RAVENNA I N LAT E ANTI QY ITY RJ\"!.'I1n'l w~s one of the mOST import:L111 cilies of laTe nnTi qll c Ellrope. Bel\\"~cn AD 400 ~nd 75[ , it """1$ The rt""s jden~""e ofwesrenJ H.Olll:m emperors, Ostrogothi"
kinp;, and Rp:antine go\"~mo~ of Italr. whi le its hi~hop~ ,md archhishops ranked only to Ih" IlOpt's. During this 35o.)"<~~r p~,.iod . th~ dry wa~ progressin~ l)'
~"eond
enla rged and e nric hed hr remarkahle works of niT nnd ~rchitccn1l"l.', m ~ny o f which still SUTvive to(iJy. Thus. R ave nn a and it~ mOnUlllCiUS arc of cri tical i1l11:>orTallCC to historialls and arT hisTOri:ln ~ of The hIt<: :Incient world. This book pl"(wides n Wtnpr~' h c nsin: surn-y of R31'cnna's history :md m onumcnts in btl' anti'luit}', including discus.~ions of scholarly c onrrovc~ie5. a rcha~ological discoveries, ami new interprl'rations of "rt works. As a synthesis o f the vol uminoll.~ literature on this topi c. this 1'01ulI1" 1)1"Ol'id",; an English _la ngl..l"ge "ntry point for rhe studr of this fa scinating city.
Deborah _\1auskopf Dclipnnis is a:;$istant protc§sor of history at In diana Uni_ ve rs ity. She is thl' editor and transb tor of Agnel1us of Ravenna's Lihel" pomijlf'llis M.-I...-i.u
Rln'elI1I11fis.
an d she is the exec utive ediTOr of Tbe
tlIedicl."111 Nevin;.
RAVENNA IN LATE ANTIOlIITY
Deborah Mauskopf Deliyannis
~CAMBRIDGE ~ UN IVERSITY PRESS
CAM BRIDGE U""VE RSlTY P ROSS
umbridge. New York. ,\ 1dboomc, ,\1 od rid. up< T o,,'n. Sing.pore, SJo 1'. 010. Ddhi. Duboi. T ok)'o C... mb";dg< Uni,..,"';'Y 1'",.. 3' A,..,nu. of the Americas. New York.
~y
1001 3·'47J. c.....
,,' ,,',.. ..,.", lwidg<_01'!(
In fom-..tiun '-'" ,h i> " ~lbriJge
,id~
,..,..,.. ..,.mb";dgo_otg!9illoj' r836i"
Unive"';ty I'"""
.01<>
nu. publi<,
....t ro .h. ptmi ....... of r"l<\~ n . rolleqil'< li""".i ng .""",me"tS. no "'p
"'f ,.....
Fin' pubiisheJ
rt"""
.0.0
Prin«d in the United St."" of Ame"""
/.ilmrry .jC"'grm C.,./oging ;n PrJoIicatiM ""'" Ddi)~"nis.
Deoo...h ,\b",kopf. '!)66--R,,,.,,nn. in ,.. < . n6qui'Y f Dooo...h D
phical r-" •-SJ671-' (hardbock) L R"-.
9-+5'47.°' -OC1l
'00j>0"'75
Cambridge Uni",,,i'Y P", .. ha, "" respons.itoili'Y for for .>:1<",,' or it"" ,dcrreJ to in thi. public>Ot gu. rantee
CONTENTS
List of lllustrJtions List of Tables
"
]' refilcc
CHAPHRONl INTRO D UCTION
•
luwenn. C.pltol? J I is",r,. of S<:h"brsllil' 011 R....'nn.
Arrh,.oJul!iall Consider,,,;,,,,, fl."·,,nn. ond Ihc I h"""<>gfllph)' of L'le Amique ,\n on,1 -\reh"",,"".
Som~
CHAI'HR TWO
The Origin' of 11."'"",,. -lhc Rcpllhi""" Ci.y Cia"",: The Rom." Impcr;' I I lorho, .nd Fleet Ih~
11.,,,,,." Fm]>ir.
.\ 'lltird- ,lid Fourth-<..:cmury Crisi,' 11."'011"" ChriSli,n Origtn, UIAt'HR THRH
RAVENNA AND THE W[SHRN EMPIRORS. AD 400 -4119 Th. 1..,0" Cemury of the \ \. ="nl Rom.n Empi,.., \In,-jllg tt,. C'pi.. i to fl. ..'.nn. JU"cmlO '~'
It"'"",, ••••
Gpi,.1 "de IIIlprii
l
"·S ,. ,.
ROMAN RAVENNA
The City ofR,,'.nn. in
•
.,., ,. II
"
C ONTENTS
\"In
Th" Uty \ \ .11s of R,wn". The I\',torm"",," Th PoI:>r<~» Other P"hlic B"ilrlmg> O,u",he'S Chu"'h .... m th. Iionon.n I'e'iod G,l1. PI""idi,. eh"",h", S.n Gim .. nni Fungcliil. Sonto Croce Th. - ,\ 10"-;01.",,, of G.II. Placid i.The Ri", of ,h~ Cln,,,,h of Ro> enn. The Coth.dr.1 The Onh"<1,,. B'p,i"cf)' Th. Fp;",up.1 1'.10<.., O,her 1'.1';-';"1',1 Church l'o"",1.';on, Tn. End uf 1"'I",ri,1 1U"",n.
5' H
<:5
"
o.,
"
0,
70
,~
'"
CHAPTER fOUR
RAV ENNA. TH E CAPITAL OF TH E OSTROGOTH Ie KINGDOM
Tn..oocric >"d
h.~,
Theo
'Throdcric',I'.Io"", Theodoric', Other SCCll],r Con."ro<;u"", 'Ine _11>u.oI<"", of -n,cod~nc The Os'!'<)gothtc Kingdo'" .fter Tho:od.ric to HO
,0< ,08
".'" '" ".
, 5'
CHAPHR IIVl
RELIGION IN OSTROGOTHIC RAVENNA ,>,ri.ni"" on.! 'nO Goth, s.". ',Ipolli".r<: .'.,h-Ce",ury ehurche, "fCb"" The Orthodox Ch"r<:I1 .fteT l"eodenc
'JO 'JO
,.' r;: ,
,i 4
'i7
,"'" "" ,,8
CONTE N TS
CHArnR SIX
RAVENNA'S EARLY BYZANTINE P[RIOD. AD .540600
'0'
Th. b,,'irolUl\em .nd 1",li'" l ro,ni>", °lnc B)u,,' inc ~"""09u,,,' ,od 'he LO!nh,,,I~
>OJ
Th~
E",,.l>I;,Ju,,em of. IIp,.ntine ,\d",;"i"r.l;on
The ,,,,,hhi"',,,,, of R.nno. 'I'he C .. hcd,..,l ,nd the Fl'i'"'0I",1
-n"01l"
Churl'h lIuildio!( Church Iluildin)i: in 'he City of R"·,,rm. S.ma ,\hr;' ,\Ioggiar"
,," "" ":I
'" ", ,1>
San \'1>le S.., .\ hchclc in ,\fric;"""
"3 '50
Sc St"phcll Othe,. Clt ... rd""
''is
Church lIuildin!( i" CI.ss.
156
.
"
"
..,
St. Pml,,"<. St. F.lc""h.di,,!, '0,1 St. F "phe",i. iIlf mart! So",', \pollin.", in el."",
'58
San So"em
'74
"
CHAPHR SLVlN
RAVENNA CA PITAL AD 600-850 IUll"enn. o Co!'it.1 of the B)"Z:Int Ine rnrch". ,A rmhi,/",!,' .n,I»"I"'" 'The '\utOC"l'h.I}' Quo"i"n
After the Exo",h"e R"'cnn,, By".min. 'nd P"'t-Il)7.lntlllC Flit. EllVim'U"."t ."d l'rba" Life AJl~nn .. h, ~.,'c"n.o Agnellu>. .nd the C.rolingi.n,
on,.
,l!J
,,.,,
"4 ,88
'91
Appendix: Tables Notes References Indel<
'" HI
LIST OF ILLUSTRATION S
Plates Ia. ",\ \,usolculll of G.Il. I)locidi •• ~ interior vicw looking towonl ,he ~.h
I h. ' j\ Iousolcum of G.Il. " Jacidia," Christ os .he Good Shepherd, north lunette Illosoic lb. O rthodox B.priSlcry. stucco deconotion .( the window rone Ill>. Orthodox B'pti,tcry. mos,ics of the dome IlIa. S.n!'Apoll in.re 1"uo,"o, mosoic of the north "",11, the Virgin .nd Child H.nked by .ngels, ,nd the three ,\logi III h. Som 'Apollin.re Nuo.·o, mosaic ofthe soulh w.l1, detail of St. f., !anin leading me pr"""",;on of m,le saints IV•. S. m'Apoll in.re N UO''', moso;c of the south R",CTUl' .nd its "p.lotium" TVb. Ari.n B.ptistery, mos.;cs of {he dome V. CRP"'" "jew of {he ch.pe]'s v.ults Via. Son Vit.le, the presbitcry .nd.pse VII>. Son Vit.lo, 1ll00';. of the south I'n,.hitcry won, Mcichisc<Je~ .nd Ahd V1l •. Son Vitole, mos.ic of the north 'P'" woll.Justini.n .nd his court Vllh. Son Vit.]e, mosoie of the south opse ""U, "I"he<:>doro .nd her eourt VIII •. S. nt'Apoli inore in Classe, ,'iew of the interior \'Ilib. S. nt' Apotlinorc in CI3SSc, l1l0s0ics of the '1"" '':;lUlt
w.n.
=""""".,•.
Figures CUlTInt ",,,,,,,I pl~n of R.,','Tma, o,'erl.id with ,he I,," onti'IU" w.lls with m.jor .",h.eologi~.. l . iles ond {>Ilg' " .' Tub; ]iui/i, "Iuse<> Nuion. le, Rovenn. I,
w.t,,.w,},,
,
.,
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
,. + 5' O.
,. •• ,.• u.
,".,. ,+ , 5·
,.
'0.
,
•.
, ". ,.
".
,,. n.
,+
". '0.
,. ',.. ".
,,.
,\ lop showing R,,'enno in the Rom.n imperi.1 period. co. AD .oo Funer..y stele of l>Ub~us Longidienus, 0 ship builder (jam- "'n'a/is) of Cia"". first century BCIAD. ,\losco N. zion.le. R,,'enlUl Reconstrt>Ction of the l'om Aure. embedded within the Iote .ntique .... ]], ,\ lap showing R,,·eoo • . Cia"", •• nd the Adri.tic coostline in the fifth, sinh •• nd ninth centuries /l lap of 11."''''''''. Cl_AD 480 G<:>ld soli~us of G. ll> I'I""iCtion diogro:rn of thc mosaics of the triumph.1 orch ond.psc The S.nto Croce complex. c.' AD 450 "'\lousnleum of G.II. I'lllCidi . ... exterior ,;e... from the snuthwest "/l I. usnl.um of G.II. 1'1..,;di.," plan., ground le"ci "/l lausoleum "fG.II. 1'1..,;di.," W",t.no with, iun.'tW of d''''T drinhng ",\ I. usoieum of G.II. p l..,i,li .... St. l ....·Tence. s"uth lunette mo,l>jc "M.usnlelUn of G.II. p locidi.," m""ics of thc c<'1ltt.1 "",It I'I.n of Ih ""nn. 's • .,hed ... 1complex. including the Ursi.n. C.thed ...1 (c •. 4"5). the Orthodo. B.ptiswy (4'05-5OS) • • nd the '/'.".", Sa""",, (second century AD) Orthodo. B.pti«cry. reconstn>Cted pl.n", ground ievel, with c-urr.mt ,1"oT .nd font, .n,1 plan .. window I,,,'''' Orthodo. B.pti«ery. view of the exterior from the southeast Orthodo. B'p,i«ery. reco"stn>Cted cross senion showing the origilUll .nd subsequent Aoor .nd roof lewis Orthodo. ll'p,i"cry. ,·i.w of the interior f..,ing so utheast Orthodo~ B'p,i"ery. ,hrone in £on",.tic .rchitccru... 1""ClIC, mos.ics of the middle •.one OrthodoI Baptistery. c~nt ... 1med.llion of the dome. depicting the b'ptism of Christ S.nt'Agotl Moggiore. reronsUUcted pl." M'I' of 11.....,,,,, •• "'. AD BO G<:>ld 'riple solidus ofTheoderic (,he S"";g. lh. Med. llioo), gold, 3,3 em di.m .• ,\ Iuseo N.zion.le. Rome Bronze dcanummiurn, ob"erse with bust of R,,,"en,, •• nd the leg""d "Felix R,,'enn •. " reverse with. monog ...", of R,,-enn. surrollllded by • wr~3th Pi.n of the pal..,e. os known from """" .. tions. "'. 516
"
., B
" "
<J
"
" " "
"" "" ""
8,
5,
'"" ,. 'J
" "
.oj
.0, .08
" 5
,"
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
'"
p. ,\ ,",ble I'"nol depicting i-l cl'CIJics and the St.g of Cerinei., early sinh cemury, ,\ luseo ",.:cion.le, IU'-enn. H- ,\ lo\lsoleum of Theodoric, view from rhe west ,\ louwl.'.111l of Theodoric. ,-jew of the interior of rhe lower 1",-eI J5. ,\ l. usolou", of Theodoric, ent.."c•. lower le,-.I
". ".
,'.". ". ..,.
.,.'.
.
H-
.... ". .'.
.,.
.'. '0. '19·
,'. ". ".
,.. !S.
". ". ".
,\ 1ausoleum of Theoderic, pion O! ground 10,-01 shOl"ing th. structure .nd {he origin . l loc"iOll of the fence posts J\ lou",I<:1"n of Th",,,Ie";., plm of the "PI"" 1",-01 ,\ lo"solc~Jm of Throdcric, monolithic c'pSlone R,'<:onSlnu,,,ion of (he ,\ \,u,.,lo\l", of Theorl'hyry b .. htub n,,,.' in the "1'1"" TOorn ,\ lousoleum "f Th,,~teric, -Z.ngcn frie," Tdid om'm""t " the h.se <>r the ""I""",e ,\ lo"solc~lm of -Thc'OSlk... 1t the Last SUI'l"" s.",' Apollinorc Nuo,·o, Ill""'ic "f the nonh w.lI, window 7.O]\e (f.r Idl sid~), IWO mal. flgum; hold;ng' scro ll ,nd. codex S."" .o\l'0ll;n • ..., Nuo'·o, m"",ic of the soulh " .. II. deu;l of Ihe lefl side ofthe "l'.l .. iw" n S.m'Al'0llin. re N oom, di'gr." " of Ihe ;m.gcs of Cl . sse .nd ,he R.n."nn, -p.IOI;u"," wilh the . ",os "'pl.""d ;n the sh.dcd 5.", 'A I",U;n". Nuo,-o, m"",ic of the north w.ll. St,,- Gee;I ;•. Eul,l i., Agnes (w;th Ihe I.mb), Agoth.,:ond I>dag;, S."" '\roU ;n • ..., 1"00'.... m"",ic frogmen! from Ihe west ,...11. he.d ofJ ustin;.n S.."o Spirito. ,i.w of Ihe interior
,60s
'"
"5
,,' '" ,,' ".'JO , J'
OJ' 13'
'JJ
'. 'J<
'
' 4;
'" '" t i" t; t
I'n
155 155
'!9 16; 16)
,0,
'",,
17)
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
XIII
S9- Th. Ari •.n C.rnedr,1(tod'r s.nto Spirito) .nd Ihptis,.ry, reconstructed pion sho"'ing oct.gon .nd now-lost ,urrounding 'poc,," (sh . ded) 60. Ari.n B'pt;,t.I)·. exterior vicw 6 T. Ari.n B'pt;,tOI)·. cemr.l",ed.,lIion depicting the b.ptislll of Ch ri.t 61. Ari.n B.pti.t.I)·. Sts. Pet.r.nd P.ul H.nking. throne 63' PI.n of R..·O",lO·S episoop. 1comple .. including the " .. hed ... l, b'ptistery, ' n,1 ,·,ri ... ,lS I,uildings <>( the 'piSc/Jf'illm 6+ Ca{J<"" IlTCh~wm"/', sollth ",t ""terior ""II with lhe r.m.ins of the eighth-cenntty "it·,.,.i,,,,, (?) 6;. Ca{J<.>Stles 611. Ca{J ",,,uming Joseph 7S· S.m 'Apollin.", in CI1<sc. oolwnn, "f I'roeonnNi.n morhle. ""'" from the n"rth .isle 76. S.",. ,\ lori. ,\I'ggior•• pia" of,he 'I's, ". Son Y""le. ,.;~w ofth. enerior frum ,he north 7R. S.n Vi .. I~. "'''',n
83.
8+ 85. 86.
87. 8R. 11<).
"'otIJI~
rc'wt",.nt on the
outer w, l1s of the .",bubtory S.n Vi,,,le. mosoi"" of the nil It of the .pse S.n Vi,,,I •. mosoie of the nonh .psc "'oil, deta il. he.d of ,\Iaximi.n S." \'""Ie. south side of the presbitel)' oreh S.n Vi ..l•. moso;e " f th~ nonlt presbitel)' """II. ;nduding the Stol)' of Ab ... ),.", S.n Yltole .• reh .nd ,,,ult of the prNb;t.l)· S.n j\ iichcle in Afriristo. pl.n of origin.ll' roUl S.n j\ iichcle ifl Afriristo. rocon<tructeJ mosoic of the "I"" .nll triwnph.1 .reh, now in the Skulpt",e"s,munlung und j\ luscwn fur 1l)'7.•minischo ](W'Sl. S.. "liche Muscct, 1.U Berlin. Berlin. Genn",,)'
177 1;9 1112 1 ~3 I R<)
1 <)0
191
19J
'9; 195
199 :0' "4
"5 , '7 ,Ii '" "j
"5 "7
,,8 "9
'H 'H , 19
' 4' '45 '41 149 '5'
'; J
LIST 01; IllU STRATI O NS
<)0. S~m:AJ)OlJin~re
<) 1.
9l.
93. <).j.. 9:;'
9(,'
<)7.
')8. 99 .
100. 101.
10 2 .
10j.
fa",
in Chsse, plan, including the l:n er cnmp:1J\ile on the north side Sant' Al)Ollinure in ChlSSt', view of the exterior from the southeast Sant' AI)OIlill:lrc in Cbssc, CQlllmn c'l piml of the COlnposite ",in.-1hlo.'11 acand1U.~ type S~nt'Ap.ollil1al·e in Cbsse, view of the ap'i<' and trium phal arch Sinopie (llnderdnlwing) from the lowe r apse wnll of Sant'Apollinare in Classc. tod.l}' i.n rhe ,\'111:;;1:0 N azionak, Ravenna Sant'AJ:><:lllinarc in Chs.se, the TransfiguraTion mosaic in the a p~e vault; 1I\i;'(hllioll n"n!.:ed b~' )1oses, Isabh, t.he H and of God (abon), ~rl<1 tfm:l' sheeJl n:pre.o;cnt.ing ~p{)sdc.< Sant'AJ>Illlinare in Cbs..'ic, St. Apollinaris al1li (left to right) BishollS Ecclesius, Sf. SeveTlL<, St. linus, and Unicinus Sant'Apolli,lal'e in Chsse, !l1osaie on rhe north wall of the apse depictin g ~!l1pel'Ors with Archhishop Rcp.,mnl< Sant'Apullinarc in Cbsst:, mosaic on the 50uth "'all ofthc apst: depicting Abel, Ml·1chiscdel, and Abraham an d Isaac San Sel'em, CI:l..~e , ground plan of the la te sixth-e... ntury basilica (including irs ;'aIM ) 3lUl lnl.' enlicr eh~llCl.~ teription S~nr' AflOllinare in Cbsst:, sarCOphOlb'\IS of An:hbishop Grariosus (d. ca. AD 789) So-clilcd ~P~bce ofth ... Ex-n ehs," actuall), [be facade of a d'Ul'ch ucJi(;,lIed to til<: Savior, ru iJ-eighth ~cntury Sant'AI"ollinarc in ChISs<:, nf,uriflm of St. EI ~uch'IJius, ninth l"t.,ntu ry AD
:(,: :63 ~ 6-t
l65 l65
l Oi li ' l i~
~i
J
175 176
: SI ~9 '
19!
LIST OF TABLES
~.
Rum,m empcroN Kings of 1t3J~·
J.
£X.lfchs (WiUllltTCSICd titles)
..J.
LO!1l b:lrd kings Bishops of Ran!nna Popcs Dimensions of R;lvenna's basilicas
I.
5. 6. 7.
png~
.lUI 30~
JO' JOJ
30' 30 5 JO'
PREFACE
I ,,'liS first introduc<-'tI to the study o f Ravenna in Cecil L. Striker's graduate seminar at the Un;~'crsicy of Pennsylvania. Lee o\'crsaw my dissertation on Agncllus of Ravenna, and was th~ motivating force behind this book. [ am cnonnously gr.ltcful to him for hiscnoour.lgcmcnt, for hisoommcntsoll the various parts of the text, and for generously providing me with photographs. My oolleages Ann Gmuchael and D iane Reilly have been constant sound-
ing boards for my ideas, and I am indebted to {hem for thcir advice and support, especially toAnn for her insistence that I find a way to work plague imothe book, and to Diane for her reassurance that I cou ld write Foran his-
oonans. Others who havc hdped un sl'••~ific questions indudeJunathan J. Arnold , Thomas Brown, Paul Dutton, Andrew Gillett, Nicole LopezJantzen, L.wTence Nees, James J. O ' Donnell, Glenn Peers, Leah Shopkow, Eugene Vance. Dorothy Verkerk, and Edward Watts. I am also "ery grateful to Kate Copenhaver, Seymour Mauslupf, Scott McDonough, Urs Pesch low, M ary Ann SuJl i,':!n, and Eugene Vance for their magnifi~'Cnt photographs; the lntcmct tru ly is a marvelous way of connecting pcople with similar interests. Invaluable help "lIS provid~~1 by Rhonda Long of Document Dchery Services at the Ilcnnan B. Wel ls Librdry and Mary Bu~'£hley of the Fine Arts Libl'llry at Indiana University, and Paola Pilandri of the SoprintL'ndem.a [It-'T i Beni Architettonici e Pacsaggistici di Ravenna. Financial support, esp~'Cially through a prctcnure IC3''C, has been providl"tl by Indiana University. I would especially like to thank Beatrice Rehl of Cambridge University Press for her kind advice and cnroUl'llgemcnt as this book took shape. and especially for her patience with my delays as the manuscript was rompleted. \Vhen I signl>d the contract for this hook, I had twO children; when the manuscri pI was completed, I had three - it has b~'Cn a very busy three years! Spending time with my sons,AJex, Harry, and Simun, has meant that I have not traveled, especially to Jraly, as much as r might ha,·e. The boys may not ~vii
xviii
PREFAC E
quitc uo(lerstJtH\ their mother's intcrest in thc late antique world, out onc day ....'e will all gO to Ravenna and they wi\! underStan(\ my enthusiasm. My husband, Constantine, has seen and understood; he has supported my career from irs beginning with love, patience, and pranicality, and I dedicate this book whim.
ABBREVlATlONS
CARR
HL U'
LPN. MGH I'L JUS
Cm"So Ji mlwrll m/fllrlr R,I<Jmm,lr (' 8i~'l/I(;lIt P"uilbr D(I1(O'II, His/ori" ulllg;~baI", Lih('1' pum ijir"fi$ ud,'.rltlr NII1:t'JIWlli.,' I\lQIIIIIII<.,,'" grr1ll,mim.' iJIS/or-im
/'lIIl1J/QgiJl Lilli,,,, flrl'lr/1/
Iliili{{/J'IlIII Srl'ipll1l'~s
xix
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODU CTION
Ravenna Capi(al? Thc city of Ra,·cnna in northeaStcrn ICI ly lvntains somc of the mOSt spectacular works of art and architecture to have survive.:! from late antiquity. These monuments were created between AD 400 and 600, at a time when Ravenna was one o f the roost imporClrrt cities in the Mediterl":lnean world. After 600 Ravenna experienced both economic and political downrurns, but the artistic and architectural monumems remained as a teSClmem to the splendor of the Christian RotHan Empire in its early cemuries. and as an inspiration both to later generations of the city's inhabitants and to visitors. In the absence of an e:({ensivc body of writtcn sources for the late antique city, the art and architecrnre have bl'COme the main source for our understanding of Ravenna 's role in ltolly and the Mediterranean. Sincc the ninth cenrury, Ravenna has been considered the "capital of the lare antique west." This is what Ravenna 's own ninth-ccntury historian Agncllus called it; it is the title of the four-volume history of the city by F. \V. Deichmann, Rllt'mnll, Hauptsrlldt drs f/liitantikrn AbrnJlonJes ( I ¢g89), and it was thc title of a conference held in !OO4 in Spolcto, subsequently publishl-d as Ravmnll; do cilpitllir imprrialr 11 capitllir mmalr. The word "capital" (Hauptsradt, capitolr) refers to the city's political function as the residencc of tile western Roman emperors after 400, of the Ostrogothic kings from 493 - 540, and of the rulers of the Byzantine province of centr:ll Ita ly from 54'>"""75 I . These rulers, along with the bishops of Ra"enna, made a determined effort to create a city that would provide a WOrtlly setting for (he rimals that demonstrated their authority. But did la te antique rulers wam the city to be regarded as a capitoll, and if so, did they suC'Ces~fully convince their contemporaries? In urder to addrc~s th is question, wc muSt fir~t dcfinc whJt a capit.l w.s in the fifth and sixth centurics. The word as it is used today, defined as a city
,
,
INTRODUCTION
serving as a seat of government, has no exacr correlare in late antique Latin or Greek. E. Chrysos has recently noted that in latc antique sources {he word capul is used only for Rome and Constantinople, and carries symholic connotations, whereas the term mks imptritJlis, referring to the location
of the emperor and administration, really corresponds better to what we would consider a capital city. ' Tnisambiguity - the fact that Romecould be a cilpuf without hous; ng a central gO\!crmnent - "'liS the result of the p01itical circumstances of the R0Il13n Empire in the fourth and fifth centuries. For 300 years the city of Rome had been the ~-enter of imperial administr.ltion and the showplace of the empire's glory . However, Rome's 10000tion was not I", rticularly convenient for admi nistering the affairs of an empire that extended east to Persia and nort h to Scotland. The military emlICrors of the t hird century spent less and less of their time in Rome, and other cities rose to prominence as places where an emperor (or a would-he emperor) might reside.' Aftcr a century of political diS;J rray, the emperor Dioclcti an (!84- 305) took the momentous step of dividing the empire into western and eastcrn halves ruled bycocmlICrors (augusri), caeh of whom had a junior colleague «({ICSar). These four rulers and their administrations were oos(:cl in different cities: iuitially tileS!' were Nioomedia and M ilan (fur the augum) and T hessalonike and Trier (for the cllcSIIm). After 31 4 Constantinople, founded hy the emperor Constantine, replaced N icomedia as the eastern imperia l capital. Rome was conspicuously om itted from thc list of new lopitlls, prooobly largely for strategic reasons, but it is also possible that Diocletian hoped TO brcak away from Roman m1ditions that he felt had [,,":en deleteriou> to the empi re in the pR-vious centllry, ancl in particular that hc wished w minimize the threat of revolt hy powcrful military units stationed in Rome) Although mostof these cities had been important adminisrrativc centers in the Roman pcriod (with the exception of Constantinople), none of thcrn had pennanent stl"Ul"tUreS for housing the imperial court. After Diocletian designated them imperial sears of government, each city began to build facilities that would acoormnooate the imperial ccremonia l and the admi nisrration that would now be situated there.'; All of tht'SC new capitals looked to Rome for inspiration, while at the same ti me reAe<;ti ng th e ne'" political, administrativc, and cI'cntually re~gious circumstanccs ofthc empirc.S As we will Sl'C in Chapter 3, the central feature was the palace, around which were arrayed hippodromes, colonnadcd streets, fura, baths, and churches. A new capital city that is intended to ~ ... break away from, in panicular, dt-veloped elite or bureaucratic institutions ... " i~ known to anthropologists as a disembedded capital. A. H. Joffe's stlldy of ancient dis<'1nbedded capitals notes that thl;' are I"CJ)' c:cpensiw, he<:ause thl;' ha"e to I"" built from scr:atch on a grandiosc seale, and highly unstable, especially in a
RAVINNA CAPITAL?
