Kerson Huang
Quantum Field Theory
Related Titles
Stolze, J., Suter, D.
Quantum Computing A Short Course from Theory to Experiment 2004 ISBN 978-3-527-40438-4
Bachor, H.-A
.
A Guide to Experiments in Quantum Optics 1998 ISBN 978-3-527-29298-1
Cohen-Tannoudji, C., Diu, B., Laloe, F.
Quantum Mechanics Volume 1 1977 ISBN 978-0-471-16433-3
Cohen- Tan noudji, C., Diu, B., Laloe, F.
Quantum Mechanics Volume 2 1977 ISBN 978-0-471-16435-7
Kerson Huang
Quanti
-
Field Theoy
From Operators to Path Integ
Second, Revised, and
WILEYVCH
WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH 84, Co. KGaA
The Author
Prof Kerson Huang
Naples FL. 34108-1501 USA
[email protected]
All books published by Wiley-VCH are carefully produced. Nevertheless, authors, editors, and publisher do not warrant the information contained in these books, including this book, to be free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate. Library of Congress Card No.:
applied for
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data:
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek
The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available on the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de . © 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH 8z. Co. KGaA, Weinheim
All rights reserved (including those of translation into other languages). No part of this book may be reproduced in any form — by photoprinting, microfilm, or any other means — nor transmitted or translated into a machine language without written permission from the publishers. Registered names, trademarks, etc. used in this book, even when not specifically marked as such, are not to be considered unprotected by law. Typesetting
le-tex publishing services GmbH,
Leipzig Printing and Binding
Strauss GmbH,
Miirlenbach Cover Design
Grafik-Design Schulz,
Fugg6nheim
Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany Printed on acid-free paper ISBN
978-3-527-40846-7
V
To the memory of my teacher Victor F. Weisskopf (1908-2002) and his teacher Wolfgang Pauli (1900-1958)
Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
Contents
Preface
X//I
1
Introducing Quantum Fields
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
The Classical String 1 Renormalization 5 The Quantum String 5 Second Quantization 6 Creation and Annihilation Operators Bose and Fermi Statistics 11
2
Scalar Fields
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13
Klein—Gordon Equation 17 Real Scalar Field 18 Energy and Momentum 19 Particle Spectrum 21 Continuum Normalization 22 Complex Scalar Field 23 Charge and Antiparticle 25 Microcausality 26 The Feynman Propagator 27 The Wave Functional 29 Functional Operations 30 Vacuum Wave Functional 32 The 0 4 Theory 34
3
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6
39 Lorentz Transformations 39 Minimal Representation: SL(2C) 41 The Poincaré Group 43 Scalar, Vector, and Spinor Fields 45 Relativistic Quantum Fields 47 One-Particle States 48
4
Canonical Formalism
4.1
1
9
17
Relativistic Fields
55 Principle of Stationary Action
55
Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright © 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
VIII
Contents
4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
Noether's Theorem 57 Translational Invariance 58 Lorentz Invariance 61 Symmetrized Energy-Momentum Tensor Gauge Invariance 65
5
69 Maxwell's Equations 69 Covariance of the Classical Theory 71 Canonical Formalism 73 Quantization in Coulomb Gauge 75 Spin Angular Momentum 78 Intrinsic Parity 79 Transverse Propagator 81 Vacuum Fluctuations 82 The Casimir Effect 84 The Gauge Principle 88
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 5.10
Electromagnetic Field
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9 6.10 6.11
95 Dirac Algebra 95 Wave Functions and Current Density 98 Plane Waves 99 Lorentz Transformations 102 Interpretation of Dirac Matrices 105 External Electromagnetic Field 106 Non-Relativistic Limit 108 Thomas Precession 1 10 Hole Theory 112 Charge Conjugation 115 Massless Particles 116
7
The Dirac Field
6
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 8
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5
63
Dirac Equation
123 Quantization of the Dirac Field 123 Feynman Propagator 126 Normal Ordering 128 Electromagnetic Interactions 128 Isospin 129 Parity 131 Charge Conjugation 132 Time Reversal 133 Dynamics of Interacting Fields 139 Time Evolution 139 Interaction Picture 140 Adiabatic Switching 142 Correlation Functions in the Interaction Picture S-Matrix and Scattering 147
145
Contents
8.6 8.7 8.8
Scattering Cross Section 148 Potential Scattering 151 Adiabatic Theorem 154
9
Feynman Graphs
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.5.1 9.5.2 9.5.3 9.6 9.7 9.8 9.9
Perturbation Theory 159 Time-Ordered and Normal Products 160 Wick's Theorem 161 Feynman Rules for Scalar Theory 164 Types of Feynman Graphs 169 Vacuum Graph 169 Self-Energy Graph 170 Connected Graph 170 Wick Rotation 171 Regularization Schemes 172 Linked-Cluster Theorem 173 Vacuum Graphs 174
10
Vacuum Correlation Functions
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7 10.8
Feynman Rules 181 Reduction Formula 184 The Generating Functional 187 Connected Correlation Functions 188 Lehmann Representation 189 Dyson-Schwinger Equations 192 Bound States 195 Bethe-Salpeter Equation 198
11
Quantum Electrodynamics
11.1
11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5
Interaction Hamiltonian Photon Propagator 205 Feynman Graphs 209 Feynman Rules 214 Properties of Feynman Graphs
12
Processes in Quantum Electrodynamics
12.1
Compton Scattering 219 Electromagnetic Form Factors 223 Anomalous Magnetic Moment 227 Charge Distribution 230
12.2 12.3 12.4 13
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5
159
181
203 203
215
235 Primitive Divergences in QED 235 Electron Self-Energy 237 Vacuum Polarization 241 Running Coupling Constant 244 Full Vertex 245 Perturbative Renormalization
219
I
IX
Contents
13.6 13.7 13.8 13.9 13.10
Ward Identity 246 Renormalization to Second Order 248 Renormalization to All Orders 249 Callan-Symanzik Equation 253 Triviality 255
261 Path integrals in Quantum Mechanics 261 14.1 Time-ordering 264 14.2 14.3 Imaginary Time 265 14.4 Path Integrals in Quantum Field Theory 266 Euclidean Space-time 267 14.5 Vacuum Amplitudes 268 14.6 Statistical Mechanics 271 14.7 14.8 Gaussian Integrals 273 14.9 Perturbation Theory 276 14.10 The Loop Expansion 279 14.11 Boson and Fermion Loops 280 14.12 Grassmann Variables 282 14
Path Integrals
15
291 Why Broken Symmetry 291 Ferromagnetism 294 Spin Waves 296 Breaking Gauge Invariance 299 Superfluidity 302 Ginsburg-Landau Theory 305 Effective Action 307 Effective Potential 308
15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6 15.7 15.8
Broken Symmetry
315 16.1 The Cutoff as Scale Parameter 315 16.2 RG Trajectories 318 16.3 Fixed points 319 16.4 Momentum Space RG 320 16.5 Real Space RG 322 16.6 Renormalization of Correlation Functions 325 16.7 Relevant and Irrelevant Parameters 326 16.8 The Free Field 327 16.9 IR Fixed Point and Phase Transition 329 16.10 Crossover 330 16.11 Perturbative Renormalization Revisited 331 16.12 Critical Evaluation 332 16.13 Why Correct Theories Are Beautiful 333 16
Renormalization
17
The Gaussian Fixed Point
17.1
Stability of the Free Field
339 339
Contents
17.2 17.3 17.4 17.5 17.6 17.7 17.8
General Scalar Field 340 Feynman Graphs 341 Wegner-Houghton Equation 343 Renormalized Couplings 346 The RG Matrix 348 Non-Triviality and Asymptotic Freedom The Case d = 2 353
18
18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 18.5 18.6 18.7 18.8
357 Absence of Long-Range Order 357 Topological Order 358 XY Model 360 Kosterlitz-Thouless Transition 364 Vortex Model 364 2D Superfluidity 366 RG Trajectories 368 Universal Jump of Superfluid Density
19
Topological Excitations
19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 19.5 19.6 19.7 19.8
In two Dimensions
399
Notation 399 Classical Mechanics 400 Quantum Mechanics 401
Appendix B Superfluidity
B.1 B.2 B.3
372
375 Topological Soliton 375 Instanton and Tunneling 378 Depinning of Charge Density Waves 379 Nonlinear Sigma Model 383 The Skyrmion 385 The Hopf Invariant 389 Fractional Spin 391 Monopoles, Vortices, and Anomalies 393
Appendix A Background Material
A.1 A.2 A.3
351
405 405
Linear Response Normal Fluid and Superfluid Superfluid Density 408
406
Appendix C Polchinski's Renormalization Equation
C.1 C.2 C.3
Renormalization Scheme 411 The Equation 412 Asymptotically Free Scalar Field Index
417
414
41 1
I
XI
XIII
Preface Quantum field theory, one could say, is an all-encompassing framework of theoretical physics. The laws of nature, as we know them, are best formulated and explored in this language. Its applications include the fundamental interactions of elementary particles, as well as the statistical behavior of condensed matter. This book introduces the subject to an advanced audience in theoretical physics, on the level of a graduate textbook. We assume that the reader is conversant with quantum mechanics at the level of a graduate course. The field concept is indispensable in the classical theory of electromagnetism. The quantal version arises as soon as Planck introduces the quantum in blackbody radiation, whose modes are described in terms of the quantum harmonic oscillator. As every student of quantum mechanics knows, there arise a and at, the creation and annihilation operators of photons, which must appear to be stunningly empowering concepts at first encounter. However, they occur in the combination at a ± a at That is, you create a photon and immediately destroy it, or vice versa; and that doesn't sound like serious business. It's when you operate a and at separately, in the act of destroying or creating a single photon, as in Einstein's theory of the photo-electric effect, that the quantum field really flies. Thus, the first quantum field theory is QED (quantum electrodynamics). After decades of development, culminating in Feynman's graphical techniques and Dyson's renormalization theory, QED has become the most accurately verified theory we have, to the tune of one part in a trillion, in its calculation of the magnetic moment of the electron. A detailed exposition of this theory forms an important part of this book. Feynman's whimsical "space-time approach" to quantum-mechanical transitions not only gives us the Feynman graph that proves to be such a powerful computational tool, but, perhaps more profoundly, his path integral — a "sum over histories", as he calls it. This method reformulates quantum mechanics without operators, extends it in ways heretofore unimaginable, and bridges quantum field theory and statistical mechanics. The second part of this book goes into the subject in some detail. A far-reaching development arising from the bridge to statistical mechanics is Wilson's formulation of renormalization. The Wilson scheme transforms what appears to be a mathematical trick in QED to something with physical content, and .
Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright 0 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH Sc. Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
XIV Preface
shows us how a theory navigates the space of all possible Lagrangians, under scale transformations. It suggests that all theories designed by us are "phenomenological", in that they can only be approximations to some "true" theory, in the neighborhood of a particular fixed point of the group of scale transformations. The wider implications of renormalization remains to be explored. In this connection, we describe the terrain of theory space near the Gaussian fixed point, and introduce a more general formulation due to Polchinski. The connection between quantum field theory and statistical mechanics rests on the apparent accident that the operator of time translation in quantum mechanics, exp (— i t Hlh), where H is the Hamiltonian, maps into the density operator of the canonical ensemble exp (—PH), where 13 is the inverse temperature, if one makes the substitution t —ihfi. That is, time corresponds to a pure-imaginary inverse temperature. The reason for this coincidence remains unknown. This mystery, and the deeper meaning of renormalization, are left for the reader's contemplation. One important subject omitted from this book is the Yang-Mills gauge theory that underlies the standard model of particle theory. This subject has been covered in the author's Quarks, Leptons, and Gauge Fields, 2nd ed. (World Scientific Publishers, Singapore, 1992), which, although predating this book, may be considered a sequel. The material in this book are gathered over the years in courses I have taught at MIT, and I have learned much from my colleagues, past and present. They include the late Herman Feshbach, Kenneth Johnson, and Francis Low, and present associates Jeffrey Goldstone, Roman Jackiw and Patrick Lee. anuary, 2010
Kerson Huang
1 Introducing Quantum Fields
1.1 The Classical String
We obtain a quantum field by quantizing a classical field, of which the simplest example is the classical string. To be on firm mathematical grounds, we define the latter as the long-wavelength limit of a discrete chain. Consider N ± 2 masses described by the classical Lagrangian N+1
—q • — —(q —q
L(q, = j=0
_2
2
j
+ 02
where m is the mass, and K a force constant. The coordinate (41 (t) represents the lateral displacement of the j-th mass along a one-dimensional chain. We impose fixed-endpoint boundary conditions, by setting (1.2)
go(t)= qN-Fi(t) = 0
The equations of motion for the N remaining movable masses are then mq j
(q j
K
—
+
=0
N)
(j
(1.3)
The normal modes have the form (1.4)
q1 (t) = cos(w t) sin( jp)
To satisfy the boundary conditions, choose p to have one of the N possible values grn
P
N+1
(n
1, ... N)
(1.5)
Substituting this into the equations of motion, we obtain N independent normal frequencies co : 2
Wn
2 = (° 0 5
(2 N n+ 1 )
(n = 1
N)
Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
(1.6)
1 Introducing Quantum Fields
where (Do
(1.7)
=
This is a cutoff frequency, for the modes with n > N merely repeat the lower ones. For N = 4, for example, the independent modes correspond to n = 1, 2, 3, 4. The case n = 5 is trivial, being equivalent to n = 0. The case n = 6 is the same as that for n = 4, since w 6 = w4, and sin( j p6) -= — sin( j 194). When N is large, and we are not interested in the behavior near the endpoints, it is convenient to use periodic boundary conditions qi+N(t) = q1 (t)
(1.8)
In this case the normal modes are q 1 (t) =
(1.9)
P — w t)
For N even, the boundary conditions can be satisfied by putting
Pn =
2grn
(n = 0, +1,
(1.10)
N/2)
The corresponding normal frequencies are w
=
prrt N
Compared to the fixed-end case, the spacing between normal frequencies is now doubled; but each frequency is twofold degenerate, and the number of normal modes remains the same. A comparison of the two cases for N = 8 is shown in Figure 1.1. The equilibrium distance a between masses does not explicitly appear in the Lagrangian; it merely supplies a length scale for physical distances. For example, it appears in the definition of the distance of a mass from an end of the chain: x
j a (j = 1, . . . , N)
o
(1.12)
0
- N/2
Mode
number
Mode
N/2
number
Figure 1.1 Normal modes of the classical chain for fixed-end and periodic boundary conditions.
7.7 The Classical String
The total length of the chain is then defined as R = Na
(1.13)
In the continuum limit a --> O
oc (R = Na fixed)
N
(1.14)
the discrete chain approaches a continuous string, and the coordinate approaches a classical field defined by q(x , t)
(1.15)
q (t)
The Lagrangian in the continuum limit can be obtained by making the replacements (qn+1
2
aq(X, t) -
a2
E _1 f R a
ax -
(1.16)
dx
Assuming that the mass density p and string tension a approach finite limits p= mla
(1.17)
= Ka
(1.18)
we obtain the limit Lagrangian 1 Lcont = — 2
p aq(x,t)
dx
at
)
a(X,
ax
0) 2
(1.19)
)
This leads to the equation of motion a2 q(x, t) at 2
1 32 q(x, t) ,2
ax 2
°
(1.20)
which is a wave equation, with propagation velocity (1.21)
The general solutions are the real and imaginary parts of q(x, t)
e l(kx—wo
(1.22)
with a linear dispersion law co = ck
(1.23)
I
3
4
I
I Introducing Quantum Fields
2
7 3
4
5
Figure 1.2 Normal modes of a discrete chain of 4 masses, compared with those of a continuous string. The former repeat themselves after the first 4 modes. (After J. C. Slater and N. H. Frank, Mechanics, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1947).
For fixed-end boundary conditions q(0, t) = q(R, t) = 0
the normal modes of the continuous string are q n (x, t) = cos(w n t)sin(k n x)
with co, = ck n , and on/ kn = (n = 0, 1, 2, • • • ) The normal frequencies w n are the same as those for the discrete chain for n/N .<< 1, as given in (1.6). However, the number of modes of the continuum string is infinite, and only the first N modes have correspondence with those of the discrete string. This is illustrated in Figure 1.2 for N = 4. Thus, there is a cutoff frequency c
TT C W,r = — a
(1.27)
This is of the same order, but not same as the maximum frequency defined earlier w o = 2 c/ a, for w, is based on a linear dispersion law. The continuum model is an accurate representation of the discrete chain only for co « w c . For periodic boundary conditions q(0, t) = q(R, t)
(1.28)
the allowed wave numbers are kn =
2yr n
(n = 0, +1, +2, • ••)
We obtain the cutoff frequency co, by setting n = N/2.
(1.29)
1.3 The Quantum String
1.2 Renormalization
The high-frequency cutoff is a theoretical necessity. Without it, the specific heat of the string will diverge, since each normal mode contributes an amount k T. The value of the cutoff cannot be determined from the long-wavelength effective theory, because only the combination c = aco c pr occurs. Absorbing the cutoff into measurable parameters, as done in (1.17), is called renorrnalization. A theory for which this can be done is said to be renorrnalizable. Non-renormalizable systems exhibit behavior that is sensitive to atomic motion. Such behavior would appear to be random on a macroscopic scale, as in the propagation of cracks in materials, and the nucleation of raindrops.
1.3 The Quantum String
We now quantize the classical chain, to obtain a quantum field in the continuum limit. The Hamiltonian of the classical discrete chain is given by K
Fi
H(p , q)
+ — (q — 2m 2
+1)
2
(1.30)
where pi = in ).. The system can be quantized by replacing pi and (1 1 by hermitian operators satisfying the commutation relations' ) (1.31)
—i6jk
We imposing periodic boundary conditions, and expand these operators in Fourier series: Q ne i2.7 nj/ N
= 1
Pi =
v
N/2
Pne
/ N
i2. rn ji 1\1
(1.32)
n=—N/2
where I), and Q,, are operators satisfying O nd P = P-11 Qin
= Q—n
1) We use units in which h = c of light.
(1.33) 1, where h is the reduced Planck's constant, and c ist the velocity
6
I
1 introducing Quantum Fields
The system is reduced to a sum of independent harmonic oscillators: N/2
H
1
=
2m
n = — N/2
2
Co n =
4K
•2 sin ( f-
1 P P, — mw 2n Qn 2
(1.34)
)
The eigenvalues are labeled by a set of occupation numbers {a n }: N/2
=
(1.35)
con(an + 1/2) n=
—
N/2
where a n = 0, 1, 2, • • • . The frequency co, is taken to be the positive root of w 2n , since His positive-definite. In the continuum limit (1.14) the Hamiltonian becomes Hcont
X
f
1
.7
(
t)
2p
2
a q(X, ax
t)) 2—
(1.36)
where, with x = j a, p (x , t) =
p 1 (t)
a
=p
a q(x, t)
(1.37)
at
The quantum field q(x , t) and its canonical conjugate p (x, t) satisfy the equal-time commutation relation [p (x, t), q(x' , t)] =
x')
(1.38)
Just as in the classical case, we have to introduce a cutoff frequency co,. General properties of the quantum field will be discussed more fully in Chapter 2.
1.4 Second Quantization
Another way to obtain a quantum field is to consider a collection of identical particles in quantum mechanics. In this case, the quantum field is an equivalent description of the system. Identical particles are defined by a Hamiltonian that is (a) invariant under a permutation of the particle coordinates, and (b) has the same form for any number of particles. The quantized-field description is called "second quantization" for historical reasons, but quantization was actually done only once.
1.4 Second Quantization
Let 7i N the Hilbert space of a system of N identical non-relativistic particles. The union of all NN is called the Fock space: 00
(1.39)
= (_j N=0
The subspace with N = 0 contains the vacuum state as its only member. We assume that N is the eigenvalues of a "number operator" Nop , which commutes with the Hamiltonian. It is natural to introduce operators on Fock space that connect subspaces of different N. An elementary operator of this kind creates or annihilates one particle at a point in space. Such an operator is a quantum field operator, since it is a spatial function. This is why a quantum-mechanical many-particle system automatically gives rise to a quantum field. For definiteness, consider N non-relativistic particles in 3 spatial dimensions, with coordinates Ir l , , r N 1. The Hamiltonian is + V(ri,
(1.40)
, rN)
where V is the Laplacian with respect to ri, and where Vis a symmetric function of its arguments. The eigenfunctions V', are defined by H Wn (r i ,
,r N) = En 111,(ri,
(1.41)
rN)
For Bose or Fermi statistics, Wn is respectively symmetric or antisymmetric under an interchange of any two coordinates r i and r1 . The particles are called bosons or fermions respectively. We now describe the equivalent quantum field theory, and justify it later. Let tp (r) be the Schrbdinger-picture operator that annihilates one particle at r. Its hermitian conjugate /pi- (r) will create one particle at r. They are defined through the commutation relations [Ip (r),
(I')] + = 6 3 [7,i) (r), (01 ± =0
(1.42)
where [A, .13]+ = AB ± BA, with the plus sign corresponding to bosons and the minus sign to fermions. The Fock- space Hamiltonian will be defined in such a manner that it reduces to (1.40) in the N-particle subspace. A general N-particle Hamiltonian has the structure H =
f(ri)
g(ri,r i ) +
h(ri,ri,rk) + • •
(1.43)
i< j
where the functions g, h, etc. are symmetric functions of their arguments. The first term is a "one-particle operator", a sum of operators of the form f(r), which act on one particle only. The second term is a "two-particle operator", a sum of operators
8f
1 Introducing Quantum Fields
of the form g(r i , r2 ), over all distinct pairs. Generally, an "n-particle operator" is a sum of operators that depend only on a set of n coordinates. To construct the Hamiltonian on Fock space, we associate an n-particle operator with an operator on Fock space, with the following correspondences: f(ri) —> f d 3 ript (r) f(r)v) (r) Lg(r i ,ri ) i<j
h(ri,ri r k)
1 —
2
1 3!
d 3 rid 3 r2147PI,g127P2ihr
, d 3 r, d 3 r,d 3 r3V1 V2111) 31h 123 7P3 1P2 1P1
i<j
(1.44)
vi
where for brevity we have written (ri ), g12 =-- g(ri, r2), etc. As an example, suppose the potential in (1.40) is a sum of two-body potentials: V(ri ,
, rN) =
v(ri, ri)
(1.45)
i<j
Then the corresponding Fockspace Hamiltonian, also denoted H, takes the form H =_ — — 1 f d 3 rlp (r)V 2 V(r) 2m
+
if
d 3 c/ 3 r2 V 1 (ri )lp I (r2)v(r i , r2 )/p(r2 )1p(r i )
(1.46)
The particle number is the eigenvalue of the number operator, defined as Nop =f d3 rtp (r)V(r)
(1.47)
By using (1.42), we can verify the relations
[Nop , H] = 0 [V) (r), Nod = (r) Pp I (r), Nop ] _ t (r )
(1.48)
These imply that the action of p (r) on a eigenstate of Nop is to decrease its eigenvalue by 1, while that of lp t (r) is to increase it by 1. Thus (r) is an annihilation operator, while zp (r) is a creation operator. The vacuum state 10) is defined as the eigenstate of Nop with eigenvalue zero. It is annihilated by all annihilation operators: (010) = 0
(1.49)
By applying ?pt (r) to the vacuum state repeatedly, it is easy to show that the eigenvalues of Nop are nonnegative integers.
1.5 Creation and Annihilation Operators
To demonstrate that the quantum field is equivalent to the many-particle system, consider a complete set of states I E, N) of the quantum field, which are simultaneous eigenstate of Hand Nop : HIE, N) = E, N) Nop l E, N) = NI E, N)
We define the N-particle wave function 'PE (ri, , r N ) corresponding to I E, N) by 1 (1.50) WE(ri, • • • , rN) = N! (017P(ri) • • • lp(r N )I E, N) which the correct symmetry with respect to particle permutation. It tell us that the probability amplitude for finding N particle at the positions r1 , , r N can be found by annihilating the particles at the respective locations from the state I E, N), and evaluating the overlap between the resulting state and the vacuum state. We leave it as an exercise to show that this wave function satisfies the N-particle Schriidinger equation (1.41). (See Problem 1.3.)
1.5 Creation and Annihilation Operators
The field operator lp (r) annihilates a particle at r. That is, it annihilates a particle whose wave function is a 6-function. Since the latter can be written as a linear superposition of a complete set of wave functions, we can express ?p (r) as a linear superposition of operators that annihilate particles with specific types of wave functions. Suppose u k (r) is a member of a complete orthonormal set of single-particle wave functions:
f
cl 3 ru *k (r)uk/(r) =
k
k'
u(r)u * (ri ) = 6 3 (r —
An example of such a set is plane-waves: 1 ik.r uk(r)
(1.51)
We can expand the field operators with respect to such a basis: (r) —
uk(r)ak
(r) =
u (r)a kl
The coefficient ak and a are operators that satisfy the commutation relations ak, akl ± = 5 kki ak, ak , ]+ = 0
(1.52)
10
1 Introducing Quantum Fields
where the + sign is for bosons, and the — sign for fermions. These relations follow from (1.42) and the orthonormality of the functions uk (r). It follows from the commutation relations that, for each k, the eigenvalues of ak are integers nk, called the occupation number of the single-particle state k: aTa1n) = nin) (n1m)
(1.53)
where we have omitted the label k for brevity. The allowed values of the occupation number are given by , Do
n = 0, 1, 2, 0, 1
(Bose statistics) (Fermi statistics)
The actions of a and a T have the following results: am) = N/TtIn — 1) atm) = ,V1+ n1n +1)
(1.54)
where the ± sign corresponds respectively to Bose (+) and Fermi (—) statistics. which show that a annihilates a particle in the state with wave function u(r), and a t creates such a particle. We leave it as an exercise to derive these basic results. (See Problem 1.2.) The state 10) corresponding to n = 0 is the vacuum state, which satisfies al0) -= 0
(1.55)
We assume that it is normalizable: (010) = 1
(1.56)
Obviously all other states can be obtained by creating particles from the vacuum: 1 (at)n In)
In) =
(1.57)
We can simultaneously diagonalize ak t a k for all k. The eigenstates are then labeled by a set of occupation numbers {no , n 1 , ...}, and they constitute a basis for the Fock space. The total number of particles present is N =- Ek nk. We have a-kr ak 1 Ø,..., n k ,...) = nkjno, • • • , nk, • • •)
akin°, ••• , nk, • • .) = (-1) s A/7'rkino,
, nk —1, ...)
, nk,...) = (l)Sl ± nk no ,
nk + 1, ...)
where
s= O {
Ep
nP
(Bose statistics) (Fermi statistics)
(1.58)
That is, s = +1 for fermions, depending on whether the number of fermions with quantum numbers less than k is even or odd, the meaning of "less than" being
7.6 Bose and Fermi Statistics
set by an arbitrary but fixed ordering. This phase factor arises from the fact that fermion creation operators anticommute: alai; = A complete set of states can be constructed by creating particles from the vacuum:
ik) = 410) p ) = a al- 0) (1.59) These states are not normalized to unity. When there are many particle present, it is more convenient to label the state with occupation numbers {n k }, where n k is the number of particles with single-particle quantum number k: =
cl .i[aktink JO)
(1.60)
These states can be normalized to unity by choosing -1/2
nk ! H _k
(1.61)
1.6 Bose and Fermi Statistics
The term "statistics" refers to the rule for counting the degeneracy of an energy level of a many-particle system. In 3 dimensional space, it depends on the symmetry of the wave function under a permutation of the particle coordinates. Technically speaking, the different possible symmetries correspond to the different irreducible representations of the permutation group. The completely symmetric and the completely antisymmetric representations correspond respectively to Bose and Fermi statistics. They are the only possible ones in a two-particle system; but for more than two particles other possibilities exist, in which the wave function is symmetric with respect to permutations among one subset S of coordinates, and antisymmetric for the complementary set. Called "parastatistics", such representations correspond to the Young's tableaux with more than one row, or more than one column. Since the particle are identical, there is more than one way to choose the subset S. Consequently, such "para" representations must be multidimensional. That is, the carrier space for such a representation must be spanned by states having the same energy eigenvalue, and they mix under a permutation of the coordinates. Therefore, the energy levels of particles obeying parastatistics must have intrinsic degeneracies, which cannot be removed by any interaction that treat the particles as identical. The Bose and Fermi statistics can be set apart from the parastatistics by virtue of the following properties:
12
1 Introducing Quantum Fields
• Under particle permutation, the symmetry character of wave functions is independent of the number of particles present. • Energy eigenfunctions do not mix under particle permutation. Parastatistics does occur in atomic physics, but only in the context of "incomplete" permutations, which interchange the positions of atomic electrons but not their spins. With respect to permutations of both position and spin, electrons obey Fermi statistics, as we know. No known examples of parastatistics have been found in nature. Perhaps the simple properties itemized above are essential for consistency on some level. Although we live in a 3D world, some interesting physical systems are effectively 2D. These include the electron sheets that exhibit the quantum Hall effect, the copper-oxide planes in a high-temperature superconductor, and thin films of superfluid helium on various substrates. In a 2D system, the variety of statistics is far richer, because the exchange of two particle in a plane is not a unique process: we may rotate the particles about a center through angle nyr, where n is any odd integer, and the paths corresponding to different n are not necessarily equivalent. Consequently, the symmetry group relevant to particle exchange is not the permutation group, but the much larger braid group. This circumstance allows for fractional spin and statistics; but we shall not discuss this, except for a brief discussion on fractional spin in Chapter 19.
Problems
Problem
1.1
Consider an actual string made of atoms spaced a = 10 -8 cm apart. Suppose the length of the string is 1 m, and it is kept at such a tension that the fundamental frequency is 100 cycles/sec. Find the cutoff frequency, and show that it lies in the infrared region of the spectrum. (This gives the Debye temperature.) Problem 1.2
a) The basic commutation relation for boson annihilation and creation operator is [a,
an
=1
where [A, B] = AB have the properties
[a, a] = —
BA.
al aln) = nin)
0
From this definition show that eigenstates In) of ar a (n = 0, 1, 2,
al n) = ,ITtl n) atm) = ../n ± lin ± 1)
—
)
Problems
b) Fermion annihilation and creation operators are defined by an anticommutation relation
{ a, at} = 1
}a, a} = 0
where {A, B} = AB + BA. Show aiajn) = nin)
(n = 0,1)
an) = ,Ftin) alln) = A/1
—
nin ± 1)
Problem 1.3 Consider the N-particle wave function defined in (1.50) 1 Wdri, • • • , rN) =
OlOri) • • • IP(rN)IE, N)
where 1E, N) is an N-particle energy eigenstate with respect to the Hamiltonian H given in (1.46). a) Show that it is normalized to unity:
f
d 3 ri • • • d 3 rNIWE(ri,
rN)I 2 = 1
b) Show 1
ETE(r i , .• • >rN) = ,
N/N!
