The development of biofuels and green chemistry has escalated rapidly in recent years, and with increased interest there...
426 downloads
2512 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The development of biofuels and green chemistry has escalated rapidly in recent years, and with increased interest there is now a great demand for scientific information on the development of biomass crops and conversion of biomass into fuels and chemicals. Plant Biomass Conversion provides coverage of a broad range of key topics that are directly tied to the sustainable and profitable development of the biofuels industry. Plant Biomass Conversion covers topics ranging from the development of dedicated biomass crops to the evolution of conversion processes. Chapters also look at sustainability issues and the economic considerations to profitably develop fuels and industrial chemicals from biomass. Bringing together contributions from scientific researchers and industry personnel, Plant Biomass Conversion will provide the reader with thorough understanding of this evolving industry. Broad ranging in scope and written in a succinct, scientific style, Plant Biomass Conversion will be an essential reference for all researchers and industrial personnel interested in the production and development of biofuels.
KEY FEATURES: • Provides an overview of plant biomass conversion for plant and crop scientists, biofuels researchers, and industry personnel • Addresses both development of biomass crops and conversion techniques • Discusses sustainability and economic issues around the development of bio-based fuels and chemicals
EDITORS: Elizabeth E. Hood is a Distinguished Professor of Agriculture at Arkansas State University. Peter Nelson is Co-Founder and Director of Business Development with BioDimensions, Inc. Memphis, Tennessee. Randall Powell is Technology Consultant and Program Manager for Sugar Platform with BioDimensions, Inc, Memphis Tennessee.
RELATED TITLES: Biofuels from Agricultural Wastes and Byproducts Editors: Hans P. Blaschek, Thaddeus Ezeji, Jurgen Sheffren 9780813802527
ISBN: 978-0-8138-1694-4
www.wiley.com/wiley-blackwell
HOOD, NELSON, & POWELL
Anaerobic Biotechnology for Bioenergy Production: Principles and Applications Samir Kumar Khanal 9780813823461
PLANT BIOMASS CONVERSION
PLANT BIOMASS CONVERSION
BIOMASS AND BIOFUELS SERIES
PLANT BIOMASS CONVERSION
ELIZABETH E. HOOD, PETER NELSON, & RANDALL POWELL
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion Editors Elizabeth E. Hood Arkansas Biosciences Institute Arkansas State University Jonesboro, Arkansas, USA
Peter Nelson BioDimensions, Inc. Memphis, Tennessee, USA
Randall Powell BioDimensions, Inc. Memphis, Tennessee, USA
A John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., Publication
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
C 2011 by John Wiley & Sons Inc. This edition first published 2011
Wiley-Blackwell is an imprint of John Wiley & Sons, formed by the merger of Wiley’s global Scientific, Technical and Medical business with Blackwell Publishing. Registered office:
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, UK
Editorial offices:
2121 State Avenue, Ames, Iowa 50014-8300, USA The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, UK 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford, OX4 2DQ, UK
For details of our global editorial offices, for customer services and for information about how to apply for permission to reuse the copyright material in this book please see our website at www.wiley.com/wiley-blackwell. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use, or the internal or personal use of specific clients, is granted by Blackwell Publishing, provided that the base fee is paid directly to the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. For those organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by CCC, a separate system of payments has been arranged. The fee codes for users of the Transactional Reporting Service are ISBN-13: 978-0-8138-1694-4/2011. Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The publisher is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Plant biomass conversion / editors: Elizabeth E. Hood, Peter Nelson, Randall Powell. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-8138-1694-4 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Plant biomass. 2. Biomass conversion. 3. Biomass conversion–Environmental aspects. 4. Biomass energy. I. Hood, Elizabeth E. II. Nelson, Peter (Peter Allan), 1974– III. Powell, Randall Worth. TP248.27.P55P554 2011 662 .88–dc22 2010040942 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. This book is published in the following electronic formats: ePDF 9780470959053; Wiley Online Library 9780470959138; ePub 9780470959091 R Inc., New Delhi, India Set in 10/11.5 pt Times New Roman by Aptara
1 2011
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Contents
Contributors Preface 1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks Peter Nelson, Elizabeth Hood, and Randall Powell 1.1 1.2 1.3
1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.10
Introduction Market Opportunity for Biofuels and Biobased Products Feedstocks 1.3.1 Biobased Feedstock Availability and Issues 1.3.2 Characterization of Lignocellulosic Feedstocks 1.3.3 The Role of Agricultural Biotechnology 1.3.4 Biomass Agricultural Equipment Development The Biochemical Technology Platform Investment and Major Players The Role of the Farmer Opportunities for Rural Development Environmental Benefits Economic Comparison of the Biochemical and Thermochemical Technology Platforms Conclusions and Future Prospects References
2 Agricultural Residues James Hettenhaus 2.1 2.2
Introduction 2.1.1 Key Issues Feedstock Supply 2.2.1 Residue Markets 2.2.2 Harvest Window 2.2.3 Residue Removal 2.2.4 Residue Management 2.2.5 Ag Equipment Needs 2.2.6 Operating Costs 2.2.7 Residue Nutrient Value 2.2.8 Land for Energy Crops
xi xiii
3 3 5 6 6 8 9 11 11 12 14 16 17 17 18 19 21 21 22 23 26 27 27 28 29 33 33 33 v
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Contents
vi
2.3
2.4
2.2.9 Farmer Outlook 2.2.10 Crop Research and Development Feedstock Logistics 2.3.1 Bulk Density 2.3.2 Storage 2.3.3 Regional Biomass Processing Centers Conclusion Endnotes References
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials Randall Rousseau, Janet Hawkes, Shijie Liu, and Tom Amidon 3.1 3.2 3.3
34 34 34 35 36 43 48 49 49 51
Introduction Natural Regeneration Overall Growing Systems 3.3.1 The Beginnings of Biomass Plantation Production 3.3.2 Short Rotation Woody Crops 3.3.3 Other Types of Hardwood Plantations 3.3.4 Southern Pine New Genetic Tools Agroforestry Products from Woody Biomass 3.6.1 Hemicellulosic Products 3.6.2 Biorefineries Using Woody Biomass 3.6.3 Hot-Water Extraction of Hemicellulose 3.6.4 Wood Extracts: Processing and Conversion 3.6.5 Residual Solid Wood Biomass: Processing and Conversion of the wood mass after extraction, an example Summary References
51 54 54 55 56 59 61 62 63 67 69 71 73 75
4 Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops Keat (Thomas) Teoh, Shivakumar Pattada Devaiah, Deborah Vicuna Requesens, and Elizabeth E. Hood
85
3.4 3.5 3.6
3.7
4.1 4.2
4.3
4.4
Introduction Miscanthus 4.2.1 Characteristics That Make Miscanthus a Potential Biomass Crop 4.2.2 Agronomy Sweet Sorghum 4.3.1 Biology of Sweet Sorghum 4.3.2 Production 4.3.3 Potential Yields 4.3.4 Economic and Environmental Advantages of Sweet Sorghum 4.3.5 Production Challenges Switchgrass 4.4.1 Physiology 4.4.2 Switchgrass Ecotypes
78 78 78
85 85 87 87 90 92 92 94 94 96 97 97 98
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Contents
vii
4.4.3 Advantages 4.4.4 Disadvantages 4.4.5 Yields 4.4.6 Switchgrass as a Bioenergy Crop Conclusions and Future Prospects References
98 99 100 101 101 104
5 Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock David J. Webster
109
4.5
5.1 5.2 5.3
5.4 5.5
5.6
5.7 5.8
Introduction Definitions 5.2.1 Second-Generation Conversion Technologies for Biofuels Disposal Infrastructure and Transfer Stations 5.3.1 Collection Practices 5.3.2 Cost Parameters Waste Generation Waste Characterization 5.5.1 Composition of Generated MSW Prior to Disposal or Processing 5.5.2 Landfilled Waste Compared to Waste Generation 5.5.3 Water in MSW 5.5.4 Heavy Metals in MSW Preparing MSW for Conversion Processing—Mixed Waste Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs) 5.6.1 Presorting 5.6.2 Mechanical Sorting Operations 5.6.3 Manual Sorting Operations 5.6.4 Recovery Rates of the MRF System Cellulosic Content of MSW 5.7.1 Glucose and Ethanol Yields from MSW Framing the Potential References
6 Water Sustainability in Biomass Cropping Systems Jennifer L. Bouldin and Rodney E. Wright 6.1 6.2 6.3
6.4
Introduction Water Use in Bioenergy Production Water Quality Issues in Bioenergy Crops 6.3.1 AGNPS Watershed Model 6.3.2 Water Quality and the Gulf Hypoxic Zone Conclusions—Water Quantity and Quality References
7 Soil Sustainability Issues in Energy Crop Production V. Steven Green 7.1 7.2
Soil Sustainability Concepts Bioenergy Crops and Soil Sustainability
109 110 110 110 112 112 113 114 114 115 116 117 119 121 122 123 123 124 124 125 126 129 129 130 133 135 138 138 139 143 143 145
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Contents
viii
7.3
7.4 7.5
7.2.1 Crop Residues 7.2.2 Dedicated Energy Crops Resource Use in Biomass Production 7.3.1 Water and Soil 7.3.2 Land Use Soil Sustainability Solutions Conclusion References
8 Fermentation Organisms for 5- and 6-Carbon Sugars Nicholas Dufour, Jeffrey Swana, and Reeta P. Rao 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6
Introduction Fermentation Metabolic Pathways Fermenting Species 8.4.1 Brief Description of Major Species Other Relevant Products Summary Endnotes References
9 Pretreatment Options Bradley A. Saville 9.1
9.2
9.3
9.4
9.5 9.6
Overview of Pretreatment Technologies 9.1.1 History 9.1.2 Mechanistic Assessment of Pretreatment 9.1.3 Severity Factor Concept Pretreatment Classification 9.2.1 Mechanical Pretreatment Processes 9.2.2 Chemical Pretreatment Processes 9.2.3 Thermochemical Pretreatment Processes 9.2.4 Impact on Moisture Content and Hydraulic Load Laboratory vs. Commercial Scale Pretreatment—What Do We Really Know? 9.3.1 Laboratory Studies 9.3.2 Pilot/Demonstration Scale Studies 9.3.3 Limitations of Laboratory-Scale Comparisons of Pretreatment Methods Process Issues and Trade-Offs 9.4.1 Inhibitors 9.4.2 Hydrolysis Efficiency and Enzyme Loadings 9.4.3 Solvent/Catalyst Recovery 9.4.4 Viscosity Reduction and Hydraulic Load Economics Conclusions References
145 146 149 149 150 150 154 154 157 157 159 160 161 175 180 183 183 184 199 199 199 200 203 205 206 206 209 210 211 211 211 214 215 215 218 218 218 220 224 224
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Contents
10 Enzyme Production Systems for Biomass Conversion John A. Howard, Zivko Nikolov, and Elizabeth E. Hood 10.1 10.2 10.3
10.4 10.5
Introduction The Challenge: Volume and Cost of Enzymes Required Theoretical Ways to Address the Challenge of Quantity of Enzyme and Cost Requirements 10.3.1 Increase Susceptibility for Biomass Deconstruction 10.3.2 Decrease Exogenous Enzyme Load 10.3.3 Increase Accumulation of Enzymes in Production Host Cost of Producing Exogenous Enzymes 10.4.1 Cost Analysis Summary and Future Prospects References
11 Fermentation-Based Biofuels Randy Kramer and Helene Belanger 11.1 11.2
11.3
11.4
11.5
11.6
Introduction First-Generation Biofuels 11.2.1 Starch-Based Ethanol—United States 11.2.2 Sugar-Based Ethanol—Brazil 11.2.3 Biodiesel Policy and Biofuel Implementation Status 11.3.1 North America 11.3.2 South America 11.3.3 Europe 11.3.4 Asia Second-Generation Biofuels 11.4.1 Cellulosic Ethanol 11.4.2 Biobutanol Issues for Biofuels Commercial Success 11.5.1 Transport by Pipeline 11.5.2 Decentralized Production and Local Distribution 11.5.3 Optimized Engine Performance 11.5.4 Value of Biorefinery Co-products Summary References
12 Biobased Chemicals and Polymers Randall W. Powell, Clare Elton, Ross Prestidge, and Helene Belanger 12.1 12.2 12.3
12.4
Introduction Biobased Feedstock Components Biomass Conversion Technologies 12.3.1 Technology Platforms Overview 12.3.2 Lignocellulose Fractionation Overview Biobased Products 12.4.1 Oil-Based Products 12.4.2 Sugar/Starch-Based Products
ix
227 227 227 228 229 231 236 240 242 245 246 255 255 256 256 257 258 260 260 262 262 263 265 265 268 269 269 270 271 272 272 272 275 275 276 277 277 279 287 287 289
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Contents
x
12.5
12.4.3 Polymer Products 12.4.4 Lignin Products Summary References
13 Carbon Offset Potential of Biomass-Based Energy Gauri-Shankar Guha 13.1
13.2
13.3
13.4
13.5
Emerging Public Interest in Carbon 13.1.1 Overview 13.1.2 Initiatives to Address Anthropogenic Climate Change 13.1.3 GHG Mitigation and Carbon Sequestration Strategies Theory of Carbon Markets 13.2.1 Tradable Permits and the Market for Emissions 13.2.2 Concept of Carbon Markets 13.2.3 Demand and Supply of Carbon Credits Creation of Carbon Markets 13.3.1 Carbon Credits 13.3.2 Global Carbon Trade 13.3.3 Carbon Trading in the United States 13.3.4 The CCX Offset Program Role of Biomass-Based Energy in Carbon Markets 13.4.1 Economic Significance of Bioenergy 13.4.2 Bioenergy Policies, Practices, and Trends 13.4.3 Carbon Offset Opportunities for Biofuels Prognosis of Carbon Markets References
14 Biofuel Economics Daniel Klein-Marcuschamer, Brad Holmes, Blake A. Simmons, and Harvey W. Blanch 14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5 14.6 14.7 14.8
14.9 14.10 14.11 14.12 14.13 Index
Introduction Production Processes Biomass Transportation and Handling Conversion of Biomass into Sugars Conversion of Sugars into Biofuels Separation and Purification Co-product Handling Major Cost Drivers 14.8.1 Biomass-Associated Costs 14.8.2 Capital Expenses 14.8.3 Operating Costs Risks Policy Support Infrastructure and Vehicle Modifications Conclusions Acknowledgments References
293 299 303 304 311 311 311 311 314 314 314 315 316 317 317 318 318 318 319 319 321 323 324 325 329
329 330 331 332 335 337 337 338 338 340 342 343 345 346 347 348 348 355
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Contributors
Tom Amidon, SUNY, Syracuse, NY, USA. Helene Belanger, Vertichem Technology Limited, Toronto, Ontario M5H 3B7, Canada. Harvey W. Blanch, Joint Bioenergy Institute, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, and University of California-Berkeley; Berkeley, CA, USA. Jennifer L. Bouldin, Department of Biological Sciences, Ecotoxicology Research Facility, Arkansas State University, Jonesboro, AR, USA. Shivakumar Pattada Devaiah, Arkansas Biosciences Institute, Arkansas State University, Jonesboro, AR, USA. Nicholas Dufour, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, MA, USA. Clare Elton, Vertichem Technology Limited, Toronto, Ontario M5H 3B7, Canada. Steven Green, Agricultural Studies, College of Agriculture and Technology, Arkansas State University, Jonesboro, AR, USA. Gauri-Shankar Guha, Economics and Finance Department, Arkansas State University, Jonesboro, AR, USA. Janet Hawkes, HD1, LLC, Ithaca, NY, USA. James Hettenhaus, Chief Executive Assistance, Inc, Charlotte, NC, USA. Brad Holmes, Joint Bioenergy Institute and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA. Elizabeth E. Hood, Arkansas Biosciences Institute, Arkansas State University, Jonesboro, AR, USA. John A. Howard, Applied Biotechnology Institute, San Luis Obispo, CA, USA. Daniel Klein-Marcuschamer, Joint Bioenergy Institute and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA. xi
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
xii
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Contributors
Randy Kramer, Kramer Energy Group, Rapid City, SD, USA. Shijie Liu, SUNY, Syracuse, NY, USA. Peter Nelson, BioDimensions, Inc., Memphis, TN, USA. Zivko Nikolov, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, USA. Randall W. Powell, BioDimensions, Inc., Memphis, TN, USA. Ross Prestidge, Vertichem Technology Limited, Toronto, Ontario M5H 3B7, Canada. Reeta P. Rao, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, MA, USA. Deborah Vicuna Requesens, Arkansas Biosciences Institute, Arkansas State University, Jonesboro, AR, USA. Randall Rousseau, Forestry Department, Mississippi State University, Starkville, MS, USA. Bradley Saville, University of Toronto, Department of Chemical Engineering and Applied Chemistry, Toronto, Canada. Blake A. Simmons, Joint Bioenergy Institute, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, and Sandia National Laboratories, Livermore, CA, USA. Jeffrey Swana, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, MA, USA. Keat (Thomas) Teoh, Arkansas Biosciences Institute, Arkansas State University, Jonesboro, AR, USA. David J. Webster, Ark Resources, LLC, Birmingham, AL, USA. Rodney E. Wright, Ecotoxicology Research Facility, Arkansas State University, Jonesboro, AR, USA.
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Preface
A host of motivations is driving the development of the “renewables” industry—a desire for energy independence in the United States, biodegradable products, global warming, and hopefully, making money. All energy utilized on the earth is ultimately derived from the sun through photosynthesis—the only truly renewable commodity. Capitalizing on this productive process in a balanced way is crucial to our survival as a species. Crude oil represents an ancient capture of carbon and sunlight by plants. However, the rate at which we are utilizing oil releases ancient fixed carbon into the atmosphere and upsets the balance of nature in a way that is unprecedented in global history. Nature’s checks and balances are not able to accommodate this huge increase in carbon from man’s activities. Thus, development of a new source of energy and products is imperative. Many models that describe processes for generating energy from biomass exist. No one book can describe them all. This work focuses on the biochemical (enzymatic) digestion of plant biomass to produce the raw materials that make up plant cell wall polymers. These raw materials can then be used as feedstocks for ethanol and other bio-based products. This volume also is focused on solving the issues for biomass conversion into ethanol and bio-based products now—not the longer-term solutions with modified microbes and modified feedstocks. The chapters review existing technologies and future expectations for those technologies. They describe multiple feedstocks, multiple pretreatment technologies, enzyme production models, fermentation models, and manufacturing of products in biorefineries. While this is a snapshot in time of the state of the industry, this volume should serve as a guide and model for describing what is possible and where the issues are, which must be solved. We hope you enjoy our book. Elizabeth E. Hood, PhD Arkansas State University
xiii
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
P1: SFK/UKS fm
P2: SFK/UKS
BLBS075-Hood
QC: SFK/UKS
December 18, 2010
T1: SFK 18:21
Trim: 244mm×172mm
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Chapter 1
The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks Peter Nelson, Elizabeth Hood, and Randall Powell
1.1 Introduction The first two decades of the 21st century will be marked as the turning point when large investments, technology breakthroughs, and new strategic alliances set the stage for the eventual widespread replacement of fossil feedstocks with renewable, plant-based alternatives for the production of fuels, chemicals, and energy. This is not a new idea, as humankind in the pre-industrial era utilized plant-derived chemicals such as proteins, sugars, and cellulose as the primary feedstocks to make a range of necessary materials and industrial products. However, as non-renewable fossil resources now become increasingly scarce, expensive, and produce negative environmental impacts, the need has never been so great to develop and expand agriculture and forestry as the source of sustainable feedstocks to serve a growing global population. Ultimately, renewable resources must feed, clothe, shelter, fuel, and provide for material goods for the planet’s inhabitants, while also addressing vexing environmental problems including climate change, pollution, access to clean water, and long-term soil health. In the 20th century, incredible technological improvements in agriculture and forestry were made. These advances included dramatic yield increases, drought tolerance, insect resistance in agricultural crops, and new production methodologies such as conservation tillage, which builds soil health and requires less energy. These productivity and environmental improvements offer much promise for a future bioeconomy in which agriculture and forestry will provide the predominant feedstocks for much more than food, feed, and fiber. Agricultural successes such as the Green Revolution have dramatically increased global crop yields, reduced hunger in the developing world, and expanded access to nutritious foods, but are still heavily dependent upon fossil-derived energy and chemicals. Fortunately, agricultural and forestry-based companies and institutions are now collaborating in new ways with industries traditionally dependent on fossil fuels to expand the use of renewable raw materials in a range of manufactured goods.
Plant Biomass Conversion, First Edition. Edited by Elizabeth E. Hood, Peter Nelson and Randall Powell. C 2011 John Wiley & Sons Inc.
3
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
4
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Over the coming decades, this will lead to a more sustainable, closed-loop-systems-based approach to the production of food, energy, and materials. This biobased transition requires development and integration of a range of technologies encompassing energy, process efficiency, environmental compatibility, and even more advanced agricultural production systems. The increasing application of biotechnology tools—previously focused on human health—to improve agricultural crops and practices, enable clean manufacturing processes, and provide sustainable products is the essential catalyst for this transition. A renewable “bioeconomy” is now starting to become a reality, but the concept is not new. In the early days of the 20th century, industrial and agricultural leaders such as Henry Ford and George Washington Carver were proponents and practitioners of the use of plant-derived materials in a range of nonfood products. These innovators demonstrated the commercial utility of renewable biobased feedstocks in hundreds of products, such as automotive composites, glues and adhesives, dyes and inks, plastics, and, of course, biofuels. Unfortunately, the rapid emergence of petroleum as an available and inexpensive feedstock, albeit with unrecognized long-term environmental consequences, drove manufacturers to develop fossil-based rather than renewable products as the initial outputs of the Industrial Revolution. A century later, as the true costs of fossil fuels are realized, renewable feedstocks are re-emerging at commercial scale, largely through innovative partnerships across the value-chain linking agriculture, biotechnology, and the chemical process industries in new ways. Evidence of this transition has become increasingly apparent over the last 30 years as some organizations began decoupling themselves from traditional businesses to focus on agricultural biotechnology. A leading example is Monsanto Company, which has aggressively divested its mainstay fossil-based chemical manufacturing business to focus on the commercial opportunity to develop new agricultural biotechnology traits in commodity crops such as corn, cotton, and soybeans. Major agricultural commodity companies such as Archer Daniels Midland (ADM) and Cargill have also expanded chemical and fuel product offerings based upon their plant-based raw material resources. More recently, a number of multinational chemical companies—notably Dow and DuPont—are pursuing biobased product platforms, with initial commercial products now entering the marketplace. Increasingly, many traditional agricultural commodity companies, fossil-based chemical companies, and newer industrial biotechnology firms are partnering to integrate knowledge of biobased feedstocks, new conversion processes, and operational expertise in order to solve future challenges related to energy and useful materials. The transition to a photosynthesis-based bioeconomy offers commercial opportunity, resource and environmental sustainability, and more equitable global economic development than has been the recent case with fossil resources. However, more intensive agricultural and forestry utilization, and the accompanying deployment of technology must be the products of clear strategic planning and sustainable development practices. If managed correctly, the transition to a renewable-based economy can create new rural and urban opportunities, offer unique environmental solutions, and create wealth. The new economy based on renewable agricultural and forestry raw materials and clean processes will also serve as a major catalyst for realignment of some of the world’s largest companies and institutions, creating many new partnerships across the value-chain. This is an exciting time in which entrepreneurial companies as well as established industries can innovate new farm-to-factory supply chains and establish an early position in the emerging bioeconomy. Although there are multiple technology platforms and an expanding portfolio of biobased raw materials, which will comprise a future biobased economy, this book will focus on biochemical processing technologies, applied primarily to sugar, starch, and lignocellulosic
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks
5
biomass feedstocks. This platform will be a significant game changer, lend itself to a wide range of potential chemical products, and provide opportunities for new players in the supply chain. In particular, sugars derived from lignocellulosic biomass represent an abundant feedstock resource that does not compete with food and feed supplies. Commercially viable processes for converting lignocellulosic biomass to biobased products must address two overriding issues: efficient nonseasonal feedstock supply and logistics, and cost-effective deconstruction of cellulose and hemicellulose polymers to fermentable simple sugars. Feedstock supply and cost issues are being addressed by new crops, new harvesting/storage practices, and decentralized processing models. Technology issues to access sugars (and lignin) within lignocellulosic feedstocks are being addressed through new pretreatment options, genetically modified fermentation organisms, biotechnology-enhanced plants, and plant-based enzyme production systems. The development and commercialization of these new technologies and the requisite biobased supply chain will be profiled in this publication. Despite the early stage and dynamic nature of the industrial bioprocessing industry, the authors hope that the current status and perspectives presented will prove beneficial to the diverse industry stakeholders.
