RHEOLOGY FOR POLYMER MELT PROCESSING
RHEOLOGY SERIES Advisory Editor: K. Waiters FRS, Professor of Applied Mathematics, University of Wales, Aberystwyth, U.K.
Vol.
1 Numerical Simulation of Non-Newtonian Flow (M.J. Crochet, A.R. Davies and K. Waiters)
Vol.
2 Rheology of Materials and Engineering Structures (Z. Sobotka)
Vol.
3 An Introduction to Rheology (H.A. Barnes, J.F. Hutton and K. Waiters)
Vol.
4 Rheological Phenomena in Focus (D.V. Boger and K. Waiters)
Vol.
5 Rheology for Polymer Melt Processing (Edited by J-M. Piau and J-F. Agassant)
RHEOLOGY FOR POLYMER MELT PROCESSING
Edited by
J-M. Piau
Laboratoire de Rheologie, Domaine Universitaire, Grenoble, France
and
J-F. Agassant
CEMEF Ecole des Mines, Valbonne Cedex, France
1996 Elsevier Amsterdam
- Lausanne
- New
York - Oxford
- Shannon
- Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Library
oF Congress C a t a l o g i n g - i n - P u b l i c a t i o n
Data
Rheology f o r polymer melt process|ng / [ e d i t e d by] J.-M. Piau and d. -F. Agassant. p. cm. - - (Rheo]ogy s e r i e s ; v o l . 5) Inc]udes b i b l i o g r a p h i c a l r e f e r e n c e s and index. ISBN 0-444-82236-4 ( a l k . paper) 1. Polymers--Rheology. 2. Po]ymer m e l t i n g . I . Piau. J.-M. I I . Agassant, J . - F . I I I . S e r l e s : Rheology s e r i e s ; 5. TP1150.R49 1996 668.9--dc20 96-31377 CIP
ISBN: 0 444 82236 4 91996 ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U . S . A . - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive Danvers, MA 01923. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science B.V., unless otherwise specified. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands.
PREFACE
This book presents the main results obtained by different laboratories involved in the research group "Rheology for polymer melts processing" and belonging to various French universities, schools of engineering and to the CNRS (Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique - France). This research group was created in 1987 and is supported by the CNRS, the French Ministry for Research and Technology and three major French companies (ELF-ATOCHEM, MICHELIN and RHONE-POULENC). The group has comprised up to 15 research laboratories with different skills (chemistry, physics, material sciences, mechanics, mathematics) but with a common challenge : to make progress in understanding the relationships between macromolecule species, their rheology and their processing. The first problem was to find a language common to all the experts in these different fields in order to promote effective cooperations. This was achieved through regular technical meetings (a minimum of two meetings every year) as well as open meetings (in Paris, Sophia Antipolis, ViUard de Lans, Biarritz, Le Mans, Strasbourg, and Paris again for the final meeting) where recognized international scientists were invited. Some crucial issues of polymer science have been addressed ; correlation of viscoelastic macroscopic bulk property measurements and models, slip at the wall, extrusion defects, correlation between numerical flow simulations and experiments. Significant research results have been obtained, and have been or will be published in International Journals or congress proceedings. In addition, every participant has benefited in his own research activities from being a member of the "Rheology for polymer processing" research group and is now better prepared for developing further cooperation as well as for addressing new problems. The selection of results provided in the present book is unique in the sense that it allows one to grasp the key issues in polymer rheology and processing at once, through a series of detailed state of the art contributions. Generally these issues can only be found in different books. Each paper was reviewed by experts and by the book editors and some coordination was established in order to achieve a readable and easy access style.
vi Nevertheless, each author remains responsible for his own contribution. Papers have been gathered in sections covering successively : "Molecular dynamics", "Constitutive equations and numerical modelling", "Simple and complex flows". However, each paper can be read independently. This book can be considered as an introduction to the main topics in polymer processing. It is therefore intended to be useful for graduate students as well as for scientists in academic or industrial research laboratories 9polymer suppliers now have the opportunity through the development of new catalysts and new polymer blends to propose speciality polymers which are well adapted to a specific type of production but this entails better control of the relationships between macromolecular structure, rheology and processing. On the other hand, machine or tool makers want to define the best tools and processing conditions for obtaining maximum throughput free of defects, at a controlled final temperature, with minimum trial and error. Computer-assisted design is starting to be commonly used but this calls for strong numerical algorithms as well as realistic constitutive equations. Finally, polymer converters are often small companies but with a high level of innovation. They also need appropriate numerical software in order to choose the right polymer and machine to achieve the best product properties. We hope that this book will help to enhance the interest of the scientific and technical community for the fascinating field of rheology and polymer sciences. We are very proud to be surrounded by he enthusiastic colleagues of the "Rheology for polymer processing" research group and we thank them for their assistance in the preparation of this book.
J. M. Piau, J. F. Agassant
~176
VII
CONTENTS
PREFACE
.............................................................................
v
I. M O L E C U L A R DYNAMICS I. 1 The reptation model : tests through diffusion measurements in linear polymer melts L. l.,6ger, H. Hervet, P. Auroy, E. Boucher, G. Massey I n t r o d u c t i o n ..................................................................... T h e r e p t a t i o n m o d e l ............................................................ Diffusion m e a s u r e m e n t s in p o l y m e r systems ............................... Interpretation and comparison with rheometrical data ..................... Conclusions ....................................................................
1 2 6 11 15
1.2 Polybutadiene : NMR and Temporary elasticity J.P. Cohen Addad Introduction ..................................................................... T e m p o r a r y n e t w o r k structures ............................................... S e g m e n t a l motions : dynamic screening effect ............................. M o l t e n high p o l y m e r s 9 semi-local dynamics ............................... Conclusion ......................................................................
17 20 28 33 35
1.3 Chain relaxation processes of uniaxially stretched polymer chains : an infrared dichroism study J.F. Tassin, L. Bokobza, C. Hayes, L. Monnerie Introduction ..................................................................... Theoretical background in Infrared dichroism .............................. Experimental .................................................................... T h e o r e t i c a l basis o f interpretation ............................................ Results and discussion on isotopically labeled chains ..................... Results and discussion on isotopically labelled 6-arm stars .............. Results and discussion on binary blends of long and short chains ....... Conclusion ......................................................................
37 38 39 41 44 49 55 61
1.4 Chain conformation in elongational and shear flow as seen by SANS R. Muller, C. Picot I n t r o d u c t i o n ..................................................................... Methodology .................................................................... E l o n g a t i o n a l f l o w .............................................................. S h e a r f l o w ...................................................................... C o n c l u s i o n s and p e r s p e c t i v e s ................................................
65 66 73 87 93
~176 VIII
1.5 Molecular rheology and linear viscoelasticity G. Marrin, J.P. Montfort Introduction ..................................................................... Linear viscoelastic behaviour of linear and flexible chains - basics and p h e n o m e n o l o g y ............................................................. The case of entangled monodisperse linear species : pure reptafion ...... E n t a n g l e d m o d e l - b r a n c h e d p o l y m e r s ........................................ Entangled polydisperse linear chains : double reptation ................... Effects of non e n t a n g l e d chains .............................................. P r o b l e m s still p e n d i n g .........................................................
95 96 105 114 119 129 135
II. CONSTITUTIVE EQUATIONS AND N U M E R I C A L M O D E L L I N G II. 1 Experimental validation of non linear network models C. Carrot, J. Guillet, P. Revenu, A. Arsac Introduction ..................................................................... T h e o r e t i c a l aspects ............................................................. E x p e r i m e n t a l aspects ........................................................... Experimental validation of the W a g n e r m o d e l ............................... Experimental validation of the Phan Thien-Tanner model ................... Conclusion ......................................................................
141 144 159 167 176 190
II.2 Mathematical analysis of differential models for viscoelastic fluids J. Baranger, C. Guillop6, J.C. Saut I n t r o d u c t i o n . T h e m o d e l s ..................................................... Maxwell type models : loss of evolution and change of type ............. S t e a d y f l o w s .................................................................... U n s t e a d y f l o w s ................................................................. S t a b i l i t y i s s u e s .................................................................. Numerical analysis of viscoelastic flows .................................... Conclusion ......................................................................
199 201 203 208 214 225 230
II.3 Computation of 2D viscoelastic flows for a differential constitutive equation Y. Demay Introduction ..................................................................... Computation of a purely viscous flow ....................................... Finite elements method for viscoelastic flows .............................. Application ...................................................................... Conclusion ......................................................................
237 240 244 252 252
III. SIMPLE AND COMPLEX FLOWS III. 1 Validity of the stress optical law and application of birefringence to polymer complex flows R. Muller, B. Vergnes Introduction ..................................................................... General relationships and usefulness of birefringence measurements ... Validity of the stress optical law .............................................. Application to complex flow studies ......................................... Conclusion ......................................................................
257 257 264 277 281
III.2 Comparison between experimental data and numerical models J. Guillet, C. Carrot, B.S. Kim, J.F. Agassant, B. Vergnes, C. B6raudo, J.R. Clermont, M. Normandin, Y. B6raux Introduction ..................................................................... Materials ......................................................................... C o n s t i t u t i v e e q u a t i o n s ......................................................... F l o w g e o m e t r i e s and e x p e r i m e n t s ............................................ Numerical models .............................................................. C o m p a r i s o n between numerical results and experiments .................. Conclusions .....................................................................
285 289 289 295 300 317 333
111.3 Slip at the wall L. IAger, H. Hervet, G. Massey Introduction ..................................................................... Local determination of the velocity at the wall .............................. M o l e c u l a r m o d e l s and discussion ............................................ Conclusions ....................................................................
337 338 348 353
III.4 Slip and friction of polymer melt flows N. E1 Kissi, J.M. Piau Introduction ..................................................................... Means used ..................................................................... F l o w in h i g h surface e n e r g y dies ............................................ F l o w in dies with low surface energy ....................................... D i s c u s s i o n and c o n c l u s i o n ....................................................
357 359 361 372 384
III.5 Stability phenomena during polymer melt extrusion N. E1 Kissi, J.M. Piau Introduction ..................................................................... E x p e r i m e n t a l facilities and flow curves ..................................... V i s u a l i z a t i o n of u p s t r e a m flow ............................................... O b s e r v a t i o n of stable flow - sharkskin ...................................... Observation of unstable flow for slightly to moderately entangled p o l y m e r s - melt fracture .................................................... H i g h l y e n t a n g l e d polymers - flow with slip ................................ Conclusion ...................................................................... SUBJECT
INDEX
....................................................................
389 391 397 402 408 413 415 421
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Rheology for Polymer Melt Processing J-M. Piau and J-F. Agassant (editors) 1996 Elsevier Science B.V.
T h e reptation model: tests t h r o u g h d i f f u s i o n m e a s u r e m e n t s in l i n e a r p o l y m e r melts
L. LEGER, H. HERVET, P. AUROY, E. BOUCHER, G. MASSEY, Laboratoire de Physique de la Mati~re Condens6e, URA CNRS 792, Coll~ge de France, 11 Place Marcelin-Berthelot, 75231 PARIS Cedex 05, FRANCE 1. INTRODUCTION The wide range of applications of polymer materials relies in part on their unique viscoelastic behaviour. In the melt state, a polymer sample can be strongly deformed (deformation ratio of several hundred of percent) without breakage, and then recover its original shape almost completely if the stress is relaxed after a short enough time. This memory is completely lost after long periods of time, and the same material flows like any ordinary viscous liquid. A number of methods have been developed to investigate this behaviour [ 1] and to try to relate the time after which the system behaves like a simple liquid to its molecular characteristics. The Brownian motion, in polymer melts or in sufficiently concentrated solutions of linear flexible macromolecules, also presents unique features, the most well known being a self diffusion coefficient scaling as Mw -2, with Mw the weight average molecular weight of the polymer chains [2], for large molecular weights. Viscoelasticity (response to an external mechanical excitation) and diffusion (response to thermal fluctuations) must have their origin in the same dynamical process at the molecular level, and any model proposed to explain one aspect must also consistently account for the other. Early in the development of this area it was suggested that the unique dynamics of dense long polymer chains was due to molecular "entanglements" [3], first introduced as a rather loose concept which expresses the strong restrictions that uncrossable, unidimensional objects must exert on the motion of their neighbours. The reptation model, proposed by P.G. de Gennes in 1971 [4], gives a framework to describe the motion of entangled chains, and leads to a universal description of the linear viscoelasticity (description developed by S. Edwards and M. Doi [5, 6]) of long flexible polymer systems. One interesting feature of this model is that it provides laws for the variation of the key physical quantities of the linear viscoelasticity as for example the zero shear viscosity, 1"10,or the terminal relaxation time, Tt, with the molecular parameters of the system such as the polymerisation index of the chains, N, (related to the molecular weight through M = Nm, with m the monomer molecular weight) and the polymer volume fraction if one is dealing with a solution. These laws are in very good qualitative agreement with the large number of available experimental data on the dynamic behaviour of linear flexible entangled polymers, but quantitative departures still remain between the experiments and the predictions, as for example the fact that the exponent of the power law which characterises the variation of the zero shear viscosity with the molecular weight is observed to be 3.3 or 3.4 [3, 6] rather than the predicted value 3. These deviations have lead to a long controversy on the validity of the reptation model, and have stimulated a series of experimental and theoretical investigations to try to understand the limitations of this model and to propose the necessary modifications to obtain a better description of the dynamic properties of liquid polymers [7 to 22].
In the present paper, after a rapid presentation of the reptation model in its simplest version, in order to pinpoint the underlying hypothesis, we discuss the interest of complementary self diffusion and viscoelastic measurements, and present the currently available methods for measuring diffusion in entangled polymer systems. Then, results obtained on polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS), a model liquid polymer well above its glass temperaturd at room temperature will be described, and the consequences on the limits of the entangled regime as seen from diffusion measurements, compared to what is observed in rheometry, will be discussed. 2. THE REPTATION MODEL: 2.1. One linear chain among fixed obstacles: The Brownian diffusion of one long polymer chain trapped among fixed obstacles has been described quantitatively by P.G. de Gennes in 1971 [4]. As schematically presented in Fig. l a, the chain cannot cross the obstacles. At any time, its shape depends on the actual monomers-obstacles interactions: the chain is confined by the obstacles. The only way for the chain to change its configuration is to find a path among the obstacles through small fluctuations of its contour, folding or unfolding locally. The leading motion takes place at the 9 9
9
9 "
9
9 "
9
9
9 9
9
9 0 ~"
~
"
9 9
"
9
9
9 " ~ ' ~ ' L ' - I'-
9 "
9
9
9
9
.
.
.
.
a_
.
.
-
.
_b
t\
Figure 1" Schematic representation of one chain among obstacles, a) The chain is constrained by the obstacles, b) By local fluctuations, the chain changes its conformation. The probability of forming a loop (dashed line) is very small (strong entropy loss), and the role of the extemities is dominant, c) The chain reptates like a snake in the virtual tube (thin line) envelope of all the topological constraints exerted on it by the obstacles. The tube is progressively redefined from the extremities, as schematically presented by the two situations at time t and t', with t'>t.
extremities of the chain, as a consequence of the low probability for the chain of forming a long loop at any other central part (figure tb), the formation of a large loop implying a large entropy loss (the two sides of the loop have to follow the same path among the obstacles). time. As a result, the extremities can engage between new obstacles and progressively pull the chain in a new environment (figure l c). This is the reptation process. As a consequence, the central part of the chain remains trapped by the same topological constraints over a long period of A way of taking these constraints into account in an averaged manner was proposed by S. Edwards [23]: one can assume that the chain is trapped in a virtual tube, or envelope made of all the obstacles which directly surround it (thin line on figure l c). The chain can move freely along the curvilinear axis of the tube, without encountering obstacles, while it cannot escape out of the tube laterally. At any time, by fluctuations of its local kinks, the chain leaves some parts of the tube, and creates new parts. The detailed statistical description of the process [4] leads to definite predictions for the molecular weight dependence of the diffusion coefficient, that can be reconstructed using simple arguments that we present now. The chain is assumed to be an ideal Gaussian chain made of N monomers of size a (that is indeed the case in a polymer melt [24]) and its average end to end vector has a length R0 = Nl/2a. For a free ideal chain, the dynamics has been modelled by Rouse [25], assuming that the chain is similar to a collection of springs, connected by beads with the size of a monomer, where all the friction is concentrated. This leads to a longest relaxation time of the chain proportional to N 2, and to a translational diffusion coefficient of the centre of mass inversely proportional to N. In the presence of the obstacles, the local fluctuations of the chain contour which involve distances smaller than the diameter of the tube, d, are not affected by the tube. The chain can thus be considered as a necklace of beads of size d, the average distance between the obstacles. The corresponding average number of monomers inside one bead is Nd, with d = Ndl/2a. The portion of chain inside a bead obeys Rouse-like dynamics, because the monomers inside the bead are not affected by the tube. The longest relaxation time of one bead is "eR(d) = ZlNd 2 ,
(1)
and the corresponding diffusion coefficient is D d -- ~,D1 Nd
(2)
where ~1 and D1 are the monomer characteristic time and diffusion coefficient respectively. "el, D! and "eR, DR are related by general diffusion laws" "elDl -- a 2, "eR(d)Dd = d 2.
(3)
The mobility of the whole chain, free to move along the curvilinear axis of the tube is N/Nd smaller than the mobility of one bead, as the friction on the full necklace is the friction on one bead times the number of beads. The diffusion coefficient of the chain along the tube is D t ~ ~DI N
(4)
The reptation time, TR, or the time it takes for the chain to renew its configuration is related to Dt through a relation analogous to eq.3: DtTR = Lt 2, with Lt = d(N/Nd) the total length of the tube. Thus
TR
"t:d(d)
(%)3
d
= %1
NfifN
d
9
(5)
TR is the longest relaxation time of the chain constrained by the obstacles. It is much longer than the longest Rouse time of the free chain, z R (N) --- xlN 2. It should be noticed that the measurable self diffusion coefficient Ds of the chain is not Dr: the tube is contorted, with a Gaussian configuration, and when the chain travels a distance Lt along the tube it only travels a distance R0 in a given direction of the real space, so that DsT R -- Ro 2 = Na 2, and Ds
N d -- D 1
N 2" (6)
The diffusion is much slower (by a factor N) than for a Rouse-type free chain. 2.2. Polymer melts: It is tempting to apply the ideas developed in section 2.1. to describe the dynamics of long linear polymer molecules in the melt state. The average radius of the chain is R0 -- N 1/2a [24]. The volume spanned by one chain, R03, is much larger, for long chains, than the volume effectively filled by the monomers of that chain, l) -- Na 3. In the melt state where the monomers are closely packed, the chains are thus interpenetrated. Since they cannot cross each other, they are strongly constrained, in a way somewhat similar to the situation of one chain among the fixed obstacles of section 2.1. One can again define a tube, envelope of all the topological constraints exerted on one chain by its surrounding neighbours. But one is now faced with two major problems. 1) All the chains in the system move, and the obstacles are not permanent. In order to apply reptation ideas to a polymer melt, it is necessary to assume or to establish that the evolution of the tube due to the motions of all the surrounding chains, is slower than the reptation. 2) The tube diameter is no longer an external parameter, it represents the average distance perpendicular to the local chain direction that one monomer can travel, due to the local chain flexibility, before being blocked by the surrounding chains. A complete determination would require a description of the actual monomer-monomer interactions and is still out of reach, despite strong efforts to do so [19, 26 to 28], and at present it is not fully understood what factors determine the tube diameter in polymer melts. It has been introduced as a phenomenological parameter, through an average number of monomers necessary to get an entanglement, Ne, with d -- Nel/2a. This is in fact the definition of an entanglement: it is not a knot between two chains, but an ensemble of constraints which the chains collectivelly exert on each other, so that the diffusive motions of the monomers are no longer isotropic, when the explored distance is large enough. Then, both the longest relaxation time TR and the self diffusion coefficient can be estimated through eq. 5 and 6 respectively, replacing Nd by Ne. One gets: TR ='1:1 N~N e'
(7)
D s = D ! Ne///2.
(8)
If chains with a polymerisation index smaller than Ne are used, they are no longer efficiently
constrained by their neighbours, and the reptation picture no longer holds. A Rouse-like dynamics should be recovered, with a self diffusion coefficient proportional to 1/N. When reptation is used to develop a description of the linear viscoelasticity of polymer melts [5, 6], the same underlying hypothesis ismade, and the same phenomenological parameter Ne appears. Basically, to describe the relaxation after a step strain, for example, each chain is assumed to first reorganise inside its deformed tube, with a Rouse-like dynamics, and then to slowly return to isotropy, relaxing the deformed tube by reptation (see the paper by Montfort et al in this book). Along these lines, the plateau relaxation modulus, the steady state compliance and the zero shear viscosity should be respectively: GN0=
J0=
kT Nea3 ' 6
5GN ~ ~2 no = ~ G N O T R 9
(9)
(10) (11)
Of course, all these relations are expected to be valid only if the reptation description holds, i.e. if the motion of the tube due to the dynamics of all the surrounding chains is much slower than the reptation of one chain. Eq. I 1 provides an easy way of checking the validity of the reptation model: the zero shear viscosity should depend on the polymerisation index of the chains like N 3. Experimentally, the observed exponent is larger, 3.3 to 3.5, except perhaps when extremely large molecular weights are used [29]. The reason for the discrepancy has been debated for many years and remains not totally elucidated. It is indeed a puzzling question: the dependences of the storage modulus versus frequency, for various molecular weights have been observed to agree well with the Doi-Edwards predictions [30], and the molecular weight dependence of the self diffusion coefficient has often been observed to agree well with the reptation prediction [2, 31 to 35]. Moreover,. more local tests of the reptation dynamics, as for example determinations of the monomer concentration profiles in a macroscopic diffusion experiment starting with a step-like labelled chains profile, through neutrons techniques, appear to agree very well with the reptation picture [34, 36, 37]. The question of the detailed limits of validity of the reptation model thus remains a pending question. What appears puzzling is the fact that, on one hand, the reptation model and the Doi - Edwards' description of the linear viscoelasticity work so well both qualitatively and quantitatively for some experiments, while, on the other hand, they seem unable to account for all the existing data. This may suggest that the reptation model does not contain the whole story of linear polymer dynamics, and that one needs to learn more on other possibly competing processes. The obviously weak points in the use of reptation ideas to describe the dynamics of linear polymer melts are the two hypotheses mentioned above. Their validity is not easy to check experimentally and it is also not easy to understand how to relate Ne to the molecular properties of the polymer. In fact, it is not simple to determine Ne in a reliable manner: prefactors not taken into account in the simple arguments leading to eq. 7 to 11 may exist and the question is not a trivial one. Severalroutes are possible: one relies on measurements of GN 0. A strong effort has been made recently by L.J. Fetters and coworkers [38] to relate the value of the critical molecular weight between entanglements, as deduced from the plateau modulus, to the molecular structure of the polymer. The correlations they obtain are remarkable and should allow one to predict how one can imagine to define a given chemistry in order to reach a given rheology. Such correlations rely on measurements performed on high molecular weight polymers, well above Ne, i.e. highly entangled. Another possible route
consists in following the well-admitted idea that a way of estimating Ne is to locate the crossover between entangled and non-entangled regimes by looking for the appearance of a plateau modulus when the molecular weight is progressively increased, or for a change of slope in a log-log plot of the zero shear viscosity versus the molecular weight. It is not clear however that this is the best way to do so: decreasing the molecular weight accelerates the dynamics of all the chains in the media, and it may well be that the crossover region could not be described, even qualitatively by reptation ideas. When decreasing the molecular weight one can eventually enter into a regime in which the chains are still entangled i.e. dynamically constrainted by each other, but in which the reptation hypothesis is no longer valid, due to the onset of collective motions of the chains. The reptation picture is a one chain picture, the topological constraints exerted on one chain by its neighbours being taken into account in an average way, through the tube notion. Collective effects are not neglected in this framework, and if they become the dominant dynamical process, the reptation model no longer holds. To try to characterise experimentally the importance of the collective effects on the dynamics of one chain, diffusion measurements reveal to be a unique tool. Mixtures of long and short chains can be used, along with labelling techniques which permits one to follow the diffusion of either the short or the long chains. Thus, diffusion measurements allow one to decouple the question of the dynamics of the surrounding chains and the question of the cross over between entangled and non-entangled behaviour. When few short chains (index of polymerisation N) are immersed into much larger chains (index of polymerisation P), one can expect that for large enough P, the motions of the surrounding chains will be frozen down on the time scale of the motion of the test chains. These labelling techniques should enable one to characterise the crossover region between entangled and disentangled behaviour, by measuring the diffusion coefficient as a function of N, in situations where the motions of the environment remain slow (P>>N). Then, the importance on the dynamics of the collective motions can be characterised, varying the ratio P/N, and comparing, at fixed N, the data for N = P and N << P. Similar experimental tests are not easy to obtain from rheometrical measurements, even if such experiments have indeed been conducted [15, 18], because rheometry is sensitive to all the chains present in the sample, and one loses the selectivity associated with the labelling. The use of diffusion measurements to help understand the dynamical behaviour of linear polymers has been recognised for many years [ 10,11,12,31 to 35,39]. Systematic experiments have already been performed, varying the relative molecular weights of the labelled and unlabelled chains, but, when approaching the non-entangled regime, one has to be carreful to avoid spurious effects associated with a possible additional molecular weight dependence in the dynamics, associated with a variation of the free volume, and of the local friction coefficient (hidden in the prefactor Dl of equation 8) with the molecular weight. We present here the results of such a systematic investigation on the dependence of the self-diffusion coefficient of flexible polymer chains as a function of P and N, conducted on polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS). This model polymer is well above its glass temperature at room temperature (To_ = -120~ so that one can expect that spurious effects associated with the variation of the flee volume and of the local monomer-monomer friction coefficient with the molecular weights of the chains are minimised. 3. D I F F U S I O N M E A S U R E M E N T S IN P O L Y M E R SYSTEMS:
3.1. Materials and techniques: The technique we have choosen to measure the diffusion coefficient of polymer chains is based on fluorescence recovery after photobleaching, using interference fringes. The principles of the technique and the details of the experimental set up have already been described [40]. This technique requires that the chains under investigation are labelled with a photobleachable fluorescent probe. A strong advantage of the fluorescence recovery after photobleaching technique, compared to other optical techniques of self-diffusion
measurements, such as, for example, the Forced Rayleigh light scattering technique [ 10, 32], is the irreversibility of the bleaching reaction. This is particularly important in polymer melts with high molecular weights, where extremly slow diffusion is expected. We have used narrow molecular weight fractions of c~-co OH terminated PDMS (obtained by conventional fractionated precipitation techniques from Rh6ne-Poulenc or Petrarch commercial products or by anionic polymerisation when one wanted to get chains with only one terminal OH). The labelling is obtained by first modifying the OH extremities of the chains by reaction with an aminosilane, CH3-O-Si-(CH2)n-NH2, with n = 3 or 4, in excess in toluene at 100~ for 24 hours. After several cycles of precipitation dissolution, the polymer is left to react with an excess of chloro-7-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3 diazole (C1-NBD), in toluene, at room temperature during 16 hours, in the dark. After separation of the polymer from the unreacted NBD, one obtains PDMS chains end labelled with NBD, with a yield which can reach 90% . Then, if one starts with an cz-co OH terminated PDMS, most of the labelled chains bear two fluorescent probes, one at each extremity. Care has to be taken to conduct all the steps of the labelling in anhydrous conditions to avoid backbiting by the unsubstituted amine. The labelled polymer has a maximun absorption wavelength of 468 nm, and a maximum emission wavelength arround 510 nm. The analysed samples are all made of mixtures of labelled and unlabelled polymer, the characteristics of the couples used are reported in table 1. The labelled chain concentration has always been kept smaller than the first overlap concentration for the correponding molecular weight, so that these chains are independent of each other. In fact, typical label concentrations were always smaller than l ppm. We have checked that under such conditions the measured diffusion coefficient was independent of the concentration of labelled chains, whatever the molecular weights of the labelled and unlabelled chains. We have also checked that the label was not affecting the measured values of the diffusion coefficient, comparing our results for N = P with self-diffusion measurements performed on the same samples by pulsed field gradient NMR [41 ]. This Table I (Couples of labelled and unlabelled chains used in this study). average molecular weight of labeled PDMS chains (g/mole) 3700 3700 6600 6600 14000 14000 22500 99500 41500 41500 68O0O 68000 106000 106000 320700 320700
N
polydispersity index
average molecular weight of unlabeled PDMS chains (g/mole)
50 50 89 89 189 189 304 304 561 561 919 919 1432 1432 4334 4334
1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.13 1.13 1.07 1.07 1.11 1.11 1.03 1.03 1.18 1.18
962000 3700 962000 6400 962000 14000 787000 24400 962000 41500 962000 68000 962000 106000 787000 320700
polydispersity index
13000 50 13000 86 13000 189 10635 330 13000 561 13000 919 13000 1432 10635 4334
1.27
1.1 1.27
1.1 1.27
1.1 1.22 1.09
1.27 1.07 1.27
1.11 1.27 1.03 1.22
1.18
technique does not require labeling, since it is provided by the local Larmor frequency of the spins during the field impulsion. As a consequence, pulse field gradient NMR cannot give selective informations on the N chains immersed in P chains: all the spins rotate under the effect of the magnetic field, with a frequency which only depends on the actual field value they feel, whatever the chain to which they pertain. In order to measure the diffusion coefficient of the chains, one first shines on the sample a brief and intense pulse of light (typical duration % = 100 ms and typical power 150 mW), with a fringe pattern. The fringes are obtained by recombining, in the sample, two beams coming from the same laser. Under the action of this intense pulse of light, a fraction of the fluorescent probes located in the bright fringes are photobleached. Using the same fringe pattern, but strongly attenuated in order to avoid further photobleaching, the fluorescence of the sample is excited and monitored. The position of the interference fringes in the sample can be modulated at a frequency F, by modulating the position of one of the mirrors used to recombine the two beams with respect to the other. If the modulation of the position of the fringes is symmetrical with respect to the bleaching fringes position and has an amplitude equal to one half of the fringe spacing, the fluorescence intensity is modulated, at the frequency 2F. The amplitude of this 2F component is proportional to the amplitude of the spatial modulation of the concentration in fluorescent probes resulting from the photobleaching. When this concentration modulation relaxes to zero due to the diffusion of the fluorescent chains, the 2F component of the fluorescence intensity relaxes to zero exponentially [40]. In Fig. 2a, such a typical relaxation is reported, along with its best fit to a single exponential decay. In Fig. 2b, the corresponding inverse of the relaxation times are reported as a function of Q2, with Q = 27z/i, with i the interfringe spacing. The linear dependence is characteristic of a diffusion process, and allows the extraction of the diffusion coefficient D (slope of the straight line). The typical relative uncertainty in the diffusion coefficients is 3%, for one set of experiments, and of 10% when one takes into account the reproducibility from sample to sample.
~2oo ~
1
a_
0.4
0 ::3
i
' i
i
800 400
o
Ib
i
~ 0.2
0
Vl,w-
0
20 t(s)
,
40
60
oV,
,
0
4 10 6
,, 8 10 6
1.2 10 7'
Q2 (cm-2)
Figure 2: a) typical experimental decay of the 2F component of the signal (full line) and the corresponding fitted exponential curve (dashed line), b) plot of the inverse of the relaxation time of the exponential decay versus the square of the wave vector, the linear fit indicates that the process is diffusive and the slope of the line is equal to the diffusion coefficient.
