Reading Biblical Poetry
READING BIBLICAL POETRY An Introductory Guide
J. P. Fokkelman
Translated by Ineke Smit
Wes...
383 downloads
3198 Views
9MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Reading Biblical Poetry
READING BIBLICAL POETRY An Introductory Guide
J. P. Fokkelman
Translated by Ineke Smit
Westminster John Knox Press LOUISVILLE • L O N D O N
Copyright © 2001 J. P. Fokkelman All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy ing, recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. For information, address West minster John Knox Press, 100 Witherspoon Street, Louisville, Kentucky 40202-1396. Cover design by Night & Day Design Interior design by Sharon Adams First edition Published by Westminster John Knox Press Louisville, Kentucky This book is printed on acid-free paper that meets the American National Standards Institute Z39.48 standard. @ PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 — 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 Library o f Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Fokkelman, J. P. Reading biblical poetry : an introductory guide / J.P. Fokkelman.— 1st ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-664-22439-3 (pbk.: alk. paper) 1. Hebrew poetry, Biblical—History and criticism. 2. Bible. O.T.— Language, style. I.Title. BS1405.2 .F67 2001 221.6'6—dc21 2001026227
Contents Preface 1
2
3
vii Preliminary exercise A strophe by Isaiah and a poem by David T h e art of poetry: a definition and analysis Components I and II: language and number
1
15
A text model and h o w to use it Language and number (continued)
37
4
Parallelism: cola and verses
61
5
T h e strophe
87
6
T h e stanza
117
7
T h e p o e m as a w h o l e
141
8
In search of the correct division The power of repetition
159
W i s d o m literature The book of Job
175
Love p o e t r y The Songs of Songs
189
T h e reader's attitude Productive questions and hints
207
9
10
11
12
Guidelines for further reading 150 and more poems, and their divisions
211
Glossary
225
Bibliographical notes
229
Notes
231
Index of biblical passages
237
Preface This b o o k is intended for those w h o do n o t read H e b r e w but have to rely o n a translation of the Bible. I have tried to put myself in their position as m u c h as possible, and w h e n I started writing I was fully resolved to refrain entirely from using information from the original texts, or at least to limit references to the original text to the utmost m i n i m u m . N o w that the b o o k is finished, however, I find that I have n o t always succeeded in this aim. Occasionally I have b e e n forced to refer to the original language after all, in order to keep m y argument transparent, and because the p o e m u n d e r consideration d e m a n d e d it. Moreover, I have frequently resorted to using m y o w n translations. This is not surprising. Poetry is the most ingenious form of ver bal expression. F u r t h e r m o r e , the poet's virtuosity permeates every level of the text, from sounds and syllables to strophes and even higher textual units; there is a b o x of tricks for every layer. T h e result is that anyone w h o discusses p o e t r y should be able to draw o n a similar extensive repertoire of tools; dealing w i t h poetry is a m u c h m o r e technical j o b than interpreting narrative prose. T h e n there are the readers, from w h o m considerably m o r e patience and stamina is required than in the case of prose w i t h its familiar forms of organization such as plot, time, etc. This b o o k is the c o m p l e m e n t to Reading Biblical Narrative, the A m e r i c a n edition of w h i c h appeared in 2000. At the same time, however, Reading Biblical Poetry is perfectly able to stand o n its o w n . This time I have m a d e m o r e allowances for the fact that the b o o k will b e consulted by college students. For their convenience, I have taken t w o measures: in the first place, every n o w and then there is a footnote containing a reference to the H e b r e w Bible or secondary literature. Secondly, I have also taken great pains over chapter 12, "Guidelines for further reading," w h i c h offers, a m o n g other information, for the first time ever the strophe divisions for
viii
Preface
all psalms.These data may serve as an incentive and a guide to the reader to try his or her o w n hand at tackling these puzzles. Even those "average" readers, w h o lack knowledge of the original text, will find that the tools offered here will enable t h e m to embark on this challenging enterprise. February 2001
1 Preliminary exercise A strophe by Isaiah and a poem by David
I n search o f t h e p o e t s o f t h e B i b l e W i t h i n the Bible, poetry is almost exclusively confined to the O l d Testament. Although poetic lines do occur regularly in the Gospels and the letters of the N e w Testament, these are actually quotations from the Psalms and the Prophets. In the first chapter of his Gospel, Luke includes two poems: the song of praise spoken by Mary w h e n she visits Elizabeth, w h o is later to b e c o m e the mother of J o h n (w. 46—55), and shordy afterwards, w h e n J o h n is born, the prophecy spoken over the child by his father Zechariah (w. 68—79). Both texts, however, owe everything to Hebrew poetics and its rules; they are mainly a collage of expressions and phrases from the O l d Testament. This means that we can safely confine our attention to the O l d Tes tament, which I will henceforth refer to as the H e b r e w Bible. This is a t e r m that is better suited to the Scriptures of both Ancient Israel and Jesus of Nazareth, as it is a collection of writings whose origin predates the Greek of the N e w Testament by centuries, and is totally independent of it from b o t h a literary and a religious point of view. W h e r e do we find the poems?The Hebrew Bible consists of 1,574 printed pages in the standard edition that is used worldwide for the study of the original text. A fairly accurate estimate would be that more than 37 percent of these, about 585 pages, contain poetry These figures, however, are fluid, as especially in Jeremiah, Ezekiel, and Ecclesiastes it is hard to determine the proportion of poetry to prose. Some scholars see more prose there than I do. If I h u m o r t h e m and lower my figure to 550 pages, this still means that almost 35 percent of the pages in the standard edition consists of poetic lines. If we take into account that these pages contain more white space than do the pages of the histories and law, w e can conclude that roughly one third of the Hebrew Bible consists of poetry. I call that quite a lot. 1
2
2
Reading Biblical Poetry
W h e r e exactly are the poems situated? For most texts, there is a quite definite answer to this question. T h e books of Psalms, Proverbs, Song of Songs, and Lamentations consist exclusively of poems, the b o o k of J o b almost exclusively. T h e books of Isaiah and the twelve so-called M i n o r Prophets (bar o n e ) were also largely written in poetry; the fact that the demarcation of the poems is often difficult does not alter this. Finally, there are a n u m b e r of indi vidual poems, distributed throughout the narrative prose. T h e y occupy carefully chosen positions; varying in length from a few words to many strophes, they articulate the mass of narrative prose, throughout the entire "history" track that runs from Genesis through to Kings. I will m e n t i o n only the most important ones here: the strophes in w h i c h Jacob, and Moses after him, character izes the tribes (in Gen. 49 and D e u t . 33), Moses' Song at the R e e d Sea (Exod. 15), his long didactic speech in D e u t e r o n o m y 32 (no fewer than sixty-nine full poetic lines in twenty-seven strophes), Deborah's Song of Victory in Judges 5, the Song of H a n n a h in 1 Samuel 2:1—10, David's lament in 2 Samuel 1:19—27, and his great Song of Thanksgiving as king in 2 Samuel 2 2 . 3
4
5
6
This is all very well, but can w e actually see the difference between prose and p o e t r y in our Bible translations? This is a question w e have to ask, as I a m writing primarily for the m a n y readers w h o do n o t read the Bible in the original languages. T h e difference b e t w e e n prose and poetry has generally b e e n carefully observed in recent translations, as for instance the bestselling N e w International Version (1978, revised 1983), and the Jewish Publication Society's 1985 translation of the H e b r e w Bible: prose has b e e n printed continuously, but p o e t r y is immediately conspicuous by its typography: the lines are ragged instead of j u s tified. In the older translations—the many reprints of the King James Bible and the widely available Revised Standard Version of 1946—52—this is unfortunately n o t the case. In these versions, only t h e Psalms, Proverbs, Job, S o n g of Songs, and Lamentations are p r i n t e d in the desired typography of true poetic lines. T h e abundant Prophetic texts have regrettably been printed as prose, often in t w o columns per page. T h e unfortunate results of this will soon b e c o m e clear, as I introduce two of the greatest poets by dis cussing a strophe from Isaiah and a lament of David's.
3
Preliminary Exercise Wash y o u r s e l v e s , m a k e y o u r s e l v e s c l e a n (Isaiah 1)
T h e first thing that strikes us w h e n w e o p e n o u r translation is the typography in w h i c h the poems are presented: their appearance o n the page. H e r e is a passage from Isaiah in the R S V rendering: [16] Wash yourselves; make yourselves clean; remove the evil of your doings from before my eyes; cease to do evil, [17] learn to do good; seek justice, correct oppression; defend the fatherless, plead for the widow. (Isa. 1:16-17) Typography like this blocks our view of the true literary situation by printing the text continuously, as if it were prose. Moreover, the text is printed in two columns per page, a procedure w h i c h in itself is already detrimental to the poetry. T h e t w o biblical verses I just q u o t e d are actually composed of three verses in the literary sense—i.e., full poetic lines—which each consist of three seg ments. T h e i r 3 x 3 exactly fill o n e strophe, and thus the unit may also be printed as follows:
Wash yourselves; make yourselves clean; remove the evil of your doings from before my eyes; cease to do evil, learn to do good, seek justice; support the oppressed, provide justice for the fatherless, plead for the widow.
line la lb lc 2a 2b 2c 3a 3b 3c
This is a w o r k i n g translation that keeps a bit closer to the o r i g inal text. T h e r e is o n e substantial difference from the R S V r e n dering, w h i c h appears at the b e g i n n i n g of the third verse. T h e H e b r e w w o r d hamots usually refers to an oppressor ("oppression" in t h e first q u o t e ) , but this time (line 3a) the object of this action is m e a n t . In the following, I will have to resist the t e m p t a t i o n to go back to the Hebrew, as this introduces information the reader c a n n o t check, w h i c h is s o m e t h i n g I w a n t to avoid. For o n c e , however, I will depart from this rule, and for a g o o d reason: the
4
Reading Biblical Poetry
very articulation of the third trio guides us in the choice o f t h e right object. T h e correct arrangement or division of the strophe is the ideal starting point for a compact and simple analysis of the structure. T h e presentation of Isaiah 1:16—17 as three trios offers a perfect view of w h a t happens. Each verse contains three forms of the imperative (in the plural). Although the first verse is about physi cal cleansing, the focus is o n the symbolic and moral meanings. W i t h these three verses w e are in the middle of a long p o e m in w h i c h t h e deity itself is fulminating against the corrupt c o m patriots of the Judaean Isaiah; this is the long oracle* of d o o m of Isaiah 1:2—20, some forty poetic lines. T h e addressed have to cleanse themselves because they have blood o n their hands (thus the end of verse 15, w h i c h immediately precedes o u r strophe), and because their cult is only a lot of p o m p and show ( w . 11-14). +
T h e second verse is a n e w series of three, w h e r e the imperative (another three times, all of t h e m in the plural) always has an abstract n o u n as its object: do evil, good, justice. In line 2a I used the w o r d "evil" for the first object to show in m y translation that this makes the phrase an e c h o of the evil in line l b . This instance of repetition is linked to another in the second verse: the root for "just" appears in 2c and is also used in 3b, in favor of the oppressed. T h e central c o m m a n d imparting m e a n i n g to the nine injunctions is 2b, "learn to do good," and starting from this pivot there are only positive commands in the text. T h e p o e t does n o t get bogged d o w n in a n o n c o m m i t t a l e x h o r tation t o such abstract virtues as " t h e good." In his last trio h e p r e sents the practical application.The c o m m a n d s (another three, still in the plural) of the third verse all have concrete direct objects: people of flesh and blood w h o are u n d e r great duress and deserve to be protected. So m u c h for our brief analysis of the structure of the strophe; it has n o w b e c o m e obvious that line 3a indeed refers to the object of oppression rather than the subject, and the m o r e recent translations have fortunately seen this. A sentence such as "I have seen y o u " or "You will praise h i m " needs only o n e w o r d in Hebrew. Moreover, the classical poets aim t The first occurrence of each glossary term is marked by an asterisk (*) follow ing the word.
Preliminary Exercise
5
for succinctness even by H e b r e w standards. This is w h y in English w e almost always n e e d far m o r e words to render a verse than there are in the original. A n d this in t u r n creates the situation that b i b lical p o e t r y works w h e n each segment (half-verse, colon) is given a line of its o w n in the typography. T h e complete verse in transla tion simply becomes t o o long to b e printed o n a single line. Let us see h o w this works for Isaiah 1:16—17: Wash yourselves; make yourselves clean; / remove the evil of your doings / from before my eyes! Cease to do evil, / learn to do good, / seek justice! Correct oppression; / provide justice for the fatherless, / plead for the widow. Even n o w it hardly works, although I have used a smaller font. As a staccato of commands, phrase after phrase, the passage is so dense that even by H e b r e w standards it is exceptional; in terms of meter, w e here have three times 2 + 2 + 2 beats. In the following, I will call the first segment of a verse the A-colon, the second the B-colon, and the third the C-colon. F r o m a visual point of view it is g o o d practice to indent the B-cola in translation, and then indent the C-cola o n e extra level, so as to show staggered articu lation, w h i c h is the true hallmark of the poetic line. For a good understanding of a p o e m it is essential to discover the contours of the units or textual layers above the level of the verse. This form of structuration and other matters will b e dis cussed together w i t h David's p o e m ; I will first print it in its entirety, in a w o r k i n g translation of my o w n .
D a v i d ' s l a m e n t for Saul (2 S a m u e l 1) T h e situation at the end of the first book of Samuel is as follows: under the command of king Saul and three of his sons, the Israelite army tries to fend off an attack by the Philistines, but is utterly defeated. Three days later the bad news reaches David in Ziklag, in the south west of Palestine, where he is formally still the vassal of one of the Philistine kings. H e composes a dirge for the fallen king and his first b o r n Jonathan, w h o is Davids closest friend.The text is in 2 Samuel 1:19-27; the author of the book first provides some information (w. 17—18) that in three prose lines tells us a surprising amount about 7
6
Reading Biblical Poetry
subject, genre, aim, target group, and source of the painful message, and as such helps to guide our reading: David composed this dirge over Saul and his son Jonathan and he said [in order to instruct the Judaeans through the hard message; see, it is recorded in the Book of the Upright]:
[prose]
[w. 17—18]
strophe stanza Your glory/gazelle, O Israel, [lies] slain on your heights; how have the mighty fallen! Tell it not in Gath, do not proclaim it in the streets of Ashkelon, lest the daughters of the Philistines rejoice, lest the daughters of the uncircumcised exult. Hills of Gilboa, [let there be] no dew and no rain on you, fields up high, for there the shield of the mighty was desecrated, the shield of Saul is anointed with oil no more. Without the blood of the slain, without the fat of the mighty the bow ofJonathan did not come back, and the sword of Saul never returned empty. Saul and Jonathan, the beloved and most dear, in life and death they never parted. They were swifter than eagles, mightier than lions. Daughters of Israel, weep over Saul, who clothed you in crimson and finery, who decked your robes with jewels of gold. How are the mighty fallen in the midst of battle! [It is] Jonathan [who is] slain on your heights! I am devastated because of you, my brother, Jonathan, you were most dear to me, your love is a miracle to me, more than the love of women. How have the mighty fallen, the instruments of war perished!
Ill
Preliminary Exercise
7
T h e seven strophes have b e e n arranged into three stanzas, as a short analysis must show. T h e first strophe consists of only o n e tripartite verse (a so-called tricolon), and has to serve as an introduction in m o r e than o n e respect. T h e very first w o r d of strophe and p o e m is ts vi in the original language (also spelled Zvi) and wrong-foots us o n purpose: w e just cannot understand it at this stage.The w o r d is a h o m o n y m * that means b o t h "jewel, glory" and "gazelle," and w e are forced to defer o u r decision as t o w h i c h m e a n i n g to choose. Moreover, w e do n o t k n o w w h o or w h a t the m e t a p h o r * refers to. T h e information that Zvi lies slain o n the heights of Gilboa—the l o w table-mountain w h e r e the battle t o o k place—suggests that w e have to d o w i t h o n e or m o r e persons, but w h o ? Is it the king, w i t h the princes at his side, or the army? Here, too, w e have to defer our decision—and, as w e shall see, as far as the final strophe. In other words, the p o e t immediately presents us w i t h a riddle. e
T h e second sentence of the p o e m is the C - c o l o n of the o p e n ing verse. W h i l e the first sentence contained an unevenness because of the awkward position of the vocative* and remained incomprehensible, the rhetorical exclamation is smooth and simple. M o r e than that, it is a cliché, a general statement that also might have b e e n exclaimed after the battles of Waterloo or Hastings. At the same time, however, its " n o r m a l " and cliché character is u n d e r m i n e d by a strategic decision. T h e p o e t makes this exclamation a seed that will grow. At the end of strophes 6 and 7 the sentence returns, first accompanied by an adjunct o f place, and then (at the end of the p o e m as a whole) w i t h a n e w clause in the B - c o l o n as its counterpart. For this reason, " h o w have the mighty fallen!" merits the label of "refrain phrase." T h e worst cliché effect has b e e n removed anyway, as it has b e e n placed after the sentence about Z v i : fortunately, the p o e m does n o t start w i t h a platitude.The r i d dle of Zvi I will call t h e t h e m e phrase. Stanza I consists of t w o strophes, w h i c h are b o t h d e t e r m i n e d by t w o c o m m a n d s placed in front, followed by t w o negative sen tences. In strophe 2 David forbids certain persons to carry the "joyful message" to the Philistine h o m e front. B u t w h o exactly are these people? In reality, the cities o n the coast have heard of the o u t c o m e of the war at least two days before David does, and e x u berant festivities must long since have started in the Pentapolis, the
8
Reading Biblical Poetry
league of the five major cities of the Philistines! I conclude that here David is addressing imaginary messengers in a desperate attempt to reverse reality. As yet, he absolutely cannot bear t h e thought that the other camp is n o w joyously celebrating its t r i u m p h o n the battlefield, and tries to prevent this party by magicalpoetical means. This is indicated by the double "lest." In strophe 3 David again opens with two prohibitions, in sen tences w h i c h have b e e n so shortened by anger that they do n o t even contain a verb. T h e i r content is remarkable: h e curses the slopes of M o u n t Gilboa. David tries to c o n d e m n t h e m to p e r m a nent infertility by blocking the supply of life-giving water. B u t w h i c h person is capable of stopping rain? T h e r e is only one: the deity. In the Song of the Vineyard (Isa. 5:1-7), G o d does indeed c o m m a n d the clouds n o t to grant their rain to the vineyard h e has decided to curse. All this demonstrates h o w David here tries the impossible, exactly as in strophe 2. Against his o w n better j u d g m e n t h e places himself in the position of God. H e feels so p o w e r less in the face of this catastrophe that he deploys all the p o w e r tools in the language he must w o r k w i t h as a poet, in order to t u r n back the clock. In this way, great poetic expressivity becomes the mask and the sign of complete impotence. All these prohibitions of David's, so characteristic of stanza I, are apotropaic*: they aim at fending off disaster by denying and aveng ing the inexorable course of history. T h e poet makes a titanic effort to eliminate the fait accompli. This in itself is also a message: the warding-off gesture is a form of avoidance. David will n o t and cannot relate to the catastrophe directly and personally at this point, w h i c h may in t u r n be explained by his distress and pain. After t w o strophes, David still has n o t reached that point. Stanza II stands out sharply from its surroundings—i.e., the first and last stanzas—by referring to the times before the battle, and surpris ingly exchanging the m i n o r key of the complaint for the major key of a song of praise. This central part praises the courage and victories of Saul and J o n a t h a n as the heroes of earlier battles. Stanza II is a eulogy* that forms the center of an elegy*.The m a x i m u m contrast b e t w e e n center and flanks creates a formidable dynamic in the perception of the p o e t and the empathetic reader. I have rendered the usual " h e r o e s " of the refrain phrase by
Preliminary Exercise
9
" m i g h t y " here, as the root "strong, m i g h t y " is an important key word in the song. It occurs in v. 25a and parallel to this in v. 27a, indicating a closure or finish at strophe level, and it is the c o u n terpart of the n a m e "Saul" in the strophe about the shields (v. 21). T h e most telling aspect, however, is its placement in w . 22a and 23b. Its position o n the edges of the central stanza gives the root a structural function, that of demarcating and framing that unit. Moreover, here it appears with a reversed key signature. In the verses of the flanking stanzas I and III, " m i g h t y " is in a m i n o r key and refers to the fallen heroes of David's o w n party; at the top and b o t t o m of the middle stanza its effect is exacdy the reverse: in v. 22 it refers to Saul's and Jonathan's former enemies, and at the end of v. 2 3 it aims to h o n o r father and son themselves: "they were stronger than lions." At the beginning of stanza II, Jonathan receives a m u c h longer sentence than his father.This is mainly because the w o r d "empty," w h i c h further specifies the return of Saul's sword, is the exact counterpart of two wordier complements that characterize the return of Jonathan s b o w : " n o t w i t h o u t the blood of the slain . . . n o t w i t h o u t the fat of the warriors." Formally speaking, o u r atten tion is directed toward the weapons rather than their bearers. T h e same already happened in strophe 3, w h e n the poet's gaze discov ered " t h e shield of the mighty, tainted" o n the battlefield, and " t h e shield of Saul [was] anointed w i t h oil n o more." Polishing one's shield w i t h oil was o n e of the things a soldier had to do in prepa ration for battle; this was supposed to make blows from the e n e m y glance off it. B u t the introduction of " o i l " in this strophe is first and foremost a subtle allusion to Saul's status: he was the Lord's Anointed, m e a n i n g that h e held the sacred office of king, and as such was inviolable. N o w , the shield smeared with blood and m u d symbolizes the terrible and desecrating end he m e t with. T h e shift to speaking of weapons instead of their bearers is an example of m e t o n y m y * . This f o r m of indirectness again betrays the poet's emotional condition: h e is still intent u p o n avoidance. At this point, however, strophe 5 appears as a c o m p l e m e n t . S u d denly, father and son are juxtaposed, and the order of their names has b e e n reversed. T h e two names are followed by t w o apposi tions ("beloved and most dear"), and t w o adjuncts o f time o f
Reading Biblical Poetry
10
m a x i m u m contrast,"life and death." Finally, in the last position of the double verse, the actual sentence core follows: "they never parted." This predicate* is the only element in the sentence that is n o t duplicated. For the Israelite, life and death cannot be meaningfully linked or united in any way: they form the ultimate polarity of h u m a n existence. Here, however, their opposition is p u t in perspective, I w o u l d almost say negated, by the mutual loyalty of father and son, whose force is so strong that it cannot be split up. Verse 2 3 is an arena in w h i c h unity and duality are at war, and all duplications in the [outer] form ultimately prove to serve the Saul-and-Jonathan unity. T h e entire p o e m is a chain of twenty-five predicates in all. T h e middle o n e — n u m b e r 13—is this o n e verb that, thanks to the negation, conquers or surpasses polarity and division, and so tries to exorcise the divisive ravages w r o u g h t by death. T h e distribution of the two proper names t h r o u g h o u t the p o e m is in itself an important beacon, w h i c h points the way to the solution of the Zvi-riddle. W i t h i n stanza II, b o t h names occur twice, in a chiastic* order. If w e take strophe 1 to be a part of stanza I, a pattern becomes visible: I
Zvi
Saul
II
Jonathan Saul Saul Jonathan
III
Saul
Jonathan
T h e balance b e t w e e n these occurrences is the first clear sug gestion that the n a m e Z v i might b e the cover for the person most beloved by David. If this is true, the t w o names u n d e r III mirror the t w o of the beginning in a crosswise construction. In that case, the p o e m starts and ends w i t h the o n e person w h o s e loss David can never get over; first d e n o t e d enigmatically as the glory of Israel, h e appears u n d e r his o w n n a m e in the final strophe, w h i c h clearly forms the climax. Stanza III consists of t w o strophes. T h e first, strophe 6, is devoted to the king; the other one, the seventh and last of the song, speaks about Jonathan. In the o n e strophe the w o m e n lament the king; in the other David himself, in the first person, laments the prince, his b o s o m friend.
11
Preliminary Exercise
A r o u n d the center, w h i c h was in a major key, the poet creates a balance between stanzas I and III.This is immediately visible in the exhortation of strophe 6. W h i l e in strophe 2 the p o e t refuses all j o y to "the daughters of the Philistines" (as the original text lit erally reads) and h e n c e tries to stop the message of victory by means of a prohibition, in strophe 6 he issues a c o m m a n d , so that t h r o u g h o u t the land " t h e daughters of Israel" express their grief in m o u r n i n g rituals. T h e y should weep for a king w h o gave t h e m prosperity in better days. Saul's care is expressed through attributes and terms of outward p o m p , and a chiasm* keeps the core of the strophe together: [weep over Saul]
who clothed you who with jewels of gold
in crimson and finery, decked your robes.
This is followed by the exclamation about the mighty having fallen, w h i c h as a repetition of v. 19c b e c o m e s the refrain sentence and concludes the strophe. T h e final strophe is m u c h m o r e personal, w i t h its intense exchange b e t w e e n " m e " and "you." B o r r o w i n g a t e r m from love poetry, David calls J o n a t h a n " m y b r o t h e r " — w h i c h is w h a t t h e girl from the S o n g of Songs calls her lover (and h e can address h e r as " m y sister"). In the center, the p o e t applied the adjectives " b e l o v e d " and " m o s t dear" to t h e k i n g and his son in a rather objective t o n e . T h e s e t w o terms n o w t u r n o u t to have b e e n used in preparation for t h e final strophe as well, w h e r e the w o r d " l o v e " appears twice exclusively in h o n o r o f J o n a t h a n , and fol lows "dear." T h e relationship w i t h t h e middle of stanza II is again chiastic: Saul and Jonathan: the beloved,
the most dear . . .
Jehonathan, you were most dear to me
your love is a miracle to me, more than the love of women.
