Positive Interactions and Interdependence in Plant Communities
Positive Interactions and Interdependence in Plant Com...
132 downloads
1475 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Positive Interactions and Interdependence in Plant Communities
Positive Interactions and Interdependence in Plant Communities by
Ragan M. Callaway University of Montana, Missoula, MT, U.S.A.
A C.I.P. Catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress.
ISBN 978-1-4020-6223-0 (HB) ISBN 978-1-4020-6224-7 (e-book)
Published by Springer, P.O. Box 17, 3300 AA Dordrecht, The Netherlands. www.springer.com
Cover figures redrawn by Wendy Ridenour
Printed on acid-free paper
All Rights Reserved © 2007 Springer No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work.
This book is dedicated to Bruce Mahall
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I got a lot of help writing this book. Most recently, the editing by Giles Thelen was priceless and he takes full responsibility for all typos. I also have had tremendous help from many others, including the Alpine Pals – Lohen Cavieres, Chris Lortie, Richard Michalet, Paco Pugnaire, Zaza Kikvidze, and Alfonso Valiente-Banuet. The Pals have been relentlessly supportive. An inordinate amount of the ideas, much of the information and a lot of the editing in this book comes from them. Chris’ inputs on meta-analysis are the only reason I could write about it here. I was also facilitated in the whole process by Mark Bertness, the king of positive interactions who years ago invited me to join him as an author on an idea paper, and now I get far too much credit for the idea. It has been Mark that has dragged facilitation into modern community ecology. Fernando Maestre and Katja Tielbörger helped me, and still are, to think though new angles on the stress gradient hypothesis; and I am particularly grateful to Fernando for reworking some of his data and providing me with a figure. I have also received a great deal of assistance from many of my students; Erik Aschehoug, Beth Newingham, Marnie Rout, Kerry Metlen, Kurt Reinhart, Dean Pearson, Wendy Ridenour, Dayna Baumeister, and Leigh Greenwood either read and edited parts of the book or contributed lively discussion. Wendy also drew several of the figures and the cover of this book. Over the years I have benefited tremendously from talking over ideas about facilitation, indirect interactions, soil microbes and succession with Lars Walker, John Klironomos, Joe Connell, Jonathan Levine, Joe McAuliffe and Steve Pennings. These times are truly appreciated. Many, many people have responded positively to my pestering for copies of the figures or the data to remake the figure, and I have tried very hard to appropriately acknowledge all of these folks; their contributions are deeply appreciated. Finally, I owe quite a debt to my PhD advisor, Bruce Mahall, for years of mentorship and friendship.
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter 1 Introduction ........................................................................................1 Chapter 2 Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation ..................................................15 2.1 Water Relations: Hydraulic Lift ................................................18 2.2 Water Relations: Canopy Interception .......................................22 2.3 Shade…......................................................................................23 2.4 Water Relations: Soil Moisture ..................................................45 2.5 Nutrients ....................................................................................56 2.5.1 Climate and Variation in Canopy Effects on Soil Fertility.................................................................59 2.5.2 Experimental Approaches to Canopy Effects on Soil Fertility.................................................................63 2.5.3 Conditionality and Canopy Effects on Soil Fertility ........66 2.5.4 Canopy Facilitation of Soil Fertility in Mesic Habitats ....67 2.5.5 Canopy Facilitation of Available Soil Nutrients...............67 2.5.6 Litter Type, Mixtures, and Canopy Facilitation................69 2.5.7 Experimental Studies of Facilitation by Canopies on Soil .............................................................................71 2.5.8 Nitrogen Fixation and Nutrient Facilitation......................73 2.5.9 Canopy Interception of Nutrients .....................................77 2.5.10 Interactions between Nutrients and Shade......................78 2.5.11 Nutrients and Conspecific Facilitation............................82 2.5.12 Nutrients and the Chemical Signature of Neighbors ......83 2.6 Wind ...........................................................................................87 2.7 Soil Oxygenation........................................................................94 2.8 Substrate.....................................................................................99 2.9 Disturbance ..............................................................................104 2.10 Population Size and Positive Density-Dependence................108 2.11 Seed Shadows.........................................................................110
ix
x
Table of Contents
2.12 Communication ......................................................................113 2.13 Conclusion..............................................................................116 Chapter 3 Indirect Mechanisms for Facilitation..............................................117 3.1 Herbivore-Mediated Facilitation ..............................................118 3.1.1 Shared Defenses..............................................................120 3.1.2 Associational Resistance.................................................129 3.2 Other Herbivore-Mediated Positive Effects .............................137 3.3 Reproductive Feedback, Pollinators, and Population Size.......140 3.4 Dispersers.................................................................................150 3.5 Mycorrhizae .............................................................................154 3.6 Plant-Soil Microbe Feedbacks .................................................160 3.7 Positive Indirect Interactions Among Competing Plants .........164 3.8 Conclusion ...............................................................................176 Chapter 4 Interaction Between Competition and Facilitation .........................179 4.1 Competition, Facilitation and Abiotic Stress ...........................192 4.1.1 Stress Gradients and the Importance of Productivity......195 4.1.2 Stress Gradients and Meta-Analysis ...............................196 4.2 Spatial Scales, Time Scales and the Balance of Facilitation and Competition on Stress Gradients.......................................219 4.3 Facilitation and Stress: Importance Versus Intensity ...............237 4.4 Facilitation and Life History Stage ..........................................240 4.5 Competitive Advantages Provided by Benefactors..................248 4.6 Indirect Effects and the Balance of Competition and Facilitation.........................................................................250 4.7 Pollution and Shifts in Facilitation and Competition ...............253 4.8 Conclusion ...............................................................................253 Chapter 5 Species-Specific Positive Interactions............................................255 5.1 Are Beneficiary Species Non-Randomly Associated with Potential Benefactors?..............................................................256 5.2 What Mechanisms Cause Species-Specific Facilitation?.........267 5.2.1 Species-Specific Direct Effects ......................................267 5.2.1.1 Shade..................................................................267 5.2.1.2 Nutrients.............................................................272 5.2.1.3 Oxygen ...............................................................277 5.2.1.4 Hydraulic Lift.....................................................277 5.2.1.5 Disturbance ........................................................279
Table of Contents
xi
5.2.2 Species-Specific Indirect Effects ....................................280 5.2.2.1 Consumers..........................................................280 5.2.2.2 Pollinators and Dispersers..................................281 5.2.2.3 Soil Microbes .....................................................283 5.2.3 Species-Specificity Due to Similar Positive Effects, but Different Negative Effects .......................................286 5.2.4 Species-Specific Interactions and Life Histories ............288 5.2.5 Communication...............................................................290 5.2.6 Implications for Community Ecology ............................293 Chapter 6 Positive Interactions and Community Organization.......................295 6.1 Positive Interactions and the Expansion of Niche Space .........296 6.2 Positive Interactions and the Role of Diversity in Community Function ...............................................................296 6.3 Positive Interactions and Spatial Scale.....................................305 6.4 Positive Interactions and Stability in Plant Communities ........309 6.5 Facilitation and Productivity ....................................................312 6.6 Positive Interactions and Exotic Invasion ................................315 6.7 Facilitation and Conservation...................................................319 6.8 Facilitation and Evolution in Plant Communities ....................319 6.9 Replacing the Notion of Individualistic Communities with the “Integrated Community” ............................................327 6.10 Conclusions ............................................................................333 References.......................................................................................................335 Index................................................................................................................413
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
Over the last 50 years there has been profound growth in the discipline of ecology. To name just a few advances, ecologists have demonstrated, quantified and explained global changes in temperature, developed elegant mathematical models for competitive interactions, constructed wonderfully complicated food webs, integrated soil biota into aboveground processes, and experimentally explored the intricacy of indirect interactions among many species in communities. Some things, however, have not changed very much. This book was written in part to address a surprisingly static idea; the individualistic conceptual paradigm for plant communities. This is the perspective that plant communities are solely the product of population phenomena, and therefore are assemblages of individual species merely because they share adaptations to particular abiotic conditions (Gleason 1926). This leads to the conclusion that plant communities are simply a handy typological construct. In this book I argue that plant communities are not simply suites of species that happen to be dispersed to and adapted to the same biotic conditions at a given place. I argue that many if not most plant communities have fascinating interdependent characteristics, with some species creating conditions that are crucial for the occurrence and abundance of other species. Most ecologists are not card-carrying members of either individualistic or interdependent guilds, but our perception of plant community organization, and the way we conduct research, is affected by a historical dichotomy with lingering and powerful heuristic impacts; the dichotomy of the individualistic versus organismal nature of plant communities (Clements 1916, Gleason 1926). For example, the legacy of Gleason’s triumph lives on in almost all ecology textbooks, neutral theory (Hubbell 2001, Whitfield 2002) and assembly rules (see Lortie et al. 2004). The fundamental thesis of this book is that the current individualistic model is inadequate in the light of the last 20 years of empirical research on facilitation and indirect interactions. This is because these interactions demonstrate that plant communities frequently contain plant species that would not be present at all, or that would be present at much lower abundances, if it where not for the presence of other plant species (Callaway 1995, 1997). The individualistic view of plant communities has led to very successful research on the importance of the abiotic environment and 1
2
Introduction
competition as factors structuring plant communities. Negative interactions predation, competition for resources and allelopathy – have been central to the study of ecology and evolution. However, it has become clear that organisms can greatly enhance the performance of their neighbors as well as modify the environment in ways that benefit other species. Positive interactions among plants, or facilitation, occur when the presence of one plant enhances the growth, survival, or reproduction of a neighbor. Much like the way the term “competition” is used in the literature, the term “facilitation” is also used in a loose manner, and facilitation may occur in concert with negative, positive, or neutral reciprocal responses from neighbors. Facilitation does not have to be mutualism, an interaction where both participants gain (+,+), but some experiments have shown mutualistic bi-directional facilitation. In some cases facilitation may occur as commensalism (+,0) in which one species benefits from another, but does not affect it in return. In a review of interaction types Schoener (1980) noted that “[documented] examples of commensalism are relatively rare”; and commensalism among plants remains relatively unstudied. However, this rarity may be an artifact of scientific disinterest rather than ecological frequency. Futuyma (1979) suggested that commensalism may be so common “that we often do not notice it”. Commensalism may be common, but the empirical research explored in the following chapters indicates that facilitation probably occurs most often as a positive effect of one species on another with a reciprocal competitive effect from the species receiving the benefits on its benefactor (+,-). It is important to grasp the broad semantic usage of the term facilitation. As one colleague has put it, “I hate the word facilitation because why would a plant make it easier for a competitor to grow next to it”? My colleague’s problem is that of perceived intent, as if plants were trying to befriend their neighbors. The word “facilitation” means nothing like this. The nuances of language are complex and facilitation, like most words, suffers from subtleties in its gestalt. The term facilitation describes a process and not purpose. The fact that seedlings of saguaro cacti occur almost exclusively under shrubs and trees in the Sonoran Desert is almost certainly a by-product of the changes the shrubs and trees create in the environment simply because the shrubs and trees exist, not because they are altruistic. By analogy, in another (+,-) interaction gazelles try hard not to be eaten, but they have a strong positive effect on lions and cheetahs anyway. Like the beneficial effect of gazelles on lions, positive interactions among plants are produced simply by benefactors with characteristic effects on the abiotic and biotic environment that other organisms can utilize. Just like the suite of different mechanisms we group into the term “competition”, it is not necessary to identify the two-way interaction signs or the precise mechanisms behind a particular facilitative interaction to show that facilitation occurs. Furthermore, casual semantics and unknown mechanisms do
Chapter 1
3
not diminish the fundamental conceptual importance of facilitation for community theory. For over 50 years most plant ecologists have accepted the notion that the distribution of plant species, and their organization into groups or communities, is determined individualistically, that is by the adaptation of each species in a “community” to a particular abiotic environment, highly stochastic dispersal events, competition among these similarly adapted species, and the disruption of adaptive and competitive distributions by consumers. Definitions of the “individualistic” paradigm of plant community organization can be controversial (see Nicolson and McIntosh 2002), but have emphasized “the fluctuating and fortuitous immigration of plants and an equally fluctuating and variable environment” (Gleason 1926). Moore (1990, see Nicolson and McIntosh 2002, Chapter 6.9) re-phrased the individualistic concept as “vegetation as an assembly of individual plants belonging to different species distributed according to its own physiological requirements as constrained by competitive interactions.” Even a loose definition of facilitation suggests something fundamentally different than this. If the presence of one species can increase another species’ fitness, or the probability that another species will occur in the same place, plant communities cannot be individualistic. In the last 20 years, hundreds of peer-reviewed papers have been published on the positive effects of plants on each other. These papers implicitly challenge the adequacy of a strict definition of the theory of individualistic plant communities (Gleason 1926), one of the most basic and widely accepted conceptual models in ecology, as a foundation for understanding how groups of plant species are organized. The implications of rethinking plant individualism go beyond academic quarreling; if plant communities are even just a little less individualistic than we have thought, the conservation implications are profound (see Byers et al. 2006, Padilla and Pugnaire 2006). Interdependence in plant communities means that the loss of some plant species will have important negative effects on others. Most general conceptual models of community structure are either explicitly or implicitly based on competition, and this perspective has a historical legacy that is intertwined with individualistic theory. After the trouncing given to holistic community concepts in the 1950’s by John Curtis (1959) and Robert Whittaker (1951, 1953, 1956), espousal of ideas with a hint of Clements’ (1916) organismal mysticism was likely to bring disapproval from one’s peers. As a graduate student in the 80’s I was encouraged by some to avoid the word ‘community’ and instead refer to ‘assemblages’. ‘Assemblage’ is a perfectly good word, and stigma for supporting ultra-holistic Clementsian views was certainly warranted. Furthermore, the proscription on holistic theory fostered the successful emphasis on plant competition over the last few decades, an interaction that has no holistic implications (Connell 1983, Schoener 1983,
4
Introduction
Fowler, 1986, Aarrsen and Epp 1990, Goldberg and Barton 1992). But the reaction against holism created an environment that was not conducive to exploring facilitation. The emphasis on competitive effects and downplay of facilitative effects has also been exaggerated by the study of plant interactions in the greenhouse. While the isolation of some mechanisms is possible only under controlled conditions and must be conducted in pots and in greenhouses, studies of plants interacting in greenhouses almost always show competition. This may be because cramming several plants into a restricted area reduces their niche options, or because conditions in greenhouses tend to be so benign that neighbors can have no real effects on the harsh conditions that exist in the real world. For example, if there are plenty of nutrients then soil amelioration is inconsequential, if there is no wind the effect of neighborhoods as buffers against wind cannot be important, if there are no herbivores there can be no shared resistance, or if ambient humidity is high then the effects of neighbors on moisture around leaves is minimal. Without the normal stress of real life, studies are far less likely to demonstrate facilitation (see Chapter 4). Much like research on Paramecium in aquaria oversimplified theoretical perspectives on interactions among organisms in general; research on plants in greenhouses and pots has overemphasized competition. To my knowledge, the first experiment on facilitation was published in 1914 by G.A. Pearson. Pearson noticed that conifer species appeared to regenerate better after fires in clones of Populus tremuloides (quaking aspen) than in the open and that “herbaceous growth is invariably more luxuriant under the aspen than in the openings.” He then planted seedlings of Pseudotsuga menziesii (Douglas-fir) under aspens and in openings and found greater survival under aspens. Recognizing the possibility that site effects may have differed (aspens may simply have been growing in sites with generally superior abiotic characteristics) he measured wind speeds and evaporation rates and hypothesized that amelioration of these effects and those of shade benefited Douglas-fir regeneration independently of site effects. Until the late 1980’s, data such as Pearson’s (including a large number of other experimental results) were rarely interpreted as conceptually important in any general way - with the exception of a few ecologists focusing on facilitative interactions driven by herbivores. In 1976, Peter Attsat and Dennis O’Dowd of the University of California at Irvine published a review in Science titled “Plant defense guilds” with the leader titled “Many plants are functionally interdependent with respect to their herbivores” (my italics). They went on to argue that the probability that a plant will suffer from herbivory depends on the chemistry, morphology, distribution, and abundance of neighboring plants. Such indirect forms of facilitation, such as described by Atsatt and O’Dowd are treated in detail in Chapter 3 of this book. However, Atsatt and O’Dowd’s strikingly
Chapter 1
5
non-individualistic perspective had no impact on plant community theory. Other early papers, such as published by J.D. Ovington as early as 1955 on the speciesspecific (see Chapter 5) effects of trees on understory composition and productivity also did not stimulate any general interest in the conceptual ramifications of facilitation. To my knowledge, the first broadly conceptual appreciation of positive interactions emerged in two foundational, but under-cited, publications with strong theoretical stances. The first, “Positive Feedback in Natural Systems” by Don DeAngelis et al. in 1986, explored the general role of positive effects in ecosystems, and the second, “Plants Helping Plants” by Hunter and Aarssen (1988), explicitly argued for facilitation as an important and common process in plant communities. A third under-appreciated paper was published in Europe with the title of “Positive Interaktionen Zwischen Pflanzenarten” by Gignon and Ryser (1986). The most powerful effect on the resurgence of interest on facilitation, however, came from a series of experimental studies conducted by Mark Bertness and colleagues at Brown University (Bertness 1988, 1991, Bertness and Shumway, Bertness and Hacker 1994). Since the late 1980’s, a large number of reviews and commentaries have refined the theoretical role of direct and indirect positive interactions in natural plant communities, and organized the body of evidence that has accrued supporting positive interactions as important and general phenomenon affecting plant distributions, productivity, diversity, and reproduction (Wilson and Agnew 1992, Bertness and Callaway 1994, Callaway 1995, Callaway and Walker 1997, Callaway 1997, Callaway 1998a, Dodds 1997, Brooker and Callaghan 1998, Bertness 1998, Stachowicz 2001, Bruno et al. 2003). These reviews have coincided with an explosion in empirical research on facilitation (Figure 1.1).
6
Introduction
1100
# of hits for “facilitation”
1000 900
40
800 700
30
600 500 20
400 300
10
200
2000
1999
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991
0
1990
100 0
# of hits for “competition” and journal totals
50
Figure 1.1. Web of science search hits on the terms: [(‘positive interactions’ or facilitation) and plant], shown as bars, [(‘negative interactions’ or competition) and plant] in filled points and total publications of American Naturalist, Ecology, Journal of Ecology, Oecologia and Oikos, shown as open points, from 1990 to 2000. Reprinted from Dormann and Brooker (2002) with permission from Acta Oecologia.
As noted in many of the recent reviews, experimental studies of facilitation and competition rarely provide unbiased neutral estimates of the relative importance of these interactions in communities. This is an important problem for those attempting to understand the fundamental role of interactions in community organization. In an effort to solve this problem, Walter Dodds (1997) constructed a general neutral model based on a number of field studies in which seven or more species were manipulated. As predicted from earlier simulation models (Dodds and Henebry 1996), he found that positive interactions among species were as likely as negative ones in communities as long as relatively large numbers of species and connections were considered. If fewer species were considered in a single interaction matrix, the probability of finding either positive or negative interactions decreased. Dodd’s models are intriguing, and in several other empirical studies involving large numbers of species, generally designed to examine competition, the results have indicated some positive interactions. However, the proportion of positive interactions demonstrated in empirical studies has usually been lower than that predicted by Dodd (Wilson and Tilman 1995, Twolan-Strutt and Keddy 1996, Thomas et al.
Chapter 1
7
1999). A review by Goldberg and Barton (1992) indicated that neighbors promoted the survival or growth of individuals in approximately 10% of experiments. Peter Ryser (1993) found that two of six species studied in a Swiss grassland required shelter by neighboring plants. In a field comparison of spatial patterns and growth correlations Freeman and Emlen (1995) found more competitive than facilitative effects, but for some traits there were large numbers of apparent positive effects of species on each other. Hoffman (1996) found that eight of 12 tree and shrub species in cerrado savanna vegetation of Brazil responded favorably to canopy cover, whereas only one species experienced lower establishment under canopies. Out of a total of 35 species in a Chilean desert community, Gutiérrez et al. (1993) found that five appeared to be facilitated by shrub canopies and five appeared to be inhibited. However, it is unclear how species were chosen for analysis or experimentation in many of these experiments. However, there are many recent studies in which high proportions of species in communities participate in positive interactions (e.g. Choler et al. 2001, Callaway et al. 2002). Furthermore, the distributional positions of particular experimental species on environmental gradients appear to be crucial for predicting the proportions of species involved in facilitation (Choler et al. 2001). The bottom line that we can gain from studies that incorporate multiple species appears to be that competitive interactions are usually more common than facilitative interactions, but facilitative interactions are not rare, and can be common even in communities composed of species with similar morphologies. Studies of spatial association are not as powerful as experimental evidence, but they also provide important insight into the relative importance of positive interactions versus negative interactions in plant communities. In some cases the consistency of spatial relationships among species can be impressive. Consider the relationship between Ziziphus lotus and Asparagus albus illustrated by Reyes Tirado and Francisco Pugnaire (2003) in oceanic dunes in southern Spain (Figure 1.2). Not only was the latter species virtually always found inside Ziziphus patches, transplanted Asparagus seedlings had higher survival rates in patches than in the open and produced more flowers, fruits, and showed a higher mass of seeds in patches than when isolated. This facilitative effect seemed to be due to nutrient enrichment in the patches.
8
Introduction Ziziphus lotus
Asparagus albus
South-North distance (m)
150
100
50
0 0
50
100
150
East-West distance (m)
Figure 1.2. Distribution map of Ziziphus lotus and Asparagus albus in a sand dune-strip on the Almeria coast of Spain. Shrub symbols are represented in three size classes (<1 m, 1–4 m, and >4 m) for Z. lotus and two (<0.2 m and >0.2 m) for A. albus. Clear triangles represent Asparagus plants with other shrub species. Reprinted from Tirado and Pugnaire (2003) with permission from Oecologia.
In a correlative study of desert perennials in Namaqualand, South Africa, Eccles et al. (1999) argued that spatial patterns for 23% of species pairs in shrubby ‘short strandveld’ suggested positive interactions, whereas only 6% appeared to be driven by competition. In ‘medium strandveld’ positive interactions appeared to determine spatial associations for 38% of species pairs and negative interactions only 13%. Based on spatial patterns, similar proportions of species also appear to be facilitated or nursed in Sonoran desert systems (McAuliffe 1988). These proportions are only based on correlations, but experiments conducted in alpine plant communities to examine the connection between spatial pattern and the interactions among species found that negative correlative spatial associations between species rarely pointed to competitive interactions (as determined though removal experiments) but positive spatial patterns often signaled facilitation (Choler 2001). Many of the facilitative mechanisms discussed in Chapters 2 and 3 would not be manifest as discrete spatial associations. Therefore empirical comparisons and a clear understanding of mechanism indicate that spatial patterns may be conservative in their estimation of the relative importance of facilitation. Other evidence for the relative importance of facilitative interactions comes from comparisons of the performance of plants in mixtures to performance in monocultures. Darwin (1858) mused about the potential for species mixtures to be more productive than monocultures, and since then many
Chapter 1
9
studies have been conducted to compare the biomass productivity of mixtures of different field crops to the productivity of the same species grown at the same densities alone (see Chapter 6.2). Legume-grass mixtures commonly “overyield’ (produce more than either species grown alone) due to the nitrogen-fixing properties of legumes, but studies of mixtures of nonleguminous species are much less conclusive. In 1974, Trenbath summarized studies on the productivity of 344 different mixtures and found that the means of 60.2% of the mixtures were above the mean yields of the monocultures, a proportion that was highly significantly different (P<0.001). Eighty three of the mixtures were more productive than the most productive monoculture, whereas only 45 mixtures yielded less than the least productive monoculture. Twenty years after Trenbath’s analysis, Peter Joliffe re-examined comparative studies on the total productivity of species mixtures to monocultures and arrived at similar conclusions (Jolliffe 1997). In 38 of 54 published experiments with two-species mixtures the mixtures were significantly more productive, and significantly lower in 8 studies. On average, mixtures were 12 to 13% more productive than pure stands, depending on the criteria used for inclusion of studies in the analysis. Overyielding is not necessarily produced by facilitation, and can be a by-product of niche partitioning, different temporal patterns of growth and development, and nutritional complementation. However, the more frequent occurrence of overyielding than underyielding in natural and man-made communities suggests profitable mechanistic research directions in community theory. The relationship of species mixtures to productivity is highly relevant to the current interest in species diversity and ecosystem function (Tilman et al. 1996, Hector et al. 2002, see Chapter 6.2). For example, Symstad et al. (1998) conducted pot experiments in which 4, 8, or 12 species from 4 different functional groups were combined into assemblages with either all species present or assemblages with random deletions of one species. The effect of losing a single species from the assemblage generally reduced the total biomass of the community, but the effects were highly species-specific. Decreasing diversity by one species had either negative, positive, or neutral effects depending on the species – the “idiosyncratic” hypothesis proposed by Naeem et al. (1994). However, Symstad et al.’s results were not completely idiosyncratic as only nitrogen-fixing legumes elicited positive effects on community biomass. The potential importance of facilitation in the diversity-ecosystem function relationship was more clearly demonstrated in a study by Mulder et al. (2001) of bryophyte communities exposed to short-term drought. They found that productivity increased significantly with the species richness of the community. Mulder and her colleagues argued that an increase in positive interactions in drought conditions, and not in more mesic conditions, among plants drove the relationship between diversity and productivity. A similar argument was made by Caldeira et al. (2001) in a semi-arid climate in Spain.
