Let R ' = MLKZF,,$(R). K is a subfield of R' by Q.E.D. theorem 7.2.3, and deg R ' = [ K : F ] so K is maximal.
Theorem 7.2.6: Br( K / F ) .
if’ K is Galois ouer F with Galois G then H 2 ( G ,K - {0))FZ
Since we want to push off in a different direction we shall not give full details of this proof, which can be found in many standard texts including Jacobson [80B, theorem 8.111. However, the general idea of the proof is very instructive. K - {O} is a G-module by means of the action of G as automorphisms on K , where the operation of K - (0) is multiplication. Rewriting formula (2) in example 5.2.13 taking M = K - (0) and using multiplication instead of addition we write c,., for f(a, t) and observe any f in Z2(G,K - (0)) satisfies 1
= df(a, z , p ) = C J C , , ~~ , , , C , , , ~ ~ C , , , ~ -I
-1
for all a, ~ , inp G.
Thus ~ ,,,c ,,,~= C , , ~ ~ C J ' C , ,which ~, is the Noether factor set condition. In this way f gives rise to a central simple algebra, yielding a map $: Z 2 ( G ,K - {O})+ Br(K/F). i j is onto by corollary 7.2.5, and f E ker$ iff the c0,, have y, for which c,. = yuayry;) by exercise 7.1.1 1, so ker i j = B2(G,K - (0)). Thus the proof boils down to showing $ is a group homomorphism or, equivalently, Lemma 7.2.7: if R, R' are crossed products with respective Noether factor sets (c0,,) and (cb,,) over K , then R OFR' is similar to a crossed product R" having Noether factor set (c,,cb,) over K . The crux of the proof of lemma 7.2.7 is to locate R" such that we can compute the factor set. Certainly K OFK c R OFR', and it turns out R" = e ( R R')e where e is as in exercise 6.
Central Simple Algebras
214
The above approach relied on the delicate connection to crossed products; one would like a version of lemma 7.2.7 which held more generally for Brauer factor sets, i.e.,
Lemma 7.2.7’: If R, R' have respective Brauer factor sets ( c i j k ) and ( c : j k ) with respect to a maximal separable subjield K then R Q R' is similar to an algebra having Brauer factor set ( C i j k c ; , ) . This lemma is proved in Jacobson [83] analogously to lemma 7.2.7, also, cf., van der Waerden [49B, pp. 207-2151. However, there is a rather direct proof once we free ourselves from fields. Namely, as in notational hypothesis 7.1.33 write R = K r K and R ' = K r ' K . Then R @ R ' = ( K Q K ) ( r @ r ' ) ( K @ K ) and the n 2 x n 2 matrix r Q r' can be computed to yield the Brauer factor set of R 0R' over K Q K; this is easily seen to be associated to the Brauer factor set obtained by repeating (CijkCijk) in blocks, completing the proof of lemma 7.2.7'. The reader is strongly encouraged to fill in the details of this proof before referring to the literature. One can also use lemma 7.2.7' to compute the Brauer factor set of ROP. Proposition 7.2.8: If the Brauer factor set corresponds to RoP.
(cij,')
corresponds to R the
(ckji)
froofi In view of lemma 7.2.7' we want ( c i j & c k j i )to be associated to the trivial Brauer factor set. Let yij = cijiciil.Then by remark 7.1.36 gy.. tj
= cn i. . n j , a i C a i . a i , n l = C a i , a j . a i C a i . a i . 1 = Y a i , a j ,
yielding the conjugacy condition. Furthermore, BFS2 yields yij = cijiciim= cijmcjim (taking k = i ) and, likewise, yij = cijicmii= cmijcmji by left-right symmetry.
Hence
y i j ) ' j ky i '
= (CijkCjik)(CjkiCkji)(CjikCjki)-’
= CijkCkji as desired.
Q.E.D.
Second Invariant of Br(F): The Exponent One of the major features of the Brauer group is that it is torsion. This can be seen at once by combining exercise 5.2.2 with theorem 7.2.6, but better results can be obtained directly. To wit, we define the exponent of a central simple algebra R, written exp(R), to be the order of [R] in the Brauer group; i.e., exp(R) is the smallest number m for which R a m 1, where we recall Ram denotes R OF. . . OFR taken over m copies of R.
-
215
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
Example 7.2.9: If R =(u, 0). and F(P1'")is a field then exp(R) is the smallest rn for which am is a norm from F(B"") to F, by Wedderburn's criterion (proposition 7.1.18).
Theorem 7.2.10:
exp(R) divides index(R).
-
Proof: Let n be the degree of R . We need to show R@" 1, or, equivalently, (by lemma 7.2.7') (cijk)" is associated to the trivial Brauer factor set, if (cijk) is a Brauer factor set of R. Putting yij = cijmyields (by condition BFS2 of definition 7.1.35)
fl:=
YijYjkYGl
=
fi (.ijmcjkmc&, n =
m= I
Cijk
= (cijk)".
m
To proceed further we need the following elementary way of cutting out the "unwanted" part of the index. Proposition 7.2.11: Suppose index(R) = pjt where p is a prime number not dividing t. Then there is a j e l d extension L over F whose dimension is relatively prime to p , for which index(R OFL ) = p J . Proof.- Let E be the normal closure of a separable splitting subfield K of R; [ E : F ] = [ E : K ] [ K : F ]= pj't' for suitable j ' 2 j and t' prime to p. Let H be a Sylow p-subgroup of Gal(E/F) and let L be the fixed subfield of E under H . By Galois theory [ L : F ] = t' is prime to p , so by theorem 7.2.3 index(R OFL) =pJt" for some t" dividing t. On the other hand, (R OFL ) OLE = R OFE is split so pjt" divides [ E : L ] = p j ' , implying t" = 1, proving index(R OFL ) = p'. Q.E.D. Theorem 7.2.12: If n,m are the respective index and exponent of a suitable centrul simple algebra R then the following two conditions hold: (i) m ( n (ii) every prime divisor of n also divides m.
Proof: (i) Holds by Theorem 7.2.10. (ii) Suppose p I n. By proposition 7.2.11 there is a field L with [ L : F ] prime p, for which R 0 L has index p J with j 2 1. But then exp(R 0 L) is a nontrivial power of p which obviously divides rn. Q.E.D.
216
Central Simple Algebras
We shall see in 47.3 that (i) and (ii) are the only numerical connections between the index and exponent. Theorem 7.2.13: Suppose D is a central division algebra of degree n = p";"'.. . pi'k' for suitable distinct p , , . . .,pk primes and a( l), . . . ,a(k) in N - { O } . Then D 2 D,Q .. . @ Dk for central division subalgebras Di of degree pP'I', I s i l k . Proof: It suffices to prove that if deg(D) = n = n'n" where n' and n" are relatively prime then D = D,0 D, where deg(D,) = n' and deg(D,) = n", for then we can continue the decomposition by induction. Take u, u in N for which un' + un" = l(modu1on) and take D, D@"""and D, DOun'. Then D,O D , D @ ( u n ' + v n ' ' ) D. O n the other hand, Dyn'-DOun- 1 so exp(D,)ln', implying by theorem 7.2.12 deg(D,) is prime to n"; but deg(D,) divides deg(D) = n'n" so deg(D,) divides n'. Likewise, deg(D,) divides n". Thus
-
-
-
~
deg(D, 0 0,)I n'n" = n = index(D) = index@, 0 D,) Ideg(D, 0 D,)
so equality holds; in particular, D,OD, is a division algebra so D,OD, z D. Q.E.D. In view of theorem 7.2.1 3 the structure theory of division algebras reduces to the case where the degree (and exponent) is a prime power. Digression 7.2.23':
The zero divisor question for tensor products (also see exercise 7.1.42). Conversely to theorem 7.2.3, we take a brief look at the question: If D, and D, are central division algebras not having a common subfield over F then is D,0 D, a division algebra? Answer: "Yes" if deg(D,) and deg(D,) are relatively prime (exercise 22) or if deg(D,) = deg(D,) = 2 (exercise 23). However, there is a counterexample, in general. Example 7.2.23': (Tignol-Wadsworth [86]) Cyclic division algebras D, and D, of degree p for p an arbitrary odd prime, not having any common maximal subfield, such that D, 0 D, is not a division algebra. Suppose F,, is a field containing a primitive p-th root [ of 1 and F = Fo(A,, A,, A 3 ) for commutative indeterminates Ai over F,. Let Di = (ai,pi), where a, = A,, = A,,a, = &(A3 - l)A;', and 8, = 4 A 3 . Taking yi,zi such that yp = ai, zp =pi, and ziyi = [yizi one sees the element a = (yl O 1 z , 8 y,)(l 0 2;') of D,0 D, is a p-th root of 1. Indeed, letting a , = zly;' 0 y, and writing 1 for 1 0 1 we have
/?,
ap = (( 1
+
+ a , )( y ,@ z ; '
))p
=(1
+ a , )( 1 + c2al) . . .(1 + l 2 ' p - ')al)(y ,o z ; I)".
57.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
+
217
nPd l
But i.' 1 = (lii+ 1) since (-' is a zero of L P + 1 for each i. Sub= a: + 1 = stituting a, for i. yields ( I + a , ) ( l + [ 2 a , ) . . . ( l + 12(p-1)al) ,blr;'a2 1, so
+
aP=(/?,a;'a2+ I)(al/?;')=(P1a2+ct,)/l;'=(A,(A,-
1)+Al)(IIA3)-'
=1
as desired. Thus D,0 D, cannot be a division algebra. Tignol-Wadsworth verify using valuation theory that D, and D, have no common maximal subfield. However, this follows at once from the following observation of Saltman, based on a leading monomial argument which foreshadows 57.3:
Claim: D,0 D;p is a division algebra.
-
-
Proof of Claim: Let D = D, 0 D;p. D;p z ( ~ 2 , a 2 ) p( A 1 , a 2 ) , 0 ( i 3 , ~ , ) , since 8, = 4 A 3 . Thus D = D , 0 D;p (A,, &a2), 0 (A,, a,),, = (A,, A i ( A 3 1)),@(&,&(& - 1)A;'). But now I, appears only in the last position. Letting D3 = (A,,A,(A3 - l)), and R = D 3 OFF(A:IP), we have identified D as the ring of central fractions of the skew polynomial ring R [ p ; a ] where a fixes D, and ~=i lJ:'p. :' (We ~ view I , as - l ) p p . )If D were not a division ring then neither would R [ p ; a ] ; taking leading coefficient of zerodivisors would yield zero-divisors in R . But and the indeterminate A, is obviously not a norm from F(I:lP,(l - I,)'/'')to Q.E.D. F ( i : ' p ) , so R cannot be split, by proposition 7.1.18. Saltman's observation raises the following new tensor product question:
7.2.13"': If index(D, @Of’")< index(D,)index(D,) for all 1 I u < exp(D,) then do D, and D, necessarily have a common subfield? Question
Although this question remains open, Schofield has pointed out a lovely way of attacking such problems generically and has some very nice counterexamples, cf., appendix C .
Outer A utomorphisms We have seen that for fields F E K there is the very natural restriction map Br(F) -P Br(K) sending [ R ] H [C,(K)]. Thus we are led to ask whether there is an inverse map from Br(K) to Br(F). This is too much to hope for, but there is a useful map, the corestriction, which remained undiscovered
Central Simple Algebras
218
until the Brauer group was examined from a cohomological point of view. Our approach, however, is ring-theoretical, following Tignol [SS], which modifies Draxl’s presentation of work of Riehm [70] and Tamagawa. The start by examining the following set-up: G is a finite group of automorphisms of an arbitrary algebra R over a field E, and we assume that each n in G restricts to a nontrivial automorphism of E. (Such automorphisms are often called “outer.”) Write tr r for nr, and write F = E G (the fixed subfield of E under G ) and R , = {trr: r E R } . Note R , G RG are vector spaces over F.
xusG
Proposition 7.2.14:
RG = Ro and R
R , OFE.
Proof: First we claim ROE= R. Otherwise, taking r in R\R,E we can find a map f:R -,E (as vector spaces over E ) such that f r = 1 and f ( R o E )= 0. For each o in G write a, for f (or)in E. Then for each y in E we have
contrary to the Dedekind independence theorem (Jacobson [85B, p. 2911) since the o:E -+ E are presumed distinct. This proves the claim. Now we have a canonical map cp: RG OFE -,RGE = R whose restriction to R , 0 E is epic. It remains to prove cp is monic, since then necessarily RG = R,, showing cp is an isomorphism. So assume, on the contrary, 0 # r = r, 0 a, E ker cp for suitable a, in E, and for suitable ri in RG which are independent over F. Then riai = 0 so for every y in E we have
xi
x
o = tr
yCr,ai
)
= tr
)
Caiyri ( i
= Ctr(aiy)ri. i
Hence for each i we have 0 = tr(aiy)= ~ , ( o a , ) a y again ; this contradicts the Q.E.D. Dedekind independence theorem unless each a, = 0. (The “outer automorphism” hypothesis can be applied much more generally, cf., Montgomery [SOB].) Corollary 7.2.15 : Suppose R is a simple (not necessarily central) E-algebra of degree n. Then R G is a simple F-algebra of degree n, Z ( R G )= Z(R)‘, and [ R : E ] = [ R G F: ] . Proofi
From R
= RGOFE
we see RG is simple, Z ( R G )0 E
c Z ( R ) , and
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
219
[ R : E ] = [ R G :F ] . But Z ( R ) is invariant under G , so using Z ( R ) instead of R in the proposition shows Z ( R ) z Z(R)' 0 E ; since, obviously, Z ( R ) GG Z ( R c ) , we conclude Z ( R G )= Z ( R ) G and thus [ R : Z ( R ) ] = [ R G : Z ( R G ) ] . Q.E.D. Corollary 7.2.16: Suppose R , and R , are simple E-algebras with Z ( R , ) = E , and G = Gal(E/F) extends naturally to a group of automorphisms on each of R , and R , . Letting G act diagonally on R , 0 R , (Le.,a(r, 0 r z ) = or, 0 or2) we have
( R , OER,)' = RY
OFRY.
Proof: ( 2 ) is clear. ( S ) Let ni = CRY: F ] . By corollary 7.2.15
[ R , : E ] [ R , : E ] = nln2 = [ ( R , 0 R,)':F], so we are done by proposition 7.1.1 (ii).
Q.E.D.
The Corestriction We now have the prerequisites to define the important corestriction map from Br(L) to Br(F), for any separable extension L of F. This is also called the transfer map or trace, and when defined in cohomology the groups are written in additive notation, instead of the multiplicative notation used here.
Definition 7.2.17: Given a E Gal(E/F) and an E-algebra R define the algebra a - ' R to have the same ring structure as R but with the new scalar product of a in E and r in G - ' R to be defined as (aa)r (the product taken in R.) The intuition here is to think of an element of a-’R in the form K ' r , and then c u - l r = a-’(a~)a-~r = a-'((oct)r). Remark 7.2.18:
(i) The cT-semilinear homomorphisms $: R , -+R , (i.e., $far) = (ua)$r), are precisely the algebra homomorphisms $: R , + a-'R,. (ii) If a fixes a subfield L of E and A E L - d f p and R E E - d f f then 6 l ( , 4 OLR ) =: A B L K 1 R for any L-algebra A (identifying E with L 0 E ) . (iii) (a,a2)-'R z a T ' a i ' R . (iv) o-'E z E . (Indeed (i) is clear, and consequently we get (ii) by taking $: A 0 a-'R 3 A 0 R to be the identity. (iii) and (iv) are also immediate from
(9.1
220
Central Simple Algebras
To define the corestriction for an arbitrary separable extension L of F, let E be a Galois extension of F containing L, let G = Gal(E/F) and H = Gal(E/L), and let a,,..., at be a left transversal of H in G, i.e., G = Ha,. (Thus I = [L:F].)
u
Defi.ition 7.2.29: The corestriction corLiFR of the central simple L-algebra R, notation as above. Define I? = @:= oL'(R 0, E), where the undecorated tensor is taken over E, and use the following rule for extending any a in G to an automorphism of I?:
First note there is n in Sym(r) for which aia E Ha,,. Indeed, IT is 1:l for if aiaand ajo are in the same coset then aiail =(aio)(ajo)-'E H so Hai= Haj and i = j . Now put cia = tioff,for suitable ti in H and define /
I
\
I
for ri in R and pi in E. To see that this definition makes sense, let us note that we would expect oo;:(R OLE)= a;'zi(R Q E) = a;'(R Q t i E ) by remark 7.2.18(ii),i.e., a sends the ni component to the i component, "twisted" by t i . It is easily checked that a, indeed, is an automorphism of I?, and so we finally can define cor,/,R
.’?I
=
Note I? E Br(E) so corLiFR E Br(F) by corollary 7.2.15; thus the corestriction is a map from Br(L) to Br(F), which we want to show is a group homomorphism. To do this we must first free the construction from the various choices which were made along the way. Proposition 7.2.20: The construction corL,FR depends (up to isomorphism) only on L, F, and R.
Proof.- First we show that if we started with a different transversal a;,...,a: we end up with an isomorphic result. Write 0;= pici for pi in H , and note a:o = p.r.a I ni. = r ia’f . f l where T: = p i ~ i p ; : . Also by remark 7.2.18(iii) (where R, E, respectively, replace A, R), I
o;-'(R OLE)= a,'p;'(R
Q,E) z o;'(R O L p 7 ' E ) z af'(R OLE),
so I? z @:= aj-'(R 0, E) (which we denote as I?') under the isomorphism @ which sends @:= (ri Q Pi) H @;= ' ( r iQ pL'Pi). Extending any a in G to
22 I
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
d
under the rule a(@’= the commutative square
,(ri 0pl'pi)) = @:= I(rrri 0~
~ p i : f l we ~ ~ )have ,
R -jy0
and thus @ restricts to an isomorphism of the fixed rings of d and d'. It remains to show that if E is another Galois extension of L containing F then we could have used E instead of E in defining corLIF R. Replacing E by a field composition E E of E and we may assume E c E. Let G = G, and Gal(E/F), i? = Gal(E/L), and N = Gal(E/E). By Galois theory N G z G / N and H z H / N ; a,,. . . ,a, is also a transversal for G over H . Let R = @;=, o['(R @,E), and extend G to act on R in analogy to (1). We want to show R N z d canonically so that RG = (EN)’ % dG.To this end note a; R
oLE) z a;
(R
z a;'(R
oLE ) oEE ) % a; I ( R oLE ) oEa; 'E
a,, E ) BEE
so R z d &E. If a E N then aiu = c'ci for suitable 6’ in N so in applying (1) we see n = 1 and a acts like 100'on d B E E .Thus R N = d @ E N z d BEEz R canonically, as desired. Q.E.D. Corollary 7.2.21:
corLIFis a homomorphism from Br(L) to Br(F).
Proofi By using the same Galois extension E over F and the same transversal, we need only show that if d , and R2 are central simple E-algebras then (d, OER2)'= dy where G is a group of automorphisms of di for i = 1,2 which restricts to Gal(E/F), and G acts diagonally on d , 0 R2; but this is corollary 7.2.16. Q.E.D.
@,a:
Of course we would like to relate the corestriction to the restriction map Br(F) + Br(L). To this end we shall recall the skew group algebra R*G from definition 1.6.40; this is a free R-module of rank (GI. Proposition 7.2.22: Noration of proposition 7.2.14. If R is a central simple E-algebra of degree n then R G @,(R*G)"* z End, R . Thus R*G is a central simple F-algebra of degree /Gin, and R*G R G .
-
222
Central Simple Algebras
Proofi Define cp: R C + End, R by the right regular representation, and cp: (R * G ) O P 4End, R by I(/ r,o)r = 1 r,(or). Clearly cp and I(/ are injections whose images centralize each other, and [ R G : F ] [ R * GF] : =n2[R:F]IGI= n41GIZ = [EndFR:F]. Since R G is central simple we see by proposition 7.1.1(ii)that cp(R*G)OPis the centralizer of +RG; hence $(R*G)”” is central simple over F, and R G @ (R*G)OP z End, R 1, implying R C R*G. Q.E.D.
(c
-
-
Digression 7.2.23: Before proceeding further we would like to refer the reader to P. Schneider’s dissertation (1977), which also treats the corestriction algebraically, deriving the properties obtained here plus others. For example, given a group G of automorphism on K define Br(K)‘ = { [ R ] E Br(K):a-’R = R for all o in G}. For F = K C he obtains the exact sequence 0 -+ ker(res,,,)
4
Br(F)
Br(K)G-+ H,(G, K - ( 0 ) ) .
If K / F is cyclic then I = H ’ ( G , K - ( 0 ) )= H 3 ( G ,K the sequence is exact.
-
( O } ) , so in this case
Goldman ’s Element To proceed further we require some general results about central simple F-algebras. Let us view the reduced trace tr:R F as a map from R to R (since F G R). Since End, R z R @ R o P z R @ R as vector spaces over F, we have a unique element a = x i 0y i in R @ R such that tr(r) = x i r y i for all r in R. We call this Goldman’s element.
c
Proposition 7.2.24:
c
Goldman’s dement a E R @ R has the following properties:
(i) u z = I . (ii) a ( r l 0r 2 ) = (r2 0r l ) a for all r l , r 2 in R. (iii) If K splits R then viewing a @ 1 E ( R @ R ) @ K z M J K ) 0, M n ( K ) , we have a 0 1 = eij @ eji.
ci,
Proof:
(ii) a ( r l 0r 2 ) = x x i r , 0y i r 2 corresponds to the map r
H
C x i r , r y i r 2 = tr(rlr)r2,
and (r2 @ r l ) a corresponds to r H c r 2 x i r r , y i= r2 tr(rrl) = tr(r1r)r2; hence a(rl 0r 2 ) = ( r 2 0rib. (iii) a @ 1 is Goldman’s element for R @ K = M , ( K ) . But c i . j e i 0 j eji clearly yields the trace in M n ( K )so is a 0 1 by uniqueness. Q.E.D. (i) By (iii) we see 1 @ 1 = ( a @ 1)2 = a’ @ 1, so a’ = 1.
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
223
Goldman's element arose in the study of Azumaya algebras, cf., KnusOjanguren [74B, p. 1123 and Saltman [Sl], which extend many of the notions of central simple algebras to Azumaya algebras. Let us apply proposition 7.2.24 to higher tensor powers. Corollary 7.2.25: Consider the action of Sym(n) on R@,, by n(rl 0... 0r,) = r,, @ ... 0r,, . There is u group homomorphism tj:Sym(n) + Unit(R@')
given by
7c H a ,
such that a;'xa,
=
nx for all x in R@,.
Pvoof: Write R@' as R , 0... 0R, where each Ri = R. If n is the transposition ( i j ) then take a , to be the Goldman's element a of proposition 7.2.24 calculated in 1 0. . . @ 1 0Ri 0 1 . . . @ Rj 0 1 0. . . 0 1. Since every permutation is a product of transpositions, we can extend the definition of a, to all permutations, and well-definedness follows from the uniqueness of Goldman's element. Q.E.D.
Basic Properties of the Corestriction We are ready for the most important property of the corestriction. Theorem 7.2.26: cor res = [ L :F ] . More precisely, if A E Br(F) and L is a separable extension j e f d of F with [ L : F ] = t then corL,F(AOFL ) % A @ , . 0
Pvoofi Let R = A @ , L , and let E be the normal closure of L over F. Under notation of definition 7.2..19 there is a map cp: r? + A @ ,OFE given by @:= 0y,) 0Di) H(@:= ui) 0 a- '(ribi) where a, E A, yi E L , and pi E E, noting R is spanned by elements of the form a, 0y,. cp is visibly a surjection of F-algebras and is thus an isomorphism because [r?:F] = [ A @ "@ , E : F ] . Thus q - l ( ( @ a , ) 0 = @(ui 0/Ii) where PI = qfl and all other pi = 1. By ( 1 ) we get o ( @ ( a i 0pi))= @(a,,@ rip,,). Let j = ~ ' 1 . For all i # j we have ripni= ril = 1. Applying cp to each side defines an action of G on A @ ,OFE, by
,
n
a)
0B) = (@U,i) 0O j ' 7 j B n j = (@,i) 0OD, since aj'rjljxj = (a;'rj)qfl = aB. Thus G acts on A @ ,@ E. .((@.j)
(2)
In other words, let 6 denote the action of o on A@' by permuting the components according to the action of 7c on the indices; the action (2) is really the diagonal action . ( ( m u i ) 08) = .^(@ai)0OD, and under this action corLIF(A OFL ) z ( ( A @ ' )OFE ) G .
