Plastic Packaging Materials €or Food Barrier Function, Mass Transport, Quality Assurance, and Legislation edited by 0.-G. Piringer and A. L. Baner
@WILEY-VCH
Plastic Packaging Materials for Food Barrier Function, Mass Transport, Quality Assurance, and Legislation edited by 0.-G. Piringer and A. L. Baner
@WILEY-VCH Weinheim . New York . Chichester . Brisbane . Singapore . Toronto
Dr. Otto G. Piringer Fabes Forschungs-GmbH Schragenhofstr. 35 D-80992 Munchen
Dr. Albert L. Baner Nestle Friskies R&D Center 3916 Pettis Rd. SI. Joseph, MO 64503 USA
This book was carefully produced. Nevertheless, editors, authors and publisher do not warrant the information contained therein to be free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate.
Library of Congress Card No. applied for A CIP catalogue record for this book is available form the British Library.
Die Deutsche Bibliothek - CIP-Einheitsaufnahme Ein Titelsatz fur diese Publikation ist bei der Deutschen Bibliothek erhaltlich ISBN 3-527-28868-6
0 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany). 2000
Coverillustration: 0P. Mercea Printed on acid-free and chlorine-free paper All rights reserved (including those of translation into other languages). No part of this book may be reproduced in any form - by photoprinting, microfilm. or any other means - nor transmitted or translated into a machine language without written permission from the publishers. Registcred names, trademarks, etc. used in this book, even when not specifically marked as such are not to be considered unprotected by law. Composition: Kiihn & Weyh, D-79111 Freiburg Printing: Betzdruck, D-63291 Darmstadt Bookbinding: Schaffer. D-67269 Griinstadt Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany.
Preface
One could say that this work was created in the laboratory but was born out of necessity. There has been a huge need for experimental data to support the harmonization of food packaging law in the European Union and to support the effort at streamlining approval of packaging materials coming into food contact in the United States. Vast amounts of literature and data have been published containing the results of thousands of experiments measuring different interactions between polymers and contacting foods. This experimental data gathering has been accelerated in the past twenty years by continuous improvements in analytical equipment and the personal computer’s ever increasing data handling abilities. The mathematical modeling of diffusion in polymers has been largely understood and was described over forty years ago in Crank’s book “The Mathematics of Diffusion”. Nevertheless, the frustration remained in many cases that one was still not able to model interactions in many cases using even the simplest diffusion equation because the necessary material constants were usually lacking. The motivation for this book thus comes mainly from a desire to collect together in one place the current state of knowledge on interactions between polymeric materials and foods in package systems and then assemble this knowledge into a systematic approach that will allow estimation of the extent of these interactions. The end result it is hoped will be a practical guide to approximating and measuring the extent of interactions between polymers and foods. In 1993 one of us (0.P) wrote a book based largely on work carried out at the Fraunhofer-Institut fur Lebensmitteltechnologie und Verpackung (Fraunhofer Institute for food technology and packaging) outlining a multi-disciplinary approach for estimating and measuring interactions between polymers and foods. However, in the intervening years it has been apparent that the book needed to be enlarged and updated to include numerous new developments. This new book not only starts where the previous edition left off but has been completely rewritten. Several authors specializing in the various fields covered in this book have agreed to contribute their expertise as it is no longer possible for one person alone to effectively cover the necessary material in the required depth. The chapters in the first half of the book describe the basic fundamental knowledge about plastics, processing aids and additives as well as the physical-chemical and mathematical background of the mass transport in these systems. The second half of the book applies the information contained in the first half to the estimation, measurement and evaluation of polymer/food interactions. Foods are considered to be the “model substances” here but these findings can be applied to many other products and systems as well.
VI
Preface
With a developing field such as this one, this book can only be a work in progress. The book does not try to be the last word on the subject and largely reflects the point of view and experience of its authors. It is hoped that the reader will find the information contained here practical and useful for understanding and estimating the phenomenon of polymer and food interactions and that researchers will be able to use this material as a starting point for future investigations. The scientific literature which covers such a large interdisciplinary field uses a variety of symbols. In many cases different symbols are used to designate the same thing but the same symbol can be used also for completely different designations. This situation is also reflected in this book due to authors coming from many different countries and professional fields. To avoid confusion as much as possible a comprehensive list of all the symbols and many of the abbreviations used here has been prepared. Reference lists are added at the end of each chapter reflecting the nature of the chapter being mainly a review or of a descriptive character. A comprehensive list of citations follows the large collection of diffusion coefficient values in Appendix I. In the first introductory chapter a list of useful secondary literature is given which contains many additional papers. Nevertheless, the authors are aware that many valuable references were not cited in this work. Finally, we wish to thank the members of the staff at Wiley-VCH for all of their help and guidance. January, 2000
A. L. Baner St. Joseph, MO (USA)
0. G. Piringer Munich (Germany)
List of contributors
Dr. Albert L. Baner Nest16 Friskies R&D Center 3916 Pettis Rd. St. Joseph, MO 64503 USA Dr. Timothy H. Begley Food and Drug Administration for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition 200 C Street SW. Washington, DC. 20204 USA Prof. Dr. Titus A. Beu University “Babes-Boly ai” Faculty of Physics Kogalniceanu 1 3400 Cluj-Napoca Romania
Chapters 1,4,14
Chapter 11
Chapter 8
Dr. Johannes Brandsch Chapters FABES Forschungs GmbH 2, 15 fur Analytik und Bewertung von Stoffubergangen Schragenhofstr. 35 D-80992 Munchen Germany Dr. Roland Franz Fraunhofer-Institut fur Verfahrenstechnik und Verpackung Giggenhauserstr. 35 D-85354 Freising Germany
Chapter 10
VIII
List of contributors
Dr. Peter V. Mercea Chapters FABES Forschungs GmbH 5, 15 fur Analytik und Bewertung von Stoffiibergangen Schragenhofstr. 35 D-80992 Miinchen Germany Dr. Stanislav NeSpurek Academy of Sciences Institute of Macromolecular Chemistry 16206 Prague Czech Republic
Chapter 3
Chapters Dr. Otto G. Piringer FABES Forschungs GmbH 1,2,6,7,9,13,15 fur Analytik und Bewertung von Stoffiibergangen Schragenhofstr. 35 D-80992 Miinchen Germany Prof. Dr. Jan PospiSil Academy of Sciences Institute of Macromolecular Chemistry 16206 Prague Czech Republic
Chapter 3
Dr. Luigi Rossi European Commission Enterprise Directorate-General Industrial affairs I11 Rue de la Loi 200 B-1049 Bruxelles Belgium
Chapter 12
Dr. Monika Riiter Chapter FABES Forschungs GmbH 13 fur Analytik und Bewertung von Stoffiibergangen Schragenhofstr. 35 D-80992 Miinchen Germany Dr. Hans Zweifel Zweifel P&A Consulting Elsasserstrasse 184 CH 4056 Base1 Switzerland
Chapter 3
Contents
1
Preservation of quality through packaging
1.1 1.2 1.3
Quality and shelf life of food 1 Physical and chemical interactions between plastics and food 4 Organization of the book 4 General Plastic/Packaging/Food References 8
2
Characteristics of plastic materials
2.1 2.1.1 2.1.2 2.2 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.3 2.3.1 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.3.4 2.3.5 2.3.6 2.3.7
Classification, manufacture and processing aids 9 Classification and manufacture of plastics 10 Processing aids 14 Structure and states of aggregation in polymers 17 Structure 17 States of aggregation 19 The most important plastics 21 Thermoplastics 21 Thermosets 34 Polyurethanes 35 Natural and synthetic rubber 37 Silicones 38 Plastics based on natural polymers 41 Coatings 42
3
Additives for plastics and their transformation products 47
3.1 3.1.1 3.1.2 3.1.3 3.1.4 3.1.5 3.1.6 3.1.7 3.1.8 3.1.9 3.1.10
Additivs for plastics 47 Introduction 47 Nucleating agents 47 Lubricants 49 Antistatic agents 50 Blowing agents 51 Plasticizers 51 Stabilizers 53 Antifogging agents 64 Dyes and pigments 64 Fillers and reinforcing agents 65
1
9
x 3.2 3.2.1 3.2.2
Contents
3.2.3 3.2.4 3.2.5 3.2.6
Transformation products of plastics stabilizers 65 Introduction 65 Cyclohexadienones and quinone methides from phenolic antioxidants and U V absorbers 66 Products from hydroperoxide decomposing antioxidants 72 Products from hindered amine stabilizers 74 Products from heat stabilizers for PVC 74 Conclusions 75
4
Partition coefficients
4.1 4.1.1 4.1.2 4.1.3 4.2 4.3 4.3.1 4.3.2 4.3.3 4.4
Thermodynamic fundamentals 79 Equilibrium between different phases in ideal solutions 80 Non-ideal solutions 82 Partition coefficients for systems with polymers 85 Additive molecular properties 87 Estimation of partition coefficients 90 The regular solution theory 90 UNIFAC 94 The retention index system 110 Expected orders of magnitudes for partition coefficients 118
5
Models for diffusion in polymers
5.1 5.1.1 5.1.2 5.2 5.2.1 5.2.2 5.3
Diffusion in polymers - The classical approach 126 Diffusion in rubbery polymers 128 Diffusion in glassy polymers 136 Diffusion in polymers - The computational approach Molecular dynamics 142 The transition-state approach 148 Conclusions 151
6
Prediction of diffusion coefficients in gases, liquids, amorphous solids and plastic materials using an uniform model 159
6.1 6.2 6.2.1 6.3 6.3.1 6.3.2 6.3.3 6.3.4 6.4 6.4.1
Introduction 159 Interaction model 161 Model assumptions 162 Prerequisites for diffusion coefficients 164 Critical temperatures of n-alkanes 164 Critical compression factor 165 The entropy of evaporation 166 The reference temperature 167 The diffusion coefficient 168 Diffusion in gases 168
79
125
141
XI
Conrents
6.4.2 6.4.3
Diffusion coefficients in the critical state 172 Diffusion coefficients in amorphous solids 172
7
Transport equations and their solutions
7.1 7.1.1 7.1.2 7.1.3 7.2 7.2.1 7.2.2 7.2.3 7.2.4 7.2.5 7.2.6 7.2.7 7.2.8 7.2.9 7.2.10 7.2.11
The transport equations 183 The terminology of flow 184 The differential equations of diffusion 185 The general transport equations 187 Solutions of the diffusion equation 188 Steady state 189 Nonsteady state 190 Diffusion in a single phase homogeneous system 190 Diffusion in multi-phase systems 198 Diffusion through a liquid boundary layer 209 Surface evaporation 210 Permeation through homogeneous materials 213 Permeation through a functional barrier 213 Permeation through a laminate 217 Concentration dependence of the diffusion coefficient 217 Diffusion and chemical reaction 218
8
Numerical solutions of the diffusion equation
8.1 8.2 8.2.1 8.2.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6
Why numerical solutions? 221 Finite-difference solution by the explicit method 221 von Neumann stability analysis 226 The Crank-Nicholson implicit method 227 Spatially variable diffusion coefficient 230 Boundary conditions 231 One-dimensional diffusion in cylindrical and spherical geometry Multi-dimensional diffusion 235
9
Permeation of gases, water vapor and volatile organic compounds 239
9.1 9.1.1 9.1.2 9.1.3 9.2 9.3 9.3.1 9.3.2 9.3.3 9.3.4
Permeation of gases 240 Permeability, diffusion and solubility coefficients 240 Experimental measurement of gas permeability 250 Estimation of gas permeability 254 Permeation of water vapor 260 Permeation of organic vapors 262 Dependence of permeability coefficient on concentration 262 Measurement of partition and diffusion coefficients 271 The significance of partition coefficients 273 The significance of diffusion coefficients 282
183
221
233
XI1
Contents
10
Migration of plastic constituents
10.1 10.1.1 10.1.2 10.2 10.2.1 10.2.2 10.2.3 10.2.4
Principles of migration testing 287 Parameters determining migration 288 Migration control methodologies 291 Analysis of specific migrants 300 The positive list system within the European Union Legislation 300 General requirements to analytical methods for compliance testing 300 Establishing (juristically) valid performance of methods 302 A practical guide for developing and pre-validation of analytical methods 306 Availability of (pre)validated methods in Europe 313 Practical examples 317 The concept of functionality of validation procedures and precision data for compliance testing 334 Safety assessment of modern food packaging applications 336 Recycling used packaging plastics into new food packaging 337 Recycled plastics covered by functional barriers 338 Recycling of post-consumer PET for direct food contact 344 Safety aspects related to refillable plastic bottles 349
10.2.5 10.2.6 10.2.7 10.3 10.3.1 10.3.2 10.3.3 10.3.4
287
13
Migration from food packaging: Regulatory considerations for estimating exposure 359
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5
Introduction 359 Estimating the exposure to components of food packaging 362 Establishing a threshold policy for regulating food contact materials 364 Evaluating migration from food packaging materials 366 Using migration modeling to estimate exposure to components of food packaging 374 Appendix 11-1 378 Appendix 11-11 380 Appendix 11-111 383
12
European Community legislation on materials and articles intended to come into contact with food 393
12.1 12.2 12.2.1 12.2.2 12.3 12.3.1 12.3.2
Introduction 393 Harmonization of national regulations 394 Directives applicable to all materials and articles 396 Directives applicable to one category of materials and articles 398 Directive on plastics materials 399 Community list of authorised substances 399 Authorization of new substances 401
Contents
12.4 12.5 12.6 12.7 12.8
Directives on the system of checking migration 402 Other complementary Community initiatives 404 Directives concerning individual substances 405 Activities of other institutions connected with the Community Directives 406 Conclusions 406
13
Sensory problems caused by food and packaging interactions 407
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.3.1 13.3.2 13.3.3 13.3.4 13.3.5
Problems with off-odor compounds 407 Identification of off-odor compounds 409 Case studies 411 Off-odor from styrene-butadiene coatings 41 1 Off-odor from printing 412 Unsaturated carbonyl compounds 413 Off-odors caused by halogenated phenols and anisols 416 Methylmercaptopentane as an interaction product between packaging and food 417 Parameters determining odor and taste 419 Derivation of threshold concentrations of sensory-active compounds
13.4 13.5
XI11
423
14
Case study: styrene monomer migration into dairy products in single serve portion packs 427
14.1 14.1.1
Introduction 427 Content of residual styrene monomer in polystyrene containing food contact materials 427 Taste threshold levels for styrene monomer in foods 429 Analytical methods for measuring styrene 431 Case study: styrene taint in coffee creamers and condensed milk packed in portion packs 431 Threshold concentration of styrene in coffee creamers and condensed milk 432 Estimation of styrene migration from PS 432 Mass balance estimation of worst case styrene migration 432 Effect of partitioning on mass balance 433 Time dependent styrene migration 435 Estimation of styrene diffusion coefficient in PS 435 Functional barrier: estimating the time it takes for styrene to travel through a material 438 Estimation of allowable styrene concentration in polymer 438 Estimation of styrene transfer from portion pack into food 439 Estimation of shelf life based on taint development in creamer portion packs 439
14.1.2 14.1.3 14.2 14.2.1 14.3 14.3.1 14.3.2 14.3.3 14.3.4 14.3.5 14.3.6 14.4 14.4.1
XIV
Contents
14.4.2
Selecting appropriate polystyrene packaging materials for specific packaging applications 441
15
Possibilities and limitations of migration modeling 445
15.1 15.1.1 15.1.2 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5
Migration modeling for polyolefins 446 Estimation of diffusion coefficients for regulatory purposes 446 Estimation of migration values 452 Migration modeling for non-polyolefins 455 Optimization of modeling 457 Migration modeling with new polymer-migrant systems 462 Modeling of migration from multilayer structures 466
Appendices Appendix I Table 1: Diffusion data for low molecular weight organic substances in Polyethylenes (PE). Low Density Polyethylene (LDPE) and Linear Low Density Polyethylene (LLDPE) 470 Table 2: Diffusion data for low molecular weight organic substances in Polyethylenes (PE). Medium and High Density Polyethylenes (MDPE & HDPE) 498 Table 3: Diffusion data for low molecular weight organic substances in various types of Polypropylenes (PP) 511 Appendix I1 and surface area (Qk) parameters Table 1: UNIFAC group volume (Rk)
531
Table 2: UNIFAC group interaction parameters for prediction of vapour-liquid equilibria at temperatures between 250 and 425 K 539 Appendix IT1 Table 1: Trivalent phosphorus antioxidants 565 Table 2: Major commercial hindered amine stabilizers 566 Table 3: Major commercial hindered phenolic antioxidants 567
Index
569
List of Abbreviations
Abbreviation
Description
AD1
accetable daily intake (toxicological magnitude)
10.1.2
AFID
alkaliflame ionization detector
10.2.6
APCI
atmospheric pressure chemical ionization
10.2.6
API-MS
atmospheric pressure ionization
15.4
ASTM
American Society for Testing and Measurements
BCR
European Community Bureau of Reference
10.2.5
BGA
Bundesgesundheitsamt
3.1.6
BgVV
Bundesinstitut fur gesundheitlichen Verbraucherschutz und Veterinarmedizin 10.1.2 10.2.6 Chemical Abstracts Service
CAS
Section
- mass
spectrometry
10.2.3
CEN
European Committee for Standardization
10.1.2
DIN
Deutsche Industrie Normen
10.2.3
DST
dual sorption theory
5.1
EC
European Community
10.1.2
EC
electro conducting
3.1.4
ED1
estimate of daily intake
11.2
EEC
European Economic Communily
10.1.2
EN
European Standard
10.1.2
ENV
European Prestandard
10.1.2
EPA
Environmental Protection Agency
10.2.3
EST-MS
electron spray ionization - mass spectrometry
15.4
ESIPT
exited state intramolecular proton transfer
3.2.2
EU
European Union
10.1.2
FA0
UN Food and Agriculture Organization
10.2.3
FB
functional barrier
10.3.2
FDA
Food and Drug Administration (USA)
10.2.3
FID
flame ionization detection
10.2.6
FP
food packaging
10.2.6
fs
femtosecond = lo-'%
5.2.1
FVP
functional validation and precision
10.2.6
GC GC/FID
gaschromatography gaschromatography/flame ionization detector
10.2.2 10.1.2
XVI
List of Abbreviations ~
~
Abbreviation
Description
Section
GClMS
gaschromatography/mass spectrometry
10.2.2
HPLC
high performance liquid chromatography
15.3
HSGCFID
headspace gaschromatographylflame ionization detector
10.2.6
ILSI
International Life Sciences Institute
10.3.3 10.2.3
IS0
International Organization for Standardization
LC
liquid chromatography
10.2.6
LMBG
Lebensmittel- und Bedarfsgegenstandegesetz
10.2.6
LOD
limit of detection
10.2.2
MAFF
Ministry of Agriculture Foods and Fisheries
10.2.6
MC
Monte Carlo method
5.2
MD
molecular dynamics
5.2
MS
mass spectrometry
10.2.4
MSD
mean-square displacement
5.2.1
ns
nanosecond = 10-9s
5.2.2
OM
overall migration
10.2.6
PMlRef
European packaging material reference number
10.2.6
PS
picosecond = 10-”s
5.2.1
QM
maximum quantity (toxicological magnitude)
10.1.2
QMU)
maximum permitted quantity of the residual substance in the material or article expressed as total of moiety or substances indicated
10.2.6
R
recycling-related
10.3.2
R&D
research and development
10.3.2
RIM
reaction injection moulding
2.3.1
SATP
standard ambient temperature and pressure
9.1.1
SCF
Scientific Committee of Food
10.2.5
SFC
supercritical fluid chromatography
10.2.6
SIM
selective ion monitoring
10.2.6
SM
specific migration
10.1.2
SML
specific migration limits (toxicological magnitude)
10.1.2
SRM
single reaction monitoring
10.2.6
STP
standard temperature and pressure
9.1.1
TDI
tolerable daily intake (toxicological magnitude)
10.1.2
TRC
threshold-of-regulation-concentration
10.3.2
TSA
transition-state approach
5.2
TST
transition-state theory
5.2.2
UNIFAC
UNIfied quasi chemical theory of liquid mixtures Functional-group Activity Coefficients
4.3.2
UNIFAC-FV
Unifac free volume
4.3.2
List of Abbreviations
XVII
List of Chemical and Polymer Abbreviations Abbreviation
Descriotion
Section
ABS
acrylonitrile-butadiene-slyrene
2.3.1
aPP
atactic polypropylene
5.2
BADGE
bisphenol-A-diglycidyl ether
2.1.1
BHT
butylated hydroxytoluene
11.4
BOPP
biaxially orientated polypropylene
2.3.1
Box
2-benzoxazolinone
10.2.6
BR
butadiene rubber
2.3.1
BS
butadiene-styrene
10.2.6
CR
chloroprene rubber
2.3.1
DAA
diacetone alcohol
13.33
DAS
9,10-dimethoxyanthracene-2-sulphonicacid
10.2.6
DEG
die thyleneglycol
10.2.6
ECH
epichlorohydrine
10.2.6
EDA
ethylenediamine
10.2.6
EP
epoxide resins
2.3.1
EPDM
ethylene-propylene-dienerubber
2.3.1
EVA
ethylvinylacetate
2.3.1
EVOH
ethylvinylalcohol
2.3.1
GPPS
general purpose polystyrene
14.1
HAS
hindered amine stabilizers
3.1.7
HB 307
mixture of synthetic triglycerides
11.4
HD
hydroperoxide-decomposing antioxidant
3.2.3
HDPE
high density polyethylene
2.3.1
HIPS
high impact polystyrene
2.3.1
HMDA
hexamethylenediamine
10.2.6
IPS
impact polystyrene
2.3.1
IR
isoprene rubber
2.3.1
LDPE
low density polyethylene
2.3.1
LLDPE
linear low density polyethylene
2.3.1
MEG
monoeth yleneglycol
10.2.6
MEK
methylethylketone
13.3.2
MeOH
methanol
10.2.6
MF
melamine-formaldehyde resins
2.3.1
MPPO
modified polyphenylene oxide
Tab.( 12-10)
NBR
acrylonitrile-butadiene rubber
2.3.1
OPA
biaxial streched polyamide
2.3.1
OPP
oriented polypropylene poly(4-methylpentene-l)
2.3.1
P4MP1
2.3.1
Abbreviation
Description
Section
PA
polyamide
2.3.1
PA1
pol yamideimide
5.2.1
PBT
polybutylene terephthalate
2.3.1
PC
polycarbonate
2.3.1
PCL
poIy caprolactone
2.3.1
PDA
propylenediamine
10.2.6
PDMS
pol ydimethylsiloxane
5.2
PE
polyethylene
2.3.1
PEG
polyethyleneglycol
10.3.4
PES
pol yethersulfone
2.3.1
PET
2.3.1
PF
polyethyleneterephthalate phenolic resins
PHB
poly-D(-)-3-hydroxybutyric acid
2.3.1
PHV
polyhydroxyvalerate
2.3.1
PI
polyimide
5.2.1
PI9
polyisobut ylene
2.3.1
PMMA
polymeth ylmethacrylate
2.3.1
PO
pol yolefins
2.3.1
POM
polyoxymethylene
2.3.1
PP
polypropylene
2.3.1
PPS
polypheny lsulfide
2.3.1
PS
polystyrene
2.3.1
PSU
polysulfone
2.3.1
PTFE
polytetrafluore thylene
2.3.1
PUR
polyurethane
2.3.1
PVC
2.3.1
QM
polyvinylchloride pol yvinylidenechloride quinone methide
3.2.2
SAN
styrene-acrylonitrile
2.3.1
SB
styrene-butadiene
2.3.1
SBR
styrene-butadiene rubber
2.3.1
TBA
tribromoanisole
13.3.4
TCA
trichloroanisole
13.3.4
THF
tetrahydrofurane
10.2.6
UF
urea-formaldehyde resins
2.3.1
UP
unsaturated polyester resins
2.3.1
VCM
vinylchloride monomer
Tab. (1 2-1)
VDC
vinylidenechloride
2.3.1
VLDPE
very low density polyethylene
2.3.1
PVDC
2.3.1
2.3.1
List of Symbols
Latin symbols Symbol
Description
Section
activity
4.1.2
solute radius
6.1
ratio of food volume to volume of polymer
11.4
scalar field
7.1.1
correlation constants for molecular weight and temperature effects on diffusion
11.5
chemical components
4.1.1
components of activity represent gombinatorial, residual and free-volume contributions
4.3.2
Langmuir capacity constant, in Eq. (5-8). [cm'(STP)/cm3 polymer atm]
5.1.2
free energy
4.1
surface of revolution area of particles
6.2.1
surface area
7.1.1
integration constant
7.2.3
matrix with tridiagonal structure
8.2.2
constant, determined from experimental data
11.5
diffusion model parameter, in Eq. (5-6). [cm2.mole/J. s]
5.1.1
molar cross-sectional area of the diffusing particle
6.4.1
effect of the polymer on diffusitivity
11.5
athermal term of the polymer on diffusitivity
15.1.1
Helmholtz energy, [J ]
5.2.2
relative atomic mass (weight)
4.2
unit area
6.4. I
hole affinity constant, in Eq. (5-8). [ a h - '
5.1.2
parameter account for the specific contributions of the migrant
15.1.1
propagation matrix
8.2
scattering between the laboratories
10.2.3
diffusion model parameter, in Eq. ( 5 - 6 )
5.1.1
concentration
7.1.3
parameter account for the specific contributions of the diffusion activation energy
15.1.1
xx Symbol
List of Symbols Description
Section ~
concentration of permeant at time t in external phase
9.3.2
total concentration of permeant in polymer at echilibrium
9.3.1
concentration of component i in food
1.1
concentration of penetrant in polymer, in Eq. (5-5), [glg polymer]
5.1.1
concentration of permeant in plastic at time t
9.3.2
concentration at equilibrium of a migrant in foodstuff or food simulant
10.1.1
average concentration of the odor compound in the outer layer of the food, having a thickness dF.,
13.5
concentration of migrant in food at time t
14.3.3
estimated concentration of migrant in the food
14.3.3
initial concentration of migrating component in food simulant
10.1.1
concentration of migrant in the food at echilibrium
14.3.1
molar concentration of “a” in the gas phase
4.1.2
molar concentration of “a” in liquid
4.1.2
concentration of a substance in the packaging material. food and gas
13.4
molar concentration of “a” in a polymer
4. I .2
concentration ratio at equilibrium of a migrant in polymer
10.1.1
initial concentration of migrant in polymer
10.1.1
hole sturation constant, in Eq. (5-8) [cm’(STP)/cm3polymer]
5.1.2
mass of substance per unit surface area of packaging
13.5
maximum allowable amount of an odor substance in a packaging material
13.5
term defined in Eq. (6-2)
6.1
cohesive energy density in a pure liquid (1)
4.3.1
concentration gradient
7.2.9
concentration change
5.1
local concentration of penetrant in polymer, in Eq. ( 5 - 8 ) [cm’/cm’polymer]
5.1.2
critical difference of two group of measurements (y, and y2)
10.2.3
consumption factor
10.3.1
diameter of penetrant molecule (particle) [cm]
5.1.1
thickness of film
7.2.1
effective “diameter” of nonspheric penetrant. [cm]
5.1.1
longest molecular dimension of penetrant, [cm]
5.1.1
average penetration distance of the solvent into the food up to time t
13.4
layer thickness of polymer
10.1.1
mutual or apparent diffusion coefficient, [cm’ ls]
5.1.1
parameter in Eq. (15-2)
15.1.1
diffusion coefficient in amorphous polymer
9.1.3
diffusion coefficient at “zero” penetrant concentration, [cm’ls]
5.1.1
diffusion of the solute in the external phase (food)
11.4
List of Synihols Symbol
XXI
Description
Section
diffusion coefficient in the polymer
6.4.3
unit value of diffusion coefficient
6.1
diffusion coefficient of odor compound in food
13.4
gas self diffusion coefficient
6.1
diffusion coefficient in liquid
6. I
“upper bond” value of the diffusion coefficient which is larger than any possible real DP for the migrant
15.1.1
diffusion coefficients of additive i respectively of simulant j in polymer
10.1.1
diffusion coefficient in solid
6.1
thermodynamic diffusion coefficient, [cm’/s]
5.1.1
constant pre-exponential factor, in Eq. (5-7), [cm2/s]
5.1.1
solvent self-diffusion coefficient. in Ey. (5-7), [cm2/s]
5.1.1
intradiffusion (tracer) coefficient
6.4.1
intrinsic diffusion coefficient, [cm21s]
5.1.1
random deviation in results occuring in every measurement
10.2.3
error function
1.2.3
environment
1.2
sum of all molecular increments
4.2
molar activation energy
6.4.1
intramolecular energy term, [ kJlniole]
5.1.1
activation energy of diffusion, [kJlniole]
5.1.1
activation energy of diffusion
9.1.1
intermolecular energy term, [kJlmole]
5.1.1
value of structural increment “i“
4.2
activation energy of permeation
9.1.1
critical energy, in Eq. (5-1). [kJ/mole]
5.1
energy per mole to overcome attractive forces from neighbors, in Eq. (5-7), [kJlmole]
51.1
theoretical activation energy of diffusion, in Eq. ( 5 4 ) , [kJlmole]
5.1.1
number of degrees of freedom involved in a diffusional jump, in Eq. (5-1)
5.1.1
flow rate
9.1.2
correction term
6.1
food type distribution factors
11.2
food (food simulating liquid)
1.2
force
6.4.1
system’s mass
4.1.3
mass of component ‘‘a”
4.1.3
mass of component “i”
4.3.2
free enthalpy (Gibbs free energy)
4.1
XXII
List ofSymbols ~~
Symbol
~
Description
Section
number of different groups present in mixture
4.3.2
gas molar free enthalpy
4.1.1
total free enthalpy of two separate liquids
4.1.1
total free enthalpy of the mixture (Gibbs free energy)
4.1.1
excess free energy
4.1.2
Planck constant = 6.626.
4.1
J .s
spatial mesh constant
8.2
enthalpy
4.1
Henry's law constant
4.1.1
excess enthalpy of mixing per mole
4.1.2
molar heat of solution of gas in polymer
9.1.1
molar enthalpy of evaporation
6.3.3
molar enthalpy of vaporization (liquid 1)
4.3.1
migrating component
7.2.4
contribution of flux
7.1.1
flux vector
7.1.1
Boltzmann constant =1.38.
J/K
reaction rate constant
7.1.3
spatial wave number
8.2.1
proportionality factor
10.1.1
transmission factor in Eq. (5-1 I )
5.2.2
partition coefficient
4.1.1
constant, determined from experimental data
11.5
parameter in Eq. (15-2)
15.1.1
solubility parameter in Henry's law, in Eq. (5-8), [cm3(STP)/cm' polymer. atm]
5.1.2
partition coefficient of a migrating compound between gas and food
13.4
partition coefficient of a migrating compound between gas and packaging material
13.4
partition coefficient of a migrating compound between the plastic ,P,and the foodstuff or simulating liquid .F
10.1.1 , 13.4
K12and KZ2 free volume parameters of the polymer, in Eq. (5-9). [cm3/g . K]
5.1.2
1
length
9.1.2
I
thickness of material
14.3.5
IL
thickness of Nernst diffusion layer
1.2.5
IP
thickness of packaging material
14.3.1
correction factor for cohesive energy density in a mixture of two substances ( 1+2) liquid (liquid food)
4.3.1
thickness of sheet
8.2
112
L L
4.1.1
~
Symbol
~
~
Description
Section
length
9.1.2
thickness of polymer
11.4
mass quantity
7.1.1.
mass of a particle
6.1
average of all values for the material studied (characteristic level)
10.2.3
amount of gas absorbed
9.1.2
mass transport from environment of package into food
1.2
mass transfer from food into package and environment
I .2
mass of food
13.5
amount of a substance migrating from polymer into food (simulant) at echilibrium
10.1.1
amount of a substance migrating from polymer into food (simulant) at time t
10.1.1
estimate migration amount
15.1.1
mass transport from package into food
1.2
mass of packaging
13.5
amount of a substance migrating into polymer from food or simulant during the contact time t
10.1.1
mass of backbone element, in Eq. (54). [g]
5.1.1
molar mass (mole)
4.1.3
number of spatial gridpoints
8.2
molar mass of component “a”
4.1.2
molecular retention index
4.3.3
concentration of migrant in the i-th food simulating solvent
11.2
relative molecular mass
2.2.1
mass that migrates at infinite time
11.4
relative molecular weigth, [dalton]
5
mass of solute that migrates at time t
11.4
mass of solute that migrates at infinite time
11.4
relative molar mass of monomeric structural unit
4.1.3
relative molecular weight
11.5
molecular weight of solute
4.3.2
molecular weight of unit of polymer
4.3.2
number of different components
1.1
number density of molecules in mixture
6.1
order of reaction
7.1.3
time step index
8.2.1
number of a given type of increment
4.2
quantity of material in liquid
4.1.2 10.2.3
number of measurements N
Avogadro number= 6.022.
[molecules/mole ]
XXIV Symbol
Ri i
List of Symbols Description
Section
Avogadro constant
6.4.1
absolute threshold level for odor
13.4
relative threshold level for odor
13.4
gas pressure
4.1
critical pressure
6.1
partial pressure of gas
9.1.2
standard pressure of 1 bar
4.1
vapor pressure of pure permeant
9.3.3
echilibrium saturated vapor pressure
4.1.1
polymer (plastic)
4.1.1
package
1.1
permeability coefficient
9.1.1
relative permeability coefficient
9.3.1
amount of heat
4.1
relative density of interaction energy
6.2.1
quality
1.1
group surface area parameter
4.3.2
total amount of diffusant
8.4
total permeability of a package
9.1.1
area of mixture
4.3.2
minimal acceptable quality where sufficient or adequate product specific characteristics are still maintained
1.1
function of concentration of component i
1.1
change in quality
1.1
penetrant partition functions, in Eq. (5-11)
5.2.2
maximum acceptable initial concentration of residual migrant in the food
14.3.6
total permeability of a laminate
9.1.2
coordinate in the configurational space
5.2.2
rate of reaction
7.1.3
radius
9.1.2
radial coordinate
8.5
repeatability limit
10.2.3
outer and inner radius
9.1.2
mean-square displacement of penetrant, [A2]
5.2.2
gas constant = 8.314 [Joulehole . K]
4.1.1
a group volume parameter
4.3.2
diffusion related resistance
7.2.9
reproductibility limit
10.2.3
rate constant, in Eq. (5-1 1)
5.2.2
List o,f Symbols Symbol
xxv
Description
Section
volume of mixture
4.3.2
estimated values of standard deviations of repeatability
10.2.3
standard error of the procedure
10.2.4
standard error of estimate
10.2.4
estimated values of standard deviations of reproductibility
10.2.3
entropy
4.1
solubility coefficient
4.1.3
solubility of gas in amorphous polymer
9.1.3
excess entropy of mixing per mole
4.1.2
molar entropy
6.3.4
relative solubility coefficient
9.3.1
solubility constant in liquid
9.3. I
solubility constant in polymer
9.3.1
change in entropy
6.3.3
molar entropy of evaporation
6.3.3
enlropy of activation [Joule/mole. K]
5.1.1
time
1.1
expected shelf life
14.3.3
time required for migrant with a diffusion coefficient of DPt o travel through the material
14.3.5
time interval
1.1
timestep
8.2
time required for half of solvent contained in the packaging material to be transfered to the food
13.5
temperature
4.1
term defined in Eq. (7-37)
7.2.4
boiling point
6.3.3
critical temperature
6.1
glass transition temperature of pure polymer
2.2.1
glass transition temperature of polymer as mixed with a solvent, in Eq. (5-9). [K] 5.1.2
U
glass transition temperature of polymer in mixture with a solvent at a particular solvent mass fraction
5.1.2
Hildebrand temperature
6.3.3
melting temperature of polymer
15.1.1
temperature reference value
6.3.4
boiling point
13.4
threshold concentration
14.3.6
atomic mass unit
6.1
internal energy of system
4.1
molar interaction energy
4.3.1
mvI Symbol
List of Symbols Description
Section
mean value of the square of the particle velocity
6.4.1
solvent volume fraction. [cm'/ cm3 polymer]
5.1.1
volume
4.1
molar volume
4.2
critical molar volume
6.1
volume of gas diffusing through a pore
9.1.2
average free volume, in Eq. ( 5 4 ) . [cm'/g]
5.1.1
volume of food simulant
10.1.1
average hole free volume per gram of mixture, in Eq. (5-7). [cm'lg]
5.1.1
volume of gas phase
4.1.2
molar volume of ideal gas
4.1.2
volume of liquid
4.1.2
molar volume (volume/mole) of liquid phase
4.1.2
molar volume
9.2
volume of polymer (packaging)
10.1.1
molar volume of polymer
4.1.2
volume of gas flowing through a pore
9.1.2
van der Waals volume
4.3.2
molar volume of a compound
6.3.2
specific polymer critical hole free volume required for a jump, in Eq. (5-7), [cm'lg] specific solvent critical hole free volume required for a jump, in Eq. (5-7), [cm'/g] numerical parameter, in Eq. (5-5)
5.1.1
relative density of interaction energy
6.4.3
percent water content
9.2
weight fraction of component "a"
4.1.3
weight fraction of component i
4.3.2
structural increment
4.3.3
normalized probability density
5.2.2
distance from contact surface
7.2.1
5.1.1 5.1.1
mole fraction of permeant in solution degree of cristallinity
9.1.3
migration distance of additive i in polymer during time t
10.1.1
distance which the migration front of the simulant has moved in the polymer during the time t
10.1.1
every individual measurement result
10.2.3
length of a meridian
6.2.1
average value of ni measurements carried out from p laboratories (i= 1.2,.....p)
10.2.3
overall mean value over yi
10.2.3
List of Symbols
XXVII
Svmbol
Descriution
Section
Y
symbol defined in Eq. ( 6 4 )
6.2.1
Y
ratio of mass transfer (k) to diffusion in polymer
11.4
7.
number of carbon atoms in a molecule
4.2
2
coordination number
4.3.2
Z C
critical compression factor
6.3.2
Greek Symbols Symbol
Description
Section
specific parameter of system
6.2.1
expansion coefficient in solid
6.4.1
term defined in Eq. (7-37)
7.2.4
function of time
8.4
constant, determined from experimental data
11.5
parameter in Eq. (15-2)
15.1.1
chain-bending modulus, in Eq. ( 5 4 ) , [N/m2]
5.1.1
function of time
8.4
ratio of diffusion in the food lo diffusion in the polymer
11.4
mole fraction of component “a” in liquid phase
4.1.1
displacement of atoms from equilibrium positions, [A]
5.2
smearing factor, [A12
5.2.2
mean-square deviation, [A]’
5.2.2
solubility parameter
2.3.1
solubility parameter based on nonpolar or pure dispersive, polar and hydrogen bonding interactions
4.3.1
second order centered-difference operators
8.6
distance parameter, in Eq. ( 5 4 ) , [cm]
5.1.1
upper limit for good solubility
4.3.1
numerical factor, in Eq. (5-2)
5.1.1
energy quantum
6.2.1
potential energy constant
9.1.3
energy parameter in the 6-12 Lennard-Jones potential, in Eq. ( M ) [Jlmole] ,
5.1.1
volume fractions of solute and polymer in the mixture
4.3.2
volume fraction
4.1.3
activity coefficient
4.1.2
function of time
8.4
volume fraction activity coefficient
4.1.3
components of activity coefficient represent combinatorial. residual and free-volume contributions
4.3.2
residual activity coefficient of group j
4.3.2
mole amount of component
4.1.1
viscosity of medium
6.1
quantity of material “a” in gas
4.1.2
group area fraction
4.3.2
thermal conductivity coefficient
7.1.1
jump distance in Eq. (5-1), [cm] and mean jump distance, in Eqs. (5-3, S 4 )
5.1.1
jump distance of a particle
6.1
Symbol
Description
Section
term defined in Eq. (8-12)
8.2
length of the "cylindrical" void, in Eq. (5-2), [cm]
5.1.1
chemical potential
4.1
standard chemical potential
4.1
echilihrium chemical potential
4.1.1 4.1.2
excess chemical potential average jump frequency. in Eq. (5-3). [s
'1
velocity
5.1.1
7.1.1
speed of swelling front
7.2.10
vibration frequency of diffusing units. in Eq. (5-1)
5.1.1
number of times a group j occurs in the solute molecule
4.3.2
number of times group j occurs in each repeat unit of the polymer (m is usually equivalent t o the monomeric unit)
4.3.2
numerical factor = 9.1' l o 4 , in Eq. ( 5 4 )
5.1.1
time lag
7.2.7
solute and polymer surface area fractions
4.3.2
density
4.1.3
local equilibrium chain center separation, [cm]
5.1.1
effective van der Waals diameter. in Eq. ( 5 4 ) , [cm]
5.1.1
prohability factor of cooperative motions. in Eq. (5-1)
5.1.1
normal state chain separation, in Fig. 5-1, [cm]
5.1
penetrant distribution function
5.2.2
collision cross section of a particle
6.1
term defined in Eq. (7-64)
7.2.5
true standard deviations of repeatability
10.2.3
repeatability variance
10.2.3
internal variance of a laboratory
10.2.3
variance between the laboratories
10.2.3
true standard deviations of reproductibility
10.2.3
jump time
6.1
relative time for diffusion
11.4
parameter accounts for the deviation of the diffusion activation energy in the con- 15.1.1 sidered polymer from the reference activation energy (E,,) parameter to describe the volume contraction at T,, in Eq. (5-9), [g K'/cm3]
5.1.2
mass fraction of polymer, Eq. (5-7). [g polymedg total]
5.1.1
mass fraction of solvent, in Eq. (5-7). [g solvent/g total]
5.1.1
parameter in Eq. (5-1)
5.1.1
weight fraction activity coefficient (molal)
4.1.3
diffusion collision integral
6.1
xxx
List of Symbols
Symbol
Description
Section
5
ratio of critical molar volume of penetrant jumping unit to critical volume of polymer jumping unit, in Eq. (5-7)
5.1.1
5
amplification factor
8.2.1
Y(j.k)
interaction energies between various groups B Cj.k) present in the mixtures
4.3.2
5
backbone element separation along chain, in Eq. (54), [cm]
5.1.1
V
mathematical operator. Nabla or del
7.1.2
Reactivity in Molecular Crystals Edited by Yuli Ohashi Copyright @ K d a o r h a Ltd .Tokyo. 1999
1 Preservation of quality through packaging Albert L. Baner and Otto Piringer Plastics are defined as processable materials based on polymers. These materials can be transformed into finished products, such as bottles, containers, films, hoses, coatings, lacquers, etc. As a result of today’s multitude of plastic applications there is a corresponding enormous variety of plastic materials. The polymer matrix as well as the incorporated plastic additives can be made to differ in such a variety of ways with respect to their chemical composition and structure that one finds or can develop a tailor made product for every application. Packaging is one major field of application for plastic materials. The development of self-service stores with their large variety of products is unimaginable without plastics. The most important function of a packaging material is the quality preservation of the packed goods. Among these goods, foods hold a place of special importance due to their principal chemical instability. This instability is also characteristic for other products containing active substances, in particular pharmaceuticals. In order to fulfill the task of quality assurance of the packed food with minimal impact both on the product and on the environment, the packaging must be optimized by taking into consideration various criteria. This book provides assistance in package optimization functions. Special emphasis is given for mass transport between plastic materials and foods and the consequences of such interaction for quality assurance and legislation.
