PROGRESS IN OPTICS VOLUME XXXVII
EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD G. S. AGARWAL,
Ahmedabad, India
T. ASAKURA,
Sapporo, Jap...
38 downloads
1416 Views
19MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
PROGRESS IN OPTICS VOLUME XXXVII
EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD G. S. AGARWAL,
Ahmedabad, India
T. ASAKURA,
Sapporo, Japan
M.V. BERRY,
Bristol, England
C. COHEN-TANNOUDJI, Paris, France V. L. GINZBURG,
Moscow,Russia
F. GORI,
Rome, Italy
A. KUJAWSKI,
Warsaw, Poland
J.
Olomouc, Czech Republic
&&A,
R. M. SILLITTO,
Edinburgh, Scotland
H. WALTHER,
Garching, Germany
PROGRESS IN OPTICS VOLUME XXXVII
EDITED BY
E. WOLF University of Rochester, N.Y. US.A
Contributors G.P. AGRAWAL, T. ASAKURA, R.Y. CHIAO, D. DRAGOMAN, R.-J. ESSIAMBRE, 1.L. FABELINSKII, 0. KELLER, K.-E. PEIPONEN, A.M. STEINBERG, E.M. VARTIAINEN
1997
ELSEVIER AMSTERDAM LAUSANNE . NEW YORK . OXFORD. SHANNON. SINGAPORE. TOKYO
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V SARA BURGERHARTSTRAAT 25 P.O. BOX 21 1 1000 AE AMSTERDAM THE NETHERLANDS
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 6 1- I9297 ISBN Volume XXXVII: 0 444 82796 X
0 1997
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V.
All rights reserved
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system. or transmitted, in any form or by any means. electronic. mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elseuier Science B. Kl Rights & Permissions Department, RO. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the USA: This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC). 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers. MA 01923. information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the USA. All other copyright questions. including photocopying outside of the USA, should be referred to the Publisher, unless otherwise specified.
No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or propery as a matter of products liability. negligence or otherwise. or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein.
PRINTED ON ACID-FREE PAPER PRINTED IN THE NETHERLANDS
PREFACE This volume presents six articles describing theoretical and experimental research of current interest in optics. The first article, by D. Dragoman, reviews some of the important applications of the Wigner distribution function in optics and optoelectronics, which is useful in the characterization of optical systems and beams, in the coupling between light sources and waveguides, and in nonlinear and ultrafast optics. Although the article focuses on the theoretical aspects, numerical simulations and experiments are also discussed. The usefulness of the Wigner distribution function approach in such a large area of research suggests that its applications are far from being exhausted. In the second article, K.-E. Peiponen, E.M. Vartiainen and T. Asakura review the mathematical foundations and the applicability of Kramers-Kronig relations to data inversion in linear and nonlinear optical spectroscopy. Also, the subject of phase retrieval by use of the maximum entropy model is discussed in connection with reflection spectroscopy and nonlinear optical processes. Sum rules for linear and nonlinear optical constants are presented. The next article, contributed by I.L. Fabelinskii, discusses experimental investigations and theoretical studies of spectra of molecular scattering of light arising from the temporal changes of optical inhomogeneities induced by pressure, entropy, concentration and anisotropy fluctuations. The investigations of such spectra make it possible to obtain much information about various equilibrium and nonequilibrium phenomena, such as the absorption and the velocity of hypersound (frequencies greater than lo9 Hz) and their temperature dependence in solids, liquids and solutions, and the velocity of first and second sound in liquid He 11. The fourth article, by R.-J. Essiambre and G.P. Agrawal, reviews the field of fiber-optical soliton communication systems. It starts by discussing the fundamental properties of fiber-optic solitons. The effects of fiber loss, dispersion, polarization-mode dispersion, and the Raman phenomenon on such solitons are described. The topics include periodic amplification, timing jitter and its control, time-division multiplexing, dispersion management, wavelength-division multiplexing, polarization-division multiplexing, and dark solitons. The article includes a discussion of the system design aspects and experimental results. V
VI
PREFACE
In the next article, contributed by 0. Keller, theoretical aspects of the local field electrodynamics in mesoscopic media are reviewed. These media are of particular importance because the so-called quantum size effects link the local field theory of bulk media to self-field (Lamb shift) and radiation-reaction (spontaneous emission) effects in atoms and molecules. After describing an electromagnetic propagator approach and a microscopic linear and nonlocal many-body response theory, the author goes on to treat the so-called loop equation for the transverse part of the local field. Various topics, including the short- and long-range electrodynamics of mesoscopic media with strongly localized electron orbitals are reviewed, and it is shown how the theory accounts for the linear and nonlinear local field electrodynamics of quantum wells and thin films. The review concludes with a brief description of optical near-field phase conjugation of the field from a mesoscopic particle, and an explanation of why understanding local-field effects may be helpful in the study of strong (subwavelength) spatial localization of matter-attached optical fields. In the concluding article, by R.Y. Chiao and A.M. Steinberger, recent experiments and theories are reviewed concerning the time it takes for a photon or an electromagnetic wave packet to tunnel across a barrier. Two controversial questions about the tunneling time are examined: the first concerns conflicting theoretical predictions of this time, and the second concerns the question whether the observed superluminal group velocities in tunneling of single-photon wave packets, femtosecond laser pulses and microwave pulses violate causality. In connection with the second controversy, the meaning of the superluminal group velocity which is predicted to occur in media with atomic population inversion is discussed. The authors conclude that Einstein causality is, in fact, not violated in any of these phenomena. Emil Wolf Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Rochester Rochester, New York 14627, USA May 1997
CONTENTS I . THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS by D. DRAGOMAN (BUCHAREST. ROMANIA) $ 1 . INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 2. LIGHTPROPAGATION IN PHASE SPACE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 3. WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Transformation laws . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. Optical generation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . OPTICAL SYSTEMS WITH THE WlGNER $ 4 . LIGHTBEAMCHARACTERIZATION IN FIRST-ORDER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1, Transformation laws for the Wigner distribution function moments . . . . . 4.2. Propagation invariants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. Wigner distribution function transformation law and the beam energy variation 4.4. Comparison with other methods ofbeam characterization . . . . . . . . . $ 5. OPTICAL SYSTEM CHARACTERIZATION WITH THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . 5 . 1. Characterization of aberrated optical systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 6 . WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION REPRESENTATION OF THE COUPLING E ~ ~ C I E N C Y . . . 6.1. Completely coherent single mode sources and waveguides . . . . . . . . . 6.2. Multimode, completely coherent sources and waveguides . . . . . . . . . 6.3. Partially coherent single mode sources and waveguides . . . . . . . . . . $ 7. THEFRACTIONAL WIGNERDISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1. Properties of the fractional Wigner distribution function . . . . . . . . . . 7.2. Optical beam characterization in the near-field diffraction regime . . . . . . 7.3. Optical production of fractional Wigner distribution hnction . . . . . . . . $ 8. OPTICAL BEAMCHARACTERIZATION IN NONLINEAR OPTICAL SYSTEMS . . . . . . . . 8.1. Soliton solution of the NLS equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 9. COMPLEX FIELDRECONSTRUCTION FROM THE WlGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . . $ 10. WlGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN QUANTUM OPTICS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ ~ ~ . C O N C L U ~ I. O. N. S. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii
3 4 6 7 9 9 12 13 16 17 18 19 20 23 26 27 30 31 32 34 35 37 38 42 44 49 53 53
...
CONTENTS
Vill
I1. DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY by KAI-ERIKPEIPONEN (JOENSUU. FINLAND). ERIKM . VARTIAINEN ASAKURA (SAPPORO. JAPAN) (LAPPEENRANTA. FINLAND) AND TOSHIMITSU
INTRODUCTION
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
$ 2 . KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. Hilbert transforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Kramers-Kronig relations in linear absorption spectroscopy 2.3, Kramers-Kronig relations in reflection spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . 2.4. Dispersion relations in nonlinear optics $ 3 . PHASERETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY . . . . . . . . 3.1. Phase retrieval using maximum entropy model . . . . 3.1 . I . Maximum entropy model . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.2. Phase retrieval procedure . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Phase retrieval in practice: examples . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1. Reflection spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.2. Nonlinear optical spectroscopy . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
$ 4. SWRULES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. Sum rules in linear optics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.1. Complex refractive index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.2. Complex reflectance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. Sum rules in nonlinear optics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . p 5 . CONCLUSIONS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
59 62 62 64 67 69 73 73 73 76 80 80 83 86 86 86 89 90 91 92 92
111. SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT by I.L. FABELINSKII (Moscow, RUSSIAN FEDERATION)
INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 97 5 2 . THEFLUCTUATIONS OF THERMODYNAMIC QUANTITIES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 $ 3 . SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR LIGHTSCAITERING ARISING FROMPRESSURE FLUCTUATIONS &(P) . EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Elastic thermal waves and emitter-generated acoustic waves . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Hypersound velocity and absorption . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Molecular light scattering spectrum and its intensity at low temperatures . . . . 3.4. Molecular light scattering spectra of gases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5. Molecular light scattering spectra in viscous liquids and glasses . . . . . . . 3.6. Light scattering by a two media interface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 4. SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR LIGHTSCATTERING ARISING FROMPRESSURE FLUCTUATIONS A E ( P .) SOMENONEQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. The influence of a steady temperature gradient on the light-scattering spectra . . 4.2. Phonon "bottleneck" in acoustic paramagnetic resonance . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. Amplification of hypersound waves in piezosemiconductors subjected to an external static electric field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
102 110 112 114 116 119 122 124 124 129 I30
CONTENTS
ix
8 5. SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR LIGHTSCATTERING ARISING FROM ISOBARIC ENTROPY FLUCTUATIONS A&(S)AND FROM CONCENTRATION FLUCTUATIONS A&(C) . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 5.1. Central peak: thermal diffusivity and diffusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 5.2. Rayleigh line and concentration fluctuations correlation radii in a critical region . 140 5.3. The investigation of acoustic peculiarities in the region of critical points of the 142 guaiacol-glycerol solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4. The Landau-Placzek relation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 148 6. SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR LIGHT SCATTERING ARISING FROM ANISOTROPY FLUCTUATIONS A~('ik) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151 . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 1 6.1, Spectrum of depolarized light scattered in liquids 6.2. Detection of the doublet structure of the spectrum . . . . . . . . . . . . . 157 6.3. General and simplified equations describing the spectra of light scattered in liquids consisting of anisotropic molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 169 177 5 7. ABOWSOMEPROBLEMS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 178
IV. SOLITON COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS by RENB-JEAN EsslAMBRE AND GOVIND P. AGRAWAL (ROCHESTER, NY. USA)
9: 1 . INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 189
5 2.
p 3.
5 4.
0 5. $ 6. p 7.
OPTICAL SOLITONS IN FIBERS . . . . . . . 2.1. Nonlinear Schriidinger equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Soliton properties 2.3. Adiabatic perturbation theory . . . . SOLITON-BASED COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS. . 3.1. Information transmission with solitons . 3.2. Loss compensation . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Amplifier noise . . . . . . . . . . AVERAGE-SOLITON REGIME . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1, Evolution of the average soliton . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. Timing jitter 4.2.1, Gordon-Haus jitter . . . . . . 4.2.2. Polarization-mode dispersion jitter 4.2.3. Acoustic jitter . . . . . . . . 4.3. Soliton interaction . . . . . . . . . 4.4. Soliton control . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1, Optical bandpass filters . . . . 4.4.2. Synchronous modulators . . . . 4.4.3. Other techniques of soliton control 4.5. Experimental progress . . . . . . . QUASI-ADIABATIC REGIME . . . . . . . . DISTRrBUTED AMPLIFICATION. . . . . . . DISPERSION-DECREASING FIBERS . . . . . . 7. 1 . Basic idea . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
190 190 192 195 196 196 198 200 201 201 203 203 204 205 206 209 209 211 213 214 217 221 223 223
CONTENTS
X
7.2. Timing jitter . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3. Optical phase conjugation . . . . . . . $ 8. DISPERSION MANAGEMENT. . . . . . . . . 8.1, Dispersion compensation . . . . . . . 8.2. Dispersion profiling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 9. CHANNEL MULTIPLEXING 9.1. Wavelength-division multiplexing . . . . 9.1.1. Collision-induced frequency shifts . 9.1.2. Limitations on WDM channels . . 9.1.3. Timing jitter . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.4. Dispersion management . . . . . 9.2. Polarization multiplexing . . . . . . . $ 10. DARK-SOLITON COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS . . . 10.1. Dark-soliton characteristics . . . . . . 10.2. Dark-soliton advantages . . . . . . . . LISTOF SYMBOLS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . LISTOF ACRONYMS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 225 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 227 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 229 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 229 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 232 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 235 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 235 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 236 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 237 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 242 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 243 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 246 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 246 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 247 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 249 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 253 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 254
V. LOCAL FIELDS IN LINEAR AND NONLINEAR OPTICS OF MESOSCOPIC SYSTEMS by OLE KELLEK(AALBORG. DENMARK)
INTRODUCTION
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
$ 2. LOCALFIELDS AND NONLOCAL OPTICS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. Electromagnetic propagator approach 2.2. Electrodynamics within the framework of linear response theory . . . . . . . 2.3. Local-field calculations in mesoscopic media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4. Retarded local-field interaction at distance: space and time-like couplings 2.5. Non-retarded self-field interaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 3. LOCALFIELDSIN MESOSCOPIC MEDIAWITH STRONGLY LOCALIZED ELECTRON ORBITALS . 3 . 1 . Short- and long-range interactions in electronically decoupled molecular systems 3.2. Optically dilute molecular systems; point-particle model . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Mesoscopic media dominated by short-range interactions . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. Linear short-range interactions in two-level hydrogen-like (Is ++ 2p, ) systems . . 5 4 . LOCALFIELDELECTRODYNAMICS IN QUANTUM WELLS AND THINFILMS . . . . . . . . 4.1. Single quantum wells with 2D Bloch and free-electron dynamics . . . . . . . 4.2. Local-field resonances and eigenmodes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. Non-retarded dynamics: self-field and scalar theories . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 5 . 2D SPATIAL CONFINEMENT OF LIGHTBY OPTICAL PHASE CONJUGATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. Source field of a mesoscopic particle: attached and de-attached parts 5.2. Confinement by means of an ideal phase conjugator . . . . . . . . . . . . ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
259 265 265 269 274 281 287 292 292 295 299 302 305 305 310 317 324 324 331 337 337
xi
CONTENTS
VI . TUNNELING TIMES AND SUPERLUMINALITY by RAYMOND Y. CHIAO(BERKELEY. CA) AND AEPHRAIM M. STEINBERG (TORONTO. CANADA) Q 1. $ 2. $ 3. $ 4.
INTRODUCTION. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A BRIEFHISTORY OF Tb"EL1NG TIMES . . . . . TUNNELING AND ITS OPTICAL ANALOGS . . . . . OPTICAL EXPERIMENTS ON TUNNELING TIMES . . . 4 . 1. Carniglia and Mandel's FTIR experiment . . 4.2. Absorptive media with anomalous dispersion 4.3. The Milwaukee group . . . . . . . . . 4.4. The Florence group, part I . . . . . . . . 4.5. The Cologne group, part I . . . . . . . . 4.6. The Berkeley group . . . . . . . . . . 4.7. The Florence group, part I1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8. The Cologne group, part I1 4.9. The Vienna group . . . . . . . . . . . 4.10. Deutsch and Golub's Larmor-clock experiment 4.1 1. Balcou and Dutriaux's FTIR experiment . . 5 5 . NEWTHEORETICAL PROGRESS . . . . . . . . . $ 6 . TUNNELING IN DE BROGLIE OPTICS . . . . . . . $ 7 . SUPERLUMR'IALITY AND INVERTED ATOMS . . . . . $ 8. WHY Is EINSTEIN CAUSALITY NOTVIOLATED? . . Q 9. CONCLUSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ACKNOWLEDGMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . NOTEADDED IN PROOF . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REFERENCES. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 347 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 350 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 359 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 364 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 364 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 365 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 367 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 367 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 368 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 369 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 374 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 375 377 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 378 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 380 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 383 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 385 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 387 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 396 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 400 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 401 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 401 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 401
AUTHOR INDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . SUBJECT INDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CUMULATIVE INDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
407 421 425 433
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
E. WOLF, PROGRESS IN OPTICS XXXVII 0 1997 ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
I
THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS BY
D. DRAGOMAN University of Bucharest, Physics Department, PO.Box MG-63. Bucharest, Romania
1
CONTENTS
PAGE
INTRODUCTION. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
LIGHT PROPAGATION IN PHASE SPACE . . . . . . . .
4
WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . . . . . . .
6
LIGHT BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN FIRST-ORDER OPTICAL SYSTEMS WITH THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
13
OPTICAL SYSTEM CHARACTERIZATION WITH THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . . . . . . . .
20
WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION REPRESENTATION OF THE COUPLING EFFICIENCY . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 THE FRACTIONAL WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION.
32
OPTICAL BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN NONLINEAR OPTICAL SYSTEMS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
38
COMPLEX FIELD RECONSTRUCTION FROM THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
44
WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN QUANTUM OPTICS 49 CONCLUSIONS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REFERENCES.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2
53 53
5
1. Introduction
The Wigner distribution function (WDF) was introduced by Wigner [ 19321 in quantum mechanics as a mathematical tool that correctly yields the expectation values of any function of the coordinates or the momenta. Since its introduction, the WDF has been applied in many branches of physics, including statistical mechanics, nuclear physics, condensed matter, acoustics, and optical signal processing. The excellent book by Kim and Noz [1991] about WDF applications in quantum mechanics includes a comprehensive list of applications in these branches. Other WDF applications in speech analysis, instantaneous frequency measurement, binary detection problems, coherence, and others with corresponding references are listed in Cohen [1989]. Gase [I9901 calculated the WDF of multilayer systems. In optics the WDF was introduced by Walther [1968] to relate partial coherence to radiometry. The success of the WDF formalism is based on the fact that it provides a simultaneous description of optical phenomena in phase space (spatial and angular coordinates for time harmonic fields or in both spatiotemporal and angular-frequency coordinates for light pulses), and is constant along the geometrical ray path at propagation through first-order optical systems. This property suggests that the WDF is an intermediate description of the field distribution between wave and geometrical optics that can be regarded as a local spatial spectrum for time harmonic field distributions or a local and momentary spectrum for light pulses. The purpose of this review is to present WDF applications to the characterization of light fields and optical systems and to the problem of coupling optimization between sources and waveguides. This brief review is supported by a comprehensive and more detailed bibliography.
3
4
THE WIGNER DISTRlBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
3
[I, 8 2
2. Light Propagation in Phase Space
The phase space approach to light propagation was introduced in geometrical optics by Hamilton many years ago. The Hamiltonian equations of motion of a light ray, dr dz
-
dH
dp
8p’
dz
-
dH dr’
can be derived from Fermat’s principle of extremal optical path (Luneburg [1966]). In eq. (2.1) rT=(x,y) is the ray position vector in a z=const. plane of an orthogonal system of coordinates Oxyz and pT= (px,p,,) is its canonical conjugate variable - an angular variable, sometimes called spatial frequency. In geometrical optics z and p correspond to the time t and to the momentum in classic mechanics. The geometrical optical Hamiltonian H(r, p ) = where n(r) is the local refractive index of the medium, reduces in the paraxial approximation (IpI << n) to H(r, p ) = p2/2n(r)- n(r). When H(r,p) is a quadratic function of its variables as, for example, in graded index media where n(r) = no + n2(lrI2) with In21 << no, the ray evolution along the optical axis consists of a succession of linear canonical transformations that can be put in a matrix form:
- d w ,
The matrix S relates the ray vectors (rTpT)in the output (z,, =const.) and input planes (zi= const. =z, - Az) of the optical systems denoted by the subscripts o and i, respectively. S is symplectic (Guillemin and Sternberg [1984]); that is, it satisfies the condition STJS= J , where J
=
(I ) 0 -I
(2.3) with 0 and I as the two-dimensional (2D) null and unit
matrix, respectively. Thus in the Hamiltonian formalism the ray evolution can be described in a 4D space spanned by r andp, which is called phase space (PS). In geometrical optics the 4 x 4 matrix S with unit determinant and real elements takes particular simple forms for optical systems with two principal axes, when the submatrices A to D are diagonal, and for rotationally symmetric optical systems, when A to D are multiples of the 2 x 2 identity matrix. In these cases
1,
5 21
5
LIGHT PROPAGATION IN PHASE SPACE
the ray evolution can be studied independently in two 2D PS (x,px)and (y,py) with corresponding 2 x 2 S matrices. The A , B, C, and D elements are then numbers, and the symplectic condition reduces to det S = 1. To avoid complicated notations, the elements A , B, C , and D will denote both 2 x 2 matrices or numbers; the distinction between these two cases is clearly indicated in the text. S matrices with complex elements were introduced from a wave optical point of view (see, e.g., Yura and Hanson [1987] and Siegman [1986]). The optical systems that can be completely characterized by a symplectic matrix S are called first-order optical systems. A ray that at a z = const. plane has a position vector r and a direction, in the paraxial approximation, o f p is represented in the PS plane by a point. An optical light source formed of a bundle of independent rays is then represented in the PS as a closed area. Under a canonical transformation the shape of the PS area generally changes, but its magnitude remains constant. This result is known as the Liouville theorem, and is not restricted to the paraxial approximation. Examples of ray tracing in PS coordinates can be found in Goethals [ 19891 and Lichtenberg [ 19691. Phenomena such as diffraction, interference, coherence, or polarization cannot be managed in the framework of geometrical optics but only within wave optics, where the light field is characterized by a vectorial distribution A(r, z, t ) that satisfies the Helmholtz equation. A PS analysis of light propagation must now be performed in a more general 6D space of coordinates (r,p, t , w), where w denotes the light frequency (see, e.g., Kostenbauder [ 19901). Generally, not all PS coordinates are implied in the field characterization: for time harmonic fields only the spatial PS coordinates (r,p) are necessary, whereas for light pulses only the temporal PS coordinates ( t ,w ) are used. Moreover, for rotationally symmetric or 1D fields the spatial PS coordinates are reduced to (x,px). Although, in general, this chapter examines the spatial PS, references are also made throughout to the temporal PS. We consider here only scalar wave fields, and if the formulas become excessively complicated or for graphic reasons, discussion is restricted to 1D field distributions. A spatial PS description of a scalar coherent and time harmonic field rp(r,z) can be achieved with either one member, of a class of PS distribution functions that at a z=const. plane are written as 1 c V ( r , p ) = 4n2
J exp [ i k ( q T r - g ~ p - q ~ U ) ]Q(q, g ) v ( u + f )
v*
(-4)
dudgdq,
(2.4) where @(q,5) is the kernel of the integral representation and k =2;1d/L By changing r with t and kp with w, a class of temporal PS distributions is obtained
6
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I, 6 3
that describes light pulses. Different members of the class are individualized by a different choice of the kernel. A systematic discussion of the constraints to be imposed on the kernel to obtain a PS distribution function with required properties can be found in Claasen and Meklenbrauker [198Oc] and Cohen [1989]. Any two members of the class of PS distributions C,, and C,,, with corresponding kernels @ I and @2, are related as
By using this relation new results for one distribution can be simply derived if the corresponding results for another distribution are known. Among the members of the class of PS distribution functions, we note the Wigner distribution function (@(q, f) = l), the Margenau-Hill distribution (@(q, 5) = cos(kqTf/2)), the Rihaczek distribution (@(q, f) = exp(ikqTf/2)), the Page distribution (@(q, f) = exp(ikqT lljl/2)), the Choi-Williams distribution (@(q, f) = exp(-k2q2g2/a)), and the spectrogram @(q, 5) =
/
h*(u- f/2) exp(ikqTu/2) h(u + f/2) du.
Although any of these distribution functions can be used for a PS description, the WDF is preferred in a large number of applications for its properties and for its very simple transformation law through first-order optical systems.
0
3. Wigner Distribution Function
The WDF of a scalar, time harmonic, and coherent field distribution p)(r,z) can be defined at a z=const. plane in terms of either the field distribution or its Fourier transform G(p, z): (3.la)
s
where @(p) = q(r) exp(ikrTp)dr. The z parameter was dropped from the formulas because all the integrals are performed over a z=const. plane. The definition of the WDF in eq. (3.la) was chosen such that p retains its meaning
1,
I 31
WlGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
I
as in geometrical optics. Since other definitions may appear in the literature, care must be taken when comparing the results. The WDF is a bilinear function of the field distribution, a fact that can be harmful, for example, in pattern recognition because the WDF of a linear combination of fields contains all kinds of cross-WDF terms; that is,
where the cross-WDF is defined as:
Wq,,,, (r, p ) =
J qI (r +
g)
q; ( r -
g)
exp(ikrtTp)dr'.
The quadratic behavior of the WDF can be desirable in other applications where the field enters the theory quadratically. For example, it allows the extension of the WDF formalism to stochastic instead of deterministic fields without increasing the dimensionality of the formulas (Bastiaans [ 19861). The WDF of a temporally stationary stochastic field distribution (partially coherent light) is defined by
W r (r, p ) =
1r
(r
r'
+ 7 ,r -
(3.3)
where T(rl, r2) is the correlation function defined as the ensemble average of q(r1)q*(r2).For a vectorial field distribution the WDF is a tensor, as discussed in Bugnolo and Bremmer [1983]. 3.1. PROPERTIES
The most important properties of the WDF of a coherent field are listed here. A more detailed discussion and demonstration of WDF properties can be found in Claasen and Meklenbrauker [ 1980al. PI : The WDF of any field distribution cp is a real but not non-negative function. For real field distributions the WDF is an even function of the angular variable; that is, W,(r,p) = W,(r, -p). P2: A shift in the spatial coordinate of the field distribution shifts the WDF with the same amount; that is, the WDF of cp'(r) = q ( r + ro) is W,(r + ro, p ) . P3: A modulation of the field with exp(ikrTpo) shifts the WDF in the angular coordinate; that is, the WDF of cp'(r) = p ( r )exp(ikrTpo) is W,(r, p +PO). Pq: If the field distribution cp(r) is limited to a certain space interval, the WDF is limited to the same interval. By analogy, if the Fourier transform of the field q ( p ) is limited to an angular interval, the WDF is limited to the same interval.
8
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
5
3
Ps: The integral of the WDF over the angular variable has a clear physical meaning. Namely it is proportional to the intensity of the field distribution (3.4) P g : The integral of the WDF over the spatial variable equals the intensity of the Fourier transform of the field distribution (the field spectrum):
The WDF integrals in P5 and P6 are called the marginals of the WDF. P7: The field distribution and its Fourier transform can be reconstructed from the WDF, up to a constant phase factor, by using the inversion formulas:
W I ) CP*(r2)= 4n2 k2
/
W q ( 2E , p ) exp(-ik(rl -r2)Tp) dp,
(3.6a) (3.6b)
Pg: Another property that will be used later was formulated by Moyal, and refers to the relationship between the WDF of two field distributions and the fields themselves:
(3.7)
It states that the average of the product of two WDF’s is always non-negative. Equations (3.6a) and (3.6b) can be interpreted as the conditions that a function must satisfy in order to be a WDF: a function of r and p is a WDF only if the integrals in the right-hand side of eqs. (3.6a) and (3.6b) are separable in the form of the left-hand side. De Groot and Suttorp [I9721 demonstrated that the necessary and sufficient condition for a function of two variables to be a WDF is (3.8) 4x2
for any a and 6 .
1,
9: 31
WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
9
Properties PI to P4 hold also for partially coherent field distributions. Properties Ps and P6 are valid in a slightly modified form: the integral of the WDF of a partially coherent field over the angular variable equals (4x2/k2)r(r, r), where T(r,r) is the positional intensity of the light field, and the WDF integral over the spatial variable equals the directional intensity of the field r ( p ,p ) . [ r ( p ,p ) is the Fourier transform of T(r, r).] The Moyal’s relation for partially coherent light reads as (Bastiaans [ 19861):
-
k2 4x2
1i.l
(PI,
p2) f;(pl,p2) dpl dp2.
(3.9) The definition and properties of the discrete WDF are extensively presented in Claasen and Meklenbrauker [1980b]. 3.2. EXAMPLES
1. A point source located at ro is described by q(r) = 6(r - ro), and its WDF is Ww(r,p ) = 6(r - ro). This shows that only the point r = ro contributes to the WDF. All the frequencies are present at this point. 2. The plane wave can be represented by a harmonic field distribution q(r) = exp(ikr*po) or equivalently by G ( p )= (4n2/k2)S(p +PO). The WDF is WV(r,p ) = (4n2/k2)6 ( p +PO).The angular variable has a unique value p =-PO at all points. 3. A 1D Gaussian beam q(x) = exp(-x2/xi - ikx2/2R) with real xo and R, also has a Gaussian WDF: WV(x,p x ) = fixoexp(-2x2/x~ - ( p x- ~ / R ) ~ k ~ x ; / 2 ) . The Gaussian beam is the only one for which the WDF is positive everywhere. 4. A 1D Gauss-Schell beam that successfully models a class of partially coherent field distributions is described by a correlation function
The WDF is Wr(x, p x ) = (&/m)exp(-4q2x2
-
( p - ~/R)~k’/4rn’).
3.3. TRANSFORMATION LAWS
The transformation law for the WDF follows from that of the field distribution. For coherent time harmonic fields we distinguish among three situations:
10
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
5
3
Case A. The field evolution through an optical system is described by an integral equation qo(ro)=
1
h (roj ri>qi (ri) dri,
(3.10)
where h is the point-spread function of the system and ro, r, are the transverse ray positions at the output and input planes, respectively, of the optical system. The integral equation can relate not only the output and input field distributions but also their Fourier transforms or even the field at one plane to the Fourier transform at the other. All these situations are detailed in Bastiaans [1979a]. The final propagation law for the WDF is the same in all cases, and therefore we refer here, for clarity, only to the case described by eq. (3.10) The transport equation for the WDF reads wcp0(ro, Po) =
(5) 1
K (ro, Po,
rir
pi) wq,(ri, Pi>dridpit
(3.11)
where the kernel of the integral equation is given by K(ro, po, ri, pi) = x exp(ik (r:Tp,- rbTpo))drb drl.
Bastiaans [1979a] showed that if the modulus and phase of the point-spread function h(ro, ri) = Ih(ro, ri)I exp(ikV(r,, ri)) are slowly varying hnctions of their variables; that is, for geometrical optical systems, the kernel of the integral equation simplifies to
For real optical systems, V(ro,r,) is identical to the Hamilton's point characteristic that can be expressed in the paraxial approximation in terms of the elements of the geometrical optical matrix S (Luneburg [ 19661): V(ro, ri) = Vo +
ir? B-' A r i + lr;fDB-'
ro - r: B-' ro.
Thus the propagation law of the WDF through first-order optical systems characterized by a real matrix S becomes Wqo(r, p) = WV,(DTr- BTp, -CTr + ATp) .
