PROGRESS IN LOW TEMPERATURE PHYSICS X
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PROGRESS IN LOW TEMPERATURE PHYSICS EDITED...
50 downloads
1317 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
PROGRESS IN LOW TEMPERATURE PHYSICS X
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PROGRESS IN LOW TEMPERATURE PHYSICS EDITED BY
D.F. BREWER Professor of Experimental Physics, Dean of the School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences, University of Sussex, Brighton
VOLUME X
1986 NORTH-HOLLAND AMSTERDAM. OXFORD. NEW YORK .TOKYO
0Elsevier
Science Publishers B.V., 1986
All righ1.r r1veriv.d. No purr of this publication may be reproduced. stored in a retrieval sysrem, or Irunsnrirred. in any form or by any means, electronic. mechanical, photocopying, recording t i i ofherwise, wirhout rhe prior permission of rhe publisher. Elsevier Science Publishers H . V . (North-Holland Physics Publishing Division), P.O. Box 103. loo0 AC Amsrerdutn. The Nerherlunds. Spccial rc,jiularions for readers in the USA: This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Cenrer Inc. (CCC). Salem. Massachuetts. Informarion can be obtained from (he C'CC' abour conditiont under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the USA. :111 olhrr c,opwighi yuesrions. including photocopying outside of rhe USA, should be referred l o rhe puhli.dicr.
ISBN: 0 444 86986 7
NORTH-HOLLAND PHYSICS PUBLISHING A DIVISION OF
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. P.O. B O X 103 1MK)AC AMSTERDAM T H E NETHERLANDS S0I.E DISTRIBUTORS FOR THE USA A N D CANADA:
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHING COMPANY. INC. 57, Vanderhilt Avenue New York, N.Y. 10017 USA Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publition Data
(Revised for vol. 10) Gorter, C.J. (Cornelius Jacobus) Progress in low temperature physics. (Series in Physics) Vol. 10 edited by D.F. Brewer. Vol. 10 has imprint: Amsterdam; New York: North-Holland; New York, N.Y.: Sole distributors for the U.S.A. and Canada: Elsevier Science Pub. Co. has imprint: Amsterdam, North-Holland Pub. Co.; New York, lnterxience Publishers. I. Low Temperatures. 1. Brewer, D.F. (Douglas Forbes) 11. Title. 111. Series. QC278.G6 536.56 55-14533 PRINTED IN THE N F n l E R l ANDS
PREFACE
In this tenth volume of Progress in Low Temperature Physics I have, partly, at least fulfilled the intention I expressed in Volume IX, to widen the scope of the articles. The quantum fluids theme still tends to dominate, as must be expected in Low Temperature Physics. Hence the article by Fetter on vortices in superfluid 3 He, which bear both similarities and striking differences to those in superfluid 4He. Hence also the article by Rainer, though of a very different nature, on the ab initio calculation of the transition temperatures of superconductors; it is interesting to recall the history of the perhaps more difficult prediction of the superfluid transition temperature of another Fermi fluid, liquid ’He, which was first much too high and finally an order of magnitude too low. Silvera and Walraven are particularly well known not only for their original experiments on spin-polarized atomic hydrogen but also for their persistent belief in the possibility of observing it, over a period of many years which saw discouraging failures. They were not entirely alone in their faith, but they seem to have pursued their aim against experimental difficulties with notable single-mindedness and conviction. Finally, Dahm’s article on charge motion in solid helium: not so obviously a quantum fluid, but a system in which the behaviour is a typical example of low temperature phenomena. As this volume goes to press, we have heard of the sad and untimely death of Professor John Wheatley, who contributed to both Volume VI and Volume VII of this series. He was a man of enormous energy and commitment, and had the unusual distinction of being awarded both the London and the Simon Prize. He is a great loss to Low Temperature Physics. As usual, I thank colleagues for their views on topics of particular current interest in low temperature physics, those authors who wrote the articles, and the publishers, particularly Professor Peter de Chitel, for their help. Sussex, 1986
D.F. Brewer
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS VOLUME X Preface,. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
v
Ch. 1 . Vortices in rotating superfluid 3He, A . L . Fetter . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
1. Introduction..
...
............................................... ........
3 4
3. General propertie 4. Vortices in supe
5.2.1. Singular and nonsingular textures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.2. Textures in low magnetic fields. . . . . . ...................... 5.2.3. Textures in high magnetic fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. NMR in rotating 'He-A. . . . . . .................................. on schemes ........................... 5.4. Other 6. Discussion. ..... Note added in ..... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
51 56 58 63
70
Ch. 2. Charge motion in solid helium, A . J . Dahm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 1 . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76 2. Background.. . . . . . . . . . . ......................... 2.1. Description of vacancies and isotopic impurities in solid h 2.2. Structure of ions . . . . . . . . 79 2.2.1. Structure of ions in liquid helium ............................. 79 2.2.1.1. Positive ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 79 2.2.1.2. Negative ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 80 2.2.2. Ion structures in solid helium. . . . ..................... 81 ..................... 82 2.2.2.1. Positive ions . . . . . . . . . . ..................... 82 2.2.2.2. Negative ions . . . . . . . . . ..................... a4 2.3. Experimental methods of measuring mob 2.3.1. Spacecharge limited currents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.2. Transient space-charge limited currents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 86
vii
...
\’Ill
CONTENTS
2.3.3. Time of flight techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.4. Comparison of techniques and the effect of crystal str mobility measurements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 . Ionic mobilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Early investigations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Mobility measurements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................... 3.3. Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................... 3.3.1. Negative ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1.1. Vacancy-assisted mobility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1.2. Surface adatom diffusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2. Positive ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2.1. Hole hopping . . . .......................... 3.3.2.2. Vacancy diffusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.3. Species-independent mechanisms . . . . . . . . . ................. ................. 3.3.3. I . Phonon-assisted ion motion . . . . . . 3.3.3.2. Motion by a plastic flow mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.3.3. Vacancy-wave scattering of charged defects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.3.4. Ions as quasiparticles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.3.5. Bound ion-vacancion complexes . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. Ion velocities in large electric fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5. Related phenomena . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.1. Ion-dislocation ring complexes . ....................... 3.5.2. Motion of charged grain bounda ....................... 3.5.3. Test for the collapse of the negative-ion cavity . . . . . . 3.5.4. Search for vacancy waves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.5. Motion of charged droplets of liquid helium through the solid phase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.6. Theory for positive-ion mobility in a dilute “He-’He solution . . . . . . 3.5.7. Theory for negative ions in an rf electric field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 . Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. General comments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............. 4.2. Helium three . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............. 4.3. Helium four . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............
.
Ch . 3. Spin-polarized atomic hydrogen. I .F . Silvera and J . T . M . Walraven . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............. 1.1. CJeneral . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I.?. Rose statistics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............. 2 . Single-atom properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............. 2.1. Hyperfine energies and states . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2, Electron spin polarization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. Magnetization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4. ESR and NMR transitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................... 3 . Interatomic interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
89 90 91 91 92 101 101 101 104 106 106 106 108 108 108 108
114 116 116 11Y
123 123
124 125
125 12Y 132 134
139 147
149 153 156 1.56 164
162 163
CONTENTS 4. Single-atom interactions with helium surfaces . . . .
ix
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 174 176
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177 181 182 . . . . . . . . . . 185 . . _ . . . . . . . 188 ........... 5. Experimental developments. . . . . . . . . . 189 189 189 ......................... 191 192 ....................... 192 e, vapor compression and 5.1.4.2. Wall confinement, wal 194 thermalization 5.1.5. Detection of H1.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1% 196 5.1.5.1. Bolometric detection. . . . . , . , . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 198 200 200 5.2.1. Effective rate constants . . . . . 5.2.2. Notation for rate constants . . ............ 20 1 201 5.2.3. General equations . . . . . . . . 203 5.2.3.1. Thermal escape. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 203 5.2.3.2. Decay of H i . . . . . . . 203 204 205 208 5 . 5 . Two-body surface 209 5.5.1. Deuterium . . . . . . . . . 209 209 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 213 5.5.2.2. The value of K ’ .. . . . . . . . . . . . 214 ......................... 217 218 218 220 ..................... 5.8.2. Impurity relaxation. . . . . . . . . 5.8.3. Relaxation and the boson nat . . . . . . . . . . 222 223 5.9. Electronic relaxation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.10. Nuclear magnetic resonance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 224 227 ...................... 5.11. Electron spin resonance . . . . . 229 235 6.1. Recombination , , , ..._.............. . . . . . . . . . . . . 236 6.1.1. Resonance r 239 6.1.2. Second-orde 24 1 24 1 255 257 259 6.1.3. Third-order recombination. . . . . .
CONTENTS
X
6.1.3.1. General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1.3.2. Exchange recombination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
259 262 6.1.4. Dipolar recombination . . . . . . . . . . . ..................... 280 6.1.4.1. bb-He recombination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 280 6.1.4.2. The KVS mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 282 6.1.4.3. The KVS mechanism on the surface . 290 6.1.5. Relationship to phenomenological experimental rates . . . . . . . . . . . . 294 6.2. Relaxation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296 6.2.1. introduction-Volume and surface processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 297 6.2.2. Spin-exchange relaxation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 303 6.2.2.1. Relation to the rate equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 309 6.2.3. Dipolar relaxation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 311 6.2.3.1. Dipolar relaxation-general ..................... 312 6.2.3.2. Nuclear spin relaxation in the bulk ga 314 6.2.3.3. Nuclear spin relaxation on the surface 317 6.2.3.4. Electronic spin relaxation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 319 7 . Thermodynamic properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 320 7.1. Ouantum theory of corresponding states . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2. Ground-state calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2. I . The boson case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 328 7.2.2. The fermion case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 331 8 . Many-body static and dynamic magnetic properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 334 8.1. Static magnetic properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1.1. Noninteracting gases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1.2. The weakly interacting Bose gas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2. Dynamical properties: spin-waves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.1. General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.2. Nuclear spin-waves in H i $ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 341 9 . Many-body effects on the surface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -346 9.1. Adsorption isotherms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 347 9.2. Two-dimensional supertluidity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 351 Y.3. Hydrodynamic modes of two-dimensional 352 355 10. Prospects for spin-polarized hydrogen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 356 1 0 . 1 . Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 356 10.2. Goals in the study o f quantum fluids. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 358 10.2.1. Compression of bubbles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 360 10.2.2. Traps for low-field seekers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 362 10.2.3. Traps for high-field seekers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 363 10.2.4. Two-dimensional superfluidity .......................... 365 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Ch . 4 . Principles of ah initio calculations of superconducting transition temperatures. D . Rainer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
371
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 . Many-body aspects diagram analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1. Technical preliminaries notations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
373 377 379
.
.
CONTENTS
xi
2.2. Classification and calculation of self-energy diagrams. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 383 3.1. Bloch-function representation ........................ 4. Band-structure theory and the electron-phonon interaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1, The electron-phonon coupling parameters 5 . Strong-Coupling Theory of the transition temperature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. The linearized Eliashberg equ 5.2. Calculation of T , from Eliashberg's equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Conclusion ...................................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
391 394 40 1 402 41 1 412 411 419 42 1
Authors Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
425
Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
,439
3. The low-energy equations
.............................................
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES
Volumes Z-VZ, edited by C.J. Gorter
Volume I (1955) The two fluid model for superconductors and helium 11, C.J. Gorter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Application of quantum mechanics to liquid helium, 11. R.P. Feynman . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Rayleigh disks in liquid helium 11, J.R. Pellam . . . . . Oscillating disks and rotating cylinders in liquid helium IV. 11, A.C. Hollis Hallett . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The low temperature properties of helium three, V. E.F. Hammel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Liquid mixtures of helium three and four, J.M. Beenakker and K.W. Taconis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. The magnetic threshold curve of superconductors, B. Senn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. The effect of pressure and of stress on superconductivity, C.F. Squire . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX . Kinetics of the phase transition in superconductors, T.E. Faber and A.B. Pippard.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Heat conduction in superconductors, K. Mendelssohn X. XI. The electronic specific heat in metals, J.G. Daunt . XII. Paramagnetic crystals in use for low temperature research, A.H. Cooke . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XIII. Antiferromagnetic crystals, N.J. Poulis and C.J. Gorter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XIV. Adiabatic demagnetization, D. de Klerk and M.J. Steenland . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xv. Theoretical remarks on ferromagnetism at low temperatures, L. Nkel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XVI . Experimental research on ferromagnetism at very low temperatures, L. Weil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XVII. Velocity and absorption of sound in condensed gases, A. van Itterbeek. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XVIII. Transport phenomena in gases at low temperatures, J. de Boer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I.
xiii
1-16 17-53 54-63 64-77 78-107 108-137 138-150 151-158 159-183 184-20 1 202-223 224-244 245-272 272-335 336-344 345-354 355-380 381-406
xiv
CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES
Volume I t (1957)
I.
Quantum effects and exchange effects on the thermodynamic properties of liquid helium, J . de B o e r . . Liquid helium below 1"K, H.C. Kramers . . . . . . . . . . 11. Transport phenomena of liquid helium I1 in slits and 111. capillaries, P. Winkel and D.H.N. Wansink . . . . . . . . Helium films, K.R. Atkins. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . IV. Superconductivity in the periodic system, V. B.T. Matthias . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Electron transport phenomena in metals, VI. E.H. Sondheimet . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Semiconductors at low temperatures, V.A. Johnson and K. Lark-Horovitz. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. The De Haas-van Alphen effect, D. Shoenberg . . . . IX. Paramagnetic relaxation, C.J. Gorter . . . . . . . . . . . . . X. Orientation of atomic nuclei at low temperatures, M.J. Steenland and H.A. Tolhoek . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Solid helium, C. Domb and J.S. Dugdale. . . . . . . . . . XI. XI1 . Some physical properties of the rare earth metals, F.H. Spedding, S. Legvold, A.H. Daane and L.D. Jennings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XIII. The representation of specific heat and thermal expansion data of simple solids, D. Bijl . . . . . . . . . . . XIV. The temperature scale in the liquid helium region, H. van Dijk and M. Durieux.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1-58 59-82 83-104 105- 137 138-150 151-186 187-225 226-265 266-291 292-337 338-367 368-394 395-430 431-464
Volume III (1961) Vortex lines in liquid helium 11, W.F. Vinen . . . . . . . Helium ions in liquid helium 11, G. Careri.. . . . . . . . The nature of the A-transition in liquid helium, M.J Buckingham and W.M.Fairbank . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Liquid and solid 'He, E.R. Grilly and E.F. Hammel 3 He cryostats, K.W. Taconis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. VI. Recent developments in superconductivity, J. Bardeen and J.R. Schrieffer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Electron resonances in metals, M.Ya. Azbel' and I.M. Lifshitz . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. Orientation of atomic nuclei at low temperatures 11, W.J. Huiskamp and H.A. Tolhoek . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX. Solid state masers, N. Bloembergen . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I.
11. 111.
1-57 58-79 80- 112 113- 152 153-169 170-287 288-332 333-395 396-429
CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES
X. XI.
The equation of state and the transport properties of the hydrogenic molecules, J.J.M. Beenakker . . . . . . . Some solid-gas equilibria at low temperatures, Z. Dokoupil .................................
xv
430-453 454-480
Volume N (1964)
Critical velocities and vortices in superfluid helium, V.P. Peshkov . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Equilibrium properties of liquid and solid mixtures of helium three and four, K.W. Taconis and R. de Bruyn Ouboter.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........... 111. The superconducting energy gap, D.H. Douglas, Jr. and L.M. Falicov . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Anomalies in dilute metallic solutions of transition IV. elements, G.J. van den B e r g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Magnetic structures of heavy rare-earth metals, V. Kei Yosida.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Magnetic transitions, C. Domb and A.R. Miedema VI . VII . The rare earth garnets, L. Neel, R. Pauthenet and B. Dreyfus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. Dynamic polarization of nuclear targets, A. Abragam and M. Borghini.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Thermal expansion of solids, J.G. Collins and IX. G.K. White . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The 1962 3He scale of temperatures, T.R. Roberts, X. R.H. Sherman, S.G. Sydoriak and F.G. Brickwedde I.
1-37 38-96 97- 193 194-264 265-295 296-343 344-383 384-449 450-479 480-514
Volume V (1967)
I. 11. 111.
IV. V.
The Josephson effect and quantum coherence measurements in superconductors and superfluids, P.W. Anderson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dissipative and non-dissipative flow phenomena in superfluid helium, R. de Bruyn Ouboter, K.W. Taconis and W.M. van Alphen. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rotation of helium 11, E.L. Andronikashvili and Yu.G. Mamaladze . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Study of the superconductive mixed state by neutrondiffraction, D. Gribier, 3 . Jacrot, L. Madhav Rao and B. Farnoux . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Radiofrequency size effects in metals, V.F. Gantmakher . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1-43 44-78 79-160 161- 180 181-234
xvi
VI. VII.
CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES
Magnetic breakdown in metals, R.W. Stark and L.M. Falicov . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Thermodynamic properties of fluid mixtures, J.J.M. Beenakker and H.F. P. Knaap . . . . . . . . . . . . .
235-286 287-322
Volume VI ( I Y70)
I
Intrinsic critical velocities in superfluid helium, J.S. Langer and J.D. Reppy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Third sound, K.R. Atkins and I. Rudnick . . . . . . . . . Experimental properties of pure He3 and dilute solu111. tions of He3 in superfluid HeJ at very low temperatures. Application to dilution refrigeration, J.C. Wheatley . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I v. Pressure effects in superconductors, R.I. Boughton, J.L. Olsen and C . Palmy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Superconductivity in semiconductors and semi-metals, J.K. Hulm, M. Ashkin, D.W. Deis and C.K. Jones VI. Superconducting point contacts weakly connecting two superconductors, R. de Bruyn Ouboter and A.Th.A.M. de W a e l e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Superconductivity above the transition temperature, R.E. Glover I11 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. Critical behaviour in magnetic crystals, R.F. Wielinga IX . Diffusion and relaxation of nuclear spins in crystals containing paramagnetic impurities, G.R. Khutsishvili The international practical temperature scale of 1968, X. M. Durieux . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1-35 37-76
77-161 163-203 205-242
243-290 29 1-332 333-373 375-404 405-425
CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES
xvii
Volumes VII-IX, edited by D.F. Brewer
Volume VII (1978) 1. Further experimental properties of superfluid 'He, J.C. Wheatley . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Spin and orbital dynamics of superfluid 3He, W.F. Brinkman and M.C. Cross.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Sound propagation and kinetic coefficients in superfluid 3 He, P. Wolfle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. The free surface of liquid helium, D.O. Edwards and W.F. Saam . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Two-dimensional physics, J.M. Kosterlitz and D.J. Thouless. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. First and second order phase transitions of moderately small superconductors in a magnetic field, H.J. Fink, D.S. McLachlan and B. Rothberg Bibby . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Properties of the A-15 compounds and one-dimensionality, L.P. Gor'kov . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. Low temperature properties of Kondo alloys, G. Gruner and A. Zawadowski. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. Application of low temperature nuclear orientation to metals with magnetic impiirities, J. Flouquet . . . . . . . . . . .
1-103 105-190 191-281 283-369 371-433 435-516 517-589 591-647 649-746
Volume VIIZ (1982) 1. 2. 3. 4.
Solitons in low temperature physics, K. Maki . , . . . . . . . . Quantum crystals, A.F. Andreev . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . Superfluid turbulence, J.T. Tough . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Recent progress in nuclear cooling, K. Andres and O.V. Lounasmaa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1-66 67-132 133-220 221-288
Volume fX (1986) 1. Structure, distributions and dynamics of vortices in helium 11, W.I. Glaberson and R.J. Donnelly . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. The hydrodynamics of superfluid 3He, H.E. Hall and J.R. Hook ...................................... 3. Thermal and elastic anomalies in glasses at low temperatures, s. Hunklinger and A.K. Raychaudhuri . . . . . . . . . .
1-142 143-264 265-344
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CHAPTER 1
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 3He* BY
Alexander L. FETTER Institute of Theoretical Physics, Department of Physics Stanford University, Stanford, C A 94305, USA
*Research supported in part by the National Science Foundation, under Grant No. DMR-81-18386.
Progress in Low Ternperorwe Physics, Volume X Edited by D.F. Brewer 0Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., 1986 1
Contents I . Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Vortices in rotating superfluid 'H 3. General properties of superfluid 4. Vortices in superfiuid 'He-B.. . . 4.1. Structure of an individual vortex line. . . . . . ..............
4.3. NMR in a rotating container 5. Vortices in superfluid 'He-A . . .
5.3. NMR in rotating 'He-A , . 5.4. Other detection schemes . . . . . . . . 6. Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
69
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
70
2
1. Introduction
Since the original suggestion by Onsager (1949) and Feynman (1955) that vortices in superfluid 4He should be quantized, experimentalists and theorists have studied their properties in great detail. It is particularly appropriate that this series reviews the current status of vortices in rotating superfluid 3He, because Feynman’s original article appeared in the first volume of this series. Subsequent volumes have also contained many related articles (Vinen 1961, Peshkov 1964, Anderson, 1967, Andronikashvili and Mamaladze 1967, Langer and Reppy 1970, Tough, 1982). However, all these articles have considered only 4He or superconductors, and the present review will deal rincipally with the newer and more exotic case of vortices in superfluid He. The essential content of Feynman’s suggestion involves two specific points. First, the idea of some sort of order parameter that characterizes the state of the superfluid condensate. In the familiar case of superfluid 4 He or a superconductor, this order parameter is a single complex amplitude. For superfluid 3He, the order parameter is much more complicated, which accounts for the subject’s fascination. In general, the order parameter varies smoothly in space, but it may have singularities or defects, where its value is not defined. The vortex core will be seen as a particular example of a line defect, which connects it directly to one area of current and active research in modern condensed-matter physics (Mermin 1979). Second, the idea that the order parameter must be a single-valued function of position; in particular, it must return to the same value if one traverses a closed path in the fluid. As will be seen below, this requirement immediately yields the quantization of circulation in superfluid 4He, and the corresponding quantization of magnetic flux in a superconductor. Similar properties hold for superfluid 3He, but they are considerably more complicated than those for 4He. During the 1960s, many important experiments clarified the properties of vortices in 4He. By the early 1970s, however, the subject became less active, and many low-temperature experimentalists turned to superfluid 3 He after its discovery in 1972 at Cornell (Osheroff et al. 1972). Correspondingly, theorists concentrated on the new superfluid, which offered unique possibilities. Although the question of vortices and rotating
s
3
4
A.L. FETTER
[Ch. 1 , 02
superfluid 3He had been raised soon after the original discovery, it was not until the early 1980s that such experiments were performed at the Helsinki University of Technology. Even the first preliminary data showed a much richer variety of phenomena than had been generally expected, and close interplay between theory and experiment has been essential in unravelling this fascinating subject (which is now largely, but not wholly, understood). The present review will concentrate on the static properties of vortices, which have been explored in considerable detail. In contrast, the dynamical behavior has not been widely studied experimentally or theoretically. This situation is similar to that for rotating 4He, where the clear picture of equilibrium properties contrasts with the uncertainty concerning nonequilibrium phenomena. Even the simplest question of vortex nucleation remains unanswered in detail, and it will doubtless require considerable effort before similar problems concerning 3He are solved. This review will start with a brief summary (section 2) of the properties of vortices in 4He to provide a basis for comparison with the more complicated situation in 3He. Section 3 reviews the relevant general properties of this superfluid, including the order parameter and the Ginzburg-Landau (GL) description. Section 4 then describes the vortices in the B phase, which are more like to those in superfluid 4He; in particular, they both have irrotational flow outside the vortex core. Vortices in the A phase are considered in section 5 , where the question of nonsingular and singular vortices is studied in detail. 2. Vortices in rotating superfluid 4He
When liquid ‘He is cooled below T, = 2 . 2 K , it undergoes a phase transition to a new ordered state that acts like a mixture of two interpenetrating components-the normal fluid with density p, and finite viscosity, and the superfluid with density p, and zero viscosity. This behavior represents a second-order transition, in which the order appears continuously as the temperature falls below T,. It reflects the onset of Bose condensation, in which a finite fraction of the particles starts to occupy the lowest single-particle state. As in an ideal Bose gas, this ordering is best characterized by an effective single-particle wave function T(r) = lly(r)l exp[i@(r)], which here becomes the order parameter. Since this function is complex, it has both a magnitude I T1 and a phase @. For a bulk uniform system, the magnitude is fixed by the temperature, but the phase remains a free parameter. Thus the order parameter in superfluid ‘He has, in effect, one scalar degree of freedom, analogous to the angle that specifies the position on a circle.
Ch. 1 , 62)
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 3He
5
In a uniform sample, the phase is a spatial constant, and all values from 0 to 27r are equivalent, producing a set of degenerate states. Slow spatial variations in @constitute low-energy excited states, similar to spin waves in a ferromagnet. In analogy with the usual quantum mechanics of oneparticle states, the free-energy density associated with nonuniform states is taken in the form IVFI’, which has contributions both from changes in the magnitude (Vl’PI)’ and in the phase I?P1*(V@)’. In the particularly simple case of a plane wave, where ly 0: exp[ik * r] the phase is just k. r. Thus the velocity associated with the ordered state (namely the superfluid velocity u s )obeys the relation us= p/m, = hk/m, = (h/m,)V@. This last form holds in general, leading to the identification us= (fL/m,)V@
.
(2.1)
Thus us is determined by the local properties of the order parameter. An equivalent and useful viewpoint is to consider two nearby points at r and r + Sr. The change in phase in moving from one point to the other is proportional to Sr, with the coefficient defining us through
The usual relation for the gradient of a scalar function then reproduces eq. (2.1). Note that the free-energy density also has the expected form, with a contribution ;p,u:, where p, is proportional to (P(’. Equation (2.1) has several important consequences: (1) In any local region where V@ is bounded, the superfluid velocity is irrotational curl us= 0 ,
(2.3)
the only exception being singularities where the phase is not defined, (2) The superfluid circulation about some closed path C is h/m, times the change in phase about C . Since the order parameter must be single-valued throughout the fluid, this change in phase must be an integer p times 27r, leading to the familiar quantization of superfluid circulation in units of a fundamental quantum K = h/m, = cm’/s,
where p is any positive or negative integer, or zero. Equivalently, p is the winding number of the phase angle associated with the contour C ;if p differs from 0, then @ must have a singularity somewhere in C.
[Ch. 1 , 82
A.L. FE’ITER
6
The simplest example is to take @ = ~ I # J + Go, where # is the azimuthal angle of cylindrical-polar coordinates. From eq. (2. l ) , the corresponding superfluid velocity becomes us= ( pfi /m4& ,
(2.5)
which characterizes a p-fold quantized vortex line on the symmetry axis. This configuration is generally visualized by drawing circular streamlines of the velocity field, but a more precise representation is to draw a field of unit vectors oriented at the local angle @ with respect to some fixed direction. Figure 1 illustrates this situation for the cases p = 2 1 ; note that an additive constant does not affect us, so that all three cases for p = 1 represent the same flow despite their very different appearances. In the presence of such a quantized vortex, the free-energy density is proportional to the quantity I?PI’(plr)’. Since us becomes infinite as r - 0, the magnitude of the order parameter \!PI must vanish at that point, and the balance between the various energies determines the coherence length (, which is the characteristic size of the vortex core. For a singly quantized vortex with p 2 = 1, this magnitude increases linearly inside the region r 6 (, and assumes its asymptotic value for r + m . The total energy associated with the vortex is largely the kinetic energy of circulating superflow; use of the approximate energy density f, = p p f leads to the energy per unit length of vortex line mps(pfrlm4)2ln(a/(), where the logarithmic divergence has been cut off at 6 (near the core) and at some
4
/I\
\I/ (Cl
(d l
Fig. 1. Phase-angle representation of vortices, (a), (b) and (c) all represent p = +1 vortices, (d) represents a p = - 1 vortex (Fetter et al. 1983, reprinted by permission of the authors and the American Physical Society).
Ch. 1 , $21
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
7
large distance a. It is clear that the order parameter is not well-defined at the center of the vortex, since the phase @depends on how one approaches the axis. Thus this state constitutes a singularity or defect, associated with the node in the order parameter. In 4He, the simple complex scalar form of 'Pensures that it must vanish at the center, because there are no other ways to avoid a divergent energy. In superfluid 3He, in contrast, the much more complicated form of the order parameter allows many different possible forms for the vortex core. Vortices in superfluid 4He can be created in various ways, such as the passage of heat currents o r ions through the sample. In the present context, however, the most important method is to rotate the fluid. In this case, the normal fluid executes solid-body rotation with
where d2 is the angular velocity of the container; this normal flow has vorticity 2a,and it is readily proved to minimize the associated free energy (see below). In contrast, the superfluid must remain irrotational and hence, cannot assume the same equilibrium flow as the normal fluid. Instead, it forms an array of singly quantized vortex lines, aligned parallel to 0. To verify these assertions, consider a rigid container rotating with angular velocity 0. Since the walls are microscopically rough, a true equilibrium state can be described only in the rotating frame, since, otherwise, the walls constitute a time-dependent perturbation. In this noninertial frame, the free-energy density f differs from that in the laboratory by a term whose integral is a - L , where L is the total angular momentum. If f is the original free-energy density [it contains the hydrodynamic contributions k(pnu: + p,uf), as well as any additional quantum mechanical contributions arising from (VlPI)'], then
f=f-a-(rxj),
(2.7)
where the total current is
It follows directly that the minimum of f with respect to u, occurs for solid-body rotation. Simple manipulations allow f to be rewritten as
where additional (nonhydrodynamic) terms have been omitted. The last
x
[Ch. 1, 12
A.L. FEITEK
term here leads to an additive constant that depends only on the shape and angular velocity of the container; it will henceforth be omitted. The minimization of the free energy f’ with respect to the superfluid velocity is equivalent to minimizing the mean-square difference (u, - u , , ) ~ ; equivalently. eq. (2.6) shows that us- u, is just the transformed superfluid velocity as seen in the rotating frame. Since u, is irrotational, this quantity cannot vanish everywhere, and the superfluid instead mimics solid-body rotation by forming a uniform array of rectilinear vortices parallel to the rotation axis. If Cis a contour encircling Nc vortices in an area A c, then eqs. (2.1) and (2.3) show that
f
(2.10)
u;ds=p~N,.