( 0 1 1P(ri) • • IP(rN)F -11 E, N)
c) Show that the wave function satisfies the N-particle Schr6dinger equation
2m i=1
v(r i , r1 )
tIJ
(ri.....rN) = E
(ri, • • • ,rN)
by going to the result in (b), and commute H all the way to the left, where it gives zero operating on the vacuum. All the results stated hold for both Bose and Fermi statistics [1].
13
14
1 Introducing Quantum Fields
Problem 1.4 A non-relativistic boson or fermion field lp (x) is governed by the Hamiltonian 1 1 H = — — f dmp I (x)V2 (x) + — f dxdpp (x) tp (y) (x — y)7p (y) (x)
2
2m
The system is enclosed in a large cubical box of volume Q (Q --> oo), with periodic boundary conditions. Expand the field in terms of annihilation operators ak for free-particle states of momentum k, and show that , k2 H = — a' ak
1 2 S2
2m k
(k) p+k aqt _k ap aq p,q,k
where 13 (k) = f d 3 r e ik'r v (r).
Problem 1.5 Consider a system of N non-relativistic electrons and N positive ions with Coulomb interactions, enclosed in a periodic box of volume Q. The Hamiltonian is given by H
The ions are heavy. Hence consider R, to be fixed numbers, neglect P„ and drop the last two terms. a) Label single-electron states momentum k and spin s, designated collectively as a = fk, sl. The corresponding wave function is u a (r) =
1
e dc.r
1 (0)
1)
(1
b) To go to the quantized-field representation, replace one- and two-particle operators by the rules K(ri) i=1
v (r i — r i ) —>
>.2,(
alKIP)aIap
ct , fl
2
(cl a cyy (a ), a),)(01vly /1) aPy),
References
c) Define Fourier transforms:
Ir
RI
1) =
a ss'(ksi ef2 ik's d 3 r Ow-1). r Q
2
e
ir – RI
(5 ssf 4,7 e 2 i(k'–k)•R • Q ir – RI e 2
(aMviyil.) =
6 5,5 3 (5 s2s4 e iO3-1(1).x+(k4 —k2).y] f d3xd3y e Q Ix – yi (5 s i s,(5s 2 s 4
Q
c5 K (ki + k 2 k3 k4)
1k43 .7rek2 ii
where (5 K is the Kronecker delta. d) Obtain the Hamiltonian in quantized-field form: h2 k2
2yre2
, 1
,
Q
2m akTs alcs
H
>•••
(ap+k,s aq—k,s' ) t ap,s ag,s'
p,q,k s,s'
ks
4-Jr e2
— p,k s
_ al
k 2 P's
ak4_
ik.11;
P' s
1=1
e) Show that the second term gives, for small k, 2.7re 2 v-,
52 k2 Z-- ' p,q s,s,
ps aqs, ) 1- aps aqs , -=
2:-/re2 N(N – 1) 52 k2
which is divergent at k = O. Show that the divergent term proportional to N2 is canceled by the k = 0 limit of the third term. The 0(N) term above remains divergent. The source of this divergence is the periodic boundary conditions, by which the set of coordinates r 1 , , r N is being repeated an infinite number of times in space. Consequently, the Coulomb energy of an electron diverges, due to long-range interactions with an infinite number of distant copies.
References 1
Huang, K. (1987) Statistical Mechanics 2nd ed., Wiley, New York, Appendix.
15
117
2 Scalar Fields 2.1 Klein—Gordon Equation
A fast way to go from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics is to replace the energy and momentum of a particle by operators, according to the prescription E --> i8/8t p
—iV
(2.1)
Making the replacements in the non-relativistic relation E = p2 / 2 in, and applying the result to the wave function, we obtain the Schr6dinger equation: —
1 -, a V`lp(r, t) = T v(r, t) 2m t
(2.2)
Of course, this is not covariant under Lorentz transformations. For a covariant equation, we use the same trick on the relativistic relation E 2 = p2 + m2 . The result is the Klein—Gordon equation (02 4_ m2) lp ( x )
(2.3)
where x stands for x ," = (t, x), and 02
a
a2 /8t2
_ v2
(2.4)
in units with c = 1. Assuming that 7,1) is invariant under Lorentz transformations, we have a covariant equation — one that has the same form in all Lorentz frames. What is not clear is how to interpret v(x). By analogy with the Schr6dinger equation, we might interpret /' (x) to be the wave function of a relativistic particle. That would require the existence of a 4vector probability current density j", which should be conserved: ap O. However, the obvious choice Jo = v*Ip is untenable, for zp*lp is Lorentz-invariant by assumption, and cannot be part of a 4-vector. As in the case of the Schr6dinger equation, we can construct a conserved current as follows. Multiply (2.3) from the left by Tr to obtain v) ± m2* 71, 0 Op 7p* ) ay op * aii (2.5) Ouanturn Field Theory fi-on Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
18
2 Scalar Fields
Subtracting this from its complex conjugate leads to
=0
(2.6)
where *
09/1
*
(2.7)
However, the time component 0
lp
.av at
av*
(2.8)
at
is not positive-definite, and therefore cannot be a probability density. The root of the difficulty lies in the second time derivative in the Klein—Gordon equation. As we shall see, this leads to negative frequencies corresponding to antiparticles. The relativistic kinematics makes it impossible to have a one-particle theory. We shall regard (x) not as a wave function but a classical wave field, and as such should be quantized.
2.2
Real Scalar Field
Consider a real scalar field (r, t), which is invariant under Lorentz transformations. The current j /1 vanishes identically in this case. We enclose the system in a large periodic box of volume Q, and expand the field in a Fourier series: (r, t) =
1 '■/ ,Q
qk(t)e
ik.r
(2.9)
where
(t) = q_k(t) -
(2.10)
because the field is real. Assuming that 0(r, t) satisfies the Klein—Gordon equation, we have 4 + W 2k qk 7= 0
(2.11)
where 2
k =
L.2
rn2
(2.12)
The system is equivalent to a collection of harmonic oscillators, and may be quantized it by imposing the commutation relations 411,(0) , q v (0) = (5 kie
k k ( 0 ), g oo)] = o
(2.13)
where 4, (0) is the hermitian conjugate of qk(0). This fixes the normalization of the field, left arbitrary by the Klein—Gordon equation.
2.3 Energy and Momentum
Since the Klein—Gordon equation is invariant under time translation, the origin of time is arbitrary. The commutations relations in fact hold at any time t: à kk,
qv(t)
(2.14)
[qk (t), qw(t)] = 0
which are equivalent to i [(r, t), 0(e, t)] = 6 3 (r — r')
[0(r, t), 0(e, t)] = 0
(2.15)
These are called equal-time commutators, which serve as initial conditions for the equation of motion. The unequal-time commutators must be calculated from the solutions, and contain dynamical information. In the present free-particle case, the equation of motion (2.11) is trivial to solve. For given wave number k there are two frequencies ± w k, with wk
(2.16)
+ k2 + rn2
Taking into account the reality property (2.10), we write the solution in the form 1
ake
qk(t)
—i wk
wk t -
(2.17)
where ak and d'ir, are operators, with commutation relations determined by (2.14): [ak, akin = c5kk, [ak, ay] -= 0
(2.18)
The normalization factor (2w) -1 /2 in (2.17) is chosen to make the commutators simple. We recognize that ak is an annihilation operator, and ai'f, a creation operator for a boson, as introduced in Section 1.5. The time-dependent quantized field operator can be represented in the form 1
0(r, t) = N
/ 2co k Q
i e -
—
i(k.r wkt)] —
(2.19)
L
The positive-frequency part (the first term) annihilates a particle, and the negativefrequency part creates a particle. The negative-frequency part is absent in a nonrelativistic field, because the kinematic relation E = p 2 /2m allows only one sign of the frequency.
2.3 Energy and Momentum
Analogy with the harmonic oscillator suggests that the Hamiltonian of the free scalar field should be
1
H =— 2
[I k1 2 + w 2kigkI 2 ]
(2.20)
20
I
2 Scalar Fields
In terms of the field 0 (x) =
(r, t), it has the form
H -= f r7-((x)
7-((x) = —21 [00002 + iv 012 + m202]
(2.21)
where Ii(x) is called the Hamiltonian density. The Lagrangian of the system can be obtained through the general relation L(q, 4) = p 4 — H(p , q): L
= f d 3 rf
(2.22)
where r(x) is the Lagrangian density given by f(x) = —21
[00 100 2
iv 01 2
m 2 0 2]
21 al
,
a Ito
_ rn2 02]
(2.23)
The last form shows that the Lagrangian density is Lorentz invariant. In contrast, the Hamiltonian density, being an energy density, cannot be invariant. For this reason, relativistic theories are usually specified via the Lagrangian density. In terms of creation and annihilation operators, the Hamiltonian takes the diagonalized form H =
12, co, (ak
k
21
(2.24) )
The zero-point energy diverges unless there is a cutoff; but the cutoff has no physical relevance, since the energy of any state relative to that of the vacuum is independent of it. The energy of a particle is given by Wk =
Vk2 in2
(2.25)
where k is its momentum, and rn the rest mass. Accordingly, the total momentum operator is
P=
Lka i- ctk
(2.26)
According to the general principles of quantum mechanics, the Hamiltonian is the generator of time evolution, through the Heisenberg equation of motion I [H,
(r, t)] =
t)
(2.27)
The formal solution yields (r, t) = ei Ht (r, 0)e—i t
(2.28)
For consistency, we must show that this is consistent with the Klein—Gordon equation, which we used to arrive at the solution (2.19). Substituting 0 (r, 0) from (2.19)
2.4 Particle Spectrum
into (2.28), we obtain ake ik.r
a-ki- e —ik.r1 e —i Ht
(2.29)
For the free-field Hamiltonian, we have (See Problem 2.1)
e i H t ake —t t
aie
—tw k t
(2.30)
This demonstrates that (2.29) is the same as (2.19). Again, according to general principles, the momentum operator P should generate spatial translations: P, 0(r, t) = VO(r, t)
(2.31)
with formal solution 0(r, t)
0(0, t)e
(2.32)
As a straightforward calculation shows, this is the same as (2.19).
2.4
Particle Spectrum
The vacuum state 10) is the state of lowest energy, defined by ak10) = 0
(all k)
(2.33)
and is normalized according to (010) =
(2.34)
A one-particle state is defined by 1p) = at,10)
(2.35)
Using the commutation relations, we find aklp) =-- akai;10) = (12, c1,k + 61(010) = (5kp10)
(2.36)
The field operator has non-vanishing matrix elements only between a one-particle state and the vacuum: e i(p.r—co n t)
(°10(X)1P)
\/2(u p
(2.37)
This is the wave function of a particle of momentum p, normalized to a density (2a) p ) -1 .By successively creating particles from the vacuum, we can build a
21
-,
22 i 2 Scalar Fields
complete set of states:
Vacuum: 10) 1-particle states: 1p) = a10) 2-particle states: Ip1p2) = atP11 a';-)2. 1 0)
2.5 Continuum Normalization
In the limit 0 —> co, the allowed values of k approach a continuum, and we can make the replacements 1
,
S2 c5ide
d3 k
f (27°3 (2gr) 3 6 3 (k —
(2.38)
We define continuum versions of the annihilation and creation operators by putting a(k)
./52 ak (2.39)
a i (k) - ./ ct
The commutators then have limiting forms [a(k), at (k')] = (2:70 3 6 3 (k — k') [a(k), a(k')] = 0
(2.40)
The field operator can be represented as a Fourier integral: 0(r, t)
d3 k 1 [a(k)e i(k. r— cok t) + a (k)e —ikt) ] = f (LT) 3 \/2(0k
(2.41)
As before, the vacuum state 10) is defined by a(k)10) = 0 with (010) = 1, and a one-particle state is defined by
IP)
(2.42)
= at (P) 10)
Using the commutation relations, we find
a (k) 1p) = (2gr) 3 (5 3 (p — k) 10)
(2.43)
The single-particle wave function is e i (pr —w p t) (0 195 (x)113 ) =
(2.44) \/2co p
with a particle density (2a) p ) -1 . The normalization is such that the number of particles in volume element d 3 r is the Lorentz-invariant combination d3r/(2wp).
2.6 Complex Scalar Field
The Hamiltonian and total momentum now take the forms H
=
f
cl 3 k w k citoo( k)
j ( 270 3
d3 k ka (k) a(k) (27c)3
P=
(2.45)
The choice between discrete or continuum normalization is a matter of notation, since we always regard Q as large but finite in intermediate steps of calculations. The limit Q co is taken only in final answers. This is done to avoid irrelevant concerns about mathematical rigor, like how to define the Hilbert space when the dimensionality is noncountably infinite. The continuum normalization merely anticipates this limit.
2.6 Complex Scalar
Field
A complex scalar field is just two real scalar fields constituting the real and imaginary parts. What is new is a symmetry between the two fields, and this leads to a conserved current. In physical terms, a complex field can have electric charge, whereas a real field must be neutral. We denote the complex scalar field by 'tp (r, t), and decompose it into real and imaginary parts in the form 1
= 71(9)1 + 2)
(2.46)
The Lagrangian density is taken to be L(x) -=
(x)ktp(x)—rn 2
v)
)v(x)
2
= 2 j=i [a"
(x)a,
(x) — m 2
(2.47)
(x)0 (x)]
The normalization factor lhh in (2.46) is chosen in order that .95 j has the same normalization as the real scalar field discussed previously. To quantize the system, we impose the commutation relations i [ i (r, t), 0 1 (r', t)] =
(5 3 (r — r')
[0 i (r, t), 1 (r', t)] = 0
(2.48)
The complex field v(r, t) becomes a non-hermitian operator satisfying i [ip (r, t), v)(r' t)] = (5 3 (r — r')
[ip(r, t), y)(r', t)]
t),
Thus, the canonical conjugate to p is ipt.
t)] = Pp(r, t),
t)] = 0
(2.49)
23
24
2 Scalar Fields
In accordance with (2.19), we can expand 0i in terms of annihilation and creation operators:
1 .\72WkQ
—t. (k.r— oikt))
tukt)
a 'lc
(j = 1,2)
j
(2.50)
with the commutation relations [a i k,
= diihe
[ctik, aikd = 0
(2.51)
In the complex representation, we have 1
(bkei(k-r—wk)
—i(k.r—cukt))
.\/260k
1
t) =
(
e i—(k-r—oi k t)
cke
r—w k o)
(2.52)
where 1
Ck
=
(a i k +
1 v2
(2.53)
— a2k)
with commutation relations bk,
— (5kp
[Ck,
6 kp
[bk, bp ] = [ck, cp ] = [bk, cp ] = 0
(2.54)
The total energy and momentum can be expressed as follows: H =
P=
cok (aIk a ik + a
Lw kk (al-k a i k +
a2 k)
=
a a2k) =
(birc bk
12, Wk
k
qCk) bk
k CI)
(2.55)
There are two type of quanta, which can be designated either as al and a2 quanta, or as b and c quanta. The energy and the momentum do not distinguish between these descriptions. We shall see, however, that only the b and c quanta have definite charge.
2.7 Charge and Antiparticle
2.7
Charge and Antiparticle
The current density for the complex scalar field is given by = 02 8"q51— 001 '02
OpaiLtp*
which satisfies the conservation law
(2.56)
= 0, or
a j o ±v.i=0 at
(2.57)
Integrating both sides over the spatial volume, we obtain
f d 3 x—aat j ° (x) , —cidt f d 3 xj ° (x) = 0
(2.58)
Or
dQ dt
=o
(2.59)
where 0 is the total charge operator d3xj°(x)
Q=
- E (a ai
—
k
(b b
— Ct
(2.60)
As we can see, a b quantum carries one unit of positive charge, and a c quantum carries one unit of negative charge. The al , a 2 quanta, being linear combinations of those of b and c, do not have definite charge. By convention, we refer to a c quantum as an "antiparticle". Thus, the positive-frequency part of annihilates a particle, and its negative-frequency part creates an antiparticle. Similarly, lp 1- either creates a particle or annihilates an antiparticle. In light of this, we can say that for the real field, the particle is its own antiparticle. The term "charge" is used in a generic sense, and does not necessarily mean the electric charge, since we have not turned on the electromagnetic coupling. The unit of charge is arbitrary, because j ," is defined only up to a multiplicative constant. It is straightforward to verify that charge is conserved: 0 H] = 0
(2.61)
This implies that the number of particles N+ minus the number of antiparticles N_ is a constant of the motion. In the free-field case, this conservation law is trivial, since N± are separately conserved. It becomes significant when, in the presence of interactions, N+ are no longer conserved. In that case, N+ — N_ is still conserved as long as (2.61) holds.
2
26
2 Scalar Fields
2.8
Microcausality
A classical signal propagating according to the Klein—Gordon equation has a group velocity Vgroup
=a01kk1
iki A./k 2
(2.62)
m2
which never exceeds 1. This means that events at two space-time points lying outside of each other's light cone, (or separated by a space-like interval,) cannot influence each other. In the quantum theory, this means that two field operators at points separated by a space-like interval must commute with each other. That is, [0(x), (x')] = 0
(2.63)
if (x — x') 2 <0
This condition is called microcausality. We must verify that our quantized field theory satisfies this condition. To compute the commutator in (2.63), note that it is a c-number 2) , and at fixed x' it satisfies the Klein—Gordon equation, because q5 (x) does. The initial condition at x0 = x(f, is the equal-time commutator (2.15), which is a c-number. Therefore the commutator remains a c-number at all times, and we can equate it with its vacuum expectation value: (x) ,
(y)] =1- (0 1 [g6 (x) , (y)]1 0)
i A (x
Y)
(2.64)
This defines a Lorentz-invariant correlation function A (x — y), which depends on x — y, and not on x and y separately, because of the translational invariance of the vacuum state. (See Problem 2.1) We use the expansion (2.41) to obtain (010(r, 00(0)10) = (010(0)0(r, 010) =
f
f
d3 k ei(k-r—wkt) (2.70 3 2wk d3 k e - 1(k-r — wkt) (2,7) 3 2C0k
(2.65)
Subtracting one from the other, we have (x) = —i(01 [0(r, t), 0(0)] 1 0 ) =
f
d 3 k sin(wk t) e ik-r (2,7 3 cok
(2.66)
)
Since A (x) is Lorentz invariant, it can only depend on the invariant 2 2 x2 = t — X
(2.67)
If x is space-like, for which x2 < 0, we can put t = 0. By (2.66) thus gives (x) = ON. 2) A c-number is a "classical" number, a multiple of the identity operator.
2.9 The Feynman Propagator i 27
The proof of microcausality depends on the initial condition from the commutator in (2.15), which quantizes the system according to Bose statistics. Had we used Fermi statistics by replacing commutator with anticommutator, microcausality would have been violated. The particles here have spin 0, since there does not exist discrete degrees of freedom corresponding to spin. Our result is partial demonstration of the spin-statistics connection, which states that particles with integer spin are bosons, while those with half-integer spin are fermions. The second half of the statement will be shown in Chapter 6 on the Dirac field.
2.9 The Feynman Propagator
The propagation of a free particle in the vacuum can be described by the correlation function A ( + ) (x2 — xi ) = —i(04(x2 )/p (x1 )10)
(2.68)
in which VI- (x1 ) creates a particle from the vacuum at xi , and is annihilate by v (x2 ) at x2 . This make physically sense when t2 > t i . Similarly, the correlation function A (—) (x2 — xi ) = —i(011» r(x i )zp(x2 )10) (2.69) describes the propagation of a test antiparticle from x2 to xi , and is physically meaningful when t i > t2 . To obtain a correlation function that has physical meaning, we use either 4 (+) or A (—) depending on the sign of the relative time. The result is the Feynman propagator, or causal propagator: A F (x2 — xi ) = —i(0rnp(x2 )7p i (xi )io)
(2.70)
where the time-ordering operator T rearranges the operators, if necessary, such that the operators stand in such order that time increases from right to left: TA(t 2 )B(t 1 ) =
1A(t 2 )B(t 1 ) if t2 > ti B(t 1 )A(t 2 ) if t2 < ti
(2.71)
If t2 > t i , the Feynman propagator describes the propagation of a particle from x i x2 ; if t2 < t i , it describes the propagation of an antiparticle from x2 to x i . Thisto is the basis of Feynman's famous remark: "An antiparticle is a particle traveling backwards in time". To calculate the propagator, we start with the expression A F(x) = —i
(01V) (x)tpt (0 ) O) (010(0)1P (x )I0)
if x° >0 if x° <0
(2.72)
and insert a complete set of states between the operators. Since the field operator connects the vacuum to one-particle states only, we can write
AF(X) = — i
f d 3 k 1(04(x)1k)(klIpt(0)10) (2703 (olv -i- (o)ik)(kilp(x)p)
if x° > 0 if x° <0
(2.73)
8
2
Scalar Fields
Using zp (x) = e i 'lp(0)e —iP 'x, and changing the integration variable from k to —k in the lower formula, we obtain d3 k
A F(x)
(17)3
(2.74)
1(012p(0)lk)12ee—iwkiti
Using the following integral representation iko t
00
e —iw k lt1
clk0
00 f-
14, — 04, + iy
y
0+)
(2.75)
we obtain ex d4 k (2y042cok1(01V(0)1k)12 k2 _ „2
A F (x)
(y —> 0+)
(2.76)
From (2.44) we have 1(0 1(0)1k)1 2 =
(2.77)
1
Therefore F
( x )
k.x f d4 k j pgr) 4 k 2 — m 2 ± in
(17 ---> 0 + )
(2.78)
Operating on both sides of this equation by LI 2 + m2 gives (02
in2)
F (x)
_ _ 6 4 (x)
(2.79)
This shows that the Feynman propagator is a Green's function of the Klein—Gordon equation. The Fourier transform of the Feynman propagator is 1
A F (k) — k2 m 2± -
(2.80)
which has poles at ko
+ m2
(2.81)
corresponding to a particle or antiparticle of mass m. The residue 2a) k1(011p (0)10)1 2 reflects the normalization of the wave function. We may view the propagator as=1 the propagation amplitude of a virtual particle of 4-momentum 10. The virtual particle, whose squared mass k 2 ranges between —oc and oc, becomes a real particle when it "goes on mass shell", at k 2 = m2 . To obtain A p (X) explicitly, we integrate over the angles of k in (2.74) to obtain k 2 sin kr i f a° dk e iwkItl A F(x) = 4 ,2 wk kr
A
(2.82)
2.70 The Wave Functional
By Lorentz invariance A F (x) can only depend on x 2 = t 2 - r2
s
(2.83)
For s > 0, we can put r = 0 to obtain the representation A F(x) =
" k2 e`wk 4,72 fo dk 0)k L
"I
(1) H i (m) is- (s > 0)
(2.84)
For s < 0, we put t = 0 to obtain i f" k 2 sin k,\/—s dk 472 ,0 Wk k ,\/—s
F(x)
im, 4-g-c2V—s
Ki (in,/—s)
(s < 0) (2.85)
where I-1 1-) and are Bessel functions. In the time-like region s > 0 the function describes an outgoing wave for large s. This corresponds to the i )7 prescription in (2.80). The prescription would have yielded an incoming wave. In the spacelike region s < 0 it damps exponentially for large Isl. On the light cone s = 0 there is a delta-function singularity not covered by the above formulas: 1 -, 6(x`) 47
lim A F (x) = 2.—>o
x
(2.86)
2.10
The Wave Functional
In quantum mechanics, the coordinate representation is defined by basis states 1r) satisfying (2.87)
rop ir) = rir)
with the basic commutator realized through the replacements rop
Pop
>r
—
(c-number) (2.88)
—V
A state IA) is represented by the wave function (2.89)
0 A (r) = (r,4)
and inner products are defined by
(AI B) =f d 3 n4(011) B (r)
(2.90)
In the analogous field representation in quantum field theory, we diagonalize the field operator, thus representing it by its eigenvalue, which is a c-number function. For a real scalar field 0 0p (r) at a fixed time t = 0, we denote its eigenstates by 10):
O0p(r)10) = 0 r)10) (
(2.91)
I
29
30
I
2 Scalar Fields
where the eigenvalue q5 (r) is a real-valued function of r. The commutation relations (2.15) are realized through the replacements
(r)
0 0p (r)
(c-number function)
6
(2.92)
ô (r)
where 6 16 (r) is denotes the functional derivative with respect to the value of the function 0 at r. A state IA) is represented in the field representation by the wave functional
wAkb] = ( 01 A)
(2.93)
which is a complex-valued function whose argument is a function. That is, its value depends on the form of the function. Inner products between wave functional are functional integrals: (WA, Ws)
=
f
n[0] Ws[0]
(2.94)
where DO denotes the measure on the space of functions. Writing the Hamiltonian in the field representation, we have the Schrbdinger equation for the wave functional:
1
f3
d r
-
62
_ ô0(r)2
+ I V95 (r)I 2
m2 0 2 (r)
w[0, t] = .aw[0,t] at
(2.95)
2.11 Functional Operations
We digress on functional operations on a functional F[0]. First, the functional derivative c5 F[0]/d qS (x) is defined as follows. We make a small change 0 —> q5 + 6q5, where the function 6 (x) is different from zero only in the neighborhood of x. Then the functional derivative is given by d.P[0]
6 (x)
1. 6
f--11->0 1
ô (x)
(2.96)
To calculate any functional derivative, we need the elementary functional derivative c5 (x)1 6 0 (y), which is obviously proportional to 6 (x — y). To determine the proportionality constant, we replace the continuous space of x by a lattice of spacing a, and denote by 0 the value of the function on site j. Clearly,
ao; =6 k aok ik
(2.97)
2.71 Functional Operations
In the continuum limi
>2, j
(2.98)
a 1 f dx
k —> a6(% — Y)
we have (5 (x)
(x
y)
(2.99)
6 95 (Y)
With this formula, we can calculate a general functional derivative. As illustration, take F[0] = f d 3 y1V0(y)1 2 . Then (5 F[0] 60(x) = 2
f
d 3 0 3 (x
—
y)V2 0(y) (2.100)
= — 2V 2 (x)
where we have assumed that boundary conditions are so chosen that surface integrals from partial integrations vanish. A functional integral is defined as the limit of an ordinary integral. Again, let us replace continuous space by a lattice of discrete points labeled by]. A function 0(x) becomes a discrete set of values {0 j }, and a functional F[0] becomes a function of this set F(0 1 , 0 2 , • • • ). The functional integral of F is defined as 00
f DOF[0]=Clif dOiF(.75 1 , 02 ,— )
(2.101)
—00
where C is a normalization constant. The continuum limit is to be taken eventually. Alternatively, we put the system in a large cube of volume Q, with periodic boundary conditions. The Fourier components 0- (k) of 0(x) are then discrete. The functional integral over 0 can be defined as the multiple integral over all Fourier components independently: 00
f DOF[0]=Clif 4(k)F[0]
(2.102)
—oo
cx). Eventually we take the limit Q In either of the above methods, the integral by itself may not have a continuum limit; but matrix elements of the form OAB =
(wA,o wB ) V ( WA, WA)( ws,
(2.103)
ws)
usually has a definite continuum limit.
I
31
32
2 Scalar Fields
2.12
Vacuum Wave Functional
We now calculate the wave functional for the free vacuum state. First let us express the annihilation operator a(k) in the field representation. From (2.41) we have, at t = 0,
f d3 r
f
k o (r) _
d3
1 [a(k) + at (k)] 20.4 — 2 k [a(k) – a (k)]
(r) =
(2.104)
Solving for a (k), we obtain a (k)
1 f( = .\/2a)k
k
r)
(2.105)
it■ (r)]
Now we write v/k2
e – ik•r co k
± m2
e_
= V_ V2 + me –ik.r
(2.106)
so that a(k) –
,\./20) k
f d 3 r [OW V–V2 + m + i4, (r)] e -tk.r
= ,/201 f d 3 r
V–V 2
M
(
(1-)}
T)
(2.107)
The last step is obtained by expanding ,\/–V2 + m in a power series in V 2 , performing a partial integration in every term, and sum the series again. The surface integrals generated in the partial integrations vanish due to periodic boundary conditions. Replacing i,b(r) by Id (r), in accordance with (2.92), we obtain a (k)
1 2cok
f d 3 re–dc.r
\ ± m2 0 (r)
(r)]
(2.108)
The virtue of this representation is that the Fourier coefficient in the integrand is independent of k. The wave functional of the free vacuum satisfies the equation (2.109)
a(k)Wo[0] = 0
Thus, it must be annihilated by the Fourier coefficient in (2.108): –V'
+ m 2 0 (r)
: (r)
vfo[0] = o
(2.110)
The solution to this equation is 1 TOM = C exp [--2 f d 3 r0(r)
V–V2
m2 0(r)
(2.111)
2.72 Vacuum Wave Functional
where C is a normalization constant. This gives the probability amplitude that the field has the functional form q5(r) in the vacuum state. The relative probability for the field to have a functional form lying in the neighborhood of 0 in the volume element DO of function space is
I v[0 ]1 2 D The most probable form is 0 0, and deviations from it occur with a Gaussianlike distribution. The exponent in (2.111) can be rewritten in different forms. Introducing the Fourier transform (k) = f d 3 re(r)
(2.112)
we can write
f d 3 rq5(r) V 2 ± m2 00 f (2c17r3k)3 f d 3 rd3 r1 0(r)K(r ri ) 0(e)
± m21:çkk)12
—
(2.113)
—
where K(r) =--
d3 k f (270
k
+ m2
(2.114)
For a complex scalar field, there are now two coordinates, which can be taken as either {01,02} or tip, 01. Inner products of wave functionals now take the form ( WA
,
= f DO1DO2V-1;[02, 02)WB[02, 02 ]
(2.115)
or equivalently (WA, 41/B)
f D'PD 7P * VIPP , V * W-IB
PP,
(2.116)
The complex measure is defined in terms of the real and imaginary parts: DipDv* D011302
(2.117)
The vacuum wave functional for the free complex field is just the product of those for the two independent real fields. Re-expressing the result in terms of the complex field, we have W0 pj= C e xp [
—f d 3 rzp*MV—V 2 + rn 2 /p(r)
(2.118)
33
34
2 Scalar Fields 2.13 The 04 Theory
As the simplest example of an interacting field theory, consider the Lagrangian density of the so-called 0 4 theory: (x)
aft 0
1 att
1
m2
9L
g
4
2 2 where g> 0. The quartic term makes the equations of motion nonlinear: ( 02 ± m 2 ) 0
± g0 3 = 0
(2.119)
(2.120)
The Hamiltonian density takes the form 1 2 1 V(q5(x)) = —2 m2 0 2 (x)
R(x) = — [0000 2 +1v012] + v(o(x)) g 4 (x)
(2.121)
which suggests that V(0 (x)) is a potential. To quantize the theory, we impose the equal-time commutators (2.15), which can be satisfied by taking as initial condition ,
.75 (r, 0) =
1
± a
—ik-ri
2(0 k 1
(ak + a_
(2.122)
V2WkQ
,
where the creation and annihilation operators akT, ak are defined by the commutation relations ak,
= kie
[ak, ale = 0
(2.123)
This equation of motion is not soluble unless g = 0. We can always write, as a formal solution, 0(r, t)
iHt
q5(r, 0)e
Ht
(2.124)
but this is not simple unless g = 0. To see the effects of the interactions, separate the Hamiltonian into a "free" and an "interaction" term, at some arbitrary time t = 0: H = Ho ±
Flint
(2.125)
where 1 Ho = — f d 3 r [(.5 2 (r , 0) + 1\70(r, O )I 2 ] 2
Hint
g f d 3 r04 (r, 0)
(2.126)
Problems
In terms of the creation and annihilation operators we have
Ho = Co
k
ak ak
(5K(ki +k2 Hint
—
+ k3 +1(4)
2,N/C010.) 2 (03 (04
k 1 ,k2 ,k 3,k4
ai )(a;
a2)(
a3)(
+ a4)
(2.127)
where Co is an irrelevant zero-point energy, (5 K denotes the Kronecker 6. We use the shorthand w 1 = wk 1 and al = aki etc. The interaction Hamiltonian Hint conserve momentum. Substitution of this ex-describ4-patloesh pansion into (2.124) generates a complicated series for the time-dependent field operator. We shall learn how to organize such terms in a systematic manner in Chapter 9.