situation of political V"~riabiliry.6 The Roman Empire in the founh to sixth centuries was extremely unstable, and while wnstantinople achieved lasting success, most of the other new COIpitals enjoyed relati"ely brief building booms.) Ravenna, on the other hand, had a tenuous cxist~"Ilce in its first century as a lllpital, but managed to hold on to its role as a political center for a serond century and beyond. This enabled it to have not just one but scwral phases of commemorative monuments, cumlliatiwly reinforcing the scnse that Ravenna was a traditional seat of go,·cnl1ncnt. Rivalry with Rome is a l>trsistent theme in the politil,,1and ecdesiastil"31 history ofRavcnna. Emperors had not livcd in Romc since z84, but the city remained the showplace of the Roman republic and empire, the repository of its history, and the home of the Senate, the group of powerful Jtalian landowners whose authority waxed and waned in the course of Rome's imperial history. Rome ".,.s the caput orbis, the "head of the worldt l'Ven ,,·hen political power was no longer ccntered in it. 8 Milan had been viewt"
3
•
INTRODUCTION
western cities in the period from 400 to 600. Ravenna's period of prosperity coincides with ~ time in " 'hich cities throughout the Roman "'OTld werC undergoing dramatic tTllll.\formations. 9 ' Ineeity o f the Roman Empire had been a center of secular administration, with a dense urban fabric that included public amenities such as {heaters and baths, aqueducts and >ewers,
clabonltc Roman-style houses for the elite, and evidence of long-distance trade. By the year 6oomanyofthose features had disappeared from w(.."Stcm Europe, replaced by towns centered on the church, with the bishop as the
main authurity figure, a mu<:h lower density o f buildings, meaner and less architectura lly imcgr:ncd houses, no secular elite residents, fewer urban amenities (except for chur<;hes), and a dramatic reduction in items obtained
from trade; the "ruralization of the ci ty" is a tenn often used. '0 Progressive invasions, sach (Rome was sacked in 4[0 and 4)5, Milan in 539), plague, and economic problems led to dramatic depopulation, a slowdown in ne'" construction, and decay of the old urban fabric. The same processes e\'enmally ocl~'TTed in Ra\'enna, hut at a different pace. Ravenna was nut, as far as we know, sacked in any of the invasions or wars that beset the Italian peninsula, perhaps testimony to its perceived invulnerability provided by the swami)'; of the Adriatic coast. R..'enna had a residt'llt secular governmental administration until the eighth century, which led to different political dynamics in tbe city than were found el:;ewhere." In Ravenna, construction of magnificent new buildings continued until the end of the sixth century; indeed, the middle years ufthe sixth century produl",d >omc of the most dramatic and spectacular works of art and architecture anywhere. After 600 Ravenna suffered from the cumulative effl'CIs of the l"CO-nomic downturn and the political cvents of the previous fifty years, but the extra time had allowed the city to build up a collection of monuments that few other cities could rival. Rawnna may have been beautifu l and prosperous, but the literary texts sbuw us a l"Ontemporarymf11wlitiin which Rome reigned SUpfl-me. Because of its political importance, Ravenna is briefly mentioned in many texts, from it"tters to bistories to poems, from the Roman and early medieval periods. Fewof these offer praise ofthencwpolitical center. Roman authors through the fifth century scorned Ravenna's marsby landscape, and sneered at its flies, bad water, and frogs. " Emperors might live at Ravenna, but they l-amc to Rome for the important l",remonial events that werc praised in panegyrics. Byzantine authors mentioned Ravenna's defensibility, but thought of the west in tenns of Rome, Even the Romans wbo "'orkt-d for the Ostrogothie king Theoderie praised Rome's monumental past far more than Ravenna 's glittering present. Fur Stnltcb';c and t:(:unomic reasons, then, Ravenna maintained its politica l role through scI'eral changes of regime, but its monuments do not seem
HISTORY OF SCHOLARSHIP ON RAVINNA
to ha ,'e convinced cantem porariesof glory a r prestige. The process of creati ng a co"'~ncing capital city took zoo years, and the m0l1 umentali7,.atian that we admire was completed JUSt in time far the <->{."Qnam ic and JXllitical decline that was to spell the cnd of Ravenna 's dominance. It was not until the ninth cenrory that viewers could admire Ravenna as a glorious lllpital: l{avcnna was not commemorated in literary sources until Agncllus wrote a history of the episcopal see in the R30!i, a century after the city had ceased to be a scat of anything but local and episcopal government. O nly in the conttxt of the Carolingian renaissance, as Ital ians began to dcvd op a renewetl sense of urban consciousness that in cl uded pride in their Roman and late antique heri tagc, " could Ravtnna's staros as a former capital of the west be fully appreciated. \ Vhen we ta lk about Ravenna as a capital, then, we must remember that we are doing SO in historical hindsight.
History of Scholarship on Ravenna T hrough the cenrories, Raven na's history has UtlOlctl-rl the anention of a v;!riety of authors and scholars. Stlrting with Agnellus in the ninth century, medieval authors wrote saints' lives, sermons, and chron icles th at document specific mo ments in the lity's history. From the fifteenth century, local historians an d antiquarians produced ever-more-learned historical texts, as well as publi shing the primary SOUK CS on wh ich these histories werc based. \ Vi th the development of the disciplines of archaeology and art history in the ninl"!eenth century, Ravenna began to occupy an ever-larger place in the historical consciousness nat just of its own inhabitants, but al so of outsiders. And with the rece nt growth of interest in late antiquity as a historica l period , scholarly inteT<~t in Ravenna has exploded. ll erore we bcgin to examine Ravenna's history and monuments, it is useful to un derstand the way that these have been described and modified over the centuries, because ea rly historians and artists provide us with crucial information, particularly about monuments, inscriptions, documents, and other sources that no longer survive.
Premodern Historiogrllphy T he historiography of Raven na hegins with Agnellus. T he "'ay he presented his city and its history has heavily influenced our understandin g of Ravenna down to the present. Historians' pr<:occupatiol1 ",ith Ravenna's riY.llry with Rome, as described abo"e, origin ~tcs with Agnellus. Jndeed, it is hardly possible to consider any aspect of larc antiquc R3"enna without
;
INTRODUCTION
reference to what he had to sayan the subject. Cerrainly he is t he person who construct~~ a past for the city on the Oasis of its splend id monuments. Agnellus is Our source o f chmnologi~'31 infonnation for many of the Sur\~ving buildings as well as our only source for the many buildings that no longer SUM"C, J\'iorl'Over, his preSCflution o f figures such as Galla Placidia, Thooderic, and Archbishop Maximian has influcnced all subsequent ideas about them. Although his text was not widely LTlown outside of Rawnna unti l the nineteenth cencury, we can trace its influence from the tenth cenrury on in texts wrinen by Ravennate authors, or by authors who camc to Ra,'cnna and consulted its archive . ' i There is no external evidence for Agnellus's existence; everything we know about him comes from the llassages in his &ok ofPontiffi 6fth. Church of Rtn'.,mll (Uber p<Jntijimfis euksiae Rnvt1l"atis, U'R) in which he tells us som~'thing ahout himself. AgncJlu.~ was hom circa Soo imoonc of the leading families of the city. H e becamc a high-ranking priest in the Ravcnnate church, and ~cms to have bcen acti"ely imulved in lUnstruction and maintenance of antiquities and monuments in thc sec. Agncllus wrOic thc LPR in the 8305 and ~os,l l The work consists of a biography of each bishop of Ravenna from the time of the co!wersion to Christianity roAgnellus's own day. D epending on the sources available to him, Agnellus tells uS about the historical background, artistic and architectural parronage, JXllitieal and/or ecclesiastica l controversies, and other notable events for each bishop. The tc:ct was dirC<."tly modeled on the U,," fJwtifoalis of Rome, a hiStory o f the papacy that by the early ninth century was widely known throughout Europe. One of Agnellus's main preoccupations was the riva lry between the sees of Ravenna and Rome, and he deliberately structured his text as a response to the Roman version of [ta lian history. '· AgneUus was also preoccupied with the rights o f the clergy in the face o f oppression by bishops. Both of these themes oolor his accounts of ind ividua l bishops and of the hiStory and monuments assodatl~1 with them. Oncof the issues that must bcaddrcsscd when using the LPR fOr studying Ravenna '5 past is that it was wrinen s~"\'eral cenrurics after the most exciting evenlS. Agnellus was wel l aware of the impact of Ravenna's material remains; indeed, he exploited it througbout his te~t as evidence that Ravenna '5 history waS equal to that of Rome. \Vhat he tells us, however, is not so much what actually tooL: place in Ravenna in the fifth tbrougb eighth centllries, as bow these things werc perceived in the ninth centllry, and this distinction is not often appreciated by modem readers of the text. Despite more than twO centuries of arehaeoJogiC31, historical, and an historical investigation, it is remarkable how linle we know about late antique Ravenna, and how much our ideas arc shap",d by Agnellus's al"<.Ullm of this period. It is t\gnellus who tells us that Ravcnna was made the capital of Ita ly;
HISTORY OF SCHOLARSHIP ON RAVINNA
that lIishop Ursus built the cathedral; thaI Galla Placidia, Theoderic, and Arch bishop Ma,imian monumenlali,,~-d the city; and that the struggle with the popes consumed the seventh and eighth centuries. Since Agnellus's staR1nents match the r~1nains of churches and \\'ails, they continue 10 providt tht basic outline for Rawnna 's hi,wry. Agnellus him>clf us~'(1 as wurccs a chronide or annal attributed to Archbishop Maximian, the semlOns of Bishop Peter Chrywlogus, and a few documents; he otherwise looked at bui ldings and inscriptions (many of which arc now lost), and rdk-d on hcarj.ay current in the ninth century. Although today we have infonnation from archaeology and bener access 10 more historical te~ts., we do not know much more than Agncllus did, After Agndlus, little else was writlen about the city of Ravenna until the thirtlocnth cenrnry. 7 Biographies of wme indi,'idual bishops and saints were produced starting in the tenth century, often taken more or less exaerly from the Ll'R; there was an increase in production of these biographies in tht thirteenth ("<'nmry.'~ In addition to hagiography, there wcrt severa 1other texIS produced in this period that are interrelated, and probably related to the manuscript of the LPR that remained in the archive. In the first half of the thirteenth century, the list of bishops in the LPR was brought up to date, with short entries written for each bishop, based on the U'R. In the J !60s, twO works were writlt'n ahout Rawnna's history. One, the Ardifulllio auillllis Rllumnne, is a short text describing the foundation of Ravenna at the time of Noah and its SubSC
,
8
INTRODUCTION
between !lIO an d 1205. After 1205, the en oi es become more frequent, but are concerned now with the seculaT poUtiol history of t he city, although 9:lme major building acti\~ties are descrihed, such as the reconstruction o f the nave of the Ursiana cathedral in 13 r 4- It is thus not possible to rcronstroct from the Cb~o"ic,. m uch infonnation about the condition of the city in this period, as could Oe done for the nimh century. From the fift~'enth cenrury on, anti quarian historians of Italy bega n to include infonnation abou t Ravenna in thcirworks. About 1413 the LPR was l"Op;ed, alung with mOSt of the other historical texts, into one volume, which toda y is housed in the Bibliotcca Estensc in Modena; all earlier manuscripts ufthe tc:: Ertm.i. manuscrillt that he had found in his liurary. His colleague and successor at the library, L. A. " Iura tori, who initiatl-d the series Rmnn Itl1/i[l1rum Scriptrn"es, IlIIblisbed Bacchini's ed ition along with most of the other texts from the Codtx Esrtmis in two volumes of his new scries. A new interest in late antique works of art also now l>t:l"alne (>vident. G. G. Ciampini's V" rrl1 mCilimmru of ,690-9 include.:! drawings of many of
HISTORY OF SCHOLARSHIP ON RAVINNA
!{a,'enna 's mosaics, im'3.lua ble evidence of their lIre restoration state. Antonio Zirardini, a Ra"ennate lawyer and historian, published a work entitkd Drgli Ilnticbi rdijizii profllni di RITVfflnll in 1762; he also wrote a companion volume, Dr Ilntiqllis w;1'"is Rllvfflnllr ardifiriis, which was published only in 1908. '{be papyrus docu mcnts surviving in Ra\'Cn na 's archive were fi rst published in 1805 by G. Marini, in an l'(]ition that is sti ll used as a reference today, although it was largely SUpersl-ded by H. O . T jader's edition of the '95°S. Count lo. larco Fa ntuzzi, also of Ravenna and a student and colleague of Z ira rdi ni and "brini, published his six-vol ume wurk Munumfflli rllvnmali dr' uroli Ifi 711= p" {a maggiflT" partr hwfiti, containing the tem of ml-dil-val doaunl-nts in the arch episcopal archive, during the pe riod ISo 1-+ Finally, the eighteenth century saw attempts at restoration in se"eral of th e city's surviving monuments, most notllbly at San Vita lc and Sant'A]Xlllinare in Clas.<;e.
M odern Historiography of RnVetl1lh D es]lite the increasing scho larly interest in Ravenna's monuments, by the early ninetl'Cnth century many of them "'ere completely destroyed or in a very fragile State. Under Na ]Xlleon the city Ix'Came part of the Italian Republic (I 796- I 8'4), and many o f its monasteries were dissol"e d; some churches were del'OnS<.><;rated, uth ers were simply abandoned. At the same time, the increasi ng interest in antiquities. and the new discipline of archaeology, led to t he first attempts to uncover Ravenna's lost past through exca vation .'1 As far hack as the late eighteenth century, local antiquarians were ilwcstigating underground rema ins, and this activity continued into the nin eteenth century; con,ouctio n of the railroa d started in 188 I, revealing many ancicnt remains, especially in Classc.,8 The rel igious monuments and mosaics al50 recti",,<:1 attentio n. Fili ]lpo L ancia ni and Alessandro Ranuzzi, enginccrs emplored br the state depan:ment of civi l engineering, condu cted excaVlltions and restoratio ns of somc of the buildings betwccn 1859 and 1897. From the 18505 to the 18705 a Roman artist narnL-d Felice Ki beI was conunissioned by thc mun icipal gO"ernmentof Ravcnna to restore the surviving mosa ics; he worked in the "mausoleum of G alla Pl acidia," the Orthodox Baptistery, Sant'Apoll inare Nuo\'O, Sant'ApoHinarc in Classe, and San Vitale, and his work was highly controversial, both ror the techniques he used and for the iconographical dctails that he restored. '9 Mosaic restora tion wo rk by the Ra,'cnnatc mosaieist5 Carlo Novelli and G iuseppe Zampiga continued into the IB?os. The Musco Naziona1c of Ravenna was csuhlished in 1885 , with its original ,,)lIcction representing that of the C amaldolensian monastcry of Sant'Apollinare in C lasse, housed in
9
,.
INTRODUCTION
"''''''''ar
tOe bu;l ding> formerly bdonging to the a h~; u.«l ,he Soprim<"cl"",• • ; ,\looum1.1. the Ii... ",do ""... u in It. ly. onder tl1< dif ond Antiqui n<> in 19"'>," !OCci', vi~Of'l ~... to "''',... IU,'eruu'. Ilncirm m"num ..", to tb<'<."fctiQm.nO OorontK'''' Iud to be f'<1""'~ -" H. immetlj".iy ;niuue.! ~'OI< Z.mpig>. A1 ...... odro Au.>.roni. ,nd hi. p< Gen~ •• m,or"out< monum,,"" were .nd te>tvtw. G"roI. 0\.."...'" I"'blkltioo of th. """Its of many of the>< pro;.ru duro ing ,I\< 1><'";00 from ,hoot '9'0 until the '93os, ' M Itiro hi""",I! ,,,,,, • ..... tl>< ""bl;<>tioo of me eight-vol","" , \ / _ , ; , IItW ~ dti """.",' .Ii (19J<>-7). ~'i>irn ron",;n d",~'ings m>rintrndcnz> P'" i Beni ,\rcheoIogici d.trEmili. Komogm (An::h>«lIogyl .nJ the 'iof>r\n,rn.Jen .. p<1' i &ni Ardi,,,,,,,,,;ci,, f"" iI P"""'gg;o .nd Envirooment)." Ricci and Gerob pb)'ed an .ro,~ role in ,,;m"ioting other hi",lric.1 WQ«: of '[1,oodork" """"',,'' of S.nt'ApoIlin"" NOOI'Q took j>I.e< .. ,~''''''' ,~.nd 19'~' " In 19'-1 the Ii.... ,~" b..,;d""of . ne" edition of the LPR. "I; ted by Ale ... ndro T coti- 1I..""",i, ' pp<,,,,d intI>< n.... .... ie< of ,he R""",, 11.li"""" SMptorn. 'This ediOoo ~' .. """,", oomj>l",ed. but h,; "'",. i..... infl"",,'i ,l; it "",,,in, <"rn~'" _ vsuited in m.;o. d .m.ge to the """"'" of , ,," ('.;.,.,~nru E""gelis" .nd minor do m_ og< '" I..il ding>. Tbe Jes, ruct;"n ...... It"'i in ,n in'.,... "'"'I"ign ,of """,,,,tion .nd ",,-.000 the W:lr. These clforu w<,ded by n..... gr<"'1'" ofr"",.rchen. ..-.m< Ioc>I .od """" from "I"""'her<. In portic ..b " f..-u lty . nti ..00""1> of the: Univ.,.iti. di ~. begin to j>I.y • p«>'ini, prof....,.. ofChristi,n .. ,-It~., boSOn "'","""", , n ,n" .,1"",roten«, the
"tIl. ....
_,.nO 1,,<,
W""
"">UD
'''''''''teoJ
R.,,,,,,,,,
n",.,...
."n_
'000."
by,..,
0<"'"
.ncr
c....
1-1 [STO RY 0 1: SC H O LARSHIP ON RAVENNA
Culturil mll'Arte RII V("I/{If~ t 8bl/lfillil (C4RB), which brought together archaeologists, art historians, and historians from Italy and abroad . The proceedings of each conference we re published in volumes of the same name; the last conference took place in 1998 (vol. 44). Bovini fonl1(led and was tbe director of the Istituto di Amichit~ Ra\'"ennati e Bizamine, associated with the university but housed in the Casa Traversa ri in Ra\'enna, which continues to serve as a c('mer for researchers studying Ravenna. reli:r: Rm)(llllll and C1RB published numerous important studies of Ravenna's history an(1 monuments, I.lUt there were no syntheses of the material, except in books aiJlled at tou rist~ and popular audiences. The task of producing a scholarly history of late antique Ravenna was underta ken oy Friedrich nTilhelm Deidunann, a German scholar based at the D eutsches Archaologisc.hes Institut in Rome. In 1958 he published a collee.rion o f photographs o f art, architecture, and sculpture that he caned Friibcbristlitbr Bllllft'll f/lld IHosllik;:ll VOlt RflVt'"llll(l . The accompanying oook, R(fv emlll,
di
HfluptSffldt ,lei ..piilflmiJ.'ell .41'clldlfllldes, Ges,bifb,c lmd i\1(JlIflllImtc ( 1969),
COJlt
"
Key :
*
Known or excavated walls Presumed walls presumed ancien! water Archaeological s~e
1 Via O'Azeglio 2 Banea Popolare 3 Ex orti Baccineni 4 Largo Firenze 5 · Palace of Theoderic' 6 UPIM (Via di Roma) 7 Santa Croce 8 Porta Cybo 9 Padere Chiavichetta, Classe 10 San Severo, Classe 11 Padars Marablna 12 St. Probus
\,
. __....., ,?-
=-'. ,. C....-cnt
['I. n of R.<eTlJl •• o"rl ili d "' i,h ,he L.. eontique ...... I,
.00 ,,·"Crw:l)~. withm.;o..n;h. e<>Iogic>l
,'res
--,---
SOME AIl.C HAE OLOGICAl CONSIDEIl.AT IO NS
collaborative stUitiCS on the "mausoleum of Galla Placidia" (1996), San Vi tale (1997), and San Michele iI/ Ajri(im) (W07). Fina lly, the Fon(lnione Centro Italiano di Studi sull'Alto Mediocvo at Spoleto held a confe rence on late anti<jue Ra\'enn~ in 2004, whose proceedings were pll blished in two volu mes as RI/VC IIIIII: dll (I/pitl//r imperil/Ie" capit"/I' ffilTadt'. T here has as yet been no sustained scholarly treatment of Ravenna in English , and this book is imclHletl to address that void. An.:hacologica l and restora tion work continucs apace in Ravenna, an(1 given the nllmbcr of questions about the latc 3ntique city that arc still unanswered, new in fO rmation will no douht necessitate revision of the historica l profi le o f Ravenna in the decades to cOllle.
Some Archaeological Considerations Givcn the shortagc of Contemporary wTitten sources for latc antique Ravenna, archaeology provides crucially important information about the city's topography, e(.'()Ilomics, and population . Before World War II, most excavation was directed toward Ravenlla's churches, and to large structures that could be linked to buildings mentionet! in the LPR; indee(l, associntion o f archaeological sitt'S with Agnellus's text ('ontinues down to today. But, e~pecially in the latter part of the twentieth century, other sitl!s, representing private houses, manufacturing and warehouse fJeilities, and walls, h ~rbors, and othcr man-made fea tures have come to the tore. allowing \IS [(J gain a much more complete picture of life in the late antique city (for a map showi.ng major sites, sec Fig . I). Beca use many of these sites will be mentioned in the cha pters that tollow, it is useful for us to understand some o f the factors that have ('olltributctl to Ravenna's archaeologica l profile. is Ravenna's ground level has been sinking fu r centuries, and this has raise{1 challcngcs for those interested in digging up the past. T hc land surround ing R,1\'cnna is subject to two gC'Olllorphological processes. First, Ravenna is located in an allm'ial ba,in; the rivers and streams that flow into it hring sediment with them . O ver time, except in periods in which it has been deliberately pre\'entt'll, th is sedimentation has filled in swamps, marshes, and lagoons, eventually creating new sol id groull(\ along the shores of the sea. This is why Raven na, tounded as a coastal port in the Ro man l}t:riod , ro{lay sits 9 km from the Adriatic coastline. T he sedimentation along the shore also contri butes to the second major process th~t has affected Ravenna, namely the subsidence, or progressive lowering, of the ground level, which has been calculated at approximately 16- l 3 em per celltury'>(, These [VIO Jlrocesses, along with the continu()u~ occupation, destructioll, spoliation, and rebuildi ng o f the dty. h;l\Ie produced ;\ sl'f'Jtigra phy in which
'3
'.
INTRO D UCTI O N
material from the Roman rcpuu1ic:ln period is found 4-f! 111 below the CUTrent grounillevei, Roman imperial materi~l is 3- 6 m below current ground k'vcI, and fifth- to sixth -ccnturr material is 2-4 III below current ground
lerel. with grcatvari~hil i ty fr0111 place to place within the cityY Morl'{wcr, Ravenna has aI ways had a watery environment. Although the swamps of the Roman period aTe no longer much in evidence, the level of groundwater is relatively high. Even Agnellus noted cases ill which things buried in previ-
ous eras were covered in water, and today most featun:s that li e morc than a few meters below the ground surface a;c envelopel] in grou!1l[watcr. ,lj As a result, pre-Roman and Roman remains 3rc sparse ill the archaeological remrd and hard to excavne, and some sites, especially chosc excavate
RAV EN NA AND LATE AN TI Q1.I E ART AND ARCH ITE CTU RE
the Istituto was reorganized as parr of the Diparrimcnto di Archcologia, with a specific unit ba sed at Ravenna, the Fac(Jiti di Conservazione ,lei Beni cultura li (Serle di Ran'nna ). Its director, Andrea Augenti, has initiated a new Sl.'ries of excavations in t:ollaiJorat10n with thc Soprintcnclcnz~. ~' A series of residents of Ra\'enna with historical and archaeological expertise have worked alongside, and often in collaboration with , the Soprintendenza and the University. In partiC1Jlar, many of the excan· tions of Ravenna's churches halle been conducted by these scholar$. Mario Mazzotti, a Ravennate priest, ht,'came involved with archaeological cxcavation in the late 193 os. He obtained a degree in Christian Archaeology, and served as thl.' diret:ror of the archiepiscopal archive and museum in Ravenna from the 1950S until his death in 1983' Nlazzotd excavated and published extensively on Ravenna's history al1(l monuments, most notably Sant'Apollinare in Ciasse, the Arian llaptistery, and Solll Frant:esco. In the 19605 and 197°5 Giuseppe Cortesi (head orthe Bibliot1;.'t:
Ravenna and the Historiography of Late Antique Art and Architecture Imagery from Ravenna is central to our cont:eptiolls of late antiquity; it is not surprising, for example, that mOS;lit:S from S;lJl Vitale arc featured on the con:r o f the encydopedic Lflt~ Alltiqllitr A Guide 10 Ib~ Portd,lfSimi l/furid:¥> Ravenna's monuments have alway, been fUlHlamental to studies of late antique art and architCCfure, both because they resulted from patronage at the highest levels of society anli because they are remarkably well preserved. Ravenna's slln,i"lng mosaics from the firth and sixth centuries oumumlier those of any other cit~" while Ravenna's political an(1cultural links with Const;lntinoplc and the east IllC;}1H that artists ;}nd ;Jrt:hi tet:ts
'5
.6
INTRO D UCTI O N
we re inA ucnccd by a vcry wide ra n ge of styles. Raven na thus occupies all impOrtant place in I::vtry c hro noll)gic~l narra tive I)f medieval and Byzantine art, and R,\I'cnna's mo numents arc cited in analyses of style. technique, iconogra phy, viewer rccl,'ption, colo r th(..'Ory. 311{\ mally other su blccts of art historical interest. Questions raised by the study of the art and arc hitecture about construction tech niques: building layout; architecnlral, sculptural,
anti artistic style; and iconography - also shed light
Oil
late antique eco-
nomics, communication, theology. (..'(;dcsiastical organiza tion, litu rgy, and power politics. \Ve call usc them t() enlarge emf picture of life in late antique R;1\'Cnna. In this book, the lil.lrviving mon\lments wi ll be trcned individually in the context of the hislOriC:
.,
RAVENN ,\ AND LATE AN TI Q1l E ART ,\ N D ARCHITECTURE
Tllbi jillili. Musco l.