When the labelled and the unlabelled chains have the same length, as the influence of the label on the dynamics appears to be negligible, (identity of the diffusion coefficients measured by the photobleaching technique and by pulse field gradient NMR), the experiment gives access to the self-diffusion coefficient of the chains. When different molecular weights are used for the labelled and unlabelled species, what is measured is a mutual diffusion coefficient. As we shall compare the values of the diffusion coefficients obtained in these two situations, in all the following we shall omit to specify the subscript self or mutual, and speak in terms of diffusion coefficient, D, making clear in each particular situation which sample is under consideration. 3.2.
Results
-
'
'
. . . . . .
I
'
. . . . .
'
'1
o
10-11
-
o
N
,
'
'
'
'
'"-
N=P 9 N<
121 cO n
~x
[]
o
ref51
o
i
DO
"
-
13
v
'
o o
Ne
E
-
n 1 0 -~3 .-
N -2
'~
o o
o
1 0 -is 10 ~
,
,
,
,
,
,,,I
,
,
,
10 z
,
,
,,,I
10 3
,
n
n
i
n
n I
10 4
N
Figure 3: Diffusion coefficient versus the polymerisation index of the labelled chains, N, in the case N<
10
In Fig. 3, all the diffusion coefficients obtained at a temperature of 23~ are reported as a function of the polymerisation index of the labelled chains N, in log scales, for two situations: a) the labelled chains have the same polymerisation index as the surrounding chains (N = P, open squares) and b) P >> N (P = 1.2 104 , filled circles). Several remarkable points appear on this figure" 1) For N > 1000, all the data are well represented by a power law D = N -2 p0, compatible with the picture of labelled chains moving by a reptation process, in a frozen environment. This is quite similar to what has already been established for polystyrene [ 11, 39], and we have not developed strong efforts to get a larger number of high molecular weights labelled samples to fully re-establish this point on PDMS, preferring to concentrate on the far less well-known range of the low molecular weights. 2) For 100 < P < 1000, the measured diffusion coefficients for N = P no longer follow the N -2 reptation prediction. In the same range of N values, D remains proportional to N -2 if P >> N, i.e. if the motion of the chains surrounding the test chain are frozen down during the diffusion time of the test chain. The comparison of the data obtained with N = P and with N << P clearly puts into evidence the acceleration of the dynamics associated with the matrix chains, similarly to what has yet been observed with other polymers [ 11, 12, 42 to 44] or in solutions [ 10]. This acceleration, by a factor close to three, can be attributed to the constraint release mechanism [7, 8, 13], the effects of fluctuations of the test chain inside its tube [9] being a priori the same in the two situations P = N and P >> N. 3) It is interesting to notice that, when P >> N, the data follow the law D = N -2 even for quite small values of N for which it is usually admitted that the chains are no longer entangled. For PDMS, the critical molecular weight between entanglements deduced from the cross over of the zero shear viscosity is in the range 20 000 to 30 000 [45, 46], and that deduced from the plateau modulus is 13 000 [46], i.e. to a Ne value of 175, larger than the smallest value for which we observe that the N -2 law starts to be obeyed. If we take as a criteria for entangled behaviour a diffusive motion in a frozen environment obeying the N -2 dependence (reptation behaviour), we can estimate that the average number of monomers between entanglements is Ne = 100. But 10 entanglements per chain are needed for the appearance of the reptation behaviour when P = N, i.e. when collective effects are present. For comparison, we have also reported in Fig. 3 the data obtained by Appel and Fleischer [51] with PDMS at 60~ using the pulsed field gradient NMR technique to measure the self-diffusion coefficient. Except for the slightly higher values due to the increased temperature, it is remarkable that exactly the same trends are observed for the two sets of data corresponding to N = P. 4) For N < 100, a departure from the N -2 law is observed even in the case P >> N, and indicates a cross over towards another dynamical regime. The two data points we have in this low molecular weight domain seem compatible with the expected N -I Rouse-like behaviour. However, we have not been able to fully establish this molecular weight dependence, due to the difficulty of synthesising controlled samples in this very small molecular weight range (for low molecular weights, the sensitivity of the fractionation by precipitation drops down, and these samples have to be anionically synthesised, but even doing so, for very small molecular weights, the initiation time of the reaction becomes dominant and does not allow one to get reasonably monodisperse samples). 5) An important question is to decide how far one can believe that a self-diffusion coefficient varying like N -2 is characteristic of reptation. It has been argued that additional molecular weight dependences could exist and compensate for departures from the N -2 law [48 to 52]. Such an effect can come from the local monomer-monomer friction coefficient which appears as a prefactor in equation 8, hidden in the diffusion coefficient DI. Several processes can combine and lead to a local friction which is molecular weight dependent, and which decreases when the polymer molecular weight is decreased. This is, for example, the
case of the glass transition temperature which is expected to depend strongly on molecular weight for Mw smaller than 10 000, a fact which should affect the local free volume and the local friction and thus give an acceleration of all the dynamics at small molecular weights [48,49]. In order to estimate the importance of such local friction effects in the range of molecular weights investigated, we have conducted diffusion measurements of a small probe, CH3-CH2-CH2-NBD, (twenty times smaller than the smaller molecular weights investigated) mixed in PDMS melts, as a function of the PDMS molecular weight. The results are reported in Fig. 4: there is no drastic variation of the local friction when the molecular weight of the PDMS melt is decreased down to 4200 g/mole, which means that our data can be compared with simple reptation predictions, and that the points made in 3) are indeed meaningful. I
I
I
I lill
i
I
I
I
I IIII
I
I
I IIIIJ
I
I
I
I
I III
I
t
i
t tttt
4 1 0 .6
Od
E 0
v210 a
{ {{
-6
0 10 ~
t
i
t
! iiltl
I
10 2
10 3
10 4
N Figure 4: Self diffusion coefficient of the small probe, CH3-CH2-CH2-NBD, versus the PDMS polymerization index (now only unlabelled PDMS is used). Given the low accuracy of the experiment at such high values of the diffusion coefficient (relative uncertainty larger than 10%, contrary to the data on figure 3, which are all slower by more than one decade and thus far easier to measure accurately), it seems that there is no significant change of the friction factor in the range of molecular weights investigated. 4. I N T E R P R E T A T I O N AND C O M P A R I S O N W I T H R H E O M E T R I C A L DATA: Both the questions of the transition from Rouse to reptation dynamics and of what fixes the average distance between entanglements in polymer liquids has been the subject of a number of recent theoretical and experimental investigations. From the theoretical point of view, the first refinement of the reptation approach has been to introduce the collective dynamics of the chains in terms of the constraint release process[7, 8, 13]. Due to the motions of the surrounding chains, some constraints which constitute the tube may disappear during one reptation time, and thus give more freedom to the test chain. Quantitative attempts have been made to take into account these additional
12
degrees of freedom, in regimes where the constraint release process is only a weak correction to reptation, i.e. when the motions of all the chains in the system can be described by reptation. Then, two independent dynamical processes have to be considered: reptation inside the tube, and modification of the tube due to constraints release. To release one constraint, an extremity of one surrounding chain has to leave the vicinity, within one tube diameter, of the test chain. The probability of such an event is 1/TR(P), (the surrounding chains move by reptation) and the tube can be considered as a Rouse chain made of N/Ne subunits, characterised by a subunit jump frequency 1/TR(P). The corresponding constraint release time is
Tc~
IN) 2"
(12)
= TR ~ee
The characteristic time of motion is Teff, with, for N = P:
T2ff= lZR , Tren = ~ R
1+
(13)
(the inverse of the times add for independent processes). Constraint release clearly appears to be a weak correction as soon as N is much larger than Ne, and the molecular weight dependences contained in eq. 12 and 13 lead to a weak acceleration of the diffusion for N larger than Ne, while pure reptation is recovered for N >> Ne, in good agreement with experiments. However, for N close to Ne the above description certainly no longer holds: all the chains in the system move by both reptation and constraint release, and their motions are accelerated compared to pure reptation, due to the additionnal degrees of freedom of tube renewal. The constraint release process can no longer be treated as a small perturbation to reptation. Attempts have been made to describe the motion in a self consistent way [ 10], but are not really satisfactory: they lead to an unphysical divergence of the characteristic time of the motions of the chains and are unable to correctly describe the crossover towards the nonentangled dynamical regime, because they do not introduce the Rouse dynamics as another competting process. This question has been addressed recently by D. Pearson et al [49], with an extensive investigation of both the self-diffusion and the zero shear viscosity as a function of molecular weight in polyethylene samples of low polydispersity. The technique used to measure the self-diffusion coefficient, pulse field gradient NMR does not allow for measurements at fixed matrix, and the data of reference 49 have to be compared with our data for P = N. Trends very similar to what we have observed in PDMS are clearly seen in polyethylene, i.e. a regime at large molecular weights well described by simple reptation arguments (Ds --- N -2) and an acceleration of the diffusion at lower molecular weights, associated with additional degrees of freedom such as tube renewal or possibly fluctuations of the test chains inside their tube. The important point made by Pearson et al is that the crossover between the Rouse-like regime and the entangled one is most clearly evidenced if one reports the product riDs, which is independent of the local friction, as a function of the molecular weight: in the Rouse dynamical regime this product is expected to be independent of molecular weight, while it should increase linearly with Mw, in the pure reptation regime. In order to perform the same kind of analysis of our data, we have measured the zero shear viscosity of our PDMS sample. These measurements have been kindly performed for us by R. Muller from I.C.S. Strasbourg, and are reported, along with low molecular weights data from reference 45 in Fig. 5. In Fig. 6, we have reported the product riD, for PDMS, as a function of the polymer molecular weight. One has to notice that for the viscosity measurements one is always in a
13
situation with N = P, and thus the filled symbols cannot be interpreted as corresponding to chains moving in a frozen environment. In a way very similar to what has been obtained in polyethylene, we observe a low molecular weight regime which could be Rouse-like, and a transition towards an entangled regime for both sets of data. 10 4
....
I
I
I
I III1~
I
I
I
I IIII
I
i
I
I
I IIII-
1 0 3 _-..-
Q
10 2 ...-
r~O
10
1
_--=
13_
v
1 0 0 _-.-
1 0 -1
.._
10-2
L
10 ~
.,
I
f
I
I I IIIII
I
I
I
I I lllli
10 3
10 2
I
I
I
I IIII
10 4
N
Figure 5: Zero shear viscosity as a function of the polymerisation index of the chains for PDMS at T = 27~ The data up to N = 400 are from reference 45, while the larger molecular weights have been measured at I.C.S. Strasbourg by R. Muller and give an exponent 3.37 for the viscosity - molecular weight law. One can try to locate a critical polymerisation index above which the data are no longer compatible with a Rouse-like dynamics, Ne' = 500, lager than the Ne = 100 value determined from the diffusion measurements in a frozen matrix. This is an illustration of the fact that the two processes, Rouse motion and entangled motion are in competition: the slowest process is the one which is indeed observed.When the matrix chains are mobile, the entangled dynamics becomes more rapid than pure reptation, and the Rouse motion can dominate the dynamics for larger molecular weights than when the matrix chains are immobile. In fact, in the crossover region, the chains are still entangled (this appears on the diffusion data with N << P), but they do not obey the simple reptation nor the simple-Rouse-like dynamics. This fact may be of practical importance in situations where the entanglements
14
directly affect a local physical property, such as the strenghthening of polymer interfaces or the determination of the friction between a polymer melt and a solid wall as discussed in the chapter on flow with slippage. It is clear however that as long as one experimentally determines the critical molecular weight between entanglements by the location of a crossover in the dependence of a physical property versus the molecular weight, there is no reason
100 -
"
9 1]D/TIDRou~e
(N<
F
"
[] rlD/rlDRouse (N=P) 10 []
11) r/)
E!
0 rr
E!
n
/ N
0.'1
,
101
~
~
,
~,lll
t
10 z
i..
N
I
,
y e
,,~1
~
103
,
,
,
~.,,
104
Figure 6" Product of riD versus the index of polymerisation of the PDMS, for N<
15
viscosity [50], and second that it can be used with different hypothesis on the number of entanglements per chain, or on the relative dynamics of the two chains. It has been applied to the problem of the cooperative motion of polymer melts [27] and to the complicated question of the dynamics of polymer melts of chains with structures more complicated than linear [52]. This is certainly a fruitful way of analysing the complicated dynamics of entangled polymer systems and has to be developed. 5. CONCLUSIONS After a review of some remaining open questions raised by the reptation model, we have shown systematic self diffusion measurements, obtained by an optical technique which allows one to benefit from the selectivity associated with the labelling of a few chains among the others. This should help to clarify the question of the transition between entangled and nonentangled dynamical regimes, by getting rid of the collective motions of the chains. We have shown that the dynamics of linear chains could be described by simple reptation arguments, assumingthat each chain essentially sees a frozen environment during its reptation time, as soon as the number of entanglements per chain is larger than 10. Below this value, the dynamics is strongly accelerated mainly through the constraint release mechanism: a simple reptation behaviour is recovered when the matrix is frozen down, indicating that the fluctuations of the chains inside their tube are not dominant in this acceleration of the motion. This simple reptation behaviour is observed (with the frozen matrix) down to molecular weights which are usually considered to be below the critical molecular weight between entanglements, i.e. down to 7000 g/mole for PDMS (Ne = 100). We think that this is an indication that, in what is usually considered as a dynamical crossover region, the chains are entangled but do not behave as if they were due to competition between different dynamical processes. In the molecular weight range where the number of entanglements per chain is smaller than 10, the dynamics as characterised through the dependence of the product riDs versus the number of entanglements per chain N/Ne appears to be quite universal: the same behaviour is observed in PDMS, in polyethylene, and also in polystyrene / benzene solutions [10]. Such a dynamical behaviour has certainly to be incorporated when one wants to model the properties of polydisperse melts of linear chains. It is also important in branched systems in which the reptation is expected to become very slow and thus susceptible to become more easily hidden by constraint release. In any case, a better characterisation of the crossover between entangled and non-entangled behaviour, on many different polymers, should help to understand what, on the molecular level, governs the value of the critical molecular weight between entanglements.
REFERENCES: I. J. D. Ferry, Viscoelasticity of Polymers, Third Edition, John Wiley and Sons eds., New York (1980). 2. P. G. de Gennes, and L. L6ger, Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem., 33 (1982) 49 3. W. W. Graessley, Adv. Polym. Sci., 16 (1974) 1. 4. P.G. de Gennes, J. Chem. Phys., 55 (1971) 572. 5. M.Doi, and S. F. Edwards, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. II, 74 (1978) 1789. 6. M. Doi and S. F. Edwards. Theory of Polymer dynamics, Oxford University Press, (1986). 7. M. Daoud and P. G. de Gennes, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 17 (1979) 1971. 8. J., Klein, Macromolecules, 11 (1978) 852. 9. M. Doi, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 21 (1983) 667. 10. M.F. Marmonier and L. L6ger, Phys. Rev. Lett., 55 (1985) 1078.
16 1 1. P.F. Green and E.J. Kramer, Phys. Rev. Lett., 55 (1985) 2145" Macromolecules, 19 (1986) 11O8. 12. B. Smith, Phys. Rev. Lett., 52,(1984) 45. 13. W. W. Graessley, Adv. Polym. Sci., 47 (1982) 67. 14. M.J. Struglinski and W.W. Graessley, Macromolecules, 18,(1985) 2630. 15. M. Rubinstein, E. Helfand, D.S. Pearson, Macromolecules, 20 (1987) 822. 16. M. Doi, W.W. Graessley, E.Helfand and D.Pearson, Macromolecules, 20 (1987) 1900. 17. H. Watanabe, T. Sakamoto and T. Kotaka, Macromolecules, 18 (1985) 1436. 18. J.P. Montfort, G. Marin and P. Monge, Macromolecules, 19 (1986) 393 and 1979. 19. W. Hess, Macromolecules, 19 (1986) 1395. 20. T.A., Kawasalis and J. Noolandi, Phys. Rev. Lett., 59 (1987) 2674. 21. J.L. Viovy, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 23 (1985) 2423. 22. J.D. des Cloizeaux, Macromolecules, 23 (1990) 4678. 23. S.F. Edwards, Proc. phys. Scoc. Lond., 92 (1987) 9. 24. P.J. Flory, J. Phys. Chem., 17 (1949) 303" and in Statistic of Chain Molecules, New York: Interscience. 25. P.E. Rouse, J. Chem. Phys., 75 (1953) 1996. 26. W. Hess, Macromolecules, 20 (1987) 2587, and Macromolecules, 21 (1988) 2620. 27. R.B. Bird, C.F. Curtiss, R.C., Amstrong and O. Hassager, Kinetics Theory, 2 nd Ed.; Dynamics of Polymeric Liquids, Vol. 2, Wiley Interscience: New York, (1987). 28. M.F. Herman and Ping Tong, Macromolecules, 26 (1993) 3733. 29. R.H. Colby, L.J. Fetters and W.W. Graessley, Macromolecules, 20 (1987) 2226. 30. D. Pearson, Rubber Chemistry and technology, 60 (1987) 439 31. J. Klein and B.J. Briscoe, Proc. R. Soc., Lond. A, 365 (1979) 53. 32. L. L6ger, H. Hervet and F. Rondelez, Macromolecules, 14 (1981) 1732. 33. C.R. Bartel, B. Crist, L.J. Fetters and W.W. Graessley, Macromolecules, 19 (1986) 785. 34. C.R. Bartel, B. Crist and W.W. Graessley, Macromolecules, 17 (1984) 2702. 35. M. Tirrell, Rubber, Chemistry and Technology, 57 (1984)523. 36. G. Reiter and U. Steiner, J. Phys. II, 1 (1991) 659. 37. R.J. Composto, E.J. Kramer and D.M. White, Polymer, 31 (1990) 2320. 38. L.J. Fetters, D.J. Lohse, D. Richter, T.A. Witten, A. Zirkel, Macromolecules, 27, (1994) 4639. 39. P. F. Green, P. J. Mills, C. J. Palmstrom, J. W. Mayer, E. J. Kramer, Phys. Rev. Lett., 53, (1984) 2145. 40. J. Davoust, P. Devaux and L. lager, The EMBO Journal, 1 (1982) 1233. 41. B. Deloche, private communication. 42. J. Klein, Macromolecules, 14 (1981) 460. 43. S.F. Tead and E.J. Kramer, Macromolecules, 21 (1988) 1513. 44. M. Antonietti, J. Coutandin and H. Sillescu, Macromolecules, 19 (1986) 793. 45. R.R. Rahalker, J. Lamb, G. Harrion, A.J. Barlow, W. Hawthorn, J.A. Semlyens, A.M. North and R.A. Pethrick, Proc. R. Soc. Lond., A394, (1984) 207. 46. C.L. Lee, K.E. Polmanteer and E.G. King, J. Polym. Sci. A2, 8 (1970) 1909. 47. G.C. Berry and T. Fox, Adv. Polym. Sci., 5 (1968) 261. 48. D.S. Pearson, G. ver Strate, E. von Meerwall and F. Schilling, Macromolecules, 20 (1987) 1133. 49. D.S. Pearson, L.J. Fetters, W.W. Graessley G. ver Strate and E. yon Meerwall, Macromolecules, 27 (1994) 711. 50. P.G. de Gennes. MRS Bulletin, (1991) 20 51. M. Appel and G. Fleischer. Macromolecules, 26 (1993) 5520 52. F. Brochard-Wyart, A. Ajdari. L. Leibler, M. Rubinstein and J.L. Viovy, Macromolecules. 27 (1994) 803
Rheology for PolymerMelt Processing J-M. Piau and J-F. Agassant(editors) 9 1996Elsevier ScienceB.V. All rights reserved.
17
Polybutadiene :NMR and Temporary elasticity J.P. Cohen Addad Laboratoire de Spectromdtrie Physique associd au CNRS, Universitd Joseph Fourier Grenoble I, B.P. 87, 38402 St Martin d'H~res Cedex, France
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N The purpose of this study was to give an insight into molecular properties which underlie the linear viscoelastic behaviour of molten polymers. Properties were probed from proton magnetic dipoles attached to polymeric chains or to small molecules in concentrated polymeric solutions.
1.1. H i e r a r c h y of r a n d o m m o t i o n s It is well-known t h a t the specific character of properties of polymeric systems, observed above the glass transition temperature, lies in the existence of a broad relaxation spectr~lm associated with a wide variety of internal random motions which occur along any linear macromolecule. The broadness of the relaxation spectrum originates from the linkage of monomeric units which induces a collective dynamic behaviour of skeletal bonds. As a consequence of the linear structure of macromolecules, monomeric units are involved in a hierarchy of random motions ; this hierarchy corresponds to a single chain property which can be detected from viscoelastic properties when measurements are performed on dilute solutions of polymer chains : a quantitative description has been given to the collective dynamic behavior of monomeric units which belong to one chain [1]. It shows that the time interval required to observe the full rotation of one Gaussian chain, in a dilute solution, is proportional to N 1-5 , where N is the total number of skeletal bonds; this time interval is proportional to N 2, in a melt, for short chains (N< 102), where hydrodynamic interactions can be neglected [2]. 1.2. A s y m m e t r y a n d t i m e s c a l e of r o t a t i o n s It will be shown t h a t chain dynamic properties are conveniently investigated within the frequency range going from about 1 to 1010 Hz, by using several NMR methods suitably adapted for different frequency domains. It is worth emphasizing that no phenomenological par_ameters will be introduced to analyse observed NMR properties. The magnetic relaxation of protons, attached to polymer molecules, is mainly sensitive to the result of the space average of tensorial magnetic interactions established between nuclear spins ; this average is induced by internal fluctuations which occur within one chain. These fluctuations arise from two kinds of basic random motions. The first kind corresponds to rotations of monomeric units about neighbouring units along one
18 chain ; the second kind is associated with transitions of rotational isomers through the finite number of states of discrete conformations of any monomeric unit. Tensorial magnetic interactions are sensitive to these internal local rotations. More precisely, the nuclear magnetic relaxation is governed by the degree of isotropy of random rotations of skeletal bonds with respect to the reference axis defined by the direction of the strong steady magnetic field which is applied to the spin-system to partly order nuclear dipoles ; it is also governed by the rate of random change of orientations of skeletal bonds. These are the two key points which must be taken into consideration to analyse NMR observations. The main feature about the hierarchy of random motions within one chain concerns the degree of anisotropy of rotations of monomeric units which is associated with the time scale of observation ; the shorter the time interval of measurement, the higher the degree of anisotropy of detected rotational motions of skeletal bonds. Consequently, from the NMR point of view, the hierarchy of random motions which occur along one chain, implies that the result of the space average of tensorial magnetic interactions depends on the time scale of observation. Fast and non-isotropic rotations are detected on a short time scale (_- 10-9 s) while a long time interval is required to observe isotropic rotations of skeletal bonds which involve the diffusion of one chain as a whole. Considering protons a t t a c h e d to one chain, for example, it may be stated, from the f u n d a m e n t a l analysis which is given to NMR properties, t h a t magnetic interactions are averaged to zero, provided the time interval required to observe the full rotation of one chain is shorter than 10-5s. [3]. A typical value of this time interval is 10 -6 s at 217~ for undiluted polystyrene (N = 102) [4] . For longer chains (N > 103), in dilute solution in a viscous solvent, the time interval required to observe the full rotation of one chain is much longer than 10:5 s. and then, only a partial space average is detected from NMR. 1.3. C h a i n c o u p l i n g j u n c t i o n s In the case of long macromolecules in a melt, it is well-known t h a t a collective behaviour of chains results from topological interactions between segments; this collective behaviour is taken into consideration by assuming the existence of characteristic uncrossable segments along each polymer. The n u m b e r of skeletal bonds which determines the mean length of these segments varies from two to three hundred; it depends on the chemical nature of the polymer. As a consequence of the existence of uncrossable chain segments, the hierarchy of random motions of monomeric units, along one chain, becomes more m a r k e d ; it gives rise to two dispersions in the relaxation spectrum of conformational fluctuations of one chain [5]. The presence of a well-defined separation between the two sets of correlation times implies that orientational correlations of skeletal bonds, within short segments, are disconnected from long r a n g e correlations of displacements of segments in one chain. It is like considering that macromolecules are coupled to one another by junctions that can be pictured as temporarily fixed points, also called entanglements; these vanish when coupling junctions dissociate according to a complex relaxation process which has been described as a reptational motion [6]. The time interval required for the vanishing of temporarily fixed points is usually much longer than 10 -5 s. The duration of the presence of these chain junctions is such that it allows the definition of a temporary network structure. Correspondingly, the relaxation of
19 the magnetisation of protons attached to polymer chains is expected to exhibit a dual behaviour. On the one hand, the magnetic relaxation process results from the fast random isomerisation of monomeric units; on the other hand, the irreversible dynamics of the magnetisation is sensitive to the topological hindrance created by the presence of entanglements. This dual behaviour parallels viscoelastic properties of polymeric systems : the degree of constraint is closely related to elasticity while the segmental mobility can be associated with viscosity. The separation between the two dispersions of relaxation times of one chain is also revealed from the plateau domain which characterises the time evolution of the relaxation modulus of any molten polymer; this plateau is associated with the modulus of temporary elasticity [4].
1.4. Transverse or l o n g i t u d i n a l m a g n e t i c r e l a x a t i o n s Any polymeric chain observed above the glass transition temperature is known to exhibit a fractal nature corresponding to the self-similarity of its spatial properties considered as a function of the number of skeletal bonds in the chain (with a fractal exponent equal to 2 or 5/3) ; the fractal nature results from large amplitude conformational fluctuations which govern also the dual spinsystem response. Nuclear magnetic properties observed in polymeric systems show a marked axial symmetry due to the presence of a strong magnetic field (1 Tesla) applied to the spin-system to induce a macroscopic magnetisation which results from a paramagnetism effect. In high polymer melts, the magnetisation of nuclear spins presents a relaxation process, along the direction of the steady magnetic field, analogous to that of the longitudinal magnetisation observed in ordinary liquids whereas the transverse component exhibits a relaxation behaviour analogous to that of nuclear spins embedded in a solid. It is worth noting that the treatment of the response of the spin-system requires the use of the framework of quantum mechanics. The spin-system is represented by a density matrix operator which applies both in the spin space and in the threedimensional space where nuclei move randomly. The quantum analysis which underlies all NMR observations will not be evoked here. It will be kept in mind that the relaxation of the transverse magnetisation of protons attached to chains will be closely related to the dispersion of quantum phases of wave functions which are associated with nuclear spins ; the relaxation process of the magnetisation of protons which occurs along the direction of the steady magnetic field win be related mainly to a quasi-resonant exchange of energy between the spin-system and the thermal reservoir of energy of molecules which carry nuclear spins. In a short way, it may be considered that, for the sake of simplicity, quantum degrees of freedom will not be evoked throughout this Chapter while macromolecular degrees of freedom associated with translation and rotations will be taken into consideration in order to investigate properties of polymeric system. The principle of the NMR approach to semi-local properties of polymeric melts is considered in Section 2 ; it is shown how the existence of a temporary n e t w o r k structure is detected from the relaxation of the transverse magnetisation of protons attached to chains. The observation of segmental motions from the longitudinal relaxation of proton magnetisation is described in Section 3 ; it is also shown how local motions in concentrated polymeric solutions can be probed from the diffusion process of small molecules. Section 4 is devoted to the analysis of the effect of entanglement relaxation on NMR properties.
20 2. T E M P O R A R Y N E T W O R K S T R U C T U R E S In this Section, the attention is focused on properties of the transverse relaxation of protons attached to polymer molecules; it is sensitive to the presence of temporary network structures in molten polymers. Any high polymer melt is pictured as an ensemble of chain segments with temporarily fixed ends.
2.1. Anisotropy and tensorial interactions of spins One of these segments is now considered (Fig.l). It is supposed that
CH:
B
>
F i g u r e 1. S c h e m a t i c r e p r e s e n t a t i o n of one chain segment, also called submolecule, in a melt ; proton groups are drawn for illustration, only. it is observed at a t e m p e r a t u r e higher t h a n t h a t of the glass transition; consequently, it undergoes conformational fluctuations. However, the random rotation in space of monomeric units which form this chain segment is hindered by the fLxing of its ends. The probability of orientation of skeletal bonds, considered at any time, is not isotropic; it is higher along the direction of the endto-end vector t h a n along the direction perpendicular to this vector. The nonisotropic character of random rotations of monomeric units is reflected by the space average of tensorial magnetic interactions of nuclear spins attached to the chain segment: these interactions are not averaged to zero. The fixing of segment ends gives rise to residual tensorial interactions of spins which accompany the reduction of entropy associated with conformational fluctuations. The strength of averaged magnetic interactions depends on the physical state of the chain segment, determined by its end-to-end vector which will be called r, hereafter, and the number of skeletal bonds that it contains; this number is called n. Let
21 r
HD( p, n ) d e n o t e the residual spin Hamiltonian in the case of dipole-dipole interactions; HD(p, n) is expressed as r
HD(p,n) =0.3{2pz 2 - py2 _ px2 } A ( a / a ( n ) ) 2 ~
,
(1)
where the steady magnetic field direction is along the Z-axis; a is the mean skeletal bond length and c(n) 2 is the mean square end-to-end distance between segment ends [7]. The normalized p vector is defined as p = r/c(n). Orientational correlations of three skeletal bonds, located along one segment, are involved in the definition of the A parameter ; this is called the second order stiffness of the i chain [7]. The H D spin-spin interaction reads i
HD
=
Z Ap,p,Bp,p, , p,p'
(2)
the sum is extended to all p and p' nuclear spins located on the chain segment; Ap,p, spin operators are supposed to commute with the Zeeman energy and B p,p' numerical factors result from transformations of spherical harmonics from monomeric unit frames to the reference frame ascribed to the r elongation vector of the chain segment. Details about these numerical factors are not given here; these are of order unity. E q u a t i o n (1) applies to weakly stretched segments; the statistical framework of description appears through the expression of cffn)2. For Gaussian segments : c(n) 2 = nCoo a 2 ,
(3)
where Coo is called the characteristic ratio of the chain; it describes the first order stiffness p a r a m e t e r which is defined from orientational correlations of two skeletal bonds located on one segment. Equation (1) expresses actually an effect of the reduction of spin-spin interactions, induced by conformational fluctuations which occur within one segment with fixed ends. The effect of reduction is given by a factor which is called f and such that r
HD( p, n) = f
,
(4)
with f = (a/c~)2 ,
(5)
22 the factor f is roughly equal to 1](nC~). The estimate of f can be compared with the time scale of experimental relaxation curves which are found to last over a few milliseconds, for protons ; for n = 2 xl0 2, C~ = 5, f is equal to 10-3. This corresponds to a transverse relaxation rate of 10 2 rad.s -1, in agreement with the observed time scale of relaxation. 2.2. S e m i . l o c a l NMR probe Considering one chain segment characterized by a normalized p stretching vector, and a number n of skeletal bonds, the transverse magnetic relaxation function of nuclear spins, attached to this segment, is generally expressed as a product Mx(t, p, n) = M: (t, p, n) ~r(t).
(6)
The contribution to the relaxation process induced by the presence of residual interactions of spins is given by M~ (t, p, n) = 'Tr ( M : (t) Mx )/ q'r ( Mx2 ) ,
(7)
where r
M x(t) = e x p ( i ~ t )
r
Mx exp(-i H D t ) .