10
Introduction
To my knowledge there have been no other studies explicitly investigating the potential for facilitation to account for the effects of species diversity on community function, but understanding positive interactions has great potential to shed light on the biodiversity-community function debate. Also, whether idiosyncratic or not, the positive effects of many species on both ecosystem and community attributes suggest a level of interdependence in plant communities that challenges the individualistic status quo. Understanding the degree to which plant communities are individualistic or interdependent is not just an academic problem. These concepts have strong implications for conservation theory and application. For example, the view that plant species are fully individualistic and “interchangeable” in communities has been used to advocate active human involvement in “shaping and synthesizing new ecosystems, even in the ‘natural’ environment.” (emphasis added, Johnson and Mayeux 1992). If maintaining functional plant communities is simply a matter of finding a suite of species that can form a stable individualistic competitive hierarchy, then Johnson and Mayeux’ ideas may not be so farfetched. However, if interactions among plants are more complex and interdependent, as suggested by research on facilitation and the indirect effects of herbivores and mycorrhizae (Callaway et al. 1999, Marler et al. 1999), networks of direct and indirect interactions within the plant community (Miller 1994, Pennings and Callaway 1996, Takahashi 1997; Callaway and Pennings 1998, Levine 1999), and novel interactions among exotic invasive plants (Callaway and Aschehoug 2000, Callaway and Ridenour 2004) such shaping and synthesizing will lead to unforeseen and disastrous results. Interestingly, conservationists often assume a high degree of interdependence in communities when they argue for the preservation of natural systems and biological diversity (Freedman 1989 Erlich 1990, Erlich and Wilson 1991, Miller 1993, Noss 1994). The Ecological Society of America, in an assessment of the use of science in achieving the goals of the Endangered Species Act (Carroll et al. 1996) recommended consideration of the following priorities: “does the species play an especially important role in the ecosystem in which it lives? Do other species depend on it for their survival? Will its loss substantially alter the functioning of the ecosystem?” If applied to plants, these priorities assume interdependence in communities. Mechanistically, negative and positive interactions can be quite different. Negative direct interactions among plants appear to depend mainly on the effects of plants on common limited resources and the responses of plants to these same resources (Goldberg 1990, Miller and Travis 1996) and the biochemical effects of neighbors on each other (Williams 1990, Mahall and Callaway 1992, Inderjit and Del Moral 1997, Wardle et al. 1998, Bais et al. 2003, Vivanco 2004). Direct positive interactions incorporate a wider
Chapter 1
11
range of different mechanisms than direct negative interactions (see Chapter 2), but like competition facilitation may occur through resource effects, one species increasing nutrient, water, or light availability to another, or through chemical effects. Facilitation may be also driven by non-resource processes. Most commonly, species that are tolerant to non-resource stress such as cold, heat, wind, salinity, and disturbance buffer these factors on other species. Other non-resource facilitative processes are indirect. In an intraspecific example, Fischer and Matthies (1998) observed that individual Gentianella germanica plants, a rare species restricted to central Europe, produced more seeds per plant when they occurred in large populations than in small populations (40 to 5000 flowering individuals), and that population growth rates of large populations were higher than those of small populations. They also conducted a common garden experiment in which seeds from plants from the different populations were germinated in a greenhouse and transplanted into a common garden. They found that seed number and survival rates were significantly correlated with the size of the source population. Other experiments demonstrated that seed bank size and seed production were important to maintaining population size for G. germanica (Fischer and Matthies 1998). At the scale of individuals it is no surprise that an outcrossing plant needs another of its own kind nearby, but Fischer and Matthies’ results suggest that an interesting positive density-dependent mechanism operates at larger scales. In the field, pollinator limitation appears to decrease individual fitness, and common garden experiments indicate that individuals in larger populations benefit from amelioration of pollinator limitation and maintain higher fitness levels. Others have shown positive correlations between population size and plant fecundity and these correlations have been attributed to pollen limitation (Jennerston 1988, Petanidou et al. 1993, Lamont et al. 1993, Widen 1993) and genetic deterioration (Menges, 1991, Heschel and Paige 1995, Menges and Dolan 1998). Facilitation affects plant community structure and diversity in very different ways than competition. Inherently, competitive interactions limit coexistence among species, and therefore competition-based theory focuses on how species avoid competitive exclusion (Lotka 1932, Gause 1934, Hardin 1960, Hutchinson 1961). Coexistence in a world dominated by competition has been attributed to 1) “niche partitioning” (Parrish and Bazzaz 1976, Cody 1986), 2) variation in the physical environment and subsequent subtle differences in competitive advantages, 3) disturbance that continuously provides patches of competition-free microhabitat and alters competitive hierarchies (McNaughton 1985), 4) heterogeneity in the ratios of limiting resources that alter competitive hierarchies (Tilman 1976, 1985, 1988), 5) the development of local and species-specific resource depletion zones that, under certain conditions, do not strongly affect the resources available to neighbors
12
Introduction
(Huston and DeAngelis 1994, Grace 1995), and 6) spatial structures that suggest niche partitioning (Van der Maarel et al. 1995). In contrast to the suite of theories that attempt to explain species coexistence despite competition for the few resources that are shared by all plants, positive interactions suggest that some interactions among plants expand niches (Chapter 6.1) and directly promote coexistence and community diversity. Positive interactions do not increase community diversity in a haphazard manner. The ways in which plants modify their environments create conditions in which the beneficiaries are likely to be functionally different than their benefactors. Therefore we have legumes facilitating non-nitrogen-fixing grasses, trees facilitating shade tolerant grasses, and woody perennial shrubs and trees facilitating stem-succulent columnar cacti. This fundamentally inherent process of plant-driven environmental modification creates a situation in which something functionally different than the benefactor can thrive is a very important aspect of positive interactions in general. An excellent example of this process occurs in savannas of southern Africa. Acacia nilotica, a tree with very small drought-deciduous leaves, is the predominant species colonizing open grassland (Smith and Goodman 1987). Acacia cannot recruit under conspecifics, but many other broad-leaved evergreen shrubs and trees can. This broad-leaved evergreen functional group apparently would not occur in this environment without the positive effect of Acacias. Acacias are maintained as a dominant species in the system by large-scale disturbance by elephants. Where elephants have been eliminated many areas once dominated by Acacia are now dominated by thickets of the evergreen shrub Euclea divinorum. Positive interactions do not only increase species diversity, they also increase functional diversity. Environmental modification by plants is generally assumed to facilitate the growth or reproduction of other species, or even the replacement of themselves by other species. However, in a review of positive-feedback switches in plant communities, Wilson and Agnew (1992) make a convincing case for processes in which plants, or communities of plants, can also modify their environment in ways that favor themselves. They argue that positive-feedback switches may produce stable mosaics in originally uniform habitat, sharp boundaries between plant communities on environmental gradients, and either accelerate or retard succession. These positive-feedback switches may be particularly important in exotic invasions. In this book, I focus on several fundamental questions about positive interactions in plant communities: Are positive interactions widespread among different biomes and climates? What kinds of mechanisms drive direct and indirect positive interactions? How do positive and competitive interactions function together? Are positive interactions species-specific? How do positive interactions affect community dynamics? What do positive interactions mean for
Chapter 1
13
community theory? By organizing the literature and concepts around these questions I hope to place positive interactions on solid theoretical footing in plant ecology and support a new conceptual paradigm for the nature of plant communities.
CHAPTER 2 DIRECT MECHANISMS FOR FACILITATION
This chapter and the next are reviews of the empirical research that provides evidence for positive interactions among plants. These chapters are organized by mechanism and I emphasize both experimental and correlative studies. The latter approach is crucial for connecting the processes demonstrated in fine-scale experiments to community-scale organization (see Kikvidze et al. 2005), but correlative studies have a hard time distinguishing between biological effects, shared physical microhabitat requirements, or the tendency of large perennials to act as foci for seed deposition. Positive spatial correlations among plant species that have been explored experimentally are generally supported in terms of facilitation, but not always (Moen 1993, Meiners and Gorchov 1998; Choler et al. 2001). Field experiments are the strongest evidence for the existence and importance of interspecific facilitation in plant communities and the mechanisms behind the phenomenon. The mistaken notion that positive interactions are not well demonstrated with field experiments may be largely responsible for perceptions of facilitation as an interesting, but not fundamental organizing process in plant communities. Positive interactions can be direct, simply the effect of one species on another, or positive interactions can be indirect, requiring an intermediate species in order to occur (Strauss 1991, Wooton 1994, Callaway and Pennings 2000). Indirect facilitation, mediated by parasitic plants, fungi, animals, microbes, and other plants within the same trophic level is discussed in Chapter 3. Although direct and indirect mechanisms can be difficult to separate operationally, the purpose of this chapter is to focus on the direct mechanisms that drive positive interactions. In following chapters I address how these mechanisms may interact with each other, establish community structure, and affect community productivity, diversity, and composition. The most common experiment performed to investigate the positive effects of plants on each other is no different that those typically done to test for competition, with the exception that facilitation has been rarely studied in the greenhouse or experimental gardens. Typically, one or more species is removed from a pair or group of species and growth, survival, reproduction, or some metric is acquired for the remaining target plant. Other approaches include manipulating the canopies or root systems of suspected benefactors separately, but without removing the entire plant. Although removal 15
16
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
experiments may not confirm the specific active mechanism (e.g. shade vs. canopy throughfall) they provide a good way to distinguish between biotic and microsite effects – a distinction that is difficult, if not impossible to accomplish without experiments. But experimental approaches are not without problems. If removal is not thorough, the experiment may create conditions in which the remaining “beneficiary” species is subjected to greater stress than would be experienced in habitats without the benefactor at all. For example, if removal eliminates positive effects such as shade, but does not substantially reduce root competition (e.g. if regrowth is abundant) the remaining target plant may do much worse than if were just exposed to the full impact of the abiotic environment alone. Therefore, removal would result in overly poor performance of target plants and the experiment would overestimate the importance of facilitation. Spatial associations and experiments dovetail when trying to understand immediate effects versus net effects of interactions over the lifespans of the interacting species. For example, removal and other manipulative experiments may provide insight into processes that may last several years, but without evidence from the longterm spatial patterns that integrate interactions over long time periods, the fundamental ecological importance of the interactions is hard to determine. An excellent example of the benefit of examining the relationships among patterns and processes plant communities was provided by Zaal Kikvidze and colleagues who found correlative links among temperature, precipitation, productivity, experimentally documented plant interactions, spatial pattern, and community richness in alpine communities around the world (Kikvidze et al. 2005). The suggested that the relationship between positive interspecific spatial patterns and increased community richness was due to niche construction by facilitators, which allows for the coexistence of more species than would be possible if niches were not built by some of the species in the community. Long-term effects of facilitative mechanisms that do not disappear with the removal of putative benefactors such as higher soil nutrients or decreased soil density also complicate interpretation of removal experiments. Facilitation is indicated if plants perform significantly worse after the removal of a neighbor. However, if residual facilitative effects make plants perform significantly better after the removal of a neighbor, or if they drive a neutral response, interpretations may be inaccurate. Interpreting improved performance after neighbor removal as competition may be even more problematic. The enhanced performance of the target plant may have more to do with the high-quality conditions left behind by the removed plant than by the elimination of its competitive effects. Considering the strong effects that plants have on the soils they grow in, overestimating the importance of competition is probably common. For example, if soil modification by species A (e.g. increased soil nutrients) produces a strong
Chapter 2
17
positive effect on species B, and competition for water produces a weak competitive effect of A on B, removal of A may result in higher performance by species B due to the residual high nutrient conditions, and be misinterpreted as strong competition. Interpretive problems are magnified by the fact that plants often interact with their neighbors via a number of different, but simultaneous, positive and negative mechanisms (Bertness and Callaway 1994, Callaway and Walker 1997, Chapter 4). Jack Greenlee and I discovered how important spatial associations can be to corroborate experiments in a study of Lesquerella carinata, a rare mustard in Montana (Greenlee and Callaway 1996). Spatially, Lesquerella was highly associated with bunchgrass tussocks, but experiments conducted in a wet year found no evidence for facilitation by bunchgrasses. Instead we found strong evidence for competition. The spatial associations convinced us to conduct another experiment the following year, which turned out to be exceptionally dry. In this year shade from the bunchgrasses had substantial facilitative effects on Lesquerella. The experimental results suggested that immediate effects may be either positive or negative, but the spatial results suggested that net effects are positive. Understanding these important processes would not have been possible without integrated spatial correlations and experiments. Greenlee’s and my results could not have been demonstrated in the greenhouse, and this is probably true for most studies that have demonstrated facilitation. If two plants are grown together in a pot with adequate water, nutrients, and light, they are quite likely to compete with each other. This is because most facilitative effects occur because a benefactor ameliorates some harsh aspect of the environment, often while simultaneously competing with their beneficiary (Chapter 4). If there is nothing to ameliorate, all that is left is competition. There are facilitative mechanisms that may become apparent only in greenhouse studies, some microbially mediated effects for example, but for the most part greenhouses are bad places to study facilitation. Other experimental approaches include separation of abiotic microsite effects and biotic facilitation with combinations of removal experiments, controls for treatment effects, and nurse plant “mimic” experiments. The latter are experimental manipulations in which nurse plant characteristics are simulated by constructing structural mimics that provide comparable levels of shade or protection from herbivores, but not long-term substrate effects. Comparison of the performance of beneficiary plants with and without benefactor mimics can provide good evidence for the importance of nurse plants and the mechanisms by which they may aid their neighbors. The understanding gained by documenting the mechanisms that drive facilitation, or any biological interaction for that matter, is not trivial. If mechanisms for facilitation are few and biologically simple, then facilitation is
18
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
less likely to be important in a wide variety of ecosystems and climatic conditions and inanimate objects such as rocks, stumps, or shade cloth may elicit the same effects as living plants (see Chapter 5). As we shall see, however, facilitative mechanisms are complex. Furthermore, if the specific facilitative mechanisms described below change substantially in intensity and importance along environmental gradients (see Chapter 4), the potential for highly variable hierarchies of advantages and disadvantages for different species in a community will be even greater. Species diversity and coexistence in plant communities may depend on such variation in competitive and facilitative hierarchies.
2.1. WATER RELATIONS: HYDRAULIC LIFT One of the first published reports of positive spatial associations among plant species was written by Phillips (1909), who found that seedlings of Pinus monophylla (pinyon pine) were found often under Artemisia tridentata (Great Basin sagebrush) and rarely in the open. This “nurse plant” spatial pattern was later described by others for P. monophylla and the closely related species P. edulis (Drivas and Everett 1988, Everett et al. 1986, Welden et al. 1990, Callaway et al. 1996, Sthultz et al. 2006). In woodlands of New Mexico Martens et al. (1997) found that young Pinus edulis and young Juniperus monosperma were highly associated with adults of different shrub species. Almost 90 years after Phillips’ observations I conducted removal and transplant experiments with colleagues at the University of Illinois and University of Nevada, Reno (Callaway et al. 1996) to study the nature of the relationship between these species. Confirming the claims of others, we found that A. tridentata shrubs significantly improved the survival rates of P. monophylla seedlings in comparison to open inter-shrub spaces and plots where A. tridentata had been removed. Shrubs provided indirect facilitation by reducing herbivory, but also directly reduced mortality due to ameliorating desiccation and heat stress. Shrubs may simply shade P. monophylla seedlings during the hottest and driest times of the year, but other, more complex facilitative mechanisms appear to be involved. Not long after Phillips’ observations, Magistad and Breazeale (1929) hypothesized that deep-rooted plant species might extract water from far below the surface and lose a portion of this water into dry soils at the surface. Five
Chapter 2
19
Figure 2.1. Deuterium-labeling experiment designed to show if water absorbed by the deep roots of Artemisia tridentata (left) would appear in the stem water of neighboring Agropyron desertorum grasses. Intact deep roots of A. tridentata were immersed in vials of D2O, and DHO content of stem water in the grasses was measured. The dashed line shows the presumed pathway of deuterium. Reprinted from Caldwell et al. (1990) with permission from the Israel Journal of Botany.
decades later Harold Mooney observed that surface soils under Prosopis tamarugo in the Atacama Desert were relatively moist, despite the almost total lack of precipitation, and hypothesized that the moisture might come from the roots of the Prosopis itself (Mooney et al. 1980). Since then, the redistribution of soil water through root systems has been shown for a large number of species in a wide variety of conditions (Caldwell et al. 1998) including relatively shallow rooted species (Wan et al. 1993). The phenomenon, christened “hydraulic lift” was first clearly documented for Artemisia tridentata when Jim Richards and Martin Caldwell recorded substantial diurnal cycles in shallow soils under Artemisia tridentata and hypothesized that the shrub was transporting water from deep, moist soils to dry surface soils during the night (Richards and Caldwell 1987; also see Chapter 5.2). In a later experiment, light provided throughout the
20
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
night significantly reduced the diurnal cycles, presumably because open stomata maintained a steep gradient of water potential to the atmosphere (Williams et al. 1993). Hydraulic lift is a passive process, in which nocturnal stomatal closure establishes a water potential gradient running from high-water potential deep soils, along the gradually decreasing gradient within the plant, and then to the low water potential endpoint in the dry surface soils. When stomata open, the low water potential endpoint is re-established in the atmosphere. By caching water in shallow soils during the night Artemisia plants can increase their total daily transpiration rates. Facilitation occurs when cached water at the surface becomes available to other species. Cached water may play a role in the nursing of Pinus monophylla, but movement of water through Artemisia via hydraulic lift to P. monophylla has not been demonstrated. However, Caldwell and Richards (1989) and Caldwell (1990) demonstrated that deuterated water absorbed by the deep roots of Artemisia appeared 11 hours after application in stems of neighboring Agropyron desertorum tussocks (Figure 2.1). However, the amount of water transferred from Artemisia to Agropyron was small, suggesting that any positive effects caused by this facilitative mechanism were probably not strong. Thus this form of facilitation may not be important relative to the intense competition that has been shown to occur between these species (Caldwell 1990). In another effort to understand hydraulic lift as a facilitative mechanism, Todd Dawson (1993, also see Brooks et al. 2002, Chapter 5) used stable isotopes to investigate the magnitude of the water lifted by Acer saccharum (sugar maple) in northeastern forests of the United States and the effects of the hydraulically lifted water on understory plants. He quantified hydraulically lifted water in the xylem of all understory plant species examined, and found that the proportional use of hydraulically lifted water by understory species ranged from 3 to 60%. Within a species, individual plants that that used large proportions of hydraulically lifted water had more favorable water potentials, conductances and growth than those that did not. For 12 understory species that varied in morphology from herbs to woody perennials, being close to hydraulically-lifting A. saccharum (0.5 m versus 5.0 m) resulted in 2-4 times higher rates of conductance and much higher water potentials. Comparison of the amount of hydraulically lifted water in understory plant xylem and the amount calculated for soil water budgets suggest that understory plants may preferentially take up lifted water due to its higher matric potential, or that the roots of understory plants are spatially associated with the roots of A. saccharum (Emerman and Dawson 1996). The positive effects of A. saccharum on the species that grow underneath them also depended on the size of the A. saccharum. Only trees larger than 10-cm dbh used large amounts of ground water, a prerequisite for hydraulic lift (Dawson 1996). Trees that were smaller than 10-cm in diameter
Chapter 2
21
used surface soil water exclusively and did not lift. Mature A. saccharum may hydraulically lift 100 L (25% of their entire daily water budget) (Emerman and Dawson 1996), giving them the potential to have large-scale effects on ecosystem processes (Dawson 1996) and function as “ecosystem engineers” (Jones et al. 1994, 1997). This potential for large-scale ecosystem engineering through hydraulic lift has recently been emphasized in a study of evergreen tropical trees in the Amazon rainforest. In a fascinating scaling up of hydraulic lifting by individual tropical trees (see Oliviera et al. 2005), Lee et al. (2005) used an atmospheric general circulation model to estimate that large numbers of hydraulically lifting trees could have strong effects on climate in the Amazon region. A widely described positive effect of Quercus douglasii canopies on understory grass productivity has been attributed primarily to the way that canopy throughfall and litterfall increase soil nutrients near the trees (Holland and Morton 1980, Holland 1980, Callaway et al. 1991, see Chapter 4). However, Ishikawa and Bledsoe (2000) observed gradual increases in soil water potential at night and rapid decreases during the day in soils under Q. douglasii trees. These diurnal fluctuations in water potential are indicative of hydraulic lift. Hydraulic lift is discernable only in relatively dry soils; when soils are wet their high water potential, relative to that in shallow tree roots, does not allow water to passively move into the soil. For example, Dawson’s findings were reported from an unusually dry year, and Ishikawa and Bledsoe found that diurnal hydraulic lift patterns developed a month earlier in a dry year than in a wet year. But it is unlikely that hydraulic lift plays a role in the general facilitative effect of Q. douglasii trees because diurnal patterns in soil moisture do not develop until later in the summer, and by this time the annual grasses that are facilitated by trees are dead. Alternatively, water released by Q. douglasii roots could delay the rate of soil water depletion and increase the growing season for the annual understory species or affect other soil processes that ultimately benefit understory grasses. Hydraulic lift has now been reported in the literature for at least 27 species (unofficially over 59, personal communication, T. Dawson) and the process occurs in a diverse number of biomes including shrub steppe, savannas, temperate forests, and tropical forests (Caldwell et al. 1998). The ecosystem effects of hydraulic lift may be large (Horton and Hart 1998, Lee et al. 2005), and clearly hydraulic lift may have broad importance as a facilitative mechanism. Although the facilitative effects of hydraulic lift have been emphasized primarily in the context of perennial trees and shrubs benefiting herbaceous understory beneficiaries, this mechanism may also be important for the survival and growth of seedlings of perennials growing under nurse plants, such as the pinyon pine seedlings that are found so often under the canopies of Artemisia.
22
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
A form of hydraulic lift, or “water transfer”, has also been described between Zea mays (corn) and Medicago sativa (alfalfa). Corak et al. (1987) grew these species in an experimental apparatus designed to examine the transfer of water from Medicago to Zea. A single Medicago plant was grown so that its roots connected with a Zea plant through two tubes separated by a 5 cm air gap, bridged only by the Medicago roots. The Zea roots were unable to cross the air gap between the tubes. When both the top tube and the bottom tubes were watered frequently, water potentials of Zea remained ≈-0.20 MPa for the duration of the 50 day experiment. When only the bottom tube was watered, the water potentials of Zea in the top tube decreased to ≈-4.0 MPa after 50 days. However, when Medicago was present, and its roots bridged the gap between the tubes, water potentials of Zea were above -2.0 MPa. Furthermore, high levels of labeled tritium supplied only to Medicago roots were detected in Zea tissue. These results indicate that water transferred from moist soil to dry soil by Medicago facilitated the survival of Zea in otherwise lethal drought conditions. Although hydraulic lift can have strong facilitative effects in many different systems, it should be noted that the very trees that lift can also have strong competitive effects on understory species for water, to the point that the competition overwhelms facilitation (Ludwig et al 2004, see Chapter 4).
2.2. WATER RELATIONS: CANOPY INTERCEPTION Many studies have shown that water input or soil moisture is higher around tree canopies or in forest stands where moisture from the air is intercepted and condensed (Vogelmann et al. 1968; Azevedo and Morgan 1974; Ingwersen 1985; Schemenauer et al. 1988; Huntley et al. 1997, Rigg et al. 2002). Furthermore, when canopy trees are removed the water input from fog drip and stream flow declines (Ingwersen 1985). This circumstantial evidence suggests that canopies can intercept and condense water from air may facilitate neighbors and create more mesic habitats. In an elegant study of Sequoia sempervirens (coastal redwood), perhaps the world’s greatest fog collector, Todd Dawson combined extensive sampling of fog and rainwater input with isotope analyses to quantify the amount of water collected by Sequoia trees and the acquiring of Sequoia-collected fog water by its smaller neighbors. Dawson found that forested sites received more total water inputs than nonforested sites and on average 35% of the total forest water inputs was due to fog drip from the Sequoia trees. In nonforested sites fog accounted for only 17% of total input. Isotopic analyses indicated that the average Sequoia obtained 19% of its annual water input from fog,
Chapter 2
23
with smaller trees receiving almost 40% of their annual budget from fog. Understory plants benefited from the water intercepted by Sequoia trees, with shallow rooted herbs acquiring up to 100% of their moisture from fog inputs in dry years. While smaller species appear to collect a little fog themselves, the presence of Sequoia, a far better fog collector, provided understory species with much greater water inputs. Dawson noted that “loss of the canopy tree S. sempervirens is not only a loss of biomass and the nutrients contained within it, but will lead to a loss of the diverse canopy ‘community’ … as well as the organic-rich forest soils to post-disturbance erosion. Tree loss will also convert a once moist, cool, closed ecosystem into a more drought prone, warmer, open ecosystem. Plants and animals which depend upon the moisture input from fog drip or other microclimatic benefits caused by the presence of fog will experience more frequent water stress when S. sempervirens is removed. In addition, both S. sempervirens seedlings and understory plant species which require moist and cool conditions to regenerate could suffer or disappear if inputs of fog decline.” In New Caledonia, Araucaria laubenfelsii, a species that is morphologically similar to S. sempervirens, collects large amounts of water from fog, even on days with no recorded rainfall, and deposits this water beneath the tree canopy (Rigg et al. 2002). They found that A. laubenfelsii facilitated succession to rainforest by reducing stress experienced by late seral species and acting as “nuclei for forest species invasion of the maquis”. Once mature A. laubenfelsii establish nuclei, rain forest develops by expansion from these patches and their coalescence.
2.3. SHADE The benefits of shade include maintenance of plant tissues below lethal or near-lethal temperatures, decreasing respiration costs, lowering transpirational demands by decreasing the vapor pressure difference between leaves and air, reduction of ultraviolet irradiation, and increased soil moisture due to lower evaporative demand. Most plants suffer substantial physiological damage at temperatures between 50 and 60oC because at these temperatures enzymes, cell membranes and thylakoid membranes begin to degrade (Larcher 1995). However, mitochondrial respiration rates increase exponentially with temperature, so temperatures much lower than 50oC can have negative effects on the carbon balance of plants. Shade can also reduce the vapor pressure difference between plant tissues and the air surrounding them by increasing ambient humidity (Geiger, 1965, Keeley and Johnson 1977, Larcher 1983), and by decreasing the temperature difference between plant tissues and the air.
24
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Furthermore, for plants that have limited access to water and cannot conduct gasexchange during hot periods, such as succulents or seedlings without fully developed root systems, stomatal closure and limited CO2 uptake may allow light to damage photosystems. Also, for many species of woody plants, and in particular conifers, soil temperatures greater than 45oC can cause seedling mortality by destroying the cambial tissue and phloem (Hartley 1918, Toumey and Neethling 1924, Levitt 1972). In hot climates, subcanopy temperatures are not only cooler than ambient temperatures, but they are also more stable. For example, soil temperatures at 5 cm and 10 cm under an Acacia tortilis tree in the winter ranged from 23-28oC and 23-26oC, respectively. At the same time temperatures at these depths in the open ranged from 25-36oC and 24-34oC. It is important to note; however, that canopy-induced decreases in temperature or other microclimatic conditions do not always appear to drive facilitative effects even though they may be correlated with positive associations among species (Callaway et al. 1991, Gass and Barnes 1998). Many species reach their maximum photosynthetic rates (light saturation) at photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) levels far below the general natural maximum (≈2000 μmol m-2 s-1). These species may benefit from the effects of shade from taller neighbors on leaf temperature and transpirational loss without any cost of decreased carbon gain. For example, Arnica cordifolia is a perennial herb that is commonly found in the understory of conifer forests in the northern Rocky Mountains. At three sites near Missoula, Montana I found the average percent cover of Arnica in stands dominated by Pseudotsuga menzeisii and Pinus ponderosa was 9.2 ± 3.0 versus 0.2 ± 0.7 in nearby open meadow. This pattern may be explained simply by the direct positive effects of moderate shade cast by the conifer canopies on the carbon/water balance of Arnica. Interestingly, Donald Young and Bill Smith found that a 30% decrease in light on the forest floor during cloudy days in the Medicine Bow Mountains of Wyoming resulted in a 37% increase in carbon gain for Arnica and an 84% reduction in transpiration (Young 1983). They found that the photosynthetic rates of Arnica remained near saturation even on very cloudy days. In other words Arnica gained from the lower transpiration rates associated with decreased light levels without an accompanying cost of lower photosynthesis. The potential positive effects of Artemisia on Pinus monophylla seedlings via hydraulic lift described above may be negligible compared to the effect of shade from Artemisia canopies. For example, in field experiments, artificial shrub mimics had strong positive effects on P. monophylla (Callaway et al. 1996). Since shrub mimics do not have roots facilitation via hydraulic lift is not possible. Shade may interact with water availability as a positive effect, but shade from overstory species can also have facilitative effects that are completely independent of effects on water
Chapter 2
25
relations. However, the effects of shade on understory plants are complex, and despite the win-win situation described above for Arnica the positive effects of shade on water relations and temperature may be counteracted by the negative effects of shade on light availability for many understory species. Interactions between the effects of shade on light as a resource, and temperature and transpiration rates as a stress, are unavoidable and must taken into account in any study of shade as a competitive or facilitative mechanism. Such interactions are likely to create the “seed-seedling” conflicts described in Chapter 4 (see Schupp 1995). Milena Holmgren and colleagues (1997) took these potential tradeoffs into account by modeling the relative importance of shade from a nurse plant as a facilitative effect or a competitive effect depending on the synergy between light and moisture in a plant’s environment. Assuming that plant growth is a relatively simple product of light and moisture, and that soil moisture is affected by canopies to a greater degree in xeric environments than in mesic environments, they argued that plant growth will increase as light increases. However, in xeric environments increasing light is correlated with rapidly decreasing soil moisture and plant growth decreases at higher light intensities. This sets the stage for shade-derived facilitation in water-limited environments, and decreased likelihood for such facilitation in mesic environments (Figure 2.2, also see Chapter 4). For example, in mesic successions after glacial retreat in southeastern Alaska, Alnus sinuata facilitates the later successional species, Picea sitchensis, via soil amelioration, but its shade effects are inhibitory (Chapin et al. 1994). In mesic forests in New Zealand, Bellingham et al. (2001) found that shade effects were consistently negative for tree seedlings, but litter and mineral soils from late seres were facilitative for two late successional species. In an experiment designed to test Holmgren and colleagues’ hypotheses about shade, soil moisture, and plant interactions, Davis et al. (1999) conducted a field experiment in which seedlings of Quercus macrocarpa (bur oak) and Q. elipsoidialis (northern pin oak) were grown in different levels of shade, nitrogen, water, and neighbors. They found that photosynthetic rates of Quercus seedlings increased with grass neighbors in dry conditions, but tended to decline in the shade in wet conditions, supporting the general model of Holmgren et al. (1997).
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Growth
26
MESIC HABITAT
XERIC HABITAT
Canopy
Light Open
Figure 2.2. Intersection of the hypothesized correlation between microsite light and moisture with seedling growth as a function of those factors. This shows the potential for decreasing growth with increasing light in xeric conditions, but not in mesic conditions. Redrawn from Holmgren et al. (1997) with permission from Ecology.
