OTHER PBL SERIES Problem-based Learning Innovation: Using problems to power learning in the 21st century (by Oon-Seng Tan)
Enhancing Thinking through Problem-based Learning Approaches: International Perspectives (edited by Oon-Seng Tan)
Problem-based Learning in eLearning Breakthroughs (edited by Oon-Seng Tan)
Australia • Brazil • Japan • Korea • Mexico • Singapore • Spain • United Kingdom • United States
Problem-based Learning and Creativity Oon-Seng Tan Publishing Director: Paul Tan Assistant Publishing Manager: Pauline Lim Senior Product Director: Janet Lim Senior Product Manager: Charles Ho
© 2009 Cengage Learning Asia Pte Ltd ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. No part of this work covered by the copyright herein may be reproduced, transmitted, stored or used in any form or by any means graphic, electronic, or mechanical, including but not limited to photocopying, recording, scanning, digitalizing, taping, Web distribution, information networks, or information storage and retrieval systems, without the prior written permission of the publisher. For permission to use material from this text or product, email to
[email protected]
Copy Editor: Lee Ming Ang
ISBN-13: 978-981-4253-14-7 ISBN-10: 981-4253-14-6
Cover Designer: Meng Hui Lee
Cengage Learning Asia Pte Ltd 5 Shenton Way #01-01 UIC Building Singapore 068808
Cover Image: iStockphoto Compositor: International Typesetters
Cengage Learning is a leading provider of customized learning solutions with office locations around the globe, including Singapore, the United Kingdom, Australia, Mexico, Brazil and Japan. Locate your local office at: www.cengage.com/global Cengage Learning products are represented in Canada by Nelson Education, Ltd. For product information, visit www.cengageasia.com
Printed in Singapore 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 11 10 09 08
CONTENTS Foreword vii Preface ix Contributors xv 1. Problems and Creativity 1 Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye 2. Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review of the Literature 15 Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo 3. Facilitating Problem-solving Processes for Adaptors and Innovators 39 Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan 4. Problem-based Learning Communities: Using the Social Environment to Support Creativity 51 Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan 5. Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning 67 Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä 6. Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design 87 Pauline Sameshima 7. Creativity and Group Dynamics in a Problem-based Learning Context 109 Clara E. Gerhardt and Claire Michelle Gerhardt
vi
Contents
8. The Problem-based Learning Model for Teaching Entrepreneurship 127 Shipra Vaidya 9. Internet-enhanced Seven-Jump Problem-based Learning: Promoting Creativity, Economic Literacy, and Argumentation Skills 145 Jonggyu Bae 10. Using Problem-based Learning Activities to Identify Creatively Gifted Mathematics Students 155 Scott Chamberlin 11. Group Collaboration in an Online Problem-based University Course 173 Donna Russell 12. Assessment of Creative Knowledge Building in Online Problem-based Learning 193 Tjaart Imbos and Frans Ronteltap 13. E-Portfolios for Problem-based Learning: Scaffolding Thinking and Learning in Preservice Teacher Education 205 Woon Chia Liu, Albert K. Liau, and Oon-Seng Tan 14. Transgenerational Problem-based Web Development Learning Experience 225 William E. J. Doane and Joette Stefl-Mabry
FOREWORD Educational innovation and transformation are taking place worldwide. In the United States, research on ways to improve curricula and pedagogy has been conducted at various levels, from elementary school to undergraduate education. In the Middle East, governments have been investing heavily on initiatives to improve education and jump-start innovation. Rapidly rising economies such as China and India are not only improving their mass education but also focusing on establishing best practices for both niche areas and scalable solutions. In Singapore, education has gone beyond the basics and fundamentals of literacy and mathematical and scientific competence to diversification of learning methods to promote smart learning as well as effective and creative thinking. In recent years, several educational agencies from countries such as Abu Dhabi and Bahrain have sought the expertise and experience of our National Institute of Education (NIE) in developing their education reform programs to achieve similar goals. As Director of NIE, I am privileged to have the opportunity to work with some of the most forward-looking academics and practitioners. This volume is just one example of the contributions of NIE academics, who are helping to change educational ideas and practices in Singapore and internationally with their expertise. Dr. Oon-Seng Tan, the editor of this volume, NIE’s Dean of Foundation Programmes and Head of Psychological Studies as well as immediate past president of the Educational Research Association of Singapore, has written or edited several publications on problem-based learning (PBL) and its role in educational innovation, enhancing thinking, and e-learning. These publications have generated much interest among researchers working on undergraduate education reform and development in the learning sciences. An advocate of PBL, Oon-Seng has helped revamp the educational studies curriculum, one outcome of which is the educational psychology module, where
viii
Foreword Contents
student teachers learn educational psychology by working on realworld problems using a combination of self-directed, peer, and collegial learning approaches that are designed to meet the demands of the discipline and the profession. Oon-Seng is an internationally recognized scholar in PBL. In 2007, he was invited to address a presidential session on PBL and e-learning at the American Educational Research Association Annual Meeting in Chicago. That same year, he delivered an Education and Human Resource Distinguished Lecture at the National Science Foundation in Washington, D.C., an event where experts are invited to share the latest developments of interest to the community of researchers, policy makers, academics, and educators. This book on PBL and creativity represents Oon-Seng’s attempt to further ideas and research in PBL, and the interface of PBL with creativity is certainly timely as schools and colleges work on infusing creativity as an important capability in learning. I congratulate Oon-Seng and his international collaborators for their contributions to advancing this area. LEE SING KONG Professor and Director National Institute of Education
PREFACE Problem-based learning (PBL) can be considered as both an idea as well as a model for approaching learning. PBL is supported in many ways by theories in the learning sciences ranging from constructivism and cognition to problem solving. As an interventionist model, it has also been substantiated by research that demonstrates its effectiveness in promoting higher-order thinking, knowledge construction, collaborative learning, and independent learning. PBL has now permeated every level, from higher and professional education down to secondary and primary education, and found application in sustainable educational practices. In the more than one decade that I have been involved in work and research on the application of PBL, I have not stopped being amazed by how a simple model like PBL can generate so much interest and gain so much momentum internationally. I salute the efforts of the hundreds of educators, academics, and practitioners who continue to keep PBL alive and use it to transform lessons and curricula. It has been a privilege to interact with practitioners and researchers worldwide when I survey the interest in PBL across the world. We have moved from interfacing PBL across disciplines and contexts to linking ideas of PBL with technology and creativity. I had the honor of being invited by the National Science Foundation (NSF) in 2007 to deliver an Education and Human Resource Distinguished Lecture about my work on PBL. This presented me an invaluable opportunity to interact with scientists working on a variety of interdisciplinary problems, which enriched my ideas on the interconnectivity of PBL with fields such as cognitive science and future technologies. In a teleconference with Professor Daniel E. Atkins, Director of the NSF Office of Cyberinfrastructure, we concurred on the importance of understanding the interface between human learning and future technologies in problemsolving situations. Prior to the NSF visit, I also had several video- and
x
Contents Preface
teleconferences with researchers across the United States during which we shared how PBL work may interface with research pertaining to future technologies, development of reflective tools in education, fostering problem-solving acumen, understanding the misconceptions about learning, new ways of engaging learning, and the importance of ethics and socio-emotional learning. With the call for innovation and the quest for novelty not only in learning but also in dealing with real-world challenges becoming more urgent, it is timely to gather together ideas and thoughts on PBL and creativity. No doubt creativity is a very broad subject and its scope defies definition. This collection therefore focuses on the creative use of PBL as well as its potential for fostering creativity. Many ideas shared here are preliminary and so serve to lay the ground for further development. Problems require solutions, and effective solutions necessitate innovation. Thus, problems and creativity are closely linked. Furthermore, PBL provides ample opportunities for creativity in the learning approaches and in the use of technology. I am thankful to our international team of contributors from Canada, Finland, India, Korea, the Netherlands, Singapore, and the United States for sharing their many ideas, conceptualizations, and research. The volume begins with a chapter on problems and creativity, in which Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye argue that problems provide opportunities for innovation by acting as a catalyst for creative thought. They draw on real-life examples of innovations and anecdotes from the lives of prominent creators to illustrate how problems can engage curiosity, inquiry, and thinking in meaningful and powerful ways. Real-world challenges increasingly require creative solutions that are both evolutionary and revolutionary. To be compatible with these demands, curricula must change such that problems are used as the spark to trigger learning and the seed to germinate creativity. This is the heart of PBL, an instructional method that through active engagement stimulates creative thinking and creative problem solving. Tan, Chye, and Teo then review relevant literature in Chapter 2 in an attempt to determine the potential of PBL for fostering creativity. The contention that PBL is an effective means of cultivating creativity may be promising in theory but lacks systematic empirical support.
Contents Preface
xi
Results of the review seem to indicate that, while a corpus of studies documenting the positive effects of PBL exists, their academic rigor and quality are in question. Further studies would benefit by understanding the limitations of previous research and should exercise discretion by qualifying any proclamations of PBL as a panacea for our students’ lack of creative thinking. In Chapter 3, Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan discuss adaption and innovation in relation to problem solving. Adaptors and innovators are two creative styles defined in the well-established Kirton’s adaption– innovation continuum, according to which adaptors choose to do things better while innovators choose to do things differently. The writers deliberate on how adaptors and innovators are likely to perform in problem-solving tasks with implications for teachers and employers on their roles in facilitating problem solving for the two creative styles. In Chapter 4, Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan share their experience of the challenges and benefits in building educational environments that support risk taking and creativity and discuss ways to support learning communities in which creativity flourishes. They also consider the social aspects of meaning making that contribute to creativity and how these aspects are fostered in PBL communities. Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä explore in Chapter 5 the development of creative learning environments in PBL. The challenges of PBL are examined through two empirical case studies that investigated computer-supported supervision of physiotherapy students undergoing practical training and the construction of individual and group knowledge bases among business students using an asynchronous discussion forum and Wiki. In Chapter 6, Pauline Sameshima shares her experience in inspiring creativity through embodied aesthetic pedagogic design and an artsbased research and learning methodology called performative inquiry. She explains in depth how teachers can transform curriculum goals into a PBL framework and develop a creative learning environment that allows access to a multiplicity of possible answers for solving the problem at hand while deeply engaging the learner. In Chapter 7, Clara E. Gerhardt and Claire Michelle Gerhardt address the issue of creativity and group dynamics in a PBL context. They point
xii
Contents Preface
out that the team context provided by PBL affords opportunities to enhance creative output by harnessing the power of group processes. The combined input of a multi-professional team allows high creativity and sophisticated end products. Knowledge of group dynamics can elevate the creative process to a higher level and minimize elements that are destructive to group functioning. Chapter 8 describes a PBL model for teaching entrepreneurship. Shipra Vaidya reports the results of a pilot course designed to introduce the concept of entrepreneurship to elementary students using the unique model. The objective of the course is to broaden the scope of general education and build students’ entrepreneurial knowledge and skills so as to ensure their well-rounded development and to lay the foundation for future employability by arming them with general core skills. In Chapter 9, Jonggyu Bae presents an Internet-enhanced PBL model designed to promote creativity, economic literacy, and argumentation skills by harnessing the power of the Internet to scaffold students’ metacognitive processes, knowledge construction, and argumentation. The author compares the model with the decision-making model and explains how the former allows students themselves to uncover their knowledge deficiency and thereby prompts them to take steps to address the gaps. Scott Chamberlin discusses PBL as a vehicle for assessing the creativity of gifted mathematics students in Chapter 10. In addition to the analysis of creative and typical responses to a problem, he considers the implications for using PBL tasks to assess creativity. The results indicate that PBL tasks can lend themselves to the identification of creatively gifted mathematicians. In Chapter 11, Donna Russell applies sociocultural learning theories to evaluate online collaborative learning in a problem-based graduate course designed to build advanced problem-solving abilities and knowledge in students. Students’ online dialogues are evaluated and related to their effectiveness in generating the problem solutions. Based on the findings, the author suggests ways to design online PBL courses that would engage students in productive group work. In Chapter 12, Tjaart Imbos and Frans Ronteltap discuss the principles behind the design of computerized assessment of creative knowledge
Contents Preface
xiii
building in an online PBL environment. The proposed methods are based on the mathematical models of latent semantic analysis and Bayesian networks. The aim is to devise a means of automatically interpreting students’ written work to assess their proficiency in the topics that they are learning. The use of e-portfolios is an emergent practice in preservice teacher education. In Chapter 13, Woon Chia Liu, Albert K. Liau, and OonSeng Tan describe the development of an e-portfolio that was piloted in a problem-based educational psychology module. The e-portfolio is presented as an efficient and creative way to scaffold knowledge construction, document students’ learning, and facilitate idea sharing. Preliminary evidence and feedback indicate that the tool provides the anticipated benefits. In Chapter 14, William E. J. Doane and Joette Stefl-Mabry present a transgenerational PBL experience involving undergraduate and graduate students working with K–12 students and in-service teachers in collaborative Web design projects that culminated in the development of Web sites tailored to the learning needs of the K–12 students. The researchers consider the processes and products that evolved from the experience in the light of Mauritz Johnson’s model of intentional education, which delineates and defines the elements of a comprehensive educational endeavor. We hope that readers will see in these chapters how PBL can promote the development of real-world competencies and bring about valued outcomes through new ways of engagement for smart learning, the use of future technologies, and the application of the learning sciences and creative ideas to develop engaging learning environments.
CONTRIBUTORS Oon-Seng Tan is Associate Professor, Dean of Foundation Programmes, and Head of Psychological Studies at the National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore. He is President-elect of the Asia-Pacific Educational Research Association (APERA) and Vice-President (Asia and Pacific Rim) of the International Association for Cognitive Education and Psychology. He received an Innovator Award from the Enterprise Challenge Unit of the Prime Minister’s Office of Singapore while he was the Director of the Temasek Centre for Problem-based Learning. Oon Seng’s current research focuses on cognitive psychology, problem solving, and mediated learning.
[email protected]
Jonggyu Bae is a social studies teacher at Sinseo High School in Seoul, Korea. He researched into Internet-enhanced problem-based learning for his Ph.D. degree at Seoul National University. His general research interests include powerful learning environments, Web-based learning, and issue-centered curricula.
[email protected]
Scott A. Chamberlin is Assistant Professor in elementary and early childhood education at the University of Wyoming, U.S.A., where he teaches undergraduate and graduate mathematics education classes as well as assessment classes. Scott holds a Ph.D. in educational psychology from Purdue University. His research interests include the intersection of mathematical problem solving, affect, and gifted education. Specifically, he has worked closely with modeleliciting activities and problem-based learning tasks.
[email protected]
Stefanie Chye completed her bachelor and master’s degrees at the University of Sydney and received her Ph.D. from the National Institute of Education, Singapore. She is a member of several professional organizations including the International Society for the Learning Sciences (ISLS), the European Association for Research in Learning and Instruction (EARLI), and the American
xvi
Contributors
Educational Research Association (AERA). Her research interests include selfregulated learning, sociocultural–historical theory, classroom discourse processes, and problem-based learning.
[email protected]
William E. J. Doane holds a Ph.D. in information science from the University at Albany, State University of New York, where he teaches computing courses, and a master’s degree in information and computer science from the University of Hawaii. He participated in a National Science Foundation–funded initiative in Hawaii to develop Web-based tools supporting K–12 teacher collaboration and professional development. Doane is a founding member of ACASE, a professional organization of educators and scientists working to improve education.
[email protected]
Jessie Ee is Associate Professor with the Psychological Studies Academic Group, National Institute of Education, Singapore. She obtained her Ph.D. from the University of Newcastle, Australia, specializing in educational psychology and a master’s degree from the National University of Singapore in the area of special education in mathematics, while she majored in English and psychology for her B.A. and special education for her B.Ed. Jessie is the main co-author of Thinking about Thinking: What Educators Need to Know. Her research interests include creative learning styles, motivation, strategy instruction of teachers, and selfregulation.
[email protected]
Claire Michelle Gerhardt graduated with a B.F.A. in industrial design from the Rhode Island School of Design and an M.S. in strategic industrial design from the Art Center College of Design, Pasadena, U.S.A., and studied in Singapore in collaboration with the French graduate business school INSEAD. She has worked as a lighting designer and freelance product designer. Claire enjoys projects that acknowledge cross-cultural dimensions, having lived on different continents and being multilingual. She is interested in the dynamics of creative work teams, designing new experiences, and teaching design methodology.
[email protected]
Clara E. Gerhardt is Professor and Chair of the Department of Family Studies, Samford University, U.S.A., and previously worked at the South African distance learning university, UNISA. She is the product of three continents: born in
Contributors
xvii
Europe, raised in Southern Africa, and now working and living in North America. Possessing an M.B.A. and a Ph.D., Clara is a clinical psychologist as well as a marriage and family therapist with special interests in family therapy, multicultural issues, education, and problem-based learning. She has presented her work on five continents and has published extensively.
[email protected]
Tjaart Imbos is Associate Professor and Senior Lecturer at the University of Maastricht, the Netherlands, specializing in statistics education and related research. He has a special interest in e-learning environments, effective feedback, and using statistical technology, such as latent semantic analysis, text mining, and Bayesian networks, to optimize learning environments.
[email protected]
Elizabeth Jordan is Senior Tenured Instructor in the Faculty of Education, University of British Columbia, Canada, where she earned her Ed.D. Her research interests in learning and pedagogy are specifically the enhancement of learning by understanding the developmental aspects of an individual’s way of knowledge acquisition, matching instruction and adapting the environment to support learning, and problem-based learning and its relationship to individual problem-solving capabilities.
[email protected]
Albert K. Liau is Associate Professor in the Department of Psychology, HELP University College, Malaysia, and previously Assistant Professor with the Psychological Studies Academic Group, National Institute of Education, Singapore. He is trained as a developmental psychologist and is a registered counselor. His research interests include resilience, the role of social–emotional development in children, and the social impact of Internet use on children.
[email protected]
Woon Chia Liu is Assistant Professor with the Psychological Studies Academic Group, National Institute of Education, Singapore. She holds a B.Sc. from the National University of Singapore, Dip.Ed. from the National Institute of Education, and M.Ed. and Ph.D. from the University of Nottingham. Her research interests include motivation and self-concept, as well as innovative teaching strategies such as project work and problem-based learning.
[email protected]
xviii
Contributors
Sari Poikela is Professor of Adult Education and heads the “Context-based Knowledge and Competence” research program at OUNAS Research Centre, Faculty of Education, University of Lapland, Finland. She has been involved in curriculum development work in many higher education organizations around Finland and has published several texts on problem-based learning. Her research and teaching areas include problem-based learning, assessment, university pedagogy, learning in adulthood, and qualitative research. sapoikel@ulapland.fi
Marion Porath is Professor in the Faculty of Education, University of British Columbia, Canada. She holds a Ph.D. from the University of Toronto. Her general research interests are different forms of giftedness, young children’s social development, instructional applications of developmental theory, and problem-based learning. Specifically, she is interested in children’s views of themselves as learners and their understanding of teaching, learning, and the social aspects of education; social giftedness; and instruction that supports social understanding.
[email protected]
Frans Ronteltap is Associate Professor in educational research and development at the University of Maastricht’s Educational Resources Centre, the Netherlands, involving for the most part in innovation projects focused on the implementation of new technologies in problem-based learning. In his career, he has specialized in instructional design, knowledge development, and knowledge management and has performed many evaluation studies as part of design research.
[email protected]
Donna Russell is Assistant Professor in the Curriculum and Instructional Leadership Department, School of Education, University of Missouri-Kansas City, U.S.A. The focus of her Ph.D. studies was educational psychology with an emphasis on cognition and technology. Donna’s research interests include the design and evaluation of three-dimensional collaborative virtual learning environments using cultural historical activity theory. She is implementing a Kauffman Foundation grant project to design three-dimensional virtual worlds for developing problem-based learning processes and geoscience content knowledge in urban high-school students.
[email protected]
Contributors
xix
Pauline Sameshima is Assistant Professor in the College of Education, Washington State University, as well as an exhibiting multimedia artist, lyricist, and designer. She researches issues in cultural studies, teacher education, technological learning environment design, and system organization. Pauline is interested in artful scholastic inquiry and alternate forms of knowledge production and acknowledgment. Her dissertation, Seeing Red, has been published as an epistolary novel.
[email protected]
Joette Stefl-Mabry is Associate Professor in the Department of Information Studies, College of Computing and Information, and Associate Research Professor in the Department of Educational Theory and Practice, School of Education, University at Albany, State University of New York. She is involved in teacher training for future teacher librarians, and believes that deep change in educational practices must begin during preservice training in order to have a lasting effect. jstefl@albany.edu
Chua-Tee Teo is Assistant Professor with the Psychological Studies Academic Group, National Institute of Education, Singapore. She has received two scholarships for postgraduate studies and has been invited to give talks and train teachers around Asia. Her areas of study include creative talent development, self-knowledge and volitional development, virtues and character development, teacher training in pedagogical knowledge, and differentiation of instruction. Her current research focuses on gifted leadership and ego studies.
[email protected]
Shipra Vaidya is Associate Professor at the National Council of Educational Research and Training, India. She specializes in human resource management and entrepreneurship development and has a strong interest in school education programs. Presently, she is working on a project assessing entrepreneurial spirit among elementary students. Shipra publishes regularly on the entrepreneurial needs of the young. Her paper “Developing Entrepreneurial Life Skills” was awarded the Best Newcomer’s Paper Award at the 2007 Institute of Small Business and Entrepreneurship Conference held in Glasgow, Scotland.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 1
Problems and Creativity Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
Abstract In a world filled with challenges where evolutionary and revolutionary innovations are increasingly valued, the capacity for creativity and innovation has emerged as all-important. This chapter argues that problems provide opportunities for innovation by acting as a catalyst for creative thought. It draws upon real-world examples of innovations and anecdotes from the lives of prominent creators to illustrate how problems can engage curiosity, inquiry, and thinking in meaningful and powerful ways. To be compatible with the demands exerted on individuals today, education must change such that problems are used as a means of fueling learning and as a vehicle for cultivating creativity. This need provides the basis for problem-based learning, an instructional method that encourages the development of creative thinking and creative problem solving. Recommendations for an education that is future-ready are considered, with emphasis placed on the salient role that must be granted to creativity and problem-based learning if this goal is to be achieved.
Introduction In September 2007, the first author was invited by the National Science Foundation (NSF) to give an Education and Human Resource Distinguished Lecture in Washington, D.C. Despite being the presenter, he discovered that he was learning a great deal from the questions posed by members of the distinguished audience. The presence of leading scientists, researchers, educators, and human resources experts turned an hour’s presentation into a meeting of minds. Fresh insights arise and
2
Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye
intuitive learning happens in interesting ways when multiple perspectives are woven and new synergies are sought. Although problems and challenges have always existed, they are coming with increasing frequency, complexity, and diversity. We face not only more and tougher problems but also newer problems and shorter time frames for problem resolution, as well as more global (larger scale) problems requiring integrated solutions. As such, the search for solutions, and how to do it effectively and expediently, becomes increasingly important. From issues as diverse as dealing with global environmental hazards, finding alternative energy sources, and arresting destructive trends in society to developing new drugs, raising agricultural yields, or simply improving a process, we need to look at problems anew. The purpose of research at NSF is to use scientia for the betterment of humanity, and billions of dollars is poured into research every year in the United States. In many other countries, including Singapore, more and more resources are also being directed at research and education, in the quest to solve the neverending problems of humanity. Scientia is the Latin word for “knowledge.” The knowledge that both basic and applied research feeds on today is multidisciplinary in nature. In this new millennium, knowledge is increasingly characterized by the creative integration of information and learning from diverse disciplines. Life science research would not be what it is today without the new connections made between chemistry, biology, physics, and computer technology. The advent of supercomputers has catalyzed research in life sciences and accelerated breakthroughs in biotechnology. The miniaturization of digital devices has been made possible by nanotechnology, a branch of material science, which combines engineering with the basic sciences of chemistry and physics. In industry and business, innovations are made often without the benefit of traditional learning paradigms and models. The real world, in fact, thrives on both evolutionary and revolutionary innovations. Incidentally, that September in 2007, Todd Siler of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology was having his works displayed at the gallery of NSF. Siler’s “artscience” of neurocosmology in many ways epitomizes the way to understand knowledge advancement today. The universe as Siler (1990) sees it imparts its creative processes to us. The creative God of this
Problems and Creativity
3
universe has given us an environment where creativity can be seen everywhere in the universe and in nature all around us. No wonder the observation of nature itself often yields ideas for replication and innovation. For example, by studying the dragonfly, scientists discovered the secret of a water sac that protects the insect’s delicate body, which led to a fighter pilot suit designed to prevent life-threatening tunnel vision and blackout during high-speed flights. Siler’s artscience brings home the power of connectivity. Like the power of neurons firing and connecting to produce a “mechanism of meaning” (a term Siler borrowed from the artist Arakawa and writer Madeline Gins), we need to appreciate the power of different perspectives and of different ways of observing and learning. Indeed, as Bronowski (1956) put it succinctly decades ago, “The scientist or the artist takes two facts or experiences which are separate; he finds in them a likeness which had not been seen before; and he creates a unity by showing the likeness” (p. 27).