1.2 Market Opportunity for Biofuels and Biobased Products Liquid biofuels including corn-based ethanol, as well as advanced biofuels such as biobutanol or cellulosic ethanol, are assured of a growing market over the next 50 years. As petroleum costs escalate with diminishing supplies, liquid transportation fuels will still be preferred due to energy density, safety, and distribution infrastructure, with increasing growth of biofuels between now and 2035 (IEA, 2008). The biofuels market represents the largest and most consistent demand from which to build a strong sugar and biomass supply chain from field to factory. The global biofuels market is already estimated to be $150 billion per year (UN, 2009). According to one report focused on the United States market: Rapid growth in the consumption of renewable fuels results mainly from the implementation of the US Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) for transportation fuels and State renewable portfolio standard (RPS) programs. Biofuels production will grow over the next two decades, though is likely to fall short of the 36 billion gallons of RFS target in 2022. However, it may exceed expectations for 2035 including fuels from cellulosic ethanol, renewable diesel, and first generation biofuels. (Newell, 2009)
Beyond biofuels, companies are increasingly targeting higher value biobased chemical products and biomaterials. Liquid fuels are the ultimate commodity chemicals, representing the highest volume, but lowest value products whether produced from fossil or renewable feedstocks. In the United States, the petroleum-based liquid fuels industry and related energy services account for approximately 67% of petroleum consumed, with an overall industry value of $350 billion dollars. In contrast to commodity fuels, the goods and services resulting from the highervalue plastics, coatings, resins, and related consumer products utilize only 7% of petroleum consumed while resulting in an approximate $255 billion impact (Frost, 2005). Cargill and McKinsey & Company estimate that there is a potential to produce up to two-thirds of chemicals from biobased materials representing over 50,000 products, a $1 trillion annual global market (Jarrel, 2009).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
6
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Commercial examples of higher value biobased products are emerging with increased frequency, as profiled in Chapter 12 of this review. By 2007, internal corporate investment in research and development related to biobased chemicals and biomaterials was as much as $3.4 billion, which far outpaced biofuels. This was due primarily to internal research and development investments from a few large pharmaceutical companies, which was in contrast to the United States Government’s continued focus during the same time period on liquid transportation biofuels (Lundy et al., 2008). While some biobased products are direct replacements for fossil-derived materials, others possess novel properties unique to their biogenic origin. An interesting example is Canadian-based EcoSynthetix (www.ecosynthetix. com) that is producing a starch-based coating product for the paper industry that outperforms its competitive products by requiring less water and heat in production, while exhibiting superior ink adhesive properties. This product is competitive with its petroleum-based counterpart when the price of oil is as low as $30 per barrel. Recent grants from United States Department of Energy (DOE) to support biomass work have not just focused on biofuels. For example a sizable $600 million round of funding awarded in late 2009, included support for Myriant Technologies’ succinic acid project and Amyris Biotechnology’s process to produce a range of biobased products to complement their biofuel program. It is expected that this trend will continue with both public and private investment focused on a range of high-value biomaterials and chemicals, as opposed to exclusively on biofuels.
1.3 Feedstocks 1.3.1
Biobased Feedstock Availability and Issues
Globally, ample supplies of renewable feedstocks are available for developing a robust and profitable biobased products industry, including agricultural crops, residues, and forestry materials, as well as future sources such as algae. Lignocellulosic biomass is globally dispersed and can be found in many forms, including agricultural crop and processing residues, forestry resources, dedicated energy crops such as miscanthus and switchgrass, and municipal solid waste. In the United States alone, resources associated with agriculture and forestry were calculated at 1.3 billion dry tons per year of biomass potential (Perlack et al., 2005). There are additional chapters in this volume that provide detailed information from a variety of perspectives on the availability of lignocellulosic biomass. It is important to note that the theoretical availability of biomass does not necessarily mean that it is economically feasible or environmentally viable to collect. For example, many primary row crop regions in the United States would produce excellent yields of perennial bioenergy crops, but the economics do not currently support substitution. The availability of agricultural crop residues must also be carefully considered. Crop residues include sustainably removable materials left after harvesting primary crops such as corn and wheat. Such residue availability has often been calculated based on 1:1 corn stover-to-grain ratios provided in the “Billon-Ton Report” published by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and DOE (Perlack et al., 2005). Corn stover is widely considered a prime candidate for bioprocessing, although the actual availability within a working farm system, as well as collection incentives to farmers, may not be understood adequately. Additionally, regional (and global) variables affecting crop residue supply are acknowledged in the Billion Ton Report. For example, in northern climates, corn stover, the stalks and residues left after harvesting the grain, does not degrade quickly due to the cold winter temperatures. This sometimes creates a problem in that there is too
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks
7
much stover for field preparation activities for the next spring. As corn yields increase due to biotechnology, this problem may increase and it will be necessary to remove stover. This is not the case in southern climates, as stover degrades quickly in the wet, relatively warm winters and is counted on by the farmer as a valuable source of organic matter in the soil. Rice straw is another potential crop residue source that is widely available. In this case it would be an environmental benefit to remove the straw because currently it must be burned or otherwise disposed of every year to avoid diseases in the following year’s rice crop. It would be a great benefit for air quality and the farmer to develop a market for this straw in a biomass application. In California, there has been much work, with limited success, in trying to develop markets for rice straw as a reaction to the Rice Straw Burning Reduction Act of 1991 (AB1378). Projects included the development of construction products and packaging materials from rice straw. Unfortunately, the straw is high in silica, which damages existing harvesting and handling equipment, making it impractical to develop a widespread harvesting system. However, if alternative technologies could extract higher value silica products, economics might support the development of more robust harvesting systems. The use of wheat straw in biomass processing and biomaterials has potential, as the straw is already harvested in the United States and globally for use in animal bedding and for other applications. Over the last two decades, wheat straw has been used for composite construction materials, filler materials in plastics, and in the development of cellulosic ethanol. Iogen (www.iogen. ca) has based its cellulosic ethanol demonstration plant on wheat straw as a major raw material. The company is planning its first commercial facility in Saskatchewan that will utilize cereal straw feedstocks. In the near term, especially in the United States, corn cobs may represent the most accessible crop residue for early commercial lignocellosic processing. Harvesting of corn cobs in a onepass system is feasible and is being developed as a component of the United States’ corn ethanol industry. There is already an existing market in some regions for corn cobs at approximately $80.00 per ton, to be used in the production of chemicals such as furfural. Companies such as POET Biomass, a division of POET (www.poetenergy. com), and DuPont Danisco Cellulosic Ethanol, LLC (www.ddce. com) are developing conversion technologies specifically targeting corn cobs as feedstocks for biochemical conversion using enzymes. There is also significant work by major equipment companies, including CNH America LLC. (www.cnh. com) and Deere & Co. (www.deere. com), on one-pass harvesting systems for corn cobs. Another potential source for lignocellulosic biomass is dedicated energy crops, both perennials and annuals. Perennials include crops such as miscanthus and switchgrass which have recently been the focus of attention by crop biotechnology and cellulosic ethanol companies. Perennials offer options to farmers and land owners for use of marginal land that is currently in pasture or other use. These crops sequester carbon in their root systems, as well as utilize relatively small amounts of inputs such as fertilizers and pesticides. The economics of producing these crops does not lend itself to replacing prime row crops, but their production may be part of farm-based crop diversification strategies in the future or as part of a program to utilize marginal and unproductive farm land. Annual crops include sweet sorghum and forage sorghums, both of which require minimal inputs and produce significant biomass. In the case of sweet sorghum, a large sugar content in the crop can be easily converted to ethanol or other biobased products with current technology, while the bagasse could serve as feedstock for lignocellulosic conversion technologies. Markets for these crops are being developed for biopower applications, even as other higher value uses are being commercialized. There is a growing market in Europe and in certain
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
8
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
regions in the United States for densified wood and energy crop pellets and briquets for home heating, industrial use, and co-firing with coal. The latter use is increasingly being driven by regulatory requirements directed toward renewable power generation and greenhouse gas reduction. Forestry and wood-processing residues and byproducts, as well as short-rotation woody crops, also represent important biomass feedstocks. Collectively referred to as “woody biomass,” these resources are often advantaged by an existing year-round harvesting and collection infrastructure. A detailed analysis of all of the crops, trees, and residues is provided in this volume.
1.3.2
Characterization of Lignocellulosic Feedstocks
Woody and herbaceous biomass, or lignocellulosic biomass, primarily comprises three major components—lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose—along with lesser amounts of minor and trace constituents. Cellulose and hemicellulose are polysaccharides or sugar polymers composed of repeating monomer sugar units bonded together into long chains, much like rail cars are coupled together to form a train. Combined with lignin, these biopolymers comprise the structural components of plant matter and are produced by the photosynthetic process, whereby atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2 ) is absorbed by the plant, chemically transformed, and “fixed” into these other useful chemical materials. Lignin is a natural polymer found in all plant materials, which combines with cellulose and hemicellulose to provide structural strength to the plant. It is not a sugar polymer, but rather an aromatic polymer, meaning its component phenylpropyl molecular units contain the highly stable benzene-ring chemical structure, which is also the basis for many commercially useful materials produced from petroleum. The aromatic chemical structure also imparts a high caloric value to the lignin molecule, which is valuable for combustion (heat) and also chemical transformations. The lignin polymer can have significant variability in its chemical structure, often differing based upon the biomass source. Cellulose and hemicellulose are referred to as carbohydrates because they are aliphatic polymers composed only of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen. Cellulose is the most abundant biopolymer on earth and is made of six carbon or C-6 glucose (sugar) monomers. Cellulose obtained from wood pulp, cotton, and other plants has been used for centuries to produce paper and cardboard, as well as derivative products. Often referred to as dietary fiber, it is not digestible by humans, but with recent technology developments, it can now be commercially hydrolyzed by chemical, enzymatic, or biological processes to its monomer sugars, which can then be readily utilized as feedstocks for bioprocessing. Yeast fermentation of glucose to ethanol (mostly for beverages) has been practiced for centuries, and other natural and genetically modified organisms can convert glucose to various useful chemical molecules. Hemicellulose is a polymer primarily composed of various five carbon or C-5 sugar monomers with some C-6 sugars as well. Unlike cellulose, it is an amorphous polymer with little structural strength and is easily hydrolyzed to its monomeric sugars with acid/base or enzymes. Unfortunately, C-5 or xylose sugars cannot be fermented using natural yeasts. However, aggressive research and development programs are developing new organisms and genetically modified yeasts to utilize these readily available C-5 sugars as bioprocessing feedstocks, as described in Chapter 8 of this volume. Fractionation, or separation, of petroleum into its component constituents has been the key methodology to develop high value petrochemical end products. A similar biobased example
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks
9
is corn wet milling, in which the corn kernel is separated into its different components, from which value-added products are produced. As noted above, lignocellulosic biomass feedstocks possess comparable compositional diversity, and several leading technology developers are pursuing fractionation, or separation, of these components in order to facilitate more efficient and targeted downstream conversion of each component to value-added products. Historically, lignocellulose fractionation originated in the pulp and paper industry, where processes were designed to remove hemicellulose and “de-lignify” wood pulp in order to obtain a purified cellulose fraction for paper manufacturing (Agenda 2020 Technology Alliance, 2006). More recent approaches have used a combination of physical and thermal pre-processing followed by aqueous and/or solvent extractions, to afford substantially purified fractions of hemicellulose, lignin, and cellulose for further processing that is specific to each component. As a supporting technology, lignocellulose fractionation may prove to be extremely valuable as an integrated component of biochemical processing, providing sugars for fermentation and also a purified lignin stream as an aromatic chemical platform feedstock. Developmental and commercial lignocellulosic fractionation technologies are fully described in Chapter 12 of this volume.
1.3.3
The Role of Agricultural Biotechnology
In order to provide sustainable food, fuel, and material needs of humans, it will be necessary to dramatically increase the yields of agricultural crops and forest resources, as well as develop crops with specific attributes for biomass feedstocks. Currently, biotechnology traits used to reduce farmers’ costs and increase profitability are widely deployed in canola, corn, cotton, soybeans, and sugarbeets, predominantly in the United States. However, more than 13 million farmers in 25 countries currently grow agricultural biotechnology crops. In 2008, the global biotechnology crop area grew by 9.4%, or 26.4 million acres, to reach a total of 309 million global acres. Between 2007 and 2008, the United States alone increased its biotechnology crop acreage from 143 million acres to 154 million, phenomenal growth considering that the first biotechnology crops were not introduced until the mid-1990 s (ISAAA, 2008). To date, the vast majority of commercialized agricultural biotechnology-derived crops have focused on genetic “input traits,” which add value to the farmer and/or environment by reducing the production costs of the farm operation. Examples include RoundupTM Ready soybeans that are resistant to the herbicide glyphosate, allowing soybean farmers to more widely adapt conservation tillage practices. There are other examples related to insect and herbicide resistance. In addition to input traits in commodity crops, plant biotechnology has developed new crops for bioenergy and pharmaceutical applications with enhanced “output traits,” which allow the crop to produce certain characteristics desired by food, health, or industrial customers. While the value proposition for input traits is directed to the farmer, output traits are directed to those making products from the crops and ultimately to the consumer. Output traits allow crops to have higher protein and other nutritional properties, stronger fibers, specific oil profiles, novel health benefits, and to produce new products within green plants. In short, output traits enhance the value of the plant as a feedstock for the production of plant-based products. Not all of these technology improvements are created through gene transfer. Some use mutation, breeding, and other novel techniques to create new crop performance. Numerous examples of enhanced crop products have been commercialized or are in development for food, feed, and industrial applications, as summarized in Table 1.1. In the mid-1990s, Monsanto Company had a designer fiber unit that attempted to match specialized end uses for
10 Low-linolenic soybeans Phytase
Mirel Vistive QuantumTM Phytase
Metabolix
Monsanto
Syngenta Seed
Amylase and cellulase (under development) New oilseeds
Syngenta Seeds
Targeted Growth Inc.
2006.
Ricinoleic acid
Linnaeus Plant Sciences Inc.
a Grooms,
Cellulase
Infinite Enzymes LLC./ Applied Biotechnology Institute
Plant-based plastic and chemicals
Improved biomass characteristics, yields
Bioenergy Seeds
Low linolenic soybeans
Mendel Biotechnology
Partnership with Bunge
DuPont/Pioneera
40% more oil than No.2 yellow corn
Plant-made industrial enzymes
Supercede HE High Energy
Dow AgroSciences (Mycogen Seeds)a
High oleic/low linolenic fatty acids
Infinite Enzymes, LLC.
Nexera
Dow AgroSciences
Improved biomass characteristics, yields
Improved biomass characteristics and plant-made enzymes
Blade
Ceres, Inc.
Trait
Camelina
Corn
Camelina
Corn
Corn
Soybeans
Switchgrass
Miscanthus and other biomass crops
Biofuels
High amylase corn for conventional ethanol production
Green chemistry/biomaterials
Plant production system for cellulase used in green chemistry/cellulosic ethanol
Animal feed ingredient
Food/feed, reduce trans fats, increase shelf life and oil stability
Biomaterials and bioenergy
Advanced biofuels and biopwoer
Green chemicals and advanced biofuels
Biomaterials and advanced biofuels
Switchgrass and corn
Corn
Food/feed, future products include high-oleic and Omega-3
Animal feed—increases energy in metabolism
Food—no trans fats and low in saturated fat
Advanced biofuels, biobased chemicals, and biopower
Applications
Soybeans
Corn
Canola and sunflower
Switchgrass, biomass sorghum, sweet sorghum and other biomass crops
Crops
20:45
Edenspace Systems Corporation
Brand
Selected plant biotechnology companies and products.
Company
Table 1.1.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010 Trim: 244mm×172mm
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks
11
cotton with specific, genetically engineered characteristics in a cotton variety. Other examples include products for reagent use that ProdiGene, Inc. commercialized. Trypsin (trade name TrypZean), beta-glucuronidase, and avidin are all sold by Sigma Chemical Co. Significant research is also being conducted to improve the fatty acid profile in camelina, a crop pioneered by United States producer groups in the Great Plains and companies such as Targeted Growth, Inc. (www.targetedgrowth. com). Targeted Growth, Inc. began a breeding program for camelina in 2005, employing a three pronged approach: classical and molecular breeding, mutation breeding, and transgenics (Panter, 2008). Other companies, such as Linnaeus Plant Sciences (www.linnaeus.net), are seeking to change the oil profile of the crop for various novel biobased product applications. Researchers are also working to adapt modern biotechnology tools to the development of new bioenergy crops. Examples of these include miscanthus, switchgrass other herbaceous crops, and short rotation woody crops. Companies working in this area include Ceres, Inc. (www.ceres.net); Chromatin, Inc. (www.chromatininc.com); Edenspace Systems Corporation (www.edenspace. com); Infinite Enzymes, LLC (www.infiniteenzymes.com), Mendel Biotechnology, Inc. (www.mendelbio.com), and Metabolix (www.metabolix. com). For both large multinational biotechnology firms and small boutique trait developers, a key hurdle is navigating a confusing and costly regulatory environment. A streamlined approach to getting crops deregulated and into commercial applications will have to be coordinated to attract the significant capital needed to grow this part of the industry.
1.3.4
Biomass Agricultural Equipment Development
As discussed in this chapter and the subsequent chapters in the volume, there is significant activity in the development of biomass feedstocks, conversion processes, and end-use applications. Increasingly, there is also investment by major farm equipment manufacturers in developing biomass harvest systems such as one-pass corn cob harvesters or systems to remove tree residues in harvesting. Noteworthy projects include commercial scale harvesting demonstrations of corn cobs by POET Energy and switchgrass by Genera Energy, LLC. (www.generaenergy.net). Equipment manufacturers actively engaged in biomass development activities include AGCO (www.agcorp. com); CLAAS (www.claasofamerica. com); CNH America, LLC. (www.cnh.com); Deere & Company; and Vermeer Corporation (www.vermeer. com). The involvement of these prominent companies in both agriculture and forestry-based biomass development addresses another major link in the new supply chain and promises innovative solutions for farmers and processors.
1.4 The Biochemical Technology Platform Biomass or components of biomass can be used as feedstocks by molecular modification of the constituents, a process often referred to as bioprocessing. There are three distinct technology platforms for these molecular transformations—chemical, thermochemical, and biochemical. Each platform has specific characteristics for commercial processing, including range of feedstocks and products, co-products, cost, scale, and stage of technology development. The focus of this book is on the biochemical technology platform that utilizes enzymes and microorganisms to effect molecular transformations, often with incredible energy efficiency and product specificity. Biochemical processing, sometimes referred to as the “sugar” or
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
12
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
carbohydrate platform, seeks to convert C-6 and C-5 sugars derived from biomass through fermentation processes to biofuel and biobased chemical products. In the United States and globally, much recent biochemical platform R&D has focused on the development of pretreatment systems and enzymes that can depolymerize cellulose and hemicellulose into monomeric sugars to allow yeast fermentation to “cellulosic” ethanol. As a second-generation biofuel, ethanol derived from lignocellulosic feedstocks eliminates the food-fuel issue associated with sugar/starch feedstocks and has also been shown to have a much more favorable net energy balance and lifecycle GHG reduction than corn (starch-based) ethanol. Also within the biochemical platform, other research is developing new bacterial organisms and genetically modified yeasts to convert both C-6 and C-5 sugars to other biofuel and chemical products (see Chapters 11 and 12 in this volume), with perhaps the most advanced efforts directed at butanol, an important industrial chemical and possible second-generation biofuel, and succinic acid, a multifunctional platform chemical. Significant progress has been made in developing biochemical technologies to use lignocellulosic feedstocks. The overall process requires several steps, including feedstock pretreatment, depolymerization, sugar fermentation, and distillation/product isolation. Several pretreatment methodologies have been developed, generally combining heat, pressure, and chemical reaction to make the cellulose and hemicellulose polymers more accessible to enzymatic and microorganism attack (as described in Chapter 9 in this volume). Pretreatment processing must be designed to minimize introduction or formation of contaminants that would be toxic to the downstream fermentation organisms. While significant hydrolysis of the hemicellulose can occur during pretreatment, cellulase and other enzymes must be added to convert the more recalcitrant cellulose to its component C-6 sugars and complete conversion of hemicellulose to C-5 sugars. Remarkable advancements in cellulase enzyme cost and effectiveness have been made in the last 5 years and are continuing (see Chapter 10 in this volume). Novel approaches to enzyme production are also being developed, for example: A major technical challenge in making cellulosic ethanol economically viable is the need to lower the costs of enzymes needed to convert biomass to fermentable sugars. The expression of cellulases and hemicellulases in crop plants and their integration with existing ethanol production systems are key technologies that will significantly improve the process economics of cellulosic ethanol production. (Sainz, 2009)
While C-6 sugars are readily fermented to ethanol by natural yeasts, current R&D programs seek to develop new organisms that can effectively convert the C-5, as well as the C-6 lignocellulosic sugars to ethanol and other chemical products. Some R&D programs are pursuing organisms that can both hydrolyze cellulose and hemicellulose and ferment the resulting mixed sugars to ethanol, referred to as consolidated bioprocessing. These efforts will be more fully described in other Chapters throughout this volume.
1.5 Investment and Major Players Despite the recent global economic downturn, $16.9 billion was invested in new biofuels in 2008 (UN, 2009) and the cleantech sector emerged as the leading investment category for venture capitalists in 2009. Recognizing the complexities of introducing new biobased
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks
13
technologies, strategic partnerships are becoming a preferred route to commercial products in the biobased supply chain. This is leading to a business environment that includes direct investments in entrepreneurial ventures, as well as many strategic partnerships and joint ventures, often leveraging existing competencies and assets. Table 1.2 summarizes key biobased product companies and their investors/partners.
Table 1.2.
Selected investments and joint ventures in biobased product companies.
Company
Feedstock/Product
Investors/Partners
Abengoa Bioenergy
Corn ethanol and experimental lignocellulosic biomass fuels and chemicals
DOE
Amyris Biotechnology
Development of advanced biofuels and chemicals from sugar-based feedstocks including sweet sorghum and sugar cane.
DAG Ventures, Khosla Ventures, Kleiner Perkins, TPG Ventures, Total
Butamax Advanced Biofuels
Biobutanol, sugarbeets
DuPont, British Petroleum
Catchlight Energy LLC.
Feedstocks, supply chain, technology licensing and deployment
Joint ventures between Chevron & Weyerhauser
Coskata
Wood, MSW
Khosla Ventures, Great Point Ventures, Advanced technology Ventures, General Motors, Globespan
Dupont Danisco Cellulosic Ethanol, LLC.
Corn cobs, switchgrass
DuPont, Danisco, Genera Energy (University of Tennessee).
Dupont Tate&Lyle
Sugar
DuPont, Tate&Lyle
Elevance Renewable Sciences
Oilseeds
Cargill Inc., Materia Inc., California Institute of Technology, TPG Growth, TPG Biotechnology Partners
Gevo Development LLC.
Biobutanol, other biobased products.
Cargill, ICM, Khosla Ventures, Virgin Fuels, Burrill & Company, Malaysian Life Sciences Capital Fund
Iogen Corporation
Wheat straw, other feedstocks, cellulosic ethanol
Royal Dutch Shell, Goldman Sachs, Volkswagen, Petro-Canada, Government of Canada, DSM
Mascoma Corporation
Biomass feedstocks, cellulosic ethanol
Khosla Ventures, Flagship Ventures, General Catalyst, Kleiner Perkins, Vantage Point, Atlas Ventures, Pinnacle Ventures
Range Fuels
Wood and other biomass feedstocks, cellulosic ethanol
Passport Capital, BlueMountain, Khosla Ventures, Leaf Clean Energy Company, PCG Clean Energy & Technology Fund
Verenium Corporation
Wood, sugarcane bagasse
British Petroleum, Khosla Ventures, Braemar Energy Ventures, Charles River and Rho Ventures
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
14
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Significant investments were made in advanced biofuels and green chemistry by a range of biotechnology, petroleum, and chemical companies in 2008 and 2009. Funding directed toward developing biobased chemicals has risen steadily since 2004 and reached $3.4 billion in 2007 in the United States (Lundy et al., 2008). From 2004 to 2009, major investments were made by large multinational petroleum and chemical companies, including Chevron, DuPont, Dow, Dutch Royal Shell, and Exxon Mobil. Venture capital investment also grew substantially, with the cleantech sector moving into a leadership position through the economic downturn of 2008–2009. As an example, new funds were announced by leading cleantech investor Khosla Ventures (www.khoslaventures.com), as well as Finistere Ventures (www.finistereventures.com). Partnerships among established global producers in the agriculture, biotechnology, chemical, and petroleum sectors are becoming commonplace. An early example was the Cargill-Dow, LLC venture started in 1997, which is now NatureWorks, LLC (www.natureworksllc. com) (wholly owned by Cargill), which invested approximately $1 billion to commercialize cornbased polylactic acid (PLA). British Petroleum and DuPont have formed Butamax Advanced Biofuels, LLC (www.butamax. com) to commercialize biobutanol as an advanced biofuel, while British Petroleum is also investing in Verenium and other advanced cellulosic biofuels businesses. More recently, Exxon Mobil announced in 2009 a $600 million investment to produce biofuels from algae in a joint venture with Synthetic Genomics founded by human genome pioneer J. Craig Venter (Mouawad, 2009). Royal Dutch Shell PLC increased its investment to $60 million in 2009 in Codexis (www.codexis) to explore biofuels production (Gold, 2009) while continuing to partner with Canada-based Iogen (www.iogen. ca). DuPont has formed Dupont Danisco Cellulosic Ethanol, LLC (www.ddce. com) to commercialize cellulosic ethanol and is in a joint venture with sugar company Tate & Lyle (called Dupont Tate & Lyle Bioproducts) to produce 1,3-propanediol (www.duponttateandlyle. com). These are a few of the hundreds of new business divisions, companies, and partnerships being developed globally to pursue renewable fuels and chemicals. Major venture capital funders such as Khosla Ventures (www.khoslaventures. com) and Burrill & Company (www.burrillandco. com) announced new funds in 2009 that will focus on biofuels and related technologies, including two new funds totaling $1 billion by Khosla Ventures. Khosla Ventures has led investment in numerous advanced biofuels companies, including Amyris (www.amyris. com), Coskata (www.coskata. com), Gevo (www.gevo. com), LS9 (www.ls9. com), Mascoma (www.mascoma. com), Range Fuels (www.rangefuels. com), and Verenium (www.verenium. com), providing strong strategic direction and momentum to the industry at a crucial time. Coskata has also received investment from General Motors, another example of the cross-industry, strategic investments made in this space between 2005 and 2009. Incorporating the forestry sector, Catchlight Energy is a joint venture between Chevron and Weyerhaeuser dedicated to combining the strengths of the two organizations to commercialize biofuels (www.catchlightenergy. com). The formation of domestic and foreign strategic alliances has grown from 532 new industrial biotechnology alliances in 2004 to 1,367 new alliances in 2007. Patent and trademark activity has intensified as firms seek to protect, commercialize, and license their new discoveries and brands. Trademark registrations in particular have shown strong growth, increasing from 197 new registrations in 2004 to 1,027 in 2007, reflecting the increasing prominence of biobased brands as the field moves from early discoveries to the commercialization of innovative technologies and products (Lundy et al., 2008). The Federal Government’s significant investments since 2000 have helped many of the early companies develop technologies, improve processes, and leverage private investment, as
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks
Table 1.3.