(8)
Mx is the x-component of the spin operator. The contribution to the relaxation process induced by conformational fluctuations of one chain segment is represented by the @r(t) function. The time evolution of this function is determined by the spin-Samiltonian 9 ~ - H D ( P ,
n). The dynamics of random
motions of monomeric units is detected from the @r(t) function while deviations from isotropic rotations of these units are revealed from the M~ (t, p, n) function. The @r(t) function accounts also for dipole-dipole interactions which exist between nuclear spins located on different chain segments. Taking Eq.1 and 8 into consideration, it is clearly seen that the transverse magnetisation is sensitive to properties delocalised over one chain segment; consequently, it probes semi-local properties over about 50A.
2.3. Polymeric system The transverse magnetic relaxation observed over a whole polymeric system, above the glass transition, is heterogeneous. It is the s u m of relaxation processes assigned to each chain segment which participates in the formation of
23 the temporary network structure. Let M~ denote the total relaxation function; it is determined by the average carried out over the distribution of all end-to-end vectors and the distribution of chain segment lengths [8]. The statistical structure of the polymeric system is represented by the probability distribution function of the normalized p vector; it is called G(p)while the probability distribution function of the number of monomeric units in segments is called Q(n); G(p) will be called structure function, hereafter. The relaxation function is expressed as
M~ =
Cr(t)~: Q(n)f G(p) M: (t,p, n) dp
(9)
r
The existence of the H D ( p, n)spin-H~miltonian gives rise to a solid-like
relaxation process of the transverse magnetisation while the Cr(t)function has a liquid-like character. These two types of behaviours can be discriminated from each other in the following way. A solid-likeecho can be formed at a time ~ after the beginning of the transverse relaxation process; let ~ (t, p, n ) denote the function which represents this echo which is also known as the pseudo-solid spinecho. Then, the spin-echo which is observed, is described by the product
0.8
0
$ ~
9
9 9
0.6
9
0.4
ee~
@
§ 0.2
% -~&
+.4-.'. ' if'-F..
0
. . . . 2 .
I
.
4
; ...... 6 __
r
1--'--"-'-~
8
t,,
.
-
I
10
t(ms)
Figure 2. Pseudo-solid spin-echoes recorded from a polybutadiene solution (0.88 w/w) in toluene at 254 K ; relaxation function (+) ; echo origins 0.8 (0), 1.6 (O), 2.4 ( . ) ms.
24 r
0o)
Ex (z; t, p, n ) = E x (z; t, p, n ) Cr(t) 9
The pulse sequence which is applied to the spin system to observe the pseudosolid spin-echo has been described elsewhere [7] ; it is determined by 90~
- z/2
- 180~
- ~/2 - 90~
- (t-r
180~
- (t-z)/2.
Characteristic pseudo-solid spin-echoes recorded from polybutadiene are shown in Fig.2 ; the polymer concentration in deuterated toluene was 0.88 (w/w). The fraction of monomeric units in the cis conformation was 0.96 (M = 110,000 g/tool.). Considering Eq. 6, the M~ (t, p, n) and Or(t) functions are distinguished from each other in the following way. The time derivative of Ex (t, p, n ), at t = z, is expressed as
aE• (z; t ~ , p, n ) _ dM:(t---z) at
dt
--
0
I
"-
i
-o.2
;
_.
=
Or(Z) + M: (z, p, n) d(~r(t---'r dt
T - -
I
--
T
. . . . . . . . .
9
~" 9
(11)
'
9
9
'-
~ i
-
"~
7
7 7
? t
-0.4
u ==
g. §
L-
-
7
7 I
-o.6 ~
-O.8
7
I I__. 19
I "
i
: i
i
7
-1
i --I1 4. 4
0
0.5
7 7
]
-I
t
I
7
I
1.5
2
2.5
~(ms)
Figure 3. Logarithmic derivative of the r function drawn as a time function from polybutadiene at several temperatures 9T = 252 (ll), 264 (A), 274 (O), 295 (~), 314 (~) and 334 K (O).
25 and, the time derivative of Mx(t, p, n), at t = r is written as
dMx(t--~, p, n) dM:(t=z) dt -dt ~r(~) + Mr (% P, n) d(~r(t=r
"
(12)
Let p' and p denote these two time derivatives, respectively. The addition and the subtraction of equations (11) and (12) lead to the determination of time derivatives of M rx(t , p, n) and @r(t) functions, at t=~" dCr(t=z) ~ / Odtr ( C )
= (p+p')/2Mx(z)
(13)
The time derivative of the logarithm of the Cr(t) function is illustrated in Fig. 3, in the case of molten polybutadiene; the molecular weight was Mn = 77000, the vinyl content was 8%. Temperatures of observation were 252, 264, 274, 295, 314 and 334 K ; the r function is experimentally found to be an exponential time function [9].
2.4. Property of time s c a l i n g The most striking feature about NMR investigations into dynamical properties of high polymer systems lies in the observation of a gel like behaviour of the transverse magnetic relaxation. This is illustrated by comparing the proton transverse relaxation and pseudo-solid echoes observed on high molecular weight polybutadiene chains, in a melt, at room temperature, with the relaxation curve and echoes observed on a vulcanized polybutadiene. These two systems are undistinguished from each other by observing the properties of the proton transverse magnetisation [7]. This result shows clearly t h a t there exists a separation between the two dispersions of relaxation times of chain fluctuations which occur in a melt. During this separation, it may be considered t h a t any given chain in a melt behaves like in a p e r m a n e n t gel; it is divided into submolecules and each submolecule has temporarily fixed ends. Let Ne denote the m e a n n u m b e r of skeletal bonds which determine the length of one submolecule; Ne is defined by analogy with the description of the property of elasticity of permanent gels Ne = ppRT / G M m
,
(14)
pp is the pure polymer density while G~ is the modulus of temporary elasticity and Mm is the mean molar weight of one skeletal bond. It is considered that the m e a n n u m b e r Ne is also involved in NMR properties. However, the relevant experimental quantity which is directly associated with the characterisation of structures, in melts, is usually G~ rather than Ne. In this work, the transverse
26 magnetic relaxation is analysed by using directly G~. The entangled polymeric system is described from Eq. 9 where Q(n) =1. NMR investigations into properties of the temporary network structure formed in polybutadiene were made by varying both the modulus of temporary elasticity and the polymer concentration r i) The modulus of temporary elasticity is predicted to vary upon addition of a good solvent according to the expression G N (r
= Go N
~_a
,
(15)
with a varying from 2 to 2.2, for different polymers [4]. ii) Variations of G were also induced by changing the concentration Xl,2 of monomeric units in the vinyl-1,2 conformation. iii) Considering Eq. 1, changes of the temporary network structure are expected to be reflected by variations of the time scale of the transverse relaxation function. Correspondingly, relaxation curves must obey a property of superposition, by applying an appropriate factor to the time scale of observation. Relaxation curves recorded from polybutadiene solutions have been shown to satisfy such a property, provided measurements are performed at a temperature higher than a temperature threshold which will be called Ts, hereafter ; Ts is higher than the Tg glass transition temperature of the polymeric system (Ts- Tg = 80K). Above this temperature threshold, the mathematical structure of the relaxation function is kept invariant except for the time scale. Because of the property of superposition, normalized relaxation curves can be characterized by chosing a given amplitude A and by measuring the time interval corresponding to this amplitude 1:A = (AG A )-1( ~ / a )2 Mx-1 (A),
(16)
where Mx-I(A) is the inverse function of Mx(t). For polybutadiene in concentrated solutions, it has been shown that 0.45 I:A = (1 + G(Xl~2)~2.2 )(T-Tg(~,Xl,2) - 50).8.10 -3 ,
(17)
the time interval is given in milliseconds and G~ is expressed in Pascals and divided by 106. The above equation applies to different chain microstructures obtained by varying Xl,2. The glass transition temperature Tg(~,xl,2) depends on both the polymer concentration and the concentration xl,2 of vinyl monomeric units. The linear dependence of ~A upon the T-Tg temperature interval is illustrated in Fig. 4, for several chain microstructures [10].
27
& 0
50
100
150
T-Tg
2gO
F i g u r e 4. The c h a r a c t e r i s t i c time ZA, m e a s u r e d from s e v e r a l chain microstructures of polybutadiene, is represented for A = 0.6 ; vinyl contents are xz,2 = 0.22 (Q), 0.40 (A), 0.58 (A) and 0.82 0). The presence of a temporary network structure manifests itself through the first factor in the right hand side of Eq. 17. It comes from the M~(t) component of the relaxation function. The second factor results from fast non-isotropic motions of monomeric units which give rise to the Cr(t) function defined in equations (6) and (9). It m u s t be noticed t h a t the reference temperature Ti = Tg(r +50 which appears in NMR properties, is close to the reference temperature Ti introduced from viscoelastic m e a s u r e m e n t s [11]. The second factor reflects a free volume effect ; it depends necessarily on an expansion coefficient which is about equal to 10-3K. It is seen that NMR properties, specific to polymeric systems, are not due to the absence of motions but to the non-isotropic character of these motions. It is worth emphasizing that the search for a characterisation of dynamical properties leads actually to the observation of non-isotropic rotations of monomeric units which result from the presence of entanglements. Asymmetry properties are observed instead of dynamic ones. Equation (17) is general and applies also to polyisobutylene solutions or to polyisoprene by using different values of the parameters.
28 A sharp analysis of relaxation functions is obtained by using equations (11) and (12). They yield an exponential time function for ~r(t), associated with fast and non-isotropic motions whereas Mxr(t) is found to depend on deviations from isotropic rotations, only. This is an illustration of the dual behaviour of the spin-spin response. 3. S E G M E N T A L M O T I O N S : D Y N A M I C S C R E E N I N G E F F E C T In this Section, the attention is focused on the longitudinal relaxation of the magnetisation of protons attached to polymer molecules. Local motions are probed from this relaxation mechanism and from measurements of the friction coefficient of host small molecules moving randomly through the polymeric system. Segmental motions are expected to be independent of chain molecular weight variations 9 long range fluctuations are screened when dynamic properties are observed in a short space scale.
3.1.
Frequency-temperature scaling
The longitudinal relaxation also called spin-lattice relaxation is induced by a quasi-resonant exchange which occurs between the Zeeman energy of the spin system and the thermal energy of molecules which carry nuclear magnetic dipoles. The condition of quasi-resonant exchange of energy is used to calibrate the time scale of relaxation of molecular processes; the precession frequency coo of nuclear spins, also called Larmor frequency, plays the role of a reference. The maximum of the spin-lattice relaxation rate occurs when the Larmor frequency is approximately equal to the inverse of the correlation time which characterizes molecular motions [3]. The exact calculation of relaxation rates necessitates an accurate description of random molecular motions which are nowadays well described in the case of small molecules in an ordinary liquid. In the case of polymeric systems, the calculation of relaxation rates comes against the description of segmental motions; the difficulty arises from the necessity to take collective rotational isomerizations of monomeric units into consideration. Several correlation times must be introduced to account for the collective random monomeric rotations. As a consequence of the existence of a spectrum of relaxation times instead of a single correlation time, the spin-lattice relaxation rate is usually found to depend on the Larmor frequency on both sides around the maximum observed by varying the temperature of the polymeric system. A few models of segmental motions which involve several skeletal bonds have been proposed until now [12, 13]. In this Chapter, experimental results are reported only to give a short illustration of the analysis which has been already p r o p o s e d elsewhere [14]. Measuring the T 1 - 1 spin-lattice relaxation rate of protons or of 13C nuclei attached to polymer chains, the function defined by the ration co0/T1 is considered. The analysis is based on the assumption that the co0/T1 ratio obeys a property of homogeneity with respect to the variable determined by the product of the co0 Larmor frequency and one characteristic correlation time. Such a property implies that the spectrum of correlation times associated with random segmental motions represents multiples of one characteristic time whatever its exact definition : let zlC(T,f) denote this correlation time. The ratio 0~0/T1
29
co0/T 1 = '6' (cool:1c),
(18)
where Xl c may depend on both the p o l y m e r concentration ~ and the temperature of the polymeric system. Equation (18) shows that a frequencytemperature or a frequency-concentration scaling can be applied to the arralysis of experimental results. It is considered that several monomeric units are involved in segmental motions which are observed from the spin-lattice relaxation rate. More precisely, it is assumed that collective rotational isomerizations of a small number of succesive monomeric units are converted into a translational random motion of a short segment. An effective friction coefficient of one monomeric unit can be associated with this translational motion : let ~f(T,~) denote this friction coefficient. It c o r r e s p o n d s to an effective correlation time Xl c (T,r 2 ~f (T,r ; b is the mean length of one skeletal bond. The property of homogeneity of the CO0/T1 functions is well illustrated from polybutadiene chains, observing 13C of 1H nuclei [14]. Polybutadiene is a flexible polymer whose viscoelastic properties have been extensively studied over a very broad temperature-frequency range [11]. The first criterion of application of this analysis is the observation of a nearly constant value of the maximum of the co0/T1 function, w h a t e v e r the Larmor frequency. Then, the experimental c00/T1 curve must be d r a w n as a function of T-Tg of T-Ti, for a given Larmor frequency, with T i = Tg + 5 5 , introduced from viscoelastic measurements; it must be shifted- towards high temperatures when the Larmor frequency is increased. The second criterion of application is the possibility to superpose all CO0/T1 functions recorded by using several Larmor frequencies. The property of superposition of all relaxation curves is well observed for pure polybutadiene, by using the variable T-Ti (Fig. 5). The broad shape of the relaxation curves near the maximum indicates that a spectrum of correlation times is involved in segmcntal motions; nevertheless, the maximum of efficiency corresponds to correlation time values near 4.x10 -9 s. A shift factor a(T-Ti) which applies to the friction coefficient is introduced; then the product coo ~f(Ti)a(Ti,T)is considered as reduced variable. Considering two Larmor frequencies coO' and coO", the property of homogeneity reads coo' a(T'-Ti) = r
a(T"-Ti)
where T' and T" are determined from any two chosen equal amplitudes of experimental curves. The value of the ratio co0'/co0" gives the relative evolution of the a(T-Ti) shift factor which is found to be in agreement with results of viscoelastic measurements
30
T-Ti Log [ a(Ti ,T) ] = -5.78 T- Ti + 94.8
(19)
This equation applies to any chain microstructure provided the Ti reference temperature is defined with respect to the glass transition temperature Tg, corresponding to the observed polybutadiene chain [11]. Such an analysis has been also extended to several solvent-polymer systems. A similar approach has been applied to polyisoprene in dilute solution in toluene [15]. The maximum value of the relaxation time is found to be independent of polymer concentrations ranging from 0.58 to 1 ; it is equal to 20 s1. This result shows that the effective number of interacting protons does not depend on the polymer concentration ; interactions between protons located on different chain segments can be neglected.
E] DO 3
~O
-
z~
A O 2
@
s
-
v]
A 0 AFa 1
-
E~
o
-2.5
rn
c~
.l -2
! - I .5
I
!
1
1
1
-1
-.5
0
.5
1
log o~oa ( T -
1.5
Ti)
Figure 5. Spin-lattice relaxation rates of protons, attached to polybutadiene chains, as a function of the variable m0 a( T-Ti); r 32 (O), 60 (O) and 100 (A) MHz.
31 The observation of the property of homogeneity of spin-lattice relaxation rates with respect to both the Larmor frequency and one basic dynamical segmental parameter is interpreted as reflecting average fluctuations which occur within short chain segments and not a single rotational isomerization process of skeletal bonds. Helical turns are known to form and to dissociate rapidly in any homopolymer ; the average fluctuation probably spreads over about 10 monomeric units since the spin-lattice relaxation rate is not affected by crosslinks between segments unless the contour length defined by two consecutive junctions is reduced down to 20 skeletal bonds [16]. Finally, it may be worth emphasizing that spin-lattice relaxation rates usually observed on high polymers are independent of the chain molecular weight. This property reflects the effect of dynamic screening ; it does not hold when polymer chains are too short. Then, variations of the polymer molecular weight correspond to variations of the concentration of chain ends which plays the role of solvent molecules. To conclude, the ratio o~0/T1 may be considered, in most cases, as a homogeneous function with respect to the product of the Larmor fequency and one characteristic molecular time constant; this property is very useful to disclose relative variations of this time constant as a function of temperature or concentration. The coincidence of maximum values of the co0/T1 ratio with one another, indicates that the mean square dipole-dipole interaction is hardly dependent on temperature or polymer concentration. It is worth noting that spinlattice relaxation rates are found to be insensitive to chain length variations unless molecular weights become lower than about 10,000 g/tool.. 3.3. S o l v e n t d i f f u s i o n : f r e e v o l u m e e f f e c t .
Local motions which occur in macromolecular systems can be probed from the diffusion process of small molecules in concentrated polymeric solutions. The translational diffusion is detected from NMR over a time scale which may vary from about 1 to 100 ms. Such a time interval corresponds to a very large number of elementary collisions and a long random path ; consequently, details about mechanisms of molecular jump are not disclosed from this NMR approach. However, the dynamical behaviour of small solvent molecules, immersed in a polymer melt and observed over a long time interval, permits the determination of characteristic parameters of the diffusion process. Applying the Langevin's equation, the self-diffusion coefficient Ds is defined as Ds = kT/~s
,
(20)
where the ~s friction coefficient of solvent molecules is governed by Stokes'law ~s = 6~ dTIo , d is the molecular diameter and TIo is the liquid viscosity [17]. The purpose of investigations into diffusion properties is twofold. i) First, starting from a free volume law which characterises a pure molten polymer, it is of interest to analyse the evolution of the free volume description upon addition of solvent.
32
ii) Secondly, the limiting value of the ~s((~) coefficient obtained when the solvent concentration goes to zero, gives a good estimate of the monomeric friction coefficient. Since the pioneering work of Stejskal, the pulse field gradient method is currently used to characterize the diffusion process of small molecules or of macromolecules in dilute or semi-dilute solutions [18-20]. In this Chapter, the NMR approach is illustrated from the self-diffusion of cyclohexane molecules t h r o u g h polybutadiene. Variations of the Ds self-diffusion coefficient of cyclohexane in polybutadiene have been reported as a temperature function considering several concentrations [21]. The WLF way of analysis has been extended to polymeric solutions assuming that polymer and solvent fractional free volumes add linearly to each other [22]. More recently, a different way of analysis has been proposed by Vrentas and Duda; it includes several parameters such as a jumping unit volume [23]. It is worth emphasizing that these two approaches become equivalent to each other when the parameters introduced in the Vrentas-Duda analysis have appropriate values. This is the case in the cyclohexane-polybutadiene system. Measurements performed by varying both the polymer concentration and the temperature lead to the determination of free volume parameters with a good accuracy. For the pure polymer; the fractional free volume is fp = 0.124 +_0.005 at 298 K, and the thermal expansion coefficient is ap = (7.0 + 0.5) x 10-4 K-1 , while for the pure solvent the fractional free volume is fs = 0.223, and the thermal expansion coefficient is as = 11.8x 10~ Kq at 298 K.
3.4 M o n o m e r i c f r i c t i o n c o e f f i c i e n t There is an interesting feature about the limiting value of the trace diffusivity of solvent determined from experimental curves when the solvent concentration is set equal to zero. The diffusion coefficient Ds(0,T) is found to obey the free volume law of the pure polymer when the above numerical values are assigned to the parameters. Furthermore, the ~s(0,T) translational friction coefficient, derived from the ratio kT/Ds(0,T), is equal to (1.64+_0,06) x 10 -1~ N.s.m -1, at 298 K ; this value is in good agreement with the result of viscoelastic measurements performed on polybutadiene (1.8 x 10-1~N.s.m-1). The trace diffusivity clearly shows that there is no discontinuity when the solvent concentration goes to zero ; in other words, solvent molecules can be used to probe local properties of polymer melts directly.
33 4. MOLTEN
HIGH POLYMERS : SEMI.LOCAL DYNAMICS
In molten high polymers, chain coupling junctions dissociate slowly; the full rotation of one chain occurs over the terminal relaxation time, hereafter called TR; this obeys a power law predicted from the reptation model proposed by De Gennes :TR = N 3 [6]. The transverse magnetic relaxation of protons, attached to polymer chains, behaves as they would in a p e r m a n e n t gel; a network structure is detected from the observation of well-defined pseudo-solid spinechoes. This network structure is temporary and its TR relaxation time shortens rapidly when the chain molecular weight is lowered. Considering dipole-dipole interactions of nuclear spins located on one chain, the full motional averaging of these interactions occurs when TR satisfies the inequality i
HDTR I N <1 ,
(21)
or i
HD nO IN G <1,
(22)
where ~0 is the zero shear rate viscosity of the polymer and ~ is its modulus of t e m p o r a r y elasticity, associated with the time b r e a k of conformational fluctuations; the estimate of ~
is 105rad.s -1, for protons. For example, for
polydimethylsiloxane ( N = 6x103 ), the G~ modulus is equal to 106 Pa. and ~o is equal to 103 Pa.s; then, proton dipole-dipole interactions satisfy ttie above inequality and no anisotropy of random rotations of monomeric units is detected from NMR, for N = 6x103. The time dependence of the transverse magnetic relaxation of protons, observed in several polymeric systems corresponding to decreasing chain molecular weights, exhibits a progressive evolution from pseudo-solid properties associated with the presence of a temporary network structure to a liquid-like behaviour. The motional averaging effect is one of the most difficult problems left to solve in NMR of complex molecular systems. The analysis of NMR properties is based on the assumption t h a t there exists a G a u s s i a n G(p)structure function which represents a t e m p o r a r y network structure. NMR becomes sensitive to the time dependence of the network structure when the chain molecular weight is varied toward low values. A scaling analysis of relaxation curves can be applied to the characterization of relaxation processes using a second order cumulant expansion to express the spin-system response [7]. Experimental results are represented according to the expression Log [ Mx(t)] =t2
(AeT~/t)2 F2 (t/T~)
,
(23)
with 1-'2 (t/T~)= j dul j du2 f2(ul,u2) ,
(24)
34
where Ae is the residual dipole-dipole interaction associated with the m e a n s e g m e n t a l spacing defined by two consecutive e n t a n g l e m e n t s along one chain; f2(ul,u2) is the correlation function of the square of one of the three components of one p vector, considered at two reduced times Ul and u2 , with u = t ~ R. A T vR correlation time which may be specific to NMR observations is introduced instead of TR. The scaling analysis was applied to polybutadiene chains, observed at room t e m p e r a t u r e , in concentrated solutions in deuterated cyclohexane [24]. The polymer concentration was 0.7 (w/w) and chain molecular weights were 70, 120, 170 and 360x103 g/tool.. The proton (Log [ Mx(t)]/t 2 ) function is represented as a function of t in Fig. 6, for several chain lengths. Then, experimental curves are shown to obey a property of superposition by applying a suitable factor to the time scale of observation of drawn curves. The relaxation curve corresponding to Mw = 70x103 g/tool, is used as a reference ; the superposition yields the relative variation of T~ as a function of the chain molecular weight- T.v R is found to be a linear function of Mw. The molecular weight dependence of ~
shows t h a t long
range chain fluctuations are involved in the relaxation process of the transverse m a g n e t i s a t i o n of protons ;
0 ,,,
I:
,,
i_ M
~e oe oe o:e ~oe "*o: ,"
,'t.
t, - ,TS~u_^oo o o oo ,~, -o- _
o
_i
~ Q
-0.3
_,
-0.4 -0.5
-0.6
/~ -
0
,
:
~. . . . . . . . . .
,
,
1
2
3
4
5
t(ms)
Figure 6. Proton function Log [Mx(t)] / t 2) recorded from pure polybutadiene ; molecular weights are 103Mw = 70 (A), 120 (O), 170 (D) and 360 ( ) g/tool..
35 however, the value of the exponent (1 instead of 3, for reptation) reveals that fluctuations detected from NMR are faster than those which give rise to the mechanism of reptation. The order of magnitude of T~ is Ae-1 (lms.).
CONCLUSION The magnetic relaxation of protons linked to polymer molecules is sensitive to collective rotational isomerisations which occur along one chain. Orientational correlations of monomeric units give rise to relaxation mechanisms specific to polymeric systems, studied above the glass transition temperature. A deep insight into dynamic properties is provided by observing the irreversible behaviour either of the proton transverse magnetisation or of the longitudinal component. Most experimental results obey a time-scaling analysis ; the time scale is governed by a friction coefficient for local observations or by the presence and the life-time of entanglements for semi-local observations. Both NMR and viscoelastic responses of polymers manifest a dual behaviour ; this appears as liquid-like and solid-like magnetic relaxations while it corresponds to viscosity and elasticity for flowing systems. The general character of nuclear magnetic relaxation properties arises from the statistical average which applies to monomeric units along one chain. The most striking feature about NMR investigations into dynamic properties of linear macromolecules concerns the possibility to explore the broad relaxation spectrum inherent to such complex systems without assuming that any frequency-temperature or frequency-concentration shift may apply to the analysis of the observed polymeric relaxation behaviour. Considering several NMR methods, the characterisation of the dynamics of a polymeric medium starts from the estimate of the monomeric unit friction coefficient; then, it concerns the gel-like behaviour of high polymer melts and segmental motions involving several skeletal bonds. Finally, long range fluctuations are taken into consideration. The domain of correlation times which can be probed from NMR spreads over a time scale going from 10"1~ s to about 1 s.. The analysis which results from the NMR approach requires a deep insight into molecular mechanisms which underlie chain fluctuations. This work shows that molecular properties, disclosed from NMR observations made on polybutadiene, are closely related to effects evidenced from viscoelastic measurements; it may be stated now that the viscoelastic behaviour of other polymers can be investigated from NMR without making, necessarily, a step by step comparison between the two approaches.
REFERENCES
1. B.H. Zimm, J. Chem. Phys. 24 (1956) 269. 2. P.E. Rouse, J. Chem. Phys. 21 (1953) 1272. 3. A. Abragam, Principles of Nuclear magnetism, Oxford University Press, London (1961). 4. J.D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers (3rd edn), J. Wiley, New-York
35 (1980). 5. W.W. Graessley, Advances in Polymer Science, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1974). 6. P.G. De Germes, Scaling Concepts in Physics, CorneU University Press, Ithaca (1979). 7. J.P. Cohen-Addad, Progress in Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (Ed. J.W. Emsley, J. Feeney and L.H. Sutcliff), Pergamon Press 25 (1993) 1. 8. J.P. Cohen Addad, Phys. Rev. B 48 (1993) 1287. 9. M. Todica, Thesis - University of Genoble (1994). 10. A. Labouriau and J.P. Cohen Addad, J. Chem. Phys. 94 (1991) 3242. 11. J.M. CareUa, W.W. Graessley and L.J. Fetters, Macromolecules 17 (1984) 2775. 12. R. Dejean de la Batie, F. Laupr~tre and L. Mormerie, Macromolecules 22 (1989) 122. 13. C.K. Hall and E.J. Helfand, J. Chem. Phys. 77 (1982) 3275. 14. A. Guillermo, R. Dupeyre and J.P. Cohen Addad, Macromolecules 23 (1990) 1291. 15. D.J. Gisser, S. Glowinkowskq and M.D. Ediger, Macromolecules 24 (1991) 4270. 16. G.C. Munie, Jiri Jonas and I.J. Rowland, J. Polym. Sci. 18 (1981) 1061. 17. P. Langevin, Comptes Rendus de l'Acaddmie des Sciences (Paris) 146 (1908) 530. 18. E.O. Stejskal and J.E. Tanner, J. Chem. Phys. 42 (1965) 288. 19. E.D. von Meerwall, J. Grigsby, D. Tomich and R. Van Antwerp, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. Ed. 20 (1982) 1037. 20. P.T. Callaghan and D.N Pinder, Macromolecules 17 (1984) 431. 21. A. Guillermo, M. Todica and J.P. Cohen Addad, Macromolecules 26 (1993) 3946. 22. H. Fujita and A. Kisbimoto, J. Chem. Phys. 34 (1961) 393. 23. J.S. Vrentas and J.L. Duda, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. Ed. 15 (1977) 403. 24. A. Labouriau- Thesis - University of Grenoble (1992).
Rheology for Polymer Melt Processing J-M. Piau and J-F. Agassant (editors) 9 1996 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
37
C h a i n r e l a x a t i o n p r o c e s s e s of u n i a x i a l l y s t r e t c h e d p o l y m e r c h a i n s an infrared dichroism study J. F. Tassin a, L. Bokobza b, C. Hayes b, L. Monnerie b aLaboratoire de Physicochimie Macromol~culaire, URA CNRS 509, Universit~ du Maine, Avenue Olivier Messiaen, 72017 Le Mans Cedex, France bLaboratoire de Physic~ S t r u c t u r a l e et Macromol~culaire, URA CNRS 278, ESPCI, 10 rue Vauquelin, 75231 Paris Cedex 05, France 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Polymer processing usually involves deformation of macromolecular coils i n d u c i n g a p r e f e r e n t i a l o r i e n t a t i o n of the polymer chain segments. The orientation is, of course, the result of a balance between shear and extensional d e f o r m a t i o n a n d molecular r e l a x a t i o n processes. The knowledge of t h e s e processes is a first but important step in the rheology of polymer melts, in order to obtain analytical expressions for the relaxation modulus for small as well as for large deformations. Mechanical m e a s u r e m e n t s can be carried out on a large variety of samples but are often difficult to interpret in terms of molecular r e l a x a t i o n m e c h a n i s m s , although experiments on model b i n a r y blends have been quite fruitful [1]. A better u n d e r s t a n d i n g is expected if information can be o b t a i n e d at a molecular level, for instance t h r o u g h s e g m e n t a l o r i e n t a t i o n m e a s u r e m e n t s . An extensive study has therefore been carried out on model m a t e r i a l s to probe molecular theories of chain relaxation. Infrared dichroism has proved to be a useful tool to observe the orientation at a segmental scale. In this chapter, the r e s u l t s of orientation m e a s u r e m e n t s by i n f r a r e d dichroism will be presented, discussing three main topics : - Relaxation of chain segments as a function of the position along a l i n e a r chain - Comparison between relaxation of linear and branched chains - Relaxation of long and short chains in binary blends. In order to create a strong molecular orientation, uniaxially s t r e t c h e d samples have been investigated. Large deformations (draw ratios up to 4) have been applied to enhance non linear relaxation phenomena t h a t are d o m i n a n t in most processing techniques. The predictions of molecular models have been c o m p a r e d w i t h e x p e r i m e n t a l d a t a in order to identify various possible relaxation processes and eventually to introduce some improvements.