Problems as Sources of Creativity Breakthroughs in science and technology are often the result of a fascination with problems. Great learning often begins with preoccupation with a problem, followed by taking ownership of the problem and harnessing multiple dimensions of thinking. The history of science reveals to us that necessity is often the mother of invention. During World War II, research in nuclear technology was accelerated in a desperate search for a powerful weapon that could defeat the invaders and end the atrocities they committed in Europe and Asia. Similarly, the mathematics of operations research was advanced as a result of looking for ways to optimize the combat effectiveness of warships in different locations in the ocean. Other than high technology, there are countless simple innovations that are designed to make our lives better or easier. After World War II, many parts of the world were threatened by food shortage. A Japanese entrepreneur by the name of Momofuku Ando wanted to lend a hand to help the thousands of starving people in different parts of the globe. But keeping food fresh, hygienic, and safe for consumption over long distances
4
Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye
was problematic. Noodle was a common staple, and Ando sought an economical way to bring it to people sometimes living in remote places. The problem led him to the idea of instant noodles that can be easily and quickly cooked. Ando invented the world’s first bag-packed “chicken ramen” and in 1948 founded Nissin Food Products. In 1971, he took it one step further and the “cup noodle” was born. Today, Nissin registers annual sales of some 300 billion yen. Problems can take various forms, such as failure to perform, situations in need of immediate attention or improvement, a need to find better or new ways to do things, unexplained phenomena or observations, gaps in information and knowledge, decision-making situations, or a need for new designs or innovations. If we adopt a mindset of learning from problems, there will be real improvement and advancement. The Defence Science Organisation in Singapore is known for its military innovations, such as lighter helmets, rifles, and field equipment designed for greater dexterity and effectiveness. Problems, big or small, can be opportunities for innovation. In Sri Lanka, villages used to rely on kerosene lamps that easily toppled over and rolled on the floor. Dr. Wijaya Godakumbura, a surgeon, found that 40 percent of accidental burn injuries were due to such lamps. But poverty did not permit villagers to switch to other, safer types of lighting. Dr. Godakumbura came up with a simple solution: a short and heavy lamp with two flat sides and a screw-on metal lid. This way the lamp would not topple easily and, even if it did, it would not roll and spill kerosene. Today, more than half a million lamps of this design are in use in Sri Lanka, and the International Red Cross has taken the design elsewhere, such as Banda Aceh in Indonesia. A problem triggers engagement in terms of emotional motivation and deep thinking. When we are solving a problem, we engage in an active search for meaningful information, a proactive immersion in the task, a conscious and subconscious investment of time on the task, and a search for meaning and explanation, along with the adoption of goal and future orientations. In real-world problem solving, the context always appears unstructured in the first instance, and it takes big picture thinking (i.e., a broad overview or a helicopter view of things), analytical thinking, as well as generative and divergent thinking to produce effective solutions.
Problems and Creativity
5
Education and Creativity Education today in many ways needs a new science of dealing with knowledge and information, together with a new art of observation and learning. Even in the past, Aristotle, Euclid, Galileo, Copernicus, Descartes, Boyle, Newton, da Vinci, and Pascal made use of the ways of knowing from both the humanities and the sciences. Contrary to Snow’s (1998) “two cultures” viewpoint, the sciences and the humanities as we know them today are complementary ways of knowing: acknowledging the reality of chaos and uncertainty yet employing the power of evidence and objectivity. A future-ready education must change and use “problems” for learning and infuse creative ways of observation to construct, derive, and create knowledge in students. Kline (1991) articulates most aptly that “the intelligent person is far more easily spotted from his response to new problems not his knowledge of old solutions” (p. 31). Since time immemorial, the intelligence of individuals has been gauged from the questions they ask and the problems they are able to solve. If only schools are able to nurture students who are curious and capable of solving new problems, we would have cultivated more intelligent and creative adults for the future society. The thrust of education is to help students construct their own knowledge about the world rather than passively receiving information. Educational programs with creative problem-solving orientations appear to also stimulate other creative processes in students (VanTassel-Baska & Stambaugh, 2006). The ability of problem-based learning to enhance creative thinking in students has been reported in various countries across disciplines. To solve real-world problems, we need not only logical thinking but also “ana-logical” thinking, the ability to creatively and laterally transfer a whole set of ideas across to another situation. In effective problem solving, not only do we need to be able to draw on and integrate knowledge from multiple disciplines, but we also have to be highly dexterous and flexible in employing diverse modes of thinking, such as seeing the big picture, generating new and alien ideas and viewpoints, as well as having a good sense of reality in terms of the constraints of circumstances, resources, the human perception, and so on. We must learn to be open to new ideas and approaches, and never box
6
Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye
ourselves in with preexisting assumptions and fixed ways of doing things. Problems can trigger curiosity, inquiry, and thinking in meaningful and powerful ways. Education needs a new perspective of searching for problems and looking at problems that will achieve the aim of helping students construct their own knowledge. In designing educational programs, we can learn much from the legacy of scientific discoveries. The ability to see a problem amidst a mass of information, to make observations and connections, and to take ownership of problems is necessary to problem solving. Sometimes, immersion in a problem leads to accidental discoveries. At a Stanford alumni gathering in Singapore, Professor Douglas Osheroff revealed how his work led to a Nobel Prize discovery. Osheroff was a graduate student of David Lee and Robert Richardson at Cornell University. At that time, they were looking for “a phase transition to a kind of magnetic order in frozen helium-3 ice,” but Osheroff ’s immersion in the problem led him to observe a different phenomenon: the superfluidity of helium-3. The breakthrough in lowtemperature physics won the team the 1996 Nobel Prize in Physics. Figure 1.1 illustrates how problems lead to cognition and learning. A problem triggers the context for engagement, curiosity, inquiry, and a quest to address a real-world concern. These psychological events, in turn, set in motion certain mental processes (cognition) and behavioral changes (learning).
Psychological events Problem
• Context for
engagement • Curiosity • Inquiry • Quest to address a real-world concern
Cognition and learning • Confronting unstructuredness,
ill-structuredness, and novelty • Active search for information • Proactive immersion in task • Conscious and subconscious
investment of time on task • Motivation to solve the problem:
need for meaning and explanation • Goal orientation • Generative thinking, analytical
thinking, divergent thinking, and synthesis
FIGURE 1.1 Problems lead to cognition and learning
Problems and Creativity
7
The Creative Process The creative ability may be understood as a form of cognitive fluidity underpinning the capacity to operate on familiar symbolic representations that allows novel ones to be generated (Gregory, 2004). Piirto (2004), after examining creativity from the psychological, psychoanalytic, philosophic, business, and technological perspectives, defines the creative process in terms of the seven I’s: inspiration, imagery, imagination, intuition, insight, incubation, and improvisation. Here, the creative process is viewed as a change in perception, or seeing new idea combinations, new relationships, new meanings, or new applications that have not been perceived before. The creative act may be regarded either as a mental or intellectual phenomenon, known as creative thinking or divergent thinking, or as a process that generates social and cultural products, such as music as well as works of art, science, and technology, a concept known as divergent production (Guilford, 1950). Treffinger describes the creative process as a sequence of stages through which a problem is solved systematically (Treffinger, 1996; Treffinger et al., 1994). The term creative problem solving was coined by Osborn (1963) and defined as comprising just three stages: (1) fact finding, including identifying a problem and gathering facts; (2) idea finding; and (3) solution finding, including evaluating and implementing ideas. Martindale (1999) notes the existence of distinct cognitive phases typical in problem solving, discovery, and creative and imagination-rich thinking. The first of these states of mind, the initial phase, is characterized by conscious logical and reality-oriented reasoning, or “secondary process thinking.” The next phase is incubation, a “fallow period” in which no apparent progress on the task or problem at hand is made, and a strong sense of frustration and block may be felt. Then, when the mind has not been consciously focused on the problem for a time, there is illumination or solution. Both the incubation and illumination phases are thought to be characterized by free-associative, nonlogical thinking, also called “primary process thinking.” In addition, the illumination phase is often noted to be accompanied by emotional euphoria, as epitomized by Archimedes’ “Eureka!” as he allegedly jumped from the bath upon
8
Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye
realizing the principle of displacement of a liquid by a solid. Many great composers and artists are reported to be most prolific when they are in a sustained form of euphoria. Better known are the stages of the creative process suggested by Graham Wallas in 1926 in The Art of Thought (cited in Davis & Rimm, 2004). These are preparation, incubation, illumination, and verification. The preparation stage involves the clarification and definition of the problem, review of relevant material, examination of the requirements for problem solution, collection of data, and understanding of implications, other innuendos, and previous unsuccessful solutions. The incubation stage is a period of “off-conscious” reflection when the person goes about his or her daily routine and is not actively seeking the solution. The third stage of illumination is when the solution suddenly appears to the person, as in the “Eureka!” or “Aha!” experience. This may come only after many hours of hard work or it may not come at all. The last stage is the verification of the solution, during which the feasibility, workability, or acceptability of the proposed solution is checked. These stages are not necessarily sequential; some may be skipped or the person may backtrack to an earlier stage (Davis & Rimm, 2004). Another way of looking at the creative process is to apply a two-stage model devised by Davis (1998) that involves a “big idea” stage and an “elaboration” stage. The big idea stage is a time of fantasy when one looks for a new, exciting idea or the solution to the problem. Upon stumbling on the “big idea,” one then proceeds to develop it such that it can be elaborated, extended, and implemented. For instance, the artist will first sketch preliminary drawings and then make refinements. The novelist must first draft the story and then revise and re-revise it. The researcher or the entrepreneur needs to organize the details of the big idea before carrying out the work required for its implementation. In whatever way a person understands the creative process or the production of creative outputs, one would invariably look for attributes of fluency, flexibility, originality, and elaboration, as described by Torrance (1966, 1995) and Guilford (1967). And as teachers, we are all too aware of the positive effects of teaching for creativity in the classroom and cultivating creative traits in students. So how do we go about nurturing creativity?
Problems and Creativity
9
Problem-based Learning and Creative Problem Solving The problem-based learning (PBL) process essentially consists of the following stages: (1) meeting the problem; (2) problem analysis and generation of learning issues; (3) discovery and reporting; (4) solution presentation and reflection; and (5) overview, integration, and evaluation, with self-directed learning bridging one stage and the next (Tan, 2003). In PBL, the problem is cast in a realistic context that the student might encounter in future. Although creative individuals tend to work alone, students in PBL classes work in groups brainstorming issues pertaining to the understanding of the problem and defining it by group consensus. They then work independently on their own to search for more information related to the problem before generating hypotheses and possible explanations to the problem. While this stage may be similar to some of the stages involved in creative problem solving (CPS), PBL in addition calls for the formulation of learning objectives and the assignment of selfdirected learning and peer teaching. The discovery stage in PBL is limited to researching existing information found in books and on the Internet. It is not intuitive like the “Eureka!” experience at the illumination stage of the creative process. Although the discovery process in PBL may be speedy and time-saving, originality may be compromised. On the other hand, by sharing research work and findings, learning is augmented for students in PBL, as the sum of learning by the group is greater than the learning by the individual students or the teaching given by a single teacher in the routine classroom. However, students must be taught to be critical and not blindly accept and follow the ideas put forth by peers. Otherwise, they may lose their ability to think independently or to discriminate between good and poor ideas. Blind imitation also stifles creativity. The articulation of the learning and knowledge acquired in the attempt to solve the given problem helps students clarify their thinking and formulate conceptions accurately and contextually. This stage of PBL encourages students to reflect consciously on their learning, although reflection in the creative process occurs at the incubation stage and is not fully conscious. Finally, the review, evaluation, and integration
10
Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye
of learning across disciplines at the last stage of PBL enables the learner to make sense of the new knowledge constructed as a result of problem solving. In all instances of learning, students need to be involved in active thinking, both creative and critical. Thinking cannot occur in a vacuum; it has to take place within a system (Elder & Paul, 2007), like in the context of a problem. Thinkers mentally create provisional small-scale logical models for figuring out the system to be understood, which may or may not match reality. Whether it is PBL or CPS, students are urged to collect evidence, test hypotheses, draw inferences on possible solutions to the problem, and then evaluate the outcomes. When thinking something through for the first time, one generates new ideas, new assumptions, and new concepts by asking new questions, making new inferences, and allowing views to form in new directions. This is basically a creative act. Reasoning or critical thinking is inherently creative, and we need to recognize that critical and creative thinking are inseparable and integrated (Elder & Paul, 2007). In both PBL and CPS, students usually remember some parts of what was figured out previously and then work out the rest anew as they strive to connect new understandings and discoveries to their prior knowledge. However, novel solutions alone are not enough for resolving a problem. Worthless novelty is easy to produce, but whatever synthesized as the solution must meet the intellectual criteria or intrinsic standards known for the intended product or outcome. Creative methods like brainstorming and insight development may be helpful in generating useful ideas or workable solutions and in understanding the problem for both PBL and CPS. While PBL and CPS are similar in their goals and the use of critical and creative thinking in problem solving, they differ in thrust or emphasis, their practical applications, and the degree of divergence and complexity. The thrust of PBL is to nurture self-directed learners (Tan, 2003), and here the aim of promoting creativity is to inculcate an independent attitude to problem identification and solution. The understanding built from self-directed learning is augmented through the sharing of learning experiences with one’s group. PBL is designed to provide a realistic and practical setting for collaborative learning, with all members of the group
Problems and Creativity
11
contributing to problem solving. It is thus more efficient as work is shared. PBL naturally finds its applications more in group-based learning, while CPS applies more to individual settings. Consequently, the pool of ideas generated by the different group members tends to exhibit a higher degree of divergence and complexity compared with the ideas generated by the individual in CPS.
Recommendations We recommend that schools begin with PBL and at the same time encourage the development of creativity and the creative attributes of risk taking and divergent and convergent thinking in students. The rationale for employing PBL in developing creativity is that students feel more confident when working in groups. Creativity is more readily developed in disciplinary areas where the content and process of learning are susceptible to “creative treatment.” Students may be exposed to different artistic media and ways of expressing themselves orally, visually, or kinesthetically, in words, dance, or other creative modes. Teachers may ask students open-ended questions and deploy problem-based scenarios to illicit unusual responses. Reflecting on ideas and considering alternatives constantly is a way to ensure that fresh ideas surface. It appears that creativity evolves from students’ deep knowledge of a domain and self-knowledge (VanTasselBaska & Stambaugh, 2006). Providing students with opportunities to plan, monitor, and assess their own work is crucial to becoming more creative. Giving alternative forms of assignments and allowing choice encourage students to become flexible and creative as well. Another way of helping students understand the development of creativity is to read to them biographies or autobiographies of individuals who have achieved creative breakthroughs in various fields, so that students may appreciate the obstacles that creative personalities need to overcome, the many failures that they have gone through, and the immense amount of effort that they have put in. This will create in students a cognitive and affective awareness of the hardship associated with the development of creative abilities (VanTassel-Baska & Stambaugh, 2006).
12
Oon-Seng Tan, Chua-Tee Teo, and Stefanie Chye
The above recommendations form a two-pronged approach in fostering problem-solving abilities and nurturing creativity. With PBL implemented in schools, students will become proficient in the methodology of guided discovery learning. At the same time, as teachers strive to provide the pedagogy and environment to nurture creativity in various subject areas, including incorporating PBL as part of the curriculum, students will gradually integrate creative attributes into their lives. With the passage of time and with maturity, highly creative students will surpass their peers and may go on to produce original and true scientific discoveries or great artistic innovations. The progress of humankind is obviously dependent on our ability to create and be creative, not only in problem solving but also in understanding uncharted territories yet to be conquered by the all-powerful human mind or intellect. With PBL as a solid foundation in the training of young students to solve real-life problems through inquiry and independent learning and thinking, we are one step nearer to the goal of education, namely, to bring civilization to greater heights, joyfully.
References Bronowski, J. (1956). Science and human values. New York: Julian Messner. Davis, G. A. (1998). Creativity is forever (4th ed.). Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt. Davis, G. A., & Rimm, S. B. (2004). Education of the gifted and talented (5th ed.). Boston: Pearson/Allyn & Bacon. Elder, L., & Paul, R. (2007). Critical thinking: The nature of critical and creative thought, Part II. Journal of Developmental Education, 30(3), 36–37. Gregory, R. L. (Ed.) (2004). The Oxford companion to the mind (2nd ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Guilford, J. P. (1950). Creativity. American Psychologist, 5, 444–454. Guilford, J. P. (1967). The nature of human intelligence. New York: McGraw-Hill. Kline, P. (1991). Intelligence: The psychometric view. London: Routledge. Martindale, C. (1999). Biological bases of creativity. In R. J. Sternberg (Ed.), Handbook of creativity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Osborn, A. F. (1963). Applied imagination: Principles and procedures of creative problem-solving (3rd ed.). New York: Scribner. Piirto, J. (2004). Understanding creativity. Scottsdale, AZ: Great Potential Press. Siler, T. (1990). Breaking the mind barrier: The artscience of neurocosmology. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Problems and Creativity
13
Snow, C. P. (1998). The two cultures. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Tan, O. S. (2003). Problem-based learning innovation: Using problems to power learning in the 21st century. Singapore: Thomson Learning. Torrance, E. P. (1966). Torrance tests of creative thinking. Bensenville, IL: Scholastic Testing Service. Torrance, E. P. (1995). Why fly? A philosophy of creativity. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing. Treffinger, D. J. (1996). Dimensions of creativity. Sarasota, FL: Center for Creative Learning. Treffinger, D. J., Isaksen, S. G., & Dorval, K. B. (1994). Creative problem solving: An introduction (rev. ed.). Sarasota, FL: Center for Creative Learning. VanTassel-Baska, J., & Stambaugh, T. (2006). Comprehensive curriculum for gifted learners (3rd ed.). Boston: Pearson/Allyn & Bacon.
CHAPTER 2
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review of the Literature Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
Abstract Problem-based learning (PBL) has been widely touted to be an effective instructional method for the present climate of change and innovation. Supporters vehemently contend that it is an effective means of cultivating creativity. These claims, while promising in theory, seem to lack systematic empirical support. Consequently, it is prudent to scrutinize existing evidence to determine if the increased resources required for PBL are indeed balanced by its educational benefits. This chapter reviews the literature from 2000–2008 in an attempt to determine the efficacy of PBL in fostering creativity. Results of the exploratory review seem to indicate that, although there exists a corpus of studies documenting the positive effects of PBL, their academic rigor and quality are in question. Caution should thus be exercised in proclaiming PBL as a panacea for our education system’s deficiencies in nurturing creativity. In conclusion, areas for future research and the steps that need to be taken to advance knowledge in this sphere are considered.
Introduction: Creativity and Education Creativity is increasingly valued as an essential capability in this age of information. As such, the role of education in fostering creative competencies has received greater emphasis. At the same time, traditional methods of instruction have been criticized for their inadequacies in preparing students for the present climate of change and innovation.
16
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
The need for flexible thinking, an issue that has pervaded discussions of classroom reform, has sparked interest in the potential of the problembased learning instructional method for meeting today’s educational needs. Education has tended to be preoccupied with the traditional form of assessment (i.e., examinations), which often creates mental defaults that generally lead to students focusing on seeking a single “best” answer. In shifting the emphasis to problem solving, we take a cognitive approach that focuses on thinking abilities as the basis of creative work. The term creative is used in a broad sense to mean having the capacity to come up with “original, inventive and novel ideas” (Cropley, 1992, p. 6). Despite its widespread application, the concept of creativity has nevertheless defied a single agreed definition. Creativity is the basis for discovery and innovation. It is considered to be chiefly characterized by two qualities: novelty and usefulness (Sternberg & Lubart, 1996). Definitions have varied depending on whether the researchers define creativity in terms of the creative person, the creative process, the creative product, or the creative environment (Amabile, 1983) and on the researchers’ theoretical perspectives (Ng, 2001). However, product definitions are widely regarded as most useful for creativity research, even among those whose research interests lie in other aspects of creativity (Amabile, 1983). The study of the impact of creative abilities involves understanding creativity in relation to (1) the intrapersonal system and attributes, (2) affective–motivational processes, (3) mediated learning processes, (4) specific cognitive functions related to creativity, (5) creative-thinking and problem-solving tools, and (6) outcomes in the form of real innovations. Interventions in developing creativity assume that deficiencies in creative thinking and skills are attributable to a lack of cognitive intervention and a conducive environment. Creativity is often the result of optimizing various ways of thinking and building on elements of (1) the affective–motivational domain, (2) systematic–strategic thinking, (3) analytical–inferential thinking, and (4) divergent thinking. The affective–motivational domain sets the philosophy and spirit of participation in and commitment to problem-based activities. Systematic and strategic thinking encompasses reflective practice, systematic problem solving, systems thinking, and strategic thinking. Analytical–inferential
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
17
thinking refers to cognitive functions such as comparison, classification, analytic perception and analysis, logical and inferential thinking, and problem-solving heuristics. Divergent thinking is thinking that radiates or flows outward from an idea or concept, in contrast to convergent thinking, which refers to a collection of information or ideas that focus on a single idea or possibility. Divergent thinking leads to contact with many other ideas, which may include ideas or possibilities that one might not ordinarily consider, and as such it has been argued that it can result in the discovery of remote associations and insights, such as the unusual uses of a common object (Finke, 1995). There have been many studies on divergent thinking and creativity (e.g., Cropley, 1992; Csikszentmihalyi, 1988; Guilford, 1950, 1956, 1970, 1988; Lubart, 1994; Osborn, 1953; Runco, 1991; Sternberg & Davidson, 1995; Torrance, 1986; Treffinger, 1994). However, Piirto (1992) questions whether divergent thinking abilities alone lead to creativity. The many debatable issues pertaining to conceptions of divergent thinking, creativity, and intelligence are beyond the scope of this chapter. Our purpose here is to highlight those aspects of problem-based learning which support the development of cognitive functions that facilitate creativity. While abilities such as generating novel and interesting ideas are often described as creative, Torrance (1986) and Sternberg (1996) point out that creativity also involves the analytical aspects of analysis, evaluation, problem solving, and decision making. How does creativity come about? Lubart (1994) cites the following approaches to the conception of creativity: (1) mystical, (2) psychodynamic, (3) cognitive, (4) social–psychological, and (5) confluence. The mystical approach subscribes to the notion of a supernatural source of creativity (see, e.g., Ghiselin, 1985). The individual is seen as an empty vessel and creative works as the result of inspiration from a divine or mystical source. The psychodynamic approach suggests that creativity arises from the tension between conscious reality and unconscious drives. Freud (1959) contends that writers and artists produce creative work as a way to express their unconscious wishes in a publicly acceptable fashion, citing eminent creators such as Leonardo da Vinci to support his theory.
18
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
The cognitive approach focuses on thinking abilities and knowledge as the basis of creative work (see, e.g., Guilford, 1950, 1988; Torrance, 1974, 1986). It emphasizes various facets of mental abilities that are linked to creativity. These include divergent thinking, perceptual processes, problem-definition and problem-solving skills, insight skills, induction skills, and the ability to form associations and analogies. More recently, cognitive approaches have also brought in biological bases of creativity, such as the hemispheric roles of the brain. The social–psychological approach focuses on personality variables, motivational variables, and the sociocultural environment as sources of creativity (see, e.g., Barron, 1968). For example, it is argued that creativity in diverse cultures has been linked to environmental variables such as the availability of role models, availability of resources, and how people judge creativity. The confluence approach adopts partial synthesis of approaches such as those above and hypothesizes that multiple components must converge for creativity to occur. Thus, Csikszentmihalyi (1988), for example, has taken a “systems” approach that emphasizes the role of the individual (via cognitive processes, personality traits, and motivation), the field (consisting of people who influence a domain and evaluate new ideas), and the domain (the culturally defined symbol system that transmits creative products to others and to future generations). Sternberg and Lubart (1995) also adopt a confluence approach that relates specific aspects of intelligence, knowledge, thinking styles, personality, motivation, and the environment to creativity. Among these approaches, Lubart (1994) notes that since Guilford’s presentation of creativity in 1950 “the cognitive approach has dominated ideas about the source of creativity” (p. 296). Apart from theorizing about what creativity is exactly, researchers have also been interested in articulating the specific components involved. In the componential theory of creativity, Amabile (1983, 1996) proposes that creativity involves three major components that are sets of elements which control, determine, and enter into creative processes. The three components are, specifically, domain-relevant skills, creativity-relevant skills, and task motivation, and they are regarded as factors essential to the production of creative responses and works. Although these three main components constitute a complete
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
19
set of generic factors necessary for creativity, the listing and elaboration of the elements within each component awaits further research.
Problem-based Learning for Nurturing Creativity? Problem-based learning (PBL) has been advocated as an alternative, more progressive approach to instruction and one that is premised on offering opportunities for exercising creativity and for its development (Barak, 2006; Tan, 2000b). The embrace of this teaching methodology has, however, been met with some trepidation. This is due in part to the major curricular overhaul that accompanies it and to the multitude of resources that are associated with its implementation (Koh et al., 2008). And while it appears to be promising in theory, systematic empirical evidence is still lacking. Before PBL is advocated as an effective means of cultivating creativity, it would be prudent to scrutinize the evidence and determine if the increased resources required are balanced by the educational benefits. As such, a review of PBL is timely. The purpose of this chapter is to examine the research in the specific area of PBL and creativity in the hope that it would shed light on the efficacy of this instructional method in fostering creative thinking.
Framing the Review PBL has been widely heralded as a methodology that prepares individuals for an ever-changing and evolving knowledge-based society. Supporters contend that, by shifting the focus from content acquisition to achieving broader educational goals, PBL can help individuals be content experts, problem solvers, team players, and lifelong learners, all of which are desired outcomes of education (see, e.g., Dunlap, 2005b; Tan, 2003). Among the outcomes that PBL can potentially produce is the capability for creative thought, which has recently drawn much attention from educators (Barak, 2006; Kwon et al., 2006; Semerci, 2006; Tan, 2000b). It is theorized that by having authentic problems rather than content as the focal point, and with students assuming the role of active problem
20
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
solvers and teachers as facilitators or guides, higher-level thinking skills are likely to be attained (Semerci, 2006; Tan, 2000a). PBL encourages students to look for new solutions to the problems presented using available knowledge and resources. This process is believed to enhance their creative capabilities (Kwon et al., 2006; Ward & Lee, 2002). In facilitation or coaching, teachers do not steer students to a single, “correct” way of thinking; instead, they indicate that there may not be clear-cut right and wrong answers but different degrees of “right” answers (Gallagher & Stepien, 1995). In the process, creative thinking is stimulated. Despite the strong interest garnered for PBL as a possible means of cultivating creative competencies, and despite its sound theoretical rationale, systematic evidence for a positive relationship between PBL and creativity is scarce. It is dissatisfying to assume on the basis of theorizing alone that establishing good conditions for creative thinking by applying instructional methods such as PBL would necessarily promote creativity. Therefore, in this review, we will compile the findings of studies that have been conducted to assess the impact of PBL on creativity, in order to construct a more coherent picture of this body of research. In an endeavor to cover the most recent research, we have focused on studies conducted in the period 2000–2008.
The Search Process and Terms Conducting a literature review of the effectiveness of PBL in cultivating creativity is a process of construction and selection. It is important, therefore, to be reflexive and to make explicit the motives that initiated the review, the selection criteria employed, and the conclusions drawn (Foster & Hammersley, 1998). To ensure consistency and reduce bias, it is advantageous to follow a systematic approach in which a specific protocol is used to guide the review process (Stevens, 2007). In cases where the field is broad and vague or where the available resources are limited, a more flexible approach can be considered, as it will provide room for informed change in the proposed protocol (Badger et al., 2000). Specific but flexible protocols were used to guide and focus the process of this literature review, owing to the small number of studies investigating PBL and creativity specifically but the relatively large literature base focusing on PBL.