[middle of strophe 4]
N e x t to this u n i q u e praise for his friend, David places his personal pain—a formidable contrast. H e speaks his n a m e twice, in its full form Jehonathan (literally: "Yahweh has given"), and n o w expresses his grief uninhibitedly and directly w i t h "I am distressed for
12
Reading Biblical Poetry
t h e e " — f o r once I will use the English of the almost fourcenturies-old King James Bible. T h e original text literally says something like "I a m hard-pressed," in the sense of "I a m in a ter rible plight." T h e avoidance stage has passed, and David is n o w ready for the naked truth. H e is crushed and shocked. His grief makes h i m aware of the full depth of their love for each other, while the love lends depth and a voice to the grief. Meanwhile, David as a speaker has made his most surprising move o n the threshold of the strophe. H e started it with a n o m i nal sentence, w h i c h is n o t h i n g but the t h e m e phrase v. 19a w i t h w h i c h the p o e m opened: "Jehonathan—[lies] slain o n y o u r heights." H e has changed only o n e element: he has replaced the word Z v i with his friend's name! Suddenly w e have received the poetic answer to the question of w h o is h i d d e n b e h i n d the metaphors "jewel" and "gazelle." T h e substitution of the n a m e Jonathan for the very first word, together with the hint provided by the structure, proves that Jonathan = Zvi. W h i l e the last strophe sings of t h e love of J o n a t h a n (for David), and immortalizes this w i t h a u n i q u e c o m p a r i s o n — " y o u r love is m o r e wonderful to m e than the love of w o m e n " — w e may call the love for Jonathan (on David's part) the alpha and omega of the song as a w h o l e . T h e refrain phrase " h o w have the mighty fallen" is repeated, and is expanded even further than in v. 25a, as it is given a parallel in the i n d e p e n d e n t clause that flanks it: "the weapons of war have perished." This last clause combines the shields, the sword, and the b o w u n d e r o n e heading, and so concludes the metonymical speech. This half-verse about the weapons thus also refers to the owners of the weapons and their deaths. T h e indirect character of the reference n o w n o longer means avoidance, but offers a discreet way to provide the lament w i t h a n o t - t o o - v e h e m e n t ending, by means of a certain distance. These preliminary exercises already demonstrate that the H e b r e w p o e t is a master of proportions. At every position in the p o e m , and at every level—whether w e are dealing w i t h sounds and words, or w h e t h e r w e are looking at half-verses or verses, strophes or stanzas—he always adapts himself to t h e proper d i m e n sions of his material. H o w e v e r conscientious, a translation can never take into account all subtleties of style such as alliteration*,
Preliminary Exercise
13
n u m b e r of syllables, rhyme, and such, but at the levels above v o c a b ulary even a translation can show m u c h of the poets' measured composing. W e have already seen this in the meticulous as well as playful handling of the "three-units" principle in Isaiah. T h e p o e m s in the Bible are extremely varied.We notice this w h e n w e look at genre: there are proverbs and p o e m s from the W i s d o m tradition, songs of victory and defeat, lamentations by individual voices or groups, hymns, songs of thanksgiving, love poetry, ora cles of d o o m or salvation p r o n o u n c e d by the prophets, and m u c h more. B u t however diverse the poems, they have a n u m b e r of powerful rules and literary conventions in c o m m o n ; and after w e have learned to recognize and apply these, t h e texts are generally self-explanatory: this is the subject of the rest of this b o o k . T h e n u m b e r of English-speakers w h o read classical H e b r e w is so small that I will here assume the position of readers w h o have to take recourse to translations. I want to find an answer to the question of w h a t the primary tools are that such readers require for an independent and creative reading of the translated p o e m s . I will start from the reality that there are three c o m m o n l y used translations: the A u t h o r i z e d (or King James) Version (usually in some sort of m o d e r n i z e d spelling), the 1946—52 Revised Standard Version, and the N e w International Version. I will regularly q u o t e from the Jewish Publication Society's Tanakh translation, 1985.
Legend I must first point out a pitfall: the t e r m "verse" is ambiguous . W h e n I write "v. 1 6 " or "verses 1 0 - 1 4 , " I a m referring to the traditional verse n u m b e r s of the transmitted text. T h e numbers here indicate biblical verses. A biblical verse can b e prose or poetry, and its length may vary from a few words in o n e sentence to as many as ten sen tences and thirty words. T h e y have b e e n transmitted or d e m a r cated as textual units by the rabbis, for the purpose of recitation in the synagogue. In a b o o k about poetics, the other t e r m "verse" is m u c h m o r e important: this refers to the complete poetic line, as w h e n w e talk about texts by Yeats or Wallace Stevens, lines by H o m e r , Horace, and Shakespeare—the verse in the literary or
14
Reading Biblical Poetry
poetical sense. In the H e b r e w Bible, the traditional verse n u m b e r s almost always coincide w i t h the actual poetic lines in the books of Job and Proverbs: a happy coincidence. Outside these, however, in the Prophets and in the books of Psalms, Song of Songs, and Lamentations, or in the strophes that here and there adorn and enrich the prose from Genesis through to Kings, the biblical verse is n o t at all the same as the (literary) verse = the poetic line. As I expect this b o o k also to be used or consulted by all sorts of students, I have added endnotes to each chapter at the end of the b o o k w h i c h may b e of service to Hebraists. Readers w i t h o u t knowledge of the original languages can safely skip t h e m . For these readers I have included a glossary of foreign and technical terms at the end of the b o o k . T h e first occurrence of such a t e r m (for instance, " m e t o n y m y " or "merism") has b e e n marked by an asterisk, indicating that it will be explained in the list. Finally, I should point o u t an important terminological distinction: I use the word " p o e t i c " as an adjective relating to poetry (i.e., primary liter ature), and the w o r d "poetical" as an adjective referring to the scholarly discipline of poetics, w h i c h produces secondary literature about poetry.
2 The art of poetry: a definition and analysis Components
I and II: language and
number
D e n s i t y ; l a n g u a g e as a s y s t e m o f differences Sensitivity to verse has something to do w i t h aptitude, and a lot to do w i t h the proper training. A correct perception of poetry is based o n the art of reading. C o m p e t e n t reading, and the right kind of experience, I consider m o r e essential than drawing u p a defini tion of the art of poetry. Yet, it is w o r t h the effort to try and define H e b r e w poetry. A n adequate set of specifications has many p r a c tical advantages and will lead to effective insight and increased pleasure in reading. W h a t exactly is "poetry"? T h e G e r m a n t e r m for it, Dichtung, by a lucky coincidence sounds as if it was derived from the G e r m a n root dicht, m e a n i n g "dense," a similarity I simply must take advantage of. T h e sounds create an association that w e can put to g o o d use, even if it is n o m o r e than m y o w n opportunist popular etymology*. W h a t a p o e t undertakes does have a lot to do w i t h creating "density." Poetry is the most compact and concentrated f o r m of speech possible. By making the most of his or her linguistic tools, the p o e t creates an immense richness of meaning, and this r i c h ness becomes available if w e as readers k n o w h o w to handle the density: h o w w e can cautiously tackle complexity, probe the vari ous layers o n e by one, and unfold t h e m . T h e p o e t creates this abundance of meanings by visiting all the n o o k s and crannies of the language, and by b e i n g an expert at it. I may draw a comparison here w i t h the visual arts: it is a wellk n o w n fact that the greatest painters and sculptors spend their entire lives lovingly studying their materials and e x p e r i m e n t i n g w i t h t h e m : paint and canvas, clay and b r o n z e . T h e same holds true for the poet: his raw material is language, in the first instance, and
16
Reading Biblical Poetry
very few p o e m s are b o r n w i t h o u t the poet's exploring and trying out various forms of language and style, w i t h o u t outlines and deletions. O u r language is a well-ordered and subtle system of signs, w h i c h may be described as a n e t w o r k of relations and differences. These forms of cohesion were discovered only at the beginning of the twentieth century, w h i c h means that scholarly attention to t h e m is comparatively recent; the poets, however, have b e e n actu ally w o r k i n g w i t h t h e m for thousands of years. T h e y brilliantly exploit the differences and contrasts inherent in their language as a system. In the case of Hebrew, an additional factor is involved: the dif ference between that language and English. We should remain aware of that difference w h e n reading translations of poems from the Bible. H e b r e w needs fewer words than o u r m o t h e r tongue. Take, for instance, the sentence: "I have listened to you." In H e b r e w this is only o n e word, of three or four syllables, w h i c h moreover contains an extra element of information as compared to English: it shows w h e t h e r " y o u " (the direct object) is a m a n or a w o m a n . A phrase such as "the people w h o pursue m e w i t h o u t reason" in the original language consists of only two words, five syllables in all. Because English needs m o r e words, it is often impossible to print a complete verse o n o n e line (as w e have already seen in the Intro duction). As a result, the RSV, NIV, and many other translations have had to decide to print o n e verset (colon, plural cola) per line in their presentation of biblical poetry. A n d sometimes even that is hardly feasible. I will illustrate this by an extreme case of divergent lengths. In Psalm 69:5a/5b, the H e b r e w text contains 5 + 4 words filling cola of regular length. Two popular D u t c h translations print the equivalent of these words (taken from the RSV) as follows: More in number than the hairs of my head are those who hate me without cause; mighty are those who would destroy me, those who attack me with lies. A rather unfortunate typography. T h e text itself consists of t w o cola, because w e easily recognize t w o sentences of almost c o m pletely parallel structure. T h e translators needed a lot of words (no
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
17
fewer than sixteen) to render v. 5a, and have succumbed to the temptation to cut the first sentence in two. T h u s they have divided a syntactically and rhythmically close-knit unit into t w o lines, o n the basis of a criterion that has n o t h i n g to do w i t h w r i t i n g H e b r e w verse but is d e t e r m i n e d by the receiving language: the length of the translated English phrase. W h i c h leads to a second mistake: printing the B-colon in the position of an A - c o l o n . T h e R S V cuts b o t h sentences in two, w h i c h leads to the illusion that w e have t w o A-cola and two B-cola here. T h e p o e t traverses the system of relations formed by the lan guage, and is very adroit at exploiting the differences that as it were form the clue to this system. Below I a m giving a list of the most important differences determining the usage of the H e b r e w language. As in English, many of these contrasts are binary*: • masculine/feminine • singular/plural • past/present/future • stating, noting, or describing versus wishing, begging, and commanding • positive/negative • figurative/non-figurative • active/passive • transitive*/intransitive* • speaking about/speaking to • abstract/concrete • regular/irregular word order This list is mainly about language and text signs (signifiers*), but w e could go o n w i t h a list of meanings (signifieds*), i.e., c o n cepts and things the language refers to: • high/low • God/man • native/foreign • good/evil • joy/distress • fear/security • trust/despair . . . etc., but I have to admit that this short list is fairly arbitrary.This second list, however, makes us realize something m u c h bigger: the
Reading Biblical Poetry
18
n u m b e r of meanings or subjects is simply inexhaustible, so I will immediately stop adding o n to it. H o w e v e r many there are, all these differences do not yet have a specifically literary quality; they also may be observed and studied in an ordinary newspaper article or some other piece of everyday language. So, it is time to consult the p o e t himself and see h o w h e juggles binary and other differences. H e r e is a short p o e m from the Psalter, a unit of nine verses: verse
Psalm 113
la b 2a b
O servants of Yahweh, give praise, praise the name of Yahweh. Let the name of Yahweh be blessed, now and forever.
3a b 4a b
From the rising of the sun to its setting the name of Yahweh is praised! Yahweh is exalted above all nations, His glory is above the heavens.
5a b 6a b
Who is like Yahweh our God, who is enthroned on high, who looks far down, in heaven and on earth?
7a b 8a b 9a b
W h o raises the poor from the dust, and lifts the needy from the ash heap, to make them sit with princes, with the princes of his people, who gives the barren woman a home, as a happy mother of children.
strophe
1
2
3
4
We only need to look at the kind of sentences, and the use of space on the page, to find the right way into the work and to be able to see its articulation in various parts. T h e division into verses and the way they have been cut into halves (cola) originates from the Jewish text tradition and is undisputed.The division into four strophes, h o w ever, is mine, and therefore need not be accepted without question. In w . 1-2 w e notice t w o verbs in the imperative, followed by a wish. This volitive* quality sets off the first strophe from the second, w h i c h contains positive sentences. In this indicative*
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
19
m o d e they point to attributes of the deity; hence, there are n o actions here, b u t rather three ways of saying "is." Speaking to ( p e o ple) has b e e n replaced by a hymnic speaking about (God). Verses 5 - 6 are again different in tone, as they form a rhetorical question. T h e four versets are parts of a single syntactic u n i t . T h e point of the question is that G o d is incomparable. In v. 6b w e r e c ognize the very first merism* of the Bible (as w e find it in Gen.1:1), pointing to the domains of G o d and man: heaven and earth, respectively. This pair has b e e n placed in a remarkable posi tion: the t w o halves do correspond to God's activities—i.e., being e n t h r o n e d and looking d o w n — b u t they have been cut loose from these and placed together as the final line of the strophe. In this way, the p o e t has avoided writing a three-part verse, w h i c h w o u l d run: " w h o is likeYahweh, our God, / w h o sits o n high, in heaven, / and looks far d o w n , o n earth?" His actual point is slightly differ ent. F u r t h e r m o r e , h e wanted to stick w i t h his bicolic* design, and has created a third quartet of cola. 1
T h e center of this foursome, w . 5b—6a, is taken u p by a spec tacular vertical axis linking the provinces of G o d and m a n . T h e axis is e m b e d d e d in descriptions of G o d , and in the t w o halves of the spatial m e r i s m . T h e words for G o d and for cosmic space form t w o pairs, w h i c h provide a g o o d balance and a perfect finish to the strophe. T h e only remaining question n o w is w h y the p o e t has delayed using the terms of space until v. 6d, and there presents t h e m together. T h e answer is that in so d o i n g h e has t h e m w o r k in t w o ways: n o t only as an explanation and topographical i n d i cation of God's actions (being e n t h r o n e d / s e e i n g ) , b u t also as a gauge of God's uniqueness. Strictly speaking, the point of the strophe is: neither in heaven n o r o n earth do w e find anybody comparable to H i m . T h u s , w e may also reorganize the quartet, and interpret it as: W h o is likeYahweh our God, / in heaven and on earth? There is nobody who sits so high / and looks down so far! R e a d i n g on, w e reach strophe 4 and see six rather than four versets.These are largely adjective clauses, and w e are struck by at least three transitive* verbs indicating sovereign action. Although w e all k n o w the answer to the rhetorical question in the exact center of
20
Reading Biblical Poetry
the p o e m ("nobody," of course!), the poet has decided to seize his opportunity and add an answer of his o w n after all. H e again p r e sents a series of actions o n God's part, w h i c h at last govern the object omitted in v. 6: here we see the people, m o r e specifically the weak and needy, w h o appear in the position of beneficiaries. T h e three transitive verbs demonstrate the constitutive power of God's liberating initiative. G o d proves to b e a totally c o m m i t t e d person, instead of a neutral physical p h e n o m e n o n . His proper name occurs, in descending frequency, three, two, one, and zero times in strophes 1—4. His activity shows a reverse development: it started at zero and reaches its m a x i m u m in strophe 4. T h e strophes not only show variation of tone and m o d e (in the verbs),but also form a quartet on their own level,in an AB-B7V pat tern: first, they view the earth/heaven, next heaven/the earth. T h e characters w e meet in t h e m are arranged in a similar crosswise struc ture: the people are exhorted to action in strophe 1 and liberated in strophe 4, while G o d is praised in the central strophes 2 and 3. T h e lyrical world as evoked by this p o e m is o n e of sheer space, and t h e reader is provided w i t h plenty of space thanks to the inter secting horizontal and vertical axes, w h i c h have b e e n dynamically positioned by the poet. In the second strophe, v. 3 shows the h o r izontal axis at its widest by tracing the course of the sun from East to West. Verse 4 duly follows w i t h the vertical axis, for a m o m e n t showing us G o d e n t h r o n e d high above the h u m a n struggle. B u t not for long: in v. 6b t h e hymnic question that constitutes the poetic axis and points to God's uniqueness reverses the order earth/heaven, so that o u r attention is bent back toward the earth, following God's gaze. N e x t , strophe 4 fills u p the plane of our his tory w i t h the images of God's intervention. In this plane, too, the horizontal and vertical axes are contrasted. T h e p o o r are raised from the dust, and w e can see h o w this sym bolizes the reversal of their fortunes; they are n o w able to straighten their backs.The horizontal orientation of w . 8—9 is n o t prominent, but certainly recognizable and lends an aspect of har m o n y to the people gathered there. T h e y are presented in the plural (princes, children), by w h i c h the poet takes us back to the beginning. In this way h e effectively rounds off his song w i t h a form ofinclusio*, a frame. O n l y after w e have crossed the finish d o
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
21
w e realize that there are excellent reasons for the call to "praise G o d " in v. 1: these are given in the long final strophe. T h e prosody* of Psalm 113 cannot b e called representative of biblical poetry, for a positive reason: this p o e m is one of the top five as regards regularity. By way of exception I will demonstrate this by a count of the syllables in the original Hebrew, so that these exact figures may again give the reader an impression of the precision the poet can employ at will. T h e left-hand column shows the n u m b e r of syllables per word o n either side of the caesura* (indicated by a slash), and the middle column adds up the totals for the versets: verse 1 2
3.2.2 / 3.1.1.2 1.1.2.3 / 3.2.2
7 + 7 = 14 7 + 7 = 14
strophe 1 = 28
3 4
3.1.1.3 / 3.1.2 1.1.1.2.2 / 1.3.3
8 + 6 = 14 7 + 7 = 14
strophe 2 = 28
5 6
1.3.4 / 4.2 4.2 / 3.3
8 + 6 = 14 6 + 6 = 12
strophe 3 = 26
7 8 9
3.3.1 / 3.2.2 4.1.3 / 1.3.2 3.2.2 / 1.3.3
7 + 7 = 14 8 + 6 = 14 7 + 7 = 14
strophe 4 = 42
T h e total n u m b e r of syllables is 28 + 28 + 26 + 42 = 124. W e may b e allowed to rewrite this as 40 (a very biblical number, the total of w . 5—7) plus 3 x 2 8 . T h e greatest regularity is found at verse level: eight out of nine verses contain fourteen syllables, a total that in five cases has been reached, moreover, by doubling the sacred n u m b e r seven. T h e minimal variation in colon length, w h i c h n o w h e r e exceeds a range o f 6—7—8 in the p o e m , is n o t represen tative either: there are quite a n u m b e r of psalms using a range of five to twelve syllables (as a measure of colon length); there is usu ally considerable variation within o n e p o e m .
T h e old definition o f H e b r e w poetry Until some thirty years ago, Old Testament scholars entertained a rather inadequate view of H e b r e w poetics. Exegetes worked with a
Reading Biblical Poetry
22
seriously flawed definition of poetry, and I fear that it is still floating about in a n u m b e r of heads. Nevertheless, their view of H e b r e w verse contains two small grains of truth, which are worth m e n t i o n ing. I will therefore use the old formula as a starting point for a quest for a comprehensive definition: a formula that will do full justice to the true riches and complexity of the p o e m , rather than reduce it. T h e old definition rests on two pillars, as it holds that the b i b lical p o e m is d e t e r m i n e d by a) meter, and b) the parallel arrange m e n t of versets (for w h i c h the technical t e r m is parallelismus membrorum). In h o w far is this correct? I will discuss the first pillar, that of meter, only briefly as the details are relevant only to readers of Hebrew. In the nineteenth century, biblical scholarship reached an important negative conclusion: h o w ever strong the impression of rhythm emanating from the verses in the H e b r e w Bible, they are obviously subject to rules totally differ ent from those governing the metrics of G r a e c o - R o m a n poetry and its various branches and offshoots in the poetry of the European lan guages. H o m e r and Virgil, Sophocles and Plautus used quantitative meter, based o n an unambiguous distinction between long and short syllables. In Arabic, too, poets have the option to work with verse feet that may be determined quantitatively—Arabic is related to H e b r e w within the Semitic family, and it was the world language with which Jews in the Middle East, N o r t h e r n Africa, and the Iber ian peninsula came into contact more than a thousand years after the canon of biblical books had been finalized. In classical Hebrew, the distinction between long and short syl lables does n o t work. At the end of the nineteenth century, schol ars concluded that the H e b r e w poetic line was best described as a string of alternating stressed and unstressed syllables: it is an accen tual verse. W h a t we n e e d to do is c o u n t the n u m b e r of stresses (beats) per colon, while between the beats there is a varying t h o u g h not too large n u m b e r of unstressed syllables. A verse may be schematically represented as separate syllables, or in a short notation.This looks as follows (for once, I will give some H e b r e w words in a scholarly transliteration—Ps. 44, v. 7): I do not trust in my bow / it is not my sword that gives me victory. e
e
ki lo b qashti ebtah / w harbi lo toshi 'eni
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
23
to be pronounced roughly as follows: kee lo b kashtee ebtakh
/
n^kharbee lo toshee-eini
o
/
00
e
600
606
6600
60
A n " o " represents a syllable; accents indicate a beat or stress. T h e practical short notation for this w o u l d be 3 + 3 , w h i c h has led the Germans to call this sort of line a Doppeldreier. Frequent patterns are 2 + 2, 2 + 3, or conversely 3 + 2, 3 + 3 , 4 + 4, and 4 + 3 or the reverse. Half-verses often differ by o n e accent or beat (one point). A pattern such as 3 + 3 for a two-part verse (a bicolon) may be nicely varied by 2 + 2 + 2 in a tricolon (three-part verse), so that the total of six syllables remains the same. I realize that all this is n o t going to help the user of a Bible trans lation m u c h . A n d there are two m o r e pieces of bad news. First, scholars are often bitterly divided on the correct scansion*, as of course borderline cases constantly crop up—for instance, about the question w h e t h e r a specific secondary stress may b e viewed as a metric accent, i.e., a beat. Second, there is the question that strikes at the very roots of the problem: can w e speak of metrics at all in connection w i t h H e b r e w verse? T h e interpreters w h o s e sen sitivity to verse I admire almost all answer in the affirmative, but there are r e n o w n e d scholars w h o radically deny the possibility of d e t e r m i n i n g any meter at all. In short, there is a v e h e m e n t discus sion about the point, or lack of it, of scanning H e b r e w verse, and it is highly unlikely that the debate will ever reach a consensus. T h e consequence of this battle is that this first pillar of the clas sical definition is tottering, and has probably fallen already. W h a t can w e do? M a k i n g a virtue out of necessity, I can point to two escape routes. In the first place, this b o o k exclusively deals w i t h Bible translations. A rendering of a H e b r e w p o e m in English can n o t h o p e to approximate the r h y t h m and m e t e r of the original, due to the e n o r m o u s gap between source and target languages, and the fact that H e b r e w uses far fewer words. Consequently, w e had better leave the entire complex of metrics and scansion aside. Yet, the text that is left in translation still shows two faces. Even t h o u g h meter has gone, there is still a powerful rhythm, w h i c h is even stronger in H e b r e w and is not denied even by scholars w h o
Reading Biblical Poetry
24
have n o time for metrics. T h e r h y t h m is kept reasonably intact thanks to parallelismus membrorum, w h i c h will be discussed in the next section; I will return to r h y t h m in due course. T h e second escape route from the y e s / n o metrics deadlock is a r o u n d a b o u t one. It is possible to circumvent the entire issue, and go back to counting the original syllables to measure and describe the powerful r h y t h m of H e b r e w verse. I return to Psalm 44, v. 7: the 7 + 8 = 15 syllables that I just presented as an accentual verse were also 15 in the old H e b r e w from centuries before C h r i s t . S o m e 65 percent of the cola in the b o o k of Psalms are seven, eight, or nine syllables long. R e c e n t investigations have shown that the poets themselves counted their syllables, and often used the sylla ble totals to make patterns in their verses and strophes. H e n c e , the poems have an explicit and precise numerical aspect—in Hebrew. As this is taking things t o o far for most readers, I refer the Hebraists a m o n g t h e m to n o t e 2 o n page 232 for m o r e information. Still, in the previous paragraph I have lifted a corner of the veil: the fig ures for Psalm 113 are a g o o d example of numerical precision. 2
3
Parallel a r r a n g e m e n t o f versets T h e second pillar of the obsolete definition is k n o w n a m o n g scholars as parallelismus membrorum. T h e Latin plural " m e m b r a " has the same m e a n i n g as the Greek plural "cola"; the singular " c o l o n " means "a member, a part." This way of arranging verse parts is n o t u n k n o w n to us. Take for example the most straightforward example from our o w n literature: Here lies Fred: He is dead. 4
Words and syllables coincide; this 3 + 3 is a miracle of efficiency, certainly if you realize that even a haiku still needs seventeen syl lables. T h e lines start w i t h an alliteration because of the h, and their first words, here /he, indicate the spot and the man. T h e verbs are intransitive* and static: they indicate duration and condition rather than action; the consonant s provides assonance*/phonetic c o h e sion. By their rhyme, the line endings best demonstrate the i m p o r tance of sound. T h e rhyme Fred/dead invites us to semanticize*:
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
25
w e make a semantic link b e t w e e n t w o words that was n o t there before, and find that the m a n becomes fused w i t h his horizontal, still position. It is a kind of identification that leads to the point of the p o e m : an attitude of complete acceptance of the end, and o n e of great sobriety and dry h u m o r . This preliminary exercise shows h o w each w o r d in o n e line has its counterpart in the other, in the same position even, and also h o w essential is the function of the sounds. O n l y if w e pay close attention, and appreciate even the smallest detail, d o w e fully real ize h o w m u c h sheer technique has gone into this. A n d then I a m n o t even talking about everything w e d o n o t see, i.e., everything that has been left out. Back to the biblical verse (in the sense of poetic line). T h e importance of parallelismus m e m b r o r u m has b e e n clear since the middle of the eighteenth century, w h e n the English bishop R o b e r t Lowth wrote a b o o k about it. His discussion of the p h e n o m e n o n has long set the t o n e for the study of biblical poetry. H e described parallelism at verse level, distinguishing three types: if the parallel versets say the same thing, Lowth called it synonymous parallelism; if o n e is opposed to the other w e have antithetical parallelism; and if there is a different relation, it is called complementary or synthetic. This is demonstrated by examples (a), (b), and (c) below: 5
(a) Ps. 2:1
Why do nations rage and peoples plot vain things?
(b) Ps. 1:6
Yahweh knows the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked is doomed.
(c) Ps. 3:5
When I cry aloud to Yahweh, He answers me from his holy mountain.
T h e first notable aspect of example (c) is that it contains a c o m p o u n d sentence, the parts of which—subclause and main clause— neatly coincide w i t h the cola, and present the actions of the speaker and his G o d . H e n c e , in this case the complementary aspect has b e e n realized mainly by sentence structure and consecution (progress of the action). In example (b) w e immediately recognize the simple opposition g o o d / b a d . W h i l e the righteous is " k n o w n " by G o d , something w h i c h to an Israelite implies attention and
26
Reading Biblical Poetry
support, the wicked dies a miserable and lonely death, as a result of w h a t seems a quasi-autonomous process: the intransive verb does n o t m e n t i o n an agent. Consequently, w e have a second c o n trast, conveyed by the difference b e t w e e n the verbs: the first is transitive, the second is not. In example (a), the synonymy is based o n t w o w o r d pairs. T h e terms in o n e colon are illustrated and explained by the terms in the other colon. Lowth's division of "parallelism of the versets" into three types has b e e n influential, and there are still theologians w h o consider it adequate e n o u g h to w o r k with. Yet, the triad s y n o n y m o u s / antithetical/complementary cannot withstand critical scrutiny. Already if w e take L o w t h seriously at the level of his o w n words, we immediately see that the label " c o m p l e m e n t a r y " is a basket t e r m that covers everything that cannot be called synonymous or contrasting. T h u s , the t e r m is exposed as a counsel of despair, and this realization immediately strikes at the root of the entire triadic structure. W e n o w have entered the path that leads toward an adequate definition of H e b r e w poetry, and in order to clear it, m o r e radical criticism of Lowth's three-part structure is needed. I see three main areas of objection: an approach that m o u n t s an epistemological attack o n his terminology, a strictly literary counter-campaign, and an insight of a structural nature. In the following explanation I will make use of examples (a), (b), and (c) above, all taken from the b e g i n n i n g of the Psalter. I will play the amateur philosopher for a m o m e n t and look at the binary division, synonymous versus antithetical, from the p e r spective of observation and epistemology. If you call the segments of a verse synonymous, you obscure the fact that actually they are not the same. Because their words are never identical, they do n o t really have the same meaning, and this opens up a crack b e t w e e n them. It is this crack that invites us to open the d o o r wider. By " w i d e r " I m e a n the following: in a case of synonymous parallelism we first notice, as L o w t h did, the great similarity in meaning. W i t h out losing sight of the resemblance, w e nevertheless should n o t stop there and think w e have finished. T h e similarity b e t w e e n the two cola, as for instance in the case of Psalm 2:1a and l b in e x a m ple (a), becomes a j u m p i n g - b o a r d or take-off point: against the
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
27
b a c k g r o u n d of the similarities, subtle differences begin to stand out. T h e nervous bustle of the peoples—they rage, as example (a) says—is further clarified in the B-colon, w h i c h disqualifies their activity as vain plotting. W e n o w understand that the verse as a w h o l e w i t h its " w h y " (which does double duty, i.e., governs b o t h cola) is n o informative question, but a rhetorical and caustic one. T h e r e are thousands of verses that at first sight seem to consist of synonymous cola, but u p o n closer scrutiny t u r n out to cover p o t holes of difference. This is not to say that w e should start express ing the relation b e t w e e n the similar and the different in figures or percentages; poems wilt w h e n subjected to this sort of boorish and w o o d e n treatment. L o w t h s second t e r m deserves similar criticism. If you call t w o elements X and Y antithetical, you have in fact already seen or assumed a significant relation b e t w e e n the two. O n l y w h e n X and Y have something in c o m m o n is it possible and meaningful to speak of an antithesis b e t w e e n t h e m . This dialectic consideration may b e illustrated by example (b):"Yahweh knows the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked is d o o m e d " — a verse that forms the conclusion of t h e first Psalm. T h e entire p o e m has b e e n based o n the opposition b e t w e e n g o o d and bad, to such an extent that there are only few cola in w h i c h the righteous or the wicked are presented with their o w n qualities, but many cola w h e r e they appear as the opposite of the other, by means of the w o r d "not." I will print the negations in strophes 1 and 3 in italics, and follow the JPS here, w i t h some small adaptations. 6
Reading Biblical Poetry
28 verse
Psalm 1
strophe
la
Happy the man
b c d 2a b
who has not followed the counsel of the wicked, who has not taken the path of sinners, and has not joined the company of the insolent; but finds his delight in the teaching of Yahweh, and studies that teaching day and night.