9
38
2. Theoretical b a c k g r o u n d in I n f r a r e d D i c h r o i s m Infrared dichroism is one of n u m e r o u s methods used to characterize molecular orientation. The degree of anisotropy of the strained polymers may also be accurately characterized by other techniques such as X-ray diffraction, birefringence, sonic modulus, polarized fluorescence and polarized R a m a n spectroscopy [2]. These techniques directly probe the orientational behavior of macromolecular chains at a molecular level, in contrast to the macroscopic information provided by mechanical m e a s u r e m e n t s . Birefringence and dichroism represent two optical methods which can be applied to m a t e r i a l s u n d e r flow conditions, forming the basis of Optical Rheometry [3,4]. The aim of these two techniques is to m e a s u r e the anisotropy of the complex refractive index tensor n = ~ ' - i v.". Birefringence is related to the anisotropy of the real part, whereas dichroism deals with the i m a g i n a r y part. Recent applications of birefringence m e a s u r e m e n t s to polymer melts can be found in Chapter III.1 of the present book. Dichroism refers to a change in the attenuation of light which depends on the orientation of the electric field. Two m e c h a n i s m s (either s c a t t e r i n g or absorption) m a y contribute to dichroism in anisotropic m a t e r i a l s and the choice of the w a v e l e n g t h r a n g e allows selection of t h e origin of light attenuation. In the infrared range, for homogeneous samples, the dichroism only arises from strong absorption effects. In this region of the electromagnetic spectrum, absorption originates from vibrational motions of atomic groups w i t h i n the molecules. These m o t i o n s are classically t r e a t e d u s i n g the mechanical analysis of a vibrating system and can be represented by a set of n o r m a l v i b r a t i o n a l modes associated w i t h well-defined n o r m a l v i b r a t i o n frequencies. An infrared active normal mode leads to a change in the dipole m o m e n t of the molecule which can be figured as a t r a n s i t i o n m o m e n t , M, which possesses a fixed and known position in the molecule. It is generally related to the s y m m e t r y elements of the molecule. The absorption of the infrared radiation is precisely caused by the interaction of the electric field vector of the incident light w i t h the electric dipole t r a n s i t i o n m o m e n t associated with a particular vibration. Segmental orientation in a material submitted to uniaxial elongation may be conveniently described by the average of the second Legendre polynomial
= 1 <3 cos20 - 1>
(1)
where 0 is the angle between the macroscopic reference axis (usually t a k e n as the stretching direction) and the local chain axis or any vector characteristic of a given chain segment. The b r a c k e t s indicate an a v e r a g e over all the segmental units. The dichroic ratio R defined as R = A/// A• is c o m m o n l y u s e d to characterize the degree of optical anisotropy; A//and A• being the m e a s u r e d absorbances of the investigated band for an incident r a d i a t i o n polarized respectively along and perpendicular to the stretching direction. The orientation function is related to the dichroic ratio R by [5]: (R- 1) 2 = C((x) R+ 1 <e2(cos0)> = (R + 2) (3cos2ct_ 1) 2
(2)
39 w h e r e a is the angle between the transition m o m e n t and the local chain axis. It can be obtained from theoretical considerations arising from group theory analysis, or d e t e r m i n e d experimentally from a n o t h e r absorption b a n d since the segmental orientation is independent of the chosen absorption band. Practical problems associated with i n f r a r e d dichroism m e a s u r e m e n t s include the r e q u i r e m e n t of a band absorbance lower t h a n 0.7 in the general case, in order to use the Beer-Lambert law; in addition infrared bands should be sufficently well assigned and free of overlap with other bands. The specificity of infrared absorption bands to particular chemical functional groups makes i n f r a r e d dichroism especially attractive for a detailed study of submolecular orientations of m a t e r i a l s such as polymers. For instance, information on the o r i e n t a t i o n of both c r y s t a l l i n e and a m o r p h o u s p h a s e s in s e m i c r y s t a l l i n e polymers m a y be obtained if absorption bands specific of each phase can be found. Polarized infrared spectroscopy can also yield detailed information on the o r i e n t a t i o n a l behavior of each component of a polymer blend or of the different chemical sequences of a copolymer. Infrar-'~l dichroism studies do not require any chain labelling but owing to the mass dependence of the vibrational frequency, pronounced shifts result upon isotopic substitution. It is therefore possible to study binary mixtures of deuterated and normal polymers as well as i s o t o p i c a l l y - l a b e l l e d block c o p o l y m e r s a n d t h u s o b t a i n i n f o r m a t i o n simultaneously on the two types of units. O u r work has been focused on polystyrene, the i n f r a r e d s p e c t r u m of w h i c h is w e l l - d o c u m e n t e d . For n o r m a l p o l y s t y r e n e , dichroism can be m e a s u r e d using the 906 cm -1 and the 1028 cm -1 absorption bands. They are associated with an out-of-plane and in-plane deformation of the CH phenyl ring deformation modes respectively. The 1028 cm -1 band has a transition moment which is perpendicular to the chain axis (a = 90 ~ whereas an angle of 35 ~ is accepted for the 906 cm -1 band [5]. For deuterated segments, the 2195 and 2273 cm -1 absorption bands have been used. They are respectively assigned to the a s y m m e t r i c stretching vibration of CD 2 groups and to stretching vibrations of the aromatic CD bonds. The 2100 cm -1 symmetrical stretching mode of the CD 2 g r o u p s h a s a w e a k i n t e n s i t y and c a n n o t be r e l i a b l y used u n l e s s the concentration of deuterated units is quite high (40 wt%). For d e u t e r a t e d segments, a preliminary study involving binary mixtures of normal and d e u t e r a t e d polystyrene of the same molecular weight has led to the following values for the calculation of the deuterated segment orientation : C = -3,8 for the 2195 cm -1 band and C = -2,7 for the 2273 cm -1 band [6]. 3. E x p e r i m e n t a l E x p e r i m e n t s h a v e been c a r r i e d out on e s s e n t i a l l y m o n o d i s p e r s e p o l y s t y r e n e , e i t h e r homopolymers (normal or d e u t e r a t e d ) or isotopicallylabelled block-copolymers. These materials have been used alone or blended. Sample nomenclature and average molecular weights, as determined by SEC, are presented in Tables 1 and 2. Isotopically-labelled block copolymers, either l i n e a r or 6-arm stars, synthesized by anionic polymerization, were kindly provided by Dr. L. J. F e t t e r s (Exxon Research and E n g i n e e r i n g Company).
40 O t h e r m a t e r i a l s h a v e b e e n p u r c h a s e d from P r e s s u r e C h e m i c a l , P o l y m e r Laboratories or supplied by E. A. H. P. (Strasbourg, France). Table 1 S a m p l e characteristics a n d n o m e n c l a t u r e of l i n e a r and s t a r polymers D e u t e r a t e d Block H y d r o g e n o u s Block Position 10 -3 Mw Mw/Mn 10 -3 Mw Mw/Mn PS DH 184 end 27 1.03 157 1.05 PS HDH 188 centre 30 1.03 79 1.03 PS DHD 500 e n d s 39 1.03 424 1.08 Star-a end 37 1.05 188 1.05 Star-b branch pt 30 1.04 215 1.05 PS 1190 1190 1.4 PS 2000 2000 1.3
Table 2 S a m p l e characteristics a n d n o m e n c l a t u r e of b i n a r y blends D e u t e r a t e d chains (PSD) M a s s fraction in 10 -3 Mw Mw/Mn the blend 72 1.03 PS 2000/PSD 72 (20%) 0.2 27 1.06 PS 2000/PSD 27 (20%) 0.2 18 1.01 PS 2000/PSD 18 (20%) 0.2 10.5 1.02 PS 2000/PSD 10 (10 %) 0.1 10.5 1.02 PS 2000/PSD 10 (20 %) 0.2 10.5 1.02 PS 2000/PSD 10 (30 %) 0.3 2.6 1.05 PS 2000/PSD 3 (20 %) 0.2
Tg (~ 105 105 105 105 105 103 97
3.1. Preparation of the samples The polystyrene films (50 ~m thick) were obtained by casting a 6 to 10wt% (depending on the molecular weight of t h e polymer) distilled b e n z e n e solution on a glass plate followed by drying at room t e m p e r a t u r e . Strips 2 cm wide were a n n e a l e d u n d e r v a c u u m for at least 48h hours a t 140~ in order to remove any trace of solvent and i n t e r n a l stress due to cutting. The films' s u p p o r t d u r i n g the d r y i n g t r e a t m e n t was chosen to provide an i r r e g u l a r surface for t h e films in o r d e r to m i n i m i z e i n t e r f e r e n c e f r i n g e s d u r i n g t h e r e c o r d i n g of F T I R spectra.
3.2. S t r e t c h i n g c o n d i t i o n s S t r e t c h i n g e x p e r i m e n t s were performed on l a b o r a t o r y - d e s i g n e d h y d r a u l i c m a c h i n e s [7]. Uniaxial elongations were m a d e a t c o n s t a n t s t r a i n r a t e a n d at t e m p e r a t u r e s above the glass t r a n s i t i o n t e m p e r a t u r e (Tg = 106~ T h e draw ratio was limited to k = 4 (~ being the ratio of the final to the initial length) to avoid s a m p l e breakage. The t e m p e r a t u r e r a n g e was chosen b e t w e e n 107 and 14~0~ S t r a i n rates ranged from 8.10 -3 up to 0.1 s -1. Two types of e x p e r i m e n t s were p e r f o r m e d . In t h e initial s t u d i e s , the s a m p l e s were s t r e t c h e d u n d e r given s t r a i n r a t e s a n d t e m p e r a t u r e conditions at a given draw ratio k ( 1.5 _
41 the s a m p l e was rapidly quenched to room t e m p e r a t u r e in order to freeze the s t a t e of o r i e n t a t i o n at t h e end of stretching. In a large m a j o r i t y of the experiments, a linear relationship was observed between and k, and h e r e a f t e r the o r i e n t a t i o n obtained at ~. = 4 will be reported. A m a s t e r curve of the o r i e n t a t i o n a l r e l a x a t i o n is o b t a i n e d by t i m e - t e m p e r a t u r e superposition u s i n g e x p e r i m e n t s carried out at various s t r a i n r a t e s and t e m p e r a t u r e s [6]. O b t e n t i o n of a m a s t e r curve implies that, for a given draw ratio, the orientation m e a s u r e d at a given t e m p e r a t u r e , T1, a n d a s t r a i n rate, al, is, within e x p e r i m e n t a l uncertainty, identical to t h a t obtained at a t e m p e r a t u r e , T2, and a s t r a i n rate, e2, such t h a t ~:2 = ~:1/ aT2/T 1 where aT2/T 1 is the shift factor between temperatures T 1 a n d T2, given by the classical W L F e q u a t i o n [8]. The coefficients obtained by Plazek [41] have been used t h r o u g h o u t this w o r k (C 1 = 9,76 and C 2 = 64,8 for a reference t e m p e r a t u r e of 115~ In more recent e x p e r i m e n t s , the samples were s t r e t c h e d at 0,1 s -1 at a given t e m p e r a t u r e and at a draw ratio k = 4. The samples were then allowed to relax u n d e r c o n s t a n t conditions (length, t e m p e r a t u r e ) for a given aging time r a n g i n g from 3 to 103 s a n d subsequently quenched to room t e m p e r a t u r e . The r e s i d u a l o r i e n t a t i o n was t h u s frozen at a given aging time. The t i m e range explored by the e x p e r i m e n t s can be extended at both ends by c h a n g i n g the s t r e t c h i n g t e m p e r a t u r e . The data points r e p r e s e n t an average over 3 samples s t r e t c h e d u n d e r the s a m e conditions. A m a s t e r curve of the o r i e n t a t i o n a l r e l a x a t i o n , covering a l m o s t 4 decades in time, can be obtained by applying t i m e - t e m p e r a t u r e superposition. On samples which have been subjected to both procedures it was checked t h a t the m a s t e r curves coincide within the accuracy of our m e a s u r e m e n t s . T h e s e s t r e t c h i n g conditions can be compared with those of Miiller and Picot described in C h a p t e r 1.4 of the present book. Our samples were obtained at c o m p a r a t i v e l y s h o r t e r times, using higher strain rates. Deviations from the l i n e a r v i s c o e l a s t i c b e h a v i o u r in s t r e s s g r o w t h are expected. As far as r e l a x a t i o n is concerned, the shortest time investigated in n e u t r o n scattering e x p e r i m e n t s c o r r e s p o n d s r o u g h l y to the longest ones s t u d i e d by infrared dichroi'sm. 3.3. O r i e n t a t i o n m e a s u r e m e n t s The i n f r a r e d s p e c t r a were recorded on a Nicolet 7199 or a Nicolet 205 F o u r i e r t r a n s f o r m infrared spectrometer at a resolution of 2 cm -1 with a total n u m b e r of scans of up to 128 for low-orientation samples. The infrared beam was polarized using a SPECAC gold wire-grid polarizer. Samples, r a t h e r t h a n p o l a r i z e r , w e r e r o t a t e d 90 ~ in o r d e r to o b t a i n t h e two p o l a r i z a t i o n m e a s u r e m e n t s . The dichroic r a t i o was c a l c u l a t e d from the m e a s u r e d absorbance at the m a x i m u m of the infrared band.
4. T h e o r e t i c a l basis of i n t e r p r e t a t i o n The molecular-level n a t u r e of our orientation relaxation d a t a has led us to carry out an i n t e r p r e t a t i o n in t e r m s of molecular motions. Therefore we have based our i n t e r p r e t a t i o n on the Doi-Edwards model [9]. We briefly recall the m a i n qualitative features of the model and include other processes proposed by
42 various authors. The relaxation will be described from s h o r t to long times following a step strain. It is assumed that, at the end of the step strain, the Rouse chains a n d s u b c h a i n s b e t w e e n e n t a n g l e m e n t p o i n t s are affinely deformed. 4.1. l , i n e a r c h a i n s The first r e l a x a t i o n process (designated A h e r e a f t e r ) corresponds to a Rouse-like relaxation of chain segments between e n t a n g l e m e n t points. It is a s s u m e d t h a t the e n t a n g l e m e n t points r e m a i n fLxed d u r i n g the time-scale of this relaxation and t h a t no diffusion of monomers t h r o u g h the slip-links is allowed in such short times. The associated relaxation time, ZA, is related to a monomeric friction coefficient, ~0, and to the n u m b e r of m o n o m e r s between e n t a n g l e m e n t points N e. ~A is given by : 3:A= ~ ~0 a2 Ne2 (3) 6/1;2kBT where a is the monomer length, k B the Boltzmann constant and T the absolute t e m p e r a t u r e . This relaxation time is thus independent of the molecular weight of the chain and as a consequence of its local character, the relaxation kinetics for this process are independent of the position of the segment along the chain. The second process (B), characterized by a relaxation time xB proportional to the s q u a r e of the molecular weight of the chain, is a r e t r a c t i o n of the deformed chain inside its tube to recover its equilibrium eurvilinear length. This process has a strong nonlinear character since its a m p l i t u d e is strongly increased by large deformations [10]. From the diffusion e q u a t i o n used to determine the kinetics of this process, it is clear t h a t the retraction motion first takes place at the ends of the chain (with short modes) and diffuses towards the centre. The r e l a x a t i o n is thus predicted to be non-uniform along the chain. However, at the end of the retraction process, and a s s u m i n g t h a t no other process has started, the orientation is constant along the chain a n d a g a i n independent of the position of the segment. It has been shown by Doi [11] t h a t on the time scale of XB contour length f l u c t u a t i o n s m a y induce a rapid r e l a x a t i o n of chain ends, especially for m o d e r a t e l y long chains. Indeed, wiggling motions involve f o r w a r d a n d b a c k w a r d motions of the chain ends. Thus, chain l e n g t h f l u c t u a t i o n s in oriented materials lead to the creation of isotropie p a r t s of tubes at each end. Their fractional length is roughly equal to 1.3(N/Ne)-I/2, where N is the n u m b e r of monomers per chain. An elaborate expression for the relaxation due to this mechanism, based on the Pearson-Helfand picture for s t a r polymers [12], has been proposed by Viovy [ 13]. The next relaxation stage (C) corresponds to the r e p t a t i o n process itself where the chain relaxes towards an equilibrium isotropie configuration. The corresponding r e l a x a t i o n time scales as the third power of the n u m b e r of e n t a n g l e m e n t s per chain, and thus as the third power of the molecular weight. During this process, chain segments are assumed to lose t h e i r orientation as they leave the original tube, which induces a faster relaxation of chain ends. This model involves only one adjustable relaxation time, XA, for instance, since the others are linked by the following sealing laws :
43 1:B = 2 (N/Ne)2 1:A
(4)
xC = 3 (N/N e) 1:B
(5)
4.2. Star polymers Following a step strain, the first relaxation motions of these polymers are almost identical to those of linear chains. Namely, a star polymer is a s s u m e d to relax locally by a type A process and a retraction of its stretched a r m s (B process). However, it has been shown that the reptative motion of linear chains is quenched by branching [14]. The relaxation is supposed to involve, via large scale fluctuations, the "pushing back" of the end of an a r m close to the branch point. The orientation, like the stress, is proportional to the portion of the tube still unvisited by a chain end. The relaxation time associated with these largescale b r e a t h i n g modes is given by :
Tm= q:A/Narm/3/2 exp(v Narm/Ne) (6) ~V Ne/ where Narm/N e is the n u m b e r of e n t a n g l e m e n t s per a r m and v a n u m e r i c a l constant of the order of 0.6 [14]. Expressions for the kinetics of this large-scale fluctuation process have been given in the l i t e r a t u r e [12,13,15] a n d allow calculation of the relaxation as a function of the position of a segment along the arm. Q u a l i t a t i v e l y , a strongly delayed relaxation a r o u n d the b r a n c h point compared to linear chains is predicted due to the exponential dependence of the relaxation time on the length of an arm. For both linear and s t a r polymers, the above-described theories a s s u m e the motion of a single molecule in a frozen system. In polymers melts, it has been shown, essentially from the study of binary blends, t h a t a self-consistent t r e a t m e n t of the relaxation is required. This leads to the concepts of "constraint release" w h e r e b y a loss of segmental orientation is permitted by the motion of s u r r o u n d i n g species. R e t r a c t i o n (for linear and s t a r polymers) as well as reptation m a y induce constraint release [16,17,18]. In the homopolymer case, the m a i n effect is to decrease the relaxation times by roughly a factor of 1.5 (XB) or 2 (xC)- In the case of star polymers, the factor v is also decreased [15]. These effects are extensively discussed in other chapters of this book especially for binary mixtures. In our work, we have assumed t h a t their influence would be of second order compared to the relaxation processes themselves. However, they m a y contribute to an unexpected relaxation of p a r t s of macromolecules which are a s s u m e d not to be reached by relaxation motions (central p a r t s of linear chains or b r a n c h point in s t a r polymers). 4~3. B i n a r y b l e n d s The theory of the relaxation of binary blends is mainly limited to the linear regime and devoted to mixtures of long and short chains, both species being sufficiently long enough to be entangled [19,20,21]. Another case corresponds to long e n t a n g l e d polymer chains diluted with shorter ones with m o l e c u l a r weights c o m p a r a b l e to the e n t a n g l e m e n t molecular weight. It is u s u a l l y a d m i t t e d t h a t u n e n t a n g l e d s h o r t chains m a i n l y act as d i l u e n t species, reducing the n u m b e r of e n t a n g l e m e n t s per unit volume and i n c r e a s i n g the a v e r a g e m o l e c u l a r w e i g h t b e t w e e n them. These conjectures h a v e been
44 successfully t e s t e d e x p e r i m e n t a l l y in the linear viscoelastic d o m a i n [22]. However, rheological m e a s u r e m e n t s , in the linear as well as in the nonlinear regime, only give information on the overall behaviour of the material. A better i n s i g h t into the r e l a x a t i o n m e c h a n i s m s of individual molecules is a g a i n obtained through spectroscopic techniques [23,24]. For instance, the individual r e l a x a t i o n of long a n d s h o r t chains in a b i n a r y blend, in s h e a r step experiments, has been followed by infrared dichroism using d e u t e r a t e d species [24,25]. These e x p e r i m e n t s have shown t h a t constraint release t h e o r y could qualitatively predict the behavior of long chains, but t h a t the relaxation of short chains was retarded. Diffusion experiments on isotropic samples, on the other hand, had shown t h a t the diffusion coefficient of short chains was i n d e p e n d e n t of the molecular weight of the matrix [26]. It has therefore been suggested t h a t intermolecular orientational coupling between the relaxing species could take place leading to a residual orientation of short chains even at t i m e s m u c h longer t h a n their individual relaxation times. The aim of our study on binary mixtures was twofold : - checking, u s i n g i n f r a r e d dichroism the existence of o r i e n t a t i o n a l coupling which h a d been observed by a n o t h e r spectroscopic t e c h n i q u e (fluorescence polarization) [27] - investigating the influence of short chains, with length c o m p a r a b l e to the e n t a n g l e m e n t length, on the relaxation of the long chains. 5. Results a n d d i s c u s s i o n o n isotopically labeled c h a i n s 5.1. I n f l u e n c e o f t h e p o s i t i o n o f t h e s e g m e n t We compare the orientational relaxation of central d e u t e r a t e d p a r t of the PS H D H 188 copolymer with t h a t of the end part of the PS DH 184 copolymer. Both types of chains have almost the same molecular w e i g h t as well as d e u t e r a t e d blocks of comparable length. The master curves of the orientationa] relaxation a v e r a g e (calculated as the weight a v e r a g e of t h e m e a s u r e d orientation of each block) can be superimposed as shown in Figure 1. 0,3
^
L,,n,,
[
0,2
~,,
,,
....
, ....
, ....
j
9
I
1
[] o
o
v
.
0.1
a
[] Q .J
9
~ -1
0
1
2
vlo _
3
,
i ,
4
- log ~ aT
Figure 1. Relaxation of average orientation of PS DH 184 (e) and PS HDH 188 (~q) at a reference temperature of 120~
45 The comparison between the relaxation of the deuterated end block of the PS DH 184 and t h a t of the central block of the PS HDH 188 is shown in Figure 2. The non-uniformity of the relaxation along the chain is clearly apparent. More precisely, whereas at short times (- log ~aT < 1) the orientation of both species is quite similar, the relaxation of the central p a r t is clearly slower than t h a t of the end block at longer times. 0,3
'
'
-~ ,.o
A
'
'
I
'
'
'
'
1
'
'
'
'
I
'
'
~
'
I
'
'
'
'
9
0,2
.
o
-
0,1
V "" . . ~ . . U
. . . .
-1
I
....
. . . .
I
0
~
1
,
,
~'~
,~.i
. . . .
2 3 4 aT Figure_2. Relaxation of the end block of PS DH 184 (e) compared to t h a t of the central block of PS HDH 188 (o) o
- log
e
The orientation of the central block shows a plateau in an i n t e r m e d i a t e time scale. It can also be noted t h a t at very short times, the orientation of the end part is slightly below t h a t of the central block. This effect can be accounted for by the fact that, during the deformation process, no topological constraint is acting at the end of the chain to orient it. This behaviour is similar to dangling chains in elastomeric networks [28]. 0,3
. . . .
a
I
'
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
'
I
. . . .
I
'
'
'
'
m
~= 0,2 A r o r
0,1 2~..
tX
v ,
-1
,
,
0
1 - log
2
3
"',",-~--" 4
~: a T
Figure 3. Comparison between the relaxation of the short end block of PS DH 184 (o) and that of the long end block of PS HDH 188 (~) The influence of the length of the end part on its relaxation is depicted in Figure 3 where the r e l a x a t i o n of an end p a r t of molecular weight 27000 is
46 c o m p a r e d to t h a t of a n end p a r t of m o l e c u l a r weight 78000 for a n i d e n t i c a l overall c h a i n l e n g t h . The longer t h e e n d part, t h e slower t h e r e l a x a t i o n (especially a t long times). 52.~ I n f l u e n e e of t h e l e x ~ h of t h e c h a i n D a t a o b t a i n e d on t h e PS D H D 500 triblock copolymer can be u s e d to compare t h e relaxation of a n end block of molecular w e i g h t 27000 w i t h t h a t of a n end block of molecular weight 39000 but located on a chain roughly 2.5 t i m e s longer. The r e s u l t s are given in Figure 4 w h e r e it a p p e a r s t h a t t h e longer t h e overall chain, the slower the relaxation of the end block a t long times. 0~3
A
. . . .
I
. . . .
I
. . . .
I
. . . .
I
. . . .
O "9176
0,2
O v
0,1
"~'. ."'""
, ,
0
I
"..... o:..:...a_~
2 - log
3
:i 4
~: a T
Figure 4. Comparison between the relaxation of the end block of PS DH 184 (~) and t h a t of PS DHD 500 (o) 5.3. D i s c u s s i o n Previous studies dealing with the influence of the molecular w e i g h t on t h e o r i e n t a t i o n a l r e l a x a t i o n a v e r a g e h a v e shown t h a t the o r i e n t a t i o n r e l a x a t i o n m a s t e r curves could be divided in two parts [7]. At short times (for - log ~a T < 1) the r e l a x a t i o n is i n d e p e n d e n t of the molecular weight w h e r e a s at longer t i m e s t h e r e l a x a t i o n is slowed down as t h e m o l e c u l a r w e i g h t i n c r e a s e s . T h i s q u a l i t a t i v e a g r e e m e n t with the predictions of the Doi-Edwards model led to the conclusion t h a t the first s t a g e s of the r e l a x a t i o n m e a s u r e d e x p e r i m e n t a l l y correspond to the A process, for which a strong increase in orientation a t short t i m e s a n d a molecular weight i n d e p e n d e n c e are expected. A fitting procedure w i t h the theoretical predictions w a s used to determine t h e relaxation t i m e ~A, giving ~A = 5.6 s at 120~ In order to d i s c r i m i n a t e b e t w e e n s u b s e q u e n t r e l a x a t i o n processes, it is n e c e s s a r y to calculate the orientational relaxation as a function of the location of a s e g m e n t along the chain and to compare the results of such predictions to e x p e r i m e n t a l d a t a . T h e o r e t i c a l e x p r e s s i o n s are given e l s e w h e r e [29] a n d reference should be m a d e for f u r t h e r details. In this work, the more e l a b o r a t e t r e a t m e n t of the chain fluctuation process h a s been used and equations used in t h e calculation of o r i e n t a t i o n h a v e been extracted from reference [13]. T h e
47
various r e l a x a t i o n t i m e s involved in t h e t h e o r e t i c a l calculations h a v e been related to 1:B using the theoretical prefactors and scaling laws. In order to avoid t h e use of a d j u s t a b l e p a r a m e t e r s on r e s c a l i n g t h e theoretical w i t h the e x p e r i m e n t a l orientation, a n d since we were i n t e r e s t e d in differences in the r e l a x a t i o n kinetics, we chose to s t u d y the o r i e n t a t i o n of the different blocks n o r m a l i z e d by t h e a v e r a g e o r i e n t a t i o n , as a f u n c t i o n of r e l a x a t i o n time. The r e l a x a t i o n t i m e s h a v e b e e n a d i m e n s i o n a l i z e d by t h e r e t r a c t i o n time, XB, which can be d e t e r m i n e d e x p e r i m e n t a l l y by a p p l y i n g t h e theoretical scaling law (see section 4.1). The influence of v a r i o u s r e l a x a t i o n processes ( r e t r a c t i o n alone, r e p t a t i o n alone, chain-length fluctuation alone) on the relative relaxation of a n end-block of size equal to t h a t of PS D H 184 is compared to e x p e r i m e n t a l d a t a in Figure 5. It can be seen t h a t none of these processes alone can account for t h e observed behavior.
~0 ;>
0,8 0,6
r
0,4
-
X
-_
~9 c,4
0,2
.... I .... I, -4
-3
-2
~ -1
~ 0
" ---1
2
log t / xB Figure 5. Influence of various r e l a x a t i o n processes on the relative orientation of chain ends ; ( ...... ) " r e t r a c t i o n ; ( - - ) " chain l e n g t h fluctuation ; (. . . . )" reptation alone; (~) 9e x p e r i m e n t a l d a t a of PS DH 184 w i t h e s t i m a t e d error bars. The d a t a agree with the almost fiat relaxation at short times and show the i m p o r t a n c e of the c h a i n r e l a x a t i o n process t a k e n into account b u t clearly disagree at longer times. B e t t e r a g r e e m e n t is obtained if the t h r e e r e l a x a t i o n processes are considered s i m u l t a n e o u s l y , as shown in Figure 6. Figures 7 and 8 shows the s a m e predictions applied to the case of the PS DHD 500 and PS H D H 188 copolymers. Again, a g r e e m e n t at s h o r t t i m e s is reasonable w h e r e a s at longer times, the relative orientation of the end block is underestimated.
48
. . . .
I ' ' ' ~ 1
. . . .
I
. . . .
I
. . . .
I
. . . .
0,8 r
0,6 r
0,4 r r
0,2
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
logt/z a Figure 6. Relative relaxation of a chain-end in PS DH 184 (o) with e s t i m a t e d error bars, compared to the prediction of fluctuation, retraction and reptation processes.
0,8
....
I ....
I ....
J ....
I ....
I ....
i ....
1
r ;>
=
0,6
~q
-~
0,4
0
-- . . . .
-5
:
-4
. . . .
I
-3
. . . .
I
-2
. . . .
I
-1
,
_
0
1
2
log t / xe Figure 7. Relative relaxation of chain-end of PS D H D 500 ( 0 ) w i t h e s t i m a t e d error bars compared to the prediction of fluctuation, retraction and reptation processes. T h e s e results, as compared to a previous study [29], illustrate a better a g r e e m e n t b e t w e e n theory and experiments. This can be attributed to a better a p p r o x i m a t i o n of the mode d i s t r i b u t i o n i n v o l v e d in the chain f l u c t u a t i o n process and to which the end of the chains are quite sensitive. T h e s e data also prove t h a t u n d e r our e x p e r i m e n t a l conditions, the relaxation of the chain is d o m i n a t e d by the chain retraction and c h a i n - l e n g t h fluctuation process. The
49 influence of reptation is very weak and only the first modes contribute to the relaxation of chain ends.
1,2 ~9 ~0 ;>
0,8
c,t
0,6 ~9
0,4
eq
0,2
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
log t / gB Figure 8. Relative relaxation of chain end of PS HDH 188 (~) with estimated error bars compared to the prediction of fluctuation, retraction and reptation processes. These experimental results which validate the basic processes of the Doi and Edwards model are in agreement with findings of Ylitalo et al. [30] who have been able to draw the same conclusions in step-shear flow experiments. Relaxation of a centrally deuterated chain in a high molecular weight matrix has led to the same conclusions [31]. However, other a t t e m p t s have not been able to distinguish between the relaxation of different parts of chains [32,33]. Discrepancy between the results of the various experiments m a y be partly due to a different contrast between the relative length of the blocks. Clearly, most discriminating results are obtained w h e n the investigated blocks are r a t h e r small, as it is particularly apparent in ref 30. 6. R e s u l t s a n d d i s c u s s i o n on isotopically l a b e l l e d 6-arm stars
In this section, we will compare results obtained on isotopically labelled p o l y s t y r e n e stars with those of the l i n e a r copolymer. With r e g a r d to the characteristics of the star, we may regard the linear polystyrene of molecular weight 180 k as having roughly the length of one arm (PS DH 184), the linear polystyrene of Mw = 500 k as having roughly the lengths of two arms (PS DHD 500) and a pure homopolymer of molecular weight 1.19 106 g/mol as having roughly the same molecular weight as the overall star (PS 1190). Inside a star, we m a y differentiate between the segments at the branch point (deuterated monomers located close to the branch point in star b), those of the end of an arm (deuterated monomers located at the ends of the arms of star b), and those of the long central block of star-a (hydrogenated monomers of star-a).
50 The results are reported as a function of t/x A since xA is independent of the molecular weight a n d n a t u r e (linear or s t a r shaped) of the polymer. This avoids the a r b i t r a r y choice of a reference temperature of various part~ of a star The orientational relaxation of various parts of the s t a r is depicted in Figure 9. Segments close to the branch point appear initially more oriented t h a n those of the central block. The end part of an a r m is clearly less oriented at short times. As relaxation proceeds, no difference can be made between the r e l a x a t i o n of the b r a n c h point and of the central block. The end block nevertheless relaxes faster. 6.1. O r i e n t a t i o n
6.2. C o m p a r i s o n b e t w e e n ~ a n d linear c h a i n s The average orientation of the 6-arm star is compared to t h a t of linear chains PS DH 184, PS DHD 500 and PS 1190 in Figure 10. It seems quite clear t h a t the short-time behaviour is almost the same in linear and star materials, i n d e p e n d e n t l y of the molecular weight. In contrast, the relaxation of the star, at longer times, is intermediate between t h a t of the linear chain PS DHD 500 and t h a t of PS 1190. It is therefore more rapid than t h a t of a linear chain of the same overall molecular weight but slower t h a n that of an unbranched chain of the same length (PS DHD 500). This suggests that long relaxation times are increased or even suppressed by branching.