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
21
The following criteria were established initially to guide the selection of studies for review: 1. The studies should be empirical and data-based. 2. They should be published in peer-reviewed journals from 2000 to 2008. 3. Studies on all educational levels and across all domains would be included to broaden the scope. Although these criteria guided the review process, there were studies that did not fulfill one of the criteria but were included because they were perceived as important or landmark studies. Bibliographic databases such as ERIC, Education Research Complete, PsycARTICLES, PsycCRITIQUES, PsycINFO, and ProQuest Education as well as psychology journals were searched for relevant peer-refereed journal articles using specific search queries. The key search terms included “problem-based learning,” “creativity,” and “creative thinking.” A search was also made of major journals on education and psychology as well as other journals in which research on PBL is likely to be published. This process uncovered a particular journal on PBL called the Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-based Learning. Cross-references to other potentially interesting articles were also followed up on. The search produced a miniscule number of relevant studies focused specifically on PBL and creativity. As such, the search was broadened to examine PBL and its impact on specific components of creativity, such as knowledge, self-directed learning, self-regulated learning, critical thinking skills, problem-solving skills, and motivation. This unearthed a corpus of about 3,930 articles. For the literature review to be completed in the allotted space and time, the vast number of articles were sorted by relevance and then their titles scanned quickly. This effort guided decisions on which articles to include and was followed by a scan of the abstracts, which reduced the number of articles to 235. Of these studies, selection for inclusion in this review was made on the basis of whether they were deemed to be important, salient, or interesting, to offer contrasting perspectives, or to be good studies. This review process follows the model of literature review that has been called a “trawl of literature” (Badger et al., 2000), which is commonly employed and serves the purpose of
22
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
acknowledging sources and sharing writings and research that are interesting and valuable. The same process was employed for the remaining 64 indirect but related studies of PBL and creativity.
Evaluating the Impact of PBL on Creativity: A Review of the Literature Although not many studies have been conducted to directly investigate the relationship between PBL and creativity, there is a corpus of studies that could shed light on how PBL impacts upon the different creativity components. These investigations primarily take the form of experimental and quasi-experimental studies in naturalistic settings as well as large-scale meta-analyses, albeit mostly in the area of medical education. Most of the studies also focus on comparing PBL with traditional modes of instruction. In the rest of this chapter, an analysis of the literature on PBL and creativity is presented.
PBL and Creativity In one of the few noteworthy efforts to directly investigate the link between PBL and creativity, Tan (2000b) examined the impact of a PBL intervention program on students’ creativity. Participants comprised experimental and control groups of first-year polytechnic students studying engineering or the applied sciences. Comparing posttest with pretest results, PBL students in both engineering and the applied sciences demonstrated significant gains in creative abilities. Encouraging results have similarly been reported with students in middle grades that showed PBL curricula had the potential to develop mathematical creativity (Kwon et al., 2006; Chamberlin & Moon, 2005). Although studies that directly investigate the link between PBL and creative capacities have been scarce, there is indirect evidence that may provide some insights. These studies have separately examined the impact of PBL on various components of creative production that may be under-
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
23
stood in terms of the three components of creativity defined by Amabile: domain-relevant skills, creativity-relevant skills, and task motivation.
PBL and Domain-relevant Skills Domain-relevant skills provide the fundamental basis for any creative performance to occur. They include factual knowledge or domain knowledge, technical skills, and special talents in the domain in question. To date, this is the aspect of creativity with which formal education has been most concerned (Ruscio & Amabile, 1996), and it is also the component of creativity on which PBL research has mostly focused. There is some evidence that has a bearing on understanding the effectiveness of PBL in fostering this dimension of creativity. Although the findings are equivocal, the majority of studies reviewed indicate that PBL can make positive contributions to the development of domain knowledge. Specifically, it can help students construct an extensive and flexible knowledge base that constitutes an important part of the domain-relevant skills necessary for creativity to occur. Pioneering work using meta-analysis to examine research conducted in the area of medical education found that medical students on PBL curricula scored slightly lower than their conventional counterparts on measures of basic science knowledge but slightly better in tests assessing clinical problem solving and on ratings and tests of clinical performance (see, e.g., Albanese & Mitchell, 1993; Vernon & Blake, 1993). In a more recent landmark meta-analysis that endeavored to examine studies outside medical education, PBL was found to have a nonrobust effect on the knowledge of students but a significant moderate positive effect on their knowledge application abilities. In addition, PBL students gained slightly less knowledge but retained more of the acquired knowledge compared with their conventional counterparts (Dochy et al., 2003). In a study comparing the effectiveness of PBL with traditional teaching in an undergraduate psychiatry program, PBL students performed significantly better in examinations both in multiple-choice questions and the viva (McParland et al., 2004). A similar investigation reported better examination performance from PBL students of physical therapy than
24
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
from the lecture-based group, although the difference was not significant (Kasai et al., 2006). Outside medical education, comparisons of PBL with traditional modes of instruction have similarly yielded encouraging results. As a departure from studies that looked at outcome variables, Hmelo-Silver (2000) examined the artifacts that preservice teachers produced in a problem-based educational psychology course. She reported that although the preservice teachers’ initial understanding of course concepts was weak, as the course progressed they were able to identify appropriate concepts and apply them with more sophistication across multiple problems. Utilizing pre- and post-test research designs, Derry and colleagues similarly found that, after employing PBL, undergraduate students studying statistical reasoning showed improvement in some of the course content (Derry et al., 2000), while another sample of preservice teachers applied more relevant concepts and produced more sophisticated explanations in an assessment task involving the analysis of a video (Derry et al., 2002). Beyond undergraduate and professional education contexts, much less work has been done on younger students. Nonetheless, steps have been taken to advance this line of investigation. In a PBL unit on designing artificial lungs, sixth-grade students demonstrated greater gains on a drawing task and in a true-or-false test than control students that suggested they had a better conceptual understanding and a more systematic view of the respiratory system. Although their understandings may be rudimentary and fragmented in areas, they showed clear advancement (Hmelo et al., 2000). PBL was also found to be more effective than the traditional lecture–discussion approach in developing high-school students’ macroeconomics knowledge, although the improvement was modest (Maxwell et al., 2005; Mergendoller et al., 2006). While such studies have provided insights into the effectiveness of PBL in developing the domain-relevant skills necessary for creativity to occur, they were not adequately controlled for potentially confounding variables (Colliver, 2000). To address this concern, Capon and Kuhn (2004) conducted a controlled systematic experimental study in naturalistic instructional settings on adult students enrolled in an executive MBA program with the aim of documenting specific learning outcomes occurring in a specified time frame that were clearly attributable to the
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
25
PBL method. They observed that students who experienced PBL not only demonstrated improved understanding but were better able to make sense of things in that they were more competent at integrating newly introduced concepts with existing knowledge and showed enhanced conceptual coherence as well as the ability to restructure conceptual understanding. Taken together, there is a substantial body of research that, to some extent, points to the effectiveness of PBL in supporting the development of domain-relevant skills. The findings in this area of research, however, have not been consistently encouraging. A review of controlled evaluation studies conducted from 1974 to 2000 in continuing medical education, for instance, found limited evidence that PBL increased participants’ knowledge and performance (Smits et al., 2002). More recently, Burris (2005), using a quasi-experimental design to compare secondary agriculture students on PBL with students on supervised study, an instructional technique where students are given basic reference materials to help them find information on their own, reported that PBL students obtained lower scores on content knowledge than students on supervised study. Similar findings have been produced by other researchers that showed no difference in the knowledge acquired between PBL medical students and students attending conventional lecture-based classes (e.g., Beers, 2005; Lycke et al., 2006). On the whole, results are not consistent nor conclusive (see, e.g., the meta-analysis by Gijbels et al., 2005). This is in spite of evidence indicating that PBL can foster, across different domains, the development of domain-relevant knowledge and skills in undergraduate and professional educational contexts (Hmelo-Silver, 2004).
PBL and Creativity-relevant Skills The second component of creative processes is creativity-relevant skills, which include knowledge of heuristics for generating novel ideas as well as appropriate cognitive styles and working styles. A creative working style is characterized by an ability to concentrate for long periods of time and a sense of when to put the problem aside. It is also related to self-discipline, the ability to delay gratification, perseverance in the face of frustration,
26
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
independence, and nondependence on social approval (Amabile, 1983, 1996; Ruscio & Amabile, 1996). The ability for self-regulation or selfdirection is part of this working style. It should be noted that, while there is a greater tendency to use the term self-directed learning (SDL) in the PBL literature, some researchers also employ the similar term selfregulated learning (SRL) (Lycke et al., 2006). The two terms are used interchangeably in this chapter. At the descriptive level, self-regulated, self-directed individuals are confident, diligent, resourceful, purposeful, strategic-minded, and persistent (Purdie et al., 1996; Zimmerman, 1990). These individuals take the initiative in identifying their learning needs, formulating their learning goals, and choosing their learning resources (Knowles, 1975). They are able to effectively monitor, regulate, and sustain the learning process as well as to apply a variety of appropriate and efficient strategies to the learning problems encountered. They are further capable of maintaining a sense of competence, motivation, and personal agency, accurately diagnosing the character and demands of particular learning challenges, and effectively utilizing and controlling environmental factors that have a bearing on learning outcomes (Lindner & Harris, 1993). One of the claims of PBL is that it emphasizes the development of SDL or SRL (see, e.g., Hmelo-Silver, 2004). Indeed, there is evidence to support this, such as PBL students’ exhibition of more SDL behaviors (Hmelo & Lin, 2000) and significantly better SDL skills (Kasai et al., 2006) than students on a traditional curriculum. These findings have been corroborated with medical students (Lycke et al., 2006; Schmidt et al., 2006), undergraduate computer science students (Dunlap, 2005b), as well as undergraduate physiotherapy students (Yeung et al., 2003). PBL has been reported to produce positive effects on important aspects of SRL in high-school students (Sungur & Tekkaya, 2006), as well as students’ selfdirectedness, although this was dependent on the size of the PBL group (Lohman & Finkelstein, 2000). Blumberg (2000) concluded from a review of the literature on SDL in PBL students that PBL fosters SDL behaviors by encouraging learners to actively seek out information and compelling them to use deep-level processing strategies. Self-direction is promoted as students engage in activities that encourage and enable them to assume more responsibility for their own learning, that urge them to make their
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
27
cognitive processes overt so that they can monitor and assess the effectiveness of their thinking, and that enculturate them into self-regulation by engaging them in relevant, authentic, and discipline-focused activities (Dunlap, 2005a). Nonetheless, reviews have established that research on this aspect of PBL has not been extensive (Colliver, 2000; Hmelo-Silver, 2004; Kelson, 2000). Work has largely been confined to students in professional training; as such, there is scope for extension to other populations, including younger students, such as those at K–12 levels (Hmelo-Silver, 2004). Further, Kelson (2000) has raised the criticism that, paradoxically, SDL or SRL has been stipulated simultaneously as both a prerequisite and an outcome of PBL. Coupled with the paucity of research in this area, the assumption of PBL’s contribution may well be erroneous. As a result, some researchers have hypothesized that, while PBL may provide students with the opportunity to develop SDL skills, it may be the case that PBL in itself does not develop the skills (Norman & Schmidt, 1992). As Evensen aptly concludes, “PBL curricula, although requiring self-regulation, do not necessarily develop positive forms of self-regulation” (Evensen et al., 2001, p. 661). Apart from the ability for self-regulation or self-direction, creativityrelevant skills can also include critical-thinking and problem-solving capabilities. Creativity cannot be divorced from the ability for critical thought, and the two of them are “inseparable, integrated, and unitary” (Elder & Paul, 2007, p. 36). Similarly, problem-solving abilities are regarded by many researchers as one of the most important parts of creativity (Lee & Cho, 2007). Studies focusing on the effectiveness of PBL in promoting the development of critical-thinking and problem-solving skills have produced equivocal results. Moore (2007), in evaluating the use of PBL in a baccalaureate dental hygiene program, found positive outcomes in both the target skills of critical thinking and problem solving. Semerci (2006) observed that PBL improved the critical thinking skills of education students in their second year of study. Graduate psychology students in Hays and Vincent’s (2004) study felt that PBL promoted critical thinking compared with traditional instructional methods. Undergraduate nursing students on PBL were also reported to register significantly higher scores in critical thinking disposition than those receiving lecture-based instruction, and
28
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
they continued to show higher scores for two years afterwards, although to a lesser degree (Tiwari et al., 2006). Compared with those from a conventional medical school, graduates of a medical school adopting the PBL approach rated themselves as having better problem-solving competencies (Schmidt et al., 2006). In contrast to the above findings, other investigations have yielded less favorable results. Secondary agriculture students on PBL produced lower scores on critical thinking abilities when matched against the comparison group put on supervised study (Burris, 2005). PBL was also found not to have substantial effects on the critical-thinking and problemsolving abilities of pharmacy students (Cheng et al., 2003). Lohman and Finkelstein (2000), studying the impact of PBL on students enrolled in a dental education program, observed no significant differences between pre- and post-test measures on any of the problem-solving tasks assigned. However, the authors suggest on the basis of prior literature (Joyce & Weil, 1996; Lohman & Finkelstein, 1999; Newbert & Binko, 1992) that the continual use of PBL over an extended period of time may have a greater probability of promoting this skill. While the findings on critical thinking skills have been generally positive, the mixed results obtained for problem-solving skills have led to conflicting conclusions among researchers with some concluding that PBL has no obvious effect on learners’ problem-solving skills (e.g., Lam, 2004) and others concluding that it does (e.g., Gijbels et al., 2005; Hmelo-Silver, 2004).
PBL and Task Motivation The third component of creativity—task motivation—accounts for motivational variables that determine an individual’s approach to a given task, including one’s attitude toward the task and self-perceived motivation for undertaking the task (Amabile, 1983, 1996). PBL possesses the potential to enhance creativity given the contention that it enhances intrinsic motivation. Thus, it is unfortunate that there is a paucity of research that bears directly on this component, with much of the work focusing on student attitudes or satisfaction instead (Hmelo-Silver, 2004).
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
29
Brinkerhoff and Glazewski (2000), in examining the attitudes of sixth-grade gifted students as well as their teachers toward a hypermedia PBL instructional unit, found evidence that PBL had positive effects on student enjoyment, engagement, and effort, although this was to a large extent determined by their teachers’ experience with student-centered teaching methods. Major and Palmer (2001) noted from their review of the literature on medical school research a positive change in student attitudes toward learning when PBL was used, with these students tending to report greater satisfaction and to have more positive attitudes toward their course experiences than those in non-PBL courses. Specifically, these students found their courses to be more engaging and useful. Other reviews of research conducted, not necessarily with medical students, have come to similar conclusions on the effects of PBL on students’ attitudes and course opinions (e.g., Albanese & Mitchell, 1993; Chung & Chow, 2004; Lam, 2004; Vernon & Blake, 1993). Dunlap (2005b) extended this body of research beyond student attitudes to students’ self-efficacy, that is, the judgment they make about their own ability to perform a specific task. She observed that self-efficacy of the computer science undergraduates in her study rose by the end of the semester and suggested that the PBL environment could have helped build the students’ confidence so that they saw themselves as competent software development professionals who were ready for the workplace. Dunlap’s findings are substantiated by other investigations. Middle-school students’ self-efficacy in learning science increased after their engagement with a computer-enhanced PBL environment (Liu et al., 2006). Nursing students’ perception of empowerment was significantly augmented with PBL, and this perception in turn would likely determine work behavior and attitude (Siu et al., 2005). Such perception was also found to be a significant determinant of health sciences students’ intrinsic interest in the subject matter, although this was dependent on how well the tutorial group functioned and on the quality of the problems employed (Van Berkel & Schmidt, 2000). In contrast to the above results on PBL and student motivation, research yielding mixed findings has been cited by Hmelo-Silver (2004). A study conducted with students attending a PBL course in statistical reasoning found that while some students really enjoyed the class, others
30
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
resisted making changes to the way they learned and still others disliked various aspects of PBL such as collaborative work (Derry et al., 2000). Although evidence of enhanced motivation has been reported with veterinary students (Ertmer et al., 1996), Hmelo-Silver cautions on the basis of Abrandt Dahlgren and Dahlgren’s work (2002) with students from different disciplines that PBL’s effect on student motivation may depend on the academic or professional discipline. Despite the generally encouraging findings, it is important to note that most of the studies have been conducted in the medical school environment. There has been insufficient work examining motivation among other populations, which makes it difficult to draw conclusions about PBL’s impact on this aspect in other contexts with other groups of participants (Hmelo-Silver, 2004).
Effectiveness of PBL in Cultivating Creativity: Overall Conclusion This chapter has examined the findings of studies conducted between 2000 and 2008 in an effort to chart the landscape of research on PBL and creativity so as to get a clearer picture of their relationship. Despite the strong interest generated in PBL as a means to cultivate creativity and its sound theoretical rationale, it appears that systematic evidence is scarce and a conclusive answer elusive. There is very little solid empirical evidence supported by a diverse range of high-quality studies that points to the effectiveness of PBL in fostering creativity. Thus, questions about PBL’s effectiveness in this aspect are likely to remain. Overall, there seems to be a lack of conclusive evidence for the efficacy of PBL in developing creativity, although there is indirect evidence pointing to its potential in some specific areas. Research designed to directly investigate the relationship between PBL and creativity is scant, while a plethora of studies investigating the link between PBL and specific components of creativity has produced equivocal or insufficiently supported evidence to be deemed conclusive. Furthermore, past research when subjected to scrutiny has been found wanting. The current body of research has primarily been conducted with
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
31
medical students, thus limiting its generalizability. Many studies have also been criticized for their lack of academic rigor and quality, and often the study samples were nonrandomized (Colliver, 2000; Norman & Schmidt, 2000). Several investigations have relied on the subjective feedback and perceptions of students and teachers and therefore do not provide objective evidence (Lam, 2004). It is unclear whether the size of the effects obtained by the body of research is large enough to be of significance, and this affects the credibility of claims (Colliver & Markwell, 2007). In view of these limitations, it is clear that the “jury is still out.” Far more research is required before we can decide if PBL can be advocated as an effective means of promoting creative thought.
Toward a More Comprehensive and Productive Research Agenda There is a dearth of studies that have been conducted to directly investigate the impact of PBL on creativity. To advance the existing knowledge base in this area, gaps in research need to be filled and limitations addressed. Critical to a productive research agenda is a greater devotion to and more rigor in the examination of this link. More specifically, there is a need to make more controlled investigations of PBL in its different forms and to assess its impact on creative thought with different populations and across different domains. Researchers need to deliberate upon how they are to assess the effectiveness of PBL and how they are to assess creativity (using actual measures rather than subjective self-ratings), as this is likely to have a bearing on the conclusions drawn. Additional investigations to shed light on the impact of PBL on the various components of creativity as well as on the mediating factors that might affect creativity as an outcome of PBL could also be beneficial. It would be profitable if future reviews of literature improve on the present one with a more systematic search and selection process. Time and space constraints did not permit a systematic review but primarily a “trawl of the literature.” This could limit the conclusions made. Some authors have expressed weariness with the avalanche of criticism continually being leveled at PBL research methods and findings, terming it
32
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
a “hyper-reflection,” of which the costs and benefits are not clear (see, e.g., Jolly, 2006). Yet others have felt this to be necessary in order to complete the “1000-piece research jigsaw” on PBL effectiveness (see, e.g., Colliver & Markwell, 2007). It seems that the latter view is more befitting in the area of PBL and creativity, where there needs to be more fine-grained analyses of the effects of PBL as well as more concrete evidence to demonstrate its efficacy. As Colliver and Markwell (2007) put it bluntly, “Researchers, reviewers and editors should channel their enthusiasm into getting the methods and findings of research right, rather than letting it directly drive their decisions and conclusions” (p. 533). This research agenda may seem like a demanding one, but it is certainly worth the effort required.
References Abrandt Dahlgren, M., & Dahlgren, L. O. (2002). Portraits of PBL: Students’ experiences of the characteristics of problem-based learning in physiotherapy, computer engineering, and psychology. Instructional Science, 30, 111–127. Albanese, M. A., & Mitchell, S. (1993). Problem-based learning: A review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issues. Academic Medicine, 68, 52–81. Amabile, T. M. (1983). The social psychology of creativity: A componential conceptualisation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 45(2), 357– 376. Amabile, T. M. (1996). Creativity in context: Update to the social psychology of creativity. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Badger, D., Nursten, J., & Woodward, M. (2000). Should all literature reviews be systematic? Evaluation and Research in Education, 14(3–4), 220–230. Barak, M. (2006). Teaching methods for systematic inventive problem-solving: Evaluation of a course for teachers. Research in Science and Technological Education, 24(2), 237–254. Barron, F. (1968). Creativity and personal freedom. New York: Van Nostrand. Beers, G. W. (2005). The effect of teaching method on objective test scores: Problem-based learning versus lecture. Journal of Nursing Education, 44(7), 305–309. Blumberg, P. (2000). Evaluating the evidence that problem-based learners are self-directed learners: A review of the literature. In D. H. Evensen & C. E. Hmelo (Eds.), Problem-based learning: A research perspective on learning interactions (pp. 199–226). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
33
Brinkerhoff, J. D., & Glazewski, K. (2000, October 25–28). Hypermedia-based problem-based learning in the upper elementary grades: A developmental study. Paper presented at the 23rd National Convention of the Association for Educational Communications and Technology, Denver, CO. Burris, S. (2005). Effect of problem-based learning on critical thinking ability and content knowledge of secondary agriculture students. Ph.D. thesis, University of Missouri, Columbia, MO. Capon, N., & Kuhn, D. (2004). What’s so good about problem-based learning? Cognition and Instruction, 22(1), 61–79. Chamberlin, S. A., & Moon, S. M. (2005). Model-eliciting activities as a tool to develop and identify creatively gifted mathematicians. Journal of Secondary Gifted Education, 17(1), 37–47. Cheng, J. W. M., Alafris, A., Kirschenbaum, H. L., Kalis, M. M., & Brown, M. E. (2003). Problem-based learning versus traditional lecturing in pharmacy students’ short-term examination performance. Pharmacy Education, 3(2), 117. Chung, J. C. C., & Chow, S. M. K. (2004). Promoting student learning through a student-centred problem-based learning subject curriculum. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 41(2), 157–168. Colliver, J. (2000). Effectiveness of problem-based learning curricula: Research and theory. Academic Medicine, 75, 259–266. Colliver, J. A., & Markwell, S. J. (2007). Research on problem-based learning: The need for critical analysis of methods and findings. Medical Education, 41, 533–535. Cropley, A. J. (1992). More ways than one: Fostering creativity. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing. Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1988). Society, culture, and person: A systems view of creativity. In R. J. Sternberg (Ed.), The nature of creativity (pp. 325–329). New York: Cambridge University Press. Derry, S. J., Levin, J. R., Osana, H. P., Jones, M. S., & Peterson, M. (2000). Fostering students’ statistical and scientific thinking: Lessons learned from an innovative college course. American Educational Research Journal, 37, 747–773. Derry, S. J., & the STEP team (2002). The STEP system for collaborative casebased teacher education: Design, evaluation, and future directions. In G. Stahl (Ed.), Proceedings of CSCL 2002 (pp. 209–216). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Dochy, F., Segers, M., Van den Bossche, P., & Gijbels, D. (2003). Effects of problembased learning: A meta-analysis. Learning and Instruction, 13, 533–568. Dunlap, J. C. (2005a). Changes in students’ use of lifelong learning skills during a problem-based learning project. Performance Improvement Quarterly, 18(1), 5–33.
34
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
Dunlap, J. C. (2005b). Problem-based learning and self-efficacy: How a capstone course prepares students for a profession. Educational Technology, Research and Development, 53(1), 65–85. Elder, L., & Paul, R. (2007). Critical thinking: The nature of critical and creative thought, Part II. Journal of Developmental Education, 30(3), 36–37. Ertmer, P., Newby, T. J., & MacDougall, M. (1996). Students’ responses and approaches to case-based instruction: The role of reflective self-regulation. American Educational Research Journal, 33, 719–752. Evensen, D. H., Salisbury-Glennon, J. D., & Glenn, J. (2001). A qualitative study of six medical students in a problem-based curriculum: Toward a situated model of self-regulation. Journal of Educational Psychology, 93(4), 659–676. Finke, R. A. (1995). Creative insight and preinventive forms. In R. J. Sternberg & J. E. Davidson (Eds.), The nature of insight (pp. 255–280). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Foster, P., & Hammersley, M. (1998). A review of reviews: Structure and function in reviews of educational research. British Educational Research Journal, 24(5), 609–628. Freud, S. (1959). Creative writers and day-dreaming (Vol. 9). London: Hogarth Press. Gallagher, S. A., & Stepien, W. A. (1995). Implementing problem-based learning in science classrooms. School Science and Mathematics, 95, 136–146. Ghiselin, B. (1985). The creative process: A symposium. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Gijbels, D., Dochy, F., Van den Bossche, P., & Segers, M. (2005). Effects of problembased learning: A meta-analysis from the angle of assessment. Review of Educational Research, 75(1), 27–61. Guilford, J. P. (1950). Creativity. American Psychologist, 5, 444–454. Guilford, J. P. (1956). The structure of intellect. Psychological Bulletin, 53, 267– 293. Guilford, J. P. (1970). Traits of creativity. In P. E. Vernon (Ed.), Creativity. Harmondsworth: Penguin. Guilford, J. P. (1988). Some changes in the structure-of-intellect model. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 68, 1–6. Hays, J. R., & Vincent, J. P. (2004). Students’ evaluation of problem-based learning in graduate psychology courses. Teaching of Psychology, 31(2), 124–126. Hmelo-Silver, C. E. (2000). Knowledge recycling: Crisscrossing the landscape of educational psychology in a problem-based learning course for preservice teachers. Journal of Excellence in College Teaching, 11, 41–56. Hmelo-Silver, C. E. (2004). Problem-based learning: What and how do students learn? Educational Psychology Review, 16(3), 235–266.
