R Journal of Macromolecular Science , Part C: Polymer Reviews, 50:1–13, 2010 Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1558-3724 print / 1558-3716 online DOI: 10.1080/15583721003624859
Perspective Scattering from Polymers YVONNE A. AKPALU Department of Chemical & Materials Engineering, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio Knowledge and understanding from scattering provides a scientific basis of control of polymer properties. This understanding has fueled technological advances in synthetic polymers that have revolutionized our daily lives. This issue of Polymer Reviews focuses on recent advances in scattering instrumentation, data analysis and modeling, and its application to the structure-property characterization of polymers. We highlight research directions where the structure-property characterization by scattering measurements can enable polymer products and technologies that significantly reduce reliance on fossil feedstock and environmental pollution. Keywords X-ray scattering, neutron scattering, renewable resources, polyhydroxyalkanoates
1. Introduction In this special issue of Polymer Reviews, we present four articles that review recent advances in structure-property characterization of polymers by X-ray and neutron scattering. Scattering techniques have been employed since the beginning of polymer science to provide information on the structure and properties of polymers.1 As early as the 1920s C.W. Bunn used X-rays to determine the crystal structure of polyethylene via the Bragg law. nλ = 2D sin(θ/2),
(1)
where D is the distance between crystallographic planes, λ, is the wavelength of the radiation used, θ , is the angle of scatter and n is the (integer) order of reflection. The scattering angle θ , is determined by the spatial period of the Fourier component that is responsible for the scattering; thus, for each scattering angle there is a corresponding Bragg spacing, D, which is given by Eq. (1). The scattering intensity I(Q), measured as a function of the momentum transfer vector, Q, is related to θ via Q=
4π sin(θ/2), λ
(2)
Received January 11, 2010; accepted January 13, 2010. Address correspondence to Dr. Yvonne Akpalu, Chemical & Materials Engineering, 400 Rhodes Hall, Cincinnati, OH 45221-0012, United States. E-mail:
[email protected]
1
2
Y. A. Akpalu
Combining equations (1) and (2) gives D 2π/Q
(3)
which indicates the distance scale probed by a measurement at a given value of Q. The Fourier or inverse relationship between the structure of a material in real space (r) and the scattering in Q-space, means that Eq. (3) can be applied to first order for all types of scattering. Experiments in the range 0.6 < Q < 15Å−1 , commonly referred to as wideangle scattering (WAS), contain most of the information for determining the unit cell dimensions of crystals.2–10 WAS probes a distance scale ∼ 0.4 < D < 10Å. The technique of small-angle scattering (SAS) is used to study the structure of the size on the order of 10Å or larger.11–16 Information such as the typical size, shape, and arrangement of the structure is contained in the intensity of the scattering X-rays, neutrons, and light at small angles. In general, data from the SAS measurements can provide information on the average size and distribution of the scattering unit or heterogeneity as long as the wavelength of the incident radiation is comparable to the size of the scattering unit or heterogeneity.17 Analysis of the scattering profiles can provide information on the nature of the interfaces, size, shape, and distribution of domains. Furthermore, contrast variation using isotopic substitutions allows one to distinguish between the shape and the spatial correlation of the different polymeric domains, ion-rich or ion-poor, crystalline or amorphous. Most polymer systems exhibit a large-scale structure that necessitates the use of multiple scattering techniques. To illustrate this complexity, we use a semicrystalline polymer as an example. In semicrystalline polymers, the macroscopic behavior is strongly dependent on the underlying microstructure consisting of molecules arranged in the unit cell (∼Å), lamellar crystals (∼10 nm), and the aggregation of these lamellae into fibrils (∼100 nm) and larger structures such as spherulites (∼µm) (Fig. 1). Quantitative relationships between microstructure and properties in these materials requires a knowledge of microstructural features on the scale of lamellar (∼10 nm), fibrils/lamellar stacks (∼100 nm) to spherulites (∼µm). The morphological characterization of crystalline polymers involves determining the unit cell dimensions and the average size of the crystal (lamella) from wide-angle scattering and interlamaller morphology from small-angle scattering.14, 18–21 Determining interfibrillar and interspherulitic parameters requires the use of ultra-small angle X-ray scattering (USAXS)22 and small-angle light scattering (SALS).23–25 Thus determining quantitative structure-property relationships from scattering studies of polymers with large-scale structures or hierarchical microstructures necessitates the use of multiple techniques to span all length scales of structure that influence the properties of the polymer. Many polymers self-organize into hierarchical structures with spatial heterogeneities in the range 10–100 nm. These polymers include block copolymers, ionomers, and liquid crystalline polymers. Scattering experiments give information on the time-averaged structure and conformation of polymer molecules and form the bulk of the large body of work undertaken to characterize the polymer structure, and understand the interrelationships among polymer properties, structure, and morphology. The review articles included in this special issue of Polymer Reviews provide a comprehensive treatment of the principles of small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering techniques as well as recent advances in instrumentation and data analysis and their application to structure-property characterization of polymers. The first contribution by Hammouda focuses on recent advances and applications of neutron scattering for polymer solutions, copolymers, polymer blends, branch or grafted polymers, polymer gels, polymer networks,
Scattering from Polymers
3
Figure 1. Schematic representation of the morphology of semicrystalline polymers and characteristic structural variables. Volume fraction of structures characteristic of each morphological level are the volume fraction of superstructures/spherulites (xs ), volume fraction of lamellar stacks (xL ), and fraction of crystals within lamellar stacks (xCL ). Interlamellar morphological variables are the average distance between crystals (L), the average crystal thickness (lc ), and the average amorphous thickness (la ). Interfibrillar morphological variables are the average size of the lamellar stack (ξ L ) and the interfibrillar amorphous regions (LD ). The crystalline fraction within spherulites (xcs = xL xCL ) is an averaged nanoscale quantity. The assumption here is that all crystals are within lamellar stacks and spherulites.
polymer micelles, polymeric nanomaterials, and polymer membranes. The prospects for the measurement capabilities that will allow probing of polymer structures from the near atomic scale to well into the optical (20 micrometers) size scale are described. Zhang and Ilavksy focus on the application of ultra-small angle scattering for probing polymers with structural heterogeneities in the size range of 1–1000 nm. The review focuses on USAXS structure-property characterization of polymer nanocomposites, polymer gels and solutions, polymer blends, polymer micelles, and microemulsions. New advances in instrumentation that support the wider use of USAXS for polymer research, including new capabilities for measuring the “complete” small-angle scattering curve for polymers are described. The next two contributions focus on recent progress in structure-property characterization of polymers with fiber symmetry. Stribeck provides a critical review of the experimental methods and data analysis required for monitoring fabrication processes, mechanical properties, and the resulting fluctuations in polymeric materials with fiber symmetry. Burger, Hsiao, and Chu provide a theoretical treatment of structural information to be determined in scattering from natural and synthetic polymer fiber systems. This review emphasizes the calculation of complete X-ray scattering patterns required for building structure-property relationships in natural and synthetic fiber polymers or polymers with self-assembled meso-structures exhibiting density and orientation fluctuations that can be described by fiber symmetry.
2. X-rays and Neutrons The physics of X-ray and neutron scattering from polymers are covered in several standard texts.17,26,27 Here, we borrow heavily from these texts to present aspects that are important
4
Y. A. Akpalu
for understanding the importance of X-ray and neutron scattering for characterizing polymers. For most applications in polymer science, the scattering of X-rays and neutrons is elastic, where the energies of the incident and scattered radiation have the same energy or wavelength. X-rays and neutrons are scattered by atomic centers at discrete angles represented as sinusoidal (Fourier) components of the electron density and nuclear scattering potential of the specimen, respectively. X-rays and neutrons have wavelengths comparable to interatomic distances in materials. The manner in which these types of electromagnetic radiation are scattered by a material depends on the mechanism of scattering from individual atoms and on their relative positions in space. X-rays are electromagnetic radiation with wavelength, λ = 10−2−102Å. X-rays used for the study of the structure of materials have typical wavelengths of 0.5–2.5 Å and are most typically generated by conventional anode generators that offer the advantage of inhouse capabilities found in individual laboratories worldwide, as well as the bright light of synchrotron sources that are available only at national facilities.14 Studies on polymers are performed mostly with Kα characteristic radiation from a copper target tube having a wavelength of 1.5418 Å, but occasional work is also done with Kα line of wavelength 0.7107 Å from a molybdenum target tube. X-rays of similar wavelength can also be selected by means of a monochromator from a broad spectrum emitted by a synchrotron radiation source.14 X-rays, like light, exhibit particle-wave duality. Certain properties of X-rays are better understood when a beam of X-rays is regarded as a stream of photons rather than a wave with wavelength λ and frequency ν. The energy of an X-ray photon is characterized by its energy E and momentum p, which are related to λ and ν by E = hν
(4)
h p= λ
(5)
c v
(6)
and λ=
where c is the speed of light (= 2.998 × 108 m/s), and h is Planck’s constant (= 6.626 × 10−34 J s). The flux of photons produced by X-ray synchrotrons is several orders of magnitude higher than the flux on a neutron beamline. The increased flux can be very beneficial when collimating the beam to a spot size of a few millimeters in diameter and for increasing the experimental throughput based on reduced exposure time needed.16, 28 A neutron is an uncharged elementary particle with a mass m = 1.675 × 10−24 g and spin 12 . It kinetic energy E and momemtum p are E=
1 2 mv 2
(7)
and p = mv
(8)
where ν is its velocity. Neutrons also exhibit wave-like behavior, with the wavelength given by the de Broglie relation λ=
h h = p mv
(9)
Scattering from Polymers
5
Table 1 Typical values of ν, E, and λ of neutrons from Cold, Thermal and Hot Sources17 Polymer
Cold
Thermal
Hot
T (K) v (m/s) E (meV) λ (Å)
25 642 2.16 6.16
330 2333 28.4 1.696
2000 5743 172 0.689
Table 1 shows the most probable velocity v in the Maxwell-Boltmann Distribution, given by Eq. (11). The corresponding kinetic energy E = mv 2 /2 = kT , and wavelength λ, are listed for the three typical moderator temperatures 25, 330, and 2000 K. Cold source neutrons emerge from a small volume (∼20 liters) of liquid deuterium maintained around 25 K while thermal neutrons are those moderated usually with heavy water D2 0 around 330 K. It is worthwhile to note that the wavelengths of cold, thermal, and hot neutrons are on the order of 1 Å, similar to X-rays. As a result, neutron scattering is also a useful tool for investigating the structure of materials. The way neutrons are produced determines the energy and wavelength. The source of neutrons for most scattering experiments is a nuclear reactor, although spallation sources have gained importance in recent years. Neutrons produced by a nuclear fission reaction in a reactor or by bombardment of high-energy protons onto a heavy metal in a spallation source are of very high velocities. For neutron scattering studies these high velocity neutrons are moderated, i.e. they are allowed to slow down by repeated collisions with atoms in a moderating material. Moderation produces neutrons with a Maxwell-Boltzmann velocity distribution, given by m 32 1 2 (10) v 2 exp − 2 mv kT f (v) = 4π 2π kT where f (v)dv is the fraction of gas molecules with velocities between v and v + dv and k is Boltzmann’s constant (1.381 × 10−23 J/K). The maximum function of f (v) or most probable velocity v occurs at v=
2kT m
12 (11)
In many ways the scattering behavior of neutrons is similar to those exhibited by X-rays, so that experimental and theoretical tools developed for X-rays can be applied to neutron scattering and vice versa. There are, however, some important differences between X-rays and neutrons, and these differences often make the two methods complementary to each other, providing the required information for characterizing polymer structure and its relation to properties. 2.1 Energy The difference in energy between X-rays and neutrons determine what kind of structure is probed. Whereas the energy of an X-ray photon is on the order of 10 keV, the kinetic energy of a thermal neutron is of the order of 10 meV. The average energy associated
6
Y. A. Akpalu
with the motion of atoms, arising from vibrational, rotational, and translational motions of molecules, is of the order of kT. At ambient temperatures, kT is about 20 meV. Thus, when X-rays are scattered by matter, even when there is an exchange of energies between the motions of atoms and the X-ray photon, the energy of the photon is scarcely affected. On the other hand, when neutrons are scattering inelastically, their energies can be modified to an appreciable extent that can be measured experimentally. This difference can be understood also from a slightly different viewpoint as follows. The time (τ = ν1 ) associated with one wave period is of the order of 10−19 s for X-rays and 10−13 s for thermal neutrons. Since a typical time period for atomic motions is 10−13 s, an X-ray, unlike a neutron, does not see a change in the atomic position. Measuring the inelastic scattering of neutrons is a very useful method for investigating the motions of atoms in materials,30,31 which is beyond the focus of this special issue. 2.2 Mechanism for Interaction of Radiation with Matter The differences in the mechanism by which incident neutrons and X-rays interact with a material leads to several important differences in how the experimental data is obtained and corrected. X-rays are scattered by the electron density of an atom or molecule, and the scattering cross-section of an atom increases in direct proportion to the square of the number of electrons or atomic number, Z; in the case of hydrocarbon polymers the X-rays “see” the electron clouds contributed by carbon’s six electrons better than the single electron attributable to hydrogen. X-rays probe atomic dimensions within an order of magnitude of the X-ray wavelengths, so that the radiation scattered by the electron cloud on opposite sides of the atom results in a different path length that gives rise to a shift in phase and decreasing the scattering power with increasing scattering angle. Neutrons interact directly with the nuclei within a molecule, and the strength of the scattering interaction varies irregularly with the atomic number, so that even isotopes of the same element do not have the same neutron scattering cross-section or scattering length.17 For example, the most significant isotopic variation occurs for hydrogen, which has a coherent scattering length of −3.74 fm, while for deuterium the scattering length is 6.67 fm. Neutrons are therefore sensitive to hydrogen and the differences between its isotopes, which permits observation and measurement of the hydrogen structural correlations in polymers, that are not easily obtainable by X-rays. Scattering experiments probe the differential scattering cross-section defined as the ratio of the scattering cross-section dσ scattered into the solid angle d about the scattering angle θ . This can be analyzed in terms of the first Born approximation32 N dσ = bi bj e(iQ·rij ) d i,j
(12)
where the sum is over the N nuclei (in the case of neutrons) or electrons (in the case of X-rays) in the sample, b is the scattering length for neutrons of a given element, while b is replaced by a Q-dependent form factor in the case of X-rays; the {rij } are the positions of nuclei, electrons, and heterogeneities larger than atomic dimensions; Q = 4π sin(θ/2)/λ is the momentum transfer for the elastic scattering process where λ is the wavelength; and the brackets correspond to a thermal average in Eq. (12). The specific form of Eq. (12) depends on (i) the scattering length of the heterogeneity, (ii) the relative size of the heterogeneity compared to the probe radiation wavelength, and (ii) the spatial arrangement of the heterogeneities.17 When the scatterers are numerous (e.g., electrons on every atom
Scattering from Polymers
7
for X-rays) and are more or less continuously dispersed in space in the sample, we replace the summation in Eq. (12) with an integral. In applying Eq. (12) and its simplified forms, it is required that various corrections to the measured scattering intensity, I (Q), has been made, accounting for effects such as incoherent scattering, beam polarization, multiple scattering, inelastic effects, container absorption, etc. Details on how to perform these corrections correctly for X-ray and neutron scattering experiments are given in standard texts.16,17,26 The articles included in this special issue of Polymer Reviews provide examples of simplified forms of Eq. 12 for different types of scattering from polymers. In a typical scattering experiment, the scattered radiation signal is captured by a detector, or detector element, of dimensions dx × dy positioned at some distance, L, and the scattering angle from the sample. This detector records the flux of radiation scattered . Single-point detectors have been used to collect into a solid angle element, d = dxdy Lz X-ray structural information from polymers, but area detectors offer several important advantages over single-point detectors, including the reduction of the background signal and greater statistics, a larger range of Q-space data collected at the same time, and the collection of several perspectives of the same data that provides an important benchmark for validation of the subsequent data processing and modeling. The use of charge-coupled device (CCD) area detectors for X-ray diffraction began around 1995 and has become increasingly popular.14 The detection of neutrons is typically accomplished through an array of individual detectors (although one- and two-dimensional linear and area detectors are sometimes used) composed of a gas of 3He, for example, or scintillator materials based on 6Li that detect the neutron as a charge produced from a nuclear reaction.17 The primary issue in devising a neutron detector is to create high sensitivity to neutrons while remaining insensitive to background events (such as γ -rays) and to minimize the loss of signal due to the “dead-time” of the detector. Gas detectors have the advantage of good discrimination against γ -rays, while scintillator detectors have better sensitivity relative to gas detectors, with a dead time on the order of hundreds of nanoseconds.17 Scattering yields measurements in reciprocal (Fourier Transform) space and depends therefore on data interpretation using models33 and not on real space imaging like microscopy. Electron microscopic imaging is in principle more powerful than small-angle scattering (SAS) for elucidating nanoscale structure and morphology. The main reason is that the phase information is lost in scattering, so one cannot uniquely determine structure. Although the loss of phase information can be viewed as a severe limitation, the loss can be beneficial34 for understanding the spatial dependence of fluctuations in polymers arising from heterogeneities in backbone structure of polymers and mesoscale morphologies. The articles included in this special issue of Polymer Reviews provide several examples of the unique scientific benefits of scattering from polymers.
3. Renewable Polymers with Controlled Properties Within the last few decades, synthetic polymers have revolutionized our daily lives.35 Globally, we use in excess of 260 million tons of plastic per year, accounting for about 8 percent of world oil production. The dwindling of fossil resources, coupled with increasing public preference for environmentally friendly plastics, has increased academic and industrial interest in biodegradable polymers prepared from renewable sources. Biopolymers differ from petroleum-based in that their feedstock is from renewable biomass rather than being oilbased. These polymers may be natural polymers (e.g., cellulose), synthetic polymers made from biomass monomers (e.g., polyactic acid), or synthetic polymers made from synthetic
8
Y. A. Akpalu
monomers derived from biomass (e.g., polyethylene derived from bioethanol).36 Although materials with functionality comparable to conventional plastics can now be produced on an industrial scale; they are more expensive than conventional polymers and account for less than 1% of plastics production.36 Below, we highlight key structure-property characterization challenges of recently developed cost-competitive renewable polymers. These renewable polymers have the potential to replace petroleum-based polymers on scales that can lead to significant reductions in reliance on fossil feedstock and environmental pollution. Recently, polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs), which are biodegradable and compostable thermoplastics polyesters synthesized by bacteria, were introduced to the market as competitors for polyethylene and polypropylene.37–39 These materials are particularly interesting as one looks forward to the next 10–50 years since they can replace polymers based on fossil feedstock without loss of performance. Further, adding small amounts of nanofillers (<5 wt.%) can enhance barrier, mechanical, and the thermal properties of polymers.40,41 Using such methods, it is possible to create renewable polymer nanocomposites with properties that rival available synthetic polymers.42,43 Environmental benefits include the reduction of solid packaging waste because PHAs fully degrade in aerobic (e.g., household compost) and anaerobic (e.g., marine, septic tanks, below the surface of rice paddies) environments37 which support the bioactivity of microbes. Thus commercial products made of PHA will not spontaneously biodegrade in the typical environment of store shelves. Several recent life cycle assessments show positive impacts of PHAs on the environment such as reduction in greenhouse gas emissions and lower total fossil energy requirement compared to petrochemical counterparts.44–46 When PHAs are produced from food and agricultural waste, 0.49 kg CO2 is emitted per kg of resin, compared with 2–3 kg CO2 per kg of resin of petrochemical counterparts. This difference represents about 80% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. The fossil energy requirement per kg of PHA is about 50% lower than that of petrochemical counterparts (78–88 MJ/kg resin). Potential green applications abound—window coatings that block heat but not light, more efficient solar panels, and light-weight, fully biodegradable automobile parts and biofuels from wastewater or sludge that do not compete with food sources and arable land.39 While the potential of PHAs is recognized in the literature and has even been realized in some cases, the knowledge of these systems is decades behind that of synthetic polymers. Composites based on PHAs, furthermore, are just emerging in the research community.40,41 NodaxTM PHA copolymers (Fig. 2) originally developed by Procter & Gamble (P&G)38,47 are designed to achieve mechanical properties and processing characteristics comparable to those of thermoplastic polyolefins such as polyethylene and polypropylene. NodaxTM copolymers (Fig. 2) consist predominantly of 3-hydroxybutryate (3HB) and 3hydroxyalkanoate (3HA) co-monomer units. The secondary 3HA comonomer units must
Figure 2. Molecular structure of NodaxTM class PHA copolymer. The value of y (mcl-3HA units) is between 2 to 50%. Chemical structures of more familiar linear PHAs: PHB is poly(3-hydroxybutyrate) (y = 0) and PHBV is poly (3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate) (n = 1).
Scattering from Polymers
9
have side groups consisting of at least three carbon atoms. Examples of PHAs with mediumchain-length (mcl) side groups include poly (3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3- hydroxyhexanoate) (PHBHx, n = 2), poly (3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3- hydroxyoctanoate) (PHBO, n = 4), poly (3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxydecanoate) (PHBD, n = 6), and poly (3-hydroxybutyrateco 3-hydroxyoctadecanoate) (PHBOd, n = 14). The architecture of NodaxTM copolymers is substantially different from that of more familiar types of PHAs, such as poly(3-hydroxybutyrate) homopolymer (PHB) or poly(3hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate) copolymer (PHBV). The size of the side groups in the conventional PHAs is limited to short-side-chain (scl) types with no more than two carbon atoms. While PHAs with only one or two carbon side groups may be viewed essentially as linear polymers, PHA copolymers with medium-chain-length (mcl) side groups are moderately branched polymers. The applications of PHB and PHBV are limited by brittle behavior caused by their high crystallinity, poor thermal stability, and narrow processing window. To improve the overall physical properties of PHB, PHAs containing over 125 types of monomers have been harvested from different microorganisms.48 The copolymers show a wide range of physical properties depending on the chemical structure of the comonomer units as well as comonomer composition. The inclusion of a small amount of mcl-3HA in PHB gives rise to polymers with useful attributes, including polyolefin-like thermo-mechanical properties, polyester-like physicochemical properties and interesting biological activity37,49–53 not achieved with PHB or PHBV. The incorporation of mcl-3HA units effectively lowers the crystallinity and melting temperature (Tm ). The Tm of mcl-3HA copolymers of PHA can be lowered well below the thermal decomposition temperature of PHB and PHBV to make this material much easier to process. The stiffness of PHA copolymers can be controlled by varying the fraction of the mcl-3HA comonomer units49 in the copolymer (Fig. 3).
Figure 3. Young’s modulus of PHA copolymers. The value of Young’s modulus of PHA spans between that of very stiff polymers, like polylactic acid (PLA) and PP, and much softer material, like low density polyethylene (LDPE). PHB-Hexanoate is PHBHx, PHB-Octanoate is PHBO and PHB-Octadecanoate is PHBOd. Bionolle 1001 and 3001 are PHBs from Biomer. Reproduced with permission from Reference 49.
10
Y. A. Akpalu
NodaxTM copolymers can be converted into various forms and products, such as films, sheets, nonwovens, molded articles, pulps, powders, coating materials, laminates, and composites, using conventional processing steps like extrusion and thermo-forming. Large-scale commercial production of the PHA copolymers (600 million pounds/year) is scheduled to start in this year. Both industrial and consumer product applications are anticipated. Factors important to the successful large-scale manufacture of PHAs for different applications include the 3HA composition of copolymers, average molecular weights, and molecular weight distributions, and the presence of processing aids like nucleating agents and plasticizers. The reduced crystallinity of mcl-3HA copolymers of PHA provides the ductility and toughness required for many practical applications.37–38 Although the copolymerization improves toughness, it also decreases stiffness. For example, the mechanical properties of PHB and PHBV are similar to isotactic polypropylene, but they show much less ductility and impact strength (low strain at break) to replace commercial PP effectively (Table 2). Incorporating 12 mol% Hx into PHB provides PP impact properties while eroding stiffness and strength. Matching ductility and impact properties of polyethylene without significantly decreasing the strength and stiffness also presents new research challenges. Biotechnology opens new paths for synthesizing biopolymers with functional properties.55–58 To date, over 120 poly(hydroxyalkanoate) (PHA) monomer units with different side chains have been reported.48 The side chains can be alkyl, aromatic, unsaturated, halogenated, expoxidized, and branched. Substituents in the side chains of PHAs can also be modified chemically, for instance by cross-linking unsaturated bonds5,9–60 Variation in the length and the composition of side chains and the ability to modify their reactive substituents is the basis for the diversity of the PHA polymers and their vast array of potential applications. Structure-property relations from scattering measurements are required to achieve control of properties at costs competitive with petroleum-based polymers. Thus we argue that widespread adoption of renewable polymer based materials can only be achieved through knowledge derived from complete characterization of the spatial dependence of fluctuations that arise from heterogeneities in the backbone structure and mesoscale morphologies of PHAs, not only the mean distances between heterogeneities but also the spatial and orientational distribution of these elements. Thus control of properties of renewable polymers and the development of cost-effective manufacturing technologies will require information on the nanoscale (1–100 nm), but also on larger scales
Table 2 Mechanical properties of PHAs and petroleum based polymers: PP is isotactic polypropylene, HDPE is high density polyethylene and LDPE is low density polyethylene. Source Polymer Handbook Polymer PHB PHBV (7 mol% HV) PHBHx (∼12 mol% HV) PP HDPE LDPE
Young’s Modulus (GPa)
Tensile Strength (MPa)
Strain at break (%)
2.5 1.4 0.27 0.6–1.2 0.7–1.2 0.15–0.45
36 24 / 22 25–32 15–20
2.5 2.8 11.5 12–20 600–900 600
Scattering from Polymers
11
(>100 nm) readily assessable by the combined use of small-angle and ultra-small angle scattering techniques.
Acknowledgements This research is supported by the Department of Energy Basic Energy Science under contract DE-SC0002253. The author is indebted to Prof. Elliot Douglas and the editorial staff at Polymer Reviews. Without their guidance and patience this Special Issue of Polymer Reviews would not have been possible.
References 1. Flory, P. J. Principles of Polymer Chemistry; Cornell University Press: Ithaca, 1953. 2. Alexander, L. E. X-ray Diffraction Methods in Polymer Science; Wiley-Interscience: New York, 1969. 3. Kakudo, M.; Kasai, N. X-ray Diffraction by Polymers; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1972. 4. Klug, H. P. X-ray Diffraction Procedures for Polycrystalline and Amorphous Materials, 2nd Edition; Wiley: New York, 1974. 5. Balt´a-Calleja, F. J. X-ray Scattering of Synthetic Polymers; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1989. 6. Glusker, J. P. Crystal Structure Analysis: A Primer, 2nd Edition; Oxford University Press: New York 1985. 7. Glusker, J. P. Crystal Structure Analysis for Chemists and Biologists; VCH: New York, 1994. 8. Tadokoro, H. Structure of Crystalline Polymers; Wiley: New York, 1979. 9. Hosemann, R.; Bagchi, S. N. Direct Analysis of Diffraction by Matter; North-Holland Amsterdam, 1962. 10. Vainshtein, B. K. Diffraction of X-rays by Chain Molecules; Translation rev. and enl. by the author ed.; Elsevier: New York, 1966. 11. Guinier, A.; Fournet, G. Small-Angle Scattering of X-rays; Wiley: London, 1955. 12. Glatter, O.; Kratky, O. Small-Angle X-ray Scattering; Academic Press: New York, 1982. 13. Higgins, J. S.; Benoit, H. Polymers and Neutron Scattering; Clarendon Press, 1994. 14. Chu, B.; Hsiao, B. S. “Small-angle X-ray scattering of polymers,” Chem. Rev. 2001, 101, 1727–1761. 15. Melnichenko, Y. B.; Wignall, G. D. “Small-angle neutron scattering in materials science: Recent practical applications,” Journal of Applied Physics 2007, 102, 021101–24. 16. Stribeck, N. X-ray Scattering of Soft Matter; Springer-Verlag: Berlin Heidelberg, 2007. 17. Roe, R.-J. Methods of X-Ray and Neutron Scattering in Polymer Science; Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 2000. 18. Jokela, K.; Vaananen, A.; Torkkeli, M.; Starck, P.; Serimaa, R.; Lofgren, B.; Seppala, J. “Differential scanning calorimetry, small-angle X-ray scattering, and wide-angle X-ray scattering on homogeneous and heterogeneous ethylene-alpha-copolymers,” J. Polym. Sci. Pt. B-Polym. Phys. 2001, 39, 1860–1875. 19. Akpalu, Y.; Kielhorn, L.; Hsiao, B. S.; Stein, R. S.; Russell, T. P.; van Egmond, J.; Muthukumar, M. “Structure development during crystallization of homogeneous copolymers of ethene and 1-octene: Time-resolved synchrotron X-ray and SALS measurements,” Macromolecules 1999, 32, 765–770. 20. Akpalu, Y. A.; Amis, E. J. “Evolution of density fluctuations to lamellar crystals in linear polyethylene,” J. Chem. Phys. 1999, 111, 8686–8695. 21. Akpalu, Y. A.; Amis, E. J. “Effect of polydispersity on the evolution of density fluctuations to lamellar crystals in linear polyethylene,” J. Chem. Phys. 2000, 113, 392–403. 22. Owen, A.; Bergmann, A. “On the fractal character of polymer spherulites: An ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering study of poly[(R)-3-hydroxybutyrate],” Polymer International 2004, 53, 12–14.