1.1 Quality and shelf life of food Foods being offered on the market can, thanks to the currently available manufacturing and preservation methods as well as the various transportation modes, come from all regions of the country, continent and other continents together. This applies to all types of plant and animal products in their raw or processed state and results in a wide variety of products being available to the consumer. A couple of hours, several months or even years can pass from the time of harvest or production until a food is consumed. This is however, usually just a matter of a couple days or several weeks. In general, foods consist of numerous ingredients, most of which have a relatively low chemical stability otherwise they could not be digested. These labile foods are exposed to numerous spoilage possibilities and one of the most important factors leading to longer shelf lives is their packaging. In order to describe what a product shelf-life is or what it means in terms of quality retention and measurement, the word quality must be defined. Whatever from a legal standpoint in different countries is used as definition, the quality (Q) determining properties of a product are in principal based on the product’s components. Thus Q can be described as a function of the chemical composition of the product:
Q = f(c1, CZ,..., ci, ..., c,)
(1-1)
Let ci designate the concentration of a specific component i in the food and n the number of different components. If Qi is defined as a function of the concentration of
2
Baner
component i, then the change in quality AQi over the time interval At becomes a function of the concentration change Aci in this time interval. In this case it is not necessary to know the change in concentration of all n ingredients and their change with time. If for example the change in concentration with time of food ingredient i can be measured then maybe this variation can be correlated with a quality change (Fig. 1-1). Even though at constant concentrations (curve 1) there is no quality change taking place with respect to i, an increase in concentration (curve 2), for example resulting from mass transport of a plastic component into the food, leads to quality loss. There are of course cases where an increase in ingredient concentration during storage can lead to improvement in quality, for example, during the ripening processes of cheeses or alcoholic beverages. A reduction in quality also takes place through the loss of an ingredient (curve 3), for example diffusion of aromatic compounds through the packaging and into the atmosphere.
Figure 1-1: Concentration variation with time of food ingredients.
For various food ingredients or undesirable foreign substances, limits can be assigned (shaded field in Fig. 1-1) outside which a significant quality reduction can occur compared to the initial quality. The importance of individual ingredients for product quality can vary considerably and therefore also the width of the allowable concentration. The importance and allowable concentration range are determined by the component’s chemical structure. Quality preservation through packaging means therefore, to maintain as long as possible a particular concentration ci within a certain value range. The time interval within which the product quality remains completely unchanged can be very short. It is therefore more important in practice to define the shelf-life over a time interval up until the limit where the most important product quality characteristics just still remain. This means amongst other things, that during this time in the food neither undesirable compounds that have health significance nor odor nor taste are allowed to occur. This requirement has two important consequences: first, the necessity of an objective quality evaluation for changes in quality and second, the adaptation of packaging to this requirement resulting from the food shelf-life. The solution of both problems has to meet the legal food requirements.
Pruwrvntion of qttulity throiigh ptickaging
3
The quality requirements as well as requirements derived from them are subject to change over time. Besides objective criteria that result from technical advances there are also subjective, political and media generated emotional criteria that also play important roles. One goal of present technological development is the production of food that still possesses as many quality attributes of the raw materials as possible. This leads to products which may still contain many naturally occurring, chemically unstable materials that are preserved by gentle processing methods. These types of product require a much higher initial quality compared to other foods manufactured or treated under harsher processing conditions. One consequence is that it is possible to have a more rapid quality decrease for the product with high initial value (1) than for the product with lower initial quality (2), both having ideal packaging (Fig. 1-2). Qmin designates the minimal acceptable quality where sufficient or adequate product specific characteristics are still maintained. Unpackaged products show a faster time-related quality decrease (left sides of the hatched triangles) than ideally packaged products (right sides of triangles). The area that can be influenced by packaging lies inside the hatched field for a given product. The straight line representation is a simplification because quality losses do not necessarily have to be linear. The conclusions are thus: in some cases foods having high initial quality but shorter shelf-life can use lower quality packaging than products with lower initial quality and longer shelf-lives. The shelf-life of milk is given here as an example. For the 6 to 7 day stability of high quality fresh pasteurized milk a relatively simple polyethylene coated carton package is satisfactory. However, the much longer stability of a lower quality aseptic milk requires a sophisticated package that includes for example an additional barrier layer. There are of course areas in which a very long shelf-life is preferred over a high initial quality product. Example of this are the establishment and maintenance of emergency reserves and the supplying of remote regions, some of which having high temperatures. The packaging requirements for these cases are particularly high. In general however, the trend today arising from higher product quality consciousness is away from product “mummification” and towards “fresh” appealing goods.
Figure 1-2: Quality loss over time of two foods ( 1 and 2) each having different initial quality. The left straight line shows the unpackaged and the right one an ideally packaged condition.
4
Baner
1.2 Physical and chemical interactions between plastics and food If one has knowledge of specific sensitivities of a food or the properties of another product, one can derive the necessary packaging requirements. The most essential requirement today compared to previous requirements is the simultaneous optimization with respect to several criteria. For example these optimization criteria could include a protective function, material and energy expenditures during manufacture, as well as disposability and other environmental considerations. Such optimization is always a compromise between different solutions which can lead to the appearance of new problems. With reference to several criteria, optimization generally means the reduction of safety margins in reference to a certain criterion. Fulfilling for example the criterion of packaging minimization, the permeability is increased to the allowable maximum, that may mean that exceeding or falling short of a packaging specification value by even a small amount might lead to a significant change in the quality of a packaged product. In future package development, optimization from an ecological viewpoint will play an especially important role and minimization of packaging will help make this possible. One should never forget however, that quality assurance of the packaged food and therefore the guarantee of consumer safety will always have priority and must remain the most important criterion for optimization. The fulfillment of these requirements assumes complete knowledge of possible interactions between packaging and food during their contact time. In this respect the properties of both parts of package, the packaging material and the food, must be coordinated with one another. Here possible interactions between the two parts play an important role in the quality assurance of the food. The term interaction encompasses the sum of all mass transports from the package into the food as well as mass transport in the opposite direction (Fig. 1-3). The mass transfers, often coupled with chemical reactions, lead to quality, Q, changes in the food and packaging material. Mass transport is understood to mean the molecular diffusion in, out and through plastic materials like that shown schematically in Fig. 1-3. This figure represents most applications where there is a layer of plastic material separating an external environmental media from an inner product media. The product can be a sensitive medium with a complex chemical composition, e.g. food, that must be protected from external influences such as oxygen and contaminants. It can also be an aggressive chemical that must not escape into the surrounding environment. Because this plastic material barrier layer usually includes low molecular weight substances incorporated into the polymer matrix, there are many applications in which the transport of these substances into the product and environment must be minimized. The mass transport of package components to the product is known as migration; and the mass transport of product components to the package as scalping. Permeation means the mass transport of components through the package in both directions.
1.3 Organization of the book Chapter 2
The goal of Chapter 2 is to draw the attention of the reader to the various problems and sources of interactions between the package and the packed product which can occur when using plastics. Today a huge variety of plastic materials are on the market. In order to select the most
Preservrition of quality through packaging
5
Figure 1-3: Mass transports in the packaged food. mE and my represent the mass transport from the environment E of the package P and from P into the food F. mFrepresentsthe mass transfer from Finto P and E. appropriate materials for specific applications some knowledge of the chemical composition, structure and corresponding properties of the plastics is necessary. Starting with a short overview of the principal manufacturing procedures, the raw materials and processing aids used, much useful information can be obtained concerning the permeability (functional barrier properties) of the plastic and the relevant toxicological or sensorial properties of potential migrants.
Chapter 3 The characteristic functions and the representative structures of plastic additives used to make marketable and durable materials are included in this chapter. Relative to the polymeric matrix, the additives are in general low molecular compounds and the stabilizers in particular are much more reactive than polymers. Due to the high reactivity of the important additive category of stabilizer substances, many reactions can occur in the polymeric matrix. As a result a variety of degradation products appear, a fraction of which are able to migrate into the product in contact with the plastic while a fraction can remain immobilized in the polymer matrix. Both the chemical nature of the degradation products and their concentrations are of great importance for the quality assurance of the product in contact with plastic. Estimation of migration of the additives themselves or their degradation products is possible only if the mass balance of these products can be predicted or measured and their chemical nature known.
Chapter 4 One of the two fundamental material constants which govern the mass transfer of a compound between two contacting phases is the partition coefficient of the compound. This chapter deals with the thermodynamic fundamentals of partition and some of the methods that can be used to estimate its magnitude. Three different estimation methods are described in detail and illustrated with examples. The oldest and best known treatment is based on the so-called Regular Solution Theory. Methods for estimating partitioning of almost any chemical structure based on structural increments (group contributions) are commonly used in chemical engineering. UNIFAC one of the oldest and most comprehensive methods that can be used for polymers is presented here as a typical example. A drawback of this method is its rather complicated handling requiring programmable calculators or computer programs. A third estimation method presented in Chapter 4 is based on molecular structural increments obtained from gas chromatographic retention measurements. This Retention Index System is extremely easy to use and where structural increment values for the specific partitioning phases are available provides estimation values for partition coefficients which are in reasonable agreement with experimental values.
6
Baner
Chapter 5 In addition to the partition coefficients discussed in the preceding Chapter, the second fundamental material constant which governs the mass transfer of a compound i from a plastic P into a liquid L or gas G is the diffusion coefficient DP.iof i in the matrix of P. A brief review of the most frequently cited and used models for diffusion in polymers is presented in this chapter. Section 5.1 discusses some “classical” approaches for analyzing and quantifying diffusion processes in polymers. It is pointed out that although some of these models can lead to quite remarkable agreements between theory and experiment, none of them is a truly predictive diffusion model. The next section reviews the more recent computational approaches describing the process of diffusion in polymers and the DP,ivalues estimated from them. These approaches have a true “ab initio” predictive character. At the same time these models are not yet capable of estimating diffusion coefficients for the complex polymer-migrant systems usually found in food packaging applications.
Chapter 6 An original estimation procedure for diffusion coefficients in plastic materials is presented in this chapter. Due to the difficulties of making estimations using currently available theoretical models as discussed in Chapter 5 , a practical equation for estimation of diffusion coefficients of migrants in plastics is needed. The development treated in this chapter uses an uniform model which is applicable to all aggregation states. One goal of this chapter is to demonstrate the reasonable agreement between calculated and measured diffusion coefficients in gases, liquids and plastics. The model is based on assumptions about interactions of the molecules in a macroscopic system, starting in its critical state. Using the homologous series of n-alkanes as a reference class of chemical compounds, a theoretical reference equation for diffusion coefficients in all polymers has been obtained. Starting from this reference equation, adaptation of each polymer matrix is possible using an empirical structural parameter which can be obtained from data banks of diffusion coefficients, or by single measurements of diffusion coefficients using a reference solute.
Chapter 7 The starting point for a mathematical treatment of all specific cases of interactions between packaging and product is a general mass transport equation. This partial differential equation has analytical solutions only for special cases. For solutions involving complicated cases, simplifying approximations are used or numerical solutions can be carried out. In order to understand the literature on this subject it is necessary to know how the most important solutions are arrived at so that the different assumptions affecting the derivation of the solutions can be critically evaluated. The selection of different equation solutions included here are: diffusion from films or sheets (hollow bodies) into liquids and solids as well as diffusion in the reverse direction, diffusion controlled evaporation from a surface, influence of bamer layers and diffusion through laminates, influence of swelling and heterogeneity of packaging materials, coupling of diffusion and chemical reactions in filled products as well as permeation through packaging.
Chapter 8 Despite the large number of analytical solutions available for the diffusion equation, their usefulness is restricted to simple geometries and constant diffusion coefficients. However, there are many cases of practical interest where the simplifying assumptions introduced when deriving analytical solutions are unacceptable. Such a case, for example, is the diffusion in polymer systems characterized by concentration-dependent diffusion coefficients.This chapter gives an overview of the most powerful numerical methods used at present for solutions of the diffusion equation. Indeed the application of these methods in practice needs the use of adequate computer programs (software).
Preservation of quality through packaging
7
Chapter 9
Beginning with this chapter the physical and chemical aspects of the packaging/product interactions, as well as their measurement and evaluation are treated with emphasis from the food regulatory point of view. The term permeation, as treated in this chapter is understood to mean the transport of a substance through the packaging. Only the simplest mathematical expressions describing permeation are used here. The study begins with the permeation of gases which is the simplest case both theoretically and experimentally. The bulk of the treatment of permeation deals with the permeation of organic compounds through plastics which is of considerable practical importance. Numerous examples in the form of worked out exercises are presented in order to help readers in applying the given equations to similar problems of interest. Chapter 10
This chapter provides a critical review of modern food packaging migration testing by addressing both the test requirements as well as their availability and the practicality of different migration assessment schemes and analytical methods. In order to enable the reader to select and tailor his own specific migration test approach the first section of Chapter 10 starts with an introduction to the principles of migration testing. After that an efficient schematic for food law compliance testing is presented covering modern indirect, semi-direct and direct migration tests. A major focus in the second section is the analytical aspects of specific migration testing. An overview of existing methods currently used in Europe provides the necessary information to complete this topic. The third section of chapter 10 addresses questions related to the safety assessment of reusing plastic food packaging materials in such applications as recycling of plastics for reuse in food packaging applications and the refillable, returnable multi-trip bottle. Chapter I1
This chapter will describe the methods used for estimating exposure to food packaging related components in the US. The text will describe the information required about food packaging materials which is needed to evaluate exposure levels. The discussion will include the concept of a threshold of regulation which defines an amount of migration from food packaging to food that is considered so small that probability of a health concern is negligible. Finally, data is presented to illustrate the use of migration modeling to calculate an estimated exposure to food packaging related chemical substances. Chapter 12
In order to harmonize the food contact material legislation throughout the European Community a broad program of action started in 1972. Community legislation has established rules for plastic materials, the most complex and important area of packaging. The Commission of the Community is currently preparing a series of texts which should make it possible for legislation on plastics to be fully harmonized at the Community level by the year 2000. This chapter describes the main aspects of current Community legislation on materials and articles intended to come into contact with foodstuffs. Ctraptrr 13
Off-flavors in food packages are not only a legal but also often an economic problem, when market recalls have to be made. This chapter describes the different kinds, origins and development of off-flavors and deals with solutions for off-flavor problems arising from interactions between packaging and food. The text covers the sensory and analytical methods used for offflavor-investigations and describes several case studies.
8
Baner
Chapter 14 In this chapter a practical case study involving the migration of styrene monomer from polystyrene containing plastics into food products is presented. The case study combines elements from the previous chapters in the book starting with the chemical structure of starting substances for polymers, sensory aspects of the styrene monomers and their threshold levels in various foods and analytical and regulatory considerations of styrene migration. The migration of styrene is then estimated for different food systems with varying degrees of accuracy using the estimation methods discussed in this book.
Chapter 1.5 This chapter summarizes the book with special emphasis on the future of migration modeling procedures for polyolefins and non-polyolefins in mono- and multilayer structures combined with modern analytical methods for measuring mass transfer in new polymer-migrant systems. These procedures can be used as a powerful tool for solving complex interaction problems between plastic materials and foods, drugs, chemicals and other environments in protecting consumer health, one of the principal aims of food contact materials and articles regulations. The methods, results and their evaluation presented in this chapter encompasses all material developed in the book’s previous chapters.
General PlastidPackagingE’oodReferences Asby, R., Cooper, I., Harvey, S., Tice, P. 1997. Food Packaging Migration and Legislation. Pira International, Leatherhead. Brody, A. L., Marsh, K. (ed). 1997. The Wiley Encyclopedia of Packaging Technology. 2nd ed. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. N.Y. Brown, W. E. 1992. Plastics in Food Packaging: Properties, Design, and Fabrication. Marcel Dekker, N.Y. Brydson, J. A. 1995. Plastics Materials. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford. Can, C. M. D., Jones, A. A. (eds). 1994. Shelf Life Evaluation of Foods. Blackie Academic & Professional, London. DeMan, J. 1999. Principles of Food Chemistry, 3rd Ed. Aspen Publishers, Frederick, Maryland. Hanlon, J. F., Kelsey, R. J., Forcinio, H. E. 1998. Handbook of Package Engineering. Technomic Publ. Co., Lancaster, PA. Heiss R., 1970, Principles of Food Packaging. An international guide, Keppler Verlag. Heiss, R., Eichner, K. 1995. Haltbarmachen von Lebensmitteln. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Hernandez, R.J. 1997. “Food Packaging Materials, Barrier Properties, and Selection” Chapter 9 in Handbook of food engineering practice. Rostein, E.. Singh, R. P., Valentas K.J. (editors). CRC Press, Boca Raton FL. Hernandez, R. J., Giacin, J. R. 1997. “Factors Affecting Permeation, Sorption, and Migration in Package-Product Systems” chapter 10 in Food Storage Stability. Taub, 1. A,, Singh. R. P. (eds). CRC Press, Boca Raton. Hotchkiss, J. H. (ed.), 1988. Food and Package Interaction. ACS Symposium Series 365, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC. Hotchkiss, J. H., Risch, S. J. (eds.). 1991. Food and Packaging Interactions 11. ACS Symposium Series 473, American Chemical Society, Washington, D.C. Katan, L. L. 1996. Migration from Food Contact Materials Aspen Publishers, Inc., Frederick, Maryland. Piringer O., 1993. Verpackungen fur Lebensmittel. Eignung, Wechselwirkungen, Sicherheit. VCH Verlagsgesellschaft mbH, Weinheim, Germany. Potter, N. N., Hotchkiss, J. H. 1998. Food Science. 5th ed. Aspen Publishers, Inc., Frederick, Maryland. Risch, S. J. 1999. New Developments in the Chemistry of Packaging. ACS Symposium Series, American Chemical Society, Washington, D.C. Robertson, G. L. 1993. Food Packaging: Principles and Practice. Marcel Dekker, N.Y. Vergnaud J. M., 1991. Liquid Transport Processes in Polymeric Materials. Modeling and industrial applications. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Reactivity in Molecular Crystals Edited by Yuli Ohashi Copyright @ K d a o r h a Ltd .Tokyo. 1999
2 Characteristics of plastic materials Johannes Brandsch and Otto Piringer
2.1 Classification, manufacture and processing aids In this book all synthetically produced or processed carbon containing high molecular weight substances are included under the term plastic. A high molecular weight material is considered to be that containing more than 1000 atoms. Plastics are a 20th century discovery, the first plastics being derived from high molecular weight natural raw materials, e.g. regenerated cellulose (cellophane) from cellulose around 1910. Plastics were first seen as replacements for natural raw materials during times of shortage , e.g. synthetic rubber during the first world war. However, since the second world war a new class of useful materials has been developed whose properties can be tailored through control of their syntheses to fit every desired application. With a yearly production of nearly 100 million tons, plastics form a pillar of the economy without which today’s standard of living would not be attainable. The importance of plastics is attested by the abundance of scientific and technical literature on the subject. For several reasons the following discussion on the manufacture, structure and properties of plastics is necessarily a brief introduction to the subject as found in the literature: 1. Measurable residual amounts or conversion products from the many different raw materials and processing aids used in the various plastic synthesis processes can remain in the finished material. Knowledge of these materials is indispensable for the toxicological evaluation of the plastics and their analysis . The same applies for the many chemically different additives which are incorporated into the plastic matrix to allow better processing, increase stability and to give the material specific properties. 2. The rate of migration of low molecular weight residual molecules from plastics into foods and interactions of the plastics with food components or other filled products depends on the molecular structure and the macroscopic (aggregate) nature of the plastic material. In order to perform useful estimations of mass transfers, for example from plastics to food, a basic knowledge of the structure of the plastic and food components and their influences on this phenomenon is necessary. In view of the enormous abundance of data and knowledge about plastics only a few representative examples from a multitude are presented in the following. When searching for solutions to special cases of interaction, one should always try to learn as much as possible about the manufacture, composition and properties of the packaging as well as about their environment. This is necessary in order to evaluate the possible reactions that could occur, to make estimations of migration; and to make comparisons with the actual interaction problem at hand.
10
Brandsch
2.1.1 Classification and manufacture of plastics Plastics can be classified according to whether they are made from converted natural products (regenerated cellulose) or from completely synthetic products. They can then be further classified according to their manufacturing method in terms of their polymerization reactions, either condensation or addition reactions. They are then further divided, according to their physical properties, into thermoplastics, elastomers and thermosets. The combining of carbon atoms in unlimited number through covalent bonding leads to the synthesis of macromolecules with hundreds to millions of carbon atoms. Depending on the way that covalent bonding occurs, heteroatoms besides carbon such as oxygen, nitrogen and sulfur can be included. Thermoplastics are composed of threadlike chain molecules tangled together. This group of plastics takes its name from the properties resulting from such structures. Thermoplastics soften with increasing temperature, which allows them to be formed and then become hard again as they cool. A network of covalent bonds crosslinking the polymer chains leads to the formation of elastomers. Thermosets are composed of networks of primary valence covalently crosslinked molecular structures. The crosslinking step occurs during forming and afterwards the plastics are heat stable (not thermoplastic). Thermoplastics are delivered in the form of granules and powders to production sites that are separate from the plastic synthesis. The raw plastic materials are often referred to as polymers. After addition of the necessary additives, e.g. plasticizers, the final material is referred to as a plastic. The synthesis steps that occur for example in forming the thermoset coatings used in food contact materials and articles, takes place in the final production phases. This difference in processing compared to the processing of thermoplastics is not insignificant with regard to quality considerations of the finished products when one considers the possible interactions from a food regulation viewpoint. The following synthesis paths deal mainly with thermoplastics, but apply as well to the preliminary steps in thermoset production. The thermosets are then crosslinked or hardened at their point of application. The most important crosslinking reactions will be briefly discussed at the end of this section. The simplest chemical compounds used directly in synthesis reactions and which are incorporated into the macromolecular chain as a structure sequence are called monomers. Monomers are either unsaturated, that is they have one or more double bonds; or are bifunctional compounds. The corresponding plastic (polymer) is produced by a technical polymerization reaction of either a free radical chain reaction (unsaturated monomers) or an intermolecular condensation reaction (bifunctional). Raw materials and polymerization processes Fossil based raw materials, mainly oil, gas and occasionally coal, are used almost exclusively for the manufacture of monomers. Plant materials, the so-called renewable resources, have been used earlier and could become more significant once again in the future. Although the plastics in these cases are obtained by direct polymerization of their monomers, the synthesis of the monomers themselves often requires several intermediate steps. The multi-functional multiple intermediate compounds in the plastic synthesis steps cannot be clearly defined as monomers in every case. The poly-con-
Clinmcteristics qfplastic riinterialu
11
densation reaction of terephthalic acid with ethylene glycol for example leads directly to polyethylene terephthalate. However, the reactions of the well defined chlorosilanes require several intermediate steps to form silicon polymers. The chlorosilanes which can be recognized as repeating segments in the silicon chain fulfill the above definition for monomers. In general the corresponding residual monomers can be found in the finished polymer material. However, in the case of silicon no chlorosilanes but residuals from the intermediate steps can be found in the finished material. The chlorosilanes themselves are not directly used in the synthesis of silicon but rather the siloxanes from the intermediate step. To avoid any misunderstanding in the definition of a monomer, the substances that are used directly in the synthesis of plastics are designated here as starting materials. These starting materials can be “real” monomers, e.g. ethylene, or a mixture of intermediates, e.g. siloxanes. Whereas it is assumed that residual starting materials will remain in the finished plastic, the raw materials of the starting materials are assumed to be completely converted, i.e. decomposed, so that they are not detectable.
Addition poIymerization The most important bulk plastics, e.g. the polyolefins, are produced using addition polymerization processes. The molecules of the starting materials contain double bonds which are broken with the help of initiators or catalysts. The resulting free radicals then undergo a chain reaction to form a macromolecule. In practice there are numerous processes with different reaction conditions. The start of chain reactions requires a radical produced as a rule by the disintegration of initiator substances, usually pcroxide. The finished plastic, usually in thc form of granules, can contain small amounts of undestroyed residual initiator and/or other disintegration products, residual monomers and low molecular weight polymerization products (oligomers) as well as residuals of other processing aids. Oxidation reactions resulting from traces of unsaturated compounds, present during the processing of the plastic material, can lead to the formation of sensory active compounds (Chapter 13). Some of the necessary additives for further converting to packaging material may already be added to the plastic granules (see Chapter 3). If it is possible to trace the nature of the plastic and some of the substances contained in it back to the manufacturing process, then this can be useful for solving product problems related to migration (Chapters 10 and 11) or the formation of off-odors (see Chapter 13). The same goes for the knowledge of package material converting processes and the additives used in them. The monomer can be polymerized either directly, that is undiluted (block or substance polymerization), or in the presence of a non-polymerizable solvent (solvent polymerization). In the first case there is a problem with dissipating the localized heat of reaction (traces of decomposition products result from overheating) and in the second case the solvent must be completely removed. Other possibilities are to suspend thc monomers in dispersions, e.g. in water (suspension or pearl polymerization), or eventually using an emulsifier (emulsion polymerization). Emulsifiers and dispersants are considered to be processing aids for the production of polymers. In addition to the use of radical producing initiators, other catalysts can also be used for ionic addition polymerization reactions. Compared to LDPE produced by
12
Brandsch
radical polymerization, the use of metal oxide catalysts produces higher density polyethylenes. A further possibility for the synthesis of such a high density polyethylene (HDPE) is metal complex polymerization with coordination or Ziegler-Natta-catalysts (metal alkyl - metal halide catalysts) under low pressure. This type of polymerization is particularly important because it is stereo selective (see PP). In this conection the metallocene catalyst systems must be mentioned. These systems have high activities and polymerization rates and the level of isotacticity can be controlled. Condensation polymerization Starting materials with two different reactive functional groups can polymerize without any further external assistance with the help of an initiator or catalyst. Another direct polymerization possibility exists between two different starting materials (monomers) having each two identical functional groups. These reactions are usually subdivided into three groups: polycondensation, polyaddition (not to be confused with radical addition polymerization) and ring opening reactions. A typical example of a condensation polymerization reaction is the reaction between a poly functional alcohol (e.g. a glycol) and a dicarboxylicacid (e.g. terephthalic acid). Condensation polymerizations are equilibrium reactions, which means they eventually stop reacting when small molecular weight reaction products like water are no longer removed from the system. These characteristics of the condensation polymerization reaction also have an effect on the chemical properties of such plastics. In the presence of water, particularly at high temperatures, polyethylene terephthalate begins to hydrolyze and low molecular weight oligomers are produced which can be transferred into a food in contact with the plastic. Synthesis of copolymers, block and graft copolymers Polymerization involving a single type of monomer produces a homopolymer (Figure 2-la), while a mixture of different monomers leads to a mixed polymer or copolymer. Copolymerization offers the possibility to tailor-make a number of different structures which differ from one another in terms of solubility, reactivity and many other properties. The different monomers can alternate with one another in the polymer chain (Figure 2-lb) or be randomly distributed (random copolymer Figure 2-lc). Random copolymers are obtained by radical addition polymerization whereby the statistical distribution of the medium length chains of a given monomer is relatively short. This means a given sequence in a random copolymer consists of 1-10 monomer units. For polymerization degrees ranging from 1000-10000 these sequences alternate with one another up to 10CL1000 times. In block copolymers a targeted distribution of the different monomers leads to sequences containing many monomers of a single type (Figure 2-ld). A magnitude of 100 to 1000 monomer molecules per chain means the polymer chain contains only 2 to 4 sequences. Graft copolymers are relatively the same only where the sequences of one monomer are attached to a chain made up of the other monomers (Figure 2-le).
Characteristics of plastic materials
-0-0-0-0
-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-
-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-O-0-0-0-
(a)
(b)
(4
-0-0-0-0
-0-0-0-0
-0-0-0-0
-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-
(4
-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-
(el
-0-0-0
-0-0-0-
13
I
0
-0-0-0-0
I
I
0
I
to-o-o--t Figure 2-1: a) homopolymer, b) and c) copolymer. d) block copolymer, e ) graft copolymer.
Polymer reactions In order to obtain materials with certain properties, polymers can be modified using different types of chemical reaction. The crosslinking reactions used for the manufacture of elastomers and thermosets referred to earlier are the most important types of chemical reaction. Preformed polymer chains are bound together at a later time using a built in reactive functional group that is activated, for example through heating. An example of such a process are the epoxy lacquers. Through an addition reaction between a diphenol (bisphenol A) and epichlorohydrin, an intermediate for the following crosslinking step is formed. In the intermediate step for example bispheno1-Adiglycidyl ether (BADGE) as well as polycondensation high molecular weight products based on BADGE are formed. Following the addition of a hardener, e.g. a polyamine, the crosslinking reaction leading to the formation of the three dimensional thermoset takes place. Other substances are also used as polymerization processing aids, like solvents (e.g. benzyl alcohol) and accelerators (e.g. nonylphenol). These processing aids are not significantly or not to a measurable degree chemically incorporated into the crosslinked polymer. Under the conditions of the epoxy thermoset reaction the epichlorohydrin, for example, is completely decomposed. Under the current, state of the art hardening technology, practically no epichlorohydrin can be detected in the finished product. It is especially difficult to make a definitive comprehensive list of all starting materials (positive list) used to make polymeric package materials by three dimensional crosslinking, which could be transferred into a product. In addition to the numerous oligomers coming from the combined intermediate steps there is a variety of combination possibilities and mixtures of polymer starting materials, together with t h e corresponding processing aids (catalysts, crosslinkers) and additives (stabilizers, plasticizers) which further complicate the inclusion of all these compounds into food regulations and quality analysis systems (see Chapters 10, 11, 12 and 13).
14
Brandsch
2.1.2 Processing aids The processing aids necessary for polymerization can be divided into two groups: substances which directly influence the manufacturing process and substances which provide an adequate medium for the polymerization process to take place (e.g. solvents and emulsifiers). Even though some processing aids could be chemically incorporated into the polymer, they do not appear systematically in the repeating units of the polymer chains and therefore cannot be considered to be monomers or starting materials. In general processing aids are used only in small amounts and after the synthesis is completed they exert practically no influence on the finished polymer. Thus they are very different in nature from additives which are also often used sparingly but which exert a much greater influence in the finished plastic. Processing aids are used to directly influence the synthesis process function as reaction controllers. Depending on their chemical state they can function as reaction accelerators (the actual catalysts and starters or initiator substances), crosslinkers and/or hardeners, reaction inhibitors or catalyst deactivators, molecular weight controllers, chain splitters or lengtheners. From a chemical standpoint (structure and method of function) the radical builders, mainly peroxides and azo compounds, are treated separately from the catalysts which are mainly metals, metal oxides, salts (redox systems) and organo-metal compounds. The carrier substances, promoters and deactivators are placed in the catalyst class of substances. The second category of processing aids contains substances which function as working media to assist initiators and catalysts. These medium forming substances are in general much less reactive or are non-reactive compounds most of which can be found as additives in further converting and polymer use applications. These processing aids are mainly: solvents, dispersants, emulsifiers, precipitants, anti-foaming and degassing agents, pH controllers, stabilizers,germinating agents, blowing agents for foams, and others. Substances that are also used as additives for plastic processing and applications will be treated in Chapter 3. In the following the two most important substance classes in the first category are discussed. Initiators and crosslinkers Organic peroxides are used as initiators or starter substances for many polymerization reactions because they easily decompose to form radicals. There are presently about 50 technically important organic peroxides. These can be formally described as derivatives of hydrogen peroxide (HOOH). Through substitution of one or both of the hydrogen atoms by alkyl, aralkyl, or acyl groups, a series of compound classes is obtained whose reactivity is heavily structure dependent (Table 2-1). The stability of the peroxide in every substance class increases with the number of carbon atoms. Along with radical formation, oxidation is the other important peroxide property. The oxidation potential decreases according to the order: peroxy carbonic acid > hydroperoxide > diacylperoxide > peroxy carbonic acid esters > dialkylperoxide. Some of the alkylhydroperoxides, e.g. cumylhydroperoxide, are used for the polymerization of diolefin (butadiene) with comonomers (e.g. styrene) at low temperatures (5-20 "C).
C/immteristicsof plastic materials
15
Table 2-1: Classes of organic peroxides alkylhydroperoxide dial kylperoxide peroxy carbonic acid diacylperoxide peroxy carbonic acid ester a-oxyperoxide a-aminoueroxide
The alkylhydroperoxides are also interesting because of their formation in natural products. Unsaturated fatty acids and their esters (plant oils) are oxidized in air to peroxides (auto-oxidation). This leads to a stepwise breaking of the double bonds leading to the formation of aldehydes, ketones and fatty acids, all of which make their presence known through their strong odor intensities (e.g. rancid oil). Dialkylperoxides are used as high temperature catalysts for suspension and bulk polymerization as well as hardeners for unsaturated polyester resins and for crosslinking polymers because of their good thermal stability. While the liquid di-tertbutylperoxide is relatively volatile at application temperatures, dicumylperoxide is much less volatile and has the disadvantage of forming decomposition products with intense odors (acetophenone)(Chapter 13). Diacylperoxide is used mainly as an initiator for radical polymerizations as well as for hardening and crosslinking polyester resins as a result of its ability to easily thermally decompose. It can be helpful to consider the reaction products of the peroxides used in terms of their eventual interactions between the plastic and filled product. Peroxycarbonic acid esters play a most important role in vinyl, ethylene and styrene polymerizations. In particular, mixtures of the tert-butylesters of the peroxybenzoic acids and the peroxyaliphatic fatty acids are used. In addition to the above mentioned homolysis, peroxides can also be ionically decomposed leaving behind by-products. Primary and secondary peroxyesters decompose into the corresponding carbonic acids and carbonyl compounds during the hydrolysis reaction of tertiary peroxyesters leading to the formation of carbonic acids and hydroperoxides to give:
R2CH-0-0-C-R’
II
0
-+ R2CzO + R’-C-OH II 0
a-Oxyperoxides are used as crosslinkers and hardeners. Adding transition metal salts, a wider useable temperature range can be achieved for warm hardening of polyester resins. In order to distribute initiators, which are often solids. throughout the reaction medium, non-reactive processing aids such as phthalates are often used. Inhibitors, which act as radical absorbers, are used to slow down peroxide controlled polymerizations. Most of these compounds are chinones, aromatic nitrogen
16
Brandsch
compounds or aromatic amines. Impurities can lead to lengthened inhibition times and subsequently an uncontrolled course of polymerization so that only the highest purity starting materials are used in the polymerization. Along with the peroxides, other compounds are used as radical formers. The azofatty acid nitriles play an important role here. Azo-isobutyric acid nitrile or 2,2'-azo bis(2-methylpropionitrile) decomposes under heat to nitrogen and two radicals which can start a polymerization chain reaction. Finished products are not allowed to show any positive reactions for peroxide on their surfaces.
Catalysts Substances which increase the rate of a chemical reaction without themselves being used up or incorporated into the finished product are called catalysts. In heterogeneous catalysis the reaction takes place on the surface of a solid support. The activity of the catalyst in this case is determined by the structure and size of the surface area as well as the way the catalyst is produced. Catalysts are not limited to immobilization on solids, they can also be introduced as homogeneous catalysts in solution. Between heterogeneous and homogeneous catalysts there is the possibility to evenly distribute small particles (dispersions) of catalyst in a liquid phase. Heterogeneous catalysts are mostly metals or metal oxides. They can be used as they are or together with inert carriers, which themselves are usually metal oxides. Homogeneous catalysts are as a rule cations of certain metals or complexes of metal atoms with an organic molecule (ligands). With regard to the possibility of residual catalyst in the plastic being transferred into the filled product, the following can be said from the above considerations: residual immobilized solid heterogeneous catalysts, provided that they cannot be separated from the polymer, can only play an interactive role on the surface of the material in contact with the filled product. The migration of metals and metal oxides from within the plastic has practically no significance because compared to organic compounds they are not dissolved in the plastic and therefore are not subject to diffusion in the form of molecules and ions. However, cases where traces of catalyst have some residual activity can have negative effects on the properties and stability of the plastic over a period of time. This can happen when reactions occur with substances diffusing through the plastic, e.g. oxygen, that subsequently lead to decomposition of the plastic structure. When dispersion systems are used some residual dispersants can remain in the plastic and then migrate out. In the case of homogeneous catalysts migration can also occur. In particular this applies to the residual organic parts of the organo-metal compounds which remain as breakdown products in the plastic after completion of polymer synthesis and destruction of the catalyst. This also applies to residual solvents that are not fully evaporated. The heterogeneous catalyst systems containing a mixture of the elements Ca, Mg, Al, Si, Ti, Cr, V and Zr are most important for polymer synthesis. Polymerizates intended for use as food contact materials may not contain a total of more than 0.1 % of these catalysts in the form of oxides. Further residual metal oxides from catalysts used for polymer synthesis, e.g. polyterephthalic acid diol ester, are oxides of antimony, gallium, germanium, cobalt, man-
Characteristics of plastic materials
17
ganese, zinc, and titanium. Residual amounts of these oxides in the polymer are also restricted in a range from 20 mg/kg for gallium to 350 mg/kg for antimony.
2.2 Structure and states of aggregation in polymers 2.2.1 Structure The overall nature and properties of a plastic are determined by its chemical structure, macromolecule mass, and the additives compounded into it. The polymer molecular chains form the backbone of the thermoplastics polymer structure. The nature and orientation of the monomer units in the chain determine the primary structure of the polymer. This primary structure of the chain can be differentiated into three groups: 1. Pure carbon chains. The chains can be unsubstituted (e.g. PE) or contain single or multiple substitutions (polyvinyl compounds). 2. Chains that in addition to carbon contain heteroatoms like 0, N, P or S. Here the nature of the segment with carbon atoms, R, can vary as well as the nature of the bound hetero groups, X, in the segment: -R-X-R-X-R-X-R-X3. Chains that are exclusively composed of heteroatoms. The most important representativs of this group are the silicons. The nature of the elements found in the polymer chain and the covalent bonds that exist between them allow one to predict the properties of the corresponding thermoplastic. The primary valence bonds determine the secondary valence bonds such as the van der Waals forces, polar bonds and hydrogen bonds occurring between the polymer chains. The intermolecular forces existing in thermoplastics composed of carbon and hydrogen are due to weak van der Waals attractions. These forces rapidly decrease with increasing temperature. The thermoplastics containing heteroatoms have comparatively much stronger polar attractions. Atoms such as C1, F and the atomic groups OH, CN and COOR create dipoles which increase the attractive forces between the chain molecules and cause the thermoplastic to be much stronger. One type of dipole attraction that is particularly strong is the hydrogen bond such as occurs between OH and NH groups and 0 atoms on other chains. The hydrogen bond are responsible for the strength and stiffness of polymers like polyamides for example, as well as their normally undesirable affinity for absorbing water. Unsubstituted polymer chains cannot form different stereo isomers, while substituted polymers can have a large number of different possible isomeric forms. As a result it is possible to have various configurations for substituted polymers. For example polystyrene produced by radical polymerization is atactic which means the phenyl groups bound to every second C-atom are randomly distributed on both sides of the polymer chain. Polymers produced using Ziegler catalysts, made from monomers like styrene, propene and others are isotactic (Figure 2-2):
18
Brandsch
R isotactic
syndio. tactlC
R
R
R
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
R
R
R
c -c - c -c -c - c - c - c - c - c R
R atactic
R
I
c -c-c -c -c -c -c -c -c -c
R
R
R
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
c -c-c -c -c -C R
-c -c - c -c
R
Figure 2-2: Polymer chain configurations of atactic, isotactic and syndiotactic polymers.
The regularity of the polymer chain structural group locations is an ideal representation. In practice the chains can have more or less branching depending on the manufacturing process. As an example the branching occurring in PE can be schematically represented in Figure 2-3.
PE-LD
PE-HD
PE-LLD
high pressure polymerization
I
I
I I I l l I II
low pressure polymerization
low or intermidiate pressure polymerization
Figure 2-3: Chain branching of polyethylene.