Central Simple Algebras
224
O n the other hand, we define G = 11 0 cr: cr E G}, a group isomorphic to G which also acts on A@' OFE, i.e., @((@ai)0 b) = (@ai) 0 ab. Obviously (A@'OFE)G z A@' OFEG x A@'', so we want to show (A@' OFE)' z (A" QF E)G or, equivalently, by proposition 7.2.22 we need find an isomorphism $ : ( A @ '0E)*G -+(A@' 0E ) * c . Now corollary 7.2.25 provides us a multiplicative subgroup { w,: cr E G } of A@' such that w i l x w , = i?x for all x in A@'.Thus for any u in G and any x in A@',B in E, we have a(x 0p) = W , l X W ,
Define $ by
c
0crb = (w, 0 l)-'a(x0 B ) ( W , 0 1 ) .
s,u
++
2s,(w, 0 1)-
a
for s, in A@"0 E. I(/ is a homomorphism which is invertible by inspection and Q.E.D. thus is the desired isomorphism. Corollary 7.2.27: lj'm is relatively prime to [ L : F ]then cor: Br,(L) is a retraction and, in particular, is onto.
-+
Br,(F)
Proofi Let cp: Br,(F) 4 Br,(F) be given by A + A @ ' where t = [ L : F ] . Then cp is an automorphism of Br,(F), and cor 0 res cp-l is the identity. Q.E.D. 0
Example 7.2.28: Let L = Q(p,pl,. .., p p )where p, p,,... , p p are commuting indeterminates over Q and c is defined on L by crp = p and api = pi+ subscripts modp. Let R = ( p i 1 p 2 , p ) " Then . corLiFR 1, seen either by direct computation or by proposition 7.2.32 below, but R is a division algebra. This shows cor: Br,(L) + Br,,,(F) may not be 1: 1 even when [ L : F ] is prime to m.
-
Remark 7.2.29: Suppose E / F is Galois with Galois group G,and R
E
Br(E).
-
(i) cor,,,aR % corEiFR for every cr in G. (ii) res cor R R’ = @ n E G aR.(Indeed, (i) is by definition 7.2.19, and (ii) translates to ’R OFE z which is proposition 7.2.14.) 0
One easy application of the corestriction enables us to throw out the "prime-to p" part. Proposition 7.2.30: Suppose R is a central simple F-algebra of degree p'. Then R is similar to a corestriction of a crossed product of degree a power of p.
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
225
Proofi Let K be a separable splitting field of R and E the normal closure of K over F. Let L be the fixed subfield of a Sylow p-subgroup H of Gal(E/F) and let m = [ L : F ] which is prime to p . E is a splitting field of R OFL , which thus is similar to a crossed product of degree p", and taking m’ such that m'm = 1 (modulo p") we have cor(R@"'O F L ) R by theorem 7.2.26. Q.E.D.
-
Digression: There are more cohomological definitions of the corestriction, based on example 5.2.13. Conceptually one defines the restriction map Res: H"(G, M ) -+H"(H, M ) for any subgroup H of G by viewing every complex over H in the natural way as a complex over G. At the 0 level this injects M G into M H . The map NGiHin the opposite direction is given by Nx = a i x where {q,. . . ,c,) is a given transversal of G; one extends this to a map cor: H"(H, M ) + H"(G, M ) by proceeding along an injective resolution. This formulation of the corestriction arose long before the concrete description we have used here. A computational cohomological definition is given in exercise 15.
The Corestriction of a Symbol These results become extremely powerful when confronted by the computation of the corestriction of a symbol, which we now perform.
Remark 7.2.31: If R = (u, /?),, is a symbol over E and 0 E Gal(E/F) then OR x (aa, a/?),by remark 7.2.18(i)(sending generator to respective generator). We return to the set-up of definition 7.2.19. Namely L is a separable extension of F, and E is the normal closure of L over F, so that E is Galois over F and G = Gal(E/F). We take a transversal a,, . ..,a, of Gal(E/L) in G. Given /? in L we define the norm NLIFIJ = oI/?...a,~; this is clearly independent of the choice of transversal. Also we now write (a, /?; L), instead of the symbol (a, /?), to specify that the center of the simple algebra is L, thereby removing possible ambiguity. ("Projection formula") Suppose a E F, /? E L , and F has a primitive n-th root 4' of 1. Then corLiF(a,/?;L), (u, NLIFP; F),.
Proposition 7.2.32:
-
Proofi (Schneider [77]; Tignol [85]) Let R = (u, /I; L),. Then R OLE x
(u, p; E),, so under the notation of 7.2.19 we have = @:= aL1(u,p; E ) , x @:=I(a,ail/?;E ) , . Take y,z in R such that zy = [yz, y" = a, and zn = p.
Central Simple Algebras
226
Letting y i , z i , respectively, be y 0 1, z 0 1 in the i-th tensor component ' p ; E), we see that ay, = y,, and az, = z,, in the notation of (I), where n is the permutation of the cosets of Gal(E/L) corresponding to a. It remains to show under this action that (a, NLIFB;F), I?*G, in view of proposition 7.2.22. To this end, letting Z = zI " ' z , = (z 0 1)@'we claim I? contains a set of invertible elements {Fa:a E G} satisfying the following properties for a11 a,? E G and all 1 Ii It :
(a, a;
-
-
rayi = ynirar I
Fa? = ?Fa and
Fa(aT;)= Far.
(3)
We shall call such a set a Tignol set. Given a Tignol set we define R,
=
F-subalgebra of k*C generated by E and the Fag.
R,
=
F-subalgebra of k*G generated by y , and Z.
R 3 = C~,,(R,R,). Let us compute R , , R , , and R , . R , 1; indeed ?,,a ++a shows R , x E*G which by proposition 7.2.22 is similar to EG = F. R , z (a,NL,,/3), since Zy, = [y,?, yy = a, and Z" = a;’/? = NLIFB. R , is split. Indeed, R , has degree n’-’ since deg(k*G) = IGJn', deg R , = /GI, and deg R , = n. On the other hand, let C = F(y,y;' ,..., y,y;') E R , . Each F(y,yT1)z F(") by lemma 7.1.13(ii) since (yiyy')"= aa-' = 1. Hence C x F ( " - ' ) so we are done by lemma 7.1.13(i). But R , , R , , R , centralize each other, so k*G zz R , Q R , 0 R , R , (a, NLiKB),, as desired. It remains to find the desired Tignol set. First note each y l ' y , acts on C (defined above) by left multiplication, and this action has order n since (yT1yi),= 1. By iteration one sees the fixed subring (without 1) under all these actions contains a nonzero idempotent which we call e. Thus yie = y,e for each i. Now for any t-tuple j = ( j (I), . . . ,j ( t ) )where 0 Ij(i) < n for each i, write ,i for zj(l).. . zp.Thus ziy,y;l = j j ( i ) - i ( l )yiy; lzi for each i 2 2. Define N
fl:=,
- -
ei
= z-iezj.
Each ei is clearly a primitive idempotent, and we claim the (ej:j(l) = 0) are all distinct. Indeed, otherwise, there is j for which zj commutes with e but j ( i ) # 0 for suitable i 2 2; then ylezj = ziy,e = zjy,e = jj(,)yiezi= ij"'y,ezi, contradiction. Since the primitive idempotents of C x F ( " - l ) are orthogonal and n’-’ in number, we see { ei :j ( 1) = 0} is a complete set of primitive idempotents of C. In particular, e = e, is unique, and thus ae = e for all a in G (since ae plays
221
87.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
the same role as e). Now we let
where n is the permutation on the cosets of H defined by c,and xj is defined as ( j ( z l ) , J ( x 2 ).,. .,j(nt)).Note a(zi) = z X iimplies c(z"j) = zj. Let us verify (3).
y y . = Cz-jeznjyi ( I 1
j
=
1
jj(ni),-iyieznj
=
Cr'
. -.
A n l ) Z J~
X l,eznj
. . 1z-JezXJ = yXiyu.
= yXi
r,? = .?yo since z' = z , " ' z , commutes with each zi and with each yiy;' (and thus with C ) . The last equation is trickier. First note ezje = zjeje = 0 unless j = 0. Also recall e is fixed by G.Now taking any h in G and its corresponding permutation p on the cosets of H we have
yUc(ir) =
C
z-ieznia(z-j'ezpi')
j(x1) = O , j ' ( p 1) =0
since we just saw that eznjz-"- 'j'e= 0 unless j'= x2j. But this shows Fuc(T;)= ror as desired, verifying (3). Furthermore, = x e j = 1; taking T = G - ' we see ruc(rr)= Fl = 1, proving each yo is invertible. Q.E.D.
- -
This is enough to prove a result of Tignol on the corestriction for cyclic algebras, cf., exercise 17; to proceed further we need to calculate cor(a,&,, when a $ F. Definition 7.2.33:
Given relatively prime polynomials f , g in F [ I ] define
the Rosset-Tute symbol
(9)
in Br(F) by induction on the length of factoriza-
tion of g into irreducibles in F [ A ] as follows, where n is fixed arbitrarily: (i) If g
=2
or g is constant then
(9
=
1
(ii) If g # A is monic irreducible then let L = F ( a )where a is a root of g, and
(iii)
(i)(%)(;). =
228
(?)f +
Remark 7.2.34:
gh =
(k),
Central Simple Algebras
in view of (ii).
Notation: If g = ~ p = u a i Awith i y,,ccu# 0 write Zj for a;' ~ p , u ~ i A i - u(i.e., = $ and the lowest coefficient is l), and c ( g ) for ( - 1)'a, E F. Note c(gW = c(g)c(h).
3
Remark 7.2.35: NL/,a- '.
In (ii) above we have Zj=g(O)-'g so c ( g ) = ( - l)deg(g'g(0)-l=
(); -
Lemma 7.2.36: (Rosset-Tate reciprocity law) -
(;)(c(a,c(f,);1.
Proof: The idea is to reduce quickly to (ii) and then apply remark 7.2.35 to manipulate symbols according to proposition 7.1.17. Explicitly, assume first g is constant or g = A. Then S = 1 so c(g) = 1 and every term is 1. Thus we may assume g # A is nonconstant; in view of (iii) we may assume g is monic irreducible, and so the constant term g(0) # 0. Then c ( g ) = NL,,a-' by remark 7.2.35. For any constant a in F we have by (ii) and the projection formula
(5)
4,
= corLjF(a,
since c(u)= a and
(!)
(0 -
= -1
(NLjFa.
a),
- ( ~ ( g ) , - (:)k(Y) Coil
= CorL/F(a,a)n corL/F(a,- 11, Iv
and
44);',
= 1 by (i). Likewise, using the fact (a, -a)
= (C(S),
since c(2)
-
(3
-
-
=
-
1 we have
( N L / F a , - l)n
(f)(c(g),c(A))i'
1
Thus we are done unless f # iis nonconstant, and it clearly suffices to prove the case f (as well as g) is monic irreducible. Let b be a root of f and let K be a field containing L = F ( a ) and L’ = F(b). Note NKjL(a- b) = f ( a ) . We have (a,a - b),-(a, 1 - a-'b),,(a, -a),,(a, - l),,. But (a, -a),, 1 (a-'b, 1 - a-'b),, so
--
(u,u-~),-(u, 1 -&'b),(a-'h,
1 -&'b),,(a, - l),,-(b, 1 -a-'b),,(a, - l),,. (4)
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
229
Interpretation of the Rosset- Tale Symbol Suppose [ L : F ] = t and 0 # a, b E L . Then NL,,,,,6 E F(a), so N,,,,,,b = f ( a ) for some f E F[A] relatively prime to the monic minimal polynomial g of a. Definition 7.2.33(ii) then says corLIF(a,hf, =
-
Theorem 7.2.37: (Rosset-Tare)corLIF(a, 6) @:= ,(c(gi),c(gi- where the gi are dejned as follows: go = g and g , = f chosen as immediately above; inductively if gikgi- then using Euclid’s algorithm write gi-l = qigi gi+ with deggi+ < deggi. In particular, k I degg I [ L : F ] .
+
Proof:
tyj (%) =
by remark 7.2.34, so the reciprocity law shows
230
Central Simple Algebras
The last nonzero gk is constant b y Euclid's algorithm, so we get the desired formula by starting with inductively.
tgil) ~
=
1, and
and plugging into (8)
Q.E.D.
Corollary 7.2.38: Suppose L is a separable extension of F and [L:F] = t, F containing a primitive t-th root of 1. Then for any symbol R =(a, b), in Br(L), corLiFR is similar to a tensor product of at most t symbols of degree n in Br(F), the jirst of which has the form (NLIFu,a), for suitable a. For t
=2
we have a stronger result.
-
Corollary 7.2.39: If [L: F] = 2, a, b E L, and char(F) # 2 then cor(a, b), (NLIFa,a ) OF(NLiFa', a ' ) for suitable a' E L, and a', a E F (which are all given explicitly in the proof ). If a E F or b E F then we are done by the projection formula so assume a, b 4 F. Let a be the nontrivial automorphism of L over F, and let g be the minimal polynomial of a; then g = (A - a ) ( i - aa). Now writing b = you + y1 for yo,yl in F we have f = yolz y1 as preceding theorem 7.2.37 so by elementary theory of polynomials we see the remainder g 1 obtained from dividing L j by f is Proof:
+
g2 =
g(-yl?O1)= ( N L / F a ) - l g ( - y l y i l ) -1
-1
= N.,F(~iyo a
= (NL/Fa)-lNL/F(-yIYil - a)
+ 1) = N L / F ( Y o ' ~ - ' ~ ) ,
so theorem 7.2.37 shows cor(a?b)2
(c(SkNL/Fa)2 @ (NL/FYi1a-1b,c(?))2,
yielding the desired result since Q
- QoP
for any quaternion algebra.
Q.E.D.
It would be extremely interesting to have a version of Rosset-Tate calculating the corestriction of a cyclic algebra when F does not contain primitive n-th roots of 1. Example 7.2.40: To see the sharpness of the Rosset-Tate theorem let Fo be a field containing a primitive n-th root of 1, let L = FOCIl,.. .,Atr p1,...,p r ]
57.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
23 I
where the ,Ii and pi are commuting indeterminates over F,, and let F = L" where 02, = ,Ii+l and api = pi+ (subscripts modt). Let R = (,I,,p1),,. By which is a division algebra. remark 7.2.29 res cor R (Al,pl),,@ . . - 0 (lLt,p,),, Thus cor R cannot be written as a tensor product of fewer than t symbols of degree n.
-
Other interesting immediate applications include the following cute result based on work of Albert, Perlis, Rowen-Saltman, and Mammone-Tignol. Proposition 7.2.41: Let R be a central simple algebra of degree n over u field F containing u primitioe n-th root of 1. Suppose R is split by a Galois extension K over F whose Galois group G has a cyclic normal subgroup H of order n, and suppose that 1 GI = pn where p and n are relatively prime. Then R is similar to a product of I ( p - 1) cyclics of' degreen n.
--
Proofi Let L = K H ; then [ K : L ] = n and [ L : F ] = p. R OFL is split by K , which is cyclic over L; hence R OFL ( K , 6,b) for suitable b. Writing K = L(y) with a = y" E L we have R OFL (a, b),,. By theorem 7.2.26 we have R B P corLIF(a,b), so R cor,,,(a,bP'f, where p'p = I(modn). Then corollary 7.2.38 shows R is similar to a product of at most p symbols, the first of which has the form (N,,,a, a),,. Thus we are done if we can show NLiFa is an n-th power in F, for then (&,,a, a) 1. Write H = (c) and take z E G of order p. Note 7C1c7 = CJ"for u satisfying U P K 1 (mod n). We may write cy = [y where [ is a primitive n-th root of 1; then m y = 70"y = ["zy so 7y = cy" for suitable c in L. Hence y 7 y . * . r P - ' y ~ Lyy". . . y"" - ' = Ly' where t = 1 f u + ... + u p - l = ( u p - l)/(p - 1) = 0 (modn), implying y7y...rP-'y is some element y of L . But NLiFa= a 7 a . ' . ~ ~ -= ' ay " F,~ so y E F as desired since n is prime to p = [ L : F ] . Q.E.D.
-
-
-
Corollary 7.2.42: When p = 2 and n is odd we see any central simple algebra of degree n split by the dihedral group of order 2n is cyclic, cf., exercise 19. In fact, by exercise 19 one can choose b such that L(b"") is Galois (dihedral) over F ; then NLIFbis an nthpower so now in [he notation of corollary 7.2.40 we hace 2 cor(a, b)n ( N L I F Y O ~Y Y ' 7 0 ) (71 Yo),. 51
-
t
Theorem 7.2.43: (Mosrly Rosset) Suppose p = degfR) is prime > 2 and F has a primitive p-th root of 1. Then R is similar to a product of ( p - 1)!/2 cyclic algebras of degree p.
232
Central Simple Algebras
Proofi We start as in proposition 7.2.30. Let E be the normal closure of a separable splitting field K of F. We assume the “worst” case, i.e., Gal(E/F)= Sym(p), which contains a dihedral group H of order 2p; let L = E H . Then R OFL is cyclic by corollary 7.2.42. But [ L :F ] = ( p - 1)!/2, which is prime to p, so R is the corestriction of a symbol (from L to F). We conclude by Q.E.D. applying theorem 7.2.37.
Central Simple Algebras with Involution A major application of the corestriction is a description of central simple algebras with involution, thereby explaining a lovely body of results of Albert whose previous proofs had been very computational in nature. We shall describe the “modern” aspects of the theory, leaving some of the older computational results to the literature (or to the exercises). The key to this subject is the following connection with the exponent.
Theorem 7.2.44: A central simple algebra R has exponent 2 iff R has an involution of the Jirst kind.
-
-
Proofi (t) Any involution is an anti-automorphism, so clearly R z RoP as F-algebras, implying R 0 R R 0 RoP F. (3) Let K O be a maximal subfield of the underlying division algebra of R , and let (cijk)be a Brauer factor set of R with respect to K = KE .We use the notational hypothesis 7.1.33, i.e., R = K r K , E is the normal closure of K O , and r = (rij). Since R RoP we see by proposition 7.2.8 there are yij in E satisfying the conjugacy conditions such that
-
ckji
-1
= cijkyijyjkyik
‘
Note, in particular, ciii= ciiiyii so yii = 1, and ciji = cijiyijyjiyG’ yielding (9)
y lJ. . yJ I. . = y . I.1= 1 .
By theorem 7.1.37 we can view R as { ( b i j r i j ) eMJE): the conjugacy conditions}, where rij = cijl. Define (*) on R by -
(P..r..)* Y lJ = (Pijrij) -
Pij satisfy
the
-
where Pij = Pjiyij.
Then (P..r..)** = (P..r..)*= (P.. ..r..)*= (P..y..y..r..) = (Pijrij)by (7). ?I lJ IJ V J ~ Y ~IJ J 11 J 1 Y V Furthermore, if (&rij) = (Pijrij)(Bijrij) so that P i = xi= Pijcijk/3Ljthen
233
57.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
=
(cbjkcikj?ik?kjflLirij) k
=
(c
bjkcjkib;iYijrij
proving (*) is indeed an anti-automorphism of degree 2.
Q.E.D.
The next result enables us to focus on a particular subfield when dealing with involutions.
Proposition 1.2.45: Suppose (0,*) is a central division algebra with involution and K is a subfeld of D having an automorphism cr of order 5 2, such that (*) and CT agree on E Then D has an involution whose restriction to K is CT.
-
Proofi By Skolem-Noether the isomorphism K -+(OK)* given by a (.a)* extends to an inner automorphism of D, i.e., for suitable d in D we have (aa)* = d-'ad for all a in K . Then d*d-'a(d*d-')-' = d*(aa)*(d-')* = (d-'(cra)d)* = (c(cra))** = a for all a in K , implying d*d-' E C,(K). Let A = C,(K). Thus d* E Ad so d* d E Ad. Since d could be replaced by any element of Ad we may use d + d* or d - d* in place of d , and certainly one of these is nonzero. Hence we may assume d* = +d, in which case D has the involution ( J ) given by x H d x * d - ' . But now aJ=da*d-' =d(d-'oad)d-' = Q.E.D. cra, for all a in K . A further refinement is given in exercise 26. We shall use the following observation to pass to involutions of the second kind. Remark 7.2.46: (i) If R has an involution (*) of the first kind, and if K is a quadratic extension of F with nontrivial automorphism CT over F, then (*) Q cr is an involution of the second kind on R QFK . (ii) Suppose, moreover, K is a subfield of R and the restriction of (*) to K is IT.Then (*) restricts to an involution of C , ( K ) of the second kind over F. The tie to the corestriction actually comes with involutions of the second kind, via corestricting along a quadratic extension. Remark 7.2.47: Suppose [ L : F ] = 2 with 1/2 E F, and write Gal(L/F) = { l,o}. In the notation of 7.2.19 we have I? = R @ OR, and o acts on I? by o(rl Q r 2 ) = r2 Q r l . Thus corLiF is spanned by { r Q r : r E R } , for if x = x r i l Q riz E cor R then 2 x = C ( r i l @ r i 2 + r i 2 @ r i 1 ) = C ( ( r i+1 r i 2 ) @ ( r i l+ r i 2 ) - r i 1 @ r i l - r i z @ r i 2 ) .
234
Central Simple Algebras
Theorem 7.2.48: (Albert-Riehm-Scharlau) Suppose [ L : F ] = 2 and R is a central simple L-algebra with an anti-automorphism (*) which restricts to the nontrivial automorphism a of L over F. Then there is ro in R for which -1 r** = rorrO for all r in R. Any such ro satisfies r:ro E F, and writing a = ror: we have COTLIF R ( L ,a,a). a quaternion algebra.
-
The existence of ro is by the Skolem-Noether theorem applied to Then
Proofi (*)2.
(ro) * - Ir * r *o
= (row;')* = r*** =
ror*ril
for all r in R , implying r:r, E Z ( R ) = L. But r:* = rilrOrO= ro so letting a = r:r0 we see a = a* and thus a E F. I@* Let q~ denote the composition R 0a R R 0 R o P zEnd RL 5 End R,, and let Q be the centralizer of cp(cor,,, R ) in End R,. Then q(cor,,, R ) 0Q z End R,: counting dimensions we see Q is a quaternion algebra over F, and
-
V ( C O ~ L ,,F. . R QoP )
N
Q.
We want to display Q explicitly. Note cp is given by q ( r l 0 r z ) u = rlurz where r i , u E R ; thus by remark 7.2.47 we see f E Q ifff commutes with all cp(r 0r), i.e., f ( r v r * ) = r( f u ) r * . In particular, Q contains the left regular representation of L , since L = Z ( R ) . Hence L is a maximal subfield of Q. Also Q contains the map z : R -+ R given by u H (oro)*,since
(riir*ro)*= rgr**v*r*
= y*r 0 0 rr-' o
u *r *
= arrilo*r* = rarolu*r*
= rr;u*r* = r(urO)*r*
Since z z v = ((uro)*ro)*= r:ro(uro)ril = au we see (taking u = 1) that z z = a; furthermore, z(Pv) = /I*zu, so conjugation by z induces a on L , and thus we have displayed Q as ( L ,0 , DL). Q.E.D. Before applying this theorem let us list two facts whose easy verifications are left to the reader.
Remark 7.2.49: (i) Any involution (*) of R extends to M,(R) by (rij)*=(rft). (ii) If a division ringD has an antiautomorphism (*) satisfying d** = ada-' for all d in D and if a* = a-l then D has an involution given by d I+ (1 + a)-'d*( 1 + a).
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
235
The converse to remark 7.2.49(i) relies on the structure theory of central simple algebras (cf., exercise 24) and actually is false for Azumaya algebras.
-
Theorem 7.2.49': Suppose [ L : F ] = 2. A central simple L-algebra R has an involution (*) of second kind over F iff corLiFR 1.
-
-
Proof: (=) ( * ) 2 = 1 so take ro = 1 = a ; then corLiFR (L,u,l) 1. (e) (Scharlau) In view of 7.2.49(i) we may replace R by its underlying division algebra. By hypothesis has a set of matric units and is thus split, so O R RoP,yielding an anti-automorphism (*) of R over F. Taking r o , a as in the theorem we have (L,a,cr) split so a = NLiFP for some P in L. Replacing ro by P-'ro yields rgro = 1 so we get the desired involution by remark 7.2.49(ii). Q.E.D.
-
Theorem 7.2.50: Suppose R is a central simple F-algebra which conrains a quadratic j e l d extension K of’ F. The following assertions are equivalent:
(i) exp(R) = 2. (ii) expC,(K) = 2, and CR(K) has an involution of second kind over F. (iii) C,(K) has an involution of second kind over F.
-
Proof: (i) (ii). By proposition 7.2.45 there are involutions and (*)2 of R of first kind, whose respective restrictions to K are the identity and the nontrivial automorphism over F. The respective restrictions of and (*)2 to C , ( K ) are involutions of the first and second kinds, and exp CR(K)=2 by theorem 7.2.44. (ii) * (iii) a fortiori. (iii) *(i) C R ( K ) R OFK so R B 2 cor CR(K) 1. Q.E.D.