N "1:i o MI~,
lla...:",," (ro ur\(",,")'
Soprinl<,,,Jenza pe r i Ikni Archilcltol1 ici e P.,es;ol:gislici .Ii R, ...enn~ IMi IHC ITALlAI)
~hool,"
which borrowed from a variety of traditions and remained influential for centuries."s Nevertheless, the contrast between East and \.vest has continued to playa role in art historical discussion of Ravenna (lawn to the present': Dddunanll was more inclined to emphasize Eastern models with ~Wes rern" modificadons, while Eugenio Russo has argued in favor of a greater n.'Cognition of western motlds, but insists that the major J ustinianic buildings arc the product of a master bu ildcr frOIll Constantinoplc ."~ The <-"(Inclusions drawn from this type of formal analysis can be problematic. There is a long tradilion in \ ,Vestern scholarship of depicting the East as degenerate, which was Strzygowski's point; lraliall and other scholars elevated the '"(IIllunit,IS of Christian art for nationalistic reasons.50 But, as J as Elsner has pointed out, if those grand narratives are removed, fortnal analysis appears to lose much of its force Y Models and borrowings must then be understoo(! in their specific historical contexts, either as ~ymbolie of tl1e aspirations of patrons and designers, or as evic!ence of trade and artistic practice ofthc past. In any given case, answers are proposed, but given the complete absence of documentation for this subject, such explanations must remain hypothetical. Let us examine Wtlle architectural examples. Most of the churches in Ravenna from the fifth century anc! beyond make usc of impost blocks (pu/viui), or truncated pyramidal stone blocks plnced between each capital and the springing of the arcade (see Figs. Il, 'W, 81, and 9l). The use of impost blocks was an architecrura I innovation that became widely used, particularly in Greece and the eastern Mediterranean, during the fifth century. Ravenna's buildings arc often cited as lhe earliest examples of using impost block~ in the west, and while early fifth-century examples are also known from Naples and Rome, only at Ravenna were impost blocks used
.8
INTRO D UC TI O N
so L'Ollsistcntl)' in later ccnturics.5' Uh:wisc, most of Ravenna's churches had apses that wen: polygonal on the extl::ri(Jf anll semicir(:ular on the interior, ~nothcr feature known from Constantinople and the eastern l\Icditcrram'an in rhe fifth ccnnlTY, but rare in Italy. On the other hanll, IllOSt of the domes and half domes in Ral'enna 's churches wefe cOlIsrrucred using fllbi jitfili, or hollow ceramic tubes approximately 0 .10 111 long that we(e
imerlinket! all(1 arranged in eOllccntric rings. held together with cement
(Fig. 2). This tC,.'f,;hniquc was widely used in Roman architecture of Italy and the west, hut dill not spread to the eastern Mcditcrr3tlCan.,' l
Taken together, these three features arc seen as typically Ravenna!c. But what do!.'s this combination of feanlres Ill!.'an? Cl!.'arly, a variety of architectural ideas were being combined ill llew ways. T his could mean thnt e"J,tern nrchitects and/or craftsmen were brought to Ravenna to ouilll the great churches of the lIew imperial capital, either be('au~e such craftsmen did not exist in Ravenna, or to lend Constal1til1opolitanlu~tcr to the Ravcnnatc structures, These maSters then would have adopted somc local technill oes. Or were the illll)Ost blocks and polygonal apses foreign tcchniques adapted by loc~1 masters, and if so, why? In the case of Illarbh: sculpture, it can be shown nO[ only that sculptur3l techniques and styles were de rived from Constantinople, but that the marble itselF originated in the eastern Mediterrnnean , which proves that there was an intel"t~st in Ravenna in high-status art from the east. :4 ArchaeolQgica l evidence shows that Ravenna's ports carri('d on a busy trade in wine, oil, and other goods with both N orth Africa and the eastern Mediterranean , so clearly the city was fairly cosmopolitan, At the same time, links with Rome, Aljuileia, and espocially .M ilan were stroog, aod there arc many similarities of architccru.tal form and IledicatiUtl between these cities abo. \Voultl these featu res have impressed pt.-op!e as being typically eastern or western? Did p<,'ople notice that decuJ'ative motit~ were 1110J'e similar to Rome than to the Aegean? Tllbi fittili, for ('x
RAV ENNA AND LATE AN TI Q1.I E ART AND ARC HITE CTU RE
mon:.'Over, Ra venna's walls and churches were usually built of reused brick. Scholars {Iis~gret: over whether the uSt: (If these JPoli11 was r;ymlNlic (triumph O\'er Roman paganism, for example) or whether thcir usc simplr had to do with the availability and e:,.:pense of material s. In other words, was their use meaningfu l, or practical, or both? Did it demonstrate rhe power of the emperors to control construction of pl'eexisting build ings, or the power of the church to demolish them? Or, by the time Ravenna 's buildings were tonstructed , were Roman ,fpO/ifl simply considered de 7'ig lleur for impressive public huildings? The beaut)' ami com plexity of Ra ven n,l 'S sculpture and mosaics ha\'c Icc! scholars to attempt to elucidate the meaning o f the images presentl.'{l there, a stud y known as iconography. Frequently, studies of individual monuments havt: arguell fo r one "real" iconogra phic nH:an,ing, presumably the meaning th at was intell/led by its creators or patrons. More recently, scholars have recogni7,ed that in late antique art, images may not have been intended to mean just one thing, but may have been intended to evokc multiple meanings and associations. As H enry NTagu ire has pointed out, early ChriStian I.'xegesis was based on the (..'o ncept that any given Biblical passage might be interpreted in several different ways. If Christian exegetes understOOti the \Vor
'9
'0
I NT RODUC TI O N
all of the scholarship on them w~s not practical, given the scale and focus of this book. Rather>the monuments ~re pre~ented as tangillJe sources of information about the city in which they were created, whose history they hoth n.·th.-ct and hdpcd to shape. Through thei r 1>C211ty and complexity WI.' can still todar experience Ravenna , ifonly in fragments, as did its inhabitants 1,;00 years ago.
CII A PTE R Two
ROMAN RAVENNA
The Origins of Ravenna The main feature that determined the hi~tory of Ra"cnn~ in antiquity was
its changing hydrological situation. 1 T ooay Rave nna lics 9 km in lallrl from the sea, but in the prehistoric and Ro man periods itW;1S located directly on the Adriatic coast, at th e southern edge of the delta of the Po river. The Po (in Latin, f>(I(IIlr) is the longest river tn Italy, Howing west to east through a river basin that contains many of northern Italy's m OS t important cities. The water<:ourses of the Po network have changed dramatically in the past •• 500 years, sometimes naturally and sometimes because of human intervention. In the Ravenna area, st:dimcntarion and subsidence have concealed me earliest courses of the river and its hranches; reconstructions of the network before the era of modem 11l3p5 is hypothetical , based on descri ptions by anciem and medieval authors and e.'I:3l1lination of settlements, bridges, canals, and other evidence of human illlcraction in the past. ' Ancient author~ include Ravenna ill the riverine network o f the Po, al1(l most of thcm speak of Ravcnna 's environlllent as marshy; it seems dear that, fr0111 its earliest days, the site of Ravenna was a pateh of dry land in a mostly watery landscape. ' According to Pliny the Elder, in the first century AD the southernmost branch of the Po entered the Adriatic at the city of Spina, which is apprm:illlatdy 15 kill tu the north of Ra\'enna:! To the north of Spina were marshes and lagoons. known to Pliny as the "se\'ell seas" (septclII .Maritl), and other river branches e'-1:ended to the south in the direction o t' R a\'e nna. ~ A large lagoon, separated from the sea by large, sandy duncs, e,-isted to the smIth and ~'est of Ravcn na's site. Several rivers and canals emptied into the lagoon. including the Lfl1lfOllf from the west, perhaps the Vatrcllu s from the northwcst, and certainly the Bidclltc, the Ronco, and the !\-lolltone from the 'jOuthwest. The exact configurations of the rivers, lagoons, marshes, and (,,
RO MAN RAVENNA
Ravenna, c. AD 200
":......:,ro :::...____...::; 5!Xl m lighthouse?
I,•
Adriatic Sea
port ?
(cemeteri!tS)
Harbor I lagoon
Classe
3. Mopshow-
in the prehistoric and early Roman periods, the site of Ravenna consisted of
ing lb"cnn3 in thcRom3n
larger ancl smal ler pieces of laml surroumlec] by water, and separated from thc seacoast by a lineoflargc, sandy, coastal dunes. Small groups of people und oubtedly inhabited this region far back into
iml""riol p"riod. "",.AD,oo
prehistory, bur pre-Roman arehacologieal evidence is very fragmentary .i Bits and picccs or Etruscan objccts dating back perhaps to thc sixth or fifth century Be have been discovered in Ravenna, as well as pottery from Greece and from ncighboring parts: of Italy dating betwecn thc fifth and
TH E O RIGINS 0 1: ]l.AVENNA
the third Centuries BC ~ From thc fi fth ccnUJry Be on, there were proba bly settlements among the ri\-ers and cana ls of the area, perhaps even by peoples o f di fferent ethnic origins.'} \"'hat we know alxnlt the early history of northeast Iral" collles from sc.'Htered references [Q the region by Greek and Roman authors, and from archaeology. «I As far back as the m id- ~ nd millenniu m BC. inhabitallfs of Greece hegan traIling with those of the Adriatic coast in Italy. Classical authors gave a variel)' of rather nonspc-cific names to these Italian peoples, who do not emerge from historical ouscurity until the sixth century He, when the Etruscans, Venctians, and Um brians developcd into ordered political and ('uIOlraI111lits that were recognizahle to Greek authors. Celts from north of the Alpsalso began to settle in Italy north of the Po in the la te nfth century BC, leading the Romans to label the region Cisalpine Gau l ("Gaul on this side of the Alps"). The origins of Ravenna were a mystery even to the Greeks and Roman s, and our earliest textual Stmn:cs for the city (late only to the first century BC. " CI;lssical authors disagreed about Ravenna's o ri gins: according to the first ccnUlry AD historian Strabo, who was usi ng Greek ethnogr
"
'.
RO MA N RAVEN NA
ideas abou t the defense of italy, Jnd after the Romans fina lly dcfc:ncd the
Carthaginians, they extenJc(\ their hegemony all the way along the Allriatic coastline, founding the city of Aq uilcia in dll Be. At the same rime, the cconomit" network ~ Iong thl,' Adriatic emst was also changing. Spina h ad been founded brGreeks in the later sixth celHury Be and since then it had served as t he maior Adriatic port for the Po rivcr hasin .'iI Diffit-ult political circumstances, first in Greece in the fourth
century Be and then in italy, partially disruptc(\ Spina's trading networks, but it was prohably the silting up of its harbor in the mid-third century Be th:n led to Spin:l 's ultim:ltc decline. '9 Ravenna in the third century had riverine 3('CCSS to the Po, a brgc na Ol r~ 1 harooron thl,' Ad ri~tic, and dry land on which to build a city. These were the right conditions for a cOlllmerci~1 port, and thcy led to thc construction of the first fo rti lied settlcmCll{ at Ra venna.'"
The Republican City R~v enn~ 's late antique w~ lls follow an irregular plan, but the southwest corner incorporatcs three sides of a rt:Ctanglt:. Scholars havc long assumed tha t the rectangular cornel' reproduced the outl ine of the original Roman cit)' (Fig. 3), since a rectangular plan sueh as this, with a street gri(\ aligned with two main rOJds intersecting in the center. was commonly used in newl y fou nded Roman colonies and etti es!' The city, usually referren to as tht: QPpidllm or as Rm'Wl/fl Ijllfld/'!l({/, until rece ntly was thought to h.we been fou nded in the first century Be by the emperor Augustus.:: In 1980, a rchaeologisr.~ working at the '--'O nStruCtlon site of the Banca POllOlan: (sec Fig. I), along the eastern line of the rectangle, revealed the J'emains of a city wall that was mlleh earlier tha n anyone hall thought, with pottery dating to the second half of the third century BC.'> The wall's remai ns werc found 7.50-+75 meters below the current ground le\'el, and consisted of a stretch of w
TH E REPUBLI C AN C ITY
whether the Padenna ;In(1 the jillmisdlullf LII1Jl1/lle 1"0r111e\1 the boundary on this side, Or whether there was a waU on one Or other side of the watercourses. " ~ These two waterways played an im(lOrtant role in the definition of th!.' sir!.', and by the first n~nmry Be they were sllppk'rncnted by a new canal, thefo.I:J11 LII"';SII, which emered the oppiduw from the west and also Rowed into the Padenna. 'Q "\Ill}' was this city wall ouilr, an(1 by whom: Unfortunately, in the absence of any textual sources, we can only hypothesite about what was going on in the area at this time. Ravenna seems to have lain just outsi(le the ag" Glllli"'fconqucred by Rome in 295; in 206 the Umbrians ofSarsina allied themselves with Rome, and it has been suggesterl that the scnl!.'ment of Ravenna became at this poilU an all ied city (rr.liws forJrmtll )YJ Another suggestion is that the settlenH!Il[ was fortified in the context of 1-lalUlibal's invasion of Italy in ! 18 Be y v. Manzdli n()[es that it is likely by this time that R;l\'ellna was becoming an important c0ll1t1H'rd~1 center that llccde(1 to be protccted from pirates)' F. Rcbecchi reads Strabo's statement that ~Rimi l1i , like Ravcnna , is an ancient colony of the U mbri, but both of thcm have n .'Ceived also Roman (;010nie5," to mean that Ravenna was founded by colonisrs from Rimini. H Rimini. which h;ld been fou nded ill 168 BC was linked di rectly to Rome b}, the construction of [he ViII Fillmillin , and in the 180s BC Ri mini was linke{1 to Other Roman colonies of Piacenz.a and Cremona by the Vi,1 /Im/ili'l. Ravl!nna wa~ not dirl!ctiy on any of the main roads, although thl're was a roadway that cOllnected the city to the Viii 1I<'lIIi/ill. It was not until 1 3 2 He that.the Romans built the Vi" Popiliil, \vhich linked Ravenna directly with Rimini to the south and Adria to the north, perhaps a sign of (hc Ra venna 's incrl'asing im porta ncc. '.1Tbe Viii POpili11 mUSt hal'e rUIl somewhere near thc town, but it is not known whctht'r it woultl have gonc through the oppidlllll or to the C;lst along the line of the dllnes. )j In sum, the wall show~ that a permanent community had forme{1 at Ravenna b~' thc late second century Be, hut it is nevertheless strange that fhe city was not ment.ioned in any witten sources \lntil a hundred years later. Repuhl ican R;lvenna had more than JUSt wall s. Material from the V ia D'Azeglio excalration with third-cenrur)1 BC pottery includes a drainage system on wooden piles, indicating a planned Roman setd ement, j6 and bricks identical to those found in the carly wall were fou nd at the base of the sewer system foun(1 in the nt'ighooring Via Morigia excavation);' The only building that can defi nitely be dated to the republic;lI1 period, specifically to the second century BC, is the atrium hO\l5e found in the Via D 'Azeglio e~:cavat ion, with it'i polychrome mosaics representing the myth of the battle betwcen the Argonams Pollux and Amictls}8 These fragments show that th.e appidulII of Ravenna had a street grid, a sewer system, and some relatively c!aoorate houses. Other structures in the republic;}n dty seem to
.,
,6
RO MA N RAVEN NA
of loca l materials, often perishable, like rce(ls and wood, which have left few traces, but also I)ut of locally availal!Je stonc. J\I Other fragmentary objects from the Roman republican period have heen tound to the cast of the oppidlllll, in the area of the lan.'r "Palace of Theoderic," suggesting that buildings, perhaps even a temple, were also COllstructed in this sector nearer the sea. ~ o It has Ilot been possible to determine whether an eaStern settlemenr existed earlier than the constrllction of the oppidmJl, o r (.X)[1tcmporary with ttY Ravenna first appears in Roman historical sources in the (:ontC;\1" of the Social anti Civil warS of the first centu ry BCi' Plutarch mentions that a marhle st~nJC of Gaim i\oJarius still e.xisted in the first century AD in Ravelllla. ~~ The Roman orator C icero in 56 BC described one Publius Caesiu5 as having bL"Cn , before the end offhe Social War in 90 BC, " ... a Ravennate from the federated people:'+! 'fhe implication is that Ravenna was an allied city before 90 BC, and tha r even in Cicero's day Ravenna held federate stan IS, although the city would be raised to the rank of a ROmll1l7!l1l11ici{li/l1Jl sometime after 49 BC.~ j Julius Cacsar famously stayed at Ravenna thl.' night before he took his a rmy across the R\lbicon to start th" Civil \Nar in 49 BC..;tI Suetollius repom that during the course of that day, Caesar had gom: to the theater and inspecte(1the site of a proposed gladi:norial school.47 Those references represent the extent of u'ritten information that we have about Ravenna in tht: repuolican period: a city that stoo(1 on the fringes of the Roman world, integrated culturally ami politically into the Roman sphere of influence. h3VC oecn cormfUl:tcd OUt
Classe: The Roman Imperial Harbor and Fleet Roman authors ttll us that Ocravian, 13tcr known 3S AUbruStllS, dt:cidell to establish a permanent navy for the Roman state. Two bases for this new navy were chos"n, one for the western !vlediterranean at Misenum on th" B~r of Naples, and the other, for the east, at Ravenna. ¥! T he re~~ns for this decision seem clear: Octavian had been involved ill two major military campaigns that involved naval action, one against the pirate-Beet of Sextus Pompe)', which culminated in the Battle of Naulochus in 36 BC, and one against Mark Anthony that conchllied with the Batde of Actium in 31 Be. Scholars Iichate the date of the fleet's foundation, hut it happened sometime between 35 and 11 BC.~? For the next 300 years Ravenna would house on" of Rome's main naval bases, which would have imporramconst:ljuences for the city. First an(1 most important, Ravenna's harbor had to be developed into a facility that could hold, repair, and provision the ships of the fleet. Ravenna 's
TH E ROMAN I MPERIAL H ARBOR AN D ]:LE ET
'7
harbor faci lities must have been del·clope{] already in rhe republican period;
the historian Appian says that in 39 Be Octavian "hrought war-ships from Rave nna and an army from Gaul" and "ordered the building of new triremes at Rome and Ravenna ," implying that Rave nn a was already a nava l sratiQn Y' Octavian recognized tha l Raven na was ideally situated to l'OlHrol piracy in the Adriatic, which \\'as a threat to O ctll\'ia n's imperia l peace, and that the lagoon CQuid h~ developed into a facility capable of holding the entire Adrinic fleet Y Thus, utH\er O ctal'ian, the harbor was enlarged and stahilized. Pliny the Elder in the first centllfY AD Ilescribcs the large canal, known as the jQ.wI ;!lIgm'flf, wh ich joined the Po river to the harbor:" Tllt;re is no ril'er ]the Pol known to receil'e a 1art.~r im;rt,jse thm this in so shon a sp~ce; so 111llch so indeed th~t it is impelled onwards by tllis I' ast body of wate r, anJ. in,'a,lin g the lan ll, flHln s ,Ieep lOhannds in its ('oun;c: henn' it is that, although a portion of its stream is Jr:lwn olT river.; anJ can"ls lx tween Ral'elllu, ;)nJ Ahinum, fo r u space of I ~ o m iles. still, 31 th e SIXH where it d.isc:h"l'gcs the \'3st body of its "'''tel'S, it is s~ id to form scven Sl:ns. By th e Augllsmn C:1l1aIIAlIglls/" fOSSIl i til(' 1'0 is ca rried [0 Ravenn", at which phlCC it is called Ihe PaJusa. b,wing runner!)' oorne tbe name of MeSSOlniclIS. ' l1,e nearest momb to this spot fonlls the <;xrensi",,; port known as Ihn ofValrt:nus. where Claudius Caesa r, on h is triumph o"cr the Britons, entered the Adriatic in ,\ vc~1 that dcscrwd r.nhe r the nUlllC Qf a ""~t palace th all " ship. Th is JllQUTh. which w"s fo nllC:rly called by some the E rid'lIlian, has been Dr others styled the SI-'inctk ltIouth , from lI,t cit)' of SI-'ina. a vc ry fX'werful l-'l" c~ "hiel! formt'rly stOO
uy
The main hranch of the Po in this period was the hra nch that ra n through SpitlajH what Plinycalle<1 the Pa
,8
RO MA N RAVEN NA
by ma,sivc cement allil Illasonry embanktllcnts; 5~ 3([jaccnr to rhe IJPpidlllfl the Padenna was 50-65 m wide. A paved r()ad 9 m wide, identinell uy the CXC31'ators as the viti PQpi1i{l , fan alo ng the western bank of this canal to the north of the ciry.5s At ~ poi nt ~ I{lng the casn:m side ofthc fossa IIlIgMffl, now occupied by the Venetian fortress calted the Rocca Brancaieone, a second port was developed. open to the sea and fed by the canal, which remained in use until the fifth century AD or later.w Pliny the EI(ler nOtes that Ravetllla
had a famous lighthouse, similar to that of Ncxandria in Egypt, which is thought to have heen located to the northeast of the oppidlllll, since Agnc1lus
in the nimh century refers to this location as
~at
the lighthouse." In that
case (he lighthouse would have functio ned as a be~con tor the northeastern harbor rather than the sou thern one. 60 Tht: mnin hnrbor of Rnl'enna was located just to the south and the west of the oppidll1l1, perhaps as little ~ s 2 00 III south of the oppidlflJl's southel'll wall.6 ' Vef)' little is known of its dimensions, Of o f the Illany buildings that must have been erected all around it,6' hut a fa ir amount is known about the structures built at the mouth of the l)(lrt. A channcllecl from th ... Ad riatic into th ... harbor; the channel was 80 m long, and it widened all the ilHerior, flowing around at least two sInal! islands. G) The channel's banks wt:re strengtht:nt:d with qua}'s and wi th piles of ouilding ru bble. T he mouth leading to the sea was fol'tifie{1 with very Strong moles, ma{[e of cement, extending to the south and pl'esumably to the north . To the north the coastline on either side was then provi(lcd with ccment barrier walls, +5-5 m wide and 40 m long, to prevenr erosion. Th is canalled into the har bor where the jQSSI1 A IIgllS1I1 entered from the north, wi th the Padenna's lllouth slightly la rthcr to the west. One section of tbe harbor extended to the west, south of the city of Ravenna, while another strt'tchell to the south. Portions of the quays have been found in the excavations on Via S. Alberto in Cla~se: the earliest constructions of the Augustan port were made of large oal beams, strengthcned in the firs t century AD by large numbers of ceramic fragments, and then finally re placed wi th brick in the second century.Got 'We halle only onc piece of evidence for the size of Ravenna's imperial fleet : JOHlanes ill the sixth century quotes a tt!..'"'- hy the early thi rd-century historian Cassius Dio, now lost. tha t says there were 2 50 ships .6 ~ Because the Roman navy is much less well dC)cllmt:nted tha n rhe army, even for the imperial period, the main sources of information are funerary inscriptions thnt mention the deceased 's ship, wh ich have provided names and types of some vessels haseti at Rave nna (Fig. -{).66 The commallller of the Ravenna fleet held the title p,.,lt!f~dll," t/iw;i.,·, and was subordinate to the f/l'lIrfrnllS of the Beet at Misellum.6~ T he tourth-century N otititl DigllltllttWI mentions the "prefeCt of the Rallennatc nCCt, with responsibili ty for that cit)' of
HI E ROMAN IMPERIALI·I ARBOR AN D FLEET
'9
,+. FII"c.or), stel c
of I'ulolill s LC>1lgi -
,jic""s,,, ship builder (fobrr "";·,,Ii~) "febsse. fir~1 ~'('nrury
BCJAD. ,\lusco N,r>;;ollalc, R.:.'·cnM (coor_ 1",,1' SOI,riolen.
d" llZa pcr i IJ;.>"j .-\rchircllonici c I'ncs:tggisrid
di R~"cnnn 1,\liBAC-
ITALIAI CL:8.13· loI 95- 1 R:)
Ravenna "; this has been interpreted as meaning that the prefect of the Reef was the ci\'ilian head of government in Ra\'enn3, althOllgh such an imerpretation is controversial, because we do not know how much earlier th is siruatioll may have applied.Ok F ragrncnts of inscriptions from the first and second centuries, found both in Ravenna ami dsewhere in Italy, seem rather to indicate that Ravenna in lh e imperial period had a regular town council with magistrates.6<;I Ravenna's Reet sem its ships throughout the i\'Jediterr3ncan, as funerary inscriptions for its sailors (c/nssillri ravrlllltlfi) have been t()llllcl in me ea~[ern J\'iediterranean, the Aegean, and the Black Seas and on me Danube.''' Inscriptions from Ravenna and abroad name at least 590 people who wt;'re attached to the Ravennate Reet}' At least in the first century AD , a large percentage of the navy was made up of Dalmalians and
,0
ROMAN RAVENNA
Pannonian:;, who received Roman dti ~cllShip upon their discharge afrer twenty-six years of service':) One single inscription from the st:<:oO(I Or th ird ccnt\lr-Y lists 100 individual members of the fleet, in appa rently dcsn.~nding order of rank: c~rpentcrs (J1bri ), Ilpper-lt.·vel soldiers (hrllrjiri,1I"ji), flag bearers (vr:rillimi ), players of various kind s of horns «(Qnririm'.>, fllbit'i1les, Illidl/(lfl)t';'J), lower-level officers (mboptiolles), lind on-duty soldiers (WlflliJir,·J). It is interesting that on this inscription, all the names art: Latin,
indica ti ng perhaps a shift in the makeup of the navy. ;1 Other inscriptions mention add itional occupations associate!\ wi th the navy, indlHiing soldiers (lI/ilirl's) and thei r officers «(r1ItllriUlIf'S and 0/itioIlCS), pilots (gllhc1?l11 rort's), underpilots ( pl'orrr,fr), men who ca lied out the rhythm to the rowers ( pIIIISffI'i), lll~SterS of weapons (1I I7l1iCllsfoJrs), rep~ir personnel (1IIIlIpbyhlm), ax makers (dolal'mri), Aag beart=rs (vrxilliftl'i ). doctors (m~(lid ) . and 5criix=s (scrib/lr) of \'arious SOrts. H Some of these insniptions give the person's cognomen as ChISSiCIIS, or "mcmbcr of thc A(.'c[. ",5 The sailors of the fl cet wcrc sometimes married (a lthough thcy wcre not legally allowed to be while enlisted), and were associilted also with s1:wcs and frel.'u ml.'n, but thl.' ships do no t sl.'em to have been crewcd by slaves, \'VI.' know that the SOilS and brothers of sailors also well[ into the navy. Scholars estimatt= that thert= may have bet=n as mall)' as 10,000 tnt=n attacht=d [0 the fleet, although they were nOt all resident at one timt=; and if even one third of them had femalt= companions of somt= sort that would bt= a wry large population that had to li\'c somewhere. It is likel y that many of them li\'cd to the southeast. of the main harbor, in the area that cvenrually became tht;' city of Classe. - 6 The pol·t city of Classc to the south of the harbor channel develo ped slowly after the establishment o f rhe fleet. In the Augustan period, the area cemcteriesF Only in the second century docs eviwas largely occupied dence of habitation emerge. An imposing structure excavated under the church of San Sevcro. dating to the early second century, contained several rooms ~'i th elaborate mosaic pavements, glass wi ndows, and other indications of high statuS, and has heen inter preted 3S a public bath cornplex.- w 1\ street and sewer system de veloped, and evidence o f lower-class ha bitations amI manufat:turing f.lcil ities have been i(l{'ntilled dating to ix=rween the second and the fourth ccnt urics.-!j The large military installation had a dra matic elfe<:t not JUSt on Ravenna's population, but also on the surrounding countryside. In order to provision the fleet, Ra venna's hinterland was mobilized to produce necessary products; one example of such a site, where a large Rom an villa has been excavated, is at Russi, i4 km west of Ravellna along' a stream that fed the harhor. \\fhile originally ;'I simple rustic villa that produced grain, in the late first or early second century AD it' was transformed into a much
oy
TH E C ITY OF RAVENNA IN TH E RO MAN EMP IRE
larger-scale operation, producing grain and wine, with facilit ies for storage and brge-scale production, presumably for sale to the navy.P<>
The City of Ravenna in the Roman Empire In the first century AD , Ravenna as a city finally begins to appear in written sourc(.'S.s, In historical works by authors such as T:lcirus :lntl Suetonius, Rave n na is the hase ofthe fl eet 3nll its commanller, and is occasion ally I1sell as a place o f exile Or refuge . ~' The satirist Martial and others complain about thl.' Hies. frogs, ball wa ter, and other \1n pleasant fearures of the tity, while others commend the vegeta bles, especially asparagus, grown in me area .S; Finally, some authors commet)t on the nature of the city itsel f, ami recanl its re putation in the Roman world. The most not:lble feature of Ravenna for Rom an authors W:lS its watcry location.H.! T he early fi rst-century AD author Straho, in his GCQgrnpbJ', devotes II considerahle amount of space to the city, which he describes as follows; ~'
Sitnated in the m :lr~h"s is th .. great f<:ity o f ] Rnl'ennR, hui lt enti. ... ly on pil"s, and tnwe rsed by cnna ls, which yOIl cross by hridges or feny -ooars. AT the full rid es iT is wa5hcd hy :t consider.lblc quanTiTy of 5C :t-WJTer, as well a~ hy The river. :md thus the ~ewagc is carried off. :md [he "ir purified; in bCT, the district is consil.fa<:d so saluhrious that th~ [Roman i govcmors have :;eluted it as a Sp<)T to hring up and exercise the gbdbrors in. IT is a remarbhle peC1.lliarity of this pbcc, th at, though situ ated ill the midst of :t m~rsh , the air i ~ perfecrly innocuous ... . Another remari.:"hle peculLuity is that of its vines, which, though growing in th e lU :n-:;hes, nHlk.. \'<:1"}' tluidcly and yield a Inrge amount of frui t, but perish in fUIlT or 11\"1: Y<:;Jrs.