Foreshadowing Holmgren et al.’s argument by over 40 years, Shirley (1945) conducted an experiment investigating the interactive effects of hardwood roots and canopies on the survival and growth of conifer seedlings and saplings in the forests of Minnesota. He found that under dry conditions, moderate shade improved conifer survival, although the overall effect of hardwoods on conifers under most conditions was negative. These experiments indicated that overstory facilitative effects occurred, but that interference was usually more important. More recently, Thomas et al. (1999) conducted similar overstory thinning experiments, but in mesic Pseudotsuga menziesii forests in the northwest US. They found that 85% of the species in their plots were released from competition and only four of the 54 most common species showed evidence for facilitation. In more arid systems, as might be predicted from Holmgren et al.’s (1997) model, the positive effects of the shade may be more common. In another test of her theory Holmgren (2000) examined responses of Liriodendron tulipifera, a common tree in mesic communities of the temperate
Chapter 2
27
deciduous forest of the eastern USA, along gradients of PAR and water availability in greenhouse experiments. She found no evidence that increasing PAR compensated for the negative effects of drought on photosynthesis and growth; instead as predicted growth rates decreased with increasing PAR under dry conditions. Specifically, estimates of daily carbon gain with plentiful water increased in high light (27% of ambient) to 686±84 μmol g-1d-1 from 161±86 μmol g-1d-1 in low light, but in dry treatments carbon gain decreased in high light to -12±12 μmol g-1d-1 from 198±34 μmol g-1d-1 in low light. Growth decreases in high light and dry soil were associated with strong decreases in sapflow. Interestingly, Liriodendron is not particularly shade tolerant, nor is it unusually adapted to drought, even in comparison to other tree species with which it occurs. Holmgren made the case that if plants do not show a tradeoff between shade and drought tolerance in general, but do experience amelioration of drought in the shade, facilitative effects of shade should be common where drought limits the establishment of plants. Drought limits the establishment of plants in deserts, and facilitation in deserts appears to have created unusually strong patterns of spatial associations and many reports of facilitation (Flores and Jurado 2003). Deserts provide striking examples of shade as a facilitative mechanism in plant communities, and strong positive spatial associations in arid environments have attracted ecologists for decades (see Agnew 1997, Robinson 2004). As early as 1910, Forrest Shreve noticed that young saguaro cacti were usually found beneath shrubs or trees (Shreve 1910, 1917). In 1929, Compton reported strong positive associations among several species of shrubs in the Karoo Desert of South Africa and argued that stress-tolerant species provided shelter for less tolerant species. In more recent studies in the Karoo of southern Africa, over 60% of pair-wise spatial comparisons suggested positive interactions (Eccles et al. 1999). In the Sonoran Desert, Shreve (1931) observed that saguaro cacti (Carnegia gigantea) seedlings were common under shrubs and trees, but not in open spaces. This particular association between saguaro seedlings and other desert perennials has been studied intensively and coined the “nurse plant syndrome” in some of the earliest detailed studies of positive interactions in plant communities (Niering et al. 1963, Turner et al. 1966, 1969, Steenberg and Lowe 1969, 1977). Saguaro seedlings are sheltered by many different species of perennial plants, but predominantly by Cercidium microphyllum (paloverde tree). Turner and colleagues (Turner et al. 1966, 1969) investigated mechanisms behind the associations between young saguaro cacti and nurse trees and shrubs by measuring spatial associations and experimentally transplanting 5-cm and 15-cm tall saguaros in factorial treatments of shade and caging for protection from herbivores. They found that predation on seedlings was very high, but that the survival of seedlings that were transplanted in the shade of nurse plants was much higher than survival in the open.
28
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
All non-shaded saguaro seedlings died, in comparison to a 65% mortality rate of shaded seedlings. In these experiments canopy shade appeared to interact with soil albedo created by litter from different plant species (see species-specific effects in Chapter 5); for example more saguaro seedlings died on darker soils from under Prosopis than on light soils from under Cercidium (Turner et al. 1966). The strong effect of Cercidium nurse trees on saguaros and the strong eventual competitive effect of saguaros on their nurse trees have been hypothesized to drive some aspects of community dynamics in the Sonoran desert (Vandermeer 1980, McAuliffe 1988). Vandermeer suggested that higher mortality rates of Cercidium with saguaros under their canopies combined with the positive effect of Cercidium on saguaro populations could establish dramatic fluctuations in population numbers of the cactus (Steenberg and Lowe 1977) determined only by the consequences of interacting populations, Alfonso Valiente-Banuet and Exequiel Ezcurra (1991) experimentally compared the relative importance of protection from predators and shade from neighbors for Neobuxbaumia tetetzo, a columnar cactus in the Viscaino Desert and the Gran Desierto de Altar in Mexico that is commonly found under Mimosa luisana. They found that cages improved survival, but that long-term survival only occurred in shade treatments. In the Sonoran Desert, three species of cacti, Lophocereus schottii, Mammillaria thornberi and Peniocereus striatus, are highly associated with the dominant shrub Olneya testota (Humberto, et al. 1996). The spatial relationships between these species and Olneya are much stronger than with other potential nurse plant species. These differences were attributed to the observation that Olneya reduced subcanopy temperatures by 15 oC, which was 3-5oC more than any other species tested. Furthermore, the spatial relationships between cacti species and Olneya were stronger on southfacing exposures than on north-facing exposures, which also emphasize the importance of shade in more stressful conditions (Humberto et al. 1996). Using matrix models based on field data, Godinez-Alvarez et al. (1998) showed that survivorship was the most important life-history parameter for the finite rate of increase in Neobuxbaumia populations, underscoring the substantial importance of facilitative interactions on the long-term population dynamics of this species. Large columnar cacti have been the subject of many studies of facilitation, probably because their association with other species is so obvious. Desert cacti have exceptionally high tolerances to temperature, but columnar cacti may be particularly dependent on benefactors because large succulents have exceptionally low surface to volume ratios and cannot dissipate heat as efficiently. Ferocactus covillei and F. wislizenii, two species of barrel cacti from the Sonoran Desert, maintain intact cell membranes and cell viability at 69oC (Smith et al. 1984), but temperatures near the ground in deserts can exceed 75oC. For succulent plants, and especially young plants near the ground surface, the
Chapter 2
29
direct effects of shade on maintaining sublethal temperatures and decreasing respiration costs are probably the most important; succulents cannot efficiently cool themselves by transpiring because of the scarcity of water. The commonly described dependence of cacti species and other succulents on nurse plants (Yeaton 1978, Vandermeer 1980, McAuliffe 1984a, Yeaton and RomeroManzanares 1986, Parker 1988, 1999, 2000, Franco and Nobel 1989, Parker 1989, Yeaton and Elser 1990, McAuliffe 1991, Valiente-Banuet 1991, ValienteBanuet and Escurra 1991, Valiente-Banuet et al. 1991, Arriaga et al. 1993, Silvertown and Wilson 1994, Suzan et al. 1994, Tewksbury and Petrovich 1994, Humberto et al. 1996, Carrillo-Garcia et al. 2000a, Reyes-Olivas et al. 2002, Flores and Jurado 2003) may be due to inefficient heat dissipation of seedlings with low surface to volume ratios and exposure of these seedlings to exceptionally hot temperatures on the desert floor. For example, young barrel cacti (Ferrocactus acanthodes) experience 11oC decreases in maximum stem surface temperatures in the shade of nurse plants (Nobel 1980b). Franco and Nobel (1989) found that 89% of all saguaro seedlings occurred under Ambrosia deltoides or Cercidium microphyllum shrubs in Organ Pipe National Monument in the Sonoran Desert, but only 29% of Ferocactus acanthodes (barrel cactus) seedlings were found under nurse plants at a second site in the Mojave Desert. Saguaro seedlings can survive apical temperatures up to 66oC, whereas Ferocactus seedlings can tolerate temperatures up to 71oC (Nobel 1984a,b). Ambrosia deltoides and C. microphyllum shrubs reduced surface soil temperature maxima from ≈60oC to ≈47oC and ≈42oC, respectively; whereas another nurse, Hilaria rigida, decreased maximum temperatures from >70oC to ≈55oC. These kinds of species-specific positive relationships are discussed further in Chapter 5. Smaller pad-forming cacti also need nurses. Cody (1993) measured spatial distributions of three different species of Opuntia cacti at three different sites in the Mojave Desert and found that the smallest (and perhaps the youngest) Opuntias were highly associated with various species of nurse plants (also see Yeaton 1978). Spatial patterns suggested that mature Opuntia may in turn serve as a nurse for the seedlings of some of the shrub species. Archer et al. (1988) described similar relationships between Opuntia and Prosopis in southern Texas. Acacia species have generally been noted in the literature for their positive effects on subcanopy fertility because they are nitrogen fixers (see below, Radevanoki and Wickens 1967, Dancette and Poulain 1969, Singh and Lal 1969, Van Auken et al. 1985, Facelli and Brock 2000, Pandey et al. 2000). However, shade from Acacia canopies may also enhance the fitness of understory plants and structure savanna plant communities. Seedlings of the very small-leaved, Acacia nilotica in savannas of southern Africa virtually never occur under conspecific adults, perhaps because small leaves have small boundary
30
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
layers and are very good at dissipating heat. In contrast, almost all seedlings of broad-leaved species occur in A. nilotica understories (Smith and Goodman 1987). For example, 100% of the sampled seedlings of the evergreen Euclea divinorum occurred underneath the canopies of A. nilotica. Shade may be crucial to leaf temperature balance of larger and darker leaves in hot arid climates, especially before the young seedlings have established extensive root systems. As for Euclea, the effect of shade on temperature is also important for many other non-succulent species. For example, Shumway (2000) found that soil temperatures beneath Myrica pennsylvanica were almost 10oC cooler than in the open. This difference was associated with higher growth and reproduction and more favorable water relations of understory herbs. Pseudotsuga menziesii seeds remain viable and germinate at much higher rates under shrub canopies in the Argentine steppe where they have been introduced (Caccia and Ballaré 1998). High viability and germination is directly related to cooler temperatures in the shade of other plants. It is important to note that even strong spatial correlations between canopy shade and the presence of particular species can be misleading. For example, Tewksbury et al. (1998) analyzed the spatial distributions of Capsicum annuum, wild chilies, with respect to different nurse species and found that Capsicum had much stronger associations with some shrubs than others. Celtis reticulata (desert hackberry) was by far the most common nurse species in proportion to its abundance, and experimental transplants also showed a preference for Celtis. They also found that the canopies of Celtis attenuated sunlight approximately twice as much as any other species. Even though the exceptionally shady canopies of Celtis appeared to be particularly facilitative for Capsicum, the high degree of specificity between these species was driven by indirect interactions with bird dispersers due to similarities in the color of their fruits (see Chapter 3). So far, I have emphasized the effects of shade on the temperature of understory plants, but the effects of shade are more complex than this. Therefore, some ecologists have attempted to compare the relative importance of shade effects on temperature to that of other factors affecting plant growth. In arid environments, the difference in soil moisture between the subcanopy and the open may be as strong as differences in temperature (Shreve 1931, Abd El Rahman and Batanouny 1965a,b). However, to my knowledge the importance of the direct effects of shade on temperature in cacti-nurse plant relationships have rarely been compared to the effects of shade on soil moisture in experiments. In one of the best comparisons, irrigation of unshaded saguaro seedlings had minor effects on survivorship relative to the effects of shade, suggesting that lower temperatures in the shade were more important than improved water relations (Turner et al. 1966).
Chapter 2
31 2
χ = 18.03 P<0.0004 observed expected
16 12 8 4 0
N
16 12
16
*
12
8
Shrub
4
8 4
0
W
0
16
E
12 N
8 4 0
S
Figure 2.3. Observed and expected azimuths under shrubs where seedlings of Austrocedrus chilensis were located in southern Argentina. Reprinted from Kitzberger et al. (2001) with permission from Ecology.
Strong spatial associations among seedlings of Austrocedrus chilensis and shrubs in the shrub-steppe of Patagonia (Kitzberger et al. 2001) suggest nurse relationships like those between Artemisia tridentata and Pinus monophylla in shrub-steppe in the northern hemisphere (Callaway et al. 1996). As for Pinus monophylla, survival of planted Austrocedrus seedlings was much higher under shrubs than in the open, and naturally occurring tree seedlings were disproportionally more common on the pole-facing cooler sides (south) and east sides of shrubs than the hotter equator-facing sides (north) (Figure 2.3). To separate the direct effects of shade versus the effects of shade on soil moisture, Kitzberger et al. conducted an experiment in which they planted seedlings under shrubs and in the open and then watered some replicates in each environment. The addition of water greatly increased survival in the open, but only shaded seedlings survived through the second summer (Figure 2.4). Corresponding with general relationships between Austrocedrus and nurse plants, and supported by experimental tests on how shade and climate interact, Kitzberger et al. (2001) and Villalba and Veblen (1997) also found that the population age structure of Austrocedrus (studied using dendrochronology) closely tracked decadal-scale climatic variability. Years with greater than average seedling establishment were associated with the cold phase of the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (La Niña) which provides more moisture during the summer. During the wetter La Niña period Austrocedrus appears to be able to establish to some degree even in open habitats. The summers are much warmer and dryer during the El Niño phase and recruitment of Austrocedrus does not occur; either with or without nurse shrubs.
32
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation 100 Aa Ab
10
Cd
1
Bc
Shade, watered Shade, nonwatered Interspace, watered Interspace, nonwatered
F M A M J J A S O N D J F M Summer 1996
Fall
Winter
Spring
Summer 1997
Figure 2.4. Survivorship curves of cohorts of Austrocedrus chilensis in southern Argentina under different treatments from February 1996 to March 1997. Solid symbols represent shade treatments whereas open symbols represent open interspaces. Triangles represent watered treatments and circles non-watered treatments. Reprinted from Kitzberger et al. (2001) with permission from Ecology.
However, during years that are intermediate in the effects of La Niña and El Niño, which are dry but not excessively so, establishment of Austrocedrus appears to require nurse shrubs. Although shade may be crucial for establishment, such annual variation in long term recruitment suggests that soil moisture may be more important than indicated in short term experiments. Other conifer species also benefit from the shade of nurse shrubs. For example, in the semiarid conditions of southern Spain, Jorge Castro and colleagues found that survival of experimentally planted seedlings of Pinus sylvestris and P. nigra was almost two times higher when grown under Salvia lavandulifoia shrubs than in the open, and nurse shrubs did not reduce growth (Castro et al. 2002). Facilitative shade effects are not restricted to the amelioration of high temperatures. Nurse plant canopies protect young saguaros from freezing temperatures in the winter (Steenberg and Lowe 1977, Nobel 1980a, Humberto et al. 1996). Many cacti species from the southwestern U.S. cannot survive temperatures lower than –6 to –10oC (Nobel 1982), in part because their succulent tissues are susceptible to internal ice formation. Nobel (1980a) measured apical stem temperature of saguaro cacti in four different sites in
Chapter 2
33
southern Arizona. He found that nurse canopies (primarily Cercidium microphyllum) increased apical stem temperatures on smaller individuals by as much as 16oC during the winter. The buffering of cold temperatures decreased with the height of cacti, apparently because taller plants were less affected by the temperatures at the soil surface. Freezing in open microsites may severely limit the recruitment of saguaros (Steenberg and Lowe 1976), and facilitation by shrubs and small trees during early life stages may extend the northern distribution this cactus (Nobel 1980a,b). Buckley et al. (1998) found similar, but larger-scale positive affects of Quercus rubra and Pinus resinosa canopies on tree seedlings in the northern USA. They planted Q. rubra seedlings in forests dominated by either Q. rubra or P. resinosa trees and in treatments where 0, 25%, 75%, or 100% of the overstory trees were left intact. When stands were either clear-cut (no trees left) or thinned to 25%, Q. rubra seedlings damaged by frost during a late spring freeze increased from 0-20% to over 90%. In 1970, Frank Ronco and colleagues at the Rocky Mountain Experiment Station observed that open-grown Picea englemannii seedlings at high elevations were chlorotic whereas seedlings in the shade remained “a normal green”. Furthermore, needles shaded by experimental shingles remained green until their tips grew out from under the shingle, after which chlorosis developed. Ronco then conducted an experiment in which he compared photosynthetic rates of potted seedlings growing in different artificial shade treatments at 3,000 m elevation. He found that P. englemannii seedlings that had been grown in full shade where able to photosynthesize at 2-3 times greater rates, across a range of light intensities, than seedlings that had been grown without shade. This difference was not associated with lower water relations, but was attributed to “solarization, a phenomenon in which photosynthesis is inhibited by high light intensities”. This light induced “photoinhibition” has been studied extensively over the 35 years since Ronco’s work and we know now that the negative effects of high light interact in very complex ways with other factors. Prevention of photoinhibition by shade from neighbors may contribute to facilitation in montane environments. Several studies have shown that recruitment of Abies lasiocarpa is higher near other trees or microhabitats with grass cover (Habeck 1969, Rebertus et al. 1991, Callaway 1998b, Miller and Halpern 1998, Germino et al. 2002) and in some cases these patterns of recruitment appear to create dense tree islands surrounded by herbaceous vegetation. Recruitment of P. englemannii also appears to be facilitated by the mature canopies, but generally to a lower degree (Rebertus et al. 1991). However, in some environments facilitation of P. englemannii appears to be crucial. Noble and Alexander (1977) experimented with seedling recruitment of P. englemanni in the central Rocky Mountains of Colorado and concluded
34
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
that successful natural regeneration in openings on south aspects “is not possible”, and shade is “absolutely” essential for survival. However, in this case, desiccation appeared to be the primary source of mortality. Annual precipitation at their site was quite low for subalpine forests (58 cm yr-1), possibly explaining P. englemannii’s need for shade at the south-facing site, but not at sites facing other directions. Shade effects on photoinhibition are also important for Picea glauca, which like P. englemannii, is also often found underneath tree canopies when it is young. A common associate of young P. glauca is Populus tremuloides, a winter deciduous species. In P. tremuloides stands, leaf-off in the spring and autumn allows high light intensities to reach evergreen seedlings and saplings, such as P. glauca, in the understory. Man and Lieffers (1998) transplanted P. glauca seedlings in P. tremuloides understories and in surrounding open grassland-shrubland and measured their photosynthetic responses. They found that photosynthetic parameters were more depressed in open-grown seedlings compared to seedlings in the understory in the spring and autumn when frosts were common at night. However, net photosynthetic rates in the summer were similar even though understory seedlings were growing with two to four times less sunlight. Additionally, shoot and needle growth of open-grown seedlings was significantly less than of seedlings growing in the shade. Freezing air makes the high-light inhibition of the light-saturated rate of photosynthesis more likely. Therefore, the positive effects of canopies on the growth and physiology of P. glauca may not have been simply due to temperature, but to synergistic effects of temperature and light. In high light, low temperatures can amplify photoinhibition; a light-dependent depression of photosynthetic rate that occurs when leaves absorb more light than can be used (Krause 1994). For P. glauca, decreased summer photosynthetic rates were not due to lower stomatal conductance (Man and Lieffers 1998) but instead to the respiratory cost of repair to chloroplast, chlorophyll, enzyme, and electron transport systems that were damaged during the spring. Other studies have shown that the amelioration of cold temperatures can improve photosynthesis by Picea species and other conifers (Germino and Smith 1999). DeLucia and Smith (1987) found that decreases in photosynthetic rate of adult P. englemannii were correlated with the minimum air temperature of the previous night during the summer. Hellmers et al. (1970) found that minimum nighttime temperatures had stronger negative effects on the growth and survival of P. englemannii in greenhouse experiments than low daytime temperatures. Nunez and Bowman (1986) found that the minimum temperature tolerated by target plants increased as a function of stand density for Eucalyptus delegatensis at high elevations, a process that may have a positive effect on understory plants by reducing photoinhibition. At tree line in Australia seedlings of Eucalyptus
Chapter 2
35
pauciflora (snowgum) establish in higher densities and are more vigorous around adult trees and on the southern (more sheltered) sides of trees (Ball et al. 1991). Similar patterns have been observed for Nothofagus solandri timberlines in New Zealand (Ball 1994). Egerton et al. (2000) experimented with vertical shade screens to reduce excess light without reducing minimum air temperatures, and found that seedlings of E. pauciflora at high elevations were less photoinhibited, maintained higher photosynthetic rates, lost less leaf area, and maintained higher leaf area ratios when they were protected from excess light in the winter. These physiological differences were consistent with greater growth rates of sheltered seedlings over the winter. In another experiment with E. pauciflora, seedlings experienced higher levels of photoinhibition in forest clearings than those under canopies, but photoinhibition was not related to significant differences in seedling growth (Blennow et al. 1998). These studies suggest that cold temperature amelioration by shade from nurse plant canopies at tree line may have important facilitative effects beyond simply preventing neighbors from freezing to death. As described above, young cacti and conifer seedlings experience increases in temperature minima under whole-stand and solitary tree canopies because solar radiation is trapped during the night and re-radiated as long-wave irradiation. Leaf temperatures at night are strongly influenced by exposure to the sky, especially on calm nights with low convective heat exchange (Jordan and Smith 1994, 1995). Leaves exposed to the open night sky experience low levels of long-wave irradiation and leaf temperatures may drop to levels as much as 7oC lower than air temperatures beneath canopies (Jordan and Smith 1994). For example, conifer seedlings near timberline and beneath 50% canopy cover receive approximately 50 W m-2 more energy on a clear night than seedlings in the open. At night, these processes resulted in an approximately 4oC increase in mean needle temperature for seedlings with cover. Such temperature amelioration may be crucial at timberline, where many plant species are growing on the edge of existence, and are probably highly affected by “modulatory forces, including the presence of certain taxa” (Korner 1998). Tree establishment and growth at treeline is highly dependent on temperature, either for overall carbon balance, or sufficient production of new cells, or the development and differentiation of functional tissues (Korner 1998). Seedlings may be facilitated by canopies that simultaneously reduce exposure to low temperatures and high light, as emphasized above. However, the lowest temperatures typically occur at night when there is no light, and the highest light levels occur when temperatures are relatively warm. Exposed sites (without canopies for example) experience exceptionally low temperatures at night that are followed by exceptionally high light during the following day. This temporal decoupling of low temperatures and high light in natural
36
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
environments has raised some doubt about the ecological significance of canopy shade effects on photoinhibition. How the diurnal sequence of nighttime cold and daytime high light affect conifer seedling physiology was examined in a series of elegantly designed field experiments by Matt Germino and Bill Smith (1999, 2000) and Johnson et al. (2004). They found that Abies lasiocarpa and Picea englemanii seedlings were most common in habitats with ≈40-80% of the overhead area open to the sky, and demonstrated that seedlings in these habitats benefited from the overstory canopies because of ameliorated nighttime temperature and lower light levels the following day (also see Callaway 1998b). Light-saturated photosynthetic rates of newly germinated, potted, Abies lasiocarpa seedlings increased seven-fold in response to increased long-wave irradiation at night (warming), approximately five-fold in response to shading during the day, and eight-fold by a combination of night warming and shading during the day. Reductions in photosynthetic rate were associated with ≈50% increases in “slowly reversible” or “irreversible” long-term photoinhibition. Picea englemanni was much less affected by warming and shading treatments than A. lasiocarpa. These results were supported by measurements on natural seedlings, and demonstrated that typical diurnal patterns of low nighttime temperatures, and high light the following day, severely inhibited the photosynthetic ability of A. lasiocarpa seedlings. The susceptibility of A. lasiocarpa to cold nights coupled with sunny days, and the relative tolerance of P. englemanni to these conditions further indicates how important the positive effects of shade can be in subalpine communities. Many studies have demonstrated the importance of overstory canopies for ameliorating photoinhibition in understory recruits. But many of these understory recruits eventually reach the sunny overstory. Why these species appear to suffer from photoinhibition when they are seedlings, but function normally in full sunlight when adults is not clear. However, the eventual development of high root:shoot ratios by adults may play a large part. Photoinhibition may be minimized by increasing carbon sink capacities of older roots (Arp 1991), and as trees mature their roots may become much larger sinks for fixed carbon. Shunting excess fixed carbon out of the chloroplasts may allow the photosynthetic apparatus of mature trees to continue functioning in full sunlight. Shade from neighbors clearly facilitates many species simply due to the buffering of temperature extremes and through direct alteration of the light regime. However, as noted above for cactus-shrub relationships, shade also reduces soil water loss and plant transpiration. In other words, canopies may “engineer” (Jones et al. 1997) more mesic environments. Mesic environments may be more important to non-succulent plant species than succulents in a broad geographic context (Shreve 1931, Abd El Rahman and Batanoury 1965a,b, Holmgren et al. 1997), but shading appears to be crucial for many different plant
Chapter 2
37
morphologies at the local scale and particularly in the early stages of development and establishment. In northern Europe, severe water stress limits seedling establishment on coastal dunes, and shade from mature plants improves seedling water relations and survival (De Jong and Klinkhamer 1988). They found that seedling survival for Cynoglossum officinale and Cirsium vulgare was highly correlated with tree and shrub cover (Figure 2.5) and moisture in the upper 10 cm of the soil. Experiments in which either water or fertilizer were added to seedlings at different sites found that water was by far the most important factor determining survival of Cynoglossum seedlings. Furthermore, the effect of watering differed substantially depending on the particular habitat. Water had very strong effects in xeric habitats, increasing survival from 0 to 50% for Cirsium. However, in the habitats where thicket canopies shaded the soil and maintained high levels of surface moisture, watering had a much smaller effect. 12
1982
10 8
Established seedlings per flowering plant
6 4 2 0 12 10
Open Scrub Thickets
1983
8 6 4 2 0 12
1984 10 8 6 4 2 0
May 1
November 1
Figure 2.5. Seedling establishment of Cynoglossum officinale in three vegetation types. Redrawn from De Jong and Klinkhammer (1988) with permission from the Journal of Ecology.
38
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
In the exceptionally xeric upper zones of California salt marshes, spring ephemeral species are facilitated by the sub-shrub Arthrocnemum subterminale (Callaway 1994). Shade from Arthrocnemum enhances soil moisture, and the ephemerals are highly sensitive to annual differences in the amount and timing of rainfall and the experimental addition of water. Interestingly, similar processes appear to be caused by Arthrocnemum macrostachyum in marshes in Spain (Rubio-Casal et al. 2001, also see Espinar et al. 2002). In other coastal communities in North America Shumway (2000) found that the transpiration rates of two dune herbs, Solidago and Ammophila, were 15 to 20% lower under the canopies of Myrica than in the open. Decreased water losses through transpiration were associated with significantly lower midday water potentials, growth rates, and reproduction of the herbs in the open. Shumway found no differences in soil moisture under versus outside the canopies, suggesting that either beneficiaries used all of the extra soil water or canopy facilitation functioned through direct effects on beneficiary water relations and not through changes in soil water status. Facilitative effects of shade from shrubs are important for the recruitment of oaks in central California savannas and woodlands (Callaway et al. 1991, Callaway and D’Antonio 1991). In field experiments, unshaded cages reduced mortality rates of Quercus douglasii due to predation, but eventually all unshaded seedlings died over a two year period. In contrast 35% of shaded and caged seedlings survived for one year (Callaway et al. 1991). For seedlings without shade, most mortality was due to desiccation. Nearer the coast, Quercus agrifolia seedlings are much more common under shrubs than in the open grassland (Callaway and D’Antonio 1991). We conducted experiments by planting oak seedlings under shrubs and found that 31% of coast live oak seedlings that emerged after being experimentally planted under shrubs survived for more than two years, but no seedlings that emerged in the open survived. Again, mortality was caused by desiccation. However, these effects of shade are conditional, as shrubs and Q. agrifolia seedlings are much more associated on drier south-facing aspects than on north-facing aspects (Callaway and Davis 1998). Once facilitated by shade from nurse shrubs, shade from mature oaks facilitates other species (Owens et al. 1995). For example, Quercus agrifolia seedlings that survive to adulthood provide positive benefits to understory grasses by shading them. Parker and Muller (1982) conducted reciprocal transplant experiments with Bromus diandrus and Pholistoma auritum, two herbaceous species that are much more abundant under oak canopies than in the open grassland. They found that these species were more tolerant to shade than Avena fatua, a species that is generally excluded from habitat beneath Quercus agrifolia. In laboratory experiments B. diandrus had higher relative growth rates
Chapter 2
39
in low light than Avena fatua (Mahall and Parker 1981). These differences in growth rates were not produced by changes in photosynthesis, which was higher per unit leaf area for Avena in both shade and sun treatments. Instead, Bromus maintained higher whole-plant assimilation rates by allocating proportionally more biomass to leaves. In experiments in which whole soil blocks were transplanted between the understories of Quercus agrifolia, adjacent open grassland, and artificial shade treatments, Maranon and Bartolome (1993) found that reduced radiation under the canopies, not soil source, limited the distribution of the species that naturally dominated in the open. Competition from grass species that were dominant in the open inhibited understory species from establishing in the open grassland. Shade from canopies has dramatic effects on understory community composition and productivity in deserts (Patten 1978, Schmida and Whittaker 1981, Holzapfel and Mahall 1999). Shrubs also establish heterogeneous microgradients of radiation and soil temperature within canopies that appear to provide different niches for different species (Moro et al. 1997). Moro and colleagues quantified the positioning of several herbaceous species under the canopy of Retama sphaerocarpa, a leguminous shrub in semi-arid Spain, in response to several gradients including irradiance and temperature. Radiation at the soil level in a central position under the canopy was 60% of that outside, and temperature differences between the shrub understory and open microhabitats exceeded 7°C, and different understory species were associated with particular understory microclimates. It is not particularly surprising that shade from large woody trees and shrubs can facilitate understory herbs and seedlings. However, other studies indicate that morphologically similar herbaceous species can have important facilitative effects on each other via shade (Eckstein 2005). In northern Switzerland, shade from grasses prevents desiccation and frost heave on limestone soils, increasing seedling survival of other species by up to 10 times that of open patches (Ryser 1993). In a study of six species he found that two, Arabis hirsuta and Primula veris, had very low establishment in gaps, and much higher success in microsites with vegetation. In abandoned vineyards of southern France, the biennial herb, Picris hieracioides is an important early to midsuccessional colonizer. Sans et al. (1998, also see Sans et al. 2002) transplanted rosettes of Picris into plots where herbaceous vegetation had been killed with herbicide, and then monitored survival and growth over a seven month growing season. They found that Picris seedlings survived at much higher rates when the herbaceous vegetation matrix was present, and that the facilitative effect was stronger in fields with denser vegetation (Figure 2.6). The mechanism for the positive effect of herbaceous neighbors on Picris was not clear; however, most Picris mortality was correlated with desiccation and extreme temperatures.