-
-
-
Passing to the centralizer of a quadratic extension of the center will be a very useful inductive procedure. The last ingredient to be analyzed here is the type of involution. Suppose R has an involution (*) of the first kind. By theorem 2.13.21 and definition 2.13.27 (*) has either orthogonal or symplectic type. However, these results do not lend themselves readily to computation. It is more convenient to tensor by the algebraic closure F of F and pass to ( R OFF, *) z (M,,(F),*) since the type is preserved under tensor extension; now using theorem 2.13.29 and example 2.13.22 we may replace (*) by the transpose ( t ) or the canonical symplectic involution (s), cf., example 2.13.6, depending on whether (*) has orthogonal or symplectic type, respectively.
236
Central Simple Algebras
According to exercise 26 one may also choose the type of (*). Although it is tempting to choose orthogonal type since the transpose is so familiar, symplectic type has a significant advantage. Proposition 7.2.51: Suppose the division algebra D has a symplectic type involution (s). Then for every (s)-symmetric element d the characteristic values of d occur in pairs, and d has degree 5 4 2 , where n = deg D.
Proofi Splitting by the algebraic closure we may assume R=M,,(F) and
(s) is the canonical symplectic involution. Extend (s) further to M,(F[A])
by putting As
= A,
and view d i n M,(F[l]). Let a =
(-: i).
and d e t a = 1. But ( 2 - d ) ’ = A - d so (a(A-d))‘= - a ( A - d ) Hence the characteristic polynomial
Then as = -a
by remark 2.13.5.
det(l-d) = detadet(2 - d ) = deta(2 - d ) =
fz
by Jacobson [85B, theorem 6.43, where fd is called the PfafJian of a(2 - d ) . Hence fd(d)2 = 0 in D so fd(d) = 0; since det(2 - d ) = f : we conclude its roots occur in pairs and are the characteristic values of d. Q.E.D. This result holds more generally for arbitrary central simple algebras, as can be seen using exercise 28; a direct computational approach is given in Rowen [80B, p. 1431. The Pfaffian leads one to believe many properties of M,,(F) will be inherited by (M,,(F),s) where s is a symplectic involution. In fact, Rowen proved in analogy to theorem 7.1.45 that every simple algebra of index 8 and exponent 2 has a splitting field with Galois group (Z/2Z)(3’ over F and is thus a crossed product. The proof given in Rowen [80B, theorem 3.2.401 is rather computational; a proof using Brauer factor sets is given in exercises 29-32.
The Merkurjev- Suslin Number We turn now to the most important theorem in the theory of central simple algebras. The Merkuqev-Suslin theorem is really a result linking the Brauer group to algebraic K-theory, as is explained in appendix B. We are interested here in its algebraic content, which is Merkurjev-Suslin “onto part”.
I f F has a primitive m-th root of 1 where
237
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
m = exp(R) then R is similar to a tensor product of cyclic algebras each of degree dividing m. (This is easy ,for R cyclic, c j , exercise 18.)
Digression. The assumption that F has a primitive m-th root [ of 1 is crucial because it enables one to deal with symbols. This raises the question of what happens when [ 4 F. The case m = 3 is easy, cf., exercise 34, and Merkurjev [86] has shown that if F ( [ ) / F is cyclic (which is often the case, e.g., when m is not divisible by 8) then R is similar to a tensor product of corestrictions (from F([) to F) of symbols. Thus the major remaining question here is whether the corestriction of a symbol from F ( r ) to F is similar to a tensor product of cyclic algebras. The following elementary computation is quite relevant to this discussion, showing us how to "push" elements of a symbol into a smaller field.
-
Remark 7.2.52: Suppose [ K : F] = 2. For any a, b in K there are a, fl in F for which (a,b), (a,p), 0 (a, fl-'b),. (Indeed, this is obvious unless a, b are independent over F. But [K: F] = 2 so a-'a fl-'b = 1 for suitable a,p in F. Then 1 (a-la, b), (a,b), 0 (a,fl-'), 0 (a-l,fl-'b), as desired.)
-
a-1
-
+
Important. One of the chief applications of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem is that the Brauer group is divisible in the presence of enough roots of 1. Indeed, the problem of finding the p-th root of [R] is reduced to the case when R is a symbol (a,&,, whose p-th root was computed in proposition 7.1.17(viii) to be (a,&, when F has a primitive pm-root of 1. Further results concerning divisibility are in exercises 35-38'. The remainder of this discussion is spent on the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem; we shall prove several special cases (also, cf., exercise 18) but not the theorem itself (although we give parts of the proof). We start with a related notion. Definition 7.2.53: R is decomposable if R = R , 0 R , with R , , R , # F. R is exp-decomposable into cyclics if R is a tensor product of cyclics each of degree dividing exp(R).
The Merkurjev-Suslin theorem says for any R we can find t such that M,(R) is exp-decomposable into cyclics; we shall call the smallest such t the Merkurjev-Suslin number p(R). It is useful to consider the degree, and we define p ( n ) to be max(p(R):deg R = n ] . In appendix C we shall see p(n) = p(UD(F, n)) and thus exists.
238
Central Simple Algebras
Our objective is to compute upper bounds for p(n) for various n prime and n = 4, thereby proving the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem in these cases. Lower bounds for p ( n ) are obtained in Tignol-Amitsur [ 8 5 ] by the following approach: If p(R) = t and deg(R) = n then the direct product of cyclic subfields of the cyclic components provides an abelian splitting field of dimension tn over F ; they prove this is impossible for certain R if t is small enough. In particular, p ( p 2 ) > 1, cf., digression 7.1.21. Remark 7.2.54: p(2) = p(3) = 1 by theorem 7.1.44. Question 7.1.31(ii) can be rephrased as, “Is p ( p ) = 1 for all primes p?” p ( p ) Ip(P-1’!/2by theorem 7.2.43.
Reduction 7.2.55:
(i) I f n = nln2 for n,, n2 relatively prime, then
P(4 = P ( n M n 2 ) .
(ii) To prove the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem (and find an upper bound for p(R)) we may assume exp(R) is prime. Proofi (i) by theorem 7.2.13. (ii) by (i) we may assume index(R) = p j for some prime p , so exp(R) = p” for some u. We argue by induction on u; we are given the case u = 1. exp(RBP)= p ” - ’ so by induction is similar to a central simple algebra R , exp-decomposable into cyclics. R, has a p-th root R, by remark 7.2.52. Thus R, which is exp-decomposable (R 0 R 2 ) @ P 1 so by hypothesis R 0 R, Q.E.D. into cyclics, as is R”,P 0 R, R.
-
-
-
Digression 7.2.5.5‘: We may assume R is split by a field K Galois over F of dimension a prime power (and thus solvable). This is seen easily by applying the corestriction to a Galois splitting field to remove the prime-to-p part, via theorem 7.2.37. Digression 7.2.55“: We may assume R is split by a field whose Galois group over F is a direct product of copies of Z / p Z This reduces the theorem to the study of abelian crossed products, cf., exercise 7.1.14, and it is hoped that their explicit description in Amitsur-Saltman [78] may soon lead to an elementary proof of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem. See exercise 33 for the proof.
57.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
239
Define p(p,p') = max{p(R):deg(R)= p' and exp(R) = p ) . We have an upper bound for p( p , p ) = p( p), but do not know how to arrive at arbitrary p'. However, when p = 2 one has the theory of algebras with involution at our disposal, and algebraic proofs of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem (onto part) are available, cf., Wadsworth [82]. (In fact, this case was Merkurjev's original theorem.) We shall carry out the theory for low values of j , both as a relatively easy illustration, and also because the results themselves have some merit. Assume char(F) # 2. Clearly p(2) = p(2,2) = 1. Lemma 7.2.56: (Albert's descent) Suppose Q is a quaternion K-algebra with involution (*) of second kind such that F = Z(Q,*). Then there is a quaternion F-algebra Qo such that Q % Qo OFI<. Furthermore, given any d = d* E Q we may choose Qo such that d E Qo.
Proof: If Q is split then take Qo = M , ( F ) ; hence we may assume Q is a division algebra. Take d l = d f # 0 in Q; then d , is quadratic over F. There is d , for which d,d,d;' = - d , ; replacing d , by d , f d ; we may assume d r = d,. Then d z E Z ( Q , *) = F so d , , d , generate the desired quaternion Q.E.D. subalgebra Qo. Theorem 7.2.57: (Albert)p(2,4) = 1, i.e., every division algebra D of degree 4 and exponent 2 is a tensor product of quaternion subalgebras. Proof: D has a maximal subfield K I K , where each [Ki:F] = 2, by theorem 7.1.45. By proposition 7.2.45 we may assume (*) induces the nontrivial automorphism of K , over F. Let Q = C,(K,), and apply the lemma to get Q.E.D. Qo; then Q1 = CD(Qo)and D z Qo 0 Q1. To push on to degree 8 we need some results about symbols, again assuming characteristic # 2. Lemma 7.2.58: Suppose the symbols (a1,P1),x (a,,j32)2 are not split. Then there is a E F - ( 0 ) for which ( a , ,Pl), = (a,&), z (a,p,), = ( a z ,/3,). Proof: Take y i , z i in (ai,Pi), for which y' = ai,z! = &, and ziyi = -yizi. Since (alrfl1),z ( a , , ~ , ) , we can work in the same algebra (al,&),. Let y = [ z , , ~ , ] .I f y = 0 then F ( z l ) = F(z,) so z1 E F(z,) and the assertion is trivial. (Just take a = q.)So assume y # 0. Then ziy = -yzi by inspection for i = 1,2; furthermore, y has reduced trace 0, being a commutator, implying y 2 = a E F for some a. Thus we have exhibited (a,,B1)also as (a, & ) and as (a,,&). Q.E.D.
240
Central Simple Algebras
Lemma 7.2.59: (Tignol) Suppose R is simple of exponent 2 and possesses an involution (*) of second kind with F = Z ( R , *); furthermore, assume there are quadratic Jield extensions K , , K , of F such that K = K , K , Z is a splitting jield of R where Z = Z ( R ) . Then there are quaternion F-algebras Q,, Q,, Q3 such that M , ( R ) % Q1 OF Q 2 0 Qs O FK. Proof: Write (a, j3) for (a,b),. By theorem 7.2.57 R is a tensor product of two quaternion algebras (over Z) split respectively by K, and K,; writing Ki = F(&) for a i E F we thus can write R as (a1,c1)Q(a2,c2) where c l , c 2 E Z. On the other hand, R has an involution of the second kind, and letting o be the nontrivial automorphism of Z over F we have ( a l ,N,c,) 0 (a,, N,c,) corZiFR 1 by theorem 7.2.49'. But these are quaternion algeand there is a such that bras so letting fli = N,ci we have ( a , , b J % (CI,,~,), (ul,bl) = (a,bl) (a,/3,) = (a,,P,) by lemma 7.2.58. Hence
-
-
=
M , ( F ) =: (a,a,B1) = (a,a,P,)
=
(C%Blb2)9
implying (a,a,c,), (a2a,c2),and ( a , c , c , ) each has involution of second kind over F, again by theorem 7.2.49'. Let A, = (ala,cl),A, = ( a 2 a , c 2 )and , A 3 = (a,c1c2).Then A , 0 A, 0 A ,
-
((a,,cl) 0 (a,cl)) 0 ( ( a 2 c,) , (a1,cl) 0 ( u 2 ,c2)8 (a2,cl)
( a l , c l )0 ( a , , c , ) 0 F 0 F
0 (a,c 2 ) )0 ((u,cl) 0 (u,c2)) 0 ( a 2 ,c2)
-
R.
On the other hand, we can write Ai = Qi QF Z by lemma 7.2.56 where Q i is a quaternion algebra over F, so R Q, Q Q, QFQ3 QFZ, as desired. Q.E.D. N
A little extra care in the proof would have enabled us t o choose Qi to be split by Ki for i = 1,2.
Theorem 7.2.60: (Tignol) If R has degree 8 and exponent 2 then M , ( R ) is decomposable into quaternions. In other words p(2,8) 2. Proof: We may assume R is a division algebra. By Rowen's theorem (exercise 32) there is a maximal subfield K = K , K 2 K 3 where each [Ki:F] = 2. Let R , = C R ( K 3 )Then . R , has an involution of second kind over F and exp(Rl) = 2, so by lemma 7.2.59 M 2 ( R 1 )= Q , Q Q2 @ Q3 Q F K 3 for suitable quaternion algebras Qi over F. Let Q4 be the centralizer of Q1QQ,Q Q 3 Q.E.D. in M , ( R ) . Then M , ( R ) x Q1 0 Q, 0 Q 3 0 Q4.
$7.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
241
Amitsur-Rowen-Tignol [79] proved p(2,8) > 1, so by Tignol’s theorem p(2,8) = 2. We can apply the above theory in a lovely result of Snider.
J-1
Theorem 7.2.61: If E F then p(4) I 16; in fact, any division algebra of degree 4 is similar to a tensor product of a cyclic algebra of degree 4 and
four quaternion algebras. Proof: If exp(D) = 2 then p(D)= 1 by theorem 7.2.57. Thus we may assume exp(D) = 4. Then D 0 D has exponent 2. Furthermore, we claim index(D 0 D) = 2. To see this note D has a subfield K quadratic over F by theorem 7.1.45, so index(D O F K )= 2 and thus (D 0 D)OFKz (D OFK)@”is split. Hence we can write D 0 D rz M 2 ( Q )where Q = (ct, p)2 for c1, p in F, so Q has a square ~ . (D 0 R)@’ (Q 0 Q ) 1. But D and R each contain root R = ( c x , ~ )Thus K so D 0 R has zero-divisors, i.e., we can write D 0 R z M2(D1) where D, has degree 8. By Tignol’s theorem M,(D,) z Q10 Q2 0 Q3 0 Q4 for quaternion algebras Qi. Hence D RoP0 Q10 Q2 0 Q3 0 Q4. Q.E.D.
-
-
-
This proof contained an exponent reduction argument which is peculiar insofar as the index goes up (to 8 here).
“Proof” of the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem (onto part) Fix a prime p . Assume F has a primitive p-th root of 1, and write Brcyc(F)for the subgroup of Br(F) generated by symbols of degree p , i.e., the classes of algebras which are tensor products of cyclics of degree p . Also given L 2 F write R , for R OFL. We shall use the exponential notation A“ for oA and AU- 1 for AoP0 oA. Let us prove the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem (onto part), modulo
-
-
Missing Link 7.2.62: Suppose LIF is cyclic of degree p, and [A] E Brcyc(L). If cor,,,A 1 then A ( A ’ ) “ - ’ 0 C, where [ A ’ ] E Brcyc(L)and [ C ] E Brcyc(0 Note: The “missing l i n k is true since it follows readily from the MerkurjevSuslin theorem (1: 1 part) applied to Hilbert’s theorem 90 in K-theory (cf., appendix B). However, Hilbert’s theorem 90 in K-theory is very difficult, as is the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem (1:1 part). Thus an algebraic proof of the “missing link” would certainly revolutionize the subject. Note that for p = 2 the hypothesis says A has an involution of second kind over F, but the result still seems very hard to prove directly; we have obtained the special cases deg(A) = 2 or 4 (in which case A’ I).
-
Central Smple Algebras
242
Since 1 0 o acts on R , we have RZ z R, for any R in Br(F), implying
R U - 1
L
-1.
We turn to the proof now that any R in Br(F) is exp-decomposable into cyclics. By reduction 7.2.55(ii) we may assume exp(R) is prime; in fact, by digression 7.2.55' we may assume R is split by a Galois extension K of F of dimension p' for some t. We induct on t. Since Gal(K/F) is a p-group there is a subgroup of index p; let L be its fixed subfield, which is Galois of dimension p over F, and let cr generate Gal(L/F). Now let A = R,. A is split by K and [ K : L ] = p ' - ' , so by induction on t we have [ A ] E Brcyc(L).Furthermore, cor A cor res R R B P 1 so by 6 C, for suitthe "missing link" we have A (A')OP@ o A ' 6 C, = able A', C as above.
-
-
- -
-
Claim 1: If B E Br,(L) then B ( a - l ) P - l (cor B),. Proof of Claim I : (0
- l)(aP-'
-
--
-
-
B("- ')' BUp-'* 1 since Br,(L) is p-torsion. But = 1 so B ( ' - l ) p - l BUP- + ... + 1 res cor B (cor B),
+ ... + 1)
by remark 7.2.29.
-
-
Claim 2: For each i I p - 1 there is B in Brcyc(L)and C in BrcYc(F)such that A C, @, BtU-')'.Furthermore, if i = 1 we can take C 1 .
-
Proof of Claim 2: For i = 1 we are done taking B = A'. In general we proceed by induction on i. Suppose we have found B and C such that A C, 0, B'" - for i < p - 1. Then B ( U - l ) i +@C;-1 l B(u-l)i+l 1 RZ-1 = AU-1
-
-
-
-
9
so 1 B ( U - l ) p - l (cor B ) L by claim 1 , and thus cor B is split by L. Write L = F(a) where oa = [ a and CL = u p E F. Then cor B = (a,p), for suitable p in F, and by the projection formula (a,p), = cor(a, &. Hence cor(B @ (a,fl)Opp) 1 so the "missing link" yields B
-
-
(a,
a), 0 (B')"-
0 Ct
where [B'] E BrcYc(L)and [C']
Substituting back yields A
-
E Brcyc(F).
-
~ , ~ , ( ~ ~ ~ ( U , ~ ) ~ ~ ( B cL@(a,fl):-l)i@ ' ) B - ~ ) ( ~ -B'''-l)i+'. ' ~ ~
-
Now (a,&-' (a-’oa,& the claim is proved.
- ([,p),
which is a restriction since
[,P
E
F;
243
57.2 The Brauer Group and the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem
Claim 3: There is C in BrcYc(F), and B in Brcyc(L)such that A -(C@cor
Proof of Cluim 3:
Apply claim 1 to claim 2 for i
=p
-
-
B)L.
1.
-
To conclude the proof we note (Rop0C 0cor B)L AoP0 (C 0 cor B ) L 1 so RoP0 C 0 cor B is split by L and thus similar to some cyclic C'. Hence R C 0 C' 0 cor B. But B E Brcy,(L),so R E Brp,cyc(F) by theorem 7.2.37. Q.E.D.
-
Digression: p- Aigebras A p-algebra is a central simple algebra of degree a power of p , having characteristic p ; p-algebras fill the gap in the theory developed here so far. Ironically the theory of p-algebras is easier than the characteristic 0 theory, largely because of the use of derivations in key places, and one might hope for a proof of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem by passing to modulo p . (This is yet to be done.) Many of the characteristic 0 techniques can be modified for characteristic D.There is a p-symbol (cf., exercise 7.1.8) and a corresponding version of the Rosset-Tate theorem, cf., Mammone [86]. Some of the highlights of the p-algebra theory are outline below; the reader should consult JAC-SAL for details.
Teichmuller's theorem: [JAC-SAL, theorem 4.2.221 Suppose K is a purely inseparable splitting Jield of the p-algebra R , and K = K,(a) for some a such that u p E K O .If i p n - c1 is the minimal polynomial of a over F and if K O is not a splitting field of R then there is a cyclic algebra (L,a,a) of degree p" for which R 0 (L,a,a-') is split by K O .(The case n = 1 is exercise 7.1.8.) On the other hand, purely inseparable splitting fields of p-algebras exist [cf., JAC-SAL, theorem 4.1.151, and, in fact, the minimal dimension of such a splitting field is the exponent of the algebra. Thus an induction argument applied to Teichmuller's theorem shows that every p-algebra is decomposable into cyclics. This was known by Albert, who proved a stronger result [cf., JAC-SAL, theorem 55.71:
Albert's theorem: The tensor product of cyclic p-algebras is cyclic. Consequently every p-algebra is similar to a cyclic p-algebra!
244
Central Simple Algebras
A good bound for the degree of the cyclic algebra is found in Mammone [ 8 6 ] , using the corestriction. (This theorem is false in characteristic 0, cf., digression 7.1.21 .) Thus we are left with the old crossed product question. The first noncyclic division p-algebra was only constructed in 1978 by Amitsur-Saltman [78] and is a rather delicate matter, using abelian crossed products. Soon thereafter Saltman [78] extended their result and found a noncrossed product division p-algebra of degree p3. It is still unknown whether or not any p-algebra of degree p is cyclic. Saltman has recently devised a theory which shows the theory of crossed products is characteristic-free, but his methods do not seem to extend to the Brauer group.
87.3 Special Results In this section we obtain examples of indecomposable algebras and noncrossed products of low exponent, based on an example of Brauer. These method should lend some intuition into the workings of division algebras. In order to get the noncrossed product results we need a "generic" division algebra of given degree and exponent, which is developed in appendix C. Lemma 7.3.1: Suppose K has an automorphism a whose order n is a power of p, and F = K" has a primitive m-th root iof 1 where m I n. Let K O be the fixed field of a""". Then K = K,(a) for some a in K satisfying a"/"'a = [a and aa = aa, for suitable a, in K O . Furthermore, No(ao)= [ for any such a,, where No denotes the norm from K O to F.
Proofi Let u = n/m. K = Ko(a) with aua = [a by Hilbert's theorem 90 (cf., Jacobson [85B, theorem 4.351). Then u'(a-'aa) = (oua)-'ou+'a = ([a)-'o([a)= a-'oa, proving a-laa E K O . Thus c a = aa, for some a, in K O . But then [a = a"a = oU-'(aa,) = o'-2(aaooao) = ... = aNo(a,), proving N,(a,) = i. Q.E.D.
Brauer 's Algebra The underlying example is a cyclotomic algebra discovered by Brauer. Fix a prime number p , and in general write in for a primitive n-th root of 1. All numbers q. n, t to be considered are powers of p greater than 1. Exampfe 7.3.2: Given q, n, t with n 5 t I qn write Eq,t= 0([,)(pl,. ..,p()
57.3 Special Results
245
where the p i are commuting indeterminates over Q. E,., has an automorphism a of order t, which permutes the p i cyclically and fixes 5;, let Kq,n,tbe the fixed subfield of Eq,, under a". Thus a restricts to an automorphism of order n on Kq,n,t,so we have the cyclic algebra R,,"., = (Kq,n,,,a, 5,). When n = t then K,,",, = E,,,, so R,,"." = (&,a, [,). Brauer proved R,,"," is a division algebra, as shown in JAC-SAL; we shall repeat his proof in slightly greater generality in order to handle other examples, following Rowen [82]. We retain the above notation in what follows.
Remark 7.3.3: i,is not an nth power in Eq,,. Otherwise ( f g - ' ) " = [,for suitable f,g in O([,)[pl,. . .,p,]. Then f = [,g" so letting a, p be the leading coefficients of f , g , respectively, (under the lexicographic order) we see a" = [$";thus 5, = (ap-')" in a([,), which cannot be, since Q([,) does not contain a primitive pq-root of 1 by Jacobson [85B, theorem 4.211.) It follows at once that if i is a root of A" - [,in an extension field of E,," then [ is a primitive nq-root of 1. Lemma 7.3.4:
Suppose t 1 qk and klt.
(i) For any j there is a suitable power [ of [+for which aka = [ a for all a in Hi. (ii) For any j there is some homogeneous b in H such that bHj E Kq,k,,and Hjb
Kq.k.t.
Proofi
1 so ak induces a transformation on each q whose order di(i) vides t/k and thus divides q; hence V, has some eigenvector ui, i.e., akui= [(i)uifor some power [(i) of i n , k . But { u E q:aku = [(i)u} is a a-submodule of for if cku = [ u then ak(au)= a k f l u= a([u) = [(au); since r/; is simple as a-module we see a'u = [ ( i ) u for all u in q. But now taking [ = [(l)j(')... [(u)"") we see aka = [ a for all a in Hi= V { ( ' ) .. . Vj'") u . (ii) Continuing the proof of (i) we see that if [ ( i ) is a characteristic root of H then so is its complex conjugate [ ( i ) = [ ( i ) - ' ; thus [(i)-' = [ ( i ' ) for suitable i', giving rise to b, in 5, with akbi = [ ( i ' ) b i .Letting b = b{("... b','"' we see b is homogeneous and akb = [-’b;hence ak(ba)= [-’[ba = ba for all a in Hj, implying bH,E K,,',,. Likewise ab E Kq,k,t. Q.E.D.
v,
Remark 7.3.5: Consequences of lemma 7.3.4(i): (i) Each Hi is a 0-module. (ii) Either Hin K,,",* = 0 or Hjc K q , n , f .
246
Central Simple Algebras
(iii) If a E H and aka = [a then akaj = [aj for each component aj of a. (iv) H n Kq.n,t inherits the grade of H (seen by taking k = n and ( = 1 in (iii).) We want to use this set-up in Rq,",,= (Kq,n,l, C J , ~ ~To ) . this end write Rq,n.r= Kq,n,cz,iwhere zaz-I = ca for each a in Kq,,,( and Z" = Let W = x(H A K q , n , r ) ~For ' . any r in Rq,n,,there is c in W-(0) for which cr = aizi for suitable a, in HnKqVn.,, i.e., cr E W. Thus W is an order in Rq,n,f, which we shall call the Brauer order of Rq,".,.We "grade" W according to the grade on H, i.e., put 4 = { c a i z iE W each ui E Hi}. We shall call this the Brauer grade on W,given w E W we say the leading term of w is the nonzero component in &, for j maximal in N(")according to the lexicographic order.
xyid
c,.
