RADIATION ACOUSTICS
RADIATION ACOUSTICS Leonid M. Lyamshev
CRC PR E S S Boca Raton London New York Washington, D.C.
...
147 downloads
2521 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
RADIATION ACOUSTICS Leonid M. Lyamshev
CRC PR E S S Boca Raton London New York Washington, D.C.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Lyamshev, Leonid M. Radiation acoustics / Leonid M. Lyamshev. p. ; cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-415-30999-9 (alk. paper) 1. Sound-waves. 2. Sound—Transmission. 3. Radiation sources. I. Title. [DNLM: 1. Radiation. 2. Acoustics. 3. Radiation Effects. 4. Thermodynamics. WN 100 L981r 2004] QC243.L93 2004 534—dc22 2003070031
This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. A wide variety of references are listed. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or for the consequences of their use. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. The consent of CRC Press LLC does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from CRC Press LLC for such copying. Direct all inquiries to CRC Press LLC, 2000 N.W. Corporate Blvd., Boca Raton, Florida 33431. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe.
Visit the CRC Press Web site at www.crcpress.com © 2004 by CRC Press LLC No claim to original U.S. Government works International Standard Book Number 0-415-30999-9 Library of Congress Card Number 2003070031 Printed in the United States of America 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 Printed on acid-free paper
FOREWORD
Radiation acoustics is a new field of research developing at the interface of acoustics, nuclear physics, high energy physics, and the physics of elementary particles. It is founded upon studies and applications of radiation-acoustic effects arising in the process of interaction of penetrating radiation with matter. The thermoradiation mechanism has been the best studied among the mechanisms of sound excitation by penetrating radiation in condensed media. According to this mechanism, sound generation is caused by thermal expansion of a medium, and the acoustic field can be described as a rule within the framework of linear theory. The book considers mainly the processes of thermoradiation sound excitation in the case of continuous (modulated) and pulsed action of penetrating radiation on a substance. Basic laws of formation of acoustic signals are established and the bonds between the characteristics of these signals, radiation parameters, and thermodynamic, radiation, and acoustic properties of substances are revealed. The efficiency and optimal conditions of thermoradiation sound generation are considered. The particular features of sound generation by a particle beam moving along the surface of a liquid or solid at subsonic and supersonic velocities and an arbitrary form of modulation of radiation intensity in the beam are described. The possibility is discussed of the creation of virtual radiation-acoustic sources of sound in a wide frequency range (from sound to hypersound frequencies) with controlled parameters in liquids or solids. We consider the particular features of thermoradiation generation of sound by single particles. Experimental results on sound excitation by beams of photons (laser radiation), electrons, protons, heavy ions, X-rays, and gamma-quanta are given. Some other mechanisms of sound generation
by single particles in the process of their absorption in a medium are considered apart from the thermoradiation mechanism, i.e., the mechanisms of microshock waves and the bubble, dynamic, Cherenkov, and striction mechanisms. Applications of radiation acoustics are discussed. We have not tried to go into the details of many of them. Our purpose is to demonstrate the prospects of application of radiation acoustics to various fields from microelectronics (radiation-acoustic microscopy) to geophysics (neutrinoacoustic sounding of the Earth), and astrophysics (detection of cosmic neutrino and muons of super-high energy by huge acoustic detectors in the ocean). We have not tried to review all papers on radiation acoustics. On the contrary, we have quite deliberately not included in the book the results of studies of nonlinear radiation-acoustic phenomena arising in the process of interaction of powerful radiation beams with matter. Although the role of nonlinear effects in future radiation-acoustic technologies will undoubtedly be essential (targeted action on physical, mechanical and chemical structure of substances, radiation-acoustic destruction of materials, etc.), investigation of these effects still continues. The book may be useful not only to acousticians but also researchers and technicians specializing in adjacent and other fields as well as postgraduates and university students. I am very grateful to G. A. Askar’yan, F. V. Bunkin, and V. I. Il’ichev for many useful remarks on the manuscript. L. M. Bolotova, M. G. Lisovskaya, and B. I. Chelnokov helped me greatly in the preparation of the manuscript for publication. I am deeply grateful to them. L. M. Lyamshev
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
1
Chapter 1. PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
7
1. Elementary particles: Fundamental laws of the microscopic world 7 2. Absorption of penetrating radiation in a condensed medium 13
Chapter 2. BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION BY PENETRATING RADIATION IN CONDENSED MEDIA 1. Mechanisms connected with heat release 2. Thermoradiation generation of sound 3. Initiation of microshock waves 4. Bubble mechanism 5. The Cherenkov mechanism 6. Striction mechanism of sound generation 7. Sound generation in the process of pulsed radiolysis 8. Dynamic mechanism 9. Other mechanisms of sound generation
Chapter 3. THERMORADIATION EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID 1. Equation of thermoradiation generation of sound 2. Reciprocity theorem in acoustics – Solution technique for boundary problems 3. Excitation of monochromatic sound in a liquid half-space with a free surface – The case of undisturbed surface 4. A liquid half-space with large-scale roughness of boundary
23 23 24 28 30 31 33 35 35 38
39 39 42
47 52
5. The case of small unevenness 6. Efficiency of thermoradiation excitation of sound in a liquid – Some estimates
Chapter 4. THERMORADIATION EXCITATION OF SOUND IN AN INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM 1. Sound excitation in a liquid half-space in the presence of a layer of another liquid at its boundary 2. Generation of sound in a liquid adjoining a solid layer 3. Liquid half-space with an inhomogeneous surface layer
Chapter 5. EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES 1. Sound generation in a liquid by rectangular pulses of radiation 2. A liquid with rough surface 3. Radiation pulses of arbitrary shape 4. Near wave field of thermoradiation pulsed source of sound 5. Sound generation in a liquid with gas bubbles
Chapter 6. GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS BY INTENSITY-MODULATED PENETRATING RADIATION 1. Basic equations 2. Boundary conditions 3. Method for solution of boundary problems 4. Thermoradiation generation of sound in a solid half-space with a free boundary 5. Particular features of excitation of Rayleigh waves 6. Solid half-space with a liquid layer at its surface 7. Efficiency of thermoradiation generation of sound 8. Influence of particular features of absorption of penetrating radiation on sound generation
61 72
75
75 88 96
105
106 113 116 124 130
137 137 139 141 147 151 156 160 164
Chapter 7. PULSED THERMORADIATION SOURCES OF SOUND IN SOLIDS 1. Sound generation by radiation pulses in a solid half-space 2. Excitation of Rayleigh waves by radiation pulses 3. Sound generation in a solid half-space in the presence of a liquid layer at its surface 4. Efficiency of sound generation 5. Influence of particular features of absorption of penetrating radiation 6. Thermoradiation generation of sound by pulses of non-relativistic protons
Chapter 8. MOVING THERMORADIATION SOURCES OF SOUND 1. Sound generation by a moving thermoradiation pulsed source in a liquid 2. Sound excitation by a moving thermoradiation pulsed source in solids
Chapter 9. SOUND GENERATION BY SINGLE HIGH-ENERGY PARTICLES 1. Sound generation by a particle in infinite space 2. Sound excitation by single particles in a solid half-space 3. Particular features of excitation of Rayleigh waves 4. Efficiency of sound generation
Chapter 10. EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF THERMORADIATION EXCITATION OF SOUND 1. Laser thermooptical (thermoradiation) sources of harmonic sound oscillations in water 2. Sound excitation in water by laser pulses 3. Sound field excited by a sequence of laser pulses 4. Acoustic field of a moving laser thermoradiation source of sound in water
169
169 184 186 191 193 195
201
202 213
227 227 234 237 238
239
240 248 252 257
5. Laser thermooptical excitation of sound in solids – Excitation of surface waves 6. Sound excitation by X-rays (synchrotron radiation) in metals 7. Sound excitation by a proton beam 8. Excitation of acoustic waves in metals by electrons, positrons, and γ-quanta 9. Sound generation by an electron beam in water 10. Sound excitation by a beam of ions in metals
Chapter 11. SOME APPLICATIONS OF RADIATION ACOUSTICS 1. Scanning radiation-acoustic microscopy and visualization 2. Scanning laser-acoustic microscopy 3. Scanning electron-acoustic microscopy 4. X-ray – acoustic scanning visualization 5. Ion-acoustic microscopy and visualization 6. Acoustic detection of super-high-energy particles in cosmic rays – The DUMAND project 7. Neutrino for geoacoustics – The GENIUS project
270 281 286 298 302 306
309
310 311 314 318 321 325 330
Conclusion
339
References
343
Addendum. ACOUSTOOPTICS OF PENETRATING RADIATION
359
1. Diffraction of X-rays and neutrons by ultrasound in crystals 2. Scanning acoustic tunneling microscopy 3. Interferometers using matter waves – Atom interferometers
SUBJECT INDEX
360 361 362
367
INTRODUCTION
Investigation of radiation-acoustic effects was stimulated mainly by progress in the field of high-energy physics and the physics of elementary particles. The latter has advanced greatly during recent decades. Particles of tremendous energy of the order of magnitude of tens, hundreds, and thousands of gigaelectronvolts (GeV) were obtained with the help of accelerators and many new elementary particles subjected to amazing interactions and inter-transformations were discovered. Quantum chromodynamics and unified theory of electromagnetic and weak interactions appeared. The state-of-the-art is now that physics is on the verge of creating the unified theory of all the fundamental interactions — electromagnetic, strong (nuclear), weak, and gravitational interactions. Experimentation at even greater energy is needed for solution of this problem. This needs powerful accelerators of elementary particles, which would provide an opportunity to make the next step into the depth of the microscopic world [2, 76, 89, 176]. Such accelerators are under design and construction now. As the construction of new, more powerful accelerators opens new opportunities for advancement of investigation of elementary particles into the field of larger and larger energies, the accelerators designed initially for purely basic studies, are applied to a greater and greater extent in research into the physics of solids, biology, chemistry, and medical science. They are utilized successfully in radiation technology, defectoscopy, analysis of rare minerals, and also (as it will be demonstrated below) in radiation-acoustic research and technology. As a rule, these are low-energy (about several megaelectronvolts (MeV)) accelerators like betatrons, linear accelerators, and microtrons [13]. Now more powerful accelerators (up to several 1
2
INTRODUCTION
gigaelectronvolts) of proton, meson, and ion beams and X-rays are being tried for these purposes. The beginning of radiation acoustics is connected in a broad sense with the discovery by A. Bell, W. Roentgen, and J. Tyndall [180, 195, 245] of the optoacoustic (photoacoustic) effect, that is sound generation in a gas volume due to intermittent (modulated) light passage or, in other words, due to interaction of modulated optical radiation (modulated photon beam) with a substance (gas). At the same time Bell discussed the problem of construction of a radiophone, “a device for producing sound by radiation of any kind” [195]. Further studies of the optoacoustic effect and its applications served, as is known, as the basis for the development of optoacoustics (photoacoustics) including optoacoustic spectroscopy of gases and condensed media [74, 126]. A powerful stimulus for the development of this field in recent decades was the construction of lasers (see [96, 127] for example). The first studies of radiation-acoustic effects were conducted in the 1950s and 1960s. So, for example, in 1956 Kaganov, Lifshits, and Tanatarov considered sound radiation in a solid by a uniformly moving electron and showed that at an electron velocity greater than the sound velocity in a medium (lattice), the Cherenkov radiation of sound (phonons) occurs [101]. The analogous problem was considered earlier (1953) by Buckingham [203]. In 1955 Glaser and Rahm reported observation of tracks of particles in the process of their passage through a metastable boiling-up liquid in a bubble chamber according to sound (vibration) signals arising as a result of the birth and development of bubbles [209]. In 1957—1959 Askar’yan considered radiation of ultrasonic and hypersonic waves by charged particles in dense media due to local heating and formation of microscopic cavities along particle tracks. Excitation of surface and bulk waves under the impact of a non-relativistic electron flux upon the surface of a dense medium was considered and the problem of utilization of acoustic signals generated by particles for detection of particles was discussed [6, 7]1. In 1963 White investigated sound generation by an electron beam in a solid [260]2. Somewhat later (1967) Graham and Hutchison [216] measured 1
In contrast to Glaser and Rahm [209], who discussed sound radiation due to the rise of bubbles at particle tracks in metastable media, Askar’yan [6, 7] considered local heating arising at particle tracks in dense stable media and producing sound pulses, as well as the bubbles generating hypersonic waves. He proposed also acoustic detection of particles and noted the possibility of manifestation of hypersonic pulses in the process of biological action of radiation on cells and chromosomes (as a part of destructive effect). 2 We must note that at the same time, White conducted the first experiments on laser generation of sound in solids. Somewhat earlier the first widely known experiments
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
3
mechanical oscillations in quartz crystals, sapphire, etc., on their being irradiated by electron beam pulses, and in 1969 Beron and Hofstadter, as Askar’yan before them [6, 196], suggested that not only electrons but also other particles can generate mechanical vibrations3. Numerous studies of sound excitation in condensed media by electron and proton beams and by single particles were conducted in the 1970s by Borshkovskii, Volovik, Zalyubovskii, Kalinichenko, Lazurik, and others, and in the 1980s, by Lyamshev and Chelnokov (see [155, 156]). Various mechanisms of sound excitation in condensed media by penetrating radiation were considered. The major results of these studies and the bibliography can be found in the book [97]. The publications of many researchers on possible applications of the radiation-acoustic effects date to the same period (see, for example, F. Perry et al. on the application of these effects to the dosimetry of pulsed beams of accelerated particles and to obtaining data on the depth distribution of irradiation dose in a target [242]). A powerful stimulus for development of research in radiation acoustics were ideas to use radiation-acoustic effects for detection of super-highenergy muons and neutrinos at a large depth in the ocean [8, 199], to develop a radiation-acoustic microscope [207], and finally, the suggestion to “sound” the Earth (using a radiation-acoustic technique) by a super-highenergy neutrino beam from super-powerful (for super-high energy of particles) proton accelerators of future generation named tevatrons [248]. Further publications (see, for example, [15, 151 – 154, 184]) were connected in this or that way with these aspects. Investigations performed in the 1950s and 1980s have been described to some extent in the book [97] mentioned above and in a collection of articles [173].
on interaction of laser radiation with a liquid were conducted in the Lebedev Physical Institute of the USSR Academy of Sciences (see G. A. Askar’yan, A. M. Prokhorov, G. F. Chanturiya, and G. P. Shipulo, Zhurnal Eksperimental’noi i Teoreticheskoi Fiziki, 1963, v. 44, No. 6, pp. 2180 – 2182) which led to the discovery of the light-hydraulic effect. This paper played a fundamental role in the development of laser and radiation acoustics. 3 Recently detection of an acoustic signal from a muon beam at the neutrino channel of the U-70 accelerator of the Institute of High-Energy Physics (Moscow) was reported (see A. B. Borisov et al., Zhurnal Eksperimental’noi i Teoreticheskoi Fiziki, 1991, v. 100, p. 112). Acoustic signals from a muon flux in the muon filter of the neutrino channel were studied. Results of measurements of signals and theoretical estimates based on the thermoradiation mechanism of sound generation were given. A satisfactory agreement between experimental and theoretical results was noted that was the evidence of the dominant role of the thermoradiation mechanism in the process of sound generation. The possibility of application of the radiation-acoustic technique to remote determination of the characteristics of particle beams from the accelerator was considered.
4
INTRODUCTION
A definite concept has been formed by now about the mechanisms of sound generation by penetrating radiation. They are connected usually with the physical phenomena (processes) resulting in the conversion of penetrating radiation energy into acoustic energy. These processes depend on the radiation type, on the target substance in which this radiation is absorbed, and on the energy release mode in the absorption region. The mechanisms of sound generation are numerous and not equal in their efficiency [155]. Heat release is one of the most universal physical phenomena taking place due to absorption of penetrating radiation. Thermal energy can transform partially into sound wave energy in different ways. At moderate released energy densities, when no phase changes occur in a substance, the main contribution to the sound generation process arises from the thermal expansion of a medium. This is the thermoradiation (thermoelastic) mechanism of sound generation. In this case the sound fields can be described within the framework of linear theory which has been developed extensively in recent years [156]. The pattern of sound generation looks much more complex in the case of large densities of penetrating radiation energy released in a medium. In this case the phenomena arising are nonlinear. The effects caused by the growth of the expansion rate of the heated region of a medium (hydrodynamic nonlinearity) and the change of thermodynamic parameters of a substance in the process of action of penetrating radiation (thermal nonlinearity) turn out to be substantial. If the density of released thermal energy increases further, more complex processes of sound generation develop, which are connected with phase transitions, for example, in the conditions of bubble mechanism of sound generation by penetrating radiation [6, 64] and the mechanism of formation of shock waves [4, 72]4. There are also “non-thermal” mechanisms of sound generation: the Cherenkov, dynamic, striction, and other mechanisms. However, the thermoradiation mechanism is the one best-studied up to now. Research on radiation-acoustic effects could hardly have drawn the attention of physicists in recent decades if it was not connected with the prospects of its practical applications. Examples are scanning radiationacoustic microscopy of condensed media [157, 201, 206, 257], acoustic detection of super-high-energy particles (the DUMAND project — Deep Underwater Muon and Neutrino Detection) [9, 56, 67, 200, 239], research 4
We should note that discussion on the density of the energy released in a medium in the process of absorption of penetrating radiation concerns first of all laser (optical) radiation (photon beams). However, in a certain sense they are valid also for particle beams and a single particle or a group of particles. In the latter cases we can discuss the peaks of local heating and overheating leading to formation of acoustic compression waves, microshock waves, microcavitation, and microbubbles.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
5
on the role of the radiation-acoustic mechanism in underwater noise generation in calm ocean [149], and also the opportunities opening up for the application of new generations of proton and linear super-powerful accelerators of future generations to the production of super-high-energy neutrino beams and the application of these beams in geoacoustics (neutrino geoacoustics, the GENIUS project — Geological Exploration of NeutrinoInduced Underground Sound) [185, 248] and in neutrino-acoustic ocean tomography [236]. We should note also the important role of radiationacoustic effects in investigation and prediction of radiation blistering [80]. The book consists of eleven chapters. The first two chapters give data on elementary particles, absorption of penetrating radiation in a substance, and mechanisms of radiation excitation of sound. The next seven chapters of the book contain the results of the theoretical treatment of thermoradiation sound generation in condensed media, i.e., in homogeneous and inhomogeneous liquids and solids, under the action of modulated penetrating radiation and radiation pulses on a substance. Particular features of the acoustic fields of moving thermoradiation sound sources are considered. Sound excitation by single high-energy particles is analyzed. The efficiency and optimal conditions of thermoradiation sound generation are discussed. The theoretical consideration is based on the solutions of boundary-value problems for the inhomogeneous wave equation with the right-hand side in the form of the function of power density of sound sources produced by radiation absorption in a substance. It is assumed that this absorption obeys the exponential law, which is valid for laser (optical), X-ray, and electromagnetic (in general) beams and with certain limitations for beams of relativistic electrons. This has provided an opportunity to obtain results in the final form and compare them to experimental data. At the same time, the role of the law of radiation absorption in formation of acoustic field of a thermoradiation sound source is analyzed, and the conditions when the absorption law does not play a considerable role are determined. Corresponding analytical expressions are given. Chapter 10 presents the results of numerous experiments conducted and published by many researchers and concerning thermoradiation excitation of sound by modulated laser radiation and laser pulses in the cases of stationary and moving laser beams, beams of protons and electrons in water, and by electron, positron, proton, ion, and X-ray beams and gamma-quanta in metals. We have to note here that comparison of these results to theoretical conclusions proves the validity of the thermoradiation theory. Some applications of radiation acoustics are discussed in Chapter 11. The purpose of this chapter is to demonstrate not only the variety of already existing applications but their “large scale”. We mean both radiationacoustic microscopy and immense projects of the future like the DUMAND and GENIUS projects.
CHAPTER 1
Penetrating Radiation: General Information This chapter provides information on particles constituting penetrating radiation, and absorption of penetrating radiation in the process of its interaction with a substance. Only the most general concepts are presented here. Detailed information may be found in specialized books on particle and nuclear physics.
1. ELEMENTARY PARTICLES: FUNDAMENTAL LAWS OF THE MICROSCOPIC WORLD The material world is “constructed” from elementary particles. This means that their properties, laws of motion, and forces between them determine the diversity of physical phenomena. Commonly the particles which cannot be separated into components are called elementary particles. This definition applies to electrons, protons, and neutrons, but not atoms and atomic nuclei. Protons and neutrons together are called nucleons. Another common and well-known particle is a light particle, i.e., photon. An electrically neutral particle, i.e., neutrino, is much less known. It is very difficult to detect, as it interacts with electrons and nucleons very weakly and therefore, goes through a tremendous thickness of substance almost freely. Knowledge on the structure of the microscopic world, i.e., physics of elementary particles, is the basis for the whole of modern science. Studies of atomic structure
7
8
PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
provided an opportunity to discover extraordinary properties of elementary particles and develop a theory of motion, i.e., quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics and the theory of relativity are the two pillars supporting the whole of modern physics. Such a general concept as symmetry, which to a significant degree determines the structure of particles and their interactions, is also fundamental for modern physics. Modern models and theories of physics of elementary particles are formulated in the mathematical language of the apparatus of symmetry, i.e., theory of groups. One of the most important parameters in quantum mechanics is spin. All particles are separated into classes depending on the value of their spin: particles with half-integer spins are fermions or Fermi particles and particles with integer spins are bosons or Bose particles. The description of spin using the mathematical apparatus of the theory of groups became the starting point of many theories, i.e., so-called internal symmetries. Development of symmetry schemes unifying fermions and bosons is the goal of the supersymmetry trend and finally, the Grand Unification Theory. Let us turn to history. It was discovered in the first decade of the last century that an atom consists of a nucleus and electrons. As it turned out, a nucleus has the dimensions of 10−13 cm and the whole atomic mass is contained in it. The density of matter is extremely high in a nucleus and is equal to 1014 g/cm3. The charge of the nucleus is positive. Electrons move around a nucleus at a distance of 10−8 cm. It was determined in the 1930s that a nucleus consists of protons and neutrons. The last do not have any charge. Electrons are held within an atom by electric forces. Physicists call the forces binding positively charged protons with neutral neutrons nuclear forces, due to their nature. Pauli had predicted the existence of the neutrino already in the 1920s. It only became possible to observe this particle experimentally twenty years after it had been discovered because of its “ability” almost not to interact with matter. Physicists associated this feature with forces of weak coupling in contrast to nuclear forces, i.e., forces of strong coupling. Further research, and first of all the studies of the nature of nuclear forces, led to the discovery of a huge number of particles, their interaction, and interconversion. Quantum electrodynamics, quantum chromodynamics, and the unified theory of electric weak interaction were developed. All particles are divided into hadrons and leptons depending on processes they take part in. Fundamental interactions of only four types stand behind all processes observed up to now, i.e., electromagnetic, weak, strong, and gravitational couplings. Gravitation is universal. All elementary particles take part in it. Sources of electromagnetic field are charges. Neutral particles, which do not have any charge, interact with an electromagnetic field only due to their complex structure or quantum
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
9
effects. In this sense electromagnetic coupling is not as universal as the gravitational one. The same is also true about weak coupling. As for strong coupling, only hadrons constituting the vast majority of particles (about 200) take part in it. Multiple mesons and hyperons (both long-lived and resonance ones, i.e., with lifetime shorter than 10−20 s) belong to the family of hadrons as well as nuclons. Leptons take part in electric weak coupling and do not participate in strong coupling. There are six of them: electrons e, muons µ, tau-leptons τ, and the corresponding three neutrinos νe, νµ, and ντ1. In contrast to leptons, hadrons may be called elementary particles only in the sense that they are really indivisible. However, it was determined that they have an internal structure and behave as “loose” systems in hadron interactions. Hadrons consist of quarks. According to modern views, quarks are structureless true elementary particles like leptons. As distinguished from hadrons, leptons and quarks are called fundamental particles. However, quarks do not exist separately. They exist within hadrons in a bound state. This property of quarks is called “confinement”. Another, so to say opposite, side of this feature of quarks is the fact that they do not interact when close to each other. This property got the name of “asymptotic freedom”. A hypothesis of existence of quarks was suggested in 1964. It followed from the assumption of the existence of symmetry among leptons and quarks that there should be six quarks. This was confirmed experimentally. In the process of experimenting with high-energy particles, it became possible to “observe” quarks and determine their masses and charges. However, it was impossible (and apparently will not be possible in the future) to knock out a quark from a hadron. Five quarks have been discovered up to now and the search for the sixth one is in progress2. Quark types or “flavors” (as they are called commonly) are denoted by letters u, d, s, c, b, and t. According to theory, each quark must have a certain “color” charge (color is “chromos”; the term “chromodynamics” follows from here). There are three color charges in all. “Color” charges are introduced analogously to common yellow, red, and blue colours. Thus according to theory, there must be 18 quarks and the same amount of anti-quarks. 1
There was very little experimental data on the neutrino until recently. The situation has changed now. Multiple reports on conversion of one type of neutrino into another and non-zero mass of neutrino were published on the basis of studies of solar neutrino and experiments with accelerators. For example, see J. N. Bahcall et al., Nature, 1995, v. 375, p. 29 and A. B. Balantekin, Phys. News, 1995, AIP, p. 49. 2 The discovery of the sixth quark has been reported! See C. Quigg, Discovery of the Top Quark, Phys. News, 1995, AIP, p. 56; F. Abe et al., (CDF Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett., 1995, v. 74, p. 2626; and S. Abachi et al., (DO Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett., 1995, v. 74, p. 2632.
10
PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
Hadrons are built from them. Hadrons are divided into two big groups: barions with barionic charge and mesons without this charge. Protons, neutrons, and other particles belong to the first group, while the second group includes π-mesons, k-mesons, and so on. Barions are constructed from three quarks with different mutually complementary “color” charges. A meson consists of a quark and an anti-quark. Both barions and mesons are “colorless”. We should stress that in the case of quarks, “color” is just a convenient term to denote quantum numbers characterizing quarks. Color charges of anti-quarks differ from that of quarks. There is a strong symmetry among quarks of different flavors and leptons. Leptons and quarks include three generations of fundamental fermions. Fermions of the first generation together with photons are the construction material for modern matter. As for fermions of the second and third generations, apparently physicists begin to understand now that on the one hand they played an important role at the earliest stages of formation of the Universe and on the other hand our existence depends on the relationship between uand d-quarks and electrons. Studying the nature of the forces binding quarks in hadrons has demonstrated that here lies a deep analogy with electromagnetic forces. Interaction of an electron with another electron or charged particle is performed by photons. They have zero rest mass but do not have an electric charge. Therefore, an electron does not change its charge when it emits a photon. Photons are vector particles. They are described by a vector field (corpuscular-wave dualism). It was demonstrated totally analogously to quantum electrodynamics and its principles of symmetry that interaction between quarks is performed also by vector particles, i.e., gluons, which have zero mass and unit spin like photons. However, unlike photons, there are eight gluons and they have “color” charges corresponding to the laws of quantum chromodynamics. Moreover, they interact strongly with each other forming elementary particles called glubols. Nuclear forces between protons and neutrons (hadrons) in a nucleus are the secondary manifestation of quark-gluon interactions. A theory of quarkgluon interactions has been confirmed experimentally. It has been developed within the framework of quantum chromodynamics and describes formation of “gluon strings” and “quark, anti-quark, and gluon streams” developing when gluon strings get broken in the process of collision of high-energy hadrons. Thus, quarks and gluons (they are often called partons) are fundamental particles constituting hadrons. It was established experimentally that their dimensions are smaller than 10−16 cm, while the characteristic size of hadrons is 10−13 cm. Therefore, partons may be considered point particles like leptons.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
11
The nature of weak forces or weak coupling was described within the framework of the so-called theory of electric weak coupling developed in the 1960s. It was established within this theory that despite the fact that electromagnetic and weak forces are different, manifestations of one and the same coupling, i.e., electric weak coupling, constitutes their nature. According to the electric weak theory, weak couplings are caused by the interchange of intermediate vectors by W±- and Z0-bosons, just as electromagnetic coupling is caused by interchange of photons. In this case the weakness and small radius of weak coupling are explained by the fact that W±- and Z0- bosons are very heavy particles. W±-bosons are charged while Z0-bosons are neutral vector particles. Bosons were discovered in 1983 by European physicists in experiments with an accelerator with counter-propagating proton-anti-proton beams at CERN (Switzerland) and this was a solid confirmation of electric weak theory. It is possible that there exist more of such particles, i.e., intermediate vector bosons. This problem is still open. One of the fundamental properties of weak forces is the fact that they are connected with slow (weak) decays and always associated with the neutrino. Weak forces play an important role in the evolution of the Universe. Nuclear reactions in the Sun are connected with them. The fact that intermediate vector particles (photons, bosons, and gluons) take part in all interactions, successful development of a unified electric weak theory, symmetry among leptons and quarks, etc., indicate the possibility of the existence of a general bond between fundamental forces. The possibility to develop a single theory unifying these forces, i.e., electromagnetic, strong (nuclear), weak, and gravitational forces, follows from here also. The key element of different approaches to formation of the Grand Unification Theory is the development of different kinds of supersymmetry schemes. However, despite the fact that papers devoted to this problem number several thousands already, “traces” of supersymmetry have not been discovered in spectra of known elementary particles. Nevertheless, it is possible that such traces will be discovered in experiments with superpowerful accelerators of new generations. The logic of development of physics of elementary particles is for this3. Let us point out in conclusion the characteristic scales of fundamental forces. Gravitational and electromagnetic forces are long-range. Nuclear 3
It was reported recently that results of very precise measurements obtained lately support predictions on minimal supersymmetric SU (5) model, which unifies electromagnetic, weak, and strong couplings (see U. Amaldi, W. de Boer, and H. Furstenau, Phys. Lett. B, 1991, v. 260, p. 447; S. Dimoklos, S. A. Raby, and F. Wilczek, Phys. Today, 1991, v. 44, p. 25). It is expected that such “unification” (if it exists) should be observed at the energy E > 1013 TeV.
12
PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
forces act at distances of the order of magnitude of nuclear size. A short range of coupling characterizes weak forces. It is at least two orders of magnitude less than the range of strong coupling. New theories including the Grand Unification Theory need new experiments with more powerful accelerators of new generations4. However, there are fundamental limits in construction of very powerful (“traditional”) accelerators. Estimates show that a hypothetical annular accelerator for energy 107 TeV, which could be constructed using a superconductor magnet, would be a ring with radius about that of the Earth. Even if such an accelerator was located in space, attempts to further increase of its power and size would be impossible because of synchrotron radiation. In the meantime, “natural” accelerators can “accelerate” particles, e.g., neutrino, up to the energy 108 TeV. Methods of radiation acoustics may be useful (or even extremely necessary) for detection of just such particles of super-high energy. Indeed, as will be described in detail in a special section, 7 8 the appearance of particles with energy E ≈ 10 – 10 TeV in the spectrum of cosmic rays is an extremely rare occasion. Probability and frequency of their detection increase with the increase of detector size. Huge detectors (with the size of tens of square kilometers) are needed for this. Just under such conditions, application of acoustic detection methods (i.e., utilization of arrays of hydrophones or seisms) instead of traditional techniques (scintillation counters and Cherenkov detectors in water) can be favorable and justified. Thus, according to modern concepts, six leptons, six types (“flavors”) of quarks, and five bosons (photons, gluons, and intermediate vector bosons γ, g, W±, and Z0) are the fundamental particles forming the world around us. All processes observed up to now are caused by fundamental couplings of four types: gravitational, electromagnetic, strong (nuclear), and weak. We have tried to give the most general idea of the modern state of affairs in the physics of elementary particles5. We do not need a detailed presentation here. Those who are interested in more details can find them in
4
It is useful to note that some theories of supersymmetry connect hopes for 16 development of the Grand Unification Theory with the energy 10 TeV and scales −33 at distances about 10 cm. As it follows from modern concepts, a strict symmetry exists at small distances. This symmetry is violated spontaneously in the process of transition to large scales which leads to the variety of particles and types of their interaction which we observe around us in the process of experimenting with modern large accelerators and in the spectrum of cosmic rays [73, 78,169] (see also the previous footnote). 5 According to a colorful expression by Ya. B. Zel’dovich, a presentation for “pedestrians” [98].
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
13
books by Akhiezer and Rekalo [14], Grishin [78], and Okun’ [168, 169], a paper by Zel’dovich [98], and other papers cited there6.
2. ABSORPTION OF PENETRATING RADIATION IN A CONDENSED MEDIUM In many cases the parameters of the acoustic field generated by penetrating radiation in a condensed medium are determined essentially by the characteristics of radiation absorption in a substance. Absorption depends on the type of particles (quanta), their energy, and the material of a target. Let us consider, in the most general form, some laws of radiation absorption. While moving through a substance, particles interact with its atoms, i.e., electron shells and atomic nuclei (or nuclear nucleons). As we have indicated already, there are three types of interactions involving particles (we ignore very weak gravitation coupling as it is very small and insignificant at this scale), i.e., strong (nuclear), electromagnetic, and weak. In contrast to electromagnetic coupling and in the case of not very large energy of particles, strong and weak couplings are essential only in the case of very small dimensions of the interaction region, about the dimensions of elementary particles and atomic nuclei. Therefore, considering passage of charged particles through a substance, the major role belongs to electromagnetic coupling.
TRANSITION OF HEAVY CHARGED PARTICLES THROUGH A SUBSTANCE Protons, nuclei of various atoms, e.g., nuclei of atoms of helium 4He (α-particles) consisting of two protons and two neutrons, nuclei of hydrogen isotope, isotope of helium 3He (two protons and one neutron), and some other particles taking part in strong coupling belong to heavy charged particles. Heavy charged particles of moderate energy lose it in the process of passage through a substance. This happens mostly because of inelastic collisions with bound electrons of atoms of a retarding substance. When the velocity of a particle becomes so small that it captures electrons, energy losses decrease. However, deceleration of a particle continues until its energy gets reduced down to the thermal energy of substance atoms. The 6
See also papers on accelerators [47, 176, 223, 229, 237, 256].