12
Y. A. Akpalu
23. Haudin, J. M. “Optical Studies of Polymer Morphology” In Optical Properties of Polymer; Meeten, G. H., Ed.; Elsevier Applied Science Publishers: New York, 1986; pp 167–264. 24. Akpalu, Y. A.; Lin, Y. Y. “Multivariable structural characterization of semicrystalline polymer blends by small-angle light scattering,” J. Polym. Sci. Pt. B-Polym. Phys. 2002, 40, 2714–2727. 25. Li, Y.; Akpalu, Y. A. “Probing the melting behavior of a homogeneous ethylene/1-hexene copolymer by small-angle light scattering,” Macromolecules 2004, 37, 7265–7277. 26. Lindner, P.; Zemb, T. Neutron, X-ray and Light Scattering: Introduction to an Investigative Tool for Colloidal and Polymeric Systems; North-Holland, 1991. 27. Cebe, P. “Introduction to scattering from polymers” In Scattering from Polymers— Characterization by X-rays, Neutrons, and Light; Cebe, P.; Hsiao, B. S.; Lohse, D. J., Eds., 2000; Vol. 739; pp 2–22. 28. Kolb, R.; Wutz, C.; Stribeck, N.; von Krosigk, G.; Riekel, C. “Investigation of secondary crystallization of polymers by means of microbeam X-ray scattering,” Polymer 2001, 42, 5257–5266. 29. Wignall, G. D.; Melnichenko, Y. B. “Recent applications of small-angle neutron scattering in strongly interacting soft condensed matter,” Reports on Progress in Physics 2005, 68, 1761–1810. 30. Kanaya, T.; Kaji, K. “Dynamics in the glassy state and near the glass transition of amorphous polymers as studied by neutron scattering” In Polymer Physics and Engineering, 2001; Vol. 154; pp 87–141. 31. Ding, Y. F.; Novikov, V. N.; Sokolov, A. P.; Cailliaux, A.; Dalle-Ferrier, C.; Alba-Simionesco, C.; Frick, B. “Influence of molecular weight on fast dynamics and fragility of polymers,” Macromolecules 2004, 37, 9264–9272. 32. Egelstaff, P. A. An Introduction to the Liquid State, 2nd ed.; Oxford University Press: Oxford, New York, 1992. 33. Ilavsky, J.; Jemian, P. R. “Irena: tool suite for modeling and analysis of small-angle scattering,” Journal of Applied Crystallography 2009, 42, 347–353. 34. Schaefer, D. W.; Agamalian, M. M. “Ultra-small-angle neutron scattering: a new tool for materials research,” Curr. Opin. Solid State Mat. Sci. 2004, 8, 39–47. 35. Thompson, R. C.; Swan, S. H.; Moore, C. J.; vom Saal, F. S. “Our Plastic Age,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B 2009, 364, 1973–1976. 36. Song, J. H.; Murphy, R. J.; Narayan, R.; Davies, G. B. H. “Biodegradable and compostable alternatives to conventional plastics,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 2009, 364, 2127–2139. 37. Noda, I.; Green, P. R.; Satkowski, M. M.; Schechtman, L. A. “Preparation and properties of a novel class of polyhydroxyalkanoate copolymers,” Biomacromolecules 2005, 6, 580–586. 38. Noda, I.; Lindsey Blake, S.; Caraway, D. “Nodax(tm) Class PHA Copolymers: Their Properties and Applications” In Plastics from Bacteria: Natural Functions and Applications; Chen, G.-Q., Ed.; Springer-Verlag: Berlin Hiedelberg, 2010; Vol. 14; pp 237–255. 39. Chen, G. Q. “A microbial polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) based bio- and materials industry,” Chem. Soc. Rev. 2009, 38, 2434–2446. 40. Maiti, P.; Batt, C. A.; Giannelis, E. P. “New biodegradable polyhydroxybutyrate/layered silicate nanocomposites,” Biomacromolecules 2007, 8, 3393–3400. 41. Xie, Y.; Kohls, D.; Noda, I.; Schaefer, D. W.; Akpalu, Y. A. “Poly(3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3hydroxyhexanoate) nanocomposites with optimal mechanical properties,“ Polymer 2009, 50, 4656–4670. 42. Pandey, J. K.; Kumar, A. P.; Misra, M.; Mohanty, A. K.; Drzal, L. T.; Singh, R. P. “Recent advances in biodegradable nanocomposites,” J. Nanosci. Nanotechnol. 2005, 5, 497–526. 43. Yu, L.; Dean, K.; Li, L. “Polymer blends and composites from renewable resources,” Prog. Polym. Sci. 2006, 31, 576–602. 44. Akiyama, M.; Tsuge, T.; Doi, Y. “Environmental life cycle comparison of polyhydroxyalkanoates produced from renewable carbon resources by bacterial fermentation,” Polymer Degradation and Stability 2003, 80, 183–194. 45. Harding, K. G.; Dennis, J. S.; von Blottnitz, H.; Harrison, S. T. L. “Environmental analysis of plastic production processes: Comparing petroleum-based polypropylene and polyethylene with
Scattering from Polymers
46.
47. 48. 49.
50. 51. 52.
53.
54. 55. 56.
57. 58. 59. 60.
13
biologically-based poly-beta-hydroxybutyric acid using life cycle analysis,” J. Biotechnol. 2007, 130, 57–66. Yu, J.; Chen, L. “The greenhouse gas emissions and fossil energy requirement of bioplastics from cradle to gate of a biomass refinery,” Environmental Science & Technology 2008, 42, 6961–6966. Noda, I. “Biodegradable copolymers and plastic articles comprising biodegradable copolymers.” 1996, US: 5,498,692 Yoshie, N.; Menju, H.; Sato, H.; Inoue, Y. “Complex composition distribution of poly(3hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate),” Macromolecules 1995, 28, 6516–6521. Satkowski, M. M.; Melik, D. H.; Autran, J.-P.; Green, P. R.; Noda, I.; Schechtman, L. A. “Physical and processing properties of polyhydroxyalkanoate copolymers.” In Biopolymers; Doi, Y. and Steinbuchel, A., Eds.; Wiley-VCH: Weinheim, 2001; Vol. 3b; pp 231–263. Noda, I.; Satkowski, M. M.; Dowrey, A. E.; Marcott, C. “Polymer alloys of Nodax copolymers and poly(lactic acid),” Macromol. Biosci. 2004, 4, 269–275. Poliakoff, M.; Noda, I. “Plastic bags, sugar cane and advanced vibrational spectroscopy: taking green chemistry to the Third World,” Green Chemistry 2004, 6, G37–G38. Noda, I.; Bond, E. B.; Green, P. R.; Melik, D. H.; Narasimhan, K.; Schechtman, L. A.; Satkowski, M. M. “Preparation, properties, and utilization of biobased biodegradable Nodax(tm) copolymers.” In Polymer Biocatalysis and Biomaterials; Cheng, H. N. and Gross, R. A., Eds.; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 2005; pp 280–291. Federle, T. W.; Barlaz, M. A.; Pettigrew, C. A.; Kerr, K. M.; Kemper, J. J.; Nuck, B. A.; Schechtman, L. A. “Anaerobic biodegradation of aliphatic polyesters: Poly(3-hydroxybutyrateco-3-hydroxyoctanoate) and poly(epsilon-caprolactone),” Biomacromolecules 2002, 3, 813–822. Peacock, A. J. Handbook of Polyethylene: Structures, Properties and Applications; Marcel Dekker: New York, 2000. Lenz, R. W.; Marchessault, R. H. “Bacterial polyesters: Biosynthesis, biodegradable plastics and biotechnology,” Biomacromolecules 2005, 6, 1–8. Qiu, Y. Z.; Ouyang, S. P.; Shen, Z. Y.; Wu, Q.; Chen, G. Q. “Metabolic engineering for the production of copolyesters consisting of 3-hydroxybutyrate and 3-hydroxyhexanoate by Aeromonas hydrophila,” Macromol. Biosci. 2004, 4, 255–261. Nakamura, K.; Goto, Y.; Yoshie, N.; Inoue, Y. “Biosynthesis of Poly(3-Hydroxyalkanoate) from Amino-Acids,” International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 1992, 14, 321–325. Madison, L. L.; Huisman, G. W. “Metabolic engineering of poly(3-hydroxyalkanoates): From DNA to plastic,” Microbiol. Mol. Biol. Rev. 1999, 63, 21. Gagnon, K. D.; Lenz, R. W.; Farris, R. J.; Fuller, R. C. “Chemical Modification of Bacterial Elastomers .1. Peroxide Cross-Linking,” Polymer 1994, 35, 4358–4367. Gagnon, K. D.; Lenz, R. W.; Farris, R. J.; Fuller, R. C. “Chemical Modification of Bacterial Elastomers .2. Sulfur Vulcanization,” Polymer 1994, 35, 4368–4375.
R Journal of Macromolecular Science , Part C: Polymer Reviews, 50:14–39, 2010 Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1558-3724 print / 1558-3716 online DOI: 10.1080/15583720903503460
Reviews SANS from Polymers—Review of the Recent Literature BOUALEM HAMMOUDA National Institute for Standards and Technology, Center for Neutron Research, Gaithersburg, MD This paper reviews the recently published literature on Small-Angle Neutron Scattering (SANS) from polymers. Papers published over the past three years and resulting from the use of the NIST Center for Neutron Research (NCNR) are included. Those with which this author is most familiar are summarized in a brief format. The intent of this review paper is to demonstrate the usefulness of the SANS technique and its impact on polymer research. SANS is a structural characterization method and a good probe for miscibility thermodynamics in polymer mixtures. SANS topics covered include polymer solutions, copolymers, polymer blends, branched or grafted polymers, polymer gels, polymer networks, polymer micelles, polymeric nanomaterials, and polymer membranes. Keywords small range neutron scattering, polymer structures, nanoscale, polymer solutions, copolymers, blends, gels, networks, branched polymers
1. The SANS Technique Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) is an effective characterization method to investigate nanoscale structures. It is based at neutron scattering facilities and has experienced steady growth over the past thirty years. It probes structures with sizes from the near atomic to the near micrometer scale and has had impact in many research areas including polymers, complex fluids, biology, and materials science. The partial deuteration method (which consists of replacing hydrogen by deuterium atoms) gives the SANS technique unique advantage. Like other scattering methods, SANS yields measurements in the reciprocal (Fourier transform) space and depends therefore on data interpretation using models and not on direct space imaging like microscopy. The SANS instrument uses the following basic steps: 1. monochromation, 2. collimation, 3. scattering and 4. detection (Fig. 1). Monochromation consists of producing a monochromatic neutron beam from the Maxwellian neutron source spectrum and is performed using a velocity selector. Collimation is performed using a source aperture and a sample aperture in order to define an Received June 18, 2009; accepted October 27, 2009. Address correspondence to Dr Boualem Hammouda, Center for Neutron Research, 100 Bureau Drive, Gaithersburg 20899-6102, United States. E-mail:
[email protected]
14
SANS from Polymers
15
Figure 1. Schematics of a SANS instrument. This Figure is not to scale; the total horizontal size is 30 m whereas the neutron detector height is 64 cm.
incident neutron beam with very small divergence. Scattering from samples of various forms (liquids, solids, gels, etc.) and in various environments (heating, pressure, shear, applied magnetic field, etc.) is measured in special cells. Detection of the scattered neutrons is performed using a 2D area sensitive detector. The pre-sample and the post-sample flight paths can be adjusted between 1 m and 15 m distance. The overall size of a SANS instrument is typically 30 m. The sample thickness is between 1 mm and 2 mm making the SANS technique a bulk probe. The NIST Center for Neutron Research (NCNR) facility operates two 30 m SANS instruments at the core of a thriving user program. Research on SANS from polymers constitutes the most active component.
2. SANS Data Analysis and Modeling Various aspects of the SANS technique including data analysis methods can be found in a recent book available online.1 SANS data analysis consists of one of three methods. 1. Rapid interpretation using standard (linear) plots such as the Guinier plot (to obtain a radius of gyration) or the Porod plot (to obtain a Porod exponent). Porod exponents vary between 1 (for 1D object such as a rod) and 4 (object with smooth surface). For example, the Porod exponent of a polymer coil in a good solvent is 5/3 while that for a polymer coil in poor solvent is 3. A Porod exponent of 2 characterizes either a polymer coil in theta solvent or a 2D structure (such as a lamella). This first data analysis method is used routinely. Extensive description of linear plots can be found in Chapter 22 of the SANS Toolbox.1 2. Nonlinear least-squares fitting to appropriate models. A large number of models are available for the analysis of SANS data from polymer systems. These are either for macromolecular scattering such as the Random Phase Approximation (RPA) or for particulate scattering such as the analytical solutions of the Ornstein-Zernike (OZ) equation. Polymer solutions and homogeneously mixed blends are well described by the RPA model while the various microphases in block copolymers (spherical, cylindrical, lamellar, etc.) are best described by solutions to the OZ equation. One such solution, the Percus-Yevick equation, offers a simple analytical form for hard-sphere interaction potential between spherical particles. The Mean Spherical Approximation is another analytical solution of the OZ equation for charged particulate systems. The zero average contrast method consists of using deuterated and non-deuterated polymer mixtures as well as deuterated and nondeuterated solvent
16
B. Hammouda mixtures in order to isolate the single-chain form factor even from concentrated polymer solutions. This method has been applied to polymer blend mixtures as well. Smearing of the models to account for instrumental resolution is performed prior to the fitting step. This second data analysis method is the most used. The RPA, the zero average contrast method, and the OZ models are described in detail in Chapters 31 and 32 of the SANS Toolbox respectively.1 3. Particle shape reconstruction and inverse Fourier transform methods are sophisticated approaches that perform in-depth analysis of SANS data using canned software packages. This data analysis method is rarely used owing to its high level of specificity.
The SANS signal is characterized by a constant (Q-independent) part due to incoherent scattering from (mostly) hydrogen in the sample as well as by a Q-dependent coherent scattering part which contains information about structure, morphology and phase transitions in the sample. Here Q is the scattering variable given in terms of the neutron wavelength λ and scattering angle θ as Q = (4π/λ) sin(θ/2). The coherent scattering cross section (units of cm−1) can be expressed as: d(Q) = φρ 2 VP P(Q)SI (Q). d
(1)
Here φ is the volume fraction and VP is the volume of the scattering “objects,” ρ 2 is the neutron contrast factor, P(Q) is the single object form factor, and SI (Q) is the inter-object structure factor. The scattering objects can be either polymer coils for macromolecular scattering or compact “particles” in the case of particulate scattering. The SANS Toolbox1 contains the form factors for various shape objects (Chapter 27) as well as for polymer chains with excluded volume (Chapter 28). The SANS technique is sensitive to composition fluctuations and is therefore a good probe for phase transition studies in polymer mixtures. The thermodynamics of miscibility are well described by the RPA model which predicts (for instance) the spinodal phase transition condition. Polymer mixtures (solutions or blends) either phase separate upon heating and are characterized by a lower critical solution temperature (LCST) or upon cooling and are characterized by an upper critical solution temperature (UCST). The mean field RPA approach uses the Flory-Huggins interaction parameters which can be measured by SANS.
3. SANS from Polymers A large number of SANS research from polymers has been covered at the tutorial level in the SANS Toolbox1 which contains a great deal of topics borrowed from this author’s research efforts. Chapter 37 describes the use of an empirical model to extract the correlation length (average distance between entanglements) in a semidilute polymer solution, applies the zero average contrast method to extract single-chain properties such as the radius of gyration and uses a simple extrapolation method to obtain an estimate of the spinodal (phase separation) temperature for an LCST system. Chapter 38 uses the Flory-Huggins Gibbs free energy to map out the phase diagram for a model polyolefin blend. Flory-Huggins interaction parameters were estimated and found to depend inversely on (absolute) temperature. The binodal and spinodal temperatures and the nucleation-and-growth region in-between were plotted. Chapter 39 describes SANS from copolymers. Here also, the RPA method is used to predict the order-to-disorder line for a diblock copolymer. SANS from copolymer spectra
SANS from Polymers
17
are characterized by a peak due to the correlation hole effect in the homogeneous phase or due to inter-domain spacing in the ordered phases. Ordered phases correspond to spherical, cylindrical, and lamellar morphologies (mostly). Chapter 40 summarizes SANS results from a ternary blend mixture in which two of the homopolymers are hydrogenated (i.e., non-deuterated). The Flory-Huggins interaction parameters were extracted for all three polymer pairs including the hydrogenated pair. Chapter 43 makes use of a sophisticated model to interpret SANS data from a crystalline polymer in solution. Thicknesses of the amorphous and lamellar regions as well as the number of lamellae per stack were obtained. A material balance approach was used along with nonlinear least squares fits to this model. Chapter 44 describes micelle formation in a triblock (Pluronic) copolymer solution. The unimers-to-spherical micelles conditions (temperature and concentration) were estimated. Cylindrical and lamellar micelles were also obtained upon further heating. The use of judicious sample environments has contributed greatly to the SANS from polymers research effort. Chapter 52 and 53 illustrate some of this effort using in-situ pressure and shear respectively. Use of the compressible RPA model along with an equationof-state yielded an estimation of the amount of free volume present in polymer blends. The use of the Clausius-Clapeyron equation helped predict the effect of pressure on the spinodal line. In some systems, pressure favored mixing while in other cases, it favored demixing. In-situ shear produces appealing 2D spectra with lots of spots and anisotropic features. Pluronic spherical micelles formed body-centered cubic structures that changed into facecentered cubic structures under Couette shear. Twinned structures were also observed. This review paper references some 76 papers on SANS from polymers resulting from use of the NCNR over the past three years. They are cataloged into broad categories that include polymer solutions,2–9 copolymers,10–19 polymer blends,20–23 branched or grafted polymers,24–32 polymer gels,33–40 polymer networks,41–48 polymer micelles,49–63 polymeric nanomaterials,64–70 and polymer membranes.71–77 Of these papers, about half are briefly summarized in order to represent the breadth of ongoing research. Those summarized are the ones with which this author is the most familiar with.
4. Polymer Solutions Chain conformations and demixing phase behaviors are common topics investigated using SANS from polymer solutions. Such topics include characteristic chain dimensions for various stiff or flexible polymers, polymer-solvent interactions, and phase transitions. Investigations of solution crystallization have been included in this section. Poly(cyclohexdiene) (PCHD) polymers contain six-member rings on the main chain. This characteristic gives them much desired mechanical properties and good thermal stability when compared to other vinyl polymers. For instance, PCHD polymers have the highest glass-rubber transition temperature (Tg around 231◦ C) of all hydrocarbon polymers. Solution properties of PCHD polymers in tetrahydrofuran and in chloroform solutions were investigated using conventional methods that included light scattering and SANS.2 These two techniques measured the radius of gyration (Rg ) and the second virial coefficient (A2 ) as a function of polymer concentration, temperature, and solvent quality. The Zimm plot method was used; it consists of an extrapolation to low scattering variables (Q) and low polymer fractions. A simple wormlike chain model reproduced the measured radii of gyration. It was found that the PCHD chain conformations were stiffer in chloroform than in tetrahydrofuran solutions.
18
B. Hammouda
Figure 2. SANS spectrum from 4% poly(ethylene oxide) mass fraction in d-water (left) showing the high-Q coherent signal (solvation intensity) and the constant incoherent background. The solvation intensity is plotted for 4% PEO in d-water/d-alcohol solvent mixtures (right). Non-ideal mixing is observed in all cases. The error bars correspond to one standard deviation.
The model water-soluble polymer poly(ethylene oxide) [–CH2 CH2 O–]n was used to investigate solvation properties in binary solvent mixtures consisting of water and other solvents (methanol, ethanol, ethylene glycol). The SANS technique was used to obtain a wide Q range.3 Deuterated solvents were used in order to enhance the neutron contrast. At low-Q, large length-scale features are characteristic of clustering (PEO in d-water) or crystallization (PEO in alcohols). The high-Q region probes polymer-solvent interactions (the solvation layer) as well as their mixing behavior (Fig. 2). The measurement temperature was kept above the crystal melting temperature when crystallization was present. A simple empirical model was used to fit SANS data and obtain solvation intensity, a correlation length, and a Porod exponent. The correlation length is an estimate of the average entanglement distance in the semidilute PEO solutions. Moreover, the random phase approximation model was used to back out Flory-Huggins interaction parameters for the ternary mixture PEO/d-water/d-methanol. It was found, for instance, that the solvation intensity for PEO in binary solvent mixtures was always lower than the ideal mixing prediction; non-ideal mixing seems to be the norm for PEO in mixed solvents. Mixed solvents seem to be better solvating agents for PEO than the individual solvents. The SANS technique was also used to investigate the solvation behavior of PEO in d-water in the dilute and semidilute regimes.4 The correlation length (obtained from the empirical model) was seen to decrease in dilute solutions but to increase in semidilute solutions. This behavior change yields an accurate method for measuring the overlap concentration used to delimit dilute from semilute solutions. The decrease in coil size in the dilute region is the precursor to the single-coil collapse transition that occurs in extremely dilute solutions of polymers with extremely high molecular weights. The temperature dependence of the correlation length shows that its inverse follows a linear behavior when plotted versus 1/T (where T is the absolute sample temperature). It remains to be seen whether this “universal” behavior observed for PEO would hold for other polymers in solution. Poly(ethylene oxide) assumes a coil conformation when dissolved in water, but it assumes a helical conformation when dissolved in isobutyric acid along with trace amounts
SANS from Polymers
19
Figure 3. Pair distribution function for a poly(ethylene oxide) solution in d-water (left) and in disobutyric acid (right). This distribution was obtained through the Fourier transform of the SANS data. The distribution on the right is characteristic of a mixture of helix and coil phases.
of water. The helix-to-coil transition can be reversibly effected by adding/removing trace amounts of water. SANS and polarimetry measurements were used to investigate the helical and coil structures in various solvent and temperature conditions.5 A number of data analysis methods and software packages were used to analyze the SANS data. These included standard plots (such as the Porod plot), fits to cylindrical structure models (to represent the helical structure), and inverse Fourier transform of the data to obtain a pair distribution function p(r). Porod exponents close to 1 were observed for rod-like (helical) structures at low-Q and close to 5/3 for swollen polymer coils. Note that the helical structures are characterized by high-Q Porod exponents close to 4 (smooth rod surfaces). The pair distribution functions showed pure coil phases for PEO/d-water and helical phases in PEO/d-isobutyric acid (Fig. 3). Mixtures of coil and helical phases were observed for high molecular weight PEO/d-isobutyric acid. The helical structure in solution was reminiscent of the crystalline structure of pure PEO (whereby 7 monomeric units form 2 helical turns). Similar investigations were performed on another (similar) water-soluble polymer, poly(ethylene imine), referred to as PEI [–CH2 CH2 NH–]n both in d-water and in d-isobutyric acid and similar conclusions were obtained. The helical structures were better developed with PEI than with PEO. The partitioning of PEO in water/isobutyric acid solvent mixtures was further investigated using SANS. Low molecular weight polymers (with Mw < 10 kg/mol) were seen to prefer dissolving in the isobutyric acid rich (top) phase and higher molecular weight ones end up mostly in the water (bottom) phase. Investigations of the phase boundaries for the PEO/water/ isobutyric acid ternary mixture were conducted.6 It was found that the addition of PEO tends to favor demixing in water/isobutyric acid solvent mixtures. Similar conclusions were obtained using star branched PEO instead of linear PEO. The early stages of crystallization of (low-molecular weight) polyethylene in d-xylene solutions were investigated by SANS.8 Crystallization was obtained upon cooling from the melt state (at 120◦ C) down to temperatures varying from 110◦ C to 85◦ C. Very early stages of crystal growth were investigated. The SANS technique was found to be sensitive to crystal volume fractions as small as 10−5. This sensitivity is much better than for SAXS where
20
B. Hammouda
low-Q background interferes with the useful signal. SAXS is the main diagnostic tool for investigations of polymer crystallization. Two competing modes of early-stage crystallization were presented with either spinodal decomposition or nucleation-and-growth as the driving force. The high sensitivity SANS measurements reported here favor the nucleation-andgrowth (crystal seeding-and-growth would be a better name) mechanism. Investigations of the late-stage crystal growth with well-formed lamellae were also discussed. Poly(ethylene oxide) forms a crystalline structure when dissolved in ethanol. SANS investigations were conducted on dilute and semidilute solutions of PEO/d-ethanol for temperatures above and below the crystallization temperature.9 Above the crystal melting temperature, fully-swollen polymer coils were observed while below the crystallization temperature, a sponge-like lamellar morphology was reported. DSC, WAXS, and confocal microscopy confirmed the SANS findings. The PEO/d-ethanol phase diagram showing both the crystallization and the extrapolated spinodal line has been mapped out. The extrapolated upper critical solution temperature (UCST) was found to be well below the crystallization temperature and therefore unreachable. The addition of a small amount of d-water to the PEO/d-ethanol mixture was found to destroy the crystalline morphology and yield regular polymer solution behavior. The phase diagram was seen to change to a lower critical solution temperature (LCST) when the water amount is increased.
5. Copolymers There are three categories of SANS investigations from copolymers; these used pure copolymers, copolymers in solution, and copolymers added to blends. These categories are represented here. The conformation of polymer chains in regular symmetric multiblock copolymers was investigated using SANS measurements from previously sheared samples.10 Symmetric copolymers tend to form lamellar structures which, when sheared, tend to align according to the “parallel” or A alignment (lamellae oriented in the shear/shear gradient plane) or the “perpendicular” C alignment (lamellae orientated in the shear/vorticity plane). The B alignment (lamellae oriented in the shear gradient/vorticity plane) is never observed under shear; it is observed only after shear cessation. The undecablock (containing 10 blocks) of poly(cyclohexylethylene) and poly(ethylene propylene) was used for these investigations. Mixtures of undecablocks and deuterated undecablocks (in equal fractions) were prepared in order to separate out scattering from the multiblock structure (characterized by an interblock Bragg peak) and scattering from partially deuterated polymer chain conformations (characterized by the radius of gyration for the entire copolymer). The Guinier plot at low scattering variable Q was used to measure this radius of gyration. These investigations showed that polymer chains tend to align in the B alignment plane when lamellae are aligned along the C alignment plane. Shear cessation relaxes the stretched copolymers into a 3D random walk spread out over many lamellar microdomains. The SANS technique was used to investigate vesicle formation when a poly(ethylene oxide)-poly(butylene oxide) diblock copolymer (EO6 BO11 ) is dissolved in water.12 The hydrophobic nature of the BO block drives the vesicle formation. At low diblock fraction and temperature, a wormlike micelle phase is observed. This is characterized by a 1/Q Porod behavior at low-Q (cylindrical structures). As the diblock fraction or temperature is increased, unilamellar, then multilamellar vesicles form. These are characterized by a 1/Q2 Porod behavior at low-Q (2D structures) and a Bragg peak at high-Q. At even higher diblock fraction or temperature, the vesicles form a lamellar phase. Indirect Fourier transform of the SANS data produced pair correlation functions which yielded estimates of vesicle sizes.
SANS from Polymers
21
Figure 4. Variation of the d-spacing (left) and of its ratio to the swelling asymmetry factor d/ξ for the PS-PDMS diblock copolymer in CO2 .
A morphology phase diagram (temperature versus diblock copolymer fraction in d-water) was mapped out. Pressurized CO2 plays the role of a selective solvent in a polystyrene-poly(dimethyl siloxane) diblock copolymer.16 This PS-PDMS copolymer is characterized by lamellar morphology with well-defined interdomain d-spacing. This d-spacing is inversely proportional to the scattering peak position. The SANS technique is useful for the characterization of this d-spacing as well as estimation of the various Flory-Huggins interaction parameters between each of the blocks (PS or PDMS) and the solvent (CO2 ) and between the two blocks (PS-PDMS). The swelling conditions are described by swollen block volume fractions fPS/CO2 and fPDMS/CO2 . These are determined from an equation-of-state for the swelling of the pure components (PS and PDMS) in CO2 along with the Flory-Huggins equation for polymer/solvent mixtures. Their ratio defines a swelling asymmetry factor ξ = fPS/CO2 /fPDMS/CO2 . SANS data were taken from the PS-PDMS diblock copolymer under CO2 pressure for three temperatures (40◦ C, 100◦ C, and 140◦ C). It was noted that whereas the interlamellar d-spacing (noted d) varies with the copolymer volume fraction φ diblock differently for each temperature, the ration d/ξ follows the same power law for all temperatures (Fig. 4). The microphase behavior for a series of poly(styrene sulfonate)-poly(methyl butylene) diblock copolymers was investigated using the SAXS and SANS techniques.17 High resolution of the SAXS technique allows the indexing of numerous Bragg reflections and therefore the possibility of resolving a wide range of ordered diblock copolymer microstructures. The observed copolymer morphologies include lamellae, gyroid, hexagonally perforated lamellae, and hexagonally packed cylinders. These morphologies were obtained by varying the copolymer molecular weight and sulfonation level as well as temperature. This range of morphologies was obtained with nearly symmetric diblock copolymers. TEM images confirmed some of the observed morphologies. SANS data were taken to estimate the Flory-Huggins interaction parameter which was used to predict the order-disorder transition conditions.
22
B. Hammouda
Figure 5. Phase diagram for the PEP/PBO/PEP-PBO ternary mixture for increasing copolymer fraction (left); i.e., along the isopleth line which is depicted within the triangle phase diagram (right).
The ternary phase diagram for a polymer mixture consisting of two homopolymers, poly(ethylene propylene) and poly(butylene oxide), and their diblock copolymer PEP-PBO has been investigated using a host of characterization methods that include SANS, smallangle x-ray scattering (SAXS), rheology, and optical microscopy.18 Deuterated PEP was used in order to enhance the SANS contrast. A ternary phase diagram similar to the one for a nonionic surfactant/water/oil micellar system was mapped out close to the isopleth line (line for equal homopolymer fractions but with increasing copolymer fraction). The upper critical binodal line for the PEP/PBO binary blend was also mapped out. Along the isopleth line, the phase separation boundaries between the mixed phase, the macrophase separated region, and the microphase separated region were delimited. Within the microphase separation region, the order-to-order phase transition lines for the lamellar and hexagonal microphases were obtained (note that no cubic phase was observed). SAXS was effective at differentiating the ordered phases. The macrophase separation region contains two-phase droplets (rich in PEP or PBO with PEP-PBO forming the boundary between them) and three-phase droplets (rich in PEP, in PBO, or in PEP-PBO). The SANS technique was useful for the characterization of a narrow bicontinuous microemulsion channel obtained for high copolymer fraction (80%) and high temperature (around 120◦ C). The Teubner-Strey model was used to fit the SANS data (Fig. 5). A-C diblock copolymers were mixed to weakly-segregated A/B homopolymer blends. Components A, B, and C used were polybutadiene (89% 1,2 addition), polyisobutylene and polybutadiene (63% 1,2 addition) respectively.19 The C block was characterized by attractive interactions with the B block but repulsive interactions with the A block. This SANS study showed that organized domains form with the addition of as little as 1% A-C diblock to a 50%/50% A/B blend. SANS data were taken from a series of samples for which the copolymer fraction as well as its molecular weight were varied. The random phase approximation (RPA) model was used to analyze SANS data in the homogeneous (mixed) phase region. The Teubner-Strey (TS) model and a self-consistent-field theory
SANS from Polymers
23
(SCFT) were used in the ordered microphase region. The RPA approach yielded FloryHuggins interaction parameters and mean-field phase boundary predictions. The TS model and the SCFT approach yielded predictions of characteristic microdomain d-spacings as observed by SANS. The combination of measurements and models produced reasonable agreement for most of the probed range except for the case with very small copolymer fractions where there is room for improvement.
6. Polymer Blends Polymer blends constitute another active area of SANS research. The SANS technique is sensitive to density and composition fluctuations and is therefore a good thermodynamic probe for investigation of phase transitions in blends. The same polymer blend A/B/A-C discussed before19 was used to investigate the effects of pressure on phase transitions.20 Block C is characterized by repulsive interactions with block A and attractive interactions with block B. At ambient pressure, the blend forms a lamellar microphase at low temperature, a bicontinuous microemulsion phase at intermediate temperature, and is macrophase separated at high temperature. The same blend, however, exhibits a mixed (homogeneous) phase when pressurized. This behavior was traced to intricate dependences of the Flory-Huggins interaction parameters on temperature and pressure; χ AC (positive) decreased with temperature but did not change with pressure, χ BC (negative) increased with temperature but decreased (became more negative) with pressure, and χ AB (positive) increased with temperature but decreased with pressure. The random phase approximation (RPA) and the self-consistent-field theory (SCFT) were used to analyze SANS data with in-situ pressure. The Teubner-Strey model was also used to fit data in the microemulsion phase region. A pressure-temperature phase diagram was mapped out showing boundaries between the microphase separation, the macrophase separation, and the homogeneous mixed-phase regions (Fig. 6). The observation that pressure induces the formation of a homogeneous phase (favoring mixing) in the A/B/A-C polymer blend is contrary to the observed effect of pressure in nonionic surfactant/water/oil ternary mixtures where pressure tends to favor demixing. The SANS technique can map out both the binodal line and the spinodal line. The binodal line is reached when the intercept of the Zimm plot I−1(0) becomes negative (here I(0) is the scattering intensity in the forward Q = 0 direction). The spinodal line is obtained by extrapolating the I−1(0) versus T−1 linear behavior to the limit I−1(0) = 0 (here T is the absolute sample temperature). This helps delimit the nucleation-and-growth region located between the binodal and spinodal lines. Growth kinetics were studied by SANS from a deuterated poly(methylbutylene)/poly(ethylbutylene) off-critical polyolefin blend sample following pressure jumps from the homogeneous (mixed) phase region into the nucleation-and-growth region.21 Pressure jumps are more rapid than temperature jumps and therefore more effective. Prior to jump experiments, the pressure-temperature phase diagram (showing both the binodal and spinodal lines) was mapped out for the same dPMB/PEB blend. Nucleation-and-growth kinetics measurements were performed for a number of pressure jumps and for many quench depths. Both single jumps and double jumps were performed. In the case of double jumps, the first jump was deep into the nucleation-and-growth region (to form the nucleation seeds) and the second jump was shallow (to follow the growth kinetics). Critical nucleus sizes and the times required to conclude the early stage of nucleation were measured. These were obtained from the time-dependent SANS intensity characterizing the growth kinetics.