To minimize the free energy in the rotating frame, eq. (2.10) must also equal the line integral of u, around the same contour. By Stokes’ theorem, this quantity is just 2f2A,-, which then gives the mean vortex density (2.11) proportional to the angular velocity R. Experiments on rotating 4He indicate that only singly quantized vortices occur ( p = l), with a vortex density about 2000cm-’ for an angular speed of 1 rad/s. Thus the intervortex spacing (of order 100pm for this typical rotation speed) far exceeds the core size (a few A ) for any conceivable experiment. For sufficiently slow rotation, the intervortex separation can exceed the linear dimensions of the container, and the superflow then remains irrotational everywhere. Indeed, for a slowly rotating circular cylinder, the superfluid is stationary, since the rotating walls exert no force on the nonviscous component. This situation persists up to a critical angular velocity l&, [ = ( h / m , R ’ ) ln(R/() for a circular container of radius R]. Above R,, , the system makes a sequence of discrete transitions between states with increasing number of vortices, and, for R @, , it behaves like an unbounded fluid. Since Ocl is usually very small, this latter limit is the most important in practice. It also follows quite generally that l2 4 O,, (=h/2m45’ = 10” rad/s), defined as the angular velocity where the vortex cores start to overlap. The preceding considerations are independent of the particular arrangement of the vortices. In an infinite system, they form a lattice that rotates rigidly with the container (this rigid motion must hold for any equilibrium configuration. since, otherwise. the mutual friction bctween the normal
*
Ch. 1. 92)
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 3He
Y
and superfluid components produces dissipative drag forces on the vortices). Tkachenko (1965) has studied the phase function @ of the order parameter for such lattices. Since each vortex moves with the local superfluid velocity at that point, this overall rotation in the lab frame implies that neither V@(= u s ) nor @ itself can be a periodic function of position. The net rotation can be eliminated, however, by transforming to the rotating frame, where the lattice appears stationary. Hence the quantity us- u, is a periodic function throughout the vortex lattice, and it is sufficient to consider a unit cell containing only a single vortex (assuming a Bravais lattice of p-fold quantized vortices). If A, is the area of the cell, it follows from eq. (2.11) that the function
V@
- (.rrp/A,)z^ X
r = (m,/h)(u,
(2.12)
- u,)
is periodic; it depends solely on the properties of @. As a corollary, the free-energy density in the rotating frame also is a periodic function with the symmetry of the lattice, and it suffices to treat only a single unit cell. For simplicity, consider an equivalent circular Wigner-Seitz (WS) cell with area A, = nV-’= .rrpfi/m,R = p ~ l 2 R,
(2.13a)
and radius
Inside this cell, the true relative velocity is approximated by an axisymmetric flow us- u, = ub, where -1
u = fip/m4r - Rr = (hp/rn,)(r
- r/a,2).
(2.14)
Note that u = O on the boundary of the WS cell. The resulting hydrodynamic contribution to the free energy per unit cell is easily found to be
F,
=
I
d2r f = .rrps(ph/m4)2[ln(a,/~) -
$1
C
= ( p , p2K2/47r)[ln(ac/() -
$1 ,
(2.15)
where the integral has been cut off at r = ( to avoid a divergence in the core. Tkachenko (1965) has shown that the exact result for square and triangular lattices differs by only.smal1 corrections, and that the triangular lattice is the stable configuration.
10
A.L. FETTER
[Ch. 1. $3
3. General properties of superfluid ’He
In the boson system ‘He, the order parameter is related to the condensate amplitude. Such a direct interpretation cannot apply to fermion systems because of the Pauli principle. Nevertheless, the evident similarities between superfluid ‘He and metallic superconductors stimulated the introduction of corresponding effective order parameters to characterize the condensation of superconducting electrons. The precise meaning of this order parameter became clear with the discovery of Cooper pairing and the subsequent BCS theory of superconductivity. Under the influence of a weak attractive interaction, two particles near the Fermi surface in a degenerate Fermi system can form a bound state (the Cooper pair). In metals, the spin $ electrons combine in a singlet state (total spin zero) [except, perhaps, for certain exotic “heavy fermion” systems, where triplet, p-wave pairing has been suggested (see, for example, Stewart 1984)j. The antisymmetry of the electron wave function then requires that the pairing occurs in even relative orbital states, and all experiments suggest that the pairing is, in fact, in s-waves. As a result, the amplitude for the Cooper pairs in metals has no internal degrees of freedom (since L and S both are zero) and can be represented by a single complex function, closely analogous to that for ‘He. Although the detailed behavior of superconductors is complicated by the presence of the electronic charge, one class of superconductors (type-11) indeed behaves very much like superfluid ‘He. Since particle currents in a superconductor are also electrical currents, the resulting vortices are magnetic, with the quantization of circulation replaced by the quantization of magnetic flux. Furthermore, vortices in superconductors appear in response to an applied magnetic field, which is the electromagnetic analog of rotation in the neutral system (as is familiar from Larmor’s theorem). Many experiments have demonstrated that these flux lines generally form triangular arrays, as is the case for 4He. One important difference. however, is the coherence length, which is typically hundreds of 8, in type-I1 superconductors, instead of the few A in ‘He. Since the flux-line density is proportional to the applied magnetic field [see eq. (2.11) for the similar effect of angular velocity], the cores of the flux lines will overlap when the intervortex separation is comparable to the coherence length; such fields, which are readily attainable in many cases, drive the system normal. In contrast, the corresponding angular velocities for rotating ‘He are of order 10’’ rad/s. so that those vortices always constitute a lowdensity system. The discovery of new ultra-low-temperature phases of 3He in 1972
Ch. 1, 83)
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
11
(Osheroff et al. 1972) stimulated an enormous effort to identify them and to understand their properties (see, for example, Leggett 1975, Wheatley 1975, Anderson and Brinkman 1978, Lee and Richardson 1978). Below 2.7 mK, the system entered a new phase, accompanied by a specific-heat anomaly reminiscent of that seen in metallic superconductors. Since the interatomic potential between He atoms has a strong short-range repulsive core, Cooper pairing was not expected in relative s-waves, and various authors had suggested either p-wave pairing or d-wave pairing. The observed magnetic properties of the new phases could not readily be explained by singlet Cooper pairs, however, so that triplet pairing (S = 1) was rapidly accepted. The Pauli principle then requires an odd orbital state, and all present evidence confirms that superfluid 3He consists of triplet p-wave Cooper pairs, with S = 1 and L = 1. The presence of internal quantum numbers associated with the unit spin and orbital angular momenta means that superfluid 3He has a much richer structure than that found in superconductors. This difference is already evident in the appearance of two distinct bulk phases (A and B); it will be particularly important in understanding the rotational behavior of the two phases. To characterize the order parameter of superfluid 3He, it is convenient to introduce the amplitude for a Cooper pair, which now must have nine independent complex elements to account for the internal degrees of freedom. Although it is sometimes useful to couple the two angular momenta to form states of definite total angular momentum ( J = 0 , 1 , 2 ) , physically relevant perturbations, such as an external magnetic field, rotation, or boundaries, all tend to introduce preferred directions that destroy spatial isotropy. Thus it will be more convenient to retain a Cartesian basis for the separate unit vectors S and L, introducing a 3 x 3 matrix A * , , whose first and second indices refer to spin and orbital coordinate axes, respectively. Near T,, which depends on the pressure, it is natural to rely on a Ginzburg-Landau (GL) formalism, which has the advantage of describing both the A and B phases. The dominant terms in the free-energy density are invariant under separate rotations of the spin and orbital coordinates, which greatly restricts the allowed form. There is one bulk quadratic contribution
f, = - ( Y A ; ~ A,~ ;
(3.la)
where LY = ;N(O)(l- T / T , ) , N ( 0 ) is the density of states of one spin projection at the Fermi surface, and repeated dummy indices are summed from 1 to 3. In contrast, there are five bulk quartic contributions
A.L. FETTER
12
[Ch. 1 . 83
p , are a set of pressure-dependent
(but temperature-independent) parameters that are only partially determined by experiments. They differ from the weak-coupling values
by strong-coupling corrections that fix the overall phase diagram and several thermodynamic properties of the phase transition. Minimization of the bulk free energy for a uniform system shows that the bulk order parameter has a magnitude (A1= A = ( c r / B ) ” ’ , where denotes some linear combination of the five quartic parameters. In addition. the free-energy density has a term associated with spatial variations in the order parameter
B
where K, are a set of constants. In the weak-coupling limit, they all have the same value K = N ( O ) t i with 5, the BCS coherence length (pressure dependent and of ordei 200 A). Since strong-coupling corrections are thought to be negligible, only the single parameter K will be used here. The balance between the bending energyf, and the bulk quadratic energy fi determines the G L coherence length [( T ) = ( K / a ) ” ’
.
(3.4a)
which can easily be rewritten
t(T) = (
&(1 - T / T c ) - ’ ! 2 ,
(3.4b)
It plays an important role in setting the characteristic length scale of the various vortex structures. Two other contributions to the free-energy density must be included. One arises from the weak magnetic-dipole interaction between the ’He nuclei, enhanced by the quantum coherence of the Cooper pairs (Leggett 1973, 1974). Near T , , a direct calculation (see, for example, Brinkman and
Ch. 1, 841
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
13
Cross 1978, but note the slightly different notation) gives the expression
where g, is a temperature-independent dipole coupling constant. Note that the first two terms of eq. (3.5) explicitly couple the spin and orbital indices, so that f, is not invariant under separate rotations of the spin and orbital coordinate systems, unlike the previous bulk contributions to the freeenergy density. The balance between fk and fd defines the dipofe length
L,
=(
K/g,y,
(3.6)
cm; it sets the characteristic scale for deviations from the of order bulk order parameter caused by f,. The other important term in the bulk free-energy density is the magnetic contribution arising from the reduced susceptibility in the superfluid relative to that in the normal Fermi liquid. A detailed calculation near T, gives the result (3.7) where g, is a temperature-independent magnetic coupling constant. Comparison of eqs. (3.5) and (3.7) defines the characteristic magnetic dipole field (3.8) which is of order 25 G. For fields H %- H,, it follows that f, dominates f,.
4. Vortices in superfluid 3He-B
To understand the behavior of vortices in the B phase, it is essential to consider first the detailed form of the order parameter, both asymptotically and near the center of an isolated vortex line. All current calculations of this structure have relied on the GL formalism, or extended versions (Passvogel et a!. 1982) valid to next order in T, - T. This matter is discussed in section 4.1. The next question (section 4.2) is the overall texture of the B phase in a stationary container, and how that texture is affected by rotation (namely, by the presence of vortices). Since the only currently available method for detecting vortices relies on NMR, it is necessary to consider the interaction of an external magnetic field with a
A.L. FETTER
14
(Ch. 1, 84
single vortex (section 4.1) and also its effect on the overall texture (section 4.2). Section 4.3 then treats the NMR of the rotating B phase. 4.1. STRUCTURE OF
AN INDIVIDUAL VORTEX LINE
In the bulk uniform B phase, the equilibrium order parameter is simply the unit matrix or any matrix obtained from it by a relative rotation of the spin and orbital coordinates. Among the various ways to specify a rotation in three-dimensional space, it is simplest for the B phase to introduce the axis ri and the angle 8 of the equivalent single rotation. Given these parameters, the actual rotation matix has the explicit form
R P i = SPi cos 8 + n , n i ( l
- cos 8 ) -
~,~ sin, 8i ,,
(4.1)
and the corresponding bulk order parameter becomes
A,; = A(T)R,, .
(4.2)
Here A(T) is a temperature-dependent amplitude, given in the GL regime by
where pij denotes the sum of the corresponding p's [see eq. (3.1b)l. Any order parameter of the form (4.2) is a local minimum of the bulk GL free energy, obtained by integrating eq. (3.1) over the sample. Thus the B-phase order parameter is massively degenerate, and various additional small terms in the free-energy density are needed to determine its actual form. In this context, the most important is the dipole energy density fd in eq. (3.5). For a bulk uniform sample, minimization of fd fixes the rotation angle 8 to be arccos(- ) = 104", but the unit vector ri remains undetermined. This question will be studied in section 4.2, in connection with the determination of the li texture in a container. In the presence of slowly varying superflow, the order parameter for the B phase acquires a phase factor exp(i@), analogous to that for superfluid 4 He (compare section 2). Thus the corresponding order parameter becomes
a
A P i= A(T) ei@'RPi
.
(4.4)
Since the effective mass of a Cooper pair is 2m3, the superfluid velocity is given by
Ch. 1 , 541
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
us=(h/2m3)V@ .
15
(4.5a)
Substitution into the kinetic-energy density [eq. (3.3)] then identifies the B-phase superfluid density as p, = (2m3/fi)210KAi,
(4.5b)
where the rotation matrix has been taken as a spatial constant on the scale of variations in the phase @ (the additional terms associated with gradients of i will be considered in section 4.2). In direct analogy with the arguments used to obtain eqs. (2.3) and (2.4), the representation (4.5a) of 2m,u,lh as the gradient of the phase has two immediate corollaries: (1) The superfluid velocity in the B phase is irrotational apart from singularities, and (2) the cm2/s. When circulation is quantized in units of u = h/2m3~ 0 . 6 X7 applied to bulk rotating 3He-B, the same arguments as in eq. (2.11) imply that p-fold quantized vortices form a regular lattice with areal density
n, = 2Rlpu = 2rn3R/.rrph,
(4.6a)
and an equivalent circular (WS) unit cell of radius [compare eq. (2.13)]. a, = ( p K / 2 7 r ~ ) ' / ~( = p h / 2 m , ~ ) ' / *.
(4.6b)
Since the quantum of circulation in the B phase is comparable to that for 4He, the intervortex separation Q, in rotating superfluid 'He is also =lo0 pm for typical rotation speeds of order 1rad/s. For containers with radii of order 1cm, the lower critical angular velocity R,, is again very small [compare the paragraph below eq. (2.11)], so that the inequality R C , 4R applies to most experiments on 'He-B. The ultimate aim is to study an array of vortices in the rotating B phase. As will be seen, the vortex-core radius is of order ( ( T ) ~ 0 . 0 pm, 5 much smaller than the intervortex separation. In contrast, the characteristic size for spatial variations in the unit vector i is of order 0.05cm [see eq. (4.23)], much larger than the same intervortex separation. This hierarchy of lengths suggests an important simplification: consider a single vortex by itself, and impose an asymptotic boundary condition on the order parameter to represent the behavior at the boundary of the unit cell in the rotating array. Since the unit vector is constant on this scale, the associated matrix R can (for the remainder of section 4.1) be replaced by the unit matrix, because an overall constant rotation has no effect on the free energy. Such an order parameter in the B phase is known to represent Cooper pairing with total angular momentum J=O (Balian and Werthamer 1963), as
A.1.. FEITER
I6
(Ch. 1, 24
expected from its isotropic form; any rotation induced by a general R then introduces components with J = 1 or 2 . It is natural to introduce cylindrical-polar coordinates ( r , 4, z), with the center of the vortex on the axis. Far from the vortex core, the matrix structure of the order parameter should approach that of the bulk. with a , circulating superfluid velocity of magnitude u, = p h / 2 m 3 r= p ~ / 2 7 r rrepresenting a p-fold quantized circulation. Just as in section 2, this condition requires that the phase @ reduces, asymptotically, to p 4 , leading to the boundary condition at infinity
Although the asymptotic superflow about a vortex in the B phase resembles that for a vortex in superfluid 'He. the tensor structure of the full order parameter introduces many new complicating features that are absent for a complex scalar order parameter. In particular, it is essential to consider various possible choices for the unit-vector basis used in constructing the order parameter itself. As described in section 3, the matrixA is projected on one set of Cartesian axes for the spin and another (in principle, independent) set for the orbital angular momentum. Here, the presence of the unit tensor in eq. (4.7) means that these axes, in fact, coincide. As noted by Ohmi et al. (1983) and by Salomaa and Volovik (1983b). this Cartesian set is inconvenient for studying a vortex, and it is preferable to use eigenstates of S, and L z , introducing the complex unit vectors
that satisfy the orthonormality relations (4.8b)
To reexpress the order parameter A,, in this new basis set, it is helpful to think ol an intrinsic tensor A, whose components in the original Cartesian basis are just the set of scalar products with the Cartesian basis vectors
Equivalently, the tensor A follows by inverting this relation
.
A =i,,ApIil
(4.9b)
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
Ch. 1. 841
17
where a summation convention is again implied. The projection onto any other basis set now follows directly by taking appropriate scalar products. Virtually all studies of vortices in the B phase have assumed axisymmetry, since such structures are likely to have the lowest free energy. Physically, an axisymmetric order parameter must look locally the same at any point around a circle of fixed radius from the center. In this connection, the eigenvectors in eq. (4.8) are not axisymmetric, since they involve preferred directions in the horizontal plane. Thus, it is natural to introduce a related set of unit vectors, defined in terms of the unit vectors ( i ,4, i) in cylindrical-polar coordinates, (4.10)
This set indeed embodies the appropriate axisymmetry; it is simple to verify that the unit vectors in eqs. (4.8) and (4.10) are related by a phase factor (4.11)
where the index A is +, 0, or -. In terms of this new basis set, it has become conventional to introduce the components of the order parameter through the relations A = A 6A CAP i.P e i p * .
(4.12)
Use of the orthonormality conditions, 6:. 6, = & - A ' A
.
.
Ep
=a,,
,
(4.13)
and eq. (4.9) readily gives
(4.14) for CAFin terms of the original Cartesian components of the order parameter. In particular, the asymptotic boundary condition (4.7) now becomes
which reflects the I = 0 character of the bulk order parameter. Note that only three components of the tensor C have nonzero values at infinity, so that the other six components are associated with the core. As a result, the
A.L. FETTER
18
ICh. 1. $4
core structure for a vortex in the superfluid B phase is far more complicated than in superfluid 'He. In principle, each of the nine components CAW could still depend on the full set of variables ( r , 4, z), but it is reasonable first to specialize to an axisymmetric structure, in which C depends only on r , independent of the azimuthal angle or the distance z along the vortex axis. Analysis of even this simplest case will become quite intricate. The first step is to rewrite the GL free energy in terms of the new components. Use of eqs. (3.1), (4.9) and (4.14) yields the bulk terms directly (4.16a)
In contrast, the spatial derivatives in fk [eq. (3.3)] complicate the associated transformation. It is simplest to use the intermediate set of unit vectors GA, since they commute with the gradient operators, and a straightforward calculation with eq. (4.11) eventually gives
The second terms (proportional to r -') represent the centrifugal barriers for the various components; it is not difficult to see that they imply the following behavior near the vortex axis
c,,
(x
- A --PI
(r+O).
(4.18)
In general. different components behave differently as r - 0 ; indeed, some components remain finite at the center of the vortex, indicating the presence of a supertluid core. If p = 1 , for example, the components C+,, and C,, can have nonzero values at the origin, whereas, for p = 2 , C , can have similar behavior. Once again, the rich and complicated core structure in the B phase contrasts with the much simpler case of superfluid 'He, where the one-component order parameter for a p-fold quantized vortex line vanishes like rlP' as r + 0 . +
Ch. 1. 541
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
19
For axisymmetric vortices of the sort considered here, Salomaa and Volovik ( 1983b, 1985) have introduced a convenient group-theoretic classification based on the behavior under various discrete symmetries. There are five distinct classes: The most symmetric vortex (their o vortex) has only five nonzero amplitudes CAF(those with A + p even), which are real. For the u vortex, the same amplitudes may be complex. In contrast, none of the amplitudes vanishes identically for the three remaining types. The v vortex has nine real amplitudes; the w vortex has real amplitudes for A + p even but imaginary ones for A + p odd; for the final type (the uvw vortex), all amplitudes can be complex. It is striking that even the simplest of these vortices has a relatively complicated structure involving five distinct, but coupled, amplitudes. Thus approximate schemes with fewer amplitudes or fewer independent functions (Passvogel et al. 1983) can never represent exact solutions; they can, of course, be considered as trial solutions, and the variational basis of the G L equations then implies that the corresponding free energy would be an upper bound to the true value. Each of the exact vortex types represents a possible equilibrium solution of the bulk G L equations, obtained as the Euler-Lagrange equations of the bulk free-energy density in eqs. (4.16) and (4.17). The o vortex, for example, gives rise to five coupled nonlinear ordinary differential equations for the five real radial functions. It is necessary to solve these G L equations for each of the different vortex types. Unfortunately, the solutions of the G L equations merely represent stationary points of the free energy, so that it is also necessary to consider whether each type is indeed a local minimum of the free energy, and, in addition, which type actually represents the absolute minimum. For the weak-coupling parameters pi in eq. (3.2), thought to describe the low-pressure part of the phase diagram near T,, detailed numerical work (Salomaa and Volovik 1983b, 1985, Passvogel et al. 1984) has shown that the v vortex (with nine real amplitudes) has the lowest free energy of all singly quantized axisymmetric vortices. As expected, the free energy per unit length has the form of eq. (2.15) for p = 1, with appropriate redefinitions of p, and the circulation quantum [see the discussion involvingeqs. (4.5) and (4.6), but note that this calculation for the B phase omits the contribution of the normal fluid]. Figure 2 shows the resulting solutions, normalized to 1 at infinity, with the radial distance scaled by the G L coherence length (( T). As expected from the previous analysis, only three components have nonzero values far from the vortex core, and only the components C,, and C,, remain finite at the center of the vortex. For the o vortex, the five nonzero components look qualitatively like those for the v vortex, but this solution turns out to be unstable in the weak-coupling regime, being only a saddle point; furthermore, there is no evidence of stability for the remaining three complex vortex types.
A.L. FETTER
20
-0.5 :---0
I
I
2.5
5
[Ch. 1 , 84
I
10
I
25
-
Fig. 2. Order parameter for the v vortex in ’He-B. For the o vortex, the top five functions are qualitatively similar, and the bottom four are absent (Salomaa and Volovik 1983b. reprinted by permission of the authors and the American Physical Society).
It is also interesting to consider axisymmetric vortices with other values of p . For liquid ‘He, the scalar form of the order parameter ensures that different multiply quantized vortices still have the same qualitative core structure. Thus the free energy of a p-fold quantized vortex scales approximately with p2 [see eq. (2.15)], whereas the area per unit cell of the vortex lattice increases only linearly with p [see eq. (2.13a)l; the resulting free energy per unit area is essentially proportional to p and is minimized for p = 1, indicating that only singly quantized vortices are expected to occur in rotating ‘He. In contrast, singly and doubly quantized vortices in 3 He-B have intrinsically different core structures, which precludes such a simple scaling argument. For doubly quantized vortices, Salomaa and Volovik (1984, 1985) find that only the o type is stable in the weak-coupling regime. In addition, a lattice of such doubly quantized o vortices has a higher free energy per unit volume than one of singly quantized v vortices
Ch. 1, $41
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ‘He
21
for angular velocities less than about 160 rad/s ( ~ 1 6 0 rpm). 0 Since current experiments typically operate at about 1 rad/s, observation of doubly quantized vortices in the B phase is not anticipated soon. The quartic term in the G L free energy [eq. (3.lb)l depends on the five parameters pi that include the strong-coupling corrections to the weakcoupling BCS theory. Since the weak-coupling parameters in eq. (3.2) imply that only the bulk B phase is stable, it is evident that the strong-coupling corrections must be important in studying the behavior at elevated pressure, especially near the polycritical point where the A and B phases coexist at T,. Although certain combinations of the p’s determine various physical quantities near T,, they are not known individually with any precision. The early spin-fluctuation model for the p’s (Brinkman et al. 1974) provided many qualitative insights into the feedback mechanism for stabilizing the A phase through strong-coupling corrections, but its one adjustable parameter S cannot consistently fit the various experimental observations (see, for example, Halperin et al. 1976). Nevertheless, it remains popular because of its simplicity. In particular, Salomaa and Volovik (1985) have used it to investigate the pressure dependence of the vortex structure in the B phase. On this basis, they predict that the singly quantized v vortex remains the stable solution throughout the G L region, up to the polycritical point. Several recent calculations (Sauls and Serene 1981, Levin and Valls 1983, Bedell 1984) have yielded improved fits for the strong-coupling corrections to the p’s. Despite small differences among them, they are qualitatively similar and all differ significantly from the spin-fluctuation model. To investigate how these corrections affect the pressure dependence of the vortex core, Fetter and Theodorakis (1984) (see also Fetter 1985b) have used variational trial functions for the different components of the singly quantized axisymmetric vortices. With the spin-fluctuation model, they find, in agreement with Salomaa and Volovik (1989, that the v vortex is stable at all pressures. With the Sauls and Serene model, however, the four additional components that distinguish the v vortex from the o vortex diminish rapidly with increasing pressure and disappear at a critical pressure of about 10 bar. Above this value, their calculations predict that only the o vortex remains stable. As seen in section 4.3, Hakonen et al. (1983a, b) have experimental evidence for a first-order transition between two types of vortex cores in the B phase, but the data do not extend to the G L regime. In contrast, Salomaa and Volovik (1983b) find that any transition between the v and o vortices must be of second order. Thus it is not clear whether the suggested disappearance of the v vortex with increasing pressure is related to the observed core transition. Since a variational calculation cannot be considered definitive, additional
22
A.L. FETTER
[Ch. 1, $4
exact solutions of the GL equations using the newer fits to the p’s would be desirable. This question remains open and intriguing. Several other distortions of the vortex structure might conceivably account for the observed vortex-core transition. The order parameter in eq. (4.12) assumes axisymmetry, but it is natural to consider more general nonaxisymmetric forms. If C in eq. (4.14) depends on both r and 4, it can be expanded in a Fourier series with different angular contributions exp(im4); axisymmetric solutions then become a special case with only m = 0. A small distortion with a single nonzero m leads to a linear problem, and the sign of the eigenvalue determines the stability. Alternatively, finite distortions can be studied with the full GL free energy, but the quartic couplings in eq. (4.16b) apparently preclude any closed finite set of m values. Preliminary calculations by Salomaa (1984) have found no evidence that such nonaxisymmetric vortices have lower free energy than axisymmetric ones. Another possibility is to allow helical distortions that break the translational invariance along the vortex axis (Salomaa and Volovik 1983a, 1985). More generally, the basis vectors for the spin and orbital coordinates in eq. (4.12) could differ by a rotation that depends on the distance from the vortex core and reduces to the unit matrix only at infinity. Such a rotation can qualitatively alter the centrifugal barriers near the vortex core, but it is not yet clear whether the potential reduction in the kinetic energy of circulating superflow can compensate for the increased bending energy associated with the gradients of the rotation matrix. Even more intriguing is the possibility of topologically distinct rotations joining the core and the asymptotic region, which could then produce the analog of inequivalent vacuum states in field theory. At present, there is no compelling argument for axisymmetric B-phase vortices (other than simplicity), and much work, both analytical and numerical, remains to be done. The preceding discussion of the structure of axisymmetric vortices in the B phase has omitted the possible effect of an applied magnetic field. This question must be considered, because NMR has been the principal means of detecting the vortices. It depends on the balance of several terms in the free-energy density, involving the dipole interaction between the nuclear spins, and the magnetic interaction of the spins with an external magnetic field [see eqs. (3.5) and (3.7)J. For the B phase, their detailed forms will be considered in sections 4.2 and 4.3, in connection with the it texture in a rotating container and the corresponding NMR. Here, it is sufficient to note that typical experimental magnetic fields ( ~ 3 0 G) 0 are too weak to affect the vortex-core structure significantly (Salomaa and Volovik 1985). This situation would be different for much higher fields, and such observations could be valuable in clarifying our picture of the vortices in superfluid jHe-B.
Ch. 1, $41
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
23
Although the vortex structure is rigid, in the sense that moderate magnetic fields do not affect it, an applied magnetic field does lead to one very interesting and unusual effect, arising from the nonunitary character of the order parameter near the vortex core. In general, an order parameter in superfluid ’He is called unitary if the matrix representing the squared energy gap is proportional to the unit matrix. In essence, this condition means that spin-up and spin-down particles are equivalent, which indeed describes the bulk A and B phases in zero field. As expected, it fails in the presence of large magnetic fields, most notably in the formation of the A , phase, where Cooper pairing occurs in only one spin component. In the present context, the asymmetry of the order parameter CAPunder the interchange ( A , p ) * ( - A , - p ) [see, for example, eq. (4.18) and the explicit solution in fig. 21 indicates clearly the nonunitanty near the vortex core. It arises from the special coupling between the orbital and spin angular momentum [the broken spin-orbit symmetry introduced by Leggett (1973)l. The overall rotation of the container induces quantized vortices, whose preferred sense of circulating superflow acts roughly like an external magnetic field in distinguishing up and down spins. This effect had been predicted earlier (Sauls et al. 1982) for vortex lines in rotating neutron stars, where the Cooper pairing occurs in the ’P2 state. In the context of the B phase, its occurrence was suggested by Ohmi et al. (1983) and by Volovik and Mineev (1983), and detailed numerical work by Salomaa and Volovik (1983b) has provided a convincing fit to the data of Hakonen et al. (1983b). The order of magnitude of the effect can be estimated by noting that it arises from the asymmetry between particles and holes, since otherwise complete cancellation would occur. The net magnetization in the vortex core is of order nlr ( h ( A/ E ~ ) ’ = 4 X lo-’ erg/G cm’, where n is the atomic number density (“2 x cm-’), lylfr/2 is the magnetic moment of a ’He nucleus erg/G), and the two factors of = reflect the Cooper pairing and the particle-hole asymmetry. Multiplying by 47r times the “area of a vortex” 7rt2, where 6 is cm, gives a magnetic flux of order G cm’ per vortex line. Since the number of vortices in a container is unlikely to exceed lo4, the total magnetic flux is far smaller than a single flux quantum in a superconductor (of order 2 x lo-’ G cm’). Clearly, direct measurement of this effect would be difficult. Nevertheless, as seen in section 4.2, it exerts a significant influence on the ri texture in a rotating container and thus is observable in the shift of the NMR spectrum. The simplest way to quantify the effect is to recall the small term in the G L free-energy density (Ambegaokar and Mermin 1973) (4.19)
A.L. FETTER
24
[Ch. 1, $4
that is linear in the magnetic field H. Here h = ( l y ( h H / k , T , ) is a dimensionless magnetic field, and 17 is a small dimensionless parameter, of order 0.01 (lsraelsson et al. 1984), that characterizes the particle-hole asymmetry. When evaluated for an order parameter of the form in eq. (4.12). the resulting integrated free energy becomes - m H,where the magnetic moment m per unit length of vortex line lies along the axis of the vortex (or, more generally, rotated by the local rotation matrix R ) and has a magnitude given by (4.20a)
(4.20b) a dimensionless integral of order 1.5 for the v vortex (Salomaa and Volovik 1985). Recent experiments (Israelsson et al. 1984) have provided detailed information on the pressure dependence of 17, but comparison with the observed NMR shifts (see section 4.3) is difficult because they are measured outside the GL regime. 4.2. TEXTURES IN A
ROTATING CONTAINER
In static equilibrium, the order parameter for the B phase has the form ” the given in eqs. (4.1) and (4.2). Since the angle 8 is fixed at ~ 1 0 4 by dipole coupling, the only remaining freedom is the spatial orientation of the unit vector ti. Although this direction is arbitrary in an unbounded isotropic system, the situation changes in the presence of perturbations that introduce one or more preferred spatial directions. Examples of interest here are boundaries of a container, an external magnetic field, or rotation and the associated vortex lines. In these cases, competing influences o n ri typically induce a spatially varying texture, obtained by minimizing the total free energy, subject to the boundary conditions. To understand this behavior in detail, it is first necessary to consider the various contributions to the free-energy density for a B-phase order parameter. One important term arises from the gradients of ti: substitution of eqs. (4.1) and (4.2) into eq. (3.3) yields the following (Smith ct al. 1977, Brinkman and Cross 1978)
+ g(ti .curl ti)’ + (ti X curl ti)’ - - F ( d i v r i ) ( t i .curl ti) + div[(ti .V)i ti div ti]}
f, = p,(h/2m,)’{ g(div ti)’
-
.
