List of Contributors P.D. Adelson, Department of Neurosurgery, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 900951769, USA F. Andermann, Montreal Neurological Hospital and Institute, McGill University, 3801 University St., Montreal, PQ H3A 2T5, Canada D.L. Arnold, Epilepsy Clinic and Brain Imaging Center, Montreal Neurological Institute and Hospital, 3801 University Street, Montreal, PQ H3A 2B4, Canada B.K. August, Department of Neurology, University of Wisconsin, 1300 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USA J.K. Austin, Indiana University School of Nursing, 1111 Middle Drive, NU 492, Indianapolis, IN 46202-5107, USA R. Baldwin, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA T.Z. Baram, Departments of Pediatrics and Anatomy/Neurobiology and Neurology, University of California at Irvine, Irvine, CA 92697-4475, USA D.E Barboriak, Department of Radiology (Neuroradiology), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA C. Barlow, The Salk Institute for Biological Studies, The Laboratory of Genetics, 10010 North Torrey Pines Road, La Jolla, CA 92037, USA N.G. Bazan, Neuroscience Center of Excellence and Department of Ophthalmology, LSU State University Health Sciences Center, 2020 Gravier Street, New Orleans, LA 70112, USA A.J. Becker, Department of Neuropathology, University of Bonn Medical Center, SigmundFreud-Str. 25, 53105 Bonn, Germany B. Bell, Department of Neurology, University of Wisconsin, 600 North Highland Avenue, Madison, WI 53792, USA Y. Ben-Ari, Institut National de la Sant6 de la Recherche Medicale, Unit 29, Institut de Neurobiologie de la M6diterran6e, Marseille, France R.A. Bender, Departments of Pediatrics and Anatomy/Neurobiology and Neurology, University of California at Irvine, CA 92697-4475, USA J. Bengzon, Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital, S-221 85 Lund, Sweden A. Bernasconi, Epilepsy Clinic and Brain Imaging Center, Montreal Neurological Institute and Hospital, 3801 University Street, Montreal, PQ H3A 2B4, Canada I. Bltimcke, Department of Neuropathology, University of Bonn Medical Center, SigmundFreud-Str. 25, 53105 Bonn, Germany K.J. Buchheim, Johannes Mtiller Institut ffir Physiologie, Universit~itsklinikum Charit6, Humboldt Universit~it Berlin, Tucholskystrasse 2, D 10117 Berlin, Germany L.D. Cahan, Neurosurgery, Southern California Permanente Medical Group, Los Angeles, CA 15261, USA F. Cendes, Epilepsy Clinic and Brain Imaging Center, Montreal Neurological Institute and Hospital, 3801 University Street, Montreal, PQ H3A 2B4, Canada
vi H.R. Cock, Department of Clinical and Experimental Epilepsy, Institute of Neurology, Queen Square, London WC1N 3BG, UK A.J. Cole, MGH Epilepsy Service, VBK 830, Massachusetts General Hospital, 55 Fruit Street, Boston, MA 02114, USA J.A. Del Rio, The Salk Institute for Biological Studies, The Laboratory of Genetics, 10010 North Torrey Pines Road, La Jolla, CA 92037, USA C.B. Dodrill, Harborview Medical Center, Epilepsy Center (Box 359745), 325 9th Avenue, Seattle, WA 98104-2499, USA RE. Dudek, Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA J.S. Duncan, National Society for Epilepsy, Chalfont St. Peter, Buckinghamshire SL9 0LR, UK D.W. Dunn, Indiana University School of Nursing, 1111 Middle Drive, NU 492, Indianapolis, IN 46202-5107, USA A. Ebner, Epilepsy Center Bethel, Epilepsy Surgery Program, Maraweg 21, D-33617 Bielefeld, Germany M. Eghbal-Ahmadi, Departments of Pediatrics and Anatomy/Neurobiology and Neurology, University of California at Irvine, CA 92697-4475, USA C.T. Ekdahl, Section of Restorative Neurology, Wallenberg Neuroscience Center, BMC A-11, S-221 84 Lund, Sweden J. Engel, Jr., Departments of Neurology and Neurobiology, and the Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, 710 Westwood Plaza, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1769, USA D.J. Ferraro, Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA S. Gabriel, Johannes MUller Institut ftir Physiologie, Universit~itsklinikum Charitr, Humboldt Universitfit Berlin, Tucholskystrasse 2, D 10117 Berlin, Germany W.D. Galliard, Clinical Epilepsy Section, National Institutes of Health, Building 10, Room 5N-250, Bethesda, MD 20892, USA O.H.J. Gr6hn, NMR Research Group, A.I. Virtanen Institute for Molecular Sciences, University of Kuopio, P.O. Box 1627, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland R.W. Guillery, Department of Anatomy, University of Wisconsin, 1300 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USA W.A. Hauser, Sergievsky Center, Columbia University, College of Physicians and Surgeons, 630 W 168th St, New York, NY 10032, USA U. Heinemann, Johannes Mtiller Institut ftir Physiologie, Universit~tsklinikum Charitr, Humboldt Universit~it Berlin, Tucholskystrasse 2, D 10117 Berlin, Germany J.L. Hellier, Department of Neurology, University of Colorado Health Science Center, Denver, CO 80262, USA C. Helmstaedter, University Clinic of Epileptology, University of Bonn, Sigmund Freud Strasse 25, D-53105 Bonn, Germany B.P. Hermann, Department of Neurology, University of Wisconsin, 600 North Highland Avenue, Madison, WI 53792, USA G.L. Holmes, Clinical Neurophysiology Laboratory, Hunnewell 2, Children's Hospital, 300 Longwood Avenue, Boston, MA 02115, USA H. Jokeit, Swiss Epilepsy Center, Bleulerstrasse 60, CH-8008 Zurich, Switzerland R. K~ilvi~iinen, Department of Neurology, Kuopio University Hospital, P.O. Box 1777, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland
vii O. Kann, Johannes Mtiller Institut fur Physiologie, Universit/itsklinikum Charit6, Humboldt Universit~it Berlin, Tucholskystrasse 2, D 10117 Berlin, Germany H. Katsumori, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA R. Kauppinen, NMR Research Group, A.I. Virtanen Institute for Molecular Sciences, University of Kuopio, P.O. Box 1627, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland R. Khazipov, Institut National de la Sant6 de la Recherche Medicale, Unit 29, Institut de Neurobiologie de la M6diterran6e, Marseille, France S. Koh, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, Massachusetts General Hospital and Department of Neurology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02114, USA R. Kotloski, Department of Neurology, H6/570, 600 Highland Avenue, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53792, USA R. Kovacs, Johannes Mtiller Institut ftir Physiologie, Universitatsklinikum Charit6, Humboldt Universit~it Berlin, Tucholskystrasse 2, D 10117 Berlin, Germany S. Lauersdorf, Department of Neurology, H6/570, 600 Highland Avenue, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53792, USA J.R. Lee, California Medical Review Inc., San Francisco, CA 94104, USA J.P. Leite, Department of Neurology, Ribeirao Preto School of Medicine, University of S~o Paulo, Ribeirao Preto, Brazil SA D.V. Lewis, Department of Pediatrics (Neurology), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA L.M. Li, Epilepsy Clinic and Brain Imaging Center, Montreal Neurological Institute and Hospital, 3801 University Street, Montreal, PQ H3A 2B4, Canada O. Lindvall, Section of Restorative Neurology, Wallenberg Neuroscience Center, BMC A-11, S-221 84 Lund, Sweden H. Liu, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA D.H. Lowenstein, Harvard Medical School and Department of Neurology, Beth IsraelDeaconess Medical Center, 333 Brookline Avenue, Boston, MA 02215, USA K. Lukasiuk, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, A.I. Virtanen Institute, University of Kuopio, Neulaniementie 2, P.O. Box 1627, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland M. Lynch, Department of Neurology, H6/570, 600 Highland Avenue, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53792, USA J.R. MacFall, Department of Radiology (Neuroradiology), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA G.W. Mathern, Division of Neurosurgery, Reed Neurological Research Center, 710 Westwood, Plaza, Room 2123, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1769, USA A.M. Mazarati, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA B.S. Meldrum, GKT School of Biomedical Sciences, Henriette Raphael House, Guy's Campus, London SE1 1UL, UK R. Miettinen, Department of Neurology and Neurosciences, University of Kuopio, P.O. Box 1777, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland T.V. Mitchell, Department of Radiology (Neurology), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA
viii E Mohapel, Section of Restorative Neurology, Wallenberg Neuroscience Center, BMC A-11, S-221 84 Lurid, Sweden S.L. Mosh6, Departments of Neurology and Neuroscience, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Einstein/Montefiore Epilepsy Management Center, 1410 Pelham Parkway South, Bronx, NY 10461, USA J. Nairism~igi, NMR Research Group, A.I. Virtanen Institute for Molecular Sciences, University of Kuopio, EO. Box 1627, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland D. Naylor, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA J. Niquet, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA J. Nissinen, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, A.I. Virtanen Institute, University of Kuopio, Neulaniementie 2, EO. Box 1627, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland J.M. Parent, University of Michigan Medical Center, Neuroscience Laboratory Building, 1103 East Huron Street, Ann Arbor, MI 48104-1687, USA E. Pauli, Department of Neurology, Epilepsy-Center University, Erlangen-Niimberg, Schwabachanlage 6, 91054 Erlangen, Germany A. Pitkanen, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, A.I. Virtanen Institute for Molecular Sciences, University of Kuopio, Neulaniementie 2, P.O. Box 1627, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland J.M. Provenzale, Department of Radiology (Neuroradiology), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA E.B. Rodriguez de Turco, Neuroscience Center of Excellence and Department of Ophthalmology, LSU State University Health Sciences Center, New Orleans, LA 70112, USA T. Salmenper~i, Department of Neurology, Kuopio University Hospital, P.O. Box 1777, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland R. Sankar, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA N. Santilli, Elan Pharmaceuticals, 800 Gateway Blvd, South San Fransisco, CA 94080, USA P. Schauwecker, Department of Cell and Neurobiology, University of Southern California, Keck School of Medicine, BMT 401, 1333 San Pablo Street, Los Angeles, CA 900899112, USA S. Schuchmann, Johannes MUller Institut fiir Physiologie, Universit~tsklinikum Charit6, Humboldt Universit~it Berlin, Tucholskystrasse 2, D 10117 Berlin, Germany M. Seidenberg, Department of Psychology, Chicago Medical School, North Chicago, IL 60064-3095, USA S. Shinnar, Comprehensive Epilepsy Management Center, Montefiore Medical Center, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, 111 E 210th Street, Bronx, NY 10467, USA Y. Shirasaka, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA S. Shorvon, Institute of Neurology, Queen Square, London WC1N 3BG, UK C.E. Stafstrom, Department of Neurology, H6-528, University of Wisconsin, 600 Highland Avenue, Madison, WI 53792, USA
ix K.J. Staley, Department of Neurology, University of Colorado Health Science Center, Denver, CO 80262, USA H. Stefan, Department of Neurology, Epilepsy-Center University, Erlangen-Ntirnberg, Schwabachanlage 6, 91054 Erlangen, Germany L. Suchomelova, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA T.E Sutula, Departments of Neurology and Anatomy, H6/570, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53792, USA J.W. Swann, The Cain Foundation Laboratories, Department of Pediatrics, Baylor College of Medicine, 6621 Fannin St., MC3-6365, Houston, TX 77030, USA E. Tasch, Epilepsy Clinic and Brain Imaging Center, Montreal Neurological Institute and Hospital, 3801 University Street, Montreal, PQ H3A 2B4, Canada W.H. Theodore, Clinical Epilepsy Section, National Institutes of Health, Building 10, Room 5N-250, Bethesda, MD 20892, USA K.W. Thompson, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Department of Neurology and Brain Research Institute, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA D.M. Treiman, Barrow Neurological Institute, 350 West Thomas Road, Phoenix, AZ 85013, USA B. Tu, Neuroscience Center of Excellence and Department of Ophthalmology, LSU State University Health Sciences Center, New Orleans, LA 70112, USA K.E. VanLandingham, Department of Medicine (Neurology), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA L. Veli~ek, Departments of Pediatrics, Neurology and Neuroscience, AECOM, K314, 1410 Pelham Parkway South, Bronx, NY 10461, USA C.G. Wasterlain, Department of Neurology, VA Medical Center (127), 11301 Wilshire Boulevard, West Los Angeles, CA 90073, USA M.J. West, Department of Neurobiology/Anatomy, University of Arhus, 8000 Arhus C, Denmark O.D. Wiestler, Department of Neuropathology, University of Bonn Medical Center, Sigmund-Freud-Str. 25, 53105 Bonn, Germany EA. Williams, Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA Y. Zheng, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, Massachusetts General Hospital and Department of Neurology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02114, USA
xi
Preface People with severe epilepsy may experience multiple seizures each day and hundreds to thousands of seizures during their lifetimes. Even for people with severe epilepsy, the time represented by the seizures, which typically last only seconds to minutes, is only a very small fraction of their total existence. The cumulative adverse impact of the brief seizures, however, is usually substantial and, in some cases, may be quite debilitating. How do brief episodes of abnormal brain electrical activity and the accompanying involuntary behaviors produce prolonged disruption of normal functions that persists beyond the seizures, and why in some cases does this disruption appear to be progressive and cumulative? Seizures can be regarded as symptoms of an underlying brain disorder, and progression of neurological disability may be caused by progression of the primary disorder. In some cases, the causative lesion may be static, but progression still occurs, which raises questions about the potentially damaging effects of the repeated seizures. For many patients, recurring seizures become increasingly frequent and are associated with progressive disability that may include memory disturbances, cognitive impairments, and diminished quality of life. These observations and concerns, which are unfortunately familiar for too many patients, families, and physicians, raise the question "Do seizures damage the brain?" The association of epilepsy with brain damage is well established, and includes the observation that as many as 70% of cases of drug refractory epilepsy are accompanied by obvious hippocampal sclerosis, a lesion characterized by neuronal loss and gliosis involving the CA3, CA1 subregions of the hippocampus, and the hilus of the dentate gyrus. The association of epilepsy with hippocampal sclerosis is of interest because the hippocampus has been implicated in memory formation, and many patients with chronic epilepsy have significant memory dysfunction. In addition to memory disturbances, the cognitive dysfunction experienced by patients with long-standing epilepsy may involve other domains, and may be observed as a cumulative consequence of poorly controlled seizures even when seizure control is eventually achieved. What are the cumulative effects of recurring brief seizures? A firm answer to this question has been surprisingly elusive for a variety of reasons. Clearly there is a subset of patients who appear to tolerate seizures with relatively limited long-term consequences, and not all patients are destined to progress to intractability with frequent seizures and disability. This variability and individual susceptibility has made it difficult to make statements that fairly apply to the full range of people with epileptic disorders, whose disorders span a broad spectrum from mild with excellent control and few limitations, to severe with multiple daily seizures and pronounced disability that affects employment, educational performance, and personal life. Another factor that has made it difficult to assess the effects of recurring brief seizures is the broad range of underlying pathologies, which also vary in respect to severity. As noted, progression of a primary condition may obscure the potentially progressive adverse effects of the superimposed symptomatic seizures. When the primary condition is static, but has produced severe cognitive disability, such as cerebral palsy or syndromes of mental
xii retardation, the incremental adverse effects of seizures may be difficult to detect on the background of significant primary impairments. Finally, in an effort to make the best of unfavorable circumstances, many people afflicted by epilepsy have been understandably reluctant to draw attention to adverse consequences, and to add to the burden of stigma and exclusion from many aspects of normal life. So what are the consequences, if any, of the repeated brief seizures that are the defining feature of epilepsy? Is there a spectrum of severity of seizure-induced damage? Should damage be regarded only as loss of neurons or atrophy of hippocampus and other brain structures? Is damage any change in cells (or properties of cells) that is sufficient to permanently alter functional properties of neural circuits, as detected by physiological assessment? In the developing nervous system, is damage any change in cells, properties of cells, or neural circuits that cumulatively modifies or alters developmental outcome? Is damage any change in cells (or properties of cells) that cumulatively results in behaviorally significant alterations? Few would dispute that inadequately treated status epilepticus produces brain damage detectable by imaging evidence of reduced brain volume and permanent cognitive dysfunction. The potential subtlety of incremental effects at the cellular level may make detection of changes induced by brief seizures quite difficult, but these seizures may still lead to cumulative structural and functional defects. This volume seeks to explore the spectrum of severe to more subtle damage that may be a consequence of seizures. The contributing authors have addressed these questions and related issues using a variety of methods in experimental models and in patients with epilepsy. The picture that has emerged in response to the question "Do seizures damage the brain?" is that cumulative damage from repeated seizures should not be regarded only in terms of loss of neurons or brain atrophy, but should be broadened to include irreversible or permanent dysfunction that is a consequence of recurring seizures. The dysfunction may or may not be associated with clear structural alterations, and may be caused by complex molecular, cellular, synaptic, and systems level dysfunction that results in permanent cognitive and behavioral impairments. T. Sutula A. Pitk~inen (Editors)
xiii
Acknowledgements The contributions to this volume were initially presented and discussed at a workshop held in Rovaniemi, Finland from June 27-July 1, 2001, which was supported by grants from Elan Pharmaceuticals and the American Epilepsy Society. The editors gratefully acknowledge not only the support, but also the encouragement from Elan and the American Epilepsy Society to pursue the difficult and sometimes unsettling questions that are the subject of this volume. We especially thank the participating authors and their 'behind the scenes' supporters, whose sacrifice of time and dedication have significantly contributed to this effort to address important questions for people with epilepsy. We also thank the many members of the Department of Neurology at the University of Wisconsin and the A.I. Virtanen Institute for Molecular Sciences at the University of Kuopio who organized the workshop, including Daryn Belden, Carol Chijimatsu, and Greg Zalesak (Madison) and Samuli Kemppainen, Sanna Viitanen (Kuopio).
T. Sutula and A. Pitkanen (Eds.) Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135 © 2002 Published by Elsevier Science B.V.
CHAPTER 1
Concept of activity-induced cell death in epilepsy: historical and contemporary perspectives Brian S. M e l d r u m * GKT Department of Biomedical Sciences, Kings College, London, UK
Abstract: Selective neuronal loss following status epilepticus was first described just under 100 years ago. The acute pathology following status epilepticus was shown to be 'ischemic cell change' and was assumed to arise through hypoxia/ischemia. Less than 30 years ago it was proposed, from experiments in primates, that the selective neuronal loss in hippocampus and cortex resulted from the abnormal electrical discharges. Selectively vulnerable neurons show swollen, calcium-loaded mitochondria in the soma and focally in dendrites. Burst firing with a massive Ca2+ entry needs to be sustained for 30-120 min to produce necrotic cell death. Lesser stress may produce apoptosis or immediate early gene expression with enhanced expression of many enzymes and receptor subunits. Changes in enzyme, transporter, ion-channel or receptor function or in network properties may lead to altered vulnerability to the effects of seizures. This type of modification and the cumulative effect of oxidative damage to proteins and lipids may explain the long-term consequences of repetitive brief seizures.
Introduction
The concept that it is the abnormal discharges associated with epileptic activity that cause selectively vulnerable neurons to die is so widely accepted today that it appears to be virtually self-evident. I suspect that most young researchers in epilepsy would be amazed to learn that the concept did not exist 30 years ago. Thus I am grateful for this opportunity to give a simple historical account of the development of the concept. A fuller account is provided by Shorvon (1994). The first account of a selective pattern of brain damage (unilateral hippocampal sclerosis, diffuse cortical atrophy, lobular cerebellar atrophy) found in institutionalized patients with intractable seizures
*Correspondence to: B.S. Meldrum, GKT School of Biomedical Sciences, Henriette Raphael House, Guy's Campus, London SE1 1UL, UK. Tel.: +44-207-848-6420; E-mail: brian.meldrum @kcl.ac.uk
was given by Bouchet and Cazauvieilh in 1825. In 1880, Sommer described the cellular pathology in the hippocampus very precisely and concluded that this focal pathology was the cause ('aetiologisches Moment') of generalized seizures (Sommer, 1880). Pfleger also in 1880 reviewed a large series of post mortem studies and remarked that some patients dying during or a few days after status epilepticus had what appeared (on gross inspection) to be acute vascular lesions in the amygdala or hippocampus. He suggested that disturbances in local cerebral circulation might be associated with prolonged seizures (Pfleger, 1880). Selective neuronal loss
The first clear account of selective neuronal loss following status epilepticus appeared in the American Journal of Insanity in three articles by Clark and Prout (1903-1904). They monitored blood pressure, respiration and temperature throughout status epilepticus, emphasizing the sinister significance of
hyperthermia. They described a sequence of cellular changes observed with Nissl staining in the brains of seven patients dying during the course of status epilepticus involving pyramidal neurons in lamina II and III in the cortex. There was initially chromatolysis (loss of Nissl staining) sometimes associated with protoplasmic vacuolation or shrinkage of the cytoplasm. Later there were glial cell changes that could be evidence of neuronophagia. Classical neuropathology developed in Germany in the early 1900s. Alzheimer (1907) was the first of about a dozen noted pathologists to write in German on the neuropathology of epilepsy and status epilepticus (quoted in Scholz, 1951, 1959; Peiffer, 1963). By far the most influential paper concerning status epilepticus was that of Spielmeyer (1927). He described the predominant early finding in selectively vulnerable neurons as 'ischemic cell change' ('Ischaemische Zellerkrankung'), a type of necrotic cell death observed in Nissl stained preparations that was characteristic of anoxic/ischemic damage. The selective pattern of damage in the hippocampus, neocortex and cerebellum was also similar to that seen following cerebral ischemia, as after cardiac arrest, severe arterial hypotension or strangulation. It was then thought that vascular spasm ('angiospasmen') played an important part in the initiation of seizures, thus it was concluded that selective patterns of brain damage observed after status epilepticus were the consequence of cerebral hypoxia/ischemia occurring as a result of vasospasm, or possibly hypoxia and cerebrovascular problems during or directly after seizures or associated with later cerebral edema (Spielmeyer, 1930). The concept of selective vulnerability in neurodegenerative disorders was explored by Vogt and Vogt (1922) who spoke of 'pathoclisis' evoking a mechanism whereby differences in fine structure or biochemistry of particular neurons could account for different patterns of selective vulnerability encountered in different degenerative disorders.
man, 1985). The first such study was from Gibbs et al. (1934) who used thermocouples in the internal jugular vein. Similarly Penfield and colleagues (Penfield et al., 1939; Penfield and Jasper, 1954) recorded focal seizure discharges with corticography in the open skull and using thermocouples and direct observation noted that there was vasodilation in association with seizure onset. Indeed, the hyperemia was such that the venous blood became red, suggesting that blood flow increased relatively more than oxygen consumption.
Incisural sclerosis Earle et al. (1953) used suction to remove mesial temporal structures as a treatment for drug-resistant complex partial seizures and described the frequent occurrence (100 of 157 cases) of sclerotic lesions in the medial tip of the temporal lobe (uncus). They called this pathology 'incisural sclerosis' to indicate that it arose from herniation of the medial border of the anterior temporal lobe over the tentorium causing ischemic lesions (through compression of branches of the anterior choroidal and posterior cerebral arteries). The postulation that this event occurred during moulding of the head in the normal birth process was supported by experimental studies on fetal brains. The ischemic lesion was seen as the focal pathology responsible for the epileptic focus. This view was very influential for 20-30 years. It was rejected by Falconer (1968) on the grounds that: (1) postmortem studies in neonates did not reveal this pattern of pathology (Veith, 1960); (2) the lack of correlation of the pathology with a history of difficult birth (as acknowledged by Penfield) is problematic; and (3) the extent of the pathology in the anterior temporal lobe and elsewhere in the brain was not compatible with compression of the anterior choroidal and posterior cerebral arteries. Nevertheless the clinical concept remained current in the 1980s (Turner and Wyler, 1981).
Changes in cerebral blood flow and metabolism in seizures
The Meyer hypothesis
This concept of the ischemic nature of the damage was widely accepted, but came into conflict with a progressive body of evidence that cerebral blood flow increased during seizures (see review by Chap-
The introduction of the en bloc resection of the anterior temporal lobe by Murray Falconer provided material suitable for detailed neuropathological study. The initial analysis of this material by Cavanagh and
Meyer (1956) is a landmark. It showed that laminar necrosis was widespread in the temporal cortex. It also noted the striking clinical correlation between mesial temporal sclerosis and a history of an early episode of status epilepticus or prolonged febrile convulsions (11 out of 17 patients with Ammon's horn sclerosis, compared with 0 out of 9 without Ammon's horn sclerosis) that preceded the clinical onset of complex partial seizures by 1 or more years. This clinical correlation whereby approximately two-thirds of drug-refractory complex partial seizure patients with mesial temporal sclerosis give a history of an early (6 months to 5 years) episode of status epilepticus or complicated febrile convulsions (more than 1 in 24 h, or lasting more than 30 min, or with focal features) has been confirmed in a large number of neurosurgical reports, e.g. Falconer, 1974; Sagar and Oxbury, 1987; Kim et al., 1990; Cendes et al., 1993; Mathem et al., 1995; Mathem et al., 2002, this volume). At the 1954 Marseille Colloquium Gastaut (1956) described Meyer as having proposed that the initial event causes the mesial temporal sclerosis and this lesion, after an appropriate maturational period, is the focal site of onset of the complex partial seizures. This causal sequence has been described as the Meyer hypothesis (Meldrum, 1997).
Primate experimental studies and activity-dependent cell death Although several authors had induced generalized or focal seizures in animals chemically or electrically and looked for pathological changes, none had successfully addressed the issue of relating the pathology to local and generalized physiological changes. The first studies permitting conclusions regarding these issues were those of Brierley and Meldrum in the early 1970s. We monitored a variety of physiological parameters in adolescent baboons during prolonged seizures induced by intravenous bicuculline and studied ischemic cell change in selectively vulnerable neurons in the acutely perfused brain (Meldrum and Brierley, 1973; Meldrum and Horton, 1973). We studied the relationship between physiological changes and acute pathology both in unmodified seizures and in paralyzed, ventilated animals in which cerebral hypoxia was minimized
(Meldrum et al., 1973). We concluded that, whereas arterial hypotension and hyperthermia could contribute to cerebellar damage, hippocampal and cortical damage was largely the result of the local seizure activity itself, with the critical duration of seizure activity for inducing ischemic cell change lying between 82 and 120 min. We also used allylglycine to induce multiple brief seizures (6-63 seizures in 2-11 h) and saw similar selective patterns of ischemic cell change in the hippocampus, but also saw, with 7-21 day survival, classical appearances of selective neuronal loss, phagocytosis and gliosis in CA1 and CA3 subzones (Meldrum and Brierley, 1972; Meldmm et al., 1974). The concept that the burst discharges were the primary (and sufficient) cause of the selective neuronal damage remained controversial, but was confirmed a decade later when Sloviter (1983) showed that perforant path stimulation could lead to damage in the hilus and CA3 (see also Olney et al., 1983; Sloviter et al., 1996).
Subsequent rodent experiments with generalized seizures With the collaboration of Astrid Chapman in Bo Siesj6's laboratory I subsequently established a similar model of status epilepticus induced by bicuculline in paralysed ventilated rats, that allowed confirmation of the selective pathology occurring in the hippocampus but also permitted detailed study of cerebral blood flow and metabolism during seizures (Meldrum and Nilsson, 1976; Borgstrrm et al., 1976; Chapman et al., 1977). These studies showed massive increases in oxygen and glucose consumption that were, however, fully compensated by the increases in blood flow. It was possible to manipulate the critical physiological parameters, confirming that hyperthermia could exacerbate cerebellar damage but perhaps surprisingly showing that arterial hypotension and mild hypoxia might be protective, possibly because they reduced the intensity of the seizure discharge (Blennow et al., 1978; Nevander et al., 1985).
Experiments with limbic seizures We and others showed that limbic seizures induced by the focal injection of kainate or NMDA (N-
methyl-D-aspartate) into the amygdala or hippocampus in rodents and primates could produce various patterns of hippocampal and amygdala damage but with a strong effect on CA3 pyramidal neurons (BenAri et al., 1980; Menini et al., 1980). NMDA receptor antagonists protect against the remote damage seen after focal injections of kainate into amygdala or hippocampus, and most of the damage seen after seizures induced by systemic kainate (Fariello et al., 1989; Clifford et al., 1990; Lerner-Natoli et al., 1991; Jarrard and Meldrum, 1993). Only a limited amount of the CA3 damage seems to be a direct consequence of kainate receptor activation; most of the damage is due to burst activity and NMDA receptor activation related to seizure spread.
Calcium and mitochondrial swelling In a series of talks in 1980, I outlined for the first time the hypothesis that mitochondrial poisoning by calcium overload was the critical link between the burst discharges and ischemic cell change (see Meldrum, 1981, 1983). This hypothesis derived from the observations of Schanne et al. (1979) in liver and Wrogemann and Pena (1976) in muscle. In collaboration with Griffiths and Evans we used the oxalate pyroantimonate procedure to visualize free calcium in EM images, during the course of status epilepticus induced in rats by bicuculline, allylglycine or kainic acid (Evans et al., 1983, 1984; Griffiths et al., 1983). In the hippocampus, we observed massive calcium loading of mitochondria focally in dendritic fields of CA1 and CA3 after 60-120 min of seizure activity, irrespective of the seizure-inducing agent. The focal dendritic swellings appeared to relate to excitatory inputs. We subsequently showed that the grossly swollen, calcium-loaded mitochondria were visible after 30 min of seizure-like discharge, but that these changes were reversible over a 30-60-min period if the seizure was terminated by diazepam (Evans et al., 1984; Griffiths et al., 1984). In the hippocampal dendritic fields, the mitochondrial changes are highly focal with a large number of mitochondria remaining morphologically normal. This finding does not appear to be sufficiently considered in ex vivo studies of mitochondrial function following seizure activity (see Cock, 2002, this volume).
Necrotic cell death and apoptotic cell death Ischemic cell change with its initial stage of mitochondrial overload with calcium is the classic form of necrotic cell death. Apoptotic cell death is the preferred form of neuronal suicide, but requires energy in the form of ATP and protein synthesis. It can be triggered either via cell surface death receptors or via the mitochondrial release of either cytochrome c (activating caspase 9, and subsequently the executioner caspases) or the apoptosis-inducing factor (Joza et al., 2001). It is clear that severe and prolonged seizure discharges trigger both forms of cell death, sometimes in the same cell population but with different time courses or in different cell populations. This is seen morphologically in dentate granule cells with pilocarpine seizures (Covolan et al., 2000) or repetitive perforant path stimulation (Sloviter et al., 1996), and with immunocytochemistry in CA3 neurons after intra-amygdaloid kainate (Henshall et al., 1999, 2000). It is clear that dentate granule cells more readily show apoptosis, and in the limbic seizure model with intra-amygdaloid kainate they may show a minimal level of apoptosis when CA3 neurons are showing severe necrosis. They also may show increased apoptosis after a single kindling seizure (Bengzon et al., 1997).