15
Selected USDA and DOE grants (2002–2009) for biomass projects.
Year
Program
Total Funding
Awarded Projects
Partial List of Recipients
2002
Biomass R&D Joint
$79,350,000.00 8 awards
Broin & Associates (now POET), Cargill, DuPont, Abengoa, National Corn Growers Association, Iowa Corn Promotion Board
2003
Biomass R&D Joint
$23,803,802.00 19 awards
Dartmouth (Mascoma), University of Florida (now partnering with Buckeye Technologies), Pure Vision Technology, Metabolix, Cargill, ADM
2004
Biomass R&D Joint
$26,357,056.00 13 awards
Rohm & Haas Co., Weyerhaeuser Company
2005
Biomass R&D Joint
$12,626,931.00 11 awards
Samuel Robert Noble Foundation
2006
Biomass R&D Joint
$17,492,507
17 awards
Increasing focus on feedstock development: Ceres Inc., SUNY, Edenspace Systems
2007
Biomass R&D Joint
$18,449,090.00 21 awards
GE Global Research, Ceres Inc., Agrivida Inc.
2007
DOE Commercial Scale Biorefinery
$385,000,000.00 6 awards
Abengoa Bioenergy, BlueFire Ethanol, Broin Companies (now POET), Iogen, Range Fuels
2008
DOE Small Scale Biorefinery
$200,000,000.00 7 awards
Verenium, Lignol Innovations, ICM, UT/Genera
2009
DOE Advanced Biorefinery
$564,000,000.00 19 awards
ADM, Amyris Biotechnology Inc., Elevance Renewable Sciences, BioEnergy International LLC (Myriant)
summarized in Table 1.3. For example, the recent $564 million DOE investment in advanced biorefinery projects leveraged a private investment of $1.3 billion. The Obama Administration is continuing to invest heavily in advanced biofuels, regional innovation clusters, renewable energy jobs, and biotechnology. On the feedstock side, substantial investment is occurring in the development of dedicated energy crops and crop-based synergies such as enhanced traits or downstream processability. These initiatives include the commercialization of plant-made enzymes by Syngenta and startup companies, and the commercialization of dedicated energy crops by companies such as Arborgen, Ceres, and Mendel Biotechnology.
1.6 The Role of the Farmer An essential component of the value chain for biobased products is the alignment of companies seeking to commercialize biobased products with feedstock providers, namely the farmers, logistics, and preprocessing producers. All too often biobased products industry proponents tout the ability of biorefineries to revitalize rural regions without understanding the overall value proposition or fully considering the vital linkages necessary with the farmer. Three
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
16
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
primary models have emerged for companies and processors to access lignocellulosic biomass, as described below (Nelson, unpublished). (1) Farm gate—In this model, farmers are paid a set price and/or contracted price for biomass baled and delivered to the factory, storage site, or made available at field for pickup. Generally, this price is between $30 and $70 per dry ton according to most publications. In discussions with farmers, it is clear that this model will require a guaranteed long-term contract that includes one or more of the following: an independent ability to market carbon credits, a contract price (especially for perennial energy crops) indexed to corn or petroleum, and a guaranteed price floor. The Biomass Crop Assistance Program (BCAP) authorized in the 2008 Farm Bill was recently released, which will provide assistance to farmers producing biomass crops within this scenario. (2) Access fee/land rental—In this model, farmers are essentially land owners, similar to the pulp and paper industry, in which companies pay to have dedicated energy crops produced and the companies handle the planting and harvesting. Although the farmers may have some role in maintenance, they are essentially operating as absentee land owners. This model is not considered viable in major row crop farming regions, but may be of interest to small, part time farmers or those that own marginal land. (3) Value-added farmer participation—In this model, farmers participate in a value-added enterprise, possibly formed as a cooperative, in which their biomass production includes some component of preprocessing, logistics, and/or value-added processing or service to the end clients. As an example, a University of Tennessee-sponsored program through its subsidiary company Genera Energy, LLC (www.generaenergy.net) has formed a biomass processing cooperative to support scale up of switchgrass in East Tennessee. In the United States, the development of farmer-owned businesses to process biomass into pellets or briquettes to cofire with coal or other biopower applications may serve to establish a reliable supply chain for lignocellulosic biomass destined for future higher-value applications, other than combustion. Show Me Energy Cooperative LLC. of Centerview, Missouri (www.goshowmeenergy.com) is a great example. Show Me Energy has over 400 farmers who own part of the cooperative and are supplying waste straw and dedicated energy crops to their pellet operation. Logistics and storage considerations for commercial lignocellulosic feedstock supply are not insignificant. For example, within each of these models, some scenarios envision biomass materials being baled and stored at the fields for delivery throughout the year to the processing facility. It remains to be seen whether off-season on-field storage of lignocellulosic crops will be accepted by high production commercial row crop farming operations. For a given project or program, the successful model must involve farmers and supporting logistics providers as more than an afterthought. To attract serious, large-scale farmers who can professionally deliver large volumes of biomass as well as invest in the supporting infrastructure will require new business models that make a compelling case to each participant in the supply chain.
1.7 Opportunities for Rural Development A pressing need exists for rural development to provide jobs and long-term sustainable opportunities in rural areas in the United States and across the world. In the United States, poverty is consistently higher in rural as opposed to urban areas, with over 500 rural counties defined as being in “persistent poverty.” Agriculture is often a significant economic sector in these regions, but its role as a job and local wealth creator has declined in recent years (Cowan,
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks
17
2002). New biobased feedstocks may offer the opportunity to grow, process, and transport lignocellulosic biomass for new products and rebuild these local agriculture-based economies. The conversion of lignocellulosic biomass to biobased products promises to have significant impact on rural communities. The low bulk density of lignocellulosic biomass dramatically changes logistics and processing dynamics. Grain crops such as corn and soybeans can be economically transported via barge and rail for remote processing and consumption, whereas at least the first phase of commercial lignocellulosic feedstock processing will necessarily be located in close proximity to the harvested biomass due to transport economics. This is especially true for herbaceous biomass such as processing and crop residues and dedicated energy crops, while forestry materials or densified feedstocks may be transported longer distances. Most models indicate that the viable transport radius of harvested herbaceous energy crops around a rural biorefinery or preprocessing facility is approximately 25–50 miles. This will necessitate smaller decentralized biorefineries across rural areas that will at least incorporate preprocessing and/or initial refining of lignocellulosic biomass substrates. To give an example of what this opportunity can mean for rural regions, the corn ethanol industry can be examined at its high growth period from 2006 to 2008. One report summarized the economic impact during this period as follows: The industry spent $12.5 billion on raw materials, other inputs, goods and services to produce an estimated 6.5 billion gallons of ethanol during 2007. An additional $1.6 billion was spent to transport grain and other inputs to production facilities. Within the corn ethanol industry, new jobs are created as a consequence of increased economic activity resulting from ongoing production and construction of new capacity supported the creation of 238,541 jobs in all sectors of the economy during 2007. These include more than 46,000 jobs in America’s manufacturing sector – American jobs making ethanol from grain produced by American farmers (Urbanchuk, 2008).
Despite its significant rural economic impact in the United States, it is generally recognized that starch-based ethanol is an important, but ultimately limited, first-generation biofuel. As such, its economic impact on rural communities may have been largely realized. Furthermore, the germplasm, production inputs, and processing of corn are controlled by a relatively small number of multinational companies such as DuPont Pioneer, Monsanto and Syngenta on the seed side, and ADM, Bunge, and Cargill on the processing side, leaving little room for entrepreneurial technology developers and farmer value participation. Fortunately, the fully realized bioeconomy will require diverse and flexible feedstocks and technologies to produce a comprehensive range of biobased products, as well as biofuels. The multiproduct “biorefinery” will increasingly utilize more globally abundant lignocellulosic feedstocks to produce both commodity and value-added products. As a result, the lignocellulosic processing opportunity is substantially larger in terms of volume, and the low bulk density will dictate that processing be located in proximity to feedstock production. In contrast to corn and other grains with fully developed food-centric supply chains, the lignocellulosic feedstock supply chain is largely undeveloped and unconsolidated. A recent comprehensive United States study concluded that in a 98-county area in the Mid-South Mississippi Delta region, lignocellulosic feedstock processing utilizing 10% of cropland, 25% of idle lands, 25% of conservation reserve program land, and 15% of pasture land would support a biomass industry valued at over $8 billion annually. This industry would create 25,000 new jobs within a decade and 50,000 jobs by 2030 in the study area alone (Tripp et al., 2009).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
18
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
1.8 Environmental Benefits The environmental benefits of biobased products and related technologies are just beginning to be fully understood. For example, studies have shown that the life cycle analysis for cellulosic ethanol produced from certain dedicated energy crops has a 90% reduction in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions compared to petroleum gasoline (Farrell et al., 2006). Case studies have shown that energy and water use for biobased processes decreased 10–80%, while the use of petrochemical solvents was reduced by 90% or eliminated completely (OECD, 2001). Additional benefits can be found in product recyclability, air emissions, and reduced overall energy consumption from locally sourced foods, materials, and fuels. However, sustainable crop production is necessary to avoid soil and water depletion, as described in Chapters 6 and 7 of this volume.
1.9 Economic Comparison of the Biochemical and Thermochemical Technology Platforms According to a recent report by the International Energy Agency (IEA), the thermochemical and biochemical routes have comparable potential energy yields, converting dry biomass at about 20 GJ/ton to about 6.5 GJ/ton of biofuels, for an overall conversion efficiency of about 35%. The report further projects potential ethanol yield of about 80 gallons/dry ton from biochemical processing and a synthetic diesel yield of 53 gallons/dry ton from thermochemical conversion. Experience with each platform, utilizing biomass feedstocks, is limited to pilot and precommercial scale at present, so accurate production cost information remains to be confirmed (see Chapter 14 in this volume). Furthermore, leading private-sector technology developers do not generally publish proprietary process cost information. IEA has estimated production costs of second-generation biofuels to be in the range of $3.02–3.79/gallon for ethanol and at least $3.79/gallon for synthetic diesel, comparable to the wholesale petrochemical fuel prices when crude oil is in the range of $100–130/bbl. The IEA report concludes that there is presently not a clear commercial or technical advantage between the platforms for the production of biofuels and that widely fluctuating crude oil prices impart high risk to investment in second-generation biofuels (IEA, 2008). The IEA report does not take into account the value of biobased products and the benefit of added flexibility of diverse end product applications.
1.10 Conclusions and Future Prospects The bioeconomy represents a disruptive technological, social, and economic change that will be realized over decades, not years. The opportunities—as described in this volume—are many, as are the challenges. These will be met and exploited by a diverse combination of traditional foodbased agribusiness, the fossil-based fuel and chemical industries, entrepreneurs, financiers, and farmers. The market for biobased products is potentially higher value than for biofuels, and biochemical processing technologies likely offer more value-added specialty chemical product options than thermochemical technologies. Sugars derived from globally abundant and dispersed
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
1 The Bioeconomy: A New Era of Products Derived from Renewable Plant-Based Feedstocks
19
lignocellulosic feedstocks would serve as the predominant raw materials for rural biorefineries, which in turn could transform declining rural economies and create new “local” supply chains for energy, liquid transportation fuels, and other products. Positive environmental impacts from the use of renewable feedstocks, lower intensity manufacturing, and more efficient local supply and consumption would be significant. A vision for plant-based renewable resources was published in 1998 (http://www1. eere.energy.gov/biomass/pdfs/technology roadmap.pdf). This document was the result of a workshop comprising industry and trade group representatives assembled to discuss what it would take to convert the US industrial base to a more sustainable economy. The goals were modest by most standards: 10% of bio-based products and 40% of fuels would be from plantbased sources by the year 2050. Over a decade later, progress down this path has been slow at best. More aggressive goals than those stated in the 1998 document have been set in the US 2007 Energy Independence and Security Act—36 billion gallons of renewable transportation fuels per year (∼20–30% replacement) to be reached in 2022. Because corn-starch-based ethanol is nearly maximal at 9 billion gallons per year (∼25% of the grain crop), the balance of the ethanol should be derived from lignocellulosic biomass. The ultimate requirement to replace finite fossil feedstocks with renewable resources is perhaps best described by Italian Chemist and holocaust survivor Primo Levi in his 1975 chronicle of the elements (Levi, 1975): Carbon, in fact, is a singular element: it is the only element that can bind itself in long stable chains without a great expense of energy, and for life on earth (the only one we know so far) precisely long chains are required. If the elaboration of carbon were not a common daily occurrence, on the scale of billions of tons a week, wherever the green of a leaf appears, it would by full right deserve to be called a miracle. Man has not tried until now to compete with nature on this terrain, that is, he has not striven to draw from the carbon dioxide in the air the carbon that is necessary to nourish him, clothe him, warm him, and for the hundred other more sophisticated needs of modern life. He has not done it because he has not needed to: he has found and is still finding (but for how many more decades?) gigantic reserves of carbon already organized, or at least reduced. Besides the vegetable and animal worlds, these reserves are constituted by deposits of coal and petroleum: but these too are the inheritance of photosynthetic activity carried out in distant epochs, so that one can well affirm that photosynthesis is not only the sole path by which carbon becomes living matter, but also the sole path by which the sun’s energy becomes chemically usable.
The chapters of this volume describe the current state of the transformation to a renewable and sustainable bioeconomy and suggest the opportunities that await its realization.
References Agenda 2020 Technology Alliance, American Forest & Paper Association. Integrated Forest Products Biorefinery. Available: www.agenda2020.org/PDF/IFPB Brochure.pdf. Cowan, T. 2002. Value-Added Agricultural Enterprises in Rural Development Strategies. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service, The Library of Congress. DOE. 2007. Top Value-Added Chemicals from Biomass, Volume II—Results of Screening for Potential Candidates from Biorefinery Lignin. Available: www1.eere.energy.gov/ biomass/pdfs/pnnl-16983.pdf.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c01 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20
20:45
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Frost, J. W. 2005. Redefining chemical manufacture, replacing petroleum with plant-derived feedstocks. Industrial Biotechnology, 1(1), 23–25. Gold, R. 2009. Shell, other oil firms bolster biofuels spending. Wall Street Journal (newspaper), December 30. Grooms, L. 2006. Farm Industry News, September. Farrell, A. E., et al. 2006. Ethanol can contribute to energy and environmental goals. Science 311(5760), 506–508. IEA. 2008. 1st to 2nd Generation Biofuel Technologies: An Overview of Current Industry and RD&D Activities. Available: www.iea.org/Textbase/Publications/free new Desc. asp?PUBS ID=20742. International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-biotech Applications (ISAAA). 2008. ISAAA Report for 2008. Jarrell, K. A. 2009. Synthetic biology and the sustainable chemistry revolution. Industrial Biotechnology, 5(4), 210–212. Levi, P. (1975). The Periodic Table. Penguin Books, London, UK. Lundy, D., et al. 2008. Industrial Biotechnology: Development and Adoption by the U. S. Chemical and Biofuel Industries. Washington, DC: U. S. International Trade Commission. Mouawad, J. 2009. Exxon to invest millions to make fuel from algae. New York Times, July 13. Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD). 2001. The Application of Biotechnology to Industrial Sustainability. Paris. Nelson, P. 2006. Developing an Ag-based biomass supply chain: What is the role of the farmer? Presented at The World Congress on Industrial Biotechnology, Toronto, Canada, July 14. Newell, R. 2009. Annual Energy Outlook 2010, Reference Case, U. S. Energy Information Administration, Washington, DC, December 14. Panter, D. 2008. Sustainable Oils LLC, Conference Presentation, Memphis, Tennessee, November. Perlack, R. D., Wright, L. L., Turhollow, A. F., Graham, R. L., Stokes, B. J., & Erbach, D. C. 2005. Biomass as Feedstock for a Bioenergy and Bioproducts Industry: The Technical Feasibility of a Billion-Ton Annual Supply. Oak Ridge: Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Sainz, M. 2009. Commercial cellulosic ethanol: The role of plant-expressed enzymes. In Vitro Cellular & Developmental Biology, 45, 314–329. Tripp, S., Nelson, P., & Powell, R. 2009. Regional Strategy for Biobased Products in the Mississippi Delta, Report by Battelle Technology Partnership Practice. United Nations. 2009. Global Trends in Sustainable Energy Investment. Available: www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/node/277152. Urbanchuk, J. M. 2008. Contribution of the Ethanol Industry to the Economy of the United States. Prepared for the Renewable Fuels Association.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Chapter 2
Agricultural Residues James Hettenhaus
2.1 Introduction The present US ethanol industry has grown rapidly using cereal grain, mainly corn, as its primary feedstock. Corn grain has been a global commodity for more than a century, with the supply and demand inextricably linked. Infrastructure is in place to grow, harvest, store, and transport corn to global markets. When the US demand for corn increased to supply newly constructed ethanol plants over the last decade, the only concern was locating those plants to economically source the corn, convert it to biofuels, and ship the products to market. The availability and quality of corn was not in question, just the price relative to other costs of goods sold. In 2007, Congress enacted the Energy Independence and Security Act, establishing a Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) goal for advanced biofuels. Advanced biofuel is defined as the total production from cellulosic biomass and biomass-based diesel and biogas produced through the conversion of organic matter from renewable biomass. Cellulosic biofuels make up the major portion of the mandate by 2016 (Table 2.1). The basic platform for building advanced biofuels is the cellulosic biofuels segment. The RFS mandates growth from a few research and early commercialization efforts now to 16 billion gallons by 2022. Massive investment of resources across the supply chain will be required in a relatively short time frame to meet this goal. New technology must be validated, plants designed and constructed, feedstock sourced, and logistical systems in place to move cellulosic biomass feedstocks to facilities and finished biofuels to customer markets. For example, five 100 MGPY facilities could meet the cellulosic goal of 500 million gallons in 2012. An examination of the 100 MGPY corn-based facilities gives some ideas of the size and logistics of this undertaking. Each 100 MGPY corn-based facility requires about 36 million bushels of corn, supplied from about 200,000 acres. Because of improved seeds,
Plant Biomass Conversion, First Edition. Edited by Elizabeth E. Hood, Peter Nelson and Randall Powell. C 2011 John Wiley & Sons Inc.
21
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
22
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 2.1. EISA 2007 biofuel goals.
Year
Advanced Biofuel (in Billion Gallons)
Cellulosic Biofuel (in Billion Gallons)
Cellulosic (% Advanced Biofuels)
Cellulosic Feedstock (Million Dry Tons)
2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022
2.0 3.8 7.2 11.0 15.0 21.0
0.5 1.6 4.2 7.0 10.5 16.0
25% 47% 59% 64% 70% 67%
500 1,600 4,200 7,000 10,500 16,000
corn yields increase 2–3 bu/ac annually. An additional 10–15 million bushels will be produced on the 5 million acres within a 50-mile radius of the facility. Depending on the relative cost, the farmer can increase the amount of corn planted or adjust the inputs to grow more corn on the same acres. The corn is usually delivered by truck over this distance. The facility may also choose to purchase the corn outside of the immediate area. Delivery could be by truck or rail, depending on the distance and relative cost. River Barge shipments are common and ocean-going shipments are also routine. The situation is somewhat different for biomass-derived products. The five cellulosic 100 MGPY facilities, necessary to reach the 2012 RFS goal, are estimated to require 1 million or more dry tons of cellulosic feedstock. Thermochemical facilities convert the lignin and the carbohydrates to fuels, producing 100–110 gallons per ton. Biochemical facilities use the cellulose and a portion of the hemicellulose for fuels, producing 80–90 gallons per ton. Their lignin is being evaluated for a multitude of uses, including supplying the process energy needs, selling the excess as power, or as raw material for value-added products (Simmons et al., 2010). Unlike corn, currently no system is in place to supply 1 million tons of feedstock to each of these facilities. In fact, this biomass supply requirement is 20 times greater than the largest corn stover or cereal straw collection supplied to a single site, currently 50,000 tons. This stover collection project for 50,000 tons required reaching agreement with 400 farmers and contracting with more than 30 custom operators for baling and hauling (Glassner et al., 1998; Hettenhaus, 2006). Thus, one can imagine the increased complexity of logistics. Cellulosic feedstock is also unlike corn and other cereal grains and sugar, i.e., no quality standards for biomass exist. Biomass is not fungible, and it has no asset value to provide source of liquidity to the owner until sold. The challenge is to overcome these and other obstacles in order to reach the goal of tripling biomass production between 2012 and 2014 and then increasing production ten times over the subsequent 8 years, between 2014 and 2022.
2.1.1
Key Issues
One of the key issues is that farmers and landowners control the cellulosic feedstock supply. They will decide when to provide their crop residues, deliver forest biomass, and make the decision to grow dedicated energy crops. Unless there is a significant benefit for farmers to change current production and crop management practices, cellulosic feedstock in large quantities from crop residues will be difficult to source for industrial use. A reliable market is needed for the farmer to commit to producing biomass, while the processor requires a reliable supply of feedstock. Unlike corn, bulky agricultural residues are
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
23
limited to a local market due to transport costs. A win-win relationship between the farmer and the processor is needed for the feedstock supply chain to flourish. Economics must benefit the farmer and the processor. Once cellulosic technology is proven: farmer participation in the value chain would help overcome the current “chicken or egg” obstacle of sourcing and supplying crop residues to biorefineries. The “Minnesota Model” provided incentives for Minnesota farmers to participate in the corn grain-to-ethanol value chain through offering ownership of corn ethanol plants. The State-funded program resulted in the formation of 12 farmer-owned ethanol processing cooperatives (Morris, 2008). Currently, over 30% of Minnesota farmers are investors in corn ethanol plants and a “Minnesota Model 2” is underway with Minnesota farmers collecting corn cobs for biomass gasification in their plants, while evaluating grasses, straw, and other cellulosic feedstocks (Kleinschmit, 2008). The feedstock must be competitive with natural gas pricing. Sustainable harvest systems must be in place to ensure that soil quality is maintained. Farmers are the stewards of the soil. However, processors and their customers expect validation of sustainable feedstock. This dichotomy requires a solution for moving agriculture residues ahead as feedstocks. Quality of feedstock is still loosely defined at the present stage of industry development. There is a consensus that feedstock needs to be free of dirt and relatively consistent in composition. Feedstock containing dirt accelerates equipment wear, increases maintenance cost, and causes lost production. Preferably, the material is collected while still standing in the field. During grain harvest, some residues inevitably end up on the ground as vehicles pulling trailers and grain carts drive alongside the combine to off-load the grain, knocking down a portion of the crop residues. A final issue is that feedstock composition varies, and any move towards more consistent composition would improve operating stability. Participants in stakeholder sessions considered consistency more important for biochemical processing than for thermochemical due to the more narrow selectivity of bioprocessing. Some processors said they would pay based on dry weight, but would eventually prefer to pay based on composition and “ease of processing.”
2.2 Feedstock Supply Sourcing an adequate, reliable, and economic supply of cellulosic feedstock is a major obstacle in commercializing renewable fuels. Studies at a macro level found the supply potential to be 900 million tons of agricultural biomass and nearly 400 million tons of forest biomass feedstock (Table 2.2; Perlack, 2005). These quantities of feedstock are based on a sustainable harvest using “best crop practices” for maintaining soil quality. The quantities will shift based on markets, government policies, and local economics. Crop residues are available in significant quantities now. However, removing large quantities for a biorefinery is a serious challenge to the farmer as well as the biomass buyer representing the biorefinery. Establishing sustainable crop systems for removal requires changing to new methods, acquiring new knowledge, and investing in different equipment. An estimated 900 MDTY of agricultural biomass is available now if “best crop systems” are practiced to maintain soil quality and achieve sustainable removal. Only 200 MDTY is required to meet the EISA 2022 goal of 16 billion gallons of cellulosic biofuels. The actual amount that can be removed in a sustainable and economic manner depends on cropping practices,
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
24
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 2.2.
US cellulosic biomass feedstock supply potential.