3a b c d
Yea, he is like a tree planted beside streams of water, which yields its fruit in season, 2 whose foliage never fades; whatever he does, prospers.
4a b 5a b
Not so the wicked 3 rather, they are like chaff that the wind blows away. Therefore the wicked will not survive judgment, and the sinners will not [survive] in the assembly of the righteous. For Yahweh knows the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked is doomed.
6a b
1
T h e poet's moral preferences are made clear by the fact that he grants the short middle strophe to the righteous, and honors h i m by speaking figuratively. T h e long strophes flanking the center, h o w ever, show a remarkable reciprocity: the first strophe "defines" the righteous by contrasting h i m with the wicked, and the opposite happens in the third strophe. This is a balance of mutual exclusion. W i t h this symmetry the composition as a whole reveals that the g o o d / b a d antithesis has a basis: one solid set of values that is firmly oriented toward the "law" (torah, strictly speaking "teaching") of God. T h e opposition between b l o o m and destruction is traced back in the final verse to the j u d g m e n t of one person, the deity. T h e p o e m is an arena w h e r e the forces of inclusion and exclusion engage in battle, but the conclusion of the song is to opt for the Torah. T h u s , the antithesis did not have the last word. If w e look at the concluding bicolon from a more verse-technical point of view, w e also notice that there is n o t only opposition: b o t h versets employ the same word "way" and subject it to a subde change in syntax*. In v. 6a, the way is the object of God's care; in 6b it is promoted to the
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
29
function of subject. This, however, is a last piece of irony directed against the wicked, as their paths will lead t h e m to destruction. T h e conclusion of this first exercise in radical criticism must b e : in every case of synonymous parallelism differences remain visible b e t w e e n cola that partner each other, and in every case of antithe sis or rivalry b e t w e e n adjoining versets there is a c o m m o n basis, or w e still see elements that the cola have in c o m m o n . R e c e n t scholarly efforts in the United States have produced a sec o n d avenue of criticism against Lowth's triad, m o r e linguistic and lit erary than the first type. "Biblical parallelism is of one sort . . . , or a h u n d r e d sorts; but it is n o t three." It would be wise to use the t e r m "parallelism" as a very broad category, and then make subdivisions within this wide concept. C o n t e m p o r a r y research into the factors contributing to parallelism of versets has uncovered so many dif ferent linguistic devices at the poet's disposal that Lowth's division into three has b e c o m e o u t m o d e d : it is arbitrary, and far too r o u g h . 7
8
O n the level of the poetic line alone, at least four layers, or gate ways into the p o e m , may b e distinguished. Parallelism may be based o n phonological or morphological, lexical or semantic text data.To put it in plain English: the poet may create parallelism by means of the tools of sound and grammatical form, and by means of vocab ulary and meaning. Surprisingly enough, w e can already see this in the six short syllables by Walpole. " H e r e lies Fred; he is dead." Phonology is represented by the poet's acoustic tools: alliteration, assonance*, and rhyme; the balance of the syllables is also a factor. Morphology, or the study of linguistic forms and structures, ana lyzes the poet's choice of grammatical forms: the lines are o p e n e d by words with a fully or partially demonstrative function (here/he), after that w e get intransitive verbs in the present tense (lies/is), and finally two nouns indicating the m a n and the main predicate to b e applied to him: dead. These aspects are implied in the vocabulary, and the w o r d order also provides parallelism. T h e circle is closed w h e n the established parallelism invites us to semanticize, to p o n der w h e t h e r there is any difference left b e t w e e n " F r e d " and "dead." In t h e next chapter, these various linguistic layers will also b e discussed, o n the basis of poetic lines from the Bible. H e r e I will n o t e only h o w limited Lowth's m o d e l turns out to be: it neglects or ignores the contributions of phonological or grammatical
Reading Biblical Poetry
30
factors, and concentrates almost exclusively o n the level of v o c a b ulary and w o r d meanings. N o t i n g these defects takes us to the third approach of radical criticism, w h i c h will uncover even m o r e serious defects. This line of criticism originates from my o w n structural view of poetry, as demonstrated in almost every chapter of this b o o k . I hold that for any p o e m there is m u c h m o r e to be probed than just the layer of words and their meanings, and that a complete ladder of paral lelisms should b e climbed if w e want our attention and e m o t i o n to cover the possibilities and effects of p o e t r y in a satisfactory way. I purposely use "parallelisms" in the plural here: there are par allelisms at virtually all levels of the text, and they require detailed elaboration in the following chapters.To p u t it differently: the text is a hierarchy of layers, each layer having its o w n characteristics and rules and making its o w n particular contribution to the overall effect of the w o r k of art o n the reader. This textual hierarchy consists of eight layers in the case of short and m e d i u m - l e n g t h poems, and nine in the case of long p o e m s as D e u t e r o n o m y 32 or Psalm 8 9 . T h e y may b e represented as a series of steps: levels in the poem
step no. the poem as a whole sections stanzas strophes
verses versets words syllables sounds
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
T h e five lower levels constitute the traditional field of linguistics and style analysis. I have inserted a blank line to show the boundary with the larger textual units. Levels 6—9 have only recendy b e c o m e avail able for systematic research, thanks to the fast developments in lin guistics and the study of literature during the twentieth century. For the poets of ancient Israel, it was a standard part of their craft to w o r k at perfect expression and form on all these levels.
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
31
A n e w , c o m p r e h e n s i v e definition T h e p o e t sets out to w r i t e a verse. T h e r e is a m o r e than 95 p e r cent chance that it will b e b i - or tri-partite. To fill that space, and to remain w i t h i n the poet's o w n cultural environment and its lit erary rules (which will t h e n be understood by readers), the poet thankfully exploits parallelism as a means to balance the m e m b e r s of the verse and control the subject matter. T h e poet creates equiv alence by introducing "parallelism of members." 9
At this point in the first stages of the poet's creative w o r k I will switch to the domain of sentence structure, and describe in syn tactic terms the four possibilities the poet may choose from: 1) A n attractive and obvious decision is to fill the verset (colon) u n d e r construction w i t h o n e short sentence of t w o to five words. T h e compactness of expression of the H e b r e w language makes this easy. In this case, clause (a simple, n o n - c o m p o u n d sentence) coincides w i t h colon. W h e n the poet repeats this and creates a dis cernible cohesion w i t h the aid of sound, grammatical form, or w o r d meaning, a complete verse has b e e n b o r n , a bicolon that in characteristic H e b r e w fashion realizes "equivalence" by the paral lelism of its members. This situation occurs thousands of times in the H e b r e w Bible. 2) T h e p o e t may also decide to employ a c o m p o u n d sentence. This is a syntactic c o m p l e x consisting o f a main clause and o n e or m o r e subclauses. If the sentence is c o m p a c t e n o u g h , it may fit into o n e colon, b u t this is rarely the case. W h a t the p o e t usually does is neatly allocate o n e colon to every part of the c o m p o u n d sentence, and because t h e same t e r m clause is used to indicate the parts of a c o m p o u n d sentence (or period), situation 2 is often just a n o t h e r instance of the equation " o n e clause = o n e colon." A sim ple example of this arrangement is the o p e n i n g of Psalm 1. T h e p o e t immediately starts his main clause, w h i c h is nominal (i.e., does n o t contain a verb): " H a p p y the man"—fortunately, most translations manage to avoid inserting " i s " or " b e " (subjunctive m o o d ) . T h i s main clause is v. la, and it completely coincides w i t h t h e sentence core (subject plus predicate). T h e p o e t continues w i t h an adjectival clause in order to tell us w h a t sort of m a n he has in m i n d , and uses this clause to fill the B - c o l o n . N e x t , h o w ever, a spectacular decision follows: the p o e t adds m o r e adjectival
32
Reading Biblical Poetry
clauses.There are n o less than four, two negative followed by t w o positive clauses: v. la b c d v. 2a b
Happy the man who has not followed the counsel of the wicked, who has not taken the path of sinners, strophe 1 and has not joined the company of the insolent; but finds his delight in the teaching of Yahweh, and studies that teaching day and night.
T h u s , this o n e move o n the part of the composer creates many forms of equivalence or balance: each of the three full lines c o n tains equivalence of the versets, and there is also equivalence at the level of the verse as a w h o l e . Moreover, in the same move, this syn tactic design creates a higher textual unit, as the three poetic lines in w . 1—2 form a ready-made strophe. T h r e e lines about scum in the plural are framed by three positive lines (la and 2ab) about the m a n (singular) w h o remains o n course thanks to "the teaching of Yahweh" (two m o r e singular forms). In this way, the shape of the strophe suggests an encircling: the scum are kept in check. 3) T h e poet may also decide to w r i t e a l o n g — n o t c o m p o u n d — sentence that exceeds the b o u n d a r y of a single colon. In that case, the p o e t will usually arrange the material so that the sentence core is in o n e colon, possibly accompanied by a direct object, and any further adjuncts occupy the other colon; this happens, for instance, in the tricolic verse that depicts the "raging of the peoples" in Psalm 2: v. 2a b c
The kings of the earth take their stand and regents intrigue together against Yahweh and his anointed.
Cola a and b contain the first main clause (again: clause = colon) and the core of the second main clause, after w h i c h the C - c o l o n is filled u p w i t h the adjunct that concludes the second sentence. T h e poet, by the way, thinks of m o r e than just syntax, and at the end even manages to effect a form of balance: h e places two people in the C - c o l o n , the deity and the king, and this pair is intended to counterbalance the w o r d pair kings/regents. H o w d o G o d and
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
33
king fare in the rest of Psalm 2? If w e read on, w e find that the first strophe ( w . 1—3) prepares the reader for a harsh confrontation, and that the bosses o n earth are in for some hard knocks. 4) T h e independence of the colon is n o t affected if the p o e t includes t w o different predicates. In that case, the verset contains t w o short sentences. This situation is n o t u n c o m m o n ; take for example the B - c o l o n of a tricolon from Psalm 2: 1 0
v. 7
Let me tell you of Yahweh's decree; He said to me:You are My son, I have fathered you on this day.
Here, the king is being addressed by G o d , and w h a t h e hears is that G o d has elected h i m "today." To this end, the poet puts terms of elementary kinship in God's m o u t h : the words " s o n " and "fathered" are metaphors that vividly and "physically" express proximity. T h e p r o n o u n s m e / m y and I / y o u effectively serve to link the sentences 2—3—4, a nice t o u c h that again expresses p r o x imity and reciprocity. To recapitulate: the versemonger has four possibilities to fill a colon. T h e poet can use a phrase (usually a syntactic adjunct); a short independent sentence; often t w o short sentences; or a part (clause) of a c o m p o u n d sentence. W h a t I described as option 1 may n o w safely be called the central option because, of the four possi bilities, a simple (main) clause coinciding w i t h the colon is the r e p resentative situation: a complete sentence is finished within a single colon. Labeling the simple sentence (the only case of sentence = colon) the central option or starting point of verse making also receives support from statistics: this type of simple cola constitutes the majority of cases. O p t i o n s 2 and 3 b o t h imply that the syntac tic unit extends beyond the boundaries of a single colon. This means that the sentence continues across the caesura, a form of border crossing that is our first acquaintance with enjambment*. It is time I presented an adequate definition of a H e b r e w p o e m . In m y b o o k Reading Biblical Narrative, t h e c o u n t e r p a r t to this volume, I have explained h o w the narrator uses m o r e than o n e ingredient: n o t only language, but also time. Every sentence in a story has a c o m p l e x relationship w i t h time, if only because
34
Reading Biblical Poetry
the tension discourse t i m e / n a r r a t e d time is always there. A simi lar circumstance applies to the poet, w h o is n o t only engaged in shaping a c o m p l e x message t h r o u g h a subtle selection of linguis tic tools, but is also constantly watching the proportions of the textual units. T h e cola fit a specific verse m o d e l , t h e p o e t keeps the verses within the prescribed boundaries of the strophe, and the strophes, too, follow an articulation w h o s e extent is controlled by t h e poet. This last statement may b e put differently, using the vocabulary of equivalence and parallelism. Parallelism is not restricted to the level of the versets; w e also observe it in verses, strophes, and stan zas. In the same way that equivalence provides cohesion for the cola and knits the verse together, this is also the purpose of the composition—literally " p u t t i n g t o g e t h e r " — o f the higher textual levels. Equivalence of verses guarantees the internal cohesion of the strophe, and by creating a specific balance b e t w e e n strophes the p o e t is able to shape stanzas. In all these forms of articulation, however, time again plays a part. T h e sentences of a story take u p discourse (narration) t i m e — the time it takes to recite or read t h e m — a n d refer to narrated (story) time. Analogously, w e might n o w say of the p o e t (who his torically speaking was often a singer, for instance during worship, and w h o s e transmitted text makes the voice of the poet-singer audible even for us): the verses take up singing t i m e — t h e time it takes to recite or read t h e m — a n d the proportions of cola and verses, of strophes and stanzas lend structure b o t h to this singing, and to m e a n i n g and content of the song = p o e m . T i m e is present here in the form of proportionality. T h e measures of all textual lev els together, from syllables through to stanzas or sections, I s u m marize in the w o r d prosody. This Greek w o r d originally means the "progress of the singing." In practice it is often reduced to metrics, b u t this betrays rather sloppy thinking. In m y view, the concept of prosody deserves a broad definition w h i c h takes into account the various levels of the text, i.e., covers its hierarchical structure. In that case, prosody implies that the p o e t watches and controls the dimensions of the textual units, and as such means regulating and controlling quan tity, at all levels of the text.
The Art of Poetry: A Definition and Analysis
35
I will n o w link this u p w i t h the w o r d quality.This w o r d may be used effectively to refer to the poem's main task: conveying m e a n ing and sense. It is the poet's j o b to relate quality to quantity. H o w ever, since this sentence may equally well apply to the r u n n i n g of a supermarket, w e n e e d to narrow d o w n this statement and apply the abstract concepts of quality/ quantity in a truly literary w a y W e are approaching the definition of poetry. Such a definition will w o r k only if it takes into account b o t h ingredients used by the poet: language and prosody, or observing proportion during the creation of m e a n i n g and sense. M y defini tion of a H e b r e w p o e m , then, is as follows: A poem is the result of (on the one hand) an artistic handling of language, style and structure, and (on the other hand) applying prescribed proportions to all levels of the text, so that a controlled combination of language and number is created. I will end this chapter in the same way as I began it. W h e r e p o e t r y is concerned, literary sensitivity and an o p e n m i n d are m o r e valu able than constructing definitions. Love and concentrated atten tion are far superior to theories. Nevertheless, it will be a challenge in the following chapters to show h o w m a n y insights and tools may be gained from a view of the p o e m as a well-constructed hierarchy.
3 A text model and how to use it Language
and number
(continued)
A m o d e l o f t h e biblical p o e m Poetry is primary literature; poetics, being a scholarly discipline, produces secondary literature. M y decision to give priority to lit erary sensitivity over theorizing about p o e t r y remains valid w h e n I construct a m o d e l of the H e b r e w p o e m . T h e three main collec tions of biblical poetry are the books of Psalms, Proverbs, and Job. T h e advantage they offer over the p o e t r y in the books of the Prophets is that w i t h these three, w e k n o w w h e r e w e are: there are hardly any instances w h e r e the boundaries of the literary units are uncertain, as almost all the poems have b e e n correctly demarcated by the tradition. In these collections, the following m o d e l applies; these rules are also useful w h e n reading p o e m s from the Prophets, even t h o u g h the m o d e l is employed less rigidly there. A p o e m has: 1
2 2 2 2
to or or or
4 beats/stresses per colon 3 cola per verse 3 verses per strophe 3 strophes per stanza
These characteristics n e e d some clarification. T h e m o d e l should n o t b e viewed as a closed system, and cannot b e taken as an absolute standard. T h e r e is n o call for mathematical rigor in the playful world of poetry. M y discussion starts at the beginning, w i t h the verset. If, like me, you have the courage to believe in metrics in H e b r e w p o e t r y you may continue to use the t e r m "beats" to indicate the length of a verset. Should you consider metrics nonexistent or improbable, however, there should b e n o problem; after all, the words still have stresses, and these can b e counted. According to the model, each colon has two to four stresses, but this is n o t an absolute limit. It
Reading Biblical Poetry
38
does apply to the overwhelming majority of cases, but every o n c e in a while w e c o m e across a verset w i t h only o n e main stress or beat, or, conversely, w e find a verset containing five stresses. All this applies only to the original H e b r e w text, and is consequently of n o great importance for this book; the reader may file it away in a footnote. T h e next layer is that of the verse in the literary sense: the full poetic line. T h e verse almost always consists of t w o or three cola, never more. Sometimes, however, w e e n c o u n t e r a verse that c o n sists of only o n e c o l o n . T h e b o o k of Psalms contains t w e n t y - o n e of these versets functioning as verses. T h e r e are n o n e at all in Job, and almost n o n e in Proverbs. Such m o n o c o l a are literally marginal p h e n o m e n a , usually functioning as markers at the b e g i n n i n g or end of a higher-level textual unit such as a strophe or stanza. O f m u c h greater importance is the proportion of t w o - p a r t to three-part verses. T h e vast majority of verses are bipartite, i.e., bicola. This is clear from the percentages of tricola: almost 12.5 percent of the verses in the Psalms are tricola, in J o b only 8 p e r cent, and in Proverbs even less, 4 percent, w h i c h means many of the p o e m s it contains are completely bicolic. W e ascend to the level of the strophes. These usually consist of two or three verses, but some shorter or longer strophes do occur. T h e Psalter contains forty-one one-line strophes; a few examples are: the hymnic verse that opens Psalm 8 and returns at the end, or the "verses" (here: biblical verses) 7 and 16 that articulate Psalm 50 in three parts; the ending of Psalm 90 (v. 17, a tricolon), or the refrain verses 57:6 = 12 and 59:7 = 15.1 estimate that J o b contains some ten strophes consisting of only o n e poetic line, and Proverbs even less. Every n o w and then an extra-long strophe materializes. I could point to five four-line strophes in the Psalms, and J o b 3 contains t h r e e . At the top of the list w e find t w o strophes consisting of as many as five verses; these are Psalm 18:21-25 and Psalm 1 1 5 : 4 - 8 ; the latter is a passage about the gods outside Israel, w h i c h I will quote here: 2
3
4
5
6
v. 4 v. 5
Their idols are silver and gold, the work of men's hands; they have mouths, but cannot speak,
A Text Model and How to Use It
v. 6 v. 7
v. 8
39
they have eyes, but cannot see, they have ears, but cannot hear, they have noses, but cannot smell, their hands—but they do not touch, their feet—but they cannot walk, they can make no sound in their throats, Those who fashion them, shall become like them, all who trust in them.
T h e indentation of the B-cola (and the surplus in v. 7 w i t h its remarkable C - c o l o n , w h i c h is n o t there for n o reason) here r e p resents the typography as offered in several translations. I have, however, added something extra by having "verses" 5—7 indent o n e m o r e level. As a threesome they are clearly distinguished from v. 4 and v. 8, since they are an obvious enumeration, and w i t h all these nonfunctioning b o d y parts constitute attractive polemics*. T h e surrounding verses have clearly b e e n synchronized. All refer to people and contain the point: w h o w o u l d be so naive as to w o r ship their handiwork? T h e C - c o l o n of v. 7 concludes the central series w i t h a slightly different pattern, and together w i t h (the " m o u t h s " in) v. 5a makes a frame around the core of the evidence. At the last m o m e n t , it seems as if the p o o r wretches want to cry o u t in distress after the merciless trouncing by the poet, but they cannot manage this—they really are d u m b . This core of three verses relates to the framing verses 4 + 8 in the same way that an example relates to a general rule. We may therefore also view the frame as a split-up short strophe, the halves of w h i c h n o w function as an envelope, while the enumeration ( w . 5—7) is a regular three-line strophe. Something similar applies to Ps. 18:21—25. Viewed in this way, these five-line strophes are exceptional and creative applications of the standard dimensions for the strophe (two or three poetic lines), rather than breaks in the p a t t e r n . 7
I will n o w leave the exceptions—the frayed edges that p u t the strict rules of the m o d e l into perspective—and again look at the bulk of the strophes. It seems sensible to adopt labels for t h e t w o line and three-line strophes. F r o m n o w o n I will call the main g r o u p S(hort)-strophes, and the small g r o u p of strophes contain ing three verses L(ong)-strophes.These abbreviations enable us to
40
Reading Biblical Poetry
record the structure of a p o e m in shorthand: Psalms 1 and 113, for instance, w h i c h have already b e e n quoted in their entirety, may n o w b e w r i t t e n as LSL and SSSL, respectively. W e n o w see at a glance that the short and metaphorical strophe that forms the c e n ter of Psalm 1 has a symmetrical frame, and that Psalm 113 places its only L-strophe at the end, by way of climax. A n example from Job, w h e r e the biblical verse usually coincides w i t h the poetic line, looks like this (ch. 9):
cola syllables
L L L S 6 6 6 4 47 51 44 33 98
77
/ /
+
L L L L 6 6 6 7 48 50 48 50 98
98
/ /
S L L L 4 6 6 6 32 46 48 51 78
99
I have added the n u m b e r of cola per strophe, and the figures for the strophes (the n u m b e r s of their original, i.e., pre-Masoretic syl lables). T h e slashes in the diagram indicate that this p o e m of thirtyfour verses consists of three parts. T h e notation in capital letters immediately shows that the text has a completely symmetrical structure, and that t h e only t w o S-strophes frame the center. T h e twelve strophes have b e e n grouped in pairs, so that the three sec tions contain six stanzas. T h e precision of the prosodic design is revealed in the stanzas w h e n w e count the original syllables; these totals are given in bold typeface. Let us return to the c o m p o n e n t s of the model. It is a great pity that o u r Bible translations achieve precious little in the way of indicating strophes. People just did not realize they existed, in the old days, and then of course nowadays there is the dying-out breed of scholars w h o do n o t wish to know. In the many translations dat ing from the middle of the twentieth century the demarcation of strophes by means of blank lines is utterly arbitrary and even absent most of the time; often a blank line has been inserted to mark a stanza boundary, i.e., a higher textual level. M o r e recent transla tions are little better, sometimes worse if o n verse level they d o n o t indent B-cola and C-cola. O n l y in the very rare instances w h e r e the text really is completely straightforward do the translations manage adequately. In t h e so-called Bible de Jerusalem, a translation supervised by t h e Dominicans of the Ecole Biblique in Jerusalem,
A Text Model and How to Use It
41
the translators were obviously o n the l o o k o u t for strophic units, but they nevertheless often get it w r o n g . Finally, w e climb u p o n e m o r e level, to the stanza. This h i g h level textual unit is usually a collection of t w o or three strophes. H e r e , too, the dividing line between strophe and stanza is n o t a firewall: at times, o n e long strophe will coincide w i t h a stanza. A n example of this is the middle strophe of Psalm 10, v. 9—11. These verses depict the absolute nadir for the harassed p o o r and consti tute an L-strophe, and hence, a stanza.This unit is part of the highly regular structure of Psalms 9 - 1 0 , w h i c h together form o n e p o e m , and apart from this strophe consist exclusively of stanzas of t w o S-strophes (= four poetic lines) each. 8
At the other end of the standard dimensions w e find stanzas containing four strophes. D o w e really? I k n o w of some: stanza IV of Psalm 69, for instance, comes immediately after the center (= stanza III, the prayer for salvation of w . 15—21) and distributes its verses 22—29 over four S-strophes in w h i c h the poet asks G o d to punish his enemies; this stanza is in part a curse. A n d lo and behold, there is o n e single stanza in the Psalter (none in J o b or Proverbs) containing as many as five strophes: this is Ps. 18:8—16, a passage k n o w n as the t h e o p h a n y * . T h i s text is a g o o d example of the thesis that recognizing the structure is the instant proof of the correct strophe division:
42 v. 8a b c v. 9a b c
Reading Biblical Poetry Then the earth rocked and quaked, the foundations of the heavens shook, rocked by his indignation, Smoke went up from his nostrils, devouring fire came out of his mouth, live coals blazed forth from him.
v. 10a b v. 11a b
He bent the sky and came down, darkness was beneath his feet. He mounted a cherub and flew, gliding on the wings of the wind.
v. 12a b v. 13a b
He made darkness his screen: dark thunderheads, dense clouds of the sky. Out of the brilliance before him fiery coals blazed.
v. 14a b v. 15a b
Then Yah weh thundered from heaven, the Most High gave forth his voice. He let fly his shafts and scattered them, he discharged lightning and routed them.
v. 16a b c d
The ocean bed was exposed, the foundations of the world were laid bare By Yahweh's mighty roaring, at the blast of the breath from his nostrils.