(3.13)
Equation (3.13) implies that the WDF is constant along the geometrical ray paths. The propagation law of the WDF of ID fields through first-order optical systems
1,
P
31
11
WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
characterized by a complex matrix S was derived by Dragoman [1995a,b]. The general expression simplifies for Gaussian field distributions to a form similar to that in eq. (3.13) with elements A , B , C, and D that also depend on the Gaussian field parameters. The transformation law of the spatiotemporal WDF through first-order optical systems was used by Paye and Migus [ 19951 to analyze a pulse shaper. Case B. The evolution of the field distribution is described by a linear transformation that can be put in a matrix form: =
(
T(A-4
V(ri)) o,z(rJ
’
(3.14) where o,,=ao,/dz. This case is represented by a stratified medium (Born and Wolf [ 19641). For example, the electric field component o, of a TE wave and its z derivative at two planes situated at a distance Az apart in a homogeneous layer are related by eq. (3.14) with tl(Az) = t 4 ( b ) = cos(kAz), t>(Az) = sin(kAz)/k, t3(Az) = -ksin(kAz). The vector of WDF, WT = (Wp, Wp,+,=, Wpz.p, Wpz), also satisfies a linear transformation law between the input and output planes. Namely,
w,= ( T
T * )wi
@I
=IWi,
(3.15)
where c31 denotes the direct product of matrices (Barnett [1990]). Case C. The evolution of the field is described by a generally nonlinear differential equation: (3.16) If H = d k 2 ( r ) + d2/dr2, eq. (3.16) is the Helmholtz equation in a transverse inhomogeneous medium. If H =-(k + ( 1/2k)d2/dr2), (3.16) describes the free space evolution of a field in the Fresnel approximation. In the framework of quantum mechanics, eq. (3.16) represents (with z replaced by t ) the timedependent Schrodinger equation. The transport equation for the WDF is (Bastiaans [ 1979b1, Dragoman [ I996a1)
(3.17)
12
THE WIGNER DlSTRlBUTlON FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
53
Here the parametric dependence of the WDF on z is shown. The last term in the argument list of the operators H and H' in eq. (3.17) disappears for linear operators. The transport equations for the WDF in cases A, B and C given, respectively, by eqs. (3.13), (3.15) and (3.17) hold also for partially coherent field distributions (Bastiaans [1986], Simon, Sudarshan and Mukunda [1985]). Case C for inhomogeneous and dispersive media was examined by Bastiaans [ 1979~1.The WDF transformation law of a Gaussian-Schell field through optical systems characterized by complex matrices satisfies in certain cases, a relation similar to eq. (3.13) but with matrix elements which depend on the field distribution (Dragoman [ 1995b1). 3.4. OPTICAL GENERATION
Many devices have been proposed to implement the WDF of 1D or 2D field distributions. One approach to the WDF realization of real 1D fields is by a one-way light passage through a Fourier transform setup (Bartelt, Brenner and Lohmann [1980]). The input consists of a transparency that represents the field distribution, multiplied by a moving Gaussian window. At the output plane that moves synchronously with the window the local spectrum of the WDF of the field convolved with the Gaussian slit transmission is recorded and the WDF is then determined. For real time applications another setup is developed with a fixed but rotated Gaussian window (Bartelt, Brenner and Lohmann [1980]). To avoid the influence of the window, two-way light passage setups were developed for the WDF realization of ID real and arbitrary complex fields (Brenner and Lohmann [1982]). The object consists of a transparency for real fields and a hologram for complex light distributions. The coordinate inversion needed for WDF generation (see eq. (3.la)) is realized with a roof top prism. Another oneway light passage setup was proposed instead of two-way light passage devices (Eichmann and Dong [1982]), but it uses two transparencies rotated relative to each other. If the incident field distribution is 2D, its WDF is 4D, and is therefore impossible to record. To obtain information about the WDF of 2D field distributions however, several setups have been proposed that generate sections of the 4D WDF (Bamler and Glunder [1983], Conner and Li [1985], Iwai, Gupta and Asakura [1986]. These sections can then be displayed in parallel or as temporal sequences. Generating the WDF for digital processing is difficult because of the large number of operations needed to compute the WDF from sampled data. For
I,
5 41
13
WDF LIGHT BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN FIRST-ORDER OPTICAL SYSTEMS
input plane
.
f
fo
Slit 2
Slit 1
4
output plane
Quadrupole
Lens fo
4
.
Fig. 1. Setup for phase space (PS) characterization of a field distribution
applications where a discrete WDF is required, it is computed from other PS distributions functions easier to implement as the Radon transform (Easton, Ticknor and Barrett [ 19841) or Hartley transform (Berriel-Valdos, Gonzalo and Bescos [ 19881). A final setup that has been used not only for the PS representation of field distributions but also for the measurement of the beam quality factor is shown in fig. 1. This device was analyzed from both a geometrical and a wave optical point of view by Weber [1992]. It consists of a rotated quadrupole of focal length f placed in the focal plane of a spherical lens of focal lengthfo and of two slits that eliminate the incident field structure along the y direction and collimate the beam. If d , and d2 are chosen such that I l d l + l/(d2 +YO)= l/fo, a PS map of the incident field distribution along the x axis can be observed at the output plane; namely, x, = -(d2/f0)xi, yo = -(fod2/f)px,.Since the WDF evolves along optical ray paths, this PS representation can also be regarded as a WDF generation. A time-frequency analog of the setup represented in fig. 1 will be described in 9 9. It generates a temporal PS representation of the incident field distribution.
5 4. Light Beam Characterization in First-Order Optical Systems with the Wigner Distribution Function An important application of the WDF is the characterization of light beams by means of the WDF moments. The moment of order i + j + k + 1 of the WDF of a field distribution is defined as k I = XY PxPy
( x -fIi
0,- j Y
@x
s
-mk(Py - P y ) '
W&, Y , P x , P y ) h d Y dPx dPy W , k Y >P x , P y ) dY dPx dPy
(4.1)
14
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
54
where
and i to 1 are non-negative integers. The same definition applies for partially coherent fields with W, replaced by Wr. One of the areas in which the WDF moments have important applications is that of pattern recognition. Teague [1980a] demonstrated that an image can be reconstructed if all its spatial moments are known. The first-order spatial moments locate the center of the considered field distribution, the second-order spatial moments characterize the size and orientation of the image, and higherorder moments determine the details of the field distribution. In practice the first 20 order spatial moments are usually sufficient for an accurate image reconstruction. The optical calculation of the spatial moments of an arbitrary order was analyzed by Teague [198Ob]. For the overall characterization of completely or partially coherent field distribution as for the definition of the optical axis, the principal axes, beam width, divergence, and other characteristics, the exact shape of the light field is not important. The optical axis is defined by the condition that the first-order moments of the WDF are zero. These moments can always be made equal to zero by appropriately shifting or rotating the system of coordinates. The principal axes of an arbitrary field can be defined by two conditions. One set of principal axes is determined by X y = 0, and another set is defined by the requirement that pxpy=O. Unlike the first set of principal axes, the second is independent of z. The z dependent rotation that should be imposed on the first set of principal axes, to superimpose them on the second set of principal (or absolute) axes provides a classification scheme of partially or completely coherent beams (Serna, Mejias and Martinez-Herrero [ 19921). The second-order spatial moments x' and are a measure of the beam width along the x and y directions. Analogously, and characterize the angular divergence of _ the _ field distribution. Moreover, the beam waist is defined as the _ _ plane where (x2 + y 2 ) is minimum. The equation a(x2 +y2)ldz = 0 is equivalent to xp,+yp,=O, both of which are invariant to rotations of the axes. _ reference _ The condition for the beam waist always has a solution unless p: = p j = 0, that is unless the field is a plane wave (Serna, Martinez-Herrero and Mejias [1991]). In applications where a small focus diameter and/or a large Rayleigh range are important, it is often desirable to have a criterion to compare two field
7
2
3
I,
8 41
WDF LIGHT BEAM CHARACTERJZATION IN FIRST-ORDER OPTICAL SYSTEMS
15
distributions from the point of view of the just mentioned requirements. Such a criterion is offered by the beam quality factor Q, defined as
Q takes its minimum value for a Gaussian beam. The ratio between the Q value of an arbitrary beam and that of a Gaussian, usually denoted by M 2 , is a measure of the relative far-field spreading of an arbitrary beam relative to an ideal Gaussian beam with the same waist. It is also a measure of the number of transverse modes of a given field distribution (Lavi, Prochaska and Keren [ 19881). A discussion of the beam quality factor for annular lasers can be found in Gase [1992]. A definition of WDF moments and of the beam quality factor in the general spatiotemporal PS coordinates can be found in Lin, Wang, Alda and Bernabeu [ 19931. The sharpness or flatness of a light field is characterized by the higherorder moments of the WDF. For 1D field distributions the kurtosis parameter
z/
K = (7)zprovides a quantitative measure for beam classification according to their sharpness. A beam is leptokurtic, mesokurtic, or platykurtic if K is higher, equal to, or lower than 3, which is the value for a pure 1D Gaussian (Piquero, Mejias and Martinez-Herrero [ 19941). Martinez-Herrero, Mejias, Sanchez and Neira [ 19921 showed that x'accounts for the symmetry of the 1D field distribution, .'px and x'px are, respectively, measure of the spatial -a -range of the beam's symmetry and sharpness, and x2p:/(x2p:) is a measure of the similarity of an arbitrary beam with a quasihomogeneous field distribution. Finally, we _-note that for any 1D completely or partially coherent field distribution x2p: >, 1/2k2 (Papoulis [1968]); this inequality reminds us of the uncertainty principle in quantum mechanics if k is replaced by h. The analogy is only formal: in quantum mechanics it refers to the probabilistic aspect of measuring, whereas in optics it is only a relation satisfied by WDF moments and is not concerned with the measurement of the WDF. The equality sign holds for the Gaussian field distribution. Apart from the moments defined by eq. (4.1) that are called global moments, the first-order local moments have also a clear physical meaning. Thus P(r) = JpW(r, p ) d p / s W(r, p ) dp can be interpreted as the average angle at position r , and R ( p ) = rW(r, p)dr/J W ( r ,p)dr is the average ray position at the anglep. In time-frequency coordinates, T ( w ) = J tW(t, O ) dt/J W ( t , w)dt is the group delay of the optical pulse and Q ( t ) = wW(t, w)do/J W ( t , W ) dw represents the instantaneous frequency (Claasen and Meklenbrauker [ 1980al).
s
s
16
THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I, 0 4
The beam quality factor can be measured with the device in fig. 1 (Hodgson, Haase, Kostka and Weber [ 1992j), arbitrary-order spatial moments can be measured as suggested by Teague [ 1980bl and all the second-order moments of a 2D field distribution can be measured as proposed by Nemes and Siegman [1994]. 4.1. TRANSFORMATION LAWS FOR THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
MOMENTS
In the previous section we presented some applications of the WDF moments for light beam characterization. As for the WDF itself, the moments are calculated at a z=const. plane. The transformation laws of the WDF moments from one z = const. plane to another allow the prediction of beam parameters’ modification at propagation. The transformation laws of the WDF moments follow from those of the WDF itself and were derived only for cases A and B in 9: 3.3. Case A. Transformation laws through first-order optical systems. To obtain a compact form of the transformation laws of WDF moments through real firstorder optical systems, the moments of a given orderj are arranged in a matrix Mi defined as
j times
where again @ denotes the direct product of matrices and the bar over the matrix in eq. (4.3) indicates that each matrix element is averaged in the sense of eq. (4.1). Dragoman [ 19941 showed that the moment matrix of orderj propagates through a first-order optical system characterized by a real matrix S according to the following relation:
--
Mjo = (S @ s @ . . .) Mji (S.@ [j/2] times
s @ . . .y .
(4.4)
( j - [.;/2]) times
In particular, one has MI, = SMl,, Mzo = SM2,ST, M30 = SM3,(S @J S)T,and M~o=(S@S)M~~(S@S)~. The transformation law of WDF moments through complex matrix optical systems has a form similar to eq. (4.4) only in a few cases: for Gaussian beams and for Gaussian-Schell beams that propagate through ripple systems and systems characterized by a matrix with elements A = a(l + i)/&, B = 6,
I,
5 41
WDF LIGHT BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN FIRST-ORDER OPTICAL SYSTEMS
17
C = c, and D = d( 1 - i ) / a with real a to d and ad - bc = 1. In these cases the symplectic matrix S in eq. (4.4) should be replaced by another symplectic matrix that depends on both the optical system and the field distribution (Dragoman [ 1995b1). Case B. Transformation laws through a stratified medium. In a stratified medium where the electric field q and its z derivative at two different planes are related by a matrix T and the WDF vector transforms according to eq. (3.15), the moments of arbitrary order satisfy the same transformation law as the WDF itself. By assuming that Wq(r, p ) dr dp = Wqz(r,p ) dr dp = 1 and defining a moment vector of order i + j + k + Z with respect to the optical axis as
s
s
where
it follows that the transformation law of the moment vector is x'yJp:p;,
=
7xiyJp:p;i.
(4.5)
4.2. PROPAGATION INVARIANTS
The existence of propagation invariants of a field distribution can help to compare or even to classify different fields according to a required criterion. Up to now invariants have been searched only for the propagation through firstorder optical systems. The first invariant that was found is the determinant of the second-order moment matrix, det M2 (Bastiaans [ 19891). The invariance of det M 2 follows from the transformation law of M2 and the symplectic properties of the real or complex S matrix (see (2.3), (4.4) and the discussion that follows). det M2 = Q2, a result that shows that the beam quality factor is constant at propagation through first-order optical systems. This result holds also for the definition of the beam quality factor in the general spatiotemporal PS (Lin, Wang, Alda and Bernabeu [ 19931). Unlike Q, the kurtosis parameter is not invariant at propagation. Its behavior at free propagation was used to classify the light beams (Martinez-Herrero, Piquero and Mejias [ 19951). Another class of invariants at propagation through real or complex matrix systems for which eq. (3.13) holds was introduced by Onciul [ 1993al and Dragoman
18
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
54
[ 1995b] in terms of the Lagrange ray invariant a(r, p , r’, p ’ ) = (rTpT)J($) = a(p, p’), where p=(r,p), p’= (r‘,p’) are two points in the PS. The elements of this class are defined as 121 =
J a2‘(r, p , r’, p ’ ) W ( r ,p ) W(r’, p’) dr dp dr’ dp’ J W(r, p ) W(r’,p’) d r dp dr’ dp’
9
where 1 is an integer; 1212 is again identical to Q. The determinant and trace of some combinations of moment matrices up to the fourth order were found to be invariant (Martinez-Herrero, Mejias, Sanchez and Neira [1992]). Although physical interpretations have been given to these invariants, it is not clear why these combinations were chosen or if these are the only invariants. A systematic approach to find beam invariants, first published by Bastiaans [1991], showed that the product between the 4 x 4 second-order moment matrix M2 and the antisymmetric matrix J satisfies a similarity transformation at propagation through first-order optical systems. The eigenvalues of M2J and any combination of them are then invariant at propagation. Several properties of the eigenvalues of M2J have been derived such as (i) the eigenvalues are is an eigenvalue, is also an eigenvalue; and (iii) if M2 is real; (ii) if proportional to a symplectic matrix with a positive proportionality factor m, the two positive eigenvalues of MzJ are both equal to +m and the two negative eigenvalues are equal to -m. Similarity transformations at propagation through first-order optical systems have also been derived for combinations of higherorder moment matrices and the J matrix. Properties (i) and (iii) were found to hold for the combinations of even order moment matrices, whereas (ii) holds for odd order moment matrices and for even order moment matrices M2k with k an odd integer (Dragoman [1994]). A similar approach for finding beam invariants from the second-order moment matrix was taken by Anan’ev and Bekshaev [ 19941. WDF moments’ propagation laws and propagation invariants through misaligned optical systems were found by Onciul [ 1993bl.
x
-x
4.3. WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION TRANSFORMATION LAW AND THE BEAM ENERGY VARIATION
The integral of the WDF over its variables is proportional to the total energy of the beam E: W ( r ,p ) d r dp = ( 4 n 2 / k 2 ) E .This relation follows from eq. (3.4). The propagation law for the WDF through first-order optical systems determines the relation between the beam energy at the output plane and that at the input
1,
5 41
WDF LIGHT BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN FIRST-ORDER OPTICAL SYSTEMS
19
plane of the optical system. For 1D field distributions such a relation was derived by Dragoman [ 1996bl for arbitrary light distributions: E,=y/Wi(x,p,)exp
Re-Im--Re-lmA C B B B
”> B
where k2exp(4kIm VO)
4n36(Bl2 ’ and V, is the constant part of the Hamilton’s point characteristic function. If IB ( = 0, other expressions in terms of the angular or mixed characteristic functions can be used instead of eq. (4.8), as explained in Dragoman [1996b]. When all elements of the optical system matrix as well as VO are real, E, = (k/2n) Wi(x,p x )dx dp, = Ei as expected, otherwise the beam loses or gains energy. 4.4. COMPARISON WITH OTHER METHODS OF BEAM CHARACTERIZATION
This section compares the method of beam width or beam quality factor definition with the WDF moments with other methods. Among these other methods Sasnett [I9891 mentioned the measurement of lie2 of the highest peak or of the outermost peak and the measurement at 86.5% of total power, but neither method gives good results for all field distributions. For example, the use of the technique of measurement at lie2 of the highest peak intensity inadequately characterizes the higher-order modes when the outer peaks fall below this level. The measurement of lie2 of the outermost peak does not solve this problem because for mixtures of two or more modes with outer peaks eliminated, the determined beam width is incorrect. The method of beam width definition with the second-order moment of the WDF has some advantages over other methods because for pure modes the values fall midway in the range of values provided by other methods, and for mixed modes the beam width is equal to the power-weighted sum of M 2 values for the pure modes (Sasnett [1989]). The results obtained from all these methods agree only for the TEMoo mode. Siegman [1993a] described other methods of beam width definition for an arbitrary field distribution as the knife-edge
20
THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
55
method, the scanning slit or pinholes method, and the Gauss-fit method. He again pointed out that for each measurement method certain beam profiles can be found for which the method gives wrong results. For example, any nearfield pattern with a step discontinuity produces a farfield pattern whose second-order spatial moment diverges to infinity in the paraxial approximation The Gauss-fit method fails to provide a reasonable value for the beam width of a field that consists of a Gaussian central lobe plus a Gaussian pedestal. In conclusion, the problem of finding a universal method for the definition of beam width, or other beam characteristics, is not completely solved. In most cases, however, the definition based on the WDF moments provides reasonable results.
@ 5. Optical System Characterization
with the Wigner Distribution Function
The previous section presented some applications of the WDF to light field characterization. In this section we show that the WDF can also be used to characterize the optical systems through which the field distribution passes. For reasons of graphic representation this section will be restricted to 1D field distributions and rotationally symmetric optical systems for which eq. (3.13) becomes W,(x, p , ) = W,(Dx- Bp,, -Cx + Ap,). To characterize a first-order optical system, the WDF must be measured at its input and output planes and then the A , B , C, and D elements of the optical system matrix determined according to the WDF transformation law. Although this procedure can be carried out for arbitrary field distributions, it would be helpful if the light field had a WDF with a simple form. Let us suppose that the input plane of the optical system is located at the waist plane of a Gaussian field. Its WDF is then (see the example in 3.2 with I/R=O):
For a better comparison of the WDF at the input and output planes of the optical system, we will examine the transformation of the phase space acceptance (PSA). The PSA represents the intersection of the WDF with a plane parallel to the ( x , p x )plane at a height equal to l/e2 of the maximum height of
I,
5
51
OPTICAL SYSTEM CHARACTERIZATION WITH THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
21
the WDF. For a Gaussian light distribution with the waist at the input plane, the PSA in the normalized coordinates X = X / X OP, = kpxxo is an ellipse given by X 2 + iP’
=
(5.1)
1.
The PSA at the output plane is obtained by inserting the WDF transformation law into eq. (5.1). The result in the X , P coordinates is
(54 The transformation of the PSA between the input and output planes of a firstorder optical system is identical to the transformation of an elliptical PS area through a first-order optical system obtained by ray tracing in geometrical optics (Goethals [1989]). The area of the PSA at both the input and output planes has the same value: 2nlk = ilin the original x , p x coordinates or 2 n in the X,P coordinates, a result that follows from Liouville’s theorem. In figs. 2a-d a dotted line represents the PSA ellipse at the input plane chosen at the waist of the beam, and a solid line represents the PSA after passing through a length of free space (fig. 2a) a thin lens (fig. 2b), a magnifier (fig. 2c), and a Gaussian aperture (fig. 2d). Both the eccentricity and the inclination of the input PSA in the normalized coordinates may change after passing through a first-order optical system, their variation being related to the elements of the optical system matrix. For example, after passing through the free space of length d characterized by an optical matrix with A = D = 1, C = 0, and B = d , the angle between the PSA ellipse and the X axis changes from zero to
and the eccentricity changes with
[
A E = E- E . =
’
2J(3k2x: - 4d2)2 + 64 (dkxi)2 5k2x4, + 4d2 + J(3k2xi
-
1/2
4d2)2 + 64 (dkx;)2
After a thin lens characterized by A = D = 1 , C = -l/f and B = 0, where f is the focal length, the PSA ellipse rotates with respect to the X axis with an angle
e = iarctan
(
3;:$x4,)
’
22
THE WIGNER DISTIUBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
5
1
:
F40
-1
.
i
-2
..__ .
.,f
a
'
-2
-1
0
1
-3
2
-1 -0.5
X
0 0.5
1
X
2
1
nlo -1 -2-2
-1
0
X
1
2
-1 -0.5 0
0.5
1
X
Fig. 2. The phase space acceptance (PSA) of a Gaussian beam in the waist (dashed line) and after (a) a free space of length d = k x i ; (b) a thin lens of focal lengthf=-O.S/kxi; (c) a magnifier with m = 1.5; (d) a Gaussian aperture with g=-O.S/kx$.
and the eccentricity varies with 1/2
Note that the rotation angle of the PSA ellipse depends on the lens type; that is, it is positive for convergent lenses c f > O ) and negative for divergent lenses
cf. The elements of the optical matrix that describe a magnifier are A = rn, D = l/m, and B = C = 0. After passing through a magnifier, only the eccentricity of the PSA ellipse changes. The variation of the eccentricity,
is, unlike for the previous optical systems, independent on the wavenumber of the incident light and the beam parameter X O .
I,
5 51
OPTICAL SYSTEM CHARACTERIZATION WITH THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
23
The Gaussian aperture is characterized by a matrix with complex elements A = 1, B=O, C=-i/g, and D = 1. As demonstrated by Dragoman [1995b] at propagation of a Gaussian field distribution through a complex optical system, the transformation law of the WDF is the same as for real optical systems but with A, B, C, and D replaced by elements that depend also on the incident field: 1, 0, -kxi/2gR (= 0 at waist) and l-kxi/2g, respectively. The determinant of this equivalent matrix is not equal to 1. Moreover, the area of the PSA ellipse in the normalized coordinates is 2161I l-kxi/2g I at the output of the aperture, whereas at the input it is equal to 216. This result agrees with the fact that Liouville's theorem holds only for lossless or gainless optical systems. Again, only the eccentricity of the PSA ellipse changes:
Although the matrices of a lens and a Gaussian aperture are similar, their effect on the field distribution (and on the WDF) is totally different. The Gaussian aperture acts as an absorber, thus modifying the PSA area and the extent on the X direction, whereas the lens modifies the divergence of the beam, that is, the extent on the P direction, without changing the PSA area. 5.1. CHARACTERIZATION OF ABERRATED OPTICAL SYSTEMS
The applications of the WDF also include the characterization of aberrated optical systems. With respect to the WDF, Lancis, Sicre and Pons [1995] discussed the propagation of polychromatic spatially coherent light through an optical system developed for achromatizing Fresnel diffraction patterns. The selected diffraction pattern to be achromatized is located at a distance Ro from the input plane and is followed by an achromatic lens and a zone plate. The WDF transformation law through first-order optical systems has been used to derive relations among the various parameters of the system in order to minimize the chromatic aberration. Experimental verification was performed to illustrate the theoretical results. Lohmann, Ojeda-Castaneda and Streibl [ 19831 took a different approach, calculating the WDF of an aberrated optical system and observing that the influence of aberrations on the WDF can be expressed by means of a differential operator of exponential type. The first term of the operator predicts a coordinate transformation of the WDF identical to the WDF transformation through first-order (unaberrated) optical systems, whereas the second term of
24
THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
5
5
the operator is responsible for the shape distortion of the WDF. The analysis was done for the 1D WDF. Dragoman [1996c] discussed in detail the influence of the different aberration types on a 2D WDF. The WDF of an aberrated optical system has been derived as in 93.3 (case A) with the input and output planes chosen as the object and exit pupil planes of the optical system. The unaberrated part, Vunab, of the point characteristic function V(xo,yo, xi, Yi)
=
[A(x? +Y:) + D(xi +v:)- 2(xixo + ~ i v o ) /2B ]
+ VO
Vab(Xo, y o ,
= Vunab(Xo,
xi, Vi)
yo, xi, yi) + Vab(Xo, yo, xi, ui)
was assumed to describe a rotationally symmetric optical system. The aberrated part (Born and Wolf [ 1964]), Vab(Xo, yo,
xi, yi) = -
2 2 (XO +yo) - b(xoxi
2
+yoyi)
+ e (xi + Y;) (xoxi + yoyi)
5
contains the contributions of all types of aberration: spherical aberration (through a), astigmatism (through b), field curvature (through c), distortion (through d), and coma (through e ) . As an example, the influence of these aberration types on an incident 2D Gaussian beam q(xi,yi)=exp[-(x? +y?)/xi] was studied. The WDF at the exit pupil plane was calculated in the normalized coordinates X = xi/xo, Y = yi/xo, P, = kxopxi, and Py = kxopyi, and the PSA of the projection of the WDF on the Y = Py = 0 plane, that is, of the W ( X ,0, P,, 0), was represented for an unaberrated or an aberrated passage through a free space. A free space is understood here as an optical system characterized by a matrix with A = D = 1, C=O, and B = d that can be realized not only by a free space of length d but also by a combination of lenses and free spaces (Sudarshan, Mukunda and Simon [ 19851). At least in the latter case the source of aberrations can be easily identified. The results are shown in fig. 3. After an unaberrated free space the PSA is a rotated ellipse, in agreement with fig. 2a. If spherical aberration is present, the PSA has an S-shaped form, as observed previously by Goethals [ 19891 and Lichtenberg [1969]. For other aberration types the PSA has different shapes, except for astigmatism and field curvature, for which the PSA’s of the WDF projection on the Y = Py = 0 plane are identical. To distinguish between them, one should be able to plot the PSA of the WDF projection on another plane, for example, on the Y =0.5, Py = 0 plane as discussed by Dragoman
1,
5
51
25
OPTICAL SYSTEM CHARACTERIZATION WITH THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
-2 -1 0
1 2
-2 -1
0
1
2
z ; p i
-1
-2
g
-1
1
0
4
p
2
1
-2
-2 -1 0
X
1
2
-3-15 0 15 3
X
-4
-2
0
2
4
X
Fig. 3. The phase space acceptance (PSA) of a Gaussian beam in the waist after an (a) unaberrated free space of length d = k x i and in the presence of (b) spherical aberrations with a=0.2/kx;; (c) astigmatism with b=O.l/kx: or field curvature with c=OS/kx;; (d) distortion with d =-0.2/kx; (barrel type); (e) distortion with d =0.2/kx; (pin-cushion type); and (f) coma with e=O.l/kx;.
[1996c]. The WDF projection on the Y = Py = 0 or the Y = 0.5, Py = 0 plane can be realized with the experimental device in fig. 1. In the first case the input beam has to be centered in the input plane, whereas for the experimental realization of the second case a downward shift of the optical beam at the input plane is required. Figure 3 suggest that different types of aberrations can be separately identified by observing their effects on the PSA of a given incident beam. Both the WDF and the WDF moments are modified in the presence of aberrations. Siegman [ 1993bl showed that the spherical aberration degrades the beam quality factor. Piquero, Mejias and Martinez-Herrero [ 19941 investigated the influence of the spherical aberration on the kurtosis parameter K . For an incident 1D Gaussian beam, the kurtosis parameter is equal to 3 and remains constant at propagation through first-order optical systems. After an aberrated lens, however, the output beam is no longer Gaussian and the value of K depends on the plane where it is determined. The experimental results showed that the beam becomes strongly platykurtic before the paraxial focal point of the aberrated lens and strongly leptokurtic after the focal point. Significant kurtosis changes can arise from small spherical aberrations. At distances much larger than
26
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
5
6
the focal length the beam is only slightly leptokurtic. Thus a Gaussian beam can be made sharper or flatter by means of a single spherically aberrated lens.