Cumulative effects and'the two hit concept The conclusion from a large series of experiments relating to activity-dependent cell death is that the threshold duration of sustained seizure activity to produce acute necrotic cell death with an appropriate selective pattern is around or above 30 min. Single brief seizures do not cause necrotic cell death. As shown by Bengzon et al. (2002, this volume) they may double the natural rate of apoptosis in certain cell types, such as dentate granule cells, but they are not documented as inducing selective patterns of cell loss. Nevertheless, sequences of brief seizures in various circumstances do appear to be capable of inducing cell loss. There is a wide range of possible mechanisms for such an effect. A single brief seizure is associated with intracellular changes in ionic concentration well outside the physiological ranges that have multiple consequences with complex time courses (see Holmes
et al., 2002, this volume). Immediate early gene expression is seen 0.5-4 h following the seizure and mRNA and protein for a variety of enzymes, receptors and ion channel subunits can be shown to be altered subsequently, including for example COX-2 (see Bazan et al., 2002, this volume). These changes will alter the vulnerability of an individual neuron to subsequent 'excitotoxic' stresses and will modify network responses to future abnormal inputs. There is of course a wide variety of experimental evidence that the consequences of brief episodes of cerebral ischemia or of epileptic activity or both combined are different if they occur with a brief separation (in the range 0.5-24 h) compared with longer intervals. Of course, some functional consequences of a single seizure may be long-term and therefore cumulative. These include long-term changes in gene expression, oxidative damage to membrane lipids and proteins or damage to nuclear or mitochondrial DNA. The changes in gene expression may result in altered subunit composition for excitatory or inhibitory receptors with major effects on synaptic function. GABAA receptor subunits are hanged after pilocarpine seizures (Rice et al., 1996) or after absence seizures (Banerjee et al., 1998). Altered expression of GABA receptor subunits may alter epileptogenesis (Poulter et al., 1999). There may also be changes in ion channel function as described by Chen et al. (2001) and Bender et al. (2001) after hyperthermic seizures (where the function of hyperpolarization activated, cyclicnucleotide-gated cation channels is altered) and by Becker et al. (2002, this volume) in the pilocarpine status model (where spontaneous limbic seizures are associated with enhanced expression of the cL-1H subunit of the T-type voltage-sensitive calcium channel). Genetic influences
There has long been evidence that different strains of mice have different seizure susceptibilities. This applies to almost all seizure models, including electroshock, chemically induced seizures and reflex epilepsies. These models offer the possibility of detecting single locus differences (see Frankel et al., 2001 for electroconvulsive shock in inbred strains, Ferraro et al., 1997 for kainic acid seizures, Fer-
raro et al., 1999 for pentylenetetrazol seizures and Skradski et al., 1998 for sound-induced seizures). The altemative approach of using microchip arrays to identify differentially expressed genes comparing brain regions in different mouse strains and the effects of seizures in those strains is described by Sandberg et al. (2000) and Del Rio and Barlow (2002, this volume). This approach shows that the induction of immediate early genes 60 min after pentylenetetrazol seizures is closely similar in 129SvEv and C57BL/6 mice and confirms the early induction of COX2. Genetic factors also influence the consequences of seizures. This has been elegantly demonstrated by Schauwecker (2002, this volume). Kainic acidinduced cell death in the mouse hippocampus is strongly modulated by genetic factors (Schauwecker and Steward, 1997), with some standard mouse strains C57BL/6, 129/SvJ and BALB/c) being relatively resistant to hilar and pyramidal cell loss (compared to 129/SvEMS and DBA/2J) in spite of similar seizure severity. As Dr. Schauwecker shows, strain crosses suggest that one or more genes with a dominant effect are responsible for the resistance to kainate-induced cell death. The complexity of the genetic factors influencing the development of Ammon's horn sclerosis following prolonged febrile convulsions in man can be broken down into several headings. The tendency to show convulsions during the course of a febrile illness is under strong genetic control (Hauser et al., 1985). The extent to which this gives rise to selective neuronal death is probably under a separate genetic Control. The nature and severity of the inflammatory response is probably independently genetically controlled as is suggested by the recent study showing specific polymorphisms in interleukin receptor antagonist genes in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (Kanemoto et al., 2000). There may be additional genetic influences that influence the subsequent process of epileptogenesis. This has been clearly demonstrated in the rodent amygdala kindling model (Mclntyre et al., 1999) where fast and slow kindling strains have been identified. Responsiveness to anti-epileptic drug therapy may also be under genetic control as is suggested by studies on phenytoin resistance in kindled rats (Ebert and L6scher, 1999).
TABLE 1
References
Some consequences of burst firing 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12.
Increase in [Ca2+]i Activation of phospholipase A2 and phospholipase C Immediate early gene expression Altered kinase activity, altered phosphorylation of enzymes, receptors, ion channels Altered ion channel function Altered subunit expression of excitatory and inhibitory receptors Altered synaptic morphology, remodelled dendritic spines Enhanced neurogenesis in dentate Sprouting, altered connectivity Oxidative damage to proteins, lipids and DNA Apoptosis (caspase activation) Necrosis (mitochondrial Ca 2+ poisoning)
Conclusions The burst firing associated with epileptic discharges when sustained for 30-120 min leads to selective neuronal necrosis in hippocampus, amygdala and cortex that is a consequence of calcium overloading of mitochondria. Some consequences of less sustained burst firing are listed in Table 1. At the threshold, there will be effects mediated via actin on dendritic spine shapes that are indistinguishable from physiological effects of AMPA and NMDA receptor activation (Fischer et al., 2000). Activation of phospholipase 2 initiates the arachidonic acid cascade with many complex consequences for gene expression, free radical production and apoptosis as discussed by Bazan et al. (2002, this volume). Functional changes occur through altered phosphorylation of many enzymes and receptors and through altered expression of receptor subunits. These and various morphological changes will lead to significant changes in network function and excitability. These types of change provide one mechanism whereby single seizures can have cumulative effects; the other mechanism is by the progressive accumulation of oxidative damage to proteins, lipids and DNA. Understanding these mechanisms allows the design and testing of a wide variety of neuroprotective strategies, as discussed in Meldrum (2002, this volume).
Alzheimer, A. (1907) Die Gruppierung der Epilepsie. Alg. Z Psychiatric, 64: 418-448. Banerjee, P.K., Tillakaratne, N.J., Brailowsky, S., Olsen, R.W., Tobin, AJ. and Snead, O.C. (1998) Alterations in GABAA receptor alphal and alpha4 subunit mRNA levels in thalamic relay nuclei following absence-like seizures in rats. Exp. Neurol., 154: 213-223. Bazan, N.G., Tu, B. and Rodriguez de Turco, E.B. (2002) What synaptic lipid signaling tells us about seizure-induced damage and epileptogenesis. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 175-185. Becker, A.J., Wiestler, O.D. and Bltimcke, I. (2002) Functional genomics in experimental and human temporal lobe epilepsy: powerful new tools to identify molecular disease mechanisms of hippocampal damage. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitk'anen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 161-173. Ben-Aft, Y., Tremblay, E., Ottersen, O.P. and Meldrum, B.S. (1980) The role of epileptic activity in hippocampal and 'remote' cerebral lesions induced by kainic acid. Brain Res., 191: 79-97. Bender, R.A., Brewster, A., Santoro, B., Ludwig, A., Hofmann, F., Biel, M. and Baram, T.Z. (2001) Differential and agedependent expression of hyperpolarization activated, Cyclic nucleotide-gated cation channel iso-forms 1-4 suggest evolving roles in the developing rat hippocampus. Neuroscience (in press). Bengzon, J., Kokala, Z., Elmer, E., Nanobashvili, A., Kokaia, M. and Lindvall, O. (1997) Apoptosis and proliferation of dentate gyms neurons after single and intermittent limbic seizures. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 94: 10432-10437. Bengzon, J., Mohapel, P., Ekdahl, C. and Lindvall, O. (2002) Neuronal apoptosis after brief and prolonged seizures. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 111-119. Blennow, G., Brierley, J.B., Meldrum, B.S. and Siesj6, B.K. (1978) Epileptic brain damage. The role of systemic factors that modify cerebral energy metabolism. Brain, 101: 687-700. Borgstr6m, L., Chapman, A.G. and Siesj6, B.K. (1976) Glucose consumption in the cerebral cortex of rat during bicucullineinduced status epilepticus. J. Neurochem., 27: 971-973. Bouchet, C. and Cazauvieilh, M. (Bouchet and Cazauvieilh) De l'6pilepsie consider6e dans ses rapports avec l'ali6nation mentale. Arch. G(n. Med., 9: 510-542. Cavanagh, J.B. and Meyer, A. (1956) Aetiological aspects of Ammon's horn sclerosis associated with temporal lobe epilepsy. Br. Med. J., 2: 1403-1407. Cendes, E, Andermann, E, Dubeau, E, Gloor, P., Evans, A. and Jones-Gotman, M. et al. (1993) Early childhood prolonged febrile convulsions, atrophy and sclerosis of mesial structures, and temporal lobe epilepsy: An MRI volumetric study. Neurology, 43: 1083-1087. Chapman, A.G. (1985) Cerebral energy metabolism and seizures.
In: T.A. Pedley and B.S. Meldrnm, Recent Advances in Epilepsy, Vol. 2. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh, pp. 1963. Chapman, A.G., Meldrum, B.S. and Siesj6, B.K. (1977) Cerebral metabolic changes during prolonged epileptic seizures in rats. J. Neurochem., 28: 1025-1035. Chen, K., Aradi, I., Thon, N., Eghbal-Ahmadi, M., Baram, T.Z. and Soltesz, I. (2001) Persistently modified H-channels after complex febrile seizures convert the seizure-induced enhancement of inhibition to hyperexcitability. Nat. Med., 7: 1-7. Clark, L.E, Prout, T.R (1903-1904) Status epilepticus: A clinical and pathological study in epilepsy. Am. J. Insanity 60: 291306, 645-675; 61: 81-108. Clifford, D.B., Olney, J.W., Benz, A.M., Fuller, T.A. and Zorumski, C.E (1990) Ketamine, phencyclidine, and MK-801 protect against kalnic acid-induced seizure-related brain damage. Epilepsia, 31: 382-390. Cock, H.R. (2002) The role of mitochondria and oxidative stress in neuronal damage after brief and prolonged seizures. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 187-196. Covolan, L., Smith, R.L. and Mello, L.E. (2000) Ultrastructural identification of dentate granule cell death from pilocarpine induced-seizures. Epilepsy Res., 41: 9-21. Del Rio, J.A. and Barlow, C. (2002) Genomics and neurological phenotypes: applications for seizure-induced damage. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 149-160. Earle, K.M., Baldwin, M. and Penfield, W. (1953) Incisural sclerosis and temporal lobe seizures produced by hippocampal herniation at birth. Arch. Neurol. Psychiatry, 69: 27-42. Ebert, U. and Ltischer, W. (1999) Characterization of phenytoinresistant kindled rats, a new model of drag resistant partial epilepsy: influence of genetic factors. Epilepsy Res., 33: 217226. Evans, M., Griffiths, T. and Meldrum, B.S. (1983) Early changes in the rat hippocampus following seizures induced by bicuculline or L-allylglycine: A light and electron microscope study. Neuropathol. Appl. Neurobiol., 9: 39-52. Evans, M.C., Griffiths, T. and Meldrum, B.S. (1984) Kainic acid seizures and the reversibility of calcium loading in vulnerable neurons in the hippocampus. Neuropathol. Appl. Neurobiol., 10: 285-302. Falconer, M.A. (1968) The significance of mesial temporal sclerosis (Ammon's horn sclerosis) in epilepsy. Guy's Hosp. Rep., 117: 1-12. Falconer, M.A. (1974) Mesial temporal (Ammon's horn) sclerosis as a common cause of epilepsy. Aetiology, treatment and prevention.. Lancet, 2: 767-770. Fariello, R.G., Golden, G.T., Smith, G.G. and Reyes, P.E (1989) Potentiation of kainic acid epileptogenicity and sparing from neuronal damage by an NMDA receptor antagonist. Epilepsy Res., 3: 206-213. Ferraro, T.N., Golden, G.T., Smith, G.G., Schork, N.J., St Jean, P., Ballas, C., Cho, H. and Berrettini, W.H. (1997) Mapping
murine loci for seizure response to kainic acid. Mammalian Genome, 8: 200-208. Ferraro, T.N., Golden, G.T., Smith, G.G., St Jean, P., Schork, N.J., Mulholland, N., Ballas, C., Schill, J., Buono, R.J. and Berrettini, W.H. (1999) Mapping loci for pentylenetetrazolinduced seizure susceptibility in mice. J. Neurosci., 19, 67336739. Fischer, M., Kaech, S., Wagner, U., Brinkhaus, H. and Matus, A. (2000) Glutamate receptors regulate actin-based plasticity in dendritic spines. Nat. Neurosci., 3: 887-894. Frankel, W.N., Taylor, L., Beyer, B., Tempel, B.L. and White, H.S. (2001) Electroconvulsive thresholds of inbred mouse strains. Genomics, 74: 306-312. Gastaut, H. (1956) Colloque sur les probl~mes d'anatomie normale et pathologique poses par les drcharges 6pileptiques Marseille. Acta NeuroL Belg., 56:29 (discussion). Gibbs, E, Lennox, W.G. and Gibbs, E.L. (1934) Cerebral blood flow preceding and accompanying epileptic seizures in man. Arch. Neurol. Psychiatry, 32: 257-272. Griffiths, T., Evans, M.C. and Meldrum, B.S. (1983) Intracellular calcium accumulation in rat hippocampus during seizures induced by bicuculline or L-allylglycine. Neuroscience, 10: 385-395. Griffiths, T., Evans, M.C. and Meldrum, B.S. (1984) Status epilepticus: The reversibility of calcium loading and acute neuronal pathological changes in the rat hippocampus. Neuroscience, 12: 557-567. Hauser, W.A., Annegers, J.F., Anderson, V.E. and Kurland, L.T. (1985) The risk of seizure disorders among relatives of children with febrile convulsions. Neurology, 35: 1268-1273. Henshall, D.C., Sinclair, J. and Simon, R.P. (1999) Relationship between seizure-induced transcription of the DNA damageinducible gene GADD45, DNA fragmentation, and neuronal death in focally evoked limbic epilepsy. J. Neurochem., 73: 1573-1583. Henshall, D.C., Sinclair, J. and Simon, R.P. (2000) Spatiotemporal profile of DNA fragmentation and its relationship to patterns of epileptiform activity following focally evoked limbic seizures. Brain Res., 858: 290-302. Holmes, G.L., Khazipov, R. and Ben-Ari, Y. (2002) Seizureinduced damage in the developing human: relevance of experimental models. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitkiinen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 321-334. Jarrard, L.E. and Meldrum, B.S. (1993) Selective excitotoxic pathology in the rat hippocampus. NeuropathoL AplJl. Neurobiol., 19: 381-389. Joza, N., Susin, S.A., Daugas, E., Stanford, W.L., Cho, S.K. and Li, C.Y.J. et al. (2001) Essential role of the mitochondrial apoptosis-inducing factor in programmed cell death. Nature, 410: 549-554. Kanemoto, K., Kawasaki, J., Miyamoto, T., Obayashi, H. and Nishimura, M. (2000) Interleukin (IL)-ll3, IL-lct, and ILl receptor antagonist gene polymorphisms in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy. Ann. NeuroL, 47: 571-574. Kim, J.H., Guimaraes, P.O., Shen, M.Y., Masukawa, L.M. and Spencer, D.D. (1990) Hippocampal neuronal density in tempo-
10
ral lobe epilepsy with and without gliomas. Acta NeuropathoL, 80: 41-45. Lerner-Natoli, M., Rondouin, G., Relaidi, M., Baldy-Moulinier, M. and Kamenka, J.M. (1991) N-(2-thienyl)cyclohexyl 1piperidine (TCP) does not block kainic acid-induced status epilepticus but reduces secondary hippocampal damage. Neurosci. Lett., 122: 174-178. McIntyre, D., Kelly, M.E. and Dufresne, C. (1999) Fast and slow arnygdala kindling rat strains: comparison of amygdala, hippocampal, piriform and perirhinal cortex kindling. Epilepsy Res., 35: 197-209. Mathern, G.W., Pretorius, J.K. and Babb, T.L. (1995) Influence of the type of initial precipating injury and at what age it occurs on course and outcome in patients with temporal lobe seizures. J. Neurosurg., 82: 220-227. Mathern, G.W., Adelson, ED., Cahan, L.D. and Leite, J.E (2002) Hippocampal neuron damage in human epilepsy: Meyer's hypothesis revisited. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 237-251. Meldrum, B.S. (1981) Metabolic effects of prolonged epileptic seizures and the causation of epileptic brain damage. In: EC. Rose (Ed.), Metabolic Disorders of the Nervous System. Pitman, London, pp. 175-187. Meldrum, B.S. (1983) Metabolic factors during prolonged seizures and their relation to nerve cell death. Adv. Neurol., 34: 261-275. Meldrum, B.S. (1997) The First Alfred Meyer memorial lecture. Epileptic brain damage: a consequence and a cause of seizures. Neuropathol. Appl. Neurobiol., 23: 185-202. Meldrum, B.S. (2002) Implications for neuroprotective treatments, ln: T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 487-495. Meldrum, B.S. and Brierley, J.B. (1972) Neuronal loss and gliosis in the hippocampus following repetitive epileptic seizures induced in adolescent baboons by allylglycine. Brain Res., 48: 361-365. Meldrum, B.S. and Brierley, J.B. (1973) Prolonged epileptic seizures in primates: ischaemic cell change and its relation to ictal physiological events. Arch. Neurol., 28: 10-17. Meldrum, B.S. and Horton, R.W. (1973) Physiology of status epilepticus in primates. Arch. Neurol., 28: 1-9. Meldrum, B.S. and Nilsson, B. (1976) Cerebral blood flow and metabolic rate early and late in prolonged epileptic seizures induced in rats by bicuculline. Brain, 99: 523-542. Meldrum, B.S., Vigoroux, R.A. and Brierley, J.B. (1973) Systemic factors and epileptic brain damage. Prolonged seizures in paralysed artificially ventilated baboons. Arch. Neurol., 29: 82-87. Meldrum, B.S., Horton, R.W. and Brierley, J.B. (1974) Epileptic brain damage in adolescent baboons following seizures induced by allylglycine. Brain, 97: 417-428. Menini, C., Meldrum, B.S., Riche, D., Silva-Comte, C. and Stutzmann, J.M. (1980) Sustained limbic seizures induced by intraamygdaloid kainic acid in the baboon: symptomatology
and neuropathological consequences. Ann. Neurol., 8: 501509. Nevander, G., Ingvar, M., Auer, R.N. and Siesjo, B.K. (1985) Status epilepticus in well-oxygenated rats causes neuronal necrosis. Ann. Neurol, 18: 281-290. Olney, J.W., De Gubareff, T. and Sloviter, R.S. (1983) 'Epileptic' brain damage in rats induced by sustained electrical stimulation of the perforant path. II. Ultrastructural analysis of acute hippocampal pathology. Brain Res. Bull., 10:699-712. Peiffer, J. (1963) Morphologische aspekte der epilepsien. Pathogenetische, Pathogisch-Anatomische und Klinische Probleme der Epilepsien, Springer Verlag, Berlin, pp. 1-185. Penfield, W. and Jasper, H. (1954) Epilepsy and the Functional Anatomy of the Human Brain. Churchill, London, pp. 1-896. Penfield, W., von Sfintha, K. and Cipriani, A. (1939) Cerebral blood flow during induced epileptiform seizures in animals and man../. Neurophysiol., 2: 257-267. Pfleger, L. (1880) Beobachtungen tiber Schrumpfung und Sklerose des Ammonshorns bei Epilepsie. Alg. Z. Psychiatrie, 36: 359-365. Poulter, M.O., Brown, L.A., Tynan, S., Willick, G., William, R. and McIntyre, D.C. (1999) Differential expression of alphal, alpha2, alpha3 and alpha5 GABAA receptor subunits in seizure-prone and seizure-resistant rat models of temporal lobe epilepsy. J. Neurosci., 19: 4654-4661. Rice, A., Rafiq, A., Shapiro, S.M., Jakoi, E.R., Coulter, D.A. and De Lorenzo, R.J. (1996) Long-lasting reduction of inhibitory function and gamma-aminobutyric acid type A receptor subunit mRNA expression in a model of temporal lobe epilepsy. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 93: 9665-9669. Sagar, H.J. and Oxbury, J.M. (1987) Hippocampal neuron loss in temporal lobe epilepsy: Correlation with early childhood convulsions. Ann. Neurol., 22: 334-340. Sandberg, R., Yasuda, R., Pankratz, D.G., Carter, T.A., Del Rio, J., Wodicka, L., Mayford, M., Lockhart, D.J. and Barlow, C. (2000) Regional and strain-specific gene expression mapping in the adult mouse brain. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 97: 11038-11043. Schanne, EA.X., Kane, A.B., Young, E.E. and Farber, J.L. (1979) Calcium dependence of toxic cell death: a final common pathway. Science, 206: 700-702. Schauwecker, EE. (2002) Complications associated with genetic background effects in models of experimental epilepsy. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 139-148. Schauwecker, EE. and Steward, O. (1997) Genetic determinants of susceptibility to excitotoxic cell death: Implications for gene targeting approaches. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 94: 4103-4108. Scholz, W. (1951) Die Krampfschiidigungen des Gehirns. Springer, Berlin. Scholz, W. (1959) The contribution of patho-anatomical research to the problem of epilepsy. Epilepsia, 1: 36-55. Shorvon, S. (1994) Status Epilepticus. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Skradski, S.L., White, H.S. and Ptacek, L.J. (1998) Genetic
11
mapping of a locus (mass 1) causing audiogenic seizures in mice. Genomics, 49: 188-192. Sloviter, R.S. (1983) 'Epileptic' brain damage in rats induced by sustained electrical stimulation of the perforant path, I. Acute electrophysiological and light microscopic studies. Brain Res., 10: 675-697. Sloviter, R.S., Dean, E., Sollas, A.L. and Goodman, J.H. (1996) Apoptosis and necrosis induced in different hippocampal neuron populations by repetitive perforant path stimulation in the rat. J. Comp. Neurol., 366: 516-533. Sommer, W. (1880) Erkrankung des Ammonshornes als aetiologisches Moment der Epilepsie. Arch. Psychiat. Nervenkrank., 10: 631-675. Spielmeyer, W. (1927) Die Pathogenese des epileptischen
Krampfes. Z. Ges. NeuroL Psychiatrie, 109: 501-520. Spielmeyer, W. (1930) Anatomic substratum of the convulsive state. Arch. NeuroL Psychiatry, 23: 869-875. Turner, D.A. and Wyler, A.R. (1981) Temporal lobectomy for epilepsy: mesial temporal herniation as an operative and prognostic finding. Epilepsia, 22: 623-629. Veith, G. (1960) On the pathogenesis of perinatal brain lesions. Geburtsh. Frauenheilk., 20: 905-909. Vogt, C. and Vogt, O. (1922) Erkrankungen der Groszhirnrinde im Lichte der topistik Pathoklise, und Pathoarchitektonik. J. PsychoL Neurol. (Leipzig), 28: 1-171. Wrogemann, K. and Pena, S.D.J. (1976) Mitochondrial calcium overload: a general mechanism for cell-necrosis in muscle diseases. Lancet, 1: 672-674.
T. Sutula and A. Pitkanen (Eds.) Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135 © 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
CHAPTER 2
Are seizures harmful: what can we learn from animal models? Andrew J. Cole *, Sookyong Koh and Yi Zheng Epilepsy Research Laboratory, Massachusetts General Hospital and Department of Neurology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02114, USA
Abstract: Epilepsy is a brain disease that requires distributed neuronal networks for its expression. Several characteristics of epilepsy, including its natural history, the latency between an initial insult and the first manifestation of seizures, the complex interaction of seizures with development as a function of developmental stage, the modulating effect of systemic physiological responses, and the fact that seizures are ultimately defined by a combination of electrical and behavioral criteria all suggest that epilepsy should ideally be studied in an intact whole animal preparation. Such preparations offer the ability to study acute and chronic changes in brain structure and function after single or repeated seizures. Animal models have major limitations, however, including strain specificity, difficulty in isolating potentially confounding variables, a relative lack of accessible higher cortical functions, such as language and abstract processing, and shorter lifespans that may be insufficient to allow the complete expression of seizure-related injury. Information we have learned from animal studies includes a broad understanding of the chemical, molecular and anatomic consequences of seizures, including their temporal and spatial relationships to each other, and information on the consequences of seizures as a function of development. Recent studies have cast light on potential mechanisms of resistance to seizure-induced injury in the developing brain. In the future, we can anticipate that animal models will continue to be useful, especially when whole-animal preparations are used to generate material for detailed in vitro examination.
Introduction Epilepsy is a brain disease, and epileptic seizures result from abnormal paroxysmal activity o f populations o f neurons. The careful reader will note that by definition epilepsy and epileptic seizures cannot be conceptualized as disorders o f single neurons per se. It is perhaps less clear whether the disease state and its primary s y m p t o m can be successfully recapitulated in an isolated array of neurons, either a plate o f cultured cells or an ex vivo preparation,
* Correspondence to: A.J. Cole, MGH Epilepsy Service, VBK 830, Massachusetts General Hospital, Fruit Street, Boston, MA 02114, USA. Tel.: -t-1-617-726-3311; Fax: +1-617-726-9250; E-maih cole.andrew @mgh.harvard.edu
such as a h i p p o c a m p a l or cortical slice. Furthermore, epilepsy, a disorder manifest by recurrent unprovoked seizures, is by definition a chronic disease, or at least a disease that manifests itself over a period o f time, not simply at an instant. Reductionist models typically are acute, in the case of ex vivo preparations, or developmentally disturbed, in the case o f cultured cells. Moreover, epilepsy occurs in the context of ongoing physiological processes such as perfusion, oxygenation, glucose metabolism, acidbase regulation, thermoregulation, endocrine modulation and the like, some of which m a y have critical interactions with the disease state itself. W h i l e the confounding influences of normal physiological responses m a y make the interpretation of whole animal experiments difficult, their absence m a y represent an important and under-recognized limitation of reductionist approaches. For these reasons, it seems that
14 TABLE 1 The spectrum of animal models Electrical stimulation
Maximal electroconvulsiveseizures (MECS) Perforant-path stimulation (PPS) Kindling
Chemoconvulsants
Systemic
Kainate Pilocarpine Picrotoxin Bicuculline Penicillin Kainate Pilocarpine Picrotoxin Bicuculline Tetanus toxin Pertussis toxin Alumina cream Penicillin
Intracerebral
Topical Physical models
Hyperthermia Freeze lesions Photic stimulation (Papiopapio) Auditory stimulation (Swiss DBA2 mice)
Genetic models
Spontaneous
Mutant
Genetically epilepsy-prone rat strain (GEPRS) Strasbourg rats (Absence) Epileptic beagles Stargazer Lurcher Totterer Mocha
Transgenic Knockout Spontaneous seizure models
Post-kindling Post-kainate Post-pilocarpine
the most effective way to model epilepsy should be to utilize whole animal preparations. And indeed a considerable body of epilepsy research work has utilized animal models, leading to many fundamental insights. In this chapter, we will review some of the important uses of animal models, discuss their limitations, and consider the role of animal models going forward. In particular, we will focus on the issue of whether a single or initial seizure is harmful, and how it might relate to the development of epilepsy.
The spectrum of animal models A wide variety of animal models of epilepsy and epileptic seizures exist. The major models are listed
in Table 1. The tremendous diversity of available animal models offers both opportunity and challenge. Many of the models are acute, and many are, in fact, models of status epilepticus which may have important differences from isolated seizures. Genetic models often have phenotypes that are complex, with seizures as only one manifestation of a more pervasive structural, functional or developmental problem. Strain differences in responses to epileptogenic or convulsant stimuli make comparisons between animals from different laboratories difficult, but may offer opportunity to identify pro- or anti-epileptic genes using differential screening approaches (Schauwecker and Steward, 1997; Sandberg et al., 2000; Schauwecker, 2000). Chemo-
15 TABLE 2
TABLE 3
Advantages and limitationsof animal models
Situations in which whole-animalmodels are required
Advantages
•
•
Allowassessment of seizure causes and consequences in an intact preparation • Survivaltime can be adjusted to examine temporal evolution of post-ictal changes • Developmentalstage can be selected, and events at one point in developmentcan be studied with respect to effects manifested at a later stage • Repeated events can studied (e.g. kindling) • Effects of physiologicalmilieu are integrated
• • • • • •
Limitations • •
Manyoffer snapshot picture of ictal/post-ictal events Manyresult in status epilepticus, which may not adequately model typical epilepsy • Straindifferences in seizures and responses highlight the difficulties in generalizingfindings in a specific model • Effects of physiologicalmilieu are integrated
• • •
To examine transductionof an input function into an output function without requiring knowledge of the mechanism To examine systems level physiology where distant or unknown connectionsmay have a role To study anatomic patterns of responses To study the relationship of anatomic findings,e.g. injury, plasticity to specific molecular markers To study developmentallyregulated anatomic, biochemical and functional events To study the effects of chronic or recurrent seizures To study the effects of specific genetic manipulationson phenotype To examine the influenceof physiologicalmilieu on seizures and their consequences To generate biological material for examinationafter seizures To confirm findingsfrom reductionist systems in the scaled-up whole animal situation
Insights from animal models convulsants may have systemic effects that are either completely independent from seizures, or even more problematic, result in seizures only as a secondary consequence to injury or functional disturbance. Finally, some of the important correlates of seizures and epilepsy, such as memory loss, behavioral changes, and secondary psychiatric disturbance are at best difficult to measure in epileptic animals. By contrast, all animal models share the property of having anatomically intact central nervous systems with functional connections and measurable efferent responses. A n i m a l s can be developmentally monitored, and prolonged survival is possible to allow examination of delayed effects of specific stimuli or treatment. Most recently, the ability to manipulate the genetic endowment of model animals has opened the door to allowing examination of complex interactions between genes and behavior, between nature and nurture. The advantages and disadvantages of animal models are listed in Table 2. In the remainder of this chapter, we will identify specific situations where animal models should be particularly useful, and offer examples of insights that have come from animal models that might not have been available elsewhere. Several situations in which animal models have an obvious utility can be defined and are listed in Table 3.