strophe 4
strophe 5
strophe 6
strophe 7
strophe 8
H e r e w e have five S-strophes, b u t the first o n e has b e e n weighted d o w n : the verses are tripartite, so that the unit contains six rather than four cola, the same length as a regular L-strophe elsewhere. T h e strong cohesion w i t h i n this spectacular passage may be sketched in a few strokes. Strophes 4 and 8 show h o w the entire cosmos is in disarray as a result of God's anger, and strophes 5 and 7 present h i m as a warrior descending in order to intervene o n earth, o n behalf of King David. It is David w h o is the speaker in this l o n g Song of Thanksgiving, and h e is so focused o n the inter vention of the G o d w h o has affiliated himself to h i m that h e does not even grant his enemies an antecedent*: he quickly disposes of t h e m by means of the short " t h e m " in verse 15, at the m o m e n t w h e n they enter the picture as the target of God's missiles. In the center w e find the mystery of the light that should b e surrounded, if not protected, by darkness in order to describe the appearance
A Text Model and How to Use It
43
of G o d . In short: the strophic structure in this stanza follows an A B X B ' A ' pattern, and this concentric design is the best possible guarantee for the unity of the stanza. T h e A B X B ' A ' pattern is a concentric design: anger and earth quake constitute the correspondence A - A ' , war and God's m o v e m e n t from heaven to earth are B - B ' , and X is the u n i q u e pivot w i t h its paradoxical view on G o d . This first climax of the song inspired the poet to create even m o r e rings w i t h w h i c h to sur r o u n d the theophany: v. 7a b c d
In my distress I called onYahweh; cried out to my God. In his temple he heard my voice, my cry to him reached his ears.
strophe 3
[here vv. 8—16: the theophany = strophes 4—8] v. 17a b v. 18a b
He reached down from on high, he took me, he drew me out of the mighty waters, He saved me from my fierce enemy, from my haters, who were too strong for me.
strophe 9
W e d o see t w o strophes here, b u t they b e l o n g together as i n e x tricably as answer belongs to question, and neither corresponds to preceding/following strophes. I therefore see t h e m as the result of (again) a splitting-up: together, strophes 3 and 9 constitute t h e stanza of distress and salvation. N o t until after God's intervention is finished does David b o t h e r to use some verse space to refer to the victims in words: " m y fierce e n e m y " together w i t h " m y haters" form an obvious w o r d pair in v. 18. T h e balance b e t w e e n the t w o strophes is reflected in the subject of the action: in stro p h e 3 , David is the " I , " addressing G o d , whereas in strophe 9 G o d as t h e powerful agent is the subject, while David is object and beneficiary. As a stanza often contains six to ten verses—and t w o or three stanzas will in this way quickly add u p to a p o e m of fifteen or t w e n t y verses—there are few p o e m s that contain a textual unit o n t h e level b e t w e e n t h e stanza and t h e p o e m itself. O f t h e 148 p o e m s in the Psalter, a b o u t 120 can b e p r i n t e d o n o n e page (in H e b r e w , w h e r e a c o m p l e t e verse fits o n o n e line). T h e r e are,
Reading Biblical Poetry
44
however, a n u m b e r of m u c h longer p o e m s , for instance, D e u t e r o n o m y 32, Judges 5, and Psalms 18, 6 8 , 69, 7 8 , and 89; these in t u r n g r o u p their stanzas in (what I call) sections. T h u s , t h e S o n g of D e b o r a h a c c o m m o d a t e s its fifty verses in t w e n t y strophes, w h i c h together f o r m seven stanzas; the latter units are arranged into three sections. 9
At this point, a critical reader w o u l d b e perfectly justified to object that this m o d e l is a product of m o d e r n scholarship, being forced o n to the text like a straight]acket. It is a pleasant surprise, t h e r e fore, to find this poetic m o d e l neatly b o r n e o u t by the so-called alphabetic acrostics of the Bible. T h e H e b r e w alphabet consists of t w e n t y - t w o characters d e n o t ing consonants. T h e vowel and accent signs w e n o w find in the Bible were added by the Jewish tradition o n e or t w o thousand years after its composition, in order to ensure an exact recording of the correct classical pronunciation (in the synagogue). T h e first four consonants are called aleph, beth, gimel, and daleth, words w e recognize through their Greek corruptions alpha, beta, gamma, and delta. Sometimes, poets—and also writers from Ugarit, three c e n turies before David—regarded constructing a text based o n the letters of the alphabet in order as a challenge: the first verse had to start w i t h an aleph, the second w i t h a beth, etc., right d o w n to v. 22, w h i c h would start w i t h the last consonant taw and conclude the p o e m . In this way, an alphabetic acrostic has b e e n created. (Such acrostics were w r i t t e n in English by Lewis Carroll and Edgar Allan Poe.) T h e r e are a dozen of these acrostics in the Bible, and their d i m e n sions reveal exacdy the contours of the text model. T h e y differ widely as regards length, and precisely because of this they d e m o n strate that the poets did indeed work with cola, verses, strophes, and stanzas. T h e alphabet provides an acrostic arrangement: • per colon, in Psalms 111 and 112, • per poetic line, in Psalms 25, 34, and 145, and also in the concluding poem of Proverbs, the praise of "the capable wife," 31:10—31, • per strophe in Psalm 37, and in four of the five poems which make up the short book of Lamentations, • and per stanza in the longest psalm, 119.
A Text Model and How to Use It
45
This is a remarkable g r o u p of p o e m s , and incontrovertible p r o o f that t h e poets k n e w exactly w h a t constituted a colon, a verse, a strophe, and a stanza. Psalms 111 and 112 are adjacent in t h e Bible, w h i c h is n o coincidence, as they have b e e n completely synchronized. T h e i r themes are c o m p l e m e n t a r y : Psalm 111 praises G o d s uprightness, and Psalm 112 mirrors this by placing t h e u p r i g h t m a n alongside it. B o t h p o e m s e n d w i t h a double t r i colon as t h e final strophe, and they are so perfectly t w i n n e d that they have exactly t h e same length: b o t h have 168 syllables in t w e n t y - t w o cola. T h e poems in Lamentations have b e e n constructed in such a way that the letter from the alphabet at the top (Greek aero-) of the strophe always opens an L-strophe in chs. 1 and 2 and an S-strophe in ch. 4. Chapter 3 also contains L-strophes, b u t the special situa tion here is that the acrostic consonant appears three times in every strophe: at the b e g i n n i n g of each verse in the strophe that it gov erns. T h e first strophe opens all of its three verses w i t h an aleph, the fourth strophe contains the daleth three times, etc. Finally, o n stanza level there is the acrostic Psalm 119—a rather special text, w h i c h at first sight seems fairly indigestible as it is so very pious. R e a d in the original language, however, the p o e m is very stimulating, a multicolored pyrotechnic of variations and other formal devices glittering against the background of a baf fling synonymy. W i t h its 176 poetic lines, this Psalm is the longest in the entire Psalter.The Unes have been g r o u p e d into t w e n t y - t w o octets and are almost all bicolic. In each stanza (i.e., always eight verses), every line starts w i t h the acrostic consonant in question. O f the t w e n t y - t w o octets, nineteen have a rigidly binary structure in halves of 4 + 4 verses, w h i c h w e may call substanzas and w h i c h themselves may b e divided as 2 + 2 verses. T h u s , the substanza consists of two S-strophes.
I will n o w draw t w o conclusions from the presentation of the m o d e l and its illustrations. First, the numbers two and three prove alldefining on the four central levels of the poem as a hierarchical structure: colon, verse, strophe, and stanza, i.e., o n all levels above that of the w o r d and below that of t h e p o e m as a w h o l e , or its sections. These are the very layers w h e r e language acquires its literary added value
Reading Biblical Poetry
46
from the poet. Second, t h e m o d e l also reveals that three building blocks are fundamental: • • •
the colon (to prosody), the verse (to semantics* or meaning), and the strophe (to the rhetorical or argumentative design).
T h e verset or colon is already fundamental, as in general it is the smallest independent text unit by virtue of having a predicate (= it contains a verb, states something): it is a unit of m e a n i n g that may be understood in itself. To the poet, attempting to control proportions, it is also fundamental as a first building block of prosody, since it is exactly colon length (= the n u m b e r of syllables) that received particular attention from the H e b r e w poets—see below. T h e verse is fundamental to poetic semantics, as this is the level w h e r e for the first time a systematic exploitation and application of parallelism takes place, the "parallelism of the members." This p h e n o m e n o n will b e discussed in detail in the next chapter. A p o e m is at t h e same time, however, a particular f o r m of p e r suasion or argument: n o t the sort of a r g u m e n t that allies itself w i t h logic, or a discourse governed by a plot, w h i c h arranges events thematically—these are characteristics reserved for narra tive p r o s e — b u t nevertheless a string of language acts in a p a r t i c ular order (often not immediately clear), the aim of w h i c h is to persuade. This last w o r d ties in w i t h the classical definition of rhetoric: the art of persuasion (by means of language). In their o w n way, poets are just as c o n c e r n e d w i t h this as the philosopher, the w r i t e r of a newspaper article, or a Speaker of the H o u s e of Representatives. T h e H e b r e w poet produces lyrical (in the Psalms and the ora cles, and in the snatches of p o e t r y that lard the long story from Genesis through to Kings) or didactic poetry (in the representa tions of the W i s d o m literature, Proverbs and Job). T h e H e b r e w poet, too, wants to persuade, by means of poetry, by the c o n d e n s ing of language. Rarely, however, does the p o e t leave this to o n e single verse; h e n c e the scarcity of one-line strophes. T h e p o e t shores u p the verse w i t h o n e or t w o m o r e verses, and c o m b i n e d
A Text Model and How to Use It
47
into a strophic unit these represent a step or phase in the poet's argument. This is eminently clear in the b o o k of Job, w h i c h of course is o n e long debate, first b e t w e e n four and later b e t w e e n six speakers, about the most profound existential questions. T h e poet of J o b has his characters present their arguments by strophe. A n example of this will b e discussed in chapter 9. Elsewhere, too, the strophe serves as the rhetorical building block—as may b e c o n firmed by rereading the texts already discussed from Psalms 1,2, 18, and 113 (and Ps. 114 further down) or David's Lament. T h e perfect tool to forge verses into a strophe that will w o r k as a unit is offered by semantics*: applying parallelism o n verse level, i.e., o n e level higher than Lowth's parallelismus m e m b r o r u m . In the next chapters w e will see h o w the p o e t uses this device. I have pointed to three building blocks, thus distancing myself from the unfruitful discussion that sometimes erupts b e t w e e n scholars, about w h e t h e r the basic c o m p o n e n t of the H e b r e w p o e m is the colon or the verse. This shows that these scholars are looking for only o n e c o m p o n e n t ; actually, there are three, each o n its o w n level. G o i n g back to the basic level of the verset w e m e e t a second series of crucial numbers. As these are found by c o u n t i n g the syllables in the original, pre-Masoretic H e b r e w from the first millennium BCE, I can offer n o m o r e than a cursory discussion of t h e m in this b o o k . The numbers 7-8—9 are also essential, and demonstrate that the colon is thefundamental building block of Hebrew prosody. This is proved by a surprising circumstance o c c u r r i n g in n o fewer than eightyfive psalms (eighty-three poems): these p o e m s score an integer for the average n u m b e r of syllables per colon; this is usually eight, sometimes seven or nine. This highly remarkable finding can b e explained only by assuming that the poets themselves c o u n t e d syllables. As w e have seen, a simple example is Psalm 1, w i t h 144 syllables in sixteen cola; the average (number of syllables per colon) here is the integer 9, instead of the fraction that w o u l d b e likely to occur had the poets failed to count their syllables and left their n u m b e r s to chance. W e arrive a fraction if a p o e m has for instance 168 syl lables in t w e n t y - t w o cola: this division yields 7.63, the fraction that 10
48
Reading Biblical Poetry
applies to Psalms 111 and 112. T h e 9 that w e have just discovered to b e the n o r m in Psalm 1 is at the same time a signal for the c o m plete Psalter. T h e 9 is the ceiling: n o psalm exceeds 9, although there are a dozen that score exactly that. If the n u m b e r of syllables in the Psalter (the actual text, n o t including inscriptions and the like), i.e., a total o f 4 5 , 7 2 5 , is divided by the total n u m b e r of cola (5,712), the result is also 8—deviating only from the integer in the third decimal (i.e., 8.005). J o b and Proverbs even exclusively aim for the 8 as the n o r m figure. S o m e of their poems score exactly 8; the average n u m b e r of syllables per colon in the others is always close. All this w o u l d seem to indicate that the n u m b e r 8 deserves the title of "central n o r m figure of prosody." This is the beacon that the poet bears in m i n d w h e n constructing the cola. It completely dominates the longest psalm by linking up with the alphabet and the acrostic arrangement, so that this technical tour deforce (as w e have seen) consists of t w e n t y - t w o o c t e t s . 11
It is totally unnecessary for poets to give all their cola the same length (= n u m b e r of syllables); it is equally unnecessary that a large n u m b e r of cola actually realize the n o r m figure. Rather, in p r a c tice poets employ a w i d e range of colon lengths, but at the same time take care to have an exact average (i.e., an integer instead of a fraction). This range of figures (indicating the n u m b e r of syllables per colon) may b e beautifully demonstrated by Psalm 97; it is an example of the precision w i t h w h i c h the poets w o r k e d — a preci sion they did not need to maintain o n syllable level, but w h i c h they occasionally liked to realize, as a challenge. If w e read v. 5 of Psalm 97 as the tricolon that it actually is, this song contains twenty-eight cola, w i t h 224 syllables, and thus realizes the n o r m figure 8. T h e way in w h i c h this happens is rather unusual: 1 colon has 5 syllables 2 cola have 6 syllables 4 cola have 7 syllables 14 cola have 8 syllables, 4 cola have 9 syllables 2 cola have 10 syllables 1 colon has 11 syllables
i.e., a total of 112
A Text Model and How to Use It
49
This concentric regularity is built up of seven symmetrical layers. O n t h e axis w e notice that exactly half of the total of twenty-eight cola realize the n o r m figure 8. These fourteen cola contain exactly as many syllables as the other fourteen together. Meanwhile, the n u m b e r 7 is also active in various ways. To n a m e only t w o : the n u m b e r of cola o n either side of the normative axis is 7 + 7; if w e multiply 7 by the n o r m figure, w e get 5 6 — a figure of w h i c h 112 and 224 are multiples. This figure is the total o n b o t h sides of the a x i s . 12
I have drawn t w o conclusions, establishing the p r o m i n e n c e of the n u m b e r s 2 and 3 , and the fact that there are three building blocks. I will draw a final conclusion from these two: that the poets paid meticulous attention to the numerical aspect of their work, and that c o m p o n e n t II will prove to b e essential—the figures for the main textual levels, or rather the care taken about the correct proportions, w h i c h these figures represent and constantly exude.
T h e reader's c o n t r i b u t i o n ; basic t o o l s Poets spend great care and love o n their work. W h o are w e n o t to follow their example? W e are the readers—but what exactly is read ing? R e a d i n g is not a passive business; while w e read, w e d o not merely undergo something. Even the description "receptive" for this activity is inadequate, as w e do m o r e than just receive. W h e t h e r they realize it or not, readers, w h e n engaged in the act of reading, are extremely involved: they infuse a text with meaning. O u r interest is part of the living text; in our capacity as readers— i.e., through our reading activity—we are a part of the structure of the w o r k of art, however strange this may sound. O u r involvement as conferrers of meaning may b e given its due recognition as fol lows. A text that is not read is a cluster of latent meanings. It can not exercise any influence; its meanings cannot have any effect. T h e unread text leads the life of a ghost in the underworld. N o t until it is read does the text b e c o m e a " w o r k " in the full sense of the word. It needs readers in order to come alive; as soon as w e start listening to a text, but only then, it starts to speak. Imperfect listening leads to bad articulation and erroneous interpretation; good listening leads to correct understanding. T h e
50
Reading Biblical Poetry
reader w h o is unfamiliar with the rules governing the text will produce an i n c o m p e t e n t reading, preventing the text from attain ing its full potential. C o m p e t e n t readers k n o w h o w to handle the conventions and techniques employed in the text, and manage to do full justice to it.The meanings that lay d o r m a n t in the t e x t - n o t yet-read are activated by the act of reading. W h a t was latent becomes patent in a mysterious process: a fusion b e t w e e n the meanings hidden in the text and the m e a n i n g being conferred during the act of reading—or, n o t to put t o o fine a point o n it, conferred by the reader. T h e p o e m comes to life only through us, and in n o other way. This saddles us w i t h a great responsibility for the soundness and life of t h e text. Because of their semantic density, poems are often hard to understand. We as readers w o u l d therefore d o well to exercise some patience. W e n e e d n o t set ourselves the goal of understand ing everything in a single sitting, or even of getting "the message." It is better still if w e manage to rid ourselves of the m o d e r n desire for instant satisfaction. T h e p o e m suffers if w e focus o u r reading o n determining o n e m a i n point, preferably within a short time. We will, however, reap its rewards if w e manage to discard the image w e have formed of the text after a few reading sessions and start afresh, looking for n e w meanings; these will certainly appear, in p r o p o r t i o n to our openness and alertness to surprises. In o u r quest for m e a n i n g w e do well to accept the basic c o m ponents in their proper value; in the case of literature this means understanding, and profiting from, the fact that the raw material here is language.The language aspect is basic, and w e will be m o r e flexible if w e k n o w h o w to use the simple instruments that demonstrate or explain the workings of language. W e really can not do w i t h o u t the basic terms of grammar, as verse after verse w e will b e confronted w i t h the dialectics and tension b e t w e e n sen tence and verse structure. In the following, I will n e e d grammatical terms every n o w and then to b e able to describe efficiently what is happening in a verse. M a n y readers will k n o w these terms; they may skip the next para graph. T h o s e readers, however, for w h o m grammatical analysis is not a part of their daily routine also deserve to be enlightened; I will refresh their m e m o r i e s by means of a few simple examples.
A Text Model and How to Use It
51
Take for instance a sentence such as: "I have listened to you." In a syntactic analysis,"I"is called the subject,"have listened" the pred icate, and " t o y o u " is the object (governed by a preposition). In the H e b r e w text, this is a direct object (no preposition here) and the entire sentence occupies just one word, but otherwise the syntactic functions remain the same.The subject-predicate combination I call the sentence core. This core is often explained or modified by an adjunct: of time, place, or mode. Adjuncts may refer to various sen tence components. In "Anna eats cornflakes with sugar," the adjunct "with sugar" qualifies the object: the cornflakes. But in "Anna eats cornflakes with a fork," the adjunct refers to the predicate: it explains h o w she eats—in this case, which implement she uses. Grammatical analysis can be very useful. Its instruments enable us to discover h o w sentence and verse (or colon) are related, and w e b e c o m e m u c h m o r e sensitive to the r h y t h m and character of the sentences: are they long or short, d o they describe or report, beg, c o m m a n d , or complain? Grammatical analysis sharpens our observation of discrepancies and transitions. In this way, w e learn to recognize strophe boundaries, and sometimes w e are even able to correct the verse division in o u r Bible translation. T h e conclu sion of Psalm 69 is a g o o d example. B o t h the original text and most m o d e r n translations represent w . 36—37 as a tricolon plus a bicolon: v. 36a b c v. 37a b
For God will deliver Zion and rebuild the cities of Judah, so that they may dwell there, and inherit it; the offspring of his servants shall possess it, and who cherish his name shall dwell there.
T h e Masoretes (the rabbis responsible for the transmission of the biblical text) and the translators have here let themselves be fooled by the transition by means of "so t h a t " and the w o r d "there," w h i c h refers back to Judah; and even m o r e by the position of " t h e offspring of his servants." This subject does n o t appear until the fourth line, but is actually already active in 36c. I will first switch the order to bicolon + tricolon, and t h e n make some minimal adjustments to the English:
52 v. 36a b c v.37a b
Reading Biblical Poetry For God will deliver Zion and rebuild the cities of Judah, So that they may dwell there, and inherit it: the offspring of his servants shall possess it, and who cherish his name shall live there.
For m y defense of this adaptation I use such elementary tools of lin guistic study as the differences between singular and plural, and between subject and object. Two lines have been devoted to G o d and his transitive actions: 36a + b. These are the only two lines to contain proper names. N e x t , n u m b e r and subject are turned around: there are n o w three lines dealing with the people, and their status as beneficiary is raised to that of subject. A quick switch from linguis tics to literature proves the decisive factor: w e observe the effect of parallelismus m e m b r o r u m , and note a neat pattern in the verbs of the tricolon: two intransitive verbs frame two transitive ones. This is an A B - B ' A ' pattern, and it governs the series dwell-inherit / p o s sess—Hve.The intransitive verbs "dwell" and "live" are an official word pair, as are the transitive verbs "possess" and "inherit." We also need to be aware of linguistic aspects w h e n w e observe the contest b e t w e e n sentence and verse structure. In D e u t e r o n o m y 32, Moses recites an awesome didactic p o e m and starts off straight away w i t h a well-wrought L-strophe containing the o p e n ing exhortation: v. la b v. 2a b c d
Give ear, O heavens, let me speak, let the earth hear the words I utter, May my teaching come down as the rain, my speech distill as the dew, like showers on young growth, like droplets on the grass.
T h e core is simple and consists of t w o short sentences: the c o m m a n d "Give ear, O heavens!" and Moses' wish that " m y teaching may bear fruit." W e are not, however, meant to smother p o e t r y in such simplifications, b u t w e should analyze and enjoy h o w the core has b e e n w o r k e d up, unfolded, and decorated—so that w e may t h e n discover that this elaboration opens up all sorts of w i n dows and dimensions t h r o u g h w h i c h we may catch sight of the added literary and spiritual value of the p o e m .
A Text Model and How to Use It
53
In the first poetic line, the elements of the half verses have b e e n arranged according to an abc / / a'b'c' pattern. W h a t u n d e r c was still a verb, "let m e speak," has already in the second colon b e c o m e nominal, "words." This in t u r n enables an inclusio of the verse by parts of the body: l a starts off w i t h ears and thus straightaway anthropomorphizes the heavens; l b ends w i t h Moses' m o u t h . In this way, a balanced c o m m u n i c a t i o n also has b e e n achieved: t h e m a n speaks, and the surrounding world listens. Parallelismus m e m b r o r u m enables the p o e t to divide the world into t w o areas, i.e., the merism "heaven and earth." R e r e a d i n g the verse, w e realize that these represent the domains of G o d and of man, respectively, and that here already the question is implied w h e t h e r there will be h a r m o n y b e t w e e n the two. T h e i r "vertical" relation is still effective in 2a and 2c, since the rain comes d o w n from heaven. In this way, Moses suggests at the same time that his lesson is of heavenly quality. This is n o t arrogance o n Moses' part, since in the preceding chapter, D e u t e r o n o m y 3 1 , w e have b e e n prepared for the song by some explanatory prose telling us that G o d himself has composed it, and that h e also c o m m a n d e d Moses to d o something that is u n c o m m o n in ancient Israel: record the text in writing. Verse 2 starts w i t h t w o m o r e lines/cola containing verbs, i.e., the n e w sentence core (two parallel lines, because of duplication), b u t 2cd n o longer contains any verbs. W e notice that the sentence runs o n and reaches a broad conclusion in an (again double) adjunct. After this initial excitement the strophe lands, as it were, in t h e quiet of green pastures. This is also the result of consider able enjambment: the sentence transcends n o t only a colon boundary, but also a verse boundary. T h e cola of 2ab constitute n o t only the numerical center; they are a sort of anchor or point of attachment for two p r o m i n e n t quartets arranged along vertical lines: t h e terms for the didactic p o e m , and the fourfold application of simile*.The interlacing of the t w o quartets in the middle makes for a tightly constructed first strophe:
Reading Biblical Poetry
54 I speak my words my teaching my speech
> >
> >
< <
< <
rain dew showers droplets
T h e first t w o terms (rain/dew) appear at the ends of their lines, and are the objects of the act of listening; their synonyms, t h e n e x t t w o terms (showers/droplets), o p e n their lines and are the s u b jects of the act of distilling, c o m i n g d o w n = m a k i n g fertile. T h e first t w o cases of simile, " r a i n " and "dew," appear at the ends of the same t w o lines (2ab), b u t are upgraded to the plurals " s h o w ers" and "droplets," w h i c h t h e n occupy front positions in lines 2cd, and also acquire the "addresses" ("targets") y o u n g g r o w t h and grass. T h u s , v. 2cd is rilled to the b r i m w i t h the terms of t h e comparison. T h e t w o poetic lines of v. 2 also show the following structure: my teaching my speech
rain dew showers droplets
young growth grass
In the pair " r a i n / d e w " w e again see the above/beneath contrast implied in heaven/earth, but our feet move closer and closer to the g r o u n d in the final verse 2cd. This concluding verse also harbors a covert suggestion: Moses, at that m o m e n t addressing the nation in a subtropically w a r m spot, quietly hopes that his audience may b e as receptive to his words as the y o u n g growth and grass are to the rain. In o u r interaction w i t h the poet's language, another set of ele m e n t a r y distinctions is also very effective: the various g r a m m a t i cal persons. M o r e differentiated than English, H e b r e w has at its disposal the first, second, and third persons in singular and plural; there are ten different forms in all, as gender is indicated not only for the third, but also for the second person: singular plural
I we
you (m) / you (f) you (m) / you (f)
he / she they (m) / they (f)
A Text Model and How to Use It o u
55
a s
and there are forms for m y / o u r , " y " o b j e c t / y o u r (singular and plural, m and f), his/her, and " t h e m " (direct and indirect object, m and f). F u r t h e r m o r e , the conjugated verb forms largely reflect the same distinctions, by means of prefixes or suffixes. W h e n Israel or Jerusalem are addressed by the prophets as a lady, and sometimes as beloved or whore, the second-person feminine is used; w e find this in passages from Hosea, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Lamentations, and the occasional psalm. T h e Song of Songs c o n sists of constantly alternating speeches by a boy and a girl, t w o lovers, addressing each other. T h e girl speaks slightly m o r e verses than the boy. W h e n he speaks to her instead of about her, the same second-person feminine is again used. T h e distinction between the grammatical persons is of great help to us for the articulation of the p o e m . In the Song of Songs it is by far the most important signal, as the speaking voice changes rapidly: more than forty times in this small collection of love poetry. W h e n someone says "Flee!" in the imperative masculine (8:14), the reader of the H e b r e w immediately knows that the girl is speaking. T h e verb form is the same as that in 2:17:"turn around, my beloved, swift as the gazelle," etc. (The Song of Songs will be discussed in m o r e detail in ch. 10.) W h e n w e hear a feminine form, the boy is speak ing. A translation should indicate the changes of voice correctly by always announcing the speakers by " H e " or " S h e " in the margin. In the Psalms, too, the change of persons is an important signal w h i c h often helps in distinguishing the strophes. T h e r e are rather a lot of poems that cover a triangle: the lyrical I (the speaker or poet)—his God—the enemies. A n obvious structure is then for o n e strophe to say: I a m complaining; the next one: they vilify m e ; and for another strophe to implore: save m e ; and this variation in per sons is accompanied by other differences. In the strophe about the enemies w e w o u l d expect the speaker to report in the past tense, and in the strophe about his own misery to describe his pain and anger in the present tense, while the verb will have the form of a wish or c o m m a n d in the strophe addressed to G o d . These lament ing psalms c o m e in t w o types: the complaint of a single p e r s o n — for instance, Psalm 7 1 — a n d the complaint of the people—for instance, Psalm 44 or 74. In the latter case, the p o e m will n o t b e about calumny or illness, but about disaster o n a national scale, such as war and destruction. Contrasted w i t h this genre are the
Reading Biblical Poetry
56
songs that praise or thank G o d , and in w h i c h the lyrical I (some times a " w e " ) usually faces only o n e other character. This is, of course, G o d , mostly addressed in the second person, but in the case of a song of praise h e may also figure in the third person. T h e benefit of a bit of grammatical analysis, and paying atten tion to grammatical persons, immediately becomes clear w h e n w e look at this short p o e m : verse
Psalm 114
la b 2a b
When Israel went forth from Egypt, the house ofJacob from a people of strange speech, Judah became his sanctuary, Israel his dominion.