8 6. Wigner Distribution Function Representation of the Coupling Efficiency Another problem for which the WDF approach has proved useful is that of coupling efficiency optimization between a light source and a waveguide. A series of papers by Onciul [1993c, 1994a,b] and Dragoman [ 1995c,d] showed that a definition of the coupling efficiency in terms of the WDF of the source and waveguide offered some advantages compared with the usual coupling efficiency definition in terms of the source and waveguide field distributions. One advantage is that it takes explicitly into account through the angular variable of the WDF the effect of the receiver’s finite angular aperture on the coupling efficiency. Moreover, Dragoman [ 1995dl defined an effective numerical aperture for single-mode or few-mode waveguides, based on the WDF representation of the waveguide modes that is similar to the geometric definition of the numerical aperture valid for multimode waveguides. This effective numerical aperture, defined for a ID waveguide mode with a WDF W,(x,p,) as
was shown to depend not only on the core and cladding refractive indices but also on the core diameter. This does not contradict the geometric optical definition of the numerical aperture in terms of the critical reflection angle at the boundary between core and cladding, because the latter gives the numerical aperture of the light that excites all bound modes in highly multimode waveguides, whereas the effective numerical aperture is related to a particular mode described by a WDF Wrn(x,px). Another advantage of the coupling efficiency definition in terms of the WDF is that it allows a simpler approach to the coupling efficiency optimization. As one might expect coupling efficiency between a source and a waveguide is higher if the fields (and the WDF) of the source and waveguide at the illumination plane are as similar as possible. Since the WDF transforms through a first-order optical system in an very simple manner (see eq. 3.13), it is possible to find a first-order optical system to be inserted between the source and the waveguide such that at the illumination plane the WDF of the source is as similar as possible to that
WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION REPRESENTATION OF THE COUPLING EFFICIENCY
I, $ 61
27
of the waveguide. For sources with unknown field distributions the WDF can be measured with one of the devices described in sect. 3.4. 6.1. COMPLETELY COHERENT SINGLE MODE SOURCES AND WAVEGUIDES
Under the assumption that the surface of illumination is planar, the coupling efficiency between a source and a waveguide can be defined in terms of the field distributions of the source and waveguide, qs(r) and cpw(r),respectively,
or in terms of the corresponding WDF, Ws(r,p), and Ww(r,p)
'
=
J Ws(r, P) Ww(r, P) dr dP k2 J Ws(r, p ) dr dp s Ww(r,p>d r dp' 4n2
where the integrals extend over the illumination plane. The expressions of the coupling efficiency given by eq. (6.2) and eq. (6.3) are identical, as can be demonstrated by using eq. (3.4) and eq. (3.7). Apart from the advantages of the coupling efficiency definition (6.3) discussed above, by a simple inspection, the graphic representation of the WDF of the source and waveguide allows an a priori estimation of the coupling efficiency. In particular from the WDF inspection of different light sources an estimation can be made regarding the value of the coupling efficiency to a given waveguide mode. To illustrate this statement, we study the coupling efficiency between a Gaussian light source and the first four modes of a waveguide. For reasons of graphic representation we will now restrict our discussion to ID field distributions. The WDF of the Gaussian light source q S ( x )= exp(-x2/x:) is
whereas the WDF of thejth mode of the waveguide in the Gaussian approximation qj(x) = (x/xw)Jexp(-x2/xi) is
j-k
C
22W-i
(-1);
i!c; c2; 2i 2 ( j - k ) (kpXxW)-2',
i=O
where C; =j!l[k!(j-k)!]. The normalized WDF [i.e., W(x,p,)lW(O, O)] of the first four modes of the waveguide ( j = O , 1, 2, 3) are represented in fig. 4 in
28
THE WlGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
56
Fig. 4.The normalized Wigner distribution function (WDF) c";.(X, P)/ ltt;.(O, 0)I of (a) the fundamental mode in a waveguide ( j = O ) ; (b) the first odd mode ( j = 1); (c) the second even mode ( j = 2 ) ; and (d) the second odd mode (J' = 3).
the normalized coordinates X = x / x w , P = kp,x,. Figure 4a also represents the normalized WDF of the light source in the coordinates xlx,, kpxx,. The source couples the most amount of light in the zero-th (fundamental) mode, because the two field distributions have similar WDF's. Moreover, the maximum coupling efficiency ( q = 1) occurs when x , =xw, that is, when the field distributions and the WDF are identical. This result can be obtained with either eq. (6.2) or eq. (6.3). The advantage of using the definition eq. (6.3) becomes obvious when one is interested in the coupling efficiency estimation of the light source in the misaligned waveguide modes. In fig. 5 the coupling eficiency between the light source and the first four waveguide modes is plotted as a function of the normalized lateral displacement XO= xolx, for xs = x , . As expected, for XO= 0 (aligned light source and waveguide modes) the coupling efficiency into odd modes ( j = 1 and j = 3 in our example) is zero, due to the different symmetry of the field distributions of the source and waveguide modes. The symmetry of a field distribution can be determined from its WDF. From the WDF definition it follows that for either odd or even modes W(-x,p,) = W ( x ,-px), but the value of the WDF is positive at the phase space origin (i.e., at x = p x = 0) for even modes and negative for odd modes. This feature can be also observed in fig. 4. The
I,
5 61
WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION REPRESENTATION OF THE COUPLING EFFICIENCY
29
xo -3
-1
1
3
Fig. 5 . The dependence on the lateral displacement of the coupling efficiency between a Gaussian source and the fundamental waveguide mode (solid line), the first odd mode (dashed line), the second even mode (dash-dotted line) and the second odd mode (long dashes).
coupling efficiency of the light source into aligned even modes decreases with j because the corresponding WDF’s become more dissimilar when j increases. The displacement of the source and waveguide modes is described in the PS as a lateral displacement along the X axis. By a lateral displacement the coupling efficiency between the light source and the fundamental waveguide mode decreases exponentially because the overlap of the two WDF decreases with the distance between their centers. By analogy, the overlap between the WDF of the source and that of the first odd waveguide mode should have one maximum with the displacement along the positive X axis and another, symmetric along the negative X axis because the WDF are symmetric. This fact is confirmed by fig. 5. The dependence on XOof the coupling efficiency between the source and the mode with j = 3 can be interpreted in the same manner. From figs. 4a and 4c it appears that the coupling efficiency between the source and the even mode with j = 2 should have three maxima: one at XO= 0 and the other two symmetrically with respect to it. The central maximum at XO= 0 does not appear, however, because all the extrema of the WDF with respect to X,along the P = 0 line, are positive. In this case the number of maxima in the coupling efficiency as a function of X is smaller (with the central peak missing) than the number of the relative maxima in the WDF of the waveguide mode. A similar interpretation can be given to the coupling efficiency as function of the tilt angle. Figure 6 shows the dependence of the coupling efficiency
30
THE WlGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
56
PO -3
-6
3
6
Fig. 6. Same as in fig. 5 as a function of the tilt.
between the Gaussian light source and the first four waveguide modes on the tilt Po=kp,ox,. In the PS the tilt between the source and the waveguide mode is represented as a displacement along the P axis of their WDF. The overlap between the WDF of the source and that of a tilted waveguide mode determines the form of the coupling efficiency dependence on Po. The only case that needs a separate comment is the coupling efficiency between the source and the mode with j = 2. The three maxima in the coupling efficiency in fig. 6 correspond to what is expected from an inspection of figs. 4a and 4c because the extrema of W, with respect to P for X = O have alternative positive and negative values. In this case the number of maxima in the coupling efficiency as a function of the parameter of misalignment is equal to the number of relative maxima in the WDF of the waveguide mode with respect to the misalignment parameter. Other examples of the connection between the form of the WDF graphic representation and the amount of coupled light, including a light modulator, can be found in Dragoman [1995c]. 6.2. MULTIMODE, COMPLETELY COHERENT SOURCES AND WAVEGUIDES
Let us suppose that the field q p , ( r )in the waveguide can be expressed as a superposition of modal fields rpc(r),
m
I,
5 61
WIGNER DISTMBUTION FUNCTION REPRESENTATION OF THE COUPLING EFFICIENCY
31
with complex coefficients a,. The q{ are not necessarily orthonormal and are not necessarily the eigenmodes of the total field. If qw(r) is the bound field in a waveguide, q{ can be chosen as the fundamental and higher-order bound modes. The field of the light source can also be multimoded:
The total coupling efficiency between the light source and the waveguide is then given by
where
are the components of the cross-coupling tensor, with Wfk(r,p ) =
/
qf(r
+
g)
qf*(r -
g)
exp(ikrtTp)dr',
i = s, w.
(6.8) represents the coupling efficiency between the nth source mode and the Ith waveguide mode. The realness of the WDF implies that rlnnl'
p d k =
sw
mnkl = nmkl = mnlk rlsw rlsw rlsw '
Further conditions can be imposed on the components of the cross-coupling tensor, depending on the choice of the modal fields qc,q:. 6.3. PARTIALLY COHERENT SINGLE MODE SOURCES AND WAVEGUIDES
Onciul [ 1994bl showed that the definition (6.3) is not valid for partially coherent light distributions, although the WDF that appears in this definition can be
32
THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
5
7
defined for partially coherent light. It was demonstrated that for partially coherent light the coupling efficiency is
in terms of the field distributions, where the angle brackets denote the ensemble average and (6.10)
W,,(r,p)= =
I(.. 1
( r + g ) c p i ( r - g ) ) exp(ikrlTp)dr'
Tsw(r
r'
(6.1 1)
+ T ,r -
For completely coherent field distributions rsw( rl, r2) = cp,(rl) qk(r2), and eq. (6.3) and eq. (6.10) coincide. If the mutual coherence function is expanded in its eigenmodes (Wolf [ 1982]), that is, (6.12) where p is a scaling factor and
/
~ ( r~ )( rd r) = d m n ,
(6.13)
the coupling efficiency can be written as (6.14)
5
7. The Fractional Wigner Distribution Function
The WDF is an appropriate mathematical tool for beam characterization. Its definition in terms of the Fourier transform of the field means that it adequately describes the light distribution in the far-field diffraction region.
1,
5 71
THE FRACTIONAL WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
33
The corresponding mathematical tool that completely characterizes the field distribution in the near-field regime is the fractional Wigner Distribution Function (FWDF). It was introduced by Dragoman [1996d], starting from the definition of the fractional Fourier transform. This transform was introduced by Namias [ 19801 in quantum mechanics to solve several types of Schrodinger equation, and its properties were investigated by Namias [1980] and McBride and Kerr [1987]. The definition of the fractional Fourier transform of order a of the 1D function v(x> is
where C = sgn(sin a), 1. 1 denotes the modulus of the argument, and &(pX) = q(kp,), s * , ( p x ) = q(-kpx). When a = nI2, the fractional Fourier transform coincides with the Fourier transform. This mathematical definition supports a physical interpretation based on the light propagation properties in a graded index optical fiber. Ozaktas and Mendlovic [1993a] defined the fractional Fourier transform of order a as what happens to a light distribution that propagates through a graded index fiber after a length al;, where L is the propagation length, after which a graded index fiber generates a Fourier transform of the incident light distribution. The fractional Fourier transform was successfully applied in optics for spatial filtering (Ozaktas and Mendlovic [ 1993b], Ozaktas, Barshan, Mendlovic and Onural [ 19941, Granieri, Trabocchi and Sicre [ 1995]), for analyzing the beam propagation in the Fresnel approximation and spherical mirror resonators (Ozaktas and Mendlovic [1994, 1995]), and for shift-variant image detection based on the concept of fractional correlation (Mendlovic, Ozaktas and Lohmann [ 19951). The search for new applications of the fractional Fourier transform continues. Recently Abe and Sheridan [1994a,b, 19951 showed that the fractional Fourier transform is a member of the class of special affine Fourier transforms that represent the most general lossless inhomogeneous linear mapping in PS. The two preceding definitions of the fractional Fourier transform are identical to a third, indirect definition as the transform performed on a function that leads to a rotation with an angle a=an/2 of the associated WDF (Lohmann [1993],
34
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I, $ 7
Mendlovic, Ozaktas and Lohmann [1994]). This means that by applying the WDF to a fractional Fourier transformed distribution, one obtains
J 43, ( x + ); 43; ( x -
g)
exp(ikx'p,) dx'
cos a - kp, sin a , x-
sina + p x cosa k
The FWDF of order a is defined, by analogy with (3.lb), as exp(-ikxp')dp'.
(7.3)
The relation between the FWDF and WDF is simple: Wt'2 (x,p,)= W,(x,px), and for arbitrary a, W,*(x, p,)
=
W,(kpx cosa + x sina, p x sina - x cos a/k);
(7.4)
that is, Wg represents a rotation of the WDF with an angle a - n/2 in the plane (x, kp,) (Dragoman [1996d]). Although the FWDF and WDF are so closely related, their physical meaning is different. This follows from the relationship between the fractional Fourier transform and the Fresnel transform derived by Gori, Santarsiero and Bagini [ 19941:
(7.5) where the Fresnel transform F,(px) is defined as (Papoulis [1968]) (7.6) From eqs. (7.5) and (7.6) it follows that the FWDF can be directly defined in terms of the Fresnel transform, so that it replaces the WDF in the near-field diffraction regime as a mathematical tool for beam characterization. 7.1. PROPERTIES OF THE FRACTIONAL WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
The following properties of the FWDF were derived by Dragoman [ 1996dl:
1, B 71
35
THE FRACTIONAL WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
Pi: A space shift in q ( x ) yields the same shift in the spatial coordinates of W;(x sin a - kp,cos a, x cos a/k +p,sina). Pi: A frequency shift in Ta(p1) (or T ( p , ) ) leads to the same shift in the frequency coordinate of W;(x,p,) (or Wg(xsin a - kp, cos a, x cos alk + pxsin a)). Pi: If q ( x ) is limited to a certain spatial interval, W;(x sin a - kp, cos a, x cos alk + pxsin a ) is limited to the same interval. By analogy, if T a ( p x )(or q ( p x ) ) is limited to a certain frequency interval, W;(x,p,) (or W;(xsina kp,cos a, x cos alk + pxsin a ) ) is limited to the same interval.
XI + x 2
.
sin a - kp, cos a,
~
+X2
2k
cos a + p x sin a
(7.10a)
(7.10b) -
rp,
( m )5 :( m )=
1wg
+P x 2 7) exp [ikn (p,l -pX2)1 h.
Pxl (X,
(7.10c)
These properties of the FWDF were numbered such that properties P', to P{ correspond to properties PI to P7 of the WDF. 7.2. OPTICAL BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN THE NEAR-FIELD DIFFRACTION REGIME
The WDF moments are used to characterize a field distribution and its propagation through first-order optical systems. Due to the close connection
36
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I, $ 7
between the FWDF and WDF, the whole moment formalism of the WDF can be translated to the FWDF in order to characterize field distributions in the nearfield region (Dragoman [1996d]). The moments of the 1D FWDF are defined as (7.1 1)
5"
where = J EWG(x, px) dx dpx/J W,"(x, px) dx dp, with 5 =x,px and i, j integers. By analogy with the transformation law of the WDF through first-order optical systems, the transformation law for the FWDF is W&(X, px) = W ; I P
- Bpx, -CX
where A B
sina
(7.12)
+ &x),
-kcosa)
(:
i3)
(
sin a -cosa/k
k cos a
sina (7.13) is an equivalent optical matrix different from the symplectic S matrix with elements A , B, C, and D that characterizes the first-order optical system; it takes into account the near-field diffraction effects through a. Of course, when a = nI2, one has S = S. The moment matrix of order j is defined as
MY= (xpx)@
(L) -.
@..-',
(7.14)
j times
where the overbar and the superscript a denote the average of all matrix elements in the sense of eq. (7.1 1). The transformation law of moment matrices is similar to eq.(4.4): (7.15) The symplectic property of S implies the invariance of det M f j , in particular the invariance of the beam quality parameter in the near-field diffraction regime defined as Qa =
?aza
- ( G O )
2
=
det M:.
(7.16)
1,
9: 71
37
THE FRACTIONAL WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
The class (4.6) of invariants defined in terms of the WDF simply transforms in the class of invariants
p 2j
=
J a2jW,a(x,Px) W,a(x/,P:) dx dP.x dx’ dP: J tV@, Px) W p ’ , P:) dx dPx dx/dP:
-
(7.17)
’
where a(x,px,x’,pc) is the Lagrange invariant. Combinations of moment matrices of even and odd order and the antisymmetric J matrix can be found that satisfy similarity transformations at propagation through first-order optical systems. All properties of the eigenvalues of these combinations are identical to the corresponding properties in the far-field diffraction regime, with S replaced by S. All combinations of WDF moments that have a physical meaning retain their significance if calculated in terms of FWDF, but in the near-field diffraction regime. 7.3. OPTICAL PRODUCTION OF FRACTIONAL WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
Several setups have been suggested to implement the fractional Fourier transform. Lohmann [ 19931 suggested two setups for the fractional Fourier transform generation that correspond to two different ways of synthesizing a WDF rotation with an angle a. These setups are shown in fig. 7, where the parameters R and Q determine the fractional order a, andfo is an arbitrary focal length. R = tan(a/2) and Q = sin a for the setup in fig. 7a, and R = sin a and Q = tan(a/2) for that in fig. 7b. Granieri, Trabocchi and Sicre [ 19951 proposed a free space Fresnel diffraction configuration equivalent to the setup in fig. 7a, and Lohmann [ 19951 described alternative realizations of the setups in figs. 7a,b with fake zoom lenses. The optical implementation of the FWDF can be realized by using any of the setups that generate the WDF, the input of which must be the output of a setup output
input plane
plane
f = f,/Q
input plane
output plane f
f = f,lQ
-~
d = Rf,
Fig. 7. Two setups for the generation of the fractional Fourier transform.
38
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
58
that generates the fractional Fourier transform. Of course, the result will be given in ( p , x ) coordinates instead of ( x , p ) ,and the Fourier transform part of the setup that generates the WDF must have inverted spatial coordinates.
6
8. Optical Beam Characterization in Nonlinear Optical Systems
The analysis of light propagation through nonlinear media is a subject of great practical importance due to the numerous applications of nonlinear media. Since the literature on this subject is vast, we will restrict discussion to publications that are closely connected with the WDF approach to light characterization in nonlinear optical systems. Martinez-Herrero and Mejias [ 199 11 made the first attempt to characterize the beam propagation through nonlinear media by using the WDF. They studied the propagation of a 1D stochastic field distribution through an active medium characterized by a small signal gain and a saturation intensity with an approximation procedure that restricts both the field diffraction along the amplifier and the variation of the medium parameters. Some general propagation characteristics but no clear solution for the WDF in the nonlinear medium were established. For example, it was demonstrated that the WDF does not propagate in active media along straight lines, contrary to what happens in passive media. The radiant intensity of the field varied at propagation, and the transformation laws of the first- and second-order moments were determined. X and px, as well as the beam quality parameter, varied with z, and it was demonstrated that even if 0 at z=O, these moments can take nonzero values at other z values. Carter [1995] also developed a detailed WDF treatment of quantum pulse propagation in nonlinear fibers. The WDF approach allowed the introduction of the excess thermal noise sources in the analysis. He pointed out that the conditions for the reliability of the WDF method are those for which the linearization of the Heisenberg equation is valid; that is, it involves an approximation formulation of the problem. Hirlimann and Morhange [1992] used the temporal WDF to describe the propagation of ultrashort light pulses under the separate effects of linear dispersion and self-phase modulation. Graphic representations of the WDF for propagation in the linear dispersion regime and the self-phase modulation nonlinear regime were derived, starting from the known solutions of the field distributions in these regimes. The time broadening induced by the linear dispersion of the refractive index and the frequency changes induced by selfphase modulation are accounted for in the WDF approach, and the numerical
X=z=
1,
5 81
OPTICAL BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN NONLINEAR OPTICAL SYSTEMS
39
results are in excellent agreement with those deduced from a classical Fourier analysis. Marcuvitz [1980] simulated the WDF of a Gaussian pulse propagating through a dispersive nonlinear medium. A WDF representation of self-phase modulation and soliton propagation in the time-frequency domain was given by Paye [ 19921. Dragoman [ 1996al formulated a complete treatment of 1D light propagation through an inhomogeneous Kerr medium. This treatment allows the calculation of the propagation law through a nonlinear medium of any quantity that can be expressed in terms of the WDF. We reproduce here the basic results obtained by Dragoman [1996a]. The propagation of a ID monochromatic, paraxial beam through an inhomogeneous Kerr-type medium is governed by the nonlinear Schrodinger (NLS) equa2 tion, which can be written as in eq. (3.16) with H ( x , id/dx, 1q(x)l ) = -yx2+ ad2/dx2 + @ I ~ P ( X > and ~ ~ real y , a, and p. The differential equation for the WDF is then
3 --2akp,-- aw9 + 2yxdW9 az
-
dx
k
dp,
Equation (8.1) is not easier to solve than the original differential equation for the field distribution. This is not necessary, however, if one is only interested in deriving propagation laws for WDF moments of arbitrary order or other quantities that can be expressed in terms of the WDF and are of practical importance. For example, by using eq. (8.1) it was demonstrated that the total beam energy E ( z ) = ( k / 2 n ) J W ( x ,p x ; z ) dx dp, was constant at propagation, and transformation laws were derived for the radiant intensity of the field distribution J ( p , ; z ) = W(x, p x ; z ) dx and for the radiant emittance R(x; 2 ) = j” W ( x ,P,; z ) dp,:
s
40
THE W C N E R DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I, 5 8
Similar to the results of Martinez-Herrero and Mejias [1991], the radiant intensity J depends on z because of both the nonlinearity and inhomogeneity of the medium. The nonlinearity also contributes to the variation of R at propagation. The first-order WDF moments satisfy a set of coupled differential equations
ax az
aE az
2yX -- -~
- = 2akpx,
k ’
whereas the second-order WDF moments evolve according to
where I=-k
2n
f
W x , pX;z> Wx, q; z ) b d p , d q -
f
W ( x ,px; Z>d.dPX
f
I c p k z)14
f
I c p k 412&’
(8.6)
If initially T(z=O)=O=px(z=O), then, according to eq. (8.4), X = p x = O at arbitrary z values. The opposite conclusion reported by Martinez-Herrero and Mejias [1991] is a result of a different calculation method and a different nonlinear medium. Transformation laws for second-order moments were also found in Porras, Alda and Bernabeu [ 19931 by an inspection of the differential equation for the field distribution (their results are equivalent to eq. 8.5), and in Pare and Belanger [1992]. A moment theory of the field propagation through a nonlinear medium was also derived by Suydam [1975]. Kamp [1987] found the transport equation for the WDF for field distributions that satisfy the NLS equation, as well as other nonlineartype equations such as the Korteweg-de Vries and Burgers equations. For these nonlinear equations an infinite hierarchy of balance equations was constructed by taking the local moments with respect to
1,
P 81
OPTICAL BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN NONLINEAR OPTICAL SYSTEMS
41
the angular variable of the WDF transport equation. The balance equations lead to an infinite class of conservation laws equation for the NLS. The beam quality factor and the kurtosis parameter of the field distribution satisfy the following propagation laws, respectively:
-__
--
x2 x3px - x4 xp, _ aK - 8ak
aZ
Equation (8.7) differs from the propagation law for the beam quality factor in Porras, Alda and Bernabeu [1993] because of the different number of transverse dimensions considered (one here, two in the reference just quoted). Park and BClanger [ 19921proposed various definitions of the beam quality factor, and discussed the influence of the number of transverse dimensions on the propagation law of second-order WDF moments. Dragoman [1996a] showed that if in the last term of eq. (8.1), the terms with n 3 1 can be neglected as, for example, for field distributions that vary slowly with x , the propagation law of the WDF simplifies to that through a first-order optical system (eq. 3.13), where for ID fields the matrix elements are A
=
D
=
cos(a(x)z),
B
with a(x) = J2a(2y+@
pa I qI2/ax)/(ka(x)).
=
K~(x)sin(a(x)z), C
=
K~(x)sin(a(x)z),
Iq12/ax), Kl(x) = -2aWu(x),
(8.9)
and K ~ ( x = ) (2y+
The matrix that characterizes the WDF propagation through an inhomogeneous Kerr-type medium depends on the field distribution and has unit determinant; that is, it is symplectic. Magni, Cerullo and De Silvestri [1993] also derived a unit determinant matrix that characterizes the propagation through Kerr media by studying the passage of a cylindrically symmetric Gaussian beam through such a medium. In their derivation the nonlinear term was approximated by a parabola, an approximation that can cause the discrepancies between the theory and experimental results of Nemoto [ 19951. The nonlinear propagation including soliton propagation can also be treated by complex ray tracing (Nasalski [ 19951). This method describes the nonlinear propagation by a scale transformation applied to the linear propagation such that in the scaled space the complex ray follows a straight trajectory as a usual ray in a linear medium. The transformation of an incident Gaussian beam through such
42
THE WlGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
5
8
a scaled space leads to the determination of a matrix for each of the thin sections of the nonlinear medium, with elements that depend on the beam parameter in the considered sections. Although not directly related to the WDF treatment, two interesting recent papers provide a PS description of nonlinear directional couplers. Snyder, Mitchell, Poladian, Rowland and Chen [1991] and Artigas and Dios [1994] studied the behavior of the nonlinear directional couplers in terms of the initial power by plotting the trajectories of motion in the PS for an initial excitation point and different powers.
8.1. SOLITON SOLUTION OF THE NLS EQUATION
Both the evolution of the WDF (and implicitly that of the field distribution through a nonlinear medium) and also the stationary solution of the NLS equation can be described by the formalism presented in the last section. The NLS equation satisfied by the complex amplitude q(z,t) of an optical signal that propagates along the z direction in a frame of reference that moves with the group velocity ug can be written as
.aq
p2 a2q
1----+yJql
az
2
at2
2
q=O.
(8.10)
In eq. (8.10), z=t-z/ug is the time coordinate in the reference frame, p2 is the dispersion parameter, and y is the nonlinear coefficient. Equation (8.10) is an evolution equation of the field distribution that can be put in the form of eq. (3.16) in the temporal PS, for which H ( z , idldt, Iq(t)12)=(P2/2)d2/dt2y l q ( t ) 1 2 . The soliton solution of eq. (8.10) is shape invariant with respect to z; that is, it has the form q(z, z ) = u ( t ) exp(iu(z, t)), where u and u are the amplitude and phase of the envelope, respectively (Du, Chan and Chui [ 19951). If sgn(B2).sgn(y) < 1, the bright soliton solution of the NLS equation is obtained: q(z, t)= A d m s e c h ( A t ) exp(-iA2zB2/2>,
(8.1 1)
where A is an arbitrary constant. It can be shown that if du/dt = 0 as in our case, WP(t,w)= WU(t,w). Moreover, if du/dz=P=const., aWqlaz=-2(ImP)W,; that is, the WDF is constant with respect to the z variable in a lossless or gainless medium.
4
§ 81
OPTICAL BEAM CHARACTERIZATION IN NONLINEAR OPTICAL SYSTEMS
43
$1r, 1
w
-1
4
-2
-1
0
1
2
T Fig. 8. The normalized Wigner distribution function (WDF) of the bright soliton (left) and its PSA (right).
The temporal WDF of the bright soliton has an analytic form (Konno and Lomdahl [ 19941): Wp(z, W)
II
= 4nA -
sin(2 zw) . sinh(2Az) sinh(nw/A)'
(8.12)
The normalized WDF of the bright soliton W ( T ,w)= W,(T, w)/W,(O, 0 ) and its PSA is represented in fig. 8 in the normalized coordinates T=Az, w=w/A. The PSA has a diamond shape, and it can be used for the determination of the ratio between the 0 2 and y . The maximum T and w values of the PSA are found by numerically solving the equations 2T = exp(-2) sinh(2T) and wn= exp(-2) sinh(wz), respectively. The result is T, = 4.1/24 and w, = 4.1AIn . From either of these two values one can determine the constant A , and then from W,(O, 0) = 4A IPz/yl the ratio between the dispersion parameter and the nonlinear coefficient is determined. T,, wmaX= 2.67 = const., independent of A, which is a characteristic of the WDF of a bright soliton. Moreover, for a pulse with a known peak input power POand halfwidth TO the determined ratio of the dispersion and nonlinear coefficients serves as a test for identifying it with a pure soliton. [ 02/y( = LNLPoTilLD, where LD= T2,/(02[ is the dispersion length and LNL= 1/( [ yIP0) is the nonlinear length. For a pure bright soliton, LNL/LDmust be equal to 1. At propagation through a gainless or lossless medium, all WDF moments as well as the total soliton energy E=2A[Pzlyl are constant. In the frame of reference that moves with the group velocity T=w=O, G = O , p=n2/12,
44
THE WlGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
89
-
w2 = 1/3, Q=n2/36. The bright soliton is a self-Fourier function (Dragoman [ 1996e1) for which the higher-order moments are related by
(8.13)
All these results are valid if the soliton field is the stationary solution of the NLS equation. If at the input of the medium a soliton is launched that is not the stationary solution of the NLS equation, its WDF evolves according to eq. (8.9). Since dl p7I2/dt has different signs for t < 0 and t > 0, it follows that the leading and trailing edge of the pulse propagate in a different manner. In this case eq. (8.9) describes the evolution of the WDF of the total field, that is, of the part of the pulse that evolves to the stationary solution of the NLS equation in the medium and of the radiated part. A WDF representation of the two-soliton solution of the NLS equation as well as of solitons in open systems was derived by Konno and Lomdahl [1994].
0
9. Complex Field Reconstruction
from the Wigner Distribution Function Equation (3.6a) for r l = r , r2 = O is the basis of time harmonic field reconstruction from the WDF. For ultrashort light pulses the field distribution q(t) can be reconstructed from the temporal WDF W(t,w)by a formula similar to eq. (3.6a), with r replaced by t and kp replaced by w. In a similar manner the field distribution can be reconstructed from the spatiotemporal PS. This chapter examines the field reconstruction problem of ultrashort light pulses from their WDF. To determine the field distribution, one must determine both amplitude and phase of the light pulse. Of several methods that have been proposed, one of the most common is the measurement of the intensity autocorrelation obtained by second harmonic generation in a nonlinear crystal. It can provide some information about the pulse amplitude only for intensities symmetric with time, but yields no information about the phase. Similarly, the measurement of the spectrum can provide information about the amplitude of the pulse in the frequency domain, but for the phase measurement separate methods must be used, such as interferometric measurements and iterative phase-retrieval
I,
5 91
COMPLEX FIELD RECONSTRUCTION FROM THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
45
procedures. Other methods for phase measurements are mentioned in Paye [1994]. An interesting method of amplitude and phase determination from the measurement of only one quantity - the spectrally resolved autocorrelation of the pulse - is described by Paye, Ramaswamy, Fujimoto and Ippen [1993]. The spectrally resolved autocorrelation is the spectrum of the second harmonic pulse obtained by nonlinear mixing in a noncollinear geometry of the pulse to be measured and a delayed replica of itself. The amplitude and phase of the pulse are determined from the measured data by an iterative algorithm. Although the temporal WDF was recognized long ago as a time frequency distribution that provides the same information about light pulses as the field distribution. the first attempt using the WDF to derive the amplitude and phase of a pulse appeared recently (Beck, Raymer, Walmsley and Wong [ 19931). This approach does not involve nonlinear correlation processes and can therefore also be applied to pulses with low peak intensities. The method, called chronocyclic tomography, consists of the temporal WDF recovering from its rotated projections that can be measured by a setup formed from a temporal free space and a temporal lens. The complex field distribution (or the correlation function for stochastic fields) are then obtained from the WDF inversion formula. The temporal free space and temporal lens are devices that act in the temporal PS in the same way on a field distribution as the free space and lens in the spatial PS. The analogy between fields modulated in time (pulses) and space (finite spatial beams) was first pointed out by Akhmanov, Chirkin, Drabovich, Kovrigin, Khokhlov and Sukhorukov [ 19681, whereas the analogy between the spatial problem of Fresnel diffraction and the temporal problem of first-order dispersion was first realized by Treacy [ 19691. The duality between the problems of paraxial diffraction and narrow-band dispersion originates in two different approximations to the wave equation. The paraxial diffraction assumes a monochromatic wave, and allows the propagation to take place mostly in one direction (z) such that the total 1D electric field takes the form E(x,z, t)=E(x,z) exp[i(wot-k(wo)z)], where E(x,z) is a slowly varying envelope function. The narrow-band dispersion assumes a plane wave spatial profile of the field distribution, and limits the frequency spectrum of the pulse to a suitable range such that the propagation of any spectral component can be accounted for by a Taylor series expansion of the propagation constant p(w) to second order in w. The total electric field can be represented in this approximation as E(x,z, t ) =A(z, t ) exp[i(wot-B(wo)z)] with A(z, t ) a slowly varying envelope function. The analog equations and quantities in the space and
46
THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I,
8
9
Table 1 Space-time analogies in optics a Space domain
Time domain
Governing partial differential equation
d E / d z = (i/2k)d2E/dx2
dA/dE = (i/32/2)d2A/at2
Propagation variable
Z
E=z-zo
Profile variable
X
t = r - t o -(z -zo)/ug
Propagation constant
k0
WO
Frequency
spatial: k,
temporal: w - 00
Transmission function
Fresnel propagation
first-order dispersion
exp(-izkzl(2ko)) lens:
time lens:
exp(-ikox2/(2f)) Imaging law
Ildl +I/d2=lIf
Here zo and r o are arbitrary references, length of the dispersive element.
a
exp(i(w - ~ 0 ) ~ / 3 2 1 / 2 )
82 = d2/3/do2 is the
exp(-iwor2/(2fT)) 1/@2l[l)+ 1/@2212)=WO/fT dispersion coefficient, and I is the
time domain are presented in Table 1 (Kolner [1994a], Godil, Auld and Bloom [ 19941). The temporal analog of the free space can be realized with either a dispersive fiber or a pair of diffraction gratings. In the first case the length d of the free space is equivalent to -021, where 1 is the fiber length, whereas in the second case d is equivalent to 1/p - the group delay dispersion of the grating pair. Since for a fiber 02 can be either positive or negative, it is possible to implement temporal analogs to positive or negative lengths of free space. Moreover, with a birefringent fiber that has the linear eigenpolarization vectors parallel to the orthogonal x and y axes, it is possible to implement anisotropic 2D free spaces (Dragoman and Dragoman [ 19961). The ID time lens introduced by Kolner and Nazarathy [1989] can be implemented by applying a voltage waveform quadratic in time to an electrooptic modulator. The phase acquired by a field that passes through the modulator is qj(t)=Acos(w,t), with w, as the modulation frequency and A as a function of the electric field, the electrooptic coefficient of the crystal and of the relative orientations of the incident field, optical axis of the crystal and of the applied field. In the quadratic approximation around t = 0, qj(t)=A( 1 - okt2/2), from which the focal length f~ is determined as f ~w ~=/ ( A w k(Table ) 1). A general 2D time lens with different focal lengths along the x and y directions can be implemented in
I,
5 91
COMPLEX FIELD RECONSTRUCTION FROM THE WICNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
47
the same manner, but with an incident linear polarized field with components along both x and y directions. The 2D time lens can be spherical, cylindrical, or a quadrupole according to the symmetry of the electrooptic crystal and its excitation (Dragoman and Dragoman [ 19961). A detailed discussion of 1D time lens implementation and characterization can be found in Kolner [1994b] and Godil, Auld and Bloom [1994], and examples of time lenses’ applications are described in Kauffman, Godil, Auld, Banyai and Bloom [1993], Godil, Auld and Bloom [ 19931 and Kauffman, Banyai, Godil and Bloom [ 19941. Implementation of other ID optical temporal processors are discussed in Yang [1995], and the temporal PS characterization of a general birefringent optical fiber is derived from Dragoman and Dragoman [1996]. The setup of Beck, Raymer, Walmsley and Wong [1993] consists of a dispersive element characterized by the dispersion 1Ip = - d2@/dw2, calculated at the central frequency 00 followed by a time lens with a focal distancefT such that d2@ldt2= - w o / f ~ ,where @ is the phase through the respective elements. The action of this setup on the input field spectrum q ( w ) is described by an integral transform similar to the fractional Fourier transform of order 6,:
(e)
qout (we) = J
F e x p 2 n w sin 8 2sin 6 x exp (-i (we- w‘ - -cot 0’2 sin 13 2
/
= P(00)/
q
e
x
p
6,))
(w’) dw’
(9.1)
(2)
with
Now, IP(w0)12=
wq(te cos 8 + we sine, -to sin
e + we cos 0) dte,
(9.3)
where Wp(t, w ) is the temporal WDF and 0 0 =
wcose
+ t sin 8,
tt,
=
-wsin 8
+ t cos 8.