IT:,'
Proof.-
(i) Let R' be the centralizer of z d . R,,,,,, = @ ::: K q , n , l as ~ i a vector space over F, so conjugating by z d we see R' = @ ::: Kq.d,tzisince Kq,d,t is the subfield fixed by ad. Furthermore, ( z ~ ) "= / ~Z" = cq, so Kq,d,,(zd) FZ Kq.d.r(cqn,d) = KpnIdsd, ,, seen by counting dimensions over Kq,d,t.Hence d- 1
R' =
@ Kq,d.,(zd)zi i=O
d- 1
@ Kqn/d,d.tZ'
i=O
= Rqn,d,d.t.
The notion of passing to the leading coefficient lies at the heart of the matter and often enables us to pass from Eq.t to F. However, we want to work in Rq.",,,and therefore need more structure. Let Fo = Q([,) and H = F o [ p , , . . .,p,], which is N-graded with respect to total degree. Then the Fopi is a a-module, by which we mean OH, = HI; 1-component H, = thus we can view HI as F,[l]-module by ( I a i l i ) x= c a i a i x for ai in F, and x in HI. Since a’ = 1 we see At - 1 E Ann HI, so HI is a module over FOIL]/(l' - 1); writing Fo[A]/(Ar - 1) as a direct product of fields L , x ... x L , by the Chinese Remainder Theorem and letting = LiHl we see H , = V, 0 ... 0 V , and the are simple as a-modules. Since the i.e., are vector spaces over Fo we can grade H lexicographically by the given j = ( j (1), . . .,j ( u ) ) in N(")we put H~ = v;'".. . ~ Uj @. )
v,
57.3 Special Results
247
Remark 7.3.7: Remark 7.3.5(i) shows zHj = Hjz for all j , implying 4 + j . ; i.e., the Brauer grade on W is indeed a grade.
q
c
We shall usually analyze Rq,n,Iby passing to W, relying heavily on the fact Rq.n.Iis the ring of central fractions of W. Lemma 7.3.6 can be used to set up an induction via "leading terms," provided k (in lemma 7.3.4) is less than n. Taking k = n / p the hypothesis of lemma 7.3.4 now says pt I qn, so we put m = qn/t 2 p and prove
Theorem 7.3.8: Let m = qn/t. Rq+n,Iis a division algebra of degree n and exponent m whenever m 2 p. (In particular exp(R,,,,,) = 4.) Proof: First we prove Rq.n,tis a division algebra, by induction on n. Take R as above. Obviously Rq,l,fis a field, so assume n > 1. Suppose ab = 0 in W. Passing to leading terms we may assume a,6 are homogeneous. Thus a E Hjzi and 6 E Hj.zi = c i z i H j . for suitable j, j', cf., remark 7.3.7. Taking k = n/p in lemma 7.3.6(ii) we have homogeneous a', 6' such that a'a E K,, nip. I ~ and i b6' E Z ~ K , . , /I .~ ,But these centralize z"/P so in C,(z",P) z RP4,n,p,I we have (a'a)(bh')= 0; by induction a'a = 0 or 66' = 0, implying a = 0 or 6 = 0. This proves W is a domain and thus Rq,n,fis a division algebra of degree n. It remains to show exp(R,,,,,) = m. Let K = and let K ' be the fixed subfield of Eq,I under diq.Since t/q n we see K' c K , and, furthermore, iq=N,,,,(a) for suitable a in K', by lemma 7.3.1. Thus 1;: = NK,/,(a)"' = NKiF(a), proving exp(R,,,,,) 1 m by Wedderburn's criterion. To conclude the proof it suffices to show R:$l'p) is not split. By lemma 7.3.6 (noting rn/p = q(n/pt)
c
xi
xi
1
R:j;/P)
% RPfifl.n. I
@Q,,,,,")Q(r,).
[Q(l,): Q(4'pf,,,)] = m/p < n, and Rpfin,n,I is a division algebra of degree n, so we see the right hand side is not split, as desired. Q.E.D. Note: The proof of theorem 7.3.8 shows index(R:AT/P)) = n/(rn/p)= pn/m = pt/q, and the same argument (cf., corollary 7.3.10 below) shows that each p-tensor power reduces the index by the factor p , until finally the index plunges to 1 at the last stage. A little-asked but interesting question is "What is index(R)/index(RBP)for a given central simple algebra R?" This question has more than passing interest, because of Remark 7.3.9: Suppose D is a division algebra with deg(D) a p-power, and deg(D) I p index(DBP).Then D is indecomposable in the sense that D cannot
248
Central Simple Algebras
be written as D , OFD2for D , , D 2 # F. (Otherwise D@', % D Y p 0 D F p so index(DmP)I index(DYp)index(D'f'P) 5 (deg(Dl)/p)(deg(D2)/p)5 deg(D)/p2, contrary to hypothesis.) Corollary 7.3.10: Rq,n,fis an indecomposable division algebra of exponent m = qn/t whenever m > p.
-
Proof: Write R, for Rq,n,r, fixing n and t. We shall verify remark 7.3.9. Indeed by lemma 7.3.6 we have R:if Rq,P,n,f 63 Q([,). But [Q([,): Q([,,)] = p and = n/p since R,,P,n,I is a division algebra thus index(R:i,) 2 index(R,,,,.Jp (by theorem 7.3.8). Q.E.D.
The Brauer division rings can also be used to construct indecomposables of exponent p, but the situation is rather more intricate, as reflected in the fact that whereas every algebra of degree 4 and exponent 2 is decomposable, we shall find indecomposable division algebras of degree pz and exponent p for odd primes p. Thus we need to differentiate between 2 and the odd primes. This is hardly surprising in view of the fact the Galois group of [a([,,): Q] is cyclic for n odd but is the direct product of Z/2Z and a cyclic for n a power of 2 (cf., Jacobson [85B,p. 2763); we shall ultimately rely on this fact. The sibling question to indecomposability is the crossed product question. As a byproduct of this analysis, we shall construct a division algebra of exponent p which is not a crossed product with respect to the group (Z/PZ)(~) for p odd; this leads to a noncrossed product of exponent p and degree p3, cf., appendix C.
p - Central Sets We say an element r in a central simple algebra R is p-central if rp E F - (0) but r 4 F. The use of p-central elements has already pervaded our discussion of crossed products and of decomposability into cyclics, and we now provide a uniform treatment which will be useful in discussing examples. Assume throughout that F has a primitive p-th root [ of 1.
Definition 7.3.11: We say elements r,r' of R are [-commuting if rr' = ['r'r for some i. A subset S of R is p-central if (1) Each s in S is p-central. (2) Any two elements of S are [-commuting.
$7.3 Special Results
249
(3) For any s,s’ in S there is some invertible element r in R-(0) for which rsr-l = s and rs'F1 = is’. We say S is strongly p-central if, furthermore, we have the condition (4) If s,, ..., s , ~ S a n d y , = s P ~thenyr'"...y:'"isnot F ap-thpowerinF unless each u(i) is divisible by p .
Example 7.3.12: (i) The symbol (a,B), has the p-central set (s,,s,) where sy = u, s; = p, and s2sl = (sls2. (ii) If R , Q R , is a division algebra and Si is a strongly p-central set of Ri for i = 1,2 then S, u S2is a strongly p-central set of R , 0 R2.In particular, any division algebra which is a tensor product of t cyclics of degree p has a p-central set of order 2t. (iii) If a subfield L of R is Galois over F with Galois group (Z/pZ)(') then L has a commutative strongly p-central set of order t. (Indeed L = L , ... L, where Li = F(ai) and a! E F ; then { a l , .. ., a t } is the strongly p-central set.) Condition (3) of definition 7.3.1 1 is included to ensure s # Fs'for s,s’ in S and usually follows automatically from the Skolem-Noether theorem. Condition (4) is included to provide the following converse of example 7.3.12(iii).
Remark 7.3.13: If S is strongly p-central then each F(s;(').. . s;(,))is a field extension of dimension p over F. (Indeed, we want to show the polynomial f = 1"- ? U ( 1 ) . . . y ;'" is irreducible over F. Let a be a root of an irreducible factor of f, and let K = F(a). Then f has the p distinct roots ["a, 0 Iu < p, each in K , proving [ K : F ] = p so f is irreducible.)
,
Our object is to show any strongly p-central set S gives rise to something like example 7.3.12. To this end write S = {s1,s2,. ..); given j = (j(l),j(2), . . .) with 0 I j(u) < p and almost all j(u) = 0, write si for the product sf1)sf2). . ., and g for the set of all these si.
Proposition 7.3.14:
$ , is independent over F. In particular Igl I [ R : F ] .
Proof.- Otherwise take a nontrivial dependence relation c u i s l = 0 with a minimal number of terms, which we rewrite more suggestively as uisi = 0 with u1,u2# 0. Multiplying through by sy-'sl we may assume s1 = sl. If each si is a power of s1 then [ F ( s , ) :F ] p, contradicting remark 7.3.13. Thus we may assume s2 is not a power of sl, implying by (3) there is r in R for
-=
1
250
which rslr-'
Central Simple Algebras
and r3,r-l
= s,
O
= is,.
= C a i s i-
Now
r C a i s i r p l= C ( l - Cu'i))aisi, i> 1
a dependence relation of shorter length, contradiction. Corollary 7.3.15:
Q.E.D.
Is1 = plsI.
Now let us write a strongly p-central set S as {sI,..., s,}, and let I? = x { F s : s E 3). Obviously I? is an F-subalgebra of R with [ I ? : F ] = p', so any p-central set in I? having t elements is maximal. One easy way to produce a new strongly p-central set is to take {sls:,s2,.. .,s,} for any i ; rearranging the order of the elements of S and iterating this procedure enables us to modify S by taking suitable products of its elements. Let us define the center Z ( S )to be { z E S : zs = sz for all s in S } . By the manipulation just described we might possibly increase IZ(S)l; we say S has best possible form if IZ(S)l is largest possible. Proposition 7.3.16: Suppose S is a strongly p-central set of best possible form, with IZ(S)l = k. Then I? as dejined above is decomposable as a tensor product R1 @F"'@FR,@FF,
where each Ri is cyclic of degree p over F, Z ( S ) ,and m = (t - k ) / 2 .
is t h e j e l d generated over F by
Proof: Write S = {sl,. . . ,s,} such that Z ( S ) = { s , - ~ + , , . . . , s t } . Note by remark 7.3.13 that F is a field. We are done if k = t so we proceed by induction on t - k, assuming t > k. By hypothesis we may assume s1 does not commute with s,; replacing s, by a suitable power we may assume s2sl = [s,s,, so the subalgebra R , of I? generated by s1 and s, is visibly isomorphic to the symbol (y1,y2)p (where yi = sp) and is thereby cyclic. Now write s3s1 = {"s1s3 and s3s2 = CVs2s3, and let s; = s:s<-"s3. Then s; commutes with s1 and s,; replacing s3 by s; and repeating this procedure for each i we may assume si commutes with s1 and s2 for all i > 3. Let I?, be the subalgebra of I? generated by S - { S , , S , ~ . Then R, centralizes R , , and {s3,..., s,} is a strongly p-central set for R , implying [I?,:F] = p'-'. Hence [ I ? : F ]= [I?,: F ] [ R , :F ] so I? = R , @,I?,. By induction we can Q.E.D. write I?, z R , 0 .. . @ R , @FF,and the assertion follows at once. Digression 7.3.17:
If S is only required to be p-central then in proposi-
47.3 Special Results
25 1
tion 7.3.16 we can only conclude F is a direct product of fields over F and thus is Azumaya. The only reservation with proposition 7.3.16 as a converse to example 7.3.13 is condition (4),which, of course, is apparent if R has no zero divisors, cf., digression 7.2.13’.
The Leading Monomial Technique Structural questions require considerable information about the subfields. There are two available methods: One way is to obtain precise information about all the maximal subfields, using cohomological and arithmetic techniques, cf., Tignol-Amitsur [ 8 5 ] , [86]. The other method is to obtain precise information about certain maximal subfields and to show how this information can be passed on to all maximal subfields of a related algebra. More explicitly, we can start with an algebra R in hand, modify it slightly, and then using “leading monomials” land in a specific subalgebra of R ; thus we exploit what is already known about R . We shall develop this method for R cyclic, following Rowen [ 8 2 ] (which unfortunately is marred by an error, leaving a gap when p = 2), and thereby obtain the desired indecomposability and crossed product results. The general setup: Given R = ( K ,a, a) of degree n and exponent rn, where F = K“ contains a primitive root i,, of 1, we assume p2 In. Let K O be the fixed subfield of K under an’p.Then [ K : K O ] = p so K = K o ( k )for suitable k in K with anlpk= [,k. Thus ak = a,k for some a , in K O ,by lemma 7.3.1. Write R = I ; Z , ’ K z ‘ where Z ” = M and zaz-‘ = aa for each a in K ; then z k z - ‘ = ak = a,k so z k = a,kz. Letting R , be the subring of R generated by K O and z p ,we can identify zniPwith in R , since snip = 1 on K O ;and thus R , % ( K , ( G I ’ / ~a) ,,a”p), a cyclic algebra of degree n/p2 over its center F(M’/”). If n = p 2 then R , is isomorphic to the ring Ko(crllP). We assume throughout Ro is a division ring. This is a rather mild assumption, which for n = p2 merely says a is not a p-power in K O .
Remark 7.3.Z8: ( R , k’zj)(R,k”z’’) = R , k i C i ’ z j + T since zk = a,kz. Thus R is (Z/pZ)‘2’-graded, by R , = R,k’zJ. The idea is to reduce questions to homogeneous elements under this grading, to which end we introduce indeterminates. Working in R(A,,A,) = R OFF ( A l ,A,) where A,,A, are commuting indeterminates over F we extend a to K ( & , A 2 ) by putting aAi = Ai for i = 1,2 and
Central Simple Algebras
252
define k‘ = ki., , a’ = an;, z‘ = 21,. F’ = F(1:,1;), K b
=
Ko(iL{,l;),
and
K’ = Kb(k’).
Then ak’ = (ak)il = aokl, = aok’ so a restricts to an automorphism of K‘, whose fixed field is F‘.Our object of interest is
R‘ = ( K ’ , a, a’), which can easily be identified with the subring of R(A1,A2) generated by K ’ and z’, since (2’)“ = a’ and conjugation by z’ induces the automorphism 0 on K’. Note R , is a subalgebra both of R and R‘. Let A be the subring of R’ generated by K,[1:,15], k’, and 2’. R’ is the central localization of A at F[AT, A<] - {0},so we can study the structure of R‘ in terms of the structure of A, which is “,’-graded according to the lexicographic order in degree of Al and 1,.For any f in A write v( f )for the “leading” monomial under this “,)-grade; since A1 is “attached to k and A, is “attached” to z we see v ( f ) must have the form rkizjl:Li for suitable r in R , where 1 5 i, j I p. Thus we have Remark 7.3.29: If f # 0 then v ( f ) is invertible; also v(f1f2) = v(fi)v(f2). If f E Z ( A ) then v ( f ) E F’. (Indeed, the first assertion is obvious. To check the last assertion it suffices to show v ( f ) commutes with every monomial g in A. But then g = v(g) SO v(S)g = v(f)v(g) = v(fg) = v(gf) = v(g)v(f) = g d f ) . )
Remark 7.3.20: Let tr denote the reduced trace. Then tr(v(f)) = v(tr(f)). In particular, if tr(f) = 0 then tr(v(f)) = 0.
Proposition 7.3.21: dividing m.
R’ is a division algebra of degree n and exponent
Proofi Suppose f1f2= 0 in R‘ with f l , f 2 # 0. Clearing denominators we E A. But then 0 = v(flf2) = v(fi)v(fi), contrary to v(fi), may assume f1,f2 v(f2) invertible (by remark 7.3.19). To check exp(R’) I m we write a“ = N,,,(a) for some a in K , and thus (a’)”’ = NK,,,JaL:), noting i;= E F’. Q.E.D.
We shall want to obtain precise information about leading monomials of elements of degree p. Given f in A writejfor the coefficient of v ( f ) (in R), i.e., the “leading coefficient” of f.
87.3 Special Results
253
Remark 7.3.22: Suppose f is a monomial and [F‘(f):F‘] 5 p . Either or f E F’. (Indeed, write f = rkizjAiA$. If p I j then 1 and f are F‘-dependent, seen by matching coefficients of A,, so f P E F‘; likewise, if p I i then f E F’. But if p I i and p I j then f E R , . )
f~ R ,
Proposition 7.3.23: Suppose tr(f ) = 0 and [F’(f): F’] = p. Then [F’(v(f )): F‘] = p ; furthermore, if v( f ) p 4 F‘ then f E R,. The minimal polynomial of v( f )can be obtained as follows:
I;=,
Write cifi = 0 for suitable ci in A n F‘, and take the leading monomials among the terms to get ~ ; ~ , c i o fv) (i = 0. (When nonzero cio = v(ci), but various cio can be 0). Proof: The last assertion is clear, and some cio # 0. If cpo= 0 then [F’(v(f)): F’] p ; but R‘ is a division algebra so [F’(v( f )): F’] divides n, a power of p , implying v( f ) E F’, contrary to tr(f ) = 0. Thus v ( f ) has Q.E.D. degree p, and in fact f E R , or ~ ( f E) F’, ~ by remark 7.3.22.
-=
Corollary 7.3.24: I f L’ is a subjield of R’ of degree p over F’ then there is f in A n L‘ such that F’(v(f )) is a Jield extension of F’ of degree p. Proofi Take f in A n L‘ having reduced trace 0, noting char(F’) # p , and apply proposition 7.3.23. Q.E.D. Our machinery is to be applied to p-central sets. However, we must first know they exist and thereby confront the possible discrepancy between subalgebras of degree p and cyclic subalgebras of degree p . For p = 2 or 3 this is not a problem since every algebra of degree 2 or 3 is cyclic. However, for p > 3 we need a method of reducing to the cyclic subalgebra case; this is done in the next proposition, which relies on the following useful result of Wedderburn, proved in exercises 7.1.15- 7.1.18:
Wedderburn’s Factorization Theorem: For any element d of a division ring D the minimal polynomial of d over Z ( D ) can be factored as ( A - d,)...(A - d , ) where each di is a conjugate of d. Proposition 7.3.25: Suppose R’ is a tensor product of F’-subalgebras of degree p. Then R‘ has two commuting cyclic F’-subalgebras of degree p.
254
Central Simple Algebras
Proof: Let R;, . . .,R: be the given central subalgebras of degree p which centralize each other; we shall find cyclic RY,. .. ,R; in R’ which centralize each other. Write R; = ( K , , q , a , ) and pick dl E A n K , with tr(d,) = 0. By Wedderburn’s result the minimal polynomial of d , is of the form (3, - dp)-..(A - d , ) where each di = rid,rF1 for suitable ri in R , . Thus ri has degree p , and we may assume ri E A ; furthermore, multiplying through by a suitable central element (the product of the “denominators” of the di)we may assume each di E A n R, . By proposition 7.3.23 the minimal polynomial of v ( d , ) is (A - v ( d , ) ) . . * ( 1 - v ( d 1 ) ) ;since char(F‘)# p we see d , cannot appear as a multiple root, so v f d , ) ,. . .,v(d,) are distinct. But d 2 r 2 = r 2 d l implies v ( d 2 ) v ( r 2 = ) v ( r 2 ) v ( d l )so v ( d , )does not commute with ~ ( r , )and, , consequently, v ( d , ) and v(r,) generate a noncommutative subalgebra R‘,‘of R’. R‘,‘is a division algebra since R‘ is. Let n , = [RY: F ] . We have n, 2 p 2 , and we shall now prove equality. , Obviously R‘,‘ is spanned by the monomials in v ( d , ) and ~ ( r , ) e.g., ~ ( d ~ ) ~ v ( r , )and v ( dso ~ )forth. But R; is spanned by the monomials in d , and r 2 , and so p 2 + 1 of them are dependent; taking the “leading part” of a dependence relation in R’, yields a dependence relation in RY, so any p 2 1 monomials in v ( d , ) and v ( r 2 ) are dependent, proving n , 5 p 2 as desired. Hence n , = p 2 , so R‘, is F’-central of degree p . Now applying “leading monomials” to each of the RI in turn we have F’-central algebras RI’ each of degree p , generated by elements which we now call v ( d l i ) and v ( r l i ) .By proposition 7.3.23 we see R ; is cyclic (using remark 7.1.15) unless iIi E R, and Fli E R,. Thus we are done unless u - 1 of the Rf‘ lie in R,(A;,A<). But then degR,(Ay,A;) 2 pu-’ = n/p, contrary Q.E.D. to deg(R,) = n/p2.
+
Proposition 7.3.26: Suppose n = p 2 . Let N denote the norm from the j e l d R, = K , ( u “ ~ )t o F(aliP).If R’ has a central simple subalgebra of degree p then N(a)cr”P E F for some a # 0 in R , .
Proof: Let R, be a central simple subalgebra of R‘ of degree p and R, = CR,(R,).Then R’ % R , 0 R, and by proposition 7.3.25 we may assume R,,R, are cyclic; thus we have a p-central set of 4 elements. Taking the leading monomials gives us a strongly p-central set v(S);taking their products 1 2 ’ gives us a set of p4 linearly independent elements s, = ruki(u)zi(u)~i(u)lj(u) 1 5 u 5 p4, where each :s E F‘ and the s, [-commute, cf., proposition 7.3.14. We may assume 0 5 i(u), j ( u ) < p , and we claim for any given (i, j ) there are at most p 2 elements s, with i(u) = i and j ( u ) = j ; indeed, otherwise, we may
57.3 Special Results
255
+
assume i(u) = i and j ( u ) = j for 1 I u I p 2 1, in which case s;’s, E R, for 1 I u 5 p 2 1, implying [ R , : F ] > p 2 , contradiction. Now by counting we have exactly p 2 elements s, for each (i, j ) such that i(u) = i and j ( u ) = j ; in particular, taking i = 0 and j = 1, we have some su= Q.E.D. r,zA2, so N(ru)ul/pA: = s," E F', implying N(r,)alIPE F, as desired.
+
This norm condition ties in with the following arithmetic result. Proposition 7.3.27: In example 7.3.2 suppose p is an odd prime, qnlt = p and q 2 p 2 . Write N f o r the norm with respect to us/p.Then N ( K q , n , , ) ~ q n K , l p ,=O. n,p,,
Proofi Straightforward, but rather long with all the gory details: Let H, = Q(Cq)[pl,.. .,p,]. We want to prove the impossibility of a , N ( h , ) = a2N(hz)Cq,
(1)
where h,,h, E H,, h,h;' E Kq,n,lrand a l , a 2 E Hqip. We may assume a l , a 2 are relatively prime, and writing hi as a product of di irreducibles in H,, that d , 2 d , . We shall induct on d l . First assume d , = 0, i.e., h,,h, E Q(Cq). Then (h2h;1Cpq)p= ala;' in Q(Cpq) which is cyclic over Q(Cq/p). But ala;' E Q(C,,J; thus h,h;'[,, E a((,)(the unique subfield of Q(),[ of dimension p over Q(Cq/p)) implying C, E Q([,), which is false. Thus we may assume d , # 0. Write the factorizations h , = and hz = n g i for f i ,g i irreducible. Each f; and gj are relatively prime, for, otherwise, we could cancel fi from h , and gj from h, and still have (l), contrary to minimality of d , . But f;/ gi = o " ( nf;/ gi) = o"jJ oRgiso that we see fi)( o"gi) = gi)( 0%) and thus f , divides some 0%. a([,)is cyclic over Q(Cqfl/,), of dimension q/p = t/n. Let T be the generating automorphism, viewed as an automorphism of Hq over H p . Note T commutes with o.gzipn fixes a , and a,. Write f , , for ~'"~~"f,. We claim f l is associate to some gJ"/Pfi.If not then f , is not associate to f l o = f, (seen by taking i = 1 and j = 0), implying the f l u are not associate; furthermore, .f, does not divide ojniPh,for any j . But fl 1 a, implies f l l ) a 2 so f I l ) N ( h , ) a , by (1); hence f l l la, so f l o ~ ~ ~ f l , p divides -l both a, and a,, contradiction. Repeating this argument shows for each i there is suitable i’ and j' for which z'lpnfi is associate to some aJ'"'Pfi.. But then we could cancel f l o . "f1,,- from h , and N ( f , , ~ ~ ~ f , , ,from ~ , ) a, unless some repetition occurs, i.e., indeed some f l u is associate to some aj"/pfi
nfi
(n n
n n n
n nn (n
,
,
,
Central Simple Algebras
256
Let 7’ =
and of = ojniP,and write r’fi = aolfl for suitable a in Q([,). Then
r’Yl
= T’(cdf1)
= (r’ct)n’~’f~ = (a~’a)o’2f,.