3a b 4a b
The sea saw them and fled, the Jordan ran backward; mountains skipped like rams, hills like sheep.
5a b 6a b
What alarms you, O sea, that you flee, you Jordan, that you run backward? Mountains, that you skip like rams, hills, like sheep?
7a b 8a b
Earth, shake at the presence of Yahweh, at the presence of the God of Jacob, who turned the rock into a pool of water, the flinty rock into a fountain!
strophe
1
2
3
4
This text has a strictly binary structure: 1 p o e m , 2 stanzas (halves), 4 strophes, 8 verses, 16 cola.The first half speaks about history and contains only third-person forms of the verb, in the past tense. T h e second half, conversely, is d e t e r m i n e d by the second person of the address, and by its questions and commands represents a dynamic present. These changes in tense and person already suggest a divi sion into two stanzas. Yet, m o r e is n e e d e d to confirm this. W e should start looking for the demarcation of the strophes—is the above division correct? Possibly the most striking aspect of Psalm 114 is the fact that the third strophe uses almost the same words as strophe 2, albeit in the interrogative.This duplication is a very broad, and hence crass, form
A Text Model and How to Use It
57
of repetition. In b o t h units, w e meet four "characters" from nature ( w . 3—4 plus 5-6).These are framed by t w o S-strophes referring to a miracle.Thus, w e may easily establish that the p o e m as a w h o l e is o n e big chiasm, since its strophic units follow the A B - B ' A ' pattern. T h e p o e m sings of the exodus, the m o m e n t in history that saw the birth of the people of Israel as a political and spiritual entity. It is, however, preferable to speak of a p e r i o d rather than a m o m e n t , as the song presupposes a broad "definition" of the exodus, in three stages: •
phase 1 is the journey out (from the hard labor in Egypt), • phase 2 is the journey through the desert (forty years, according to the tradition), • phase 3 is the journey into the promised land (called Canaan at the time, later Palestine).
This series of three phases is subtly reflected in the p o e m . T h e transition from phase 1 to phase 2 is pointed out o n the map, as it were, by the reference to the sea; this is the (northern tip of) the R e d Sea, w h o s e b e d ran dry w h e n the Israelites left Egypt, and w h i c h shortly afterwards buried the pursuing Egyptian cavalry u n d e r its waters (as narrated and sung in the b o o k of Exodus, chs. 14—15).The transition from phase 2 to phase 3 is demonstrated by the exact North—South course of the Jordan. T h e choice of sea and river in v. 3 n o t only is very precise, but also implies that the poet cleverly connects the dimensions of time and space. As a pair, sea and river evoke the complete three-stage structure of the exodus, thanks to their position o n the c o n t i n u u m of space and time. I will briefly survey the strophes. T h e cohesion of the first strophe is already guaranteed by the sentence structure: this verse pair constitutes o n e c o m p o u n d sentence. T h e strophe is also remarkable because it connects the b e g i n n i n g and the end of the j o u r n e y : v. 1 describes the actual departure; v. 2 mentions the settlement in the promised land. By immediately pointing to the t w o extremes of the expedition, the p o e t has already presented the w h o l e of the three-part event in the first strophe, in the line of a merism. This leaves the other three strophes free to occupy themselves w i t h m o m e n t s from the middle phase, the j o u r n e y t h r o u g h the desert.
Reading Biblical Poetry
58
T h e song has b e e n meticulously constructed in other ways, too. In the " o u t e r " strophes, the device of double duty is applied o n c e per verse: the predicate of the A - c o l o n is also active in the B-colon. We see this in each pair of lines; the predicates " g o forth" and " b e c o m e " also apply to w . l b and 2b, and "shake" and " t u r n i n t o " are also effective in w . 7b and 8b. T h e "inside" strophes, however, do something exceptional by b o t h m o r e than duplicating the use of a virtual predicate! W h a t in v. 3a is first said of the sea—i.e., that it saw the crossing—applies just as m u c h to the river in 3b and to the mountains in 4ab. A n d the lively question opening v. 5, w h i c h may be freely rendered as " W h a t o n earth is w r o n g w i t h y o u ? " is of course also asked of the Jordan, etc. T h e question is given only once, but applies to four subjects—what density and efficient use of language! T h e following diagram again notes h o w carefully this o n e device has b e e n applied t h r o u g h o u t verses and strophes; an " o " indicates a virtual predicate, and an " x " the visible (I a m t e m p t e d to say, physical) presence of the verb: strophe 1
strophe 2
strophe 3
strophe 4
x o x o
x o o o
x o o o
x o x o
Let us look once more at the cohesion of the strophes. T h e c o r r e spondence between the " i n n e r " strophes (2 and 3) as a B - B ' pair is crystal clear: it is an instance of perfect mirroring. T h e c o m b i n a tion A - A ' for the "outside" strophes (1 and 4) is ensured n o t only by the fact that they b o t h refer to a miracle, but also by the pres ence of two characters that are missing from strophes 2—3: G o d and Israel, in their qualities of powerful savior and chosen people. T h e n a m e Jacob ( l b and 7b), and the Israel of la, represent the entire people (ideally consisting of twelve tribes). Things are slightly dif ferent in v. 2, w h e r e a rare form of parallelism is employed in w h i c h b o t h members are explicitly meant to include each other: v. 2a b
Judah became His sanctuary, Israel His dominion.
H e r e , J u d a h represents the s o u t h e r n k i n g d o m , w h i c h was t h e d o m a i n of the Davidic dynasty, and Israel in v. 2b refers to t h e
A Text Model and How to Use It
59
n o r t h e r n k i n g d o m (of t h e ten tribes, after the schism). O f course, the verse is n o t saying that only J u d a h has b e c o m e hallowed g r o u n d for G o d , to the exclusion of the ten tribes, or that G o d w a n t e d to b e the ruler of the n o r t h e r n k i n g d o m only. W h a t actu ally happens here is that the t w o names infiltrate each other, although the division into cola seems to pull t h e m apart. T h e verse m e n t i o n s t w o dimensions: politics (power) and religion. To all the people of Israel (albeit t o r n into t w o halves after S o l o m o n ) , b o t h areas remain active and important. W i t h its u n i q u e t e c h nique o f an inclusive alignment o f cola, the verse proclaims that G o d is t h e creator and sovereign of b o t h dimensions, but the s u b tle construction also suggests that the sovereignty of this Savior and G o d of the covenant far exceeds t h e schism and is a crucial uniting factor. T h e d i c h o t o m y of the poetic line implicitly and lovingly relativizes the schism w i t h i n t h e nation: the parallelism poetically restores unity, and forcefully defends the view that Israel as a spiritual unity was a w h o l e , and should remain a w h o l e — a truly paradoxical relationship b e t w e e n verse form and the intention of the p o e m . Strophes 2 and 3 are masterpieces thanks to metaphorics, a n t h r o p o m o r p h i s m , and personification: the poet has equipped sea and river, mountains and hills w i t h eyes in order to see, and they observe so well that they acutely realize w h a t is happening here: a ragged b u n c h of semi-nomads are trekking through the cruel desert, and n o o n e dares to lift a finger against t h e m . T h e eye witnesses understand that there is only o n e explanation: the overwhelming power of the only true G o d . T h e y want to do an a b o u t - t u r n in n u m i n o u s dread, and rear up in fright—all perfectly reasonable. In strophe 3 , the liveliness of this a n t h r o p o m o r p h i c treatment of the landscape is raised another n o t c h w h e n the poet addresses sea and mountains: they are even p r o m o t e d to conversa tion partners! This type of personification, however, at the same time implies that the p o e t changes the dimension of time w i t h a magic wand. W h a t thus far has b e e n represented as history (in the first half), reported in the past tense, n o w becomes, by the ques tioning of sea and rocks, the present—not only for the speaker, but also for that other character silently involved, the reader. A n d this means that the miracle of the liberation from Egypt is not really
60
Reading Biblical Poetry
finished; it is n o t a closed b o o k , b u t living reality for the p o e t and his audience. In the final strophe the awe for the Savior is still prominent. T h e speaker commands the earth to "shake." T h e choice of this word, for w h i c h I a m responsible, is a n o t totally convincing attempt to preserve a salient ambiguity in the original text. T h e c o m m a n d employs h o m o n y m y : t w o roots in H e b r e w that sound the same, but of w h i c h the o n e means " w r i t h e , shiver in fear or agony," and the other "perform a r o u n d dance." Poets like these ambiguities, and so did the maker of Psalm 114. T h e earth has to tremble in awe, as well as perform a chorus dance "at the presence of the G o d of Jacob." Together, these actions are the best acknowledgment of G o d . T h e t e r m " e a r t h " is an extension of the words that have b e e n used earlier for the landscape: it summarizes sea and river, m o u n tains and hills. T h e magic of the poetic w o r d has t u r n e d all of nature into an eyewitness of miracles, from w h i c h it should n o w draw the consequences: adoration and worship. T h e final strophe recollects h o w it was possible to survive a forty-year trek t h r o u g h the desert: o n the water that G o d allowed to b e struck from the rock. T h e opposition r o c k / w a t e r expresses the miracle, and the close-knit symmetry of the cross construction A B - B ' A ' invites us to make a metaphoric link w i t h the o p e n i n g of the p o e m . T h e fact that life-giving water may b e drawn from unsympathetic rocks also serves as an image for the chosen p e o ple, w h o will live by leaving harsh Egypt and the chains of slavery b e h i n d i t . T h e o n e is just as m u c h of a surprise as the other.
Parallelism: cola and verses
T h e poet's main strategy for shaping his verses is of a semantic nature. It is a special kind of repetition-and-variation w h i c h w e have m e t before, and w h i c h is called parallelismus m e m b r o r u m . T h e clarity of Bishop Lowth's description of it has, for t w o c e n turies, also had the negative effect of encouraging people n o t to look further than their noses (i.e., the verse). Scholars looked at the poetic line, asked themselves w h e t h e r the semantic links were based o n correspondence or opposition, and called the result syn o n y m o u s or antithetical parallelism. All analysis was, however, "horizontal," i.e., it considered only the parts of a single verse, h e n c e mostly the bicolon.Yet, w e quickly discover that this view is far t o o narrow. Take for instance the following three popular verses from Psalm 137, the song in w h i c h "by the rivers of Baby lon, there w e sat down, and wept, and hanged o u r harps u p o n the willows": v. 5 v. 6
If I forget you, O Jerusalem, let my right hand wither; let my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth, if I do not remember you, if I do not set Jerusalem above my highest joy.
This is the slightly old-fashioned English from the R S V . Together, these poetic lines form an L-strophe. It is immediately obvious that the four cola of w . 5—6b have b e e n arranged chiastically, because "forget" is identical w i t h " d o not remember," and the center of the quartet has b e c o m e a closely knit pair because of the three b o d y parts in uncomfortable situations. T h e p o e t feels himself b e c o m ing physically ill at the very t h o u g h t of giving u p his roots. T h e
62
Reading Biblical Poetry
conclusion of the strophe is a climax resulting from a sort of spa tial collision. In 6c the speaker tries for the third time to express the inexpressible by means of the conditional conjunction ("if"), and for a m o m e n t his subclause seems to drag us d o w n w i t h it in " d o n o t set above," but that is it: the positive terms of v. 6d propel h i m and us in the other direction, upwards.This final colon u n a m biguously reveals w h a t the capital of his h o m e l a n d J u d a h really means to him: it is his supreme source of inspiration. T h e p o e t is w r i t i n g a "song of Zion," whereas h e has just refused to submit to the pressure from the Babylonian victors and has answered their request for a song w i t h " H o w can w e sing a song of Yahweh / o n alien soil?" T h u s h e manages effectively to sing of his situation of n o t - w a n t i n g - a n d - n o t - b e i n g - a b l e - t o - s i n g — w e r u n into another paradox. T h e cross construction A B - B ' A ' for the quartet of cola in w . 5—6b demonstrates that the "parallelism of the m e m b e r s " as a p r i n ciple of repetition and ordering is certainly not restricted to the single verse, and easily transcends the verse boundary. It is also obvious that the bicolon in v. 6cd is inextricably linked to the p r e vious t w o verses, o n the basis of semantic repetitions (i.e., again parallelismus m e m b r o r u m ) . W i t h respect to the parallel ordering of versets, this means that this alignment may just as easily d e m a r cate a textual unit of a higher level: a complete strophe. W e have n o w shaken off a few Lowthian chains and gained unrestricted access to the p h e n o m e n o n of parallelismus m e m b r o r u m . Yet, w e have n o t finished w i t h the bishop entirely. It was he w h o pertinently observed that the parallelism of cola may already b e established by o n e single word pair. W h e n w e read about the destruction of Jerusalem (on w h i c h Lamentations looks back): Lam. 2:17ab
Yahweh has done what he purposed, He has carried out the decree that he ordained,
litde practice is required to see that every element of o n e verset has a counterpart in the other. Here, parallelism is based o n the m a x i m u m n u m b e r of w o r d pairs, as was also the case in David's lament. Lowth, however, observed that o n e pair is already e n o u g h to establish parallelism. A bit further o n in Lamentations the p o e t says of God:
Parallelism: Cola and Verses 3:7
63
He has barred every exit for me, he has chained me in heavy brass chains.
T h e repetition of " h e has . . . m e " is a part of the verb form in the original language, and this predicate is the only element that has a counterpart in the other colon. O n c e w e have made the c o n n e c t i o n — w i t h considerable support from prosody: the suggestion of cooperation emanating from the lengths of the t w o clauses—we find that there is another, antithetical relationship. T h e w o r d "exit" betrays n o t only the speaker's position (he has n o w h e r e to go, see also v. 9), but also his desire to escape.This longing to move is n o w thwarted by solid matter: h e is chained up! G o i n g o n e step further, I quote another verse of w h i c h the halves have, at first sight, only one element in c o m m o n : Ps. 3:5
When I cry aloud to Yahweh, He answers me from His holy mountain.
We quickly notice, however, that there is a simple but effective r e c iprocity in "I . . .Yahweh" plus " h e . . . me." It often happens that a reader first sees o n e such p e g to hold o n to, and then finds that there is m o r e going on, noticing m o r e subtle or hidden points of contact b e t w e e n the cola. T h u s , we may listen to old Jacob w h o , o n his deathbed, blesses all his sons o n e after another, that is, gives t h e m strength for the future. In Genesis 4 9 : 5 - 7 , however, the for mula h e utters about S i m e o n and Levi—about t h e m , i.e., h e uses the third person, an option that already betrays distance—changes into a real curse: Gen. 49:6b
For in their anger they slay men and in their wantonness they hamstring oxen.
In the original language the verse has exactly 8 + 8 syllables. N o r mally, m e n and oxen w o u l d not constitute a w o r d pair, but here they do. This is because the opening words of each verset straight away establish the parallelism. T h e poet has placed the adjuncts disqualifying the sons in front, a syntactic decision for the sake of expressiveness.The synonymy of "their anger" and "their w a n t o n ness" is evident, thus m a k i n g m e n / o x e n a pair of complements. Outside the context of the p o e m , n o clear connection exists
64
Reading Biblical Poetry
b e t w e e n slaying and cutting hamstrings either, but n o w that the parallelism has already b e e n established these t w o verbs b e c o m e obvious partners in violence. Another, simple example of parallelismus m e m b r o r u m b e c o m ing active and visible o n the basis of o n e obvious word pair is the repetition of the w o r d " w a y " in the concluding verse of Psalm 1: Ps. 1:6
ForYahweh knows the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked is doomed.
T h e duplication of " w a y " is immediately obvious, but straight after that w e see that the opposition r i g h t e o u s / w i c k e d also produces a w o r d pair, and w e next enjoy the subtle difference b e t w e e n the transitive verb representing care and contact, and the intransitive predicate in the final colon, w h i c h contains o n e character less.
T h e relation w o r d p a i r — p a r a l l e l i s m S o m e twenty to thirty years ago the " w o r d pair" was the center of scholarly attention. As it is the principal c o m p o n e n t in the cre ation of parallelism b e t w e e n versets, an extensive h u n t was started to build u p a collection. This collector's mania suited a p e r i o d in w h i c h scholars followed largely atomistic methods. Researchers sifted through separate words, sunk their teeth into grammatical details, or focused o n textual criticism, all because of the many flaws in the transmitted text. T h e exegetes did not realize at that time that outside the world of biblical scholarship, research into productive theories w i t h respect to the textual whole, c o m m u n i cation processes, pragmatics, the text-reader interaction, etc. had long since begun. Biblical texts were primarily studied diachronically: o n e hypothesis after the other was drawn u p concerning the origin of the texts, their previous forms, the history of their trans mission, and so forth. A valiant search also was conducted to dis cover " t h e writer's intention," as if it were even remotely possible to ascertain this if the text itself did not make it fully implicit. All this effort was based o n the misguided conviction that a correct understanding of the text could not be achieved w i t h o u t first k n o w i n g h o w it originated, and that such a detour t h r o u g h the reconstruction of the text's history even constituted the principal
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
65
access to its meaning. Scholars also speculated about the p o e t s methods: his predecessors were supposed to have accumulated a complete stockpile of w o r d pairs, from w h i c h poets then drew in order to assemble their lines. T h e theory was that d u r i n g this process of tinkering and fiddling w i t h words, parallelismus m e m b r o r u m arose by accident or as a kind of by-product. In short, the illusion was as follows: parallelismus m e m b r o r u m is the result of (using) w o r d pairs, and w r i t i n g poetry becomes p o s sible only after a linguistic c o m m u n i t y has scraped together or t h o u g h t u p a sizeable collection of w o r d pairs.This line of t h o u g h t in t u r n stimulated the exegetes to continue their h u n t for w o r d pairs ("another o n e for m y list!"). T h e s e lists of collected w o r d pairs do have some function, b u t only if w e radically t u r n t h e t h e o r y that " w o r d pairs make p a r allelism" upside d o w n . Actually, the situation is exactly t h e reverse: parallelism attracts w o r d pairs, and these n e e d n o t be taken from some artificially created inventory; the vast majority are simply available in everyday language. Even if you are n o t a poet, y o u will still b e able to conjure u p a plentiful array of w o r d pairs: f a t h e r / m o t h e r , light/dark, g o o d / e v i l , above/below, left/ right, arms/legs, and so on; and t h e n there are such nice c o m b i nations as " h i d e n o r hair" or "all and sundry." This radical rever sal consequently means that the w h o l e (of t h e verse or strophe) controls t h e parts and allocates their functions to t h e m , rather than t h e o t h e r way r o u n d . O f course, it is t r u e that t h e parts c o n tribute to t h e w h o l e , b u t these have b e e n chosen and arranged from t h e start w i t h an eye to the overall structure. T h e w h o l e is m o r e than t h e s u m of its parts, as h e r m e n e u t i c s (the art of explaining) has k n o w n for centuries. 1
Parallel and concentric arrangements After this short excursion, I will further explore the possibilities of parallelismus m e m b r o r u m . W i t h i n the demarcation lines of prosody—and here I m e a n especially the limited dimensions of cola and verses—there are two ways to arrange w o r d pairs or other obvious correspondences: a parallel pattern, w h i c h w e may n o t e d o w n as abc/abc, or a concentric arrangement, w h i c h w o u l d b e
66
Reading Biblical Poetry
abc/cba. This could result in tedious monotony, were it n o t that language offers many forms and devices o n different levels, and the p o e t is their p r i m e manipulator. For instance, the p o e t could write: " h e led m e in darkness, / b r o u g h t m e in gloom," a neatly parallel bicolon; each half-verse has its o w n sentence core, and the structure is a b / a ' b ' . T h e maker of Lamentations apparently t h o u g h t this yielded t o o m u c h syn onymy, and w r o t e the line as follows: 3:2
He has led me and brought me in darkness and gloom.
This solution, w h i c h repeats the verb in the first half-verse and renders the darkness inescapable by duplicating it in the other halfverse, makes G o d m o r e of a conspirator. T h e pattern here is a a ' / b b ' , w h i c h implies that the parallelism is n o w already active w i t h i n the colon. In 3:56, too, the predicate is doubled in the first half-verse, w i t h the adjunct being varied in the other: You have heard my voice: do not shut your ear to my groan, to my cry. C o m p a r e this w i t h the following variant, o n e verse further o n in Lamentations, in w h i c h the " I " of the A - c o l o n is transformed into a second person, thanks to an e m b e d d e d speech in the B-colon: 3:57
You are near the day that I call upon you, You say: fear not.
In these examples the c o m p o n e n t s have b e e n arranged in a paral lel structure. T h e other obvious order is, conversely, concentric (abc/cba) or chiastic (ab/ba). This is a form of m i r r o r i n g that occurs often and may have varying effects. T h r e e of these effects have to do w i t h balance created by symmetry—for instance, the cycle of nature (a), a tightly closed unit, finished and perfect (b), or its opposite: contrast or irreconcilable difference (c). S o m e examples follow; let m e start in o u r o w n age, w i t h the following lines from T. S. Eliot's Four Quartets: What we call the beginning is often the end, And to make an end is to make a beginning
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
67
In t h e overture to Ecclesiastes w e find the following observation, n o t m e a n t to cheer: (a) Eccl. 1:5
the sun rises and the sun sets, and panting hurries to the place where it rises.
It is clear that the p o o r creature—the " p a n t i n g " turns it into a p e r son—does n o t have a moment's rest and like the Black Q u e e n in Through the Looking Glass is h u r r y i n g n o w h e r e fast. In 1:7, w e read: all streams flow to the sea, yet the sea is never full. a chiasm that depicts half of a cycle, and especially the pointlessness of it. T h e r e is an attractive similarity w i t h l:8ab, w h i c h should p e r haps be classed u n d e r "being tightly closed."The verse should have the refractory quality that a very literal translation brings out, but this is unfortunately absent in the existing translations: (b)
All words/things are wearisome, man can not state them.
T h e closure of the a b / b ' a ' pattern can w o r k out favorably or unfa vorably. T h e actual word order in Psalm 22:13 is as follows: Ps. 22:13
Surrounded I am by many bulls, buffaloes of Bashan have encircled me.
T h e animals are a m e t a p h o r for the poet's enemies; shortly after wards, in v. 17a, they are dogs. A n o t h e r example of a chiasm in a m i n o r key occurs a bit further d o w n in this psalm, w h i c h starts w i t h the w e l l - k n o w n " M y God, m y G o d , w h y hast t h o u forsaken me?" Ps. 22:16
Like a shard my vigor dries up, my tongue cleaves to my palate.
Being encircled, however, also may m e a n being protected, of w h i c h a chiasm is the perfect expression in a major key. T h u s , David says of G o d " w h o girded m e w i t h m i g h t " in Psalm 18:
68 Ps. 18:34
Reading Biblical Poetry who made my feet like a deer's and on my heights has made me stand
an image of power and sovereignty that is the exact opposite of that in 2 Samuel 1:19, w h e r e (as w e heard) the mighty have fallen, " y o u r gazelle/jewel [disguise and m e t a p h o r for Jonathan], O Israel" lies slain o n the heights of the land. G o d is a shield, the lady called W i s d o m says in Proverbs 2, Prov. 2:8a
guarding the paths of justice, the way of those loyal to him he protects.
In Psalm 89, a p o e t loyal to David's dynasty addresses the follow ing words to G o d , about the power of chaos: Ps. 89:10
You rule the swelling of the sea, when its waves surge, you still them.
A concentric structure is eminently suited to show compelling coherence. T h e prose narrative of the paradise story is illuminated by a poetic line (Gen. 2:23) that has a lot to say about the balance b e t w e e n m a n and w o m a n — w o r d s that in H e b r e w sound roughly like 'ish and 'isha. After the w o m a n has b e e n created, the m a n expresses his recognition and concurrence in these words: this one | shall be called | 'isha | because | from the 'ish | taken was | this one, in an abc x c'b'a' pattern that revolves around the hinge of the motivating conjunction "because." (The | separates the various c o m p o n e n t s , as in the next example.) T h e symmetry represents balance and reciprocity. T h e same symmetry, this time w i t h o u t the pivotal "x," in Genesis 9 declares that murder may be avenged only by the life of the killer. For the sake of structure I will translate literally: Gen. 9:6
Whoever sheds | the blood | of a man for that man | his blood | will be shed.
T h e symmetric precision shows that the " m a n " w h o is the victim in t h e first half-verse is identical w i t h "that m a n " in the second
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
69
half-verse. This means that n o additional group or individual is introduced in the second colon, as implied by the standard trans lation, w h i c h runs: "by m a n shall his blood b e shed." As soon as w e start w o n d e r i n g by w h o m else (an ant? an elephant?) w e realize that the rendering "by m a n " is a stopgap, w h i c h in an erroneous translation has b e e n placed in front in the B - c o l o n . A n o t h e r d r a w back is that in this way a third party is suddenly introduced. T h e translation "for that man," meaning as a compensation for the life taken, is as part of the abc-cba symmetry a perfect expression of talio (retaliation): the legal principle that by the symmetry of "an eye for an eye" says that unrestrained revenge is sinful; the p u n i s h m e n t should fit the c r i m e . 2
Case (c), a chiasm expressing opposition, also requires illustra tion. In Proverbs 8 , W i s d o m says: Prov. 8:7
For truth is uttered by my palate, abhorrent to my lips is wickedness.
T h e abstract nouns, representing totally non-abstract behavior, encircle the parts of the body; they cannot b e united and thus have b e e n driven to the edges of the poetic line, as far apart as possible. A n o t h e r sharp contrast is expressed by the prophet w h o despairs of his life and his mission, since n o o n e is willing to listen to h i m . Jeremiah 20 contains g r i m words, strongly reminiscent of the p r o logue to J o b : Jer. 20:14
Accursed be the day that I was born, the day my mother bore me, let it not be blessed.
W e also c o m e across a chiastic distribution of the curse/blessing opposition in Genesis 12:3, w h e r e G o d provides Abraham w i t h a n e w life by sending h i m away from his familiar surroundings. T h e deity employs poetry to protect A b r a h a m from the great insecu rity that might prove daunting: Gen. 12:3
I will bless those who bless you, and whoever curses you, I will curse him.
T h e people w h o prove forthcoming are presented in the plural; the wicked are described in the singular. W h a t about Abraham? If
70
Reading Biblical Poetry
w e consider h i m for a m o m e n t , w e find that h e is implicitly h o n ored as the n o r m : he is p r o m o t e d to the standard w h i c h G o d will observe. T h r e e biblical books further d o w n , G o d has n o t forgot ten his o w n poetic line. H e forces a prestigious diviner—called Balaam and contracted by the king of M o a b to curse the people of Israel w h o are passing t h r o u g h — t o do the very opposite of w h a t h e had been ordered, the result being that the m a n speaks a p o e m full of blessing some three or four times: N u m b e r s 2 3 : 7 - 1 0 and 18—24, 24:3—9 and, in a slightly looser connection, also w . 15—24. O n behalf of the G o d of Israel w h o subjugated h i m , Bal aam says of the people: N u m 24:8a b c d e 9a b c d
God who brought him out of Egypt is for him like the horn of the wild ox. He shall devour enemy nations, crush their bones, and pierce them with their arrows. He crouches, he lies down like a beast of prey, yea, like the lion—who dare rouse him? W h o bless you: blessed and who curse you: cursed!