Seizures trigger a cascade of biochemical, anatomic and functional changes in the central nervous system It has long been recognized that critical aspects of brain development are activity-dependent. For example, the pioneering experiments of Hubel and Weisel established the critical role of visual input in the post-natal organization of the visual system, including the establishment of cortical columns, pruning of redundant connections, and establishment of the critical property of surround inhibition (Hubel and Wiesel, 1970; Hubel et al., 1977). Later studies have demonstrated that cortical plasticity, both functional and anatomic, occurs in response to altered afferent activity, e.g. amputation or fusion of digits in primates (Merzenich et al., 1984; Allard et al., 1991). Perhaps surprisingly, our appreciation that brief seizures trigger long-term changes in CNS properties is relatively recent. Fig. 1A summarizes, in a schematic form, some of the events that occur after seizures. A critical point is that each of these observations came from animal studies. As an example, consider the observation that brief seizures induced by pentylenetetrazole or maximal electroconvulsive treatment results in rapid and transient expression of a large class of immediate early genes, many encoding transcription factors. While cell culture studies of
16
Time Course of Biochemical, Anatomic and Functional Changes After Seizures (a)
S u s c e iflbilit to recur 'ent se z u r e s
(week to m, ,nths) O - - - - - ' 4 ) N e u "ogene ds (da~ s- wee ts)
Be] laviot~ J Def'N its (61 tours- montl ~) A
dm
leuro~ al Cell Loss hour
Glial Activa ion (6 hol lrs - 5 lays)
0=== ='=0
A v
0"
E
arly G me Ac tivafio (.J: m t n - 6 horn s)
; a + + I m Infl ax
0"
rnse~, min~t .~s)
I
10-3
P r o t i inexp] ession e.g. S o n ~ tostafi ~, NPI (2 ho ]rs - 3 l a y s )
K i n a ~e Acti ration (5 mi nutes I o 2A h,,urs)
. -
-4
- 14 q lays)
10-2 lO-I
1
10
10 ~
1~
1 0 I~
1 hour
1 min
I
10 4
1 day
10 9
1010
1 week
Time (seconds)
Time Course of Biochemical, Anatomic and Functional Changes After Seizures S u s c e )tibilit tto recur *nt se zures (week ; to m~ ~uths)
(b)
O - - - - - - 4 i Neu rogem iis
( d a s - we, ~s)
Be tavior IDefie Is (6 ours, montt s) A v
v
0-----4
~eurot al Cel Loss 6 horn s - 141 ays)
Glial~ ictival Ion (6 ho, irs - 5 ~lays) FCOR
2
Som~ t,ostati n, NP~ (2 ho Jrs, 3 Ja3~) ~atil)|l ltlJles
ECT
o 24 h ~ c s l
lkatio 6 hm/ s}
}lR ~{
(a++
It" I 10 a
10 -2
10 "~
1
10
10 1 min
10 3
|,m hfft p~.
{ n~, t- - . i , l q ~ s! i
I0 a
1 hour
I day
I
tO~ I week
10 9
1010
Time (seconds) Fig. 1. (A) Diagrammatic representation of some of the biochemical, anatomic and functional changes seen after seizures in a variety of electrical and chemoconvulsant animal models. (B) Diagrammatic representation of changes seen in ECT models (indicated in green). Note that many of the lasting changes have not been reported after single or repeated ECT.
17
Parallel Model ]
(a)
Seizures [ Sprouting
(b)
I Injury
Gliosis
Neurogenesis
Functional Change
Series Model Seizures Iv wy G] psis Spro ating Neure enesis Functional Change
Fig. 2. Theoreticalrepresentationof the relationship between various documentedchanges occurring after seizures. (A) Parallel model indicates that specific consequences of seizures may occur independently of each other. (B) Series model represents the alternative hypothesisthat later latencychanges depend on earlier events for their expression.
activity-dependent gene expression could have suggested this phenomenon, only whole animal studies allowed us to appreciate the extraordinary anatomic specificity of this response (Morgan et al., 1987; Saffen et al., 1988; Cole et al., 1989). Similarly, observation of a variety of events including kinase activation (Murray et al., 1998, 1999; Anderson et al., 2000), neuropeptide regulation (Gall et al., 1990; Baraban et al., 1993; Vezzani et al., 1999; Madsen et al., 2000), cell loss (Margerison and Corsellis, 1966; Corsellis and Meldrum, 1976; Schwob et al., 1980; Gloor, 1991; Sloviter, 1994), mossy fiber sprouting (Sutula et al., 1988; Cavazos et al., 1991; Wuarin and Dudek, 1996; Patrylo et al., 1999), enhanced neurogenesis (Parent and Lowenstein, 1994), altered receptor expression, chronic behavioral deficits, and altered susceptibility to recurrent seizures are all the result of animal studies. With the exception of the latter phenomenon (see next section), it remains un-
clear whether any or all of these effects of a single seizure contribute to the development of epilepsy. Moreover, it is unclear whether whatever contribution they may have is organized in series or in parallel (Fig. 2). Obviously this issue has critical therapeutic implications.
Early life seizures increase susceptibility to later life seizures and neuronal injury An important observation from animal studies is that seizures early in life result in a long-term susceptibility to recurrent seizures with resultant neuronal injury and behavioral deficits later in life. This finding has been established in multiple laboratories using a variety of animal models including repeated kainate administration (Koh et al., 1999), early life hyperthermic seizures (Dube et al., 2000), and earlylife fluroythyl-induced status (Holmes et al., 1998;
18 Schmid et al., 1999). Each of these models shares the property that anatomic injury is difficult or impossible to detect after the initial insult, suggesting that the resulting susceptibility is the consequence of a functional change in network properties. These studies raise several important questions: (1) What is the transduction process that results in enhanced seizure-susceptibility later in life? (2) Why are juvenile animals resistant to seizureinduced injury? (3) Is there a critical point in development before or after which seizures no longer have this long-term effect?
Early-life seizures alter synaptic connectivity in developing brain One hypothesis, unproven, is that early life seizures may stabilize immature synaptic connections normally destined for removal, thereby resulting in an intrinsically hyperexcitable brain in adulthood. Evidence for this concept comes from Grigonis and Murphy (1994) who showed that topical application of penicillin to immature rabbit visual cortex resulted in persistence of the immature pattern of callosal projections without the pruning that occurs in normal development. By contrast, Swann and colleagues have found that early seizures resulted in a reduction in dendritic spine density, suggesting an alternative substrate for lasting functional change (Jiang et al., 1998). Similar findings have been reported in human surgical tissue (Multani et al., 1994) and in chronic animal seizure models (Willmore et al., 1980) as well.
Resistance to neuronal injury in the juvenile brain Many studies have established that in the rodent, seizures prior to P21 result in little, if any, detectable injury. In the adult brain, we have observed that treatment with nerve growth factor attenuates hippocampal injury after kainate-induced seizures (Weiss et al., 1995). Ambient levels of NGF are maximal during development, peaking at P14-15.
Because we have no data on this point, this question will not be discussed.
We therefore hypothesized that high ambient levels of NGF may prevent seizure-induced neuronal injury in the immature brain. To test this hypothesis, we selectively lesioned cholinergic neurons bearing the low-affinity neurotrophin receptor, p75ntfr using a selective immunotoxin, 192-IgG-saporin. In preliminary experiments, rats treated with 192-IgG-saporin on P7 that showed complete loss of basal forebrain cholinergic neurons and marked depletion of acetylcholinesterase stained terminals in hippocampus also demonstrated severe selective cell loss in CA3 after subsequent treatment with kainate on P16. By contrast, animals treated with saline on P7 and animals in which the saporin treatment was unsuccessful in depleting cholinergic neurons had no kainate-induced hippocampal injury (Fig. 3). While these experiments are consistent with our hypothesis, b e c a u s e p75ntfr binds several neurotrophins including BDNF, NT-3 and NT-4/5 it remains unclear whether high levels of NGF are critical to neuronal survival in this experimental paradigm. Moreover, in light of the fact that seizures induce NGF expression, and the findings of Grigonis and Murphy described above, we must consider the possibility that enhanced neuronal survival may have negative consequences with respect to later seizure susceptibility.
Are seizures neuroprotective ? The preceding discussion emphasizes the commonly held belief that seizures are harmful. Seizure-induced phenomena, such as neuronal loss, synaptic remodeling and aberrant neuronal proliferation, especially in the context of decreased performance on behavioral testing and enhanced susceptibility to recurrent seizures would seem to support this notion. Long clinical experience and recent experimental data, however, have challenged this axiom. For example, for many years psychiatrists have been treating patients with refractory depression with electroconvulsive seizures, often with gratifying results. There is little to suggest that ECT, as typically applied causes significant anatomic injury or behavioral dysfunction, although patients who receive hundreds of treatments may provide anecdotal exceptions. Suggestions that ECT causes progressive brain atrophy and hippocampal changes have not been supported by careful clinical studies (Sheline et al., 1999; Ende
19
DNAF
CV
Saline - Kainate
Saporin - Kainate
Fig. 3. Neuronal injury after kainate-induced seizures in P15 rats. DNAF indicates DNA fragmentation, a marker of neuronal injury. CV indicates Cresyl violet Nissl staining showing neuronal integrity. Saline-Kainate indicates animals pretreated with intraventricular saline on P7, prior to kainate on P15. Saporin-Kainate indicates animal treated with 192-IgG-Saporinintraventricularlyon P7 prior to kainate on PI5. Note injury and cell loss in CA3 after saporin treatment. et al., 2000) which have concluded that depression itself and its pharmacological treatment are confounding variables with a more powerful effect on structure and function. By contrast, animal studies during development have pointed out injurious effects of ECT (Wasterlain and Plum, 1973; Jorgensen et al., 1980) and in experimental systems electroconvulsive seizures have been shown to induce abnormal gene expression (Morgan et al., 1987; Saffen et al., 1988; Cole et al., 1990, 1997), kinase activation (Baraban et al., 1993), protein synthesis (Cole et al., 1990; Gall et al., 1991; Bhat et al., 1993), and neurotransmitter receptor expression (Bergstrom and Kellar, 1979; Kellar et al., 1981; Lerer, 1984; Green et al., 1986) (See Fig. 1B). These observations suggest that many of the early events occurring after seizures, while perhaps necessary, are not sufficient to mediate later emergence of neuronal injury, synaptic reorganization, and network dysfunction. They also emphasize the possibility that many of the events occurring af-
ter seizures are arranged in parallel, rather than in series (see Fig. 2A,B). Whether seizures are harmful, neutral or beneficial may depend on seizure type, e.g. brief electrically induced generalized attacks occurring in controlled clinical circumstances versus spontaneous seizures of variable duration occurring in an uncontrolled environment, or host characteristics, such as the presence of underlying neurological (as opposed to psychiatric) dysfunction or disease. In any case, these observations emphasize the need for cautious and unbiased interpretation of the observations gathered from experimental systems. Recent experimental data have also challenged the notion that seizures are harmful. For example, Greenberg and colleagues (Sasahira et al., 1995) found that repeated bicuculline seizures separated by 1, 3, 5 or 7 days conferred a time-dependent protective effect against hippocampal injury induced by subsequent seizures in the CA3c sector of the hippocampus. They coined the term 'epileptic tolerance'
20 to describe this phenomenon, and suggested that enhanced expression of heat-shock proteins caused by the initial seizure might be responsible for subsequent protection against recurrent seizure-induced injury. Their study suggested, however, that the protection was brief and of uncertain clinical relevance. Mclntyre and colleagues (Kelly and Mclntyre, 1994) have shown that kindling stimulation protects against kainate seizure-induced injury for up to 28 days, and Penner and colleagues have confirmed this result in a rapid kindling paradigm (Penner et al., 2001). Similarly, Gale and colleagues have reported in abstract form that repeated electroconvulsive seizures protect against kainate-seizure induced injury in experimental animals. ECT has been shown to cause declining seizure severity with repeated administration (Cole et al., 1990), perhaps the behavioral analogue of the relative refractory period described in synaptic physiology. It will therefore be important to review Gale's work critically to determine the duration of protection conferred.
Transgenic and knockout experiments The ability to determine the genetic endowment of experimental animals has offered an important alternative to classical pharmacology for hypothesis testing. Rather than relying on specific agonists or antagonists, one can now directly block either the synthesis or activity of specific molecules and then examine the resultant phenotype. These studies may be confounded by at least two practical issues. First, animals born with altered genomes may utilize compensatory mechanisms to overcome the induced deficits, or they may develop abnormally in a manner that renders hypothesis testing impossible or irrelevant. The extreme example, of course, is the embryonic-lethal transgene or knockout. More subtle is the situation where alternative isoforms of specific gene products serve to partially or completely compensate for the genetic alteration. To some extent, the development of inducible expression systems for transgenes and conditional knockouts may partially overcome these limitations. Second, strain differences in genetic background may, in fact, have more influence on phenotype than the targeted genetic alteration itself. A graphic example of this phenomenon came from studies of p53 knockout
animals. Several groups of investigators found that p53 knockout animals were protected against kainate seizure-induced neuronal injury (Morrison et al., 1996). Another group, however, using p53 knockout animals from a different source, were unable to reproduce that result (Schauwecker and Steward, 1997). It subsequently became apparent that the difference in the two studies was the result of strain differences in the genetic backgrounds of mice used to develop the knockout lines. Animal models in the new millennium
As we move into the new millennium, a new trend in animal models is emerging that promises to offer powerful insights into the cause and effect of seizures. These models share the property that in vivo and in vitro techniques are combined to allow experiments that could not be conducted in either environment exclusively. While these strategies are perhaps best thought of as evolutionary, rather than revolutionary, they deserve special mention none the less. Three experimental paradigms provide illustrations of these approaches.
Use of biological material from genetically manipulated animals for in vitro study Perhaps one of the most valuable uses of genetic manipulation results from the ability to harvest biological material from manipulated animals for in vitro studies. For example, recent studies have demonstrated that conditional knockout of the neuronal MAP kinase kinase (MEK) gene in hippocampus alters the characteristics of long-term potentiation as studied in hippocampal slices (Atkins et al., 1998; Selcher et al., 1999; Schafe et al., 2000) (Kelleher, personal communication). Similar approaches are now routinely undertaken to examine the effect of genetic manipulation on in vitro physiology using slice preparations and patch clamp techniques, and on neuronal viability and biochemical responses using primary neuronal cell culture techniques.
Receptor alterations in epileptic animals Another example of the combination of in vitro and in vivo techniques comes from the work of
21 Coulter and colleagues. These investigators have developed spontaneously epileptic animals using the pilocarpine model. After documenting recurrent seizures, they have prepared hippocampal slices and documented physiological abnormalities, especially in the properties of G A B A receptors (Gibbs et al., 1997). They have then gone on to use RT-PCR techniques on single cells from these slices to document changes in the specific G A B A receptor subunits expressed in epileptic animals as compared to controls (Brooks-Kayal et al., 1998). Interestingly, an extension of this study to examine G A B A receptor subunit expression in animals after the initial seizure, but before the development of spontaneous seizures could provide insight into the fundamental question before this meeting, whether a single seizure is harmful. Microarray analysis o f epileptic animals
A third example of the use of in vivo and in vitro techniques in combination illustrates the idea that this approach is really an evolutionary extension of older analytical methods where in situ techniques were used to characterize molecular responses to seizures. Microarray analysis of cDNAs generated from epileptic material offers an open-ended method for documenting altered gene expression that requires little de facto knowledge of the targets to be examined. In its earliest incarnations, 2-D get electrophoresis of proteins and differential screening of cDNA libraries led to the identification of previously unknown molecular responses to abnormal activity. For example, the finding that Homer (Brakeman et al., 1997), GRIP (Dong et al., 1997) and ARC (Lyford et al., 1995) were regulated after seizures came from a differential screening strategy. Homer and GRIP are PDZ-domain containing proteins that interact with metabotropic- and AMPA-type glutamate receptors, respectively. ARC, by contrast, is expressed mainly in dendrites where it may mediate synaptic plasticity. Each of these proteins has the potential to mediate changes in synaptic efficiency that are long-lasting. More recently, this approach has been extended by the use of microarray analysis in which thousands of known and unknown transcripts can be quantitatively assessed in response to seizures and compared to controls to look for both up- and down-regulation of activity-dependent tran-
scripts (Sandberg et al., 2000). Dingledine has used this approach to examine differences between early and late transcriptional responses, whereas Lowenstein and colleagues have concentrated on examining transcripts that are regulated both during development and after seizures. Applications of this technology, which starts with the whole animal and quickly moves to the in vitro environment will be limited only by the arrays of targets available and the imagination of investigators.
References Allard, T., Clark, S.A., Jenkins, W.M. and Merzenich, M.M. (1991) Reorganization of somatosensory area 3b representations in adult owl monkeys after digital syndactyly. J. Neurophysiol., 66(3): 1048-1058. Anderson, A.E., Adams, J.E, Varga, A.W., Selcher, J.C., Feng, J., Trzaskos, J.M. and Sweatt, J.D. (2000) Essential role for ERK MAPK activation and K+ channel phosphorylation in the kainate model of epilepsy. Soc. Neurosci. Abstr., 26:1836. Atkins, C.M., Selcher, J.C., Petraitis, J.J., Trzaskos, J.M. and Sweatt, J.D. (1998) The MAPK cascade is required for mammalian associative learning. Nat. Neurosci., 1(7): 602-609. Baraban, J.M., Fiore, R., Sanghera, J.S., Paddon, H.B. and Pelech, S. (1993) Identification of p42 mitogen-activated protein kinase as a tyrosine kinase substrate activated by maximal electroconvulsive shock in hippocampus. J. Neurochem., 60: 330-336. Bergstrom, D.A. and Kellar, K.J. (1979) Effect of electroconvulsive shock on monoaminergic receptor binding sites in rat brain. Nature, 278: 464-466. Bhat, R.V., Tansk, F.A., Baraban, J.M., Mains, R.E. and Eipper, B.A. (1993) Rapid increases in peptide processing enzyme expression in hippocampal neurons. J. Neurochem., 61(4): 1315-1322. Brakeman, ER., Lanahan, A.A., O'Brien, R., Roche, K., Barnes, C.A., Huganir, R.L. and Worley, EE (1997) Homer: a protein that selectively binds metabotropic glutamate receptors. Nature, 386(6622): 284-288. Brooks-Kayal, A.R., Shumate, M.D., Jin, H., Rikhter, T.Y. and Coulter, D.A. (1998) Selective changes in single cell GABA(A) receptor subunit expression and function in temporal lobe epilepsy. Nat. Med., 4(10): 1166-1172. Cavazos, J.E., Golarai, G. and Sutula, T.E (1991) Mossy fiber synaptic reorganization induced by kindling: time course of development, progression, and permanence. J. Neurosci., 11(9): 2795-2803. Cole, A.J., Saffen, D.W., Baraban, J.M. and Worley, EE (1989) Rapid increase of an immediate early gene messenger RNA in hippocampal neurons by synaptic NMDA receptor activation. Nature, 340: 474-476. Cole, A.J., Abu Shakra, S., Saffen, D.W., Baraban, J.M. and Worley, P.E (1990) Rapid rise in transcription factor mRNAs
22
in rat brain after electroshock-induced seizures. J. Neurochem., 55: 1920-1927. Cole, A.J., Koh, S., Liu, Z. and Holmes, G.L. (1997) DNA fragmentation in developing brain after kainate-induced seizures. Epilepsia, 38(Suppl. 8): 40. Corsellis, J.A.N. and Meldrum, B.S. (1976) Epilepsy. In: W. Blackwood and J.A.N. Corsellis (Eds.), Greenfield's Neuropathology, 3 edn. Edward Arnold, London, pp. 771-795. Dong, H., O'Brien, R.J., Fung, E.T., Lanahan, A.A., Worley, P.F. and Huganir, R.L. (1997) GRIP: a synaptic PDZ domaincontaining protein that interacts with AMPA receptors. Nature, 386(6622): 279-284. Dube, C., Chen, K., Eghbal-Ahmadi, M., Brunson, K., Soltesz, I. and Baram, T.Z. (2000) Prolonged febrile seizures in the immature rat model enhance hippocampal excitability long term. Ann. Neurol., 47(3): 336-344. Ende, G., Braus, D.E, Walter, S., Weber-Fahr, W. and Henn, EA. (2000) The hippocampus in patients treated with electroconvulsive therapy: a proton magnetic resonance spectroscopic imaging study. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry, 57( 10): 937-943. Gall, C., Lauterborn, J., Isackson, E and White, J. (1990) Seizures, neuropeptide regulation, and mRNA expression in the hippocampus. Prog. Brain Res., 83: 371-390. Gall, C., Lauterbom, J., Bundman, M., Murray, K. and Isackson, EJ. (1991) Seizures and the regulation of neurotrophic factor and neuropeptide gene expression in brain [Review]. Epilepsy Res. Suppl., 4: 225-245. Gibbs, J.W., Shumate, M.D. and Coulter, D.A. (1997) Differential epilepsy-associated alterations in postsynaptic GABA(A) receptor function in dentate granule and CA1 neurons. J. Neurophysiol., 77(4): 1924-1938. Gloor, E (1991) Mesial temporal sclerosis: historical background and an overview from a modem perspective. In: H. Luders (Ed.), Epilepsy Surgery. Raven Press, New York, pp. 689-703. Green, A.R., Heal, D.J. and Goodwin, G.M. (1986) The effects of electroconvulsive therapy and antidepressant drugs on monoamine receptors in rodent brain-similarities and differences. Ciba Found. Symp., 123: 246-267. Grigonis, A.M. and Murphy, E.H. (1994) The effects of epileptic cortical activity on the development of callosal projections. Dev. Brain Res., 77(2): 251-255. Holmes, G.L., Gairsa, J.L., Chevassus-Au-Louis, N. and Ben Ari, Y. (1998) Consequences of neonatal seizures in the rat: morphological and behavioral effects. Ann. Neurol., 44(6): 845-857. Hubel, D.H. and Wiesel, T.N. (1970) The period of susceptibility to the physiological effects of unilateral eye closure in kittens. J. Physiol., 206: 419-436. Hubel, D.H., Wiesel, T.N. and LeVay, S. (1977) Plasticity of ocular dominance columns in monkey striate cortex. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci., 278(961): 377-409. Jiang, M., Lee, C.L., Smith, K.L. and Swann, J.W. (1998) Spine loss and other persistent alterations of hippocampal pyramidal cell dendrites in a model of early-onset epilepsy. J. Neurosci., 18(20): 8356-8368. Jorgensen, O.S., Dwyer, B. and Wasterlain, C.G. (1980) Synaptic
proteins after electroconvulsive seizures in immature rats. J. Neurochem., 35(5): 1235-1237. Kellar, K.J., Cascio, C.S., Butler, J.A. and Kurtze, R.N. (1981) Differential effects of electroconvulsive shock and antidepressant drugs on serotonin-2 receptors in rat brain. Eur. J. Pharmacol., 69: 515-518. Kelly, M.E. and McIntyre, D.C. (1994) Hippocampal kindling protects several structures from the neuronal damage resulting from kainic acid-induced status epilepticus. Brain Res., 634(2): 245-256. Kob, S., Storey, T.W., Santos, T.C., Mian, A.Y. and Cole, A.J. (1999) Early-life seizures in rats increase susceptibility to seizure-induced brain injury in adulthood [In Process Citation]. Neurology, 53(5): 915-921. Lerer, B. (1984) Electroconvulsive shock and neurotransmitter receptors: implications for mechanism of action and adverse effects of electroconvulsive therapy. Biol. Psychiatry, 19(3): 361-383. Lyford, G.L., Yamagata, K., Kaufmann, W.E., Barnes, C.A., Sanders, L.K., Copeland, N.G., Gilbert, D.J., Jenkins, N.A., Lanahan, A.A. and Worley, EE (1995) Arc, a growth factor and activity-regulated gene, encodes a novel cytoskeletonassociated protein that is enriched in neuronal dendrites. Neuron, 14(2): 433-445. Madsen, T.M., Greisen, M.H., Nielsen, S.M., Bolwig, T.G. and Mikkelsen, J.D. (2000) Electroconvulsive stimuli enhance both neuropeptide Y receptor Y1 and Y2 messenger RNA expression and levels of binding in the rat hippocampus. Neuroscience, 98(1): 33-39. Margerison, J.H. and Corsellis, J.A.N. (1966) Epilepsy and the temporal lobes: a clinical encephalographic and neuropathological study of the brain in epilepsy, with particular reference to the temporal lobes. Brain, 89: 499-530. Merzenich, M.M., Nelson, R.J., Stryker, M.E, Cynader, M.S., Schoppmann, A. and Zook, J.M. (1984) Somatosensory cortical map changes following digit amputation in adult monkeys. J. Comp. Neurol., 224(4): 591-605. Morgan, J.I., Cohen, D.R., Hempstead, J.L. and Curran, T. (1987) Mapping patterns of c-los expression in the central nervous system after seizure. Science, 237(4811): 192-197. Morrison, R.S., Wenzel, H.J., Kinoshita, Y., Robbins, C.A., Donehower, L.A. and Schwartzkroin, EA. (1996) Loss of the p53 tumor suppressor gene protects neurons from kainateinduced cell death. J. Neurosci., 16(4): 1337-1345. Multani, R, Myers, R.H., Blume, H.W., Schomer, D.L. and Sotrel, A. (1994) Neocortical dendritic pathology in human partial epilepsy: a quantitative Golgi study. Epilepsia, 35(4): 728-736. Murray, B., Alessandrini, A., Cole, A.J., Yee, A.G. and Furshpan, E.J. (1998) Inhibition of the p44/42 MAP kinase pathway protects hippocampal neurons in a cell-culture model of seizure activity. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 95(20): 11975-11980. Murray, B., Beer, T. and Cole, A.J. (1999) Pre- and postsynaptic activation of p44/42 MAP kinase in hippocampus after kainate-induced seizures. Epilepsia, 40:2 I. Parent, J.M. and Lowenstein, D.H. (1994) Treatment of refrac-
23
tory generalized status epilepticus with continuous infusion of midazolam. Neurology, 44(10): 1837-1840. Patrylo, P.R., Schweitzer, J.S. and Dudek, EE. (1999) Abnormal responses to perforant path stimulation in the dentate gyms of slices from rats with kainate-induced epilepsy and mossy fiber reorganization. Epilepsy Res., 36(1): 31-42. Penner, M.R., Pinaud, R. and Robertson, H.A. (2001) Rapid kindling of the hippocampus protects against neural damage resulting from status epilepticus. NeuroReport, 12(3): 453457. Saffen, D.W., Cole, A.J., Worley, P.E, Christy, B.A., Ryder, K. and Baraban, J.M. (1988) Convulsant-induced increase in transcription factor messenger RNAs in rat brain. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 85: 7795-7799. Sandberg, R., Yasuda, R., Pankratz, D.G., Carter, T.A., Del Rio, J.A., Wodicka, L., Mayford, M., Lockhart, D.J. and Barlow, C. (2000) Regional and strain-specific gene expression mapping in the adult mouse brain. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 97(20): 11038-11043. Sasahira, M., Lowry, T., Simon, R.P. and Greenberg, D.A. (1995) Epileptic tolerance: Prior seizures protect against seizureinduced neuronal injury. Neurosci. Lett., 185: 95-98. Schafe, G.E., Atkins, C.M., Swank, M.W., Bauer, E.P., Sweatt, J.D. and LeDoux, J.E. (2000) Activation of ERK/MAP kinase in the amygdala is required for memory consolidation of pavlovian fear conditioning. J. Neurosci., 20(21): 8177-8187. Schauwecker, P.E. (2000) Seizure-induced neuronal death is associated with induction of c-Jun N-terminal kinase and is dependent on genetic background. Brain Res., 884(1-2): 116128. Schauwecker, P.E. and Steward, O. (1997) Genetic determinants of susceptibility to excitotoxic cell death: implications for gene targeting approaches. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 94(8): 4103-4108. Schmid, R., Tandon, P., Stafstrom, C.E. and Holmes, G.L. (1999) Effects of neonatal seizures on subsequent seizure-induced brain injury. Neurology, 53(8): 1754-1761.
Schwob, J.E., Fuller, T., Price, J.L. and Olney, J.W. (1980) Widespread patterns of neuronal damage following systemic or intracerebral injections of kainic acid: a histological study. Neuroscience, 5: 991=1014. Selcher, J.C., Atkins, C.M., Trzaskos, J.M., Paylor, R. and Sweatt, J.D. (1999) A necessity for MAP kinase activation in mammalian spatial learning. Learn. Memory, 6(5): 478490. Sheline, Y.I., Sanghavi, M., Mintun, M.A. and Gado, M.H. (1999) Depression duration but not age predicts hippocampal volume loss in medically healthy women with recurrent major depression. J. Neurosci., 19(12): 5034-5043. Sloviter, R.S. (1994) On the relationship between neuropathology and pathophysiology in the epileptic hippocampus of humans and experimental animals [Review]. Hippocampus, 4(3): 250253. Sutula, T.E, He, X.X., Cavazos, J. and Scott, G. (1988) Synaptic reorganization in the hippocampus induced by abnormal functional activity. Science, 239(4844): 1147-1150. Vezzani, A., Sperk, G. and Colmers, W.E (1999) Neuropeptide Y: emerging evidence for a functional role in seizure modulation. Trends Neurosci., 22(1): 25-30. Wasterlain, C.G. and Plum, E (1973) Vulnerability of developing rat brain to electroconvulsive seizures. Arch. Neurol., 29(1): 38-45. Weiss, S., Cataltepe, O. and Cole, A.J. (1995) NGF reduced DNA fragmentation in CA1 neurons but not elsewhere after systemic kainate-induced seizures in the rat. Soc. Neurosci. Abstr., 21: 985. Willmore, L.J., Ballinger Jr., W.E., Boggs, W., Sypert, G.W. and Rubin, J.J. (1980) Dendritic alterations in rat isocortex within an iron-induced chronic epileptic focus. Neurosurgery, 7(2): 142-146. Wuarin, J.-E and Dudek, EE. (1996) Electrographic seizures and new recurrent excitatory circuits in the dentate gyms of hippocampal slices from kainate-treated epileptic rats. J. Neurosci., 16(14): 4438-4448.
T. Sutula and A. Pitk~nen (Eds.)
Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135 © 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
CHAPTER 3
Doubt and certainty in counting R.W. Guillery 1,, and B.K. August 2,** 1Department of Anatomy and 2 Department of Neurology, School of Medicine, University of Wisconsin, Madison, W1 53706, USA
Abstract: Some of the methods used for counting objects in histological sections are discussed. The method best suited for any particular counting program depends on many variables, which include the level of accuracy required, the type of preparation available for study, the size of the objects to be counted, the thickness of the sections that can be used, the equipment available and the amount of labor that can reasonably be invested. For light and electron microscopy, profile counts are simple and quick for objects that are small relative to section thickness and whose dimensions are readily defined. The 'physical disector' is particularly useful where objects to be counted are large relative to sections thickness, or where their dimensions are unknown or highly variable. For light microscopy, the optical disector is often easier to use. However, it makes more assumptions than the physical disector; some of these can introduce serious bias in the counts, and they are explored. Electron microscopy raises some special problems that relate to the depth of focus, the relatively very thin sections, and the tendency for thin structures that do not span the full thickness of a section to be lost or unrecognizable in some section planes. The importance of recognizing the assumptions that underlie any method of counting and its interpretation is stressed.