40
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Survival (%)
100
neighbors & resources neighbors
80
a
60 no neighbors & resources
40
20
a
b
no neighbors
b 0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Weeks after transplanting Figure 2.6. Survivorship curves of Picris hieracioides in the presence of neighbors (solid lines), absence of neighbors (dashed lines) and with or without the addition of resources. Survivorship curves within each field with the same letter are not significantly different based on log-rank tests. Redrawn from Sans et al. (1998) with permission from Oikos.
The facilitative effects of shade within herbaceous communities such as those demonstrated by Ryser (1993) and Sans et al. (1998, 2002) appear to be produced, in part, by effects of the general vegetation matrix on microclimate. With this perspective, Zaal Kikvidze (1996, also see Kikvidze et al. 2006) measured strong bimodality in insolation due to variable and dynamic cloud cover in subalpine meadow communities in the Caucasus Mountains. He conducted removal experiments in different densities of vegetation, which was produced by different grazing intensities. In the most productive and dense plant communities (low grazing) he found that leaf temperature increased for plants without neighbors in sunny weather by an average of 3oC (-0.8 to 5.5oC depending on the target species). In heavily grazed communities there was no effect of removing neighbors on leaf temperature. Kikvidze then measured photosynthetic rates of Trifolium ambiguum either in intact swards of vegetation or in clearings throughout the day as clouds passed over and the sky cleared. He found that plants with intact neighbors increased their photosynthetic rates by 50% in sunny conditions, but when clouds appeared plants with neighbors decreased photosynthetic rates by 26%. As described above, many sun-loving species light saturate well below full sunlight, so decreasing PAR from ≈2000
Chapter 2
41
μmol m-2sec-1 to ≈1200 μmol m-2sec-1 probably did not light-limit T. ambiguum. However, if leaves are heated much above ambient air temperatures, leaf-to-air vapor pressure differences increase dramatically and may cause stomata to close in order to avoid a decrease in water-use-efficiency. Whole sward boundary layer effects may also promote stable and higher humidity near the plants, increasing water-use-efficiency and stimulating higher photosynthetic rates. For example, Antheleme et al. (in press) found that the highly drought-tolerant tussock-grass, Panicum turgidum, strongly diminished the vapor pressure deficit (VPD) within its canopies, and facilitated other species. Similarly, Caldeira et al. (2001) found that found target species in experimental plots with higher plant species richness and cover had carbon isotope ratios indicative of higher water-use-efficiencies. As found by Kikvidze, this was probably due to the overall effect of enhanced community boundary layer, retention of more humid air around the leaves of plants, and greater shading within the community. Similar facilitative processes have been demonstrated in other herbaceous communities. At the Cedar Creek Experimental Station in Minnesota, Wilson and Tilman (1995) found that Chenopodium album grew faster in the presence of other herbaceous neighbors than when neighbors were removed. But of eight species tested, only C. album showed this positive response to neighbors. Hillier (1990) found facilitative effects among herbaceous species in communities on dry calcareous slopes in Great Britain. Jack Greenlee and I (1996) found that the rare herbaceous mustard, Lesquerella carinata, was highly associated with bunchgrasses in dry montane grassland in western Montana. In experiments that included bunchgrass removal and the construction of artificial shade, we found that shade facilitated Lesquerella in an unusually dry year and at a dry site. David Wardle et al. (1999) conducted a large-scale experiment in perennial grasslands in New Zealand, continuously removing subsets of functional groups or species over a three-year period and monitoring the responses of other species. Most responses indicated competition; however, Trifolium repens responded to the removal of Lolium perenne in a much more complicated fashion. During the winter Trifolium was strongly stimulated by Lolium removal, indicating competition, but in summer when conditions were dryer, removal of Lolium strongly inhibited Trifolium, indicating facilitation. Other experiments have shown that Lolium tends to be less competitive with Trifolium in drier environments (Thomas 1984). Much like plants in temperate or semiarid grasslands of similar stature facilitate each other through community-scale shading, temperature reduction, and increasing ambient humidity, such community-scale shading processes may function in arctic and alpine communities to maintain temperatures above that of the ambient air. The shoot morphology of many alpine and arctic species allows
42
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
them to trap heat and thus modify their environment. Compact cushions and rosettes hug the ground and possess dense schlerophyllous leaves which increase temperatures at the leaf surface. For example, Korner (1999) found that temperatures within cushion plants may be 20oC higher than the ambient air. In alpine vegetation in Patagonian Chile, Arroyo et al. (2003) found that at 700 m in elevation the cushion plant, Azorella monantha, increased temperatures at the leaf surface approximately 5oC above ambient air temperature and at 900 m the leaf-air temperature difference was 8oC. They also found that temperatures of the leaves of the cushion plant, Diapensia lapponica, can be 3-5oC above ambient on cloudy days and 12-15oC higher on sunny days. Other species can benefit from the warmth of these cushions. It is difficult to separate the effects of temperature from the effects of other harsh environmental characteristics at high elevations such as wind (see below), but many studies have shown that large proportions of species are spatially associated with cushions (see below, Whitehead 1951, Griggs 1956, Bonde 1968, Blundon 1983, Sohlberg and Bliss 1984, Alliende and Hoffman 1985, Kikvidze 1993, 1996, Kikvidze and Nakhutsrishvili 1998, Anderson and Bliss 1998, Pokatzhevkaya 1998, Nunez 1999, Arroyo et al. 2003, Cleavitt 2004, Caveries et al. 2006), and several have shown strong facilitative effects experimentally (Choler et al. 2001, Callaway et al. 2002, Klanderud and Totland 2005). Experiments conducted by Maranon and Bartolome (1993, (described above) suggest an alternative interpretation for some experiments in which shade has been assumed to play a predominately direct role. Shade from a canopy dominant may have a positive effect on understory species, or it may suppress superior competitors and indirectly facilitate other species by providing them relatively competition-free habitat (Chapter 3 addresses such indirect facilitative effects). Seedling establishment of oaks (Quercus velutina and Q. alba) is inhibited by dense herbaceous vegetation (Harrison and Werner 1984) and Werner and Harbeck (1982) found that the highest densities of oak seedlings occurred in patches of low vegetation and with the canopies of staghorn sumac shrubs. Similar effects have been described for junipers, which provide openings for oak seedlings by suppressing herbaceous vegetation (Bard 1952). Petranka and McPherson (1979) found that drought-intolerant tree species were not able to invade tall grass prairie vegetation without the prior invasion of the shrub Rhus copallina, and that the colonization of prairie by more drought-tolerant tree species was enhanced by the shrub (Figure 2.7). Invasion by Rhus increased levels of soil moisture and nutrients, but apparently interfered with the growth of prairie grasses by allelopathic suppression and decreasing available light.
Chapter 2
43
Tree seedling density (#/m 2)
A
Inside Rhus shrubs In open near Rhus shrubs
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
0
0
0
B
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1 0 U am lmus eri can a J un i p vir gin erus ia n a
0 Ce spe ltis c ie s
Q ma uerc rila us nd ic a
0 Qu e ste rcus lla t a
0.0
Figure 2.7. Densities of tree seedlings within and near clones of Rhus copallina at the prairie-forest ecotone in Oklahoma. A) Near the forest border. B) Far into the prairie. Redrawn from Petranka and McPherson (1979) with permission from Ecology.
Shade from plants may elicit positive responses from neighboring species even in exceptionally wet environments. Spartina alterniflora (cordgrass) is very closely associated with algal species, including the brown alga, Ascophyllum nodosum, in marsh plant communities on much of the eastern coastline of North America (Chock and Mathieson 1976, Gerard 1999, Chapman and Chapman 1999). On Long Island, New York, removal of Spartina caused Ascophyllum to grow slower and Ascophyllum without Spartina neighbors experienced greater dehydration (Gerard 1999). Farther north on the coast of Nova Scotia, however, removal of Spartina in a similar experiment produced the opposite results. Removal of Spartina did not have significant effects on the growth of Ascophyllum, but reduced dehydration (Chapman and Chapman 1999).
44
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
They proposed that Spartina was important for the stabilization of substrate throughout its range, hence potentially explaining the consistently strong association between Spartina and Ascophyllum, but that the facilitating effect of substrate stabilization operated at a far larger scale than that at which they conducted their experiment. Tree canopies may also have very large scale effects on climate, and apparently increase regional temperatures. Gordon Bonan (1999) used maps of predicted natural vegetation and true vegetation maps to develop climate simulations for the midwestern United States. He found that the removal of trees may have contributed to temperature decreases of as much as 2.5oC in the region. Such effects may not be readily discernable in experiments conducted by most ecologists, but large-scale environmental modifications, or “ecosystem engineering” (Jones et al. 1997) should not be dismissed as potential facilitative processes. Subsumed within the large-scale effects of shade in forests, very small scale facilitative shade effects may be caused by species-specific patterns in light transmission through canopies (Canham et al. 1994, Seiwa 1998) and phenological niches caused by seasonality in light availability (Mahall and Bormann 1978). For example, Canham et al. (1994) measured the light transmission through canopies of nine deciduous and evergreen tree species in forests of southern New England. They found that light extinction, as light passed through canopies, differed among species with shade-tolerant species casting the deepest shade (1% of full sunlight, ≈20 μmol m-2 sec-1) and early successional species casting the least shade (6%, ≈120 μmol m-2 sec-1). Furthermore, sunflecks contributed little of the transmitted light under the shadiest species, but 40-50% of the transmitted light under the less shady species. Species-specific variation in subcanopy light regimes correlated with models of predicted sapling mortality under the different canopies. Shade intolerant species in general transmit more light to their understory than shade tolerant species (Messier et al. 1998), because the latter have a more efficient leaf display (Bond et al. 1999). Species-specificity in canopy effects is not only determined by canopy structure. Seiwa (1998) found that the seasonal growth of Acer mono seedlings in temperate deciduous forests in Japan was greatly affected by the timing of leaf fall and flush of different overstory species. Growth rates of experimentally planted seedlings were higher under trees that flushed leaves later in the spring and dropped them earlier in the fall (Ostrya japonica, Ulmus davidiana, and Juglans ailanthifolia), than under trees with early flushes and late drops (Quercus mongolica). The strongest differences in species-specific understory community composition have been observed when tree species differ morphologically in
Chapter 2
45
ways that affect shade, such as evergreen versus deciduous, but many studies have described specific canopy-understory species associations among species with similar morphologies (Veblen et al. 1979, Hicks 1980, Sydes and Grime 1981, Beatty 1984, Boettcher and Kalisz 1990, Dzwonko and Loster 1997, Pabst and Spies 1997). These patterns are the basis for predictive transition matrix models of forest dynamics (Horn 1975, Woods and Whittaker 1981). Frelich et al. (1993) described “neighborhood effects” in temperate forests in which several overstory species appeared to have strong effects on the composition of the understory community. Models based on these data indicate that these positive neighborhood effects may also augment small differences in the environment and result in large mono-specific patches (Frelich et al. 1998). In models including the possibility of such neighborhood effects, groups of species were initiated in a random pattern and then allowed to interact in positive and negative ways. These modeled species formed different and distinct communities.
2.4. WATER RELATIONS: SOIL MOISTURE In the section above, I focused on how shade may directly benefit plants by reducing leaf temperatures, reducing transpiration, and limiting light damage, and introduced the potential for how shade creates a more mesic environment. I also discussed how hydraulic lift can contribute to the effects of overstory species on soil moisture. In this section I go into more detail on the effects of shade on soil moisture and discuss other mechanisms by which plants can improve soil moisture conditions and facilitate their neighbors. Tree canopies often intercept precipitation, keeping it from reaching the understory, but often these same understories have wetter soils than soils of surrounding open areas (McLeod and Murphy 1977, Belsky et al. 1989, Ko and Reich 1993). The proportion of precipitation reaching the understory is affected by the intensity and duration of rainfall events. For example, in rainfall events in a semi-arid savanna in Kenya that were less than 2 mm, no throughfall reached the understory (Belsky et al. 1989). But in events that exceeded 20 mm average throughfall equaled ambient rainfall. Similar patterns have been observed in California oak woodlands (Callaway and Nadkarni 1991) and deserts (Robinson 2004). Different tree species can have widely variable effects on the amount and distribution of precipitation reaching the ground based on tree size, bark characteristics, and leaf area (Haworth and McPherson 1995). Despite the interception of precipitation by oak and Acacia canopies, and increased productivity of the herbaceaous understory, subcanopy soils in both California oak woodland and Kenyan savanna are often wetter than in the open,
46
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
corresponding with many other studies showing that canopies can create mesic habitats. In savannas (dehesas) in southwestern Spain, the canopies of Quercus rotundifolia and Quercus suber cause significant delays in soil water loss relative to soils in the open (Joffre and Rambal 1988). They measured water movement through the upper 150 cm of soil and found that increased soil moisture due to shade, and the effects of the oaks on physical soil characteristics, correlated with large differences in species composition under trees versus in the open. Similar effects occur in Acacia-dominated savannas. Ovalle and Avendaño (1987) found that herbaceous species under Acacia craven were more productive than in open areas and attributed this to improved soil moisture conditions. In Kenyan savannas herbaceous communities under Acacia tortilis and Adansonia digitata (baobob) tree canopies are strikingly different in comparison in to the surrounding matrix of open grassland (Belsky et al. 1989, Belsky 1994). Others have reported similar strong canopy effects on species distributions in South African savannas (Kennard and Walker 1973). Improved water relations may play a role in these patterns as leaf water potential of grasses under Acacia tortilis is significantly higher than grasses in the open (Maranga 1984). Anderson et al. (2001) found that woody seedling densities and the survival of transplanted Prosopis glandulosa seedlings were higher under Quercus fusiformis in a Texas savanna. However, many Q. fusiformis individuals in the populations had been infected by the oak wilt, which increased their general facilitative effects. Soil moisture under symptomatic trees was significantly higher than under healthy trees, presumably because leaf drop in the infected canopies reduced transpiration. Drought is one of the primary causes of mortality for seedlings of Olea europea (wild olive) in southern Spain (Rey and Alcántara 2002). They planted seeds of Olea in a variety of habitats, and found that survival was negatively correlated with the light intensity of the environment and was much higher under several species of shrubs where shade retained soil moisture than in the open. They also followed seedling germination and survival of a natural cohort and found that germination and emergence of seedlings was higher on open ground, but only seedlings that were under shrubs survived the two year duration of their experiment. Breshears and colleagues (1998) measured micrometerological dynamics under Pinus edulis and Juniperus monosperma canopies in New Mexico in detail, providing a relatively complete picture of the long-term effects of these canopies on understory moisture. Subcanopy temperatures were as much as 10oC cooler in the summer, but subcanopy soils were warmer during the coldest parts of the day in the winter. They used these measurements, soil volumetric water content, and measurements of the rates of soil drying from excised samples
Chapter 2
47
to calculate evaporation from subcanopy and inter-canopy spaces. During the growing season drying rates in the inter-canopy spaces were as much as 2% per day higher than drying rates under the canopies of the trees. Furthermore, these rates were amplified at low soil water contents. These results show that the commonly reported facilitative effects of canopies on understory moisture are temporally dynamic, perhaps more so than in open habitats, and this may increase microhabitat heterogeneity for understory species Soil moisture under canopies is also affected by the way soils are modified by long-term deposition of litter (Eckstein and Donath 2005). Soil bulk density (soil mass per unit volume) decreases as litter from canopies accumulates and degrades into soil organic matter, which creates a more favorable rooting substrate and soils that can hold more water. Root channeling may also increase the rate of water infiltration and storage. Joffre and Rambal (1988, 1993) found that subcanopy soils beneath two evergreen oaks, Q. suber and Q. rotundifolia, had significantly lower dry bulk density and lower moisture release curves than soils from the surrounding open grassland. These differences were correlated with much higher subcanopy soil water storage capacities, higher seasonal soil water contents, and shifts in species composition. Georgiadis (1989) found that the soil bulk density under shrubs in West African savannas was 22% lower than in the open, and the soil compaction index was less than half of that of open soils. Low densities increased water infiltration rates of subcanopy soils over three times more than that of open soils. In southern African savannas soils under trees are deeper and contain higher percentages of organic carbon, a pattern that appears to affect the mosaic of herbaceous communities (Carter and O’Connor 1991). I found that soil bulk density in the upper 10 cm under Quercus douglasii in Californian savannas and woodlands ranged from ≈0.7 to 0.8 g/cm3, whereas in the open density was >1.0 g/cm3 (Callaway et al. 1991), but differences in soil moisture were not clear. Tiedemann and Klemmedson (1986) found that soil bulk density was lower under Prosopis juliflora trees than in the open spaces between the trees. The effects of trees on subcanopy soil characteristics are difficult to separate from the effects of subcanopy soil characteristics on trees. For example, it is possible that Prosopis juliflora trees (or any other tree species) are more likely to establish and grow in sites with lower bulk densities than sites with high bulk densities. Because physical soil characteristics change very slowly, there are few options for experimentally separating cause from these kinds of spatial correlations. However, there are three approaches to this dilemma. First, if trees actually are causing the soil characteristic, then such changes should be very consistent - in my opinion much more consistent than subcanopy vegetation which is affected by many other factors. Second, if trees are causing the change there should be a relationship between the age of the tree and the magnitude of
48
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
the effect. For example, Baumeister and Callaway (2006) found that the age of Pinus flexilis (limber pine) trees on the eastern front of the northern Rocky Mountains was highly correlated with the depth of the A horizon beneath them, potentially explaining how limber pine might affect understory plant communities. Finally, it is reasonable to expect tree canopies to increase litter and the organic content of soil, and trees may certainly reduce the density of soils, but trees are much less likely to alter soil texture several centimeters below the soil surface. If soil texture is similar, but organic content is not, it is reasonable to assume that site differences are biotically determined. In a few cases, herbs (which are usually the beneficiaries of shade from woody perennials) have positive effects on the water relations of the shrubs that shelter them. Understory herbs cannot shade overstory perennials, but they can shade soil and affect soil moisture. Holzapfel and Mahall (1999) conducted experiments using thatch additions and removal of annuals and found that understory annuals had positive effects on the predawn water potentials of associated Ambrosia dumosa shrubs. In southern Spain, one of the driest regions of Europe, Retama sphaerocarpa shrubs have higher water potentials when the understory herb Marrubium vulgare occupies the understory than when the understory is bare ground (Pugnaire 1996a), suggesting that a dense understory helps to retain rainfall. In greenhouse experiments, Espigares et al. (2004) found that herbs found in the understory of Retama exerted strong competitive effects on Retama seedlings and claimed that the positive effect of understory herbs occurred only after a shift away from competitive effects with age. This may be true, but greenhouses are very poor places to study facilitation because watering, fertilization, and protection from wind and herbivores ameliorate stress in the greenhouse and make facilitation less likely. Greenhouse experiments almost always demonstrate competition. Although understory effects on overstory shrubs and trees have not been investigated frequently, research like that of Holzapfel and Mahall (1999) and Pugnaire et al. (1996a) has the potential to provide fresh insight into the generality of positive interactions in communities. Facilitative effects on moisture are stronger in arid conditions, but relatively drought tolerant species can modify the environment in ways that facilitate the water relations of less tolerant species even in very mesic habitats. Eriophorum vaginatum, and other Eriophorum species (cottongrass), readily germinate and grow on open, bare surfaces of peatlands and are common species on boreal and temperate peatlands around the world. In peatlands that have been cut for fuel, Eriophorum appears to facilitate the colonization and survival of some the world’s best “ecosystem engineers”, the Sphagnum species that gradually form peat through the accumulation of their dead and living biomass (see below). Even though peatlands have high water tables and water-saturated
Chapter 2
49
soils just below the surface, the uppermost layers tend to be dry when plant cover is low because of the low albedo of dark peat and desiccating winds (Salonen 1987, 1991). In the Jura Mountains of eastern France the majority of Sphagnum colonization occurs under the leaves of Eriophorum vaginatum tussocks (Grosvernier et al. 1995), and in Canadian peatlands E. angustifolium appears to facilitate revegetation of other species (Ferland and Rochefort 1997). Tuittila et al. (2000) studied the spatial associations of several species with E. vaginatum tussocks in a Finnish peatland 20 years after fuel cutting and abandonment. They found that almost all of the other species showed a positive association with the early-colonizing E. vaginatum. Furthermore, the smaller the E. vaginatum tussock, the closer other plants occurred to it. Not only did other species occur more frequently near the tussocks, they occurred more frequently on the northern, shadier, aspects of the tussocks. These spatial associations were assumed to be related to the more humid microclimate under the tussocks. Previous examples show that some plant species modify physical habitat in ways that create mesic conditions. In some cases, however, a beneficiary host plant may provide mesic environments with its own body. Epiphytic plants live in conditions where moisture is highly variable. On Sapelo Island, Georgia, colleagues and I conducted field experiments to study mechanisms behind the preference of two vascular epiphyte species, Tillandsia usneoides and Polypodium polypodioides for particular host species (Callaway et al. 2002). The abundances of these epiphytes on Celtis laevigata (hackberry), Quercus virginiana (live oak) and Juniperus virginiana were over twice that of any of the other host species, and this correlated with the much greater water-holding capacity of the bark of these species. After 24 hours of experimental drying, 42-66% of the initial water remained for Celtis, Q. virginiana, and Juniperus, compared to 0-14% for Pinus elliotii, P. taeda, Magnolia grandifolia, and Ilex opaca which were all very poor epiphyte hosts (Figure 2.8). The saturated capacities of the three best hosts for epiphyte species was more than twice that of the “bad hosts”. Because atmospheric epiphytes lack access to consistent water supply from the soil, they are susceptible to water stress. Bark with a high water-holding capacity may improve the performance of air plants such as Tillandsia by increasing humidity near the tree and decreasing leaf-to-air vapor pressure differences. Low leaf-to-air vapor pressure differences promote high rates of gas exchange in Tillandsia usneiodes and other species in the genus (Lange and Medina 1979, Martin and Siedow 1981). Interestingly, Garth (1964) found that atmospheric humidity was the single climatic factor which best fit the northern limit of the distribution of Tillandsia usneoides. Unlike Tillandsia, Polypodium is able to grow roots into the bark of host trees; therefore, bark with high water-holding capacity may provide a consistent water supply. Polypodium can regain full
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
a
2
saturated (r =0.76) 2 after 24 hours drying (r =0.77)
800
b
600
b b
400
b
b
b
n
b
b
b no
200
Ac er
P. tae da M ag no lia
P. e
lli oti i
0
LOW
o
o o
o
o
Rank order of Tilandsia preference
Ce lti s
o
igr a Li qu id am ba r Ju nip er us Q. vir gin ian a
o
Q. n
o
Ile x
2
Water held in bark (mg/cm )
50
HIGH
Figure 2.8. Water-holding capacity at saturation and after 24 h for branch bark of different tree host species for Tillandsia usneoides. Host species are displayed in order of field ranking for epiphyte density with the poorest hosts on the left. Bars indicate means + 1 standard error. Shared letters within each variable indicate no significant difference (post-ANOVA Tukey test). Inset figure shows regressions for water-holding capacity and duration and field abundance rank for each host species. One-way ANOVA, Fcapacity=14.23, df=9,49, P<0.001; F24 hrs=14.48, df=9,49, P<0.001. Reprinted from Callaway and Pennings (2002) with permission from Oecologia.
photosynthetic capacity after complete dehydration (Stuart 1968), but Polypodium is susceptible to photoinhibition as leaves begin to dry, and even partial drought decreases carbon gain (Muslin and Homann 1992). The spatial distributions of other Polypodium species in tree canopies in a Mexican cloud forest correlate with their ability to tolerate drought (Hietz and Hietz-Seifert 1995, Hietz and Briones 1998). The positive effects of canopy trees on subcanopy soil moisture are affected by the age or size of the overstory tree. Kellman and Kading (1992) found that densities of young Pinus strobus and P. resinosa on sandy soil near Lake Huron were about six times more abundant under the canopies of Quercus rubra than in the open. Pine seedlings were much more common under old oaks than young oaks. Experiments with transplanted pine seedlings resulted in high emergence and survival under medium and large oak trees (Figure 2.9), but young oaks did not have this effect. Summer high temperatures at ground level
Chapter 2
51
Pinus resinosa
'large' oaks
'medium' sized oaks
5 4 3 2 1
0 25
0
0 0
0 0 0
5 4 3 2 1
1 2 3 4 5
0 0 0
0 0 0
5 4 3 2 1
0
1 2 3 4 5
'large' oaks
'medium' sized oaks 20
Pinus strobus
Number of seedlings
6
15
10
5
0
0 0
0 0
0 0 0
5 4 3 2 1
1 2 3 4 5
0
0 0 0
5 4 3 2 1
0
0 0 0
1 2 3 4 5
Quadrats at proportional distances from tree trunks Figure 2.9. Emergence and survival of Pinus resinosa (red pine) and P. strobus (white pine) seedlings planted beneath and outside of the canopies of oaks of different sizes. n=100 seeds for each location. Shaded boxed and dotted lines depict the position of the oak canopies. Redrawn from Kellman and Kading (1992) with permission from the Journal of Vegetation Science.
ranged from ≈32-54oC (depending on position under the canopy) under small oaks, but only from ≈22-45oC under large canopies. Seedling emergence and survival were highly correlated with subcanopy soil moisture, which was much higher under the larger tree canopies. Not only trees improve local water relations. After a stand-replacing fire in a matorral community in southern Argentina, Raffaele and Veblen (1998) removed half of the canopies of two different shrub species. They measured soil moisture and the density and growth of other species resprouting under intact canopies and where canopies had been removed. They found that soil moisture was 2-3 times higher, and the number of resprouting species was 2-10 times
52
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
higher, when canopies were left intact. Total resprout density was 6-7 times higher under canopies. Påhlsson (1974) compared microclimatic conditions in tussock grassland on south- and north-facing slopes in Sweden. He found that relative humidity and temperature within tussocks of Onomis repens was similar to that on the north-facing slope. Onomis tussocks were associated with higher soil moisture than the surrounding open matrix and some herbaceous species common on the north-facing slopes could only be found on the south-facing slopes when associated with Onomis. Fonteyn and Mahall (1981) removed interspecific and intraspecific neighbors from around target Larrea tridentata shrubs in the Mojave Desert and found that Ambrosia dumosa competed strongly with Larrea for water. But in the Chihuahuan Desert of Mexico the xylem pressure potential of Larrea shrubs was more than 1.0 MPa higher (less water stress) in some months when interspecific neighbors were left intact than when they were removed (Briones et al. 1998). Algae may also facilitate vascular plants in dune environments by improving soil moisture. In one of the rare examples of a greenhouse experiment demonstrating facilitation (Vazquez et al. 1998) found that the presence of filamentous algae increased the germination rates of four herbaceaous species common in tropical dune slacks to approximately 2-3 times that occurring on bare sand by maintaining substrate humidity. Most studies of positive effects of plants on each other have focused on interspecific relationships. However, despite the general assumption that intraspecific interactions should be exceptionally competitive because different individuals require exactly the same resources and occupy the same rooting and canopy spaces, there are a number of examples of facilitation for water relations among conspecifics. Ptelea trifoliata (hop tree) is a shrub that colonizes mid- and fore-dunes at the edge of Lake Michigan. Ptelea reproduces entirely by seed so germination and seed survival in the xeric, sandy environment of the dunes are limiting stages in this plant’s life history. Ptelea canopies reduce precipitation reaching the ground by 40%, but maximum soil temperatures are reduced by 1520oC, light intensity is reduced by an average of 85%, and evaporation under shrubs is only 42% of that in the open (McLeod and Murphy 1977). These changes in microclimate resulted in a two-fold increase in soil moisture under shrubs compared to the open. Increased surface moisture under mature shrubs was associated with 24.5% survival of seedlings in the understory microhabitat during the 6 month growing season, whereas all seedlings in the open died within 2 months of the beginning of the experiment (Figure 2.10).