Side groups in atactic structures and chain branching hinder crystallization of the thermoplastic polymers in contrast to unbranched and isotactic configurations which lead to increased crystallinity. With increasing crystallinity the density, strength and stiffness are increased but the transparency and processability of the plastic decrease. The extreme hardness and lack of formability of thermoset plastics is due to the extremely large number of primary valence bonds between the plastic’s atoms. In an extreme case of crosslinking with covalent bonds practically no secondary valence bonds exist that can be loosened by increasing the temperature. This means that no thermoplastic processing of the polymer is possible. A thermoset plastic can be depicted as being a huge single molecule. The removal of these intra molecular bonds by increased tempera-
Characteristics of plnstic niuterinls
19
ture leads to destruction of the polymer. In practice there exists a range of plastics having different degrees of crosslinking, from those of the uncrosslinked thermoplastics to the completely crosslinked thermosets. With increasing degree of crosslinking the strength, stiffness and thermal resistance of the plastics increases. By varying the degree of crosslinking the elastic behavior of elastomers can be established over a wide range. The elasticity of an elastomer is therefore determined by both the primary valence and the secondary valence bonds between the molecule chains. The properties of plastics are also determined by chain length and the distribution of different chain lengths. The relative molecular mass of a macromolecule, M,, has a large influence on the polymer’s flow properties, its glass transition temperature, T,, and its mechanical properties. All synthetically produced thermoplastics exhibit a characteristic distribution of the macromolecule’s length and mass. With increasing degree of polymerization the tensile strength, tear resistance. hardness, strain at break, impact resistance and melt viscosity all increase. At the same time the tendency to crystallize, flowability, swelling and stress cracking tendency decrease. The interesting molecular mass range for technical applications lies between a M, value of 200,000 to 400,000 for the thermoplastic polyvinyl plastics and between 15,000 and 25,000 for the polyamides. For polyesters which are used as precursors for hardened crosslinked plastics, the optimum molecular mass lies around 2000 to 4000.
2.2.2 States of aggregation A low molecular weight substance can exist in one of three aggregate states: solid, liquid or gas dependent of temperature or pressure. The transition from one state into another is sharp; and the corresponding melting and boiling temperatures are characteristic properties of the substance. These small molecules are usually arranged in orderly crystals in the solid state. Macromolecules are for the most part irregular amorphous structures. A large difference exists between low molecular weight substances and most polymers, in that polymers can show a coexistence of crystalline and amorphous regions. In amorphous polymers, changes of state are less well defined and may occur over a finite temperature range. The polymer chain mobility resulting mainly from the primary polymer structure is responsible for this characteristic. Here it is understood that polymer chain mobility means its freedom of movement, i.e. the rotation of certain chain segments; and not translational and rotational movements of the whole polymer. A measure of the chain mobility is the glass transition temperature or freezing temperature T, (Table 2-2). Above this temperature the polymer chains can move freely and the polymer is rubbery or plastic. Below the glass transition temperature the chain mobility stops and the polymer becomes glassy and hard (glassy state). When heating an amorphous polymer it eventually reaches a temperature designated as its flow temperature. This is a very viscous transition state and further heating leads to a viscous melt. If a sample of an amorphous polymer is heated to a temperature above its glass transition point and then subjected t o a tensile stress, the molecules will tend to align themselves in the general direction of the stress. If the mass is then cooled below its transition temperature while the molecule is still under stress, the molecules will become frozen in an oriented state. Such an orientation can have significant effects on the properties of the polymer mass. The polymer is thus anisotropic.
20
Brandsch
Table 2-2: Abbreviations, densities and glass transition temperatures of some important thermoplastics. Polymer
Abbreviation
Density (gkm')
Glass tr. temp. ("C)
Low-density polyethylene High-density polyethylene Linear low-density polyethylene Poly-4-methylpentene-1 Polypropylene Polystyrene Acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene polymer Polymethyl methacrylate Polyvinyl acetate Polyvinyl alcohol Ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer Polyvinyl chloride Polytetrafluoroethylene Polyethylene terephthalate Polybutylene terephthalate Polycarbonate Polyoxymethylene Polvamide
LDPE HDPE LLDPE P4MP1 (PMP) PP PS ABS PMMA PVAC PVAL (PVA) EVA PVC PTFE PETP (PET) PBTP (PBT) PC POM PA
0.915-0.94 0.945-0.964 O.Y(M.935 0.83 0.9W.91 1.04-1.12 1.03-1.07 1.18-1.24 1.19 1.19-1.27 0.91-0.97 1.39-1.43 2.28-2.30 1.37 1.3-1.5 1.2C1.24 1.42-1.435 1.12-1.14
-30 15 -30 15 -30 f 15 55 -17 5 5 8G100 99-104 28-31 70-85
* *
-
8C100 115-125 67-81 48-55 120-150 188-1 99 50-60
In addition to the deliberate monoaxial or biaxial orientation carried out to produce an oriented filament or sheet, orientation will often occur during polymer processing, whether desired or not. Thus in injection moulding, extrusion or calendering the shearing of the melt during flow will cause molecular orientation. If a polymer molecule has a sufficiently regular structure it may be capable of some degree of crystallisation. Crystallisation is limited to certain linear or slightly branched polymers with a high structural regularity. Well-known examples of crystalline polymers are polyethylene, acetal resins and polytetrafluoroethylene. There are substantial differences between the crystallisation of simple molecules such as water and copper sulphate and of polymers such as polyethylene. For example, the lack of rigidity of polyethylene indicates a much lower degree of crystallinity than in the simple molecules. In spite of this the presence of crystalline regions in a polymer has a large effect on such properties as density, stiffness and clarity. The essential difference between the traditional concept of a crystal structure and crystalline polymers is that the former is a single crystal whilst the polymer is polycrystalline. A single crystal means a crystalline particle grown without interruption from a single nucleus and relatively free from defects. The term polycrystallinity refers to a state in which clusters of single crystals are involved, developed from the more or less simultaneous growth of many nuclei. There are two principal theories of crystallisation in polymers. The fringed micelle theory considers that the crystallinity present was based on small crystallites of the order of a few hundred Angstrom units in length. This is very much less than the length of a high polymer molecule and it was believed that a single polymer molecule actually passed through several crystallites. The crystallites thus consisted of a bundle of segments from separate molecules which had packed together in a highly regular order. Between the crystallites the polymer passed through amorphous regions in which molecular disposition was random. Thus there is the general picture of crystallites embedded in an amorphous matrix.
Characteristics o f plastic materials
21
This theory helps t o explain many properties of cristalline polymers but it was difficult to explain the formation of larger structures such as spherulites. The lamellae formation theory is based on studies of polymer single crystals. It was found that in many circumstances the polymer molecules folded upon themselves at intervals of about 100 A to form lamellae which appear to be the fundamental units in a mass of crystalline polymer. Crystallisation spreads by the growth of individual lamellae as polymer molecules align themselves into position and start to fold. For a variety of reasons, such as a point of branching or some other irregularity in the structure of the molecule, growth would then tend to proceed in many directions. In effect this would mean an outward growth from the nucleus and the development of spherulites. In this concept it is seen that a spherulite is simply caused by growth of the initial crystal structure, whereas in the fringed micelle theory it is generally postulated that formation of a spherulite requires considerable reorganisation of the disposition of the crystallites. Both theories are consistent with many observed effects in crystalline polymers. The closer packing of the molecules causes an increased density. The decreased intermolecular distances will increase the secondary forces holding the chain together and increase the value of properties such as tensile strength, stiffness and softening point. The properties of a given polymer very much depend on the way in which crystallisation has taken place. A polymer mass with relatively few large spherulitic structures will be very different in its properties to a polymer with far more, but smaller, spherulites. A polymer crystallised under conditions of high nucleationfgrowth ratios, with smaller structures, is generally more transparent. Homogeneous nucleation occurs when, as a result of statistically random segmental motion, a few segments adopt the same conformation as they would in a crystallite. High nucleation rates can be achieved together with high growth if heterogeneous nucleation is employed. In this case nucleation is initiated by seeding with some foreign particle. This can be of many types but is frequently a polymer of similar cohesive energy density to that being crystallised, but of a higher melting point. Nucleating agents are now widely used in commercial products. They gives a high degree of crystallisation and good clarity in polymer films. In later discussions in this book it should be noted that migration behaviour is strongly dependent on the given polymer sample. This dependency comes from the variety of plastics that exist with respect to their chemical nature, structure, molecular mass distribution, manufacturing and processing conditions.
2.3 The most important plastics 2.3.1 Thermoplastics Polyethylene ( P E )
PE is the most widely used mass-produced plastic. The worldwide production of PE at the early 1990s was 40 x lo6 metric tons per year. Of this amount 16 x lo6 tons were LDPE (low density PE), 8 x lo6 were LLDPE (linear LDPE) and the remainder was principally HDPE (high density PE) (LDPE:HDPE:LLDPE=40:40:20). The development of PE began in 1936 with the introduction of the high pressure polymerization process of ethylene to LDPE (0.915-0.94g/cm3) which produced a
22
Brandsch
relatively low molecular weight polymer. The manufacture of HDPE by low pressure polymerization first began after the discovery of the Ziegler catalysts in 1953. The HDPE produced using this process has a medium density (0.945 g/cm3). The Philips and Standard Oil process was also developed in the 1950s and produces HDPE with the highest density (0.96 g/cm3). Through the addition of small amounts of propene, 1-butene, 1-hexene or 1-octene to ethylene, short side chains can be added to the main polymer chain. The word “linear” should be interpreted to mean the absence of chain branches. With these short side chains LLDPE has a density range from 0.900 g/cm’ for VLDPE (very LDPE) to 0.935 g/cm3 for octene-ethylene copolymer. In this field metallocene catalysts become more and more important. At the present time there are available many hundreds of grades of polyethylene, most of which differ in their properties in one way or another. It is worth mentioning the polymer called poly(methylene), which is also the name being recommended by IUPAC to describe polyethylenes in general. It is a reproducible reference material obtained through synthesis with the help of diazomethane. It has no side chains and is used for characterizing technical PE and other plastics. This PE has only methyl end groups and possesses the highest obtainable density for a PE of 0.98 g/cm3. PE is a wax like thermoplastic which softens at temperatures between 80-130°C and possesses good chemical stability. The mechanical properties are dependent on the molecular weight and degree of chain branching. PE can be easily heat sealed, is tough and has high elasticity. It has good cold resistance properties and is a good water vapor barrier. However LDPE has low barrier properties to gases, aromas and fats. With increasing density, all the barrier properties increase as well as the stiffness, hardness and strength, as a result of the higher crystallinity. At the same time there is a decrease in the impact resistance, toughness, resistance to stress cracking, cold resistance and transparency. The polymer has a low cohesive energy density (the solubility parameter 6 is about 16.1 MPal”) and would be expected to be resistant to solvents of solubility parameter greater than 18.5 MPa”* (Chapter 4). Since polyethylene is a crystalline hydrocarbon polymer incapable of specific interaction, there are no solvents at room temperature. Materials of similar solubility parameters and low molecular weight will however cause swelling, the more so in low-density polymers. LDPE has a gas permeability in the range normaily expected with rubbery materials. HDPE has a permeability of about one-fifth that of LDPE. The processing of PE is normally carried out at temperatures between 150-210 “C. However temperatures as high as 300 “C can be reached during paper coating. PE is stable at these high temperatures under inert atmospheres and, when being processed under these conditions, the oxygen concentration in and around the plastic should be kept as low as possible. The chemical stability of PE is comparable to paraffin. It is not affected by mineral acids and alkalis. Nitric acid oxidizes PE and halogens react with it by substitution mechanisms. By chlorination in the presence of sulfur dioxide, chlorine groups and sulfonyl chloride are incorporated and an elastomer is formed. Oxidation of polyethylene which leads to structural changes can occur to a measurable extent at temperatures as low as 50°C. Under the influence of ultraviolet light the reaction can occur at room temperature.
Characteristics o,f plastic materials
23
In order to obtain sufficient adhesion of printing inks on PE surfaces, oxidation of the surface must take place. This can be accomplished either with flame or by corona treatment. Significant off-odors can be produced as a result of the oxidation process. In particular unsaturated ketones and aldehydes are implicated in these off-odors (Chapter 13). LDPE is used mostly in the form of films over thicknesses ranging from 15-250 pm. Coextrusions, laminates, shrink films, films for the building industry and for agricultural purposes, shopping bags, trash bags and household films are all made from LDPE. The coating of cartons and paper with LDPE using an extrusion process makes the packaging (milk cartons and paper bags) water-tight and heat sealable. Films of PET, PP, PA and other plastic substrates are extrusion coated with PE and, in so doing, are converted into water, gas and aromatight, hot-fill and aseptic packaging. Blown containers from LDPE are used as packaging in the pharmaceutical and cosmetic industries as well as for foods, toys, and cleaning agents. Injection molded LDPE is used to make buckets and various household and kitchen containers. The most important application area of HDPE is the production of containers and injection molded articles. Bottles for detergents, gasoline cans and heating oil tanks are some examples. The most common use of HDPE for injection molded articles is for the production of storage and distribution containers, like buckets and bottle cases. However, processing into films and pipes has become increasingly more common. Films made out of HDPE possess high fat resistance (as wrappers for meat) and have better aroma barrier properties compared to lower density PE materials. Copolymers of PE with vinylacetate. acrylic acid ester and methacrylic acid increase the heat sealability, adhesion to other materials and seal strength; and they improve the polymer's cold resistance and transparency. EVA in the form of shrink films are well suited for meat packaging because of their relatively high gas permeabilities. EVA-copolymers are used as sealants. With vinyl acetate contents ranging from 1540 % these copolymers are particularly applicable for the production of hot melts because of their good compatibility with fillers and other plastics. Ethylene vinyl alcohol copolymer (EVOH) is a plastic with exceptional barrier properties. It is manufactured by saponification of EVA. Polypropylene Since approximately 1986 PP has ranked third in the bulk plastic production after PE and PVC, with an estimated annual production of 21 x 106 tons. PP is differentiated into three classes: homopolymer PP; copolymers containing primarily PP; and PP elastomer mixtures. PP is composed of linear hydrocarbon chains and therefore its properties quite closely resemble those of PE. The properties of isotactic PP are particularly useful. The stereo regularity of the macromolecule chain construction and the related high crystallinity give PP its outstanding characteristics. Large scale commercially produced PP is up to 95 % isotactic in nature. Homopolymer polypropylene is one of the lightest thermoplastics, having a density ranging from 0.90 to 0.91 g/cm3. Pure isotactic PP has a melting temperature of 176°C. In general the melting temperature of commercial materials is around 160170°C with melting beginning around 140"C, which is much higher than PE. The chemical compatibility of PP is similar to that of HDPE. PP can be swelled by aro-
24
Brandsch
matic and chlorinated hydrocarbons and dissolved in them at higher temperatures. The tertiary C atoms reduce the chemical inertness of PP and make it above all more sensitive to oxidation. This sensitivity to oxidation must be compensated for by the addition of antioxidants. PP possesses good water vapor barrier and fat resistance properties. Normal PP films have limited food packaging applications (e.g. packaging of bread) because of their low cold temperature resistance. Copolymer mixtures with ethylene are used to improve cold resistance and heat sealability as well as material strength and, above all, seal strength. The statistical distribution of the monomer units leads to a significant decrease in the degree of crystallinity with small amounts of ethylene (4-15 YO).These products result in better strength and transparency. The melting range is also broader and begins at a lower temperature. The large availability of nucleating agents based on sorbitol enables the fabrication of clear PP products, with transparencies between 89 (homopolymer) and 96 YO (metallocen random copolymers). PP is an excellent material for injection and extrusion processes. The packaging containers, in particular bottles, made using these processes should be mentioned. PP bottles maintain their shape well at high temperatures which allows them to be hotfilled. Improved properties are obtained by using polymer mixtures with ethylene as mentioned before. Injection molded containers are used for frozen foods, e.g. ice cream. In addition, steam sterilizable containers and dishes can be produced for heating in microwaves. New PP packaging developments are multiplelayer bottles and cans with inner barrier layers which can be hot-filled or sterilized in an autoclave as well as directly steam sterilized. PP packaging can be filled with liquids that are surface active because of its good stress cracking resistance. Over 40 Yo of the PP produced in Europe is used to make films. Random copolymers with ethylene are superior with regard to toughness, transparency, shrink characteristics and sealability. These films exhibit low stiffness, strength and hardness. The thickness of these films lies between 12 and 125 pm. By stretching, usually biaxially, under their melting temperature range, PP films can be orientated. Orientation can be used to improve properties like strength, cold stability (down to -50 " C ) and heat resistance. Heat sealable biaxially orientated PP (BOPP) is used for the packaging of confectionery products, baked goods, snack products, pasta, potato products and dried fruits. In addition BOPP films play an important role in cigarette packaging as well as for cosmetic and pharmaceutical packaging. OPP films serve as carriers in laminates. The shrink characteristics of PP are greatly increased by biaxial stretching. After wrapping an article, the film shrinks back to its unoriented state upon nearing the crystalline melting point. The disadvantage of orientation is that it is not particularly suitable for heat sealing. To overcome this disadvantage, the BOPP is coated with a heat sealable layer having a low melting temperature. By coextruding a core layer of homopolymer PP along with two heat sealable layers and subsequently stretching it, the thickness of the heat seal layers can be reduced to 1pm. For the packaging of sensitive foods, PP films are coated with polyvinylidene chloride, polyvinyl acetate, EVAcopolymers, polyacrylates, styrene-butadiene copolymers, LDPE, poly-1-butene or random copolymers of propene with ethylene and 1-butene. By using these various coatings PP has recently sharply reduced the use of regenerated cellulose (cellophane), the previous market leader in this area.
Churactrristics of plastic nzaterials
25
Polymer chain segments of pure PP and pure PE placed one after the other form block copolymers that have an increased degree of crystallinity. Depending on the manufacturing process, copolymers with an ethylene fraction of up to 30 YOcan also be noncrystalline, thus forming an ethylenepropylene elastomer. Products with similar properties are also obtained from mixtures of homoPP with PE as well as with ethylenepropylene elastomers. Such mixtures are interesting because of their high flexibility at low temperatures. These mixtures, which may contain up to SO YOelastomer, are designated as elastomermodified thermoplastics. Those materials with elastomer content over 50 YOare referred to as thermoplastic rubbers. Polybutene-1 The manufacturing process and properties of polybutene-1 are comparable to PP. Compared to the aliphatic hydrocarbons. this material is not as inert as PE and PP. Its high burst strength and tear strength are very advantageous for the manufacture of hot water pipes (resistant up to 95 "C). Good flexibility is a characteristic of polybutene films which makes it a good plastic coating for paper and aluminum because of its high tear strength. Butene-1 can be copolymerized with ethylene as well as higher a-olefins like propylene and 4-methyl-pentane. Polyisobutene The rubbery character and particular physical and chemical properties of polyisobutene stem from its paraffinic origins. Its outstanding properties are its low glass transition temperature, very low water vapor permeability and resistance to many chemicals. At room temperature polyisobutene is resistant to dilute and concentrated mineral acids and bases, as well as hydrogen peroxide. Low molecular weight polyisobutene is used both as the soft component and as the adhesive component in glues and sealants. The high molecular weight polymers are quite similar to vulcanized rubber. Polymer mixtures of isobutene and polyolefins are used for the manufacture of lacquers. Polymer mixtures with styrene also have different applications for impregnation compounds, glues etc. Copolymers of isobutene with styrene (< 10 YO)and isoprene (< 3 YO)may be used for the manufacture of food contact materials. The following polymerizates and polymer mixes can be added to these polymerizates: polyethylene, polypropylene, styreneacrylonitrile mixed polymers, mixed polymers of ethylene, propylene, butylene, vinyl esters and unsaturated aliphatic acids as well as salts and esters and polybutene-1. Poly (Cmethylpentene-1)( P I M P ] ) Poly (4-methylpentene-1) possesses a largely isotactic structure with over 40 YO crystallinity. Characteristic properties are its high transparency and very low density of 0.83 g/cm3, as well as its applications at high temperatures up to 150 "C. 4-Methylpentene-1 can be copolymerized with n-alkenes (C2-CS; < 10 YO,C6-Cl4; < 5 Yo).
26
Brandsch
Ionomers
Polymers having carboxyl groups in their ionized form are obtained through high pressure polymerization of ethylene with 1-10 YOof an unsaturated organic acid and treatment with compounds of magnesium, zinc, calcium or sodium (e.g. magnesium acetate). These polymers have a type of ionic crosslinking which is stable at normal temperatures but can be reversed at higher temperatures. By these means ionomers possess increased stiffness while still having sufficient flexibility at high temperatures. Ionomer films, also known as Surlyn (DuPont), have high water vapor permeability because of their low crystallinity compared to PE. At the same time ionomers show exceptional oil and fat resistance. A particular advantage of this material is its good adhesion to other substrates. Thus it is used in laminations because of its good resistance to delamination. Disadvantages compared to PE are its high cost and low application temperatures. The maximum zinc content of the finished ionic crosslinked mixed polymerization material is about 3.5 YO.Polymer mixtures of ethylene, propylene, butylene, vinyl esters and unsaturated aliphatic acids as well as salts and esters can be used in the manufacture of ionomer food contact materials. The materials are then differentiated according to whether they contain no crosslinking or have by peroxides ionic or physical crosslinked materials. For the manufacture of non-crosslinked ionomer polymer mixtures ethylene, butene-I , isobutylene, vinyl chloride, vinylidene chloride, aliphatic carboxylic acids of vinyl esters (C2-C18), aliphatic unsaturated mono and di carboxylic organic acid esters (C3-C8) with mono aliphatic saturated alcohols (C2-Cl2) and unsaturated aliphatic mono and di carboxylic organic acids (C3-C8) can be used as raw materials. Ionomer polymer mixtures can be blended with various products. The materials used to cut the ionomer are paraffins, microcrystalline waxes, plasticizer free vinyl chloride, polymer mixtures of polyethylene, polypropylene as well as natural and synthetic rubber. Finished materials made from uncrosslinked ionomer mixtures may not be used for contact with fatty foods. Peroxide crosslinked ionomer mixtures made from the abovementioned raw materials may be used in contact with fatty foods under certain limited conditions, according to their raw materials and additives. Vinyl chloride and vinylidene chloride should not be used in materials having either ionic (ionQmer) or physical (e.g. through electron beam irradiation) crosslinks. Crosslinked polyethylene can be used for t h e manufacture of food contact materials, e.g. for drinking water pipes and fittings. The crosslinking can be done using either peroxide or electron beam irradiation. Polystyrene
With an annual production of over 6 x lo6 tons (excluding eastern European countries) polystyrene (PS) occupies forth place behind PE, PVC and PP on the bulk polymer list. PS has been commercially produced since 1930. As a thermoplastic plastic it can be processed between temperatures of 150 to 300°C. At higher temperatures depolymerization takes place by splitting out the styrene. Products formed from PS are hard and transparent, with high brilliance and resistance to many chemicals. Its disadvantages are its brittleness and sensitivity to stress cracking. Because of its high permeability to gases and vapors it is mainly used as a material for products requiring
Cliaracteristics of plastic muterials
27
short shelf lives, usually refrigerated and not having too high a fat content, such as yoghurt, ice cream, fresh cheese and coffee cream. PS is also used as a divider or organizer for fruits, eggs, baked goods and sweets. In the past few years PS has been increasingly replaced in many application areas by the less expensive PP. Styrene can be copolymerized with many monomers. The following monomers can be used along with styrene in the manufacture of food contact materials: a-methylstyrene, vinyltoluene, divinylbenzene. acrylonitrile. ethyleneoxide, butadiene, fumaric and maleic acid esters of the mono functional saturated aliphatic alcohols Cl-C8, acrylic acid ester and methacrylic acid, maleic acid anhydride, methylacrylamidemethylol ether, vinylmethyl ether, vinylisobutyl ether. Styrene and/or a-methylstyrene and/or vinyltoluene should be the main mixture component in every case. Through polymerization of a styrene rubber solution, one obtains SB mass (styrene-butadiene). SB forms a twophase system in which the styrene is the continuous phase and the rubber, usually a butadiene base, is the discontinuous phase. The rubber phase also contains pockets of styrene. The SB polymer, because of its properties, is also known as impact resistant or high impact PS (HIPS). When the continuous phase is formed by a copolymer of styrene and acrylonitrile, then one obtains a material known as acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene (ABS). The acrylonitrile part improves the stresscrack resistance of the polymer. Although the absorption of water vapor by PS is very low, it cannot withstand boiling water. PS is soluble in aromatic and halogenated hydrocarbons as well as ethers, esters and ketones. Even though many single substances do not attack PS, one can observe obvious synergistic effects with respect to interactions. Essential oils and various cosmetics and medical preparations attack PS and lead to stresscracking among other problems. PS is resistant to salt solutions, bases and dilute acid solutions. Oxidizing acids cause oxidathe degradation of the PS. In the presence of oxygen, UV light leads to yellowing and brittleness. The chemical stability of PS is on the whole lower than PE. Packaging for food and pharmaceuticals as well as household appliances and containers like drinking cups and disposable dishes are all made from PS and SB. Oriented PS films are used for packaging milk products and cigarettes. The low heat conductance and high impact resistance at low temperatures are advantageous properties for the use of PS as a packaging material for freezing. Of the styrene copolymers used for food packaging the styrene-acrylonitrile copolymer known as SAN still needs to be mentioned. SAN copolymers possess better mechanical properties and better resistance to oils and aroma compounds than PS. Copolymers with acrylonitrile fractions of 20-35 % find uses as household and camping dishes. Copolymers with a higher acrylonitrile content (> 60 9'0) have earned particular importance as barrier plastics. With an increasing acrylonitrile fraction, the gas permeability decreases sharply. Copolymers with methacrylic acid esters are also used in packaging. The breakthrough to bulk plastic was made possible by the development of ABS polymers. This copolymer mixture leads to a combination of technologically important properties that have allowed its use for many diverse applications. The continuous phase in the ABS polymer is responsible for most of its chemical properties. Because of the presence of only C-C binding in the polymer chain no hydrolytic reactions can take place. ABS polymers are in general resistant to aqueous salt, base or acid solutions and are not dissolved by paraffinic hydrocarbons. Depend-
28
Brundsch
ing on the type and amount of the rubber phase a weight gain due to uptake of hydrocarbons can take place. The copolymer is also resistant to fat and various cosmetic creams. This results from increased polarity due to the acrylonitrile. Halogenated hydrocarbons, aromatics, esters and ketones however dissolve the SAN phase. Oxidative substances, in particular acids, destroy the polymer chain. The good cold resistance of this material (to -40 "C) deserves a mention. Finally, styrene homopolymers with the addition of = 6 YO of a low molecular weight hydrocarbon, for example pentane, are the most important starting materials for the manufacture of PS hard foams. Polyvinyl chloride
The ability of vinyl chloride to polymerize was first observed over 150 years ago. Polyvinyl chloride has been industrially manufactured since approximately 1930. Even though pure PVC is fairly unstable, it is ranked second after PE for bulk plastic production. The manifold applications of PVC are made possible by the discovery of effective stabilizers and other additives for the polymer. At the beginning of the 1970s the annual production figures for PVC and PE were quite similar. However, since 1971 serious health problems and complications have been seen in persons exposed to vinyl chloride in the air. The formation of liver angiosarcomas in workers in the PVC industry marked a turning point in PVC production. The residual concentration of vinyl chloride monomer in PVC that were approximately 30@400 ppm (mg/kg) in the 1960s were reduced to 2-5 ppm in 1976 and presently are well under 1 ppm. The additional technological effort needed to remove the remaining residual monomer and the decreasing acceptance by consumers of this plastic in the meantime led to a relative decrease in the use of PVC compared to PE. This decrease has been particularly noticeable for food packaging. Additionally, PVC can be replaced by PP in various applications. Nevertheless, PVC has still maintained a leading position among the bulk plastics today because of its low price and numerous application possibilities. Global capacity for PVC production is about 22 x lo6 t.p.a.. second only to polyethylene, with polypropylene third. PVC is resistant to nonpolar (hydrocarbon) and strongly polar substances (water, inorganic acid). Middle polarity compounds such as cyclohexanone, dimethylformamide, acetone, chlorinated hydrocarbons, tetrahydrofuran, and phenol all either swell PVC or dissolve it. This behavior can easily be attributed to the slightly polar structure of the PVC macromolecule. When PVC is pyrolyzed, the main decomposition product is hydrochloric acid, along with small amounts of saturated and unsaturated hydrocarbon side products. PVC is easily degraded through the effect of heat, light and mechanical energy. In order to improve the low stability of this plastic, a series of additives are incorporated into the PVC melt. The most important additives for the processing of PVC are the plasticizers, which may be incorporated at elevated temperatures to give mixtures stable at room temperature. Due to its particularly good polymer characteristics PVC has an enormously wide spectrum of applications. From the consumption of more than 5.5 x 10' t in Western Europe (1997), 60% is in the building field, with a tendency to rise. Blow molded containers for packaging liquid products (beverages, edible oils, detergents, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals) receive special consideration, as do dishes for fatty foods (highly
Characteristics of plastic materials
29
stable against low polarity substances) and films (such as soft PVC films with high gas permeability) for fresh meat packaging. Soft PVC is also used as a component in seals. Vinyl chloride can be copolymerized with a series of monomers: Vinylidene chloride, trans-dichloroethylene, vinylesters of aliphatic carboxylic acid (C2-C18). acrylic acid esters, methacrylic and/or maleic acid as well as fumaric acid with mono-functional aliphatic saturated alcohols (CI-Clx), mono-functional aliphatic unsaturated alcohols (C3-CI8), vinyl ethers from mono-functional aliphatic saturated alcohols (C ,-CIx). propylene, butadiene, maleic acid, fumaric acid, itaconic acid, acrylic acid, methacrylic acid (total < 8 YO)and N-cyclohexylmaleinimide (< 7 YO). PVC can be blended with numerous other polymers to give it better processability and impact resistance. For the manufacture of food contact materials the following polymerizates and/or polymer mixtures from polymers manufactured from the above mentioned starting materials can be used: Chlorinated polyolefins; blends of styrene and graft copolymers and mixtures of polystyrene with polymerisate blends; butadiene-acrylonitrile-copolymer blends (hard rubber); blends of ethylene and propylene. butylene. vinyl ester, and unsaturated aliphatic acids as well as salts and esters; plasticizerfrec blends of methacrylic acid esters and acrylic acid esters with monofunctional saturated alcohols (C1-CIx) as well as blends of the esters of methacrylic acid: butadiene and styrene as well as polymer blends of acrylic acid butyl ester and vinylpyrrolidone; polyurethane manufactured from 1,6-hexamethyIene diisocyanate, 1 .Cbutandiol and aliphatic polyesters from adipic acid and glycols. For unplasticized chlorinated PVC, unplasticized chlorinated polymer blends of vinyl chloridc and mixtures of these copolymers with other polymer blends, the following starting materials can be used: PVC (homopolymer); polymer blends of vinyl chloride, vinylidene chloride, trans-dichloroethylene, ethylene, propylene, butylene, maleic acid, fumaric acid, itaconic acid, acrylic acid, methacrylic acid as well as chlorine. Unplasticized PVC and polymer blends of vinyl chloride can be added to chlorinated polymers manufactured using the above starting materials. Because of the increasing amount of criticism from consumer groups due to the formation of hydrochloric acid during burning and because of plasticizer migration from soft PVC films, PVC is continually being replaced by other plastics. The strongest competition exists in the container market whcre it is being replaced by PET for beverage packaging. Soft PVC films can also be replaced by other polyolefin-based systems.
Poly vinylidene chloride Homo and copolymers of vinylidene chloride (VDC) possess extremely high barrier properties to gases, water and aromas as well as good resistance to water and solvents. The barrier properties of polyvinylidene chloride (PVDC) come from the dense packing of its polymer chains (without voids or branching) which are crystalline in their stable form. The chlorine content of the highdensity polymer is 73 YO(1.80-1.97 g/cm3,crystalline). PVDC dissolves at room temperature only in polar solvents like hexamethylphosphoric acid amide or tetramethylene sulfoxide. Amorphous PVDC can also be dissolved in tetrahydrofuran. Above 125 "C PVDC decomposes by giving off hydrochloric acid. Under the influence of high energy irradiation, basic compounds and heavy
30
Brandsch
metals cause decomposition. Stability with respect to decomposition can be increased by copolymerization with vinyl chloride, acrylonitrile, methyl acrylate and others. At the same time copolymerization decreases crystallinity and increases the gas permeability. In packaging, thin PVDC films are used as barrier layers in laminates. PVDC dispersion coatings provide very good barrier properties on paper, regenerated cellulose, OPP and other plastic films. The coatings can also be manufactured so that they are heat sealable. Because of their heat sealability, fat and oil resistance and good flexibility, PVDC polymers are exceptional packaging materials. Thermoplastic polyesters
The most important representatives of this group are polyethylene terephthalate (PET) and polybutylene terephthalate (PBT). The consumption of PET in the world (excluding fibers) was about 4 x lo6 t in 1997 (audio and video films, technical mouldings, packaging, particularly bottles). Even though the cost of these plastics is presently in the medium price range, one can count on a reduction in their price in the future due to their widespread use. The following starting materials can be used for manufacture of polyesters for food contact: terephthalic acid, isophthalic acid (< 25 YO), adipic acid, azelaic acid, sebacic acid, ethylene glycol, butanediol-1,4, 1,4-dihydroximethylcyclohexane,terephthalic acid methyl ester, azelaic acid dimethyl ester, sebacic acid dimethyl ester, oligomeric diglycydyl ether of 4,4'-dioxidiphenyl-2,2-propane (Bisphenol-A-diglycydyl ether; (> 2 %), n-decane dicarboxylic acid-1,lO (> 15 YO), polyethylene glycol (< 10 %). PE (< 5 Yo)or PP (< 5 YO)may be added to polyesters manufactured from the above starting materials. The linear saturated polyesters are hard, semicrystalline thermoplastics that are impact resistant even at low temperatures, smooth and have good wear resistance. Their amorphous fractions have glass temperatures around 50-70 "C. The barrier properties of PET are good with respect to gases, aromas and fats and have slightly lower barrier properties against water vapor. Because of its partial crystallinity PET has a high strength at shorttime load over a wide temperature range from 4 0 "C to over 200 "C. The glassy clearness and strength are improved by stretching the plastic. Biaxially stretched PET films with thicknesses around 12 pn are important substrates in barrier laminates and have a wide spectrum of uses especially for longer times at high temperatures over 150 "C. Cardboard baking dishes coated with crystalline PETor crystalline PBT can be used in convection ovens up to temperatures of 2W220"C. Single portion dishes made from heat formed films find wide applications in microwave ovens. Biaxially stretched PET covers an important application area of bottles, wide mouth jars and cans. These containers are particularly well suited for carbonated beverages, edible oils and spirits. The gas barrier properties can be improved by coextrusion with a barrier layer such as polyamide. With improved barrier properties it can also be used for beer and wine.
C\iaructeristics of plustic materials
31
Polycarbonute Polycarbonate (PC) is a high value plastic with high strength and hardness along with good toughness. PC has a high resistance to heat, up to 135 "C, as well as to cold, down to -90 "C. The relatively expensive glassclear amorphous plastic however possesses relatively high permeability to gases and water vapor which makes it necessary to combine it with a suitable barrier layer. The production in the world in 1997 was about 1.2 x 10' t (40 YOfor electrotechnical and household articles, 23 YOin the building field, 13 YOfor audio-CDs and CD-ROMs). PC, because of its properties, is well suited for the manufacture of dishes and kitchen utensils, coffee filters and machines, baby bottles and other containers. For food contact articles the following starting materials can be used: 4,q-dioxy-diphenyl-2,2-propane, 4,4'-dioxy-diphenyl-l, 1-cyclohexane, 2,6-bis-(2'-hydroxy-S'-methylbenzyl)-4-methyl phenol (< 1 YO), 1,4-bis-(4',4'-dihydroxytriphenyl-methyl)-benzene (< 1 YO), diphenyl carbonate, phosgene, terephthalic acid dichloride, isophthalic acid dichloride, 4,4'-dioxy-diphenyl-3,3'-oxindol (< 1 YO),3,3-bis-(3-methyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)-2-indolinone (< 1 Yo). The following substances for limiting polymer chain length in the manufacture of PC can be used: phenol (< 2 YO),tertiary butylphenol (< 3 YO)or 4-(1,1,3,3-tetramethyl-buty1)-phenol (< 5 %). These substances are incorporated into the polymer macromolecule. PC can be mixed with copolymers of styrene, butadiene and acrylonitrile where the PC forms the bulk of the total mixture. Polyriniitle
The manufacture of the large variety of polyamides (commonly referred to as nylons) occurs through polycondensation of amino carboxylic acids (or functional derivatives of them, e.g. lactams) and from diamines and dicarboxylic acids. Labeling the amino groups with A and the carboxyl groups with B allows differentiation of the different chemical structures between the two types AB (from amino carboxylic acids) and AA-BB (from diamines and dicarboxylic acids). The number of C atoms in the monomers acts as a code number for the identification of the polyamides. The polycaprolactam manufactured from caprolactam (type AB) is then called polyamide 6 (PA 6). The number of carbon atoms in the diamine is given first for type AA-BB followed by the number of atoms in the dicarboxylic acid, e.g. PA 66 for polyhexamethylenediadipic amide from hexamethylenediamine and adipic acid. For copolymers the components are separated by a slash, e.g. PA 66/6 (90:lO) is a copolymer composed of 90 parts PA 66 and 10 parts PA 6. The world-wide production of PA (excluding fibers) in 1997 was 1.6~10't. with a 75 Youse of casting processed materials. For food contact articles the following can be used as starting materials: straight chain w-amino acids ( C S - C ~ ~and ) their lactams; adipic acids, azelaic acids, sebacic acids, dodecane dicarboxylic acids and heptadecanedicarboxylic acids salts with hexamethylenediamine; isophthalic acid, bis(4-aminocyc1ohexyl)-methane, 2,2-bis(4'-aminocyclohexyl)-propane,3,3'-dimethyl-4,4'-diaminodicyclohexyl-methane, terephthalic acid or its methylester, 1,6-diamino-2,2,4-trimethylhexane, 1,6-diamino-2,4,4-trimethylhexane, l-amino-3-amino-methyl-3,5,5-trimethylhexane.
32
Brandsch
Polymer blends having PA as the bulk phase can contain ethylene, propylene, butylene, vinylesters and unsaturated aliphatic acids as well as their salts and esters. PA 6, PA 12, PA 6/66, PA 6/12 and PA 11 all have particular importance in the packaging area. Because of the strong polar nature of the CONH group, hydrogen bonds are formed between neighboring macromolecules. As a result PA is hard, temperature resistant and some types are highly crystalline. The shorter the segment between the amide groups the more water the polar groups can absorb. The absorption of water increases the strength while at the same time decreasing the stiffness. Air moisture conditioned samples are not in danger of stress cracking. Except for the chlorinated hydrocarbons, polyamides are resistant to most solvents, fats, oils, alkalis and acids. They can be dissolved in concentrated sulfuric acid, phenol and m-cresol. Even though PA have good barrier properties to gases and aromas, the barrier properties against water are only mediocre. The melting points vary between 175-255 "C.PA is also applicable for use at low temperatures ranging from -50 "Cto -70 "C. The main application of this relatively expensive plastic in the packaging area is in laminates. Its good barrier properties are improved by combining it with PE which has good water vapor barrier and heat sealability properties. Thermoformable laminates are used for vacuum or inert gas packed meat products, fish and cheeses. Biaxial stretching of PA (OPA) improves its stiffness and leads to its use as a carrier film together with a heat sealable layer in laminates. Vacuum and inert gas packing of coffee, milk powder and meat products are some of the many examples of such applications. These PA laminates are also used in the inner bags for 'bag-in-a-box' liquid packages. Polymethylmethucrylute
In comparison to bulk plastics, thermoplastic polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) is much more expensive. Its particular characteristics are clarity, hardness, low absorbance and resistance to aqueous solutions, acids, alkalis, carbon dioxide and fat. It is attacked or dissolved by polar organic solvents. The world-wide use of PMMA in 1997 was ca. 1.2 x 106t, principaly for optical articles in cars and buildings and glazing material in aircraft. Typical food contact articles are dishes, cups and silverware. In addition it has orthopedic and denture uses. For food contact articles made from acrylic and methacrylic acid ester copolymers and their polymer blends, the following starting materials can be used: a) Esters of methacrylic acid and acrylic acid with mono and multi-functional saturated aliphatic alcohols C1-CI8,dimethylamino ethanol, cyclohexylamino ethanol, trimethyl ammonium ethanol chloride, ether alcohol, phenol, benzyl alcohol, b) styrene and a-methylstyrene, c) acrylic acid, methacrylic acid, maleic acid, itaconic acid, d) amides of acrylic and methacrylic acid, e) butadiene, f) vinylidene chloride, g) vinyl and ally1 esters of acrylic and methyacrylic acid, h) triallylcyanurate. The esters of methacrylic acid and acrylic acid should form the largest fractions in the finished product. The addition of different starting materials to methylmethacrylate modifies the properties of the PMMA melt. For example, by lowering the working temperature or increasing the warm form stability (through incorporation of maleic acid and styrene) the plastic can be made impact tough down to 40 "C and is suitable for the manufacture of blown containers and deep drawn packaging for food and medicines.
Cliaracteristics qf plastic materials
33
Polyoxyniethylene or acetal resin Polyoxymethylene (POM) plastics are highly crystalline thermoplastics that are obtained by polymerization of formaldehyde and can also be in the form of trioxymethylene oligomers (trioxane). The world-wide consumption in 1997 was 0.5 x lo6 t for car parts and other articles processed by injection moulding. Polyacetals are primarily engineering materials being used to replace metals. In food contact articles ethylene oxide, butane diolglyceride ether, butane diolformal, 1,3-dioxane, 13-dioxolane (total < 6 %) can be used as comonomers. Amines, triphenylphosphine, borotrifluoride and others can be used as catalysts (total < 0.1 %) and various polymerization regulators and polymerization inhibitors can be used. Because of their high crystallinity POM polymers are white opaque, have high strength and toughness even at low temperatures (usable from 4 0 ° C to 100°C and for short times at 150°C). They are resistant to alcohols, esters, hydrocarbons and weak alkalis but are not resistant to acids (pH < 4). The copolymers are more resistant to hot water.
Polysulfone As a result of incorporating benzene rings in the molecular chain, the temperature resistance of thermoplastic polysulfone is quite high and lies around 130°C. Better temperature resistance at higher temperatures can be obtained by bonding the benzene rings using oxygen, sulfur or sulfur groups as well as nitrogencontaining imide groups. Polysulfone (PSU) and polyethersulfone (PES) are two amorphous polar thermoplastics having lower application temperatures from -70 to -100 "C and constant use temperatures in air from 150-170 "C (PSU), 200 "C (PES) and for short times up to 200 "C (PSU) and 260 "C (PES). These plastics have high strength and stiffness and are particularly suitable for the manufacture of microwave dishes, hot water containers and other household articles. The uptake of water by polysulfones influences the mechanical properties in a similar manner to PA. One obtains particularly good heat resistance with polyimide plastic dishes.