However, if one remains aware that these methods yield approximations, one or another of them will prove useful. The choice of method depends on the actual conditions and is, moreover, largely a matter of taste. E.R. Weibel (1969) writing on stereological principles. Introduction The importance of reliable counting methods in neuroscience has increased over the past decade, and has received significant discussion in a literature that is surprisingly extensive. (Recent references include:
*Correspondence to: R.W. Guillery, Department of Anatomy, School of Medicine, University of Wisconsin, 1300 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USA. Tel.: +1-608-263-4763; Fax: +1-608-262-7036; E-mail: rguiller @facstaff.wisc.edu ** Responsible for the electron microscopic studies.
Gundersen et al., 1988; Pakkenberg and Gundersen, 1995; Coggeshall and Lekan, 1996; Guillery and Herrup, 1997; West, 1999; Geuna, 2000; Benes and Lange, 2001). Counts of nerve cells, glial cells, vesicles, or synapses in sections prepared for light or electron microscopy are being undertaken more commonly than in the past. They can help to define the progress of disease, allow comparisons between experimental and normal conditions, or show changes that characterize development. If the counting is based on reliable methods, it can provide crucial information. If not, it can be seriously misleading. However, no method of counting can be certified as free of error. The investigator who needs to count is best placed if the need for counts is established before the tissue is prepared for sectioning. Matching tissue preparation to the objects to be counted and to the degree of accuracy required by the counts should be a first step wherever possible. Often, however, counts need to be done on tissue that has already been prepared, perhaps many years ago, or that needs to serve more
26 than one experimental purpose. For such material one needs to devise the best counting method available, establish possible sources of error, and decide whether the likely size of the error of the final counts will justify the necessary labor and lead to sufficiently trustworthy conclusions. Although neuroscience has been greatly advanced by studies that included counts from sections, it should be recognized that there are situations where, on the basis of the material available and the likely size of the error of a count, it may be prudent not to count. An erroneous count may be more of a hindrance to advancing knowledge than no count at all; authors, reviewers and editors should strive to make the description of methods relevant to a counting study as complete and translucent as possible, so that readers can be helped to evaluate the reliability of a count. Where two comparable quantitative studies produce conflicting results, it is often difficult to understand the basis of the difference. For example, Haug (1986) reports that the number of nerve cells reported in human cerebral cortex has varied from 0.6 x 109 to 16 x 109, and Pakkenberg and Gundersen (1995) report 20-25 x 109 (see also footnote 2). Although different methods of counting have been clearly presented, and sources of errors as well as possible corrections of errors have been discussed (e.g. Floderus, 1944; Abercrombie, 1946; Konigsmark, 1970; Pakkenberg and Gundersen, 1989; Clarke, 1992, 1993; Coggeshall and Lekan, 1996; Guillery and Herrup, 1997; Gundersen et al., 1999; West, 1999; Benes and Lange, 2001), serious differences concerning methods can be found in the literature, and discrepancies in the results obtained are still common. There is an increasingly widely held, but overly simple faith that only one method of counting, using the 'disector', often described as 'un-biased' or 'assumption-free' (see: Coggeshall and Lekan, 1996; Mayhew and Gundersen, 1996; West, 1999), can produce valid results. Although this is a powerful and useful method, the view that only counts that use the disector should be accepted for use in publications and grant-supported research is too sweeping. So also is the claim that these methods are free of assumptions of the type that can, and often do, lead other methods into systematic errors. For almost any counting method that has been used, there have been many publications in which the method of count-
ing is either quite evidently flawed, or is presented without the detail that is needed to evaluate the significance of the final count. In this brief review, we stress that there is no one 'correct' way to undertake a count, and we indicate that there are innumerable, often unforeseen errors that one can make, no matter which method of counting is used. Any student interested in the subject can find examples of more or less egregious errors in the literature (in fact, encouraging students to find such errors is a good way to introduce them to the problems of counting). Since almost all of us who have made counts have committed errors of omission or commission, we cite only few examples of the sorts of things that can go wrong. No matter what method of counting is used, the range of possible sources of errors is great, far beyond the scope of this review. Planning a count
The first step in evaluating a counting method is to decide what sort of information is being sought. This is a first step for the investigator who has to provide a clear statement; it is also an essential first step for those who give advice on counting and for those who have to evaluate studies that include counts. For some studies one simply needs a ballpark figure to indicate how many cells or axons or synapses characterize a particular structure or brain. More commonly, one is looking to make comparisons, between nerve cells and glia, nerve ceils and synapses, between structure A and structure B, or between different experimental conditions, disease states, or developmental stages or species. There is, as we shall see, an important difference between wanting to know the number of objects within a particular nucleus or cell layer, and wanting to know the number of objects per unit volume of a brain part. Perhaps an important opening statement for the methods section of a quantitative study should be one that clearly describes the nature of the counts to be made, and defines the margins of error that are considered acceptable. This not only alerts the reader to the relevant variables of the study, but will also protect the author from being attacked for not achieving a level of accuracy greater than that actually needed in the study. A second step should perhaps be recognition of possible errors, their likely
27 size, and a summary of the steps that have been taken to reduce or eliminate such errors. Possibly the most important source of error is the bias introduced by the observer who is making a comparison between two populations. Unless the observer is blind to the conditions of the study, there will be a possibility of a serious bias in the results. Labeling a counting method as 'unbiased' or 'assumption-free' may at times have led investigators into a false sense of security about the unbiased nature of their results. Whenever a count reports a comparison, the methods section should indicate whether the observer was blind to the conditions being compared, and if the methods section does not include such a statement, then one is well advised to treat the results as unreliable. It is tempting to think that some defined formula could be devised for the method to be used in any quantitative study, but since each tissue, each preparatory method, and each type of count raises its own particular array of problems, the development of such a 'formulaic' approach is to be discouraged. There is already too great a tendency for investigators to name their method, cite a general account of the method, and leave out specific and important details that, as we shall show, can make a significant difference to the reliability of a count. In general, any study that does not look at the possibility of errors in the counts deserves particularly close scrutiny, especially if it claims to be free of 'assumptions'.
Defining the 'acceptable' error Preliminary observations can often give a clue as to the size of the error that is acceptable. For a doctoral dissertation one of the authors (R.W.G.) counted the cells in the mamillary nuclei and found about 80,000 cells in the medial mamillary nucleus of the cat, and only about 3000 cells in the lateral mamillary nucleus. The difference tells something significant about the functions of the two parts of the system, and the general conclusion about a large difference between the two nuclei could have been firmly established even by counts that had a large error. However, for comparisons between species, and for ratios of cells relative to axons, methods that were sensitive to smaller differences were needed. Comparably, when electron microscopic images of the visual relay in
the thalamus (the lateral geniculate nucleus) first became available, one of the striking features was that a relatively small proportion of the total synaptic junctions were established by retinal axons. The predominance of non-retinal afferents was demonstrable by counts (Guillery, 1969). These cannot be regarded as having provided an accurate quantitative survey, but they did stress what was at the time a surprising conclusion about the preponderance of non-retinal afferents. More recent counts have confirmed this general conclusion, but have provided rather more accurate figures (Eri~ir et al., 1998). Counts of ratios between (e.g.) Purkinje cells and granule cells in the cerebellum can similarly show that the latter greatly outnumber the former, and a large error would not alter the conclusion. However, if a theoretician needed more precise ratios, or if one wanted to compare the ratios between species, then the smaller size of the acceptable error must be taken into consideration when the counts are planned. The smaller the acceptable error, the more important is the method, and the greater the necessary investment in the study. It has been pointed out that errors differ in their nature and can differ in the effects that they produce. For many purposes it is important to distinguish between errors that are random, and thus affect the variance of the mean obtained, and errors that are systematic (or 'biased'), which shift the mean up or down (West, 1999). The distinction is important when one is planning a count, but it should be noted that distinguishing the effects of each type of error in any particular published count can be extremely difficult, and often impossible. The first type of error, provided that an appropriate method of sampling has been used, produces a set of counts that are randomly scattered around the actual value, and the extent of this scatter, the variance, can be estimated, and recorded in terms of standard errors. Up to a point, the more counts that one has, the smaller this error is likely to be, although the labor required for accurate counts often leads to relatively small sample sizes. It should be stressed that the estimate of the variance will depend on the distribution of the population of objects being counted, on the nature of the population of organisms being studied, and on the sampling procedure used. In some tissues the problem of variation from
28 one section to another or from one part of a section to another is relatively small. Gundersen and Osterby (1981) have made the point that this can be of 'negligible importance' relative to the 'biological variation' between individuals. However, the nervous system is a highly structured (i.e. non-random) tissue, where objects that are to be counted are likely to be heterogeneously distributed. Here a limited random sampling procedure of the sort that is often used can give a false estimate of the size and of the variability of the population (see Benes and Lange, 2001). Consider a population of cells that is highly concentrated in small clumps or layers in a tissue. If 90% of the cells occupy only about 5% of the volume of the tissue, then there is significant probability that a sample of 20 counts will not include a region of the high cell concentration. That is, these 20 counts could provide not only a significant undercount, but would also provide an entirely false picture of the variability, and so provide a seriously misleading clue for evaluating the data. Investigators should have a clear view of how the population of objects that is to be counted is distributed, should ensure that their sampling method provides a representative sample of all parts of this population, and should also indicate how the sampling procedure used relates to the known distribution of the objects being counted. The problem of variance applies not only to the objects being counted but also to the population of individuals from whom the tissue for counting has been obtained. A point that may be particularly important for the subject of this conference concerns the measure of variance that one can expect to find in any population of individuals likely to be used. Whereas one can expect a highly inbred strain of mouse to produce a relatively low variance for many counts (Williams et al., 1996), especially when age and sex are taken into account 1, a human population is likely to show very much more variation 2. This will not only produce high standard errors for the relatively small samples that often have to be used, Note, however,that where two investigatorsuse different inbred strains the chances of obtaining discordant results are increased. 2 Pakkenberg and Gundersen (1997) show a range from <15 x 10 9 to >30 x 10 9 for numbers of neocortical neurons in human brains.
but it may also mean that subjects used for counts in one laboratory may differ in real terms (general health, diet, environment etc.) from subjects used in another. The same is likely to hold for animals obtained from the wild or for animals that, though bred for laboratory research, have not been inbred, such as the cats or monkeys most commonly used in CNS research. Again, one should be on guard for small sample sizes, which can provide ballpark figures, but which may be seriously misleading not only about the population mean, but also about the variance. Heavy investments made to obtain highly accurate individual counts may prove counter productive where this leads to records from relatively few individuals in a highly variable population. Experimental studies of ageing that involve more than a few years face a particularly difficult problem because housing conditions for the experimental subjects change as governments adopt new guidelines, and as the training received by animal caretakers changes. For human studies the occurrence of major wars, famines, or changing diets may be more relevant than age in itself. The second major type of error is a systematic error that produces undercounts or overcounts. The most common example occurs where objects of unknown size are counted in sections. Since many of the objects are cut and appear in more than one section, an uncorrected count will provide an overcount, and the larger the objects, the greater the overcount. Where two conditions are being compared, it is possible to record a significant difference in cell number where, in reality, there is a difference in cell sizes, or cell shapes, with no difference in the numbers. That is, there is a systematic error (or bias) because there has been a confusion of parameters. Larger objects produce spuriously higher counts. In this example, the confusion is between cell size (or shape) and cell number; in following sections we illustrate other confusions of parameters that can also lead to comparable systematic errors, or biases, and that are less widely recognized. In practice, many of the problems and errors that one encounters in light microscopy and in electron microscopy are different, and for this reason, we consider the two separately in what follows.
29
Light microscopical studies Profile c o u n t s
T h e m o s t c o m m o n l y d i s c u s s e d s y s t e m a t i c error in counts that use light m i c r o s c o p i c a l study o f tissue slices is the one i n t r o d u c e d above, p r o d u c e d by double c o u n t i n g o f objects in sections, w h e r e s o m e o f the objects are cut so that they a p p e a r in two or m o r e sections (Fig. 1). I f all o f the profiles in the s a m p l e d parts o f the sections are c o u n t e d (profile counts), then the severity o f this bias, and the extent to w h i c h it can be r e c o g n i z e d and c o r r e c t e d d e p e n d s on h o w m u c h the o b s e r v e r k n o w s about the shape and the size o f the objects and the thickness o f the sections. T h e less one k n o w s about the shape and the
Fig. 1. Schema to represent the use of the Abercrombie correction for a profile count. (A) Twenty-five cells (or nuclei or nucleoli or mitochondria etc.) are distributed through a tissue. One of a series of sections is represented by the tissue between the two solid lines. This includes some of the cells, cuts some and excludes others. (B) h, the mean dimension of the 25 cells in the z-axis is equal to H/25. Estimates of h and T are based on measurements that represent dimensions in the z-plane. If it can be shown that on average the dimensions of the cells are equivalent in all directions, then h can be obtained from sections cut in any plane, but if this cannot be shown, then h should be measured in the z-plane itself, either directly, using measurement of movements of the microscope stage along the z-axis (see section on measurements along the z-axis), or by cutting sections perpendicular to the original section plane, using either equivalent tissues to those used for counting or, where the method allows this, re-cutting the same sections perpendicular to the original section plane. (C) When the section is viewed through the microscope from above, a profile count will, on average, represent cells having a unique point (top, bottom or some other, theoretical, unique central point) in a thickness of the original tissue equivalent to T + h. That is, the profile count over-estimates the cell number by a factor of T + h / T . (D) If, for the measurement of h and T sections are re-cut perpendicular to the original section plane, then, if there is further shrinkage during this second process of cutting (which may require re-embedding), then, provided that the shrinkage acts equally on all parts of the section, for calculating the Abercrombie correction factor, no further correction is required, since the ratio T / ( T + h) = s T / ( s T + sh), where s represents the degree of shrinkage. However, the point about equivalent shrinkage of all parts of the tissue should be treated as an assumption (see text). It is useful to compare measurements made on the original sections (by calibrated vertical movements of the microscope stage) with measurements made directly along the same axis on the re-cut sections.
size o f the objects b e i n g counted, the stronger the a r g u m e n t for using an alternative, such as the 'disector' m e t h o d (Pakkenberg and G u n d e r s e n , 1989, 1995; C o g g e s h a l l and Lekan, 1996; West, 1999), w h i c h is i n d e p e n d e n t o f o b j e c t shape and size. It has b e e n argued that the d i s e c t o r t e c h n i q u e should always be used, and that profile counts are intrinsic a l l y unreliable, and thus should be avoided. S i n c e profile counts are relatively s i m p l e to do and can be carried out fairly rapidly on m a n y different types o f section, it is worth l o o k i n g at the d e g r e e to w h i c h they are unreliable, and defining c o n d i t i o n s u n d e r w h i c h their use should be e n c o u r a g e d . A point that is o f p r i m a r y i m p o r t a n c e in e v a l u a t i n g counts is the tension that a l w a y s exists b e t w e e n , on the one hand, using a labor-intensive, h i g h l y accurate m e t h o d such as the p h y s i c a l disector, w h i c h often leads to small s a m p l e sizes, or, on the o t h e r hand, using a m o r e
2
3
4
5
I • •
6
7
9
12
16
•
19
b
25
3
7
4
13
j h =H/25
9
10
12
•
• •
11
• • •
t
22
24
•
B I
21
2
•
, "
17
zu 23
C
I0
13
]4
t6
17
1
"I" /
• /
t5
18 i
i
1
lh/S •
6
7
8
13
D
• •
12 11
~"
.TIS
30 rapid method that allows for larger samples. The more that is known about the sources of variability discussed above, the easier it will be to decide on the most appropriate approach. Fig. 1 shows that the size of the error in a profile count depends on the thickness of the sections and on the mean dimension of the counted objects in a plane perpendicular to the section (the z-plane). That is, the smaller the objects being counted and the thicker the section, the smaller the error. A suitable correction for this error was published by Abercrombie 55 years ago and can be expressed as N = Nl ( T / T + h), where N is the actual number of objects that should be recorded, N1 is the recorded count, T is the thickness of the sections, and h is the mean height of the objects in the z-plane (Abercrombie, 1946). As h becomes larger relative to T, the error becomes larger, and is quite unacceptably large if h is greater than T. Clarke (1992) has suggested that profile counts combined with the Abercrombie corrections should not be used where T exceeds h by a ratio of 1.5, which is good general rule, although one is wise to work well on the safe side of this limit. Where h is small relative to T, the error will be correspondingly small. That is, given
that one has reliable information about h and T and h / T is small, profile counts with the Abercrombie correction, or with an appropriate variant of that correction (e.g. Floderus, 1944; Konigsmark, 1970) can produce reliable results. Arguments against the use of such counts are often based on situations where the objects to be counted are large relative to section thickness or of unknown shape (Coggeshall and Lekan, 1996; West, 1999). Where the objects are small and of well-defined shape, those arguments do not apply. Furthermore, since the method is simple and relatively straight forward, and since it can be used on material where adjacent sections are not stained by the same method (which is important if the physical disector method described below is to be used) it is a mistake to discourage its proper use. An example, where a profile count can be useful, is provided by nucleolar counts (which can also be used for cell counts in tissues where cells are known to have one and not more than one nucleolus). In sections that are 10-30 ~tm in thickness and where the nucleoli are roughly spherical and 1-3 Ixm in diameter, as they are in many neural structures, pro-
file counts provide a simple and rapid method. For the dimensions given above, an uncorrected profile count will produce an error of about 3% for a population of small nucleoli in 30-1xm sections and of about 23% for large nucleoli in 10-txm sections, so that for small nucleoli and 30-1xm sections, even with no correction, the counts can produce useful results for many purposes. With larger nucleoli or thinner sections, the correction becomes important, but once the correction is made, provided that it is based on reliable information about the dimensions h and T, one can expect the estimate to be relatively close to the actual number in that sample. It should be noted that there have been several versions of the Abercrombie correction. Some (e.g. Floderus, 1944; Konigsmark, 1970) make allowance for small pieces of the counted structures that are lost in the cutting (so-called lost caps), or that cannot be recognized because they are too thin at the surface of a section. Others (e.g. Coupland, 1968; Hendry, 1976; Hedreen, 1998) address the problem posed by objects whose size represents a significant fraction of section thickness, causing measurements of h to be biased in favor of smaller objects that are completely included in the sections. These corrections are refinements that can provide a somewhat closer approach to the 'real' number but, as can be seen from the above example of nucleolar counts, such corrections are a case of gilding the lily for small objects in relatively thick sections. Where the ratio of object size to section thickness is relatively high, these additional corrections may help, but the correction for the lost caps can then also be of slightly dubious value, since often the assessment of just what allowance to make for lost or unrecognizable 'caps' can be arbitrary. Nuclear counts in thin sections may give a rather high h / T ratio, but can still be used in relatively thick sections provided there is good evidence about the value of h. Ideally h and T should be measured in some of the sections of the series that is used for the counts, and this can be done after some of the sections have been cut perpendicular to the original section plane (see Marengo, 1944, and Fig. 1). That is the measurements should be made in the z-plane. However, alternate sections, sections from the other hemisphere or possibly even from other, closely matched brains can also be used; alternatively, the measurements can be made on the sections used
31 for the counts by measuring stage movements of the microscope in the z-direction, beating in mind, however, the problems involved in making such measurements, which are considered in a separate section below. It may be of some interest for those who have done or plan to do profile counts to note that the Abercrombie correction is wrongly presented in two recent articles that argue strongly against profile counts in general and in support of the disector methods in particular (Coggeshall and Lekan, 1996; West, 1999). The correction factors given there would not lead one to recognize the importance of the ratio of h to T for profile counts, and could lead to serious error if used to correct a profile count. For anyone planning a profile count, the best strategy is to compute the correction factor on the basis of a figure such as Fig. 1C, which shows clearly that a profile count is actually counting objects representative of numbers in a volume equivalent to a section having a thickness of h + T. Alternatively reference can be made to Abercrombie's original paper, which also includes some interesting further thoughts on counting and measuring the objects to be counted. One of the suggestions made in that study is that the correction can be avoided if one cuts adjacent sections at different thickness (TI and T2, where TI > T2). The difference between the profile counts (Nl minus N2) made in the two sets of sections will then give the correct number for the number of objects in a (notional) section having thickness T1 minus T2. Where celloidin or frozen sections are cut on a sliding microtome, this method can be quite practical, provided that actual section thicknesses are measured. 3 Shrinkage of the tissue, either before sectioning, or on the slide after sectioning, can be considerable. The issue may become important if one is comparing two tissues that do not undergo the same amount of shrinkage (Uylings et al., 1986; Haug, 1987), and if one is recording cell densities rather than total
3 For paraffin sections, two knives mounted precisely parallel to each other, one above the other and one slightly closer to the block face than the other can also providethe needed two series, but collecting two paraffin ribbons concurrently takes quite some skill, even if one managesto arrange for the knives to be properly mounted, which is, of course, critical.
numbers. This would lead to a different confusion of parameters, where a greater amount of tissue shrinkage becomes interpreted as a higher cell density. The issue can also be important if one measures volume before shrinkage and cell packing densities after shrinkage. The use of the 'disector'
This method of counting has been fully described in several publications (Gundersen et al., 1988, 1999; Coggeshall and Lekan, 1996; West, 1999, 2002, this volume) and was first brought to the attention of contemporary investigators by a paper published almost two decades ago (Sterio, 1984). Benes and Lange (2001) have pointed out that an earlier use of the same principle was described in 1895 at the University of Wisconsin for counting the glomeruli in the kidney of a cat (Miller and Carlton, 1895). The method is based on a comparison of two adjacent sections, recording the number of profiles of objects seen in one section, the 'sampling section', and then only counting those objects that do not also appear on the adjacent 'look-up' section. This is a simple method for avoiding double counts, and its particular strength is that it is completely independent of the size and shape of the objects being counted. That is, with this method, the two parameters, size and number, cannot be confused. If the two sections are physically separate sections (the 'physical disector') then the process is difficult because the two sections need to be precisely matched so that objects on one section can be matched against objects on the next section. Furthermore, the method often cannot be used on archival material where complete series may not be available, either because different stains were used for adjacent sections, or sections were not mounted as complete series. For these reasons the 'optical disector' has considerable appeal, since it uses two or more optical sections within a single histological section to achieve the same result. In principle, this method can be used rather like the physical disector, recording number of profiles at one plane of focus, and then only counting those that are not still present at another plane. Within a reasonably thick section, several pairs of optical sections can be used, with the look-up section of one pair serving as a sample
32 section for another (West, 1999)4. In essence, it is necessary to ensure that within any volume of tissue in the single physical section, only one point on any object to be counted is recorded; a simple choice is to record the top of any object that first comes into focus as the section is raised towards the objective (West, 1999; Geuna, 2000). This then resolves the method into a simple procedure of recording the number of such 'tops' within an optically defined thickness within the thicker histological section. The volume used for such counts should avoid the edges of the sections, where there may be unevenness and where there is likely to be a 'lost caps' problem. The optical disector has justifiably gained considerably in popularity in recent years. Its use is to be encouraged since it is relatively simple and so can produce larger sample sizes than the physical disector. Furthermore, it can serve where the objects to be counted are too large or too irregular to be counted by profile counts. However, it is important that two issues be clearly appreciated by those using this method. One is the importance of the basic rules that govern the production of optical images with a light microscope, and a second is the problems of tissue shrinkage associated with the production of histological sections. Failure to recognize the importance of these can introduce serious bias into a count. The most important point about the optical disector concerns measurements in the z-axis. Whereas the physical disector avoids many (but not all) of the problems related to measurements along this axis, these problems can play a major role in the production of systematic errors when the optical disector is used.
Measurements in the z-axis We have seen that measurements of section thickness are critical for profile counts. They can sometimes be ignored where a physical disector is used to sample
4 If this method is used then it is important to ensure that the distance between the two optical sections is smaller than the smallest object to be counted, since, of course, such small objects would be missed as they fell between two chosen optical sections. The problem does not arise if one simply counts tops as the section is raised from one focal plane to the other.
from a known proportion of sections through a well defined volume of tissue (Gundersen et al., 1988). That is, if the sections are all of essentially the same thickness, and if each section then represents a known fraction of the total tissue dimension in the z-plane, then a count in a sample of each section will represent a proportion of the total tissue volume that can be defined without recording section thickness. However, often, for comparisons of densities of objects in a tissue, which are likely to be important where boundaries are difficult to define (see below), section thicknesses need to be defined. For counts that use the optical disector, it is important to define the thickness of the optical section from which any one count is obtained, and this is crucial and can readily lead to undercounts or overcounts if the measure is wrongly determined. In a recent review of quantitative methods Geuna (2000), discussing the optical disector, argues that the top of an object: "is a point (and thus adimensional), it has no size, shape or orientation (therefore no assumptions are needed for these parameters) and can be sampled in only one disector volume (i.e. it cannot be split into two disectors)". This represents a serious misunderstanding of optical sections and one that, to judge from published accounts, is shared by several other users of the optical disector. Although the top of the object is a dimensionless point, its microscopic image is not. The image has three dimensions, and these dimensions depend upon the optical conditions of the study. The depth of the field when using widefield optics 5 and actual measurements made along the z-axis depend on the numerical aperture of the lens, and on the optical properties of the specimen. With good optical conditions (see below) and a good oil immersion lens having a high numerical aperture (1.35 or 1.4), one can expect the accuracy to be of the order of 0.5 txm, or even less6. This assumes that
The term refers to light microscopic methods that are distinct from confocal microscopy and other methods using a restricted beam of light. 6 Under ideal conditions, it can be as small as 0.3 txm (Williams and Rakic, 1988), but conditions, as argued below, are rarely ideal. It is best to check empirically. Lange and Edstrrm (1954) discussed problems of measurements in z-axis in detail and recorded a 10% error for measurements of 5 ltm along the
33 a suitably thin cover glass has been used and that the refractive index of the mounting medium and the tissue is very close to that of the glass and of the immersion oil. However, these ideal conditions are rarely, if ever, met, and often the details provided are not sufficient for judging the extent to which they have been met. Mounting media that have been used in the preparation of histological sections vary greatly in their refractive index. Lillie (1965) shows a range from 1.413 to 1.8225 7, but it is rare, in publications that use measurements along the z-axis, to find any information about refractive index, either of the mounting medium, or, where this is relevant, of the embedding compound used. Concerns about the refractive index of the mounting medium are particularly important where sections have not been cleared and are viewed in an aqueous medium. Each change of refractive index encountered by the light on its way through the specimen, the mounting medium and the cover glass to the objective lens will produce a shift from the ideal condition and a consequent change o f the distance along the z-axis over which the object appears to be in focus. The effect on the apparent size of an object in the z-axis produced by changes in refractive index can be surprisingly large (amounting to about 65% for objects viewed without immersion oil; see Glaser, 1982; West and Slomianka, 1998). The refractive index of the tissue itself could play a significant role in the formation of the image, but is usually not considered since one assumes that dehydration and clearing replace water and lipids from z-axis. West et al. (1996) using a high numerical aperture, oil immersion lens give an estimate of 'depth of focus' as 1-2 Ixm, which is probably the sort of figure one can generally expect. Uylings et al. (1986), using x63 and xl00 lenses (NA not given) report inter-individual variation with a range of 3 txm for measuring a section that was 5 Itm in thickness. We have used a Nikon 'microcator' (Gundersen et al., 1988) to record vertical movements of the microscope stage and have measured the thickness of number 1 cover glasses that had ink marks on both surfaces, and were mounted in Eukitt mounting medium (RI = 1.51: Calibrated Instruments Inc., Hawthorne, NY 10502). With a ×40 lens (NA = 1.0) we recorded measurements ranging from 146 to 159 txm (mean = 153.0, SE = 0.51, n = 40) for one cover glass. With a x 100 lens (NA 1.25) the corresponding values for the same cover glass were 147-158 tim (mean = 152.7, SE = 0.54, n = 20). 7 Immersion oil has a refractive index close to 1.51.
the tissue so that it takes on the refractive index of the mounting medium. However, if an unstained section of the tissue can be imaged by phase contrast or interference contrast optics (either of these providing a suitable test) then the tissue itself is acting to refract the light passing through it, and this is likely to be the case for any tissue of interest to neuroscientists. That is, some parts of the section, most probably proteins that have not been replaced by the dehydration and clearing procedures, are producing variations in the refractive index of the cleared tissue. The question for measures along the z-axis, is whether the overall effect of these variations in the refractive index affect the measurements. Preliminary observations of lines drawn on a microscope slide and observed through a 60-1xm tissue section, suggest that the sections do not seriously affect measures along the z-axis, except in so far as the resolution of the image is poorer when viewed through the section. That is, the refractive properties of the CNS tissues we have used (cerebral cortex, cerebellar cortex) produced some slight loss in the accuracy of the measures, but not a systematic shift in the mean of the measures that were recorded. Where measures along the z-axis are critical for a particular set of observations, it would be useful to have commercially available slides that are marked with fine lines. These could serve two purposes if appropriately designed. If the lines were spaced a known distance apart along the z-axis ( 5 - 1 0 Ixm apart between layers of glass, or of plastic having the same refractive index as the glass) they could serve to calibrate the equipment used for measurements along this axis. Furthermore, sample sections could be mounted over such lines so that any changes in resolution and focal depth produced by the presence of the section could be recorded and reported as a part of the study 8. A simple method of calibration that may be more practical is to use c o m m e r c i a l l y available microspheres, and check that mean and standard errors for measures in the x - and y-axes match the measures in the z-axis. A minor, but interesting, variable relevant to measurements in the z-axis is represented by the optics s However, measurements of fine lines present a best case scenario. As noted below, the nature of the object being observed is relevant to the accuracy with which its position and dimensions in the z-axis can be defined.