Equation (9.3) resembles eq. (7.9) and can be inverted to obtain Wp(t,w) by the use of the inverse Radon transform (Hermann [1980], Lohmann and Soffer
48
THE WlGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTlCS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
input
[I, 6 9
Quadratic phase modulator Birefringent and dispersive fiber
Dispersive fiber
4
fT
dT,,
Fig 9 Setup for the generation of a temporal phase space (PS) representation of a field distnbution
[ 19941). The procedure is as follows: (1) measure Ii&ut(w~)12for different values of the rotation angle 8, that is, for different values of l/p + 00/fT; (2) rescale the measurement to obtain IP(o0)l2;(3) perform the inverse Radon transform to obtain Wq(t, 0 ) ;and (4) obtain the field distribution cp(t), up to an unimportant phase constant $0, from
exp(i$o) u?(t>=
~
fi
Wq(t/2, w ) exp(-itw) dw
Jm
(9.4)
Equation (9.4) follows from the temporal form of eqs. (3.4) and (3.6a). For the stochastic field by Fourier inverting the WDF definition, one obtains the correlation function. The method proposed by Beck, Raymer, Walmsley and Wong [I9931 determines the WDF indirectly, by measuring its rotated projections. A direct method of WDF measurement by Dragoman and Dragoman [ 19961 consists of the transposition in the temporal domain of the setup in fig. 1. The result is the setup in fig. 9. As discussed before, the free space of length dl is replaced by a dispersive fiber of temporal length d T = - b 2 1 1 , , and the spherical lens of focal length f 0 is replaced by a quadratic phase modulator of focal length f T . Since the spatial rotation has no exact analog in the time domain, the remaining part of the device, (i.e., the free space of length fo, the rotated quadrupole, and the free space of length d 2 ) was replaced by a single birefringent dispersive fiber characterized by a set of parameters d,,, where i,j =x,y , depending on the cross polarization dispersion coefficients of the fiber 0 2 , and the fiber length 1 2 . To perform a temporal PS representation of the incident field distribution along the x axis, the parameters of the setup must be chosen such that d T + d T x x - d T d T x x 1f T = 0 and d T y x =fT. The first condition determines the length of the first fiber 11 that must be chosen such that dT= - 8 2 1 11 = d T x x f T /(dTxx -fT). The second condition can be used to determine the length of the birefringent fiber 1 2 , if f T is fixed, or the peak value of the applied electric field that determines the value of f T , if 12 is given. i the With these conditions a temporal PS map: txo= -dTxxt,i / d T , tyo= d ~ y ~ O , of
1, § 101
WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN QUANTUM OPTICS
49
incident field distribution is obtained at the output plane, where tx and ty are the times associated with the x and y components of the polarized field and 0, and uy their corresponding frequencies measured from W O . For ultrashort optical pulses the time length of the output pulse can be increased by appropriately choosing d T x x and f T . If d T x x = NfT with N > 2, the length of the pulse at the output plane is increased by ( N - 1). This setup can be used for the amplitude and phase reconstruction of the incident field in the same manner as the previous device.
0
10. Wigner Distribution Function in Quantum Optics
Wigner [ 19321 introduced the WDF to calculate the quantum corrections for thermal equilibrium that become important at low temperatures. The idea was to extend the PS treatment of thermodynamics from the temperature region, where the classic mechanics is valid and where all the calculations are based on the classical PS density, to lower temperature regions not too far away from the validity of classical physics. A new quasiprobability function of the position and momentum variables, the WDF, (10.1)
was introduced in terms of the density matrix 6 that represents the state of a spinless system. Soon it became evident that the WDF was the basis of a quantum-mechanical formulation alternative to the Heisenberg or Schrodinger representations. In the PS formulation of quantum mechanics both the position and momentum variables are c-numbers, so that the quantum theory can be treated in a manner similar to classical statistical mechanics. The main aspects of this formulation are (Ruggeri [1971]): (a) The states of the system are described by means of a distribution function F(r,p;t), defined on the classical PS, that depends parametrically on time. This distribution function should be as close as possible to a true probability distribution. (b) A c-number function A(r,p) defined on the PS is associated with a quantum operator such that the quantum expectation value can be calculated classically by means of a PS integration rather than through the operator formalism:
A^
A (->
=
J
A(r, p ) F(r, p ; t) d r dp.
(10.2)
A large number of papers (e.g. Aganval and Wolf [ 1970a-c], Cahil and Glauber [1969a,b], Srinivas and Wolf [1975], Cohen [1966, 19761, Ruggeri [1971])
50
THE WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I, 9: 10
discuss in detail the problem of associating a c-number function with a quantum operator in such a way that eq. (10.2) holds (and, implicitly, the problem of defining the corresponding PS distribution function). As in classical theory, a class of PS distribution functions correctly satisfies the marginals, the members of which are derived by applying different ordering rules between the quantum mechanical operators and the associated classical quantities. In particular in quantum optics, three such PS distributions are known: the WDF, the P function and the Q function. For each, eq. (10.2) holds if the following ordering rule is obeyed: normal ordering for the P function, antinormal ordering for the Q function, and symmetric (or Weyl) ordering for the Wigner function. Among the PS distribution functions, a class of non-negative distributions is associated with the antinormal ordering, which also includes the Q function. However, Wigner [ 197I] demonstrated that no non-negative distribution function exists that is a joint probability distribution for the noncommuting operators F and p^. This theorem can also be stated in the form: the quantum mechanics cannot be formulated as a classical stochastic theory, which would require that at least a distribution function exists such that if A(r,p) is the PS function used to calculate the expectation value of the operator A^(F, ?), then K ( A ( r , p ) )will give the expectation value of K(A^(P,p^)) for any arbitrary function K (Cohen [ 19661). The WDF is a joint probability distribution for i and p^, so that it must take negative values in some PS regions. Narcowich and O’Connell [1986] showed that the necessary and sufficient condition for a quantum PS function F to be a WDF is to be of h positive type; that is, for arbitrary al to a, the m x m matrix with elements exp(iha(ak, a,)/2)F(a, - a k ) is non-negative, where F ( a ) = F ( x ) exp(ia(a, x)) dx is the symplectic Fourier transform of F with o(al,a2) - the Lagrange invariant defined on two PS points a1 and a2. The properties of the quantum WDF generally parallel those in the classic theory; see, for example, Wigner [1932], Aganval [I9871 and Leonhardt and Paul [1995]. The WDF has been used in quantum optics to study the coherence properties of light (Glauber [1963], Mehta and Wolf [1964], Lax and Louise11 [1967], Bialynicki-Birula and Bialynicki-Birula [ 1973]), to describe quantum noise in interferometers (Aganval [ 1987]), to study the propagation through a parametric amplifier (Mollow and Glauber [ 19671) or in connection with the quantum theory of radiative transfer (Sudarshan [1981]). Moreover, the WDF is the simplest scientific language for the study of coherent and squeezed states (see Kim and Noz [1991], ch. 6). Finally, the measurement of the WDF of a quantum system allows the determination of the complex Schrodinger wave function (or the density matrix) that carries the maximum information about the quantum system. For an excellent review about this subject see Leonhardt and Paul [1995].
WIGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN QUANTUM OPTICS
51
vacuum
sig
reference beam Fig. 10. Homodyne detection scheme for quantum Wigner distribution function (WDF) measurement. The dashed beam splitter is fictitious; it models the imperfect photon counting.
All these applications require the knowledge of the WDF of a quantum system. Some information about the WDF (about the quantum state) can be inferred from the process of preparing the quantum system, but a measurement method of the WDF is desirable for the characterization of unknown quantum systems. Since the position and momentum operators do not commute, the Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle forbids the simultaneous measurement of the position and momentum and therefore it seems that it is not possible to measure the quantum WDF. Recently, however, both theoretically (Vogel and Risken [ 19891) and experimentally (Beck, Smithey and Raymer [ 19931, Beck, Smithey, Cooper and Raymer [ 19931, Smithey, Beck, Cooper and Raymer [ 1993a,b], Smithey, Beck, Raymer and Faridani [1993]) it was shown that the WDF can be reconstructed from a set of distribution functions wg(rg) by a technique known as optical homodyne tomography: wg(rg) =
J ~ ( r cos g s -Po sin S, r g sin s +Po cos S) dpe.
(10.3)
Note the similarity between eqs. (9.3) and (10.3). The distribution function W g ( r 0 ) is measured with a balanced homodyne detector (fig. 10) that consists of a 5050 beam splitter, two ideal photodetectors, and a reference beam with a well-defined phase 8 with respect to the signal. If the reference beam is coherent and intense with respect to the signal, the difference between the measured photocurrents is proportional to the expectation value wg(r0) of
52
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
[I, (i 10
i cos 0 + 5 sin 0, with i a n d a the incident operators. Thus by changing the phase between the reference beam and the signal, different combinations of the position and momentum variables can be measured. The WDF is then determined from the (eventually discrete) set of data by using the inversion formula:
Fo
=
(10.4) Leonhardt [I 9953 proposed a tomographic scheme to infer the quantum states of finite dimensional systems for which he developed a discrete WDF formalism. The influence of the imperfect photon counting is taken into account by inserting a fictitious beam splitter (dashed line in fig. 10) in front of the ideal homodyne detection. The transmissivity t of the fictitious beam splitter is given by the efficiency r] of the photodetector: t = q 2 . In this case the ID measured distribution is a smoothed version of the ideal one obtained from the latter by an averaging procedure with a real Gaussian function. To improve the accuracy of the homodyne detection, an amplifier (“anti-squeezer”) is placed in front of the whole setup. If the gain of the amplifier G is large, the measured distribution becomes a scaled version of the ideal distribution: W ~ ( X O= )(r]G)-’/2wt((~ G ) - ’ / ~ x o thus ) , allowing perfect measurement of distributions with imperfect detectors. The optical homodyne tomography is a complicated procedure to determine the WDF. Useful information about the WDF can be gained by means of simpler techniques that do not require a reference signal. Leonhardt and Paul [1994a] proposed the measurement of the square of the WDF by optically mixing the wave function and a phase conjugate replica of it in a beam splitter. A similar measurement can be performed using a parametric amplifier. For an important class of quantum states, the squeezed states, even the WDF itself can be measured directly, because in this case the WDF is a product of r and p distributions that can be measured separately, each on one half of the statistical ensemble. Information about the WDF can also be gained from measurements of the Q function. The Q function is non-negative and can be interpreted as a smoothed WDF. This smoothing process, which causes negative values of the WDF to disappear, also leads to a loss of information where the finer details of the WDF are wiped out. The Q function, which is related to the WDF by Q(r, p) =
1
W(r’, p’)exp
(- [(r
-
r’)” + (p
-’.,I
) dr’ dp’,
(10.4)
I1
REFERENCES
53
is a member of the so-called non-negative Wigner-type distributions (Cartwright [1976], Mourgues, Feix, Andrieux and Bertrand [1985]), and can be measured, for example, in an eight-port homodyne detector scheme, with a parametric amplifier or with a heterodyning scheme. For a discussion of measurement techniques for the Q function, see Leonhardt and Paul [1994b, 19951, and the references therein, Leonhardt, Bohmer and Paul [ 19951.
5
11. Conclusions
The applications of the WDF presented in this review, together with other applications mentioned in the introduction, support the assertion that the WDF is a valuable theoretical and experimental tool in optics and optoelectronics. New applications will certainly be proposed in the future. Further expansion of WDF applications will probably result from the recent extension of the WDF definition as a quantum quasiprobability distribution of number and phase (Vaccaro [1995]) and as a wide-band distribution hnction in signal processing (Shenoy and Parks [ 19951).
References Abe, S., and J.T. Sheridan, 1994a, J. Phys. A 27, 4179. Abe, S., and J.T. Sheridan, 1994b, Opt. Lett. 19, 1801. Abe, S., and J.T. Sheridan, 1995, Opt. Commun. 113, 385. Agarwal, G.S., 1987, J. Mod. Opt. 34, 909. Agarwal, G.S., and E. Wolf, 1970a, Phys. Rev. D 2, 2161. Aganval, G.S., and E. Wolf, 1970b, Phys. Rev. D 2, 2182. Aganval, G.S., and E. Wolf, 1970c, Phys. Rev. D 2, 2206. Akhmanov, S.A., A.S. Chirkin, K.N. Drabovich, A.I. Kovrigin, K.V. Khokhlov and A.P. Sukhorukov, 1968, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 4, 598. Anan’ev, Yu.A., and A.Ya. Bekshaev, 1994, Opt. Spectrosc. 76, 558. Artigas, D., and E Dios, 1994, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 30, 1587. Bamler, R., and H. Glunder, 1983, Opt. Acta 30, 1789. Barnett, S., 1990, Matrices: Methods and Applications (Clarendon Press, Oxford). Bartelt, H.O., K.H. Brenner and A.W. Lohmann, 1980, Opt. Commun. 32, 32. Bastiaans, M.J., 1979a, Opt. Commun. 30, 321. Bastiaans, M.J., 1979b, Opt. Acta 26, 1265. Bastiaans, M.J., 1979c, Opt. Acta 26, 1333. Bastiaans, M.J., 1986, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 3, 1227. Bastiaans, M.J., 1989, Optik 82, 173. Bastiaans, M.J., 1991, Optik 88, 163. Beck, M., M.G. Raymer, I.A. Walmsley and V Wong, 1993, Opt. Lett. 18, 2041. Beck, M., D.T. Smithey, J. Cooper and M.G. Raymer, 1993, Opt. Lett. 18, 1259.
54
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
Beck, M., D.T. Smithey and M.G. Raymer, 1993, Phys. Rev. A 48, R890. Berriel-Valdos, L.R., C. Gonzalo and J. Bescos, 1988, Opt. Commun. 68, 339. Bialynicki-Birula, I., and Z. Bialynicki-Birula, 1973, Phys. Rev. A 8, 3146. Born, M., and E. Wolf, 1964, Principles of Optics, 2nd Ed. (Pergamon Press, New York). Brenner, K.H., and A.W. Lohmann, 1982, Opt. Commun. 42, 310. Bugnolo, D.S., and H. Bremmer, 1983, Adv. Electr. Electron Phys. 61, 299. Cahil, K.E., and R.J. Glauber, 1969a, Phys. Rev. 177, 1857. Cahil, K.E., and R.J. Glauber, 1969b, Phys. Rev. 177, 1882. Carter, S.J., 1995, Phys. Rev. A 51, 3274. Cartwright, N.D., 1976, Physica A 83, 210. Claasen, T.A.C.M., and W.F.G. Meklenbrauker, 1980a, Philips J. Res. 35, 217. Claasen, T.A.C.M., and W.F.G. Meklenbrauker, 1980b, Philips J. Res. 35, 276. Claasen, T.A.C.M., and W.F.G. Meklenbrauker, 1980c, Philips J. Res. 35, 372. Cohen, L., 1966, J. Math. Phys. 7, 781. Cohen, L., 1976, J. Math. Phys. 17, 1863. Cohen, L., 1989, Proc. IEEE 77, 941. Comer, M., and Y. Li, 1985, Appl. Opt. 24, 3825. De Groot, S.R., and L.G. Suttorp, 1972, Foundations of Electrodynamics (North-Holland, Amsterdam) ch. 6 . Dragoman, D., 1994, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 11, 2643. Dragoman, D., 1995a, Optik 100, 137. Dragoman, D., 399513, Appl. Opt. 34, 3352. Dragoman, D., 1995c, Appl. Opt. 34, 6758. Dragoman, D., 1995d, J. Mod. Opt. 42, 1815. Dragoman, D., 1996a, Appl. Opt. 35, 4142. Dragoman, D., 1996b, J. Mod. Opt. 43, 1127. Dragoman, D., 1996c, Appl. Opt. 35, 161. Dragoman, D., 1996d, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 13, 474. Dragoman, D., 1996e, J. Mod. Opt. 43, 1933. Dragoman, D., and M. Dragoman, 1996, Appl. Opt. 35, 7025. Du, M., A.K. Chan and C.K. Chui, 1995, lEEE J. Quantum Electron. 31, 177. Easton, R.L., A.J. Ticknor and H.H. Barrett, 1984, Opt. Eng. 23, 738. Eichmann, G., and B.Z. Dong, 1982, Appl. Opt. 21, 3152. Gase, R., 1990, Opt. Commun. 79, 397. Gase, R., 1992, Opt. Quantum Electron. 24, 1109. Glauber, R.J., 1963, Phys. Rev. 130, 2529. Godil, A.A., B.A. Auld and D.M. Bloom, 1993, Appl. Phys. Lett. 62, 1047. Godil, A.A., B.A. Auld and D.M. Bloom, 1994, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 30, 827. Goethals, A,, 1989, in: Physics and Technology of Laser Resonators, eds D.R. Hall and P.E. Jackson (Hilger, Bristol) pp. 143-153. Gori, F., M. Santarsiero and V Bagini, 1994, Atti Fond. Giorgio Ronchi 49, 387. Granieri, S., 0. Trabocchi and E.E. Sicre, 1995, Opt. Commun. 119, 275. Guillemin, V, and S. Sternberg, 1984, Symplectic Techniques in Physics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Hermann, G.T., 1980, Image Reconstruction from Projections: The Fundamentals of Computerized Tomography (Academic Press, New York) chs. 6-8. Hirlimann, C., and J.F. Morhange, 1992, Appl. Opt. 31, 3263. Hodgson, N., T. Haase, R. Kostka and H. Weber, 1992, Opt. Quantum Electron. 24, 927. Iwai, T., A.K. Gupta and T. Asakura, 1986, Opt. Commun. 58, 15.
I1
REFERENCES
55
Kamp, L.P.J., 1987, J. Phys. A 20, 3279. Kaufhan, M.T., W.C. Banyai, A.A. Godil and D.M. Bloom, 1994, Appl. Phys. Lett. 64, 270. Kauffman, M.T., A.A. Godil, B.A. Auld, W.C. Banyai and D.M. Bloom, 1993, Electron. Lett. 29, 268. Kim, Y.S., and M.E. Noz, 1991, Phase Space Picture of Quantum Mechanics (World Scientific, Singapore). Kolner, B.H., 1994a, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 30, 1951. Kolner, B.H., 1994b, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 11, 3229. Kolner, B.H., and M. Nazarathy, 1989, Opt. Lett. 14, 630. Konno, H., and P.S. Lomdahl, 1994, J. Phys. SOC.Jpn. 63, 3967. Kostenbauder, A.G., 1990, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 26, 1148. Lancis, J., E.E. Sicre and A. Pons, 1995, J. Mod. Opt. 42, 425. Lavi, S., R. Prochaska and E. Keren, 1988, Appl. Opt. 27, 3696. Lax, M., and W.H. Louisell, 1967, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 3, 47. Leonhardt, U., 1995, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 4101. Leonhardt, U., B. Bohmer and H. Paul, 1995, Opt. Commun. 119, 296. Leonhardt, U., and H. Paul, 1994a, Phys. Lett. A 193, 117. Leonhardt, U., and H. Paul, 1994b, J. Mod. Opt. 41, 1427. Leonhardt, U., and H. Paul, 1995, Prog. Quantum Electron. 19, 89. Lichtenberg, A.J., 1969, Phase Space Dynamics of Particles (John Wiley and Sons, New York) ch. 3. Lin, Q., S. Wang, J. Alda and E. Bernabeu, 1993, Opt. Lett. 18, 669. Lohmann, A.W., 1993, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 10, 2181. Lohmann, A.W., 1995, Opt. Commun. 115, 437. Lohmann, A.W., J. Ojeda-Castaneda and N. Streibl, 1983, Opt. Appl. 13, 465. Lohmann, A.W., and B.H. Soffer, 1994, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 11, 1798. Luneburg, R.K., 1966, Mathematical Theory of Optics (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA). Magni, V;, G. Cerullo and S. De Silvestri, 1993, Opt. Commun. 96, 348. Marcuvitz, N., 1980, Proc. IEEE 68, 1380. Martinez-Herren, R., and P.M. Mejias, 1991, Opt. Commun. 85, 162. Martinez-Herrero, R., P.M. Mejias, M. Sanchez and J.L.H. Neira, 1992, Opt. Quantum Electron. 24, 1021. Martinez-Herrero, R., G. Piquero and PM. Mejias, 1995, Opt. Commun. 115, 225. McBride, A.C., and F.H. Kerr, 1987, IMA J. Appl. Math. 39, 159. Mehta, C.L., and E. Wolf, 1964, Phys. Rev. 134, A1149. Mendlovic, D., H.M. Ozaktas and A.W. Lohmann, 1994, Appl. Opt. 33, 6188. Mendlovic, D., H.M. Ozaktas and A.W. Lohmann, 1995, Appl. Opt. 34, 303. Mollow, B.R., and R.J. Glauber, 1967, Phys. Rev. 160, 1097. Mourgues, C., M.R. Feix, J.C. Andrieux and F! Bertrand, 1985, J. Math. Phys. 26, 2554. Namias, V;, 1980, J. Inst. Maths. Its Appl. 25, 24E. Narcowich, F.J., and R.E. O’Connell, 1986, Phys. Rev. A 34, 1. Nasalski, W., 1995, Opt. Commun. 119, 218. Nemes, G., and A.E. Siegman, 1994, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 11, 2257. Nemoto, S., 1995, Appl. Opt. 34, 6123. Onciul, D., 1993a, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 10, 295. Onciul, D., 1993b, Optik 93, 23. Onciul, D., 1993c, in: Proc. Workshop on Laser Beam Characterization, eds P.M. Mejias, H. Weber, R. Martinez-Herrero and A. Gonzalez-Urena (SEDO, Madrid) pp. 4 0 5 4 1 5.
56
THE WGNER DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION IN OPTICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS
Onciul, D., 1994a, Optik 96, 20. Onciul, D., 1994b, Optik 97, 75. Ozaktas, H.M., B. Barshan, D. Mendlovic and L. Onural, 1994, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 11, 517. Ozaktas, H.M., and D. Mendlovic, 1993a, Opt. Commun. 101, 163. Ozaktas, H.M., and D. Mendlovic, 1993b, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 10, 2522. Ozaktas, H.M., and D. Mendlovic, 1994, Opt. Lett. 19, 1678. Ozaktas, H.M., and D. Mendlovic, 1995, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 12, 743. Papoulis, A., 1968, Systems and Transforms with Applications in Optics (McGraw-Hill, New York). Pare, C., and P.-A. Betanger, 1992, Opt. Quantum Electron. 24, 1051. Paye, J., 1992, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 28, 2262. Paye, J., 1994, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 30, 2693. Paye, J., and A. Migus, 1995, J. Opt. SOC.Am. B 12, 1480. Paye, J., M. Ramaswamy, J.G. Fujimoto and E.P. Ippen, 1993, Opt. Lett. 18, 1946. Piquero, G., P.M. Mejias and R. Martinez-Herrero, 1994, Opt. Commun. 107, 179. Porras, M.A., J. Alda and E. Bemabeu, 1993, Appl. Opt. 32, 5885. Ruggeri, G.J., 1971, Prog. Theor. Phys. 46, 1703. Sasnett, M.W., 1989, in: Physics and Technology of Laser Resonators, eds D.R. Hall and P.E. Jackson (Hilger, Bristol) pp. 132-142. Sema, J., R. Martinez-Herrero and P.M. Mejias, 1991, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 8, 1094. Serna, J., P.M. Mejias and R. Martinez-Herrero, 1992, Opt. Quantum Electron. 24, 873. Shenoy, R.G., and T.W. Parks, 1995, Signal Processing 41, 339. Siegman, A.E., 1986, Lasers (Univ. Science, Mill Valley, CA). Siegman, A.E., 1993a, in: Proc. Workshop on Laser Beam Characterization, eds P.M. Mejias, H. Weber, R. Martinez-Herrero and A. Gonzalez-Urena (SEDO, Madrid) pp, 1-21. Siegman, A.E., 1993b, Appl. Opt. 32, 5893. Simon, R., E.C.G. Sudarshan and N. Mukunda, 1985, Phys. Rev. A 31, 2419. Smithey, D.T., M. Beck, J. Cooper and M.G. Raymer, 1993a, Phys. Scr. T 48, 35. Smithey, D.T., M. Beck, J. Cooper and M.G. Raymer, 1993b, Phys. Rev. A 48, 3159. Smithey, D.T., M. Beck, M.G. Raymer and A. Faridani, 1993, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 1244. Snyder, A.W., D.J. Mitchell, L. Poladian, D.R. Rowland and Y. Chen, 1991, J. Opt. SOC.Am. B 8, 2102. Srinivas, M.D., and E. Wolf, 1975, Phys. Rev. D 11, 1477. Sudarshan, E.C.G., 1981, Phys. Rev. A 23, 2802. Sudarshan, E.C.G., N. Mukunda and R. Simon, 1985, Opt. Acta 32, 855. Suydam, B.R., 1975, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 11, 225. Teague, M.R., 1980a, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 70, 920. Teague, M.R., 1980b, Appl. Opt. 19, 1353. Treacy, E.B., 1969, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 5, 454. Vaccaro, J.A., 1995, Opt. Commun. 113, 42E. Vogel, K., and H. Risken, 1989, Phys. Rev. A 40, 2847. Walther, A,, 1968, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 58, 1256. Weber, H., 1992, J. Mod. Opt. 39, 543. Wigner, E., 1932, Phys. Rev. 40, 749. Wigner, E.P., 1971, in: Perspectives in Quantum Theory, eds W. Yourgrau and A. VanderMenve (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp. 25-36. Wolf, E., 1982, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 72, 343. Yang, X., 1995, Opt. Commun. 116, 193. Yura, H.T., and S.G. Hanson, 1987, J. Opt. SOC.Am. A 4, 1931.
E. WOLF, PROGRESS IN OPTICS XXXVII 0 1997 ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
I1
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY BY
KAI-ERIKPEIPONEN Viiisalii Laboratoy, Department of Physics, Universig of Joensuu, PO. Box I l l . FIN-80101, Joensuu, Finland
ERIKM. VARTIAINEN Department of Physics, Lappeenranta Universig of Technologv. PO. Box 20, FIN-53851, Lappeenranta, Finland
AND
TOSHIMITSU ASAKURA Research Institute for Electronic Science, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Hokkaido 060, Japan
57
CONTENTS
PAGE
5 1. 8 2. 9 3.
INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
59
KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . .
62
PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY . . . .
73
9 4 . SUMRULES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
86
3 5. CONCLUSIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
91
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
92
REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
92
58
6
1. Introduction
In materials science various types of spectroscopies, exploiting for instance radioactive particles or electromagnetic radiation as a probe, have been wellestablished in order to gain information about the physical properties of the media. Such information has provided scientists with a better understanding of the electronic and nuclear systems of elements and compounds. Furthermore, the knowledge of the spectroscopic properties of materials has had an impact on many technical applications, which include, for example, different detector devices. An electromagnetic field that is incident on a medium will have interactions with electrons or protons. The strength of the interaction depends upon the energy of the incident photons. In linear optical spectroscopy, probably the bestknown and most often exploited measurement techniques involve the detection of wavelength-dependent light transmission of transparent materials or the normal reflection of opaque materials. During this century the spectral investigation of the intrinsic optical properties of insulators, metals and semiconductors has drawn much attention. Theoretical models dealing with absorption and dispersion were formulated rather long ago. A relatively simple classical description of the permittivity of insulators, which is a complex valued function, is due to Lorentz whereas that of metals is due to Drude (see, e.g., Born and Wolf [1980], Wooten [1972]). The permittivity of semiconductors can be described by coupling the models of Lorentz and Drude together. The advantage of these models lies in the fact that one can explicitly resolve mathematical formulae for absorption and dispersion. However, the classical description usually gives a qualitative, but not a quantitative, picture of the optical properties of the gaseous, liquid or condensed matter. An improvement in dispersion models is to take into account quantum effects as devised by Kramers and Heisenberg. Nevertheless, dispersion formulae of general validity have not yet been formulated. The measurement of either the optical density or reflectance of materials is relatively easy, but the measurement of the wavelength-dependent change of the real refractive index and the phase of the reflected wave may be problematic. An important step toward resolution of this problem was taken at the beginning 59
60
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[II,
9
1
of this century independently by Kramers [1927] and Kronig [1926], who were the first to derive the dispersion relations later known as the KramersKronig (KK) relations. These relations are valid for linear optical constants and also for nonlinear susceptibilities, excluding degenerate four-wave mixing processes for which they do not hold. The idea of the KK relations is that the measured wavelength-dependent data is inverted by numerical calculations to yield the appropriate quantity that is needed. This inversion procedure, involving measured and computed data, has provided intrinsic optical properties and has also affected the quantum mechanical description of electronic systems of media. As an example we mention here the seminal paper devoted to the properties of aluminum written by Ehrenreich, Philipp and Segall [1963]. KK relations have been applied not only in optical physics but also in high energy physics, geophysics, chemistry, etc. (Bohren and Huffman [ 19831). It took a considerably long time before the KK relations could be applied in practice. The main obstacle was the lack of means for numerical computations which were tedious a few decades ago. The obstacle disappeared when computers were developed and became widely available for use by scientists. Despite general agreement that the KK relations are valid, it is a well-known fact that for the data inversion the measured data must be extrapolated beyond the measured range. This procedure has brought up criticism (see, e.g., Aspnes [ 19851) about the reliability of the absolute values of the intrinsic linear optical constants calculated using the KK relations. Attempts to avoid usage of the KK relations have been presented in the literature. Among them is a simple method introduced by King [1977, 19781. He proposed that linear spectral data could be inverted with the aid of conjugate Fourier series. This was tested by Ketolainen, Peiponen and Karttunen [ 19911, who applied King’s method to the calculation of the refractive index change of mixed alkali-halide crystals containing F color centers. It was observed that the method of Fourier series also needs data extrapolation beyond the measured range, and the inverted extinction coefficient should have relatively low values at the wings of the spectrum for successful data inversion. The data extrapolation is usually the critical part of KK calculations. This is the case when optical constants are derived, in particular, from reflectance measurement. Therefore, it is a considerable advantage if only the measured spectrum of finite wavelength range is needed for calculating the optical constants in that range. This is possible in reflection spectroscopy with the aid of a maximum entropy procedure that has been introduced for that purpose by the authors of this review article (Vartiainen, Asakura and Peiponen [ 19931). Nonlinear spectroscopies have become important tools in material sciences.