(4.21)
Ch. 1, 941
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ‘He
25
Here, p, is the superfluid density from eq. (4.5b), and the last term is a pure divergence, equivalent to a surface contribution. By itself, this gradient energy density tends to favor a uniform texture. The form of the remaining terms in the free-energy density depends crucially on the presence or absence of a magnetic field. Since all the Helsinki experiments on rotating 3He-B have used a strong field ( ~ 3 0G 0 9 Hd), only the latter situation will be considered here, but the generalization to the weak-field regime requires no new principles. Recall that the B-phase energy gap at the Fermi surface is isotropic in zero field, with a magnitude given in eq. (4.3). The addition of a strong magnetic field deforms the gap slightly into an ellipsoidal shape, with A, reduced along the direction of the field (Engelsberg et al. 1974, Fetter 1975, Leggett 1975). When combined with the dipole energy, this deformation leads to an orienting term in the bulk energy of the form (see, for example, Brinkman and Cross 1978) fH = - a H 2 ( i *
k)’ ,
(4.22a)
where
evidently reflects the combined role of the magnetic and dipole energies. Comparison of eqs. (4.21) and (4.22) suggests the introduction of yet another characteristic length [see eqs. (3.6), (3.8), (4.3) and (4.5)]
tH= ( p S / ~ ) ” 2 ( h / 2 m 3 Hz) ‘i Hd
5
H ’
(4.23)
that determines the scale of spatial variations of i in a large magnetic field. Note that tHvaries inversely with H and is therefore field-dependent (as well as temperature-dependent, through 5). Since the coefficient a in the orienting energy is very small (it involves the product of two perturbations), this length is macroscopic even in the present high-field limit ( tH= 0.05 cm for ~ 3 0 G). 0 For comparison, the containers used in the Helsinki experiments have radii about five times larger than t,, but this condition depends on the particular experiment. The combined effect of magnetic fields and vortices is slightly complicated, and it seems preferable to start with the simpler case of a fluid at rest in a stationary container, where the only additional contribution is the surface energy f,. In the strong-field limit, f, is proportional to -(If. R . i)’, where s^ is the normal to the surface (Smith et al. 1977.
A.L. FETTER
26
[Ch. 1. $4
Brinkman and Cross 1978). For definiteness, consider a long cylindrical container, with the field parallel to the symmetry axis z^. A simple calculation then shows that the resulting surface energy is minimized by the values
where n, and ne are the radial and azimuthal components of h. In the typical Helsinki experiment (see the discussion by Jacobsen and Smith 1983), these values provide the boundary conditions that serve to determine the h texture in the cylinder, whose qualitative form now follows by comparing the energies f, and f,. The unit vector ii will be uniform and parallel to H (along the z-axis) in the interior of the cylinder to minimize eqs. (4.21) and (4.22a), but this texture cannot satisfy the boundary conditions in eq. (4.24). Thus h bends throughout a surface layer of thickness 5, from vertical to one of the values given in eq. (4.24), say n, = (1 /5)1'2 and n+ = (315)'". The resulting texture in a stationary cylinder is axisymmetric, with h exhibiting a spiral pattern near the boundary. To understand the NMR in both stationary and rotating containers filled with B-phase fluid, it will be important to consider this texture in greater detail. The configuration may be parametrized with a pair of angles a and /3, through the relations ti = sin
/3 ( i cos a +
sin a)+ i cos p .
(4.25)
Thus p is the polar angle of h , but a is not the conventional azimuthal angle, since eq. (4.25) involves cylindrical-polar unit vectors instead of Cartesian ones. This choice offers the important advantage that a and f3 depend only on the radial distance r from the center of the cylinder, and eq. (4.24) implies the corresponding boundary values
P ( R ) = arcsin d!, ~ 6 3 " .
a ( R )= 60",
sH),
(4.26)
Several studies of wide cylinders (radius R S both analytical (Hakonen and Volovik 1982, Maki and Nakahara 1983) and numerical (Jacobsen and Smith 1983) indicate that P ( r ) decreases rapidly within a surface region R - r < 5" from its boundary value of ~ 6 3 at " r = R toward its central value p ( 0 ) = 0. In the interior, it has a roughly parabolic form, with a curvature proportional to exp(-Rlf,). In contrast, the angle a varies smoothly, decreasing slowly to a central value determined by the ratio R / 5 , ; for R15, 1 a ( 0 )= 38". Figure 3 illustrates this behavior for the ~
Ch. 1, 541
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
27
.o Fig. 3. The C texture for nonrotating ’He-B in a cylinder of radius.R = 4 t H , with a and p defined as in eq. (4.25) (Jacobsen and Smith 1983, reprinted by permission of the authors and Plenum Press).
typical value R / [ , = 4 (Jacobsen and Smith 1983). As will be seen in section 4.3, the form of the angle P ( r ) , especially its deviation from a strict parabolic form, is important for the NMR spectrum for the B phase in a cylinder. It is evident that the ri texture in a stationary cylinder arises from the balance between the orientational energyf, in eq. (4.22a) and the gradient energy f, in eq. (4.21), supplemented by an appropriate set of boundary conditions. Furthermore, the small value off, implies that the corresponding characteristic length (, is macroscopically large. It also implies the crucial corollary that other small orientational energies will be equally significant in determining the overall texture. In the present context of rotating superfluid ’He-B in a strong magnetic field, two additional contributions are relevant. One, originally suggested by Gongadze et al. (1981), reflects the local alteration of the magnetic energy caused by the circulating superflow around the vortex and the resulting deformation of the order parameter near the core. This contribution f, is automatically quadratic in the magnetic field and thus even under a field reversal. The other, suggested by Ohmi et al. (1983) and Volovik and Mineev (1983), and studied in detail by Salomaa and Volovik (1983b), arises from the nonunitary order parameter near the vortex core and the associated magnetic moment [discussed in connection with eq. (4.20)]. This “gyromagnetic” contribution fern is linear in the magnetic field and is
?s
A.L. FETTER
(Ch. 1. $4
therefore odd under a field reversal. The distinct symmetries under field reversal are important in the experimental separation of the two effects. The original derivation (Gongadze et al. 1981) of the orienting energyf, relied on a formalism combining the effect of a uniform magnetic field and uniform hydrodynamic flow (see, for example, Brinkman and Cross 1978). The resulting (rather complicated) generalization of eq. (4.22) was then applied to the nonuniform flow about the vortex. Since the supcrfluid velocity diverges at the center of the vortex [see eq. (2.5) for the corresponding situation in ‘He], this procedure required a short-range cutoff to approximate the intrinsic deformation of the core. More recently, Salomaa and Volovik (1985) have introduced a simpler approach that relies explicitly on the localized character of the circulating supercurrent and core deformation. They start from the observation that the various vortices in zero field (discussed in section 4.1) are, in principle, exact solutions of the G L equations obtained from the bulk free-energy densities f,, f,. and f, [see eqs. (3.1) and (3.3)]; furthermore, the order parameter for each vortex automatically approaches the bulk form (4.4) far from the core. To include the effect of an applied field to leading order, it is sufficient to use first-order perturbation theory and evaluate the spatial integral of the magnetic energy densitiesf, [eq. (3.7)] a n d f , , [eq. (4.19)] for the known vortex order parameter in zero field. Although this procedure gives no orienting effect for the bulk uniform order parameter in eq. (4.2), it does properly include the orienting effect of the localized vortex-core structure; indeed, it is just the approach used to obtain the magnetic moment (4.20) of the vortex in section 4.1. The analysis of the order parameter near a vortex in section 4.1 must first be generalized to allow for a rotation matrix R that is locally constant over the intervortex separation of order a,. Thus eqs. (4.9a) and (4.12) arc rewritten as
where eq. (4.11) has been used to simplify the subsequent analysis. Substitution into eq. (3.7) then gives the associated magnetic energy density (4.28) whose average over the azimuthal angle vanishes unless K = A . A straightforward analysis yields an isotropic term, which will be ignored, and the relevant vortex-orientation contribution
ilc-gl2 I .
(4.29)
Ch. 1, 941
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
29
Averaging over the unit cell of area mug = n,' [see eq. (4.6)] then gives the corresponding vortex orientation energy density
(4.30) where the radial coordinate is scaled with write this contribution in the form
where
h denotes the
5. It has become conventional to
rotation axis and
is a dimensionless coupling constant, proportional to the vortex density n, and thus to the angular velocity. Although the integrand in eq. (4.31b) would vanish identically for a bulk B-phase order parameter, it is here nonzero because of the altered (non-B-phase) order parameter in and around the core. Indeed, the dimensionless integral diverges logarithmically for large r, which accounts for the finite upper limit, and has a value of order 25 (Salomaa and Volovik 1985). They ascribe the logarithmic contribution to the circulating superflow [it has the form originally suggested by Gongadze et al. (198l)l and the remaining constant to the "magnetic anisotropy inside the vortex core", but this separation is not unique. The other magnetic contribution to the textural free-energy density follows immediately from eq. (4.20). When eq. (4.27) is substituted into eq. (4.19), an average over the unit cell of the vortex lattice yields the gyromagnetic free-energy density fgm
= -(H-R . m ) n , ,
(4.32)
where the property RA X RB = R ( A X B ) has been used, and m is given in eq. (4.20a). It is conventional to rewrite this expression in a form analogous to eq. (4.31)
where
K
is another coupling constant, again proportional to the angular
A.L. FE’ITER
30
[Ch. 1, 84
velocity, but now with the dimension of a magnetic field K
=
-
:mn,/a.
(4.33b)
As noted previously, fv and fgm are even and odd, respectively, under a reversal of the relative directions fi and d. It is now possible to consider the equilibrium ri texture in a rotating container subject to a strong axial magnetic field. The total free energy in the rotating frame of reference is given by (4.34) where the last two terms comprise the effect of the vortex lines (and thus the rotation of the container). In principle, eq. (4.34) must be minimized subject to the boundary conditions in eq. (4.24), and it is again convenient to parametrize i with the two angles a and p introduced in eq. (4.25). To understand the qualitative effect of rotation on the texture, it is helpful to evaluate the quantity (H R z^) = ? H ( i R i) explicitly, where H = &Hi is assumed parallel to the rotation axis. Use of eq. (4.1) with cos 8 = gives the value +H[1 - sin’ p ] . Apart from an additive isotropic constant, it follows that the last three terms in the integrand of eq. (4.34) may be written as
-
- -
a H Zsin’@ [I - A ( l -
sin2p) 7 K / H ] ,
(4.35)
which characterizes the combined effect on the i texture of parallel (antiparallel) magnetic field and rotation. Since A and K are both positive, rotation parallel to H evidently acts to reduce a by an approximate factor 1 - A - K / H ,assuming that p 4 1. In particular, this reduction decreases the effective strength of the bulk orienting energy f, in eq. (4.22a); at the same time, it increases the effective value of the characteristic length in eq. (4.23). The qualitative effect of rotation ( h l l H ) on the ri texture in a cylinder is now clear: the reduced effective orienting energy implies a narrower central region where ri is parallel to the applied field (namely, where p = 0), and the increased tH implies a thicker surface region where P ( r ) decreases from its boundary value. Both of these effects act to increase the curvature of p ( r ) near the center, which will be important (section 4.3) in understanding the NMR. Reversing the magnetic field direction changes the sign of fgm but leaves f, unchanged. Experimental studies (Hakonen et al. 1983b) at -29 bar for TIT, 6 0.6 (well below the GL regime) yield the approximate values
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
Ch. 1. 841
31
A ~ 0 . and 8 K I H= 3 X lo-* for 0 = 1 rad/s and H = 300 G (see fig. 4). Thus the rotation has a significant effect on the overall texture, and numerical studies are necessary to obtain the detailed form of the angles a and p for various angular velocities and magnetic field strengths. The same formalism also applies to more general situations, for example, those with the magnetic field tipped relative to the rotation axis. In a finite container, this configuration is complicated because it breaks the
10
C
205
0
Lx10-Z
o,o,O (25', 155')
1.4 1.4 1.7 1.7 1.4
(LSo,135') P (L5',135') x (65',115') + (65',115') A
I C
3
\
#
2
I
-
-
I I I
I I I
1 1
0
05
d
8.r.,.
06
Atx
1
I
07
0.8
0.9
10
Fig. 4. Temperature dependence of the normalized parameters h l f l and K I O Hat 29.3 bar. The solid lines refer to a theoretical calculation (Hakonen et al. 1983b, reprinted by permission of the authors and the American Physical Society).
31
A . L . FETTER
[Ch. 1. 84
cylindrical symmetry; consequently, the only detailed studies of tipped fields have concentrated on the simpler question of the corresponding uniform ti texture, ignoring the finite-size effect of boundaries. The resulting minimization of the last three terms in eq. (4.34) produces a transcendental relation for the angle /3 that depends on the tipping angle and the two parameters A and K I H .When applied to the experimental data for the central region of a rotating cylinder (Hakonen et al. 1983b), these observations provide the most accurate values of the two parameters. Strictly speaking, the present description of the ri texture in a container applies only in the vicinity of T,, because the derivation of the gradient energy (4.21) and the three “coupling constants” a , A , and K in eq. (4.22), (4.31). and (4.33) relies o n the GL formalism. At lower temperatures, the various contributions are expected to have the same general form, but with altered coefficients that depend on temperature as well as pressure. In particular, Brinkman and Cross (1978) discuss the gradient energy, which involves Fermi-liquid corrections and several different coefficients for the distinct invariant terms in eq. (4.21). In addition, the parameter a in eq. (4.22) can be related to experimental values (Osheroff and Brinkman 1977) of N M R shifts in the bulk B phase. Alternatively, a, A, and K can be considered phenomenological parameters. to be determined by comparison with experimental data, using the theory to be discussed in section 4.3 (Hakonen et al. 1983b). As a result. the description of h textures in rotating containers should hold throughout the B phase. 4.3. N M R
IN A ROTATING CONTAINER
The preceding section provides a prescription for obtaining (in general, numerically) the equilibrium ti texture of ‘He-B in an arbitrary container, subject to a strong static magnetic field. The remaining question in determining the N M R spectrum is the linear response of the superfluid B phase to a weak external rf magnetic field. Soon after the original observation o f the NMR shifts in ’He by Osheroff et al. (1972), Leggett (1974) developed the basic formalism, which relies on an effective magnetic free-energy density
f,,,= y2S2J2xB- y S * H
+ fd + fk .
(4.36)
Here S(r) is the spin density, xu is the B-phase susceptibility, y is the “gyromagnetic ratio” for the - He nucleus, H is the total magnetic field,f, is the dipole energy density from eq. (3.5), and fk is the kinetic energy density associated with spatial variations in the order parameter, taken either from eq. (3.3) in the GL. regime or its generalization to lower
Ch. 1, 941
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ‘He
33
temperature. Althoughf, plays no role in a uniform system, it is crucial for understanding the NMR in a bounded geometry. The effective free energy density depends on the spin density and on the order parameter A,,. As shown by Leggett (1974), the orbital part of the order parameter remains fixed on the relatively short time scales associated with an rf magnetic field, so that only the spin part of the order parameter varies. Thus the theory involves two sets of dynamical variables, the spin density S and the spin part of A,, (the first index). In static equilibrium, the order parameter has the general form AZi given in eqs. (4.1) and (4.4), with the rotation angle arccos(- $ )and the rotation axis ri determined as described in section 4.2. This solution can also be shown to minimize the spatial integral of eq. (4.36) for the appropriate static magnetic field. Small deformations in the spin part of the order parameter can be characterized by an infinitesimal rotation 8, of magnitude 101 about the axis 8/181, leading to
where
For small-amplitude motion, the infinitesimal rotations themselves can be taken as the dynamical variables of the order parameter, and the canonically conjugate spin operators S (the generators of spin rotations) complete the set. They obey the usual commutation relations
If He,, denotes the spatial integral of the effective magnetic free-energy density feff, this quantity then acts as an effective Hamiltonian that governs the dynamical motion of these variables through the familiar relations (4.39)
To derive the explicit equations of motion, it is helpful to rewrite the dipole energy density in terms of the small rotations 8. Substitution of eq. (4.37) into eq. (3.5) eventually gives the result
A.L. FE'ITER
34
[Ch. 1. 44
(4.40) correct through second order in small rotations. Here, ti characterizes the unperturbed order parameter A:, , and a constant term that plays no role in the dynamical equations has been omitted. Consider, temporarily, a bulk uniform sample in a static magnetic field H O i , with G a spatial constant and a uniform static spin density S,, = x e H O / y . In the presence of an additional rf magnetic field H', the commutation relations in eq. (4.39) yield the pair of dynamical equations (4.41a) (4.41b)
15gdAin(n
where H is the total magnetic field. These equations are readily combined in a single equation that expresses the infinitesimal rotation in terms of the rf field H' d '8 _ _ -- w O $ at?
Y2 dH' xi-15-gg,A~h(G-8)-y XB
dt
'
(4.42)
where w,) = yH,, is the Larmor frequency. In the usual case that G is parallel to H,, [recall the coupling energy in eq. (4.22)], this equation predicts the familiar transverse response ( H ' perpendicular to i) at the Larmor frequency wo, and an additional longitudinal response ( H ' parallel to i) at the characterisic frequency (Leggett 1974) (4.43) which Wheatley (1978) tabulates for several pressures. Note that 0, is proportional to A , and thus vanishes as T-+ T , in the G L regime [see eq. (4.3)]. More generally, if ti differs from z^ for some reason, the bulk transverse and longitudinal responses are characterized by the approximate frequencies w: = wt 7
+~ ,
wz = f j t , n ; .
; ~ ( nl f- ) ,
(4.44a) (4.44b)
apart from corrections o f order (fl,/q,)', which are small in most cases of interest. These relations show that the ti texture can affect the NMR
Ch. 1, 141
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
35
response significantly, even in a bulk sample. In particular, the bulk transverse response shifts from the Larmor frequency whenever textural effects rotate ri away from the direction of the static field. To understand the actual NMR in a bounded container, it is essential to consider the bending contribution fk in eq. (4.36) (Smith et al. 1977, Brinkman and Cross 1978, Buchholtz 1978). Substitution of eq. (4.37) into eq. (3.3) eventually gives the approximate expression
where L, is the dipole length from eq. (3.6), k is a constant of order one [the ratio of the bending constants (K, + K3)/2K,, which equals 1 in the weak-coupling GL regime], and Tis a tensor that depends explicitly on the unperturbed i texture [compare eq. (4.1) for the angle arccos(-i)] T,, = ~(c?,, - 5ripriv + Y B E , , , ~ , ) .
(4.46)
Since the i texture varies on the scale ( ~ 0 . 0 cm), 5 whereas L, = cm sets the scale for spatial variations in 8, gradients of ri and T have been ignored in deriving eq. (4.45). This expression must be combined with the dipole energy density (reexpressed in terms of the frequency 0,) to give the total effective free-energy density (4.36). A generalization of the previous derivation then gives the dynamical equation for the oscillatory motion of the ith component of the small rotation angle 8 in the presence of a static magnetic field Hot and a weak rf field H' exp(-iot) oscillating at frequency o
L?i(Dij+ i i i j ) q- w2t$+ iowo(8 x t),= iwyHI,
(4.47)
where
D , = $ L i [ - S i j ( l + k)V'
+ kTildlTjmdm]
(4.48)
is a hermitian differential operator. This equation differs from eq. (4.42) only in the term involving the gradients of 8, which arises from the physical effect of the nonuniform i texture. The structure of eq. (4.47) resembles that of the Schrodinger equation, with an inhomogeneous driving term proportional to the rf field. To make the correspondence precise, it is convenient to project it onto the Cartesian spherical unit vectors qAfrom eq. (4.8), using the definitions
e,
=e
- 4, ,
e = e,+;
.
(4.49)
A.L. FETTER
36
[Ch. 1, $4
A straightforward analysis yields the equation for the spherical component
O’,(D,,, + tiAi;)fls - w(w
-
- Aw,)8,
= iwyH;,
(4.50)
-
where D,, = (ti, i , ) D l , ( i , 4;) is the projection of eq. (4.48) onto the new basis, and the summation convention is implied. Evidently D,, acts like the “kinetic energy” in the Schrodinger equation, and ti,;; acts like a (hermitian) potential V . In principle, all three components 8+, O,, and 8are coupled by these matrix operators, but this coupling becomes negligible in the usual case that (0,1w,)2 + 1 (Theodorakis and Fetter 1983). Thus eq. (4.50) separates into three inhomogeneous Schrodinger equations for the spherical components O,, with w ( w - Aw,)/O’, acting like the eigenvalue for the effective motion in the real potential V, = ltiA12, governed by the kinetic energy operator D, = D,,(here, no summation on A is implied)
O;(D,
+ V,)e, - W ( W - Aw,,)B, = i w y H ; .
(4.51)
These equations must be supplemented by appropriate boundary conditions. Since there is no flux of spin density into the walls, the normal derivative of S must vanish there (Smith et al. 1977, Brinkman and Cross 1978, Buchholtz 1978), which then gives the corresponding (Neumann) boundary condition on the small rotations
im, = 0 .
(4.52)
In dealing with an inhomogeneous equation of this form, it is convenient to introduce the eigenfunctions $; of the homogeneous equation, and the corresponding eigenvalues w : , defined by
(4.53) subject to the same boundary conditions in (4.52). If the spherical component 0, is expanded in this (assumed complete) set, eq. (4.51) readily yields the explicit solution
where the frequency w has been given a small positive imaginary part ie to ensure a causal response (see, for example, Fetter and Walecka 1980,
Ch. 1. 941
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ‘He
37
section 50). The structure of this equation is physically transparent, for the applied (uniform) rf field excites the ith normal mode with a strength proportional to its overlap integral with H;, and the response contains a causal resonant denominator that is large if the applied frequency w is close to the eigenfrequency w A. The physical quantity of interest is the mean power absorbed by the system dUldr = to
I
d’x Im H‘** M ( x ) .
(4.55)
Use of eq. (4.41a) and the relation M = yS leads to the expression (4.56) Equation (4.54), combined with the familiar relation ( x - iE)-’ = P x - ’ + i ?rS(x), where P denotes a principal-value integral, yields the approximate form
X
2u(2~ boo)-'
I
1’
d3x $;(I)
(4.57)
for the power absorbed from a weak external rf field with spherical component A . As expected, excitation of spin-wave normal modes occurs only if the applied frequency equals one of the resonant frequencies w : , and the strength of the absorption is proportional to the square of the overlap integral of the appropiate eigenfunction with the uniform rf field H;. In the present physically motivated picture, the study of the NMR spectrum in a bounded container reduces to solving an effective Schrodingcr equation (4.53) for the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues, subject to the (Neumann) boundary condition (4.52). Apart from the unusual boundary conditions, this procedure is familiar from quantum mechanics, and all the well-known techniques can be used to find the solutions. In particular, the Rayleigh-Ritz quotient provides an estimate for the lowest eigenvalue of a particular spherical projection
(4.58)
A.L. FEITER
38
[Ch. 1, 84
giving a variational principle for the shift in the NMR frequency from the bulk value (w,, for transverse excitation H i , @, for longitudinal excitation
H;).
This formalism applies directly to 3He-B in a long cylinder of radius R, where the equilibrium texture is axisymmetric and has the form discussed in section 4.2. The spherical components of Ii follow from eqs. (4.8), (4.25), and (4.49) as
if = (d)-’ sin p e”“’’)
, Ii =cos
p
(4.59)
with a and p functions of r only. As a result, the effective potential V, is axisymmetric; when compared with the texture for a bulk uniform sample with p = 0 , the transverse potential
V,
=
t sin’ p
(4.60)
is positive (“repulsive”) and raises the NMR above the (bulk) signal at the Larmor frequency wo, whereas the longitudinal potential
y, = cosz p
(4.61)
lies below that for a bulk uniform sample with p = 0 (“attractive”) and lowers the NMR below the (bulk) signal at 0,.Solutions in such axisymmetric potentials can be classified by their angular dependence [exp(imc$)], and eq. (4.57) shows that only the axisymmetric modes with m = 0 couple to the uniform rf field. It is convenient to deal first with the transverse modes, which have been studied in considerable detail (for theoretical work, see Hakonen and Volovik 1982, Theodorakis and Fetter 1983, Jacobsen and Smith 1983, Maki and Nakahara 1983; for experimental work, see Hakonen et al. 1983a, b). For axisymmetric modes, eq. (4.53) reduces t o a one-dimensiona1 equation
-
where T , , = G, T - i and k has been set equal to one. In a stationary container, the potential sin’ p follows the discussion below eq. (4.26) and from fig. 3; typically, it is quadratic near the center of the container, with exponentially small curvature, and rises within a surface layer of thickness &,(-GR) to its boundary value 0.8 [compare eq. (4.26)]. As a first approximation, the potential near the center of the cylinder can be
Ch. 1, §4]
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ‘He
39
replaced by a parabola ( plr)2,where p, is proportional to the curvature and has the dimension of an inverse length. In this way, eq. (4.62) describes an effective two-dimensional harmonic oscillator. The characteristic length (4.63) determines the spatial scale of the approximate eigenfunctions, and the resulting approximate eigenvalues are equally spaced, with transverse NMR absorption occurring at the approximate frequencies
where n = 0 , 1 , 2 , . . . . In this approximation, the intensity of the nth normal mode relative to a bulk sample of area ?rRZis given by
I,,lI,,,, = 4 r : / R 2 .
(4.65)
As expected from the role of r , in setting the scale of the wave functions, this ratio is of order ( r l / R ) 2 ;its independence of n arises from a cancellation between the increasing size of the harmonic-oscillator wavefunction and the reduced overlap integral, which does not hold for the exact eigenfunctions. The observations of transverse NMR in stationary cylinders (Hakonen et al. 1983a) agree qualitatively with this approximate theory; in particular, a set of nearly equally spaced absorption peaks is seen above the Larmor frequency, but the intensity falls off with increasing n. To incorporate the deviations from the harmonic-oscillator model, Jacobsen and Smith (1983) have integrated eq. (4.62) numerically, using the exact equilibrium ti texture for various stationary cylinders (recall fig. 3); fig. 5 shows a typical spin-wave eigenfunction found for the exact sin’ p and (for comparison) the corresponding approximate potential with equal curvature at the origin. In detail, the exact solutions differ significantly from the approximate ones, and the data clearly support the numerical studies. The same description also holds for a rotating cylinder, since (see section 4.2) the dominant effect of the induced vortex lines is to modify the equilibrium ti texture. As noted below eq. (4.35), rotation with d parallel to l&,increases the curvature p, of the polar angle P ( r ) near the center of the cylinder and hence increases the splitting of the transverse spin-wave modes relative to that in a stationary cylinder [see eq. (4.64)]. This qualitative effect [first suggested by Maki and Nakahara (1983) and analyzed in detail by Hakonen and Volovik (1982)J agrees well with the observa-
A.L. FETTER
ICh. 1 . 14
Fig. 5 . Effective potential sin' p (solid line) and a typical spin-wave eigenfunction (dotted line) for nonrotating 'He-B in a cylinder of radius R = 56,. For comparison. an approximate quadratic potential (dashed line) with equal curvature at the origin is also shown (Jacobsen and Smith 1983. reprinted by permission of the authors and Plenum Press).
tions of Hakonen et al. (1983a). In practice. extensive numerical studies are required to determine: (1) the equilibrium ti texture in a rotating cylinder for given values of H , R, R, 6 , . A and K , and (2) the position and intensity of the corresponding transverse NMR satellites above the Larmor frequency. In this way. Hakonen et al. (1983b) have determined the parameters A and K as a function of temperature at 29.3 bar, as shown in fig. 4 (this figure also includes data obtained for NMR experiments in tipped magnetic fields, which provides clearer separation of A and K ) . The most striking feature of the data is the discontinuity at TIT, = 0.6, which is interpreted as arising from a first-order phase transition in the vortex core (since, as discussed in sections 4.1 and 4.2, the core structure determines the parameters A and K ) . More recent NMR experiments (mentioned in Pekola et al. 1984) have mapped out this transition in the p T plane (see fig. 6); it appears to approach the normal-superfluid transition line near the polycritical point (about 20 bar), but the small value of the NMR shift in the GL regime makes quantitative studies difficult. At present, there is no general agreement on the character of this phase transition, and much additional effort will be required. This question remains one of the outstanding problems associated with rotating 'He-B.
Ch. 1, 541
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He 10
I
1 ’He
“1
I
SOLID
2.0
1.5 T
41
25
3.0
(mlo
Fig. 6. Observed transitionsin’He-B. The Odenote the transition seen in fig. 4usingNMR; the + and denote that inferred with the gyroscopic techniques (Pekola et al. 1984, reprinted by permission of the authors and the American Physical Society).
Pekola et al. (1984) have studied the same phenomenon with a rotating powder-filled torus that performs torsional oscillations. As seen in fig. 6, the resulting phase transition differs somewhat from that determined with NMR. The gyroscopic measurements presumably involve vortex lines in small interstices, which need not be similar to those in the open geometry used for the NMR experiments. Thus the precise connection between the two techniques remains unclear. The same formalism also describes longitudinal NMR in rotating cylinders (Theodorakis and Fetter 1983), although the corresponding experiments have not been performed. The principal difference from eq. (4.62) for the transverse spin-value modes is the appearance of the longitudinal potential cos2 p, which is always negative relative to the bulk value for p = 0 and is most attractive near the boundary where cos2 p = 0.2. Thus the longitudinal spin-wave modes are concentrated at the outer edge of the cylinder and could provide a useful probe of boundary conditions. As in the case of the transverse modes, the effect of rotation occurs through the change in the overall equilibrium ri texture, which correspondingly alters the position and spacing of the spin-wave eigenvalues. Since the same ri texture determines both the transverse and longitudinal “potentials”, experimental detection of the longitudinal resonances would help confirm the present theoretical picture of the rotating B phase. In principle, other techniques could detect the vortex lines in rotating 3 He-B (or in turbulent B-phase counterflow). Two obvious possibilities
A.L. FETTER
42
[Ch. 1, $5
that have been suggested for the A phase (see section 5.4) are ions and zero sound. In each case, the intrinsic A-phase anisotropy of ionic mobility and zero-sound attenuation plays a crucial role, whereas these properties are effectively isotropic in the B phase. Thus ions in 'He-B are more likely to behave as in 4He, where trapping on the vortex cores is the central feature (see, for example, Fetter 1976). It must be noted that the ionic radius is of order 10-20 8, in both liquids; this value is large compared with the vortex core (a few A) in 4He, yet small compared with that in 3He-B (a few hundred A). Mineev and Salomaa (1984) predict that the attractive potential between the B-phase vortex and the ion is rather small, suggesting that vortices in rotating 'He-B will at best trap ions only weakly. Experiments at the Helsinki University of Technology plan to study this question in detail, and additional theoretical work will doubtless be required.