34 of the observer's eye (see e.g. Haug, 1956; Uylings et al., 1986). They are best eliminated by using an image on a screen or a photographic image. Ideally, perhaps, if one is not using a screen or a photograph, one should always use very old observers whose lenses have hardened (it should be regarded as unethical to paralyze the accommodative mechanisms of young observers). Mechanical problems are also relevant to measurements in the z-axis. The accuracy of the fine markings on the focal adjustments of microscopes varies greatly, and some instruments may give rather inaccurate measures. Devices for recording the actual vertical movements of the microscope stage ('microcators': Gundersen et al., 1988) have been described and these provide more reliable measures of stage movements, although reports that use such devices would be well served by brief mention of their calibration before use. 9 Accurately defining the focal plane in which the top of an object lies, depends not only on the optics, but also on the nature of the object. Theoretical considerations generally apply to very small objects having high contrast, i.e., a point source. In practice, we do not have many point sources in our sections, and generally that is not what we count. For very small, well-defined objects that have a high contrast, finding exactly where the top is in focus is relatively straight forward, whereas a larger opaque object, a pale one, or a slightly granular one may prove much more difficult. If one is studying a Nisslstained section, then defining the top of the cell can be extremely difficult, since one is assessing where the very small Nissl granules, scattered immediately below the surface of the cell, first come into focus. Defining the top of the nucleus may prove easier, because the nuclear membrane is generally (but not invariably) more clearly defined, and since it has a higher curvature, the 'top' is nearer to Geuna's idealized point. If the control and the experimen-
9 We are uncertain about the degree to which the variance of the measures reported in footnote 5 was due to the mechanism used, to the optics of the preparation, to the observer's visual system, or to slight variations in the cover glass thickness. Although the means and standard errors we have recorded are relatively consistent, the range of these observations is somewhat disconcerting.
tal samples differ in the staining properties or the dispersal of the structures (such as the Nissl granules near the cell surface) that define the 'top' of the counted objects, then this could well influence judgments about best focus. In summary, measurements along the z-axis are subject to systematic errors that depend on the optics of the preparation and the mechanics of the recording equipment. Some errors, like the changes in refractive index, can lead to serious under counts. Others, like the uncertainties of defining the precise focal plane of an object, will increase the size of the random errors that characterize a result. Where relatively small distances along the z-axis are being recorded (e.g. 10 txm or less between the optical slices), the margin of error introduced by the optical and mechanical problems may well represent a significant percentage of the total z-dimension. There are some good reasons for having optical disectors closely spaced, but the likely errors summarized above suggest that it may be better to have a fairly wide spacing. Where comparisons are being made that depend on judgment calls as to whether an object is or is not in focus, it is absolutely essential that the observer be blind to the conditions under investigation, and that this be clearly stated in the description of the methods. The z-axis also presents difficulties for quantitative methods because of the shrinkage that occurs along this axis x0. Any tissue when it is dehydrated or hydrated during histological processing is likely to change in volume, and different methods of preparation introduce different amounts of change. The amount of the volume change in any part of a section depends on the nature of the tissue, on the nature of the treatment, and on forces that may be acting on the tissue to counteract those produced by the shrinkage itself. When a tissue block or a freefloating section is processed, one generally assumes that all parts of the tissue shrink equally, although anyone who has handled individual sections of cerebral or cerebellar cortex after they have been exposed to significant shrinkage, will know that the gray and
10Linear shrinkages to 70-80% are commonly found. Since this has to be cubed to calculate the volume shrinkage one is dealing with very significant volume changes.
35 the white matter do not shrink equally. In spite of this, measurements along the x- and the y-axes, before and after processing are generally considered to give a reasonable estimate of shrinkage, where this measure is needed. When frozen sections or vibratome sections are used, if these are fixed to the slide, then, provided that the sections adhere firmly to the slide, there can be no further shrinkage of the attached section surface in the x- and y-axes, and much of the shrinkage must occur along the z-axis. Consequently, the amount of this shrinkage can be relatively large. Furthermore, since one surface of the section is firmly adherent to the slide but the other is free, there is every reason to expect that the amount of the shrinkage will not be uniform along the z-axis. We know of no observations that have investigated this point, and would expect it to vary depending on the tissue, the method of adhesion, and the type of treatment. Where the optical disector is used, therefore, two caveats should be considered. One is that two optical slices taken one above the other from the same area of a single histological section and measured as equal in their dimensions along the z-axis may not represent equal thicknesses of the original unshrunk section, and the second, a consequence of the first, is that the precise position along the z-axis, of a single optical slice, may make a difference to a count if the tissue has not undergone even shrinkage along this axis. Some of the issues addressed above apply to all sections, no matter how they are viewed, but the problem of defining the focal plane is different when the confocal microscope is used. Here the refractive indices of tissue, mounting medium and specimen, and the optical properties of the lens are still important, as is tissue shrinkage, but one can expect to have a narrower extent of the z-plane in focus than with widefield methods (see footnote 4). Given that setting up optimal conditions for confocal microscopy is not simple and that many investigators rely on technical support that a reviewer or referee cannot evaluate, some calibration or empirical evidence regarding the depth of focus of a confocal image should be provided where images that are relatively closely spaced are used.
Other problems Although the problem of double counting cut objects with profile counts has received the most attention, there are many other sources of error, several of them being a confusion of parameters comparable to the confusion of cell size and cell number. Where the number of objects within a cell group (e.g. a nuclear group or a lamina) needs to be determined, defining the outline of the particular cell group accurately is critical. Many such outlines are very hard to define in terms of objective criteria, and may depend upon features that seem obvious to an experienced microscopist, but that are not easily rendered into a clear written summary. There are several important outcomes: one is that two observers working independently in different laboratories and at different times may well be using different criteria to identify boundaries. Another is that the features that serve to identify boundaries may well be affected by the variable under study, the disease state, the age, or the experimental condition. Architectonic studies often rely on subtle changes from one region to another in cell or background staining, in cell size, or cell distribution, and if these are features that differ in the two conditions being compared, then an objective quantitative comparison may prove very difficult to establish. Here the staining properties of cells or background represent parameters that influence judgments about borders, and so can lead to erroneous conclusions about size of a cell group or the number of the objects that they contain. Where comparisons between two disease states or experimental conditions are being studied, the criteria used for establishing borders should be clearly defined and the methods section should indicate that the observers who drew the borders were blind to the disease state or experimental condition. The issue is raised not because we have a suggestion for entirely avoiding the problems, but because there is a tendency in some published accounts to treat a so-called 'unbiased' method as guarantee for accuracy; it is not, and especially in comparative counts, it is important to identify likely sources of error no matter what particular counting method is being used. Sometimes one can change strategy and count objects that show a particular property rather than cells that are included in a nuclear group or lamina.
36
37 For instance, one may choose to count cells that are retrogradely labeled following a particular delivery of axonally transported marker, or to count cells having particular staining properties (GABA or G A D reactive, ACh containing, or immunoreactive to one of any number of epitopes). The obvious caveat here is to make sure that the distinction between a change in actual cell number and a change in the affinity of the particular marker or stain (or the concentrations used) is clearly recognized. Again, there is a possibility of confusing two parameters, here, staining properties and cell numbers. For example, the difference between saying that there is a loss of cells in the nucleus of Meynert, and saying that there is a change in the staining properties of the cells in the nucleus of Meynert is important unless one is willing to assert boldly and clearly (as some are) that a cell does not belong to the nucleus of Meynert unless it has particular staining properties, and then one leaves changes in total number of cells in that region of the brain deliberately unresolved. The important point is to be clear about what the results may mean in terms of cell number or cell staining. A further point about many methods that stain particular components of a cell is that they are often not all-or-none methods. With these methods, the strength of the reaction and, therefore, the identifiability of a positively stained cell, that is, the final decision about the threshold between a stained and an unstained cell, depends on the vagaries of the method and the judgement of the observer. For example, immunohistochemical methods often stain the surface of a section well, but stain the inner parts of a section weakly or not at all. If the border between these two regions is sharp, then one can choose to study the well-stained part and ignore the rest. However, the change in staining intensity is more likely to be along a gradient, and decisions about the parts of the section that are suitable for
counts will generally then be rather arbitrary. The extent to which the reaction product can be seen in the depth of a section may depend on the amount of the epitope available, on properties of the matrix that surrounds the positive cells, or on the concentrations of antibody used, and these, rather than the number of cells reported, may be the variable that differs between two populations being studied. This provides yet another example of a confusion of parameters.
Electron microscopical studies Counting objects in electron microscopic materials presents a number of problems not encountered in light microscopy and is, on the whole, more difficult. If one starts with tissue preparation, then problems of tissue shrinkage are generally comparable to problems encountered with light microscopical methods, with one important exception. Cutting thin sections can readily lead to a compaction of the tissue perpendicular to the knife edge. That is, measurements along this axis of a section may not be equivalent to measurements along the corresponding part of the block face or to measurements taken parallel to the knife edge. The point is readily checked, and it seems reasonable to assume that where compacting has occurred it is even across the whole block face. Measurements of section thickness, where they are needed, can be based on interference colors, or (better) on views of folds in the section, where the thickness of the section can be measured directly (Small, 1968). It is generally assumed that section thickness is even throughout any one section, since unevenesses are readily spotted on the basis of interference colors. Since sections are extremely thin (down to about 50 nm) variations in section thickness can be a significant fraction of the thickness itself, and the evenness of the sections should be reported. Occasionally, comparisons need to be made be-
Fig. 2. Six micrographs taken at six different tilt angles from the same region of the hippocampus of a rat. The axis of tilt is indicated by the short black line at the upper left of figure A and the angle of tilt is shown in the upper right of each micrograph. The junction labeled I is a symmetrical junction with a visible cleft in A at +47 °. At the other angles some of the vesicles that lie close to the presynaptic membrane of this junction are more clearly shown, but otherwise there is little to identify this as a synaptic junction in B-E Junction 2 is clearly shown in D, E and F, from 0° to -27 °, but at the other angles, particularly in A, at +47 °, it is poorly defined as a synaptic junction. Junction 3 is recognizable at all angles in this figure because the axis of tilt was roughly perpendicular to the plane of the junction.
38 tween measurements or counts in adjacent thin and semithin sections made by electron and light microscopy, respectively. The points discussed above about the refractive index of the embedding resin may then become important. If this differs from the refractive index of glass and immersion oil, then some corrections for measurements along the z-axis will be required for the light microscopical observations. Depth of focus in an electron micrograph exceeds section thickness, so that all parts of the image are in focus at the same time. This limits the ways in which electron micrographs can be used. Profile counts based on electron micrographs are generally not advisable, since most structures to be counted are large in relation to section thickness, which is usually less than 100 nm. However, useful sections can be slightly thicker than this and, since synaptic vesicles are roughly 2 0 - 4 0 nm in diameter, they are an exception. Not only are their dimensions small relative to section thickness, but also one can reasonably treat them as spherical or ovoid objects that are generally not oriented relative to section plane, or that can be measured in more than one section plane if there is reason to suspect some orientation of 'flattened' vesicles. The extent to which a section through a part of a vesicle may be invisible in an electron micrograph will depend on the size and the nature of the vesicle, but arriving at a determination of this particular 'lost caps' problem may prove elusive. In practice, counts of vesicles, unless the vesicles are relatively large and sparsely packed, could not be based on serial reconstructions or use the physical disector, since the small, closely packed vesicles, will all be in focus in any one micrograph, so that matching from one section to the next is not feasible for most synapses. Probably profile counts with appropriate corrections are the best that one can expect to do, and where two conditions are being compared on the basis of vesicle packing or number, a good record of vesicle sizes should also be provided. Counts of larger objects, such as mitochondria,
synaptic terminals or synaptic junctions 11, are best carried out with the physical disector method. Profile counts would need to include unacceptably large corrections based on the size of the objects and the thickness of the sections. In principle, object size can be estimated (see Anker and Cragg, 1974; Colonnier and Beaulieu, 1985), but such estimates represent approximations and, more importantly, are labor-intensive so that there is a danger that the final number will be based on relatively small samples and thus represent rather rough estimates (which, in some instances, may, of course, be sufficient for the purposes of the study). Two problems concerning counts of synaptic junctions deserve some attention. One is the question of defining exactly what is to be classified as a synaptic junction. If one insists that the synaptic cleft must be visible, the pre- and postsynaptic thickenings clearly distinguishable, and a small crowd of vesicles associated with the presynaptic thickening, then one will count relatively few synapses. Most investigators accept obliquely cut synapses, where the membrane thickenings are recognizable, but not necessarily distinct (see Figs. 2 and 3), but when this is done, it is not easy to define the point at which an apparent thickening ceases to be classifiable as a synapse. Similarly, the rigidity with which the juxtasynaptic presence of more than one vesicle is used as a criterion can vary. This is fine, provided that exactly the same criteria are used throughout any one study, but becomes more difficult where two independent studies need to be compared. Unless the criteria are rather strictly outlined in the methods section, it is unlikely that two laboratories will be using exactly the same criteria. Furthermore, where two conditions are being compared by one observer, it is essential that a 'blind' observer make the counts. J1The distinction between synaptic junctions and synaptic terminals is important since one terminal will often establish several junctional specializations.
Fig. 3. Four micrographs taken at four different tilt angles from the same region of a section from the hippocampus of a rat. Conventions as in Fig. 2. The junction labeled 1 shows a clear synaptic cleft in A at -30 °, but is only poorly defined in D at +50 °. In contrast, junction 2 has a well-defined cleft at all angles, except in A at -30 °. Junction 3, which is a symmetricaljunction, shows a well defined cleft at -30 °, but only the presynaptic dense projections are recognizable at +30 ° and +50 °. The region labeled 4 probably represents a junction roughly en face in A and B, with some sign of a thickening identifiable in D.
39
40
Fig. 4. When a synaptic junction is viewed en face it is difficult to recognize it as a junction, particularly if not all of it is included in a single section. The three structures indicated by arrows in this figure may represent such en face views, partially (3) or completely (1 and 2) included in the section. However, interpreting them as synaptic junctions is necessarily tentative, and for the purpose of synaptic counts they would almost certainly not be counted. The second problem, which is closely related to the first, is presented in Figs. 2 - 4 , which are electron microscopic images of sections that have been tilted through a total of 9 0 - 1 0 0 °. Zero degrees in the figures represents the usual position of the grid perpendicular to the beam. It is evident that the appearance of a synaptic junction changes with a change in the angle at which it is viewed. Most tellingly, the appearance can be changed from one that quite obviously represents a synaptic junction to one that might not readily be accepted as a synaptic junction, being only a blur or smudge that represents a synaptic thickening viewed en face or partially en face. It is important to notice that although the quality of the image deteriorates with increasing tilt (because the beam is passing through more tissue), some synaptic junctions are recognizable at maximum tilt, but are absent or dubious in the untilted section. In any single electron micrograph one can identify structures such as those illustrated in Fig. 4 that can be interpreted as en face images of synaptic junctions, some probably representing most or all of a junction, whereas others represent a part of a cut, en face junction. Unless these junctions are long and curve into the adjacent section, they will not be recognizable as synaptic junctions even where serial sections are available. With thicker sections, junctions viewed en face disappear completely (Scott and Guillery, 1974), so that information about section thickness may be important for an interpretation of
synaptic counts that are based on electron microscopic images. Even so, however, we know of no way in which one can estimate the proportion of synaptic junctions that are unrecognizable in any one section. Since the maximum tilt possible is generally about 90 ° , circa 45 ° in either direction, and with greater tilt the image becomes unusable, one cannot examine even a small piece of tissue at all possible tilt angles. Furthermore, for our studies, we only had one tilt axis (indicated in the figure) available, and could not rotate the stage in order to study a single junction with several different tilt axes. The conclusion that a significant proportion of synapses cannot be seen in electron micrographs is probably not surprising to many electron microscopists. The problem for synaptic counts is two-fold. One is that we have no estimate of what that proportion is. The other, intuitively obvious, and illustrated in Figs. 2 and 3, is that the angle over which any one synapse remains recognizable will vary. Asymmetrical junctions with a thick postsynaptic thickening can take more tilt than symmetrical junctions before they are lost to view, and curved junctions, depending on how the curvature relates to axis of tilt, will often remain identifiable over greater angles than junctions that are fiat. Small junctions are more likely to be lost than large junctions, particularly if serial sections are used, because few large junctions are completely flat. The conclusions that arise from these considerations are rather disconcerting, because they suggest
41 that in any study of synaptic junctions, no matter whether they are profile counts or use the physical disector, only a certain proportion of all synapses can be identified, and, so far, we know of no methods that would define what that proportion is. However, this still allows useful estimates of synaptic numbers in a tissue, by providing orders of magnitude and ratios, and these are often all that is needed. Whether one can use such counts for making comparisons between two ages or two clinical or experimental conditions, will depend on the extent to which one can establish that variables affecting the visibility of synaptic junctions are unchanged; that is, that there is not a change in the curvature of some or all of the junctions, and that the junctions do not change in terms of the relative density of the synaptic thickenings. In view of the problems considered above, staining methods that may be selective for synaptic junctions are likely to prove useful for more accurate counts. A method earlier proposed by Bloom and Aghajanian (1968), using ethanolic phosphotungstic acid, reveals synaptic thickenings quite strikingly in electron micrographs, and may still be a useful tool, but it is likely that other methods employing post-embedding immunohistochemical staining of specific components of the juxta-synaptic specializations could prove more useful. The use of the physical disector on such preparations may provide a means of recording numbers of synaptic junctions in a relatively accurate way. Of course, given a method for revealing all synaptic junctions in an electron microscopic section, it should then be possible to estimate the proportion of synaptic junctions that are not seen in conventional electron micrographs, although one should expect this proportion to vary somewhat, from one part of the brain to another, from one synaptic type to another, and also to depend on section thickness.
Conclusions The major conclusion for investigators planning counts is that there is no one best method. The method has to be suited to the nature of the material and to the nature of the problem. It may also need to be suited to the equipment available. There is often significant tension between highly accurate, often
labor-intensive counts, which are likely to produce small samples, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, more rapid, possibly less accurate counts, that can, however, produce relatively large samples. The more that is known about the variability of the populations, and this includes the populations of the objects in terms of their sizes, shapes and distributions, as well as the populations of organisms, people, cats, mice etc. being studied, the clearer will be the choice as to methods and necessary sample sizes. No counting method is entirely free of assumptions in all of its applications. Given the danger that the term 'assumption-free', when applied to a quantitative method, will lead to a false sense of security about the reliability of the results and their interpretation, it may be best for the term to he avoided altogether and replaced by a thoughtful and complete account of the tissues that have been used, and the methods employed to avoid a biased result.
Acknowledgements We thank Dr. J.B. Pawley for helpful discussions of some of the optical problems, Dr. A.O.W. Stretton for helpful comments on an earlier draft, and Dr. A. Messing for the loan of a microcator. Supported by grants EY 11494 and EY 12936.
References Abercrombie, M. (1946) Estimation of nuclear population from microtome sections. Anat. Rec., 94: 239-247. Anker, R.L. and Cragg, B.G. (1974) Estimation of the number of synapses in a volume of nervous tissue from counts in thin sections by electron microscopy.J. NeurocytoL, 3: 725-735. Benes, EM. and Lange, N. (2001) Two dimensional versus three dimensional cell counting: a practical perspective. Trends Neurosci., 24:11-17. Bloom, EE. and Aghajanian, G.K. (1968) Fine structural and cytochemical analysis of the staining of synaptic junctions with phosphotungstic acid. J. Ultrastruct. Res., 22: 361-375. Clarke, P.G.H. (1992) How inaccurate is the Abercrombie correction factor for cell counts?. Trends Neurosci., 15:211-212. Clarke, P.G.H. (1993) An unbiased correction factor for cell counts in histological sections. J. Neurosci. Methods, 49:133140. Coggeshall, R.E. and Lekan, H.A. (1996) Methods for determining numbers of cells and synapses: a case for more uniform standards of review. J. Comp. Neurol., 364: 3-16. Colonnier, M. and Beaulieu, C. (1985) An empirical assessment of stereological formulae applied to the counting of synaptic
42
discs in the cerebral cortex. J. Comp. Neurol., 231: 175-179. Coupland, R.E. (1968) Determining sizes and distribution of sizes of spherical bodies such as chromaffin granules in tissue sections. Nature, 217: 384-388. Eri~ir, A., Van Horn, S.C., Bickford, M.E. and Sherman, S.M. (1998) Distribution of synapses in the lateral geniculate nucleus of the cat. Differences between laminae A and A1 and between relay cells and interneurons. J. Comp. Neurol., 390: 247-255. Floderus, S. (1944) Untersuchungen fiber den Bau der menschlichen Hypophyse mit besonderer BeriJcksichtung der quantitativen mikromorphologischen Verh~iltnisse. Acta Pathol. Microbiol. Scand. Suppl., 53: 1-266. Geuna, S. (2000) Appreciating the difference between designbased and model-based sampling strategies in quantitative morphology of the nervous system. J. Comp. Neurol., 427: 333-339. Glaser, E.M. (1982) Snell's law: the bane of computer microscopists. J. Neurosci. Methods, 5: 201-202. Guillery, R.W. (1969) A quantitative study of synaptic interconnections in the laminae of the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus of the cat. Z. Zellforsch., 96: 1-38. Guillery, R.W. and Herrup, K. (1997) Quantification without pontification: choosing a method for counting objects in sectioned tissues. J. Comp. NeuroL, 386: 2-7. Gundersen, H.J.G. and Osterby, R. (1981) Optimizing sampling efficiency of stereological studies in biology: or 'do more less well!'. J. Microsc., 121: 65-73. Gundersen, H.J.G., Bagger, P., Bendtsen, T.E, Evans, S.M., Korbo, L., Marcussen, N., Moiler, A., Nielsen, K., Nyengaard, J.R. and Pakkenberg, B. (1988) The new stereological tools: disector, fractionator, nucleator and point sampled intercepts and their use in pathological research and diagnosis. APM1S, 96: 857-881. Gundersen, H.J.G., Jensen, E.B., Kieu, K. and Nielsen, J. (1999) The efficiency of systematic sampling in stereology - - reconsidered. J. Microscop., 193:199-211. Haug, H. (1956) Remarks on the determination and significance of the gray cell coefficient. J. Comp. Neurol., 104: 473-492. Haug, H. (1986) History of neuromorphometry. J. Neurosci. Methods, 18: 1-17. Haug, H. (1987) Brain sizes, surfaces and neuronal sizes of the cortex cerebri: a stereological investigation of man and his variability and a comparison with some mammals. Am. J. Anat., 180: 126-142. Hedreen, J.C. (1998) What was wrong with the Abercrombie and empirical cell counting methods? A review. Anat. Rec., 250: 373-380. Hendry, I.A. (1976) A method to correct adequately for the change in neuronal size when estimating neuronal numbers after nerve growth factor treatment. J. Neurocytol., 5: 337-349. Konigsmark, B.W. (1970) Methods for the counting of neurons. In: W.J.H. Nauta and S.O.E. Ebbesson (Eds.), Contemporary Research Methods in Neuroanatomy. Springer, Heidelberg, pp. 315-338. Lange, P.W. and Edstr6m, A. (1954) Determination of thickness of microscopic objects. Lab. Invest., 3:116-131.
Lillie, R.D. (1965) Histopathologic Technic and Practical Histochemistry. 3rd edn., McGraw Hill, New York, NY. Marengo, N.P. (1944) Paraffin section thickness - - a direct method of measurement. Stain Technol., 19: 1-10. Mayhew, T.M. and Gundersen, H.J.G. (1996) "If you assume you can make an ass out of u and me": a decade of the disector for stereological counting of particles in 3D space. J. Anat., 188: 1-15. Miller, W.S. and Carlton, E.P. (1895) The relation of the cortex of the cat's kidney to the volume of the kidney and an estimation of the number of glomeruli. Trans. Wisc. Acad. Sci., 10: 525-538. Pakkenberg, B. and Gundersen, H.J.G. (1989) New stereological method for obtaining unbiased and efficient estimates of total cell number in human brain areas. Exemplified by the mediodorsal nucleus in schizophrenics. APMIS, 97: 677-681. Pakkenberg, B. and Gundersen, H.J.G. (1995) Solutions to old problems in the quantitation of the central nervous system. J. Neurol. Sci., 129(Suppl 95): 65-67. Pakkenberg, B. and Gundersen, H.J.G. (1997) Neocortical neuron number in humans. Effect of sex and ages. J. Comp. NeuroL, 384: 312-320. Small, J.V. (1968) Measurements of section thickness. Proc. 4th Eur. Cong. Electron Microsc., 1: 609. Sterio, D.C. (1984) The unbiased estimation of number and sizes of arbitrary particles using the disector. J. Microscop., 134: 127-136. Scott, G.L. and Guillery, R.W. (1974) Studies with the high voltage electron microscope of normal, degenerating and Golgi impregnated neural processes. J. Neurocytol., 3: 567-590. Uylings, H.B., van Eden, C.G. and Hofman, M.A. (1986) Morphometry of size/volume variables and comparison of their bivariate relations in the nervous system under different conditions. J. Neurosci. Methods, 18: 19-37. Weibel, E.R. (1969) Stereological principles for morphometry in electron microscopic cytology. Int. Rev. Cytol., 26: 235-302. West, M.J. (1999) Stereological methods for estimating the total number of neurons and synapses: issues of precision and bias. Trends Neurosci., 22:51-61. West, M.J. (2002) Design based stereological methods for counting neurons. In: T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.), Do Seizures Damage the Brain. Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 43-51. West, M.J. and Slomianka, L. (1998) Total numbers of neurons in the layers of the human entorhinal cortex. Corrigendum. Hippocampus, 8: 426. West, M.J., Ostergaard, K., Andreassen, O.A. and Finsen, B. (1996) Estimation of the number of somatostatin neurons in the striatum: an in situ hybridization study using the optical fractionator method. J. Comp. Neurol., 370:11-22. Williams, R.W. and Rakic, P. (1988) Three dimensional counting: An accurate and direct method to estimate numbers of cells in sectioned material. J. Comp. Neurol., 278: 344-352. Williams, R.W., Strom, R.C., Rice, D.S. and Goldowitz, D. (1996) Genetic and environmental control of variation in retinal ganglion cell number in mice. J. Neurosci., 16: 7193-7205.
T. Sutula and A. Pitkanen (Eds.) Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135 © 2002 Published by Elsevier Science B.V.
CHAPTER 4
Design-based stereological methods for counting neurons M a r k J. W e s t * Department of Neurobiology, University of Aarhus, 8000 Arhus C, Denmark
Abstract: Recently developed stereological methods for counting neurons have a number of advantages over previously available stereological methods. These methods are most aptly referred to as 'design-based' because, in contrast to their predecessors, the probes and the sampling schemes that define the newer methods are 'designed', that is, defined a priori, in such a manner that one need not take into consideration the size, shape, orientation, and distribution of the objects to be counted. The elimination of the need for information about the geometry of the objects to be counted results in more robust data regarding estimates of total neuron number and neuronal loss because potential sources of systematic errors in the calculations are eliminated. In this article I will describe the salient features of the newer, design-based, methods and why they represent improvements over previously available methods.
Introduction A recent search of the electronic database maintained by the National Library of Medicine indicates that of the approximately 9000 articles dealing with the morphology of epilepsy, only 16 deal with morphometry or quantitative anatomy and only 3 papers in the last three years involve counting neurons. In view of the fact that neurons are the fundamental functional units of the nervous system and that neuron loss can be viewed as a robust measure of the cumulative damage to a region of the central nervous system, the question arises as to why this is so. It is the author's opinion that this state of affairs is the consequence of the confusion that has been generated by the manner and style of the first articles that described the new stereology and the somewhat uninformed debate that is presently going on in the literature between the advocates of the classic
* Correspondence to: M.J. West, Department of Neurobiology/Anatomy, University of Aarhus, 8000 Arhus C, Denmark. Tel.: +45-8942-3011; Fax: +45-8942-3060; E-maih
[email protected]
assumption-based counting techniques and those of newer design-based counting techniques. Here I will attempt to eliminate some of this confusion by describing the differences between the two approaches and explaining some of the unique features of the newer methods that lead to better data.
Assumption-based stereology Previously available stereological methods for counting, in large part, were based on modeled relationships between the number of objects embedded in a structure and the number of times two dimensional, sectional probes intercept objects of known size, shape, and orientation. At a theoretical level, model-based approaches are valid and have made valuable contributions to the field of stochastic geometry, the mother of stereology. In practice, however, these model-based approaches are more aptly referred to as 'assumption-based' methods because one often assumed, rather than determined or estimated, the size, shape, orientation, and distribution of the modeled objects. This was primarily because it was difficult and time consuming to actually determine the degree to which the 'model' parameters
44
Fig. 1. Low-power light micrographs of a silver-stained horizontal section through the brain of a mouse. The micrographs are taken from different parts of the CA3 pyramidal cell layer on the same section. Note that the profiles of the nuclei of the pyramidal cells appear to have different sizes and shapes, which reflect the different shape and orientation of the nuclei in different parts of the layer. Intraand inter-sectional differences in the size, shape, and orientation of the nuclei within the same structure make it difficult to determine or estimate the height, H, of objects and thereby make estimates with Eq. 1 that do not have a systematic error.
were accurate representations of the true values of the parameters in real structures. For example, it was often assumed that neurons or neuronal nuclei (a frequently used counting unit) were spheres. In many parts of the nervous system, particularly cortical structures, this is the exception rather than the rule (Fig. 1). The principle that underlies the most fundamental model-based approach for estimating the number of objects in a unit volume of tissue, Nv, is based on the relationship between the number of object profiles per unit area of the sections, QA, the mean height of the objects measured orthogonal to the sectioning plane, H, and the thickness of the sections, h (CruzOrive, 1997): Nv = Q A / ( H q-h)
(1)
H + h is the average number of times that a profile of an object can be identified in a section series. This is the basis of the methods described by Abercrombie (1946) and Konigsmark (1970). Note that this method requires either (1) a determination of H (the mean object height) from serial constructions, if H > h, or (2) a determination of H along the focal axis of a thick section, if H < h. In practice, an assumption about H has most often been used (hence the name 'assumption-based' methods) because of the difficulties encountered when
attempting to make determinations of this parameter (Cruz-Orive and Weibel, 1990). In Fig. 2, the mean height, H , of the objects orthogonal to the plane of sectioning, is approximately four section thicknesses (actually 3.94) and there are 326 sectional profiles. According to the formula presented above, Nv = Q A / ( H + h) = 326/5 (which is approximately 66). In this case the volume of the region containing the objects of interest, V(REF), would be the same as the volume sampled, i.e. the sum of the areas of all of the sections multiplied by the thickness of the sections, and the estimate of the total number of neurons is estN = Nv • V ( R E F ) , that is, 66 = 6 6 . 1 . Note, that with this approach, the accuracy of the determination is dependent upon the accuracy of the geometrical description of the objects, more specifically H. If an assumption about the H of the object is not accurate, the resulting determination of N will systematically deviate from the true number and, in a statistical sense, be biased. An error in measurement or false assumption about object H, comparable to one section thickness will in this case result in a 20% bias, that is estN will be 326/4 or 82 rather than 66. If one is determined to avoid making assumptions and actually make determinations of H , this should be done in each individual, in order to avoid assumptions.
45
A.
B. []
oR,
Borrn
m
,,,[], oPn
,nn, B
S=mqnB,,,n, B
96 SECTIONS C.
LOOKUP
D.