Fluoride containing polymers Even though these plastics are used mainly as coatings in the manufacture of food contact materials they are treated in this section as thermoplastics. The most important representative of this group is polytetrafluorethylene (PTFE) which is synthesized by radical polymerization of tetrafluoroethylene. This high molecular weight, crystalline, linear polymer is exceptionally resistant to solvents and other chemicals. PTFE melts around 320-345 "C and can be used continuously between temperatures of -200 and 260°C. Because of its nonwetability PTFE has exceptional anti-adhesive properties and in addition shows good slip characteristics. For these reasons the polymer is used as a raw material for temperature resistant nonstick coatings for frying pans, pots and other cooking pots and utensils. Plastics with similar properties and applications can be found in the form of polymer mixtures of PTFE with other polymers (see coating Section 2.3.7).
34
Brandsch
Poly vinylether The polyvinylethers form a further group of thermoplastics which are not used as containers or packaging films. They are atactic polymers forming oils, sticky soft resins or nonsticky rubber elastic materials according to their molecular weight and composition. All polyvinylethers are very resistant to saponification by dilute acids and alkalis. They can subsequently be used as unsaponifiable polymer plasticizers and for the manufacture of glues. The following starting materials can be used for the manufacture of polyvinylether polymers: vinylmethylether, vinylethylether, vinylisobutylether, vinyloctylether, vinyldecylet her and vinyloctadecylether . Polymerization of polyvinylethers is initiated using cationic initiators like borotrifluoride and the finished product may not contain more than 0.4 % borane and 0.3 YO fluoride as decomposition products. Tertiarybutylphenol disulfide (< 0.15 Y )can be used as a stabilizer as well as a polymerization regulator. The solubility of the polymer in various media is dependent on the nature of its vinyl groups. Polyvinylmethyl ether dissolves in aromatic hydrocarbons, esters, ketones, alcohols, and cold water. However, polyvinylbutylether is soluble in aliphatic hydrocarbons but not in water, methanol and ethanol. Polyvinyloctadecyl ether possesses a wax-like consistency. The polymers can be mixed with one another as well as with many natural resins and plastics.
2.3.2 Thermosets The most important thermosets are: phenolic resins (PF) urea-formaldehyde resins (UF) melamine-formaldehyde resins (MF) unsaturated polyester resins (UP) epoxide resins (EP) The world-wide consumption in 1997 of urea- and melamine-formaldehyde resins ~ m3, UP-resins 2.9 x 10' t and EP-resins was 8 x lo6 m3, phenolic resins 2 . 8 10' 1.5 x 10' t.
Amino resins (UF: MF) Melamine resins are used from this group of thermosets for the manufacture of food contact materials. The melamine can be used in mixtures with urea and in some applications with phenol (< 1 YO).The polymerization process is catalyzed in the presence of organic acids (e.g. acetic acid, lactic acid, tartaric acid, citric acid), hydrochloric acid, sulfuric acid, phosphoric acid, sodium and potassium hydroxide, ammonia, calcium or magnesium hydroxide as well as salts of these substances (total < 1 "/o) which cause the elimination of water and lead to a cured resin system. Stearic acid can be used as a lubricant as can zinc, calcium and magnesium salts, esters of montanic acid with ethandiol and 1,3-butandiol, as well as silicone oil (total < 1 %). Dishes and cups for eating and drinking are manufactured by moulding and can be recognized by their light, non-fading color. These articles are resistant to hot water, organic solvents, oils, fats and alcohols. The polymers containing phenol may only be
Chnrmteristics of plastic mnterinls
35
used for household and kitchen utensils and equipment (intended only for short foodcontact times).
Utisuturated polyester (UP) As a preliminary step in the manufacture of unsaturated polyester thermoset plastic one uses low molecular weight linear polyester (M, << 10,000) obtained by a polycondensation of polyglycols with saturated and unsaturated dicarboxylic acids. The precondensate can then be dissolved and stored in the stabilized comonomer, e.g. styrene, with which it will be crosslinked later. The crosslinking polymerization reaction between the polyester chains and the styrene bridges is initiated with the help of organic peroxides which are added dispersed in plasticizers. The reaction begins at 60-90 "C and then proceeds exothermally. In addition to this a cold hardening reaction can also be carried out. For this reaction cold accelerators are necessary, e.g. tertiary amines or cobalt naphthenate. Food contact materials must be hardened in a hot air oven (80-100 "C) for a couple of hours. After the oven treatment the material must be washed for 1-2 hours with hot water (80 "C) in order to remove volatile and water soluble components. The following substances are recommended starting materials for unsaturated polyesters: fumaric acid, maleic acid. methacrylic acid, adipic acid, phthalic acid, resinic acid. isophthalic acid, terephthalic acid, hydrated or halogenated phthalic acids, aliphatic and substituted aliphatic single and multi-functional alcohols up to CI8, alkoxylated and hydrated phenols and bisphenols, styrene, vinyltoluene, acrylic acid and methacrylic acid esters of the CI-C4 alcohols, and tricyclodecane dimethanol. The hardened, light stable, lightly pigmented food contact materials are not susceptible to stress cracking, but are resistant to alcohols, ethers, hydrocarbons, fats, and can be used with weak acids and boiling water. Typical applications are beverage containers and silos for foodstuffs. Phthalate based polycondensate resins, modified with unsaturated fatty acids and styrene as well as vinyltoluene have many applications in the form of paints and lacquers as "alkyd resins".
2.3.3 Polyurethanes This plastic includes a large group of polyaddition polymers which are formed through the reaction of bifunctional or trifunctional alcohols with di- or polyisocyanates. By varying the starting materials, linear as well as crosslinked macromolecules with correspondingly different properties are formed. Alcohols with three functional groups and/or triisocyanate are used to make crosslinked polyurethane elastomers (PUR). The global consumption in 1997 was 7 x 10' t. The market is dominated by flexible foam (49% in the USA, 38% in Western Europe) and rigid and semi-rigid foam (28 % USA, 35 % Western Europe). Reaction injection moulding (RIM) products account for about 6 YOand cast rubbers 2 %, and about 15 % is used as thermoplastic rubbers, surface coatings, sealants, adhesives and synthetic leathers. With respect to food packaging applications there are many different cases. Most of the food contact articles as well as coatings do not come into complete contact with foods for long periodes.
36
Brandsch
Examples are storage containers, container coatings, seals having large surface areas and packaging. The following raw materials can be used: adipic acid, carbon dioxide, 1,2-ethanediol, 12-propanediol, glycerin, 1,6-hexanediol, 1P-butanediol, 2,2dimethylpropanediol, 2,3-butanediol, diethyleneglycol, propoxylated trimethylpropane, diethoxyhydrochinone, as well as polyesters of these diols and acids with hydoxyl end groups. In addition polyethers based on ethylene dioxide, propylene dioxide and/or tetrahydrofuran with free hydroxyl groups can be used. The following isocyanates are mentioned hexamethylene-l,6-di-isocyanate,diphenylmethane-2.4'di-isocyanate and diphenylmethane-4,4'-di-isocyanate, 2,4-toluene di-isocyanate, 2,6toluene diisocyanate. Crosslinked polyurethanes are used as glue layers in food packaging. As opposed to glued seams, which when properly used have no or very minute food contact surface areas, the glue layer is a very thin coating covering the complete package surface area. But it has no possible direct contact with the food due to a covering material. Nevertheless, it cannot be ignored that some migration may take place from the polyurethane layer through the cover material layer. There should be no migration of residual reactive low molecular weight starting material components found in the glue during the manufacture of the laminate. The following starting materials can be used for these applications: a) Polyesterpolyole (polyesters containing hydroxyl end groups) based on carboxylic acid, adipic acid, phthalic acid, trimellitic acid (benzene-l,2,4-tricarboxylic acid), sebacic acid, maleic acid, ethanediol, propanediol-1,2, butanediol-13, butanediol-1,4, 2,3-dimethyl propanediol-1,3, l,l,l-trimethylol propane, diethylene glycol, hexanediol-l,6, glycerine, dimethylpropanediol-1,3. b) Polyetherpolyole (polyether containing hydroxyl end groups) c) Reaction products with hydroxyl end groups manufactured from a) and b) polyoles with toluene diisocyanate-2,4, toluene diisocyanate-2,6, diphenylmethane-4,q-diisocyanate, hexamethylene diisocyanate-1,6. d) Reaction products with end isocyanate groups manufactured from the above mentioned isocyanates and polyoles. As accelerants caprolactam and as chain lengtheners tri-isopropanol amine are recommended. After the removal of solvents not more than 10 g of polyurethane should be applied per 1 m2. Residual solvents and amines may not be detected in foods or food simulants coming in contact with the laminate films. Linear polyurethane is used for coating paper. The abovementioned diols and polyethers based on ethylene oxide and propylene oxide with free hydroxyl groups, adipic acid, phthalic acid and the isocyanatesindicated in c) may be used as starting materials. As emulsifiers Na and K salts of glycine, lysine and taurine (total < 0.8 YO)as well as N-(2-amino-ethyl)-3-aminopropane sulfonate and/or N-(2-amino-ethyl)-2-amino ethane sulfonate (total < 5.0 Y )are recommended. These emulsifiers are incorporated into the macromolecules and therefore can be found only in very small amounts in the finished product. Esters of montanic acid with ethanediol andlor 1,3-butanediol and mixtures of these esters with unesterified montanic acid as well as Ca salts (total < 1.5 YO)can be used as lubricants and mold release agents. Linear polyurethane for paper coating can be mixed with plastic dispersions where the polyurethane forms the bulk of the coating.
Characteristics of plastic materials
37
Polyurethane is also used as a foam, mostly in sheet form as an underlay or middle layer for example in fruit bins. The following starting materials for polyurethane foam can be used: polyester with hydroxyl end groups made from adipic acid, diethylene glycol, trimethylol propane as well as polyether based on ethylene oxide and/or propylene oxide with free hydroxyl groups in combination with 2,4-toluene diisocyanate and 2,6-toluene diisocyanate. Stabilizers, dispersants and amines (as catalysts in amounts up to 1.2 YO)can be used.
2.3.4 Natural and synthetic rubber The consumption of classical elastomers in 1997 was about 16x lo6 t on what about 60 YOwas synthetic rubber: Styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR) 53 % Butadiene rubber (BR) 18 Yo Isoprene rubber (IR) 2 Yo Chloroprene rubber (CR) 3% Ethylene-propylene-dienerubber (EPDM) 8 'TO Acrylonitrile-butadiene rubber (NBR) 4% In food contact materials and articles that contain rubber only a portion of the material's surface area contacts the food and for only a short time. For this reason articles containing rubber can be divided into five categories corresponding to the intended application of the rubbercontaining materials and articles: Category I: Food contact materials and articles which according to their intended use come in contact with food for 24 hours to several months. Examples of such applications are storage containers, protective container coatings, seals with large surface areas, and sealing rings for cans, jars, bottles and similar articles. Category 2: Food contact materials and articles which according to their intended use come in contact with food for a maximum of 24 hours. Examples are hoses for pumping food, stoppers and caps for bottles, sealing rings for pressure cookers, hoses for coffee machines, lid seals for milk containers and valve balls. Category 3: Food contact materials and articles which according to their intended use come in contact with food for a maximum of 10 minutes (short time contact). Examples are shaker beakers, milking machine hoses, seals for milk processing equipment, membranes, pistons, faucets, pump rotors, roller coverings and conveyors for fatty foods as well as gloves and aprons worn when handling food. Category 4: Food contact materials and articles from which, according to their intended use conditions, no mass transfer to food could occur. Examples are conveyor belts and roller covers, suction and pressure lines for filling or emptying tanks, seals for pipes, pumps, faucets and valves for drinking water. Special category: Food contact materials and articles which are intended to be used during the consumption of food which, according to their intended use, will be put in the mouth. Examples are toys, balloons, nipples, pacifiers, teething rings, and bite protectors. Solid rubber, latexes and rubber dispersions may be used for the manufacture of food contact materials. The starting materials used for solid rubber are: Natural rubber, graft copolymers of natural rubber with acrylic or methacrylic acid esters of mono-functional C1C4 alcohols; butadiene and isoprene polymers; polymers
38
Brandsch
and polymer mixtures of mono, di and tri-chlorobutadiene including styrene or acrylonitrile (chloroprene rubber); polymer mixtures of butadiene as well as isoprene and styrene and/or acrylonitrile (nitrile rubber) and/or divinyl benzene and/or acrylic as well as methacrylic acid: polymer mixtures of isobutylene and isoprene (butyl rubber); polymer mixtures of ethylene and a-olefin with chain length C3-C4 and/or acyclic or cyclic double unsaturated monomers (ethylene-propylene-rubber);chlorosulfonated polyethylene for rubberized materials and clothing. These starting materials can be used alone and in combination with various polymers or polymer mixtures. The starting materials for solid rubber may also be used for the manufacture of latexes and rubber dispersions.
2.3.5 Silicones The term silicone, or more precisely polyorganosiloxane, is used to describe a group of plastics whose backbones are composed of an inorganic chain of alternating silicon and oxygen atoms. The silicon valences not bound to oxygen are saturated using organic groups (R):
R
I
R
l
R
l
-Si-0-Si-0-Si-0-
I R
l R
l R
With this structure the silicones occupy a special classification between the inorganic silicates and organic polymers. This structure leads to a series of very useful material characteristics which no other product group has. The numerous possible compounds with linear or crosslinked spatial structures can lead to oils, greases, rubbers or resins that are used in every conceivable technology. Uses of silicone fluids: polish additives, release agents, water-repellent applications, lubricants and greases; Uses of silicone resins: laminates, moulding compositions; Uses of silicone rubbers: car uses (sealing rings, O-rings, gaskets, ignition cables etc.), cable insulations. Diverse applications: blood transfusion tubing, antibiotic container closures, domestic refrigerators, non-adhesive rubber-covered rollers for handling different materials, potting and encapsulation, medical applications (particularly for body implants). The building blocks of the polymer are the siliconcontaining siloxane units. Their composition comes from the fact that every oxygen atom acts as a bridge between two silicon atoms and only half of the silicon atom is needed for bonding. The number of oxygen bonds determines the functionality of a siloxane unit (Table 2-3). The use of the symbols found in the table simplifies the description of the chemical composition of the macromolecule, usually polymethyl siloxane. If the siloxane methyl groups are partly or completely replaced by other groups then a corresponding symbol is used Vi = CH*=CH-,H = hydrogen). As an example like Dph2,TPh,D", MH (Ph = C~HS-, one obtains the simplified notation:
Characteristics of plastic materials
CH3
I
(CH3)3Si-O-[ -Si-01
I CH3
39
C6Hs CH3
I I [4-01 ,-Si-CH=CH2 I
CH3
: MDxDyPhMV'
I
CH3
The most important monomers (> 95 O/O by weight) for silicone synthesis are the methyl chlorosilanes. Next to them are the phenyl chlorosilanes, methyl phenyl chlorosilanes, methyltrifluoropropyl chlorosilanes, and a variety of silanes containing organic functional groups such as hydroxyl, amine, epoxy, acrylate and carboxyl which are responsible for the different products. Table 2-3: Labeling of siloxane unit structures
Unit of siloxane
Formula
Symbol
The intermediate steps leading to the formation of polydimethyl siloxanes are composed of linear and/or cyclic dimethyl siloxanes formed by hydrolysis or methanolysis of dimethyl dichlorosilane: CH3
I
n C1-Si-Cl
+ ( n + 1) H20
+
HODnOH+2nHC1
I
CH3
,, (CH3)2Si CI2 + n H 2 0 n (CH3)2Si Clz + 2 n CH30H
Dn+2nHCI
+
D,
+ 2 n CH3Cl+ n H20
The hydrochloric acid by-product can be used again for the formation of silanes. The same can happen with the methyl chloride produced by methanolysis. If the
40
Brandsch
dimethyldichlorosilane used contains residual tri- or tetrafunctional silanes or other impurities, a clean up step of the polydimethyl siloxane is conducted using a ring closing reaction with the help of alkali. The synthesis of linear polydimethyl siloxane for silicone oil and elastomers (raw materials for silicone rubber) takes place either through acid or basic ring opening and polymerisation, or through polycondensation of linear dihydroxymethyl siloxane with hydroxyl end groups. The average chain length and subsequent viscosity of silicone oil is adjusted by the addition of chain building siloxane types like MD,M, Mz or water. The branched polyorganosiloxanes present in silicone resins are manufactured in an analogous manner. The intermediates from the siloxane oligomers are the starting materials for the polycondensation reaction. The resulting product can contain OHor alkoxy groups and can be used for further processing to make siliconebased resins. These resins can be pure silicones or copolymers with polyethers. The details of silicone synthesis mentioned here show the complicated problem of assigning starting materials for these plastics which can be the object of mass transfer processes. From the analytical and toxicological viewpoints the silane monomers are completely altered during the course of the reaction by for example ring formation and alteration in the presence of alkali. The only detectable substances that can be considered are the residual low molecular weight oligomer mixtures. A listing and description of individual components is just not possible. The technically most important silicone oils are of the type MD,M. They are resistant to high temperatures up to 250 "C in the presence of air. The products containing phenyl groups are the most stable. The low temperature dependence of their viscosity makes their use at very low temperatures ( 4 0 "C) possible. Their packaging uses are usually in the form of emulsions. They function as coatings and coverings, for example as lubricants for corks and plastic casings or as anti-stick coatings for rubber stoppers and seals. The addition of thickening fillers (e.g. calcium salts or straight saturated monofunctional carboxylic acids C10-C20) to silicone oil produces greases as well as pastes. Silicone elastomers (silicone rubber) are marked by their high stability and constant mechanical properties over a wide temperature range (-50 to +200 "Cand for short times up to 300 "C). They can be manufactured using a two-component system that becomes crosslinked at room temperature (RTV 2K) or through formation of crosslinks at high temperatures (hot vulcanizable, HV). The RTV 2K elastomers are crosslinked either with polydimethyl siloxane with hydroxyl end groups in the presence of a catalyst (di-n-octyltin-dilaurate) or with polydimethyl siloxane with dimethylvinyl siloxy end groups with the help of a platinum catalyst. The crosslinking of HV products takes place between the polymethyl siloxane containing vinyl groups with the help of an organic peroxide. Platinum catalysts can also be used for crosslinking. Silicone elastomers can be used for paper coatings, nipples, teething rings, seals for baking ovens and refrigerators etc. Silicone resins can be made from pure polyorganic siloxanes with a high percentage of tri- and tetrafunctional d o x y groups, which are crosslinked in the presence of a catalyst by heating at 250 "C for a long time. They can also be made from a mixture of polyorganic siloxanes with polyesters. One differentiates resins into those for direct food contact use like lacquers for baking forms and paper coatings: and those resins for indirect food contact use like grills, warming plates and others.
Characteristics of plastic materials
41
2.3.6 Plastics based on natural polymers Regenerated cellulose The group of plastics known as regenerated celluloses forms a transition from the natural polymers to the completely synthetically produced plastics. As a converted natural product, regenerated cellulose foil (Cellophane) has formed the basis for the first transparent, flexible packaging for food and tobacco which contributed significantly to the development of the self service shops since the beginning of the 1920s. Regenerated cellulose, as its name implies, is manufactured from cellulose. The raw material is transformed to sodium-cellulose-xanthogenate (viscose) with sodium hydroxide and carbon disulfide. With this process the cellulose chains composed of over 1000 glucose units are reduced to approximately 400 units. The very viscous viscose is passed through a nozzle under pressure into a sulfuric acid bath, where it coagulates and a regeneration of cellulose takes place. The soft, regenerated cellulose is then passed through a series of baths where it is further strengthened, bleached and conditioned. During these processes plasticisers and moisturizing agents are worked into the regenerated cellulose film. In order to make the regenerated cellulose film heat sealable it is lacquered. The resulting different film types are then described according to an international standard nomenclature. With a three place number the weight to surface area ratio is given. With a combination of letters the following properties are labeled: unlacquered (P), nitrolacquered (M), PVDC lacquered (X), heat sealable (S), suitable for folding and twist wrapping (F), and high water vapor permeability (D). The glassclear, shiny and tear resistant regenerated cellulose is permeable to water vapor, but resistant to contact with fats. P-regenerated cellulose foil is used for the packaging of baked goods and dough products for short storage times, and also used for candies. The permeability of the lacquered films to water vapor, oxygen and aromas depends on the type of lacquer. X-regenerated cellulose foil is particularly impermeable. Lacquered regenerated cellulose is used for the packaging of bread and other baked goods, particularly for fatty products, for spices, nuts, dried fruits, pralines, foods with intensive odors and cigarettes. The outstanding properties of regenerated cellulose as a packaging material are its machinability and thick seal seams, because cellulose does not melt when the heat seal temperature is set too high. For economic reasons, regenerated cellulose has been replaced recently or is in serious competition with polypropylene films in many applications. Regenerated cellulose has the advantage that it biodegrades well in composting.
Biodegradable polymers Pol ysacch arides One of the industrially available natural polymers for the manufacture of biodegradable plastics materials is starch. Starch is produced and stored by various types of plants. The differing properties of various starches result from their different proportions of amylose (linear starch chains) and amylopectin (branched starch chains). The solid polymeric starch granules with their defined structures and crystallinities can be incorporated as biodegradable filler into nonbiodegradable synthetic polymers
42
Brandsch
like PE. Starch and PE mixtures can be extruded. Until now shopping bags and compost sacks have been manufactured and various application possibilities tested in the packaging area. Starch is suitable in principle for processing as a thermoplastic, Water retained in the starch can function as a plasticiser. Starch has also been used as a raw material for producing foams. By fermentation of the starch one obtains pullalane, which belongs to the polymaltoses group. The expensive material is not extrudable but rather suitable for molding processes and can be used for water soluble packaging. Polyesters Various procaryotic microorganisms can produce polyhydroxyalkanoates using regenerable carbon sources. This polymer is a storage material and can make up to 90 % of the dried cell weight. The most widely researched material in this group up till now is the poly-D(-)-3-hydroxybutyric acid (PHB). ICI has developed a fermentation process for PHB having various levels of polyhydroxyvalerate (PHV) as a copolymer. This polymer is marketed under the product name BIOPOL. The material is extrudable and can be used as bottles for packaging cosmetics. Because of the high migration rate of the triacetine plasticiser used (see Chapter 4) it is not suitable for food use. Currently efforts are being made to manufacture this material as a film. While PHB and PHV are not considered true plastics, another biodegradable polymer polycaprolactone (PCL) is a plastic material because its monomer e-caprolactone is obtained on an industrial scale from petrochemical products (cyclohexanone and peroxyacetic acid). This synthetic plastic with its low melting point is easily extrudable and applications in the packaging area are envisioned. In view of the necessity for getting waste disposal under control coupled with the limited fossil raw material resources, biodegradable polymer and in particular polymers from renewable resources will gain importance in the future. In the most sensitive application area, food contact materials and articles, it is possible initially to use these materials in very limited amounts. The easy decomposition of these packaging materials is in opposition with the inertness needed to protect packaged food. These polymers are particularly sensitive to moisture. By finishing operations such as surface treatments, one could improve the inertness of these polymers. However, the degradability would be diminished by such processes.
2.3.7 Coatings Most of the plastics discussed here could be used, not just in the manufacture of different materials and articles, but also as finishing materials in the form of coatings on other substrates. By using coatings, paper for example could be made impermeable to water or fat; tin cans protected against corrosion; kitchen articles and appliances made non-stick; etc. Whereas films, containers and other plastic materials and articles are manufactured from polymerized materials, one often uses partly polymerized mixtures as coatings. These coating mixtures are then chemically crosslinked or thermally treated to bind them to the substrate material to make the finished product. This can cause complications for
Characteristics of plastic materials
43
the study of mass transfer processes from coatings because the coating mixtures used can contain an enormous number of substances which are no longer detectable in the finished material. These substances for example can be solvents, crosslinking agents or certain starting materials. In addition the coating formulations are composed of many low molecular weight polymers whose properties have been selected for a particular application. Coated articles can also come in contact with food.
Lacquers The manufacture of lacquers with good adhesion, independent of the intended application, requires numerous chemical substances. These can be broadly divided into volatile and nonvolatile components. Solvents belong to the volatile group and binding agents and additives belong to the nonvolatile group. Binding agents are the main coating components and principal film formers. Film formation can take place using the following techniques: - Application of a solution or dispersion of macromolecular binding agent onto a substrate and evaporation of the solvent. In order to reduce the amount of organic solvent, water based solutions and dispersions are being used more frequently. - Application of the binding agent in molten form. - Film formation by chemical reaction. The physicallydried binding agents include acrylic resins, polyesters, silicones, cellulose derivatives and others. Polyamides and polyolefins are used as raw material for powder lacquers. Differing from physically dried lacquers, chemically dried lacquers contain crosslinked macromolecules. The raw materials used as binding agents can in this case be used without solvents because of their low viscosities; and react with the substrate by one of the above mentioned polymerization reactions. One can further divide lacquers according to their drying processes into oxidative drying, cold hardening, irradiation hardening and oven drying. The additives used for lacquer manufacture are composed of processing aids like hardening accelerators, flow agents, crosslinking agents and others like plasticisers, fillers and if necessary pigments. Natural products and transformed natural products can also be used as binding agents for packaging applications. These are shellac, dammar gum, dried unsaturated oils (linseed oil), rosin and hydrated esters of rosin, cellulose acetate and propionate acetate, cellulose acetobutyrate, cellulose nitrate and ethyl cellulose. The following polycondensation, polymerization and polyaddition products can be used as binding agents: Alkyd and polyester resins, epoxy compounds, phenol-formaldehyde resin, urea and/or melamine-aldehyde resin, cyclic urea resin, carbamide acid ester formaldehyde resin, ketone formaldehyde resin, polyurethane, polyvinylester, polyvinyl acetate, polyvinyl chloride and polymer mixtures, polyethylene, polystryrene, styrene mixtures and graft copolymers, polyamide, polycarbonate, polyvinyl ether, polyacrylic and methacrylic acid esters, polyvinyl flouride, polyvinylidene chloride copolymers, UV and/or electron irradiated lacquers.
44
Brandsch
Plastic dispersions A dispersion is a system consisting of two or more phases in which a material is finely distributed throughout another. Dispersions can be liquid/liquid (emulsions) or solid/liquid (suspensions). Polymer dispersions consists of an internal phase, the polymer or copolymer and an external phase, water. The consumption of polymer dispersions in 1997 was 10x106 t. The market is divided among styrene-butadien dispersions (35 YO),dispersions containing vinyl acetate (32 YO),styrene and styrene-acrylate dispersions (25 YO) and others in minor quantities. They have many applications: coatings and paints, adhesives, textile finishing, paper coatings and others. When used as coatings the dispersions should be suitable for food contact. Many substances can be used as monomers: a) Acrylic acid and methacrylic acid esters of CI-Cg mono-functional aliphatic saturated alcohols and ether alcohols (RO-(CH2),-OH). b) Vinyl esters of C1-Cg aliphatic saturated carboxylic acids. c) Vinyl chloride, vinylidene chloride. d) Acrylonitrile and methacrylonitrile. e) Ethylene, butadiene, isoprene, isobutylene, propylene, 2-chlorobutadiene, 2,3dichlorobutadiene, tetrafluoroethylene, styrene. f) Maleic acid and fumaric acid esters from C1-C8 mono-functional aliphatic saturated alcohols or C3-CI8 mono-functional aliphatic unsaturated alcohols, esters of C3C12 aliphatic carboxylic acids with C3-ClX unsaturated alcohols, esters of unsaturated dicarboxylic acid with polyethylene glycol and/or polypropylene glycol. g) Vinyl ethers of CI-Cls mono-functional aliphatic saturated alcohols. h) Acrylic acid, methacrylic acid, crotonic acid, maleic acid, fumaric acid, itaconic acid, vinyl sulfonic acid, styrene sulfonic acid, half esters of maleic and fumaric acid, itaconic acid with C1-Clg mono-functional aliphatic saturated alcohols as well as their alkali and ammonium salts, vinyl pyrolidone, amides of acrylic and methacrylic acids and N-methylolamide of acrylic and methacrylic acid as well as their ethers, N-vinylN-methylacetamide. i) Acrylic acid ester of diethylaminoethanol and/or methacrylic acid ester of dimethylaminoethanol. k) Acrylic acid and methacrylic acid esters of C2-C18 aliphatic dialcohols, divinyl and diallyl esters of C3-C18 saturated aliphatic dicarboxylic acids, vinyl and ally1 esters of acrylic acid, and crotonic acid, triallyl cyanurate. Some of these dispersions can be crosslinked by vulcanization. Microcrystalline waxes The substances discussed here are used mostly for coating, impregnation and lamination of paper packaging. They can be divided into four groups: 1. Hard paraffins having natural origins. Included in this group are mixtures of solid, pure, mostly straightchain hydrocarbons coming from oil, brown coal, and shale tar oils. The solidification temperature must lie between 43 "C and 75 "C. For liquid packages, in particular milk, this temperature may not be below 52 "C. Further conditions (kinetic viscosity, iodine color number) and purity requirements are given. In particular these materials may not contain any fluorescence-quenching substances.
Characteristics of plastic materials
45
2. Microcrystalline wax. These are mixtures of solid, purified, mainly branched, saturated microcrystalline hydrocarbons made from oil with solidification temperatures between SO and 90 "C. They must also meet specific purity requirements. 3. Synthetic hard paraffin. This includes mixtures of high molecular weight, solid, purified, mainly straightchain hydrocarbons with solidification temperatures between 92 and 105 "C. 4. Low molecular weight polypropylene with a relative molecular mass between 2500 and 6000. The abovementioned materials can be mixed with one another. A series of other polymers and resins can also be added if the substances listed in 1 to 4 form the bulk of the material. Additional materials are: PE, PP, low molecular weight polyolefins, polyterpenes (mixtures of aliphatic and cycloaliphatic hydrocarbons produced by polymerisation of terpene hydrocarbons), polyisobutylene, butyl rubber, dammar gum, glycerine and pentaerythritol esters of rosin acid and their hydration products, polyolefin resins, hydrated polycyclopentadiene resin (substance mixtures manufactured by thermal polymerization of a mixture mainly composed of di-cyclopentadiene with methylcyclopentadiene, isoprene and piperylene which is then hydrogenated). The finished products coated with substances or substance mixtures listed above may not be used as food contact materials for fats and oils or for foods containing fat in which the fat forms an external phase. Temperature resistant coatings
Fluoropolymers are used for the manufacture of coatings for frying pans, pots, fryers and other cooking equipment and utensils. Polytetrafluoroethylene with a melting point of approximately 327 "C is mostly used but polymer mixtures with perfluoroalkylvinyl ether and hexafluoropropylene can also be used. According to the intended conditions of use, these types of cooking equipment can reach temperatures of 32&340 "C for short times (< 15 min) in places not covered by food (e.g. foods like sausages, pancakes). In addition to the polymer substrate, a series of binding resins made from polyamide and polyimide, polyphenylsulfide (PPS), polyether sulfone (PES) and/or silicone resin are necessary for applying the coating. Such substances like laminating agents (lithium polysilicate, aluminum phosphate and phosphoric acid) and various additives are also used. Included in these additives are emulsifiers and further processing aids (e.g. silicone oil). Under the present state of the art technology with correctly applied sintering of the coating, the total amount of substance released during heating of the cooking item is well under 1 mg/dm2. General references Brody A L. Marsh K (ed). 1997. The Wjley Encyclopedia of Packaging Technology 2nd.Ed. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. N.Y. Brown W E, 1992. Plastics in Food Packaging: Properties. Design and Fabrication. Marcel Dekker. N.Y. Brydson J A, 1995. Plastics Materials 6"d. Ed. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford Elias H G , 1993. An Introduction to Plastics, VCH, Weinheim Franck R, Wieczorek H, (eds), 1998. Kunststoffe im Lebensmittelverkehr, Carl Heymanns Verlag KG, Koln, Berlin
Reactivity in Molecular Crystals Edited by Yuli Ohashi Copyright @ K d a o r h a Ltd .Tokyo. 1999
3 Additives for plastics and their transformation products 3.1 Additivs for plastics
Jan Pospi5l and Stanislav Neipurek
3.1.1 Introduction When considering mass transport phenomena in the plastics either used as packaging materials in contact with fresh or processed food. as bottles for drinks, cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, as greenhouse or mulching films in agriculture and various articles or as implantates in human and veterinary medicine (e.g., bags for blood transfusion and dialysis, coverings for facial or limb corrections, surgical fibers or supports, syringes), specific attention must be paid to possible transfer of residual monomers, oligomers, processing aids and additives, mostly low-molecular weight compounds. Any polymer used for the above mentioned environmentally-controlled applications, i. e. appropriate grades of high density (HDPE), low density (LDPE) and linear-low density polyethylene (L-LDPE), isotactic polypropylene (PP), poly(viny1 chloride) (PVC), poly(ethy1ene terephthalate) (PET), polyamide (PA) and polystyrene (PS) is not processable and durable without additives. Polyolefins (PO) form the largest part of the global plastics consumption for packaging applications, followed by PVC (Oxley, 1998) and PET. Scientific development of various categories of additives enabling these plastics to suit particular applications was exploited commercially under stringent legislation and environmental rules. Some additives, residues or processing aids remaining in trace amounts in the plastics, are not generally declared in commercial articles. However, the presence of additives used as stabilizers and plasticizers must be declared, and their suppliers must provide appropriate details on the regulatory status of each additive with respect to industrial hygiene, the environment and indirect contact with food. Characteristic functions and the representative structures of plastics additives providing marketable and durable materials are included in this chapter. Types of additives for plastics used in contact with food are listed in Table 3-1. Similar additives as for PS are used for elastomer-modified plastics forming multilayer systems (blends) and used rather exceptionally in contact with food, such as high-impact polystyrene (HIPS) or acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene polymer (ABS). Some of the additives, stabilizers in particular, are very reactive and are present in the plastic matrix in a chemically transformed form. 3.1.2 Nucleating agents
To achieve consistent properties and morphology of semicrystalline plastics, nucleating agents are added to trigger a heterogeneous nucleation of the plastic melt and to give crystals of regular size. Nucleation can occur on the surface of some impurities in
48
PospifiL
Table 3-1:Additives used in plastics for contact with food and related applications Additive
Polymer HDPE
LDPE L-LDPE
Nucleating agent
(+I +
Lubricant Antistatic agent
+ +
+ +
PP
+ +
+
Blowing agent
PS
+ + + +
Plasticizer Phenolic antioxidant
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+ + + + +
+ +
+ +
+ +
+ +
Dialkylhydroxylamine Benzofuranone Thioether Organic phosphite, phosphonite
PA
c
+ + +
UV absorber Heat stabilizer (organotin, metal soap) Antiacid
+ +
+ + +
+
+ +
+ +
+ +
(+I +
Organic phosphate Hindered amine stabilizer
PET PVC
+ +
+
(+)
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
Antifogging agent
+
+
Dye, pigment
+
+
+
Filler
+
+
+ + +
+ +
Dehydrating agent
+
+ +
+
+ +
+ +
+
+
+
the polymer (such as residues of polymerisation catalysts in PO, transformation products of heat stabilizers in PVC) or on fillers or reinforcing agents (Shanks and Tiganis, 1998). These provide sites for absorbing some segments of the polymer chain and forming a prerequisite for a nucleus. However, special additives controlling the process are preferred. They form either a physical gelation network within the polymer or provide single nucleation sites dispersed within the plastic mass. Sodium salts of organophosphates, salts of benzoic or phthalic acid, some organic compounds, e.g. sorbitol bis(3,4-dimethylbenzylidene diacetal) (1) or very finely ground fillers (clays, silica) are used in PP in amounts 0.1-0.3 %. Analogous agents may be used in PET or PA.
1
Additives ,for plctstics and their transformation products
49
3.1.3 Lubricants By adding lubricants, the melt rheology of plastics is affected and processing above the glass transition temperature is improved due to the decrease of external friction (lubricants applied to the outer surface of the polymer melt ensure the additives are effective on plasticsiprocessing equipment interfaces) and internal friction (lubricants added into the polymer mass ensure the compounds are effective on macromolecule/ macromolecule interfaces and improve polymeric chain movements). This is due to the lowering of the melt viscosity by readily soluble “inner” lubricants in the plastic. Only slightly soluble lubricants improve melt viscosity to some extent but effectively form a film on the plastics melt and processing equipment “outer” lubricants). Moreover, the danger of thermo-mechanical degradation (melt fracture) is reduced by plasticizers; components in multiphase systems (i.e., polymer/pigment, stabilizer, filler or impact modifier) are better dispersed; and finished articles have smoother surfaces due to the mold-release and slip effects of lubricants (Riedel, 1990). Typical lubricants are fatty alcohols CI2-C22. fatty acids CI4-C18, their esters with fatty alcohols, glycerol or pentaerythritol, amides (2) or diamides (3) and metallic soaps (see “Heat stabilizers”), acids C2,&31 from montan wax and their esters, diesters of phthalic acid (4b),paraffin wax C20-C7”, PE waxes C125-C700or their oxidized (polar) grades containing hydroxyl and carbonyl groups. The solubility of lubricants in polymers is managed by the old rule simili similia solvuntur: e.g., the non-polar additives (waxes) are readily soluble in polyolefins. On the contrary, fatty acids and their esters are not and function as outer lubricants that may come more easily in contact with food than the inner lubricants. The solubility or compatibility of lubricants such as 2 or 3 is temperature dependent. Some fine particle fillers, such as silica gel or chalk, called as antiblocking agents, can also be classified as external lubricants. They make the separation of rolled films easier. 0
0 I
12
3
2
0
4
1
50
Pospiiii
Lubricants are used in rigid PVC (PVC-U) in amounts 0.3-0.8 Yo (metallic soaps acting primarily as heat stabilizers are used at levels up to 1.5 YO).In polyolefins, calcium or zinc stearates used as antiacids provide the lubricating effect at 0.1 to 0.2 Yo. Fluoropolymers are used specifically for L-LDPE.
3.1.4 Antistatic agents Ionogenic and non-ionogenic additives reducing the chargeability of plastics are applied either from solutions on the plastics surface (“external” antistatics) or mixed into the plastics mass during processing (“internal” antistatics). A conducting layer is formed on the surface of the plastic. The antistatic protection is made possible due to dissipation of electrons on the polymer surface (Pfahler, 1990). Hydrophobic parts of the molecule of antistatic agents are considered to be fixed to the macromolecule and separate it from direct contact with air humidity. The hydrophilic part of the antistatic agent enables adsorption of humidity, increases conductivity of the surface and helps to prevent electrostatic build-up. This eliminates spark discharges capable of igniting flammable gases, and prevents dust deposits at plastics surfaces. In packaging applications, antistats are of great importance for flexible packagings as well as for containers (e.g. aerosol cans). Typical ionic agents that arc used as external antistats are cation-active [quaternary ammonium, phosphonium or sulfonium salts, e.g. (3-dodecanoylamidopropyl) trimethylammonium methylsulfate (S)]and anion-active [e.g. alkylsulfonate (6)or salts of alkylated benzenesulfonic acid]. Non-ionic agents [such as poly(ethy1ene glycol)monoethers (7) or ethoxylated fatty alkylamines] are used as internal antistats. Their molecular structure plays an important role in terms of their compatibility with the plastics and migration rate to the polymer surface. O n one side, their solubility in the plastic may not be good, giving a tendency for them to migrate to the surface. On the other side, solubility must not be too low, or blooming accelerates. The solubility of external antistats plays no role in their activity mechanism. Therefore, various hygroscopic compounds such as polyols [glycerine, poly(ethy1ene glycols)] can be used. Ionic antistats are the choice for polar plastics (PVC) and for PS. Non-ionic antistats are excellent for application in PO. Application of internal antistats is limited in plastics processed at high temperatures, typically for some engineering polymers (due to the thermolysis of antistats), or in cases when a decreased transparency is an undesirable consequence (e.g. in PET). Concentration of antistats in plastics is mostly 0.1 to 2 YO.Special grades of electroconducting (EC) carbon black are used in PO at levels higher than 10 YO(Accorsi and Yu, 1998). Other conducting fillers incorporating antistatic effects, such as metals or organic semiconductors (e.g. polypyrrole) are not commonly used in plastics for contact with food.
Additives fiir plastics otld their transformntion products
r
I
0 II
51
1
1
(CH~)~N+(CH~)~NHCCI 1H23 C H j O S O i 5
0I
0 = SOC,,H2,
b
Na’
H0[(CH2h01 8C12H25
7
3.1.5 Blowing agents Some expanded PVC or PS packaging materials and other articles are widely used in the catering industry. Various chemical blowing agents, generating inert gases, are used (Hurnik, 1990), e.g. 2,2’-azobis(isobutyronitrile), p-toluenesulfonylhydrazide, p-toluenesulfonylsemicarbazide or diisopropylhydrazodicarboxylate. Rather lowmolecular-weight and migrating transformation products of these additives remain in the final expanded polymer matrix.