5. Vortices in superfluid 'He-A In the A phase, the order parameter is intrinsically more complicated than in the B phase, and properties such as the hydrodynamic variables and the free-energy density merit separate consideration (section 5.1). The resulting rich internal structure of the order parameter allows both singular and nonsingular vortices, with various quantum numbers for the circulation (section 5.2). The NMR spectrum for these vortices is studied in section 5.3, and other possible detection techniques are discussed in section 5.4.
5.1. GENERAL PROPERTIES OF 'HE-A In the A phase of superfluid 'He, the triplet p-wave order parameter A P j factorizes into a direct product of vectors, a real one for the spin component p. and a complex one for the orbital component j
As in eq. (4.2), the overall coefficient A ( T ) is a temperature-dependent amplitude, given in the GL regime by
A: = a / 4 P 2 , , .
(5.2)
In contrast, the remaining (intrinsically complex) structure of the order parameter for the stationary bulk A phase is very different from the real rotation matrix of the stationary bulk B phase. Specifically, the unit vector
Ch. 1, 551
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
43
d is perpendicular to the unit spin of the Cooper pairs, which will be important (section 5.3)in understanding the NMR. In addition, the orbital part of the order parameter consists of two orthogonal unit vectors A, and A,, combined in the complex form A, + id,. This structure incorporates a preferred sense of rotation, defined with the right-hand rule by a third orthogonal unit vector i= A, X A,; thus A,, A,, and i constitute an orthonormal triad. Apart from its overall magnitude A( T), complete specification of the A-phase order parameter involves the orientation of the unit vector 2 and the orthonormal triad A,, A,, and i, all of which can vary in space, depending on the boundaries and external perturbations. The unit vector i has the physical interpretation as the orbital angular momentum of the Cooper pair. Furthermore, the energy gap in the A phase is anisotropic, with uniaxial symmetry relative to the local direction of i and magnitude given by A( T) sin(&), where O,, is the angle between i and the direction i on the Fermi surface. Note that A( T) is the maximum energy gap, occurring at the equator of the Fermi sphere, with nodes at the poles (defined relative to i). These nodes lead to special and unexpected divergences in the low-temperature hydrodynamics (Cross 1975, Brinkman and Cross 1978), and it remains an interesting challenge to detect such be.havior experimentally (for example, by applying sufficiently large magnetic fields to stabilize the A phase for all temperatures below T,). To interpret the remaining orbital vectors A, and A,, it is first necessary to consider several matters of principle (see, for example, Mermin 1978): How is the supertluid velocity v, defined? What constitutes a vortex in the A phase? What contributes to the mass supercurrent j , and associated angular momentum density r X j,? For simplicity, consider the special case of a constant i vector (i= i), and a constant orbital order parameter f + i j . If this system then undergoes a uniform translation with velocity
v, = hk/2m,
(5.3)
[compare the discussion above eq. (2.1)], the resulting orbital vector in the order parameter merely acquires an additional phase factor
A,
+ i s , = e""(i + i j ) ,
(5.4a)
which follows either from the GL kinetic-energy density (3.3) and the corresponding expression for the mass current (see, for example, Fetter 1975), or from the general properties of Galilean transformations (Ho 1978a, Mermin 1978). A simple calculation shows that this expression can be rewritten as
A.L. FE’ITER
44
A,
+ iA2 = [icos(k
*
(Ch. 1, $5
r ) - y sin(k r ) ]
+ i [ i sin(k. r ) + j
-
cos(k r ) ] ,
(5.4b)
which represents a rotation of complex vector pair i + i j about the i-axis through a spatially varying angle - k r. Thus the orbital part of the order parameter acquires a helical form, analogous to the polarization vectors for circularly polarized light, with i as the symmetry axis. More generally, uniform flow with velocity usinduces a spatial rotation of the orbital part of the order parameter about the orthogonal direction i, with magnitude -(2m,u,lh) r. For many purposes, it is preferable to use the equivalent prescription
-
-
which defines the superfluid velocity even for nonuniform flow. Substitution of eqs. (5.1) and (5.4a) for constant 2 into the G L kinetic-energy density (3.3) for equal K,’s yields
Use of eq. (5.3) shows that the superfluid density tensor p, has the general form
This A-phase anisotropy, which holds outside the G L regime, is of relative order unity. The preceding treatment considered only the special case of a constant i vector, but i t is not difficult to allow for spatial variations. Equation (5.5) continues to define the superfluid velocity; in contrast, the supercurrent now contains additional terms (similar to the c curl M contribution to the electromagnetic current in a nonuniform ferromagnet) j , = p,u,
+ C curl 1 .
(5.8)
Here, the tcnsor C has a form similar to p, in eq. (5.7a)
c,,= c:q,
A
-
^
C0lll,,
(5.9a)
Ch. 1 , 851
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
45
where (in the GL regime)
C = 4(h/2m3)p,,, C, = 2C,
(5.9b)
and the generalization to lower temperatures merely renormalizes the various coefficients in eq. (5.8) (Cross 1975, Brinkman and Cross 1978). The same situation holds for the gradient contribution to the free-energy density (including spatial variations of 2). It can be expressed either in the GL form near T, [substituting eq. (5.1) into eq. ( 3 . 3 ) ] , or in the “hydrodynamic” form
which holds throughout the A-phase region of thep-T plane. Near T,, the various coefficients are readily expressed in terms of the three GL bending coefficients { K , } , and the generalization to lower temperatures (including Fermi-liquid corrections) can be found in Cross (1975), Brinkman and Cross (1978), Fetter (1979) and Fetter et al. (1983). Equations (5.8) and (5.10) together constitute the “hydrodynamic” theory that is valid wherever the order parameter retains its A-phase form in eq. (5.1). This approximate description requires that the various unit vectors d, Al,A’, and i vary slowly on the scale of the coherence length; it ceases to hold in singular regions, where eq. (5.1) fails. The hydrodynamic theory has the virtue of providing an explicit form for the free-energy density, but it involves a potential source of confusion. Specifically, usand i appear to be independent orbital variables (implying five distinct orbital parameters, since i is a unit vector), when, in fact, specification of the orbital part of the order parameter requires only three independent parameters (since it is equivalent to a rigid orthonormal triad). Thus the set us and i must obey additional constraints, which have the form (Mermin and Ho 1976) a;u,, - aju,; = ( h / 2 m 3 ) i (a;i . x dji).
(5.11)
This Mermin-Ho condition generalizes the irrotational condition ( 2 . 3 ) on usin superfluid 4He (and in the B phase). In the present case of 3He-A,eq. (5.11) shows that the superfluid vorticity no longer vanishes identically;
46
A.L. FETTER
[Ch. 1 , 05
instead, it is fully determined by the spatial variations of the 1^ vector. Although curl usindeed vanishes for a uniform i texture, the more general situation will be of great interest in connection with vortices in the rotating A phase. For superfluid 4He, the phase function @ characterizes the single degree of freedom associated with the order parameter at a given temperature T. Its relation to usis made explicit in eq. (2.1), which automatically enforces the irrotational condition in eq. (2.3). The same general relation applies to the B phase, for, apart from the deformation near the vortex core, the phase function @ again characterizes the single degree of freedom in the order parameter. However, the situation is more complicated for 3He-A because the orbital triad has three distinct degrees of freedom. For many purposes, it is helpful to introduce specific parametrizations for the orbital variables; this will be seen to enforce the Mermin-Ho condition automatically. Among the various ways to characterize the orientation of the orbital triad relative to some fixed reference set i ,y^, i,the Euler angles a,p, and y (see fig. 7, and Fetter and Walecka 1980, section 29) are especially convenient, but one must be aware of possible spurious singularities in 1y if sin p vanishes (Mermin 1978, section 111, Mermin 1979, p. 596). In the
I
/
I/
/
I I
I
I
Fig. 7 . Schematic diagram of the Euler angles a.Band y , used to define the orientation of the orbital triad for superfluid 'He-A.
Ch. 1, SS]
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
47
familiar quantum-mechanics convention (Edmonds 1957), the angles p and a are the usual spherical-polar coordinates of the vector i on the unit sphere, with p the polar angle relative to i, and a the azimuthal angle relative to i .The remaining angle y then represents an additional rotation about the direction i. To be precise, define the auxiliary orthonormal triad
i=
(i cos a
+j
sin a ) sin p
+ i cos p ,
rii = (icos a + j sin a ) cos p i = -i sin (Y
+j
- i sin
p,
(5.12)
cos (Y .
The full orbital part of the order parameter in eq. (5.1) then has the representation
A1 + iA, = e-'Y(i
+i i ) ,
(5.13)
so that spatial variations of the Eule! angles induce corresponding variations in the order parameter A, + id,. To relate the superfluid velocity to the Euler angles, recall that the superfluid velocity at some point r in 4He was defined in terms of the change in the order parameter on moving from r to some nearby point r + Sr [see eq. (2.2)]. A similar approach will apply for 3He-A, but the details are more complicated naturally. It is evident that the infinitesimal change in the rigid orbital triad must represent an infinitesimal rotation Sa proportional to Sr. Since an infinitesimal rotation acts like a vector (Fetter and Walecka 1980, section 7), S a can be decomposed by projecting it onto the original orthonormal triad. The part of Sn perpendicular to i corresponds to a change in the direction of i,correctly requiring two free parameters because iis a unit vector. The remaining part of S f l parallel to i represents a rotation about the local direction i, with magnitude S a i. The discussion below eq. (5.4b) relates this local rotation of the orbital triad about i to the superfluid velocity
-
(5.14a)
-
and elementary geometry shows that Sa i = Sy + cos p &a (see fig. 7). Comparison of these expressions yields the fundamental result (5.14b) which also follows from eqs. ( 5 . 5 ) and (5.13). This relation replaces the
A.L. FEITER
48
(Ch. 1, 55
simpler eqs. (2.1) for ‘He and (4.5a) for 3He-B; it has several striking features: ( 1 ) Whenever the spatial variations of the orbital triad involve a local rotation about the direction i. there is a corresponding local superfluid velocity us and vice versa. (2) The superfluid vorticity does not, in general, vanish. Instead, a direct calculation gives curl u, = sin p (Vp x Va),
(5.15)
so that nonzero curl u, requires simultaneous changes in both a and p. Apart from singularities in the third Euler angle y, the superfluid vorticity is wholly determined by i a n d its derivatives [see eq. (5.12)], which merely restates the Mermin-Ho (1976) condition from eq. (5.11). This distributed vorticity differs qualitatively from the line singularities of the B phase and superfluid 4He. (3) The angles a and y a r e “phase-like”, in that the single-valuedness of the orientation of the orbital triad requires them to return to their original values modiilo 2~ on traversing some closed path C in the fluid. Thus the superfluid circulation us d s in the A phase involves a quantized part [from the first term of eq. (5.14b)], and another (in general) nonquantized part because of the presence of the factor cos p in the second term of eq. (5.14b). This nonquantized circulation in ’He-A is a direct consequence of the distributed superfluid vorticity. Two other contributions to the free-energy density from section 3 must be rewritten in specific A-phase form. The first is the dipole-energy density f,. Direct substitution of the A-phase order parameter (5.1) into eq. (3.5) yields an irrelevant isotropic term and the following orienting term
I,. -
fd =
-2g,AZ,(d-
i)’ ,
(5.16a)
which explicitly exhibits the coupling between the spin and orbital degrees of freedom. More generally, eqs. (3.6) and (5.7) can reexpress fd in hydrodynamic form fd
=
-~Pa(ti/2rn,)’l,,2(d.i)l1
(5.16b)
which holds outside the GL regime. The dipole coupling acts to align d and l” in a bulk fluid, and deviations from this oriented configuration are expected only within small regions of characteristic size L, (=lo p n ) . The other contribution to the energy arises from the magnetic freeenergy density (3.7), which, for the A phase, becomes
Ch. 1. 851
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
f ,= 2g,A:(d
- H)’ .
49
(5.17a)
Evidently, the magnetic field tends to orient d perpendicular to its local direction. Using eq. (3.8) and the previous relations yields the equivalent (but more general) hydrodynamic form
f,
=
~ ~ l l ( f i 1 2 m , ) 2 ( H / H , L ,ri)’ ) 2 ( d. ~
(5.17b)
Comparison of eqs. (5.16b) and (5.17b) indicates that the orienting effect of the magnetic field predominates if H 9 Hd,in which case d tends to lie in the plane perpendicular to 8 ;the dipole coupling then orients i along d, apart from regions of characteristic size L,. In the hydrodynamic (or “London”) theory (Mermin 1978) of 3He-A, the spin vector d and the orbital triad serve as dynamical variables whose spatial orientations vary slowly on the scale of the GL coherence length (3.4). The corresponding total hydrodynamic free-energy density, given by the sum of eqs. (5.10), (5.16b) and (5.17b), holds throughout the A-phase region of the p - T plane. Since this description assumes that the order parameter retains its A-phase form, it can never provide a full description of singular regions, such as singular vortex cores, where the order parameter deviates significantly from eq. (5.1). In such cases (discussed in section 5 . 2 ) , the full G L theory from section 3 must be used to incorporate local regions with more general order parameters, as was done in section 4.1 for the (non-B-phase) core of a vortex in the B phase. Unfortunately, this latter approach is restricted to the vicinity of T , , and the construction of a uniform theory throughout the phase diagram remains for future investigations. Apart from a few special cases, the hydrodynamic theory suffices for a description of vortices in rotating 3He-A. Near the phase transition, it explicitly reduces to the G L form, but it otherwise includes Fermi-liquid corrections and the anisotropic energy gap (Cross 1975, Brinkman and Cross 1978). Near the melting pressure, the various hydrodynamic coefficients have been evaluated explicitly (Fetter 1979, Williams 1979), and Fetter et al. (1983) provide a brief table. The gradient energy (5.10) assumes that d and i are independent, each with its own set of bending coefficients. If they each vary slowly on the scale of L,, however, the dipole energy (5.16) locks them together. Equation (5.10) can then be simplified considerably by setting d = i; the resulting expression retains the same form (omitting the last two terms) but with renormalized dipole-locked bending coefficients KI or K L , also tabulated in Fetter et al. (1983).
A.L. FETTER
50
[Ch. 1. $5
The equilibrium configuration of 'He-A in a rotating container is determined by minimizing the total free energy in the rotating frame. The general transformation to a reference frame in uniform motion is slightly intricate. involving both Galilean and Legendre transformations (Ho 1978a. b, Mermin 1978). One unusual feature for 'He-A is that both the normal and superfluid densities are anisotropic [see eq. (5.7)]. Similar considerations apply to a frame in uniform rotation. Detailed calculations, analogous to those in eqs. (2.7)-(2.9) for 'He, verify that the normal component executes solid-body rotation (2.6) (Fujita et al. 1978, Williams and Fetter 1979); furthermore, the transformed free-energy densityfin the rotating frame follows from f f o r 0 = u, = 0 with a simple substitution. In the GL regime, the gradients V in eq. (3.3) are replaced by V i(2rn3lh)l2 X r, analogous to the minimal gauge substitution in the Schrodinger equation for a charged particle in a uniform magnetic field. In the hydrodynamic theory, the superfluid velocity us is replaced by the relative velocity u, - u,, and an additional additive term can be omitted, as in eq. (2.9). Although the normal-fluid corrections are generally small, they are important in comparing the free energy of different proposed vortex configurations.
5.2. SPECIFIC VORTICES
IN
'HE-A
Consider a long cylinder of radius R( % Ld) filled with liquid 3He in the normal phase. When cooled slowly into the superfluid A phase, the system is expected to attain the state of lowest free energy. If the container is at rest in zero magnetic field, the resulting texture, first studied in detail by Mermin and Ho (1976), has unit quantized circulation about the boundary, even though it remains nonsingular throughout the container. Suppose instead that the container rotates at fixed angular velocity about its symmetry axis. When cooled into the superfluid A phase at constant 0 (and again zero field), the Mermin-Ho (MH) texture persists essentially unchanged up to a (generally low) critical angular velocity = 10(h/2rn3R'), above which the texture changes to one with three units of circulation at the boundary, still remaining nonsingular everywhere (Williams and Fetter 1979). For somewhat larger angular velocities, the sequence of states is not known, but the situation eventually becomes simple when the total circulation about the boundary contains many quanta (0B @,). In this latter case, the boundary plays a negligible role, and the system can be treated as a bulk rotating fluid. For zero magnetic field and moderate rotation speeds, a square array of nonsingular textures, similar to that proposed by Mermin and H o (1976), is believed to have the lowest free energy. At still higher angular speeds (0>O.lh/2m3L; =
n,,
Ch. 1, 151
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
51
30 rad/s), a transition to a triangular lattice of singular vortices has been predicted (Fetter et al. 1983), and similar classes of singular states should persist up to the upper critical field OC2= h/8m3,f2(of order 10" rad/s), when the singular cores of radius 6 begin to overlap (Schopohl 1980). The situation is quite different in large magnetic fields (H %- H d ) parallel to the rotation axis, since (as seen below) the MH texture is strongly suppressed. In this case, the overall texture has b and i predominantly uniform and aligned in the plane perpendicular to H,but with isolated vortex cores of characteristic dimension L, = 10 km arranged on a (presumably triangular) lattice (Volovik and Hakonen 1981, Salomaa and Volovik 1983a). In principle, these cores can be either singular (and singly quantized) or nonsingular (and doubly quantized). Theoretically, the former seem to have lower free energy, but (see section 5.3) experiments (Seppala et al. 1984) provide strong evidence for the latter textures. This discrepancy remains unresolved. Since a magnetic field has a dramatic effect on the rotating A phase, it is helpful to consider separately the two limiting cases of H I H , G 1 and Bl. The following discussion will amplify the preceding brief summary, paying particular attention to the difference between singular and nonsingular textures. 5.2.1. Singular and nonsingular textures As noted in section 5.1, an orbital texture in 3He-A is specified by giving the orientation of the rigid orthonormal triad A,, A2, and i at every point of the fluid. A nonsingular texture is one for which the configuration is well defined everywhere, whereas a singular texture typically has one or more regions where the orientation has different values depending on the path used to reach the particular point in question. This idea is familiar in the case of supertluid 4He and 3He-B, where the phase variable CP is equivalent to the orientation of a unit vector in a plane. Figure 1 illustrates various singular configurations for circulation p = ? 1; each different integral circulation state represents a distinct type of singularity, implying an infinite set, one for each integer. The situation can be clarified by recognizing that the phase variable @ is topologically equivalent to the angular variable around the circumference of a circle or a cylinder. On traversing a single closed path in physical space, the single-valuedness requires that CP return either to its original value or to one that differs by 2 r p , where the integer p characterizes the number of times that the phase angle increases by 2 r . Thus a p-fold circulation in 4He is analogous to a rubber band wrapped p times around a cylinder, and states with different winding numbers p are topologically distinct, because they cannot be
A.L. FEITER
S2
[Ch. 1. 55
continuously deformed into each other (in other words, without cutting the rubber band). To appreciate the crucial role of the order parameter’s intrinsic structure, consider a Heisenberg ferromagnet. The effective order parameter is now a three-dimensional spin vector with fixed length, whose orientation is equivalent to the position on the surface of a unit sphere. This system differs profoundly from the previous one, for a rubber band around the equator of a sphere can be removed merely by pulling it to one pole. As a result, a ferromagnet has no stable line defects (Mermin 1979). For 3He-A, the remarkable new feature is that it has only a small number of distinct singularities or defects, and many apparently different textures are. in fact, topologically equivalent. In particular, if 2 and i are dipole-locked, a general theorem (Volovik and Mineev 1977, Mermin 1978, 1979) asserts that there are only two distinct defects, with quantum numbers zero and one; all other configurations can be continuously deformed into one or the other of these. Although explicit construction of such deformations is rarely easy, the general theory ensures their existence. The Euler angles (fig. 7) provide a useful way to think about this question. The angle /3 ranges from 0 to n-, but the angles a and y can increase without limit and are analogous to the phase angle Q, for superfluid ‘He. Many of the unusual properties of 3He-A arise from the presence of two such functions in specifying the orbital order parameter. In general, line singularities in a or y lead to vortices and singular textures, and several different possibilities exist. Suppose that a and /3 are constant (so that i is constant). The superfluid velocity then becomes [see eq. (5.14b)l u, = - ( h / 2 m 3 ) V y ,
(5.18a)
essentially the same as eqs. (2.1) and (4.5a) for ‘He and 3He-B. Thus any singularity in y produces a “phase” vortex, with quantized circulation. A simple example is to take 7 = -PdJ + Y”
7
(5.18b)
where 4 is the polar angle in cylindrical coordinates. The resulting circulating velocity p f i /2m,r represents a p-fold quantized vortex line, whose divergent behavior near the center forces the order parameter to vanish for r + 0. This “normal” core is analogous to that for the o vortex in ‘He-B [see the discussion below eq. (4.18)]. A second important case is to take y constant, so that U, =
- ( h /2rn,) cos p V a
( 5.19a)
Ch. 1 , 551
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
53
Generally, a line singularity in a produces both a singular superflow (unless cos P vanishes there) and [see eq. (5.12)] a singular i texture (unless sin /3 vanishes there). In any case, however, the free-energy density diverges at the singularity, which represents the vortex core. One simple example is to take a
= p 4 + 010
9
P = P(r)
7
(5.19b)
where P ( r ) increases smoothly from f T at the center to 7r far from the core. Thus i = -? asymptotically, and the corresponding superfluid velocity looks like a p-fold quantized vortex line. With decreasing r , however, i rotates to a horizontal orientation, so that u, in eq. (5.19a) is everywhere bounded. Nevertheless, the texture is still singular because i itself has a “disgyration” (shown in’fig. 1 for p = ?1). Muzikar (1978) has considered various possible core structures for p = 1 and finds that an A-phase radial disgyration changes continuously into the “polar” phase for r < 6. Since the polar phase is not found in bulk superfluid 3He, this behavior is similar to that of the v vortex in the B phase. The preceding discussion shows that singularities in either a or y typically generate singular textures, and the same situation usually holds if a and y both have singularities. In certain cases, however, the singularities cancel, leaving a nonsingular texture that varies smoothly throughout the fluid. This possibility arises because the rotations labeled by a and y are equivalent if P = 0, so that only the sum a + y is relevant. In this case, the superfluid velocity in eq. (5.14b) contains only V ( a + y ) , and opposite singularities in a and y can therefore yield a nonsingular us. One simple and important example is the MH texture (fig. 8a), in which the orbital triad lies along i ,y^, i at the center, with i upward in the vortex core. To define the global configuration, move outward in a radial direction, rotating the triad by 17r about the azimuthal direction; consequently, far from the center, i points radially outward. It is evident that the resulting texture is nonsingular everywhere, yct an examination of fig. 8a shows that the orbital triad executes a single negative rotation about the (radial) i direction on moving once around a large circle at infinity. Thus, by the discussion of eq. (5.14a), there is a net circulating superfluid velocity at infinity with unit quantum number ( p = 1). It is not difficult to see that this MH texture has the equivalent Euler-angle representation
where p ( 0 ) = 0 and P ( r ) = i7r for r + = . velocity is
The corresponding superfluid
[Ch. 1, 85
A.L. FETTER
54
E ?
*
--*
(a)
Fig. 8. Typical nonsingular singly quantized vortices in 'He-A. The orientation of the orbital triad at different locations shows the rotation of I from vertical at the center to horizontal far away, as well as the single negative asymptotic rotation about ion once encircling the core. Neither (a) the Mermin-Ho (1976) texture nor (b) the mixt-twist texture (Ho 1978a) can tile the plane by itself.
with distributed vorticity ( h/2rn,r) sinp (dp/dr)z^. Since p ( r ) approaches was r--* z.u, looks asymptotically like a singly quantized vortex; near the origin, however, P ( r ) tends linearly to 0, and u, vanishes smoothly. In addition, i i s uniform in the core region, so that the MH texture is indeed nonsingular. With the additional assumption of dipole locking (2 = i),the resulting texture is believed to represent the ground state of 3He-A in a long cylinder of radius R >> L, and zero magnetic field, because it
Ch. 1, 551
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
55
automatically satisfies the boundary condition that i be normal to the walls. Apart from nonunitary corrections that are important only in the currently unattainable regime R 6 506 (Passvogel et al. 1984), the order parameter retains its A-phase form everywhere. Thus the hydrodynamic theory is applicable, and detailed calculations show that P ( r ) increases nearly linearly from the center to the outer boundary (Buchholtz and Fetter 1977). The resulting orientational part of the free energy per unit length is independent of R, because the spatial derivatives (of order R - ), cancel the R Zfactor from the cross-sectional area. This texture is also interesting because it has a permanent ground-state orbital angular momentum =( p , / p ) h per particle. More generally, adding a constant a, to a in eq. (5.20a) rotates i uniformly about the z^ direction by angle a, [see fig. 1 for several different values of a,; Maki (1983) and Zotos and Maki (1984) have called the textures for 0 and T “radial”, and that for ;T “circular”]. Although such textures obviously violate the boundary conditions for a cylinder, they are of interest as candidates for vortices in the rotating A phase. In addition, they have different divergence and curl, and hence different free energies, even though us remains unaffected. Detailed calculations (Fetter et al. 1983) incorporating particle conservation show that a,, near + T minimizes the free energy, but the numerical differences are not large. Anderson and Toulouse (1977) have suggested another, closely related, nonsingular texture; it differs from eq. (5.20a) and fig. 8a only in the asymptotic boundary condition that P ( r ) = IT for r - w . Equation (5.20b) shows that the Anderson-Toulouse vortex is doubly quantized asymptotically, yet it again has distributed vorticity and remains nonsingular throughout the fluid. As will be seen below, these vortices can tile the plane, because their asymptotic i texture is uniform, in contrast to the MH vortices, whose asymptotic i texture involves a net rotation. One other nonsingular texture is important, in which i points down at the center, so that P ( 0 ) = T . The superfluid velocity in the core [eq. (5.14b)l now involves V ( a - y ) , and the two phase-like angles now must have the same singularities to produce a nonsingular texture. A particular example [called “mixt-twist” by Ho (1978a) and “hyperbolic” by Maki (1983) and by Zotos and Maki (1984)] arises from the choice
’
(5.2 1a) with boundary values P ( 0 ) = 7~ and p ( r ) = 4 T for r ing superfluid velocity
0s.
The correspond-
(5.21b)
A.L. FETTER
56
[Ch. 1, $5
again looks asymptotically like a singly quantized positive ( p = 1) vortex with distributed vorticity throughout the core. The mixt-twist (MT) i texture is analogous to the phase pattern in fig. Id, since the 1 vector at infinity rotates once in the negative sense on once encircling the origin (see fig. 8b). Although both the MH and MT textures have uniform and continuous cores, it is evident that they have very different asymptotic symmetries. These particular nonsingular textures with asymptotic circulation by no means exhaust the various possibilities, and other qualitatively different nonsingular configurations will be considered in connection with high magnetic fields. At present, however, these structures suffice for a description of rotating superfluid 'He-A in low magnetic fields.
5.2.2. Textures in low magneric fields The transformation to the free-energy density f for 'He-A in a frame rotating with constant angular velocity Oi has been considered at the end of section 5. I . As in the analogous case for 'He [see the discussion below eq. (2.11)]. the bulk rotating A phase is expected to have an array of vortices, arranged on a regular lattice. If each unit cell has a net superfluid circulation ph/2m3, then eq. (4.6a) shows that its area is A,
=
rph/2m3R.
(5.22)
The order parameter will depend only on the two-dimensional coordinate r in the xy-plane, and i and u, - u, both must have the periodicity of the lattice. In particular [see eq. (5.12)], the Euler angle a(.) should be periodic modulo 2 7 ~ .If, in addition, a ( r ) is continuous, the same arguments used in obtaining eq. (2.12) imply that Va - ( r q / A C ) ix r must be periodic, where the integer q is the net winding number of a on once encircling the unit cell (in general, q differs from the circulation quantum p mentioned above, since p involves the winding numbers of both a and y ). Since Va is strictly periodic, the second term violates this periodicity unless q = 0 (or a is not continuous, contradicting the initial assumption). For example. neither the MH nor the M T vortices can form lattices by themselves, because each has a net winding number in a, with q # 0. A texture with no net winding number of a has been proposed independently by H o (1978a) and by Fujita et al. (1978). in which a ( r ) has p = 1 singularities at the corners of a square lattice and p = - 1 singularities at the center of each square (fig. 9). The unit cell contains equal numbers of positive and negative singularities, so that the net circulation of a vanishes. In addition. t h e i texture flares upward at the
Ch. 1. 551
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
57
p = 1 singularities (0’s in fig. 9), and downward at the p = - 1 singularities ( X’S in fig. 9), with the polar angle p(r) having the symmetry of the lattice. This i texture (called “type-I” by Fujita et al. 1978) can be considered as a pair of interpenetrating square lattices (like two-dimensional NaCI), one with MH textures (the 0’s in fig. 9) and on with MT textures (the X ’ S in fig. 9). The preceding analysis of these separate structures shows that the overall i texture has finite elastic energy density everywhere; to ensure that us is also finite, it suffices merely to choose the remaining Euler angle y ( r ) to have p = -1 singularities at both sets of sites. In effect, a given square contains two singly quantized vortices, and [see eq. (5.22)] the nearestneighbor separation between like vortices is b = ( ~ /m,O)”*, h because p = 2 in a given square cell. To calculate the free energy of this nonsingular vortex lattice, recall that the excess (gradient) free energy of a MH texture in a cylinder is independent of the cylinder’s radius R, because the polar angle /3 varies smoothly on the same characteristic scale R [see the discussion below eq. (5.20b)l. In effect, R serves as the core radius of the nonsingular texture. A similar situation holds here as well: the polar angle p ( r ) varies smoothly (on the scale of the lattice spacing b) from 0 at the up-sites to T at the down-sites, with b also determining the characteristic core size. Thus spatial gradients are of order b-’, and the quadratic character of fk in eq. (5.10) means that the free energy per unit cell integrated over the area bZis
Fig. 9. Type-I lattice of nonsingular singly quantized vortices in rotating ’He-A at low magnetic fields (Fujita et al. 1978). The unit cell encloses two MH (0sites) and two MT ( X sites) vortex textures, shown individually in fig. 8 (Fetter et al. 1983, reprinted by permission of the authors and the American Physical Society).