14
PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
first stage of the process of deceleration, i.e., deceleration during the time when a particle is still charged, may be described theoretically in a satisfactory way [188, 190]. The second stage of the deceleration process, i.e., the stage when a particle captures electrons (e.g., at energy less than 1 MeV for an alpha-particle or 0.1 MeV for a proton), practically cannot be treated theoretically. However, there are reliable experimental data [244]. The loss of energy by multi-charge nuclei has a special feature: they can capture not a single electron but several, which makes the spectrum of energy losses more complex [232]. Theoretical calculation for the first stage of the process of deceleration of a heavy particle leads to the formula [188] dE 4πe 4 z 2 NB , = dx mV 2
(1.1)
where, for example, in the case of relativistic velocity of a particle 2mV 2 − ln(1 − β 2 ) − β 2 ; B = Z ln I E is the particle energy; ze and V are its charge and velocity; M and m are the masses of the incident particle and electron, respectively; N is the number of atoms in the unit volume of a substance; Z is the charge of nuclei of atoms of a medium substance; I is the average excitation energy of an −19 J); β = V/u; and u is the velocity of light. The atom (I = 18.5Z⋅1.6⋅10 quantity dE/dx is called the “stopping ability” of a substance and B is called the deceleration coefficient. Sometimes the quantity B is identified as the “stopping ability” of a substance. In the general case, B is determined either theoretically or experimentally. Passing through a substance, a heavy charged particle performs ionization, which results in loss of energy. The most probable initial collisions with atomic electrons are collisions, such that a relatively slow secondary electron with kinetic energy not exceeding the ionization energy is knocked out. However, secondary electrons with relatively large energy form in the result of a small number of collisions, their maximum energy 4(v/M)E corresponding to the maximum velocity equal to the double velocity of an incident heavy particle. For example, in the case of a proton with energy E = 10 MeV, secondary electrons of different energy may be produced, the maximum energy being equal to 20 keV. These so-called delta-electrons (δ-electrons) ionize atoms of a retarding medium further. Therefore, the initial ionization produced by the charged
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
15
particle itself should be distinguished from secondary ionization produced by delta-electrons. According to experimental data, total ionization exceeds initial ionization approximately three times. Distribution of ionization losses along the path of a particle coincides to a first approximation with the stopping ability of a substance or, in other words, with the distribution of energy losses at the unit length of the path dE/dx. The main result obtained from formula (1.1) is the fact that specific energy losses of a charged particle for ionization are proportional to the particle charge, concentration of electrons in a medium, and a certain function of velocity, but they do not depend on the particle mass. Formula (1.1) shows that as the particle energy grows, specific losses for ionization decrease at first very rapidly (inversely proportional to energy), but do this more and more slowly as the particle velocity comes closer and closer to the light velocity. However, starting from a certain large enough energy of a particle, energy losses increase on account of relativistic effects. Formula (1.1) is not quite exact: in the case of a large velocity of a particle it is necessary to take into account the so-called density effect [188], which leads to decrease of specific energy losses. Due to this fact, relativistic growth of specific losses stops and the curve becomes flat. The density effect manifests itself in condensed media earlier than in rarefied ones.
ABSORPTION OF NEUTRAL HEAVY PARTICLES IN A SUBSTANCE Deceleration of neutral heavy particles (neutrons are the most important ones) in a condensed medium occurs mostly because of direct collisions with atomic nuclei of target substance. Nuclear forces play the main role in this process. It is very difficult to obtain analytical functions in this case and one has to use either experimental data or semi-empirical functions [20]7. We should note here that energy losses by heavy neutral particles are much smaller than the corresponding losses by heavy charged particles and consequently, their depth of penetration into a medium is much larger than that of heavy charged particles.
7
Another way is to use a complex computer simulation of processes of neutron transfer in a substance using the Monte Carlo method for example or other ones. Only in some cases is it possible to obtain analytical functions of a rather complex form. Some information on these functions characterizing absorption of fast neutrons in a substance can be found in a paper by Han S. Uhm, J. Appl. Phys., 1992, v. 72 (7), p. 2549 – 2555.
PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
16
ABSORPTION OF ELECTRONS IN A SUBSTANCE Energy losses in a substance for electrons with relatively low energy (smaller than the so-called critical energy; see below) are caused by ionization and excitation of bound electrons of a retarding medium as in the case of heavy charged particles. If electron energy is larger than the average energy of atom excitation, the formula for calculation of ionization losses by such electrons does not differ too much from formula (1.1) and can be written down in the next form [188]:
−
dE 2πe 4 mV 2 E = − (2 1 − β 2 − 1 + β 2 ) ln 2 + NZ ln dx mV 2 2 I 2 (1 − β 2 ) (1.2) 1 (1 − β 2 ) + (1 − 1 − β 2 ) 2 , 8
where E is the energy of an incident electron (total energy minus rest energy). The difference of formula (1.1) to formula (1.2) is caused by the difference between the equivalent masses of an electron and a heavy particle or two electrons and also quantum-mechanical indiscriminability of two electrons participating in the process of collision. If electron energy is lower than the average excitation energy of atoms, it is difficult to describe the process theoretically as in the case of small energy of heavy charged particles, when they capture electrons of a medium, and one has to use experimental data [244]. In the case of high-energy electrons, we have to take into account the density effect as in the case of heavy charged particles. This effect reduces ionization losses as compared to those given by formula (1.2). If the energy is very large, electrons start to lose energy effectively since the role of bremsstrahlung increases. According to the classical electromagnetic theory, a charge under 2 2 3 acceleration a emits energy (2/3)(e a /c ) per time unit. An electron can be accelerated in the electric field of a nucleus since its mass is small and acceleration is proportional to the charge of a nucleus Z divided by the electron mass m. The bremsstrahlung has the major effect upon energy losses by fast electrons. Radiation does not play an essential role in the process of deceleration of fast heavy particles. This is caused by the fact that acceleration is proportional to 1/M, and as a result, radiation gets 2 reduced (m/M) times as against radiation by electrons. We can write down the next expression for energy losses for radiation by a relativistic electron [164, 188]:
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
1 dE 1 =− , E dx x0
17
(1.3)
where x0 is the so-called radiation length different for different substances. Comparison of expressions (1.2) and (1.3) shows that energy losses for radiation increase with energy growth almost linearly, while energy losses for ionization increase only logarithmically. Therefore, in the case of large energies, losses for radiation are dominant and as the energy of electrons decreases, and ionization becomes more and more important until at some critical energy Ecr losses for ionization and losses for radiation will become 2 comparable. We can give an approximate formula Ecr ≈ 1600 mu / Z and obtain an equation for the ratio of energy losses for radiation to losses for ionization [188], (dE / dx) rad EZ . = (dE / dx) ion 1600mu 2 It follows from here that in the case of water for example, Ecr ≈ 100 MeV and in the case of lead Ecr ≈ 10 MeV. In the case of electrons with energy higher than critical, as the distance increases, the energy losses are described (on the average) by an exponential law corresponding to expression (1.3). In the case of water and air x0 is equal approximately to 36 g/cm2, for aluminum it is equal to 24 g/cm2, and for lead it is about 6 g/cm2.
ABSORPTION OF ELECTROMAGNETIC RADIATION IN A SUBSTANCE In the process of transmission through a substance electromagnetic radiation is subjected to characteristic exponential absorption in contrast to the laws characterizing absorption of heavy charged particles or electrons. The reason for this is the fact that in the process of absorption each gammaquantum is taken away from an incident beam as a result of a single act. In this case the beam intensity at the absorber thickness x has the next form [188]: I ( x) = I 0 exp(− µx) ,
(1.4)
where I0 is the intensity of incident beam and µ is the coefficient of radiation absorption. The main processes determining absorption of gamma-
18
PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
quanta in a substance are the photoeffect, Compton scattering, and formation of electron-positron couples. In the case of gamma-quanta (γquanta) of low energy the most essential role is played by the photoeffect; the Compton absorption is dominant in the range of intermediate values of energy; and formation of couples is most important at large values of energy.
FORMATION OF NUCLEAR-ELECTROMAGNETIC CASCADES IN A SUBSTANCE Nuclear-electromagnetic cascades (cascade showers as they are called frequently or just showers) are formed in a substance in the process of absorption of penetrating radiation with quanta of very high energy sufficient for formation of multiple secondary particles. Their rise occurs as a result of a large number of single interactions, and therefore, it is not an elementary process [119, 163, 174]. In the case of large values of energy of an initial particle, the energy distribution in a cascade is almost independent of the type of the initial particle since development of a cascade is determined basically by an electron−photon avalanche. Quantitative characteristics of electron−photon cascades are studied by the electromagnetic cascade theory. The major task of this theory is determination of the function describing the distribution of particles at a certain depth in a substance with atomic number Z with respect to energy, angles, and distances from the shower axis, which is determined as the line of motion of the initial particle. A spectrum of electrons in a shower or socalled cascade curves of a very complex shape can be obtained from the solutions of the kinetic equations of the cascade theory. About 80% of electrons in the maximum of a shower have energy smaller than the critical one, and 50% of them have energy smaller than 1/3 of the critical energy. The distance of recession of an electron from the shower axis is determined basically by Coulomb scattering at the path of the order of magnitude of the radiation length. It is inversely proportional to the electron energy. In other words, in the tail of a cascade, where the energy of electrons is small, they can go away farther from the cascade axis.
EXTENSIVE AIR SHOWERS Studies of cosmic rays lead to the discovery of nuclear-electromagnetic showers in the atmosphere, i.e., showers of particles of cosmic rays covering large areas. These showers got the name of extensive air showers. They rise as a result of interaction of high-energy particles belonging to the
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
19
so-called hard component of cosmic rays with a substance in the atmosphere. Let us present basic results concerning absorption of penetrating 10 radiation in a substance. If particle energy is very large (about 10 eV and higher), the rise of cascade showers occurs in a medium (in this case it is necessary that neutrinos and muons interact with a substance in the process of some nuclear reaction). If particle energy is smaller and showers do not arise, absorption of penetrating radiation in a substance depends on the type of particles and energy. Thus, absorption of gamma-quanta (and optical radiation) occurs according to an exponential law in the whole range of these energies. Absorption of charged heavy particles (and muons) is governed by law (1.1) up to the energies when a particle captures an electron or its energy becomes equal to the average energy of atom excitation. Further absorption is determined by more complex functions, which can be obtained in a simpler way from experimental data. As a proton continues to move in a substance, its losses grow until it captures an electron of a substance atom and then losses begin to decrease. A curve characterizing dependence of losses of a proton on the so-called residual path displays a peak. This peak got the name of the Bragg peak [188]. Absorption of relativistic electrons occurs at first according to an exponential law according to formula (1.3) until the critical energy is attained. Then its absorption is determined by formula (1.2) up to the energies when the velocity of incident electrons equals velocities of electrons of atomic shells. Further absorption is determined by complex functions obtained from experimental data. We should note that the energy range, when expressions (1.2) and (1.3) become invalid and absorption of heavy charged particles and electrons is determined by functions obtained from experiments, is usually small and we can consider a particle to be totally absorbed when it attains such small energy. The grounds for theoretical treatment of the thermoradiation mechanism of sound generation are the solutions of an inhomogeneous wave equation. The right-hand side of this equation contains a function describing the power density of thermal sources of sound, which are created by absorption of penetrating radiation in a substance. In the case of fluid media, this equation has the form
∆p −
1 ∂2 p c
or
2
∂t
2
=−
α ∂Q , C p ∂t
(1.5)
20
PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
∂2 p ∂t 2
− c 2 ∆p = Γ
∂Q , ∂t
where p is the sound pressure, c is the velocity of sound, α is the coefficient of cubical thermal expansion, Cp is the specific heat capacity of a liquid, Q is the function characterizing energy evolution (absorption) of penetrating 2 radiation or the power density of thermal sources of sound, and Γ ≡ c α / Cp is the Grueneisen coefficient. In the case of an isotropic solid, the equation has the form 1 ∂2 (3 − 4 / n 2 ) β divF ∆ − u = Qdt − div , ∫ 2 2 2 Cε ρ c ∂ t c ρ l l
(1.6)
2 ∆ − 1 ∂ rot u = − rotF . ct2 ∂t 2 ct2 ρ
(1.7)
Here cl and ct are the velocities of longitudinal and transverse waves, respectively, n = cl / ct , u is the vector of displacement of a particle of a solid, ρ is the density, β is the coefficient of linear thermal expansion, Cε is the specific heat capacity of a solid, and F is the external non-thermoelastic force applied to the unit of solid volume (the nature of this force will be explained later); F ≡ 0 if we consider only the thermoradiation mechanism of sound generation, and therefore, only thermal sources of sound are taken into account. One can see from the equations given below that the amplitude of sound pressure is proportional to the Grueneisen coefficient Γ and depends on the function of energy release Q (the power density of thermal sources of sound). The form of the function Q for different types of penetrating radiation differs. In the case of electromagnetic radiation Q( x1 , x 2 , x3 , t ) = µI ( x1 , x 2 , t ) exp(− µx3 ) ,
(1.8)
where x3 is the coordinate in the direction of propagation of radiation beam, µ is the coefficient of radiation absorption in a medium or the inverse path of radiation quanta in a medium. For example, in the case of light with the wavelength λl = 1.06 µm (radiation of a neodymium glass laser) and pure −1 water µ = 0.17 cm and in the case of CO2-laser radiation (λl = 10.6 µm) −1 and pure water µ = 800 cm . Formula (1.8) is true for electromagnetic radiation of various types, i.e., light, X-rays, synchrotron radiation, beams of γ-quanta, etc., as well as
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
21
relativistic electrons, where energy losses in the process of interaction with a substance are connected with emission of photons (radiation losses). We can write down an expression for the intensity of penetrating radiation in a beam: I ( x1 , x 2 , t ) = n p ( x1 , x 2 , t ) E ,
(1.9)
where np(x1,x2,t) is the density of particles. We have for the function of energy release Q( x1 , x 2 , t ) = n p ( x1 , x 2 , t )
dE ( x3 ) . dx3
(1.10)
One can see readily from expressions (1.3), (1.4), (1.9), and (1.10) that −1 formula (1.8) is true for relativistic electrons if we take µ = x0 . If the energy of electrons (non-relativistic) is small but larger than the average energy of excitation of substance atoms interacting with the electron beam, losses are determined by ionization. As we have mentioned above already, radiation losses increase with the growth of energy almost linearly and the losses of energy Ee increase only logarithmically. Therefore in the case of large energy Ee (relativistic velocities), radiation losses prevail and as the energy of electrons decreases, ionization plays a more and more important role until losses for ionization and losses for radiation become equal at a certain critical energy Ee,cr. For example in the case of water, Ee,cr = 100 MeV and for lead Ee,cr = 10 MeV. In the case of energies higher than the critical one, energy losses are described (on the average) by an exponential law according to formulae (1.3) and (1.8). Thus, a beam of relativistic electrons with energy of 1 GeV loses up to 90% of its energy in water and up to 99% of it in lead in compliance with exponential law (1.8), and only about 10% and 1%, respectively are lost due to ionization. In the case of heavy charged particles (protons, nuclei of various atoms, and particles in general, which take part in strong coupling), formula (1.8) is inapplicable and we can use expressions (1.1) and (1.10) to determine the form of the function of energy evolution. In the process of absorption of penetrating radiation with particles of very high energy sufficient for production of multiple secondary particles, when nuclear-electron-photon or nuclear-electromagnetic cascades rise in a substance energy absorption in a cascade can be considered as approximately exponential.
22
PENETRATING RADIATION: GENERAL INFORMATION
As for deceleration of neutral charged particles (the most important of them are neutrons) in a condensed medium, this deceleration occurs due to direct collisions with nuclei of atoms of the substance as we have mentioned above. Derivation of universal analytical functions in these cases is difficult as a rule, and one has to be content with specific calculations or empirical functions based upon experimental data. Thus, determination of the analytical form of the function of energy release, Q can be difficult. Therefore, the exponential law of absorption of penetrating radiation in a substance, and the Gaussian intensity distribution in a beam with respect to its radius, are adopted frequently when specific problems of thermoradiation generation of sound are treated. The basic conclusions of the theory also stay true in the majority of cases for other kinds of radiation, when absorption in a substance is not governed by an exponential law [156].
CHAPTER 2
Basic Mechanisms of Sound Generation by Penetrating Radiation in Condensed Media Mechanisms of sound generation are physical phenomena resulting in conversion of energy of penetrating radiation into energy of sound waves in the process of radiation absorption in a medium. Mechanisms of sound generation may depend on the type and intensity of penetrating radiation, target substance where this radiation is absorbed, and the mode of energy release. Physical phenomena of conversion of energy of penetrating radiation into sound energy (mechanisms of sound generation) are multiple and unequal in their efficiency. Here we treat only those of them which are apparently most important in the sense that they alone determine sound fields in the majority of real situations.
1. MECHANISMS CONNECTED WITH HEAT RELEASE One of the most universal physical phenomena taking place in the process of absorption of penetrating radiation in a substance is heat release. Released thermal energy can be converted partially into the energy of sound waves in different ways. 23
24
BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION
In the case of moderate density of energy released in a medium when phase transitions do not occur, the major contribution into the process of sound generation belongs usually to thermal cubical expansion. This is a socalled thermal or thermoradiation mechanism of sound generation. Sometimes it is called a thermoelastic mechanism, when sound excitation by penetrating radiation in a solid is discussed. A distinctive feature of the thermoradiation mechanism is the fact that the basic fundamental features of sound fields can be described within the framework of a linear model corresponding to the acoustic approximation in the case of calculation of hydrodynamic or elastic disturbances. It has provided an opportunity to develop a very effective theory of sound generation in a liquid (e.g., by laser radiation), which agrees well with experimental data (see reviews by Bunkin and Komissarov [41], Lyamshev [128, 129], and Lyamshev and Sedov [142]). Recently a theory of thermoradiation sound generation by penetrating radiation has been developed [156]. The pattern of sound generation in the case of large intensities of radiation (and more precisely, in the case of large densities of energy delivered into a medium) looks more complex. The effects developing in this case are of nonlinear character, and the design of an exhaustive theory of these phenomena is really far from being finished. Some results concerning sound generation in a liquid by high-intensity laser radiation can be found in reviews by Lyamshev [128] and Lyamshev and Naugol’nykh [141]. Nonlinear effects similar to the ones characteristic to interaction of powerful laser radiation with a substance also arise in a medium in the process of absorption of penetrating radiation in it, when the density of energy released in a medium is sufficient for phase transitions [86]. An exhaustive theory of such phenomena has been developed to an even less extent than in the case of absorption of laser radiation. Further we consider only some examples of such phenomena. Let us treat in more detail the basic mechanisms of sound generation by penetrating radiation.
2. THERMORADIATION GENERATION OF SOUND Many studies have been devoted to the thermoradiation mechanism of sound generation by various types of penetrating radiation [8, 9, 11, 16, 23, 28, 36, 54 – 56, 58, 68, 70, 81 – 83, 85, 103, 104, 151, 153, 154, 158, 159, 193, 194, 199, 200, 209, 212, 224, 225, 231, 235, 242, 244, 255, 261]. Sets of hydrodynamic equations or equations of dynamic theory of thermoelasticity and equations of the field of radiation of a given type are initially required for derivation of the equation of thermodynamic
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
25
generation of sound in a liquid or isotropic solid by penetrating radiation. Linearizing a set of equations and ignoring the effects of thermal conductivity and viscosity in the case of a liquid, we write down an inhomogeneous wave equation of sound generation in the form [259],
∆p −
1 ∂2 p c
2
∂t
2
=−
α ∂Q . C p ∂t
(2.1)
In equation (2.1), p is the sound pressure, α is the coefficient of cubical thermal expansion, Cp is the specific heat capacity of a liquid, Q is the function characterizing the power density of thermal sound sources arising due to absorption of penetrating radiation in a liquid, and c is the sound velocity in a liquid. It follows from this equation that in the case of a sound field of high frequency or sound pulse of small duration, the amplitude of a signal is proportional to the quantity αc2/Cp or the Grueneisen parameter (coefficient) Γ. The same may be said also about sound stress in a solid. The power density of thermal sources of sound depends on the type of penetrating radiation and the target material. Many papers studied the dependence of acoustic signal amplitude on the energy of penetrating radiation and the substance and geometry of the target. Thus, Borshkovskii and Volovik [36] studied the dependence of the amplitude of acoustic signal excited in thin metal (aluminum) plates by pulsed beams of electrons and protons. Some results are given in Fig. 2.1, where dependences of acoustic signal amplitude on energy of electrons and protons are presented. As the authors note, these results are the evidence of the fact that the main contribution to acoustic vibrations from electrons and protons flying through thin metal plates derives from energy losses for ionization.
Figure 2.1 Dependences of acoustic signal amplitude on the energy of (1) protons and (2) electrons.
26
BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION
Volovik and Ivanov [53] demonstrated that the ratio of amplitudes of acoustic signals excited by pulsed beams of protons and electrons in aluminum and piezoelectric ceramics is equal to the ratio of the corresponding Grueneisen coefficients (if the density of absorbed energy is the same). This was considered by the authors as the proof of the thermoelastic nature of the signal in these substances. Analogous estimations of acoustic signal amplitude (or experimental data) were made in the majority of other relatively early papers [28, 242, 261]. The authors of later papers studied the shape of a signal together with its amplitude. Blazhevich et al. [28] used the shape of an acoustic pulse excited in a solid sample by a pulse of electronic beam for determination of density of energy absorbed in the sample. In this case the shape of a one-dimensional acoustic pulse is connected with the density of energy absorbed in a sample E(x) by the relationship, v ( x, t ) ≡ −
Γ E ( x − ct ) , 2
(2.2)
where c is the sound velocity in a sample. Lyamshev and Chelnokov [152, 153, 158, 159] studied theoretically sound excitation by penetrating radiation in a liquid and solid in an approximation of the thermal mechanism. Many papers were devoted to investigation of the problem of the mechanism of generation of acoustic vibrations by penetrating radiation in a liquid [16, 68, 235, 255]. For example, Golubnichii, Kalyuzhnyi, and Korchikov [68] established that the rise of the acoustic signal produced by an absorbed electron beam in a liquid is determined by the thermal mechanism of sound generation. Performing accurate measurements, they demonstrated that the measured amplitude of acoustic signal in a liquid coincided with the one predicted theoretically and in the case of changing of water temperature around 4°C, the acoustic signal changed its polarity which was explained by the change of the sign of the absorption coefficient of water. Analogous results were obtained by Balitskii et al. [16] who studied, however, an acoustic field generated by a totally absorbed electron beam in water, and not by a beam, which was partially absorbed in a cell with water and partially transmitted through it [68]. Similar results demonstrating that, in the case of protons, the thermal mechanism of sound generation in water is dominant, were obtained by Danil’chenko et al., Levi et al., and Sulac et al. [85, 235, 254, 255]. Many papers devoted to acoustic detection of single high-energy particles (the DUMAND Project) analyze the parameters of the sound field
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
27
in the near-field zone of a nuclear-electron cascade arising in water [11, 56, 194, 200, 214]. Thus, using equation (2.1) and calculating in different ways the function Q(x, y, z, t), we can obtain the shape and amplitude of a produced acoustic pulse. The time dependence of the function Q is always taken in the form of the delta-function δ(t) since the time of the cascade rise is much smaller than other characteristic times of the process of sound generation, and the spatial dependence is determined on the basis of various direct calculations of density of energy release in the cascade taking into account possible approximations. For example, Volovik et al. [58] give the next expression for the amplitude of acoustic signal in sea water:
Pmax =
0.44ϕ (r ) E 18 Pa , r 10
where E is the energy of a particle (in eV) and r is the distance from the cascade axis (in meters). The factor ϕ(r) allows for deviation from the law p(r) ~ r−1/2, because of absorption or sound refraction for example and it is taken approximately equal to one. For example in the case of a particle with the energy E = 1017 eV, the amplitude of acoustic signal at a distance 100 m from the cascade axis is about 4.10−3 Pa. Figure 2.2 presents shapes of acoustic pulses for various dependences of the function of power density of sound sources Q [58].
Figure 2.2 Shapes of acoustic pulses for various dependences of the function of density of energy release Q. (1) The case of distribution of energy released in an electromagnetic cascade according to the Nishimura-Kamata-Greisen model; (2) the case of uniform distribution in a cylindrical region of the length of 5 m and radius of 2 cm; (3) the area with the Gaussian distribution of density of energy release.
28
BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION
3. INITIATION OF MICROSHOCK WAVES Passage of penetrating radiation through a substance may cause microshock waves. Thus, for example in the case of passage of fission fragments through a liquid, shock waves may arise in it along the track of the fragments [72, 233]. On the other hand, delta-electrons arising in the process of passage of ionizing particles through a liquid produce overheated micro-regions (thermal sources) in it. Explosive expansion of these regions gives birth to a shock wave [4]. The rise of shock waves is an essentially nonlinear effect. The theory of such processes is also far from being completed. Following Anoshin [4], let us perform estimation of parameters of shock waves produced by delta-electrons. In order to produce micro-regions capable of explosive expansion, it is necessary for the energy lost by an ionizing particle to be localized initially in a small enough volume. This condition may be satisfied in the case of delta-electrons knocked out by an ionizing projectile particle. The path l(Eδ) (in cm) of a delta-electron depends on its energy Eδ (in eV) in the following way: l ( Eδ ) = 0.58 ⋅ 10 −12 ⋅ AEδ2
1 , ρ0Z
(2.3)
where ρ0 is the medium density and Z/A is the ratio of the number of electrons to the molecular mass. As the energy of a delta-electron decreases, its trajectory differs more and more from a straight line and becomes similar to a coil. For example, already at Eδ = 10 keV the average path of an electron is a half of the path l(Eδ), i.e., 0.5l(Eδ). The number ν of water molecules per the path l(Eδ) is determined as
ν=
1/ 3
l ( Eδ ) l ( Eδ ) 4πρ 0 N A = d 2 3A
,
(2.4)
where d is the diameter of the spherical volume V1 occupied by a single water molecule and NA is the Avogadro constant. If the energy of a deltaelectron is small enough, its track is located within the sphere of the volume V0, which is determined according to the formula V0 = νV1 =
l ( Eδ ) A . ρ0 N Ad
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
29
The energy transmitted on average to a single molecule is equal to ∆E = Eδ /ν = Eδ d / l(Eδ). If we choose (proceeding from reasonable assumptions) for water ∆E = 30 eV when micro-explosive production of bubble nuclei occurs, the parameters making possible explosive expansion of overheated regions in water have the values Eδ = 1.23 keV, ν ≈ 41, and 3 V0 = 1.23⋅10−21 cm . The radius of the sphere of the volume V0 is equal to −8 a0 = 6.64⋅10 cm. The density of energy release Q in the thermal peak, which is determined according to a formula Q = Eδ/V0 = EδAd/[l(Eδ)ρ0N0], in this case is equal to 16.09⋅104 J/cm3. Comparing it to the caloricity of a common explosive, one can see that the latter is equal to 4.19⋅103 J/cm3 approximately. According to the theory of underwater explosions, pressure in a shock wave psh(r,t) can be written down as (2.5)
psh (r , t ) = psh max (r ) exp(−t / Θ) ,
where psh max(r) is the maximum pressure (in Pa), r is the distance from the centre of the spherical volume of thermal peak (in cm), t is time, and Θ is the time constant (in seconds). In this case it is possible to demonstrate that psh max (r ) = 1.37 ⋅ 10 2 r −1 Pa , Θ(r ) = 1.07 ⋅ 10 −10 (7.18 + log r ) at r > 102 a0. The spectrum of the pulse psh(r,t) has the form
[
S (ω ) = psh max (r ) Θ − 2 (r ) + ω 2
]
−1 / 2
.
(2.6)
If frequencies ω < 1 / Θ(r), the spectrum is uniform and can be written down as S (ω ) ≈ psh max (r ) ⋅ Θ(r ) .
Root-mean-square pressure at the distance r from a single thermal peak in water is p = 7.76 ⋅ 10 −8 (7.18 + log r ) ⋅ (1 / r ) Pa/Hz1/2 .
30
BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION
The number of such thermal peaks per unit length of a track of a relativistic electron is equal to the number of delta-electrons with Eδ = 1.23 keV (according to Anoshin [4], it is equal to 17.32 cm−1). It is interesting to note that it is possible to obtain the following estimate for the intensity I (in W/cm2) of acoustic radiation in water from a single high-energy particle, which produces in the process of its entry to the atmosphere an extensive air shower consisting mostly of electrons [4]. I = 10 −29 E0 / R ,
(2.7)
where E0 is the energy of a particle (in eV) and R is the distance from the axis of an extensive air shower (in cm). Apparently, now it is possible to 17 detect extensive air showers at E0 ≥ 10 eV according to underwater acoustic radiation. When a cosmic particle of super-high energy gives birth to a shower of secondary particles directly in water, the density of radiating centers is much larger than in the case of an extensive air shower in the atmosphere. This provides an opportunity to lower the threshold of detection with respect to particle energy. Apparently, this takes place in mountain lakes, for example. The considered opportunity for acoustic detection of a high-energy cosmic particle does not concern apparently muons and neutrinos because of their large penetrating power. These particles produce cascades deep in the ocean and Earth and their sound fields are generated due to the thermal mechanism of sound excitation. It is interesting to note that the estimated value of intensity of sound field of an extensive air shower does not contradict the hypothesis by Lyamshev et al. [150] on generation of noise in the calm ocean by aggregate cosmic radiation.
4. BUBBLE MECHANISM Many authors discuss the possibility of sound generation in a liquid by penetrating radiation on account of the rise, oscillation, and collapse of microscopic bubbles at tracks of particles constituting a given type of ionizing radiation1. The theory of the bubble mechanism of sound generation is far from being completed. This is connected with the fact that a satisfactory description of arising phenomena needs to take into account the complex processes of nonlinear dynamics of a single bubble and a set of bubbles, and nonlinear effects in a liquid. For example, rough estimations 1
See [17, 57, 62, 64, 65, 150, 217, 238].
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
31
are conducted within the framework of a linear theory. A bubble arising as the result of interaction of a particle with a liquid is treated as a spherically symmetric source of sound with efficiency connected with the value of Q(x, y, z, t) in the place of “absorption” of the particle. The total effect from microscopic bubbles of a certain kind depends on both the relative amount of such microscopic bubbles and the efficiency of ultrasonic generation by a single bubble. Estimations demonstrate [57] that an essential contribution to sound radiation is made by quasistable microscopic bubbles and not only collapsing bubbles of a size of about 10−7 – 10−6 cm. In this case the acoustic signal imitates a signal from the thermal mechanism of sound generation (but it is much stronger). Recent experimental papers are evidence of the fact that the bubble mechanism of sound generation may be realized apparently (under normal experimental conditions, i.e., at atmospheric pressure and room temperature and in stable liquids) if penetrating radiation consists of heavy particles, e.g., fragments of fission nuclei [17, 71]. Further studies must clear up this question.
5. THE CHERENKOV MECHANISM When a particle moves in a medium with a velocity exceeding the phase velocity of wave propagation in this medium, it emits waves which are called the Cherenkov radiation. The intensity of the radiation and its characteristics (dispersion and polarization) depend on the nature of the waves and particle properties. The Cherenkov radiation of sound by a particle moving with a supersonic velocity in a solid can be described using a phenomenological model if a force (per unit volume) acting on a solid (lattice) and caused by a particle is introduced into the equation of the dynamic theory of elasticity [101]. The equation for the longitudinal component of displacement vector u takes the form, 1 ∂2 D div u = ∆ − ∆δ (r − vt ) , 2 2 2 c t c ∂ ρ l l
(2.8)
where D is the dimensional constant coinciding in order of magnitude with the bond energy of a particle with the lattice, v is the velocity of a particle, and cl is the velocity of longitudinal waves. The transverse component of the displacement vector is identically equal to zero since the acting force is
32
BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION
“longitudinal”. In this case the particle emits longitudinal sound waves and the spectral density of radiation energy Iω is proportional to the third power of sound frequency ω (see [101]:
Iω =
D2 4πρcl4
ω3 .
(2.9)
In the case of motion in a metal, a charged particle produces an electromagnetic field around itself. This field disturbs the equilibrium of conductivity electrons. The latter move ions due to the bond with the lattice. If the particle velocity is larger than the sound velocity, this mechanism leads to generation of not only longitudinal waves but also transverse sound waves [102]. Spectral densities of radiation of longitudinal Il(ω) and transverse It(ω) sound waves depend essentially on the properties of a particle and metal (the velocity of a particle, free path of electrons in a metal, Debye frequency, Fermi energy, etc.). In the case of low frequency, It(ω) ≥ Il(ω). At a certain frequency, ω = ϖ the values of It(ω) and Il(ω) become equal and at ω >> ϖ we have Il(ω) >> It(ω). The frequency ϖ depends on the particle velocity v and the free path of an electron l. The larger l and v are, the larger the value of ϖ is. The value of ϖ attains its maximum in the case of ultrarelativistic particles (v ≈ u) at l > δ0(vF cl)1/2, where vF is the Fermi velocity of conductivity electrons of a metal (~ 108 cm/s), δ0 ≈ 10−5 cm, and ϖ ≈ 104 s−1. The total intensity of radiation at all frequencies of transverse sound waves is much smaller than the analogous value for longitudinal waves It ≈ ≈ It(Vcl / u2)2 << Il and consequently, the total intensity of sound radiation (at all frequencies) is determined by radiation of longitudinal sound waves. The indirect character of excitation of sound waves (a particle – electromagnetic field – sound) does not change the Cherenkov character of their propagation along the cones cos θ l(t) = cV, the cone width for fast particles (v >> cl) being close to π/2. Deceleration of particles (finiteness of trajectory length) smears the cone to some extent. This smearing depends on frequency. It is larger, the smaller the frequency. In the case of the lowest possible frequencies (cl / ω >> L, L is the length of particle track), radiation is quite dissimilar to the Cherenkov radiation. It is determined by the average acceleration of a particle and looks like bremsstrahlung of light. The Cherenkov mechanism of sound generation contributes noticeably to the sound field emitted by a particle only at very high hypersonic frequencies (the spectral density of emitted energy is proportional to the third power of frequency). Thus, according to Borshkovskii and Volovik
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
33
[36], in the case of frequency range of hundreds of kilohertz, which may be important in practice, the ratios of acoustic energy emitted by particles due to the Cherenkov mechanism of sound generation to the acoustic energy emitted due to the dynamic (see below) and thermal mechanisms are 10−13 and 10−21. This is the evidence of relative weakness of this mechanism of sound generation in the low frequency range (in comparison with hypersound). Similar to electrodynamics, with the transition radiation connected with motion of a charged particle through media with different electromagnetic properties, the transition radiation can exist in acoustics also. This radiation is connected with the change of acoustic properties of a medium, where penetrating radiation is absorbed [171]. As in the case of the Cherenkov radiation, this radiation is quite weak. We will not discuss it in detail. There are mechanisms of sound generation specific to this or that type of radiation or target material. Let us discuss some of them briefly.