24
B. Hammouda
Figure 6. SANS data from A/B/A-C polyolefin blend mixture of two homopolymers A/B and a diblock copolymer A-C under pressure (0.3 kbar) and for a sample temperature of 50 ◦ C (left) and pressure-temperature phase diagram (right). The Teubner-Strey model yields good model fit to the SANS data in the bicontinuous (microphase separated) phase region. The error bars correspond to one standard deviation.
SANS studies were performed to assess the possibility of swelling for high molecular weight “tracer” polymers (poly(ethylene oxide) and poly(methyl methacrylate) in low molecular weight polymer matrix.23 The same polymers (PEO and PMMA) were used for the matrix component. Three matrices were considered—pure PEO, pure PMMA, and 50%/50% (mass fractions) PEO/PMMA blend. Deuterated polymers were used for the tracer polymers and hydrogenated polymers were used for the matrix polymers. Low tracer polymer fractions were used. Measurement temperatures were chosen to be above the crystal meting temperature of PEO and above the glass-rubber transition temperature of PMMA. The SANS intensity was fit to a Debye function (form factor for unperturbed coils) in order to extract a radius of gyration in each case. The tracer polymers were found to follow unperturbed coil configurations in all cases; no chain swelling was observed.
7. Branched or Grafted Polymers Many investigations on SANS from branched or grafted polymers have been reported. These include single generation branching (stars and combs) as well as multi-generation branching (dendrimers and arborescent graft polymers). Polymer chain architecture plays a role in the mixing behavior of polymer blends. A systematic investigation has been undertaken24 using a series of branched polystyrene macromolecules (Fig. 7) with either varying number of branch points (and fixed number of chain ends) or varying number of chain ends (and fixed number of branch points). All polystyrene macromolecules were carefully synthesized and characterized. They all correspond to the same molecular weight. Blends were prepared using 50%/50% mixtures of linear deuterated polystyrene and branched (hydrogenated) polystyrenes. SANS data were taken from the two groups of blend samples at various temperatures. Random phase approximation (RPA) equations for blend mixtures of linear and specifically branched
SANS from Polymers
25
Figure 7. Polymer chain architectures with increasing number of branch points (left) or with increasing number of chain ends (right).
polymers were used to obtain an effective Flory-Huggins interaction parameter χ eff in each case. Partial form factors corresponding to the various regular branching architectures were used as inputs to the RPA fitting approach. The results showed that χ eff increases with increasing number of branch points (group I) and with increasing number of chain ends (group II). Branching seems to favor demixing in polymer blends. A Gaussian field theory was successful in predicting the overall χ eff trend for group II but not for group I. Arborescent graft polymers containing hyperbranched structures with a polystyrene comb-like backbone and poly(2-vinyl pyridine) chains grafted onto the “teeth” of the comb were investigated in either deuterated water or deuterated methanol dilute solutions.26 SANS and dynamic light scattering (DLS) were used to characterize the “fast” mode representing the local polyelectrolyte structure and the “slow” mode representing longrange clustering. SANS data showed a polyelectrolyte peak only when the pH was changed by adding hydrochloric acid. This peak is due to the so-called correlation-hole effect and is characteristic of an average distance between charged domains. The peak position scales like polymer fraction to the third power owing to the spherical (3D) symmetry of arborescent polyelectrolytes. Note that for linear polyelectrolytes, the peak position scales like the square root of the polymer fraction (2D symmetry). When enough acid is added to completely neutralize the charges on the P2VP blocks, the polyelectrolyte peak disappears again. Arborescent polymers with longer P2VP grafted blocks resulted in the formation of a gel for fractions greater than 1% mass fraction. The mean spherical approximation model for charged spheres was used to analyze the SANS data when long-range Coulomb interactions are present. Arborescent polymer sizes and degree of chain swelling were investigated using arborescent polystyrenes with two different size polystyrene side chains (with either 5K or 30K molecular weight) in dilute d-toluene solutions. Generations from G0 to G3 were measured using the SANS technique.27 A radius of gyration was obtained from the Guinier
26
B. Hammouda
Figure 8. Representation of an arborescent copolymer corresponding to two generations (plus backbone) of h-polystyrene onto which one generation of d-polystyrene was grafted. The h-polystyrene forms the “core” structure whereas the outer d-polystyrene forms the “shell” structure. When the solvent is hydrogenated, only the shell is visible (left) while when the solvent is deuterated, only the core is visible (right).
and the Kratky data analyses methods and compared to the Zimm-Stockmayer model for branched polymer systems with different architectures. This model gives reasonable agreement for the case with short (5 K) side branches but not for the case with long (30 K) side branches. The measured radius of gyration scales with molecular weight for the various generations like Rg ∼ Mw 0.26 for short side branches and Rg ∼ Mw 0.32 for long side branches. Arborescent polymers with long side branches act like compact particles with tight packing. The influence of polymer-solvent interactions on Rg was expressed in terms of the expansion factor due to excluded volume. Swelling effects were clearly observed for short side chains but not for long side chains. Inverse Fourier transforms of the SANS data yielded pair distance distribution functions p(r) which contain information about internal arborescent particle inhomogeneities within the core and within the shell regions. Furthermore, arborescent polymers were synthesized using hydrogenated polystyrene for the core and deuterated polystyrene for the side branches. This helped realize solvent contrast match conditions for either the hydrogenated core or the deuterated shell (Fig. 8) using solvents with more convenient scattering length densities (THF and cyclohexane and their deuterated versions). The higher generation arborescent polymers showed a better-defined core-shell structure than the lower generation ones. Comblike copolymers with polynorbornene (PNB) backbone and oligo ethylene glycol (OEG) side chains were measured in dilute d-water solutions.30 The diblock copolymer consists of a (hydrophobic) block with short OEG3 chains and the other (hydrophilic) block with long OEG6.6 chains. SANS measurements were performed over a temperature range between 25◦ C and 68◦ C. At 25◦ C, the copolymers were found to associate into micelles with the hydrophobic block forming an inner spherical core and the hydrophilic block forming cylindrical structures within the outer shell. As the temperature is increased, even long OE G6.6 chains become hydrophobic and phase separation occurs at the cloud point temperature of 60◦ C. Above this temperature, a transition to another phase characterized by sharp Bragg d-spacing of 349 Å is observed. A hybrid model for micelles with spherical core and cylindrical “spokes” radiating out to form the shell was used to analyze the SANS data for low temperatures. A scattering density profile for the micellar shell was obtained
SANS from Polymers
27
along with an aggregation number. The aggregation number was found to increase and the micellar size was found to decrease with increasing temperature. This is due to the increasing hydrophobicity of OEG chains upon heating. The hydrophilic block of the previously described diblock copolymer was used to investigate solvent effects in d-toluene and d-water dilute solutions.31 This corresponds to 50 monomers of norbornene backbone (NB) and oligo ethylene glycol side chains (OEG6.6 ). Four polymer fractions in the dilute solution range and four temperatures between 25◦ C and 74◦ C were measured by SANS. Chain dimensions (radius of gyration) and polymer-solvent interactions (second virial coefficient) were obtained from the familiar Zimm plot for dilute polymer solutions. Polymer chains were seen to follow random-coil conformations at low temperature and low polymer fraction when dissolved in d-toluene. Polymers were found to contract with increasing polymer fraction. Deuterated water is a selective solvent for the OEG blocks which tend to take a cylindrical shape forming the teeth of the comblike polymer. The theta temperature was estimated to be 45◦ C. At 74◦ C, hydrophobic interactions take over and most of the polymer precipitates out of solution (in d-water).
8. Polymer Gels Polymer gels form when crosslinking is introduced. The various microstructures formed are in the nanometer length scale making the SANS technique a useful characterization method. Gels were formed through (electron beam) radiation crosslinking of two diblock copolymers; poly(α-methylstyrene)-polyisoprene (PaMS-PI) and poly(vinylferrocenium triflate)-polyisoprene (PVFT-PI). Radiation crosslinks the PI blocks, induces chain scission in the PaMS blocks, and has no effect on the PVFT blocks. Swelling of the formed gels in partially deuterated solvents allowed the characterization of the crosslink density as function of the radiation dose by SANS, as well as by standard gel characterization methods.35 This allowed characterization of the copolymer microdomain morphology in the presence of crosslinks. It was found, for instance, that uncrosslinked PaMS blocks play an important role in the swelling behavior of PaMS-PI gels. Chain scission in PaMS seems to release stresses that may appear during gel formation. It was also found that chains in the PVFT blocks undergo stretching as the gel crosslinking becomes tighter. Information about solvent partitioning in the two swollen gels was obtained. Solvent-filled open channels were observed in the PaMS-PI gels whereas large length-scale clustering was observed in PVFT-PI gels. Poly(vinyl alcohol) hydrogels were formed by introducing physical crosslinks consisting of small ice crystals. These were created through freeze/thaw cycles. Samples that were stretched after the first cycle remained oriented. The PVA hydrogels are intended for potential use in biomedical applications. Their morphology and stress response were investigated using SANS and mechanical testing.36 Other characterization methods were also used (SAXS, TEM, C-13 NMR, etc.). The Debye-Bueche model was used to obtain a correlation length characterizing the average distance between crosslinks. The Teubner-Strey model was also used to obtain a correlation length along with a quasi-periodic d-pacing characterizing the hydrogel network at the local level. The dominant low-Q feature of the SANS signal was fitted to a power law behavior to represent long-range correlations. SANS results showed that the PVA hydrogel comprises a polymer-rich local phase formed
28
B. Hammouda
Figure 9. Representation of the flower-like spherical micelle (left) and lamellar micelle (right) formed of triblock copolymers where the central block is hydrophilic and the outer blocks are hydrophobic.
of nanopores 150 to 300 Å in size surrounded by a larger overall structure containing micron size morphology. This structure is held together through the small crystal crosslinks. PLA-PEO-PLA triblock copolymers are formed of hydrophyllic poly(ethylene oxide) blocks and hydrophobic poly(lactide) blocks. Since the hydrophilic block is the middle block, a flowerlike structure is obtained in water solution (Fig. 9). SANS measurements were made from PLA-PEO-PLA solutions in order to understand the morphology as function of PLA block length and stereospecifity.38 It was found that spherical micelles form when amorphous D/L-lactic acid blocks are used whereas lamellar micelles form when crystalline L-lactic acid blocks are used. Moreover, an increase in the triblock fraction (in d-water solutions) leads to gel formation. SANS data were analyzed using single micelle form factors and inter-micelle structure factors. In the case of spherical micelles, the familiar Percus-Yevick solution of the Ornsterin-Zernike equation was used while in the case of lamellar micelles, a lamellar stack model introduced to interpret data from lamellar stacks in crystalline polymers in solution was used. Micellar sizes and inter-distances were obtained. The association characteristics of the micelles were found to be controlled by the length and crystallinity of the PLA blocks. Double-network hydrogels formed of a charged crosslinked polymer network (PAMPS) and neutral linear polyacrylamide (PAA) polymers were investigated using the SANS and Ultra-SANS techniques.40 The USANS technique can probe size scales up to 20 µm. Deuterated PAA and d-water were used in order to enhance the neutron contrast. Investigation of PAMPS solutions in d-water and of PAMPS/d-PAA solutions in mixtures of d-water and h-water were conducted in order to measure the various Flory-Huggins interaction parameters for the various components. It was found that χ PAMPS/PAA χ PAMS/water < χ PAA/water . Measurements from PAMPS/d-PAA/d-water were also taken from the fully formed double-network hydrogels. A random phase approximation model that incorporates charge interactions (through a Debye-Huckel factor) and a crosslinked network (though a characteristic mesh size) was used to fit the SANS data. This model reproduces the high-Q SANS data well and yields some understanding of double-network hydrogel structures at the molecular level.
SANS from Polymers
29
Figure 10. Inhomogeneous structure of PAA (left) and PAMPS (right) polymerized in water as inferred from SANS data.
9. Polymer Networks The boundary between gels and networks is fuzzy. These appellations could be used interchangeably. Gels usually form beyond a sol-gel transition which is reversible while networks are usually not reversible; they involve covalent crosslinking. The PAMPS/PAA double-network hydrogel described earlier40 was used to understand the molecular origin of some unusual mechanical properties (Fig. 10). In-situ SANS investigations were undertaken using samples deformed in a compression device.41 Molecular conformations of the deuterated PAA chains were monitored. Possible molecular origin of the correlation between enhancement in solution viscosity and fracture toughness of crosslinked gels was discussed. It was argued that molecular association between the PAMPS and PAA components of the double-network could be at the origin of the unusual mechanical performance. The attractive interactions between these two polymers could explain the increased toughness of these polymeric materials. Polymer blends consisting of stiff liquid crystalline polyurethane and flexible polystyrene-poly(vinyl phenol) copolymers form hydrogen bonded networks characterized by a wide miscibility window.45 The polystyrene blocks were deuterated to enhance the neutron contrast. SANS measurements from the pure copolymer and with increasing amount of polyurethane allowed the monitoring of crystalline polyurethane chain conformations within an amorphous flexible polymer matrix. FTIR studies showed clear evidence of hydrogen-bonding between the two network components. Increasing the polyurethane fraction succeeded in breaking down the network of hydrogen bonds and led to the formation of new large-scale structures. The semiflexible polyurethane chains assume anisotropic conformations as observed by the SANS high-Q data and fits to the Kratky-Porod wormlike chain model. Interpenetrating polymer networks (IPNs) are formed through the in-situ synthesis of a network within the matrix of another. The state of miscibility of the mixed components during synthesis dictates the resulting network morphology. SANS and dynamic mechanical thermal analysis (DMTA) were performed on a series of methacrylate/epoxy interpenetrating polymer networks in order to assess the extent of molecular miscibility.46 SANS is sensitive to composition fluctuations and DMTA can measure the glass-rubber transition temperatures (Tg s) for polymeric materials precisely. A single Tg is a signature of a homogeneously mixed phase while two Tg s point to a demixed two-phase system. The
30
B. Hammouda
Debye-Bueche model was used to interpret SANS data from the interpenetrating polymer networks and yielded a phase separation size scale of order 180 Å. DMTA of the rubbery region of some of the IPNs revealed bicontinuous structures and the extent of phase separation. A number of amphiphilic co-networks of methacrylic acid (MAA) and 2-butyl-1-octyl methacrylate (BOMA) were synthesized and characterized using a host of methods.48 Some were model co-networks containing A-B-A copolymer chains between cross-links of precise length and composition. Here the A block contains multiple MAA monomers and the B block contains multiple BOMA monomers. The linear co-network precursors used in the group transfer polymerization were characterized by GPC and NMR for their molecular weight and composition. The degree of swelling of these amphiphilic polymer co-networks was investigated in water and in THF over a broad ionization range of the MAA monomers. It was found that the degree of swelling in water increased with the degree of ionization and the size of the MAA blocks. The degree of swelling in THF also increased with the length of the copolymers between cross-link points. The SANS technique and atomic force microscopy were used to characterize the co-network morphology.
10. Polymer Micelles Water-soluble polymers can form nonionic micelles owing to their hydrophobic/ hydrophilic characteristics. Here also, the SANS technique has been an effective tool for the characterization of structure and miscibility. Wormlike micelles are formed using trimethylammonium cations and 4-vinylbenzoate counterions in aqueous solution. The resulting polymer-surfactant aggregates were polymerized to obtain rodlike ionic micelles.49 The micelle radius was controlled by varying the hydrocarbon length on the trimethylammonium and its length was controlled by varying the initiator decomposition half-life. This was done by varying temperature or using different initiators. The micelle radius was varied between 17 Å and 24 Å and its length was varied between 800 Å and 5000 Å as characterized by SANS measurements. This approach yielded stable polymerized rodlike micelles with controllable sizes that are independent of surfactant concentration (provided that it is higher than the critical micelle concentration). Long polymerized micelles were obtained using low initiator content and low temperature. Free radical polymerization of the mixture of cetyltrimethylammonium (CTVB) and sodium 4-styrenesulfonate (NaSS) in aqueous solution produced stable rodlike particles (Fig. 11) with controlled surface charge density.51 Rodlike particle dimensions were
Figure 11. Chemical representation of CTVB and NaSS (left) and schematic representation of the polymerized rodlike micelle (right).
SANS from Polymers
31
characterized by SANS; the diameter was found to be constant (equal to 40 Å) and the length varied between 240 Å and 850 Å depending on NaSS concentration. When the NaSS concentration was increased, the rodlike particle length increased then decreased. The longest particles were obtained at the charge neutralization condition. Zeta potential measurements were also performed to characterize NaSS charge effects. Polymer micelles were formed using an A-C diblock copolymer (acting as surfactant) mixed with A and B homopolymers. The C block was characterized by repulsive interactions with the A block but attractive interactions with the B block.56 This project was also included in earlier sections (SANS from copolymers and blends). The SANS technique was effective at mapping out a microphase separation region, a macrophase separation (twophase) region, and a homogeneously mixed (one-phase) region in-between. The random phase approximation (RPA), the self-consistent-field theory (SCFT) and Teubner-Strey (TS) model were used to analyze the SANS data. Reasonable agreements were found. Small molecule surfactants cause the melting of polymeric micelles formed of amphiphilic diblock copolymers. The poly(butylacrylate)-poly(acrylic acid) (PBA-PAA) diblock forms micelles in aqueous solution. Neutral or ionic surfactants (such as C12E6 for example) break the polymer micelles as documented by light scattering (SLS and DLS), SAXS, SANS, cryo-TEM, and capillary electrophoresis;58 they reduce the interfacial tension and gradually produce two populations—one rich in large polymer micelles and one rich in small surfactant micelles. Before adding small surfactants, fits of a core-shell model to SANS data yielded an estimate of the core radius for the polymeric micelles around 80 Å (polydispersity of 0.2). After adding 1.5% mass fraction of C12E6 small molecule surfactant, the mean micelle radius decreased to 34 Å (polydispersity of 0.14). This size (34 Å) is very close to the size of pure-surfactant micelles. Simple interfacial tension arguments with and without surfactant permits the interpretation of the observed trends. A model hydrophobically modified polymer was used to crosslink wormlike micelles59 in water. Water-soluble poly(ethylene oxide) containing hydrocarbon tails (C14 to C22 ) at their ends was used to form bridges across wormlike micelles (1% mass fraction CTAT in water). SANS and rheology were used to characterize crosslinked network. The hydrophobic end groups stick to the wormlike micelles while PEO chains remain dissolved. Three types of PEO chains were used— 1. PEO chains with a sticker at one end, 2. PEO chains with a sticker at each end, and 3. 3-arm PEO stars with a sticker at each end. The wormlike micelles are likely breaking locally and reforming to shield the hydrophobic stickers from contact with water. The PEO chains form bridges between the wormlike micelles (Fig. 12). Pluronic triblock copolymers (PEO-PPO-PEO) form micellar structures at ambient temperatures. Spherical micelles formed when Pluronic F127 solutions in d-water (20% mass fraction) were sheared in a Couette shear cell. In-situ SANS investigations were performed using the radial and tangential neutron beam configurations.60 The spherical micelles were seen to form layered macrolattice structures characterized by single-crystal type scattering (with bright diffraction spots). Transition from face-centered cubic structure at low shear rates to random layer stacking at high shear rates was observed. This was the cause of the observed shear thinning behavior. A model comprising intra-layer sphere arrangement as well as inter-layer structure was used to interpret the SANS data under shear. This model incorporated oriented stacks of micellar layers and allowed for disorder
32
B. Hammouda
Figure 12. Two possible clustering configurations. There is evidence that the configuration on the left is more likely than the one on the right.
effects; it reproduced the observed cubic structures and a transition to random layer stacking leading to a hexagonal phase. The SANS technique was used to investigate the structure of polystyrene-poly(acrylic acid, sodium salt) copolymers in water solution under Couette and plate-plate shear.63 This investigation reported a wide range of copolymer fractions in water solution using PSPAA of Mn = 4,700–11,300 g/mol. Since the polystyrene block is hydrophobic, wormlike micelles form. These were found to form hexagonally close-packed cylinders under shear with the cylinder axis parallel to the shear gradient direction; i.e., perpendicular to the shear flow direction. SAXS and electron microcopy confirmed the oriented cylinders structure. Evidence for bridging between cylinders was reported. This may be due to the long PAA block length and some clustering driving force which depends on the cylindrical micelle fraction.
11. Polymeric Nanomaterials This is a category gathering SANS investigations from various materials including those described here. SANS from mixtures of deuterated and non-deuterated isotopic blends is a good monitor of chain orientation in (for instance) injection-molded samples. A series of isotopic polystyrene blends has been injection molded, while varying a number of experimental conditions, including injection molding speed, mold thickness, and mold temperature.64 Elliptical averaging of the anisotropic 2D data yielded an eccentricity factor which is a measure of the degree of chain orientation. This eccentricity factor was found to decrease with injection speed, mold thickness, and injection molding temperature. It was also found to decrease with the length scale probed showing that nano-stresses acting upon polymer chains relax at the local chain segment level. SANS and x-ray reflectometry have been used to characterize the porosity of a poly(phenylene) low-k dielectric thin film material.65 This material contains porogen which degrades upon baking at elevated temperatures thereby forming the pores. Three baking temperatures were used (150◦ C, 400◦ C, and 430◦ C). Since the thickness of each film was around 1 micron, many wafers were stacked in order to enhance the SANS signal. The
SANS from Polymers
33
Figure 13. Porosity representation of the low-k dielectric material containing porogen after baking at 400◦ C without (left) and with solvent contrast match (right). The partially deuterated solvent vapor matches the scattering length density of the matrix and fills the pores making them invisible.
samples were placed in a custom-built flow-through cell in order to control the vapor pressure. Mixtures of deuterated and non-deuterated methanol or toluene solvent vapors were used to adjust the neutron contrast by filling the pores (Fig. 13). The pore size distribution and pore fraction were determined for each baking strategy. The fraction of porogen that remains in the low-k films was estimated and found to decrease with baking temperature. Body armors are made out of high strength material containing poly(p-phenylene-2,6benzobisoxazole) fibers. An extensive study of such material aged at elevated temperatures for extended periods of time (around half a year) was conducted using a battery of characterization methods including mechanical testing (tensile strength measurements), SANS, FTIR, atomic force microscopy, and confocal microscopy.66 A 30% decrease in yarn tensile strength upon aging in humid environment was correlated with the hydrolysis of specific chemical groups as observed by FTIR. When aging was performed in an inert (argon) environment, this decrease went down to 4%. This demonstrates that moisture is a key factor in fiber degradation. SANS studies were conducted on composites formed of isotopic polystyrene blends mixed with silica nanoparticles under contrast match condition.69 It was found that polymer chain conformations follow unperturbed Gaussian chain statistics regardless of polymer molecular weight and nanoparticle loading. The polymer reference interaction site model (RISM) was used to model polymer/nanoparticle interactions.
12. Polymer Membranes The hydrogen fuel cell technology has become an active SANS area of research. Fuel cells use hydrogen to produce electricity. Hydrogen fuel is channeled to the anode on one side while oxygen is channeled to the cathode on the other side. At the anode, a catalyst causes hydrogen to ionize into protons and electrons. The polymer membrane allows only the protons to pass through to the cathode. The electrons, on the other hand, travel along an external circuit thereby generating an electrical current (Fig. 14). SANS has been used to characterize the structure of some polymer membranes.
34
B. Hammouda
Figure 14. Schematics of a hydrogen fuel cell (left) and bicontinuous morphology of a polymer membrane (right).
Poly(perfluorosulfonic acid) also referred to as Nafion is a fuel cell membrane material. SANS investigations have been conducted on Nafion membranes in an in-situ vapor sorption cell used to control the relative humidity.71 Different membrane processing conditions (melt extrusion or solvent casting), thermal pretreatment histories, and submicron membrane thicknesses were studied. The SANS data showed features characterizing semicrystalline copolymers and porous media with ion channels in the nanometer size range. A strong correlation was found between the interionic domain distance and the relative humidity. Diffusion coefficients of water vapor were estimated based on the observed structural evolution. Diblock copolymer films composed of a fluorocarbon block and a sulfonated polystyrene block were investigated by SANS and TEM.73 These are the potential proton exchange membranes for low-temperature fuel cells. Two hierarchical structure levels were observed—one due to the block copolymer microstructure and one due to the charged domains structure. The copolymer microstructure shows clearly fluorous domains and sulfonated polystyrene (darker) domains by TEM. Longer and partially sulfonated polystyrene blocks yield well-ordered microdomains, whereas shorter and fully sulfonated polystyrene blocks yield more disordered structures. Polystyrene sulfonate-b-poly(methyl butytlene) block copolymers have also been investigated as potential membrane material for hydrogen fuel cells.75 The microdomain morphology was controlled by varying the molecular weight of the polystyrene sulfonate (PSS) block and therefore the size of the hydrophilic proton channels. A drastic trend reversal was observed for channel sizes around 50 Å. The proton conductivity was found to decrease with increasing temperature for channel sizes higher than 50 Å (i.e., when high molecular weight PSS blocks are used) and to increase with increasing temperature for channel sizes smaller than 50 Å (i.e., when low molecular weight PSS blocks are used).
SANS from Polymers
35
These findings were supported from evidence based on TEM and SANS studies. Some of these studies were conducted under systematic moisture control. The correlation between the moisture content and proton conductivity in these membranes was clearly demonstrated. The phase behavior of one of the above-described block copolymer PSS-PMB used as ion-containing membrane has been investigated as function of relative humidity (RH). The copolymer ion content (sulfonation level) represented by the ion-exchange capacity (IEC) parameter was varied as well as the membrane temperature.76 SAXS, TEM, SANS, DSC and water content measurements were used to probe the rich phase behavior. Indexing of the various SAXS Bragg peaks helps in structure determination. The disordered phase was observed for low IEC and low RH values, the gyroid phase was observed for high IEC and low RH values, whereas the lamellar phase was observed for high RH values.
13. Summary and Future Prospect Use of the SANS technique has been ever-growing in the area of polymer research. Improvements of SANS instrument capabilities, sophistication of data analysis methods, and the advent of judicious sample environments have brought about renewed interest over the past thirty years. One of the leading SANS research centers, the NCNR, operates two 30 m SANS instruments in the user mode. This attracts over 200 SANS users per year resulting in over 80 publications in refereed journals. Polymer research constitute about one-third of this effort. Increased demand for additional SANS beamtime is the driving force behind a major upgrade of the NCNR facility. This upgrade includes the construction of a higher resolution SANS instrument. The new 40 m VSANS instrument (V is for “very”) will lower the measurement range (Qmin ) by an order of magnitude without too much loss in neutron flux on sample. The new (lower) Qmin will be around 0.0002 Å−1 which will be achieved by using multiple-hole converging collimation. The measurement window of the VSANS instrument will overlap nicely with the Bonse-Hart USANS instrument. The new capability VSANS/USANS combination will cover 5 orders of magnitude in scattering variable. This will allow the probing of polymer structures from the near atomic (nanometer) scale to well into the optical (20 micrometers) size scale and will open up exciting new prospects for polymer research. Other neutron scattering facilities in the US, in Europe, as well as elsewhere are also thriving. The SANS technique is the major driving force fueling the success of these facilities.
Disclaimer/Acknowledegments Certain commercial equipment, instruments, or materials are identified in this paper to foster understanding. Such identification does not imply recommendation or endorsement by the National Institute of Standards and Technology, nor does it imply that the materials or equipments identified are necessarily the best available for the purpose. This work is based upon activities supported in part by the National Science Foundation under Agreement No. DMR-0454672.
References 1. Hammouda, B. Probing nanoscale structures—The SANS toolbox, 2009, available online at http:www.ncnr.nist.gov/staff/hammouda/the sans toolbox.pdf.
36
B. Hammouda
2. Yun, S. I.; Terao, K.; Hong, K.; Melnichenko, Y. B.; Wignall, G. D.; Britt, P. F.; Mays, J. W. “Solution properties of 1,3-cyclohexadiene polymers by laser light scattering and small-angle neutron scattering,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 897–899. 3. Hammouda, B. “Solvation characteristics of a model water-soluble polymer,” Journal of Polymer Science: Part B: Polymer Physics, 2006, 44, 3195–3199. 4. Hammouda, B., Ho, D. L. “Insight into chain dimensions in PEO/water solutions,” Journal of Polymer Science: Part B: Polymer Physics, 2007, 45, 2196–2200. 5. Norman, A. I.; Fei, Y.; Ho, D. L.; Greer, S. C. “Folding and unfolding of polymer helices in solution,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 2559–2567. 6. Norman, A. I.; Ho, D. L.; Greer, S. C. “Partitioning, fractionation, and conformations of star poly(ethylene glycol) in isobutyric acid and water,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 9628–9639. 7. Rahman, M. H.; Chen, C. Y.; Liao, S. C.; Chen, H. L.; Tsao, C. S.; Chen, J. H.; Liao, J. L.; Ivanov, V. A.; Chen, S. A. “Segmental alignment in the aggregate domains of poly(9,9-dioctylfluorene) in semidilute solution,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 6572–6578. 8. Wang, H. “SANS study of the early stages of crystallization in polyethylene solutions,” Polymer, 2006, 47, 4897–4900. 9. Ho, D. L.; Hammouda, B.; Kline, S. R.; Chen, W. R. “Unusual phase behavior in mixtures of poly(ethylene oxide) and ethyl Alcohol,” Journal of Polymer Science: Part B: Polymer Physics, 2006, 44, 557–564. 10. Wu, L.; Lodge, T. P.; Bates, F. S. “SANS determination of chain conformation in perpendicularaligned undecablock copolymer lamellae,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 294–299. 11. Foster, L. J. R.; Knott, R.; Sanguanchaipaiwong, V.; Holden, P. J. “Polyhydroxyalkanoate-based natural–synthetic hybrid copolymer films: A small-angle neutron scattering study,” Physica B, 2006, 385–386, 770–772. 12. Norman, A. I.; Ho, D. L.; Lee, J. H.; Karim, A. “Spontaneous formation of vesicles of diblock copolymer EO6BO11 in water: A SANS study,” J. Phys. Chem. B, 2006, 110, 62–67. 13. Triftaridou, A. I.; Vamvakaki, M.; Patrickios, C. S. “Cationic amphiphilic model networks based on symmetrical ABCBA pentablock terpolymers: Synthesis, characterization, and modeling,” Biomacromolecules, 2007, 8, 1615–1623. 14. Jacquin, M.; Muller, P.; Talingting-Pabalan, R.; Cottet, H.; Berret, J. F.; Futterer, T.; Th´eodoly, O. “Chemical analysis and aqueous solution properties of charged amphiphilic block copolymers PBA-b-PAA synthesized by MADIX,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2007, 316, 897–911. 15. Agrawal, S. K.; Sanabria-DeLong, N.; Jemian, P. R.; Tew, G. N.; Bhatia, S. R. “Microto nanoscale structure of biocompatible PLA-PEO-PLA hydrogels,” Langmuir, 2007, 23, 5039–5044. 16. Francis, T. J.; Vogt, B. D.; Wang, M. X.; Watkins, J. J. “Scaling of interdomain spacing of diblock copolymers in a selective diluent,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 2515–2519. 17. Park, M. J.; Balsara, N. P. “Phase behavior of symmetric sulfonated block copolymers,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 3678–3687. 18. Zhou, N.; Lodge, T. P.; Bates, F. S. “Influence of conformational asymmetry on the phase behavior of ternary homopolymer/block copolymer blends around the bicontinuous microemulsion channel,” J. Phys. Chem. B, 2006, 110, 3979–3989. 19. Ruegg, M. L.; Reynolds, B. J.; Lin, M. Y.; Lohse, D. J.; Balsara, N. P. “Minimizing the concentration of diblock copolymer needed to organize blends of weakly segregated polymers by tuning attractive and repulsive interactions,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 1207–1217. 20. Ruegg, M. L.; Reynolds, B. J.; Lin, M. Y.; Lohse, D. J.; Krishnamoorti, R., Balsara, N. P. “Effect of pressure on a multicomponent A/B/A-C polymer blend with attractive and repulsive interactions,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 355–365. 21. Patel, A. J.; Balsara, N. P. “Observing nucleation close to the binodal by perturbing metastable polymer blends,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 1675–1683. 22. Wanakule, N. S.; Nedoma, A. J.; Robertson, M. L.; Fang, X.; Jackson, A.; Garetz, B. A.; Balsara, N. P. “Characterization of micron-sized periodic structures in multicomponent polymer blends
SANS from Polymers
23. 24.