Biomass Source
MDT
Agricultural biomass Crop residues Perennial crops Others: e.g., process residues Forest biomass Forest products industry residues Logging residues Forest thinning Urban wood residues Energy crops
900 430 370 100 370 150 60 60 50 50
MDT, million dry tons.
especially till or no-till, and geophysical parameters—soil type, field slope, and length, as well as weather. The largest component of agricultural biomass is 430 MDTY of crop residues (Table 2.2), mostly corn stover. Stover production is 300 MDTY. Other residues are largely straw from cereal grains—wheat and barley. There is a 1:1 stover to grain weight ratio in most grain crops. A field producing 180 bu/ac corn leaves 5 tons/ac of stover in the field. Straw residues in dryland farming amount to 1–2 tons per acre. Some amount is often left on the field to retain soil moisture and prevent wind and water erosion. Larger residue quantities provide a harbor for fungi, weed seeds, and pests that can damage the crop. In the northern parts of the Corn Belt, the surface cover prevents the cold damp soil from warming in the spring, delaying seed germination. A rule of thumb is that each day delay in soil warming reduces the yield by 1 bu/ac. For these reasons, there is a clear advantage to the farmer for removing the stover, which will increase as corn yields increase. Continued trait improvement of corn is expected to raise corn yield 3 bu/ac/year in the near term. Seed companies project 300 bu/ac corn yields by 2030 due to advances in molecular breeding and biotechnology. The 1:1 ratio is expected to remain unchanged and stover, now at 8.4 tons/ac, becomes even more difficult to manage. Until now, there has been little market for stover. Most is on-farm use for animal bedding and cattle grazing after the grain harvest. As a result, the fields are tilled to bury most of the surface residue and compensate for soil compaction. Tilling adds $15/ac cost, increases soil erosion, and results in a loss of soil organic material, reducing soil quality. Process residues, 100 MDTY, include cotton gin trash, bagasse, and oat hulls. Available in smaller quantities at the processing plant, they enjoy an economic advantage, as they do not have to be collected and transported from the field. Forest products and energy crops are discussed in other chapters in this volume (Chapters 3 and 4) and will not be addressed here. As mentioned previously, conventional biofuel is ethanol produced from corn starch, while advanced biofuel is defined as renewable fuel that has life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions that achieve at least a 50% reduction over baseline life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions. Cellulosic biofuel is renewable fuel derived from any cellulose or lignocellulose that is derived from renewable biomass. Included within the definition of feedstocks for advanced biofuels are sugar or starch (other than corn starch), crop residues, vegetative waste material, food waste, and yard waste.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
25
While the current data provide some idea of estimated feedstock, the future is not likely to maintain the agronomic system status quo. The segments in the agricultural production and processing pie will shift due to new and varied markets and technology improvement of the crops. Future feedstock availability will depend on the following: r Crops will be planted to meet the demands of new and existing markets. As markets
change, crops will be adjusted to meet customer demand.
r Cropping practices will be required to ensure soil quality maintenance. When a market
for crop residues develops, new residue management practices are likely that lead to economic and sustainable removal. ◦ No-till is assumed in most studies of crop residue management systems that will yield excess cellulosic biomass feedstock. Presently, only one out of five corn and wheat farmers use no-till today (CTIC, 2007). ◦ New cropping systems that include cover crops are needed for erosion control and to maintain soil carbon on many fields to allow for sustainable residue removal. r Accurate models for “soil quality” based on soil organic material must be developed. Several models are in development, but validation is required (See Chapter 7 in this volume). r Changes in farm and energy policies will be needed, with stronger connections between farm policy and energy policy, which can incentivize cellulosic feedstock production. Significant regional differences exist in soils, weather, and crop characteristics, as well as differences in harvesting mechanics for stover and straw. In dryer areas, more residue is currently left in the field to retain moisture in the soil. More cover must also be left on highly erodible soils and sloping fields to protect the soil from water and wind erosion. More corn stover is produced than straw, but straw is more readily removed. Corn stover yields are 3–5 times greater per acre than straw from cereal crops. Unless cereal crops are irrigated, there is little straw left to collect. For example, the average dryland wheat straw yield is 2,500 pounds per acre compared to 10,000 pounds per acre or more for corn stover. The equivalent of 1,200 pounds per acre of straw must be left on the surface to comply with erosion guidelines with no-till. The excess is less than 1 ton of straw per acre that is removable. In contrast, leaving 2,000 lbs of stover with no-till is often sufficient and the excess is 8,000 lbs or more of stover per acre. Straw collection infrastructure is generally well developed, while corn stover collection is not. When cereal grain is ready to harvest, straw usually contains 20% moisture or less, suitable for baling. In contrast, stover contains 50% moisture and must remain in the field to dry and be collected later, depending on the weather. A wet harvest season can prevent its collection entirely. Farmers generally agree that $50/acre pretax margin would raise some interest in harvesting crop residues, but only if the grain harvesting was not hindered in any way. Cash crop values—$3–$5/bu corn, $7–$10/bu for soybeans and wheat—make the relative value of residues small in comparison. Collecting the stover can add $100–$200/ac sales ($50/dry ton, collecting 2–4 dt of the 4.8 dt produced). However, some estimate $70–$100/dry ton delivered would likely be required to raise farmer interest. Most processors base their cost for biomass on $30–$50/dry ton delivered, a $40–$70 million annual difference in costs for a 100 MGPY plant. This discrepancy has not been adequately evaluated by potential purchasers of crop residues and other biomass feedstocks.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
26
Realizing this profit from residue sales requires overcoming related issues with harvesting and transporting crop residues that must be addressed on the farm level. Farmers routinely raise the following issues in evaluating this opportunity: r r r r r r r r r
Residue markets Residue harvest window Residue removal cost Corn yield and residue management Ag equipment needs Operating costs Residue nutrient value Farmer outlook Crop R&D lead times.
2.2.1
Residue Markets
Currently, there is a limited market for cellulosic crop residues and no market for energy crops. Crop residues that are collected are mostly for on-farm use—bedding and animal feed. Corn cobs are an exception. Corn cobs are 15%–20% of the stover. They are currently used for a wide variety of applications ranging from abrasives for polishing metal and wood (no silica hazard), as a carrier for pesticides and fertilizers, and as an absorbent for hazardous liquid spills (high absorbency properties). The price for a 40 lb bag of ground cobs for polishing metal is $25 FOB facility, equivalent to $1,250/ton (Soda-Blast.com, LLC). Collecting just the corn cobs during the grain harvest is less disruptive than collecting stover. The yield is about 0.5–0.6 tons per acre. Collecting 30% of all the cobs results in 10–15 million dry tons of feedstock nationwide. The cobs are discharged with the husk and usually spread over the field surface behind the combine after the grain is removed. Collecting the cobs and husks as they are discharged from the combine is one possibility. The cobs do not touch the ground, so they are free of dirt, rocks, and other foreign material, a common problem when baling material left on the ground. Because of recent government and economic incentives, several agricultural equipment suppliers and processors are evaluating two methods for cob collection: r Pulling a caddy behind the combine to collect cobs as they are discharged after shelling.
Questions have been raised concerning whether this process will slow the harvest too much. r Collecting the cob with the grain and screening the grain enroute to storage. A key question that must be addressed is whether the additional step in the logistics infrastructure will be cost effective. Trials to look at both methods are in progress. Two companies evaluating the methods for feedstock are Chippewa Valley Ethanol Co. (www.cvec.com), who is working to replace natural gas, and Poet, Inc. (www.poetenergy.com) for conversion to fuel ethanol. Residue sales are limited to local markets, typically within a 50-mile radius. The bulky, lowdensity properties make them expensive to load and transport. The biomass is not fungible, so there is little spot market. Sales are arranged a year in advance many times with no contract and only with a handshake.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
27
Another market for residue is leasing the harvested corn fields for grazing cattle. Most fields can provide several months of grazing after harvest. A rule of thumb is 1 cow/acre. Typical lease rates are $7–$10/acre. The only cost involved for the leaser is fencing the fields and providing drinking water for the livestock. A one-wire electric fence is generally used to contain the cattle. The fence can be easily moved from one area to another as the cattle consume the stover and is reused from year to year. Obviously, this use of agricultural residues competes with the ethanol and biobased products market.
2.2.2
Harvest Window
The harvest window for residues is the time between the grain harvest and the next field operation. For no-till fields, this is the planting time for the next crop. For tilled fields, fall tilling is usually done immediately after the harvest of the current crop, weather permitting. Fields must be dry enough to permit good ground conditions to support the equipment operations in tilled systems. According to the last USDA survey, 85% of the wheat acres and 80% of the corn acres are tilled (CTIC, 2007). The wheat ripens in early June and is harvested much earlier in the season than corn, which is harvested in mid-August through early September. Weather conditions are more favorable for field operations in June than in the fall, and therefore, wheat straw is generally more accessible for baling. Because corn harvest is later when days are shorter and cooler, wet weather may delay fields and crop from drying adequately, extending the harvest beyond 30 days. Additionally, the physiology of wheat straw is very similar to commercial hay and there is no special equipment required, while corn stover is not a homogeneous material and presents some issues in harvesting. For stable storage, the residue needs to be below 20% moisture or above 60% moisture. Between 20% and 60% moisture, microbial activity is high, thereby digesting the cellulosic material and reducing the yield. In the worst case scenario, the heat is not dissipated from the reaction and auto ignition of the material can occur. The physical structure of straw and the timing of harvest ensure conditions will be right for collection. Corn stalks are more difficult. The stalk contains about 30% more moisture than the grain and must be left in the field after the harvest to dry. Wet weather can prevent drying well past the time when the farmer would do fall tilling. Harvesting wet corn above 20% moisture is common. Its high value justifies drying in equipment designed for that purpose. The lower value of stover and its heterogeneous character prevent economic drying. Corn cobs are the exception as whole cobs dry well and store well in the open.
2.2.3
Residue Removal
The crop residue removal cost has two components: cost per acre and cost per dry ton collected. The more collected per acre, the lower the cost per ton. The quantity of residue for harvesting after the erosion requirement is met depends on cropping practices. Tillage greatly affects availability when following USDA guidelines for erosion control. No-till practice allows most of the residue to be removed, especially when cover crops are employed. In contrast, conventional tillage leaves less than 30% of the surface covered, and there is no excess residue. Baling dry material is common practice. Collecting the stover with existing equipment requires multiple passes through the field. Conventional baling requires additional passes to
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
28
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 2.3. Custom Bale & Haul economics for corn residues.
1:1 ratio, 15% moisture, sell Sale, $70/dt P&K nutrient credit, $10/dt Reduced field operations, $14/ac Total revenue increase Less stalk chopping (corn only), $9/ac Less raking, $6/ac Less custom baling $23/dt Handling, storage $5/dt Strinkage, 10% Hauling, 23 mile radius, $10/dt Net to farmer, $/ac
130 bu/ac
170 bu/ac
200 bu/ac
2 dt/ac $140 (20) 14 $134 (9) (6) (46) (10) (14) (20) $29
3 dt/ac $210 (30) 14 $194 (9) (6) (69) (15) (21) (30) $44
3.8 dt/ac $266 (38) 14 $242 (9) (6) (87) (19) (27) (38) $56
Assumptions: $70/dry ton delivered, 1 million acres, 23 miles radius collection site, 1 dt/ac left in field.
Table 2.4. One-pass harvest and transport economics for corn residues.
1:1 ratio, 15% moisture, sell Sale, $70/dt P&K nutrient credit, $10/dt Reduced field operations, $10/ac Total revenue increase Less one-pass harvest $18/ac Field to collection site transport $10/dt Handling, storage $6/dt Shrinkage, 3% Transport from collection site $7/dt Net to farmer, $/ac
130 bu/ac
170 bu/ac
200 bu/ac
2 dt/ac $140 (20) 14 $134 (18) (20) (12) (14) (20) $56
3 dt/ac $210 (30) 14 $194 (18) (30) (18) (21) (30) $86
3.8 dt/ac $266 (38) 14 $242 (18) (38) (23) (27) (38) $109
Assumptions: $70/dry ton delivered, 1 million acres, 3–13 miles radius collection site, 1 dt/ac left in field.
chop, rake, bale, and remove the bales from the field. Estimated baling costs are summarized in Table 2.3. Baling cost is about $30/dt for round or square bales at the roadside. Storing, stacking, and transporting bales add $14–$25/dt to the cost. The example assumes $70/dry ton delivered price. Collection is within a 23-mile radius encompassing 1 million acres. Costs are based on the average value from the 2008 Iowa Farm Custom Rate Survey. To achieve $50/ac pretax income, grain yields need to be 200 bu/ac, while leaving 1 dry ton in the field. One-pass harvest, bulk storage, and transporting the feedstock from regional collection centers is estimated to reduce the costs and nearly double the margins for the farmer but remains to be demonstrated (Table 2.4).
2.2.4
Residue Management
The emerging market for cellulosic feedstock and increasing yields of corn present new opportunities for better reside management. Continued trait improvement of corn by seed companies, including Monsanto (www.Monsanto.com), Pioneer (www.pioneer.com), and Syngenta
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
29
(www.syngenta.com), is expected to raise the yield 3 bu/ac/year in the near term. The ratio of stover to corn grain remains unchanged, producing an additional 150 lbs/ac of stover annually. Advances in breeding will boost the average to 300 bushels per acre by 2030. For the same 90 million acres in corn now, stover increases from 3.7 to 7.4 dt/ac, doubling stover to 600 million dt of residue to be managed. A major challenge is managing residue in an economically and environmentally sustainable way. An evolution in crop tilling practices toward no-till cropping is needed in order to supply adequate feedstock while complying with erosion guidelines and maintaining soil quality. No-till cropping is increasingly practiced but not widely utilized in regions of the country with the greatest potential to supply crop residues, as calculated based on their average yields of corn. Farmers need relevant information on the effects of biomass removal to establish a better basis for sustainable removal as biorefining opportunities emerge. A series of colloquies, or informal discussions, was held to discuss needs to accelerate cellulosic biofuels commercialization. Participants were a multidisciplinary group of industry leaders in a position to influence the future direction of the industry. Topics traced the supply chain from the farmer’s field to the marketplace. Discussion focused on increasing feedstock availability, logistical challenges to transport agricultural biomass, and financing commercial scale plants with new technology supplied with a nonfungible feedstock (Hettenhaus, 2006). All participants concurred that residue management needs to extend beyond the field, considering other portions of the supply chain. Additional infrastructure in collection, storage, and transportation are also needed, including equipment for one-pass harvesting and investments for alternatives to trucking collected material, including pipelines and short-line rail.
2.2.5
Ag Equipment Needs
Several general statements were made in the colloquies describing Agricultural Equipment needs: r To supply clean feedstock to the biorefinery, the feedstock should contain little to no dirt,
preferably the material collected never touches the ground. The dirt causes severe wear on piping, conveyors, and equipment. r To not slow down the grain harvest, crop planning is premised on collecting 10–12 acres per hour, completing the harvest within 30–40 days. The acres planted, the size of the harvest crews, and supporting equipment and infrastructure are sized to operate accordingly. If the harvest is slowed, there is increasing danger of losing a portion of the crop due to high winds and wet weather, exposing the crop to fungi and risk of more deterioration of the grain in the field. The harvest window is especially important for corn, since it is harvested late in the season with cooler weather and shorter days. Several one-pass prototypes are being investigated that do not slow down the grain harvest. The base case shown (Table 2.5) assumes the stalk and ear are removed together in one truck from the field. Grain is separated at the collection center. Locating collection centers at existing grain elevators, the “grain elevator model,” makes use of existing infrastructure to store the corn. These assets are often underutilized since much of local corn is sold to nearby ethanol plants. Land may need to be acquired at some locations to accommodate the additional cellulose storage.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
30
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 2.5. One-pass harvester requirements: 200 bu/ac example. Harvest Days Stover Collected in Million dt
30
1 2
Harvesters required 28 21 17 56 42 34
40
50
To collect 1 million dry tons of stover in the example above, 30 one-pass harvesters would be required based on the following assumptions: (1) 12 ac/h average harvest rate, (2) 200 bu/ac average yield, (3) 20 hours per day operating time, and (4) two spare harvesters for back up. The number of harvesters drops as the harvest days are increased (Table 2.5). There are no spare harvesters included in the table values. To maintain the harvest rate at 14 ac/h, a 12 head combine in a 200 bu/ac field harvests 40 bu/min, filling a trailer to legal weight (20 tons) in 15 minutes. A one-pass harvester will fill the truck in 5 minutes. The number of trucks required per harvester triples, and the trucks are volume-limited (3,000 ft3 , 8 lbs/ ft3 , 12 tons as is). Depending on yield and distance, present corn harvesters operate with a minimum of 3–4 trucks/combine. Therefore, for similar distances, 10–12 trucks will be required per one-pass harvester. One-Pass Investment The list price of a 12 row, 375 horse power (hp) rotary combine is about $300,000. Assuming trucks can be contracted with no additional investment and the same harvest cost can be achieved when the additional handling is done off site, the investment in new one-pass harvest equipment is $9 million (30 × $300,000) per 1 million dry tons of stover collected. Large operators lease their combines, and if the economics work, the opportunity would warrant serious consideration. Baling Investment The equipment investment for baling in the same example as above, i.e., 1 million dry tons of stover in 30 days, is $15 million. The capital is the same for round or square bales (Table 2.6). Cost of equipment for moving the bales from the field, storing, and transporting are not included. The baling-related units required are based on the same values used for the one-pass harvest example: (1)feedstock, 1,000,000 dt/year, (2) yield, 200 bu/ac, (3) stover (1:1 ratio), 4.8 dt/ac, (4) cover left, 1.0 dt/ac, (5) stover baled, 3.8 dt/ac, and (6) area baled, 265,000 ac. The units required are shown in Table 2.7. They are based on the September 2009 University of Minnesota Extension Machinery Estimates for Net Cost of a New Unit and Work Performed, acres per hour. The stalk chopper is widely used now to help microbes attack stover residue. For baling, the stalks are chopped immediately after the harvest to accelerate drying. After the chopped material dries to less than 18% moisture, it is raked to form a windrow. The windrow reduces the number of passes the baler makes across the field, improving the baling rate. Windrows
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
Table 2.6.
31
Capital equipment investment for baling. Harvest Days
Capital Equipment
Unit Cost $(000)
Stalk chopper Rake Square baler Round baler Tractor, 60 HP w/rake Tractor, 60 HP w/rnd baler Tractor, 130 HP MFWD, chop Tractor, 130 HP MFWD, sq baler Chop, rake, square bale only Chop, rake, round bale only
20 27 75 21 26 26 106 106
Table 2.7.
30
40
50
Capital required $ (Millions) 1.1 0.8 1.7 1.3 2.1 1.5 2.3 1.7 1.5 1.1 2.9 2.1 5.0 4.5 2.9 2.2 15.3 11.4 15.4 11.6
0.7 1.0 1.2 1.4 0.9 1.7 3.6 1.7 9.1 9.3
Baling equipment requirments. Harvest Days
Harvest hours Collection rate required Equipment employed Stalk chopper Rake Square baler Round baler Tractor, 130 HP MFWD Tractor, 60 HP
20 h days ac/h Equip. rate ac/h 7.8 6.8 16.0 4.0 NA NA
30
40
50
600 439 Units required 56 64 27 110 83 174
800 329
1000 263
42 48 21 82 63 130
34 39 16 66 50 105
once wet due to rain or even a heavy dew are difficult to dry back down, so raking is scheduled just prior to baling. Tractors are multipurpose. A 60 HP tractor can rake and pull the round baler. The 130 HP Mechanical Front Wheel Drive tractor can handle all the assignments, but is only required for the stalk chopper and the square baler. Harvest Choices While baling can fit other residues and energy crops, for stover, the collection choice appears to favor one-pass harvest. Several reasons drive this conclusion. First, the grain is harvested when it is mature, usually after drying below 20% moisture. However, in a wet season, the grain is harvested when field conditions permit and dried in specially designed dryers. One-pass harvests the wet stover material with the grain. The stover is stored wet, adding water as required to be at 60% or more moisture. In contrast, baling requires material to be 18% moisture or below. Wet weather keeps residue moisture too high for baling and feedstock remains in the field. One-pass harvesters replace existing combines for corn harvest. The grain and stover are collected in one pass (with more trucks). Stalk chopping in one-pass harvested
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
32
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 2.8.
Bale staffing requirment, 1 million dry tons.
Operation
Positions
Stalk choppers Rakes Rotary balers, 30% of balers Square balers, 70% of balers Baling support crew, 15% Field operators, bales left in the field
56 64 33 20 27 200
fields is eliminated. Conventional combines continue to be used when residue is baled. The baling equipment is an additional investment and its utilization is weather dependent. Second, during the seasonal harvest, operations are planned to continue around the clock, supplementing the regular workforce with all able-bodied persons including spouses, retirees, students during nonschool times, and contract labor. There is little to no slack, as 12 or more hours per day are normal. Any additional work, including harvesting, transporting, and storing residues, will require additional people. For one-pass harvesting of 1 million dry tons of stover in 30 days, farmers must plan for four more trucks per combine, 30 harvesters, and 120 additional trucks (240 drivers, as workers would rotate through positions working 24/7) to remove the grain and stover from the field to collection centers. Replacing existing combines with one-pass harvesters is a trade-off for operators. Support crews are deployed for combines now. A similar crew would support one-pass harvest. To match existing combine harvest rates, one-pass harvesters require more trucks—one loaded every 5 minutes for ear and stalk in contrast to one every 20 minutes for grain. When baling stover, 1 million dry tons produces 2 million bales. Nearly 200 additional positions are needed to operate the equipment (Table 2.8) Since the work week is 24/7, 400 people are required to staff the baling operation not including administrative needs. Three operations are employed: chop, rake, and bale, leaving the bales in the field. Stalk chopping follows the combine to hasten the stalk drying. When the residue reaches the required moisture, a baling crew is deployed. Raking and baling are done together, collecting the windrow immediately to prevent it from getting wet. Heavy dew on a cloudy day or a local shower will add moisture and delay baling. Thus, advance scheduling is difficult. In this example, 30% are round bales and 70% square bales are produced. The net wrapping protects round bales from weather. They can be left in the field for collection until the next field operation. For no-till, this is spring. Square bales are not protected and must be removed from the field and stacked. In most areas, they must be covered to protect them from the weather. This additional movement is not included in the above operations. When wet weather curtails collection, there are limited other assignments for the baling crews, and their fixed costs continue to accumulate.
Soil Quality and Compaction When making a choice to remove stover, the impact on soil quality is a serious factor. Traffic in the field can cause excessive soil compaction, damaging the soil structure. Compacted soil inhibits root growth, increases water runoff, and reduces the flow of nutrients to nourish the plant . . . all reducing crop yields. In both harvest cases, more traffic will occur on the field.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
33
Compaction can be avoided in several ways, including wide tires that have better distributive weight, limiting traffic to tracks between rows and tilling the compacted area. Tilling is the least attractive, because of added cost and it releases soil organic matter.
2.2.6
Operating Costs
Farmers make annual crop planting and selling decisions based on their historical operating costs and yields, and the expected market for their crops that year. The average age for farmers is 62. Over the many crop seasons, they have accumulated much experience, and they know their operating costs well. Their focus is increasingly on cost of inputs, especially fertilizer, emphasizing costs per acre, not yield per acre. Farmers are generally conservative in their approach, diversifying their fields and crops to produce a profit across the board, in dry years and in wet years. Changes for existing crops are adjustments made in an evolutionary way, trying several rows, then several acres, increasing acreage after results meet expectations. When considering a new practice—no-till, drill planting, removing crop residues, and growing energy crops—many questions arise. The answers vary depending on many conditions, including the soil types, crop system needs, and the weather. Accumulating the information to arrive at a satisfactory answer requires years.
2.2.7
Residue Nutrient Value
The present market for residues—grazing, bedding, and animal feed supplement—recycles the nutrients back to the soil. With grazing, nutrients remain in the same field. Bedding and manure from feedlots can be recycled to local fields where needed. The major nutrient components in the residues are phosphorus, potassium, and nitrogen. The phosphorous and potassium content (P&K nutrients) in straw and stover is typically 0.1% and 1%, respectively. The composition varies depending on the soil and local conditions. Rain quickly washes out these soluble nutrients. If a dry season, the P and K value removed with the stover is $10 per dry ton, $8 for the K, and $2 for P. The nitrogen fertilizer value is more complex and depends on local conditions. The N content in the stover is 0.5%–2.0% depending on the length of time in the field after the plant has matured. However, there is conflicting information regarding its value. If the residue is plowed under the surface, microbes desire a 10/1 ratio of C/N for breaking down residue. Since the C/N ratio of straw and stover is 40–70/1, 20 lbs N fertilizer addition per ton of residue is recommended to avoid denitrification of the next crop. If left on the surface, there is some evidence that shows that the same N deficiency occurs, but the results are not conclusive.
2.2.8
Land for Energy Crops
Energy crops provide another source of feedstock. The quantity depends on the incentives for replacing the existing land use. The Corn Belt is an unlikely area for growing energy crops due to the profitability of current cash crops. See Chapter 4 for a discussion of energy crop production.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
34
2.2.9
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Farmer Outlook
Farmers embrace change at a conservative pace. Will farmers bother with supplying corn stover, the most abundant cellulosic feedstock available? Moreover, how can they participate in the value-added prospects? Farming, efficiently supplying commodity crops at a low cost, planting improved seeds with better traits, and employing improved crop practices with equipment that covers more acres per hour remains the primary focus. Removing the residues will be approached cautiously. When results are proven, expansion on their lands will occur. On average, farmers own 40% of the land they farm, renting the rest. Landlord approval is important to increase supply. Agricultural equipment and seasonal demands are planned around the total acres. Changing crops or crop practices on the rented lands is usually done with the consent of the landowner. Agreement on land use is in their mutual interest—keeping the equipment utilized and the rented land farmed. Downstream Value-Added Prospects: Farmer-owned dry mill ethanol plants are a shining example of how farmers can prosper from downstream “value-added” processing. In the areas surrounding these facilities, the farmers have enjoyed a stronger market for their corn since the facilities began operation. In addition, operating margins from their ethanol plants have increased due to higher gasoline prices. The farmer-investors and others in the community are benefitting from the increased dividends and higher value of their investment. The local economy has also benefitted from the jump in local expenditures to improve and expand plant operations. The corn to ethanol process was well proven when farmers began to invest in the dry mill plants. States, especially Minnesota, added incentives for farmer ownership. Similar programs may help to include the farmer in the value-added downstream prospects.