T h e verse of curse and blessing, reminiscent of God's blessing for Abraham, n o w has a parallel structure: the 2 + 2 words of the o r i g inal H e b r e w text are neatly aligned as a b / a ' b ' . In v. 9ab, o n the other hand, w e observe a chiastic construction, w h e r e the devour ing beast is framed by the polar expressions of lying d o w n and being roused. T h e relationship between w . 8c and 8de is also expressed in a crosswise construction, but this time it is mainly sen tence structure that is responsible.The king of M o a b can n o longer get a w o r d in edgewise, as his position, b e t w e e n wild oxen and lion, is not exactly enviable. T h e poet leaves us readers w i t h a puzzle: w h o exactly is the subject of w . 8 c - 9 b , G o d or Israel? T h e schoolmaster wants a definite answer; the lover of poetry is happy to leave b o t h options open. T h e rigorous design often discerned in the poetic lines s o m e times yields an unexpected bonus: it enables the specialist to repair the occasional mishap. In Psalm 44:2—3 most translations meekly
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
71
follow the verse division as handed d o w n in the rabbinical tradition. Below, I quote two complete strophes from the R S V , and would like to draw attention especially to the transition from v. 2 to v. 3: Ps. 44:2a b c d 3a b 4a b c d 5
We have heard with our ears, O God, our fathers have told us, what deeds thou didst perform in their days, in the days of old: thou with thy own hand didst drive out the nations, but them thou didst plant thou didst afflict the peoples, but them thou didst set free. for not by their own sword did they win the land, nor did their own arm give them victory but thy right hand, and thy arm, and the light of thy countenance for thou didst delight in them. Thou art my King and my God; who ordainest victories for Jacob.
T h e subject is the promised land, and the point is also clear: it is a gift from G o d , and Israel should not regard taking possession of it as a military feat o n w h i c h it can pride itself.The first strophe looks far back into history, the second strophe draws the lesson and c o n cludes w i t h an appeal for renewed s u p p o r t . T h e conclusion of v. 2 is suspiciously short—only three syllables in the original Hebrew, w h i c h is n o t e n o u g h — a n d the o p e n i n g of v. 3 seems t o o long. This impression is correct: if w e look at v. 3ab closely, w e observe a strictly regular a b c / / a ' b ' c ' pattern, and the striking fact that each colon has a predicate consisting of two verbs. T h e ele m e n t " w i t h thy o w n h a n d " belongs to the conclusion of v. 2—I a m n o t the first o n e to make this observation.Translated extremely literally, this is the text of v. 2cd + 3ab: 3
2c d 3a b
what deeds thou didst perform in their days, in the days of old, thou, with thy own hand. thou didst drive out the nations, but them thou didst plant a b c thou didst afflict the peoples, but them thou didst set free a' b' c'
72
Reading Biblical Poetry
This arrangement h o n o r s n o t only the strict design of v. 3ab, b u t also that of v. 2cd.We may n o w observe h o w beautifully the c o n tents of v. 2cd have b e e n balanced: a striking duplication of the root " d o , p e r f o r m " broadens the predicate in the A - c o l o n , and another, expressive repetition answers this device by also e x p a n d ing the subject: " T h o u , w i t h thy o w n hand." T h e reverse of this is that the B - c o l o n does n o t need a predicate. T h e decisive factor, however, is the circumstance that the t w o cola n o w show the c o m pelling structure of a chiasm: subject and predicate frame t h e t w o temporal adjuncts, thus forming a perfect conclusion to the verse. Finally, the short motif " w i t h thy o w n h a n d " anticipates strophe 2, w h e r e it is meticulously worked out by means of the opposition " n o t by your o w n sword, b u t by his hand." T h e connection in itself creates a n e w parallelism, this time o n strophe level, and this form of alignment is also brought out m u c h m o r e clearly if w e repair the verse b o u n d a r y and move God's hand back to the end of v. 2. In English w e sometimes hear the expression "a voice crying in the wilderness," w h i c h w e assume is from the Bible. Well—yes and no. T h e words occur in the N e w Testament, in M a r k 1:3 and J o h n 1:23. T h e Gospel writers t o o k these words from Isaiah 40 and applied t h e m to J o h n the Baptist, but they treated the quotation so freely that the dividing line between the cola was lost. T h e p r o p h e t — a poet n o w called Deutero-Isaiah, as h e lived two c e n turies after the actual (first) Isaiah and had lived through the entire exile (which ended in 538 BCE)—immediately in his overture (Isa. 40:1—11) proclaims to the Judaeans a message of comfort and return from exile, and says: "Hear, a voice cries" (v. 3a). This is an introductory colon, w h i c h remains outside the highly regular stro p h e design, b u t this is of less importance than what it is the a n o n y m o u s voice (an exile? an angel?) has to say in 3bc.This is a bicolon of 4 + 4 words (and the same n u m b e r of beats, for supporters of scansion,like myself),in w h i c h I have indicated the two phrases per colon by a | ; I have retained the original w o r d order o n purpose: Isa. 40:3bc
In the desert prepare make straight in the desert
| |
the way of Yahweh, a highway for our God.
W e have here a m a x i m u m parallelism of the m e m b e r s , based o n four w o r d pairs. Before the break, the correspondence is chiastic
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
73
(ab-b'a'), after the break it is parallel: cd-c'd". Consequently, the correct translation of the verse is: Isa. 40:3
A voice cries: "In the wilderness prepare the way of Yahweh, make straight in the desert a highway for our God."
Thus, there is n o "voice crying in the wilderness" at all in the orig inal poem! As it was not Mark's and John's business to write a text b o o k o n verse structure, they took the poetic license to introduce a n e w connection between two adjoining words. This sort of liberal adaptation of the Scriptures was certainly not u n c o m m o n a m o n g their Jewish contemporaries. 4
T h e appearance and function o f saying things twice T h e vast majority of verses are bicola, and it is useful to keep the bicolon in m i n d w h e n p o n d e r i n g the question of the actual func tion of parallelismus m e m b r o r u m . T h e old approach, w h i c h goes back to L o w t h and was until recently the exclusive preserve of t h e ologians, betrays a hint of intellectualism and a Western sense of superiority: w h y should things always b e stated twice? Isn't that a bit primitive? This attitude is incorrect, and can b e w e e d e d out only if w e take the poetic aspect of p o e t r y seriously and cease to make it subservient to historiography, theology, or other disci plines that feel slightly uncomfortable w i t h literature. T h e bipartite design that a verse often shows is rarely an example o f mathematical balance. Often, verses will have their center of gravity in t h e A - c o l o n , b u t equally often t h e focus is o n t h e B - c o l o n of a verse. I will explain b o t h situations. T h e m a i n p o i n t of a verse is clearly in t h e A - c o l o n if (a) that verset contains t h e sentence core, and the second half-verse does n o m o r e than c o m p l e t e t h e information in t h e verse by means of an adjunct, o r — a slightly less obvious strategy—if (b) t h e p o e t applies gapping: h e constructs t w o sentences coinciding w i t h t w o cola, b u t places a predicate only in the A - c o l o n . In that case, t h e verb is still virtually present in t h e B - c o l o n b u t does n o t take u p any space. T h e slot reserved for the predicate there m a y t h e n b e filled w i t h s o m e t h i n g new, or w i t h a w o r d repeating a n o t h e r
Reading Biblical Poetry
74
c o m p o n e n t (subject, object, or adjunct). W e have already seen this in 2c d
what deeds thou didst perform in their days, (case b) in the days of old, Thou, with thy own hand.
Since the predicate has b e e n left out of the B - c o l o n (= v. 2d) there is r o o m for a bit m o r e attention to the subject. A n d because those words ( T h o u , w i t h thy o w n hand) take u p only four syllables in Hebrew, the adjunct "in their days" may be expanded to "in the days of old." A simpler application of (b) is the following: Lam. 5:2
Our heritage has passed to aliens, our homes to strangers.
In v. 6, however, w h e r e the predicate has also b e e n left o u t of the B-colon, w e see the gap filled, not w i t h a merely decorative t e r m , but w i t h an object: Lam. 5:6
To Egypt we hold out a hand, to Assur, for our fill of bread.
Case (a), only an adjunct in the second colon, is less exciting. T h e r e are t w o examples a bit further d o w n in the same chapter from Lamentations; these are verses that together make u p an S-strophe: Lam. 5:9 10
We get our bread at the peril of our lives because of the sword of the wilderness. Our skin glows like an oven with the fever of famine.
It is not the desert that is the oven here, but our o w n skin. A n d the word "famine," elsewhere a recognized word pair if combined with "pestilence" or "the sword" to depict the disasters of war or damna tion, here does double duty as the counterpart to b o t h "sword" and "bread"—which at the same time serves to frame the strophe. In other cases, the center of gravity of the verse is placed in the B-colon. For this, a neat formula has b e e n devised, saying: " A , what's more, B." In other words: the first colon states (describes, demands, complains of) A, but the second colon says something
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
75
5
even stronger. This is an important rule of t h u m b that has all sorts of applications. C o m p e t e n t readers use it in order to d e t e r m i n e in each case the exact relationship b e t w e e n the second half-verse and the first.The B - c o l o n can d o all sorts of things w i t h the statement, contribution, or information of the A-colon: expand it, intensify it, underline it, embellish it. These are all variations w i t h i n a process of amplification, and there is a w h o l e range of devices at the poet's disposal to lend shape to this intensification in the B-colon. A n u m b e r of examples are listed below, and I invite the reader to start p o n d e r i n g straight away w h e t h e r the B - c o l o n is " m o r e " than the A-colon: (a) Prov. 2:14
(about bad company) who rejoice in doing evil, and exult in the treacheries of evil men.
(b) Prov. 3:7
Do not be wise in your own eyes, Fear Yahweh and shun evil.
(c) Song 2:3
Like an apple tree among trees of the forest, So is my beloved among the youths. I delight to sit in his shade and his fruit is sweet to my palate.
(d) Ps. 37:21
The wicked man borrows and does not repay, the righteous is generous and keeps giving. Those blessed by him inherit the land, but those cursed by him shall be cut off.
22
(e) Ps. 61:5
That I might dwell in your tent forever, take refuge under your protecting wings.
(f) Ps. 18:42
They cried out, but there was none to deliver, to Yah weh, but he did not answer them; I ground them fine as windswept dust, I trod them flat as dirt of the streets.
43
T h e s e are six examples o u t of t h o u s a n d s , a n d they require lit tle c o m m e n t . In (a) w e see h o w d o i n g evil is e x p a n d e d i n t o t h e c o n c r e t e plural " d i r t y t r i c k s " (translated freely), a n d especially that t h e p e r p e t r a t o r s are as b o l d as brass: they are actually
76
Reading Biblical Poetry
c h e e r i n g . In (b), t h e verse grows from o n e t o t w o predicates, and t h e B - c o l o n gives c h a p t e r a n d verse (figuratively speaking): it places God's p r o p e r n a m e o p p o s i t e t h e " e v i l " that w o u l d result from " b e i n g wise in one's o w n eyes," if t h e w a r n i n g was not heeded. In (c), the strophe from the Song of Songs, the first bicolon is occupied by o n e long sentence, a c o m p a r i s o n . T h e rule "A, what's more, B " is active in v. 3cd, since the desire to sit in his shade is surpassed by the indicative, the concrete elements "fruits" and "palate," and the sensory/sensual aspect of the second colon. T h e S-strophe I have given u n d e r (d) arranges its quartet of cola chiastically according to t h e difference of good/evil. In v. 21 a subtle moral assessment takes place.To return w h a t o n e b o r r o w e d is only to b e expected; n o special merit is attached to it. A "righteous m a n " (tsaddiq), however, w h o goes o n giving, does far m o r e than is asked or expected of h i m . In v. 22 a pleasant rule is followed by an extremely harsh one. In example (e), "take refuge" is m u c h m o r e specific than "dwell," and the singular " t e n t " is overtaken by "your wings," n o t only because these are plural, but also because they follow the explicit "protecting," and contribute to the c o n notation of shelter. In (f) w e have a full S-strophe, in w h i c h the established King David speaks of the war, his enemies, and God's support of h i m . T h e crying out of v. 42a is also present in the B-colon, but (only) n o w accompanied by an address: G o d himself, by way of his proper n a m e . T h e anonymous "there was n o n e to deliver" of the A - c o l o n is replaced by the m u c h m o r e painful non-reaction of the deity. In the next verse David can reap the rewards: the B - c o l o n of v. 4 3 is even m o r e humiliating than the A-colon. Every once in a while w e are able to understand h o w poets w e n t about their w o r k , and h o w they c o m b i n e d pleasure in vari ation w i t h amplifying and intensifying meaning. In David's lament w e soon hear w h a t obsessed the speaker: the fact that the Philistine h o m e front was celebrating the great victory of its army over Saul and his troops. David finds the very idea unbearable, and h e tells t h e messengers w h o h e is at that m o m e n t imagining, but w h o in reality have l o n g since reported the victory to the Philis tine cities:
Parallelism: Cola and Verses 2 Sam. 1:20
77
Tell it not in Gath do not proclaim it in the streets of Ashkelon, lest the daughters of the Philistines rejoice, lest the daughters of the uncircumcised exult.
This is a full S-strophe w h e r e in b o t h verses the rule "A, what's more, B " is active. " E x u l t " is stronger (louder) than "rejoice," and the n a m e "Philistines" is replaced and explained by " u n c i r c u m cised," a pejorative t e r m suggesting uncleanness.We immediately notice the sharp differences in length: the line about Ashkelon is m u c h longer than that about Gath, also in the original language. This time, it is especially the two prohibitions (v. 20ab) that enable us to track the options the poet had at his disposal, by asking o u r selves: W h y did the p o e t (the historical David, or the author w h o centuries later portrayed the character David in the books of Samuel) choose the names Gath and Ashkelon? T h e enemy lived scattered over five cities, the names of w h i c h w e all k n o w : Gath, Gaza, Ekron,Ashdod, and Ashkelon. (Three of t h e m still/again appear o n the m a p of Palestine.) T h e names in the middle of this list have t w o syllables, but the surrounding ones have o n e and three syllables.The difference in length b e t w e e n Gath and Ashkelon in David's verse is a first and very simple application of the "A, what's more, B " principle and does n o t yet add any liter ary quality to the verse. W e also notice, however, that Ashkelon beats Gath by having "streets" granted to it by the poet, and that the verb in this verset describes the contents of the message m o r e explicitly: instead of merely "telling," the B - c o l o n c o m m a n d s to "proclaim" (= " b r i n g g o o d tidings"). T h e s e are already three points in favor of t h e Ashkelon-verset, w h i c h is e n o u g h . B u t this does n o t m e a n that (the colon c o n taining) Gath has lost! This name, the only n a m e of o n e syllable, was chosen for at least t w o reasons.The sounds of " G a t h " exactly m i r r o r the veto o n "proclaiming" (in t h e original H e b r e w taggidu). A n d t h e n there is the political angle: at the m o m e n t David is reciting the p o e m , three days after t h e battle, h e is still vassal to Achish, the king o f . . . Gath! T h u s , in a sense, he starts w i t h his o w n position, and the prohibitions and curses that then follow betray a t u r n i n g point in his life. T h e i r negativeness is a signal of
78
Reading Biblical Poetry
distance; by c o m m e m o r a t i n g Saul and J o n a t h a n in this beautiful song, David separates himself from his embarrassing position and opens u p for himself t h e way to the t h r o n e of Judah. O u r c o n clusion must be that although the line about Ashkelon realizes the "A, what's m o r e , B " principle o n three counts, the choice of Gath is a striking instance of polyvalence w h i c h keeps t h e verse bal anced: the n a m e is here a n o d e of meanings thanks to (another) three aspects, i.e., the prosodic (the minimal single syllable), the e u p h o n i c (via strong alliteration), and the political (David resigns). This simple exercise makes thoroughly clear that the old p e r spective—parallel half-verses were assumed to "really o n l y " say the same thing twice—falls far short of the mark, and blocks our view of all the subtle details. W e have n o w reached the point w h e r e w e can formulate w h a t exactly parallelism achieves.
T h e function o f "parallelism o f the m e m b e r s " T h e first thing a parallel construction does is to introduce a form of repetition. As a result, the reader immediately notices or recog nizes a correspondence b e t w e e n the c o l a — w h e t h e r this c o n n e c tion is based o n antithesis or synonymy does n o t c o n c e r n us now. N o t i c i n g the correspondence b e t w e e n the A - c o l o n and B-colon, however, is only the beginning. This form of repetition and equiv alence serves as a foundation for observing and enjoying differ ences. T h e similarity b e c o m e s the background against w h i c h disparity announces itself: the folds of difference in the half-verses. If w e let our attention penetrate into these folds, w e find ourselves o n the track of n e w meanings. T h e dynamics and surprises of parallelismus m e m b r o r u m may also be expressed in a metaphor. This way of constructing verses is like a pair of binoculars. S o m e centuries ago, the lenses of a field glass were set in cylinders w h i c h could be slid in and o u t b u t w h i c h remained a single t u b e — t h e watch o n a ship looked through it w i t h o n e eye. Today's field glass is a binocular: w e look through t w o cylinders, w i t h b o t h eyes, so that w e have the advan tage of seeing depth. O u r eyes, w i t h or w i t h o u t binoculars, see "in stereo." T h e effect results from the fact that o n e eye has a slightly different angle of incidence than the other and hence produces a
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
79
rninimally different image; these two pictures are easily super imposed and assembled into o n e image inside o u r brain. Parallelismus m e m b r o r u m does something comparable: this shaping device creates t w o subtly different images o n o n e line (the full poetic line). As this is d o n e w i t h the tools of language, w e have every opportunity to consider b o t h pictures separately and let t h e m sink in.This is w h e r e the m e t a p h o r ceases to b e appropriate: the point of the similarity b e t w e e n A and B is their very differ ence! O n l y those w h o look closely and have patience will discover and savor the role played by dissimilarity, its surprises, and its r i c h ness of meaning. 6
These dialectics of the equal and the dissimilar, of similarity and difference, make us realize the limitations of such old labels as "synonymous or antithetical," and especially h o w they may lure the reader into the trap of an either-or situation. In Proverbs 2:13 is a t w o - p a r t verse in w h i c h W i s d o m warns us against the w r o n g company: Prov. 2:13
of those who leave the path of rectitude, to follow the ways of darkness.
Is this is a case of synonymous or antithetical parallelism? S o m e followers of L o w t h will opt for the antithetical, pointing to the opposition of the straight paths and the dark ways, and of leaving (= n o t treading on) and following. A n o t h e r follower, however, will maintain that b o t h cola say the same thing: are they n o t " m e r e l y " variants of each other? A third will latch o n to the w o r d " t o " and point out that the verse indicates an a b o u t - t u r n in behavior. A pity only that the original H e b r e w phrase b e rendered just as easily as "by following" or even "and follow." T h e reader would do better to withdraw from this yes-no c o n test. T h e r e is equivalence here, and this balance fits the p o e m as a w h o l e beautifully. Proverbs 2 is a p o e m of twenty-two verses, exactly the n u m b e r of consonants of the alphabet, although it is n o t an acrostic. These twenty-two verses are divided exactly into two; the first half, eleven verses, strikes a positive note, the second eleven are in a m i n o r key. T h e positive half consists of t w o stanzas, w . 1—6 and 7—11 (four strophes: one SL and o n e LL combination), w h i c h constantly recommends the reader to follow W i s d o m s counsel;
80
Reading Biblical Poetry
those w h o do this will b e under God's protection.The negative half intends to do the same, but is full of apotropaic and cautioning terms: o n e should t u r n against evil. This part consists of five stro phes, arranged as SS plus SSL, in two stanzas, w . 12—15 and 16—22. T h e L-strophe at the end returns to a positive tone. T h e stanzas r u n parallel, because of their complementary openings: Prov. 2:12
to save you from the way of evil men, from men who speak duplicity
(in w . 13—15 expanded into a series of plural forms) 2:16
to save you from the strange woman from the alien woman whose talk is smooth
(after w h i c h w . 1 7 - 1 9 e x p o u n d o n her unfaithfulness, and the accompanying dangers). It happens only rarely that a sentence transcends and ignores a strophe b o u n d a r y (in typographical terms, a blank line). It is even m o r e rare for a sentence to r u n across a stanza boundary. Yet, Proverbs 2 is a spectacular example of exactly this.The entire p o e m is an extreme instance of talking in synonyms, separated into p o s itive and negative terms. Just about every verse is a variation o n the t h e m e of " l o o k for wisdom," or conversely, "avoid evil." As this synonymy goes o n and o n , the text may b e read as o n e large syn tactic unit, and a simple adjunct consisting of a preposition and an infinitive, " t o save you," may b e c o m e the marker of a n e w stanza. Still, it is exactly the duplication of those words, i.e., the parallelism b e t w e e n w . 12 and 16, w h i c h encourages us to place the stanza b o u n d a r y immediately before it, although the adjunct appears to be separated from the sentence core by this blank line.
Linguistic forms, and variation in repetition R e a d i n g and experiencing the articulation of complete verses b e c o m e s easier if w e are aware of the linguistic foundation of the variations. Poets explore all the nooks and crannies of their native language system, and adroitly exploit the many contrasts and dif ferences for their parallel constructions. I have collected some
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
81
examples below, o n w h i c h I will c o m m e n t briefly. T h e first series (a t h r o u g h f) contains instances of the poet's using differences in grammatical form. (a) Ps. 34:2
I bless Yahweh at all times, praise of him is ever in my mouth.
(b) Ps. 34:19
Yahweh is close to the brokenhearted and he delivers those crushed in spirit.
(c) Songs 1:2
let him give me of the kisses of his mouth, for your love is more delightful than wine.
(d) Prov. 1:8
My son, heed the discipline of your father and do not forsake the instruction of your mother.
(e) Isa. 44:26
(f) Deut. 32:7
(It is I,Yahweh, who have made everything . . . ) who confirm the word of my servant and fulfill the prediction of my messengers Remember the days of old consider the years of generation after generation; ask your father to inform you, your elders, to tell you.
In (a) and (b), the main difference is that the o n e colon uses a verb to express w h a t in the o t h e r colon is expressed by a n o u n : " I bless" versus "praise," and "close" versus " h e delivers." In the first verse from the Song of Songs (c) w e see that the grammatical person shifts straight away: the " h i m " of the A - c o l o n is the second p e r son in the B - c o l o n . T h e girl manages to maintain t h e distance of the third person for only o n e colon, and t h e n she "has t o " b e c o m e m o r e personal: she wants to start addressing her lover as soon as possible.The semantic point of contact o f t h e t w o sentences is n o t expressed, and is a subtle one: the oral activity of kissing b e c o m e s the tasting of w i n e in the second half-verse, and as a result of the comparison drawn by t h e girl, the w i n e is a half-metaphor. In (d), the m a n / w o m a n difference is exploited ingeniously so that the synonymy does not degenerate into monotony. T h e words "discipline" and "instruction" are masculine and feminine in the original Hebrew, and in gender correspond to father/ mother. F u r t h e r m o r e , the half-verses relate to each other as plus
Reading Biblical Poetry
82
to minus: the positive advice is in the B - c o l o n underlined by the two-minuses-make-a-plus formula. In (e), the singular "servant" becomes the plural "messengers," while " w o r d " is nar rowed d o w n to "prediction," so that w e as readers dare to c o n clude that the messengers G o d mentions in this oracle are prophets. In (f) w e see a double application of "A, what's more, B." T h e days b e c o m e years, the father is accompanied by the elders (plural). (about evildoers:) they say: how could God know; is there knowledge with the Most High?
(g) Ps. 73:11
(h) Prov. 3:1
My son, do not forget my teaching and let your mind retain my commandments.
We n o w reach the d o m a i n of sentence structure and syntactic variation. Example (g) offers an alternation of verb and n o u n (both from the root " t o k n o w " ) , and the simple w o r d " G o d " is replaced and colored by o n e of his titles. T h e verse contains an e m b e d d e d speech consisting of t w o sarcastic questions, a lively direct quotation of these unsavory types. Example (h) reveals a minus-plus order and t w o transitions: from second to third p e r son, and, in the case of the object, from singular to plural. O l d Isaac's blessing of Jacob starts off as highly synonymous (i),but the poetic line 29cd smartly switches the positions of subject and object around and places Jacob (in the second person) chiastically around the brothers (plural, a collective); they are encircled by their boss: (i) Gen. 27:29a b c d (j)
P s
-
6 : 6
(k)Job 5:14
People will serve you, and nations bow to you; be master over your brothers, and your mother's sons will bow to you. No, there is no praise of you among the dead, who would acclaim you in Sheol? (about the fall of those in power:) By day they encounter darkness and at noon they grope as in the night.
Parallelism: Cola and Verses (1) Ps. 33:10 11
(m) Ps. 125:1 2
83
Yahweh frustrates the plans of nations, he brings to naught the designs of peoples; what Yahweh plans endures forever, the designs of his heart from generation to generation. Those who trust in Yahweh are like Mount Zion, that cannot be moved, enduring forever. Around Jerusalem there are mountains, andYahweh enfolds His people now and forever.