11, § 11
INTRODUCTION
61
Therefore the question of the validity of the Kramers-Kronig type relations coupling the real and imaginary parts of nonlinear susceptibilities has been investigated, starting in the early sixties by Kogan [1963], Price [1963], and Caspers [1964] and a decade later by Ridener and Good [1974, 19751, Smet and Smet [1974], Smet and van Groenendael 119791 and recently by Peiponen [ 1987a, 19881, Bassani and Scandolo [ 19911, Hutchings, Sheik-Bahae, Hagan and van Stryland [1992], and Kircheva and Hadjichristov [1994]. The consistency between the KK relations and experiments in the case of nonlinear wave interaction with media was shown by Kishida, Hasegawa, Iwasa, Koda and Tolcura 119931, who performed rather tedious experiments with the thirdharmonic wave generation in polysilanes. Inversion of optical data, related to the phase retrieval from the measured modulus of nonlinear susceptibility, without any data extrapolations, has been dealt with by Vartiainen [ 19921, who investigated coherent anti-Stokes Raman spectra using maximum entropy procedure. The same procedure was applied for solving the nonlinear optical constants of polysilanes by Vartiainen, Peiponen, Kishida and Koda [1996]. It has been pointed out by many authors (Peiponen [ 19881, Hutchings, Sheik-Bahae, Hagan and van Stryland [1992], Kircheva and Hadjichristov [1994]) that the KK relations do not hold in the case of degenerate four-wave mixing spectroscopy. However, the maximum entropy model can be applied even in the description of such pathological meromorphic nonlinear susceptibilities as shown by Vartiainen and Peiponen [ 19941. Martin [ 19671 and Mezincescu [ 19851 have examined the cases of meromorphic linear susceptibilities to provide modifications in the KK relations and related sum rules. Since the days of the invention of the KK relations, it has been realized that they can be used to provide deep information about the physical parameters of the investigated system. For instance, one can derive with the aid of a particular KK relation a sum rule that is known as thef-sum rule (see, e.g., Smith and Dexter [ 19721). The f-sum rule is the optical counterpart of the quantum mechanical Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule. The message of the optical f-sum rule is that by measurement of absorption one can get information about the electron density and the oscillator strengths of the electronic transitions. Another feature of many sum rules for optical constants is that they can be exploited to test the consistency of the theoretical models and, importantly, also the success of the data inversions. Altarelli, Dexter, Nussenzveig and Smith [ 19721 were pioneers in deriving a set of new and important sum rules to characterize linear optical constants of materials. Altarelli and Smith [I9741 continued the work and could show by
62
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[n,5 2
using the novel sum rules that, at that time, corrections were needed to describe precisely the magnitudes of the optical constants of some materials obtained by data inversions. Thereafter, several authors (Villani and Zimerman [ 1973a,b], Furya, Villani and Zimerman [1977], Smith [1976a,b, 19801, King [1976,1979], Peiponen [ 19851) continued to realize more general or sophisticated sum rules for linear optical constants. Sum rules for nonlinear susceptibilities have been introduced by Peiponen [1987a,b, 19881, and by Peiponen, Vartiainen and Tsuboi [ 19901, Peiponen, Vartiainen and Asakura [1992], Vartiainen, Peiponen and Asakura [ 1993a1, Bassani and Scandolo [1991, 1992a,b], and Scandolo and Bassani [ 19921. In this review article we deal with the Kramers-Kronig relations appearing in linear and nonlinear optical spectroscopy. In addition, we consider the phase retrieval in linear reflection spectroscopy and in nonlinear optics with the aid of the maximum entropy procedure. Finally, sum rules for linear and nonlinear optical constants are presented.
Q 2. Kramers-Kronig Relations 2.1. HILBERT TRANSFORMS
The mathematical theory of complex analysis has provided good means to deal with complex valued optical constants. The reason for this is due to the holomorphicity (we prefer here the terminology where the property “holomorphicity” of a function is used instead of the analogous concept “analyticity”) of the optical constants. From the mathematical standpoint, the holomomorphicity of a function means that a complex valued function of a complex variable is derivable, the derivative is finite and obeys Cauchy-Riemann conditions. In physics, holomorphicity has a profound interpretation and it is a result of causality. In other words, the response is always later than the cause of the response. A practical example illustrating the principle of causality is as follows: if one is kicking a football towards a wall the response, rebounding of the ball from the wall, will be at a later instant than the kicking of the ball. The principle of causality and its relation to holomorphicity and the existence of dispersion relations have been described in the elegant paper written by Toll [ 19561. A comprehensive treatment of general dispersion theory can be found in the book of Nussenzveig [1972]. For a complex valued physical quantity, f(z) = u(z) + iu(z), that is a holomorphic function of the complex variable, z = x + iy, and has appropriate
11,
9 21
KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS
63
asymptotic properties, one can derive the so-called Hilbert transforms with the aid of complex contour integration (Morse and Feshbach [ 19531). The function can in principle be holomorphic in the whole complex plane. However, in spectroscopy, f is holomorphic in a half-plane and it has poles in the other half-plane. The poles can be simple (linear optics) or of higher order (nonlinear optics) and the set of the poles may be countably infinite (like in the case of the Kramers-Heisenberg model for permittivity). The poles represent the resonance points of the system. In the case of measured data they express information about the resonance frequencies and line widths of the spectra and can depend on the temperature of the medium. In the quantum mechanical description they yield information about the electronic transition energies and life times of the related exited states. Hilbert transforms are as follows:
The integrands in eqs. (2.1) are singular for the value x = x’. However, the integrals are finite provided that the Cauchy principal value, which is denoted by the symbol P, exists. Taking the Cauchy principal value means that during the integration the nonessential singular point x = x’ is approached symmetrically from the left and the right side. In numerical integrations it means that we cannot allow the integrals of eqs. (2.1) to have precisely the singular value. Reliable estimates are obtained for u(x’) or u(x’) when the values of the integrals are, practically speaking, not changing while the symmetric approach of the point x’ becomes closer and closer. The advantage of Hilbert transforms is that if we can measure, e.g., the function u then we may calculate the hnction u and vice uersa. The shortcoming of the Hilbert transforms is that one integration, performed for the data inversion, will yield the desired physical parameter at only one point. This means that the point x’ must be scanned over the infinite real x-axis in order to resolve the wanted quantity. It is noteworthy that the Hilbert transform of a constant function yields a zero value; i.e., the Hilbert transforms of u(x) and u(x) + C , where C is a constant, are the same. Therefore, we obtain the same value, e.g., for an integral where the integrand u(x)/(x - x’) is replaced by the integrand (u(x) - u(x’))/(x - x’). Obviously, the latter form will approach the derivative of u when x is approaching x’. It is thus evident that by the Hilbert transforms we may calculate the change in the physical parameter. The additive constant C that may be needed is usually known from the physics of the system, and it has a unique value. Actually, this is a necessary property in the derivation of the Hilbert transforms. That is to say,
64
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[II,
5
2
we must choose C, in accordance with physics, to guarantee the vanishing of a complex valued integral along an arc of a semi circle while the radius tends to infinity. This property is known as Jordan’s lemma. The mathematical assumption of the asymptotic behavior of the physical quantity, needed for the validity of eqs. (2. l), is rather weak: f ( z ) IZI-~, 6 > 0, as IzI + 00. For linear and also nonlinear optical constants, the asymptotic fall-off is always stronger. The universal property for linear permittivity (Smith [ 19851) states that the fall-off of the permittivity is inversely proportional to the second power of the angular frequency for high frequency values. For nonlinear susceptibilities, an even stronger fall-off can usually be found. In the case of optical physics, x can be the time variable. Then Hilbert transforms characterize an analytic signal, which is of great importance in the description of coherence properties of optical fields as devised in the seminal paper of Mandel and Wolf [1965]. In optical spectroscopy, x is often replaced by the wavelength of the incident light or more commonly by the corresponding angular frequency. The contour integration using complex angular frequency variable for dispersion relations of the permittivity and the permeability is presented, e.g., in the book of Landau and Lifshitz [1960]. Detailed mathematical procedures of the contour integrations and the estimations which are needed can be found, e.g., from the paper of Hutchings, Sheik-Bahae, Hagan and van Stryland [ 19921.
-
2.2. KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS IN LINEAR ABSORPTION SPECTROSCOPY
Inspection of the Hilbert transforms described above reveals that at first sight they would not be of much importance in practical optical data inversion since integration is also needed in the domain of negative frequencies. Negative angular frequencies are not related to the physical reality, which allows only positive values. However, optical constants have symmetry properties which will reduce the integration to positive values. The symmetry properties will result from the fact that a real valued electromagnetic field (input) must result to a real valued polarization (response) of the electric charges. The symmetry relations or crossing relations, as they are also called, can be written for complex permittivity and permeability and hold for all known systems. The message of the symmetry relations is simple, and it states the even and odd parities of the optical constants. In the case of the angular frequencydependent, complex refractive index, . N ( w ) = a ( w ) + iK(w), where4 is the real
11,
5 21
KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS
65
refractive index and K is the extinction coefficient, one can write the symmetry relations as follows:
In the event that complex angular frequencies, B = Re& + i ImB, are permitted the symmetry relation for complex refractive index is N * ( B ) = N ( - B * ) , where * denotes the complex conjugate. Note that in the case of circularly polarized light and in magneto-optics the crossing relations are asymmetric and therefore dispersion relations of modified Kramers-Kronig form (Smith [ 1976a,b]) are valid for the corresponding complex refractive indices. The best-known form of the KK relations often dealt with in optics are given for the complex refractive index (related to the the linearly polarized light modes in isotropic media) as follows:
n.(w) - 1 (32
- (3‘2
do.
These relations express the principle of causality in the frequency space. Accordingly, the linear response of the system to a light field is defined completely by m(w) or K ( o ) . Similar relations, but of more general validity (not limited by the isotropy of the material) which take into account the tensoric nature of the permittivity (Smith [1980]) can be written for the complex permittivity of insulators, metals and also semiconductors. However, the measurement of the permittivity as a function of angular frequency is problematic and therefore the corresponding Kramers-Kronig relations have importance mainly in theoretical considerations. Usually it is easier to measure and calculate the complex refractive index and thereafter resolve the complex permittivity, t, using the well known identity Efi = N 2 ,where fi is the complex permeability. For insulators, as well as for metals at optical frequencies, the permeability is equal to unity. In fig. 1 are shown the measured extinction coefficients (in a region of strong absorption) and corresponding refractive index changes, calculated from eq. (2.3), for a KBr crystal that contains defects which are F , M and R color centers. The optical constants change as a function of the crystal temperature. Precautions must be taken in order to meet the assumptions imposed on the use of the KK relations. Firstly, we must regard the symmetry properties in theoretical lineshape models. If a line model that does not fulfill the particular
66
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
I
[II,
5
2
a)T=120K
F
Fig. I . (a) The extinction data of F , M and R color centers of a KBr crystal at various temperatures, and (b) corresponding refractive index changes (Peiponen and Vaittinen [ 19841).
symmetry model is employed in the calculations, an error in the result is unavoidable. This was shown by Peiponen and Vartiainen [1991] with the aid of a gaussian line model. The moral of that study was that if we invert a function that does not obey symmetry relations, the correct values are obtained from the Hilbert transform but not from the Kramers-Kronig form. This observation
11, § 21
KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS
67
stimulated Lee and Sindoni [1992] in their studies of the susceptibility of a semiclassical gas. Inserting w' = 0 in the upper part of eq. (2.3) will provide us the information about the static refractive index. Such information related to the static term or low frequency value of the real part of the permittivity of insulators is important in electric power applications like those of the insulating materials of capacitors. A method to generalize the Kramers-Kronig relations to hold for finite frequency intervals was proposed by Hulthtn [ 19821. His method enables one to compute a complex refractive index, N ( w ) , for u < W I and w > w2, if N ( w ) is known for 01 w w2. So far, this remarkable method has not attracted much interest - probably because usually only either the real or imaginary part of N ( w ) is measured within some interval 01 < w < w2, and Hulthtn's method requires both of them to be known.
< <
2.3. KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS IN REFLECTION SPECTROSCOPY
Kramers-Kronig relations in reflection spectroscopy have drawn much attention. The validity of the Kramers-Kronig relations in reflection spectroscopy was treated by Jahoda [1957] and Velicky [1961]. Criticism about their validity has been presented by Goedecke [1975a,b] (see also Agudin, Palumbo and Platzeck [1986]) on the basis of the proposed violation of the micro causality due to radiation reaction. Smith [ 19771 has provided a simplified proof of the validity of the dispersion relations for complex reflectivity. The KK relations in reflection spectroscopy are important when dealing with strongly absorbing materials like metals and semiconductors for which the measurement of the optical density is cumbersome. The advantage of the measurement of reflectance is due to its simplicity and the wide spectral range of probe wavelengths that can be used. Complex refractive index can be determined solely by ellipsometric measurement, but that procedure is more dependent on instrumental factors and a relatively narrow spectral range can usually be covered. The complex electric field normal reflectance, r, can be given in the polar form r(w) = Ir(w)l exp[iO(w)]. By measurement, we obtain information about the amplitude reflectance R = lrI2.The desire is to resolve the optical constants n and k . The normal reflectance and the complex refractive index are coupled by the Fresnel formula,
r ( u )=
1- N(0) 1+ N ( w ) '
68
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[I],
5
2
The remarkable property of eq. (2.4) is that it provides a means, together with the proper KK-relation, to resolve the absolute value of n instead of its change, which is the case when absorption data are inverted. The information about the optical constants of n and k of an opaque medium can be calculated when we notice that the logarithm of the reflectance and the corresponding phase of the reflected wave can be resolved by taking the logarithm Inr = In Ir( + i0. This function is holomorphic on the real axis and in the upper-half of the complex angular frequency plane. However, the asymptotic behaviour of r, i.e., Ir(w)l 0 and therefore lnr(w) + -00 as w + 00, (no interaction with material for infinite energy values of the incident photon) has brought up much confusion in the context of the related Kramers-Kronig relation. Smith [ 19771 has formulated dispersion relations for reflectances where the pathological behavior as decribed above is shown to be nonessential. Following Smith’s argument, we can write the KK relations for the phase retrieval problem in the form: ---f
The constant 60 has the value zero for insulators and metals. However, in some special cases it may have a nonzero value; this has been observed recently by Nash, Bell and Alexander [1995]. Lee [1995] has considered the phase recovery and reconstruction of the Raman amplitude from the Raman exitation profile. He generalized the KK relations to a case where the complex function may possess, in addition to the poles, also zeros in the complex plane. It should be stressed that the latter relation in eq. (2.5) is not a difference of two KJS relations since both integrals are individually divergent, whereas the difference is convergent. The above definition of the reflectance in the polar form means that there is an indeterminacy in r, just as in the case of Hilbert transforms related to an additive constant considered in $2.1. This can be realized when we investigate a product C Irl, where C is a real constant so that C Irl < 1. Then we can write In C Irl = In C + In Irl. When calculating the KK relation, the additive constant term is filtered out. This property with the polar reflectance has importance in the deduction of possible sum rules for Irl. Nevertheless, as already stated in the context of absorption data inversion, the constant C must be consistent with physics. Therefore, the only choice is C = 1 in order to fulfill the demand of Jordan’s lemma. The numerical integrations to calculate the phase angle are very critical to the width of the spectral range of the measured data and also to data
11,
P 21
69
KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS
extrapolations beyond the measured range. Aspnes [ 19851 has investigated the published values for optical constants obtained by KK analysis and found substantial errors in them. He ascertained that these errors are caused mainly by the data extrapolations, and stated that "A Kramers-Kronig analysis should be attempted only if accurate reflectance data are available over a very, very wide energy range". Nevertheless, various fitting procedures have been presented in the literature (Rasigni and Rasigni [1977], Jezierski [1984]). The failure of KK relations in reflectance spectroscopy in the case of layered materials was dealt with by Young [1972]. 2.4. DISPERSION RELATIONS IN NONLINEAR OPTICS
The history of KK type dispersion relations for nonlinear response dates back to the early sixties. Kogan [ 19631, Price [ 19631, Caspers [ 19641, and Smet and Smet [ 19741 were dealing with second order nonlinear responses, whereas Ridener and Good [1974, 19751 derived dispersion relations for a third and an arbitrary order nonlinear response of the system. Smet and van Groenendael [1979] showed that no dispersion relation can be established between different nonlinear phenomena. All of the systems mentioned above were treated in such a way that only one angular frequency of the incident electric field was permitted to change whereas other pump fields were assumed to have a fixed wavelength. Then the dispersion relations are of the KK form and the derivation of them is based on the complex contour integration of one complex variable. The corresponding dispersion relation for the nth order nonlinear susceptibility can be then written as follows: p ( u I , .
. . , w;,.
l
. . , 0,)= 7-P
W X ( " ) ( W l , . . . ,uj,. .. '
s,
0. - w! J
dwj.
(2.6)
J
The above dispersion relation was generalized by Peiponen [1987a, 19881 to allow the changing of the angular frequency of all incident fields. With the aid of the theory of several complex variables and by applying the complex contour integration separately for each variable, one can write the generalized form to read:
x'"'( w;,w;, . . . ,0,)
However, only the odd orders will yield dispersive-dissipative effects to be written by KK type dispersion relations. The symmetry relation relating
70
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[II,
92
to the nth order nonlinear susceptibility and involving real frequencies is x(")*(ul,. . . 0,) = x(")(-ul7 . . . -u,). If all frequencies are allowed to vary and the symmetry property is used, the integrations in eq. (2.7) can be performed from zero frequency to infinity. Bassani and Scandolo [1991] have derived dispersion relations, by considering the nonlinear process of all orders, for the refractive index that is a sum of the linear ( h ~and ) nonlinear (R,NL) angular frequency dependent terms, R = n ' +~~ , N L ,and extinction coefficient, K = KL + KNL, in the regime of a probe and one pump beam (with fixed wavelength). These relations are as follows:
where u]is the angular frequency of the probe beam to be scanned, 0 2 is the fixed frequency of the pump beam and E2 is the electric field of the pump beam. From eq. (2.8) we can observe that in the absence of the probe beam there will be a nonzero "static" contribution, RNL(O, u2,Ez), to the refractive index. This kind of procedure with probe and pump beams is quite common in many experiments like those involving coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (see, e.g., Shen [1984]). Unfortunately, most of the experiments with the nonlinear optical processes will provide information only about the modulus, Ix(")l,of the nonlinear susceptibility. Then the problem of phase retrieval will again arise, and problems similar to those in linear reflectance spectroscopy are present. The maximum entropy method will provide us with a way to solve the phase retrieval problem and to avoid the data extrapolation in resolving the real and imaginary parts of the nonlinear susceptibility from the wavelenght-dependent modulus data, as will be described later. Nonlinear susceptibilities can also be described by series expansions (Peiponen [1988]) and by making use of the concept of conformal mapping by a similar way as King [ 19781 did in linear optics to avoid KK relations. However, complicated measurements and data extrapolations are then needed. The generalized dispersion relations of several angular frequency variables of eq. (2.7) as well as those of one frequency are valid only for nondegenerate cases. The degenerate case means that a frequency pair like (u,, -uj)appears in the functional dependence of the nonlinear nth order susceptibility. This in turn means that there appear simultaneously poles in the upper and lower half planes. Therefore dispersion relations of the KK type are no longer valid. A function
11, § 21
KRAMERS-KRONIG RELATIONS
71
with poles in both the lower and upper half planes is called meromorphic (Peiponen [ 19881). Shore and Chan [ 19901 and Hutchings, Sheik-Bahae, Hagan and van Stryland [ 19921 have discussed the dispersion relations for meromorphic susceptibilities like ~ ( ~ ) w, ( w-w), , which are closely related, for example, to semiconductors (see Hopf and Stegeman [ 19861). For the possible dispersion relations one must know the resonance points in the upper half plane. This may not, however, be possible with the aid of measured data due to, e.g., the overlapping of adjacent lines belonging to different electronic transitions. Using the complex contour integration we can write a dispersion relation for the meromorphic nonlinear susceptibility. In the case of one angular frequency variable (the others being fixed), a dispersion relation for the nth order nonlinear susceptibility can be given as (Vartiainen and Peiponen [ 19941): X'"'(w;, . . . , wj, -oj,. . . ,w;)
(9- y,!)
do,
=
inx(")(wi,.. . , w,!, -u,!, . . . ,w,,)
(2.9) The latter term on the right-hand side of eq. (2.9) is the contribution of the residues, which takes into account the poles in the upper half plane. Apparently the KK type dispersion relation is now modified by adding a term due to the poles, but as mentioned above, we are not usually provided with the information of resonance frequencies of such poles. An example is shown in fig. 2 (Vartiainen and Peiponen [1994]). Typical theoretical dispersion curves of real and imaginary parts of degenerate susceptibility x ( ~ ) ( w, o ,-w) are plotted along with corresponding curves computed using the dispersion integral of eq. (2.9), but omitting the residues. Clearly, the contribution of residues is significant; otherwise these curves would coincide with Re ~ ( and ~ Im 1 ~ ( ~ 1 . It should be emphasized that there is no causality breaking with meromorphic nonlinear susceptibilities. Merely causality is necessary, but not a sufficient condition for the existence of the conventional KK relations, as pointed out by Kircheva and Hadjichristov [1994]. Kishida, Hasegawa, Iwasa, Koda and Tokura [ 19931 were the first to show the consistency between the KK relations and experiments in nonlinear optics. They made laborious experiments with the third harmonic generation from polysilanes. Inverting the modulus of the third order susceptibility, they calculated the corresponding phase and thereafter the intrinsic real and imaginary parts of
72
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY .
,
.
,
.
,
,
.
,
.
,
.
,
.
,
.
,
[II, $ 2
_
0.2 3
?
0.1 -
/-*'.
.
..mc.-".'
0.0
-0.1 -0.2 -0.3 -
d
-0,4 -0.5
-0.6
-8 .Fi --j a
0.2
j
0.0
m
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
"
"
"
"
0.1
-0.1
-;- 0 2 -0.3 -0.4' 1.0
'
"
2.2
"
2.4
"
2.6
"
2.8
'
3.0
Energy (eV) Fig. 2. Theoretical curves (a) R e ~ ( ~ ) ( w , w , - oand ) (b) I m ~ ( ~ ) ( w , w , - w (solid ) lines) and the corresponding curves given by the dispersion integral of eq. (2.9) (dots) (Vartiainen and Peiponen [ 19941).
the third order susceptibility related to the third-harmonic wave generation. The consistency between the theory and experiments was verified by ellipsometric measurements and exploiting various laser lines to generate the third harmonic wave. Finally we remark that care should be taken while employing KK relations in time-resolved spectroscopy as devised by Tokunaga, Terasaki and Kobayashi [ 1993, 19951. They applied femtosecond time-resolved spectroscopy to study the pumpprobe processes in CS2 liquid. According to their experimental and theoretical results the causality condition is not always satisfied when a pump pulse causes changes in the state of the material before the probe field is applied. Basically the situation corresponds the meromorphism of the nonlinear susceptibility.
11,
P 31
PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
0
73
3. Phase Retrieval in Optical Spectroscopy
Practical experiments in optics usually provide only partial measurements of the electric field E(t). For example, in optical spectroscopy only an intensity spectrum, IE(w)I2 0; lf(w)I2,is measured while the entire complex response function,f(w) = If(w)l exp[iO(o)], is needed for obtaining the desired material properties. This leads to the question of phase retrieval: With some extra obtainable information, is it possible to compute the phase function, O(w), from a measurement of the amplitude If(w)l? Recently, significant progress has been made in solving this problem in spectroscopic applications. The progress is due mainly to the idea of applying a certain type of the maximum entropy model in phase retrieval. This approach was first shown to be applicable in coherent anti-Stokes Raman spectrum (CARS) analysis (Vartiainen [ 19921) and in reflection spectroscopy (Vartiainen, Peiponen and Asakura [ 1992, 1993b1). Later, an improved version of the procedure, applicable to any case of spectrum analysis wheref(w) is to be computed from If(o ) l, was given by Vartiainen, Asakura and Peiponen [1993]. In particular, this method was shown to be valid even in the case where the alternative Kramers-Kronig method is not: whenf(c;)) is a meromorphic complex function, such as the degenerate third-order nonlinear susceptibility x ( ~ ) (61, &-61) , (Vartiainen and Peiponen [ 19941). In this section we give a short review of the phase retrieval in optical spectroscopy using the maximum entropy model: its theorical background, why it works and how it is applied. 3.1. PHASE RETRIEVAL USING MAXIMUM ENTROPY MODEL
3.1.1. Maximum entropy model
It has been conjectured in information theory (Shannon [ 19481, Jaynes [ 1957a,b]) that entropy defines a measure on the space of probability distributions, such that those of high entropy are favored over others. Accordingly, the maximum entropy (ME) principle states that any inferences made from incomplete information should be based on the probability distribution that has the maximum entropy permitted by the available data. Most notably this principle has been utilized with iterative ME algorithms in various image-restoration problems arising in astronomy (Gull and Daniel [1978], Bryan and Skilling [1986]), X-ray crystallography (Collins [ 1982]), medical tomography (Kemp [ 19811) and electron holography (Matsumoto, Tanji and Tonomura [ 19941).
14
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[II,
5
3
There exists another type of maximum entropy method that was originally developed by Burg [1967]. His method is an algorithm for computing the power spectrum, S(w), when the measured data consist of sampled signal,
x,
= x(t,),
0
<m <M,
whose autocorrelation values can be given by:
where & denotes the expectation operator. The autocorrelation function, C(m), and the power spectrum, S(w), form a Fourier transform pair, 00
C(m)exp(-imwht),
S(w) = At
,=-a
in
C ( m )= - L " " S (
w ) exp(imwAt) dw,
where At is the time between equispaced samples. In the following it is more convenient to use a normalized frequency v = (2n)-'wAt (i.e., Y is normalized within the interval 0 v 1). Equations (3.3) and (3.4) can now be written as
< <
oc,
S(V) =
C
~ ( mexp(-i2nmv), )
m=-m
S(v) exp(i2nmv) dv, where S( v) = S( w)/At. The conventional method of obtaining a power spectrum estimate from known autocorrelation values, C(m), lml < M , is to assume that C(m) = 0 for )m1 > M , and to take a Fourier transform of w(m)C(m), where w(m)is a window function. The windowing is used to reduce the errors due to the truncation of the autocorrelation function. A shortcoming of this kind of estimation is the fact that there is no knowledge about the window function that would give the best result. In Burg's maximum entropy method, the idea is to choose the spectrum that corresponds to the most random or the most unpredictable time series whose autocorrelation function agrees with a set of known values. This leads to an extrapolation of the autocorrelation function by maximizing the entropy (a
11,
5
31
PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
75
measure of the average information content) of the process x ( t ) ; hence, the name of the method. As a consequence, Burg's procedure leads to a certain maximum entropy model for S(w). On the one hand, this model is the final result of Burg's approach, and on the other hand, it is the starting-point in the phase retrieval procedure described in sect. 3.2.2. We emphasize that this model for S(w) is the only feature of the phase retrieval method common with Burg's maximum entropy method. For any stationary time series, {xn}, it can be shown that the entropy rate of the time series is (see, e.g., Haykin and Kesler [1983]):
1 I
h
0:
logS(v)dv,
(3.7)
where it is assumed that the time series is limited to the angular frequency band 0 < w < w, and u, = 2 n / A t . Suppose that we know the first 2M + 1 values of the autocorrelation function, namely:
I'
C(m)=
S ( v ) exp(i2nmv) dv,
Iml
< M.
(3.8)
Then the most reasonable choice for the unknown values of C(m), Iml > M , is the one that adds no information or entropy to the process. Therefore, the required maximum entropy power spectrum is the fimction k ( v ) that maximizes eq. (3.7) under the constraint of eq. (3.8). That is,
This leads to the following maximum entropy model (MEM) for S(v) (Haykin and Kesler [ 19831): 3(v)=
1
1+
M
IN2
C a k exp(-i2;zkv) k=l
1'
where the unknown MEM coefficients ak and Toeplitz system, C(0) C(1)
C(-I) C(0)
...