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
35
Hmelo, C. E., & Lin, X. (2000). The development of self-directed learning strategies in problem-based learning. In D. H. Evensen & C. E. Hmelo (Eds.), Problem-based learning: A research perspective on learning interactions (pp. 227–250). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Hmelo, C. E., Holton, D., & Kolodner, J. L. (2000). Designing to learn about complex systems. Journal of the Learning Sciences, 9, 247–298. Jolly, B. (2006). Problem-based learning. Medical Education, 40, 494–495. Joyce, B., & Weil, M. (1996). Models of teaching (5th ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall. Kasai, R., Sugimoto, K., & Uchiyama, Y. (2006). The effect of problem-basedlearning on physical therapy education: A comparison of the short-term educational effect between PBL and lecture-based educational approaches. Rigakuryoho Kagaku, 21(2), 143–150. Kelson, A. C. M. (2000). Assessment of students for proactive lifelong learning. In D. H. Evensen & C. E. Hmelo (Eds.), Problem-based learning: A research perspective on learning interactions (pp. 315–346). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Knowles, M. (1975). Self-directed learning as a guide for learners and teachers. Cambridge, MA: Adult Education Company. Koh, G. C. H., Khoo, H. E., Wong, M. L., & Koh, D. (2008). The effects of problembased learning during medical school on physician competency: A systematic review. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 178(1), 34–41. Kwon, O. N., Park, J. S., & Park, J. H. (2006). Cultivating divergent thinking in mathematics through an open-ended approach. Asia Pacific Education Review, 7(1), 51–61. Lam, D. (2004). Problem-based learning: An integration of theory and field. Journal of Social Work Education, 40(3), 371–389. Lee, H. J., & Cho, Y. S. (2007). Factors affecting problem finding depending on degree of structure of problem situation. Journal of Educational Research, 101(2), 113–124. Lindner, R. W., & Harris, B. (1993). Self-regulated learning: Its assessment and instructional implications. Educational Research Quarterly, 16(2), 29–37. Liu, M., Hsieh, P. P. H., Cho, Y. J., & Schallert, D. L. (2006). Middle school students’ self-efficacy, attitudes, and achievement in a computer-enhanced problembased learning environment. Journal of Interactive Learning Research, 17(3), 225–242. Lohman, M. C., & Finkelstein, M. (1999). Segmenting information in PBL cases to foster the development of problem-solving skill, self-directedness, and technical knowledge. Unpublished manuscript, Florida State University and University of Iowa.
36
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
Lohman, M. C., & Finkelstein, M. (2000). Designing groups in problem-based learning to promote problem-solving skill and self-directedness. Instructional Science, 28, 291–307. Lubart, T. I. (1994). Creativity. In R. J. Sternberg (Ed.), Thinking and problemsolving (pp. 290–323). San Diego, CA: Academic Press. Lycke, K. H., Grøttum, P., & Strømsø, H. I. (2006). Student learning strategies, mental models and learning outcomes in problem-based and traditional curricula in medicine. Medical Teacher, 28(8), 717–722. Major, C. H., & Palmer, B. (2001). Assessing the effectiveness of problem-based learning in higher education: Lessons from the literature. Academic Exchange Quarterly, 5(1), 4–9. Maxwell, N. L., Mergendoller, J. R., & Bellisimo, Y. (2005). Problem-based learning and high school macroeconomics: A comparative study of instructional methods. Journal of Economic Education, 36(4), 315–331. McParland, M., Noble, L. M., & Livingston, G. (2004). The effectiveness of problem-based learning compared with traditional teaching in undergraduate psychiatry. Medical Education, 38, 859–867. Mergendoller, J. R., Maxwell, N. L., & Bellisimo, Y. (2006). The effectiveness of problem-based instruction: A comparative study of instructional methods and student characteristics. Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-based Learning, 1(2), 49–69. Moore, T. S. (2007). Implementation of problem-based learning in a baccalaureate dental hygiene program. Journal of Dental Education, 71(8), 1058–1069. Newbert, G. A., & Binko, J. B. (1992). Inductive reasoning in the secondary classroom. Washington, DC: National Education Association. Ng, A. K. (2001). Why Asians are less creative than Westerners? Singapore: Pearson/ Prentice Hall. Norman, G. R., & Schmidt, H. G. (1992). The psychology basis of problem-based learning: A review of evidence. Academic Medicine, 67, 557–565. Norman, G. R., & Schmidt, H. G. (2000). Effectiveness of problem-based learning curricula: Theory, practice and paper darts. Medical Education, 34, 721–728. Osborn, A. F. (1953). Applied imagination. New York: Scribners. Piirto, J. (1992). Understanding those who create. Dayton, OH: Ohio Psychology Press. Purdie, N., Hattie, J., & Douglas, G. (1996). Student conceptions of learning and their use of self-regulated learning strategies: A cross-cultural comparison. Journal of Educational Psychology, 88(1), 87–100. Runco, M. A. (1991). Divergent thinking. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing. Ruscio, J., & Amabile, T. M. (1996). How does creativity happen? Retrieved January 28, 2008, from http://www.geniusdenied.com/articles/Record.aspx? NavID=13_27&rid=10592.
Problem-based Learning and Creativity: A Review
37
Schmidt, H. G., Vermeulen, L., & van derMolen, H. T. (2006). Longterm effects of problem-based learning: A comparison of competencies acquired by graduates of a problem-based and a conventional medical school. Medical Education, 40(6), 562–567. Semerci, N. (2006). The effect of problem-based learning on the critical thinking of students in the Intellectual and Ethical Development Unit. Social Behaviour and Personality. Retrieved December 15, 2007, from http://findarticles.com/ p/articles/mi_qa3852/is_200601/ai_n17187271/print. Siu, H. M., Laschinger, H. K. S., & Vingilis, E. (2005). The effect of problembased learning on nursing students’ perceptions of empowerment. Journal of Nursing Education, 44(10), 459–469. Smits, P. B. A., Verbeek, J. H. A. M., & de Buisonjé, C. D. (2002). Problem based learning in continuing medical education: A review of controlled evaluation studies. BMJ, 324, 153–156. Sternberg, R. J. (1996). Successful intelligence: How practical and creative intelligence determine success in life. New York: Simon & Schuster. Sternberg, R. J., & Davidson, J. E. (1995). The nature of insight. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Sternberg, R. J., & Lubart, T. I. (1995). Defying the crowd: Cultivating creativity in a culture of conformity. New York: Free Press. Sternberg, R. J., & Lubart, T. (1996). Investing in creativity. American Psychologist, 51(7), 677–688. Stevens, P. A. J. (2007). Researching race/ethnicity and educational inequality in English secondary schools: A critical review of the research literature between 1980 and 2005. Review of Educational Research, 77(2), 147–185. Sungur, S., & Tekkaya, C. (2006). Effects of problem-based learning and traditional instruction on self-regulated learning. Journal of Educational Research, 99(5), 307–317. Tan, O. S. (2000a). Intelligence enhancement and cognitive coaching in problembased learning. Paper presented at the Teaching and Learning in Higher Education Symposium, Singapore. Tan, O. S. (2000b). Thinking skills, creativity and problem-based learning. In O. S. Tan, P. Little, S. Y. Hee & J. Conway (Eds.), Problem-based learning: Educational innovation across disciplines. Singapore: Temasek Centre for Problem-based Learning. Tan, O. S. (2003). Problem-based learning innovation: Using problems to power learning in the 21st century. Singapore: Thomson Learning. Tiwari, A., Lai, P., So, M., & Yuen, K. (2006). A comparison of the effects of problem-based learning and lecturing on the development of students’ critical thinking. Medical Education, 40, 547–554.
38
Oon-Seng Tan, Stefanie Chye, and Chua-Tee Teo
Torrance, E. P. (1974). Torrance tests of creative thinking: Technical norms and technical manual. Lexington, MA: Personnel Press. Torrance, E. P. (1986). Torrance tests of creative thinking. Bensenville, IL: Scholastic Testing Service. Treffinger, D. J. (1994). Creative problem solver’s guidebook. Sarasota, FL: Center for Creative Learning. Van Berkel, H. J. M., & Schmidt, H. G. (2000). Motivation to commit oneself as a determinant of achievement in problem-based learning. Higher Education, 40, 231–242. Vernon, D. T., & Blake, R. L. (1993). Does problem-based learning work? A meta-analysis of evaluative research. Academic Medicine, 68, 550–563. Ward, J. D., & Lee, C. L. (2002). A review of problem-based learning. Journal of Family and Consumer Sciences Education, 20(1), 16–26. Yeung, E., Au-Yeung, S., Chiu, T., Mok, N., & Lai, P. (2003). Problem design in problem-based learning: Evaluating students’ learning and self-directed learning practice. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 40(3), 237–244. Zimmerman, B. J. (1990). Self-regulated learning and academic achievement: An overview. Educational Psychologist, 25(1), 3–17.
CHAPTER 3
Facilitating Problem-solving Processes for Adaptors and Innovators Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
Abstract Adaptors and innovators are two creative styles defined in Kirton’s adaption– innovation continuum. Adaptors choose to do things better, while innovators choose to do things differently. In this chapter, how adaptors and innovators are likely to perform in problem-solving tasks is discussed with implications for teachers and employers on their roles in facilitating problem solving for the two creative styles.
Introduction We often observe individual differences among problem solvers yet fail to understand the reason why some individuals have more difficulty relating to others, whether it is at home, in school, at the workplace, or even in the community. It is not merely a matter of individual personality traits but also differences in problem-solving styles. It is hoped that this chapter will shed some light on the behavioral characteristics of two creative styles—adaptors and innovators as defined by Kirton (1976)—in problem solving that will provide relevant implications for teachers and employers.
40
Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan
Who Are Adaptors and Innovators? The adaption–innovation inventory was developed by Kirton for gauging whether a person’s creative style is toward the adaptive or innovative end (Kirton, 1994). Kirton lists three facets that correspond to three factor traits: sufficiency of originality refers to a preference for producing a few implementable solutions to problems; rule governance concerns a social tendency to maintain workgroup cohesion by doing things in accepted ways; and efficiency refers to a bureaucratic concern with being exact, systematic, and disciplined. Bagozzi and Foxall (1995) found that adaptors tend to produce fewer implementable solutions to problems and are more compliant and bureaucratic within the workgroup. In contrast, innovators tend to be brimming with ideas, flout rules, and display little regard for bureaucratic details. Their study supports the results found by McHale and Flegg (1986) on the different working styles adopted by innovators and adaptors. Taken together, these findings indicate that innovators and adaptors operate on two ends of a continuum and, as a result, will tend to have difficulty working together. Adaptors do not like to behave like innovators, as it is against their nature to solve problems by bending rules, while innovators do not like to behave like adaptors, as it is against their nature to solve problems by following rules. Both adaptors and innovators are equally creative, but they choose to express their creativity in different ways. Adaptors choose to do things better, while innovators choose to do things differently. Adaptors operate within a structured system associated with sufficiency of originality, efficiency, and rule–group conformity, whereas innovators break away from such existing structured system and show great interest in originality of ideas and less concern with efficiency and rule–group conformity. Furthermore, according to Kirton (1994), adaptors are likely to improve on the existing structure and favor staying in groups, maintaining cohesion by following the accepted ways, and solving problems in a disciplined, methodical, and predictable manner. They are unlike the innovators, who are risk takers and are likely to generate innovative yet practical ideas, thus altering the existing paradigm. Table 3.1 lists the differences between the two creative styles.
Facilitating Problem-solving Processes for Adaptors and Innovators
TABLE 3.1
41
Behavior descriptions of adaptors and innovators Adaptor
Innovator
Characterized by precision, reliability, efficiency; seen as methodical and disciplined.
Seen as thinking tangentially, approaching tasks from unsuspected angles; undisciplined, unpredictable.
Concerned with resolving problems rather than finding them.
Tends to discover problems as well as less expected avenues of solution.
Seeks solutions to problems in tried and understood ways.
Tends to question a problem’s concomitant assumptions; manipulates problems.
Lessens problems through improvement and greater efficiency with maximum of continuity and stability.
Is catalyst to settled groups, irreverent of their consensual views; seen as abrasive, creating dissonance.
Disciplined in solving problems with minimum of risk.
In solving problems, seeks to explore untested areas that may be risky and jeopardize the situation.
More loyal to policy of consensus.
Shows less respect for others’ views, more abrasive in presenting solutions.
Seen as conforming and dependable.
Seen as ingenious, unsound, impractical.
Does things better.
Does things differently.
Liable to make goals of means.
In pursuit of goals, liable to challenge accepted means.
Seems impervious to boredom and able to maintain high accuracy in long spells of detailed work.
Usually unable to stay on detailed routine (system maintenance) work for longer than short bursts, quick to delegate routine tasks.
Is an authority within given structure.
Tends to take control in unstructured situations.
Challenges rules rarely, cautiously, when assured of strong support and problem solving within consensus.
Often challenges rules; may have little respect for past customs.
Has high self-doubt when system is challenged, reacts to criticism by closer outward conformity; vulnerable to social pressure and authority; compliant.
Appears to have low self-doubt when generating ideas, not needing consensus to remain steadfast in face of opposition; less certain when placed in core of system.
42
Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan
TABLE 3.1 (Continued) Adaptor
Innovator
Essential to the functioning of the institution all the time, but occasionally needs to be “dug out” of the current systems.
Ideal for tackling unscheduled crises in the institution, or for helping to avoid them, if can be trusted by adaptors.
When collaborating with innovators, provides stability, order, and continuity to the partnership.
When working with adaptors, provides task orientations and the break with past and accepted theory.
Sensitive to people, maintains group cohesion and cooperation; can be slow to overhaul a rule.
Appears insensitive to people when in pursuit of solutions, hence often threatening group cohesion and cooperation.
Provides a safe base for the innovator’s riskier operations.
Provides the dynamics to bring about periodic radical change, without which institutions tend to become rigid.
Has a conscientious personality trait.
Has an extroverted personality trait.
Tends to adopt ego avoidance orientation.
Tends to adopt mastery goal orientation.
SOURCE: Adapted from Kirton (1984).
Difference in personality traits can affect creativity style. Research has shown that creative style is correlated with more than 30 different personality traits. Gelade (2002) demonstrated that many of these correlations could be understood within the framework of the five-factor model of personality. This model asserts that there are five basic personality traits, as follows. Neuroticism refers to individuals who are primarily characterized by a tendency to experience the states of negative affect. Extroversion refers to individuals who are assertive, active, cheerful, and high-spirited and who are happiest in the company of others. Openness to experience refers to individuals who are inquisitive and ready to contemplate radical ideas, new experiences, and unconventional values. Agreeableness refers to individuals who are friendly and sympathetic toward others and generally adopt an optimistic outlook in interpersonal matters. Finally, conscientiousness refers to individuals who are purposeful, disciplined, strong-willed, and reliable. It has been reported
Facilitating Problem-solving Processes for Adaptors and Innovators
43
that the predominant correlates of creative style are personality indicators in the domains of openness to experience and extroversion for innovators and conscientiousness for adaptors (Gelade, 2002; Ee et al., 2007). The NEO Personality Inventory–Revised (NEO PI-R) (Costa & McCrae, 1992) is a 240-statement questionnaire measure that is widely regarded as the standard representation of the five-factor model of personality. Gelade (1997), in examining the relationship between the five-factor model of personality and creativity, found that creative people break away from conformity and social norms and take pride in their work. In addition, they are independent and complex persons. He also noted that commercial creative studies reported considerably higher levels of neuroticism and openness to experience than professionals of a similar age working in occupations that are not evidently creative. The willingness to take risk can also account for creative achievement. Dunbar (1997) noted the importance of risk taking in scientific discovery in the field of molecular biology. While there was variability across laboratories in their ability to achieve creative insights, the cognitive processes involved did not vary. However, a difference was shown in the scientists’ willingness to take risk, their willingness to try a new procedure, examine an unexplained phenomenon, or propose a wild new theory to explain the data. He concluded that a higher willingness to take risk is related to creative achievement. In the school context, students are motivated by learning goals to work hard in their studies (Ee, 1998). There are many kinds of goals, and different students adopt different learning goals. Students with mastery goals are intrinsically motivated to master a certain topic, unconcerned with how they will appear to significant others like parents, teachers, and friends. On the other hand, students adopting ego-approach goals in the learning situation are preoccupied with demonstrating their competence to significant others, and powerful extraneous forces such as evaluation pressure and social comparison suppress their employment of more creative forms of problem solving. In contrast, when a person involved in tasks adopts a mastery goal, the person engages in the activity in a more flexible manner (Csikszentmihalyi, 1990; Isen et al., 1987). Finally, individuals with an ego avoidance goal have a tendency to avoid difficult tasks for fear of failure. Research has revealed that innovators are mastery
44
Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan
goal oriented, while adaptors are ego involved, especially ego avoidance (Ng, 2003; Ee et al., 2007). In a study examining the relationships between creativity, risk orientations, achievement goals, and personality traits of tertiary students in Singapore, innovators scored significantly higher than adaptors in creativity, risk taking, mastery goal orientation, extroversion, and openness to experience. On the other hand, adaptors scored significantly higher on risk avoidance, ego approach, and conscientiousness. Furthermore, mastery goal orientation, risk taking, extroversion, and openness to experience were found to be predictors of innovative behavior, while risk avoidance goal, ego avoidance goal, and conscientiousness were predictors of adaptive behavior (Ee et al., 2007). The preceding review suggests that these two creative styles of adaptor and innovator differ in many ways, including personality, risk-taking tendency, learning goals adopted, and even the manner they solve problems.
Processes Involved in Problem Solving When faced with a problem, an individual is likely to engage in the processes of clarifying, defining and reframing, analyzing, as well as summarizing and synthesizing the problem. Thus, effective problem solving in the real world involves the harnessing of cognitive processes that include the following: 1. “Planful” thinking. In attempting to understand the nature and demands of the problem, the problem solver has to take time to think and plan by listing the facts in the problem and what needs to be known and done. 2. Generative thinking. Then, in attempting to make inferences from the facts and considering what needs to be known and done, the problem solver has to adopt an open mind with flexible thinking and come up with ideas by looking at the problem from various angles. 3. Systematic thinking. After determining what needs to be done, the problem solver has to conduct research and collect data in an organized, thorough, and systematic manner.
Facilitating Problem-solving Processes for Adaptors and Innovators
45
4. Analogical thinking. Having obtained the data, the problem solver needs to analyze them by looking for similarities, patterns, and parallels through lateral thinking. 5. Systemic thinking. Finally, in addressing the problem, the problem solver needs to adopt holistic thinking while synthesizing the findings into coherent solutions to the problem.
Roles of Adaptors and Innovators in Problem-solving Processes Because of differences in working style, it is easy for conflict to develop between the adaptors and innovators in a group (Kirton, 2000). By nature, adaptors dislike bending rules innovatively in order to solve problems, while innovators loathe being adaptive and following rules in handling problems. To prevent such conflict from occurring, it is important to highlight to adaptors and innovators that a good blend of creative styles is needed to solve problems creatively. This is because the creative problemsolving process requires periods of divergent ideation/innovation alternating with convergent evaluation/adaption, as well as the ability to judge when each is appropriate (Brophy, 1998; Runco, 1994). In problem-based learning (PBL), ideally, innovators should be called upon to contribute during the early stages when generative thinking is involved, as they are able to approach tasks from new angles and to think divergently. However, when systematic thinking and data synthesis are called for, adaptors may be preferred, as they are concerned with resolving problems and are reliable, efficient, methodical, and disciplined, unlike innovators. Since creative styles are complementary, adaptors and innovators would do well to learn from each other. Adaptors can learn to set mastery goals like their innovative counterpart, so that they will be motivated to explore a variety of interesting alternatives in coming up with viable solutions. Similarly, innovators can learn to set ego or performance goals like their adaptive counterpart, so that they will stay focused on the task and keep the end goal in mind. Finally, in developing a good blend of creative styles, both adaptors and innovators should banish egoistic thought such as “My way is right/ better; your way is wrong/inferior.” What is important is not the method
46
Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan
per se but whether it solves the problem at hand. As the late Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping once said, it doesn’t matter whether the cat is black or white so long as it catches the mice.
Role of Teachers in Facilitating Problem-solving Processes In facilitating problem-solving processes, it is advisable for teachers to provide cognitive coaching (Figure 3.1) to help students refrain from making unplanned and impulsive responses, sweeping generalizations,
3
2
1
4
50
5
49
23
24 25
26
21
[Co O mm utp un ut ica tin g]
strategies Memory of rtoire ols repe to Wide verbal ion icat ssif Cla es ori teg ca st g ra in nt lop s co ve ie d De n rit a ila re a m i p m rs Co fo g in k o 22 Lo
Making connections
20
27
18
ev an tc ue of nti fic p s r ati ob 30 on Sim le m of ulta p n r ob ma eou lem s ny sou hand 29 Disce rce ling so rning of f and cons data e cons rving tancy 28 Prioritizing
17
re l
16
L o 1 o 9 k in Se g ep fo art an r a – t w t d ho fe ribu le at te r ela ur s es tio Se ein ns g hip “ big pic tur Use e” of s trate gies L o o ki n g from dif persp ferent ective s Search for sources of error
31
15
on
g Systematic zoomin
iti
14
on plorati atic ex System ning scan atic ry tem Sys age f im on eo Us ati z ali ld ie lf ta en
fin
13
fm
su Vi
De
12
so
Ide
11
es dn
Se le ct in g
oa
32
Br
10
33
9
FIGURE 3.1 Cognitive coaching in problem solving SOURCE: Tan (2000).
8
Re fr 7 ai n i ng tr fro ia m 6 O l C v a l a er nd err rify co in er atic m g ins in ro g tru bi r c Q as u est co tions ion ns i t and n r g a int ass s um ptio R ns e s tr aint of im pulsiv ity Planning behavior
eption Clear perc
Cognitive Functions
] ut Inp cting lle
34
[Co
36
on ducti g
g
37
t pro
as
ide
38
kin
ing
s ea id
Deductive thinking king ive thin Induct nce vide al e logic ing g ink Usin l th tica hip e h t ns po tio n Hy a l io re ut or ol gf rs n i o f ok Lo an pl a g 35 in ak M
thin
kin in
y an
m
th
Elaboration [Connecting and creating]
Analysis
39
rgen Dive
vel
in
g
40
ut
No
y ilit
in at
pr R em e at stra ur in e t of clo fro bo Ov x” su m erc re t hin om kin in g g blo cka ges Eva luat ion Synth esis “O
t ora
xib
41
b Ela
Fle
42
er en
43
G
44
Precision and accuracy
48 47 46 45
Facilitating Problem-solving Processes for Adaptors and Innovators
47
and unwarranted narrow perceptions. By repeatedly asking questions about the data obtained, teachers assist students to obtain a clear mental picture of the problem-solving process and guide them toward systematic and more thorough information gathering. PBL processes and cognitive coaching involve getting the mind to make connections through reflection, articulation, and learning to see different perspectives. In PBL, the generation of cognitive connections is promoted through the use of problem scenarios and scaffolding (e.g., using templates and questions to guide students). After gathering relevant data, students have to analyze them by applying analytical thinking skills such as comparing, classifying, logical reasoning, and making inferences. Good analytical thinking involves not only logical reasoning but also knowing when to interpolate and extrapolate. According to Manktelow (1999), human reasoning can be biased and flawed. A study has found that people have a tendency to give a “pseudodiagnostic” response based on their experience and belief, rather than a diagnostic response (Evans et al., 2002). Hence, there is a need to emphasize the learning of problem solving based on facts and reason. The PBL process and cognitive coaching can help students develop flexible, helicopter views by making connections with prior knowledge and experiences, real-world contexts, theories, others’ perceptions, and new facts and ideas. Connectivity is enhanced through data collection and information elaboration and communication. And problem-solving competencies are developed and internalized through raising students’ awareness of the different ways of thinking needed in resolving a problem.
Setting the Climate for Adaptors and Innovators The patterns of relationships between creativity, risk taking, personality, and learning goals have major implications for nurturing mastery goal– oriented learners who will not only enjoy learning for learning’s sake but are intrinsically self-regulated and creative individuals who adopt an extroverted and open-minded attitude toward their learning. The classroom climate must be one that inhibits the ego-approach or egoavoidance orientation in our students, or these students may also develop
48
Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan
neurotic personality traits and a risk-avoidance orientation, which may not be conducive to their learning. The findings presented here suggest that, to nurture creative, enthusiastic, and vivacious learners who enjoy learning, educators should build learning environments that facilitate task involvement while inhibiting ego involvement in students. Some of the current educational policies, such as national primary school streaming and national secondary school ranking, contribute to an extremely stressful learning environment in which incessant pressure is applied in a top-down fashion: Principals are pressured by the competitive system of education to raise the performance of their schools. They then pressure their teachers to deliver high grades in their classes. The teachers in turn pressure their students to do well in tests and examinations. In this, they are joined by the students’ parents, who push their children to work hard so that they will not end up in a slower stream or a lower-ranking school. Ryan and Guardia (1999) showed that an excessive focus on competitive evaluation would undermine the intrinsic value attached to learning, decrease interest in the topic being studied, as well as result in lower-quality learning and creativity. An experimental study by Reeve and Deci (1996) explored the possibility that winning a competition could be experienced either as controlling (if the interpersonal context emphasized the importance of beating one’s opponent) or as informational (if the interpersonal context did not pressure one to win). They found, as predicted, that both groups of winners—those in the nonpressured context and those pressured to win—felt highly competent relative to the losers. However, compared with the nonpressured winners, the pressured winners showed a marked reduction in perceived self-determination, which in turn undermined their intrinsic motivation in performing the task. The researchers note that “winning a competition may not undermine intrinsic motivation if the interpersonal context does not add undue pressure to win. Unfortunately, it seems that the unyielding focus of our society on winning— whether in athletic competition or school performance, for example— may be creating a pressuring context that can have quite negative effects on individuals’ experience and motivation” (p. 32). Thus, teachers who attempt to inculcate creativity in their students should bear in mind that creativity is a qualitative construct—each
Facilitating Problem-solving Processes for Adaptors and Innovators
49
creative style has its own strengths and weaknesses. As adaptors and innovators subscribe to different values, teachers may need to develop a good blend of creative styles in the classroom.