3.1.6 Plasticizers Additives can gel the polymer and improve processibility and flexibility or stretchability of plastics by decreasing their melt viscosity, glass transition temperature and modulus of elasticity without alteration of the chemical character of the polymer. These are listed among external plasticizers (in rubber applications these additives are called extenders or processing oils). They are extractable to some extent into the environment. Although their toxicity is very low, aspects of toxicology during oral, dermal or intraperitonal exposures have been regularly tested (Meier, 1990). PVC and other chlorinated polymers are the principal application fields for plasticizers. Plasticizers are generally differentiated as external and internal. The former are bound to the plastics macromolecule as a solvent, by physical (van der Waals) forces. The amount of adsorbed plasticizers is almost unlimited. However, even small amounts of most plasticizers have noticeable effects in plastics. The advantages of external plasticizers consist in the wide variations of both the amounts than can be used and the properties of the bound substances. The role of diffusion and volatility of external plasticizers increases rapidly with temperature. Some thermo-oxidation and thermolysis of plasticizers may also result. From the point of view of the danger of extractability, the relatively low-molecular-
52
PospiSiI
weight external plasticizers used at high concentration levels in polymers become the most problematic additives in plastics. High-molecular-weight external plasticizers with limited migration rates are therefore always preferred. Various organic plasticizers having boiling points over 300 “C are available, such as di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (4a), di(2-ethylhexyl) adipate (S), oligomers formed from dicarboxylic acids and diols with molecular weights ranging up to 3500, esters of trimellitic acid, epoxidised fatty acids or organic phosphates, such as tris(2-ethylhexyl) phosphate (9) or (2-ethylhexyl) diphenyl phosphate (10).Most phosphates also function as flame retardants and some, such as 10, are smoke suppressants as well (Meier, 1990). Phthalates, 4a in particular, are certainly the most frequently applied plasticizers. Esters of dicarboxylic acids, such as 8 impart very good flexibility at lower temperatures. Aliphatic oligomeric esters are excellent fat-resistant plasticizers. Epoxidized plasticizers provide some co-stabilizing effect to heat stabilizers in PVC and improve oil and water resistance. Plasticizers used in elastomers are generally classified as extenders. High-molecular-weight or chlorinated hydrocarbons are used for this purpose.
8
9
10
Due to high application levels of plasticizers, their behavior with respect to environmental influences (weathering resistance) and impact on the polymer matrix (effect on optical properties or plastics lifetime) have to be tested. The plasticizer content in the plastics plays a key role in the evaluation of food contact materials and articles. As long as the danger exists that the plasticizer can transfer to food, the application in plastics is fundamentally undesirable. Therefore, according to the B G A recommendations, which are similar to those found in many countries, the application of external plasticizers is generally limited to the following applications: conveyor belts, tubes or hoses for liquid foods, coatings, seals and sealants, lacquers and pigments. A total plasticizer content of 35 YOmay not be exceeded in films, coatings and tubes made from soft PVC, vinyl chloride based copolymers, and chlorinated PE based blends with PVC. These materials and articles should not come into contact with food in the form of powder or fine particles having a size below 3 mm, foods containing fat, waxed or paraffin coated foods, milk and milk products including cheeses and foods containing alcohol or essential oils. The same high standards are set for the application of articles from plasticized PVC in medicine and cosmetics. Soft PVC films with high oxygen permeability for packing fresh meat may not contain phthalates and phosphates and the total amount of plasticizers may not exceed 22 YO. Some plasticizers used at low levels (up to 15 YO)can increase brittleness, as a consequence of increased orientation of the plastic and formation of crystalline regions. This “antiplasticizing” effect may be overcome by increasing the amount of the plasticizer that dissolves the crystallites. Specific attention has to be paid to the application of plasticizers for chlorinated rubber used as a coating for drinking water containers. No plasticizer should be extracted by water.
Additives fiw plastics and their transformation products
53
Internal plasticizers are synthesized by copolymerization of suitable monomers. Polymeric non-extractable plasticizers, mostly copolymers having substantially lower glass transition temperatures due to the presence of plasticizing (“soft”) segments such as poly(ethy1ene-co-vinyl acetate) with approximately 45 % vinylacetate content, ethylene-vinyl acetate-carbon monooxide terpolymer, or chlorinated PE, are available for rather special applications in medicinal articles (Meier, 1990). In this case, the performance of the internally plasticized polymers is the principal advantage. However, copolymerization may account for worse mechanical properties. A combination with external plasticizers may provide an optimal balance of properties. For example, food contact products made from poly(viny1idene chloride) should have at most a citrate or sebacate ester based plasticizers content of 5 % and at most 10 YOpolymeric plasticizers.
3.1.7 Stabilizers Plastics suffer from various forms of degradation during processing, storage and application. These are triggered by combined attacks of chemical deteriogens (oxygen and its active forms, atmospheric pollutants such as NO, or SOz), harmful physical effects of tropospheric solar and high-energy radiations, heat and mechanical stress. The relevant degradation processes are classified as melt (processing) degradation, thermal degradation, long-term heat aging (thermal oxidation) and weathering (including photo-oxidation). Some of the processes are catalyzed by traces of metals. Mechanisms for individual degradation processes of plastics have been explained in detail. Physical and chemical deteriogens attack plastics under real conditions either in concerted or consecutive processes. Plastics are rather different as far as their inherent sensitivity to degradation is concerned. Differences in sensitivity are due to their chemical structure, i.e. presence of characteristic degradation-sensitive moieties in polymer construction units, defect structures (structural inhomogeneities) present in unpredictable amounts and/or formed as a consequence of adventitious oxidation during manufacture, storage and shipping, and sensitizing degradation during processing and subsequent application. The progressive degradation is catalyzed or sensitized by non-polymeric impurities, such as various metal contaminants (including residues of polymerization catalysts) or photoactive dyes or pigments (PospiSil et al., 1997). The level of structural inhomogeneities sensitizing the degradation of plastics increases gradually during the polymer lifetime. Chain scission, branching or crosslinking and the formation of new functional groups, such as olefinic unsaturation C=C and polymer-bound oxygenated groups (hydroxyl, carbonyl, carboxyl) are chemical consequences of degradation. They are accompanied by changes in the polymer appearance (discoloration, loss of gloss or transparency, formation of surface cracks) and undesirable changes in mechanical properties (elongation, tensile and impact strengths). Plastics have to be stabilized to withstand chemical and physical stresses during different phases of their lifetime. Stabilizers protecting plastics against particular degradation processes were developed and commercialized by various companies. According to their principal activity mechanisms, polymer stabilizers are conventionally classified as antioxidants, photoantioxidants, photostabilizers, heat stabilizers and
antiacids (PospiSil and Klemchuk, 1990). Other important stabilizers, such as metal deactivators, antiozonants, fire retardants and biostabilizers are not used in plastics for contact with food and related applications. Molecular architecture, including functional moieties determining the stabilization mechanism, and structural modifications (such as steric and polar effects of substituents) optimising the activity of functional moieties are the principal factors governing the long-term inherent chemical activity of stabilizers. Structural modifications optimising physical relations between the stabilizer and the polymer matrix (solubility, migration behavior, compatibility with the polymer matrix) and assuring physical persistence (resistance to volatilization and leaching into contact environments) by increasing the molecular weight of stabilizers or hindering blooming (diffusion of stabilizers out of the polymer bulk and formation of deposits on the polymer surface) by a proper balance between physical persistence and stability, provide a better longterm exploitation of the inherent chemical efficiency. Relations between the stabilizer structure and its integral efficiency were determined for all principal classes of stabilizers used either as single additives or, more frequently, as physical mixtures optimising the final integral effect and reducing the levels of stabilizers necessary for practical protection (PospiSil, 1990a). Combinations of two or more stabilizers are necessary to protect the polymer against the attacking complex of deteriogens. Additives protecting polymers by different activity mechanisms are combined in stabilizer blends (PospiSil, 1990a). Stabilizers characteristic of plastics are briefly outlined together with examples of typical structures. The market offers many stabilizers under different trade names, but having identical chemical structures (Appendix 111). Antioxidants
Antioxidants are added to oxidizing polymers to prolong their useful lifetime (PospiSil, 1990~;PospiSil and NeSphrek, in press). Polymers are oxidized either in purely thermal processes or processes triggered by solar UV radiation in the range 300-400 nm. The simplified mechanism of oxidation of polymers (PH) induced thermally, mechanochemically, catalytically or by radiation (Reaction scheme 3-1)indicates formation of macroradicals P' , Eq.(3-l),their oxidation to alkylperoxyls POW, Eq.(32), generation of hydroperoxides POOH by chain propagation, Eq. (3-3),homolysis of POOH accounting for alkoxy radicals P O , Eq. (3-4).The latter are a source of carbony1 compounds K O formed by p-scission Eq. (3-5). PH
A ,shear ,hv ,M""
(3-1)
3P
-+ P O 0 P O 0 PH + POOH p'+ 0 2
POOH
Po-
A ,hv ,M"+
A hv
>co
Reaction scheme 3-1
PO'
(3-2) (3-3)
+H O
(3-4) (3-5)
Additives for plasrics and their transformation products
55
Two principal classes of antioxidant are effective in thermal oxidation. Chainbreaking or primary antioxidants limit the rate of the chain propagation steps (Eqs. 32 and 3-3) by trapping carbon- or oxygen-centered free radicals. Hydroperoxide decomposing or secondary antioxidants prevent chain initiation by interfering with ROOH. Photoantioxidants protect plastics exposed to photo-oxidation. Chain-breaking antioxidants Hindered phenols and dialkylhydroxylamines protect plastics against thermal oxidation. Alkylated benzo[b]furane-2(3H)-ones was introduced very recently as a processing stabilizer for polyolefins. Hindered phenols are used preferentially for processing and long-term heat aging of PO where their very low-discoloring properties are advantageous (PospiSil, 1998; Zweifel, 1998; PospiSil, 1993). Phenolic antioxidants are effective also for thermal stabilization of styrene-based polymers. Low amounts are used in PET and aliphatic PA. Common concentrations in plastics range between 0.025 and 0.3 %. Phenols may be used as single stabilizers. Their efficiency is, however, very effectively improved in combinations with either organic compounds of trivalent phosphorus and benzofuranone (in melt stabilization of PO), or activated sulfides and some hindered amine stabilizers (HAS, in long-term heat stabilization), or HAS and UV absorbers (in PO weathering/photostabilization) (PospiSil, 1990a; PospiSil, 1993). Some disadvantages of phenolic antioxidants should be mentioned: low discoloration due t o some phenol transformation products; decrease of activity above 150 "C and in photo-induced processes; and depletion by oxidizing atmospheric pollutants (gas-fading by NO,) or ions of transition metals. Phenolic antioxidants scavenge P O 0 radicals according to Eq. (3-6).
+
Subst.
POO'
-
POOH
+
(3-6)
Subst.
I
POO'
~
Products
The effective but volatile 2,6-di-terr.butyl-4-methylphenol (11) was replaced for most applications by various mononuclear (12). binuclear (13), trinuclear (14) and tetranuclear phenols (15,16). Recently, synthetic DL-a-tocopherol (17) was introduced for effective melt stabilization of PO. This antioxidant may be listed among the stabilizers generally recognised as safe (GRAS). Di(octadecy1)hydroxylamine (18) (Seltzer et al., 1989; PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1997) was recently introduced commercially for the stabilization of PO, PP in particular. 18 is a hydrolysis-resistant processing stabilizer used in combination with aromatic phosphites, and a long-term heat stabilizer used in combination with suitable HAS. Dialkylhydroxylamine is considered as scavenger of radicals P O 0 and P: The latter are trapped by nitroxide or nitrone, arising from the parent hydroxylamine (Eq. 3-7).
(CH2)2C0C18H37
b
11
%f
12
OH
R
R=-CH2
CH CC
COCH2-
G
0 OH
14
16
15
17
19
R2NOH
POO'
Additives for plustics and their trunsfortnutiori prodiicts
R2NO'
RCH \ f--f
R/
N+O-
R*
57
Products
Products Hydroxylamine 18 is used in concentrations 0.04-0.06 % (Seltzer et al., 1989) and may potentially replace part of the phenolic antioxidants in applications where discoloration due to antioxidant transformation products is extremely restricting. Alkylated benzo[b]furan-2(3H)-ones (19) is another non-traditional stabilizer introduced very recently (PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1997; Irganox, 1997) for high-temperature melt stabilization of PO. It provides an outstanding color maintenance and is used in amounts of 0.01-0.02 % in stabilizer blends consisting of hindered phenols (such as 12, 14, 16) and aromatic phosphites (total amount of the stabilizer blend is approximately 0.1 %) (Irganox, 1997). Most probably, stabilizer 19 is able to scavenge both radicals P O 0 and P: the latter by recombination with a carbon-centered radical generated from 19. Hydroperoxide decomposing antioxidants Alkylhydroperoxides arising according to Eq. (3-3)act as thermo- and photoinitiators in plastics degradation. Additives reducing POOH to alcohols compete with homolysis according to Eq. (3-4) and, consequently, chain initiation and transfer (PospiSil, 1990c; PospiSil and NeSpurek, in press). Activated organic compounds of sulfur and trivalent phosphorus are used as hydroperoxide decomposing antioxidants in plastics. Sulfur containing stabilizers, such as dialkyl thiodipropionates (20, R=CI2-C18) or dioctadecyldisulfides (21) are classified as thiosynergists and are used in combination with phenolic antioxidants in long-term heat stabilization of PP (PospiSil, 1990a; Zweifel, 1998). Thiosynergists are conventionally used in excess to phenolics (the ratio is 1:3-5), the total concentration of the stabilizer combination is usually not greater than 0.75 Yo.
20
21
Organic compounds of trivalent phosphorus are excellent processing stabilizers for PO and are commonly used in combinations with phenolic antioxidants (PospiSil and NeSpurek, in press; Zweifel, 1998). They reduce phenol consumption during melt processing of P O and improve the color of final products, stabilize PET by chelating transition metals from residues of polymerization catalysts and stabilize PVC by deactivating labile chlorine atoms and acting as co-stabilizers with metal soaps and organotin stabilizers. The activity of organophosphorus compounds is structure dependent. Aliphatic phosphites, such as tris(dodecy1) phosphite (22) or mixed aliphatic-aromatic phosphites, e.g., compounds 23 and 24 are used in PVC (Andreas, 1990). Aromatic phosphite 25, cyclic phosphites 26-28 and phosphonite 29 are effective in PO (Zwei-
fel, 1998; Bauer et al., 1997). Phosphites 22 and 25 are used also in PET. Application levels of phosphites are between 0.05 and 0.3 YOin PO, PS or PET. A higher concentration, up to 1 YO,may be used in PVC.
22
24
23
25
= C18H37
26
27
28
29
Additives f o r plnstics and their trnnsforniution products
59
Photoantioxidants This class of additives includes chain-breakers or hydroperoxide decomposers effective under photo-oxidation conditions. Some of them are active also in y-irradiated PO. The selection of suitable additives for plastics in contact with food is limited. Conventional phenolic antioxidants, such as 11 to 16 suffer generally from sensitivity to photolysis and a rather low activity in the photo-oxidation process characteristic of short kinetic chains (PospiSil, 1993). Photostable hydroperoxide decomposers, i.e. nickel(I1) thiolates such as dialkyldithiocarbamates or dialkyldithiophosphates should be eliminated from food-contact applications. The photoantioxidant problem is solved by HAS (PospiSil and NeSpurek, in press; PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1997; PospiSil, 1995). Recent optimisation of their inherent chemical efficiency and physical persistence, including resistance to acid environment, and application of blends of HAS differing in molecular weight (Kramer. 1996) increased substantially application of HAS in plastics. They are effective as long-term heat stabilizers and photoantioxidants. They act, moreover, as stabilizers in y-ray sterilized items. The mechanism of HAS (represented as >NR, where R is alkyl or H) includes deactivation of hydroperoxides in the first step resulting via some intermediates in the respective nitroxide > N O (Eq. 3-8). The nitroxide >NO' is prone to scavenge alkyl radicals P'accounting for 0-alkylhydroxylamine >NOP (Eq. 3-9). The latter scavenges P O 0 radicals and regenerates by this way nitroxides (Eq. 3-10). The simplified Reaction scheme 3-2 explains the high efficiency of HAS, including reactivity with free radicals and regeneration of the nitroxide (Eq. 3-10) (PospiSil, 1995). >NR
-
>NO'>NOP-
POOH p'
PO0
>NO'
(3-8)
>NOP
(3-9)
>NO'
(3-10)
Reaction scheme 3-2.
Most of the commercialized HAS contain 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine moiety. A piperazinone moiety is exceptional in commercialized HAS. Hindered secondary >NH and tertiary >NR (R is mostly methyl) amino groups, 0-alkylhydroxylamine groups >NOR or acylamido groups >NCOCH3 are functional moieties assuring high efficacy of HAS. Effective mononuclear (30), binuclear (31, R=H, CH3, 0-i-C8HI7) or 32, high-molecular-weight polynuclear (33) and oligomeric HAS (34-36) are used as examples of commercialized stabilizers. The optimum effectiveness in plastics protection has been obtained in cooperative combinations of HAS with phenolic antioxidants, dialkylhydroxylamines, organic phosphites and/or UV absorbers. Common concentrations of HAS in plastics range generally from 0.1 to 1 % (Gugumus, 1990). Very impressive results were obtained using combinations of two HAS, such as 33/35,34/31 (R=H) or 34/35 (Kramer, 1996). Applying of combinations of secondary or tertiary HAS with sulfur-containing stabilizers should be avoided due to potential antagonistic effects (PospiSil, 1990a; PospiSil, 1995). HAS containing 0-alkylhydroxylamine or acylamide moieties are more resistant to acids.
60
PospiSiI
0
30
HN
N-CH
32
33
n
R=-NH-t-C,H,,
, -N
0
U
34
36
Additives for plastics and their transformation products
61
UV absorbers Aliphatic commodity polymers do not strongly absorb the actinic part (300-400 nm) of terrestrial sunlight. The situation is dramatically changed, however, in the presence of trace amounts of polymer-bound UV light-absorbing impurities, such as alkylhydroperoxides or carbonyl compounds (internal chromophores) arising in the polymer matrix according to Eqs. (3-3) and (3-5) respectively, or non-polymeric photosensitizing impurities, such as some ions of transition metals or pigments and dyes (admixed chromophores) (PospiSil et al., 1997). Trace amounts of the impurities are prone to trigger photodegradation during atmospheric aging. Chromophores (Ch) are transformed after absorption of the actinic solar radiation in excited singlet ('Ch*) and triplet (7Ch") states (Rabek, 1996) (Eq. 3-11). Excited chromophores sensitize the formation of macroalkyls from the matrix polymer (Eq. 3-12a) and singlet oxygen from the ground state oxygen (Eq. 3-12b); and accelerate homolysis of POOH via an exciplex (Eq. 3-12c), Reaction scheme 3-3. Ch
hv
*
'Ch
3Ch*
P
Ch + P '
(3-11)
(3-12a)
Reaction scheme 3-3.
The application of photostabilizers interfering with the harmful effects of solar radiation is mandatory to protect plastics in outdoor exposure. In some applications, such as mulching films in agriculture or handbags in supermarkets, the light-screening effect of carbon black used at 3 % level is exploited (Accorsi and Yu, 1998). Quenchers, photostabilizers able to take over the energy from the excited chromophores and singlet oxygen and dispose of it effectively as heat or fluorescent or phosphorescent radiations, cannot be used in plastics for food contact due to ecological objections (all of them contain nickel in their molecules. The application of UV absorbers, i.e. compounds absorbing the harmful solar radiation, represents an effective solution of the problem (Rabek, 1990). The absorbed radiation is deactivated by intramolecular radiative and radiationless processes. The ideal UV absorber is expected to absorb all terrestrial UV-A and UV-B radiation but no radiation having wavelengths higher than 400 nm. Different classes of commercialized UV absorbers fulfil requirements on effective plastics protection. A group of UV absorbers acting by excited state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT) mechanism (PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1997) includes phenolic derivatives of benzophenone (37), various benzotriazoles, such as 38 or 39, and 1,3,5-triazine 40.Non-phenolic UV absorbers are represented by oxamide 41 and a-cyanoacrylate 42.
62
Pospifil
38
37
40
39
41
42
Relatively high concentration levels of UV absorbers, 0.25-0.5 %, are used in plastics containing conventional basic stabilization (i.e. a combination of a phenolic antioxidant, organic phosphite and calcium stearate) (Gugumus, 1990). Combinations of UV absorbers with HAS are beneficial in pigmented polyolefins. Heat stabilizers
This category of stabilizers is principally for PVC due to its very low thermal stability (Andreas, 1990) and plays an important role also in PET (Karayannidis et al., 1998). PVC suffers from dehydrochlorination during molding or extrusion. The process produces isolated double bonds C=C. Gradually, light-absorbing conjugated sequences of double bonds are formed (Eq. 3-13). As a consequence, thermally aged PVC is deeply discolored.
Heat stabilizers protect PVC during processing and applications under heat exposition (PospiSil, 1990~).Typical heat stabilizers consist of barium, calcium or zinc soaps of fatty acids (43, R=CL1-Cl7,M=Ba, Ca, Zn; binary salts Ba/Zn or Ca/Zn are mostly used) and various organotin compounds, e.g. dibutyltin maleate (44)or dioctyltin bis(iso-octylthioglycolate) (45) (PospiSil, 1990~).
Additives for plactics and their transformatimi product\
63
0 I
0 11 (RC0)2M2+
0
0-C-CH (C4H9)2S
1 I
/I
(CsHl7)2Sn(SCH2CO-~€BH17)2
0-C-CH
0 43
44
45
Concentration levels of heat stabilizers in various PVC products are in the range 1.5-3.0 % for metal soaps and 0.3-2.5 % for organotin stabilizers (Pospiiil, 1990~). Aliphatic (22) or mixed aliphatic/aromatic phosphites (23, 24) are used together with polyols (e.g., pentaerythritol o r sorbitol) and acid scavengers as co-stabilizers in PVC (PospiSil, 1990c). PET degrades thermally during processing at 280-300 "C. The chain scission is catalyzed by transesterification catalysts (zinc, manganese or cobalt acetates, alkyl titanates). PET is stabilized by tributyl phosphate (46)or triphenyl phosphate (47), considered as heat stabilizers and metal deactivators (Karayannidis et al., 1998).
46
47
Besides heat stabilizers, commercial PET is doped with an antioxidant combination of hindered phenols with aliphatic or aromatic phosphites and, in some cases, by a dehydrating agent.
A ntiacids Acid scavengers (antiacids) form an important component of the base additive system for PO (Thiirmer, 1998) and function also in other polymers (PVC, PA, PET). They play an important role in melt viscosity retention during processing and in longterm heat stability of the final articles. They contribute significantly to the overall performance of the stabilizer combinations (Zweifel, 1998; Andreas,1990; Thurmer, 1998). Antiacids include calcium or zinc salts of weak organic acids [e.g, stearic (43, M=Ca, Zn, R=C17H35)or lactic] and inorganic acids (calcium carbonate), epoxidized oils (soybean, linseed, sunflower) or esters of oleic acid, e.g. 48, and some fillers, such as synthetic hydrotalcite (49, mostly coated with sodium stearate). They neutralize acids arising from residues of Ziegler-Natta catalysts in PO (King and Kuell, 1995) or from thermodegradation of PVC. Additionally, they reduce shear damage during extrusion due to their complementary lubricating effect (this behavior is characteristic of calcium stearate). They also exhibit a weak nucleation effect and protect HAS from deactivation by acid deposits (characteristic of pesticide vapors attacking greenhouse films). A very specific complementary mechanism is characteristic of calcium stearoyl-2-lactylate (chelation of residual trace amounts of titanium and aluminium catalysts in PO) and micronized zinc oxide (a white pigment having UV light absorbing properties). Very beneficial complementary effects are imparted in blends of antiacids consisting of hydrotalcite, zinc oxide and calcium stearate.
Dehydrating agent
PET undergoes acid-catalyzed hydrolytic degradation during melt processing. The humidity must be kept below 0.005 %, which may be achieved by the addition of bis(2,6-di-tert.butylphenylcarbodiimide) (50) (Karayannidis, 1998).
3.1.8 Antifogging agents The visual appearance, clarity in particular, of packed products with high water content (vegetables, fruits, various cheeses, fresh meat) in packaging can be impaired by fogging caused by condensation of water as small droplets on the inside surface of the plastic film. In applications where perforated films with effective water vapor transmission are undesirable, antifogging agents with the properties of surface active substances, such as poly(oxyethy1ene)sorbitan monooleate are effectively used.
3.1.9 Dyes and pigments These additives are used to impart color, either for market appeal or functional demands. Dyes have many different structures (derivatives of anthraquinone, quinophthalone, perinone, methine, azine, furanone) and are solubilized in the polymer matrix. In contrast, pigments are essentially polymer insoluble, non-migrating additives (Rabek, 1990; Allen, 1989). Colorants may be either mixed into the polymer mass or applied as printing inks for printing films on plastics surfaces. Some processing aids such as dispersants, binding agents or solvents have to be used together with colorants. Acrylic, alkyd, polyester or melamine resins are used as binding agents. Ethyl acetate, ethylalcohol, isopropylalcohol, methyl ethyl ketone or toluene are common organic solvents for printing inks. Inorganic pigments, such as titanium dioxide, zinc oxide or carbon black act as efficient light screens and thus protect plastics against photodegradation (Accorsi and Yu, 1998; Rabek, 1990; Allen, 1989). Colored iron oxides and organic pigments, such
Additives for plastics and their transformation products
65
as various azo compounds or metal phthalocyanines, act primarily as colorants. Colored pigments based on cadmium and lead are no longer used as colorants for food packaging, in spite of their exceptional colors, because of their toxicity. Surface adsorption of migrating stabilizers on carbon black has to be taken into account when considering transport processes in plastics. To improve whiteness or brightness of finished articles from thermoplastics, fluorescent whitening agents (optical brighteners) may be added. The additives absorb UV light (having wavelengths lower than 400 nm) and re-emit it as a visible blue or violet light (Berger, 1990). Derivatives of benzoxazole, phenylcumarine or stilbene are mostly used.
3.1.10 Fillers and reinforcing agents Fillers are mostly powdered inorganic additives, such as calcium carbonate, talc (hydrated magnesium silicate), kaolin (hydrated aluminium silicate), mica (complex potassium/aluminium silicate) or silica (silicon dioxide), used to increase bulk and improve mechanical (impact resistance) and physical (heat and flame resistance) properties of plastics (Schlumpf, 1990). Glass, carbon and polyester fibers are used as specific reinforcing additives in the manufacture of large rigid containers. Particular fillers are mostly coated to improve surface properties and compatibility with the polymer matrix. Polarity of fillers and their surface properties result in adsorption of some migrating additives, such as HAS on acid fillers or acid products arising from sulfur-containing hydroperoxide-decomposing antioxidants, or heat stabilizers on basic fillers. This influences the transport processes of additives in plastics.
3.2 Transformation products of plastics stabilizers
Jan PospiSil, Stanislav Neipurek and Hans Zweifel 3.2.1 Introduction An adequate protection of plastics against attacks by hostile environments is mandatory. Examples of stabilizers protecting polymers against thermomechanical, thermal, thermooxidative and photochemical degradation are outlined in the preceding section. All commercial stabilizers are chemically more reactive compounds than the protected polymer matrix (PospiSil, 1991; PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1997). As a consequence, the stabilization process proceeds at the expense of a particular stabilizer and is regarded as sacrificial stabilizer consumption. Stabilizers are chemically transformed during the deactivation of polymer-borne free-radical intermediates (alkyls, alkoxyls, alkylperoxyls, acylperoxyls) participating in initiation or propagation steps of the chain degradation. This may be by oxidation with hydroperoxides or singlet oxygen or as a consequence of deactivation of the harmful solar radiation or excited chromophores. The sacrificial consumption of the original structure of the stabilizer
66
P0spi.N
begins during polymer processing and continues during thermal aging or weathering. The consumption is preferential at randomly distributed sites which have a high concentration of oxidizing species (Billingham, 1989; White and Rapoport, 1994) and in polymer surface layers. The stabilizers remain in the undamaged zones of the polymer bulk. Besides the sacrificial consumption, the stabilizers are depleted by oxidation or chelation with metal impurities (including residues of polymerization catalysts), by oxidizing atmospheric pollutants (nitrogen oxides in particular), by sensitized photolysis and, in some particular cases, by acid environments (PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1997; PospiSil, 1981; PospiSil, 1993). New structures arising from inactive consumption (depletion) of stabilizers are mostly identical with those of sacrificial processes. The consumption of stabilizers results ultimately in the reduction of the effective concentration of stabilizers to a level unable to protect the degrading polymer against loss of serviceable properties. New compounds formed from the original stabilizer accumulate gradually in the polymer matrix. They have different structures and sometimes very different molecular weights from the parent compounds. Some transformation products discolor polymers due to their ability to absorb visible light. Extensive product studies were performed, deciphering chemical reactions of some stabilizers [phenolic antioxidants and phenolic moieties containing UV absorbers, sulfur- and phosphorus-containing antioxidants, hindered amine stabilizers (HAS) and heat stabilizers for poly(viny1 chloride) (PVC)] in degrading polymers and describing the structure of the principal transformation products (PospiSil, 1991; PospiSil, 1993; PospiSil, 1980; PospiSil, 1995; PospiSil et al., 1996; Andreas, 1990). The problem is connected with rather difficult analyses of extracts from aged plastics and syntheses of model compounds to enable identification of the transformation products. Typical structures of transformation products of stabilizers are outlined in this chapter.
3.2.2 Cyclohexadienones and quinone methides from phenolic antioxidants and UV absorbers Hindered phenols 11 to 16 are used as melt stabilizers and antioxidants in thermal aging and (in combination with photostabiljzers) in weathering of plastics. The chainbreaking process (Eq. 3-6) is based on hydrogen transfer from the phenolic hydroxy group to alkylperoxyl derived from the oxidizing polymer (PospiSil, 1993; PospiSil, 1980). Phenoxyls, such as 51 derived from the simplest antioxidant 11, are primary free-radical intermediates arising from mono- or polynuclear phenols and are precursors of all isolated transformation products (PospiSil, 1991; PospiSil, 1993; PospiSil, 1980; PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1995). Phenoxyls react in mesomeric cyclohexadienonyl forms (e.g., 52 and 53) and are able to rearrange to substituted phenolic benzyl radicals 54 (Eq. 3-14). Free radicals 51-54 are short-lived species. Only the oxygen-centered form (i.e. 51) may be detected in the polymer matrix by electron spin resonance spectroscopy. Phenoxyls (and their mesomeric forms) participate in autorecombination (coupling) processes, recombination with alkylperoxyls and disproportionation reactions. The transformation of individual nuclei in polynuclear phenols proceeds independently. This accounts for a rather complicated mixture of products. Recombination reactions are influenced by steric effects of substituents. Fully hindered phenols (containing tertiary alkyls in both ortho positions to the phenolic hydroxy group, such as in 11,l2,14 and 16) are
+
Additives for plastics arid their transformation products
51
67
53
(3-14)
'CHp 54 prone to react in the less hindered para position. Partially hindered phenols, such as 13, contain two formally reactive positions, ortho and para. Cryptophenoll5 having the para substituent bound to the nucleus with quaternary carbon atom and one free ortho position, is able to recombine exclusively in position two. Coupling of phenoxyl 51 with cyclohexadienonyl 52 accounts for a dimer unstable at ambient temperature. However, coupling of the carbon-centered free radicals 52 and 54 accounts for an isolable dimer 55. Two radicals 54 dimerize to 4,4'-ethylenebis(2,Bdi-tert. butylphenol) (56). The coupling processes take place at sites of high concentration of phenoxyls in the degrading polymer and account for products having higher molecular weight and, consequently, lower migration rates and extractability than the parent phenol. The coupling described for 51 may be restricted in phenoxyls bearing voluminous substituents on the para-methyl group, such as phenoxyls derived from 14. 0
OH 55
56
Transformation products having the structure of alkylated 4-alkylperoxycyclohexa2,5-dien-l-ones (57) arise from cyclohexadienonyl radicals 52 and alkylperoxyls ROO' at sites of high concentrations of both radical species. Alkylperoxycyclohexadienones analogous to 57 were isolated in model experiments from phenols 12, 14 and 16 and various ROO'. In polynuclear phenols 14 or 16, the reaction proceeds gradually; and
68
Pospiiil
products with partially or fully oxidized molecules were isolated. Phenolic antioxidants having a lower steric hindrance in position two, such as 13, are prone to form alkylated 2-alkylperoxy-cyclohexa-3,5-dien-ones (58). During weathering, phenolic antioxidants are photooxidized into hydroperoxycyclohexadienones, such as 59 (PospiSil, 1993;PospiSil, 1980). The presence of peroxidic moieties in 57 and 59 renders them thermolabile at temperatures exceeding 100°C and photolysable under solar UV radiation. Both processes account for homolysis of the peroxidic moieties. As a result, the oxidative degradation of the polymeric matrix is accelerated by formed free-radical fragments (tests were performed with atactic polypropylene and acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene terpolymer (ABS) (PospiSil, 1981; PospiSil, 1980). Low-molecular-weight products of homolysis, such as 60 to 63 are formed in low amounts.
&
COCHs
+O()R OOR
57
0
CH2 Subst. 58
OOH 59
9
0
COCH3 61
YY 0
62
60
C HO 63
’ ‘NO2 64
Oxidative transformation of phenolic antioxidants by atmospheric nitrogen oxides (NO,) taking place in the polymer matrix should be mentioned. Discoloring cyclohexadienones (64 is an example) are formed in the process called gas fading. Hindered phenoxyls containing at least one hydrogen atom on the carbon atom in position four disproportionate to the parent phenol and a relevant quinone methide (QM). Unstable C-0 coupling intermediates may be formed. The disproportionation competes with the free-radical recombination of phenoxyls. The simplest example indicates formation of an unstable QM (65, Eq. 3-15). After dimerization and disproportionation, 65 is transformed to a mixture of ethylenebisphenol 56 and 353’3‘tetra-tert.butylstilbene-4,4’-quinone (66, Eq. 3-16). Phenols bearing bulky substituents in the para position to the hydroxy group, such as 14 or propionate-type phenolics l2,13 and 16 dimerize via C-C coupling in the P-position to the QM ring (PospiSil et al., 1996).
+
69
Additives for plastics and their transformation products
2 51
11 +
(3-15)
c H2 65
(3-16)
66
Various QM were isolated from phenolic antioxidants. The most important QM from the point of view of the integral stabilizing effect are those developed from propionate type phenols (12,13,16).Their effect is based on an intramolecular rearrangement of the conjugated QM system and aromatisation to a new phenolic species. An example is given using a “primary” QM 67 derived from octadecyl3-(3,5-di-terf.butyl4-hydroxypheny1)propionate (12)(PospiSil et al., 1996). QM 67 is prone to aromatize into a phenolic cinnamate 68.The latter is an effective chain-breaking antioxidant scavenging alkylperoxyl. The process results in oxidation of 68 and formation of a dimeric QM 69. Another rearrangement and P O 0 scavenging account for a dimeric phenolic cinnamate 70 and QM 71,respectively. QM 71 is the ultimate product (R in 67 to 71 is CI8H3,).
CH I
I
CH2 I COOR
AH I COOR
67
68
CH COOR
CI C OOF
69
70
I
CH I
II
C= I
c OOF 71
The cascade regenerating phenolic antioxidants from their quinone methinoide transformation products, shown for the QM 67, is considered also for other QM derived from propionate-type phenols, e.g. 13 or 16, and explains their excellent antioxidant activity in plastics. Dimerization of the cinnamate 68 via p-position to the aromatic nucleus also enhances the physical persistence of the quinone methinoide transformation products in comparison with the parent phenols. QM are the final stable transformation products of phenolic antioxidants 11-14,16. Formation of QM cannot be avoided in phenols containing a methyl or substituted
70
PospiiiI
methyl in positions two or four to the phenolic hydroxy group. QM absorb visible light 420 to 463 nm. As a consequence, the sacrificial transformation of phenols at ,A results in discoloration of the polymer (PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1997; PospiSil et al., 1996; PospiSil et al., in press). However, the stabilization power is not completely lost after QM formation. This is due to the ability of QM to trap alkyl radicals (PospiSil, 1991; PospiSil et al., 1996) and react with organic phosphites during processing of polyolefins or with HAS during polyolefin weathering (PospiSil, 1991; PospiSil, 1995; Pospsi1 et al., 1996). In polynuclear phenols, the individual phenolic nuclei are oxidized independently. As a consequence, complicated compounds are formed having, in one molecule phenolic groups in various degrees of transformation. For example, oxidized trinuclear phenol 14 forms a mixture of mono-, bis- and tris-alkylperoxycyclohexadienones,a product having in one molecule quinone methinoide and alkylperoxycyclohexadienoide moieties (72) and compounds with aldehyde groups (e.g., 73) arising from degradation of the alkylperoxycyclohexadienoide moieties. The missing cyclic substituents were split-off in the form of 2,6-di-rert.butyl-l,4-benzoquinone (62). The analysis of a mixture of transformation products of phenols in extracts from plastics is difficult.
CHp
72
73
Information on the exact structures arising during the transformation of the tetranuclear phenol 15 is missing due to the complexity of the reaction mixture formed. It was extrapolated from chromatographic analyses and results of model experiments (PospiSil, 1993) that the mixture of transformation products contains a compound bearing a substituted 12-benzoquinone moiety (74), coupling products having the structure of a substituted 2,2'-biphenyldiol (75) and compounds of its oxidative transformation, a spiroquinol76 among them (A in 74-76 means the rest of the molecule of 15).
0 I
1'
1 J
d, 74
OH 0
I
*l! 11-11 I ~
L
A 75
0
OH
1
A
1
"
-\Q
I
4
A 76
Additives for plastics and their transformation products
71
Great attention has been paid to DL-a-tocopherol (17), a synthetic analogue of a natural antioxidant of plant origin. Its application in packaging materials in contact with food was studied intensively. A detailed elucidation of the sacrificial consumption of a-tocopherol in thermal oxidation and photo-oxidation of organic materials revealed transformations analogous to those of synthetic hindered phenolic antioxidants (PospiSil, 1993; PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1995; Rieger, 1987). Among various products of transformation, alkylperoxycyclohexadienone 77 (R=C12H25),hydroperoxycyclohexadienone 77 (R=H), a reactive quinone methide 78, the respective rather complicated oligomers arising from 78 and a-tocopherylquinone 79 were identified. Compounds 78 and 79 contribute to discoloration arising in polyolefins doped with atocopherol.
77
78
79
Oxidative transformations of hindered synthetic phenols and a-tocopherol are analogous to the oxidation of various mono- and dihydric phenols of plant origin. Natural phenols present in fruits or green tea leaves are oxidized on contact with air and/or during fermentation (a process characteristic of tea leaves) and are transformed into dark colored quinoid systems, not harmful for human beings. It may be extrapolated that trace amounts of discoloring quinones or quinone methides arising from phenolic antioxidants in plastics are harmless as well. Phenolic moieties differing in the steric hindrance are present as functional groups assuring the excited state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT) stabilizing mechanism in UV absorbers 37 to 40 (Ghiggino et al., 1988). Oxidation with alkylperoxyls proceeds by a mechanism analogous to that characteristic of phenolic antioxidants. Phenolic groups in UV absorbers are, however, more resistant to oxidative transformations. It is because a non-oxidizing zwitterionic non-phenolic form arises reversibly during the ESIPT mechanism. Nevertheless, after a long-term service, a small part of the phenolic moieties of UV absorbers is oxidized, photolysis of the hydroxy group accelerating the process. This breaks the H-tunneling from the phenolic group to carbonyl or nitrogen functions in the UV absorber. Its molecule cannot act via the ESIPT mechanism and the photostabilizing function is lost (PospiSil and NeSpurek, 1997). Substituted l,.l-benzoquinone 80 (R=CxH17) and alkylperoxycyclohexadienone 81 are formed from 2-hydroxybenzophenone 37 and 2-(3,5-di-tert.butyl-2hydroxypheny1)benzotriazole (38), respectively. Quinone methide 82 arising from benzotriazole 39 is expected to isomerize in a phenolic cinnamate in a mechanism analogous to the rearrangement of 67 to 68. The ESIPT mechanism may be thus formally re-established. The service lifetime of UV absorbers is prolonged in combination with phenolic antioxidants, protecting the ESIPT mechanism from depletion by preferential oxidation of the antioxidant.
80
81
82
3.2.3 Products from hydroperoxide decomposing antioxidants SN2displacement on the peroxidic bond 0-0 accounts for the reduction of alkylhydroperoxides and oxidation of the hydroperoxide-decomposing antioxidant (HD, Eq. 3-17) in products, generally HD(0) or HD(0)2. Peroxidolyticproducts
(3-17)
I
ROOH,
HD(0)2 + ROH
Sulfur-containing antioxidants 20 or 21 react with ROOH in the first stoichiometric step and yield the product HD(O), i.e. the corresponding sulfoxide 83 (R=C12-C18, n=1) or thiosulfinate 84 (n=l) (PospiSil, 1991; PospiSil, 1990b; Shelton, 1981). Both primary products 83,W (n=l) deactivate another molecule of ROOH in the second stoichiometric step. The arising HD(0)2 has the structure of sulfone 83 (R=CI2-HI8, n=2) or thiosulfonate 84 (n=2). The primary oxidation products HD(0) are thermolabile and decompose to peroxidolytic products in a very intricate mechanism involving various free-radical species. From 83, 84 (n=l), sulfenic 85 (n=O) and sulfoxylic acid 86 (n=O) respectively, are formed. Unsaturated sulfurless fragments, such as 87, remain in the polymer matrix. Acids 85, 86 (n=O) act as catalysts for the decomposition of
Additives f o r plastics and their transformation products
73
hydroperoxides. Generally, 85,86 (n=O) are considered as “peroxidofytic” transformation products responsible for the high (over-stoichiometric) activity of sulfidic antioxidants.