25.
26. 27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33. 34. 35.
36. 37.
38.
39. 40. 41.
37
by ultra-small-angle neutron scattering and optical microscopy,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 471–477. Zeroni, I.; Lodge, T. P. “Chain dimensions in poly(ethylene oxide)/poly(methyl methacrylate) blends,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 1050–1052. Lee, J. S.; Foster, M. D.; Wu, D. T. “Effects of branch points and chain ends on the thermodynamic interaction parameter in binary blends of regularly branched and linear polymers,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 5113–5121. Rathgeber, S.; Monkenbusch, M.; Hedrick, J. L.; Trollsas, M.; Gast, A. P. “Starlike dendrimers in solutions: Structural properties and internal dynamics,” The Journal of Chemical Physics, 2006, 125, 204908-1 to 204908-11. Yun, S. I.; Briber, R. M.; Kee, R. A.; Gauthier, M. “Dilute-solution structure of charged arborescent graft polymer,” Polymer, 2006, 47, 2750–2759. Yun, S. I.; Lai, K. C.; Briber, R. M.; Teertstra, S. J.; Gauthier, M.; Bauer, B. J. “Conformation of arborescent polymers in solution by small-angle neutron scattering: Segment density and core-shell morphology,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 175–183. Chen, W. R.; Porcar, L.; Liu, Y.; Butler, P. D.; Magid, L. J. “Small angle neutron scattering studies of the counterion effects on the molecular conformation and structure of charged G4 PAMAM dendrimers in aqueous solutions,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 5887–5898. Cheng, G.; Melnichenko, Y. B.; Wignall, G. D.; Hua, F.; Hong, K.; Mays, J. W. “Conformation of oligo(ethylene glycol) grafted polystyrene in dilute aqueous solutions,” Polymer, 2007, 48, 4108–4113. Cheng, G.; Hua, F.; Melnichenko, Y. B.; Hong, K.; Mays, J. W.; Hammouda, B.; Wignall, G. D. “Association and structure of thermosensitive comblike block copolymers in aqueous solutions,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 4824–4827. Cheng, G.; Hua, F.; Melnichenko, Y. B.; Hong, K.; Mays, J. W.; Hammouda, B.; Wignall, G. D. “Conformation of oligo(ethylene glycol) grafted poly(norbornene) in solutions: A small angle neutron scattering study” European Polymer Journal, 2008, 44, 2859–2864. Mortensen, K.; Gasser, U.; Gursel, S. A.; Scherer, G. G. “Structural characterization of radiationgrafted block copolymer films using SANS technique,” Journal of Polymer Science: Part B: Polymer Physics, 2008, 46, 1660–1668. Loizou, E.; Butler, P.; Porcar, L.; Schmidt, G. “Dynamic responses in nanocomposite hydrogels,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 1614–1619. Matos, M. A.; White, L. R.; Tilton, R. D. “Electroosmotically enhanced mass transfer through polyacrylamide gels,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2006, 300, 429–436. Durkee, D. A.; Gomez, E. D.; Ellsworth, M. W.; Bell, A. T.; Balsara, N. P. “Microstructure and solvent distribution in cross-linked diblock copolymer gels,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 5103–5110. Millon, L. E.; Nieh, M. P.; Hutter, J. L.; Wan, W. “SANS characterization of an anisotropic poly(vinyl alcohol) hydrogel with vascular applications,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 3655–3662. Jiang, J.; Malal, R.; Li, C.; Lin, M. Y.; Colby, R. H.; Gersappe, D.; Rafailovich, M. H.; Sokolov, J. C.; Cohn, D. “Rheology of thermoreversible hydrogels from multiblock associating copolymers,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 3646–3652. Agrawal, S. K.; Sanabria-DeLong, N.; Tew, G. N.; Bhatia, S. R. “Structural characterization of PLA-PEO-PLA solutions and hydrogels: Crystalline vs amorphous PLA domains,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 1774–1784. Tirumala, V. R.; Tominaga, T.; Lee, S.; Butler, P. D.; Lin, E. K.; Gong, J. P.; Wu, W. L. “Molecular model for toughening in double-network hydrogels,” J. Phys. Chem. B, 2008, 112, 8024–8031. Tominaga, T.; Tirumala, V. R.; Lee, S.; Lin, E. K.; Gong, J. P.; Wu, W. L. “Thermodynamic interactions in double-network hydrogels,” J. Phys. Chem. B, 2008, 112, 3903–3909. Tominaga, T.; Tirumala, V. R.; Lin, E. K.; Gong, J. P.; Furukawa, H.; Osada, Y.; Wu, W. L. “The molecular origin of enhanced toughness in doublenetwork hydrogels: A neutron scattering study,” Polymer, 2007, 48, 7449–7454.
38
B. Hammouda
42. Sun, Y. S.; Jeng, U. S.; Huang, Y. S.; Liang, K. S.; Lin, T. L.; Tsao, C. S. “Complementary SAXS and SANS for structural characteristics of a polyurethethane elastomer of low hard-segment content,” Physica B, 2006, 385–386, 650–652. 43. Li, Y. C.; Chen, K. B.; Chen, H. L.; Hsu, C. S.; Tsao, C. S.; Chen, J. H.; Chen, S. A. “Fractal aggregates of conjugated polymer in solution state,” Langmuir, 2006, 22, 11009–11015. 44. Burford, R. P.; Markotsis, M. G.; Knott, R. B. “Real-time SANS study of interpenetrating polymer network (IPN) formation,” Physica B, 2006, 385–386, 766–769. 45. Mehta, R.; Dadmun, M. D. “Small angle neutron scattering studies on miscible blends of poly(styrene-ran-vinyl phenol) with liquid crystalline polyurethane,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 8799–8807. 46. Dean, K. M.; Cook, W. D.; Lin, M. Y. “Small angle neutron scattering and dynamic mechanical thermal analysis of dimethacrylate/epoxy IPNs,” European Polymer Journal, 2006, 42, 2872–2887. 47. Kali, G.; Georgiou, T. K.; Ivan, B.; Patrickios, C. S.; Loizou, E.; Thomann, Y.; Tiller, J. C. “Synthesis and characterization of anionic amphiphilic model co-networks based on methacrylic acid and methyl methacrylate: Effects of composition and architecture,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 2192–2200. 48. Kali, G.; Georgiou, T. K.; Iv´an, B.; Patrickios, C. S.; Loizou, E.; Thomann, Y.; Tiller, J. C. “Synthesis and characterization of anionic amphiphilic model co-networks of 2-Butyl-1-octylmethacrylate and methacrylic acid: Effects of polymer composition and architecture,” Langmuir, 2007, 23, 10746–10755. 49. Gerber, M. J.; Walker, L. M. “Controlling dimensions of polymerized micelles: Micelle template versus reaction conditions,” Langmuir, 2006, 22, 941–948. 50. Kuntz, D. M.; Walker, L. M. “Solution behavior of rod-like polyelectrolyte-surfactant aggregates polymerized from wormlike micelles,” J. Phys. Chem. B, 2007, 111, 6417–6424. 51. Kim, T. H.; Choi, S. M.; Kline, S. R. “Polymerized rodlike nanoparticles with controlled surface charge density,” Langmuir, 2006, 22, 2844–2850. 52. Kim, T. H.; Doe, C.; Kline, S. R.; Choi, S. M. “Water redispersible isolated single-walled carbon nanotubes fabricated by in-situ polymerization of micelles,” Adv. Mater. 2007, 19, 929– 933. 53. Pozzo, D. C.; Walker, L. M. “Shear orientation of nanoparticle arrays templated in a thermoreversible block copolymer micellar crystal,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 5801–5811. 54. Pozzo, D. C.; Walker, L. M. “Small-angle neutron scattering of silica nanoparticles templated in PEO–PPO–PEO cubic crystals” Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochem. Eng. Aspects, 2007, 294, 117–129. 55. Pozzo, D. C.; Walker, L. M. “Macroscopic alignment of nanoparticle arrays in soft crystals of cubic and cylindrical polymer micelles,” Eur. Phys. J. E, 2008, 26, 183–189. 56. Ruegg, M .L.; Reynolds, B. J.; Lin, M. Y.; Lohse, D. J.; Balsara, N. P. “Microphase and macrophase separation in multicomponent A/B/A-C polymer blends with attractive and repulsive interactions,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 1125–1134. 57. Gomez, E. D.; Ruegg, M. L.; Minor, A. M.; Kisielowski, C.; Downing, K. H.; Glaeser, R. M.; Balsara, N. P. “Interfacial concentration profiles of rubbery polyolefin lamellae determined by quantitative electron microscopy,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 156–162. 58. Jacquin, M.; Muller, P.; Cottet, H.; Crooks, R.; Th´e odoly, O. “Controlling the melting of kinetically frozen poly(butylacrylate-b-acrylic acid) micelles via addition of surfactant,” Langmuir, 2007, 23, 9939–9948. 59. Lodge, T. P.; Taribagil, R.; Yoshida, T.; Hillmyer, M. A. “SANS evidence for the cross-linking of wormlike micelles by a model hydrophobically modified polymer,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 4728–4731. 60. Jiang, J.; Burger, C.; Li, C.; Li, J.; Lin, M. Y.; Colby, R. H.; Rafailovich, M. H.; Sokolov, J. C. “Shear-induced layered structure of polymeric micelles by SANS,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 4016–4022.
SANS from Polymers
39
61. Jiang, J.; Li, C.; Lombardi, J.; Colby, R. H.; Rigas, B.; Rafailovich, M. H.; Sokolov, J. C. “The effect of physiologically relevant additives on the rheological properties of concentrated Pluronic copolymer gels,” Polymer, 2008, 49, 3561–3567. 62. O’Driscoll, B. M. D.; Hawley, A. M.; Edler, K. J. “Incorporation of sparingly soluble species in mesostructured surfactant–polymer films,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2008, 317, 585–592. 63. Grandjean, J.; Mourchid, A. “Restricted swelling and its orientation effect on copolymer micellar solutions of hexagonal-packed cylinders under steady shear flow,” Langmuir, 2008, 24, 2318–2325. 64. Healy, J.; Edward, G. H.; Knott, R. B. “Residual orientation in injection micro-molded samples,” Physica B, 2006, 385–386, 620–622. 65. Silverstein, M. S.; Bauer, B. J.; Hedden, R. C.; Lee, H. J.; Landes, B. G. “SANS and XRR porosimetry of a polyphenylene low-k dielectric,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 2998–3006. 66. Chin, J.; Forster, A.; Clerici, C.; Sung, L.; Oudina, M.; Rice, K. “Temperature and humidity aging of poly(p-phenylene-2,6- benzobisoxazole) fibers: Chemical and physical characterization,” Polymer Degradation and Stability, 2007, 92, 1234–1246. 67. Stefanescu, E. A.; Dundigalla, A.; Ferreiro, V.; Loizou, E.; Porcar, L.; Negulescu, I.; Garno, J.; Schmidt, G. “Supramolecular structures in nanocomposite multilayered films,” Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2006, 8, 1739–1746. 68. Li, J.; Jiang, J.; Li, C.; Lin, M. Y.; Schwarz, S. A.; Rafailovich, M. H.; Sokolov, J. “Effect of temperature on shear-induced anisotropic structure in polymer clay hydrogels,” Macromol. Rapid Commun. 2006, 27, 1787–1791. 69. Sen, S.; Xie, Y.; Kumar, S. K.; Yang, H.; Bansal, A.; Ho, D. L.; Hall, L.; Hooper, J. B.; Schweizer, K. S. “Chain conformations and bound-layer correlations in polymer nanocomposites,” Phys. Rev. Lett., 2007, 98, 128302-1 to 128302-4. 70. Chatterjee, T.; Krishnamoorti, R. “Dynamic consequences of the fractal network of nanotubepoly(ethylene oxide) nanocomposites,” Physical Review E, 2007, 75, 050403-1 to 050403-4. 71. Kim, M. H.; Glinka, C. J.; Grot, S. A.; Grot, W. G. “SANS study of the effects of water vapor sorption on the nanoscale structure of perfluorinated sulfonic acid (Nafion) membranes,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 4775–4787. 72. Gao, J.; Yang, Y.; Lee, D.; Holdcroft, S.; Frisken, B. J. “Self assembly of latex particles into proton-conductive membranes,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 8060–8066. 73. Rubatat, L.; Shi, Z.; Diat, O.; Holdcroft, S.; Frisken, B. J. “Structural study of proton-conducting fluorous block copolymer membranes,” Macromolecules, 2006, 39, 720–730. 74. Shin, K.; Obukhov, S.; Chen, J. T.; Huh, J.; Hwang, Y.; Mok, S.; Dobriyal, P.; Thiyagarajan, P.; Russell, T. P. “Enhanced mobility of confined polymers,” Nature Materials, 2007, 6, 961–965. 75. Park, M. J.; Downing, K. H.; Jackson, A.; Gomez, E. D.; Minor, A. M.; Cookson, D.; Weber, A. Z.; Balsara, N. P. “Increased water retention in polymer electrolyte membranes at elevated temperatures assisted by capillary condensation,” Nano Letters, 2007, 7, 3547–3552. 76. Park, M. J.; Nedoma, A. J.; Geissler, P. L.; Balsara, N. P.; Jackson, A.; Cookson, D. “Humidityinduced phase transitions in ion-containing block copolymer membranes,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 2271–2277. 77. Nieh, M. P.; Guiver, M. D.; Kim, D. S.; Ding, J.; Norsten, T. “Morphology of comb-shaped proton exchange membrane copolymers based on a neutron scattering study,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 6176–6182.
R Journal of Macromolecular Science , Part C: Polymer Reviews, 50:40–58, 2010 Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1558-3724 print / 1558-3716 online DOI: 10.1080/15583720903503478
X-ray Scattering for the Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials with Fiber Symmetry NORBERT STRIBECK Department of Chemistry, University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany Synchrotron facilities with improved equipment will grant the execution of very advanced scattering experiments to every interested polymer scientist. The patterns recorded are two-dimensional, high-resolution, and low-noise images. They permit to monitor structure evolution during the processing of polymer materials with repeat rates of several Hertz. In a different class of novel experiments the structure gradient inside of graded polymer materials will be determined with a spatial resolution of less than 1 µm. Scattering patterns must be complete. In order both to record complete patterns, and to evaluate them within tolerable time it appears reasonable to study parts with fiber symmetry. In the present paper a review of corresponding methodical work and the results of test experiments is presented that has recently been compiled in the group of the author. Keywords
polymers, fibers, WAXD, SAXS, tomography
1. Introduction Presently we are experiencing that intense, reliable X-ray sources and fast detectors become generally available. At DESY in Hamburg PETRA III will provide one of the most brilliant X-ray sources worldwide. There less than a second will be sufficient to expose a lownoise two-dimensional (2D) scattering pattern of a polymer sample. Moreover, in detector development a similar breakthrough has been achieved. Cycle times of less than a second can easily be realized with the novel PILATUS1, 2 detectors. It may be objected that for a long time low-noise scattering curves can be recorded with repeat frequencies of several Hertz. Nevertheless, the value of those older data is limited. Either the material is exhibiting isotropic scattering—in this case a comprehensive analysis requires assumptions on the structure (e.g. the assumption of an ideal lamellar stack). Or the material is anisotropic—then a measured curve does not describe the complete scattering pattern or the old 2D pattern is noisy. On the other hand, by application of the new technology it will become possible for many polymer scientists to monitor the structure evolution in oriented polymer materials in real time. The results of such experiments offer the potential to strengthen the understanding of structure evolution mechanisms in polymers. Moreover, the new instruments provide very narrow X-ray beams with diameters of less than 1 µm (“microbeams”) that permit to study the variation of structure inside the material with respective spatial resolution. A complete sweep of a polymer fiber by a microbeam Received September 21, 2009; accepted November 5, 2009. Address correspondence to Norbert Stribeck, Department of Chemistry, University of Hamburg, D-20146 Hamburg, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected]
40
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
41
will take ca. 30 s. Thus, spatial resolution and time resolution may be combined to study the response of different annular zones in a polymer fiber to, e.g. mechanical or thermal load. Parts with fiber symmetry, like fibers, rods, or tubes, are not only of practical interest because they are ubiquitous in everyday life. Moreover, they appear particularly suited for investigation by means of scattering methods. As the part is rotated about its axis, the 2D scattering pattern does not change. Thus, there is no need to take patterns at different rotation angles, as it would be necessary for materials with less symmetry. The recorded 2D scattering pattern of a fiber is oriented and contains all the accessible information on the structure of the sample. Nevertheless, it will not be sufficient to simply engage the novel instruments—the anticipated data must be adequately evaluated in due time, as well. In this connection two big problems are arising. On the one hand, the data flood is increasing to such an extent that automated evaluation methods must be developed. On the other hand, the data structure has changed, in principal. Instead of scattering curves scattering images must be evaluated. In fact, reasonable scattering curves can be extracted from scattering images as well,3 if loss of information is accepted. Nevertheless, it appears more reasonable to develop evaluation methods adapted to the processing of images as a whole. This goal can be achieved by combining digital image processing and scattering theory.4 In this review several methods are presented that have recently been developed in our group in order to quantitatively evaluate extensive sets of 2D scattering patterns from polymer materials with fiber symmetry. Two previously published reviews deal with other aspects of the scattering experiments from polymer materials, namely a presentation of scattering theory5 from the point of view of the materials scientists and a presentation of instrumental development.6
2. Practice of Experiment and Data Analysis It is not seldom that users who have carried out experiments at a synchrotron source return with incomplete data. In the worst case only images (the TIFF files from the detector) have been collected and relevant environmental data are missing. Such data are the primary beam intensities before and after the sample, exposure time, exposure mode, time stamp, etc. More frequently the user has forgotten to record a machine background or parameters of the setup are incomplete. Such errors could be reduced if the operator of the synchrotron source would offer a data pre-evaluation service. The required data and the steps of data preevaluation are described in a text book4 of the author. With respect to the description given in the book the procedure of machine-background elimination has recently been changed so that it becomes consistent with tomographic experiments, as well. Now the intensity in the scattering pattern is divided by the linear absorption factor of the sample and from this image the measured machine background is subtracted. This method compensates intensity loss by absorption inside the sample. For the professional analysis of anisotropic 2D scattering patterns of polymer materials there are no user-friendly standard computer programs, because materials scientists do not carry out standard experiments (like, e.g. protein crystallographers). Therefore some program modules must be adapted to the experiment in order to reflect the actual setup or the actual mode of operation. After adaption and proper combination of modules the data can be evaluated automatically. The other option is cumbersome frame-by-frame manual evaluation that is prone to inconsistency or incompleteness.
42
N. Stribeck
The sequence of evaluation steps is a function of several parameters like the setup, the individual scattering power of the studied material, and the features of the anisotropic scattering pattern. New program modules must be constructed if the experimental procedure is fundamentally changed. Complex correction modules may be required if experimental shortcomings are detected during data evaluation. A typical shortcoming is insufficient synchronization among the different recorders of the experiment. Thus, the acquisition of programming skills is recommended. Moreover, it is helpful to choose a computing language that is optimized for the processing of multidimensional data. Suitable commercial platforms are, e.g. PV-WAVE, IDL or MatLab. If free programming tools shall be used, ImageJ offers a good starting point for arduous programmers. Actual references are readily found by search engines on the worldwide web. Our group uses PV-WAVE.7 The sources of the modules are free and available.8
3. WAXD Fiber Mapping 3.1 Motivation and Method Design In wide-angle X-ray diffraction (WAXD) experiments the diffraction patterns must be mapped into reciprocal space before they can be analyzed quantitatively. For this purpose interactive computer programs9, 10 are utilized that rest upon unnecessary11 approximations. Such a design is no disadvantage in crystallography, because sophisticated interactive refinement methods are required anyway for the exact determination of crystal structure parameters in manageable series. In contrast, in materials science frequently time-resolved experiments are carried out, and voluminous series of diffraction patterns must be processed. The materials scientist already knows the unit cell parameters. Thus, minor inaccuracy of the mapping can be tolerated, if in the experiment variation of peak intensity or shape shall be monitored. Here it is important to carry out the mapping fast and automatically. Because the fiber tilt may change during the experiment, the algorithm must be able to track and to compensate such variation. By revisiting the theoretical treatment of the fiber mapping it has been demonstrated11 that there is no principal reason to refine an approximate center of the fiber pattern iteratively. Moreover, instead of an approximation12, 13 of the tilt angle β of the fiber an exact equation11 can be employed. In the methodical paper14 an algorithm is presented by which the mapping can be performed automatically. Its design rests on the application of the mentioned findings. Intricate parametrization is simplified, and slow trigonometric functions are avoided to a large extent. The method is unsuitable for diffuse scattering patterns. If inaccuracies of 2 pixels can be tolerated, a pattern is automatically mapped into reciprocal space in real time.
3.2 Actions Required by The User For each series of diffraction patterns from a time-resolved experiment, some mapping parameters must once be determined interactively. Our procedure wf premap assumes that the studied material exhibits a sharp reflection that is located neither on the equator nor on the meridian. In the example we investigate polypropylene and select the (131) reflection of the crystallographic α2 -modification as the internal standard. With the crystallographic c-axis parallel to the meridian, the reflection is characterized by the parameters15 dhk = d131 = 0.406 nm and by c/ = 0.6504 nm that defines the position of the reflection ring
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
43
Figure 1. (a) Interactive mode of wf premap: Draw the reflection circle through the centers of the reflection spots of an internal standard reflection (here: polypropylene (131) reflection), and widen the circle into a belt that contains the maxima of the reflection spots. Finally input 4 circles (one indicated at bottom right). (b) The procedure wf map has mapped the fiber diffraction pattern into reciprocal space.
on the Polanyi sphere.11, 16, 17 The wavelength of X-radiation (here: λ = 0.15 nm) must be known, too. In this case the first pre-mapping run of the series is started by wave> ab = wf premap(ss,a,0.15,0.406,0.6504)
The procedure requires a diffraction pattern as input (a). It generates output both in a “saveset” (ss), and in a background-corrected diffraction pattern (ab). If the provided save-set has never been used before, the procedure enters interactive mode and the user is presented the pattern as shown in Fig. 1. Obviously, in Fig. 1a the meridian is not vertical and the fiber is tilted. By means of the pointing device the user draws the reflection circle through the maxima of the reflection spots of the (131)-reflection. Thereafter he transforms the circle into a belt that is wide enough to contain the maxima of the spots (Fig. 1a). Now the procedure cuts out this belt and presents it to the user, who finally specifies 4 disjoint clips (regions of interest on the reflection circle). This is done by punching out circular regions from the belt (the bottom right one is shown in Fig. 1a. The clips are the intersections of the belt (white double-band) and the smaller circles. The program determines the positions of the maxima in the clips. From these 4 maxima-positions the best reflection circle is determined by regression. The error of determination is computed. In general, it is below 1 pixel. After that the orientation of the meridian is computed both from the upper and from the lower pair of spots. The difference is, in general, approximately 0.1o . Based on this information the diffraction pattern is centered and aligned. Finally, the program computes the tilt angle β of the fiber from the orientation angles11 δ and δ of the spots using the exact equation11 4 − λ2 sr2 tan β = (cos δ − cos δ). 2λsr Here sr = 1/d131 is the radius of the Polanyi sphere of the reference (131)-reflection. Finally, the save-set ss is filled with several data: the tilt angle β; the true radius pr
44
N. Stribeck
of the reference-reflection circle on the detector; the crystallographic data of the reference reflection; the wavelength λ; and the geometrical data of the 4 clips. This information is sufficient for an automatic processing of the complete series of diffraction patterns recorded in a time-resolved X-ray diffraction experiment of materials with fiber symmetry. 3.3 Automated Mapping If the procedure wf premap is called with a filled save-set, the interactive part is skipped, and the geometry of the 4 clips is taken from the save-set. For each clip the position of the spot maximum is computed. From these positions the fiber tilt angle β is computed, and the image is centered and aligned. Finally, the mapping into reciprocal space is accomplished by the routine wf map. The function call wave> rec=wf map(ss,ab)
maps the diffraction pattern ab into reciprocal space using the save-set ss. The result is called rec. A more detailed description is in the original paper.14 Figure 1b shows a typical result obtained by automatic direct mapping. In the example the computed tilt angle is β = 5.85◦ . Because the result pattern is in reciprocal space, it should exhibit symmetry in 4 quadrants. Thus, the quality of the mapping can be assessed by comparison to a 4-quadrant average of the pattern. 3.4 Application In a study18 that applies the method, uniaxially oriented polypropylene (PP) is molten and crystallized isothermally from the oriented, quiescent melt. The results show that nucleation and growth of differently oriented sets of crystallites (c-set and a ∗ -set) are decoupled. After shallow quench crystallization is preceded by (spinodal) decomposition. Peak integrals (crystallinity) and minimum crystallite size are tracked. In the commercial starting material a ∗ -set crystallites melt at 158◦ C. The c-set melts at 170◦ C furnace temperature. After recrystallization both sets melt at 170◦ C. Isothermal crystallization is divided in two distinct phases. During nucleation the crystallinity stays low. The second phase is dominated by crystallinity growth. At 150◦ C the c-set is seeded first. At 145◦ C and 140◦ C a ∗ -oriented crystallites are the first. The first-seeded set starts to grow first, as well. c-set crystallinity is always growing faster than a ∗ -set crystallinity. The evolution of the corresponding SAXS19 cross-diagram in the growth phase can both be explained by lamellae growing at right angles, and by block merging. Figure 2 shows β (t, T ) of one of the experiments. The tracking curve appears smooth and demonstrates the reliability of the tilt-angle determination. Tilt-angle variation is an issue, because the oriented PP film is heated until it becomes a viscous melt. Therefore the material shrinks and bends in the synchrotron X-ray beam. After the mapping the intensity distribution is known almost everywhere in reciprocal space except for a wedge region near the meridian (cf. Fig. 1b). Thus, reflection intensities can readily be integrated in reciprocal space. In reciprocal space the relation between scattering and structure is clear from scattering theory,4, 18 and structural data can be computed,18 e.g., from total intensities (crystallinity) and integral breadths (crystallite sizes). Figure 3 shows the evolution of the weight crystallinities of the two sets of crystallites at 3 different crystallization temperatures. As shown by Ruland,20 such reflection integrals that
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
45 200
20
10
T(t)
T [°C]
β(t) [°]
150 0 100 -10 50 -20 -20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
t [min] Figure 2. Tilt-angle tracking curve β (t, T ) from the automatic fiber-mapping procedure in an experiment in which β is changing considerably (hard-elastic polypropylene; melt-annealing at 171◦ C 18 c with permission of the ACS). and recrystallization at 150◦ C) (Reproduced
are complete in reciprocal space are proportional to the weight crystallinity of the perfect crystallites that produce the reflections. Latency periods between the quench and the start of the crystallization, as well as crystallization velocities of the two kind of crystallites can be extracted from these data. Finally, conclusions concerning the crystallization mechanisms can be drawn.18
Figure 3. Evolution of relative weight crystallinities S, and S ∗ of c-oriented crystallites (dashed regression lines) and a ∗ -oriented crystals (solid regression lines), resp. during isothermal, oriented crystallization of hard-elastic PP from a quiescent melt as a function of crystallization temperature. Double-head arrows pointing at the t-axis indicate the first sighting of the a ∗ -set (full arrow head), and of the c-set (open arrow head), respectively.