Iterating the procedure yields f, = (at‘aT”a.. .( T ’ ) ~ -‘ a ) f 1 .Thus a7’a. . * = 1, so by Hilbert’s theorem 90 there is some p in Q(lJ for which u=(z‘p)- ‘p. Now T‘(fi.ll) = (T‘B)aolfi=
P.’fi
=
o’(8fA
so N(pf,)is fixed under T ’ . Thus we can cancel jflfrom h, and N(Bfl) from a 2 . Proceeding in like manner with each on% enables us to shrink the length of h , , contrary to assumption. Q.E.D. We are ready to combine the various techniques to produce the desired examples. Theorem 7.3.28: Suppose R = Rq,n.pqis Brauer’s division algebra, where p is odd prime and n = p 2 . Then R’ is indecomposable. Proofi If R‘ were decomposable then we would have N(u)[,E F by proposition 7.3.26; this is impossible by proposition 7.3.27 (replacing q Q.E.D. by pq, and n by p ) . Digression 7.3.29: For p = 2 one would of course need to take n = 8 = p 3 . An indecomposable example was found in Amitsur-Rowen-Tignol [79]. In Rowen [82] an alternative is sought, relying on an analogue to proposition 7.3.27, but now the argument seems to me to be flawed, although possibly salvageable. Let us turn to the crossed product result. The methods are largely the same, but the use of the Brauer grade is more intricate for the twofold reason that we are working in higher degrees but with more restricted p-central sets. Theorem 7.3.30: p is an odd prime. Suppose qnlt = p , and n = p 3 . Let R = Rq,n,r.Then R’ has exponent p but is not a crossed product with respect to (Z/pH)‘3’.
Proof: On the contrary, assume R’ has a commuting p-central set S = {sl,s2, sj}; furthermore, there are r, in R such that r,s, = [ps,r, and rus,= s,r, for all u # u. Replacing s,,r, by v(s,),v(r,) we may assume s, = v(s,) for 1 I u I 3. Write s, = d,ki(”)zj(”)where d, E R , and 0 I i(u),j(u)s p - 1 . Rearranging the s,, and if necessary using sI to cancel out k, we may assume i(u) = 0 for all u > 1. Let Lo be the subfield of R spanned by all su,u > 1. If
87.3 Special Results
257
zniP $ Lo then we could replace s1 by z " / ~On . the other hand, if znipE Lo then (by Galois theory) zniPis a product of powers of the s,,u > 1, so we could then i(1) = 0 since s, commutes with each s,, assume some other s, = and we could interchange s, and s,. In this way we may always assume s, = Z"'P. Kq,n+r is cyclic over F and thus has some element y $ F with y p E F. Repeating the argument of the previous paragraph we may assume s2 = y. Note y commutes with zp. Thus we have attained Reduction I : R' has a commuting p-central set {sI,s2,s3} with s, = zniP and s2 = y. Let K i be the fixed field of Kp,n,r under a"""’, e.g., K O is as previously defined, and let be the subring of R generated by K i and z. Thus To 3 TI 3 T2.... Now view To as the cyclic algebra ( K , , O , [ ~=~ RPq,nlp,f, ) giving rise to a new Brauer order and Brauer grade. Since s3 E R, c To we may multiply by a suitable element of F to assume s3 is in the Brauer order of To,and take its leading component s;. Note (s;)~ E Z(T,) = F(zp2). Clearly s; E T,kb for some i, where k , E K O with kP, E K , , but s; E R, so matching powers of z shows s; E R,ka where R , is the subring of R generated by K , and z p .
+
Reduction 2: sj $ Z(R,). For suppose s; E Z(R,) and write sj = s; b and let b' be the leading term of b. Then (s;)~ p ( ~ ; ) ~ - ' b... = ss E Z(T,) so subtracting (s;)P and taking leading terms shows p ( ~ ; ) ~ - ' Eb 'Z(T,) and thus b' E Z(T,)s;. Continuing down the line shows b E Z(T,)s; so s3 E Z(T,)s; L Z(R,). But Z(R,) is spanned by the products of powers of s, and s 2 , contradicting proposition 7.3.14. R, is the field K , ( z P )which is Galois over F(zP).If s; E R , then s; E Fy"zPj for suitable u, j ; multiplying s3 by a suitable power of s2 = y we may assume u = 0. On the other hand, if s; $ R, then 1 I i < p . In these two respective cases we see s; and k,, or s; and z p , generate an F(z"'P)-central subalgebra of To of degree p, so its centralizer W has degree p. Furthermore, y E W so there is some w in W for which wy = [,yw. But w commutes with z p so is in T,; writing w = wizi for wi in K , ( z ~ we ) see C w i y z i = y w = [ j ' w y = C [ b w i y z i = C [ b - ' w i y z i , so matching components yields w = w l z . But then N ( w , ) z P = w p E F ( Z " ' ~ )contrary , to proposition 7.3.27. Q.E.D.
+
[;'
+
I::,’
Noncrossed Products of Prime Exponent We turn to the question of determining noncrossed product division algebras of arbitrary exponent. Inspired by Amitsur's noncompatibility results
258
Central Simple Algebras
we should look for two division algebras of exponent p and degree pi, one of which is a crossed product only with respect to the group ( b / p H ) ( ‘ ) and the latter of which is nor a crossed product with respect to ( Z / p B ) ( * )The . former is provided by theorem 7.1.29, and the latter by theorem 7.3.30 when t 2 3 (for p odd). To finish the argument one needs some sort of “generic” of exponent p and degree p’, which will fill the role UD(F,n) played in the “comparison” lemma 7.1.27. There is a more general construction (cf., appendix C) which works for any exponent, thereby yielding
Theorem 7.3.31: There is a noncrossed product division algebra of degree p 3 and exponent p , for any odd prime p .
Appendix A: The Arithmetic Theory and the Brauer Group One of the most important areas of recent investigation in finite dimensional division algebras has been the generalization of valuation theory from fields to division algebras, thereby enabling one to apply standard arithmetic techniques to division rings. Although the scope of this book does not permit a close look at this subject, let us glance at its highlights. An (exponential) valuation on a division ring is a function v : D - ( O ] + G where G is an ordered group called the valuation group such that
The valuation ring R of D is ( r E D:u(r)2 0} and is clearly seen to be local with maximal ideal M = { r E D : u(r) > 0). R I M is called the residue division ring. Although G is not required to be abelian in this generality, we still have used + to denote its group operation. Example A l : Suppose Do is a division ring with valuation u: Do + G, and (T is ari automorphism on Do such that v ( a d ) = u(d) for all d in Do. Let D = D o ( ( A ; ~ ) )i.e., , D has the additive structure of the skew Laurent series ring Do((A)), but additive structure given by Id = (od)A, cf., definition 1.6.39. Ordering Z x G lexicographically, we define the valuation v on D by i7( d i n i )= (r, u(d,)).
xi,,
Appendix A: The Arithmetic Theory and the Brauer Group
259
In case Do is a field and CJ is an automorphism of order n one sees without difficulty that Z(D) = Z,((L"))where Z, is the fixed field of Do under CJ, so [D:Z(D)] = n z and D has degree n. In particular, if Fo is a field containing a primitive n-th root [ of 1 we could take Do to be the field of Laurent series F,((p)), where CJ is given by c ~ p= [p. Note Do has the valuation given by u(Ctrj a j p J )= j , so D has valuation group Z x Z. More generally one could iterate this construction for any abelian group G and form an iterated Laurent series division ring, in analogy to example 7.1.16. The advantage of this construction is that valuation theory is now available. Amitsur [72] exploited this fact; for a detailed exposition see Jacobson [75B, pp. 94- 1033. Recently Tignol-Amitsur [85] have found a cohomological description of this division ring, cf., exercise 7.2.1 1. Suppose now D is a central division algebra of degree n over F. A valuation u on F extends to D iff u extends uniquely to each maximal subfield of D, cf., Wadsworth [86], so in this case the structure of D is likely to be closely bound to those of the maximal subfields. A classic instance is when F is complete with respect to a discrete valuation u, since then u extends uniquely to all finite dimensional field extensions of F, cf., Jacobson [80B, theorems 9.5 and 9.121; then Hensel's lemma applies, cf., Jacobson [80B, p. 5731. We say a field F as above is a local ,field if the residue field is finite; examples include the field of p-adic numbers Q, or a field of Laurent series over a finite field. In this case D has a maximal subfield W which is an unramified extension of F, cf., Jacobson [SOB, theorem 9.211 or Reiner [75B, p. 1451. Extending u to a valuation of W and letting W,F be the respective residue = q" for some n, so by Hensel's lemma fields of W and F, let q = IFI; then 1 W is the splitting field of the polynomial Aq" - A over F. In particular, W is uniquely determined up to isomorphism (and thus up to conjugation in D by Skolem-Noether), and one shows easily Gal(W / F )z! Gal(W/F). Since the latter group is generated by the Frobenius automorphism CJ: a H a4 we see D z! (W,CJ, a) for suitable a. Note that W and ~7are uniquely determined, so let us examine a further. Pick n E F such that v(n) generates the value group G. Then a = aOnkfor suitable k E Z and suitable a, such that u(a,) = 1. Another application of Hensel's lemma shows t1, is a norm from W (cf., Jacobson [80B, proposition 9.81) so D z! (W,a, n k ) by exercise 7.1.12. Similarly n" is a norm so we may take 1 I k < n. In fact, i must be relatively prime to n for D to be a division algebra, and, conversely, each such (W,CJ, n k ) is a division algebra by Wedderburn's criterion, and these are nonisomorphic. The classic work on local fields is Serre [79B].
wl
Central Simple Algebras
260
Particular Brauer Groups These results show Br(F) x Q / Z for any local field F. Indeed, we saw any division algebra D of degree n over F has the form ( W , a , n k )where ~ ( n ) generates the value group of F and 1 Ik < n with k relatively prime to n. Fixing n we define the Hasse inuariant map Br(F) .+ Q/Z by [ D ] H k/n, and it is now straightforward to show this is a group isomorphism. Furthermore, one sees that the exponent and index are equal for central simple algebras over local fields. Local fields are useful in studying the Brauer group of an arbitrary field, for one can take the restriction map cp,: Br(F) .+ Br(F,) where F, is the completion of F at an absolute value u. This procedure becomes meaningful for the following kinds of fields: (1) algebraic number j e l d , defined as a finite extension of Q; the valuations arise from the maximal ideals of the corresponding ring of algebraic integers, and the archimedian absolute values arise from the embeddings in C. ( 2 ) function j e l d , defined as a finite extension of a field of rational fractions F,(1) where F, is finite; the valuations arise from the discrete valuation subrings. Fields F of the form (1) or ( 2 ) are called global j e l d s and using theorem 7.2.13 to reduce to the prime power case one sees that any [ R ] E Br(F,) lies in the kernel of almost all 40,. Thus there is a map cp: Br(F) .+ @Br(F,). The celebrated Hasse-Brauer-Noether-Alberttheorem says this map is nonic, and one can conclude that any central simple algebra over the global field F is cyclic (cf., Reiner [75B, theorem 32.201). Hasse actually pushed the monic cp further. Noting as above that each Br(F,) z Q / Z for each nonarchimedian absolute value u, and Br(F,) z 2/22 for each archimedian absolute value, he defined t,b: (2/22)"'0 (Q/E)("' + Q/Z by taking the sum of all nonzero components in Q/Z and proved there is an exact sequence 1 + Br(F) -+ @ Br(D,)
-+
Q/Z
+0
for any global field F. Hence Br(F) x (Z/2E)'')0 (Q/Z)(") but in a tricky way. For example Br(Q) z (Z/2Z) 0 (Q/Z)("). An important tool in Brauer group theory is the Auslander-BrurnerFuddeeu Theorem: if F is an infinite field and char(F) 1 p then p-Br(F((4) z p-Br(F) 0
@ Hom(Ga1 FJF, Q / Z
KIFfinite
Appendix B: The Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem and K-Theory
26 1
where F, is the separable closure of F. Using this result Fein, Schacher and Sohn have computed the Brauer group of a purely transcendental extension of a global field, cf., Fein-Schacher [81] and Fein-Schacher-Sonn [85]. This team continues to produce interesting new results about Brauer groups. In view of the Merkujev-Suslin theorem, one basic question in Brauer group theory is
Question A2: Is every abelian, divisible torsion group the Brauer group of a suitable field?
The Brauer Group of a Commutative Ring Since we have had occasion to consider maximal commutative separable subalgebras of R in place of maximal subfields (e.g., when F = @), remark 7.2.1 leads us to study the Brauer group of an arbitrary commutative ringC, defined as the set of equivalence classes of Azumaya algebras, modulo the relation End,P 1 where P is a C-progenerator (which by remark 4.1.8’ means P is faithful and projective). Then Br(C) is indeed a group, since the “opposite” is the inverse. This leads us to study the “restriction” for standard ring constructions involving fields, which was carried out in the pioneering paper of Auslander-Goldman [60]. For example, suppose A is a commuting indeterminate over C. The composition C C[i] 1,C (where the latter map sends i H0) yields a composition Br(C) 2 Br(C[E,])+Br(C) which is the identity, implying Br(C[i]) = Br(C) 0 ker Brj; in particular, Br i is monic. When C is a field Auslander-Goldman [60, 7.51 showed Br i is an isomorphism iff C is perfect. However, the canonical monk Br(F) + Br(F[i,, i2]) will never be epic since we can use the “generic” ideas of 47.1 to construct “cyclic” Azumaya algebras over F[1,, ,&I. When C is not a field there are general instances when Br(C) z Br(C[E.]). On the other hand, one can return to fields by means of the fields of fractions; if F is the field of fractions of C then Br(C) + Br(F) often is monk by Auslander-Goldman [60, 7.23 but is rarely epic, e.g., Br(Z) = 0 but Br(Q) is not! These facts (and much more) as described in the excellent survey article of Zelinsky [77].
-
Appendix B: The Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem and K-Theory So far we have discussed only half of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem! To state the other half we must bring in the K,-theory of a field, which can be done by means of the elementary matrices. Let {eij:1 I i, j I m > be a given
Central Simple Algebras
262
set of matric units and € ( m , F )= { 1 + a e i j : aE F and i # j} c M,,,(F). (Here "1" denotes the identity matrix.) Analogously to exercise 7.1.38 one can show easily by means of elementary transformations that 8(m,F ) generates GL(m, F ) as a group.
Remark BI: If m 2 3 then &(m, F ) satisfy the following relations (where [ , ] is the group commutator).
(i) (1 (ii) [I (iii) [ l
+ aeij)(l + Beij)= 1 + ( a + /?)eij. + R e i j , 1 + Bjk] = 1 + a/?eik for i # k. + r e i j , 1 + pekl] = 1 for i # l and j # k .
Formalizing these relations we now define the Steinberg group St(m,F ) to be generated by elements designed {x": 1 Ii , j Im, i # j , and a E F - {O)} satisfying the relations for all a,b in F - (0): xu.x!. 11 1 1 = xu. 0", [x;,,x;J
=!:x
for i # k, and [xt,xtl] = 1
whenever i # P and j # k. Since these relations are precisely those of remark B1 we have an epic an: St(m, F ) -+ GL(m, F ) given by x; I-+ 1 aeij. We define K,(rn, F ) = ker an.There are natural embeddings of St(m, F ) -+ St(m + 1, F ) and € ( m ,F ) -+ € ( m + 1, F), so we have K,(m, F ) E K , ( m 1, F ) E .... We define K , F = U n E N K 2 ( m , F )or, , more precisely, the direct limit. Define wij(a)=x;~x$'x; and hij(a)= wij(a)wij(- l), and define the Steinberg symbol {cx,B) = hij(a/?)hij(a)-'hij(b)-'. The reason we do not include i j in the notation is that {a,/?}does not depend on the choice of i, j and turns out to be in the center of the Steinberg group; we leave this as an exercise for the reader (or else check Milnor [71B]), as well as the following identities:
+
+
Also one sees easily that each Steinberg symbol lies in K , ( F ) . Now comes the surprise. By a deep theorem of Matsumoto (cf., Milnor [71B, $1 1.1 and $123) K , ( F ) is generated by the Steinberg symbols, and all relations among the symbols are consequences of (I), (Z), and (3). In particular, K , ( F ) is an abelian group, and its operation is usually written as addition.
Appendix B: The Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem and K-Theory
263
On the other hand, the symbol algebras (a,fl), satisfy conditions (1)-(5), assuming F contains a primitive m-th root of 1. Thus there is a group homomorphism K 2 ( F )+ Br,(F) given by (a,/?}H (a,fl),. (Here Br,(F) denoted {[R]:exp(R) divides m ) . ) Obviously m K 2 ( F ) lies in the kernel, so we have a map Rm,F:K2(F)/mK2(F) Brm(F). +
This map is dependent on the particular choice of the m-th root of 1, since the structure of the algebra (a,fl),,, depends on the choice of [. To free ourselves of this choice, we could let p,,,denote the group of m-th roots of 1 and define K2(F)ImK2(F) Brm(‘) 0P m +
by { a , f l } H (a,fl), 0[. We are ready to state the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem properly. Theorem B2: (The real Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem) Rm,Fis an isomorphism. Before continuing let us interpret this result. Rm,Fepic implies Br,(F) is generated by cyclics of degree m; this is what we have been calling the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem. On the other hand, R,,,F monic means the whole theory of central simple algebras can be reread in K2-theory. Suslin [82] also obtained characteristic p results, e.g., K , ( F ) has no p-torsion. An important special case of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem is Bloch’s Theorem: If E is a purely transcendental jield extension of F then Rm,Fand Rm.Ehave isomorphic kernels and cokernels. In particular, if Rm,Fis epic then Rm,Eis also epic; since every central simple algebra over an algebraic number field is cyclic, one concludes Br,(F) is generated by cyclics whenever F is a purely transcendental extension of an algebraic number field. In presenting the Auslander-Brumer theorem, Fein-Schacher [80] give a relatively straightforward proof that every central simple F(,l)-algebra is similar to the tensor product of a restriction of a central simple F-algebra with a finite number of corestrictions of symbols (the corestriction taken from finite dimensional extensions of F(1). Hence the epic part of Bloch’s theorem follows easily from Rosset-Tate. On the other hand, one could prove the “epic” part of Merkurjev-Suslin if one could show the center of the generic division algebra U D ( F , n ) is purely transcendental over Q. This observation (due to Rosset) led to a
264
Central Simple Algebras
spate of attempts to build various “generic” division algebras whose centers were purely transcendental, and, although some success was achieved, the theorems thereby obtained have been proved more succinctly by the methods we have already presented. Until now the Bloch-Rosset approach has led to various open cases of Noether’s famous problem of whether the fixed subfield under a group of automorphisms of a purely transcendental field extension is purely transcendental. An elementary reduction of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem to Bloch’s theorem would be most welcome. Let us say a few words about the proof of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem. The Rosset-Tate reciprocity law only relies on formal properties of symbols, as the reader can easily verify, and thus holds in K , (where the corestriction is replaced by the “transfer” Tr, defined in Milnor [71B]; in fact, Rosset and Tate framed their results more generally for “Milnor functors” (taking values in an abelian group) which possess the formdl symbols (a,p) and the transfer maps, satisfying the following properties, written now in additive notation, where we always assume a, fi # 0: (a, - a ) = 0 = (a, 1 - a )
TrLIF(a,b) = (a, NLIFb)
where here a # 1 for a E F, fi E L.
Note that the K,-version gives an explicit formula for Tr of a symbol and thus for Tr on all of K , , since the symbols generate. Consequently, we have the following commutative diagram, fixing an m-th root iof 1:
K,(F)ImK,(F)
-
Br,(F)
This diagram permits us to pass back and forth from K , to Br,(F), thereby permitting us to bring in the powerful tool from K-theory.
Hilbert’s Theorem 90 for K-Theory: If LfF is cyclic of prime degree p and Tr x = 0 for some x in K , ( F ) then there is y in K , ( F ) for which x = ay - y , where Gal(L/F) = (a). This result is the key obstacle to an “elementary” proof of the MerkurjevSuslin theorem, for its current proof relies on results from “higher” K-theory.
Appendix C: Generics
265
Appendix C: Generics In this discussion we sketch a method for obtaining generic division algebras of different classes and also see what they are good for.
Definition Cl: A pseudo-place cp: W + R of algebra is a map cp: W -, R n (?) where ? is a formally undefined element, such that if W, = cp-lR then the restriction of cp to W, is a surjection cp,: W, -,R . An algebra U in a class % is generic if for every R in % and every finite subset S of U - (0) there is a pseudo-place cp: U -+ R for which 0 # cpu E R for each u in S.
Nore: We require cpl to be a surjection so that the image of central elements is central. The reader should compare “pseudo-place” to the classical definition of a “place” of fields, cf., Jacobson [80B].
Remark C2: We shall always take %? to be a class of central simple algebras which includes division algebras. Then the proof of theorem 7.1.24 shows any generic is a division algebra. The motivation behind the definition is that any finite p-central set of U would be mapped via suitable cp to a p-central set of R, so decomposability and crossed product properties are thereby preserved. More precisely, let us say R is split by a group G if R has a splitting field Galois over Z ( R )with Galois group G ; in particular, if [GI = deg R then R is a G-crossed product.
Proposition C3: Suppose U is generic for %.
(i) If U is a G-crossed product then every division algebra in %? is a G-crossed product; if U is split by G then every central simple algebra in % is split by a subgroup of G . (ii) If U is a tensor product of cyclics of exponents m , , . . .,mj then every algebra in % is a tensor product of cyclics of exponents dividing m,,. . , ,mj. Proof: Left to the reader, since the idea is exactly as in the lemma 7.1.27; the reason we must pass to subgroups of G in the general case is that we have direct products of subfields. For (ii) one writes U = (K,,o,,a,) Q ..*0 ( K j ,oj,aj), encodes all the information into elements, and takes u in U to be the product of all relevant numerators and denominators, stipulating the denominators are central. Q.E.D.
Central Simple Algebras
266
Example C4: Let VT = (simple F-algebras of cardinality I a and degree n}, where r is an arbitrary infinite cardinal 2 IF!. Then U = UD(F,n) obtained from a generic matrices; indeed given any R in and = f ( Y ,,...,
Ym)dYl,..., Y X 1
in U we take r , , . . . ,rm such that f ( r l , . . . ,rm)g(rl,.. .,rm)-' # 0, and listing the elements of R as { r i : i E I ) with 111 = c( one defines the pseudo-place U -,R to be the specialization & H ri for each i in I . It remains to show that generics exist. This was done for arbitrary exponent by SaItrnan and for other classes of interest by Rosset and Snider. Now we shall sketch a geometric approach of unifying these constructions, and soon shall consider a very useful technique of Schofield. Let F be an infinite field and let % = {prime PI-algebras over F having PI-degree n ) . To make things simpler, conceptually we consider each object in V as a pair ( R , Z ) where 2 = Z ( R ) . Let 'e, denote the subclass defined by one additional sentence cp = 3XVY(f(X)
z0A
$(X,Y))
where x = (xl.. . .,x,), y = ( y l , . .. , y k . ) ,the various x i ,y j taken from R or Z , according to specification, and where f is a given polynomial and 9 is a conjunction of atomic formulas (i.e., polynomials whose values in (x, y, .. .) are 0). We want a generic for qv.To accomplish this we first observe that if ( R ,Z ) E Wv then @ [ A ] , ZCi.1) E Vv as in corollary 6.1.45. (One uses the same x and looks at homogeneous components in y.) Now consider the algebra F [ A ] , { Y} of generic n x n matrices over the commutative ring F[A] where A is a set of commuting indeterminates {&: 1 I u I n 2 , i E N}. Let t = n'. Noting the generic matrices Yl ,..., I; are a base of the ring of fractions of F[A],{ Y ) over its center, we let x i = i.,,x for 1 5 i I k and yj = Aj+,."YU.The conditions on cp translate to a set of polynomial conditions in the Aiu and the ( (viewing the Yu as matrices whose entries are from another set of commuting indeterminates); so letting A be the ideal of F[A; < ] generated by these polynomials, we take U to be the image of F [ A ] , { Y} in M,(F[A,( ] / A ) . By construction U is generic if it is prime. But U has a central extension which is M , ( F [ A ; < ] / A ) and so will be prime when A is a prime ideal in F [ A ; t ] , i.e., when the corresponding algebraic variety V is irreducible, which will usually be the case. In fact, the only situation where V will not be irreducible is if every specialization of the ,Iiu to 2 gives an algebraic equation in Z , eg., if cp = {3x: x2 = 1). But in this case we name a solution for
zt=
<
267
Appendix C: Generics
each such equation and introduce corresponding new constant symbols; rewriting cp in terms of these new symbols then produces a variety I", and we get a generic by taking an irreducible component. In applications we are usually interested in a class of simple algebras of degree n, which of course is obtained by taking the rings of central fractions.