Chapter 2
53
Survival (%)
100 80 Sheltered microhabitat 60 40 20 0
Open microhabitat 19 25 5
May
26 5
June
19 28
July
25
Aug
11
Sept
13
Oct
11
Nov
Figure 2.10. Survivorship curves for Ptela trifoliata seedlings on sand dunes near Lake Michigan, USA. Redrawn from McLeod and Murphy (1977) with permission from The American Midland Naturalist.
Even in alpine environments adult plants may facilitate conspecific seedlings by improving moisture conditions (Wied and Galen 1998). They found that the litter from the decaying flowering and fruiting structures of mature adults sheltered the soil below them. This created microsites in which soil moisture was higher and evaporation rates were lower. Experimentally planted seedlings had higher water potentials in sites that were protected by litter from adults than in sites where litter had been removed. A little lower in elevation, subalpine conifers improve soil moisture conditions near them by altering the flow of wind near the ground surface which has direct effects on other plants in the lee of their canopies, and other effects by increasing snow deposition. Holtmeier and Broll (1992) found that snow accumulated inside and leeward of tree islands at high elevations in Colorado, increasing soil moisture. Similar processes appear to create snowdrifts and more moisture on the leeward sides of mature trees and develop “ribbon forests” in subalpine regions of the Rocky Mountains (Billings 1969). Billings stated that seedling establishment is inhibited in these drifts but the higher moisture left after the drifts melt enhances the growth of seedlings that do manage to establish. Alpine “tree islands” at Niwot Ridge in Colorado create large snowdrifts in their lee which create mesic microenvironments that are beneficial to other species (Marr 1977). For example, Marr found that Ribes montigenum only occurred within or in the lee of Picea engelmanii and Abies lasiocarpa islands at Niwot Ridge. These tree islands appear to move across the landscape over decades, driven across the tundra by wind-induced desiccation and mortality on the
54
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
windward sides of the island and growth on the leeward side where stems and buds are protected from the wind by layered branches (Marr 1977). Pontecorvo and Bokhari (1975) also asserted that Juniperus excelsa facilitated similar islands via the same mechanisms. At timberline, tree islands and krummholtz may function as focal points for snow and moisture accumulation. However, Brooke et al. (1970) found that snow next to the trunks of trees at lower elevations in subalpine meadows in coastal British Columbia melted faster than snow in the open. In this environment earlier snowmelt appeared to facilitate the growth of shrubs and other trees in these “snow craters”, eventually creating tree islands (also see Wipf et al. 2006). This phenomenon may be important in establishing interspecific aggregation such has been described for Abies lasiocarpa (subalpine fir) around Pinus albicaulis (whitebark pine) in the northern Rocky Mountains of Montana (Habeck 1969, Callaway 1998b), conifers in the central Cascades of Oregon (Miller and Halpern 1998), and Picea engelmannii (Englemann spruce) and Abies lasiocarpa around Pinus flexilis (limber pine) in the Colorado Front Range (Rebertus et al. 1991). Interestingly, other species may facilitate seedlings of P. albicaulis, a common benefactor when an adult, by improving moisture conditions (Maher et al. 2005). Abies lasiocarpa recruitment may also be facilitated by moisture provided by shrub species. Weisberg and Baker (Weisberg 1995) reported a much higher spatial relationship between A. lasiocarpa seedlings and Vaccinium species in the Rocky Mountains of Colorado than would be predicted by the proportional cover of Vaccinium. Other researchers have noted this relationship, but generally at larger scales (Stahelin 1943, Franklin et al. 1971). As for virtually all positive spatial associations, the putative benefactor, Vaccinium, may simply be an indicator of some aspect of site quality for A. lasiocarpa, or Vaccinium shrubs may actually have a direct positive effect through amelioration of dry soils. Much like the ‘ghost of competition past’, facilitative effects may not always be obvious because the effects often disappear as the interactions among species mature (see Figure 2.15), and because multi-mechanistic interactions among benefactors and beneficiaries may shift in relative strength over time (see Chapter 4). For example, tussock grasses are facilitated by shrub species in arid Patagonian shrub-steppe, apparently due to seed accumulation and shadeincreased soil moisture under the shrub during the growing season (Aguiar et al. 1992, Aguiar and Sala 1994). However, once grasses have established under shrubs, soil moisture decreases dramatically and the survival of grass seedlings becomes lower. As the original beneficiaries grow they reach the point where they can use all shrub-enhanced water and more, obscuring the facilitative effect of their benefactors. When mature grasses were removed from beneath shrubs,
Chapter 2
55
soil water potential increased from –1.5 to –0.3 MPa during the spring, and correspondingly, grass seedling survival was enhanced as the facilitative effect of the shrub was unmasked. Aguiar and colleagues argued that all of these interactions together established dynamic interactions and community development. When the shrubs are young and small, facilitation through shade is the most important interaction, resulting in a dense ring of tussock grasses associated with shrubs. When shrubs increase in age and size, competition from the shrub and from the previously facilitated grasses overshadows the benefit of shade. After the death of the shrubs grass rings fragment, and then establish patches of grass-dominated communities. Shrub patches also affect the distribution of sexes for the dioecious grass species, Poa ligularis, but genderbiased patterns depended on the quality of the shrub patch (Bertiller et al. 2000). When patches were either short and dense or tall and sparse, conditions in which abundant populations of P. ligularis did not develop, males and females coexisted. However, when shrub patches were large and tall enough to facilitate large numbers of P. ligularis, females dominated the patches, and males occupied the edges of the patch and the bare soil outside of the patch where no females occurred. Shade may also affect the water relations of plants by altering soil salinity. Saline soils stress plants by decreasing the osmotic potential of water in the soil and toxic effects of salt ions on plant tissues. Shade provided by salt tolerant species in salt marshes reduces evaporation from subcanopy soils and consequently maintains lower soil salinities, and therefore higher soil water potentials, than in adjacent soils exposed to direct insolation (Bertness and Hacker 1994, Callaway 1994). In a New England salt marsh, Steve Brewer et al. (1997) manually removed Juncus gerardi at three different elevations and measured soil responses. They found that soil salinity increased significantly at all elevations in the marsh when Juncus was removed, but the difference was greater at low elevations. Other experimental manipulations of soil salinity in the upper zones of a New England salt marsh have shown that Distichlis spicata, a salt tolerant colonizer of saline bare patches created by disturbance, facilitates the growth of Juncus gerardi when soil salinities are high (Bertness 1991, Bertness and Shumway 1993). When soil salinities were experimentally reduced by watering, growth of Juncus was not improved by Distichlis. This process depended to some degree on the size of the disturbed patch; in large patches salinities were very high and salt-tolerant species played facilitative roles. In smaller patches, however, soil salinities were not as extreme and interactions among early colonizers and latecomers were competitive (Shumway 1994). As discussed above (Brewer et al. 1997), once Juncus was established its turf morphology shaded the soil. This maintained much lower soil salinities than experimentally cleared patches, decreasing evaporation and therefore salt
56
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
accumulation (Hacker and Bertness 1995, 1999). At higher elevations in the marsh Bertness and Hacker (1994) and Bertness and Yeh (1994) found that shade provided by the shrub Iva frutescens also decreased soil salinity and facilitated the growth and survival of Juncus gerardi.
2.5. NUTRIENTS The development of vegetation is a fundamental driver of soil development, and it is clear that shrubs and trees alter the characteristics of the soil microhabitat in ways that favor some species over others. As stated by Ovington in 1955, “Trees are the dominants of the community, and by virtue of their size and longevity they are able to determine to some extent the site conditions under which the associated plants and animals live. Under different tree stands distinct woodland environments exist. Whilst the trees cannot alter primary site factors such as bedrock or topography, they may modify some secondary factors. Nutrients are removed from the soil and are returned in part as litter fall so that the tree’s influence those soil processes which affect the physical and chemical condition of the soil. A closed tree canopy forms an effective barrier and the climate beneath the canopy is vastly different than that above. The floristic composition and luxuriance and ground vegetation in woodlands are largely dependent on secondary site conditions such as these…”
Whilst trees may tilt the competitive playing field towards certain understory species by creating a ‘vastly different’ climate, Ovington also noted that deeply rooted perennials take up nutrients that are unavailable to more shallowly rooted understory plants and deposit them on the soil surface via litterfall and throughfall. Understory plants may eventually acquire these nutrients after the litterfall from the overstory decays. The importance of this process for species that are adapted to life in the understory may be accentuated because shadegrown or shade-adapted plants typically allocate proportionally less biomass to roots and have lower root:shoot ratios than sun-grown plants (Bellingham et al. 2001). Root symbionts such as nitrogen-fixing bacteria or mycorrhizae may also contribute to the concentration of nitrogen and phosphorus around understory plants. Organic matter deposited through litterfall provides energy to these microbes and also stimulate decomposition and mineralization rates in the understory (facilitative interactions mediated by soil microbial communities are discussed in Chapter 3). Other mechanisms by which plants may enhance
Chapter 2
57
nutrient availability for other plants include trapping of airborne particles by foliage and eventual deposition at the base of the plant, and the indirect effects of nitrogen fixation. The effects of tree canopies on nutrient availability may be confounded by indirect interactions with animals because trees provide perches for birds and shady habitat for ungulates. Animals that are attracted to trees often spend disproportionally large amounts of time near them and defecate there more often than in open environments, transporting nutrients from the surrounding open, treeless areas to understory habitats (McNaughton 1983). As noted in another study of forest canopy effects on communities and ecosystems by Madgwick and Ovington (1959), nutrients in throughfall and litterfall greatly exceed those deposited by precipitation and dry deposition. Those nutrients that are retranslocated to a lesser degree such as calcium and potassium can be especially abundant under canopies (Callaway and Nadkarni 1991, Callaway et al. 1991). Leaf litter is generally the primary source of nutrients from canopies, but non-leaf litter may account for a relatively large amount of nutrient deposition; under Quercus douglasii canopies in central California approximately 15-35% of nutrient deposition is in twigs, bark, flowers, and acorns. For some tree species, throughfall (precipitation coming directly through the canopy) nutrient deposition can equal litter as a nutrient source. Hart and Parent (1972) found that concentrations of sodium, calcium, magnesium, potassium, phosphorus, and nitrate were 3-16 times higher under the canopies of Pseudotsuga menziesii and Juniperus scopulorum than in the open and thought that canopy enrichment of precipitation was a major source of ecosystem resources. Stemflow may be an even richer supply of resources to the understory. Voight (1960) compared throughfall to stemflow under Pinus resinosa, Tsuga canadensis, and Fagus grandifolia in the northeastern U.S. and found that nitrogen was over two times higher in stemflow than in throughfall. Other nutrients showed similar patterns. By altering nutrient cycles, canopy species provide habitat in which other plant species thrive. Throughfall can be chemically complex, and therefore is not simply a source of nutrients, but can also affect basic soil characteristics. In what may be the most dramatic quantified example of a species’ effect on its soil, Amiotti et al. (2000) found that the influence of Pinus radiata, an invasive in the study area in Argentina, “triggered changes in the evolutionary trends of the soils of such magnitude as to be reflected at the highest taxonomic level in soil taxonomy”. Clear evidence of acid hydrolysis of primary silicates, decreasing values of pH, CA, and exchangeable Mg, and increasing values of exchangeable H and Al under the trees resulted in the soil next to the trunks of trees being classified as umbric rather than the mollic soils of the grassland matrix. High levels of nutrients in throughfall and litterfall, relative to the amounts deposited by precipitation in the open, are usually reflected as higher
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Nutrient concentration (mg/g)
58 10
a
"positive" trees "negative" trees OPEN
8 6
b
a a
4 c
b
2 0
c
a a
a a a
a b c NITROGEN PHOSPHORUS POTASSIUM CALCIUM
MAGNESIUM
Figure 2.11. Total nitrogen and phosphorus and exchangeable potassium, calcium, and magnesium under Quercus douglasii and in the open in woodland, and savanna soils. Shared letters within sites and nutrients designate means that were not significantly different. “Positive” and “negative” trees refer to overall effects on understory productivity and are discussed in Chapter 4. Reprinted from Callaway et al. (1991) with permission from Ecology.
nutrient concentrations in understory soils than in open soils. But understoryopen soil differences tend to be less dramatic than throughfall and litterfall versus open deposition differences. For example, the total annual deposition of nitrogen and phosphorus in the throughfall and litterfall of Quercus douglasii was 5-10 times that of precipitation in the open grassland between the trees, yet total soil phosphorus and nitrogen were only 15-60%, and 2-3 times greater, respectively, in the subcanopy soils (Figure 2.11; Callaway and Nadkarni 1991, Callaway et al. 1991). Most documented cases of soil enrichment by perennial canopies are from semi-arid environments where there are clear boundaries between canopy and shrub patches (see review by Scholes and Archer 1997). In these cases the differences in physical soil characteristics and soil nutrients between subcanopy and open microhabitats are often substantial and litter deposition consistently develops higher organic matter contents in subcanopy soils than open soils (Vetaas 1992). For example, Belsky et al. (1989) measured levels of total phosphorus, calcium, and potassium roughly two times higher under Acacia trees than in the open in African savannas. High nutrient concentrations under Acacia canopies were correlated with high herbaceous productivity. Soil nitrogen concentrations were also higher under Sericocomoosis pallida shrubs in other Kenyan savannas (Georgiadis 1989). As for Acacias, understory productivity
Chapter 2
59
was much higher under S. pallida canopies and a common understory grass grew larger in subcanopy soil than in open soil. In addition to these examples, nutrient enrichment, relative to open areas, has been found under trees and shrubs in African savannas (Radevanoki and Wickens 1967, Dancette and Poulain 1969, Weltzin and Coughenhour 1990, Belsky 1994), Asian savannas (Singh and Lal 1969, Tupas and Sajise 1977), evergreen and deciduous mediterranean-climate savannas and woodlands (Jackson et al. 1990), deserts (Went 1942, GarciaMoya and McKell 1970, Charley and West 1975, Halvorson and Patten 1975, Hazlett and Hoffman 1975, Patten 1978, Whittaker et al. 1979, Schmida and Whittaker 1981, Mott and McComb 1974, Aggarwal et al. 1976), grasslands (Tiedemann and Klemmedson 1973, 1977, Barth and Klemmedson 1978, Yavitt and Smith 1988), alder shrublands (Goldman 1961), Patagonian shrublands (Rostagno et al. 1991), dune systems (Yarranton and Morrison 1974), and open Pinus contorta (lodgepole pine) stands (Zincke 1962). These positive effects are often associated with enhanced understory productivity or shifts in community composition, but by no means is facilitation the only interactive outcome produced by tree canopies. The competitive effects of overstory trees may be as strong as or stronger than their facilitative effects (Scholes and Archer 1997). Bastow Wilson (1989) demonstrated a unique positive interaction between the grasses Deschampsia flexuosa and Festuca ovina involving nitrogen. Deschampsia naturally grows in nitrogen-poor habitats and nitrogen-rich conditions in greenhouse actually reduce its growth. However, when grown with Festuca in high nitrogen conditions Deschampsia biomass increased relative to when it was grown alone in high nitrogen. Wilson presumed that this was due to the uptake of nitrogen by Festuca which established nitrogen levels more suitable for Deschampsia. Whether or not this would occur at nitrogen levels found in the field is unknown.
2.5.1. Climate and variation in canopy effects on soil fertility The positive effects of canopies on soil fertility in such a broad range of ecosystems supports the generality of this type of facilitation, but the relative influence of tree canopies on soil fertility varies with climate. Scholes (1990) developed a conceptual model for the general interactive effects of soil fertility and annual rainfall on herbaceous productivity in South African savannas (Figure 2.12). This effect of soil fertility on rainfall-productivity relationships has important implications for predicting the relative intensity of tree canopies on soil nutrients and understanding the balance of competitive and facilitative mechanisms in communities in general (see Chapter 4). Scholes argued that the effect of rainfall on herbaceous productivity depends on soil fertility, with fertile
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation -1
Herbaceous productivity (kg ha )
60 6000
5000
4000
3000 A
2000
B 1000
0 0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
-1
Annual rainfall (mm yr ) Figure 2.12. Relationship between above-ground annual herbaceous productivity and annual rainfall. Lines with large dashes represent upper and lower limits of the general relationship between rainfall and productivity in semiarid regions (Rutherford 1980). The line labeled “A” represents the relationship found on a fertile soil soils, “B” on infertile soils. Note the more rapidly increasing herbaceous productivity on fertile soils. Redrawn from Scholes (1990) with permission from Journal of Biogeography.
sites hypothesized to increase rapidly in productivity and infertile sites to increase slowly in productivity with increasing rainfall. This relationship between moisture and soil fertility suggests that positive canopy effects on soil nutrients should have stronger effects on understory productivity in mesic climates; at least until canopy density limits light (Holmgren et al. 1997), than in xeric climates where moisture may constrain the potential benefits of soil nutrients. There are not many studies that have addressed this issue directly, but several have quantified production or density of the plants under canopies versus in the open in different years or sites with different amounts of rainfall. A second conceptual model was suggested by Garner and Steinberger (1989) who proposing that “fertile islands” (see Cross and Schlesinger 1999, Stock 1999) are prominent around woody perennials in deserts because “concentrating biological mechanisms” such as water transport and biological deposition rates are more important in arid climates than “dispersive physical mechanisms” such as soil water diffusion, leaching, atmospheric washout, and gaseous diffusion, which predominate in mesic environments (Figure 2.13).
Transport rate, distance/time
Chapter 2
61 dispersion mechanisms dominate physical transport concentration mechanisms dominate biological transport
Relative moisture Figure 2.13. Relationship between relative moisture availability and the transport rate of nutrients in soils. Redrawn from Garner and Steinberger (1989) with permission from the Journal of Arid Environments.
McClaran and Bartolome (1989) quantified productivity under canopies of Quercus douglasii versus in the open in different years and sites with different amounts of rainfall. They found that the effect of canopies on understory productivity (relative to open grassland) varied by about 50% in five sites over two years, and along a rainfall gradient ranging from 40 to 90 cm yr-1. Unlike results reported by others (Holland and Morton 1980, Callaway et al. 1991, Ratliff et al. 1991, Connor and Willoughby 1997), who showed that Q. douglasii increased subcanopy productivity, Q. douglasii canopy effects were primarily neutral at more xeric sites and negative at mesic sites in both years. However, reanalyzing McClaran and Bartolome’s results indicates that productivity in the fertile soil under the canopies increased ≈45% in an aboveaverage rainfall year; whereas, in the open productivity increased only ≈25%. Although the comparative fertility of the different sites is not known, these patterns and what is known about the fertilizing effect of Q. douglasii on soils support Scholes’ general hypothesis. A reanalysis of my data (Callaway et al. 1991) and unpublished data (R.M. Callaway) also supports Scholes’ hypothesis. Understory productivity and total soil nitrogen (0-10 cm) in the subcanopy soils was quantified for each of 12 “positive” (trees that showed a general facilitative effect) Quercus douglasii trees in central California. Productivity was measured
62
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Percent difference in producitivity (1987/1988)
30
25
20
15
10
5 6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Total soil nitrogen (mg/g soil) Figure 2.14. Relationship between total soil nitrogen beneath Quercus douglasii trees in a central California savanna and the difference in the proportional effect of Q. douglasii on understory productivity in a wet year (1987) and a dry year (1988). R2 = 0.61, P<0.05. Percent difference = ([(subcanopy-open)/open in 1987] – [(subcanopy-open)/open in 1988]) * 100.
in a wet year (1987) and a dry year (1988), and soil nitrogen was measured in 1987. Understory productivity for each tree in each year was calibrated with the productivity in the surrounding open savanna or patches of grassland within woodland. Understory productivity was approximately 2.5 to 5.0 times greater than open productivity under these trees. Quercus douglasii trees with higher soil nitrogen showed the highest productivity response to increased rainfall (Figure 2.14). For example, the facilitative effect of trees with soil nitrogen contents of 67 mg/g soil only increased ≈10% in the wetter year, whereas trees with 11-12 mg/g soil increased their facilitative effect by 20-30%. Research by Tielborger and Kadmon (1997) shows an opposite relationship between canopy effect and annual precipitation. Their work in the Negev desert showed that the mean density of annual plants under various shrubs was higher than in the open in wet years, but lower in dry years (see Chapter 4). As in McClaran and Bartolome’s study, soil fertility was not measured, but since many other researchers have found that desert shrubs create “resource islands” the subcanopy was probably a much more nutrient-rich microhabitat than the intershrub spaces.
Chapter 2
63
Conflicts between studies that support Scholes’ hypothesis and those that do not may be due to synergistic interactions between soil conditions and the facilitative effects of nutrients that can produce conditional results. Virginia and Jarrell (1983) found that nitrogen accumulation under Prosopis glandulosa canopies was always higher than in open grassland, but the improvement was much greater where Prosopis was utilizing ground water and where surface soils had high clay contents. Virginia (1986) also found that the mount of nutrient accumulation under Prosopis glandulosa and Dalea spinosa trees was positively correlated with estimated water availability at particular sites.
2.5.2. Experimental approaches to canopy effects on soil fertility There have been few large-scale removal experiments conducted to test litterand throughfall- enrichment of soil nutrients versus other mechanisms. However, in one of these Kay (1987) removed all Q. douglasii from areas by either cutting, or cutting and applying herbicide. Prior to these treatments, herbaceous productivity under oak canopies tended to be less than productivity in open grassland (as for the ‘negative’ trees of Callaway et al. 1991). However, after the trees were killed, herbaceous productivity did not simply increase to equal that of open grassland, instead ex-understory productivity exceeded that of open grassland for 12 of the next 14 years (Figure 2.15).
Productivity (10's of pounds per acre)
350 NS
300 NS
250 200
NS NS NS
NS
150 NS 100 50 0
live trees open grassland trees cut & herbicide 1967
1972
1977
1982
Date Figure 2.15. Annual productivity of open grassland, under live Quercus douglasii, and where Q. douglasii had been cut and herbicided. All points not labeled with “NS” showed significant differences between the cut-herbicide treatment and the live trees. Drawn from data presented in Kay (1987).
64
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Only after 15 years did the residual effect of the trees on herbaceous productivity disappear. While not specifically demonstrating nutrients as the mechanism, these results indicate that Q. douglasii trees modified soils in ways that lasted for years after the removal of the tree itself, and that these effects eventually went away. Thirteen years after cutting Prosopis juliflora trees, the subcanopy-open difference in soil organic carbon decreased from 3.0x to 1.6x and total nitrogen from 2.8x to 1.9x (Tiedemann and Klemmedson 1986), also illustrating the impermanent nature of plant-driven soil enrichment. Experiments with soils and bioassays from this same system provide a more ecologically relevant picture of long-term changes in soil enhancement. Klemmedson and Tiedemann (1986) grew two grass species, Digitaria californica (Arizona cottontop) and Hordeum vulgare (barley) in soils collected from under Prosopis canopies and in the open soil matrix, and also where Prosopis canopies had been removed 13 years prior to the study. Where Prosopis was intact the growth of Digitaria and Hordeum was 3.2x and 1.6x higher in subcanopy soil than in soil from the open spaces between the trees. In sites where Prosopis had been removed the effect of subcanopy soil on growth of Digitaria was much lower. The effects of Prosopis on understory fertility and plant growth existed 13 years after tree removal, but the effect was decreasing with time. In an innovative approach to exploring causal relationships between canopies and soil fertility, Kleb and Wilson (1997) moved understory soils from aspen forests to prairie habitats, and prairie soils to understory forest habitats, and then measured changes in soil characteristics. They found that the nitrogen-poor soils from the aspen stands increased in soil nitrogen concentration when they were moved to the prairie and that prairie soils decreased in nitrogen concentration when moved to aspen stands, indicating a strong biotic effect rather than simple microsite differences. Other experiments demonstrated similar effects of vegetation on soil moisture. When they transplanted cores from aspen forests to prairie, soil moisture in the cores was similar to that in prairie soils. Further evidence for trees and shrubs causing resource islands (versus preferentially establishing in them) comes from measurements of correlations between the age of the tree forming the canopy and soil characteristics beneath the tree. For example, Josè Facelli and Daniel Brock (2000) at the University of Adelaide in Australia found no differences in any soil characteristic between samples from under very young Acacia papyrocarpa trees and samples from open areas. However, organic matter, total and available phosphorus, total nitrogen, and soil salinity increased dramatically with the age of Acacia papyrocarpa until maturity, and then declined as the tree canopy senesced (see Figure 4.36, Chapter 4). Total nitrogen in the soil under trees declined precipitously after the death of trees. Organic matter and total and available phosphorus remained higher than that in the open grassland matrix soil for
Chapter 2
65
approximately 50 years after the death of the trees. Documentation of these tree age-soil relationships is one of the few studies confirming that the resource islands associated with the trees were actually caused by the trees, rather than the tree preferentially establishing in high resource patches. Interestingly, there were no differences in sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium, nutrients that typically accumulate through rainfall washing through the canopy. Only nutrients associated with organic matter deposition changed in availability with the influence of the tree, indicating that the accumulation of organic debris was probably the most important facilitative mechanism. The resource patches that developed under A. papyrocarpa facilitated many understory species, and some species were almost entirely restricted to A. papyrocarpa understories. Furthermore, Enchylaena tomentosa, an herbaceous species found almost exclusively under the canopies of A. papyrocarpa, established and grew significantly larger in soil collected under tree canopies than in soil from the open matrix. For some resources the degradation of the resource islands started with tree senescence rather than death, suggesting that the effects of tree canopies on soil chemistry may be more complex than simply the deposition of nutrients on the ground via throughfall and litterfall. Facelli and Brock hypothesized that the fragmented canopies of older senescing plants transmitted more sunlight, increasing soil temperatures and faster decomposition of organic matter as well as reducing deposition rates. Other experiments and field studies have shown that when vegetation develops on previously denuded or bare substrate, soil nutrients increase (see Bellingham et al. 2001), and others have shown that nutrient concentrations and organic carbon content increases with tree age or size (Barth 1980, BernhardReversat 1982). Also, nutrient accumulation over time in the presence of perennial woody plants has been demonstrated in microcosms by Silber and Raviv (1996). They measured increases in water-soluble phosphorus, calcium, and magnesium in volcanic tuff when roses were grown in the pots for two years. The effect of vegetation on nutrient availability and cycling is probably one of the most general and broad facilitative effects in natural systems. The modest experimental evidence for canopies causing “resource islands” calls for more research, but the correlations among canopies and increased soil fertile is so strong that other interpretations are unlikely. However, it is reasonable to expect that in particular systems trees or shrubs preferentially select unusually fertile sites or that animals defecate and urinate more under the canopies and eat more in the open.
66
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
2.5.3. Conditionality and canopy effects on soil fertility The relative importance of deep-rooted facilitators, through the deposition of litterfall and throughfall from their canopies, depends on the inherent soil fertility at a particular site. At fertile sites the effects of litterfall and throughfall are unlikely to make large differences, but at infertile sites the effect of canopies can be strong. For example, soils under junipers on infertile sand dune substrate showed 5-12 times higher concentrations of manganese, potassium, and organic carbon than open dune soils (Yarranton and Morrison 1974); whereas I found that in the relatively fertile soils of California oak woodlands canopy-open differences in nutrients typically range from <1.5 to 3 times (Callaway et al. 1991). Few studies have addressed the issue of canopy effects on soil nutrients over gradients of fertility (such as commonly addressed for other stress gradients, see Chapter 4), but in a study of arctic tundra, not a biome renowned for fertility, on Devon Island, Gold and Bliss (1995) reported that comparative differences in nutrient concentrations between fertile “resource islands” caused by cryptogams and the open spaces between them varied with larger scale environmental conditions. Jim Reynolds et al. (1999) addressed the issue of temporal conditionality of shrub effects on soil fertility by conducting a 3-year study in New Mexico using rainfall exclusion shelters to manipulate the effects of drought on the nutrient dynamics of resources islands associated with Larrea tridentata and Prosopis glandulosa. They found that concentrations of nitrate increased under shrubs exposed to fall drought, relative to that of controls, creating steeper gradients in resource availability between resource islands and open substrate. As mentioned in other places in this chapter, a number of other researchers have found that nitrogen-fixing Prosopis species have pronounced positive effects on soil fertility (Tiedemann and Klemmedson 1973, 1977, 1986, Virginia and Jarrell 1983). Parsons et al. (1994) measured the responses of Empetrum hermaphroditum, Vaccinium myrtillus, C. uliginosum, and V. vitis- idaea to increased temperature, nutrients, and water in the field. They found that all species responded significantly to warmer temperatures. Additionally they found that temperature and fertilization treatments together elicited strong and positive synergistic effects on plant growth. Their results suggest that some facilitative mechanisms may be poorly expressed if other limits to plant growth are not ameliorated. In the study of Parsons and colleagues, for example, the benefits of fertilization were not realized until low temperatures were ameliorated.