Example (j), from Psalm 6, not only switches from n o u n to verb in its predicate, but also shifts m o d e : the first colon is a statement, and the second is a rhetorical question. Example (k) is a c o m p l i cated mixture of lexical and semantic w o r d pairs. T h e lexical pair is the d u o day/night, w h i c h frames the verse as a w h o l e in an inclusio. O n either side of the caesura this couple is chiastically replaced by another pair of opposites, darkness/noon. At the same time, however, two parallel pairs semantically support each other: d a y / n o o n at the b e g i n n i n g of each colon, and darkness/night at the end. T h u s , the verse appears to offer us an intricate puzzle, w h i c h it does n o t do for nothing. T h e confusion it threatens to land us in reflects the confusion that will seize the "bigwigs" as soon as G o d strikes t h e m : they even lose their grip o n the ele m e n t a r y distinction b e t w e e n light and dark. Example (1) contains an ab-a'b' series in two verses.This parallel construction, however, also contains the opposition between the peoples, whose plans are frustrated, and God's plan, w h i c h will endure; this contrast is further illustrated by the juxtaposition of two transitive verbs (of destructive action) w i t h the quiet and m o r e nominal character of the intransitive predicates in Psalm 33:11 .The opening of Psalm 125, example (m), presents four proper names in a chiastic alternation: Yahweh + Zion-Jerusalem + Yahweh. This crosswise construction already betrays h o w inextricably the capital o n M o u n t Zion—itself a m e t o n y m y for the Judaeans—is linked to God. This is outdone, however, by the mere contiguity (in a paratactic arrangement via the conjunction "and") of cola 2a and 2b. This design creates a simile (comparison): in the same way as the
84
Reading Biblical Poetry
mountains encircle the city, God's protection surrounds the people. O n this basis the poet concludes that people w h o trust in G o d are as solid as the m o u n t a i n — a conclusion he moves to the front. In this chapter w e have already seen m o r e than a dozen passages w h i c h are longer than a single verse, and w h i c h even constitute w h o l e strophes. This abundance of examples makes clear that par allelism works n o t only o n the level of the colon, but also o n that of the verse. T h e definition of parallelismus m e m b r o r u m should certainly be expanded to include verses as well. As a textual unit, however, the verse is n o t covered by the t e r m "member," so that in addition to "parallelism of the m e m b e r s (= cola) " w e should also grant full recognition to "parallelism of poetic lines (= verses)." This figure also has a valid claim to a place in the m o d e l of the H e b r e w p o e m . I will conclude this chapter w i t h a few examples. W e have just read v. 7 from Moses' long didactic p o e m , D e u t e r o n o m y 32. T h e biblical verse itself was an S-strophe arranging its full lines in parallel, in w h i c h the audience was encouraged to go and ask their father/the elders about the lesson from the past. T h e p o e m goes o n to provide its o w n panoramic answer to this ques tion, and looks back to the beginning of history in three strophes, t w o long and o n e short ( w . 8-12): Deut. 32:8a b c d v. 9a b
When the Most High gave nations their inheritance, and set the divisions of man, He fixed the boundaries of the peoples in relation to Israel's numbers, ForYahweh's portion is his people, Jacob his own allotment.
v. 10a b c d
He found him in a desert region, in an empty howling waste, He engirded him, watched over him, guarded him as the pupil of his eye.
v. 1 la b c d v. 12a b
Like an eagle who rouses his nestlings, gliding down to his young, so did he spread his wings and take him bear him along on his pinions, Yahweh alone did guide him, no alien god at his side.
strophe 5
strophe 6
strophe 7
Parallelism: Cola and Verses
85
T h e three verses of strophe 5 are governed by a threefold " p e o p l e s / p e o p l e " in the A-cola, and a threefold " i n h e r i t a n c e / portion/allotment." T h e n u m b e r of the sons of Jacob, w h i c h at the end of Genesis amounts to seventy, will b e the measure for the division of the world. T h e climax of the first L-strophe is the elec tion of o n e people, w h i c h becomes God's o w n property. This is the reason w h y the six cola are balanced as 3 + 3: the first three refer to the masses, and the second series deals with the o n e people. This latter series stands out by containing proper n a m e s — another threesome. T h e short strophe 6 progresses like a narrative. Half o f it is about finding, and terrifies by three fearsome terms of space. After this, t h e care taken of the foundling is all the m o r e comforting; there are also three verbs that take G o d as their subject. T h u s , t h e halves of this unit, t w o bicolic verses, also have b e e n well syn chronized and justify the demarcation of the strophe by their cohesion. T h e long strophe 7 can immediately b e identified as a unit because it is an elaborate metaphor. T h e image of the eagle fills n o fewer than four cola, w h i c h by H e b r e w standards is quite a lot, and t h e n proves to b e part of a simile. T h e comparison takes u p the complete strophe w i t h its "just as . . . so . . . " structure, and in v. 12 lands, as it were, o n the uniqueness of Yahweh. T h e w h o l e of w . 9—12 deserves a title along the lines of " t h e stanza of the election." Moses continues his didactic p o e m a m o m e n t longer as if it were a story by means of a stanza in w h i c h G o d strengthens and pampers the people (the nine cola of w . 13—14).Then w e reach the lowest point: the luxury leads to cor ruption, or worse, to idolatry (a n e w stanza, w . 15-18). In t h e stanza of the election, the verses reveal a parallelism that articulates the three strophes; their concluding lines form a series that brings out God's intervention and c o m m i t m e n t : v. 9a b
For Yahweh's portion is his people, Jacob his own allotment.
v. 10c d
He engirded him, watched over him, guarded him as the pupil of his eye.
v. 12a b
Yahweh alone did guide him, no alien god at his side.
86
Reading Biblical Poetry
T h e first of these three verses is static; the second full of action and of a narrative character. T h e third concluding verse already looks back again, and makes the stanza end o n the exclusiveness of this deity called Y a h w e h . T h e r e is, however, a snake in the grass: the last colon denies that an alien god helped him, and w i t h this the p o e t anticipates the drama w h i c h will be unfolded four verses further d o w n (idolatry and punishment), and w h i c h will almost lead to the total destruction of Israel (in w . 2 2 - 2 5 ) . T h e only thing that will eventually stop G o d from totally annihilating the people is the realization ( w . 26—31) that if h e does so, his enemies in the area will brag, and foster the illusion that Israel was destroyed by t h e m and their strong arm. This prospect revolts G o d so m u c h that h e abandons his original plan and eventually takes pity o n the afflicted people ( w . 3 6 - 4 2 ) . T h e concluding verses of strophes 5—7, w h i c h I have here w r i t ten o u t again, are also interesting, since they demonstrate that the " A , what's more, B " rule is also active o n the level of verses and strophes. T h e intensification that the poet so often achieves in consecutive cola may b e achieved just as well by means of poetic lines. Finally, this w h o l e chapter may be reread w i t h an eye o n prosody: all the material discussed here also demonstrates that par allelism, b o t h of cola and of verses, is a powerful mechanism for regulating proportions. T h e p o e t employs such maneuvers as par allelism, inversion, w o r d pairs, and binary differences in linguistic forms while never for a m o m e n t losing sight of proportions. Lan guage obeys number, and n u m b e r intensifies language.
5 The strophe
The w o r d "strophe" comes from Greek and means " t u r n " or "twist." It is by n o means obvious that a Greek t e r m should offer an appropriate label for textual units in the Semitic languages of the ancient N e a r East. In our case, however, it does. T h e r e are plenty of twists in classical H e b r e w literature, and the technical term "strophe" is eminently suited to biblical poetry, w h i c h is characterized by rapid shifts and changes. Tone, verb tense, g r a m matical person, genre, subject material, or m o o d all constantly vary, and all these changes are reflected in the structure of the strophe. We are able to discern these shifts by means of the strophic char acteristics of the text. T h e isolated strophe does not occur in the p o e t r y books of the Bible, b u t it does appear in the prose passages. Along the route from Genesis through Kings w e c o m e across medium-sized p o e m s every n o w and then—for instance, the Song of H a n n a h in 1 Samuel 2 or David's lament in 2 Samuel 1—and w e occasion ally even discover a very long p o e m , such as D e u t e r o n o m y 32, fudges 5, or 2 Samuel 22. This type of p o e t r y is articulated in the same way as the psalms into strophes and stanzas. I also n o t e t w o verse-filled chapters that I w o u l d rather call a chain of strophes with the occasional stanza: the blessings for the tribes of Israel in Genesis 49 (spoken by Jacob, shortly before his death) and D e u t e r o n o m y 3 3 (spoken by Moses, shortly before his farewell). M o s t poetry w i t h i n a prose setting, however, is short: just o n e or a few verses.We are then confronted with a short or long strophe w h i c h at the same time is a complete p o e m . T h u s , Genesis 2:23 is an S-strophe, and Genesis 9:6—7 and 12:1—3 are b o t h L-strophes—I have already discussed a verse from each of these passages. Lamech's song of revenge, Genesis 4:23—24, also consists of three verses. A n d
88
Reading Biblical Poetry
the oracle that R e b e c c a receives in Genesis 25:23, w h i c h describes the tumult in her w o m b (an alarming pregnancy), consists of t w o bicola in a design that quickly becomes clear to the reader: Gen. 25:23
Two nations are in your womb, and two nations will issue from your body. One nation will be mightier than the other and the older shall serve the younger.
This is the a n n o u n c e m e n t of the arrival of the twins Jacob and Esau. As they will b e ancestors, they are here presented u n d e r the guise of t w o collectives—the people of Israel versus their n e i g h bors from E d o m . T h e first verse promises the m o t h e r a n u m e r o u s progeny, but the second verse carries a message of inequality by specifying a master-servant relationship. A n d the surprise has b e e n saved for the end, w h e n the natural order is reversed. Like a stinger in the tail, this last verset n o t only presents the point of the oracle, but by its choice of the adjectives "older" and " y o u n g e r " also reveals that the difference will already manifest itself in t h e individuals. Various instances of such short b u t complete poems may b e found in N u m b e r s , Joshua, Judges, and Samuel. T h e y obey the rules I have already discussed, and they do their w o r k a l o n e — albeit in interaction w i t h the surrounding prose, w h i c h they inter rupt in order to illuminate. In this chapter, however, I will focus o n strophes from those biblical books that wholly or largely c o n sist of poetry. A strophe from Psalms, Job, Proverbs, Isaiah, Jeremiah, L a m e n tations, or Song of Songs never speaks and works o n its o w n . This is because in such cases the strophe is always a building block of a greater whole, just a part of a p o e m , w h i c h for those books means part of a text that consists of several strop hie units. T h e question n o w arises: H o w may a textual unit that is n o m o r e than part of a w h o l e nevertheless b e observed and b e dis tinguished from its surroundings? W h a t makes a strophe a strophe? M y answer requires t w o sections: o n e in w h i c h I analyze the stro p h e from the inside and indicate h o w it holds its o w n , and a sec o n d section that looks carefully at h o w the strophe stands out from its surroundings w i t h o u t being left to fend for itself. T h e strophe
TTie
Strophe
89
has internal as well as external cohesion. Finally, I will examine the relationship b e t w e e n these two forms of unity. T h e reader may already suspect that this will t u r n out to b e variable.
T h e p r i v a t e life o f t h e s t r o p h e In the textual m o d e l the numbers t w o and three are normative. At verse level, w e have seen that they are applied disproportionately: there are many m o r e bicolic verses than tricolic verses. This dis crepancy disappears o n strophe level, w h e r e the dimensions t w o and three have m u c h less unequal status. Poems consisting exclu sively of two-line strophes are rare. To give the reader an idea of the distribution of these numbers, I offer some statistics that I myself have collected from the largest collection of poetry, the b o o k of Psalms. Its 148 poems together contain 1,193 strophes, w h i c h in t u r n may b e divided into 855 short units (S-strophes, usually two verses) versus 338 long units (L-strophes, almost always consisting of three verses). C o n v e r t e d into poetic lines, this means that the S-strophes (including several dozen one-line strophes!) govern almost 1,700 verses, and the L strophes, sometimes consisting of four verses, are responsible for almost 1,100 verses. In percentages this w o u l d be roughly 60 p e r cent for S versus 40 percent for L. T h e strophe is so essential to the structure of the p o e m that its internal cohesion deserves to b e analyzed first and evaluated. This cohesion may c o m e about in various ways. T h e strophe may •
• • • • •
constitute one syntactic unit, for instance, one com pound sentence or a sentence extended in a different way, formulate or explain one thought, present its cola as a clear series, be an embedded speech, for instance a quotation, present or work out a metaphor or simile, demarcate itself by means of inclusio.
I will discuss these possibilities o n the basis of some examples, starting w i t h the cohesion that arises from syntactic structuring. Psalm 18 starts with a hymnic strophe ( w . 2—4), w h i c h is the counterpart to a stanza full of thanks and praise ( w . 47—51, an
Reading Biblical Poetry
90
L- plus an S-strophe).These exalted o p e n i n g and closing passages f o r m an inclusio in a major key, framing the long Song of T h a n k s giving spoken by the established King David. Inside this frame, w e find a w i d e range of dynamics, and w e accompany David o n a j o u r n e y through fear and distress. As w e r e m e m b e r from the dis cussion in chapter 2, the special stanza of the theophany (God comes d o w n and goes to battle, five S-strophes) is enclosed by the stanzas of distress and salvation ( w . 5 - 7 and 1 7 - 2 0 , b o t h consist ing of t w o S-strophes). In w . 5—6 the p o e t constantly varies b e t w e e n a verb in the past tense and a phrase containing a n o u n in the plural and o n e in the singular. I give 18:5ab + 6ab below, each o n a separate line, w i t h the slash indicating the caesura b e t w e e n the A - c o l o n and B-colon. T h e h y p h e n indicates that a particular w o r d group is either o n e word or o n e phrase (a c o m b i nation of nouns) in the original language. In Hebrew, there are exactly twelve words, evenly distributed over the cola as 3 + 3 and 3 + 3.1 have indicated the subject by N W (Nominal W o r d group) and the predicate by v P (verbal Predicate); the w o r d " r o p e s " in the first colon in 2 Samuel 22 appears as "breakers" = waves (the same p o e m , w i t h a lot of variant details), w h i c h I have here adopted. Surroundingme-were
wavesof-death
vP NW
NW vP
ropes-of-Sheol
encircled-me
/
/
torrents-ofcorruption
terrified-me,
NW vP
vP NW
before-meyawned
snares-ofdeath.
T h e numerical perfection proves to go hand in hand here with a cast-iron syntactic design, and with the m a x i m u m use of word pairs. We see a quartet of cola, and note that the strophe has been c o n structed o n a total of five (!) chiasms. First, each poetic line follows the A B - B ' A ' pattern, i.e., o n the horizontal level w e immediately observe two crosswise constructions. Reacting "vertically," w e find an all-governing chiasm o n strophe level, which going from the first verse to the second moves the outside members inward and the inside members outward. Finally, b o t h A-cola form a cross in w h i c h
The Strophe
91
the verbs encircle the nouns, and the B-cola together also form an X (Greek chi), this time w i t h the nouns encircling the verbs. This is an extreme example of semantic, syntactic, and n u m e r ical density, as well as concentric symmetry; there is n o arguing against it. It proves very little about the m o d e of existence of other strophes, but it does show what level of precision is possible and feasible, and also that the poet can create remarkable forms of cohesion w h e n h e wants to. This should prevent us from taking verse and strophe structure too lightly; w e never k n o w beforehand w h a t w e are going to encounter, so it is g o o d to be prepared for the impossible. Is there really n o arguing against this interpretation of the struc ture of this strophe? I t u r n the image inside out, because of t h e m e a n i n g w h i c h the strophe offers t h r o u g h its multiple chiastic construction: there is n o chance for the " I " to escape.The A B - B ' A ' structure is perfectly suited to depict and symbolize confinement and encircling, and the p o e t here seized his chance to make this prison unassailable for David o n three levels: the half-verses, the poetic lines, and the strophe itself chain h i m u p in their very design, that of concentric symmetry. In semiotics* (the t h e o r y of signs) this sort of situation would b e called an "iconic sign." T h e verse and strophe here are designed to b e an icon, i.e., an image that is to represent incarceration. T h e question that remains for David is, W h o in heaven's name is going to get h i m out of this multiple confinement? Nobody, e x c e p t . . . and here the p o e t inter venes w i t h his super-stanza: the five strophes about God's appear ance from heaven constitute his final solution. T h e strophic unit may also be the result of an extended or c o m p o u n d sentence. W e have seen this several times already. In his Lament (2 Samuel 1), David forbade the messengers to report the o u t c o m e of the battle to Philistia. T h e sentence core consisted of the prohibition, w h i c h was followed by subclauses starting with "lest." T h e first strophe of Psalm 1, after the "happy," consists of little else besides a chain of adjectival clauses. Psalm 114—as w e have also seen—starts w i t h a temporal clause, and completes its first strophe w i t h the main clause that proclaims Judah-and-Israel to b e the d o m i n i o n and temple of G o d . T h e S-strophe at the end is also a syntactic unit consisting of o n e sentence.
Reading Biblical Poetry
92
Psalm 13 consists of three strophes, and according to general scholarly opinion has twelve cola. This is w r o n g , and comes from an erroneous division of v. 4, w h e r e there is actually a chain of three subclauses starting w i t h "lest." T h e correct articulation is: 13:2a b 3a b c
How long, Yahweh, will you ignore me forever? How long will you hide your face from me? How long will I have cares on my mind, grief in my heart, all day? How long will my enemy have the upper hand?
4a b c 5a b
Look at me, answer me,Yahweh! My God, restore the luster to my eyes, lest I sleep the sleep of death, lest my enemy say "I have overcome him," lest my foes exult when I totter.
6a b c
But I trust in your faithfulness, my heart will exult in your deliverance: I will sing to Yahweh, for he has been good to me.
T h u s , there are actually thirteen cola, w h i c h by their total of 117 syllables in the original language realize the exact n o r m figure 9. T h e first strophe is o n e of impatience and despair, presented in a two-line and a three-line verse. T h e cola form a chain because they are all questions; they ask " h o w l o n g " four times, and also employ a temporal adjunct in v. 3b. This is an instance of the strophe being demarcated by an obvious sequence. T h e middle strophe has the same r h y t h m of bicolon-plus-tricolon. T h e r e is a positively w o r d e d verse (4ab) containing t w o commands and t w o vocatives for G o d , w h i c h thanks to a clever arrangement proves to b e a neat chiasm, after w h i c h a tricolon occurs, fending off nega tive events.Thus, this strophic unit is defined by sentence structure and a plus-minus relationship. T h e transition to the first person and a positive o u t c o m e mark off v. 6 as the third strophe. A strophe also may derive its unity from the fact that it is a q u o tation or e m b e d d e d speech. This happens twice in Psalm 132. In w . 3—5 David swears an oath to God, and in w . 1 led—12 G o d answers by in t u r n swearing an oath to David; these are b o t h L-strophes. T h e i r function will b e discussed w h e n I consider the composition as a w h o l e , in chapter 7.
The Strophe
93
A strophe may be shaped by a metaphor; the eagle from D e u t e r o n o m y 32 is an example. Below, I q u o t e six verses from the b o o k of J o b ; these are strophes 3 and 4 from the p o e m J o b 14: Job 14:7
8 9
10 11 12
There is hope for a tree; if it is cut down, it will renew itself, and its shoots will not cease. If its roots are old in the earth and its stump dies in the ground, at the scent of water it will bud, and produce branches like a sapling. But mortals languish and die; man expires; where is he? As water evaporates from a lake and a river dries up and is parched, so man lies down, and will not rise; until the heavens are no more, he will not awake, not be roused from his sleep.
T h e third strophe of the p o e m is determined exclusively by figura tive speech: each line contains a vegetative image. Verses 10—12 offer us a negative image, this time that of man. T h e first verse is very bare, as if the poet wants to say: forget all metaphors, just look death straight in the eye. Verses 11—12, however, do contain another image, this time in the form of a comparison. T h e connection with the strophe about the tree trunk is well maintained, as w e again have water here. T h e water in strophe 3, however, was life-giving, whereas in w . 11—12 it becomes an image for the evanescence of our lives, and as such serves death. T h e concluding tricolon contains as many as four negations, and uses these to strike out the euphemism "sleep." A strophe may very well be kept together by a frame; this is a p h e n o m e n o n w h i c h takes us to the boundaries of the unit and h e n c e to the next paragraph, w h e r e w e shall consider h o w the strophe is distinguished from its surroundings.Yet, such an inclusio will have its points of contact w i t h the words it encloses, i.e., w i t h the " c o n t e n t s " of the strophe. T h e L-strophe o p e n i n g Psalm 69 is built o n the image of m u d and water into w h i c h the " I " is sinking, w . 2—3.The L-strophe w . 4—5 b e c o m e s even m o r e phys ical, and already speaks of the hatred that is felt for the speaker.The
94
Reading Biblical Poetry
L-strophe w . 6 - 7 already starts a prayer. A n o t h e r t w o strophes fol low, again in L-format, about the position of the " I " : Ps. 69:8 9 10
11 12 13
It is for your sake that I have been abused, shame covers my face. I am a stranger to my brothers, an alien to the sons of my mother; my zeal for your house has consumed me, and the abuse of those who revile you have fallen upon me.
strophe 4
When I wept and fasted, I was reviled for it. I made sackcloth my garment, but I became a byword among them. Those who sit in the gate talk about me —I am the taunts of drunkards.
strophe 5
T h e keywords here are "abuse" and "taunt," and in b o t h strophes the " I " is confronted w i t h a collective. T h e most painful c i r c u m stance is the fact that these are n o t enemies from outside, but his o w n people. T h e gate is the spot w h e r e the c o m m u n i t y meets and sits in j u d g m e n t , but n o w it is a scene of debauchery, at the cost of the " I . " In the original Hebrew, strophe 4 is marked by a frame consisting of the 3 + 3 words of w . 8a and 10b. T h e translation can show only half of this, in the correspondence b e t w e e n "for y o u r sake" / " u p o n me," and especially in the keyword "abuse." T h e word " c o n s u m e d " from v. 10a literally means "eaten." This knowledge puts us o n the track of a beautiful, associative c o n n e c tion b e t w e e n the t w o strophes. T h e "eating" that the speaker e x p e rienced in v. 10a is followed in v. 11a by fasting. At the end of strophe 5 w e discover its counterpart, the act of "drinking," p r e sented negatively as drunkenness. This n e w inclusio, however, is the imaginative variation of a w e l l - k n o w n word pair, eating and drinking, and stretches b o t h activities in a direction w h i c h is d e t r i mental to the speaker.The three cola about abuse (8a, 10b, l i b ) are supported by three cola about taunts (12b—13b), so that the " I " has totally lost his bearings. I have also m e n t i o n e d that the unifying factor w i t h i n a strophe may b e a single idea. A n y concept of "idea" should b e treated w i t h
The Strophe
95
extreme caution, as in the Western world the Bible has b e e n studied for so long by intellectuals w h o s e research has been either damaged or threatened by their worship of concepts, hypotheses, and theories. T h a t is n o t the fault of the concept itself, however, and of course there were plenty of ideas in ancient Israel. As an example I have chosen a sequence of strophes spoken by the first pedantic prig w h o confronts J o b in the long debate of the e p o n y m o u s b o o k . Eliphaz opens the debate in J o b 4. H e first notes that the m a n w h o was such a support to others in times of trouble is n o w himself unnerved (strophe 1 = w . 2—4 and strophe 2 = w . 5—6)—not a particularly compassionate beginning. T h e fifteen poetic lines w h i c h fill strophes 3—8 are all bicolic except for t w o verses, and this is w h a t the hero has to listen to:
Reading Biblical Poetry
96 Job 4:7 8 9
10 11
12 13
14 15
16
17 18
19
20 21
Think now, what innocent man ever perished, and where have the upright been destroyed? As I have seen, those who plow evil and sow mischief, reap them. By a breath from God they perish, by the blast of his nostrils they perish.
strophe 3
One lion roars, the other one growls, the teeth of the cubs are broken. The lion perishes for lack of prey, and the whelps of the lioness are scattered.
strophe 4
A word came to me in stealth, my ear caught a whisper of it in thought-filled visions of the night, when deep sleep fell on men.
strophe 5
Fear and trembling came upon me causing all my bones to quake with fright. A spirit passed by me, making the hair of my flesh bristle, like a wind. It halted; its appearance was strange to me, a form before my eyes; I heard a murmur, a voice: "Can mortals be acquitted by God, or man be cleared by his Maker? Even his servants he does not trust, and he finds error in his angels."
strophe 6
strophe 7
"How much more in those who dwell in houses of clay, whose origin is dust! They are crushed like moths, strophe 8 shattered at daybreak or at night, unnoticed, they perish forever. Is not their tent cord pulled up? They die, but not in wisdom."
Strophe 3 starts w i t h a question and ends w i t h a vengeful G o d . T h e point of this unit is the inescapable pattern linking guilt and annihilation. A speaker starting verses w i t h " T h i n k n o w " and "As I have seen" increases the pressure o n the addressee. If the " y o u -
The Strophe
97
a n d - I " t o n e suggests intimacy, this is a manipulative strategy. It obscures the fact that Eliphaz is uttering a threat; w h a t else could the function of the m e t a p h o r governing strophe 4 be? T h e trans lator runs into problems here, as the H e b r e w p o e t cleverly uses five different words to indicate lions of various rank and type, whereas English offers only one; I have had to improvise. Strophes 3 and 4 together constitute the second stanza of the p o e m . T h e third stanza recounts a n o c t u r n a l revelation (strophes 5 - 6 ) , and the fourth quotes its content, a message in words (strophes 7—8). By introducing this revelation Eliphaz gives a n e w twist to the business of impressing Job, and h e is n o t going to h u r r y : h e uses four strophes this time. Strophe 5 is still seemingly neutral, offering such "hard facts" as night, sleep, and whispering, while strophe 6 presents t h e accompanying e m o t i o n , and t h e fig ure that will b e c o m e t h e envoy of the revelation. T h e cohesion of strophe 5 is easily guaranteed by the sentence structure: the sentence has n o t finished after v. 12b, and so e n j a m b m e n t occurs. T h e m u r m u r of 16c and " t h e w o r d " of v. 12a together form a neat inclusion of this narrative stanza. T h e unifying factor of strophe 6 is the n u m i n o u s character of w h a t is b e i n g described. All this is an attempt to make J o b receptive to a view of G o d and m a n that w o u l d b e repulsive to all b u t the staunchest Calvinist. T h e negative t o n e of strophe 7 almost noticeably reeks: G o d is presented as a being totally poisoned by suspicion. As if that were n o t yet e n o u g h , Eliphaz employs a special argumentative t e c h nique as the p o e m moves from this strophe to strophe 8.The rabbis call this m o d e l qal wachomer ("from light to heavy"), and in rhetoric it is k n o w n as a minori ad maius; it is indicated by the pivot " h o w m u c h more." If w e listen closely, Eliphaz's " h o w m u c h m o r e " really m e a n s its opposite, " h o w m u c h less"—a disingenuousness that is c h a r acteristic o f his m i n d . H e argues: G o d does n o t trust his angels (v. 18), how much less does h e trust t h e creatures o n earth! C o n sequently, this " h o w m u c h less" is a negative a fortiori: h o w m u c h stronger is his distrust of p e o p l e ? T h e q u e s t i o n in v. 17 is again manipulative, a n d as t h e o p e n i n g o f t h e f o u r t h stanza it is t h e perfect c o u n t e r p a r t or successor to t h e verse that o p e n e d t h e s e c o n d stanza, v. 7. Because of t h e i r f o r m (a r h e t o r i c a l
Reading Biblical Poetry
98
q u e s t i o n p r e s u p p o s i n g a negative answer) and c o n t e n t (the guilty or u n c l e a n p e r s o n ) , these p o e t i c lines b e l o n g t o g e t h e r so that w e also recognize their c o r r e s p o n d e n c e w i t h i n t h e stanza design. B u t look who's talking: w h a t Eliphaz proclaims in strophe 7 — that total distrust is part of God's character—is a projection of his o w n innermost attitude to life, and h e even tries by means of ver bal fireworks to grant this doctrine official status by presenting it as a revelation. Let us take a brief excursion into prosody. J o b 4 has b e e n c o m posed in meticulous fashion: the eight strophes constitute four stanzas, w h i c h mirror each other t w o by two. A great regularity may b e observed o n three levels, demonstrated below by the c a p itals S and L, and also by the syllable totals for the strophes and stanzas. T h e figures for the stanzas have b e e n given in bold type below the figures for the strophes: Job 4 strophes cola syllables
L S L S 6 4 6 4 51 39 53 32 90
85
S L S L 4 7 4 7 34 54 33 54 88
87
If w e n o w add the stanza totals, b o t h halves of the p o e m t u r n out to have exactly the same n u m b e r of syllables, i.e., 175; this results in a r o u n d figure 350 for the p o e m as a w h o l e .
T h e strophes exist by b e i n g distinguished from each other F r o m the preceding section w e may conclude that the strophe can easily fend for itself. This section will demonstrate that it does n o t have to. T h e poet has many devices at his disposal to grant the strophe internal cohesion, and the reader will do well to learn to recognize these tools. O u r p o e t r y manuals teach us, however, that a strophe is never alone, but always works together w i t h its colleagues, the textual units surrounding it. T h e strophe always functions in relation to the other strophes, w h i c h offers n e w p o s sibilities to the "composer," the p o e t w h o assembles t h e m .