T he phrase transl ated here as "built entirely on pi les" is, in rhe original Greek, ~VAOlTayTJS SAT[; it has also been translated "built entirely of wood ." Vitruvius, tOO, after noting that towns built in marshes 3re generall}' not healthy, observes that: 86 Ihhe " "Jlled town is built among tlie lll:lrshes Themselves, pn)l'ided they are by the sea, with a 1l0rdlern or nurth" aSTern ex posure, and are :IUove th" IeI'd of th" ><:ashol"t', the site will he re:'soll"ble enough. For dit ches e:m be- dug to let OUT the W:lter 10 the shore, ,100 ~Iso in times o f 5tol1 115 the sc" ~lI'elis ~nd comes h:lCkjng up into the n),nshes, whe re its birrer hlend pI"e"ents the reproductlons of the llsll~l m ~rsh <:1"t:'lnLres . .. \Ln imt.ln<:e of rh is llI\Ly be foun ,! in th" G~llic I1lHshes surroundin g Airilll"n, R~venn :l, A<juileb, lInd other TOwns in I,laces ohhe \dnd , dose by marshes. They are man'clously healthy, for tlw rea!>()IlS r ha" e gi,·en.
3'
RO MA N RAVEN NA
In describing {IifTerellt kitHls of timber to Dc used for construction, Vitruvius SIXaks of piles of alderwood usell as the substructure of buihlings in marshy areas: ;
city:to Ravenna in the first century AD was an important anll interesting city but we still know rehltivcly little about its features. By the first century AD the n:ptlblican city walls were at li:ast partially in ruins; at the Banca Papolan: site a house was built on top of them ." Defensible city walls were abandoned throughom Ita ly in the early imperia l period, taken to be a sign of peace within rhe empire.~ ' T races of Ravenna 's wall s mUSt still have been vi~ible, as in AD 42 a large gate was built or rebuilt as a triumphal arch in honor of the emperor Claudius (Fig. 5).1" The Porta Aurea ("Golden Gate"), as it was later known, was on the short south side of the oppidll1lf, a monulllental double-arched panal that hare an inscription COlllmemOrating itSCOl1strucrion .~ It was not a gate that could be dosed for defense, but rather a monumental arch leading from the port to me center of the town, as arc also known from cities such as Ancona and perhaps Pou.uoli; it is possiltle that an existing gate wa~ modified to give it monumental form. Q; The arch was destroyed by the French in 158:, hut is known from Renai ssance drawings to have been a double arch~'ay dan in ma rble, whose architrave, su rmounted by twO triangula r pediment.s, was held up by six engaged Corinthian columns; flanking the openings werc aed icll lae surmounted by dipei dt'Corated with vegetation (one of which survives), and flanking the acd iculae and the ga teways were more uceora tcd coloncncs: 16 The Porta Aurea's locatio n at the center of tht: sOtlth wall of the oppidll'111 has led to the conclusion that this region must havc remained at the heart of the Roman illl perial city. It IS hypothesi7,.cd that the cmdo or the t/UUllllIIIIIJof the Roman town ieli from the Porta Aurea northeast across me city, evenruallr crossing rhe JllI1l1ixdlllfJI to the northeast by means of the pow A"IIglI.rti, which was exeanted in 1983 .97 Excavations at the site of Via D 'A.zeglio uncovered a paved roadway, with a ma.~imurn width of 6 Ill, th;}t letl from
THE C ITY OF RAVENNA IN THE ROMAN EMPIR E
the Porta Aurea to the northeast. Tnis street nad been repaved several times starting in the republican period, first in brick and then in stone.~ Beneath [he street ran :I sewer system
33
5. ]kcollstnlcrion of rh " Po rta '\lIre~ " ",h.,
la,.,
(a fter~bMud]i.
'<)67. fig. 7)
RO MA N RAVEN NA
Ravenna's increasing importance and its associated population expansion in the second century led to the further development of its infrastructure, and particu larly its supply of fresh water. '''f An aqueduct was built, reportedly hy the emperor T rajan (98- 11 7 AD), to hring in water from [he somhwest. ;<'5 Remains o f the course of the aqueduct have been observed and excavated, and its rome is fa ir ly cetrai n; it began at Meldola, 35 km to the ~ou thwest, and Followell the course of the river Ronco toward Ravenna and Clas~e. 'o"h How it crossc(l th e harbor is not clcar, but oncc on the northern sille it r:ln along the eastern wa ll o f the QPpidlllll . A tower that is currently part of the si.\:th-eentury nrchiepiscopal palace. known as the Tnrn' SilllIsrm, perhaps originally part of a ga te in the republicm walls, also served as the Cilstdlllllllltjlllll: , the water distribution tower for the aque T he elaborate floor mosaics as well as remains of furnishings, such as bronze furn iture fittings dating to the second century, indicate a high standard of living.'!! \-Vith a large an(1 busy port, trade also increased dramatically in Ravenna and Classe. \ ·Ve hear from VitTuvius that the ri,'er Po was used to tranSI)()rt tim ber from inland to the cities on the Adriatic coast. <" and it is likely that Ravenna gradually developed a mercantile identity. "} To the southwest of the oppidll1l1 excavations have revea led evidence of ceramic production from the first century BC through rhe first century AD, particularly of term ,rigil/flti/ cups and heakers. ' 'i Ceramics produced in other locations in
A TH I RD- AN D FOURTH -CENTURY CRISIS ?
central Italy were a[so brought to Ravenna to be filled with wine from the region, " 'hich was thcn exported to places throughout the Mediterranean in the first to third centuries AD. ' 'J From the seeond cenrury, Ravennate workshops were producing marble sarcophagi and other sculpted works.' ,6 Ravenna also imported a variety of products from throughout the Mediterranean, particu[uly from the east. Remains of vessels containing products such as wine from the Dalmatian coast and Rhodes, along with some evidence for oli"e oil from Spain, have been found at Ravenna, ' '1 as has a mid-scoond l'entury tombstone with an inSCTil'tion in G reek commemorating "Titus Julius Nico<;rratus the Rhodian." perhaps a wine merchant. ' , ~ In the mid--second--<enrury marble from the island ofProoonnesus neu Constantinople began to be imported into R:lvenna, to be madc into sarcophagi and public monuments. ' '9 As mentioned above, the provision ing of the fleet must have led to an enonnous inerea"., in the amount of trade between Ra"enna and its terrestrial and maritime neighbors, and the creation and maintenance o f one or more large ports fostere<1 the devcl0l'ment of the city as a commercia l center. Most houses, public, and cormnercial buildings "'ere located to the westof the presumed jos<JI Augustll. The region between t he canal and the coastline was the city'sccmetery wne, extending the length of the inhabited area and then all the way down to Classe, where very large cemL'teries contained the tombs of members of the fleet. The oldest ccmetcry that has been found, dating from the first eenrury AD and "(mtinuing in usc until the fourth or fifth century, was located on the east side of the jos<JI ncar the northern port; "O the josya, constructed just prior to this, is not known to have had bridges connecting its twO sides, and seems to have become the delimiting fearure between the living and the dead. ", Roman tomhstones provide uS with more information ahout the inhabitants of thc city than wc will have for later periods. The r ,jO! people who either lived in Ra"'~Jlna or came from Rawnn. arc knoWTl from the Roman period, mainly from inscriptions. '" Based on agcs recorded on tombstones, A. Donati has calculated that men in Ravenna lived to an average age of 23.40 rears, while members of the fleet specifically (s8 of the 85 known malc epitaphs) had an avcrage age of death of 40.R6 rears. \Vomen (on the basis of 29 epitaphs) lil'ed an average of !O.55 years. Thesc dara arc similar to those cak1tlared for other areas of the Roman Em )lire. "J
A Third- and Founh-Cenrury Crisis? The third century was a peri(Ki uf nisis in the Ruman Empire. In addition to a demographic crisis caused br epidemic disease (probably smallpox)
,6
RO MA N RAVEN NA
and internal political insta bility. Italy was lx!set by external enemies; the Alamanni invaded in z 54 anti a!f: Septimius Severus seized the Ra\'enna fleet on his way to Rome in 193, ':;] and it seems w have been used for various purposes In the early third cenfUry, from tra nsporting troops to battling pirates, but in the later parr of the century it collapsed, or, at least, there is no mention of any fleet from Italy being involved in any of the invasiuns, raids, ur fighting that was ha ppening all over the cmpire in thesc rea rs. Significantly, inscriptions with Il
ATHIRD - AND FO URTH -CE NTURY C RISIS?
The (led ine of the Ileer had an impact on R;l\'enna's wan:n'ourses also, It is likely that in the thinl century, either be<:ause of the (I edine of tht: Aeet or as a cause of it, the water systems in Ravenna's surroundi ng area had not been properly maintained. Given three cenUlries of ji\l bsideno: md se(li mentation, the result was that the lagoon and the harbor had been drying alit and filting with silt. Some e\'idence o f layers of alluvial deposits over the Roman-era structurt.-s implies a perio(1of t.-xcessive ilO()(lillg in the areas to the east of the oppiJl/1I/ in tbe later fourth century; at this time habitation cease!1 at other cities such as Butrium ro the north, perhaps becal\Se of hydrological changes, '}' By the end ofthe fourth century, however, the fa;sa AllglISW easr of the Padenna had gOlle out of \l5e. '.IS Many Italian cities were in decline in the third and fourth centuries, and RaVel1l1a was no t:xception; lhe archaeological material shows a progressive depopulation of the city after the mitl- thinl centu ry, prol);1bly as a result of the invasions. ' JQ A m~jority of thc CX('3vatcd cemCtcrics contain burials fmlll before the third century or after the fifth, bu t not in between.'*" Almost all of the houses e.xcavll ted both in the oppidllll! and iIt the areas to the cast and north were abandoned in this period, many of them after destrU(;tion by fire. ,~: Only three sites contain evidence of activity in the later third or fOlirth cenrury. At Via D'A~,eglio in the northwest corner of the Oppitfll'lll, tht: "House of the Floral Thre-;holtl" was burne{1 in the third century but then partially reused in the hurth by an elaborate privote bath complex with Christian flOOr mosaics. The UPI)"I site cast of the QPpiauf/I along the presumed/o)')"" AugllSTa had mosaics dating to the late third or early fourth century. ' ..' Finally, the "Palace ofTheoderic~ provided evidence implying continuous usc and a "ebuilding of the villa in eitherthe fOllrth or the e~rly fifth century; if the former date is upheld by further excava tion, the building would probably represent the residence of the provincial governor or military comIll3n
37
,.
RO MA N RAVEN NA
tratling patterns changed in lb\'cnna in the thinl and fourrh tClUlirics, trade did not come to a halt. Connectiom with the Aegean remained imp(JTtlllt, and the ceramic evidence shows a dramatic increase in imports from North Africa. loW Thus, in the fourth century the re was still sollle life in rhe Ravenna area, and perhaps even a certain level of administrati,'e and commercial wealth, hut rhe dty was a shell ()f what it hat! been at its height in the second century.
The Gallic author Ausonius, writing around 385.
lIrc described. No one could have fOreseen wh:lt was to happen in the years after -100.
Ravenna's Christian Origins In Ra\'cnna as in moH cities of the Roman world, Christianity was introduced ill the imperial period. Agnc1lus tells tiS that the first bishop of Ravenna. I\pollil1ari5. was a dist:iple of St. Peter and was martyred at th" time of [\le emperor Vespasian (69- 79). Agnellus took his info rmation from a text that we know as the PIJ5Si(Hfillcti ApollilllJ ris, which was probably written in the sixth or seventh CentUly.'j:" Both the PaJsio and Agnellus tell us that Arollinaris wa5 sent by the a(XIscle St. P eter to Ravenna, began to convert people and petfoTll1111iracies, was brought before a Roman judge, tortured , and ended his life as a martyr. Certainly by the mid-sixth century the story of Apollinaris 3S the first bishop was established in it5 basic outlines. because at th
RAV EN N A'S ct-!RIST IAN O RIG I NS
~ r st performed baptism," that originally the bishop of Ravenna was basell in Classe rather than in the city of Ra\Cenna itself. '5-1 T his often-repeated hypothesis C3nnot be sustained on the basis of Agnel1us's statements, especially si nce thl.'Te were two ch11rches de(hcated to St. Eu phemia, ami the one called lid IJriarll1 was in dIe oppidlllll itself. A Christian focus in Classe is certainly possible, howe\'er, givell the state of Ravenna and C lasse in the thlrd ;11111 fourth centuries. ISS Attempts to establish (Iates for the eleven hishops who, according to Agncllus, preceded Severus arc speculative; it is likely that some of the bishops in the series listed hy Agnellus were invented, perhaps in the sixth century when the episcopa l chronology was bcing established, or perhaps by AgnclIus himself. 'l't'> \ >\I)lile we are told by Agnellus (almost our only source) that Christians were living in Ravenna ill the Roman period, he does nor descri he ;lny church construction there until the early fifth century. The first Structure that he memions is the chapel ofSt. Pullo, ~not far fmm the gate which is called the parta NOlin," bui lt ahom thc YC3r 400. Il'" The large house CXC3" vated at the north side of the Via D'Azcgl io site, richly redecorated in the third and fourth ccnnlril.'S with mosaics that could ('onta in Christian symbolism, lies JUS t to the south of the location of the church of St. Euphemia, perhaps the one identilied hy Agndlus as lid Arirtelll and said to be the location of Apollinaris's first baptisms in Ravenna. J. Baldini Lippolis nOtes that there might be some kernel of tr uth to the idea that an ea rly Chri~tian place of worship in the city was located hcrc. ' j ~ But other th ~n Sc\'crus, we k.now nothing about the bishops or other personali ties of the church of Ravenna before the arrival of the imperial Court in 40;.
39
\ •
_.-
_•
--
-
-.-.-
- --.•
-
...,,'-•---•,...\ --.1 .. . - ... ~
6. Map sha"';ng 1U'·~n "" . CI:tIS<". ~nd , h" ,\d ri " k w~),.l in c
in tho;: fifth, ~inh , and ninth c,"'t urics
..
---"-" _• ..•
..
-
CIIAPTE R THRH
RAVENNA AND THE WESTERN EMPERORS , AD 400-489
Shordy after
th~
yenr 400, the western Roman em]>erors moved their base
of orcrati()n~ from Milan
TO
Ravenna. An imperia l residence was
cst~b
lished there, new walls were huilt to surrounll an essentia lly new dry, a mint was established, and infrastructure ;lIld insti tutions were created in order to make them comlllensurate with th ... city's new statlls. The bishop ofR
The Last Century of the Western Roman Empire The emperor D ioclecian (z8 4- ) OS) reformed the adm inistration of the Roman state at the end of the third ccntury: amollg his Illany innovations, his dt'cisiotl to dividt' tllt' empirt' into t'astt'rIl 31lt1 westt'rIl halves, ;lruj to tlil'ide its administration among SC\'cr;l1 ca pital cities, woul(1 h;ll'c lasting (:onseque!l(:es for Ravenna. In 324 Constantine rellnited the tv.'o halvcs of the cmpire and esta blished his capital in the new eaStern city of Constanrinople. Milan remained thc west's main adm inistrati vc center, and after Constantine's (leHh the empire was divided again and his western successors ruled from .j\ 'lilan. Rome remained tlle scat of the Roman Senate and the symbolic ht'art of tht' empire, but lackt'd the pt'rmallent presence o f the empcrors.
Ravenna, c. AD 480
.Ell
(~
\
--
\
. III.~I'.
~
7
•
"',," _ _
-
.... 0': .... 0."1" "
.......
..
-.~, . -,.,
....... eFTs ..
~_"
d - ,,~
.-. ,.
M ~ l' o f
Ra'·~"n3. 1:;>.
AD 480
TH E LAST CENTURY OF TH E WESTERN ROMAN EMPIRE
8. ('.ok] soIiJus
ofG.lI. PlxiJi •.
00-..,...., .nd
"""
Dumhanon Oaks. Brun. ti~< CoIl«rion. W .. hingtun, DC)
In 394 the emperor Theodosius I, who had reunited the empire under his sole command, established his son Honorius as emperor in Milan, and his older son Arcadius in Constaminople. T heodosius dicd in 395, leaving Bononus, age eight, under the guidance of Theodosius's military commandtr (mngirtffmilirum) and trusttd friend Stili cho. The following yens were difficult ones filr the western empire; the Visigoths, an immigrant group who had Ix.en senk
"
••
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
of her day. subject of both andellt ;lIld modern romantic legend. The OU[lines of her life come from fifth-century chroniclers' who alSQ offer intriguing glimpses into the personality of Galla. although these probably tel l us morc about (heif ;lmhofs than abollt the empress herself. ' Ae)ia Galla Placidia was born sometime oerween 388 and 393, [he daughter of' ]'heooosius I and his second wife Galla; she was thus the halfsister of Honorius aud Arc;lliius.J She seems to have spent her youth ill Italy UI}(ler
the care of Serena, her cousin and lhe wife ofStiJicho. \Vhcn Stilicho was mllfdcrcd in 408, Serena 311(1 Galla Placi dia were living in Rome; when the Visigoths first attacked th e city in 409, Serena was acrusco of conspiring with the enemy and was I!xenm~d with Galla P l acirli~'sconsent,ac<:onlingto one source,4 V\'hen the Visigoths sacked Rome in 4 [ 0, the twenty-year-old Galla Placidia was taken into custwly and carried along with the Visigoth ic army into Gaul. As pan of a Visigothic pact with Honorius, Galla was married to the Visigothic leader Athaulph in 4 [4 and went with him into Spain, where she bore him a son who was given the hopeful name Thcodosius, but the child died shortly afterward . Athaulph was assassinated ill 4[ 6 and Calla retmlled to th\.' court of Honori\lS in Italy, where she was marri\.'d (against her will, one source says) to the Roman general Constamius in 41 7.5 She bore him two children: lusta Grata Honoria (0. 4 [ 7 or 4 [R) and Valentinian (b. 4 19)' C.onstantius was matllS in 411, and Gal la was named ,1IlgIlSft1 ; however, the~e titles were nOt recognized by her nephew the emperor T hcodosius II in Constantinople. Constantius died later in 4l [, and G~lla quarreled with Honoriusi in 413 she took her children to Constantinople to seek refuge with T heodosius II. I-Ionorius died in the same year, leaving no children, aDd the throne was seized by a government official, the p r illlkcI"illf 1101111";01"11111 John, who had the SUpJXlrt of the Senate and of powerrul generals includ ing the Roman Aetiu5. The eastern court decided that Galla's son Valentinian was the rightful emperor, and the youth was betrothed to Theodosius's daughter, Licinia Eudoxia . Theodosiu s sent an army headed by the eastern 1//agisler milirlllll Anla bur to remove John and place V:!lentinian on the throne. G !\etiu5 was orou ght over to Valentinian's side, and Galla took the reins as regent for hel" son in 415 . From 425 to 43i, G;l11
TH E LAST C ENTURY 0 1: HI E WESTERN !tO MAN EMPIR E
was ccleurated ~rst H Constlllltinople and then at Rome in 43 7, after which he tOok control of the empire in his own right. After 43 7 Galla fades from written SOurces, although it is assumed that she was still innuelltial until her death in 45 0. By the late 4405, the IIuns h ~d emerged as a new threat to the empire. 'rhe I·hms had occupied the Hunga"ian plain in central Europe since the late fourth century, a[1<1 had been actively involve(1 in imperial politics. Aetius, for example, made c:~tetlsiv e use of them as soldiers in the wew:rn Roman army, and the eastern empire hall al ternately fought them an([ pai([ them subsidies to prevent them from attacking. In 450. the new e,lstern I.'mperor ,\>1arcian ended the ~"\lusidies to the Huns, and their leader Attila lUrned his arllly agai nst the westerll empire. According to se\'er~1 sources, his pretext was a scandal in the imperial family . lusta Gratn Honoria, who had never married, h:1I1 an affair with her estate manager; when they were discovered. her para mo ur was c.~''Cute(1 and she was im prisonc(\. She wrote to Anila and told him that if he invaded the western empire. ~he would m;lrry him lind he wou ld have half of the empire as her dowry. The entire story is fantastic, but the fact that so many historians rcpeatell it tells us something about late antique attitudes to imperial women and politics} \Vhatever his motivation, in 45 I AcriJa 3ml his arm ies invaded Gaul. Aetius formed a coalition rhat induded the Visigoths, and blocked Attila's advance at Chalons. Atti la withdrew eastward, but in the following year he took his army din..'Ctly into Italy. T he H UllS captured several cities, most notably Aq uileia and Mi lan, but for various reasons Attib was c\'ell fUally persuaded [(J withdraw.\! \iVhat Atti la might have done next we do not know, bu t he died unexpectedly in 45 3 and his federa tiol) collapsed, endtng the HUJlnic threat. After Gall~ died in 450, conditions in the empirc WCnt from bad lO worse.>' Valentinian, perhap~ feeling tha t he no longer needed his greatest general to defend the empire from the I·runs, murdered Aetius in 454. Then he was assassinated in Rome in 455 . Valentinian had two dallghtl.'rs, Eudocia and Placi
,6
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
Ricimcr, Gundobad, Orestes, and Qdoaccr. In the meantime, llooncoould pay much attenti(>n to the Vandals Or the Visigoths, nor to the ropuiati(m ofTt'aly, which was all that was left of the empire. After a complex series of event!; in 474-6, the general Odoaccr took control of Italy, bm. rather thm choosing a Roman to be emperor, he returned the imperial regalia w the emperor Zena. He proclaimed himsel f king and pnfl'icills of the west, and Zena tacitly accepted his claim. O(loacer set about stll>ilizillg the regions
around ItaI}'; he reconquered Sicily from the Vandals by 477, took Dalmatia in 480, defeated the Rugialls of Norl<:utn in 48 7. and allied himself with th e Visigoths and Franks. "Vith his borders secure, Odoaccr was able to n.'store som!,' scmhlan<:e of Rormn law and onler to Italy, governing (or at least minting coins) in the name oflino. lIe rub! haly for dlineen years, until Zeno sent the Ostrogoths aga inst him.
Moving the Capital to Ravenna At the time of {he Visigothic invasion of 40!, 1-lonorillS and his advisers seem [0 have felt thaL i\'lilan was too har(1 to defe n(l , and so tile emperor lllovcd to Ra\'cnna; the first i,mperial decree to ha\'e been issued at Ravenna is dateu December 6,401 ." "I'he year 401 appears in almost every mo(iern account as a pivotal (late in Ravenna ' $ history, even though no contemporary authors Illcntion such a transfer in that year. " Vic do know that many of the imporram events in fifth-cennlry imperial history took place in Ravenna, and some of the emperors spent much of their time there. ,,\Thy Ravenna? Tbc llsual answcr is thac Ravcwla's marshy hinterlands ma(l c it difficult to attack oy Imd, and as a result armies like the Visigothic army that sacked Rome in 41 0 lefl Raven na alone. ') Socralcs Schola stkus, writing in Constantinople in the l;In: 4ps, (Iescribes the establishment of Valentinian rn on the throne at Ravenna: 'i -1111:n agai n at thist:risis th" pra~'''rof thl' pious elnp.:ror pre\·ailed. Foran angd of GOI.f, under the appearance I)f a shepherd, Im,lcrtook the gui tl ance of !\spar and the troups which wer" with him, "ml leo him through the lI1,mihy bke [AII,wry] near Ravenna - for in th~t city the usurper [John] was then r.::siding- an ti tll<:n: J"tain"d the milit1l.l'Y dlitf. Now, no une had e""r heen kIlOwn to h~"e fOHlcd tha I lak" l>cfon:; hut God then rendered thut passab lc which had hitherto been impussuhk. H av ing the refore CT=d the lake, ;IS if going O\'~r dry ground. tlI~r fOllnd th.:: ipt.::s of th .:: city Opell, ano o,·erpow.::red til'::
uSIlrf>t'r.
ACl'()rding to Socrates it was Ra\'elllla's hIIJIIIl, or marshy bke, dlat gave it an almoSt impregnable defense, 'S The defcnsible nature of Ravenna
MOV I NG THE CAIJITAL TO RAVE N NA
was mentioned in writings by the sixth-century histOrians j o nlancs anll ProtOpius. Jonlanes, descri bing the fa<.1: that Alaric the Visig{lth dill nOt attack Ravcnna in 408, says, HThis city lies ,lmi£1 the streams of the Po UcnVl.'en rmrshes (poll/drs) and the sea , and is at:cessible only on one side.... Bur on the west it has marshes through which a son of door has been left by a vel'y narrow entrance (1IIIolIlIgllsfi.,'jimIJ illf1'oiflillf ponll}."' (, Procopius, in the Gorbie War, repeatS this description , with a military analysis that has tolored all subsequent interpretations: l ] 'rhis dty of Rnl'eJlllll lies in I' le~'eI plain M th~ e .~trerlljt}' of the lonhon Gull', lackin g! st-adcs!== ca . 380 Ill] ofhcingon the 5C~ , and it is so simated ~s not to be e~5il~· appro~ched either hy $hip~ o r by ~ l.1nd army. Ships ean not possihly put into shore there bee:luse [he sea itself p~ l'e nrs [hem br Forming ;;hoal~ for not less th:ln 30 sud"s; consequently the heach 'Lt RaHim:!, '1ltlWlIgh to the eye of nmrinl'rs it iSYl' l')' 11~ 'lr "t hand, is in r~ 'llity W I)' far aw.l)' hy re'lson of the b",eat n.-tent of the :;hoal wateL And a land army cannot appmaeh it at all; for the r1Yl'r Po, alsu ealll'J the Eridanus, which flows past R;ll'enna .. . and other nav igable rin:rs together with sOllie Illarsh~s (1Ih.lVOIS), encircle it em all sides and so cau~ thl' city to be surrounded h)' watn.