Problems
Problem 2.1 Space-time Translation Consider a free scalar field q) (x), which can be expanded in terms of the annihilation operators ak. This problem illustrates the fact that the 4-momentum = Ek kit a ak is the generator of space-time translations. a) As a useful tool show that, for two operators A and B, e A Be —A
1
=
B + [A, B] + — [A,[A, B]] 2
1
— [A, [A, [A, B]]] ± • • • 3!
b) Use this formula to show e i P•x ake —iP•x
ake —ik•x
and the infinitesimal form [1)1`, ak] =
ak
c) Establish that 1)" is the generator of space-time translations by showing [P/ , 0(x)] =
d) Let I K) be an eigenstate of 1)", satisfying I)" I K) = KuIK). Show that this state is translationally invariant: (1(10(x)0(y)1K) = (Ki0(x — y)0(0)1K)
35
36
2 Scalar Fields
Problem 2.2 Charge Conjugation The designation of particle and antiparticle is a matter of convention, and we can freely reverse the labels. More specifically, for a complex scalar field O (x), construct an operator C that takes bk to ck and vice versa, and commutes with Hamiltonian H:
p (x) C -1 = e i Y
(x)
[H, C] = 0 Ct C = 1 C2 = 1 where y is an arbitrary phase angle. The operation
C is called charge conjugation,
or particle-antiparticle conjugation.
Problem 2.3 Lorentz Invariance We have calculate the function A (x) = (01[0(x), 0 (0)]10) in (2.66), but not in a manifestly Lorentz-invariant form. Show that it can be put into the desired form
A (x)
d4
2yri
k
6 (k 2 — rn 2 )E(ko)
(2z) 4
where E(k o ) denotes the sign of ko .
Problem 2.4 Spin and Statistics Quantize the real scalar field according to Fermi statistics, i.e., replace the commutators in (2.15) by anticommutators. In this case, microcausality requires that field operators at positions separated by a space-like interval anticommute with each other. Show that this is not the case., and thus a spin-zero field cannot obey Fermi statistics.
Problem 2.5 External Source Consider a real scalar field
0(x) coupled to an external source function J(x), with
Lagrangian density L(x
a)
)
1
oat 05
2
'
1 m 22
+
2
Obtain the Hamiltonian in terms of the creation and annihilation operators ak,
c4 for plane-wave states. b)
Suppose the external source consists of a single static point source:
J(x)
(r). Calculate the change in the energy of the vacuum state to order g 2 . The
Problems
result will be a divergent integral. Cut it off at a large momentum A. This illustrates a prototype of divergence in quantum field theory. c) Show that all levels of the system shift by the same amount, and therefore the divergence in this case has no physical relevance. Problem 2.6 Yukawa Potential
Continuing with the last two problems, suppose the source function J(x) consists of two static point sources located at r1 , r2 : J(r, t) = g [6 3 (r — ri ) + 6 3 (r — r2)]
Treating g as a perturbation, calculate the change in the vacuum energy to second order in g, and show that there is an attractive potential between the two point sources:
V(R) =
0.2
4,7
e
— mR
R
where R = 1r 1 — r2 1. This is the Yukawa potential, originally proposed as the potential between two nucleons due to interactions with scalar mesons. Problem 2.7 Vacuum Fluctuations Consider a free scalar field in a large periodic box of volume Q. Let the Fourier transform be denoted (k)
=
Q
fd 3 re— ` 1" (r)
is zero. a) Show that the vacuum expectation value of ,i)(k) b) By expanding the field in terms of creation and annihilation operators, show that the mean-square fluctuation of the Fourier transform is given by (01:73 2 (k)10) =
1
2,\/k2 + m2
c) The mean-square average can be expressed in the field representation as (010 2 (k)10) = f Do 9- -52(k) wo2[0] f DOY0 2 [0]
where W0 [0] is the wave functional of the free vacuum state. Reproduce the last result from this formula. d) Calculate the mean-square fluctuation (010 2 (x)10) in coordinate space. The result is divergent because of the high-momentum modes. Exhibit its dependence on the cutoff momentum A.
37
39
3 Relativistic Fields
3.1 Lorentz Transformations
Relativistic quantum fields can be classified according to the way they transform under Lorentz transformations. More specifically, they transform according to irreducible representations of the Lorentz group. The different representations give rise to particles with different values of the spin angular momentum. According to the principle of special relativity, the laws of physics should be covariant with respect to Lorentz transformations, i.e., they should have the same forms in all reference frames connected by Lorentz transformations. The simplest Lorentz transformation is a "boost" of the reference frame with velocity v along some axis, say the x axis: t—vx
tl =
—v2 X
—vt
(3.1)
V1 — v 2
This may be supplemented by a rotation of the coordinate system, say, about the z axis through an angle 0: X' = x cos 0 + y sin 0
y' = —x sin 0 + y cos 0
(3.2)
Defining a boost "angle" 475 by 1
cosh yb sinh g5 =
— v2
v ,N/1
—
(3.3) v2
Ouantton Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
40
3 Relativistic Fields
we can write the matrices of these transformations as follows: / cosh 0 — sinh 0 (A — sinh 0 cosh 0 0 0 Lorentz boost: 0 0 10 \ 0 0 01,! /1 0 0 (A 0 cos 0 sin 0 0 Rotation: 0 — sin 0 cos 0 0 \0 0 0 1/
(3.4)
The inverses of these matrices can be obtained by reversing the signs of 0 and O, respectively. The rotation matrices are orthogonal matrices, while the Lorentz boosts are not, because the invariant form t 2 — x 2 for the Lorentz boost is not positive-definite.
The angles of rotation are not additive, unless the rotations are all made about the same axis. Similarly, the velocities of successive Lorentz boosts are not additive, unless the boots are all made along the same direction. We use a relativistic notation in which the coordinate 4-vector is denoted by xP = (t, r) and the metric tensor is diagonal: —1
glt
(3.5)
—1 —
1/
A general Lorentz transformation is a linear transformation A on x that leaves x 2 = t2 r2 invariant: =
(3.6)
with the requirement g1 AA — g a fi
(3.7)
which ensures the invariance of x 2 . As a short hand, we write the transformation in the form X'= Ax
(3.8)
The transformations above form the continuous Lorentz group, which is characterized by 6 parameters: 3 velocity components, and 3 angles of rotation. As we can see from (3.4), they are represented by matrices with determinant +1. In contrast, the discrete transformations Spatial reflection:
t' = t
Time reversal: t' = —t
Xt
—X x' = x
(3.9)
3.2 Minimal Representation: SL(2C)
have determinant —1. These discrete elements together with the continuous Lorentz transformations form the general Lorentz group. We shall reserve the name "Lorentz transformation" for the continuous Lorentz transformations. Any element of the Lorentz group can be built up from infinitesimal ones, with the general form
g`i; +
(3.10)
We write in short hand A =1+ w
(3.11)
Lorentz transformations generally do not commute with one other; but the infinitesimal transformations do, because their commutators are of second order smallness: (3.12)
0(w 2 )
(1 + (01 ) (1 + (02) = 1 ± w1 + (02
Thus, group multiplication is equivalent to addition of the w's. An infinitesimal transformation of the coordinate system, characterized by boosts with velocities vj along the x axes, and rotations of angles 0 k about the x k axes, is described by the tensor
—V
—v 0
—v 2
—0 3
—v 2 03 0
02
—0 1
/ 0
\—v 3
\
—V 3
—02
(3.13)
01 0
By raising the lower index, we obtain an antisymmetric tensor 0
w 11
—V 1
= gV2,.
—v 2
V
3
v1 0
v2 —0 3
03 _02
0 01
V3 02 _01 0
(3.14)
i
whose elements can be summarized as follows: Ok —
wil
=
CO
k0
w1L
= =
V
k
_ E ijkok
(3.15)
3.2 Minimal Representation: SL(2C)
It is well-known that the smallest faithful representation of the rotation group is S U(2), the group of 2 x 2 unitary matrices of unit determinant. For the Lorentz group, the minimal representation is SL(2C), the linear group of 2 x 2 complex
4
2 3
Relativistic Fields
matrices of unit determinant. To see this, let us organize the coordinates into a 2 x 2 complex matrix: t z _= t + (a . x) = ( x + iy
i y) t —z
X
—
(3.16)
where ak are the Pauli matrices 1) (0 10
0
a = f. 1
0)
U3
-77-
(3.17)
with the following properties: f o.
=_ à ik
• 3 (and cyclic permutations) 1a2 = la [ 0.1 , a 2] = 2 i 0.3 (and cyclic permutations)
(3.18)
The cyclic relation can also be expressed in the form j a k = i c jict at
(j o k)
(3.19)
where summation convention is used. We see that det X = x 2
(3.20)
A Lorentz transformation that takes X into X' can be represented by the operation X' = L(A)X L (A)
(3.21)
where L(A) is a 2 x 2 complex matrix, and Lt (A) its hermitian conjugate. Taking the determinant of both sides, we have det X' = det X I det L(A)1 2
(3.22)
To preserve x 2 , we must have det X' = det X, and hence det L(A) = +1
(3.23)
Consequently det A = +1. This is a more formal proof of a result stated earlier. The matrices L(A) with det L = 1 constitute the group SL(2C). Any 2 x 2 matrix can be represented in the form A + B3 B1 — 1B2 A + (B u) = (B1 ± _s2 id A — B3)
(3.24)
where A and Bk are real numbers. The determinant of the above is A2 — E k B. Hence L(A) is a matrix of this form, with A2 — E k B i2c = 1. We leave it as exercises
3.3 The Poincaré Group
to show that a rotation and boost of the reference frame are represented by the following:
Rotation of frame about
ri:
i0 , ) L(A) = exp ( —E n . o.
. 0 0 ,, --= cos --± t(n . u) — 2
Boost of frame along
ri:
L(A) = exp (—
= cosh
where ri is a unit vector, (3.3), which implies
2
o.)
2
(ri u) sinh
2
(3.25)
is the rotation angle, and 0 is the boost angle defined in
cosh — = 2 (3.26)
sinh
where y
2 = (1 _
v 2) -1/2 .
3.3 The Poincaré Group
The laws of physics should be covariant with respect to space-time translations as well as Lorentz transformations. These transformations combined constitute the inhomogeneous Lorentz group, or the Poincaré group. The transformation law is as follows: (3.27)
= a + A x"
where a," is a 4-vector. The infinitesimal version has the form =
alL
(3.28)
wi'v` x"
which contains 10 independent parameters: a," and oi!`" = We can realize the Poincaré group on the space of functions f(x), through the transformation
± a ± cox) f(x) alt ay f(x)
f(x 1 ) = f(x
4- a
—
1
cox"
Wity(X it
f(x)
aV — %vat')
f(x)
(3.29)
where we have use the fact that co„ is antisymmetric. We can rewrite f(x l ) = (1 — ia p pp
± co ill, mit 2
f(x)
(3.30)
4
44
3 Relativistic Fields
which defines the generators PJ
= iaY Ae" =x'"P" —
(3.31)
Of these, 10 are independent operators, constituting the Lie algebra of the Poincaré group. An arbitrary element of the Poincaré group can be written in the form exp (i
—
icop „Mit")
(3.32)
where a," and col" represent 10 real independent parameters. From (3.31) we obtain the commutator [x p , pv]
gay
(3.33)
Though derived from an explicit representation, we consider the above as abstract algebraic relations. Such a procedure is analogous to obtaining the Lie algebra [ j i , pc] , iEjkiji for angular momentum from the special representation J = —ir x V. As abstract relations, the Lie algebra admits half-integer representations. The Lie algebra of the Poincaré group consists of the following commutators: (git a m v (gte p
g v m Ac /3 ± gl MY a et M V )
g.), 7,
" P"] = 0
(3.34)
which can be obtained through a straightforward calculation. In physical terms, the 4 generators =
(H,
P1 , P2, P3)
(3.35)
make up the total 4-momentum operator, and P° = H is the Hamiltonian. The 6 independent components of MY' are generalized angular momentum operators. made up of the angular momentum J and the Lorentz boost K: m jk = E jkl m 0 = j
(3.36)
We can recast the Poincaré algebra as follows. The last two lines in (3.34) are equivalent to Pi , P k ] = [PI, H] = [Ji, H] =0 i E jkl pl
=
Pi
= ôJkH
(3.37)
3.4 Scalar, Vector, and Spinor Fields
These relations all involve the inhomogeneous part of the group. The first equation above expresses the independence of the spatial translations among themselves, of spatial and time translations, and of rotations and time translations. The second equation is what one can deduce from J = — ir x V and P = iV. The other equations above describe how energy and momentum change under a Lorentz boost. In addition to these, we obtain from (3.34) a closed set of commutation relations among angular momentum and boost operators: —
jI , jk
i e jklil i e jkl JI
K1 , K
ji , Kk]
=
IEJuKI
(3.38)
These form the Lie algebra of the Lorentz group.
3.4 Scalar, Vector, and Spinor Fields
In quantum mechanics, the wave functions in a central potential can be classified according to orbital angular momenta, which correspond to irreducible representations of the rotation group, with possible dimensions 21 + 1, (1 = 0, 1, 2, ...). In a similar way, relativistic fields transform according to irreducible representations of the Lorentz group, which have definite dimensions. Accordingly, a relativistic field has a definite number of components, related to the spin angular momentum of the field. The simplest relativistic field is a scalar field, which may have more than one component, but each component ç (x) must be invariant under Lorentz transformations: (11(x') = 0(x)
(3.39)
This says that the transformed field called q5', at the transformed coordinate x', is the same as the original field called , at the old coordinate x. It expresses the fact that x' and x are different labels we use for the same physical point, and the scalar field does not care about that; but to us the functional form of the field must change: (3.40)
4/(x) = 0(A -1 x)
As we shall see, the spin of a scalar field is zero. A vector field, such as the electromagnetic field AY (x), does care about a change in the coordinate system, since by definition its 4 components transform among themselves like xi'. The transformation law is 26V1'(x l) =
A' (x)
= 0, 1, 2, 3)
The spin of a vector field is 1. This will be demonstrated in Section 5.5.
(3.41)
4
46
3 Relativistic Fields
In general, a tensor field of rank n transforms like a product of nx/vs, and corresponds to spin n. For example, the gravitational field is a symmetric tensor of rank 2. There are "half-integer" representations, analogous to those for the rotation group. The latter are representations of SU(2), which generalizes to SL(2C) in the present case. To accommodate space-time reflections, we have to include two copies of SL(2C), so that they transform into each other under a reflection. Accordingly, the minimal representation space is spanned by a 4-component complex field, called the Dirac spinor field p (x) , which transforms according to (3.42)
V ir (x t ) = S rs (A)/) s (X)(r = 1, 2, 3,4)
where S (A) is a 4 x 4 complex matrix discussed in more detail in Chapter 6. The spin of a spinor field is 1/2. In general, a field forming a K-dimensional irreducible representation of the Lorentz group has K components: (3.43)
(a =- 1, 2, ... , K)
a(x)
which transform under a Lorentz transformation A according to (3.44)
= S ab(A)0b(x)
For an infinitesimal transformation A = 1 ± co, we can put S (A) in the form Sab = 6 ab
2
(3.45)
ktilv Lev I a,
this defines the coefficients Z:by , which, as we will show, constitute the spin matrix. Under an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation, then, a general field transforms according to qvc,(x 1 )
= o.(x) + (0 „,,E :bv 95 b
(3.46)
x)
(
The change in the functional form of the field can be found by writing
O fa (x t
)
qVa (x ± cox) = qVa (x) + co —
O fa (x)
1 — —
a/.`
co '11 „(xli8" — x",9110 /a (x)
(3.47)
2
Thus, qYa (x) =(x')
v (x t 8 /
—
(3.48)
x"alt )0 ,(x)
Substituting .75',(x l ) from (3.45), we obtain qVa (x) = 0,(x) -1- —21 w yv [(x,"av — xv F)ôab +
b(X)
(3.49)
3.5 Relativistic Quantum Fields
This identifies the K x K matrices X ,"' = v" as spin matrices, since they are added to the generalized orbital angular momentum. The spin matrix for a scalar field is obviously zero. For the vector field, we can find it from it transformation law under an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation: A(x 1) = A a (x) Putting w a /3 = w,, v yv
(3.50)
we obtain for the vector field
u y gagfi
fi
af3A '(X)
,ry
(3.51)
As we shall show in Section 5.5, this gives spin 1. The case of the spinor field will be discussed in Chapter 6, and is include in the following summary for reference: Scalar field: Vector field:
El'" = 0
Spinor field:
Zg1" = (u'uv )rs
gg1c;
(3.52)
where o-i" is a 4 x 4 Dirac matrix defined in Chapter 6. The indices rs refer to the matrix elements.
3.5 Relativistic Quantum Fields
Since quantum fields are operators that act on a Hilbert space, we can represent Lorentz transformations by transformations on the Hilbert space. Recall that a Lorentz transformation changes the functional form of a classical field: 0,(x) ---> O la (x)
(3.53)
In the quantized version, this means that the operator Ø a attached to point x is replaced by Ota . Since çb a and O ta act on the same Hilbert space, the transformation is a mapping of the Hilbert space into itself. Since a and q5',„ are physically equivalent, the transformation must be unitary. Thus, there should exist a unitary operator U(A) on the Hilbert space, corresponding to the Lorentz transformation A, such that gYa (x) = U(A)q5 a (x)U-1 (A)
(3.54)
That the transformation is unitary means U 1 (A) =- U -1 (A)
(3.55)
From the definition of the primed fields C,(x') = tion
uo
(
x
)
u-1
=
b
(
A —1 x)
Sab
b( X), we obtain the condi(3.56)
47
48
3 Relativistic Fields
The set of operators U(A ) forms an infinite-dimensional unitary representation of the Lorentz group. In contrast to this, the finite-dimensional representations of the Lorentz group are non-unitary. As examples, we have 0(A -1 x)
Scalar field:
U (x) U
Vector field: Spinor field:
U AP (x) U -1 =
A"(A —1 x) (3.57)
Uv r (x) U-1 = S r op s (A —l x)
We can immediate extend the above consideration to Poincaré transformations: = SabOb(A —l x — a)
UO ta (x)U
(3.58)
For infinitesimal Poincaré transformations, U must be in the neighborhood of the identity operator, and linear in the parameters of the Poincaré group: (3.59) MP" 2 This defines the hermitian operators PP and MP", which represent the generators of the Poincaré group on the Hilbert space. In contrast, the generators denoted by the same symbols in (3.31) are finite matrices, generally non-hermitian. Substituting (3.59) into (3.58), we obtain U=1
(1
—
—
i aP
ia • P
—
—
co • M) 0,(x) (1
ia •P
( 6
ab
— —
w • M)
2
2
— (0 • rab) b (X — aix — 2
a)
(3.60)
which is written in an obvious abbreviated notation. Expanding both sides to first order in aP and wit", and equating their coefficients, we obtain a(x)] = i [MP", „(x)] = (x," [P",
—
x"0")
a (x)
l'aPbv b(x)
(3.61)
This shows that PP is the 4-momentum operator, since it generates space-time translations, and MP" is a generalized angular momentum operator, since it generates space-time rotations. The spin matrix T a b induces a mixing of the field components undergoing space-time rotation. The generators PP and MP" can be constructed explicitly from the field operators a . Rather than doing this on a case-by-case basis, we shall do it via a unified approach in the next chapter.
3.6 One-Particle States
A one-particle state is an eigenstate of PP, with energy eigenvalue E > 0, and momentum eigenvalue p, such that the invariant mass squared p2 = E2
p2
m2
(3.62)
3.6 One-Particle States
is a fixed number. Such a state corresponds to a particle of mass m. The P 2 of any state generally lies in a continuum, but those of one-particle states form a discrete set. If there are no massless particles, the invariant-mass spectrum of a field theory consists of the vacuum value 0 as a lower bound, a discrete set of particle masses, and a continuum separated from the vacuum value by a finite gap. The continuum corresponds to states containing two or more particles, whose masses occur within the gap. There can be particles whose mass occurs in the continuum, but only if these particles are stable against decay, dues to selection rules. The gap vanishes when there are massless particles, such as the photon. In this case, there is a discrete mass in the continuum corresponding to the electron, which cannot decay into photons due to conservation laws. The one-particle states of a free field can be generated by applying creation operators al- to the vacuum state. If we do this for a non-free field, we will not get one-particle states, because we will not get eigenstates of P". Instead, we will have a mixture of states involving interacting particles. Nevertheless, we can discuss properties of a one-particle state through general considerations, without constructing it explicitly. We confine our attention to massive particles, with m > O. There exists a Lorentz frame in which p = 0, called the rest frame. The spin operator S of the one-particle state is defined as the total angular momentum in the rest frame. The eigenvalue of S 2 has the form S(S + 1), where S is called the spin of the particle. The projection s of S along the momentum of the particle is called the helicity, which for m > 0 has 2S 1 possible values S,S 1,..., S. We can label a one-particle state by momentum p and helicity s: —
—
lone-particle state) = jp, s)
(3.63)
The parameters m and S are suppressed, because they are constants. For m > 0 a one-particle state in the rest frame is denoted by Is), and we can obtain I p, s) from I s) through a Lorentz boost L(p). Here, L(p) stands for a 4-tensor of the same type as the generic A li ', . It should not be confused with L (A) in (3.25), which is a 2 x 2 matrix. The state of a particle can thus be represented as jp, s) = U (L(p)) Is)
(3.64)
Under a Lorentz transformation A, this state transforms according to U(A)1p, s) = U(A)U (L(p)) Is)
(3.65)
We expect that the momentum is changed from p to A p, and the spin might undergo a rotation. To exhibit these changes explicitly, insert in front of the right side the identity operator in the form 1 U (L(A p)) U-1 (L(A p)): U(A)Ip, s) = U (L(Ap))[U -1 (L(Ap)) U(A)U (L(p))]Is)
(3.66)
The motivation is to write the state in the form of a boost to A p from some state. By the group property, the factors in the square brackets can be identified with a
50
3 Relativistic Fields
single operation: U-1 (L(Ap)) U(A)U (L(p)) = U (L -1 (Ap)A L(p))
(3.67)
This represents a rotation of the spin called the Wigner rotation: R(A,p)
-7.=
L -1 (Ap)AL(p)
(3.68)
which boosts a particle from rest to momentum p, makes Lorentz transformation A, and then boosts the particle back to rest. The state vector of the particle is unchanged, except possibly by a phase factor, which represents a rotation. Thus the Lorentz transformation A can be represented as U(A)lp, s) = U (L(Ap)) U(R)Is)
(3.69)
That is, the spin is first rotated by R (A, p) in the rest frame, and the resulting state is then boosted to momentum Ap. A more explicit representation of the Wigner rotation can be obtained by inserting a complete set of helicity states to obtain U(A)lp, s) =
L U (L(Ap)) Is') (sl IU(R))Is) si L Dsss,(R) Ap, s')
(3.70)
s,
where asss,(R) = (si lU(R))1s)
(3.71)
is the rotation matrix for spin S. A physical example of the Wigner rotation is the Thomas precession of the electron discussed in Section 6.8. An example of a general Wigner rotation is worked through in Problem 3.6. Massless particle are special, in that there is no rest frame. A massless particle of spin S can only have the two values of the helicity ± S. We shall explicitly demonstrate this for photons in Section 5.5. A general proof may be found in books on representations of the Lorentz group 3) .
Problems Problem 3.1
Verify the Poincaré algebra (3.34).
3) See, for example, [1].
Problems
Problem 3.2
Verify the spin matrix (3.51) for the vector field. Problem 3.3 Verify that the SL(2C) matrices L(A) given in (3.25) correctly represent Lorentz transformations. It is only necessary to verify them for infinitesimal transformations. Problem 3.4 Show the following identity, which is useful when working with SL(2C) matrices: (a• A)(or •
B)=A•B+io- •AxB
where the components of u are Pauli matrices, and the components of A and B are numbers. Problem 3.5 Consider two infinitesimal successive infinitesimal Lorentz boosts with angles 0 1 and 0 2 • Show that the result is equivalent to a boost 0 1 + 02 plus a rotation 0 1 x 02 . Here, 0 = tanh -1 v, where v is the velocity of the boost. This is an example of the Wigner rotation. Problem 3.6 a) A Lorentz boost with velocity IT transforms a 4-momentum pa to p'. Show 13' = P + v [01 1 ) vv. 2P Y Po Y (po — v • P) Pô
where y = (1 — b) Writing p'/` = A l;`, p'', verify that 71;`, is given by Ag = y
A?, = yvk A olc
—yv k = —gik — (y —1) VVkIV 2
which can be displayed symbolically as =
k
I
gk
'y v
y vk - 1 ) 1» Vk /V 2
51
52
3 Relativistic Fields
c) Let L(p) be the transformation tensor corresponding to a Lorentz boost that transforms the rest frame of a particle of mass m into a frame in which the particle has momentum p and energy E. Show — PkIns (pEki 1mm g ik p Pk[rn(E m )] -1 )
[L(19)r
Problem 3.7 a) Consider a particle of 4-momentum p, moving along the z axis. Make a Lorentz p'. One can readily obtain the boost A, of velocity y along the x axis, so that p Wigner rotation kit' [L(—p')A , since L and A are explicitly constructed in the last problem. b) Show R = I
RI.), 0)
1
where y —1 Y vi pk + E+1 (y E + 1)(E +1) P y (E ± 1) , ± y E + 1 P ' vk (y 1) y 2
= gik +
where the mass is set to unity, y = (1 — 2 ) -1/2 , and E is the initial energy. (The transformed energy is E' = y E.) c) Show Ri k
E yE+1 P
v
For an ultra-relativistic particle (E pk E
p'i E'
oc):
(ultra-relativistic particle)
In this case, the Wigner rotation rotates the initial velocity p/ E to the final velocity pl /E', both being unit vectors in this limit. That is, the momentum rotates in sync with the spin. This shows that the helicity of a massless particle, such as the photon, is Lorentz invariant.
References i 53 References
1
Tung, W.K. (1985) Group Theory in Physics, World Scientific, Singapore,
Sec. 10.4.4.
55
4 Canonical Formalism
4.1 Principle of Stationary Action
The equations of motion for a classical field can be derived from a Lagrangian through the principle of stationary action. This approach gives a unified treatment of topics discussed previously through special examples. It also makes clear that symmetries of the system give rise to conservation laws. Consider a set of classical fields collectively denoted by (x): 0(x) =
(4.1)
We denote their space-time derivatives by 0(x)
aji 0(x)
(4.2)
The Lagrangian density is assumed to depend on the fields and their first derivatives: f(x) = L(¢) (x), —
1,(x))
(4.3)
This will ensure that the equations of motion are second-order differential equations in the time, as in classical mechanics. We assume that, unless external fields are explicitly introduced, space-time is homogeneous. Thus, G(x) depend on x not explicitly, but only implicitly through 0(x) and çb ,u (x). We consider only local field theories, for which the Lagrangian density at x depends only on properties of the field at x. Non-local terms of the form
f d4 y0,,(y)K ab(x — Y)Ob(Y)
(4.4)
are ruled out, unless K a b(x — y) oc c5 (x — y). The classical action of the system is
s [0 ] ,Ld4xL (x )
Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
(4.5)
56
4 Canonical Formalism
where Q is the space-time volume, which eventually goes to infinity. We impose = 0. The principle of definite boundary conditions on the surface of Q, say that in classical mechanics, states a generalization of stationary action, which is the following: Suppose 0(x) is a solution to the equations of motion. If we vary its functional form by adding an arbitrary infinitesimal function 60(x) that preserves the boundary condition:
0(x) -± 0(x) -I- ô (x)
(x) = 0 on boundary of Q
then the variation of the action will be of second-order smallness: OS
S[0 ± 60] — S[0] = 0
This means that S[0] is at an extremum when q5 (x) is a solution to the equation of motion. To find the equation of motion according to this principle, let us calculate the variation of the Lagrangian density: (5,C = Using
ar + ac —WO
(4.6)
the fact that
(4.7)
O 95 = (5(ay o)=a(60) we get
C = _-aL Bo
a„ ( a'c oo+a„( 30,1_
6», )
(4.8)
The last term is a total 4-divergence. It vanishes when integrated over the spacetime volume, since it then becomes a surface integral by Gauss' theorem, and (50 = 0 on the surface. Thus
as= f crx
ar au ( ar)-ao
60 = 0
(4.9)
(50(x) is arbitrary, its coefficient must vanish. We thus obtain the equation of motion Since
ar _ 0 aa ge —
(4.10)
where (4.11)
The canonical conjugate to 0(x) is defined by analogy with classical mechanics:
ar yr(x)-- 70(x), — where a dot denotes partial time derivative.