6. STRICTION MECHANISM OF SOUND GENERATION Microstiriction occurs in the field of ions in the process of medium ionization. It manifests itself noticeably in macroscopic effects [10]. A transiting charged particle (or any other particle capable of ionization) produces N1(0) pairs of ions per unit length of track in a medium. The number of these ions Nt(t) decreases sharply in time because of their recombination. Each ion attracts molecules of a medium by its field and creates local clouds. Microstrictional compression can play a significant role in the process of sound emission by charged particles in the case of a small coefficient of thermal expansion of a medium. In particular, the experimental results by Levi et al. [235] apparently can be explained with its help. It was revealed in these experiments that a sound pulse from a beam of charged particles in water vanishes and changes its sign not at T = 4°C when the coefficient of thermal expansion of water α = 0, but at T = 5.7°C when α ≈ 10−5 K−1. Amplitudes of pulses become equal at α ≈ 10−5 K−1, i.e., compensation of thermal expansion by strictional compression is possible in this case. Fast alternating striction in the field of a moving particle and in the collective field of beams also exists in the field of ions apart from microelectrostriction. Let us consider the strictional mechanism of sound generation in terms of laser excitation of sound. The equation of sound generation in the process of action of laser radiation on a liquid medium,
34
BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION
which takes into account thermal and strictional mechanisms, takes on the following form [43]: ∆p −
1 ∂2 p c
2
∂t
2
=−
α ∂Q 1 + C p ∂t 8π
∂ε ρ ∆ E 2 ; ∂ρ T
(2.10)
here ε is the dielectric constant of a liquid, E is the strength of electric field of laser (optical) radiation in a liquid, the angular brackets mean averaging with respect to the period of optical oscillations, (∂ε /∂ρ)T is the derivative of dielectric constant with respect to density in the case of constant temperature. The second term in the first part of equation (2.10) corresponds to the strictional mechanism of sound generation. Let us estimate the order of magnitude of the expression ∆〈E2〉. Monochromatic sound oscillations with the frequency ω can be excited due to the strictional mechanism in the case of two laser beams crossed under the angle θ and with frequencies ω1 and ω2, ω1 - ω2 = ω, and 2(ω1,2/u)n sin(θ/2) ~ ω / c = k. We have 1 8π 1 + (ak ) 2 + (aµ ) 2 q0 , ∆ E 2 ~ + k 2 + µ 2 E02 ~ nu a2 a2
(2.11)
where n = u1/2 is the refraction coefficient of a medium, k is the wave number, a is the radius of radiation beam, µ is the coefficient of radiation absorption in a liquid, E0 is the amplitude of the strength of electric field, u is the light velocity, c is the sound velocity in a liquid, and q0 is the intensity of light pulse in the middle of a beam. Since |∂Q / ∂ t| ~ µq0ω, the ratio of the first term in the right-hand side of equation (2.10) (corresponding to the thermal mechanism of sound generation) to the second term is equal to
αanuω µα . C p ( ρ∂ε / ∂ρ )T 1 + (ak ) 2 + (aµ ) 2 This relationship shows that the strictional mechanism of sound generation prevails over the thermal one only in the range of very high or very low frequency. In the case of water for example, the thermal mechanism is dominant with respect to the strictional mechanism at µ ≥ 0.2 cm−1 in the frequency range from 102 to 109 Hz.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
35
7. SOUND GENERATION IN THE PROCESS OF PULSED RADIOLYSIS Pulsed radiolysis is the mechanism of release of latent energy on account of substance decomposition under the effect of pulses of penetrating radiation [52, 59 – 61]. In particular, slow electrons arising in the process of substance ionization can be absorbed effectively by some halogencontaining liquids, i.e., reactions of the following type may occur: ABC n + e − = ABC n −1 + C − , where ABCn is the formula of a molecule of a liquid containing a certain halogen C in it. Further, this released energy may be transformed into sound energy with the help of the mechanisms of sound generation already considered above. These may be, for example, the thermal or bubble mechanisms of sound generation. In this case, if the density of released latent energy of a substance exceeds the density of energy evolved on account of absorption of penetrating radiation, the determining contribution to acoustic field in such radiation-unstable substance belongs to the effect of pulsed radiolysis [60].
8. DYNAMIC MECHANISM If penetrating radiation affects a substance, transfer of momentum from radiation quanta to atoms of a medium occurs. This phenomenon accompanied by excitation of sound waves is called the dynamic mechanism of sound generation [7, 63, 165]. In crystals the effect depends on the reciprocal directions of crystal axes and the velocities of particles constituting penetrating radiation [165]. Like the thermal mechanism of sound generation, the dynamic mechanism takes place in the case of any kind of penetrating radiation and manifests itself in both liquids and solids. In solids, however, the dynamic mechanism may be of fundamental importance because of the existence of transverse sound waves there [160]. The point is that transverse waves in solids under conditions of thermal mechanism result only from transformation of longitudinal waves at interfaces and medium inhomogeneities. As a result of action of the dynamic mechanism, longitudinal and transverse waves are excited in all cases and even in homogeneous isotropic solids.
36
BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION
Dynamic stress in solids in the process of transmission of beams of charged particles through them was determined by Nasonov [165]. In the case of small energy in a beam (the energy of several hundreds of electronvolts for plates of thickness of the order of magnitude of 0.01 cm), the pressure p produced by a beam incident on a plate does not depend on the target substance, and increases linearly with energy: p = n0p0ν0, where p0, ν0, and n0 are the momentum, velocity, and density of a beam of incident particles. In the case of large energy of a beam, the dependence of pressure on energy is of more complex character. Results of numerical calculation of dynamic pressure conducted by Nasonov [165] for aluminum, copper, and lead plates of thickness of 0.01 cm at different values of energy, are given in Figure 2.3.
Figure 2.3 Dynamic pressure upon a plate vs. energy of a beam in a plate. Broken curves correspond to proton beams and solid curves correspond to electron beams. (1) Copper, (2) lead, and (3) aluminum.
Sound generation under the dynamic mechanism can be treated within the framework of linear approximation. In this case, equations of sound generation in a solid have the form [160], 1 ∂2 div F ∆ − div u = − , 2 2 cl ∂t cl2 ρ (2.12) 2 ∆ − 1 ∂ rot u = − rot F , ct2 ∂t 2 ct2 ρ
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
37
where u is the displacement, cl and ct are the velocities of longitudinal and transverse sound waves, ρ is the medium density, and F is the dynamic force applied to unit volume. Comparing equations (2.1) and (2.12), one can see that the dynamic mechanism of sound generation produces a source of both longitudinal and transverse waves in a solid as distinct from the thermal mechanism, which excites sources of longitudinal waves only. In the case of penetrating radiation with quanta consisting of ultrarelativistic particles (e.g., photons), the dynamic force is equal to F = Q/u, where u is the light velocity. In order to compare the efficiency of sound excitation by the thermal and dynamic mechanisms, it is necessary to rewrite expressions (2.1) in terms of the displacement vector u and add dynamic sources to the right-hand side:
α 1 ∂2 div F ∆ − ∆Qdt − div u = . ∫ 2 2 2 Cpρ c ∂ t c ρ l l
(2.13)
One can see readily from here that under the condition F = Q/u and for the majority of substances, the ratio of displacements in sound waves excited due to the dynamic mechanism (the second term) to analogous displacements caused due to the thermal mechanism (the first term) is of the order of magnitude of the ratio of the velocity of longitudinal sound wave to the light velocity: cl/c ≅ 10−5. Thus, accounting for the dynamic mechanism of sound generation for ideal liquids (where only longitudinal waves can propagate) gives us only an insignificant correction to the sound field produced by the thermal mechanism of sound generation. Only hypersonic frequencies may be the exception. These frequencies are excited by the thermal mechanism inefficiently because of thermal conductivity of a substance, which is not taken into account in expression (2.1). However, in the case of solids, when the field of transverse waves, which cannot arise because of reflection or scattering of longitudinal waves, is studied, the dynamic mechanism of sound generation together with the thermal mechanism may provide a significant contribution.
38
BASIC MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION
9. OTHER MECHANISMS OF SOUND GENERATION As for other mechanisms of sound generation by penetrating radiation, we should note the mechanism of excitation of elastic waves with the help of the inverse piezoelectric effect [53, 122] and the transition mechanism already mentioned above. The first mechanism is connected with mechanical deformation of piezoelectric ceramics under the action of an electric field of penetrating radiation. We have to mention also that if weakly ionized plasma is produced in the area of absorption of penetrating radiation, interaction of electric and magnetic fields with plasma may violate the stable state of a medium and therefore, sound waves may be generated [123]. It is also possible that new data on as yet unknown mechanisms of sound generation may be obtained in the course of further theoretical and experimental research. Such research will provide an opportunity to use the methods of radiation acoustics for the solution of applied and basic problems even more widely. All considered mechanisms of sound generation have different restrictions in intensity, nature, and frequency range of emitted sound waves. Exact quantitative values can be obtained by the solution of specific boundary problems. It is essential in this case that in the majority of real situations all possible mechanisms of sound generation in solids contribute only small corrections to the sound field produced by the thermal mechanism of sound generation [55]. This is also true in the case of liquids if there are no phase transformations. Thus, the above discussion of the determining role of the thermal mechanism of sound generation in liquids and solids in the case of moderate density of energy released in a medium explains the importance of detailed studies of generation of sound fields in the approximation of this mechanism.
CHAPTER 3
Thermoradiation Excitation of Sound in a Homogeneous Liquid This chapter considers thermoradiation excitation of sound in a homogeneous liquid by intensity modulated penetrating radiation. Basic equations and the technique of solution of boundary problems are discussed in details. Specific features of excitation of monochromatic sound in a liquid half-space with the undisturbed surface (boundary) as well as the case when the liquid surface is characterized by large or small (in comparison with the sound wavelength) unevenness are considered. Efficiency of thermoradiation generation of sound in a liquid by penetrating radiation is discussed.
1. EQUATION OF THERMORADIATION GENERATION OF SOUND We understand the thermoradiation mechanism as a mechanism of sound excitation by penetrating radiation in a liquid, when a medium expands in the area of absorption because of heating due to radiation absorption but the aggregate state of a substance and its thermodynamic parameters do not change and the expansion velocity of the heated volume is essentially smaller than the velocity of sound propagation in the medium. This provides an opportunity to write down the set of equations of conservation 39
40
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
in the linearized form and derive a linear equation of thermoradiation generation of sound on its basis. Thus, an initial set of linearized equations of hydrodynamics complemented with equations of state and heat conductivity of a liquid is [43, 120]:
ρ
∂v η = −∇p ′ + η∆v + ξ + ∇(∇ ⋅ v ) , ∂t 3
∂ρ ′ ∂s ′ = − ρ (∇ ⋅ v) , ρT = κ∆T ′ + Q , ∂t ∂t (3.1) ∂p αc 2 ρT ∂p ρ ′ + s ′ ≡ c 2 ρ ′ + p ′ = s′ , Cp ∂s v ∂ρ s ∂s s′ = ∂T
Cp ∂s α T ′ − p′ . T ′ + p ′ ≡ T ρ p ∂p T
Here ρ, v, p, T, and s are the density, velocity, pressure, temperature, and specific entropy of a liquid, respectively; a stroke means a small increase of the corresponding parameter of a medium; η and ξ are the coefficients of shear and bulk viscosity; Cp and Cv are the specific heat capacities; v is the specific volume; α = v−1(∂v/∂T)p is the coefficient of cubical thermal expansion; κ and χ are the coefficients of thermal conductivity and diffusivity (χ = κv/Cp); Q is the power density of thermal sources produced due to absorption of penetrating radiation in a liquid, Q = − (∇⋅Π), and Π is the density of energy flux of penetrating radiation. We can obtain the desired equation of thermoradiation generation of sound on the basis of set (3.1): ∆p ′ −
1 ∂ 2 p′ c
2
∂t
2
+ 2Γ∆
∂p ′ αρT = Cp ∂t
4 / 3η + ξ ∂s ′ α ∂Q , − χ ∆ − ρ ∂t C p ∂t (3.2)
Γ≡
Cp 1 2 4 / 3η + ξ + χ − 1 . C C 2 ρ v
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
41
Let us turn to the physical meaning of some terms in equation (3.2). First of all, one can see that the third term in the left-hand side of the equation characterizes sound attenuation caused by viscosity and heat conductivity of a liquid. In the majority of cases, this term may be omitted in the process of solution of boundary or initial problems without any restrictions to generality. It can be taken into account separately while considering the final result as is done usually in acoustics. Terms in the right-hand side of equation (3.2) describe sound sources. It is possible to ignore the role of the first of them if we ignore the influence of viscosity and heat conductivity of a liquid. This is possible if the next conditions are satisfied: l 2 l 2 τ << min , min . χ ν
(3.3)
Here τ is the characteristic time of action of penetrating radiation on a substance, e.g., the duration of a single pulse or τ ~ ω −1, where ω is the modulation frequency of radiation intensity; and lmin is the minimum dimension of the area of absorption of penetrating radiation in a liquid. The dimension lmin ~ a is the radius of a radiation spot at the liquid surface and lmin = µ−1 is the so-called path of a particle of penetrating radiation equal to the inverse value of the coefficient of light absorption µ in the case of laser radiation or X-rays (synchrotron radiation); ν is the kinematic coefficient of viscosity. The physical sense of conditions (3.3) is evident. In fact, the quantity l2min/χ characterizes the time of equalization of temperature in the area of radiation absorption, i.e., the time of thermal relaxation. In the case of τ ≤ l2min/χ, there is no equalization of temperature in a medium. As for the condition τ >> l2min/ν, we have to note that the quantity (1/τν)1/2 ~ (ω/ν)1/2 characterizes the penetration depth of a so-called viscous wave and therefore, the condition τ << l2min/ν is equivalent to the condition lmin >> (ω/ν)1/2. In other words, the minimum dimensions of the area of heat evolution (thermal source) must be essentially larger than the depth of wave penetration. If the condition τ << l2min/χ is satisfied, the term κ∆T′ in the thermal conductivity equation in system (3.1) does not play any role and therefore, ρT ds′/dt ≈ Q(t), and under the condition τ << l2min/ν, the first term in the right-hand side of equation (3.2) is small in comparison with the second one and may be ignored within the whole region of generation and propagation of sound. Condition (3.3) is very frequently well satisfied for not very viscous liquids. The most strict limitations for the value of τ are imposed in
42
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
the case of liquids strongly absorbing radiation; usually lmin ~ µ−1 for these liquids. For example in the case of CO2-laser radiation (λl = 10.6 µm), the absorption coefficient of water is µ = 800 cm−1 (lmin ≈ 103 cm; the penetration depth of an electron beam of energy ~ 30 keV is approximately the same) and condition (3.3) leads to the requirement τ << 10−4 s (taking into account the fact that χ << ν ≈ 0.01 cm2/s for water). For optical radiation of the near IR range lmin ~ 1 mm (in the cases interesting from the practical point of view) that also corresponds approximately to the penetration depth of an electron beam with energy ~ 1 MeV. In this case condition (3.3) may be invalid only for infrasound. Thus, condition (3.3), which is the condition for the effect of viscosity and heat conductivity upon the efficiency of a thermal source, limits sound frequency from below. The same processes limit sound frequency from above by the condition of minimum absorption of sound (i.e., Γω << 1): ω << {c2 / χ, c2 / ν}. This condition is satisfied up to hypersound frequency for the majority of liquids. The estimates given above show that in the majority of cases, the equation of thermoradiation generation of sound can be represented in the form [259], ∆p −
1 ∂2 p c 2 ∂t 2
=−
α ∂Q . C p ∂t
(3.4)
Here and further p is the sound pressure (we omit the stroke everywhere). This equation will be used further while considering various specific problems of thermoradiation excitation of sound in liquids.
2. RECIPROCITY THEOREM IN ACOUSTICS – SOLUTION TECHNIQUE FOR BOUNDARY PROBLEMS The author developed an effective technique for solution of boundary problems of sound generation by penetrating radiation under conditions of the linear thermal mechanism [130]. The solution of a boundary problem may be reduced directly to quadratures with the help of the reciprocity relationship if the solution of an auxiliary self-adjoint diffraction problem on the field of a point source of sound, when the source is located at the point of a medium, where it is necessary to determine the field of thermal sound sources due to the effect of penetrating radiation, is known.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
43
In the majority of cases, the Fraunhofer field is of the main interest. Then, it is necessary to know the solution of an auxiliary problem of diffraction of a plane sound wave. In the majority of cases, it is quite simple to determine such a solution. Now let us consider the essence of the solution technique in more detail. We should consider some basic reciprocity relationships in acoustics first of all. As is known, Helmholtz was the first who noted the existence of the reciprocity relationship in acoustics [218], and a little later Rayleigh extended this relationship and established a certain general reciprocity principle connecting various types of external action on a linear dynamic system with the effect of these actions [177, 252]. The reciprocity principle was formulated by Rayleigh mathematically for linear systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom [177, 181, 252]. It was demonstrated also that in the case of a medium with motionless boundaries, this principle follows from the Green formula for the Laplace operator. As for a medium containing elastic plates, shells, membranes, etc., Rayleigh indicated only generally the validity of the reciprocity principle in this case also. There was no mathematical formulation of the reciprocity principle describing the connection between volumetric sources in a medium, certain external forces affecting shells, membranes, etc., and radiation fields produced by these forces and bodies. Such a relationship was obtained by the author [131]1. Further, we restrict our consideration within the framework of harmonic oscillations. As is known, this does not limit its generality, but makes mathematical manipulation simpler. We omit the time factor of the form exp (−iωt) everywhere. We take an arbitrary volume Ω filled with any kind of combination of acoustic media and elastic shells (rods, membranes, etc.), which are closed or limited and fixed in motionless screens. We denote a shell surface by Si and a fixation contour by Γi. Let us treat the field p1(r) produced by a certain system of volumetric harmonic sources Q(1)(r), which is distributed continuously over Ω. Then, p(1)(r) is the solution of an equation2,
1
See L. M. Lyamshev, Proceedings of 14th International Congress on Acoustics, Beijing (China), 1992, vol. 4, p. 5, for more details. 2 As is known, equation (3.5) is valid also for an inhomogeneous medium, when the sound velocity in a medium is a function of coordinates and the medium density is constant. However, there are no basic difficulties in consideration of a more general case of an inhomogeneous medium with density and velocity depending on coordinates if we proceed from an equation for such medium given in the form provided by Landau and Lifshits [121].
44
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
∆p (1) (r ) + k 2 p (1) (r ) = −Q (1) (r )
(3.5)
and satisfies boundary conditions, lim p (1) (r ) → 0 , Im k > 0 ,
(3.6)
∂p (1) (r ) (1) = wi (r ) , 2 n | ∂ s1 ω ρ
(3.7)
−
1
(1)
(1)
Li wi (r ) = Fi
(r ) − p (1) (r ) | S i ,
(1) (1) (1) Tij ( wi ) = g ij |Γi′ , Rij ( wi ) = − f ij | Γi′′ , Γi′ + Γi′′ = Γi .
(3.8) (3.9)
Let another system of continuously distributed sources Q(2)(r) be set. The field p(2)(r) produced by these sources obeys an equation, ∆p ( 2) (r ) + k 2 p ( 2) (r ) = −Q ( 2) (r ) ,
(3.5′)
and boundary conditions (3.5) and (3.6), where index (1) is changed for (2) as in expression (3.5). In expressions (3.7) − (3.9), n is the external normal to Si, wi is the normal displacement of the shell surface, Fi are the external mechanical forces affecting the shell in the direction of the normal, gij and fij are the external forces, moments of displacements, etc., affecting the shell along its contour Γ (at the shell border), Li is the self-adjoint differential operator3, which is consistent with the Green formula,
∫ wi
(1)
Si
N
∫ ∑ Rij ( wi
Γi j =1 3
( 2)
( 2)
Li wi
( 2)
− wi
( 2)
Li wi
dS i =
)Tij ( wi(1) ) − Tij ( wi( 2) ) Rij ( wi(1) ) dΓi ,
(3.10)
The conditions, when the operator Liwi is self-adjoint in the case of thin elastic shells, coincide essentially with the conditions of satisfiability for the Betti theorem in the case of shells.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
45
where Rij and Tij are also certain differential operators. We multiply equation (3.5) by p(2)(r) and equation (3.5’) by p(1)(r), add them, and integrate both sides of the obtained equality over the volume Ω using the Green formula, boundary conditions (3.6) – (3.9), and formula (3.10). Finally, we obtain k
∫
N
m
i =1 S i
Ω m
∑∫
∂p (1) (r ) ( 2) Fi (r )dS i + ∂n i
( 2) (1) ∫ Q (r) p (r)dΩ + ∑
∑ gij(2) Rij
i =1 Γ′i j =1
∂p (1) (r ) dΓi + ∑ ∫ ∂ni
N
∑ fij(2)Tij
i =1 Γi′′ j =1
∂p (1) (r ) dΓi = ∂ni (3.11)
∫Q
(1)
∑∫
(r ) p ( 2) (r )dΩ + ∑ ∫
∂p ( 2) (r ) ∂ni
i =1 Si
Ω m
k
N
m
∂p ( 2) (r ) (1) gij dΓi + ∑ ∫ ∂ni
∑ Rij
i =1 Γ′i j =1
N
Fi(1) (r )dSi +
∑ Tij
i =1 Γi′′ j =1
∂p ( 2) (r ) (1) f ij dΓi . ∂ni
Expression (3.11) can be treated as the mathematical formulation of the reciprocity principle in acoustics. Let us analyze some particular cases. Let (1)
Fi
( 2)
= Fi
( 2)
= g ij
(1)
= f ij
= 0 , i = 1, 2, ..., k , j = 1, 2, ..., N .
Then, the next relationship follows from expression (3.11):
∫Q
Ω
(1)
(r ) p ( 2) (r )dΩ = ∫ Q ( 2) (r ) p (1) (r )dΩ .
(3.12)
Ω
This reciprocity relationship is obtained usually under the assumption that the sources and their fields exist in a free space or a space with motionless (free) boundaries. Expression (3.12) can be considered as a certain integral relationship connecting the solutions of two self-adjoint boundary problems of sound diffraction at elastic shells (membranes, rods, etc.) in a liquid.
46
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
Let us assume that (1)
Q ( 2) (r ) = Fi
(1)
( 2)
(r ) = g ij = g ij
( 2)
= f ij
= 0,
i = 1, 2, ..., k , j = 1, 2, ..., k . We have
∫Q
(1)
(r ) p ( 2) (r )dΩ =
Ω
∫ Si
∂p (1) (r ) ( 2) Fi (r )dSi . ∂ni
(3.13)
Relationship (3.13) connects the solutions of boundary problems of diffraction and sound radiation. We should note some opportunities for application of the reciprocity principle in the form of integral relationships obtained above. Let it be necessary to solve a problem on sound scattering by an elastic shell when the incident field is produced by a system of sources distributed in space. Then, if the problem on the field of a point source in the presence of a shell is already solved, the desired solution is reduced directly to quadratures as it follows from expression (3.12). Indeed, if it is necessary to determine the field of scattering at a certain point r1 of the space Ω, then positioning an auxiliary point source Q0(1)δ(r − r1) with the known field p(1)(r) at this point we obtain p ( 2) (r1 ) =
1
∫p
(1) Q0 Ω
(1)
(r1 , r2 )Q ( 2) (r )dΩ(r ) .
(3.14)
We can determine the solution of a problem on transmission of sound field through a shell as has been done above, if this field is produced by a system of distributed sources. Let us assume that it is necessary to determine the field of a shell oscillating under the action of forces distributed over its surface F(2)(r). If we know the solution of the corresponding diffraction problem as earlier, we have from expression (3.13), p ( 2) (r1 ) =
∂p (1) (r1 , r ) ( 2) F (r )dS (r ) . (1) ∫ ∂n Q0 S 1
(3.15)
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
47
Formulae (3.14) and (3.15) will be used further in the process of consideration of problems of thermodynamic generation of sound.
3. EXCITATION OF MONOCHROMATIC SOUND IN A LIQUID HALF-SPACE WITH A FREE SURFACE – THE CASE OF UNDISTURBED SURFACE Let us consider the simplest case of thermoradiation generation of sound. We assume that a beam of penetrating radiation (e.g., a laser beam, a beam of relativistic electrons or γ-quanta or X-rays) propagating from the upper half-space in the positive direction of the axis z of the Cartesian coordinate system x, y, z (Fig. 3.1) is incident upon a free surface of a liquid (the equation of the surface has a general form z = ξ (x, y) and the beam intensity changes according to a harmonic law with the frequency ω). In this case thermal sources of sound arise in a liquid. We can write down an expression for the power density of these sources, Q( x, y , z , t ) = Aµ ( x, y ) exp{−[ z − ξ ( x, y )]}[1 + m cos ωt ] ,
(3.16)
where I(x, y) is the intensity distribution of particles in the beam, which we assume Gaussian, I(x, y) = I0 exp [−(x2 + y2)/a2]; m is the modulation index (0 ≤ m ≤ 1); µ is the absorption coefficient of penetrating radiation in a liquid; A is the coefficient of radiation transmission at the liquid boundary; and a is the radius of radiation spot at the liquid surface.
Figure 3.1 Scheme of sound generation by penetrating radiation in a liquid. (1) Direction of incidence of a beam of modulated penetrating radiation; (2) boundary “air – liquid”; (3) region of absorption of penetrating radiation in a liquid; (4) front of sound waves in a liquid.
48
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
Here and below we use the exponential law of penetrating radiation absorption in a substance in order to be more specific, and assume the intensity distribution in the beam to be Gaussian. The question on the role of the absorption law of penetrating radiation in formation of the acoustic field is considered separately. As we have noted already (Chapter 1, Section 3), the exponential law describes absorption of electromagnetic radiation (light, laser radiation, Xrays, a beam of γ-quanta). Let us consider the process of transmission of a laser beam through an infinitely thin plane-parallel layer of a substance. We denote a radiation flux incident perpendicularly on the layer by I. Being transmitted through the layer of the thickness dz, the flux decreases by dI. If the layer is infinitely thin, i.e., absorption is small, we can assume that the dependence between radiation attenuation and the layer thickness is linear and radiation attenuation is proportional to the incident flux: dI = −Iµ dz, where µ is the constant characterizing the layer absorption, calculated per unit thickness, and called by the name of absorption coefficient. Integration of this equation with respect to z gives the dependence of the transmitted flux of optical radiation on the absorption coefficient of a substance, layer thickness z, and incident flux I = I0, i.e., I = I0exp(−µz). This is the Buger-Lambert law (see [187] for example). The exponential law describes absorption of relativistic electrons until their velocity becomes small enough and electrons stop to be “relativistic”. However, it may turn out in many interesting cases that less than 10% of the total energy of electron beam is released at this last “non-relativistic” stage of absorption of electrons in a substance and absorption may be considered as exponential for the whole path of electron absorption. Now the equation of thermoradiation generation of sound takes on the form, ∆p −
1 ∂2 p c 2 ∂t 2
=
αωm AµI ( x, y ) exp{− µ[ z − ξ ( x, y )]} sin ωt . Cp
(3.17)
Taking the time factor in the form exp(−iωt), we have finally (∆ + k 2 ) p = i
αωm AµI ( x, y ) exp{− µ[ z − ξ ( x, y )]} , Cp
(3.18)
where k = ω/c is the wave number of sound in a liquid. This equation is basic for consideration of thermoradiation generation of harmonic sound oscillations in liquids. The factor exp(−iω t) is omitted as usual.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
49
The solution of equation (3.18) can be written down on the basis of the reciprocity theorem, p(r ) = i
αωm Aµ ∫ I ( x ′, y ′) exp{− µ[ z ′ − ξ ( x ′, y ′)]} × Cp Ω
(3.19) p * ( x ′, y ′, z ′; x, y , z )dx ′dy ′dz ′ , where p*(r′, r) is the solution of a self-adjoint problem on the diffraction of the sound field of a point source positioned at the point r, where it is necessary to determine the acoustic field of thermal sources produced by the action of penetrating radiation upon a medium (liquid). In fact, p*(r′, r) is the source or Green function of the reduced wave equation, which satisfies the boundary conditions for a corresponding self-adjoint boundary problem. Let us consider the sound field of a monochromatic radiation-acoustic source in the far wave field in a liquid half-space with the even boundary (z = 0). Let us analyze the particular features of the sound field in the far wave zone. In the case under consideration, the auxiliary solution has the form, dp * (r ′, r ) =
exp(ikr ) {exp[−i (αx ′ + βy ′ + γz ′)] − 4πr (3.20) exp[−i (αx ′ + βy ′ − γz ′)]} .
Expression (3.20) is the asymptotic representation of the Green function at kr → ∞. Solution (3.19) of equation (3.18) takes on the form,
p(r ) = i
exp(ikr ) αωm AµI 0 Cp 4πr
∞
∞
x′ 2 + y ′ 2 − ′ exp( z ) exp µ − ∫ ∫∫ a2 −∞ 0
× (3.21)
{exp[−i (αx ′ + βy ′ + γz ′)] − exp[−i (αx ′ + βy ′ − γz ′)]}dx ′dy ′dz ′ . 2
2
2
2
The α-component of the wave vector k, i.e., α + β + γ = k , is under the exponent in expressions (3.19) and (3.21). Integrating, we obtain p( r ) =
k 2a 2 exp(ikr ) αωm µk cosθ exp − sin θ . AI 0 a 2 2C p r 4 µ 2 + k 2 cos2 θ
(3.22)
50
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
Here θ is the angle between the direction of incidence of a penetrating radiation beam and the direction from the observation point to the coordinate origin, and r is the distance from the observation point to the coordinate origin. One can see form expression (3.22) that the amplitude of sound pressure increases with the growth of the power of penetrating radiation (~ I0a2), frequency, and modulation index. Directivity of radiation depends on the parameters ka and kµ−1, i.e., on the relation between the dimensions of a radiation-acoustic source and the wavelength of sound. If kµ−1 << 1 and ka << 1, we observe the dipole radiation of sound since satisfaction of these conditions means that a monopole source is operating at the free surface of a liquid. The sound field of this source represents the field of a dipole because of the influence of the free surface (Fig. 3.2a). If kµ −1 >> 1 and ka << 1, sound is emitted mainly along the surface. A set of volume thermal sources forms a vertical array, which is thin in the transverse direction and long in comparison with the sound wavelength in the direction of the beam of penetrating radiation, i.e., a so-called “rod-like” array (Fig. 3.2b). If kµ −1 << 1 and ka >> 1, the array has the shape of a disk with diameter much larger than the sound wavelength. Acoustic radiation is emitted mainly in the propagation direction of penetrating radiation (Fig. 3.2c).
Figure 3.2 Directivity patterns of thermoradiation sound sources. (a) Source dimensions are small, (b) and (c), directivity of radiation of sources of “rod-like” and “disk” types.
Analysis of expression (3.22) shows also that the optimal mode of acoustic radiation in the case of thermoradiation excitation of sound is observed when k ≈ µ. This requires a certain type of penetrating radiation, i.e., a certain type of quanta-particles, their energy, and laser light wavelength. A problem of optimal conditions of thermoradiation (laser) generation of sound in the case of the linear thermal mechanism was considered in detail from the point of view of acquisition of the maximum amplitude of sound pressure [29]. Now let us analyze the sound field of a radiation-acoustic source in the near wave zone (the Fresnel zone), when the observation point r = {ρ, L}
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
51
(where ρ = (x′2 + y′2)1/2 and L is the coordinate of the observation point along the axis z) is located under the irradiation spot (ρ ≤ a) at depth L ≤ ka2. We write down the auxiliary solution in a general form (and not in an asymptotic form as has been done above while considering the field in the Fraunhofer zone), p(r ′, r ) =
1 exp(ik | r ′ − r |) exp(ik | r ′ * − r |) − , 4π | r′ − r | | r ′ * −r |
(3.23)
where r′ = {x′, y′, z′} and r′* = {x′, y′, −z′}. The solution of equation (3.18) takes on the form
p(r ) =
1 4π
∞
∞
x′2 + y′2 αωm − exp(− µz ) × µ A I exp 0 ∫ 2 Cp a −∞ 0
∫ ∫i
(3.24) exp(ik | r ′ − r |) exp(ik | r ′ * − r |) − dxdydz . | r′ − r | | r′ * −r | As L >> µ −1 and L >> a in all cases, we assume that in the near wave field L >> ka2/(µL) or L >> ka2/(a/L) that is the condition of the Fresnel diffraction. Taking into account these conditions and the fact that radiation intensity rapidly decreases already at ρ = a, we may change |r′ − r| and |r′* − r| in the denominator of the integrand in expression (3.13) for L and change them in the exponential factor for L = z′ + (ρ − ρ′)2 / 2L. After this substitution and integration, the solution takes on the form [43],
p=i
ρ2 mAαc µk exp[(ik − Γ) L] . I 0 exp − a2 Cp µ2 + k2
(3.25)
Naturally, a sound beam in the near wave zone is not subjected to divergence and its width (with respect to pressure amplitude) coincides with the width of the penetrating radiation beam. Thus, we arrive at an important conclusion that while in the far wave field, where sound waves are spherical, the amplitude of sound pressure p is determined by the total power P of penetrating radiation, in the near wave field the amplitude of sound is determined by the beam intensity according to expression (3.25).
52
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
4. A LIQUID HALF-SPACE WITH LARGE-SCALE ROUGHNESS OF BOUNDARY Above we have considered the particular features of a sound field of a radiation-acoustic source in a liquid bounded by an even surface. In real conditions a liquid surface is uneven because of many reasons. Therefore, it is useful to estimate the effect of boundary roughness upon the sound field generated by a radiation-acoustic source. At first we consider the influence of unevennesses which are large in comparison with the sound wavelength in a liquid [108, 133]. We take random unevennesses in order to consider a general case. Let a penetrating radiation beam intensity-modulated with the sound frequency ω be incident along the axis z upon the uneven surface of the liquid half-space determined by the equation z = ξ(x, y). Thermal sound sources and a sound field arise in a liquid due to absorption of penetrating radiation in it. As we have mentioned above, they are described by the inhomogeneous reduced wave equation (∆ + k 2 ) p = i
αA mωµI ( x, y ) exp[− µ ( z − ξ ( x, y ))] . Cp
We write down the solution of this equation on the basis of the reciprocity principle (see equation (3.19)),
p ( x, y , z ) =
1 4π
iαA p x y z x y z mωµI ( x1 , y1 ) × ( , , ; , , ) 0 1 1 1 ∫ C p Ω (3.26)
exp{− µ [ z1 − ξ ( x1, y1 )]} dx1dy1dz1 , where p0(x, y, z; x1, y1, z1) is the solution of the regular problem of sound scattering at the boundary when the source of the regular field is located at the point (x, y, z), i.e., at the point, where it is necessary to determine the desired field; and Q is the volume occupied by thermal sound sources produced by the effect of penetrating radiation. Assuming that the point (x, y, z) is located in the far wave field, we can represent the incident regular wave by an expression, pi =
e ikR exp[i (αx1 + βy1 + γz1 )] , R
(3.27)
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
53
where R = (x2 + y2 + z2)1/2. Here α, β, and γ are the components of the wave vector directed from the point (x, y, z) to the coordinate origin. In the considered case of the boundary with large-scale unevenness, the solution of the diffraction problem can be written down in the Kirchhoff approximation, i.e., under the assumption that reflection at each point of the surface occurs in the same way as from the infinite plane tangential to the boundary surface at this point [18, 125]. In this case the total field at the boundary consists of the incident pi and reflected pr = Wpi waves, where W is the reflection coefficient. We may take W = −1 at the liquid−air boundary. The scattered field in a liquid half-space in the general case can be represented by the Kirchhoff integral. However, in the case under consideration, when the distance from the point (x1, y1, z1) to the boundary is not larger than the sound wavelength (just this length of the region of the thermal sound sources along the axis z provides the optimal mode of sound generation as has been mentioned before), the scattered field in the layer of the depth k−1 can be represented at the boundary in an approximate form, pr = −
e ikR exp{i (α ′x1 + β ′y1 + γ ′z1 ) − i[γz1 + γξ ( x1 , y1 )]} , R
(3.28)
α ′ = k sin θ ′ cos ϕ ′ , β ′ = k sin θ ′ sin ϕ ′ , γ ′ = k cos θ ′ , and the angles θ′ and ϕ′ are expressed with the help of the coordinate angles of the wave vector of the incident wave θ and ϕ in the following way:
ϕ ′ = arctan
(tan θ sin ϕ + 2∂ξ / ∂y )(1 − tan θ cos ϕ ⋅ 2∂ξ / ∂x) , (1 − tan θ sin ϕ ⋅ 2∂ξ / ∂y )(tan θ cos ϕ + 2∂ξ / ∂x)
θ ′ = arctan
tan θ cos ϕ + 2∂ξ / ∂x 1 + tan 2 ϕ ′ . 1 − tan θ cos ϕ ⋅ 2∂ξ / ∂x
The validity of expression (3.28) is limited by the conditions of applicability of the Kirchhoff approximation and, in particular, by the condition of the absence of multiple reflection of the incident wave at the boundary. As can be demonstrated readily, this corresponds to imposing a certain restriction upon the slip angle of the incident wave, i.e., the following condition must be satisfied: (π/2 − θ) > 3δ , where δ is the meansquare angle of inclination of boundary unevennesses.