Example C5: Let us describe {simple algebras of degree n and exponent I m} in terms of elementary sentences. Let t = n2 and u = tm. Then exp(R) I m iff R@'"has a set of u x u matric units. In other words, given 1 I k ( l ) , . . . , k ( m )I t write k = (k(l),.. . , k ( m ) ) and b k for bk(l)0 . . . 0bk(,,,) in R@"; existence of a set of u x u matric units now translates to the existence of C(ijk in Z ( R ) ,1 I i , j I u such that eij = xkuijkbksatisfies the matric unit conditions of definition 1.1. I . This is clearly in the desired form and, therefore, yields the generic of degree n and exponent m that we have looking for.
Remark C6: (Amitsur) If U is generic for Wq then M,,(U) is generic for {M,,(R):R E gq}.Note that the existence of a set of n x n matric units is of the desired form, so this defines a class gq,.Thus by passing to Wqewe can obtain the following instant consequences of proposition C3:
Proposition C7:
(i) If M,,(U) is split by G then M,,(R) is split b y a subgroup of G , for every central simple algebra R of Vq. (ii) If M,,(U) is a tensor product of cyclics then M,,(R) is a tensor product of cyclics. Corollary CS: The Merkurjeu-SuJin number p(n) = p(UD(F,n)). by (ii). Proof: ( 2 )is obvious; ( I )
Q.E.D.
Generic Splitting Fields and Schofield's Method Definition C9: A generic splitting field for R is a splitting field E of R such that for each splitting field K of R there is a place E -,K . Intutitively a generic splitting field is the "most general" splitting field for R and can be found if we can determine a varietal criterion for R to be
268
Central Simple Algebras
split. The most famous criterion is by means of Grasmmannians and their Plucker coordinates, giving rise to the Brauer-Seueri variety, which is instrumental in the proof of the Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem. A more direct criterion, found independently by Peterson and Jacobson, comes from noting that R is split iff there is an element r in R such that [ r R r : Z ( R ) ] = 1; this criterion translates readily to equations and thus to varieties. For details the reader can consult JAC-SAL. Given a generic splitting field construction, we can easily build generics for various classes by tensoring by a suitable generic splitting field. For example, to build a generic division algebra of degree n and exponent rn we start with the generic D = UD(F,n) of degree n and let E be the generic splitting field for Dam. Then D@,E has exponent m and degree n, and is generic such as seen by an easy specialization argument. The advantage of this approach is that one can bring in the following result. Theorem: (uan den Bergh [83]-Schofiefd).If E is the generic sptitting field of R 2 then index(R, 0 E) = min{index(R, @FRYi:1 Ii Iexp(R,)}. This theorem is proved using Quillen's K-theory and obviously bears on the tensor product question; indeed, Schofield [ 8 7 ] has found very natural counterexamples (i.e., D, 0 D, has zero divisors although D, and D, have no subfields in common) for wide ranges of values of deg(D,) and deg(D,). Thus he "explains" and extends the Tignol-Wadsworth example.
Exercises 47.1 Maximal Commutative Subalgebras K is a maximal commutative subalgebra of a central simple F-algebra R. If K is separable over F then R is projective as K-module, and [ K : F ] = deg R. (Hint: K is projective as K'-module so R z R BKK is projective over R @OK K' x R & ( K @ , K ) z R @ , K , which is free over K. Now using exercise 2.11.15 note [R:F]=[R@OFK:K]=[EndKR:K]=[EndK,R,:K,]=[R,:K,]2 for any P in Spec(K); but [ R 8, K : K] = [R@OKK':K ] = [ R p @ ( K e ) p KP] : = [R,: KP][K:F].) 2. Any central simple algebra has a maximal commutative subalgebra which is separable. (Hint: Write R = M,(D) and take K(’)where K is a maximal separable subfield of D. Appeal to the counting argument of exercise l to show CR(K"))= K"'. 1. Suppose
269
Exercises
+
3. Prove Schur’s inequality [C:F] 5 [n’/4] 1 for any commutative subalgebra C of M,(F). (Hint: (Gustafson) Writing M,(F) z End, V where [ V : F ] = n note V is a faithful C-module. Switching points of view, one need only show if C is a commutative F-algebra and V is a faithful C-module with [V:F] 2 n then [ C : F ] 5 [n2/4] 1. C is Artinian and thus semiperfect commutative, implying C is a direct product of local rings. It suffices to assume C is local. Let J = Jac(C). Let G I , . . . , & , be a base for V/JV as C/J-module; choosing b, such that 6, = bi J V define f : J Hom( V / J V , J V )sending a to the map f. given by f.bi = abi. Then f is monic by Nakayama’s lemma so [J:F] 5 m(n - m) [(n/2)’]. But [ C : F ] = 1 [J:F].) 4. (Sweedler) An alternate approach to showing D @, K z End, D for a maximal subfield K of a central division algebra D. First show if L is a subfield with C,(C,(L)) = L and L c T c D then there is a monic $: TOLDOP+ Hom,,(,,(C,(L),D) given by $ ( a @ d ) x = axd. (To prove $ is monic take 0# r = a, @ d , E ker $ with n minimal. One may assume d, = 1, so a, Q [x,di] E ker $ for any x in C,(L), implying each diE L; hence r = ( x a , d i )0 1 = 0, contradiction. K QFD 4 End,D. Apply this fact twice. First T = K and L = F yields But taking T # D and L = K yields [D:K]2[K:F] I[K:F][D:F] so [D:K] 5 [ K : F ] and is thus onto.)
+
+
+
XI=
Skolem-Noether Theorem 5. Prove the Skolem Noether theorem. (Hint: Suppose $: A + A ’ is an isomorphism of simple F-subalgebras and form T = A @ RoP. R is an A - R bimodule and thus T-module in two ways: the obvious way and by the action (a Q r ) x = ($a)rx. These module actions are isomorphic since T has a unique simple module whose
multiplicity in R is determined by [R:F]. Hence there is f : R + R satisfying f ( a x r ) = ( + a ) ( f x ) r .Take a = 1 to show f is given by left multiplication by an invertible element u of R; then take r = 1.) 6. Weaken the hypothesis in the Skolem-Noether theorem to “finite dimensional simple subalgebras of an arbitrary simple Artinian aglebra R.” (Hint: Use the underlying division ring of R in place of F.) 7. Counterexample to generalizing Skolem-Noether to semisimple subalgebras. 0 01 Let A = F [ a ] and A‘ = F[a’] where R = M , ( F ) , a = 10 2 0 and a’ =
rl
1 0
I
1 0 . Then a and a’ have the same minimal polynomial so A z A’ but
0 2J ar # ra’ for all invertible r in R. 8. Suppose char(F) # p. Define a p-symbol [a,/?), (where n is a power of p ) to be the cyclic algebra ( K ,a$) where K = F ( y ) , y p = y + a, zyz-’ = y + 1, and z p = /?.If deg(R) = p and R has an element r # F with r p E F then R is a p symbol. (Hint: exercise 2.5.10.) Also check [a,,/?)@ [a,,/?) [al a,,/?) and [a, B11 0 [a, 8 2 )
-
[a, PIBz).
-
+
270
Central Simple Algebras
Brauer and Noether Factor Sets 9. A Brauer factor set is normalized if ciik= 1 = cikkfor all i, k. This can be achieved via theorem 7.1.40 by taking yij = 1 if i # j and yii = ciii.A Noether factor set (cur)is normalized if cla = c U I = 1 for all u in G ; this is achieved by taking u1 = 1. 10. Suppose K = F(a) is Galois over F and a, = a, a * , . . . ,a, are the conjugates of a.
Then any u E Gal(K/F) is defined by its action on 0 1 ' . There is a 1:l correspondence Y: {Brauer factors sets} + {Noether factor sets) given by defining ,c, = Y - ' is given by defining c l j k = c ~ where , ~ ul = j and ~l = K ' k , and then putting cija = C l i j C l j k C l i ; . Furthermore, prove the corresponding factor sets arise from isomorphic central simple algebras. In particular, a central simple algebra R is a crossed product iff R has a maximal subfield Galois over F. (Hint: The 1: 1 correspondence is a computation and the last assertion is a trick. First, given ( C i j k ) show Y is defined by verifying (lo),applying BFS2 (where i = 1, j = u l , k = 071, and m = urpl). (taking u = 1 in (10)) Conversely, given a Noether factor set (cur)note so c 1I j = c l I k for all j , k. The definition ci,k = cIijcljkc;~ is well-defined (since for i = 1 one has clljc;:k = I), and this condition yields BFS2 at once. Taking C T , T , ~in G for which a1 = i, 71 = u - ' j and p l = ( c T T ) - ' ~ (so that urpl = k ) one has Cijk
11.
12.
13.
14.
=c
l i j ~ l j k ~ ~=i icurcur,pc,,lrp
= OCr.p.
Thus pcijk= c , , ~ , , , ~ ,for , , ~ all p in G. By inspection the two correspondences Y and Y - ' are indeed inverses. Finally given Y(cijk)=(cur) and letting R be the central simple algebra giving rise to (cijk), one wants to identify R with the algebra giving rise to (cur).Taking u, in R for which u,au,' = aa and building a Noether factor set (Fur)as in (9) in the text one gets a corresponding Brauer factor set (Fijk) = Y ' ( F , , ) , which thus must be associated to (cijt),i.e, there are (yij) for which (8) holds. Replacing u, by y;.lelu,, yields a Noether factor set (ckJ corresponding to (cijk). A Noether factor set (cur)corresponds to a matrix algebra iff there are yu in K for which c,.~ = yuay,y,'. (Hint: The corresponding Brauer factor set ( c i j k ) is associated to (1) iff there are yij satisfying the conjugacy conditions, for which cijk = yijyjky;'. To prove (a) let ye = yl,ol and note c,,~ = yuayry;:.) (Wedderburn's criterion) The cyclic algebra ( K , a , a )is split iff a is a norm from K to F. (Hint: If a = N,(y) then taking ye, = y6y..-ai-’yone sees the Noether factor set of example 7.1.42 corresponds to M,(F). Conversely, if there are y,, as in exercise 1 1 then taking y = y, one has yei = yay.. .ai- ' y for each i < n, by induction on i, so u = cu.u n - I = yu(y.. . u"- ’7) = Nuy.) A cyclic algebra R = ( K ,D, a) has Brauer factor set (cii,) given by cijk = 1 if i I j Ik or i 2 k 2 j , and C i j k = a, otherwise. (Hint: Translate example 7.1.42 using exercise 10.) (Abelian crossed products) Suppose K is Galois over F with abelian Galois group G = ( 0 , ) x ... x (a,), with oi of order ni. If K is a maximal subfield of R then there are invertible ul,. . . , u , in R such that u p ; ' = ua for all a in K. Write cij = uiuju;'u;l E K and bi = ulz, an "abelian factor set" corresponding to R, and derive the ensuing abelian factor set conditions: cii = 1, c;' = cji, o;(bi) =
Exercises
271
Ni(cji)bi, NiNj(cij)= 1 , and aicjkujckiukcij= cjkckicij.Here N, denotes the norm with respect to ui. Conversely, any abelian factor set determines a crossed product with respect to the corresponding abelian group. The algebra corresponding to the abelian factor set is split iff there are a, in K satisfying bi = N ( a i ) and cij = (oiaj)ai'ai(ujai)-'. This important construction due to Dickson was rediscovered by Amitsur-Saltman [ 7 8 ] , who used it to get a concrete description of crossed products when the underlying group is abelian, with striking consequences for p-algebras; Amitsur-Rowen-Tignol [79] used this construction to build an indecomposable division algebra of degree 8 with involution. Wedderburn's Division Algorithm (see Rowen [80B, pp. 178-1 791 15. We say f divides g in D [ 1 ] if g = qf for some q in D [ 1 ] . Using the Euclidean algorithm (remark 1.6.20) show 1- d divides g(A) - g ( d ) , and thus (A - d )
divides g iff g ( d ) = 0. 16. If i- d divides g h and not h then 1- h(d)dh(d)-' divides g . (Hint: 1- d divides
g ( l ) h ( d )by exercise 15.) 17. If h ( d ) = 0 for all conjugates d of d , then the minimal polynomial p of d , over
Z ( D ) divides h. (Hint: Take a counterexample h of minimal degree; writing h = q p + r for deg r < deg p show the coefficients of r lie in Z ( D ) . ) 18. (Wedderburn [ 2 1 ] ) If g(1) is irreducible in F[A] and g has a root d , in some F-central division algebra D then g can be written as a product ( A - d , ) . . . ( i - d , ) where the di are each conjugates of d , . (Hint: Write g = q(1)(A- d k ) . . . ( l- d , ) for k as large as possible, and let h = (l - d k ) . . . ( l- d l ) . Then h satisfies the criterion of exercise 17, so the minimal polynomial p of d , over Z ( D ) divides h and thus g. Hence p = g implying h = 9.)Actually, the proof does not require
[D:F]< co.
19. Give Wedderburn's proof that every central division algebra of degree 3
is cyclic, using exercise 18. (Hint: The minimal polynomial of d , can be written (1. - d 3 ) ( 1- d , ) ( l - d , ) where d , can be taken t o be [ d , d , ] d , [ d , d , ] - ' for arbitrary d, cf., exercise 16. Let x = [ d , , d , ] . d , + d , + d , E F, so commutating with di shows [ d n l , d n 2 ]= k x for every n in Sym(3). But then d , = xd2x-' by exercise 16, and, likewise, d i + = xdix-' for each i . Hence x 3 E F. By Zariski topology there is d , such that x # F.) 20. Using Wedderburn's method reprove the fact that every D of degree 4 is a crossed product. (Hint: Take d E D of degree 4.The minimal polynomial is of the form (I.* + a ' l + b')(A2+ a l + b), and matching parts one can show a' is quadratic over F, cf., Rowen [80B, p. 1811. One concludes easily D is a crossed product.)
,
Division Rings The next exercises contain a collection of results about arbitrary division rings. We start with a very easy proof of the theorem of CartanBrauer-Hua. 21. Suppose V is a vector space over a division ringD, and A is an additive subgroup of V containing two D-independent elements. If f: A + V is a group homomorphism satisfying Ja E Da for every a in A then there is d in D such that fa = da
272
22.
23. 24. 25.
26.
Central Simple Algebras
+
for all a in A. (Hint: If a , , a, are D-independent and /ai= diai then / ( a , a z ) = d i a l d,a, implies d , = d,.) (Treur [77]) Suppose D 5 E are division rings, such that D is invariant with respect to all inner automorphisms determined by a n additive subgroup A of E. Assume 1 E A. Then either A c D or D c C,(A). (Hint: Fixing d in D, let fd: A -+D be right multiplication by d . Exercise 21 implies either ad = d a for all a in A, o r else every element of A is D-dependent on 1 so that A E D.) (Cartan-Brauer-Hua) Suppose D is a division subring of E, invariant with respect to all inner automorphisms of E. Then D = E or D E Z ( E ) . If E E prove the analogue of exercise 23, using derivations instead of automorphisms. (Faith [58]) If E is a division ring which is not a finite field and if D is a proper division subring then the multiplicative group D - ( 0 ) is of infinite index in E - ( 0 ) .(Hint: E is infinite by Wedderburn's theorem, so one may assume D is infinite. If [E - (0): D - { O } ] < a,then for any x in E one can find d l # d, in D with x d , E D ( x d , ) ; solve to get x E D.) (Herstein) Any noncentral element of a division ring has infinitely many conjugates. (Hint (Faith): In exercise 25 take D to be the centralizer.)
+
+
+
The next few exercises describe and illuminate Bergman's example of a division ring D f.g. as a module over a subringR which is not a division ring, answering a question of P. F. Smith.
27. (P. F. Smith) N o such example exists if R is left Noetherian. (Hint: D would be a Noetherian R-module so for any r in R the ascending chain Rr-' IRr-' -< ... implies r is invertible in R.) 28. (P.F. Smith) N o such example exists if R is right Ore. (Hint: One could take D to be the ring of fractions, but then by common denominators D = Rr-' for some r in R so D = R.) 29. (Bergman) Let G be the free group on three elements x , y , z ordered such that z is minimal among ( x , y , ~ , x - ~ , y - ~ , z(Just - ~ } . reverse the usual order.) Let E = Q((G)) and let D be the division subalgebra generated by x , y , z . Define u: E + G by taking u ( f ) to be the least element of supp(f). Since D is countable there is a monic function p:D -+N - {O} such that yzqdx < u ( d ) for each d in D. Note { y , z, yz'x: i E N} generate a free subsemigroup; thus the Q-subalgebra R of D generated by y , z , and { d + yzqdx:d E D ) is free and so is not a division ring. But D = R + R x since d = (d + y z P d x )- ( y z q d ) x . 30. (Bergman [83]) If in exercise 29 one takes G generated only by two elements y , z and now stipulates p satisfies ~ z ~ " ' ~ +<' yu(d), then the Q-subalgebra R generated by y , z 2 and d + y z Z q d + ' yis still a free Q-algebra, and now D = R + ( y z ) R = ( y z ) R + R . Bergman also modifies the construction to provide a n instance where R is left Ore. 31. (Vamos) The following are equivalent for fields F c K : ( i ) KBFK is Noetherian; (ii) (fields between F and K } satisfies ACC; (iii) K is an f.g. field extension of F. (Hint: (i) -(ii) If F, c F2 c ... are fields define pi:K OFK-+ K OF,K canonically and take A i = ker pi; then Ai c A'+ since a @ 1 - 1 @ a E ker p,+ - ker pi for any a in Fi+ - 6 . (ii) ==-(iii)Take K , to be a maximal f.g. field extension of F ; then K , = K. (iii) 3 (i). See exercise 32 (e).)
,
273
Exercises
32. Suppose K is a subfield of D. D @z(D, K is Noetherian iff K is an f.g. field extension of Z ( D ) .(Hint: (-) D 6 K is a free K @ K-module so K 0 K is Noetherian by sublemma 2.5.32'. Apply (i) => (iii) of exercise 21. (t) D @ K is f.g. as module over D(a,, . .. , a , ) where (al,.. . ,a,) is a transcendence base of K over Z ( D ) . )This easy result of Resco-Small-Wadsworth [79] is surprisingly useful, as we see in the next exercise. 33. Let D be the division ring of fractions of the Weyl algebra A,(F) where char(F) =O. Then every subfield K of D is finitely generated over F. (Hint: D 0 K is a localization of A,(F) @ K z A,(K) which is Noetherian, so apply exercise 32.) 34. (Lorenz [84]) Generalizing exercise 33, suppose R is an F-algebra such that R OFK is left Noetherian for each field extension K of F. If S is a left denominator set for R then every subfield L of S-'R is f.g. over F and, furthermore, satisfies tr deg L / F 5 K-dim R OFL.(Hint: L is f.g. as in exercise 33. tr deg L / F = K-dim L = K-dim L @ L 5 K-dim S - ' R @ L IK-dim R @ L , cf., exercise 3.5.26.)
The Dieudonne Determinant (cf., Draxl [83B]) Assume D is a division ring and n 2 3.
35. Suppose r E GL(n,D ) , the invertible n x n matrices over D. Then r can be written in the form u,dpa, where a , is lower triangular with 1's on the diagonal, a , is upper triangular with 1's on the diagonal, d is diagonal, and p is a permutation matrix. This is called the Bruhar decomposition. (Hint: The standard linear algebra argument using elementary transformations, noting left resp. right multiplication by an elementary matrix corresponds to an elementary row (resp. column) transformation.) 36. In the Bruhat decomposition d and p are uniquely determined. (Hint: If a,dpa, = aid'p'a; then d - l a ; ' a i d ' is lower triangular but equals p a 2 ( u ; ) - ' ( p ' ) ~ 'so p = p ' and hence the diagonal d - ' d ' = 1.) Consequently, writing d as the diagonal ( d , ,... ,d , ) and p as thegermutation matrix e i , n iin the Bruhat decomposition of r we can define d ( r ) = (sg x ) d l . .. d , . 37. (Dieudonne determinant) If r, r l E GL(n, D ) then in the above notation &rl)&rz) Z(rlr2)-' is a product of group commutators in D - (0). Thus writing GUbfor G / G ' where G' is the group commutator of G and writing Rab for {units of R } a b for any ring R, we get a group homomorphism det: M,(D) + Dab which is the composite of 2 with the canonical map D + D O b . This is called the Dieudonne determinant. The Dieudonne determinant can be tied in with algebraic K-theory, as we shall now see. 38. Define SL(n, D ) = { r E GL(n, D ) : det r = 1). Then SL(n,D) is generated by elementary matrices (i.e., of the form 1 + eij for i # j ) and is its own commutator subgroup for all n 2 3. (Hint: The elementary matrix 1 + e l * can be written as the commutator of 1 e I 3and 1 + e 3 2 ,so it suffices to prove the first assertion.
+
For any
u,u
in D write
as products of ele-
mentary matrices by transforming them to the identity up elementary row and column transformations.)
Central Simple Algebras
274
39. The conclusion of exercise 38 also holds for n = 2 if ID1 2 4. 40. The Dieudonne determinant gives an isomorphism M,(DYb -P Dab for all n, except for n = 2 and D = 2 / 2 2 o r 2 / 3 2 . (Hint: exercises 37-39.) This is a useful piece of information since it relates to the Whitehead group K , ( D ) , cf., Milnor [71B, $31. 41. (Cohn-Schofield) Division rings D c E such that the left dimension [ E : D ] = 2 and the right dimension is infinite. Let E be a division ring generated by the free algebra F { X , , X , } , cf., corollary 1.3.41, and let D be the division subring generated by X , , X i , and X f X , - X 2 X , . (Hint: Clearly E = D + D X , , since the last generator enables one to pull X I to the left. It remains to show the right dimension is infinite. First observe that nowhere in exercises 6.3.9 or 6.3.10 was C required to be commutative! Thus taking C = D and R = E in exercise 6.3.10 it sufices to show M ( E ;0,O) z ker(E ODE+ E) is infinite dimensional as right module over D . But M ( E ;0,O) has bimodule generators S X , ,SX, with relations 6 X , = 0, 0 = S X : = X , S X , ( S X , ) X , , and 0 = S ( X ? X , - X , X , ) = X : S X , ( 6 X , ) X , , it., M(E;O,O)can be viewed as the E - E bimodule E(SX,)E where ( S X , ) X , = - X , S X , and ( 6 X , ) X , = X : 6 X , . The right dimension over D is infinite because ( ( X , X ; ) S X , :n E N } are independent.)
+
The Zero Divisor Question The following exercises are addressed to the following question, which we call the zero divisor question for tensor products: If R , and R , are domains over an algebraically closed field F then is R , 6 R , a domain? The reason the zero divisor question is posed here is that it is usually asked more specifically for division algebras and is still open in this case. Bergman [75] indeed found domains R , , R , over F for which R, BFR , is not a domain, but in this example R , OFD and D OFR , are domains for every division algebra D. (In particular, neither R , nor R , can be a subring of a division algebra, and, in fact, he shows there is no nontrivial homomorphism from R , or R , to a division algebra!) The following exercises present his example. Incidentally, when F is not algebraically closed a related zero divisor question can be raised for finite dimensional division algebras, and its solution is given in digression 7.2.13'8; also see appendix C. 42. Define a bilinear system over F to be a system A =(A,, A,, A,: cpa) where q :A, x A , -+ A, is a bilinear map of vector spaces over F. Let &W& denote the category of bilinear systems, where morphisms are defined in the natural way (so that the appropriate diagram commutes.) There is a forgetful functor G : S - d f f-P YBl'fc'n given by G R = ( R , R , R ; ( p , ) ; in other words, any algebra R provides a bilinear system by taking (P, to be the ring multiplication and then forgetting the ring structure. Also note that if A and B are bilinear systems one can define their tensor product A 0B = ( A , 0B,, A , @ B,, A , 0B,; (pa 0q,), where (cpa 0 q s ) ( a , 0b , , ~ 0 , h,) = rp,(a,,az)Ocps(b,,b,) for a, in A i and bi in Bi. 43. The universal from a bilinear system A = (A,, A,, A,; ( p A ) to the functor G of exercise 42 can be constructed as follows: Define F ( A ) to be the tensor algebra T ( A , @ A , @ A,) modulo the ideal generated by all ala2 - qA(a,,a,)for a, in Ai.Show there is a natural vector space embedding A F ( A ) (which, more precisely, is an injection A + G ( F ( A ) ) in Bl'fin). 44. F ( A ) is not a domain iB A has zero divisors in the sense that there are nonzero
Exercises
275
a , , a , in A , , A , , respectively, such that q ( a , , a , ) = 0. (Hint: Take two distinct prime integers p 1 , p 2 and grade T ( A , 0 A , 0 A , ) by putting deg(Ai) = pi for i = 1,2 and deg(A,) = p I p 2 .This induces a grading on F ( A ) , which has zero
45.
46.