(4.12)
4.2 Noether's Theorem
The independent variables of the local field are 0 (x) and aP o(x). The Hamiltonian density is defined by 7 4x) -
—
G(x)
(4.13)
The independent local variables are 7r, 0, ak 0. Thus, 0 should be re-expressed in terms of 7r according to (4.12). The Hamiltonian is given by H =--
d 3 x7i(x)
(4.14)
To quantize the system, we replace the field and its canonical conjugate by operators, which are defined by the equal-time commutators = (53 (x — y) i [r (x, t), r(y, t)] + = [0(x, t), 0(y, t )] + = 0
(4.15)
where for boson we use the commutator [A, B]_
[A, B] = AB
—
BA
(4.16)
and for fermions we use the anticommutator [A, B]+ = IA, B1
AB ± BA
(4.17)
If (x, t) 0, as is the case for the electromagnetic field, then the field conjugate to .7r(x, t) is not an independent dynamical variable, and should not be independently quantized.
4.2 Noether's Theorem
A transformation 0 (x) > 0(x) + ç5(x) is called a symmetry transformation of the system, if it changes the Lagrangian density only by the addition of a 4-divergence. As we have seen, this does not change the equations of motion. More specifically, the change must be of the form G(x) = EJ W (x) for arbitrary 0(x), whether or not it obeys the equation of motion. If the symmetry transformation is continuous, then there is an associated conserved current density. The formal statement is as follows. —
Theorem 4.1 Noether's Theorem [1,2]
If, under a continuous infinitesimal transformation 0(x) > 0(x) c50(x) —
the change in the Lagrangian density is found to be of the form G(x) =
w„, (x)
5
58
4 Canonical Formalism
without using the equations of motion, then there exists a current density jqx) =
(4.18)
(x)
(x)6 (x) —
which, for fields obeying the equations of motion, satisfies (4.19)
0
(x ) when the field changes by 6ç5, using the equation Proof: We calculate the of motion, but without assuming that ôc5 comes from a symmetry transformation:
aL a = —6 +
Of,
a4.71-€60)+ (ao = a ft
ao
+
a
(6 0)
a t yrY) (50
0)
where the equation of motion was used in the last step. Specializing the above to symmetry transformations, we equate the above with a,„\v" to obtain
e(50 — vv") = 0
The conserved current j12 is called a Noether current, and is determined only up to an arbitrary normalization factor. Noether's theorem was proven for classical fields, and one usually extends it to quantum theory by replacing the fields in j by the corresponding quantized fields. This does not always give a conserved current in the quantum theory. When the quantum current so obtained fails to be conserved, the nonzero divergence a,„ j" is called a "current anomaly". Some examples of this are discussed in Section 19.8.
4.3 Translational Invariance
An important symmetry for any system is Poincaré invariance, which is called a "space-time symmetry", because it is associated with the transformation of the field under a change in the coordinate system. We discuss this symmetry by breaking up the Poincaré group into the translation and Lorentz subgroups. Invariance under the translation group should give rise to 4 independent Noether currents corresponding to the 4 possible space-time translations. Consider an infinitesimal translation —>
(4.20)
4.3 Translational Invariance
under which each component of (x) independently transforms according to '(x + a) = 0(x). The functional form of the field changes according to 0 1 (x) = 0(x — a) = 0(x) —
0(x)
(4.21)
We shall choose al, to have only one non-vanishing component, say and take a = 0, 1, 2, 3 in turn. Thus, the change in functional form of the field is (50(x) = 0"0(x)
(4.22)
where we have dropped the proportionality constant —a„, because it enters all subsequent formulas only through the overall normalization of the Noether current. Differentiating the above with respect to x ," gives (50 11 (x) = a'0„(x)
(4.23)
The statement of translational invariance is that L(x) does not depend on x explicitly. Hence aL a at ô(x) = ao a 0+ Bott ro,„=a-L(x)
=
(4.24)
from which we read off W(x) = g"a L(x)
(4.25)
The 4 corresponding Noether currents are denoted by direction of translation: (x) = 7E4' aa 0(x) — gua L(x)
, where a labels the
(4.26)
They satisfy the conservation law
(x) =
0
(4.27)
This is called the canonical energy-momentum tensor. It is generally not a symmetric tensor. The subscript c, which stands for "canonical", distinguishes it from a symmetrized version to be discussed later. The conservation law can be rewritten in the form
a TOa at
a axk
T
ka —
0
(4.28)
Integrating both sides over all space, and assuming that surface contributions vanish, we obtain d — dt
=0
(4.29)
i
59
60
I
4 Canonical Formalism
where (4.30)
Pa = f d 3 x Tc°"
is the total 4-momentum. Thus, Tic3° is the energy density, and VcDk the k-th component of the momentum density. Their conservation laws are given respectively by the time and spatial components of (4.28):
a nn at a o•j TiTc
a
1, n
_0
axk
a
k•
axk
(4.31)
T, = 0
is clear that Tck° is the k-th component of the energy current, and Tcki is the k-th component of the current of the 'J-th component of momentum". The latter is called the stress-energy tensor. These components are displayed in the following matrix: It
=
TO2
TOI
/ Tca°
TI,33 \
Tcl°
(4.32)
Tr?3 \T
The identification of T°° as the energy density is consistent with the definition of the Hamiltonian density in (4.13). The explicit expressions for the total energy and momentum are P° =f d3 x (x) k b (x) — L(x) = f d 3 xR(x) pk
f d3 xyr(x )ak (x)
(4.33)
where a dot denotes time derivative, and 7-1(x) is the Hamiltonian density. We go over to the quantum theory by replacing 7r(x) and 0 (x) by the appropriate operators. To show that P k generates spatial translations, we calculate the commutator of 0(x) with the total momentum operator Pk
=f co y
( y )8( y )
(4.34)
The above does not depend on yo . We are therefore free to choose yo =xo = t, to take advantage of the simplicity of the equal-time commutators. Thus, we have P k , (X, t)] =
'1)( Y' t) f d 3 y .7(y, t) aayk
,0x,
f
d3 0 3 (x
ao(x, t) 8 oy, Y.) ayk axk
(4.35)
4.4 Lorentz Invariance
To show that P° generates time translations, we calculate
t),
t)] — [L(y, t), 0(x, t)ll
[P° , (x, t)] =
f
= —i0(x, t)
f d3 y {yr(y, t) [0(y, t), (x, t)] — [C(y, t),
d3 y {[yr(y, t)b(y,
(x,
(x,
(4.36)
The integral in the second term identically vanishes. Proof: Use the representation 0 = i 6 Id .7t to write [ 0 (Y) , 0(x)] =
6 0(y) ào_r(x)
a0(y) y) ag(x)
3
i (x
Using yt = aL •b , we can calculate the integral as follows:
—
if
d3 y af(Y)
)(Y) _aç.6) (y) 6:r(x)
x) a5(x)
ab x) a7r(x)
ô(y) 6,7(x)
a,c(x) a:r(x)
0
Combining the above results, we have
i [Pa, 0(x)] =
(x)
(4.37)
This shows that the total 4-momentum generates space-time translations. If F is a function of 0 and its derivatives, then [P", F] = a" F
(4.38)
Choosing, in particular, F = , we have i [Pa, 1) ,"] = aa . The right side vanishes because PP is independent of space by construction, and independent of time by 4-momentum conservation. Thus [P", PP] = 0
(4.39)
which is part of the Poincaré algebra discussed in the last chapter. It is realized here in terms of the field operators.
4.4 Lorentz Invariance
Consider an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation in the direction labeled by {a, fi } . For example, a rotation about the x 3 axis corresponds to 11, 21, and a boost along the x 1 axis corresponds to 10, 11. Under the transformation, the functional form
61
62
I
4 Canonical Formalism
of the field changes by 0(x), as given by (3.46). We have, up to a multiplicative constant, (4.40)
60(X) = (X a afi — X/ 3 aa
where a/3 is the spin matrix, antisymmetric in {a, /3 } . Differentiating ô q5 with respect to acl` , we find
0,„ (x) =
xaafi — xfi
a. +
(x) + (41,0
—
(4.41)
g1,3 45 a )
Using the fact that L(x) has no explicit x-dependence, we have =
ai:
+ ai:
a0 u y aL = (ea,' — xfiaa) + — X afi a0
+ "l c° Op + gra 0/3 — q5 a (4.42)
The statement of Lorentz invariance is that the above is a 4-divergence. The L) = first term is of the desired form, for it can be rewritten afi (xa — must vanish: L). Therefore the rest a, (g`i xa x 13 —
ao
+ Ic° y Yr a O P — 7r 13 q5 a = 0
(4.43)
With this, we have
a = a„ (efi
(4.44)
— guaxfi,c)
which gives (4.45)
WY(x) = (efixa — eax) L(x)
This leads to 6 independent Noether currents labeled by la, fif: Mrfi = grf` (x° — xaa
(x)
(et3
X clua X 13
G(x)
(4.46)
which can be written in the form Mr/3 (x) = x°
(x) — x'
(x) + yr"Zafi 0(x)
(4.47)
where Tr is the canonical energy-momentum tensor. It satisfies the conservation law =0
and is called the canonical angular momentum tensor.
(4.48)
4.5 Symmetrized Energy-Momentum Tensor
The conservation law gives rise to 6 constants of the motion, the Lorentz boost
f
dj xmc0 0j
(x) =
d 3 x [x °
(x)
—
x i T °° x (
)
(4.49)
and the angular momentum 1 j k = —E
f d3xm(x)
2
_1 6iik jr d3x
Oj
2
(x)— xi T 1 (x)
7t(x)Ei 1 0(x)]
(4.50)
The first two terms above represent orbital angular momentum, and the last term is the intrinsic spin. It is straightforward to verify that Ki and J I` generate Lorentz transformations by showing
f
d3 y m c0a/3(y, t), 0(x, t)
c50(x,
t)
(4.51)
where 6,95 is given by (4.40). It can also be verified that the commutation relations among the operators PI' and M,Ou/3 realize the Poincaré algebra (3.31).
4.5 Symmetrized Energy-Momentum Tensor
The canonical energy-momentum tensor Tr is not unique, because the Lagrangian density is defined only up to a 4-divergence. We can replace it by any tensor of the form (4.52) where X'IP" is antisymmetric in Ay: (4.53)
x4la —xPAa
The antisymmetry is a sufficient condition that the conservation law be unchanged:
a
T" =
a ( 1-'"" ± 2 /
=o
(4.54)
A possible change in the total 4-momentum is
f cl3 x T ou _ f d 3 XT 0 = —1 d3 xa) X 2ma 2
(4.55)
i
63
4
I 4
Canonical Formalism
which vanishes for the following reasons. (a) The term with 2 = 0 vanishes because xoou = 0 by antisymmetry. (b) The terms from 2 = k vanish because they gives a surface integral. From a physical point of view, therefore, Pm is equivalent to because they give the same total 4-momentum. The fact that Tr is not guaranteed to be a symmetric tensor, poses a problem if it is to be used as a source of the gravitational fi eld. We can, however, replace it with a equivalent symmetric tensor T. The condition for symmetry is = [Tr — Tr] +
T" —
1
(x I ." — X )1 ") = 0
(4.56)
The term in brackets can be rewritten using the condition (4.43) for Lorentz invariance: - Tcak"
aL
—
Jill
),zita
(
aL
a2
) zkec
(4.57)
where the last term vanishes by the equation of motion. Substituting this result into (4.56), we obtain the condition (4.58)
= 2yr)`Zi`a0
X 2" —
a solution to which is xu
( 7111, fia
z az;Vi
j.c. k t z ;,a) o
(4.59)
This term is needed only when the spin is nonzero. Corresponding to the symmetrized energy-momentum tensor, we can define a new angular momentum tensor: xa ritt3
—
x t3 T
(4.60)
This is related to the canonical angular momentum tensor through mitaP
Apr/3 +
_21 a
( x a xAftfl ____
(4.61)
It is easy to show that MP° is conserved, and that it preserves the definition of the boost and the angular momentum:
=0
f d3 xm° 0 = f d3 xm c° 0 From a physical point of view, therefore, MY a13 and MrP are equivalent.
(4.62)
4.6 Gauge Invariance
4.6 Gauge Invariance
In contrast to space-time symmetries, there are internal symmetries, which are x-independent transformations of the field that leaves the Lagrangian density in-
variant. A simple example is a change of phase in a complex scalar field: 7,0 (x) (x)
e ia
(x)
(4.63)
This is called a global gauge transformation, where the label "global" refers to the fact that a is independent of x. Invariance with respect to it means that the Lagrangian density is independent of the phase. This is true for the free field, in which the fields appear in the combination v 1- (x)zp (x) or aft tpt (x)a,,v)(x). The infinitesimal form of the transformation is 611)(x) = Ip(x)
6V) (x) = ---tp(x)
(4.64)
where we left out a proportionality constant i a. In terms of the real and imaginary parts defined by zp(x) =
2
[0 1 (x) ± i0 2 (x)]
1 [01(x)
x)
io2(x)]
2
(4.65)
the transformation is a rotation in internal space: 0 1 (x) =0 1 (x) cos a + 02(x) sin a
0 12 (x) = —95 1 (x) sin a + 0 2 (x) cos a
(4.66)
The Noether current is just the conserved current mentioned in Chapter 2:
aL a(aft -1P)
7,0
= va" 1,0* —1,0*al`v 1 = — (9)2V9) ]. — 00'1'02) 2
(4.67)
More generally, internal symmetries are linear transformations for a multicomponent field O a (x), (a = 1, , K), of the form O ia(x) = CabOb(x)
where
(4.68)
are elements of a Kx K constant matrix. If the matrix belongs to a K-dimensional representation of some group G, we call G an internal symmetry Ca b
65
6
4 Canonical Formalism
group. The group can be continuous or discrete. In the previous example G =U(1), the unitary group of dimension 1. Physical examples of conserved charges are • electric charge = positive minus negative charge • baryon number = number of protons minus number of antiprotons • electron number = number of electrons minus number of positrons A important case is isospin, which is discussed in Section 7.5.
Problems
Problem
4.1
Consider a field 0 (x) with Lagrangian density L o (x) L i (x), where the first term has a certain symmetry, while the second term does not. That is, under a transformation 0(x) —> 0(x) ± 0(x),
(5,c0(x)=
aft
whereas L l (x) cannot be put into the above form. If L i (x) were absent, the system would have a conserved Noether current. Show that, in the presence of L i (x), the divergence of the would-be Noether current is 6L i (x). Problem 4.2 A condition for Lorentz invariance is (4.43). For scalar fields, for which afi = 0, what restriction does this place on the Lagrangian density? Problem 4.3 Non-Relativistic System A non-relativistic many-particle system has a second-quantized Hamiltonian 3 x (x) (_
1
V 2H=fd
,u) ?,o (x)
(y)] = where y is the chemical potential. The commutation relation Pp (x), 6 3 (x — y) makes the system equivalent to the N-body problem (Section 1.3). We want to show this is consistent with the canonical formalism. , H]. a) Find the equation of motion using i b) Regard H as a classical Hamiltonian. Show that the corresponding Lagrangian density is L= IV— at
+1P' 2m — v — itt)
Problems
) Work out the Noether current associated with space-time translational invari-
ance, and global gauge invariance.
Problem 4.4 Modified Field Representation Since lp (r) and i t (r) are canonical conjugates in the non-relativistic system, it would be awkward to introduce the field representation by diagonalizing p (r). Show that in this case we can put (r) =
1 2
yo(r)
1
2
6 6q(r) _
-
(r)
(r) _
where yo(r) is a c-number function.
Problem 4.5 First-order Lagrangian The non-relativistic Lagrangian in the last problem differs from a relativistic one, in that it is first-order instead of second-order in the time derivative. The Dirac field discussed in Chapter 7 also has a first-order Lagrangian. To frilly explore the consistency of the canonical formalism, let us strip the problem down to bare essentials, and consider a classical system with two coordinates a and b, which are like iv* and 'p. Take the Lagrangian to be L(a, b, b) = ab
—
V(a, b)
The canonical rule says that a has no canonical conjugate. It is the conjugate to b. Show that this is completely consistent with the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian equations of motion, and thus it is thus completely consistent to quantize the system by imposing [a, NI = a) Find the Lagrangian equations for motion for à and b. b) Find canonical momenta, and the Hamilton equations of motion. Check that they are the same as the Lagrangian ones.
References
1 Noether, E. (1918) Nachr. kg-1. Wiss., Gottingen, 235.
2
Hill, E.L. (1951) Rev. Mod. Phys., 23, 253.
I
67
69
5 Electromagnetic Field
5.1 Maxwell's Equations
The classical electromagnetic field is described by two 3-vector fields, the electric field E(r, t) and the magnetic field B(r, t), which obey Maxwell's equations. In rationalized units with c = 1, they read V•E= p V • B =0 VxE=—
v
aB
at SE
xB=j+
(5.1)
— at
where p(r,, t) and j(r, t) are respectively the external charge density and external current density, which must satisfy the continuity equation (5.2)
The second and third equations are solved by introducing the vector potential A(r, and scalar potential .1) (r, t): B
t)
=VxA
SA
(5.3)
Whereupon the remaining two equations become a2
at2
v20
8 0) — V 2 \ A = — V (V • A-F-
at
a A ., f) _v at
Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH Sc. Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
(5.4)
70
5 Electromagnetic Field
The potentials are determined only up to a gauge transformation, which involves an arbitrary function x (r, t) A —> A + Vx
ax •
(5.5)
at
The Lorentz gauge corresponds to the condition
V • A + ato = 0 —
(Lorentz gauge)
(5.6)
a t
In this gauge, both potentials satisfy the wave equation:
( aa2t2
V2) A = j
( aat22
- V2)
=
p
(5.7)
The symmetric appearance of these equations is sometimes convenient; but it actually obscures the physics. These equations seem to indicate that there are four independent propagating modes; but actually there only two — the transverse components of A. This can be shown by going to Coulomb gauge. In Coulomb gauge (or radiation gauge,) A is purely transverse: V• A = 0
(Coulomb gauge)
(5.8)
The equations for the potentials become l'
2 v2 ) A
=
at2
JT
V2 = —p
where
iT
(5.9)
is the transverse current density (5.10)
which satisfies V • j T. = 0. In this gauge, A describes transverse electromagnetic radiation, whose source is the transverse current density, while describes the instantaneous Coulomb interaction between charges. The potential between two unit charges located at r1 and r2 is given by (r) =
1 — 1-21
(5.11)
To show that we can always impose the Coulomb gauge, suppose V • A = f. To go to the Coulomb gauge, we make the gauge transformation A —> A + Vx, with
5.2 Covariance of the Classical Theory
x satisfying V2 x = — f. The solution corresponds to the statement that x is the electrostatic potential due to the charge distribution V • A. We are using rationalized instead of unrationalized units. The difference between these systems arises from the normalization convention for the free fields, and is tabulated in the following table: Rationalized
4-Current: Coulomb's law: Energy density: Field operator:
Unrationalized
r jlt
q2 /4:-/rr (E 2 ± B2 )/8,71. Nti7 :7rA
5.2
Covariance of the Classical Theory
We postulate that the potentials form a 4-vector (5.12)
--= (0, A)
and this determines how Maxwell's equations transform under a Lorentz transformation. Since we always impose a gauge condition, a Lorentz transformation must be accompanied by a gauge transformation A"
AP —
x
(5.13)
in order to maintain the gauge condition. Under an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation, therefore, the vector potential transforms according to X," =
—
— 3I5
(5.14)
where x is such that Af1 satisfies the gauge condition. The Lorentz gauge 8,, Alt = 0 is covariant, and the equations of motion take the form (5.7), which are manifestly covariant fl 2 A' 1
(5.15)
where j/- ` is the conserved 4-vector current density
= (P,i) a/, j" = 0
(5.16)
In this gauge, however, the physical degrees of freedom are not manifest. In the Coulomb gauge, where physical degree freedom are made explicit, the equations of motion (5.9) are not manifestly covariant; but they actually are, because there always exists a gauge transformation to maintain the appearance of the
71
72
5 Electromagnetic Field
equations in all Lorentz frames. One has to choose between manifest covariance with Lorentz gauge, or manifest transversality with Coulomb gauge, and we choose the latter. The electric and magnetic fields are components of the antisymmetric field tensor FP" =
a" A"
—
8
V A»
(5.17)
which is gauge-invariant. The dual field tensor is defined as -
1 2
FICV
p UpFap
(5.18)
In terms of the electric and magnetic fields, we have Ek
Fk0
_E i jk B k
F 1 „
B k =-
(5.19)
The components of the field tensor and its dual can be displayed as matrices: /
FP"
= /
Fv
=
0 El E2 E3
0 B3 —B 2
0
13 1 0 —E 3 E2
—
B1 B2
\B 3 We see that
—E 2
— E3
—B 3 0 B1 —B 2 E3 0
B2 —B 1 0/
—El
is obtainable from
(5.20)
—B 3 \ —E 2
(5.21)
El 0/ FP" through
the duality transformation
{E, B } -->- {B, —E}
(5.22)
From the field tensors we can form two independent Lorentz invariants: 1
F„„ = (B 2 E2 ) (Scalar) 4' 2 1.4: FI" F,„ = —B • E (Pseudoscalar) ' —
—
(5.23)
In terms of the field tensors, Maxwell's equations read
a„ FP" = j"
a, Piv = o
(5.24)
which are gauge invariant and Lorentz covariant, and are invariant under the duality transformation when j = 0. Since FP" = F", the first equation is consistent only if a„ jP =0. The second equation is identically satisfied by putting FP" = aP A' — 8 V A". —
5.3 Canonical Formalism i 73
5.3 Canonical Formalism
The Lagrangian density of the free electromagnetic field is 1
=
1 = — ( 2 — B2 ) 2
(5.25)
Apart from an overall factor, this is uniquely determined by the requirement that it be Lorentz and gauge invariant, and does not contain higher derivatives of At than first derivatives. The minus sign in front is chosen to give a positive energy density for the free field, and the factor 1/4 sets the normalization of the fields. To obtain the equations of motion from the action principle, we must use the potential AV as the field variable. The Lagrangian density then reads 1 = -- (a" Av — 2
(5.26)
from which we obtain
_
ar a(a„Ai,)
(5.27)
The equation of motion is
a
.714"
ar BA „ = °
(5.28)
Since the second term on the left side is zero, we have B „, FP"
=0
(5.29)
The use of the potential makes B equations for free fields. The canonical conjugate to Ay is yr ov
O. Thus, we correctly recover Maxwell's
_ F ov
(5.30)
which vanishes identically for y = 0, indicating that A° is not a dynamical variable. The dynamical fields are Ak, with canonical conjugate — F°k = Ek. However, the longitudinal part of A has no physical significance, because it can be changed at will through a gauge transformation. (See Table 5.1.) The only dynamical degrees of freedom are the two transverse components of A, and we can go to Coulomb gauge to make this explicit. In Coulomb gauge A° satisfies the Poisson equation, and is determined by the external charges. The canonical energy-momentum tensor is, according to (4.26), 14
"8"A v
—
guaL = —Fl"0"A„ — g"",C
(5.31)
4
5 Electromagnetic Field
Table 5.1 Fields and Canonical Conjugates
Field
Canonical Conjugate
Remark
A°
0
A
—E
Not dynamical variable Only transverse part physical
which can be rewritten using the equation of motion: = — Pt"
Ca
— glair
— 0„(F—A a )
(5.32)
The last term is not symmetric in kt and a, and not gauge-invariant. However, it is a total 4-divergence antisymmetric in ,u and y, and is conserved because a,av (F—Aa) O. As discussed in Section 4.5, such a term has no effect on the conservation law and the definitions of total energy and total momentum, and may therefore be omitted. Thus we take as energy-momentum tensor the symmetric and gauge-invariant tensor = —Pt" Fa
„—er
(5.33)
which satisfies a„ Ty; = 0
(5.34)
The trace of the tensor vanishes:
=
(5.35)
It is now straightforward to obtain
_ T oo
F ok Fok
the Hamiltonian density:
_ 1 (E 2 ± B 2 ) 2
(5.36)
The momentum density (the Poynting vector) is TOk = F01 Fkj
k
E ki j E i B i
(5.37)
The total Hamiltonian H and total momentum P are given by H = P=
f d 3 r (E 2 + B 2 ) f d 3 rE x B
(5.38)
The conservation of energy and momentum correspond to the statements
a a
at
V•S=0 -/ +-7
— sk +a•Tik = 0 at
(5.39)
5.4 Quantization in Coulomb Gauge
where B k ) + -12- (5 ik (E 2 + B2 )
Ek +
Ti k
(5.40)
is the stress tensor. According to (4.47) the generalized angular momentum tensor is Mu ° = x" T' 1 — x
(5.41)
which satisfies the conservation law
a„ mf'13 = 0
(5.42)
It follows that the total angular momentum and the Lorentz boost K are given by d 3 rr X (E x B)
J
K= tP —rH
(5.43)
5.4
Quantization in Coulomb Gauge
To quantize the electromagnetic field, we must first eliminate all unphysical degrees of freedom by fixing the gauge, and in the following we shall use Coulomb gauge. In the absence of external charges, we can set A° = 0, and write the Hamiltonian in the form 1 2
H = — f d 3 r(E2 + IV x Al 2 ) (V • A = 0)
(5.44)
The canonical conjugate to A is —E = aAla t, and we would normally impose the = i k (5 3 (r — rI). But this is equal-time commutation relation [Ei (r, t), Ak incorrect here, because the right side is not consistent with V • A = 0, nor with one of Maxwell's equations V • E = 0. We therefore replace d i k (5 3 (r — r') by its transverse projection, and take: flu (r,
ic5 j7:k (r — r')
t), Ak (11 , t)
(5.45)
where the transverse delta function c5Tjk (r k (r)
= f ci 3 k
ki ki k
) 3
(j
Ik12
—
r') is defined by
eik.r
(5.46)
(27
and satisfies
a' (57;k(r) = ak 6
(r)
4) For quantization in other gauges see [1]
(5.47)
75
76
5 Electromagnetic Field
6
2(k)
Figure 5.1 Polarization vectors of an electromagnetic wave.
Q
A complete set of solutions to Maxwell's equations in a periodic box of volume are the transverse plane waves c (k) e i(k•T— alkt)
Wk
=
lki
where e (k) is a unit polarization vector normal to k. For each k, there are two independent polarization vectors c i (k) and 6 2 (k), and E i (k), c 2 (k), k together form a right-handed coordinate system: k • E (k) = k.6 2 (k) = 0
E s (k) • E r (k) = 5 sr E 1 (k) x c 2 (k) = klIkl
(5.48)
Having chosen E i (k), 6 2 (k), there is still arbitrariness in the choice of E2(—k). By convention, we choose El
(—k) =
El
c i (—k),
(k)
E2(—k) = —E 2 (k)
(5.49)
as illustrated in Figure 5.1. The following sum over polarizations results in the transverse projection operator (see Problem 5.2): 2
I 11 (k)
k
si (k)e-si (k) =
(5.50)
lkl 2
s=i
We now expand the field in terms of the transverse plane waves: 1
(r, 0) =
Esi
k,s
(r, 0) = —
,
(k) [ct s (k)e iler
clI(k)e —ik.r]
V2C0k
)2, k,s
Wk j — es 2Q
r
(k) La s (k)e — ct(k)e
—ik-r
(5.51)
5.4 Quantization in Coulomb Gauge
The commutation relations (5.45) are satisfied by imposing the commutation relations _a s (k), a(p) = ôs rôkp [a (k), ar (p)] = 0
(5.52)
where a s (k) is the annihilation operator of a photon — a field quantum of momentum k and linear polarization s. In the free-field case, the time dependent operator Aj (r, t) is simply obtained by replacing (k r) by (k . r —w kt) in the exponents in (5.51), because e iHt a s (p) e —il -It = as (p)e —iw P t
(5.53)
The Hamiltonian and total momentum operator of the electromagnetic field are given respectively by (k) a (k) (5.54)
ka s t(k)a s (k) k,s
These equations show that photons are boson with energy-momentum relation (1) k = IN. The vacuum state 10) is the state with no photons. All other states of the system can be generated by applying creation operators repeatedly to the vacuum state co, the expansion (5.51) becomes a Fourier integral: In the limit Q f
A-1(r,
=
2
Vic c(k, s) [a(k, s) e a"(2,yr) 3 2( 0 k s =
a 1 (k, s)e —ik l
(5.55)
where we write E (k, s) = E s (k) for consistency in notation. The continuum form of the annihilation operator is (5.56)
a(k, s) = ALQ a,(k)
which obeys the commutation relations a(k, s), at (k', s')] = (2,7)3 ss, (5 3 (k — le)
(5.57)
The Hamiltonian and total momentum now take the forms H
2
= _1 f d3 k Ikl 2 s=1 (2703
Jf d3 k ka (270 3
(k, s) a(k, s)
s) a(k, s)
(5.58)
77
8
5 Electromagnetic Field
5.5 Spin Angular Momentum
According to (5.43), the angular momentum density is u = r x [E x (V x A)]
(5.59)
We define the spin density to be the part that is independent of the origin of r. To find it, let us first rewrite the above in component form: ui =
jk e kl
mnq x j Elan A q
(5.60)
Now combine the last two c symbols according to the rule E klm E nqm
A A = tiknk-qq
(5.61)
— 6 kOln
We then obtain
= c i i k (xi Eqak Aq — x 1 Enan A k ) e i jk [ x j Eqa k Aq a n ( x j En Ak ) x j (anr)A k
±
En Ak
(5.62)
The factor xi in the first term cannot be remove by manipulations involving a k , because j k. The second term is a total 3-divergence, and can be ignored. The third term vanishes because V • E = 0. The last term is independent of r, and identified as the spin density: s=ExA
(5.63)
This is the spatial part of the tensor sPev
A al'"orfi
(5.64)
where TI2v is the spin matrix given in (3.52). The spin angular momentum is given by S
=
f
d 3 rE x A
(5.65)
Using the expansion (5.51), we obtain
s=iLk
2 (k)
1 a l (k) — al (k) a 2 (k)]
(5.66)
where Ic = k/lki. To diagonalize this, we make a linear transform to circularly polarized photons. The polarization vectors for circularly polarized photons are E±
1
iE 2 )
(5.67)
5.6 Intrinsic Parity
where the label k has been suppressed. As one can easily verify, the plane wave Re [c e i_(k tY
(5.68)
represents a traveling wave whose polarization vector rotates in a right-handed sense about k. This is called a left-circularly polarized wave, because an observer facing the incoming wave would see the polarization rotating to the left. Similarly, E_ corresponds to a right-circularly polarized wave. The annihilation operators for circularly polarized photons are given by Left-circularly polarized:
a±(k) =
Right-circularly polarized:
a_ (k) = —
a i (k) — ia 2 (k)] 1
2
i (k)
i a 2 (k)]
(5.69)
The commutation relations are [a±(k), a± 1 (p)] = 6kp [a+(k), a_ (p)] = [a+(k), a_ I (p)] = 0
(5.70)
In terms of these, the spin operator becomes diagonal: [a+(k)i a+ (k) —
S=
(k) a_ (k)]
(5.71)
This shows that the photon has spin 1, but there are only two helicity states. The helicity +1 corresponds to left-circular polarization, and —1 corresponds to rightcircular polarization: a ± (k) annihilates helicity state ± 1
(5.72)
In terms of circular polarization, the field operator has the expansion A(r, 0) =
,
1 {
[E +
k
(k) c _ (k)a_(k)]
k '\7Ic 2°)Q [E'14_ (k) a + I
(
k) + c* (k) aL (k)
(5.73)
In the convention (5.49) the sense of the circular polarizations remains unchanged when k —> —k: = ic+(k)
(5.74)
_(—k) = — ic_ (k)
5.6 Intrinsic Parity
Let us make a coordinate transformation r —> r', with the transformation law 3
pj kx/k 1=1
(5.75)
I
79
80
5 Electromagnetic Field
Since Ak is a vector field, this induces the unitary transformation U according to (3.54): 3
pj k A k
UA 1 (r) U 1 =
(5.76)
j =1
where AI (r) = A1 (r, 0). For spatial reflection r' = —r we denote the unitary transformation by?: (5.77)
PAk (r)P -1 = —Ac(—r)
This establishes the fact that the electromagnetic field has odd intrinsic parity. To investigate how photon states transform, we substitute into the above the expansion (5.51). Using the abbreviation 2
(5.78)
a(k) =»s(k)as(k) s=1
we have 1
PA(r)7) -1 = ,
[Pa(k)P- 1 e ilc.r
paï (k)p-1
‘/2W k +
2
(k)
LL ,/20)k,Q [a(—k)e 1 + 1
(
e
-
(5.79)
k a=1
where the last relation is obtained by changing the summation variable from k to —k. Thus, 'Pa(k)P -1 = —a(—k)
(5.80)
which gives Pa 1 (k)7 -1 = —a i (—k) Pa2(k)P -1 = a 2 (—k)
(5.81)
In terms of circular polarization, = —c2+(—k)
(5.82)
A one-photon state of momentum k, linear polarization s, is defined by lk, s) = aI(1c)10)
(5.83)
States with circular polarization are given by lk, +) = a (k)I0)
(5.84)
5.7 Transverse Propagator
which are linearly superpositions of states with linear polarizations: 1
lk, ±) = [1k, 1) ± ilk, 2 )]
(5.85)
2
Assuming that the vacuum state is invariant under reflection, we have 'Pik, ±) = 7)
(k)P -1 10) = — 1k, f)
(5.86)
Thus, under spatial reflection, left and right are interchanged, and the state vector changes sign.