Certainly Ravenna was perceived to be a defensible location, although Ihis may nOt have actually heen the case; in fact Ravenna was repeau'ly !>ecause the mar~hes were not as £1efensible as they were pcrccive£1 to be. 's Sever;!l scholars have argued that Ravenna was chosen for reasons more complex than a dubious strategic :ldv:lntage. F. VV. Deichrnann observed that the development of Ravellna ~ftcr 4-0 2 came SOOI) ~fter the esta blish mentofConstantinople as the permanent residence of the eastern emperors under T heodosius I and Arcadius, rendering sea contact between July lilld the eastern Mel]iterranean more desirable.'Q Impel'ial couriers traveling from Rome to Constantinople \·ja Brind isi coulrlll1ake the journey in twenty days, bllt to be able to depart directly from Ravenna would have rc£1uccd me journey tirne. 'o Communication with the east was particularly impormilt during the reigns or Honorius and Valentinian III, whereas after 455 the emperur~ wefe instead depemlent on the support of the western army ;Hld Rome's Senatc. and communic;ation with the C;lSt became less signifi clnt. Ravenna offered the addi tional advantage of l>eing ea~ily provisioned, because it was an important part of thc maritimc nctwork. " Alternately, V. Neri has notc£1lhat while Milan and Aquilcia had Ucen strategically impor[;1m in the second an(l third centuries, by the late fourth century the rivalry Uctween Romc a nd i\lilan had increasc£1, an£1 RaVClllla may have been cho;;en to promote Rome at the opense of Milan, while Aquileia wa~ rejectell as tOO cxposed to attacks from the north and cast. "
.7
,8
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
A tilll}1 rca~otl for the choice ofRavct1na may have been the ~ta tc of the city in the year 40J . A!i n()ted in the previ()us (>hapter, an:hae(llogy has shown that by thc thi rd century the city seems to have been mostly abandoned in fa \'or of the porr city of Clas5c to thc south. V. Mam:dli has called what was left a "palimsest" on which the imperia l administrators could build an emirely new imperial city, full of relev3llt public buildings including churches.' J In this, perha p~, Ravenna may have heen rather like Byz;lmiuln before Constantine tran sform ed it. Und er Theodosius I, Christianity was strongly promoted as the official religion of the empire, and puhl ic pagan religious practices were banned. It has been ,lrguecl that at Constantinople, Constantine eonstnlctcd a ~pccifically C hristian capital city, with a ("athcdr~1 ~nd palace in close proximity ~t the dty's core. ' + IIonorius may have seen Ravenna in the same way, strategically useful and without a strong pagan core, a blank slate on which a new Christian clpi tal could he built. \Vc havc no evidence for pag-Jn telllpics at Ravenna, except for a Story that St. Apollin3ris destroyed onc by his prayers, ~n(l that is a fopOJ of hagiograph)' rather than necessarily a memory of a historical el'ent. '5 But we do know that in the new impcri31 Ravl.'nna, thl.'cathcdral and the palace formed the two foci of the city. ,(.
Ravenna as a Capital The iclt:a that Ravenna became the capital of the western Roman Empirt: really only hegins wi th Agnellus, who says that Valentinian III (4 l5 -55) ..... ordered and decreed that Raven n,1 should be tbe head of Ita ly (Cllplll ItlllitlL') in place of Rome."'7 Agnellus's accoullts of the buii(!ing activities of I-lonorius, Galla Placi{iia, and Valeminian Ul promolcd a legend th~t has affected views of Ran:nna down to the present. Recently, A. Gillett has presented a detailed analysis of the known residence of emperors in thl: early fifth cent1.1f)' in order to show that despite imperial activity in Ra\'enn;l, it W;lS Rome that was viewell by almost everyone as the true center of the empirl:. The panegyrist Claudian e,xtols Rome as the emperor's "true" home, but no contemjl<)raf)' author ever praises Ravenna in this way. '~ Cdcllr:ltions of imperial accessions, consul~les, and other significant milestones at Rome, HQlloriu s's construction of his mausoleum in Rome, and Valentinian's ultimate transfe r of thc COurt to Romc in .no, arc fOr Gillen signs that, even for Honorius, Rome was the sym bolic center of tht: western empire. And yct, clearly Ravenna did have a special status in the fifth cennl ry. \Vhile Rome retainetl irs symholic value as Ctlplll orbi;', RavelUla nevertheless bec;lmc ;l S(·Jr:s imperii ("im pcri;ll residence") perceived as a phlce
RAV EN NA AS A SEDES IMPERII
where emperors mighl live and govern. llllleed, at rhe end o f rhe century Pope Gelasius, addn:ssing the (Iutstion of whether the hishop of a H?gia r:/lIifll.f ("regal city") should hal'e
Ravenna as a sedes impn-U \Vhat wa~ a ,'I'des imperii in the Roman world, and how does Ravenna fit the defin ition? jOAfter the third century, the Roman Empire developed a bureaucratic administr.nlon that was centralized around the person of the emperor. vVe know that the imperial bureaucracy in the early fifth century was extensivc; just how extensive can be secn from tbe Notitiil Diglliffltll'lll, a liSt of civil atH! military government officials for th e eaStern ami western em pires that is thought to have been com piled between 395 and the 42 0S, H exactly at the time that the emperors were resident in Ravenna,H Government officials of the central ~d m inistration include the P raetOrian Pn:fcct of Iraly, the Masters of Foot and Horse in the Pres(.'nce, the Prae(JOsitus of the S
.9
so
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400- 489
"'here is no clear conSellSus about where a II these pcopl c lived and worked in the fifth century. It is sometimes stated that the entire ~dministrati(m traveled with the emperor in this Jlcriocl .J6 On the other hand, it seems clear that at ll,';lst after 395. or even arrer Constantine, the eastern administration senled down in tbe palace at Consraminople,17 and it is sometimes assumeo that II simi lar establishment of adminisrration in the \Vest took place at Ravenna, although on ;I less grandiose scal e )~ You can't put a I .Sco-person uurc:llK'3CY in a place that docs not have buildi ngs to actolllmodate them; and since, in the case of Ravenna, this ac<:ommodarinn had to be huilt up from scratch, the emperors must havc intcndcd to livc thcrc
for a good parr of the tim!.'. It is likewisc often assumed that all government officials served in Ravenna, yet the only seeure evidence for this are a few imperial rescripts adltressed to oflicials there. C. Pietri amlJ. !\>Ianhews have shown that offici31~ who helll the highest offices, who often came from the great Roman senatorial families, liv(.'d in Ravcnna only during their t(.'nns ofofficc)'i HowL
For now we can only surmise that th is is what existed in fifth-century Ravenna ..... \Ve lIlay know relatively little about tlu: people who live(1and worked in Ravenna, but we know morc about its physica l topography, which can Uc
RAV EN NA AS A SEDES IMPERII
compare!1 with the layout of orher similarly ranked dries of the late third and fourth centuries, most notably Comtaminople and Milan:!S In Constantine's new capital, the main governmental buildings were constructed adjacent to the cathedral and the imperial palace, which was also flanked by a large circus, the I Iippodrome. Colonnaded streets connected this core area with the rest ofrhe city, punctuated by fora, baths, and monuments:l~ Protecte(1 on three siMs hy water, the city's land limit was walled by Constantine, and new walls endosing a much la rger area were built during the reign ofThcodosius II. Milan h3113 similar layout: originally 3 provinci31 capital and prospcrous trading ccnter, with the arrival of the imperial court new walls, palaces, and other structures were built. "I'he late tourrh--ccnUlry poet Ausonius, who compiled a series of poems in honor of the great cities o f the empire, lists lor Milnn wnlis, a circus, a theater, temples, a pal nee, a mint, haths, porticoes, and statues .~' Churches, although IlOt mentionell by Ausonius, were a 11lnjor component of both Mila n 's and Constantinople's topography. These features were fo und in various I.:Ombin3tions also in other imperial cities of the: period, Inside Ravenna's new walls, at least 50111e of these fa6lities must have been constructed in the first half of the fi fth centu ry. The rransiormation did not hnppen o\'(!rnight, and its chronology is unclear. Nlany surviva ls are fragmenta l), and without context, for example a sculpted torso made of porphy'')', part o f a statue of an emperor im ported from COIlstantinople, whose original location is unL:nowll ..;.S Agnc-1 lus implies that most of thc work was carried om under Valentinian III and perhaps especially during the regency o f Galla Placiclia,4'J and this information is repeated in most cuncnt histories of im perial Ravenna. This docs oat realJy make SCIl5C, given that HOllorius is said to have lived in the city for almost twent~' years; certainly SOllle, el'en much, of the construction that turned Ravenna into an imperial city must have been begun during his reign .5" The main dements for which we have textual, archaeological , ami architectural evidence Jrc fhe city walls. the palace(s), the mint, and churches, and we will consider each of these in rum. It is o ften observed that in Ravenna the em perors were particularly inspired by the cilY of COllstantinople. 'Ne will examine individual pieces of c\·ic.lcnce for this, lmt here it shou ld bc pointed out that ;Ilmost all of our written evidence (lares to after 550, Con~ra ntinople remained a model for Ravcnna's leaders for two centuries, and we cannot say precisely whcn mo~t of the Constanrinopoliun epithets were appl ied.'i' Moreover, although many features in Ravenna are assumed to imitate lost Constantinopoli{an originals, we must also recognize that Ravenna was not simply a pale imitatioll of [he eastern capital, hut a place in which new ideas aud clementS were introduced illto [hc imperial repertoire.
S'
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
S'
The City Willis oj R"vemul Th(' urban topogr.\phy of Ravenna froll) till' late antique period to the present has been defined by a set of walls that werc lmilt someti me in thl,' fourth or fifth century (Fig. 7).5' The republican walls of Ravenna had enclosed II rectangular space of appJ'Oximarely 33 hectares, although in the fir~t ;lnti second centuries AD habitation had spread beyond these limirs and the walls themselves wcre ruined, at least in plac('s.H The new walls, many parts of which arc still pn:scnrcI] today, form a circuit 4.5 km long llnd enclose an arca of [66 hectar('S. 51 The construction of thi5 wall was an extraordinary CVI,'n( for this period in northern haly. In c\'cry other casl,' tha t we know, cities were shrinking; Ra vcnn;l is theonlydty in which a new wal l circuit endost:J a much larger an:a than its prcJL"Ccssor. )~ Agnellus tells us of Valentini an Ilp 6 . . . here :lIld there on e:(eh side he ,(domed the streets of th e city with g rt';\t w"lls, ~nd he Or(krcd iron b~T1i to be e!\do~d in the bowels of the w,til. Alid so grcH " 'as his cart dla( (he iron h,u, not only appeared ornamenral, but ~ I,;o if at some ame some orner people should Wal}[ to thn: ~ t en this ~·ir)'. ~nd if not 'IS llI~n~' we'lpons l'oulJ l>e found ~s wert: needed, from these loars arrows ,mil bIKes ,mIl eve n swurds l"<.)ukllx: m,,,k; or, as "'~ said, th~ w"lls would supply (he iron for some mher purpose. H e ~d derl lll\lch (Q th is wall of th~ city kh'itill]. where formtrly it h~J hetn girdt d ~ s mer.:!y a town [oppidum [. An d this empt:rot nwdc gre ~( wh~t \\',IS snwller in fomler times, and he ordered and decreed lh ~ 1. Ravenna sho\lld I~ the 11(',1<.1 of Ital), ill phl~C of Home ....
Agncllus's accounl has been the basis of the ioterpretatio n of the topographical development of Ravenna; however, there has been, alltl continues to be, consic.lcrable controversy about the d~tc(s) of construction of this wall CirCU It .
A. T csti -Rasponi, as part of his 19~4 edition of Agncl lus's tcxt, proposed that an original Roman core, RmJrllll1l 'Iliadi'll la, which corresponds to wha t we ha vt: been calling the republican Oppidlllll, was supplemented several times , once dtlri ng the rei gn of Valcruinian Ill, and once by Odoacer in the later fifth century.51 T esti-RaslxlIli 's map i~ still sometimes reproduced in studics of th e dty, It is only in the past tWO decades that scholars have serio usly Cjuestionecl this view, and only very recently thaI' the question of the wall's purpoSC and its rclationship to Ravenna's expansion in the early fifrh cenmry has bcen c:\lliorecl. N. Christie and S. Gibson's stucl yof the masonry of the survivingpamof thc walls indicated that the cxpanded wall circuit was built at olle time, not in se\'eral stages as proposed by Testi-RasponiY' This prollOsal has been accepted by many subscq uetH 5chol:lr5.59 Christie concludes th;lt Ravenna's
RAV ENNA AS A SEDES IMPERII
imperial defenses stood 9 meter high and were ap proximately 1.~ meter thick, which woulll make them lower than the walls ofVeron~, Mi lan , anll Rome at th is lime. Thecircuit included several towerS, fourteen main g"Jtes, and more than thirty posterns inclnding openings tor waterways, ~Il '-milt as pan of the origiml plall.t'.o In the course of this new work, Claudius's arc h was flan ked by round rowers and incorporated into the wall system, al111 waS suhsequen tly known as the Porta Aurea, or "Gol(len Gate.""'; ' T he walls were made mostl}' of reltSeo I:orkks,~' not surprising given that the city's l3nliscapc wa s littered with rnins /'! Vlh:u remains a mystery is exactly when these w:llls were built: were they built because rhe co urt had moved thl.'re, or did the court move there because the walls were already bui lt? Christie accepts Agnellus's attribu tion ofthe walls to the reign ofVnlenrillian [II (42 ;-55)' One rcason he gives for this d ating is the silnilari ty of the bricks in the wall to those used to mIlstruct Sa n Giovan ni E\'angcii st
53
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPER.O RS. AD 400 - 489
walls? At the least, we can s~ y that rhese eaStern authors wcre \·isualizing a city surruunlled hy w31l ~ when des.tribing these strategically important events, and r wou ld argue that the scattered bits of tell.1:ua l evidence do sllggest that the "imperial" walls existed by rhe very early lifth ccnnll'yJ o \-Vhen we rum to archaeology, we encounter funher conrradictions ami dilferences of interpretation. V. ManzeUi shows that archaeology reveals little activity outsitle of the oppiJulII in the fourth century, ~ ' although Classe was being de veloped in this perio
The J-Vnle,-c'o,wses Ra venna's new topography did not only involve the laying {Jut of a new wall circuit; the hydrology of the site was adapte(\ to the new urban conlines. As we have seen, the watery nat\lre of Ra\'enna was its (listinguishing characteristiC in ancient literature, aTH! this was to continue for writerS of the lare Roman Empire)) Sioonius Apollinaris, a Gallo-Roman ~ristocr at who visited Ravenna in 467 on his way to Rome, describes the city in m'O letters.-6 111 the first, which narrates the S{oty or his journey throu gh Italy, he discusses the water supply in various places; he describes the watercourses through Ravenna, in order to complain that nOllC of it was fit to drink. In
RAV EN NA AS A SEDES IMPERII
the Sl'C'OIHiil:tter, Sidonius describes Ravenna's Ales and frogs, a city where "the walls fall, the waters stmd , the tOwers sink, the ships sit . . . . a place that marc casily has a territory [tclTitori1l1llj than solid ground [tcnamJ," in other words, a city o f hydrau lic instabiliry .77 The complex hyd rological system of Ravenna, which had contributed to the city's importance as a naval and mercantile center, deteriorated in the fourth anti fifth cenruries J~ The subsidence of the ground , to which R:l\'enna was always su bjl,.'Ct, was Sli pplcmcl1ted by the neglect of the water system, particularly the jossa Ill/gwtll; the separate t:al1al to the east of the P:ldenna wen t outaf usc in this period. It is likely that the lIi(( PI/pilill, which had followed the CO\lrse of the canal , continued in Ilse, becoming the main road through the eastern parr of the new dty; this road was known as the plllle'11IIlIiul" al1(l is now the Via di Roma (Figs. I, i ).~" The water that ha(1 once Rowetl through this canal was (liverted elsewhere in the city. In his fi rst lctter, Sido n ills says of Ravenna: ... Above, the two-fold hr:mehcs of the Po w.1.Sh around and th rough the town {O/,pidIlIllJ; kd ~wa}' from its main h(.'cI IIr puhlic dykes, through them by divcrtecl channels it cli ,,-jclc~, diminished, with di,·iclccl flow, S() that part surrounds th<: w,lIs pru"idi ng prot<:<.:tion, part 11.0ws within and prO\'ides tnde, as com'enient:ltl arrangement for ~ummtrr~ as cpcci~II~· for bringing in provisions ... !Io
\Ve have seell that in the Roma n period, the Padenna and the Lalllone Rowed along the nonh and east sides of the oppidlllll, and the [oml [.II1l/ira or A lImi.< passeli th rough the oppidll1l1 from east to west. Sidonius's description implies that new canals were dug to create a branch of tbe P aden ll ,1 flow ing around the northwest corner of the new city into the Lamone to provitle ~dd itionaJ defenses. 8 , It is reasonable to ass ume that this happened at the sa me rime as the wall~ were lmilt (this channel was later known a$ thejil...sa I I"'-o/Iis). Ra venna thus would havc become a cit}' largely surrounded by water.
The PaJace(s) There wa~ certain ly an iml}t:rial residence in Ra venna , and whether or not it was called a pl/larim!! or "palace" at the time, it ix>camc known by this namc in later periods.s> The ccntra lization of the govern ment bureaucracy in the fourth century meant that the palace hatl to house a large staff of officials, and it was the setting for thc elaborate ceremonies in which the centrality of the emperor and his government were ,Iemonstrarell to his suojCcts. Bj Emperors had sporadically st;lyed at Raven n~ in the th ird ;}nd
55
,6
R.... V[ NN A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
fou rth centuries, ~" so a n:. sidcncc suitable lor temporarily housing the L"{)Urt must have existed . The permanent residence of HOll(Jrius and then V~len tinia n IU, howcI'cr, required a mOre signi 6cant set of buildings. There aTC faint hints in literary texts of {he splendor of this stnlcturc: two JXICIllS written around 44 3 by Flal,jus Merobaudes describe depictions of Valentini311 [II and his family on the walls and ceili.ng of a palace, perhaps one in Ra\fenna. ~$
Our only textual evidence for imperial palaces in Ravenna
COlllC5
from
Agncllus, who tells us: Honorius wanted co bllil(l a palace in Caesarca, the arca bctwl,'cn Ravenna and Classe, but his official Lauric-ius built instead a church ue(licarcd to St. Lawrence (ch. 35); later Agndlus refers to the "Laurentian palace" near the C aesarean gone hllflt' est tlkhlil pUI'ti/r O/ulln:lI, ll'/ictt) [..llll rwti I'II/ario), so perhaps a palace was built there too? (ch . 13z ) _. T hcoderic killed Ocloan:r in the pa lace At the La urc1 (ill ",tI/ltiu ill Ltlllro) (ch. 39) - it is also nu:nnonecl in two sixth-cenw ry chronicles that Odoacer was kil1e(1 ~il\ Laureto.":I(, ," Valentinian IIJ built a roral hall at the place called At the Laurel (il1/0(0 qui dicitlII' ad Laureta). (ch. 40) J.
Thes(' passages tell us that by the sixth century, the palace that was considered {O be imperial had [he name At the Laurel. "I 'his designa tion probably imitates the name of the Jl:llace of Daphnetll.oqlVTJ ("Laurel") in Constaotlnople, built. according to tradition, by Cooslantine.K, In chapter 132 Agnel1us 1listin guishes between the pllifftilllll '-"lIIn'lIIi and the pi/liIIilllll 'f'heuJuriCllmml later used uy the c.'{arch. implying that they were tv:o distinct structun:s;SB however, it is not dear whether the pll/atimJl Lmre/lri is the same as the plt/rltil/'lll il1 LrJ/lrQ/(,d l.lIl/reM , a lthough the similarity of the words has led to rnonern confusion. The location of th is pabce, or of any imperial palace (if indeed I-Ionorills would have inhabited a different onc), is entirely conjoctural. It has been suggested that the imperial palace must have heen locatetlnear San Giovanni Evangelista, ot church known to h;l\'C been built by G;\lIa PhlC'itl ia; it has been suggested that the palace quarter as describe(1 by Agnellus must havc covered the cntire southeastern sector of the city. And it was even suggcsted, although now discredited, that there \\' 3S a palace in the nonhwestern quarter of the dry, also built by Galla Placid i a. ~ A.s described in the previous chapter, the only part of the eastern sector of the city to have heen _~ubjecte11 to extensive archaeological excavation is the site known as the "Pa lace of T heoderic," so identified occausc Thcoderic's church, now
RAV EN NA AS A SEDES IMPERII
57
- --
--- --- -
--- ----
,
,
,,
,
,
,
,, \
'- ::::::I"J.
,,,,
\,, 0
0
_---- " O ~
\ ~
,
\ ,
\,
,
,,
\ ,
\,
,, ,
_.._.......... --.--
~ ---....
- --
o
5
10
lS
,
20
25 ...
,,
,, ,,
"
fl ~
"\,, , ,
,
\
- _ __I
called Sallt'A1xlllinare Nuovo, was atf<Jchetl to it. It is often assullled, based on Agncllus, th;1t this building must have been dilrcre:nt from the: palace o f Valentinian HI, and perhaps also of Honorius, which would han: been farther to the south. N. Duval goe:s so far as to argue tha t the remains found at this site arc merely those of an aristOCnltic ho use, not an imperial palace.90 But it is hard to understand why Theoderic and later the exarchs would have preferred to inhabit an old aristocratic house rather {han the forme r imperial palace. Recent stud it!S have shown that on the foundations of a Roman villa there was a major rd.)Uild ing in the fourth century, prcsumal>ly tonca te the r~i(lence of the pro\·incial governor or mil itary commander, followed by another elaboration in the caTl}' fifth century {Fig. 9 ) .~ 1 Another piecc of evidence in favor of this interpretation is that the western entrance to the palace is called by Agnellus and other sources Had Calchi," which probably imitates the ChalkclXcAKTl ga te of {he Grcat Pa lace in Constantinoplc, buill hy Constantine. \Vh.ile the date at which this !lame was appliell is uncertain, an attribution to the fifth century is not unlikely.?'
9' Plan ohh.c p~l ~cc, ~s kllown frum nco'~.-
1;""$, "'•. AD 450 (a fter A"g~nli, ~Ard".·{) I{)gi.I
e ropognfi.>."
' 0<,)5, I;g. 6)
,.
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400- 489
The l:xcav3tc(i arca was just part of what must have OCCll a much larger JllmlniStrative mel resilientia] complex, txtenlling presumably to the eaSt, north, and south, and flankcd on its western side by the plilfctllllffiQl-, or main road. "I'he struct\lrcs that were built or adapted for imperial me on this sic!,' in the early fifrh century were typical of luxurious \'i11as in [he late antique world. A large colonnaded courtYllrd was flanked by suites of rooms on at least the norrh and south sides. On the north sille the focal ('Ioim was a large
apscd hall, which was inrrcascd in site at some point ill the fifth century to ~ 7 X II m and was paved with a nmallie opus sertile pavement of imported marble. Around and to the south of the courtyanl, the corridors and smaller rooms were decorated and redecorated with mosaic pavementS; the rooms to the south were el'entu;ll1y turned inlo a bath complex complete with a hypocausr system ." j The,e dements of high-status living proba hI}' formed only a part of the palace complex. Since we <10 nOt know the full extent of the palace at any period in Ravenna's hiSTOry, we cannOt n:3th any conclusions about how Ravenna's palace may have <:ompared ro those in other imperial capitals.
Other Public Buildings One of the mysteries of Ravenna in the late imperial period is how much other construction took place within thc new city walls. As J. Ortalli has noted, "Popular opinion has it that the transfer of the capital revita 1i 7.cd the ci ty with new buildings and a higher urbanisric level. In reality there is no memory of such a direct initi,]{ive by !-Ionorius; when it happened it probably didn't integrate the eourt functionaries into the leX."al urban network.It guaranteed to the city a good public appearance and maimcnance of a certain technological vitality. " 'M It is inconceivable tha t the transfer of achninistra tive functions to Ravcnna could 1/1)1 have meant an increase in popu lation, but there is almost no archaeologica l evidence of widespread construction activities in the city. Is this attributable to the nature of archaeological evidence, and of the fa ilure of earlier archaeologists to recognize fifth-century materials? Or dill most of the population continue to live in Classe at this time, with only ,1 few imposing puulic uuiJ
OTIHIl.. I'UBLI C BU IL D INGS
major cities such as Aquileia. t\ mint was opencd in Ravcnna in 401, an importmt inlli(;ation (>f the city's sUllden devation in rank Y" Ravenna's mint produced a complete range of gol d ancl si lver coins from 401-55, and continued, with some interruptions, ~traight thrmlgh to thc cnll of thc cenrury and l:leyond, an indication of importance of Ra venna even arrer the death of Valentini an 1.11.""-; A mint that produced gold and silver coins re1luired protection. This leads to questions about its location. Agnellus rcfers twice to a location "at the mint" (rid "IIIQIJeftnn) in the northwest sector of the (;ity.'i' Dnnl1nent$, one from the year 57l and several from the eleventh century and later, name
59
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400- 489
60
such :Ill cll tcrt:.linmcnt facility. Perhaps most signi ficalll. the GJllk author Salvian, writing in the 4405, cOnt rastS " Roman plebs in the circu ~, ani] the pcopk of Raven na in tlu.' thC"Jtcr. ... ',"00 Fi nally, gil'ell what we know of thl,' location of gates, waterways, streets, and churches in fifrh- and si:"1:hcentury Ravenna, it is difficul t to know where a large circus could have been located . All of the ci,'cuses built in imperial capitals in the fourth and fifth centuries wefe over 440 meter long, a[1<1most wert' oriented north-south. '''7
1\'i. Johnson's suggestion that a circus was oriClHcd cast-west just to the sou th of the church of Sant'Agata 10.'1 raises the problem that rhe (I istancc between the Padcnna and thc pllftm lJIaiOI" at this IXlim was only 35 0 111; if a cir,·us ha(l bccn squcclcel in here, it wouln havc bcen an impossibly small one. E. Cirelli, on the other hand, proposes a circus oriented llorthsouth on the Wl..~t side of the plllf~{1 waior, which coulel have been 450 111 in length. ''''I H owewr, all of these proposals are completely hypothetical; in the absence of ally archa(.'Ologkal evidence, it is hanl to make the case that Ravenna had a circus attached to the imperial palace. \Vc havc cven less c\'idence for other public f:lcilities. ' ·Vith the arrival of thl.' COllrt and thl.' cvcr-i ncreasing population of the town, anothl.'r prohlcrn was the provisioning of the dty Hid ilS inhabil:lms. "o Sidon ius Apollinaris's letter written around 467, alter
Churches Churches are the o ne set o fhuild ing~ for which we have much more sound evidencc, since somc of them still sorvive today. In the post-Consta ntin ian era it was expected that C hristian emperorS wo uld Imi l(1 chur<:hes, especia lly in illl])(Jrt3m cities, and in this one aspect, at least, Ravenna provides plenty of suita blc evidence. rvl ajor parts of at least fi\·c strucrures from the fifm century still stand and relatively de tailed information about others comes to us from texts. Together these strllctures form an important part of the corpus of early Christian art and architecture, and tl1U.~ have been extensively stu(\ied by art histOrians for the last 100 years.