54
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
As we consider only mildly sloping unevennesses, that is equivalent to the satisfaction of the condition ∂ξ/∂x << 1 and ∂ξ/∂n << 1, then we can ignore the influence of the tangential plane at the point of reflection of the sound beam from the boundary in the layer of depth 1/k with precision up to the order of magnitude of δ 2 << 1 that can be demonstrated easily in the process of averaging. Thus, we can assume that reflection from the boundary occurs in the same way as from the plane parallel to the coordinate plane (x, y) and passing through the given point of the boundary surface. Therefore, the solution of the regular problem of scattering of a sound wave generated by a distant source can be represented approximately in the region of thermal sources by an expression, p0 = −2i
e ikR exp[i (αx1 + βy1 ) − γξ ( x1 , y1 )] sin γ [ z1 − ξ ( x1 , y1 )] . R
(3.29)
This expression and expression (3.26) are the starting points for further considerations. The coefficient of transmission of penetrating radiation A in formula (3.26) depends, generally speaking, on the angle of liquid surface inclination. However, estimates show that the angular dependence of A in the considered case of mildly sloping unevennesses is very weak and we can take the value of A to be equal to one. Substitution of solution (3.29) to formula (3.26) gives the next expression for sound pressure:
p=
∞ e ikR αµmω I0 2πC p R ∫
∞
exp ∫ ∫ − −∞ 0
ρ12 exp(−iγξ1 ) exp[− µ ( z1 − ξ1 )] × a 2 (3.30) sin[γ ( z1 − ξ1 )] exp[i (αx1 + βy1 )]dx1dy1dz1 ,
where a is the effective radius of the radiation beam with intensity distributed according to the law I ( x, y ) = I 0 exp(− ρ12 / a 2 ) , ξ1 = ξ ( x1 , y1 ) , ρ1 =
x12 + y12 .
It is interesting to determine the average sound pressure. After the change of the variable z = z1 − ξ1, the average field in the far wave zone can
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
55
be determined by averaging of expression (3.30) with respect to all possible realizations of the inhomogeneous surface: ∞ I αµmω e ikR 〈 p〉 = 0 2πC p R ∫
∞
exp ∫ ∫ − −∞ 0
ρ12 − iγξ1 〉× exp(− µz ) sin γz 〈 e a 2
exp[i (αx1 + βy1 )]dx1dy1dz1 .
(3.31)
−iγξ
Here 〈e 1〉 = f (−γ) is the characteristic function of the random quantity ξ which is the displacement of the boundary surface. After integration we obtain an expression for 〈p〉, a 2 k 2 sin 2 θ I αµmω e −ikR a 2 k cos θ 〈 p〉 = 0 exp − f (−γ ) 2C p R µ 2 + k 2 cos 2 θ 4
(3.32)
(here θ is the angle between the axis z and the direction to the observation point (x, y, z)). Using formula (3.32) we can calculate the pressure field if we know the function f(−γ) in the explicit form. Let us assume that surface displacements obey the normal distribution law. We substitute the function f(−γ) in the explicit form into formula (3.32). We obtain the next expression for the density of probability distribution: w(ξ ) =
ξ2 exp − , 2πσ 2σ 2 1
where σ is the mean-square height of unevennesses. Now the characteristic function is expressed by the formula γ 2σ 2 k 2σ 2 cos 2 θ = exp − f (−γ ) = exp − = e − p / 8 , (3.33) 2 2 where p = 2kσ cosθ is the Rayleigh parameter. One can see from expression (3.33) that if the Rayleigh parameter tends to zero, the characteristic function becomes equal to one and formula (3.32) transforms into the expression describing the pressure field in the case of thermoradiation excitation of sound in a liquid half-space with even (plane) boundary. Formulae (3.32) and (3.33) show that the average radiation field is
56
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
characterized by certain directivity. In the case of the observation angles θ < arctan(21/2σ/a) the directivity characteristic is affected mainly by the Rayleigh parameter and in the case of the angles θ > arctan(21/2σ / a), the directivity is determined by the ratio of the radius of the penetrating radiation beam to the sound wavelength, i.e., the influence of the Rayleigh parameter on the average sound field decreases as the angle θ grows. The average field in the direction of the axis z decreases rapidly with increase of the Rayleigh parameter. Polar diagrams obtained according to formulae (3.32) and (3.33) and under the condition (ka)2 = 10 are given in Fig. 3.3 (ka is the wave dimension of the radiation spot).
Figure 3.3 Polar diagrams of average pressure distribution for (ka)2 = 10. Curves 1 – 4 correspond to the next values of the parameter σ/a: o.01, 0.1, 0.5, and 1. Dashed lines indicate the angles determined by the conditions θ = arctan(21/2σ / a).
It is necessary to note that, as in the theory of sound scattering by rough surfaces, the average field in this case (under the conditions of the selected approximate solution of the problem) depends only on the distribution of unevenness heights and does not depend on the shape of the uneven surface. Another important characteristic of random sound field is the average intensity. We can write an expression for it in the next form on the basis of expression (3.30): 2 ρ2 + ρ2 I 0αµmω ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ 2 2 × exp − 1 〈 p〉 = 2 2πC p R a −∞ 0 −∞ 0
∫ ∫∫ ∫ ∫∫
e − µz sin γz1e − µz 2 sin γz2 〈 exp[−iγ (ξ1 − ξ 2 )]〉 ×
(3.34)
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
57
exp[i (α ( x1 − x2 ) + β ( y1 − y2 ))]dx1dy1dz1dx2 dy2 dz2 . Here 〈exp[−iγ(ξ1 − ξ2)]〉 = f (−γ, γ) is the two-dimensional characteristic function. If we consider statistically homogeneous unevenness, when the two-dimensional characteristic function depends on the difference of the coordinates ξ = x1 − x2 and η = y1 − y2 , and assume that unevennesses are isotropic, i.e., the function f (−γ, γ) depends only on the distance between the points ρ = (ξ 2 + η2)1/2, then we obtain an expression for the average field intensity, ∞ 2π I 0αµmω γ 2a 2 f (−γ , γ ; ρ ) × 〈| p | 〉 = 2C p R ( µ 2 + γ 2 ) ∫ ∫ ∫ ∫ 0 0 2
2
exp −
ρ 22 a
2
−
ρ2 a
2
−
(cos ϕ cosψ + sin ϕ sinψ ) × 2 a
2 ρρ 2
(3.35)
exp[iρ (α cos ϕ + β sin ϕ )]ρρ 2 dρ dρ 2 dψ dϕ , where x1 − x2 = ρ cos ϕ, y1 − y2 = ρ sin ϕ, x2 = ρ2 cos ψ, and y2 = ρ2 sin ψ. After integration expression (3.35) is reduced to the form 2 ∞ I 0αµmω γ 2a 2 f (−γ , γ ; ρ ) × 〈| p | 〉 = 2C p R ( µ 2 + γ 2 ) 2 ∫ 0 2
(3.36)
ρ2
I ρ α 2 + β 2 ρ dρ , exp − 2a 2 0 where I0(x) is the Bessel function of the zero order. As in the previous case, we assume that the two-dimensional distribution law is valid for boundary displacement, ξ 2 − 2ξ ξ N ( ρ ) + ξ 2 1 2 2 , exp− 1 w(ξ1 , ξ 2 ; ρ ) = 2 2 2πσ (1 − N ( ρ )) 2πσ 2 1 − N 2 ( ρ ) 1
(3.37)
58
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
where N(ρ) is the coefficient of boundary unevenness. In this case the twodimensional characteristic function takes on the form f (−γ , γ ; ρ ) = exp[−γ 2σ 2(1 − N ( ρ ))] .
(3.38)
In the case of large unevennesses meeting the condition γσ >> 1, the integrand in expression (3.36) is essential only for the values of ρ close to zero. Then the correlation coefficient can be expanded into a series and we can take only two terms of the expansion: | N ′′(0) | ρ N (ρ ) ≈ 1 − ρ 2 0
2
,
where ρ0 is the correlation length of the boundary unevenness. Let us determine the mean-square angle of unevenness inclination by a relationship, ∂ξ tan 2 σ = ∂ρ
2
=
σ2 ρ 02
| N ′′(0) | ,
(3.39)
and obtain an expression for the characteristic function, γ 2 tan 2 δ 2 f (−γ , γ ; ρ ) ≈ exp − ρ . 2
(3.40)
Substituting expression (3.40) to formula (3.36) and assuming that tan2σ = 2(σ/ρ0)2 for the normal distribution law, we represent finally the average intensity of the sound field of thermoradiation sources in the case of largescale homogeneous isotropic unevenness of the boundary in a liquid in the form, 2 I 0αmc 1 µ 2 a 4 cos 2 θ 2 〈| p | 〉 = × 2C p R [( µ / k ) 2 + cos 2 θ ] 2 1 + ∆2 cos 2 θ
(3.41) ρ 2 ∆2 sin 2 θ , exp − 0 σ 4( ∆2 cos2 θ + 1)
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
59
where ∆ = 21/2kaσ / ρ0 is the dimensionless parameter. We have to note that the average field intensity can be also obtained readily for the case of anisotropic unevenness. It is necessary to note that the quantity tan2δ in the index of the characteristic function determines the bond between displacements of two points of the uneven boundary. As one can see from expression (3.41), in the process of calculation of the average intensity, tan2δ is essential in the exponential index, though we may ignore fluctuations of surface inclination while determining the scattered field (see expression (3.29)). Now let us analyze expression (3.41) and consider two limiting values of the parameter ∆ (∆ << 1 and ∆ >> 1). Let ∆ << 1. In this case the adopted condition kσ >> 1 corresponds to the smallness of the light spot as against the correlation length of the surface unevenness, i.e., the relationship a/ρ0 << 1. If ∆ tends to zero, the average intensity tends in the limit to the intensity of the sound field arising in the case of penetrating radiation absorption in a liquid with the plane surface, 2 k 2 a 2 sin 2 θ I 0αmc µ 2 a 4 cos 2 θ 2 lim 〈| p | 〉 = exp − . 2C p R [( µ / k ) 2 + cos 2 θ ] 2 2 ∆ →0
It follows from here that in the case ∆ << 1, we may ignore the effect of boundary unevenness on the sound intensity and calculate the intensity in the approximation of plane boundary. Now let ∆ >> 1 that at kσ >> 1 corresponds to the radius of the light spot comparable to or larger than the correlation length of the boundary unevenness, i.e., the condition a/ρ0 ≥ 1. The average intensity is described by an expression, 2 I 0αmc a2 µρ 0 2 〈| p |〉 ≈ 2C p R [( µ / k ) 2 + cos 2 θ ] 2 kσ
2
× (3.42)
1 ρ 2 exp − 0 tan 2 θ . 4 σ As one can see from formula (3.42), in this case the angular characteristic is determined by the scale of surface unevenness. The intensity decreases e times for the observation angle corresponding to the relationship tanθ = 2σ/ρ0, i.e., the angular beam of the directivity pattern is approximately
60
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
equal to the mean-square angle of inclination of the uneven surface θk = 21/2σ. Directivity patterns for the average intensity are given in Fig. 3.4 for µ = k, σ/ρ0 = 0.17, and ∆2 = 0.1, 1, and 10. The limited angular width of the directivity pattern θ 0 = arctan(21/2σ/ρ0) = 14° for the selected ratio σ/ρ0 is indicated at the plot at ∆2 = 10.
Figure 3.4 Polar diagrams of average intensity distribution. Curves 1 – 3 correspond to the next values of the parameter ∆2: 0.1, 1, and 10.
It is easy to determine the dispersion of acoustic field fluctuations using formulae (3.32) and (3.41): 2 I 0αmc 1 µ 2 a 4 cos 2 θ 2 2 × D = 〈| p | 〉− | 〈 p〉 | = 2C p R [( µ / k ) 2 + cos 2 θ ] ∆2 cos 2 θ + 1
ρ 2 a 2 k 2 sin 2 θ ∆2 sin 2 θ exp − − k 2σ 2 cos2 θ . exp − 0 2 σ 4( ∆2 cos2 θ + 1) (3.43) In the case of the dimension of the radiation spot small being compared with the correlation length of boundary unevenness, the dispersion is proportional to the factor [1 − exp(−p/4)], i.e., the dispersion is maximal in the direction of the axis z and increases with the growth of the Rayleigh parameter. If the dimension of the radiation spot is large in comparison with the correlation length, the angular dependence of the dispersion is close to
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
61
the angular dependence of the square of the average pressure. In this case the dispersion is minimal in the direction of the axis z and tends to zero in this direction with the growth of the Rayleigh parameter. According to this consideration, we note the next characteristic features of the sound field arising due to absorption of modulated penetrating radiation in a liquid half-space with large-scale unevenness of the boundary. The average pressure represents the product of the sound pressure in the half-space with even boundary and the characteristic distribution of the height of boundary unevennesses. The average pressure depends essentially on the Rayleigh parameter as in the problems of sound scattering. The influence of boundary unevenness on the average intensity of sound field is given by the exponential dependence on the parameter ∆, i.e., in the case of large unevennesses (kσ >> 1), the intensity depends exponentially on the ratio of the radius of the radiation spot at the boundary to the correlation length of boundary unevenness. If the radius of the radiation spot is small as against the correlation length of unevennesses, we may ignore the effect of boundary unevenness on the average intensity of the field. In this case, the larger the Rayleigh parameter, the larger the peak of the directivity pattern along the axis z of the dispersion. If the radius of the radiation spot is larger than the correlation length of unevenness, the angular width of the directivity pattern is approximately equal to the average mean-square angle of inclination of the uneven surface. In this case the dispersion has a directivity pattern with the minimum along the axis z.
5. THE CASE OF SMALL UNEVENNESS Now let us consider the effect of an uneven liquid boundary on thermoradiation generation of sound when unevennesses are assumed to be mildly sloping, statistically homogeneous, and isotropic and their height is small in comparison with the sound wavelength. We consider the developed generation mode as above. We will obtain the expressions providing an opportunity to calculate the average field and the intensity of sound field fluctuations in the far wave zone. Simple relationships connecting the average sound field with the Rayleigh parameter, mean-square height, and spatial correlation length of unevennesses will be given for some limiting cases. As one will be able to see, the boundary unevenness affects sound field fluctuations in two ways: first, the field of volumetric thermal sources is scattered at random boundary unevennesses, and second, the intensity of these sources fluctuates as the track length of particles (quanta) of penetrating radiation in a liquid changes randomly.
62
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
Let a penetrating radiation beam propagating in the positive direction of the axis z be incident upon the free uneven boundary of a liquid half-space z ≥ ξ (x, y). The boundary unevenness is random and ξ ( x, y ) = 0. Here and further, the line above means averaging with respect to the statistical ensemble. Using the reciprocity principle, we write down the solution of the equation of thermoradiation sound generation in the form p(r0 ) =
iωmαAµ Cp
∫ I ( x, y) exp{−µ[ z − ξ ( x, y)]}G(r, r0 )dV ,
(3.44)
V
where G(r, r0) is the function, which is the solution of the inhomogeneous reduced wave equation (the equation of thermoradiation sound generation in a liquid) with the right-hand side in the form of the δ-function, satisfying the condition G (r, r0 ) | z =ξ ( x, y ) = 0 ,
(3.45)
at the uneven surface, where r(x, y, z) is the radius-vector of the current point and r0(x0, y0, z0) is the radius-vector of the observation point. Integration in expression (3.44) is performed over the part of the half-space z ≥ ξ (x, y), where thermal sources exist. The function G(r, r0) is the solution of the problem, i.e., the field of a point source located at the point r0 of the half-space with the uneven boundary, where it is necessary to determine the radiation field. It is known that the exact analytical representation for G(r, r0) has not been obtained yet. Therefore, making certain assumptions on the problem parameters, we use an approximate expression for G(r, r0). We need to determine the sound field in the far wave zone4. In this case the function G(r, r0) can be represented as the solution of the problem on the diffraction of a plane monochromatic wave at an uneven boundary, and the spherical divergence of the field can be taken into account with the help of the common factor exp(ikr0) / (4π r0). We assume that the height of boundary unevennesses is small as against the sound wavelength. We restrict ourselves also for simplicity to 4
As in the previous section, we mean here the far wave zone with respect to both the dimensions of the region of effective heat release (and therefore, effective sound generation) and the uneven boundary. The conditions determining the far wave zone with respect to the uneven boundary have been considered in detail by Lysanov [125] for example.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
63
consideration of mildly sloping, statistically homogeneous, and isotropic unevennesses of the boundary. The problem of scattering of a plane sound wave at the boundary with small mildly sloping unevennesses has been considered in details by many researchers (see [18, 125] for example). We will basically follow these considerations to determine the solution. Let us expand boundary condition (3.45) into a series with respect to the power of the small parameter kσ, where σ is the mean-square height of unevennesses, and keep in the expansion only the terms of order of smallness not higher than the second. Then the exact boundary condition is changed for the approximate one at z = 0. We represent the field described by the function G(r, r0) in the form of the sum of the average field Gav(r, r0) and the random addition Gran(r, r0), G (r, r0 ) = Gav (r , r0 ) + G ran (r , r0 ) ,
where G ran (r , r0 ) = 0. Let us write down an approximate expression for Gav(r, r0) keeping the terms of the order of smallness not higher than the second order with respect to kσ: Gav (r, r0 ) =
exp(ikr0 ) exp[i (k x x + k y y )] × 4πr0 (3.46)
[exp( −ik z z ) + w exp(ik z z )] , where (kx, ky, kz) are the components of the wave vector k coinciding in its direction with the radius-vector r0 and w is the average coefficient of reflection of a plane sound wave from the uneven boundary, which is represented (as it is possible to demonstrate) with the help of the normalized function of correlation of statistically homogeneous and isotropic unevennesses N(ρ), where ρ is the horizontal distance between two points at the boundary: w = −1 + η cosθ ; 2 ∞ 2 2 ∂ exp(ik ρ + z ) η = 2ikσ 2 ∫ N ( ρ ) J 0 (kρ sin θ ) ρ dρ . ∂z 2 2 2 ρ +x 0 z = 0
(3.47)
Here J0(kρ sinθ) is the Bessel function of the zero order and θ is the angle between the axis z and the radius-vector r0. Thus, we have
64
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
Gav (r , r0 ) = G0 (r , r0 ) + O(k 2σ 2 ) , where
G0 (r, r0 ) =
exp(ikr0 ) exp[i (k x x + k y y )][exp(−ik z z ) − exp(ik z z )] . 4πr0
(3.48)
Within the framework of the above assumptions, the term Gran(r, r0) has the form Gran (r , r0 ) =
exp(ikr0 ) Ψ ( x, y , z ) , 4πr0
(3.49)
where Ψ(x, y, z) is the random component of the field of scattering of a plane monochromatic sound wave incident at the angle θ on the statistically uneven boundary of the half-space. As is known (see [125]), the function Ψ(x, y, z) can be represented in the form of the double Fourier integral, Ψ ( x, y , z ) = ∫
∞
∫ A(α , β ) exp[i(αx + βy + γz )]dαdβ ,
(3.50)
−∞
where γ = (k2 − α2 −β 2)1/2, and an expression for the random amplitude A(α, β) has the form A(α , β ) =
i 2π 2
k cos θ ∫
∞
∫ ξ ( x, y ) ×
−∞
(3.51) exp{−i[(α − k x ) x + ( β − k y ) y ]}dxdy . Let us make one more assumption. Let µσ << 1. We represent exp[µξ(x, y)] in the form of a series keeping the terms of the order of smallness with respect to µσ not higher than the second order:
exp[µξ ( x, y )] = 1 + µξ ( x, y ) +
µ2 2 ξ ( x, y ) . 2
(3.52)
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
65
Such an assumption is quite natural since, as we have mentioned above, the most efficient conversion of optical energy into sound energy occurs at k ~ µ, and therefore this case is most interesting from the practical point of view. Keeping the terms of the order of smallness with respect to kσ and µσ not higher than the second order, we obtain on the basis of relationships (3.44) – (3.52) the approximate expression describing the solution p(r0): p(r0 ) =
iωmαAµ Cp
∫ I ( x, y) exp(−µz ){Gav (r , r0 ) + µξ ( x, y)G0 (r, r0 ) + V
(3.53)
µ2 2
ξ 2 ( x, y )G0 ( r, r0 ) + Gran ( r, r0 ) + µξ ( x, y )Gran ( r, r0 )}dV .
Let us proceed in expression (3.53) from integration with respect to the volume V(z ≥ ξ(x, y)) to integration with respect to the volume V0(z ≥ 0) and estimate the error arising in this case. One can see that the error is
∆=
iωmαAµ Cp
ξ ( x, y )
∫ ∫ F ( x, y, z)dzdS ,
(3.54)
0 S0
where F(x, y, z) denotes the integrand in expression (3.53), and S0 is the area in the plane x, y, which limits the volume occupied by thermal sources. Taking into account the restrictions imposed above, we represent F(x, y, z) in expression (3.54) in the approximate form F ( x, y, z ) = F ( x, y,0) + z
∂F ( x, y, z ) . ∂z z =0
Integration with respect to z in expression (3.54) can be performed easily now. We have the result ∆=
iωmαAµ Cp
1 ∂F ( x, y, z ) ξ 2 ( x, y )dS . ∂z z =0
∫ F ( x, y,0)ξ ( x, y) + 2
S0
Substituting here F(x, y, z) from expression (3.53), using expressions (3.46) – (3.50), and keeping the terms of the order of smallness with respect
66
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
to kσ and µσ not higher than the second order, we obtain finally that, substituting integration with respect to the volume V0 for integration with respect to the volume V in expression (3.53), it is necessary to add the following term: ∆=
exp(ikr0 ) ωmαA kµ cos θ Cp 4πr0
∫ξ
2
( x, y ) I ( x, y ) ×
S0
(3.55) exp[i ( k x x + k y y )]dS .
Expressions (3.53) and (3.54) determine with precision up to the terms of the second order of smallness with respect to kσ and µσ, the sound field generated by a thermoradiation source in a liquid occupying a half-space with an uneven boundary under the condition that the height of unevennesses is small compared with the sound wavelength. Let us represent this field in the form of the sum of the average field pav(r0) and the random addition pran(r0): p (r0 ) = p av (r0 ) + p ran (r0 ) ,
so that p ran (r0 ) = 0 . Now let us consider for definiteness the specified form of the intensity distribution I(x,y) in the penetrating radiation beam. It is presumed commonly that the real distribution is close to the Gaussian one. Therefore, we take I ( x, y ) = I 0 exp[−( x 2 + y 2 ) / a 2 ] .
(3.56)
Substituting expression (3.56) into expressions (3.53) and (3.55) and averaging with respect to the total realizations of the function ξ(x, y), we obtain for the average field
pav (r0 ) =
k 2a 2 ωmαAa 2 I 0 exp(ikr0 ) exp − sin θ × 2r0 4 Cp (3.57) kµ cos θ 2
µ + k 2 cos 2 θ
f (θ ) ,
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
f (θ ) = 1 −
67
η µ η (kσ cos θ ) 2 cos θ + i − − µ ( µ 2 + k 2 cos 2 θ ) × k 2 2 2 ∞
∫ ℑ(κ )κ 0
2π
dκ dΨ
∫
2
2 2 0 µi k − (κ cos Ψ + k sin θ ) − κ Ψ
(3.58)
,
where the function ℑ(κ) is the spatial spectrum of statistically homogeneous and isotropic unevennesses of the boundary. The spatial spectrum is connected with the function of correlation of unevennesses by a wellknown relationship ∞
σN ( ρ ) = 2π ∫ ℑ(κ ) J 0 (κρ )κ dκ . 0
Here J0(κ, ρ) is the Bessel function of the zero order. The function f(θ ) characterizes the effect of boundary unevenness on the sound field in a liquid half-space. In the absence of unevenness, f(θ ) ≡ 1 and expression (3.57) describes the field generated by an optical source in a half-space with an even boundary. This coincides with a corresponding expression (see expression (3.22)). Expressions (3.47), (3.57), and (3.58), provide an opportunity to calculate the parameters of the average component of the sound field in the half-space according to known characteristics of boundary unevennesses. We have to note some particular cases when it is possible to make expression (3.58) simpler to some extent. Let kρ0 >> 1, where ρ0 is the correlation coefficient of unevennesses. Let us consider the double integral in expression (3.58). At the essential interval of integration, κ << k. Therefore, let us take approximately κ = 0 in the denominator of the integrand. As ∞
∫ ℑ(κ )κ dκ = σ
2
/ 2π ,
0
we obtain f (θ ) = 1 −
η µ η (kσ cos θ ) 2 cos θ + i − − ( µσ ) 2 − iµkσ 2 cos θ . 2 k 2 2
68
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
2
In the case of non-slip observation angles (kρ0 cos θ >> 1) 3 η = 2(kσ ) 2 cos θ , f (θ ) = 1 − P 2 − ( µσ ) 2 , 8 where P = 2kσ cosθ is the Rayleigh parameter. Thus in this case, the decrease of the average field in comparison with the field in a half-space with an even boundary is determined not only by the Rayleigh parameter as in the case of large-scale unevenness, but also by the quantity µσ. It is necessary to note that the latter does not depend on the observation angle. In the case of slip observation angles such that kρ0 cos2θ << 1, ∞
( 2 kσ ) 2
1 dN ( x*) π exp i ∫ dx * , η=− 2πkρ 0 x * dx * 4 0
where N(x*) is the normalized correlation function of boundary unevenness and x* is the distance normalized to the correlation length. In particular, we have at N(x*) = exp(−x*2) f (θ ) = 1 − 1.2kσ 2
µ + k cos θ (kσ cos θ ) 2 − − ( µσ ) 2 + 2 πkρ 0
k cosθ − µkσ 2 cos θ . i 1.2kσ 2 πkρ 0 In the case of small-scale boundary unevenness (kρ0 << 1)
η = −2i
kσ 2
ρ0
∞
1 dN ( x*) dx * , dx *
∫ x* 0
and if N(x*) = exp(−x*2) as above, then we obtain from expression (5.58), f (θ ) = 1 − π
kσ 2 µσ 2 (kσ cos θ ) 2 − − i π cos θ − µ ( µ 2 + k 2 cos 2 θ ) × ρ0 2 ρ0
σ 2 ρ 02 ∞ ρ 02κ 2 2π dκ dΨ . κ ∫ exp − ∫ 4π 4 2 2 2 2 i k k µ − − κ Ψ + θ − κ Ψ ( cos sin ) sin 0 0
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
69
The integral here cannot be reduced and one has to calculate it numerically. It is interesting that in the considered approximation, the modulus of the function f(θ) is smaller than one, though the modulus of the average coefficient of reflection of a plane sound wave from the boundary with small-scale unevennesses (kρ0 << 1) is equal to one. Thus, we can see that the average component of the sound field depends on the characteristics of boundary unevenness and, in particular, on the Rayleigh parameter and the spatial correlation of unevenness. In the case of large-scale unevenness and observation angles close to the normal angle, the average component of the field is described by a simple analytical expression. In other cases detailed calculation is needed to determine the parameters of the average sound field. Let us consider the random component of the field pran(r0). We obtain from expression (3.53) for pran(r0): iωmαAµ pav (r0 ) = I ( x, y ) exp(− µz )Gran (r , r0 )dV + Cp ∫ V0 (3.59) µ ∫ ξ ( x, y ) I ( x, y ) exp( − µz )G0 ( r, r0 )dV . V0 One can see from this expression that within the framework of the perturbation method, the random component of the field is represented by the sum of two integrals. Each of these integrals describes separately different mechanisms of unevenness influence on sound generation due to absorption of laser radiation. The first integral in expression (3.59) is the random component of the field of stationary thermal volumetric source of sound in a half-space with a rough boundary, and the second integral is the random component of the field of thermal volumetric sound sources with the intensity changing randomly in a half-space with an even boundary. Fluctuations of intensity of thermal volumetric sources are caused here by the fact that the path length changes randomly in the case of propagation of a particle beam in a liquid to a certain point of the half-space. Multiplying expression (3.59) by the complex conjugate and using relationships (3.48) and (3.49), we can obtain readily a formula for calculation of the dispersion of fluctuations of the sound field: ωmαAµ × | p ran (r0 ) | 2 = 4πC p r0
70
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
∗ ∫ ∫ I ( x, y ) I ( x1, y1 ) exp( − µz − µz1 ) Ψ( x, y, z ) Ψ ( x, y , z )dVdV1 − V 0 ∫ ∫ I ( x, y ) I ( x1, y1 ) exp(ik x x + ik y y − µz1 ) × µ 2 + k 2 cos2 θ V S 0 0 2iµk cos θ
ξ ( x, y ) Ψ ∗ ( x1, y1, z1 ) dSdV1 − (3.60)
∫ ∫ I ( x, y ) I ( x1, y1 ) exp( −ik x x1 − ik y y1 − µz ) × V0 S 0
]
ξ ( x1, y1 ) Ψ( x, yz ) dVdS1 + 2 µk cos θ µ 2 + k 2 cos2 θ
2
∫ ∫ I ( x, y ) I ( x1, y1 ) exp[ik x ( x − x1 ) + ik y ( y − y1 )] × S0
ξ ( x, y )ξ ( x1, y1 ) dSdS1 . Sound field fluctuations are given above in the form of the sum of two random quantities. Therefore, the fluctuation dispersion must be represented by the sum of the dispersions of each of these fluctuations plus cross terms. The first integral in expression (3.60) describes the dispersion of fluctuations of the field of stationary volumetric thermal sources in a half-space uneven boundary. The co-factor Ψ( x, y, z)Ψ * ( x1, y1, z1) in the integrand is nothing other than the correlation function of the random component of the scattered field in the case of incidence of a plane sound wave on a rough boundary. This function has been thoroughly studied. The last integral in expression (3.60) is the dispersion of fluctuations of the field caused by fluctuation of intensity of thermal volumetric sources. By the way, we have to note that just the same integral (see [132]) describes the
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
71
dispersion of the random component of the sound field arising due to absorption of laser radiation in a half-space. This component is produced due to random fluctuations of the transverse distribution of light intensity in the laser beam if we assume that the relative fluctuation of this distribution is equal to µξ(x, y). The other two integrals in expression (3.60) are the cross terms, which are nonzero, since the random functions describing sound field fluctuations are statistically independent. In the case of statistically homogeneous and isotropic unevenness, we obtain from expression (3.60) using relationships (3.50), (3.51), and (3.56) | p ran (r0 ) | 2 2 | pav (r0 ) |
= ( µ 2 + k 2 cos 2 θ ) 2 ×
κ 2 a 2 2π − κ exp[ −kκa 2 sin θ cos Ψ ] × ℑ κ ( ) exp ∫ 2 ∫ 0 0
∞
(3.61) µ ∗ [2 µ − i ( q − q )] 1 − 2 µ2 µ + k 2 cos2 θ + dκ dΨ . 2 2 2 2 ∗ ( µ − iq)( µ − iq ) ( µ + k cos θ ) 2 2 1/2 Here q = (k cosθ − κ − 2kκ sinθ cos Ψ) and q* is the complex conjugate to q. We obtain for the field under the source (θ = 0) 2 1 − 2µ k | p ran (r0 ) | 2 µ2 + k2 µ2 = 2π ( µ 2 + k 2 ) 2 ∫ ℑ(κ ) + 2 µ 2 + k 2 − κ 2 (µ 2 + k 2 ) 2 | p av (r0 | 0 θ =0
κ 2a 2 κ dκ + exp − 2
×
(3.62)
2µ (µ + κ 2 − k 2 ) 1− 2 2 2 2 2 µ κ a µ +k + exp − κ dκ . ∫ ℑ(κ ) 2 2 2 2 (µ + k ) µ + κ 2 − k2 k
∞
72
THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: HOMOGENEOUS LIQUID
Expressions (3.61) and (3.62) allow us to calculate the dispersion of intensity fluctuations of the sound field for different forms of the spatial spectrum of unevenness. We should note that, even for the simple forms of ℑ(κ), it is impossible to obtain analytical expressions, but expressions (3.61) and (3.62) can be calculated rather easily.
6. EFFICIENCY OF THERMORADIATION EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID – SOME ESTIMATES It is interesting to clarify what is the efficiency of conversion of the penetrating radiation energy into acoustic energy in conditions of thermoradiation sound excitation. This question with respect to sound generation by laser radiation was addressed by Bozhkov and Bunkin [29]. The efficiency can be characterized by the quantity η = Psound / Prad, where Psound = ∫ IsoundR2dΩ is the power of the sound generated in a liquid in the case of incidence of a harmonically modulated beam of penetrating radiation with power Prad at its surface and Isound = | p2 | / 2pc is the sound intensity. Calculating this integral (over all spatial angles of the half-space z > 0), it is possible apparently to use expression (3.22) for the amplitude p, which is valid for the far wave field. For example, in the case of a wide laser beam (ka >> 1) with Gaussian profile, it is easy to obtain a general expression for η:
η = (c / ρ )(mAα / 2C p ) 2 [ µk ( µ 2 + k 2 )]2 I 0 .
(3.63)
Thus, the efficiency of radiation-acoustic conversion η depends linearly on the penetrating radiation efficiency I0 = Prad/(πa2). The maximum efficiency corresponds to the condition k = µ and is determined by a formula,
η max = (c / ρ )[mAα / 4C p ] 2 I 0 .
(3.64)
Let us give some estimates of generation of monochromatic sound in water (in many cases the necessary radiation-acoustic and thermophysical constants are well known for water) and in particular, the estimates for the cases of sound generation by CO2- and YAG-lasers. In these cases the thermal expansion coefficient α = 3⋅10−4 K−1 and according to expression (3.64), the maximum conversion efficiency ηmax ≈ 5⋅10−12 W/cm2.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
73
CO2 laser (λ = 10.06 µm). Let us calculate the maximum value of the ultrasonic amplitude that can be obtained at the axis of a laser beam at a distance R = 1 m from the water surface while using a laser pulse with length 10 µs and modulated with an ultrasonic frequency (intra-pulse modulation). The absorption coefficient µ ≈ 800 cm−1 [99, 119, 179]. At the optimal sound frequency, the far wave field is realized in the case of focusing of laser radiation into a spot a ≤ 2 mm. Assuming a = 1 mm and Popt = 103 W, we obtain according to expression (3.22), p ≈ 500 dyne/cm2 at the sound frequency 6 MHz and in the sound spot ∆l ≈ 15 cm. In this case the intensity I0 = Popt/(πa2) = 3⋅104 W/cm2 and according to expression (3.64), the conversion efficiency η ≈ 5⋅10−8. YAG laser (λ = 1.06 µm). Let us calculate the amplitude of ultrasound emitted in the quasi-CW mode along the water surface at the frequency ω/2π = 100 kHz at distance R = 1 m from the radiation spot of radius a = 2.5 mm. The absorption coefficient µ = 0.18 cm−1. As k ≈ 4 cm−1, then ka ≈ 1, ka2 ≈ 2.5 mm, and k/µ >> 1, i.e., the conditions for sound radiation along the liquid surface are satisfied. In this case the direction of the maximum of the directivity pattern constitutes the angle θ ≈ µ/k ≈ 4.5⋅10−2 rad = 2.6° to the liquid surface. Assuming Popt = 50 W, we obtain p ≈ 1.3 dyne/cm2 or 0.13 Pa according to expression (3.22).