Chapter 2
67
2.5.4. Canopy facilitation of soil fertility in mesic habitats Canopy effects on soil nutrients in mesic forests are more difficult to observe and quantify than in savannas. However, many studies have reported strong correlations between particular canopy species and the soil nutrient characteristics beneath them (Lodhi 1977, Beatty 1984, Boettcher and Kalisz 1990, Dzwonko and Loster 1997, Finzi et al. 1998a,b, Lovett and Rueth 1999). Others have reported correlations among canopy and understory species, but as for many studies in savannas these studies do not separate canopy effects from the confounding effects of the physical environment (Lippmaa 1939, Whittaker 1951, 1956, Bratton 1975, McCune and Antos 1981, Austin 1985, Rheinhardt 1992, Fensham and Butler 2004). For example, Maguire and Forman (1983) sampled canopy-overstory species associations in an old-growth forest and argued that the distribution of understory herbaceous communities was affected by canopy foliage of the different species. The potential for different tree canopies to affect soil nutrients to affect understory communities is illustrated by research conducted by Diekman and Falkengren-Grerup (1998). They measured soil nitrogen mineralization rates for ammonium, nitrate, and total-N in incubation experiments for 661 plots in deciduous forests in southern Sweden. From these measurements they calculated a “functional N index” for understory species and found that community composition and species distributions were highly correlated with the index. It was not clear how specific overstory species correlate with patterns of the functional N index, but Diekman and Falkengren-Grerup’s results suggested that the canopy-specific patterns in nutrient deposition and accumulation described by others (Boettcher and Kalisz 1990, Finzi et al. 1998a,b, Lovett and Rueth 1999) affect the composition and productivity of understory communities. Different sampling approaches may exacerbate the problem of detecting facilitative canopy effects in complex mesic forests. For example, if plots are established randomly, as in classic community studies, fine-scale correlations among canopy and understory species may be obscured by variation both in the canopy layer and in the understory layer. If plots are scaled to the size of individual canopies the probability of detecting differences in species composition may be higher.
2.5.5. Canopy facilitation of available soil nutrients The majority of studies of spatial associations between perennial canopies and soil nutrient concentrations have focused on total nutrients, and available nutrients show similar, but more complex patterns. Parker and Muller (1982)
68
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
measured far higher levels of nitrate in soils under Quercus agrifolia than in open grassland soils (Figure 2.16), but similar concentrations of ammonium. These patterns in nitrate concentration correlated with plant distributions, with Bromus diandrus and Pholistima auritum dominating the understory, and Avena fatua dominating the open grassland. Others have shown that fertilized microsites favor Bromus diandrus over Avena (Jones 1963, Hull and Muller 1976), but Parker and Muller (1982) found that all three species showed similar increases in growth when grown in soils from under Quercus, and other experiments suggested that variation in light was more important for herbaceous spatial patterns than nitrogen. I found that ammonium and nitrogen were significantly higher at the beginning of the rainy season in central California under Quercus douglasii than in open grassland around the trees (Callaway et al. 1991). Later in the rainy season, after herbaceous species had matured, these patterns were less pronounced (Figure 2.17). Soil under trees with high densities of fine oak roots in the upper 50 cm (“negative trees”, see Chapter 4) showed sharp decreases in nitrate in March, when fine oak roots undergo a flush of growth. 80
Grassland soil Oak subcanopy soil
Nitrate (ppm)
60
40
20
0 October December January February March
May
Figure 2.16. Nitrate in soil beneath Quercus agrifolia canopies and in the open grassland around the trees. Error bars show 95% CI. Reprinted from Parker and Muller (1982) with permission from the American Midland Naturalist.
Chapter 2
69
30
30
Savanna
Savanna
25
25 "Positive" trees "Negative" trees Open grassland
20
20
15 10 5
a
c
b b
Woodland 25 a a a
15
10 b
a
b
b
5
b
10 c
b
5
March 1988
Woodland
a
25 20
a
15
b
10 b b
November January 1987 1988
b
0 30
b
0
a
15 b
0 30
20
a a
Nitrate (ug/g soil)
Ammonium (ug/g soil)
a
a
a
b b
a a b
5 0
November January 1987 1988
March 1988
Figure 2.17. Ammonium and nitrate in soils in woodland and savanna habitats under “positive” and “negative” Quercus douglasii trees (see Chapter 4). Error bars show 2 SE, and different letters within a date denote significant differences (Tukey, P<0.01). Redrawn from Callaway et al. (1991) with permission from Ecology.
2.5.6. Litter type, mixtures, and canopy facilitation The type of litter a tree produces can cause widely varying effects. In general, persistent tree litter, that which does not decompose rapidly, tends to reduce the growth of understory species (Sydes and Grime 1981). In field experiments using litter from four deciduous canopy species from British forests, Acer psuedoplatanus, Fagus sylvatica, Fraxinus excelsior, and Sorbus aucuparia, Barret (1931) found that the grasses Poa trivialis and Holcus mollis were strongly inhibited by persistent litter from certain species, and high amounts of litter per ground surface area. In contrast, Endymion non-scriptus and Viola
70
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
riviniana were unaffected by litter source or quantity, and a fifth species, Galeobdolon luteum, slightly benefited from persistent litter. Field distributions of these species fit these results with Poa occurring only in relatively litter-free sites and Endymion and Galeobdolon occupying sites with heavy litter. The litter of Fagus, which was the most persistent of all species, had stronger effects than those of plastic litter treatments, which of course was even more long-lasting. This result suggests that leaf chemistry had effects in addition to leaf persistence. Monk and Gabrielson (1985) experimented with litter from the floor of different deciduous species in South Carolina in the field and found that litter generally improved the overall productivity in understory plots, but the effects of litter on individual species ranged from facilitation to interference. They attributed these effects primarily to leaf chemistry. Facelli and Pickett (1991) found that white oak (Quercus alba) leaf litter indirectly facilitated the growth of seedlings of Ailanthus altissima by suppressing herbs that competed with Ailanthus. Litter may also provide “safe sites” for seed germination and recruitment (Enright and Lamont 1989, see Chapter 3). The effects of leaf litter from a species can be altered by the way that litter decomposes in mixtures of litter from other species. Nutrient release from leaves of species that decay rapidly can stimulate the decomposition of more recalcitrant leaves (Seastedt 1984) resulting in enhanced nutrient release, increased litter decay rates, and increased respiration rates (Carlyle and Malcolm 1986, Chapman et al. 1988, Ineson and McTiernan 1992). In contrast, some mixtures result in decreased respiration rates, suggesting that they decay more slowly. Briones and Ineson (1996) compared the decomposition rates, respiration, nitrogen release, and acidity of leachates of Eucalyptus globulus leaf litter alone, to rates when combined with Quercus petraea, Fraxinus excelsior, or Betula pendula litter. They found that mixing Eucalyptus leaf litter with Quercus litter resulted in substantially enhanced total respiration from the litter and weaker enhancements with Fraxinus and Betula litter. Quercus and Betula litter greatly reduced ammonium release from Eucalyptus litter, Fraxinus litter enhanced ammonium release from Eucalyptus litter, and surprisingly, adding Eucalyptus litter almost doubled the ammonium release from Fraxinus litter (Figure 2.18). Although Eucalyptus is not naturally associated with the other three species, such complex effects of different litter types on each other, and the associated microbes, have the potential to maintain high community productivity, synchronize nutrient release and plant uptake (Briones and Ineson 1996), and generate unusual positive interactions.
Chapter 2
71
NH4 release rate (µg N g-1)
400
Eucalyptus litter Expected values of mixture Fraxinus liter Eucalyptus, Fraxinus mixture
300
200
100
0 1
3
5
7
9
11
13
Weeks Figure 2.18. Ammonium release (μNH4-N g-1) over two weeks from microcosms containing ‘pure’ litter and (a) eucalyptus litter mixed with litter from oak, ash or birch. Pure eucalyptus litter is shown as a solid circle, the pure litter from the focal tree species in each panel (e.g. oak, ash, birch) is represented with an open circle, the expected additive value is shown as an open square, and the observed value for the mixture is shown as a open diamond. Error bars are 1 SE. Reprinted from Briones and Ineson (1996) with permission from Soil Biology and Biogeochemistry.
The effects of litter from the same species can range from suppression to facilitation. I found that fresh leaves of blue oak strongly suppressed the growth of an understory grass species, whereas blue oak litter that dropped naturally at the end of the growing season facilitated grass growth (Callaway et al. 1991). Sydes and Grime (1981) found that Fagus sylvatica litter collected at different times or applied in different amounts elicited contrasting and highly variable results.
2.5.7. Experimental studies of facilitation by canopies on soil Other studies on the positive effects of canopies via nutrients have used soil collected from under different species in comparisons of plant performance. Turner et al. (1966) found that saguaro seedlings in field garden tests survived best on soil collected from under Cercidium microphyllum than on soils from under either Prosopis juliflora or Olneya tesota, but the potential effect of soil
72
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
nutrients was confounded by soil albedo and temperature. In another Sonoran desert site, soils under C. microphyllum were almost 3 times higher in total nitrogen than soils collected from the open matrix (Franco and Nobel 1989). As noted above, surface soils under the canopies of Quercus douglasii are much more nutrient rich than surrounding open grassland (Holland 1980, Callaway et al. 1991, Dahlgren 1997) and in greenhouse experiments understory soils improved the growth of Bromus diandrus, an understory species, when compared to open grassland soils. When Q. douglasii litter was added to open grassland soil the growth of B. diandrus also improved (Callaway 1991). Walker et al. (1986) used greenhouse experiments to demonstrate the facilitative effects of nitrogenrich soil from under Alnus tenuifolia on Salix alaxensis and Populus balsamifera seedlings and found that these effects were due to litter-mediated increases in growth or nutrient uptake. Prosopis cineraria (khejri) is a dominant tree on alluvial and sandy plains of the Thar Desert near Johdpur, India. Farmers keep Prosopis on their fields because their crops grow better under the trees than in the open fields. Aggarwal et al. (1993) found that soil nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium were higher under Prosopis canopies than in open fields, and that the biomass of Penesetum typhoides was three times higher when grown in Prosopis soil than in open soil. Adding nutrients reduced these differences, but Penesetum grown in Prosopis soils was always at least two times larger than when grown in open soils regardless of the nutrient additions, suggesting a possible microbial effect. Soil nutrients are also higher under canopies of Eucalyptus xanthoclada and E. drepanophyllla in northeastern Australia (Jackson and Ash 2001). These canopies were also associated with higher pasture productivity. Native Australian grasses produced 42% more biomass when grown in pots containing soil from under canopies than when grown in soils from the open inter-canopy matrix. Not all experiments examining the effects of canopy-enriched soils on the performance of understory species demonstrate facilitation. Total nitrogen, phosphorus, and soil moisture in the soil under Sophora trees is much higher than in various other microhabitats on the island of Hawaii (Walker and Powell 1999); however, juvenile Argyroxiphum sandwicense (silversword) had lower relative growth rates under these canopies than in more nutrient- and moisture poor microhabitats. They observed that dense swards of grasses developed under Sophora canopies and hypothesized that poor Argyroxiphum regeneration was due to indirect effects (see Chapter 3), with Sophora facilitating grasses and then the grasses out competing Argyroxiphum.
Chapter 2
73
2.5.8. Nitrogen fixation and nutrient facilitation Facilitative canopy effects on soil nutrient pools and fluxes have been shown for many different types of trees and shrubs, but as suggested in examples above, nitrogen-fixers can have particularly strong effects on their microhabitats and the species associated with them (Bellingham et al. 2001). For example, field plots with Lupinus perennis, a common perennial in North American grasslands, have 32% higher plant N concentrations and 26% higher total plant N pools than plots without Lupinus (Lee et al. 2003). Leaf nitrogen concentration of cooccurring non-fixing plants increased 22% and mass-based net photosynthetic rates increased 41% in plots containing Lupinus compared to those without Lupinus. After glacial retreat in southeastern Alaska, bare sands and gravels contain about 30 kg/ha of total nitrogen (Lawrence et al. 1967). After 25 years of occupation by Dryas drummondii, a nitrogen-fixing early colonizer, soil nitrogen averages 95 kg/ha, and by the time Dryas begins to disappear from the system soil nitrogen averages 400 kg/ha. In the alpine vegetation of the southern Rocky Mountains, Trifolium nitrogen-fixers are estimated to contribute 0.5 mg N m-2 year-1 to the nitrogen budget, which is substantial considering that estimates of the total mineralized N in these systems is 1.2 mg N m-2 year-1 (Bowman et al. 1996). Høgh-Jensen and Schjoerring (1997) measured seasonal variation in nitrogen fixation, nitrogen transfer from the nitrogen-fixing Trifolium repens to the non-fixer Lolium perenne, and soil nitrogen absorption in the field over three years in different mixtures of the species. They found that only small amounts of fixed nitrogen were transferred to Lolium in the first year, whereas in the second and third years of the experiment up to 21 kg ha-1 was transferred. Transfer accounted for 3%, 16%, and 31% of Lolium’s annual nitrogen budget, in the three years of the experiment, respectively. More importantly, Trifolium-Lolium mixtures absorbed much higher amounts of soil-derived nitrogen than the pure stands of either species (Figure 2.19). They concluded that positive interactions between Trifolium and Lolium produced a more efficient fixation of atmospheric nitrogen and absorption of nitrogen from the soil than occurred when the species were grown alone. The fact that mixtures enhanced soil nitrogen uptake is unusual, and was probably due to the positive effect of Trifolium-fixed nitrogen on Lolium growth and biomass, and then an increase in uptake of soil-derived nitrogen by Lolium.
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
A
80 60 40 20 0 -20
B
80 60 40 20 0
22 July, '96
14 June, '96
2 Oct, '95
3 July, '95
1 June, '95
2 Oct, '94
27 June, '94
-20
16 May, '94
Proportion of nitrogen derived from atmosphere (%)
74
Figure 2.19. Proportion of atmospherically derived nitrogen in shoots of Lolium perenne in mixtures with Trifolium repens under A) three different fertilizer regimes (solid triangle=24 kg ha-1, open triangle=48 kg ha-1, solid circle=72 kg ha-1); and B) three different species ratios (upside down open triangle=1Trifiolium with 20 Lolium, open square=6:20, and upright open triangle=12:20) with fertilizer added at 3 kg ha-1yr-1. Error bars are 1 SE. Reprinted from Høgh-Jensen and Schjoerring (1997) with permission from Plant and Soil.
Although a nitrogen fixer, Lupinus arboreus is an exceptionally poor facilitator for Quercus agrifolia seedlings, the poorest of four different shrub species tested experimentally (Callaway and D’Antonio 1991). This may be because the strongest effects of L. arboreus occur after the plant dies, due primarily to the fact that lupine canopies reduce available light from 1725 μmol m-2 sec-1 to 13 μmol m-2 sec-1 (Maron and Jefferies 1999). Canopies of dead lupine transmit 370 μmol m-2 sec-1. Repeated cycles of lupine encroachment and dieback in coastal prairie appear to double total soil nitrogen and lead to a largescale shift in community composition from native perennials to exotic annuals, which appear to be strongly facilitated by increased nitrogen accumulation. A very similar dynamic process occurs during primary succession on the volcanic soils of Mount St. Helens. Lupinus lepidus, an early colonizing nitrogen-fixer, increases soil nitrogen and facilitates colonization of other species
Chapter 2
75
in the nutrient-poor soils; however clear facilitative effects are only evident after the death of the lupine (Wood and del Moral 1987, Morris and Wood 1989, Wood and Morris 1990, del Moral 1993a,b). This pattern is found yet again on volcanic substrate in Hawaii where the introduced nitrogen-fixing tree Myrica faya enriches the otherwise nitrogen poor soil (Vitousek et al. 1987). Living Myrica trees appear to suppress virtually all understory species, including nonnative grasses. However, when Myrica trees are removed, other exotic species increase in abundance in the patches formerly occupied by Myrica (Aplet et al. 2001). Adler et al. (1998) studied the recruitment of native and non-native species into the nutrient-rich patches remaining after an outbreak of an introduced leafhopper, Sophonia rufofascia, killed large number of Myrica. The cover of non-native grasses increased 2.3 to 14.1% (depending on the species) more under dead Myrica than under live Myrica, and native shrubs and herbs increased 4.8 to 15.2%. As for subalpine lupines in Oregon and coastal lupines in California, these results suggest that nitrogen-fixing plants may leave a stronger facilitative legacy in the soil after their death than they create while they are living. Non-nitrogen-fixing species are positively associated with the nitrogenfixer Hedysarum boreale on alpine glacial moraines in the Canadian Rockies (Blundon et al. 1983, Dale et al. 1991). Similarly, in the central Rockies, nitrogen-fixing alpine Trifolium dasyphyllum adds large amounts of nitrogen to the soil, driving a doubling in total productivity compared to Trifolium-free patches (Thomas and Bowman 1998). However, this increase in productivity is mostly due to increases in abundance of T. dasyphyllum and both facilitative and competitive effects of Trifolium were observed. Forb species increased 44% in foliar nitrogen concentration and tripled in biomass (Figure 2.20). Graminoid species, however, only showed a 9% increase in foliar nitrogen concentration and their abundance was much lower in the presence of Trifolium. Species-specific spatial relationships with Trifolium patches were highly variable with 5 species showing significant positive associations, 4 species showing significant avoidance and 7 species showing no significant preference. Similar studies of interactions between Trifolium repens and Lolium perenne show that Trifolium enhances the growth of Lolium under some conditions, and that the magnitude of the positive effect declines with increasing soil fertility (Wright 1981, Weiner 1985, Menchaca and Connolly 1990).
76
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
in Trifolium patch away from Trifolium patch
Foliar N (%)
2
1
0
Graminoids
Forbs
Figure 2.20. Foliar nitrogen concentrations of graminoids and forbs with patches of Trifolium dasyphyllum and in surrounding tundra without Trifolium. Error bars are 1 SE. Redrawn from Thomas and Bowman (1998) with permission from Oecologia.
In Hawaii, Walker and Vitousek (1991) used a combination of greenhouse and field experiments to examine the relative importance of different mechanisms by which the invasive Myrica faya affected the regeneration and growth of the native tree, Metrosideros polymorpha. The nitrogen-fixing Myrica caused large increases in available nitrogen in this nitrogen-limited system, and nitrogen fixed by Myrica is used by other plant species (Vitousek et al. 1987, Vitousek and Walker 1989). Nitrogen-rich soils and shade under Myrica improved Metrosideros seedling growth, germination, and survival, but the overwhelming effects of root competition created a strong net negative effect. The grasslands of the “Flooding Pampas” in central Argentina have been invaded by exotic nitrogen-fixing legumes, along with a large number of other non-native dicots (Quinos et al. 1998). The native grass, Paspalum dilatatum, was subjected to interactions with a suite of exotic non-nitrogen-fixing dicots, the exotic nitrogen-fixing Lotus tenuis, or no competitors in a fully factorial arrangement. The effects of the non-nitrogen-fixing dicots were weakly competitive, but not significant for any variable; however, the effects of Lotus on the nitrogen in the soil and tiller survival of Paspalum were positive across both dicot treatments (Figure 2.21).
Chapter 2
77
Dead tillers
Number of live tillers per plant
50
A
**
40 + dicots - Lotus - dicots - Lotus + dicots + Lotus - dicots + Lotus
30
*
20 10 0 -10
B 0 days Spring
17 days 55 days End of spring Summer
***
104 days Autumn
Figure 2.21. A) Tiller survival and B) mortality for plants of Paspalum dilatatum in treatments with and without dicot neighbors removed, and with and without Lotus tenuis neighbors removed. Asterisks represent significance of positive Lotus effect. Redrawn from Quinos et al. (1998) with permission from Oecologia.
2.5.9. Canopy interception of nutrients Throughfall effects described above are generally attributed to leaching from leaves, but canopies also filter and capture atmospheric nutrients, and these processes can contribute large amounts of nutrients to the understory (Art et al. 1974, Schlesinger and Reiners 1974, Lovett et al. 1982). Martin Kellman (1986) estimated that canopy filtration of atmospheric nutrients provided 8.1% of the K, 37.9% of the Mg, 9.6% of the Ca, 17.4% of the Na, and 24% of the P in the bulk influx of nutrients to an unthinned stand of Pinus caribbaea. The contribution of canopy-filtration to nutrient budgets may be exceptionally important in tropical forests where rooting depths are shallow and nutrient capitals in soil are low compared to those in biomass (Kellman, 1989). Kellman (1979) found that the surface soils beneath five species of savanna trees in Belize were substantially higher in nutrients than the surrounding matrix of open savanna, and some cases exceeded that in nearby rainforest soil. Excavations demonstrated that only one species of these savanna trees had deep roots, indicating that there was little translocation of nutrients from deep soils to the surface. Subcanopy soils did not have higher cation-exchange-capacities nor increased soil moisture retention (this ecosystem receives high levels of precipitation), indicating that canopy capture of nutrients and incorporation into a larger plant-litter nutrient cycle was probably the major source. These same savanna species are highly associated with the establishment of the seedlings of trees found only in the nearby rainforest
78
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
(Kellman and Miyanishi 1982, Kellman 1985). Kellman and Miyanishi (1982) argued that the creation of such nutrient-enriched microsites provide nuclei for repeated invasions of infertile savannas by rain-forest trees during Quaternary climate fluctuations. Because weathering at depth is not a significant nutrient source in intensely weathered soils, facilitation through capture of atmospheric nutrients and local sequestration may also be crucial to the development of soils with the nutrient content suitable for rainforest regeneration after burning or logging (Kellman 1989).
2.5.10. Interactions between nutrients and shade The effects of shade on the nitrogen cycle may interact with the direct effects of canopy shade on soil moisture and temperature. For example, decomposition rates of litter in the shade may decrease due to lower temperatures, or increase due to higher soil moisture content. Decomposition of tree litter is often slower than that of understory herbaceous litter (Vetaas 1992), and the return of nitrogen from understory herb decomposition to the soil is often faster than that of tree litter (Bernhard-Reversat 1982, Escudero et al. 1985). In these studies it was concluded that subcanopy nitrogen enrichment was due to processes that increased the productivity of understory grasses and those that altered nitrogen cycling. Thus, it is possible that the primary facilitative effects of shade on understory species composition, productivity and decomposition may also have important effects on nutrient cycles. These may in turn create positive effects on other species that are difficult to separate from the direct effects of canopy nutrient deposition. As described above, many researchers have measured higher levels of nutrients in soils directly beneath the canopies of perennials than in the surrounding open spaces. Other studies have described spatial associations between perennials with high-nutrient subcanopy soil and the productivity and species composition of understory herbs, and many studies have shown that litter from different canopy species has different effects on different understory species. However, few studies have attempted to isolate nutrient addition from other facilitative mechanisms such as canopy effects on soil moisture and temperature. Since the majority of correlations between enhanced subcanopy soil nutrients and herbaceous communities come from arid and semi-arid environments, confounding effects of shade on these correlations are quite likely. For example, the direct effects of shade provided by nurse shrubs and trees on young cacti are well documented (see above) and shade keeping the tissues of beneficiaries cooler is considered to be the primary mechanism by which facilitation occurs. However, Carrillo-Garcia et al. (2000a,b) conducted a field experiment in which they planted young Pachycereus pringlei (a giant columnar
Chapter 2
79
A
90
80
Shoot dry mass (g)
70
Resource island soil Bare area soil
4
3
2
1
0
3
2
1
11
D
10 9 8 7 6 5 4
0.2
0.1
F
35
Root length (mm)
E
0.3
Root:shoot ratio
B
4
0
C
Shoot dry matter (%)
Survival (%)
100
Plant dry mass (g)
cactus) in soils collected under Prosopis articulata, a common nurse associate, and in soils collected from open areas around the mesquite resource islands. They then placed replicates with both soil types in either 50% (the mean attenuation of light measured under Prosopis in the field) or 100% sunlight. Unlike other nurse plant studies of columnar cactus (Turner et al. 1966, 1969), they found that soil from under Prosopis had stronger positive effects on the survival and whole plant dry mass than reducing insolation (Figure 2.22). More importantly, they found strong interactions between soil and shade effects. In open soil, shade increased the final biomass of Pachycereus by 1.2 g, but in soil from beneath Prosopis shade increased the biomass of Pachycereus by 2.3 g. Interactions like this are observed frequently when researchers investigate more than one mechanism simultaneously, and emphasize the importance of considering synergistic processes when studying plant-plant interactions.
30 25 20 15 10 5
Half sun
Full sun
0
Half sun
Full sun
Shading
Figure 2.22. Shading and soil effects on survival and growth of seedlings of Pachycereus pringlei. Resource island soils are from under Prosopis articulata trees. All main effects are significant for each variable (shading and soil source) with the exception of survival (A) and root length (F). Redrawn from Carrillo-Garcia et al. (2000a) with permission from Plant and Soil.
80
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Like Carrillo et al. (2000a,b), Franco-Pizaña et al. (1995, 1996) conducted experiments in a greenhouse with soil collected under a Prosopis species, P. glandulosa, and found evidence for facilitative effects. There were many other species that were more abundant under P. glandulosa than in the open and this tree appears to play a crucial role in the establishment of many woody species in southern Texas, USA and the conversion of grassland to shrub savanna to contiguous thorn woodland (see Archer et al. 1988) Lars Walker et al. (2001) manipulated shade and the soil resources that develop under shrubs by removing their canopies in the Mojave Desert. Seven months after removing the canopies the ex-shrub understories still had significantly higher organic matter and total and mineralizable nitrogen than open soils, but soil water had decreased. Transplanted Ambrosia dumosa seedlings had the highest survivorship where shrubs had been removed and in the open treatment and lowest under living shrub canopies. They interpreted their results as demonstrating the overriding importance of root and shoot competition over the potential of nurse shrubs to facilitate other plants. This certainly was the case in their experiment, but A. dumosa rarely seems to behave as a beneficiary species (but see Miriti 2006) and therefore is not a good species from which to generalize. Others have shown that A. dumosa and other Ambrosia species are primary nurse species themselves for the seedlings of many other species in deserts and rarely occur under the canopies of other species (Franco and Nobel 1989, McAuliffe 1986, 1988, Holzapfel and Mahall 1999). Parker and Muller (1982) tested shade and soil nutrients as complementary mechanisms for the distinct differences in species distributions under Quercus agrifolia versus grassland in California. In field transplants, they found that Avena fatua, the dominant species in the open grassland, consistently outperformed the understory dominants in full sunlight, regardless of the soil conditions. For the two understory species, Bromus diandrus and Pholistma auritum, the effect of soil was greater than that of light, and these species performed better in soils from under the trees than soils from the open. Quercus douglasii (which benefits from the shade of shrubs when it is a seedling - see above) also has been shown to have important facilitative effects on the biomass of grass species in its understory and this appears to be due to soil nutrients (Callaway et al. 1991). The percent of full sunlight reaching the subcanopy floor beneath individual trees does not correlate with the facilitative effect of the tree on understory biomass, but the effect of trees on soil fertility is highly correlated with its facilitative effect. In greenhouse experiments Bromus diandrus, the dominant understory species, grew better in oak soil or with oak litterfall and throughfall than in open soil with ambient precipitation (Figure 2.23). In the
Chapter 2
81
field however, the manifestation of the positive effects of soil nutrients depended on the abundance of fine oak roots in shallow soil depths. In contrast to Callaway et al. (1991) and Parker and Muller (1982), Weltzin and McPherson (1999) found that nutrient enhancement in the understory of Quercus emoryi was not a mechanism driving higher survival and growth in the understory. Nitrogen and phosphorous concentrations were about 2 times greater under canopies than in grassland, but nutrient amendments did not improve conspecific seedling growth nor did reciprocal transplants of soil indicate that soil characteristics were important. Instead, providing artificial shade increased rates of seedling emergence and survival as much as 19 times and recruitment rates 30-60-fold. From these results they argued that shade from adult canopies provided a “self-enhancing feedback mechanism” (see Wilson and Agnew 1992) that stabilized the lower tree line and ecotone between oak woodlands and grasslands at their sites in southern Arizona. A similar disproportionate importance of shade was reported by Gómez-Aparicio et al. (2005d), who found that microclimatic amelioration due to canopy shading was much more important that nutrient addition in the facilitative effects of shrubs on tree seedlings in Spain, and this effect was particularly pronounced in drier conditions (see Chapter 4). 1.4
1.2 "positive" tree soil "negative' tree soil OPEN SOIL
Biomass (g)
1.2
1.0
a
"positive" tree litter & throughfall "negative' tree litter & throughfall OPEN THROUGHFALL
1.0
a
a
a
0.8
ab
a
0.8
b 0.6
0.6
a
ab c
b
c 0.4
0.4 0.2
0.2
0.0
WOODLAND
SAVANNA
0.0
WOODLAND
SAVANNA
Figure 2.23. Biomass of individual Bromus diandrus plants (a) grown in soil from under ‘positive’ Quercus douglasii trees, ‘negative’ trees (see above) or open grassland and (b) grown in soil from open grassland and watered with precipitation collected in the open, open soil with 0.25 g of ‘negative’ tree litter and watered with ‘negative’ tree throughfall, and open soil with 0.25 g of ‘positive’ tree litter and watered with ‘positive’ tree throughfall. Error bars are 2 SE, different letters represent significant differences among treatments. Reprinted from Callaway et al. (1991) with permission from Ecology.