CHUI{CHES
One striking feature cOlllmon to all of tht.:se bu ildings is that, like the city walls, they were made of bricks that had been reused from earlier Roman structu res. In addition, they incorporate columns, capitals, and other picces o f architt..-ctu ral scu lphl re rhatwerc li kewise taken fro m earlier monu ments. This useofJPo/iil is evidence for the ruined state of Ravenna, and for the large amounts of reusa ble build ing materials a\'ailable in 400. Scholars today still debate whether this was simply a question of practicality, or whether the reuse of spolia had symbolic meaning. cspL'Cially of the reappropria tion o f the Ro man past. but most o fthese discussions arc about the Cnmtantinian period ." ) By 400 when Ravenn a's ch urches bega n to appear, botb migh t have been tT\le: By this time it was expected tha t a noble church would be built of spolill. and in th e case o f Ravenna, where speed was o f the essence and a ruined city la}' all arouml, the use of '"poIiIl solve{] several problems at once.
Churches;11. the HonQriOll Period There must h,lVe been some churches in Ravennil. before the arrh'al of the imperial court, bUT of those we have only vague references. Howt::ver, tor the period after 400, we have ever mort:: cerrain evidence for the construction o f churches ~ponsored by the emperors and by others, mOst notabl), the bishops . The cathedral and baptistery complex, begun soon after '100, will be considered in detail belo w. It should be no ted here that while there is no evi,ience of imperial p:ltTonage of the cathed ral, it is not unlikely mar H onorius and his family materially assisted the construction and decoration o f these buildings, as they are known to have done ill Rome . The only churdl specifically attri huted to the reign of HOllorius was (IeO delivered about 42 5 . 1111 A~ usual, Agnellus is o ur main SOUrl.:e for the existence o f this ch urch in Ravenna. H e tells us th at Honorius wanted to build a palace to the south of Ravenna, and he commissioned his 11!(1/0r mhiclI/i Lauricius to supen'ise it, but the pious Lauricius took the moncy and built instead a church dedicated to St. Lawrence. Honorius was angry that his orders had been (lisobeyed, but a vision of St. Lawrence induced him [0 ove rlook this misappropriation offu nds. 1 1 ' Thc e:.:tramural church, built in an cxisting cemetery, was a martyrial basilica rhat was used for funera ry purposes, thus it funnioncd likc the fourth-ccntury basilica of St. Lawrcnce outsi
6.
6.
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400- 489
Rome.' ,S Lauricius himself was eventually buried in a chapel dedicated to Sts. Stephen, Gervase, and PrOtase, martyrs whvse veneration waS parti(:ularly promoted in the years ~round 400. I '" Agncllus quotes the dedicatory inscription of the chapel that says that" Lauri6us dedicated this on September 19. in the 15th rear o fTheodosius rU] and Placid us Valentin ian IIlIl," thus in the year 435. 11 " Agnellus also tells us of llllother inscription commemorating o ne Opilio.'" who generously supported the church and was
buried in the south aisle. The church of St. Lawrence was demolished in 1553 and its lmilding I..Umponcnts were ta ken to various m her churches; from the little surviving documentary evidence it seems to have been a basilica with a nave and aisk'S separa tcd by rows of f\I.·clvc or fiftl.'en coluIllns, but heyonJ that we knoll' nothing abou t its ex-dCt location or appearance. ' "
GaUIl Plnddhl's Churches Calla Placidia's chief claim to fame in Ra\'cnna was her S\lpport of thc C hurch and her patronage of churches. An active promoter of religious or thOlIo.~y, along with TheOtlosius U and his sister Pulcheria in the east, she supported the C hurch at a time when heresies about the nature of Christ were flouris hing, and she wrote to Theodosius II an(1 Pulcheria in support of Pope Leo 1'5 position at the Second ('..ouneil of Ephesus in 449 ." .\ She was closely connected with variOIlS popes; shc had Qcen actively involvc(1 in 3 .schisllI involving the p3Jl:lCY in 418-19," 4 and it is possible thar she gave ber palace in Constantinople to the popes, since in the seventh ami eighth centuries their reside.nee in C.o nstantinopie is called the "house of Placid ia.''' 'S She contributed to decoration and rellol'arion at the basilica oISt. Pau l Outside the Walls an(1Santa Croce in Gerusalemme in Rome. ,,6 Galla's piety is also highl ighted in the biography of St. Gcrmanusof A\l XerrC, an ascetic bishop from Fra nce who visited the impcri:lll'Ourt on business anti died while in Rayen na in [he 430S or 44os. "7 Her coim, mimed firs t in Constantin ople and then in Ravenna, Aqu ileia, and Rome, tIepin her in imperial <.: m tume, with the monogram o f Christ prom inen tly emhroi(lered on her shoulder, and, in some <.:3ses, [he Ha lllJ of God holding a crown over her head, while on the reverse a personificarion of Victory holli s a jeweled crOSS (Fig. 8). T hese lllotif~ were licrivcd from the coinage of the eastern emperors, fi rst used for ThcodosillS II and h is sister Pukheria shortly after 41O. "~ Agncllus makes C alla the star of his sectio n on imperial Ravenna, chiefly beca use of her patronage of the C hurch. She is credited with the eOllsrrucdOll of the major ch urches ofSant,l Croce and San Ciova llni Evangelista in
C HUI{C HES
Ravenna, and AgnelJus says that her niece also ouil t a chapd dCIlicared to Sr. Zacharias. Galla abo gave p recious objects to the church of Ravenna, ~uch as a large lamp with her image on it and i\ chalice. ' '9 H er (XIrtrait, along with i lll~ges of hcr chil{lrcn, could still b(.> found in S~n Giovanni Evangelista in the ninth cenrury. She was a major supporter of one of Ravenna's most notable bishops, Peter Chrysologl.ls (ca. 43 1- ; 0), and Agnelllls erroneously credits a church dedic:l tetl to Sts. John the Baptist and Barbarian to Gal la's and Chrysologus's joint patronage. 'J" As we have seen, Agnellus attrioutes the construction of the walls an.1 pala{:es of Ravenna to Va J cntini~ n III, which would also ha\'e becn sponsored by Galla . Some of th(.> chllf,'h(.>s built by Galla Placidia still survive, and arc thus extremely im(XIrtant for an undersunding of the development of art and architecture in Ravenm at this time. As we will see, the form al1(l decoration of these StrU('tures expressed new iconographies Ileveloped to link Christianity atHl imperial rule. T he lise ofirnperia l l)Ortraits in church decoralion was something new, rem inding the community of GOII's protection o f imperial dy nasty and empire. T his iconography would be repeated in other churches in Ravenna, literally creating a Christian ,·api tal through the images found on its churches. S.l.N 610 \'A"'N I [ '·ANG ELISTA
During a sea \'oyage the shi p carrying Galla Placidia and hl;'r two children was beset by a storm. '3' T he empress cried out to St.John the Ellangelist for protection, vowing to bui ld him 3 church in R,lVcnna ifrhe ship was spared. Upon her return to Ravenna, she built this church, near to the small harhor i.n (he nortbeast corner of tbe cit)', and arranged to have it decorated witb mosaics that told the story of her preservation and glorifie(1 the imperial dy nast}' of which she and her children were a part. 'J! \-Ve do not know exactly when the church was built, but it wa$ probably shortly after Galla and her children had taken triumphant control of Ravenna in -+ 25. S~n Giova nni Evangel ista still stands, in large part rebuilt after it w~s accidentally bombed by Allied forces in 'W orld Wa r II (who were aim ing at the nearby train station), and, like all the churches of Ravenna, it was redecorated and rebuilt st"\'eral times in its history: the floor was raised ;}nd repaved Ln 1 ~ 13, 'Jl ;lnJ the n;l\"e arc;lde aJHI II'alls wcrc raised in the fifteenth cenrury, ').; T he church was the object Qf extensive re5torarions from 1919- 2 I, and aftc:rthe bombing duri ng \'lorld \Var U, fu rther investigat ion was carried out as part: of the rcconstruction, T he original wall decoration had been remove(1 in 1568, but written descri ptions have allowed scholars to reconstruct something of what it might have looked like, and we can therefore see how it tin; with Galla's general aims allil intentions as empress.
6,
R.... V[NNA AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERORS. AD 400 - 489
.- - .-~-
I
•
~
~
•
~
• •
~
•
,,,
~
,
• • I D.
San
Gim'ann, Evon"dis"" plan of .he ~;Hly /if" ,_ ""nm,,· phase (uftcrGross_ "",n n,
' Q6.+,
.:.:::.::1.
~
!Ii)
~
,. • • ,. l\I AI •
...
- -
=>ill'
f
r.g. :)
San Giovanni Evangrdista is a ba5ilica made almQst cntird}' of reused R01ll31llllatcrials: brick for the walls. and first- to fourth-century colulIlns and their bases and Corinthian capitals [0 scpar;ltc the nave from tht;' aisles. ' 3, The original building (Fig. 10) had :In interior colonnade of nine columJls on each side; newly carved im post blocks (tru ncated pynlll1i-
tlal StOlle blocks) were plaeN! bern'cen each capital anti the springing of the arcade. T he upper parts of the walls arc later construction, bm they originally comainc(1 windows both on the e>.terior aisle walls and on the clerc$tor~' walls above the nave arcade, resulting ill an unusually brightly lit intcrior. ,~6 \·Vhcn first built, rhe church was emerea through a narthex that was 9 meters deep; no rth and south of the narthex we re small chambers. approximately 7 x 6,5 meters, emered from the na rthex through arches su pported hy columns. Rooms like this are well known from Greek ch urcllt~s built ;It the same time. ' n T heir lo('arion is similar to the chapels/mausolea at the end~ of rhe narthex o f Santa C roce, and Agnellus mt:ntions somt:olle who was buried in the eighth century "in the corner of the entranceway" of San Giovanni Evangelista, which might rl'fl'T to a sidl' chamber. ' 38 The narthe.'I: opened to the exterior through a colonnade composed of six columns. and probably comained three doorways into the church, one for the nave and one tor each of the aisles.
Os
CHURCHES
"
, • _ ..... ' "',_101,
-
-" .....
,
_M _-"
,-,
'
. .....• ..-. ....'_.
,
•
At some point the narthex WllS absorbed into the nave, wh ich was elon gated to its preSent dimensions with twelve columns on each side; at this time an atrium was added and thc sideehambers wcre remO"ed (Fi g. T r). ' N No distinetion can he made between the original eighteen columns and the six that were added; al l {\I.·eney-four impost blocks werc made at one time in the fifth century. The impost blocks (and the ~ulumns and ~.. pit;als) of the westernmost three bays of the nave must theretUre ha,'e been pan of the origina l church, and Grossmann has suggested that th~1' were us~-d originally in the narthex. ' ¥' The date of this modification is the subject of controversy. It has becn suggest~-d that thc plan "'as changed shortly aher its origina l construction, or that it w:lS mod ified when new mos.aics wcre installed around 600, 'i ' Howcver, R. FarioH points out that Agnellus refers in the ninth cent:ury to the nanhex of this church, and thus it is mOSt likely thaI the changes should be dated to the temh or elevcnth century, at the time of the construction of the campanile to the southeast of the narthex. 'i' The castern end of the na"c tcrrninat~"<."Ome traditional for Ravenna's churches. Inside the alISo:, a bench for the clergy, with a throne for the bishop at the center, ,,'as attached to thc interior WllII, terminated at each cnd by columns that upheld the triumphal arch over the apse. 'i l The allSc was vaulR-d with a semidome made of I1lbi firrili, interlinked hollow clay tubes, but the layout of the win_ dows IJt,I0w the \':lult is also the suhj(.><."t of ,Ichatc. '+I The current apse,
1 I.
Son Gio-
.. nni F'''''~ Ii,,,, . pl.n
of,.,.,
mOOified chll,.d., ",,,,nth-tenth =,"~ . . (.fior G rx:&lIl."n, '<)64, fig. J)
RA VINNA AND TH E WESTE RN EM PE RORS, AD 40(}-489
rebuilt in the [94°S (Fig. ! 2). conm ins seven windows that arc 2,75 meters high, immediately below the level of the springing of the dome; these windows ate separated hy douhle-eolonnettes, AO()ding the al>se with light. The colonnettes date stylistically to the fifth century and came from the Prownnesian workshops of ConStantinople, which implies that this feature was original to the building, although it has also been proposed that the se"en-arch feanlre had been a loggena that aniculat~-d the wall surface on lyon the eXterior of the bui Iding. '. 5 Below these windo""s the outlines of three smaller windows, now filled in, can be ~en along the bad, wall of the apse; either these were a lower row of windows-or they were the original windows, with the upper wne add~-d later. Since no other surviving apse from Ravenna has a feature like the scven-arched opening, neither windows nor loggetta, and since in all other cases the apse windows are taller than the lower niple array, we can on ly conclude that the o riginal arrangement in San Giovanni was unique, whichever form it took. The a]>se was flanked by two rct:tangular chambers that were entered from the aisles; they measure 5 x 6 meters, and each of their e>;ternal walls contains two an;hed windo~ approximately 1.5 meters wide and l meters high. Below the level of the windows, the interior northern, eastern, and southern walls each contain two niches ! X 1.25 meters and 0.56 meters deep. These rooms are ohen called {JMInpbtrrir, a term that refers to spaces wi th particular liturgical functions du ring the Eucha ristic service, but these rooms ~"nnot have had this fun~-tion, sinl"t' they did not communk"te directly with the apse. J. Smith has presented evidence that the northern chamber, at least, had a hypocaust, or wall-heating, system in it, and suggests that these spaces were used as libraries. As she notes, such side chanlbcrs flanking the apse were known from many churehes in Ravenna, but in each ease the function or funetions weTC different. ,. " St. John is the on ly evangelist who frequently had churches dedicated to him in late antiquity. Re\'ered as the author of the Gospel of John and the Book of Revelation , biographies of him began to circulate in the early fihh century, and included references to his conn~"Ction with sea trawl and stonns. John's burial si te at Ephesus in A~i a Minor was marked by a fourthcentury church, and another church in his honor e. isted by the time of Thoodosius I in the suburb of Constantinople Imown as the Hebo:iomon, ncar a harbor and an imperial I",iace. '41 Deichmann asscrt5, on the basis of a few later topographical references, that San Giovanni Evangelista was built near the imperial palace in Ravenna. J-t8 Bur, while the eastern 7.one of the city cerm inly oontained buildin~ that were part of the administrative complex, there is no evidence that San Giovanni Evangelista was in any way J "palace ehurch,~ as it is ohtn called. '.9
"
CHURCHES
" .s."
GioVlInni han_ g
"One reason for it~ anribunon a~ a palace church is the apse mosaics, in which IXlnraiu; of Christian emperors featured prominently. The mos.aics no longer sUn'ive, but descriptions of them are found in Agnellus, in {\I.'O sermons from the fourt~...,nth wnturywrincn on the occasion of the n-.:k'
RA VINNA AND TH E WESTE RN EM PE RORS, AD 40(}-4 89
where they have been placed in this reconstruction. '55 Rossi lists them: on the right, Constantinus, Theodosius, A=dius, Honorius, and TheodO'lius >I.p.; on the left, Valeminianus II I, Gratianm., ConSt:l.nti us 1111 ?J, Gratian u~ >Itp., and Johannes "'p. These figu res link imperial rule, and Galla's family members in partkubr, to orthodoxy; not:l.bly, emperors whose orthodoxy was questionable, such as Valens, Valentinian II, and Constantius II, were not depiet~-d. '56 T he epithet "'p. is probably Rossi's misread ing of NP, the abbreviation for "iJbilimmur purr, a title bestowed upon imperial chi ldren; th~ hoys may ha'"C been d~",aSt:d sons of Th l"()(iosi us I, ',7 or perhaps Thoodosius >If{!. was the son of Galla Placidia by Athaulph. '58 Dcichmann supposes that Rossi may have gotten some of the names wrong, either because of his source or because they were degraded with time. '59 In any case, the main male m lers of the Christia n empire are obviously the focus o f this series. In the apse itself. the semi dome comained a large image of Christ seated on a throne holding an open hoo k in his hand that oomaintd a quote from Matthew 5:7, "Blessed are the merciful, for God will show mercy to th em."'oo Christ was surrounded hytwelve books representin g the apostlL'S; this is an exmlOrdinary concept that is not known from any other apse image, although Gospel books in bookshelves do appear in the St. La wrencc mos:a ic in the "mausoleum of Galla Pl aci dia, ~ dating to exactly the same period. Below the dome, probably just above the "indow level around the interior of the apse, was the main dedkatory insni l'tio n: ,", Thc empress G all o 1'laciJio with hcr 'Ow to the holy and mOst bles.so..J 'IJOstle John the h.ngdist for their ddive"ll1cc from ,Imgcr
., ....
Symbols of thc evangelists may have flanke d thc windows . Below thc windows ran another inscri ))tion from P5:llm 67(68)"9-3°' "Confinn, 0 God, that which you havc wroughl for us; from your temple in Jerusa lem, ki ngs shall offer you gilis."'6' Belo"· this, on the wall alx"'e the clergy's bench, were shown on the right Tnoodosius 11 an d his wife Eudoci3, and on the left Area dius and his wife Eu doxia . T he depiction ofthcse eastern rulers in such a promincnt position underscored the wcstern court's relationship with the cast. Givtn the inscri ption ahove their heads, it is )>ossi bie that they were shown in the act of presenting something 10 Christ or to the central figure on th is wa ll, Bishop Peter I Ch rysologus, who "'as depicted celebrating mass in the presence of an an gel. ,6) As far as we know, San Giovanni Evangelista is the first church anywhere to ~"Ontain imperia l portra its as )>:lrt of its dtcora til)n.' ''' San Giovanni Evangelista's cntire decorative program emphasizes thc piety of the
CHURCHES
a . ; " glHNgo
.k>Iw _
"""'.,
E-'~c
.........
,
co, ~".""'...I" ~
Sol.. _,.. WI/« PI
Silip"" Goi .. Pi«;i.. ...,j kr,liJm.o, "....
..,....,..........
.. "'" b,'JoIoo ....
' ;"og
F."".¢~ ,
E,"
-
"._CIris<
_Mc_';" '".,..' _ _
..... . ........,_,
d,~
~"""
""..", p -
O<) ' q'"
_..... "'. of··
v.n....o.. '"'.... 11
-
e..<.c ..
I
J. Son Gi<>-
'~TU1i
E""ngoo-
Ii.... re",o,"",ruc· 000 d"lP"'m of tho ....,..icsof the triumrJ>ol.n;h
.... imperial dynasty and its connections to God and the Orthodox Church. All of the inscriptions emphasize the role of kings in the divine plan ; even the boo\.: held by the enthroned Christ in the apst: (I uotc~ the Beatitude of particular relevance to ruleN, emphasizing compa~sion and charity by those in position~ of power. The "cry depiction of Christ on a throne underscore~ the parallel i~rn hetween the earthly and heavenly rulers. Bi~hop Peter Chrysologus, as we will see, was closely connected with the imperial court, and he spt'cifical1y praises Gal!. Placidi. for her merl)' (m;m"ironJill) in his Sermon 130. ,65
~
R.... V[ N N A AND T H E WESTE R.N [MPER.O RS, AD 400 - 489
' I'he t:Onstruc tion o f a church in commemoration of the salvation of G<1lla and her child ren underscorell GOII's protection of the dynasty, represented br the portraits of irs mcmber.>, At this particular moment. G alla 's triumph over the \15urpl.'r John, shl.' reminded (he members of the Ro man eli te establishment of her divine claims to power and o f the support of tbe rule rs in the ellsrern empire, 1M SM.'T,\ C R OCR
In a,ldition to San Giovanni Evangelista, Agne){us td ls lI S that Calla P lat:idia built a chu rch dcdicated to the H oly Cross. and he notcs a tradition thn she prayed there at night, prOStrate on the porphyry pavement, by the light of candles. ,67 The church w~s built in the northwest pan of the new CilY, on top of Roman houses that had been in rui ns since The t hird centu ry AD. 1M; It retainell its original form until the later M iddle Ages; in th e late foutee nth century the north- sou th arms and the chancel \I'ere removed, in the late sixteenth Cl.'ntllly the narthex was Ill.'stwYl.'d , anll in 160 2, 7 meters of the western end of the nave was destroyed to make way for a street now named Via Calla Placidia .' ~ Parts of the ch urch arc s(il1 \'isiblc; it W;JS I.'x1:l.'nsively I.'XC;Jvared in the earl y twentieth cenIDry, in 1967-80 lind in the ((;80s-90s, and so the history of the site and irs construction stages are well understood, ' ?O The church dellicated to the Cross was built of reu sed Roman bricks; the exterior of the walls were articulated wi th pila5ters and perhaps blind arcades, a~ have survivcd for the southcnl chapel. Unique in Ravenna , the ch\lrch has a ground plan in the for m of a Latin cross, with a single aisleless nave ( I I. W III wille), wide transepts to the north and sou th , and a reClangular chancel (Fig. 1-+) , 1;1 T he individual parts of the church do not foUow a strict rectilinear Ilesign ; the angles of \'ariou ~ partS of the walls are Iluite skewc!l, c~pcriall y the enJ~ of the crossarms. In pl:m, thc llU ild ing is vcry similar to other cross-shaped chur(·hes buil t in capitalt:ities, especially the BfUi!i{(/ l /po"o/am1ll and the R'.,-ifim Virgilllll11 (now San Si ll1 pliciano) in J\
C HUI{C HES
7'
NI<"
• •
' 4. The S,Ul'" Cmcccompl~x , ,,~ . AD 450 C"J" ptd f ru", Gdi<:h i/No,"",,",
t9'J5. fig. pJ
(bWIII ), 175 tha t tht:ft: ~'as a st:lllicifculaf bench (lJllfhrolioll) arOlmn the inte-
rior of the re<..'tangular chancel,' ;1> as well as a raised pathway (soll'l1) along th e nave leading to tbe pulpit (a mbo). AJI of these features show the influ -
ence of Con ~r-Jntillopolitan architecturalllirurgical treIHk '·i The chancel was surrounded by adJiuonal rooms, some of which may havc \}cCIl open courtyanls, dirtttly connectc{1 to either the chancel or aisles. J. Smith has ~uggested that the entire complex was intended as an imitation of the
Holy Sepulchre com plt:x in J eru5.11t:1ll, with a large open cOIlftyan\' a small shrine off that courtyard analagous to the shrine of (',.olg-orha, and o ther rooms to racilitate the passage o f clergy and congrega nts during the Easter ceremonies. r~~ An unusual feature is the presence, on the north and south si{\es of the Jl;l\'e, of externa l colonn;}ded porches or porticoes, 4 meters wide, which e~1:en{!et1 from the narrhex to the crOss-arms. Such external porches arc not known from an}· of thc Othcr basilicas in Ravcnna, although S~n Simpliciano in Milan h ~d a dosed passage along its nave wa lls. Santa Croce's porches were use\i fo r burial starting at leas[ in the sixth century, ' 7') although we do not know whether they were built for this purpose. T he porches had figured mosaic J1oor~ with geometric allil \'eget31l1lOtifs which were subsequently cut into the llUri;}ls. ' So
or
7'
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400- 489
At irs western cnd, the (hurch was fronu:d by a narthex that was (j Illeters deep a011 extended 4 m willer than the n~\'e, at least on the southern side,
where its presence has been dctcnnincd . T hc southern end ofthis narthex was conneCted to a small cross-shapcl[ ch~peI that is now known as thl,' "mausoleum of Galla Placidi;!." Excavations in the mid- nineteenth ami early twentieth centuries showed that the chapel was entered through a triple archway leading to a vestibule that was raised up a step from the levd of the narthex; two further steps led from the \'csib\l[c into the chapcl. '~1 The triple archway wa, stlStaincI[ by nm columns set on bases of red Verona marble, with colonncttcs on the sidewalls on inlaid marble bases.':!' T he floor It.,,,'cl ofthe "m~us{lleum" was I I centimeter higher than the n~rthcx, and the type of bricks and mortar are differem in the chapel from those of the mait) church, which has led to the conclusion that it was built slightly later than the narthex. , Rl It has bcen proposc(l that originally there was a corresponJing chapel ~t the north end of the narthex, which is now relatively in3cccssiblc to exca\ · ation .' s~ and that th is northern chapel might be the one described by Agnellus as built by Galla's "niece" Singledia ncar Santa Croce and dedicatell to St. Zacharias.'85 G. Pavan's description of the mosaics found in e.~cavatiolls idelltifk-s the ones found by I)i Pietro in 19! 5--6 as dating to the Roman period, all(1 they thus do not pnwide information about a northern chapeJ. JS6 Gdichi amI Novara, on the basis of the most recent excavations, indicate the existence of a vestibule on the north end of the narthex, but do nor show a chapel. ,8; In the fifth ce1lfury this part of fhl;' city contained sel"eral small chapels; one, for e.xampie, lay on the si te of the sixth-century chutch of San Vitale . ,~S Tbus, it is nor neccssa ry to presume that Sing-leilia's chapel was at the northern end of Santa Croce's narthex. On the: other hand, San G iovanni Evangelista hall ch apels flanking both emls of its narthex, SO it is certainly possible that the same layout was found here. The richness of Santa Croce's decoration is indicated by the surviving mosaics in the ~lllausoi eum." From archaeology we know that the church was pavcd in largc panc:ls of geometric Opllf smile and contained c:laboratc wall revemt;'JU, al l madt'ofltlack, whitt', and polychrome mar blt'.•110) Agnellus tells us that Galla used to lie o n porphyry roundcls on the !loor; these have now Ilisa ppeareli, bu t their use is wel l known both in Ravenna and elsewhere in this period. ' ~ \Vhat we know about the imagery in the main church also comes from Agncllus, who tells \IS: The Elllllt"eSS G~lb b\lilt the chll["(;h of rhe Holy Cross, constrllcted of most prec ious stoncs ~n\l "ith carvcd smcco;q· gnd in rhe roundness of the fII"\:hes there are mt:(rical "e~s reading thus:
CHURCHES
"John w.shes Christ at the font in the SCot of p.rodisc; where he gi~es. h.ppy life, he poin" the ""Y to m.nyrdom," On the f:>c. de of thot temple, enteri~ g the m. in
RA VINNA AND TH E WESTE RN EM PE RORS, AD 40(}-489
that it was bui lt aftcr 415."'" Bodies wcre buried both in the porches and around the church after it was first built, probably after the end of the fiftb cenrnry, and perhaps sub,..... juent to the C()nstruction o f the southern narthex chapel. It bas been suggested that Santa Croce was intended as a cemeterial church, '~' although since the burials date later than the first pbase of tbe cburch, it does not seem that a funerary purpose was originally meant.'"' The construction of this church dedicated to the Holy Cross by an empress, was most likely intended as a reminiscen~-e of the mUSt powerful and pious Cbristian empress, Helena, the mother of Constantine, who was by this time famous fur her discovery of the True Cross in Jerusalem. Helena had built a church dedicatt'd to the Cross in Rome, a fact of which Galla Placidia "'3S well aware, since she and her chi ldren sponsored a mosaic in that church also.' ~J '1'he Tbeodosian dynasty used the motif of the cross on its C()ins as a symbol of victory (Fi g. 8),''''* and G alla Placidia may ban: felt that the imperia l family should sponsor the veneration of the Cro>s; perhaps she had acquired a relic of the True Cross, wh ich was to be boused in this church, '0, or perhaps she felt that a church of this sort would provide a suitable focus for au imperia l mausoleum.