2.2.10 Crop Research and Development To supply the cellulosic feedstock market, new crop systems are needed. Energy crops and present cash crops that have a cellulosic feedstock component offer new opportunities for growth, but bringing a new crop to the market requires 5–7 years in the United States. A “disruptive” technology takes 10 years. To improve crop breeding, regional centers that conduct parallel crop development programs are needed. In addition to switchgrass, the possibility of other new feedstocks including cover crops, forage soybeans and sorghum, high fiber sugar cane, miscanthus, willows, and poplars are some that are being investigated. Improving plant traits, including enzymes in the plants to lower the processing costs, are related projects that could accelerate commercialization.
2.3 Feedstock Logistics Cellulosic feedstocks face several logistical hurdles, including low density for transportation and storage stability. Additional trucks and drivers are required to transport the bulky material, increasing the traffic at a time already prone to congestion. Collecting the annual supply of feedstock during the fall harvest to supply the facility over the next years requires secure storage conditions.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
Table 2.9.
35
Densification of dry material. Feedstock Density (dry lbs/ft3 )
2.3.1
Form
Operating Cost $/dt
Bulk Milled Baled Pellets
NA $15–$25 $25–$30 $25–$30
Corn Stover
Straw
Cobs
40
4 8 8–12 25–35
8–10
Bulk Density
Grain density is about 40 lbs/ft3 . Stover or straw bulk density is 4 lbs/ft3 , thus requiring 10 times the volume to transport and store it, unless compacted or finely milled. A trailer with the standard dimensional limits, 3,000 ft3 , holds 60 tons of grain, nearly triple the usual legal load of 20 tons of baled or ground biomass. Thus, hauling logistics will be difficult, but critical, to resolve. During harvest season, most states provide an overweight allowance for trucks since the crops must be harvested during a short time period and varying water content makes it difficult to estimate actual harvest weight. The temporary limit is based on maximum safe weights for roads, especially bridges. For example, Wisconsin permits a 15% overweight allowance between September and November. Nevertheless, biomass bulk density is too low to take advantage of the higher weight limits. Chopped corn stalks or straw is about 4 lbs/ ft3 . Without some compaction or grinding, the same trailer would contain just six (6) tons, more than tripling the transportation costs of grain. Permitting larger trailer dimensions would help, but then equipment is nonstandard, limiting the utilization after the seasonal harvest. Increasing the bulk density—incurring cost for baling, pelletizing, or compressing in other ways—can lower transport cost. The most economic trade-off depends on transportation distances, and the costs of handling, storing, and processing. Densification Processing the material removed from the field through a mill or grinder to reduce its size can increase density to 8 lbs/ft3 (Table 2.9). The same density, 8 lbs/ft3 , can be achieved with a one-pass harvest, collecting corn stalks with the ears. Baling, round or square bales, further increases density to 8–12 lbs/ ft3 . Pellets are the densest at 25–35 lbs/ft3 . However, they can be friable, i.e., easily broken apart if not processed properly or if handled in a rough manner. Pelletizing cost Transportation cost is offset by densifying the feedstock. Dry feedstock is usually baled when removed from the field after harvest. Dense square bales, pellets, and cobs readily fill trucks to capacity while remaining in legal dimension limits. Round bales are most efficiently handled by a “load and go” wagon that picks bales off the field and carries them over the road with a high-speed tractor in less than a 10-mile radius. Pelletizing occurs in series. Bales are broken and pelletized at a collection center and then transported to their final destination. Pelletizing requires significant investment and the
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
36
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
relatively high fixed pelletizing cost depends on the volume. For example, Green Circle’s pelletizing plant in Cottondale, FL, recently began production. The $65 million plant has 13 pelletizer machines scaled to produce 550,000 tons of wood pellets per year from regionally sourced yellow pine. Extending this example, pelletizing 1 million dry tons annually would require a $100 million investment (Kotrba, 2009).
2.3.2
Storage
Storage stability is mostly a function of moisture. Many methods for storing crop residues have been investigated over the years. An early patent (Lanthrop and Munroe, 1926) claimed that one of two conditions must exist during storage for good fiber properties and minimum storage losses: either the moisture content must be below 20% during storage so that the microbial activity is nearly dormant, or the material must be kept wet, above 60% moisture. Dry storage of cellulosic feedstock is seen as the most likely practice for supplying biomass in the United States today. Baling and bale handling equipment are readily available from Ag machinery suppliers. While baling adds cost, it supplies needed compaction for economic transport. Wet storage of silage is a common practice for feeding cattle. Wet storage is also used for bagasse, the fiber residue left after removing the juice from sugar cane. Dry Storage The first industrial scale application of crop residues occurred in the sugar cane industry in the last century. Bagasse exits the sugar cane refinery at 50% moisture, too damp for stable storage. Some is burned to supply process energy. The excess is used as a component in building materials like fiberboard and as a pulp mill feedstock. Production of building materials is a dry process. Producers pursued ways to economically dry the feedstock for storage. This effort resulted in using the heat from microbial fermentation to dry bales from 50% to less than 20% moisture (Munroe and Lathrop, 1933). The bales were sized and stacked to dissipate heat and acid fumes without fiber damage (Figure 2.1). Sheltered from the weather, bales are kept for several years without serious deterioration or fiber loss (Hay and Lathrop, 1941; Lathrop and Munroe, 1926). Classical bale storage is pictured in Figures 2.2 and 2.3.
Figure 2.1.
Bale stacking, about 1930.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
Figure 2.2.
Bale storage, 1930–1960.
Figure 2.3.
Bale storage, 1997 winter.
37
This original dry storage method was used for more than 40 years. However, a change to wet storage occurred in the 1960s due to increasing recognition of dry storage disadvantages, including that the bales were relatively small, weighing 250 lbs “as is,” mechanical handling was slow and costly; the bales had to be precisely stacked to vent fumes and dissipate heat; procedures were labor intensive; several months were required to dry bales from 50% to 15% moisture; and as fire loss was high, fire insurance costs were increasing. While some progress in handling has occurred, experience in baling, storing, and transporting has demonstrated that the issues above are still unresolved today. Corn stover bales harvested in 1997 for furfural feedstock are shown in Figures 2.3–2.6. The bales survived the cold weather well (Figure 2.3). However, warm weather disclosed serious decomposition of round and square bales (Figures 2.4 and 2.5). Inspection of the round bales showed they were loosely made. Evidently, that bale operator had not tightened the belt to better compact the bale. The loosely packed bale absorbed excessive water so that microbial activity was high since air was more able to diffuse into the bale. Consistent, dense bales and covered storage on well-drained pads can minimize the feedstock loss. Other hazards remain, such as fire. Once ignited, bale fires cannot be extinguished. Figure 2.6 shows the results from a fire in Harlan, IA, started when a small flame caused by a welder’s spark blew into the stacks on a windy day. The blaze destroyed much of the inventory (Figure 2.6), which burned for several weeks. The Harlan Tribune reported “by far the most notable incident during the year was the corn bale fire at Penn Chemical Company, south of Harlan, on October 7–8, 1999. Thousands of corn bales burned, keeping the department, as well as other area fire departments, on call for both days” (Harlan Tribune, 2000).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
38
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Figure 2.4.
Round bale loss.
Figure 2.5.
Square bale loss.
Figure 2.6.
Storage area after bale fire.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
39
Process water
Feedstock
Washshred(pump)
Wet storage pad
Cellulosic process
Circulation liquor Water management • Remove dirt • Recycle nutrients
Figure 2.7.
Wet storage platform.
Figure 2.8.
Wet storage mound with pumping arm.
Wet Storage Since pulping is a wet process, companies in the pulp and paper industry investigated wet storage of nonwood fibers for feedstock. The results were more successful than dry storage. Even companies with a dry process abandoned bales in favor of wet storage. Wet storage of sugar cane bagasse has been in wide use on a commercial scale since 1960 (Atchison and Hettenhaus, 2002). Unlike ensiling forage for animal feed, the biomass material is typically slurried to 3% solids and piped to a storage pad (Figure 2.7). The liquor drains through the pile and is recirculated until a height limited by the pump performance is reached—typically more than 100 feet (Figure 2.8). The Imperial Young Farmers and Ranchers Assn, Imperial, NE, validated wet storage for corn stover, as part of a USDA funded project (Hettenhaus and Mosier, 2010). A 700 dt pile was built in 2005. Samples over the next 8–16 months were pretreated, hydrolyzed with cellulase enzymes, and fermented to ethanol. The feedstock from wet storage showed improved results over dry material since inorganic solubles were dissolved in the circulating liquor when the pile was constructed (Figure 2.9).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
40
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Figure 2.9.
Corn stover wet storage; Imperial Young Farmers & Ranchers Assn, Imperial, NE.
Adapting wet storage to a crop that has “damp” feedstock like high fiber cane, silage sorghum, and corn stover fits well into a wet biorefinery process. Harvesting when the crop is mature, including the excess wet stover, can reduce the weather risk and soil compaction in addition to lowering cost.
Storage Comparison A comparison of dry bale and wet bulk storage shows there are significant advantages for the wet method in most categories (Table 2.10).
Storage Area Wet storage density is 12.5–14 dry lbs/ft3 of average pile density (Bruijn et al., 1974; Moebius, 1966). The height of a wet pile is only limited by the pump head capacity, how high is it economic to pump? Bales require ten times or more the wet storage space due to bale stacking limits, access corridors, and a measure of fire protection. The total area required for 1 million dry tons is about 500 acres for square bales. Annual rent at $300/acre would be $150,000. Square bales, 10 dry lbs/ft3 , can be stacked about 300 lbs/ft2 or 30 feet high before the weight begins to compress the lower bales, causing the stack to shift in storage and possibly fall. Round bales, stacked three high require about 140% more storage area, 170–200 dry lbs/ft2 . Using “cotton modules” to compress the feedstock, even more area is needed for a
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
Table 2.10.
41
Dry and wet storage comparison.
Parameter
Dry (Bales)
Wet Storage (Ritter Method)
Dry density, lbs/ft3 Storage areas Storage loss Foreign matter and soil nutrients Solubles removal Weather risk Fire hazard Investment Storage quantity
8–12 10× >5% High Process residue Rain High Low to high Small, mostly farm use
12–14 1× <5% Low Storage liquor Extreme cold None Medium to high Large, bagasse for pulp
single layer. Following insurance underwriting guidelines, bales are limited to 4,000 tons/pile with a minimum of 30 m distance between piles. In contrast, with wet storage, a 333,000 dt pile requires 15 acres. For 1 million dt storage, just three piles or about 50 acres is needed at $15,000 annual rent at $300/acre. Storage Loss Bales are adversely affected by wet weather and without shelter can decompose and break apart (Figures 2.2 and 2.3). In dry climates, for example, Idaho, Colorado, and Oklahoma, losses can be 5% or less. However, most of the crop residues are in the Corn Belt, which has a wet climate. In Iowa, for net-wrapped round bales at 6’ × 5’, 30% of the mass is in the outer 4 inches and 25% weight loss can easily occur in one season. Stored inside barns, both round and square bales had 14% weight loss over 10 months in Eastern Canada (Billy, 2001), although the overall composition remained nearly the same. For wet storage, the major losses are the 5%–8% solubles removed during storage. Typical cellulose and hemicellulose losses reported by the pulp and paper industry are 1%–3% (Atchison, 1971; Moebius, 1966; Salaber and Maza, 1971). Surface loss is dependent on the total surface exposed relative to the stored volumes. The higher the pile is, the lesser the surface exposure and surface loss. Foreign Matter and Solubles Bales harbor foreign material that can be deleterious during storage and processing. Wet storage has proven to remove dirt, foreign matter, and solubles over time. Removing the nutrients during storage and returning them to the fields is much preferable to processing the bales and disposing of the process ash. Less solubles in the wet, stored feedstock with the absolute values of holocellulose and pentosans, unchanged increases the facility capacity up to the distillation step: 7% removal opens up 7% more pretreatment, hydrolysis, and fermentation capacity. However, more distillation equipment is required for the increased load. The process and economic impact is significant. A nominal 100 million gallon plant increases 3 million gallons to 103 million gallons annually. NREL’s Aspen model indicates a cost decrease of $0.04/gallon or $4 million annually. The improvement assumes that half of the solubles are removed in storage and an additional 3.5% of the feedstock is processed.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
42
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Disposal of Nonvolatile Solubles Crop residues contain up to 12% solubles, including valuable soil nutrients. Soluble soil nutrients, especially P and K, are removed with the bale, depleting the soil. While there is considerable variation in the composition (Templeton et al., 2009), their average value is $3.20/dt (Glassner et al., 1998). For sustainable harvest, nutrients contained in the stover must be replaced. In dry climates, farmers often run the irrigation system before baling to wash some of the solubles into the field. Unless removed, they are processed, becoming part of the process residues. Presently, it is uncertain if the process residue must be landfilled or may be used as a soil conditioner. Either route is expensive. Annual landfill cost is $1.6 million for a 2,000 dt/day facility at a nominal $20/dt. In wet storage, most of the nonvolatile solubles are removed before processing. Excess liquor is high in nutrients and can more likely be returned to the soil, free of process ash. In either case, transportation can be a significant cost factor. More investigation is needed to determine the cost and disposition of each.
Storage Risk Weather and fire are hazards for dry storage. Bales must be protected from absorbing moisture to avoid loss. Depending on the local climate and length of storage, roofed shelters are generally preferred over wraps or tarps. Round bales may be mesh wrapped, but wrap disposal presents another cost. Fire is an additional hazard for dry material, in storage and in transit. Bale fires, once started, result in a total loss (Figure 2.4). They burn slowly with much smoke and can last for weeks. Nearby areas often are obscured and at a minimum inconvenienced. At worst, roads may be closed and neighborhoods evacuated. A hay bale fire shut down Interstate 25 near Colorado Springs, CO, for hours despite the efforts of the local fire departments, including the nearby Air Force Academy, to control the flames and smoke On the other hand, wet storage piles are not affected by the weather and at 75%–80% moisture and are not flammable.
Industry Proven Wet storage of cellulosic feedstock is industry proven. Bales are largely for on-farm use and have been used for small industrial applications, mostly for particleboard. Large applications that rely on bales have historically encountered problems including cost, quality, storage deterioration, fires, and adequate supply (Lengel, 2001). These same problems encouraged the nonwood fiber pulpers to move to wet storage more than 50 years ago with much proven and well-documented success. Although stover and straw are expected to perform in a similar manner, further validation is required.
Investment Required Investment for dry bale storage is well established. Wet storage investment remains to be investigated. Bale storage cost varies from purchasing tarps to cover stacked square bales or plastic wrap for round bales to covered buildings. An uncovered stack of net wrapped round
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
43
bales on the ground has negligible investment. Sheltered bale storage investment can be high, depending on the structure. Bale storage systems were estimated for square bales of rice straw (Huisman et al., 2005). Results showed that tarps were favored at an annual cost of $7–$10/dt for short-term storage with no investment other than tarps, which were assumed to have a three-year life. For longerterm storage, pole barns are favored at $5/dt, including the land leasing cost. Tube wrapping has costs similar to storage in buildings, but allow greater losses of biomass in longer-term storage. Tubes are not stacked and have a large land area requirement. Metal buildings give overall better protection of quality in long-term storage, but increase storage cost $1/dt–$6/dt, adding $1 million in infrastructure cost for a 100 MGPY plant. Truss arched tarps are only slightly higher cost than conventional tarping under the best conditions but offer better long-term storage options. Land rental for storage averages $300 ac/year A longer-term investment is justified by reducing yield loss of the bales otherwise exposed to the weather. Leasing buildings reduces the upfront capital and establishes a long-term relationship, typically 15 years that corresponds to the useful life of the biorefinery. At the bioprocessing facility, the bale unloading, interim storage, and handling system designed for NREL’s model has $13 million in capital cost, or $3.00/dt. The operating cost is $2.60/dt based on 12 operators 24/7 to handle the bales, adding a total of $5.60/dt to the feedstock cost (Aden et al., 2002; Harris Group, Inc., 2000). Wet storage investment cost needs to be investigated and evaluated as part of the supply chain, including the following: r r r r
Modified cropping practices compensating for the residue removal One-pass harvest equipment and logistics Transport from the field to the collection center Collection center logistics with truck unloading, separation, circulation basins, flumes, pipes, and other equipment r Disposition of the nutrient-containing liquor r Preprocessing and pretreatment r Transport to the biorefinery.
2.3.3
Regional Biomass Processing Centers
Some industrial participants in the colloquies were confident that their technology is ready for a few feedstocks, including paper mill sludge, wood chips, crop residues, and forest trimmings. Nearly a dozen commercial and semi-commercial scale projects with a mix of processes, and feedstocks are moving ahead as a result of matching government funds, grants, and loan guarantees to test conversion to renewable fuels.
Process Types Emerging cellulosic validation projects are taking three forms: first, co-locating the new technology with proven technology on an existing site, e.g., the POET-Voyager Ethanol Plant, Emmetsburg, IA; second, greenfield site, co-locating new and proven technologies, e.g., Abengoa; third, building on a greenfield site with stand-alone new technology, e.g., Iogen and Range Fuels.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
44
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
450,000 ac
Figure 2.10.
15 mir
Imperial, NE, collection centers
Expanding an existing site has the advantage of operating infrastructure to support the new technology start-up and operation. Co-locating the two technologies lowers the associated fixed costs by providing a larger operating platform. For example, 80% of production will be from a proven process, with the other 20% from new technology. Recognizing the challenge of obtaining a reliable, economic, and sustainable feedstock supply at least some companies are pursuing projects that use a modular or regional collection approach encompassing a 10–20-mile radius. Companies include Terrabon, Pure Vision Technology, AFEX, UOP and Lurgi. The cellulosic feedstock is preprocessed, being pretreated at the collection sites. Grain elevator locations could make great collection centers because of their rail access. For example, AFEX estimates the capital cost for processing 900 dry tons/day at $11 million (Carolan et al., 2007). In Figure 2.10, each circle has a 15-mile radius and contains 450,000 ac, comprising a total of 3 million acres in the area surrounding the biorefinery. The total amount of economic and sustainable feedstock supplied will vary depending on the local conditions. If 30% of the acres provide 2.3 dry tons feedstock per acre, 300,000 dt is collected and stored at the collection centers during harvest. During the year, the collection centers preprocess and pretreat about 900 dt/day. The centers supply the biorefinery via truck or pipeline for further processing. About 30 miles of pipe are required for each collection center to connect to the biorefinery. In this case, 2 million dt from the 3 million ac is processed, producing 27 MGPY ethanol (90 gal/dt).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
45
Initial Project Financing Commercial biofuels projects cannot be debt financed due to the associated risk of new technology.1 Relying on total equity financing for a $200 million plus facility is out of the question. For biofuel projects to move ahead, some equity coupled with government support in the form of government grants and government loan guarantees is required. Participants look at leveraging government support where possible. Some examples are discussed in Chapter 11 in this volume. A much larger federal and state government effort is required to meet RFS goals. Many approaches to commercial success are needed to find “the” most suitable processing paths for the different technologies, regional feedstocks, infrastructure, and logistics. Opinions about how grants and loan guarantees should be applied differs across the spectrum of participants. Farmers in the Corn Belt view their investment as short term, the next crop planting choice. Farmers with traditional farm operations do not have a lot of cash on the balance sheet. They mainly work with annual contracts. These conflict with the biomass project investment needs, as production facilities have a time horizon of 20–30 years. The need for working capital invested in cellulosic feedstock for the 10 or 11 months between harvests seems to be taken in stride by the farmer—as long as there is a market for the material. However, not having a fungible feedstock increases risk. To mitigate the lack of a fungible feedstock and assist the farmer in gaining an equity stake in a biofuels plant, the State of IL has established a program to guarantee the value of the feedstock. The farmer can borrow against this value to take an equity interest in the project. Grain elevators, mostly organized as a farmer co-op, may provide infrastructure for establishing collection centers. They have an asset base, are located in 10–15 mile centers in grain growing areas, and have rail access. Farmer ownership in the co-op allows an affordable entry in the value chain—a possibility for smaller projects in the $10 million range needed for preprocessing and pretreatment. Agricultural equipment manufacturers are mostly spectators, waiting to see how the feedstock collection and logistics needs evolve. There are many feedstock supply options, including r r r r
Crop residues and energy crops Wet and dry feedstock collection and storage Bales and bulk storage One-pass vs. multiple-pass corn harvest.
John Deere and CNH are investigating several methods for one-pass grain and cob collection. Vermeer and others have improved baling equipment, with a focus on stover. Oxbo Corp, a specialty manufacturer is applying matching funds from the USDA to develop a prototype for one-pass corn grain and stover harvesting with the adage that the collection “will not slow down the grain harvest.” Biomass brokers and contract harvesters are in the same category as Ag equipment manufacturers, watching and waiting.
Cellulosic Process Developers Facility owners look to government grants and loan guarantees to finance the design, construction, and start-up of facilities. Tax credits are less attractive in most cases, since the benefit is on the back-end, after the project is online and profitable.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
46
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Loan guarantees can be difficult to organize. Some project situations are difficult to work through successfully, especially for a partial guarantee of the total debt. The most workable government solution to funding projects is grants with matching equity. However, even with government grants, the developer carries an extra burden when dealing with new technology. Grants only fund hard assets. The development costs are usually not included in the R&D federal costs.
Sustainable Removal Erosion control and carbon sequestration models are not comprehensive enough to understand the whole story of sustainability of soil health. No processor wants to be associated with a harvesting operation without knowing the potential impact of removing the biomass, particularly corn stover. Crop residue removal was studied nearly 40 years ago after the first Arab oil embargo (Larson et al., 1972). To prevent soil erosion, some crop residue is needed on the surface. The amount required varies and depends on many factors such as degree of slope, length of slope, and management practices. These characteristics have been modeled by the USDA, are readily applied, and can be relied upon for controlling soil erosion. For soil carbon sequestration, the Century model is widely accepted. This model simulates C, N, P, and S dynamics through an annual cycle over time scales of centuries and millennia http://www.nrel.colostate.edu/projects/century5/reference/index.htm. A farmer friendly version, Comet VR, can model individual fields as a decision support tool (http://www.cometvr.colostate.edu/). The model is offered by the USDA Natural Resource Conservation Service and considers a wide range of cropping system rotations and tillage practices. It determines the effects of management and global change on productivity and sustainability of the farmer’s fields for different scenarios. The results are presented as 10-year averages of soil carbon sequestration or emissions with associated statistical uncertainty values. Estimates can be used to construct a soil carbon inventory. The results meet the requirements for voluntarily reporting GHG emissions according to Section 1605(b) of the Energy Policy Act of 1992, often referred to as the 1605(b) program. The Chicago Climate Exchange makes payments to the landowner based on the COMET VR carbon sequestration results for Agricultural land and Rangeland (CCX, 2009) These studies continue to provide a better definition of the sustainable amount that can be removed—moving past erosion and carbon sequestration just in the soil. Research needs to be extended to include emission of greenhouse gases such as nitrous oxide, methane, and carbon dioxide for various locations, crops, and management practices. For example, nitrous oxide has 320 times the impact of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Its significance must be accounted for along with alternative applications down the value chain. In addition, removal studies need to look at collecting the whole plant—both the grain and the remainder of the plant on the surface. Information for Life Cycle Analysis and Life Cycle Inventory are especially needed. The impact on greenhouse gas emissions from removing some of the residue is currently being evaluated, but the results are incomplete.
Plant Science Opportunities The time to market is measured in years. Perennial crops require 2 years to establish before harvesting and gaining cash flow. Thus, financial incentives are needed for the grower to plant these crops. The major seed companies have a focus on improving seeds for current cash crops:
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
47
corn, soybeans, and cotton, but are watching cellulosic developments. They currently offer corn seeds with enhanced ethanol yield potential. As the biofuels market develops—especially for corn stover—one expects them to screen their corn seed germplasm for phenotypes that enhance cellulosic fuel potential. The application of biotechnology to plants opens up many possibilities: increased yields of biomass per acre and per unit processed; improved composition, e.g., increased cellulose and lower lignin; and enzyme expression along with other coproducts. To realize these gains, extended time ranging from 3–10 years for research, development, and deployment is required. The tools for implementation are well proven. In a 3 year time frame, existing hybrids can be selected, which will improve field yields, and with process development support, genotypes identified, which make processing easier and lower production cost. In the midterm, enhanced processing yields could be achieved. Longer term, 7–10 years, the plant carbon can be redirected, changing the composition to favor desired products. Cellulase enzyme system expression or other coproducts could also be engineered for new products within this period. Private companies are leading this research on cash crops: corn, soybeans, and wheat. International consortia usually perform the cane research. Sugar cane is grown by vegetative reproduction, not seed, so intellectual property is difficult to control, requiring public rather than private effort. Public acceptance of engineered crops is a concern, but most believe it will dissipate, as more of the consumer benefits are demonstrated and no adverse effects come about for existing genetically modified crops. Biotech crop plantings continue to increase. In 2009, the global acreage of biotech crops continued to grow strongly, reaching 335 million acres, up from 312 million acres in 2008. From 1996 to 2009, the cumulative acres exceeded 2 billion acres (800 million hectares). It took 10 years to reach the first billion acres but only 3 years to reach the second billion acres. In 2009, an impressive 85% of the 90 million acre corn crop nationally in the USA was biotech—remarkably, 75% was hybrids with either double or triple stacked traits. Only 25% was occupied by hybrids with a single trait (ISAA, 2008).