The Strophe
99
Let us first think back to the figure of the frame. A n inclusio such as w e have seen in Psalm 69 looks inward, as it were: as a b o r der it draws attention to the strophe itself and w h a t is inside it. T h e r e is a reverse side to this obvious statement, however: because of the inclusio, the strophe is also distinguished from its s u r r o u n d ings. It seems to w i t h d r a w u p o n itself, as if saying to adjoining units: this area is mine, n o t yours. Internal cohesion thus may be viewed from the other side. W e must n o w take a step backward, to create some distance and to ascertain h o w the strophe behaves w i t h i n the tissue of relations that make u p a p o e m . In doing so, w e e n c o u n t e r properties of external cohesion: although the strophe remains identical w i t h itself, it also owes its existence to differences, to its quality of being a"twist."The strophe is marked out by b e i n g different from its sur roundings. T h e p o e t marks the differences b e t w e e n strophes by always introducing n e w twists. W h a t do these changes look like? Here, too, the p o e t can employ all sorts of linguistic, stylistic, and struc tural devices to make the reader experience transitions. W e enter a n e w strophe if there is a change in • the characters who populate the unit; • verb tense; • the mode of the sentences (do they report or describe?; are they wishes or commands?); • grammatical person; • language: from verbal (reporting or desiring action) to nominal (static, describing properties) language; • subject matter; • tone or genre. F u r t h e r m o r e , the b o u n d a r y positions in the strophe are sensitive: especially the b e g i n n i n g may be clearly marked, for instance, by a striking adverb such as "Therefore," a f o r m of address (the voca tive, in the Psalms often " O Y a h w e h " or " M y God!"), or an i m p e r ative such as " H e a r m e " or "Save m e ! " It is n o t difficult to illustrate each of these possibilities by dozens of examples. This would, however, also entail quoting several c o n nected strophes for each option, w h i c h w o u l d take up a lot of space.There is another m e t h o d that makes this unnecessary. I have
100
Reading Biblical Poetry
chosen a substantial passage from Isaiah and a lament from Psalms, and as I discuss each strophe briefly, most types of "twist" or tran sition will pass u n d e r review.
T h e p o w e r f u l o p e n i n g s p e e c h o f t h e b o o k o f Isaiah T h e b o o k of Isaiah is n a m e d after a Judaean prophet w h o was active in the second half of the eighth century BCE. H e lived t h r o u g h the rapid expansion of the most powerful nation of his time, the Assyrians, in Syria-Palestine; saw the demise of the n o r t h e r n k i n g d o m (Samaria fell in 722 BCE); and also saw the tiny state of Judah attacked. After the war has completed its destructive course through the land, Isaiah pronounces God's part of a dispute: the argumentative speech w e n o w find in Isaiah 1:2-20 (a rib or lawsuit, as it is called by scholars); this is an indictment. In his text h e hardly mentions any name, historical detail, or concrete fact of the kind historians love to hear, but focuses mainly o n quality. This characteristic has—we may suppose—made the text so valued that it has survived the ages and has received a place in the canon. I will discuss the p o e m roughly per stanza. T h e first stanza comprises w . 2—4; the next t w o occupy w . 5—9. Isa.l:2
Hear, O heavens, and give ear, O earth, forYahweh has spoken: "I reared children and brought them up, but they have rebelled against me.
strophe 1
3
An ox knows its owner an ass its master's crib, but Israel does not know, my people takes no thought."
strophe 2
4
Ah, sinful nation, the nation laden with iniquity, brood of evildoers, depraved children! They have forsaken Yahweh, spurned the Holy One of Israel, they turned their backs.
strophe 3
The Strophe
101
T h e first strophe is also the pretentious o p e n i n g of the b o o k . T h e p o e t calls u p o n the entire cosmos to b e his witness, in about the same way as Moses did in his didactic p o e m in D e u t e r o n o m y 32. After the exhortation to listen, the floor is given to a character w h o for t h e m o m e n t plays the part of the plaintiff in a trial. It is G o d himself w h o w i t h o u t delay takes o n the part of the father and thus justifies his expectations of the other party, w h o m h e has raised. Developments move so fast that already in the second poetic line w e hear the friction b e t w e e n claim and complaint. Nevertheless, the speaker still has n o t told us exactly w h o it is h e is so unhappy about. T h e identity of the other party is indirectly revealed in the sec o n d strophe. This unit differs from the preceding one in that the subject matter has changed. T h e first half sounds like a proverb, and in v. 3cd the accused is rather exposed; translated literally: "Israel does not know, m y people do not understand." T h e r e is n o direct object, i.e., the verb is here used absolutely (as the technical t e r m goes), and not w i t h o u t reason.What this omission (ellipsis*) makes clear is that the ignorance described is n o t related to something specific and is therefore unlimited: their stupidity is boundless. Changes of grammatical person and genre mark strophe 3.This is a so-called "woe"-exclamation in w h i c h G o d is n o w a third p e r son, and the prophet specifies the indictment: iniquity and cor ruption, culminating in a turning away from G o d , w h i c h also explains the criminal actions.This ending (v. 5c) is the elaboration of v. 2e, a connection w h i c h also creates a parallelism b e t w e e n strophes 1 and 3 that in t u r n keeps the stanza together. C o r r u p t i o n breeds corruption. T h e p o e t - p r o p h e t abandons the original depravity, and in stanzas II—III speaks of the resulting degeneracy as the manifestation of underlying evil. Stanza II ( w . 5-6) employs the language of the body; stanza III ( w . 7—9) is c o u c h e d in military-poHtical terms.
Reading Biblical Poetry
102
Why do you seek further beatings, that you continue to offend? The whole head is ailing, and the whole heart is sick.
strophe 4
6
From the sole of the foot to the skull no spot is sound: all bruises, and welts, and fresh sores, not pressed out, not bound up, not softened with oil.
strophe 5
7
Your land is a waste, strophe 6 your cities burnt down: your soil, before your eyes— strangers consume it, a wasteland, as overthrown by strangers.
8
The daughter of Zion is left like a booth in a vineyard, like a hut in a cucumber field, like a city beleaguered.
strophe 7
9
Had notYahweh of hosts left us a fugitive, we should soon be like Sodom, and seem as Gomorrah.
strophe 8
Isa.1:5
T h e strophes are marked by a shift in subject and tone, as well as by the introduction of the second-person plural: the prophet addresses his audience as separate persons. First, there is a unit which sounds almost medical: strophes 4—5 about pus and festering sores (= stanza II).This image of an ailing b o d y serves as an excellent m e t a p h o r for the corruption of the nation: the people are critically ill. Strophe 4 addresses the people as "you," and covers the w h o l e person via m e t o n y m y by m e n t i o n i n g head and heart. After that, the form " y o u " disappears to make way for the almost clinical description in v. 6. Again, the w h o l e person is dealt with, this time by a merism, "from head to t o e " (as w e would put it). This physical manifestation of decay is followed by a n e w twist, w h i c h offers images of war and its effects, so that strophe 6 repre sents the political effects of corruption: destruction of the land as
The Strophe
103
a p u n i s h m e n t for the entire nation. This stanza (the third) ends w i t h a form of desolation that nevertheless offers a glimpse of h o p e . Verses 8—9 present an image from horticulture, and by means of a counterfactual* ("Had not . . . , w e should . . . " ) end in a dis tant past: S o d o m and G o m o r r a h have b e e n proverbial for deprav ity since the primeval age w h i c h Genesis tells us about. T h e y should b e viewed as mythical-literary places rather than as names from a historical reality. W e have n o w looked at eight strophes. T h e y contain many cola that are all the m o r e intense because of their shortness and that leave us w i t h little h o p e . In the seventh strophe, however, the city of Jerusalem appears u n d e r the n a m e of "daughter of Zion," and in the shape of the w r e t c h e d structure of branches and leaves that has b e e n relinquished by the farmer. This image is clarified in the eighth strophe as "a fugitive, a survivor." T h e names of S o d o m and G o m o r r a h convey the message that J u d a h has escaped total anni hilation only by the skin of its teeth. This does seem to b e a posi tive statement, and the prophet suddenly even uses the p r o n o u n " w e " in order to get closer to his audience and to give t h e m a feel ing of adversity shared, and of a n e w beginning. This concludes the first section of the long oracle. T h e Judaeans have listened to all this w i t h mixed feelings, but breathe somewhat m o r e freely thanks to the first-person plural. This is, however, a mistake; the p o e t has wrong-footed t h e m . H e has inserted a h o o k linking the end of the first section to the b e g i n n i n g of the second, by repeating the names of S o d o m and G o m o r r a h . In v. 9, the reference seems comforting, locked inside the counterfactual m o d e and the message that " w e " escaped after all. In v. 10, however, Isaiah deals his audience a blow by address ing t h e m as the "chieftains of S o d o m " : a major insult that certainly keeps their attention from drifting. . . . Again, the shift in g r a m matical person is the strophe marker:
Reading Biblical Poetry
104 Isa. 1:10
11
12
13a
13c
14
15
16
17
Hear the word of Yahweh, you chieftains of Sodom! give ear to our God's instruction, people of Gomorrah! "What need have I of all your sacrifices?" —says Yahweh. "I am sated with burnt offerings of rams, suet of fadings, and blood of bulls; lambs and he-goats I do not delight in." "That you come to appear before m e — who asked that of you? Trampling my courts, do not continue it! Bringing vain oblations, offensive incense it is to me. New moon and Sabbath, proclaiming of solemnities: assemblies with iniquity I cannot abide. Your new moons and fixed seasons I hate with all my soul; they are become a burden to me, I am exhausted carrying them. And when you lift up your hands, I will turn my eyes away from you; even when you pray harder, I will not listen. Your hands are stained with blood! Wash yourselves, clean yourselves, put your evil doings away from my sight! Cease to do evil, learn to do good, devote ourselves to justice! Aid the wronged, Uphold the rights of the orphan, defend the cause of the widow!"
strophe 9
strophe 10
strophe 11
strophe 12
strophe 13
strophe 14
The Strophe
105
Strophes 9—16 may, t w o by two, b e a c c o m m o d a t e d in higher t e x tual units, stanzas IV—VI, but the stanza boundaries are n o t very conspicuous this time, except for the line dividing v. 15 from v. 16. T h e cola of strophe 9 are varied according to the A B - A ' B ' pat tern. As a plea for attention, they form a strophic unit. At the same time a parallelism is created two levels further up, as this e x h o r t a tion is the successor o f the first strophe. T h e r e is also a p e r t i nent/fitting variation in the repetition: it is n o t the cosmos that is addressed here, but "you," and " y o u " had better listen very care fully to a p r o n o u n c e m e n t , an "instruction" (torah) from G o d . B y phrasing this as " o u r God," Isaiah for a m o m e n t retains the c o m m o n g r o u n d that has enabled h i m to reach his obstinate audience, but this is the end of the familiarity indicated by "our." Strophes 10—11 n o w present the contents of the lesson; w e k n o w exactly h o w far this instruction to the c o m m u n i t y extends, thanks to the use of the first person for God, w h i c h runs t h r o u g h to v. 15. As G o d continues to say " y o u " even after v. 15, w e also may see h i m as the speaker of the last strophes, w . 16—20. A shift of speaker and subject marks the transition to strophe 10, a unit that focuses exclusively o n a graphic c o m p o n e n t of w o r ship: all forms of sacrifice. A frame provides the rounding-off: " w h a t n e e d have I" becomes "I a m sated," w h i c h is chiastically completed by "I d o n o t delight in." In strophe 11 w e see the place that should be o n e of sincere c o m m u n i c a t i o n , i.e., the temple court, while strophe 12 covers the cultic calendar of the visitors. T h e underlying t o n e remains o n e of disgust, since the persistent criticism is that the people care only about outward forms, and the " I " (i.e., God) castigates this hypocrisy T h e unity of strophe 13 is already suggested by a n e w A B - A ' B ' design. Two c o m p o u n d sentences neatly coincide w i t h the t w o verses, and their c o m p o n e n t s exactly cover the half-verses. This arrangement is varied by a chiasm, hands-seeing/hearing-hands. F u r t h e r m o r e , there is a surplus: line 15e about the hands being stained w i t h blood, an extremely incriminating m o n o c o l o n , is the final blow. W e gradually move from the c o r r u p t "yesterday-and-today" toward "tomorrow," as G o d n o w uses the future tense: h e prefers to close his eyes and ears. H e even rejects prayer, a m u c h m o r e
Reading Biblical Poetry
106
direct and honest form of contact than the m u m b o - j u m b o of sac rifice and ritual. Strophe 14 is marked by the change to n e w linguistic forms, and finally reveals the exact nature of the corruption: social injus tice. G o d bursts into a chain of c o m m a n d s that occupies three times three cola. It is the sharp staccato that at the b e g i n n i n g of this b o o k acquired its proper form. These commands are very direct, and they make sense only if G o d is convinced that it is p o s sible to continue together after all. T h e circumstances that will ensure this are the subject of the concluding verses 18—20 (stanza V I I ) . T h e escapee will b e given o n e m o r e chance: Isa. 1:18a b c d e f 19
20
"Let us go, let us have a tribunal," Yahweh says. Be your sins like crimson, they will turn snow-white; be they red as purple, white as fleece they will become.
strophe 15
If you agree and give heed, you will eat the good things of the land; strophe 16 but if you refuse and disobey, you will be devoured by the sword! The mouth of Yahweh has spoken.
It does n o t matter m u c h any m o r e w h o is speaking. T h e first line of v. 18 is spoken by G o d , but after that the prophet's p o i n t of view practically coincides w i t h that of his superior. T h e very last colon mentions Yahweh in the third person, so that we are inclined to allot this line to the p r o p h e t . W h a t is essential, however, is to see that this straightforward sentence concluding t h e long oracle is t h e counterpart to v. 2c, the pivotal line of the o p e n i n g strophe. In this way, the passage as a w h o l e has acquired a formal inclusio, as t h e entire text begins and ends with a tricolon that concludes w i t h "Yahweh has spoken." Strophe 15 in t u r n has a vocabulary of its o w n . T h e first verse reveals the status of this oracular speech: G o d has all the time played the role of plaintiff in a court of law, and has e x p o u n d e d his views as part of a lawsuit. T h u s , the long p o e m has a formal-legal
The Strophe
107
aspect.The strophe is characterized by a fourfold comparison built o n neat chiasms, in b o t h 18cd and 18ef. I have retained the o r i g inal w o r d order so that the crosswise construction remains visible: the verbs are o n the edges, whereas the colors red and w h i t e sur r o u n d the caesura in b o t h bicola.The phrase " B e [your sins] . . ." has the same m e a n i n g as the conjunction "if" in the final strophe, so that a parallelism is created b e t w e e n t h e units 15 and 16. In the same way as the color red reminds the listener and reader of the hands stained w i t h blood, " t h e land" and " d e v o u r i n g " remind us of the aftermath of the war, w h e n strangers came and razed the land. T h e bodies of b o t h these strophes have b e e n constructed o n an opposition. In strophe 15 (v. 18cd + ef) the t w o cola in each verse cover the t w o halves of a radical turn, while the message of the t w o poetic lines remains the same. Strophe 16 contains only o n e such t u r n , and here the complete verses each express half of an opposition: goodwill in v. 19ab versus obstinacy in 1 9 c d . T h e quar tets 18cdef and 19abcd are framed by o n e line asserting that G o d has spoken; this is an inclusio that unites the strophes into a final stanza. This p o e m constitutes the powerful o p e n i n g of the b o o k of Isaiah. It is long, b u t its vigor and passion are reflected in and c o n veyed by proportions that are surprisingly modest. Even in trans lation t h e cola are still very short; there are m a n y terse strophes, and five stanzas consist of only t w o strophes. T h e vocabulary is extremely varied, since the p o e t draws from a m u l t i t u d e of domains, the most i m p o r t a n t of w h i c h are law, war, horticulture, and t h e c u l t — n o t to m e n t i o n the language of a distraught sur g e o n in stanza II. T h e imagery is very apt: t h e crib, the w o u n d s and their bandages, t h e w i n e grower's hovel, t h e racket around the temple, and the contrast b e t w e e n red and w h i t e . T h e r e are seven stanzas and forty verses—very biblical figures. In the statistical s u m m a r y b e l o w I have indicated the separation b e t w e e n w . 1—9 and 10—18 by a double slash. This b o u n d a r y contains t h e c o n catenating device (the " h o o k " ) , w h i c h makes sure that the far away names S o d o m and G o m o r r a h suddenly creep unpleasantly close to the poet's audience.
108
Reading Biblical Poetry
stanza nos. of: strophes verses cola
I
II
III
3 7 16
2 5 10
3 6 13
//
IV
V
VI
VII
2 5 11
2 6 12
2 6 14
2 5 11
In the original language, this formidable disputation takes u p n o m o r e than 234 words. In t h e darkest p l a c e s , i n t h e d e p t h s : P s a l m 88 This psalm is a lament of exactly forty cola. Verses 9 and 10 are tricolic; the rest are bicolic. T h e articulation in seven strophes is inescapable, and I am filled with vicarious shame to have to report that not a single translation or commentary presents the correct division.The only remedy for this sort of omission is subjecting the p o e m to a sound poetics. As always, the first step in the analysis is to read the text over and over again, and try to cover the ground exhaustively by noting everything of any literary value. N o t h i n g short of check ing the complete range of stylistic and structural devices will do. In the case of Psalm 88, the next step is to examine the relative effects of the various formal characteristics. We shall see that the strategic placement of keywords has far-reaching consequences here. First, however, I will start looking for "twists," referring to the list of char acteristics I have given earlier. T h e text of w . 2—7 is as follows: Ps. 88:2 3
4
5
6
OYahweh, God of my deliverance, by day and night I cry out before you. Let my prayer reach you, incline your ear to my cry.
strophe 1
For my soul is sated with misfortune, strophe 2 I am at the brink of the realm of the dead. I am numbered with those who go down to the Pit, I have become like a man without strength. Among the dead released, strophe 3 like bodies lying in the grave, of whom you are mindful no more; and they, they have been cut off from your hand.
The Strophe v. 7
109
You have put me at the bottom of the Pit, in the darkest places, in the depths.
T h e speaker marks the o p e n i n g by a vocative: God's proper name. H e supplements this by an apposition m e n t i o n i n g that quality of God's to w h i c h h e wants to appeal: " G o d o f m y deliverance" (JPS). This sounds positive, b u t unfortunately it is b o t h the first and the last fragment in this song o n the brink of the grave that indicates any h o p e . Verse 2b contains the merism of day and night, w h i c h tells us that the poet has time for little else b u t crying for help. In the second poetic line, the speaker himself furnishes a label for his text: it is a "prayer." T h e half-verses c o m b i n e the visual w i t h the a u d i t o r y — a n o t h e r aspect suggesting totality, just like the merism of the temporal terms in v. 2b. T h e transition to strophe 2 is clear, thanks to the shift from pres ence to absence and the change in verb tense and m o d e . T h e c o m m a n d s of v. 3 are followed by four cola in the past tense, w i t h predicates, moreover, in the passive. T h e wishes expressed in stro p h e 1 have b e e n replaced by a description of " m y " unpleasant sit uation: I a m about to topple into the grave any m i n u t e now. A n d w h e r e has G o d gone? N e x t , the presence of the " I " in the text also becomes d o u b t ful.The personal p r o n o u n is conspicuous by its absence in the very first colon of the third strophe (v. 6a). This omission is t o o m u c h for most biblical scholars, so that they start tinkering w i t h the Hebrew. Even w i t h o u t the visible presence of the w o r d " I , " h o w ever, it is clear that the speaker is talking about himself, and actu ally I consider the ellipsis of the p r o n o u n — i n linguistic terms: a z e r o - m o r p h e m e * — a meaningful signal, part of a clever play o n the contrast presence/absence in this p o e m . By dropping t h e form " I , " the p o e t shows us that he is d o n e for. T h e absence of the p r o n o u n is another example of an iconic* sign.The " I " surfaces only at the e n d of the strophe, but it is the object, even the victim, of " y o u r " cruel treatment. This " m e " anticipates strophe 4. T h e poet is very ironical about his fate by representing himself as "released a m o n g the dead." G o d has returned to the text, this time as the " y o u " w h o is held responsible for "cutting off" the p o e t — w h o fills the rest of the strophe w i t h terms for the u n d e r world (sheol in H e b r e w ) that leave n o t h i n g to the imagination. H e
Reading Biblical Poetry
110
chooses, for instance, the w o r d "Pit," and since h e had also used this in v. 5a, he has n o w created a parallelism o n strophe level. T h e p o e t continues w i t h t w o massive units: 8 9
10
11 12 13
Upon me your fury lies heavy, with all your breakers you afflict me. You make my companions shun me, You make me abhorrent to them; [I am] shut in, and cannot go out. My eye pines away from affliction; I call to you,Yahweh, each day I stretch out my hands to you.
strophe 4
The dead—do you work wonders for them? strophe 5 Do the shades rise to praise you? Is your faithful care recounted in the grave, your constancy in the place of perdition? Are your miracles made known in the darkness, Your justice in the land of oblivion?
Strophe 4 is the middle unit of the composition and, with its eight cola, the weightiest. Four lines are devoted to G o d and his repres sive actions; four lines explore the misery and despair of the speaker, w h o eventually returns to the position he t o o k at the beginning, i.e., praying and crying for help. T h e " I " is complaining of the total isolation into w h i c h h e has b e e n cast by n o n e other than his G o d . H e does not complain about enemies, but about something m u c h worse: h e has been robbed of his friends, to the extent that they are disgusted with him. T h e words of v. 9c t u r n this alienation into a p r i s o n . T h e strophe progresses from " u p o n m e " to " t o you."These pronouns form a thin border around the whole. T h e real cohesion in this loaded center comes from the outside rather than from within. T h e b o u n d a r y w i t h strophe 5 is beyond doubt, as this n e w unit, w . 1 1 - 1 3 , is instantly recognizable as a chain of three verses asking six rhetorical questions. T h e speaker impresses u p o n G o d that it is n o t a g o o d idea to push h i m into the grave, as in that case h e (God) cannot expect h i m (the poet) to p u t in a w o r d for h i m , let alone a w o r d of praise—an attractive and spirited manipulation of the addressee. F u r t h e r m o r e , the argument is the most powerful application of the contrast b e t w e e n present
The Strophe
111
and absent: the " I " is n o t present at all in strophe 5! T h e ego has n o w completely evaporated, so to speak, and the p o e t talks in strictly general terms of the dead and their deafening silence. 14 15 16
17 18 19
As for me—I cry out to you, OYahweh, in the morning my prayer reaches you. Why,Yahweh, do you reject me, do you hide your face from me? I have been afflicted and near death from my youth, I suffer your terrors, I am at my wits' end.
strophe 6
Upon me your fury descends, strophe 7 Your terrors dumbfound me. They swirl about me like water all day long, they encircle me together. You have put friend and neighbor far from me, and my companions are total darkness.
T h e threshold of the final stanza is indicated by the fact that the same " I " that was so notoriously absent in strophe 5 has been emphatically placed in front position in strophe 6.Verse 14 is the counterpart to the very first verse, w h i c h creates a parallel o n stanza level. N e x t , a double w h y - q u e s t i o n follows that certainly does n o t ask for information, but is, as elsewhere, the vehicle of great indignation: v. 15 is a reproach, and by its choice of words again holds G o d responsible for the speaker's isolation. In v. 16 h e frankly states his distress.Thus, a verse in the second person (15) is surrounded by verses of cause (distress, 16) and effect (cry for help, 14). These lines all have " I " as subject, whereas the final strophe repeats the object form "me," in order to demonstrate consistently the extent to w h i c h the speaker is the "fall guy." This final strophe (w. 17-19) is characterized by a remarkable aspect which at the same time guarantees its cohesion. In the three successive cola 8a-8b-9a w e saw, respectively, God's anger, threaten ing breakers (as an image of anger), and alienation caused by God; the first words of that strophe were " u p o n me." T h e seventh and last strophe starts in exactly the same way, and again presents the ele ments of anger, water, and alienation. This time, however, they have been doubled and each receive a complete bicolon of their own.
Reading Biblical Poetry
112
T h e duplication, of course, also means that strophe 7 functions as the climax. I have not yet m e n t i o n e d the most conspicuous markers in the p o e m . For once I will permit myself the luxury of repetition, by printing the p o e m again, this time in its entirety. T h e phrases I have italicized demonstrate that the opening words of strophes 4—5 refer crosswise forward and backward. T h e "dead" of v. 6a are "the dead" of v. 11a, which is w h y I have tried to maintain the original w o r d order as closely as possible in my translation of this colon. T h e o p e n ing " u p o n m e " guarantees the start of a n e w strophe in w . 8a and 17a. These crosswise connections make strophes 4—5 the central stanza where the main lines of the p o e m meet and are tied together. T h e demarcation of w . 8—13 as t h e center w o u l d b e even m o r e convincing if it were accompanied by cohesion in the flanks. C a n we assume that the first three strophes are stanza I and that strophes 6—7 are stanza III? T h e poet again provides us with a structural signal. T h e three-part structure of the p o e m is itself marked by the strategic placement of a keyword: this is the series d a r k darkness—the darkest places, w h i c h in the original language also shows m i n o r variations, b u t always o n the same root. This keyword, too, deserves italics: Ps.88 2 3
4 5
6
7
OYahweh, God of my deliverance, by day and night I cry out before you. Let my prayer reach you, incline your ear to my cry.
stanza I
For my soul is sated with misfortune, I am at the brink of Sheol. I am numbered with those who go down to the Pit, I have become like a man without strength. Among the dead released, like bodies lying in the grave, of whom you are mindful no more; and they, they have been cut off from your hand. You have put me at the bottom of the Pit, in the darkest places, in the depths.
The Strophe 8 9
10
11 12 13
14 15 16
17 18 19
Upon me your fury lies heavy, with all your breakers you afflict me. You make my companions shun me, You make me abhorrent to them; [I am] shut in, and cannot go out. My eye pines away from affliction; I call to you,Yahweh, each day I stretch out my hands to you.
113 stanza II
The dead—do you work wonders for them? Do the shades rise to praise you? Is your faithful care recounted in the grave, your constancy in the place of perdition? Are your miracles made known in the darkness, Your justice in the land of oblivion? As for me—I cry out to you, OYahweh, in the morning my prayer reaches You. Why,Yahweh, do you reject me, do you hide your face from me? I have been afflicted and near death from my youth, I suffer your terrors, I am at my wits' end.
stanza III
Upon me your fury descends, Your terrors dumbfound me. They swirl about me like water all day long, they encircle me together. You have put friend and neighbor far from me, and my companions are total darkness.
T h e articulation of the p o e m in seven strophes may thus b e n o t e d as SSL/LL/LL, w i t h a balance of 14—14—12 cola. After o n e paragraph o n internal and o n e o n external cohesion, I conclude w i t h a synthesis of these two. T h e i r relationship varies, but they manage to w o r k together very well. If the internal c o h e sion is considerable or compelling, as was the case w i t h w . 11—13 in Psalm 88, few or n o devices for external cohesion are needed. If, o n the other hand, the unity within the strophe itself is n o t clear or unce