0,2 e, 9 "',0
0,15
9
,
A O
0,1
~9
(D.
r
V
0,05
~
""O... ,
,-1
-0,5
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
3
log t/XA Figure 9. Relaxation of various parts of a star" branch point (o), central block (o) and chain end (~) In order to test whether the chain ends or the central part are responsible for this behaviour, the orientation of both blocks has been compared to t h a t of l i n e a r chains. The r e l a x a t i o n of chains ends in the s t a r polymer and in copolymers PS DH 184 and PS DHD 500 is compared in Figure 11. The short time orientation is similar for the 3 materials, but the end of an arm relaxes slower t h a n t h a t of the PS DHD 500 copolymer although the involvec( length is
51 slightly lower and the length of the arm also lower t h a n the half of the linear chain.
0,2
. . . .
I
. . . .
I
. . . .
I
. . . .
1
. . . .
x
0,15
:,
\
A r 9 r
0,1
n ~
m--j
r
V
~ . _ X x
0,05
9.
9 X
"'n.
-. . . . . . . . . X X .
X
-
9 g
-1
0
1
2 log t/~g
3
4
Figure 10. Comparison between the relaxation of average orientation of a star (x), PS DH 184 (o), PS DHD 500 (O) and PS 1190 (m) As far as the orientation of the central block is concerned, a slower relaxation is also observed for the star as shown in Figure 12. At long times, the central block of the star remains more oriented t h a n t h a t of the linear chain. The differences are significant and cannot be explained by simple differences between length of chains and blocks. This effect must therefore be a t t r i b u t e d to the "pinning" effect of the centre of the chain and s u b s e q u e n t suppression of the reptation motion. 0,2
/k
0,15 ~ ~
(2:) 9 r
V
0,1
,.,
-,
0,05
-~ I -1
0
1
2
3
4
log t/xA Figure 11. Relaxation of chain ends ofPS DH 184 (~1), PS DHD 500 (O), Star (0)
52
0 , 2
,
,
,
,
i
,
,
,
,
i
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
I
,
f~,
,
,
_
_ 9
-
0,15
-
A o
,
O 0,1
V
o,o5
9
I
-
o
L -1
' 0
1
2
--,,. 3
4
log t/xA Figure 12. Comparison between the relaxation of the central block (o) of the PS DHD 500 and of the central block of star (~) 6.3. Discussion
Before going into a detailed comparison of experiments with theoretical predictions, the main points of this study may be emphazised. The relaxation of the star is intermediate between t h a t of the PS DHD 500 and PS 1190 polymers. In this range of molecular weights, the viscosity and the t e r m i n a l relaxation times are highest for the star. This indicates t h a t under our e x p e r i m e n t a l conditions, the r e l a x a t i o n is not d o m i n a t e d by the d i s e n g a g e m e n t of the branches. However, the effect of pinning the centre of the chain is clear from the slower relaxation of the s t a r (or central block) as c o m p a r e d to the PS DHD 500 copolymer. The last point deals with the surprisingly higher orientation of the ends of the arms. Since the length of this p a r t of the arm is on the order of one tenth of the length of an arm, we expect a quite rapid relaxation, at least at much shorter times t h a n the arm fluctuation time. The strong orientation observed might be qualitatively interpreted as an effect of an orientational coupling with surrounding segments. The difference between s t a r and linear species would be due to a higher average orientation in the star as seen in Figure 10. As far as the fluctuation dynamics of an end-attached chain is concerned, a characteristic length is defined as the size of the t h e r m a l fluctuation of the tube which is given by : Leq (7) Xeq = # 2 v Narm/N e w h e r e N a r m / N e is the n u m b e r of e n t a n g l e m e n t s per arm and Leq is the equilibrium contour length of an arm, simply given by Leq = d Narm/Ne, d being the average contour length between entanglements. The associated relaxation time, ~eq, is given by :
53 d2 (Narm/Ne)2 2vkT
T,eq =
(8)
being t h e a v e r a g e friction coefficient a c t i n g on the d i s t a n c e d (~ = N e ~0)- T h e r e l a x a t i o n t i m e a s s o c i a t e d w i t h the complete r e l a x a t i o n of a n a r m is r e l a t e d to l:eq by "
~eq(
ll~ }112 exp(V Narm/Ne) (9) V Narm/Ne All t h e s e r e l a x a t i o n t i m e s can be e x p r e s s e d as a f u n c t i o n of t h e local r e l a x a t i o n t i m e ~A. S e h e m a t i e a l l y , at a n y t i m e following t h e s t e p d e f o r m a t i o n process, t h e s t r e s s is a s s u m e d to be r e l e a s e d only on t h e l e n g t h of a n a r m t h a t h a s been visited by a fluctuation. A r a p i d r e l a x a t i o n of c h a i n s e n d s is e x p e c t e d on t h e t i m e scale of Zeq for d i s t a n c e s s m a l l e r t h a n Xeq a n d t h e d y n a m i c s proposed by Viovy [13] c a n be u s e d as for l i n e a r chains. A t l o n g e r t i m e s , t h e fraction {(t) of a n a r m w h i c h h a s been r e l a x e d by a f l u c t u a t i o n c a n be c o m p u t e d as the solution of t h e following e q u a t i o n " Tm ----
t=
!
l:eq (v Na~m/Ne)nI/2 1__~exp(VNarm~Z/Ne)
(10)
a n d the s t r e s s is p r o p o r t i o n a l to (1 - ~(t)) for t i m e s such as Xeq < t < Xm 9Since our e x p e r i m e n t a l conditions correspond to r e l a x a t i o n t i m e s on t h e order of Zeq, t h e a p p r o x i m a t e e x p r e s s i o n for t h e r e l a x a t i o n at t i m e s l o n g e r t h a n Xm h a s not b e e n considered.
1,2
,
,
l
I
m l m m dmNlm m l ' I m m
'
mm m
'
'
~
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
J
)
...........................................
'
'
'
9
0,8 co ~9 0
0,6
["
0,2
.,..~
0 ,4
i
i
I
-02
, J , I , ~ , I , , , I .... -4
-2
0
2
I , , 4
6
8
log t / Z B F i g u r e 13. Theoretical orientation of various p a r t s of a s t a r : ( - - - ) end of a r m , ( ) a v e r a g e , ( ....... ) b r a n c h p o i n t a s s u m i n g r e l a x a t i o n by a r m fluctuation alone (light lines) or combined with r e t r a c t i o n (heavy lines).
54 It is thus possible to compute the relaxation of different p a r t s of the stars using this fluctuation process alone or combined with the retraction process. As an illustration, the orientational relaxation of a short end-block (like in stara) is compared to the average orientation and to the orientation of the branch point (like in star-b) in Figure 13. Since relevant relaxation processes occur on the time scale of XB, theoretical curves are presented with t/x B as abscissa. Although a very large difference can be expected if only the fluctuation process is t a k e n into account, the retraction of the arms increases significantly the overall relaxation and tends to induce less-differentiated behaviours. As far as q u a n t i t a t i v e c o m p a r i s o n with t h e e x p e r i m e n t a l d a t a is concerned, we decided to compare directly the e x p e r i m e n t a l l y d e t e r m i n e d orientation with the theoretical prediction. This requires a rescaling of the theoretical orientation in order to match it with the experimental data at times of the order of XA. A satisfactory a g r e e m e n t for the average orientation is observed as shown in Figure 14.
1,2 - , , , , ,
. . . .
I
. . . .
I ' ' ' ' 1 ' ' ' ' 1 ' ' ' "
1 r
"~ ~9
0,8
>
0,6
a,
0,4
[]
0,2 -4
-3
-2
-1 0 log t / x B
1
Figure 14. Comparison between the experimental rescaled average orientation of a star (~) with theoretical predictions (full line). Using the same rescaling, the orientation of the short end-block and of the central block of the s t a r can be compared with theoretical predictions as shown in Figures 15 and 16. This quantitative comparison between the theoretical and experimental relaxation of star polymers shows t h a t the main observations can be accounted for by the combination of the arm fluctuation and a r m retraction processes. A reasonable order of m a g n i t u d e of the orientation of chain ends can be theoretically predicted. However, the relaxation of the branch point is significantly more rapid t h a n predicted theoretically. This discrepancy m i g h t be a t t r i b u t e d to constraint-release processes which tend to relax the b r a n c h point of the star. The influence of the latter processes is more easily observed on the branch point where the relaxation should appear at longer times.
55
I
. . . .
I
'
"''
'
I
. . . .
0,8
0,6 =
0,4
q:~
0,2
[]
L 0 .
. . . . .
-4
,
. . . .
,
-3
. . . .
-2
, , .
.
.
.
.
.
.
-1 0 log t / ~B
.
.
1
2
Figure 15. Comparison between theoretical (full line) and experimental (el) relaxation of chain ends of star-a.
1,2
~
....
-,-,,
,D
,,,
,,1
0,8
....
, ....
i ....
~Ez
0,6 =
~
0,4
0,2 0
. . . .
-z
!
-3
. . . .
I
-2
,
~
~,,
I
-1 log t /
,
,
,
,
[
0
~
,
,
,
I
1
. . . .
2
"tB
Figure 16. Comparison between theoretical (full line) and experimental (a) relaxation of the branch point of star-b.
7. R e s u l t s a n d d i s c u s s i o n o n b i n a r y b l e n d s o f l o n g a n d s h o r t c h a i n s B i n a r y blends composed of d e u t e r a t e d short chains and of e n t a n g l e d h y d r o g e n a t e d long polystyrene chains have been investigated. The relaxational b e h a v i o u r of the s h o r t chains h a s been a n a l y s e d as a f u n c t i o n of t h e i r molecular weight. Additionally, a t t e n t i o n has been focussed on the role of the short chain concentration on the orientational relaxation of the long chains. F i g u r e 17 shows m a s t e r curves of the orientational r e l a x a t i o n of s h o r t d e u t e r a t e d chains of various molecular weights present at 20 wt.-% in a m a t r i x of molecular weight 2x106 g/mol (PS 2000). The m a s t e r curves have been d r a w n at a reference t e m p e r a t u r e of Tg + 9 ~ using t i m e - t e m p e r a t u r e superposition.
56 This choice relies on t h e a s s u m p t i o n t h a t a c o n s t a n t T g + T c o r r e s p o n d s to a c o n s t a n t free volume s t a t e . S u c h a n a p p r o x i m a t i o n p r e s u m e s t h a t the t h e r m a l e x p a n s i o n of free volume, af, as well as the fractional free volume, fg, at Tg, a r e i n d e p e n d e n t of t h e b l e n d composition. In t h e case of b i n a r y b l e n d s w i t h s h o r t chains, xA m a y d e p e n d on t h e composition of the blend, so t h a t a n o r m a l i s a t i o n of e x p e r i m e n t a l t i m e s w i t h t h i s p a r a m e t e r would be m i s l e a d i n g .
0.20
'"'',
....
u....
1 ....
I ....
I''''J
....
? 0.15
/b
A
O
\
~
r
\
xo
\
0.10
C)
~
.
%
r
0 \
\ o\
9
V
0.05
-
. ,~ ~ \ .,o~ ,-I. 9
0.00
,.,t -1
.... 0
~5-~ ----- 9 o- " * - " - - :c~ . o. _ o - o r - ~,b ~ ,,o,,, .... , ..... , .......... 1 2 3 4 5 log t (Tg+9~
.
TM-
6
F i g u r e 17. O r i e n t a t i o n a l r e l a x a t i o n of the s h o r t d e u t e r a t e d chains PSD72 (o), P S D 2 7 (O), PSD18 (i), PSD10 (~) a n d PSD3 (#), b l e n d e d a t 20 wt.-% with PS2000. While the o r i e n t a t i o n of t h e s e d e u t e r a t e d c h a i n s shows a s t r o n g m o l e c u l a r w e i g h t d e p e n d e n c e e s p e c i a l l y a t s h o r t t i m e s , all c h a i n s e x h i b i t a r e l a t i v e l y c o n s t a n t r e s i d u a l o r i e n t a t i o n a t long times. E v e n c h a i n s of m o l e c u l a r w e i g h t as low as 3000 p r e s e n t a n o n - z e r o local o r i e n t a t i o n . T h i s w a s c o n f i r m e d by p o l a r i s a t i o n m o d u l a t i o n i n f r a r e d d i c h r o i s m - a t e c h n i q u e s e n s i t i v e to v e r y small a n i s o t r o p i e s [34]. T h e s h o r t c h a i n s w i t h M < M e can be c o n s i d e r e d as b e h a v i n g like Rouse chains w i t h r e l a x a t i o n t i m e s on t h e order of the e x p e r i m e n t a l time-scale. F o r example, t h e Rouse t i m e s of P S D 3 a n d of P S D 1 0 a r e a p p r o x i m a t e l y 9s a n d 19s seconds, respectively at 115~ [35,36]. C o n s e q u e n t l y , t h e r e s i d u a l o r i e n t a t i o n at long t i m e s for t h e s e c h a i n s c a n be a t t r i b u t e d to o r i e n t a t i o n a l c o u p l i n g i n t e r a c t i o n s w i t h the long c h a i n s of t h e p o l y m e r m a t r i x . S i m i l a r o r i e n t a t i o n a l correlations h a v e b e e n o b s e r v e d on v a r i o u s s y s t e m s by 1H N M R s p e c t r o s c o p y s t u d i e s of s t r e t c h e d e l a s t o m e r s w h e r e even dissolved s o l v e n t m o l e c u l e s a n d free c h a i n s w e r e s h o w n to p o s s e s s a very s h o r t - l e n g t h scale local o r i e n t a t i o n [37]. T h e coupling coefficient, E, proposed by Doi e t al. [38] h a s been e x t r a c t e d from t h e o r i e n t a t i o n d a t a , y i e l d i n g a v a l u e of c a . 0.26 [36]. H o w e v e r , t h e u n c e r t a i n t y in the o r i e n t a t i o n m e a s u r e m e n t s at long t i m e s does not allow t h e
57
d e t e r m i n a t i o n of a molecular weight dependence of E, as observed by Ylitalo et al. [39] in a study of polybudadiene b i n a r y blends.
T h e cooperative n a t u r e of the o r i e n t a t i o n a l r e l a x a t i o n in a s y m m e t r i c b i n a r y blends has been f u r t h e r investigated t h r o u g h the analysis of the effect of the s h o r t chain concentration, for a given short chain length, Mw = 10 000. M a s t e r curves of the o r i e n t a t i o n a l r e l a x a t i o n of the long c h a i n s a r e p r e s e n t e d in F i g u r e 18. The long c h a i n r e l a x a t i o n in the p u r e p o l y m e r is c o m p a r e d to t h a t in the blends which c o n t a i n i n c r e a s i n g c o n c e n t r a t i o n s of s h o r t chains.
0.30
. . . .
I " " ' ' 1
. . . .
I ' ' ' ' 1 ' ' ' ' 1
. . . .
I . . . . _
O \
^
0.20
-
r
VS. OX
~
o
v
0.10
-
\
_
_ o',~,,o o
'~"
-
"otb " O ~ 9 m--.
0.00
.... -1
I .... 0
o o ~
0--10 ~ 0
.
~-a-
Dq~- O
I .... ~.... I .... i .... I .... 1 2 3 4 5 6
log t (Tg+9~ F i g u r e 18. M a s t e r curves of the orientational relaxation of t h e long chains, at Tg+9~ for PS2000 (m), PS2000/PSD10(20 wt.-%) (o) and PS2000/PSD10(30 wt.-%) (o). In a d d i t i o n to t h e u s u a l c h a r a c t e r i s t i c r a p i d decrease in o r i e n t a t i o n at short t i m e s before reaching a p l a t e a u at long times, a decrease in orientation is observed as the concentration of short PSD10 chains increases to 30%. Such a high concentration of short chains is required to affect notably the relaxation of the long species. Indeed, Figure 19 shows a negligible difference b e t w e e n PS 2000 a n d blends containing 20 wt.-% of short chains, even of very low molecular weights. O n e c o n v e n i e n t s t r a t e g y to i n t e r p r e t t h e s e r e s u l t s is to r e v i e w t h e m o l e c u l a r c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s of b i n a r y b l e n d s as e x t r a c t e d from p o l y m e r m e l t rheology [40]. The influence of short chains (M < M e) is to effectively decrease the p l a t e a u m o d u l u s and the t e r m i n a l r e l a x a t i o n times as c o m p a r e d to the p u r e p o l y m e r . C o n s e q u e n t l y , the m o l e c u l a r w e i g h t b e t w e e n e n t a n g l e m e n t s 0
0
which is related to G N by G N - pRT/Me is increased. The short chains, in other words, cause a typical diluent effect a n d t h u s the " t e m p o r a r y e n t a n g l e m e n t n e t w o r k " is looser. Therefore, a lower o r i e n t a t i o n of long chains is expected.
58 However, an i n c r e a s e in M e also implies an increase in I:A, as given by equation (3) and, therefore, the relaxation kinetics should be slower.
0.30
^
0.20
~~
0 e,i
a, V
~
9
9
0.10
o o 5"-.~
0.00 -1
0
l
2
3
4
5
6
log t (Tg+9~ Figure 19. M a s t e r curves of the orientational relaxation of the long chains at T= Tg+ 9 ~ PS2000 (0), PS2000/PSD18(20 wt.-%) (o) and PS2000/PSD3(20 wt.-%) (0). Besides Me, the relaxation time XA is proportional to a monomeric friction coefficient, ~0. This p a r a m e t e r , w h i c h describes the frictional d r a g per m o n o m e r unit as it moves t h r o u g h its environment, depends on t e m p e r a t u r e , p r e s s u r e and molecular weight (for low molecular weights) [8]. Rheological studies of the u n d i l u t e d p o l y m e r (PS2000) and the blend (PS2000/PS10) containing 30 wt.-% short chains have confirmed a decrease in the plateau modulus with the addition of the short chains. M a s t e r curves of the storage G'(co) a n d loss G"(co) moduli of the pure polymer a n d the blend are p r e s e n t e d in F i g u r e 20. The moduli were m e a s u r e d at t e m p e r a t u r e s r a n g i n g from Tg + 100 to Tg + 30~ and data were reduced to a reference t e m p e r a t u r e of 165~ The horizontal shift factors, aT, were used to e v a l u a t e the W L F coefficients C1 a n d C2 [8]. No a p p a r e n t v a r i a t i o n in the product C1C2 was detected on dilution with the short chains. In fact, an average product of 650 + 30 was obtained for both the p u r e p o l y m e r and the blend, consistent with various other reported values [41,42]. A p a r t from a reduction in the w i d t h of the p l a t e a u region and a lower plateau modulus , (G~N blend = 0.5 G 0N pure polymer), the blend exhibits a shift in the G'/G" crossover m o d u l u s a n d f r e q u e n c y in the t r a n s i t i o n zone. G oN corresponds to the value of G'(co) at the m i n i m u m of tan 5 = G"(c0)/G'(o~).
59
106
105
f
lO 4
103
........' ........i ........l ........, ........, ........l ......... ........i ........I 10.4 10-2 100 102 104 T
Figure 20. M a s t e r curves of G'(o)) (heavy lines), G"(co) at T = 165~ for PS2000 (full lines) and PS2000/PS10(30 wt.-%) (dotted lines). Due to difficulties in m e a s u r i n g the z e r o - s h e a r viscosity of such high m o l e c u l a r w e i g h t p o l y m e r s , a n d t h u s d e d u c i n g t h e m o n o m e r i c friction coefficient from G r a e s s l e y ' s ' u n c o r r e l a t e d d r a g model' [43], the following equation a d a p t e d from the modified Rouse theory has been applied [8]. G'(o~) = G"(oJ)= (appNA/4Mo)(~kBT/3)Y2o) 1/2
(11)
In e q u a t i o n 11 "ap" is a characteristic length (taken to be 7.4 .s [8]), p the d e n s i t y , NA Avogadro's n u m b e r , Mo the m o n o m e r m o l e c u l a r weight, k B B o l t z m a n n ' s c o n s t a n t , T the a b s o l u t e t e m p e r a t u r e a n d co the a n g u l a r frequency. Although this equation is based on the b e h a v i o u r of low molecular weight, u n e n t a n g l e d polymers, only the difference, r a t h e r t h a n the absolute v a l u e of friction coefficients b e t w e e n the pure p o l y m e r and the blend, is significant. F u r t h e r m o r e , the value of ~o e x t r a c t e d for the pure polymer is c o m p a r a b l e w i t h t h a t d e t e r m i n e d by e n t i r e l y i n d e p e n d e n t e s t i m a t e s from forward-recoil spectroscopy m e a s u r e m e n t s [44]. The r e s u l t s have indicated t h a t the monomeric friction coefficient is s e n s i t i v e to the p r e s e n c e of the short chains, and is smaller, at a given t e m p e r a t u r e , t h a n the homopolymer. This observed reduction in ~o h a s been shown to be only a t t r i b u t e d to an increase in the fractional free volume. Indeed, the t e m p e r a t u r e dependence of the monomeric friction coefficient is described by a WLF-type equation : lo ~~W)._ =- CI(T-To) ~To C2 + (T-To) This equation can be rewritten as :
(12)
60 CzC2 _ log~o(T) - C g + 12.303 fw log~o(T) = log~o(Tg)- Cg + (T-T=)-
(13)
where T~ = Tg-C~ is the Vogel t e m p e r a t u r e , t h a t is, the t e m p e r a t u r e at which the free volume vanishes. As mentioned above, the product C1C2 is the same for both samples. Consequently, plots of log ~0 as a function of 1/(T-T~) present identical slopes for the homopolymer a n d the blends. In fact, as shown in F i g u r e 21, not only are the slopes the same, but the intercept does not vary. Thus, the change in log ~0 upon dilution with shorter chains is only controlled by T~. A further step in the analysis of the orientation curves is to consider the role of ~0 in the relaxation processes t a k i n g into account the rheological m e a s u r e m e n t s . An alternative method of presenting the orientation-relaxation curves is to compare the pure polymer and the blend at t e m p e r a t u r e s at which ~o is the same (115~ for the homopolymer and l l 0 ~ for the PS2000/PSD10 (30 %) blend). It is shown in Figure 22 t h a t the relaxation curves of both systems can be superimposed at short times but t h a t increased deviations a p p e a r at longer times. This result suggests t h a t at short times (or short distances) the monomeric friction coefficient governs the local relaxation processes, while at longer times the relaxation dynamics depends on the environment. Recalling the Rouse and tube models, this explanation fits in with the well-established notion t h a t the local relaxation processes can be described by Rouse modes [35]. F u r t h e r m o r e , at a fixed ~o' the short time relaxational kinetics of long chains are essentially insensitive to the presence of the short species. ~,
, , , i , , , , i , , , , i , , , , i , , V , l V , , , l ~ , , ,
i
5 E Z
[]
7
~
D
g
8
[]
9
9 -10
B
F.
~e~ e
L ~ , , l
6
D
....
7
i ....
8
z ....
i ....
~ ....
9 10 103 ( 1/T-T
11 )
~ .... 12 13
oo
Figure 21. Logarithmic plot of the monomeric friction coefficient as a function of 1/(T-Too) for PS2000 (0) and PS2000/PS10(30 wt.-%) (~). It can thus be deduced t h a t the "dilution effect" of short chains is a dynamical process which does not act at short times 9 On the contrary, at longer times, as reptation theory postulates, the topological constraints which govern the chain d y n a m i c s a p p e a r looser as the concentration of short chains is increased. Indeed, even in an environment of equivalent local chain characteristics, as
61
fixed by a given m o n o m e r i c friction coefficient, the PS2000/PSD10(30 wt.-%) blend, w i t h a lower n u m b e r of effective constraints, t h a t is, a higher Me, has t h u s an i n c r e a s e d chain mobility, and, consequently, a reduced orientation.
0.30 . . . . I . . . . I . . . . , . . . . , . . . . , . . . . , ' ' ' 0.25 ^
0.20
~D
o
0.15
g~ , . O
a," 0.10 V
9 O
o
00
9
c~ 9 .~o 9 LT- I~9
2
lie ~ 1 7 6 1o 7 6
0.05
D oc:b ~
0.00
, , , , I , , ~ , l , J , , i , , , , I , , , , l , , , , l
-1
0
1
2
3
4
~o
....
5
log t (~o = Constant) F i g u r e 22. Long chain orientational relaxation reduced to reference t e m p e r a t u r e s at which log ~o = -3.54 N.s.m-l: PS2000 (o), PS2000/PSD10(30 wt.-%) (g).
8. C o n c l u s i o n
I n f r a r e d d i c h r o i s m has been successfully applied to c h a r a c t e r i z e the o r i e n t a t i o n a l r e l a x a t i o n of linear a n d b r a n c h e d polystyrene chains as well as b i n a r y blends of long and short chains. By d e u t e r a t i n g some chains or p a r t s of chains, i n f r a r e d spectroscopy provides a m e t h o d of analyzing t h e orientational b e h a v i o u r of t h e d i f f e r e n t species a n d c o n s e q u e n t l y probe t h e m o l e c u l a r relaxation mechanisms. In t h e case of l i n e a r polymers, the o r i e n t a t i o n of a chain s e g m e n t has been s h o w n to depend on its location along the chain. A more rapid orientation of chain ends has been evidenced. S i m i l a r l y , in the case of s t a r polymers, t h e r e l a x a t i o n s of the b r a n c h point, a r m centre and c h a i n end have been differentiated. The influence of b r a n c h i n g h a s been detected by c o m p a r i n g l i n e a r chains w i t h a r m s of star polymers. A slower relaxation is observed in the case of b r a n c h e d species. T h e s p e c t r o s c o p i c d a t a h a v e been c o m p a r e d w i t h t h e t h e o r e t i c a l predictions of the Doi- E d w a r d s model. In the time scale of our experiments, a q u a n t i t a t i v e a g r e e m e n t b e t w e e n e x p e r i m e n t and theory is o b t a i n e d if chain l e n g t h f l u c t u a t i o n s , r e t r a c t i o n a n d r e p t a t i o n are t a k e n into account. In the case of s t a r polymers, t h e large scale fluctuation m e c h a n i s m as proposed by P e a r s o n a n d Helfand associated w i t h the r e t r a c t i o n process is accounting for
52 the observed relaxation, except in the case of the branch point of the star, where a more rapid relaxation is experimentally observed. The infrared analyses of binary polystyrene blends have been discussed in the light of rheological measurements of the same systems. It is shown that, in addition to the existence of an orientational coupling which is essentially evidenced by the high orientation of short species, the behaviour of the long chains is sensitive at short times to the average friction coefficient in the blend. Addition of short species leads to a decrease of the friction coefficient and thus a decrease in the relaxation times. At longer times, topological effects (changes in the entanglement spacing) are superimposed to the change in the relaxation times. RE~~CES 1. See for instance Chapter 1.5 and references cited therein 2. I. M. Ward, Structure and properties of Oriented Polymers, Applied Science Pub, London, 1975 3. H. Janeschitz-Kriegl, "Polymer Melt Rheology and Flow Birefringence", Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1983 4. G. G. Ffiller, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech., 22, 1990, 387 5. B. Jasse, J. L. Koenig, J. Macromol. Sci., Rev. Macro. Chem., C17, 1979, 61; J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 17,1979,799 6. J. F. Tassin, L. Monnerie, Macromolecules, 21, 1988, 1846 7. R. Fajolle, J. F. Tassin, P. Sergot, C. Pambrun, L. Monnerie, Polymer, 24, 1983, 379 8. J. D. Ferry, "Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers", 3rd edition, Wiley, New York 1980 9. M. Doi, S. F. Edwards, "The Theory of Polymer Dynamics", Oxford University Press, New York 1986 10. M. Doi, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 18, 1980, 1005 11. M. Doi, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Lett. Ed., 19, 1981, 265; J. Polym. Phys. Polym. Phys. Ed., 21, 1983, 667 12. D. S. Pearson, E. Helfand, Macromolecules, 17, 1984, 888 13. J. L. Viovy, Polymer Motions in Dense Systems, Springer Proceedings in Physics, 29, 1988,203 14. P. G. de Gennes, J. Phys. Fr., 36, 1975, 1199 15. R. C. Ball, T.C.B. McLeish, Macromolecules, 22, 1989,1911 16. J. L. Viovy, L. Monnerie, J. F. Tassin, J. Polym. Phys. Polym. Phys. Ed., 21, 1983, 2427 17. W. W. Graessley, Adv. Polym. Sci., 47, 1982, 67 18. J. Klein, Macromolecules, 19, 1986, 105 19. M. Doi, W. W. Graessley, D. S. Pearson, E. Helfand, Macromolecules, 20, 1987, 1900 20. M. Rubinstein, E. Helfand, D. S. Pearson, Macromolecules, 20, 1987, 822 21. M. Rubinstein, R. H. Colby, J. Chem. Phys., 89, 1988, 5291 22. A. Schausberger, H. Knoglinger, H. Janeschitz Kriegl, Rheol. Acta, 26, 1987, 4668 23. J. F. Tassin, L. Monnerie, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 21, 1983, 1981 24. J. A. Kornfield, G. G. Fuller, D. S. Pearson, Macromolecules, 22, 1989, 1334
63 25. G. G. Fuller, C. M. Ylitalo, J. of non crystalline Solids, 131, 1991, 676 26. P. F. Green, P. J. Mills, C. J. Palmstrom, J. W. Mayer, E. J. Kramer, Phys. Rev. Lett., 53, 1984, 2143 27. J. F. Tassin, Th~se de doctorat d'Etat, Universit~ Paris VI, 1986 28. L. R. G. Treloar, "The Physics of Rubber Elasticity", Oxford Univ. Press. London, 1958 29. J. F. Tassin, L. J. Fetters, L. Monnerie, Macromolecules, 21, 1988, 2404 30. C. M. Ylitalo, G. G. Fuller, V. Abetz, R. Stadler, D. S. Pearson, Rheol. Acta, 29, 1990, 543 31. A. Lee, R. P. Wool, Macromolecules, 20, 1987, 1924 32. K. Osaki, E. Takatori, M. Ueda, M. Kurata, T. Kotaka, H. Ohnuma, Macromolecules, 22, 1989, 2457 33. W. J. Walczak, R. P. Wool, Macromolecules, 24, 1991, 4657 34. T. Buffeteau, B. Desbat, S. Besbes, M. Nafati, L. Bokobza, Polymer, 35, 1994, 2538 35. P. J. Rouse, J. Chem. Phys., 21,1953, 1272 36. J. F. Tassin, A. Baschwitz, J. Y. Moise, L. Monnerie, Macromolecules, 23, 1990, 1879 37. H. Toriumi, B. Deloche, J. Herz, E. T. Samulski, Macromolecules, 18,1989, 1488 ; B. Deloche, A. Dubault, J. Herz, A. Lapp, Europhys. Lett., 1,1986, 629 38. M. Doi, D. Pearson, J. Kornfield, G. Fuller, Macromolecules, 22,1989, 1488 39. C. M. Ylitalo, J. A. Zawada, G. G. Fuller, V. Abetz, R. Stadler, Polymer, 33,1992, 2949 40.J.P. Montfort, G. Marin, P. Monge, Macromolecules, 17,1984, 1551; 19,1986, 1979 41. D. J. Plazek, J. Phys. Chem., 69,1965, 3480 42. P. Lomellini, Polymer, 33,1992, 4983 43. W. W. Graessley, J. Chem. Phys., 54,1971, 5143 44. R. J. Composto, E. J. Kramer, D. M. White, Polymer, 31, 1990, 2320
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Rheology for Polymer Melt Processing J-M. Piau and J-F. Agassant (editors) 9 1996 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
65
Chain conformation in elongational and shear flow as seen by SANS R. Muller and C. Picot Institut Charles Sadron (CRM-EAHP), 4-6 rue Boussingault, 67000 Strasbourg, France.