5.7 Transverse Propagator
We now calculate the photon propagator in Coulomb gauge: (x) = —i(01TA'(x)AJ (0)10)
(5.87)
where the subscript T reminds us that the field is transverse: 8k A/ =--- 0. Expanding the field in creation and annihilation operators, we have (X)
f d 3 kd 3 k'
=
(17) 6
J
4 ww'
/ (01 ai (k, s)ai 1 ss ,
(le, s')10) e —i " (Xo
(01 a' (k', s')dit(k, s)10) e ik •x
(xo
>
0)
<0)
(5.88)
where w = lc()
(5.89)
and we use the abbreviation ct i (k, s)
E t (k, s)a(k, s)
(5.90)
The vacuum expectation values are easily calculated: (01 a' (k, s)a)
s')10) = (01a.) (k', sl ) a' (k, s)10) = (2,7) 3 6,,, 6 3 (k — k')E i (k, s)Ei(k', s')
(5.91)
Therefore
(%) = (2703 f d2c03 k e ik•x—witliij ( k)
(5.92)
8
82
5 Electromagnetic Field
where Ili is defined in (5.50). This can be rewritten as 4-dimensional Fourier integral, with the help of the identity 2o)
1
Do
27r i
_ 00
—tut
du (0 2
u2
—> 0+)
(5.93)
The final form is elk . x
d4 k
(x) =f (2704 k2
„
P 1 (lc) -
(5.94)
where k 2 = k — 1k1 2 . The Fourier transform is VT
7.
kiki
1
- k2
(5.95)
1ki2
This is not Lorentz covariant, for it is in Coulomb gauge. To prove that the quantized field theory is covariant, we should exhibit the gauge transformation that will maintain the form of the transverse propagator under Lorentz transformations. However, this is unnecessary, as we shall show in Chapter 11. The points is that non-covariant part of the propagator is physically irrelevant, because, owing to current conservation, it does not contribute to the scattering amplitude.
5.8 Vacuum Fluctuations
The vacuum state is neither an eigenstate of E nor B, since these operators annihilate or create photons singly. Although the fields average to zero, their mean-square fluctuations are large. This can be shown via direct calculation, but we can also demonstrate it through the following argument. The energy density in the vacuum state is (5.96)
(01E 2 +B2 10) = (01 E 2 10)
for the free field theory is invariant under the duality transformation. Equating this with the zero-point energy per unit volume in (5.54), we have (01E2 10) =
1
,
2_, co k ks
f
1 = (2703 1 d3 k1k
(5.97)
which diverges due to the short-wavelength modes. This divergence is harmless, since only energy differences have physical significance; but the long-wavelength part of the fluctuations give rise to observable effects, including the Casimir effect. We illustrate the essence of the Casimir effect in a simple one-dimensional example, leaving for the next section a more detailed treatment. Consider the modes
5.8 Vacuum Fluctuations
VVVVVVV\
<
Cutoff
>
Figure 5.2 When a wall is inserted into a box, those normal modes that do not have a node at the wall are suppressed. Consequently, the number of modes below a fixed frequency decreases, and the zero-point energy is lowered.
of a harmonic oscillator in a box of length L. The zero-point energy is 1 E0 (L) = — 2
f(w) 0.1
= .7rn/L (n = 1, 2, ... oo)
(5.98)
where we have introduced a cutoff function f(w), with the properties f(0) = 1 f(co) --> 0 (0--->co
(5.99)
There is a cutoff frequency (p c , above which f(co) decreases rapidly to zero, and we oc eventually. Suppose a partition is inserted, such that normal take the limit co, modes are required to have a node at the wall. The modes near the cutoff frequency are hardly affected, because their wavelengths are vanishingly small. Therefore, there are now fewer normal modes below the cutoff, as illustrated in Figure 5.2, and the zero-point energy decreases. Now insert two partitions into the box, separated by a distance a << L. As a decreases, an increasing number of modes are suppressed, and thus the zero-point energy decreases. This gives rise to an attractive force between the partitions, and the question is whether this force is independent of the cutoff frequency. For definiteness choose the cutoff function to be
1(60
)
=
(5.100)
8
84
f
5 Electromagnetic Field
The zero-point energy for a box without partitions can be easily calculated, with the result E0 (L) -=
1
g
8L sinh2 (yr/co,L)
_>. Ol c
Lcq g
27r2
24L
+ 0(o.) 2 )
(5.101)
Now insert two partitions centered about the midpoint, separated by distance a. The box is divided into 3 compartments, one with length a, and the others with length (L — a)I2, and the zero-point energy becomes E(a) = EOM +2E0 ((L
—
Lco 2, —>(0,-->-00 2.7'2
g
a)I2)
6(L —
Jr
a)
24a
(5.102)
In the limit L ---> co, the attractive force between the walls is given by aE(a)
g
aa
24a2
(5.103)
which is independent of the cutoff.
5.9 The Casimir Effect
We now calculate the force between two metallic plates in the electrodynamic vacuum. The first task is to obtain the normal modes of the electromagnetic field in a perfectly conducting box of size axbx c. We choose one corner of the box as origin, and use Coulomb gauge. On each face of the box, the boundary condition is (5.104)
Ell = 0 Bi_ = 0
where the subscripts II and I denote respectively the tangential and normal components. We put B = V x A, E = —A, to obtain A11 --,-- 0 (V x A)" ---= 0
(5.105)
On the y-z plane, for example, the boundary conditions are A y -=-- A, = 0 a y A z —
az A y ----= 0
The first says that A is normal to the surface, and therefore the second condition is automatically satisfied. We must, however, satisfy the gauge condition
8,A, + ay A y + az A z _ o
(5.106)
5.9 The Casimir Effect
which leads to
ax A x = 0
(5.107)
Thus, the boundary conditions in Coulomb gauge are
a
Am, 0 a n A1 = 0
(5.108)
For A, for example, the conditions are
ax A x (x, y,z)L =0 = [B,A x (x,y, z)_ x=a "-= A x (x, y,0) = A x (x, y, a) = 0 A x (x,y, 0) =- A x (x , y, c) = 0
(5.109)
A complete set of solutions to the wave equation is given by A, = cos(k,x) sin(k y y)sin(k,z) A y = sin(k,x)cos(k y y)sin(k,z) A z = sin(k,x) sin(k y y)cos(k z z)
(5.110)
where = yrn,/a
with
ni
k y = 7rn y /b k, = rrrnz /c
= 1, 2, ... , oo. The frequency is given by k
+k +k
(5.112)
If all three components of k are nonzero, there are two independent solutions corresponding to the ± signs in A. If any component of k vanishes, there is only one solution. For example, if k x = 0, then A, = A, = 0, and the ± sign does not make any difference. We can now obtain the zero-point energy: (5.113)
)--: k x ,k y ,k,
+
+k F
(5.114)
where F(k) is a cutoff function. Consider now a large cubicle box of edge L, which is divided into 3 compartments as shown in Figure 5.3, with two parallel metallic plates inserted normal to the xaxis, separated by a distance a, symmetrical about the midpoint. The zero-point energy is the sum of those of the compartments. That of the middle compartment,
I
85
6
5 Electromagnetic Field
Figure 5.3 Two metallic plates separated by distance a in the electrodynamic vacuum, which is represented by a cube of 00. edge L
of dimensions Lx Lxa, with
L
oc, is given by
U(a) = E0 (a, L, L)
L2 f d 2 k
2(27 ) 2
kF(k)
Yr2 n2 /a 2 F ( 1/k 2
+ 2 1.: 1/k 2
yr 2 n2/ a 2)
n=1 L2 .=
3T 2 L2 00
f(51 2 kk F(k)
4yr
4a3 ns=1
G(n)
(5.115)
where 00
G(n)
=
dy IfF(3r
2
if/a)
(5.116)
We can rewrite the n-sum using the Euler-MacLaurin formula [2] oo
oo
G(n)
f
=
dnG(n)
n=1
1
— G(0) 2
B2
/
B4
G (0) — 7,— G L! 2!
I
,/
(0) + • •
(5.117)
where B2 = 1/6, B4 = —1/30. Using G'(0) = 0, G m (0) = —4, and the fact that all higher derivatives vanish at n = 0, we obtain 00
00
f
G(n) =
f
dnG(n)
dyly- F(yrif/a)
n=1
4 4!30
This leads to Ci a -I- C2
U(a) = L2
76 2 -
(5.118)
720a 3
where = C2 =
Tx) dr r dkk-ik 2
4.7.2 .D 1
8:r
f
0
°()
r2 F
0
dk k 2 F(k)
(5.119)
5.9 The Casimir Effect
1.5
1.0 d (micron)
0.5
0
2.0
Figure 5.4 The Casimir attractive force between two metallic plates in the vacuum: x-chromium steel, o-chromium. Solid line-Theory. Data from M. J. Sparnay, Physica, 24, 751 (1958).
The zero-point energy in the box in Figure 5.3 is given by E(a) = U(a) +2 U((L — a)/2) L
+ 2 C2
,7t
2 -
720a 3 _
This gives an attractive force per unit area between the plates, given by
f
1 aE(a) L2 a a
gr 2
240a4
(5.120)
or, in practical units, 1=
1C 2 h
240a4
0.013 dyne/cm 2 4 a
(5.121)
where a is in p.m. Figure 5.4 shows a comparison between this result and early measurements [3], with reasonable agreement. More recent measurements of a similar force between a plate and a sphere have achieved much greater experimental accuracy [4].
87
88
5 Electromagnetic Field
5.10 The Gauge Principle
We now discuss how the electromagnetic field should be coupled to charged fields. A non-relativistic charged particle obeys the Schr6dinger equation [ 21m
(v
a (r , t) = — v(r, t)
i eA) 2 + eq)
at
(5.122)
where A, 0 are the vector and scalar potentials of an external electromagnetic field, and e is the charge of the particle. We can derive the form of the interaction as follows. In the absence of external fields, the Schrbdinger equation is invariant under a global gauge transformation (5.123)
(r, t) —4- e —i w v(r, t)
where co is an arbitrary real constant. The invariance depends on the fact that ai, lp and transform in the same manner as lp . If we make a local gauge transformation, with co dependent on r, t, these conditions will not hold, for we have —
e
aU
cow]
(5.124)
To make the equation invariant, we must cancel the terms involving at, w. This can done by introducing the fields AY = (A, 0) through the replacement
a
+ ieA" (x) 11)(x)
(5.125)
The Schr6dinger equation is now invariant under the local gauge transformation A" (x) + B'1 (x) Ip(x) --> exp[—iez(x)]p(x) (x)
(5.126)
The quantity
(x)
DP/p(x) =[aP + ieA" (x)]
(5.127)
is called the covariant derivative, and Af1 is called the gauge field, and the recipe to replace a- by DP is called the gauge principle. Actually, the gauge principle works only for a fully relativistic theory. For the non-relativistic Schr6dinger equation, it fails to produce magnetic moment terms of the form —p • V x A, which has to be put in by hand, with p arbitrary. In the relativistic Dirac equation discussed in the next chapter, the gauge principle gives the full electromagnetic interaction of the electron, with a completely determined magnetic moment. As a relativistic example, consider the complex scalar field with Lagrangian density fo(x ) = a f` v * a„ —
*
(5.128)
Problems
which is invariant under the global gauge transformation (x)
(5.129)
e»(x)
where w is a constant; but it is not invariant when w depends on x. To extend the symmetry to local gauge invariance, we make the replacement (5.130)
+ ieA"(x)
a" =
where e is the electric charge. The Lagrangian density is generalized to 1 G(x) = -- Fl" F „„ ' 4
(D)* D 1
m2 ip*tp
(5.131)
which is invariant under the local gauge transformation 0(x) e (x) 0(x) Au( x ) —> A" (x) z(x)
(5.132)
where x(x) is an arbitrary space-time function. The Lagrangian density of the free electromagnetic field is included to make the system self-contained dynamically.
Problems
Problem
5.1
The Lagrangian density for the electromagnetic field in the presence of an external current density ji` is =
1 Fl" F„„ — j'"A II 4
What is the condition on j" in order that this be gauge invariant? Problem 5.2 Consider the symmetric tensor 2
(k)E!, (k)
(k) = a=---1
= 0, and I ii = 2. a) Show kI 11 = ki b) Using the above conditions show the statement in (5.50): (k) = (S i
1k12
I
89
90
I
5 Electromagnetic Field
Problem 5.3 Verify that the field operators (5.51) satisfy the commutation relations (5.45). Show, in particular, that the transverse delta function arises from thet ransversality of the polarization vectors expressed by (5.50). Problem 5.4 Rotations Apply the transformation law (5.76) to rotations. In particular, let R be a rotation of the coordinate system about z axis through yo, and be that about the x axis through 7r: /
x = x' cos cp + y' sin ço
R:
y = —x' sin ya + y' cos cio z .------ z'
X
: {
{
=
X
y = --/ z = —z
Show that the creation operators transform as indicated in the following: a+ (k)
Ra +(k)R -1 = e
= a+(k)
R a'!+_(—k) R -1 =
= a i+ (k)
RaL(k)R -1 = ei(P ai_(k)
. at (k) —I- = al_(—k)
Rai (—k)R -1 =e
aL (k)
Problem 5.5 Two-Photon States [5] We can obtain interesting information about a state of two photons by examining its behavior under rotations and reflection. Consider two photons with momenta k and —k. There are 4 independent states of polarization, which can be classified according to circular polarizations:
I++) 1+—) I—H--)
= a l+ (k)a4(—k)10) = a +' (k)a -LA—k)10) = ai (k)a + l (—k)10)
I -- ) =
aL (k)a'f (—k)10)
a) Verify that, in terms of states with linear polarization, =
— a(k)4(_k)] 10)
[al (k) 2 (—k) + a2(k)al (—k) 10) _
1+ — ) = [al (k) al (—k) +
a2(1c)a (—k) + i al (k)a2(—k) — i a '2(k) al (—k)
0)
I ---F) = [al (k)al (—k) +
c14(k)a';(—k) — 1(k)a( —k) + ic4(k)c4 (—k)
0)
Problems
From this, note that the polarization of the two photons are correlated: • in the state 1+ +) + 1— —) the planes are parallel; • in the state 1+ +)-1--) the planes are orthogonal; O in the states 1+—) and 1—+), the planes have equal probability of being parallel or orthogonal. b) Work out the transformation laws for the 4 polarization states under R,
, P,
using results of the last problem, and the fact that the vacuum state is invariant. Verify the results are summarized in the table of eigenvalues (listed whenever the state in question is an eigenstate of the operation indicated):
R
P
I+ + ) + I- -)
I+ -I
1+-) l-+)
1
1
e --240
1
1
1
—1
e 240
1
c) From the table above, verify the following quantum numbers for a two-photon
state: * The only state with odd parity is I++)—I--). There are 3 states with even parity: 1+ +)+1--), 1+—), and 1—+). • For odd total angular momentum J = 1, 3, 5, • • • , the only possible states are 1+—) and 1— +). The reason is as follows: The other two states are both eigenstates of R and with eigenvalue 1. However, an eigenstate of R with eigenvalue 1 must have the rotation properties of the spherical harmonic yy, and therefore changes sign under for J = 1, 3, 5, • • • . O For total angular momentum J = 0, 1, the only possible states are 1+ +) + 1--) and 1++)-1--), because the other two states have spin projections ±2 along the z-axis, values that are too large for J = 0, 1. d) Verify that a two-photon state cannot have J = 1. This gives Yang's selection rule [6]: A spin 1 particle cannot decay into two photons. For example, since the 7r0 meson decays into two photons, we know that its spin cannot be 1. (It is in fact a spin 0 particle.)
Problem 5.6 Dirac Monopole A magnetic monopole has a magnetic field B pole — g17 r2 , with total magnetic flux 4,7g. This makes V • Bpoie O. We can reconcile this with Maxwell's equation V • B = 0 by postulating a returning flux —47rg concentrated in a "string" — an infinitely narrow flux tube. The vector potential then consists of a part due to the
I
91
92
5 Electromagnetic Field
monopole, and a part due to the string: A=
Apole + Astring
ifi VxAp ole 7-7 B pole . It is determined h satisfies where Ap olei--s any vector potential that only up to a gauge transformation. a) Give one solution for Apole• b) The shape of the string can be change through a gauge transformation. For a straight-line string leading from the monopole to infinity, show that the vector potential of the string is of the pure-gauge form Astring = —2gVya
where ça is the azimuthal angle around the string. c) Consider a quantum-mechanical particle of electric charge e in the field of the monopole, with wave function p. Show that the string can be transformed away through a gauge transformation
,1» e
-2igeço v
d) Since 7p has to be single-value, the coefficient of ()a in the exponent must be an integer n, and thus ge = n/2
This is the Dirac quantization condition. The mere possibility that a monopole can exist quantizes the electric charge. e) Show that the total angular momentum of the system consisting of a charge e and a monopole g points from the charge to the monopole, and has the magnitude ge. Obtain the Dirac quantization condition by quantizing the angular momentum. Problem 5.7 Cutoff Functions a) Calculate the vacuum energy (5.98) for a one-dimensional system using a sharp cutoff, which corresponds to f(w) = 0 (c. o c — co), and show E(a) =
La) 2
W;
4yr
4
(sharp cutoff)
When L is divided into segments a and L — a, this is independent of a. Thus there will be no force between inserted partitions.
References
b) Show, on the other hand, that any continuous cutoff function will a nonzero cutoff-independent force. To do this, write 00
TC
E0(L) = — 2L
f(7rn/w, n=1
Since the argument off approaches a continuous variable in the limit co, —> Do, we can approximate the sum by an integral, using the Euler—MacLaurin formula (5.117): :7T
E0(L)
f
Lw 2 =
fTB2
dnn f(yrn1 (DJ)
4L
71-
dYYPY)
0(o)2)
24L
The cutoff-independent term is the same as that in (5.101).
References
1
Huang, K. (1992) Quarks, Leptons, and Gauge Fields, 2nd Ed., World Scientific, Singapore, Chap. 8. 2 Abramowitz, M.J. and Stegun, I.A. (eds)
(1964) Handbook of Mathematical Functions, National Bureau of Standards, Washington, p. 806.
Sparnay, M.J. (1958) Physica, 24, 751. Lamoreaux, S.K. (1997) Phys. Rev. Lett., 78, 5. 5 Yang, C.N. (1950) Phys. Rev., 77, 242. 6 Yang, C.N. op. cit., Landau, L.D. (1948) Dokl. Akad. Nauk. (USSR) 60, 207. 3 4
93
95
6 Dirac Ecpation 6.1 Dirac Algebra
A relativistic wave equation must treat space and time on the same footing. The Klein—Gordon equation does that, but it involves second time derivatives, a feature responsible for its failure as a one-particle equation. Dirac tries to remedy this by proposing a first-order differential equation. To obtain a equation for the wave function //) that is linear in the space-time derivatives a/t ip , Dirac writes (iy ,"611
—
m) 7,0(x) = 0
(6.1)
where the r" are numerical coefficients, so far undetermined. To satisfy the relativistic kinematics, V)(x) must also satisfy the Klein—Gordon equation. Multiplying from the left by (i yi` a + m), we have
a + m)(i y a„ — inylp(x) = —OP" y"ai, „ + ns'ytp(x)
0 = (i y
y
y rit)ad v
2
rn 2 /p(x)
(6.2)
This reduces to the Klein—Gordon equation (02
+ m 2),1» (x)
(6.3)
if and only if y
;)„, V+ y V y y
2g/11,
(6.4)
This algebraic relation defines 4 objects yf', which anticommute with one another, with (y0)2
1
(y k)2
Clearly
yP
(6.5)
cannot be numbers. They can be represented by matrices, called Dirac
matrices. Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
96
6 Dirac Equation
According to (6.4) yUy '' should be a hermitian matrix. Thus y' is either hermiy and taking the trace of both sides in (6.4), we tian or antihermitian. Putting y obtain Try =0
(6.6)
= 0, 1, 2, 3)
This condition immediately rules out matrices of odd dimension. It also rules out dimension 2, for there are only 3 independent traceless 2 x 2 matrices — the Pauli matrices. Therefore, the dimension must be at least 4. That a 4 x 4 representation exists can be shown by explicit construction. Define the following 4 x 4 hermitian matrices: Gr k)
Û
ak =
fi
k
(1
(6.7)
—1)
where 1 stands for the 2 x 2 unit matrix, and o-k are the 2 x 2 Pauli matrices:
=
(0 1) 1
02 (0 —i) 0)
03 = (1 0 —1)
(6.8)
We shall not use different notations for 2 x 2 and 4 x 4 matrices, since the context usually makes the meaning clear. It follows from the definitions that ( a k)2 = fi2 = 1
foc k ,fil = 0
(6.9)
A standard representation for the Dirac matrices is = fi = (1 0 ) 0 —1
y0
k
(6.10)
0
= y 0y a k =
0 ak)
(6.11)
The matrix y ° is hermitian with (y 0 ) 2 = 1, and y k is antihermitian, with ( y k) 2 = —1: (y
y0
yk =
( y 0)2 ( y k)j- ( y k)2 = 1
(6.12)
From these we can show 0
(y
ti ,
0
=
Y
t,
(6.13)
The representation given here is not unique. A unitary transformation Syu S ' gives an equally acceptable set of matrices, since such a transformation obviously preserves (6.4).
6.1 Dirac Algebra
The yl' and their products, together with the unit matrix, generates a set of 16 independent 4 x 4 matrices, in terms of which any 4 x 4 matrix can be expanded. We introduce special symbols for some of their products: y5 = i y 0 y 1 y 2 y 3
a ity =
( y ‘ti
yl
(6.14)
The "fifth" Dirac matrix y5 is hermitian, with square 1, and anticommutes with all four y u : (Y5) i = Y5 (Y5) 2 = 1
(6.15)
{y5 , rit } =
In our standard representation it has the form _ (0 1) Y5 — 0)
(6.16)
The generalized Pauli matrices al" = —," have 6 independent members: Ok
• k = ta
= E ijk 0, k
(6.17)
where 0 ic denotes the matrix of 2 x 2 blocks made up of Pauli matrices along the diagonal. It is straightforward to show that ak
y5 a k
y O aiii y 0 = 0/1»
(6.18)
A complete set of 16 independent 4 x 4 matrices F, is given in Table 6.1. By are traceless except for ro: definition, we take To 1. All the Tr F, = 0 (n
0)
(6.19)
The set is closed under multiplication and commutation, and is called the Dirac algebra. The commutators are given in Table 6.2. An arbitrary 4 x 4 matrix M can be expanded in the form 15
cd;
M=
(6.20)
n=0
where Co =-7 CV
=
1 4
— Tr
M
Tr (MF,) Tr (Tii ) 2
(6.21)
97
8
6 Dirac Equation
Table 6.1 Matrices of the Dirac algebra
Number
1
1
Yu
4
Y5 Y u aity
4 6 1
Total
16
Table 6.2 Commutators of the Dirac algebra
=
[Y 2" , Y u ]
2y À y ," — 2g4 2ysy,"
[Y5 , ru] [Y5)/ 11, Y u ]
=
0
=
[ 0-4, rti]
=
2y )" 2 i (y ), gp1t _ y pet )
[a?"P, 75]
=
0
[ 0..4 y 5 ra ]
=
[y5r', rs]
[ 0.4
v
2 i 0.4 gpv _ 0,)4ve1t
GrPt,
a p,u g tiv)
6.2 Wave Functions and Current Density
Rewriting the Dirac equation in a 3-vector notation, we have ,
(— ia • V ± fin't) ?P( ) =
a tp (x) at
(6.22)
This looks like a single-particle wave equation with Hamiltonian
H = a •p
m
(6.23)
where p is the momentum operator. The wave function 1,0(x) is a 4-component column vector called a Dirac spinor: 01\
=
1P2
(6.24)
\IP41
where
i are complex numbers. The complex conjugate is the column vector
(6.25)
6.3 Plane Waves
and there are other types of conjugates: Hermitian adjoint: Pauli adjoint:
= (7/4 'Ç4 7p3
7,04 ) —
— V:)
(6.26)
The hermitian conjugate of (6.1) reads
(x)] r"' — rn/p (x)
[a
(6.27)
=0
Now write lp t = y ° , and use y ° y adjoint:
° = yP to obtain the equation for the Pauli (6.28)
(84)iyft + my) = 0
Another way of writing this is (6.29)
Ip(irut, + rn) = 0
where the overhead arrow on a indicates that it acts to the left. The conserved current density is given by (6.30)
1PYP/P
It is easy to see, with the help of (6.1) and (6.29), that api u = (a/l/P)rti V + y tp
mI
a1
)
(6.31)
=0
Note that j° is positive-definite: (6.32)
as opposed to =VPi + 7,4 11)2 — 7,61'zP3 —
IP4
(6.33)
The current jP can therefore serve as a particle current density. As we shall see, however, the Dirac equation fails to qualify as a single-particle equation for a different reason, namely the energy spectrum is not bounded from below. The remedy is a redefinition of the vacuum state known as "hole theory", which makes the system a many-particle system. With this modification, j ° is no longer positive definite, but can be interpreted as a charge density.
6.3 Plane Waves
Plane-wave solutions to the Dirac equation can be constructed by putting (x) = e —i P'xu(p)
(6.34)
99
100
I
6 Dirac Equation
where pl`
(p ° , p), and u(p) is a column vector called a Dirac spinor:
u(p) =
(6.35)
Since Tp(x) satisfies the Klein—Gordon equation, we have 2
P
Po
2
2
=- 0
For given momentum, there are two roots for the energy p ° , with opposite signs: (6.36)
Po = ±E
where E is defined as the positive quantity E=
Vp2 n12
(6.37)
The Dirac equation now takes the form (0 — m)u(p) =0
(6.38)
where 0 is a 4 x 4 matrix defined by = ylipp
y Op0
y kpk
(6.39)
It has the property ± 00 = 2p • q
(6.40)
which follows from (6.4). To find explicit solutions, we note that (1t
-
(6.41)
in)(o + rn ) = p2— rn2
Thus, each column of the matrix (0 + m) satisfies the Dirac equation. The explicit form of the matrix is 7m + p0 +
o
0 m po
— P3 — p+
m— p 0
0
(6.42)
where p± „ p
ip2
(6.43)
6.3 Plane Waves
The number of independent columns can be found by letting p k ---> 0, since the matrix is a continuous function of p k . In that limit p° = ±m, and the matrix becomes proportional to
1 0 0 0\ 0100 0000
for
p° > 0
0 0/
000 000 010 001
for p ° < 0
This shows that columns 1 and 2 are independent for p° > 0, while columns 3 and 4 are independent for p ° < 0. The independent solutions are then columns 1 and 2 of (6.42) for p ° = E, and columns 3 and 4 for p ° = —E. We designate them as u(p, s). The explicit solutions for p° = E are 0 ) 1 u(p, 2) = C p_/(m E) \—p 3 /(m E) f
u(p, 1) =
(6.44)
The solutions for p ° = —E are 7-13 3 /(m
u(p, 3) = C
—
+ E)\
p+/(rn + E)
\
1
/
/—p_/(m E)\ p 3 /(m E) u(p, 4) = C 0 \ 1 /
(6.45)
where
E=
p2
± m2
C = V(m E)/2m
(6.46)
For a given p, these solutions form an orthogonal set: u t (p, s)u(p, s') = (E/m)(5 ,
(6.47)
For a given energy, the wave functions above resemble those of a non-relativistic particle of spin 1/2, and it is natural to regard s as a spin label. We shall see that this is a correct interpretation. Taking the hermitian conjugate of the equation (6.38), we have u (p, s)(0 1 — m) = 0
(6.48)
Multiplying the equation from the right by y °, and using the identity
y Oot y 0
(6.49)
we find the Pauli-adjoint equation
ft(p, s)(0 — m) = 0
(6.50)
o
102
6 Dirac Equation
Multiplying (6.48) from the right by u, and (6.38) from the left by ut, and writing out 6 more explicitly, we have ul (y ° p ° — y k pk — rn)u = 0 u (y o_ p o y kp k =
(6.51)
Adding the two equations leads to the relation 0
(6.52)
-
14, = -14U
We can restate the orthonormality of the solutions in the form (6.53)
s)u(p, s') = ±dssi
where the plus sign applies for the positive-energy solutions, corresponding to s = 1, 2, and the minus sign is used for the negative-energy solution with s = 3, 4.