In Conclusion It would be ideal if every educator is committed to the mission of nurturing creative, passionate, and spirited learners who are infused with the joy of learning, rather than competitive, conforming, and wary learners who are emotionally numbed by their fear of learning. We will do well to remember these words of Albert Einstein, the creator par excellence, who saw the deleterious effects of a competitive system of education that pressured students to do well. In his autobiography, Einstein wrote, “It is in fact nothing short of a miracle that the modern methods of instruction have not yet entirely strangled the holy curiosity of inquiry, for this delicate little plant, aside from stimulation, stands mainly in need of freedom. Without this it goes to wreck and ruin without fail” (as quoted in Ng, 2001, p. 97). To conclude, our task as educators is to close the discernible gap that presently exists between our espoused theory (what we say we will do) and our theory-in-use (what we actually do). This can only occur when we muster the will to free our students to be creative.
References Bagozzi, R. P., & Foxall, G. R. (1995). Construct validity and generalisability of the Kirton Adaption–Innovation Inventory. European Journal of Personality, 9, 185–206. Brophy, D. R. (1998). Understanding, measuring and enhancing individual creative problem-solving efforts. Creativity Research Journal, 11(2), 123–150. Costa, P. T. Jr., & McCrae, P. R. (1992). NEO-PI-R: Professional manual. Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources. Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1990). Flow: The psychology of optimal experience. New York: Harper Perennial. Dunbar, K. (1997). How scientists think: On-line creativity and conceptual change in science. In T. B. Ward, S. M. Smith & J. Vaid (Eds.), Creative thought: An investigation of conceptual structures and processes (pp. 461–493). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
50
Jessie Ee and Oon-Seng Tan
Ee, J. (1998). Relationships among teachers’ classroom orientations, strategybased instruction, and students’ goal orientations, self-regulated learning and achievement. Ph.D. thesis, University of Newcastle, Australia. Ee, J., Tan, O. S., & Ng, A. K. (2007). Styles of creativity: Adaptors and innovators in a Singapore context. Asia Pacific Education Review, 8(2), 343–355. Evans, J. B. T., Venn, S., & Feeney, A. (2002). Implicit and explicit processes in a hypothesis testing task. British Journal of Psychology, 93, 31–46. Gelade, G. A. (1997). Creativity in conflict: The personality of the commercial creative. Journal of Genetic Psychology, 158, 67–79. Gelade, G. A. (2002). Creative style, personality and artistic endeavour. Genetic, Social and General Psychology Monographs, 128, 213–234. Isen, A., Daubman, K. A., & Nowicki, G. P. (1987). Positive affect facilitates creative problem-solving. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52, 1122–1131. Kirton, M. J. (1976). Adaptors and innovators: A description and measure. Journal of Applied Psychology, 61, 622–629. Kirton, M. J. (1984). Adaptors and innovators: Why new initiatives get blocked. Retrieved January 15, 2008, from http://www.kaicentre.com/initiatives.htm. Kirton, M. J. (Ed.) (1994). A theory of cognitive style. In Adaptors and innovators: Styles of creativity and problem-solving (pp. 1–33). London: Routledge. Kirton, M. J. (2000). Adaption and innovation: Styles of creativity and problemsolving (rev. ed.). London: Routledge. Manktelow, K. I. (1999). Reasoning and thinking. Hove, East Sussex: Psychology Press. McHale, J., & Flegg, D. (1986, October). Innovators rule ok—or do they? Training and Development Journal, pp. 10–13. Ng, A. K. (2001). Why Asians are less creative than Westerners. Singapore: Pearson/ Prentice Hall. Ng, A. K. (2003). Learning goals, creativity and personality. Asia-Pacific Journal of Education, 23(2), 183–200. Reeve, J., & Deci, E. L. (1996). Elements of the competitive situation that affect intrinsic motivation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 22(1), 24–33. Runco, M. A. (Ed.) (1994). Conclusions concerning problem-finding, problemsolving and creativity. In Problem-finding, problem-solving, and creativity (pp. 271–290). Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing. Ryan, M. R., & Guardia, J. G. L. (1999). Achievement motivation within a pressured society: Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation to learn and the politics of school reform. Advances in Motivation and Achievement, 11, 45–85. Tan, O. S. (2000). Effects of a cognitive modifiability intervention on cognitive abilities, attitudes and academic performance of polytechnic students. Ph.D. thesis, National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore.
CHAPTER 4
Problem-based Learning Communities: Using the Social Environment to Support Creativity Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan University of British Columbia, Canada
Abstract This chapter explores the educational environmental conditions that support risk taking and creativity, discusses the challenges and benefits in building such supportive environments, and offers tools to support learning communities in which creativity flourishes. It considers the social aspects of meaning making that contribute to creativity, and how these aspects are fostered in problembased learning communities. Full participation in one’s education begins with the building of teacher–student and student–student relationships based on mutual respect and understanding. People construct knowledge based on their personal understandings and shared experiences, and meaning is made in the comparative interface of our own understandings and new insights. While the intellectual and social aspects of meaning making are intertwined, it is the social aspects—cooperation, discourse, and debate—that foster interpersonal relationships and evoke excitement in classrooms. Problem-based learning contributes to the collaborative construction of knowledge and the development of supportive relationships.
Introduction Problem-based learning (PBL) provides an opportunity for teachers to become partners with students in a unique learning environment. This partnership builds supportive, risk-free relationships, in addition
52
Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan
to strong declarative, procedural, and conceptual knowledge bases. It provides an environment that fosters (1) collaborative knowledge building, a process that is so important to life in a learning society; (2) the development of relationships believed to be crucial to contemporary life in the global community (Bruner, 1996; Keating & Hertzman, 1999); and (3) learning contexts that support the building of “intellectual camaraderie” and communities of learners (Donovan et al., 1999). People construct knowledge based on their personal understandings and shared experiences, and meaning is made out of the similarities and differences between our own understandings and new insights (Fosnot, 1996). While the intellectual and social aspects of meaning making are intertwined, it is the social aspects that foster interpersonal relationships, ignite excitement in classrooms, and nourish respect for novel ideas. This social and intellectual interaction forms the basis for what Csikszentmihalyi (1988) calls the “social support factors” that are vital to creativity, such as openness to novel ideas, positive attitude toward novelty, acceptance of diversity, and rewarding divergent thinking. This “congenial” environment, as Csikszentmihalyi (1996) describes it, allows students to think beyond socially acceptable conventions and provides a safe haven for breaking rules. We explore in this chapter the concept of the educational environment as a community, emphasizing the conditions necessary for developing the vibrant intellectual atmosphere for increased risk taking and creativity. The social support of a safe environment is vital for building the courage to think beyond socially acceptable responses. We will consider the social aspects of meaning making, with an emphasis on those that influence creativity; a working definition of the community environment; the challenges to building community; the conditions for building relationships; and PBL case structures that foster group support. We are currently experiencing a paradigm shift in education that challenges existing models of teaching and systems of education (Barr & Tagg, 1995; Dodge, 2006). It is a time when we must carefully consider the roles of educators in relation to the needs of students and the nature of optimal learning environments, with the aim of creating what Barab and Plucker (2002) term “smart contexts” in our schools and universities. It is also necessary to think creatively about how we support learning so
Problem-based Learning Communities
53
as to bring artistry in teaching to bear on our repertoires of pedagogical strategies, blending rules with art. Joseph J. Schwab captures this blend of rule and art well: Every art, whether it be teaching, stone carving or judicial control of a court of law . . . has rules, but knowledge of the rules does not make one an artist. Art arises as the knower of the rules learns to apply them appropriately to the particular case. Application, in turn, requires acute awareness of the particularities of that case and ways in which the rule can be modified to fit the case without complete abrogation of the rule. In art, the form must be adapted to the matter. (As cited in Shulman, 1986, p. 31)
PBL provides a framework for thinking about creative adaptations of form. It fosters not only intellectual engagement but also congenial learning environments. Much goes into teaching conducted in a way that truly supports learning and creativity (Torrance, 2004). Teachers’ knowledge of the curriculum and instructional strategies and their ability to craft learning environments that are responsive to students are critical to all pedagogical approaches, but central to PBL are those aspects related to the social educational environment. Table 4.1 summarizes six important aspects of expertise in teaching as defined by researchers of practice and highlights features that are central to PBL. The integration of these aspects of teaching underpins the creation of responsive and congenial learning environments.
The Social Aspects of Meaning Making We learn not only from the inside out but also from the outside in. Students bring their own understandings and questions to learning situations; these, together with their feelings, desires, and intentions related to learning, must be respected and connected in meaningful ways to the curriculum (“inside out” learning). In their interactions with peers, teachers, and others in their communities, students need to be offered opportunities to express their understandings and questions, gain new perspectives, have their thinking challenged, share and build on their knowledge, and learn about the knowledge traditions in their cultures
Expert inference of student understanding with students who are known to the teacher
Berliner (2001)
Domain expert bringing “adaptive expertise” to bear on new problems
Organization of instruction Content specialist in terms of students’ who can situate preconceptions and apply deep PBL scenarios must be knowledge constructed to optimize in ways that the connection of connect it to the students’ knowledge with real world the knowledge that the curriculum conveys.*
Shulman (1986)
Understanding of subject matter
Automaticity for repetitive operations, which allows “reinvestment” of cognitive resources in higher-level activities. This reinvestment facilitates the role of the teacher as designer and facilitator of creative learning experiences.
How topics, principles, and strategies in different subjects are understood, learned, and misconstrued and how real-world problems may build on or challenge those understandings and misconceptions
Understanding of pedagogy
Multiple classroom “worlds”
Understanding of and sensitivity to context
Teacher’s thoughts and feelings in relation to actions
Knowledge of self
Deep knowledge Flexible teaching that Rich and personal providing a structure sources of accommodates and responds to student within which information to interpret the brought to needs; having a curriculum complex rather than the solution of problems simple view of what it means to teach
How knowledge is organized and “packaged” for instruction and how the “packaging” may be deconstructed and “repackaged” creatively
Understanding of curricular knowledge
Elements of teaching that support the central features of problem-based learning (PBL)
Cognitive psychology of instruction
TABLE 4.1
Rich factual knowledge of subject
Sensitivity to the deep structure of a subject; well-integrated knowledge
SOURCE: Adapted from Porath (in press).
*The central features of PBL are highlighted in italics.
Wisdom—the understanding of and interest in others’ minds and the learning context
Arlin (1999)
Using higher-order executive processes to plan, monitor, and reflect on instruction; development of models of problems together with insightful solutions
Rich factual knowledge of teaching, rich procedural knowledge of teaching strategies, and practical knowledge of when and how to use both
Well-developed structure for planning instruction; connection of student feedback to learning objectives
Substantive General pedagogical and syntactic knowledge and beliefs knowledge of about teaching (views of the process of education) subjects; beliefs about subjects (orientation and conceptions of what is important to know)
Sternberg and Horvath (1995)
Knowledge of child development; empirical or social knowledge of learners
Turner-Bisset (1999)
A constructive process that includes understanding students’ perspectives on the curriculum
Curricular innovation coupled with practical knowledge of how to “work the system” to implement innovations
Sense of the context of instruction and the context in which students are being instructed
Practical knowledge of the social and political contexts in which one teaches; tacit knowledge
Teacher as learner orientation; willing to take risk and comfortable with uncertainty
Drawing on deep Knowledge of Identity as a educational settings; knowledge of teacher and its relationship to a subject to understanding teach curricular of a particular personal identity group of learners’ knowledge; critical analysis of curricular knowledge, actions, materials and understanding
56
Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan
(“outside in” learning). Crafting learning experiences that honor the significant role that the social environment plays in meaning making is central to PBL. Arlin’s work (1993, 1999) on the wise teacher is important in understanding the teacher qualities that optimize educational experiences where the social interactions in class are focused on meaning making. Arlin’s wise teacher is one who has “an orientation toward self, students, and teaching that highlights the teacher as learner in the act of constructing knowledge with her students” (1999, p. 12). This construction of knowledge unites the curriculum and learners’ perspectives (Bruner, 1996). PBL does not supplant the curriculum but, rather, provides a meaningful vehicle for student and teacher engagement with the curriculum. To truly be a teacher as learner implies creating a social environment in which students interact around problems that are meaningful to them and their community and where curiosity about others’ points of view on the curriculum and their ways of solving problems is evident. The foundation for such intellectual camaraderie lies in the social aspects of meaning making: cooperation, discourse, and debate. Ways in which teaching, curricula, and social aspects of meaning making are organized to support creativity in PBL communities are outlined in Table 4.2 (pp. 58–59), with emphasis on the questions to consider in implementing PBL and on the reciprocal role of the educator as both teacher and learner. Social environments conducive to meaning making can be characterized as having a vibrant intellectual atmosphere and exhibiting the following features:
• • • •
Students are perceived as bringing important, relevant knowledge to school and are viewed as thinkers. Teachers are curious about this knowledge, with the result that learners’ points of view are taken into account in planning instruction. Dynamic learning experiences are planned that engage students in meaningful challenges, and there is a climate of mutual respect and trust. Teachers help learners build bridges between their own conceptions and those of the culture.
Problem-based Learning Communities
•
57
Students collaborate through helping each other solve problems and teachers play an active role in promoting this collaboration.
A Working Definition of the Community Environment In order to grasp the importance of the environment for encouraging and nurturing creativity, we need to have a more refined notion of the concept of community. Broadly, it refers to a group of people working together with a common set of goals or interests. It can be expanded to the neighborhood, town, province, or state, but once it goes beyond a reasonable size the idea starts to break down. We tend not to think of regions or countries as communities. This implies the need to have some kind of personal relationship with others in order for a community to exist. This critical size limitation means that the smaller the group of people the greater is the realization of a common focus and therefore the existence of a community. It is those necessary interpersonal dynamics that hold a community together. Shavinina and Ferrari (2004) note the importance of social–cultural factors for the development of creativity at the micro-social level of school, family, and significant peers and the macro-social conditions of culture, politics, and history. As part of the micro-social level for students and teachers, the community consists of the classroom and school that together form a learning community with common goals. As long as the goals are common to students, teachers, and administrators, this learning community provides the support network necessary for learning to occur. Peterson (1992) asserts that “when community exists, learning is strengthened . . . everyone is smarter, more ambitious, and productive” (p. 10).
Social Aspects of Meaning Making that Influence Creativity Csikszentmihalyi (1988) notes that social support groups or networks are vital for creativity to flourish. The interpersonal relationships built within
Active, focused listener and designer who matches students’ skills, talents, needs, interests, and cognitive ability with the curriculum
Questioner and facilitator who challenges students to question their knowledge and models collaboration and inquiry
2. Student engagement with the problem, defining issues and elements that need research
Teacher’s role
1. Designing a problem that matches the curriculum
Step in PBL
• What are students’
preconceptions? • How do students understand group work? • What strategies result in positive group interactions? • What strategies get in the way of other strategies?*
to move toward definition of issues • Adopts respectful, interested approach to questioning • Helps students engage in and reflect on group processes
certain issue]? • What collaborative skills and backgrounds do students bring to problem solving? • What experience do students have with learning communities?
• Assists learning groups
• What do students think about [a
points of view • Promotes open communication
Questions to consider
• Respects students’
Relationship building
TABLE 4.2 Organizing the curriculum and the learning environment in ways that support creativity in problem-based learning (PBL)
• • • • •
• • • • •
Audiotapes Videotapes Meeting notes Students’ learning logs Teacher’s logs
Observational data Annotated notes Checklists Teacher’s journal entries Students’ journal entries
Sample formative assessment strategies
Assessor who evaluates students’ shared meanings in their conversations and products
4. Students proposing plausible solutions and negotiating meaning
of one’s thoughts influence how the thoughts develop further?* • How do representations of thoughts relate to ways of working in a group? • How does a new idea lead to a new question and vice versa?* • How are new ideas/questions communicated to and received by the group?
SOURCE: Table mainly adapted from Jordan et al. (2003), pp. 147–148. *Adapted from Duckworth (1987), pp. 134–135.
interprets group processes and relationships
• How does a specific representation
to students’ thinking? • How are ideas and group processes modified?* • How does a firmly held conviction influence how a person interprets an experience?* • In what circumstances is a person confused by/deaf to/helped by another person’s thoughts on the problem and/or process?*
and respect students’ points of view • Continues to help students monitor and reflect on their thinking and problem solving, at both individual and group levels • Analyzes and
• What seem to be critical barriers
• Continues to listen to
Coach and mentor who challenges students to expand their knowledge, to think at higher levels, and to solve problems intellectually and interpersonally
3. Students researching by accessing books, experts, and other information sources to gather relevant facts
Questions to consider
Relationship building
Teacher’s role
Step in PBL
Audiotapes Videotapes Meeting notes Students’ learning logs Teacher’s logs First drafts of products (e.g., portfolios, posters, charts, speeches)
interpretation of students’ products • Analysis and interpretation of the interactions between group relationships and products
• Analysis and
• • • • • •
Sample formative assessment strategies
60
Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan
a learning community promote a sense of group loyalty among students, a willingness to help each other, a sense of inclusiveness that respects diversity as well as personal and social growth, high levels of participation, greater quality of discussion and questioning, use of diverse strategies for problem solving, and increased risk taking in forming points of view or opinion. An aspect of this type of environment is a community built on mutual respect among all members. These social–emotional qualities encourage risk taking and provide the social validation necessary for students to take cognitive risks. That validation produces feelings of satisfaction and sometimes elation as well as pride in oneself (Cropley, 2003; Csikszentmihalyi, 1996). Overall, a risk-free, or congenial, environment —one of openness, positive attitude toward novelty, acceptance of personal differences, and willingness to reward divergence—enhances the vibrant intellectual atmosphere that encourages the use of metacognitive skills. It provides an opportunity for skill development and helps maintain the intense and sustained motivation or perseverance found in creative individuals (Csikszentmihalyi, 1988; Howe, 2004). This type of environment produces students who are self-confident in their social roles within a group, are willing to take risk in the very public social arena of the classroom, and willingly collaborate with others to interpret and develop meaning from challenging problems. The role of the teacher, beyond creating a risk-free intellectual social environment, is to provide students with age-appropriate problems that challenge their thinking. The provision of opportunities for manipulation and negotiation of ideas is essential in moving knowledge beyond facts to understanding. Within this vibrant environment, individual and group creativity begins to emerge and is highly valued by students. In our experience, the self-esteem that appears to result from such successful thinking encourages and reinforces the value of creativity in problem solving. Students begin to see creative thinking as part of their metacognitive repertoire for solving problems (in the broadest sense). A social environment that encourages novelty provides the “courage to create,” and this courage includes a readiness for divergent thinking and, by defying conventional opinion, exposes one to the possibility of being wrong (Motamedi, 1982).
Problem-based Learning Communities
61
Cropley (2003) points out that when teachers employ methods that emphasize “branching out, finding out, or inventing,” beneficial effects for students accrue, especially their motivation, attitude toward school, and self-image. All of these activities require student–student and student–teacher interactions. This socialized learning underscores the importance of the social–emotional aspects of the learning enterprise. For students, it means a cultural and social support system that nurtures creativity.
Challenges to Building Relationships In building a congenial environment, some of the biggest challenges to the development of a vibrant learning community that educators may face include the following:
• • • •
Time constraints. Most teachers have to make priority decisions based on the amount of time available for each topic. Problem solving requires opportunities to explore ideas and negotiate with others. Other commitments. While project and problem-solving work may become a focus for the class, there are other obligations within the curriculum that may vie for everyone’s time, students’ and teachers’ alike. External pressures. Often, outside influences affect the teacher’s decisions, such as administrative support that is lacking or district-wide testing that necessitates reverting to a more traditional pedagogical mode. Complexity of relationships. The idea of a community as described implies everyone getting along with each other. In the reality of a classroom, that is not always the case. Teachers need to work with students to nurture mutual respect.
Given the above potential constraints on building relationships, the following conditions are necessary for fostering relationships that support PBL:
62
Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan
• •
• •
•
Small class size and small working groups. While it is not impossible to nurture community, social cohesion, and effective group problem solving in large classes, smaller groups optimize the chances of building successful learning communities. Acknowledgment of team membership. Students need to know that they are valued for their contributions to finding and solving problems, for their knowledge, and for their ability to work collaboratively and respectfully with others. Their questions, knowledge, and goals become part of the group’s shared efforts. Suitable physical environment. A physical environment that is accessible by all class members and is aesthetically pleasing, well organized, and stocked with appropriate support materials and equipment is essential to supporting learning and creativity. Diverse composition of groupings. Changing group membership periodically encourages the development of a repertoire of social skills, optimizing harmonious relationships among all class members. Diversity in group membership encourages collaboration within and among groupings. Students come to appreciate that they require the participation of all members of their learning community and that all points of view are important to increasing understanding and creativity. Social and emotional support. Conditions that foster a social environment conducive to creativity make it possible to deal with the challenges articulated above. In a community that supports risk taking, aims for deep understanding, values diversity, and promotes collaborative problem solving, these challenges can be understood and addressed proactively.
PBL Case Structures that Foster Group Support The features inherent in the structure of a problem in a PBL case, or scenario, support the types of student experiences and the social– emotional environment necessary for creativity to emerge. These features are often missing in case studies, an instructional strategy often seen as
Problem-based Learning Communities
63
similar to PBL despite some significant differences. PBL scenarios are characterized by the following features:
•
• • •
•
Ill-structured problems. The nature of real-world problems is that they are often without the types of boundaries or structures that define problem solutions. Most problems, in reality, are confounded with other variables and need to be teased out of the social, emotional, cultural, and environmental contexts. Partial information. When we encounter problems in real life, we often have only partial information available to us at first when we try to find a solution. At times, additional information is found or presented to us during the solution process. Questions that belong to students. PBL scenarios are designed to give students the opportunity to become self-directed in their search for solutions, thereby making them, rather than the teacher, the persons who develop the questions. A real problem with a number of plausible solutions. The illstructured nature of real problems means that often there is more than one solution. There may be a right answer, but it is also possible that the right answer is mixed in with a number of plausible answers and so further investigation would be required. Requirement of cooperative group work. The reality of most problem-solving situations in life is that they are group efforts. We tend to seek out individuals who have information that could be useful to problem solution and usually discuss our findings to solidify our understanding of problems and situations. This natural collaborative problem-solving tendency is captured in the PBL procedure.
In contrast, case studies have the following characteristics:
• •
Structured, self-evident problems. Cases are written with the problem to be solved made obvious to students. Questions are provided by the author to guide students rather than students being given the opportunity to develop questions. Enough information to “solve” the problem. Cases come with all the facts necessary for students to solve the problem. Usually,
64
Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan
• •
•
there is no need to explore beyond the material provided to solve the problem. Leading questions provided. To ensure that students will be able to find and solve the right problem and learn the lesson objectives, the author provides sets of leading questions at the end of the case. Solutions known to instructors. Most cases come with answer books. Students are to seek the right answer rather than a plausible one. In many instances, students’ results are compared against those achieved in a real situation. Evaluation is often a question of how close the student came to the actual or right answer. Designed for individual or group work. Discussion and the negotiation of meaning are not necessarily part of case studies.
The differences between the value of case studies and that of PBL scenarios point out the need for case scenarios that not only support curricular goals but also are designed with a deep understanding of the developmental needs of students. When properly designed, PBL scenarios provide students with the scope necessary for creativity to emerge.
Conclusion Shulman’s (1990) perspective on turning the foundational educational disciplines of psychology, philosophy, history, and sociology upside down is relevant to PBL. This “upsetting” of foundations puts the content of the curriculum first and asks that the foundational discipline adapt to the content. While Shulman’s suggestion was made in the context of students of education, it is relevant to how we craft PBL scenarios to shape students’ experiences. Students in any discipline can benefit from investigating what it takes to understand a problem, be it scientific, artistic, historical, or geographical, by applying the relevant foundational discipline to the problem at hand. By probing what they know and need to know, coming to a consensus about problem definition, and researching possible solutions, students become aware of what it takes to understand the problem, bringing them to an awareness of the “conceptual landscape” (Leinhardt & Steele, 2005). If students do not engage in this sort of meaningful inquiry in PBL, they may form “one-time-only” theories (Bereiter & Scardamalia,
Problem-based Learning Communities
65
2000). There is a critical difference between a “one-time-only” theory that applies only to the problem under discussion and a general theory that has the potential for broader explanation. Educators also need to engage in meaningful inquiry and form general theories. They must be aware of the conceptual landscape of their classes, crafting the form of instruction in consideration of students’ knowledge and group dynamics. They must also have a general theory of how the learning environment and pedagogy can support deep understanding of the curriculum and nurture creativity in their students. These aspects of teaching represent both the art and the craft of education.
References Arlin, P. K. (1993). Wisdom and expertise in teaching: An integration of perspectives. Learning and Individual Differences, 5, 341–349. Arlin, P. K. (1999). The wise teacher: A developmental model of teaching. Theory into Practice, 38, 12–17. Barab, S. A., & Plucker, J. A. (2002). Smart people or smart contexts? Cognition, ability, and talent development in an age of situated approaches to knowing and learning. Educational Psychologist, 37, 165–182. Barr, R. B., & Tagg, J. (1995). From teaching to learning: A new paradigm for undergraduate education. Change, 27(6), 12–25. Bereiter, C., & Scardamalia, M. (2000). Commentary on Part I: Process and product in problem-based learning (PBL) research. In D. H. Evensen & C. E. Hmelo (Eds.), Problem-based learning: A research perspective on learning interactions (pp. 185–195). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Berliner, D. C. (2001). Learning about and learning from expert teachers. International Journal of Educational Research, 35, 463–482. Bruner, J. (1996). The culture of education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Cropley, A. J. (2003). Creativity in education and learning: A guide for teachers and educators. London: Kogan Page. Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1988). Society, culture, and person: A system view of creativity. In R. J. Sternberg (Ed.), The nature of creativity (pp. 325–339). New York: Cambridge University Press. Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1996). Creativity: Flow and the psychology of discovery and invention. New York: HarperCollins. Dodge, B. (2006, July). From nouns to verbs: Turning fossilized content into lively learning. Paper presented at the International Conference on Problem-based Learning, Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú, Lima.