C(-W
. ' . C(1-M)
C ( M ) C ( M - 1) . . '
C(0)
(3.10)
IPl2
can be obtained from a
16
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[II, $ 3
Van den Bos [ 197I] has shown that the MEM, as defined in eqs. (3.10) and (3.1 l), is equivalent to the autoregressive (AR) model of a stationary stochastic process x ( t ) . A time process is called autoregressive if an observation x , can be given by a linear combination of the A4 preceding observations: M
(3.12) k= 1
where em is a corresponding error at m (with E[e(n)e(m)]= 0 for n f m), and the ak's are the same coefficients as in eqs. (3.10) and (3.11). Here we are interested in using the model of eq. (3.10) for the phase retrieval. Therefore, in addition to the model for S ( Y ) = lf(v)I2, we must have an ME model forf(v) = If(v)I exp[i@(v)]. We can derive this by taking a z-transform (see, e.g., Haykin [1986]) from both sides of eq. (3.12) and using the convolution theorem to obtain:
+ a2zp2 + . . . + aMz-M>X(z)+ ~ ( z ) ,
X(Z) = -(alz-'
(3.13)
where X(z) and E(z) are z-transforms of the sequences { x m } and { e m } , respectively. Thus, we get the expression for X(z): X(z) = 1+
E(z) M akz-k
c
(3.14)
k=l
Finally, if we replace the signal x ( t ) with the time response function g(t) and set z = exp(i2nv), the z-transforms can be recognized as the discrete-time Fourier transforms. Hence, we can write the maximum entropy estimate for the complex spectral responsef(v) = .F{g(t)} as a function of the normalized frequency v as (3.15) I
+
ak exp(-i2nkv) k= 1
3.1.2. Phase retrieval procedure
Suppose that a power spectrum, S(w) = lf(o)I2, is measured within the frequency range of 01 < w < 0 2 . Now, defining a normalized frequency as: v = (0- 0 1 ) / ( 0 2 - 01),
(3.16)
11,
P 31
PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
I7
S ( W ) can be fitted by eqs. (3.6), (3.10) and (3.11). However, instead of using
the continuous Fourier transform of eq. (3.6), the autocorrelations, C(rn), are in practice computed by using the discrete Fourier transform: N-l
C(m) = N-'
S,, exp(i2nmn/N),
(3.17)
n=O
where N is the number of S(W,,) = S,, samples. In this case there exists an upper limit to the number of C(m) and, therefore, to the MEM parameter M in eqs. (3.10) and (3.11); i.e., A4 < N/2. Contrary to Burg's maximum entropy method, here there is no ambiguity in selecting the order of M . Namely, if the object is to get the MEM estimate S(W) as close as possible to the original one, then using the maximum value for M = M,, gives the best result. However, if the original spectrum, S ( W ) is noisy, it is possible to reduce the noise in $0) by computing it with the lower order of M < Mmm. This is illustrated in fig. 3 (Vartiainen, Asakura and Peiponen [ 19931). Three simulated spectra, with the same spectral features but different amounts of noise, are shown in fig. 3a. The number of samples was selected to be N = 1001 and, consequently, Mmax= 500. Figure 3b shows how the order of M affects the root-mean-square (RMS) errors in the MEM estimates of the spectra in fig. 3a. The RMS error is defined here as: (3.18) where i E ( v ) , i = A , B, C, is an MEM estimate computed from spectrum i in fig. 3a, and So(v) is the original noiseless spectrum (curve A in fig. 3a). In the noise-free case of curve A, the minimum error (ERMSM is obtained with the maximum value M = 500. The error increases with a decrease of M , although the increase is only nominal over a wide range of M . At the low order of M < 70, however, the error increases very strongly. The latter observation is also true for the noisy spectra of curves B and C. For noisy spectra, the smallest error (compared with the noiseless spectrum) is obtained using the optimum value M = Moptthat is a compromise between the high orders which also reconstruct the noise (see fig. 3c) and the low orders which do not result in much noise but result in distortions instead because the higher-order MEM is required. Therefore, in practice, when Mop,cannot be obtained we should clearly use a high value of M > Mop, rather than a low one of M < Mop,to avoid the distortions at the expense of some noise to be reconstructed.
78
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
,"t 9
[II,
5
3
(b)
I
N
W
L
200
400
MEM parameter M
Fig. 3. (a) Simulated power spectra S(w) with the noise-to-signal (N/S) ratios (defined as RMS values) of 0 (curve A), 5% (curve 8) and 10% (curve C). (b) RMS errors versus the order of M in MEM estimates of spectra in (a). (c) Power spectrum S ( o ) with N/S=5% (curve A) and its MEM ) M = 500 (curve B) and M = 60 (curve C) (Vartiainen, Asakura and Peiponen fits $ ~ ( owith [ 19931).
The next step in the procedure is to find a way to compute
](Y)
from
$(Y ) = lf(v)I2,assuming that some additional information onf(v) is available. Now, on the presumption that the complex spectral response function f(v) is given by eq. (3.16) and its modulus by eq. (3. lo), we can write the error spectrum as:
where # ( Y ) is the phase of the error spectrum. Thus the error spectrum has a constant amplitude and only its phase can have a frequency dependence. The error phase @ ( Y ) is now the only quantity in eq. (3.16) that cannot be obtained from the measured modulus If(v)I. Consequently, using the MEM in phase retrieval reduces the problem of finding the phase off(v) = If(v)I exp[iO(v)] to the problem of finding the corresponding error phase. In order to find a reasonable estimate for @ ( Y ) , we must have some additional information onf(v). For example, if we know the value of the real (or imaginary) part off(v) or the value of the phase O(v) at L + 1 discrete frequency values Y/ inside the measurement range, we can compute the corresponding error phase values qj(v,) and estimate the error phase by a polynomial interpolation as L
$ ( Y ) = B~
+ B , Y + . ..+ B
~ =Y
CB/Y/, ~
l=O
(3.20)
11, § 31
PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
19
where the Bl’s satisfy a Vandermonde system (see, e.g., Press, Teukolsky, Vetterling and Flannery [1992]) as:
(3.21)
The idea of using the MEM in resolvingf(v) from its modulus is that the error phase is usually a much smoother function than the actual phase and therefore, that it can be estimated with a low order polynomial (i.e., the number of required known values of $ ( Y [ ) is low). Clearly, the ideal situation would be if the error phase could be given by a linear estimation; i.e., L < 1 in eq. (3.20). In fact, it is possible to reduce the optimum degree, Lopt,of the polynomial in eq. (3.20) by a simple “squeezing” procedure. Namely, instead of using the measured power spectrum S ( Y )as such in eq. (3.9), we should use a modified spectrum Ssqgiven by : (3.22) where ZK(W) =
(2K + 1)-’ w2
- w1
(3.23)
and
Now, choosing the squeezing parameter K = 0, eq. (3.22) restores the original spectrum in Ssqas a function of the normalized frequency Y . However, when K > 0, the original is transformed (squeezed) into a narrower range. For example, setting K = 2 the original spectrum S ( Y ) is squeezed from the interval Y E [0, I] into interval Y E [0.4,0.6]. The rest of the squeezed spectrum is obtained by adding constant wings having the same values as the original spectrum at its end points Y = 0 and Y = 1. Quite commonly, this procedure reduces Lopt enough that a linear approximation ( L = 1) gives a reasonably good estimation for the error phase.
80
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY 0 . 7 - ,
,
O.'
(a)
Q)
0
,
I
I
,
,
,
I
I
I
,
"
"
I
,
,
.
[II,
03
-
c (d
c
0
-a,
0.5
-
c
2
0.3
"
1.5
"
2.0
'
'
"
2.5
'
'
J
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
"
5.0
5.5
6.0
Energy (eV)
4
0.8
0.7
-
0.5
-
1.5
1
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
8.0
Energy (eV) Fig. 4.(a) Reflectance of GaAs as a funtion of energy. (b) Phase 0 and the error phases obtained with (&) and without (9) the squeezing procedure. Exact (dots) and computed (solid lines); (c) real refractive index and (d) extinction coefficient. The arrows in (c) and (d) point out the energies at which the phase values were assumed to be known a priori; e.g., determined by ellipsometry (Vartiainen, Peiponen and Asakura [ 19961).
3.2. PHASE RETRIEVAL IN PRACTICE: EXAMPLES
3.2.1. Rejection spectroscopy An example of the utility of using the maximum entropy model in phase retrieval in reflection spectroscopy is illustrated in fig. 4 (Vartiainen, Peiponen and Asakura [1996]). In fig. 4a the reflectance spectrum, R ( o ) = lr(o)I2,of GaAs is shown within the energy range from 1.5 eV to 6.0eV This spectrum (dots) was obtained using complex refractive index data from the literature (Palik [1985a]). The corresponding phase function, @w), and the error phase functions are shown in fig. 4b. Clearly, both the error phase obtained with
11,
9 31
81
PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
4
5.5
:
:
: 2.0
-
1 .o 1.5
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
5.0
5.5
6.0
Energy (eV)
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
Energy (eV)
($sq(w)) and without ($(w))the squeezing procedure (defined in eqs. 3.22-3.24) are “slowly varying” functions compared with O(w). Moreover, gSq(w)can be well described by a linear approximation. Consequently, the complex refractive index N ( w ) = n(w) + ik(w) = [l + r(w)]/[I- r(w)] can be retrieved, if in addition to R ( w ) the value of r(w) is known at two frequencies inside the measurement range of R(w). In the present example this additional information was assumed to be obtained by ellipsometric measurements at wavelengths of a red (A = 633 nm) and a green (A = 543 nm) light emitting He-Ne lasers. The resultant real (refractive index, ~ ( w )and ) imaginary (extinction coefficient, ~ ( w )parts ) of JV(0) are shown in figs. 4c and 4d (solid lines), respectively. The exact values (dots) are also shown for comparison. Another example, concerning the reflectance spectrum of KC1, is shown in fig. 5 (Vartiainen, Peiponen and Asakura [ 19961). The spectrum shown in fig. 5a extends over the energies from the visible (2.0 eV) to the far ultraviolet (34 eV)
82
DISPERSION ELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[I], 4 3
o.3}
a
0 C c 0
0.2 -
-a .c
a
a
-
0.1
0.0
i .
3.0
20
10
0
,
.
,
I
.
.
,
30
,
2.5 h
u
2
v
2.0 -
1.5 -
v)
nr
1.0
-
0.5
-
0.0
"
"'
"
"
'
"
"
"
'
-
Fig. 5. (a) Reflectance of a KCI crystal. (b) Phase 6 and the corresponding error phase @ obtained with the squeezing procedure. Exact (dots) and computed (solid lines); (c) real refractive index and (d) extinction coefficient. The arrows in (c) and (d) point out the energies in the visible range where the extinction coefficient k x 0; these two points were used to give a linear estimate for the error phase (Vartiainen, Peiponen and Asakura [1996]).
region. This spectrum was also obtained using complex refractive index data from the literature (Palik [1985b]). In fig. 5b, the idea of the MEM procedure becomes evident: although the phase O(w) has a very complex line shape, the corresponding error phase $sq(o) can still be given rather well by a linear approximation. Furthermore, in this case no extra measurement for recovering O(w) is needed, because KCl is transparent in the visible range and thus we have the constraint ~ ( wM) 0 when w E [2.0 eV, 3.1 eV]. Using this constraint, the error phase was estimated and the complex electric field reflectance was obtained. The resulting real refractive index and extinction coefficient are shown in figs. 5c and 5d (solid lines), respectively.
83
PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
11, § 31
3.0 X
Q,
-0
1
'
'
'..
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
.
'
'
'
1
2.5
.-K
a,
> .c. 0 E .c
= Q,
2.0
1.5
:I
1.0
0.5
0
c
.-
.-
.-0
20
10
30
Energy (eV)
c
0
.E c
0.5
X
UI 0.0 0
10
20
30
Energy (eV)
3.2.2. Nonlinear optical spectroscopy
In nonlinear optical spectroscopy the most typical measurement is a power 2 spectrum measurement: the squared modulus of nth-order susceptibility = lx(")Iexp(i0) is measured within some frequency interval. Since both the modulus and the phase 0 provide crucial information on the multiphoton processes of a medium, the phase retrieval problem arises. It has been shown recently (Kishida, Hasegawa, Iwasa, Koda and Tokura [ 19931) that the phase of third-order susceptibility x ( ~w, ) (w, w ) of poly(dihexylsi1ane) can be computed from its modulus by Kramers-Kronig integration. In that calculation the extrapolation problem was avoided by a procedure similar to the Roesler method (Roesler [1965]). In that method, the integrals outside of the measurement region were replaced by two experimental phase data points. In fig. 6 these results are shown together with the corresponding maximum entropy
Ix(")I
x(")
Ix(")I
84
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETNEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
L
0.5
1 .o
1.5
Energy (eV)
2.0
0.5
[]I,
8
3
.
1 .o
1.5
2.0
Energy (eV)
Fig. 6 . Experimental values of (a) real and (b) imaginary parts (dots and open circles) of the , o)of PDHS, and the corresponding curves obtained by the KK analysis susceptibility x ( ~ ) ( oo, (dotted lines) and by the MEM procedure (solid lines). The additional information used for the MEM estimates with L = 1 are the two phase values indicated by the arrows (Vartiainen, Peiponen, Kishida and Koda [1996]).
calculations [the real and imaginary parts of x ( ~ ) ( ou, , o)] (Vartiainen, Peiponen, Kishida and Koda [1996]). The MEM curves were computed by estimating the error phase with first-order ( L = 1) and third-order ( L = 3) polynomials. It is observed that these MEM curves are identical, although the curves with L = 1 were obtained using only two measured phase values as additional information, whereas all the measured phase values (about 60 values) were used in the cases of the curves with L = 3. Moreover, the KK and the MEM estimates are very similar, excluding the fact that the KK computation could not reproduce the two-photon resonance peak at 2.1 eV Accordingly, both the KK and the MEM approaches for phase retrieval required phase data at two frequency points as additional information. However, the significant difference between the KK and the MEM analysis is the fact that in the KK calculation the additional information is needed outside, whereas in the case of MEM it is needed inside the measurement range of ( x ( ~ ) ( . Another third-order susceptibility having much practical interest is the frequency degenerate susceptibility x ( ~w, ) (w, -w), which determines the degenerate four-wave mixing processes. Furthermore, it links together the Kerr coefficient, y(w) 0: Re~(’)(w,u,-u), and the two-photon absorption coefficient, B(w) K Im ~ ( ~ ) w (w , -0). , Unfortunately, the phase of ~ ( ~ ’w( ,0 -w) , cannot be
11,
5 31
85
PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
0.2
-d
-
7
-H3
01
OD -01 -02
-03
X
2
-04 -0 5 -0.6 I 1.5
'
1.0
'
'
'
1.7
i n
I
'
1.0
2.0
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.1
2.5
Energy (eV)
i
0.45
--
0.85
7
0.25 0.1 5 0.05 -0.06
X
5
-0.15
-0.25 -0.35 1.5
1.8
1.1
ia
1.a
2.0
2.1
1.2
2.5
1.4
2.5
Energy (eV)
Fig. 7. (a) The theoretical amplitude ~ x ( ~ ) ( w , wThe , - ~KK (open squares) and MEM (dots) estimates of (b)
I I
and (c) ImX(3) computed with the aid of x ( ~. )The corresponding solid lines are the actual curves (Vartiainen and Peiponen [1994]).
obtained by the KK integration. This is because of the fact that the dispersion relation for ~ ( ~ )o, (-w) o , (given in eq. 2.9) includes in addition to the ordinary KK dispersion relation a term due to contribution of residues. This term can be neither computed nor omitted (see Vartiainen and Peiponen [ 19941). However, it is possible to use the MEM approach also in this case for computing the phase. This was demonstrated recently (Vartiainen and Peiponen [ 19941) by using a theoretical model for ~ ( ~ ) (w,w-o) , (see fig. 7). Figures 7b and c show its real and imaginary parts computed using the amplitude spectrum I,-((3)(o,w,--0)1 (fig. 7a) by the MEM procedure and by the KK
86
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[II,
5
4
integrations (the residue-term is omitted). The MEM curves were obtained by assuming that, beside the amplitude spectrum, the phase is known at the resonant frequency m. The same assumption was used for KK integrations apart from the fact that was perfectly “extrapolated” beyond the “measurement” range. The subtractive KK procedure (Ahrenkiel [1971]) was used, when use could be made of the fact that the phase is known a priori at a single frequency m. This offers a greater convergence than does the conventional KK method. Nevertheless, although this procedure forces the phase to have a correct value at m, a good estimate for its dispersion could not be obtained due to significant contribution of unknown residues. By contrast, the MEM procedure yields a good result.
I
9
4. Sum Rules
Sum rules are important in quantum mechanics where they yield information about the electronic transitions. For that purpose we usually must solve the Schrodinger equations to have the wave functions of the states and thereafter to calculate, for instance, the dipole matrix elements to obtain the oscillator strengths. After some commutator algebra, we can then derive the ThomasReiche-Kuhn sum rule for the oscillator strengths (Wooten [1972]). It is interesting to note that the KK relations were first derived for the purpose of optics but later adopted in high energy physics. On the contrary, sum rules have played an important role in high energy physics for a considerably long time. Superconvergence sum rules for particle physics as described by De Alfaro, Fubini, Rosetti and Furlan [I9661 probably stimulated the study of novel sum rules related to optical constants.
4. I . SUM RULES IN LINEAR OPTICS
4.1. I . Complex refractive index
The sum rule that probably has the longest history in optical spectroscopy is the so-called f-sum rule for the extinction coefficient (or the imaginary part of the permittivity), which is analogous to the quantum mechanical ThomasReiche-Kuhn sum rule (Smith and Dexter [ 19721). The f -sum rule is obtained
11, I 41
87
SUM RULES
by recognizing the asymptotic behavior of the complex refractive index for high energies as follows
where = Ne2/m,Eois the square of the plasma frequency, wp, defined by the well-known constants and the electron number density N . Now applying the result of eq. (4.1) to the first KK relation of eq. (2.3) we can obtain thef-sum rule,
which will provide, via absorption measurement, information about the number density of electrons participating in the absorption. The sum rule of eq. (4.2) is related to the generalized Smakula’s equation (Smith and Dexter [ 19721, Smith [1985]), which makes it possible to estimate the oscillator strengths of defects and impurities in a host material provided that the density of the defects is much less than the density of the host atoms. Altarelli, Dexter, Nussenzveig and Smith [ 19721 were the pioneers in optical spectroscopy to derive novel sum rules for the complex refractive index. They made use of the asymptotic properties of the complex refractive index for high angular frequency values. They also employed sophisticated results of complex analysis to introduce the superconvergence of the dispersion-absorption integrals related to the optical constants. Using the superconvergence property they derived the elegant sum rules for isotropic materials as follows:
i
00
[&(w)- 13 d w = 0,
[n( w )- 112dw =
~ ~ dw. ( 0 )
(4.3) The first sum rule of eq. (4.3) states that the average of the real refractive index over all frequencies is unity. It holds for insulators and metals, and is a restatement of causality. The asymptotic property to yield the first sum rule is directly related to Newtonian laws of particle dynamics in the classical description. In quantum mechanical description, it is related to the time dependent Schrodinger equation. The second sum rule, which is valid only for insulators, can be employed for data analysis in order to check the success of the Kramers-Kronig data inversion. Altarelli and Smith [1974] gave further a set of new sum rules by observing that the power of the complex refractive index, (JV- 1)” (m is a positive integer), and also the products w‘(JV - 1>”
88
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTKAL SPECTROSCOPY
[I],
54
(r and s are positive integers), are holomorphic functions in the upper half of complex angular frequency plane. Applying the superconvergence theorem they gave sum rules for the complex refractive index and the permittivity of insulators, and analogous sum rules (taking into account the DC-conductivity) for metals. For instance, the following equations hold for the complex refractive index of insulators: lmRe{[N(w)-l]m} dw=O; (4.4)
From the first sum rule of eq. (4.4) we can resolve the sum rules of eq. (4.3). Using different weighting functions, Villani and Zimerman [ 1973a,b], Furya, Zimerman and Villani [1976a,b] and Furya, Villani and Zimerman [I9771 derived a set of new sum rules for the optical constants. King [ 19761 considered the Kramers-Kronig relations and avoided the use of the superconvergence theorem in his derivation of sum rules that was based on the properties of the Dirac’s delta function. Indeed, by such a procedure he could give, e.g., the sum rules of eq. (4.3). Furthermore, King considered the imaginary angular frequencies and the zeros of the real refractive index to obtain other sum rules. Griindler [1983] derived sum rules by using the superconvergence property and Cauchy theorem, Peiponen [1985] by making use of the subtraction of Kramers-Kronig relations, and Peiponen [ 1987~1by using the Cauchy theory and less restrictive assumptions on the optical constants. It is evident that sum rules are holonomic constraints which involve integrals. The sum rule integrals which yield a zero value are important since, e.g., the sum rule for the real refractive index in eq. (4.3) holds separately for the real refractive indices of the host materials and the impurities, as devised by Smith [1974]. Other types of sum rules can give a definite value for the integral and therefore are related directly to physical parameters like plasma frequency. The third class of sum rules involve integrals on both sides of an equation. These are usually applied to check the consistency of theories and more importantly to check the validity of Kramers-Kronig calculations and sometimes the uncertainties in the measurements of spectra. The dependence of the sum rules on physical parameters can be calculated using some simple line model like that of Lorentz but such a result may not hold in general cases of any spectra. The shortcoming with sum rules is that integration, like in the case of Kramers-Kronig relations, is needed to cover the whole spectral range from zero to infinity. Fortunately, the use of the powers of the optical constants usually provide a very fast asymptotic
11, P 41
SUM RULES
89
fall-off of the optical constants and therefore an integration reduced to a finite range is usually enough. Sum rules for the complex refractive index have been given for materials with natural and magneto-optical activity by Smith [ 1976b], who has been the key person not only in realization of many sum rules but also in explaining the physics involved therein. 4.1.2. Complex reflectance
Sum rules in the context of reflectivities were first considered by Smith [ 1976~1 who dealt with magnetoreflectivity. Later, sum rules for complex reflectance were derived by King [1979], who exploited Kramers-Kronig relations and the technique based on the Dirac's delta function. He observed that the following relation holds for insulators and conductors:
I
00
~ - ' R ( O ) ' ' sin ~ O(w)dw = inR(0)"2,
(4.5)
where R is the amplitude reflectance. For metals, R(0) = 1, whereas for insulators, R(0) < 1. King derived many other sum rules, using a weighting factor approach, for the amplitude reflectance and the phase angle. It became evident that dealing with the complex reflectance was not as straightforward as dealing with the complex refractive index. The main problem was that it was not possible to derive a sum rule that would contain only the amplitude reflectance or the phase angle. Indeed sum rules, as can be seen from eq. (4.5) and the following (4.6): Ir(w)l" cos [mO(w)]dw = 0 w Ir(w)l" sin [ m O ( o ) ] d o =
( m = 1,2,3,. . .),
$nwi ( m = I),
(4.6)
involve mixing of the modulus and the phase in the integrands. The results of eq. (4.6) were given by Smith and Manogue [1981], who used the superconvergence theorem for the powers of the complex reflectivity, r = Irl exp(iO) of insulators and conductors. Smith and Manogue argued that due to the indeterminacy that the same phase is associated with the electric field reflectance IrI and with C IrI, where C is a constant and C Irl < 1, we cannot derive the conventional type f-sum rules for the phase and the modulus. King [ 19791
90
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[II,
44
considered imaginary angular frequencies and could resolve a sum rule that is related only to R = lrI2. It can be written in the following form: O0
lnR(w)
3t
d o = -lnR(io’). 2o/
(4.7)
Unfortunately, this sum rule has not much use in practical data analysis since an imaginary frequency is involved. Therefore, IOng proposed that it can be applied in testing the consistency of theoretical models for the reflectance of insulators and conductors. The sum rule of eq. (4.7) can also be obtained by using the Poisson’s formulae for the upper-half of the complex angular frequency plane (see, e.g., Morse and Feshbach [1953]). 4.2. SUM RULES IN NONLINEAR OPTICS
Sum rules for nonlinear susceptibilities were introduced by Peiponen [ I987a,b,c, 19881, who considered the model of an anharmonic oscillator and derived sum rules for the cases of sum and difference frequency generation. With the aid of the theory of several complex angular frequency variables and the powers related to the nonlinear susceptibility, we can obtain for instance: (4.8)
r=l,2,...
m = 1 , 2 ,...
r<m,
provided that the nonlinear susceptibility is not meromorphic. After the application of the symmetry property related to the nonlinear susceptibility, we may write, e.g., for the susceptibility of the third harmonic wave:
Furthermore, sum rules for meromorphic nonlinear susceptibilities can be obtained if the integration is not performed using the angular frequency variable that produces simultaneously poles in both half-planes. Then we can write, for instance: (4.10)
r = 1 , 2 ,...
m = 1 , 2) . . .
r<m.
Obviously, sum rules for nonlinear susceptibilities which are analogous to those for linear optical constants can be found.
11,
I 51
91
CONCLUSIONS
Sum rules for the modulus of the nonlinear Raman susceptibility were considered by making use of the Poisson’s formulae for a disk (Peiponen, Vartiainen and Tsuboi [1990]), but there was the difficulty with the imaginary frequency just as in the case of linear reflectance observed by King [ 19791. Sum rules which hold for the nonlinear parts of the complex refractive index were given by Bassani and Scandolo [1991], who observed that:
1
M
~ I K N L ( W I , % , & )=o, ~~I
loc)fl~~(m~,
m2,&) dwi
=
0. (4.11)
Furthermore they predicted that
(4.12)
where the quantity C depends on the nonlinear properties of the medium as well as the strength of the pump beam, and can be calculated if some theoretical line model is employed. Scandolo and Bassani [ 19921 studied nonlinear absorption by analyzing the three-level model of atomic transitions. By using the nonlinear sum rules they explained the anomalous asymmetry in the nonlinear absorption line shape. Bassani and Scandolo [1992a,b] continued their work by studying nonlinear sum rules for atomic hydrogen and thereby to predict the nonlinear absorption spectra of atomic hydrogen. Vartiainen, Peiponen and Asakura [ 1993al applied sum rules for the third order nonlinear susceptibility of coherent anti-Stokes Raman spectrum of the nitrogen Q-branch. Sum rules were exploited in the context of the maximum entropy procedure. According to the sum rules it was possible to estimate the value of the background susceptibility, which is important in CARS spectroscopy. Sum rules for nonlinear reflectances, which may be interesting for instance in the case of the second harmonic wave generation from a metal surface (Bloembergen and Pershan [ 19621, Sonnenberg and Heffner [ 196811, and those for nonlinear magnetoreflectances have not been, as far as we know, described in the literature.
8
5. Conclusions
Mathematical methods for optical spectrum analysis were reviewed. KramersKronig (KK) relations have their origin in the principle of causality and are
92
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
[I]
therefore connected to fundamental physics. They have been used tradionally in data inversion of linear optical constants. The KK relations also hold in most cases of nonlinear optical spectra. The shortcoming of KK analysis is the need for data extrapolation. The maximum entropy model is interesting, in particular, for phase retrieval problems arising in both linear and nonlinear optical spectroscopies.There is no need for data extrapolation. Sum rules provide information about the microscopic properties of systems. Sum rules of general validity can be found for linear and nonlinear optical constants.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to express their gratitude to Professor Pertti Ketolainen for his careful reading of the manuscript. One of us (K.-E. P) is grateful to the Academy of Finland for financial support.
References Agudin, J.L., L.J. Palumbo and A.M. Platzeck, 1986, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 3, 715. Ahrenkiel, R.K., 1971, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 61, 1651. Altarelli, M., D.L. Dexter, H.M. Nussenzveig and D.Y. Smith, 1972, Phys. Rev. B 6, 4502. Altarelli, M., and D.Y. Smith, 1974, Phys. Rev. B 9, 1290. Aspnes, D.E., 1985, The accurate determination of optical properties by ellipsometry, in: Handbook of Optical Constants of Solids, ed. E.D. Palik (Academic Press, Orlando, FL) p. 89. Bassani, F., and S. Scandolo, 1991, Phys. Rev. B 44, 8446. Bassani, F., and S. Scandolo, 1992% Phys. Status Solidi B 173, 263. Bassani, F., and S. Scandolo, 1992b, Nuovo Cimento 14D, 873. Bloembergen, N., and P.S. Pershan, 1962, Phys. Rev. 128, 606. Bohren, C.F., and D.R. Huffman, 1983, Absorption and Scattering of Light by Small Particles (Wiley, New York). Born, M., and E. Wolf, 1980, Principles of Optics, 6th Ed. (Pergamon Press, New York). Bryan, R.K., and J. Skilling, 1986, Opt. Acta 33, 287. Burg, J.P., 1967, Maximum entropy spectral analysis. Paper delivered at 37th Ann. Int. Meeting SOC. Explor. Geophysics, Oklahoma City, OK. Caspers, W.L., 1964, Phys. Rev. 133, A1249. Collins, D.M., 1982, Nature 298, 49. De Alfaro, V., G. Fubini, G. Rosetti and G. Furlan, 1966, Phys. Lett. 21, 576. Ehrenreich, H., H.R. Philipp and B. Segall, 1963, Phys. Rev. 132, 1918. Furya, K., A. Villani and A.H. Zimerman, 1977, J. Phys. C 10, 3189. Furya, K., A.H. Zimerman and A. Villani, 1976a, Phys. Rev. B 13, 1357. Furya, K., A.H. Zimerman and A. Villani, 1976b, J. Phys. C 9, 4329.
111
REFERENCES
93
Goedecke, G.H., 1975a, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 65, 146. Goedecke, G.H., 1975b, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 65, 1075. Griindler, R., 1983, Phys. Status Solidi B 115, K147. Gull, S.F., and G.J. Daniel, 1978, Nature 272, 686. Haykin, S., 1986, Adaptive Filter Theory (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ). Haykin, S., and S. Kesler, 1983, Prediction-error filtering and maximum-entropy spectral estimation, in: Nonlinear Methods of Spectral Analysis, ed. S. Haykin (Springer, Berlin) ch. 2. Hopf, F.A., and (3.1. Stegeman, 1986, Applied Classical Electrodynamics, Nonlinear Optics (Wiley, New York). Hulthen, R., 1982, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 72, 794. Hutchings, D.C., M. Sheik-Bahae, D.J. Hagan and E.W. van Stryland, 1992, Opt. Quantum Electron. 24, I . Jahoda, F.C., 1957, Thesis (Cornell University) unpublished. Jaynes, E.T., 1957a, Phys. Rev. 106, 620. Jaynes, E.T., 1957b, Phys. Rev. 108, 171. Jezierski, K., 1984, J. Phys. C 17, 475. Kemp, M.C., I98 1, Maximum entropy reconstruction in emission tomography, in: Medical Radionucleaic Imaging 1980, Publ. IAEA-SM 247, Vol. 1 (International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna) p. 128. Ketolainen, I?, K.-E. Peiponen and K. Karttunen, 1991, Phys. Rev. B 43, 4492. King, F.W., 1976, J. Math. Phys. 17, 4726. King, F.W., 1977, J. Phys. C 10, 4726. King, F.W., 1978, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 68, 994. King, F.W., 1979, J. Chem. Phys. 71,4726. Kircheva, PI?, and G.B. Hadjichristov, 1994, J. Phys. B 27, 3781. Kishida, H., T. Hasegawa, Y. Iwasa, T. Koda and Y. Tokura, 1993, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 3724. Kogan, S.M., 1963, Sov. Phys. JETP 16, 217. Kramers, H.A., 1927, Estratto dagli Atti del Congress0 Internazionale de Fisici Como, Bologna, 545. Kronig, R., 1926, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 12, 247. Landau, L.D., and E.M. Lifshitz, 1960, Electrodynamics of Continuous Media ( h g a m o n Press, New York). Lee, M.H., and 0.1. Sindoni, 1992, Phys. Rev. A 46, 3028. Lee, S.-Y., 1995, Chem. Phys. Lett. 245, 620. Mandel, L., and E. Wolf, 1965, Rev. Mod. Phys. 37, 231. Martin, P.C., 1967, Phys. Rev. 161, 143. Matsumoto, T., T. Tanji and A. Tonomura, 1994, Optik 97, 169. Mezincescu, G.A., 1985, Phys. Lett. A 108, 477. Morse, P.M., and H. Feshbach, 1953, Methods for Theoretical Physics (McGraw-Hill, New York). Nash, P.L., R.J. Bell and R. Alexander, 1995, J. Mod. Opt. 9, 1837. Nussenzveig, H.M., 1972, Causality and Dispersion Relations (Academic Press, New York). Palik, E.D., 1985a, Gallium arsenide, in: Handbook of Optical Constants of Solids, ed. E.D. Palik (Academic Press, New York) p. 429. Palik, E.D., 1985b, Potassium chloride, in: Handbook of Optical Constants of Solids, ed. E.D. Palik (Academic Press, New York) p. 703. Peiponen, K.-E., 1985, Lett. Nuovo Cimento 44, 445. Peiponen, K.-E., 1987%Phys. Rev. B 35,4116. Peiponen, K.-E., 1987b, J. Phys. C 20, L285. Peiponen, K.-E., 1987c, J. Phys. C 20, 2785.