1. INTRODUCTION The central problem in the understanding of the rheological properties of polymer melts is to achieve a description at a molecular level of such highly entangled and consequently interacting long flexible chains systems. This goal is clearly of fundamental interest as well as of practical importance with regard to polymer processing. A variety of molecular models have been proposed to represent the behaviour of polymer chains in interaction with their surroundings. Extensive reviews describing the molecular approaches of polymer viscoelasticity can be found in monographs discussing the limits of their applicability [ 1,2]. In these models, equilibrium and dynamical properties are described in terms of spatial distribution of the chain segments. Whatever the models invoked, from the simplest (i.e the Rouse model) to the more sophisticated (reptation model,...), the stress is directly related to the orientation of the bound vectors of the polymer chain. Therefore a direct knowledge of the spatial distribution of the chain segments is the key point in the molecular description of the macroscopic viscoelastic behaviour. Among all experimental techniques, radiation scattering is the most appropriate to accede to this topological description. The scattering is indeed directly related through Fourier transform with the spatial correlation of fluctuations. More specifically, when observing a polymer system containing labelled chains, the distribution of chain segments in space can be analyzed [3]. With regard to polymeric condensed systems, small angle neutron scattering (SANS) is particularly well suited for studying chain conformations [4]. The advantages of SANS are twofold: the available range of scattering vectors on low angle spectrometers (10-3 - 1 A"t) matches particularly well the polymer chain dimensions. neutron scattering is the result of neutron-nucleus interaction and hence different isotopic species can interact with neutron differently. In particular, hydrogen and deuterium have coherent scattering lengths (arr=-0.374x 10~2; aD=+0.667x 10~2 cm respectively) which differ in both sign and magnitude. Consequently, a deuterated molecule in a protonated matrix will be "visible" by neutrons and vice versa. The SANS technique has already contributed to the analysis of polymer conformation in systems at equilibrium (i.e. dilute and concentrated solutions, bulk) [5-7] and to the molecular response of polymer systems under external constraints (i.e. polymer networks, polymer melts under uniaxial or shear deformation) [8-14]. The aim of the present work has been to establish correlations between bulk macroscopic response of polymer melts under flow and the behaviour at a molecular level as seen by SANS, and to discuss the results in the frame of molecular theories. Two simple and well defined geometries of deformation have been investigated: uniaxial elongation and simple shear. The -
-
66 basic experiment consists in submitting the polymer melts containing deuterium labelled chains to different, well-defined regimes of flows (transient and steady flows, relaxation, creep) and then perform SANS measurements on probes where the chains have been frozen in by rapid quenching below the glass transition temperature Tg.
2. METHODOLOGY 2.1. Polymers used All samples consist of anionically synthesized PS containing deuterated polystyrene (PSD) chains. Two hydrogenated (PSH1 and PSH2) and two deuterated (PSD 1 and PSD2) polymers were synthesized. Their weight-average molecular weight was determined by light-scattering measurements in benzene taking into account the refractive index increments for PSH and PSD. The polydispersity was characterized by gel permeation chromatography using the universal calibration. As shown in Table 1, PSH2 and PSD2 have a weight-average polymerization index which is about ten times that of PSH1 and PSD 1.
Table 1 Molecular WeiBht Characteristics of Polymers Polymer
Ms
Mw
Mz
M,dM,
Il~
PSH1 PSD 1 PSH2 PSD2
80 000 81 000 865 000 975 000
90 000 95 000 970 000 1 170 000
99 000 108 000 1 057 000 1 355 000
1.12 1.13 1.12 1.2
865 848 9 330 10 450
With these polymers, two narrow MWD samples (S 1 and $2) and seven binary blends were prepared for the SANS experiments. The composition of all samples is given in Table 2. They were obtained by freeze-drying a solution of all constituents in benzene [9]. For the narrow MWD samples, the weight fraction ~D of deuterated species is 10%. The weight fraction O2 of high molecular species in the binary blends ranges from 10% to 60%; they contain either PSD 1 03'20 and B'40) or PSD2 chains (B 10, B20, B40 and Br0), which allows one to investigate respectively the conformation of the low or high molecular weight species. As seen in Table 2, the total weight fraction ~ of deuterated species is lower for the binary blends than for the narrow M W samples. The concentrations were calculated so that the measured scattering intensity remains simply related to the form factor of the deuterated species (see section 2.3.). The linear viscoelastic properties of all samples were characterized by dynamic shear measurements in the parallel-plate geometry. Experimental details have been previously published [9]. Using time-temperature equivalence, master curves for the storage and loss moduli were obtained. Fig. 1 shows the master curves at 140~ for the relaxation spectra and Table 3 gives the values of zero-shear viscosities, steady-state compliances and weight-average relaxation times at the same temperature.
67
Table 2 Composition in weight fractions of all samples Sample
~PSm
~PSD~
q~Psm
(~)PSD2
~2
S1 $2
0.9 0
0.1 0
0 0.9
0 0.1
0 1
0.1 0.1
B10 B20 B40 B60
0.9 0.8 0.6 0.4
0 0 0 0
0.092 0.189 0.382 0.574
0.008 0.011 0.018 0.026
0.1 0.2 0.4 0.6
0.008 0.011 0.018 0.026
B'20 B'60
0.76 0.36
0.04 0.04
0.2 0.6
0 0
0.2 0.6
0.04 0.04
n
Figure 1. Relaxation spectra at 140~ of samples S 1, $2, B 10, B20 and B40.
--Im-- $1
v
BIO - - ~ - - B20 - - V - - B40 - - ~ - - $2
o
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
log(x) (s)
Table 3 Linear viscoe!astic parameters at 140~ of all samples. Samp!e
110 (106 Pa.s)
Jr ~ (10 s Pa ~)
X.(s)
S1 B10 B20, B'20 B40 B60, B'60 $2
0.65 9 42 290 780 3550
1 60 27 7.8 4.3 1.6
6.5 5 400 11 300 22 600 33 500 56 800
68
2.2. Experimental setup The data in this work were obtained by quenching either uniaxially stretched samples for which the low thickness of the specimens allows rapid cooling, or samples deformed in simple shear where higher thickness of the specimens was required in order to perform the scattering experiments along the three principal shear directions. For both types of flow, special devices were developed to control the flow kinematics in the molten state as well as the quenching process which freezes the molecular orientation. These devices are briefly described in the next paragraphs. 2.2.1. Eiongational flow For the elongational flow experiments, all specimens were uniaxially stretched with the extensional rheometer schematically shown in Fig. 2. A detailed description of this instrument has been published elsewhere [ 15]. Its main features are the following: (a) symmetric stretching with respect to the centre of the specimen (this allows measurement of flow birefringence at a fixed point of the sample), (b) temperature control with a double silicon-oil bath, which can be removed by vertical displacement. This oven provides a good temperature control (less than • ~ gradient in the whole bath), whereas buoyancy prevents the specimen from flowing under the effect of gravity. Homogeneous deformation is thus achieved even at very low strain rates for which the time that the specimen stays in the molten state is longer than the terminal relaxation time of the polymer sample. Stretched specimens are quenched by rapid removal of the surrounding oil bath.
Figure 2. Schematic drawing of extensional rheometer. (a)motors, (b)screws, (c) transducer, (d) sample, (e) oil bath, (f) laser, (g) lower position of bath.
69 2.2.2. Shear flow
The experimental device constructed to orient uniformly thick samples in simple shear is schematically represented in Fig. 3. It is basically a sliding-plate rheometer, the polymer sample being sheared between two temperature-controlled parallel plates. The upper plate is fixed whereas the lower plate can be displaced both horizontally and vertically with two pneumatic jacks. The shearing experiment occurs in the following way: (a) the temperature of both plates is set to its value during the melt flow by a silicon oil circulation before the polymer sample is inserted between the plates; (b) once thermal equilibration of the sarriple is achieved, the gap between the plates is fixed by a mechanical stop; (c) a constant shear force Fs is applied to the melt with the horizontal jack during a given time. At the same time, the normal force Fr~ in the sample is recorded with a force transducer mounted below the lower plate. From the horizontal displacement, the shear strain is obtained as a function of time; (d) after shearing, the sample is cooled by stopping the oil circulation and starting the cold water circulation which is located close to the surface of the plates. Throughout the cooling stage, both the shear force Fs and the normal force F~ are kept constant, the vertical jack being now driven with the same compressive force which has been measured during the sheafing stage. Keeping a constant compressive force on the sample during cooling allows compensation for thermal shrinkage and prevents the polymer from slipping away from the surfaces of the rheometer. Furthermore, if the temperature is assumed to be uniform in each polymer layer (at constant height) at any time during cooling, each polymer layer will experience the same constant shear and normal stresses during quenching. This in turn means that if steady flow is reached at the beginning of the cooling stage, the orientation will be uniform throughout the whole thickness of the sample, although the inner layers, which will be cooled later, will experience a higher final shear strain than the outer layers in contact with the plates which are quenched first. Birefringence provides an easy way to check the uniformity of orientation in the sample thickness: the observation with a polarizing microscope of small strips cut out vertically in the x-y sheafing plane shows that both the.birefringence and the extinction angle are uniform in the whole thickness (see also chapter III.1). Further experimental details have been previously published [ 13].
Figure 3. Schematic drawing of shear apparatus: (a) specimen, (b) oil circulation, (c) water circulation, (d) normal force jack, (e) shear force jack. x, y and z are the principal shear directions.
70
2.3. Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) in bulk polymers 2.3.1. Theoretical background Detailed reviews about application of SANS to the study of polymer in bulk are available in the literature [3]. These reviews provide information on the experimental technique as well on as on the fundamental theories related to scattering by polymers. Here, we will restrict ourselves to the description of some basic concepts to enable a better understanding of the experimental results that will be presented. A schematic representation of an experimental device used for SANS measurements is shown in Fig. 4.
I I
x
I
Stretching direction %
z Neutrons
IIIII ~
I \\\x~,,X
t
q Sample
Y
9
I
Y
Figure 4. Schematic representation of an experimental setup for SANS.
As mentioned before, the scattered intensity arises from the interaction between neutrons and nuclei. It decomposes into two terms, namely the coherent and the incoherent contribution. The coherent intensity depends on the scattering vector q which is the difference between the momentum of the incident and the scattered neutrons. Its norm is q=(4r~/k) sin(0/2), 0 being the
71 scattering angle and ~, the neutron wavelength. The incoherent intensity arises mainly from H nuclei and is not q dependent in the small q range of SANS. Its contribution results in a fiat background which can be taken into account by appropriate subtraction. For a mixture of identically D-labelled chains in a matrix of H chains with the same polymerization index, the coherent scattered intensity is given by:
S(q)= N AP~2-2(aD - all)2~D(I- q)D)P(q)=KM~D (1- q)D)P(q)
(1)
where aD and aH are the coherent scattering lengths of D and H monomer units, m and M are the molar weights of monomer unit and polymer chain, p is the density, ~D is the volume fraction of labelled chains, NA is Avogadro's number and P(q) the intra chain correlation function relative to the labelled coil: P(q) = ~
1
(2)
Z (exp(iq. rkl))
k,1
where r~a is the vector joining subunits k and 1 of the chain formed by N segments, < > is an ensemble average over all chain conformations in the sample.
Isotropic samples. For an isotropic set of identical coils, the form factor only depends on 0 and is given by the Debye function g(x):
g(x) = ~--
with x=q2xRg2, Rg being the radius of gyration of the chains. In the Guinier range of q ( qR~
1
)
S-'(q)= KMw~D(I_~D ) 1---~-R2z
(4)
where Mw and Rz are the weight and z averages for the molecular weight and radius of gyration respectively. The Zimm representation of the scattered intensity (S'l(q) versus q2) then allows the determination of Rz. In the intermediate range of scattering vector (1/R~< q
q2S(q) =
12KCPD(1 - eD)P(q) m 2
a
(5)
72 The Kratky plot (q2xS(q) versus q) leads to a plateau allowing the determination of a2/m. These two representations will be used as references for characterizing the anisotropy of the deformed samples. In the case of binary blends of chains with different molecular weights (the case which will be considered in this work), Eq. 1 no longer holds. In order to take into account the mismatch between the lengths of the chains of different species (H and D chains) one has to reformulate exactly the expression of coherent scattered intensity according the theory of random phase approximation (I~A) [16]. After straightforward calculations one can show that the Zimm representation leads to an apparent radius of gyration which is the true radius of the labelled chains multiplied by a coefficient C. This coefficient depends on the ratio of the molecular weights of the two polymers, the composition of the blend and the volume fraction of labelled chains. For all polymer blends that have been investigated, the value of C was close to unity so that this correction could be neglected. In the intermediate range of q, the theory shows that whatever the composition, the effect of the difference in chain length of the blend components is negligible.
Oriented samples. For anisotropic samples, the space correlation function will depend on the orientation imposed to the vector r~ and P(q) will vary both with the scattering angle 0 and azimuthal angle 6. One can then define scattering form factors along the reference axes as: 1
P ~ (q) = .-ST ~ (exp(iq act ld ) with cL= x, y, z IN- k,1
(6)
Expanding the exponential for small q gives: P(q) = - ~1~
exp [ - ~1 (q2x(X2) + q2 ( y h ) + q2 (zh)) ]
(7)
k,l
This defines the anisotropic radii of gyration along the reference directions : g,x - 2 N 2
x2)
the same for y and z
(8)
These quantities measure the average value of the square of the distance of chain units to the plane normal to the reference axis and going through the centre of mass of the chain. If one refers to the isotropic case, they are equal to one third of the radius of gyration.
2.3.2. SANS measurements and analysis of data
The neutron scattering experiments have been carried out at the Institue Laue Langevin (ILL) Grenoble, France and at the Laboratoire L6on Brillouin (LLB), Saclay, France. By using different spectrometers the following ranges of scattering vector amplitudes q were covered:
73
Spectrometer: q range(/l-1):
ILL-D 11 3x10 -2
4 x 1 0 "3 .
ILL-D 17 1.2x10 "l
1 0 -2 _
LLB-PAXY 1 0 "3 . 5 . 5 x 1 0
"2
Water calibration was used to convert the scattering data to an absolute coherent scattering cross-section, S(q), with units of reciprocal centimetres. A general result for all samples is the agreement between the data obtained on the different spectrometers in the overlapping qdomain. After appropriate incoherent background subtraction, the data analysis is carried out over the whole bidimensional detector by grouping at constant scattering angle 0 for isotropic samples. For oriented samples, grouping of data is performed at constant 0 in limited sectors around the reference axis or the main axis of deformation.
3. ELONGATIONAL F L O W 3.1. Narrow MWD samples 3.1.1. Results A first series of tensile experiments at constant strain rate has been carried out on sample S 1: the specimens are stretched at constant elongational strain rate up to a given extension and immediately quenched. According to time-temperature superposition, a rheological material function at a given temperature To can be shifted to any other temperature T knowing the thermal shift factor aT-,To. For the tensile stress-growth coefficient, the following equation holds:
,
=~ - tie pT aT~To
(
~ , t aT_~T~
x aT_,T0,
,)
(9)
which has been confirmed experimentally [ 15,17-18]. For these first experiments, a temperature relatively close to Tg, T=123~ was chosen with the intention of minimizing the relaxation of stress and chain orientation during the quenching: the weight-average relaxation time of sample S 1 at 123~ is calculated from that at 140~ and the thermal shift factor between 123~ and 140~ Lw(123~ On the other hand the cooling time of the stretched specimens can be estimated to a few seconds [ 19], which is very small compared to the polymer relaxation time at the temperature of the experiments. For strain rates lower than 8• 10.4 s~, it was found that the rheological behaviour is nearly at linear viscoelastic: Fig. 5 shows the tensile stress-growth f u n c t i o n cr§247 123~ for three different strain rates in the linear range; after about 1000s, the stress reaches a steady value close to 3ri0 x e where r10=3.8x107 Pa.s is the zero-shear viscosity at 123~ For each strain rate, samples for the scattering experiments were obtained by quenching specimens at different macroscopic extensions in the steady-state flow as shown by the arrows in Fig. 5.
74 Comparison of o § (~:,t)for different samples stretched at the same strain rate shows that the reproducibility of the tensile test is satisfactory. Figs. 6 and 7 show the Kratky plots of these samples and Table 4 gives their radii of gyration t ~ / a n d R~;. At this stage, several conclusions can be drawn on a qualitative level: (a) there is a good agreement between the results obtained on the two spectrometers (D 11 and D 17) in the overlapping q-domain, (b) as shown by Fig. 6, the anisotropic scattering intensity becomes time-independent like the stress. This result was expected and confirms the reliability of the experimental method. (c) The chain anisotropy increases with strain rate, but the decrease in R~. is less pronounced than the increase in R~/. The measured radius of gyration for an isotropic sample is close to 82 A and the data are represented by the solid line in Fig. 6; they are in close agreement with the Debye function for Cvaussian coils (Eq. 3).
A
cl
v
(/) u) I,OxIos.
~v~ ~ 4,V
._---m 7,5~e-
lit
~c2
Figure 5. Tensile stress-growth function for sample $1 at 123~
v v vvv ~bl
~ Z X
~
b2
zxz~ zx "/x zx
~q~E)"O Q(!R)~p(P o
B,O,O: ~: = 3.7x10 "4s"l o
o o
e,A: ~ = 5.3 x 10.4 s "1
2 , ~ 0 40,0 ,
o
O,V:e = 7.4x 10.4 sa ,~
" tom
~
~o
~
3oo0 ~ m e (s)
~ " 0.15
0,15
-.
E ,~
-SBB'~'~~
0,10"
l
o
0,05.
1
9
a2D17 '
c?. Dll
%0,05 0,00
o.m
o.~ " o.~
o.~
"o.~o q(A-~)
Figure 6. Kratky plots for the three specimens of the (a) series. Data below the isotropic curve correspond to the parallel direction.
0,~
o.oo
-
o,~
.
0,6
,,,
"
o,~s
"
oN
0,10
q(A"I)
Figure 7. Kratky plots for specimens a2 and c2.
75
d2
"2T ~
v
d3
3%
Figure 8. Tensile stress-growth coefficient of sample S 1 at 123~ A : e = 3 . 7 x l 0 -4 s-Z, I I : e = 1 0 -a s'~; i-'1. s = 2.3x10 -2 s-1.
log(t) (t in s)
Table 4 Radii of G/ratio n of S 1 specimens. Sample
9 e (s")
Hencky ..strain
Pw/(A) (exp_erim.)
R~; (A) Rv/(A) (experim.) .... (Rouse).
R~. (A) (Rouse)
al a2 a3
3.7x10.4 3.7x10.4 3.7x10.4
0.37 0.65 0.925
91.5 91 91
76.5 75.5 75.5
95 99 101
77 76.5 76.5
bl b2 b3
5.3x10 "4 5.3 x 10.4 5.3 • 10.4
0.53 0.93 1.32
95.5 95.5 95
75 74.5 76.5
102 110 116
75.5 75 74.5
cl c2
7.4x 10.4 7.4• 10.4
0.74 1.3
102 100.5
74.5 75.5
114 131
73.5 72.5
dl d2 d3
10-3 10.3 10"3
0.5 1 1.75
102 106 115
77 74
109 133 170.5
73.5 71 70
el e2 e3
2.3x10 "2 2.3• .2 2.3 • 10.2
0.3 0.69 1.29
100 125 164
63 60 56
108 153 262
72 62 52
Further tests have been carried out on sample S1 at two higher strain rates. The stressgrowth coefficient corresponding to these experiments is represented in Fig. 8, where the
76 arrows indicate the specimens quenched for the SANS experiments. As can be seen in Fig. 9, which shows the Kratky plots of specimens e 1, e2 and e3, and in Table 4, the anisotropy of the chain conformation increases with the macroscopic elongation just like the stress.
,•o• Figure 9. Kratky plot for the 3 specimens of the (e) series stretched at e -- 2.3 x 10-2 s"] (data from D 17 spectrometer). e2 o3 o,0o
o,|
.
.
.
o.'o5
.
r
0,15
q(A"1)
For the high molecular weight sample $2 as well as for the binary blends, a higher temperature (140~ was chosen for the elongational flow. On the other hand, instead of being quenched at various extensions during a constant strain rate test, these samples were rapidly stretched (within about 3s) to a given extension (L/L0=3 for all specimens) and the stress was then allowed to relax for a certain time tR before quenching. In all cases, tx was very large compared to the stretching time of 3s. Fig. 10 shows SANS data for sample $2, which confirm that the chain anisotropy decreases with increasing tR.
oE ~
o,
,~l~'o ] ]~,L r
o.=q Z
o,oJ
0,00
o
o ~:~x~ A ~:3ooos Figure 10. Kratky plot for sample $2 stretched at 140~ The two specimens were allowed to relax during 200s and 3000s (data from D 11 and D 17 spectrometers).
.
.
.
.
0,05
.
.
.
0,10
0,1,5 q ( A "1)
77 It has to be mentioned that the radii of gyration of the high molecular weight chains (which are of the order of 300 A) could not be determined in the frame of the present study. Reaching scattering vectors as low as 10-3 A "~, which would have been required, involves technical difficulties on the spectrometer and very long counting times.
3.1.2 Rouse model
A more quantitative interpretation of the scattering data involves molecular models. As an example, we turned to the Rouse model [20] developed for solutions and extended to melts [21]. As this model is unable to account for the molecular weight dependence of zero-shear viscosity (rl0--M34) above the critical molecular weight (M,~35 000 for PS), the analysis will be extended as a next step to other models which are more realistic for entangled systems. A basic result of the Rouse model relates the monomeric friction coefficient Q0 and the zero-shear viscosity TI0: ~0 = 36r10m2 pa2MNA
(10)
m and a being the molecular weight and length of the statistical segment, M is the molecular weight of the whole chain and NA is Avogadro's number. In the linear viscoelastic limit, the Rouse model is equivalent to a generalized Maxwell model with relaxation times g~=Xl/n 2. The longest relaxation time k,1 (or Rouse time) is simply related to the zero-shear viscosity and molecular weight of the chain: X,1 = 6rl~ x2oRT
(11)
If the Rouse time is determined from the experimental value of the zero-shear viscosity, one finds XI=615s for sample S 1 at 123~ which is not too far from the experimental value of the weight-average relaxation time (X~380s). Clearly, the determination of ~0 and ~,i from the experimental value of 110 implies the assumption of monomeric friction enhancement by entanglements [20], since for sample S 1 M is of the order of 3 • To allow a comparison with rheological and SANS data, the stress and scattering intensity have been calculated for the Rouse model as a function of time and strain rate for simple elongational flow. L being the chain length, the nth normal mode is given by [1 ]: L ( n x s ) ds R n = 2~ r(s) co~---~-) -L0
(12)
r being the position vector along the chain axis. If n,p, the nth and pth modes are uncorrelated (=0). The spatial components X~, Y, and Zn of a mode are also uncorrelated and obey Gaussian statistics. If x is the stretching direction, it is easily shown that:
78
1 - 2 ~ , n exp - 1 - 2 ~ , n
9
Xn 2 (t) = Rg,iso ~n 2
EI" 9
l nl
1-2~;~ n
I+E:~Ln exp - I+~:~Ln 2 2 (Yn2 (t)) = (Zn2 (t)) = R g ~ ~2n2
9
Ic 9 l nJ
(13)
l+ek n
The tensile stress is shown to be [2]:
o xx - o ~ =
2aM
X XR2)+
(14)
The rheological constitutive equation of the Rouse model is that of an upper-convected Maxwell model, with the consequence that steady-state elongational flow only exists for strain rates lower than 1/(2~,0. The steady-state elongational viscosity depends then on strain rate:
(~) TIE
3pRT N ~, M " l - 2 e ~ . p l+e~.p
and obeys Trouton's relation for vanishing strain rates. The scattering intensities in the parallel and perpendicular directions:
S//(q) = ~
S•
E ~ exp{-~ q k 1 k 1
(x k - x 1 (16)
q (Yk-Yl
where xk, yk and Zk are the components of rk, the position vector at monomer k, can also be calculated from the normal modes [22] since: rk = R 0 + 2 ~ R p c o p=l
(17)
79 A first comparison between the model and our rheological data for sample S 1 shows that the critical strain rate of the model (e = 8.1 • 10 "4 s"~) is close to the value corresponding to the departure from linear viscoelasticity in elongation (see Fig. 8). However, a fundamental discrepancy lies in the fact that no strain rate dependence of the steady-state elongational viscosity is seen in the experimental data below the critical strain rate. Figs. 11 and 12 compare the stress data of Figs. 5 and 8, and the Rouse model predictions according to Eqs. 5 and 6. Close agreement is only found for the lowest strain rate corresponding to the (a) series, the model generally overestimates the tensile stress. The scattering intensity has been calculated according to Eqs. 16, 17 and 13 and the results are compared to the data in Fig. 13, 14 and 15 for samples a2 and c2, d l and d3 and el to e3 respectively. Table 4 compares the calculated radii of gyration with the experimental data.
m 1'5x10S
~
;.-y
--O--a ~b "'<)me
I
-----Rouse
+~ 1,t~o ~,
....~,~
5,0x104
ml
d Rouse .......... e Rouse
O 0,0 ~,
o
. . . . .
1~
2~
3o0o time (s)
Figure l 1. Tensile stress-growth function of sample S1 at 123~ Symbols" data of Fig. 5. Solid lines: Rouse model.
~,--'- O,lS
d ~
Jog(t) (t in s)
Figure 12. Tensile stress-growth coefficient of sample $1 at 123~ Symbols: data of Fig. 8. Solid and dotted lines' Rouse model.
0,15
<
"T,
E o
0,10 ,G, I.,E, ~
0,05-
A,
~ R~
m~
I
&
c2 Rouse model I 0 , ~
-
~"
0,00
0,02
. 9
-
~
0,04
....
,
0,06
,
0,08
q(AI)
Figure 13. Kratky plots for specimens a2 and c2. Symbols: data of Fig. 7. Solid and dashed lines: Rouse model.
- - - -0,00
o,oo
9
o,~
o.~
d3 Data Rouse cl3 Rouse dl
o,~
""
olin
q(A"I)
Figure 14. Kratky plots for specimens d 1 and d3. Symbols: data. Solid and dashed lines Rouse model.
80
(13)
'E
0,15.
Figure 15. Kratky plots for specimens el, e2 and e3. Symbols: data of Fig. 9. Solid lines: Rouse model.
0,10.
_~ ~| (tO0
(~oo
0.05
O,W10
"
(~15
q(A "I)
The main conclusions coming out of these results are the following: (a) the Rouse model systematically overestimates the parallel radius of gyration whereas the agreement is satisfactory in the perpendicular direction. (b) For strain rates below the critical strain rate, the experimental values of stress and scattering intensity become time independent at a time shorter than that predicted by the model. (c) These results should be compared to the fact that the model also overestimates the steady-state elongational viscosity with respect to the experimental value which obeys Trouton' s relation: VIE=3Xrl0(shear). (d) At higher q-values, an overall satisfactory agreement between model and experimental data is found over the whole range of strain rates, except for the highest strain rate in the transverse direction. For molecular weights up to a few times the molecular weight between entanglements (for S 1 about 5 times) the chain conformation in uniaxial elongation, especially at a local scale, is fairly well accounted for by the Rouse approximation. We now examine the data for the high molecular weight sample with a molecular weight of about 50xM~. If the Rouse time for sample $2 at 140~ is estimated as before from the experimental value of the zero-shear viscosity according to Eq. 3, one obtains l~=6.3x 105 s, which is about 10 times the experimental value of L~. This discrepancy reflects the incapacity of the Rouse model to account for the molecular weight dependence of both rl0 and 7~, for highly entangled melts. For this reason, we calculated the scattering intensity of the high molecular sample by taking for the Rouse time the measured terminal relaxation time (57 000s). Fig. 16 shows the result compared with the data of Fig. 10. It is seen that the model only agrees with the data in the small q-range, which is related to the choice of the Rouse time k~, taken here as the measured terminal relaxation time of the sample. On the other hand, the model strongly underestimates the chain orientation at a more local scale, which can be qualitatively understood by considering that the chain is actually trapped in a tube which keeps an orientation at the scale of the tube diameter for times close to the reptation time.
81
<
0,30 ,
~000~0
0
'E 0,25, o
0,20
\\
=~
OO~
tR=200S Data 9 tR=3000SData . . . . tR=200S R o u s e ~ t R : 3 0 0 0 S Rouse
model model
Figure 16. Kratky plot for sample $2 stretched at 140~ Symbols: data of Fig. 10. Solid and dashed lines: Rouse model.
!
~-- 0,15
o ~. 0,10, 0,05 0,00, 0 00
,
0,05
,
0,10
,
015
q(A "I)
3.1.3. Temporary network model Rheological models using the concept of a temporary network of entanglements have been very successful in describing the rheological behaviour of polymer melts [23-25] and especially the strain-hardening effect in elongational flow [26]. However, the assumption of affine displacement of temporary junctions with respect to macroscopic deformation leads to an overestimation of the stress. Fig. 17 shows the tensile stress during a constant strain rate experiment, plotted against the quantity (~2_~-~) where ~ is the recoverable strain. ;~ has been measured by cutting off a part of the stretched and quenched specimen (of length L) and annealing it at the surface of an oil bath at 150~ L, is then defined as the ratio L/L~ where Lf is the length after recovery. Since for each experimental point a new specimen is required, the data in Fig. 17 were obtained with a commercial polystyrene sample, available in larger quantities than the anionic and deuterated polymers used for the SANS experiments. The curves in Fig. 17 suggest the following expression for the tensile stress:
t~+(;,t1=t~0(;1+G(;l(~r2_~r-1)
(18)
It has been found that Equation 18 describes to a good approximation tensile stress data on various polystyrene samples [27] . G(~) is an increasing function of strain rate and becomes close to the plateau modulus GN~ at high strain rates. Eq. 18 amounts to the assumption that the deformation experienced by the entanglement network is just the macroscopic recoverable deformation of the specimen. With respect to the scattering experiments, this picture is of particular interest since it suggests to calculate the form factor of the chains in the melt as for a labelled multi-cross-link path in a strained network [28]. A slightly different calculation, taking
82 into account the dangling end segments has been proposed for uncrosslinked chains in a melt [14].
"~' 3.0x105. I:L
&
1/) 1@
&
Figure 17. Tensile stress as a function of ~2_~-, for a commercial polystyrene at 140~ and 3 different strain rates, i : 0.005s'1; r'l: 0.01 s~; A: 0.02 ]-1.
A
~ 2,~,
&
~176 o
0
ill thai 0
0,0- - - . .
0
, 5
o
0
0 0o
il -
!
'
.