66
Marion Porath and Elizabeth Jordan
Donovan, M. S., Bransford, J. D., & Pellegrino, J. W. (Eds.) (1999). How people learn: Bridging research and practice. Washington, DC: National Academy Press. Duckworth, E. (1987). “The having of wonderful ideas” and other essays on teaching and learning. New York: Teachers College Press. Fosnot, C. T. (Ed.) (1996). Constructivism: Theory, perspectives, and practice. New York: Teachers College Press. Howe, M. J. A. (2004). Some insights of geniuses into the causes of exceptional achievements. In L. V. Shavinina & M. Ferrari (Eds.), Beyond knowledge: Extracognitive aspects of developing high ability (pp. 105–118). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Jordan, E., Porath, M., & Bickerton, G. (2003). Problem-based learning as a research tool for teachers. In A. Clarke & G. Erickson (Eds.), Teacher inquiry: Living the research in everyday practice (pp. 141–153). London: RoutledgeFalmer. Keating, D. P., & Hertzman, C. (Eds.) (1999). Developmental health and the wealth of nations. New York: Guilford Press. Leinhardt, G., & Steele, M. D. (2005). Seeing the complexity of standing to the side: Instructional dialogues. Cognition and Instruction, 23, 87–163. Motamedi, K. (1982). Extending the concept of creativity. Journal of Creative Behavior, 16, 75–88. Peterson, K. (1992). Life in a crowded place: Making a learning community. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann. Porath, M. (in press). What makes a gifted educator? A design for development. In L. Shavinina (Ed.), The international handbook on giftedness. New York: Springer Science. Shavinina, L. V., & Ferrari, M. (Eds.) (2004). Beyond knowledge: Extracognitive aspects of developing high ability. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Shulman, L. S. (1986). Paradigms and research programs in the study of teaching: A contemporary perspective. In M. C. Wittrock (Ed.), Handbook of research on teaching (3rd ed., pp. 3–36). New York: Macmillan. Shulman, L. S. (1990). Reconnecting foundations to the substance of teacher education. Teachers College Record, 91, 300–310. Sternberg, R. J., & Horvath, J. A. (1995). A prototype view of expert teaching. Educational Researcher, 24(6), 9–17. Torrance, E. P. (2004). Predicting the creativity of elementary school children (1958–80): The teacher who “made a difference.” In D. J. Treffinger (Ed.), Creativity and giftedness (pp. 35–49). Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. Turner-Bisset, R. (1999). The knowledge bases of the expert teacher. British Educational Research Journal, 25, 39–55.
CHAPTER 5
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski,* and Maija Kärnä† University of Lapland, *Mikkeli University of Applied Sciences, and †Pirkanmaa University of Applied Sciences, Finland
Abstract This chapter explores through two Finnish case studies the use of problembased learning to provide a creative learning environment. In the first case, online supervision and collaboration during clinical placement of students in a problem-based physiotherapy course were carried out in the virtual learning environment Moodle and using the desktop conferencing tool Marratech. The second case examined business students’ perception of the usefulness of pre-tutorial discussion conducted asynchronously in a discussion forum and in Wiki, both built into the Moodle environment, in constructing students’ individual and group knowledge bases. The results of both cases show benefits as well as challenges in facilitating computer-supported collaboration and learning. The lessons learned from the case studies and the implications are discussed.
Introduction Problem-based learning (PBL) was introduced in Finnish higher education in the 1990s. Since then, its use has spread to various disciplines and programs, and it can be said that PBL has now entered the second phase of development in Finland. What distinguishes PBL as a teaching methodology, perhaps more of an educational strategy, is the change in the whole learning environment that it requires. And this
68
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
involves the holistic consideration of a number of elements: the organizational context, curriculum content and design, as well as teaching and learning approaches, including methods of assessment and evaluation. For students, PBL provides a creative learning environment in which knowledge is constructed. For teachers, it offers an effective tool for facilitating learning and nurturing active learners. However, the use of this tool demands faculty cooperation rather than the traditional approach of working alone (Poikela & Poikela, 2006). In this chapter, we examine the development of creative environments in PBL through two case studies investigating the integration of online collaboration with problem-based pedagogy in a business and a physiotherapy course in Finland. Based on the findings, we consider the lessons learned and the implications.
PBL for a Creative Learning Environment Savin-Baden and Howell Major (2004) have noted different approaches to PBL adoption. Among them are what they describe as the “PBL funnel approach” and “PBL on a shoestring,” which involve implementation on a macro level where individual teachers experiment with PBL in their own courses or modules within traditional subject-based curricula. These “patchwork” PBL models adopt a two-pronged approach, using lectures and other traditional teaching methods on the one hand and group work along the line of PBL on the other. An integrated curriculum, in contrast, allows PBL to be implemented on a macro level across the entire curriculum. On a broader scale with a cross-disciplinary approach, problems from different disciplines are integrated into the curriculum. This is a strategy for transforming curricula. At its best, it leads to fundamental pedagogical changes, redirection of teachers’ work, and transformation of the entire learning culture (Barrett, 2005; Chen, 2000; Poikela, 2003). The PBL curriculum provides a collaborative knowledge-building and self-directed learning environment that can be simplified as shown in the schematic in Figure 5.1. This concept has been adopted in many disciplines in higher education institutions in Finland. From our experience,
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
69
Work life Experts
Organizations Problems Training Tutorial
Assignments
Other media Internet Library
Lessons Self-directed study
FIGURE 5.1 The problem-based learning curriculum provides a collaborative knowledge-building and self-directed learning environment SOURCE: Poikela & Poikela (2006), p. 76.
it is very important to understand PBL as a whole system rather than merely an instructional technique. Such a learning environment promotes empowerment and creativity for both learners and teachers. The core of the PBL method is the tutorial, a small group session with 7–9 students and a teacher acting as tutor. Tutorials are held once or twice a week with the same participants throughout the study module or semester. Another fundamental element of PBL is a self-directed study period between tutorials when students are required to explore various kinds of information resources in their search for solutions. Group members share responsibilities for conducting information searches focusing on sources of theoretical knowledge with the aim of gaining sufficient understanding to allow deeper exploration of the problem at hand. Additional information can be obtained by interviewing experts or conducting Internet research. The purpose of integrating shared research and self-study into the curriculum is to reduce the time spent in lectures while increasing the time for independent study and information search. Lectures become a learning resource like any other type of resource, including published literature, practical training, and assignments. New kinds of demands are placed on the quality of lectures and assignments; they need to be tailored
70
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
and timed according to the process of problem solving. New demands are also placed on the quality of learning materials. For instance, Webbased material provided for solving the given problem needs to be relevant, useful, and up-to-date. At the same time, the material produced by students themselves is of increased importance because the learning is shared and collaborative. For PBL implementation, broad cooperation across the institution is required. Teachers cannot handle the curriculum by themselves because PBL demands institution-wide planning and implementation.
The Problem-solving Process The process of problem solving may be structured in different ways. One of the most well-known models was developed by Barrows at the University of McMaster, Canada (Barrows, 1985; see also Barrett, 2005). Another is the “seven jump” model of Schmidt (1983) at the University of Maastricht, the Netherlands, and its many variations from other institutions. The cyclical model developed at the University of Linköping, Sweden, has been widely applied, too. For this reason, it is not possible to identify a single, “best” model of PBL. PBL offers a framework for structuring and facilitating learning and group processes based on creative problem solving. Carefully designed work-related problems create a solid base for learning. The problemsolving process is facilitated by the teacher in tutorials lasting two to a maximum of four hours at a time. The PBL process begins with students working toward a shared understanding of the problem presented to them. They then brainstorm ideas about the content area related to the problem using their existing knowledge and prior experiences. Similar types of ideas are grouped into named categories. The most important and actual problem areas among the named categories are determined. The first tutorial session is then held to decide on the learning tasks to undertake and the goals to achieve. Following the tutorial, students engage in information search and self-study, working both individually and in pairs or in small groups depending on the learning tasks and goals as well as the strategy deemed
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
71
most appropriate for seeking information. The second tutorial is the time for applying the new knowledge acquired, to tackle the learning tasks, and to reconstruct the problem in a new way. New and deeper knowledge is synthesized and integrated to provide a basis for deeper learning. Participants clarify and reflect on the whole problem-solving process and the learning process in the light of the new knowledge. The PBL process, or cycle, is summarized in Figure 5.2. In the diagram, assessment is placed at the center, as it is part of every single phase of the process. However, it is still necessary to close the tutorial with feedback about students’ own learning, their information-seeking behavior, their problem-solving skills, and the group processes so that improvements can be made. Students may need to learn information-seeking skills when they start doing PBL. It is not enough for the tutor to simply ask students to go
Problem-solving cycle continues
1. Problem setting 8. Clarification: comparing with and structuring original problem
2. Brainstorming: free association 3. Systematization
Assessment 4. Selection: thematization 5. Learning task formulation
7. Knowledge integration and construction
6. Knowledge acquisition: self-study
Experts Training Organizations
FIGURE 5.2
Lessons Assignments
Internet Library Other media
The problem-based learning cycle and knowledge acquisition
SOURCE: Poikela & Poikela (2006), p. 78.
72
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
and find information from the library or the Internet. It is essential that tutorials include discussion about where and how the most relevant information can be found and what the most important resources are. Students need practice and guidance to familiarize themselves with different kinds of information resources before they can become effective, competent information seekers. Librarians and other information specialists can also provide the necessary guidance. Virtual and Web-based environments are becoming increasingly important as forums for guiding study and for finding, sharing, and evaluating information. Such concepts as Web 2.0, social media, and mobile learning have been the subject of lively discussion concerning the next stage of development of the Finnish technological society. Social media (Web 2.0), including the notion of online collaboration, is the most rapidly evolving phenomenon on the Web. The various facilities of the social media, such as blogs, wikis, discussion forums, and Internet calls, are widely used by the young generation. Thus, it is only natural that the educational possibilities that social media offer should also be seriously considered. Moreover, mobile technology provides new ways for teachers and learners to augment and improve learning and teaching, especially when working with geographically dispersed groups. There has been a growing interest among educational researchers recently in computer-supported PBL in online environments (Donnelly, 2004, 2005; Strømsø et al., 2004; Valaitis et al., 2005; Savin-Baden & Wilkie, 2006; Portimojärvi, 2006a, 2006b). The networked environment can provide a space for constructive learning that enables interaction between learners as well as extensive information search from diverse sources. And students are expected to enhance each other’s learning by using various tools and resources for collaborative problem solving. When students work remotely, they need effective tools for communication. The combination of online technology and PBL challenges not only learners but also educators to adapt their existing skills as well as to adopt new skills to enhance learning in virtual environments. We will next analyze two cases, one in physiotherapy education and the other in business education, where PBL has been successfully implemented for several years and advanced technological solutions have been deployed recently to support PBL online.
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
73
Cases Case 1. Enhancing Learning and Supervision via Online Collaboration during Clinical Placement in a Problembased Physiotherapy Course This study is an integral part of a wider development project launched in 2005 at the Mikkeli University of Applied Sciences, Finland. The project aims to utilize information and communication technology (ICT) along with problem-based pedagogy to enhance learning and supervision during clinical placement. A fully integrated PBL curriculum has been implemented in this bachelor-degree physiotherapy course since 1998. Integrated blocks of academic study alternating with practical training periods have been designed to enhance the integration of academic and clinical learning. Since its launch, a range of electronic resources and online communication tools have been introduced to staff and students. This study examined online collaboration between students on clinical placement and with their teachers and supervisors using the virtual learning platform Moodle (http://www.moodle.org) for asynchronous communication and the desktop conferencing tool Marratech (http:// www.marratech.com) for synchronous communication. Marratech, used together with a laptop, a Web camera, headphones, text-based chat, and a shared whiteboard, offers a multimodal channel for real-time online communication and mobile learning.
Research question and methods The aims of the study were to examine online collaboration between the participants during clinical placement to find out which aspects of the collaboration were problematic and what improvements could be made to enhance the integration of academic and clinical learning. The study was conducted in autumn 2006 over a five-week period of clinical placement in private and public health organizations located in different parts of Finland. The participants were 24 third-year physiotherapy students, 3 teachers, and 21 clinical supervisors (physiotherapists). A problem scenario related to recording patient information
74
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
and making decisions in physiotherapy was integrated into the clinical training. The first tutorial was held before the placement, and the second tutorial following the first. As an integral part of professional training, the clinical posting offered an opportunity for independent study and information seeking on the given problem scenario. During clinical placement, students were required to record how they identified and recognized patients’ needs, assessed and gathered information, made diagnoses, analyzed and synthesized information, and applied problem-solving strategies and clinical reasoning in order to plan, prioritize, and implement appropriate physiotherapy. For the tutorials, the students were divided into three small groups of 7–9 students at the beginning of the term. One off-campus group engaged alternately in synchronous and asynchronous online collaboration and self-study. The two groups remaining on campus engaged in computer-supported collaborative knowledge construction and documentation, traditional face-to-face tutorials, and asynchronous online collaboration between tutorials. All participants had access to Moodle during clinical training. The students were required to post their written learning documents, case reports, learning agreements, and reflection diaries onto Moodle. The case report was an account of the student’s own clinical experiences together with relevant research literature. The learning agreement was a written agreement negotiated between the student, the teacher, and the clinical supervisor on the learning objectives and resources, the learning criteria, and the learning outcomes. At the end of each study week, students were expected to reflect on their own learning and understanding in their reflection diary. The teachers and supervisors would guide and give feedback on students’ learning documents via Moodle, while students were required to comment on each other’s documents in the same forum. Additionally, two students on clinical placement abroad used Marratech to communicate with their teacher. Textual data consisted of individual students’ learning documents as well as written comments and conversations between students, teachers, and supervisors made over Moodle. Videos were recorded of conversations conducted between students and teachers using Marratech. Qualitative content analysis (Hsieh & Shannon, 2005) was done to define
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
75
the type of online collaboration. The comments and conversations were coded and then, based on how the various codes were related and linked, sorted into the categories of clinical behavior, content knowledge, and reflective writing. Content analysis continued with a comparison of the content of the categories against students’ individual learning documents. This combined analysis became the basis for interpreting and presenting the findings.
Results The data indicate that online communication appeared to create more opportunities for versatile collaboration, thus enhancing the integration of academic and clinical learning during clinical placement. On the other hand, the lack of ICT skills, time, motivation, or access to appropriate communication tools was a hindrance. Asynchronous online collaboration in Moodle enabled physiotherapy students to receive and post written comments and feedback on their learning and to reflect on the feedback. Most of the collaboration in Moodle was between students and teachers. The content of collaboration was divided into three categories: (1) clinical behavior, comprising comments about students’ behavior in clinical situations; (2) content knowledge, consisting of comments on the given problem scenario relating to recording information and making decisions in physiotherapy; and (3) reflective writing, comprising students’ reflections on their own learning and understanding. While most of the comments and feedback on students’ reflective writing and content knowledge were given by teachers, students commented most often on each other’s clinical behavior. The supervisors’ written comments related only to the learning agreements. In their reflection diaries, students expressed disappointment with delayed feedback on their learning documents. However, they were generally satisfied with their peers for their helpful observations and good questions, and with the teachers for being the most reliable evaluators of curricular expectations. It must be noted that the students did not place emphasis on teachers’ feedback on their clinical learning. Similarly, they did not expect their clinical supervisors to comment on their reflection
76
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
diaries and case reports, but instead they attached greater importance to their face-to-face interactions with the supervisors in daily learning situations. They also highlighted the benefits of getting feedback during placement from all parties—peers, teachers, and supervisors. Table 5.1 summarizes these observations. The two students on attachment abroad highlighted desktop conferencing as a versatile and efficient way of communication during placement, enabling synchronous collaboration remotely with sight and sound. It allowed the students to get immediate feedback and response from their teacher, reassuring them that they were “on track.” Additionally, the textual communication in Moodle enabled them to follow parallel discussions about similar questions that concerned them. This seemed to ease their anxiety about being “isolated” or “uninformed.” There were other students echoing this sentiment.
Discussion The results of this case study are compatible with those of other studies. It was reported that medical students’ expectations of tutor involvement
TABLE 5.1 Content of asynchronous online collaboration during clinical placement Clinical behavior
Content knowledge
Reflective writing
Participants’ contributions
Peers giving good questions and helpful observations
Most feedback from teachers
Most feedback from teachers, while supervisors comment on learning agreements
Noteworthy observation
Decreased expectation of tutor involvement
Reliance on teacher as evaluator of curricular expectations
Disappointment with delayed feedback; importance attached to feedback from all parties
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
77
in problem-based tutorials conducted remotely during clinical placement decreased compared with face-to-face tutorials held within the institu-tion (Strømsø et al., 2004). A similar decrease was noted in our physiotherapy students’ expectations of teacher involvement in their clinical learning. Several possible explanations may be offered, such as the characteristics of the communication media used (Portimojärvi, 2006b) or the teacher’s and the supervisor’s competence in working in and guiding interaction in the virtual environment (Donnelly, 2004). The online environment differs from the face-to-face environment in a number of ways, accompanied by its specific tensions. As such, the expertise and skills required for online instruction are different. “Going online” does not necessarily lead to savings in staff time (Hmelo-Silver et al., 2006), an indication of the complexity of the work involved. The context of clinical placement must also be considered in this regard. Physiotherapy students gained greater access to experts during clinical placement, and this may have reduced their need for guidance and feedback from their teacher on their learning. It is also important to note that, while these students expected feedback from their peers and teacher, it was on different aspects of learning from what they expected from clinical experts. Well-timed synchronous and asynchronous virtual communication during clinical placement seemed to create a conducive environment for collaborative learning, joint knowledge construction, and information exchange. It can be concluded that this enhanced the integration of academic and clinical learning as well. However, it might be insightful to examine more closely the different expectations of the students about the role of the teacher and the clinical supervisor. It became clear that guidance was focused on individual learning processes. It could be useful to design collaborative activities conducive to joint guidance, such as online tutorials with the participation of both the teacher and the clinical supervisor, as well as synchronous online sessions for group interaction and guidance during clinical placement. Prior to that, clearly we need to train teachers and clinical supervisors to use online environments and communication technology to facilitate synchronous and asynchronous communication between all parties—students, teachers, and supervisors.
78
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
Case 2. Using Web 2.0 to Create a Common Knowledge Base in Business Education This study is part of a development initiative undertaken at the Ikaaline Business School, Pirkanmaa University of Applied Sciences, to create an innovative learning environment combining PBL and Web 2.0. The first phase of the project was to develop the curriculum for a Bachelor of Business Administration program based on PBL. The new integrated curriculum was introduced in 2005. It was quickly followed by a plan to integrate Web 2.0 facilities into the PBL environment, so as to encourage students to actively engage in online collaboration, not just to use the existing information resources on the Web. The process of building common ground for a group formed the focus of this study. The common information base, or common ground, is necessary for a group to operate, to achieve its objectives, and to create new knowledge. The concept of collective information processing was first introduced by Kathleen Propp in 1999. The process consists of four stages, beginning with the construction of the individual information base. The individual information base consists of the knowledge that each member possesses of the task concerned and which the member brings to the group, including the person’s past experiences in similar situations, general knowledge, and any information that he or she has collected before meeting with the group. At the second stage, the individual knowledge bases are connected and a new group knowledge base is formed. This group knowledge base includes all the collective knowledge available to the group as a whole. At this stage, there are several group-level factors that might affect the rest of the process, such as group size and composition, internal relationships, and preexisting preferences of group members. The impact of communication and discussion becomes the central focus at the third stage. The information that the group members exchange and shape during group discussions forms the communicated information base. At the final stage, the outputs of the previous stages are processed. The final collective information base includes the information that is accepted and utilized by the group to reach a decision on the task at hand (Propp, 1999, pp. 231–236).
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
79
Research question and methods The aim of the study was to first explore whether it was possible to create a common information base using two Web 2.0 tools: an asynchronous discussion forum and Wiki, a Web-site engine that allows visitors to edit its contents. Both tools were embedded in the Moodle virtual learning platform. Moreover, we wanted to find out if there were any differences in students’ use of these resources. Nine first-year business students volunteered to participate in this study, which was conducted in the second term of academic year 2005/ 2006, consisting of two eight-week study periods. The students used the discussion forum during the first study period and Wiki during the second period, both to support self-study between weekly tutorials. For each period, the students worked with a different tutor, both of whom were interviewed after they concluded their work with the students. Learning diaries were collected from students after each period, and at the end of the second term a group interview was organized. The interview was recorded and transcribed. The data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis.
Results The students used the Web discussion space to get new ideas, find new sources of information, and refine their own information search. The space became a forum for sharing the knowledge that each student possessed. There was a general effort among the students to always find unique information to share on the forum. The students reported frequently a reluctance to repeat any information already given by others. The messages contained mainly facts culled from various sources, whereas own experiences were not shared except at the very beginning of the first period. According to the students, the Web discussion helped them form a holistic picture of the topic at hand and focused their own information search. It was considered valuable in expanding individual knowledge bases. Additionally, it generated a pool of shared information that served as a basis for subsequent face-to-face tutorial discussion.
80
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
However, there was a general dissatisfaction among the students with the nature of the discussions. The messages were mostly long, unconnected statements of facts clearly copied directly from various sources. The students reported that hardly any real discussion, questions, or exchange of opinions could be found. New information introduced by fellow group members was not internalized. After using the discussion forum for eight weeks, the students switched to Wiki. Wiki was a new tool to the students and, in spite of training given at the beginning of the period, they found it difficult, awkward, confusing, and time-consuming to use and the structure of the Wiki environment unsuitable for actual discussion. They used Wiki in the same way that they did with the discussion forum: for sharing the information that they possessed individually, for helping them to refine their own information search, and as a source of new ideas. Compared with the discussion forum, the students found Wiki more convenient for storing information because information on it was well organized and easy to locate. Both Wiki and the discussion forum restricted the topics of discussion in the face-to-face tutorials. Only issues introduced on Wiki were discussed, as the topics for the tutorials were determined based on those found on the Wiki index page.
Discussion The results show only minor differences in application between the discussion forum and Wiki. Both tools appeared to form a source for building up individual knowledge bases and a space for storing shared information. Wiki seemed to offer a more structured and organized resource for broadening the knowledge base than the discussion forum, where the shared information was scattered in the messages. However, the students were unable to reach common ground over the Web. This is well in line with the findings of earlier studies. Clark and Schaefer (1989) note that before the participants of Web-based conferencing are able to reach a deeper level of interaction and learning they have to find adequate common ground in terms of shared understanding, knowledge, beliefs, assumptions, and presuppositions. For that to happen, all participants should show an interest and a willingness
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
81
to continue discussion toward reaching common ground by providing feedback, questions, and support to their peers (Mäkitalo et al., 2002). In the present study, it was noted that students shared knowledge but not mutual understanding, beliefs, or assumptions. They failed to express support and give feedback to their peers, a fact that was clearly evidenced by the lack of discursive messages. Thus, the group was not able to reach mutual understanding and establish common ground during their Web interaction, and the negotiation of meaning was left for face-to-face discussions. Figure 5.3 shows how the various stages of collective information processing of the study group were divided between Web interaction and face-to-face interaction. The information base is depicted as a triangle, with its tip being the individual information base that a student starts to build at the beginning of a learning task and the base being the common knowledge base of the group at the completion of the learning task. On the basis of the study findings, it is clear that only the first two stages— the expansion of individual information bases and the creation of the group knowledge base—took place over the Web, whereas negotiation of meaning started only during the face-to-face discussion in the tutorial. The line cutting across the triangle represents the border between the
Web interaction
Group knowledge base
Individual knowledge base
Negotiation of meaning Face-to-face interaction
Common ground
{
{
• Information retrieval • Expansion of individual
knowledge bases • Construction of group
knowledge base • Negotiation of meaning • Final group knowledge
base formed • Completion of
individual knowledge bases
FIGURE 5.3 Contribution of Web interaction toward establishment of common ground SOURCE: Kärnä & Kallioniemi (2006), pp. 64–66.
82
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
outcomes of Web interaction and those of face-to-face discussion (Kärnä & Kallioniemi, 2006). In order to further integrate and harness the full benefits of the online PBL environment, we must find a way to move the boundary between Web interaction and face-to-face discussion further down toward the final stage, which is the formation of the final collective information base or common ground.
Conclusion: The Lessons Learned Both the business and physiotherapy programs under study have incorporated PBL for several years, with fully integrated problem-based curricula. At the beginning, when developing the innovative curricula, many issues had to be solved, such as the design and development of the new curricula, teachers’ insecurity about shifting the focus from teaching to facilitating learning, as well as students’ unwillingness to accept greater responsibility for their own learning. After resolving these issues, the focus has now shifted to developing even more creative and effective learning environments with the implementation of ICT. The two cases represent different fields of professional studies as well as different stages of study (academic study versus professional training). However, in both cases, advanced technological solutions were applied to support PBL online. Despite the differences, similarities can be noted. Firstly, students used online collaboration to get reassurance for being “on the right track.” This physiotherapy students got from their teacher and business students from their peers. Secondly, although students generally welcomed the introduction of new learning methods and the use of online facilities, there was still hesitation and doubt among teachers and supervisors, as well as among some of the students, about adopting ICT tools for learning and teaching. More training and support from ICT experts is needed to build confidence in using the facilities. Only when this is done will students and teachers be able to focus on learning and teaching and not get distracted by frustrating technical problems. Thirdly, in both cases, one of the problems encountered was the lack of discussion and knowledge building among students. In the physiotherapy case, most of the collaboration in Moodle was between
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
83
teachers and students during clinical placement. In the business case, there was a general lack of discussion and exchange of opinions, beliefs, and understandings among students during the independent study period. Thus, in both cases, the potential of the technologies was not optimally and fully exploited. The online collaboration did not lead to common ground, which would have enabled group members not only to share knowledge but also to create new knowledge. In online PBL, there is an increasing focus on synchronous as well as asynchronous collaboration to meet the need for shared understanding and knowledge building. The aim is not only to enable online tutorials to be held but also to facilitate independent study between tutorials, when students share information in order to build mutual understanding and a common knowledge base. Further, desktop conferencing tools like Marratech coupled with Web cameras and headphones allow communication and group work to take place in online tutorials with sight and sound just like in face-to-face tutorials. Additionally, technological tools can be employed for recording, constructing, and visualizing the shared understanding and knowledge in face-to-face tutorials. Finally, we consider the implications of the lessons learned for the design of problem-based curricula and the implementation of problembased pedagogy. PBL does not follow the structure of academic subjects but that of problem solving within shared and individual learning processes. In a holistic approach to problem-based curriculum design, all aspects of learning, teaching, and assessment, regardless of the tools and environments used, have to be tuned to support the integration of shared learning and self-study, the integration of academic and practical learning, and the building of professional competence.