Fig. 2. Assumption-based and disector counting. (A) Representation of a green structure that contains 66 objects of different size, shape and orientation and that are unevenly distributed throughout the structure. The structure has been serially sectioned into 96 sections and is viewed orthogonal to the plane of sectioning. The number of objects can be determined by (1) counting the total number of sectional profiles that appear in the sections, 326, and dividing this number by the mean number of sectional profiles per object, 5, gives approximately 66 objects (indirect or assumption-based counting), or (2) counting the first profiles of the objects as they are encountered, that is the leading edges shown in yellow, as one proceeds sequentially through the series (design-based or disector counting). (B) A histogram in which the number of leading edges, small yellow squares, is plotted as a function of the position in the series where the first profile of an object appears when proceeding from left to right. Note that the distribution of objects is not even along the sectioning axis. (C) A disector composed of two sections, the red and blue sections shown in (A) after being rotated 90 degrees. The objects that have sectional profiles within these sections are shown in their entirety. Using the leading edge counting rule, three objects are counted in the red section. (D) An expanded view of the disector seen in (C) which shows the spatial positions of the sectional profiles. The red section is referred to as the 'sample section' and the blue as the 'lookup section'. There are sectional profiles of objects (yellow) in the sample section that do not have sectional profiles in the 'lookup' section. (With permission of Elsevier, from West, 1999.)
46
Design-based stereology The new stereological methods are not dependent upon the need for assumptions about the size, shape, and orientation o f the objects being counted. This is because of the use of a 3-D counting probe, the disector (Sterio, 1984), rather than a 2-D probe (i.e. the section) used in the previously available methods. Unlike the assumption-based approach described above, in which the numerical density, Nv, is derived from a model relationship between the number of object profiles counted on 2-D probes (i.e. sections), disector counting involves the direct counting of objects in a known volume of tissue. In its simplest form, a disector is c o m p o s e d of two sections: a ' s a m p l e section' and a 'lookup section' (Fig. 2C). The volume being probed by the disector is the product o f the area o f the ' s a m p l e section' and the distance between the two sections. The two requirements for proper use o f the disector probe are: (1) any object placed within the region o f interest must be able to be identified on at least one o f the sections that pass through the region, and (2) sectional profiles of the same object must be able to be identified. The disector counting rule is then: an object is considered to be in a disector probe when a sectional
A°
profile o f the object is apparent in the second section, the ' s a m p l e section', and not in the first, the 'lookup section', as one proceeds through the section series. In essence, what one is doing is directly counting the number o f leading edges 'tops' present in the volume defined by the disector. Regardless of the direction o f sectioning and the size, shape, and orientation of the objects, there will be only one leading edge for each object. In order to identify sectional profiles that belong to the same object, as in the case of branching objects, it may, however, be necessary to have access to additional sections that are between and adjacent to the disector pair. Although this method o f counting has been discovered and rediscovered over the centuries (Bendtsen and Nyengaard, 1989), a relatively recent development has made disector counting feasible in histological tissue in which the numbers of objects reaches thousands and millions. This is the unbiased areal counting frame o f Gundersen (1977) (Fig. 3), which enables one to perform unbiased sub-sampling of sections that have large numbers of sectional profiles of objects of interest. Accordingly, one samples, at random, an area of the test section with an unbiased areal counting frame. The profiles o f the objects that lie partially or entirely within the frame and do not intercept the forbidden line (i.e. a hyper-plane
B°
Fig. 3. Subsampling sections. (A) A physical disector consisting of two separate sections. The small blue square in the sample section (red) represents an unbiased 2-D counting frame that can be used to sample a limited area of the section. Profiles of objects that are either entirely within the frame or partially within the frame, but do not touch the green 'forbidden' line are sampled. (Not shown is the infinite extension of the forbidden line in both directions.) When disector counting rules are used, only one object is counted (yellow profile in upper left of frame. The volume of the disector is defined by the area of the counting frame and the thickness of the sample section. (B) A diagrammatic representation of an optical disector. In this case, the counting grid is superimposed on an image of a thin focal plane that is moved a known distance through a thick section. An object is counted if its leading edge comes into focus within the counting frame, as the latter is moved through the section. The volume of the disector is defined by the area of the counting frame and the extent of the movement of the frame through the thick section. In this example, only one object is counted. (With permission of Elsevier, from West, 1999.)
47 that divides the sampling field), are defined as the objects that are to be 'tested'. One then applies disector counting rules to the profiles sampled by the frame and the corresponding part of the 'lookup section'. If the sectional profile of an object, 'sampled' by the areal counting frame placed on the 'sample section', does not have a profile in the 'lookup section', it is defined as an object that should be counted in the volume defined by the disector. In this case, the latter is the product of the area of the counting frame and the distance between the corresponding surfaces of the two sections. A short time after the first descriptions of how disector counting rules could be applied to unbiased sub-samples of large sections, it became apparent that the sections used to define a disector need not be physically separate sections (Gundersen, 1986; Gundersen et al., 1988b). By adjusting the optics of the light microscope so that the depth of focus was minimized (i.e. opening the diaphragm of the sub-stage condenser lens), it was possible to apply disector counting rules to optical sections positioned within thick sections. It was also possible to increase the volume of the sample by increasing the number of consecutive optical sections, so that a virtual 'stack' of optical sections then defined the probe. This probe was subsequently referred to as an optical disector (West and Gundersen, 1990) and the original disector referred to as a physical disector in order to distinguish between the two. The volume of an optical disector probe is then, the product of the area of the unbiased areal counting frame and the distance between the corresponding surfaces of the upper and lower optical sections in the stack. Optical disector counting is performed by superimposing an unbiased areal counting frame on an image of an optical section and 'moving' the counting frame a known distance, through the thickness of the section, with the focus control of the microscope (Fig. 4). An object is considered to be in an optical disector if its top comes into focus within the unbiased counting frame, as one focuses through the section. Objects in focus at the uppermost focal level of the optical disector are not counted because this represents the 'look up section' of the first disector pair in the stack. They are counted at the bottom level, since this is the 'sample section' of the last disector in the stack. The optical disector probe has a number of advan-
tages over the physical disector probe when used at the light microscopic level. First and foremost, one's ability to find the corresponding parts of the sections that have to be compared, when applying the counting rules, is greatly simplified in that one only has to focus up and down to find the corresponding areas of the 'sample' and 'lookup' sections. This is a major problem when using physically separate sections that contain large numbers of profiles of the objects of interest. When using the optical disector probe it is also considerably easier to look at other 'sections' when attempting to determine whether or not profiles of objects at one level belong to the same object. Unfortunately, the optical disector concept cannot be used at the electron microscopic (EM) level (e.g. to count synapses). This is because the depth of focus of an electron image is very large (in the order of meters) and cannot be positioned or moved as a section within of an EM section.
Disector counting is not enough In order to obtain a truly unbiased estimate of total object number, it is not enough to just count the objects with disector probes, it is also important that the sections used in the analysis and the positions on those sections to be sampled with disectors be chosen in a statistically unbiased manner. In order to make this point clear, one should recall that there are two, basic, 'design-based' methods for making unbiased estimates of total object number, N, using optical disector probes (West, 1993). One is the 'two step' method which involves (a) making estimates of the numerical density of objects, Nv, from multiple samples made with optical disector probes, and (b) making estimates of the volume of the tissue in which they are found, V(REF), which can be readily and efficiently obtained by point counting (Gundersen et al., 1988a). According to the first method, Nv. V(REF)= N. This method was unfortunately referred to earlier in the literature as the optical disector. To avoid confusion with the optical disector probe, it is now recommended that it be referred to as either the 'two step' method or the ' N V • V(REF)' method. The other of the two methods is the 'optical fractionator' method (West et al., 1991), with which one counts, also with optical disector probes, the number of objects, ~ Q - , in a known
48
49 fraction, f , of the volume of the structure of interest (Fig. 5). In this case, ~ Q - x ( I / f ) = N. The proper implementation of optical disector probes with both of these methods involves unbiased sampling at two additional levels of the sampling scheme. To make an unbiased estimate of total cell number (i.e. an estimate obtained with a method that on average gives the true number) with either method, there must be a random selection of (1) the sections used in the analysis and (2) the positions on those sections that are sampled with the optical disectors (Fig. 5). If this is not done at both levels, there are constraints with regard to the conclusions that can be drawn from the resulting estimate. For example if one uses a 'standardized' section (Hyman et al., 1998) or a set of sections taken from one end of the region of interest to make counts, the estimate can only be considered to be representative of the entire region when, and only when (1) the Nv estimated in that section is the same as the ratio of the total number of neurons to the reference volume, i.e. NCroT~/V(REF),and (2) the reference volumes, V~REF), are the same in all individuals. The same will be the case if one only samples on one edge or side of the sectional profiles of the region of interest. Without a priori knowledge about NCroTI/V(REV),this approach would also fall into the category of 'assumptionbased' methods because the validity of the resulting data is dependent upon the validity of the assumption about Nv stated above and the assumption that the reference volumes are the same in all individuals in the study. In the biological world, assumptions of this type are generally weak and must be addressed openly in the discussion of any data of this type.
The potential biases inherent in the assumptionbased sampling scheme described above can be eliminated by designing the selection and sampling of sections in such a manner that one does not have to make assumptions about the distribution of the objects of interest. As already alluded to above, the assumption about Nv being the same as the ratio N(TOT)/V(REF)can be eliminated if the sections and the positions within the sections sampled by disectors are randomly sampled (Miles and Davy, 1976). That is, one uses a method of selecting (1) the sections from all of the sections that pass through the region of interest, and (2) the positions within the sections so that all parts of the region of interest (i.e. along all three spatial axes) have equal probabilities of being sampled. The random selection and sampling procedures can be either independent random or systematic random. Systematic random is preferred because in general it is more efficient and more readily applied to histological preparations because they are cut along one axis (Cruz-Orive, 1993; Gundersen et al., 1999). Fig. 5 depicts the application of such a sampling scheme. An example of a scheme for the unbiased sampling of structures that can only be identified at the electron microscopic level (e.g. synapses) can be found in Geinisman et al. (1996).
Summary Data from design-based stereological methods for estimating total neuron number are free from potential biases related to inaccuracies in the geometrical description of the objects being counted. This is
Fig. 4. An optical disector. A stack of optical sections through the granule cell layer, of the dentate gyrus of the human hippocampus, used to make an estimate of the numerical density Nv of granule cells with the optical disector technique. An unbiased counting frame of known area (0.02 m m x 0.02 mm) is superimposed on an optical section obtained with a high numerical aperture oil immersion objective. Each optical section (A-L) is separated by 0.002 ram. Starting with the first lookup section, (A), the nuclei sampled by the frame are counted as one proceeds to focus through a known distance of the section thickness. (In this example nuclei, rather than cell bodies are counted because it is easier and because there is only one nucleus per granule cell.) The profiles of nuclei within the frame or in contact with the thin lines of the frame are considered to be inside the counting frame. Those touching the thick forbidden line are defined as being outside the frame. The two nuclei in focus at the top level of the optical disector, level (A) (black arrows are not counted because they do not come into focus and one proceeds to focus through the section. That is, the top of the disector is also a forbidden line. This point is emphasized by omitting the counting frame from this level. In this optical disector, four nuclei are counted (white arrow heads). Other nuclei that come into focus within the field, but are not sampled by the optical disector, are shown in black. Note that the bottom level of the optical disector is (K). Profiles at this level are sampled, unlike those at level (A). Level (L) has only been included to resolve ambiguities that may arise with branched objects (seldom the case with convex structures such as nuclei) and is not used for counting. (With permission of Wiley-Liss, from West and Gundersen, 1990.)
50
/ a(frame)
l//Ill
L-. ',,l
kkXl
a I It
I I ./I
/ I //,~
I / / ~1
/11
'
I"£N
'\
\ t
,q
P P f~l,~l
~,
P ~ II 1// r ~Y'' '
'
IIIII)kk
7
~d~
1 / /
I'Ll
I I
t \
I t / l ' l
11 \ \
lilly
/
-
a(step)
tll I111
111 I I I I
C
b
Fig. 5. A diagrammatic representation of the optical fractionator sampling scheme for estimating total number of neurons expressing somato-statin mRNA in the striatum of the rat. (a) A systematic random sample of 10-13 sections that span the entire length of the striatum are selected for analysis. The sections are selected at equal intervals, i.e. every nth section after a random start within the first interval, to ensure that all parts of the striatum have equal probabilities of being in the sample. The selected sections therefore constitute a known fraction of the sections in the series, the section sampling fraction (ssf). (b) The labeled neurons are counted under a known fraction of the section area, the area sampling fraction (asf). This fraction corresponds to the ratio of the area of the disector counting frame, a(frame) (shown here as small black rectangles), to the area associated with each step movement of the slide, a(step) (shown here as large white rectangles); asf = a(step)/a(frame). (c) The neurons are counted in optical disectors positioned in the central part of the section thickness. The height of the optical disector, h, constitutes a known fraction of the section thickness, t. The ratio h/t is the thickness sampling fraction (tsf). The area of the counting frame, a(frame), is shaded. After systematically sampling at all levels, one has directly counted the number of neurons Y~ Q - in a known fraction of the region of interest without having to make assumptions about the size, shape and orientation of the objects. The sum of the number of neurons in the disectors, Y~.Q - , times the product of the inverse of the fractions, constitutes an unbiased estimate of the total number of labeled neurons in the striatum, estN = ~ Q - • l/ssf. 1/asf. t/h Note that the volume of the structure and the numerical density are never estimated. (With permission of Wiley-Liss, from West et al., 1996.) b e c a u s e 3 - D p r o b e s a r e u s e d to d i r e c t l y c o u n t t h e n u m b e r o f o b j e c t ' t o p s ' in a k n o w n v o l u m e o f t i s s u e . The tops are zero-dimensional and therefore their
n u m b e r is n o t a f f e c t e d b y t h e g e o m e t r y o f t h e o b jects. Equally important, the probes are distributed in a r a n d o m
manner
throughout
the three dimen-
sions of the region of interest, so that all neurons in the region of interest have an equal probability of being sampled, and assumptions about the distribution of the objects (which also have the potential for leading to biases) need not be made. An appreciation of the differences between the recently developed 'design-based' methods and previously available 'assumption-based' methods can help the investigator of structural dynamics to understand why the newer 'designed-based' stereological methods provide more robust and useful data. The practical aspects of the application of these methods have been described by West (1993). References Abercrombie, M. (1946) Estimation of nuclear population from microtome sections. Anat. Rec., 94: 239-247. Bendtsen, T.E and Nyengaard, J.R. (1989) Unbiased estimation of particle number using sections - - an historical perspective with special reference to the stereology of glomeruli. J. Microsc., 153: 93-102. Cruz-Orive, L.M. (1993) Systematic sampling in stereology. Bull. Int. Stat. Inst., 55: 451-468. Cruz-Orive, L.M. (1997) Stereology of single objects. J. Microsc., 186: 93-107. Cruz-Orive, L.M. and Weibel, E.R. (1990) Recent stereological methods for cell biology: a brief survey. Am, J. Physiol., 258 (Lung Cell. Mol. Physiol., 2): LI48-L156. Geinisman, Y., Gundersen, H.J.G. and West, M.J. (1996) Unbiased stereological estimation of the total number of synapses in a brain region. J. Neurocytol., 25: 805-819. Gundersen, H.J.G. (1977) Notes on the estimation of the numerical density of arbitrary particles: the edge effect. J. Microsc., 1 I1: 219-233. Gundersen, H.J.G. (1986) Stereology of arbitrary particles. A review of unbiased number and size estimators and the presentation of some new ones, in memory of William R. Thompsen. J. Microsc., 143: 3-45.
Gundersen, H.J.G., et al. (1988a) Some new, simple, and efficient stereological methods and their use in pathological research and diagnosis. APMIS, 96: 379-394. Gundersen, H.J.G., et al. (1988b) The new stereological tools: disector, fractionator, nucleator, and point sampled intercepts and their use in pathological research and diagnosis. APMIS, 96: 857-881. Gundersen, H.J.G., Jensen, E.B., Kieu, K. and Nielsen, J. (1999) The efficiency of systematic sampling in stereology - reconsidered. J. Microsc., 193: 199-211. Hyman, B.T., Gomez-Isla, T. and Irizarry, M.C. (1998) Stereology: a practical primer for neuropathology. J. NeuropathoL Exp. Neurol., 57: 305-310. Konigsmark, B.W. (1970) Methods for the counting of neurons. In: W.H.J. Nauta and S.O.E. Ebbesson (Eds.), Contemporary Research Methods in Neuroanatomy. Springer, New York, NY, pp. 315-340. Miles, R.E. and Davy, EJ. (1976) Precise and general conditions for the validity of a comprehensive set of stereological fundamental formulae. J. Microsc., 107:211-226. Sterio, D.C. (1984) The unbiased estimation of number and size of arbitrary particles using the disector. J. Microsc., 134: 127136. West, M.J. (1993) New stereological methods for counting neurons. Neurobiol. Aging, 14: 275-285. West, M.J. (1999) Stereological methods for estimating the total number of neurons and synapses: issues of precision and bias. Trends" Neurosci., 22:51-61. West, M.J. and Gundersen, H.J.G. (1990) Unbiased stereological estimation of the number of neurons in the human hippocampus. J. Comp. Neurol., 296: 1-22. West, M.J., Slomianka, L. and Gundersen, H.J.G. (1991) Unbiased stereological estimation of the total number of neurons in the subdivisions of the rat hippocampus using the optical fractionator. Anat. Rec., 231: 482-497. West, M.J., Ostergaard, K., Andreassen, O. and Finsen, B. (1996) Estimation of the number of somatostatin neurons in the striatum: an in situ study using the optical fractionator. J. Comp. Neurol., 370:11-22.
T. Sutula and A. Pitk~inen (Eds.) Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135 © 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
CHAPTER 5
The course of cellular alterations associated with the development of spontaneous seizures after status epilepticus F. Edward Dudek 1,,, Jennifer L. Hellier 2, Philip A. Williams Kevin J. Staley 2
1 Damien
J. Ferraro 1 and
1 Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA 2 Department of Neurology, University of Colorado Health Science Center, Denver, CO 80262, USA
Abstract: Chronic epilepsy, as a consequence of status epilepticus, has been studied in animal models in order to analyze the cellular mechanisms responsible for the subsequent occurrence of spontaneous seizures. Status epilepticus, induced by either kainic acid or pilocarpine or by prolonged electrical stimulation, causes a characteristic pattern of neuronal death in the hippocampus, which is followed - - after an apparent latent period - - by the development of chronic, recurrent, spontaneous seizures. The question most relevant to this conference is the degree to which the subsequent chronic seizures contribute further to epileptogenesis and brain damage. This article addresses the temporal and anatomical parameters that must be understood in order to address this question. (1) How does one evaluate experimentally whether the chronic epileptic seizures that follow status epilepticus contribute to epileptogenesis and lead to brain damage? To answer this question, we must first know the time course of the development of the chronic epileptic seizures, and whether the interval between subsequent individual chronic seizures is a relevant factor. (2) What anatomical parameters are most relevant to the progression of epilepsy? For instance, how does loss of inhibitory intemeurons potentially influence seizure generation and the progressive development of epileptogenesis? Does axon sprouting and formation of new synaptic connections represent a form of seizure-induced brain damage? These specific issues bear directly on the general question of whether seizures damage the brain during the chronic epilepsy that follows status epilepticus.
Introduction Considerable research at the molecular and cellular levels has been conducted on the mechanisms of epileptogenesis, but most of this work has focused on hypothetical changes thought to be important for the development of spontaneous seizures (e.g., Dudek et al., 1994; McNamara, 1994, 1999; Dudek and Spitz,
* Correspondence to: EE. Dudek, Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA. Tel.: +1-970-491-2942; Fax: +1-970-491-2623; E-mail:
[email protected]
1997). Experimental status epilepticus (SE) is known to induce death o f susceptible neurons, and to lead to the development of chronic epilepsy (e.g., BenAft, 1985 and Nadler, 1991 for kainic acid-induced SE). However, relatively little is known about how the subsequent seizures associated with the chronic epileptic state, which follows SE after an apparent latent period, further affect the brain. The present article will focus primarily on recent work from our group concerning progressive changes in the dentate gyrus after kainate-induced SE. We will consider the SE-induced loss of hilar neurons, and the issue of whether the chronic seizures contribute to further neurodegeneration in the hippocampus. Data on
54 the time course of mossy fiber sprouting and the formation of local excitatory circuits will be considered in relation to the evolution of epilepsy in the kainate-treated rat. The dentate gyrus, aside from its importance for hippocampal function, is considered a model for studying changes that could occur in the other parts of the temporal lobe. Neuronal loss in the hilus and this form of synaptic reorganization in the dentate gyrus have been well documented in human tissue from patients undergoing surgical treatment for intractable epilepsy (e.g., de Lanerolle et al., 1989; Sutula et al., 1989; Houser et al., 1990; Babb et al., 1991). Several technical and conceptual issues relevant to whether chronic seizures contribute to epileptogenesis and damage the brain, at least after experimental SE, will be discussed. Induction of status epilepticus (SE) Several experimental treatments have been used to induce SE, and they can generally be divided into two types: injection of chemotoxins and electrical stimulation. Kainic acid (i.e., kainate; Ben-Ari, 1985; Nadler, 1991) and pilocarpine (Turski et al., 1983) are the two primary chemotoxins that have been used to induce SE. The electrical stimulation protocols involve prolonged, repetitive stimulation of the perforant path, hippocampus, or other limbic structures (e.g., Lothman et al., 1990). In both types of models, repetitive seizures are induced for hours, and they likely cause widespread brain damage. Although these models (and their variants) probably have some significant differences, they have many similarities. In the hippocampus, SE causes loss of neurons in the hilus and in the CA3 and CA1 areas, but other regions of the hippocampus and brain are also clearly affected. Many physiological (e.g., receptors) and structural (e.g., dendrites and axons) alterations, which probably occur with different time courses, follow the SE-induced death of susceptible neurons. Seizures are thought to occur after a latent period of days, weeks or months (e.g., see Hellier et al., 1998, 1999, for kainate-treated rat). The time course of chronic seizures after SE Several studies have reported that chronic SEinduced motor seizures begin to occur after a latent
period, although only a few studies have provided quantitative data (see Stafstrom et al., 1992 and Hellier et al., 1998). We have analyzed this question with direct observation (approximately 6 h/week) and 24 h video monitoring of motor seizures (Racine, 1972). With 6 h/week monitoring, the latent period appeared to be an average of 2-3 months, and there was considerable variability across animals (Hellier et al., 1998). This approach has the limitation that one is monitoring the animals only about 5% of the time. As expected, a different but complementary picture was obtained with 24 h video monitoring (Hellier et al., 1999). In this study, 81% of 26 kainate-treated rats did not have any motor seizures in the first week after kainate treatment (Fig. 1). With this treatment protocol, virtually all kainate-treated rats develop epilepsy (Hellier et al., 1998), and most of these particular rats were later observed to have had one or more motor seizures with 6 h/week monitoring. Of the 19% (i.e., five rats) of the kainate-treated rats that had one or more seizures during the first week after treatment, two of the five rats had one or two motor seizures that occurred only 1 or 2 days after the SE. Two rats had no seizures until day 7, and then had either one or two seizures. One rat, however, had several motor seizures over a 3-day period, 5 - 7 days after the treatment. Our interpretation is that the two rats that had motor seizures within the first 2 days after SE, but no motor seizures for the next several days, had not become epileptic; instead, they had seizures that were an extension of the SE. Based on the criterion that epilepsy is defined as the condition of having had two or more unprovoked seizures, only two of the twenty-six animals became epileptic within the first week after treatment, and their motor seizures began on days 5 and 7 after kainate-induced SE. Thus, the latent period for motor seizures in most kainate-treated rats, using this protocol, is at least 1 week. These data are similar to the results of Stafstrom et al. (1992). Another issue relevant to the concept of progressive changes in epileptogenesis relates to the question of whether seizure frequency increases with time after SE. It is generally believed that many people with temporal lobe epilepsy, although not all of them, have a progressive worsening of their condition. We, therefore, asked whether the frequency of motor seizures increases with time after SE (Hellier
55 100
A
8O "o (1)
60
40
o
"E (13
//
20
Q.
0
No seizures
> 1 seizure
u) ..~ o
B
'-9 O
E
.--
0 "J
z
6 Days after kainate treatment
o
.Q E Z
oJ
i
, 0
B
----
I
I
I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Days alter kainate treatment Fig. 1. Analysis of motor seizures during the first week after kainate-induced status epilepticus. (A) With continuous 24 h video monitoring during the first week after kainate treatment, 81% of the rats had no spontaneous motor seizures, but the other 19% were observed to have > 1 motor seizure. (B and C) Number of spontaneous motor seizures per day as a function of time after kainate treatment. Of the five rats that had motor seizures during the first week after treatment, two experienced seizures within the first 27 h, but had no subsequent seizures during the remainder of the first week. The other three rats had their first motor seizure at 5-7 days after kainate treatment. (Reproduced from Hellier et al., 1999 with permission.)
56
~ 0.8
0@
o
A
0.8
t-" (/)
"O
1~20
~0.60.6
~
N~12
1~35
0.2
1
(D
Plus sign represents animals used for analysis
~ 0.2D"
N~471~47
23 N
0.4-
(,9
N-~47
0.0
P
.~1',4
N~47
0.4 ~
N~36
09
23 N
C
B
O
I
I
I
I
I
I
2
3
4
5
6
7
~
~4z 0.0
23 N
Months after kainate treatment
0
(/3
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Months after onset of seizures
to 0.6
0.8
C 0.5 ~0.6
D
t--
C
~
"~ o.4 N
0.4
-N
0.3
N~23
t
8'0.2
N
~
in Figure 3D.
C 03
O.2
,,$.-
0.0 0
I
I
I
I
25
50
75
100
Duration of epileptic period (%)
,~ o.o ._N 0 03
6O
tAsterisk represents significant difference (P<0.05) from the first month after onset of seizures.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Months after onset of seizures
Fig. 2. Seizure frequency as a function of time after kainate treatment. These data are based on a population of 47 kainate-treated rats that had at least one seizure every 30 days after their initial seizure, and that were euthanized >4 months after kainate treatment. (A) Graph of seizure frequency for all 47 rats. At later periods, fewer kainate-treated rats were available for the analysis, because they were either used for experiments or died. (B) In this graph, seizure frequency is assessed as a function of time after the onset of seizures to compensate for the different latent periods. (C) Seizure frequency as a percent of the duration of the total epileptic period. The epileptic period was defined as the number of weeks between the onset of chronic seizures and death of the animal. These data compensate for the effect of preferentially using animals with a high seizure frequency for electrophysiological experiments and for the observation that those animals that had a high seizure frequency were more susceptible to death. (D) Analysis of seizure frequency as a function of time for seven rats that were analyzed for 4-8 months. The seizure frequency at 4-8 months was significantly higher compared to 1 month (note asterisks). (Reproduced with permission from Hellier et al., 1998.)
et al., 1998). Fig. 2 shows the results of an analysis of motor seizure frequency as a function of time after SE. The data indicate that initially the seizures occur at a low rate, and then increase in frequency
over the next several months. On average, seizure frequency reaches an apparent maximum at approximately one seizure every 2 h (0.5 seizures/h). These data, and those of Stafstrom et al. (1992), support the
57 hypothesis that the epileptic state worsens for most animals. Furthermore, the motor seizures can occur nearly every hour, at least under some conditions in some animals, although this requires several months to develop. The data in Fig. 1, and described above, emphasize the difficulty assessing the actual latent period. Our experience suggests that analyses based on seizure frequency are more practical than assessments of the latent period, and are potentially a more accurate approach to assessing the progressive nature of the epileptogenesis in SE-based models. SE causes neuronal death presumably because repetitive seizures occur at a high rate, and several seizures precede each subsequent seizure by a relatively short time period (i.e., minutes). Does the amount of time between seizures (i.e., the interseizure interval) during chronic epilepsy contribute to the likelihood that a seizure will cause neuronal damage? The initial chronic motor seizures that occur shortly after SE are usually quite infrequent in experimental animals, but after several weeks and months, motor seizures can be observed every hour or two. When chronic seizures occur nearly every hour, are they more likely to be deleterious? With intervals as short as an hour, it seems likely that brain recovery systems are inadequate, so that an additive effect of successive chronic seizures may be present in a manner reminiscent to what occurs during SE. A continuum between infrequent seizures, clusters of seizures over several hours with short inter-seizure intervals, and actual SE could hypothetically exist. This possibility emphasizes the need for quantitative analysis of seizure frequency as a variable when considering this question, since the frequency of spontaneous seizures during chronic epilepsy may occasionally come relatively close to the seizure frequency that occurs during SE (i.e., one per hour versus several per hour). Because seizure frequency increases for at least several months after kainate-induced SE, this may be a highly vulnerable time period in the post-SE models of temporal lobe epilepsy.
Anatomical changes after SE: neuronal death The issue of how one measures neuronal death is a fundamental and long-standing problem for the field of epilepsy research. We have chosen to analyze
this issue using neuron counting with stereological methods (e.g., West and Gundersen, 1990; West et al., 1991). In our initial analysis of kainate-treated rats (Buckmaster and Dudek, 1997), we assessed neuronal loss in the hilus of the dentate gyms along the septal-temporal axis using cresyl violet and immunocytochemically stained tissue. We found that about 52% of the hilar neurons in rats with kainateinduced epilepsy (i.e., several months after treatment) were lost compared to saline-treated controls, and that neuronal loss occurred predominantly at the temporal end of the hippocampus. In a subsequent study (Hellier et al., 1999), we analyzed the number of neurons with similar although not identical methods at 1 week after kainate treatment (Fig. 3). The estimated loss of hilar neurons 1 week after kainate treatment was about 35% relative to the controis, also with a preferential loss at the temporal end of the hippocampus. If chronic seizures did kill neurons, one would expect more neuronal loss in the chronically epileptic rats than in rats evaluated 1 week after SE. The apparent loss of hilar neurons was greater (i.e., 52% compared to 35%) in the rats with kainate-induced epilepsy compared to rats 1 week after treatment (i.e., before most rats have chronic motor seizures). For the group studied many weeks after SE, chronic seizures had been occurring for a considerable period of time, and presumably at a high frequency for many of them. Although we did find fewer neurons in the hilus of the rats with kainate-induced epilepsy compared to kainateinjected rats 1 week after treatment, this is a post hoc comparison and an actual quantitative analysis would be inappropriate. First, different investigators conducted the studies, and differences in neuronal counting could have been a source of variance. Second, the animals were prepared at different times, and thus were not appropriately matched. Therefore, although similar stereological analyses were used in these two studies (i.e., Buckmaster and Dudek, 1997 versus Hellier et al., 1999), and the animal model was virtually identical, it is not possible to make firm conclusions from a direct comparison of these two data sets. Furthermore, even if a difference in the two experimental groups were found, it would not be possible to conclude that the chronic seizures caused the loss of neurons. In the long term, it would also seem necessary to use an experimental design that
58 U) t-
2 cO
E
"m c-
400
septal middle temporal Portion of the septotemporal axis
versus after SE and chronic seizures). Furthermore, the neurons that are lost after SE would be expected to be those most susceptible to chronic seizures. These two general issues represent major potential problems in regard to using SE-based models of experimental epilepsy to determine whether chronic seizures damage the brain. Experiments that aim to mark damaged neurons destined to die (e.g., TUNNEL stain) necessarily assume that these neurons will die, and when applied to the SE-based models, still have the limitations and caveats summarized above.