46
N. Stribeck
4. X-Ray Scattering Fiber Tomography 4.1 Motivation The structure inside a polymer part is not necessarily homogeneous. With fibers, extrudates, and latex particles21 frequently a core-shell structure is reported. Moreover, engineers deliberately generate structure gradients in polymer parts for special functionality.22, 23 If such a part is irradiated by an X-ray beam, the recorded pattern is an integral superposition of all the SAXS patterns emerging from the sequence of volume elements (voxels) along the beam path. From the mathematical point of view such a superposition is a projection, and a single projection is of little use for the study of graded materials. A first step towards a study of structure gradients has been the development of the X-ray microbeam technique.24–26 Here only the diameter of the beam is limiting the lateral spatial resolution. Nevertheless, the longitudinal spatial resolution is simply the thickness of the sample. Microbeam scanning experiments, in particular of fibers, have been performed for many years and the raw data have been discussed, although the corresponding shortcoming has been known (Paris et al.:27 “The long-term goal is to proceed from microbeam scanning experiments to a real imaging technique”). The solution of the problem is tomographic reconstruction. Problems arise from the fact that scattering patterns are multidimensional but not simply a number (like the absorption in classical tomography). Thus, approximate tomographic reconstruction of scattering data with a manageable amount of artifacts is difficult. An exception is the case of part with uniaxial symmetry. In this case a reconstruction of the scattering patterns is possible that would have emerged from individual voxels in a plane perpendicular to the “fiber” axis.28 Nevertheless, this method is only of academic value. The exposure time for the recording of scattering data of one cross-section of the part is in the order of days. The computing time for the tomographic reconstruction of the scattering patterns is at least a week.28
4.2 Introduction of the Method A more practical tomographic method can be applied, if the part to be studied both exhibits macroscopic fiber symmetry, and the structure only varies as a function of the distance from its central axis. By means of this method fibers, pipes, and extruded strands can be investigated. Thus, we call it “X-ray scattering fiber computer tomography” (XSF-CT). A complete set of projected scattering patterns is collected in a single microbeam scan across the fiber, because the set of projections does not change as the sample is rotated about its axis. Such an experiment is completed in about 30 min. Moreover, compared to the general tomography the mathematics of image reconstruction is simplified considerably and the computational effort decreases by 5 orders of magnitude. A set of 40 measured scattering patterns is reconstructed in typically less than 10 min. From medicine and other fields of science the considerable potential of information increase after tomographic imaging is well-known. In a general tomographic X-ray experiment,29 a voluminous sample is scanned by a thin X-ray beam. As a function both of the position x of the scanning beam on the sample, and of the sample rotation angle φ, projections (notation: { }) of the absorption {A} (x, φ) or even of complete scattering patterns {I } (s, x, φ) are measured, in order to analyze the structure variation in the plane of the sample that is scanned by the X-ray beam.28, 30, 31 Here s is the scattering vector with |s| = s = (2/λ) sin θ , the X-ray wavelength λ and the scattering angle 2θ . In the examples mentioned, a tomographic image reconstruction29, 32, 33 returns
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
47
Figure 4. (a) cross-section irradiated by an X-ray beam at an offset x from its center. The Fiber structure ρ ρf shows fiber symmetry. From all structures along the beam path a superposition is probed. y is the variable of the integration. (b) One-dimensional tomographic reconstruction turns the measured series of projected scattering patterns that carry the accumulated the structure information passed by the beam (vertical bars) into the image patterns from voxels (quadratic boxes) residing on the fiber radius.
either the spatial variation of the absorption in the plane, or of the scattering emanating from the resolved voxels in the plane. The smearing caused from projection is eliminated by application of the Fourier transform theory, and a clear image of the inner structure is obtained. If the studied material shows cylindrical symmetry, the results of the measurement are no function of φ any more, and the complete image information is in a single microbeam scan. The fundamental geometry is sketched in Fig. 4a. The information in the measured signal {A} (x) or {I } (s, x), respectively, does not represent the sought information A (x) or I (s, x) originating from the small square (voxel) around the position x. Instead, to a first approximation it is represented by the projection integral ˆ ∞ {I } (s, x) = 2 I (s, x 2 + y 2 ) dy (1) ˆ
x ∞
=2 x
I (s, ρf ) ρf dρf . ρf2 − x 2
(2)
In the equation only the accumulated attenuation of the primary beam by X-ray absorption is not accounted for. This is no problem for very thin polymer parts with low absorption. For thicker samples the absorption correction from Section 2 is sufficient to account for it. The sought information in image space (I (ρf )) along the radius ρf of the fiber has to be reconstructed from the information in projection space ({I } (x)). Equation (1) is the definition of the Abel transform.33 In X-ray scattering Eq. (1) is established textbook knowledge.4, 34–39 There it describes the slit smearing. Even the inverse Abel transform ˆ 1 ∞ d{I }(s, ρf ) dy I (s, x) = − (3) π 0 dρf ρf ˆ 1 ∞ d{I }(s, ρf ) dρf , (4) =− π x dρf ρf2 − x 2
48
N. Stribeck
Figure 5. Sketch of local fiber symmetry inside the cross-section of the fiber. Each voxel has its own fiber axis. Inside the voxel there is only axial grain.
which first has been derived by Niels Abel40 is found in scattering textbooks since Guinier41 and DuMond.42 Similar to the filtered backprojection algorithm of the general tomography, low-noise reconstruction algorithms43–45 for the tomography of materials with cylindrical symmetry are readily available in the field of “one-dimensional tomography.” The principle of one-dimensional tomographic reconstruction is sketched in Fig. 4b. It must be mentioned that here we implicitly assume that the scattering from every irradiated voxel in the fiber shows fiber symmetry itself (local fiber symmetry). Otherwise characteristic reconstruction aberrations are expected.28, 46 The meaning of local fiber symmetry is sketched in Fig. 5. Deviations from local fiber symmetry (i.e. tangential or radial grain, resp.46 ) cause restricted or shifted visibility of scattering features along the fiber radius. These aberrations can be detected and result in additional information on the structure inside the fiber.46 4.3 Application In an application-oriented feasibility study46 precursors of polymer microfibrillarreinforced composites (MFC) containing poly(ether)-block-amide (PEBA) and poly (ethylene terephthalate) (PET) with varying cold-draw ratio are studied. The studied strands are relatively thick, because presently the achievable “microbeam” at HASYLAB in Hamburg is relatively wide. The results from a direct analysis of the smeared measured patterns are compared to results obtained after tomographic reconstruction. Ideas for advanced practical applications of the XSF-CT method are discussed. Data are presented from a cold-drawn (draw ratio λd ≈ 3) co-extrudate of 70 wt.-% PEBA and 30 wt.-% PET (abbreviated: MFC73). In the scanning-microbeam experiment
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
49
Figure 6. Cold-drawn (λd ≈ 3) MFC73 in a scanning microbeam experiment. Measured scattering intensity {I }(s12 , s3 , ρf ) (top row) and reconstructed scattering I (s12 , s3 , ρf ) (bottom row) for short distances ρf from the fiber axis. The patterns display the range −0.1 nm−1 ≤ s12 , s3 ≤ 0.1 nm−1 in uniform logarithmic scale (s = (2/λ) sin θ).
the strand shows an isotropic long period and an equatorial streak at almost every beam position (Fig. 6, top row). Only the tomographically reconstructed patterns (bottom row) exhibit that the long-period ring-reflection is not present in the core of the fiber. As the feature becomes visible, it first shows up at the equator. With increasing distance from the fiber axis, reflection arcs are growing towards the meridian. Above ρf = 300 µm the arcs join into a closed circle. Because such behavior has been observed with neat PEBA as well, this orientation phenomenon is not indicating some interaction between the PEBA and the PET microfibrils. The reconstructed central voxel (ρf = 0) is dominated by one of the reconstruction aberration effects (from voxels with tangential grain).46 Examination of the equatorial streak exhibits only in the reconstruction that it grows broader towards the center of the fiber. The streak is allocated to needle-shaped domains, and is only observed with strands from co-extruded blends. If these needles are thin PET microfibrils, the tomography shows that in the center of the fiber these microfibrils are shorter than in an intermediate region. The structure gradient in the outer region of the strand is discussed in the original paper.46
5. SAXS Monitoring of Mechanical Tests 5.1 Motivation and Method Development Advanced polymer materials are urgently sought after e.g. in the automotive industry in order to accomplish the goals of climate protection by reduction of weight. Such newly engineered materials have to prove their serviceability in mechanical tests. Classical tensile tests are performed to determine the modulus and ultimate properties. Load cycling experiments are carried out to determine the fatigue behavior. In order to reveal the mechanisms of, e.g., failure or fatigue, it is desirable to monitor mechanical tests by SAXS. In this way the response of the nanostructure to mechanical load is revealed. Since about 2005 the advance of instrumentation at synchrotron beamlines facilitates considerable reduction of the exposure required for the recording of low-noise SAXS patterns. Such quality is
50
N. Stribeck
required for a quantitative analysis by, e.g., the CDF method.47, 48 Concerning the monitoring of tensile tests by SAXS this advance has meant that change-over from the stretch-hold technique49 to the more practical continuous straining has become possible,50 although the achievable strain rate is frequently still by a factor of 100 lower than that relevant in industry and service. With the advent of very high-brilliance synchrotron sources even this limitation is presently being abolished. In order to gain full control on tensile and load-cycling tests a tensile tester has been R built for operation at synchrotron beamlines.50 The control program written in LabVIEW is continuously adapted to more complex experiments. Presently it can handle different kinds of continuous load-cycling programs that now are strictly synchronized with both the SAXS detector and a video grabber module (recording sequences of pictures of the sample with fiducial marks). The latest methodical development51 is an automatic evaluation method of the video frames, by which the true macroscopic elongation of the sample can be determined with an accuracy of 3 decimals. Such high accuracy is required for thermoplastic materials that fail at low elongations (ca. 0.1). The method extracts the grating of the fiducial marks on the sample from the actual video image, computes the 1D correlation function,52, 53 and evaluates its “long period.”
5.2 Results In a study50 of hard-elastic polypropylene (PP), scattering patterns recorded during continuous straining differ considerably from those recorded in the step-hold technique. Even though during exposure the elongation is no longer constant when applying the dynamic technique, the images collected in stretch-hold technique appear much more blurred (Fig. 7). This result indicates relaxation of nanostructure while the extensometer stands still. Quantitative analysis shows that during relaxation the extension of crystalline lamellae
Figure 7. Oriented PP films in tensile tests. Comparison between SAXS patterns I (s12 , s3 ) recorded during continuous straining (top row, ε˙ ≈ 10−3 s−1 ) and patterns from an experiment in stretch-hold technique (bottom row). Straining direction and meridian is vertical (s3 ). Equator (s12 ) is horizontal 50 c with permission of Wiley Interscience). (Reproduced
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
51
Figure 8. Oriented PP. Load cycling monitored by SAXS. Circular dots show where SAXS patterns have been recorded. Numerical labels indicate their sequence. The highlighted part of the curve near label 11 indicates the part traversed during the recording of pattern 11. The drawing direction with 48 c with permission of respect to the patterns, s3 , is indicated by a double-head arrow (Reproduced Wiley-VCH).
is increasing. Lamellae thicknesses are becoming non-uniform. The range of order is shortening. Cross-hatched lamellae are formed. In another study48 slow continuous mechanical tests of oriented PP are monitored by SAXS and quantitatively evaluated by the CDF method.47 A continuous-strain test exhibits fracture and release of weak lamellae (2 – 10% strain). Beyond that conversion of lamellae into needles is observed. As all layers are consumed, the material breaks. Fatigue is studied in a load-reversal experiment (between 10% and 35% strain, Fig. 8). In each cycle crystallization, layer break, and relaxation melting are observed. Figure 9 presents the result. The top chart shows the true elongation, ε (t), imposed to the material and measured at the point of X-ray irradiation. The four load-reversal cycles are easily identified. The chart in the middle reports the extracted nanostructure parameters, L (t), ecac (t), and S (t). The bottom diagram presents the macroscopic resistance, σ (t), which the material is opposing to strain. The figure shows that crystallization, rupture of lamellae, and melting of fragments are continuously reshaping the domains of the PP material in the cycles of the fatigue test. The long-period cycle exhibits a phase shift with respect to the imposed strain cycling. Moreover, there is an indication of amplitude attenuation. Fatigue is demonstrated in the curve σ (t) by decreasing stress peaks. An in-depth discussion of the zones indicated in Fig. 9 is in the original paper.48 In particular, the combination of SAXS and fatigue test shows the transition from stress-induced crystallization to crystallite rupture σ (t) ≈ 20 MPa. In a recent study51 of microfibrillar reinforced blends based on polyethylene we have switched from hard-elastic materials to materials that fail at the low elongations typical for plastic polymers. Because of the much lower elongation at break (εb ≈ 0.1), now the macroscopic elongation εm and nanoscopic elongation εn must be determined with high precision. Respective methods are presented. The results show that the hardest materials exhibit a very inhomogeneous nanodomain structure. During straining their domains appear to be wedged together and inhibit transverse contraction on the nanometer scale.
52
N. Stribeck
Figure 9. Dynamic load-reversal mechanical test of hard-elastic PP film. As a function of the elapsed time t the macroscopic parameters elongation, ε (top graph), and tensile stress, σ (bottom graph) are displayed together with topological nanostructure parameters (middle). In the middle diagram the solid line shows the long period, L. The broken line displays the lateral extension, ecac , of a sandwich made from two crystalline lamellae. The line with circular dots exhibits the variation of the strength, S, of the CDF. Vertical bars indicate zones of strain-induced crystallization (dark bars) c Reproduced48 with permission of and relaxation-induced melting (light gray bars), respectively ( Wiley-VCH).
Further components are polyamides (PA6, PA12) (20–30%) and as compatibilizer R 8102 (YP) (0–10%). Some HDPE/PA6 blends are additionally loaded with nanoYparex R R clays (Nanomer or Cloisite ). Blending of HDPE with PA12 causes no synergistic effect. In the absence of nanoclay, PA6 and HDPE form a heterogeneous nanostructure with high Young’s modulus. After addition of YP a more homogeneous scaffold structure is observed in which some of the PA6 microfibrils and HDPE crystallites appear to be rigidly connected, but the modulus has decreased. Both kinds of nanoclay induce a transition from a structure without transverse correlation among the microfibrils into a macrolattice with 3D correlations among HDPE domains from neighboring microfibrils. For extensions between 0.7% and 3.5% the scattering entities with 3D correlation exhibit transverse elongation instead of transverse contraction. The process is interpreted as overcoming a correlation barrier executed by the crystallites in an evasion-upon-approaching mechanism. During continued straining the 3D correlation is reduced or removed. The true macroscopic elongation εm is determined from video frames taken of the sample that carries fiducial marks (see Fig. 10a). Once for an experiment the user has to provide some input. It is based on the first image (Fig. 10a) of the series. The center of the X-ray beam on the sample is marked by a cross in the image. Close to this center the user defines a rectangular region of interest (ROI), ρm (x, y). In Fig. 10a this region is bordered by a dashed line. x and y are pixel coordinates in the direction of strain and perpendicular to it, respectively. The same ROI is applied to all video frames of the experiment. The ROI is structured by the fiducial marks running perpendicular to the straining direction. As is known from scattering theory,4 from such a structure function ρm (x, y) the 2D correlation
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
53
Figure 10. Elongation from recorded video frames. Inset a: In the first video frame a region of interest (ROI) with fiducial marks is defined. Inset b: From the ROI the 2D correlation function γ2 (x, y) is computed. Main drawing: The center of the long-period peak in γ1 (x) = γ2 (x, 0) is fitted c Reproduced51 by a parabola (dashed line) to compute the distance between the fiducial marks ( with permission of Wiley Interscience).
function γ2 (x, y) =
ρm 2 (x, y) ρm 2 (0, 0)
can be computed, with ρm (x, y) = ρm (x, y) − ρ¯ m representing the fluctuation of ρm (x, y) about its average ρ¯ m , and the autocorrelation being defined by the integral ¨ ∞ f 2 (x, y) = f (u, v) f (u + x, v + y) dudv. −∞
In Fig. 10b the colored caps demonstrate, where γ2 (x, y) is positive. The macroscopic elongation εm in straining direction is the section γ1 (x) = γ2 (x, y) 1 (x) of γ2 in straining direction. Figure 10 presents this curve and its analysis. Its first positive peak is the longperiod peak that is related to the actual average distance of the fiducial marks, . A parabola (dashed line) is fitted to the long-period maximum, and the position of its vertex is determined (arrow). Thus, can be determined with an accuracy of 0.01 pixels. Let 0 the initial distance between the marks, then the macroscopic elongation is εm = /0 − 1. Concerning the scattering patterns, similar analysis is possible. Nevertheless, the peaks observed in the scattering pattern or in the CDFs47 computed from the pattern are no longer one-dimensional but two-dimensional – positioned in the plane (s12 , s3 ) or (r12 , r3 ), respectively. Again, the user defines a ROI in which the analysis procedure searches for the peak maximum, extracts the peak cap, and fits now a bivariate54 polynomial of 2nd order to it. From the coefficients of the polynomial several parameters are readily determined. Most important are the peak position and the widths of the peak in meridional and equatorial
54
N. Stribeck
Figure 11. MFC precursor blends from HDPE, two different polyamides (PA12, PA6) and a compatibilizer (YP) in tensile tests. Evolution of macroscopic stress and strain (σ , ε) as well as of nanostructure parameters. εnano is the nanoscopic elongation computed from the HDPE long period. DL is the relative change of the width of the long period distribution. DM is the relative change of the extension of the microfibrils in transverse direction.
directions, respectively. Thus, the evolution of these parameters during the experiment can be tracked automatically. Figure 11 presents the results of a quantitative nanostructure analysis for the blends which do not contain nanoclays. Elongations are illustrated by dashed lines. Bold lines show the macroscopic elongation, ε. Thin lines report the nanoscopic elongation εnano of the HDPE matrix. Circular marks indicate regions in which ε ≈ εnano . All materials reinforced by PA12 exhibit this similarity of macroscopic and nanoscopic deformation. Dashed-dotted lines show DL , the relative variation of the breadth of the long-period
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
55
distribution. The increase of all curves demonstrates increasing inhomogeneity of the long periods with increasing elongation. Dotted lines show DM , the relative variation of the microfibrillar diameter during the straining process. In all materials the elongational deformation causes the microfibrils to thin. Variation of the material composition does not cause considerable changes. This is different with the samples reinforced by PA6 (Fig. 11d-f). Here an increase of the PA6 content to 30% causes strong thinning of the microfibrils. In the PA6 blends the strong transverse decrease is going along with only moderate nanoscopic elongation εnano of the HDPE. An explanation for this finding could be microfibrillation by fracture of crystalline domains of the polyethylene. Moreover, the diagrams in Fig. 11d-f demonstrate a considerable difference (vertical arrows) between the two dashed curves. In Fig. 11e-f (εnano < ε) the nanoscopic elongation of the HDPE phase is considerably lower than the macroscopic elongation. Similarity is only observed during the initial deformation in Fig. 11f (circular mark). In the 80/20 HDPE/PA6 blend (Fig. 11d) the nanoscopic elongation of the HDPE microfibrils is considerably longer than the macroscopic elongation (εnano > ε). Although this finding appears to be unreasonable, an indication for a possible mechanism is in the strong increase of DL (Fig. 11d). This is discussed in the original paper.51
6. Conclusions Considering the present instrumental development at synchrotron radiation facilities the development of advanced data evaluation methods appears to be both promising and necessary in order to master the future data flood. The three presented methods demonstrate the potential of such work. In order to discharge the user, a part of the data evaluation may be carried out at the synchrotron facility. Such added service would require not only considerable computing power, but also additional manpower. In addition to the beamline scientist an evaluation specialist would become necessary. It would be his job to detect if raw data must be smoothed. He would have to eliminate the machine background, would generate detector masks, would center and align each scattering pattern, and would fill blind areas from consideration of symmetry. As an added service, the community of the evaluation specialists could select some standard experiments for which complete user-friendly programming environments could be built. Nevertheless, for the predominant fraction of individually designed setups it will remain necessary for the polymer scientist himself to familiarize with adapted programming techniques. This will be of particular importance, if methods shall be developed that grow with the growth of instrumental capacity. Ultimately, it is expected that an increase of the quality of results returned from scattering experiments will be closely correlated to the manpower dedicated to the programming of data evaluation modules.
Acknowledgment The author thanks the Hamburg Synchrotron Radiation Laboratory (HASYLAB) for beam time granted in the frame of project II-20080015. Development of the reported methods has been supported by the 7th framework program of the European Union (Project NANOTOUGH FP7-NMP-2007LARGE-2.1.1).
References 1. Broennimann, C.; Eikenberry, E. F.; Henrich, B.; Horrisberger, R.; H¨ulsen, G.; Pohl, E.; Schmitt, B.; Schulze-Briese, C.; Suzuki, M.; Tomizaki, T.; Toyokawa, A.; Wagner, A. “The PILATUS 1M detector,” J. Synchrotron Rad., 2006, 13, 120–130.
56
N. Stribeck
2. H¨ulsen-Bollier, G. The PILATUS 1M Detector. A Novel Large Area Pixel Detector, Ph.D. thesis, Dept. Physics, University of Erlangen-N¨urnberg, Germany 2005. 3. Stribeck, N. “Analysis of SAXS Fiber Patterns by Means of Projections,” ACS Symp. Ser., 2000, 739, 41–56. 4. Stribeck, N. X-Ray Scattering of Soft Matter, Springer, Heidelberg, New York, 2007. 5. Stribeck, N. “Scattering of Soft Condensed Matter. From Fundaments to Application,” In Applications of Synchrotron Light to Scattering and Diffraction in Materials and Life Sciences, Ezquerra, T. A.; Garci´a Guti´errez, M.; Nogales, A.; G´omez, M., eds., Springer, Berlin Heidelberg, 2009, volume 776 of Lect. Notes Phys. pp. 25–62. 6. Stribeck, N. “Deformation behavior of nanocomposites studied by X-ray scattering: Instrumentation and methodology,” In Nano- and Micromechanics of Polymer Blends and Composites, Karger-Kocsis, J.; Fakirov, S., eds., Hanser Publisher, M¨unchen, 2009, volume 1 pp. 269– 300. 7. VNI “PV-WAVE Manuals,” V 7.5, Houston, TX, 2007. 8. Stribeck, N. “Downloads,” http://www.chemie.uni-hamburg.de/tmc/stribeck/dl 2008. 9. Rajkumar, G.; AL-Khayat, H.; Eakins, F.; He, A.; Knupp, C.; Squire, J. “FibreFix—A new integrated CCP13 software package,” Fibre Diffraction Rev., 2005, 13, 11–18. 10. Bian, W.; Wang, H.; McCullough, I.; Stubbs, G. “WCEN: a computer program for initial processing of fiber diffraction patterns,” J. Appl. Cryst., 2006, 39, 752–756. 11. Stribeck, N. “On the determination of fiber tilt angles in fiber diffraction,” Acta Cryst., 2009, A65, 46–47. 12. Franklin, R. E.; Gosling, R. G. “The structure of sodium thymonucleate fibres. II. Cylindrically symmmetrical patterson function,” Acta Cryst., 1953, 6, 678–685. 13. Fraser, R. D.; Macrae, T. P.; Miller, A.; Rowlands, R. J. “Digital processing of fibre diffraction patterns,” J. Appl. Cryst., 1976, 9, 81–94. 14. Stribeck, N.; N¨ochel, U. “Direct mapping of fiber diffraction patterns into reciprocal space,” J. Appl. Cryst., 2009, 42, 295–301. 15. Mencik, Z. “Crystal structure of isotactic polypropylene,” J. Macromol. Sci. Phys., 1972, B6, 101–115. 16. Polanyi, M. “Das R¨ontgen-Faserdiagramm I. (The X-Ray Fiber-diagram I.),” Z. Phys., 1921, 7, 149–180. 17. Polanyi, M.; Weissenberg, K. “Das R¨ontgen-Faserdiagramm II. (The X-Ray fiber-diagram II.),” Z. Physik, 1923, 9, 123–130. 18. Stribeck, N.; N¨ochel, U.; Funari, S. S. “Melting and crystallization of differently oriented sets of crystallites in hard-elastic polypropylene,” Macromolecules, 2009, 42, 2093–2101. 19. Stribeck, N.; N¨ochel, U.; Almend´arez Camarillo, A.; Roth, S. V.; Dommach, M.; B¨osecke, P. “SAXS study of oriented crystallization of polypropylene from a quiescent melt,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 4535–4545. 20. Ruland, W. “X-ray determination of crystallinity and diffuse disorder scattering,” Acta Cryst., 1961, 14, 1180–1185. 21. Dingenouts, N.; Bolze, J.; Potschke, D.; Ballauff, M. “Analysis of polymer latexes by small-angle X-ray scattering,” Adv. Polym. Sci., 1999, 144, Epoxide Resins, Polyampholytes), 1–Epoxide Resins, Polyampholytes), 47. 22. Kieback, B.; Neubrand, A.; Riedel, H. “Processing techniques for functionally graded materials,” Mater. Sci. Eng. A Struct. Mater. Prop. Microstruct. Proces., 2003, 362, 81–106. 23. Pompe, W.; Worch, H.; Epple, M.; Friess, W.; Gelinsky, M.; Greil, P.; Hempel, U.; Scharnweber, D.; Schulte, K. “Functionally graded materials for biomedical applications,” Mater. Sci. Eng. A Struct. Mater. Prop. Microstruct. Proces., 2003, 362, 40–60. 24. Riekel, C.; Engstr¨om, P. “Diffraction and diffuse scattering from materials with microfocussed X-rays,” Nuclear Instr. Meth. Phys. Res., 1995, B97, 224–230. 25. Waigh, T. A.; Donald, A. M.; Heidelbach, F.; Riekel, C.; Gidley, M. J. “Analysis of the native structure of starch granules with small angle x-ray microfocus scattering,” Biopolymers, 1999, 49, 91–105.
Monitoring of Processes in Polymer Materials
57
26. Kolb, R.; Wutz, C.; Stribeck, N.; V. Krosigk, G.; Riekel, C. “Investigation of secondary crystallization of polymers by means of microbeam X-ray scattering,” Polymer, 2001, 42, 5257–5266. 27. Paris, O.; Li, C.; Siegel, S.; Weseloh, G.; Emmerling, F.; Riesemeier, H.; Erko, A.; Fratzl, P. “A new experimental station for simultaneous X-ray microbeam scanning for small- and wide-angle scattering and fluorescence at BESSY II,” J. Appl. Cryst., 2007, 40, s466–s470. 28. Stribeck, N.; Almendarez Camarillo, A.; N¨ochel, U.; Schroer, C.; Kuhlmann, M.; Roth, S. V.; Gehrke, R.; Bayer, R. K. “Volume-resolved nanostructure survey of a polymer part by means of SAXS microtomography,” Macromol. Chem. Phys., 2006, 207, 1239–1249. 29. Bonse, U.; Busch, F. “X-ray computed microtomography (µCT) using synchrotron radiation,” Prog. Biophys. Molec. Biol., 1996, 65, 133–169. 30. Schroer, C. G.; Kuhlmann, M.; Roth, S. V.; Gehrke, R.; Stribeck, N.; Almendarez Camarillo, A.; Lengeler, B. “Mapping the local nanostructure inside a specimen by tomographic small-angle x-ray scattering,” Appl. Phys. Lett., 2006, 88, 164102. 31. Schroer, C. G.; Kuhlmann, M.; G¨unzler, T. F.; Benner, B.; Kurapova, O.; Patommel, J.; Lengeler, B.; Roth, S. V.; Gehrke, R.; Snigirev, A.; Snigireva, I.; Stribeck, N.; Almend´arez Camarillo, A.; Beckmann, F. “Full-field and scanning microtomography based on parabolic refractive x-ray lenses,” Proc. SPIE, 2006, 6318, 6318H. 32. Kak, A. C.; Slaney, M. Principles of Computerized Tomographic Imaging; IEEE Press: New York, 1999. 33. Bracewell, R. The Fourier Transform and Its Applications; 3rd Ed. Mc Graw-Hill: New York, 1999. 34. Guinier, A.; Fournet, G. Small-Angle Scattering of X-Rays, Chapman and Hall: London, 1955. 35. Hosemann, R.; Bagchi, S. N. Direct Analysis of Diffraction by Matter; North-Holland: Amsterdam, 1962. 36. Alexander, L. E. X-Ray Diffraction Methods in Polymer Science; Wiley: New York, 1979. 37. Glatter, O.; Kratky, O., eds., Small Angle X-ray Scattering; Academic Press: London, 1982. 38. Feigin, L. A.; Svergun, D. I. Structure Analysis by Small-Angle X-Ray and Neutron Scattering; Plenum Press: New York, 1987. 39. Balt´a Calleja, F. J.; Vonk, C. G. X-Ray Scattering of Synthetic Polymers; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1989. 40. Abel, N. H. “Aufl¨osung einer mechanischen Aufgabe,” J. Reine Angew. Math., 1826, 1, 153–157. 41. Guinier, A.; Fournet, G. “Correction of measurments of low-angle X-ray scattering,” Nature, 1947, 160, 501. 42. DuMond, J. W. M. “Method of correcting low angle X-ray diffraction curves for the study of small particle sizes,” Phys. Rev., 1947, 72, 83–84. 43. Bitter, I.; Kaufman, A. E.; Sato, M. “Penalized-distance volumetric skeleton algorithm,” IEEE Trans. Visualization and Computer Graphics, 2001, 7, 195–206. 44. Dasch, C. J. “One-dimensional tomography: a comparison of Abel, onion-peeling, and filtered backprojection methods,” Applied Optics, 1992, 31, 1146–1153. 45. Dribinski, V.; Ossadtchi, A.; Mandelshtam, V. A.; Reisler, H. “Reconstruction of Abeltransformable images: The Gaussian basis-set expansion Abel transform method,” Rev. Sci. Instr., 2002, 73, 2634–2642. 46. Stribeck, N.; N¨ochel, U.; Fakirov, S.; Feldkamp, J.; Schroer, C.; Timmann, A.; Kuhlmann, M. “SAXS-fiber computer-tomography. Method enhancement and analysis of microfibrillarreinforced composite precursors from PEBAX and PET,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 7637–7647. 47. Stribeck, N. “Extraction of domain structure information from small-angle X-ray patterns of bulk materials,” J. Appl. Cryst., 2001, 34, 496–503. 48. Stribeck, N.; N¨ochel, U.; Funari, S. S.; Schubert, T.; Timmann, A. “Nanostructure evolution in polypropylene during mechanical testing,” Macromol. Chem. Phys., 2008, 209, 1992–2002. 49. Wu, J.; Schultz, J. M.; Yeh, F.; Hsiao, B. S.; Chu, B. “In-situ simultaneous synchrotron small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering measurement of poly(vinylidene fluoride) fibers under deformation,” Macromolecules, 2000, 33, 1765–1777.
58
N. Stribeck
50. Stribeck, N.; N¨ochel, U.; Funari, S. S.; Schubert, T. “Tensile tests of polypropylene monitored by SAXS. Comparing the stretch-hold technique to the dynamic technique,” J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys., 2008, 46, 721–726. 51. Denchev, Z.; Dencheva, N.; Funari, S. S.; Motovilin, M.; Schubert, T.; Stribeck, N. “Nanostructure and mechanical properties studied during dynamical straining of microfibrillar reinforced HDPE/PA blends,” J. Polym. Sci. Part B: Polym. Phys., 2009, in print. 52. Vonk, C. G.; Kortleve, G. “X-ray small-angle scattering of bulk polyethylene,” Colloid Polym. Sci., 1967, 220, 19–24. 53. Strobl, G. R.; Schneider, M. “Direct evaluation of the electron density correlation function of partially crystalline polymers,” J. Polym. Sci., Part B: Polym. Phys., 1980, B18, 1343–1359. 54. Hall, E. L. Computer Image Processing and Recognition; Academic Press: London, 1980.