CHAPTER 4
Thermoradiation Excitation of Sound in an Inhomogeneous Medium Inhomogeneity of liquid may influence sound excitation by penetrating radiation. Firstly, parameters of thermoradiation sources of sound may change because of the change of the path of radiation particles in a medium. Secondly, sound waves may be refracted and scattered by inhomogeneities and reflected by boundaries. In this chapter we consider some examples of thermoradiation excitation of sound in an inhomogeneous liquid.
1. SOUND EXCITATION IN A LIQUID HALF-SPACE IN THE PRESENCE OF A LAYER OF ANOTHER LIQUID AT ITS BOUNDARY Let us consider specific features of thermoradiation generation of sound in a liquid half-space in the presence of a layer of another liquid at its boundary, and in the case of absorption of intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in a two-layer medium. The presence of a liquid layer with acoustic (radiation) parameters, which differ from the parameters of the liquid in the half-space, can substantially influence characteristics of sound emission and intensity of the sound field. Both increase and decrease of intensity are possible in this case [145]. Let a beam of penetrating radiation be incident normally upon a free boundary of a liquid layer with density ρ and sound velocity c. Let the layer 75
76 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
of the thickness H be located on a liquid half-space with density ρ1 and sound velocity c1. It is necessary to determine the sound field in the halfspace produced by absorption of intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in such a two-layer medium. As usual we select a coordinate system in such a way that the plane (x,y) coincides with the free surface of the layer. The axis z is directed within the liquid, and the coordinate origin is positioned in the center of the place of incidence of penetrating radiation (radiation spot) at the free surface of the liquid. We assume that the intensity of penetrating radiation is lower than the value necessary for changes of aggregate state in the region of absorption. Let us consider the stable regime of sound generation. The field of sound pressure p in the layer is described by the solution of the equation, ∆p + k 2 p =
iωmα µE ( x, y , z ) , 0 < z < H , Cp
(4.1)
where ω is the frequency of generated sound, k = ω /c is the wave number, m is the modulation index of intensity of penetrating radiation, α, Cp, and µ are the coefficient of cubical thermal expansion, specific heat capacity, and absorption coefficient of penetrating radiation in the layer. The function E(x,y,z) describes distribution of intensity of penetrating radiation in the liquid layer. The sound pressure p1 in the half-space is described by the solution of the equation ∆p1 + k12 p1 =
iωmα1 µ1E1 ( x, y, z ) , z > H , Cp
(4.2)
1
where k1 = ω /c1 and α1, Cp1, and µ1 are the coefficient of cubical thermal expansion, specific heat capacity, and absorption coefficient of penetrating radiation in a liquid occupying the half-space z > H, respectively. The function E1(x, y, z) describes distribution of intensity of penetrating radiation in the half-space. Solutions of equations (4.1) and (4.2) must satisfy the boundary conditions p = 0, p = p1, z = 0,
1 ∂ρ 1 ∂ρ1 = , z = H, ρ ∂z ρ1 ∂z
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
77
and the condition of termination at infinity. The desired solution p1 of equation (4.2) can be written down on the basis of the reciprocity principle. The mathematical formulation of the reciprocity principle in acoustics was obtained by the author [131] (see Chapter 3, Section 2) under very general assumptions for the case of an inhomogeneous medium with constant density. An opportunity to generalize relationships obtained for the case of media with density depending on coordinates was indicated there also. In the case of a twolayer medium, such generalization is attained in a rather simple way described by the author [131]. Therefore, we will not dwell on this technique. Let us write down an expression for the desired sound pressure p1(r0) in the form
ρ iωmα p1 (r0 ) = 1 µ ∫ E ( x, y, z ) p * (r, r0 )dV − ρ Cp Vl
(4.3) iωmα1 µ Cp
∗
∫ E1( x, y, z ) p1 (r, r0 )dV ,
Vhs
where r0(x0, y0, z0) is the radius-vector of the observation point and r(x, y, z) is the instant radius-vector. Integration in expression (4.3) is performed over the layer region Vl and the region of half-space Vhs, where thermal sources of sound exist. The functions p* and p1* describe the field of a point source of unit amplitude located in the observation point r0. Thus, the problem is reduced to determination of these auxiliary functions, and the functions E(x, y, z) and E1(x, y, z) describing the distribution of the intensity of penetrating radiation in the layer and in the half-space. Firstly let us obtain an expression determining the intensity distribution of penetrating radiation in the layer E(x, y, z). In order to do this, it is necessary to sum all reflections of the initial beam of penetrating radiation from the layer boundaries. Thus, a direct beam produces at some level z in the layer the distribution of radiation intensity, which is determined by the expression AI(x, y) exp(−µz), where A is the coefficient of penetrating radiation transmission through the free boundary of the layer, and the function I(x, y) describes the transversal distribution of radiation intensity in a beam. The radiation intensity in the beam at the level z after partial reflection at the boundary “layer – half-space” is described by the expression A(1 − A1 ) I ( x, y ) exp[− µ (2 H − z )] ,
78 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
where A1 is the transmission coefficient of radiation through the boundary “layer – half-space”. Then, after a partial reflection from the free boundary of the layer, the radiation intensity at the level z decreases down to the value A(1 − A)(1 − A1 ) I ( x, y ) exp[− µ (2 H + z )] , and so on. It is easy to sum the series obtained using the formula for the sum of an infinitely decreasing geometric progression. In the result we can write down an expression for E(x, y, z): E ( x, y , z ) = A
exp(− µz ) + (1 − A1 ) exp[− µ (2 H − z )] I ( x, y ) , 1 − (1 − A)(1 − A1 ) exp(2 µH )
(4.4)
at 0 ≤ z ≤ H. The intensity of penetrating radiation in the half-space is calculated in an analogous way. A corresponding expression for E1(x, y, z) can be presented in the form
E1 ( x, y, z ) =
AA1 exp[− µH − µ1 ( z − H )] I ( x, y ) , z ≥ H . 1 − (1 − A)(1 − A1 ) exp(−2µH )
(4.5)
It is necessary to determine the excited sound field p1(r0) at the point r0 in the liquid half-space at distances greater than the dimensions of the region occupied by thermal sources of sound. In this case we assume that the observation point r0 is located not too close to the boundary “layer – half-space”1. In this case the auxiliary solutions within this area can be represented approximately in the form
p * (r , r0 ) =
1
exp(ik1r0 ) exp(−ik1 x sin θ )W [exp(−iγz ) − exp(iγz )] , 4πr0
We have to note that under certain conditions, a normal mode relatively weakly emitting energy into the half-space can exist in the layer, and therefore it relatively weakly attenuates with distance from the source. The solution given below is valid also in the case when the distance from the source to the observation point is large in comparison with the dimensions of the layer region, where the existence of a weakly attenuating normal mode is noticeable.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
p * (r , r0 ) =
exp(ik1r0 ) exp(ik1 x sin θ ){exp(−ik1 z cos θ ) − 4πr0
79
(4.6)
V exp[ik1 ( z − 2 H ) cos θ ]} . Here W =
2 β exp[i (γ − k1 cosθ ) H ] 1 − β + (1 + β ) exp(2iγH ) , V = , 1 + β + (1 − β ) exp(2iγH ) 1 + β + (1 − β ) exp(2iγH ) (4.7)
γ = k 2 − k12 sin 2 θ , β =
ρk1 cosθ , ρ1γ
θ is the angle between the radius-vector r0 and the axis z, and the plane x, y is assumed to include the observation point. Substituting auxiliary solutions in the form of expressions (4.6) and E(x, y, z) and E1(x, y, z) in the form of expressions (4.4) and (4.5) into expression (4.3), we obtain a relationship determining the sound pressure p1(r0):
p1 (r0 ) =
ρ α WµγQ exp(ik1r0 ) Aωm + F (θ ) 1 1 − (1 − A)(1 − A1 ) exp(−2µH ) 2πr0 ρ C p µ 2 + γ 2 (4.8)
µ1k1 cos θ (1 + V ) + iµ12 (1 − V ) α 2 A1 exp[− µH − ik1H cos θ ] , C p1 2 µ12 + k12 cos2 θ where
F (θ ) = ∫
∞
∫ I ( x, y) exp(ik1 x sin θ )dxdy ,
−∞
Q = 1 − 2 exp(− µH ) cos(γH ) −
80 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
µ A1 exp( − µH ) sin(γH ) − cos(γH ) − (1 − A1 ) exp( −2 µH ) . γ Expression (4.8) determines the sound field in a liquid half-space in the far wave zone. The field is produced due to absorption of intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in the case when a layer of another liquid is present at the half-space boundary. Using this expression, we can calculate directivity patterns of thermoradiation sources of sound in various situations. As we have noted before, a transverse distribution of intensity in a beam of penetrating radiation is close to the Gaussian one. Therefore, we assume I ( x, y ) = I 0 exp[−( x 2 + y 2 ) / a 2 ] . Integrating, we obtain the next expression for F(θ ): F (θ ) = I 0πa 2 exp[−(k12 a 2 / 4) sin 2 θ ] .
(4.9)
Figure 4.1 shows examples of directivity patterns calculated according to formulae (4.8) and (4.9) for a laser source (photon beam) and the Gaussian distribution of intensity in a laser beam. Directivity patterns in Fig. 4.1a correspond to the situation in which a layer of benzene is present at the surface of water. The wavelength of optical radiation is 0.3 µm. In this case µ = 2.3 cm−1 and µ1 = 0.18 cm−1 (for example, see [179]). The coefficients of light transmission are A = 0.96 and A1 = 0.99. The radius of light spot is taken to be equal to a = 0.4 cm. The ratios are ρ/ρ1 = 0.88, α1/Cp = 63.3⋅10−12 g/erg, and α1/Cp1 = 4.7⋅10−12 g/erg. The directivity patterns are calculated for the three values of thickness of the benzene layer: H = 0.33 cm (kH = π/2), H = 0.66 cm (kH = π), and H = 1.99 cm (kH = 3π). The observation angle is counted off from the vertical axis, where the modulus of the amplitude of sound pressure p1(r0) is normalized to (2ωmI0a2/2r0)⋅10−12 g/(cm⋅s2). We should note that under such conditions the directivity pattern of a laser thermoradiation source in water without a benzene layer is strongly extended along the surface, and the amplitude of sound pressure in the vertical direction (θ = 0) is approximately two orders of magnitude smaller than that in the considered case with a layer. Thus, the presence of a layer of another liquid on the surface of a liquid half-space can lead to a significant change of intensity of sound field. If a liquid in the layer is characterized by the value of α /Cp large in comparison with a liquid in the half-space, the intensity of sound field increases
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
81
substantially. The difference in the ratios µ/k for liquids in the layer and in the half-space leads also to significant differences in directivity patterns in the cases with a layer and without it. As we have noted already, in the absence of a layer, the directivity pattern is strongly extended along the free surface of water. And when a benzene layer is present, it displays a peak in the vertical direction. Finally, if the values of kH are large enough, the resonance properties of a layer begin to manifest themselves which also leads to changes (irregularity) in directivity patterns.
Figure 4.1 Directivity pattern of a thermooptical source of sound in a two-layer medium. (a) Benzene – water, thickness of benzene layer H = 0.33, 0.66, and 1.99 cm (curves 1 – 3, respectively); (b) water – benzene; and (c) warm water – cold water correspond to the thickness H = 0, 1.86, and 2.23 cm (1 – 3).
Directivity patterns given in Fig. 4.1b describe a reversed situation: a water layer is located on a benzene half-space. Calculations are conducted
82 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
for three values of layer thickness, i.e., H = 0 (a half-space without a layer), H = 1.86 cm (kH = 2.5π), and H = 2.23 cm (kH = 3π). Such arrangement of liquids may be of theoretical interest only. However, it is important to note the following fact. Only about 30% of the energy of laser radiation is absorbed in a water layer in this case. Moreover, the ratio α/Cp for benzene is more than one order of magnitude larger than this ratio for water. Therefore, acoustic radiation is produced almost exceptionally by thermal (thermooptical) sources of sound located in the half-space, i.e., benzene. Nevertheless, the shapes of directivity patterns in the cases with a layer and without it are essentially different. This fact is connected with the change of conditions at the boundary of the half-space: a layer is present with wave resonance properties instead of a free boundary. Directivity patterns given in Fig. 4.1c correspond to a situation in which a layer of warm water (20°C) is located on top of cold water (0°C). The wavelength of laser radiation is selected to be equal to 1 µm. In this case µ = µ1 = 0.18 cm−1. The frequency of generated sound is ω /2π = 105 Hz. The next values of wave numbers are k = 4.23 cm−1 and k1 = 4.38 cm−1. Furthermore, A = 0.98, A1 = 1, ρ/ρ1 ≈ 1, α/Cp = 4.76⋅10−12 g/erg, and α1/Cp = 1.19⋅10−12 g/erg. The radius of the light spot is taken to be equal to 0.4 cm. The patterns are calculated for three values of layer thickness: H = 0 (a homogeneous half-space), H = 1.86 cm (kH = 2.5π), and H = 2.23 cm (kH = 3π). In the case considered, the liquids in the layer and the half-space differ noticeably only in the ratio α /Cp. Nevertheless, the presence of the layer leads not only to an increase of the intensity of generated sound, but also changes significantly the shapes of directivity patterns. It is difficult to conduct a more detailed analysis of the dependence of the parameters of the sound field generated in a two-layer medium by a source of penetrating radiation on the problem parameters in a general form, as expression (4.8) is rather complex. Therefore, we restrict ourselves to consideration of a particular case which may be of practical interest. Let exp(−µH) << 1, i.e., the energy of penetrating radiation is absorbed in the main layer. Further, let ρ ≤ ρ1 and c ≤ c1. Then, ignoring the terms of the order of exp(−µH) in expression (4.8), we obtain an approximate expression for p1(r0):
ρ ωmαA exp(ik1r0 ) µγ p1 (r0 ) ≈ 1 WF (θ ) . 2πr0 ρ Cp µ2 +γ 2
(4.10)
Let us compare the sound field generated by a thermoradiation source in a two-layer medium with the sound field in a homogeneous liquid halfspace without a layer. An expression describing a sound field in the case of
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
83
thermoradiation generation of sound in a homogeneous half-space is obtained above and can be rewritten in the form
p0 (r0 ) =
ωmα1 A2 exp(ik1r0 ) µ1k1 cos θ F (θ ) , C p1 2πr0 µ12 + k12 cos 2 θ
(4.11)
where A2 is the coefficient of light transmission through the free boundary of a half-space. The influence of a layer on the amplitude of sound field and the directivity pattern of a thermoradiation sound source can be evaluated comparing expressions (4.10) and (4.11). We have to note that the shape of the directivity pattern depends essentially on the ratio of the wave number of sound to the absorption coefficient of penetrating radiation in a liquid. In the case of a homogeneous half-space, this dependence was investigated in detail. Reasoning and conclusions are practically the same in the considered case with a layer. To make it simpler, let us take µ = µ1 and αA/Cp = α1A2/Cp2. Let us consider the modulus of the ratio p1(r0)/p0(r0), which we denote by the letter q. Taking into account expressions (4.7), (4.10), and (4.11), we obtain
q=
µ 2 + k12 cos 2 θ p1 (r0 ) 1 . =2 2 2 + β + − β | 1 ( 1 ) exp(2iγH ) | p0 (r0 ) µ +γ
(4.12)
At the beginning let c = c1 and ρ = ρ1, i.e., liquids in the layer and halfspace differ only in density. In this case an expression for q takes on an especially simple form q=
2 | 1 + ρ / ρ1 + (1 − ρ / ρ1 ) exp(2ikH cosθ ) |
.
(4.13)
Analyzing expression (4.13), one can see that q ≥ 1 at any value of θ. The maximum of q is equal to the ratio ρ/ρ1 and attained when kH cos θ = (n + 1/2)π, where n is a certain natural number. The minimum of q is equal to one and attained at kH cosθ = nπ. Thus, selecting a corresponding layer thickness (or the frequency of generated sound) it is possible to obtain an increase of sound pressure in a
84 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
set direction by the factor ρ/ρ1 as against the pressure generated in a homogeneous liquid half-space in the absence of a layer of another liquid. In the case ρ < ρ1 and c < c1, the dependence of q on the observation angle θ is much more complex. Let us consider alteration of q depending on parameters of liquids only for θ = 0. In this case expression (4.12) takes on the form,
q=2
µ 2 + k12 µ
2
1
+ k 2 | 1 + ρc / ρ1c1 + (1 − ρc / ρ1c1 ) exp(2ikH ) |
.
As ρc/ρc1 > 1, the maximum value of q is attained at kH = (n + 1/2)π and is equal to 2 2 ρ c µ + k1 . q= 1 1 ρc µ 2 + k 2
It is necessary to note that the value of q may be larger than one in this case. Everything discussed is illustrated by the directivity patterns calculated according to approximate formula (4.10) and given in Fig. 4.2. Calculations were conducted for the Gaussian distribution of the intensity of penetrating radiation in a beam (in a laser beam) as above. The observation angle was counted off the vertical axis where the level of sound pressure p1(r0) normalized to the value of
ωmαA 2 I 0 µk a 2 Cp 2r0 µ + k 2 is displayed. The next relationships between the problem parameters are taken: ρ/ρ1 = 0.79, µ/k1 = 1, and ka = 2. Directivity patterns in Fig. 4.2a correspond to the value k/k1 = 1 and in Fig. 4.2b k/k1 = 1.27. These directivity patterns were calculated for the values kH = 2.5π and kH = 3π. The directivity pattern of sound radiation generated by a radiation-acoustic source in a homogeneous half-space without a layer is given for comparison. We have to note that the values k/k1 = 1.27 and ρ/ρ1 = 0.79 correspond roughly to the case when a layer of alcohol is present on the water surface. One more particular case is interesting. Let ρ = ρ1 and k2 = k12 + ib2, while b/k1 << cosθ. In other words, a liquid in the layer differs from a liquid in the half-space by the presence of a small attenuation of sound. This sound
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
85
attenuation may be caused by a small amount of air bubbles in the surface layer for example. Restricting ourselves to the terms of the order of smallness not higher than the second order of smallness with respect to b/k1, let us write down expression (4.10) in an approximate form, i (b / k1 ) 2 b p1 (r0 ) = p 0 (r0 )1 − + i 2 2 ( µ / k1 ) + cos θ 2k1 cos θ 1 − exp( 2ik1H cos θ ) − k1H cos θ
b k1
2
exp − k1H 2
2
×
b k1 cos θ
2
.
One can see from the analysis of this expression that if the values of k1H are large enough, the amplitude of the field generated by a radiation-acoustic source in this case can be essentially smaller than in the case of a homogeneous half-space. Moreover, the presence of an absorbing layer can make the directivity pattern of generated sound field essentially narrower.
Figure 4.2 Directivity patterns of a thermooptical source of sound in a two-layer medium. The patterns are calculated according to approximate formula (4.10). (1) kH = 2.5π; (2) kH = 3π; and (3) a homogeneous half-space without a layer.
86 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
EXTENSION TO THE CASE OF UNEVEN FREE BOUNDARY. The above results may be extended to the case when the free boundary of a layer is uneven. Let us consider for example the case when the height of unevenness is small in comparison with the wavelength of generated sound. A problem of sound generation by penetrating radiation in a liquid halfspace with uneven boundary in the case of small (in comparison with the sound wavelength) height of unevenness is considered in detail by Lyamshev and Sedov [144] (see Chapter 3, Section 5). Using the results of this study and calculation technique described above, we can obtain pav(r0) for the average field in the case of uneven boundary. Let us assume for simplicity that almost the total energy of penetrating radiation is absorbed in a layer, where thermal (thermoradiation) sources are located. In this case the auxiliary solution is determined by the expression, p * (r , r0 ) =
exp(ik1r0 ) w exp(−ik1 x sin θ )[exp(−iγz ) + v exp(iγz )] , 4πr0
where w=
2 β exp[i (γ − k1 cosθ ) H ] , 1 − β − v(1 − β ) exp(2iγH )
and v is the average coefficient of reflection of a plane sound wave from an uneven surface. After calculation analogous to calculation described in detail in Chapter 3 and by Lyamshev and Sedov [144], we obtain an expression
ρ ωmαA exp(ik1r0 ) µγ pav (r0 ) = 1 wF (θ ) f (θ ) . 2πr0 ρ Cp µ2 +γ 2
(4.14)
The function f(θ) in expression (4.14) characterizes the effect of the free boundary of the layer on the sound field generated by a thermoradiation source. In Chapter 3, Section 5 we obtained a rather general relationship connecting the function f(θ) with various parameters of boundary unevenness and analyzed some limiting cases. An expression determining the average coefficient of reflection of a plane sound wave from an uneven boundary was also given there. Here we consider only one particular case. Let the correlation coefficient of boundary unevenness ρ0 be greater than the wavelength of generated sound. Furthermore, let us restrict ourselves to
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
87
the case of not too flat observation angles satisfying the condition kρ0 cos2θ >> 1. Then, as is demonstrated by Lyamshev and Sedov [144], f(θ) = 1 – 3P2/8 – (µσ)2, where P = 2kσ cosθ is the Rayleigh parameter and σ is the mean-square-root height of unevenness. In this case the relationship v = − 1 + P2/2 is valid for the average reflection coefficient. Substituting these values of f(θ) and v into expression (4.14) and keeping the terms of the order of smallness not higher than the second order with respect to kσ and µσ, we obtain an expression, 3 p2 (1 − β ) exp(2iγH ) pav (r0 ) = p1 (r0 )1 − p 2 − ( µσ ) 2 + , (4.15) 2 1 + β + (1 − β ) exp(2iγH ) 8 (expression (4.10) is used here for p1(r0)). Expression (4.15) is obtained under the assumption p2 (1 − β ) exp(2iγH ) << 1 . 2 1 + β + (1 − β ) exp(2iγH ) Analyzing expression (4.15), one can see that naturally, the average field in the case of uneven boundary is rather smaller than the field under an even boundary. The degree of field decrease is different in different directions, and this difference depends on the layer thickness. The maximum attenuation under the source (θ = 0) takes place at kH = (n + 1/2)π, where n is a certain number of natural series. It is determined by the factor p av (r0 ) p2 1 1 + − ( µσ ) 2 . = 1− 4 2 β p1 (r0 ) The minimum attenuation occurs at kH = nπ and it is determined by the factor p av (r0 ) p2 1 2 = 1− + β − ( µσ ) . p1 (r0 ) 4 2 Thus, in some cases the presence of a layer of another liquid at the surface of a liquid half-space may influence essentially the characteristics of the sound field generated by intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in the half-space.
88 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
2. GENERATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID ADJOINING A SOLID LAYER We have considered already sound generation by penetrating radiation in a liquid half-space in the presence of a layer of another liquid on its surface due to absorption of intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in such a two-layer medium. Situations may arise in practice where a liquid adjoins a solid layer. In this connection it is expedient to clarify the specific features of thermoradiation generation of sound in a liquid half-space adjoining a thin elastic plate for example [134]. We will consider two limiting cases: the case when a plate is transparent to radiation and penetrating radiation is absorbed in a liquid and the case when absorption of penetrating radiation occurs in the surface layer of a plate and sound field in a liquid is caused by plate vibrations under the effect of penetrating radiation. As it turns out in both cases, plate vibrations affect the characteristics of sound field in a liquid mainly in the directions close to the so-called critical angles determined by the ratio of the sound velocity in a liquid to the velocity of flexural or longitudinal oscillations in a plate. Let a thin elastic plate be present at the boundary of a liquid half-space, and let an intensity-modulated beam of penetrating radiation be incident upon the plate. The radiation propagates in the positive direction of the axis z of a rectangular system of coordinates (x, y, z). Let us investigate the specific features of the sound field generated in the liquid half-space by a thermoradiation source. First, we assume that the plate is radiation transparent, i.e., penetrating radiation is almost not absorbed in the plate, 2h << µ−1 << µ1−1, where 2h is the plate thickness and µ and µ1 are the coefficients of radiation absorption in the liquid and the plate. We can write down an expression for sound pressure, iαAmω r p(r1 ) = ∫∫ I ( x, y ) exp(− µz ) p * dΩ(r ) . Cp r1 Ω
(4.16)
Here α is the coefficient of thermal expansion; Cp is the specific heat capacity of liquid; c is the sound velocity in a liquid; A is the transmission coefficient of penetrating radiation for the liquid limited by a plate; and p*(r/r1) is the solution of the diffraction problem on the field of a point source of sound in a liquid half-space limited with a thin elastic plate, when the source is located at the point of the half-space, where it is necessary to determine the acoustic field generated by a thermoradiation source.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
89
We need to determine an acoustic field produced due to absorption of penetrating radiation in a liquid in the far wave zone. In this case the auxiliary solution can be written down in the approximate form, p * (r / r1 ) =
1 exp(ikR1 ) {exp[i (k x x + k y y − k z z )] + R1 4π (4.17)
+V (k x , k y , k z ) exp[i (k x x + k y y + k z z )]} ,
where R1 = (x12 + y12 + z12)1/2, V(kx, ky, kz) is the reflection coefficient of a plane sound wave in the case of a thin elastic plate positioned at the boundary of a liquid half-space with vacuum, and kx, ky, and kz are the components of the wave vector k of a sound wave in a liquid. Two types of vibrations are possible in a thin plate: vibrations symmetrical with respect to its median plane, or so-called transverse pressure vibrations connected with longitudinal vibrations, and antisymmetrical vibrations, i.e., flexural vibrations. Using the equations of plate motion and solving a problem on reflection of a plane sound wave from a plate positioned at the boundary of a liquid half-space with vacuum, we obtain an expression for the reflection coefficient V(kx, ky, kz) (for example, see [135]), V (k x , k y , k z ) =
2 ZZ1 cos θ − 2 ρcZ1 − ρcZ . 2 ZZ1 cos θ + 2 ρcZ1 + ρcZ
(4.18)
Here Z and Z1 are the plate impedances for flexural vibrations and transverse pressure vibrations: 4 c f Z = −iωm1 1 − cosθ , cosθ = c
Z1 =
k 2 − (k x2 + k y2 ) k2
2 c 1 − 1 sin θ , 2 c c ωh 1 − ν 12 − 1 sin θ c
iE1
,
(4.19)
(4.20)
90 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
where m1 = 2hρ1 is the plate mass per unit area, ρ1 is the material density, ν1 is the Poisson’s ratio of the plate, c1 = (E1/ρ1)1/2 is the velocity of longitudinal waves, E1 is the elasticity modulus, cf = [2ω2E1h3/3m1]1/4 is the velocity of flexural waves in the plate, θ is the angle between the direction to the observation point r1(x1, y1, z1) and the coordinate axis z, ρ is the liquid density, and c is the sound velocity in the liquid. Substituting expression (4.17) into expression (4.16) and assuming that the distribution of intensity of penetrating radiation in the beam obeys the Gaussian law I(x, y) = I0 exp[−(x2 + y2)/a2] , we obtain after integration
p(r1 ) = i
k 2 a 2 sin 2 θ αAmωµ exp(ikR1 ) I 0 a 2 exp − 4C p 4 R1
× (4.21)
1 1 ik cos θ − µ − V (θ ) ik cos θ + µ . Expression (4.21) is basic and its analysis allows us to determine the effect of the plate on the field of a radiation-acoustic source in a liquid. Let us consider some particular cases. Let | z | → ∞. This means that transverse pressure vibrations of the plate are “forbidden”. In this case we obtain an expression for the reflection coefficient, Z cos θ − ρc . V z →∞ = 1 Z cosθ + ρc
(4.22)
Further, let Z cos θ << ρc .
(4.23)
One can see from expression (4.19) that this condition is valid when the plate thickness is very small. Now V Z → ∞, Z cos θ << ρc ≈ −1 . 1
(4.24)
Taking into account the assumptions made for sound pressure in a liquid, we obtain
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
p (r1 ) =
91
exp(ikR1 ) ωmαA µk cos θ × I0a 2 2 2C p R1 k cos 2 θ + µ 2
(4.25) k 2 a 2 sin 2 θ exp − 4
.
Naturally, expression (4.25) characterizes the field of a radiation-acoustic source in a liquid with a free boundary. Now let the plate thickness satisfy the condition Z cos θ >> ρc .
(4.26)
We have to note that the last condition may be valid also if the velocity of flexural waves cf is small in comparison with the sound velocity in a liquid. We obtain an expression for the reflection coefficient, V Z → ∞, Z cos θ >> ρc ≈ 1 , 1
(4.27)
and the formula for sound pressure in a liquid takes on the form p(r1 ) ≈ −
exp(ikR1 ) iωmαA µ2 I0a 2 × 2C p R1 k 2 cos 2 θ + µ 2 (4.28) k a sin θ . exp − 4 2 2
2
Expression (4.28) characterizes the far field of a radiation-acoustic source acting in a liquid half-space with a rigid, motionless but radiationtransparent boundary. One can see from expressions (4.25) and (4.28) that in the first case if k < µ and ka < 1, the dipole radiation of sound takes place and in the second case there is the monopole radiation. The condition k ≈ µ is connected usually with the optimal regime of thermooptical radiation of sound in a liquid. If this condition is satisfied, the amplitude of sound pressure in the case of a liquid with a free boundary, as a matter of fact, differs from the amplitude in the case of a rigidly fixed
92 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
boundary. However, it is interesting to note that in the case k = µ, the amplitude of sound pressure in the direction of incidence of a beam of penetrating radiation (θ = 0°) does not depend on the character of the boundary. In the considered case of a heavy thin plate, the reflection coefficient V is always equal to one in its absolute value and changes only in its phase within the range from 0 to π depending on the parameters of the plate and liquid. Analyzing expression (4.18), one can see that the reflection coefficient takes on the value V = −1 if the conditions Z = 0 or Z1 = 0 are satisfied. These conditions correspond to such critical angles of observation when θf = arcsin(c/cf) or θ1 = arcsin(c/c1). Considerable changes including “gaps” are observed in the directivity pattern of a radiation-acoustic source in the directions close to critical angles. It is easy to explain them. The point is that the conditions Z = 0 and Z1 = 0 or (cf/c) sinθ = 1 and (c1/c) sinθ = 1 that is equivalent (see expressions (4.19) and (4.20)) are the conditions of the socalled spatial resonance, when a plate becomes almost sound-transparent [135]. If we imagine that thermal sources of sound in the area of absorption of penetrating radiation produce a field of plane sound waves propagating under various angles, then the plate behaves (with respect to plane waves propagating under critical angles) as almost totally sound-transparent and does not influence the amplitudes and phases of these waves. In other words, interaction of these waves with the boundary of a liquid half-space occurs as if this boundary were free. What is said above is illustrated by Fig. 4.3a–d where angular dependences of the level of sound pressure in a liquid half-space with a free boundary (curve 1) and limited by a thin plate (curve 2) are shown. Calculations were performed for water and a glass plate. The plate thickness is 1 mm, the modulation frequency of radiation intensity of a photon beam (laser 6 radiation) is 10 Hz, the beam radius is 1 mm, and the laser power is 1 W. The values of critical angles are θf = arcsin(c/cf) ≈ 40° and θ1 = arcsin(c/c1) ≈ 31°. The results given in Fig. 4.3a correspond to the case k = µ = 42 cm−1 and the case 420 cm−1 = µ > k = 42 cm−1 is given in Fig. 4.3b. One can see that the “gaps” in angular patterns not only attain the value of sound pressure in the case of a free boundary, but are also much deeper. Figures 4.3c and d illustrate the cases µ << k, namely 4.2 cm−1 = µ < k = 42 cm−1 (Fig. 4.3c) and 0.42 cm−1 = µ < k = 42 cm−1 (Fig. 4.3d). One can see that at µ << k, the maxima and minima of angular patterns are observed in the vicinity of critical angles. The maxima are observed when the field amplitude is equal to its value in the case of the free boundary. Such a pattern is explained by the interference structure of the field of vibrations in a plate and sound waves in a liquid. Now let us consider the case when absorption of penetrating radiation occurs almost entirely in a thin surface layer of a plate, i.e., when µ -1 << h.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
93
Figure 4.3 Dependence of sound pressure in a liquid on observation angle. (1) Liquid boundary is free; (2) a glass plate is present on the liquid surface.
Now sound field in a liquid is produced only by plate vibrations caused by the effect of external forces. The role of these forces is played by a thermoelastic stress arising in a surface layer of a plate when intensitymodulated penetrating radiation is absorbed there. The acoustic field of a vibrating plate can be calculated using the reciprocity theorem in the formulation by the author [131] (see Chapter 3, Section 2), p(r1 ) =
∫ S
∂p * (r / r1 ) F (r )dS (r ) . ∂n
(4.29)
Here, as in expression (4.16), p*(r/r1) is the solution of a diffraction problem on the field of a point source of sound in a liquid half-space limited by a plate, when the source is located at the point r1, where it is necessary to determine sound pressure in the acoustic field emitted by a plate vibrating under the action of penetrating radiation; and n is the normal to the plate, which is directed along the positive direction of the coordinate axis z.
94 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
We assume that the density of absorbed energy of penetrating radiation is essentially smaller than the specific heat capacity of evaporation of plate material. Let us consider the thermal mechanism of sound generation. We can write down an expression for thermoelastic stress playing the role of external forces2, F (r, t ) = − Eα1T1 (r, t ) ,
(4.30)
where E is the elasticity modulus of plate material, α1 is the coefficient of thermal expansion of plate material, and T(r,t) is the function characterizing distribution of temperature and its change with time. If the conditions of interaction of penetrating radiation with the plate provide an opportunity to ignore heat conductivity and losses for heat emission from the plate surface, and the penetration depth of radiation is very small while the distribution of radiation intensity in a beam has the Gaussian character, we can write down an expression for T(r, t) (for example, see [40]), x2 + y2 µm exp( −iωt ) , T (r, t ) = 1 I 0 exp − C p1 a 2
(4.31)
where Cp1 is the specific heat capacity of plate material. We need to determine the sound field in a liquid in the far wave zone. We obtain the next expression for the normal derivative of pressure at the plate surface in the field of a point source located at the spatial point where it is necessary to determine the acoustic field of a plate vibrating under the action of penetrating radiation: exp(ikR1 ) ∂p * (r / r1 ) . = −ik z (1 − V ) exp[i (k x x + k y y )] 4πR1 ∂n
(4.32)
Substituting expressions (4.30) – (4.32) into expression (4.29) and integrating, we obtain p (r1 ) =
2
exp(ikR1 ) iωa1mµ1 cos θ × I 0a 2 2C p c R1
Expression (4.30) is a particular case of the relationship of thermal elasticity (for example, see [166]).