References Barrett, T. (2005). Understanding problem-based learning. In T. Barrett, I. Mac Labhrainn & H. Fallon (Eds.), Handbook of enquiry and problem-based learning: Irish case studies and international perspectives (pp. 13–25). Galway: All Ireland Society of Higher Education (AISHE) and Centre for Excellence in Learning and Teaching (CELT), National University of Ireland. Retrieved from http://www.nuigalway.ie/celt/pblbook.
84
Sari Poikela, Pirjo Vuoskoski, and Maija Kärnä
Barrows, H. (1985). How to design a problem-based curriculum for the preclinical years. New York: Springer. Chen, S. E. (2000). Problem-based learning: Educational tool or philosophy. In O. S. Tan, P. Little, S. Y. Hee & J. Conway (Eds.), Problem-based learning: Educational innovations across disciplines (pp. 210–219). A collection of selected papers from the Second Asia-Pacific Conference on Problem-based Learning. Singapore: Temasek Centre for Problem-based Learning. Clark, H., & Schaefer, F. (1989). Contributing to discourse. Cognitive Science, 13, 259–294. Donnelly, R. (2004). Investigating the effectiveness of teaching “on-line learning” in a problem-based learning on-line environment. In M. Savin-Baden & K. Wilkie (Eds.), Challenging research in problem-based learning (pp. 50–68). Maidenhead: Society for Research into Higher Education (SRHE) and Open University Press. Donnelly, R. (2005). Using technology to support project and problem-based learning. In T. Barrett, I. Mac Labhrainn & H. Fallon (Eds.), Handbook of enquiry and problem-based learning (pp. 157–177). Galway: AISHE and CELT. Retrieved from http://www.nuigalway.ie/celt/pblbook. Hmelo-Silver, C. E., Nagarajan, A., & Derry, S. J. (2006). From face-to-face to online participation: Tensions in facilitating problem-based learning. In M. Savin-Baden & K. Wilkie (Eds.), Challenging research in problem-based learning (pp. 61–78). Buckingham: SRHE and Open University Press. Hsieh, H., & Shannon, S. (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research, 15(9), 1277–1288. Kärnä, M., & Kallioniemi, M. (2006). Verkkotyöskentelyn osuus yhteisen tietoperustan rakentamisessa (The influence of interaction over the Web in building the common knowledge base). In T. Portimojärvi (Ed.), Ongelmaperustaisen oppimisen verkko (Net of problem-based learning) (pp. 47–66). Tampere, Finland: Tampere University Press. Mäkitalo, K., Häkkinen, P., Leinonen, P., & Järvelä, S. (2002). Mechanisms of common ground in case-based Web discussions in teacher education. Internet and Higher Education, 5, 247–265. Poikela, S. (2003). Ongelmaperustainen pedagogiikka ja tutorin osaaminen (Problem-based pedagogy and tutors’ knowing and competence). Tampere: Tampere University Press. Poikela, E., & Poikela, S. (2006). Problem-based curricula: Theory, development and design. In E. Poikela & A. R. Nummenmaa (Eds.), Understanding problem-based learning (pp. 71–90). Tampere: Tampere University Press. Portimojärvi, T. (2006a). Hyppy tuntemattomaan: Opiskelijana ongelmaperustaisessa verkkoympäristössä (Leap to the unknown: Students in computermediated problem-based learning environments). In A. R. Nummenmaa
Developing Creative Learning Environments in Problem-based Learning
85
& J. Välijärvi (Eds.), Opettajan työ ja oppiminen (Teacher’s profession and learning) (pp. 223–247). Jyväskylä: Institute for Educational Research, University of Jyväskylä. Portimojärvi, T. (2006b). Saman-ja eriaikaisen etätyöskentelyn vuorottelu ongelmaperustaisessa verkko-opiskelussa (Synchronous and asynchronous collaboration in online problem-based learning). Retrieved June 13, 2008, from http://elearn.ncp.fi/materiaali/epeda/artikkelit/CMCPBL_vuorottelu_ ePeda_Portimojarvi.pdf. Propp, K. M. (1999). Collective information processing in groups. In L. R. Frey, The handbook of group communication theory and research (pp. 225–250). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Savin-Baden, M., & Howell Major, C. (2004). Foundations of problem-based learning. London: Open University Press. Savin-Baden, M., & Wilkie, K. (Eds.) (2006). Challenging research in problembased learning. Buckingham: SRHE and Open University Press. Schmidt, H. G. (1983). Problem-based learning: Rationale and description. Medical Education, 17(1), 11–16. Strømsø, H., Grøttum, P., & Hofgaard Lycke, K. (2004). Changes in student approaches to learning with the introduction of computer-supported problem-based learning. Medical Education, 38, 390–398. Valaitis, R. K., Sword, W. A., Jones, B., & Hodges, A. (2005). Problem-based learning online: Perceptions of health sciences students. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 10, 231–252.
CHAPTER 6
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design Pauline Sameshima Washington State University, USA
Abstract Embodied aesthetic pedagogic design is a means of approaching teaching that intentionally attends to holistic embodied aesthetic considerations, reconceptualizes and destabilizes the teacher role, and develops complicit learning environments. To teach creatively, the teacher must develop an artful relationship between the self and the curriculum, and open avenues for the student to personally engage with, thoughtfully reflect on, and meaningfully organize that curriculum. An arts-based research and learning methodology called performative inquiry is explicated in depth to provide the reader with an understanding of how a teacher can transform curriculum goals into a problem-based learning framework, seek an instructional form that attends to these three design tenets, and thereby develop a creative learning environment that allows access to a multiplicity of possible answers for solving the problem at hand while deeply engaging the learner.
Introduction The world has changed from a manufacturing engine to a services-driven enterprise. To adapt, we need to change our educational approach to developing not only skills and knowledge bases but also lifelong learning skills in order to prepare young people for a complex future. We need an education system that dynamically nurtures and honors imagination, creativity, flexibility, novelty, interdisciplinary perspectives, and deep
88
Pauline Sameshima
reflexive thinking. Young people need to develop the skills for learning how to learn. They need to interact with multiple modes of learning and engage with creative people to help them develop processes of creative thinking and design. They also need to learn how to gather seemingly disparate information, organize it holistically, and refine it mindfully to create elegantly integrated products. This artful design process is the same process for designing engaging curricula. In this chapter, I introduce embodied aesthetic pedagogic design, a means of approaching teaching that (1) intentionally attends to holistic embodied aesthetic considerations, (2) reconceptualizes and destabilizes the teacher role, and (3) develops complicit learning environments. Worldwide, different countries and their governments have considerably dissimilar views on what constitutes creative thought and how creativity is to be studied (Sternberg, 2006). As far back as 1877, Jevons had described creativity as “divergence from the ordinary grooves of thought” (p. 576). My work draws on creativity research from Englishspeaking countries that is based on Guilford’s seminal creativity work in the 1950s and onward, which has led to creativity being understood as meaning divergent thinking (e.g., Baer, 1993; Baer & Kaufman, 2006; Guilford, 1956, 1967; Guilford & Hoepfner, 1971; Torrance & Presbury, 1984). Sternberg notes that “a wide variety of personality traits have been associated with creativity, including independence of judgment, self-confidence, attraction to complexity, aesthetic orientation, tolerance for ambiguity, openness to experience, psychoticism, risk taking, androgyny, perfectionism, persistence, resilience, and selfefficacy” (Kaufman & Sternberg, 2006, pp. 17–18). Evidenced creativity is the ability to conceive of the unlikely being systematically and gracefully integrated as if it should have always been the most likely response to the problem at hand. To teach creatively, the teacher must develop an artful relationship between the self and the curriculum, and open avenues for the student to personally engage with, thoughtfully reflect on, and meaningfully organize that curriculum. To explain this concept, I will briefly introduce each of the three aspects of embodied aesthetic pedagogic design and then demonstrate how these three tenets can generate creativity and deep transformative learning through an arts-based research methodology
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
89
called performative inquiry. The development of creative learning spaces does not necessarily have to take place in performative role spaces as in the example I will provide; but rather the focus should be on how the teacher can attend to these tenets in a variety of particular contexts in relation to the considered curriculum. The example is explicated in depth to provide the reader with an understanding of how the three tenets work together in pedagogic design. If the teacher transforms curriculum goals into a problem-based learning framework and then seeks a form that attends to the tenets, the number of possible answers for solving the problem inherently increases. The example I use stemmed from questions I had as a practicing teacher concerning perceptions of the teacher–parent relationship. I translated the questions into a problem-based “playshop” where participants attempted to shed light on the issues of concern through a performancebased research inquiry. This project, named “Performing outside the parameters of pedagogy: A performative inquiry into the teacher–parent relationship,” developed into an international performative inquiry study that included not only elementary-aged students but also teacher educators, practicing teachers, parents, and university faculty members from multiple fields of study.
Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design Holistic Embodied Aesthetic Considerations Transformational learning can be significantly deepened through the intentional development of a curriculum system and an educational culture that attend to teaching and learning holistically by incorporating body learning (multisensory arts–infused active learning). Consideration must be given to increasing receptivity and openness to learning; fostering skills for relating between learners, between learner and teacher, and between learner and context; modeling wholeness-in-process (the teacher modeling creative knowledge production behavior); layering multiple strategies for connecting to the experience; and acknowledging ecological and intuitive resonances. (For detailed descriptions of these
90
Pauline Sameshima
considerations, see Sameshima, 2007a, 2007b, 2008.) These considerations are essential for developing embodied aesthetic teaching. However, in this chapter, I shall attend to the broader scope of how the three tenets of embodied aesthetic pedagogic design, when integrated, make possible the development of multiple perspectives. The example will show how these considerations are intricately woven into the fabric of the performance framework.
Reconceptualizing and Destabilizing the Teacher Role The teacher’s approach to students’ learning is especially important, as creative problem solving in educational settings requires facilitation, yet without suppression of freedom. Thus, the teacher’s role in overtly as well as indirectly steering the learning is significant. I agree with Scandinavian notions of creativity, that creativity is “an attitude toward life and a way of dealing with the challenges life poses” (Sternberg, 2006, p. 4). The teacher’s perspective and outlook will influence how the curriculum is delivered. In order to be open to other perceptions, the teacher must destabilize self by suspending perceived stereotypical views that are based on socialization and experience. Shapiro (1999) and Boal (1979) consider these views as barriers to moving out of routine views. Authentic learning experiences occur when the learning situation is spontaneous, open, and seemingly undirected (Deleuze & Guattari, 1987). Critical to the use of this approach to inspire creativity is the call for intuition to be acknowledged, particularly when encouraging learning that is “messy” or “rhizomatic” (Deleuze & Guattari, 1987; Sameshima, 2007b; Wiebe et al., 2008). Such a learning environment demands a radical reconceptualization of the teacher role as that of co-constructor of learning. When the teacher’s being is positioned in a way that is not hierarchical or directive, then the learning “system” will be open to a creative means of learning. Significant transformative learning occurs through problem-based learning situations (Tan, 2003) when specific consideration is given to relational pedagogy and power, in combination with the teacher’s approach to learning. Transformational learning occurs when tradi-
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
91
tional relationships of power are disrupted (Hytten, 1999). In role drama teaching, also known as Forum Theatre (Boal, 1979), the teacher is no longer the teacher, as the drama becomes co-constructed and the students are empowered. This decentralization of power is also a marked characteristic in inspiring authentic creativity. Finding ways to destabilize identities and redistribute power in the classroom creates the possibilities for students to delve deeper or immerse themselves in learning. Destabilizing the teacher identity and changing the power dynamics are part of the uncertainty principle that Tan (2003) talks about. He explains that problem-based learning projects are strengthened by accepting uncertainty, unsystematic thinking, and nonplanning as part of the learning process. This is the crux of creativity generation.
Complicit Learning Environments Think of the teaching environment that allows learning to emerge as, metaphorically, a garden with sprinklers spouting water. The water coming out has the freedom to flow in multiple directions. The water (knowledge), while suspended in the air, is “influenced” by the sun, wind, and other environmental (contextual) conditions before falling freely to the ground to be absorbed as needed by the earth (the learner). Cohen and Stewart (1994) explain that complicit systems are not dependent on initial conditions that frame and limit the space of the possible (see also Sumara & Davis, 1997). The word complicit suggests implication, involvement, and commitment. It usually alludes to association or participation in questionable activities. The word is used specifically to remind educators that, to be mindful and progressive, one needs to be “subversive.” The subversive educator continually questions the unquestioned and the accepted, disturbing and reconceptualizing the status quo. To teach a complicit curriculum, the teacher must be complicitly involved, be deeply committed to learning, and continually question assumptions and traditional processes. To learn within a complicit curriculum, the learner must be immersed in the learning environment. Creativity is most energized when the learner has the possibility of seeing multiple points of view through being both “in” (absorbed in the
92
Pauline Sameshima
moment) and “out” (seeing the immersion from a distance) (Sameshima, 2007b). For example, in performative inquiry, a qualitative arts-based research methodology used as a problem-based learning strategy in role drama situations (Fels, 1999, 2002), creativity is fostered when the learner is able to delve into new transformative spaces yet suspend belief. The ability to move in and out of “reality” is crucial, as this skill provides a safety net or exit point for the learner. The ability to suspend belief but use the “unreal” to negotiate personal positioning is key to this type of creative learning. Augusto Boal (1995), talking about performance spaces for learning, describes this dual awareness as metaxis, which is when the student or actor “can see himself in the act of seeing, in the act of acting, in the act of feeling, the act of thinking. Feel himself feeling, think himself thinking” (p. 13). To use a metaphor to illustrate this bisociative thinking (Koestler, 1975), imagine Janus, a Roman mythological god who had a face on both sides of his head that allowed him to see the past and the future while always located in the present. The ability to view a situation from various vantage points, diverse standpoints, or multiple references is advantageous for broadening perception (Rothenberg, 1979; Sameshima, 2007b; Stout, 2000). Creativity stems from this ability, the skill of seeing multiple perspectives. Pezeshki (2007) points out that integral thinking will be necessary for twenty-first century education. “Integral thinking is generated when individuals who are strong in their independent disciplines come together with open minds toward the concerns of other disciplinary experts” (p. 9A). Performance inquiry provides a learning space that implicates the learner, thereby creating complicit involvement. Problem-based learning environments developed in performative inquiry spaces support and validate learning, providing complicit learning environments that destabilize identity and allow transformative learning to occur.
Performative Inquiry Example This research project demonstrates the use of a holistic embodied aesthetic learning situation, the reconceptualization and destabilization
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
93
of the teacher role, and the development of a complicit learning environment. A 60-minute multimedia interactive playshop was designed to elicit publicly articulated dialogically constructed undestandings of the teacher–parent relationship from participants. The hope was for participants to come forth with obvious as well as submerged presumptions, notions, and biases of the barriers inhibiting positive teacher– parent relationships. Performative inquiry was a fitting method of research for this interrogation, uniquely allowing and providing a safe forum for voicing commonly unspoken understandings that strongly frame paradigms and ideologies on teacher–parent communication. The playshop was presented in Canada and the United States in 2004 to a broad range of participants, including teacher candidates, beginning teachers, practicing teachers, grade 6–7 students, graduate students and university faculty members from various disciplines, and management conference participants (Sameshima, 2004a–2004e). Many of these participants were parents.
Background to the Project This qualitative arts-based methodological investigation examined the communication practices and the underlying conceptions of the relationship between teachers and parents. The goal of the participatory playshops was to extend the foundation for emergent research on developing positive teacher–parent partnerships for the purpose of raising student achievement at the elementary level (kindergarten to grade 7). Research has indicated that involving the family in a child’s education is an important element in improving the child’s learning (DuFour, 2000; Hirsh, 2003; Richardson, 1997; Sameshima et al., 2006). The areas of concern in research are in providing teachers with appropriate guidance on how to be more effective in communicating with parents (Hirsh, 2003) and teaching parents how they can effectively help their children with schoolwork (Epstein, 2001). Understanding preconceptions, perceptions, and conceptions of the teacher–parent relationship is foundational to addressing these concerns.
94
Pauline Sameshima
Teacher–Parent Communication I get very frustrated . . . ask [about] my daughter and then the answer I’ll get back, “yeah she’s doing fine” which isn’t really what I want to know. So it is frustrating. (Power & Clark, 2000, p. 42, quoting a parent)
Power and Clark (2000) observed in their research that parents had widespread concerns about both written and oral reporting by teachers. Parents found written reports confusing or overgeneralized. When the information was understood, parents did not feel that the reports sufficiently guided them to assist their children. Teachers, on the other hand, spent considerable time reporting formally and informally to parents, much more frequently than the legally mandated number of times in a Western school year (see also Davidson, 2003; Epstein et al., 2002). To look into these issues, my research was guided by the following questions: Why is it difficult for teachers to openly communicate with parents? What barriers are there between teachers and parents? How can better communication be facilitated between the two groups?
Performative Inquiry as a Methodology The insights that arise during role drama may encourage the rethinking of personal and societal positionings and beliefs and the choice of the lens through which an individual views his or her life, thus becoming an invitation to each [participant] to imagine alternative ways of being in the world. (Fels, 2002, p. 8)
Tom Barone (2001) asserts that the goal of using arts-based inquiry is to disturb, to interrogate personal and cultural assumptions that have come to be taken for granted; [and] to do so, [researchers] employ design elements that are appropriate for their intent. These elements (which vary according to art form) are important for their usefulness in recasting the contents of experience into forms with the potential for challenging (sometimes deeply held) beliefs and values. (p. 26)
In 2003, at the University of British Columbia, Canada, I met and studied with Lynn Fels, the pioneer of performative inquiry as a site and action of learning and as an arts-based research methodology. In
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
95
performative inquiry, the creation of a virtual reality (role drama) becomes a heuristic device that creates a new set of meanings and values for the participant. Through role play, dance, or movement, participants respond to photographs, stories, enacted scenes, or other forms of stimuli proposed by the researcher, teacher, or peer leader. Performative inquiry is based on Boal’s (1979) Theatre of the Oppressed. Boal created a number of activities, such as Forum Theatre, that various communities can use to explore social justice issues. Through the performative inquiry playshop described above, participants publicly revealed assumptions and understandings not previously articulated. Forum Theatre, which enables learners to construct personal understandings of the unfolding scene, is a method of teaching that intrinsically creates complicit, involved learning. I use the word “playshop” instead of “workshop” because, although we are working to seek understanding, the process of play and the unscripted performance excitement generate fresh, bright, and energetic new ways of thinking. Gadamer (1989/1960) speaks of transformation in play: Something is suddenly and as a whole something else, [and] this other transformed thing that it has become is its true being in comparison with which its earlier being is nil. When we find someone transformed we mean precisely this, that he has become another person, as it were. (p. 111)
The plausibility of role drama is based on “structural corroboration . . . coherence with the human condition and credible possibility” (Kilbourn, 1999, p. 31). Arts-informed researchers Cole and Knowles contend that clear intellectual and moral purpose, the researcher being present in the moment of research with the participants and in the retelling, a procedural harmony, and “ambiguity and humility to allow for multiple interpretations and . . . response” are integral to legitimate research (2001, p. 217). Although, according to Cole and Knowles, these defining qualities describe life history research, these and other beliefs support the authenticity of role drama as a means to advance knowledge claims, and offer theoretical and transformative potential. A virtual reality world has the capacity to pull the person who experiences it into an alternative reality (Barone & Eisner, 1997; Langer, 1957). After the role drama activity, out of role, the participants’ views are
96
Pauline Sameshima
broadened as they have come to appreciate another point of view after attempting to enact a scenario, or engage with someone, from a different perspective, paradigm, or ideology. Through role drama sessions, participants may reveal assumptions and understandings not previously evident to themselves or to others. Edward and Nancy Kienholz, installation artists who explore oppression, suffering, and societal pathos, talk about using their art to “force the viewer to a position of self-identification” (Harten, 1996, p. 45). Unlike visual art, where the self-identification is internally realized in the mind and perhaps verbally reflected upon, the performance form of art allows embodied hermeneutic comprehension—visually, auditorily, and kinesthetically. Appelbaum (1995) succinctly holds that “Intellect’s light sees but is powerless to do. The body’s light sees and is able to do” (p. 121). Even a powerful visceral response to an inert visual art piece is generally a private static response. But in role drama, the conversation and understandings are “outside,” publicly and dynamically co-constructed in the moment—a living, breathing multidimensional canvas of art in action. In role, Clifford (1988) says, “reality is no longer a given, a natural, familiar environment. The self, cut loose from its attachments, must discover meaning where it may” (p. 119). Clifford believes that detachment of the self, when assuming another’s role, “is the practice of juxtaposition, a hybrid of ethnography and surrealism, that enables the repositioning of the body within the matrices of culture” (p. 147). In the midst of role play, the individual comes to an understanding of the self in relations because the unarticulated is voiced and participants become aware of holistic themes—seeing the self as an essential piece of the whole puzzle. I believe this concept of seeing oneself as vital in the scheme of the whole is a critical tool that provides powerful agency not only to researchers and individuals in general but also for children to function responsibly in a classroom, whatever their age. Philosopher Hannah Arendt (1968) further supports the aforesaid. She discourages simple acceptance of the abstract collective perspective, strongly promoting “visiting,” which she defines as careful listening to the perspectives of others. By keeping various standpoints in mind while pondering a given issue, one is better able to make a wise judgment. This
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
97
very action of listening closely and publicly dialoguing within a role drama has wonderfully broad potential for recognizing possibilities for individual and collective agency. Performative inquiry not only allows the individual “thought struggle” but also affirms multiple voices, realities, and experiences (Paley, 1995). When interacting in a group role-play, the synergy of the group often raises awarenesses that may previously have been unidentified. Paley calls this community voice the “polyphonous voice.” To create this individual but harmonious voice, we must speak it aloud. Brownyn Davies tells us, “Collective biography makes visible the liberal humanist myth of oneself as unique and distinct and enables [us] to see the collective (usually discursive) processes through which we become embodied as human” (as cited in McLaren, 2001, p. 70).
Research Inquiry Sessions The 60-minute inquiry session comprised an introductory interactive activity, a visual information slide presentation, and three short activities followed by a discussion period. The final segment was essential in helping members synthesize and create meaning from the preceding exercises. During this segment, we discussed what happened, what questions emerged about the relationships, and what recommendations we could make as a group to improve communication. I will explain each segment and share the most relevant revelations. As participants entered the playshop space, each person was instructed to make a simple hat, a stapled circular strip of construction paper, on which they each wrote their name boldly and attached a yellow square to the “front” and a purple square to the “back.” Participants drew an icon that represented “teacher” in the yellow square and “parent” in the purple square. For example, on my hat, I drew “sun” for teacher by day and “moon” for parent by night. The wearing of the hat contributed to a sense of “instant community,” allowed participants to know each other by name, and ultimately provided a “mask” that promoted freedom of speech. In role, with the “mask” of an alternate persona, participants could more freely contribute to a nonconstricted conversation.
98
Pauline Sameshima
Creating an open, trusting, and secure place for sharing is imperative when attempting to get people to share the unspoken, particularly in a short period of time. As facilitator, I purposely spent time sharing my own location in this landscape. Providing private and personal contexts (photographs of my family and my classroom) and sharing some information wider than “in the moment” are important for opening communication paths. Using the Johari Window leadership personality framework developed by Luft and Ingham (see Hersey et al., 1996) in a slide, I was able to simply frame effective communication based on self-perception, disclosure, and feedback. Simply put, in order to open communication with a group, we have to let the group see each other in alternate contexts, not only the current visible. For example, knowing that the man in the blue sweater loves to sail helps make connections between group members. Laying down a foundational “net” between people is important when beginning this particular type of research, which can be likened to an aerial trapeze act. One never knows where the role drama will lead. Comments may be “caught” by other flyers, or perhaps not. Following the introductory activity, I briefly shared key research information slides on performance inquiry as a research method.
Activities First drama activity The first activity involved sharing three photographs that raised issues about role perceptions. Participants were asked to look at the photographs and identify the teacher and the parent. “The woman on the left is the teacher because she is dressed more professionally.” “The woman on the right looks like a teacher.” “The pad of paper is closer to the woman on the left so she is most likely the teacher.” “The woman on the right looks like she’s the teacher because of her body language.” “Both women look closed off. They don’t look like they’re communicating well.”
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
99
“If the woman on the left is the teacher, then she looks defensive and the woman on the right looks aggressive.” “The woman on the right is the teacher because she looks like she’s in control.”
Responses to the pictures were consistently similar across all research groups. Most groups became ambivalent as the discussion continued, but it was clear that people were at first quick to make decisions, implying that they had preconceived notions and expectations of what a teacher and a parent look like in a school setting. In my experience as a long-time classroom teacher and administrator, role perception is one of the most significant barriers between teachers and parents. For many teachers, the classroom is a distinctly separate place from their private lives. Teachers essentially create within themselves boundaries or frames around their school and home lives, which in turn impact their public relationships. Gregory Bateson (1972) likens such framing to “the frame around a picture, as a message intended to order or organize the perception of the viewer. . . . The message says, ‘Attend to what is within and do not attend to what is outside’” (p. 187). Unwittingly, framing the roles and dichotomizing the self, even subconsciously, through choice of clothing, location of home relative to the school, and using colloquial language away from school, for instance, all positively enhance what is in the frame. Thus, the roles become self-generatively strengthened as they are defined, and the frames become barriers discouraging intrapersonal wholeness as well as interpersonal connections.
Second drama activity The second drama activity required participants to separate into groups. Using a “Lights on! Lights off!” signal, participants were asked to create a soundscape involving teachers and parents. For example, without using words, one group representing teachers muttered in a slow monotone, while the “parents” made urgent ambulance siren sounds. After the soundscape, the group was asked to explain their interpretation of what they observed. In this case, the act was of worried parents pleading for help for their children and teachers being noncommittal, nonchalant, tired, and overworked.