R Journal of Macromolecular Science , Part C: Polymer Reviews, 50:59–90, 2010 ISSN: 1558-3724 print / 1558-3716 online DOI: 10.1080/15583720903503486
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers FAN ZHANG1,2 AND JAN ILAVSKY3 1
Materials Science and Engineering Laboratory, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, USA 2 Department of Physics, Northern Illinois University, Dekalb, IL, USA 3 X-ray Science Division, Advanced Photon Source, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL, USA Ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering (USAXS) is capable of probing structural inhomogeneities in the size range of 1 to 1000 nm. Recent developments of X-ray sources and optics make USAXS increasingly relevant to polymer research. In this review, we examine the current technical state of USAXS instrumentation, and briefly introduce the method of data reduction and analysis. We emphasize USAXS’s application in areas such as polymer nanocomposites, polymer gels and solutions, polymer blends, polymer micelles and microemulsions, and colloidal sciences. Finally, we predict more USAXS studies on polymeric systems, especially those with large-scale structures or hierarchical microstructures. Keywords ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering, small angle X-ray scattering, polymers, colloids
Introduction Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS)1 is a nondestructive scattering technique that records elastic scattering of X-rays at scattering angles close to the direction of the incident beam. SAXS data contain information about important microstructural parameters such as the size, shape, volume, and total surface area of the scatterers, as well as characteristic distances if the scatterers are ordered or partially ordered. In a typical pinhole setup, SAXS is capable of delivering structural information between 1 and 100 nm. Much larger objects can be viewed directly with optical microscopes. The intermediate size range, however, is difficult for both microscope and SAXS, especially when the specimen is either highly absorbent or optically opaque. Ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering (USAXS) has been developed to extend the scattering q range (where its modulus q = (4π /λ)sinθ , λ is the wavelength of the X-ray, Received September 3, 2009; accepted November 22, 2009. The submitted manuscript has been created by UChicago Argonne, LLC, Operator of Argonne National Laboratory (“Argonne”). Argonne, a U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science laboratory, is operated under Contract No. DE-AC02-06CH11357. The U.S. Government retains for itself, and others acting on its behalf, a paid-up nonexclusive, irrevocable worldwide license in said article to reproduce, prepare derivative works, distribute copies to the public, and perform publicly and display publicly, by or on behalf of the Government. Address correspondence to Jan Ilavsky, X-ray Science Division, Advanced Photon Source, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL, 60439, USA. E-mail:
[email protected]
59
60
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
and 2θ is the scattering angle) of SAXS to 10−4 Å−1 and bridge the gap between SAXS and the optical microscope.2,3 USAXS features very high angular collimation in one or both collimating directions, which enables a small minimum scattering momentum that can be distinguished from the direct beam. This collimation is usually performed with single-crystal optics, first proposed by Compton nearly a century ago.4 The first experimental realization of crystal collimation was achieved in the early 1920s.5 This technique, however, suffered significant parasitic scattering from the surface scattering from the imperfect crystals and could hardly compete with slit- and curved-crystal collimation introduced by Guinier.1 In 1965, Bonse and Hart in their seminal work demonstrated that the parasitic scattering tails can be greatly suppressed with multiple reflections on channel-cut crystals.6 This result, together with the increasing availability of near-perfect Ge or Si crystals, makes double-crystal multiple-reflection collimation preferable when high angular collimation is desired. The Bonse-Hart configuration enables small-angle scattering which is commonly “behind the beamstop” in pinhole SAXS to be probed, and forms the basis of modern USAXS instruments. Many USAXS instruments have been constructed over the years using various X-ray sources, for example lab sources,7–11 second-generation synchrotron sources,8,12–14 and third-generation synchrotron sources.15–17 By making use of very long camera length (sample-to-detector distance), pinhole SAXS can also reach the low-end scattering angle offered by the Bonse-Hart configuration, albeit the total scattering range is comparatively limited.18,19 In a recent development, Cerbino et al.20 showed that analysis of near-field coherent speckles could provide scattering information in a range even lower than that afforded by Bonse-Hart cameras, though with limitations. In addition to a broad q range, USAXS also offers several distinct advantages such as high angular resolution (limited mainly by the width of the crystal rocking curve), wide dynamic range of intensity (∼8 to 9 orders of magnitude in instruments operated in thirdgeneration synchrotrons15,17), accurate energy tuning (E/E as small as 0.00015 which enables anomalous-USAXS15), and primary calibration of the X-ray scattering cross section.14 The advancement of X-ray sources, especially the availability of high-flux undulator beamlines in third-generation synchrotrons, further facilitates the quest for low photon counting statistics for samples with low scattering contrast, which makes USAXS a useful technique for obtaining bulk and ensemble-averaged structural information at the micron range and below for soft matter such as polymers, colloids, and biomaterials. Furthermore, USAXS is often unique for the study of concentrated, opaque systems or systems that are prone to structural damage during the preparation for microscopy measurements, which are common among soft materials. USAXS has been utilized in the study of polymers and other soft materials since the operation of the first USAXS instrument.21 However, when compared with pinhole SAXS, USAXS is often regarded as underutilized.22 This is largely due to the deficiencies of previous versions of USAXS instruments, where low X-ray flux and high parasitic scattering hinders the successful applications of USAXS in such systems. Recent technical improvements have resolved these obstacles and made USAXS an increasingly appealing technique for studies of soft matter in general and polymers in particular. This review will cover USAXS studies of polymers and colloids, especially those employing synchrotron radiation, to demonstrate its versatility and effectiveness. We will start with recent advancements in USAXS instrumentation and data processing, which make USAXS more relevant to soft matter research. We will emphasize USAXS applications
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
61
in areas such as polymer nanocomposites, polymer gels and solutions, polymer blends, polymer micelles and microemulsions, and colloidal sciences. We hope that this review will act as a bridge to the existing instrumental capabilities and exciting sciences for which USAXS may be found suitable.
2. USAXS Instrumentation All Bonse-Hart USAXS instruments have schematic layouts similar to the one shown in Fig. 1. The main difference is the radiation source that is employed. Conventional X-ray sources, while easier to access, have disadvantages such as high beam divergence, low X-ray flux, and very limited availability of X-ray wavelength, which makes it difficult for USAXS to study specimens with low scattering contrast. Synchrotron sources, on the other hand, do not suffer these restrictions. It is especially true in the case of third-generation synchrotrons, where the X-ray energy from an undulator source is continuously tunable in a wide range (3.2 to 80 keV and above for Undulator A of the Advanced Photon Source23), X-ray flux at the sample position about 1013 photons s−1mm−1,15,16 and beam divergence about 10 microradian.24 These features contribute greatly to the sprouting of USAXS studies of polymeric systems in the past decade. After passing through beam defining slits and X-ray mirrors, the X-ray beam is collimated with multiple reflections in the collimating crystals. The angular divergence of the incident beam is fixed by the monochromator, and the angular width is decided by the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the collimating crystal reflection curve, which is given by the dynamical diffraction theory. For a single reflection, the tails of the rocking curve roughly follow a (θ -θ B )−2 law, where θ is the diffraction angle away from the surface, and θ B is the Bragg angle for the collimating crystal. Multiple reflections between the crystal pairs, although having no effect on the FWHM of the reflection curve, greatly reduce the tail reflection following (θ -θ B )−2n, where n is the number of reflections. In this manner, a large number of reflections act to deliver an optimized signal-to-noise ratio in the scattering data. The original Bonse-Hart design employed triple and fivefold reflections on channelcut crystals,21,25 which has been adopted in many USAXS instruments.7,11,16 An alternative is to employ an even number of reflections in both the collimating and analyzing crystal pairs.8,14,15 This geometry does not change the propagation direction of the X-ray beam, and therefore makes alignment easier when energy tuning is required. We note that in recently built USAXS instruments pseudo-channelcut crystals consisting of two pieces of separate crystals are preferred. This design enables better polishing of the crystal surfaces, and therefore significantly reduces parasitic scattering from loose
Figure 1. Schematic of a Bonse-Hart USAXS instrument in the one-dimensional collimation mode.
62
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
or disoriented crystallites. Brief polishing and etching procedures can be found in Ilavsky et al.15 and Sztucki and Narayanan.17 The scattered beam, after being analyzed by the analyzing crystals, is recorded by the detector. USAXS employs a point detection system, such as an avalanche photodiode detector (APD),13,16 PIN photodiode,15,26 and scintillation counting detector.7,8 To ensure the reliability and reproducibility of USAXS data, the detector is required to be linear over the entire dynamic range of USAXS. For example, a low-cost, low-noise, high quantum efficiency PIN photodiode detector is shown to be linear over 10 decades of X-ray intensity.26 Several operational modes of USAXS are available. When the sample is isotropic and the X-ray flux is the bottleneck, one-dimensionally collimated (slit-smeared) USAXS is normally preferred. For an anisotropic sample, however, true scattering data cannot be recovered from slit-smearing data. An additional dimension of collimation and analyzing would be required along the direction orthogonal to the directions of both beam propagation and first collimation. This two-dimensionally collimated USAXS offers effective pinhole collimation, and is capable of recording scattered intensity as a function of both momentum transfer q and azimuthal angle χ .27 Collimation along vertical and horizontal directions, however, greatly reduces the photon flux on the detector. This geometry, therefore, is practical only with high flux sources, such as an undulator source in a third-generation synchrotron. Within the framework of one- and two-dimensionally collimated USAXS, anomalous USAXS and selected-area USAXS measurements can be made by taking advantage of the high energy resolution and high stability of both sample and high-resolution beam defining slits. Examples of these configurations can be found in Ilavsky et al.15 We mention that USAXS imaging, a size-sensitive imaging technique, can be operated in a setup very similar to that of one-dimensional collimated USAXS, except that the camera length is very small and imaging data are collected with a two-dimensional charge-coupled device (CCD) camera instead of a point detector.28 USAXS imaging has been used to investigate a wide range of systems, from polymer composites29 to plastically deformed metals.30 The imaging contrast mechanism of USAXS imaging has been explained based on wave propagation and dynamical diffraction theory. Zhang et al.31 found that refraction in the form of Porod scattering and, to a much less extent, reflection, fully account for USAXS imaging contrast. In the end of this section, we take advantage of a comparison of SAXS and USAXS scattering profiles of the same sample to illustrate the capability of USAXS, as shown in Fig. 2. The sample is a polydispersed silica suspension in water. The USAXS profile was collected at the USAXS beamline (32ID-B) at the Advanced Photon Source (APS), Argonne National Laboratory. The SAXS profile was collected with a desktop SAXS instrument. The SAXS intensity was absolutely calibrated to match the USAXS intensity. Figure 2 clearly shows that USAXS offers a broader q range and dynamic range of the intensity. In addition, the USAXS intensity is automatically calibrated (details in Section 3). The very low-q end of the USAXS scattering profile demonstrates the angular resolution of USAXS, which can be as high as 1 × 10−4 Å−1.
3. Data Reduction and Analysis Data reduction process for USAXS consists of several standard procedures such as absolute intensity calibration, desmearing (for one-dimensional collimated USAXS), and (if necessary) correction for multiple scattering.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
63
Figure 2. Comparison of USAXS and intensity-calibrated SAXS profiles of silica in water suspension.
For small-angle X-ray scattering, the scattering intensity I(q) is written as14 I (q) = 0 AtT ε
d d
(1)
where 0 is the incident X-ray flux in photons s−1 area−1, A is the illuminated sample area, t is the sample thickness, T is the sample transmission, ε is the converting efficiency of the detector, is the detector solid angle, and d (q)/d is the differential scattering cross section per unit volume per unit solid angle. It can be shown that absolute calibration of the scattering cross section only depends on the known quantities t, T, , and I0 .14 Therefore, a Bonse-Hart USAXS camera provides inherent absolute scattering intensity, which is essential for many important aspects of quantitative small-angle scattering analysis, such as obtaining the number density, volume fraction, and the specific surface area of the scatterers. Taking advantage of these properties, Zhang et al. established glassy carbon as an absolute intensity calibration standard, which is readily available for SAXS laboratories so as to incorporate absolute intensity analysis.32 For one-dimensional collimated USAXS, correction for slit smearing is required to recover the correct scattering cross section. The schematic of finite slit scattering is shown in Fig. 3. The vertical slit width 2w0 is decided by the FWHM of the crystal rocking curve. The horizontal slit length 2l0 is only restricted by the detector. The vertical slit-width 2w0 is comparable to the angular resolution of the instrument and is much smaller than 2l0 . Thus its correction is negligible. Consequently, the slit-smeared USAXS intensity is described
64
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
Figure 3. Schematic of finite slit scattering in one-dimensional collimated USAXS. 2θ is the scattering angle, 2l0 is the slit length, 2w0 is the slit width. Pl and Pw are the slit-length and slit-width weighing functions, respectively.
by ˜ 1 d (q) = d l0
0
l0
d 2 q + l 2 dl, d
(2)
˜ where d (q)/d is the measured, slit-smeared scattering intensity; d (q)/d is the unsmeared scattering cross section; and l is the reciprocal vector of integration in the slit direction. d (q)/d can be accurately calculated following an iterative algorithm developed by Lake.33 Because USAXS data are obtained in directions very close to that of the incident beam, multiple scattering can sometimes be significant. Multiple scattering is indicated by the apparent broadening of the rocking curve when the sample is in the beam. This effect can be corrected following a procedure described in Ilavsky et al.15 We note that multiple scattering is mostly negligible for samples with low scattering contrasts, such as polymer melts, and solutions. The reduced data are analyzed within the framework of small-angle scattering theory, which is outside the scope of this paper and will not be discussed in detail here. Interested readers are encouraged to refer to standard small-angle scattering references1,34,35 or related articles in this issue. We do note, however, that Irena, a tool suite that is developed for the support of the USAXS instrument at the Advanced Photon Source, brings together a variety of advanced small-angle scattering data modeling and evaluation tools and is in free circulation.36
4. Radiation Damage USAXS measurements making use of the Bonse-Hart configuration scan the reciprocal space point-by-point. Accordingly, samples are exposed to the X-ray beam much longer
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
65
(∼10 min) than normally required with a pinhole camera. X-ray radiation damage to the sample therefore becomes a concern, especially for soft materials. It is well known that polymers degrade when exposed to intense X-ray radiation.37–41 Many chemical processes take place concurrently, each progressing at a different rate. For example, intense X-rays create photoelectric electrons, which are shown to be linearly dependent on the X-ray dose.42 For this effect, commonly known as primary radiation damage, an upper limit of the radiation damage was observed. In polymeric and biological materials, photoelectric electrons are capable of further damaging the specimen through the creation of free radicals, which lead to hydroperoxidation and consequent chain scission43 thus altering the polymeric microstructure. This process is normally referred to as secondary radiation damage. Despite the understanding of the chemical pathways, various aspects of X-ray radiation damage still have not been elucidated. Its prevention remains largely empirical. Practical mitigating approaches include monitoring a sample’s discoloration, repeating USAXS measurements to monitor the reproducibility of scattering profile as a function of time, and employing a flow-cell for polymer or colloidal suspensions.44 Extra attention needs to be paid to the prevention of radiation damage so as to ensure the quality of data.
5. Applications In this section, we present an overview of various USAXS applications in the studies of polymer gel and solution, colloidal dispersion, microemulsion, etc. The broad q range, high dynamic range, and very high angular resolution make USAXS a unique technique in these examples, which we will address. Here, we will not go into the details of individual analysis. Instead, we will devote the next section to the fundamentals and general principles of USAXS analysis.
5.1 Polymer Gels and Solutions Polymer gels form when polymers arrange into three-dimensional networks by virtue of covalent or noncovalent bonding in a second medium. Depending on the binding mechanism, polymer gels can be classified into chemical gels and physical gels. Polymer gels often exhibit hierarchical structure, with the largest dimensions on the length scale of or greater than 100 nm, which makes USAXS an appealing technique. Much effort has been conducted in the USAXS study of various polymer gels,45–66 such as hydrogels,45–49 organogels,51–54 xerogels,56, 57 and aerogels.57, 60–66 Hydrogels are composed of water-insoluble polymer chains and are highly absorbent of water. Hydrogels have a complicated structure on both the nano- and micro- scale. Due to their significant water content, hydrogels possess a degree of flexibility that resembles natural tissue. Agrawal et al.45 studied the nano- and micro-scale structures of biocompatible poly(L -lactic-acid)–poly(ethylene oxide)–poly(L -lactic acid) (PLLA-PEO-PLLA) gels. The USAXS spectra at low q were fit to a power law. The exponent monotonically increased with increasing length of crystalline PLLA blocks, which suggested that the internal structure of the hydrogel became denser during this process. Ando and Konishi46 studied the structure of transparent (VI-P) and translucent (VI-L) cellulose hydrogels prepared by coagulation and regeneration of viscose in acid solutions with and without acetone. By assuming a twophase model, the authors determined the volume fraction and average size of a high-density phase that only consists of cellulose in both types of gels.
66
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
When ambient conditions such as temperature, solvent quality, and electric field change, hydrogels are often subject to a first-order volume phase transition (VPT). Tirumala et al.48 studied temperature-induced VPT in neutral poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PIPAAm), poly(N,N-diethylacrylamide) (PDEAAm), and poly(N-isopropylmethacrylamide) (PIPMAm) hydrogels and their weakly charged counterparts prepared by copolymerizing with sodium methacrylate. USAXS results showed an abrupt VPT in both PIPAAm and PIPMAm gels, but a continuous one in PDEAAM gels. Furthermore, the VPTs were suppressed in poly(N-alkylacrylamide)s but not in PIPMAm with the addition of sodium methacrylate. The authors attributed these observed difference in VPTs to the hydrogen-bonding constraints on thermal fluctuations instead of relative hydrophobicity, as one would normally expect. Grigoriew et al.51–54 conducted a series of USAXS studies on organogels, a group of thermoreversible, viscoelastic materials formed from low-molecular-weight organic gelators. The authors found that the gel structure of monosaccharide is highly dependent on the gelator concentration.51,53 When the concentration increases, the sizes of the gelator aggregates decrease and their shapes change from disk-like to rod-like. Additionally, the sizes of the primary aggregates were found to depend strongly on the polarity of the gelators.54 Xerogel and aerogel form when the solvent is removed. Xerogels undergo unhindered shrinkage during drying, while aerogels are obtained under hypercritical conditions, which lead to no shrinkage. Both are highly porous materials and possess extremely high surface areas. USAXS is often utilized to understand the nature of the porosity in these materials. For example, a study of organosilioxane-aerosil aerogel provided evidence of two fractal structures, one built up by the organosilioxane, the other by the added silica soot.64 Schaefer et al.57 observed porosity in the nanometer range with a distinct feature of fractal in arylenebridged polysilsesquioxane xerogels and aerogels. The pore morphology shows a systematic dependence on the bridging group, but is only weakly dependent on the catalyst type, concentration, and the drying protocol. Pahl et al.66 showed that the average pore size and mass fractal dimension of resorcinol-formaldehyde (RF) aerogels change systematically as a function of resorcinol-to-catalyst ratio. Brandt and Fricke63 studied subcritically dried RF aerogels with very high catalyst concentrations. A wide range of pore size, from <1 nm to 200 nm, was reported. While SAXS is considered to be one of the best available techniques to measure the morphology of macromolecules,67 USAXS studies of polymer solutions have been few and far between. Compared with USANS, the X-ray scattering contrast is unfavorable. Compared with SAXS, USAXS features a size range that is large for individual macromolecules, and a measurement time that could easily incur radiation damage when precaution is not taken. Nonetheless, USAXS has been successfully utilized in a few cases.68–70 In one example, Li et al.69 observed a small-angle upturn in the USAXS spectra of sulfonated polystyrene ionomers and found that this upturn was not strongly dependent upon the counterions, compression-molding condition, temperature, and annealing. Instead of explaining the upturn using the Debye-Bueche model, the authors described the upturn with a power law and attributed its origin to polydispersity and irregularity when long-range order was absent. This analysis would not have been possible if not for the extended q range provided by USAXS. 5.2 Polymer Blends Polymers of different species are frequently blended together as a common industrial method to reduce cost and tune the property and functionality for a given application.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
67
In academia, polymer blends, as model systems rich in nonlinear, nonequilibrium phenomena, offer fascinating research opportunities. Depending on the miscibility of the polymeric components, polymer blends can form various structures, including microphase and macrophase domains in a phase separation process. It is therefore important to understand the morphological transitions in polymer melts and blends, and their implications on the structure-property relationship of the materials. USAXS, due to its q range, often proves useful to study the large structures in binary or ternary blends where one or more components crystallize. In a recent work, Michiewicz et al.71 studied binary blends of four different high-molecular-weight poly(styrene-b-isoprene) diblock copolymers with a lowmolecular-weight poly(styrene-b-isoprene-b-styrene) triblock copolymer and established a morphological phase diagram in the parameter space of molecular weight ratio R and blend composition. The values of R (14 < R < 43) probed in this study were significantly larger than the known ratios (R < 7). Similar to the case of 5 < R < 7, the authors found a large miscibility gap with macrophase separation into two distinct microphase-separated domains, as well as morphological transitions from lamellar to cylindrical structures. In addition, for R > 30, the blends also exhibit disordered bicontinuous and double-gyroid-like structures. The same research group also explored a ternary blend of a poly(styrene-b-isoprene) dilock copolymer, polystyrene, and polyisoprene solution-casted from cumene as a candidate of photonic crystals.72,73 The dried sample showed a well-defined peak in the reflectivity curve in the visible wavelength range (350–600 nm), which indicates a large structure formed in the blend. USAXS measurements for samples containing 20% and 40% homopolymers confirmed that the morphology of the blend was a highly ordered lamellar. The alternating layers of styrene and isoprene were found to possess a periodic dielectric structure, with their thicknesses 0.52 L and 0.48 L, respectively, where L is the lamellar thickness. Based on this structure, the band diagram was calculated, and pass- and stop-band were consequently obtained. To strengthen microphase separation and increase the inter-domain spacing of block copolymer melts, Tirumala et al.74 studied the effect of adding an additive poly(acrylic acid) homopolymer with a molar mass 1–13 times that of the poly(oxyethylene-oxypropyleneoxyethylene) copolymer on the Flory-Huggins segment-segment interaction parameter χ . While the neat copolymer was disordered, the addition of poly(acrylic acid) resulted in a well-ordered lamellar structure with an interdomain distance of 10 ± 1 nm. Powerlaw decay was consistently observed in the low-q region of slit-smeared USAXS profiles with exponent between 2 and 2.5, which is below the Porod exponent 3. This result showed that the droplet macrophase separation of homopolymers is not present in the blend regardless of its molar mass. Instead, the homopolymer was expected to uniformly distribute through the polyoxyethylene domains of the lamellae-forming blends. Kobayashi et al.75 combined light scattering (LS), USAXS, and SAXS and studied the self-assembly and morphology of l,3:2,4-bis-O-(p-methylbenzylidene)-D-sorbitol/ndibutylphthalate in the parameter space of temperature T and solute concentration PDTS in detail. In particular, USAXS was found useful for establishing the characteristic distances in the self-assembled states and the power-law slope in the gel states. Again, a mass fractal dimension was observed, which excluded the presence of a sharp interface. Combined with the previous example, this result suggests that USAXS is a powerful technique for investigating the degree of phase separation in the polymer blends.
68
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
5.3 Polymer Micelles and Microemulsions Surfactant molecules dispersed in selective solvents can self-assemble into various micellar morphologies such as sphere, ellipsoid, cylinder, and bilayer. Similarly, microemulsions form when two immiscible liquids are mixed together with at least one component being surface active. Polymer micelles and microemulsions often have sizes that make USAXS a suitable technique. In this section, we show a few recent USAXS applications for these systems. One example is the determination of the structure of casein micelles by Pignon et al.76 Casein micelles (calcium-protein complexes), milk fat globules, and milk sugar (lactose) are the three main biological components of milk. Despite being the subject of extensive investigation, the exact structural details of casein micelles have remained elusive.77 Using USAXS and unified analysis, as is shown in Fig. 4, the authors found two characteristic length scales for the equilibrium structure of casein, with radius of gyrations Rg about 100 and 5.6 nm pertaining to the globular micelles and their non-globular internal structure, respectively. The low-q region of the USAXS curve followed a q−4 power-law decay, which suggests the existence of a smooth interface of the large, globular micelles. The high-q region showed a decay following q−2, which was described by the Debye formula for entangled flexible polymer chains. This physical picture was in agreement with a recently proposed casein micelle model, which negated the existence of the submicellar structure within the micelle.78 In a subsequent work, Marchin et al.79 considered the environmental factors on the casein micelle structures. The casein micelles were fractionated into six fractions using a sequence of six consecutive centrifugation steps. In the low-q region, different Rgs were obtained, as expected. The globular structure of the micelles was confirmed in all cases. In the high-q region, the USAXS curves showed identical fractal-like features, which demonstrated that micelles of different fractions, albeit with different sizes, possessed the same internal structure. Furthermore, the authors studied the effects of temperature, pH, and calcium chelation on the structure of casein micelles. Thermo-treatments were found to have little influence on the structure as the USAXS curves overlapped. Reducing pH did not change the low-q region of the scattering curve, which suggested that the globular structure was independent of the acidity, at least in the range of pH probed. The change in the high-q
Figure 4. Static SAXS and USAXS measurements of casein micelle suspensions at 25◦ C and pH = 6.6. The continuous lines in the figure are obtained with unified fit.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
69
region confirmed that the internal structure of casein micelles was related to the presence of micellar calcium phosphate, which was disassociated at a lower pH value of 5.2. When the casein micelles were depleted of calcium by chelation, the USAXS curves completely changed over the entire q range and suggested the destruction of globular structure of the micelles. Di Cola et al.80 studied the morphologies of micelles formed by linear and cyclic poly(styrene-b-isoprene) (PS166 -b-PI278 ) copolymers in different solvents as a function of temperature. The micelles have one characteristic length scale of the order 100 nm, which makes USAXS suitable. For linear copolymers, the morphology of micelles formed in good solvents for PS blocks does not vary with temperature. A detailed analysis of USAXS spectra of linear copolymer in good solvents for PI blocks for temperatures above 60◦ C showed that the micelles undergo a cylinder-vesicle transition. For a cyclic copolymer, its morphology was found to be independent of both temperature and concentration. Zemb and coworkers utilized USAXS to study the structures of microemulsions.81,82 For example, Testard et al.81 examined the effect of apolar solute lindane on the microstructure of water-didodecyldimethylammoniumbromide (DDAB)-dodecane ternary microemulsion. The absolute intensity in the high-q region of USAXS curves showed a q−4 power-law dependency, demonstrating the presence of a sharp oil/water interface. The specific area measured at the Porod limit yielded the area per surfactant, which was shown to be irrelevant to the solute concentration. In addition, with increasing solute concentration, the characteristic size of the microemulsion cell was found to decrease. These structural results, together with conductivity measurements, were consistent with a disordered, open connected cylinders model. 5.4 Polymer Nanocomposites Modification of polymers with an inorganic or organic material as fillers or additives to produce polymer composites is one of the most successful examples of polymer engineering in the chemical industry. Polymer nanocomposites, in which the secondary, or in uncommon cases, ternary materials have dimensions of less than 100 nm, or structures with comparable repeating distances, offer exciting opportunities not possible with conventional polymer composite materials.83,84 Compared with macroscopic or microscopic composite fillers, the nanoscale fillers offer advantages such as ultra-high surface area per unit mass, ultra-low filler mass concentration to achieve filler percolation, and small interparticle distances in the polymer matrices. As a result, polymer nanocomposites are lighter than the conventional polymer composites and exhibit large increases in tensile modulus, strength, toughness, and heat resistance. Due to their outstanding properties, polymer nanocomposites have found many applications such as conducting polymers,85 optical materials,86 and fire retardants.87 The physical mechanism behind these applications, however, remains controversial and elusive, largely due to the complex, and often hierarchical structures of polymer nanocomposites. In polymer nanocomposites, the nanoscale fillers present an enormous amount of interfacial areas, which leads to direct interaction between polymers and the filler components. This effect introduces heterogeneity within the polymer matrix on the nanoscale and deforms the polymer from its bulk confirmation. The primary filler particles, with a length scale of tens of nanometers, form aggregates, which in turn could form agglomerates. Understanding this structural variation is crucial in terms of understanding various material behaviors of polymer nanocomposites. USAXS, because of its favorable q range, is an ideal tool for this investigation. Due to the hierarchical nature of the structure, unified analysis developed
70
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
by Beaucage88 is often the method of choice, which results in interpretation based on an analogy of surface or mass fractals.89,90 Narayanan et al.91 studied the structure of silica-polyvinyl acetate nanocomposites with matrices of two different molecular weights. They found that particle aggregation is independent of the molecular weight of the matrix for a fixed filler concentration and surface treatment. They also reported that various surface treatments reduce the bonding strength to the polymer matrix, as well as reduce the particle aggregation. This result was in agreement with a nonlinear viscoelastic study of the same nanocomposites above glass transition temperatures by Sternstein et al.92 Ehrburger-Dolle et al.93 studied the anisotropic structure of carbon black (CB)-filled, high-density polyethylene (HDPE) polymers. No anisotropy was observed when the CB concentration was below its percolation threshold. For concentrations above the threshold, CB aggregates with a fractal dimension less than 2 were found, and their role in the mechanical properties of CB filled nanocomposites was consistent with the model for reinforcement of rubber by fractal aggregates proposed by Witten et al.94 In a separate study of CB and polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) nanocomposites, Levine et al.95 found that mechanically prepared samples exhibit very high electric conductivity at an extremely low CB loading percentage. USAXS measurements were used to explain this phenomenon as the formation of a three-dimensional CB-assembled nanowire network, with the mean diameter and length of the nanowire about 24 nm and up to 100 µm, respectively, which was further confirmed by USAXS imaging. Thill et al.96,97 studied spray-dried nanocomposites of silica and bromostyrene-styrene copolymer prepared by a one-step droplet drying process. The fine structure of the grains and the localization of the polymers were described. Instead of having empty pores in the dried composites, copolymers were found to fill half of the porous volume. Bellare et al.98–100 performed a series of studies on PMMA and barium sulfate nanocomposites as bone cement materials. To strengthen and provide a higher resistance to cracking, 100-nm barium sulfate particles were used instead of conventional 1–3 µm barium sulfate or zirconium oxide radiopacifiers. By comparing the analyzed total specific area with the theoretical value, they found that the nanoparticles were well dispersed in the PMMA matrix and the number of voids was limited. The stronger bonding resulting from this structure was confirmed by the increases in tensile strain-to-failure, tensile work-of-fracture, and fatigue life obtained through mechanical measurements. Chemin et al.101 studied the structure and mechanical properties of mesostructured functional hybrid coatings based on anisotropic nanoparticles dispersed in poly(hydroxylethyl methacrylate) (PHEMA). They reported that at low volume fraction, the anisotropic goethite nanorods and isotropic nanospheres form a homogeneous dispersion within the polymer matrix, which led to a strong reinforcement effect of PHEMA. Ikeda et al.102 reported an isotropic dispersion of silica nanoparticles in an in situ study of the morphological variation of silica/isoprene rubber nanocomposites. The scattering patterns change according to the stretching ratio in a manner similar to that of liquid crystalline elastomers under stress103 which indicated that the nanoparticles displaced affinely with the elastomer network. These results were further utilized as data input for reverse Monte Carlo simulation104,105 which showed that the structural change of the nanoparticles during elongation was minimal. Recenly, Kumar et al.106 observed anisotropic assembly of isotropic nanoparticles in a polymer nanocomposites system. Polystyrene chains were grafted onto the surface of spherical silica nanoparticles, the average diameter of which was about 14 nm. These
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
71
Figure 5. USAXS profiles of silica grafted with different molecules mass (Mg ) of polystyrene brush. The continous lines are obtained with unified fit.
isotropic particles were implanted into isotropic polystyrene matrices of different molecular masses. USAXS, shown in Fig. 5, and TEM measurements found that after prolonged annealing, the isotropic grafted nanoparticles were capable of assembling into spherical aggregates, connected sheets, and strings, or stay well dispersed (unstructured) depending on the relative grafting density and grafted chain length. This extraordinary behavior was explained by the balance between the short-range interparticle attraction and the entropy loss of the distorted grafted polymers, and opens a new paradigm for the control of nanoparticle dispersion in a polymer matrix. Most notably, Schaefer and his coworkers68,107–126 have performed an extensive survey of various polymer nanocomposites using USAXS. The nanoscale fillers range from single-walled carbon nanotube68,124 (SWCNT) and multi-walled carbon nanotube118,123 (MWCNT) to precipitated silica.107,111,114,125,126 For these fillers, a typical small-angle scattering profile is shown in Fig. 6, where light scattering and USAXS data for Dimosil precipitated silica120 are combined to illustrate the levels of structures present in the sample. It is evident from the data that the primary particles (in this case, silica) form aggregates, which are further clustered into two types of agglomerates. Similar results were found in SWCNT124 and MWCNT118 dispersions as well, which directly showed that the nanoparticles, instead of being well dispersed, form aggregates and agglomerates. Considering that the presumption of nanoparticle reinforcement in nanocomposites is that the smaller nanoparticles offer more surface area and hence stronger bonding, these results pose a serious question for the overall effectiveness of polymer nanocomposites. For example, for the nanocomposite of MWCNT and melt-processed thermoplastic polyamide 6 (PA6), Zhao et al.117 found that the CNTs are quite flexible, regardless of the degree of chemical modification. Due to the flexibility of CNT, the yield strength of CNTs/PA6 nanocomposites is almost unchanged, and the tensile strength is only slightly increased. In a recent work, Schaefer et al.122 further showed that despite the formation of aggregates and agglomerates and the unremarkable performance in nanocomposites with hard matrices, carbon nanofibers are still capable of reinforcing soft materials (in this case, a
72
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
Figure 6. Combined light and USAXS scattering data for Dimosil precipated silica in the wet and dried states.