94
DISPERSION RELATIONS AND PHASE RETRIEVAL IN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
Peiponen, K.-E., 1988, Phys. Rev. B 37, 6463. Peiponen, K.-E., and A. Vaittinen, 1984, Phys. Lett. 103A, 209. Peiponen, K.-E., and E.M. Vartiainen, 1991, Phys. Rev. B 44, 8301. Peiponen, K.-E., E.M. Vartiainen and T. Asakura, 1992, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 4, L299. Peiponen, K.-E., E.M. Vartiainen and T. Tsuboi, 1990, Phys. Rev. A 41, 527. Press, W.H., S.A. Teukolsky, W.T. Vetterling and B.P. Flannery, 1992, Numerical Recipes, 2nd. Ed. (Cambridge University Press, New York) pp. 113-1 16. Price, P.J., 1963, Phys. Rev. 130, 1792. Rasigni, M., and G. Rasigni, 1977, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 67, 54. Ridener, EL., and R.H. Good Jr, 1974, Phys. Rev. B 10, 4980. Ridener, EL., and R.H. Good Jr, 1975, Phys. Rev. B 11, 2768. Roesler, D.M., 1965, Br. J. Appl. Phys. 16, 1 1 19. Scandolo, S., and E Bassani, 1992, Phys. Rev. B 45, 13257. Shannon, C.E., 1948, Bell Syst. Tech. J. 27, 623. Shen, Y.R., 1984, The Principles of Nonlinear Optics (Wiley, New York). Shore, K.A., and D.A.S. Chan, 1990, Electron. Lett. 26, 1207. Smet, F., and P. Smet, 1974, Nuovo Cimento 20B, 273. Smet, E, and A. van Groenendael, 1979, Phys. Rev. A 19, 334. Smith, D.Y., 1974, Conference of Colour Centres in Ionic Crystals, paper 118, Sendai, Japan. Smith, D.Y., 1976a, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 66, 454. Smith, D.Y., 1976b, Phys. Rev. B 13, 5303. Smith, D.Y., 1976c, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 66, 547. Smith, D.Y., 1977, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 67,570. Smith, D.Y., 1980, Dispersion theory and moments relations in magneto-optics, in: Theoretical Aspects and New Developments in Magneto-Optics, ed. J.T. Deversee (Plenum, New York). Smith, D.Y., 1985, Dispersion theory, sum rules, and their application to the analysis of optical data, in: Handbook of Optical Constants of Solids, ed. E.D. Palik (Academic Press, New York) p. 35. Smith, D.Y., and D.L. Dexter, 1972, Optical absorption strength of defects in insulators, in: Progress in Optics, Vol. X, ed. E. Wolf (North-Holland, Amsterdam) ch. V Smith, D.Y., and C.A. Manogue, 1981, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 71, 935. Sonnenberg, H., and H. Heffner, 1968, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 58, 209. Tokunaga, E., A. Terasaki and T. Kobayashi, 1993, Phys. Rev. A 47, R4581. Tokunaga, E., A. Terasaki and T. Kobayashi, 1995, J. Opt. SOC.Am. B 12, 753. Toll, J.S., 1956, Phys. Rev. 104, 1760. Van den Bos, A,, 1971, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory IT-17, 493. Vartiainen, E.M., 1992, J. Opt. SOC.Am. B 9, 1209. Vartiainen, E.M., T. Asakura and K.-E. Peiponen, 1993, Opt. Commun. 104, 149. Vartiainen, E.M., and K.-E. Peiponen, 1994, Phys. Rev. B 50, 1941. Vartiainen, E.M., K.-E. Peiponen and T. Asakura, 1992, Opt. Commun. 89, 37. Vartiainen, E.M., K.-E. Peiponen and T. Asakura, 1993a, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 5, LI 13. Vartiainen, E.M., K.-E. Peiponen and T. Asakura, 1993b, Appl. Opt. 32, 1126. Vartiainen, E.M., K.-E. Peiponen and T. Asakura, 1996, Appl. Spectrosc. 50, 1283. Vartiainen, E.M., K.-E. Peiponen, H. Kishida and T. Koda, 1996, J. Opt. SOC.Am. B 13, 2106. Velicky, B., 1961, Czech. J. Phys. B11, 541. Villani, A,, and A.H. Zimerman, 1973a, Phys. Lett. 44A, 295. Villani, A,, and A.H. Zimerman, 1973b, Phys. Rev. B 8, 3914. Wooten, E, 1972, Optical Properties of Solids (Academic Press, New York). Young, R.H., 1972, J. Opt. SOC.Am. 67, 520.
E. WOLF, PROGRESS IN OPTICS XXXVII 0 1997 ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
I.L. FABELINSKII PN. Lebedeu Physical Institute of the Academy of Sciences of Russian Federation, Leninsky Prosp.. 53. I I7924 Moscow, Russian Federation
95
CONTENTS
PAGE
INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
97
THE FLUCTUATIONS OF THERMODYNAMIC QUANTITIES
99
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR LIGHT SCATTERING ARISING FROM PRESSURE FLUCTUATIONS Ae(P). EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
102
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR LIGHT SCATTERING ARISING FROM PRESSURE FLUCTUATIONS A&(P).SOME NONEQUILIBRrUM PHENOMENA . . . . . . . . . . .
124
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR LIGHT SCATTERING ARISING FROM ISOBARIC ENTROPY FLUCTUATIONS A&(S) AND FROM CONCENTRATION FLUCTUATIONS A&(C) . . . .
132
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR LIGHT SCATTERING ARISING FROM ANISOTROPY FLUCTUATIONS A E ( ~ / K ). . . . . .
151
ABOUT SOME PROBLEMS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
177
REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
96
178
8
1. Introduction
Molecular (Rayleigh) light scattering spectra have long been known as an efficient instrument of both theoretical and experimental studies of various phenomena and their dynamics in physics, chemistry, and biology. They led to the discovery of several new phenomena and appeared to be usefbl for the solution of many applied problems. Light scattering can appear only in the case when the light flux encounters some optical inhomogeneities on its way. Optical inhomogeneities can be of diverse origin. They can be represented by water droplets forming clouds and fog, dust and soot particles in a haze or smog, colloidal particles in a liquid, or single molecules in a rarefied gas when the mean free path of a molecule is greater than the wavelength of light, A. Reviews of the investigations in this field are given in the books of Shifrin [1951], van de Hulst [1957], Kerker [1969], and others. In a condensed medium, free of any foreign admixtures (i.e., an optically “empty” medium), optical inhomogeneities arise from the statistical fluctuations of those physical quantities which lead to the fluctuations of the optical permittivity, A&.Light scattering due to such fluctuations is called “molecular”, or Rayleigh light scattering to underscore its difference from light scattering due to the reasons mentioned above or to combinational (Raman) scattering. Several books and review articles devoted to the investigations of molecular light scattering have already been published. Here we mention only a few that appeared earlier than the others - Fabelinskii [1968] (in Russian [1965]), Griffin [ 1968b], Fleury [ 19701, Fleury and Boon [ 19731, Chu [ 19741, Lallemand [ 19741, Crosignani, DiPorto and Bertolotti [ 19751, Cardona [ 19751, Cardona and Guntherodt [1982a,b, 19841, Berne and Pecora [1976], Dil [1982], BorovikRomanov and Kreines [1982], and Cottam and Lockwood [1986]. The foundations of modern ideas about the light scattered by optical inhomogeneities of the fluctuative origin, were laid down at the very beginning of the twentieth century and were further developed simultaneously with the improvements of the theory of a solid state specific heat - both, it appeared, were bound tightly together. The development of the molecular light scattering theory has proved to be so closely related to the theory of the specific heat of 91
98
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
[IIL § 1
solids that without much error, one could assume that both phenomena have a common origin. Since the history of the theory of the specific heat is of interest, I shall now briefly recount the principal stages in the studies which have been carried out. As early as the beginning of the previous century, I? Dulong and A. Petit (18 19) established an empirical law that under normal conditions the specific heat of any solid is C = 6 cal mol-’ K-’ , explained on the hypothesis of a uniform distribution of energy among the degrees of freedom. However, a discrepancy between the predictions of the above law and the experimental results for certain substances, especially at low temperatures, required an improvement of the theory. In 1907, in his theory of the specific heat of a solid, Einstein replaced the uniform distribution of energy among the degrees of freedom by a Planck’s distribution of energy among the frequencies of elastic vibrations. Einstein took here a qualitatively new step by applying Planck’s law, previously used solely in emission theory problems, to the theory of elastic vibrations. However, Einstein considered only the average effective frequency of the particles constituting the solid. Einstein [ 19071 did not discuss the problems of light scattering or of the diffraction of light by the elastic vibrations of a solid. A striking phenomenon, involving a marked increase in the light scattering in a narrow temperature and pressure range at a phase transition and called the critical opalescence, has long been known, it was finally explained correctly in 1908 by Smoluchovski as being the result of a strong increase in the density fluctuations in pure liquids and of the concentration fluctuations in solutions. In 1910, Einstein employed Smoluchovski’s fruitful idea of fluctuations in a quantitative calculation of the intensities of light in liquids and solutions. In this calculation, Einstein expanded the density fluctuations as a three-dimensional Fourier series. The determination of the amplitudes of these series makes it possible to calculate the scattered-light intensity. Einstein not only obtained his famous formula for the scattered-light intensity but also devised the modern method for the calculation of fluctuations of any thermodynamic quantity using thermodynamic relations together with Boltzmann’s statistical principle relating entropy to the probability of a closed system state. In his lengthy paper, Einstein says nothing about the specific heat of a solid. The component of the Fourier series are referred to as static “waves”. In 1913, Mandelstam superimposed surface fluctuation irregularities onto planar ‘‘diffraction gratings”; in this case, the surface “grating waves” are static. The next significant step was taken in 1912 by Debye, who tackled the still unsolved problem of the specific heat of a solid, especially at low temperatures,
111,
5 21
THE FLUCTUATIONS OF THERMODYNAMIC QUANTITIES
99
and developed in essence Einstein’s theory already mentioned above. In Debye’s theory, a solid is regarded as a continuous medium, but one having a finite number of normal vibrations equal to 3N (where N is the number of atoms or molecules in a sample) and with the minimal wavelength of the elastic waves, which is determined by the interparticle distances, while the maximum frequency is correspondingly equal to the velocity of sound divided by the interparticle distance. Debye says nothing about the scattering or diffraction of light by these dynamic elastic waves. It was not until later that it became clear the Einstein’s and Debye’s studies of the theory heat of a solid, and Einstein’s and Mandelstam’s studies of the theory of molecular light scattering deal with waves of the same nature. One can even say that the Einstein and Mandelstam Fourier components and the Debye thermal elastic waves are the same thing. It was not easy to understand this at the time the theory was proposed, but the realization of this identity has stimulated the development of optics and of molecular acoustics, and has led to the discovery of new phenomena and the appearance of new fields of experimental and theoretical research (Leontovich [ 19311, Fabelinskii [ 19681, Ginzburg [ 19721). The present review is devoted to some problems of the molecular Iight scattering spectroscopy in liquids and solutions which possess two critical points or a double critical point; to phase transitions; to nonequilibrium phenomena in acoustic paramagnetic resonance in the presence of a temperature gradient; to the hypersound amplification in piezosemiconductors subjected to a static electric field and also to the molecular light scattering spectra arising from the anisotropy fluctuations in liquids consisting of anisotropic molecules.
5
2. The Fluctuations Of Thermodynamic Quantities
In a continuous medium (7 << A, with 1the mean free path and A the wavelength of light), optical inhomogeneities arise as a consequence of the statistical nature of the motion of the particles constituting the medium. Different quantities characterizing the states of the substance may fluctuate. Only the fluctuations of physical quantities which lead to the appearance of an optical inhomogeneity in the investigated medium are significant for light scattering. These include density and temperature fluctuations, and - in their turn -the density fluctuations depend on the pressure and entropy fluctuations. Pressure fluctuations arise when particles with momenta somewhat smaller or greater than the volume-average momentum accumulate in a definite place and at a definite time while a fluctuation of temperature, (AT), or entropy, (AS), means
100
[W li 2
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
that particles with a kinetic energy greater or smaller than the value averaged over the sample have gathered in a certain small region at a particular time. Pressure fluctuations (AP)are quite independent of temperature fluctuations (AT) or entropy fluctuations (AS). This means that the statistical average products of the pressure and entropy fluctuations are zero. Considering the entire picture, we can assume that the scattering as a consequence of pressure fluctuations at a particular point in a sample and at a particular time is unrelated to the same fluctuations at another point in the sample at the same time. This also applies to entropy fluctuations. Consequently, in order to calculate the intensity of light scattered as a consequence of fluctuations of different origin, it is sufficient to calculate the scattering by one fluctuation and to multiply the result by the number of such fluctuations in the scattering volume. The integral intensity of the molecular light scattering is proportional to the mean square of the fluctuation, A&: I
- (A&’).
It is worthwhile to assume that A&is a function of a set of independent variables of pressure P , of entropy S and of concentration C (although we might consider A&to be a function of any other set of variables). In the selected case:
(ap)‘
(A&’ ( P ,S, C)) = (AP’)+ ap s,c
Er
(g):,c(AS’) + (ac
(AC’) ,
P,S
(2) because due to the mutual independence of S and C, APAS = 0; ASAC = 0 and APAC = 0. The evaluation of the mean square of the fluctuations of the thermodynamic quantities, that appear in eq. (2), being fulfilled with the help of a method first proposed by Einstein [1910] (see also Landau and Lifshitz [ 19581, Fabelinskii [1968]) leads to the following: \
kT
(AS’) - k p C p . V’ ’
(AC’)
=
CkT
v*ap,/ac’
I
(3)
Here, V’, ,6s, PI, T , and k are, respectively, the effective volume of the fluctuations, the adiabatic compressibility, the osmotic pressure, the absolute temperature, and the Boltzmann constant. The angular brackets denote averaging over the ensemble. Let us consider the case in which the effective dimensions of a fluctuation are much smaller than the wavelength A of the scattering light. One can make the approximating assumption that ( V*)1’3= ler < U 2 5 .
111,
5 21
THE FLUCTUATIONS OF THERMODYNAMIC QUANTITIES
101
The intensity of the molecular light scattering due to fluctuations described by eq. (3) is given by the following expression (Fabelinskii [1968]) for natural exciting light:
where I0 is the exciting-light intensity and L, p and 8 are, respectively, the distance between the scattering volume and the point of observation, the density, and the scattering angle;
I . ~ E2A4L2 ( L a r )u' do Tz k T 2Cpp (l+cos28), where u and Cp are, respectively, the coefficient of volume expansion and the heat capacity at constant pressure; 2
Ion2V ckT ( 1 + cos2 8) , Ic = 2A4L2 &)p,s dpl/dc where C is the concentration and PIthe osmotic pressure. Here, l a d and liS,are the intensities of light scattered by the adiabatic and isobaric density fluctuations respectively, and I , is the intensity of light scattered by the fluctuations of concentration. The overall intensity of the light scattered by the density fluctuations in a liquid is:
(
If one assumes that
(P$)L
=
(;g):
2
=
(P$)
T
9
and takes account of the familiar thermodynamic relationships
(the subscript S denotes throughout the adiabatic value of a quantity and the subscript T corresponds to isothermal values), then the familiar Einstein formula is obtained from eq. (7) (Einstein [1910], Fabelinskii [1968]):
I emphasize that the light scattered as a consequence of the density fluctuations and Ijs) and the concentration fluctuations is in all cases linearly polarized
(lad
I02
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
"9
3
for observations at the scattering angle f3 = 90" relative to the electric field vector of the light wave (this vector is in a plane perpendicular to the scattering plane). If the exciting light is linearly polarized in such a way that its electric field vector lies in the scattering plane, there is no scattered light ( I and I,) for observations at f3 = 90". The light scattered by, for example, the anisotropy fluctuations is depolarized, but this is due to nonthermodynamic fluctuations which are discussed below. However, it is possible to determine the contribution of the intensity of light scattered by the anisotropy fluctuations to the total light flux in the way it was done by Cabannes [1929], who used the depolarization coefficients of a total light flux A and the depolarization coefficient of light, scattered only by the anisotropy fluctuations p, both being easily measured experimentally. Cabannes' correction factor is:
In harmony with the theory and the experiment, the depolarization factor p = 6 / 7 if the exciting light is polarized arbitrarily, and p = 3 / 4 if it is polarized linearly (Placzek [ 19351). Consequently, the intensity of light, scattered by the fluctuations of pressure, entropy and anisotropy in a single liquid, and being observed at an angle of 90", according to eqs. (7) and (10), will be:
As was shown earlier (see e.g. Fabelinskii [1968, 1994]), the ratio of the integral intensity i of light scattered by the anisotropy fluctuations to the intensity I (eq. 7) for 0=90" is:
B = -i = A ( l + p ) I p-A As follows from the measurements of A, keeping p=6/7, the values of B are approximately 2 for benzene, 5 for CS2, and 13 for both salol and benzophenone, while they are 0.56 for acetone and 0.2 for ethyl ether.
5
3. Spectra Of Molecular Light Scattering Arising From Pressure Fluctuations A&(P).Equilibrium phenomena
In all these cases the optical inhomogeneities of fluctuation origin have been assumed to be static ("frozen") and independent of time, so that eqs. (4)-(7) and
111,
5
31
SPECTRA FROM A&(P).EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
103
(9) yield the integral intensity. Nevertheless, the fluctuations defined by eq. (1) vary as a function of time, like statistical fluctuations in general, leading to fluctuations of the permittivity, A&, or of the refractive index, An ( E = n’). They appear and are suppressed, appear again and are again suppressed, and so on. The mean square of a fluctuation, (A&’), or its root-mean-square, (A&’)”’, is thus a function of time. The exciting light (with a certain frequency q )incident on such a fluctuation is scattered sideways and the field of the scattered light wave is also a function of time. In other words, the time dependence of an optical inhomogeneity leads to modulation of the scattered light. The modulation phenomenon occurs in a wide variety of fields in physics, radiophysics and engineering. A theory of this phenomenon has been developed satisfactorily by Rytov [1940], Mandelstam [ 19501, and Fabelinskii [ 19681. In the case of light scattering, the modulation and the Doppler effect are the physical causes of a scattered-light spectrum differing from the exciting-light spectrum. Light scattering always occurs under the influence of exciting light, and is therefore a stimulated process. The theory of time dependence of the concentration fluctuations in a solution and of the density fluctuations in a liquid was developed in detail by Leontovich [1931]. Its results have been applied to the problem of the scattered-light spectrum and a formula has been obtained for the frequency distribution of the scattered-light intensity. Our ultimate aim is, in fact, to do this for all possible fluctuations, but for the moment we shall deal with the pressure and entropy fluctuations or the temperature and the concentration fluctuations. Naturally, the time dependencies of different fluctuations are different, in other words, the modulation functions @(t)are different. We shall designate by d i p ( t ) , di,(t), dic(t), etc., the root-mean-square values of the permittivity fluctuations determined by AP, AS, and AC. Suppose that the monochromatic light exciting the scattering is given by:
E
= Eo exp [i (mot
-
k . r)]
The electric field of the scattered light can then be described by:
E’ ( t )= E ( t )di ( t ) .
(13)
It is necessary to find the law governing the variation of @(t)in order to obtain a specific form of E’(t). The function @(t)or the average fluctuations, (AE’)”’, induced by the pressure fluctuations, are described by the phenomenological equations which apply to and have been formulated for the average values. For
104
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
[IN
§ 3
the pressure fluctuations in an ideal medium, that is free of losses and dispersion, this is a wave equation of the type:
& - U2V2@= 0.
(14)
Since any function of a known argument t - ( d o ) can be a solution of the wave equation (14), we shall proceed in the usual way and seek its solution in the form: @ ( t )=
cos (Qot - q . r - q),
(15)
where @o, Qo,q and r are, respectively, the maximum value of @(t),the angular frequency, the wave vector, and the coordinate, while u is the velocity of sound. Thus, in this case the modulation function @(t) varies in accordance with the cosine law and E’(t) can be readily determined from eqs. (13) and (15):
It follows from eq. (16) that there are two satellites in the scattered-light spectrum: a Stokes satellite with a frequency 00 - QO and an anti-Stokes satellite with a frequency wo+SZo; according to eqs. (14) and (15), the elastic wave frequency is 90= uq. The satellites arising in the course of the modulation of the scattered light are known in the Western literature as the Brillouin components. However, they were predicted independently by Mandelstam [ 19261 and Brillouin [ 19221. Mandelstam also carried out an experimental search for the phenomenon which he predicted. On Landsberg’s and Mandelstam’s suggestion, Gross [ 1930al joined this investigation and detected the Mandelstam-Brillouin (MB) components in a quartz single crystal with the aid of improved apparatus. Gross also observed the same phenomenon in liquids. It follows from the law of conservation of energy and momentum that:
where w, is the scattered-light frequency, 520 the frequency of the elastic (sound) wave, and k , and q are the wave vectors of the scattered light and the elastic wave, respectively (fig. 1).
SPECTRA FROM A&(P).EQUILIBRlUM PHENOMENA
105
k
Fig. 1. Scattering (diffraction) of light by an elastic acoustic wave representing the Fourier component of a pressure fluctuation. The wave vectors represent the exciting light (ko), the scattered light (k&, and the elastic wave (4).
Since Q/WOis small
one can put lksl M Ikol, while
Here, A is the wavelength of the elastic waves and 8 the scattering angle. The relationship between Qo, q, and u follows from eq. (17): 4nn . 8 u SZ,=uq= - n n - = 2 n - ~ s i n - . A 2 c
8 2
(19)
Hence, the shift of the frequency SZ relative to wo is proportional to the ratio of the velocity of sound u to the velocity of light c, as well as to the refractive index and the sine of half the scattering angle:
A _ u_ W
u c
8 2
- f 2 n - sin -,
(20)
where Am is the frequency shift of a ME3 component. It follows from eqs. (19) and (20) that the investigated sound frequency QOcan be varied between wide limits by varying the angle of observation of the scattered light from Q O = O for 8=0 to Q0=2n(u/c)uo for 0=180". For wo = 4 x 1015rad s-l, we obtain 520 M 5 x 10" rad s-' or f M 10" Hz for water, where u = 1.5x lo5 cm s-l and the green-light refractive index is n = 1.33. For diamond, SZO is an order of magnitude higher than for water.
106
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTEMNG OF LIGHT
[“I,
I3
It is thus possible to investigate sound waves of frequencies which may be varied by several orders of magnitude by varying the scattering angle. Studies at hypersonic frequencies QO>109-10’0 Hz are especially effective. The details will be given later. Elastic or sound and hypersound waves are the Debye thermal waves and their number is 3 N , where N is the number of molecules or species within a volume of a sample. These extremely numerous sound waves propagate along very diverse directions within a bulk sample and, at first sight, it appears that there is no hope whatsoever of investigating the properties of matter at any one frequency 520 with a wave vector q. However, this would be a premature conclusion. Figure 1 helps one to understand how this can be achieved experimentally. If a plane light wave with a wave vector ko is incident on a sample and observations are made in the direction of the wave vector k,, then in the same direction k , one can observe light diffracted by a grating formed by a standing wave with wave vectors &q which satisfy eq. (1 7) or Bragg’s condition. This condition can be formulated as follows:
0
2An sin - = A, 2
(21)
where A is the period of this grating or the wavelength of the sound, and A is the wavelength of light in vacuum. One may speak of the formation of a standing grating because among the many sound waves there are always some having wave vectors identical in magnitude but with opposite directions. An expression for the field of the scattered light (eq. 16) is obtained by taking account of the modulation of the scattered light. Using eq. ( 1 6), we obtain an expression for the time variation of the intensity: E ’ ( t ) E ’ * ( t ) = I ( t ) = I o [ l+cos(2Q0t-2q.r)], where I0 = ;(E;@O)~(see eqs. 13 and 16). Equation (22) shows that the expression for the intensity of the MB components contains a time-independent constituent equal to I 0 and, against the background of the constant intensity, there is an intensity which varies at a frequency 2520 FZ 2 x 10” Hz. At the maximum, the variable constituent is I o , while at the minimum it is determined by the constant constituent also equal to 1 0 . Thus, the overall maximum intensity is 210. Hence, in our idealized model, with no losses or dispersion of the velocity of sound in matter, the scattered-light spectrum of a liquid phase exhibits two MB scattering components arranged symmetrically around WO.In this model the
111,
5 31
SPECTRA FROM At.(P). EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
I07
MB components do not have a finite width; they are represented by a &function. For an isotropic body, such as a glass, one observes two MI3 components due to longitudinal sound and two components due to transverse sound. In the case of an anisotropic crystal, the formula for the frequency of sound QO or for the optical shift in the spectrum Am is (Chandrasekharan [ 195 11):
Here, ni and n, are the refractive indices for the incident (exciting) and scattered light, respectively. One quasilongitudinal and two quasitransverse waves (“fast” and “slow”) can propagate in any direction in a crystal, and the position of the MB components differ in the two polarization states of the exciting light and in the two polarizations of the scattered light, so that the total number of components may be 24, but - for certain polarizations and orientations of the crystal - it is possible to observe six components of the spectrum simultaneously. Figure 2 shows six MB scattering components. More information can be deduced from the scattered light spectrum if the function @(t)is found for a more realistic medium in which there are losses but the dispersion is neglected. It is then necessary to describe @(t)by the phenomenological hydrodynamic equation for the average values; i.e., the Stokes equation (Rayleigh [ 1894/96], Leontovich [ 193 11, Lamb [ 19321)
iii-u2u2@-ru2&=o.
(24)
Here,
r=-
K
-q+q/+-(y-i) P [43 CP
1
,
where q is the shear and q’ the bulk viscosity, K the thermal conductivity, y = Cp/C,, and C p and Cy are the specific heats at constant pressure and constant volume, respectively. The solution of eq. (24) will be sought in the form of an expansion representing a three-dimensional Fourier series of the type
Substitution of eq. (26) in eq. (24) gives the following expression for the components of the sum (26):
& + rq2& + u2g2@ = 0.
(27)
108
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT I
I
I
T2
Fig. 2. Spectrum of light, scattered in a quartz (SiOz) single crystal. 1'7 and Tz are the MB components corresponding to the slow and the fast transverse elastic wave; and L is that corresponding to the longitudinal wave. (Laboratory of LA. Yakovlev, Moscow University.)
The Laplace transform,
1
m
@(PI =
@ ( t ) exp (-pt> dt,
applied to eq. (27) yields the following expression for @ ( p ) :
where 1
6 = - r q 2 , Q; 2
= u2$.
111, § 31
109
SPECTRA FROM A&(P).EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
The time dependence in the modulating function @(t)is obtained from eq. (29) by the inverse Fourier transformation: @ ( t ) = @ (0) exp (-6t) [cos
(Qi- a2) t + sin (0: b2) -
t] .
(3 1)
When p is replaced by iw in the Laplace transform, the latter becomes a Fourier integral and then, if eq. (28) is multiplied by @(O) and it is assumed that (@ (0)& (0)) = 0, the result is the following expression for the intensity distribution:
Integration of eq. (32) over all the frequencies should give the intensity fad of the light scattered by the adiabatic density fluctuations (eq. 4). Hence, the normalization conditions yield
it therefore follows that
If 6 << szo
(35 )
then
It follows from eq. (36) that the overall width of a MB scattering component at half the maximum intensity is (6w),,
=
26.
(37)
I10
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
UK 8 3
Equation (34) was obtained in a different way by Ginzburg [1972, 19791. The factor representing decay with time can be expressed simply in terms of the amplitude absorption coefficient a, namely,
S = ao,
(38)
where o is the velocity of sound. On the other hand, the hydrodynamic theory yields the following expression for a:
a = -q2r , 20
where gives
(39)
r is defined by eq. (25). Substitution of eqs. (39) and (38) into eq. (37)
Consequently, if the molecular scattering spectrum is suitably recorded, it is possible to find the phase velocity of sound from the position of the MB components, while the sound or hypersound decay factor can be found from the halfwidth of these components. Thus, a new field of optical and acoustic research has arisen. The dispersion of the velocity of sound (Fabelinskii and Shustin [ 19531, Molchanov and Fabelinskii [ 19551) has been observed by means of such procedures, and hypersound relaxation and absorption process in liquids have been investigated quantitatively. Many phenomena also affect the intensity of MB components; but this will be discussed in detail below. 3. I . ELASTIC THERMAL WAVES AND EMITTER-GENERATED ACOUSTIC WAVES
It must be emphasized that the elastic thermal or Debye waves differ significantly from the elastic acoustic waves, which are generated by an emitter and are then injected into the medium being investigated. A plane radiation wave then generated is
A
= A0
exp [i (Qat - Qx)] ,
(41)
where Ao, Qa, and Q are the amplitude, the frequency and the wave number of the sound wave, respectively. If A = A0 at time t = 0 and at a point in space x = 0, then this wave is described by eq. (41) as time progresses and the wave propagates in the medium.
111,
P
31
SPECTRA FROM Ae(P). EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
Ill
If the medium suffers acoustic losses under these conditions, the implication is that the frequencies Q, or Q are complex variables. For example, we may assume that Qa =
QI + i s .
Substitution of eq. (42) in eq. (41) yields A
= A0
exp (-st) exp [i (521 t - Qx)]
(43 )
It follows from the last expression that the amplitude of the sound wave may decay as a function of time and, when account is taken of eq. (38), it can also be attenuated in space. It is easy to show that b represents the same quantity in eqs. (43) and (38) [Rayleigh [ 1894/96], Isakovich [ 19731, Landau and Lifshitz [ 19871). In the case of the elastic or Debye waves, the situation is completely different. According to the Debye [1912] theory an average energy hQ [exp (hQ/kT) - I]-' corresponds to each normal vibration and, bearing in mind that h W k T << 1, an average energy kT corresponds to each normal vibration in the MB spectrum. Hence it follows that at a temperature T the elastic thermal or Debye waves retain a constant amplitude A and therefore this amplitude (eq. 43) does not decay in the usually accepted sense. At a constant temperature T , the amplitude of the thermal wave is constant at any point within a sample and at any time, and it can be described in terms of a combination of constants, the velocity of sound, and the frequency interval. The natural conclusion from the foregoing considerations is that, having the MB spectrum at one's disposal and knowing the intensity distribution in the MB components, it is possible to find the decay factor of the sound wave, generally speaking in the range from Q = 0 to 52 = 2n(u/c)oo. However, it is worthwhile to emphasize once again that this possibility arises not because the thermal elastic wave decays, but because the modulating function for the time variation of @(t) includes as parameters quantities such as the viscosity, which determines the elastic perturbation losses, the frequency, and the elastic-vibration wave vector. Because of that, in some of the cases, one can identify an elastic thermal wave with a customary acoustic wave, and this is what we shall be doing, bearing in mind, what has been noted above. It is of interest to find the value of pressure fluctuations and the value of the amplitude of an elastic thermal wave that leads to the appearance of the MB components.