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
×
95
k 2 a 2 sin 2 θ ρcZ + 2 ρcZ1 exp − 2ZZ1 cos θ + ρcZ + 2 ρcZ1 4
.
(4.33)
A plate can influence considerably the parameters of the acoustic field. Let us consider several particular cases. Let |z1| → ∞ as above, i.e., a plate cannot perform transverse pressure vibrations. In this case we have p (r1 )| Z |→ ∞ =
exp(ikR1 ) iωα1 mµ1 cos θ × I 0a 2 2C p1 c R1
(4.34) k 2 a 2 sin 2 θ ρc exp − Z cos θ + ρc 4
.
If Z = 0, pressure in the acoustic field of the plate attains its maximum value and naturally, dipole radiation takes place at ka << 1 since the field in the liquid is produced due to the effect of an external periodic source created by an intensity-modulated beam of penetrating radiation incident upon the plate surface. The condition Z = 0 is satisfied for a so-called critical angle for the plate when the velocity of flexural waves in the plate is larger than the sound velocity in the ambient medium and (cf/c) sinθ = 1. Thus, the maximum of plate radiation is observed in the direction of the critical angle θf = arcsin (c/cf). It is easy to see that the radiation maximum is observed in the direction of another critical angle also. These considerations are illustrated by results of calculation given in Fig. 4.4. Levels of sound pressure in a liquid (water) with the free surface (curve 1) and limited from the top by a thin steel plate (curve 2) are given here. Calculation is performed for the next parameters: the plate thickness 2h = 1 mm, the beam radius a = 1 mm, the modulation frequency of laser radiation ~ 106 Hz, and the laser power 1 W. Thus, the presence of a thin elastic layer (elastic plate) at the surface of a liquid half-space can affect essentially the parameters of the acoustic field excited by intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in a liquid. In the case of a radiation-transparent layer and the absorption coefficient of radiation in a liquid µ considerably larger than the wave number of sound k, the presence of a layer leads to the increase of the amplitude of the field of a radiation-acoustic source in a liquid as compared to the case when the liquid boundary is free, and only in the direction of so-called critical angles the amplitude of the acoustic field decreases essentially. On the contrary, if penetrating radiation is weakly absorbed in a liquid, i.e., µ << k, and a plate
96 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
is radiation-transparent or penetrating radiation is completely absorbed in it close to its external boundary, then the maximum values of the amplitude of acoustic field are observed in the directions close to critical angles.
Figure 4.4 Dependence of sound pressure in a liquid on observation angle.
These conclusions can be extended to the case of an elastic layer of finite thickness or a system of layers. Basic formulae stay valid and it is necessary only to substitute corresponding expressions for the reflection coefficients V in their final form (see [40]). It is possible to demonstrate that in the case of a layer of finite thickness, the number of critical angles is determined by the number of normal (symmetrical and antisymmetrical) modes in the layer.
3. LIQUID HALF-SPACE WITH AN INHOMOGENEOUS SURFACE LAYER Thermoradiation generation of sound by intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in the process of its absorption in a liquid half-space with a layer of a liquid with different parameters at the half-space boundary was considered in Section 1. However, parameters of a liquid in the surface layer can change not stepwise but continuously due to nonuniform heating of a liquid by penetrating radiation, in the process of an experiment for example. In this connection it is interesting to analyze the effect of alteration of temperature of a liquid in the surface layer with depth on thermoradiation generation of sound.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
97
In this section we consider specific features of sound generation by intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in a liquid half-space with a surface layer where the coefficient of cubical thermal expansion, specific heat capacity, and sound velocity change with depth according to a linear law. It will be demonstrated that the amplitude of sound field and directivity of acoustic radiation may differ significantly from those in a homogeneous liquid half-space if the ratio of the coefficient of cubical expansion to the specific heat capacity of a liquid changes essentially at the characteristic dimensions of the region of interaction of penetrating radiation with a liquid. Alteration of sound velocity with depth in a surface layer affects only propagation of sound waves [145]. Let a laser beam or a beam of relativistic electrons, γ-quanta, or X-rays be incident upon the even free boundary of a liquid half-space. We select a system of coordinates in such way that the plane x, y coincides with the free surface of the half-space, the axis z is directed inside the liquid, and the origin of coordinates is located in the center of the radiation (light) spot at the liquid surface (see Fig. 4.5a).
Figure 4.5 Generation of sound in an inhomogeneous liquid (a); patterns of alteration of sound velocity (b); and ratio of coefficients α/Cp (c).
Let us assume that the temperature of the liquid directly at the surface is t1 and it changes continuously with depth to the value t2 at the depth h. The liquid temperature is t2 at z > h. It is necessary to determine the sound field in the inhomogeneous part of the half-space, which is generated due to absorption of intensity-modulated penetrating radiation in such medium. Alteration of liquid temperature with depth leads to a change of the ratio α/Cp (where α and Cp are the coefficient of cubical thermal expansion and specific heat capacity of a liquid, respectively) and the sound velocity in the liquid c. Let us assume for definiteness that the liquid temperature changes with depth according to a linear law. If we restrict ourselves to consideration of not very large values of temperature (for example, for water t1 = 25°C and
98 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
t2 = 10°C), the law of alteration of the ratio α/Cp with depth is also approximately linear,
α ( z ) / C p ( z ) = α 0 / C p0 − ∆(α / C p ) z , 0 < z < h , where α0 and Cp are the corresponding parameters of the liquid near the surface and ∆(α/Cp) is the alteration of the ratio α/Cp per unit depth. We take the law of alteration of sound velocity with depth in the form c( z ) = c0 / 1 + bz , 0 < z < h , bh < 1 , where c0 is the sound velocity near the surface. Since |bh| << 1 in all cases of interest from the practical point of view, this law of alteration of sound velocity with depth is very close to a linear one. We also restrict ourselves to the case when almost the total energy of penetrating radiation is absorbed in the surface layer exp(−µh) << 1, where µ is the absorption coefficient of penetrating radiation in the surface layer of the liquid. The field of sound pressure p1 in the layer is described by the solution of the equation, ∆p1 + k 02 (1 + bz ) p1 = iωm[α 0 / C p0 − ∆(α / C p ) z ] × AµI ( x, y ) exp( − µz ) ,
(4.35)
where ω is the frequency of generated sound (the modulation frequency of intensity of penetrating radiation), k = ω /c0, m is the modulation index, A is the coefficient of penetrating radiation transmission through the liquid surface, and I(x, y) is the function describing the distribution of radiation intensity at the liquid surface. The sound pressure p in the inhomogeneous part of the half-space obeys the equation, ∆p + k12 p = 0 , z > h ,
(4.36)
where k1 = k0(1 + bh)1/2. Solutions of equations (4.35) and (4.36) must be consistent with the boundary conditions p1 = 0, z = 0, p = p1, and ∂p/∂z = ∂p1/∂z, z = h as well as the condition of suppression at infinity. The desired
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
99
solution of equation (4.36) can be written down immediately based on the reciprocity principle: p(r0 ) = iωmAµ ∫ [α 0 / C p0 − ∆ (α / C p ) z ] exp(− µz ) × Ω
(4.37) I ( x, y ) p * (r, r0 )dΩ(r ) , where r0(x0, y0, z0) is the radius-vector of the observation point and r(x, y, z) is the current radius-vector. Integration in expression (4.37) is conducted over the region Ω of the inhomogeneous layer where thermal sources of sound exist, and the function p*(r,r0) describes the field in the layer which is produced by a point source of unit amplitude and located in the observation point r0. We need to determine the sound field p(r0) at distances exceeding essentially both the dimensions of the region occupied by thermal sources of sound and the thickness of the inhomogeneous layer. We assume that the observation point is located not too close to the boundary of the layer with the inhomogeneous part of the half-space. In this case the auxiliary solution within the limits of the region of action of thermal sources of sound can be represented as the field of a plane sound wave incident in the direction of the vector – r0/r and spherical divergence may be taken into account with the help of the factor exp(ikir0)/4πr0. Taking into account everything said before, we can obtain the next expression for the auxiliary field in the layer: p * (r, r0 ) =
2Qq[u (τ 0 )ν (τ ) − ν 0 (τ 0 )u (τ )] exp(−ik1 x sin θ ) , u (τ 0 )[ν ' (τ 1 ) + qν (τ 1 )] − ν (τ 0 )[u ' (τ 1 ) + qu (τ 1 )]
(4.38)
where Q = exp(ikr0 − ik1h cos θ ) / 4πr0 , q = ik1 H cos θ , H = (bk 02 ) −1 / 3 ,
τ 0 = H 2 ( k12 sin 2 θ − k02 ) , τ1 = τ 0 − h / H , τ = τ 0 − z / H , u, ν, u′, and ν′ are the Airy functions and their first derivatives and θ is the angle between the axis z and the radius-vector r0.
100 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
Substituting expression (4.38) into expression (4.37), we obtain an expression for the sound pressure p(r0) in the observation point r0, p(r0 ) =
2iωmAQqE (θ ) × u (τ 0 )[ν ' (τ 1 ) + qν (τ 1 )] − ν (τ 0 )[u ' (τ 1 ) + qu (τ 1 )]
(4.39) α 0 S − ∆ (α / C p ) S − ν (τ ) α 0 S − ∆(α / C p ) S . u(τ 0 ) 1 3 0 2 4 C C µ µ p0 p0 Here F (θ ) = ∫
∞
∞
∫ I ( x, y ) exp(ik1x sin θ )dxdy,
−∞
∞ ζ − S1 = ν (τ 0 − ζ / µH )e dζ , S 2 = u(τ 0 − ζ / µH )e −ζ dζ , 0 0
∫
∫
∞
∞
0
0
S3 = ∫ ζν (τ 0 − ζ / µH )e −ζ dζ , S4 = ∫ ζu(τ 0 − ζ / µH )e −ζ dζ .
It is very difficult to analyze expression (4.39) in a general form. At the beginning let us consider a simplified version of this expression. We have to note that, for example, in the case of water, the ratio α/Cp changes essentially with temperature. Thus, α/Cp = 6.6⋅10−12 g/erg at 25°C but α/Cp = 2.0⋅10−12 g/erg at 10°C. The change of sound velocity is only 3% in this case. Therefore, let us consider first the effect of the change of the ratio α/Cp on the sound field assuming the sound velocity constant within the whole half-space. A corresponding expression for the sound field we obtain directly from expression (4.37) by substitution of the auxiliary solution in the form of the sum of incident plane waves and plane waves reflected by the free surface into it, and taking into account the factor exp(ik1r0)/4πr0, p(r0 ) = ωmA
exp(ik1r0 ) α0 µk1 cosθ × F (θ ) 2 2 2 2πr0 µ + k cos θ C p0 1
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
∆(α / C p ) µ 1 − 2 . α 0 / C p µ 2 + k 2 cos2 θ 1
101
(4.40)
One can see from expression (4.40) that the maximum sound amplitude in a certain direction is observed at µ = k1cosθ, i.e., as in the case of thermoradiation generation of sound in a homogeneous half-space. It is natural to compare the sound field described by expression (4.40) with the acoustic field generated in a homogeneous half-space p0(r0). An expression for p0(r0) is well known, and the ratio p(r0)/p0(r0) can be written down in the form, ∆(α / C p ) p(r0 ) α C p1 µ , 1− 2 = 0 p0 (r0 ) C p 0 α1 α 0 / C p 0 µ 2 + k 2 cos 2 θ 1
(4.41)
where α1 and Cp1 are the values of the corresponding liquid parameters in the homogeneous part of the half-space. If the value of α/Cp decreases with depth α0/Cp0 > α1/Cp1, then ratio (4.41) is larger than one and naturally, as follows from general physical concepts, the presence of an inhomogeneous layer in this case leads to an increase of the amplitude of the sound field generated by modulated penetrating radiation. Analyzing expression (4.41) we can note the following. At certain values of µ, k1, and ω the increase of amplitude of sound field is a maximum at θ = 0, i.e., in the propagation direction of the beam of penetrating radiation, and the amplitude decreases as the observation angle θ grows. Thus, the presence of an inhomogeneous layer changes the shape of the directivity pattern of the sound field to some extent. However, if the value of the ratio α/Cp changes little at the characteristic size of the region of action of sound sources 1/µ, the square bracket in expression (4.41) differs little from one and sound generation occurs in the same way as in a homogeneous liquid half-space with the parameters α0 and Cp0. The last is evident from physical considerations. Let us turn again to analysis of expression (4.39), which must be performed numerically. In this case we restrict ourselves to consideration of not too “gliding” observation angles. Let us note first that as calculation shows, it is possible to use the relation µ ≈ k1 in order to determine the optimum generation mode to good precision. The validity of this relation was demonstrated for a homogeneous liquid half-space. Let us estimate the effect of change of sound velocity on the amplitude of generated acoustic field for the values µ ≈ k1, i.e., for generation modes close to the optimal one. It turns out that if the sound velocity decreases
102 THERMORADIATION EXCITATION: INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM
with depth, the field amplitude in these directions increases to some extent, the maximum increase being attained in the direction of the beam of penetrating radiation, i.e., at θ = 0. However, the relative increase of amplitude is about several percent. If the sound velocity increases with depth, the amplitude of acoustic field in the indicated directions decreases, being attenuated most significantly at θ = 0, while the relative value of this decrease is also about (c1 – c0)/c0. These effects are almost independent of the layer thickness and determined only by the difference of sound velocities at the layer boundaries, which mainly follows from general physical concepts connected with the particular features of sound propagation in a homogeneous medium. Finally, if the sound velocity decreases with depth, then a certain “critical” angle of observation exists. In the case of observation angles larger than this “critical” one, the sound field is practically absent. The critical angle is determined by the condition τ0 = 0 or sinθ = c1/c0. Directivity patterns calculated according to expressions (4.39) and (4.40) are given in Fig. 4.6 in order to illustrate this. Directivity patterns have been calculated for the case of laser excitation of sound and the Gaussian distribution of light intensity in a laser beam.
Figure 4.6 Directivity pattern of a thermooptical sound source in a liquid half-space. (1) A homogeneous half-space with the parameters of liquid α1, Cp1, and c1; (2) the ratio α/Cp changes in a surface layer of liquid; (3) the ratio α/Cp and the sound velocity change in the surface layer.
The next parameters have been taken for calculation: µ = 3 cm−1, α/Cp0 = 6.6⋅10−12 g/erg, α1/Cp1 = 2⋅10−12 g/erg, k0 = 3 cm−1, k1 = 3.08 cm−1, h = 30 cm and the radius of the light spot at the liquid surface a = 0.4 cm. The
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
103
observation angle is counted off from the vertical axis, where the absolute value of sound pressure p(r0) normalized to the value (ωmAα0/2πr0Cp0)P is indicated, where P is the power of laser radiation. Thus, the change of the ratio α/Cp0 with depth in the surface layer of a liquid affects essentially the amplitude and shape of the directivity pattern of the sound field generated due to absorption of modulated penetrating radiation in a liquid if this ratio changes noticeably within the characteristic dimensions of the region of sound generation. The change of sound velocity with depth affects the amplitude of generated sound field weakly for all observation angles except for the angles larger than the critical one, when the field is almost nonexistent. The latter follows also from general physical considerations. Indeed, the amplitude of sound pressure is directly proportional to the Grueneisen parameter of a liquid Γ = αc2/Cp. If c = c0(1 + ε), where ε << 1 and c0ε is a small addition to sound velocity, then Γ = αc0(1 + 2ε)/Cp, i.e., the change of the amplitude of sound field is proportional to ε << 1.
CHAPTER 5
Excitation of Sound in a Liquid by Radiation Pulses Excitation of sound by radiation pulses is especially interesting since large radiation power (and therefore, high efficiency of radiation-acoustic (optoacoustic) conversion) and acoustic pulses of large amplitude may be produced in the process of operation of accelerators and lasers in a pulsed mode. Many theoretical and experimental papers have been devoted to the study of the process of thermooptical generation of sound by laser pulses. First theoretical papers (see for example [200, 215]) considered onedimensional problems, and it is not surprising that in many cases the sound pulses observed experimentally differed in their shape from the ones predicted theoretically. For example, Hunter and Jones [220] tried to explain this discrepancy by the nonlinear effects taking place in the process of generation and propagation of sound pulses in liquids. In this connection, attempts were made to solve nonlinear equations of hydrodynamics numerically [204]. However, as detailed theoretical studies demonstrated [109, 110], in the case of small density of optical energy in a medium the linear theory describes the real process of sound generation by laser pulses correctly, and the data obtained theoretically agree well with the results of previous experiments including the data obtained by Hunter and Jones [220] and special experiments [75, 90, 91, 93]. Further we consider the laws of sound generation by radiation (laser) pulses in a liquid. The major attention will be given to the characteristics of sound pulses in the far wave field. We should note that we mean pulses of laser radiation, γ-quanta, X-rays, relativistic electrons, and synchrotron 105
106
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
radiation, i.e., the cases when radiation absorption in a medium is described by an exponential law. The conclusions are valid also for pulses of other kinds of penetrating radiation with some exceptions, which we consider in Chapter 7.
1. SOUND GENERATION IN A LIQUID BY RECTANGULAR PULSES OF RADIATION Let us consider the far sound field generated in a liquid half-space by rectangular pulses of radiation and analyze the dependence of the shape and duration of signals on the characteristic parameters in the case of “long” and “short” laser pulses [109]. Let a radiation pulse of the duration τ be incident from the air along the axis z upon the boundary of a liquid halfspace z > 0 (Fig. 5.1). The field of sound pressure in a liquid is described by an inhomogeneous wave equation,
∆p −
1 ∂2 p c
2
∂t
2
=
α ∂Q , C p ∂t
(5.1)
where the power density of thermal sources is determined by the expression, Q( x, y, z , t ) = AµI ( x, y )e − µz [Θ(t ) − Θ(t − τ )] ,
(5.2)
and Θ(t) is the Heaviside function. We perform the Fourier transformation with respect to time and obtain an inhomogeneous reduced wave equation, (∆ + k 2 ) F [ p] = −
α Cp
µI ( x, y ) exp(− µz )[1 − exp(iωτ )] ,
(5.3)
where F[p] is the spectrum of sound pressure, k = ω/c is the wave number, and ω is the circular frequency. As usual, we take the Gaussian distribution of penetrating radiation intensity over the cross-section of a particle or laser beam, I(x, y) = I0exp(−ρ2/a2), where ρ = (x2 + y2)1/2 and a is the effective radius of the beam. Under these assumptions and in the case of a free plane boundary, the solution of equation (5.3) is given by the formula,
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
a 2 k 2 sin θ iI µα e ikR a 2 k cos θ exp − F[ p] = − 0 2C p R µ 2 + k 2 cos 2 θ 4
107
× (5.4)
(1 − e ), iωt
where R = (x2 + y2 + z2)1/2 and θ is the angle between the axis z and the direction to the observation point (x, y, z).
Figure 5.1 Correlation of problem parameters in the scheme of pulsed thermoradiation generation of sound in a liquid.
The sound pressure characterized by spectrum (5.4) is given by the expression,
p ( x, y , z , t ) = −
iI 0αµa 2 c 4πC p R cos θ
∞
∫
−∞
exp[(− a 2 k 2 sin 2 θ ) / 4]
µ 2 cos 2 θ + k 2
{exp[ik ( R − ct )] − exp[ik ( R − ct + cτ )]}kdk .
× (5.5)
After integration of expression (5.5) (see [21], p. 74 (26)), we obtain the next formula for the sound pressure generated by a radiation pulse of rectangular shape:
p ( x, y , z , t ) =
s 2 R / c − t I 0αa 2 Erfc s − R / c − t − exp exp − 2 4 8C p Rτ µ τ τ a µ
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
108
R/c −t Erfc s + R / c − t − exp − R / c − t + τ − exp τµ τa τµ 2 s R / c − t +τ Erfc − τa 2
R / c − t +τ + exp τµ
×
Erfc s + R / c − t + τ 2 τa
(5.6)
,
where
τ cos θ a sin θ ,τ = , s = a = µa tan θ , τ a = µc c τµ and ∞
Erfc( x) = 2 π ∫ exp(−t 2 )dt x
is the complementary error function. It follows from formula (5.6) that the basic parameters determining the shape of a sound pulse in a liquid are the length of penetrating radiation pulse τ, the characteristic delay time of sound from elementary thermal sources located in the horizontal section of the region of sound generation τa, which is determined by the effective radius of the beam a, the characteristic delay time of sound from elementary thermal sources located in the vertical section of the region of sound generation τµ, which is determined by the efficient radiation length or the length of light absorption in a liquid 1/µ, and the ratio s = τa/τµ (Fig. 5.1). Relative levels of sound pulses calculated according to formula (5.6) are given in Fig. 5.2a and b. According to them we can judge the characteristic features of pulse shapes according to the relation between the problem parameters. If the length of laser pulse is large, i.e., τ >> τa, τµ, then the shape of a sound pulse is determined mainly by the value of τ (Fig. 5.2a) and depends weakly on the parameter s. If τ << τa (Fig. 5.2b), i.e., in the case of short pulses of penetrating radiation, the shape of sound pulses depends strongly on the characteristic times τa and τµ and their ratio s. The amplitude of sound pressure decreases as the parameter s grows. Let us analyze the dependence of the shape of a sound pulse on the parameter s = τa/τµ in more detail. Let us consider the limiting values of the parameter s.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
109
Figure 5.2 Relative levels of sound pressure in water in the cases of “large” (a) and “small” (b) length of radiation (laser) pulse τ for three observation angles. (a) τ = 5 µs; (b) τ = 0.05 µs; θ = 30°, 45°, and 60° (curves 1 – 3, respectively); γ* = (ct – −1 R)/l, l is the unit length; µ = 5 cm and a = 0.1 cm.
110
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
Let s >> 1 that corresponds to the region of thermal sources in the form of a flat disk or to observation under large angles θ. In this case the expression under the integral in formula (5.5) decreases exponentially as frequency grows and may be ignored at k >> 2/(a sinθ ). Therefore, we can ignore the quantity k2 as against µ2/cosθ in the denominator of the integrand. Integrating (see [21], p. 73 (19)) we obtain an expression for sound pressure at s >> 1 in the form R/c −t 2 p ( x, y , z , t ) = ( R − ct ) exp − 2 2 π C p Rs sin θ τ a2 I 0αc
− (5.7)
R / c − t + τ 2 . ( R − ct + cτ ) exp − 2 τa Sound pulses determined by expression (5.7) are close to the ones given by curves 3 in Fig. 5.2a and b. The pulse shape is determined by the characteristic times τ and τa in this case. In the case of small τ satisfying the condition cτ τ = << 1 , τ a a sin θ expression (5.7) becomes even simpler and takes on the form
p ( x, y , z , t ) =
R/c −t 2 exp − 2 τ a2 2 π C p Rs sin θ I 0αc 2τ
R/c−t 2 . ⋅ 2 2 τ a
(5.8)
The length of the pulse of negative excessive pressure (the distance between zero points in the curve) and the time interval between the peaks of positive excessive pressure (the distance between the symmetrical peaks in the curve) can be estimated readily for the pulses determined by expression (5.8) (Fig. 5.2b, curve 3). They are equal to 21/2τa and 61/2τa, respectively. Therefore, in the case of short radiation pulses and under the condition s >> 1 the shape and length of sound pulses are determined completely by the characteristic time τa. The pressure amplitude is inversely proportional to the parameter s.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
111
If s >> 1, which corresponds to the region of thermal sources in the shape of a narrow cylinder or to observation under small angles θ, then the decrease of the integration element in expression (5.5) with growth of frequency is determined by the denominator, and for k >> µ/cosθ the integration element becomes close to zero. Therefore, the exponent in the integration element can be changed to one. Integration gives an expression for sound pressure in the case s << 1,
p ( x, y , z , t ) =
I 0αa 2 2C p Rτ µ
R / c − t exp − τµ
sign ( R − ct ) − (5.9)
R / c − t +τ exp − τµ
sign( r − ct + cτ ) .
Expression (5.9) can be obtained also directly if we proceed to the limit s → 0 in formula (5.6). In this limiting case, the length of negative pressure pulse is equal to the length of the laser pulse τ (Fig. 5.2b). In the case of small τ satisfying τ /τµ = µcτ /cosθ << 1, expression (5.9) takes on the form,
p ( x, y , z , t ) =
I 0αa 2 2C p Rτ µ
R / c − t exp − τµ
sign ( R − ct ) − (5.10)
R/c−t exp − τµ
sign( R − ct + cτ ) sign( R − ct + cτ ) + τ . τ µ
The sound pulse determined by formula (5.10) is presented basically by a pulse of negative excessive pressure with the length τ (Fig. 5.3, curve 2). We have to note that expression (5.9) is exact for the direction along the axis z (the axis of the laser beam). Thus, on the basis of the conducted analysis of solution (5.6) and its limiting cases, we can separate the next characteristic features of the sound field generated in a liquid with an even boundary by laser pulses. If the length of a radiation pulse is large in comparison with the characteristic times τa and τµ, i.e., τ >> τa, τµ, the length of a sound pulse is determined by the length of a radiation pulse independently of the change of the observation angle θ and the ratio of the characteristic times s. In this
112
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
case the pressure amplitude decreases as the observation angle (i.e., the parameter s) grows.
Figure 5.3 Levels of sound pressure (relative) in water at s << 1. (1) τ = 13 µs, µ = 5 cm−1; (2) τ = 0.05 µs, µ = 1 cm−1.
In the opposite case of short pulses of penetrating radiation, if the condition τ << τa, τµ is satisfied, the length of sound pulse changes strongly with the change of observation angle depending on the value of s. In the case of small θ (s << 1), the length of sound pulse is determined by the value of τ, the sound pulse being presented basically by a pulse of negative excessive pressure, while in the case of large θ (s >> 1), it is determined by the characteristic time τa. In the latter case the amplitude of sound pressure decreases as the observation angle increases, and at large values of s, it is inversely proportional to this parameter.
Figure 5.4 Sound pulses detected experimentally by Hutcheson, Roth, and Barnes 3 −1 −1 [221] in the case of observation along the axis z. (1) µ = 10 cm , (2) µ = 5 cm , τ = 0.05 s.
It is interesting to note that sound pulses given in Fig. 5.3 coincide in their shape depending on the parameter τ/τµ with the pulses observed by Hutcheson, Roth, and Barnes [221] in the direction of the laser beam (Fig. 5.4). In particular, at τ/τµ = 7.5 a pulse given by curve 1 in Fig. 5.4 was
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
113
observed experimentally. This pulse coincides in its shape with curve 1 in Fig. 5.3. At τ/τµ = 4⋅10−8 a negative pressure pulse was observed given by curve 2 in Fig. 5.4 and coinciding in its shape with curve 2 in Fig. 5.3. Hutcheson, Roth, and Barnes noticed the discrepancy in the shape of the pulses obtained experimentally and the shape of the pulses predicted theoretically by Chia-lun Hu [210] and Gournay [215] and erroneously attributed this discrepancy to nonlinear effects. In fact, as has been noted earlier, the discrepancy is connected with the fact that Chia-lun Hu [210] and Gournay [215] have considered only onedimensional problems of optical generation of sound waves. Naturally, the solution of one-dimensional problems cannot describe real spatial sound fields in the presence of a boundary. The coincidence of experimental data obtained by Hutcheson, Roth, and Barnes [221] with the results of the solution of the boundary problem of optical generation of sound by radiation (laser) pulses considered here (see [109]) is evidence of the validity of a linear approximation for description of processes of thermoradiation (optical) generation of sound. Experimental and theoretical results will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 10.
2. A LIQUID WITH A ROUGH SURFACE Let us extend the solution obtained above to the case of a rough surface of a liquid [109]. Let the boundary be described by the equation z = ζ(x, y, t), the velocity of boundary motion satisfying the condition max(τ , τ a , τ µ )
∂ζ << g , ∂t
i.e., we can assume the liquid boundary to be motionless during the process of sound generation. As has been shown in Chapter 3, a spectrum of sound pressure averaged with respect to realizations of random surface ζ is represented by the product of the spectrum of sound pressure obtained for an even boundary by the characteristic function of distribution of height of unevennesses. In the case considered, averaging with respect to surface realizations can be equalized to averaging with respect to the number of pulses repeated with the period T during which the liquid surface changes its shape. For definiteness, we consider the normal distribution of heights of unevennesses, when the average spectrum of sound pressure has the form
114
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
iI αµa 2 e ikR k cosθ F [ p] = − 0 (1 − e iωt ) × 2 2C p R µ + k 2 cos 2 θ (5.11) k a sin θ k σ cos θ , − exp − 4 2 2 2
2
2 2
2
where σ is the mean-square height of waves. The inverse Fourier transform of spectrum (5.11) for determination of average sound pressure assumes integration with respect to frequency starting from zero, but expression (5.11) is true only for wave numbers k > ε, where ε is determined by the condition of the large scale of unevennesses with respect to the sound wavelength. However, it is possible to demonstrate that the error from the replacement of the lower limit of integration by zero is proportional to the squared ratio ε/µ and may be arbitrarily small in the case of corresponding restrictions for the dimensions of unevennesses. As a result we obtain the next formula for the sound pressure average with respect to pulses:
p =
s 2 R / c − t I 0αa 2 Erfc sσ − R / c − t − exp σ exp − 2 4 8C p Rτ µ τ µ τ aσ R/c−t Erfc sσ + R / c − t − exp 2 τµ τ aσ (5.12) R / c − t +τ exp − τµ
Erfc sσ − R / c − t + τ 2 τ aσ
+
R / c − t +τ exp τµ
Erfc sσ + R / c − t + τ 2 τ aσ
.
If sσ << 1 (s << 1), i.e., the effective radiation length or the length of light absorption is large in comparison with the mean-square height of unevennesses, the length of sound pulse is determined by the length of
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
115
radiation pulse τ, while in the case of small τ the sound pulse is presented basically by a negative peak. If sσ >> 1, i.e., the mean-square height of unevennesses is large in comparison with the effective length of absorption of penetrating radiation in a liquid, the shape and length of sound pulses are determined completely by the characteristic time τ (similar to the case of a plane boundary when for s >> 1 the shape and length are determined by the value of τa). In particular this is also true for observation along the axis of the radiation beam. We can determine the time-average intensity of pressure field for pulses repeated with period T. The pulse-average field intensity averaged with respect to period T is evidently the time-average intensity and it is represented by the next expression:
p
2
∞
2 2 2 ≡ p = ∫ F [ p] dω , T T 0
(5.13)
where 〈|F[p]|2〉 is the spectral power average with respect to surface realizations. Let us consider as an example the normal law of distribution of heights of unevennesses large in comparison with the sound wavelength, i.e., the case kσ >> 1. Using the results obtained in Chapter 3, Section 4 and taking into account the remarks on the inverse Fourier transform, it is possible to write down the time-average intensity:
p
2
1 I 0 µα = T C p R
2 a 4c ∞ 1 − cos(kcτ ) × cos 2 θ ∫ ( µ 2 / cos 2 θ + k 2 ) 2 0
(5.14) 2 ∆2 sin 2θ k 2 dk ρ0 exp − , 2 2 2 2 2 4(1 + ∆ cos θ ) 1 + ∆ cos θ 2
where ∆ = 21/2kaσ/ρ0 is the parameter of scattering and ρ0 is the correlation coefficient of boundary unevenness. As has been demonstrated in Chapter 3, Section 4, at ∆ << 1 (i.e., under the condition that the radius of radiation beam a is small in comparison with the correlation coefficient of boundary unevenness ρ0), we can ignore the
116
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
effect of boundary unevenness on the average intensity and use the results obtained for an undisturbed surface. Under the condition ∆ >> 1 (the radius of radiation spot at the liquid surface is comparable to the correlation coefficient of unevenness of liquid boundary or larger), the effect of unevenness on the average intensity of sound field is essential and we obtain the next formula for the time-average intensity:
p
2
=
π T
2 1 tan θ I 0α a 2c 1 exp− C p R 4µ cos θ tan 2 β 2 tan δ
2
× (5.15)
τ 1 − 1 + τ µ
exp − τ τµ
,
where tanβ = 21/2σ /ρ0 is the mean-square angle of surface slope. The average intensity of field (5.15) in the case of large radiuses of penetrating radiation beam (a/ρ0 ≥ 1) has an angular distribution. The angular width of the lobe of a polar directivity pattern is equal to 21/2β and determined by the mean-square angle of surface slope β. The average intensity depends essentially on the ratio τ/τµ: if the length of radiation pulse is small τ << τµ, the average intensity is proportional to the square of this parameter, and if τ ≥ τµ, it attains quickly the maximum value, which does not depend on this ratio.
3. RADIATION PULSES OF ARBITRARY SHAPE The influence of the parameters of penetrating radiation (laser beam) and a medium on the sound field generated by radiation pulses of rectangular shape in a liquid half-space with even and uneven boundaries, has been analyzed in detail in previous sections. The conclusions obtained are qualitatively true also for pulses of various triangular shapes [111]. In reality, the shapes of real radiation pulses (see [175]) can be only approximately represented by the simple functions of the models considered earlier. The examples are laser pulses in the Q-switch mode, which can be approximated by a rectangular function [109], and a triangular shape of pulses in the millisecond mode [175].