58
A.L. FETTER
[Ch. 1, 15
a sum of the various bending constants with dimensionless coefficients, independent of the parameter 6 . This property arises directly from the nonsingular nature of the texture, since, otherwise, additional length scales introduce logarithmic factors (as seen below for singular textures or nonzero magnetic fields). Fujita et al. (1978) have evaluated the dipolelocked free energy of the type-I lattice per unit cell numerically, explicitly incorporating the four-fold lattice symmetry. A simpler but approximate approach is the Wigner-Seitz (WS) model (Fetter et al. 1983). in which the MH and MT vortices are treated separately, each confined to circular cells of area A c / 2[see eq. (5.22)] and radius a, = (fi/2rn3R)”’,as in eq. (4.6b). For the currently available rotation speeds R ( s l rad/s), the WS cell radius a, (=lo0 pm) far exceeds L, (=lo pm). so that deviations from dipole locking are insignificant. In this regime, both calculations (Fujita et al. 1978, Fetter et al. 1983) conclude that the type-I lattice has lower free energy per quantum of circulation than other candidates [such as a triangular lattice of nonsingular Anderson-Toulouse doubly quantized vortices (Volovik and Kopnin 1977). described in the previous section, or specific singular vortices, to be considered below; both these vortices can tile the xy-plane since i = -2 far from the core]. In contrast to the scale invariance of the nonsingular vortices, singular vortices involve additional length scales associated with the internal structure. One important example is that in eq. (5.19) (called the z vortex by Fetter et al. 1983), where i and 2 are dipole-locked along -2 far from the core, with kinetic energy arising from the unit circulating velocity. For r s L,, however, the texture can lower the kinetic energy by rotating 1 from vertical to radial. at the cost of introducing dipole energy (since d remains along -i). The resulting radial disgyration in i has a singular div i near the origin, forcing the order parameter to change character from A phase to polar phase inside an inner core of characteristic radius 5 (Muzikar 1978). In the WS approximation, the resulting free energy per quantum of circulation has additional logarithmic factors proportional to In(a,/L,) and In(L,/,$). The first of these decreases with increasing angular speed, and detailed calculations show that a (presumably triangular) lattice of these z vortices becomes favored at a temperature-dependent angular velocity that rises rapidly with decreasing temperature from about 30 rad/s for T/ T , = 0.99. Since this angular velocity considerably exceeds current experimental ones, rotating ‘He-A in zero magnetic field should quite generally contain a type-I nonsingular vortex lattice. 5.2.3. Textures in high magnetic @el&
For rotating ‘He-A in a high magnetic field (H + H,),the magnetic energy
Ch. 1, ‘351
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ‘He
59
density (5.17) forces the 2 vector to lie perpendicular to H (assumed, for simplicity, parallel to the rotation axis 2; the more general case is discussed briefly at the end of this section). Furthermore, the curvature energy density [the last two terms of eq. (5.10)] acts to keep auniform, which can be assumed constant (2 = i , say) throughout most of the sample. The dipole coupling energy in eq. (5.16) then ensures that i is also essentially uniform, minimizing the corresponding part of the curvature energy (5.10). As seen in comparing eqs. (5.10) and (5.16), however, 2 and ican become unlocked within regions of characteristic size L,, where i deviates from its asymptotic uniform texture; this region represents the core of the high-field vortex [Volovik and Hakonen (1981), called the “soft core” by Salomaa and Volovik (1983a)l. In principle, also can deviate from i within the smaller distance L , ( H , / H ) ; in most cases, however, this effect turns out to be unimportant, and 2 is frequently assumed to be uniform throughout the fluid. Seppala and Volovik (1983) have proposed two remarkable candidates for the nonaxisymmetric vortex textures in rotating 3He-A in a large magnetic field. Both have a dipole-locked asymptotic region far from the core ( r % Ld), where i and 2 are uniform and parallel (say, to i ) .One of these is singly quantized and singular; its outer region can be obtained from that of the MH texture by rotating the orbital triad in fig. 8a about -i through the polar angle 4, thus rotating i from radial to the i direction (see fig. 1Oa). It is obvious by inspection that this modified texture still involves a single negative rotation of Al + iA2 about i ( = i )on once completing a large circle around the core, so that it indeed represents a singly quantized vortex [see eq. (5.4b) and the following discussion]. To avoid a divergent superfluid velocity in the core, an additional rotation of 1.. about the direction -A2 on moving radially inward brings A, parallel to i in the core (see fig. 10a). Consequently, the infinitesimal rotations near the center involve only a local reorientation of the direction i, ensuring that us vanishes there [see the discussion above eq. (5.14a)l. It is also clear from inspection of fig. 10a that this texture remains singular at the center, where i has no unique direction. For a quantitative analysis of this texture, it is convenient to parametrize the orbital part 8, + i& of the order parameter by
i1= i cos 7) - ( j sin 4 + i cos 4) sin 7 , &=jcos$-isin+,
(5.23a)
where this modified notation will facilitate comparison with eq. (5.24a) below. Here the angle T ( r ) varies smoothly from 0 near the origin to 1 mfor r S= L,, and a possible additive constant in the angle 4 has been omitted.
A.L. FE'ITER
[Ch. 1, 95
n' ?
(b)
Fig. 10. Typical nonaxisymmetric vortices proposed by Seppala and Volovik (1983) for rotating 'He-A in high magnetic fields. (a) Singular singly quantized texture (5.23) shows the single negative asymptotic rotation about i o n once encircling the core; the core clearly has singular structure. (b) Nonsingular doubly quantized texture (5.24) shows the double negative asymptotic rotation about ion once encircling the core; the core clearly has a unique structure.
The corresponding i texture and u, become (5.23b) confirming that the circulating velocity field looks asymptotically like a singly quantized vortex yet vanishes smoothly inside the core [compare the discussion below eq. (5.19)]. The singularity in the i vector for r % L ,
Ch. 1, §5]
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
61
means that the order parameter ultimately must depart from the A-phase form as r - 0 , like Muzikar's (1978) proposed polar core for a radial disgyration. It is also evident from fig. 10a that i deviates from d ( = i ) inside the core, and numerical studies (Seppala and Volovik 1983, Vulovic et al. 1984) based on the WS circular-cell model with constant d indicate that this core region has a radius of order 2Ld. The second high-field vortex texture proposed by Seppala and Volovik (1983) is doubly quantized and nonsingular. It is obtained from eq. (5.23a) by imposing an additional negative rotation about the local i direction
A,+ i6, = e'"(t, + i & ) ,
(5.24a)
at the core to 1 7 for ~ i, eq. (5.23b) continues t o describe i, but with the extended range for q. Specifically (see fig. lob), inow rotates continuously from i in the outer region to -i at the center; it remains in the xy-plane along certain radial directions, whereas it becomes vertical along certain others. The additional phase factor in eq. (5.24a) ensures that this vortex has two quanta of circulation far from the core, yet us is nonsingular, given everywhere by and by extending the parameter 77 to run from -
T
r B L,. Since this additional rotation is purely about
(5.24b)
Furthermore, the order parameter near the center is also nonsingular, with the orbital components z^ + i j . This last property exemplifies the previous assertion at the start of section 5.2 that 3He-A has only two distinct line defects (with quantum numbers 0 and 1). Detailed numerical studies (Seppala and Volovik 1983, Vulovic et al. 1984, Seppala et al. 1984) using the WS circular-cell model for uniform d indicate that the core radius fo: the doubly quantized nonsingular vortex is =4Ld, within which distance 1 deviates significantly from d = i . It is interesting to compare the free energy of these two different textures. Although the doubly quantized vortex has more circulating superflow and therefore more hydrodynamic kinetic energy, its nonsingular core has less energy than that of the singular vortex. Seppala and Volovik (1983) conclude that their singly quantized singular vortex has slightly lower free energy per quantum of circulation for currently accessible rotation speeds ("1 radis). They predicted a transition to a lattice of doubly quantized nonsingular vortices at a critical angular velocity of order 3 r a d / s near T / T c = 0 . 8 that increases slowly with increasing temperature, and Vulovic et al. (1984) confirmed this conclusion. Nevertheless, NMR experiments (section 5.3) indicate unambiguous-
62
A.L. F E T E R
(Ch. 1, 05
ly (Seppala et al. 1984) that rotating 'He-A in high fields indeed contains nonsingular vortices, with no evidence at all for singular ones. This discrepancy between theory and experiment remains unresolved. Figure 10b illustrates an important alternative view of the high-field doubly quantized vortex, for, by inspection, the i vector lies along the rotation axis in two regions (one up and one down). Locally, these regions are similar to the MH and MT vortices (figs. 8a, b); thus the overall texture in the core of the nonsingular doubly quantized vortex can be considered a bound pair of nonsingular singly quantized vortices ( H o 1978a, Zotos and Maki 1984, Maki and Zotos 1985a), neither of which can, by themselves, form a lattice because of topological constraints. Zotos and Maki (1984) have used this picture to construct a trial function for the high-field doubly quantized nonsingular texture and confirm the (relatively large) characteristic core size. Unfortunately, their intrinsically two-dimensional variational parametrization requires a more intricate numerical analysis than eq. (5.24a). Furthermore, they did not consider the alternative possibility of singular high-field vortices [see eq. (5.23)], and their different form of the free-energy density precludes direct comparison with the calculations of Seppala and Volovik (1983). On the other hand, Maki and Zotos (198Sa) have made a detailed analysis of ultrasonic attenuation by these nonsingular vortices, which will be considered as a potential detection scheme in section 5.4. Ohmi (1984) has extended this picture of a triangular lattice of bound pairs to include the orientation of the pair axis relative to that of the lattice. At present, such orientational effects remain unobservable. Volovik and Hakonen (1981) and Maki and Zotos (198Sb) have also considered a tipped magnetic field, whose principal effect is to orient perpendicular to both H and R. lifting the rotational degeneracy of i i n the xy-plane. In particular, Maki and Zotos (1985b) find that the separation of the bound-pair constituents decreases with increasing tipping angle. The resulting altered NMR signal (section 5.3) is consistent with the observations of Seppala et al. (1984). The equilibrium texture of rotating 3He-A evidently depends strongly on the magnetic field, and it is natural to consider the transition between the two extremes of low and high fields. Specifically, the low-field texture involves nonsingular dipole-locked MH and MT vortices, arranged on an interpenetrating square lattice (fig. 9), with the central core region of each vortex having a radius comparable to the lattice spacing. An axial magnetic field forces 2 toward the xy-plane, and the dipole coupling then pulls i along with it. This magnetic deformation shrinks the core and flattens the texture, retaining the fundamental four-fold symmetry. At some point, however, the free energy of this deformed type-I lattice exceeds that of the
Ch. 1 , SS]
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
63
doubly quantized Seppala-Volovik vortices [as seen in section 5.3, experiments of Seppala et al. (1984) conclusively rule out singly quantized high-field vortices]. Fetter (1985a) and Zotos and Maki (1985) have compared the free energy of these two configurations and conclude that a first-order transition occurs at a critical field of order H , that depends weakly on temperature and on the rotation speed. It remains an open question whether the low-field square lattice can instead dimerize and deform through shear into the high-field array of bound pairs.
5.3. NMR
IN ROTATING
3HE-A
Given the high-field texture from the preceding section, the corresponding NMR follows as in section 4.3 for the rotating B phase (Volovik and Hakonen 1981, Fetter 1983, Seppala and Volovik 1983, Seppala et al. 1984, Vulovic et al. 1984, Zotos and Maki, 1984). The basic dynamical variables for the A phase are the spin density S and the spin part of the order parameter, now specified by the unit vector d. Thus the effective freeenergy density [compare eqs. (4.36), (5.10) and (5.16)] becomes
where the tensor x incorporates the anisotropy in the magnetic susceptibility, and K, is dimensionless, normalized relative to ~ ~ , ( h / 2 mSince , ) ~ .>acts like a vector under rotations of the spin coordinates, it obeys the usual commutation relations (5.26)
and a straightforward calculation analogous to eq. (4.39) gives the desired dynamical equations
(5.27)
Here, Sf/Su = d f / d u - d , [ d f / d ( d , u ) ] , where fdenotes the last three terms of eq. (5.25), and x, is the normal-state susceptibility. In static equilibrium, d lies in the xy-plane perpendicular to the uniform field H, = fig, and, for simplicity, d will be assumed to be uniform and along i (as in the preceding section). When subjected to a weak rf field H ’exp(-iwt), d acquires a small oscillating part d’ (perpendicular to the
A.L. FETTER
64
[Ch. I . $5
original static direction i ) ,with components d:y^+ d : i . Elimination of the associated spin density S ' then yields a pair of coupled inhomogeneous equations for the amplitudes d : and dj. As in the similar case for the B phase [see eq. (4.51)], these equations decouple. in the usual situation that the Larmor frequency w,, = y H , , is much bigger than the characteristic A-phase frequency fl, = ( y h /3m,L,)( p,,/,yn)"'. For transverse excitation, the resulting equation becomes
where
D
=
L i [- K,V'
-
( K , - k,)(V- i ) ( i * V ) ]
(5.28b)
is a scalar differential operator [compare eq. (4.48)],with the dipole length L,, setting the characteristic scale. Once again. eq. (5.28a) resembles an inhomogeneous Schrodinger equation. with an aftractive potential
v,= -(If + 2 1 3 .
(5.2%)
and the solution can be expressed in terms of the corresponding eigenfunctions 4, and eigenvalues wz of the homogeneous equation
(D + V { ) $ ,= R A 2 [ 0 f- ( w ; + n;)]& .
(5.29b)
Note that V, involves the components of i perpendicular to d and is therefore significant only in regions where i differs from the local direction of d (here i ) .Since V , is attractive, the lowest solutions represent bound states with squared resonant frequencies (eigenvalues) below the bulk transverse value w: + 12;. It has become conventional to characterize these eigenvalues with the parameter R,(< l ) , defined by the equation
so that the "eigenvalue" on the right-hand side of eq. (5.29b) is just RI - 1. To find the lowest bound state, it is necessary first to know the i texture explicitly, and then to solve for t h e ground state of eq. (5.29b). Variational techniques are particularly convenient for this second step, since they provide a variational principle for Rz - 1 [compare eq. (4.58)]
Ch. 1, 65)
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ‘He
65
(5.31) which determines the position of the NMR satellite through eq. (5.30). The corresponding power absorbed at the resonant frequency is easily found as in eqs. (4.55)-(4.57), and the relative intensity of the shifted NMR satellite signal relative to that of the bulk A phase is given by the squared overlap integral of the ground-state wavefunction with unity (becaues the rf field is effectively uniform on these scales) I,
= V-’lJ
dV $ I 2 .
(5.32)
This formalism applies directly to rotating 3He-A in a strong parallel magnetic field. As shown at the end of section 5.2, the corresponding i texture is uniform and parallel to 2 = i throughout most of the sample, so that V, vanishes in these regions. Near each vortex core, however, i deviates from 2, producing an array of attractive cylindrical potentials, aligned along the rotation axis, and with radius of order 4L, for nonsingular doubly quantized vortices and of order 2L, for singular singly quantized vortices (Seppala and Volovik 1983, Seppala et al. 1984, Vulovic et al. 1984). Since these cores are widely separated at currently available rotation speeds, it is reasonable to use a “tight-binding’’ approximation that treats only a single vortex. Thus the high-field transverse NMR for rotating 3 He-A reduces to the solution of the effective Schrodinger equation (5.29) with an attractive two-dimensional potential V,determined by the i texture of a single vortex. This picture is evidently quite different from that used for rotating ’He-B, where the ti texture was fixed by the combined effect of the boundaries and the weak orienting terms in eq. ( 4 . 3 9 , and varied only on the (very large) characteristic length tH.Here, in contrast, the orbital i texture varies with the dipole length L,, which also characterizes the vortex core size. It is clear from eq. (5.29a) that the potential V,has a depth of order unity and a range of order L,. Such two-dimensional potentials typically have only a small number of bound states (Morse and Feshbach 1953). Since L, also sets the scale for spatial variations in the eigenfunctions [see eq. (5.28b)], the binding energy is very sensitive to the range of the potential. For the doubly quantized nonsingular vortex in eq. (5.24), the relatively large core size (-4L,) produces a tightly bound state, with R, significantly less than 1 [see eq. (5.30)j. Furthermore, the binding energy determines the spatial extent of the wave function (Landau and Lifshitz 1959), so that
66
A.L. FETTER
[Ch. 1, gS
this tightly bound state is well localized within the core. Equation (5.32) then implies that the doubly quantized nonsingular high-field vortex should have a relatively weak NMR satellite signal at a “bound-state” frequency shifted well below the bulk value. In contrast, the situation is quite different for the singly quantized singular high-field vortex in eq. (5.23), whose smaller core size (=2L,) yields only a weakly bound state with a significantly bigger spatial extent. Thus this singular vortex would be expected to have a relatively strong NMR satellite signal [from eq. (5.32)] at a frequency only slightly below the bulk frequency [from eq. (5.31)]. In practice, the detailed calculations involve considerable numerical work. first to determine the equilibrium i texture of each vortex, and then to find the ground-state eigenvalue and eigenfunction of eq. (5.29). The problem is further complicated by the explicit angular dependence of i in eq. (5.23b), which means that the effective potential V, is nonaxisymmetric, precluding the usual separation into partial waves. Seppala and Volovik ( 1983) analyzed the transverse NMR for both high-field vortices near T , and found R f = 0.5 for the nonsingular texture. with relative intensity 0.047 at 1 rad/s. In contrast, the singular vortex gave values of 0.98 and 0.56 for the same parameters, in accordance with the preceding discussion of bound states in two dimensions. Vulovic et al. (1984) extended the calculations to lower temperatures, using the hydrodynamic parameters of Williams (1979). and concluded that R : and the relative intensity both decrease with decreasing temperature. Seppala et al. (1984) have observed the A-phase NMR satellite at 29.3 bar for a range of temperatures and for various orientations of the field relative to the rotation axis. They find that R : is independent of tipping angle but depends on temperature, falling nearly linearly from about 0.6 near T, to about 0.3 near TIT, ~ 0 . 7 The . strength of the satellite absorption peak increases linearly with the angular velocity (and hence with the number of vortices), having a value of about 0.06 at 1 rad/s. In contrast to the magnitude of the shift. however. the relative intensity increases with tipping angle, in agreement with the calculations of Maki and Zotos (1985b). In addition, the improved variational calculations on the i texture near T , (Seppala et al. 1984) confirm the earlier analyses. Comparison of the experimental and theoretical values shows unambiguously that rotating ’He-A in a high magnetic field contains doubly quantized nonsingular vortices. This conclusion remains somewhat puzzling, because theoretical estimates (Seppala and Volovik 1983. Vulovic et al. 1984) indicate that the singular singly quantized vortices have lower free energy per quantum of circulation at angular velocities of order 1 rad/s and should therefore be preferred, at least for an experiment that cools the liquid in a state of
Ch. 1, 551
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID ’He
67
rotation. Various types of metastability have been suggested, but none is entirely satisfactory; this question remains unresolved. A similar analysis (Vulovic et al. 1984) describes the longitudinal NMR (with the rf field parallel to the applied field H,Z^), and the principal difference is the substitution of V, = -21: - 1: for V, in the effective Schrodinger equation (5.29b), along with the elimination of the Larmor frequency on the right-hand side. Since the itexture in eq. (5.23b) for both high-field vortices is essentially symmetric in the y and z components, the resulting frequency shifts and relative intensities are very similar to those for the transverse case. At present, no such experiments have been reported, but they could provide valuable additional confirmation of the previous identification.
5.4. OTHER DETECTION
SCHEMES
In principle, when rotating liquid .‘He is cooled from the normal sate to the superfluid A phase, it passes first through the transition at a,, (compare the discussion at the start of section 5.2), because the GL coherence length always becomes comparable with the intervortex spacing ( p h / 2 r n 3 0 ) 1’2 [see eqs. (4.6b) and (5.22)] sufficiently close to T,. In low magnetic fields, this implies the formation of a lattice of singular vortices (Schopohl 1980, Fetter et al. 1983), analogous to those seen in type-I1 superconductors at Hc2.The situation in 3He-A is more complicated, however, because many different types of vortices are possible; this singular lattice is expected to be stable only in an extremely narrow temperature interval, below which the nonsingular type-I lattice (see fig. 9) has lower free energy and should be the equilibrium state. Conceivably, singular vortices might remain metastable at lower temperatures, leading to hysteresis; in this case, the alternative procedure of accelerating the superfluid A phase from rest to some final angular velocity (of order 1 rad/s) should indeed produce the nonsingular lattice. Experimental study of this nonsingular low-field lattice and investigation of possible hysteresis both require a detection scheme that is independent of the magnetic field. Two approaches have been suggested, each of which depends on the anisotropy of certain parameters in ‘He-A. The first is the anisotropy of ultrasonic attenuation a (Serene 1974, Wolfle 1978), which has the following explicit dependence on the angle 8 between the propagation vector of the sound and the local direction of i a
=
a,,C O S ~e
+ 2a, sin’ e cos’ e + a , sin4 6 .
(5.33)
68
A.L. FEITER
(Ch. I . $5
The strong anisotropy observed in a for "He-A (Paulson ct al. 1976) arises from the rapid variations of (Y, and a . with temperature and frequency. Nakahara et al. (1979) have proposed that this anisotropy might be a useful probe of the texture of the rotating A phase, especially in low fields when NMR is inapplicable. Specific calculations by Fetter et al. (1983) show that different possible low-field vortex lattices should produce quite different temperature dependences for the spatially averaged attenuation coefficient 6 , reflecting the overall differences in the itextures. In addition, Zotos and Maki (1985) note that ultrasonic attenuation would also provide a sensitive detector of the transition between the low-field nonsingular type-I lattice. where i is distributed roughly uniformly in the xy-plane, and the high-field doubly quantized nonsingular lattice, where i (and d ) have a preferred direction in the xy-plane. Since this transition occurs at a field of order H , (see the discussion at the end of section 5.2), direct use of NMR is likely to be difficult. They have also suggested (Maki and Zotos 1985a) that ultrasonic attenuation may bc more sensitive than NMR in studying the specific form and temperature dependence of the high-field texture. An experimental program to investigate these various possibilities would be most valuable. The other potential probe of rotating 'He-A relies on the anisotropy of ionic mobility (Roach et al. 1977). In an electric field E , the steadystate velocity u depends on the relative local orientation of i according to
where p,,Ip -0.1 is a measure of the anisotropy. For a given E , an ion moving perpendicular to i has a higher velocity than one moving parallel. Thus. each specific texture of the rotating A phase should produce a characteristic distribution of arrival times for an initial ion pulse (Williams and Fetter 197'3) moving along the rotation axis. Specific calculations (Fetter et al. 1983) for the low-field textures indicate significant differences between the nonsingular type-I and the singular lattices. The same technique should also be able to detect the field-induced distortion of the nonsingular type-I lattice (discussed at the end of section 5 . 2 ) , since the narrowing of the core region with increasing H forces i preferentially into the xy-plane. The experimental study of ions in superfluid 'He has provided much valuable information (Fetter 1976), and a similar study of 'He-A would be of great interest.
Ch. 1, 561
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
69
6. Discussion
This chapter has presented an account of the static properties of vortices in rotating superfluid 3He, emphasizing the similarities and differences between the A and B phases, as well as the more familiar superfluid 4He. A series of experiments at the Helsinki University of Technology have provided much detailed information and stimulated enormous theoretical efforts. Much is now known about the static textures, but several problems remain unresolved. There is clear evidence for some sort of transition in the vortex cores of 'He-B (figs. 4 and 6), but a theoretical description has proved elusive. A second question concerns the equilibrium texture of rotating 'He-A in high magnetic fields. Experiments (section 5.3) indicate the presence of doubly quantized nonsingular vortices, independent of the order of cooling and rotating, yet theoretical calculations [see discussion below eq. (5.24)] imply that singular singly quantized vortices have lower free energy per quantum of circulation for angular velocities less than =3 rad/s. This real discrepancy should not be ignored. A third challenge is the experimental detection of the low-field structure of rotating 'He-A, which is predicted to contain a square array of singly quantized nonsingular vortices (fig. 9). Since NMR is inapplicable, new techniques will be necessary (section 5.4). For the future, the vortex dynamics in 'He has scarcely been considered. Even in 'He, the creation and destruction of vorticity is not well understood in detail, and the problems are likely to be even more severe in the present case. Bunkov et al. (1983a) report some studies of time-dependent effects following spin up, but much additional work remains. Another question is the possibility of vortex waves in either the equilibrium A or B phases, and the specific effect of orbital viscosity in the A phase (Brinkman and Cross 1978). Hook and Hall (1979) have exhibited certain time-dependent textures for 'He-A in a magnetic field, but more realistic models would be desirable, especially in connection with rotation. Conceivably, heat flow along the rotation axis might induce either static or dynamic helical distortions. The question of superfluid turbulence in 'He and the role of vortices also remains unexplored. These questions will challenge the ingenuity of both theorists and experimenters for the foreseeable future. Note added in proof (3/10/86)
Two recent papers (Thuneberg 1986 and Salomaa and Volovik 1986) have reported that the B-phase v vortex (previously thought to be the preferred state) is unstable at low pressures with respect to a finite-amplitude quadrupole deformation of the core. In addition, Thuneberg uses the Sauls and Serene 1981 strong-coupling parameters to study the pressure dependence of both
70
A.L. FETTER
[Ch. 1
states. He has found a first-order transition to the v vortex a few bar below the A-B transition, in qualitative agreement with experimental observations. References: Thuneberg, E.V. 1986. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56. 359. Salomaa, M.M., and G . E . Volovik. 1986. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 363
References Ambegaokar, V . and N.D. Mermin, 1973, Phys. Rev. Lett. 30, 1981. Anderson. P.W.. 1967. in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics, Vol. 5, ed. C.J. Gorter (North-Holland. Amsterdam) p. 1. Anderson, P.W.. and W.F. Brinkman, 1978, in: The Physics of Liquid and Solid Helium, Part 11. eds K.H. Bennemann and J.B. Ketterson (Wiley, New York) p. 177. Anderson. P.W.. and G. Toulouse, 1977. Phys. Rev. Lett. 38,508. Andronikashvili. E.L., and Yu.G. Mamaladze, 1967. in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics, Vol. 5. ed. C.J. Gorter (North-Holland, Amsterdam) p. 79. Balian, R.. and N.R. Werthamer. 1963, Phys. Rev. 131, 1553. Bedell. K.S.. 1984. unpublished. Brinkman. W.F.. and M.C. Cross, 1978. in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics, Vol. 7A. ed. D.F. Brewer (North-Holland. Amsterdam) p. 105. Brinkman, W.F.. J.W. Serene and P.W. Anderson, 1974, Phys. Rev. A10,2386. Buchholtz. L.J.. 1978. Phys. Rev. B18, 1107. Buchholtz. L.J.. and A.L. Fetter, 1977. Phys. Rev. B15, 5225. Bunkov, Yu.M., P.J. Hakonen and M. Krusius, 1983, in: Quantum Fluids and Solids1983, eds E.D. A d a m and G . G . lhas (American Institute of Physics, New York) p. 194. Cross, M.C.. 1975, J. Low Temp. Phys. 21, 525 and 24, 261E. Edmonds. A . R . , 1957. Angular Momentum in Quantum Mechanics (Princeton University, Princeton) p. 6. Engelsberg, S.. W.F. Brinkman and P.W. Anderson, 1974, Phys. Rev. A9, 2592. Fetter. A.L.. 1975. in: Quantum Statistics and the Many-Body Problem, eds S.B. Trickey, W.P. I r k and J.W. Dufty (Plenum, New York) p. 127. Fetter, A.L.. 1976, in: The Physics of Liquid and Solid Helium, Part I . eds K.H. Bennemann and J.B. Ketterson (Wiley. New York) p. 207. Fetter, A.L.. 1979, Phys. Rev. 820.303. Fetter. A.L.. 1983. in: Quantum Fluids and Solids - 1983, eds E.D. A d a m and G.G. lhas (American Institute of Physics, New York) p. 229. Fetter, A.L 1985a, J. Low Temp. Phys. 58.545. Fetter, A.L.. 1985b. Phys. Rev. B31. 7012. Fetter, A.L.. and S. Theodorakis. 1984. Phys. Rev. Lett. 52, 2007. Fetter. A.L.. and J.D. Walecka. 1980. Theoretical Mechanics of Particles and Continua (McGraw-Hill. New York) sections 7, 29 and 50. Fetter, A.L.. J . A . Sauls and D.L. Stein. 1983, Phys. Rev. BZS, 5061. Feynrnan, R.P., 1955, in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics. Vol. 1. ed. C.J. Gorter (North-Holland. Amsterdam) p. 17. Fujita. T.. M. Nakahara. T Ohmi and T. Tsuneto. 1978. Progr. Theor. Phys. 60.671.
.
Ch. 11
VORTICES IN ROTATING SUPERFLUID 'He
71
Gongadze, A.D., G.E. Gurgenishvili and G.A. Kharadze, 1981. Fiz. Nizk. Temp. 7,821 [Sov. J. Low Temp. 7, 3971. Hakonen, P.J., and G.E. Volovik, 1982, J. Phys. CIS, L1277. Hakonen, P.J., O.T. Ikkala. S.T. Islander, O.V. Lounasmaa and G.E. Volovik, 1983a, J. Low Temp. Phys. 53,423. Hakonen, P.J., M. Krusius, M.M. Salomaa, J.T. Simola, Yu. M. Bunkov, V.P. Mineev and G.E. Volovik, 1983b, Phys. Rev. Lett. 51, 1362. Halperin, W.P., C.N. Archie, F.B. Rasmussen, R.A. Buhrman and R.C. Richardson, 1976, Phys. Rev. B13,2124. Ho, T.-L., 1978a, Ph.D. thesis (Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) unpublished. Ho, T.-L., 1978b, Phys. Rev. B18, 1144. Hook, J.R., and H.E. Hall, 1979, J. Phys. C12,783. Israelsson, U.E., B.C. Crooker, H.M. Bozler and C.M. Could, 1984, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53, 1943. Jacobsen, K.W., and H. Smith, 1983, J. Low Temp. Phys. 52,527. Landau, L.D., and E.M. Lifshitz, 1959, Quantum Mechanics (Pergamon, New York) Section 45 and pp. 156-157. Langer, J.S., and J.D. Reppy, 1970, in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics, Vol. 6, ed. C.J. Gorter (North-Holland, Amsterdam) p. 1. and R.C. Richardson, 1978, in: The Physics of Liquid and Solid Helium, Part Lee, D.M., 11, eds K.H. Bennemann and J.B. Ketterson (Wiley, New York) p. 287. Leggett, A.J., 1973, J. Phys. C6, 3187. Leggett, A.J., 1974, Ann. Phys. (USA) 85, 11. Leggett, A.J., 1975, Rev. Mod. Phys. 47, 331. Levin, K., and O.T. Valls, 1983, Phys. Rep. 98, 1. Maki, K., 1983, in: Quantum Fluids and Solids - 1983, eds E.D. A d a m and G.G. Ihas (American Institute of Physics, New York) p. 244. Maki, K., and M. Nakahara, 1983, Phys. Rev. B27,4181. Maki, K., and X. Zotos, 1985a, Phys. Rev. B31, 177. Maki, K., and X. Zotos, 1985b, Phys. Rev. 831,3116. Mermin, N.D., 1978, in: Quantum Liquids, eds J. Ruvalds and T. Regge (North-Holland, Amsterdam) p. 195. Mermin, N.D., 1979, Rev. Mod. Phys. 51,591. Mermin, N.D., and T.L. Ho, 1976, Phys. Rev. Lett. 36,594. Mineev, V.P., and M.M. Salomaa, 1984, J. Phys. C17, L181. Morse, P.M., and H. Feshbach, 1953, Methods of Theoretical Physics, Vol. I1 (McGrawHill, New York) p. 1654. Muzikar, P., 1978, J. Phys. (France) Colloq. 39, C6-53. Nakahara, M., T. Ohmi, T. Tsuneto and T. Fujita, 1979, Prog. Theor. Phys. 62,874. Ohmi, T., 1984, J. Low Temp. Phys. 56, 183. Ohmi, T . , T. Tsuneto and T. Fujita, 1983, Progr. Theor. Phys. 70,647. Onsager. L., 1949, Nuovo Cimento 6, Suppl. 2,249. Osheroff, D.D., and W.F. Brinkman, 1977, unpublished. Osheroff. D.D.. W.J. Gully, R.C. Richardson and D.M. Lee, 1972, Phys. Rev. Lett. 33,584. Passvogel, T., N. Schopohl, M. Warnke and L. Tewordt, 1982, J . Low Temp. Phys. 46,161. Passvogel, T., N. Schopohl and L. Tewordt, 1983, J. Low Temp. Phys. 50,509. Passvogel, T.. L. Tewordt and N. Schopohl, 1984, J . Low Temp. Phys. 56, 383. Paulson, D.N., M. Krusius and J.C. Wheatley, 1976, J. Low Temp. Phys. M,73. Pekola, J.P., J.T. Simola, P.J. Hakonen, M. Krusius, O.V. Lounasmaa, K.K. Nummila, G. Mamniashvili. R.E. Packard and G.E. Volovik, 1984, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53,584.