carbon nanofiber/thermoplastic polyurethane nanocomposite), although through a different mechanism. The fractal clusters formed by the nanofiber agglomerates are capable of storing elastic energy, which in turn explains the improvement in the mechanical strength. For a detailed and in-depth review of Schaefer’s work on nanocomposites, interested readers can refer to Schaefer et al.120 5.5 Colloidal Suspensions and Gels Colloidal suspensions and gels often have intrinsic sizes or characteristic distances befitting the q range of USAXS. The high-q resolution serves to obtain an accurate scattering structure factor, and the inherent absolute intensity calibration enables determination of number density of scattering particles. All these features are important to the understanding of basic statistical mechanical interactions and microstructures of such systems. Because of these reasons, USAXS has enjoyed great success in various colloidal systems, such as monocomponent dispersions,127–136 binary or ternary mixtures,137–139 colloidal gels,125,140–146 and colloidal crystals.147–151 In addition to the aforementioned advantages, USAXS allows precise measurement of the scattered intensity as q approaches 0. The normalized scattering intensity at q = 0 is related to the osmotic compressibility of the suspension. Furthermore, as previously mentioned, the structure factor of a colloidal suspension is often conveniently obtained in USAXS measurements. Therefore, USAXS profiles can be used to determine interparticle potentials or test models that govern the stability of colloidal suspension. For example, Tara et al.152 reported amorphous clustering of highly charged poly(chlorostyrene-styrene sulfonate) colloids in dilute deionized suspensions of various concentrations. In all cases, the structure factors showed a first peak and a split second peak, which indicated the formation of glasslike order despite the dilute nature of the dispersion. This research was
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
73
among the first experimental evidence of long-range attraction in colloidal suspensions of low volume fraction. When the colloidal particles interact via an attractive, short-range potential, which is significantly greater than the thermal energy, a gas-liquid-type jamming transition can happen at a very low colloidal packing fraction. Pontoni et al.153 studied the static microstructure of charged silica colloidal particles in a binary mixture of 2,6 lutidine and heavy water near the fully reversible colloidal aggregation temperature TA . They found that at a low volume fraction (8% volume), the colloidal particles undergo repulsive to short-range attractive transition by a temperature dependent absorption process. Furthermore, the first maximum of the structure factor S(q) well above TA is below the Hansen-Verlet criterion 2.85, which suggests that the aggregated state has the dense, liquid-like packing feature of gas-liquid transition of colloids, instead of that of a freezing transition. In a similar, but more detailed study, Sztucki et al.154 investigated the static structure of a short-range interacting colloidal system over a large range of colloidal concentrations, including the vicinity of a reentrant glass-liquid-glass transition. The structure factor was modeled with an attractive square-well potential. The results, including the depth and range of the interparticle attraction and the structure of the aggregates, were found to be consistent with the predictions of a mode-coupling theory.155 The fine angular resolution and wide q range of USAXS make it an excellent technique for binary colloidal suspensions. Lutterbach et al.137 studied the static structure of the charge-stabilized polystyrene (PS) and perfluorinated (PFA) particles with diameters of 79 and 162 nm with a total volume fraction of 9%. PS and PFA have greatly different scattering length densities in water. Due to this property, the authors were able to extract the PFA-PFA partial structure factor and found the intensity of the first peak of this partial structure factor decreases with decreasing number fraction of PFA, which suggested the weakening of liquid-like order. The results were found to be in good agreement with predictions made by DLVO theory. USAXS is also applied in a binary suspension with large size ratio. Zhang et al.139 investigated the arrangement of highly charged zirconia nanoparticles (mean radius 2.57 nm) near the surface of negligibly charged silica microspheres (mean radius 280.11 nm), as shown in Fig. 7. The nanoparticles were shown to form a loose layer near the surface of the microspheres, with average nanoparticle-to-microsphere surface separation distance of 2 nm, which is nearly equivalent to the Debye length. The nanoparticle concentration in this layer is significantly higher than that in the bulk solution, and the average nanoparticle separation distance within the layer is about 9 times that of the nanoparticle radius. This result experimentally illustrated the static structure of a colloidal nanoparticle halo156 which has remained elusive since its discovery mainly because of the size discrepancy between the nanoparticles and microspheres. When the colloidal particles are anisotropic in shape, 2-D collimated USAXS is preferred over slit-smeared USAXS because of the complicated desmearing involved. Mock et al.157 used 2-D collimated USAXS to study the static microstructures of anisotropic polystyrene particles of various degree of anisotropy. The particle form factors of the anisotropic particles are represented by two interpenetrating spheres, with one sphere possessing a constant diameter and the other possessing a varying diameter. By changing the volume concentration, the colloids undergo a disorder-order transition. An example of anisotropic homonuclear colloids and corresponding USAXS profiles is shown in Fig. 8. Interestingly, the authors found that when the volume concentration is below 45%, the anisotropic colloids form a rotary or plastic crystal phase, where the centers of mass of the particles are ordered, but not the particle director. When the concentration is higher, the colloids form a body-center tetragonal structure, where both the center of mass and
74
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
Figure 7. USAXS measurements of monodisperse silica, zirconia, and the mixture of silica and zirconia. The continuous lines are least-squares fitting with user-defined mode in the framework of Irena SAS analysis package. Note the greatly different size (q) range of silica and zirconia.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
75
Figure 8. USAXS of anisotropic homonuclear colloids. The colloids, shown in Fig. 8(a), can be approximated with overlapping particles models obtained with Debye model for single particle scattering. Figure 8(b) shows its USAXS at 5% vol and its fit with Debye model.
the director are ordered. In a separate experiment, Levitz et al.158 studied the suspension of charged, disk-like synthetic clay Laponite/particles at very low ionic strength (in the order of 10−5M). By changing the concentration of the clay particles, a liquid-soft solid transition driven by electrostatic repulsive interaction was observed. The soft solid features a correlation peak at low-q. A detailed inspection of the peak showed that the clay particles form clusters, instead of being uniformly dispersed. In a rather unusual, gaseous colloidal suspension, Beaucage et al.159,160 studied the in situ nanoparticle nucleation and growth in flame aerosols at different positions inside the flame. The nanoparticles were found to form aggregates and agglomerates, the size and morphology of which were in turn mapped with the height above the burner and lateral distance from the axial center of the flame. The height above the burner was further converted to a kinetic time with the known gas flow rate. The dynamics of nanoparticle growth in flames was thus acquired. When attractive interaction exists between colloids, it is well known that the colloidal particles can aggregate to form colloidal gels which often have the characteristics of a fractal.161 For a mixture of hard-sphere colloids and nonadsorbing polymers, depletion attraction arises from the entropy-driven exclusion of the polymers from the region between closely neighbored colloids, where the range and strength of this effective attraction can be delicately tuned. Zukoski et al.141–146,162,163 performed a series of detailed and in-depth investigation of such concentrated depletion gels. In one example, Shah et al.141 studied the influence of polymer concentration and radius of gyration of the polymer on the microstructure of model hard-sphere nanocolloids, where the volume fraction of colloids was fixed at 0.40. For the given system where the radius of gyration was significantly smaller than the mean radius of the colloids, a direct homogeneous fluid to nonequilibrium gel transition was observed with increasing polymer concentration. The authors deducted the scattering structure factor S(q) by comparing the concentrated USAXS profile with corresponding dilute profile of the same particles and modeled S(q) with the polymer reference site interaction model (PRISM).164,165 The elastic modulus of the gel, yielded by
76
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
Figure 9. USAXS measurements of highly monodisperse silica beads. The insert shows a magnified curve near q = 3.2 × 10 −4 Å−1, where the oscillations are still clearly visible due to the very high angular resolution that USAXS provides.
this model, was found to depend on the polymer-colloid size ratio and the reduced polymer concentration in a power-law fashion. This study was extended further by Ramakrishnan et al.142 where the volume fraction dependence of the collective structure and the elastic modulus of colloidal gels of the same type was investigated. The elastic modulus extracted from PRISM was shown to have a power-law dependence on the volume fraction of the colloids, with an effective exponent decreasing with increasing depletion attraction strength. Despite the fact that the discussion in this section is confined to colloidal suspensions and gels, it is necessary to point out that USAXS is a valuable and often unique tool when investigating large particles with narrow size distribution in their ordered states due to the small angular resolution of USAXS. One example as shown in Fig. 9 is given in Ilavsky et al.,15 where USAXS profiles of monodisperse silica beads in their dilute and ordered states were compared. At q as large as 3 × 10−2 Å−1, the oscillations from the scattering form factor were still clearly visible. This feature facilitates the accurate and reliable extraction of the structure factor, and predictably, will also be useful to identify sharp diffraction peaks, if present. 5.6 Other Materials In addition to the examples shown in the previous sections, USAXS has been successfully utilized in other areas of polymeric and colloidal research, such as non-affine deformation of soft colloidal films,166 self-assembly of cellulose that is artificially synthesized via enzymatic polymerization,167 structure of dendrimers with univalent and bivalent counterions in ionic dilute solutions,168 forced assembly of two immiscible polymers produced by layer-multiplying extrusion,169 water-swollen perfluorinated ionomer membranes,170
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
77
structure of hydroxypropyl cellulose as flavor-barrier membrane,171 morphology of dry lignins and size and shape of dissolved lignin particles,172 nanostructure evolution of polyethylene,173–175 the failure mechanism of glass-beads filled polystyrene,176,177 the domain-interface sharpening process during crystallization,178 and the degree of homogeneity of homogeneous dispersions.179 These examples, together with the aforementioned examples, explicitly demonstrate the wide-range applicability of USAXS. Recent technical improvements to the available instruments have made USAXS an increasingly attractive tool to study large scale and hierarchical structures in complex fluids. As a result, more effort has been made to employ the unique capability of USAXS to understand physical, chemical, or engineering properties of these materials. There is no doubt that USAXS, as a proven structure-characterization technique, will continue to tackle complex, yet important and interesting scientific problems in soft condensed matter.
6. State of Analysis for USAXS Data USAXS instruments, when compared with pinhole SAXS instruments, provide a wider range of scattering vector as well as a larger dynamic range of scattering intensity. The information content of USAXS data, therefore, is more complete. In principle, the results obtained from proper analyses of USAXS data ought to be more accurate and more representative of the microstructures studied. However, it sometimes seems that the exact opposite is true. Developing a model which would describe the microstructure over up to four decades in size, such as that in the case of USAXS study of binary colloidal mixture with great size disparity139 is not a simple feat; and many studies significantly fail in this regard. In this review we have reported the wide range of USAXS applications in polymers, while realizing that the quality of data analysis varies. So far, we have avoided pointing out specific flaws in data analysis to keep the review easier to follow. In this section we will identify the major challenges facing USAXS data analysis, and will offer some general suggestions regarding good practices in this area. We will also provide a few examples where analysis may have fallen short. While ab initio small angle scattering (SAS) analysis can still be seen in literature, it has become more popular to construct SAS analysis based on existing SAXS analysis packages. The availability of these packages not only makes the analysis more convenient, but also establishes a degree of confidence to the analysis, considering that the software packages, which are tested and employed by many users, are less error-prone. Some packages were developed on the basis of the Igor Pro commercial scientific software (Wavemetrics, 2008), for example, NIST analysis tools,180 Motofit,181 and Irena.36 Self-standing SAS packages developed with more common programming languages (Fortran, C, Java, Pascal, etc.) also exist, such as Scatter,182 SASFit,183 Fish,184 and ATSAS, a suite of software developed by Svergun et al.185–189 The exact functionalities of these packages vary, and there are usually specific areas where they excel. For example, ATSAS186 is the undisputed standard for bio-SAXS analysis. The wide availability of these packages may lead the users to enjoy the seemingly large freedom regarding curve fitting, and sometimes base their analysis on convenience, rather than facts. It is worth being aware that proper usage of any SAS analysis package or any SAS analysis method in general, stresses on the reliance of the users to be knowledgeable about the specific problem and capable of choosing an appropriate tool/method. This is more evident for USAXS analysis because most SAS analysis packages except Irena are not primarily developed to be used with USAXS data.
78
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
As stated above, the main challenge to USAXS data analysis lies in the fact that USAXS probes a wide range of scattering vector. Therefore it is necessary to design either one model to describe the microstructure over such a wide range of sizes—potentially from Angstrom to micron, or to find a valid approach to split the data into different segments, analyze each segment with an appropriate method, and then combine the results in a meaningful way to describe the microstructure. For example, Unified fit is developed for the latter case88,90 in which the microstructure is modeled as a sequence of hierarchical structural levels. These levels could be independent or could also possess complex relationships among themselves. One needs to have a fundamentally sound understanding of the sample to assign the true meaning of each structural level in terms of the underlying microstructure. Having clearly stated and defendable basis for the chosen analysis method is of essential importance for fitting of any small-angle scattering data. It is especially this case for USAXS data analysis, as its q range is extensive and various portions of data may need to be analyzed with different assumptions. It is also crucial to realize that different methods (packages) may have different foundations. For instance, ATSAS assumes that the scatterers are mono-sized and mono-shaped; volume size-distribution analysis assumes that the scatterers have the same shape but varying sizes, and fractal analysis assumes self-similarity of the microstructure over an extended length scale. A good example of proper USAXS analysis with several methods combined can be found in the investigation of the structure of nanocomposites by Schaefer and Justice,120 where scattering from primary particles was analyzed by Guinier analysis or size-distribution analysis, and the structure of large-scale aggregates and agglomerates were obtained with fractal analysis. We do note, however, that in some cases multiple analysis methods are used without befitting justification.51,54 One example is shown in Fig. 10, which is an attempt to fit USAXS data from apolar and polar gels by fractals analysis.54 The data do not aid this analysis by presenting clearly separated regions with different power-law dependence. In the same articles, pair distribution function and Guinier analysis are also employed, again without discussion about their applicability. Here we strengthen the misuse of fractal analysis when there is no clearly defined fractal region and/or the power law slope obtained strongly depends on the selection of the fitting interval. Another common issue in USAXS analysis is the inability to distinguish between highly asymmetric particles (long rods, high aspect-ratio disks, etc.) and fractals. It is commonly recognized that for these particles the region bound by two “Guinier type regions” features a power-law slope of -1 (randomly oriented rod) or -2 (disk or sheet-like object). But it is much less realized that it is also possible to have particles with these shapes to cause the scaling to have a nearly arbitrary power law component. This possibility is manifested in recent USAXS studies of aerogels.190,191 These materials are constructed by solid materials in various shapes (sheet-like or rod-like) and not fractals. Their USAXS profiles, however, exhibit varying power-law slopes. These results suggest that simple fractal analysis of USAXS data such as in the case of silica aerogels192 may require further discussion to eliminate other possible microstructures. USAXS analysis is often not unique. Without constraints, data fitting can be meaningless. It is therefore important to keep in mind that the more one knows, the more one can learn from USAXS, or SAS in general. We are glad that most USAXS applications so far show deep appreciation of these principles. We also recognize that improvement could also be made, and awareness of these principles should be steadily promoted especially as USAXS instrumentation has greatly matured and USAXS, as a technique, is ready to make greater contribution to polymer research.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
79
Figure 10. USAXS data of (a) apolar gels and (b) polar gels with fractal analysis.
7. Summary and Outlook Small-angle X-ray scattering is a very useful technique to study the size, shape, and structural inhomogeneities of polymers. USAXS, by taking advantage of a wide q range, acts to bridge pinhole SAXS and light scattering, and provides access to large-scale structures and hierarchical structures. Recent developments in high-flux sources and crystals with low parasitic surface scattering enhance the capability of USAXS to probe samples with low scattering contrast. Many applications of USAXS have been found in areas such as
80
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
polymer gels and solutions, polymer nanocomposites, polymer blends, polymer micelles and microemulsions, and colloidal sciences. We acknowledge that despite the success that USAXS enjoys, it remains largely a static scattering approach due to point-scanning detection in the reciprocal space. Efforts are currently under way to perform on-fly USAXS scans, which will reduce the scan time by an order of magnitude (from ∼10 min to ∼1 min). This will have two major implications—1) for polymers and biomaterials, radiation damage will become less of a concern; 2) probes of slow kinetics will be possible. Undoubtedly this improvement will open a window into future scientific discoveries. There is also a plan at APS to incorporate a short pinhole camera that covers the q range from 0.05–1 Å−1 with the existing Bonse-Hart setup to facilitate automatic measurement of a “complete” small-angle X-ray scattering profile. This combination not only greatly improves the q resolution of USAXS at high qs, but also allows probing from the molecular structure to the self-assembled microstructure, and will be especially useful to characterize structures with multiple length scales. USAXS, as a technique, has reached a stage where technical developments have made it ready to greatly contribute to research into polymers and other soft materials. USAXS has, and will continue to enjoy success in areas such as nanocomposites and colloidal sciences. It is also foreseeable that USAXS will be adopted as an ideal technique to study biomaterials with hierarchical structures and to answer the related open questions.
Acknowledgment Research at the Advanced Photon Source, Argonne National Laboratory is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences under Contract No. DE-AC02-06CH11357.
References 1. Guinier, A.; Fournet, G. Small-Angle Scattering of X-Rays: John Wiley & Sons: New York, 1955; p 268. 2. Allen, A. J.; Jemian, P. R.; Black, D. R.; Burdette, H. E.; Spal, R. D.; Krueger, S.; Long, G. G. “Ultra-small-angle x-ray-scattering to bridge the gap between visible-light scattering and standard small-angle scattering cameras,” Nuclear Instruments & Methods in Physics Research Section a-Accelerators Spectrometers Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1994, 347, 487–490. 3. Allen, A. J. “Characterization of ceramics by x-ray and neutron small-angle scattering,” J Am Ceram Soc, 2005, 88, 1367–1381. 4. Compton, A. H. “The intensity of x-ray reflection, and the distribution of the electrons in atoms,” Physical Review, 1917, 9, 29. 5. Davis, B.; Stempel, W. M. “An experimental study of the reflection of x-rays from calcite,” Physical Review, 1921, 17, 608. 6. Bonse, U.; Hart, M. “Tailless x-ray single-crystal reflection curves obtained by multiple reflection,” Appl Phys Lett, 1965, 7, 238–240. 7. Lambard, J.; Zemb, T. “A triple-axis bonse hart camera used for high-resolution small-angle scattering,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 1991, 24, 555–561. 8. Chu, B.; Li, Y.; Gao, T. “A bonse-hart ultrasmall angle x-ray scattering instrument employing synchrotron and conventional x-ray sources,” Rev Sci Instrum, 1992, 63, 4128–4133. 9. Lambard, J.; Lesieur, P.; Zemb, T. “A triple axis double crystal multiple reflection camera for ultra small-angle x-ray-scattering,” Journal De Physique I, 1992, 2, 1191–1213. 10. Rieker, T. P.; Hubbard, P. F. “The university of new mexico/sandia national laboratories smallangle scattering laboratory,” Review of Scientific Instruments, 1998, 69, 3504–3509.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
81
11. Matsuoka, H.; Nakatani, Y.; Yamakawa, M.; Ise, N., “Ultra-small-angle x-ray-scattering study of the structure of colloidal and polymeric systems,” Journal De Physique Iv, 1993, 3, 451–454. 12. Chu, B.; Yeh, F.; Li, Y.; Harney, P. J.; Rousseau, J.; Darovsky, A.; Siddons, D. P. “Construction of a high-energy bonse–hart ultrasmall-angle x-ray scattering instrument,” Review of Scientific Instruments, 1994, 65, 3233–3237. 13. Smolsky, I. L.; Liu, P.; Niebuhr, M.; Ito, K.; Weiss, T. M.; Tsuruta, H., “Biological small-angle x-ray scattering facility at the stanford synchrotron radiation laboratory,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2007, 40, S453–S458. 14. Long, G. G.; Jemian, P. R.; Weertman, J. R.; Black, D. R.; Burdette, H. E.; Spal, R. “Highresolution small-angle x-ray-scattering camera for anomalous scattering,” J Appl Crystallogr, 1991, 24, 30–37. 15. Ilavsky, J.; Jemian, P. R.; Allen, A. J.; Zhang, F.; Levine, L. E.; Long, G. G. “Ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering at the advanced photon source,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2009, 42, 469–479. 16. Narayanan, T.; Diat, O.; Bosecke, P. “Saxs and usaxs on the high brilliance beamline at the esrf,” Nuclear Instruments & Methods in Physics Research Section a-Accelerators Spectrometers Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2001, 467, 1005–1009. 17. Sztucki, M.; Narayanan, T. “Development of an ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering instrument for probing the microstructure and the dynamics of soft matter,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2007, 40, S459–S462. 18. Shinohara, Y.; Kishimoto, H.; Inoue, K.; Suzuki, Y.; Takeuchi, A.; Uesugi, K.; Yagi, N.; Muraoka, K.; Mizoguchi, T.; Amemiya, Y. “Characterization of two-dimensional ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering apparatus for application to rubber filled with spherical silica under elongation,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2007, 40, S397–S401. 19. Krosigk, G. V.; Cunis, S.; Gehrke, R.; Kranold, R. “Recent developments and asaxs measurements at the ultra small angle x-ray scattering instrument of hasylab,” Nuclear Instruments & Methods in Physics Research Section a-Accelerators Spectrometers Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2001, 467, 1088–1091. 20. Cerbino, R.; Peverini, L.; Potenza, M. A. C.; Robert, A.; Bosecke, P.; Giglio, M. “X-rayscattering information obtained from near-field speckle,” Nature Physics, 2008, 4, 238– 243. 21. Bonse, U.; Hart, M. “Small angle x-ray scattering by spherical particles of polystyrene and polyvinyltoluene,” Z fur Physik, 1966, 189, 151–162. 22. Bhatia, S. R. “Ultra-small-angle scattering studies of complex fluids,” Current Opinion in Colloid & Interface Science, 2005, 9, 404–411. 23. Lai, B.; Khounsary, A.; Savoy, R.; Moog, L.; Gluskin, E. Undulator a characteristics and specifications; ANL/APS/TB-3; Advanced Photon Source, Argonne National Laboratory, 1993. 24. Yang, B. X.; Lumpkin, A. H. In Visualizing electron beam dynamics and instabilities with synchrotron radiation at the aps, 21st Particle Accelerator Conference (PAC), Knoxville, TN, May 16–20, 2005; Knoxville, TN, 2005; pp 2603–2607. 25. Bonse, U.; Hart, M. “Tailless x-ray single-crystal reflection curves obtained by multiple reflection,” Applied Physics Letters, 1965, 7, 238–240. 26. Jemian, P. R.; Long, G. G. “Silicon photodiode detector for small-angle x-ray scattering,” J Appl Cryst, 1990, 23, 430–432. 27. Ilavsky, J.; Allen, A. J.; Long, G. G.; Jemian, P. R. “Effective pinhole-collimated ultrasmallangle x-ray scattering instrument for measuring anisotropic microstructures,” Review of Scientific Instruments, 2002, 73, 1660–1662. 28. Levine, L. E.; Long, G. G. “X-ray imaging with ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering as a contrast mechanism,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2004, 37, 757–765. 29. Levine, L. E.; Long, G. G.; Ilavsky, J.; Gerhardt, R. A.; Ou, R.; Parker, C. A. “Self-assembly of carbon black into nanowires that form a conductive three dimensional micronetwork,” Applied Physics Letters, 2007, 90, 014101.
82
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
30. Long, G. G.; Levine, L. E.; Fields, R. J. “X-ray scattering and imaging from plastically deformed metals,” Materials Science and Engineering a-Structural Materials Properties Microstructure and Processing, 2001, 309, 28–31. 31. Zhang, F.; Long, G. G.; Levine, L. E.; Ilavsky, J.; Jemian, P. R. “Quantitative characterization of the contrast mechanisms of ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering imaging,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2008, 41, 416–427. 32. Zhang, F.; Ilavsky, J.; Long, G.; Quintana, J.; Allen, A.; Jemian, P., “Glassy carbon as an absolute intensity calibration standard for small-angle scattering,” Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A. DOI: 10.1007/s11661-009-9950-x. 33. Lake, J. A. “An iterative method of slit-correcting small-angle x-ray data,” Acta Cryst, 1967, 23, 191–194. 34. Glatter, O.; Kratky, O. Small-Angle X-Ray Scattering; Academic Press: London, 1982; p 515. 35. Lindner, P.; Zemb, T. In Neutron, X-Ray and Light Scattering: Introduction to An Investigative Tool for Colloidal and Polymeric Systems, European Workshop on Neutron, X-ray and Light Scattering as an Investigative Tool for Colloidal and Polymeric Systems, Bombannes, France, 1991, 1990; Lindner, P.; Zemb, T., Eds. North-Holland, Amsterdam: Bombannes, France, 1990; p 375. 36. Ilavsky, J.; Jemian, P. R. “Irena: Tool suite for modeling and analysis of small-angle scattering,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2009, 42, 347–353. 37. Kusy, R. P.; Greenberg, A. R. “Determination of radiation-damage in isotactic poly(methyl methacrylate) by x-ray-diffraction,” Macromolecules, 1978, 11, 1051–1053. 38. Kusy, R. P.; Greenberg, A. R. “X-ray-diffraction technique to assess radiation-damage in semicrystalline polymers .1. Isotactic poly(methyl methacrylate),” Journal of Polymer Science Part a-Polymer Chemistry, 1979, 17, 3969–3978. 39. Rightor, E. G.; Hitchcock, A. P.; Ade, H.; Leapman, R. D.; Urquhart, S. G.; Smith, A. P.; Mitchell, G.; Fischer, D.; Shin, H. J.; Warwick, T. “Spectromicroscopy of poly(ethylene terephthalate): Comparison of spectra and radiation damage rates in x-ray absorption and electron energy loss,” Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 1997, 101, 1950–1960. 40. Kuwamoto, S.; Akiyama, S.; Fujisawa, T. “Radiation damage to a protein solution, detected by synchrotron x-ray small-angle scattering: Dose-related considerations and suppression by cryoprotectants,” Journal of Synchrotron Radiation, 2004, 11, 462–468. 41. McGeehan, J. E.; Carpentier, P.; Royant, A.; Bourgeois, D.; Ravelli, R. B. G. “X-ray radiationinduced damage in DNA monitored by online Raman,” Journal of Synchrotron Radiation, 2007, 14, 99–108. 42. Teng, T. Y.; Moffat, K. “Primary radiation damage of protein crystals by an intense synchrotron x-ray beam,” Journal of Synchrotron Radiation, 2000, 7, 313–317. 43. Shlyapnikov, Y. A.; Kriryushkin, S. G.; Mar’in, A. P. Antioxidative Stabilization of Polymers: CRC Press: Boca Raton, FL 1996. 44. Allen, A. J.; Hackley, V. A.; Jemian, P. R.; Ilavsky, J.; Raitano, J. M.; Chan, S. W. “In situ ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering study of the solution-mediated formation and growth of nanocrystalline ceria,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2008, 41, 918–929. 45. Agrawal, S. K.; Sanabria-DeLong, N.; Jemian, P. R.; Tew, G. N.; Bhatia, S. R. “Microto nanoscale structure of biocompatible pla-peo-pla hydrogels,” Langmuir, 2007, 23, 5039– 5044. 46. Ando, H.; Konishi, T. “Structure analysis of regenerated cellulose hydrogels by small-angle and ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering,” Physical Review E, 2000, 62, 727–733. 47. Kang, J. M.; Beers, K. J. “Synthesis and characterization of pcl-b-peo-b-pcl-based nanostructured and porous hydrogels,” Biomacromolecules, 2006, 7, 453–458. 48. Tirumala, V. R.; Ilavsky, J.; Ilavsky, M. “Effect of chemical structure on the volume-phase transition in neutral and weakly charged poly(n-alkyl(meth)acrylamide) hydrogels studied by ultrasmall-angle x-ray scattering,” Journal of Chemical Physics, 2006, 124, 234911.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
83
49. Ando, H.; Konishi, T.; Ise, N.; Saga, H.; Saito, H. “Structural analysis of cellulose hydrogel by small-angle and ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering”, In Statistical Physics, Tokuyama, M.; Stanley, H. E., Eds. 2000; Vol. 519, pp 205–207. 50. de Moor, P.; Beelen, T. P. M.; van Santen, R. A.; Tsuji, K.; Davis, M. E. “Saxs and usaxs investigation on nanometer-scaled precursors in organic-mediated zeolite crystallization from gelating systems,” Chemistry of Materials, 1999, 11, 36–43. 51. Grigoriew, H.; Gronkowski, J. “Usaxs studies of monosaccharide gels. Ii. The common features of structural changes,” Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 2006, 352, 5492–5497. 52. Grigoriew, H.; Luboradzki, R.; Cunis, S. “In situ studies of monosaccharide gelation using the small-angle x-ray scattering time-resolved method,” Langmuir, 2004, 20, 7374–7377. 53. Grigoriew, H.; Luboradzki, R.; Gronkowski, J. “Usaxs studies of monosaccharide gels. I. Dependence of the glucofuranose-based gel structure on the gelator concentration,” Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 2006, 352, 3052–3057. 54. Grigoriew, H.; Temeriusz, A.; Chmielewska, D.; Gronkowski, J.; Mirkowska, M. “Usaxs study of influence of gelator polarity on organogel structure,” Journal of Sol-Gel Science and Technology, 2007, 44, 249–254. 55. Klausener, P.; Woermann, D. “Structure and transport properties of cation exchange gel membranes: Facilitated transport of ethene with silver ions as carriers,” Journal of Membrane Science, 2000, 168, 17–27. 56. Boury, B.; Corriu, R. J. P.; Delord, P.; Le Strat, V. “Structure of silica-based organic-inorganic hybrid xerogel,” Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 2000, 265, 41–50. 57. Schaefer, D. W.; Beaucage, G.; Loy, D. A.; Shea, K. J.; Lin, J. S. “Structure of arylenebridged polysilsesquioxane xerogels and aerogels,” Chemistry of Materials, 2004, 16, 1402– 1410. 58. Skillas, G.; Agashe, N.; Kohls, D. J.; Ilavsky, J.; Jemian, P.; Clapp, L.; Schwartz, R. J.; Beaucage, G. “Relation of the fractal structure of organic pigments to their performance,” Journal of Applied Physics, 2002, 91, 6120–6124. 59. Takenaka, M.; Kobayashi, T.; Saijo, K.; Tanaka, H.; Iwase, N.; Hashimoto, T.; Takahashi, M. “Comparison in fractal dimension between those obtained from structure factor and viscoelasticity of gel networks of 1,3 : 2,4-bis-o-(p-methylbenzylidene)-d-sorbitol in polystyrene melt at gel point,” Journal of Chemical Physics, 2004, 121, 3323–3328. 60. Berthon, S.; Barbieri, O.; Ehrburger-Dolle, F.; Geissler, E.; Achard, P.; Bley, F.; Hecht, A. M.; Livet, F.; Pajonk, G. M.; Pinto, N.; Rigaci, A.; Rochas, C. “Dls and saxs investigations of organic gels and aerogels,” Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 2001, 285, 154–161. 61. Brandt, R.; Petricevic, R.; Probstle, H.; Fricke, J. “Acetic acid catalyzed carbon aerogels,” Journal of Porous Materials, 2003, 10, 171–178. 62. Berthon-Fabry, S.; Langohr, D.; Achard, P.; Charrier, D.; Djurado, D.; Ehrburger-Dolle, F. “Anisotropic high-surface-area carbon aerogels,” Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 2004, 350, 136–144. 63. Brandt, R.; Fricke, J. “Acetic-acid-catalyzed and subcritically dried carbon aerogels with a nanometer-sized structure and a wide density range,” Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 2004, 350, 131–135. 64. Marliere, C.; Woignier, T.; Dieudonne, P.; Primera, J.; Lamy, M.; Phalippou, J. “Two fractal structures in aerogel,” Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 2001, 285, 175–180. 65. Woignier, T.; Lamy, M.; Marliere, C.; Dieudonne, P.; Primera, J.; Beurroies, I.; Phalippou, J. “Large scale porous structure in gels and relationship with their plastic behavior,” Journal of Sol-Gel Science and Technology, 2003, 26, 143–147. 66. Pahl, R.; Bonse, U.; Pekala, R. W.; Kinney, J. H. “Saxs investigations on organic aerogels,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 1991, 24, 771–776. 67. Chu, B.; Hsiao, B. S. “Small-angle x-ray scattering of polymers,” Chemical Reviews, 2001, 101, 1727–1761.