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
117
Now we will consider specific features of sound generation by radiation pulses of arbitrary shape with the following natural restrictions: a pulse is positive, the pulse envelope satisfies the existence condition of integrals and the convergence conditions of series obtained in the process of problem solution. It will be demonstrated that in the case when the length of radiation pulse is large in comparison with the delay time of sound from thermal sources in the horizontal section of the generation region, a pulse of sound pressure in the far wave field does not depend on geometrical parameters of generation region and is determined completely by the shape of penetrating radiation pulse. In the opposite case when the length of radiation pulse is small, the shape of sound pulse does not depend on the shape of radiation pulse and is determined by the ratio of characteristic delay times of sound from thermal sources in the horizontal and vertical sections of generation region. In this case the sound pulse is represented by a family of universal curves [110]. Let a beam of penetrating radiation be incident along the axis z at the boundary of a liquid half-space z > 0. Let the beam intensity at the liquid boundary be described by an expression, I ( x, y , t ) = I ( x, y ) f (t ),
(5.16)
where f(t) is the function of time, which determines the shape of a radiation pulse in such a way that max f(t) = 1, and I(x, y) is the surface distribution of radiation intensity at the boundary. The solution of the reduced wave equation for the spectrum of sound pressure generated by penetrating radiation may be written down in the form of an integral,
pω ( x, y, z ) =
1 4π
iAα ωµI ( x , y ) × p0 ( x, y, z; x1 , y1 , z1 ) − 1 1 Cp V1
∫
(5.17) exp( − µz1 ) F (ω )dV1 , where p0 is the solution of the diffraction problem for a point source, V1 is the volume occupied by thermal sources of sound, which are produced by the action of penetrating radiation, and ∞
F (ω ) =
∫ f (t ) exp(iωt )dt
−∞
118
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
is the spectrum of radiation pulse. A solution of the stationary problem for a liquid half-space with a free boundary can be obtained readily in the far wave field for a specific distribution of intensity I(x1, y1). Let us consider the Gaussian distribution of intensity as usual, I ( x1 , y1 ) = I 0 exp[−( x12 + y12 ) / a 2 ] , where a is the effective beam radius. In this case the spectrum of sound pressure has the form
pω = −
2 2 2 AI 0αa 2 e ikR ω τ µ e −ω τ a / 4 F (ω ) , 2C p R 1 + ω 2τ 2 µ
(5.18)
where R is the distance from the center of the region of thermal sources to the observation point, τµ = cosθ/(µc) and τa = a sinθ/c are the characteristic delay times of sound from elementary sources in the vertical and horizontal sections of the region of thermal sources, respectively, θ is the angle between the axis z and the direction to the observation point, and c is the sound velocity. An expression for sound pressure is obtained by the inverse Fourier transform of spectrum (5.18),
p=−
∞
κ 2s2 exp − 4 4πC p Rτ µ2 − ∞ AI 0αa 2
∫
κ2 κ exp(iκγ ) F τµ 1+ κ 2
dκ ,
(5.19)
where the substitution κ = ωτµ, γ = (R/c – t)/τµ, and s = τa/τµ is performed. Expression (5.19) is the initial one for further analysis. Let us determine now the characteristic features of acoustic field without setting a specific shape of radiation pulse or its spectrum. Let τ be the length of radiation pulse, which is determined in a certain way, e.g., according to the drop of pulse envelope, the portion of energy contained in a pulse, etc. Let us represent the integral in expression (5.19) in the form of the sum of two integrals,
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
p=−
∞ κ 2s2 AI 0αa 2 − exp 2 ∫ 4 4πC p Rτ µ − ∞
exp(iκγ ) F κ τµ
119
dκ − (5.20)
∞
κ 2s2 κ ∫ exp − 4 exp(iκγ ) F τ µ −∞
dκ . 1+κ 2
The spectral width of functions in the integration element in expression (5.20) can be determined in the following way: the upper frequency limit for the spectrum of radiation pulse F(ω) is obtained on the basis of a known relationship [182] ω = c1/τ, the upper limiting frequency for the exponential function exp(−κ2s2/4) is ω = c2/τ, and the frequency limit for the rational function 1/(1 + κ2) is ω = c3/τµ, where c1, c2, and c3 are the constants depending on the way of determination of the spectrum width and the width of radiation pulse. Thus, depending on the relation of the characteristic parameters of the problem (τ, τa, τµ), some function under the integral determines the character of the drop of spectral density. Let us consider the limiting relationships τ >> τa and τ << τµ, which mean that the delay time of sound from elementary sources in the crosssection of the generation region is very small or very large, respectively in comparison with the length of radiation pulse. Let τ >> τa, i.e., we consider the region of thermal sources in the form of a narrow cylinder or radiation along the directions close to the axis z. Under this condition we may assume that the exponent exp(−κ2s2/4) in expression (5.20) is equal to one within the frequency range, where the spectrum of a pulse of penetrating radiation is essential, and write down an expression
p=−
∞ AI 0αa 2 κ R τ f t F − − ∫ 2 µ τ c 4πC p Rτ µ −∞ µ
exp(iκγ ) dκ . 1 + κ 2
(5.21)
The second integral can be estimated for the cases τ >> τµ and τ << τµ, i.e., for different limiting relationships of the length of radiation pulse and delay time of sound from elementary sources in the longitudinal section of generation region. If τ >> τµ, i.e., the drop rate of spectral density in integral (3.6) determines the spectrum of a pulse of penetrating radiation F(ω), the rational function can be expanded in a series and integrated:
120
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
∞
κ ∫ F τ µ −∞
∞ ∞ R exp(iκγ ) (−1) n κ 2n dκ = τ µ2n +1 f 2n t − . ∑ ∑ c n=0 n=0
Let us assume as has been agreed earlier that the series converges with respect to the power of the parameter τµ /τ << 1 and restrict ourselves to the first two terms of the series. As a result, the sound pressure is represented by the following expression: p≈−
AI 0αa 2 R τ µ f ′′ t − , c 4πC p R
(5.22)
instead of expression (5.21). And if τ << τµ , i.e., the region of thermal sources has the shape of a long narrow cylinder, the spectrum of radiation pulse in the second integral can be represented under the condition ω < 1/τµ or ωτ < τ /τµ << 1 by the formula τ
τ
0
0
F (ω ) = ∫ f (t )e iωt dt ≈ ∫ f (t )dt = σ
(5.23)
(here σ is the “area” of radiation pulse). After that, an expression for sound pressure (5.21) takes on the form
p≈−
AI 0αa 2 4πC p Rτ µ
R πσ R exp − t − . f t − − c τµ c
(5.24)
Thus, in the considered case of radiation pulses long in comparison with the characteristic time τa or in other words, for narrow beams of penetrating radiation, the shape of a sound pulse does not depend on the parameter s and is determined completely by the envelope of radiation pulse f(t). In the case of radiation pulses long in comparison with τµ (i.e., long in comparison with all characteristic times of the problem), the shape of sound pulse is determined almost completely by the second derivative of the envelope of radiation pulse (5.22). In the case of radiation pulses short in comparison with τµ, a sound pulse is a rarefaction pulse repeating, in fact, the envelope of the “overturned” radiation pulse –f(t) with a certain positive addition
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
121
proportional to the small parameter τ/τµ (expression (5.24)). It is necessary to note that formula (5.21) is exact for θ = 0 and formulae (5.22) and (5.24) describe the field along the axis z. These laws were observed experimentally while investigating sound generation by laser pulses [220]. This consideration confirms the validity of the experimental data. In particular, the fact that in the case of short laser pulses (τ << τµ) a rarefaction pulse with length τ propagates along the axis z, is fundamental. Positive “splashes” preceding the rarefaction pulse and following it (as one can see from expression (5.24)) are also the features proper to this physical phenomenon and not distortions introduced by measuring devices as it might seem. Now let us consider the opposite case τ << τµ, i.e., the case of radiation pulses short in comparison with the delay time of sound from sources in the cross-section of the generation region. In this case the spectral density is limited to frequencies ω < 1/τa and consequently, ωτ < τ/τa << 1. Therefore, expression (5.23) is valid and an expression for sound pressure (5.20) takes on the form
p=−
∞ κ 2s2 AI 0αa 2σ exp − ∫ 4 4πC p Rτ µ2 − ∞
exp(iκγ )dκ − (5.25)
∞
κ 2s2 − exp(iκγ ) dκ . exp ∫ 4 1 + κ 2 −∞ Expression (5.25) can be integrated readily:
p=−
γ2 AI 0αa 2σ 4 exp − s2 16C p Rτ µ2 π s
2 − exp s 4
× (5.26)
s γ s γ e −γ Erfc − + eγ Erfc + , 2 s 2 s
122
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
where Erfc( z ) =
2
∞
2
−t ∫ e dt is the complementary error function.
π z Thus, as we can see from expression (5.26), in the case of a wide beam τ << τa, the shape of a sound pulse does not depend on the shape of radiation pulse and is determined only by the ratio of characteristic times s. Shapes of sound pulses determined by formula (5.26) are given in Fig. 5.5a and b (the coefficient before the curly bracket in expression (5.26) is assumed to be equal to one).
Figure 5.5 Shapes of a pulse of relative sound pressure. (a) A pulse determined by formula (5.26) for s = (1) 1.0 and (2) 5; (b) s >> 1, τ << τa.
Let us consider limiting cases. Let s >> 1, which corresponds to the region of thermal sources in the shape of a wide disk and observation under not too small angles θ. In this case the exponent is the determining function under the integral and sound pressure is given by the formula
p≈
2 2 2(t − R / c) − 1 exp − (t − R / c) π C p Rτ µ2 s 3 τ µ2 τ a2 AI 0αa 2σ
.
(5.27)
It is interesting to note that expression (5.2) turns into formula (5.8) in the particular case of a rectangular pulse and corresponding substitution of the quantity σ. If s << 1 which corresponds to the region of thermal sources in the shape of a long cylinder and observation under small angles θ, the exponent under the second integral in expression (5.27) can be considered equal to one. As a result we have
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
p≈−
(t − R / c) 2 AI 0αa 2σ 2 exp − 8C p Rτ µ2 s π τ a2
− s exp − t − R / c τµ
123
.
(5.28)
As one can see from expressions (5.27) and (5.28), the shape of sound pulse is universal for any envelope of a radiation pulse. In particular in the case s >> 1, τ << τa, sound pressure given by expression (5.27) is presented by a curve in Fig. 5.5b (the coefficient at the square bracket in expression (5.27) is assumed to be equal to one). Zeros and the points of extremum at the curve in Fig. 5.5b are completely determined by the value of τa (see Section 1). Only the amplitude of sound pulse depends on the envelope of radiation pulse. Thus, within the framework of the thermoradiation mechanism, sound pulses generated by radiation pulses of arbitrary shape obey the next laws in the far wave field. In the case of narrow radiation beams (τ >> τa) or observation along the axis z, the shapes of sound pulses do not depend on the ratio of characteristic times s and are determined completely by the envelopes of radiation pulses (see expressions (5.22) and (5.24)). However, in the case of short radiation pulses τ << τa or for long regions of generation, a sound pulse is presented mainly by a rarefaction pulse repeating the shape of a radiation pulse (expression (5.24)). In the case of wide beams of penetrating radiation (τ << τa) and observation under not too small angles, the shapes of sound pulses are absolutely independent of the envelopes of radiation pulses and are presented by a universal curve (Fig. 5.5b) depending on the ratio of the characteristic times s. Only the amplitude of sound pressure depends on the shape of a radiation pulse in this case (τ << τa). In the case of limiting values of s, we obtain universal formulae for sound pressure (5.27) and (5.28). The first of them determines the shape of a sound pulse according only to the characteristic time τa. The conditions of pairwise equality of characteristic times τ, τa, and τµ determine correspondingly the characteristic angles of the problem θ0 = arctan µa (s = 1), θ1 = arccos µcτ (τ = τµ), and θ2 = (arcsin cτ)/a (τ = τa). The next three cases are possible (see Fig. 5.6): (1) τ < τ0, (2) τ = τ0, and (3) τ > τ0, where τ0 = a/[c(1 + µ2a2)1/2. In the first case, formula (5.24) is valid for the angles θ < θ 2 (τa < τ1, τµ > τ), expression (5.28) is true for the angles θ 2 < θ < θ 0 (τa > τ, s < 1), and formula (5.27) is valid for the angles θ > θ 0 (τa > τ, s > 1). In the second case when θ 0 = θ 1 = θ 2, expression (5.24) is true for the angles θ < θ 0 (τ > τa, τ < τµ) and expression (5.27) is valid for θ > θ 0 (τ < τa, s > 1). In the third case at θ < θ 1 (τ > τa, τ < τµ), formula (5.24) is true, expression (5.22) is valid at θ 1 < θ < θ 2 (τ > τa, τ > τµ), and at θ > θ 2 (τ < τa, s < 1) expression (5.27) is true.
124
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
Figure 5.6 Ranges of application of expressions (5.22), (5.24), (5.27), and (5.28). (a) τ < τ0; (b) τ = τ0; and (c) τ > τ0. Digits in brackets are the numbers of expressions.
We have to note in conclusion that the conducted theoretical consideration can be extended to the case of a liquid with rough surface using the results obtained in Section 2 of this chapter.
4. NEAR WAVE FIELD OF THERMORADIATION PULSED SOURCE OF SOUND In the previous section we have discussed the characteristics of acoustic radiation far from the region of sound generation. Meanwhile, the situation when the track length of penetrating radiation in a liquid is large enough and detection of an acoustic signal occurs in the near wave field of a thermoacoustic source arising due to absorption of penetrating radiation in a liquid, is quite common. Such a case is considered in this section (see [190]). Let a beam of penetrating radiation be incident perpendicularly on the free surface of a liquid, and the radiation track length l = µ−1, where µ is the coefficient of radiation absorption in the liquid, be large compared with the radius of the beam cross-section a (l >> a). We assume that the intensity distribution of penetrating radiation is even (and not Gaussian as usual) over the cross-section. A cylindrical region emitting a sound wave due to thermal expansion is formed in the liquid under the action of radiation pulse (Fig. 5.7). Taking equality of sound pressure to be zero as the boundary condition at the free surface of a liquid, we can write down the solution of the wave equation of thermoradiation generation of sound in the form p=
1 α 4π C p
1 ∂Q(t − r1 / c, r ) dV − ∂t
∫ r1
V
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
−
1 α 4π C p
1 ∂Q(t − r2 / c, r ) dV . ∂t
∫ r2
V
125
(5.29)
We assume that the length of radiation pulse τ is so large that cτ >> a, and we can ignore the difference between the arrival times of signals from different points of the beam cross-section.
Figure 5.7 To calculation of the near wave field of a pulsed thermoradiation source. (1) A beam of penetrating radiation; (2) the surface of a liquid; and (3) a thermoradiation source.
Let us consider the characteristics of a sound field in the near wave field of the radiating region, i.e., at distances x << l2/λ = 1/(µ2cτ). In this case in the cylindrical system of coordinates r1 = ( z − z A ) 2 + x 2 and r2 = ( z + z A ) + x 2 (see Fig. 5.7). Taking also into account the fact that Q = ∂I/∂z, where I = I(t)exp(−µz) is the intensity of penetrating radiation, we obtain z 4 − µz z2 e µαs e − µz r1 r0 p= I t − dz − ∫ I t − dz . 4πC p ∫ r1 c r c z3 2 z1
(5.30)
Here s = πa2. It is necessary to know the function I(t) in order to calculate the integrals in formula (5.30). This function describes the time dependence of intensity of penetrating radiation. A typical experimental dependence in a laser pulse radiated in the free-running mode is given in Fig. 5.8a. Irregularity of the
126
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
pulse is caused by chaotic modulation of laser radiation. The envelope of such a pulse can be approximated by the formula I (t ) = 5.4 I m (t / τ ) exp(−2t / τ ) .
(5.31)
It is plotted in Fig. 5.8b. Here Im is the peak intensity connected with the total pulse energy E by the expression I = 0.74E/τs, which follows from the normalization requirement ∞
∫ Isdt = E .
0
Figure 5.8 Oscillogram of a laser pulse (a) and the plot of the function I/Im (b).
Figure 5.9. Time dependence of pressure in an acoustic signal in the observation point with the coordinates zA = 12 cm, xA = 10 cm. (a) µcτ = 22.5, τ’ = 0.01τ; (b) µcτ = 0.15, τ’ = 7.5τ; T = t /τ − t1/τ.
Formula (5.31) is true at t ≥ 0. We assume that I = 0 at t < 0. Correspondingly, integrating in expression (5.30), we have to take into consideration the fact that only those sections of the axis z, where the conditions t – r/c ≥ 0 are satisfied, make nonzero contributions. These conditions provide an opportunity to determine the limits on the integral. In the case xA/c ≤ t ≤ (xA2 + zA2)1/2/c only the first integral in expression (5.30) is nonzero, while z1 = zA − [(ct)2 − xA2]1/2, z2 = zA + [(ct)2 − xA2]1/2. If (xA2 + zA2)1/2/c ≤ t, the limits on integral are the following:
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
127
z1 = 0 , z 2 = z A + [(ct ) 2 − x 2A ]1 / 2 , z 3 = 0 , z 4 = [(ct ) 2 − x 2A ]1 / 2 − z A . Figure 5.9a gives the shape of an acoustic signal at the point with the coordinates xA = 10 cm, zA = 12 cm. This plot was obtained by numeric integration of expression (5.30) taking into account expression (5.31) under the condition cτ >> a, µcτ = 22.5. The acoustic signal at the point A starts at the moment t1 = xA /c when a compression wave from the closest region of sources arrives at this point. Then, at the moment t2 ≈ (xA2 + zA2)1/2 a rarefaction wave arrives. This wave is produced by addition of the pulse radiated by sources located in the vicinity of the point 0 and the wave reflected from the free surface. The rarefaction wave is added to the compression wave. Therefore, the pulse length depends on the difference of arrival times of the compression and rarefaction waves. This difference is determined by the relationship
τ ' ≈ t2 − t1 .
(5.32)
Oscillograms of an acoustic signal excited by a laser pulse in water and detected at the point with the coordinates xA = 10 cm, zA = 12 cm under the conditions corresponding to the calculation are given in Fig. 5.10a and b.
Figure 5.10 Oscillograms of an acoustic signal at the observation point with the coordinates zA = 12 cm, xA = 10 cm. (a) A signal in a wide frequency band; (b) a signal in a low frequency band.
The upper picture demonstrates a signal detected by a wide-band receiver. One can see that the acoustic pulse consists of a leading and a high-frequency component, which are specified by the spiking structure of
128
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
the laser pulse. The lower picture gives the low-frequency part of the signal separated by a filter. As one can see, the leading part of the pulse is similar to the theoretical dependence describing the shape of an acoustic pulse in the near wave field of a thermoacoustic array. If the distance from sound sources in the direction perpendicular to the axis of the laser beam grows, the difference between the arrival times of compression and rarefaction waves decreases and they eliminate each other. As the result of this process under the condition τ1 < τ′ << τ, where τ1 is the characteristic period of chaotic modulation, the leading low-frequency part of the signal vanishes and only the high-frequency component exists. An example of such a signal in a smaller time scale is given in Fig. 5.11. If the distance from the source in the transverse direction grows even more, the high-frequency component of the signal vanishes also at distances xA >> zA, where τ = 0.
Figure 5.11 Oscillogram of an acoustic signal close to the surface at xA > zA.
A different pattern is observed in the case when the difference of the arrival times of compression and rarefaction waves τ′ exceeds the characteristic length of a radiation pulse τ. Such situation may arise in the case of short radiation pulses or in the case of moving away from the observation point along the axis z. Figure 5.9b gives as an example the shape of an acoustic pulse at the same observation point as in Fig. 5.9a in the case of a shorter laser pulse when τ′ = 7.5τ. If the distance from the generation region increases, the amplitude of a leading pulse decreases proportionally to exp(−µz) and the amplitude of a closing pulse decreases proportionally to 1/(x2 + z2)1/2.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
129
If a medium is spatially inhomogeneous and its properties change noticeably at distances smaller than the value of cτ, the structure of an acoustic pulse at the observation point becomes even more complex. For example, let the properties of a medium at the depth z = H change in such a way that the parameter µαS/Cp increases. Then, an additional signal arises at the observation point at the time moment t = (xA2 + H2)1/2/c. The leading part of this signal is a compression wave with amplitude proportional to the degree of medium inhomogeneity. We should note in conclusion that the characteristic properties of the sound pulses excited by pulsed penetrating radiation in the near wave field of a thermoacoustic array can be revealed in the process of consideration of the next simplest one-dimensional model (see [141] and also [41, 210, 215]). Let the energy E be released in the spherical region of the radius R0 during the time τ. This leads to the increase of the volume V = (4π /3)R03 by the value ∆V =
Eα , ρC p
(5.33)
where as usual α is the cubical coefficient of thermal expansion of a medium, ρ is the medium density, and Cp is the specific heat capacity. If R0 >> cτ (c is the sound velocity), the region does not have time to expand during the time of energy release and pressure in the region increases by the value
p = ρc
2 ∆V
V
=
c 2 Eα . C pV
(5.34)
Thus, a spherical region of increased pressure arises in a medium at the initial moment. This leads to radiation of a spherical sound wave. The profile of such wave is given in Fig. 5.12a and the peak value of pressure is equal to a half of the initial excessive pressure multiplied by the ratio R0/r, which takes into account spherical divergence of the wave:
p=
PR0 3 Eαc 2 . = 2r 16π C R 2 r p 0
(5.35)
In this case the pressure amplitude is determined by the released energy and does not depend on its release rate, while the pulse length is determined
130
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
mainly by the travel time of sound over the disturbed region (the time of volume discharge) R0/c. If R0 << cτ, the dimensions of radiating region are small as against the characteristic length of sound wave cτ. In this case the calculation according to Lyamshev and Naugol’nykh [141] and Chia-lun Hu [210] leads to the following expression for the peak value of pressure: p=
3Eαc . 16πR0τC p r
(5.36)
This expression can be obtained with precision to a numeric coefficient from the expression p = ρV″/(4πr) if we take for estimation V′ ~ ∆V/τ, V ~ V′/R0. Thus, the pressure amplitude is determined in this case by the rate of energy release and the pulse length is determined by the time of energy release τ (see Fig. 5.12b).
Figure 5.12 Profile of a wave propagating from a thermal source. (a) R0 >> cτ; (b) R0 << cτ.
Thus, one can see from this discussion that a sound signal in the near wave field of a thermoacoustic array in a liquid with a free surface has a characteristic form, i.e., the form or shape of a so-called N-wave. Specific properties of sound signals in the near wave field of a laser thermoacoustic source of sound were discussed in detail by Burmistrova et al. [44] and Karabutov, Rudenko, and Cherepetskaya [106].
5. SOUND GENERATION IN A LIQUID WITH GAS BUBBLES Let us consider one more specific example of formation of an acoustic signal under the effect of pulsed penetrating radiation. We will discuss the specific features of thermoradiation generation of sound in a liquid with gas bubbles.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
131
Bubbles are always present in real liquids and in water in particular. Therefore the question of the effect of bubbles on thermoradiation excitation of sound in a liquid with bubbles can be of certain practical interest. We will not use the discussed earlier results of general consideration of processes of thermoradiation excitation of sound in inhomogeneous media but following Egerev and Naugol’nykh [94], we will consider this problem proceeding from general physical concepts. Let a flow of penetrating radiation be incident normally from a transparent medium on the plane boundary of a liquid. Let the beam diameter be large enough in comparison with the “radiation” length in a liquid l so that an arising sound wave may be considered as a plane one. We assume that penetrating radiation has the form of rectangular pulses of intensity I and length τ. It is known that the process of sound generation has certain differences in the cases cτ < l and cτ > l in the sense that the first of them corresponds, as it were, to the problem with the initial conditions, and the second one corresponds to the problem with the boundary conditions. In particular, in the case of short radiation pulses (cτ < l), the excessive pressure P arises as a result of energy evolution in a liquid. This pressure is proportional to the increase of the volume ∆V of the region of heat discharge, which is caused by the effect of thermal expansion P = ρc 2V −1dV .
(5.37)
Here ρ is the liquid density, c is the sound velocity in the liquid, V = lS is the volume of the medium where energy is released, S is the sectional area of a radiation beam, ∆V = αE / ρC p ,
(5.38)
where α is the coefficient of thermal expansion, E = IτS is the energy of radiation pulse, and Cp is the specific heat capacity. If the medium-liquid interface is transparent and acoustically rigid, the energy absorbed in the medium region V is radiated in the form of a compression pulse with amplitude proportional to the energy of radiation pulse [110]:
p=
P ρc 2 ∆V c 2 Eα , = = 2 2 V 2lSC p
(5.39)
and its length is determined by the travel time of sound over the region of energy release T = l/c.
132
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
In the case of long pulses (cτ > l), continuous generation of sound from the liquid volume V occurs in the process of absorption of penetrating radiation, and the pressure in a sound wave is determined by the expansion rate of the region V, which is proportional to the intensity of penetrating radiation [110], p = ρcV = ρc
∆V αIc . = Sτ Cp
(5.40)
The coefficient of thermal expansion in liquids is small and therefore, the intensity of generated sound can change strongly in the presence of a large amount of gas bubbles affecting noticeably the degree of expansion of a heated volume. The effect of bubbles is determined mainly by their size and concentration in the volume absorbing penetrating radiation. Small bubbles, which are always present in liquids, influence under real conditions the process of thermoradiation generation of sound. This effect plays an essential role even at very small concentrations of bubbles and small (in comparison with the heat of vaporization) density of released energy, when penetrating radiation scattering (caused by bubbles) from the region of energy release is negligible, and the increase of pressure of gas and vapor in a bubble resulting from its heating is small. It is caused by a strong change of compressibility of a liquid containing gas bubbles. Large bubbles have a low resonance frequency f0 and during the time of radiation energy release τ, they behave as incompressible ones. This makes a medium apparently more rigid in the region of heat evolution and increases the amplitude of acoustic pulse. Small bubbles (f0 >> 1/τ) have enough time to change their volume under the effect of increasing pressure and by virtue of large compressibility of gases as against compressibility of liquids, the pressure in an emitted compression wave decreases. The degree of bubble compression may be determined from the energybalance equation: the work of external pressure on a bubble A is equal to the increase of internal energy of gas in a bubble W. The quantity A is expressed by the formula, A = ( P0 + P)(V0 − V1 ) ,
(5.41)
where P is the excessive pressure in a compression wave, which is determined by formulae (5.37) and (5.38), V0 and V1 are the initial and final values of the bubble volume, and P0 is the hydrostatic pressure. The value of W for an adiabatic process is equal to
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
W =
QV0 V0 γ − 1 V1
γ −1
− 1 ,
133
(5.42)
where Q is the initial gas pressure in a bubble and γ is the adiabatic exponent. Equating expressions (5.41) and (5.42), we obtain an equation for determination of the degree of bubble compression z = V0/V1 in the form ( P0 + P)(γ − 1) z γ − z . = Q z −1
(5.43)
If the change of the radius of each bubble is small, i.e., z = 1 + ε, where ε << 1 and bubbles are not very small such that it is possible to ignore the surface tension forces, equation (5.43) leads to the simple result
ε = 2 P /(γQ) .
(5.44)
Expression (5.44) is true if the temperature wavelength in a gas Λ = (4πχτ)1/2 is small compared with the bubble radius R0 (here χ is the temperature conductivity). In the opposite case (Λ > R0), the process of bubble compression is isothermal and we have to take γ = 1 in the expression for ε. Now it is possible to determine the amplitude of a sound wave emitted in a liquid with bubbles. Let M be the volume of gas phase in the generation zone. Then, the change of this volume under the effect of excessive pressure at moderate values of intensity of penetrating radiation is Mε. Thus, the absorbing volume increases by the value ∆V – Mε. Let cτ << l. Using formula (5.39), we obtain an equation pc =
1 2 ∆V − Mε ρcc . 2 V
Taking into account expressions (5.38) and (5.44), we obtain
pc =
αEcc2 1 . 2 SC p l 1 + ρcc2 n / γQ
(5.45)
134
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
Here n = M/V is the volume concentration of gas and cc is the sound velocity in a two-phase medium: cc ≈
2πf 0 ( 2πf 0 ) 2 − 3nc 2 / R02
.
And if cτ >> l, then using formulae (5.38), (5.40), and (5.44), we obtain pc = ρcc
∆V − Mε . Sτ
It follows from here that pc = αcc I
1 C p (1 + ρcc ⋅ 2nl / τγQ)
.
(5.46)
The dependence of the amplitude of acoustic pressure in a wave emitted from the generation zone on the volume concentration of gas bubbles n for cτ << l and cτ >> l is plotted in Fig. 5.13 (it is assumed that f0 >> 1/τ in both cases). The values of pc are normalized to the amplitude of acoustic pressure p in a single-phase liquid to make the plot more illustrative. The next values of constants are taken: 1/l = 0.18 cm−1 and c = 1.5⋅105 cm/s.
Figure 5.13 Dependence of sound pressure amplitude on the volume concentration of gas bubbles. (1) τ = 1 µs, short pulses; (2) τ = 1 µs, long pulses.
The plot illustrates the effect of bubbles on the process of generation of a compression pulse. One can see that the effect becomes noticeable if the concentration of small enough bubbles is not too small.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
135
Now let us consider the case when the action of penetrating radiation leads to generation of a wave, which has a rarefaction pulse together with a compression pulse. For example, let the energy E be released as the result of absorption of a radiation pulse in a spherical region of radius a during the time τ << a/c, where c is the sound velocity. This causes a fast increase of pressure by the value [44, 141]
P=
c 2αE , C pV
(5.47)
where V = (4/3)πa3. The rise of a region of increased pressure leads to radiation of an N-wave with the peak value at a distance from the center of generation zone determined by a relationship p = Pa/2r and the length determined by the time of sound travel over the disturbed region T = a/c (see Fig. 5.14a). In the process a discharge wave propagates inside the disturbed region from the zone of energy release. Its peak value at the point r < a is determined by the relationship p=−
Pa , 2 r
(5.48)
and the characteristic length is τ = 2r/c (Fig. 5.14b). As r decreases, the wave amplitude increases and the length decreases. A rarefaction region arises in the liquid. Bubbles in this region expand. The characteristic radius of a bubble attained as the result of action of the negative phase of the discharge N-wave can be estimated in the roughest approximation as follows. In the order of magnitude R = uτ ' ,
(5.49)
where u ≈ (∆p/ρ)1/2 is the rate of bubble expansion, τ′ ≈ 2r/c is the time of its expansion, ∆p is the difference of pressures inside and outside of a bubble, which causes its expansion, ∆p ~ Pa/2r. Substituting the values of τ′ and ∆p into expression (5.49), we obtain R = 2 Par /( ρc 2 ) .
(5.50)
136
EXCITATION OF SOUND IN A LIQUID BY RADIATION PULSES
As one can see, the maximum radius of a bubble arising under the action of a rarefaction wave decreases with the decrease of r since the duration of action diminishes.
Figure 5.14 Pressure profiles in (a) a radiated acoustic pulse and (b) discharge wave.
Taking for estimation the value of r at which the amplitude of rarefaction wave attains p = − P (r = a/2), we obtain R ≈ a P /( ρc 2 ) = a Eα /(VC p ρ ) .
(5.51)
For example, let the energy E = 10–2 J be released in water in the volume V = 1 cm3. Then, at α = 1.4⋅10−4 K−1 and Cp = 4.2 J/(g⋅K), we obtain the value of R = 2⋅10−3 cm, i.e., the nuclei present in a liquid can expand to a noticeable size. We have to stress that this estimation is based on the assumption of the absence of bubble interaction. We may assume that despite the sketchiness, the obtained results reflect correctly the main features of the phenomenon of sound generation by pulses of penetrating radiation in a liquid with gas bubbles. A more detailed consideration might be conducted on the basis of the reciprocity method and the theory of propagation of sound waves in a liquid with bubbles [114].
CHAPTER 6
Generation of Sound in Solids by Intensity-Modulated Penetrating Radiation Shear waves can propagate in solids together with longitudinal waves. Thermal (volumetric) sources of longitudinal waves arise under the action of penetrating radiation due to the thermoelastic mechanism of sound excitation. Shear waves result only from reflection of longitudinal waves from borders or their scattering by inhomogeneities. In practice, solids are always limited and both longitudinal and shear waves are always present in solids under the effect of penetrating radiation. Further we will consider specific features of generation of monochromatic acoustic waves in solids by intensity-modulated penetrating radiation.
1. BASIC EQUATIONS Let us write down the equation of thermoelasticity [168] for a homogeneous and isotropic solid, A 1 ∂2 4 ∆ − 2 2 Φ = 3 − 2 αT − 2 , сl ∂t n cl ρ 137
138 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
(3 − 4 / n 2 )αcl2T0 ∂Φ 1 ∂ Q ∆ − T − ∆ =− , ∂ ∂ χ χ χ t c t c ε ερ
(6.1)
2 ∆ − 1 ∂ Ψ = − M , ct2 ∂t 2 ct2 ρ
where Φ and Ψ are the scalar and vector potentials of the displacement vector of a solid u = grad Φ + rot Ψ, respectively, cl and ct are the propagation velocities of longitudinal and transverse sound waves, respectively, n = cl/ct, α is the linear thermal expansion coefficient of a solid, T is the difference of temperatures of a heated and unheated solid, T0 is the temperature of an unheated solid, χ is the thermal diffusivity, cε is the specific heat capacity of a solid, ρ is its density, Q is the quantity of heat released per unit time in unit volume, and A and M are the potential and solenoidal components of the external non-thermoelastic force F applied to unit volume of a solid (F = grad A + rot M). The first equation of system (6.1) is a wave equation for longitudinal waves. The sources of these waves are the change of solid volume caused by the change of solid temperature and the potential component of the non-thermoelastic volumetric force. The second equation of this system is the balance of heat. Its first term is a common diffusion term and the second one is present due to the change of solid temperature in the process of propagation of a longitudinal wave in it, and is called a dilatation term. The right-hand side of the second equation is the source of thermal energy. The third equation of the system is a wave equation for transverse waves. The source of these waves is the solenoidal component of the non-thermoelastic volumetric force. Now let us apply the operator ∆ – 1/∂t to the first equation of system (6.1) and change the right-hand side of the obtained equation according to the second equation of system (6.1). In the result we get a system of equations equivalent to system (6.1), 4 2 1 + 3 − ∆ − n2
=−
2 α T0
2 3 cl2 1 ∂ ∆ − 1 ∆ ∂ + 1 ∂ Φ = cε χ ∂t c 2 ∂t 2 χc 2 ∂t 3 l l
(3 − 4 / n 2 )αQ 1 ∂ A − ∆ − , χcε ρ χ ∂t c 2 ρ l
(6.2)
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
139
2 ∆ − 1 ∂ Ψ = − M . ct2 ∂t 2 ct2 ρ
The dilatation term (3 – 4/n2)2α2T0c02/cε lies within the limits 10−3 – 10−5 for the majority of substances, which provides grounds to ignore it further. Now basic equations of sound generation in solids by penetrating radiation take on the form 1 ∂2 1 ∂3 2 1 ∂ div u = ∆ − ∆ − ∆ + χ ∂t c 2 ∂t 2 χc 2 ∂t 3 l l =−
(3 − 4 / n 2 )α∆Q 1 1 ∂ ∆ − div F , − 2 χcε ρ χ ∂t cl ρ
(6.3)
2 ∆ − 1 ∂ rot u = − rot F . ct2 ∂t 2 ct2 ρ
If we ignore the influence of heat conductivity on sound generation in a solid (this question with respect to liquids was discussed earlier; see also [43]), equations (6.3) take the form 1 ∂2 (3 − 4 / n 2 )α div F u div , ∆ − = ∆Qdt − ∫ 2 2 2 cε ρ c ∂ t c ρ l l (6.4) 2 ∆ − 1 ∂ rot u = − rot F . ct2 ∂t 2 ct2 ρ
2. BOUNDARY CONDITIONS In the process of solution of boundary problems with the help of equations (6.4), the boundary conditions at the boundary surfaces are determined by the character of allowed displacements and stress at these surfaces. However, if we use equations (6.3), the situation becomes more complex
140 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
because of the presence of a thermal field in their solutions apart from the field of sound waves. In this connection, let us determine the character of the boundary conditions necessary for solution of corresponding boundary problems. Let us perform the Fourier transformation of equations (6.3) with respect to time: iω 3 iω A ω ω2 (3 − 4 / n 2 )α 2 iω Φω = − Qω − ∆ + , ∆+ ∆+ ∆ + 2 2 c χ χ ρ χ c 2 ρ ε cl cl l (6.5) 2 ∆ + ω ct2
Ψ = − M ω , ω ct2 ρ
where ω is the circular frequency and ∞
pω =
∫ p exp(iωt )dt
−∞
is the Fourier transform of the function p. Let us write down the Green function (for a free space) for the equation 2 iω iω 3 2 ω G = δ ( x, y , z ) . ∆ + ∆ + ∆ + 2 2 χ χ c c l l
(6.6)
Let us perform the Fourier transformation of equation (6.6) with respect to the coordinates x, y, z in order to do this. As a result we obtain the equation for the Fourier transform of G, (ω 2 / c 2 − iω / χ ) −1 (ω 2 / c 2 − iω / χ ) −1 l l G∗ = − + . 2 2 2 2 2 ω / cl − k x − k y − k z iω / χ − k x2 − k 2y − k z2
(6.7)
Here kx , ky , and kz are the components of the wave vector in the axes x, y, and z, respectively and
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
G∗ = ∫
141
∞
∫ ∫ G exp(−ik x − ik y − ik z )dxdydz
−∞
is the Fourier transform of the function G. The first term in the right-hand side of expression (6.7) is the Fourier transform of the Green function of a reduced wave equation with an additional factor – (ω2/cl2 − iω /χ), and the second term differs from the first one only in the sign and formal substitution of the quantity iω/χ instead of ω2/cl2 in the denominator. Therefore, the Green function of equation (6.6) for a free space has the form 2 iω ω G= − χ c2 l
−1
exp[i (ω / cl ) R] − exp[(i − 1) ω / 2 χ R] 4πR
,
(6.8)
where R = (x2 + y2 + z2)1/2 is the distance from the source to the observation point. The fact that the Green function of equation (6.6) represents two independent terms, one of them describing a sound wave and another one describing a thermal wave, is explained by neglecting the dilatation term. If we take into account the dilatation term, both parts of the Green function are interconnected, but such a bond must be small because of the smallness of the dilatation term. Thus, if we ignore dilatation (that is implied everywhere further), sound and thermal fields are independent of each other, and therefore, the boundary conditions may be determined independently for sound and thermal fields. Basically, we will consider characteristics of sound waves in the far wave field (the Fraunhofer field). Therefore, we will ignore the second term of the Green function (6.8) describing the thermal field decreasing with distance from the source much faster than the sound field.