12
A.L. FETTER
Ch. I]
Peshkok. V.P.. 1964. in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics. Vol. 4. ed. C.J. Gorter (North-Holland. Amsterdam) p. 1. Roach. P D.. J.B. Ketterson and P.R. Roach. 1977. Phys. Rev. Lett. 39,626. Salomaa. M.M., 1984. unpublished. Salomaa. M.M.. and G . E . Volovik. 1983a. in: Quantum Fluids and Solids - 1983. eds E.D. Adams and G . G . lhas (American Institute of Physics, New York) p. 210. Salomaa, M.M.. and G . E . Volovik. 1983h. Phys. Rev. Lett. 51. 2040. Salomaa. M.M.. and G . E . Volovik. 1984. Phys. Rev. Lett. 52. 2008. Salomaa. M.M.. and G . E . Volovik. 1985. Phys. Rev. B31. 203. Sauls. J.A.. and J.W. Serene. 1981. Phys. Rev. B24. 183. Sauls. J.A.. D.L. Stein and J.W. Serene, 1982. Phys. Rev. D25. 967. Schopohl. N.. 1980. J. Low Temp. Phys. 41,40!2. Seppali. H.K., and G . E . Volovik. 1983. J . Low Temp. Phys. 51.279. Seppalii. H . K . , P.J. Hakonen. M. Krusius. T. Ohmi, M.M. Salomaa. J.T. Simola and G.E. Volovik. 19x4. Phys. Rev. Lett. 52. 1802. Serene, J.W.. 1974. Ph.D. Thesis (Cornell University. Ithaca. NY) unpublished. Smith, H.. W.F. Brinkman and S. Engelsherg. 1977. Phys. Rev. B15. 199. Stewart. G . R . . 1984. Rev. Mod. Phys. 56,755. Theodorakis, S . , and A.L. Fetter. 1983, J. Low Temp. Phys. 52, 559. Tkachenko. V.K.. 1%S. Zh. Eksp. & Teor. Fiz. 49, 1875 (1966. Sov. Phys.-JETP 22. 12821. Tough, J.T.. 1982. in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics, Vol. 8. ed. D.F. Brewer (North-Holland. Amsterdam) p. 133. Vinen, W.F., 1961. in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics. Vol. 3, ed. C.J. Gorter ( North-Holland. Amsterdam) p. 1. Volovik. G . E . . and P.J. Hakonen. 1981. J. Low Temp. Phys. 42, 503. Volovik. G . E . . and N.B. Kopnin. 1977. Pis’ma Zh. Eksp. & Teor. Fiz. 25, 26 [JETP Lett. 25, 221. Volovik. G.E.. and V.P. Mineev. 1977, Zh. Eksp. & Teor. Fiz. 72. 2256 [Sov. Phys.JETP 45, I186j. Volovik. G.E.. and V.P. Mineev. 1983. Pis‘ma Zh. Eksp. & Teor. Fiz. 37. 107 [JETP Lett. 37. 1271. Vulovic. V.Z.. D.L. Stein and A.L. Fetter, 1984, Phys. Rev. B29. 6090. Wheatley, J.C.. 1975. Rev. Mod. Phys. 47,415. Wheatley. J.C.. 1978. in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics. Vol. 7A, ed. D.F. Brewer (North-Hotland, Amsterdam) p. 1. Williams. M.R.. 1979, Ph.D. thesis (Stanford University. Stanford. CA) unpublished. Williams. M.R.. and A.L. Fetter. 1979. Phys. Rev. BZO. 169. YMe. P., 1978. in: Progress in Low Temperature Physics, Vol. 7A, ed. D.F. Brewer (North-Holland, Amsterdam) p. 283. Zotos, X.. and K. Maki. 1984. Phys. Rev. B30. 145. Zotos. X . , and K . Maki. 1985. Phys. Rev. B31, 7120.
CHAPTER 2
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM BY
A.J. DAHM Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106, USA
Progress in Low Temperature Physics, Volume X Edited by D.F. Brewer 0 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., 1986
13
Contents .. 1. Introduction . . . , . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Background . . . . . , . . . . . . ........................ . . . . . unties in solid helium . . . . . . . . 2.1. Description of vacancies 2.2. Structure of ions . . . ............................
....................... . . . . . ............................ 2.2.1.2. Negative ions . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.2. Ion structures in solid helium . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.2.1. Positive ions . , . . . . . . . . . .................... 2.2.2.2. Negative ions . . . , . . , . . . 2.3. Experimental methods of measuring mob 2.3.1. Space-charge limited currents , . . . . . . . , . . , . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............. 2.3.2. Transient space-charge limited currents . . . . 2.3.3. Time of flight techni 2.3.4. Comparison of techni
measurements. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. ionic mobilities , . . . . . . . . , . . . . ................... ................... 3.1. Early investigations . . . . . , . 3.2. Mobility measurements . . , . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Theory , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................ 3.3.1. Negative ions . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1.1. Vacancy-assisted mobility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1.2. Surface adatom diffusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2. Positive ion ...................................... 3.3.2.1. Ho ....................................... 3.3.2.2. Vacancy diffusion. . 3.3.3. Species-independent mechanisms. . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.3.1. Phonon-assisted ion motion . . 3.3.3.2. Motion by a plastic flow mechanism . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.3.3. Vacancy-wave scattering 3.3.3.4. Ions as quasiparticles. . . 3.3.3.5. Bound ion-vacancion complexes. . . . . . . . 3.4. Ion velocities in large electric fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5. Related phenomena . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.1. Ion-dislocation ring complexes . . 3.5.2. Motion of charged grain boundaries.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.3. Test for the collapse of the negative-ion cavity . . 3.5.4. Search for vacancy waves . . , . , . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.5. Motion of charged droplets of liquid helium through the solid . . .
phase. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
........................... 74
76 77 77 79 79 79 80 81 82 82 84 85 86 89
9u Y1 91 92 101 101 101 104
1M 106 106 108 108 108 108 112 113 114 116 116 119 121 122
123
3.5.6. Theory for positive-ion mobility in a dilute 4He-3He solution. . . . . . . 3.5.7. Theory for negative ions in an rf electric field . . . . . 4.1. General comments . . . . .
123
. . . . . . . . . . . 125
......................
75
130
1. Introduction
The study of ions in liquid helium proved to be very rewarding, and developed into a subfield of superfluid physics. These probes provided information on quantized vorticity and turbulence and were used to study vortex lattices and vortex excitations; they were useful in studying the quasiparticle spectrum through scattering from phonons. rotons and 'He impurities and were used in roton creation; they were used to study the 'He-'He interface and the condensation of 'He atoms on surfaces and vortex lines in dilute solutions of 'He in 'He, and have been used to probe the anisotropic properties of superfluid 3He. In addition, the structure of these ions were of intrinsic interest. Much of this work was reviewed by Schwarz (1975) and Fetter (1976). In light of the success of these studies in liquid helium, it seemed reasonable to expect ions to be valuable in probing the solid phase as well. The work on charged particles in solid helium has been much less extensive. in large part due to the low mobility of these probes in the solid phase and the requirement of excellent crystal quality to probe the solid over a large temperature range. At this point the experimental work is quite thorough, and although there is a need for further efforts, particularly theoretical, it seems an appropriate time to review the results to date. Early reviews on ions in solid helium were included in Shikin (1977a) and in Spear and le Comber (1977). In the next section we give some background necessary for the understanding of the experimental and theoretical work. A short summary of the nature of vacancies and isotopic impurities in solid helium is given as background to theories of ion motion. The structure of ions in liquid helium is discussed since their structure in the crystal phase may be expected to be similar. We then examine the theory of similar structures in t h e solid phase and evidence for the cavity structure for t h e negative ion. The experimental techniques for probing ion motion are also described here. The experimental and theoretical work are presented in section 3. For pedagogical reasons, the results of each experimental effort are not compared with theory. Instead, the pioneering work and all low-field experimental work are presented first, and the results are compiled. Then theories of the mobility and predictions for ion velocities in large electric
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
Ch. 2. $21
77
fields are given, followed by experimental measurements in large fields. Related experiments and predictions are also given in this section. The data are summarized and discussed in light of present theories in section 4 and a summary is given in section 5. The units used are cgs units with the following exceptions. Pressures are given in atm, since this is the convention used in all the work which is reviewed. Boltzmann’s constant is set equal to unity, and, except for section 2.2, energies are measured in Kelvin. Other units, used in figures, are specified.
2. Background OF 2.1. DESCRIPTION
VACANCIES A N D ISOTOPIC IMPURITIES I N SOLID HELIUM
Some theories for ionic motion in solid helium are based on concepts first developed for vacancies and isotopic impurities in helium. Furthermore, an understanding of the nature of vacancies is essential for understanding their role in ion motion. The energy of a vacancy or impurity in a lattice is periodic in space. If the transport of a vacancy from one site to an equivalent site occurs via tunnelling, a band of vacancy states will be formed analogous to electron states in metals. In solid helium, the large zero-point motion of atoms leads to a large tunneling rate via exchange of sites for both vacancies and isotopic impurities. These excitations are calculated to occupy a band of states of width @ (Hetherington 1968, Andreev and Lifshitz 1969, Guyer and Zane 1970). The tight-binding approximation is used to calculate the band states for these excitations in 4He. The dispersion curve in bcc ‘He is given by &
= E0
+ ;@[l+ cos(k,ald3)
cos(k,ald3) c o s ( k , a ~ ) ,]
(1)
where E() is the energy at the bottom of the band, k is the wavevector of the excitation, and a is shortest lattice vector. Vacancies and isotopic impurities are treated as quasiparticles with well-defined energy and momentum, and having an effective mass given by
m * = cr,h’/a% ,
(2)
where a, = 6 for the bcc phase. The values of @ are somewhat uncertain: 1-10K for vacancies (Guyer et al. 1971, Mineev 1972, Hetherington K for 3He atoms in solid 4He (Guyer et al. 1971, 1978) and (1-5) X
78
A.J. DAHM
(Ch. 2 , 02
Mikheev et al. 1977). Delocalized vacancies are called vacancy waves or vacancions and have been reviewed by Guyer (1972) and Andreev (1976, 1978). The impurity quasiparticles are called mass fluctuation waves or impuritons and are discussed by Andreev (1976, 1978). The diffusion constant for these excitations is D = uA 16, where A is the mean free path and the velocity u i s of the order of a@lh. The vacancy mean free path is limited by phonon, impurity or vacancion-vacancion scattering. In the phonon scattering regime, A, a T-”. where n = 9 (Andreev and Lifshitz 1969) or for T Q @, n = 7 (Kagan and Maksimov 1983). Estimates of the temperature for which A, 9 a are: T < $18 (Pushkarov 1970), i.e., at all temperatures in the solid phase, and T < 8 ( h w , / 8 ) ” 2=S 1 K (Landesman 1974). Here 8 is the Debye temperature and w, is the vacancy hopping frequency. The situation is different in solid ’He. Here vacancies and ‘He impurities have a definite spin associated with them. Suppose that the vacancion wavefunction in ‘He extends over N atomic sites. Then the probability of any of these sites being vacant is 1/N. In the case of ’He, suppose that an atom of spin f has been removed. Then only sites of spin t can be vacant. The random orientation of spins in ’He destroys the coherence of the vacancy wavefunction. and it cannot extend uniformly over N sites. The mean free path is A = a. A band of energy levels exists, and the tunnelling probability is still = @ / A . Thus, D ua = @a2/h. Vacancy and impurity diffusion have been studied by NMR techniques. See the reviews by Guyer et al. (1971) and Landesman (1975). These studies yield the diffusion coefficient, D,, and bandwidth, @,, for impuritons and the vacancy creation energy E,,. The diffusion coefficient for ’He impurities in ‘He is presented as a function of T - ’ in fig. 1. The diffusion coefficient decreases exponentially with T - ’ at high temperatures where impurity motion proceeds via vacancy hopping. In this regime, D , is proportional to the concentration of vacancies c0 = exp(-e,,/T). At lower temperatures the ’He atoms diffuse as quasiparticles with a temperatureindependent mean free path which is limited by ’He-’He collisions. For sufficiently dilute solutions and large molar volumes, the impuriton mean free path is limited by phonon scattering, and D, varies as T below 1.5 K (Mikheev et al. 1977, Allen and Richards 1978, Esel’son et al. 1978). In this regime, A, 9 a. Kagan and Maksimov (1983) examined the localization of quasiparticles when energy levels on neighboring sites are shifted with respect to each other by an amount greater than the bandwidth. Localization can occur due to fluctuations in the energy levels caused by thermal phonons. In this case the diffusion of quasiparticles decreases with increasing temperature. Quasiparticle interactions also cause static shifts in the energy levels, in
-
Ch. 2, $21
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
lo"
79
I-
-121
10
0.5
,
I
0.7
,
I
,
0.9
, 1.1
,
I
,
1.3
T-' (K-')
Fig. 1. Temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient of impurities in a hcp crystal of 4He. The symbols represent: isotopic impurities, 0 0.75% 'He, 0 2.17% 'He, V,,, = 20.7 cm3; 0 positive ions, V, = 20.76 cm3. After Keshishev (1977).
which case fluctuations allow tunnelling to a neighboring site, and the diffusion coefficient increases with temperature. This occurs for large concentrations, 3 2 % 3He, and has been observed by Mikheev et al. (1982). For the case of static shifts, a maximum in the diffusion coefficient as a function of temperature is predicted. One final relevant note is the theoretical prediction of 'He impurityvacancy bound states by Locke and Young (1976). 2.2. STRUC~URE OF IONS 2.2.1. Structure of ions in liquid helium 2.2.1.1. Positive ions A model of the positive ion, which is supported by a huge body of experimental data, was proposed by Atkins (1959) to explain the large ion-roton cross section. He suggested that the density of liquid in the vicinity of the ion core is enhanced by electrostriction and is greater than the melting density for R > 6 ,&This model neglects any structure within the solid and treats the helium as a classical continuum. The center of the positive entity is a singly charged bare helium ion. This is assumed to be a He: ion with an internuclear separation of 1.08 A
(Ch. 2, 02
A.J. DAHM
80
(Pauling 1967). However, Patterson (1968) reported evidence for a stable He,' ion in gaseous helium below 200K with a dissociation energy of 0.17eV to He: + He. This conclusion is consistent with theoretical calculations (Pdshusta and Zetik 1968, Vauge and Whitten 1972) which give a linear molecule with adjacent nuclei separated by 1.2 A. The effect of the surrounding medium on the core is uncertain. Electrostriction in the surrounding medium results from the field gradient due to the bare ion. The force on an atom in the presence of an electric field gradient is
(3)
f = grad f a E ' ,
where a is the atomic polarizability. The pressure gradient in the helium near the charge is grad p = n grad :aE'
= grad(nae?/p'r")
- l(ae'/&'r')grad n .
(4)
Here n is the number density, &(r) is the dielectric constant and r is the distance from the charge. The second term on the right-hand side of eq. (4) is always small compared to the first term. The pressure in the liquid p ( r ) is approximately 7
7
.
p ( r ) - p, = +nae-/&-(r)r"
(5)
where p , is the external pressure applied to the liquid. Just inside the solid the pressurep,(r) isenhancedover the meltingpressurep,(m) by thesurface tension pressure pt
The exact value of p , depends on the structure of the solid. By combining these equations we obtain an approximate value for the radius R . of the positive ion R , = (nae'/2~;( p , ( s )
where
E,
+ p , - pe)]"'
,
(7)
is the dielectric constant at the melting pressure.
2.2.1.2. Negative ions The negative ion in liquid helium consists of an electron trapped in a cavity void of helium atoms. This structure was proposed by Ferrell (1957) to explain the long lifetime of ortho-positronium in liquid helium. Careri et al. (1959, 1960) suggested that this model might also apply to the structure
Ch. 2, $21
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
81
of negative ions. This model has been subjected to a number of interesting experimental tests, and is consistent with all experimental data. This cavity structure results from the short-range Pauli repulsive interaction between an electron and a helium atom. The requirement that the wavefunctions describing an excess electron and helium atomic-core electrons be orthogonalized leads to large curvatures in the excess-electron wavefunction when it is injected into a dense helium medium. The resultant large kinetic energy leads to a barrier for electron penetration of the liquid. This barrier is 6, = 1 eV at the vapor pressure. The formation of a cavity of radius R - around an excess electron in the liquid leads to a large reduction in the kinetic energy of the electron with a small cost in surface-tension energy, electrostatic energy (due to a decrease in the local dielectric constant) and enthalpy. The summation of these terms gives a free energy of
F = E , ( R ) + 4 ~ a R ’where u is the surface tension, and p is the ambient pressure. A good approximation for the zero-point kinetic energy E, is obtained by assuming a square density profile at the cavity surface and treating the electron as a particle of mass m in a square well-potential of height V,( p ) and radius R . For the descriptive nature of our discussions here, it is sufficient to assume V,, = =. Then E, = h2m2I2mR2. The equilibrium radius R - is obtained by minimizing F with respect to R . This yields the condition
Theoretical values of R - obtained from eq. (9), corrected for a finite value of V,, are: R - = 17 %, at p = 0, and R - = 12.5 A at p = 25 atm. Values of R - deduced from experiments carried out at the vapor pressure, range from 14-17A. More detailed discussions of these models and the theoretical and experimental radii are given in the reviews by Schwarz (1975), Fetter (1976) and Shikin (1977a).
2.2.2. Ion structures in solid helium The physical arguments leading to the solid cluster of atoms surrounding the positive ion and the negatively charged cavity in the liquid apply to the
A.J. DAHM
82
[Ch. 2, $2
solid phase as well. In the solid phase the lattice-strain energy contributes to the free energy of the structure.
2.2.2. I. Positive ions Unless the positive ion is a hole which propagates with a diffusive velocity of the order of the sound velocity, an idea which can be rejected on the basis of the small experimental ion mobilities, there must be an enhanced density surrounding the ion core due to electrostriction. The electrostrictive pressure, eq. ( 5 ) , in a continuum model is -300 atm at a distance of one atomic spacing from the bare ion. Far from the ion, the regular lattice structure exists. Thus a few A from the center of the ion a highly strained transition region to a regular lattice is expected. 2.2.2.2. Negative ions Cohen and Jortner (1969) examined the cavity model of the negative ion in solid helium. They estimated the ground-state energy of the quasifree (conduction band) state by the Wigner-Seitz method. This energy represents the barrier for electron penetration into the crystal and is given by the relation
where k,, is determined from the boundary conditions; tan k , ( r , - a , ) = kor, .
(11)
Here r, is the Wigner-Seitz radius and a, is the electron-helium atom scattering length. Their calculated value of V,, is 1.6 eV at 30 atm. The calculation of the ground-state energy and the radius of the cavity is identical to that for the liquid phase except for the inclusion of the lattice-strain energy. These authors treat the solid as an isotropic elastic medium and introduce a rigid cavity of radius R,) into the lattice. This may not represent the energetically stable configuration of the system, as elastic shear forces may change the cavity radius from R,, to R , > R,. The corresponding energy change is (Frenkel 1948)
where C is the elastic constant. This represents an upper limit since a nonrigid cavity would relax. This is the only term in the free energy which
Ch. 2. S2l
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
83
depends on R,;
A minimization of the free energy with respect to r, yields
R , = R,,
and
E,,(R,, R,)
=0
The above argument is intended to show that the elastic shear contribution is small and may be neglected. In any case, the expression for E,, is small, even if the cavity would relax and the values of R, - R,, were relatively large. The elastic constant is =5 X 10' erglcm3 (Greywall 1971). For R, = 10 8, and R , - R,, = 1 A, E,, = lo-' eV. With the neglect of Esh, the energetics of the cavity in the solid are identical to those of cavity in the fluid. For a pressure of 30 atm, Cohen and Jortner calculate a cavity radius of 9 8 , and a total cavity energy of 0.5eV- iv). Thus the stabilization criterion is satisfied. These authors neglect the small electrostrictive term in eq. (13), but use an estimate for the solid-vacuum surface tension of us"= 2.4 dynlcm at 30 atm. This value appears to be quite large. Amit and Gross (1966) calculate the surface tension for the liquid phase to be 0.7fins, where n is the number density and s is the sound velocity. This value of us"would give an -10% larger radius. A detailed presentation of the Wigner-Seitz method applied to an electron in helium and the energy of the cavity is given in Springett et al. (1967). Smith et al. (1977) discuss models for V,, the pressure dependence of the surface tension and the surface profile. Shikin (1971b) calculates the cavity radius at various pressures. He uses the Born approximation to calculate V, (Lenz 1929, Levine and Sanders 1967);
y, = 2.rrfi2na/m .
(14)
This approximation neglects correlations, and underestimates V,, perhaps by 50%. The result is a greater penetration of the electron outside of the cavity, and a smaller cavity energy and radius. He includes the electrostatic energy, but neglects the lattice-strain and surface-tension energies. The latter is important. The energy associated with the electron penetration into the surrounding medium is doubly counted in his calculation. Shikin calculates radii of 12 8, at 30 atm and 8.5 8, at 140 atm. He points out that
84
A.J. DAHM
[Ch. 2, 92
there is a slight density enhancement just outside the cavity due to electrostriction. The electrostrictive pressure at 10 8,from the center of the cavity is -6atm. The actual potential barrier step for the electron occurs at R - a, for a square helium-density profile. This will slightly increase the cavity radius. The value of 0%is 1 . 1 9 = ~ 0.64 ~ A, where a, is the Bohr radius (O’Malley 1963, LaBahn and Callaway 1964, Golden 1966). Two experiments have been carried out to test the cavity model for positronium in solid helium. Trifthauser et al. (1968) measured the angular correlation of gamma rays from the decay of para-positronium. This measurement yields the momentum distribution of the positronium atom. The data show a clean signature of the momentum components associated with the positronium atom in the cavity state. Hernandez and Choi (1969) analyzed these data and obtain a radius of 210 8, at 30 atm. Smith et al. (1977) measured the lifetime of ortho-positronium as a function of the pressure in liquid and solid helium. They obtain an excellent two-parameter fit to the cavity model with a radius of 9.6 8, at 30 atm. The electron cavity is expected to have a larger radius because of its larger zero-point energy. The ortho-positronium lifetime varies smoothly with pressure from p = 0 to 130 atm. The smooth variation through the melting curve verifies that the lattice-strain energy is unimportant in determining the cavity radius. The theoretical ortho-positronium-helium atom scattering length is 1.390, (Drachman and Houston 1970). The values, ( 1.0-1.5)0,, deduced from various experiments are discussed by Smith et al. (1977). These values are approximately equal to the electron-helium atom scattering length. The potential barrier V, for penetration into helium is inversely proportional to the mass. Thus, the barrier for positronium should be less than for electrons. The experimental evidence for a cavity structure for positronium provides strong support that this same structure is valid for an electron in solid helium. 2.3. EXPERIMENTAL METHODS
OF MEASURING MOBILITIES
The conventional method of measuring ionic mobilities in liquids and gases is to measure the time of flight across a drift space. Most experimental cells employ one or more grids. For the case of a solid sample, the crystal must be grown with the grids, in situ. Early attempts to use grid structures in solid helium resulted in difficulties with charge trapping on crystal defects (Keshishev et al. 1969a. Dionne et al. 1972). For this reason some
Ch. 2. 021
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
85
experimentalists have chosen to measure mobilities in a diode configuration, using either steady-state or transient space-charge limited currents. The formulas for the steady-state and transient currents for various ion velocity-electric field relations and a discussion of possible difficulties with this technique for small mobilities are given below. Other techniques are discussed briefly, A thorough discussion of diode techniques to measure mobilities including the effects of charge traps is given by Lampert and Mark (1970). 2.3.1. Space-charge limited currents One method of measuring mobilities in a diode is to plate one electrode with a tritium-alloy beta-emitter. An electric field is applied across the diode to extract charges of either sign, determined by the sign of the field, from the beta tracks. These tracks are ==lopm in condensed helium. The temporal and steady-state currents for a space-charge limited (SCL) diode are obtained by solving Poisson’s equation with charge density p = j / e u ( E )subject to the boundary condition that the field E vanish at the cathode. Here j = I/S is the ratio of the total current to the diode area, and u is the ion velocity. Various forms of u ( E ) have been used to fit experimental data. For small electric fields, the mobility p in solid helium is well defined: u = p E. For large electric fields, two other formulas for u ( E ) have been used to fit experimental data. Keshishev (1977) derived the relation u = x ( E + E,)3, where x and E, are constants, and Efimov and Mezhov-Deglin (1981) obtained an empirical fit of the data with the form u ( E ) = ( p i y ) sin y E . The steady-state SCL I-V characteristics in a diode plate with separation L are given for these cases. For a well-defined mobility (Thomson and Thomson 1928)
I = 9&psv’/32rL3. For the case u = x ( E
+ E0)3 (Keshishev 1977)
I = 625&x(V+ EoL)4S/4096.rrL5. For u = ( p / y ) sinh y E the relation is [ycosh-’y-(y’ - l ) l ” ] I ( y - l ) = y V ~ L . Here y = 1 + 4rILy2/p&S).
(15)
A.J. DAHM
86
(Ch. 2, 92
Gudenko and Tsymbalenko (1979) derived the following relations for a general form of u ( E ) ,
u ( E , ) = ( 4 7 r L / ~ A d) l l d E , ,
(18b)
where E, is the field at the collector. The velocity can be determined from a numerical differentiation of experimental curves. Low-field characteristics for a sample of 4He are shown in fig. 2. In principle, very precise values of the mobility can be obtained from the slopes of these curves. One problem with any technique is the possible presence of charges trapped on dislocations or grain boundaries. In a diode, the presence of trapped charge results in an intercept of the abscissa in an I ’ ‘-V plot at V = V, > 0. The amount of trapped charge per unit area is -V,14reeL, and V, increases with decreasing temperatures. Trapped charge has a negligible effect on these curves for V 9 V,, and, in addition, some of the charge is extracted from traps at large electric fields. An advantage of the SCL-current technique is that the I”2-V plot gives a relative measure of the crystal quality, and poor crystals can be immediately discarded. The density of dislocations in a good crystal can be estimated from fig. 2. For V,l L 1 statV/cm at lower temperatures and an estimate of 10’ charges trapped per cm on a dislocation (Marty and Williams 1973), an order-of-magnitude estimate yields a dislocation density of -lO3/cm2. A more serious difficulty was pointed out by Keshishev (1977). X-rays, created in the source by bremsstrahlung radiation or by electron excitation of atoms in the source or substrate can eject high-energy photo-electons from the collector. The number of ions created near the collector is a very small fraction of the number created at the source. However, at sufficiently low mobilities and consequently low currents, charges created near the collector where the applied field is relatively large, 3 V / 2 L , contribute a measurable current. This contribution results in an intercept of the ordinate on an I”’-V plot at I, > 0. The value of I, is small, as can be observed in fig. 2. No quantitative analysis has been carried out to determine errors which may be introduced by these effects. However, large deviations in the mobility, measured in a cell with a strong beta-source, have been attributed to this effect as discussed below in section 3.2.
-
2.3.2. Transient space-charge limited currents The time of Hight of ions can be determined from the transient response to
Ch. 2. 821
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
1.7 K t +/
v
87
1.6Kt
(Volts)
Fig. 2. I”’-Vplots for a SCL diode at various temperatures. V,,,= 20.5 cm3. 0 positive ions, 0 negative ions. Curves taken by Lau (1978).
a step increase in voltage applied to a SCL diode (Efimov and MezhovDeglin 1978b). The transient response has the following features: (1) An instantaneous increase in current induced in the collector by a sheet of current injected at the source to maintain the condition E ( 0 ) = 0. (2) A monotonic increase in current, as more charge is injected, up to a maximum at time t , , when the initial current sheet reaches the collector.
A.J. DAHM
X8
[Ch. 2. $2
(3) A decrease in current after the sheet is collected. (4) Small oscillations in t h e current as the charge distribution in the diode approaches steady state. The cusp at the maximum. which may be -20% greater than the steady-state current. is rounded by diffusion. The transit time is obtained by measuring t , . If a step voltage is applied from V = 0, the time 1 , for u = p E (Many et al. 1961, Helfrich and Mark 1962) is
and for u = ( p / y ) s i n h y E , t , = ( y L / p ) {z - [ 1
+ (z’
-
1) e-’]’’’},
z = coth(yVI2L) .
(20)
A small incremental voltage step yields a maximum at f , = ( 7 r / 3 ) i Oif v = p E (Baron et al. 1964). The expression for f , in the case of a small
incremental voltage step and u = ( p / y )sinh y E is much more complicated and is not given here. Samples of transient traces are shown in fig. 3. For high-quality crystals, steady state is attained quickly and a second maxima in the current is observed as steady state is approached. Trace C was taken on the same crystal as trace B, after a strain was intensionally introduced. There is a I
I
100
200
300
400
500
600
t (sec)
Fig. 3 . Space-charge limited current transients following a step change in voltage o n crystals of ‘He at V, = 20.5 cm’. The vertical lines indicate the time at which the electrometer was shorted and the voltage was changed. The thicker horizontal bars denote the steady-state current. The curves and voltage changes are : (A) 1.1 K , positive ions. +3OO t o +SO0 V. The maximum at -150s from the vertical line is due t o noise: (B) 1.3 K. negative ions before straining crystal. -12OOV to -14ooV. (C) 1.3 K. negative ions after strain. - 1 O V to -8OOV. Curves taken by Lau (1978).
Ch. 2. 92)
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
89
long decay to steady state as charge traps fill up in a characteristic trapping time T~ 9 1 , . The effect of trapped charge on transients and SCL steadystate currents is discussed by Many and Rakavy (1962), Lampert and Mark (1970) and Gudenko and Tsymbalenko (1979). The transient response allows a separate check on the steady-state SCL current mobility and gives a stringent test of crystal quality. The effect of a small current source, introduced at the collector by photo-electron ejection, on the transient response has not been analyzed.