[
c 18H37SS(O)nC 1BH37
~0;(~~2ts(o)n
ROC(CH2)2S(0)nOH
0 83
84
86
85
87
These polar transformation products and sulfur oxides (SOz, SO3) arising in the ultimate stages of the transformation process are formed in trace amounts in the aged polymer matrix. Volatile products may be sources of undesirable organoleptic problems. This limits the use of organic thiocompounds in odor-sensitive applications. Organic S-protonic acids 85, 86 deactivate basic stabilizers (HAS). The peroxidolytic effect of 85,86 is reduced in the presence of some antiacids or fillers, e.g., calcium carbonate. Organic compounds of trivalent phosphorus are the second group of hydroperoxide-decomposing antioxidants. Their reactivity with hydroperoxides decreases in the series arylphosphonite > alkylphosphite > hindered aryl phosphite. The stoichiometric phase of their sacrificial transformation results in structurally relevant compounds of pentavalent phosphorus (PospiSil, 1990b; Schwetlick and Habicher, 1996). For example, phosphate 88 is formed from phosphite 25. Aliphatic open-chain and cyclic phosphites are prone to hydrolyze by humidity during storage and handling. Model experiments were performed with aromatic phosphites, more resistant to hydrolysis (Schwetlick and Habicher, 1996). Hydrogen phosphate 89 is formed and a phenol ArOH is released. 89 and analogous products of partial hydrolysis of other phosphites retain properties of a hydroperoxide decomposer and melt stabilizer (Tochficek and Sedlfir, 1995). The hydrolysis is catalyzed by acid impurities arising either from residues of polymerization catalysts in polyolefins or from degrading poly(viny1 chloride) (King and Kuell, 1995) and accounts for phosphorous acid in the ultimate phase. 0 = P(H)(OArh
88
89
74
Pospiiil
Acids arising either during storage or processing from hydrolysis-sensitive phosphites are prone to corrode the processing equipment. To minimize hydrolytic instability, basic additives such as tris(2-hydroxypropy1)amineare added to phosphite 27 (R=CI8-H3,). A new hydrolysis-resistant phosphite was commercialized (Spivack et al., 1985).
3.2.4 Products from hindered amine stabilizers Individual pathways for the activity mechanism of HAS have been re-evaluated (PospiSil, 1995). A complex of transformations is characteristic of the integral activity. Nitroxides >NO' (Eq. 2.3-8), O-alkylhydroxylamines >NOP (Eq. 2.3-9) and alkylhydroxylamines >NOH are formed as stabilizing active forms from HAS during the cyclic regenerative process (PospiSil, 1995). These sacrificial products arise in very low concentrations in the polymer matrix and may be detected by high-sensitivity spectral methods. However, some irreversible chemical transformations account for the loss of HAS activity either due to the formation of species unable to regenerate nitroxides >NO, such as salts of strong organic or mineral acids (90, R=H, methyl; X=residue of an acid, e.g. 85, 86), N-acyloxy derivatives 91 arising by recombination of nitroxide with acyl radicals generated by the photolysis of polymer-bound ketones, or volatile cyclic and open-chain products 92 to 95 arising due to photolysis of nitroxides derived from various HAS. These products were detected in model experiments in deep stages of photodegradation of HAS-doped polyolefins (PospiSil, 1995). 0 +/H /N \RX\
II
)NOCR
I
OH 90
91
92
Subst.
93
94
95
3.2.5 Products from heat stabilizers for P V C Heat stabilizers have preventive and curative functions (Andreas, 1990). As preventive stabilizers, they deplete initiation sites in the PVC backbone by elimination or complexation of reactive chlorine atoms by organotin stabilizers (e.g. 45) according to
Additives ,for plastics und their transformation products
75
Eq. (3-18) or by chemical binding of hydrogen chloride released from the degrading PVC by metal soaps (43), organotins (45) or costabilizers (having the function of antiacids), such as epoxide 48 or hydrotalcite 49. Chemical transformation products of heat stabilizers resulting in their preventive action are represented by compound 96 and a metal-free fragment 97 formed from organotinthioglycolate 45, metal chlorides (e.g., calcium or zinc chloride) and the corresponding free fatty acids generated from metal soaps 43, and chlorohydrin 98 arising from 48. (3-18) The curative mechanism of heat stabilizers accounts for a reduction in the rate of formation of polyene sequences -[CH=CH],- and deactivation of hydroperoxides in PVC (Andreas, 1990). Organotin maleate 44 or thiol97 released from 45 were reported to stop the growth of polyenes by adding to the C=C bond in PVC.
97
96
99
98
100
Organotin stabilizers containing sulfur (e.g. 45) or their transformation products 96, 97 are considered as hydroperoxide-decomposing antioxidants (Al-Malaika, 1989). Within this stabilizing function, thiol 97 is oxidized by hydroperoxide in disulfide 99 and sulfenic acid 100, having peroxidolytic properties.
3.2.6 Conclusions The formation of various transformation products from the stabilizers added to plastics cannot be avoided. The sacrificial fate of stabilizers is in agreement with their activity mechanism, accounting for the protection of plastics against degradation. In
76
~ospifi/
elucidating transport phenomena in commodity polymers, the presence of combinations of originally added stabilizers with varying amounts of their transformation products, sometimes having very different molecular parameters, has to be taken into account. Acknowledgement. The financial support by grant KONTAKT No 184-1998 from the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport of the Czech Republic and grant No A4050603 from the Grant Agency of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic is gratefully appreciated by J. P. and S. N. The authors thank to Mrs D. Dundrovi for technical cooperation in the preparation of the manuscript. References Accorsi J and Yu M (1998) Carbon black, In Plastics additives, an A-Z reference, Pritchard G (Ed), Chapman & Hall London, pp 153-161. Allen N S (1989) Effect of dyes and pigments In Comprehensive polymer science, Vol6, Polymer reactions, Eastmond G C, Ledwith A, Russo S and Sigwalt P (Eds) Pergamon Press Oxford, pp 529-537. Al-Malaika S (1989) Effects of antioxidants and stabilizers, In Comprehensive polymer science, Vol 6, Polymer reactions, Eastmond G C. Ledwith A, Russo S and Sigwalt P (Eds), Pergamon Press Oxford, pp 539-578. Andreas H (1990) PVC stabilizers, In Plastics additives handbook, Gachter R and Miiller H (Eds), Hanser Publishers Munich, pp 271-325. Bauer I, Habicher W D, Korner S and Al-Malaika S (1997) Antioxidant interaction between organic phosphites and hindered arnine light stabilizers: effect during photooxidation of polypropylene. Polym Degrad Stab 55-217-224. Berger K (1990) Fluorescent whitening agents, In Plastics additives handbook, Gachter R and Miiller H (Eds), Hanser Publishers Munich, pp 775-790. Billingham N C (1989) Location of oxidation in polypropylene, Makromol Chem, Macromol Symp 28: 145-163. Ghiggino K P,Scully A D and Bigger S W (1988) Photophysics of hydroxyphenylbenzotriazole polymer photostabilizers, In The effects of radiation on high-technology polymers, Reichmanis E and O'Connor J H (Eds), ACS Symp Ser 381: 57-79. Gugumus F (1990) Photooxidation of polymers and its inhibition, In Oxidation inhibition in organic materials, Vol 11, PospiSil J and Klemchuk P (Eds), CRC Press Boca Raton, pp 29-162. Hurnik H (1990) Chemical blowing agents, In Plastics additives handbook, Gachter R and Miiller H (Eds), Hanser Publishers Munich, pp 811-8321. Irganox HP products (1997) CIBA Specialty Chemicals, Information A7765M27. Karayannidis G P,Sideridon I D and Zamboulis D X (1998) Antioxidants for poly(ethy1ene terephthalate), In Plastics additives, an A-Z reference, Pritchard G (Ed), Chapman & Hall London, pp 95107. King R E and Kuell C (1995) Potential impact of catalyst residues on polymer stabilization, 17'h International conference on advances in stabilization and degradation of polymers, Luzern, Proceedings 145-165. Kramer E (1996) Lichtschutzmittel, Kunststoffe 8 6 948-953. Meier L (1990) Plasticizers, In Plastics additives handbook, Gachter R and Miiller H (Eds), Hanser Publishers Munich, pp 327422. Oxley D F (1998) Innovation in the gas phase, Chemistry & Industry 305-308. Pfahler G (1990) Antistatic agents, In Plastics additives handbook, Gachter R and Miiller H (Eds), Hanser Publishers Munich, pp 749-773. PospiSil J (1980) Transformations of phenolic antioxidants and the role of their products in the longterm stability of polyolefins, Adv Polym Sci 3 6 69-133. PospiSil J (1981) Photo-oxidation reactions of phenolic antioxidants, In Developments in polymer photochemistry-2, Allen N S (Ed), Applied Science Publishers London, pp 53-133. PospiSil J (1990) Stabilizer mixtures and polyfunctional stabilizers, In Oxidation inhibition in organic materials, Vol I, PospiSil J and Klemchuk P (Eds), CRC Press Boca Raton, pp 173-192. PospiSil J (1990) Antioxidants and related stabilizers, In Oxidation inhibition in organic materials, Vol I. PospiSil J and Klemchuk P (Eds), CRC Press Boca Raton, pp 33-59.
Additives f o r plastics and their transformation products
77
PospiSil J (1990) Antioxidants and related stabilizers, In Oxidation inhibition in organic materials, Vol I, PospiSil J and Klemchuk P (Eds), CRC Press Boca Raton, pp 61-72. PospiGl J (1991) The key role of antioxidant transformation products in the stabilization mechanism - a critical analysis, Polym Degrad Stab 34: 85-109. PospiSil J (1993) Chemical and photochemical behavior of phenolic antioxidants, a state of the art report, part I, Polym Degrad Stab 40:217-232. PospiSil J (1995) Aromatic and heterocyclic amines in polymer stabilization, Adv Polym Sci 124: 87-180. PospiSil J (1998) Antioxidants: hindered phenols, In Plastics additives, an A-Z reference, Pritchard G (Ed), Chapman & Hall London, pp 72-79. PospiSil J and Klemchuk P (Eds) (1990) Oxidation inhibition in organic materials, Vols I and 11, CRC Press Boca Raton. PospiSil J and NeSphrek S (1995) Chain-breaking stabilizers in polymers: the current status, Polym Degrad Stab 49: 99-110. PospiSil J and NeSphrek S (1997) Highlights in chemistry and physics of polymers stabilization, Macromol Symp 115: 143-163. PospiSil J and NeSphrek S (in press) Highlights in the inherent chemical activity of polymer stabilizers, In Handbook of polymer degradation, 2’ldedition, Hamid S H (Ed) Marcel Dekker Inc New York. PospiSil J. NeSphrek S and Zweifel H (1996) The role of quinone methides in thermostabilization of hydrocarbon polymers, Part I, Formation and reactivity of quinone methides, Polym Degrad Stab 54: 7-14. PospiSil J. NeSphrek S, Pfaendner R and Zweifel H (1997) Material recycling of plastics waste for demanding applications, Trends Polym Sci 5: 204-300. PospiSil J, NeSphrek S and Zweifel H (1999) Formation and role of conjugated cyclic dienones in polymer stabilization, In: Chemistry and Technology of Polymer Additives, Al-Malaika S, Golovoy A and Wilkie C (Eds), Blackwell Science Ltd Oxford, pp 3 W 1 . Rabek J F (1990) Photostabilization of polymers, Elsevicr Applied Publishers London. Riedel T (1990) Lubricants and related additives, In Plastics additives handbook. Gachter R and Miiller H (Eds), Hanser Publishers Munich, pp 423-480. Rieger M (1987) The chemical fate of antioxidants, Cosmetics & Toiletries 102: (No 11) 83-96. Schlumpf H P (1990) Fillers and reinforcements, , In Plastics additives handbook. Gachter R and Miiller H (Eds), Hanser Publishers Munich, pp 525-591. Schwetlick K and Habicher W D (1996) Action mechanism of phosphite and phosphonite stabilizers, In Polymer durability: degradation, stabilization and lifetime prediction, Clough R L, Billingham N C and Gillen K T (Eds), Adv Chem Ser 249: 349-358. Seltzer R, Ravichandran R and Patel R A (1989) Polyolefin compositions stabilized with long-chain N,N-dialkylhydroxylamines, Eur Pat Appl EP 323 409; Chem Abstr (1990) 112:21791. Shanks R A and Tiganis B E (1998) Nucleating agents for thermoplastics. In Plastics additives, an A-Z reference, Pritchard G (Ed), Chapman & Hall London, pp 464472. Shelton J R (1981) Organic sulfur compounds as preventive antioxidants, In Developments in polymer stabilization-4. Scott G (Ed), Applied Science Publishers London, pp 23-70. Spivack J D, Pastor S D. Patel A and Steihuebel L D (1985) Bis- and trisphosphites having dioxaphosphepin and dioxaphosphocin rings as polyolefin processing stabilizers, In Polymer stabilization and degradation, Klemchuk P (Ed), ACS Symp Ser 280: 247-257. Thiirmer A (1998) Acid scavengers for polyolefins. In Plastics additives. an A-Z reference, Pritchard G (Ed), Chapman & Hall London, pp 4348. Tochacek J and Sedlar J (1995)Hydrolysis and stabilization performance of bis(2,4-di-rerr.butylphenyl)pentaerythntyl diphosphite in polypropylene. Polym Degrad Stab SO 345-352. White J R and Rapoport N Y (1994) Stress effects in polymer durability in the oxidative environment, Trends Polym Sci 2: 197-202. Zweifel H (1998) Stabilization of polymeric materials, Springer Berlin.
Reactivity in Molecular Crystals Edited by Yuli Ohashi Copyright @ K d a o r h a Ltd .Tokyo. 1999
4 Partition coefficients Albert L. Baner
4.1 Thermodynamic fundamentals Solving the equations derived for practical mass transport problems requires values for fundamental material constants which describe the solubility of the diffusant in the polymer matrix or the partition coefficient of the diffusant between two contacting media. This chapter deals with estimation methods for solubility values and partition constants. In most cases the necessary material constant can be determined by direct measurement. In practice however, because of the time and cost required to measure the numerous types and combination possibilities of plastics and contacting media, only a limited selection of such experimental constants is available. Consequently in practice one cannot avoid using estimated values. Such estimations are possible within a degree of accuracy adequate for practical purposes, when the chemical structure of the migrating substance, the polymer and the contacting media are known. Thermodynamic terms are used to characterize the equilibrium distribution of a diffusant substance between plastic (P) and contacting media (e.g. a liquid L). The most important of these terms is the chemical potential p. During a spontaneously occurring process at constant temperature T and constant volume there is a decrease in the free energy A . For a spontaneous process at constant temperature and constant pressure p, a decrease in the free enthalpy C takes place. Because most spontaneous processes occur at constant pressure, the free enthalpy is particularly important for describing such processes. When energy, e.g. in the form of heat, is supplied to the system under constant pressure, only a fraction of this energy serves to increase the internal energy of the system U. The remainder of the energy goes for expansion work (volumetric work) against the external pressure. The sum of U and the volumetric expansion work p ' V is the enthalpy H . With entropy of a system defined as the ratio of the amount of heat q and temperature, S = q/T, the two quantities A = U - T S and G = H - T S are thus defined. The quantities U, H I S, A , G, q and V are extensive and p and T intensive quantities. When an extensive quantity is related to the amount of material in a mole, then it becomes a molar and therefore specific quantity with which the properties of the material under consideration can be described. The molar free enthalpy G, in analogy to a mechanical system, is called the chemical potential and is designated with p (p = G). In a mechanical system, a body moves in the direction of decreasing potential (e.g. an object falls to earth or a ground state) and from this comes the analogy to the chemical potential. Designating the standard pressure of 1 bar with p', the chemical potential of a system that behaves as an ideal gas is given as:
80
Baner
+
p = p@ R T In($)
(4-1)
where p" is the standard chemical potential at po. Equation (4-1) allows the evaluation of p for a perfect gas at any given pressure and temperature. For the temperature and pressure conditions coming into question in this book, most gases behave like a perfect gas, which means their chemical potential can be described using Eq. (4-1). A gas phase can be composed of several gaseous elements or compounds. If one labels the mole amounts of components 1,2,... with nl, nZ,... then the free enthalpy is a function of p , T and the quantities nl, n2, ... so that G = G(p, 7; nl, n2, ...). The complete differential of this function is:
From the definition of the chemical potential, the case for a single component gas having n moles results in G = n . C =n . p whereby the partial derivative of n at constant temperature T and p is given as (BG/an),,T = p. One can consequently hold all other variables constant and define the partial derivatives of G for I t l , n2, ... as the chemical potentials of the single components e.g.: (4-3)
4.1.1 Equilibrium between different phases in ideal solutions Component a making up a liquid phase (L) in contact with a gas phase (G) forms a two phase system. In the equilibrium state, the chemical potential of component a in the gas and contacting phase are equal. The equilibrium saturated vapor pressure of pure component a in the gas phase over the pure liquid phase a can be designated with p;. Using the expression for a perfect gas, Eq. (4-l), for the chemical potential of a, one gets an expression of the chemical potential of component a in liquid a, p;(L), in the equilibrium state:
&(L)
= ki(G) =:p
+ R T ln(pi/p@)
(4-4)
For a two component liquid phase composed of a and b whose partial pressures in the gas phase at equilibrium with the liquid phase are p a and Pb, one can write:
From Eqs. (4-5) and (4-4) one gets equations that are analogous to Eq. (4-4) for components a and b:
Partition coefficients
81 (4-6)
In a so-called ideal solution, that is a mixture of several components with very similar properties, the ratio of pa/pz is equal to the mole fraction x , of component a in the liquid phase. Thus Raoult’s law is valid: Pa
= xa
pi
(4-7)
Consequently Eq. (4-6) can be expressed in the form:
If two pure liquids, one composed of only n, moles of component a and the other of only nb moles of component b, are mixed and the total free enthalpy of the two liquids in separate initial states, GA,is considered, then the enthalpy of the mixture GE for an assumed ideal solution can be calculated. Because n, + nb = n, n,/n = x, and nb/n = xb Eq. (4-8) results in:
(4-9)
Because x, < 1 and x b < 1 the enthalpy of mixing, ALGM,is always negative: ALGM < 0. The same result is obtained for mixtures of two perfect gases. Because there are no interactions between the individual particles of perfect gases (atoms or molecules) the decrease in the free enthalpy during mixing can be traced back to the increase in entropy. Mixing increases the disorder of the system. In ideal solutions there exist interactions between the individual particles. However, because the molecular properties of components a and b are very similar, the interactions between a and b in the mixture can be assumed to be on average the same as those between a and a as well as those between b and b in pure liquids. Consequently in this case ALGM is the increase in entropy due to mixing. For very dilute solutions of component a in component b, all the neighboring molecules of a are b molecules. Thus the partial pressure above the solution is proportional to the forces that oppose the evaporation of a. These forces can be expressed as a constant, H ,thus giving an expression which is Henry’s law (Denbigh, 1981): Pa = H . xa
(4-10)
Nernst’s Law: partitioning
Given two partially immiscible liquids h and c, consider a third component (subscript a ) which is present in the two liquid layers. If this substance is sufficiently dilute
82
Baner
in each layer, it may behave individually as an ideal solute in both of them even though the system as a whole is non-ideal. When this condition is satisfied the result at equilibrium: (4-11) may be replaced by:
pib + RTln xt =:p
+ RTln x;
(4-12)
and therefore: (4-13) where the partition coefficient K' is defined in terms of the mole fraction ratio to be K'= xZ/xi which is independent of composition. The ratio .;/xi is independent of the individual values of xk and x i in the region where each solution is ideal. This partition coefficient is also equal to the ratio of the Henry's law coefficients in the two solvents: HC K'= 3
(4-14)
Ha
4.1.2 Non-ideal solutions Non-ideal solutions deviate as a rule from Raoult's law. One can however still retain the form of the equation derived for ideal solutions if, instead of the mole fraction x,, the activity a, is used:
With the help of the activity coefficient, y', in Eq. (4-15), all deviations from the ideal state can be taken into consideration. Instead of Eq. (4-8) for the chemical potential of component a in the liquid mixture one now gets:
pa&) = &(L)
+ R T In Xa + R T In ya
(4-16)
One can now define an existing liquid phase as the standard state so that y, goes to 1 when x, -+ 1. All deviations from ideal behavior in a mixture (x, # 1) are then included in the term RTIn(y,). Because the chemical potential of component a in the liquid phase and that in the contacting gas phase are equal in equilibrium, it is possible to determine the partition coefficient for component a between the liquid and gas phases with the help of thermodynamic quantities. For the equilibrium state for substance, a, distributed between the gas (G) and liquid (L) phases then:
Purtitioti coefficients
pa(G) =:p
83
+ R T In (pa/p@)= pa(L) = p;(L) + R T In Xa + R T In Ya
(4-17)
+ R T In (p:/p@)
(4-18)
and because:
p;(L)
= pf
then:
R T In
%I =:p
Pa
:p
-
-
R T In p i
+ R T In po
-
R T In po
-
R T In ya
(4-19)
and consequently:
a- 1 or P: Ya
pa
Pa = Ya . xa . P;
(4-20)
which is a form of Raoult's law for non-ideal solutions where a, = pa/pl. The thermodynamic characteristics of solutions are often expressed by means of excess functions. These are the amounts by which the free energy, entropy, enthalpy, etc. exceed those of a hypothetical ideal solution of the same composition (Denbigh, 1981). The excess free energy is closely related to the activity coefficients. The total free enthalpy (Gibbs free energy) of a system is:
G
= Cnipi
(4-21)
and p substituting from Eq. (4-16) one obtains:
G
=
C nip:
+ R T C niln xi + R T C niln yi
(4-22)
If the solution were ideal the last term of course would be zero. The excess free energy, GE is thus defined as:
GE = H E - T SE = R T C n i l n y,
(4-23)
Differentiating the above expression at constant temperature and then applying conditions of constant temperature and pressure gives (Denbigh, 1981): (4-24) Where G%sthe excess free energy of mixing per mole, @ is the excess enthalpy of mixing per mole and Sp is the excess entropy of mixing per mole. Note that the excess free energy of mixing is also referred to as the excess chemical potential p? in some notations. A regular solution is a special case where solutions of similar sized molecules are completely randomly oriented in solution (i.e. no attractive forces other than dispersion forces), such that the volume change on mixing is quite small and the excess entropy per mole of mixture is essentially zero. For regular solutions then $ = 0 but HE# 0. Another special case, athermal solutions, is assumed to have zero (or negligibly small) enthalpy of mixing.
84
Baner
Partition coefficients for non-ideal solutions For partitioning substance a between two non-ideal liquid solutions with superscripts b and c one gets:
pt
= pLc, so
that p:b
+ RTln xi + RTln y:
=:p
+ RTln x i + RTln yLc,
(4-25)
Solving it, one gets: (4-26) where the partition coefficient K' for non-ideal solutions is now defined to be the ratio: (4-27) Note that for ideal solutions yn = 1 and Eq. (4-27) is equal to Eq. (4-13). Experimentally it is often more convenient to describe solute concentrations in terms of molar (mole/volume) or weight/volume concentration quantities instead of mole fractions. A partition coefficient K can be defined to be a ratio of concentrations: (4-28) The relationship between a mole fraction partition coefficient (K') and a molar concentration partition coefficient ( K )for dilute solutions is: (4-29)
In order to get the molar concentration c L , ~(e.g. moles/voIume) of a in the liquid phase at equilibrium, if one relates the quantity of material n,(L) in the liquid phase to the volume of the liquid, VL:
where nL is the total number of moles in the system and VL its molar volume (e.g. volume/mole) of the liquid phase and Ma the molar mass of component a. For dilute solutions (the case most applicable for food packaging systems), one can make a simplifying assumption and use the molar volume of the pure bulk liquid phase instead of the molar volume of the liquid solution. From the ideal gas law:
PV
=
nRT
one obtains for the gas phase VG/n,(G) = & a centration of a in the gas phase c ~ , ~ :
(4-31) = RT/p,
and with it the molar con-
Partition coefficients
85
where yGis the molar volume of the ideal gas. For T = 298.15 K (25 "C)and p = 1 Pa = 1 N m-2 = 1kg m-l ss2,one obtains the value for an ideal gas with R = 8.31451 J K-' mol-' for = 2478.94 m3 mol-' and forp = 1 atm = 101325Pa,y, = 24.47 dm' mol-l. The dimensionless partition coefficient KG/L(a) for component a between an ideal gas and a dilute liquid solution of a is obtained by combining Eq. (4-28) with (4-20), (4-30) and (4-32) to give:
vc,
(4-33) Using the index P for a polymeric material phase one obtains an equation analogous to Eq. (4-33) for molar concentrations: (4-34) ~ partition coefficient between a polymer and a From the ratio of KG/L to K G the liquid can be calculated for molar concentration ratios: (4-35) Note that molar concentration partition coefficients K are the same as if the partition coefficient were defined as a ratio of weight/volume concentrations due to the canceling out of the molar masses, Ma, of the solute in the numerator and denominator. With these Equations (4-33) to (4-35) the first goal is reached of describing partition by using parameters resulting from thermodynamic state functions.
4.1.3 Partition coefficients for systems with polymers A complication in estimating the partition of some solute a in systems containing polymers occurs due to the large, in general non-uniform, molar volumes of polymers. It is usually more convenient to work with weightivolume concentrations, weight fractions (molal concentrations) or volume fractions. Instead of mole fractions one can define analogous weight fractions using the mass g of the system's i components: (4-36)
with analogous equations for Raoult's law:
for very dilute ideal solutions and:
86
Baner
for non-ideal solutions where 0, is referred to as the weight fraction (molal) activity coefficient. For dilute liquid solutions having components with well defined molar weights the relationship between the molal activity coefficient and molar activity coefficient is:
where M is the molar mass. For dilute concentrations of substance a in a polymer, cp,, can be approximated using weight fractions as: CP,, ? wa
. pp = P a. pp = 23L Pi QP,, QP.a p p
(4-40)
'
For dilute concentrations of a in a liquid the molar concentration in terms of the weight fraction is: (4-41) where a, = p,/pi is the activity. Combining Eqs. (4-39) and (4-40) one can derive an expression for partition coefficients of dilute solutions calculated using molal activity coefficients. For KG/L one combines Eqs. (4-39) and (4-33), the ideal gas law Eq. (4-31) and Eq. (4-41) to get: (4-42) (4-43) Combining Eq. (4-42) and Eq. (4-43) one gets Kp/L: (4-44) In some cases it is more convenient to define a molal activity coefficient for the solute in the polymer phase and a molar activity coefficient for the liquid phase. Combining Eq. (4-33) and (4-43) one gets: (4-45) Sometimes volume fractions, @a, are used which can be defined: $a=&
(4-46)
as well as volume fraction activity coefficients, y!: pa
= $a . Ya@ . P:
(4-47)
with related partition coefficient expressions for dilute solutions (e.g. $L.a 2 V,/VL and C L . ~z $~.;p,) based on volume fraction activity coefficients and assuming ideal gas law behavior (Eq. 4-32):
Partition coefficients
87 (4-48) (4-49)
(4-50) Using the above expressions for partition coefficients defined on the basis of weight fraction and volume fraction activity coefficients one avoids the difficulty of trying to define what exactly the molar volume of a polymer is. Due to the difficulties caused by using polymer molar volumes, it is common in some estimation methods to use the molar volume of the polymer’s repeating structural unit (i.e. molar volume of monomer) instead of the actual molar volume when estimating the values of physical properties. This molar volume is designated ypand one can use Eqs. (4-33) and (4-35) without difficulty because the relative molar mass of the monomeric structural unit M p is known and the density of the polymer pp is easy to determine (yp= Mp/1000 pp . dm3/mol). Taking for example polyethylene with a density of pp = 0.93 (g/cm3) at 25 “C and the monomeric structural unit -CH2CH2-, with M p = 28 g/mol, then = 0.030 dm’/mol. For calculating the partitioning of a substance i between polyethylene and water according to Eq. (4-35), yL= 1811000 = 0.018 dm3/mol is used for water. In general the corresponding molar volume for nonpolymeric liquids can be obtained without difficulty, because the densities are available from tables or can easily be determined experimentally.
vp
Relationship between partition coefficientsand solubility coefficients The partition coefficient describing solute partitioning between air and polymer is often referred to as a solubility coefficient, S. The solubility coefficient can be expressed in terms of the molal activity coefficient for polymers using Eq. (4-40):
Solubility has cgs units of g/cm3 . Pa, where pa is the solute partial pressure and pi is the solute saturated vapor pressure at the temperature of the system. Note that at ambient temperature and pressure one can assume ideal gas behavior. Henry’s constant for a solute in a polymer is a special solubility coefficient case where c ~x ,H ~. pz.
4.2 Additive molecular properties The physical properties of a substance are dependent on the nature of the atoms found in it and the type of bonds between them. The size and shape of the molecules from which a substance is composed determine the aggregate state and all related specific properties like melting point, vapor pressure, density, viscosity and solubility in various media. This also includes the number value of the partition coefficient. Funda-
88
Baner
mentally, there are two completely different ways to determine the number values of specific quantities. The first and most exact way is by direct experimental measurement. This requires significant effort and is not always feasible for two main reasons. First, there is a multitude of system combinations coming into question; and second the measurement techniques themselves in most cases are not simple. Numerous sources of error in the various experimental methods can make the use of published data difficult because it is not always possible to critically evaluate it. The second way to obtain numeric values for specific quantities is a purely deductive approach where calculation of a number value is attempted with the help of theoretical derivations from quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics. Even with modern computing facilities, it is not yet possible to carry out these calculations without a series of simplifying assumptions. Such simplifications can nevertheless have large negative effects on the precision of the calculated results. In practice one is obliged to use yet a third way that goes between the two extremes in order to get useable number values for material-specific properties (Chapter 15). This way touches on the estimation of values with the help of experimentally determined data collections that allow the estimation of values using a series of simplifications and more or less theoretically based assumptions. In view of the often large simplifications used, the results can be astoundingly reliable. Even when estimations obtained in a semi-empirical way are considered only as approximations, they are in practice extremely useful and in many cases the only useful estimation of a property. In the next section it will be shown that even very empirical approximation methods are ultimately based on theoretical foundations. One of the reasons why estimated data can be so reliable is the experience that values for a given substance within a homologous series show a very slow change in their properties. A substance class is designated a homologous series when its individual members have the same structural characteristics and are differentiated only through the number of a repeating structural unit. The simplest example of homologous series is the class of straight chain saturated hydrocarbons, the so-called normal or n-alkanes, . is the number of carbon atoms in with the elementary composition CzH2z+2. Where z a molecule in this series. Specific properties like the melting point and boiling point increase after a certain z value in a predictable way. This behavior is based on the similarity of the repeating structural unit which is a CH2 or methylene group. There are deviations for small z values which are caused by the different behavior of the end CH3 or methyl group. Because of the very slow change of the value within a homologous series, values of individual members that contain errors can be discovered easily and missing values can be estimated by interpolation or extrapolation. Homologous series, and in particular the homologous series of n-alkanes, serve as the backbone for estimating values for various specific properties of organic substances (see Chapter 6 ) . A further reason for the reliability of estimated values is the relative independence of various structural units within a molecule as long as these units or functional atomic groups are not placed too near one another. Using the basis of this relative independence, the possibility exists to simply sum the individual contributions of the characteristic atom groups to give a value for the properties of the substance. However, complications exist due to influences from neighboring groups, which must be taken into account to improve the estimation in the so-called second approximation. As an example, take the di-ketone compound CH3COCH2CH2CH2CH$OCH3, with two identical carbonyl groups in positions 2 and 7. For estimating the value of a specific
Partition coefFcients
89
property, one can in general add the contributions from the carbonyl groups, the methylene and the two methyl end groups to account for the complete structure. If both of the CO groups are neighbors, as for example in the molecule CH3CH2CH2COCOCH2CH2CH3,then there must be a contribution added o r subtracted to account for this, because the two groups influence one another. Despite the complications inherent in adding together structural group contributions of a molecule, which are referred to as structural increments in the following text, these methods are practical and useful for the estimating the values of specific properties. The simplest example of a quantity obtained by the addition of structural increments is the relative molecular mass M , (which is dimensionless and is commonly but not correctly referred to as molecular weight).The relative molecular mass is made up by strict addition of the single atomic masses (atomic weights), A,, and can be calculated using the elemental formula of the substance. The influence of neighboring groups takes no place in calculating molecular mass, because such influences are based on the binding relationships between the atoms and these have no influence on the masses. The relative molecular mass is a dimensionless quantity because it comes from the ratio of the actual molecular mass to the 1/12 atomic mass of the carbon isotope. This is comparable to the molar mass or mole mass M which has the dimensions g mol-'. A further specific quantity that can be calculated by adding together contributions from individual building blocks is the molar volume usually expressed in cm3 mol-'. This is the volume that the mole of a given substance occupies. Compared to mole mass the molar volume is dependent on the physical state of the substance as well as pressure and temperature. As a result there are several difficulties in summing the individual contributions to give molar volume, because along with the volume of individual molecules the spatial volume between molecules must also be considered. The spatial volume is dependent on the state of the system, which means the opposing spatial ordering of molecules in a crystal lattice or liquid. For this reason it is not so easy to give such an exact value for a specific property such as density (specific weight) from M and J! as it is for M and M,. For the following applications, additive quantities are needed that can reproduce the inter-molecular binding relationships, e.g. partition coefficients are based on such relationships. For all additive mole constants there are two generally valid rules: 1. The additive structural increments in either atomic constants or in binding constants can be determined purely by calculation. Secondly, additional values or structural increments can be added for certain structural elements e.g. ring systems, branching and others. 2. The structural increments are considered to be purely calculated quantities for which no simple physical meaning can be established. When putting together a table of additive strutural increments, attention must be given that it does not contain too many values that unnecessarily complicate its application. The most sensible method is to combine several atoms in groups, e.g. into functional groups, for which a constant valuc can be used. By doing this, the table becomes more convenient to use. The additive principle makes it possible to simply sum the group contributions with the help of the following simple formula:
v,
90
Baner
E = Cni Ei
(4-52)
1
where E represents the sum of all molecular increments, nj is the number of a given type of increment and E, is the value of the structural increment i. There already exists a substantial literature devoted to the estimation of various material properties with the help of additive structual increments (Reid et. al, 1987, Van Krevelen, 1990). The regular solution theory in combination with additive structural increments has a wide application for estimating the relative solubilities of organic substances in polymers and the solubility of polymers in various solvents (Barton, 1983) and will be described later in this chapter. When estimating partition coefficient values, one is quickly confronted with this method’s application limits, particularly with polar and non-polar structures, for example the partitioning of substances between polyolefins and alcohol (Baner and Piringer, 1991). A modern set of methods which can be used to estimate partition coefficients is the group contribution method. These methods were developed to allow chemical engineers to estimate activity coefficients in liquid and polymeric systems. Of the numerous methods developed, UNIFAC, the oldest and most thoroughly tested method, is probably the most universally applicable to a wide variety of substances and sytems despite its known weaknesses (Baner, 1999). The use of UNIFAC and example calculations will be described later in this chapter. Given the inaccuracies of the Regular Solution Theory and the large amount of effort required to use the UNIFAC method (that still has inherent errors), a third estimation can be presented. The third approach is largely empirical but leads to accurate values by using simple calculations for the most important practical partitioning cases. The method described in Section 4.3.3, referred to here as the Retention Indices Method, is based on a recognized fact in gas chromatography that the partitioning of a substance between a gas and a polymer liquid can be estimated, based on its structural increments and these can be used as characteristic quantities for identification.
4.3 Estimation of partition coefficients 4.3.1 The regular solution theory For a solute 1 in a pure liquid 1 a solubility parameter designated as 6, can be defined: (4-53) Where IJ, = AH,,, - RT is the molar interaction energy for particles of solute 1 and can be approximated by the molar enthalpy of vaporization expressed at is the molar volume of the pure liquid substance 1. The cohesive temperature T. energy density is expressed by c1 which describes the interaction between the particles of the pure liquid 1. In a two component system it is assumed that the interaction
v,
Partition coefficients
91
between particles 1 and 2 can be approximated by a geometrical average of the interactions between similar particles corresponding to 1-1 and 2-2 so one can use the expression: (4-54)
112)
in which LI2 is a correction factor to represent the deviation from the geometric average. In the first approximation, the positive or negative value of 112 is assumed to be << 1 and thus can be ignored. By doing so it is possible to estimate the solubility parameters of pure substances l and 2 with the help of additive structural increments (for an estimation method see Van Krevelen, 1990). The solubility parameter is valid only for regular solutions (where the excess entropy is equal to zero) and mainly for nonpolar classes of substances. Of the numerous suggested improvements that have been made, the one by Hansen is worth mentioning. Here the solubility parameter is the sum of three parts (Barton, 1983) corresponding to a nonpolar or pure dispersive (&), polar (6,) and hydrogen bonding (6,) based interactions:
62 = 6;
+ 6; + 62,
(4-55)
Table 4-1 contains numeric values for the solubility parameters of different polymers and solvents. From these, the interactions of various combinations can be derived (Barton, 1983, van Krevelen 1990). Table 4-1: Solubility parameters 6 for several plastics and solvents. (Barton, 1983). Range 6
Substance Plastic polyethylene polypropylene polyisobutylene polystyrene polyvinyl chloride polyvinylidene chloride polytetrafluoroethylene polyvinyl alcohol polyvinyl acetate polymethyl methacrylate polyethyl methacrylate pol yacrylonitrile polybutadiene polyisoprene polyformaldehyde polytetramethylene oxide polypropylene oxide polyepichloro hydrine polyethyleneterephthalate poly-%amino caprylic acid bisphenol- A-pol ycarbonate e thylcellulose acetal resin cellulose diacetate
(Jl/21cm”)
15.8 16.8 16.0 17.4 19.2 20.3 12.7 25.8 19.1 18.6 18.2 25.6 16.6 16.2 20.9 17.0 15.4 19.2 19.9 26.0 19.4 17.3 22.6 23.2
17.1 18.8 16.6 19.0 22.1 25.0 29.1 22.6 26.2 18.7 31.5 17.6 20.5 22.5 17.5 20.3 -
21.9 -
21.0
92
Baner
Table 4-1: (continued) Range 6 (J’”lcm”)
Substance
Solvent n-hexane diethylether n-octane methylcyclohexane di-isopropyl ketone cyclohexane s-amylacetate amylacetate methyl-n-butyl ketone methyl-n-propyl ketone xylene toluene mesityl oxide ethyl acetate diacetone alcohol chloroform trichloroethylene tetrachloroeth ylene dichloromethane cyclohexanone cellosolve dioxane carbon sulfide acetone n-octanol butyronitrile n-hexanol pyridine n-butanol isopropanol n-propanol dimethylformamide acetic acid ethanol cresol formic acid methanol phenol glycerin water
14.9 15.1 15.5 15.9 16.3 16.7 16.9 17.3 17.6 17.8 18.0 18.2 18.3 18.6 18.7 19.0 19.0 19.2 19.8 20.2 20.2 20.2 20.4 20.4 21.0 21.4 21.8 22.2 23.2 23.4 23.4 24.7 25.7 26.0 27.1 27.6 29.6 29.6 33.6 47.7
conversion factor: 1 J”2/cm3‘2= 0.49 cn1“21cm’’2
According to the regular solution theory, polymers are as a rule soluble in solvents if their solubility parameters are similar to those of the corresponding solvent. The upper limit for good solubility is defined to be a difference (A6) of 6 units between solubility parameters:
A6 = ((Sl
-
w2)112
or the difference for the three part system of Hansen is calculated:
(4-56)
Partition coefficients
93 (4-57)
Exceptions to this rule are for example the following systems which are not soluble in one another: Polvmer/Solvent
A6
polyvinyl chloride - chloroform polyvinyl chloride -toluene polystyrene - n-heptane polyvinyl acetate - hexane polyvinyl acetate - diethyl ether cellulose - dimethylsulfide
1.6
2.5 2.9 4.3 3.7 5.3
On the other hand polyvinyl acetate is very soluble in methanol even though the difference between the solubility parameters is 9.8. The activity coefficient for a binary solution of solute 1 in solvent 2 is (Hildebrand et al. 1970): (4-58) Eq (4-58) expressed in terms of the Hansen type solubility parameters is:
where the volume fraction $2 is defined as: (4-60) For polymers the solubility coefficient is calculated for the polymer repeat unit. Where no molar volume data exists (e.g. for polymers) then a molar volume group contribution estimation method must be used (Van Krevelen, 1990). The Regular Solution Theory with its solubility parameters gives good qualitative indications of the affinity of organic substances for polymers in terms of mixing, solubility and partitioning. Predictions of activity coefficients and partition coefficients are greatly overpredicted and require empirical corrections to obtain accurate estimations (Baner and Piringer, 1991). Conceptually the Regular Solution Theory is easy to understand and apply. That coupled with it's qualitative correctness has resulted in numerous successful qualitative correlations using solubility parameters to predict the behavior of organic molecules in polymer systems (Barton, 1983). Example 4-1: Qualitative prediction using Regular Solution Theory. Ethyl acetate, acetone and ethanol can be used as solvents for flexographic printing on a plastic pouch containing a fruit flavored liquid beverage which is made from oriented polypropylene (OPP)/low density polyethylene (LDPE) laminate material. Some residual solvent could potentially remain in the plastic after printing. Which of these three solvents is most soluble in the beverage? Which solvent is most soluble in the plastic? Based on the anticipated solubilities in the beverage and plastic which solvent is most likely to migrate into the beverage?
94
Baner
Solution: Calculate the A6 between the three solvents and water (assuming the beverage contains mostly water). Using the solubility parameters given in Table 4-1 calculate the A& using Eq. (4-56): 112 112 Ethyl acetate (l)/water (2): A6 = ((61 - 62)’) = ((18.6 - 47.7)2) = 29.1 Acetone (l)/water(2): A6 = ((61 - 62)2)
112
=
((20.4 - 47.7)2)
112
Ethanol (l)/water (2): A6 = ((61 - 6 ~ ) ~=)((26.0 - 47.7)2)
112 112
= 27.3 = 21.7
Based on the ranking of solubility parameter differences, AS, ethanol would be the most soluble followed by acetone and then ethyl acetate. This is what we would expect based on the complete miscibility of ethanol in water. Calculating the A6 for the solvents in LDPE since LDPE is in direct contact with the drink we can use an average value for LDPE ((15.8 + 17.1)/2 = 16.5): I /2 112 Ethyl acetate (l)/LDPE (2): A6 = ((61 - 6 ~ ) ~=) 18.6 - 16.5)2) = 2.1
((
Acetone (l)/LDPE (2): A6 = ((61 - 62,’) Ethanol (l)/LDPE (2): A6 = ((61 - 6’)2)
112
117.