-
10
9
-
2'0' ~
15
30 ~Lr2-;Lr"1
The calculation only requires the knowledge of the network deformation, taken in our case as the recoverable strain which is known from experiment, and the number n of elastic subchains per chain which for high enough strain rates should be close to M/M~ where M is the total molecular weight of the chain and Mr the molecular weight between entanglements. The network model leads to the following expression of the radius of gyration in the directions parallel and perpendicular to the stretching direction:
Rg,j. = Rg,iso 1 +
-
1
n
2n 2
+
(19)
One may also estimate n from the scattering data by finding the best fit in the Kratky plots between the experimental and calculated form factor. This is illustrated in Fig. 18 for samples a2 and d2, in Fig. 19 for samples e2 and e3 and in Fig. 20 for sample $2 relaxed for 200s and 3000s. For the last sample, the sensitivity of the form factor to n is illustrated in Fig. 21. The values of n determined by adjusting the SANS data in the intermediate scattering vector range are given in Table 5. Figs. 18 to 21 show that the network model satisfactorily describes the SANS data in the intermediate scattering vector range with reasonable values of the number of subchains, close to M/Mr for both S1 and $2 samples. As shown by the data in Table 5 for the radii of gyration, the agreement is also good in the Guinier range, for lower values of the scattering vector. It has to be noted that the radii of gyration of the long chains could not be measured, due to very long counting times on the spectrometer and to experimental problems arising for scattering vectors lower than 1 0 " 3 A "1. In the flame of the temporary network model, the number of elastic subchains can also be determined from the tensile stress according to the classical relation of rubber elasticity:
83
(
cr = v c ~ r
r
~r
n~
r
where v= is the number of elastic strands per unit volume and r~ the number of elastic strands per chain determined from the value of the stress. According to the network model, ~ should be equal to n (determined from the SANS data).
a:
, • 0,20-
0,15
z,,~=~
,~3 0'10"
....
0,15. ,----~ 0,10 '
.~
0,~.
~.
0,05,
L~-~,-~-~
O,O0.
0,00
0,02
0,04
0,06
e2 O
---
o,o0.
o 00
0.08
~
-
,,v-
o,os
e3 Data -- e3 Network
O,lO
q(A "1)
o.ls q(A "1)
Figure 19. Kratky plots for specimens e2 and e3. Symbols: data of Fig. 9. Solid lines: Network model for ~=1.64 and n=10. Dashed lines: Network model for 7~=2.21 and n=10.
Figure 18. Kratky plots for specimens a2 and d2. Symbols: data. Solid lines: Network model for %=1.17 and n=5. Dashed lines: Network model for %= 1.4 and n=5.
A
~
.r--1~ 0,30 'E o v 025.
0.30
o IX -
IR=3(XJOsDala
~.~'er
- - - - IR--'200S N e l w o r k
~
o~o-
025-] / 1
......... "........ n=40 ------ n=60 - - - - - n=100
"
.,'~ ~ \
\
Ooooo~c ~
'O' 0,15
u" --~" 0,10
%r
0,135
0,00
0 00
0,05
0,10
0, 5 q(A -4)
Figure 20. Kratky plots for sample $2 with tR=200S and 3000s. Symbols: data. Dashed lines: Network model for L~=2.63 and n=60. Solid lines: Network model for ~=2.45 and n=60.
' 0,00
0,05
0,10
0,15 q(A "1)
Figure 21. Kratky plots for specimens e2 and e3. Symbols: data of Fig. 9. Lines: Network model for ~=2.45 and 3 different values of n.
84 The data in Table 5 show that both values are of the same order of magnitude, though the number of elastic strands determined from the stress data are systematically lower than those determined from the form factor. The difference becomes even stronger if the viscous contribution o0 is subtracted from the stress according to Eq. 18.
Table 5 Recoverable strain and number of subchains determined from SANS (n) and stress (n,) data. Experimental radii of gyration compared to the predictions of Eq. 19.
Sample
~
n
o
M
~, (A)
Pw, (A)
~I(A)
91 95.5 100.5 106 125 164
92 96 102 106 129 171 757 705
75.5 74.5 75.5 74 60 56
~
(A)
pRT Z,2 - kr-l (expefim.) (Network (experim.) (Network model) model) a2 b2 c2 d2 e2 e3 $2 tR=200S $2 tR=3000S
1.17 1.25 1.35 1.4 1.64 2.21 2.63 2.45
5 5 5 5 10 10 60 60
2.5 2.5 2.5 2.7 6 6 42 30
78 76 74 71 67 59 181 188
3.2. Binary blends The chain conformation of the high molecular weight species in the binary blends has been characterized in the same rheological test as for sample $2 (quick stretching up to L/L0=3, stress relaxation during a time tR at the same temperature, quenching). Fig. 22 shows the influence of the blend composition on the stress relaxation curve. For a given blend composition, the form factor can be measured as a function of tR, which is shown as an example for blend B 10 in Fig. 23. As expected, the chain anisotropy decreases with increasing time of the relaxation step. It is interesting to notice that the $2 chains have not completely relaxed even after tR=40 000S, which corresponds to about 8 times the terminal relaxation time determined from linear viscoelasticity (see Table 3). Another possibility is to look at the influence of the blend composition on the anisotropy of the long chains at a given value of tR. This is shown in Fig. 24 for tR=3000S and three blend compositions. The anisotropy of the high molecular weight chains increases by increasing their concentration in the blend. The SANS data in Figs. 23 and 24 are confirmed by the values of recoverable strain listed in Table 6. We tried to extend the network model to the binary blends and to determine the number n of elastic strands per $2 chain by adjusting the form factor calculated from the recoverable strain to the SANS data. Fig. 25 gives an example of the type of agreement which could be obtained between the model and the data. The corresponding values of n are listed in Table 6.
85
(q-. o
--A,-9 BIO
~;L--,~_~--.~._~ ..
---~~
,--
0,15
~z~'a~,zxzxzx
o,o e~.
o
i
~
~
;,
~
0,05-
o
o.oo
o ~0
log(t) (s)
o,~
%= 40(XX~
030 q(A "~)
Figure 22. Tensile stress as a function of time during relaxation at 140~ following a rapid deformation of L/Lo=3.
020-
Figure 23. Kratky plots for blend B 10 stretched and relaxed for various times.
<.
9 2~
0,15 -
mll~OOOoom~
020/ IE/
~3 |
o.=t~ ~'~176176176176176 ' I
~
i
1~11~m
-
m
u
.~ 61~ o
0,1~
0,02
0,04
0,06
0,08
0,15
0,10
0,12
q(A 1)
Figure 24. Kratky plots for blends B 10, B20 and B60 stretched and relaxed for 3000s.
e'~5 o, Io
\
~tJ
0
r-1... \ ~.
gj . _ _ --
~
000,
~m_._==~._, a l l i ' -
~
- _ _=.=._.= =~ ....
o oo~o.
..... "---"=lnilE
. _
o,o5 0,1111. 0,000
0,025
0,050
0,075
0,100
0,125
q(A"1) Figure 25. Symbols: Data for blends B10 (tR=40 000S) and B60 (tR=3000S). Solid lines: network model with: L~=1.19, n=10. Dashed lines: network model with ~=2.45 n=30.
To compare the values of n determined from the SANS data with those obtained from the stress values, a modified expression of the stress should be used instead of Eq. 20:
a - Ve(~r2 - ~ r - l ) -
~)2n~ -pRT ~ (~r2 - ~r_ 1)
(21)
86 where ~2 is the weight fraction of high molecular weight species in the blend. Eq. 21 amounts to the assumption that the stress in the blends is only due to the high molecular weight chains. The SANS experiments allow us to verify this assumption by using blends where the low molecular weight component S1 has been deuterated (blends B'20 and B'60). Fig. 26 shows the Kratky plots of these two blends, stretched in the same way as all the other blends and relaxed for 200s. Even for the shortest time of relaxation of the present study, the orientation of the low molecular weight component is found to be very low, and the assumption leading to Eq. 21 appears to be valid. However, the data in Fig. 26 show that the orientation of the short chains, like that of the long chains depends on the blend composition: the higher the content in high molecular weight species, the higher the short chain orientation. It has to be noticed that due to the rather short relaxation times used for blends B'20 and B'60, no <> or <> scattering patterns [29] were observed for our experiments.
Table 6 Recoverable strain and number of elastic strands per $2 chain determined from SANS data (n) and tensile stress (n,,).
1~-"
Sample
ts (s)
Z.
M
n r
r Xr 2 - ~,r-1
B 10
200
2.29
20
16
B 10
1000
2.02
15
10
B10
3000
1.93
10
8
B 10
20000
1.23
10
6
B 10
40000
1.19
10
4
B20
200
2.59
20
15
B20
3000
2.08
15
8
B40
200
2.8
30
18
B40
3000
2.26
20
12
B60
200
2.84
40
23
B60
3000
2.45
30
18
87
a:
0,15
'E 0
e,
0,10-
e ~ , 0,o5.
/
B'20 &
0" =-
0,00 0
Figure 26. Kratky plots of blends B'20 and B'60 stretched up to L/Lo=3 and relaxed for 200s at 140~
o,~
....
o,&
"
o,=
B'60
0,08
q(A-~)
4. SHEAR FLOW 4.1. Experimental results All experiments were carried out on sample S1. The radius of gyration of an isotropic sample, determined from the Zimm plot in the low scattering vector range, is close to 82 A. Specimens were sheared by using the above described sliding plate rheometer at two different shear stresses 07:0.05 and 0.2 MPa. For o~y=0.05 MPa, the behaviour of the melt was found to be nearly Newtonian. One sample was sheared at the highest shear stress up to a final shear strain of y=2.4. For the lowest shear stress, two samples with different shear strains were prepared: ?=2.8 and y=4. These samples are referenced in Table 7. Fig. 27 defines the principal directions of molecular anisotropy (I, II and III) with respect to the principal directions of shear (x, y and z), x being the direction of velocity and y the normal to the plates. Symmetry of the flow leads to III-z and the relative orientation of (I,II) with respect to (x,y) is defined by the angle g.
Figure 27. Definition of the principal directions of molecular orientation (I,II) with respect to the principal shear directions (x,y).
88
At vanishing chain orientation (at either small strains or low shear rates) X is expected to be close to 45 ~ whereas for large affine chain deformation X tends to 0~ More generally, depends on shear rate or shear stress. It should be emphasized that the value of ~ depends theoretically on the way the orientation is measured. Birefringence measurements will give the extinction angle Xa, whereas SANS measurements in the range of low scattering vectors give slightly higher values (see Table 7). This can be qualitatively understood in the framework of molecular models where relaxation mechanisms with different relaxation times are associated with characteristic length scales on the chain [1]. It would be expected that the molecular anisotropy at a local scale on the chain is lower than the anisotropy of the end-to-end vector or radius of gyration. In the particular case of a shear flow, this will result in an orientation with respect to the shear axes which also depends on the considered length scale; in other words, in a scattering experiment may depend on the magnitude of the scattering vector [30]. In the following, the limit of ~ at zero scattering vector will be referred to by ~0.
Table 7 Parameters of the shear flow, characteristic angles of orientation and experimental root mean square chain dimensions in the various directions. Radius of gyratio n of isotropic sample: 82A. Sample
A
B
C
Shear Stress (Pa) T(~ Shear strain
5 x 104 130 2.8
5 x 104 130 4
2x 10~ 120 2.4
X z~ Xaff. X0
26~ 18~ ~27 ~
24~ 13.5 ~ ~27 ~
22"5~ 20 ~ 19~
P-,g.iexp. (/~) R ~ exp (A) R ~ exp.x-z plane(A) R ~ exp.x-z plane(A) Rg,y exp.y-z plane(A) R ~ exp.y-z plane(A) R ~ calc. (A) R~y calc. (A)
94 73 89 83
99 69 93 83 77 83 95 75
143 47 136 81
91
137
Fig. 28a shows typical isointensity curves on the multidetector for a specimen in the x-y shearing plane (for the sake of clarity, only three curves have been plotted). According to the above comments on a possible q-dependence of the chain orientation with respect to the shear directions, the scattering data were analyzed as follows: each isointensity curve was fitted with
89
an ellipse using a least square program which determines for each curve both the minor and major axes (which are the scattering vectors qI and qn along directions I and II, respectively) and their orientation ~ with respect to the shear axes.
'y
~Z
:Y
._Z
._X.
,
b
C
s
Figure 28. Isointensity curves of sample B in the three principal shearing planes: x-y (a), x-z (b), y-z (c). All isointensity curves are fitted with ellipses. In the x-y plane, the minor and major axes define the scattering vectors qt and qa and their orientation with respect to the shear axes defines X. In the x-z and y-z planes, the axes of the ellipses coincide with the shear axes.
Fig. 29 shows the variation of 7~as a function of the minor axis qi for the isointensity curves of sample C. Despite some scatter in the data, it appears that for low q values (typically qi<2.5 • -t which corresponds to qiI<5.5x 10-2A-~) X levels offto a value of the order of 19~
25
~3 v
20-
15
9
mm m 9
~ mmmmmm ~ m
9
o,o
o',s
m m mm
m
Figure 29. Variation of ;~ with the square of the scattering vector in direction I.
9
i',o
2,0
1000 x q2 (A-2)
90 The angle go can be compared on the one hand to the extinction angle gA of birefringence, and on the other hand to the orientation ~ . of the principal directions of the Cauchy deformation tensor, which would correspond to a molecular deformation purely affine with the macroscopic deformation shear strain. For a simple shear deformation y, %=r is given by: 1 arctg(2) ;(aft'= 2
(22)
It appears that for sample C, the value of go determined from the SANS isointensity curves in the low q-range is lower than %A and close to ~ t (see Table 7). Furthermore Fig. 29 clearly shows that % increases with increasing magnitude of the scattering vector, thus confirming the idea that the direction of molecular orientation in shear flow depends on the considered length scale on the chain: the overall chain orientation is closer to that of an affine deformation than the local chain orientation [30]. The extinction angle of birefringence should then represent some average of g over the whole q-range. Since for the highest q-value of the present set of experiments, % is roughly equal to %A (see Fig. 29), this should be confirmed by complementary measurements in a higher q range, where it is expected that % will take values above 7,A. Another interestingresult is obtained from the comparison of the scattering of the sheared samples in the z direction to that of an isotropic sample. Fig. 30 shows the Zimm plot of sample C in the directionsx and z for a specimen cut in the x-z plane. The corresponding curve for an isotropic sample, which has also been plotted in the same figure, is found to be identical to within experimental error to the curve in the z direction. This result indicates that the position correlationswithin the chain in the neutral direction of the shear flow are not affected by the flow, at leastup to the values of stress and strainused in the present study. In particular, Table 7 shows that the mean square chain dimension in that direction, Rg z, which has been determined eitherin the x-z or in the y-z planes for the various samples, is found to be equal to the radius of gyration of an isotropic sample to within experimental error (Rg,z=82-d:I/~).The same result has been found by Lindner in dilute solutions [31 ].
~
Figure 30. Zimm plot of the absolute coherent scattering cross-section reduced to the concentration of deuterated species for sample B in the directions z (r'l) and x ( I ) compared to an isotropic sample (full line). The curves extrapolated at zero q are found to intersect at the same value. From their initial slope, one can calculate Rg,z and Rg,x.
== i m ===
~.~
3
=rl ==1~1
o;
0.0
o:s
~',0
[]
~',s
2:0 2:s looo x q2 (A-2)
3,0
91
4.2. Discussion For all three samples, it can be assumed that g becomes independent of q in the low qrange (X=g0). As a consequence, one can determine a mean square dimension of the chain in the direction of gO and in the perpendicular direction g0+rd2, from a Zimm plot of the scattered intensity as a function of qi and qn respectively, according to Eqs. 7 and 8. The data for Rg,i and Rg,II for the three samples are given in Table 7.
From specimens cut in the x-z and y-z sheafing planes, mean square chain dimensions similar to Rg,I and Rg,i I can also be determined in the principal shear directions x, y and z. Typical isointensity patterns in the three shearing planes are shown in Fig. 28 for sample B. It can be seen that the shape of these curves in the x-z and y-z planes is nearly elliptical like in the x-y plane. However, due to the symmetry of the shear flow, the z direction is a principal direction for molecular orientation at all scales and the major and minor axes of the isointensity curves are indeed found to be parallel to the {x,z} and {y,z} directions. Therefore, the analysis of the scattering data in the x-z and y-z planes has been carried out by fixing the direction of the axes of the ellipse (to 0 ~ and 90 ~ in the least-squares fit program. The major and minor axes of these ellipses then define the scattering vectors qx, qy and qz in the principal shear directions and allow us to calculate the mean square chain dimensions Rg,x, Rg,y and Rg,z. Obviously, Rg,I and Rg,i I are not independent of Rg,x and Rg,y. From the relations between x, y and xx, xn: {~ = x I COSX0 - Xli sin ~0 = XI
(23)
sm g0 + x , cosz0
the following relations between the mean square coordinates are obtained: <<x2 > = <xI 2 >COS2 X 0 + < X l I 2 >sin2 X0 - 2 <XlXii > s i n x 0 cosg0
(24)
y2 > = < x i 2 >sin 2 Xo+<Xii 2 >cos 2 go +2 <xixii > s i n x o cosgo If the principal directions for the chain orientation were X 0 and 7~0+rt/2 at all scales, the mean value of the product XlXn would be zero (due to the symmetry of the conformation distribution with respect to the I and II axes). In this case, the following relations between the mean square chain dimensions would hold: R g,x = Rgj 2 COS2 X0 + Rg,II 2 sin2 X0 2 = Rgj 2 si n 2 Zo + RgjI 2 cOs2 X0 Rg,y
(25)
In Table 7, the experimental values ofR~. ,,x and Rg,y determined in the x-z and y-z shearing planes are compared to the values calculate~l from Rg,I, Rg,i I and g 0 according to Eq. 25. The observed agreement indicates that the q-dependence of ~ at local scales as shown in Fig. 29 has little influence on the mean square chain dimensions Rg,i and Rg, II. As a matter of fact, these quantities are determined in the low q-range and involve mainly large scale position correlations for which the principal directions of orientation are equal to ~ 0 and X 0+zc/2-
92 In section 3.1.3. we proposed a simple model to calculate the anisotropic form factor of the chains in a uniaxially deformed polymer melt. The only parameters are the deformation ratio Z, of the entanglement network (which was assumed to be identical to the macroscopic recoverable strain) and the number ne of entanglements per chain. For a chain with dangling end submolecules the mean square dimension in a principal direction of orientation is then given by Eq. 19. As seen in section 3.1.3. for low stress levels n can be estimated from the plateau modulus and the molecular weight of the chain (n~-5 por polymer S 1). The molecular deformation ratio Z, in the directions I and II can be estimated in the following way: the difference Ao between the principal stresses in the x-y plane can be readily calculated from the birefringence A (measured parallel and perpendicular to the direction of extinction) and the stress-optical coefficient C for molten polystyrene (C = 4.8x10"gPa"1, see Chapter III. 1). According to the classical network theory, the stress tensor is proportional to the Cauchy deformation tensor which means that the network deformation along the principal directions of the stress tensor are Z, and I/Z, where:
k2 __}_.1 = Ao
(26)
The values of Z, calculated from Eq. 26 are given in Table 8. It should be pointed out that the classical rubber theory does not account for a dependence of molecular orientation on the considered length scale, as found for sample C in Fig. 29. Therefore the simplistic approach presented here should in principle be restricted to samples A and B for which the principal directions for the low-q SANS data (I and II) are close to the principal directions for the refractive index. The data in Table 8 actually show a satisfactory agreement between calculated and experimental mean square chain dimensions for samples A and B. For sample C, the agreement is less satisfactory in the direction perpendicular to the chain elongation, but one must be aware that for this sample, the directions in which Rg I and Rg, i I have been measured are different from those corresponding to the calculation of Eq. 26.
Table 8 Extension ratio and root mean square dimensions in the principal directions of stress calculated from the network model (see text). . ..... Sample
A
B
. . . . .
C
A XA AO (Pa) Z, l/Z,
9.4x 10.4 26~ 2• 105 1.27 0.79
1.08x 10-3 24~ 2.3• 105 1.32 0.76
3.8x 10-3 22"5~ 8.1• 105 2.07 0.48
Rg(~) (A) I/Z,) (A) ,I (~) ,II (A)
98 70 94 73
101 69 99 69
148 56 143 47
93
5. CONCLUSIONS AND PERSPECTIVES The reliability of the experimental procedure (deformation in the melt, quenching, characterization of orientation at room temperature) could be verified in elongation (specimens quenched for different macroscopic extensions in steady elongational flow) as well as in simple shear (good correlation of the chain dimensions measured in all principal shear directions). In the uniaxial elongational flow geometry, the proposed model of a temporary network leads to a satisfactory description of the SANS data both in the intermediate scattering vector range and in the Guinier range. The number of elastic strands per chain determined from both stress and SANS data is approximately the same. The agreement also holds for high molecular weight chains and binary blends. For these systems, SANS proves to be a powerful technique since selective deuteration allows one to characterize the orientation of the various components of the blends. For the characterization of chain orientation in shear, specific experimental problems had to be solved. An apparatus was specifically designed for the purpose of quenching thick specimens oriented in simple shear with good homogeneity of orientation throughout the thickness. The data obtained with the scattering vector in the x-y principal shearing plane showed that the principal directions of orientation depend on the magnitude of the scattering vector, and therefore on the considered length scale on the chain. On the other hand, the position correlations within the chain in the neutral direction of the flow have been found to remain unaffected by the shear deformation. It should be mentionned that the result of q-dependent chain orientation in shear was also found by nonequilibrium molecular dynamics (NEMD) simulations by Kr6ger et al [32]. The increasing power of computational techniques will surely result in increased accuracy and usefulness of this type of numerical simulation.
REFERENCES
.
.
.
9. 10. 11.
Doi M. and Edwards S.F., The Theory of Polymer Dynamics, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1986. Bird R. B., Armstrong R.C. and Hassager O., Dynamics of Polymeric Liquids, Wiley, New York, 1987. Higgins J.S. and Benoit H., Polymer and Neutron Scattering, Oxford Science Publications, 1994. Picot C., Static and Dynamic Properties of the Polymeric Solid State, NATO Advanced Study Series, Vol.94, Pethrick A. and Richards R.W. (Eds), Reidel Publishing. Cotton J.P., Decker D., Benoit H., Farnoux B., Higgins J., Jannink G., Ober R., Picot C. and des Cloizeaux J., Macromolecules, 7 (1975) 863. Kirste R.G., Kruse W.A. and Ibel K., Polymer, 16 (1975) 20. Daoud M., Cotton J.P., Famoux B., Jannink G., Sarma G., Benoit H., Duplessix R., Picot C. and de Gennes P.G., Macromolecules, 8 (1975) 804. Picot, C., Prog. Colloid Polym. Sci., 75 (1987) 83. Muller R., Picot C., Zang Y.H. and Froelich D., Macromolecules 23 (1990) 2577. Bou6 F., Bastide J. and Buzier M., Springer Proc. Phys., 42 (1988) 65. Lindner P and OberthOr R., Colloid Polym. Sci., 263 (1985) 443.
94 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 28. 29. 30. 31.
Lindner P. and Oberth0r R., Physica B, 156 (1989) 410. Muller R., Pesce J.J. arid Picot C., Macromolecules, 26 (1993) 4356. Bastide J., Herz J. and Bou6 F., J. Phys. (Les Ulis, Ft.) 46 (1985) 1967. Muller, R; and Froelich D., Polymer, 26 (1985) 1477. De Cremes P.G., Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics, Comell University Press, 1979. M0nstedt H., Rheol. Acta, 14 (1975) 1077. MOnstedt, H. and Laun H.M., Rheol. Acta, 18 (1979) 492. Delaby I., Ernst B., Germain Y. and Muller R., J. Rheol., 38 (1994) 1705. Rouse P.E., J. Chem. Phys., 21 (1953) 1272. Ferry J.D., Landel R.F. and Williams M.L., J. Appl. Phys., 26 (1955) 359. Rabin Y., J.Chem.Phys., 88 (1988) 4014. Green M.S. and Tobolsky A.V., J. Chem. Phys., 14 (1946) 80. Yamamoto M., J.Phys.Soc.Japan, 11 (1956)413; 12 (1957) 1148; 13 (1958) 1200. Lodge A.S., Armstrong R.C., Wagner M.H. and Winter H.H., Pure Appl. Chem., 54 (1982) 1349. Wagner M.H., Rheol. Acta, 18 (1979) 33. Muller R., Froelich D. and Zang Y.H., J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 25 (1987) 295. Bou6 F., Bastide J., Buzier M., Lapp A., Herz J. and Vilgis T.A., Colloid Polym. Sci., 269, 195 (1991). Ullman R., Macromolecules, 15 (1982) 1395. Muller, R. and Picot, C., Makromol. Chem., Macromol. Symp., 56 (1992) 107. Lindner P., Neutron, X-Ray and Light Scattering, Lindner P. and Zemb T. (Eds); North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1991. KrOger M., Loose W. and Hess S., J. Rheol., 37 (1993) 1057.
Rheology for Polymer Melt Processing J-M. Piau and J-F. Agassant (editors) 9 1996 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
95
Molecular Rheology and Linear Viscoelasticity G. Marin and J.P. Monffort Laboratoire de Physique des Matdriaux Industriels, URA-CNRS 1494, Universit6 de Pau et des Pays de r Adour, 64000 Pau (France) 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N M e a s u r e m e n t of the linear viscoelastic properties is the basic rheological characterization of polymer melts. These properties may be evaluated in the time domain (mainly creep and relaxation experiments) or in the frequency domain: in this case we will talk about mechanical spectroscopy, where the sample experiences a harmonic stimulus (either stress or strain). One may use the linear viscoelastic data as a pure rheological characterization, and relate the viscoelastic parameters to some processing or final properties of the m a t e r i a l u n d e r study. F u r t h e r m o r e , linear viscoelasticity a n d n o n l i n e a r viscoelasticity are not different fields that would be disconnected: in most cases, a linear viscoelastic function (relaxation fimction, memory function or distribution of relaxation times) is used as the kernel of non linear constitutive equations, either of the differential or integral form. That means that if we could define a general nonlinear constitutive equation t h a t would work for all flexible chains, the knowledge of a single linear viscoelastic function would lead to all rheological properties. On the other side, the linear viscoelastic functions of polymer melts are directly related to their molecular structure, and these relations are now defined well enough to derive, with a reasonable accuracy, what would be the linear viscoelastic behaviour of a given species from its molecular weight distribution, at least in the case of linear polymers. Moreover, there is a definite trend to use rheology as a molecular characterization tool, in the same way as other popular spectroscopic methods such as N.M.R spectroscopy or Size Exclusion C h r o m a t o g r a p h y . However, the inverse problem, i.e., getting molecular weight distribution from rheological measurements, is a difficult (and ill-defined) problem, and this is a very up-to-date area of research due to its obvious practical implications in polymer characterization. The relationship between chemical structure and viscoelastic behaviour is established through molecular models considering that polymers relax or diffuse in the same way: they are considered as flexible statistical chains trapped between the topological constraints created by the surrounding chains.
96 2. L I N E A R VISCOELASTIC BEHAVIOUR OF L I N E A R AND FLEXIBLE CHAINS . BASICS AND P H E N O M E N O L O G Y We will begin with a brief survey of linear viscoelasticity (section 2.1) 9we will define the various material functions and the mathematical theory of linear viscoelasticity will give us the mathematical bridges which relate these functions. We will then describe the main features of the linear viscoelastic behaviour of polymer melts a n d c o n c e n t r a t e d solutions in a p u r e l y r a t i o n a l a n d phenomenological way (section 2.2)" the simple and important conclusions drawn from this analysis will give us the support for the molecular models described below (sections 3 to 6). 2.1. L i n e a r viscoelastic functions The measurable linear viscoelastic functions are defined either in the time domain or in the frequency domain. The interrelations between functions in the frequency domain are purely algebraic. The interrelations between functions in the time domain are convolution integrals. The interrelations between functions in the time and frequency domain are Carson-Laplace or inverse Carson-Laplace transforms. Some of these interrelations will be given below, and a general scheme of these interrelations may be found in [1]. These interrelations derive directly from the mathematical theory of linear viscoelasticity and do not imply any molecular or continuum mechanics modelling. In t h e various f o r m u l a t i o n s of the m a t h e m a t i c a l t h e o r y of l i n e a r viscoelasticity, one should differentiate clearly the m e a s u r a b l e and nonmeasurable functions, especially when it comes to modelling: a p a r t from the material functions quoted above, one may also define non-measurable viscoelastic functions which are pure mathematical objects, such as the distribution of relaxation times, the distribution of retardation times, and the memory function. These mathematical tools may prove to be useful in some situations: for example, a discrete distribution of relaxation times is easy to handle numerically when working with constitutive equations of the differential type, but one has to keep in mind that the relaxation times derived numerically by optimization methods have no direct physical meaning. Furthermore, the use of the distribution of relaxation times is useless and costs precision when one wishes simply to go back and forth from the time domain to the frequency domain. This warning is important, given the large use (and sometimes overuse) of these distribution functions. 2.1.1. Functions in the time domain The relaxation modulus G(t) is the value of the transient stress per unit strain in a step-strain experiment. This type of experiment may be achieved with modern rotary rheometers with a limited resolution in time (roughly 10 -2 s). If one wishes to evaluate G(t) at shorter times, it is necessary to derive G(t) from the high frequency G*(co) data by an inverse Carson-Laplace transform. The creep function J(t) is the transient strain per unit stress in a step-stress experiment. The resolution at short times is also limited from instr~ment response and sensitivity. J(t) at short times may also be derived from the high frequency complex compliance data.
97 One m a y also use a memory function m(t) within the integral formulation of l i n e a r a n d nonlinear viscoelasticity; this memory function m(t), which is t h e derivative of the relaxation function G(t), is not a measurable function.
2.1.2. Functions in the frequency domain Three complex functions m a y be used to characterize the linear viscoelastic behaviour in the frequency domain" - The complex shear modulus, which is the complex stress to complex strain ratio" G * (co) = complex stress c*(r - ------- = G'(co)+ j G"(co) y*(~) complex strain
(2-1)
- The complex viscosity, which is the complex stress to complex rate of strain ratio" 11"(o)) =
complex stress = (co-----)) ~* = Tl' (co)- j 11"(o)) = ~ _*(co) _G complex rate of strain ~/* (co) jco
(2-2)
- The complex compliance, which is the complex strain to complex stress ratio" j .(co) = complex strain = 7*(co) = j,(co)_ j j,,(co) = 1 (2-3) complex stress ~* (co) G* (co) These three functions are related via simple algebraic relations" G * (co) = ~
1
J*(r
= jco T1* (co)
(2-4)
Although the complex shear modulus is not the most appropriate function to use in all cases, we will describe the linear viscoelastic behaviour in terms of this last function, which is the most referred to experimentally; furthermore, molecular models are mostly linked to the relaxation modulus, which is the inverse Fourier transform of the complex shear modulus.