82
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Walker et al. (1986) demonstrated that nitrogen-rich soil collected from under Alnus tenuifolia growing in riparian soils in central Alaska had positive effects on the biomass of Salix alaxensis and Populus balsamifera seedlings in greenhouse conditions. However, this facilitative mechanism was only weakly manifest in field experiments designed to compare the effects of shade and nutrients because of the strong effects of root interference. Similar positive effects of soils, but negative effects of canopies, were measured in an early successional, Salix-dominated community in the Cascade Mountains of the northwest United States (Jumpponen et al. 1998). There, soil developing beneath the Salix canopies had strong positive effects when removed from the influence of the canopies on shade. In Glacier Bay, Alaska, Chapin et al. (1994) found strong, facilitative effects of Alnus sinuata and Dryas drummondii, both nitrogenfixers, on the growth of Picea sitchensis. These effects came primarily from the inputs of organic matter and associated nitrogen. Naturally occurring and transplanted Picea seedlings had higher nitrogen and phosphorus uptake and tissue concentrations when with Alnus or Dryas, and the addition of Alnus litter enhanced the nutrient status of Picea seedlings. The relative effects of nutrient addition (versus shade or root competition) were much stronger than previously shown on floodplain soils (Walker et al. 1986), and the net effects were positive. This difference was attributed to the much lower N-availability after glacial retreat than after floodplain deposition, and therefore a greater potential for Alnus to facilitate later successional species by ameliorating a highly limiting resource.
2.5.11. Nutrients and conspecific facilitation Plants can modify their nutrient environment in ways that favor conspecifics (Wilson 1992). For example, Wedin and Tilman (1990) and Tilman and Wedin (1991a) found that when plots were planted with different species of perennial grasses the plots developed different levels of available soil nitrogen. Other experiments showed that the two species that produced the lowest nitrogen availability in their soils were the best competitors at low levels of soil nitrogen (Tilman 1991b), suggesting that these species may create soil nutrient conditions that favor conspecifics. Sphagnum bogs are a good example of how plants can “ecosystem engineer” nutrient conditions (Jones et al. 1994, 1997) in a way that favors conspecifics but inhibits other species. Ugolini and Mann (1979), Klinger (1990), and van Breeeman (1995) challenged the traditional bog-succession paradigm in which open water is colonized by Sphagnum and other mosses which ultimately creates habitat suitable for trees. They argued that forest floors are slowly invaded by Sphagnum, which gradually engineers an environment that
Chapter 2
83
is too acidic, anaerobic, and nutrient-poor for forest conifers. They marshaled evidence showing that Sphagnum inhibits conifer roots, Sphagnum increases in small-scale plots in forests over time, forest mortality increases as the area covered by Sphagnum bogs increases, and that Sphagnum detrital remains increase in substrate cores over time while forest detrital remains decrease. The process by which Sphagnum accomplishes this takeover is related to its unusual morphology which allows it to retain tremendous amounts of water proportional to its mass, and its chemical composition. Sphagnum is rich in phenolic chemicals, including a specific acid which only occurs in the genus. This acid appears to virtually eliminate decomposition and creates unusually low soil pH, which is why Sphagnum bogs are famous for preserving prehistoric human and animal remains. Low pH reduces the availability of phosphorus and other nutrients, primarily by decreasing microbial activity, and low phosphorus availability strongly favors Sphagnum (Wilson and Fitter 1984). Living Sphagnum is about 98% pore space due to the presence of hyaline cells and the way the successive generations of plants layer on top of each other. This pore space and the constantly accreting layers of dead Sphagnum store water, which creates highly anaerobic environments. Iron pans and organically clogged soils form under Sphagnum mats. These also contribute to the anaerobic conditions that Sphagnum prefers and that kill conifers. Sphagnum mats also have higher albedos than conifer-dominated vegetation which decreases absorption of solar energy and substrate temperature. Sphagnum species engineer low nutrient and other conditions that either have direct positive feedbacks to their own success and dominance or conditions that are inhibiting to competitors and indirectly facilitate their own success.
2.5.12. Nutrients and the chemical signature of neighbors The most apparent direct positive effect of trees on epiphytes is to provide access to light. However, species-specific spatial associations among host trees and epiphyte species have been interpreted as evidence for other kinds of facilitative effects such as host-specific canopy chemistry (Benzing 1981, Dejean et al. 1995, Kernan and Fowler 1995, Hietz and Briones 1998). Species-specific hostepiphyte relationships may be produced by differences in available nutrients in the throughfall washing through the canopies of different tree species and differences in the nutrient status of soil mats that accumulate in tree canopies. For example, Schlesinger and Marks (1977) demonstrated that the preference of Tillandsia usneoides, “Spanish moss”, for Taxodium distichum, Quercus spp., and Carya glabra and the avoidance of pines by Tillandsia, was correlated with the amount of calcium, potassium, and magnesium in the throughfall under these
84
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
trees in the field. In controlled experiments, they found that the foliage of Taxodium, the most common host for Tillandsia in the study area, released 4-20 times the levels of cations, total nitrogen, and total soluble phosphorus than the non-host species Pinus elliottii and Cinnamomum camphora. Lesica (1991) sampled nitrate, ammonium, and a large number of cations in the “soil mats” on different species of tropical forest trees in Costa Rica. They noted that the variation in nutrient content in the canopy varied much more that reported for surface soils in other tropical forests and argued that this variation could be an important mechanism for host-specificity among epiphyte species. In old-growth Picea abies forests in Norway the distribution of Usnea longissima, an epiphytic lichen, was correlated with the mineral composition of foliage (Gauslaa et al. 1998). Other studies have not found important effects of host chemistry on epiphytes. Steve Pennings and I investigated species-specific relationships among Tillandsia usneoides and Polypodium polypodioides epiphytes and 10 host tree species in a coastal plain forest in the southeastern U.S.A. (Callaway et al. 2002). Our results showed that throughfall nutrient content was correlated with the abundance of epiphytes, but experiments demonstrated that nutrient and chemical effects were relatively weak, and were secondary to water availability in determining overall patterns of host preference. In no case did Tillandsia perform better when watered with throughfall from the different host trees than when watered with rainfall collected in the open. In fact, Tillandsia tended to perform worse when watered with the throughfall of some species than when watered with rainfall, suggesting that allelopathic effects might have been more important than fertilization effects. In contrast to the airepiphyte Tillandsia, throughfall nutrients were marginally related to the host preference of the rooted epiphyte Polypoidium. Preferred hosts were “leakier” for 7 of the 11 nutrients we measured, and germination was ≈15% higher when watered with the throughfall of preferred hosts. The concentration of the highly toxic element cadmium was 3 times higher in leachates from the leaves of “bad” hosts than “good” hosts. However, the small positive effect of throughfall changed with life stage; there were no differences in the effects of throughfall from good versus bad hosts on mature Polypodium ramets. The most overlooked area for potentially paradigm-changing facilitative (and competitive) research may be understanding interactions among species with complementary root exudates. We know that plants exude a very large number of chemicals from their roots and that different plant species exude different chemical cocktails. These exudates are comprised of “a complex mixture of organic acid anions, phytosiderophores, sugars, vitamins, amino acids, purines, nucleosides, inorganic ions, gaseous molecules, enzymes and root border cells which have major direct or indirect effects on the acquisition
Chapter 2
85
of mineral nutrients required for plant growth” (Dakora and Phillips 2002). Many of these chemicals also detoxify compounds in the soil (Kochian et al. 2004). Since different species produce such strikingly different assortments of biochemicals, it is reasonable to hypothesize that some species may benefit by the presence of other species that release exudates that alter the environment in favorable ways. There is growing evidence for these sorts of interactions. Trees in the eastern deciduous forest appear to have species-specific effects (also see Chapter 5) on soil calcium due to the particular organic acids exuded from their roots. Dijkstra et al. (2001) measured organic acidity and its degree of neutralization in the forest floor under six North American tree species. They concluded that the “quantity, nature and degree of neutralization of organic acids differ among the different tree species.” Leaching with organic anions was greatest under Acer saccharum and Fraxinus americana where soils contained more exchangeable cations than did the acidified soil under Tsuga canadensis. Variation in organic acids leached from the roots of different species appeared to create species-specific differences in calcium availability (Dijkstra and Smits 2002, Dijkstra 2003). A good example of root exudate-mediated facilitation appears to occur with chemicals that are released for phosphorus acquisition. Plant roots release phosphatase to make organic P available, and roots release a bewildering array of different chelators that separate elements from inorganic P, a process that makes P available for root uptake. The effect of a chelating chemical depends on what element binds P in a particular soil. If a species does not exude a chelator that functions well in a certain soil type, it might benefit that species to grow next to a neighbor that does. Fusuo Zhang and Long Li (2003) of the China Agricultural University reviewed the processes involved in intercropping and found facilitation between different crop species that may have been related to shared effects of root exudates. Maize improved iron uptake for intercropped peanut plants, faba beans enhanced nitrogen and phosphorus uptake by intercropped maize, and chickpeas facilitated P uptake by associated wheat. In the last case, Zhang and Li hypothesized that P depletion in chickpea rhizospheres induced the release of substances that mobilize organic P. Centaurea diffusa, a highly invasive weed in the northwestern US, exudes an allelopathic compound from its roots called 8-hydroxyquinoline (8HQ, Vivanco et al. 2004). 8-HQ is an excellent chelator in volcanically derived soils increasing P availability by 2-3 times (T. DeLuca and R.M. Callaway, unpublished data). In earlier experiments on the allelopathic effect of C. diffusa Erik Aschehoug and I found that adding activated carbon as an adsorbant of organic molecules almost eliminated the uptake of labeled P by allelopathically tolerant European grass species (Callaway and Aschehoug 2000). While not
86
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
quite the appropriate experiment, these results suggest that European grass species might benefit substantially from the exudation of a chelator from C. diffusa neighbors. Such P facilitation might be more common than we realize. Li et al. (2003) found that total P uptake by Triticum aestivum (wheat) plants was 68% greater when its roots were allowed to mingle with the roots of Cicer arietinum (chickpea) and 37% greater when exudates were allowed to pass through a nylon mesh than when root and exudate were separated with a solid barrier. Cicer arietinum roots facilitated P utilization of T. aestivum. The potential for root-exudate mediated facilitation gets even more complicated and fascinating with recent evidence for cross talk among roots (Weir et al. 2006). They found that that Lupinus sericeus and Gaillardia grandiflora increase root exudation of organic acids in response to a phytotoxic compound released by the invader Centaurea maculosa. Oxalic acid reduces oxidative damage generated by the allelotoxins exuded by C. maculosa. Furthermore, native grasses are highly associated with Lupinus in communities invaded by C. maculosa (Figure 2.24) and field experiments show that Lupinus indirectly facilitates native grasses in Centaurea stands (Figure 2.25, also see Chapter 3). This facilitation is correlated with the presence of oxalic acid in the soil. Addition of exogenous oxalic acid to native grasses alleviated the allelopathic effects of catechin, indicating that root secreted oxalic acid may act as a chemical facilitator for plant species that do not produce the chemical. 20
Cover (%)
Lupinus in plot No Lupinus in plot 15
10
5
0
Pseudoroegneria
Festuca
Figure 2.24. Cover of native grasses in communities invaded by Centaurea maculosa in plots containing Lupinus sericeus and in plots without Lupinus. Error bars show 1 SE. Festuca cover and Pseudoroegneria cover is significantly different between treatments (t-test, P<0.05). Drawn from data reported in Weir et al. (2006) with permission from Planta.
Chapter 2
Biomass (g)
4
87
In Centaurea stand
Not in Centaurea stand
With Lupinus Without Lupinus
3
2
1
0
Pseudoroegneria Festuca
Pseudoroegneria Festuca
Figure 2.25. Biomass of native grasses experimentally transplanted next to Lupinus sericeus in communities invaded by C. maculosa and communities not invaded. In a two-way ANOVA for Pseudoroegneria, FCentaurea x Lupinus effect = 24.50, df =1,59, P<0.001. In a two-way ANOVA for Festuca, FCentaurea x Lupinus effect = 12.04, df =1,56, P<0.001. Reprinted from Weir et al. (2006) with permission from Planta.
In summary, there are many examples of plants facilitating other plants by improving nutrient availability. This is important because competition for nutrients is often seen as a fundamental determinant of community composition. If plants can facilitate each other by improving the availability of fundamental resources such as water and nutrients, the rules of interactive engagement that affect the composition of communities are based on much more complicated and fascinating processes than simple rates of uptake and utilization.
2.6. WIND Wind can damage plants by decreasing leaf and meristem temperatures, increasing vapor pressure differences between leaf and air, abrading tissue with particulates, or simply by battering leaves and branches against themselves and nearby objects (Wardle 1968, Marchand 1972, Marchand and Chabot 1978, Tranquillini 1980, Hadley and Smith 1983, 1986, 1989, Grace 1989, Arno and Hammerly 1990). Wind also increases soil erosion (Armbrust and Bilbro 1997). For example, they estimated that a canopy cover of only 4% reduced the transport capacity of a 16 m s-1 wind by
88
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
50%. High wind speeds can reduce the net carbon assimilation rates of alpine plants for one to two days after wind events are over (Hadley and Bliss 1964). In environments where wind is the limiting factor for growth and survival, plant species that do not adapt to the wind through mechanisms such as leaf area reduction, thickened cuticles, or stronger root bases must avoid wind by sheltering beneath or behind other plants or topographic structures (Osmond et al. 1987). The benefits of sheltering are illustrated by models describing the relationship between plant cover and the movement of air. These models demonstrate that plant cover is highly correlated with reduction in threshold wind velocity and transport capacity of wind. Clearly, plants can benefit from being protected from wind by other species. The effect of established plants on the movement of windblown particles is also addressed below in the section on disturbance. The effects of wind are also connected to the effects of temperature. For example, summer winds in the Rocky Mountains have been estimated to induce a 3-6oC cooling at the plant surface in fellfield communities (Bliss 1985). Tree “islands” or “ribbon forests” (described earlier in this chapter) often develop in windy subalpine areas, with seedling regeneration restricted to the leeward side of the islands or ribbons (Billings 1969, Pontecorvo and Bokhari 1975, Marr 1977, Minnich 1984). Mature trees directly buffer seedlings from harsh alpine winds, but they also improve soil moisture by altering the patterns of windflow over the land’s surface and snow deposition. Meristem tissue temperatures are substantially higher within the branches of krumholtz and windward needles have lower winter water content, lower water potentials, lower cuticular resistance, and higher transpiration rates (Hadley and Smith 1983, 1986, Grace 1989). For example, in the Medicine Bow Mountains of Wyoming, needles of Abies lasiocarpa buried by snow had autumn and winter water potentials 1.0 to 1.5 MPa higher than those above the snow pack (Hadley and Smith 1986). Neighboring trees or packed snow also protect leaves from extensive photoinhibiton damage during the winter (see above, (Ball 1994, Germino and Smith 1999, 2000). Snowdrifts that accumulate in the lees of trees provide more soil moisture as they melt, adding to the direct buffering effect of nearby trees. Holtmeier and Broll (1992) found that snow accumulated inside and leeward of tree islands in Colorado, increasing soil moisture. Tree islands also affect tundra soils. Tim Seastedt and Gina Adams at the University of Colorado found that “mobile tree islands”, gradually moving across the alpine landscape due to leeward recruitment and windward mortality, left discernable differences in soil organic matter and nitrogen storage potential that may persist for centuries (Seastedt and Adams 2001).
Chapter 2
89
Similar processes may occur at the margins of some high-elevation meadows and at timberline. In the Oregon Coast Range, Abies procera establishes primarily at forest-meadow ecotones, but much less either in the open meadow itself or in the interior of the forest (Magee and Antos 1992). Similar patterns have been described for Pinus uncinata recruitment in the central Pyrenees where seedlings are associated with krummholtz vegetation which apparently buffer recruits from the harsh environment (Camarero and Gutiérrez 1999). Alftine and Malanson (2004) found that empirical and modeled community composition at timberline corresponded with protection from wind. Based on the accumulating evidence for wind-based facilitation at tree lines, Bill Smith and colleagues (2003) proposed “another perspective on altitudinal limits of alpine timberlines”. They argued that most studies of the causes of the tree-alpine ecotone have come from studies on older trees, and not the mechanisms by which seedlings establish away from the forest edge in the tree line ecotone. They cite evidence that protection from severe mechanical damage from wind is provided by other trees. Other facilitative processes appear to occur throughout the summer growth period which enhance root growth, ameliorate drought stress, and increase seedling survival. There have been few studies that have tried to experimentally manipulate the effects of wind independently of other factors. Dayna Baumeister and I examined the relative importance of several interacting mechanisms important to the facilitative effects of Pinus flexilis on Pseudotsuga menziesii and Ribes cereum at the ecotone between the Rocky Mountain forests and Great Plains grasslands in Montana (Baumeister and Callaway 2006). This environment is known for strong, unidirectional winds, highly variable temperatures, and frequent winter Chinook winds. Chinooks are catabatic winds that dramatically increase air temperature as the air compresses. Sixty-nine percent of Pseudotsuga seedlings and saplings and 91% of Ribes were located beneath P. flexilis. The effects of overstory P. flexilis were more important at a windward site than at a leeward site, suggesting that wind amelioration was a dominant mechanism. We manipulated wind with Plexiglass wind shields, shade, and snowdrift accumulation separately and after two years found that shade, not wind, was of overwhelming importance for the survival of both Pseudotsuga and Ribes. However, once shade was provided, the effects of wind amelioration significantly increased survival of Pseudotsuga and Ribes. In Swedish Lapland, Carlsson and Callaghan (1991) showed that Carex bigelowii increased in leaf length and culm height when growing within clumps of Empetrum hermaphroditum or Racomitrium lanuginosum. They experimentally manipulated the effects of wind by erecting artificial shelters and
90
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
found that the shelters elicited similar positive responses from Carex. Shevtsova et al. (1995) compared the effects of coexisting shrub species (Empetrum nigrum, Vaccinium vitis-idaea, and Vaccinium uliginosum) on each other’s growth, branching, survival, and reproduction in northern Finland and found that the growth of E. nigrum and V. uliginosum was positively correlated with the cover of V. myrtillis. Furthermore, the removal of V. uliginosum or V. myrtillis resulted in decreased growth of E. nigrum and V. uliginosum, respectively. They hypothesized that a primary mechanism for this may have been protection from wind provided by the more stress-tolerant species. Shevtsova et al.’s results were surprisingly similar to those reported earlier by Maillette (1988) for three Vaccinium species, including V. uliginosum, in the arctic-alpine tundra on the Laurentian Plateau of Quebec, Canada. She found that the biomass of individuals of each Vaccinium species was lower outside of its own “area of dominance” (where it was proportionally more abundant) unless a plant was in contact with the locally dominant congener. In other words, one of the best positive predictors of the biomass for less abundant Vaccinium species at a site was the biomass of the locally dominant Vaccinium species. Microsite effects could have caused these correlations, but as Shevtsova et al. thought, Maillette hypothesized that protection from wind from dominant congeners was important for the success of subdominant species at a particular site. Gerdol et al. (2000) experimented with some of these same Vaccinium species in the alpine tundra of the Apennines in Italy by reciprocally removing one of the three dominant shrub species, Vaccinium myrtillus, V. uliginosum, or Empetrum hermaphroditum. In some cases neighbor removal had no effect, in others neighbor effects were competitive, and for some species neighbor effects were facilitative (Figure 2.26). Jonasson (1992) experimented with the effects of Betula nana on Vaccinium in the tundra of northern Sweden and found that Vaccinium myrtillus, various lichen species, and diversity in general, declined after Betula removal. This corresponded with his observation that V. myrtillus was much more abundant and healthy under the canopies of Betula and Salix shrubs than in the spaces between the shrubs. However, it was not clear if wind was an important mechanism.
Chapter 2
91 30
Empetrum hermaphroditum
Growth of current year shoots (%)
20 10
40
Vaccinum uliginosum
** 30
0 -10
20
-20 -30 -40 -50
*
1995 1996 1997
** **
Fertilized
V. uliginosum removed
60
0
Fertilized
E. hermaphroditum removed
60
Vaccinum uliginosum 40
10
**
**
*
Vaccinum myrtillis 50
**
40
*
30
20
20 0
10 0
-20
-10 -40
Fertilized
V. myrtillis removed
-20
Fertilized
V. uliginosum removed
Figure 2.26. Differences in the lengths of current-year shoots between ramets in plots with and without fertilizer, and with and without neighbor removal. “F” designates the fertilizer treatment, and error bars = 1 SE. Species names at top of each panel indicate target species. Differences were calculated as [(treated – untreated)/untreated). –Vm = removal of Vaccinium myrtillus, -Vu = removal of Vaccinium uliginosum, -Eh = removal of Empetrum hermaphroditum. Redrawn from Gerdol (1998) with permission from the Journal of Ecology.
In subalpine environments of the Snowy Mountains of southeastern Australia winter wind appears to affect tree lines. Egerton and Wilson (1993) found that growth and stem elongation of Eucalyptus pauciflora, the dominant tree species at timberline, decreased over the winter in grassland but not in shrubland. Furthermore, the removal of neighbors had negative effects on stem elongation in both habitats, suggesting that the presence of neighbors was facilitative. They hypothesized that the erect growth form of Eucalyptus exposed it to winds and scouring snow and ice during the winter and that by associating with protective vegetation damage could be reduced. In other experiments in the same system, Wilson (1993) found that the presence of neighbors was positive for the survival of Poa costiniana, a mid-altitude grass, but negative for the growth of the grass. Many authors have reported strong spatial associations among species in extreme alpine environments where wind is consistent and intense (Whitehead 1951, Griggs 1956, Bonde 1968, Blundon 1983, Sohlberg and
92
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Bliss 1984, Alliende and Hoffman 1985, Kikvidze 1993, 1996, Kikvidze and Nakhutsrishvili 1998, Anderson and Bliss 1998, Pokatzhevkaya 1998, Cavieres et al. 1998, Nunez et al. 1999, Choler et al. 2001, Cavieres et al. 2002, Arroyo et al. 2003, Badano and Cavieres 2006a,b). Most of these studies reported high degrees of clumping of some species inside cushions or tufts of other species. Most of these studies are correlational, but some experiments support the argument that these associations are due to facilitative interactions and have hypothesized that protection from wind may be a major factor (Callaghan 1987, Choler et al. 2001, Callaway et al. 2002). The importance of experimental separation of microsite effects from real facilitation in alpine vegetation, however, was emphasized in a study by Jon Moen (1993). He noted that many of the species found associated with cushion plants or with other vegetation can also be found away from them, and in some cases germination may be as high in the open as near putative nurses (Bliss 1971, Pysek and Liska 1991). Moen conducted experiments in the mountains of northern Norway (69o56’N) at 850-m elevation in an alpine “block field” by sowing seeds of Oxyria digyna in plots with Ranunculus glacialis and where R. glacialis had been removed. Instead of facilitation, he found higher germination in one year where neighbors had been removed (suggesting competition) and no effect of neighbors in another year. Other experiments conducted in alpine and arctic plant communities have also demonstrated net competitive interactions among species (Chapin and Shaver 1985, Theodose and Bowman 1997, Olofsson et al. 1999). Competition must surely occur in arctic and alpine communities, and a recent large-scale and multi-species experiment in the French Alps demonstrates the potential pitfalls that may occur when we attempt to generalize from studies of one or few species and when we do not recognize the conditionality inherent to plant interactions (also see Chapter 4). These pitfalls beset both studies of facilitation and competition. Choler et al. (2001, also see Callaway et al. 2002) conducted a neighbor removal experiment using large proportions of the species in natural alpine plant communities of the southwestern Alps. The purpose was to test for the relative importance of positive and negative interactions along elevational and topographical gradients. The effects of neighbors on the biomass, growth rate, survival, and reproduction of five target species were tested at each of six different experimental sites, half of which occurred on convex topography exposed to the wind, and the other half in concave, sheltered sites. They measured both strong competitive interactions and strong facilitative interactions, depending on the particular species involved and the environmental conditions. Competitive effects were stronger in sheltered sites and facilitation was more common in exposed sites. At high-elevation and exposed sites, experimental
Chapter 2
93
evidence for facilitation was coupled with small-scale spatial associations among species. However, spatial disassociation was not coupled to experimental evidence for competition at any sites. These experimental results, in contrast with those of Olofsson et al. (1999), indicate that strong spatial associations are often indicative of positive interactions in harsh, windswept environments. On exposed ridges near the timberline in the northern Rocky Mountains of Montana and Idaho, Abies lasiocarpa of all sizes are often highly aggregated around mature Pinus albicaulis (Callaway 1998b; also see Chapter 6). Tree ring analyses indicate that the growth rates of mature Abies at timberline decreased by 24% when adjacent P. albicaulis died, suggesting an important facilitative effect of P. albicaulis on A. lasiocarpa. These spatial associations and growth responses did not occur at lower elevations indicating that positive interactions among conifer species are only important in the highly stressful conditions that occur at the altitudinal limits of tree growth. In fact, at lower elevations the interactions were competitive. One hypothesis for this relationship is that the highly stress-tolerant Pinus albicaulis provides shelter from wind desiccation and abrasion. At high-elevation study sites, large Abies were 2-4 times more aggregated with Pinus albicaulis trees than were Abies seedlings, a pattern that would not be expected if shade were the important mechanism. Furthermore, growth rates of large Abies were significantly lower when they were more than 3 meters from a mature Pinus than when they were adjacent to either living or dead Pinus albicaulis, but the growth rates of small saplings did not differ among these microsites. Stronger facilitative effects on mature trees than on seedlings or saplings may develop because the winter snow pack protects small Abies from blowing ice and snow, but as trees grow above the snow pack, shelter from other objects may be crucial. Damaged foliage at the tops of small saplings on open ridgelines was common. Arno and Hammerly (1990) also hypothesized that ice abrasion and mechanical injury during high winds may determine timberline limits and krummholz formation in the northern Rocky Mountains, and exposure to wind has been shown to cause needle mortality due to cuticle degradation and subsequent desiccation for Abies lasiocarpa (Hadley and Smith 1983, 1986). Wind may also create misleading patterns that may be falsely interpreted as facilitation (see section 11 in this chapter). Perennial plants often act as filters or traps for seeds in windy environments, and the consequent collections of plants under canopies may have nothing to do with the canopies’ positive effects. In fact, wind may redistribute seeds into environments in which the germinating plant experiences even greater competition than it would otherwise.