=
=
((20.4 ((26.0
16.5)’)
-
112
= 3.9
1I 2
-
16.5)2) = 9.5
Ethyl acetate is the most soluble solvent in the plastic based on having the smallest A6 with LDPE. Note that the solubility of these solvents in OPP will not differ greatly from LDPE based on the similar average solubility parameters between OPP and LDPE (17.8 vs. 16.5). From the viewpoint of retention in the plastic (i.e. more likely to have residual solvent problems) ethyl acetate is the least desireable solvent to use in the printing ink. However, from the viewpoint of migration into the beverage it may be the best solvent to use since it is the least soluble in the beverage. Based on this the KP,,. for ethyl acetate will be the largest of the three solvents thus favoring it to be retained by the plastic. One can estimate relative KpIL: for the different solvents between LDPE and water by combining Eqs. (4-35) and (4-58):
Ethyl acetate between LDPEIWater:
K p j= ~
A
~
L 2 9~1
a6 = P
= 13.9
‘I
AGLd
Acetone between LDPE/Water. KP/L = Ethanol between LDPE/Water: K
p j ~ =
~
s p a
A
~
~
Asp,
21 3
= -= 7 3Y
L 2 1~7
= - = 2.3 Y5
From these estimations of relative K p I L one can say that ethyl acetate would be the best choice in terms of the tendency to migrate into the beverage. Other considerations such as taste and odor thresholds may favor ethanol.
4.3.2 UNIFAC Significant effort has been devoted to activity coefficient estimation methods in the fields of chemical engineering, environmental and pharmaceutical research because the necessary experimental data for many substances are not available and are difficult to measure. While there are numerous activity coefficient estimation methods for
Partition coefficient.s
95
liquid solutions there are far fewer activity coefficient estimation methods for polymer systems because of the special problem in defining polymers for modeling. In recent years, several activity coefficient estimation models have been introduced, based on equations of state (Flory 1970, High and Danner, 1990, GCFLORY 1990 by Chen et al. 1990, GCFLORY 1994 by Bogdanic and Fredenslund 1994), statistical mechanics (UNIFAC-FV Oishi and Prausnitz, 1978), quantum mechanical (Mavrovouniotis 1990, Constantinou et al., 1993) and free volume models (ELBRO-FV Kontogeorgis et al., 1993). One of the central problems with estimating activity coefficients in polymer systems is that general observations made for low molecular weight component systems are no longer valid for polymers. It is observed that solution dependent properties are no longer directly proportional to the mole fraction of solute in the polymer at dilute concentrations. For example the solute partial pressure in a system containing a polymer is no longer directly proportional to its mole fraction, which is an apparent deviation from Raoult’s law. Some estimation models work around the difficulty of using mole fractions for polymers by using weight fractions (molal concentration). This avoids the problem of defining what is a mole of polymer. However, even using weight fractions and defining the estimated activity coefficient on a molal basis is not enough to overcome the differences between what is expected from a low molecular weight liquid system and what is experimentally observed in a polymer system. This difference is treated in most estimation models by describing the difference as being due to free volume differences between the polymer and liquid (see for example Flory, 1970, UNIFAC-FV, GCFLORY 1990, GCFLORY 1994, ELBRO-FV). The free volume concept was specifically developed to describe the variation of polymer system properties from those of a liquid system. All current activity coefficient estimation models are by necessity semi-empirical in nature. because too little is known about solution theory for outright estimation. Chemical modeling is not readily available and is not far enough developed to make this type of calculation. The constants required by these models must be estimated using either experimental data (e.g. an infinite dilution activity coefficient or a molar volume) or group contributions derived from experimental data (e.g. interaction constants, molecular volumes and surface areas). The activity coefficient is described in UNIFAC-FV and several other estimation models as being roughly composed of two or three different components. These components represent combinatorial contributions (yf)which are essentially due to differences in size and shape of the molecules in the mixture, residual contributions (yr) which are essentially due to energy interactions between molecules in the solution, and free volume (yf‘) contributions which take into consideration differences between the free volumes of the mixture’s components: (4-61) The combinatorial and free volume contributions can be thought of as being roughly analogous to the excess entropy of mixing. The residual contribution is roughly analogous to the excess enthalpy of mixing. In some models the free volume contribution is treated in a separate term (Eq. (4-61), e.g. UNIFAC and GCFLORY) and in others (ELBRO-FV) the combinatorial and free volume contributions are
96
Baner
essentially combined into the free volume term thus eliminating the combinatorial term. The Regular Solution Theory essentially considers only a residual contribution. The concept of free volume varies on how it is defined and used, but is generally acknowledged to be related to the degree of thermal expansion of the molecules. When liquids with different free volumes are mixed, that difference contributes to the excess functions (Prausnitz et al., 1986). The definition of free volume used by Bondi (1968) is the difference between the hard sphere or hard core volume of the molecule (Vw=van der Waals volume) and the molar volume,
v:
v
-fV-V-VW --
(4-62)
The UNIFAC (Unified quasi chemical theory of liquid mixtures Functional-group Activity Coefficients) group-contribution method for the prediction of activity coefficients in non-electrolyte liquid mixtures was first introduced by Fredenslund et al. (1975). It is based on the Unified Quasi Chemical theory of liquid mixtures (UNIQUAC) (Abrams and Prausnitz, 1975), which is a statistical mechanical treatment derived from the quasi chemical lattice model (Guggenheim, 1952). UNIFAC has been extended to polymer solutions by Oishi and Prausnitz (1978) who added a free volume contribution term (UNIFAC-FV) taken from the polymer equation-ofstate of Flory (1970). The UNIFAC method has a useful temperature range of -23 to 152 "C. The accuracy of infinite dilution estimations for relatively low molecular weight organic mol< 200) averages 20.5 YOfor 3357 low molecular weight compounds (Thomas ecules ( M i and Eckert, 1984), 21 % for 6 compounds in three classes of solvents (Park and Carr, 1987) and 21.1 YOfor 791 series of measurements containing 1773 data points (Weidlich and Gmehling, 1987). Several modifications have been proposed to the UNIFAC model in addition to the free volume contribution already mentioned. Some proposed modifications to the combinatorial and residual terms improve estimations by about 11 YO(Weidlich and Gmehling, 1987, Larsen et al., 1987) but cannot be used for polymers (Fredenslund, 1989). Other UNIFAC modifications have been developed (Bastos et al., 1988, Iwai et al., 1985, Doong and Ho, 1991) that attempt to increase the prediction accuracy of the original model for infinite dilutions, hydrocarbon solubility and swelling/dissolving of semicrystalline polymers. Mixtures of hydrocarbons are assumed to be athermal by UNIFAC, meaning there is no residual contribution to the activity coefficient. The free volume contribution is considered significant only for mixtures containing polymers and is equal to zero for liquid mixtures. The combinatorial activity coefficient contribution is calculated from the volume and surface area fractions of the molecule or polymer segment. The molecule structural parameters needed to do this are the van der Waals or hard core volumes and surface areas of the molecule relative to those of a standardized polyethylene methylene CH2 segment. UNIFAC for polymers (UNIFAC-FV) calculates in terms of activity (ai) instead of the activity coefficient and uses weight fractions
instead of mole fractions, where giis the mass of component i and there are j components in the mixture.
Partition coefficients
97
UNIFAC calculations for polymers Calculations using the UNIFAC-FV model are carried out as follows for a binary mixture of solute (a = 1) dissolved in a solid polymer (P = 2) (Goydan et al., 1989): The activity of the solute, al, is separated into the three components the combinatorial contribution, a;, the residual contribution, a;, and the free-volume contribution, af". (4-63) The combinatorial contribution, hay, accounts for the difference in sizes and shapes of the solution's molecules. To determine it, a group surface area parameter, Q, and a group volume parameter, R , need to be calculated for each component (solute (1)and polymer (2)): (4-64) G
Q2 =
C v!'"'Q(j) J
(4-65)
j=l
(4-66) G
R2 =
C vJ2"'R(j) J
(4-67) j=l The equations for the area and volume of the mixtures can be simplified for binary mixtures: (4-68)
R* = C wiRi/Mi
= wlRI/MI
+W~RZ/ML")
(4-69)
i
where v:') is the number of times a group j occurs in the solute molecule and v;'"') is the number of times group j occurs in each repeat unit of the polymer (rn is usually equivalent to the monomeric unit). The summations are over all groups G. Mland MY) are the molecular weights of the solute and the repeat unit of polymer. w I and w 2 are the weight fractions of the solute and polymer. The properties Q(j) and R(j) are the contributions to the molecular area and volume due to group j and are given in Appendix I1 Table 11-1 for most groups. The configurational term is calculated using the equation:
where $1 and $2 are the volume fractions of solute and polymer in the mixture. 01 and 02 are the solute and polymer surface area fractions.
98
Baner
Z is the coordination number and is usually set to 10 (Fredenslund et al., 1975). The residual contributiong In a;, is related to the group area fraction S(j) and to terms wfj, k)which are functions of the interaction energies between various groups B(j,k) present in the mixture. The solution is treated as if the solution is composed of all the groups in the solute and polymer phase together in one mixture:
[
S(j)= Q(j) (0, /Ql )vil)
w(j, k)
= exp[-B(j,
+ (02/Q2)~,!~"']
(4-73) (4-74)
k/T)]
Note that B(j,k) # B(k,j) and T is in K . Values of B(j,k) are given in Appendix I1 Table 11-2 for many groups. Using Eq. (4-73) and (4-74) the group residual activity coefficient is calculated in the following manner: G
(4-75)
(4-76) where C is once again the number of different groups present in the mixture. The residual activity coefficient of group j in the solute molecule (l),In r;'),is calculated in an identical manner to In rjexcept that w Iis set equal to unity. This assures that In a; is equal to zero as w Iapproaches unity. To determine the free volume contribution, In a?, the following equation is used )] lnafv = 3 c l n [ ( ~ ~ ' ~ - l ) / ( v ~ ~ - l-c{[(vl/vmix)-l]/[l
- ( l / v l ) 1/31}
(4-77) The reduced dimensionless volumes v1 and vn,ix are calculated using the densities in (g/crn-?)of the pure solute and polymer, p1 and p2 at the system's temperature: V I = M1/(15.17.
Vmix =
b . R1 . P I )
[(wI/P~+ ) (~2/~2)1/(15.17'b.R*)
(4-78) (4-79)
where c = 1.1 and b = 1.28 according to the convention set by Oishi and Prausnitz (1978). The weight fraction activity coefficient of a solute i in a polymer is then calculated from the activity by dividing by its weight fraction in a manner analogous to mole fraction activity coefficients: Ri
= ai/wi
(4-80)
Partition coefficients
99
UNIFAC calculations for liquids
In normal liquid solutions where the molar volumes of the solute and the liquid have similar orders of magnitude the free volume term is relatively insignificant and the free volume term in Eq. (4-63) is equal to zero and the mole fraction activity coefficient is calculated directly: In a1 = In a'j + In a1
(4-81)
Since it is more convenient to work in mole fractions ( x i ) with liquid solutions instead of weight fractions ( W J the expressions for the combinatorial contribution for a binary mixture are (Fredenslund et al., 1975): (4-82)
where $1 and $2 are the volume fractions of solute and solvent in the mixture. 01 and 82 are the solute and solvent fractions.
81 = xlQl/M,Q* = 1 - 8 2
(4-86)
Z is the coordination number and is set to 10 by convention (Fredenslund et al., 1975). By definition the activity a is expressed in terms of the mole fraction activity coefficient for a solute i with a mole fraction x of i in the solution as: ai = yixi
(4-87)
Taking t h e exponent of both sides of Eq. (4-81) and substituting in Eq. (4-87), one can write: ai =
= xiyTyf
(4-88)
If one lets a; = xi$ then it follows that at = y:. Thus, in this treatment the residual activity and residual activity coefficient are the same whether or not one expresses concentration in mole fractions or weight fractions.
100
Baner
K p l ~ estimations
using UNIFAC
UNIFAC estimations of activity coefficients were estimated using a BASIC computer program based on a program (Sandler, 1989) modified for allow calculations for polymers (UNIFAC-FV). The modifications added the free volume correction and was altered to calculate weight fraction based activity coefficients (Oishi and Prausnitz, 1978). The program was rewritten using published algorithms (Goydan et al., 1989) for binary polymer/solute solutions and the interaction parameters were updated using the UNIFAC 5th revision interaction parameters (Hansen et al., 1991). The UNIFAC group contribution parameters are found in Appendix I1 Tables 11-1 and 11-2. In UNIFAC calculations the polymer monomer repeat unit is used to represent the chemical structure and molecular weight of the polymer in the polymer activity coefficient calculations. For polyethylene (PE) polymers the density of amorphous PE (pp = 0.85) gave the most accurate estimations for UNIFAC. For other polymers the average densities of typical semi-crystalline commercial polymers were used in UNIFAC calculations. The partition coefficients were calculated using polymer molal activity coefficients and liquid molar activity coefficients using Eq. (4-45). A test set of 6 to 13 aroma compound partition coefficients between different food contact polymers (low density polyethylene (LDPE), high density polyethylene (HDPE); polypropylene (PP), polyethylene terephthalate (PET), polyamide (PA)) and different food simulant phases (water, ethanol, aqueous ethanol/water mixtures, methanol, 1-propanol) were taken from the literature (Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989, Baner, 1992, Franz, 1990, Koszinowski, 1986, Franz, 1991, Baner, 1993, Piringer, 1992). Table 4-2 shows the test set of 13 different aroma compounds, with their properties and their structures. The experimental data were compared to estimations using different estimation methods of UNIFAC-FV, GCFLORY (1990), GCFLORY (1994) and ELBRO-FV. Table 4-3, with partition coefficient estimation results for 13 aroma compounds partitioned between polyethylene (PE) and ethanol, shows an example of the estimation accuracy one can expect comparing UNIFAC to experimental data and the other partition coefficient estimation methods (Baner, 1999). In order to compare the different estimation methods, average absolute ratios of calculated to experimental values were calculated partitioned substances. When the calculated values are greater than experimental values the calculated value is divided by the experimental value. For calculated values less than the experimental values the inverse ratio is taken. Calculating absolute ratios gives a multiplicative factor indicating the relative differences between values of the experimental and estimated data. A ratio of one means the experimental value is equal to the estimated value. The liquid phase and polymer phase activity coefficients were combined from different methods to see if better estimation accuracy could be obtained, since some estimation methods were developed for estimation of activity coefficients in polymers (e.g. GCFLORY, ELBRO-FV) and others have their origins in liquid phase activity coefficient estimation (e.g. UNIFAC). The UNIFAC liquid phase activity coefficient combined with GCFLORY (1990 and 1994 versions) and ELBRO-FV polymer activity coefficients were shown to be the combinations giving the best estimations out of all possible combinations of the different methods. Also included in Table 4-3 are estimations of partition coefficients made using the semi-empirical group contribution method referred to as the “Retention Indices Method” covered in the next section.
Partition coefficients
101
Table 4-2: Aroma compounds studied. Aroma compound
Molecular weight
Experimental van der Waals molar volume molar volume 25 "C (Bondi, 1968)
Saturated Vapor Pressure 25 "C (Pa)
d-limonene
(glmol) 136.24
(mL/mol) 161.08
(mL/mol) 88.35
diphenylmethane
168.23
168.1
101.93
4.61'
linalylace tate
196.23
219.32
124.08
14.2'
camphor
152.23
153.27
96.8
41.5'
diphenyloxide
170.21
isx.99
96.7
2.692
isoamylacetate
130.18
150.39
83.47
723
undelactone
184.28
194.18
117.51
0.457'
Structure
0 I1 I
P eugenol
164.2
153.98
98.98
2.63'
citronellol
156.27
182.77
110.23
5.86'
dimethylbenzyl-carbinol (DMC)
150.22
154.5
94.72
17.42
menthol
156.27
173.63
106.9
16.1'
phenylethylalcohol (PEA)
122.17
120.36
74.31
11.2'
cis-3-hexenol
100.16
118.49
69.26
140'
OH
OH
1) Experimental data from Liley and Gambill 1973, fitted using Miller equation (Bertucco et al., 1991) 2) Estimated using substances with similar retention indices.
5.0
5.2
AAR
AARs.d.
5.6 (11) 6.4 (17) 115 (156)
67 (63) 90 (89) 134 (141)
82 36 20 2.3 13 1.6 3.4 0.034 0.39 0.22 0.24 0.13 0.16 2.8 64 1.8 0.17
Calculated using Eq. (4-103) and Table 4-8.
3.5 (3.2) 2.2 (2.3) 63 (70)
1.2 0.23 0.017
-
0.20 0.0019 0.052 0.0097 0.010 0.040
0.26
0.37 0.096 0.18 0.012 0.48
6.5 (6.8) 3.3 (3.4) 52 (50)
0.22 1.4 0.60 0.097 0.48 0.41 0.32 0.0041 0.15 0.12 0.081 0.11 0.15 0.47 0.60 0.21 0.1 1
97.5
4.77
4.89
-
-
-
-
1.9 1.2 0.34 0.38 0.75 0.26 0.63 0.0010 0.22 0.012 0.23 0.010 0.016
73.9
2.15
2.91
-
-
-
0.027 0.0029 0.0029
-
0.3 0.17 0.074 0.16 0.027 0.053 0.008 -
70.1
1.so
2.01
-
-
0.0095 0.011 0.0071 0.0022 -
-
0.24 0.22 0.075 0.031 0.22 0.021 0.052 0.015
Retention Indices'
Calculated using polymer density = 0.85., (L) = liquid phase activity coefficient. (P) = polymer phase activity coefficient, - not possible to calculate a result AAR = average absolute ratio: for calculated (calc.) > experimental (exp.) = calc./exp.; for calc. < exp. = exp./calc. AAR s.d. = standard deviation of absolute ratio. AAR C.V.YO= % coefficient of variation absolute ratio.
( ) calculated using cyclic group contribution parameters (GCFLORY only)
*
193
9.0
4.7
-
0.92 0.27 0.15 0.21 0.20 0.16 0.32 0.00051 0.019 0.0082 0.017 0.0076 0.015 -
GCFLORY ELBRO-FV UNIFAC (L) UNIFAC (L) UNIFAC (L) Regular (1993) GCFLORY GCFLORY ELBRO-FV Solution (PI (1990) (PI (1994) (PI Theory
' Experimental data from (Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989, Baner, 1992).
YO
AAR C.V. 103
-
0.011 0.25 0.012
-
-
-
-
-
0.0088 0.0037 0.034
4.3 0.040 1.5 0.029 0.52 0.30 0.20 0.0051 0.046
2.18 1.09 0.31 0.36 0.68 0.27 0.66 0.00093 0.018 0.0091 0.019 0.0067 0.014
0.42 0.25 0.065 0.064 0.14 0.0464 0.017 0.013 0.025 0.0062 0.0087 0.0028 0.0024 0.0 17 0.42 0.064 0.0087
d-limonene diphenylmethane linalylacetate camphor diphenyloxide isoamylacetate undelactone eugenol citronellol DMC menthol PEA cis-3-hexenol (undelactone) (limonene) (camphor) (menthol)
UNIFAC-FV GCFLORY (1990)
J
Exper.'
Aroma compound
Table 4-3: Accuracy of partition coefficient estimations for 13 aroma compounds between 100 YOethanol and LDPE.
$
2
8
CI
Partition coefficients
103
This method as its name implies is based on the concept of retention indices from gas chromatography. So far the method only has group contribution units worked out for estimating the partitioning of organic substances between polyolefins in contact with cthanol and water but it gives very good estimations for these systems. Table 4-4 shows examples of average absolute ratios (estimated values to experimental values) and their corresponding standard deviations for several polymer/ aromakolvent systems (Baner, 1999). This is representative of the estimation behavior one can expect from these models and does not include all data tested to date. UNIFAC-FV is the most consistent, most widely applicable and overall gives the most accurate partition coefficient estimations of all the models. However, the UNIFAC model partition coefficient estimations here are less accurate than the 20 % variation reported in the literature (Thomas and Eckert, 1984; Park and Carr, 1987) for solute in solvent activity coefficient data. GCFLORY (1990) could not estimate water and polar polymer (PVC, PET, no amide group for polyamide) containing systems well. GCFLORY (1994) is very similar to GCFLORY (1990) but made worse estimations because it was not intended to be used for estimating activity coefficients in low molecular weight liquids. When the GCFLORY polymer activity coefficient was used with the liquid phase activity coefficient from UNIFAC, partition coefficient estimations were significantly improved. The GCFLORY models had cyclic and aliphatic group contribution terms. Calculations were made for four different ring-containing aroma compounds using both cyclic and aliphatic groups to see if there was any advantage of one set of groups over the other for these estimations. In most cases the results were very similar, either slightly better or slightly worse. ELBRO-FV cannot model water as a solvent, otherwise it was often better than UNIFAC-FV in accuracy. For water-containing systems UNIFAC liquid activity coefficient estimations should be used with ELBRO-FV polymer activity coefficients. The scope of application of the Regular Solution Theory is limited only to estimating solute partitioning in PE/ethanol systems. The Retention Indices system is currently only developed for PE/ethanol and PE/water systems. Their better accuracy is not surprising since they are essentially correlations of this experimental data. The UNIFAC-FV semi-empirical thermodynamic based group contribution model can be used estimate partition, solubility and permeability coefficients for small solute molecules (molecular weight < 300) with average accuracies ranging from 2.9 (ethanol liquid contact phase) to 17.7 (water liquid contact phase) times greater or smaller than experimental values. Considering partition coefficients can vary over six to seven orders of magnitude (see Chapter 9) this variation provide an order of magnitude accuracy. The method is applicable to a wide range of polymer, liquids and solutes and allows estimation of activity coefficients based solely on the molecular structures and densities of the system’s components. UNIFAC-FV is recommended over the other partition coefficient estimation models because of the availability of commercial programs, overall accuracy, and broader range of application. UNIFAC is widely used and continuously being improved as evidenced by the large amount of literature published on it. Although UNIFAC has some inherent weaknesses, i.e. it is based on regression of available experimental data and there are assumptions (solution of groups) that may limit its accuracy for certain systems; it is more universally applicable. Combining other activity coefficient estimation models with UNIFAC may lead to increased estimation accuracy for some systems but the extra effort is not justified for the small increase in accuracy.
59 c:62
1380 c:922
(27)
(1.8)
(11)
(2.9)
(2.7)
5.8
14
2.9
12
4.5
6.1
73 c:27
100
-
-
127 c:127 -
1598
4.7
(181) (178)
(147) (130) 24
5.7
(199) (199)
Experimental data from (Franz. 1990).
(3.8)
7.0
9.1
(3.5)
7.9
169
-
-
620 c:4.8
(3.1) 250 4.6
122 c:131
(53)
(12)
5.5 c:4.6
(12)
10.2 (6.2)
(480) (4.0)
(1220) (4.6)
(334) (347)
(6.6) (6.3)
(10.0) (3.9)
UNIFAC (L) GCFLORY (PI (1990) 3.5 (2.2) c:3.2 (2.3)
(21) (17)
(6.3) (6.8)
(75) (75)
15 15
16
-
-
(18)
(18)
3.3 (3.3) c:3.4 (3.2)
16 c:14
9.9 c:ll
45 c:43
U N F A C (L) GCFLORY (P) (1994) 6.5 (3.3) c:6.8 (3.4)
c calculated using cyclic group contribution parameters (GCFLORY only). -not possible to calculate a result AAR = average absolute ratio: for calculated (calc.) > experimental (exp.) = calc./exp.; for calc. < exp. = exp./calc. ( ) = AAR s.d. = standard deviation of absolute ratio.
' Experimental data from (Franz, 1991)
(9.0)
10
2 . 6 ~ + 6 ( 3 . 2 ~ + 6 ) 4.4 c:3.6E+6 (4.3E+6)
73 c:68
133 c:115
-
(85) (49)
(2210) (2240)
(122) (122)
(15) (21)
(90) (89)
ELB RO-FV
653000 1.9Ec6 4.2E+19 (l.lE+20) c:653000 (1.9E+6)
67 c:(63)
GCFLORY (1993)
' Experimental data from (Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989, Baner, 1992), ' Experimental data from (Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989),
8.5
9.2 c :l l
(6.8)
17.7
Average AAR:
8060 (24300) c:2120 (607)
(6.4) (17)
(30.3)
5.6 c:ll
(5.2)
5.0
PE (pp=0.918) /13 aromas1 100 % Ethanol' PE (pp = 0.918) /13 aromas/ 100 oh water* PP (pp = 0.902) 113 aromasll00 % Ethanol PVC (pp = 1.36) 113 aromasllO0 % Ethanol2 PET (pp = 1.37) 17 aromas/100 Methanol' PET (pp = 1.37) 17 aromas1100 % 1-PropanoC PA (pp = 1.14) 16 aromas1100 YO Methanol" PA (pp = 1.14) /7 aromasll00 % l-~ropanol~
GCFLORY (1990)
UNIFAC-FV
Partition System
(22)
(3.8)
(8.2)
(5.0)
10.3
12
6.6
18
4.1
(26)
(6.6)
5.8 13
(29)
18
UNIFAC (L) ELBRO-FV (P) 4.89 (4.8)
Table 4-4: Average absolute ratios of estimated aroma compound partition coefficients between polymers and solvents.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Regular Solution Theory 2.9 (2.2) 5.8
2.3
-
-
-
(4.3)
(1.6)
Retention Indices
5L
2 g
P
0
P
105
Partition coefficients
Example 4-2: Calculation using UNIFAC. Estimate the polymer/liquid partition coefficient for cis-3-hexenol between a package with a LDPE material food contact layer. The package contains a food system whose partitioning characteristics can be simulated using 100 % ethanol at 2.5 “C. Use the UNIFAC activity coefficient estimation method and assume a dilute solution ( x , w , z 0.00001). The system’s components have the following characteristics: density p”
(g/cm3)
Component
M , (r/mol)
:is-3 hexenol
100.16
0.8947
LDPE (monomer)
28.05
Ethanol
46.07
0.85 0.785
”‘
Molecular Structure - [CHrCHzl.CH3-CHz-OH
OH
In order to begin calculations using UNIFAC it is necessary to have the corresponding group contribution parameters. The necessary group volume (Rk) and surface (Qk) parameters can be found in Appendix 11 Table 11-1: Group
Rk
CH3
0.9011
2
CHz
3
CH=CH
4
OH
1
Qh
cis 3 hexenol Frequency
LDPE Frequency
Ethanol Frequency
V,
V,
V,
0.848
1
0
1
0.6744
0.540
3
2
1
1.1167
0.867
1
0
0
1.00
1.20
1
0
1
The interaction group contribution parameters B(j,k) and B(k,j) are obtained from Appendix 11 Table 11-2: ~
~
CH2
c=c
OH
CH2
0
86.02
986.5
c=c
-35.36
0
OH
156.4
457.0
k
37.85 0
First it is necessary to calculate the group area parameters (Q,) and the group volume parameters ( R , )for each component of the system using Eqs. (4-64) to (4-67). Let 1 be cis 3-hexenol, 2 be LDPE and 3 be ethanol: G
QI =
v/”Q(j) = 1 Q(CH3) + 3 . Q(CH2)+ 1 . Q(CH = CH) + 1 .Q ( 0 H ) =
I-1
1 ‘ 0.848 + 3 ’ 0.540 + 1 - 0.867 + 1 ’ 1.20 = 4.535 G
Q. = C v~2””Q(j) = 2 Q(CH2) = 2 ‘0.540 = 1.080 J=I
G
Q3 =
1v;l)Q(j) = I .0.848 + 1 .O.S40+ 1 . 1.20 = 2.588 ]=I
106
Baner G
+ 3 R(CH2) + 1 R(CH = CH) + 1 1 .0.9011 + 3'0.6744 + 1 . 1.1167 + 1 . 1.0 5.041
R I = C v;')R(j) = 1 . R(CH3)
R(0H)=
j= I G
(2mi
RZ = C vj
R(j) = 2 . R(CH2) = 2 0.6744 = 1.3488
j=1 G
R I = C vj(')R(j) = 1 . R(CH3) j=1
+ 1 . R(CH2) + 1 . R ( 0 H ) = 0.9011 + 0.6744 + 1 .O = 2.5755
The areas and volumes of the mixtures are then calculated using Eq. (4-68) and (4-69):
Simarly one gets 0,056175 and 0.055904 for Q;-,and R;-3. Next the volume ($) and area (0) fractions of the components in the mixtures need to be calculated using Eq. (4-71) and (4-72): +j-2 $1-3
$2-1
1E - 5 '5.041 - 1.046678 - 5 100.16~0.048086I E - 5.5.041 = W I R I / M I R *= - 9.00284E - 6 100.16~0.055904and $3-1 E 0.99999 = w ~ R I / M I R= '
1E - 5'4.535 - 1.1760E - 6 100.16 0.038503 1E - 5 '4.535 - 8.0601E - 6 = wiQi/MiQ* = 100.16 .0.056175 and C l - 1 GX 0.99999
= WQ,/M~Q* = 01-3 02-1
Now using Equation (4-70) the combinatorial activity contribution is calculated for cis 3-hexenol(1) in LDPE (2):
In aTL2 = In $1 + $2 + (z/2)Q1 [In (el /$I 1 - 1 t $1/0~1 = In (1.04667E - 5 ) + 0.99999 + T 10 .4.535 . [In ( ~ , , l -1 ~ + ~~!~~) 1,1760E = -10.3193 Using Eq. (4-84) the combinatorial activity contribution, In can be calculated for cis 3-hexenol(l) in ethanol (3)with the result In a;-,= -11.6546. Next the residual contribution, In a;_z, must be calculated for cis 3-hexenol in LDPE using Eqs. (4-73) through (4-76). First the group area fractions. O(j), for cis 3-hexenol in LDPE need to be calculated (Eq 4-73): Wj) = Q(j) [(%/Ql)v,!I' t (WQ2)vj2"']
1.1769E - 5 0.99999 4.535 . 41 = 2.1989E 1.1769E - 5 0.99999 4.535 . + '21 = O(CH2) = (0.540) 1.1769E - 5 0.99999 O(CH = CH) = (0.867) 4.535 ' .o] = 2.2482E -
6(CH1) = (0.848)
[( [(
) )
[(
+
)
(m) (m) +
(m)
Partition coefficients
iY(OH) = (1.2)
[(
1.1769E
~
4.s3s
5
)
.1
0.99999 + (m) ,0 ] = 3.1 117E
~
107
6
Similarly the group area fractions, S(j),for cis 3-hexenol in ethanol are also calculated:
a(CH3) = 0.32767 IS(CH2) = 0.20866 S(CH = CH) = 2.24819E - 6 lY(OH) = 0.46368 f i e interaction energy functions, w(j, k ) , between the various subgroups j and k are calculat:d using the values of B(j,k) takcn from Appendix I I Table 11-2 (Eq. 4-74):
w(j. k ) = r:xp[-B(j, k)/T] 46.02
v(CH2,CH = CH) = cxp[-=] ~ ( C H OH) Z ? =cxp-
E]
v(CH = CH, OH) = exp
=
1.3344; yr(CH = CH,CH2) = exp
= 0.03656:
yr(OH,CH2) = exp
= 0.8808; yf(OH,CH =
Next the In ri and In terms are calculated for the number (G) of different groups (j). Note that the interaction w(j, k) of a groups j and k from the same group or itself (see Appendix I1 Tables 11-1 and 11-2) is one. Calculating thc In r-for the CH3 group in the cis 3-hexenol/LDPE system as an example one gets using Eq. (4-35):
'
1 - In[8(CHq) + 19(CHz)+ 19(CH = CH)v(CH = CH, CH?) + B(OH)v(OH, CH3)]-
WCHq) 19(CH?)+ fl(CH2) + 19(CH = CH)v(CH = CH, CH3) + IY(OH)~(OH. CH?) 1 8 CH 3 ) *(CHI) + 19(CHz)v + 19(CH = CH)v(CH = CH. CH?) + f?(OH)v(OH. CHz) s(CH = CH)v(CHq. CH = CH) B(CH%)v(CH3, CH = CH) + B(CH:)y(CHZ. CH = CH) + 79(CH = CH) + B(OH)v(OH, CH = CH) i?(OH)v(CH,. OH)
. B(CH?)v(CH+OH) + 19(CH*)v(CH2.OH) + 6(CH = CH)v(CH = CH. OH) + 19(OH) 1 - 1n[2.199E~+0.9999+2.24X~~~O.XXX2+3.112E4~0.591X]-
2.199E4 2.1 9YE-6+0.9999+2.248Ed .0.8882+3 1 I2E44.5918 0.9999 = 0.848 2.199Ed+O.Y999+2.24XEd~0.8882+3.112E-6~0.5918 2.24XE4.1.3344 2.199E4~1.3344+0.9999~1.3344+2.248E-6+3.112Ed~ 0.2159 3.1 1 2 E d 0.03656 2.1 99E4~0.03656+0.9999.0.03656+2.248E-6~0.8808+3. I12E4
=o
108
Baner
The remainder of the In rj terms are calculated in a similar manner. The In r:') terms are also calculated in a similar manner however the weight fraction of the component (solute, polymer or liquid) are set equal to one when calculating the component area (8) fractions and group area fractions, S(j). It quickly becomes apparent when calculating the residual contribution that UNIFAC calculations are best carried out with the help of a computer. The residual activity contribution for cis 3-hexenoULDPE is then calculated using Eq. (4-76):
1 . (0 - 0.20757) + 3 . (0 - 0.13218) + 1 . (0.14094 - 0.27521) + 1 . (4.45957 - 1.07926) = 2.6419 The residual activity contribution for cis 3-hexenol in ethanol calculated in exactly the same way is: In a\ = 0.28995. For systems containing polymers the free volume activity contribution must be calculated to account for the large differences between molecules. First the reduced dimensionless volumes v1 and vmiXare calculated using the densities in (g/ cm3) of the pure solute and polymer, pl and pz at the system's temperature using Eq. (4-78) and (4-79):
Then the free volume contribution can be calculated using Eq. (4-77):
3 . 1.1 , In
I(1.1437II3
-
1)/(1.2599\"
c{ [(1.1437/1.2599) - 1]/[1
-
-
1)]-
(1/1.1437)1i3]) = 0.47306
With the necessary contributions calculated then the activities and activity coefficients can be calculated. For solutions with polymers Eq. (4-63) is used: In al = In af +In a; a1 = 7.434E - 4
+ In a? = -10.3193 + 2.6419 + 0.47306 = -7.2043
By definition we can calculate the weight fraction activity coefficient of cis 3-hexenol in LDPE: 7 4.1358-4 Q1-* = "i= = 74.34 WI o.oow1 Using Eq. (4-81) the activity coefficient of cis 3-hexenol in ethanol is calculated: In al = In a; + In a; = -11.6546 al = 1.1598E - 5
+ 0.28995 = - 11.3647
By definition (Eq. 4-87) the activity coefficient is calculated by dividing the activity by the mole fraction:
Since a molal activity coefficient has been calculated for the solute in the polymer phase and a molar activity coefficient calculated for the liquid phase Eq. (4-45) should be used to calculate the polymedliquid partition coefficient:
Partition coefficients yt.Y,.p, KP/L=
- 1 159X.(58.688 cm’/mol) -
(0.85 g/cniz)
74.34.1100. I6 g/mol)
109
= 0.00777
vL,
Note the molar volume of the liquid phase. is calculated by dividing the molecular weight by the density of the liquid at the test temperature of 25 “C. The result is about three times higher than the experimental value of 0.0024 shown in Table 4-3.
Limitutions of UNIFAC and future work Some apparent problems appear when using the UNIFAC method for large molecular weight solute molecules ( M , < 300) as shown in Table 4-5. UNIFAC-FV underpredicts experimental data by several orders of magnitude for large additive molecules. The polymer weight fraction activity coefficients can become very large (e.g. R > 1E+4) while the liquid phase activities can become very small (e.g. y < 1E-4) giving very small partition coefficients. One suspected error is the free volume term in UNIFAC-FV which requires using “liquid” densities for pure large solute molecules. Normally these molecules are solid at room temperatures so the liquid densities are estimated from estimated liquid molar volumes at 25°C. If the free volume term is left out of the polymer activity coefficient calculations some improvement in estimation accuracy can be observed (last column Table 4-5) compared to UNIFAC-FV. However, not all the estimation error comes from the free volume estimation difficulty, it is well known that the solution of groups concept used in UNIFAC cannot account for stearic hindrances of the multiple functional groups like those present in complex additive molecular structures. Failing to account for the effect of stearic hindrances in the solute molecule causes the activity coefficient in the polymer phase to be overestimated (i.e. the system deviates widely from an ideal system). Partition coefficients for small molecules ( M i< 300) partitioned between solvents and polymers are relatively insensitive to changes in temperature and remain fairly constant over the temperature range from 10 to 40 “C (Baner, 1992). This fact is also observed in UNIFAC calculations which shows very slight increases in partition coefficients with increasing temperature for small molecules over this temperature range. Partition coefficients for larger solute molecules like polymer additives ( M i > 300) on the other hand are known to decrease with increasing temperature as the solubility of these large solute molecules increases faster in the solvent phase relative to that in the polymer phase. Contrary to this experimental observation, UNIFAC predicts partition coefficient will increase slightly for large solute molecules over this temperature range (10 to 40 “C). UNIFAC partition coefficient calculations were carried out for the same group of additives in Table 4-5 but partitioned between LDPE and a representative corn oil triglyceride (composed of one oleic fatty acid and two linoleic fatty acids). The polymer/oil partition coefficients ranged from 0.058 for phenol to 4.1E-9 for Irganox 1010 using UNIFAC-FV and from 0.060 for 2,6-t-butylphenol to 1.OE-6 for Irganox 1010 for UNIFAC without the free volume term. From experimental migration measurements one expects partition coefficients for these additives between LDPE and oil to be close to one. Once again partition coefficients of large molecules ( M i > 300) are several orders of magnitude too small. More complete testing of UNIFAC or the other group contribution method partition coefficient estimations for polymer additives between polymers and food simulants is currently limited by the lack of experi-
110
Baner
Table 4-5: UNIFAC prediction of polymer additive tions.
KpiL
between LDPE and ethanol (ETOH) solu-
Molecular Wt. Experimental UNIFAC-FV UNIFAC
Additive
Liquid Phase
Phenol
100 Yo ETOH
94.11
0.0026"
0.0020
0.0020
p-Cresol
100 % ETOH
108.15
0.0056"
0.00 12
0.0017
2,4,6-TrimethylphenoI
100 % ETOH
136.11
0.019"
0.00064
0.0016
2,3,5,6-Tetramethylphenol 100 YOETOH
150.11
0.03"
0.00045
0.0016
2,4-Di-t-butylphenol
100 Yo ETOH
206.32
0.016"
0.0031
0.0039
2.6-Di-t-butylphenol
100 % ETOH
206.00
0.13"
0.0031
0.0039
2,6-Di-t-butyl-4-methylphenol (BHT)
100 YOETOH
220.36
0.19a
0.0028
0.0038
3.5-Di-t-butyl-4-hydroxy- 100 % ETOH benzoicacid-(2,4-di-t-butylphenyl-) ester (Tinuvin 120) 1,1,3-Tris(2-methyl-4100 % ETOH hydroxy-5-t-butylphenyl) butane (Topanol)
438.42
0.045"
1.62E-6
0.0021
544.82
0.00031a
2.68-12
3.9E-8
220.5
-
0.0018
0.0025
2-Hydroxy-4n-octyloxyben- 95 % aqueous zophenone (Chimassorb 81) ETOH
326
-
o.Ooo10
0.00012
95 % aqueous ETOH
515
-
0.64b
0.64b
Octadecyl-3-(3,5-di-t-butyl- 95 % aqueous 4-hydroxyphenyl) ETOH propionate (Irganox 1010)
1178
-
1.7E-15
4.5E-13
fdm4
BHT
dilauryl thiodipropionate (Irganox PS 800)
95 YOaqueous ETOH
KWL
a = experimental data from Koszinowski (1986b) b = UNIFAC missing interaction parameter between groups (parameter set to zero) -no experimental data available
mental partition coefficient data. The estimation of partition coefficients of plastic additives will remain an active area for future research.
4.3.3 The retention index system Because of the lack of quantitativeness of the Regular Solution Theory and large amount of effort and computing power required for the UNIFAC method, yet another way will be taken here. This way leads to values using simple means which can adequately estimate values for the most important practical cases. The method described in this section is based on the potential already recognised in gas chromatography that the partition of a substance between a gas and a polymer liquid can be estimated based on its structural increments and these can be used as characteristic quantities for identification.