B
Anatomical changes after SE: mossy fiber sprouting
A
-~--~a[in~e, / ~
300 200 100
t-6}
0
3.0 o
2.5
E E
2.0
O 0~
-,-saline -o-kainate
iv. 1.5 m 1.0 ¢-
0.5
0.0
0
O--------------~
septal middle temporal Portion of the septotemporal axis
Fig. 3. Distribution of hilar neurons and Timm stain in the inner molecular layer as a function of position along the septaltemporal axis for saline- and kainate-treated rats. (A) The salinetreated rats had more neurons at the temporal end (100% septotemporal distance), compared to the septal end (0%). All three regions of the hippocampus had fewer neurons in kainate-treated rats. (B) The difference in Timm score for kainate- and salinetreated rats was small but significant along the full extent of the hippocampus. (Reproduced with permission from Hellier et al.,
1999.)
first blocks the chronic seizures after SE for an appropriate period, and then assesses neuronal damage relative to a group with unblocked chronic seizures. Additional technical and conceptual problems exist in this type of experiment, and these issues should be considered in future work. The number and proportion of neurons damaged or killed after SE can be large and variable. In this type of experiment, this variability will be an important source of error in a quantitative comparison of the two experimental groups (i.e., after SE but before chronic seizures
Several laboratories have reported that Timm stain in the inner molecular layer increases with time after SE and during kindling (e.g., Mathern et al., 1992, 1993; Cavazos et al., 1994). We have analyzed both the histological and electrophysiological changes that occur in the dentate gyrus as a function of time after SE (Wuarin and Dudek, 2001). A semi-quantitative analysis of mossy fiber sprouting (i.e., scores ranging from 0 to 3) was based on the intensity and area of Timm stain in the inner molecular layer (see Tauck and Nadler, 1985). We found that mossy fiber sprouting clearly began to occur within the first week or two after kainate treatment. It had progressed substantially by 2-4 weeks, and had become extremely robust 10-51 weeks after treatment (Fig. 4), when virtually all of the animals were displaying spontaneous motor seizures. Using whole-cell recording from dentate granule cells in hippocampal slices from kainatetreated rats, we found that the frequency and amplitude of spontaneous EPSCs increased in parallel with the Timm stain in the inner molecular layer. Furthermore, with flash photolysis of caged glutamate to stimulate relatively small regions of the dentate granule-cell layer, we found that hippocampal slices from kainate-treated rats with mossy fiber sprouting showed EPSCs to focal stimulation of granule cells (Fig. 5; see also Molnar and Nadler, 1999). The number of granule cells that received excitatory input from nearby granule cells increased progressively as a function of time after kainateinduced SE (Fig. 6). Only 1 of 52 controls showed
59
KA-treated
Controls 100
n=441 7 rats
n = 519 8 rats
n = 395 7 rats
n = 678
n = 783
n = 832
1K r=f¢
1~ r~f~
14 r~fe
10
~mm staining rading scale rauck and Nadler, • Neurosci., 5, 1985)
80 i
09
i 60.
i = 3
t-
0 = 2 ~ = 1
09 09 a.
40.
C--] = 0
!
20.
i
! !
0"
1-2
2-4
i
!
I
17-72
1-2
2-4
10-51
Time after treatment (weeks) Fig. 4. Analysis of Timm staining score as a function of time after kainate treatment. Hippocampal sections from kainate-treated rats used in electrophysiological experiments (see below) were analyzed with the Timm stain after saline or kainate treatment. The Timm score was significantly greater in kainate-treated rats and showed a progressive increase as a function of time after kainate treatment• All assessments were done with blind procedures, and the number of sections and rats is shown above each bar. (Reproduced with permission from Wuarin and Dudek, 2001 .)
a similar response (Fig. 6). These data indicate that excitatory connections from granule cells to other granule cells increase in density as a function of time after SE. Previous studies from our group and others (e.g., Cronin et al., 1992; Wuarin and Dudek, 1996, 2001; Patrylo and Dudek, 1998; Hardison et al., 2000; Lynch and Sutula, 2000) showed that epileptiform bursts could be evoked in the isolated dentate gyms after robust mossy fiber sprouting had occurred, months after kainate- or pilocarpine-induced SE, if inhibition was depressed and/or extracellular potassium was elevated slightly. Similar observations have been made in slices of human hippocampus with mossy fiber sprouting from patients with intractable epilepsy (Franck et al., 1995). Activation of a small population of granule cells (using focal photolysis of caged glutamate) evoked network bursts when slices were treated with bicuculline and high extracellular potassium, but only in preparations with
robust sprouting several months after kainate treatment (Fig. 7). Burst discharges were not evoked at earlier time periods with less Timm stain in the inner molecular layer. These data indicate that a progressive increase in local excitatory circuits occurs in the dentate gyrus after SE. As the density of axon sprouting increases with more time after SE, the dentate gyms progressively becomes more capable of generating epileptiform bursts when granule cells are activated after inhibition is depressed and potassium is elevated. These data and others indicate that SE and the consequent neuronal death are followed by a progressive increase in seizure frequency after an apparent latent period. In the dentate gyms, which serves as an experimental model, an increase in neuronal death in the hilus may occur as a function of the chronic seizures, but data from our group are not definitive on this point. A profound in-
60
A
3
B
lO
C
15
Fig. 5. Photoactivationof caged glutamate in the dentate granule-cell layer evoked repetitive EPSCs in granule cells from kainate-treated rats with mossy fiber sprouting. Whole-cell recording at resting membrane potential from a granule cell in the outer blade from a rat 39 weeks after kainate treatment. Repetitive photostimulations(0.05 Hz) were given at one site in the granule-cell layer, 600 txm from the recorded cell. The numbers in each trace indicate the stimulation number, and the traces are continuous in A-C. The top trace in each panel shows baseline activity.The arrows indicate the stimulus artifact from the flash. The bottom trace in C is an expansion of the time period marked by the dashed lines. (Reproduced with permissionfrom Wuarin and Dudek, 2001.)
crease in mossy fiber axons in the inner molecular layer is, however, observed during the months after SE. Several laboratories have provided evidence that this increase in mossy fiber sprouting is also associated with the development of local excitatory circuits (e.g., Cronin et al., 1992; Wuarin and Dudek, 1996, 2001; Molnar and Nadler, 1999; Lynch and Sutula, 2000), and possibly also an increase in lo-
cal inhibitory circuits (Cronin et al., 1992; Sloviter, 1992; Buhl et al., 1996). Ultrastructural observations support these electrophysiological data (Kotti et al., 1997; Zhang and Houser, 1999; Wenzel et al., 2000). Local inhibitory circuits are known to mask the effects of local excitatory circuits (Miles and Wong, 1987; Christian and Dudek, 1988), and when inhibition is intact, the responses of the granule cells
61 100
¢q ID O tt~ t_ O O~
90
•
KA-treatedrats
80
[]
Saline-injected
controls 66% (n = 32)
70 60 50 40
¢Q~
30
Q}
13-
20
10% (n = 29)
10 0
0%
0% (n = 18) 1-2
(n = 17)
2-4
10-51 (kainate) 17-72 (saline)
Time after treatment (weeks) Fig. 6. Plot of the percentage of granule cells responding to photoactivation of caged glutamate with an increase in EPSCs as a function of time after treatment for saline- and kainate-injected rats. For each group, the number of tested cells is indicated above the bar. (Reproduced with permission from Wuarin and Dudek, 200l.)
are either similar to those in the normal dentate gyrus or slightly hyperexcitable (e.g., see Patrylo et al., 1999). Thus, the granule-cell network establishes new forms of connectivity after the loss of approximately half of the neurons in the hilus, but inhibitory circuits tend to mask the new excitatory interconnections. Although we cannot determine from our data whether neuronal loss occurred over time, the progressive nature of the axon sprouting and synaptic reorganization is well established. Anatomical changes after SE: loss of inhibitory interneurons When considering neuronal damage, it is obvious that one has to give particular consideration to the loss of inhibitory interneurons versus principal neurons. Loss of GABAergic interneurons themselves is likely to cause hyperexcitability and seizures in many cortical areas. Several studies have been con-
ducted on dentate granule cells using hippocampal slices in vitro, which have had the excitatory inputs from the entorhinal cortex removed. In these studies, blockade of GABAA-receptor-mediated inhibition and/or elevation of extracellular potassium in control animals has minimal effect or may lead to mild hyperexcitability in response to perforant-path stimulation (Wuarin and Dudek, 1996, 2001; Patrylo et al., 1999; Hardison et al., 2000; Lynch and Sutula, 2000). These experimental conditions, however, do not lead to network bursts from hilar stimulation or focal activation of granule cells with caged glutamate in slices from control animals. On the other hand, as summarized above, after robust mossy fiber sprouting has occurred following experimental SE, pronounced burst discharges have been evoked when GABAA-receptor-mediated inhibition was depressed and/or the concentration of extracellular potassium was raised. Therefore, loss of inhibitory interneurons could have a much more profound effect on the func-
62
t
t 50 mV
500 ms
~.__ ~___. ~_.., ..
t
® Fig. 7. Photoactivation of caged glutamate in the granule-cell layer in the presence of 30 IxM bicuculline and 6 mM extracellular potassium. Photoactivation of caged glutamate in the granule-cell layer evoked epileptiform bursts of action potentials at numerous locations throughout the dentate gyrus when the flash was localized to the granule-cell layer (but not the hilus). The patch pipette indicates the position of the recorded cell in the outer blade of the dentate gyms. Each number shows the location of the photostimulation in the diagram and the correspondingbursts of action potentials. The recording was conducted in current-clampconfigurationat resting potential (-71 mV), and the rat had been treated 33 weeks previously with kainate. The arrowheads indicate the stimulus artifact from the flash. (Reproduced with permission from Wuarin and Dudek, 2001.)
tion of the granule-cell network when new recurrent excitatory circuits are present than when they are not. Several studies have provided evidence for neurodegeneration, axon sprouting and formation of new recurrent excitatory circuits in the CA1 area of the hippocampus after treatments that induce SE (Nadler et al., 1980; Meier and Dudek, 1996; Perez et al., 1996; Esclapez et al., 1999; Smith and Dudek, 2001). Thus, the formation of new recurrent excitatory cir-
cuits could be a widespread p h e n o m e n o n that occurs in many cortical areas under a variety of epileptogenic conditions. Frequent seizures (i.e., during SE or even during chronic epilepsy) could damage or kill some interneurons, and thus not only increase overall excitability, but also u n m a s k new recurrent excitatory circuits. These two mechanisms would be expected to have a combined effect to increase seizure susceptibility, and would lead to a progres-
63
sive worsening of the epilepsy. Gorter et al. (2001) found that rats with a progressive, post-SE increase in the frequency of spontaneous seizures had both extensive loss of parvalbumin- and somatostatinimmunoreactive neurons and also robust T i m m stain in the inner molecular layer compared to rats without a progressive increase in the frequency of spontaneous chronic seizures, which had less of these histopathological markers. The c o m b i n e d loss of inhibitory interneurons and the formation of new recurrent excitatory circuits would potentially have a positive-feedback effect to promote epileptogenesis.
Conclusions Several technical and conceptual issues are relevant to evaluating whether the chronic seizures that develop after SE damage the brain. Because SE itself causes significant and variable neuronal death, an evaluation of subsequent injury attributable only to the chronic seizures is problematic. Neuronal counts, even with an appropriate experimental design, will be a difficult but important approach for assessing whether the post-SE chronic seizures damage the brain. If neuronal injury does result from the chronic seizures, presumably it will become more of a problem as seizure frequency increases weeks and months after SE. Although it has not been clear in our studies whether there is a gradual seizuredependent decline (i.e., independent of prior SE) in the number of neurons, progressive and profound synaptic reorganization occurs in animals and humans for months after SE. This synaptic reorganization signifies, at least partially, the formation of new recurrent excitatory circuits, which are masked in some areas (e.g., the dentate gyms) by strong inhibitory circuits. Loss of inhibitory interneurons, either during or after the injury, would tend to unmask abnormal recurrent excitatory circuits and other potential epileptogenic mechanisms (e.g., upregulated N M D A receptors). Progressive loss of inhibitory interneurons would be expected to augment the electrophysiological effects of new excitatory local circuits. These abnormal circuits would presumably contribute to cognitive deficits that can occur in animal models (Stafstrom et al., 1993) and some people with epilepsy. These issues and concerns are
likely to be important to an analysis of whether seizures lead to brain damage.
References Babb, T.L., Kupfer, W.R., Pretorius, J.K., Crandall, RH. and Levesque, M.E (1991) Synaptic reorganization by mossy fibers in human epileptic fascia dentate. Neuroscience, 42: 351-363. Ben-Aft, Y. (1985) Limbic seizures and brain damage produced by kainic acid: Mechanisms and relevance to human temporal lobe epilepsy. Neuroscience, 14: 375-403. Buckmaster, ES. and Dudek, EE. (1997) Neuron loss, granule cell reorganization, and functional changes in the dentate gyrus of epileptic kainate-treated rats. J. Comp. Neurol., 385: 385404. Buhl, E.H., Otis, T.S. and Mody, I. (1996) Zinc-induced collapse of augmented inhibition by GABA in a temporal lobe epilepsy model. Science, 271: 369-373. Cavazos, J.E., Das, I. and Sutula, T.E (1994) Neuronal loss induced in limbic pathways by kindling: evidence for induction of hippocampal sclerosis by repeated brief seizures. J. Neurosci., 14: 3106-3121. Christian, E.E and Dudek, EE. (1988) Characteristics of local excitatory circuits studied with glutamate microapplication in the CA3 area of rat hippocampal slices. J. Neurophysiol., 59: 90-109. Cronin, J., Obenaus, A., Houser, C.R. and Dudek, EE. (1992) Electrophysiology of dentate granule cells after kainateinduced synaptic reorganization of the mossy fibers. Brain Res., 573: 305-310. De Lanerolle, N.C., Kim, J.H., Robbins, R.J. and Spencer, D.D. (1989) Hippocampal interneuron loss and plasticity in human temporal lobe epilepsy. Brain Res., 495: 387-395. Dudek, EE. and Spitz, M. (1997) Hypothetical mechanisms for the cellular and neurophysiologic basis of secondary epileptogenesis: proposed role of synaptic reorganization. J. Clin. Neurophys., 14: 90-101. Dudek, EE., Obenaus, A., Sehweitzer, J.S. and Wuarin, J.-E (1994) Functional significance of hippocampal plasticity in epileptic brain: electrophysiological changes of the dentate granule cells associated with mossy fiber sprouting. Hippocampus, 4: 259-265. Esclapez, M., Hirsch, J.C., Ben-Ari, Y. and Bernard, C. (1999) Newly formed excitatory pathways provide a substrate for hyperexcitability in experimental temporal lobe epilepsy. J. Comp. Neurol., 408: 449-460. Franck, J.E., Pokorny, J., Kunkel, D.D. and Schwartzkroin, EA. (1995) Physiologic and morphologic characteristics of granule cell circuitry in human epileptic hippocampus. Epilepsia, 36: 543-558. Gorter, J.A., van Vliet, E.A., Aronica, E. and Lopes da Silva, F.H. (2001) Progression of spontaneous seizures after status epilepticus is associated with mossy fibre sprouting and extensive bilateral loss of hilar parvalbumin and somatostatinimmunoreactive neurons. Eur. J. Neurosci., 13: 657-669.
64
Hardison, J.L., Okazaki, M.M. and Nadler, J.V. (2000) Modest increase in extracellular potassium unmasks effect of recurrent mossy fiber growth. J. Neurophysiol., 84: 2380-2389. Hellier, J.L., Patrylo, P.R., Buckmaster, P.S. and Dudek, EE. (1998) Recurrent spontaneous motor seizures after repeated low-dose systemic treatment with kainate: assessment of a rat model of temporal lobe epilepsy. Epilepsy Res., 31: 73-84. Hellier, J.L., Patrylo, P.R., Dou, P., Nett, M., Rose, G.M. and Dudek, EE. (1999) Assessment of inhibition and epileptiform activity in the septal dentate gyrus of freely behaving rats during the first week after kainate treatment. J NeuroscL, 19: 10053-10064. Houser, C.R., Miyashiro, J.E., Swartz, B.E., Walsh, G.O., Rich, J.R. and Delgado-Escueta, A.V. (1990) Altered patterns of dynorphin immunoreactivity suggest mossy fiber reorganization in human hippocampal epilepsy. J. Neurosci., 10: 267282. Kotti, T., Riekkinen Sr., P.J. and Miettinen, R. (1997) Characterization of target cells for aberrant mossy fiber collaterals in the dentate gyrus of epileptic rat. Exp. NeuroL, 146: 323-330. Lothman, E.W., Bertram, E.H., Kapur, J. and Stringer, J.L. (1990) Recurrent spontaneous hippocampal seizures in the rat as a chronic sequela to limbic status epilepticus. Epilepsy Res., 6: 110-118. Lynch, M. and Sutula, T. (2000) Recurrent excitatory connectivity in the dentate gyrus of kindled and kainic acid-treated rats. J. Neurophysiol., 83: 693-704. Mathern, G.W., Kupfer, W.R., Pretorius, J.K., Babb, T.L. and Levesque, M.E (1992) Onset and patterns of hippocampal sprouting in the rat kainate seizure model: evidence for progressive cell loss and neo-innervation in regio inferior and superior. Dendron, 1: 69-84. Mathern, G.W., Cifuentes, E, Leite, J.P., Pretorius, J.K. and Babb, T.L. (1993) Hippocampal EEG excitability and chronic spontaneous seizures are associated with aberrant synaptic reorganization in the rat intrahippocampal kainate model. Elec. Clin. Neurophysiol., 87: 326-339. McNamara, J.O. (1994) Cellular and molecular basis of epilepsy. J. Neurosci., 14: 3413-3425. McNamara, J.O. (1999) Emerging insights into the genesis of epilepsy. Nature, 24: 15-22. Meier, C.L. and Dudek, EE. (1996) Spontaneous and stimulation-induced synchronized bursts after discharges in the isolated CA1 of kainate-treated rats. J. Neurophysiol., 76: 2231-2239. Miles, R. and Wong, R.K. (1987) Inhibitory control of local excitatory circuits in the guinea-pig hippocampus. J. Physiol., 388: 611-629. Molnar, P. and Nadler, J.V. (1999) Mossy fiber-granule cell synapses in the normal and epileptic rat dentate gyrus studied with minimal laser stimulation. J. NeurophysioL, 82: 18831894. Nadler, J.V. (1991) Kainic acid as a tool for the study of temporal lobe epilepsy. Life Sci., 29:2031-2042. Nadler, J.V., Perry, B.W. and Cotman, C.W. (1980) Selective reinnervation of hippocampal area CA1 and the fascia den-
tata after destruction of CA3-CA4 afferents with kainic acid.
Brain Res., 182: 1-9. Perez, Y., Morin, E, Beaulieu, C. and Lacaille, J.-C. (1996) Axonal sprouting of CA1 pyramidal cells in hyperexcitable hippocampal slices of kainate-treated rats. Eur. J. Neurosci., 8: 736-748. Patrylo, P.R., Schweitzer, J.S. and Dudek, EE. (1999) Abnormal responses to perforant path stimulation in the dentate gyrus of slices from rats with kainate-induced epilepsy and mossy fiber reorganization. Epilepsy Res., 36:3631-3642. Patrylo, P.R. and Dudek, F.E. (1998) Physiological unmasking of new glutamatergic pathways in the dentate gyrus of hippocampal slices from kainate-induced epileptic rats. J. Neurophysiol., 79: 418-429. Racine, R.J. (1972) Modification of seizure activity by electrical stimulation, II. Motor seizures. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol., 32: 281-294. Sloviter, R.S. (1992) Possible functional consequences of synaptic reorganization in the dentate gyrus of kainate-treated rats. Neurosci. Lett., 137: 91-96. Smith, B.N. and Dudek, EE. (2001) Short- and long-term changes in CA1 network excitability after kainate treatment in rats. J. Neurophysiol., 85: 1-9. Stafstrom, C.E., Thompson, J.L and Holmes, G.L. (1992) Kainic acid seizures in the developing brain: status epilepticus and spontaneous recurrent seizures. Dev. Brain Res., 65: 227-236. Stafstrom, C.E., Chronopoulos, A., Thurber, S., Thompson, J.L. and Holmes, G.L. (1993) Age-dependent cognitive and behavioral deficits after kainic acid seizures. Epilepsia, 34: 420432. Sutula, T., Cascino, G., Cavazos, J., Parada, I. and Ramirez, L. (1989) Mossy fiber synaptic reorganization in the epileptic human temporal lobe. Ann. Neurol., 26: 321-330. Tauck, D.L. and Nadler, J.V. (1985) Evidence of functional mossy fiber sprouting in hippocampal formation of kainic acid-treated rats. J. Neurosci., 5: 1016-1022. Turski, W.A., Cavalheiro, E.A., Schwarz, M., Czuczwar, S.J., Kleinrok, Z. and Turski, L. (1983) Limbic seizures produced by pilocarpine in rats: behavioural, electroencephalographic and neuropathological study. Behav. Brain Res., 9: 315-335. Wenzel, H.J., Woolley, C.S., Robbins, C.A. and Schwartzkroin, P.A. (2000) Kainic acid-induced mossy fiber sprouting and synapse formation in the dentate gyrus of rats. Hippocampus, 10: 244-260. West, M.J. and Gundersen, H.J. (1990) Unbiased stereological estimation of the number of neurons in the human hippocampus. J. Comp. NeuroL, 296: 1-22. West, M.J., Slomianka, L. and Gundersen, H.J.G. (1991) Unbiased stereological estimation of the total number of neurons in the subdivisions of the rat hippocampus using the optical fractionator. Anat. Rec., 231: 482-497. Wuarin, J.-E and Dudek, EE. (1996) Electrographic seizures and new recurrent excitatory circuits in the dentate gyrus of hippocampal slices from kainate-treated epileptic rats. J. Neurosci., 16: 4438-4448. Wuarin, J.-P. and Dudek, F.E. (2001) Excitatory synaptic input
65
to granule cells increases with time after kainate treatment. J.
NeurophysioL, 85: 1067-1077. Zhang, N. and Houser, C.R. (1999) Ultrastructural localization
of dynorphin in the dentate gyrus in human temporal lobe epilepsy: a study of reorganized mossy fiber synapses. J. Comp. Neurol., 405: 472-490.
T. Sutulaand A. Pitk~inen(Eds.) Progress in Brain Research, Vol. 135
© 2002 ElsevierScienceB.V.All rightsreserved CHAPTER 6
Progression of neuronal damage after status epilepticus and during spontaneous seizures in a rat model of temporal lobe epilepsy Asia Pitk~inen 1,3,,, Jari Nissinen 1, Jaak Nairism~igi 2, Katarzyna Lukasiuk 1, Olli H.J. Gr6hn 2, Riitta Miettinen 3,4 and Risto Kauppinen 2 I Epilepsy Research Laboratory and e NMR Research Group, A.L Virtanen Institute for Molecular Sciences, University of Kuopio, PO. Box 1627, F1N-70 211 Kuopio, Finland 3Department of Neurology, Kuopio University Hospital, P.O. Box 1777, FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland 4 Department of Neurology and Neurosciences, University of Kuopio, P.O. Box 1627, FIN- 70 211 Kuopio, Finland
Abstract:
The present study was designed to address the question of whether recurrent spontaneous seizures cause progressive neuronal damage in the brain. Epileptogenesis was triggered by status epilepticus (SE) induced by electrically stimulating the amygdala in rat. Spontaneous seizures were continuously monitored by video-EEG for up to 6 months. The progression of damage in individual rats was assessed with serial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) by quantifying the markers of neuronal damage (T2, T10, and Dav) in the amygdala and hippocampus. The data indicate that SE induces structural alterations in the amygdala and the septal hippocampus that progressively increased for approximately 3 weeks after SE. T2, T~p, and Dav did not normalize during the 50 days of follow-up after SE, suggesting ongoing neuronal death due to spontaneous seizures. Consistent with these observations, Fluoro-Jade B-stained preparations revealed damaged neurons in the hippocampus of spontaneously seizing animals that were sacrificed up to 62 days after SE. The presence of Fluoro-Jade B-positive neurons did not, however, correlate with the number of spontaneous seizures, but rather with the time interval from SE to perfusion. Further, there were no Fluoro-Jade B-positive neurons in frequently seizing rats that were perfused for histology 6 months after SE. Also, the number of lifetime seizures did not correlate with the severity of neuronal loss in the hilus of the dentate gyms assessed by stereologic cell counting. The methodology used in the present experiments did not demonstrate a clear association between the number or occurrence of spontaneous seizures and the severity of hilar cell death. The ongoing hippocampal damage in these epileptic animals detected even 2 month after SE was associated with epileptogenic insult, that is, SE rather than spontaneous seizures.
Introduction Analysis of histologic preparations stained using Nissl, silver, terminal deoxytransferase nick end* Correspondence to: A. Pitk~inen, Epilepsy Research Laboratory, A.I. Virtanen Institute, University of Kuopio, P.O. Box 1627 (street address: Neulaniementie 2), FIN-70 211 Kuopio, Finland. Tel.: +358-17-16-3296; Fax: -+-358-1716-3025; E-mail:
[email protected]
labeling (TUNEL), or immunohistochemical techniques indicates that even a few electrically induced kindled seizures can cause a loss of subpopulations of neurons in the amygdala (Callahan et al., 1991; Pretel et al., 1997; Tuunanen et al., 1997; Tuunanen and Pitk~inen, 2000) and hippocampus (Cavazos et al., 1994; Bengzon et al., 1997; Pretel et al., 1997; Dalby et al., 1998; Zhang et al., 1998). In the hippocampus, the severity of neuronal damage correlates with the number of afterdischarges, that is,
68 evoked seizures in a kindling model (Cavazos et al., 1994), and its distribution depends on the stimulation site (Kotloski et al., 2002). Finally, the severity of damage correlates with the impairment in cognitive performance (Sutula et al., 1995). Several lines of evidence suggest that brief seizures can also cause damage in the human epileptic brain. The neurochemical basis for this damage is explained by the study of During and Spencer (1993) who demonstrated a potentially neurotoxic 8-fold increase in the extracellular levels of glutamate in the hippocampus after secondarily generalized spontaneous seizures. Several studies indicate an increase in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) level of neuronspecific enolase (y-enolase), a marker of irreversible neuronal damage, after brief seizures (Jacobi and Reiber, 1988; Rabinowicz et al., 1994, 1996; Greffe et al., 1996; Tumani et al., 1999). Further evidence comes from a classic histologic study of MourizenDam (1982) who reported that hippocampal neuronal loss correlates with the number of generalized seizures and the duration of epilepsy. More recent histopathologic analysis of patients undergoing hippocampal resection due to drug-refractory temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) favors the idea that both the initial insult as well as recurrent seizures contribute to the damage (Mathern et al., 1995). The study by Henshall et al. (2000a) suggests that programmed cell death contributes to ongoing neuronal damage in the brain of patients with epilepsy. In addition to neuronal damage, an 11-fold increase in microglia in the CA1 subfield and a 3-fold increase in the CA3 subfield of the hippocampus in patients with TLE undergoing surgery due to drug-refractory seizures support the idea of continuing neuronal injury due to ongoing seizure activity (Beach et al., 1995). Whether recurrent seizures cause progressive neuronal loss has also recently been addressed in crosssectional as well as follow-up magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) studies. Our cross-sectional MRI volumetry studies of patients with TLE indicated that only 5% of patients with newly diagnosed epilepsy (< 1 year of TLE) had a unilateral hippocampal volume reduction of at least 2 standard deviations (SDs) of the control mean (Salmenper~i et al., 2001). In chronic patients who experienced more than two seizures per year for more than 20 years, however, there was a volume reduction of at least 2 SDs in the
hippocampus in 50% of patients (Salmenper~i et al., 2001). The severity of the hippocampal damage correlated with the lifetime number of seizures (K~ilvi~iinen et al., 1998; Salmenper~i et al., 2001). Consistent with our observations, Van Paesschen et al. (1997) concluded that the degree of hippocampal volume loss might be associated with the number of generalized seizures. The cross-sectional MR spectroscopy study by Tasch et al. (1999) demonstrated that the Nacetyl aspartate (NAA)/creatine (Cr) ratio correlated negatively with the duration of epilepsy, and they concluded that generalized seizures might cause progressive neuronal dysfunction or loss. The follow-up study by Van Paesschen et al. (1998) demonstrated that two patients exhibited a hippocampal volume loss over a 1-year follow-up. O'Brien et al. (1999) described a case study in which a 28-year-old man with refractory TLE had progressive hippocampal atrophy of 12% over a period of 4 years. Another case study by Jackson et al. (1999) demonstrated a 47% hippocampal volume decrease over 8 months in a 23year-old male with three tonic-clonic seizures. More recently, there have been several other case studies demonstrating progressive hippocampal damage in patients with epilepsy (see Sutula and Pitk~inen, 2001). Taken together, data accumulating from histologic analyses of brains from kindled rats support the idea that brief seizures can cause neuronal loss. Imaging studies indicate that spontaneous brief seizures lasting less than 2 min can also cause progressive damage in humans, at least in some individuals. In kindling, however, the seizures are induced electrically and the data from humans are based on volumetric measurement, which is an indirect indicator of cellular death. Also, no direct evidence is available on spontaneous seizure models in animals. Therefore, it has remained under dispute whether spontaneous seizures can cause neuronal loss. In retrospective human studies it has also been difficult to differentiate the contribution of the underlying epileptogenic insult versus recurrent seizures to overall damage. The present study was designed to address the question of whether recurrent spontaneous seizures cause progressive neuronal damage in the brain using MRI and histologic techniques. We used an experimental model of TLE in which epileptogenesis is triggered by electrically induced status epilepticus
69 (SE). In this model, a subpopulation of rats develops epilepsy with frequent spontaneous seizures (mean seizure frequency up to 31 seizures per day; Nissinen et al., 2000). Spontaneous seizures were monitored using a continuous video-EEG recording system. According to our hypothesis, the lifetime number of spontaneous seizures should correlate with the severity of neuronal loss. Further, rats with frequent seizures should have signs of ongoing brain damage.
after more than 50 HAFDs (n = 8). Rats were monitored with video-EEG (every other day, 24 h/day) for 60 days, and thereafter, perfused for histology. In addition, there were 14 electrode-implanted unstimulated controls. In 'the chronic group', self-sustained SE was induced in 16 rats. The rats were monitored with videoEEG for 6 months (24 h/day, every other day). In addition, there were 8 electrode-implanted controls.