47.
divisors iff there are homogeneous zero divisors.) Thus the zero divisor question has been transferred to gifin. Show the zero divisor question in #i/i>!depends on finite dimensional bilinear systems. Given a bilinear system A = ( A , ,A , , A,; cpa) one has an induced map (PA: A , @ A , + A , . Let A , = ker(PA. Replacing A, by q A ( A , x A , ) one may assume qA (and thus (PA) is onto, providing an exact sequence 0 + A , + A , 0 A, -+ A , + 0. Let A: denote the dual space Hom,(A,,F). Then ( A , 0 A,)* z A: 8 A : via the dual base (by a dimension count), so exercise 1.5.5 provides an exact sequence O + A ~ + A : @ A ~ + A E + O . Define A* = ( A : , A : , A E , $ ) to be the corresponding bilinear system where $ is obtained from the dual of the map A , + A , @ A , . The bilinear system A 0 A* then has the “canonical” zero divisors s, = ~ b , , @ f I j and s, = x b , j @ f 2 j where for i = 1,2 the b, (resp. J j ) are a base of A i (resp. A : ) . Notation as above. Let H = ( a l @ a 2 : u IE A, and a , E A 2 } . If [ A i : F ] = ni for 1 5 i 5 3 then [ A , : F ] = n l n 2 - n3 and as an algebraic set H has dimension n , + n, - 1 (since aa, @ a , = a , 0 aa,). Hence A, n H # 0 if (nlnz - n,) ( n , + n , - 1) > n l n 2 , i.e., n3 < n , + n , - 1. This is a sufficient condition for A to have zero-divisors. Likewise, A* has zero-divisors if n3 [ H : F ] > n l n 2 , i.e., if n , > n l n z + 1 - n , - n,. Thus for A and A* each not to have zero divisors we need n , + n , - 1 I n 3 n l n z + 1 - n , - n,, implying (nl - 2)(n2 - 2) 2 2. Conversely, if (nl - 2)(n, - 2) 2 2 then n , can be found as desired; any nondegenerate A (under certain geometric stipulations) satisfying [A,: F ] = n, would have A and A* without zero divisors. Bergman’s concrete example. By symmetry one may assume n , 2 n 2 . By exercise 47 the minimal counterexample would be n , = 4, n , = 3, n 3 = 4 + 3 - 1 = 6. Let { b , ,..., b,} be a base of A , and { c I , c 2 , c 3 be } a base of A,. Choosing a E F arbitrarily # 0,l define A(a) = ( A , , A , , A,;cp) where A , = ( A , 0A z ) / A o and A, is spanned by the following elements (taking j modulo 3):
+
+
48.
h, @cj - b, @ c j + ,
for 1 5 j 5 3
h,@cj-b,@cj+,
forlSjc2
and
b2@~3-abqQc,.
Define (pA by ‘ p ( a , , a , )= a , @ a2 + A , for all ai in A i . Then A ( a - ’ ) = (A(a))*. Moreover, if f: F ( A ( a ) ) + D is a ring homomorphism to a division algebra D for a # 0,l then A ( a ) E kerf. (Otherwise, writing d j , e j for the respective images in D of bj,c, one would have d,e, =ud,e, but solving the various relations yields d 2 e , = d,e, so d , = 0 or el = 0 from which it follows all d, = 0 = ej.) 49. F ( A ( a ) )0 D is a domain for every division algebra D,so in particular F ( A ( a ) ) is a domain. (Hint: Otherwise, A(a) @ U has nontrivial zero-divisors, i.e., cp(y,,y,) = 0, where U is the underlying bilinear system of D.The universality of the construction gives us a morphism f: A ( a - ’ ) + U such that ‘psi = yi for i = 1.2, where si is as in exercise 46, thereby contradicting exercise 48.)
Central Simple Algebras
276
1. (Frobenius) The only central division algebras over R are R and the quaternion algebra H. (Hint: If D # R then C is a maximal subfield of D , so degD = 2 and thus D is isomorphic to the symbol (a, - l), x (f1, - 1)*.) Thus IBr(R)I = 2. 2. eRe R for any idempotent e of R. (Hint: Let L = Re z Lg)where Lo is a minimal left ideal of R; eRe z End, Re z End, L$) x M,(End, Lo). 3. (Cancellation) If [K: F ] is prime to deg(R) and R €3 K z R' €3 K then R z R'. (Hint: RoP€3 R' €3 K is split.) 4. Suppose deg(R) = n = m ,. . . m , where m , , . . .,rn, are distinct prime powers. If there are fields K i with [ K i : F ] = ./mi such that each C,(K,) is a division ring, then R is also a division ring. (Hint: Otherwise, let rn = n/index(R); take some mi not prime to m and reach a contradiction.) 5. Suppose R has a maximal subfield K Galois over F with Galois group G. Letting K, be the fixed subfield of K under the Sylow p-subgroup of G, show that if each C,(K,) is a division ring then R is also a division ring. (Hint: exercise 4.) 5
Brauer Factors Sets and Cohomology 6. Suppose K is a separable field extension of F. K @ K has a primitive idempotent e such that (a €3 a')e = (a' €3 a)e for all a, a' in K; if K is Galois over F then (uQ u)e = e for all u in Gal(K/F). (Hint: K BFK is a direct product of copies of F. Define Jl: K €3 K -P K by a €3 a' ++ an', and write ker Jl = (K €3 K ) e , for e, idempotent. Let e = 1 - e,. Then Ke z K so e is primitive. Jle = 1 implies ( a €3 a')e = (a' Q a)e. If K is Galois over F then ker $ is invariant under u €3 u for any u in Gal(K/F). Hence (u @ a)eo is an idempotent in ker $, so (u @ a)e, = e,.) 7. Prove lemma 7.2.7 by taking e from exercise 6 and showing e(R8R')e is a crossed
product with respect to K e having Noether factor set (c,,cb,). 8. If index(R) is odd then R has a Brauer factor set (cijk)with ciij= 1 and cijk= cjki= ckij=ckjf = c;: = cn: for all i, j, k. (Hint: Take (cijk)for R; then (cijkcijf) is associated to R @ (R0P)Op z R @ R; take cijk = ( C ~ ~ ~ C ; ~ ~ ) '')".) "' 9. (Inflation) Any group homomorphism cp: G, -+G induces a map H Z ( G ,K - lo))+ H * ( G , ,K - (0)) given by f + + f where f ( u , t )= f(cpu,cpr) for all u,7 in G. This is called the inflation of cp. In particular, when G and G, are groups of automorphisms on K the inflation of cp yields a map Br(F) + Br(K,) where F, K, are the fixed subfields of K under G, G,, respectively. Show the inflation corresponds to the restriction if cp is monic. 10. (Neumann) Suppose G is an arbitrary ordered group (not necessarily finite) acting as automorphisms on a field K. Any 2-cocycle f: G"' -P K - (0) gives rise to a division ring 9 ( K ,f )whose elements are those formal sums { a,Lg:agE G} for which the support (9: a, # 0) is well-ordered, where addition is componentwise (in terms of coefficients of each &) and multiplication is given by the rules I,a = (ua)Igfor all a in K, and I,& = f ( g , h ) L , , , . (Hint: Use the argument of propositions 1.2.22 and 1.2.24.) If G = Z("' the additive structure of D is that of Laurent series K ( ( L , ,. . . ,A,))with multiplication given by Lia = (aia)Iiand l j I i = f ( u j ,u i ) f ( a iuj), ' A i l j where o,,.. .,a,are the generators of Z'"). 11. (Tignol-Amitsur [ 8 5 ] ) If G is an arbitrary finite abelian group and f: GIz' K is
c,
-+
Exercises
277
a Noether factor set then taking a gro_up surjection cp: Z(")G yields a Neumann division algebra L) = 9 ( K , f ) where f is the inflation of f under cp to a 2-cocycle f : Z'") x Z(") + K . Show D is naturally isomorphic to the iterated Laurent power and a’ for cry'). . . series ring. Given i = (i( I), .. . ,i(n)) in Z'") write 2' for 27'). . . a:"). Using the notation at the end of exercise 10, say an element a of K is i-good if for all j in 7'")we have ,f(a’,af)f(al,cri)-’ = a(o'a)-'. Let r = {i E P ) : a *is the identity on K and there is an i-good element}. Then Z ( D ) = ~ l E , { a , l i : ais, i-good}. Hence (deg 0)' = [Z'"T)]:[ K : F ] where F = K G ;since each of the righthand terms divides IGI show degD divides (GI. Amitsur-Tignol continue by describing all the subfields of D which are Kummer extensions of the center. --f
Factor Sets and Roots of 1 12. (Rowen [MI)If R has odd degree then there is an element d in R for which tr(d) = tr(d') = 0 where tr is the trace. (Hint: Take the Brauer factor set ( c i j k ) of exercise 8. One wants such that d =(fiijcijl)satisfies O = tr(d)=x/3iiciil= x p i i and 0 = tr(d2) = c p i j p j i .Thus one may assume (cijk)is trivial, in which case R is split and the result is obvious.) 13. (Brauer) If exp(R) = m and F has a primitive m-th root ( of 1 then R is similar to an algebra having a Brauer factor set all of whose elements are roots of 1. (Hint: Take a Brauer factor set ( C i j k ) for a maximal separable subfield K , and take yij such that 1 = c&yijyjky;'. Let L = K[yh"": 1 Ii,j In], also separable over F. If [ L : K ] = t then MI(R) has a Brauer factor set (c;,) with respect to L , comprised of blocks of ( C i j k ) . Since Gal(L/K) sends 7";' to ("y$/" for u = u ( i , j ) one can use the conjugacy conditions to expand the n x n matrix (yij) to a tn x tn matrix ( y ; ) with each y? = y i j . Now let cijk = C ~ j k y ~ j y ~ k & ' ,an m-th root of 1. The ( c g ) is a Brauer factor set associated to ( c g ) . 14. (Benard-Schacher) R is cyclotomic if there is a root ( of 1 for which F ( ( ) is a maximal subfield of R and the corresponding Noether factor set consists only of roots of 1. Show if R is cyclotomic of exponent m then F contains a primitive m-th root of 1. (Hint (Janusz [72]): Choose (' in the Noether factor set (cur)such that each ,c, is a power of ('. If = 1 then each cbr = 1 so rn It. It suffices to show [' E F. Write R = 1 ,F(()uo as in (1 1). For any p in G = Gal(F(()/F) build the new crossed product RP = ~ , F ( [ ) u ,with respect to (pc,,). One has an isomorphismR+R,sendingdu, to(pa)u,. Butp(=('forsomei,so R @ i N R , N R . Thus m I (i - 1) and hence pi' = (' for each p in G , proving (' E F.)
(aij)
(c')'
Corestriction 15. (Tate [76]) A cohomological description of the corestriction. Defining the cocomplex A = { A " ( G , M ) : nE N } and the cohomology groups H " ( G , M ) as in example 5.2.13. If H is of finite index in G and b = {bl,. .. ,b,} is a left transversal of H define tr,: A"(H,M ) + A"(G, M ) by I
(trb f ) ( g l * . ..,gn) =
C bO,Lf(bocSlb;!,
I=
1
b,igzb;!,
..
- 7
bn-
I.ignbii')i
278
Central Simple Algebras
where boi= bi and, inductively, bUiE Hb,for 1
-
17.
18.
19.
Show d( fl u f2) = ( d f , )u f2 + ( - l)'"f, u d f , where d is as in example 5.2.13, and cor( jlu res f2)= (cor fi) u f2 in the cohomology groups. (Tignol [83]) Suppose K is a cyclic field extension of F of dimension n, i.e., Gal(K/F) = (a) with a" = 1, and F has a primitive m-th root of 1. Let L be the fixed field of K under 0"'. Then the image of corL,F:Br(K/L)-+Br(K/F) is Br,(K/F). (Hint: " G " is clear. Suppose (a,P). E Br,(K/F), where K = F(fl""). Then (a, /3"),, 1 implying a is a norm from L, so use the projection formula.) (Tignol [ 8 3 ] ) Every cyclic F-algebra of degree n and exponent m is similar to a tensor product of n/m symbols of degree m, provided F has a primitive m-th root of 1. (Hint: Apply Rosset-Tate to exercise 17.) (Rowen-Saltman [ 8 2 ] ) Short proof of corollary 7.2.42. (Hint: Write G = ( u , ~ : a" = 1 = T' and UT = TO-’). Let L be a splitting field of R with Gal(L/F) = G. Let K be the fixed field L’,and Lo = La. K splits R since [ L : K ] is prime to n so K _C R, and also one can view L in the cyclic algebra R @ Lo. Take a E L such that aa = [a, and take b in R @ Lo such that ab = (ba. Then Ta E Fa. Let T' = 1 @ T. Replacing b by b("+1 ) ' 2 ~ ' b - (l)" " + one may assume 7'b = b-'. But Lo(b) also has Galois group G over F, so reversing the roles of a and b one may assume Ta = a - l , Let d = ( b + b - ' ) ( a + a - ' ) - ' . Using Newton's identities one can show the odd characteristic coefficientsof d are 0 by showing tr(dZk+I ) = 0 for k < n/2. But the same holds for d - ' , so the minimal polynomial of d has the form 2" a, i.e., d" E F.), Reprove every division algebra of degree 3 is cyclic by noting it is split by the dihedral group of order 6. (This assumes characteristic 0.) Do exercise 20 in char. # 0.
-
+
20.
21.
The Zero-Divisor Question 22. If D,,D, are division algebras having relatively prime degrees n l , n2 then D , 6D2 is a division algebra. (Hint: Tensoring by DQ2P shows n , [ index(D, 6 D2).) 23. (Albert) If Q = (a,& is a quaternion division algebra and D is a division algebra such that no subfield of D splits Q then D @ Q is a division algebra. (Hint: Take y , z in Q with y 2 = a, z 2 = fl, and y z = - z y . Suppose D @ Q has a zero-divisor r l + r 2 z where r l rr2 E D @ F ( y ) . Then r2 # 0, so one may assume r 2 = 1. Writing r l = d , + d z y yields the zero-divisor ( d , - d 2 y - z ) ( r , + z ) = d : - d : a - P + [ d , , d J y in D @ F ( y ) ,so this is 0. Hence [ d , , d , ] = O so F ( d , , d z )is a field; thus F(d,,d,)QQ is a division algebra in which (r,z)' = P2, so r , z = k f l , contradiction.)
279
Exercises
Central Simple Algebras with (*) 24. If M,(R) has an involution then R has an involution of the same kind. (Hint: For first kind use theorem 7.2.44; for second kind translate to the corestriction.) 25. Any involution (*) of first kind on R has either symplectic or orthogonal type. Furthermore, for any other involution (J)of the first kind on R there is some ro in R; with r: = f r o , such that r J = rglr*ro for all r in R; in characteristic # 2, (*) and (J) have the same type iff r: = + r o . (Hint: Skolem-Noether shows the automorphism r H ( r J ) * is given by conjugation by some ro. But then rgr;' E Z ( R ) = F, so r: E Fro; r z = +ro since r;* = r o . To prove the last assertion one may tensor by the algebraic closure F of F and thereby assume R = M,(F);now apply theorem 2.13.29 and remark 2.13.5.) 26. In proposition 7.2.45 we may take (*) to be of symplectic or orthogonal type at our discretion and may assume d* = d. (Hint: Notation as in that proof, one is done if Ad has both symmetric and antisymmetric elements. But, otherwise, there is ( = 5 1 such that (ad)* = [ad for all a in A, yielding da* = ((ad)* = ad, and hence A is commutative; conclude K is maximal and D = 1.) 27. Suppose n is a power of 2. The generic matrix ring with involution (F,{ Y } ,t) of exercise 6.4.3 is a domain whose ring of central fractions is a division algebra of exponent 2 and degree n. The same holds for (F,fY}, s). 28. Suppose (aij)r= -(aij). Define the Pfafian adjoint matrix to have its 0-entry be ( - l ) i + j - times the Pfaffian of the (n - 2) x (n - 2) matrix obtained by striking out both the i and j rows and columns. Using the Pfaffian adjoint prove by induction Pf(aij)= &g n)anl,n2.. . ax(n-l,.zm, summed over all permutations n for which n(2k - 1) < n(2k) for each k. For example, P f ( a i j )= a I 2for n = 2, and P f ( a i j )= 012434 - ul3az4 a14a2, for n = 4. 29. (Jacobson [83]) Suppose R has orthogonal type involution. Then R has a maximal commutative separable subalgebra K = F [ a ] with a* = a, and there is r = r* in R with R = K r K . Under notational hypothesis 7.1.33 (fiijrij)*= (Ojirij)and the Brauer factor set (cijk)satisfies cijt = ckji for all i, j , k. (Hint: Using Zariski topology one may assume R = M,(E); take a diagonal and r = Ci,jeij.A typical element is b = aU$- ' r d - so b* = xcxuva"-'ra"- I ; writing b = (pijrij)note
+
xu,"
pij = Ca,,u;-'ay-1.)
30. Suppose R has symplectic type involution. R has a maximal commutative separable subalgebra K = F [ a ] with a* = -a, and there is r = -r* in R with R = K r K . (*) is now given by ( j i j r i j ) *= -(fij+m,i+mrij), where m = n/2 and subscripts are taken modulo rn. (Hint: Take a,+, = -ai for 1 < i < m. Note if mi = aj then = Apply exercise 29 to the involution x H a - ' x * a to get ro such that ro = a-'r,*a and R = K r o K = K a r o K ; take r = aro. 31. If deg(R) = n = 2m and R has an involution (*) of symplectic type then there is h=h* for which tr(b)=tr(b-')=O. (Hint: Notation as in exercise 30, take Bij= f(ai) - f(aj+,) subscripts mod n, where f = a i l i is to be determined. Then b = (pijrij)is symmetric, and t r h = 0. Arguing as in proposition 7.1.43, using the Pfafian polynomial, one needs to solve a linear condition on the ai to ensure tr(b-') = 0.) 32. Any division algebra D of degree 8 and exponent 2 contains a maximal subfield
cy=-:
Central Simple Algebras
280
K Galois over F = Z ( D ) with Galois group (.Z/2Z)(3).(Hint: If D has a central quaternion subalgebra Q then D z Q 8C,(Q),so one is done by theorem 7.1.45. In general, by exercise 31 there is b * = b satisfying b4 + a , b 2 +a,=O for suitable a, in F; hence D does contain a quadratic field extension K, of F. By exercise 25, D has a symplectic-type involution which restricts t o the nontrivial automorphism u of K l over F; take d = d* for which dad-' = ua for all a in K. If d Z E F then K , and d generate a quaternion subalgebra, so assume d Z .$ F and let K , = F ( d Z ) .[ K z : F ] = 2 .Now one may assume (*) restricts to u @ l on K l @ K , = K, K, and repeat the argument.)
Merkurjev-Suslin Theorem 33. In proving the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem one may assume that R has prime exponent p and has a splitting field Galois over the center with Galois group an abelian p-group. (Hint: By digression 7.2.55' one may assume that R has a splitting field L whose Galois group is a p-group. Thus L contains a cyclic extension F, over F of degree p. Using the corestriction it is enough to show that R OFK is similar to a tensor product of cyclics of degree p , for some field K with [ K : F ] prime to p. By induction C,(F,) is similar to a tensor product of cyclics over F,. Consider such a cyclic algebra (a, b; F,),. Then b = f(a) for some f E F[E.] of degree < p ; taking K to be the splitting field of j over F, one sees [ K : F ] is prime to p and thus may replace F by K; thus one may assume f splits over F. Write f = (1. - al)...(A - al).Then b = ( a - al)...(a - a l ) , so (a,b), is similar to ( a , a - a 1 ) , 6 . . . @ ( a , a - a , ) , . But ( a , a - a i ) , - ( * a i , 1 - i 1 a , ) , by an easy computation, and this contains the cyclic field extension F(a!/P)of F; do this for each i and put them together.) = 1 then any symbol of degree 3 over F ( c ) is similar to the restriction of a tensor product of two cyclic algebras over F, by remark 7.2.52. (Hint: Take K = F([).) Conclude the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem can be extended to arbitrary base fields in case m = 3.
34. If
c3
Divisibility in the Brauer Group
supp0s7-
is a primitive m-th root of 1. Then F ( ( ) is cyclic over F provided m is 35. odd or - 1 E F. (Hint: Use Jacobson CUB, theorem 7.19 and 4.203.) 36. Suppose K O is a cyclic field extension of F with [ K O :F ] = p'. and F has a primitive p-th root [ of 1. Then K O is contained in a cyclic field extension K of F with
[ K : F ] = p t f l , iff c = No(ao)for some a, in K O ,where No is the norm from K O to F. (Hint: ( a )by lemma 7.3.1. (t) Let u be the generating automorphism of Gal(K,/F). By Hilbert's theorem 90 there is b, in K O for which bi’ub, = a:. Let K = K , ( b ) where b is a root of the polynomial f ( L ) = P - b , . Then uf=LP-ubbo so a extends to an automorphism of K given by a b = ['a,b. Applying No shows b .$ K O SO [ K : K O ] = p.) 37. Suppose K is a cyclic field extension of F having a subfield K Owith [ K : F ] = n and [ K , : F ] = m. Then [ ( K , O , ~ ) ] ~ /= " ' [ ( K o , u , a ) ] in Br(F) where u generates Gal(K/F). (Hint: Let k = n/m. It suffices to show R = ( K , , u , a ) @ ( K , u , a - ' ) is split. Take zo in (K,,u,a) with z t = a and zoaz,' = ua for all a in K O ;take z
Exercises
28 1
in ( K , c , ~ - ~with ) 2" = CI-’ and zaz-l = c~afor all a in K. Let R , be the subalgebra of R generated by zo @ z and 1 @ K; R , is split since (zo @ z)" = 1. Let K ' = ( K O@ and let R, be the subalgebra of R generated by K' and zo @ 1. It suffices to prove K ' has rn orthogonal idempotents, for then [R2: F ] 2 m z and thus R , = C,(R,) and is also split, proving R is split. Take the primitive idempotent e E K' as in exercise 6; {(d@ 1)e: 1 5 i n) are distinct primitive idempotents, as desired.) 38. Suppose F has a primitive p-th root [ of 1. [R] has a cyclic p-th root in Br(F) if R has a cyclic splitting field from which [ is a norm. (Hint: One may assume deg(R) = q' for q prime, and the result is trivial unless q = p. If R (K,,o,or) take K as in exercise 36 and apply exercise 37.) 39. If [ is a reduced norm from a splitting field of R then [R] has a p-th root in Br(F). In particular, if F has a primitive p'+'-root of 1 then the p'-torsion subgroup of Br(F) is p-divisible. (Hint: Apply Merkurjev-Suslin to exercise 36.)
-
p - Algebras 40. Suppose L is cyclic over F of dimension n = p'. Then L is contained in a field L( y) cyclic over F of dimension p i I ; yp = y + a where a E L satisfies oa - a = bP - b for suitable b in L. (Hint: Parallel to exercise 36. Tr,,,b = 1 for some b in L by the Dedekind independence of characters, cf., Jacobson [85B, p. 2973. Tr(bP- b) = 0 so Hilbert's theorem 90 (additive form) yields a in L for which ua - a = b P - b. Let y be a root of IJ' - I - a; u extends to an automorphism C? of L(y) given by Zy = y + b + u for some u in N. C?"y = y + 1, so C? has order np = p" '.) +
41. Any cyclic p-algebra is a p-power of a cyclic p-algebra. (Hint: by exercises 37,40. 42. If char(F) = p then the p-Sylow subgroup of Br(F) is p-divisible. (Hint: exercise
41 and Albert's theorem.) 43. In characteristic 2 prove the following: Every algebra of degree 4 is a crossed
product; every algebra of degree 4 and exponent 2 is decomposable into cyclics; every algebra R of degree 8 and exponent 2 is a crossed product, and M , ( R ) is decomposable into cyclics. (Hint: Use the computation that if y2 yy E F then for all r in R one has [y,r]y = -(y y)[y,r].)
+
+
Appendix 1. Analogously to example C5 find a generic crossed product with respect to a
specified Galois group C. (This can also be done using group rings, cf., exercises 8.2.7ff.) 2. Find a generic crossed product of exponent I rn with respect to a specified Galois group G .
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
8
Rings from Representation Theory
$8.1 General Structure Theory of Group Algebras In Chapter 1 we defined monoid algebras as a tool for studying polynomial rings. In this section we turn to the case where the monoid is a group G # (1); C [ G ] is then called a group algebra and is a C-algebra with base consisting of the elements of G. We shall concentrate on the situation for which the base ring C is a field F and shall study group algebras in terms of their ring-theoretic structure. F [ G ] is never simple since there is a surjection F [ G ] -P F sending each g in G to 1. O n the other hand, when G is finite F [ G ] is finite dimensional and thus Artinian and, in fact, is sernisimple Artinian when char(F) = 0 by Maschke’s theorem (8.1.8’ below). Thus many interesting structural questions pertain only to infinite groups. On the other hand, the study of group algebras of finite groups is enhanced by the rich theory of characters of group representations, and we would like that theory to be available. We shall try to circumvent this paradox by outlining some of the basic character theory, emphasizing that part which will yield intuition for some of the later results. However, we shall focus on general structure theory, which does not rely much on the character theory. Structural results on Noetherian group algebras are to be had in $8.2. Most
283
Rings from Representation Tbeory
284
of this material follows Passman [77B], which is the standard text (as well as reference for results published through 1976). A few newer results are given in the exercises. Throughout this section we assume that C is a commutative ring, F is a field, and G is a group, written multiplicatively. We identify G canonically as a subgroup of C [ G ] or F[G], by the injection g H lg. In this sense the group algebra contains all of the information about the group. On the other hand, sometimes C [ G ] z C[H] even when G a H.