Partition coefficients
111
A dimensionless molecular retention index M , parameter can be defined as the sum of M , (relative molecular weight) and a structural increment W. Contained in W are all the additive contributions of the functional groups (see Eq. 4-52) which differ from a hypothetical n-alkane with the same M , value. According to definition, the W values of the n-alkanes are always equal to zero. In this manner it is possible to estimate the partition coefficients of any given organic compound between a gas and any given liquid or polymer with help of additive structural increments. From the definition of the molecular retention index M,(i) for a substance i (Piringer et al., 1976): (4-89) the gadliquid partition coefficient K(G,,2)(i)can be represented as the ratio of the concentration of i in gas G and liquid L using the following expression: (4-90) The corresponding partition coefficients of two neighboring n-alkanes with z and z 1 carbon atoms are designated with K ( c ; , ~ ) ( zand ) K(G,L)(z + l), and one can assume for a homologous series of n-alkanes with good approximation that the ratio:
+
(4-91) is constant. M , ; and M,, are the relative molecular masses of i and z. An analogous expression can be used for the partition coefficient K(G/P)(i)of i between gas G and polymer P: (4-92) Experimental data measured over the last two decades show that the W ,value of a substance i for different polymers vary only slightly from one another if the polymers possess little or no polarity. Based on this observation one can use the W values for estimating of KG/Land KG,p values in nonpolar liquids and polymers, e.g. polyolefins, that are determined with the help of gas chromatography using a nonpolar separation column. A further advantage of using the retention index system is the very slight temperature dependence of the W value. As a result W values can be determined by gas chromatography at relatively high temperatures without causing significant error for partition estimates at room temperature. A series of W values is collected in Table 4-6 for different common structural groups. OV-101 is a alkylpolysiloxane, a non-polar gas chromatography stationary phase, and C-20M a polyethylene glycol with a molecular weight of approximately 20,000 which is considered a polar gas chromatography stationary phase. The W; value of the substance i is a measure of the interaction between the different atomic groups in the molecule i and the molecules in L or P. Positive W values mean a stronger attraction to the L or P molecule compared to a n-alkane of the same molecular mass and consequently a stronger retention. Negative W values mean the
112
Baner
Table 4-6 W values of several structural units for a polar (C-20M) and a nonpolar (OV-101) stationary phase and for water (Piringer, 1993). W,-values Structural Unit
ov-101 (non-polar)
C-20M (polar)
Water (hydrogen bonding)
alkane
0
0
0
branching
-6 to 4
-8 to -3
-10 to -5
double bond
0-6
6-14
74
cis > trans
cis > trans
cis > trans
ring
8-12
22-26
-
aromatic ether
13-17 4 to +4
51-71 7-12
-
ester
4 5 to -1
27-46
360
aldehyde, ketone
8-16
47-59
360-390
230
tertiary-alcohol
2
411-53
-
secondary-alco hol
10
6&71
440
primary-alcohol
20
78-92
470
nitrile
20
87-106
-
uhenol
-
18CL190
560
opposite where there is a relative repulsion, e.g. in the case of a bulky i molecule. Expressed in the units of relative molecular mass, the positive W values can also be considered to act like additional relative masses or retention weight. In more polar liquids and polymers the W values of polar substances increase sharply while the W vaIues for branching and other steric hindrances remain practically constant. In polyethylene glycol, e.g. in Carbowax 20-M, one can see in Table 4-6 there are greatly increased W values for polar groups compared with W values in nonpolar liquids. As expected, due to its chemical nature, water has the largest W value (Table 4-6). In order to be able to estimate the partition coefficient of a substance i according to Eq. (4-90) or (4-92), the W values for i in L or P, the value for KGIL(z)and the ratio KG/L(z)/KG/~(z + 1)= bG/b or the corresponding value for the gas/polymer system must be determined. This is possible with the help of Eqs. (4-48) and (4-49) if the corresponding values for the vapor pressures and activity coefficients of z and z + 1 as well as the densities are known. The vapor pressure of pure n-alkanes can be readily calculated using an empirical formula based on the Antoine equation in Eq. (4-93) (Piringer, 1993): logp,+,== 7.3029 -
(4-93)
where (4-94)
Partition coefjcicirnts
113
and where z is the number of carbon atoms in the n-alkane molecule, the temperature Tis in K , e = exp(1) = 2.718 and the pure vapor pressure is given in mmHg (1 mmHg = 133.322Pa). The corresponding activity coefficients,yL,a,for n-alkanes can be calculated based on the model presented in Chapter 6 (Piringer, 1993). For a solution of a n-alkane with z carbon atoms in a n-alkane with x carbon atoms on gets with a=z and LFX:
$:..
Wx.e
J k e
(4-95)
. wx,e
where
For estimating the activity coefficient, y;,=, of a n-alkane with z carbon atoms in polyethylene one can use with a=z and x=P: In yz.z = 1 -
(4-97)
In this discussion it is assumed that the polymer behaves like a liquid and this assumption is only correct above the polymer's melting temperature. However, the aggregate condition of the polymer has a negligible influence on the ratio KG,P(Z)/KG/P(Z + 1). In the case of polar liquids and polymers an estimation of the activity coefficients for z and z + 1 in L or P can be tried using another method, e.g. the UNIFAC method. If this is not possible then both the partition coefficient for z and z + 1 in the gaslliquid or gas/polymer system must be experimentally determined. For the relatively volatile alkanes this is possible without a great amount of work. The necessary values for applying Eq. (4-92) for the estimation of KC/p(i) can be calculated for the nonpolar polyolefins. To do this one sets z = 7, i.e. selects heptane as the reference alkane, o b t a i n s ~from ~ , ~Eq. (4-93), y$,pfrom Eq. (4-97) and KG/P(7) from Eq. (4-49). K P , ~ ( 8for ) n-octane is calculated in the same manner. With the corresponding densities for heptane and n-octane at 25 "C, p7 = 0.68 and px = 0.70, and with Mr,7 = 100 and M,.x = 114, one obtains both values KG/p(7) = 2.5 x and KC;,^(^) = 9 . 4 ~ 1 0 From ~. Eq. (4-91) one obtains bC/p = 0.42 and consequently according t o Eq. (4-92) it follows that: logK,/,(i)
=
-2.6
-
14 (WIG/') 0.42
+ Mr.,
-
100)
(4-98)
For the structural increment Wp" the values given in Table 4-6 for the nonpolar % Wpv-lO1.The estimated values using Eq. (4-98) for phases can be used, i.e. W ": several partition coefficients are given in the first column of Table 4-7. One must pay particular attention to aqueous systems because the activity coefficients of n-alkanes in water increase rapidly with increasing chain length. Even short chain n-alkanes have very large activity coefficients and as a result the partition coefficients of the n-alkanes in gadwater systems (L = W) KGIL(1')also increase rapidly with chain length (Fig 4-1). The increase in the activity coefficient overides the decrease in the artial pressure p*(i). For this reason one can define a molecular retention index M f ) for such systems using the following equation:
114
Baner
Table 4-7: Several examples of estimated values of gasipolyolefin, gadwater, and polyolefin/water partition coefficients calculated using Retention Indices. Solute (i)
Km4)
limonene
1.4.104
Kc/w(i) 5.5
3.9'104
diphenylmethane
4.6.1O4
0.078
1.7'104
isoamylacetate phenylethyl alcohol
5.5'104 4.8. 1WS
0.024 2.5 ' lo4
4.3.10' 0.05
n-heptanol
2.1 ,104
0.001
4.8
Kpdi)
n-dodecanol
1.6. 10-'
0.005
3.1. lo3
n-tetradecanol
2.2. lor7
0.010
4.5.104
n-octanal
1.6.104
0.027
1.7.102
n-decanal
2.2 ' 10-5
0.039
1.8.103
n-dodecanal
3.2,10-'
0.080
2.5.104
2
2
Figure 4-1: The partition coefficients of n-alkanes in the gadalkane and gadwater systems.
(4-99) Using this equation the partition coefficient KGw(i) can be estimated for known values of wjW):
While polar functional groups in molecule i (positive W values) lead to a decrease in the K value, the nonpolar organic molecule structure acts to increase the value due to its repulsive effect on the polar water (high activity coefficient value of n-alkanes). Table 4-6 contains WIW)values for several structural characteristics. Using n-heptane as a reference substance (z = 7) one obtains from Eq. (4-100) at 25 "C: log KG/W(i) = 2
-
(wi(w) -
Mr3i+ 100)
(4-101)
Partition cotfficients
115
and is consequently a directly applicable expression for estimating partition coefficients in gadwater systems. The partition coefficient values in the third column of Table 4-7 were estimated using Eq. (4-101). In the last column of this table are the estimated partition coefficient values for i in a polyolefinlwater system calculated by dividing the KG/Wby K<;,p to get KPIW(Eq. 4-35). The application of structural increments follows the principal of additivity according to Eq. (4-52) when the individual atomic groups are far enough apart that they have no significant influence on one another. Phenylethyl alcohol for example, is composed of additive Wvalues contributions from both the aromatic and primary alcohols. For neighboring groups, e.g. diphenyl methane, the two groups exert an opposite influence on one another (hindrance) leading to a reduction in the sum of the Wvalues. In such cases the average of the Wvalues of two neighboring increments is multiplied b a factor of 1.5. For diphenylmethane in a gadwater system this means for example, Wi ’=1.5(230 + 230)/2 = 345 and for benzylacetate W,iW)=1.5(230 + 360112 = 442.5. The increment value of a double bond on the other hand is added without any further reduction. From the examples contained in Table 4-7 one sees that KG/p(i)values are decreasing within a homologous series with increasing chain length. The decrease is a result of the decrease in the vapor pressure. In comparison, for the gadwater system K G N ( i ) values increase, because the interaction with polar water decreases with increasing nonpolar chain length. The consequence for the behavior in the polyolefidwater system, and consequently for a significant portion of the food packaging cases, are rapidly increasing K p ~ ( ivalues ) as the molecular weights of the migrating components increase. This is valid for substances containing polar groups like alcohols and phenols and in particular for phenols with large M , , values used as antioxidants shielded by bulky tert-butyl groups. The equilibrium concentration of such substances in water is for this reason so small that their migration into aqueous systems is insignificant. Ethanol and aqueous ethanol mixtures play important roles as food simulants for the determination of migration of substances from packaging into foods. Depending on the polarity of the plastic one can use pure ethanol (for nonpolar plastics) or aqueous ethanol mixtures up to 50/50% (for polar plastics) as alternative simulants to edible oils (see Chapters 9, 10 and 11). The estimation of partition coefficients in polymerlsimulant systems is consequently of practical importance. It is possible to do this for polyolefins in contact with alcohol and aqueous alcohol mixtures with the help of an equation analogous to Eq. (4-100) (Piringer, 1993):
x
log Kp/L(i) = log K p / ~ ( z )-
A (WiPiL)
-
Mr,i
+
100)
(4- 102)
whereby n-heptane is chosen as the relative alkane (z = 7) and consequently M,(z) = 100. For LDPE and ethanol or methanol as well as various ethanollwater mixtures at 23 “C the corresponding values for hP/[-= KP/L(Z+ l)/KP,L(~)= 0.1 and log KPIL(7)= -0.60 and one obtains from Eq. (4-102): log Kp/L(i) = -1.31
-
0.0071 (W!piL)
-
M,
(4-103)
The W(”/’-) values for several structural increments in polyolefin/ethanol and polyolefin/methanol are given in Table 4-8.
116
Baner
Table 4-8: Wi values for several structural increments in polyolefin/ethanol and polyolefin/methanol systems (Piringer, 1993).
w,'P/I.I
Structural Increment alkane
0
20
double bonds aromatics ether
50 20
ester aldehyde, ketone
180 180
tert-alcohol sec-alcohol
200
primary-alcohol and phenol acids
250 270 330
2,6-dimethyl phenol 2,6-di-tert-butyl phenol nitrile
190 140 130
The summation of the increments takes place in the manner described above whereby neighboring groups are multiplied by a reduction factor of 1 3 2 = 0.75. If there are three neighboring groups that must be taken into consideration, e.g. in a dia+ lkylphthalate, then one follows the following measures (Table 4-8): 1.5 (Waromatics Weste,)/2= 1.5 (50 + 180)/2 = 172.5 = W,; W,,ta1 = 1.5 (W, + WeSt,,)/2 = 1.5 (172.5 + 180)/2= 264.4. Simple double bonds (W = 20) in conjugation with other double bonds, e.g. in styrene (Wstyrene= 50), or in a,p unsaturated carbonyl compounds, (Wcarbonyl = 180) are not included in the calculations. In this way a very limited number of increments can be used to estimate a large number of different structures. Many stearic effects, e.g. branching, must not be taken into consideration because they exert similar effects in gadwater as well as in gas/liquid systems and are canceled out in KplL= KG/L/KG/P. For the compounds contained in Table 9-7 the calculated KP1~(i)values using Eq. (4-103) are listed next to the experimental values. Example 4-3: Partition calculationusing retention indices. Calculate the partition coefficient of cis-3-hexenol between LDPE and water and between LDPE and 100 YOethanol. To calculate the cis-3-hexenol LDPE/water partition coefficient use Eqs. (4-98), (4-101) and Eq. (4-50). The W ivalues are taken from Table 4-6.
0.42 -(20 +3 14 KGIP(i)= 5.07E - 4 - 2.6 -
+
100.16
-
100) = -3.2948,
Note that the increments for the hydoxyl and double bond groups are additive and that the average value for the group contribution of the double bond has been used.
Partition coefficients
log KGIw(i) = 2 -
0.157 (Wi"' 14
~
-
M,,
+
117
100) =
0.157 (470 74 - Mr.i + 100) = -4.0988 2 - - - 14 KG/L 7.97E - 5 KG,w(i)= 7.97E - 5 = Ka/p =
+
-
0.157
This compares well with an experimental KP,,> value ranging from 0.22 to 0.33.
1
The value for cis-3-hexenol partitioned between LDPE and ethanol can be calculated using Eq. (4-103) using the Wi from Table 4-8.
1
log KP/,.(i) = -1.31 - 2.6579 KPIL(i)= 0.0022
1 ~
-
0.0071 (W/p/L)- M,.i) = -1.31
-
0.0071 (270 + 20 - 100.16) =
This value is very close to the experimental value of 0.0024 (Table 9-7).
Example 4-4: Partition calculation using retention indices. Calculate the partition coefficient of IRGANOX 1076 betwen LDPE and 100 YOethanol and between LDPE and water at 25 "C. The molecular structure of the polymer additive IRGANOX 1076 with M , , = 531 is shown in Appendix 111. To calculate the IRGANOXlethanol partition coefficient use Eq. (4-103) and Table 4-8. Two structural increments are considered: Wi("IL)= 180 for ester and W,(p'L)= 140 for the 2,6-di-tert-butyl-phenol: log Kp/L (i) =-1.31-0.0071(180+140-531) = 0.1881 and KpiL=1.54. Compared with the partition coefficient of cis-3-hexenol in example 4-3, the partition of IRGANOX 1076 is three orders of magnitude higher. This behavior is a result of the relative lower solubility of the less polar additive in ethanol. To calculate the IRGANOXiwater partition coefficient use Eqs. (4-98). (4-101) and (4-50) in combination with Table 4-6. The average-value W,("") 2 -4 is used for the ester increment in LDPE. For the 2.6-di-tert-butyl-phenol increment no value can be extracted from Table 46. But comparing the increments in Table 4-8 one half of the value for primary-alcohol is taken and one can use W,(G'P' = 10 for LDPE. A four-fold branching has to be considered and this gives W,'"'') = 4 x (-5) = -20 (as average): log KGiP(i)= -2.6-(0.42/14)(4+10-20+531-100) = -15.11 and KGIp= 7.8E-16. With the same considerations for W,'G/W'in water, one gets: log KGIW(i)= 2-(0.157/14)(360- 4(7.5)+235-531+100) = 0.497 and KGiw= 3.14. The calculated partition coefficient, KpiW = 4E15, is an extremely high value. Nevertheless it demonstrates the very low tendency for the additive to migrate into pure water. Comparing the partition of this additive between LDPEiethanol and LDPEiwater one can imagination the dramatic change that occurs in the partition behavior as water is added to ethanol. This finding agrees with the results shown in Chapter 9.
118
Baner
4.4 Expected orders of magnitudes for partition coefficients Three different approaches have been presented for estimating the partitioning of solutes between plastics and liquids. In the context of evaluating the output from these different approaches it is also useful to define the expected experimental ranges and limits for partition coefficients based on the solutes, plastic and contacting liquid phases involved. Table 4-9 shows approximate upper and lower limits for partition coefficients one may normally encounter in plastic/food systems based on the poiarities of the solutes, plastics and foods. The table also gives approximate ranges of partition coefficient values for various solutes between typical food contact plastics and liquid phases. Table 4-9a: Approximate partition coefficient values for various plasticlfood package systems.
Substance (i) nonpolar (n-alkane) nonpolar to middle polarity (d-limonene) nonpolar to middle polarity (d-limonene) middle polarity (ketone) middle polarity (ester) nonpolar (large n-alkane) nonpolar (n-alkane) all polarities polar (alcohol) polar to middle polarity (alcohol and hydrocarbon) polar (alcohol) polar (alcohol) polar (alcohol and middle polarity)
very polar (acid)
Polymer (P) nonpolar (PO) nonpolar (PE) nonpolar (PO) middle polarity (PW nonpolar (PO) nonpolar (PO) nonpolar (PO) all polymers
Food Phase (L) very polar
very polar (PA) polar (PET) nonpolar (PO) middle polarity ( P W very polar, polar (PA) (PET) nonpolar (PO)
( ) = examples, PO = polyolefin (PE, ionomer, PP)
(H20)
very polar (H20) polar (fruit juices) polar (ethanol) very polar
KP/L
1x 105-1 loh (40000) 1200 4w00
10-20 (17) 10-40
WzO)
polar (ethanol)
5
nonpolar (n-alkane)
1
oil
0.1-10
very polar (H20) polar (5050 aqueous ethanol)
1 0.1-3
very polar
0.5
W2O)
polar (et hano I)
0.1
polar (propanol) (methanol) very polar (HTO)
> 0.1 0.05-0.1 (0.0014.05) 0.001 t0.0011
(0.07)
Partition coefficients
119
Table 4-9b: Examples of polarity classifications.
Phase
Polarit v
Examples
Substance
Very Polar
acids
Polar ~
Polymer
Food
_
_
_
phenols alcohols ~
_
~
~
Middle Polarity
aldchydes esters kctones ethers
nonpolar
hydrocarbons n-alkanes
Very Polar
Polyamide (PA) Ethylene vinyl alcohol (EVOH)
Middle Polarity
Acrylonitrile (PAN) Polystyrene (PS) Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) Polyethylene terephthalate (PET) Polycarbonate (PC)
nonpolar
polyolefins (PO)
Very Polar
water 0.1 YU fat milk
Polar
alcohols and aqueous alcohol mixtures wine fruit iuicrs
Middle Polarity
emulsions I .5-3.S % fat milk
nonpolar
fats and oils > 7 3 % fat milk
To further illustrate the possible experimental ranges of partition coefficients, examples of experimentally determined partition coefficient ranges are given below. In Table 4-10 data for BHT partitioned between polypropylene and different food and food simulants at 40 "C and in Table 4-1 1 for d-limonene partitioned between LDPE and various foods and food simulants are shown. The partition coefficient values in these tables are representative examples of the ranges one can expect with polyolefins which are the most common food contact plastics.
120
Eaner
Table 4-10 Experimental BHT partition coefficients between PP and various foods (Kochmann et al., 198.5). Food Milk 30.0 YOFat Milk 10.0 % Fat Milk 7.5 70Fat Milk 3.5 YO Fat Milk 1.5 % Fat Milk 0.1 % Fat Pernod (40 % volume aqueous ethanol) EthanolNater (40 % volume ethanol) Grapefruit juice Orange juice Water (demineralized)
KWL
0.40 1.1 1 1.43 10.0 25.0 333 125
142.8 4545 5555 4oooo
Partition coefficienrs
121
Table 4-11: Experimental d-limonene partition coefficients between LDPE and various foods and rood simulants. Liquid Phase
d-Limonene liquid phase KpiL concentration ppm (w/v)
Reference
Octanol
100400
0.15
Koszinowski and Piringer. 1989
100 % Ethanol
68
0.67
Baner, 1992
100 % Methanol
100-400
0.69
Becker et al.. 1983
80 Yo Aqueous Ethanol
100400
1.99
Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989
75 % Aqueous Ethanol
68
2. I
Baner. 1992
Milk 3 YO Fat
100400
4.8
Koszinowski and Piringer. 1989
60 YO Aqueous Ethanol
100-400
6.5
Koszinowski and Piringer. 1989
40 YO Aqueous Ethanol
100-400
9.7
Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989
Milk 1.5 YO Fat
100-400
12
Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989
S O % Aqueous Ethanol
68
33
Baner, 1992
Water with a sugar ester dispersant
1.8
84
Harita and Tanaka. I989
Orange Juice
106
97.5
Hirose et al., 1988
35 % Aqueous Ethanol
80
150
Baner, 1992
20 % Aqueous Ethanol
10WO0
275
Koszinowski and Piringer. 1989
Ethylene-propylene copolymer/ vegetable based beverage (e.g. Cola)
2-3
270-310
Jabarin and Koilen, 1988
Wine (5.8 % w/w Ethanol)
100-400
1000-1100
Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989
10 % Aqueous Ethanol
100
4700
Kwapong and Hotchkiss, 1987
Zn IonomerllO YO Aqueous Ethanol 100
4400
Kwapong and Hotchkiss, 1987
Water
<100
5300
Koszinowski and Piringer, 1989
Air
1
1400-1600
Baner et al., 1991
HDPElArgon
1.9
5280
DeLassus. 1985
HDPElNitrogen
0.3-7
6900-15600
Mohney et al., 1988
122
Baner
References Abrams. D.S., Prausnitz, J.M. Statistical thermodynamics of liquid mixtures: A new expression for the excess gibbs energy of partly or completely miscible systems. AICHe Journal. l975.21.1: 116128. Baner, A.L., Piringer, 0. Prediction of solute partifion coefficients between polyolefins and alcohols using the regular solution theory and group contribution methods. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1991, 3 0 150&1515. Baner, A.L., Kalyankar, V., Shoun, L.H. Aroma Sorption Evaluation of Aseptic Packaging. J. Food Science, 1991. 56(4): 1051-1054. Baner. A.L., Partition coefficients of aroma compounds between polyethylene and aqueous ethanol and their estimation using UNIFAC and GCFEOS. Ph.D. Dissertation. Michigan State University, E. Lansing, 1992. Baner. A.L. unpublished data. 1993 Baner. A., Franz. R.. Piringer. 0.1994. “Alternative Fatty Food Simulants for Polymer Migration Testing”. Chapter 2 in Food Packaging and Preservation. (M. Mathlouthi, ed.). Blackie Academic and Professional, London. presented at IFTEC symposium, 15-18 November 1992. The Hague, Netherlands. Baner, A. L., Brandsch. J., Franz, R.. Piringer. 0. 1996. The application of a predictive model for evaluating the compliance of plastic materials with European food regulations. Food Additives and Contaminants 13(5): 58W501. Baner, A. L. The estimation of partition coefficients, solubility coefficients and permeability coefficients for organic molecules in polymers using group contribution methods. New Developments in the Chemistry of Packaging Materials. ACS Symposium Dallas 1998. ACS Symposium Series, ACS Washington D.C. 1999. Barton, A.F.M. CRC Handbook of Solubility Parameters and Other Cohesion Parameters. CRC Press, Inc. Boca Raton. Florida, 1983. Bastos, J.C.. Soares, M.E., Medina, A.G. Infinite dilution activity coefficients predicted by UNIFAC group contribution. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1988.27: 1269-1277. Becker, K., Koszinowski, J., Piringer, 0. Permeation von riech- und aromastoffen durch polyolefine (Permeation of flavor and aromas through polyolefins). Deutsche Lebensmittel-Rundschau. 1983, 79(8): 257-266. Bertucco, A,, Piccinno, R.. Soave, G. A Method for Estimating Vapour Pressures of Pure High Boiling Substances. Chem. Eng. Comm. 1991. 106: 177-184. Bogdanic, G., Fredenslund, A. Revision of the Group-Contribution Flory Equation of State for Phase Equilibria Calculations in Mixtures with Polymers. 1. Prediction of Vapor-Liquid Equilibria for Polymer Solutions. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1994,33: 1331-1340. Bondi, A. Physical properties of Molecular Crystals, Liquids, and Glasses. John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1968. Brandsch, J.; Mercea, P.: Piringer, 0 . Modeling of Additive Diffusion Coefficients in Polymers. New Developments in the Chemistry of Packaging Materials. ACS Symposium Series, ACS, Washington, D.C. 1999. Chen, F., Fredenslund, A., Rasmussen, P. Group-contrihution flory equation of state for vapor-liquid equilibria in mixtures with polymers”. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 1990,29: 875-882. Canstantinou, L.; Prickett, S.E.: Mavrovouniotis. M.L. Estimation of Thermodynamic and Physical Properties of Acyclic Hydrocarbons Using the ABC Approach and Conjugation Operators. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1993,32: 1734-1746. Denbigh. K. The Principles of Chemical Equilibrium. 4rth ed. Cambridge Univenity Press, Cambridge. 1981. DeLassus, P. T. Transport of Unusual Molecules in Polymer Films. TAPPI 1985 Polymers. Laminations & Coatings Conference. TAPPI Press, Atlanta, Book 2: 445450. Doong, S.J., Ho. W.S.W. Sorption of organic vapors in polyethylene. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1991, 3 0 1351-1361. Elbro. H.S.. Fredenslund, A,, Rasmussen, P. A new simple equation for the prediction of solvent activities in polymer solutions. Macromolecules, 1990.23 (21): 4707. Flory, P.J. Thermodynamics of polymer solutions. Discuss. Faraday SOC.,1970,48(7): 7-29. Franz. R. Personnal communication. Fraunhofer-Institut IVV. Freising, Germany. 1990 Franz, R. Fraunhofer-lnstitut fur Lebensmitteltechnologie und Verpackung ILV Annual Report (now Fraunhofer IVV. Freising, Germany). 1991. Munich, pp 47 Fredenslund, A,. Jones, R.L., Prausnitz, J.M. Group-contribution estimation of activity coefficients in nonideal liquid mixtures. AICHe Journal, 1975,21(6): 108&1099.
Partition coefficients
123
Fredenslund, A. UNIFAC and related group-contribution models for phase equilibria. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 1989.52: 135-150. Goydan. R., Reid, R.C.. Tseng, H. Estimation of the solubilities of organic compounds in polymers by group-contribution methods. Ind. Eng. Chem. Rcs., 1989.28: 445454. Guggenheim. E.A. Mixtures. Clarendon Press. Oxford, 1952. Hansen, H.K., Rasmussen, P., Fredenslund, A,, Schiller. M., Gmehling. J. Vapor-liquid equilibria by UNIFAC group contribution. 5. Revision and extension. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 1991,30 2352-2355. Harita, S., Tanaka, Y. Flavor Barrier Properties and Applications of EVAL Barrier Resins. Proceedings Europak ’89. Fourth Ryder European Conference on Plastics and Packaging for Food and Beverages. Oct. 31 - Nov. 1,1989. Dusseldorf. High, M.S., Danner. R.P. Prediction of solvent activities in polymer solutions Fluid Phase Equilibria, 1990,SS: 1-15. Hirose. K., Harte, B.R., Giacin, J.R.. Miltz, J.. Stine. C. in Food Packaging Interactions. ed. J.H. Hotchkiss. ACS Washington. D.C. 1988,28-41. Iwai. Y.. Ohzono. M., Aria, Y. Gas chromatographic determination and correlation of weight-fraction henry’s constants for hydrocarbon gases and vapors in molten polymers. Chem. Eng. Commun., 1985, 34: 225-240. Jabarin. S.A.. Kollen. W.J., Polyolefin Properties for Rigid Food Packaging. Polymer Engineering and Science, 1988,28(18): 1 156-1 161. Kolh. B., Welter, C., Bichler, C., Determination of partition coefficients by automatic equilibrium headspace gas chromatography by vapor phase calibration. Chromatographia, 1992.34: 235-240. Kochmann, R., Kutzki, R., Niebergall. H. Modelluntersuchungen zur Migration von Inhaltsstoffen aus Verpackungsmaterialien in Lebensmittel. VI Mitteilung. Lebensm.-Wiss.u. Technol. 1985,XS:154-158. Kontogeorgis, G.M.. Fredenslund. A,. Tassios. D.P. Simple activity coefficient model for the prediction of solvent activities in polymer solutions. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 1993.32: 362-372. Koszinowski, J. Diffusion and Solubility of n-Alkanes in Polyolefins. J. Appl. Poly. Sci. 1986. 31: 18051826. Koszinowski, J. Diffusion and Solubility of Hydroxy Compounds in Polyolefins. J. Appl. Poly. Sci. 1986b, 31: 271 1-2720. Koszinowski. J., Piringer, 0.The Influence of Partition Processes between Packaging and Foodstuffs or Cosmetics on the Quality of Packed Products. Vcrpackungs-Rundschau: Technische-wissenschaftliche Beilage. 1989.40(5): 3944. Kwapong. O.Y.. Hotchkiss. J.H. Comparative Sorption of Aroma Compounds by Polyethylene and Ionomer Food-Contact Plastics. Journal of Food Science. 1987,52(3): 761-785. Larsen, B.L., Rasmussen, P., Fredenslund, A. A modified UNIFAC group-contribution of phase equilibria and heats of mixing. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 1987.26: 22742286, Liley, P.E., Gambill. W. R.. Chemical Engineers’ Handbook. McGraw-Hill Book Co., N.Y. 1973, Section 3. pp 49. Mavrovouniotis, M.L. Estimation of Properties from Conjugate Forms of Molecular Structures: The ABC Approach. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1990.29: 1943-1953. Mohney, S.M.. Hernandez, R.J., Giacin, J.R.. Harte, B.R. Miltz, J. Permeability and Solubility of dLimonene Vapor in Cereal Package Liners. J. Food Science, 1988.53(1): 253-257. Oishi. T.. Prausnitz, J.M. Estimation of solvent activities in polymer solutions using a group-contribution method. Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Res. Dev.. 1078. 17(3): 333-339. Park, J.H., Carr, P.W. Predictive ability of the MOSCED and UNIFAC activity coefficient estimation melhods. Anal. Chem., 1987.59: 2596-2602. Piringer. 0..Jalobeanu, M.. Stanescu. U. J. Chromatography. 1976. 119: 423. Piringer. 0.Verpackungen fur Lebensmittel: Eignung. Wechselwirkungen, Sicherheit. VCH. Weinheim, Germany, 1993. Chapter 6.1. Prausnitz, J.M.; Lichtenthaler, R.N.; Gomes dc Azevedo, E.; Molecular Thermodynamics of Fluid-Phase Equilibria. Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1986; Chapter 6, pp 193. Reid. R.C., Prausnitz, J.M., Poling. B.E. The Properties of Gases and Liquids. McGraw-Hill: N.Y., 1987. Sandler. S.I. Chemical and Engineering Thermodynamics. John Wiley and Sons. New York, N.Y., 1989. Thomas, E.R.. Eckert. C.A. Prediction of limiting activity coefficients by a modified separation of cohesive energy density model and UNIFAC. End. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev., 1984.23: 194200. Van Krevelen, D.W. Properties of Polymers: Thcir Correlation With Chemical Structure; Their Numerical Estimation and Prediction From Additive Group Contributions. 3rd edition Elsevier Scientific Pub. Co.: Amsterdam, 1990. Weidlich, U., Gmehling, J. 1987. A modified UNIFAC model. I. Prediction of VLE. hE. and y”. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 26: 1372-1381.
Reactivity in Molecular Crystals Edited by Yuli Ohashi Copyright @ K d a o r h a Ltd .Tokyo. 1999
5 Models for diffusion in polymers Peter Mercea
The literature contains a very large amount of both experimental and theoretical information on the diffusion of small molecules, especially gases, in polymers. Since the pioneering works (1,2) on the diffusion of gases through rubber septa interest in diffusion phenomena in polymers has continously increased and diversified. The considerable interest and the concentrated academic and industrial research efforts in the study of diffusion in polymers arises from the fact that important practical applications for these materials depend to a great extent on diffusion phenomena. In the last five decades a series of classic books and reviews have been devoted to the presentation of the main topics, experimental results, theories and applications for the diffusion of small penetrants in and through polymers (3-19). An interested reader will most certainly find in one of these references information which apply to her/his special area of interest. To produce an exhaustive review today in the field of substance diffusion in polymers would require an ample amount of work and space, which is beyond the aim of this book. Therefore in this chapter we will try to present concisely only some outlines of the models currently found in the literature for the interpretation of the diffusion of small penetrants in polymers (6,8.11,13,15,19-21). In a large part of the literature, the term “small molecules” denotes permanent or rare gases, the hydrocarbons from C1 to C4, some hexafluorides and simple organic vapors. However, from the point of view of many practical applications of polymers the term “small penetrants” includes also a wide range of organic substances, others than macromolecules, with a relative molecular weight, M, up to about 2000 daltons. This is true especially in the packaging sector where the spectrum of diffusion phenomena in which a process engineer may be interested has a somewhat different weight than that given in most of the above textbooks, see especially refs. (1 6,18,20-27). The first section of this chapter is devoted to the presentation of some diffusion models constructed on the basis of phenomenological considerations. These so-called “heuristic” models are often cited in the literature and used for the interpretation of experimental results. A special emphasis is to discuss how the mathematical formulae of these models can correlate with experimetal data and moreover to predict diffusion coefficients beyond the ranges experimentally investigated. This latter aspect is of great interest not only from a fundamental point of view but also in many practical fields where the possibility to predict a diffusion process might be a more economic alternative to its experimental investigation. The last section gives a presentation on the present status of so-called “ab initio” computer simuiations of the diffusion of small penetrants in polymer matrices. This is a domain currently in rapid development and there are many expectations that, computer simulations will one day become a practical and performant tool to predict diffusion phenomena in complex penetrant polymers system.
126
Mercea
5.1 Diffusion in polymers - The classical approach Many theoretical models have been proposed in the last six decades to describe the diffusion of small penetrant molecules in polymer matrices. According to the distance-time scale at wich the basic physico-chemical processes involved in these models have been set one could classify them in two main categories, namely “microscopic” and “atomistic” diffusion models. The “microscopic” models have been developed since the late 30’s and therefore can be coined as “classical” , too. They attempted to demonstrate that experimental results, i.e. the dependence of diffusion coefficients on temperature, nature of the penetrant and its concentration in the polymer, can be put into correspondence with some “microscopic” structural or energy parameters of the polymer matrix and/or of the penetrant species. Very often at the basis of these classical models were phenomenological “heuristic” reasonings used to develop eventually mathematical formulae capable to quantify the diffusion processes investigated experimentally. The “microscopic” parameters involved in the development of the classical diffusion models are most often average data on the structural geometry and dimensions of the polymer macromolecules and/or penetrant molecule, i.e. the length of the polymer chains and chain segment angles, estimated average spacings between the polymer chains, uniformly distributed average free-volumes, penetrant collision diameters, etc. In fact most of these models are not truly microscopic because the mathematical formulae developed in their framework rely on macroscopic properties of the polymer such as: thermal expansion, compressibility, viscosity and/or density. In this section we will present briefly some relevant aspects of the “classical” approach to model diffusion in polymers along with representative features and results of the most often cited of these models. Since about 15 years, with the advent of more and more powerful1 computers and appropriate softwares, it is possible to develop also “atomistic” models for the diffusion of small penetrants in polymeric matrices. In principle the development of this “computational approach” starts from very elementary physico-chemical data - called also “first-principles’’ - on the penetrant polymer system. The dimensions of the atoms, the interatomic distances and molecular chain angles, the potential fields acting on the atoms and molecules and other local parameters are used to generate a polymer structure, to insert the penetrant molecules in its free-volumes and then to simulate the motion of these penetrant molecules in the polymer matrix. Determining the size and rate of these motions makes it possible to calculate the diffusion coefficient and characterize the diffusional mechanism. Nowdays the “atomistic” simulation of diffusional processes in polymers is a domain of vivid research activity which already shows remarcable results and brings continously new achievements. The second section of this chapter is devoted to a concise presentation of this topic. In approaching the problem of modelling diffusion in polymers, regardless if in a “classical” or “computational” manner, an important feature must be highlighted, namely that markedly different diffusion mechanisms operate at temperatures above and below the glass transition temperature, T,, of the polymer. This is due in principal to the fact that polymers at temperatures T > T,, so-called “rubbery” polymers, respond rapidly to changes in their physical condition. Therefore, the penetrant polymer system adjusts immediately to a new equilibrium when a penetrant species is
Models for dijfusion in po1ynier.s
127
absorbed by and transported through the rubbery matrix of the polymer. The time taken to reach the new state of equilibrium is very much shorter than the characteristic time involved in the diffusion of the penetrant through the matrix of the polymer, (6.1 1.13). In contrast, for “glassy” polymers, i.e. when T < T,, the motion of the polymer chains is not sufficiently rapid to completely homogenize the penetrant’s environment. Therefore, below T, the polynicr is not in a true equilibrium within the time scale of a conventional diffusion or sorption experiment, (6,9,11,13,15). From these considerations one may state that: - in rubbery polymers the diffusion of penetrants is generally Fickian, excepting special cases in which for example sorption equilibrium is not achieved at the polymer interfaces (28) and - in glassy polymers the diffusion of penetrants is much more complex and can be classified in three categories (29): (i) Case I (or Fickian) diffusion, when the rate of diffusion is much less than that of the relaxation of the penetrant-polymer system, (ii) Case I1 diffusion (30) and Super Case 11 diffusion (31) when the diffusion process is very rapid in comparison with the relaxation processes of the penetrant polymer system, and (iii) Anomalous diffusion, when the diffusion and relaxation rates are comparable. In this case it is assumed that the diffusion process is affected by the presence of preexisting “holes” or “microcavities” in the structure of the polymer matrix. According to the physico-chemical parameters and the type of mathematical formalism used in the development of “microscopic” diffusion models, one could classify them into: - molecular models, - free-volume models, - hybrid models. This classification should in principle be valid for both rubbery and glassy polymers. However, as will be shown in this section, until now more detailed and true “microscopic” treatments have mainly been models for diffusion in rubbery polymers. An explanation for this may be the much more complex nature of the diffusion process in glassy polymers (9,13,32-34). Historically most of the “microscopic” diffusion models were formulated for amorphous polymer structures and are based on concepts derived from diffusion in simple liquids. The amorphous polymers can often be regarded with good approximation as homogeneous and isotropic structures. The crystalline regions of the polymers are considered as impenetrable obstacles in the path of the diffusion process and sources of heterogeneous properties for the penetrant polymer system. The effect of crystallites on the mechanism of substance transport and diffusion in a semicrystalline polymer has often been analysed from the point of view of barrier property enhancement in polymer films (35,36).
128
Mercea
5.1.1 Diffusion in rubbery polymers Molecular models Molecular models to describe diffusion in polymers began to be developed with the pioneering work published about six decades ago in refs.(37,38). The attempt was to model the diffusional process by analysing specific motions of penetrant molecules and the surrounding polymer chains relative to each other and take into consideration the pertinent molecular forces acting between them. Earlier molecular models used satistical-mechanical concepts, were greatly oversimplified and can only roughly be labeled as “microscopic”. The mathematical formulae developed in their frameworks expressed most often only the dependence of the diffusion activation energy, Ed, on certain parameters of the penetrant polymer system. In the “activated zone” model given in ref.(38), it was assumed that diffusion of a small penetrant in a polymer matrix occurs when a total energy equal to or greater than a critical energy, E*, is absorbed in the region surrounding the penetrant molecule. The energy of activation for diffusion appears in any region of the polymer as a result of thermal fluctuations in it. This energy is shared by the penetrant molecule and adjacent polymer segments and is stored in a so-called “zone of activation” (37,38). The diffusional jump occurs within the life-time of the energy fluctuations with the addition requirement for cooperation and synchronization between segmental rotations and intermolecular vibrations within the zone of activation. Eventually the expression for D is obtained as:
This model was used by its author to correlate and discuss experimental data on diffusion activation energies and diffusion coefficients of simple gases and organic vapors in elastomers (37). The procedure is not trivial and among other things requires the knowledge of a series of data on the viscosity of the polymer and the making of “heuristic” assumptions on the magnitude of h and v,. A somewhat closer phenomenological tie to the “microscopic” structure and motions in the penetrant polymer system was proposed in ref. (39).The main assumption made was that diffusion of a small penetrant in the matrix of a polymer takes place by “jumps” between “holes” or “vacancies” created by the thermal fluctuation of the polymer chains. It was further assumed that the unit diffusion step for small penetrants in polymers is governed by the energy required to separate the polymer chains surrounding a molecule of penetrant and to give a space of sufficient cross section for the molecule to pass to another “hole”. Thus, above T, the activation process of diffusion is breaking off van der Waals bonds between polymer chains and creating voids of “cylindrical” form. For very small penetrant molecules, i.e. He, Ne, or N2, complete separation of the segments beyond the limit of van der Waals interactions would not be required but for larger penetrants this will be the case. Applying the theory of absolute reaction rates (40) to diffusion, eventually an expression for the diffusion coefficient D was derived (39): D =E~
* 2
e x p ( q ) exp( -
&)
(5-2)
Models for diffitsion in polymers
129
where A* is equated with the length of the “cylindrical” void. The model has been used to calculate from experimental D and Ed such parameters as A* and the entropy of activation AS*. The results led to reasonable correlations of the experimental data (39,41) but the model was not tested by its author to see if it held for the diffusion of more complex organic vapors in rubbery polymers. A further attempt to correlate the activation energy Ed with “microscopic” structural features of the polymer matrix was proposed in ref.(42). This classical diffusion model is constructed on the assumption that, in order to create a passageway for a penetrant molecule, the energy of activation is used in part to bend the molecular chain segments which surround the penetrant - intramolecular energy Eb - and in part to overcome the attractive forces between the segments - intermolecular energy E,. Within the framework of this model, mathematical formulae have been derived to express Eb and Ei in terms of a simplified structural model of the polymer matrix. Further, a relationship for the apparent energy of diffusion activation was tested against experimental diffusion data obtained for a simple ethane-polyethylene system (42). The discrepancies between theory and experiment were ascribed to limitations resulting from the oversimplified mechanism of diffusion assumed in the development of the model. In principle this diffusion model allows a semi-predictive calculation of diffusion coefficients but the procedure relies on the knowledge of a series of additional parameters such as: internal pressure in the polymer and average geometric parameters of the polymer chains which must be evaluated from structural, density, specific volume data on the polymer and other parameters. Nevertheless, taking into account the simplicity of the motions assumed to be responsible for the diffusional jump and the crude method of estimating some of the structural and energy parameters involved, it might be reasonable to consider that such estimates will at best give information on the order of magnitude of the calculated diffusion coefficients. Moreover it should be mentioned that the validity of the model was tested only for the diffusion of very simple penetrants (permanent gases) in rubbery polyethylene. The molecular model concept presented above was further refined and developed in (43,44), which are often cited in the literature. In this statistical molecular model it is assumed that the whole structure of the polymer matrix consists of a random distribution of identical n-center segments in cylindrical cells. The bundle of parallel chains creates a cylindrically symmetric force field which influences the motions of the central chain. During the course of normal thermal vibrations and rotations of the polymer chains, the unit cell expands and contracts. The motion of the segments can be coordinated to produce a cylindrical void adjacent to a molecule absorbed into the polymer, which is then able to “diffuse” into this void. The o