Feedstock Business Model It is generally recognized that a successful operation requires a win-win relationship between the local farmers and the processor. Unlike corn, the biomass feedstock is bulky and transporting it long distances is not economically feasible. Local sourcing of feedstock material is needed to keep transportation costs minimal. On the basis of the colloquies participants’ comments, considerable education is required to change management practices to be consistent with stover removal and to overcome value judgments that do not match up with facts. A significant outreach effort will likely be needed to ensure collection of an adequate amount of feedstock. Some colloquy participants felt that having the farmer invest in the facility would be necessary. While desirable, others pointed out that a previous attempt to use this approach by Heartland Fibers failed. Over the 1990s, Heartland pushed the concept to farmers in MN, OH, IN, IL, and NE before closing down. No attempts to get farmers to invest in a new, yet-to-be proven venture were successful. Once the concept is proven—such as corn to ethanol—farmers are willing to invest as is shown by the proliferation of farmer-owned corn dry mill plants.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
48
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
With biomass, the local connection between farmer and processor is similar to the sugar cane model, simplifying identity preservation. NREL analysis shows significant variation in the stover feedstock composition, which in turn impacts processing cost up to 20% (Ruth and Thomas, 2003). It appears the economic effect will require payment based on composition, ease of processing and product yield. Complexity may increase, depending on the co-products. However, if the variation in composition is a result of environmental conditions, the farmer may not be able to make a living or profitably harvest the biomass, creating an unstable supply.
Storage and Inventory Ownership No processor wants to have a large inventory listed as an asset with just one annual turnover. Most corn millers operate with a 3–7 day supply of corn. The bulk of the inventory is expected to be carried by the farmer or a farmer-owned entity. On basis of conversations with local farmer organizations in IL, IA, and NE, the potential processors in the colloquies believed they could deal with a single supplier group as an intermediary between them and the individual farmers. Either a Co-op or other farmer-owned entity would serve as the “feedstock elevator,” storing the material until ordered by the processor and billing in the same way that grain elevators do now. Initially, this entity would likely be the vehicle to entice grower commitments to supply the feedstock, working closely with the processor and other local stakeholders such as the USDA NRCS and Extension staff. The assignment is a sizable task. About 250,000 acres are needed when using 3 t/ac collected feedstock, leaving 1 t/ac in the field for erosion control. If each grower offers 200 acres, 1,250 growers would be required.
Feedstock Supply The feedstock supply requires an inventory cost outlay of $20–$40 million for crop residues. Some of this cost is expected to be carried by the “grain elevator-like” biomass supplier. As most, if not all, of the harvesting, collection, and storage of the feedstock needs to be performed prior to the facility start-up, feedstock suppliers need to be convinced the project is real before investing resources into the venture.
2.4 Conclusion There are multiple sources of cellulosic feedstock, and corn stover offers the largest opportunity for crop residues. The stover surrounds existing corn to ethanol facilities. Expansion of these facilities to include cellulosic processing is a likely route for their growth. Their existing infrastructure facilitates expansion, debt financing, and permitting. The obstacles for a greenfield plant are greater, with no infrastructure, more capital to raise, and a longer permitting process. The feedstock is in the field, available for collection. More than 300 million tons were produced in the 2008–2009 crop year. Seeds in the pipeline will increase corn grain yields and stover more than 50% over the next decade. Removing the stover is better than plowing it under in many areas where stable soils limit erosion or when cover crops are included in the crop system.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
2 Agricultural Residues
49
When cellulosic conversion technology is proven, farmers will gradually adopt new cropping methods that reduce tillage and better manage residues through removal of the excess required for sustainable removal. A variety of methods that improve present baling practices will be used. Regional biomass processing centers will be established, building on existing grain elevators where practical. New infrastructure is required, reducing logistics and enabling the farmer the option to participate in the value chain.
Endnotes 1. Even with proven technology, debt financing is difficult without Wall Street-type investors. For projects with estimated costs of $250–$500 million, Regional Bankers usually limit investment to $20 million/project. 2. The costs are based on “as is” metric tons, equivalent to dry US tons with 11% moisture.
References Aden, A., Ruth, M., Isben, K., et al., 2002. Lignocellulosic biomass to ethanol process design and economics utilizing co-current dilute acid prehydolysis and enzymatic hydrolysis for corn stover. NREL Report No. TP-510-32438. 154 pp. Atchison, J. 1971. Review progress of bagasse for use in industry. In: International Society of Sugar Cane Technologist. Baton Rouge, LA: Franklin Press, pp. 1202–1217. Atchison, J. & Hettenhaus, J. 2002. Benefits of bagasses type storage of stover for supplying large biomass processing plants. Presented at Corn Utilization and Technology Conference, Kansas City, MO, USA. Billy, J. 2001. Corn stover in eastern Canada as raw material for the production of ethanol. Natural Resources Canada and Georges Le of “Ressources Naturelles Quebec”. Bruijn, J., Gonin, C., Mcmaster, L. & Morgan, R. 1974. Wet bulk storage of bagasse. Presented at International Society of Sugar Cane Technology (ISSCT) XV Congress. pp. 1793–1820. Carolan, J., Joshi, S. & Dale, B. 2007. Explorations in biofuels economics, policy and history: Technical and financial feasibility analysis of distributed bioprocessing using regional biomass pre-processing centers. Journal of Agriculture and Food Industrial Organization, 5. CCX, Offset Project Protocol, Sustainably Managed Rangeland Soil Carbon Sequestration, R Chicago Climate Exchange , Page 18, September, 2009 http://www.chicagoclimatex.com/ docs/offsets/CCX Sustainably Managed Rangeland Soil Carbon Sequestration Final.pdf. CTIC Conservation Technology Information Center National Residue Survey, 2004, http:// www.ctic.purdue.edu/CRM/crm search/ (Accessed 26 April 2010). Glassner, D., Hettenhaus, J. & Schechinger, T. 1998. Corn stover potential for ethanol production. Presented at BioEnergy ‘98 Conference. Harlan Tribune. 2000. Hay, H. & Lanthrop, E. 1941. Storage of crop fibers and preservation of their properties. TAPPI Technical Association Papers. Hettenhaus, J. 2006. Biomass commercialization and agriculture residue collection. In: Kamm, B., Gruber, P. & Kamm, M. (eds.) Biorefineris, Biobased Industrial Processes and Products. Germany: Wiley-Vch Verlag GmbH & co.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c02 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
50
20:47
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Hettenhaus, J. & Mosier, N. 2010. Validating reliable stover feedstock supply. Presented at 32nd Biotechnology Symposium for Fuels and Chemicals, Clear Water, FL. Huisman, W., Jenkins, B. & Summers, M. 2005. Storage Systems for Rice Straw in California. Davis, CA: Department of Agrotechnology and Food Science, University of California. Harris Group Inc., Process Design and Cost Estimate of Critical Equipment in the Biomass to Ethanol Process, Report No. 99-10600/13, Baled Feedstock Handling System, Revision 1W, October 11, 2000 http://www.p2pays.org/ref/22/21200.pdf (Accessed 26 April 2010) ISAAA. 2008. Executive Summary: Global Status of Commercialized Biotech/GM Crops: 2009—ISAAA Brief 41-2009. Kleinschmit, J. 2008. Minnesota Model 2.0—Innovation, diversification, and evolution in Minnesota’s farmer-owned biofuel sector. Presented at Third Annual Midwest Ag Energy Summit, Rosemont, IL. Kotrba, R. 2009. Closing the wood pellet gap. Biomass Magazine. Lathrop, E. & Munroe, T. 1926. Methods of preserving fiber for pulp-making purposes, US Patent 1572540. Larson, W., Clapp, C., Pierre, W. & Morachan, Y. 1972. Effects of increasing amounts of organic residues on continuous corn. Agronomy Journal, 64, 204–208. Lengel, E. 2001. A clarion call for common sense and reality in the composite panel industry, Eastern Canadian section. Presented at Forest Products Society Meeting. Moebius, J. 1966. The Storage and Preservation of Bagasse in Bulk Form, without Baling. United Nations, NY: Pulp and Paper Development in Africa and the Near East. Morris, D. 2008. Ethanol Program—Minnesota Model, The New Rules Project. Munroe, T. & Lathrop, E. 1933. Fiber storage and preservation. US Patent No. 1920129. Perlack, R. D., Wright, L. L., Turhollow, A. F., Graham, R. L., Stokes, B. J. & Erbach, D. C. 2005. Biomass as feedstock for a bioenergy and bioproducts industry: The technical feasibility of a billion-ton annual supply. http://handle.dtic.mil/100.2/ADA436753. Ruth, M. F. & Thomas, S. R. 2003. The effect of corn stover composition on ethanol process economics. Presented at The 25th Symposium on Biotechnology for Fuels and Chemicals, Breckenridge, CO; http://www1.eere.energy.gov/biomass/pdfs/34040.pdf (Accessed 26April2010). Salaber, J. & Maza F. 1971. Ritter biological treatment process for bagasse bulk storage. TAPPI Non-wood Plant Fiber Pulping Progress Report, October ed. Simmons, B. A., Loqu´e, D. & Ralph, J. 2010. Advances in modifying lignin for enhanced biofuel production. Current Opinion in Plant Biology, 13 (3), 312–319. Templeton, D., Sluiter, A., Hayward, T., Hames, B. & Thomas, S. 2009. Assessing corn stover compostion and sources of variability via NIRS. Cellulose, 16 (4), 621–639.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Chapter 3
Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials Randall Rousseau, Janet Hawkes, Shijie Liu, and Tom Amidon
3.1 Introduction A key question that must be asked as a nation is whether we can integrate our natural renewable resources in a manner that will not only be sustainable but meet the future increases in energy, transportation fuels, and food systems. Optimistically, the answer is a resounding “Yes,” but this response is one probably from the heart and not based on scientifically verifiable data. A reserved “yes” is probably more realistic, as we are facing a technological challenge that is truly a paradigm shift, moving from a predominately fossil fuel-driven economic system to one with a substantial renewable energy and fuel component. The original forest of the United States covered approximately 1 billion acres, but today approximately 740 million acres remain. The reduction of nearly 300 million acres has been fairly stable for 100 years, but growing population centers in the Southeast has begun to substantially impact forested acres. Recent predictions estimate that an additional 12 million acres will be lost in the southern United States by 2020 (Treasure et al., 2008). Forests have played a key role in the development of the United States from lumber production for towns to the production of a variety of items including chemicals, pulp and paper, and specialty products. The National Forest System has also played a critical role in the development of the United States. National Forests were initially designated in 1891 and today total approximately 193 million acres. Originally, these forests were focused primarily on timber management and timber harvests but in a fashion that was multidimensional with wood, recreation, wildlife, and water. Today, national forests are more focused on the management of non-timber values such as ecosystem services, including recreation and wildlife. State forests have also followed the trend set by the National Forest System focusing less on timber management and more on management of recreation values. More recent changes in the forest products industry have
Plant Biomass Conversion, First Edition. Edited by Elizabeth E. Hood, Peter Nelson and Randall Powell. C 2011 John Wiley & Sons Inc.
51
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
52
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
resulted in many companies selling their timberlands to either TIMOs (Timber Investment Management Organizations) or REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts), and LLCs (Limited Liability Corporations). While intensive forest products management is viewed as a key component of revenue for these types of organizations, the long-term objectives vary by company. Landowner values have changed as well with forest management for timber revenue no longer being the sole priority. In addition, the increasing urban forestry interface has begun to greatly impact management techniques, especially on the East Coast. Forest fragmentation, urban expansion, the demand for increased recreation, public demand for ecosystem management, land user values, litigation, endangered species, loss of wetlands, pesticides, and air pollution are just some of the issues influencing the current debate over appropriate management of America’s forest resources. The shift in the National Forest system, traditional timber companies, landowner values, as well as public perception seems to point to the need for dedicated biomass plantations to feed the increasing bioenergy and biofuels industry in the United States and especially in the Southeast. The use of biomass for bioenergy and biofuels will play a critical role in the United States’ efforts to become energy independent. The US Department of Energy (DOE) indicated that biomass is the key component for the southeastern United States in building a renewable energy base. The agency noted the excellent growing conditions of the southeastern United States for biomass production of both annual crops as well as forest tree species. The billion ton report cited forest resources biomass such as logging residue, removal of excess biomass from forestlands, primary and secondary wood processing mill residues, pulping liquors, and urban wood residues. Although short-rotation woody crops were mentioned in the report, they were placed under the agriculture resource section. This was probably the result of the rotation length (i.e., time from planting until harvest) of these dedicated plantations, which is expected to range from 1 to 3 years. As the United States looks to move from a fossil fuel economy to that of a renewable economy, the use of woody biomass for energy and liquid fuel production will play a key role. While the use of woody biomass for energy and fuel has been discussed for a number of years, only moderate gains have been made. It is critically important that research and development in the field of biomass utilization be substantially increased as to ensure the use of this type of feedstock. This is particularly true for the southeastern United States where biomass is extremely abundant, due to the region’s expansive forests. Biomass can be defined as plant materials, such as wood or annual crops, that can be used in the production of either energy or fuel. Biomass is a renewable resource that can be considered fairly close to being carbon neutral. This near neutrality is particularly important as pending national legislation is focused on reduction of CO2 emissions. Carbon neutrality is achieved with the growth of biomass when absorption of CO2 during growth processes is equivalent to the amount of CO2 released as energy is produced by the plants. However, when fossil fuels are consumed in the establishment, management, and harvest of biomass, it often prevents biomass production systems from being completely carbon neutral. The Energy Information Administration (EIA) identified biomass, geothermal, wind, solar, and hydropower energy as renewable energy sources. Within the definition of biomass energy sources, the EIA specifically included wood and wood waste. A memorandum of understanding among the US Department of Agriculture, the US Department of the Interior, and the DOE defined woody biomass as trees and woody plants, including limbs, tops, needles, leaves, and other woody parts, grown in a forest, woodland, or rangeland environment that are the byproducts of restoration and hazardous fuel-reduction treatments. In addition, they also defined woody biomass utilization as the harvest, sale, offer, trade, and/or utilization of woody biomass
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
53
to produce the full range of wood products, including timber, engineered lumber, paper and pulp, furniture and value-added commodities, and bioenergy and/or bio-based products such as ethanol and diesel. The use of wood as a source of energy is not new and has long been practiced within the pulp and paper industry where bark, unusable chips, and black liquor have been the feedstock for energy production, thus reducing the cost of operation. However, it is mandatory that the forests be harvested in a sustainable manner. As related to forest dynamics, sustainability includes environmentally sound management and harvesting techniques that ensure that the benefits derived from today’s forests are not compromised, thus allowing the opportunities for future generations to benefit in a similar fashion. It is apparent that woody biomass will become an increasingly important renewable source for bioenergy and biofuel production. The sources of woody biomass will include dedicated plantations, logging residues, thinnings from traditional plantations, and salvaged material from disasters. Some of the benefits of woody biomass include: r Less capital-intensive conversion technologies employed for exploiting the energy potenr r r r
tial Attractive opportunity for local and regional energy self-sufficiency Viable alternative to fossil fuel use Reduction in greenhouse gas emissions Provide opportunities to local farmers, entrepreneurs, and rural populations in making use of its sustainable development potential.
Sometimes, advocates of cellulosic technologies (also termed second-generation fuels referring to the conversion of cellulose and hemicellulose into simple sugars that then can be fermented by yeasts to produce ethanol) can become over enthused with their vision of a burgeoning industry. In their fervor, they underestimate the complexity of even the most basic processes that will be required to build the industry. That includes the collecting, transporting, and storing of feedstocks. Producing billions of gallons of ethanol will require millions of tons of cellulosic feedstocks. Moving that feedstock efficiently, safely, and with as little impact on infrastructure and the environment as possible will be a major challenge in the years ahead (Kram, 2008). Research suggests development and deployment of woody biomass resources have distinct energy, economic, and environmental advantages over traditional agricultural crop sources. These advantages are: r Year-round availability and numerous sources of material r Positive net energy ratio r Physical–chemical characteristics of hardwoods consistent even when supplied from
multiple sources
r Effective technical and engineering competencies to manage woody biomass have been
developed
r Sustainably harvested forest biomass can nationally provide at least 368 million dry tons
of wood per year. The value for production and processing requirements for woody biomass has yet to be firmly established, thus alternative pricing has been used to provide a range of possible financial trajectories (Bateman and Lovett, 2000; Bowyer et al., 2001).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
54
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
3.2 Natural Regeneration Although the discussion to this point has centered on plantation establishment and production, it is imperative that natural regeneration of hardwoods and pines be introduced as it could be a major component of bioenergy fiber. Today, most hardwood stands have originated from natural regeneration of idle land, or following harvest of pine and hardwood sites. In 1999, it was reported that upland and bottomland hardwoods accounted for approximately 105 million acres in the southern United States (Wear and Greis, 2002). The growing costs of plantation pine are at times 6–9 times lower than plantation hardwoods. In addition, there are also a wider array of markets for pine pulp, chip and saw, and sawtimber over a shorter timeframe. Because of this, hardwoods are typically naturally regenerated. Although naturally regenerated stands are not focused on rapid growth, they will produce a considerable amount of biomass that could be used by the bioenergy market. Under natural regeneration management, techniques such as removal of the understory and mid-story are done by either mechanical or chemical means to either improve the stand or set the stage for regeneration of the desired species. During the regeneration process, removal of the overstory is delayed until there are enough young seedlings of the desired species on a per acre basis. With the removal of the overstory, full sunlight is able to reach the forest floor, allowing numerous intolerant tree species (i.e., those species that cannot grow under shade) to populate the early stages of growth. Although these intolerant species exhibit rapid growth and dominate the stand during the early stage, they are usually not the desired species of the mature stand. It is during this early stage that thinning would be extremely advantageous to those higher-valued species. Removing unwanted intolerant species would provide reduced competition to the higher-valued species and better mid-stage growth. In the past, removal of this material was problematic, as it was generally too small for pulpwood, thus becoming an additional cost to the landowner. In most cases, landowners chose to do nothing and allowed the stand to develop naturally, with the shorter-lived intolerant species eventually dying out of the stand. If smaller woody hardwood biomass proves to be feasible for the bioenergy market, this type of previously overlooked material may become a viable source of biomass. However, the landowner and logger should be reasonably compensated in order to extract this type of woody biomass across the South. Although natural regenerated hardwoods have been the focal point of this brief discussion, it should not be forgotten that there are significant acreage in naturally regenerated pine. As stated previously, pine plantation acreage in the South comprised some 32 million acres while hardwood plantations were estimated at best to be 200,000 acres. In 1950, natural pine stands in the southern United States accounted for nearly 72 million acres, but by 1999, this acreage fell to approximately 30 million acres (Wear and Greis, 2002). However, much of the decline in natural pine and hardwood stands was due to diversions to agriculture and urban land uses. Densely stocked stands of naturally regenerated could also provide a substantial amount of woody biomass.
3.3 Overall Growing Systems It has become apparent that logging residues alone will not be enough to meet the future needs of the bioenergy and biofuels industry of the southern United States. Forest plantations dedicated not only to production, but to the maximization of biomass will play a major role in meeting the future needs for woody biomass. Forest pine plantations have been sustainably grown in the southern United States for nearly 90 years, with the first large-scale plantation
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
55
being established between 1920 and 1925 on the lower Gulf Coastal Plain. The Civilian Conservation Corps planted over 1.5 million acres in the 1930s (http://www.forestencyclopedia.net). To date, forest pine plantation acreage has grown to an estimated 32 million acres in the Southeast. Unfortunately, hardwood plantations have not matched that of pine plantation acreage, with short-rotation hardwood plantations being estimated to be approximately 200,000 acres. However, since that time, significant hardwood plantations have been established under the Federal Conservation Programs, such as the Conservation Reserve Program (CRP) and the Wetlands Reserve Program (WRP), in the Lower Mississippi Alluvial Valley (LMAV). In 2007, Rousseau estimated that in a four state area (i.e., Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Missouri) of the LMAV, there were approximately 711,000 acres in WRP hardwood plantations. However, WRP acreage is somewhat misleading in that only early age thinning would provide material for the biomass market. The total acreage of hardwood plantations solely designed for production is extremely small. The reasons for the lack of hardwood plantations includes the lack of a single species adapted to a wide variety of sites, difficulty in correctly matching the species and the site, lack of markets for intermediate size material, and the perception that cheap and plentiful hardwood fiber was virtually inexhaustible.
3.3.1
The Beginnings of Biomass Plantation Production
While wood has been used as a source of energy for as long as mankind has existed, the use of fossil fuels, such as coal and oil, as a source of energy and fuel began to steeply increase in the United States during the 1920s. Fifty years later following the Arab oil embargo, the United States began to look at alternative energy sources. The US DOE Short Rotation Woody Crops Program, now named the Bioenergy Feedstock Development Program, funded a number of projects focused on understanding and optimizing the growth of a variety of tree species under intensive plantation culture. Later, DOE settled on poplars (Populus ssp.) and willows (Salix ssp.) as their model tree species. At the same time, the pulp and paper industry in the southern United States was also examining similar systems and species as a means of providing a captured fast-growth dedicated source of hardwood fiber for their mills. The primary species being examined in the South were eastern cottonwood (Populus deltoides Bartr.), American sycamore (Platanus occiendtalis L.), and sweetgum (Liquidambar styraciflua L.). These efforts were also combined with that of the USDA Forest Service Southern Hardwood Laboratory, the North Carolina State University Hardwood Research Cooperative, and the Western Gulf Tree Improvement Program. From these efforts, new genetic planting stock was developed and silvicultural techniques refined. With the exception of eastern cottonwood, the rotation length (i.e., time of planting to time of harvest) in most cases exceeded what would be considered today as a suitable timeframe for a bioenergy crop. Certain companies, such as Westvaco and Crown Vantage, continued their research and development efforts of this concept as it proved beneficial to their respective mills (Figure 3.1). While this material was never considered for bioenergy, it did allow the development of systems that are applicable to today’s biomass production systems. If we were constructing the optimal tree for establishment and growth as a biomass crop, the traits desired would include (1) the ease of vegetative propagation so that genetically superior selections of any age could be easily cloned and quickly placed into a large-scale plantings, (2) rapid juvenile growth rates that reached expected harvest in 2–3 years, (3) ease of coppice, thus eliminating replanting costs for numerous rotations, (4) adaptability across a wide variety of sites, and (5) the ability to spray chemicals directly over the top of the trees to control herbaceous and vine competition. This list of traits is by no means all-inclusive, but it does represent those traits that would allow accelerated development of genetic material and substantially lower
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
56
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Figure 3.1. Excellent survival and growth of a 4-year-old eastern cottonwood plantation on a Mississippi River alluvial site in Carlisle Co., KY, established by Westvaco Central Region.
growing costs. Unfortunately, there is no single tree species that encompasses this entire list of traits. The goal is to use those species that possess some of the desired traits and then incorporate a variety of new technologies that would increase yields while lowering costs. In addition, financial modeling will be necessary across the various species so as to determine optimal numbers of trees per acre (TPA), rotation length, and harvesting systems (Gonzalez et al., 2009).