2.1.3. The distribution of relaxation times By analogy with a generalized Maxwell model, it is possible to write the relaxation modulus or the complex modulus as a sum of the contributions of n individual Maxwell models" 12
G(t)=~G k=l
12
k(t)=~G ke
----
t
~k
(2-5)
k=l 4oo
and G * (co)= jco ~ G(t) e -j~t dt 0
(2-6)
98 n
n
hence G*(co)= ~ G k *(co)= ~ jOTlk k:l k=ll+f~k
(2-7)
with Tlk=Gk~k. In terms of molecular models (section 3), the set of individual times ~k and weighting factors Gk is imposed by the model. It is also possible to derive a set of relaxation times and weighting factors numerically by optimization or approximation methods from the experimental data. In that case, the relaxation times have no real physical meaning and are simply numerical/empirical parameters which allows one to represent the viscoelastic behaviour as a sum of decaying exponentials which are handy to use for numerical analysis. It is also possible to give integral forms of these sums" oo
G * (co) = jr
H(z) 0 ~+jcoz dz +oo
(2-8)
t
and G(t)= ~ H(z)e ~ d ln(z)
(2-9)
--oo
H(z) is a continuous distribution of the logarithms of relaxation times and is called the "relaxation spectrum" by rheologists, whilst the "true" distribution of relaxation times is zH(z). We have r e p o ~ on Figure I the normalized distribution of relaxation times for 4 polystyrene samples with polydispersity indices ranging from 1.05 to 4.2 [2]. It is clear that the distribution of relaxation times broadens with the distribution of molecular weights; these features will be analyzed in terms of molecular models in sections 3 to 6.
A
v
o
I
-3
-2
-I
0 Log z / Z o
+1
*2
Figure 1 9Reduced distribution of relaxation times for atactic polystyrene samples having different values of polydispersity index P=l.05 (A), 1.25 (B), 2.45 (C), 4.2 (D)[ref. 2]
99 2.2. T h e m a i n f e a t u r e s of the l i n e a r viscoelastic b e h a v i o u r of p o l y m e r melts: We will discuss in this section the variations of the viscoelastic parameters derived from linear viscoelastic measurements; all these parameters may be derived from any type of m e a s u r e m e n t (relaxation or creep experiment, mechanical spectroscopy) performed in the relevant time or frequency domain. The discussion will be focused however on the complex shear modulus which is the basic function derived from isothermal frequency sweep measurements performed with modern rotary rheometers.
-
log G* (W)
G,.-...-..~ ~ - . - - . ~
G' ~ G
fMu
-//,,'M2 f
~~
G o'
G
t er min al
e
log UJ plat eau
POLYMERIC
"BEHAVIOUR
transition
glass y
SMALL SCALE MOLECULAR MOTIONS
Figure 2 9Schematic of the variations of the complex shear modulus of linear polymers (dotted lines: molecular weight M2>M1). The main features of the linear viscoelastic behaviour of polymeric melts in the frequency domain are reported on Figure 2 : - the lowest frequency range describes the slowest relaxation motions of the macromolecules. The double logarithmic plot of G' and G" exhibits slopes of -respectively- 2 and 1, leading to two characteristic parameters. The zero-shear viscosity" ~o = lim G"(co____~) co-,0
CO
(2-10)
100
The limiting compliance:
G'(r j0=lim ~-~o [G"(co)] 2
=1
limG'(c~
Tioz ~-,o r ~
(2-11)
which is the elastic parameter governing the main features of the elasticity of the melt (first normal stress difference, extrudate swell, etc...). The zero-shear viscosity is the norm of the relaxation spectr~m :
Tlo= ~~H(z)d In z
(2-12)
The product TIo jo is the characteristic relaxation time zo of the terminal region. In terms of molecular models, this time scales as the longest relaxation time. In terms of the distribution of relaxation times H(z), zo is the "weight-average relaxation time" which is the average relaxation time related to the second order moment of the relaxation spectm~m : ~o = no jo =< ~w >= ~ z2H(z)d In
(2-13)
At intermediate frequencies, monodisperse polymers exhibit a well-defined "plateau region" where G'= constant G~ (Figure 2). For a given macromolecular species, the value of the plateau modulus is a characteristic feature t h a t does not depend on molecular weight. The only way to lower the plateau modulus is to add small compatible molecules, either of the same species or not : this is, for example, what is done for Hot-Melt Adhesives (HMAs) when adding a "tackifying resin" which softens the polymer and improves the "tack". In terms of the distribution of relaxation times, the ratio TIo/G~ is an average relaxation time (we may call it "n-tuber-average relaxation time"), which is the first order moment of the normalized relaxation spectm, m : < ZN >= no/ G~ = i ~H(z)d In H(~)d In z
(2-14)
The ratio: < Zw >
o co = Je
(2-15)
<~N >
is a "polydispersity index of relaxation times" which characterizes the broadness of the distribution of relaxation times. For monodisperse species, the experimental value of this ratio lies between 2 and 2.5, whatever the polymer nature. This value increases largely as polydispersity increases. One of the direct practical
lO1 applications of molecular modelling will be to relate the distribution of molecular weights to the distribution of relaxation times.
2.2.1. The effects of chain length 2.2.1.1. The zero-shear viscosity Tl0 The variations of the zero-shear viscosity of monodisperse polymeric melts and concentrated solutions exhibit two domains, each being characterized as a first approximation by a power law exponent" at low molecular weights, corresponding to less than 200 monomeric units, the exponent lies between 1 and 1.5. This domain will be analyzed in section 5. above a critical molecular weight Mc, the power law exponent is 3.4-3.5. As far as viscosity is concerned, Mc defines the begining of a regime where the macromolecular chains are viewed as "entangled", which explains the large molecular weight dependence of viscosity. The entangled regime will be modelled later using the "reptation" concept (see section 3). -
-
f
!
i
i 0 K)
_
/
o/+
13
vi r I0 e n
I'--I
(J
o
o
c;
.
~_
/,
/
g
/
#o,+
IO s -
o/
_
0
10 4 -
10 2 10 3
I
10 4
I
10 5
I
10 6
log M
Figure 3 : Molecular weight dependence of the structure factor of nearly monodisperse polystyrene samples [3]. Figure 3 illustrates this type of behaviour for various series of anionic polystyrene samples with a fairly narrow distribution of molecular weights. In the case of entangled polydisperse materials (Mw>>Mc), the zero-shear viscosity follows approximately the same molecular weight dependence as for monodisperse species when the viscosity data is plotted as a function of the weight-average molecular weight Mw; i.e. : 110 = A(T) M~ 4
(2-16)
I02 2.2.1.2. The plateau modulus G~ The plateau region begins to be developed at molecular weights somewhat above Mc; it is however a well-defined elastic parameter for a given chemical species of high molecular weight. Comparing different polymer species, its value increases with the flexibility of the chain (i.e: GNPolystyrene< o o GNPolyethylene). The use of the theory of rubber elasticity may give an order of magnitude of the average molecular weight Me between entanglements which create a temporary network: G~ = pRT
(2-17)
Me '
p being the polymer density and T the absolute temperature. The critical molecular weight Mc is roughly two times the molecular weight between entanglements Me.
2.2.1.3. The limiting compliance jo In the entangled regime, the limiting compliance jo of monodisperse samples is also an elasticconstant characterizing a given polymer chemical species: contrary to the plateau modulus, its value depends on the distribution of molecular weights, i.e.,on the polydispersity index as a firstapproximation. This is a very important point, as m a n y elasticeffects(firstnormal stress difference,extrudate swell, ...)of the melt are governed by the limitingcompliance. For purely monodisperse samples, the product jo G ~ has a value close to 2 for all flexiblepolymers. Below the entangled regime, the limiting compliance follows approximately a linear dependence with molecular weight according to Rouse's theory (see section 6)jo = 0.4 M . pRT
(2-18)
The molecular weight value M'c where the compliance becomes independent of molecular weight is larger than M c (M'c--3Mc), which indicates that the "polymeric" regime seems to appear at higher molecular weights for elastic properties compared with viscous properties. So one has to keep in mind that the chain length (or molecular weight) at which "entanglements" effects begin to appear depends strongly on the physical property measured (melt viscosity, melt elasticity,self-diffusion,etc...)(see in particular chapter L1). In the case of polydisperse polymers, the limiting compliance increases strongly with the broadness of the distribution of molecular weights. The limiting compliance is not, however, a simple function of the polydispersity index, because its value depends on the shape of the distributionitself.There is indeed no simple correlation with any molecular weight moments (averages), and molecular models will be really helpful to describe the elasticity of the melt.
103
2.2.2. The effect of temperature: For a given polymer, the viscoelastic curves (either moduli or compliances) obtained at different temperatures in the plateau and terminal regions are simply afflne in the frequency (or time) scale, in a double logarithmic plot. The use of this time-temperature equivalence allows one to obtain "master curves" at a reference temperature, which enlarges considerably the experimental window. For glass-forming materials such as polystyrene, polymethylmetacrylate, polycarbonate, polymerists describe the shift factor aT in terms of the WLF equation: -c~ -To) In aT = (co + T - T o ) '
(2-19)
T being the experimental temperature and To the reference temperature to which the data is shifted. The WLF may be reduced to the Vogel equation which describes the viscosity of molten glasses and supercooled liquids"
B/af
In a T = _T0 ---~-
B/af W-'-~_ '
(2-20)
where the limiting temperature Too may be related to the glass transition temperature Tg by the approximate rule: Tg-Too = c2g -- 60 ~ C. The entropic nature of the elasticity of the melt implies also a slight vertical sbJR in the plateau and terminal regions. This shi~" b T = P~176 pT'
(2-21)
may be neglected when using the time-temperature equivalence in a limited range of temperatures. The time-temperature equivalence implies that the viscosity (or relaxation times) of polymers may be written as the product of two functions : no = $(P(M)). M (T)
(2-22)
The mobility factor M (T) describes the segmental mobility of the chain : it depends mostly on temperature and pressure, but may be affected by the presence of small chains (such as solvent molecules or small chains of the same chemical species as the polymer). For concentrated polymer solutions, the addition of small molecules affects mostly the glass transition temperature (hence Too), and the value of B (eq.2-20) is essentially the same as for the bulk polymer. A plastifyer will decrease the value of Too, and hence increase the segmental mobility. On the contrary, the addition of a tackifying resin which has a higher Tg than the polymer will increase the segmental mobility of the polymer in the case of formulations of Hot-Melt adhesives.
104 The structure factor $(P(M)) describes the topological relaxation of the macromolecular chains: t ~ s is the function which will be described by molecular models, P(M) being the distribution of molecular weights. Here lies a very impo~t point: if one wishes to "isolate" the topological effects in order to test molecular models, one has to use rheological functions defined at the same segmental mobility, and hence the same value of the mobility factor: as far as viscosity is concerned, the reduced function Tlo/M (T) will be used instead of the viscosity itself.
2.2.3 The effects of concentration (concentrated solutions): In the case of concentrated entangled solutions, the "elastic" parameters follow power law dependences as a function of polymer volume fraction r : 0 GN)sol=(GN)bulk
( 0
{~{~
( jO)sol=(jO)bulk ~ - a
(2-23) (2-24)
with an exponent a - 2-2.3 for entangled chains, so the product jo G~(which reflects the polydispersity of relaxation times) remains the same whatever the concentration. That means that the effects of the addition of small compatible species on the elastic parameters are mainly topological, i.e., the nature itself of the solvent molecules has a very small effect on the melt elasticity and the shape of the distribution of relaxation times. On the contrary, the effects of dilution on the polymer viscosity will be twofold : - a topological effect on the structure factor $ that will be described by molecular models; a change of the mobility factor M, that may either increase or decrease, depending on the plastifying -or antiplasfif3dng- effect of the molecules added to the polymer. -
2.2.4 The self-similarity of the viscoelastic behaviour of flexible chains The above phenomenological description of the viscoelastic behaviour of polymer melts and concentrated solutions leads to the following i m p o r t a n t conclusions 9if one focuses on the behaviour in the terminal region of relaxation, what is usually done for temperature (time-temperature equivalence) may also be done for the concentration effects and the effects of chain length; one may define a "time-chain length equivalence" and "time-concentration equivalence"[4]. For monodisperse species, the various shifts along the vertical (modulus) axis and horizontal (time or frequency axis) are contained in two reducing parameters: the plateau modulus G~ and a characteristic relaxation time, either Zw = qo jo or ZN = rio/G~. A plot of G*(cOZo)/G~ - where zo is either T~Vo r 1; s - in the terminal relaxation region is a universal function independent of temperature, concentration, chain length, and independent also of the chemical nature of the polymer (Figure 4). This self-similarity of the viscoelastic behaviour of monodisperse linear chains, whatever their chemical structure, may be extended to polydisperse species having the same shape of the molecular weight distribution (i.e., the same
105 polydispersity index as a first approximation). This implies some universality in the large-times relaxation processes of entangled polymers. As a consequence, the general features of the mechanical relaxation of long and flexible polymeric chains will be described by molecular models that do not "see" the local structure but describe the overall diffusion and relaxation of these chains in a universal way. Hence the power of the models described below lie in their universality:, it is easy to shift from one polymer to another, changing only a few parameters linked to the local scale structure of the polymer under study.
0-
o
@
-2
l
-I
I
0 log (~qo G~
I
I
,_,
I
2
Figure 4 : Master curve for the linear viscoelastic behaviour of entangled polymers in the terminal region of relaxation : V Polystyrene, bulk (M=860000, T=190~ Q Polyethylene, bulk (M=340000, T=130~ A Polybutadiene solution (M=350000, polymer=43%, T=20~ [from ref.4]. 3. THE CASE OF E N T A N G L E D M O N O D I S P E R S E L I N E A R S P E C I E S : PURE REPTATION
3.1. The basic reptation model The reptation concept was introduced by de Gennes [5] in 1971: it is based on the idea that long and flexible entangled chains rearrange their conformations by reptation, i. e., curvilinear diffusion along their own contour. De Gennes considered the reptation of a linear chain among the strands of a crosslinked network which create p e r m a n e n t topological obstacles. First, the dynamics of the wriggling motion of the chain along its own contour (what Doi and Edwards called later the primitive path) was described by de Gennes in terms of a diffusion equation of a "defect gas": he showed that this motion is fairly rapid: its longest relaxation time Teq is proportional to M 2, where M is the molecular weight of the chain (that time Teq would be equivalent to the ~B relaxation time in the slip-link model; see text below and Fig.8).
106
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
Q
9
Figure 5 9The basic concept of P.G. De Gennes 9reptation of a chain trapped in a tube-like region by migration of "defects" along the chain. At times t >Teq, the wriggling motion results merely in a fluctuation around the primitive path, so the chain moves coherently in a one-dimension diffusion process, k e e p i n g its arc length constant. The macroscopic diffusion coefficient of a reptating chain scales with chain length (molecular weight) as" D o, M-2,
(3-1)
and the time for complete rearrangement of conformation" 1; o~ M 3.
(3-2)
This time is the longest relaxation time of a linear chain. We will refer to it as the "reptation time".
e
,
~
-
,
.
e
/
.-
Figure 6 9The tube concept: The real chain is trapped between entanglements and is wriggling aroud the "primitive chain" (full line).
Doi and Edwards used this concept to derive the viscoelasticproperties of polymer liquids from the dynamics of reptating chains [6]. They ass1~med that
107 reptation would be the dominant relaxation process for polymer melts, even in the absence of a permanent network. This is a very strong assumption, as the topological constraints are made by surrounding chains that also diffuse by reptation. This assumption was justified later when analyzing the constraints release (or tube renewal) process (section 4).
~/
I "- \ ?
J
f /
~\
\ __kJ
Figure 7 9Reptation: the chain disengages from its initial tube by back-and-forth motions; the time necessary for a complete renewal of its initial configuration is the "reptation time" which is the longest relaxation time of the polymer. When analyzing the overall diffusion of a single chain due to Brownian motion, the topological constraints made by the surrounding chains confine the chain in a tube-like region. The centreline of the tube is called the "primitive path" and can be regarded as the curve which has the same topology as the real chain relative to the other polymer molecules; the real chain is then wriggling around the primitive path. The Doi-Edwards calculation is based on the theory of rubber elasticity. In order to calculate the time-dependent properties, the contribution of individual chains to the stress following a step strain is evaluated; then the relaxation of the stress is related to the conformational rearrangement of the chains by a reptation process. For this calculation, the topological constraints along the chain are represented by frictionless rings around the chain (Fig. 8), which is another way of describing entanglements. The succession of segments ("primitive segments") joining these "slip-links" along the chain is called the "primitive chain". As the sliplinks are now local constraints, the continuous nature of the constraints is accounted for by assuming a natural curvilinear monomer density along the chain. So all three models (reptation among fixed obstacles/tube model/slip-links model : Figs. 5 to 8) are equivalent in essence. When submitting the polymer sample to a sudden deformation (step strain), the primitive path is distorted by affine deformation (Fig. 8b), and the curvilinear monomer density is perturbed from its equilibrium value.
108
B
D
A
C
a) t < O : e q u i l i b r i u m
A
C
F
E
c) t--_ 1;a ( A p r o c e s s )
state
E
b) t = O : s t e p s t r a i n C
E
d) t _=_ ~s (B p r o c e s s )
C~
B'
E~
D'
e) t =_ 1:c (C p r o c e s s : reptation)
Figure 8 " Relaxation of a polymeric chain after a step-strain deformation[6]: process A (8c): reequilibration of chain segments; process B (8d): reequilibration across slip links; process C (8e): reptation. Then the chain will relax: The f i ~ t relaxation process (called the A relaxation process; Fig. 8c) which occurs at the shortest times will be a local reequilibration of monomers without slippage through the slip-links. In other words, it is basically a Rouse relaxation process between entanglement points which are assumed to be fixed in that time scale. The characteristic relaxation time of this process is rather short and is independent of the overall chain length (see below). The second relaxation process (B process; Fig. 8d) is a reequilibration of segments along the overall chain, i.e., across slip-links. It is basically a retraction of the chain to recover its natural curvilinear monomer density, which may be depicted as a Rouse relaxation process along the entire chain. In the last relaxation process (C process; Figs. 7 and 8e), the chain renews its entire configuration by reptation. The viscosity, p l a t e a u modulus, limiting compliance and m a x i m u m (terminal) relaxation time derived from the basic D-E model are power laws of the molecular weight M: Tlo or M 3, G~ or M o, jo or M 0, to = ~o jo o~ M 3,
(3-3)
109
and
jOG~=6. 5
All viscoelastic functions may be expressed in terms of a single reptation parameter (for example the plateau modulus or tube diameter) and the monomeric friction coefficient (or mobility factor in our terminology), in agreement with the above phenomenological presentation. If the general features of the viscoelastic behaviour are well depicted, the experimental molecular weight dependence of these parameters is : 110or M3.4, G~ o~ M o, jo o~ M o,
(3-4)
~0 = T10jo or M3.4, and j O G ~ = 2 . In particular, the fact that the experimental "polydispersity of relaxation times" jo G~ is larger than the theoretical value indicates the presence of other relaxation processes. In the following section we will describe a somewhat different analytical derivation of the Doi-Edwards model taking into account additional relaxation processes (in particular the Ta (glass transition) relaxation). Our derivation, which gives a good quantitative agreement with the observed linear viscoelastic behaviour for a large number of linear polymers, keeps however the basic physical concepts of the reptation model. Hence this model is dedicated only to the case of entangled linear monodisperse species. The case of branched polymers, polydispersity and short chains effects will be presented in, respectively, sections 4,5 and 6. The same basic models are also used in chapter 1.1 and 1.3. In chapter 1.1, the mutual diffusion in polymer melts is related to the reptation and constraint release processes, whereas in chapter 1.3 the relaxation of chain segments along the polymer chain is investigated in terms of the some relaxation mechanisms as described below. 3.2. Detailed d e r i v a t i o n of linear viscoelastic p r o p e r t i e s of l i n e a r s p e c i e s [7] 3.2.1. The (A) relaxation process That relaxation process may be defined as a Rouse diffusion between entanglement points. The characteristic relaxation time of the (A) process is : ~ob2 N 2, 1;A = 6~2ksT
(3-5)
where Ne is the number of monomers between e n t a n g l e m e n t points, ks Boltzmann's constant, T the absolute temperature, b the effective monomer length
110 (b=C~o 1,1 being the monomer length) and ~o the monomeric friction coefficient. The relaxation function associated to the (A) process is :
FA(t) =
expF-L P~At],J
(3-6)
p=l
where Ne is the number of Kuhn segments between entanglements. In order to define completely the relaxation function, we have to determine the initial modulus
G'N SO: O(t) = GN FA(t),
(3-7)
G'N is a function of strain and may be written as : GN = pRT
1
Me (~Ul>o ,
(3-8)
w h e r e p is the polymer density, E is the strain tensor, u a unit vector corresponding to the vector linking two entanglement points (slip-link segment) [6]; 1 the < ~ / o term expresses the fact that the molecule is outside its equilibrium configuration" from Doi-Edwards theory G N = 4 pRT.
5 Me
We may then write the relaxation modulus corresponding to the (A) relaxation process (short times) as :
N~e x p [ _ p t21 GA(t) = 4 pRT ~ 5 M e p=l L ZA J"
(3-9)
3.2.2. The (B) relaxation process Doi and Edwards postulate that the chain recovers its equilibrium monomer density along its contour by a retraction motion of the chain within the tube. That motion, induced by the chain ends, leads to a relaxation function : 8
FB(t) =
poddZp2/t;2
exp[-p2t] L -~-BJ'
(3-10)
with: ~0 b2N2 ~B =
3g2kBT
where N is the number of segments along the chain.
(3-11)
111 Viovy [8] describes that re-equilibration process as an exchange of monomers between neighbouring segments : he calls that process "reequilibration across sliplinks", and the corresponding relaxation function may be written as : N/Ne Ne [ p2t] FB(t)= ~ - - ~ - e x p - - - - - . p=l
(3-12)
~;B J
This function corresponds to a Rouse spacing of relaxation times and gives a better fit of the experimental data than Eq. 3-10. Hence the relaxation modulus of the (B) process may be written as a hmction of the entanglement density N/Ne:
G B(t)= 4 pRT N~~ Ne
5 Me
[ p2t]
-'NeXPL-Bj
(3-13)
3.2.3. Reptation: relaxation process C In that final relaxation process the molecule recovers its final isotropic configuration by a reptation motion. The characteristic time for the reptation process is (see also chapters L1 and L3):
1 ~0a2Ne(N) 3 ~:c =--g kBT "~e '
(3-14)
where a is the tube diameter (a 2 = Ne b2). The relaxation function is given in the original Doi-Edwards picture [5-8] by the equation" Fc(t)= E p28~2exp[-p2t]
podd
(3-15)
k "~'CJ
The plateau modulus of that relaxation domain is :
=RT
(3-16)
Me ' and hence the relaxation modulus is: Go(t)= pRT
8 exp[-pat] podd
(3-17)
k -~-cJ
The refinement introduced by Doi [9] who considers tube length fluctuations is more relevant to experimental scaling laws as far as the viscosity/molecular weight dependence is concerned. Following that concept, Gc(t) can be cast into the integral form :
112
Oct':0RT[ Me JO4N/N~
e
'/ '
/
- ~ ( i i d~ + ~2v/s, exp - ~(2i
~,'
(3-18)
where N ~4v4 ~(1) = Ne 16 Zc
2v ~ < ~]N/Ne,
v
~(2) =
~ - 4N / Se
1 > ~ > ~~/'N/N~, 2v
~c
(3-19)
(3-20)
The v parameter may be approximated to 1 for highly entangled chains.
3.2.4. The Ta high-frequency relaxation domain: the transition region between the rubbery and glassy regions In order to give an analytical representation of the mechanical properties in the high frequency range characterizing local motions in the molecular chain, we used analytical forms derived from studies on dielectric relaxation : a Cole-Cole or Davidson-Cole equation generally gives a good fit in the transition region; we used in the present case a Davidson-Cole equation, that presents the advantages of being truncated at large times and to give analytical forms both in the time and frequency domains" G *HF = Goo -
Go. (1+ j ~ H F ) 1/2'
(3-21)
with"
1;HF -
~o 12 X2kBT
(3-22)
The inverse Fourier transform of Equation 3-21 gives the relaxation modulus"
]
(3-23)
Other m a t h e m a t i c a l forms may be used to describe the high frequency relaxation. These various equations, either phenomenological or based on diffusion defect models lead to a characteristic relaxation time ~;HFof the glass transition (Ta) domain of the same order of magnitude.
113 As a s u m m a r y , the characteristic relaxation times of the various relaxation mechanisms presented here above are linked to each other by (see also Chapter
1.3):
I:.~ = ~1 I:i Ne2 SB = 21;A( ~ ) 2 = ~l 1;i N2 N
(3-24)
N3
1;c = 3ZB ~ee = I;i Ne with ~i = ~0 b2 ~2kB T " 3.2.5. Viscoelastic function in the whole time/frequency domain Thus the relaxation modulus may be calculated from a very limited number of physical parameters (G ~ Goo and ~i), with no "ad-hoc" parameters, in a time range covering the initial glassy behaviour down to the terminal relaxation region. For a typical polymer, this range exceeds ten decades of times. The complete expression of the relaxation modulus is :
NINe exp - zr
G(t) = Me
+-
2v e exp 4N/N
~ 2)
[ p2tll + G~ [ 1 - e f t [ p2t 1 N~eNe exp--+ --~-exp5 Me L p=l I:AJ p=l ~BJJ
4pRTIN~e
(#--~) ] .
(3-25)
The complex shear modulus is the Fourier transform of Equation 2-25 : G * (co) = G~
2,,
f04N/Ne
jcozr 1+ jco~(1)
d~ +
~1
jco~r ] 2v d~ ~]N/ Ue 1+ jC0Z~(2)
NNe
+ -G~ e Ne jc0(1:B/p2) + jc0(~A/p2) 5 k p=l N l+jco(~ B/p2) p=l 1+ jco(xA/p2)
] I
+ Goo 1-
1 1
1 .(3-26) (1+ jO~HF)2
We have reported on Figs 9 through 12 a comparison between the experimental complex shear modulus and its theoretical calculation (full line) for two polymer species. The model fits reasonably well the linear viscoelastic properties of a large number of linear polymers ranging from polyolefins to glass-forming polymers. This calculation gives us the basic "long-chains monodisperse behaviour" which feeds the more complete derivation taking into account the effects of constraints release (section 5).
114
,oj.
1
f
8.-
- 8I
Eo
~-6
~,6 = o
4
4
i
-5
0
l
log t~ (sec -I]
5
I0
log ~
(sec-al
Figures 9 and 10 9storage (G') and loss (G") moduli of nearly monodisperse polystyrene samples at 25~ 9(A)M=900000; (Q)M=400000; (O)M=200000; (0) M=90000; full line ( )" theory (eq.3-25) [from ref. 7].
I~ f
/ 8~-
:
~'
I
1
i
"
'l
1
1
Io
l
~
;
~
~
;
J
!i 1
8
4 i
loq ~
(sec J]
log ~J (sec -~)
Figures 11 and 12: Storage (G') and loss (G") moduli of nearly monodisperse polybutadiene samples at 160~ (A)M=361000; (~)M=130000; (O)M=39400; full line ( ): theory (eq.3-25) [from ref.7]. 4. E N T A N G L E D M O D E L . B R A N C H E D POLYMERS Branched polymers may be classified into two categories from the point of view of rheology : - polymers with short branches (Marm<<Me, Marm being the branch molecular weight and Me the molecular weight between entanglements for the linear species). These polymers may be considered also as reptating species with a higher friction coefficient ~0, (hence a higher viscosity activation energy) and a
115
lower plateau modulus, so the formalism used for linear flexible polymers may still be used with a good approximation; - polymers with long entangled branches. In spite of the fact that the mlmber of branches per molecule is generally small, experimental data show a tremendous viscosity increase with branch length and a much wider distribution of relaxation times compared with linear polymers. On the other side, the plateau modulus values as well as the temperature dependence of viscosity and relaxation times are close to what is obtained for linear chains of the same species. Another difference with linear chains is the regular increase of the limiting compliance with molecular weight. We will deal in this review article with monodisperse, model-branched polymers in order to describe the basic relaxation modes of branched polymers. The concepts described below are the source of current attempts to describe the viscoelastic properties of complex tree-like structures which are close to those found in low density polyethylene, for example. One may found interesting approaches of that problem in recent papers presented by Mac Leish et al [10]. If one considers that the reptation process is dominant for linear chains, one has to imagine additional processes of diffusion for polymers with long branches. The experimental data suggest strongly, however, that the basic kinetic unit of the chain (whatever it is) is the same as for linear chains : the Rouse-like A and B processes are still there, which are still strong imprints of the "tube".
......
:
:
-.:
(a)
(b)
(c]
(d)
Figure 13 : T h e picture of de Gennes: "reptation of stars": the branch has to go back to its attachment point to renew its configuration. The basic models consider well-defined star-branched polymers. De Gennes [11] imagined in 1975 a simple relaxation mechanism of a branch based on the Brownian motion of an arm of a star-branched molecule in a network of fixed obstacles (Figure 13). From statistical considerations, the time necessary for a branch to renew its configuration is : I;m or f ( N a r m ) e x p ( k N arm)
where Narm stands for the number of chain segments per arm.
(4-1)
116 The e x ~ n e n t i a l dependence of the relaxation time with arm length is a constant feature for all models describing the renewal of configuration of long branches, and the debate has focused on the non-exponential term f(Narm). Doi and Kuzuu [6] have proposed a somewhat different approach based on the tube concept. They start with three basic assumptions : - the segments of a branch are confined within a tube; - the tube deforms amnely with the macroscopic deformation; the centre of the star is assumed to be fixed during the relaxation of the branch. The relaxation of a branch occurs by a retraction process within the tube and the branch end is a s s u m e d to be in a potential barrier. The m a x i m u m relaxation time of a branch is analogous to De Gennes' result (eq. 4-1) with a predicted value of v=8/15. Doi and Kuzuu [6] subsequently derived the the relaxation modulus of a star-branched polymer as : -
G(t)
4---G~ 15
ex
-
d~
with
z~ = Zrn ~2exp(a(~2-1))
(4-2)
(4-3)
8 Narm 15 N e "
with a=~.
"
i
" ~-A
9
9
9 ~e
9
9
9
9
"]'X2
9
i
: (a]
[b]
Figure 14 9Another picture of the disengagement of a branch from its initial p a t h is a '"oreathing" of the branch by fluctuations in path length. Pearson and Helfand [12] used a somewhat similar approach to determine the characteristic relaxation time for a branch to disentangle; their calculation leads to a similar form, with a different exponent for the front factor :
~rn~
Ne )
exp v Ne ).
(4-4)
I17
Ball and Mac Leish [13] used the same concept of the free end of a branch in a potential well, creating a process of"dynamic dilution" (Figure 15) which results in a v a r i a t i o n of the molecular weight between e n t a n g l e m e n t s during the disentanglement process of a branch. The mad'mum relaxation time of a branch is the same as that given in equation (4-4), but the relaxation modulus which takes into account the gradual disentanglement of the branch is given by" G(t) = ~
Jo
1
exp -
(4-5)
ds
Mann being the molecular weight of a branch.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 15 : The various models of Mac Leish lead rather to disengagement of a branch by fluctuations from its ends. The tree-like cloud is the trace of the agitation of chain segments over a period of time of the order of Zm. Some general important remarks may be formulated regarding the characteristic viscoelastic parameters of these polymers with long chain branching : the maximum relaxation time does not depend on the total molecular weight, but depends essentially on the molecular weight of the branch, and more precisely on the entanglement density of the branch Narm/Ne. - all models predict an exponential dependence of the zero-shear viscosity and terminal relaxation time as a function of the entanglement density on the branch. This is confirmed by the experimental data obtained on model-branched monodisperse samples. The v factor which appears in the exponential term is fairly close for all models, ranging from 0.5 to 0.625; this parameter is also related to the polydispersity of relaxation times jo G O(see section 2.2) as 9 -
jo G~ = 5 v Narm 4 Ne jo G~ = v -Sarrn --