84
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
68. Brown, J. M.; Anderson, D. P.; Justice, R. S.; Lafdi, K.; Belfor, M.; Strong, K. L.; Schaefer, D. W., “Hierarchical morphology of carbon single-walled nanotubes during sonication in an aliphatic diamine,” Polymer, 2005, 46, 10854–10865. 69. Li, Y. J.; Peiffer, D. G.; Chu, B. “Long-range inhomogeneities in sulfonated polystyrene ionomers,” Macromolecules, 1993, 26, 4006–4012. 70. Rzayev, J. “Synthesis of polystyrene—polylactide bottlebrush block copolymers and their melt self-assembly into large domain nanostructures,” Macromolecules, 2009, 42, 2135–2141. 71. Mickiewicz, R. A.; Ntoukas, E.; Avgeropoulos, A.; Thomas, E. L. “Phase behavior of binary blends of high molecular weight diblock copolymers with a low molecular weight triblock,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 5785–5792. 72. Urbas, A.; Sharp, R.; Fink, Y.; Thomas, E. L.; Xenidou, M.; Fetters, L. J. “Tunable block copolymer/homopolymer photonic crystals,” Advanced Materials, 2000, 12, 812–814. 73. Edrington, A. C.; Urbas, A. M.; DeRege, P.; Chen, C. X.; Swager, T. M.; Hadjichristidis, N.; Xenidou, M.; Fetters, L. J.; Joannopoulos, J. D.; Fink, Y.; Thomas, E. L. “Polymer-based photonic crystals,” Advanced Materials, 2001, 13, 421–425. 74. Tirumala, V. R.; Daga, V.; Bosse, A. W.; Romang, A.; Ilavsky, J.; Lin, E. K.; Watkins, J. J. “Wellordered polymer melts with 5 nm lamellar domains from blends of a disordered block copolymer and a selectively associating homopolymer of low or high molar mass,” Macromolecules, 2008, 41, 7978–7985. 75. Kobayashi, T.; Takenaka, M.; Saijo, K.; Hashimoto, T., “Self-assembly and morphology of gel networks in 1,3 : 2,4-bis-o-(p-methylbenzylidene)-d-sorbitol/n-dibutylphthalate,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2003, 262, 456–465. 76. Pignon, F.; Belina, G.; Narayanan, T.; Paubel, X.; Magnin, A.; Gesan-Guiziou, G. “Structure and rheological behavior of casein micelle suspensions during ultrafiltration process,” Journal of Chemical Physics, 2004, 121, 8138–8146. 77. Farrell, H. M.; Malin, E. L.; Brown, E. M.; Qi, P. X. “Casein micelle structure: What can be learned from milk synthesis and structural biology?” Current Opinion in Colloid & Interface Science, 2006, 11, 135–147. 78. Holt, C. “Structure and stability of bovine casein micelles,” Advances in Protein Chemistry, 1992, 43, 63–151. 79. Marchin, S.; Putaux, J. L.; Pignon, F.; Leonil, J. “Effects of the environmental factors on the casein micelle structure studied by cryo transmission electron microscopy and small-angle x-ray scattering/ultrasmall-angle x-ray scattering,” Journal of Chemical Physics, 2007, 126, 045101. 80. Di Cola, E.; Lefebvre, C.; Deffieux, A.; Narayanan, T.; Borsali, R. “Micellar transformations of poly(styrene-b-isoprene) block copolymers in selective solvents,” Soft Matter, 2009, 5, 1081–1090. 81. Testard, F.; Zemb, T. “Solute effect on connectivity of water-in-oil microemulsions,” Langmuir, 2000, 16, 332–339. 82. Barnes, I. S.; Hyde, S. T.; Ninham, B. W.; Derian, P. J.; Drifford, M.; Zemb, T. N. “Small-angle x-ray-scattering from ternary microemulsions determines microstructure,” Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1988, 92, 2286–2293. 83. Giannelis, E. P. “Polymer layered silicate nanocomposites,” Advanced Materials, 1996, 8, 29–35. 84. Vaia, R. A.; Giannelis, E. P. “Polymer nanocomposites: Status and opportunities,” Mrs Bulletin, 2001, 26, 394–401. 85. Gangopadhyay, R.; De, A. “Conducting polymer nanocomposites: A brief overview,” Chemistry of Materials, 2000, 12, 608–622. 86. Beecroft, L. L.; Ober, C. K. “Nanocomposite materials for optical applications,” Chemistry of Materials, 1997, 9, 1302–1317. 87. Porter, D.; Metcalfe, E.; Thomas, M. J. K. “Nanocomposite fire retardants—a review,” Fire and Materials, 2000, 24, 45–52. 88. Beaucage, G. “Approximations leading to a unified exponential power-law approach to smallangle scattering,” J Appl Crystallogr, 1995, 28, 717–728.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
85
89. Schaefer, D. W. “Polymers, fractals, and ceramic materials,” Science, 1989, 243, 1023–1027. 90. Beaucage, G. “Small-angle scattering from polymeric mass fractals of arbitrary mass-fractal dimension,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 1996, 29, 134–146. 91. Narayanan, R. A.; Thiyagarajan, P.; Zhu, A. J.; Ash, J.; Shofner, M. L.; Schadler, L. S.; Kumar, S. K.; Sternstein, S. S. “Nanostructural features in silica-polyvinyl acetate nanocomposites characterized by small-angle scattering,” Polymer, 2007, 48, 5734–5741. 92. Sternstein, S. S.; Zhu, A. J. “Reinforcement mechanism of nanofilled polymer melts as elucidated by nonlinear viscoelastic behavior,” Macromolecules, 2002, 35, 7262–7273. 93. Ehrburger-Dolle, F.; Hindermann-Bischoff, M.; Livet, F.; Bley, F.; Rochas, C.; Geissler, E. “Anisotropic ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering in carbon black filled polymers,” Langmuir, 2001, 17, 329–334. 94. Witten, T. A.; Rubinstein, M.; Colby, R. H. “Reinforcement of rubber by fractal aggregates,” Journal De Physique Ii, 1993, 3, 367–383. 95. Levine, L. E.; Long, G. G.; Ilavsky, J.; Gerhardt, R. A.; Ou, R.; Parker, C. A., “Self-assembly of carbon black into nanowires that form a conductive three dimensional micronetwork,” Applied Physics Letters, 2007, 90, 014101. 96. Thill, A.; Spalla, O. “Influence of templating latex on spray dried nanocomposite powders studied by small angle scattering,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2005, 291, 477–488. 97. Sen, D.; Spalla, O.; Thill, A. In Nanocomposite Powders by Evaporation Driven Self Assembly during Spray Drying: Some New Insights on the Structure Modifications, Symposium on Doped Nanopowders held at the 2006 Fall E-MRS Meeting, Warsaw, POLAND, Sep 04–08, 2006; Lojkowski, W.; Blizzard, J. R.; Narkiewicz, U.; Fidelus, J. D., Eds. Warsaw, Poland, 2006; pp 73–80. 98. Gomoll, A. H.; Bellare, A.; Fitz, W.; Thornhill, T. S.; Scott, R. D.; Jemian, P. R.; Long, G. G. In A Nano-Composite Poly(Methyl-Methacrylate) Bone Cement, Symposium on Nanophase and Nanocomposite Materials III held at the 1999 MRS Fall Meeting, Boston, Ma, Nov 29-Dec 02, 1999; Komarneni, S.; Parker, J. C.; Hahn, H., Eds. Boston, Ma, 1999; pp 399–404. 99. Bellare, A.; Gomoll, A. H.; Fitz, W.; Scott, R. D.; Thornhill, T. S. In Improving the Fatigue Properties of Poly(Methyl Methacrylate) Orthopaedic Cement containing Radiopacifier Nanoparticles, 4th International Conference on Processing and Manufacturing of Advanced Materials, Madrid, Spain, Jul 07–11, 2003; Chandra, T.; Torralba, J. M.; Sakai, T., Eds. Madrid, Spain, 2003; pp 3133–3138. 100. Gomoll, A. H.; Fitz, W.; Scott, R. D.; Thornhill, T. S.; Bellare, A. “Nanoparticulate fillers improve the mechanical strength of bone cement,” Acta Orthopaedica, 2008, 79, 421–427. 101. Chemin, N.; Rozes, L.; Chaneac, C.; Cassaignon, S.; Bourhis, E. L.; Jolivet, J.-P.; Spalla, O.; Barthel, E.; Sanchez, C. “Structure and mechanical properties of mesostructured functional hybrid coatings based on anisotropic nanoparticles dispersed in poly(hydroxylethyl methacrylate),” Chemistry of Materials, 2008, 20, 4602–4611. 102. Ikeda, Y.; Yasuda, Y.; Yamamoto, S.; Morita, Y. “Study on two-dimensional small-angle xray scattering of in situ silica filled nanocomposite elastomer during deformation,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2007, 40, S549–S552. 103. Zhang, F.; Heiney, P. A.; Srinivasan, A.; Naciri, J.; Ratna, B., “Structure of nematic liquid crystalline elastomers under uniaxial deformation,” Physical Review E, 2006, 73, 021701. 104. Hagita, K.; Arai, T.; Kishimoto, H.; Umesaki, N.; Shinohara, Y.; Amemiya, Y. “Two-dimensional pattern reverse monte carlo method for modelling the structures of nano-particles in uniaxial elongated rubbers,” Journal of Physics-Condensed Matter, 2007, 19, 230017. 105. Hagita, K.; Arai, T.; Kishimoto, H.; Umesaki, N.; Suno, H.; Shinohara, Y.; Amemiya, Y. “Structural changes of silica particles in elongated rubber by two-dimensional small-angle xray scattering and extended reverse monte carlo analysis,” Rheologica Acta, 2008, 47, 537–541. 106. Akcora, P.; Liu, H.; Kumar, S. K.; Moll, J.; Li, Y.; Benicewicz, B. C.; Schadler, L. S.; Acehan, D.; Panagiotopoulos, A. Z.; Pryamitsyn, V.; Ganesan, V.; Ilavsky, J.; Thiyagarajan, P.; Colby, R. H.; Douglas, J. F. “Anisotropic self-assembly of spherical polymer-grafted nanoparticles,” Nat Mater, 2009, 8, 354–359.
86
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
107. Schaefer, D. W.; Chen, C. Y. “Structure optimization in colloidal reinforcing fillers: Precipitated silica,” Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 2002, 75, 773–793. 108. Schaefer, D. W.; Suryawanshi, C.; Pakdel, P.; Ilavsky, J.; Jemian, P. R., “Challenges and opportunities in complex materials: Silica-reinforced elastomers,” Physica A, 2002, 314, 686–695. 109. Schaefer, D. W.; Vu, B. T. N.; Mark, J. E. “The effect of interphase coupling on the structure and mechanical properties of silica-siloxane composites,” Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 2002, 75, 795–810. 110. Rajan, G. S.; Sur, G. S.; Mark, J. E.; Schaefer, D. W.; Beaucage, G. “Preparation and characterization of some unusually transparent poly(dimethylsiloxane) nanocomposites,” J Polym Sci Pol Phys, 2003, 41, 1897–1901. 111. Suryawanshi, C. N.; Pakdel, P.; Schaefer, D. W. “Effect of drying on the structure and dispersion of precipitated silica,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2003, 36, 573–577. 112. Vu, B. T. N.; Mark, J. E.; Schaefer, D. W. “Interfacial modification for controlling silicapolysiloxane interactions and bonding in some elastomeric composites,” Compos Interface, 2003, 10, 451–473. 113. Petrovic, Z. S.; Cho, Y. J.; Javni, I.; Magonov, S.; Yerina, N.; Schaefer, D. W.; Ilavsky, J.; Waddon, A. “Effect of silica nanoparticles on morphology of segmented polyurethanes,” Polymer, 2004, 45, 4285–4295. 114. Schaefer, D. W.; Justice, R. S.; Koemer, H.; Vaia, R. A.; Zhao, J.; Yang, M.; Vale, J. In Large-Scale Morphology of Dispersed Layered Silicates, MRS 2004. 115. Justice, R. S.; Schaefer, D. W.; Vaia, R. A.; Tomlin, D. W.; Bunning, T. J. “Interface morphology and phase separation in polymer-dispersed liquid crystal composites,” Polymer, 2005, 46, 4465–4473. 116. Vale, J. M.; Justice, R. S.; Schaefer, D. W.; Mark, J. E., “Calcium alginate barrier films modified by montmorillonite clay,” J Macromol Sci Phys, 2005, B44, 821–831. 117. Zhao, C. G.; Hu, G. J.; Justice, R.; Schaefer, D. W.; Zhang, S. M.; Yang, M. S.; Han, C. C. “Synthesis and characterization of multi-walled carbon nanotubes reinforced polyamide 6 via in situ polymerization,” Polymer, 2005, 46, 5125–5132. 118. Zhao, J.; Schaefer, D. W.; Shi, D. L.; Lian, J.; Brown, J.; Beaucage, G.; Wang, L. M.; Ewing, R. C. “How does surface modification aid in the dispersion of carbon nanofibers?” Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 2005, 109, 23351–23357. 119. Zhao, L. H.; Clapsaddle, B. J.; Satcher, J. H.; Schaefer, D. W.; Shea, K. J. “Integrated chemical systems: The simultaneous formation of hybrid nanocomposites of iron oxide and organo silsesquioxanes”,Chem Mater, 2005, 17, 1358–1366. 120. Schaefer, D. W.; Justice, R. S. “How nano are nanocomposites?” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 8501–8517. 121. Chen, C. G.; Justice, R. S.; Schaefer, D. W.; Baur, J. W. “Highly dispersed nanosilica-epoxy resins with enhanced mechanical properties,” Polymer, 2008, 49, 3805–3815. 122. Schaefer, D. W.; Zhao, J.; Dowty, H.; Alexander, M.; Orler, E. B. “Nanofibre reinforcement of soft materials,” Soft Matter, 2008, 4, 2071–2079. 123. Schaefer, D.; Brown, J. M.; Anderson, D. P.; Zhao, J.; Chokalingam, K.; Tomlin, D.; Ilavsky, J. “Structure and dispersion of carbon nanotubes,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2003, 36, 553–557. 124. Schaefer, D. W.; Zhao, J.; Brown, J. M.; Anderson, D. P.; Tomlin, D. W. “Morphology of dispersed carbon single-walled nanotubes,” Chemical Physics Letters, 2003, 375, 369–375. 125. Schaefer, D. W.; Rieker, T.; Agamalian, M.; Lin, J. S.; Fischer, D.; Sukumaran, S.; Chen, C. Y.; Beaucage, G.; Herd, C.; Ivie, J. “Multilevel structure of reinforcing silica and carbon,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2000, 33, 587–591. 126. Green, D. L.; Lin, J. S.; Lam, Y. F.; Hu, M. Z. C.; Schaefer, D. W.; Harris, M. T. “Size, volume fraction, and nucleation of stober silica nanoparticles,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2003, 266, 346–358. 127. Matsuoka, H.; Kakigami, K.; Ise, N.; Kobayashi, Y.; Machitani, Y.; Kikuchi, T.; Kato, T. “Ultra-small-angle x-ray-scattering study—preliminary experiments in colloidal suspensions,”
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
128.
129. 130.
131. 132.
133.
134. 135.
136. 137.
138.
139.
140.
141. 142. 143. 144. 145. 146. 147.
87
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 1991, 88, 6618–6619. Morvan, M.; Espinat, D.; Lambard, J.; Zemb, T., “Ultrasmall-angle and small-angle x-rayscattering of smectite clay suspensions,” Colloids and Surfaces a-Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects, 1994, 82, 193–203. Arora, A. K.; Tata, B. V. R., “Interactions, structural ordering and phase transitions in colloidal dispersions,” Advances in Colloid and Interface Science, 1998, 78, 49–97. Shalkevich, A.; Stradner, A.; Bhat, S. K.; Muller, F.; Schurtenberger, P. “Cluster, glass, and gel formation and viscoelastic phase separation in aqueous clay suspensions,” Langmuir, 2007, 23, 3570–3580. Smith, W. E.; Zukoski, C. F. “Hard structured particles: Suspension synthesis, characterization, and compressibility,” Langmuir, 2004, 20, 11191. Matsuoka, H.; Kakigami, K.; Ise, N. “Ultra-small-angle x-ray-scattering study of the structure of colloidal dispersions,” Proceedings of the Japan Academy Series B-Physical and Biological Sciences, 1991, 67, 170–175. Peyre, V.; Spalla, O.; Belloni, L.; Nabavi, M. “Stability of a nanometric zirconia colloidal dispersion under compression: Effect of surface complexation by acetylacetone,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 1997, 187, 184–200. Yoshida, H.; Yamanaka, J.; Koga, T.; Ise, N.; Hashimoto, T. “Novel crystallization process in dilute ionic colloids,” Langmuir, 1998, 14, 569–574. Yoshida, H.; Yamanaka, J.; Koga, T.; Koga, T.; Ise, N.; Hashimoto, T. “Transitions between ordered and disordered phases and their coexistence in dilute ionic colloidal dispersions,” Langmuir, 1999, 15, 2684–2702. Harada, T.; Matsuoka, H. “Ultra-small-angle x-ray and neutron scattering study of colloidal dispersions,” Current Opinion in Colloid & Interface Science, 2004, 8, 501–506. Lutterbach, N.; Versmold, H.; Reus, V.; Belloni, L.; Zemb, T., “Charge-stabilized liquidlike ordered binary colloidal suspensions. 1. Ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering characterization,” Langmuir, 1998, 15, 337. Anderson, B. J.; Gopalakrishnan, V.; Ramakrishnan, S.; Zukoski, C. F. “Scattering for mixtures of hard spheres: Comparison of total scattering intensities with model,” Phys Rev E, 2006, 73, 031407. Zhang, F.; Long, G. G.; Jemian, P. R.; Ilavsky, J.; Milam, V. T.; Lewis, J. A. “Quantitative measurement of nanoparticle halo formation around colloidal microspheres in binary mixtures,” Langmuir, 2008, 24, 6504–6508. Sztucki, M.; Narayanana, T.; Beaucage, G. “In situ study of aggregation of soot particles in an acetylene flame by small-angle x-ray scattering,” Journal of Applied Physics, 2007, 101, 114304 Shah, S. A.; Chen, Y. L.; Ramakrishnan, S.; Schweizer, K. S.; Zukoski, C. F. “Microstructure of dense colloid-polymer suspensions and gels,” J Phys-Condens Mat, 2003, 15, 4751–4778. Ramakrishnan, S.; Chen, Y. L.; Schweizer, K. S.; Zukoski, C. F. “Elasticity and clustering in concentrated depletion gels,” Phys Rev E, 2004, 70, 040401. Ramakrishnan, S. A. S. S.; Chen, Y. L.; Schweizer, K. S.; Zukoski, C. F. “Scattering studies of the structure of colloid-polymer suspensions and gels,” Langmuir, 2003, 19, 5128–5136. Ramakrishnan, S.; Zukoski, C. F., “Microstructure and rheology of thermoreversible nanoparticle gels,” Langmuir, 2006, 22, 7833–7842. Ramakrishnan, S.; Gopalakrishnan, V.; Zukoski, C. F., “Clustering and mechanics in dense depletion and thermal gels,” Langmuir, 2005, 21, 9917–9925. Shah, S. A.; Chen, Y. L.; Schweizer, K. S.; Zukoski, C. F. “Viscoelasticity and rheology of depletion flocculated gels and fluids,” J Chem Phys, 2003, 119, 8747–8760. Matsuoka, H.; Harada, T.; Yamaoka, H. “An exact evaluation of salt concentration-dependence of interparticle distance in colloidal crystals by ultra-small-angle x-ray-scattering,” Langmuir, 1994, 10, 4423–4425.
88
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
148. Matsuoka, H.; Harada, T.; Kago, K.; Yamaoka, H., “Exact evaluation of the salt concentration dependence of interparticle distance in colloidal crystals by ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering .2. The universality of the maximum in the interparticle distance salt concentration relationship,” Langmuir, 1996, 12, 5588–5594. 149. Konishi, T.; Ise, N. “Orientation and lattice structure of microcrystals of colloidal silica particles in dispersions observed by ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering,” Langmuir, 1997, 13, 5007–5010. 150. Harada, T.; Matsuoka, H.; Ikeda, T.; Yamaoka, H., “An exact evaluation of salt concentration dependence of interparticle distance in colloidal crystals by ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering. 3. Confirmation of solid-liquid transition by three-dimensional paracrystal analysis,” Langmuir, 1999, 15, 573–577. 151. Harada, T.; Matsuoka, H.; Ikeda, T.; Yamaoka, H. “Exact evaluation of the salt concentration dependence of interparticle distance in colloidal crystals by ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering. 4. Effect of counterion species and the possibility of new factors for colloidal crystal formation,” Langmuir, 2000, 16, 1612–1619. 152. Tata, B. V. R.; Yamahara, E.; Rajamani, P. V.; Ise, N. “Amorphous clustering in highly charged dilute poly(chlorostyrene-styrene sulfonate) colloids,” Physical Review Letters, 1997, 78, 2660–2663. 153. Pontoni, D.; Narayanan, T.; Petit, J. M.; Grubel, G.; Beysens, D. “Microstructure and dynamics near an attractive colloidal glass transition,” Physical Review Letters, 2003, 90, 188301. 154. Sztucki, M.; Narayanan, T.; Belina, G.; Moussaid, A.; Pignon, F.; Hoekstra, H. “Kinetic arrest and glass-glass transition in short-ranged attractive colloids,” Phys Rev E, 2006, 74, 051504. 155. Menon, S. V. G.; Manohar, C.; Rao, K. S. “A new interpretation of the sticky hard-sphere model,” J Chem Phys, 1991, 95, 9186–9190. 156. Tohver, V.; Smay, J. E.; Braem, A.; Braun, P. V.; Lewis, J. A. “Nanoparticle halos: A new colloid stabilization mechanism,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2001, 98, 8950–8954. 157. Mock, E. B.; Zukoski, C. F. “Determination of static microstructure of dilute and concentrated suspensions of anisotropic particles by ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering,” Langmuir, 2007, 23, 8760–8771. 158. Levitz, P.; Lecolier, E.; Mourchid, A.; Delville, A.; Lyonnard, S. “Liquid-solid transition of laponite suspensions at very low ionic strength: Long-range electrostatic stabilisation of anisotropic colloids,” Europhysics Letters, 2000, 49, 672–677. 159. Kammler, H. K.; Beaucage, G.; Kohls, D. J.; Agashe, N.; Ilavsky, J. “Monitoring simultaneously the growth of nanoparticles and aggregates by in situ ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering,” Journal of Applied Physics, 2005, 97, 054309. 160. Beaucage, G.; Kammler, H. K.; Mueller, R.; Strobel, R.; Agashe, N.; Pratsinis, S. E.; Narayanan, T. “Probing the dynamics of nanoparticle growth in a flame using synchrotron radiation,” Nat Mater, 2004, 3, 370–374. 161. Schaefer, D. W.; Martin, J. E.; Wiltzius, P.; Cannell, D. S., “Fractal geometry of colloidal aggregates,” Physical Review Letters, 1984, 52, 2371–2374. 162. Gopalakrishnan, V.; Shah, S. A.; Zukoski, C. F. “Cage melting and viscosity reduction in dense equilibrium suspensions,” J Rheol, 2005, 49, 383–400. 163. Gopalakrishnan, V.; Zukoski, C. F. “Microstructure of equilibrium fluid clusters in colloidpolymer suspensions,” Physical Review E (Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics), 2007, 75, 021406–9. 164. Fuchs, M.; Schweizer, K. S. “Structure of colloid-polymer suspensions,” J Phys-Condens Mat, 2002, 14, R239–R269. 165. Fuchs, M.; Schweizer, K. S. “Macromolecular theory of solvation and structure in mixtures of colloids and polymers,” Phys Rev E, 2001, 64, 021514. 166. Men, Y.; Rieger, J.; Roth, S. V.; Gehrke, R.; Kong, X. “Non-affine structural evolution of soft colloidal crystalline latex films under stretching as observed via synchrotron x-ray scattering,” Langmuir, 2006, 22, 8285–8288.
Ultra-Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of Polymers
89
167. Tanaka, H.; Koizumi, S.; Hashimoto, T.; Kurosaki, K.; Kobayashi, S., “Self-assembly of synthetic cellulose during in-vitro enzymatic polymerization process as studied by a combined small-angle scattering method,” Macromolecules, 2007, 40, 6304–6315. 168. Ohshima, A.; Konishi, T.; Yamanaka, J.; Ise, N. “Ordered” Structure in ionic dilute solutions: Dendrimers with univalent and bivalent counterions,” Physical Review E, 2001, 64, 051808. 169. Ania, F.; Puente-Orench, I.; Calleja, F. J. B.; Khariwala, D.; Hiltner, A.; Baer, E.; Roth, S. V. “Ultra-small-angle x-ray scattering study of pet/pc nanolayers and comparison to afm results,” Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics, 2008, 209, 1367–1373. 170. Gebel, G.; Moore, R. B. “Small-angle scattering study of short pendant chain perfuorosulfonated ionomer membranes,” Macromolecules, 2000, 33, 4850–4855. 171. Heitfeld, K. A.; Schaefer, D. W. “Structure-property relationships in flavour-barrier membranes with reduced high-temperature diffusivity,” Soft Matter, 2009, 5, 156–163. 172. Vainio, U.; Maximova, N.; Hortling, B.; Laine, J.; Stenius, P.; Simola, L. K.; Gravitis, J.; Serimaa, R. “Morphology of dry lignins and size and shape of dissolved kraft lignin particles by x-ray scattering,” Langmuir, 2004, 20, 9736–9744. 173. Turell, M. B.; Bellare, A. “A study of the nanostructure and tensile properties of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene,” Biomaterials, 2004, 25, 3389–3398. 174. Stribeck, N.; Bayer, R.; von Krosigk, G.; Gehrke, R. “Nanostructure evolution of oriented high-pressure injection-molded poly(ethylene) during heating,” Polymer, 2002, 43, 3779– 3784. 175. Wang, Z.-G.; Hsiao, B. S.; Stribeck, N.; Gehrke, R. “Nanostructure evolution of isotropic high-pressure injection-molded uhmwpe during heating,” Macromolecules, 2002, 35, 2200– 2206. 176. Karl, A.; Cunis, S.; Gehrke, R.; Von Krosigk, G.; Lode, U.; Luzinov, I.; Minko, S.; Pomper, T.; Senkovsky, V.; Voronov, A.; Wilke, W. “Investigation of failure mechanisms in polymer composites by simultaneous measurement of ultra-small-angle scattering and acoustic emission during the deformation. I. Method,” Journal of Macromolecular Science-Physics, 1999, B38, 901–912. 177. Minko, S.; Karl, A.; Senkovsky, V.; Pomper, T.; Cunis, S.; Gehrke, R.; Von Krosigk, G.; Lode, U.; Luzinov, I.; Voronov, A.; Wilke, W. “Investigation of failure mechanisms in polymer composites by simultaneous measurement of ultra-small-angle scattering and acoustic emission during the deformation. Ii. Evaluation of the interface strength,” Journal of Macromolecular Science-Physics, 1999, B38, 913–929. 178. Xiao, Z.; Ilavsky, J.; Long, G. G.; Akpalu, Y. A., “How do orientation fluctuations evolve to crystals?” In Lecture Notes in Physics: Progress in Understanding of Polymer Crystallization, Reiter, G.; Strobl, G. R., Eds. Springer: Berlin Heidelberg, 2007; Vol. 714, pp 117–132. 179. Ise, N.; Konishi, T.; Tata, B. V. R. “How homogeneous are “homogeneous dispersions” Counterion-mediated attraction between like-charged species,” Langmuir, 1999, 15, 4176–4184. 180. Kline, S. R. “Reduction and analysis of sans and usans data using igor pro,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2006, 39, 895–900. 181. Nelson, A. “Co-refinement of multiple-contrast neutron/x-ray reflectivity data using motofit,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2006, 39, 273–276. 182. Forster, F.http://www.chemie.uni-hamburg.de/pc/sfoerster/software.html 183. Kohlbrecher, J.; Bressler, I.http://kur.web.psi.ch/sans1/SANSSoft/sasfit.html 184. Heenan, R.http://www.small-angle.ac.uk/small-angle/Software/FISH.html 185. Svergun, D. I.http://www.embl-hamburg.de/ExternalInfo/Research/Sax/software.html 186. Konarev, P. V.; Petoukhov, M. V.; Volkov, V. V.; Svergun, D. I. “Atsas 2.1, a program package for small-angle scattering data analysis,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2006, 39, 277– 286. 187. Konarev, P. V.; Volkov, V. V.; Sokolova, A. V.; Koch, M. H. J.; Svergun, D. I. “Primus: A windows pc-based system for small-angle scattering data analysis,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2003, 36, 1277–1282.
90
F. Zhang and J. Ilavsky
188. Svergun, D.; Barberato, C.; Koch, M. H. J. “Crysol—a program to evaluate x-ray solution scattering of biological macromolecules from atomic coordinates,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 1995, 28, 768–773. 189. Semenyuk, A. V.; Svergun, D. I. “Gnom—a program package for small-angle scattering dataprocessing,” Journal of Applied Crystallography, 1991, 24, 537–540. 190. Barty, A.; Marchesini, S.; Chapman, H. N.; Cui, C.; Howells, M. R.; Shapiro, D. A.; Minor, A. M.; Spence, J. C. H.;