3. METHOD FOR SOLUTION OF BOUNDARY PROBLEMS A technique based on the reciprocity principle, which provides an opportunity to write down the solutions of boundary problems in quadratures on the basis of the solution of an auxiliary diffraction problem, was used earlier for solution of boundary problems. This technique was
142 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
proposed by the author [131] and has been widely used in the theory of laser generation of sound [128]. Let us obtain analogous relationships for solids. The reciprocity relationship for solids can be written down in the following form [117]:
∫u
(1)
( x1 , y1 , z1 ; x, y, z )F ( x, y, z )dΩ =
Ω
(6.9)
∫ u( x, y, z; x1, y1, z1 )F
(1)
( x1, y1, z1 )dΩ1 ,
Ω1
where u(1)(x1, y1, z1; x, y, z) is the harmonic vector of displacements of a solid at the point x, y, z, which originates from the action of forces in the region Ω1; u(x, y, z; x1, y1, z1) is the harmonic vector of displacement of a solid at the point x1, y1, z1, which originates from the action of forces in the region Ω; and F(1)(x1, y1, z1) and F(x, y, z) are the harmonic bulk forces applied to the regions Ω1 and Ω. Now let us present the displacement vector and the bulk force in the form of the sum of potential and solenoidal components u = grad Φ + rot Ψ, F = grad A + rot M and rewrite the expressions obtained as the result of pairwise multiplication of the potential and solenoidal parts of the vector of bulk force: grad Φ ⋅ grad A = div [Φ ⋅ gradA] − Φ∆A , grad Φ ⋅ rot M = div [Φ ⋅ M ] , (6.10) rot Ψ ⋅ grad A = div [Ψ ⋅ grad A] , rot Ψ ⋅ rot M = div [Ψ ⋅ rot M ] + Ψ rot ⋅ rot M . In the processes of substitution of expressions (6.10) in reciprocity relationship (6.9) and integration over the volume, the terms containing the operator “div” transform into surface integrals and vanish by virtue of the boundary conditions. Therefore, reciprocity relationship (6.9) takes on the form,
∫ [Φ
Ω
(1)
( x1 , y1 , z1 ; x, y, z )∆A( x, y, z ) −
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
143
Ψ (1) ( x1, y1, z1; x, y, z ) rot rot M( x, y, z )]dΩ = (6.11)
∫ [Φ( x, y, z; x1, y1, z1)∆A
(1)
( x1, y1, z1 ) −
Ω1
Ψ( x, y , z; x1, y1, z1 ) rot rot M (1) ( x1, y1, z1 )dΩ1 . Now let the region Ω be located in the far wave field and the source of waves in it has a delta-like character: ∆A(x, y, z) = δ(x, y, z) and rot rot M(x, y, z) = γ1δ(x, y, z) + γ2δ(x, y, z) (γ1 and γ2 are the unit vectors in the incidence plane and the boundary plane). Then the transverse wave Ψ has two polarizations Ψ1 and Ψ2 in the planes of incidence and boundary, respectively. In this case the expressions for Φ(x, y, z; x1, y1, z1), Ψ1(x, y, z; x1, y1, z1), and Ψ2(x, y, z; x1, y1, z1) for a half-space can be presented in the next form: Φ (1) ( x, y, z; x1 , y1 , z1 ) = −
exp(ik l R) (exp Ql + V1 exp Pl ) − 4πR
exp(ikl R ) V2 exp Pl , 4πR (1)
Ψ1 ( x, y, z; x1 , y1 , z1 ) = −
exp(ik t R ) (exp Qt + V3 exp Pt ) − 4πR
exp(ikt R ) V4 exp Pt , 4πR (1)
Ψ2 ( x, y, z; x1 , y1 , z1 ) = −
exp(ik t R ) (exp Qt + V5 exp Pt ) , 4πR
Ql = −ik lx x1 − ik ly y1 − ik lz z1 , Pt = −ik tx x1 − ik ty y1 + ik tz z1 , Qt = −ik tx x1 − ik ty y1 − ik tz z1 , Pl = −ik lx x1 − ik ly y1 + ik lz z1 ,
(6.12)
144 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
where R = [(x1 – x)2 + (y1 – y)2 + (z1 – z)2]1/2; kl and kt are the wave vectors of longitudinal and transverse waves directed from the origin of coordinates to the point x, y, z; and V1, V2, V3, V4, and V5 are the reflection coefficients of plane waves from the boundary of a solid (in this case the boundary equation is z = 0) for a longitudinal wave in the case of incidence of a longitudinal wave, a transverse wave in the case of incidence of a longitudinal wave, a transverse wave polarized in the plane perpendicular to the boundary plane in the case of an analogous transverse wave, in the case of incidence of a transverse wave, and a transverse wave polarized in the boundary plane in the case of incidence of an analogous transverse wave, respectively. The coefficients of reflection of plane waves from the boundaries of a solid depend on the angle of wave incidence at the boundary and on the boundary form. Using a delta-like character of sources at the point x, y, z, expression (6.11) can be presented in the form Φ ( x, y, z ) − Ψ1 ( x, y, z ) − Ψ2 ( x, y, z ) =
∫ {Φ( x, y, z; x1, y1, z1 )A
(1)
( x1, y1, z1 ) −
Ω1
(6.13) Ψ1 ( x, y, z; x1, y1 , z1 )[ rot rot M (1) ( x1 , y1, z1 )]γ 1 − Ψ2 ( x, y , z; x1 , y1, z1 )[ rot rot M (1) ( x1, y1, z1 )]γ 2 }dΩ1 , where [rot rot M(1)(x1, y1, z1)]γ1 and [rot rot M(1)(x1, y1, z1)]γ2 are the projections of the vector rot rot M(1)(x1, y1, z1) at the planes of incidence and boundary, respectively. Dividing expression (6.13) in the only way according to the principle of different polarizations of displacement, we obtain the next expressions: Φ ( x1 , y1 , z1 ; x, y, z ) = −
exp(ik l R ) 4πR
∫ {[exp Ql + V1 exp Pl ] ×
Ω1
∆A (1) ( x1, y1, z1 ) + V4 exp Pt [ − rot rot M (1) ( x1, y1, z1 )]γ 1 }dΩ ,
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
Ψ1 ( x1 , y1 , z1 ; x, y, z ) = −
exp(ik l R ) 4πR
145
∫ {[exp Qt + V3 exp Pt ] ×
Ω1
(6.14) [ rot rot M (1) ( x1 , y1, z1 )]γ 1 + V2 exp Pl ∆A (1) ( x1 , y1, z1 )}dΩ1 , Ψ2 ( x1 , y1 , z1 ; x, y , z ) = −
exp(ik t R ) 4πR
∫ [exp Qt + V5 exp Pt ] ×
Ω1
[ − rot rot M (1) ( x1 , y1, z1 )]γ 2 dΩ1 . If we consider only the thermal mechanism of sound generation by penetrating radiation, sources of transverse waves are absent. Therefore, taking into account expression (6.8), we obtain for the Fourier transforms with respect to the times of potentials (omitting the index (1)), Φ ( x, y , z ) =
∫ g ( x, y, z; x1 , y1 , z1 )∆A( x1 , y1 , z1 )dΩ1 ,
Ω1
(6.15) Ψ1 ( x, y, z ) =
∫ h( x, y, z; x1 , y1 , z1 )∆A( x1 , y1 , z1 )dΩ1 ,
Ω1
where 2 iω ω g ( x, y, z; x1 , y1 , z1 ) = − − χ c2 l
−1
exp[i (ω / cl ) R] (exp Ql + V1 exp Pl ) , 4πR (6.16)
2 iω ω h( x, y, z; x1 , y1 , z1 ) = − − χ c2 l
−1
exp[i (ω / ct ) R] V2 exp Pl . 4πR
Let us write down in conclusion, basic equations of sound generation (we omit the factor exp(– iωt) in the case of harmonic oscillations):
146 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
ω2 ∆ + 2 cl
2 div F (3 − 4 / n 2 )α 1 − iωχ / cl i , u ∆Q − div = 2 2 4 ω 2 cε ρ c c ω χ ρ 1 / + l l
(6.17) 2 ∆ + ω ct2
rot u = − rot F . ρct2
We have to note also that it is convenient to consider sound fields in a solid in terms of the components of the strain tensor σik, which have the next form in spherical coordinates in the far wave field: ∂ 2Φ 2 ∂u σ RR , σ RR = ρcl2 R = ρcl2 , σ θϕ = 0 , σ θθ = σ ϕϕ = 1 − ∂R ∂R 2 n2 (6.18) 2 2 ∂uϕ ∂u ∂ Ψ1 ∂ Ψ2 = ρct2 , σ Rϕ = ρct2 , σ Rθ = ρct2 θ = ρct2 2 ∂R ∂R ∂R ∂R 2 where uR is the solid displacement in the propagation direction of longitudinal wave, uθ is the solid displacement in the observation plane perpendicularly to the propagation direction of transverse wave, and uϕ is the displacement in the boundary plane perpendicularly to the propagation direction of transverse wave. One can see from expressions (6.18) that in fact, only the components σRR, σRθ, and σRϕ, which originate from longitudinal waves and transverse waves with polarization in the boundary plane, respectively, are independent. Figure 6.1 presents the geometry of the vector of displacement in a solid, which is caused by the presence of sound wave.
Figure 6.1 Geometry of displacement vector in a solid.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
147
4. THERMORADIATION GENERATION OF SOUND IN A SOLID HALF-SPACE WITH A FREE BOUNDARY Let a beam of penetrating radiation be incident from the air (vacuum) upon the boundary of a solid half-space z > 0 under a certain angle with respect to the axis z. Let the beam be intensity-modulated with the sound frequency ω. It is necessary to note that the specific features of sound generation in a liquid in the case of oblique incidence of laser radiation were considered by Bozhkov, Bunkin, and Gyrdev [30]. Thermal sources of sound arise in a solid in the process of absorption of energy of penetrating radiation, Q( x, y, z , t ) = µI ( x, y ) exp(− µz / cos θ )(1 + m cos ωt ) ,
(6.19)
where µ is the coefficient of radiation absorption, I(x,y) is the radiation intensity at the boundary taking into account the coefficient of radiation transmission through this boundary, m is the modulation coefficient of radiation intensity, θ is the angle of inclination of the axis of the radiation source in a solid with respect to the axis z, which does not coincide, generally speaking, with the angle of incidence on the boundary because of the possible effect of refraction. Here we turn our attention again to the fact that the law of absorption of penetrating radiation in a solid is assumed to be exponential. This is true for photons, relativistic electrons, synchrotron radiation, and X-rays but not for protons, ions, neutral particles, low-energy electrons, etc. The effect of particular features of absorption of these particles on the sound field is considered further. It is necessary to note that dynamic sources of sound arise also apart from thermal sources. These sources have the bulk force F directed along the axis of a thermoacoustic source and equal in its absolute value (under the assumption that quanta of penetrating radiation can be treated as ultrarelativistic particles) to F = Q/u, where u is the light velocity. The presence of a surface dynamic recoil force due to partial reflection of penetrating radiation from the solid surface does not play any considerable role, as it will be seen from further consideration, since this force is directed along the normal to the surface. Using equations (6.17), we can show that the amplitude of displacements in sound waves caused by the presence of thermal sources of sound is approximately five orders of magnitude larger than the amplitudes of displacements in sound waves produced by dynamic sources of sound. Indeed, comparing the first and the second terms in the right-hand side of
148 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
the second equation of system (6.17), we can see readily that under the condition F = Q/u and for the majority of solids, the ratio of the displacements in sound waves produced due to the thermal mechanism (the first term) to the analogous displacements caused by the dynamic mechanism (the second term) corresponds to the ratio of the light velocity to the velocity of longitudinal sound waves, i.e., c/cl ≈ 105. Therefore, dynamic sources of sound play a more or less significant role only in the cases when thermal sources do not excite all possible components of sound fields. For example, in the case of a liquid where propagation only of longitudinal waves is possible, accounting for the dynamic mechanism is senseless. At the same time, in the case of a solid, transverse waves exist also apart from longitudinal waves. Transverse waves polarized in the plane of incidence may arise in the process of reflection of longitudinal waves from a boundary and therefore, one may ignore the effect of the dynamic mechanism on sound generation for this type of waves. As for transverse waves polarized in the boundary plane, they cannot arise in the process of reflection of longitudinal waves from a boundary. Transverse waves of this polarization are excited only due to the dynamic mechanism of sound generation. Assuming now that I(x, y, z) = I0 exp [–(y2 + x2cos2ϑ)/a2] (a is the characteristic radius of penetrating radiation beam) and using the technique of boundary problem solution described above, which is based on the reciprocity principle, we obtain the next expressions for the components of strain tensor in the far wave field:
σ RR = G1G2
exp[i (ω / cl ) R] × R
exp[−ω 2 a 2 sin 2 θ (sin 2 ϕ + cos2 ϕ / cos2 ϑ ) / 4cl2 ] 1 + ω 2 cos2 θ cos2 ϑ / µ 2 cl2 cos θ cosϑ ω K (θ ) + iM (θ ) ω , µcl
σ Rθ = G1G2
exp[i (ω / ct ) R ] × R
×
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
exp[−ω 2 a 2 sin 2 θ (sin 2 ϕ + cos2 ϕ / cos2 ϑ ) / 4ct2 ] 1 + ω 2 cos2 θ cos2 ϑ / µ 2 ct2
149
× (6.20)
cos θ 1 / n 2 − sin 2 θ 1 − ω µct
σ Rϕ = −iG3
V2 (θ )ω ,
exp[i (ω / ct ) R] × R
exp[−ω 2 a 2 sin 2 θ (sin 2 ϕ + cos2 ϕ / cos2 ϑ ) / 4ct2 ] 1 + ω 2 cos2 θ cos2 ϑ / µ 2 ct2
G1 =
1 − iωχ / cl2 1 + ω 2 χ 2 / cl2
, G2 =
ω,
m(3 − 4 / n 2 )αa 2 I 0 ma 2 I 0 sin 2 ϕ sin ϑ , G3 = , 4cε 2cl c t
K (θ ) = 1 − V1 (θ ) , M (θ ) = 1 + V1 (θ ) ,
ϕ is the angle in the boundary plane between the projections of the axis of the thermoradiational array (source) and the direction to the observation point to the boundary. The reflection coefficients V1(θ) and V2(θ) in the case of free boundary can be written down explicitly [121], V1 (θ ) =
2 sin θ sin 2θ n 2 − sin 2 θ − (n 2 − 2 sin 2 θ ) 2 2
2 sin θ sin 2θ n −
sin 2
,
θ + (n 2 − 2 sin 2 θ ) (6.21)
V2 (θ ) = −
4n sin θ cos 2θ 1 − n 2 sin 2 θ
.
2 sin θ sin 2θ 1 − n 2 sin 2 θ + n cos 2 2θ
One can see from expressions (6.20) that the transverse waves polarized in the boundary plane exist only in the case of inclined position of the axis of the thermoradiational array (i.e., within the region of radiation absorption) with respect to the surface, i.e., under the condition that the dynamic force acts under some angle with respect to the surface. It is clear from here that
150 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
the presence of a surface dynamic recoil force does not play a significant role because of partial reflection of penetrating radiation from the surface of a solid. This happens since the force is directed along a normal to the surface. We have to note that one can readily obtain an expression for the sound pressure p in a liquid half-space from expressions (6.20) if one takes into account the fact that the analog of sound pressure in a liquid is the component of strain tensor (–σRR) and the reflection coefficient V1(θ ) must be taken equal identically to minus one in the case of a liquid. In this case we obtain the next expression for sound pressure from expressions (6.20):
p=−
1 − iωχ / c 2 mαa 2 I 0 2 cos θ cos ϑ exp[i (ω / c) R] × ω R µc 1 + ω 2 χ 2 / c 4 2C p (6.22) exp[−ω 2 a 2 sin 2 θ (sin 2 ϕ + cos2 ϕ / cos2 ϑ )] / 4c 2 . 1 + ω 2 cos2 θ cos2 ϑ / µ 2 c 2
Here c is the sound velocity in a liquid. This formula coincides with an analogous expression by Bozhkov, Bunkin, and Gyrdev [30] if we ignore the effect of heat conductivity on the process of sound generation (χ → 0) and there is no refraction of radiation beam at the liquid boundary. In the case of normal incidence of a beam of penetrating radiation on a free liquid boundary, an expression for sound pressure takes on the form (we ignore heat conductivity), p=−
mαa 2 I 0ω 2 cos θ exp[i (ω / c) R ] exp(−ω 2 a 2 sin 2 θ ) / 4c 2 . 2C p µc R 1 + ω 2 cos 2 θ / µ 2 c 2
(6.23)
It is easy to see that this formula is analogous to expression (3.22) from Chapter 3 (see also [40]). As one can see from expressions (6.20), heat conductivity affects considerably the generated sound fields only if the frequency ω ≥ c2/χ. In this case the effect is reduced to the decrease of their amplitudes. Figure 6.2 gives the directivity patterns (in polar coordinates) of the components of strain tensor σRR, σRθ, and σRϕ determined by expressions (6.20) under the condition ω2a2/cl2 = 10 and n = 2. The directivity patterns for the components σRR and σRθ are obtained for the case of the vertical position of the axis of the thermoacoustic array, while the directivity pattern for the component σRϕ is obtained for the case ϑ = 5° and ϕ = 90°.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
151
Figure 6.2 Directivity of a thermoradiational source in the case of normal incidence of penetrating radiation on the surface of a solid (a and b) and in the case of oblique incidence of a radiation beam (c).
The directivity pattern of the component of strain tensor σRθ due to transverse waves polarized in the observation plane has a sharp peak for small observation angles since the coefficient of reflection of these waves from the boundary is equal to zero at the zero observation angle, and, in the case of large observation angles, this component is decreased by the exponential factor, which is larger than in the case of longitudinal waves because of the smaller velocity of transverse waves ct in comparison with the velocity of longitudinal waves cl. The directivity pattern of the component of strain tensor σRϕ due to transverse waves polarized in the boundary plane, is similar to the corresponding pattern for σRR, but it decreases faster with the growth of observation angle because of the fact that the velocity ct is smaller than the velocity cl as in the previous case.
5. PARTICULAR FEATURES OF EXCITATION OF RAYLEIGH WAVES Surface waves may exist also at corresponding interfaces in solids apart from bulk waves. The simplest example of such waves is the Rayleigh wave at a free surface of a solid homogeneous isotropic half-space. This wave arises in the process of incidence of longitudinal or transverse waves polarized in the plane perpendicular to the boundary plane at this boundary. If there is some other kind of interface between two solid half-spaces or solid and liquid half-spaces instead of a free surface, the existence of
152 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
corresponding types of surface waves is possible also. Like the Rayleigh wave, these waves are produced by superposition of incident and reflected inhomogeneous waves of the types indicated above. Another type of surface waves can exist in a solid half-space if there is a solid layer with different acoustic properties at its boundary. These are the so-called Love waves, which transform into transverse waves polarized in the boundary plane if the layer width tends to infinity. It is clear that it is necessary to take into account the dynamic mechanism of sound generation in order to consider generation of Love waves, while in the process of consideration of surface waves of the Rayleigh type, it is possible to restrict oneself to taking account of the thermal mechanism of sound generation only since the role of the dynamic mechanism is inessential in this case. As the thermal mechanism of sound generation produces only sources of longitudinal waves, the incidence angle of a “plane” longitudinal wave, which initiates the Rayleigh wave resulting from superposition of incident and reflected waves, is determined from the relationship, 2 1/ 2 2 − 1)1 / 2 , cos χ 0 = (ω 2 / cl2 − ω 2 / v R ) (ω / cl ) = i (cl2 / v R
and the incidence angle χ0 itself is expressed as follows:
χ 0 = π / 2 − i arccos(cl2 / v R2 − 1)1 / 2 , where vR is the propagation velocity of the Rayleigh wave determined from equation [100], 6 vR
ct6
−
4 8v R
2 + 241 − ct4 3n 2
2
vR 1 2 − 161 − 2 = 0 . n ct
The reflection coefficients V1(θ ′) and V2(θ ′), where θ ′ is the incidence angle of a longitudinal wave (see expressions (6.21)), we write down in the form V1(θ ′) = B(θ ′)/A1(θ ′) and V2(θ ′) = D(θ ′)/A2(θ ′). (Using expressions (6.21) we have to remember that θ ′ = θ for the coefficient V1(θ ′) and θ ′ = arcsin (n sin θ ) for the coefficient V2(θ ′) in this case. The denominator A1,2(χ0) for the incidence angle χ0 vanishes naturally.) It is necessary to expand an elementary spherical wave into plane waves in order to apply the solutions of boundary problems determined in Chapter 1 to the problem of generation of Rayleigh waves [40]:
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
exp[i (ω / cl ) R] iω / cl = R 2π
153
π / 2 − i∞ 2π
∫
∫ exp[i(ω / cl ) x sin χ cosψ +
0
0
(6.24) y sin χ sinψ ± z cos χ ] sin χ dϕ dψ ,
where the sign + or – is taken in order for the principle of radiation decay in infinity to be satisfied. The part connected with the Rayleigh wave is separated in expansion (6.24) for the incidence angle χ0: 2π
exp[i (ω / cl ) R] iω = exp[i (ω / v R )( x cosψ + R 2πv R ∫ 0 (6.25) 2 2 1/ 2 y sinψ ± i (1 − v R / cl ) z )] dψ ,
and in this case expressions (6.21) for the reflection coefficients V1(θ ′) and V2(θ ′) in the corresponding range of angles take on the form: V1* ( χ 0 ) = − B( χ 0 ) / A1' ( χ 0 ) , V2* ( χ 0 ) = − D( χ 0 ) / A2' ( χ 0 ) , where
i vR V1* ( χ 0 ) = − 2 L cl
2 2 2c l − n 2 vR
1/ 2
c2 L = l − n2 v2 R
2 1/ 2 2 2 n cl 2 2cl * , V2 ( χ 0 ) = L 2 − 1 n − 2 , v R v R
2 3c 2 (c / v 2 − 1)cl2 / v R 2 − l − l R + 2 2 2 − 2 v c / v n R R l
1/ 2
4c 2 l − 1 2 vR
2c 2 l − n2 . 2 vR
(6.26)
154 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
Further direct application of the method of solution of boundary problems developed in Section 3 and integration of the expressions obtained using the saddle-point technique leads us to the next expressions for vertical and radial displacements in the far wave field of the Rayleigh wave (we should remember that radial displacements in the far wave field uR = ∂Φ/∂R – ∂Ψ1/∂z and vertical displacements uz = ∂Φ/∂z + ∂Ψ1/∂R):
uR =
ω 2a 2 exp − 2 4v R
2 (3 − 4 / n 2 )αa 2 I 0 m 1 − i 1 − iωχ / cl 3/ 2 8 π cε ρv R
2 2
R 1+ ω χ / c4 l
exp
2 ϕ 2 cos sin ϕ + ω iV * ( χ ) + ω 1 − 1 0 cos2 ϑ
ω exp − v R
1−
2 vR cl2
1/ 2
cosϑ z 1 + ω 1− µv R
2 vR cl2
iωR × vR 1/ 2
2 vR 2 cl
1/ 2
V2* ( χ 0 ) ×
−1
. (6.27)
2 (3 − 4 / n 2 )αI 0 m 1 − i 1 − iωχ / cl iωR × exp uz = 3 / 2 2 2 4 vR R 1+ω χ / c 8 π cε ρv R l
ω 2a 2 exp − 2 4v R
2 2 ϕ 2 cos sin ϕ + ω iV * ( χ ) − 1 − v R 2 0 cl2 cos2 ϑ
1/ 2 ω ω cosϑ v R2 1+ 1− ω µv R c 2 l *
*
−1
ω exp − v R
1/ 2
v2 1 − R cl2
V1* ( χ 0 ) ×
1/ 2
z ,
where V1 (χ0) and V2 (χ0) are determined by expressions (6.26), R = (x2 + y2)1/2 is the distance from the origin of coordinates to the observation point, and other notations correspond to the notations introduced earlier.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
155
We consider all displacements at the solid surface at z = 0, therefore expressions (6.27) may be presented in the form
uR =
ω 2a 2 exp − 2 4v R
2 (3 − 4 / n 2 )αa 2 I 0 m 1 − i 1 − iωχ / cl 3/ 2 8 π cε ρv R
2 2
R 1+ ω χ / c4 l
exp
2 2 sin ϕ + cos ϕ ω iV * ( χ ) + ω 1 − 1 0 cos2 ϑ ω cosϑ 1 + µv R
1 −
2 vR cl2
1/ 2
iωR × vR 1/ 2
2 vR cl2
V2* ( χ 0 ) ×
−1
, (6.28)
2 (3 − 4 / n 2 )αI 0 m 1 − i 1 − iωχ / cl iωR exp × uz = 3/ 2 2 2 4 vR R 1+ω χ / c 8 π cε ρv R l
ω 2a 2 exp − 2 4v R
2 ϕ 2 2 cos sin ϕ + ω iV * ( χ ) − 1 − v R 2 0 cl2 cos2 ϑ ω cosϑ 1 1− + µv R
1/ 2
2 vR 2 cl
1/ 2
V1* ( χ 0 ) ×
−1
.
We have to note that thermoradiational excitation of surface acoustic waves in solids was considered by Askar’yan et al. [11]. Figure 6.3 presents a polar directivity pattern of radial and vertical displacements in the Rayleigh wave at different inclinations of the axis of thermoacoustic array to the normal to the surface. This diagram gives displacements at the body surface at z = 0 as a function of the observation angle ϕ with respect to the direction x. Stretching of the directivity pattern along the axis x, which accompanies increasing inclination of the axis of
156 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
thermoacoustic array with respect to the normal to the surface can be explained by the fact that in this case the projection of the region occupied by sound sources onto the body surface differs more and more from a circle that increases the factor [−(ω2a2/4vR2) (sin2ϕ + cos2ϕ/cos2ϑ)] in expression (6.28).
Figure 6.3 Polar directivity pattern of radial and vertical displacements in a surface (Rayleigh) wave at different angles of incidence of a radiation beam at the surface of a solid. (1) Normal incidence (θ = 0°); (2) θ = 30°; and (3) θ = 45°.
6. SOLID HALF-SPACE WITH A LIQUID LAYER AT ITS SURFACE A situation may arise in some cases when a layer with different properties is present at the surface of a solid. In this connection we note a study by Lyamshev and Sedov [143] who investigated sound generation by modulated radiation in a liquid half-space with a layer of another liquid at its boundary. The authors treated the problem for the case of a liquid halfspace with a solid layer at the boundary.
Figure 6.4 Geometry of the problem of sound generation in a solid half-space with a liquid layer at its boundary.
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
157
The problem of sound generation by penetrating radiation in a solid with a liquid or solid layer with different properties at its boundary is also important. For precision, let us consider the problem of sound generation in a solid half-space with a liquid layer at its boundary. We assume that penetrating radiation is incident vertically at the free boundary of the layer. The geometry of this problem is shown in Fig. 6.4. As we assume that a beam of penetrating radiation has a circular cross-section and intensity is distributed over the beam cross-section according to the Gaussian law, transverse waves polarized in the boundary plane are absent because the symmetry of the problem. Therefore, as we have mentioned above, the dynamic mechanism of sound generation can be ignored and we may restrict ourselves to the thermal mechanism only. A sound field in a solid halfspace consists of a field of longitudinal waves and a field of transverse waves polarized in the plane perpendicular to the boundary plane. Since the field of longitudinal waves and the field of transverse waves can be separated into independent components in a unique way because of the difference in their polarization, let us consider only the field of longitudinal waves bearing in mind that expressions for the field of transverse waves can be obtained using an analogous technique. Equations (6.17) with the function Q (i.e., the energy released in unit volume per unit time) are initial. In the case of a liquid layer with the thickness H, density ρ, and sound velocity c (0 ≤ z ≤ H), the function Q has the form Q( x, y, z ) = µAmI 0
exp(− µz ) + (1 − A1 ) exp[− µ (2 H − z )] × 1 − (1 − A)(1 − A1 ) exp(−2 µH ) (6.29) x2 + y2 exp − a2
,
where A and A1 are the coefficients of radiation transmission through the free boundary of a layer and the boundary “layer – half-space”, respectively, I0 is the intensity of radiation beam in the center of the spot at the free boundary of a liquid, a is the radius of radiation beam, µ is the coefficient of radiation absorption in a liquid, and m is the modulation index. The energy Q released per unit time in unit volume in the solid halfspace with density ρ1 and sound velocities cl and ct (z ≥ H) is calculated as Q( x, y, z ) = µ1 AA1mI 0 ×
158 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
exp[− µH − µ1 ( z − H )] exp[−( x 2 + y 2 ) / a 2 ] . 1 − (1 − A)(1 − A1 ) exp( −2 µH )
(6.30)
Here µ1 is the coefficient of radiation absorption in the solid. The solutions of equations (6.17) must be consistent with the boundary conditions of zero sound pressure at the free boundary of the liquid layer, parity of sound pressure in the liquid layer and normal stress in the solid half-space at the boundary of the layer and the half-space, parity of normal displacements at the boundary of the layer and the half-space, and the condition of radiation decaying at infinity. The desired solution describing a sound field in a solid half-space can be obtained using the technique for solution of boundary problems, which was developed above. In the case of the far wave field and such points of the half-space which are not too close to the boundary “layer – half-space”, we obtain
σ RR = I 0 a 2 mA
cos θ exp iω γ − cl
2 2 2 exp(iωR / cl ) ω a sin θ exp − 4R 4cl2
αρ1µω − ρC × p
G 2 H × V i H A A1 ) exp( −2 µH ) ωγ − − − − 1 exp( 2 ) 1 ( 1 )( 1
µA exp( − µH ) sin ωγH − ωγ [1 + (1 − A ) exp( −2 µH )] 1 + 1 2+ 2 2 µ ω γ
(6.31)
2 ωγ ( 2 − A1 ) exp( − µH ) cos ωγH (3 − 4 / n 2 )αµ1 1 − iωρ / cl ωA1 × + cε 1 + ω 2 ρ 2 / cl2 µ 2 + ω 2γ 2
exp[−( µ + i (ω / cl ) cos θ ) H ] (1 − V1 )(ω / cl ) cos θ + iµ1 (1 + V1 ) , 1 − (1 − A)(1 − A1 ) exp( −2 µH ) µ12 + (ω 2 / cl2 ) cos2 θ where γ = (1/c2 – sin2θ /cl2)1/2; θ is the angle between the axis z and the direction to the observation point; R = (x2 + y2 + z2)1/2 is the distance from
RADIATION ACOUSTICS
159
the origin of coordinates to the observation point; and G, V, and V1 are the coefficients [40]:
G=
2 ρc l cos θ
2 sin 2 θ 1 − n2
ρ c 1 l cos θ
2 sin 2 θ 1 − n2
+
ρc 2 sin θ 2 + sin θ 1 − 2 2 2 2 2 n n 1 − c sin θ / cl
4 ρ1ct
ρ c V = 1 l cos θ
ρ1cl cos θ
2 sin 2 θ 1 − n2
2 sin 2 θ 1 − n2
−1
2
;
2 4ρ c ρc + 1 t sin 2 θ 1 − sin θ − × 2 2 n n 1 − c 2 sin 2 θ / cl2 −1
, (6.32)
2 4ρ c ρc + 1 t sin 2 θ 1 − sin θ + 2 2 n n 1 − c 2 sin 2 θ / cl2
V1 = V '− DG
exp(2iωγH ) ; 1 + V exp(2iωγH )
ρ c 2 sin 2 θ 4ρ c sin 2 θ ρc + 1 t sin 2 θ 1 − − 1 l 1 − V '= cos θ n2 n2 n2 1 − c 2 sin 2 θ / cl2 ρ1cl cos θ
2 sin 2 θ 1 − n2
2 4ρ c ρc + 1 t sin 2 θ 1 − sin θ + 2 2 n n 1 − c 2 sin 2 θ / cl2
D = cl 1 − c 2 sin 2 θ / cl2 (1 − 2 sin 2 θ / n 2 ) 2
−1
.
× −1
,
160 GENERATION OF SOUND IN SOLIDS: MODULATED RADIATION
Expression (6.31) determines the sound field in a solid half-space in the Fraunhofer zone. Using this expression we can calculate the directivity patterns of sound sources for various situations. As usual the component of stress tensor σRR is the analog of sound pressure in a liquid. And in the case of water-like solids, i.e., solids with small transverse sound velocity ct, the directivity pattern of sound sources is similar to the directivity pattern of sound pressure in a liquid half-space, other conditions being equal. It is necessary to note that, in both cases of liquid and solid half-spaces, the directivity pattern may change significantly in the presence of a layer with different properties at the half-space surface. This fact must be taken into account in the process of calculation of sound fields produced in targets by various types of penetrating radiation. A more detailed analysis of sound fields in a solid half-space with a liquid layer at its boundary in some limiting cases when absorption of penetrating radiation occurs mainly either in the liquid layer or in the solid half-space, is given in the next chapter where sound generation by pulses of penetrating radiation is considered.
7. EFFICIENCY OF THERMORADIATION GENERATION OF SOUND Efficiency of sound generation η is assumed to be determined by the ratio of the power of radiated sound