6.4 Lorentz Transformations
Under a Lorentz transformation x' = Ax, the Dirac equation in the new frame reads (
irua; — m) v/(x') = o
(6.54)
Note that y'1 remains unchanged, because it is just a numerical matrix. We relate the new wave function to the old through a linear unitary transformation: 10x')
=
S(x)
st s
=1
(6.55)
where S is a non-singular 4 x 4 unitary matrix. To demonstrate Lorentz covariance, we shall show that there exists a non-singular transformation on y 11 that will restore the Dirac equation to the old form. Putting aft = A a, and multiplying the equation by S -1 from the left, we obtain ,
S -1 (iy/tA8, — m)S1p(x) = 0
which reduces to the original equation if (S1 y "
=
y 'or
S —l eS =
(6.56)
The existence of S will be demonstrated by explicit construction. It suffices to consider an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation (6.57)
6.4 Lorentz Transformations
where (14 contains 6 infinitesimal parameters, the three rotations 0 k and the three boosts v k of the coordinate frame: (t)
Ok
= (,t)
k0
w ij
=V jk ek
(6.58)
We put (6.59)
S=1+R
where R is an infinitesimal hermitian matrix linear in co,. To first order in 04 the condition for covariance is w;yft = i[y", R]
(6.60)
We can write R as a linear combination of the T, of Table 6.1, whose commutators are listed in Table 6.2. As we can see, only cr 4 can contribute to R. Thus R must have the form R = C co it ,,a,"", and a short calculation determines C = —1/4. Therefore S=1—
4
(6.61)
„
This demonstrates the Lorentz covariance of the Dirac equation. Comparison with (3.52) shows that the spin operator is z ,tiv _
v
(6.62)
2
Writing S in terms of the parameters of the infinitesimal Lorentz transformation, we have 1 —v• a + — 0 • 2 2
S
(6.63)
A finite rotation about a given axis can be build up from successive infinitesimal rotations about the same axis: S = e i0.612 = cos — + iê o- sin — 2
2
(6.64)
where 0 is a vector whose direction is the axis of rotation, and whose magnitude is the angle of rotation. Similarly, for a Lorentz boost of the reference frame with finite velocity y corresponds to S=
= cosh — — 0 • a sinh — 2 2
(6.65)
where = tanh -1 y
(6.66)
103
104
J
6 Dirac Equation
The advantage of using 0 is that, unlike v, it is additive for successive boosts. We note that S is unitary for rotations, but not for Lorentz boosts. The Dirac equation realizes a finite-dimensional representation of the Lorentz group. As we have seen in Chapter 3, the smallest faithful representation of the Lorentz group is of dimension 2. Here the dimension is doubled in order to represent spatial reflections. Consider the total reflection of the spatial coordinate system r'
—r
(6.67)
t' = t
In the transformed frame, the Dirac equation reads
a
a
k
axik
m
)
Putting p '(x') = S0 (x), and multiplying the equation from the left by S -1 , we have
i(s — l y °s)— aat
i(s — lyks)
a axk
which exhibits covariance if there exist S that commutes with y °, anticommutes with y k with S 2 = 1. An obvious choice is ,
S = y ° (Spatial reflection)
(6.68)
which shows the necessity for 4 x 4 matrices. For total space-time reflection x' = —x, we have (—iraa,„ — m)'(—x) = 0
with complex conjugate — m)0/*(—x) = 0
Accordingly we put = S0*(x)
To restore the original equation, we seek S that anticommutes with ru, with S 2 = 1, and an obvious solution is S = y 5 (Space-time reflection)
(6.69)
For time reversal, which is the product of space-time reflection with spatial reflection, we have S = y ° y 5 (Time-reversal)
(6.70)
6.5 Interpretation of Dirac Matrices
Table 6.3 Transformation properties
iu
Scalar
Tir" u
Vector
rty5 y u Pseudovector u Tiy5 u
Tensor
Pseudoscalar
This is an algebraic transformation that preserves the form of the Dirac equation when t is replaced by —t; but it is not the operation that governs physical states, which must be taken as states in quantum field theory. In the next chapter, we shall see that physical time reversal must involve complex conjugation of the state. For a plane-wave state we have
(x) = e —i "u(p, s) (6.71)
Di! (pf , s')
(x')
where p' is the 4-momentum with respect to the new frame, and s' labels the new solutions. Since p • x is invariant, we have ut (pl , s') = S u(p, s) a/ (p', s') = a(p, s) S
(6.72)
In general, we can reshuffle the 4 solutions in the new frame; but since a Lorentz transformation preserves the sign of the energy, the mixing of solutions can only occur among s = 1, 2, and separately among s = 3, 4. With this freedom understood, we set .5' = s by convention. It is straightforward to show (Problem 6.2) Y cl u(-13,
u(p, s) u(p, s)
1,2) (s = 3,4) (s =
(6.73)
which indicates that positive-energy and negative-energy states have opposite parity. We see from (6.72) that au is invariant under a Lorentz transformation, and ay ," u transforms like a 4-vector. More generally, the transformation properties of aT," u are listed in Table 6.3.
6.5 Interpretation of Dirac Matrices
The Dirac matrices a k are velocity components in the sense d dt = i[H, x k 1
=
(6.74)
i
105
106
6 Dirac Equation
Individually, each component has eigenvalues +1, but the components do not commute with one another. This conjures up the picture that the electron performs a curious dance at the speed of light about its average motion called the zitterbewegung. But this motion is not directly observable. (See Problem 6.5.) Expectation values of the Dirac matrices, on the other hand, have physical significance. Let I E) be a normalized eigenstate of energy: HIE) = EIE) (RIE) = 1
(6.75)
We have the trivial identity (El(HO — OH)IE) = 0
(6.76)
which can be rewritten in the form (El(HO + OH — 20 H)I E) = 0
(6.77)
This gives 1
(0) = 2E ({H, O})
(6.78)
where (0) =( E I 01 E) / (E I E). Choosing for O the Dirac matrix fi, we find
m (fi) = 7 = -\/ 1 - v 2
(6.79)
As we have seen, a is the velocity. Hence the magnetic moment is p=
e 2
-I' X
a
(6.80)
where e is the electric charge. Now put 0 = It in (6.78). A straightforward calculation gives e (p) .= — (L + 2S) 2E
(6.81)
where L = r x p is the orbital angular momentum, and S = aI2 is the spin operator. This show that the gyromagnetic ratio associated with the intrinsic spin is 2, but that associated with orbital motion, as in spin-orbit coupling, is 1. We shall verify these properties, and give physical interpretations.
6.6 External Electromagnetic Field
The Dirac equation in the presence of an external electromagnetic field Au (x) is [iy/ID,„ — m] tp(x) = 0
(6.82)
6.6 External Electromagnetic Field
with
=
ieA fi (x)
(6.83)
The Hamiltonian has the form H = a • a- + fim eq5
where
(6.84)
(x) = (x), and a is the kinetic momentum (6.85)
p — eA(x)
where p is the one-particle momentum operator defined by [p It is straightforward to verify the equations dadt du dt
e (E
a x B) (6.86)
2:r x a
where E and B are respectively the external electric and magnetic fields. The first equation is the analog of the Lorentz-force equation, and the second describes spin precession. Taking the dot product of the second equation with a, we have du dt
2a•a-xa= 2Jrx :r a
(6.87)
Noting that axa- =—e(Axp+pxA) =—ieB
(6.88)
we can write a-
du = —2iea • B dt
(6.89)
Combining this with the equation for daldt, we obtain d(u • a) = eu E dt
(6.90)
In arriving at this equation, we used the identity ux a = 2ia, which can be obtain from ux u = 2i o- by observing that a = y 5 0-. The equations (6.89) and (6.90) have interesting physical consequences [1]. For E = 0, (6.90) states d(u • a) dt
(In pure magnetic field)
(6.91)
That is, the spin projection along the velocity is a constant of the motion in a pure magnetic field. This means that the precessional frequency of the spin is exactly
07
108
6 Dirac Equation
equal to the orbital frequency. Deviations from this law measure corrections due to quantum field effects. For B = 0, (6.89) states •
du —
(In pure electric field)
0
(6.92)
dt
Suppose a longitudinally polarized particle moves along the z axis, loses energy, and stops. This equation says duz /d t = 0, or that the particle is not depolarized. This result is crucial to the interpretation of the classic experiment [2] that established parity violation in the decay process yr – y – f). The y-mesons were observed after being stopped in matter, and found to be longitudinally polarized. The above result shows that they had the same longitudinal polarization at the moment of decay.
6.7 Non-Relativistic Limit
We shall study the non-relativistic limit of (6.82) by first putting it in second-order form. Multiplying it from the left by i y "D i, m, we obtain ()iv D„D ± m2) V = 0
(6.93)
Writing the first term as half the symmetric part plus the antisymmetric part with respect to the labels y and y, we can show y r" D v
+ –21
= g"I` D„
y "[D„, D„]
(6.94)
A straightforward calculation gives [De , D„] = ieF111,
(6.95)
We thus arrive at the second-order equation (.1Y 1 D,„
uf"
+ m2 ) V = 0
Consider a stationary solution of energy E, with the equation in the form [(p – eA) 2 – ea • B
(6.96)
alp lat
iea • E ± m 2 ] V= (E
–
e0) 2 1p
E p. We can rewrite
(6.97)
where we have used the relation 1 – cri'vF = –u • B 2
ia • E
(6.98)
The equation displays a magnetic-moment term u • B, with electric-moment term a E generated by the moving magnetic moment.
6.7 Non-Relativistic Limit
In the non-relativistic limit the components 1/) 3 and 7P4 are small, and it is convenient to rewrite the above in two-component form by putting (6.99) where z and are two-component column vectors. Substituting this into the Dirac equation (6.82), we obtain the coupled equations
(E —
— m)z — • (p — eA) =0 (E— e0 + — u • p — eA)z = 0
(6.100)
Solving for the "small" component we have u • (p — eA)z E — e0 4- m
(6.101)
which shows that it is of order Ipl / E compared to the "large" component z. The second-order equation can be rewritten in the block form (.7t2 — eu • B + m2 ieu • E
jeu eu- •-F
(6.102) )
(X )
= (E e4))2 ( X )
where a- = p — eA. We write the equation for z, and eliminate g with the help of (6.101): — eu — • B rn2 +
(u E)(oE e0 + m _
•
z = (E — e0) 2z
(6.103)
—
which is an exact equation. We go to the non-relativistic limit by putting
E=m
E
(6.104)
and assume c <.< m and e0 << m. Keeping only terms to first-order in c and es75, we obtain 1
2 + 4
2m
e
2m
u B=—— S•B
4 m2
o- E x +
ie
z = cz (6.105) This has the form of a Schrbdinger equation except for the non-hermitian iE • term, which reflects the fact that ztz is not conserved, due to the existence of negative-energy states. A one-particle interpretation is consistent only when this term can be neglected. The magnetic-moment term has the form 2m
o- • B
4 m2
E
(6.106)
where S = u/2 is the spin operator. The coefficient of the magnetic field gives the magnetic moment: ii = (e/2 m)gS
(6.107)
09
110
6 Dirac Equation
where (6.108)
g=2
is the gyromagnetic ratio. There is a small correction to this value, known as the anomalous magnetic moment, due to vacuum fluctuations of the quantum fields. The spin-orbit interaction is contained in the term Fli =
e 4 m2
(6.109)
u Exz
In a central electrostatic field, with A = 0 and (6.110)
E =
we can write e
e çb'
4m2 r
2m2 r
where L = r x p. Viewed from a frame co-moving with electron, this can be interpreted as the energy —p' • B' of a magnetic moment p' in the magnetic field B' = E x y = — r x 02
-
r
(6.112)
where v = p/ m. This gives it' =
g' (e 12m)S
(6.113)
with (6.114)
g' = 1
which is in agreement with experiments on the fine structure of atomic spectral lines.
6.8 Thomas Precession
The electron exhibits two different gyromagnetic ratios: g = 2 with respect to an external magnetic field, and g' = 1 with respect to a magnetic field generated by its orbital motion in a central electrostatic potential. To understand these results, consider first an electron in an external magnetic field B. It moves in a circular orbit with the cyclotron frequency W cydotron =
(el rn)B
(6.115)
6.8 Thomas Precession
The spin precesses about the magnetic field according to the equation dpldt = x B. With p = gS, this gives a precession frequency CO precession
= ( e /2 in)gB
CO precession
—
(6.116)
Thus CO cyclotron
= ( e / 2 m)(g — 2)B
(6.117)
If g =- 2, as implied by the Dirac equation, the orbital motion and the spin precession are synchronized, as stated previously in (6.91). In reality g deviates slightly from 2, due to vacuum fluctuations, and g — 2 can be measured to very high accuracy by observing the slippage between orbital motion and spin precession. Consider now an electron moving in an electrostatic potential in a circular orbit. In the frame co-moving with the electron, there is a magnetic field B', about which the spin precesses with frequency Wrest
(6.118)
= (e/2m)gB'
with g = 2. However, this is not the precession frequency observed in the laboratory frame, due to the Thomas precession. This arises because the electron frame has a precession relative to the lab frame, due to the non-additivity of velocities in successive Lorentz transformations. To see this, make a Lorentz transformation from the laboratory frame, (which is presumed to be an inertial frame), to the instantaneous rest frame of the electron at time t. The orbital velocity y being small in the non-relativistic limit, the electron spinor undergoes an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation 1 =- 1 — — a • y 2
(6.119)
At time t dt, the velocity becomes y ± ad t, where a is the instantaneous acceleration, and we make a successive Lorentz transformation 1 S2 = 1 — — a • ad t 2
(6.120)
Over the time interval d t, we have made the overall transformation 1 2
S = S2 = (1 — — a • adt) (1— —1 a • v)
1 = 1 — — a • (y 2
2
1 adt) + — (a • a)(a v)dt 4
(6.121)
with last term causing the non-additivity of velocities. Now use the identity
(a
B) =
(a. • AO • B) = A • B
ia •AxB
(6.122)
and write (a • a)(a • y)dt = ia • a x ydt
(6.123)
111
112
6 Dirac Equation
Figure 6.1 Thomas precession.
where we have used the fact that a • y = 0 for circular motion. Thus 1 i S = 1— —a • (v + adt) + —o- • a x vdt 2
4
(6.124)
The last term is a pure rotation — an example of the Wigner rotation discuss in Section 3.6. It leads to the Thomas precession, with angular frequency (D y =
1 Xy 2
(6.125)
As illustrated in Figure 6.1, its sense is opposite to that of W rest , and the magnitude is given by co l = (e/2m).13'
(6.126)
-
The spin precession frequency in the lab frame is therefore Wlab = Wrest — WT =
(e/ 2 m)(g -1)B'
(6.127)
which leads to the result g' = g —1 = 1.
6.9 Hole Theory
The energy spectrum of the Dirac equation consists of a positive continuum extending from m to oo, and a negative continuum from —m to —oc. The negativeenergy levels cannot be ignored, because it is required by relativistic kinematics. Their existence destabilizes the theory, for, if there are any interactions at all, a particle can lose energy and fall down the bottomless pit of negative-energy states. Thus, no stable particles of positive energy can exist. Imagine that the negative spectrum is cut off at some large but finite depth. If the particles obey Fermi statistics, the avalanche will stop when all negative-energy level are filled with two particles (of opposite spin.) The filled "negative-energy sea" will be the state of lowest energy — the vacuum state. Removing a particle in this sea will create a hole that appears as an "antiparticle", in the sense that it can be
6.9 Hole Theo
Empty levels
Occupied levels
Figure 6.2 Vacuum state in hole theory.
annihilated with a particle falling into the hole. Redefining the vacuum state in this manner results in "hole theory", as illustrated in Figure 6.2. This redefinition of the vacuum state stabilizes the theory, and the important points are that • it is possible only if spin 1/2 particles obey Fermi statistics; • it makes the system into a many-particle system — a quantized field. In hole theory, the absence of a negative-energy particle corresponds to the presence of an antiparticle with positive energy. This is expressed through the fact that the wave function of an antiparticle of energy E and momentum p is the complex conjugate of that of a particle of energy —E and momentum —p. Accordingly, we shall redefine the solutions to the Dirac equation by reversing the momentum for negative-energy states. Let the positive-energy solutions be redesignated u+ (p, 1), u + (p, 2), and the negative-energy solutions u_ (p, 1), u_ (p, 2). We choose as a complete set the following: u(p, s) = Co u + (p, s) v(p, s) = Co u_(—p, s)
(6.128)
where Co = V(in
E
\/p2
E)/2m
7n2
(6.129)
They satisfy the equations
U6 — (pi
u(p, s) = 0 m)v (p, s) = 0
(6.130)
113
114
6 Dirac Equation
with adjoint equations s)(16— m) = 0 (6.131)
m) = 0
In the above equations, pa is defined such that p° > 0: (6.132)
-:=•• (E, P)
In 3-vector form, the equations read (a • p /3m) u(p, s) = E u(p, s) (—a • p
p m)v (p , s) = — Ev (p, s)
(6.133)
Note that the energy of v(p, s) is still negative, for all we did was to reverse the momentum, and write its energy as —E (with E > O.) The orthonormality of the solutions is expressed by the relations 4(p, s)u(p, s') = ass, ij(p, s)v(p, s') = — ass, (6.134)
s)u(p, s') -= 0
which are equivalent to ul (p, s)u(p, s') = (El rn)(5 ss' vi (p, s)v(p, s') = (E/m)assi u t (p, s)v(—p, s') = 0
(6.135)
The completeness of the solution is stated as 2
>_, [u(p , s ) u np, + v.(p, s ) v": (p, s)]
Et m) 6 b
(6.136)
s=-- 1
where a and b are spinor indices. This is equivalent to the matrix equation 2
[u(p, s)Et(p, s) — v(p, s)i3(p, s)] = 1
(6.137)
s=i
The terms above are respectively projection operators onto positive-energy and negative-energy states: 2
u(p,
A + (p) =
s) = (m + 0)/2m
s=i 2
v(p,$)(p,$) = (m —16)/2m
A +(p) = — s=i
(6.138)
6.10 Charge Conjugation
They have the properties [A ±(P)
2
= A ± (p)
A + (p)
_ (p) = 1
(6.139)
Note that the 4-vector pP in p is defined to have positive time component p ° = E. The Dirac equation cannot be a one-particle equation, but it furnishes a finitedimensional representation of the full Lorentz group. As such, it provides a complete set of one-particle wave functions, in terms of which we can analyze the operator of a spin 1/2 field, as we shall do in the next chapter.
6.10
Charge Conjugation
An antiparticle should have opposite charge to a particle, since it represents the absence of a particle in the negative-energy sea. This is intuitively obvious; but let us make certain that the formalism gives this result. In the presence of an external electromagnetic field AP (x) the Dirac equation is given by (6.82). We denote the wave function as ?p (x) for positive-energy plane wave states, and p`(x) for negative-energy plane-wave states: e —i Et+ ip.x u(p, s)
11) (x) (x)
e iEt—ip.x v (p, s )
(6.140)
where E = + Vp2 + m 2 . Then (6.82) can be rewritten 11)(x) = 0 — m]lp c (x) = 0
i eA — —
(6.141)
which show that the charge indeed has opposite signs for particle and antiparticle. The two equations above can be transformed into each other through "charge conjugation", or "particle-antiparticle conjugation". To change the sign of the coupling term in the first equation, we take the complex conjugate: [—iy*P(a
-
ieA p ) — m] tp*(x) = 0
(6.142)
We then make a unitary transformation to bring it to the form of the second equation. Thus, Tpc(x) = ipp*(x)
(6.143)
where )7 is a 4 x 4 matrix with the properties )7 2 = 1
(6.144)
= -y"
1
115
116
I
6 Dirac Equation
The solution is, in our standard representation of the Dirac matrices, y2
(6.145)
(where y 2 is the second Dirac matrix.) In terms of the spinors, charge conjugation corresponds to the transformation (6.146)
v (p, s) = 17 u* (p, s)
Since {y 2 y = O. this shows that particles and antiparticles have opposite parity. Like the time reversal discussed earlier, the charge conjugation here is an operation on Dirac wave functions, and not on physical states, which are defined in quantum field theory. They are relevant because we expand the quantum field operators in terms of Dirac wave functions. ,
6.11 Massless Particles
For a massless Dirac particle, with m = 0, the equation for the Dirac spinor reduces to Ou(p) = 0, or (a • p) u(p) = po u(p)
(6.147)
P0 = ± E,
(6.148)
where E
II
Since [a y5 ] = 0, we can diagonalize y 5 , whose eigenvalue ±1 is called "chirality". The solution with chirality +1 is called "right-handed", denoted u (p, R); one with chirality —1 is called "left-handed", denoted u (p, L): ',
y5 u(p, R) = u(p, R) y5 u(p, L) = —u(p, L)
(6.149)
Using the relation (6.150)
Ys a = a
we have (a • P) u(13) =
)1 5 U (P)
(6.151)
which states that the helicity (u •) is the chirality times the sign of the energy. Thus, for R the helicity is has the same sign as p ° , and for L it has the opposite sign. The helicity is not an independent variable for massless Dirac particles. We can classify the four independent spinors of given momentum p by chirality and
Problems
sign of energy: u_(p,
u+(p,
(6.152)
where = R, L is the chirality, and ± refers to the sign of the energy. With the mass equal to zero, we cannot normalize the spinors according to ut u = E/ in, as we did in (6.135). Instead, we put 2E
-= ô
(6.153)
With this normalization, the one-particle states 1p) have the properties (pi lp) = 2 E(2.7) 3 6 3 (p — p')
f d3 p (27)32E
(6.154)
11)41 = 1
We note that the Pauli adjoint
a is orthogonal to u:
=0
(6.155)
This is because it has opposite chirality, owing to the relation { y 5 , y = 0, and is left as an exercise (Problem 6.7). We must of course define the vacuum using hole theory. In analogy with the massive case, we define antiparticle spinors 1), and use a new notation: Â(P) (p)
u+
A)
u_ (—p, ./1,)
(6.156)
where ). = R, L. The independent solutions for given p are listed below with their quantum numbers: Chirality Helicity R UL
(6.157)
VR VL
Problems
Problem 6.1 Lorentz boost a) The transformation matrix for an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation is of the form S = 1 + iR, where R satisfies (6.60). Review the argument leading to the form R = Ccoa, , and show C = —1/4. b) Using the identity y'a-P 1'1 y ° = al", show
yo styo With this, verify the transformation law for 4 given in (6.72).
7
118
I
6 Dirac Equation
c) Obtain the free-particle solutions u(p, s) to the Dirac equation by applying a
Lorentz boost to the solutions in the rest frame. That is, . u(p, s) = cosh — + p • a smh — b 2 2 = tanh-1 v, and
where
b1 =
/0 \ b2 = 1
0 \O
/0 \
7O\
b3 =
V)/
0 \1!
b4 =
o o
Problem 6.2 Intrinsic parity
Show (6.73): u(p, s) Y ° u(- p,
(s -= 1, 2)
—u(p, s) (s = 3,4)
and therefore y ° u(—p, s) = u(p, s) (s = 1,2) y ° v(—p, s) = —v(p, s) (s = 1,2)
These relations indicates that particles and antiparticle have opposite intrinsic parity.
Problem 6.3 Pauli term
The Dirac equation describes a particle with g = 2. Physical particles have g-factors different from 2 because of interactions, which give rise to an "anomalous" magnetic moment. The electron acquire the anomalous moment through interactions with the quantized electromagnetic field. That for the proton and neutron are dominated by the strong interactions. Suppose the g-factor is 2 + K. Show that this can be accommodated by taking the Dirac equation in external electromagnetic field to be iy ,"(8,„
ie.A.,„)
eK
4m
—m
tp (x) = 0
The extra term is called the "Pauli term". For the proton and neutron, the experimental values are Kp = 1.79, KN = -1.91.
Problems
Problem 6.4 Chiral Current The chiral current density is defined by
.g(x)= i(x)y')/ 5 p(x) Using the Dirac equation, show that
atz.g = 2 mVy5» The chiral current become conserved in the massless limit O. In quantum field theory with electromagnetic interactions turned on, this properties is destroyed by the axial anomaly [3].
Problem 6.5 Zitterbewegung [4] The zitterbewegung is a kinematic property of the spin 1/2 representation of the Lorentz group, the "clockwork" of the Dirac equation. It refers to an unobservable irregular motion the electron must be executing, at the speed of light. To exhibit this motion, construct a wave packet for the Dirac electron: (r, t)
= f d3P
(210 3
eP
r
L
e W-
)
—iEt
(p)
where E = + ,/p2 I11 2 , and w± (p) are linear combinations of Dirac spinors with positive (negative) energies ± E. Calculate the expectation value of the velocity (v) = f d 3 r1pTa/p. Show that (IT)
= vo + 2Re
f d3
(2703
where vo = (17) -3 J d 3 p age position (r) = r o + vo t + Im f
aw_ ) e 2iEt (
a IN+
aw_). Integrate this to obtain the aver-
Ci 3 P e2iEtw T a w (2:r) 3 E + —
The last term is the zitterbewegung, which arises from an interference between positive- and negative-energy states. On dimensions grounds, we can conclude that the amplitude of this oscillatory motion is of the order of the Compton wavelength 1/ m, and therefore unobservable. In the hole theory, when all negative energy state are filled, the zitterbewegung becomes part of the vacuum fluctuations of the Dirac field, for it can happen only when holes are momentarily created due to fluctuations.
119
120
Dirac Equation
Problem 6.6 Gordon Decomposition a) From the definition of the Dirac matrices show y lt y 1, = g U V
jaw,
— m)v) = 0 from the left by lp y y, and use the b) Multiply the equation (i identity to rewrite the result in the form 1 Vr"/P = 2m
_ 8 N(VIP) (au V)V] + v(Vu'uv7P)}
with spatial components 1
vrv = 2m This is the Gordon decomposition, which splits the current density into a "convection" part, plus contributions from the spin. It suggests that the spin is the orbital angular momentum of the zitterbewegung. c) Let ui = u(pi, s i ), (i = 1, 2), be two Dirac spinors. Let p'u = pi + P2
e = Pi( PZ
Show a2ruui = — u2(Ru + iu'uv kii) 4 1 2m
Problem 6.7 Massless particles Consider massless Dirac particles. a) Show 4),(p)u),(p) = O. b) Show that the projection operators A j (p) for positive and negative energies have the properties A±(p) = E±a•p
A 2± (p) = 2EA±(p) A +(p) A_(p) = 2E
References References
1 Case, K.M. (1957) Phys. Rev., 106, 177. 2 Garwin, Lederman, and Weinrich (1957) Phys. Rev., 105, 1415.
3 Huang, K. (1992) Quark, Leptons, and Gauge Fields, 2nd ed., World Scientific, Singapore, Chap. 11. 4 Huang, K. (1952) Am. J. Phys., 20, 479.
121
I
7 The Dirac Field 7.1 Quantization of the Dirac Field
In hole theory, the Dirac equation describes a many-fermion system, and thus the Dirac "wave function" lp (x) should be regarded as a classical field to be quantized according to Fermi statistics. To carry out the quantization in the canonical formalism, we take as classical Lagrangian density L(x) = V(x)(irua y — rn)tp(x)
(7.1)
where 7p (ac) is a 4-component spinor, and the independent field variables are the components v), (x). We note that L(x) is Lorentz invariant, and globally gauge invariant. This is a first-order Lagrangian density, involving first instead of second derivatives with respect to time. We have illustrated the self-consistency of the canonical formalism in this case, in Problem 4.5. Therefore, following strict canonical procedures, we calculate
ar 0014) a )
a
b(ylb.
aVa
=—m
(7.2)
The equation of motion is + mV) =
(7.3)
which correctly gives the Dirac equation in hermitian-conjugate form. The Lagrangian density vanishes for fields satisfying the equation of motion: G(x) = 0
(for fields satisfying equation of motion)
(7.4)
The canonical conjugate to lp a is ttJ , since :2-( a
=
(7.5)
The Lagrangian does not depend on './) , which therefore has no conjugate. Sometimes one cannot resist making the Lagrangian more "symmetrical" by replacing Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
123
124
7 The Dirac Field
y ," a with (i/2) [i» yke (a ) + (a)ra Id. This would be akin to "adding feet when drawing a snake". The canonical quantization rules lead to the following anticomutation relations: { 7Pa(r, t), Vb t (11 , t)} = 6ab.6 3 (r tp ajr, Vh(rl , t)} = 0
(7.6)
where a and b denote spinor indices. The anticommutators serve as initial conditions for the Dirac equation. They also fix the normalization left arbitrary in the Dirac equation. The Lagrangian density is invariant under the global gauge transformation ?,0 -> , where w is a constant. The associated Noether current is 1 11 (x) =
(7.7)
(x)ru V(x)
which is conserved: 8 .»"(x) = 0
(7.8)
The canonical energy-momentum tensor, which is associated with translational invariance, is given by (x)ru act tp (x)
Z-la (x) =
(7.9)
with conservation law 8T(x) = 0
(7.10)
The energy and momentum densities are respectively T',°"3 =
1 ia°,tp= t(_j a . V ± /3 m)p iak
(7.11)
When integrate over space, they give the Hamiltonian H and total momentum P: H =f d 3 rtpi
(r, t)(-ia • V
711,)1p(r,t)
f d 3 rtp (r, t)V7p(r, t)
P
(7.12)
The generalized angular momentum tensor is
_
-
M(x) = '1/) (x) i(xarug - xfiyieaa) + -21 ruo-a[3 V(x)
(7.13)
and the angular momentum and the boost operators are respectively
p K'
=___ »la _
f
fd
3 rmoki
d3rmooi
=
jkl
f
d3 rtp -
r
( x k al ___ x lak\ ___
'
1 if d 3 rip t ( x o a j _ x j au + _ a n
2
lv
2
1/)
(7.14)
7.1 Quantization of the Dirac Field
From the angular momentum, we can read off the spin operator:
z
pv
(7.15)
2
in agreement with what we found in the last chapter. The one-particle solutions obtained in the last chapter constitute a basis in terms of which the field operators may be expanded. We normalize the wave functions in a large periodic box of volume Q, and write Ep t)
a ps it(p, s) e
(r, t) =
ct s
p s v(p
s)e—i(P'E—Ept)
b
s)e —i(p.r—E p I)
I (p, s
-r—E p t)
Ps
(7.16)
where Ep
1/p2
rn2
(7.17)
The factor VmlE p appears because the Dirac spinors are normalized according to (6.134) and (6.135): 1-4(p, s) (p, s') = (mlEp )ui (p, s)u(p, s') i3(p, s)v(p, s') =
(ml Ep )vi (p, s)v(p, s') = — (5ss'
—
=0
(7.18)
With this factor taken out, we have simple anticommutation rules laps , apt y l = {bps,
{aps ,
=
{
6 ss'àppf
bps bp' s f} = aps > py ,
(7.19)
= 0
which lead to the interpretation that a ps annihilates a particle whose wave function is u(p, s), and b ps annihilates an antiparticle whose wave function is v 1 (p, s). Hole theory is implement through the statement a p5 10) = b p5 10) = 0
for all p, s
(7.20)
That is, there are neither particles nor antiparticles in the vacuum state 10). In terms of the annihilation and creation operators we have H=
Ep (a s aps — b ps b,) = ps ps
b ps ps)
Ep (a-pr s aps + ap,
s bps b p ,)
(7.21)
125
126
7 The Dirac Field
If we had not used hole theory, b ps would be a creation instead of annihilation operator, and bps 14 5 would have eigenvalues 0,1. Consequently, the Hamiltonian would not be bounded from below. The sign-reversal that makes the Hamiltonian positive-definite, of course, depends on the fact that we quantized the system according to Fermi statistics. The charge operator is given by Q= f d 3 rïpy ° V f d 3 rtp
(ct;s aps — N;s bp, + 1)
—
(7.22)
ps
which shows that particles and antiparticles have opposite charge. The minus sign above arises through rewriting bps 4s as — b bp, + 1. This is dictated by the fact that s bps has positive eigenvalues in holes theory. The normalization of Q is arbitrary, for the magnitude of the charge is determined only when there is interaction with the electromagnetic field.