3.3.2
Short Rotation Woody Crops
Short-rotation woody crops (SRWC) were defined in the early 1970s as a means of rapidly producing biomass for both fuel and fiber (Brown, 1976; Steinbeck et al., 1972). It was the objective of the US DOE to find a way to not only improve on yields of biomass feedstock but to also develop the technology of converting the biomass to liquid transportation fuel (Ranney et al., 1987). While development of SRWCs was rapidly building and landowners were investing in this system, there were very few end users other than the wood products industry. From these early investigations, it was learned that this type of biomass supply system involved a number of components, including site selection, site preparation, improved clonal genetic stock, extensive competition control, fertilization, pest control, and efficient harvesting systems that were essential in achieving potential yields (Tuskan, 1998). Yield improvement expressed as either green or dry tons per acre per year was the primary driving force behind short-rotation woody crop systems. Species such as eastern cottonwood, American sycamore, green ash (Fraxinus pennslyvanica Marsh.), sweetgum, willows, and hybrid poplars were among those species investigated across the United States. In the South, eastern cottonwood, American sycamore, green ash, and sweetgum were the prime species investigated. A variety of non-native species such as eucalyptus (Eucalyptus spp.) and European black alder (Alnus glutinosa L. Gaertn) were also investigated by a number of agencies and companies. Black alder did not work well in the South because most sources were not well adapted to the southern climate (http://www.ncsu.edu/project/hardwood/research).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
57
Productivity results of eucalyptus were rather dismal except when specific species were planted in Florida. Rockwood et al. (2008) indicated that SRWC systems of eucalyptus may be implemented not only in Florida but other southern states. On suitable sites and/or with intensive culture, fast-growing hardwoods such as E. grandis may reach harvestable size in only a few years. Eucalyptus grandis is now grown commercially in southern Florida and can also be grown in central Florida. ArborGen, LLC has been testing and pursuing the possibility of commercializing a genetically engineered cold-tolerant hybrid eucalyptus for use in milder climatic conditions of the lower Gulf Coastal Plain and the Atlantic Coastal Plain. Species/Site Selection In order to obtain optimal growth of the native hardwood species, they must be established on those sites that possess characteristics conducive to each respective species. Site characteristics such as unrestricted soils, good moisture availability, and inherent fertility are paramount to obtaining optimal growth of fast-growth hardwoods. In other words, these species need considerable fertility, year-round moisture availability, and unrestricted root growth to obtain their rapid growth potential and maintain greatest possible growth to harvest. When planted off-site, these species may perform well for a short period of time (i.e., one to five years), but growth typically stagnates. Extensive mortality may follow stagnation. At times, these stressed trees succumb to a variety of either insects or diseases. Since fast-growth species are highly intolerant, effective site preparation and early competition control is an integral component of SRWC culture. Unfortunately, there are very few effective herbicides that can be used with fast-growth hardwood species. Thus, it is necessary to prepare the site to near agricultural row-crop standards followed by sub-soiling for the exact spacing desired, which allows the use of mechanized equipment to control herbaceous, vine, and undesired woody competition. Without early competition control, these fast-growth hardwoods will become stressed and never express their full growth potential. Genetic Improvement The use of genetically improved planting stock has been shown to provide greater survival, increased growth, and disease resistance. In total, these improvements have resulted in increased yields and shorter rotations. Because an autonomous tree improvement program dictates considerable labor and cost, most institutions settled for programs that were built around cooperatives such as the North Carolina State University Hardwood Cooperative and the Western Gulf Tree Improvement Program. Individually, most agencies participated in pooled testing of open-pollinated selections and formation of first-generation seed orchards. Those companies that owned suitable land for eastern cottonwood primarily conducted clonal refinement to obtain greater genetic yields. Eastern cottonwood was the only native short-rotation species operationally planted as clonal material. Eastern cottonwood planting stock is usually deployed as dormant unrooted cuttings, but can also be deployed as dormant or in-leaf rooted cuttings. Other species, such as American sycamore and sweetgum, have been clonally propagated, but this technique has not been adopted operationally. Thus, most programs rely on genetically improved open-pollinated seedlings for these two species. Competition Control When hardwood plantation establishment spacing is reduced, mechanical control of herbaceous weeds and vines becomes increasingly difficult and costly due to the lack of effective
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
58
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
chemicals. Disking has been shown to be an effective technique for obtaining post-planting competition control (Fisher, 2002). Increased survival and growth of planted hardwood species in response to disking has been documented and is considered necessary when managing some hardwood species. Eastern cottonwood and American sycamore typically require two-way cultivation through the first and second growing seasons (Kennedy Jr and Henderson, 1976; Stanturf et al., 2001). Chemical weed control is a more desirable alternative to efficiently manage competition, but few chemicals are specifically labeled for hardwood forest plantations. Because of hardwood susceptibility to some herbicides, most chemical control research has been performed out of necessity and under specific situations. Diseases Disease problems have limited the use of hybrid polar in short-rotation plantations throughout the Southeast. A wide variety of hybrid poplar taxons demonstrated susceptibility to Septoria leaf spot and stem canker (Septoria musiva Peck.) on sites in Kentucky (Rousseau et al., 2008). This particular disease, while present in the LMAV, causes little problem to native eastern cottonwood. However, there are areas within the Southeast where the disease does not currently exist. In these areas, hybrid poplars have survived and grown well. The reason for the lack of Septoria occurrence in these areas is not understood, but this may break down fairly quickly if large acreages are dedicated to hybrid poplar plantings. While Septoria leaf spot results in loss of photosynthetic area and reduction of growth, Septoria stem cankers typically result in mortality. Although eastern cottonwood has been used in various crosses to produce hybrid poplars, the resulting hybrids for the most part have shown susceptibility to Septoria stem canker (Rousseau et al. 2008). One particular hybrid poplar clone, NM-6 (which is a cross between Populus nigra L. and P. maximowiczii A. Henry), is known for its resistance to Septoria stem canker in the Midwest. Clone NM-6 showed early susceptibility to Septoria leaf spot but no stem cankers were visible through age 5. However, Septoria stem canker was present at age 10 and trees harvested at this age showed very little sound wood. The rapid growth rate, thin bark, moderate wood density level, and wider site adaptability makes American sycamore a prime candidate for biomass production in short-rotation plantations. Yet as American sycamore plantings increased, significant disease problems arose and nearly eliminated this species as a plantation species. Disease problems were initially thought to be the result of off-site planting. However, in the 1970s and 1980s, reports of mortality and dieback as a result of diseases began to be reported in sycamore plantations throughout the southeastern United States. Many of these plantations were located on optimal sites with adaptive seed source material. Several diseases, including bacterial leaf scorch of sycamore, caused by the bacterium Xylella fastidiosa, canker stain fungus Ceratocystis fimbriata f. sp. platani (Ellis and Halst.), Botryosphaeria canker (Botryosphaeria rhodina (Cooke) Arx) were noted in hardwood plantations at ages as young as 3 years. It was also noted that Xylella fastidiosa infections cause leaf scorching, branch dieback, and eventually can kill trees (Leininger et al., 1999). Clonal propagation of resistant trees would provide the ability to build a resistant population of American sycamore for the Southeast, but little work has been completed on vegetative propagation. In each case, disease problems can be overcome but would entail concerted efforts in the fields of genetics, physiology, and pathology. Hybrid poplar clones for the southeastern United States are also somewhat limited as all of the clones were developed for other geographic areas. While new hybrid poplar clones could be developed for the South this would entail extensive testing for site adaptability, growth, and disease resistance.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
59
Insect Control Coyle and Coleman (2005) stated that often fast-growth hardwood species by their nature are nutrient-rich and may provide insects with more optimal diets. They noted that in particular Populus and Salix species are more suited for and susceptible to various pests from establishment to age 3. The reasons that short-rotation tree plantations are susceptible to insects are low biodiversity and spatial uniformity. Coyle and Coleman (2005) also provided a number of guidelines that should be considered. First, pest-resistant stock should be planted whenever possible. Second, monocultures should be avoided by planting polycultures or mixed species plantings, thereby minimizing the evolutionary capacity of the pests to overcome the plant’s defense mechanisms. Third, it is advisable to create a mosaic of small plantations. These small plantations support smaller populations of insects and allow a higher probability of being preyed upon by natural enemies. Among the species considered for the Southeast, eastern cottonwood is the most susceptible to pests. Sweetgum is the most widely adapted of the three species being compared (eastern cottonwood, sycamore, and sweetgum) and seems to be the best in terms of disease and insect resistance. The growth of sweetgum is certainly not comparable to that of the other two species when planted on a highly fertile site, but it will outperform the others on a number of sites.
3.3.3
Other Types of Hardwood Plantations
Johnson et al. (2007b) used the term woody perennial energy crops (WPEC) to describe fast-growing trees under intensive management. This term (WPEC) was used interchangeably with other terms such as short rotation woody crops (SRWC) and bioenergy tree plantations (BEP). In each case, the rapid growth rates achieved by these intensely grown, rapid growthrate trees will allow harvesting in a matter of years (i.e., between 2 and 8 years) rather than decades, considered as the norm for traditional tree plantations. This shortened timeframe falls between agricultural systems and traditional plantation forestry, and because of this, there have been some negative comments from both the agricultural sector and environmental groups. Some in the agricultural sector look at these systems as a threat to the current agricultural footprint, but these plantations have always been designed to be grown primarily on marginal agricultural land. The recent debate between energy and food was brought to the forefront when corn production dedicated to ethanol was greatly increased. Even if second-generation lignocellulosic fuels become the standard, the debate will still continue if these dedicated plantations are established on agricultural land. Some environmentalists argue that if wood is adopted as a viable bioenergy source, the results would significantly increase harvest of natural stands, thus leading to declining biodiversity. This argument is totally unfounded as dedicated bioenergy plantations, although less biologically diverse than natural stands, will be much more economically feasible in procuring the woody biomass needed for the bioenergy and biofuels market than natural stands. In this situation, there would be much less pressure on natural forests, allowing young native stands to mature. The maturation of these native stands would provide a wider base of ecosystem services, more traditional products, and increased biodiversity. It is possible to classify the various types of forest plantations by type, species, and size. Johnson et al. 2007a classified WPEC into three categories: (1) large-stature widely spaced hardwoods, (2) low-stature coppice culture, and (3) intensively managed pine. The classification of large-stature widely spaced hardwoods is difficult to consider as a bioenergy crop primarily due to the high cost of site preparation and establishment and the current low
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
60
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
returns for biomass. The reality is that such a system is not much different than intensive pine culture with the exception of much higher growing costs. Low-stature coppice culture is again a hardwood plantation system that has been used successfully in shrub willows in the northeastern United States. Intensive pine plantation management has been successfully used in the Southeast for over 80 years. Improvements in genetics, planting stock quality, and silvicultural techniques resulted in faster growth rates and higher survival. Thinnings must be accomplished at an earlier age and the tree size is usually at best only pulpwood size. It is this material or even smaller that could be used for bioenergy or biofuels. The three most probable native hardwood species for dedicated bioenergy plantations include eastern cottonwood, American sycamore, and sweetgum. The reasons for this are shown in Table 3.1. Table 3.1. Probable hardwood bioenergy species and the associated advantages and disadvantages of each species. Species
Advantages
Negatives
Eastern cottonwood
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Ease of vegetative propagation Coppices well Rapid growth Extensively studied Improved clonal material available Populus genome completed
1. Lack of chemicals for weed control 2. Narrow adaptability 3. Pest susceptibility
American Sycamore
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Rapid growth Coppices well Vegetative propagation Thin bark Medium wood density
1. Susceptible to disease complex 2. Lack of chemicals for weed control
Sweetgum
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Coppice well Can be cloned Advanced genetics Broad adaptability Medium wood density Few diseases
1. Medium growth rates
Populus is the one genus of tree species that continues to intrigue most people in the field of bioenergy. Rapid growth rates and ease of vegetative propagation are the characteristics that continue to draw attention. While DOE recognizes the importance of poplars, this recognition has not been limited to the United States, as Populus programs are found throughout the world, though primarily in the northern hemisphere. A great majority of these programs are based on hybridization where F1 individuals are generated through interspecific crosses among the more than 29 species within the genus Populus (Stettler et al., 1996). In the southern United States, very little hybrid poplar is grown due to its susceptibility to the disease Septoria musiva. Many hybrid poplars are susceptible to this disease resulting in mortality. However, there are places in the southern United States where this disease does not occur and hybrid poplars could thus thrive in these areas. Eastern cottonwood gained popularity in the South, especially in the LMAV during the 1960s and 1970s as result of the work accomplished by the USDA Forest Service Southern Hardwoods Laboratory at Stoneville, MS (Schmidtling et al., 2004). Numerous companies installed cottonwood plantations using genetically superior cottonwood clonal stock. These
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
61
plantations, while in most cases designed specifically for pulpwood production, unknowingly laid the groundwork for current bioenergy plantations. From these beginnings, our understanding of cottonwood grown under plantation culture grew as work in silviculture, physiology, pathology, entomology, and biometrics increased. Eastern cottonwood plantations in the South are typically regenerated by dormant un-rooted cuttings. These cuttings are grown in stool beds or cutting orchards planted at a spacing of 1 × 3 feet. This type of system is closely related to bioenergy plantations. Control of herbaceous competition is the major problem with this system during the first year. Yet, if competition is adequately controlled, the cuttings will attain heights between 8 and 19 feet in the first year. Competition control in subsequent years is rather limited and as the stump sprouts are growing so rapidly, they quickly outgrow and shade out the herbaceous competition. Although most eastern cottonwood plantations were established at a spacing of 12 × 12 feet, coppice regeneration was used whenever possible. However, even though coppice regeneration works well for widely spaced cottonwood plantations, only limited acreage was coppiced because harvesting usually occurred during the summer months. Typically, height growth of cottonwood is approximately 10 feet per year, and its diameter growth is over an inch per year. This type of growth will only be obtained by selection of a fertile site, thorough competition control, and excellent genetics. Cottonwood in a bioenergy system will more than likely comprise 800 plus TPA, with rotation lengths between 1 and 5 years. There is no doubt that coppice regeneration will have to play a key role in this system as to provide lower establishment and growing costs. However, there will always be a need to re-establish plantations because coppice regeneration can only be done a finite number of times. It is also hoped that new clones will replace older clones as plantations must be re-established. Hardwood species such as American sycamore, sweetgum, red maple (Acer rubrum L.), silver maple (Acer saccharinum L.), and black locust (Robinia pseudoacacia L.) have in general been deployed in plantations as either bare-root or containerized planting stock. The use of seedlings is somewhat problematic if seedlings are necessary for replanting at the end of every rotation. With the exception of eastern cottonwood and to a lesser extent sweetgum, the genetic programs of hardwoods are rather limited. Thus, to extract genetic gains from these species, newly designed traditional improvement programs must be initiated. The one positive aspect is that these species all coppice rather easily, and as long as suitable genetic material is established initially, a number of rotations may be completed before entire replanting is necessary.
3.3.4
Southern Pine
Forest plantations in the southern United States are, in general, planted to a single tree species and can vary from hardwoods to conifers. However, the typical forest plantation in the southern United States is planted to loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) at a rate of approximately 400–700 seedlings per acre. To date, there are approximately 32 million acres of plantation pine located in the southern United States. Some of this acreage is greatly overstocked and early removal of trees through chopping or mowing has been practiced to lower the number of stems per acre to allow for better growth. In a few cases, this material has been harvested and used in generation of electricity through simple burning. It has also been demonstrated that young 10-year-old loblolly pine could be used in the production of various bio-oils (Hassan et al., 2009; Mitchell, 1998). Typically, pine plantations are grown from 25 to 30 years depending on site conditions, and thinned once or twice to remove pulpwood or trees that will not yield high-quality sawtimber (Gonzalez et al., 2009). Loblolly pine has proven to be widely
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
62
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
adapted across the southern United States, easily outperforming hardwoods on marginal upland sites. Added to this is the wealth of knowledge in pine plantation systems including nutrient needs, competition control, and genetics, easily defining loblolly pine as a prime candidate for biomass production in the Southeast (McKeand et al., 2006; Schmidtling et al., 2004). While the plantation concept has been a great success for pine and can provide material for bioenergy and biofuels, a change is needed to further the progress toward dedicated bioenergy plantations. Today, there is a definite interest in characterizing the growth and production of pine genotypes to understand if it is possible to select for more intensive use in biomass systems. ArborGen has developed a hybrid type of system that they have labeled as FlexStandsTM . In this system, they have combined forest biomass production with that of a higher revenue stream resulting from sawtimber. The keys to this system are that it takes advantage of the fact that loblolly pine is widely adapted across the entire southeastern United States, the well defined and less costly silvicultural techniques, and the sophisticated genetic program. MeadWestvaco and ArborGen’s development of mass-control pollinated (MCP) and varietal genetic material are the sawtimber focus of this system. The FlexStand approach employs 535 seedlings per acre with MCP seedlings or varietal stock (i.e., clonal seedlings) planted in every other row, while less expensive open-pollinated seedlings or designated biomass trees are placed in the alternate rows. The major difference is in the within-row spacing, where the biomass trees are planted every 3–5 feet. The sawtimber designated trees are planted at a within-row spacing of 10 feet. Depending on inherent site quality, the biomass trees will be harvested when they near the carrying capacity of the site. While this approach employs forest species as both the biomass component as well as the traditional sawtimber component, it lacks the ability to provide a continual biomass component throughout the rotation. At Mississippi State University, a true hybrid system combining loblolly pine and switchgrass is the primary focus of what has been termed “Co-Culture” (See section on Agroforestry).
3.4 New Genetic Tools Increases gained from clonal forestry have been shown to be dramatic in the US Pacific Northwest, with hybrid poplars demonstrating gains of greater than 100% over the average seedling (Stettler et al., 1988). The ability to incorporate molecular genetics techniques will provide a better understanding of the processes of wood formation, diseases, drought resistance, and growth. With this knowledge, breeding and selection can be tailored toward specific techniques that would make the biomass product more efficient and productive in yields of energy and fuels. Genetic engineering or genetic transformation has been accomplished in forestry and has demonstrated great potential. This potential would be even greater for hardwoods where chemicals used for site preparation and establishment are very limited and at times ineffective (Schmidtling et al., 2004). Herbicide resistance in hardwoods would solve the primary obstacle that stands in the way of increasing the acreage of hardwood plantations and subsequently bioenergy plantations. However, while the use of genetically engineered trees holds great promise, it is unlikely that trees of this type will be commercially deployed on a large scale in the United States until effective evaluation of their impact has been conducted. A number of organizations have taken the initiative to assist in development of purposegrown forest bioenergy plantations. This is to support the dozens of new and existing users of woody biomass for renewable energy. ArborGen, LLC is developing forest tree species for traditional uses such as pulp, paper, and lumber. They are also actively engaged in developing
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
63
forest tree species for bioenergy as well as developing appropriate silviculture to support these bioenergy forest plantations. Several genera including pine, sweetgum, poplars, and eucalyptus are important in ArborGen’s southern United States efforts. The traditional tree improvement programs have led to increased yields, and when combined with appropriate silviculture of higher number of TPA and shorter rotations, large benefits for growers and energy processors will be attained. The use of biotechnology to enhance forest plantation yields and energy value of the wood will ultimately provide a cost-effective bioenergy forest plantation system. Estimated improvements from biotechnology could lead to an increase of 40%–100% in BTUs/acre/year production over current systems. Biotechnology improvements will be achieved by utilizing selected varietal genotypes from traditional improvement programs, insertion of genes, field testing to verify gene effects, regulatory compliance, and eventual commercial sales. The use of biotechnology is especially important for traits that would take considerable time using conventional genetic improvement programs. A major step in the development of genetic resources was to decode the genetic blueprint of Populus trichocarpa by sequencing its genome (Tuskan et al., 2006). This provides the unique opportunity to understand the various genetic controls over various traits that may be critically important to the production of forest plants. This understanding will allow fundamental research questions to be translated into applications in genetic improvement for growth, stress tolerance, process compatibility, or specialized chemical components needed for biorefineries (Davis, 2008). This tool is becoming more commonplace as the cost of gene sequencing continues to drop. One of the primary objectives of the sequencing work is to more efficiently and effectively identify individual genotypes in a population that possess the desirable genes of interest for the production of optimal levels of bioenergy and biofuels. This objective is currently being addressed by a number of institutions in the United States (e.g., DOE, University of California Davis) by identifying single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) via gene sequencing and phenotyping in populations of poplars and loblolly pine. The resulting SNP markers can be a valuable tool for efficient and precise breeding and selection. The use of transgenic manipulation has been done in poplars and provides the primary technology in proving gene function. When combined with naturally occurring genetic variants, it is now possible to clarify the underlying causes of observed variation (Davis, 2008). These new tools have provided the geneticist with a new opportunity to accelerate, improve, and develop novel individuals for woody trees tailored to the production of bioenergy and biofuels. Combining effective breeding with the knowledge of the genome to guide selection will prove to be a powerful approach. This might be visualized through adaptive breeding, but it will be imperative to identify the correct species (parents) for hybrid combinations. Reducing the cost of testing while increasing the effectiveness of genetic testing through the use of marker-aided selection may allow us to grow poplars on what has been previously considered marginal sites.
3.5 Agroforestry Agriculture and forestry are the primary producers of bioenergy feedstocks. Agronomic crops and forests convert solar energy into chemical energy by photosynthesis. Agriculture and forestry have a unique opportunity to both provide biomass for energy and to serve as a net sink for CO2 . The current hypothesis is that if managed correctly, bioenergy can provide a C-neutral or even a C-negative feedstock. Thus, in the future we will be increasing our demands on both the agriculture and forestry sectors to provide bioenergy (Johnson et al., 2007a).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
64
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Figure 3.2. Agroforestry system employed by Westvaco Central Region located in Wickliffe, KY, along the Mississippi River. Picture shows lack of sunlight resulting in the inability to grow row crops. Chufa was planted for wildlife purposes.
Agroforestry purposely integrates agriculture and forestry in a manner that provides benefits from both systems (Schoeneberger, 2009). In most cases, the objectives are to evaluate the suitability of different tree species for marginal sites in terms of their yield potential and the influence of the trees on the sustainability and yields of annual biomass crop supply. Numerous trials have been established worldwide and some have shown interesting results. However, the common thread has been the need to identify tree species that perform well on the site chosen and evaluation of the synergy from combining agriculture and forest systems (Gruenwald et al., 2007). The Central Region of Westvaco Timberlands employed an agroforestry system on bottomland sites along the Mississippi and Ohio Rivers in the 1980s. The design consisted of two rows of either eastern cottonwood or American sycamore planted at a spacing of 8 × 12 feet. The rows of planted trees were separated by 40 feet, allowing an agricultural crop to be grown. This design was intended to allow agricultural production for a couple of years, thus providing income to help defray the cost of plantation establishment. The double row of trees provided the TPA necessary for pulpwood yields and competition control in a single direction. This system worked well for the first few years, but because of the rapid growth of the trees, agricultural production was minimized by a lack of sunlight. The area initially occupied by row crops provided additional growing space, allowing the trees, especially eastern cottonwood, to reach sawtimber size. This space also allowed access by mechanized equipment, thus easily employing a select harvest of higher value individuals (Figure 3.2). Agroforestry systems have the ability to sequester large amounts of carbon while providing additional benefits such as economic diversification, biodiversity, and water quality (Montagnini and Nair, 2004; Schoeneberger and Ruark, 2003; Schroeder, 1994). This type of
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
65
hybrid system has considerable appeal as a greenhouse gas (GHG) mitigation activity. The tree component provides substantial amounts of carbon sequestered, but the bulk of the land remains in agricultural production (Ruark et al., 2003). While agroforestry on the surface seems to be a win–win situation, it does represent a change, and it is perceived by many in the agricultural community as a cost. It is evident that landowners employing such as system must realize that it is a long-term commitment as it will take time for the tree component to reach the point of functional maturity. One aspect of forestry and agroforestry is the role they will play in the reduction of GHGs. Trees sequester a tremendous amount of carbon dioxide and have been used as an offset component of the US voluntary carbon market. The key components of any carbon offset are additionality and permanence. This at times has been questioned by those who are opposed to using forests as a means of GHG reductions. But the conversion of agricultural land to forest plantations, albeit limited, in an agroforestry system does meet the requirements of additionality. Moreover, converting these plantings back to agriculture is both costly and difficult, thereby providing a degree of permanence. Loblolly pine has a history of being grown in combination with warm-season grass species. Much of this has involved silvipastoral systems combining sawtimber production with either grazing or haying operations. Clason (1998) examined four forage species established in a 20-year-old loblolly pine plantation. Under common forage management practices, including fertilization, he noted no effect of forage species on tree growth over 11 years. Burner and Brauer (2003) planted loblolly pine seedlings into established pastures and examined the effects of different row spacings and row configurations on herbage yields. They found that loblolly pine negatively affected herbage yields up to a pine spacing of 4.9 m. Wolters (1973) also found that southern pine overstories increasingly reduced herbage production as levels of pine stocking increased, as was seen by Halls and Schuster (Halls and Schuster, 1965). Loblolly pine can also be managed as a source of biomass for bioenergy production (Scott and Tiarks, 2008). However, while its biomass production potential is high, it is probably not as high as for some other tree species such as species of poplar or willow. Loblolly pine has a substantially higher value for sawtimber production in the Southeast. A slight twist on typical agroforestry systems incorporates annual bioenergy crops such as switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) or giant miscanthus (Miscanthus × giganteus) in place of annual row crops, while the tree plantings favor longer rotations in the production of highly valued sawtimber species and individuals. At Mississippi State University, this type of agroforestry system has been termed “Co-Culture” and incorporates switchgrass with loblolly pine varietal (i.e., clonal) planting stock. In this system, a highly selected varietal loblolly pine genotype is combined with that of switchgrass. The number of TPA is reduced to 300, and switchgrass is established prior to tree seedling establishment. The key to this system is to continue to produce an annual biomass crop of switchgrass while allowing the trees to develop their inherent characteristics, thus providing an additional source of revenue some 25–30 years following establishment. Thinning would be possible at those times when the annual biomass crop needed re-establishment, which would allow ease of access to the trees, resulting in little or no damage to the remaining stand. If the carbon market is a viable alternative in the future, the trees may provide an additional revenue stream in carbon credits. The first trial studied at Mississippi State University included two loblolly pine varietals that expressed divergent crown ideotypes (crop vs. competitor) and a typical second-generation family as well as an area of switchgrass that is 56 feet wide and 360 feet long. The two loblolly pine varieties were selected because of their crown architecture. The crown of a crop ideotype is one that has more angular branches and carries less leaf biomass. In contrast, the
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
66
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
crown of a competitor ideotype would be wide and carry considerably more leaf biomass, thus shading out any type of competition. A selected second-generation family was added to use a baseline in determining the number of sawtimber potential trees in comparison to that of the selected varietal types. Trees were planted at a spacing of 12 × 14 feet in either four-row or two-row configurations. The objectives were to determine the effect that shading of specific tree genotypes would have on the yield of switchgrass through time and if varietal loblolly pine genotypes would exhibit the inherent traits of quality sawtimber in a more open-growth environment. More recently, a Co-Culture Study at Mississippi State University has been designed and will be implemented in the spring of 2010, where a single loblolly pine variety (i.e., clone), selected for sawtimber quality traits, will be grown in conjunction with an herbaceous biomass crop (in this case, switchgrass) (Roberts et al., 2009). The key initial component to the study is that a uniform stand of switchgrass must be in place prior to the tree component being installed. To do this, the switchgrass component will be established during the spring of the year followed by a fall planting of containerized varietal stock. To examine the competitive effect of the switchgrass on the tree performance and vice versa, specific free-to-grow zones will be applied to the trees. In this fashion, it is hoped that a clear understanding of the primary components limiting the performance of either tree growth or biomass yields of switchgrass will be gained. The short-term objectives of this study are to r Quantify competition between pine and switchgrass for soil moisture and nutrients r Quantify the effects of competition between pine and switchgrass on early growth of both
species The long-term objective is to gain a better understanding of competitive interactions between pine and switchgrass when grown in co-culture and the impacts of these competitive interactions on growth and yield of both species. Louisiana State University AgCenter has also been investigating the use of a bioenergy crop with loblolly pine at a site located at the Hill Farm Research Station in north central Louisiana. Their approach was to sow switchgrass between rows of loblolly pine in a plantation setting that was ages 2 (juvenile age), 11 (mid-rotation age), and 21 years (late-rotation age). Switchgrass was planted under relatively low and high densities of loblolly pine in each pine age group to test the effects of tree overstory on switchgrass establishment and growth. For the juvenile pine, the low and high densities of pine were created by planting trees at 225 and 450 TPA, respectively. The space between rows of trees was 16 feet for both densities, and the space between trees within rows was 12 feet for the 225 TPA density and 6 feet for the 450 TPA density. For the mid- and late-rotation pine, the low and high densities were created by a thinning operation. The mid-rotation stand was thinned to 100 and 200 TPA for the low and high densities, respectively. The low and high densities for the late-rotation pine were 25 and 50 TPA, respectively. To prepare the stands for switchgrass planting, imazapyr herbicide was applied by tractor-mounted sprayer at 48 oz per acre one year prior to planting and a 5% solution of glyphosate herbicide was applied by tractor-mounted sprayer two weeks prior to planting. Immediately prior to planting the soil was disked, and then the Alamo cultivar of switchgrass (which has shown the best growth potential among switchgrass varieties in much of the southeast United States) was broadcast seeded in April 2008 with a tractor-mounted cyclone seeder at 8 lb of pure live seed per acre. Seed was then culti-packed immediately after broadcast. To control weeds within the switchgrass, it was necessary to rotary mow the site with a tractor-drawn mower set at a 9-inch height in June 2008, September 2008, April 2009,
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
67
and June 2009. In July 2009, 0.25 oz per acre of metsulfuron methyl herbicide was applied using a tractor-mounted sprayer to further suppress the herbaceous vegetation competition. The LSU AgCenter study has revealed that switchgrass could be successfully established in rows between loblolly pine trees at juvenile, mid-rotation, and late-rotation ages at their site. By the second year of the study, switchgrass biomass covered at least 80% of ground within the alleys in all stand ages and stand densities. Switchgrass biomass by the second year was comparable across all ages and pine densities, which suggests that there may be substantial management flexibility for establishing switchgrass within alleys of loblolly pine. Shading from the pine overstory apparently enhanced switchgrass establishment success in the first year of this study because in all stand ages, switchgrass ground coverage was greater with the presence of loblolly pine than that of switchgrass grown at the same site without loblolly pine. Further evidence of the beneficial effects of shading on first-year switchgrass coverage was seen in the switchgrass coverage among the three stand ages being in the order of late-rotation > mid-rotation > juvenile. At the Hill Farm Research Station, an older similar study has shown that yields of fully mature switchgrass (greater than age 3) when grown under loblolly pine without fertilization averaged 2.5 tons per acre per year, with a maximum of 3.5 tons per acre per year (Michael Blazier, personal communication). Catchlight Energy, LLC is a joint venture between Chevron and Weyerhaeuser, whose objective is to develop the next generation of renewable transportation fuels from non-food sources. This unique venture will capitalize on the biological expertise of Weyerhaeuser and the advanced fuels expertise of Chevron. Currently, the Catchlight group is exploring the possibility of combining a bioenergy crop that can be harvested annually with trees that are managed for wood products and fiber. Their concept is very similar to that of many agroforestry systems where alternate rows of trees and an annual biomass crop are grown and used to feed a second-generation biofuels plant (http://www.catchlightenergy.com).