2.3.3. Time of flight techniques Marty and Williams (1973) used a cylindrical photo-diode with a spacing of 1 0.1 mm. The cell was fabricated from beryllium and the outer electrode was gold-plated. A pulsed X-ray source ejected electrons preferentially from the gold electrode. These electrons ionized helium atoms to a depth of -10 Fm, and charges of either sign could be injected into the diode. This design conveniently eliminates grid structures while measuring the time of flight of a sheet of charge. A strong thermal coupling with a liquid-helium bath was required to extract the heat deposited in the gold-electrode by the X-rays. Triode cells are operated in one of two modes. Both use ionizing radiation from a beta-emitter as a source of ions. In one method, used by Keshishev (1977), a constant potential is applied across the drift space between the grid and the collector. An additional step voltage is then applied between the source and the grid, and the induced collector-current waveform is monitored. The collector current increases linearly in time from Z = 0, when the first ions pass the grid, to a steady-state value which is attained when the leading edge of the ion beam reaches the collector. The separation between these changes in the derivative of the waveform is the time of flight. A more accurate mode of operation for short flight times (-1 s) was introduced by Cunsolo (1961), and used by Golov et al. (1984b) in the bcc phase of 4He and by Keshishev et al. (1970). In this method, a fixed voltage is applied between the source and grid so that a source of ions is always present at the grid. A square-wave voltage of frequency f is applied between the grid and the collector, and the time-averaged collected current (Z) is monitored as a function of frequency. If the time of flight across the drift space I, is greater than 1/2f, the charges do not reach the collector and return to the grid during the alternate half cycle, (( Z) = 0 ) . For t , < 1/2f the current is (Z) = Z,( 1 - 2r, f ) , where I , is a constant. The drift time is determined from a plot of ( I ) versus frequency.
*
A.J. DAHM
00
[Ch. 2 , $2
2.3.4. Comparison of techniques, and the effect of crystal strain on mobility measurements
Gudenko and Tsymbalenko (1979) compared different methods of measuring the mobilities and tested the effects of crystal strain on these measurements. They measured a nonlinear u ( E ) relation, using eqs (18a) and (18b) and the steady-state SCL I-V characteristics. The agreement with time of flight measurements made in a triode cell by Keshishev (1977) were excellent, although there was more scatter with the steady-state SCL technique. The agreement between mobilities determined by SCL transients and steady-state SCL measurements was better than 15%, and both sets of measurements were within 20% of the triode cell measurements of Keshishev. The effect of crystal strain on these measurements was studied by applying a controlled strain, in situ. They attached the collector of their diode to a magneto-strictor, and the diode spacing was changed by the application of a magnetic field. The maximum crystal deformation, ed = A L / L , was 9 x For E~ < 3 x the current changed by <0.5%. Further increases in E~ caused plastic flow of solid helium in the diode. For E~ lo-' the density of trapped ions was estimated from the I-V characteristics to be -10" cm-3. differed from the values in Values of f , on crystals with E~ = 9 x unstrained crystals by 10%. (These measurements appear to have been taken in fields >2100V/cm.) When plastic flow set in, the steady-state current dropped, and the I-V characteristics were not quadratic in severely strained crystals. However, the dependence of the current on temperature, at 5000V/cm. did not change, that is, the same activation energy was measured in strained crystals. The results of a careful investigation of the effect of thermal cycling on mobility measurements in helium crystals (Efimov and Mezhov-Deglin 1982) indicated that dislocations are introduced into hcp 'He upon cooling. These effects. which were also observed in sound experiments (Iwasa and Araki 1979), presumably result from anisotropic strains produced by differential contraction of the sample and electrodes. Thermal cycling of isotropic bcc 3He did not affect their measurements. These authors compared measurements of the SCL current made at a fixed temperature T , before and after cooling to a lower temperature T , at rates <1 K/hr. A significant decrease in ion current, resulting from trapped charge, occurred for T I< 4 7, , where T , is the melting temperature. The current returned to its initial value upon annealing at temperatures N . 9 5 T,,,. Space-charge limited transient response measurements were made after
-
Ch. 2, §3]
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
91
setting V = 0 for a sufficient time to allow charges of opposite sign to move into the crystal and recombine with trapped charge. The transit times measured by the transient technique were unaffected by the cooling cycle, i.e., by the presence of charge traps. In the absence of charge traps, the two techniques yielded the same values of the mobility. The I-V characteristics of the cell deviated significantly from quadratic in the presence of a space-charge, in part because the amount of charge trapped is field dependent. One may conclude that the steady-state SCL technique is unreliable in hcp helium crystals for T<0.5 T,, or in strained crystals, and that the mobilities can be determined from transient measurements even in the presence of crystal defects.
3. Ionic mobilities 3.1. EARLY INVESTIGATIONS The pioneering work on the study of charge motion in solid helium was carried out by Shal’nikov (1961, 1964). He initially investigated the dependence of the ion-current decrease upon crystallization in several crystals. His results emphasized the need for careful crystal growing techniques in order to study the motion of charges in solid helium. An earlier, unsuccessful attempt to detect ion currents in the solid phase (Careri et al. 1959) can, in retrospect, be attributed to charge trapping on crystalline defects. In later work, Shal’nikov and co-workers (Shal’nikov 1964, Ifft et al. 1967) measured the temperature dependence of the current, at constant voltage, in crystals grown between the plates of a parallel-plate diode. Their results for positive ions in a series of crystals grown at different molar volumes are shown in fig. 4.The currents shown are SCL currents and are proportional to the mobility on the linear portion of the curves of fig. 4. Positive ion currents near the melting curve, presented by Ifft et al. (1967), are not space-charge limited, and for this reason deviate from an exponential dependence on T - ’ . The activation energy A + associated with positive-ion motion was obtained from current-inverse-temperature plots. It increases monotonically with pressure from 10-42 K in the pressure range 26-154 atm. There were small variations in the activation energies measured on different crystals of the same molar volume. A single measurement of A+ in bcc 3He was identical, within experimental error, to the corresponding value in hcp 4 He at the same molar volume.
92
A.3. D A H M
[Ch. 2, 43
lo-'>
lo-"
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.0
1.0
1.2
T-l (K-')
Fig. 4. Plot o f positive-ion current. in a diode tilled with 'He at a fixed voltage, versus inverse temperature for different pressures. The pressures in atm are: I 26. I1 33.5. 111 49, IV 60. V 84, VI I I X . VII 154. The circles indicate the respective currents in the liquid near Tn,. After Shal'nikov (1964).
Ifft et al. investigated constant-voltage negative-ion current-ternperature characteristics in the vicinity of the bcc-hcp phase transition in 'He. The current, which was in the SCL regime, changed abruptly by a factor of -5 as the phase boundary was crossed into the hcp phase. The slopes of the negative-ion current-inverse-temperature plots were nearly independent of crystal structure. Keshishev et al. (1969) investigated positive-ion currents in 'He crystals in very largc fields. They observed melting as a result of Joule heating at temperature-dependent onset fields -0.3 MV/cm. No breakdown occurred for fields up to O.SMV/cm.
3.2. MOBILITY MEASUREMENTS The first measurements of the mobility in solid helium were achieved by Keshishev et al. (1970, 1971) in a triode cell. Three data points, shown in fig. 5. were reported in fields of 1.5 X 10' V/cm at temperatures near the melting curve and at pressures =38 atm. These mobilities are two to three orders of magnitude lower than in the liquid phase at the same pressure. Mobility measurements extending over a range of temperatures were first reported by Sai-Halasz and Dahm (1972a.b) and Dahm (1975). The mobility was obtained from SCL diode I-V characteristics. Their mobility
Ch. 2, 93)
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
93
T-l(K-*)
Fig. 5. Ionic mobility versus inverse temperature. Molar volumes are given in cm3. The symbols used are: A positive ions; 0negative ions. The solid symbols are from Keshishev et al. (1970). After Sai-Halasz and Dahm (1Y72a).
data, taken in hcp 4He, are plotted versus T - ' in fig. 5. They obtained the diffusion-coefficient pre-exponential factors D, and activation energies A from
Their results are summarized here. Positive-ion activation energies for diffusion were in agreement with those of Ifft et a]. and were slightly larger than activation energies associated with the vacancy-assisted diffusion of isotopic impurities. Negative-ion activation energies were larger by 2550%. The diffusion-coefficient pre-exponential factors for positive ions were of the order of magnitude of those for isotopic impurities. Corre-
94
A.J. DAHM
[Ch. 2, 83
sponding quantities for negative ions were two orders of magnitude larger. These are quoted with a large uncertainty. Along the melting curve, positive-ion mobilities were independent of molar volume, while the negative-ion mobility increased with molar volume. The mobilities were thermally activated up to the melting curve. Keshishev (1977) pointed out that the deviation from the exponential behavior [eq. (21)] at the lower temperatures is an artifact of the measurement caused by ions created near the collector by high-energy photo-electrons. Marty and Williams ( 1973) reported much more extensive mobility measurements on positive ions in 4He and on both species in 'He. They measured the time-of-flight of ions in a cylindrical, X-ray photo-diode. Trapping of negative ions on crystal defects prevented them from making accurate measurements on this species in hcp 4He. The mobility of negative ions in bcc 'He was about 50(!) times larger than in hcp 4He, while the positive-ion mobility was the same in the two phases within a factor of two. Activation energies from their work are shown in figs. 6 and
i
I ,
17
18
19
20
21
21
Molar Volume (cm3)
Fig. 6. Activation energy versus molar volume for 'He. (Solid symbols-positive ions; open symbolsnegative ions.) The symbols represent: V Ifft et al. (1967); A Sai-Halasz and Dahm (1972a); 0 Marty and Williams (1973); 0 Keshishev (1977); 0 Lau et al. (1978); >*: determined from a figure in Gudenko and Tsymbalenko (1979); 0 Efimov and MezhovDeglin (1981); OGolov et al. (1984a,b). Activation energies associated with the diffusion of 'He isotopic impurities lie within the dashed lines (and in the range indicated by the arrows in the bcc phase) except for the point denoted by X . These values are taken from Miyoshi et al. (1970), Grigor'ev et al. (1974), Mizusaki et al. (1974). Allen and Richards (1978) and Mikheev et al. (1982). The bcc phase is separated for clarity.
Ch. 2. 931
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
95
7 as a function of molar volume along with all other values reported in the literature to date. They also observed an empirical relation between the diffusion-coefficient prefactors and the ratio of the activation energy to the Debye temperature. This is shown in fig. 8. These data can be fit reasonably well
-
40
30
>
i!
15
-1
20
C
.Q
= Y
10
18
19
20 21 22 Molar Volume (cm9
23
24
Fig. 7. Activation energy versus molar volume for 'He. (Solid symbols-positive ions; open symbols-negative ions.) The symbols represent: V lfft et al. (1967); Marty and Williams (1973); 0 Efimov and Mezhov-Deglin (1978b); 0 Lau (1978); 0Efimov and Mezhov-Deglin (1981); x Formation energy for vacancies (Heald et al. 1984). Activation energies associated with specific heat (Sample and Swenson 1967) and NMR (Reich 1963, Sullivan et al. 1975) measurements lie within the hatched regions. Vacancy formation energies from X-ray measurements (Heald et al. 1984) lie within the hatched region in the bcc phase.
by the formula
Do = C exp( 124 l o ) ,
(22)
where C has the same numerical value for positive and negative ions in 'He and is a factor of 5 smaller for positive ions in 4He. The largest activation energy does not exceed the edge of the phonon spectrum at =l.l$. Marty and Williams reported two anomalies in 'He. First, the mobility of positive ions was roughly constant within 0.1-0.2 K of the melting temperature, while the negative-ion mobility was sharply peaked at 0.1 K below T,. Secondly, they report a discontinuity in the mobility of a factor of 2 along a line in the p-Tplane, roughly 20 atm above the hcp-bcc phase transition. Two values of the mobilities co-exist at this transition. The authors report that the features of this transition differed from those at the hcp-bcc transition which was crossed on two samples. Lau (1978)
A.J. DAHM
96 1
1
1
1
1
[Ch. 2, 83 1
1
1
a'
0 pos We left scale 0 pos We right scale /
A neg 'He right scale
-
I
//a
t
typical errors
0.2
//
/A
/
o
1.o
0.5
A/@ Fig. 8. Diffusion-coefficient pre-cxponential factors versus the ratio of activation energy to the Debye temperature. The scale is shifted by a factor of 5 for 'He. Nearly all data from figs 17 and 18 lie within the dashcd lines. After Marty and Williams (1973).
reproduced the features of the first anomaly in 'He by blocking the helium flow to his cell before crystal growth was completed. As the temperature was lowered, the system remained on the melting curve until the cell was filled with solid. The mobility behavior is consistent with the variation of the mobilities along the melting curve. From an analysis of figs. 10 and 12 in Marty and Williams' article, which show these two anomalies, one might conclude that the discontinuities reported in hcp 'He occurred at the bcc-hcp transition. The existence of two phases, at slightly different molar volumes, in different parts of the cell would explain the two co-existing mobility values. Keshishev and Shal'nikov (1975) were successful in using a triode, made with a very thin grid. t o measure the tempcrature dependcnce of mobilities. This work was extended by Keshishev (1977) who measured ion velocities in 4He. A plot of his positive-ion diffusion coefficients versus T - ' is shown in fig. 1 for a comparison with the diffusion coefficient of 3He atomic impurities. At molar volumes >20cm3 in 'He, he finds that plots of
Ch. 2, 831
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
97
In p versus T - for positive ions have a positive curvature below 1 K. This curvature can be seen in fig. 1. He attributes this curvature to a temperature dependence in the pre-exponential mobility factor. Activation energies measured by Keshishev are displayed in fig. 6. Efimov and Mezhov-Deglin (1978a,b,c) measured the SCL diode transient response to determine the ion mobilities. They measured the thermal conductivity of the sample in the diode as a check on crystal quality. A small activation energy -6" was reported for negative ions in bcc 3He at molar volumes V,,, >22cm'. Activation energies from their data are included in fig. 7. A large increase in p- and a smaller decrease (-2) in p, on entering the 4He bcc phase had been reported by Marty and Williams and by Keshishev. This transition was studied in more detail by Golov et al. (1984b) who measured the activation energies in both phases. A plot of p versus T-I for one sample is shown in fii . 9. The measurements in the bcc
I
1
-
10' 0.5
0.6
T-'1
0.7
0.8
(K-')
Fig. 9. Mobility versus inverse temperature in the vicinity of the bcc-hcp phase transition in 'He. The symbols are: n positive ions and 0negative ions both in the same sample; positive ions in another sample. After Golov et al. (1984b).
w
[Ch. 2, $3
A.J. DAHM
phase were taken along the phase boundary, but the variation in molar volume, 21.1-20.8cm 3, is not expected to change the qualitative behavior. Upon cycling through the phase boundary, the mobilities in bcc 'He were reproducible to within +20%, while mobility values in the hcp phase varied by a factor of 2 and the activation energies were not as reproducible. The activation energies in the bcc phase were A + = 15 K and A- = 10 K. The average activation energies in the hcp phase were A + = 9 K and A =22.5K. Lau et al. (1978) noted the large range of positive-ion activation energies reported at a given molar volume in hcp 'He. They studied ion motion in a large number of crystals with nearly identical molar volumes. The positiveion mobilities are plotted in fig. 10 as a function of inverse temperature for five crystals with a molar volume, V,,, = 20.5 cm-3. Their results suggest an anisotropic mobility tensor characterized by different activation energies for motion along the c-axis and in the basal plane.
I
I
I
I
I
I
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
T-I ( K-I)
Fig. 10. Positive-ion mobility versus inverse temperature for a narrow range of pressures. The solid lines are given by eq. (24) with the parameters given in the text. The values of 0 for a best fit are given in the figure. After Lau et al. (1978).
Ch. 2, $31
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
99
They define the ratio of the velocity component along the field to the field as p E . For an hcp crystal 2
pE = V . E / [ E ( =
sin2 4
+ pc cos 2 4 ,
(23)
where pb and pc are, respectively, the mobilities in the basal plane and along the c-axis, and 4 is the angle between the field and the c-axis. The solid lines in fig. 10 are given by p = p1 e-’IlT cos2 e
+
,+ e-”/’sin2
0,
(24)
where A, = 10.2K and A, = 17.8K. The crystal orientation was not measured, and a value of 8 was assigned to each crystal. The value of 8 is assumed to be 4 or 7~ - 4. Five crystals grown in a second diode ‘at the same molar volume (Lau 1978) gave a fit to eq. (23) with A , = 12.1 K and A, = 19.8 K. Evidence for anisotropic behavior for negative ions was much less convincing, particularly in the light of the strong binding of negative ions to defects. The range of activation energies for the negative ions was 21-25 K in the first diode and 22-24 K in the second one. These crystals were strained, in situ, in an attempt to alter the measured activation energies. The current decreased, but the values of A were reproduced to within small errors (Lau 1978). Crystals which showed signs of substantial trapping were rejected. Lau was unable to explain these results in a model in which a large number of traps were assumed. A source was employed which was a factor of 15 weaker than the source used by Sai-Halasz and Dahm in order to reduce the number of ions created near the collector. Keshishev (1977) and Golov et al. (1984b) also observed that positive4 ion activation energies in hcp He were not entirely reproducible. Keshishev reproduced negative-ion activation energies to within 1 K on 13 crystals grown at the same molar volume. Marty and Williams (1973) measured mobilities in different regions of their cylindrical cell. They saw no evidence of anisotropy in the positive-ion mobility, although it is possible that all measurements were taken in the basal plane. They observed anisotropy in the negative-ion mobilities, but this observation may have been related to their problems with trapping. A very interesting feature of the temperature dependencies of ion mobilities for both species in 4He was observed by Efimov and MezhovDeglin (1978a,b,c). As the temperature is lowered in small fields, E < 2 x lo4V/cm, the mobilities decrease exponentially, reach a minimum, increase by a factor of order -2 to a maximum, and again decrease exponentially at lower T . This anomaly, which occurs in the region
4 A.J. DAHM
100 16’
l0*l0
CI
p loll
a v
m
(Ch. 2, $3
10”
ldO
41
10
lb’
10-12
0.2
~
lo1’
16l3 1.0
1.5
2.0
T-YK-~)
(a)
Fig. 11. Positive-ion current as a function of inverse temperature at constant voltages in a SCL diode with a gap of 1 mm. The voltage for each curve is given in kV. (a) ‘He, p = 32 atm; (b) ’He, p = 60 atm. After Efimov and Mezhov-Deglin (1978a).
0.7-0.9K, is shown for positive ions in fig. l l a . Plotted here is the SCL current in a 1 mm gap diode, at a series of fixed voltages, versus inverse temperature. The maxima decrease in amplitude and shift to slightly higher temprature as the field is increased. The infections disappear for E > 3 x 10 Vlcm. This behavior is peculiar to 4He. In 3He, the I versus T - ’ curves remain nearly exponential for positive ions above 70 atm and for negative ions at all pressures. Below 60 atm, there is a very large reduction in the slope of the In I versus T - ‘ curves for positive ions in the vicinity of 1 K. This is shown in fig. 1l b . The shapes of the curves are voltage dependent as in fig. lla. Measurements of the positive-ion velocities from SCL current transients in ‘He, which are less susceptible to error, exhibit the same behavior (Mezhov-Deglin et al. 1984, Golov et al. 1984a). These results are shown in fig. 12 for two crystals. The diode spacing was 0.3 mm. The height of the current and velocity maxima were specimen dependent.
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
Ch. 2. 831
200 10
101
lo00
100
.5
h
u)
Y
> 10
10
,
I
I
I
I
I
1.o
I
I
I
T-’ (K-’1
I
I
1.5
, \ , \ L
I
2.0
Fig. 12. Positive-ion velocity versus inverse temperature for two crystals of 4He. The symbols are: 0 p = 31.2 atm; 0 p = 31.0atm. The curves are labeled with the diode voltages. After Mezhov-Deglin et al. (1Y84).
3.3. THEORY 3.3.1. Negative ions
3.3.I . I . Vacancy-assisted mobility 3.3.1.I . 1. Classical vacancies. The first theoretical treatment of ion mobilities in solid helium was carried out by Shikin (1971a,b; see also 1977a) who calculated the vacancy contribution to the negatively charged cavity. In the presence of an electric field, the electron pressure on the cavity walls is asymmetric. This leads to a net flow of vacancies from high-pressure to low-pressure regions. Shikin solved for the change in the normal electron pressure Sp,(O) on the surface of the cavity in the presence of an electric field E , and related the ion velocity u to E through the following conditions: V2c(r)= 0 ,
(25)
I02
A.J. DAHM
[Ch. 2 , 93
Here c ( r ) is the local vacancy concentration, 6 c ( r ) is the change in concentration, c, is the concentration at the cavity surface in zero-field, 8 is measured from the direction of E and R is the volume of a vacancy. We labeled the vacancy diffusion coefficient 0:with a superscript a to indicate that D,should be evaluated with A, = a. This follows from the fact that an appreciable gradient in the vacancy concentration occurs only over atomic dimensions. Equation (25) states that there are no sources of vacancies in the bulk, and eq. (26) states that the local normal velocity of an element of the cavity surface, Un(8), is determined by the local vacancy current and that the surface profile remains fixed during ion transport. For small values of 6 p , , ( 8 ) ,i.e. small electric fields, eq. (27) is approximated as
The distortion of the cavity is expanded in Legendre polynomials P,(cos O), and the electronic wavefunction may be written as (Gross and Tung-Li 1968)
where j , ( k r ) are spherical Bessel functions. The electron pressure is obtained from spatial derivatives of $(r, 8) evaluated at r = R - . The total excess pressure, which is given by the deviation in the terms in eq. (9) from equilibrium, is expanded in odd Legendre polynomials, and 1 = 1 is the only nonvanishing term for steady-state motion of the cavity. An estimate of the excess pressure on the cavity surface is given by (Shikin 1977a) 6 p , ( $ ) = p;,eER- cos 81Ez ,
(31)
where p e0 l = 3,EZ/3R- is given by eq. (9) and R is the volume of the cavity. With dc(r)/drlR-= d6c(r, O)l, l a R - , and eqs. (26), (29) and (31), the following approximate expression for the mobility is obtained p,. = eL)~c,RlrrR'T .
Shikin's more exact expression yields
(32)
Ch. 2, 931
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
103
where A = 1.1 and is given in terms of spherical Bessel functions, and A, - A, = h27r212mR2is the separation of the ground and first-excited electronic level of the unperturbed cavity. The interaction between the negative charge and a vacancy consists of a repulsive term due to the polarization interaction (Shikin 1971b) and an attractive term due to the elastically strained medium (Shikin 1977a). The net interaction is nearly zero in an isotropic elastic medium, and c , is approximately equal to the bulk concentration c,. With approximate values for A and A, - A, the vacancy assisted mobility for the negative ion is
This formula agrees with the vacancy contribution to the diffusion coefficient of microscopic voids in classical solids (Kelly 1967)
Dvoid= D , c , a 3 3 / 2 7 r R ~ ,
(35)
where f - 1 is the correlation factor for vacancy motion.
3.3.1.1.2. Vacancy-wave assisted motion. At low temperatures in 4He, T S 1 K, vacancies are assumed to be delocalized. For this case, Shikin uses a classical Boltzmann distribution function f, to describe these quasiparticles. The cavity surface is assumed to be a perfect absorber for vacancies, and detailed balancing requires that the number of thermal vacancies emitted be equal to the number absorbed. In equilibrium, the flux of vacancies impinging on an element of the ion surface is
Here u is the vacancy velocity, uT is its thermal velocity, and the z-axis is along the normal to the surface element. In the presence of an electric field, the distribution function f(r, 8) has a small correction which depends on the angle 8. This is a consequence of the fact that the vacancies leave the cavity preferentially from the rear where the electron pressure is reduced. The change in the local vacancy current density from equilibrium becomes
6 j , ( R - ) = 6 c , u T / 2 f i = u cos 8 .
(37)
A.J. D A H M
104
[Ch. 2. 53
The mobility follows from eqs. (29), (31) and (37). It is
The thermal velocity is given by
- ( 2 T / m * ) ' - a ( T @ ) " ? / h , for T 6 @ , U T - u@!ii. for T * @ ,
uT
(39)
where the symbol @ without a subscript denotes the vacancy bandwidth. Phenomenologically, this result follows from writing the ion diffusion coefficient as D = 5'167. Here, the probability of a vacancy-cavity collision in the limit A " % R - is T - ' =(c,,/a')u,..rrR?, and, on the average. the ion moves a distance 6 = a'/fi.rrRy each time a vacancy is absorbed and another is emitted from a random location on the cavity surface. The result, eq. (38), should be compared with eq. (32), since the same approximations were used. The increase in mobility of a factor of R _ / a may be cancelled by a numerical factor. 3.3.1.1.3. Nonlinear velocity-field relation. Shikin (1971b) extended his calculations to larger electric fields, E > 10' V/cm. For large fields eq. (27) must be used instead of the approximation eq. (29). The excess vacancy concentration is written as
The expression for 17, eq. (28), is substituted into eq. (40), and only terms which contain cos 8 are kept, in order to satisfy the boundary condition, eq. (26). The first-order correction leads to
3.3.1.2. Surface adatom diffusion Sai-Halasz and Dahm ( 1972) compared their measured negative-ion activation energies and diffusion-coefficient prefactors with the corresponding quantities for 'He atomic impurities: A - = l S A , at Vn,= 20.6cm' and A _ is much more pressure dependent; D , / D %= 10'. Theoretical arguments given above yield Db /Di= L&/R' = 10- ' for a classical vacan-
Ch. 2, $31
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
105
cy diffusion mechanism and -a2/R! = lo-’ for vacancy-wave diffusion. Here 0,is the volume of a 3He impurity. These authors ruled out a vacancy assisted mechanism for negative-ion motion in hcp 4He on the basis of these comparisons. Sufficiently small microscopic voids in classical solids move by the diffusion of surface absorbed atoms as opposed to a vacancy mechanism (Kelly 1967). The void diffusion coefficient for adatom-assisted motion is Dvoid= (3a4/2.rrR!)D,, D,= pl‘w, exp(SG) . Here D, is the surface diffusion coefficient (Bonze1 and Gjostein 1969), 2 : o, is taken as the Debye frequency and SG is the Gibbs free energy required to create and move a diffusible adatom. Equation ( 4 2 ) is to be compared with the vacancyassisted diffusion coefficient given by eq. ( 3 5 ) . In classical solids the adatom diffusion-coefficient prefactor is smaller by a factor of all?, but the adatom activation energy is the energy required to create a surface vacancy plus a small barrier for surface motion, and is less than the activation energy associated with vacancy motion, E,, + E ~ where , E~ is the energy barrier for vacancy motion. Thus large voids move by vacancy diffusion and smaller voids move by surface-adatom diffusion. The situation in solid helium is different in two respects. If we consider the surface adatom to be nonlocalized, then the number of available surface states is -exp(SS) = 47rR21a2. In addition, the jump distance of the adatom is 1 R . For this case, D,-68az/h for adatom motion and is much larger than the coefficient associated with vacancy-assisted motion, which is determined by the vacancy tunnelling probability. On the other hand, the creation energy for an adatom is larger than because it includes the work performed against the electron pressure in the creation process. Sai-Halasz and Dahm suggest that negative ions move via an adatom mechanism with I = R . The expression for the mobility for this case is
0 1 , 1 is the mean free path of an adatom,
-
pa
-
(6e8a2/hT) exp(-Aa/T) .
(43)
Marty and Williams (1973) estimate the energy to inject an atom into the cavity as =60K. They treat the atom as uniformly distributed over the cavity. The energy required to inject a surface adatom is less than this estimate. Their estimated upper limit on the diffusion prefactor of 5 X lo-’ cm’ls for the negative ion does not include the possibility of a large adatom activation entropy.
I0 6
A.J. DAHM
(Ch. 2, $3
3.3.2. Positive ions 3.3.2.1. Hole hopping Shal'nikov suggested that a hole mechanism is responsible for the mobility of the positive ion. A hole hopping mechanism would require a transfer of an electron from a neighboring lattice site with a subsequent shift of the density hump to the new site. Sai-Halasz and Dahm argue that the rapid increase in activation energy with reduced molar volume (a factor of 2 in A+ for a 13% increase in density) is inconsistent with this model. A simple qualitative argument can be given. The binding energy of the positive ion to the density hump in an isotropic medium is IW,l
=
lox
(e2/2r2)(e(33)-.' - ~ ( r ) - 'd]r - w , ,
(44)
where w , is a small strain energy. The compressibility decreases with increasing pressure so that E(=) increases faster than E [ p ( r ) ] , where p ( r ) > p ( = ) , and I WBldecreases with pressure. The hopping barrier is the change in the integral in eq. (44),when the density hump is displaced by an This change and the displacement atomic spacing and is a fraction of 1 WBl. decrease with increasing pressure. 3.3.2.2. Vacancy diffusion Sai-Halasz and Dahm suggest vacancy diffusion as a mechanism for positive-ion motion. Their measured activation energy A + == 1.3A, was inconsistent with the penetration of a vacancy up to the ion core. On the basis of a suggestion by Guyer that the radius of the ion might be defined as the distance to which vacancies can penetrate the density hump, these authors suggest that the vacancies penetrate to within a couple of atomic spacings. Their measured diffusion constant, D, = D,, with a large quoted error for both values, is large even for a radius of 2a. Mineev (1973) calculated the vacancy-assisted mobility of a sphere of radius R in solid helium. The excess energy required to create a vacancy by removing a polarizable atom from a site located a distance r from a charge is ~ , ( r= ) ae2i2/2rJ.
(45)
Mineev writes the local vacancy concentration as c ( r ) = co exp( - V p /T ) .
(46)
He estimated R + . the distance to which vacancies could penetrate, by
Ch. 2, 831
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
107
setting V , ( R + ) I T= 1. This yields R+ = 10 A. His derivation of the mobility follows that of Shikin for the negative ion, except for the calculation of the normal pressure on the surface of the sphere. He applies a deltafunction force, eE6(0) to the positive charge and calculates the local displacement of the medium u(r, 8). The stress tensor is determined from the displacement, and the pressure tensor is expressed in terms of the stress tensor. The resultant normal pressure exerted by the field is 6Pn(r7 e > =
where v =
(2-
U)
eEcos8 4Tr2
7
(47)
is Poisson’s ratio. With eqs. (26), (29) and (47)
This expression is numerically equal to eq. (32) for R , = R - to within 25%. For the limit of a long vacancy mean free path, Mineev adapts the calculations of Shikin for the negative ion. He obtains
+
ec, R
(2-
” = 27-41 - V) R 2 , ( 2 ~ m * T ) ”‘ ~
(49)
His mobility pre-exponential factor is two orders of magnitude less than values reported by Sai-Halasz and Dahm. Shikin (1977a) points out that there is a second term in the vacancy-ion interaction which is attractive. This results from the attraction of a vacancy to the elastically stressed region surrounding the charge. He writes the vacancy-charge interaction as
where Oi, is the change in lattice volume and a;,is the stress tensor. For an isotropic elastic medium V, = - nuii,where the minus sign indicates that the volume is negative. Both terms in the interaction vary as Y4. Shikin writes the interaction as
[
v+=-,. 1-Rn (3 2 are 2 (1--5u)4 1 where n is the density of helium atoms.