7.2 Feynman Propagator
The Feynman propagator for the Dirac field is a 4 x 4 matrix
iS F (x) = (01TV (x)tp (0 )I O)
(7.23)
where the time-ordering operator T is defined to include a sign change when two fermion operators A and B are interchanged: T[A( ti) B ( t2)]
if t 1 > t2 if t2 > ti
A(ti )B(t2 )
—B(t 2 )A(t i )
(7.24)
The propagator can be calculated straightforwardly, using the expansions (7.16). Let x = (t, r). For t > 0, the only contribution comes from terms in the expansion of the form caT :
[ sF(x) Li b --= ( o lva ( r, t ) z-p b (o
)
jo) 2
■
Ua
P, s)i-tb(P ,
(7.25)
s=1
For t < Owe need only keep terms of the form
S F (x)L b =
bb:
—(011/'b(0)V a (r, 010)
1 ——
,
11'1,
i(E t—p.r) "■2 P
s=1
va (p, spb (p, s)
(7.26)
7.2 Feynman Propagator 127
The sum over spin states result in the projection operators given in (6.138). Supco, we have pressing the spinor indices and going to the limit Q d3 p
iS F (x) =
1
(m
o)e—i(Ept—p•r) (t > 0) (270 3 2Ep (m — p)ei(Ept—p.r) (t <0)
(7.27)
f
We can make the replacement m
+ _ m+ y o Ep _
yk p k _> m + iy
a at
Y
k
P
k
(7.28)
because this operator acts on the exponential factor. For t < 0, make the change of p. Then we have variables p —
1
d3 p
isF (x)
J (25-
) 3
a r at
( m,
2Ep
k k) e_iEpItI ei
(7.29)
Now use the representation e —iE P itl
EP =—
irc
e —i pot f cc d40 .
_00
Ep2
i Ep f"
p 02 —
e—ipot
dp o p 2 m2 + iij J-00
(7.30)
where /7 0+. Then, the operator ia/at in the previous formula can be replaced by p o . The final result is d4 p
SF(x) = f (17
)4
+m
px
e
(7.31)
p c _ mc
We leave it as an exercise to show that m)A F (x)
S F (x) =- Grua",
(7.32)
where A p(X) is the Feynman propagator for a free scalar field of mass m. The Fourier transform of the propagator is
+m p2—m2 +
1 —m+
(7.33)
where the right side is the inverse of a 4 x 4 matrix. The 4-vector p is arbitrary, with either p° > 0 or p° < 0. For p° > 0, we have according to (6.138)
2m
For p° < 0, let us define qP (.0 + m) 2m
(7.34)
p, s) 4(p, s) (p ° > 0) s=1
( - 0+ 111) 2m
—p ,", Then according to (6.138) 2
v(q, s)i)- (q, s)
s=1
(p ° <0)
(7.35)
128 f 7 The Dirac Field
This shows that the residue at the mass-shell pole at 13' = m2 contains the wave functions of an electron of momentum p, or those of a positron of momentum = — P.
7.3 Normal Ordering
Both H and Q contain divergent contributions from the zero-point energy and charge of the vacuum state. These terms have no physical relevance since energy and charge are measured relative to those of the vacuum state. They can be eliminated by redefining the reference points, and this can be achieved by arranging the order of operators appropriately. We first introduce the notion of normal ordering. Suppose 0 is a product of creation and annihilation operators. The corresponding normal product : 0 : is defined as that obtained from 0 by rearranging the order of the factors, if necessary, such that all creation operators stand to the left of all annihilation operators. In the rearrangement process, an interchange of two fermion operators gives rise to a factor 1. As an example: —
p s p s ••=
ps p s
: a p , s atps •• -- —atp s ap ,s
(7.36)
Normal ordering can be naturally extended to a sum of products: :
+ 02:=: 01 :+: 02:
(7.37)
We now redefine the Hamiltonian and the current as H =: f d3 rzp (r, t)(—ict • V ± j(x) =:
(r, t) :
(7.38)
It is clear that these operators give zero when operating on the vacuum state, because annihilation operators stand to the far right. This is just a formal way of stating that the zero-point energy and currents are to be omitted. As the notation is somewhat cumbersome, we shall not explicit indicate normal ordering unless necessary.
7.4 Electromagnetic Interactions
We consider systems of interacting fields with a Lagrangian density consisting of the sum of the free Lagrangian densities of the participating fields, plus an interaction Lagrangian density that couple the fields together. This is not the most general
7.5 lsospin
case conceivable, but it is what we can handle mathematically. We illustrate the types of interactions commonly encountered. Consider a Dirac field, a complex scalar field, and the electromagnetic field, which have free Lagrangian densities given by m)lp
LDirac = 7,7) (
a" 0* ap — K 2 0* 0
Lscalar
Len, =
4
F"' F/1 ,,
(7.39)
According to the gauge principle, the matter fields can be coupled to the electromagnetic by replacing ,9/1 by the covariant derivative =
+ iekt(x)
(7.40)
where e is the electric charge. Assuming that both the Dirac field and the scalar field have the same charge e, the electrodynamic Lagrangian density is L=
1 Fav F+ (ir" — m)0 + [DP 0]* Di — K 2 0* 0 4 141
— Lem ± LIDirac
(7.41)
Lscalar + Lint
where
Lint = (±" + JP )A,„
i ll = ieTPY P IP = e [0 * (a" 0) — (a" 0 * )0] + e2
(I)
(7.42)
The matter fields are coupled through conserved currents, which are the Noether currents associated with global gauge invariance. For the scalar field, the current has an e2 term proportional to AP . This becomes a mass term for the photon when 0* 0 develops a vacuum expectation value, in spontaneous symmetry breaking. (See Problem 15.5.) The electromagnetic field couples to all charged fields through the gauge principle, and is universal in this sense. The vacuum fluctuations of the electromagnetic field includes the momentary creation of virtual particle-antiparticle pairs and their subsequent annihilation. The temporary charge separation makes the vacuum into a dielectric-like medium, and all the charged fields of the world participate in this "vacuum polarization", their contributions being determined solely by charge and mass.
7.5 lsospin
The Dirac field can be used in a phenomenological description of protons and neutrons, which are really made of quarks. The effective theory is useful in describing the "charge-independent" pion-nucleon interactions at low energies. It is based
1
129
130
7 The Dirac Field
on the fact that proton and neutron are almost identical, and so are the three 7r mesons, and the strong nuclear forces respect the identities. By ignoring the electromagnetic and weak interactions, we can regard the proton and neutron as different state of a particle called the nucleon, and the 7r mesons as different states of the pion. The nucleon field is represented by a two-component Dirac field (x) =
)
(7.43)
zP2(x))
where i = 1 corresponds to proton, and i = 2 to neutron. Each Tp i is a 4 component Dirac spinor field. Writing out all the indices, we have 8 complex fields zpi a (x), with a = 1, • • • ,4 and i = 1, 2. By analogy with spin angular momentum, we define the isospin Y/2 as generators of rotations in the two-dimensional internal space spanned by and 1p 2 :
-
Ti
=
(0 1) 0
v2 =-
0 .
(7,
r3
0
(1 0 ) 0 —1
(7.44)
The proton and neutron states are eigenstates of r 3 /2 with respective eigenvalue +1/2 and —1/2: 1p) = (1)
In) = (
(7.45) 01)
which can be created from the vacuum by applying v) (x). We use a shorthand notation in which the spinor and internal indices are suppressed. For example, 7/-)
-rf = Via(ru)abMijVbj
(7.46)
where a, b are sum from 1 to 4, and i, j are summed from 1 to 2. More generally we define isospin as an internal symmetry group whose generators I obey angular-momentum commutation relations (the Lie algebra): {Ik Iii = ic k`'n 1. .
Thus one can simultaneously diagonalize Y = I(I + 1) and 13 , and denote isospin eigenstates by I I, 1 3 ). The nucleon belongs to the fundamental representation with I = 1/2, in which 7 = Y/2. The overhead arrow denotes a vector in isospin space, which has 3 components because that is the number of generators of the group. The pion field has I = 1, and is described by a 3-component real field 01(x))
Ox) = ( 0 2 (x)
(7.47)
This the "adjoint representation" of the group, which has the same dimension as the number of generators, and in which the generators are represented by matrices T taken directly from the Lie algebra: (Tk)i n,
klm
(7.48)
7.6 Parity
Experimental evidence dictate that 0 (x) be pseudoscalar, i.e., it changes sign under spatial reflection. We note that 13 is not diagonal. The physical pion fields, which are eigenstates of i 3 , are related to 0 k through ,2-r+(x) =
-[01(x) + i02(x)] 1
7r— (x) =
V
0 1 (x) — i0 2 (x)] [
(7.49)
03(X)
These operators create states with 1 3 = +1, —1, 0 respectively, when they operate on the vacuum state, Charge-independence in the pion-nucleon system means that the interaction conserves isospin. A Lorentz-invariant effective Lagrangian density, known as "pseudoscalar coupling", is given by L(x) = ( ir"a —M) + —21 aq;
•
— m2
. .;b]+g ( t» ysi-
tp)j
(7.50)
The vector notation makes manifest the rotational invariance in isospin space. A competing model is the "pseudovector coupling" model, with — ivnlp + —21 [ate:is
(x) =
— rn'ib)
(7.51)
giopy s yYT>4).
Some consequences of isospin invariance are explored in Problem 7.4.
7.6 Parity
We discuss the discrete symmetries, using as an example the electromagnetic coupling as contained in L(x) =
4
F,„ V[iy,"(a
ieA,„) — mJ
(7.52)
Ax, the field operators 0,,(x) undergoes a Under a Lorentz transformation x given by (3.56): unitary transformation U U0(x)
u-1 = sabOb(A — lx)
(7.53)
where S a b is defined in (3.56), and given explicitly in Section 6.4. This can be ext, for which the unitary operator U is tended to spatial reflection x —›- x, t denoted by P. For the Dirac field, we have S = y ° according to (6.69) and (6.70), and thus y oy,— r, t) Py)(r, t )p —i OP 1 =
t)y °
(7.54)
131
132
7 The Dirac Field
Since
Au
transforms like a vector,
?Ak (r, t)? -1 =- —Ak (—r, t) 'PA° (r, t)?-1 = Ao (—r, t)
(7.55)
Thus we have PL(r, t)P-1
= r(—r, t)
(7.56)
which show that the Lagrangian L = f (1 3 x G(x) is invariant. From the expansion (7.16) at t = 0:
_
ni
lp(r)
aps e'P r u(p, s)
Ep
Ps
bi;s e —i "V (p, s)
(7.57)
we have in Q Ep
—
x [P aps 'P —1 eu(p, s)
y ° (-0 =
L
r
Ps
P-
PN;5P-1
v (p, s)
ip.r y Ow , r iq) s)] apse —IP.r y ° u(p, s) + b pse
(7.58)
Using the relations (Problem 6.2) y ° u(—p, s) = u(p, s) y ° v(—p, s)
=
—v(p, s)
(7.59)
we obtain the statement that particles and antiparticles in Dirac theory have opposite intrinsic parity: Paps ?-1 = a_ ps
= —b —ps 'Pbps P-1 ! U
The transformation ? may be accompanied by a rotation in spin space with respect to the index s; as is clear from (7.58); but we leave it out for simplicity.
7.7 Charge Conjugation
Charge conjugation, or particle-antiparticle conjugation, is defined as a unitary operation C on the Hilbert-space that interchanges particle and antiparticle, and reverses the sign of the electromagnetic field: CapSC 1 = bpS
CbC-1 = a ps ps CA k (X)C -1 =
(X)
(7.61)
7.8 Time Reversal
The transformation of A° (x) is not specified independently, because it in Coulomb gauge it is not an independent field. It is clear that (x) is invariant under this transformation, because the free fields Lagrangian densities are invariant, and the Dirac field is coupled to the electromagnetic field through the current density, which changes sign. To find how the Dirac field operator transforms, let us compare the following expansions: QE (r) =-
aps e ip•r u(p, s) + b ps e — i P • rv (p, * aps e —i p-r u (p,
s) + b ps e i P'v* (p, s)]
(7.62)
The expansion coefficients satisfy (6.146): (7.63)
v(p, s) = yu * (p, s)
where y = 1/ 2 is a real 4 x 4 matrix. Therefore ps e iP.r u(p,
s)
alp s
v (p, s)
(7.64)
which shows (r)C - 1 = rpp (r)
(7.65)
Note that the Dirac wave functions undergo complex conjugation, which is a nonlinear operation, because (.1u)* = /1* u*. The field operator, however, undergoes a linear transformation, because C(.11p)C -1 = AC lp C -1 . The difference can be traced to the fact that in the Dirac equation we have to change the sign of the coupling to an external electromagnetic field, whereas in the field theory, the electromagnetic field is part of the system, and automatically changes sign under charge conjugation.
7.8 Ti me Reversal
Time reversal is the operation of interchanging past and future, represented by a operator T on Hilbert space. Suppose Vla is a member of a complete set of states in Hilbert space, where a stands for quantum numbers, such as momentum p and helicity, i.e., spin projection s on the momentum vector. The operation T is defined by the following properties:
TW a = Wã (TWa,TWb) = (Wb, WO
(7.66)
I
133
134
I
7 The Dirac Field
where a are the time-reversed quantum numbers:
p = —p s = —s
(7.67)
(Thus the helicity remains invariant.) Orthonormality of basis states is preserved: (n,via)= (TWa,T 114) = (Wb, Wa)
(7.68)
The time reversal is not a linear operation. To see this, rewrite the last property in the form (TWa,"1- Wb) = (Wa, Wb) *
Replacing
Wb
(7.69)
by .1 Wb, where is a complex number, we obtain
Wa ,
gib))
---= 2* (Wa, Wb) *
(7.70)
Therefore T(AWb) = A*T .Vb
(7.71)
That is, when acting on a number, T takes its complex conjugate. This makes T nonlinear. Generally, the operation T consists of complex conjugation, followed by a unitary transformation: T = U*
(7.72)
T -1 = U-1 *
It is assumed that U commutes with complex conjugation. For the Schrbdinger equation
=
(7.73)
at
time reversal means
H(TW) = i
a(TW)
at
(7.74)
The system is invariant under time reversal if the time-reversed equation is equivalent to the original. Taking the complex conjugate, we have H*(UW) = t
(.a uw)
at
(7.75)
Thus, the system is invariant under time reversal if the Hamiltonian is real: H = H*
which implies that the Lagrangian must be real.
(7.76)
Problems
Without going through all the details, we can conclude that TA k (r)T -1 _Ac (r) y 0 y5 (r)
(7.77)
The first follows from the requirement that Ak transform like the current density, which must change sign, because classically it is a velocity. The second follows from the fact that y 0 y 5 is the transformation that preserves the Dirac equation under time reversal, as shown in (6.70). It is straightforward to verify that the Lagrangian is invariant, if the charge e is real. There is a theorem known as the PCT theorem, which states that a local field theory that is Lorentz invariant is automatically invariant under the product PCT, even though it may not be separately invariant under P,C,T separately. We refer the reader elsewhere [1] for proof.
Problems
Problem 7.1 The canonical energy-momentum tensor Tr for the Dirac field is not symmetric in y a. According to Section 4.5, we can construct an equivalent symmetric tensor = Tta + a, X 41 a. Find Problem 7.2 Show that the propagator for the Dirac field is related to that of the scalar field through
SF (x ) = ( y l"
+ m ).z1 F (x )
Problem 7.3 Expand the field operator of a massless Dirac field in terms of annihilation and creation operators, using the convention for wave functions given in Section 6.11. Problem 7.4 a) Show that under an infinitesimal isospin transformation, the nucleon field and pion field transform according to
where the components of co are arbitrary infinitesimal real parameters.
135
136
7 The Dirac Field
b) Let V= IpTi= where T is a 4 x 4 Dirac matrix. Show that V transforms like a vector in isospin space:
Problem 7.5 Pion-Nucleon Scattering As far as isospin properties are concerned, the pion and nucleon states can be labeled by I and 13:
1 1 , 1 ) 1 ,7 - ) = 11,-1) 1 70 ) = 1,0) I19 ) = 1/2,1/2) 1n) = 1/2,-1/2) a) A state containing a pion and a nucleon is a direct product in isospin space, as for example lgr+ n) = 11, 1) x 11/2, 1/2). However, this is not an eigenstate of total isospin and thus not an eigenstate of the Hamiltonian of the system. Show that eigenstates of the isospin are the following: I = 3/2 : 13/2,3/2) = Ipz +) 13/2, 1/2) = /1/3j n +)
V2olpyr°)
13/2,-1/2) = A/1/31p)-r— ) 13/2,-3/2) = Irtyr ° ) I = 1/2 :
A/2/31rtgr ° )
1/2,1/2) = \/2/31ny-c+) — V1/31p .7r ° ) 11/2, —1/2) = V1/31n7r ° ) — V2/31p 7r— )
b) For interactions that conserve isospin, the pion-nucleon scattering amplitude depends only on total isospin and not on 13 , (for the same reason that atomic energy levels are independent of the magnetic quantum number, i.e., the Wigner-Eckart theorem.) Denote the transition amplitudes by a312 and a 112 , and show that they have the form (Por + 1 71197r + ) = a3 1 2 1 (Pgr- ITIp7r- ) = a3/2 (nyelTipgt — ) = -T a3/2
2
3
a1/2
where T is the transition operator. The corresponding scattering cross sections are proportional to the squares of these amplitudes.
References
c) Neglect a 112 compared to a 372 , and show that pion-nucleon scattering cross sec-
tions bear the ratio cr(pgr + ) : a(p7r — ) : o(n7r °
pg — ) = 9: 1: 2
This is verified experimentally at low energies. The reason that a372 dominates N, where A is a particle of spin is the resonance scattering yr 3/2, isospin 3/2, with mass 1232 MeV, known at one time as the "33 resonance".
References
1 Streater, R. and Wightman, A. (1964) PCT, Spin and Statistics, and All That, Benjamin, New York.
1
137
I
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
8.1 Time Evolution
The dynamics of a quantum mechanical system is governed by the Hamiltonian H, which generates time translations. One may view the time development from different perspectives. In the Schrbdinger picture, one regards the operators O s as time-independent objects, and the state vector lifs changes with time according to the Schr6dinger equation
,a vfs (t)
at
= H lifs (t)
(8.1)
Assuming that H is time-independent we have the formal solution ips(t)
e —itH
(8.2)
The matrix element of an operator O s evolves in time according to (0 5 (t)10 5 1W5 (t)) = (0,(0)le"HOse't w5(0))
(8.3)
The subscript s identifies states and operators in the Schr&linger picture. In the Heisenberg picture, the state is assumed to be constant in time, but the operators evolve. The matrix elements of an operator must be independent of the picture, and this requirement relates the Heisenberg picture to the Schrbdinger picture: tlf h = W5 (0) Oh(t) = e itHo se — itH
(8.4)
The subscript h labels states and operators in the Heisenberg picture. The two pictures coincide at time t o , which will be taken to be zero from now on. The equation of motion in the Heisenberg picture is
,aoh (t)
LI] at = [Oh(t),
(8.5)
If the Hamiltonian has explicit time dependence, then e —ItH will be replaced by a more complicated evolution operator, but Wh is still defined to be constant in time. Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH Sc Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
139
140
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
8.2 Interaction Picture
Suppose the Hamiltonian can be split into a "free" part and an interaction term:
H = Ho ±
(8.6)
where Ho represents an "unperturbed" system that we understand. The two terms above are time-dependent, even if H is independent of time. By convention, the split is made at some fixed time, say t = 0. Thus, Ho and H' are constant operators by definition, being shorthands for H0 (0) and H1 (0). We now introduce the interaction picture, in which Ho governs the time evolution of operators, while H' governs that of the state vector. In this picture, the state W, and operators 0 s are related to those in the Schriklinger picture by W(t) = e iH°' tlfs (t) 0,(t) = e` 1-1°`O s e — ` 1-10 '
(8.7)
Thus, interaction-picture operators are the Heisenberg operators of the unperturbed system. The equations of motion in the interaction picture can be found by substituting (8.7) into the Schrbdinger equation, resulting in
,aw,(t) at i
at
,
H (t)tift (t)
= [01 (t),
Ho]
(8.8)
where W(0 = e iHotH/ e —i Ho t
(8.9)
We define an evolution operator U( t2 , t1 ) through 'F (t ) = U(t, to) W.,(to )
(8.10)
It is a unitary operator, since H' is hermitian, and the norm of V", (t) is conserved: Ulr(t, to) U(t, to) = 1
(8.11)
The following properties are easily deduced: U(t, t) = 1
U(ti, to) = U-1 (to, t1) U(t2, to) = U(t2 , t1 ) U(t i , to)
(8.12)
The equation of motion can now be cast in the form
a u.(t, to )
=
, H (t)U(t, to)
at
with the initial condition U(t, t) = 1.
(8.13)
8.2
Interaction Picture
It is not trivial to solve for U(t, to ), because Hi(t i ) and PO t2 ) generally do not commute. Let us divide the time interval (t, to ) into N small steps of duration A t: A t = (t — to )/N
(8.14)
To first order in A t, the equation of motion gives U(to + At, to) = [1— 1-1 / (to ).4
U(to , to)
(8.15)
The last factor is of course unity. We built up the finite time interval t — to from successive infinitesimal ones. Putting t n = to + nA t
(8.16)
we have U(t, to) = [1 — il-1 / (t N )A t][1 — i.F1 / (t N _JA t] • • • [1 — IFI'(to )A t] ± (— ) 2
=1—
n
n=0
+
(t n )H 1 (t m )
Ho'
1-11 (t 0 ) H' (t 1
( t1)
)
(8.17)
+•••
n<m<
Taking the limit
U( t, to)
N
> 00
—
= 1— i
gives
fd
)
(—
ft d ft o
to
d t2 H i
(
ti) H i ( t2)
•-
o
t
(—ir f d t i • • • f to
dt, [Fr(ti ) • • • 1-1 1 (t)] + • • •
t„
(8.18)
This is a formal solution to the equation of motion. To make the integration regions more symmetrical, consider, for example, the integral in the third term: 11 =
j dt d t2 f' r
Fr (t i )Hf(t 2 )
where the integrations extend over the region I in Figure 8.1, in which t 1 > t2 . If we integrate over region II, we would have =
d t2 to
f
t2 d ti
H I ( t2) H I (t1)
t0
where t2 > t 1 . The ordering of the operators in the integrand is such that they stand in chronological order from right to left. Evidently 1 1 = /2 , for they differ only by an exchange of integration variables. We can therefore replace 11 by ( + 12 ) 1 2,
4
142 1 8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
t2
I II
t1
Figure 8.1 Regions of integration.
which can be rewritten in the form /1 =
1t
f
4
t
dti f
0
dt2T[1-11t2 ) Fr( t1)1 O
where the time-ordering operator T is the same as that defined in (7.23): T[AB
• • • C] = ±AB • • •
C
(in chronological order from right to left) (8.19)
A factor —1 is attached to the result each time two fermion operators are exchanged in the rearrangement process. For an integral with n factors in the integrand, there are n! ways to permute the integration variables. Taking 1/ n! of the sum over all possible permutations, we obtain t n -1
t
fo
Citi
dt n [F1/(ti) • • ' Hi(t)]
• • • f
t,,
f t Citi f t CitnT[H i (ti) • • • 1-r(tn)] n! to
1 —
=
••-
t„
We can now write the evolution in the final form (
qi, to) = n=
j)fl
n!
ftot A •••f
t
dt n T[F-1 1 (4) • — H i (t)]
(8.20)
t„
which can also be written in a shorthand notation as U(t, to ) = Te i it', dtixt(ti)
(8.21)
In this form, we should expand the exponential in a power series, and then apply the operator T to each term.
8.3 Adiabatic Switching
The operator U(t, to) contains an exponential factor that oscillates rapidly when t —> ±oo. To make the expression well-defined, we assume that the interaction
8.3 Adiabatic Switching
Hamiltonian H' was "switched on" very slowly from the distant past, and will be "switched off' very slowly in the distant future. Specifically, we replace H' with H'
H i e+ E i t i (e
(8.22)
0+)
The limit e > 0+ is to be taken last, after all calculations. The corresponding evolution operator is denoted —
Ue (t,
to) = Te i fit, dtix'Ati)
(8.23)
which approaches a the S-matrix, (or S-operator), when to —> —oc, t --> oc: S
lirn
(oo, —oc) = lim
dt1-1(t)
(8.24)
E
This is a unitary operator: ST S = 1
(8.25)
-
and is central to the theory of scattering, which we shall discuss later. Let us put adiabatic switching to use. We assume that the vacuum state in the Heisenberg picture 10) is unique and normalizable: (8.26)
(010) = 1
The interaction-picture vacuum state 1W0 (t)) evolves according to the interaction Hamiltonian, with initial condition1W0 (0)) = 10), up to a phase factor. By switching off the interactions, we make
im I Wo ( t )) = 1 0 t --o0 l
(8.27)
)
which defined the phase. In the infinite future we have lim 1 1F 0(t)) = S1 0 ) = ei L 10)
t —oo
(8.28)
where L is a real number. Taking the scalar product of the above with (01, we obtain e` = (OIS 10)
(8.29)
The relation between the interaction and Heisenberg pictures can be obtained from (8.7) and (8.4): IAA = e i Hot e
0 1 (t) = e
t wh —i1-1,t O h
m e —i He t e i Hot
(8.30)
where H0 = Ho +
ti
(8.31)
43
144
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
Substituting this into (8.10), we obtain an explicit form for the evolution operator: U0 (t, to) =--
1-10t
HE (t -1°)
11°1°
(8.32)
We can rewrite (8.30) as • (t) = Ue (t, Vfh
(8.33)
0,(t) = Ue (t, 0) 0 h(t) UE-1 (t, 0)
The initial time t = 0 can be changed to t = to by using the identity UE (t, 0) = U,(t, to ) U0 ( to , 0) to write 11-f, (t)
(8.34)
= UE (t, to) U, (to, 0) WI,
Owing to adiabatic switching, • ( to , 0) = eixoto
to —> 00
1
(8.35)
Therefore V(t) = U6 (t , -o0) Wh 0 1 (t) = UE (t, -00) Oh(t) Unt , —oo)
(8.36)
This formula is more convenient to use than (8.33), because the two pictures coincide at t —> —oo, when the system was being prepared. As we shall see, perturbation theory relies on this relation. Why is it legitimate to use adiabatic switching? In the theory of scattering, the answer is that it reflects what happens in the laboratory. An incident particle, in the form a wave packet, approached the target particle, but did not interact with it until the collision took place. After the collision, the scattered particles eventually leave the scattering region as non-overlapping wave packets, and there is no interaction after that time. The adiabatic switching is a mathematical simulation of the situation, justified by the fact that the scattering cross section is insensitive to the detailed shapes of the wave packets. Actually, adiabatic switching need not correspond to any physical process; in general it serves a more abstract function. When we describe a physical process by saying "A interacts with B", we have to define what is meant by A and B, and to do that we must conceptually turn off the interaction. In the theory of metals, for example, it is customary to apply adiabatic switching to the electron-phonon interaction, which is of course always present. What we are doing is to imagine that the system was "assembled" by putting free electrons into an idealized lattice. As long as the conceptual assemblage took place a long time ago, it should not make any difference whether it actually happened; but we need it to identify the "free parts". As long as we accept the crucial formula (8.36), adiabatic switching has done its job, and need not be invoked again.