100
Pauline Sameshima
In the soundscape, words, with their encapsulating multi-meaning baggage, did not guide the path of meaning creation. The vagueness, elusiveness, and openness of the performance method of playing in the liminal space (the edge of conscious understanding) allows the learner to invoke an unworded notion and encourages transformation and différance to generate. The word différance was coined by Jacques Derrida (1982) from the French word différer, “to defer” (in the sense of to postpone) and “to differ.” Différance generally refers to the belief that words and signs can never pronounce exactly what they mean but can only be defined or explained using more words, which leads to the notion that words and signs are always different from what they mean. Derrida argues that, because the perceiver’s mental state is constantly in a state of flux, reading and seeing differs with each rereading. Différance does not imply contradictory understanding upon rereading, but rather a re-arrival of the moment of reading. In performative inquiry, the present moment is always considered the “real” and there is no différance because there is no text to come back to. Even my recollections of the playshops are constructed stories because the role drama was not captured or stilled. I am of the belief that “full” openness may be inhibited if people knew they were being recorded. My postmodern perspective that knowledge is not truth, that knowledge is partial, and my resistance to constraint and closure, all pull me to search for ways to render understanding in heartfelt, nonsequential, and nonlinear forms. If we can render thoughts in nonwords, we may actually come to deeper understandings. I expect a multiplicity of interpretations and know that the understandings are synchronically produced.
Third drama activity This activity required the participants to separate themselves on either side of a masking tape strip taped across the floor. The participants took a pose, in role, as parents (purple square on their hats facing forward) or teachers (yellow square visible). As the facilitator, I then tapped parents and teachers randomly, who then each made a comment from “their side” to the other. They were to
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
101
say whatever they had always wanted to but could not say to the “other side.” Some comments were responses to comments made, while others were independent; but as the comments progressed, general themes began to emerge. At a preservice teacher conference where I presented this playshop, a theme emerging from the crowd of over 30 teacher candidates was that issues surrounding behavioral management in class arose because of poor parenting skills. Comments such as “Don’t you know your child is driving me crazy!” or “He is ruining all my lesson plans!” and “I’m not here to raise your child!” were surprisingly frequent. Naturally, teacher candidates who spent copious time on detailed lesson plans would have much more frustration dealing with the unpredictability of student behavior when trying to adhere to a lesson plan that is often broken down by time schedules. More experienced teachers were more likely to express their insecurity about delivering the curriculum “properly.” Deep fears of uncertainty in all adult groups about teaching and parenting “the right way” were a recurrent theme. In a grade 6–7 group, students in role as parents instructed the “teachers” to be stricter with their children but not to give their children as much homework because homework was a family stressor. Lastly, fears about either group “crossing” into the other’s space were evident. Some participants in role as teachers felt that parents were challenging their professional skills by asking questions about student learning. Other participants, in role as parents, felt that poor achievement on the part of their child reflected negatively upon the family, allowing teachers a view into the family’s private life. Creating the role play as it unfolds allows space for embodied learning. Role drama encourages a freedom to write a story without having to write on the lines, to even ignore lines, to not use words, to connect body learning with head learning, to create artifacts without understanding, to search for meaning without theme, or to play with no record. These are the ways of learning—playing. As mentioned, Gadamer (1989/1960) posits that transformation occurs in play. What is present will emerge in play, for play is a rite of passage to learning. And learning in safe, secure landscapes encourages provocative liberation.
102
Pauline Sameshima
Discussion Period Following the drama activities, a discussion period is essential. The debriefing, named “mapping-in-exploration” by Fels (2002), is the time and place to begin to unravel the intricacies of reaction and experience. Although the experience of being in a role drama is powerful, very often it is in the reflexive recollections and verbal articulations of the experience where the dialogic synergy of new understanding occurs. The discussion period metaphorically opens the door on the other side of the limen—the metonymic space of the backslash as described by Ted Aoki, which is “the hinge between the imaginary worlds of possibility, and those which we inhabit, that allows us new imagining of possible ways of becoming” (as cited in Fels, 2002, p. 8). Maxine Greene (1978) describes this space as “wide-awakeness.” Garoian (1999) asserts that performance art teaching allows critique and challenge of culture in general. Performative inquiry provides a forum for “awakenings” or “coming to understanding” of “reality” or assumptions often unvoiced. Elliot Eisner (1995) agrees that “artistically crafted novels, poems, films and paintings, and photography have the capacity to awaken us from our stock responses” (p. 2). Performative inquiry thus has the capacity to switch our realities with our dream worlds, to take us from the “real,” the mundane quotidian of day into the awakened dream state. The “awake” space is a merging of the real and the unlimited potential possibilities of imagination and dreams where wholeness, creativity, invention, freedom, wonder, understanding, peace, and hope reside. Surprise and deep revelation were consistent responses expressed during all the discussion periods. Many participants were astonished to find that their views, when voiced aloud, were often universal, sometimes irrational and defensive, and surprisingly liberating. Speaking the unsaid across the “tape border” metaphorically released the “stoppers” and dissolved the barrier between the two groups in the discussion period. During that time, participants were able to reflectively chuckle at what they had come to believe as acceptable teacher and parent defensive postures. Many participants who considered themselves shy and quiet found that they were free to express in this forum. This point is especially
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
103
important because very often in classroom learning situations conversations are generally directed by the most vocal. There is much work to be done in the area of understanding the teacher–parent relationship. This playshop can be a valuable tool for professional development and for helping preservice teachers come to understand the relationship and barriers to communication between teachers and parents as well as their own underlying values, beliefs, biases, questions, and fears that impact on that relationship. Further work in this area can articulate a set of recommendations to teacher education programs for developing required courses in communication, cultural diversity, and family studies. Improved understanding will result in better communication practices between the two groups, which could subsequently positively impact student achievement.
Conclusion This performative inquiry into perceptions and conceptions of the teacher–parent relationship can liberate our communication practices by opening bridges of acknowledgment to public dialogues. By stepping outside of parameters of pedagogy, we can then begin to understand and work together toward common goals. From this example, we understand not only that perceptions of role and the particular frames in which learners situate the self can impede dialogue and creative innovation, but also that developing environments that allow for multiperspective learning opens avenues for creative and transformative learning. To establish creative learning spaces in curriculum design, teachers must develop an artful relationship between the self, the students, and the curriculum. Mindfully attending to holistic embodied aesthetic considerations, reconceptualizing and destabilizing the teacher role, and developing complicit learning environments are means to construct creative learning spaces that support embodied aesthetic pedagogic design.
104
Pauline Sameshima
References Appelbaum, D. (1995). The stop. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Arendt, H. (1968). Between past and future: Eight exercises in political thought. New York: Penguin Books. Baer, J. (1993). Creativity and divergent thinking: A task-specific approach. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Baer, J., & Kaufman, J. C. (2006). Creativity research in English-speaking countries. In J. C. Kaufman & R. Sternberg (Eds.), The international handbook of creativity (pp. 10–38). New York: Cambridge University Press. Barone, T. (2001). Science, art, and the pre-disposition of educational researchers. Educational Researcher, 30(7), 24–28. Barone, T., & Eisner, E. (1997). Arts-based educational research in complementary methods for research in education. Washington, DC: American Educational Research Association. Bateson, G. (1972). Steps to an ecology of mind. San Francisco: Chandler. Boal, A. (1979). Theatre of the oppressed (C. A. McBride & M.-O. Leal McBride, Trans.). New York: Routledge. Boal, A. (1995). The rainbow of desire: The Boal method of theatre and therapy (A. Jackson, Trans.). London: Routledge. Clifford, J. (1988). The predicament of culture: Twentieth-century ethnography, literature, and art. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Cohen, J., & Stewart, I. (1994). The collapse of chaos: Discovering simplicity in a complex world. New York: Penguin Press. Cole, A. L., & Knowles, J. G. (2001). Qualities of inquiry. In L. Neilsen, A. L. Cole & J. G. Knowles (Eds.), The art of writing inquiry (pp. 211–219). Artsinformed Inquiry Series, Vol. 1. Halifax, Nova Scotia, and Toronto, Ontario: Backalong Books and Centre for Arts-informed Research. Davidson, J. (2003). Show, don’t tell: Strategies for family involvement in CES schools. Horace, 19(4). Retrieved November 12, 2007, from CESNationalweb: http://www.essentialschools.org/cs/resources/view/ces_res/305. Deleuze, G., & Guattari, F. (1987). A thousand plateaus. London: Continuum. Derrida, J. (Ed.) (1982). Différance. In Margins of philosophy (pp. 3–27). Chicago: Chicago University Press. DuFour, R. (2000). Community: Clear connections. Journal of Staff Development, 21(2), 59–60. Eisner, E. (1995). What artistically crafted research can help us understand about schools. Educational Theory, 45(1), 1–6. Epstein, J. L. (2001). School, family, and community partnerships: Preparing educators and improving schools. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
105
Epstein, J. L., Sanders, M. G., Simon, B. S., Salinas, K. C., Rodriguez Jansorn, N., & Van Voorhis, F. L. (2002). School, family, and community partnerships (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. Fels, L. (1999). In the wind clothes dance on a line: Performative inquiry—a (re)search methodology: Possibilities and absences within a space-moment of imaging a universe. Ph.D. thesis, University of British Columbia, Canada. Fels, L. (2002). Spinning straw into gold: Curriculum, performative literacy, and student empowerment. English Quarterly, 34(1/2), 3–9. Gadamer, H. (1989). Truth and method (D. Marshall & J. Weinsheimer, Trans., 2nd rev. ed.). New York: Continuum. (Original work published 1960) Garoian, C. R. (1999). Performing pedagogy: Toward an art of politics. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Greene, M. (1978). Landscapes of learning. New York: Teachers College Press. Guilford, J. P. (1956). The structure of intellect. Psychological Bulletin, 53, 267– 293. Guilford, J. P. (1967). The nature of human intelligence. New York: McGraw-Hill. Guilford, J. P., & Hoepfner, R. (1971). The analysis of intelligence. New York: McGraw-Hill. Harten, J. (1996). Universal life. In W. Hopps (Ed. & Curator), Kienholz: A retrospective: Edward and Nancy Reddin Kienholz (pp. 44–47). New York: Whitney Museum of American Art/Distributor Art. (Original work published 1989) Hersey, P., Blanchard, K. H., & Johnson, D. E. (1996). Management of organizational behavior: Utilizing human resources (7th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. Hirsh, S. (2003, April). Develop teachers’ skills as communicators. Results. Retrieved November 12, 2007, from http://www.nsdc.org/library/publications/ results/res4-03hirs.cfm. Hytten, K. (1999). The promise of cultural studies, of education. Educational Theory, 49(4), 527–543. Jevons, W. S. (1877). The principles of science: A treatise on logic and scientific method. New York: Macmillan. Kaufman, J. C., & Sternberg, R. (2006). The international handbook of creativity. New York: Cambridge University Press. Kilbourn, B. (1999). Fictional theses. Educational Researcher, 28(9), 27–32. Koestler, A. (1975). The act of creation. London: Picador. Langer, S. K. (1957). Problems of art. New York: Scribner. (Original work published 1942) McLaren, R. (2001). Off the page. In L. Neilsen, A. L. Cole & J. G. Knowles (Eds.), The art of writing inquiry (pp. 62–82). Arts-informed Inquiry Series, Vol. 1. Halifax, Nova Scotia, and Toronto, Ontario: Backalong Books and Centre for Arts-informed Research.
106
Pauline Sameshima
Paley, N. (1995). Finding art’s place: Experiments in contemporary education and culture. New York: Routledge. Pezeshki, C. (2007, November 6). Moving toward integral thinking at WSU. Moscow-Pullman Daily News, 92(266), 9A. Power, S., & Clark, A. (2000). The right to know: Parents, school reports and parents’ evenings. Research Papers in Education, 15(1), 25–48. Richardson, J. (1997, December/January). Student learning improves when families get involved. Tools for Schools. Retrieved November 12, 2007, from http://www.nsdc.org/library/publications/tools/tools12-97rich.cfm. Rothenberg, A. (1979). The emerging goddess: The creative process in art, science, and other fields. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Sameshima, P. (2004a, February). Emancipation of our roles: Interrogating the status quo. Participatory workshop presented at the Western Canadian Association of Student Teachers (WestCAST) Conference, University of Alberta, Canada. [With data collection] Sameshima, P. (2004b, April). Emancipation of our roles: Interrogating the status quo. Participatory workshop presented at the American Association for the Advancement of Curriculum Studies (AAACS) Conference, University of San Diego, San Diego, CA. [With data collection] Sameshima, P. (2004c, April). Emancipation of our roles. Participatory workshop presented at the International Association of Management Conference, Norfolk, VA. [With data collection] Sameshima, P. (2004d, April). Emancipation of our roles. In 2004 Association of Management/International Association of Management Conference Proceedings (Vol. 1, No. 1). Chesapeake, VA: Maximilian Press. Sameshima, P. (2004e, May). Emancipation of our roles: Interrogating the status quo. Participatory workshop presented at the Canadian Society for the Study of Education (CSSE) Conference, Winnipeg, Canada. [With data collection] Sameshima, P. (2007a). Collaboration as integration: An “embodied aesthetic wholeness.” Curriculum in Context, 3(2), 10–14. Retrieved from http://www. wsascd.org/cic.htm. Sameshima, P. (2007b). Seeing red—A pedagogy of parallax: An epistolary bildungsroman on artful scholarly inquiry. Youngstown, NY: Cambria Press. Retrieved from http://www.cambriapress.com/cambriapress.cfm?template= 4&bid=102. Sameshima, P. (2008). Letters to a new teacher: A curriculum of embodied aesthetic awareness. Teacher Education Quarterly, 35(2), 29–44. Sameshima, P., von Euw, N., & Bonney, M. (2006, March). Bifocal frameworks for communication: Parental involvement in an elementary classroom. BC Educational Leadership Research, 3. Retrieved from http://slc.educ.ubc. ca/eJournal/index.htm.
Inspiring Creativity through Embodied Aesthetic Pedagogic Design
107
Shapiro, S. B. (1999). Pedagogy and the politics of the body: A critical praxis. New York: Garland. Sternberg, R. (2006). Introduction. In J. C. Kaufman & R. Sternberg (Eds.), The international handbook of creativity (pp. 1–9). New York: Cambridge University Press. Stout, C. J. (2000). In the spirit of art criticism: Reading the writings of women artists. Studies in Art Education, 41(4), 346–360. Sumara, D., & Davis, B. (1997). Enlarging the space of the possible: Complexity, complicity and action-research practices. In T. Carson & D. Sumara (Eds.), Action research as a living practice (pp. 299–312). New York: Peter Lang. Tan, O. S. (2003). Problem-based learning innovation: Using problems to power learning in the 21st century. Singapore: Thomson Learning. Torrance, E. P., & Presbury, J. (1984). The criteria of success used in 242 recent experimental studies of creativity. Creative Child and Adult Quarterly, 9, 238–243. Wiebe, S., Sameshima, P., Irwin, R., Leggo, C., Gouzouasis, P., & Grauer, K. (2008). Re-imagining arts integration: Rhizomatic relations of the every day. Journal of Educational Thought, 41(2), 263–279.
CHAPTER 7
Creativity and Group Dynamics in a Problem-based Learning Context Clara E. Gerhardt and Claire Michelle Gerhardt* Samford University and *Art Center College of Design, USA
Abstract The team context, as provided by problem-based learning (PBL), affords opportunities to enhance creative output. Teams involve several participants, implying increased resources, ideas, and energy. Groups have the potential to generate their own synergy, ideally allowing the group to go beyond the capacities of individuals working by themselves. The complexity of some problems requires the input of multiple participants. The dimensions of the combined work output, supported by a multi-professional team, allow high creativity and sophisticated end products. Knowledge of group dynamics can take the creative process to a higher level and minimize elements that are destructive to group functioning. In PBL, the power of group processes is harnessed to facilitate learning through problem solving. Attention to the group structure, group management, and conflict resolution, as well as knowledge of common group-related difficulties, can help the facilitator in making PBL a success.
Introduction Problem-based learning (PBL) is a powerful teaching and learning vehicle partly because of the group processes that occur in PBL teaching and learning interactions. Group members have to assume real-life work roles in these collaborative situations and, above all, they learn from one another. In the PBL classroom, healthy group functioning is integral to the teaching and learning process. The facilitator, with knowledge and skills
110
Clara E. Gerhardt and Claire Michelle Gerhardt
of group dynamics, can anticipate problem areas in group functioning and resolve them in a constructive manner, in the process adding to the impact of the learning situation. Groups tend to go through predictable patterns in order to function as a cohesive and constructive whole. The PBL group can become a classroom model of what group functioning in the workplace can entail. Part of becoming a better team member is understanding the value gained from being part of a team. Teams involve more people, implying increased resources, ideas, and energy than what an individual could generate. For this reason, successful groups represent more than just the sum of the contributions of their members. Groups have the potential to generate their own synergy, ideally allowing the group to go beyond the capacities of individuals working by themselves. Some Nobel prizes are increasingly awarded to teams, because the complexity of certain problems requires the input of multiple researchers. For example, the 2006 Nobel Prize in Physiology went to Andrew Fire from Stanford University and Craig Mello from the University of Massachusetts for their joint work on RNA interference and gene silencing (Nobel Foundation, n.d.). The dimensions of their research did not allow the project to be executed by one individual.
The Synergy of a Team Individual insight is seldom as broad and deep as that of a group. Teams share the credit for victories and the blame for losses. This fosters genuine humility and authentic community. (Avery et al., 1981)
The team context generates multiple perspectives that allow a number of proverbial roads “leading to Rome.” Each path can be approached through several alternative possibilities, and this in itself enhances flexibility. As situations and problems are multidimensional, they require more than individual insight to reach the desired goal or to meet the need in question. Successful teams have leaders who keep the team on target. These leaders are goal directed, keeping their eye on the prize and leading their
Creativity and Group Dynamics in a Problem-based Learning Context
111
team members through difficult transitions to get it. Teams can anchor their goals and pool complementary skills, thereby multiplying the individual worth of their members. Ideally, teams maximize a leader’s potential while minimizing his or her weaknesses. For team members, the team context can have the effect of exposing their individual strengths and weaknesses. In contrast, individuals working alone can change their goals without accountability. They will also take credit and blame by themselves, which in turn can foster a sense of pride or of failure. Being a member of a good team is worthwhile, as it can enhance an individual’s professionalism in a variety of careers. There are simple rules and guidelines to make teamwork more efficient, problem-free, and enjoyable. These guidelines also allow self-assessment in working toward becoming a better team player.
Laying the Ground Rules In successful team collaboration, ideally a set of rules is laid down before the team begins a major task. Laying down the rules for group functioning should be the first communal task of the group, leading toward creative team building and smoothing the collaborative process. Ideally, the rules should not impose on group functioning; instead, they should set the group free to perform at its peak. The Italian ballerina Alessandra Ferri says her dancing technique “gave me the freedom to be who I am onstage, to move with the music however I wish, because my body is so finely tuned. You have to translate your emotions in your body, that is how you speak onstage. That comes naturally for me, but your body is your speech. Technique is not the ultimate, but the beginning” (as cited in Woods, 2007, p. 39; italics added). Team formation is the setting up of a framework within which everyone will function. The metaphor of a harmonious chamber orchestra or a jazz band comes to mind. In a creative team of designers, the process should be the same. Everyone on that team needs to agree that they are all there to create something or to solve a problem, as well as who will play what part and what will be the rule set by which the team will be
112
Clara E. Gerhardt and Claire Michelle Gerhardt
governed. Maxwell (2001) suggests that team members think of the first team-building exercise as “writing the Magna Carta.” The Magna Carta was the most significant early document in Great Britain, which influenced and led to the rule of constitutional law. Similarly, everyone needs to come together and decide on major issues, establishing the rules and regulations that will allow successful collaboration and unity in mission. It is essential to lay down the following guidelines to ensure successful teamwork.
Clarity of Mission What is the major goal of the team? Ask everyone around the table, “Why are we doing this?” Spend time going through individual answers and considering the various viewpoints. Continue until team members agree on one of the suggestions in order to achieve clarity.
Disclosure of Dedication What will it take for people to invest 100 percent effort? People are motivated by a range of things: to expand their horizons, monetary rewards, visibility, acknowledgment, or simply a good grade. People need to honestly disclose what it is that they need and want from the group interaction. If they are not truthful, they may hinder the group process. Some individuals handle multiple projects and cannot give priority to any one project. As a team, you can barter with individuals so that they can indeed get what they want. In this exchange, individuals have to contribute what the team needs to be successful while also meeting their own needs. In a genuine exchange, group members should be able to commit to saying “Yes, I’ll do that,” as this is the foundation for a strong team.
Decision Making Clarify how decisions will be made. Will they be made by consensus, the leadership, or majority vote? There will come a time in every team when
Creativity and Group Dynamics in a Problem-based Learning Context
113
major decisions have to be made, and the team can fall back on their earlier agreement on the decision-making process. This is also a guiding principle in the orderly running of committees.
Communication Practices Establish how and when team members communicate. Ask for preferences: email, telephone, or in person. Collect contact information and make it available to all group members. One of the most important elements in building personal relationships is communication. This applies to teams as well. Effective and clear communication ensures that a group of people can function on the same plane and work toward the same goal without wasting time. If English is a second language to some team members, allow sufficient time to ensure that everyone has an equal opportunity to voice their opinions. Be respectful of cultural and individual differences in communication style, and learn from them. If communication threatens to become unclear, go back to the source to clarify and indicate communication preferences that will facilitate clear exchanges.
Team Structure How will the team be structured, in terms of who does what and when? Determine team members’ strengths and, more importantly, interests and how these can be utilized. Just like in an orchestra, not everyone plays the same instrument. There must be opportunities for each member to show their strengths. Teams that have worked together previously know each member’s strengths well and can allocate the work efficiently. If it is a newly formed team, try to be as open as possible about what each member is interested in working on. Remember to communicate clearly.
Conflict Resolution How will the team deal with conflict should it arise? Create a team constitution of how members should behave. This helps convert the team into a community. Besides talking about how conflict is to be resolved, also
114
Clara E. Gerhardt and Claire Michelle Gerhardt
consider rewarding the team for good performance: “If we do a good job on this presentation, we’re all going out to dinner.” Occasionally, teams become totally dysfunctional. If after going through a reasonable process of trying to get people in a productive mode but the interventions fail, then it may be necessary to just pull some people out of the team. Alternatively, it can be helpful to break the impasse by bringing in an outside consultant to examine the team’s progress to that point and clarify directions.
Process Management Establish guidelines on who the designated note taker will be, or whether this role should rotate, both of which have advantages of their own. It is important to use consistent file formats and provide access to the group’s documentation to ensure continuity and minimize resource waste. Having to reinvent the wheel at the beginning of each work session can be avoided if documentation is central and available. In the classroom situation, a course management system such as Blackboard (incorporating WebCT) (http://www.blackboard.com/products) can serve this function. This Web-based information platform allows continuous communication between all group members and also provides a valuable record of inputs. Such systems can be applied in both educational and work environments. Being able to readily access each other’s inputs saves time and prevents frustration with miscommunication. It is good practice to have at least one person, a “scribe,” take notes during each meeting session. These notes have to be shared with the rest of the team. When creative ideas flow fast and furious, the designated scribe in the group can capture them on paper for later use and assessment.
Perseverance Some of these guidelines may sound obvious, but the foremost problem that keeps recurring is of teams falling apart because they have not invested time in laying the ground work. Or they have strayed from the guidelines because they thought they already knew the team rules and
Creativity and Group Dynamics in a Problem-based Learning Context
115
could bypass the mundane procedure. Take the time to go through this process in order to build a strong team. If we think of how much effort we put into designing products, systems, and services, or learning and teaching new course material, we owe it to ourselves to set aside some time to designing our team, for after all it is a system that will enable and enhance our creativity.
Methods for Successful Collaboration and Inspiring Creativity The main requirements for successful collaboration are to define the goal and to set up the structure for achieving that goal. Once the framework is in place, there are other factors that can help make a strong team. Individual team members can become an asset by offering skills and expertise that can help the team get the work done better and faster. In addition, teams can employ techniques and methods such as the following to inspire creativity.
Six Hats Method by Edward de Bono As a team member figuratively changes hats, the attitude with which a problem is examined changes. This technique can enhance diversity of thought by applying different types of thinking to the subject. It can foster creativity by maintaining a playful (not too critical) attitude as everyone in the group switches from one metaphorical “hat” to another, each representing a different mindset. This allows the team to concentrate on a specific focus at a specific time; for example, criticism can be put on hold while wearing the yellow hat. The group works through one hat or mindset at a time, not all simultaneously. The six hats comprise the following: White hat is cold, neutral, and objective; while wearing it, you can look at the facts and figures. Red hat represents anger (seeing red), and it signals the time to listen to your intuition and emotions. Black is careful and cautious. Yellow is sunny and positive. Green is full of creative new ideas. Blue is the organizer of thoughts (de Bono, 1985).
116
Clara E. Gerhardt and Claire Michelle Gerhardt
Changing the Environment By moving outdoors or to a more or less stimulating environment, team productivity may be enhanced or the focus refreshed. Rearranging the furniture in the team meeting room can give the team a fresh perspective. Change the environment and maybe the idea previously set will change as well. It can be very helpful to be in the environment or setting for which one is designing or about which one is learning. For example, if a new hospital bed is to be designed, take time to see and experience hospital beds (hopefully merely simulating the experience of being a patient). Fung, Lo, and Rao (2005) describe a learning situation in which students were blindfolded so as to better understand the challenges of designing a product for the visually impaired. They asked the students to sensitively observe key characteristics of one environment and then reintroduce these characteristics into a different context. For example, the mobility of a market may contain elements that may be beneficial to the design of an office space. Similarly, to learn about multicultural perspectives, take the team to a multicultural setting where behaviors or products can be observed, such as an art museum or a place of worship, other than those with which the participants are familiar.
Handing around Partial Solutions Try handing around incomplete concepts to get unexpected ideas. The idea behind this is that even if one team member cannot complete the entire cycle, someone else in the team may be able to. This principle is very powerful in collaborative efforts, such as where teams work on research publications or even where students work on collaborative papers. The work is completed relay style, passing the baton from runner to runner, and in this way optimal effort can be maintained. It should not be confused with the “divide and conquer” method so frequently adopted by students, where an assignment is broken into segments that are then distributed among team members. Handing around partial solutions should have a greater sense of Gestalt, where the whole or sum of the output is greater than its contributing parts or inputs.
Creativity and Group Dynamics in a Problem-based Learning Context
117
IDEO Method Cards IDEO is a California-based international design consultancy whose aim is to help organizations “innovate through design” (http://www.ideo. com). IDEO’s general manager, Thomas Kelley, in his books on innovation (2001, 2005) categorizes innovators as personas, such as the learning, the building, and the organizing persona. In a team context, these different personas bring different skills to the team, which if utilized optimally will promote the innovati