Remark 8.1.1: If R is a C-algebra and H is a multiplicative subgroup of R then any group homomorphism f:G -+ H extends uniquely to an algebra homomorphism C [ G ] -+ R given by csg H c g f g . (This is a special case of proposition 1.3.16'.) In particular, any group homomorphism G -+ H extends to an algebra homomorphism C[G] -,C [ H ] , thereby yielding a functor %fi -+ C-dt!g given by G -+ C[G]. O n the other hand, the functor Unit: C - d t g -,%h, sending R to its multiplicative group of invertible elements (and restricting homomorphisms), also enters into the picture.
1
Remark 8.1.2: If G is a group then C [ G ] , together with the canonical injection G --+ C [ G ] , is a universal from G to the functor Unit. (Indeed, any group homomorphism f: G -+ Unit(R) extends uniquely to an algebra homomorphism C[G] -+ R , which restricts, in turn, to a group homomorphism Unit(C[G]) + Unit(R); this completes the appropriate diagram and is unique.)
3
In view of these observations it makes sense to transfer some terminology from algebras to groups, and in definition 5.2.12 we introduced G-modules; we see at once that any G-module becomes a Z[G]-module under the action ( x g n g g ) x= x n g ( g x ) , and thus G - & d and Z [ G ] - A o d are isomorphic categories. To proceed further we shall consider some of the basic structural properties of groups. Some minor ambiguities arise since the same terminology has a different connotation for groups than for rings and will depend on the context. In particular,
N 4 G denotes N is a normal subgroup of G. [gl, g2] will denote the group commutator g 1 g 2 g ; '9;'. The center Z ( G ) = { z E G: [z, G] = (l)}. The subgroup of G generated by a subset S is denoted (S) or as ( g l,. . .,g,) if S = { g , ,. . .,9,).
$8.1 General StructureTheory of Group Algebras
285
CG(A)denotes the centralizer of a subset A of G, which is {g E G: [ g , A ] = (1)); recall for any g in G that [G: c G ( g ) ] is the number of conjugates
of g. Recall supp(
c,g) = ( 9 :cg # 0 ) .
The order of an element g in G is also called the period of g; G is called a p’-group if no element has period p. It turns out that many of the structural results hold for F [ G ] when char(F) = 0 or when p = char(F) > 0 and G is a p’-group. We shall unify these two situations by means of the terminology, G is a char(F)‘-group”.
An Introduction to the Zero- Divisor Question One of the most elementary questions one can ask about F [ G ] is whether or not it has zero-divisors. If g E G has period n then 0 = 1 - g” = (1 - g) (1 + g + ... + g”-l), so C[CJ certainly is not a domain. What about the torsion-free case?
-
Questions for Torsion-FreeGroups:
(i) Zero-divisor question. I s F [ G ] necessarily a domain? (ii) Failing (i), can F [ G ] have nontrivial idempotents? Amazingly, these questions are still open, although F [ G ] is now known to be a domain in many cases, to be discussed in $8.2. When G is abelian the answer is easy.
Proposition 8.1.3: If G is torsion-free abelian and C is an integral domain then C [ G ] is an integral domain. Proof: Suppose rlrZ = 0 for r l ,r2 in C[G]. Replacing G by the subgroup generated by supp(rl)u supp(r,), we may assume G is finitely generated abelian, so G % (gl) x ... x (gt) for suitable gi in G. But now C[G] can be identified with a subring of the Laurent series ring C((G)), which is a domain. Q.E.D.
An alternate conclusion to the previous proof is by the following convenient observation.
Remark 8.1.4: C I G l x G,] = CIGl] 0 C[GJ (Indeed, define 9:CIGl] x C [ C , ] -C[G, x G,] by y ( ~ c , g , ~ c b h=)x c , c l ( g , h ) . Clearly rp is a balanced map which induces a surjection C[G,] 0 C [ G 2 ]-+ CIGl x G,], whose inverse is given by C c(g.h)(g,h) I+ C c,g,h,g0 It.
286
Rings from Representation Theory
Maschke s Theorem and the Regular Representation Group algebras have an extra piece of structure. Remark 8.1.5: Suppose C has a given automorphism u of degree 2. (In particular, one could take 0 = 1). Then C[G] has an involution given by
(CSP&Y)*= C ( q S - l . Proposition 8.1.6: Suppose C is a subring of C closed under complex conjugation, and take (*) as in remark 8.1.5. l f a E C [ G ] and a*a = 0 then a = 0. In particular, C[G] is semiprime. Proof: Write a = C a g g . The coefficient of 1 in a*a is O = ~ g i i g a q = ~ I a ~ ~ 2 soeacha,=O.Hencea=O.It followsthat if A d (C[G],*) withO=A2=A*A Q.E.D. then A = 0, so C[G] is semiprime by the easy proposition 2.13.34.
Corollary 8.1.7: (Maschke’s theorem for C) @[GI is semisimple Artinian for any jinite group G.
Proofi
@[GI is semiprime and Artinian.
Q.E.D.
Maschke’s theorem is the fundamental theorem in the subject of group algebras. Let us try to generalize it in various directions. Using field theory we shall first show that the main hypothesis in proposition 8.1.6 is superfluous. For that proof to work, the only property required of C was that C = K [ G ] for a suitable field K in which 0 cannot be written as a sum of nonzero squares; in the proof we took K = R. We shall now see that all algebraically closed fields of characteristic 0 have this property.
Theorem from the Artin-Schreier Theory of Real-Closed Fields: Any algebraically closed jield E of characteristic 0 has a subjeld K satisfying the following properties: (1) Any sum of nonzero squares is a nonzero square. (2) E = K [ i ] w h e r e i 2 = - 1 . Proof: Obviously -1 is not a sum of squares in Q; so by Zorn’s lemma, E has a subfield K maximal with respect to - 1 is not a sum of squares. By Lang [65B, theorem 11.2.11 K is real closed; in particular, every sum of nonzero squares in K is a nonzero square in K , and K[i] is algebraically
287
$8.1 General Structure Theory of Group Algebras
closed. It remains to show E is an algebraic extension of K , for then we shall have K [ i ] = E. Suppose a E E - K . Then K ( a ) =I K so - 1 = C(Pi(a)/q(a))’
for p i , q in K [ A ] taken with degq minimal. Thus -q(a)’ =zpi(a)’, so q(a)’+ Cpi(a)’ = 0. We claim the polynomial q(1)’ Cpi(A)’ is nonzero. Otherwise, taking the constant terms pio, qo of pi,q we get 0 = q i x p f in K , implying each pio = qo = 0. But then we can cancel A from q and from each pi,contrary to supposition, so the claim is established. It follows at once that a is algeQ.E.D. braic over K , as desired.
+
+
Lemma 8.1.8: If F is algebraically closed of characteristic 0 then FCG] has no nil left ideal L # 0. Proof: Otherwise take 0 # a E L. As seen above we can write F = Foci] where F, is real closed. Then the proof of proposition 8.1.6 is available (for C = Fo), implying b = a*a # 0, so b2 = b*b # 0, and by iteration each power of b # 0, contrary to L being nil. Q.E.D.
Theorem 8.1.8‘: (Maschke’s theorem in characteristic 0 for arbitrary groups). ff char(F) = 0 then F [ G ] is semiprime. In particular, if G is finite then F is semisimple Artinian.
Proof: Let F be the algebraic closure of F. Then F [ G ] z F[G] 0 F has no nonzero nilpotent ideals, so F[G] has no nonzero nilpotent ideals. Q.E.D. Next we aim for an alternate proof of Maschke’s theorem, which also deals with characteristic p , by looking at conjugacy classes.
Proposition 8.1.9: ff h E G has oniy a jinite number of conjugates h,, . . .,h, then C I = , h i ~ Z ( C I G ] )and , conjugation by any g in G permutes the conjugates.
Proof: Let hffi= ghig-’, a conjugate of h. Clearly ni # Irj for i # j , so 7c permutes the subscripts. Write a = hi. Then gag-’ = Cy=,hffi= c h i = a, showing a commutes with each g in G; thus a E Z ( C [ G ] ) . Q.E.D.
cy=,
288
Rings from Representation Theory
This leads us to the following important definition. Definition 8.1.10: A(G) = ( g E G:g has only a finite number of conjugates} = { g E G: C,(g) has finite index in C}.
Remark 8.1.11: A(G) is a characteristic subgroup of G, and A(A(G)) = A(G). More generally, if gi has ni conjugates for i = 1,2 then g;' has n , conjugates and g 1 g 2 has at most nln2 conjugates (seen by observing Y(9192)g-' = ( s g i '9)(99i19)).
Proposition 8.1.12: (Converse to proposition 8.1.9) Suppose z E Z(C[C])). I f h E supp(z) then every conjugate of h is in supp(z), so h E A(G). Consequently, Z(C[G]) is a free C-module whose base consists of all elements of the form C { a n conjugates of h} where h E A(G); in particular, Z(C[G]) G C[A(C)J. Proof: Write z = x c h h . For any g in G we have x c , h = z = gzg-' = Cc,ghg-', implying every conjugate of h appears in supp(z) with the same coefficient. Since supp(z) is finite this proves the first assertion. Moreover, writing zh for C{conjugates of h} we can rewrite z = IChZh, summed over representatives of the conjugacy classes in supp(z). Thus all the zh span Z(C[G]) and are independent because distinct conjugacy classes are disjoint. Q.E.D.
Corollary 8.1.13: Suppose H is a finite subgroup of G , and r = x h E Hh. Then r 2 = J H J rmoreover, ; r E Z(C[G]) iff H a G.
zh.EHh'
Proof: For each h in H we have rh = Ch.E,h'h = = r, so r2 = x h E H r h= C h c H r= J H J rThe . other assertion follows at once from propositions 8.1.9 and 8.1.12. Q.E.D.
xhEH
h used in this proof has fundamental significance in The element the theory of group algebras over finite groups. To apply this result, suppose J G J= n. Recall that there is a group injection Sym(n) + G L ( n , F ) sending a permutation 7~ to the permutation matrix eni,i ; composing this with the group injection G -,Sym(n) given by Cayley's theorem yields a (faithful) representation G -,G L ( n ,F ) called the regular representation, which is the restriction to G of the regular representation of F [ G ] as F-algebra. Writing G = .( g l , . . .,g.} we see that the matrix $ corresponding to y is x e , i , i where gyi = gni. Note tr($) = 0 if g # 1, since then ggi # gi for all i; tr(1) = n.
88.1 General Structure Theory of Group Algebras
289
Theorem 8.1.14: (Maschke's theorem for arbitrary j e l d s ) Suppose [GI = n. Nil(F[G]) = 0 ifs char(F){n, in which case F[G] is semisimple Artinian. Proof: (=.) Let z = c g E G gThen . 0 # z E Z(F[G]), so 0 # z 2 = IGlz = nz, implying char(F))n. (-=) Take r = x g E G a y g in Nil(F[G]). For any h in supp(r) we have h-'r = crhl + Cg+hagh-lg,so (taking traces via the regular representation) we get
But h-'r is nilpotent so tr(h-'r) = 0. Thus nuh = 0 implying ah = 0. This proves r = 0, as desired. The last assertion is clear since F[G] is Artinian. Q.E.D.
Group Algebras of Subgroups Later on we shall consider the question of when a group algebra satisfies a polynomial identity. For the present we record one easy result which places much of the PI-theory at our disposal. Recall a transversal of a subgroup H in G is a set of representatives of the left cosets of H in G. Remark 8.2.25: Any transversal B of H is a C[H]-base for C[C]; if H 4 G then B is C[H]-normalizing. (Indeed G = U b a e H b implying C[G] = C[H]B, proving B spans. To prove B is a base suppose C r i b i = 0 where ri = C C i h h E C[H] and bi E B; then 0 = Ccihhbiso each Cih = 0 implying ri = 0. The last assertion is clear.)
This has an immediate application. Proposition 8.1.16: I f [G: H] = n then there is a canonical injection C[G] -+ M,(C[H]) since C[G] is a free C[H]-module of dimension n; in particular, if G has an abelian subgroup H of index n then C[G] satisjies all polynomial identities of n x n matrices. Proofi The first assertion follows from remark 8.1.15 by means of corollary 1.5.14; the second assertion is then immediate since C[H] is abelian. Q.E.D.
290
Rings from Representation Theory
Augmentation Ideals and the Characteristic p Case It remains to consider the case where char(F) = p and G has p-torsion. The situation becomes much more complicated, although the answer is very neat in one particular case. If H
kerp,
= { ~ C g g : ~ C=g0 ) .
If F is a field then w ( F [ G ] ) is a maximal ideal since F [ G ] / w ( F [ G ] )2 F. More generally, if char(F) = p and G / H is a finite p’group then kerp, is an intersection of a finite number of maximal ideals, by Maschke’s theorem. Remark 8.1.18:
c
Remark 8.1.19:
versely, if r
=
cgsc C ( g - 1).
o(C[G]) = cgg E o(C[G])
then r
=
c
(Indeed ( 2 )is clear; concg = c c , ( g - l).)
cgg -
Theorem 8.1.20: Suppose G is a .finite p-group and char(F) = p . Then F [ G ] is a local ring whose Jacobson radical is nilpotent. Proof: For any g in G we have g4 = 1 for a suitable power q of p , so ( g - l)q = g 4 - 1 = 0. Thus w ( F [ G ] )= c F ( g - 1) is spanned by nilpotent elements and thus is nilpotent by proposition 2.6.32. We are done since Q.E.D. w ( F [ G ] )is a maximal ideal. One can actually use the augmentation ideal to compute kerp, for H
ker p H = o ( C [ H ] ) C [ G ] = C [ C ] w ( C [ H ] ) .
Proofi By symmetry we need only show the first equality. Let {gi:i E 1 ) be a transversal and write G = G / H . By remark 8.1.15 any r of CCG] can then be written as c r i g i where ri E CCH], and we have p H r= x(pHii)gi. Thus r E ker p H iff each pHri= 0 in C , i.e., iff each ri E w ( C [ H ] ) .This proves Q.E.D. ker p , G o ( C [ H ] ) C [ G ] and , the reverse inclusion is clear.
58.1 General Structure Theory of Group Algebras
291
Major Digression: The Structure of Group Algebras of Finite Groups Starting with Maschke’s theorem one can branch off to a detailed study of the structure of F[G] for G finite. This subject is of utmost significance in the study of finite groups as well as other branches of algebra, but is so extensively treated in the literature that any presentation here would be inadequate and superfluous. Nevertheless, since we need the intuition to be had from that theory, we shall recall certain aspects of the theory, our goal being to indicate how the character theory can be used to study the structure of the group ring. The reader should consult Jacobson [SOB] for a beautiful summary or CurtisReiner [62B, 82B] for a thorough account of the representation theory. The best source of results on characters which apply to the group algebra structure may be Isaacs [76B]. For the remainder of this digression G is finite and char(F) = 0. We already have the following information about the semisimple Artinian ring R = F[G]: (i) The number of nonisomorphic simple R-modules equals the number of simple components of R , by theorem 2.3.13. (ii) The number of conjugacy classes of G is [Z(R): F], by proposition 8.1.12. (iii) These numbers are all the same iff the center of each simple component of R is canonically isomorphic to F. Of course, if R is split, i.e., a direct product of matrix algebras over F, then (iii) holds; in this important case we call F a splitting field for G. We shall return to splitting fields shortly. The key to investigating F[G] is the group representation of degree n, by which we mean a group homomorphism p : G + GL(n, F ) ; sometimes it is convenient to extend p to an F-algebra homomorphism F [ G ] + M J F ) . There is a fundamental correspondence between representations and F[G]modules which are finite dimensional over F. Suppose V is an F[G]module and [V:F] = n. Left multiplication by any g in G yields a linear transformation pg: V + V. The map y I+ pg yields a homomorphism G + Aut, V % GL(n, F ) , which is a representation of degree n. Conversely, viewing M , ( F ) as End, V for a vector space V over F, we can use any representation p to study I/ naturally as a G-module or thus as an F I G ] module. So the representation theory is part of the module theory of F [ G ] ; in particular, we say y is irreducible if the corresponding F[G]-module V is simple. In this case D = End,,,, V is a division algebra by Schur’s lemma.
292
Rings from Representation Tbeory
If p is a representation of degree n then p l is the n x n identity matrix so tr(p1) = n. This leads us to define the character x aflorded by p to be the function 1:G + F given by x g = tr(pg). Characters are much easier to handle than the representations which afford them, but still carry much of the information contained by the representation; consequently they are the main tool of representation theory. Crucial Remark: If g E G has order m then the minimal polynomial of g divides i." - 1, so the characteristic values of pg must be m-th roots of 1. Thus xy is a sum of m-th roots of 1. Examples:
(i) If x1 = 1 we say x is a linear character; in this case x = p : G -+ F is a group homomorphism, (ii) The unit character is the linear character given by xg = 1 for all g in G. (iii) The regular representation has degree IGI and affords the character x given by X I = (GI and x g = 0 for all g # 1. Until further notice assume F is a splitting field for G, and let t be the M n ( F )for suitable number of conjugacy classes of G. Thus F [ G ] z ni,and a dimension count shows nf = jGJ. Note that the ring structure o j F [ G ] is completely determined by the n,. Let us describe the commutative part of F [ G ] . If H 4 G then the map G -+ G / H yields a surjection F[G] + F[G/H], so F [ G / H ] is isomorphic to the direct product of some of the simple components of F [ G ] . Let G’ be the commutator subgroup. Then G/G' is abelian so F[G/G'] is commutative. We claim F[G/G'] is isomorphic to the direct product of all of the commutative components of F [ G ] . Indeed, we may pass to a splitting field and assume F is a splitting field. But then each commutative component of F[G] corresponds to a linear character x : G + F ; since ker x 2 G’ we see x factors through G + G/G' + F, yielding a linear character of G / G ' as desired. Let pl ,. . . ,p, correspond to a maximal set of nonisomorphic simple F[G]-modules, which thus are a maximal set of inequivalent irreducible representations. Let xi denote the character afforded by p i . Then deg(xi)= n i , so the characters yield the ring structure of F [ G ] . Furthermore, the xi are distinct. Indeed letting e, = p i l we have
I:=
n:=,
xj(eig)= tr pj(eig) = tr 6,ejpjg = iiijxg, so taking g i such that xigi # 0 we see x i ( e i g i )= x i g i # 0 but x j ( e i g i )= 0 for i # j.
88.1 General Structure Theory of Group Algebras
F
293
A fairly straightforward computation enables one to prove that when =4 2 there is a Hermitian form on characters, given by
cf., Jacobson [80B, pp. 272-2751.
Brauer's Theorem on Splitting Fields [80B, p. 3141: Suppose G has exponent m. Then any jield F in which the polynomial I" - 1 splits is a splitting jield for G . Note: The proof in characteristic p is actually quite trivial: Let F , be the splitting field of 2" - 1 over the characteristic subfield of F, a finite field. Then every simple component Ri of F,[G] has the form M,,(K,) for a suitable field K , , by Wedderburn's theorem that finite division rings are fields. But for each a in R , , tr a, is a sum of roots of 1 and thus belongs to F,, proving K i = F,, as desired.
Note xg= n iff p g = 1 , and IxgI = n iff p g is a scalar. This is seen by passing to the algebraic closure of F, over which p g is conjugate to a diagonal matrix whose entries clearly are roots of 1. We have the following two normal subgroups of G : kerx = {g E G : xg = n } = kerp and Z ( x ) = { g E G:IxgI = n } .
Proposition: Each n: I[ G :Z(xi)], equality holding iff xig = 0 for all g 4 Z(x,).
Corollary: lf G/Z(xi) is abelian then (G: Z(x,)l = n:. Proofi One must show x i g = 0 for all g 4 Z(xi). But then pig is not a scalar matrix so there is h in G such that the group commutator [ ~ ~ g - ~ , #p ~1 h ] so z = [ g - ' , h] 4 ker xi. But z E Z(xi) by hypothesis so p i z = [I for some Q.E.D. i# 1. Thus xig = xi(hgh-') = x i g z = [xisimplying xig = 0. Finally, we would like to quote a theorem of Schur (Jacobson [80B, p. 283]), that the degree of each irreducible character divides [G:Z(G)]. With these results in hand we can determine quite a few group algebras. Examples (letting Z = Z ( G ) ) : Recall from group theory that if G is a p group # 1 then Z # (1) and [G:Z] # p . In particular, if IGI = p 2 then G is abelian. Assume char(F) = 0 for simplicity.
Rings from Representation Tbeory
294
(i) G is abelian. Remark 8.1.4 reduces the structure of F [ G ] to the case G is cyclic. Write G = ( 9 ) where g" = 1. If F has a primitive nthroot [ of 1 then F [ G ] z F(") where the j I h component is generated by the idempotent ["g'. At the other extreme let us determine Q[G]. Write F, = Q[["'"] for all m n. Then [F,: Q ] = cp(m) where cp is Euler's cp function. Moreover, for each m I n there is a surjection F [ G ] + F, given by the group map g +["/'", so F, is a component of F [ G ] . Counting dimensions shows Q [ G ] z F,. In particular, if n is prime then Q [ G ] z Q x Q[']. (ii) Suppose ]GI = p 3 for p prime and G is not abelian. Then IG/Zl = p 2 , so G / Z is abelian. Thus G' = Z so G has IG/G'I = p 2 linear characters. Any other irreducible character xi has n? = [ G : Z ( x i ) ] I p 3 implying n, = p . Now p 3 = IGI = = p 2 1 ( t - p 2 ) p 2 , whence p = 1 + r - p 2 , implying t = p 2 p - 1. This implies F [ G ] z P p 2 x) M p ( F ) ' P - l )for any splitting field F of G .
c:=
I
n,,,
+
En;
- +
For p = 2 there are two nonisomorphic nonabelian groups of order 8, namely the dihedral group D, and the quaternion group Q s . Each has exponent 4 and so by Brauer's theorem is split by O[i]; their group algebras over Q [ i ] are isomorphic by the last paragraph. Let us compare their group algebras over Q. In each case G / G ' z E 2 x Z,, and Q [ Z 2 ] z Q c 2 ) by (i), so O [ G / G ' ] x Qf2)@a Q c 2 ) z Qe(,), which is the commutative part of Q [ G ] . There is room only for one more component, of dimension 4 over Q. For G = D, = (a, b: a4 = 1 = b2 and b-lab = a 3 ) , we have a surjection Q [ G ] + M 2 ( Q ) given by a H
(-:
L)
and b H
(i -:);
hence M 2 ( Q )
is one of the components of Q [ D 4 ] , which thus is M 2 ( Q ) x Q('). Thus Q is a splitting field for D,. For G = Q8 = ( a , b : a 4 = 1 = b4, a' = b2, and b-'ab = a 3 ) , we take Hamilton's quaternion algebra W = Q @ Qi @ Qj @ Qk where i j = -ji = k and i 2 =j 2 = k 2 = - 1; there is a surjection Q [ G ] + W given by a H i and b Hj , so Q [ Q J z W x QC4! (iii) G is the Dihedral group D, = (a, b : a m= 1 = b2 and b-lab = a"-’). (We treated m = 4 in (ii).) Then [b,aj] = a-2i so ( a 2 ) E G'; on the other hand, G / ( a 2 ) is abelian so G' = ( a ' ) has index 1 4 in G. ( a ) has index 2 in G so by proposition 8.1.16 we see F [ G ] has PI degree I 2, implying each component Rihas degree < 2. Passing to the splitting field and counting linear characters, we see each R , is F-central, so [ R , :F ] = 1 or 4. If rn is even then (a’) # ( a ) so [ G : G'] = 4. This implies 4(t - 4) 4 = 2m, i.e., r = m / 2 + 3, which is usually proved by describing the conjugacy classes explicitly. Thus F [ G ] x F'4' x m i 2 - 1 R , for quaternion F-algebras R , .
+
Hi=,
48.1 General Structure Theory of Group Algebras
295
If m is odd then (a’) = ( a ) so G / G “ z Z, and F [ G / G ’ ] = F(”; as before, we see F [ G ] = F‘” x R , where each R , is a quaternion F-algebra. One can display the complex representations of D, explicitly (cf., Jacobson [SOB, p. 261]), and show that many of the characters of degree 2 have values not in Q whenever m > 3. Thus Q is not a splitting field for D, for m 2 3. However, every fin