IOS
A.J. DAHM
[Ch. 2 . $3
This reduction in V ; allows vacancies to penetrate closer to the core and reduces R , . Shikin suggests that a near cancellation of the two terms in V : may allow the vacancy to penetrate to the ion core. This would explain the experimental results of Keshishev and Shal'nikov (1975) who found 0 , = LI?.
3.3.3. Species-in depend ent nieciiun isms 3.3.1.1. Phonon-assisted ion niotiori As discussed above. Marty and Williams (1973) noted that the diffusion pre-exponential factors for both species of ions had an unusual and strong depcndence on A / & eq. ( 2 2 ) . This observation led the authors to suspect that a phonon-assisted mechanism might dominate ion motion. They speculated on a two-well model in which the ion is located in one of two neighboring symmetric potential wells and estimated the probability of a phonon-assisted transition to the neighboring well. They found that, as in other models. the prefactor is too small unless the mean jump distance is several lattice spacings. This would require a band of states.
3..1.3.,7. Morion by ri plastic pow mechanism Plasticity occurs in a solid when the difference between the radial and angular stress components is sufficiently large and positive. Efimov et al. (1975) point o u t that the sti'esses surrounding a charge in solid helium may favor a plastic zone of radius R , > R . . They quote a formula (Kachanov 1956) for R , ,
whew dp = p ( R ) - p ( x ) , a, is the flow stress of helium, and R , is taken to be =6 A . For the negative ion d p / 2 q , 2 10. They suggest that a plastic region would enhance t h e phonon-charge cross section and could possibly be detected as a charge-density dependent heat conductivity. An attempt t o detect phonon scattering by ions (Efimov and Mezhov-Deglin 197%) yielded the large upper limit for the phonon-ion cross section of lo-"' cm2. 3.3.3.3. Vacuncy-wave scatteririg of charged defects
3.3.3.3.I . Low-field niobihfy. Andreev and Meierovich ( 1974) pointed out a difficulty with t h e concept that the radius of a positive ion in solid helium be defined as the distance from the core to which a vacancy can penetrate. Unlike the negative-ion cavity, there is no surface. bounding the positive ion, which can serve as a source and sink for vacancies. Instead,
Ch. 2. 131
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
109
they point out that vacancies located near the bottom of the vacancy band have a wavelength which is larger than the size of the ion complex. On this ground they ignore the structure of the ions and calculate the inelastic scattering of vacancions from ions in a manner analogous to the scattering of vacancions from isotopic impurities subjected to a force field. This treatment is also discussed by Andreev (1975,1976). The vacancion is treated as a quasiparticle in a definite momentum state at a temperature T 4 @. If a vacancy appears at a nearest-neighbor lattice site to an ion, it may scatter elastically with the ion remaining at rest, or it may undergo an inelastic scattering event. In the latter case, the ion is transferred to the vacant site and the vacancion absorbs the potential energy loss of the ion, eE a, , and leaves in a different momentum state. Here a, is the lattice vector connecting the original ion and vacant site. The average ion drift velocity is given in terms of the inelastic ion-vacancion cross section a,(/?)
-
u=
c
a,
d3k ( 2 ~ ) - ~ a ( k ) u ( k ) [ DD ( ~( )E+ eE * a,)] ,
(53)
where u(k) is the velocity of a vacancion with wave vector k, D ( E )is the density of states for vacancions, and the sum is taken over nearest neighbors for which eE a, > 0. The displacements -a, are accounted for as inverse processes in eq. (53). Equation (53) is rewritten as u=
2 a,
I
dE ( 2 ~ h ) - ~ [ D -( & D )( E+ e E . a , ) ]
I
a,(/?) dS ,
(54)
where the last integration is over a constant-energy surface in momentum space. The authors use the fact that inelastic scattering cross sections for slow particles are inversely roportional to the velocity, and evaluate this integral as 4 7 r h a ( ~- E " ) 1 , where a For a Boltzmann distribution the velocity is
/P
u = ( a / 4 h 2 ) ( T / ~ ) exp(-qJT) "2
-
C a,[l n
-
exp(-eE.a,/T)].
(55)
This relatively simple and elegant approach leads to some interesting predictions contained in eq. (55). In a weak electric field eEu s T, the mobility is a tensor ui = B i k E k ,where
The magnitude of the mobility tensor differs from that for a charged point
A.J. DAHM
110
[Ch.2, 93
defect moving by localized vacancies by a factor of TI@. For strong electric fields, the velocity is approximately independent of the electric field
-
Keeping in mind that the sum is in the forward direction, E a, > 0, both the magnitude and direction of u change abruptly as the direction of E is varied. That is, the sum remains fixed until a plane passing through a lattice site and having a normal parallel to E , intercepts a set of atoms. The transition to a new magnitude has a width TleEa since exp(-eE a , / T ) = 1 for atoms lying near this plane. The final energy state of the vacancy must lie within the band: E - E,, < @. If Ihree-body processes are neglected, then, at large electric fields, only those lattices vectors for which eE a, < @ contribute to eq. (57). For large electric fields, ion motion is blocked except for directions of E nearly perpendicular to some vector a,. The velocity of the ion is nearly perpendicular to E for these directions of electric fields. Finally, the authors note that the sum C, a, depends on the sublattice in hcp helium and that in very large electric fields and certain orientations of E, the ions will be concentrated on one sublattice. The above calculations assume that a vacancion can penetrate to within one lattice spacing of the ion. If the interaction between a vacancion and an ion is sufficiently large and repulsive. V > @, then the inelasticcrosssection will besmall (Andreev 1976).
-
-
3.3.3.3.2. Largefields (eEa 9 @). Keshishev (1977) extended the vacancion scattering theory of Andreev and Meierovich to large fields eEa 9 @ in order to explain his empirical results IJ CK ( E + E,l)3. This extension, which includes vacancy scattering with the simultaneous emission of a phonon is based on similar ideas put forward by Andreev and Meierovich (1974) and Meierovich (1975a). The final state of the vacancion in a scattering process must lie within the vacancy band. Thus, the ion scattering process cannot proceed for eE - a > @, without the emission of a phonon (eEa 1 K at 2300 V/cm). For T -% eE a , the density of thermal phonons is small, and the emission is spontaneous with a probability ( f i ~ ) Energy ~. conservation requires
-
E,
+ e E - a = E~ + ho ,
where the subscripts i and f refer to the initial and final vacancion states.
Ch. 2. 831
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
111
Equation (53) is replaced by u a nc a,
I
where hw, = E yields
I
Y
d3k u ( k ) u ( k ) f ( k )
WI
w 3 dw
,
+ eE - a, - @ and ho, = E + eE - a , .
(59) The integral over w
*
where E a, is replaced by Ea and terms of order (@/eEa)' are neglected. For eEa @, the ion velocity can be written as u = x ( E + E,)3 with E , ( T ) given by
I,@'
@ ( E ) u ( E ) Dexp(-E/T)(E (E) - ;@) dE
eaE,( T ) =
(61) @,/"
~ ( E ) u ( E ) Dexp(-E/T) (E) dE
The cross section is assumed to be temperatures, T G @,
E,
= (3T-
cx u - ' ( E )
and independent of E. For low
@)/2ea.
(62)
The limit E,( T = 0) = @ / 2 e a reflects the fact that for T = 0, and large values of eEa, the average final state is in the center of the band. Keshishev and Meierovich (1977) have carried out a slightly more detailed calculation for T << @ 4 eEa, they obtain the expression ea[E+ E ~ ( T ) ]
(63)
where a. is a dimensionless constant, the sum is carried out in the forward direction, we have set E a , = Ea, and EA is given by eq. (62) with @ replaced by another parameter @ ' 2:@. For @ G T G eEa, a similar expression is obtained with ( T l @ ) 3 ' 2replaced by a term of order unity, and EA = ( ( E - ( E ) ) ' ) /Tea. Here the averages are defined by
-
(w)
= Id3k
I W ) I ~ W / JI~W ~ ~
where $(k) is the wavefunction of the incident vacancion.
[Ch. 2, $3
A . J . DAHM
112
In the limit T + eEa %- @, the ion-vacancion scattering process is accompanied by the scattering of thermal phonons. In this limit the authors obtain an ion velocity with a strong temperature-dependent pre-exponential factor given by
,, a
8
3.3.3.4. Ions as quasiparticles The energy of an ion in the crystal is periodic in coordinate space. If an ion can tunnel between lattice sites, then the ions will become delocalized and will exist. Andreev and Meierovich (1974) a band of states of width treat the charges as delocalized point defects in analogy with impuritons. At sufficiently low temperatures the tunnelling mechanism will dominate over vacancy-assisted diffusion. Since the ions are massive, @= is certainly smaller than the impurity bandwidth which is - l W J K. Thus, only the case T 9 @c is treated, and the band occupation is assumed to be uniform. The authors solve the Fokker-Planck equation for the momentum distribution function describing the charged quasiparticles in the presence of an electric field. They obtain the following result in the limit e€u G QC:
where d = h21a'r, 3: T-' is the diffusion coefficient in momentum space, and r, is the ion-phonon scattering time. As in the case of the vacancion mechanism. the mobility is a tensor. The inverse dependence on the electric field for sufficiently small values of d is analogous to that of an electron in a conduction band in the presence of an electric field. If the scattering time is large enough, the electron will oscillate in real space as it cycles through momentum states and is Bragg scattered at the zone edges. The particle diffusion is very small for large scattering times. and ion For realistic electric fields, E > 1 V/cm, we have eEa S transport via tunnelling requires the emission of a phonon of energy hw = eEa, since there are no energy states for the ion above the band. If hw + T, spontaneous emission occurs with a probability which is proportional to w ' x E3. They predict an ion velocity at low temperatures of QC,
u = (eEa/8)3@2a/h8.
(67)
Ch. 2, 931
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
113
3.3.3.5. Bound ion -vacancion complexes Meierovich (1975a,b) proposed that vacancions may be trapped in the attractive, long range, electric field dependent ion-vacancion potential. The complex, ion plus bound vacancions, would then move as an entity with the ion tunnelling into vacant sites and the vacancions presumably returning to the core of the ion by another path. In the presence of a delta-function force, eE6(0), applied to the solid, dipolar stresses are produced, and the corresponding potential is V ( r )= eEa(a/r)’g(B,4) .
(68)
For an isotropic elastic medium 1 R l+u g(6, ((I) = 6 - -cos e
a3 I - u
Meierovich considers long-wavelength vacancions and neglects the ion structure and the shorter range r Y 4 [eq. (51)] and r Y 3 terms in the potential. The r Y 3term is due to the lattice strain surrounding any point defect. Schroedinger’s equation is solved for the vacancion wavefunctions and eigenvalues. Perturbation techniques are used in the limit T Q eEa 4 Qb, where Qb is the bandwidth for vacancions bound to the ion. These limits demand that only long-wavelength vacancions are excited and that V ( r ) varies slowly. The effect of the dipolar potential for small fields is to alter the vacancion wavefunction in the vicinity of the ion and to change the functional form of the inelastic scattering cross section on the wavevector. The vacancions are attracted to the ion, but are not bound, in this limit, and there is only a small correction to the ion velocity given by eq. (55). The case of large electric fields is more interesting. For zo < - f , where
an infinite set of discrete bound states exist with an energy spectrum
where Lo is a constant determined by the crystal deformation field and ,yo = I f + zoI The wavefunctions describing states with E, s 0 extend to r % a, and are insensitive to the core structure. An integration of the probability of tunnelling W E , I ( ( I , , ( Y ) ~ ’ ~ ~ = ~over all states leads to the
”’.
A.J. DAHM
114
[Ch. 2. 83
following expression for the ion velocity at small T
k,,([ ( , u ) ( @ ~ / T )exp[Qh( "' &,a)'/T],
u = u,,47~I
(72)
where u,, is the velocity given by eq. (55). In the limit eEa ah,phonon emission is required to satisfy energy conservation. The drift velocity for T Gb, is derived to be
*
The signature for this process is a reduced activation energy in large fields, E > E , , where the critical field E, is obtained by setting z0 = - in eq. (70). Its value is E, -- IO@,,/en. The value of &, is determined by the deformation field and could lead to different activation energies for positive and negative ions. 3.4.
ION VELOCITIES IN LARGE ELECrRlC FIELDS
Nonlinear u( E ) relations in solid 'He were first investigated by Keshishev ( 1977) with both SCL current and time-of-flight techniques. He observed two types of behavior. At 25.8 atm the positive-ion drift velocity dependence was less than linear for € > 70)OO V/cm. With this exception, the ion velocities for both species in fields >lo' V/cm were fit empirically by the relation c' = ,y[ E + Efl(T ) j 3 ,where the parameter Eo( T ) is a monotonically increasing function of T . The range of fields studied extended to 2 x 10' V/cm and 5 x 10' V/cm for positive and negative ions, respectively. Keshishev amended the theory of Andreev and Meierovich (1974). as discussed in section 3.3. and obtained the empirical dependence on electric field. From the condition that the cubic dependence of u ( E ) should set in at a field E , == @leu 10' Vicm, he obtained a vacancy band width of 4 K. The measurements could not be carried out at sufficiently low temperatures to determine the bandwidth from E , , ( T + O ) . eq. (62). At still higher fields, E > E: , Keshishev and Meierovich (1977) observed a second regime, in which the positive ion velocity varied as u ( E ) = x , ( E + E l )'. Here the parameters xIand E l differ from the values y, and El, which describe the behavior at fields less than the critical field E i . The authors cautiously point out that the theory of ion motion by ion-vacancy bound states predicts qualitatively t h e observed behavior with a critical field of E, lO@/ea. A value of E:=2.7 X 10JV/cm. measured at p = 30.5 atm and 7 = 1.54 K , yields @ = 1 K . Lau (1978) also fit this data with the nonlinear form u ( E ) = x ( E + with values of E ( , / T = 8 x 10' V/cm K. He found that the transition
-
-
Ch. 2, 831
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
115
-
region to the cubic behavior occurred at a field E, iE,. Lau pointed out a discrepancy between the theoretical predictions and the experimental parameters. According to theory, the cubic form for u ( E ) applies for eEu' 9 @ 9 T [eqs (56) and (57)], where u' is the distance by which an ion advances in an inelastic scattering event. He evaluated E, [eq. (61)] as a function of @IT. He found 2ea'E,/T = f ( @ / T ) is negative for @ b T [see eq. (62)] and
u ( E ) = A(T) e-A'Tsinh(ebE/T) ,
(74)
where A( T ) is at most weakly dependent on T, and b is a fitting parameter. For a given crystal and ion species, the product u(E)exp(AlT) was a universal function of EIT. Note, that the Einstein relation, D = Tpie, and the small-field limit of eq. (74) give D = b A exp(-A/T), consistent with a nearly temperature-independent diffusion pre-exponential factor. These authors also fit the positive-ion data of Keshishev (1977) and Keshishev and Meierovich (1977) with eq. (74). In strong fields, eq. (74) extrapolates to
u(E).: A exp(-A,,,/T)= exp[ - ( A - e E b ) / T ].
(75)
Table 1 Values of the parameter b , determined with the use of eq. (74) unless noted otherwise. Helium isotope 3 3 3 4 4 4 4
Pressure (arm)
46 46 61 32 32.4 40.5 46.0
b,
b
(A)
(A)
0.47 0.720.1 0.6-0.8 0.46 1.1 2 0.2 0.9 1.2-1.5
0.23 0.5+0.1
[ 11 Efimov and Mezhov-Deglin (1981). (21 Keshishev (1977). [3] Keshishev and Meierovich (1977). [4] A reanalysis of the data of Lau (1978).
Ref. 111 111, Eq. (75) [41
0.49
(11
1.3-1.6
1-21 131 [41
[Ch. 2, 83
A.J. DAHM
116
The measured effective activation energies Aeffdecreased linearly with E. Values of the parameter b determined from eqs. (74) and (75) are given in table 1 . Values from a reanalysis of the data of Lau are included. The best fits to the data of Lau for ‘He at 61 atm and of Keshishev in ‘He at 32.4 atm, yield a temperature-dependent parameter b . Different forms of u ( E ) are compared in fig. 13 in a plot of u l i 3 versus E. The forms u ( E ) = ( p / y ) sinh( Y E ) and u ( E ) = x ( E + E,,)3 are nearly identical for a range of fields. The tangent to [ ( p l y ) ~ i n h ( y E ) ] I at ’ ~ its inflection point extrapolates to a value of E, = 1 . 3 ~ -V/cm. ’ The data of Keshishev for negative ions at 36.6 atm and 1.43 K in ‘He are also shown in the figure.
2.0
2 .o
0.0
E
4.0
6.0
( 1 0 4 CMISEC)
Fig. 13. A comparison of various functions for u ( E ) . The curves are: - u = 6.5 x IO-’sinh(yE). y = O . 7 ; . . . . . . . according t o e q . (87) with y = 0 , 7 ; - - - ~ = , y ( E + E , ) ~ ; O Keshishev (1977). for negative ions in ‘He for p = 36.6 atm. T = 1.43 K .
3.5. RELATED PHENOMENA 3.5.I . Ion-dislocation ring complexes Nosanow and Titus (1969) made the intriguing suggestion that iondislocation ring complexes might be able to propagate in the crystal. These entities would be analogs of ion-vortex ring complexes which propagate in the liquid phase. Rayfield and Reif (1963,1964) discovered that charges in liquid helium create vortex rings when accelerated to some critical velocity. An ion is
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
Ch. 2, 831
117
trapped by the vortex ring, and any additional energy given to the complex is converted into the energy of the vortex ring with a resultant increase in the ring radius and a decrease in its velocity. The velocity of a large vortex ring is approximately inversely related to its energy. Careri and coworkers (Careri et al. 1965a,b, 1966, Bruschi et al. 1968) studied the steady-state velocity of charged vortex rings in large electric fields in the temperature regime where the frictional drag on the vortex ring absorbed the energy given to it by the field. The charged vortex ring drift velocities, measured by Bruschi et al. (1968), versus the electric field E are plotted in fig. 14 along with the theoretical curves of Padmore (1972). Three regimes are shown in the figure. For small fields the drift velocity varies linearly with E. Nonlinear effects set in at larger fields as the drift velocity continues to increase until the critical velocity for vortex creation is reached at a maximum drift velocity. In the second regime, the velocity decreases with increasing field. This is a result of the trapping of the ion by the vortex ring it created and the peculiar dynamics of vortex rings discussed above. In this regime the velocity is determined by the drag imposed on the vortex ring by the normal helium fluid. As E increases further, the velocity falls more slowly until a minimum velocity is reached. In the third regime, the velocity again increases with a further increase in field. Here the ion escapes the ring through a field-assisted stochastic process. It then accelerates and creates a new vortex ring. I
I
I
I
I
I
=
T
=
0
30
I
A T
I
1.18 K 1.30 K
0
%
2
20
Y
U
>
10 I I
I
I I
I
I
I
2
4
6
1
I
8 I0 E (kV/cm)
I
I
12
14
Fig. 14. Comparison of theory [(a), (b)] and experimental data [A, 0 1for the drift velocity of positive ions in liquid helium versus electric field. The data are from Bruschi et al. (1y68). After Padmore (1972).
[Ch.2 , 83
A.J. DAHM
11R
Nosanow and Titus point out that the energy per unit length of a dislocation in solid helium, and a singly quantized vortex line in liquid helium are nearly equal. Furthermore, ions are attracted to both entities and would thus be trapped on dislocation loops as well as on vortex rings. They suggest that a moving ion could create a dislocation loop and attach itself to the loop. The dynamical behavior and dissipative processes for the loop are much more complicated than that of the corresponding vortex ring. Golov et al. (1983, 1984a) report a decrease in positive-ion velocity with increasing electric field beyond a temperature-dependent critical velocity and a further increase in velocity with field, at still larger fields. A plot of their measured drift velocities versus applied voltage is shown in fig. 15. These measurements were taken from current transients in a space-charge limited diode with a diode spacing of 0.3mm. These data are strikingly similar to those of Bruschi et al. (1968) shown
1
2
3
4
V (kV)
Fig. IS. Average velocity of a positive charge in ‘He as a function of voltage applied across a SCL diodc at different temperatures, p = 31 arm. The numbers of the curves denote the temperature. The solid squares indicate the diode current at 0.67 K and refer to the right axis. After Golov et al. (1983).
Ch. 2, $3)
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
119
in fig. 14. There are again three regimes. The maximum velocity, 10-3-10-2 cm/sec, occurs at an electric field of 40-60 kV/cm. The minimum-velocity critical field is 80 kV/cm. Golov et al. suggest that the positive ion creates a dislocation loop at the maximum critical velocity, is subsequently captured by it, and the ion and loop move together as a complex. They point out that dislocations have a high mobility in solid helium (Levchenko and Mezhov-Deglin 1983). These authors suggest that the increase in drift velocity with field at large fields could be partially due to an increase in the sample temperature over the measured cell temperature, due to Joule heating. A more interesting possibility is field assisted escape of the ion from the loop in analogy with the corresponding case in the fluid phase.
3.5.2. Motion of charged grain boundaries Guenin and Dahm (1 981a,b) investigated the quasiperiodic current bursts which had been observed by Lau et al. (1978) in strained crystals. The strain was introduced by locally melting a small amount of helium in a sealed chamber with a heater located near one side of a 10 x 10 x 1.1 mm3 sample. Crystals strained in this manner exhibited sharp, quasiperiodic, current spikes for positive ions in hcr 4He at V,,, = 20.5 cm3 and for both species in bcc 3He at V,,, = 21.6cm . Examples of such current bursts, superimposed on a steady-state background, are shown in fig. 16. The temperature and voltage dependencies of the period T obeyed the relations
where w = 2 0 K , and Vo was sample dependent and ranged from 2006OOV. The width of the bursts was -;T o , where To = 4 L 2 / 3 p V is the steady-state SCL transit time. The amount of charge in a single burst was as large as 4 x 10' ions. In explaining these data, the authors assumed that the largest flow of helium during the heating cycle occurred in the center plane of the diode, and that a low-angle grain boundary, i.e. a plane of parallel dislocations, was created in this plane. Such grain boundaries can be transported as a whole by the application of a uniform stress (Washburn and Parker 1952). All features of these data were explained by a model in which a fraction of the charges are trapped on dislocations and the charged grain boundary moves (or bends) toward the collector in the presence of an electric field.
A.J. DAHM
60 sec
I
I
d , 60 sec
[Ch. 2, 13
4
G
L I
Fig. 16. Examples of well-defined current bursts in strained crystals: upper trace, 4WV; lower trace, 600 V. After Guenin and Dahm (1981a.h).
When the dislocations are sufficiently close to the collector, the largeimage field extracts the trapped charge, and the uncharged grain boundary relaxes to is equilibrium position until it is recharged. A large current burst appears if the ion velocity along the dislocation lines is larger than through the bulk solid. It is suggested that this is a result of the enhanced vacancy concentration near dislocation cores. The velocity of a charged dislocation line was derived as u , x exp[-(w eE b) / T I . where b is the Burgers velocity for the line, Ibl = a , and w is the formation energy for a vacancy, located a lattice spacing from the dislocation core, plus the change in strain energy when the ion moves from
-
Ch. 2, 831
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
121
the dislocation core to the vacant site. The model predicts the period to vary as T a ( u : ’ ) 0:exp(w/T)lsinh(V/V,), where V,, depends on b E and, therefore, on the crystal orientation. This explains the empirical relations, eqs. (76) and (77), for V B V,. The amplitude Q of the current spikes, which is proportional to the total trapped charge, is obtained by equating the charge-capture rate to the escape rate. The predicted amplitude
-
Q x
V-“’ exp[(B - 2 4 - PV”’)/T]
(78)
fits the experimental data. Here B is the binding energy of an ion to the dislocation line, and is a derived constant. The binding energy of a positive ion to a dislocation line was measured to be -20-25K for positive ions in 4He. This may be compared to an estimate of 6180K for negative ions (Marty and Williams 1973). The authors argue that the lack of current bursts for negative ions in hcp 4He is evidence that the velocity of these entities along the line is not enhanced, and that a steady-state displacement of the grain boundary near the collector is maintained. They conclude that negative ions do not move by a vacancy-assisted mechanism in hcp 4He at V,,, = 20.5 cm’.
3.5.3. Test for the collapse of the negative-ion cavity Cohen and Jortner (1969) predicted that the electron would become delocalized at a pressure of -4000 atm. This prediction was based on an earlier rough estimate by Springett et al. (1967) that the electron cavity in the liquid would become unstable for p(atm) lO’(V,/eV)”’. Presumably, there is a numerical error here since this relation yields much too small a barrier, V, < 1.74 eV, at 4000 atm pressure and a density of -0.44 g/cm3. The barrier V,, is a rapidly increasing function of density; see eqs. (10) and (11). Dionne et al. (1972) tested this prediction. They used the Cunsolo technique with a single grid, and measured ion mobilities under pressure in liquid and gaseous helium. No charge transport was detected in solid helium at pressures of 32atm and 6480atm in fields up to 3300V/cm. These authors conclude that the lack of charge motion in the solid phase is evidence that the electron remains localized in the cavity, although they could not rule out trapping of quasifree electrons in the solid. The results suggest that ions were trapped on crystal imperfections, at least at 32 atm. These authors measured the mobility of both positive and negative ions in gaseous helium at 8 0 K , p =6760atm and a density of 0.44g/cm3, similar to the density at 4000 atm in the solid. They used Atkins model with the neglect of surface tension, to calculate the radius of the positive ion as
-
122
A.J. DAHM
[Ch. 2, $3
R , = 3.9 A. The negative-ion radius was deduced from the ratios of the Stoke‘s law mobilities. They obtain R - = 6.2 %, using rigid boundary conditions. Slip boundary conditions yield R _ = 9.3 A. The observation of a cavity state, i.e., low mobility, in dense helium gas is a strong support for this state in the solid at the same density. Dionne et al. point out that the Bloch wave in the conduction band k = 0 state, contains a significant amount of high-energy plane-wave components and that an energy-dependent scattering length should be used in calculating V,. They calculate V,, versus pressure for different values of the scattering length and conclude that the cavity will not collapse if the low-energy scattering length is used in the calculation. 3.5.4. Search for vacancy waves
Sai-Halasz and Dahm (1972b) (see also Dahm 1975) attempted to use positive ions as probes to study the mobility of vacancies in solid helium. They assumed that positive ions moved by a vacancy-assisted mechanism. For this case, the positive-ion SCL current a p is also proportional to the local vacancy density which has an equilibrium value exp(- &,,IT).They further assumed that vacancies were created and annihilated at the boundaries of the crystal. The alternative in a single crystal without dislocations is the creation of an interstitial-vacancy pair which is energetically less favorable. The time response of both the crystal temperature and the positive-ion current to step-function changes in the heat input to the crystal chamber were monitored. The response time for the current is expected to yield the relaxation time for vacancies to attain a new equilibrium concentration. This relaxation time is 7, = L 2 / r 2 D ,(Shewmon 1952) for vacancies created at a wall of a specimen of thickness L . This experiment was designed to compare the vacancy diffusion constant in ‘He and ‘He. If vacancions with A v S a waves were present in ‘He, D, would be large. Tests for vacancy waves would be made by measuring D, as a function of temperature and by introducing ‘He impurities to change the vacancion-wave mean free path. For 3He. D , -5 x lo-’ cm2/s (Reich 1963), and with the experimental value of L = 4.6 mm, 7, = 425 s. These authors quote upper limits on T, of 2 s in crystals of pure ‘He and 2% ‘He in ‘He, and of 4 s for pure ‘He and 5% ‘He in ‘He. Dislocations are also sources and sinks of vacancies. If the efficiency of dislocations for vacancy annihilation is unity, then T,,= df ln(d,la,) (Crank 1956). Here d , = ( T N ~ ) - ” ’ ,where Nd is the dislocation density, and a, is the dislocation core radius. A dislocation density of 104/cm2can account for the failure of this attempt to measure vacancy diffusion.
Ch. 2, $31
CHARGE MOTION IN SOLID HELIUM
123
Another possibility is that ions do not move via a vacancy-assisted mechanism. Shikin (1977~)has suggested this same experiment to determine whether vacancies are created at the crystal walls or as vacancy-interstitial pairs. He suggests that two steps will be observed in the negative-ion current versus time if vacancies are created at the walls. The first step will occur when the thermal wave enters the monitoring region, because of the temperature-dependent mobility prefactor, and a second when vacancions arrive.
3.5.5. Motion of charged droplets of liquid helium through the solid phase Savignac et al. (1983) deposited negative charges on a liquid-solid helium interface. The electrons remain on the liquid side of the interface because of the energetics of the cavity, discussed in section 2.2. In the presence of an electric field, applied perpendicular to the surface, the negative ions exert a pressure on the solid. At high areal densities, -lo9 cm-2, and fields -2 x lo3 V/cm, a surface instability occurs and dimples form on the surface. Charge flows into the dimples, which increase in depth until a liquid droplet, 0.1 mm in diameter and containing -lo6 electrons, breaks off from the dimple tip and enters the solid. The charged droplet moves with a velocity of -1 mm/sec in a field of 2000V/cm. The electrostatic pressure on the leading surface gives rise to a chemical-potential difference A p between the liquid and solid phases. This leads to melting at the bubble front with a velocity ub = M K A p , and solidification on the opposite side. Here M is the mass of a helium atom and K is the kinetic growth coefficient.
3.5.6. Theory of positive-ion mobility in a dilute 4He-3He solution Shikin (1977b) examined the attractive interaction, between the positive charge and a 4He impurity, and its effect on the mobility of a positive ion in a dilute 4He-3He solid solution. In a pressure field p ( r ) within a liquid medium, it is energetically favorable to replace 3He atoms in the regions of high pressure with 4He atoms of smaller volume. The energy gain is [ p ( r ) - p ( = ~ ()u] , - u 4 ) , where u3 and u4 are the effective volume of 3He and 4He atoms in a ,He medium. Near a charge, p ( r ) - p(m) is the polarization pressure and the positive i ~ n - ~ Hattractive e interaction is
v:
=
-( a e 2 / 4 r 2 )1( - u 4 / u 3 ).
(79)
A.J. DAHM
124
[Ch. 2, 93
This interaction leads to anomalous behavior of the positive-ion mobility in dilute 'He-'He liquid solutions (Roach et al. 1979 and references therein). Shikin obtains the same expression for the case of a solid where the pressure field is replaced by an elastic stress field. The ratio u,Iu, = 0.8. An equilibrium distribution of 'He impurities, determined by V : and the concentration of 'He, surrounds a static ion. A slightly distorted distribution o f impurities surrounds a moving positive charge analogous to a polaron. This polaronic cloud exerts a drag on the ion and reduces its mobility. Shikin calculates the effective mobility pc of the cloud of impurities under the condition that N noninteracting 'He impurities are bound i n the potential o f the charge. The mobility of the positive ion p+.$in the dilute limit is -I
- I
- I
p.4=p. +p,
.
(80)
where p , is the positive ion mobility in pure 'He, and p, is proportional to N - I . If the mobility of a single 'He atom in ,He is - p