When Calla Placidia died in Rome, sbe was probably buried in the imperia l mausoleum at St. Peter's;'''" but by the ninth wnturythe legend had grown up that she was huried in a side chapel in San Vitale in Ravcnna , and by the thirteen th century this legend had herome C()nfused and her buria l was atrributcd to the structure that is still known as the "mausoleum of Galla Placidia."'OJ This small cross-shaped srructure, which now stands d,>t.ched fro m .ny other building, "'3S Ori ginally .ttached to the southern end of the narthex of Santa Croce.'oij It is therefore C()rrcct to 3ttribute the l"(lnsrruction of this chapel to Galla's )).1rronage, and to see it as one small part of what must have been 3 magnificent oomple~ . This chapel is one of on ly thn-e late antique strucntrcs in Ravenna that retain their compk'te decorative programs. It thus provides a small sample of thc ricbness of interior decoration found in imperially sponsored buildings at this time. \\'e will return tothe question of whether it was intended asGalla Placidia's mausoleum. The "mausoleum" is a small cross-shaped structure built mainly of reused Roman brick,''''' "'hich may originally have been covered ",i th plaster (Figs. 15, 16)."° The east-w~st branch m~asures 3-4 x 10.2 !11l'ters (interior), while the north-routh branch is 3.4 x ! T.9 meters, longer because it originally l"Onnt"(;ted the srruCtllre to the vesti bule and narthex. Interestingly. the angles of the C()rners arc not precisely 9D degrees, hut arc slightly skewed so that each component of the plan is not a r~"(;tangle but a
CHURCHES
' 5. "Abu_ ooIeumofG:.J], P!xid;': exte_ rior vi .... from
,he ,o,"h~·<s' (I.how E. V."",,)
parallellogram. Origioally the ground IL'vel W3S ~ j>proximately J . 5 m lower than it is today, and thus the building .....ould have had a higher profile. Each o f the exwrna l walls is nticulatcd with a blind arcade, whose pilasters rest on a plinth now partially below ground. '" The entrance wall, with
'
...
16. "Abu_ ",",um of G.l], P!xid;': plan
"grouOO 1","<1 (oft.,. Dekhm.M. '9i6. l~ 8)
,
•
"
RA VENN" AND TH E WESH RN EM PE RORS, AD 40(}-489
the door that led to the vestibule, has no arcade, hut was cO\-en~d "im marble revetment;'" {he doorway's lintel is a reused marble cornice with a fiNt-Cenrury AD IhC'Chic friew."l Around the building. J brick cornice complete with dentils on the underside marks the roollinc; behind the cornice, wooden beams were inScrtl-d in the interior of the wall, presumably for stability. Over the central core of the building a square rower rises I r tn, topped by a brick oomice identical to the one on the lower leveL At the summit of the centra l lo"'cr is a marble pinecone. ' 'i The chapel's walls arc pierced by windows at three levels. Each of the walls of the ccntr:lllOwcr bas a rectangular window just about the roollillC. The "..,d, of the cast, south, and west anns have a window in the rectangular pediment (which corresponds to the lunette fonned by the harrel vault on the interior). And at the level of thc exterior blind araldc, narro'" slits are found on SL'ven of the wall surfaces (as shown in Fi g. 16)." I T he windows now arc coI'cred with thin slabs of alahaster, a gift from King Victor Emmanuel III in 1908_ II", 6 but it is more likely that they were originally coated with glass. Inside thc building, the space rcpeats what is dcmarcated by thc architccrureofthe exterior. Each crossann is surmnunted by a harrel vault that rises 6.3 mctcrs abovc the original floor level, and the ccntral space is covcrL-J by a dOlrnical vault (3 vault in which the dome continues dOlwn through pcndcntives) to a height of 10.7 meters. Al l Olf the vaulting is done in brick; for the dome, the bricks arc la id in conL'Cntric circles. In both barrel vaults and dome, clay amphor.lc were laid on top of the bricks of the vaults, beneath the roof, for support."? The floor in the building today, made of marble opur uctift, was laid in 1540 whcn the floor level was raised 1 -43 metcrs above thc original IcvcL The lower part of thc walls on the inside are sheathed in marble fL,.,.ennent; the yellowish Siena marble is mostl y a restoration donc in 1&)8--1901, but was based on fragments of giollo on(iro that werc presumed to hal'e been part of the original dccor.ltion. ' ,8 A marble stringcourse with a bead-andreel pattcrn articulates the flat revctmcnt; a plain sUtero cornicc separates the revetment from the rone of glass-tesscne mosaie that covers the upper parts of tbc walls and the vaults (PL la). The brill iance of the colors of the mosaic, the lavish use of gold, the richness and l"lIricty of {he abstract dCLurati\'c motifs, and {he darity of {he figural images are overpowering; a term often used to describe the effect in th is small space is ~jewe1 box." Thc fact tba{ {he mosaic program has been I)rcserved in its entirety has invited schOllars to identifY meanings uniting the different pans, based on thc prcsuml-J origin and fu nction of the buildi ng. Other studies have c:
CHURCHES
' 7. "Abusoiounl
ofG.n.. Plxidi.,. wc>t onn with . lunette ofd"., drinking (l>OOt()
I"";'"t fUr Kunstge><:hichte der Johannes
Gutenberg UniverSi"t ,\bin>., 8;IJdmnboml:)
based on style an d technique. " 9 We will first sec what is depicted in the mosaics, and will thcn discuss the meaning of the architecture and the il'()nography l'()nsidcred as a whole. The ba rrel ~aults of the anns arc covered with abstract patterns. On the north and south anns, the vaults contain a regular panern on a dark blue ground consisting of larger and smaller rosenes, worked primarily in red, Ught blue, gold, an d white, which has been compared to F-"lstern textiles (1'1. h). no In the east and west anns, the vault mntains against a dark blue ground a gold grapevine that springs from an acanthus plant I;() filJ the sp.Ke. At the center of each side, standing on a SOrt of l1lt1delabrum springing from the acanthus plant, stands a small gold male figure wearing a tun ic (dolmarica) and mantle (pI/Ilium) and holding a scroll (Fig. 17); these have been interpreted as four apostles, as the evangelists, or as prophets.'" The vine "·as a popular dl'COtative motifin Roman art, adoptl"
7·
RAVENNA ..... N D HI E W[STEltN EMI'E RO RS. AD 400- 489
garland rising from baskets al1
1lle mosaics of tile lunettes 3[ the ends of the arms are brillian tl}' conceived {O acrommooa te a semicircular space with a window in the middle.
The lunettes in the east and west aflllS acc fill&1 with acamhus scrolls workel[
in green and gold. against 11 dark blue background . On a narrow groundline, two deer, entwined in the acanthus, face each other across a pool of water, which fits below the window (Fig. 17)' This image visu al i ~,cs Psalm 41(41);1; "As a hut longs for springs o f wncr, SO my soul longs for fhce, 0 God": the use of deer as symbols of de\·otion and of baptism is common in the fifth century.2: i ' nlC JUliette on the south arm is the first o lle vi sible to someone who enters from the door on the north side. T he \'ivid depiction (;(Illsists of three clements resting Oil a shallow green grounll, set against a h~ekgro\lnd gradated in shadesofbl ue (Fig. I S). To the leftofth ewindow is II cupboard, or (//71111";11111. that conuins four l"Odcx books labl:k'd as the four Gospels: from du' top left, they are Mark, Luke, Matthew, and John. In the center of the lunene, 1x=neath the window. is a metal gri ll on wheels over 3 roaring fi re. To the right of the window, a haloed and bearded man dressed in a striped i/11//JI(lti( (I and white pilililllll runs toward the grill. Over his righ t shoulder he bears a large processional cross and in his left hand he displays an open book whose pages ~e1ll to depict ~·ritin g. although no real letters are shown. The particularity of the clements of the !;Cene, and its prom inence on the wall facing the entrance, imply that it had particu la r meaning in th is chapd, and yet the idenri ty of this figure is l'Olllrovcrsial. "5 \ ,Vllile some have suggestel] that the figure is Christ,"'" it is generally agreed that lx:cause the person is drCllsed as a deacon. carrying the oujeets borne by deacons in the mass, he must be a de~con and ma rtyr who was gril led alive. -, 'he mostwidcly venerated saint who fits this descri ption is St. Lawrence, who, as we have seen , was the objcct of particular veneration by the T heodosian dynasty. In this interpretation. the presena.' of the cupboard with the GOSI>els is seen as a symbol of that for which Law rence w~s 1t13rt)'rL"\1. Although in carly Christian art La wrence is often shown l-oeing roastt:<1 on the grill, there are also representatiom of him as a deacon carrying a prOCCllsional cross,"and the artist here has bri lliantly found a way to use the space defined by the lunelte and the window to best 3(lvamage .' ,8 It has also l-oeen argued by G . Mackie that this image instead depicts St. Vincent of Sa rag ossa, Spain. anOther deacon who was tortured on a gridiron. Vincent'scult spreal\ widely
CHURCHES
, 8. · ,\!.uwicum orCaI!. PI.d Ji... S,. l .. wre<>« ....... ,h lunett< mosaic (p/>oto K V."",,)
in the Mediterranean (including Ravenna) in the fifth century, and may have been known to Galla Placidia from her time in Spain. Maekie points out that Pru dentius's poem on St. Vincent specifically mentions books, which are depicted in this image, and also says that Vincent hastened toward his torture.' '9 No ea rly sources from Ravenna n3me this ehapd,' JO and in the alJst,nce of any definite evidcn,"C onc way or the othcr, wc can only say that in either case, the saim would have had special meaning for Gal la Placidia. Here, because it seems the most likely solution, I will continue to refer to the figure as St. uwrence. Over the entrance, facing the 51. Lawrence panel, is a representation of Christ as the ('rl)O<.."3jJC, wcars a guld tunic and sits in an ahnost ;,lentil.l pose to our
80
R.... V[NNA AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400- 489
Good Shepherd, 'H Among the plants growing in the scenc, palm fronds in the backgr1)unl] are al~ highlighted in golll, perhaps emphasizing their role in Ch rist's narrative. H ere as in the St. Lawrence panel, the backgrou nd is light blue, amI shallows o f {he cross, Christ's feet and halo, and S0111e ofthl,' sheep are rende red against the background. A pattern of three-dimensional
rocks defines the edge of the foreground . Once again, the image has been tiesignetl to fit the space it occupies: The northern lunette does nOt contain
a window (since it would have been COll lH.'(;t cd to the narthex), Utit the head orChrist, 5urroun.1c!1 liya gO] I] halo, falls in the spot in which the win l]ows ll r c foun d in the other lunettes, emphasizing Christ's role as "light orthe
world." Moreover, the location ohhe image o f Christ alxwe the doorw ay to the chapel echoes John 10 :7- 10: "I am the gateway of the sheep ... if anyone enters by lIle, he will be saved, ami wiJI go in and out and riml pasrure."'lS The up]l!.'r lunem's of the central tow!.'r also each contain a window at the center, surrounlle(1 by a dark blue tiel(1. We find t he same composition on all fou r sides. Flanking these wiruloll's, standing on greenish blocks, arc male figures wearing white stripe(1 u mics and pallia, with their right ar ms upheld in a gesrure of acclalllation (PI. la).'3(' Each of these figures has a differe nt physiognomy; some are beardless, some are bearded, and they are assu mell to represent apostles, since the 1;\1:0 on the eastern lunette can be identified as Peter and Paul. Paul is the onl y figure who gestures across his body to the left instead of to the right: he and Peter face each other across the eastern window, directing the \'iewer's attention to the cast. Peter, likewise, is the only figure [0 hold something in his covered left hand, appal·curlya kcy. Bcneath cach window, a palr o f doves either faces a small fou m ain (north and south) or perches on the edge o f a hasin of water, frOIll which onc of them drinks (cast ;llld we~t) . rep resenting the souls of thc dead drinking the water of eternal life, the ~Iiving water" of J ohn 4 : 10-1 4 aod Revelation ~ 1:6 .'37 The top of each lunette contains a represcntation of a scallop shell sernidome in gold and white; beneath the fee t of [he apostles is another grapevine on a dark blue background, and surrounlling the lunette is a ribbon patlern o n a rcd backgrou nd, which unites the lower and upper zones of the mosaic decora non. I • R \-Vc finally reach the (lome over the central space (Fig. 19). Against a dark blue backgrollo(l , 56 7 gal(1 eight-pointell stars swirl in concentric circles; at thc apex of the dome is a gold cross whosc long arm points toward the cast side of thc strucrure. Amid the arlllS of the cross arc seven stars, three each in the spaces below the crossarm, and one in the upper left s pace. T hese scvcn stars have been inter preted as the seven sta rs o f thc apocaly pse, or the se\'en planet.~ , or thei r n umber may be sim ply attributable to chance. '!-J In
8,
CHURCHES
,~
-,\1....,. ....,
of Gin, I'l2cid;.: mosaics of th.
="Imd , .. ui< (photo E. V,nee)
the lUrners ufthe dome, rising from striped douds uf red and light blue, we see the gold winged figures of the four living creatures of the apocalypse: counterclockwise from the southeast (the bottom right as you vi<.-"W the cross) they are the Lion, the Ox, the Man, and the Eagle, which is the order that the living crearnres around the throne of (JQd are listed in Revelation 4:7. Already by the early third century Christian scholars associated these l'Teatures with the four evangelists. and they appear frt"(juently in fourth- and fifth-century art. '+<' Many schulars have argut~l that in this chapel the figures are on ly apocalyptic symbols, as they are not holding books, '4' but it is surely significant that in the armlm'lIm in the south lunette, the Gospel books are arranged in the order Mark, Luke, Alatthew,John (Fig. [8), thus in the same order as the crearnTes in the vault. 'i' The nighttime effect of th is ceiling is extraordinary, but the overall meallingofthe dome', imagery has bt......, hudy debated by >cholar,. Certainly the four living creatures are apocalyptic, as could be seven stars, om a nighttime sky covered with stars, with a cross at the center, is not part of the vision of Revelation; there the creatures surround a throne. A blue dome covered with stars was a well-known decorative feature in Roman art, but here its meaning, with the indusiun uf the eros>, is nut de;u. Scholars have
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
8.
illlcrprctc{1 the cross as a reference ro the Second Coming of Christ frOIll the east, the vision of the crOSS at Jerusalem in 351 ; the heavenly cross; thc city of heaven; Ch riSl himself; Christ as creator of thc world; or simply as ;I symbol of redemption. It seems most reasonable to ~ssunll,' that in th is particular context, the vault mosaic Illay not have had only one 1lleaning. ·~1
Call this collection of im ages help us to understand the chapel's original
function? Many schola rs have wanted to call it eitbtr a lIlemorial chapd for a saintol" a mausoleum; the second intcrrrct~tion is the most common, with the mosaics interpreted as expressing Christian ideas about death ~nd the afterlife. However, the binary oppositlon between ~ memorial I.:hapel and a m~usoleum has been oH:'rdrawni in fact, memorial cll;lpelS were freq uently used for burial, while burial I.:hnpels were commonly dedicated to n saillt or saints. as we have seen ill Ra venna il"e1f.'+1 The form and del.:oratioll of our Structure easily allow for both functions to coexist, an(1 the IlIcanings of the (le(:or3tion are most unclerstallllablc in this I.:ontext. It certainly appears that one of the functions of this space was for the burial of important people. \Nhen one entcrs the strm'mre, the first impression is of darkness, and lhe chamber has been eompareJ to other Roman mausolea that WCTC also Jimly lit.'45 T he funerary motif is reinlorced by the large marble sarcophagi that are today located in three of the crossarms, where thE1' fit perlixtiy. These sarcophagi date to the mid-fifth l.:entury; ,~6 we do not know when they were placed in the st.ruct1Jre or who their accu· pants were, but by the thirtecnth cenrury they wen: believed to contain the hodies of nriou s late Ro man emperors. ' 4J The i lllag~ fo und o n the sarcophagi correspond to, or enha nce, the m05aics in the va ul ts, wruch implies that they were made specifically fo r this space, although it .~hould be noted th;lt such moufs arc common on s;lrcophagi of th is period. '48 T he funer:llY character of the buil(ling is also IlemOllstrate{! by the pinttone 011 the sU1I1m it of the roof. which ~Yll1bolized immortality in Roman and early Christian art. 'oW Many of the images can be inrerprered as carrying particu lar meaning rel;lred to death and the afterli fe; for example, the doves and the deer drink the water of salva t ion .' ~o the landscape of the Good Shepherd represent.. paradise, '5' and the delllt'nts in the dome rc:-fc:-r to the LIst Jutlgmcnt. ' 5' The depiction of Sf. Lawrence is the onl)' image that {loes not fit easily into funerary interpretations of the iconography. Attempts to interpret this scene to conform with an overa ll theological program (for example, that the martyrdom of Lawrence represents the allegorical sense of salvation) seem forced. ' 53 L aw rence is dea rly a celHral fOC ll S of the chamber since he appear.~ in the lunette directly fac ing the entr;1ncc:-.lt is likely that tlle chapel was dedicated to him, with an altar in the c:11sterll an n that would explain the
CHUI{CHES
overall orientarion of the imagery (es pecially the apostles and the (.TOSS in the central tower) tOwanl the east. ')4 Lawrence's re putation cert~inly malle him a su itable saint for a ch apel or a mausoleum in an imperially sponsored church. Hi s prominence is cnhanec(l uy the way that this image fits into the general decorati\'e program of the chapel. Lawrence is the only moving figure in rhe whole space; everything else I·epresents ordered calm - the Goo.l Shephcf(l, the books in the cahinet, the deer, the al>osdes, and the stars in their tOUr.SL'S. Except tor Lawrcnce, c\·crythittg is outsidc of tillle and space; and the heavenly peaee eontrashi \....ith the torments of the earth repn::sented hy the m:lrtyr. Law rence literally and visually "leaps out" at the viewer, crossing the boundary bl.'!"Ween the living worshipers an,1 the mosaic stasis of eternity. Another important iconographic motif, found both in the architecture and the iconography of this chapel, is the trOSS. '5 1 In this cross-sh aped chapel, .machcd to the cross-shapc<\ chu rch de(\icated to the Holy Cross, the cross is held by IXlrh St. Lawrence and the Good Shepherd, and appears also in the vaults and at the center of the domc. In each case it is a mul tivalent symbol. St. Lawrence's cross is both a sign of his nlllction as a deacon and a symbol of his martyrdom in imitation of Christ; the GOOti Shepherd's cross is both symbol of the flock that he leads amI s~llllbol orhis passion. The cross in the vault likewise may represent the Secon(l Coming of Christ, awaited oy those buried in the tom b, but also the symhol of salvation for which Lawrence died, and perhaps a rdie of the True Cross venerated in the main church. As we have noted , the cross was used as a symhol of victory by the T heodosian dynasty, ami personifications of Victory bolding a long-handled jeweled cross appear on coins of the dynast)', for example, for Theodosius II, his sister Pulcheria, Ho norius, lusta Grata Honoria, and for Ga lla Placi{lia herself (see Fig. g). 'S6 The long-halllllet! crosses held by St. Lawrence amI Ch rist echo this imagery very clearly, and thus the chapel, ~nd the entire complex, reflect the imperial iconography. Did Galla Placillia intend this chapel to be her mausoleum, even though she was evcnmalJy buried clsewherc? Ultimately wc cannot know the answer to this question. Certainly the richness of d!;'t"Orarion and rhe themes of the images would have ucen suit~\.Jlc for su(;h a usc; it has also been suggested that it was planned as a omial space for her infa nt son Theodo~ill s, who died in Spain ." - Either St. Lawrence or St. Vincent would havc been a suitable dedicatory saint for this Theodosian empress. Agndlus's account of a cross-shaped building near Sama Croce that contained the tomb of Singledia, whom hc identifies as a niecc of Galla, indicates that in this area there were llIausolea of impOrtant people. All we call say is that in ~fth-ccntu ry Ravenna, the elite were: constructing elaooratc shrincs ;lnt!
"
8,
R.... V[N NA AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400- 489
mausolea that they dccorau:d to reflect their beliefs and aspirations about their faith.
The Rise of the Chllrel, of Ravenua The other Structures that date to the early years of imperial rule in Ravetllla
afC the cathedral, known as the Ursiana, ;111(1 its associatc(l baptistery, whose development is (."(mncctcI\ to the risc of Ravenna 's church in the imperial period. Under the western emperors, Ambrose of Mil:lI1 had made the church of M ibn second only to Roml,' in the It
pl/llilll1l and meuopolit;ln jurisdiction, lists fourteen subordinate bishops and !lames a BishopJohn; hO\\'I;:\'<:r, [his UOCUl1ll;:tJt was shown in [h<: eighteenth century to be a late sixth- or early seventh-century forge ry, an(1 the name of J ohn is probably an errOr. ,.;" It s<:ents likely that both th<: emp<:rf)r and the pope granted this statu s to a bishop of Ravclllla, despite opposition from the bishop of Mil;m.'.s.;. The first I;'vidence of:l bishop :lcring as a metropolita n by consecrating other bishops comes from sermons delivered by Peter 1,'(\1 one o f Ravenna's great bishops, who. alter the time of Agnellu ~ , was known as Chrysologus, or ';golden worll. ",,,. Peter Chrysologus is Ravenna 's most notable bishop; his main cla ims to fame art: his sermons, which were colJ e<:ted and publishell lJy his eighth-century successor rcl ix . , 6~ Agncllus wrote the earliest biography of Chrysolog\1S, based on local tradition and on his sermons, in which WI;' lea rn that he was a native o flm ol a, appointed as bishop by 3 pope in about 430 _,6 4 The involvement of the pope in his selection is an indication of the dramatic riSt: in status of Ravenna 's dlUrch; '~;: amI Chrysologus l)ec3me fOf Ravenna what Ambrose hold oeen for the sec of Miloln sixty years col rlier. Galla Placitlia lila}' have had somt:thing to (10 with Chrysologus 's devarion, and in his Sefmon T30, per haps delivered JUSt after his consecration, he praises her spccifically:'OiJ Also pn:sentis the mothe r of the Christian. etemal, :md faithful Empire herself. who. b)' following anJ imitating the blessed Church in her faith, her works
C HUI{C HES
of mercy. her holiness, ~nd in her re,'erence for rhe T riniry, h,,~ heen found worth}' of paremillg, marrying, nnJ possessing nil hlll)l!ri,l rriniT}'. Elsewhert: ChrysologllS prenches in glowing terms about the coopera tion o f rulers ami thc church ;,6; he was obviously immenscly proud (If having thc imperial f.1 mily 3S his congrcgants, and as wc will sce, hc workcd actively with Galla Placid ia on the constr uction and fu rn ishing of ('hurches in Ravcnna. Chrysologus was also activc in church polidcs, and in particular was involved in the condemnation of Eutyches as a heretic at the Council o f Ch alcedon of 451; a letter sur.'ives th;lt he wrotc to Eutyches before the cou ncil. at the re'luest of the popc !6~ After the cmperors 1I10\'ell to Rome in the 450s. ann with the clisu nity and eventual demise o f the imperial office, the bishop emerged as o ne o f the major authority figures in Ravenna. Bishop Neon (ca . 450- 73 ) umlertoo k several major builuing programs in and aroulHl th e city, which were cominued hy his successor Exuperantius (473 - 7)' We know \'ery little ahout the status of Ravenna undcr Odoaccr, other than the fact that he used it once again as his ca pital; bll t upon the arrival of the OSfTogoths in Ravenna, it is Bishop Jo hn (477-94) who is said to have negotiated a peace Ileal between O doacer and the Ostrogothic leader Thcoderic that led to the for mer's surrender ofthe city ill 493. =0 TllE CATll E DR ." L
The relationshi p betwcen Galla ann C hrysologus highlights one of the fe3 ~ rures o f Ravenna that is often pointecl om as charncteristic oflate antique capital cities, namdy the linb ge hetween the palace and the ecclesiastical center. Ravenna's cathedral, " o with a rather unusual dedication to the Anastasis (the Resurrection of Christ), became the centtal focus of a group o f build ings di rectly controlled by the bishop.';! The cathedral's location, at the eastern edge of the former oppid/flll , provided the city with two poles o f authority; the em peror to the east, ano r,he bishop TO the wesr. '7' Evidence for tht: linking o f these rwo areas by a colonna(ied street, as arrcsrc(l in tenth-ccllrury and la tcr documents, has very recently been found through excavation; I ,,; the cemralityoflxlth foci represen~ the confident incorporadon o fC hristi ani ly as partofimperi al ideology ill the mid-fifth ccmury! H 'There is con tro\'ersy over the dat.e that the cathedral "'as constructed, a crucia l point of chronological informadOll that has uroad implications for the development of the city. i\gnellus tells I\S that [he cathedrn l was bl1il t by Bishop Ursl1s (hence it was known th rol1g-holll the Mi(l{lle Ages as the Ursiana), a nd that itwas dedicated to thc An astasison Easter Sunday. ' 75 T he pro blem is that there is no agreement on the date of U rsus\ reign; scholars
"
86
R.... V[ NN A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
place it ei ther from ca. 370-96 or from ca. 405- 3 I . This issue has importatH ra mifica tions: if U rsuS waS bish()p before 40l, then the very grand ca thedral would have been huilt before the arrival of the e m perors. indicating a high
Slatus for Ravenna that might have been an ind\lccmcnt for the emperors to move the capi tal the re. : ~1I If, on the mher hand, the later dates for Ursus
are accepted, then the construction of the cathedral was a consequence of the eventS of 401 }i1 T he dating i[epends all the interpretation of a complex variety of texts, and on the qUi.'Stion of whether there was a bishop n3mcd Jo hn hetween Ursu$ and Peter I. My own interpreta tion, hascd on a close exam ination of Agnct1us's sourccs and research mcthods, is that Drsus n.. igned fro m ca. .f0 5-Jl , followl,'d by Peter Chrysologus,'7 ft ~ nd thm that the grand cathedral was a product of Ra\'enna '5 new imperial importance. Raven na's current cat hedral. (lesigned by Gian FranCL"SCO Buona mici 3111] begun shortly after 1734, was huilt on tile site of the e~r lier building thal was
largely tklllOlished at that tillle.'·ij Bishop Manco Farsctti, who initiated the work, insistct] that the new str m.:turc should follow the outline of the earlier buildi ng and lncl udc SOllle parts. including the tenth-century campanile al1(l two si xteenth-c.:ntury side chapels. The Roor of the current bullding is made up of reused marble from va rious sources, some dearly taken from the older build ing, and some apparen tly brought from the lormer church of Santa Euphemia; several large sbbs that had originally been tl'llllSt'llllflt were lIlf)\'ed to the Musco .Arci\'e:;covile in the 1890S.' 8o \-\Tha t we know about the late antique cathedral comes from records and dr~wings of investigations made betweell the eighteenth and twell{ieth celltu r ies and analp:e(l in det:lil by P. Nova ra. Vihi le we cannot know precise details o f cither the pIau or chronolog)" we do know that the origlnal structure consisted of a nave Ranke{l b}' twO aisles o n each side, with an apse to the cast, of the same wid th as the nave (Fig. : 0). The apse had ;\ semicircular intCl·ior and a polygonal exterior (in eA-ect, half of an octagon), and was crowned with a half dome made of tlfl,; fittili, both features that we have already seen at San Giovan ni Evangelista . The basilica with dO\l ble aisles was a type widely known in the fourth- and fifth-century Me(literranean ; certainly found in imperial cities stich as Rome and Mila n, th is type of building could also be found in other, nonimperial cities . ~~' Ravelllla's cathedral measured approximately 60 x 35 mete rs (nave and .lis1cs). It was therdon: smaller tha n the Lateran in Rome (is x 55 m) allli Ambrose's cathc{lral in Milan (8 ~ x 45 Ill), but was comparable in scale to the new basilica built at Aquilcia jusc before 400 (ca. 72 x 3' m), although that structure had only single aisles. Certainly Ra venna's new c~thed ral was an imposi ng building, up-to-date with the main arch itccnmd dC\felopmemsof the late fourth and fifth centuries.