8.4 Correlation Functions in the Interaction Picture
8.4 Correlation Functions in the Interaction Picture
A vacuum correlation function is the vacuum expectation value of a time-ordered product of Heisenberg field operators: G n (xi , • • , x) = (01T A h(x i )Bh(x 2 ) • • • Ch(x)j0)
(8.37)
where 10) is the exact vacuum state, normalized such that (010) = 1. They are also called vacuum Green's functions, because they satisfy differential equations with a delta-function source. But "correlation function" more closely describes their role in our applications. In the interaction picture, we can use adiabatic switching to "assemble" the correlation functions of the interacting system from those of the unperturbed system, and this leads to perturbation theory. Consider a correlation function involving two operators: G(t i , t2 ) = (01TAh(t i )Bh(t 2 )10)
(8.38)
where we display only the time dependences, the spatial coordinates being kept fixed. Our objective is to re-express the above in terms of interaction-picture operators. Consider first the time-ordering t 1 > t2 . From (8.36), we have A h(t) = U -1 (t, —oo)A i (t) U(t, —oc) = U(—oo, t)A t (t) U -1 (—o o, t)
(8.39)
Thus, G(th t2) = (01 U(-00, t1).A 1 (t1)U -1 (-0o, t1)U -1 (t2, —oc) x B 1 (t2)U(t2, — 00)10) =- (01 U( —oc, t i )A,(t i ) U(t i , t2).13,(t2) U(t2, —00)10)
(8.40)
where we have used the relation U'( —oc, t 1 ) U -1 (t 2 , —oc) = U(t i , —oc) U(—co, t 2 ) = U(ti , t2 ). The time development is represented in Figure 8.2(a) by a contour beginning from the far right at t = —oc, going to t2 , then to t 1 , and then back to —oc. This contour can be deformed to two straight path from —co to oc, and from oc to —oc, by rewriting U( —oc, t1 ) = U(—co, oc) U(oo, t1 ) = S
t1 )
(8.41)
Therefore G(t i , t2 ) = (01S -1 U(co, t i )A
U(t i , t 2 )B,(t 2 ) U(t2 , —oo)10)
(8.42)
The new time contour is illustrated in Figure 8.2(b). The returning branch of the contour, represented by the operator S -1 , contributes a phase factor when acting on the vacuum, for, using (8.28) and (8.29), we can write (01 S —1 = e
(01 =
1 (01 (01S10)
(8.43)
i
145
146
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
t2 co
ti -oo
(a)
(b) Figure 8.2 (a) Contour of time evolution. (b) Contour deformed into two branches. Because of the uniqueness of the vacuum state, the lower branch gives only a phase factor.
Therefore G (ti , t2) =
(01 U(00, ti)A (4) U(ti, t2) 13, ( t2) U(t2, —00)10) (0 1 S1 0 )
(8.44)
The time contour now consists of the path from —oo to oc only. The trick to straighten the contour works because the vacuum state is unique. If the vacuum expectation value were replaced by an ensemble average, then we would be stuck with a contour that comes from —oc and returns to —oc. A technique to deal with such a case has been developed by Keldysh [1]; but we do not need it here. We can simplify (8.44) further, by examining more closely the operator X = U(oo, ti )A,(t i ) U(ti, t2)B,(t2) U(t2, —00) = [Te -117 drH/(r) ] At(ti)
[Te — ii drHt(T) B 1 (t2 )
j_•`20„, drxi(r)] (8.45)
If all the exponential factors are expanded out, we will have a sum of terms, each containing products of the H' bunched into three groups, of the form T {T[Fe(ri)H 1 (T2) • • • iA1(ti)T[H / (4) 1-11 (T;) • • • iBt(t2)T[FOrï)-FOri) (8.46)
where we have supplied a redundant T in front, not needed because t 1 > t2 . With it in place, however, we are free to rearrange all the H' factors in arbitrary order. The condition t1 > t2 , which determines the relative position of A , (t i ) and B,(t 2 ), ensures that the factors cannot wind up in the wrong group when the overall time ordering is enforced. As a shorthand, therefore, we can write X = Te — ` ,11 `1TH V) A,(ti)Bi(t2)
(8.47)
The correlation function can then be written in a more compact notation: G (ti, l2 ) =
(01TSA,(ti)B,(t2)10) (01 S 1 0 )
(8.48)
8.5 S-Matrix and Scattering
Though derived under the assumption t i > t2 , this result is also valid for t1 < t2 , as one can easily verify by repeating the derivation. The above results can be immediately generalized: =
(OITSA,(xi )B,(x2 ) •
(OIS 0)
C1(x)l 0)
(8.49)
This is convenient for calculations, because the interaction-picture operators evolve like free fields.
8.5 S-Matrix and Scattering
In a scattering experiment, an incident beam of particles A falls on a target particle B, producing a number of outgoing particles C, . . . , D, which are detected by devices that measure their momenta, and possibly other quantum numbers. We indicate the reaction by Ad B -
>C+•••±D
—
The states of the particles are labeled by momentum, mass, spin, and other singleparticle quantum numbers. The wave functions of A and B are wave packets that do not overlap initially. When they eventually overlap, the reaction takes place, and after a short time the final particles emerge from the interaction region as wave packets that recede from one another, eventually becoming well-separated. The size of the interaction regime is microscopic, and by comparison the wave packets is practically a plane wave. In our theoretical treatment, we idealize the wave packets as plane waves, but only before the interaction began, and after the interaction is over. The is done mathematically via adiabatic switching. Let us denote the initial and final free-particle states by O i and Of respectively. In our idealized scattering experiment, O i is the state prepared in the infinite past, and 1 is the state that the detectors are set up to detect in the infinite future. The actual state of the system evolves from O i into some interaction-picture state at time to , which is denoted by Wi(±) ( to ) = U( to , —oo)
(8.50)
The superscript (±) indicates that eventually final particles will emerge as outgoing spherical waves. In the infinite future, the particle detectors looks for plane waves Of instead of spherical waves. The state that will become Of is, at the time to , given by Vff( ) (to ) -- U(to , co) O f
(8.51)
where the superscript (—) indicates that it consists of incoming spherical waves in the past. The overlap between 01-) and Wi(+) is the probability amplitude that the
147
148
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
,MItANV\
(a)
,NVV\I\M
11
Mg' t= 0
t = -oo
t = + 00
114 (b)
t=o
= -00
Figure 8.3 (a) Time evolution of W(+), and (b) that of w( — ). The S-matrix is the overlap of the two states at t =---- O.
scattering process takes place:
(w(f ' ilf.(+)) = (o i -)
,
U
(to , co) U(to , —co)0i) = (0 i , U(oo, —oc))0i)
(8.52)
This defines the S-matrix: (f S
(8.53)
), Vf,(+) )
i)
where I i) and I f) are free-particle states. Thus, as anticipated earlier, S = u(00, _ 00) = Te —iff°„
dtHt(t)
(8.54)
The process is illustrated in Figure 8.3.
8.6
Scattering Cross Section
Ifs = 1, then the final state is the same as the initial state, and no actual scattering occurs. The probability amplitude that a reaction occurs is therefore the matrix element of S — 1. By analogy with potential scattering, we define the T-matrix through the relation
(ii(S —
= — 42704 6 4 (P — P ) ( f iTii)
(8.55)
8.6 Scattering Cross Section
where P1 and P1 are respectively the total 4-momentum in the final and initial state. The the factor (5 4 ( Pf — Pi) expresses conservation of total momentum and energy. The energy conserving factor 27r (5(P ,° — P) is familiar from potential scattering; it comes from the assumption that the total Hamiltonian is time-independent, and that the process was observed over a long time. The momentum-conserving factor (270 3 6 3 ( Pf — Pi ) was extracted from the transition matrix element, under the assumption that the system is invariant under spatial translations. The transition probability for the reaction i f is given by
I f I ( s — 1)101 2 = ( 2 T) 4 6 4 (0) ( 17) 464 ( Pf — Pi )1(fITIO
(8.56)
The factor (2yr) 4 (5 4 (0) should be interpreted as the total volume of space-time, being the limit (2n) 464 (0) = Bin
x e iP•x
(8.57)
P—>- 0
We omit this factor to obtain the transition rate per unit volume. The final state f, which must lie in a continuum of states, is contained in an infinitesimal neighborhood d Q of some state. For example, we may specify that final particles are scattered into specific solid-angle elements. The transition rate per unit volume into d Q is given by dR =
( 27 ) 464 ( pf _ POI( f IT1i)1 2 = Ida
(8.58)
fEd52
This defines the differential cross section du, with the incident flux I given by =
n 2 v12
(8.59)
where v12 is the relative velocity of the colliding partners, and n 1 and n2 their spatial densities. For the decay of an unstable particle from the initial state i, the lifetime is given by
V
(8.60)
,L(2,)4,54(p f
where the sum extends over all possible final states f. The S-matrix is unitary: SI S = 1. In terms of the T-matrix this means (11( T — TI- )J i) =
Ii)
(8.61)
( 2 ) 4 4 ( Pi — Pn )1 ( I T t I n)1 2 = I utot
(8.62)
(2a- ) 4 4 ( Pi — PO(
(n T
Putting f = i, we obtain the optical theorem: Im( il(T — T
i)
where a t°, is the total cross section.
49
150
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
The normalization of particle wave functions affect the matrix element (f1T1i), phase space volume elements, and the incident flux I; but the cross section is independent of the convention, as long as it is used consistently. A wave function normalized to n particle per unit volume has the form ip.r
(r) =
ne i r"r u(p, s)
(boson) (fermion)
(8.63)
where nu, is 1 for particle, and —1 for antiparticle. This correspond to a singleparticle state 1p) with the properties (134) = n( 270 3 (53 (P — 13')
f
(2yr)3n
(8.64)
iP) (Pi = 1
`1319
Whatever we choose for n, the convention must be adhered to in the expansion of field operators into creation and annihilation operators. The convention used in this book is n = 1. With this, the creation or annihilation of a boson or fermion is accompanied respectively by a factor (2E) — 1/2 or (m/E) -1 /2 . This is indicated in the field expansions (2.29) and (7.16) respectively, and originates from the fact that the boson Lagrangian is quadratic in the time derivative, whereas the fermion Lagrangian is linear. By taking n=
(boson)
2E
(8.65)
E/ m (fermion)
these factors disappear in the field expansions, but reappear in the properties of 1p). This convention is call invariant normalization, because it has the same form in all Lorentz frames. In practice, it makes little difference which convention we choose, for these factor appear either with the matrix element, or appear squared in the phase-space volume element. It is merely a matter of when to include them. As an illustration, consider a reaction in which two particles go into N particles, with initial and final states given by
I i) = 113 i , P2)
If
(8.66)
p 13; • • • liN)
With the convention n = 1, the incident flux is 1= P'
P2 — "IE2
1 E2
(Pi P2) 2 — mm
(8.67)
where p denotes 4-momentum, and E and m denote energy and mass respectively. The momenta pi and 132 are assumed to be colinear. The differential cross section da is given by d3 p i Ida = fl -1 (270 4 6 4 (Pi — Pf)1(i (27) 3 N
(8.68)
8.7 Potential Scattering
where P i and P1 are respectively the total 4-momentum of the initial and final With invariant normalstate. The wave function factors are contained in (f ization, we take them out of the matrix element, and put their squares under d 3 p . The transition rate I du is not changed.
8.7 Potential Scattering
To help understand scattering in quantum field theory, we give a parallel description of potential scattering in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. The experimental situation is that a steady beam of particles is scattered by a potential well, and detectors are set up very far away to register scattered particles of definite momenta. The incident beam is represented by a stream of non-overlapping wave packets, which can be considered one at a time. A wave packet must small enough that it does not overlap the scattering center initially, but large enough that its momentum can be well defined. It is assumed that the wave packet does not spread appreciably during the course of the experiment. We imagine the wave packet getting larger and larger, and ultimately approaching a plane wave. In the plane-wave limit, the overall scattering process is described by the stationary wave function 71, (r) of the particle, which satisfies the Schrôdinger equation with outgoing-wave boundary condition: 1 2 ± V(r) 2m V
(r) = E
(r)
e ikor r >00
(r)
f(Q )
(8.69)
where V(r) is the scattering potential, and Q denotes the scattering angles. We have written r = rI, k o = kol, and E = ki /2 m. The the incident wave corresponds to exp(iko • r), and the outgoing spherical wave corresponds to exp(i ko r)/ r. We can calculate the number of particles scattered per unit time into solid angle d S2 from the current density of the scattered wave. The differential cross section d u/ d S2 is the above rate per unit solid angle, divided by the incident flux. This procedure yields the familiar result du d S2 =
(8.70)
Q )1 2
where f (Q ) is called the scattering amplitude. The wave-packet nature was taken into account through the neglect of interference between incident and scattered wave. In the laboratory, scattering is a time-dependent process, which can be described by the stationary wave function 1,0(+) through the following construction. Let the initial wave packet be F(r) =
fd
3kf
r
151
152
I
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
where f(k) is a function peaked about k = 1(0 . Then the time-dependent wave function describing the actual scattering process is W(r, t) = f d 3 k f(k)V4,±) e — l Et
where E = k 2 /2m. A "motion picture" of this wave function will show the wave packet being scattered by the potential, receding as an outgoing spherical wave front. The stationary wave function obtains in the plane-wave limit f (k) 6 3 (k — k0 ). We now restate the problem in a more formal language, to compare with the treatment in quantum field theory. Let us write the Hamiltonian as (8.71)
H = Ho + V
with Ho = —V 2 /2 m. Consider the eigenvalue problem with a continuous spectrum E: (Ho ± V)14o (r) = E» (r) v(±)( r)
e iko.,
f(s 2 ) e±iko'
r —>oo
(8.72)
where the superscript (±) labels a solution with outgoing (incoming) spherical wave. The unperturbed problem at the same energy E is defined by (8.73)
Ho Oko = E0k 0
where Ok = e
ik.r
(8.74)
The Schrbdinger equation and the boundary condition are incorporated in the following integral equation: w (+)
65 ,
k°
' -`)
+
1 E — Ho
V-tpi(:)
(8.75)
0+. The term ± i y prescribes the way to skirt the pole (E — HO', so where y as to give an outgoing or incoming wave. We define the T-matrix by TOko
(8.76)
V/pi(: )
It satisfies the Lippmann—Schwinger equation T=V+V
1 E — H0 +
T
(8.77)
and is related to the scattering amplitude through 17r ( çbk ' v1 ) 2.7r (çbk, T°k°) where k is the scattered wave vector, with magnitude ko and polar angles Q. f (Q)
(8.78)
8.7 Potential Scattering
The set of wave functions with the (+) and (—) boundary conditions separately form complete sets of eigenstates of H, (barring bound states.) The unitary transformation matrix relating the two sets is called the S-matrix: ) , h (+))
(1(1 s 110
(8.79)
k0 )
To find the relation between the S-matrix and the T-matrix, rewrite (8.75) in the more explicit form ,h(±)
1+
ko
1 V E — H iy _ Oko
(8.80)
which can be obtained by iterating (8.75), and resumming. In the limit ri —> 0+ we have 1 E—H
E— H
i:Trx5(E — H)
(8.81)
where P denotes principal part. We therefore have (—) ko — ,hko
— 1-Jr
.A /r
—
(8.82)
ko
Now take the scalar product of both sides with respect to 1p k(+) noting that ,
= (klko) = (2.7) 3 6 3 (k — ko )
(V)(k+),
(8.83)
This leads to (k1S1k0 ) = (kl [1— 27rià (Ek —
Ek o )
T] iko)
(8.84)
Energy conservation is enforced in the S-matrix, but not in the T-matrix. The latter can be defined for arbitrary E, including complex values, through the Lippmann— Schwinger equation (8.77). We can write as an operator relation S = 1— 2yrià(E — H)T
(8.85)
The unitarity condition St S = 1 implies that T
T = 27riTtô(E — H)T
(8.86)
The diagonal matrix element of this relation gives the optical theorem: 4,7 otot
Im f(0)
(8.87)
where a to, is the total cross section for incident wave number k, and f(0) is the scattering amplitude in the forward direction.
153
154
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields 8.8 Adiabatic Theorem
The meaning of the S-matrix rests upon the statements (8.27) and (8.28). That is, the vacuum state in the interaction picture approaches that of the Heisenberg picture in the infinite past and in the infinite future. The two limiting states can differ only by a phase factor, which defines the S-matrix. The assumption was that the system remains in an evolving ground state, and does not get excited from it. A formal statement is the adiabatic theorem, which can be loosely stated as follows: A system being perturbed in its ground state will remain in the ground state, as long as the perturbation varies sufficiently slowly with time.
A precise mathematical statement of the theorem will be given later, after we develop some mathematical tools. We write the Hamiltonian in the form H = Ho ± AH'
(8.88)
where H' is the interaction to be turned on and off by adiabatic switching, and A is a parameter introduced for convenience, to be set to unity at the end of the calculations. The splitting of H into the two terms is made at time t = 0. We enclose the system in a large but finite box, and assume that the eigenvalues of H are discrete and non-degenerate. Suppose W is an eigenstate of H, and 0 the corresponding unperturbed state: H E H00 =EM (0 , 0) = 1
(8.89)
In stationary perturbation theory, the relation between W and 0 can be found as follows. We write (8.90)
where (x, 0 ) = 0. Note that W is not normalized to 1. It simplifies the analyze to take the coefficient of 0 to be unity. Substituting this equation into H W = E W, we obtain, after some rearrangement, (E
—
0)0 = (Ho
—
E)2(
—
A
(8.91)
Taking the scalar product of this equation with 0, we obtain an expression for the perturbed energy: E=
+ A(0 , H' Vf)
(8.92)
The perturbed state W is found by solving for x from (8.91). To insure that the result is orthogonal to 0, we first multiply both sides of (8.91) by the projection
8.8 Adiabatic Theorem
operator 0 onto the space orthogonal to 0:
o Qx=x
Q0 -=
(8.93)
We then obtain the result = 0
A
1
(8.94)
QH'
H0— E
The following is an equivalent form of the equation with the unperturbed energy EM in the denominator: 1
W=
H0 — E(c )
Q(H t
—
E)
(8.95)
The formulas for E and W are valid for any state, as long as the energy levels do not cross when A varies from 0 to 1. In particular, we use them for the vacuum state, which is assumed to be unique for all A. With adiabatic switching, the Hamiltonian is taken to be HE = Ho +
(e
> 0+)
(8.96)
—
and the time-development operator in the interaction picture is given by 00 UE
HA)n
UE (0, — 00) =
Clti
n!
n=0 0
L
0
n eE (t1 +
••
) T [H t (t i ) • • • H t (t n )]
(8.97)
oo clt
Let us calculate [H0 , UE ]. For the commutator [H0 , H' (t)], we use the formula [H0 , Him]
(8.98)
i at
which can be deduced from (8.9). For brevity, write Zn
T[Filt i ) • • • 0
fn
f co dti
(t,)]
dt, exp e (t 1 + • • • + tn ) — 00
00
(—i A)"
U, =
(8.99)
fn Zn
n=
Then, __ 0„ ) n f
[Ho , UE ] = —
a
n!
f
°°\ -,---
H 1 (0)U,
e n=1
(n 1)!
in
(8.100) Zn
155
156
I
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
In the last step, we have made a partial integration with respect to t 1 . The above can be rewritten as [Ho , Us ] =
H T (0) U,
(8.101)
aU ils
We can arrearage this to read
u,Ho u» = Ho + A H'(0)
ie
au,
U,
(8.102)
which leads to lim UE HO U,7 1 = H E—>o
(8.103)
That is, the operator U, transforms the unperturbed Hamiltonian into the perturbed one. We now give a more precise statement of the adiabatic theorem [2]. Theorem 8.1 Adiabatic Theorem: Let
x,
U, (0, U,0)
(8.104)
where Ho cP = E 10 di Then .
(8.105)
lirn X E = CW £ ->0
where W is the eigenstate of the Hamiltonian corresponding to the unperturbed state 0, and c is a normalization constant. Proof: Let (8.106)
U,
Consider (Ho — EM) WE = (Ho — EM) U,
= [Ho , U,]
(8.107)
Using (8.101), we obtain (H, E (°) ) WE = ieA
aw,
(8.108)
Dividing both sides by (0, U, 0), we can rearrange the above to read
(HE —
—
aA
= iem aln(0, We )
(8.109)
Problems
In the limit e
0 this becomes (8.110)
H X 0 = (B (°) ± A E) X 0
where AE =
E,0
a ln(0 , WE )
ie /l
a2
Thus, X0 is an eigenstate of H. To show that it has the correct eigenvalue, we take the scalar product of (8.108) with 0 to obtain (0 , (HE — E 1 ) )W) = ieA
(ao,w,)
(8.112)
a2
Dividing both sides by (0 , U, ), we can rewrite this in the form IEJI
a ln(0 , a2
)
= (P, (H, —
X,) =
, I-1 / X,)e'I'l
(8.113)
Comparison with (8.111) shows that AE = 11(0 , X 0)
(8.114)
This completes the proof that X0 is the eigenstate of H with the correct eigenvalue (8.92).
Problems
Problem 8.1 Show that the term + i )7 in the operator (E — H0 ± i ?/ 1 in (8.75) corresponds respectively to an outgoing (+) and incoming (—) spherical wave, as defined in (8.72).
Problem 8.2 a) Consider the scattering of a charged particle by the Coulomb potential of an atomic nucleus, as in Rutherford scattering. The scattering amplitude involves the Fourier transform of 1/ r, which is ambiguous due to the lack of convergence at large r: Show that by introducing a screening factor e — ar, one obtains a definite scattering cross section in the limit a —> 0. b) The screening is a mathematical device like adiabatic switching. Why does it make sense physically in this case? c) Can you think of circumstances in which the screening device should not be used, because it would correspond to the wrong physics? (Hint: Would you get plasma oscillations if the Coulomb potential is screened?)
57
158
8 Dynamics of Interacting Fields
Problem 8.3
The time-reversal operation T defined in Section 7.8 interchanges initial and final state. Show that we must have T ST = S
St
Problem 8.4 From (8.32), we have the relation U(t, 0) = exp (—i Ht) = exp (—i
Ho t)
eiHote—iHt.
T exp (— i
0
Using (8.21), we can write
d H t (ti ))
where H = Ho H', and H' (t) = e i 0t H' e — t Hot . By expanding the right side in powers of H', we have a perturbation series. Show that the series has the form 1
e A±B = eA 1 + f cble ---)` A B e }` A
+f
d
f
2, 1
c1.1. 2 e — '11A B e (111—)`2)A Be ,12A
References
1 Keldysh, L.V. (1964) Zh. Eksp. Thor. Fiz., 47 1515 [(1965) Soy. Phys. JETP 20, 235].
2
Gell-Mann, M. and Low, F.E. (1951) Phys. Rev., 84 350.
I
9 Feynman Graphs
9.1 Perturbation Theory
We have obtained the S-matrix as an expansion in powers of the interaction Hamiltonian. Perturbation theory is based on this expansion, considered an asymptotic expansion, whose first few terms can give very good approximations. Whether the expansion actually converge is usually unknown. The value of perturbation theory, however, goes beyond obtaining good numerical answers, for the following reasons:
• The formal sum of the perturbation series, or even a partial sum, can reveal interesting properties of the theory, as for example the renormalizability of quantum electrodynamics. • Divergence of the perturbation series usually signals "non-peiturbative" effects, such as the formation of bound states or solitons, or the onset of a phase transition. In this chapter, we illustrate the use of perturbation theory in the calculation of S-matrix elements in the çb 4 theory. The Lagrangian density of the theory is given by 1
m2 0 02( x l
vo(x)a„o(x) —2
/1' 0 0 4 1x)
(9.1) 4! where the mass mo and coupling constant are called "bare" or "unrenormalized" constants. They differ from the physical mass and coupling constant, which are "renormalized" by the effects of interactions. The unperturbed system is taken to be the free field of mass mo , and the corresponding interaction Lagrangian density is L(x) = — 2
—
/1 0 4 rint(X) = -- q) (x) 4!
(9.2)
The interaction Hamiltonian differs only by a sign: Rint(x)
/10 04(x) !
Quantum Field Theory from Operators to Path Integrals. K. Huang Copyright C) 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 978-3-527-40846-7
(9.3)
159
160
9 Feynman Graphs
We use the interaction picture, in which the S-matrix can be written as the following power series in the bare coupling constant: =
( 1:114)n ni 4! ) 1
n=0
f C14 X1 • • f d 4 x,„ T [ 0 4 (xo „ 04( xo]
(9.4)
where q5 (x) evolves in time like a free field. Our goal is to calculate the matrix element of S between given initial and final free-particle states. The field operator çb (x) contains two terms: a positive-frequency part that annihilates a particle, and a negative-frequency part that creates a particle. The n-th order term in the S-matrix is a sum of terms, each of which is a product of creation and annihilation operators. To obtain the matrix element of such a product, we first try to rearrange the order of the factors in normal order — with all annihilation operators standing to the right of all creation operators. In general, the factors involved do not commute with one another, and we will generate other terms in the rearrangement process. This is, however, a finite process, and in the end we will obtain the nth-order S-matrix as a finite sum of normal products. Once this is done, the matrix element can be read off, because a normal product has non-vanishing matrix element only between an initial state containing the particles to be annihilated, and an final state containing those to be created. In the following we develop some mathematical tools to implement this task.
9.2 Time-Ordered and Normal Products
In this section, let capital letters, such as A, denote either a creation or annihilation operator for fermions or bosons. The commutator between any two boson operators, or the anticommutator between any two fermion operators, is a c-number. The same is true of the commutator between a boson and a fermion operator. Such a commutator or anticommutators may be replaced by its vacuum expectation value. We restate the definitions of time-ordered and normal-ordered products in a more formal way. A time-ordered product (T-product) is defined as T(A1A2
•
An)
ABBi B2 • • Bn
(9.5)
where { Bi } is the same set of operators as {A i }, except possibly in different order, such that an operator with a later time label appears to the left of one with an earlier label. The quantity rJAB is a signature factor:
'JAB
= +1
if {A} and { B } differ by an odd permutation of fermion operators otherwise
(9.6)
9.3 Wick's Theorem
Time-ordering is distributive: T[(ABC•• •)
(DEF • ••)] = T(ABC •••) +T(DEF•••)
(9.7)
A normal product (N-product) is defined as :A l A n : —=
yAc
(9.8)
Cn
where {C} is the same set as {A}, except possibly in different order, such that in the set { C i } all creation operators appear to the left of all annihilation operators. The signature factor 77 AC has been defined in (9.6). Normal-ordering is distributive: :[(ABC•••)±(DEF•••)]:=:(ABC•-•):+:(DEF•••):
(9.9)
We define the contraction between two operators as the vacuum expectation value of their product: (9.10)
(01A1310)
A. .13*
If there are intervening operators between A and
B,
then
AC B' _= ±(0IABIO)C
(9.11)
where the sign is ± depending on whether an even or odd number of fermion operators exchange position when B is pulled across C to the left. If there is more than one contractions in a product, we distinguish the different contractions using multiple dots: A . B"
C s " D E • F. " G" = ±(01AE10) (OP G10) (0ICF10)D
(9.12)
9.3 Wick's Theorem
The operator form of Wick's theorem tells us how to expand a T-product into N-products. A T-product orders operators according to time labels, regardless of whether they are creation or annihilation operators. An N-product, on the other hand, orders operators according to whether they are creation or annihilation operators, regardless of time label. Thus, it is sufficient to learn how to expand an ordinary product into N-products, because at fixed times a T-product is just an ordinary product, and the N-product does not care about time labels. Since a single operator is its own N-product, the non-trivial cases start with a product of two operators. The general result will be obtained by induction on the number of factors in the product.
61
162
9 Feynman Graphs
Lemma 9.1 A 1 A 2 = :A 1 A 2 :
(9.13)
Proof: a) For two boson operators, :A 1 A 2 : =
A 1 A 2 if A 2 is annihilation operator A 2 A 1 if A 2 is creation operator
(9.14)
In the latter case we write A 2 A 1 = A 1 A 2 + [A 2, A 1 ] = A 1 A 2 + (0 1[ A2, A 11 10) = A A 2 — (0 1A i A 2 10 )
(9. 15 )
where the last step follows because (01A 2 = O. Therefore, if A2 is a creation operator, we have A i A 2 = : A iA 2 : +
(0 1 A
(9.16)
A 2 10 )
This is also true if A2 is an annihilation operator, for then the second term vanishes. b) For two fermion operators, :A i A 2: =-
if A 2 is annihilation operator —A 2 A 1 if A2 is creation operator AiA2
(9.17)
In the latter case write —A 2 A 1 = A 1 A 2 — 2,
= A1A2 — (011A2, A1110)
= A 1 A 2 — (01A 1 A 2 10)
(9.18)
which leads to the same result as in the boson case. If one operator is boson, and the other fermion, then the boson calculations apply, for the operators commute. LI
Lemma 9.2 :A 1 • A n :C = :A 1
A n
C:
•
AC: ± • • • ± :A i
(9.19)
Proof: If C is an annihilation operator, then the lemma is trivially true, for C is already stands in normal order, and all contractions vanish. Hence assume that C Is a creation operator. To normal order the given product, we commute (or anticommute) C all the way to the far left. First write A n :C = y AB B i
.••
B,C
(9.20)
9.3 Wick's Theorem
where { B 1 • • B,} is the set {A 1 •
A n } in normal order. Now interchange B n and
C: B ii C =
where 77 nc is
—
n c C B,
BC °
(9.21)
1 if both B n and C are fermion operators, and +1 otherwise. Thus,
:Ai• • • A„:C
C--n R R -1AB 77, nC-1•••
7
(9.22)
77ABBi••• B:C .
Continuing the process, we obtain :A 1 •• • A n :C = rhic + YAB (Bi • • • BC) + 7/AB (B1 • • • B„._,B,C • ) = :A i • • • A n C:
:AI.
••
A
,C • : ± • • • + :A i • • •
A:C . : (9.23)
El Lemma 9.3 A i A 2 •• • A, = :AiA2-• • A n : + :AI/AI • • • An: + :A1A2A*3 - • A n : + • • •
(9.24)
where all possible contractions are to be made. Proof: The statement is true for n = 2, as demonstrated in Lemma 1. Assume that it is true for n. We prove it for n + 1 by multiplying the above equation by A n + i LI from the left, and applying Lemma 2 term by term. The extension of Lemma 3 to a T-product Is straightforward, because for any fixed time-ordering the T-product is an ordinary product. However, we have to redefine the contraction symbol to take into account time ordering: AB
(9.25)
= (01 TABIO)
Then we have Theorem 9.1 Wick's Theorem: T(A1A2•••A n ) = :A1A2•••A n : + :ALA2
A3•••
+ : AiA2A3••• An: + • •
where all possible contractions are to be made.
An: (9.26)
163
164
9 Feynman Graphs
Corollary: Wick's theorem also holds when any A 1 is replaced by a linear combination of creation and annihilation operators.
A weaker form of Wick's theorem deal