112
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
“11, § 3
The calculation of the value of [(AP2)]’’2can be done only approximately and it is based on eq. (3) where the value of the volume of the fluctuation V* stays undefined. This value can only be estimated on the basis of the following considerations. Because the media studied in this work are supposed to be far from a critical point, the scattering indicatrix has a Rayleigh outlook, and this means that a typical linear dimension of a fluctuation is much less than the scattered light wavelength 12. Let us suppose that a fluctuation has a spherical shape with a radius Y = 12/25 (Fabelinskii [1968]). Then for the value of cm3. For the temperature T = 300 K, cm we find that V’ = 3 x A =5x the hypersound velocity u = 1.5x lo5 cm s-’ and if p = 1 g ~ m - we ~ , can estimate: [ (AP’)] = 5 x lo6 dyne cm-2, which is equal to 5 atm. The internal or “molecular” pressure in liquids, which originates from intermolecular interactions, reaches enormous values lying between 1O3 and 1O5 atm. Supposing that the internal pressure is lo4 atm, one can see that the pressure fluctuations locally change the pressure in a liquid by a 5 x 10-4-th part of its average value. A rough estimate of the amplitude of an elastic thermal wave can be done on the basis of Planck’s formula. In our case, when hP/kT << 1, Planck’s formula transforms into the Rayleigh-Jeans formula: I/ (52, d P ) = (x2u3)-’ . 52’kT. d P = p P 2 A & ,
(44)
where p P 2 A & is the energy density of an acoustic wave. From eq. (44) it follows that:
A,R
=
[(px2u3)-’. kT d P ]
1/2
(45)
Equation (45) allows one to see that A,ff is proportional to the square root of the temperature and is a function of the velocity of sound u. For the numerical calculations, it is necessary to know the value of d P , which is somewhat undefined. The author supposes that for the calculation of the value of A,ff one can assume that the value of d52 equals the true value of a halfwidth of a MB component. For benzene, if we assume that u = 1.5x lo5 cm s-’ , T = 300 K and dSZ M 1 x lo9 rad s-I, from eq. (45) it follows that A,ff M 4 x lo-” cm. In the course of such estimates we can discuss only the orders of magnitude. 3.2. HYPERSOUND VELOCITY AND ABSORPTION
As already mentioned, the first effective application of MB spectroscopy was made by Fabelinskii and Shustin [1953] and Molchanov and Fabelinskii [1955]
111,
P
31
SPECTRA FROM A E ( P ) .EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
I13
in connection with the observation of the dispersion of the velocity of sound in benzene, carbon tetrachloride, chloroform, carbon disulfide, and then also in a series of other liquids'. The dispersion of the velocity of sound Auh is 0.01 1 for C6H6, 0.09 for CS2, 0.12 for CC14, and 0.135 for quinoline. To date, huh has been measured for many liquids. We measured the hypersound absorption coefficient a only after laser light sources became available in our laboratory (Mash, Starunov, Tiganov and Fabelinskii [ 19641). We found that a = 4.5 x 1O3 cm-' for benzene and a = 1.6x 1O4 cm-' for carbon tetrachloride. The technique used by us in the measurement of the dispersion of the velocity of sound and of the absorption coefficient made it possible to carry out a direct experimental test of a formula from the relaxation theory, developed by Mandelstam and Leontovich [ 19371, and to determine the relaxation time z of the bulk viscosity. For example, z = 2.7 x lo-'' s for benzene and z = 28.3 x lo-'' s for carbon disulphide. The relaxation time z has also been found for other liquids. One can say that the experimental studies described here have laid the foundations of a new quantitative method for investigating the optical and acoustic properties of matter in a wide variety of states, for example in the course of phase transitions in the critical region, in paramagnetic materials under the phonon "bottleneck" conditions, in magnetic materials, in piezoelectric semiconductors subjected to an external static electric field, in transparent and opaque insulators, in semiconductors and met?ls, and in viscous liquids and glasses. Naturally, this list does not exhaust the numerous applications of this method. The first reported spectrum of the molecular scattering of He-Ne laser radiation in benzene, will be considered as an example. This spectrum can be used to determine the amplitude absorption coefficient of hypersound and its velocity with the aid of eqs. (36) and (20) (fig. 3). The MB spectra also make it possible to investigate the propagation of hypersound in the region of the liquid-vapor phase transition as well as in liquid solutions. The temperature dependence of the velocity of sound near the phase transition in carbon dioxide (CO2) was determined above and below the critical temperature from the positions of the MB components (Cummins [1971]).
'
It is noteworthy that attempts to use the MB components for the determination of the velocity of hypersound had been undertaken much earlier (Gross and Khvostikov [1932], Rao [1937], Venkatesvaran [1942a], Sunanda Bai [1943]), but were unsuccessful; a positive dispersion of the velocity of sound, expected for a series of liquids, was not observed.
I14
"IL 5 3
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
Av, cm-'
Fig. 3 . Spectrum of light scattered in liquid benzene (Fabelinskii [1968])].
3.3. MOLECULAR LIGHT SCATTERING SPECTRUM AND ITS INTENSITY AT LOW TEMPERATURES
As a result of the investigations of Tamm [1930] and Ginzburg [1943], the formulae for the intensity of each of the two MB components have been derived:
From eq. (44), the overall intensity at 8= 90" is I (w- W )+ I (w + W ) = l a d and, hence:
The quantum-mechanical eq. (47) is valid for any temperature of the scattering medium. In the case when hQ/kT << 1, eq. (47) turns to the classical formula (4) for 8 = 90". If hQ/kT M 1, the classical formula (4) lacks sufficient precision and one must use eq. (47). The temperature limit for the validity of eq. (4) can be estimated to be T = hQ/k M 0.1 K , which means that the formulae of the theory of molecular
“1,
9 31
SPECTRA FROM Ae(P). EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
115
scattering of light obtained with the help of a classical approach remain valid ~ K. We also must note that as far down to extremely low temperatures 7 ‘ 0.1 as for liquid He y = 1.008, the isothermal values differ very slightly from the adiabatic ones. It follows from these examples that molecular light-scattering spectroscopy is effective in the study of various substances and various phenomena under wide variety of conditions. The method is universal. It affords optical and acoustic information, but one should not imagine that molecular light scattering spectroscopy constitutes a simple and easy way of obtaining fundamental results. This is by no means so. The method requires experimental skill and experience. Major and varied difficulties, which are far from easy to overcome, await the physicist in this field. Perhaps the most significant experimental difficulty is the low intensity of scattered light. Equations (4) and (5) make it possible to estimate the proportion of the exciting light scattered by fluctuations of various origins. It has been found that the proportion of the blue exciting light scattered in air, 4 x in molecular hydrogen, in quartz is as follows: 2 x crystal, and in benzene. Thus, the scattered light intensity, integrated - ~the exciting light with respect to frequency, lies in the range from l ~ l O of for liquids such as benzene. The difficulty for various substances to 1 x increases even further when this weak light flux has to be “spread out” between various frequencies and the spectrum must be recorded reliably. Another serious difficulty is the need to investigate lines with very different intensities over a narrow spectral range of -1 cm-I. There are other difficulties, but these will not be discussed here. More than 50 years ago Ginzburg [I9431 pointed out an interesting MB spectrum of He 11, where (apart from the usual longitudinal sound) yet another type of sound is propagated, so that four ME3 components should be observed in the spectrum: two due to the longitudinal sound, and two due to the second sound. The frequency shift of these components in helium I1 is A d w x 1 0-6, for the second sound we have A m l o x and the overall intensity is lo-* of the intensity of the exciting light. In 1968 I wrote (Fabelinskii [1968]): “However, the displacement of the components of the second doublet, called “second sound” is so small and its intensity so negligible that there is no hope of finding these components experimentally”. Lasers had only just begun to be used in the laboratory at the time, and in 1978, Vinen and Hurd [I9781 in their fine spectroscopic investigations obtained excellent records of the MB components for helium I1 at 20 bar pressure (fig. 4). Thus, my general “prophecy” has proved ill-founded. However for a normal pressure the MB components have
1 I6
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
AT=-10.86 rnK
. AT=-3.05 rnK
(c) Fig. 4. MB spectrum of liquid helium below the A point (a, b) at a pressure of 20 bar. The inner narrow doublet is due to second sound. The outer components are due to the first sound (c), The latter spectrum was obtained by reducing the pressure to 17bar. Only the components due to the first sound can be seen. AT is the temperature drop below the A point. The spectra were recorded by a Fabry-Perot interferometer with plane mirrors separated by 80cm. (Vinen and Hurd [1978], Vinen [1980].)
been obtained only for the usual sound. The results of Vinen and Hurd [1978] (see also Vinen [1980]) must be regarded as a record achievement. 3.4. MOLECULAR LIGHT SCATTERING SPECTRA OF GASES
The study of the molecular light scattering spectra of gases belongs to the class
111, § 31
117
SPECTRA FROM Ae(P). EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
of interesting and important problems. The study has an unusual history, which began mote than 50 years ago (1942) with the experimental search for the MB components in H2 at 100 atm, in N2 and 0 2 at 80 atm, and in C02 at 50 atm (Venkatesvaran [ 1942b1). This search was unsuccessful. The components were not recorded and it was actually claimed that the MI3 components should not exist. I did not agree with this claim and demonstrated, on the basis of elementary and qualitative considerations, that discrete MI3 components should be observed for hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, and carbon dioxide at the pressures used and for all the investigated gases (Fabelinskii [ 1955, 19591). If a medium can be regarded as continuous or, in other words, if the mean free path 1 of a particle of the medium is shorter or, better still, much shorter, than the wavelength A (eq. 21), then all the results referring to liquids also apply to gases, subject only to the condition that the attenuation of hypersound at a given wavelength is much less than 2n. If we assume that discrete MB components cannot be observed when the halfwidth of a component 60= au is equal to the separation between the maxima of the components and the central line,
60
=
V 8 A o = 2n-00 sin -, C 2
we can obtain the required criterion on the basis of eqs. (19), (20) and (48):
aA = 2n.
(49)
Thus, if aA << 23t, discrete MB components should be observed. The quantity a A can be estimated from elementary gas-kinetic data:
-
1 aA = A - , A
where a rough estimate yields A M 25 and this makes it possible to find aA under experimental conditions when the gas pressure is 50-100 bar (Fabelinskii [1955, 19681). If scattered light is observed for 8 = 90" at atmospheric pressure (7 M cm) and if a A > 1 , discrete MB components cannot be observed, but since aA < 1 at just 20 bar discrete components can be observed. This has been confirmed experimentally, although admittedly the first evidence for the existence of the fine structure in gases was obtained under the conditions of stimulated MB scattering (STBS) (Mash, Morozov, Starunov and Fabelinskii [1965]), but the
I18
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
"§
3
MB components were subsequently also detected in gases due to the scattering by thermal fluctuations (Eastman, Wiggins and Rank [ 19661, Greytak and Benedek [ 19661). Gases are suitable systems for experimental and theoretical studies because different regimes can be realized. For rarefied gases, when 1 >> A, the gaseous medium cannot be regarded as continuous - each particle scatters the exciting light independently of other scattering centers. The scattering spectrum then reproduces that of the exciting light, but the former is somewhat broader as a consequence of the Doppler shift of the frequency of the scattering centers migrating at thermal velocities. The Maxwellian velocity distribution is assumed. The scattered line half-width is then
where rn is the mass of a scattering center (molecule). The experimental results can thus be simply described in the two extreme cases. In the intermediate range, when 1x A, it is not difficult to obtain experimental results, but a quantitative theoretical description is no longer quite so simple. Here it is necessary to solve the Boltzmann kinetic equation. If the changes in the frequency distribution of the intensity I ( o ) are studied at increasing pressures, it can be seen how the Gaussian distribution becomes gradually distorted and, when 7 << A, is converted into a distinct triplet in which there are two MB components and a central (Rayleigh) line (see below). The first experimental study of the spectra of the molecular scattering of light by thermal fluctuations in gaseous Ar, Xe, N2, C02, and CH4 was carried out by Greytak and Benedek [1966] and was followed by other experimental and theoretical investigations (Hara, May and Knaap [1971], Boley and Yip [ 19721, Cazabat-Longequeue and Lallemand [ 1972]), in which the changes in the frequency distribution of the intensity as function of the gas pressure could be readily traced. Theoretical studies by Andreeva and Malyugin [1986, 19871 are of special interest. These authors predicted that a new picture of the molecular scattering of light would emerge when all three components can be seen clearly in the scattering spectrum (1 << A). When account is taken of the interaction of the translational and rotational degrees of freedom and the dispersion of the kinetic coefficients, a new section appears in the molecular light-scattering spectrum: it represents a narrow band with a maximum at an unshifted frequency resulting from a redistribution of the
111, 9: 31
SPECTRA FROM A&(P).EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
I19
intensity in the spectrum. At higher pressures, the new band is converted into the MB components. The redistribution of light in the spectrum is than complete. An extensive review of the work on the subject is given in the paper by Andreeva [1993]. Theoretical investigation of a Rayleigh scattering in a dense spin-polarized gas was performed by Andreeva, Rubin and Yukov [1995].
3.5. MOLECULAR LIGHT SCATTERING SPECTRA IN VISCOUS LIQUIDS AND GLASSES
The history of the spectra of light scattered in viscous liquids and glasses has been very similar to the history of such investigations of gases, in the sense that initially the MB components were sought in viscous liquids and glasses, but could not be detected. It was then decided that they should not exist, whereupon they were in fact observed and such studies have continued and have yielded interesting results. The first investigations were carried out by Gross [1930b], who observed the MB components in a quartz single crystal, but he failed to find these components in the spectrum of light scattered by a glass. The next unsuccessful attempt to observe the MB components in glasses was made by Raman and Rao [1937]. Other attempts to detect these components in the spectrum of light scattered by glasses and viscous liquids were likewise unsuccessful (Raman and Rao [ 1937, 19381, Venkatesvaran [1942a], Velichkina [1953, 19581). The studies were of a fundamental nature and the results seemed to be so reliable that it became desirable to explain this. Such an explanation was formulated (Rank and Douglas [1948]). Briefly, the explanation is as follows: it is well known that the halfwidth 6w of the MB components is determined by the absorption coefficient of the hypersound (eqs. 37,38) and this coefficient is proportional to the viscosity: ac( Q (eq. 39). Next it is claimed that the viscosity of highly viscous liquids P. The viscosity measured under static and glasses is enormous and reaches conditions is indeed as high as this and, accordingly to Rank and Douglas [1948], its enormous value broadens the MB components so much that they cannot be observed as discrete lines. If a viscosity of P determines the absorption of sound in glasses, then even a thin glass layer should not transmit sound waves. However, it is well known that this is not the case and that even high frequency sound passes through glass readily. The important point is that, even at low sound frequencies, the relaxation process renders the absorption of sound incomparably weaker than might have been expected on the basis of the viscosity at the zero frequency. The relaxation process also leads to the dispersion of the velocity of sound (Mandelstam and Leontovich [ 19371).
I20
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
“11,
P
3
This lack of knowledge or misunderstanding of the role of relaxation has been largely responsible for the long-lasting failure to observe the MB components in viscous liquids and glasses. All the above-mentioned experimental searches for these components in viscous liquids and glasses were carried out before laser light sources became available in laboratories, and for this reason the exposures lasted many hours and even many tens of hours. For a long time it has been unclear why, for example, the MB components are clearly seen in glycerol at 5O-6O0C, while in the region of the glass-transition temperature T, of the same glycerol it has not been possible to find these components. If one bears in mind that the relaxation process results in the dispersion of the velocity of sound and that at high viscosities and high hypersonic frequencies it can reach loo%, the velocity of sound is doubled. This means that the adiabatic compressibility, Ps, decreases by a factor of 4 and the integral MB component intensity (eq. 4) also decreases by the same factor. Consequently, the exposure must also be increased by a factor of 4. Under such conditions, exposures lasting many hundreds of hours are needed to observe these components. When this became understood, Pesin and Fabelinskii [ 1959, 19601 increased the aperture ratio of the experimental apparatus by an order of magnitude and discovered the MB components for a number of viscous media. Krishnan [ 19501 was the first to observe these components in fused quartz at 300°C at the A = 263.6 nm line in apparatus with a mercury vapour resonance filter. Flubacher, Leadbetter, Morrison and Stoicheff [ 19591 also detected the MB components related to longitudinal and transverse hypersound in fused quartz. They used a lamp operating on the basis of the mercury-198 isotope. These problems were examined in greater detail in my book (Fabelinskii [ 19681). Further experiments have shown distinctly that for viscous and extremely viscous liquids, the hypersound propagation velocity o and the amplitude absorption coefficient, a, depend on the hypersound frequency, Q, in quite a different way than they do for the liquids with a low viscosity (centipoise range). Below the relaxation region, for small r], a Q2, while for high viscosity, aInside the relaxation region the frequency dependencies of v and a are also different for low- and high-viscosity liquids. Above this region both parameters experience practically no frequency dependence while their value becomes extremely low or even reaches zero. A relaxation process is a process in which a medium approaches the equilibrium after it has been withdrawn from it. This statement is valid for any physical parameter, in our case - viscosity. The relaxation time, z, is the time needed for a parameter under consideration to become e times closer to
-
111,
5
31
SPECTRA FROM AE(P).EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
121
its equilibrium value. For low-viscosity liquids (e.g., benzene), the theories of Mandelstam and Leontovich [I9371 and Isakovich [I9391 are valid (see also Herzfeld and Litovitz [ 19591). But it became clear that for viscous media, the single relaxation time model is not applicable. Many authors unwilling to leave the equations of local relaxation theory introduced a continuous spectrum of relaxation times; i.e., f ( t ) . It is clear that having at one’s disposal a continuous function of a set of some parameters, one can describe the result of any experiment, but it appeared that f(t) was not a universal function and separate ones had to be introduced for longitudinal and transverse sound. Different functions were also needed for different substances. From here it becomes quite evident that this manifold of continuous spectra of z does not bear any physical sense. Still, experimental investigations of viscous liquids carried out at ultra- and hypersonic frequencies can be described by a single parameter. However, one must formulate the requirements (Krivokhizha and Fabelinskii [ 19661) for the desired theory. A version of such a theory was developed by Isakovich and Chaban [1966]. This theory was not a local one; it described the experimental results quite satisfactorily and yielded an a 12”2 dependence. The theory dealt with a single, and not an arbitrary parameter:
-
where p = (a/a,)Q,el, r] is the shear viscosity, and u, and 00 are the velocities of sound at extremely high and extremely low frequency limits, respectively. The variables a and a , are the absorption coefficients; the former stands for the total absorption and the latter for the absorption which is due only to the shear viscosity. At the basis of this theory lies the hypothesis of a micro-nonuniform structure of a viscous liquid that is believed to be composed of two components which differ by some internal parameter; one of these components is supposed to form a “drop” with distinct borders inside the other. The equations given by this theory describe the experimental results quite well, but the basic hypothesis seems less than completely convincing. Also, it appeared to be impossible to expand the results of this theory on the theory of molecular light scattering spectra. The attempts to build up a more comprehensive theory are difficult to understand, but there remains some hope for future progress. Before a complete and adequate theory of the amorphous state will be created, every step will require enormous efforts.
I22
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
"II,
5
3
There now exist many papers devoted both to the theory and to the experiments in the field and in particular to physico-chemical properties of silicate glasses and other viscous and glassy substances. Most are investigations of polymers and liquid crystals. Here we shall mention only a few papers devoted to the discussed problem: Gotze [ 19871 and Dembovskii and Chechetkina [ 19901. 3.6. LIGHT SCATTERING BY A TWO MEDIA INTERFACE
Light scattering at the interface between two media was predicted by Smoluchovski [I9081 and observed by Mandelstam [1913], who also devised a theory of this phenomenon, which was subsequently developed further by Andronov and Leontovich [1926]. These first studies involved the use of light that was not decomposed spectrally, and it was not until 1968 that the first experimental study of light scattered inelastically by the surface of liquid methane was carried out by Kayte and Ingrad [1968]. The development of spectroscopic studies of light scattered by a surface required devices permitting a marked increase in contrast within the spectrum. A high contrast in the spectrum is necessary in all spectroscopic studies, and this was well understood a long time ago. Thus Dufour [ 195 I ] was apparently the first to propose the use of one instead of two consecutively arranged interferometers (Houston [1927]), making sure that light passes through it twice. Although the advantages of this scheme have been demonstrated experimentally (Hariharan and Sen [ 196 l]), the low luminosity of the apparatus has prevented wide-scale employment of multipass Fabry-Perot interferometers. The situation changed radically when laser light sources and improved, weakly absorbing dielectric mirrors appeared in laboratories. Such apparatus has become available in numerous laboratories throughout the world largely owing to the excellent experimental studies by Sandercock [1970, 1972, 19821, who constructed numerous Fabry-Perot interferometers with a corner-cube (triple) prism for the turnback of the light beam and who used his apparatus in a wide variety of investigations. Multipass Fabry-Perot interferometers are nowadays manufactured in unlimited numbers by companies such as Burleigh and others. This has opened extensive opportunities for research requiring a high contrast of -109-10'2 and in particular that involving the determination of the spectra of scattered light modulated by surface waves of various origins. The study of elastic surface and volume waves, propagated in opaque media such as metals and semiconductors, has yielded particularly striking results. In such cases the volume scattering in one direction (into the bulk of a sample) is determined by the depth of a
111, I 31
SPECTRA FROM A E ( P ) .EQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
Intensity, arb. units 500
5
10
15
R M '
I
2
3
4
5
v, h i s Fig. 5 . Mandelstam-Brillouin spectrum of light scattered by a sample of GaAs with a ( I I I ) free surface. The surface wave vector q is parallel to the ( 1 10) direction, a=60", 1 = 5 1 4 S n m MBC corresponding to Rayleigh wave, pseudo-surface mode and longitudinal resonance are marked by RM, PSM and LR respectively (Aleksandrov, Saphonov, Velasco, Yakovlev and Martynenko [ 19941).
skin layer cm at the optical wavelength of 5 x cm) and by the crosssectional area of a light beam on the surface of a sample mm2). Thus the scattering volume is just 1 0-l' cm3. Furthermore, one must bear in mind that the intensity of the scattered light is maximal in the direction of the reflected beam, but one must also not forget that the intensity of the parasitic light, preventing determination of the scattered-light spectrum when the contrast is low, is maximal in the same direction. Examples of high-precision molecular light-scattering spectra are presented in figs. 5, 6 and 7, taken from the papers of Aleksandrov, Velichkina, Vodolazskaya, Voronkova, Yakovlev and Yanovskii [ 19901, Aleksandrov, Velichkina, Mozhaev, Potapova, Khmelev and Yakovlev [ 19921, and Aleksandrov, Saphonov, Velasco, Yakovlev and Martynenko [ 19941, respectively. A multipass Fabry-Perot interferometer is suitable for various experiments and is naturally widely used to solve various problems. Figure 5 presents the spectrum of light scattered by a GaAs (1 11) surface when a Rayleigh wave (mode) (RM), a pseudosurface wave (PSM), and a longitudinal acoustic resonance mode (LM) propagate along it. The vector q is parallel to
-
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
[III,
94
0 -20
-12
4
12
20
Frequency shift, GHz Fig. 6 . MB spectrum due to a surface Rayleigh wave in a Ge single crystal (Aleksandrov, Velichkina, Mozhaev, Potapova, Khmelev and Yakovlev [ 19921).
(1 lo), the light incidence angle a = 60°, and the scattering angle is 180”.Figure 6 presents the light-scattering spectrum of TmBa2Cu307, and fig. 7 the spectrum, originating from a Rayleigh mode of Ge.
0 4. Spectra Of Molecular Light Scattering Arising From Pressure Fluctuations A&(P).Some nonequilibrium phenomena 4.1. THE INFLUENCE OF A STEADY TEMPERATURE GRADIENT ON THE LIGHT-
SCATTERING SPECTRA
In all previous cases, it has been assumed that the scattering medium is at an equilibrium temperature identical at all points within the medium. However, about 60 years ago, Mandelstam [1934] stated that if there is a temperature gradient, the intensity of light scattered at a particular point within a body depends on the temperature at other points of the body. The distribution of the scattered-light intensity is then more uniform than the temperature distribution. Mandelstam predicted that this may be observed in solids and in liquids, while according to Andreeva and Malyugin [1987, 19901 this phenomenon with its interesting features should also be observed in gases at suitable pressures. In the presence of a steady temperature gradient, the scattering at a particular “point” in a sample depends also on the temperature of the neighboring regions.
SPECTRA FROM AE(P).SOME NONEQUILIBRIUM PHENOMENA
125
twin-free TmBa,Cu,O,~, Intensity, arb. units 140
k*
a1
'0011
120 100
anti-Stokes
80 60 40
a = 51.9" 20
I U U J ~ ~ L U ~ JVL ~ U ~-L~ Gu
jawr.
L I ~ ~ L L G I I I I ~EC) U L U C L ~ J
10 ~ C D C U L C U I U
uic
uppi
p i , UI LLLC
~ r g w c iicir, .
n is the normal to the sample surface, k , , k , and k~ are the wave vectors of incident and scattered
light and of an elastic surface wave respectively; a is the incidence angle, and E is the electric field vector of the incident light wave. The scattering angle is 180" and the excitation wavelength is 514.5 nm. (Aleksandrov, Velichkina, Vodolazskaya, Voronkova, Yakovlev and Yanovskii [1990].)
The effect depends on the shape and size of a sample, as pointed out by Mandelstam in his very first communication. Mandelstam [ 19341 also mentioned that the distribution of the scattered'light intensity does not reflect exactly the temperature distribution because the energy of the Debye waves, responsible for light scattering constitutes a very small proportion to the entire Debye spectrum. The physical nature of the phenomenon can be readily understood if one takes into account the fact that the scattering of light may be regarded as dimaction by a Fourier component; e.g., by an adiabatic fluctuation or an elastic thermal wave with a wave vector fq. A maximum of the scattered (diffracted) light is observed for exciting light with a wavelength A at an angle 6 when condition (21) is fulfilled (fig. 1). Fluctuations at the most diverse points within a given body generate an elastic wave with a wave vector q. Therefore, if a body is heated nonunifonnly, elastic waves or Fourier components with different amplitudes
I26
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
[HI, $ 4
arrive at the point of observation of the scattered light. For this reason, if the wave with -q differs in amplitude from the wave with +q, the intensity of the Stokes MB scattering component also differs from that of the anti-Stokes component. Following Mandelstam’s proposal, the problem of the temperature dependence of the scattered-light intensity in a medium with a steady temperature gradient has been solved by Leontovich [1935] for a specially derived model. For the scattered-light intensity he obtained a formula where a temperature gradient is taken into account. A more general case of light scattered in a nonuniformly heated body was also examined by Leontovich [ 19391. This problem concerns the energy distribution of elastic lattice vibrations and is solved in a similar way to the problem of the light intensity distribution in an emitting and absorbing medium. Here elastic heat waves, having frequencies in the range responsible for light scattering, are treated as noncoherent beams of various directions. The investigated case is the case of a crystalline plate infinite along the xy-plane and finite in the z-direction. The temperature changes only in the zdirection so that T ( z )= TO+ Cz, where C = ( T I- T0)il is the temperature ( T ) gradient and To corresponds to the temperature on the lower (z=O) face of a crystal and T I corresponds to the temperature on the upper face. For the functions A(z,b), which are proportional to the energy of elastic waves that propagate in opposite directions and determine the scattered-light intensity, Leontovich’s [ 19391 theory yields: ~c - . i , , a . z (A
[ l - (1 + r ) exp (-2az/cos 1 + r exp (-2al/cos
a) a)
for 0 < 8 < nJ2, and A(Z,a)=c(T-G${
1 - (I
+ r ) exp [2a (I z)/cos a] 1 + r exp (2a1/cos a) -
for n / 2 < z9 < n.Here, a is the amplitude absorption coefficient, determined by eq. (39), 0 is the angle between the direction of the temperature gradient and the wave vector of an elastic wave q, and r is the reflection coefficient. If for the directions of the two elastic waves we assume the angles to be and t9‘8, the scattered-light intensity will be:
111,
I 41
SPECTRA FROM A & ( P ) SOME NONEQUlLlBRlUM PHENOMENA
127
where D is a factor that depends on the scattering angle, but not on the temperature distribution. Equation (54) yields the scattered-light intensity dependence on temperature and temperature gradient. If 1998 > 0, then
In 1943, Vladimirskii suggested the use of difference in the intensity of the Stokes and the anti-Stokes MB component for the determination of the hypersound decay coefficient a. In fact, supposing z and I - z to be infinite in eqs. (52) and (53) and taking into account eq. (55), one obtains:
For the uniformly heated body, I , = Ias.One can find from eqs. (56) and (57): Is-Ias I
-
GCOSfi~- ( q V T ) 2aT 2aT '
where q is the unit vector in the direction of a wave vector of an elastic wave, and I = I s + Ia,.Taking into account eq. (39) instead of eq. (58), one obtains
Taking into consideration the above mentioned properties of the elastic heat waves, one can assume that the calculations of Leontovich [1939], carried out for crystals, can also be applied to liquids and to gases at proper pressures. The first attempt to investigate experimentally the scattering of light in a nonuniformly heated body was made by Landsberg and Shubin [1939], who investigated the scattering in a nonuniformly heated quartz single crystal illuminated with white light. Within the limits of an experimental error of about I%, Landsberg and Shubin found no deviation of the intensity distribution from that of a uniformly heated body, which enabled them to conclude that the absorption coefficient is a > 0.75 cm-' for the elastic wave responsible for the light scattering. On the other hand, since the discrete MB components are observed in a quartz crystal, one can postulate that (r < 5 x 1O4 cm-' . In any case, the first quantitative theory and the first experimental attempts to investigate the
128
SPECTRA OF MOLECULAR SCATTERING OF LIGHT
Th scattered
iLzzTC
Fig. 8. Schematic diagram of the apparatus for determining the MB spectrum of a medium with a constant temperature gradient. PM is a photomultiplier (Kiefte, Clouter and Penney [1984]).
light scattering in a medium with a steady temperature gradient were produced before 1940. During the next 40 years, there appeared only the theoretical note by Griffin [1968a,b] who was aware of the investigations of his predecessors. The problem did not attract other scientists' attention. Only in the late 1970s several independent groups of physicists published (nearly simultaneously) a number of theoretical papers devoted to the influence of the temperature gradient on light-scattering spectra in liquids and solutions. Among them are the papers by Procaccia, Ronis and Oppenheim [ 1979a,b], Ronis, Procaccia and Oppenheim [ 1979a,b,c], Kirkpatrick, Cohen and Dorfman [ 1979, 1980, 1982a,b,c], Ronis, Procaccia and Machta [1980], van der Zwan and Mazur [1980], Tremblay, Arai and Siggia [1981], Tremblay and Tremblay [1982], and Tremblay [1984]. Of course, this list does not cover all the good papers where the influence of a steady temperature gradient on the ratio of the intensities of the MB components has been studied. All these papers differed in the approach to the problem, but before the paper of Tremblay, Arai and Siggia [ 19811 was published (and even after that) the authors were not aware of the papers of Mandelstam [1934], Leontovich [1935, 19391, and Vladimirskii [I9431 and did not cite them. These papers were discussed in detail in my book, published in Russia in 1965 (Fabelinskii [1965]) and in the USA in English in 1968 (Fabelinskii [ 19681). The latter was known to Griffin [1968a]. Tremblay, Arai and Siggia [1981] included a short history of the problem in their publication. The theoretically predicted asymmetry of the MB components (see eqs. 5 8 and 59) was confirmed experimentally in a most convincing manner by Kiefte, Clouter and Penney [ 19841 who used water and fused silica as the samples. The schematic of their setup is presented in fig. 8 and the results in fig. 9. Study of the influence of a steady temperature gradient in liquids and solutions
111, P 41
SPECTRA FROM A.E(P). SOME NONEQUlLlBRlUM PHENOMENA
129
(@VT)/q*