Materials and methods
Implantation of electrodes
Animals
The animals were anesthetized with intraperitoneal injection of sodium pentobarbital (60 mg/kg) and chloral hydrate (100 mg/kg) and placed in a stereotaxic frame. A pair of stimulation electrodes (0.5 m m vertical tip separation) was implanted into the lateral nucleus of the left amygdala (3.6 m m posterior, 5.0 m m lateral, and 6.5 m m ventral to bregma). One stainless-steel screw was inserted as a cortical electrode into the skull above the right frontal cortex (3 mm anterior to bregma, 2 m m lateral to midline). Two stainless-steel screws were inserted as indifferent and ground electrodes into the skull bilaterally over the cerebellum. The electrodes were fixed with dental acrylate. The rats were allowed to recover from the surgical operation for 14 days until electrical stimulation was started.
Male Sprague-Dawley rats (275-325 g) were used in the present study. After implantation of electrodes, rats were housed in individual cages at a temperature of 19-21°C, with humidity maintained at 50 to 60% and lights on from 0700 to 1900. Standard food pellets and water were freely available. All animal procedures were conducted in accordance with the guidelines set by the European Community Council Directives 86/609/EEC. To mimic the process of human TLE, three rat groups were included in the study: 'newly diagnosed', 'recently diagnosed', and 'chronic' rats with epilepsy. In 'the newly diagnosed group', selfsustained SE was induced by electrically stimulating the lateral nucleus of the amygdala in 16 adult male Sprague-Dawley rats. The animals were allowed to recover from SE spontaneously. Nonstimulated electrode-implanted rats (n = 16) served as controls. Rats were monitored with video-EEG continuously 24 h/day via cortical electrode until they developed a second spontaneous seizure and 11 days thereafter, before being perfused for histology. In 'the recently diagnosed group', self-sustained SE was induced in 30 rats. To investigate the effect of the duration of SE on neuronal damage, SE was stopped with diazepam (15 m g / k g and 10 mg/kg 8 h later, intraperitoneally) after the rats experienced 5 or fewer high-amplitude and high-frequency discharges ( H A F D s 1; n = 7), after 6 to 50 HAFDs (n = 15), or
I A conspicuous feature of EEG activity during SE is the occurrence of high-amplitude and high-frequency discharges (HAFDs), which are typically associated with behavioral
Induction of self-sustained SE Afterdischarge threshold was assessed by stimulating the amygdala with a 1-s train of 60 Hz, 50 to 400 IxA (peak to peak), 1-ms bipolar square-wave pulses. Only those rats in which afterdischarges could be induced at a current level of 400 txA or lower were included in the study. To induce SE, the amygdala was stimulated with 2 trains/s of 1-ms, 60-Hz bipolar pulses (each train lasting 100 ms) at 400 lxA current (peak to peak). After 20 rain of continuous stimulation, the stimulation was interrupted, and the behavioral and electrographic seizure activity of the animal was observed
seizures. HAFDs are defined as a high-amplitude (>2 x baseline) and high-frequency (>8 Hz) discharge in the amygdala or in the cortex (or both) that lasts for at least 5 s.
70 for 60 s. If the behavior of the animal revealed the presence of epileptic activity (head nodding/or limb clonus), the observation period was extended up to 10 min. If the animal did not meet the criterion of clonic SE (continuous epileptiform spiking and recurrent clonic seizures), stimulation was resumed and the behavior of the animal was checked again after 5 min. Once the criterion of SE was achieved, no further stimulation was given.
Electrophysiologic characterization of SE and spontaneous seizures To electrophysiologically characterize the duration and severity of SE, seizure activity was recorded by a digital video-EEG system as described previously in detail (Nissinen et al., 2000). The severity of SE was assessed by counting the number of HAFD during SE. The duration of SE was defined as an interval between the first and last HAFD. The occurrence of spontaneous seizures was determined based on the analysis of EEG data. If an electrographic seizure was observed, the severity of the behavioral seizure was scored based on the video. Criterion for an epileptic seizure was a highfrequency (>5 Hz), high-amplitude (>2 x baseline) discharge either in the amygdala or in the cortex (or both) that lasted for at least 5 s.
Characterization of behavioral seizures During the stimulation and follow-up periods, the behavior of the rats was recorded using a video camera that was time-locked with the digital EEG. Behavioral motor seizure activity was classified according to a slightly modified Racine scale (Racine, 1972). Score 0: electrographic seizure without any detectable motor manifestation. Score 1: mouth and face clonus, head nodding. Score 2: clonic jerks of one forelimb. Score 3: bilateral forelimb clonus. Score 4: forelimb clonus and rearing. Score 5: forelimb clonus with rearing and falling.
Histologic analysis of brain tissue Fixation Rats were deeply anesthetized and perfused intra-
cardially according to the fixation protocol for Timm staining (Sloviter, 1982). The brains were postfixed in the fixative for 4 h and then cryoprotected in a solution containing 20% glycerol in 0.02 M potassium phosphate buffer, pH 7.4 for 24 h. The brains were then blocked, frozen in dry ice, and stored at - 7 0 ° C until cut. They were sectioned in the coronal plane in a one-in-five series at a thickness of 30 Ixm (newly diagnosed, recently diagnosed groups) or 50 txm (chronic group) with a sliding microtome. The sections were stored in a cryoprotectant tissuecollecting solution (TCS; 30% ethylene glycol, 25% glycerol in 0.05 M sodium phosphate buffer) at - 2 0 ° C until processing. Assessment of neuronal damage in thionin staining One series of sections was stained with thionin to characterize the cytoarchitectonic boundaries of various brain regions and to locate the electrode tips. These sections were also used to assess the severity of neuronal damage by counting cells. The hippocampus was partitioned into different regions according to the nomenclature described by Amaral and Witter (1995).
Stereologic estimation of total neuronal numbers in the hilus. Stereologic analyses were conducted blindly with respect to the treatment status of the animal. The optical fractionator method was implemented using Stereo Investigator software in a Neuro Lucida morphometry system (MicroBrightField, Germany) with guidelines described by West et al. (1991). A color video camera (Hitachi HVC20, Japan), interfaced with an Olympus BX50 microscope, was used to view sections on a highresolution monitor, and neuroanatomic borders of the hilus were digitized under low-power magnification. Subsequent cell counting was confined within these borders. The sections were inspected according to a systematic random sampling scheme such that counts were derived from a known and representative fraction of the hilus. Specifically, the motorized stage of the microscope system was under computer control, and the hilar fields in every histologic section were surveyed at evenly spaced x-y intervals of 180 x 180 txm for the hilus. For each x-y step, cell counts were derived from a known fraction of
71 the total area using an unbiased counting frame that was 36 x 36 txm. Counting was performed throughout the section, avoiding the neurons that were in focus at the surface of the section. Neuronal nuclei were counted only as they first came into focus within each optical dissector. Glia, identified by size and cytologic characteristics, were excluded from the counts. Finally, the total neuron number was estimated by multiplying the sum of the neurons counted by the reciprocal of the fraction of the hippocampus that was sampled (i.e., a multiple of the fraction of the histologic sections examined, the fraction of the x-y step interval covered by the counting frame, and the fraction of the total section thickness examined). Assessment of neuronal density in the septal and temporal hilus. Because the severity of hilar cell damage varies along the septotemporal axis of the hippocampus, the density of hilar cells was estimated from the septal and temporal ends of the hippocampus separately. At the septal end, the neuronal density was assessed from three sections that were systematically sampled at 450-txm (newly diagnosed and recently diagnosed animals) or 200-~tm intervals (chronic animals) starting at the level at which the suprapyramidal and infrapyramidal blades of the granule cell layer form a continuous band of cells. At the temporal end, the neuronal density was assessed from two adjacent sections (150 txm apart) at the level where the granule cell layer forms an oval shape. Using Stereo Investigator software in the Neuro Lucida morphometry system described above, hilar fields in every histologic section were surveyed at evenly spaced x-y intervals (70 x 70 ~tm septally, 150 × 150 Ixm temporally). For each x-y step, cell counts were derived from a known fraction of the total area using a counting frame that was 25 × 25 Ixm septally and 30 x 30 Ixm temporally. Because the area of the hilus in the epilepsy groups did not differ from that in controls, neuronal density was calculated by dividing the neuronal number by the area. The mean density was used for the statistical analysis. Analyses were conducted blindly with respect to the treatment status of the animal. To compare the severity of damage between the groups, the severity of damage was transformed to damage-%, that is (density of neurons in experimental animal/mean density of neurons in the control group) x 100%.
Assessment of neuronal damage in Fluoro-Jade B preparations An adjacent series of sections (1 in 10) was stained with Fluoro-Jade B according to the protocol described by Schmued et al. (1997). The density of Fluoro-Jade B-positive neurons was semiquantitatively assessed as follows (Fig. 3A). Score 0: no damage. Score 1: lesions involving less than 20% of neurons in the region of interest. Score 2: lesions involving 21 to 50% of neurons. Score 3: lesions involving 51 to 100% of neurons. The damage score was based on the analysis of all sections in which the region of interest was present. To visualize the distribution of Fluoro-Jade Bpositive cells, fluorescent neurons were plotted using a fluorescent microscope, Leitz DMRD (Leitz, Wetzlar, Germany) equipped with a computer-aided digitizing system (Minnesota Datametrics, St. Paul, MN). To determine the location of plotted fluorescent neurons, cytoarchitectonic borders of the region of interest were drawn using a camera lucida from adjacent thionin-stained sections with a stereo microscope and a drawing tube. Thereafter, cytoarchitectonic outlines were superimposed on computergenerated plots using Canvas 3.5 (Deneba, Miami, FL) software on a Macintosh computer. MRI follow-up of rats during epileptogenesis and epilepsy To follow the progression of structural alterations in individual rats, a separate group of rats (n = 10) was prepared for MRI analysis. In these animals, a bipolar stainless-steel stimulating electrode was implanted into the left amygdala. To detect spontaneous seizures, three platinum-iridium wires were implanted into the skull as described in the section 'Implantation of electrodes'. To improve the quality of MRI, the stimulating electrode was removed 2 days after the induction of SE. To monitor the spontaneous seizures, video-EEG was recorded via a cortical platinum electrode for 4 days before each imaging session. Three rats with electrode implantations without stimulation served as controls. MRI of the amygdala and the septal hippocampus was performed using a scanner operating at 4.7 T (a bird-cage-type volume-coil, coronal 1 mm slice
72 - 2.8 mm from bregma, matrix 128 • 256, FOV 35 mm) at 2, 9, 21 and 50 days after SE. Diffusion (Dav, TR = 1.5 s, TE -----55 ms, b-values 0, 470, 856 s/mm 2) and T2 (TE = 20 to 60 ms, TR = 1.5 s, 4 averages) images were sequentially acquired. Tip was quantified at the same time points (variable length (10-90 ms) adiabatic spin-lock pulses followed by a fast spin echo imaging sequence, TR = 2.5 s, echo spacing 10 ms, 16 echoes/excitation, 4 averages). Regions analyzed included the amygdala (stimulation site, primary focus for spontaneous seizures) and the septal hippocampus (remote area connected polysynaptically with the primary stimulation site).
Results
crease in the number of hilar neurons contralaterally in epileptic animals compared to controls (44,600 4- 6021 vs 37,369 4- 9337). Neuron counts did not differ between the ipsilateral and contralateral sides. The severity of hilar damage varies along the septotemporal axis of the hippocampus, being more severe temporally than septally (Nissinen et al., 2000). During the course of these studies it has become apparent that even substantial damage involving a small segment of the septotemporal extent of the hilus might lead to a relatively small decline in the total neuronal numbers. Therefore, we assessed the association between hilar cell loss and lifetime seizure number in the septal and temporal ends separately. In the ipsilateral septal hilus, the density of neurons in newly diagnosed, recently diagnosed, and chronic animals was reduced by 23 4- 17%, 25 4- 14%, and 12 + 9%, respectively, compared to that in controls (all, p < 0.001; Fig. 2A). In the contralateral septal hilus, the density of neurons in the newly diagnosed, recently diagnosed, and chronic animals was reduced by 20q- 17% (p < 0.001), 15-t- 13% (p < 0.001), and 144- 12% (p < 0.01), respectively, compared to that in controls (p > 0.05, p < 0.05, p > 0.05 compared to ipsilateral side). In the ipsilateral temporal hilus, the neuronal density in newly diagnosed rats was reduced by 38 + 16% and in recently diagnosed rats by 30-4-17% compared to that in controls (both, p < 0.001). In the contralateral temporal hilus, the neuronal density in newly diagnosed animals was 36 4- 24% and in recently diagnosed rats 31 5:23% lower than in controls (both p < 0.001; Fig. 3A). The severity of damage did not differ between the ipsilateral and contralateral sides.
Severity of neuronal damage in the hilus at different stages of the epileptic process
Association of lifetime seizure number with neuronal numbers and densities
According to our hypothesis, the neuronal numbers would be lowest in rats with chronic epilepsy. Therefore, we first estimated the total neuronal numbers in the hilus of the chronic group by stereologic cell counting. The number of neurons in the ipsilateral hilus did not differ between the controls (n = 8) and epileptic (n = 13) animals (44,650 q- 3923 vs 40,3544-9992; Fig. 1A). There was also no de-
If recurrent spontaneous seizures cause further damage to the hilar cells, we hypothesized that there would be a correlation between the severity of hilar damage and lifetime seizure number. In chronically epileptic animals, the total number of lifetime seizures did not correlate with the total number of neurons in the ipsilateral (Fig. 1B) or contralateral hilus (both, p > 0.05). When the association be-
Photomicrography Photomicrographs were taken with a Leica DM RB microscope equipped with a CoolSnap digital camera system (RS Photometrics, Sweden). Statistical analysis Data were analyzed using SPSS for Windows (version 9.0) or Statview 4.5 for Macintosh. MRI data were analyzed using Student's t-test. The severity of neuronal damage in different temporal lobe structures in the different treatment groups was compared using the Mann-Whitney U-test. The severity of neuronal damage between the stimulated and contralateral sides was compared using the Wilcoxon signed rank test. Correlations between hilar cell damage and seizure frequency were analyzed using Spearman's rank correlation. A p-value of less than 0.05 was considered significant.
73
B
60000
50000
A6OOOO
40000 30000
50000 ..................... i ..................... I ........................
20000
Chronic epilepsy
10000 O9
40000 .............................................................................. • |
R.S.
0
2000
Z
O II rr" 30000 ................................................................................ LU
4000
6000
LIFETIME Sz NUMBER
Z
20000 ................................................................................ 1 0 0 0 0 ........ 44 650 ].......................................
C
60000 50000 40000
................................................. . .............
.....
30000 [ 40~ 0
'
Control
] '
20000 10000
Chronic epilepsy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
n.s.
Chronic
Epilepsy
0
50
100
150
200
DURATION OF EPILEPSY (d) Fig. 1. (A) Total neuronal number in the ipsilateral hilus was not decreased in chronically epileptic animals compared to that in controls (6 months after SE). (B) The number of hilar neurons did not correlate with the lifetime seizure number in chronically epileptic animals. Note that some animals with a very high seizure number have normal hilar cell counts (arrows). (C) The number of hilar neurons did not correlate with the duration of epilepsy in chronically epileptic animals. Note that some animals with the longest duration of epilepsy have normal hilar cell counts (arrows). Abbreviations: d = days; n.s. = statistically nonsignificant; Sz = seizure.
tween lifetime seizure number and damage to hilar cells at the septal and temporal ends was assessed by combining the data from the different animal groups, the lifetime seizure number did not correlate with neuronal density in the hilus ipsilaterally, but did correlate contralaterally (r = 0.335, p < 0.05, n = 37) at the septal end (data available from newly diagnosed, recently diagnosed, and chronic animals) (Fig. 2B). At the temporal end (data available from newly diagnosed and recently diagnosed animals), however, there was a correlation both ipsilaterally (r = 0.447, p < 0.05, n = 24; Fig. 3B) and contralaterally (r = 0.605, p < 0.01, n = 24). It should be noted, however, that some animals with a very low lifetime seizure number had damage as severe as the animals with a large number of seizures (Fig. 3B).
Association of seizure frequency with neuronal numbers and densities Exposure of neurons to the toxic effects of glutamate presumably depends on the seizure frequency, and therefore, the association of seizure frequency with neuronal loss was assessed. There was no correlation between seizure frequency and total neuronal numbers in the hilus. Ipsilaterally seizure frequency correlated with the severity of damage in the temporal hilus (r = 0.498, p < 0.05, n = 23) and contralaterally, both septally (r = 0.365, p < 0.05, n = 36) and temporally (r = 0.612, p < 0.01, n = 23). Analysis of data from individual animals, however, indicates that some rats with a very low seizure frequency had substantial ( > 3 0 % ) hilar cell damage. In contrast, some animals with a mean daily seizure frequency of more than 15 had the same magnitude of damage as rats with very low seizure frequency.
74
B 100
/x. ._J
100
o~ 8O
......................l ....................: ...................z ........................
~ z 0rr
..............................
~
2o
z
0
I
•
.0.
............. i ................... i .......................
60 40
.iiit!i.ii.i...i_iiii..i.ii.i.. .....,
............................................................................ 1J ~n.s. " L~'""t""l;~
500 1500 2500 3500 4500 5500 6500
W _J
o~ 60 z O rr w z
I
..................................................................
LIFETIME Sz NUMBER
0
40
o~ 100 h o t -28%
..............o , ,
.............• .....................t ~
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
8o
20
6o
co z 40 '
'
'
Chronic Recent New
~
20
D w z
0
,;:;: ::; ; ;: :i; t ,anmaSns 0
50
100
150
200
DURATION OF EPILEPSY (d) Fig. 2. (A) Density of neurons in the ipsilateral septal hilus (expressed as a percentage of neurons remaining compared to controls; 100%) was decreased both in the newly diagnosed, recently diagnosed, and chronically epileptic animals (all, p < 0.001). (B) The density of neurons in the ipsilateral septal hilus did not correlate with the lifetime seizure number when data from all animal groups were combined. Note that some animals with a very high seizure number have normal hilar cell counts (arrows). (C) The density of neurons in the ipsilateral septal hilus did not correlate with the duration of epilepsy when data from all animal groups were combined. Note that some animals with the longest duration of epilepsy have normal hilar cell counts (arrows). Abbreviations: d = days; n.s. = statistically nonsignificant; Sz = seizure.
Association of duration of epilepsy with neuronal numbers and densities
Association of duration of SE with neuronal numbers and density
Longer duration of epilepsy was assumed to associate with more severe damage caused by both the progression of degenerative processes initiated by SE and recurrent seizures. In the chronic group, there was no correlation between the duration of epilepsy and the neuronal numbers in the hilus (Fig. 1C). Also, the duration of epilepsy did not correlate with neuronal density in the ipsilateral or contralateral septal or temporal hilus (ipsilateral septal in Fig. 2C and ipsilateral temporal in Fig. 3C).
SE is a brain damaging insult, the duration of which is associated with the severity of neuronal damage (Meldrum and Brierley, 1973). We retrospectively assessed the association of the duration of SE with cell counts. Interestingly, the duration of SE did not correlate with the decrease in the total neuronal numbers in the hilus (chronic group). Also, there was no association between the duration of SE or the number of HAFDs and the density of neurons in the septal or temporal hilus (all animals; Fig. 4).
75
~°100
A 100
80 t-
I.I_ UJ
- 60 co z O
~
60
o
4o 1 All animals 2o .............................................................................
UJ
z
| ................................................................t • |
I p=0.033
0
40
90
140
LIFETIME SZ NUMBER
................................
C
g 4o
o~
IJ.I
~_ 100
z
20
._1
0
Recent
New
~z 0 D uJ z
80
60 .... tt- ................................... • ' ' ° , ............................ 40 ...............°.~. .................................................. All animals 20 i n.s. 0 ......................................................................... 0 20 40 60 DURATION OF EPILEPSY (d)
Fig. 3. (A) Density of hilar neurons (expressed as a percentage of neurons remaining compared to controls; 100%) was decreased at the temporal end of the dentate gyrus both in the newly diagnosed and recently diagnosed (both p < 0.001) epileptic animals. (B) The density of neurons in the ipsilateral temporal hilus correlated with the lifetime seizure number when data from newly and recently diagnosed animal groups were combined. Note, however, that many of the animals with only very few seizures (arrows) had hilar cell loss as severe as the rats with frequent seizures. (C) The density of neurons in the ipsilateral temporal hilus did not correlate with the duration of epilepsy when data from newly and recently diagnosed animal groups were combined (Spearman's rank correlation). Note that many of the animals with a very short duration of epilepsy (arrows) had as severe damage as the rats with the longest duration of epilepsy. Abbreviations: d = days; n.s. = statistically nonsignificant; Sz = seizure.
MRI of brain during SE-induced epileptogenesis and epilepsy Histologic analysis provides insight into only one time point, which compromises the analysis of the temporal course of damage in individual animals. Therefore, we used modem imaging techniques to follow the progression of damage after SE (Fig. 5). At 2 days, T2 was prolonged in the ipsilateral amygdala (by 162%, p < 0.01) and in the hippocampus (127%) compared to electrode-implanted controls (is 100%). At 9, 23 and 50 days, T2 remained elevated but tended to decrease in the ipsilateral amygdala (to 117% at 50 days) as well as in the ipsilateral hippocampus (to 114%). Changes in T10 paralleled
the changes in T2 even though the abnormalities were more pronounced and Tl0 remained elevated even at day 50 (Fig. 5). At 2 days, D,v in the ipsilateral amygdala did not differ from controls, whereas it was increased in the ipsilateral hippocampus (127%). At later time points, Day was elevated in both the amygdala and the hippocampus. MRI parameters during the first 23 days did not predict the severity of epilepsy at later time points.
Assessment of Fluoro-Jade B staining at different stages of epilepsy Fluoro-Jade B stains irreversibly damaged neurons (electron microscopic observations by Miettinen and
76 SEPTAL HILUS
100
....~,~...._•...•
.................................................
. ,......:'....
u4, 80
~ •
o ............... •
,ip..~
100
..............
- ......................................
. . . . . . . . . . . .
m 80 ~
60
O or 40 D 20 Iii z 0
0 rr
40
i iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii'iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii "nsan,n a,s 0
500 1000 DURATION OF SE (min)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
O.._l.Z.l.._.o__i -
......... ~ . O . 0
............... a •
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6o
~z
............,
__I~I
.................. ~
_ ~ O
...................................
..............................
.O. ................................
............................ • ......................................
[ p=0.037
LU 20 Z 0
1500
•
0
50
100 HAFDs
150
200
TEMPORAL HILUS o~ ii UJ
G0
Z
O
fr D L.U Z
C 100 ..o----..--
.......................................................................................................
80 ~
............................. i-".......................................................................
60 r ~
................go .......................................................................... _ _ 40 I-- ........................................o ........................I All animals ...................................................................... [n.s. 0-0 500 1000 1500 DURATION OF SE (min)
I ~ 1 0 0 l.............l ........................l .tu
80
l
..............................................................................
........................... i i - - - ~ ..............o ............................................................
COZ 60 ",," 0 • D rr 40 iiiiiiiiiiii iiii iiii iiii i°iiiill iiii iiiiiiiii t All animals UJ z n.s. 0 0 50 100 150 200 HAFDs
Fig. 4. Association of the severity of SE with neuronal damage in the ipsilateral septal (A and B) and temporal (C and D) hilus. (A) The severity of cell loss (expressed as a percentage of neurons remaining compared to controls; 100%) did not correlate with the duration of SE (data pooled from all three rat groups). Note that some of the rats with the longest SE (arrows) had normal hilar cell densities. (B) The severity of cell loss correlated with the number of high-amplitude and high-frequency discharges during SE. The association, however, suggested that animals with a higher number of seizures during SE had a higher density of hilar cells. At the temporal end, there was no association between hilar cell loss and duration of status epilepticus (C) or the number of high-amplitude and high-frequency discharges during SE (D). Abbreviations: HAFD = high-amplitude and -frequency discharge; rain = minutes; n.s. = statistically nonsignificant; SE = status epilepticus.
Pitk~inen, unpublished). In the present study, FluoroJade B-positive neurons were assessed in the newly diagnosed and chronic groups (Fig. 6). None of the newly diagnosed rats had positive neurons in the hilus, whereas 10/14 had Fluoro-Jade B-positive neurons in the CA3, 9/14 in the CA1, 14/14 in the amygdala, 3/14 in the piriform cortex, and 11/14 in the thalamus. Also, one of the two rats that was stimulated but did not develop epilepsy had a few Fluoro-Jade B-positive neurons in the amygdala and thalamus, and the other rat had a few in just the amygdala. In the newly diagnosed group, the density of Fluoro-Jade B-positive neurons corre-
lated negatively with the time from SE to perfusion in the CA3 (r = -0.488, p < 0.05), the perirhinal cortex (r = - 0 . 2 8 4 , p < 0.05), and the thalamus (r = -0.286, p < 0.05). There were no Fluoro-Jade B-positive cells in any of the animals in the chronic group. When the data from newly diagnosed and chronic groups were pooled, there was no correlation between the lifetime seizure number and hippocampal total damage score (Fig. 7A). Time to perfusion, however, correlated with the total hippocampal damage score (p < 0.001; Fig. 7B). Approximately 60 days after SE, there were no positive neurons in any
77
HIPPOCAMPUS
AMYGDALA
B
A
180 160 140 120
•-.L
180 160 140 120
seizures
........................................................................
...................................................................................................................................
...... 3.x .................................
~..I--.-.~...**.-.ii....=.......
.
i i!!!!!!
80
80 60
Lseizures
........................................................................
I.
...............................................................................................• -
l_._ Day
40 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
20 I
0
I
10
I
t
I
40 20
1- I - Tip
............................................................................
0
60
T 2
1
I
I
20 30 40 FOLLOW-UP (d)
I
I
50
.................................................................................................. iiiiiii ii iiiiiiiiii ii iiiiiiiiii ii iiiiiiii ii "O'T2~ T1 °Dav
0
I
60
I
0
I
10
I
I
I
I
I
I
20 30 40 FOLLOW-UP (d)
I
I
50
I
60
Fig. 5. Long-term magnetic resonance imaging follow-up of rats after SE. (A) In the ipsilateral amygdala, T2 and Tip were increased 2 days after SE (p < 0.01), returned to normal levels during the next 2 weeks, and thereafter tended to increase again. The diffusion coefficient, Day, became progressively more abnormal during the first 3 weeks. Importantly, all parameters were above the control level even 50 days after SE. (B) Unlike in the amygdala, there were no rapid increases in the T2 and Tip values in the ipsilateral septal hippocampus after SE. Instead, all parameters (T2, Tip, Day) increased progressively during the first 3 weeks after SE and remained above the control level even at 50 days. Values are expressed as a percentage of that in controls animals (control value is defined as 100%). Abbreviations: d = days; Day = 1/3 of the trace of the diffusion tensor; TLp = longitudinal relaxation time in the rotating frame; T2 = transverse relaxation time. of the rats despite a high frequency of daily seizures ( > 1 0 seizures/day) in some chronically epileptic animals (Fig. 7B).
Discussion Methodologic considerations When comparing data obtained from animal studies to those obtained from human studies, a critical question arises. What does the animal model model? In the present experiments, epileptogenesis was induced by electrically stimulating the amygdala in adult male rats. This results in the development of self-sustained SE and the appearance of spontaneous seizures of temporal lobe origin after a latency period of approximately 1 month. In some animals seizures might occur tens of times per day (Nissinen et al., 2000). We propose that our model models TLE in humans that has an adult onset with acute nonsymptomatic SE as an etiology. It is important to realize, however, that the lack of data on the development of brain damage in spontaneous seizure
models triggered by other etiologies, such as head trauma or stroke, compromises the extrapolation of data obtained in SE models to sequelae of other etiologies. In the present study, SE was induced by electrical stimulation of the amygdala, which is also the site of origin for most of the spontaneous seizures occurring later in life (Nissinen et al., 2000). The amygdala provides substantial inputs to the CA1 and CA3 subfields of the temporal half of the hippocampus (Pikkarainen et al., 1999). Projections to the septal hippocampus are meager, and there are no monosynaptic projections to the hilus (Pikkarainen et al., 1999). With these caveats in mind, we assumed that the polysynaptically connected hippocampus would provide a good candidate region to study seizureinduced neuronal death that would not be contaminated by monosynaptic neuronal death associated with the SE-triggering stimulation itself. In the present study, neuronal loss was assessed by estimating the total neuronal numbers in the hilus and measuring neuronal density in the septal and temporal hilus. These approaches have a limited sen-
78
~--;
~..~
~:x8 ~t~
~
o
..~ ~ ~ ~ "
~-~ ~ o~-~
.~'~ t.~
~ ~ =
~ - ~
~.~
0
"0
,~
02
O~
c~
0
."
"~
-= ~
~.~ ~
'
:~
"
II
~
~:
~
~ -~
a.~ o ~ I e . ~
o
~ . ~
•~ 5
• .0
oo~
~
~
o'd ,
~
0
.~ ~-~ ~
. ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~
79
A uJ nO u~ m
8 7 6 5 4 3
B ......... • ........................
Newly
..............a .......................
chronic
..............~ t .......................
n.s.
diagnosed
no o
animals
1 0
54
.........• .............................
Newly
,,~, ~ ' ~ ; ua " n o s e
.............w
chronic
animals
.............. a .................................................. ~ . . . ~ ¢ . . . . ~ ' . ................... ~ .............Q l
0
......
...................................... -Q....Q---.-Q .................... Q ...........
2000
4000
6000
LIFETIME SEIZURE NUMBER
"?, ,,
.......................
..............a .........................
.........Q
2 "
8
and
'~ a n d
p<0.001
...............................................................................................................
1 0 0
50
100
150
200
TIME TO PERFUSION (d)
Fig. 7. (A) Number of Fluoro-Jade B-positive cells in the hippocampus was not associated with the lifetime seizure number (the correlation was also not significant if calculated separately for partial or secondarily generalized seizures in the newly diagnosed group; data not shown). Note that several animals with a very high lifetime seizure number (and high daily seizure frequency; arrows) had no Fluoro-Jade B-positive cells in the hippocampus. (B) Number of Fluoro-Jade B-positive cells correlated inversely with the time to perfusion. Note that there were no positive cells in animals that were sacrificed 180 days after SE (13 rats, arrow) even though some of the animals had several spontaneous seizures per day. Abbreviations: d = day; F-J B = Fluoro-Jade B.
sitivity to detect minor loss of a subpopulation of vulnerable neurons (Tuunanen et al., 1997; Tuunanen and Pitk~inen, 2000). Further, there is substantial interanimal variability in the severity of damage caused by SE. Seizure and SE-induced neurogenesis is another factor con