94
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
2.7. SOIL OXYGENATION In 1958 Coult and Valance demonstrated that the roots of rice plants were able to oxidize the anaerobic media in which they grew. Later, Armstrong (1964) measured oxygen diffusion from the roots of three bog species in Great Britain and found that the roots of all three species released oxygen, but when leaves were sealed with Vaseline oxygen diffusion from the roots dropped immediately. These findings have very important implications for they way plants in these environments interact because low levels of soil oxygen often limit plant growth in wetlands (McDrew 1983). Since these early experiments a number of other experiments have shown that emergent wetland plants are able to passively transport oxygen from leaves to roots through aerenchymous tissue. This appears to alleviate the effects of low soil oxygen for the transporters themselves and on soil processes very close to the roots (Armstrong 1979, Dacey 1981, Armstrong and Armstrong 1990, Grosse et al. 1991). Some experiments indicate that oxygen transported belowground is consumed only by the plant itself or associated microbes (Bedford 1991), but other studies show that oxygen can leak out of submerged roots, oxidize nutrients and toxic substances in the rhizosphere, and oxygenate marsh sediments (Howes et al. 1981, Armstrong et al. 1992). Armstrong (1964) noted that the three species he worked with released oxygen to highly varying degrees, and hypothesized that the variation may relate to the highly anaerobic soils that the species are able to tolerate. Such variation may also contribute to differences in the ability of different wetland species to facilitate neighboring plant species. Experiments that directly demonstrate soil oxygenation by one species yielding a facilitative effect on another species, while controlling for other correlated effects, have not been conducted to my knowledge, but a number of studies provide strong evidence for the process. For example, Plantago coronopus and Samolus valerandi are tightly clumped around tussocks of the aerenchymous Juncus maritimus in dune slacks on the coast of Holland, where survival rates appeared to be enhanced by soil oxygenation and oxidation of iron, manganese, and sulfide (Schat and Van Beckhoven 1991). When grown with Juncus maritimus in the greenhouse, growth and nutrient uptake of Plantago and Centaurium were improved (Schat 1984). In southern Spain, Spartina maritima aerates surface sediments in coastal marshes, which creates conditions favorable for the growth of Arthrocnemum perenne (Castellanos et al. 1994). In eastern salt marshes in North America, Hacker and Bertness (1994, 1995) found that the aerenchymous Juncus maritimus increased the redox potential in its rhizosphere. When Juncus was removed experimentally the growth of Iva frutescens, an associated woody-stemmed perennial, decreased substantially. They thought that oxygenation by Juncus extends the distribution of Iva to lower elevations in the
Chapter 2
95 60
Salinty (ppt)
50 40 30 20 10 0
Redox (mV)
100
0
-100
-200
No removal of vegetation Removal of vegetation
-300
HIGH JUNCUS
MID JUNCUS
LOW JUNCUS
Figure 2.27. Effects of biomass removal on a) soil salinity, and b) soil redox potential at three different elevations in the Juncus gerardi zone. Error bars are 1 SE. Redrawn from Brewer et al. (1997) with permission from Oikos.
marsh. In the same marsh, Brewer et al. (1997) manually removed Juncus gerardi at three different elevations and measured soil responses. They found that soil redox potential decreased dramatically at all elevations in the marsh when Juncus was removed, but the magnitude of the difference was greater at low elevations (Figure 2.27). In the low marsh zone removal of Juncus and decreasing soil redox potential was associated with lower species richness. Similar results have been reported for plants from freshwater marshes. Typha latifolia has a highly effective whole-plant aeration system based on internal convective flow of gases (Bendix et al. 1994). Leah King and I found that undrained pots containing Typha latifolia had dissolved oxygen contents over 4 times greater than pots without cattails (Callaway and King 1996). Other marsh plants grown with Typha survived longer and grew larger than in pots without cattails when pot substrates were kept between 11 and 12oC (Callaway and King 1996; Figure 2.28). In the field, Myosotis laxa plants growing next to transplanted Myosotis were larger and produced more fruit that those isolated from cattails. However, the effective oxygenation of soils by aerenchymous
96
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
*
o
11-12 C
*
*
200
200
*
Mass (g)
0
0 o
18-20 C 200
WITH Typha WITHOUT Typha
200
Length (mm)
100
100
100
100
* 0
ROOT LENGTH
ROOT MASS
SHOOT MASS
0
Figure 2.28. Growth characteristics of Myosotis laxa when grown for 40 days with and without Typha latifolia in the greenhouse at two different substrate temperatures. Error bars represent 2 SE. and * represent significant differences between treatments as P < 0.01, Student’s t-test). Reprinted from Callaway and King (1996) with permission from Ecology.
plants may depend on particular soil conditions. Jespersen et al. (1998) found that Typha latifolia substantially improved soil redox potential compared to soils with no Typha, but that the effect of Typha depended on the carbon content and quality of the substrate. When acetate was added to the soil (to saturate carbonreducing or methanogenic bacteria) the positive effect of Typha on soil redox potential was much less. When King and I increased soil temperatures to 18-20oC, the oxygenation of soils and the facilitative effect of Typha disappeared. Large stands of Spartina alterniflora appear to benefit from communal rhizosphere oxygenation. Spartina seedlings and small plants are generally not able to oxygenate marsh soils (but see Huckle et al. 2000), but large groups, which may be clonally interconnected, increase oxygen in the soil and enhance growth (Bertness 1991b). Increased growth may lead to a positive feedback loop between increased soil oxygen and plant productivity (Howes et al. 1981, 1986, de la Cruz et al. 1989). Substrate oxygenation via the roots of some plant species may also elicit positive effects on other plants indirectly by preserving nitrifying capacity and nitrate availability. Engelaar (1995) compared the effects of radial O2 loss from
Chapter 2
97
the roots of the flooding-resistant Rumex palustris, which has aerenchyma in its roots, and the flooding-intolerant, non-aerenchymous Rumex thyrsiflorus in welldrained and waterlogged soils with an initially high nitrifying capacity. In the well-drained soils nitrification was high for both species, and both species had high levels of nitrate reductase in their leaves (indicative of an adequate supply of nitrate). In waterlogged soils with R. thyrsiflorus, nitrification was inhibited and ammonium accumulated. Waterlogged soils planted with R. palustris had redox potentials high enough to keep O2 replenished and maintained high nitrifying capacities (Figure 2.29). However, oxygenation does not consistently cause higher nitrification rates. In field experiments that showed evidence for the positive effects of oxygen loss from Typha latifolia on Myosotis laxa growth and reproduction, soil nitrate and ammonium did not differ between sites with planted Typha versus those without Typha (Callaway and King 1996). Experiments conducted by Levine et al. (1998) indirectly support the complex and intertwined roles of root-mediated soil oxygenation and soil nitrogen in positive interactions. They manipulated Iva frutescens-Juncus gerardi combinations (see above) in the field by adding nitrogen and found that nitrogen had strong mediating effects on the positive effects shown previously for Juncus on Iva (Figure 2.30), (Bertness and Hacker 1994, Hacker and Bertness 1995, Brewer et al. 1997). Iva plants that grew without nitrogen fertilization, but in the presence of Juncus, were much smaller and produced many times fewer flowers than Iva plants in plots where Juncus had been removed. Increasing
Redox potential (mV)
500
400
300
200
100 20
30
40
50
60
Days Figure 2.29. Redox potentials in well drained soils (open symbols) and water-logged soils (closed symbols) planted with either Rumex thyrsiflorus (triangles) or R. palustris (circles). Water logging started on day 21. Each point is the mean of two replicates. Redrawn from Engelaar et al. (1995) with permission from Biology and Fertility of Soils.
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Whole plant leaf biomass (g)
98
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0 not fertilized fertilized Plot 1 Zero
Flower number
400
300
200
100
0
Juncus present
Juncus removed
Figure 2.30. Characteristics of Iva frutescens in fertilized and unfertilized treatments and with and without Juncus gerardi. Reprinted from Levine et al. (1998) with permission from Oecologia.
nitrogen availability caused Iva to increase in size both with and without Juncus, but interestingly, nitrogen addition allowed Iva to fully compensate, both in leaf biomass and flower number, for the effect of removing Iva’s benefactor Juncus. Importantly, nitrogen addition did not alter the ability of Iva to tolerate salt stress. However, they did not measure proline differences in leaves, nor did they consider the possibility that substrate oxygenation and facilitation by Juncus may have functioned indirectly by increasing available nitrogen (e.g. Engelaar et al. 1995). Even so, nitrogen addition appeared to eliminate the need for a benefactor that oxygenated the soil rather than just increasing the salt tolerance of Iva. Plants also may oxygenate the soil in ways other than transport of oxygen through their tissues. Berendse and Aerts (1984) reported that Molina caerulea did not appear to transport oxygen belowground, but transpired rapidly enough to reduce the depth of water in waterlogged containers. Lower water
Chapter 2
99
levels permitted aeration of the shallow root system of Erica tetralix which grew better in mixtures of Molina than alone. In summary, facilitation through soil oxygenation is often overlooked; but many plants adapted to anoxic soils appear to ameliorate conditions for less adapted plants by providing oxygen or altering soil chemistry.
2.8. SUBSTRATE Trees and shrubs often facilitate the growth and survival of other species by providing a substrate for them to grow on. For example, as described in detail above epiphytes benefit by gaining cheap access to light, or by escaping superior competitors. Vascular epiphytes are important features of subtropical, tropical, and temperate rainforests, making up about 10% of the world’s total flora and up to 25-35% of the plant diversity in tropical forests (Gentry and Dodson 1987). Many epiphytic species possess only rudimentary root systems and as a consequence are obligately dependent on trees for their substrate, providing a rather obvious example of facilitation. Epiphytism is ubiquitous in temperate forests as well; however, the beneficiaries of trees in these systems tend to be lichens and mosses. Epiphytes in marine seaweed and seagrass communities also constitute high proportions of the community diversity and productivity. Many authors have shown that terrestrial epiphyte-host species combinations are not random associations (Went 1940, Johansson 1974, Benzing 1981, Bennett 1986, Jernakoff and Nielson 1988, ter Steege and Cornelissen 1989, Migenis and Ackerman 1993, Dejean et al. 1995, Kernan and Fowler 1995). Others have shown that some apparently suitable host species are virtually unoccupied by some species of epiphytes (Schlesinger and Marks 1977). Lianas, like epiphytes, depend on the structural biomass of other species for substrate, but acquire nutrients and water from the soil. As for vascular epiphytes, patterns of liana host specificity have been described in tropical and temperate systems (Daniels and Lawton 1991, Talley and Lawton 1996, Talley and Setzer 1996). Despite the large amount of literature that describes correlations between host and epiphyte species, there has been little experimental work in terrestrial systems. This work has been primarily limited to the comparison of the effects of bark and leaf leachates and extracts on germination and growth under controlled conditions (Frei and Dodson 1972, Schlesinger and Marks 1977, Talley et al. 1996). For example Talley and Lawton (1996) found that the vines of Toxicodendron (Rhus) radicans, the climbing liana commonly known as poison ivy, are more common on some host tree species than on others. Experiments with seeds demonstrated that bark extracts from various hosts all decreased germination relative to controls, but that the extracts from
100
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
preferred hosts had weaker negative effects than extracts from avoided hosts. Transplant experiments with other species demonstrated that two dominant epiphytes had higher growth rates in some tree hosts than in others (Callaway et al. 2002). The basic need for substrate may dominate the interactions among woody hosts and epiphytes, but studies cited below show that other mechanisms are also important. Epiphyte-host relationship may be commensal, with only the epiphyte benefiting and the host left unaffected; however, epiphytes may damage host tissues as well establishing a somewhat parasitic interaction. On the other hand, epiphytes may return the favor to their hosts by creating a nutrient pool in the tree canopies that some tree species can access through aerial roots (Nadkarni 1986). Additionally, although probably not much of a payback, epiphytes also reduce branch temperatures by 2-5oC, perhaps reducing respirational costs for their hosts (Freiburg 2001). Exotic plant species generally have negative effects on native species. However, the effects of Celastrus orbiculatus, a partially epiphytic vine introduced from Asia, on developing forest communities in New England are complex (Fike and Niering 1999). They observed that Celastrus dominates some parts of the forest canopies “like a carpet being unrolled”, but in an unusual twist the exotic vine appears to provide important substrate for a native vine, Vitis labrusca, by serving as a “ladder” to carry Vitis into the tree canopies. In the presence of Celastrus, Vitis appears to occur in greater abundances, and have stronger effects on other native species. Although epiphytism and hemi-epiphytism are the most intuitive and obvious example of plant species providing substrate for other species, plants can also enhance substrate conditions in other ways. Perennials can facilitate other species by altering the physical characteristics of the substrates beneath them. In California woodlands, litter deposition and root penetration under Quercus douglasii appears to develop soils with lower bulk densities, which presumably also increases soil water storage capacity (Kay 1987, Callaway et al. 1991). In dry lakes of the Mojave Desert, Kochia californica establishes in cracks in very fine textured soil and eventually collects small mounds of coarser textured soil that Atriplex torreyi can colonize (Vasek and Lund 1980). Atriplex torreyi accumulates large mounds of sandy soil, which coalesce across the landscape and provides habitat suitable for Atriplex confertifolia and Haplopappus acradenius. Large shifts in soil chemistry are correlated with these soil textural and microtopographic changes. In similar desert environments of the Great Karoo in South Africa, Yeaton and Elser (Yeaton 1990) proposed a similar cycle of substrate development, facilitation, and succession (see Chapter 6). In this system, open exposed soil is colonized by species in the Mesembryanthemaceae family which accumulate soil and
Chapter 2
101
build mounds. These mounds are colonized by several species of woody shrubs which eventually outcompete the early mound builders. Trichglochin maritima occurs commonly in “pannes” in New England salt marshes where the microtopography creates unusually high levels of waterlogging. Trichglochin roots and rhizomes build raised rings in these pannes that are occupied by other species. Fogel et al. (2004) studied the effects of raised Trichoglochin rings on other panne species in field experiments with natural Trichoglochin rings, experimentally lowered rings, artificially raised mud, and bare mud. They transplanted four perennial species, followed naturally occurring seedlings, and monitored edaphic conditions to assess treatment effects over two growing seasons. Raised substrate treatments showed a decrease in waterlogging and an increase in reductive potential (greater oxygenation) than non-raised treatments and all transplanted species showed increased success in raised treatments. There was no significant effect of the presence of Trichglochin without raising the substrate. Incompletely decomposed remains of plants may also facilitate the recruitment of other species by providing substrate (see review by Harmon et al., 1986). In Sitka spruce-western hemlock (Picea sitchensis and Tsuga heterophylla) forests of northwest America 94-98% of tree seedlings are found on “nurse logs” that cover only 6-11% of the forest floor (Franklin and Dyrness, 1973; Grahm and Cromack, 1982; McKee et al., 1982; Harmon, 1985). Logs are also important seedbeds in other Pacific Northwest forests (Christy and Mack, 1984). Griffith (1931) and Smith (1955) found much higher growth of Abies lasiocarpa and Picea englemanii seedlings on nurse logs in subalpine forests in British Columbia than on the forest floor. In a series of elegant experiments, Harmon and Franklin (1989) determined that the primary role of these nurse logs during recruitment of P. sitchensis and T. heterophylla was to provide a substrate free from competition with herbs and mosses on the forest floor (Figure 2.31, see discussion of indirect interactions in Chapter 3). First, the survival of tree seedlings was highly negatively correlated with the abundance of mosses in test plots. Furthermore, in sites either sterilized for pathogens and cleared of moss competitors, or just cleared of mosses, survival of seedlings of P. sitchensis, T. heterophylla, Thuja plicata, and in some cases Pseudotsuga menziesii, was significantly higher than sites with mosses. Similar patterns involving nurse logs have been documented in the temperate rain forests of Chile, where all seedlings of some species are found on nurse logs (Christie and Armesto 2003).
102
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Seedlings per 100 seeds
5 Picea sitchensis Pseudotsuga menziesii
4
Thuja plicata Tsuga heterophylla
3
2
1
0
0 0
0
0
On ground On nurse log On ground not protected protected
Figure 2.31. Survival of conifer seedlings for >1 year on logs, or on soil protected from mosses not protected from mosses. Error bars show 1 SE. Redrawn by estimating presentation in Figure 2 and results presented in text in Harmon and Franklin (1989) with permission from Ecology.
At 5,000 m altitude in the Annapurna Range of the Himalaya, the hummock forming species Chesnya nubigena occurs on glacial moraines and appears to facilitate other species (Jacquez and Patten 1996). Soil in Chesnya hummocks is higher in organics, the canopy accumulates snow, and daily temperature fluxes are moderated compared to surrounding gravels. The mounds developed by Chesnya are occupied by several other species that are rare on the open gravel. These beneficial effects of Chesnya on the associated grasses were not demonstrated experimentally, but because Chesnya is known to develop the mounds, the strong association of herbaceous species with mounds is likely a facilitative by-product of Chesnya. Similarly, Empetrum rubrum, a dominant species in early succession in recently deglaciated valleys in southern Chile, facilitates Nothofagus antarctica by developing substrate (Henríquez and Lusk 2005). They found that seedlings with an intact cover of E. rubrum showed significantly higher survival, growth and leaf number than seedlings which had been exposed experimentally. Partially decomposed remains of wetland plants and the sediment trapped in their remains provides habitat that is colonized by different plant species that are less tolerant of submersion (Barko and Smart 1986, Bertness 1988). In the Santee Swamp of South Carolina, Dennis and Bateson (1974) found that 11 plant species were restricted to floating logs and stumps. Similarly, Clethra alnifolia, a widely distributed wetland shrub in eastern North America,
Chapter 2
103
regenerates more commonly on logs, tree roots, and stumps than on more available soil substrates (Jordan and Hartman 1995). Agnew et al. (1993) reported that virtually all seedling regeneration of two dominant tree species at a forest-mire ecotone on the south island of New Zealand occurred on nurse logs. No nurse logs and no seedlings occurred in the mire. They argued that the presence of dead and decaying trees maintained the forest ecotone, creating a “positive vegetation switch” (Wilson and Agnew 1992) in which forest species created conditions that favored themselves. As noted above for nutrient effects, species that dominate bogs may also “engineer” positive feedback switches with respect to substrate building (Jones et al. 1994, 1997). The unique chemical properties of Sphagnum mosses contribute to highly unfavorable conditions for other species of plants, but allow Sphagnum to produce environments that favor its own growth (van Breeman, 1995). Sphagnum contains high concentrations of phenolic compounds, including genus-specific acids. The accumulation of many centimeters of dead Sphagnum, the tissue of which is one of the most water-absorptive materials known, also creates a water-logged, anoxic, nutrient-poor environment that impedes other species without substantially limiting Sphagnum. Sphagnum further appears to engineer its own preferred substrate by forming impervious iron pans and clogging soil pores under the peat debris. Crowding is a common state of affairs in plant communities, and is typically studied from the perspective of competition for limited resources. Harley and Bertness (1996) took a different approach and studied how crowding leads to morphologically modified individuals that become dependent on their neighbors for structural support. They created crowded and isolated treatments for four different salt marsh species, and found that crowded plants were typically taller and thinner, producing less aboveground biomass, and were more susceptible to breaking under stress. Then crowded plants were thinned to test the hypothesis that crowding leads to dependence on neighbors. They found that plants grown in crowded conditions were dependent on their neighbors to remain upright, in their words, “once plants have grown in a crowd, it is important that they remain in that crowd”. Structural interdependence has also been suggested for trees in tropical and temperate forests where thinning often leads to increased tree fall (Skorupa and Kasenene 1982, Holbrook and Putz 1989). Positive interactions in which plants provide other plants with vital substrate or structural stability is an overlooked process in ecology, and these kinds of interactions are good examples of ecosystem engineering (Jones et al. 1994, 1997). Understanding how sessile and crowded organisms perform in groups provides interesting insight into the nature of communities.
104
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
2.9. DISTURBANCE Some plant species are able to tolerate disturbance and create stable environments that benefit other species that cannot handle disturbance. This facilitative process is conceptually similar to the positive effects of some plant species on substrate development, but not identical. For example, it has been known for a long time that some plant species stabilize shifting sand dunes (Bagnold 1954, Bressolier and Thomas 1977) which creates habitat that can be colonized by other species (Whitfield and Brown 1956, Hewett, 1970, Toft and Elliot-Fisk 2002). However, the effect of established plants on the movement of moving sand is not simple. Franks and Peterson (2003) measured sand accumulation under mature plants and in the open and found that less sand accumulated under the plants than in the open, and therefore the mature plants protected seedlings from burial and mortality. Interestingly, he attributed this to plant stabilization of substrate, but noted that substrate instability may lead to either the accretion or loss of material. Martinez (2003) and Martinez et al. (2004) found similar patterns in Mexico, with the shrub, Chamaecrista chamaecristoides, ameliorating wind and protecting young grasses that grew beneath the shrub from burial. El-Bana et al. (2002) found that stable “rekbah” soil mounds built by Retama raetam protected desert annuals from disturbance in the Sinai Desert. The general effect of root systems on preventing soil erosion is obvious, but some species bind soil better than others, and therefore maybe better at facilitating other species. For example, Cerdà (1997) found that Stipa tenacissima, a large Mediterranean bunchgrass, was unusually good at stabilizing eroding soil (also see Alados et al. 2006). Such stabilization of substrate is important for buffering the disturbance created by wave impact on coastlines (Chapman 1974). The roots of tolerant species bind marsh and beach sediments and aboveground biomass slows water movement. This increases the deposition of sediments and protects other species from the impact of the waves (Pennings and Bertness 2001). Some of the most ingenious experimental work on the role shoreline plants play in protecting others from physical disturbance has been conducted in the last few years. Whole communities of halophytic forbs that occur on “cobble beaches” appear to depend on protection from beds of Spartina alterniflora in places where the impact of waves is high along the New England coast (Bruno and Kennedy 2000, van de Koppel et al. 2006). Cobble beach communities and Spartina beds form parallel bands, 3-10 m in width, along large sections of the shoreline. Species that form the cobble beach communities are highly restricted to the zones directly behind the Spartina. Spartina beds reduce the velocity of water movement during tidal events and stabilize the gravel substrate (Bruno 2000). Not all Spartina beds have equally facilitative effects.
Chapter 2
105
When seeds of two cobble beach species, Suaeda linearis and Salicornia europea, were planted behind Spartina beds of different sizes the seedlings of both species emerged and established in greater numbers behind large beds (Bruno 2000, Bruno and Kennedy 2000). When the substrate was mechanically stabilized behind small Spartina beds, seedlings emerged and established much as they did behind large Spartina beds (Figure 2.32). Other experiments showed seed supply and soil characteristics to be much less important than the presence of large, stable Spartina beds. Similar positive effects of neighbors occur on lakeshores where waves disturb sediments and vegetation (Wilson and Keddy 1986, Twolan-Strutt and Keddy 1996). Seedling emergence
Seedling establishment
Percent
A) S. europaea 100
100
80
80
60
60
40
40
20 0
20 0
0 0 80
100 No. seedlings/plot
B) S. linearis
C) S. europaea 80
0
D) S. linearis
60
60 40 40 20
20 0
0
0
Small
Small + Large stabilization
0
0 Small
Small + Large stabilization
Treatment
Figure 2.32. Emergence and establishment of Salicornia europea and Suaeda linearis seedlings behind small and large stands of Spartina alterniflora and in small stands where substrate was mechanically stabilized to mimic the effects of the large stands. Error bars are 1 SE. “Percent” refers to the frequency of the plots of each treatment that contained one or more seedlings. Reprinted from Bruno and Kennedy (2000) with permission from Oecologia.
106
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
The general facilitative role of Spartina alterniflora appears to vary with genotype. Proffitt et al. (2005) experimented with different clonal genotypes of S. alterniflora and found that different genotypes varied in their competitive effect on a codominant species, Salicornia bigelovii, and their facilitative effects on many less common marsh species. Spartina alterniflora also appears to have a facilitative role in stabilizing substrates at lower elevations in eastern marshes. Several authors have described an “obligate co-occurrence of fucoid algae, primarily Ascophyllum nodosum, with S. alterniflora on the eastern coast of North America” (Chock and Mathieson 1976, Gerard 1999, Chapman and Chapman 1999). One hypothesis for this relationship is the stabilization of algal mats, which have been described as “stapled in position by grass shoots,” (Chapman and Chapman 1999). Gerard (1999) experimented with removals of S. alterniflora and found that almost all Ascophyllum from Spartina-removal plots was lost during fall and winter storms, when disturbance tore the algae from the intertidal bed. Wilson and Keddy (1986) manipulated eight different species in a lakeshore community in southern Ontario. The experiment was designed to investigate “diffuse” competition (see Chapter 3), which is the combined effect of several species interacting together inclusive of the indirect interactions among the species, and found that diffuse effects on three of the eight species were facilitative. In other words, individuals grown with neighbors accumulated more biomass than conspecifics grown alone. They hypothesized that these positive responses may have been due to neighbors providing shelter from wave action or stabilizing sediments. In many streams and rivers of northern California, large tussocks of the aptly named “torrent sedge”, Carex nudata, are exceptionally tolerant to disturbance generated by high spring runoffs (Levine 2000). Levine found that most of the 60 plant species growing in this riparian habitat occurred almost exclusively within the thick root mats and vegetation of the Carex tussocks. In experiments designed to test the hypothesis that C. nudata provides stable substrate for other species during extreme winter floods he found that transplants of five species grew as large or larger in the open streambed as they did in C. nudata tussocks, but winter mortality was much higher outside of the tussocks (Figure 2.33). In streams in the Sonoran Desert, Dudley and Grimm (1994) observed that Cynodon dactylon (Bermuda grass) formed mats over sand and gravel substrates that were typically scoured of natural vegetation during annual floods. They found that five other plant species were associated with Cynodon and hypothesized that the invasive grass provided resistance to disturbance and thereby modified community structure in the streams. Johnson et al. (1985) argued for a similar function for Salix nigra, which appears to stabilize alluvial
Chapter 2
107
0.8
Mimulus cardinalis
Conocephalum conicum 2 X = 40.83, P<0.001
2
X = 32.95, P<0.001
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 1.0
Mimulus guttatus 2 X = 27.49, P<0.001
Brachythecium frigidum X2 = 13.32, P<0.021
0.6
0.4
0.6
ns e De
Th in ne d
Pi nn ed
ip pe d
Juncus covillei 2 X = 82.76, P<0.001
0.8
Cl
0.0 1.0
am be d
0.2
St re
Mortality (%)
0.8
Carex
0.4
0.2
ns e De
Th in ne d
Pi nn ed
ip pe d Cl
St re
am be d
0.0
Carex
Figure 2.33. Winter mortality of five transplanted target species in open streambed or in various manipulations of Carex nudata tussocks. Bars represent the proportion of transplants that died during the winter of 1997-1998. Redrawn from Levine (2000) with permission from Ecology.
soils deposited in the deltas of southern Louisiana, enhancing the development of many other species. While not directly a modification of disturbance regimes, seagrass communities dominated by Halodule wrightii and Thalassia testudinum appear to enhance the efficiency of nitrogen uptake by slowing the velocity of water moving around them. Large, dense stands slowed water velocity more, with apparent positive feedbacks to nitrogen uptake rates (Thomas et al. 2000). Using a field flume, they found that the effect of seagrass communities on water velocity also resulted in higher ammonium uptake.
108
Direct Mechanisms for Facilitation
Small-scale disturbance may also play a role in the facilitative effect of some dominant species. Heilbronn and Walton (1984) proposed that graminoids might initially be favored as colonizers of steep slopes because of their fibrous, highly branching roots. These roots stabilize sediments by limiting microsolifluction and thereby create stable islands for forb colonizers. Ikeda and Okutomi (1992) conducted experiments in which plant interactions were studied in the context of human trampling. They found that Plantago asiatica was sensitive to the drought conditions created by heavy trampling, and when in monocultures its abundance and survival decreased sharply as the soil compaction increased. However, when Eragrostis ferruginea was planted with Plantago soil moisture levels stayed higher and Plantago performance increased because of protection provided by the tougher species.
2.10. POPULATION SIZE AND POSITIVE DENSITY-DEPENDENCE Positive density-dependent processes within populations are known as Allee effects (Allee 1931). Allee hypothesized that population growth and survival may decrease at low densities because of reproductive limitations, the inability of small numbers to exploit a particular resource, or the greater potential for a predator to wipe out an entire population. For plants, the Allee effect may be manifest most explicitly as pollen limitation (Davis et al. 2004) or the inability of small populations to modify the environment through positive feedback processes. Most examples of positive density-dependence that I know of for plants involve animal pollinators. Interactions mediated by a third organism are indirect, and these kinds of density-dependent phenomena are discussed more thoroughly in Chapter 3. However, some density-dependent processes may be direct, for wind-pollinated species for example, and I address them in this chapter. An interesting twist on positive density-dependence in plant populations was demonstrated by Wied and Galen (1998) who found that seedlings of Frasera speciosa and Cirsium scopulorum, alpine herbs in the central R