'7
C HUI{C HES
o
OIthodox 6aphslery
N
...
zoo Pl.ln o f R:"·c,,,,~ 's <:";!fhe-
•
••
•
U~iana
••
rlr~1
comric.. , in cluding ,h" U.,;bn3 C "d, ~_ Jr,l (~". 40;)' tile Orrho
,
Calhedral
••
•
50s), 3m l the-
T",," S"It/:iJrll
,.,.
o •
,0
"' ..
o
("""'onJ centuty
Torre SaluSIia
Other information about Ravcnna 's original cathedral comes from much later sources, the most important of which are drawings made by Buonamici at the tim e of the eigbteentb-century rebuilding. ,x, According to these pictures, corrobora ted to some extent by written descriptions. the cathedral's aisles were separated from each other by rows of fourteen columns each, for a total of fifty-six columlls, which ran uninterrupted right up to the eastern wall. Two acldiriona I columns Ranked the entrance to the :Ipse, again as at San Gim'anni Evangelista . Buonamici 's drawing o f the navC of the cathedral before its demol ition shows [ha t [he columns were surmounted by capirab topped by impost hlocks. Novara cautions that the nave arcade of the Ursiana was probably com pletely rebuilt at least three times, ill the tenth, the fourteenth, and the sixteenth centuries, and thus the impost lJlocks shown by Buonamici may not ha\'c [)ecn part of th ~ original StfuCfurc.'8; Howcvcr, we have scen thnt impost blocks were one of the characteristic feamres of fifth-century churches in R ~\'cnna, and wCre used in the conremporary Orthodox Baptistery, so it is not farfetchcd [0 prcsume that they were also used in the Ursiana. '~~ Agncll us's ninth-century description remains our main source of information about the decoration of the cathcdral: :~~ H t lintd tht walls with LIlost prtdous ~wn<:s; 11" arraJlgt:J Jivtrsc tigur<:s in o'·er rhe vault of th" whole temple . . .. Ellscrills ~nd
LIlulti~("o lourd mos~ics
P;J.u\ deeont<:d on<, wall ~urbec. on the north siJ", n<:xt to the altar of SI. Anast:J.sb, which Agatho mad<:. 1113t is the waU whl"r<: eolumns;lre plan·,] in
AD) (a
88
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
" row up roth" w,,11 ohhe main door. S:lti\l~ "nd Stephen decor~ted the Other "":1[[ on the south side, up (0 the "l)(we-lllentioneu door,
altar und .. r a porphyry stone, wh"rt the bishop stan1b \\'h"" he sings th .. mass.
It is impossible ro know when all this decoration may have been inserted; Euserius, Paul, Agatho, Sati u~, and Stephen wcrc probahly not artist:i;, but rather the patrons of the decoration, whose generosity was com memorated by inscriprions. ,Rt; The original Roor was 3.55 m bdow the current lerel, and eighteenth-century drawings indicate th~t it lIlay have oeen co\'en~d with mosa ic; traces lound in the ap~ indicate the presence o f marble wall revetmem.'H7 Elsewhere Agnell us refers to a portrait of the late fifth century Bishop John 1 in the Ursiana , although what its context was is not known. :RH If the dCL'Orarion of the ba ptistery is anything to go by, Ravenna's cathedral must have been a splendid building, corresponding to the amhitions of its bishops. TilE OMT HOIlO X S",f"TISTRRY
Baptism is the sacrament that ma rks a person's entry into the Christian community. In the early tifth century, Ch"istianity had only recently been established as the sole publ icly celebrated religion in the Roman Empire, and ideas abo\l[ baptism and convt;'rsiOIl wt;'re in a process of flux. T hrough the fourth century. it was comlllon for adults to be baptiz:ed, often only toward tbe ends of their lives, and most lim rgical texts that describe baptiSIll through the fifth century assume that those heing haptiz.ed are adultS. 'f lte bishop was re(luireu to preside over the ceremony of baptism in h is episcopal city, and w a ~ the only per~on who could (.'Onfer the H oly Spirit by anointing and laying on of hands, which in this period were part ofthe sa me ceremony. :fI? 'fh us, 3bollt the year 400 the bishop of Ravenna wOIlld have been the gatekeeper, a~ it were, of the city's C hri stian community, the prime actor in a semipublic ri tual enacted el'ery year on the el'e of Easter Sunday. :
C HUI{C HES
Iwl ~ separa te baptistery as part o f its original conception, a centra lhed space with an Octagonal groll n(l plan .l94 N umerous explanations have been proposed fOr the choice of octagonal stmctnres fo r baptisteries.'lI) It was not a new architl.'ctural form; the Romans built octagons as pa rt of elaborate villas, bath complexes, and tombs. T he t heological suitability of the octagon for baptism was most famous ly expre~se(l by Ambrose of At ilan, who, in a(ldition to bu il(ling a new octagonal baptistery next to the catllc(INII o f Milan in the 37os, wrote extensively on the meaning of haptism.:\ poem in Milan's bapristery that is attributed to Ambrose sa id, "cight corners has its font, worthy o f that number, it was suitable to build this hall tC.lr sacred baptism with this n um ~ ber ... ," identifying the number 8 as symbolic of baptism, because it corresponds to the Resurrection o f Christ that took place on the eighth day.'!/> There were additiollal layers of meaning: Both bathing com ple.xes and baptisteries arc associated with water, and similarities with Roman ma usolea associated b~ ptis m with the death of the catachumcn anl[ the heginn ing o f his new life as a Christian.'9l" Finally, a freestanding octagonal build ing is a striking add ition to a <:ity's landscapl.'. and baptism 3 11([ the bishop·s role in the Christian community thereby b<:!came visuallr accentuated.''''s On the model of ROllle :1 11(1 Jvlilan t he idea of an ocragonal , or at least a centrally planned, baptistery spreall through Italy in the fi fth and sixth ct'ntu ries.' "3 It wa, huilt of reused Roman bricks, as ~n octagonal prism wi th fou r proj ..'(·ting apsiJioles at the
90
R.... V[N NA AND TH E WESTER.N [MPER.O RS. AD 400- 489
""'--- '" ,
11. Or! hoo,,~
~;\prj51C1')'.
rn'U!l>trllcrcd "I,,,, a1 ll""'''''! le,-d , wj!h ~ "n::nI ,)..,0 ' ~" .. fom , ~r1tl l'bl1
"t "'j,,-
dv,," Ic,-d (~ ft~r D ~jdIll1~lln ,
!9j6, I,k 4
'1[,,1 ~)
C HURC HE S
9'
~~.
Orthodu.>:
B~"cislery,
,-je'" of the u,,:rior from th e s" utheast
ground level (originally the ground level was ~pproxim~{ely J meters below toJay's level))"'! Today the buil{ling has the footprint of a square with rounded corners, but it is likely that originally the absidioles did not extend all the way w the corners of the OCtagon (Fig. ! I).l°) Viewed from the exterior, the tall ocugonal StruCtUre creates a striking silhouerre (Fig. 21 ). It has been proposed that the top portion of the walls, which arc ornamented with a blind fri eze consisting of twO double-arched panels on each side, were a larer addition to the walls built at some time in the tenth century or later to raise the structure's profile at a time when the city's subsidence may have buried the lower parts of the buiJding;Joo but other scholar~ argue that the rebuilding co uld have taken place in a second
R.... V[ NN A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
9'
1
J.
Or!hoJ".~
l:I~pfi"tt"ry.
rccon.rructed no"" ""'tjo" showing th~
original ami s~h ,;cqucmllooran,j rour 1~... e1s ("frer " (I~t<>f. 19"5)
fi frh--{;cno lT), ph ase. when t he do me ~'as added )O'/ The sidcs of t he octagon afe 5.0-5-3 mete rs lo ng extern:llly and 4.; me ters long internally. T he original baptistery built br Ursus had a woode n roof approximately 1 1 III
above the f1 oor ; J"'~ under Bishop Neon (ca. 45O-i3 ) there was an
extensive rebui lding ;llld rcd(:corating program, resul ting in the struct ure that ~~r\'i\'es tOday (Fig. !3)}"'I A shallow dome, 9.60 meters wide at its springing point and ris ing to a peak of '4.60 meters above the o riginal Roo r, was constnlctcd of a dou ble t hickness of I1Ihifirri!i; at t he summit o fthc
dome. blocks ofl ight pumice replace(1 the tllbi, presum;lhly to create an even lighter structure.;10 The exterior walls of the build ing arc only 0 . 6 0 meters thick, which explains the l"Ollcern for the weight of the dome; moreover, the masonry of the dome and its su pporting arches is Jlot bonded to the outer ~ hell of brick, !Jut tor ms an inner ski n, as it were, to the structure, held up by the interior arc hes and columns.}' I The dome is pierced by eight small holes m ade of fllbi placed perpendicu lar to t he rings of the dome, directly above the eight windows; these were probably for ropes to
suspend lamps in the interior, since the baptismal ceremonies took place at night. HI Two smaller windows on the west and southeast sides of the
CHURCH ES
93
l 4' Ortl..:xl(j~
" 'pfist ... rv • • vi",.. ohh~ imerio r f.\cing SOUthC1lSI
building give access to the space between the c:.:lrados of rhe dome and the roof. \1)
A. "" harto]} has re('ollstru('wl elementS of the baptisma l ritual based on the writings of Ambroseof Milan and e~:plains how they would be performed in this struCtu rc. ,li On the cvcning of H oly Saturday. the baptistery wou ld be exorcised by the bishop and clergy, and the bishop took his place in or in from of the southeast absidiole.l'5 T he baptisands emered from one or the t\\'O original doors on the north and west sides (the door on the west side is the only one that is still o pen tOday)\16 and were "'openetl " by havi ng their ears and noses LOuehed. They faced west and rejccted the Oel'il, then faced east and conhrmc(l their allegiancc to Christ. They were then immersed threc times in the font at thc center of the floor. The font that can he seen today, composed of marble and porphyry slahs and columns 3.45 meters wide and 0.84 meters deep, with a semicircular pulpit on the cast side, was built sometime in tlte later A1iddle Ages when the floor level was raised. However, it stands on the fou ndatiOllS of the original fOllt, which, according to nineteenth-cemury e.~ca\'alions, was circular on the inside and 3.10 III across. w Such :1 font, likc those in Nlilan and Rome, provided a vcssel for thc bodily immcrsion of adult initiates who still fOrlll cd the majority of candidates around the year 400. \18 After the immersion, the bishop anointed the new initiates with oil and washed their feet. They were dressed in white garments and proceeded, with their sponsors and the derb,)" into the cathe/l ral for the Easter Eucharist.
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
9.
The beauty l ll(l mystery of this Ceremony were enhanced by the tlccoration (If the space in which tht:~e rituals tOok place. Agnellu~ lkIys of BiRh(Jp Neon : ~He
Jecoratcd th" baptisteries of lh" UrsiallJ d lUrch most Gcautifully: he set ur in mos~il' Jnd gold I(' s.~cnc the' images of the arostlcs and rn<' ir names in the vault, he girded th l' sidc -wall~ wi th di!l(,-rmt t}'fx:s of swnes. H is name is w ritten in stone lette..,;:
Yield, nk! n~mc. yield, age, to nc~mcss! Behold the glory of the renewed font shines more beautifully. For Neon, highest priest, h~s ge nero\1sl), "don}e,l il, ~ rrJngi ng aII thin gs in Ix:~\ltilill rc linemen!. I' I
The Ortho/lox Baptistery is the ollly late antique baptistery who$e interior decoration survives almost intact, and thus its decoration is extrcmely important fo r understanding the rituals and theology of baptism in this period. "Ve dln herc gct a sensc of the comple.,ity of the artistic program and the splendor of its effects in a way that can be only imagined for most of the other buildings in the late antique worl(1. Tht: baptistt::ry is decorated with mosaic. marble, stucco, and paint. T his is a relatively small space, 12 m across ami 14.6 m high, and one's natural impulse upon entering it is to look up, into the ever-rotating heavenly realm of the domcY " But as thc c~'c travels hack dow n, it encounters an ever-mon:-real and tangible space. From the glittery fl atness of the glass mosaics in the vault. we pass through a mosaic wne that depicts a threed imcnsional rangc of architecture using borh glass and marble tcsscrac}'! Below this is an architectural zone worked ill shallow Stucco rdief, consisting of eo lonncttes and pediments framing winuows and figu res; and bclow this, at ground h:\'el, a real ~eries of arches defi nt:s altsidioles ami emltrasures, the frames for the real Acsh -an d ~ blood partici pants in the drama of baptism Y) As \Vharton has noted, the figures of the newly b~ pt ized, in their white robes, would han.' been reflected by the stucco figure, and the mosaic apostles aoovc thcm. all clad in white and gold, in 1I progressively more dematerial ized world that finally reaches heavenY) At ground level, the interior is surrounded by lin arcade supported by eight reusetl Roman columns and third-century Corinthia n capitals rhat do not match one another. T hese arc surmounted by impost blocks that {bte to the fourth or fi!Th century, and arc among the oldest sUIi'iving e~.amplcs of th is arch itectural feature in late antique Ita lyY o! T he flCXlr level and this arcade have beell ra ised several times, so the original proportions afe no longer visihleYs The arcade frames absidioles recessed into four sides of the octagon. alterna ting with Aat wall su rf,lCCS tha t arc today co\'crc(1 with
CHUI{CHES
95
an ebloorate maro1e wall revetment, created at the turn of the twentieth century on the presume
(Psalm
31[j~ 1:' -'~ )
northeast:
"\Vh<:rt: Jesus bid asidt: his clothing- and put
w~t<:r
in
a uasin and
washed th" f"ct of his disciples." (paraphT:lSc of J ohn I j:4- S) northwest: " He makes me lie davm ,,·atcl'S." (PsaJm ~l [ !JJ:!)
in green pastures; he IClds 111e by still
Each of the~t: (\uotes can be ~pt:citically related to the meaning of baptism, and it is certainly signi ficant that the southeast inscription, the one direct]y in alignmenf with the baptismal scene in the dome, spe<1ks directly to {he concept ofhaptism's relllm"ing sin. The quote on me northeast side seems {O be cvidence tbat the fee t or me initiatc:s were washed as part of (he ceremOllY, which A,mbroSt: tells us was a general practice in much of the weSt, although not in Rome)" It has been suggested that the texts might refer to image:; originally decorating the absidioles, but there is no tvillence either way for thi s )'~ The spandrels above the arcade arc covered with mosaic decoration depicti ng a gold acanthus scroll on a dark hhle ground. At each of the eight corners the scroll forms a medallion with a gol(1 background (hat encloses a male runic- and pallium-clad figure holding a book or a scroll; these figun~s afe interprete(l as prophetsY') The soffits of the arches ;lrc covcreu with elaborate decorative mosaic bands. Above a marble cornice, the set.'On{i zone, at the level of the windows, is defined by eight broad arches corresponding to the ones below, which support the dome (PI. It a). \Vithin tbese arches is an arcade created by twenty-four coloonettes, again reused and not all matching (a lthough me)' were originally stuccoed and painted to hide this fact). These colollnenes are surmounted I,y matching Ionic capitals alltl plain impost blod.:s anll atOp the impost blocks at each of the eight corners ;lrc additional StOlle llr;lckets
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPER.O RS. AD 400 - 489
carved wi th crosses 011 which n..'St the arches of the dome. The central unit of each wall takes up about 40 percent of the wi{lth, anll is fl anked by two slightly narrOwer ull its) 3° T lu.' wi ndows arc ~'4 meters high and 1.4 meters wide, rather brge, e-spt..-cially for a space that was use(l primarily at night.HI An elaborate decoration in stucco relief fi lls the spaces that flank the windows, one of very few exam ples of SOlcro relief decorlltion to hllve survived frOIll late antiquity, although we know that the.re were other ('(Jiltemporary examples ill Ravenna, '.I' Each interstice of th e arcade cornains a n additional stm:co architecnlral frame composed of flu ted pila sters ~nl{ alternating trillngular or semicircu lar pediment'> sorrounding hal (.. sca llop shells. In these frames are sta nding heard less male figures dad in nmics and pallia, holding J.:xx,ks or scrolls that are either open or closed; some of the standing figures seem (0 step out of their frames, creating The illusion of a gallery.J\! T ht!5e figures, who are usually interpreted as the , ixteen prophets, were created br two differen Tartists and were originally brightly paimed with the tunics probably white like the mosai(~ figures bclow.m The awkward spaces between the pediments and the arcade also hold stucco figures. Twelve of the spaces (:o11tain bi rds or animals fa6ng a vast;' or rlallt between them (PI. Ua)) 1i However, on the north and northwest sides, four of these spaces conta in instead narrative re prescmations as 101lows, clockwise from the northwest sille: Daniel between (wo lions, Christ dressed os a philosopher giving the low to Peter in the presence of Paul, Christ dress('d as a warrior trampling the lion and a serpent, and Jonah between two whales. T h e~ arc all motifs thar arc found on carved sronesarcophagi and in other media throughout Ravenna.Bti These particular scenes had signi6cance for the baptismal ceremonies, as they represent triulIlph over danger alld evil: hoth Daniel andJonah are Old Testament types of sal\';ltion and of Christ's resurrection, while the other two iJll;lges present the triumph of Christ o\"er the old law and over evil. According to Ambrose's liturgy for bapti sm, the catachu mens would he fucing the northwest wall and looking ar these images precisely at the point in the ceremony in which they were renouncing the Devil. Bi Above the arcade, eight large arc.hes define the octagonal base o f the dome. The inter....ening spaces and soffits of the arches are filled with more vegctal and ;lbstnlct mosaic and paimc(\ decora tion. A new ground-line, intersected by the arches of the {[ante, underlies a three-dimensional architectural wile rendered in mosa ic. Each side of the octagon corresponds to a tripartite architectural unit consisting of a recessed niche in the center, flanked by S(luare compartments with coffered ceilings (PI. Ih ; Fig. ~ 5).3111 On the southeast, southwest, northellst, and northwest sides the central niche contains an empty jewelell throne with a purple and gold garment in the scat, su rmounted by a /.:ross in a medallion, and the side compartments
CHURCHES
contain topiary and other garden imagery. On the north, south, Cast, and w~t sides the central niche contains an ahar with an open Gospel book on top, and the si{lc COmpartlllCIltS conrain chairs beneath conch-shaped scmidoll1es. The books contain inscriptions identifying them as the four Gospels, but the meaning of the four empty thrones is IlOt explained, amI has been the subject of imcnsivc scllOla rly discussion. Such th roncs arc a COlllmon motif in church mosaics of this peTio(l, 1l'J and hcre they have been interpreted as Ui/llflSill (hoII-lO"O'iu, literally, "preparation of the throne") referring to the Second Coming of Christ, HO as symbol s of the sovereignty of ChriSt,H' as episcopal throncs, and in various Other ways.He T he overall program of this register, depicting a lavish and fantastical seuing far remove(] from everyday life, lIlay represent the heavenly kingdom anaine(] b}' those being baptil.ed. Abovc rhe architectural register, ~cparared by a rcd and blue border, is the dome itself, around which march the twelve apostles to wh01l1 Jesus assigned thc mission ofbapri7.ing believcrs (PI. IIb). H1 T he apostles hold jeweled crowns and arc (iressel] ill tunics with broad stripcs covcrc{j with mantlcs; these costumes arc allernately white tunic with gold lllanl1c and gold covered by white. Tbe apostles are processing toward 3 point beneath the baptismal scene at' the apex of the dome and each is labeled b~' name.
97
25'
Orthooo.~
L!~Jl{istcl)' ,
throne in {,,,ms· • j" """h it~clu,....1 ".:cn~,
",,,,,,,i.,.. uf
the midul e zone
9·
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPERO RS. AD 400 - 489
Peter leads the right side of the procession, followed
ll~'
An(lrcw, Jamcs, son
ofZeheilee,John, Phili p, and Bartholemew; Paul leads the left side, followed br Thoma s, Matthew, James son of Alphaclls, Simon the Canaa nite, and j\l(lc the Zealot}+! The faces arc individua lized: some 3TC shown as }'OImg
beardless men, some as older men with beards of brown or gray. Peter's and Pau l's faces correspond to the portrait types fOl' these apostles lilready established by the fi fth century, but the fadal features of the others do
not exactly match those of other surviving depictions. ;-l5 T he apostles arc walking on a narrow green ground space that displays the shadows cast by their feet, and stand in front of a d:l rkbluc background. They are separatcd from each other by what S. Kostof call s a "plmt-<:andclabra, ~ ami above and behind their heads a drapery swag encircles the cemral medallion; the central dra pe elJecrivdy create:; the iHusion of:1 halo beh ind each heall. "I~ It is not dear to whom or to what the oll>osties arc offering tileir crowns. l~i It is likely that the}' arc offering them to Christ who is depicted in the celltral me(lallion }~H Nonlstrom's interpretation ofthe scene as reflecting the ceremony of IIIf/'rlll) rOnJ1lllrilflil , in which senators offer gold wrea ths to the emperor upon his coronation, resonates with the imperial ceremonial that pervaded Ravenna at this time,3i'< However, given lha[ it was the apostles and their successors, the bishops, who were charged by Christ with the task of baptizing believers, A. \-\'harton's suggestion that the crowns are being olfel'ed to the newly baptize<1 congregants is equally convincing. \ $0 It is likely that all of thcse as~iati on s were eithcr intended by the mosaic's creators or experienced by its audience in tht: mid-lifth ct:(1(u ry. \-\le finally reach the central medallion of the clome (Fig. ~6) . The ~eene was heavi ly and cOlltrovcrsially restored in the 18 ; os by Felice Kj bel and perhaps also earlier, but enough of the original survives to show that it depletell the b~pt i sm or Christ. On the left, Joh n the Baptis t stands on a nx l" prominence hol(ling a tall jeweled sta ff (which has been restored as a cross, but may have been a shepherd's staff or crook). In the center a nude Christ stands in th e rivt:r, while on the right the upper torso of a bearded nucle man holding a green mantle an(l a reed is labeled as;1 personification of the rivcr Jordan. The central axis of the depiction is the space between John and Christ, highlighting their relationship in the context of baptism. The hC
CHURCHES
,6.
Ortt.:..lw! Bop,i"e.", ce8' ,,..1 meJ.llion of ,he 00"'<, depict.
ingthcbopti>m ofChru. (rhoto
S. ,\ t.usl:opf)
The central scene is set off from the apostle register by the mosa ic r~l' reSentation of a circular marble cornicc with egg-and-dart molding, which crea tes the effect that one is looking through a hole in the center of the dome srraight up into hea,~n. The action takes place against 1 gold background, which funhcr removes it from the natural world and places it in a separate, divine space)l' T he s<.:ene as a whole dej>i~"tS the baptism of Christ as reported in Mark 1:9-11 and MatthC'.>· P 3- 17, both of which mention John the Baptist, the river Jordan, and the dove of the Holy Spirit. Olwiously this scene represents thc prototypc for Christian baptism. It also serves as a model for the ceremonies held in {he baptistery itself, with {he baptisand identifying himself with Christ,John the Baptist with the bishop, and the river Jordan with the deacon \\'ho assistt" Joshua 3: t4- 17, that
R.... V[N N A AND TH E WESTER.N [MPER.O RS. AD 400- 489
the river Jordan (li{1not Ace fro m the prc:;ence of the Trini t)' at the baptism, which shows that the pious need nOt fear (".oIl. In this image the personified Jordan fuees the baptism scene, rei nforcing this point. \56 As the sening for the religious pagemt o f ba ptism, the interior o f the O rthodox Baptistery overwhelms the viewer with color, texture, and imagery, creating, as Kostof noted, a visionary rea lm removed from ordi nary space ami time. 1n Til E EI' ISI."OI'AL P ALM: E
An important part of the cathedraI comple x was the residence of the bishop, known as the epis,·(lpiIl1l!. As the public role of the bishop was enlarged in the late antique em pire, his residence became a public space in which he could give audiences, judge legal cases, hol(1 assem blies of clergy, and entertain guests. Eviilen('e of cpiSt"opiti fr(Jm the fourth and fifth centuries is !'iparse. In pJac(.'s such asMilan, Rome, Geneva, Naples, Grado, PlIfCn7,O, and Aquileia, we know that onc c(Jmponenr was a large amlicnc(.' hall, in some ca~es richly dccorated, H ~ but beyond th is there docs not seem to he any sta ndard layout or type for a bishop's residen(·e. H9 Ravenna's episcopal pal ace is unusually well documented, th anks to Agnellus and to its partial survival , which has allowt::d M.lv1iller to trace its histOry ami significance withi n the broader context of episcopal residences in nvrtht::rn Italy. 1f1o One of the ,Iefining characteristics of Ravenna '$ rpis(()pilllll was that, according to Agnellus, it was 3n agglomeration ofi:luild· ings that had been built by different bishops, making it an articulation of the history of the episcopal sec)ti ' \.ve will trace the~ aclditions through· out the course of this book, noting the significance of eacb addition in its histOrical COiUext.-·I . , Nothing is known of the earliest ~pis<"upill"', but Agndlus assumed that one existell near the ca thedral )"'~ It devdoped an)lI ml ;1 tower that W ;1S later known as the TOITI! Stlitmnt, which, as wc havc seen in the previous chapter, scrved as the water distriblltion tower for the allllcduct. "I'he fi rst distinct building identified by Agnellus was the '"house which is called quinqul: IIrCl/hifll," built by Bishop Ncon. Qil/ll/Ilfe furl/hifll mClIns ;'five dining couches," and refers to a type o f high-status fl"iclillitl lll, or dining hall, that contains a nidH: for a number of semicircular dini ng couches. Aglldlus descri bes the dining hall as follows: On e;lch side of the dining hall he huilt wo ndrous ,,; ndows, and he ordel-.:d the I)~wmt:nt of the din ing' ha ll to l,t: (It'corHed wiTh diff.,ren t tYl~s of ,tones. The story of the 1"5;11m which we sing d:l il)" th
.0.
CHUI{CHES
stre~m,
he had it adomer! in colors with the sto~' of our Lorr! Jeslls Christ, when.:Is we read, he fed so many dlO\ls~l!lds of men from five 10;l\'e5 \l.nd two fishes. On one side of the interior facade of the dining h:11I he set ollr the creation of the worlr! .... And 011 the oth~r facar!e was depicted tJl~ sto~' of the apostle Pe ter. ...
Each o f these scenes wns accompanied by a po em in hexameter, which Agnellus quoteS; tlu.· whole decorative effect was luxurious, and at the same time presented rdigious S('enes with messages aiJollt the sanctity of food and the rofe of bishops as the heir s of Peter .l~~ T his din ing hall was appar emfy ouilt i11llllediaH.'fy oehind the cathedral, adjacent to the foWtl AI/lJJis. 1(15 Dining halls of this type wefe typical of aristocratiC f~idellccs and palac~; Nc..·oll's triciilliu1II, built at a time in which the imperial palacc at Ravcttlla was largely unu:'>ed, emulate{! and perhaps competell \vith the imperial palace, '(;¢ at a time in which the bishop was becoming the main :lutborit)' figufe in the (;iryY'7 (Hil ER
F.Pl ~O:; OPA L
elillRell r O US P ATIONS
\Ve know less about other c hurch~ huill in Ravenna in the fifth century, although iTsecms that much morc building activity was taking place. Evidence for other constructions is very ~anty, anll, as usual, comes mostly from Agnellus, ill some cases supplemented by surviving re mJ ins or arc h ~e ologica l evidence. One of the most notable churches built in the first half of the fifth century was 3 large basilica founded in Class!! by Peter C h rysologus, app:lrendy dedicated to Christ and namet] alter its lOunder as the Petriana; it was completed by Peter's successor Ncon )68 Agncllus, who is our sole sou rce for this church, [dIs us that iT collapsed in an ea rthquake in the mid-cighth century and h~d not been rebuilt; he tells \1s;Jw Nodlurch like it in {'(mstruction W:lS brgtr, ei ther in kngth o