3.6 Products from Woody Biomass The US DOE and US Department of Agriculture estimated potential lignocellulosic biomass production for fuels in the United States at more than 1.3 billion tons annually, sufficient to replace more than 30% of current transportation fuel use (Perlack et al., 2005). Although age-old processes are available for converting the starch content of grain into sugars, which can then be fermented to ethanol, the conversion of lignocellulose to sugars is much more difficult. The recalcitrance of lignocellulose lies in its structure, which has evolved to provide long duration resistance to pests and pathogens. Thus, the development of processes for converting lignocellulosic biomass to fuels is hampered by the lack of energy-efficient and cost-effective processes for the deconstruction and conversion of this feedstock (Lynd et al., 1999). Trees and herbaceous material are made of three basic components plus many trace materials. The most abundant components are structural natural organic polymers: cellulose, hemicelluloses, and lignin. Cellulose is the long strong and flexible natural linear polymer in fibers that predominately gives trees and woods their strength. Cellulose fibers are held together in part by hydrogen bonds with itself but also by lignin, natural phenolic glue. Hemicelluloses are heteropolysaccharides of lower degree of polymerization than cellulose that are found encrusting the cellulose and lignin and also provide some bonding in the natural structure. Structural wood is simply the tree with all these components cut and shaped to the desired form. White paper is made predominantly from the cellulose fibers with most of the hemicellulose and almost all of the lignin removed.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
68
CH2OH
HO
OH
4 O
O HO
HO
O
O OH
1
1
4
CH2OH
CH2OH O
OH OH OH
n
Figure 3.3. Sterochemical structure of cellulose.
Cellulose consists of long chains of the six-carbon sugar glucose that are connected end to end as a polymer (Figure 3.3). It would seem simple to break that connection, by mechanical means or with enzymes, so that a long fiber of cellulose would become thousands of simple glucose molecules. However in practice, it is very difficult. The glucose molecules are connected by the more difficult to break β-O-4 linkages (Figure 3.3) and are arranged in regions with high crystallinity, which limits accessibility. Thus, cellulose is much more difficult to break up than starch molecules with their α-O-4 linkages that connect the glucose. Natural selection has resulted in cellulose that does not break apart easily. Fortunately, cellulose fibers are more valuable than their derived sugars because paper products can be made from them at present. However, as the demand for fuel and energy is increasing more than the demand for paper, conversion of cellulose to platform sugars will become more important as fossil energy sources diminish. Relatively pure cellulose can be hydrolyzed to glucose in formic acid media (Sun et al., 2007) and many other methods have been used in the past and are being developed now. It has been demonstrated that a woody biomass hot-water hemicellulose hydrolyzate stream can be separated into products and the sugars used for fermentation to ethanol. This sequential deconstruction of woody biomass is expected to become the dominant commercial method for production of new forest-based materials as it preserves the original value of components and allows their recovery for society’s use. The general process flow is to remove the easiest major component first, the hemicellulose, followed by application of a separate separation technique to fractionate the lignin and cellulose. Past techniques have focused on removing the lignin from cellulose, as in Kraft pulping and pulp bleaching, to provide fiber for papermaking. This approach may not be preferable to removing the cellulose from the lignin when the goal is to produce monomeric or oligomeric sugars from the cellulose. Current research is taking both approaches to continued deconstruction after hemicellulose removal without a clear winner yet clear. The method of deconstruction has significant implications for development of growing systems for traditional products integrated with new forest-based materials. The relative value of some components in traditional products may be trivial or even negative while the same component might be as valuable as cellulose, or significantly higher, as a new forest-based material. One example of this is the Ac, which stands for acetyl group, shown in the hemicelluloses galactoglucomannan and glucuronoxylan in Table 3.1. The acetyl group when recovered in an aqueous medium as acetic acid has values that can range from equal to that for relatively pure cellulose pulp to three times as valuable per unit of mass. This is important as the most dominant method of making relatively pure cellulose pulp (white pulp) is an alkaline system (using NaOH), and the acetyl groups use up alkali by neutralization while producing sodium acetate that is burned to recover the sodium. The fuel value of sodium acetate is very small, a few pennies per pound while the acetic acid could have recovered from $0.25 to $0.65 per pound.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
Table 3.2.
69
Major components of hemicelluloses and extractives. Distribution (wt%) Type
Hemicelluloses Galactoglucomannan (1:1:3)
G−M−M−M−G−M−M−M → | | | | Ga Ac Ac Ga
(Galacto) glucomannan (0.1:1:4) Glucomannan (1:2–1:1) Arabinoglucuronoxylan
Glucuronoxylan Extractives Aliphatic and alicyclic Phenolics Carbohydrates Inorganics Others
G−M−M−G−M → X −X −X−X−[X]5 → | | Gu 2 A X− X− X −[X] → | | Ac 7 Gu
Softwoods
Hardwoods
25–30
25–35
5–8
0
10–15
0
0
2–5
7–10
Trace
Trace
15–30
5–8 2–4 Terpenes: terpenoids, esters, fatty acids, alcohols Phenols: stilbenes, lignans, isoflavones Arabinose, galactose, glucose, xylose, raffinose, starch, pectic material Ca, K, Mg, Na, Fe, SO4 2− , Cl− Cyclitols, tropolones, amino acids, protein, alkaloids
Ash
0.2–0.5
0.2–0.8
G, glucose unit; Ga, galactose unit; M, mannose unit; X, xylose unit; A, arabinose unit; Ac, acetyl group (H3 C-CO-); and Gu, 4-O-methyl-glucuronic acid unit; all the linkages shown in the table are through –O–.
Discussion of the wood components will begin with hemicelluloses as they represent a significantly underutilized component of wood, which are most frequently lost during current chemical conversion processes used to purify cellulose, most commonly the Kraft pulping process followed by a bleaching sequence. These hemicelluloses will likely become targeted for enhancement in future growing systems, as their sugar complement will eventually be equal in value to glucose and their easier disassembly and high value substituents recommend increasing their content in the raw material.
3.6.1
Hemicellulosic Products
Hemicelluloses are heteropolymers of 5- and 6-carbon sugars with side chains. Table 3.2 shows major hemicellulose constituents together with wood biomass extractives. If one considers cellulose as a one-dimensional polymer, most hemicelluloses are two-dimensional polymers. Hemicellulose oligomers can be partially extracted from hardwood chips through solution in water at high temperatures (Amidon et al., 2008; Liu and Amidon, 2007; Liu et al., 2006), and xylose or hemicellulose sugars can be fermented to ethanol by microorganisms (Jeffries and Jin, 2004; Liu and Amidon, 2007; Qureshi et al., 2006). Hemicellulosic sugars may also be used as building blocks for biodegradable plastics (Keenan et al., 2004) or other products and chemicals that are currently made from petroleum (Liu et al., 2006). The residual woodchips can be processed into pulp to make paper, burned for renewable energy, or converted to
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
70
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
γ
CH2OH
CH2OH
CH2OH
β
α 1
2
6
3
5 4
OCH3
OH a. trans-Coniferyl alcohol
OCH3
H3CO OH
b. trans-Sinapyl alcohol
OH c. trans-p-Coumaryl alcohol
Figure 3.4. The precursors of lignin (Al´en, 2000).
reconstituted wood products such as fiberboard or pellets (Amidon, 2006; Amidon and Liu, 2009). This process would add additional products to the current paper and wood energy business starting an evolution towards wood-based biorefineries (Myerly et al., 1981). Making pulp and/or paper products from cellulose remains attractive today due to cellulose having a higher value as pulp than as sugar. However, the pulp and paper industry in the United States and Canada has actually been declining steadily in recent years as production shifts to higher growth areas such as China and Brazil. Further conversion of cellulose into sugars and/or other chemicals/liquid fuel is highly desirable because of higher future demand. A purpose-built biorefinery will include all these process alternatives, though adaptations of current processing locations may not include all alternatives. Lignin is a heteropolymer composed primarily of methoxylated phenylpropylene alcohol monomeric units interconnected by a variety of stable carbon–carbon and carbon–oxygen–carbon (ethers and esters) linkages (Dence and Lin, 1992). Structurally, lignin is a three-dimensional macromolecule. While the lignin of gymnosperms (also called softwoods, conifers, needle trees, or evergreens) is primarily an enzyme-initiated dehydrogenative polymerization product of coniferyl alcohol (Fengel and Wegener, 1984), the lignin of angiosperms (also hardwoods, deciduous or broad-leaved trees, grasses, etc.) is derived primarily from a mixture of coniferyl and sinapyl alcohols. Figure 3.4 shows the three cinnamyl alcohols, lignin precursors. The oxygen to carbon ratio in the lignin precursors (Figure 3.4) is less than 4/11. One can infer that lignin is much less oxygenated than carbohydrates, where approximately each carbon atom is accompanied by one oxygen atom. Therefore, lignin has the highest heating value in woody biomass. Lignin aromatic structure also provides excellent functional chemical sources, e.g., aromatic monomers. Lignin phenylpropane units, guaiacyl (G) and syringyl (S) derived from coniferyl and sinapyl alcohol, respectively, are linked together by different bonds (Figure 3.5) (Pu et al., 2007). The β-O-4 inter-unit linkages are the most abundant in lignin, estimated to be as high as 50% in softwoods and almost 60% in hardwoods. In general, more than two-thirds of the phenylpropane units are linked by ether bonds and the rest by carbon–carbon bonds. Depending on the hardwood species, GS-lignin as a copolymer of coniferyl and synapyl alcohols varies in the G/S ratio from 4:1 to 1:2. G-lignin occurring in almost all softwood is largely a polymerization product of coniferyl alcohol. Different contribution of p-hydroxycinnamyl alcohols in the biosynthesis of hardwood and softwood lignins causes significant differences in their structure, including the contents of different types of bonds and main functional groups (for example, methoxyl (OMe), phenolic hydroxyl (PhOH), aliphatic hydroxyl, carbonyl, and carboxyl groups). Softwood lignin is more condensed than hardwood lignin due to the difference in substitution of the lignin
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
C C O
C
C
C
C
C
C O
C
C O
C
O
O
C
C O
O
O β-O-4
C
α-O-4
71
O
β-1
dibenzodioxocin
C C
C C
O
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C C
O O
O β-5
O β-β
O
O 5-5
O 4-O-5
Figure 3.5. Common linkages between phenylpropane units in lignin (Pu et al., 2007).
precursors; substituted C3 and unsubstituted C5 in coniferyl alcohol versus substituted C3 and C5 in synapyl alcohol. Significant differences observed between hardwood and softwood lignin structures lead to different physical and chemical properties of these two lignin types (Argyropoulos and Menachem, 1997).
3.6.2
Biorefineries Using Woody Biomass
Current technologies for the chemical utilization of wood use a “destructive strategy” to obtain a single, relatively pure, component (cellulose). Other fractions are either wasted or used for power generation that gives a low added-value. The “biorefining” philosophy provides an alternative approach for utilization of lignocellulosic biomass. Lignocellulosic biomass can be “fractionated” into its main components by sequential treatments to give separate streams used for different product applications, maximizing the benefits of a renewable and complex resource by preserving as much of the value inherent in its original structures as possible. Wide applications of the carbohydrate oligomer streams exist. For example, xylooligomers are currently used as novel sweeteners in food additives (Aoyama, 1996; Ichikawa and Mitsumura, 1996). Health applications of indigestible oligosaccharides have been recently reported: for example, Imaizumi et al. (1991) found that a xylooligosaccharide-based diet reduced the blood concentrations of sugars and lipids on diabetic rats, and Toyoda et al. (1993) reported that xylooligosaccharides improved calcium absorption by rats. The phagocytic activity of neutrophils in mice was enhanced by either oral or intraperitoneal administration
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
72
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
of xylooligosaccharides (Aoyama, 1996); increased resistance of mice towards infection by Clostridium difficile caused by xylo- and fructo-oligosaccharides was reported by May et al. (1995). Improvements in the gastrointestinal health of rats caused by a xylooligosaccharidecontaining diet have been reported by Campbell et al. (1997). In relation to human health, xylooligosaccharides selectively enhance the growth of bifidobacteria, thus promoting a favorable intestinal environment (Okazaki et al., 1990; 1991). Sequential incremental deconstruction of wood into cellulosic, hemicellulosic, and ligninbased streams holds significant promise for industrial development. Each of these streams can be further processed to yield valuable products in a biorefinery setting. Papermaking pulps can be produced from the cellulosic components, biofuels including ethanol and bioplastics produced by fermentation from the hemicellulosic and cellulosic streams, and other chemical components from lignin. We address the fundamental challenges of biomass conversion to both conventional products—materials, chemicals and energy—and unconventional (new) ones not currently used in our daily life. In cellulose fibers, cellulose molecules fit together snugly lengthwise via hydrogen bonding. In conversion of woody biomass to chemicals, materials, and energy, systematic incremental deconstruction can lead to energy-efficient synthesis of revolutionary new forms of matter with tailored properties. For example, paper today is made of cellulose fibers. If we further split fibers into fibrils and make paper with fibrils, the outcome can be significantly different. Deconstruction of woody biomass one component at a time reduces the chances of forming undesired side products. We can more effectively control the conversion process and make better use of the released products with sufficient scientific knowledge applied. When biomass or a constituent of woody biomass is oxidized, it produces carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and water. The composition depends on oxygen availability. Incremental deconstruction of woody biomass requires transformation in a controlled way, far away from equilibrium. For example, partial oxidation of aromatic compounds or lignin to aldehydes requires the oxidation reaction to stop before completion, or equilibrium. Much knowledge is needed to allow the necessary control to develop effective commercial processes. The knowledge developed in the fundamental characterization of biomass and the identification of chemical linkages that make it difficult to convert lignocellulose will positively impact the development of engineered plants specifically tailored for fuel conversion. These engineered plants are envisioned to (1) contain weak links within the cell wall components that make them more amenable to deconstruction, (2) have certain chemical, genetic, and/or environmental triggers that initiate the deconstruction process, and/or (3) have been engineered so that certain structural and cross-linking elements no longer exist. The key to obtaining benefits associated with success is the development of the science underlying biomass disassembly, separation, and conversion processes. This will allow an increase in production and economic utilization of currently underutilized components of woody and agricultural biomass available in the United States. Woody biomass crops such as willow, cottonwood, aspen, alder, and Loblolly Pine could very significantly increase the amount of biomass available for processing when the science is developed that relates the different properties among species to disassembly, separation, and conversion methods. The method of growing the wood, the age of the wood, the height above ground, and the competitive situation of the tree producing the wood all affect the wood chemical, anatomical, and physical traits that affect its value and the preferred use and disassembly method (Amidon, 1975). As new forest-based materials become a larger component of the forest or purpose-grown biomass value, the agricultural and silvicultural systems employed will adapt to enhance the production of other value components or to make the disassembly easier.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
3.6.3
73
Hot-Water Extraction of Hemicellulose
One currently used disassembly procedure that is moving to commercial use is an example to show some of the key concepts. The method is Hot-Water Extraction of Hemicellulose. The key to this hot-water extraction process is to provide a beginning for systematic sequential deconstruction of woody biomass. Fractionation of woody feedstocks into their respective process streams (cellulose, hemicelluloses, lignin, extractives, etc.) is of interest for commercial operations. The elementary processes occurring during the conversion of biomass depended on the rate and extent of treatments that affect the structure and chemical composition of the woody biomass. The use of water as the sole solvent is a strength of this approach. The major constituents of lignocellulosic biomass (cellulose, hemicelluloses and lignin) cannot be simultaneously isolated as polymers. Extraction or prehydrolysis (e.g., Amidon et al., 2008; Conner and Lorenz, 1986; Garrote et al., 1999; 2001; Liu and Wyman, 2005; Overend et al., 1987; Weil et al., 1997) has a wide range of applications, including (Heitz et al., 1991) (1) fractionation or pulping processes, in which there is removal of hemicelluloses with selectivity towards cellulose degradation and splitting the α and β aryl ether bonds of lignin (Lora and Wayman, 1978; Schultz et al., 1984); (2) defibration for fibreboard production, in processes using high pressure steam; and (3) as a pretreatment for the enzymatic hydrolysis of cellulose (Dekker and Wallis, 1983; Grethlein and Converse, 1991). Since xylan is the main component of hardwood and grass hemicelluloses, xylooligomers and xylose are the main products obtained in hydrothermal treatments of this raw material. Sugar-degradation products (such as furfural or hydroxymethylfurfural) and acetic acid (generated from acetyl groups) can also appear in the reaction media. Extraction and subsequent acid hydrolysis are commonly carried out in water media. There are many advantages of using water as the sole solvent. However, harsh reaction conditions, i.e., either high temperature or a combination of high temperature and strong acid, are required and thus limit the processes to large-scale operations for economic success. Enzymatic hydrolysis is a slow process and is still in the process of developments (Gan et al., 2009; Zhang and Lynd, 2003). In reactions involved with woody biomass, either by pulping or extraction/autohydrolysis, a homogeneous model has largely been implicitly applied. For example, the kinetics of the Kraft pulping process is expressed through the following empiricism: −
dL = (ka [OH − ]a + kb [OH − ]b [HS − ]c )L d dt
(3.1)
where L is the concentration of lignin in wood, [OH− ] is the alkali or hydroxyl ion concentration in the cooking liquor, [HS− ] is the hydrosulfide ion concentration in the cooking liquor, and ka and kb are reaction rate constants. Different values of parameters a, b, and c were found for each stage during the delignification process. The transition points between the stages depend on the lignin content and the cooking conditions and are determined empirically by plotting carbohydrate content versus lignin content. There are two imperfections in the simplistic Equation 3.1, first, the rate of reaction is represented simply as rate change of reactant, and second, the mechanism is lost. A direct challenge to this empiricism is the gradual changing of order of reaction as it progresses (Li et al. 2002; Yang and Liu 2005) despite its popularity in dealing with woody biomass. On the basis of the surface reaction theory, Liu (2004; Liu and Wyman, 2005) and Yang and Liu (2005) inserted more fundamental kinetic approaches into developing bleaching and
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
74
pulping reactions involving wood and fibers. This introduction did explain why the orders of reaction in regard to the reactants in the liquid phase change with concentration range. In Yang and Liu (2005), the Kraft pulping kinetics was described by seven steps: (1) transport of hydroxide and hydrosulfide ions from the bulk liquor to the exterior surface of the chip, (2) diffusion of the chemical ions to the interior of the chip, (3) chemisorptions occur on the interior surface, (4) surface reaction between the chemical ions and lignin, (5) desorption of the soluble lignin degradation products, (6) diffusion of the soluble lignin degradation products to the chip exterior, and (7) transport of the soluble lignin degradation products in the bulk liquor. This is appropriate in kinetics of complex materials and reactions. However, the solid phase is not acting as a catalyst. The solid phase contains both reactant and the desired product. Under normal conditions, transport steps 1 and 7 are probably unimportant but the diffusion steps of 2 and 6 may play a significant role unless the effective thickness of the biomass particles is less than the critical thickness, say 2–3 mm (e.g., Hatton and Keays, 1973; Wilder and Daleski, 1965). Under 2–3 mm thickness conditions, these transport steps are negligible in effect on the overall observed pulping rate. The chemical reactions involved are said to be the rate-controlling steps, which means the overall reaction rate is dependent on steps of 3–5 directly, provided that the wood chips with the thickness of 4 mm or less are cooked. In many cases, our interests are on the intrinsic kinetics, i.e., steps 3–5, only. For the aqueous hydrolysis of woody biomass catalyzed by acid, the underlying principles of chemical kinetics are similar. However, the reactive sites are known not to be at the end of the molecular chain. The hydronium ion needs to access the O at β-1→4, forming the H. + .. complex as the first step towards the dissolution–hydrolysis reaction. Therefore, swelling −O− of the biomass matrix to expose the β-O-(1,4) linkage to the surface or solid–liquid interface is highly desirable. While the true mechanistic steps of the hydrolysis reactions catalyzed by acid can be very complex, we use a simplistic preliminary model to describe the behavior:
R1 − O − R 2 + H
H+ • R1 − O − R 2
+
H+ • + H2O R1 − O − R 2
H+
H
R1 − O
O
H
H+
H
R1 − O
O
(3.2)
H (3.3)
R2
R 1OH + R 2OH • H +
(3.4)
R2
R2 OH•H +
R 2 OH + H +
(3.5)
In the above model, Equations 3.2–3.5, the hydronium ion (H+ ) is a catalyst. Reactions 3.2 and 3.3 can be considered as adsorption steps, while reaction 3.5 is a desorption step.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
75
R1 and R2 can be carbohydrate groups, acetyl group, or methoxyl group. If the ROH is a small enough molecule, it effectively dissolves in the solvent (water) and becomes part of the solution. Reaction 3.4 is a hydrolysis reaction. Therefore, this hydrolysis reaction is the key reaction in the woody biomass conversion in aqueous medium. After the carbohydrates dissolve in the water, the hydrolysis reaction continues. The kinetics can be again represented by reactions 3.2–3.5). The only difference is that in the “extraction” stage, the carbohydrates are in the solid phase, whereas the carbohydrates are in the liquid phase during hydrolysis or “post-hydrolysis.” The hydrolysis ends when all the carbohydrates are converted to monosaccharides. In an acid medium, carbohydrate monomers (xylose and glucose, for example) can be dehydrated and thus form undesired products if the sugars are the desired products. The most common dehydration products are hydroxylmethylfufural (HMF, from 6-carbon sugars) and furfural (from 5-carbon sugars). Many more products can form from furfural and HMF, including levulinic acid, succinic acid, etc. Furfural, HMF, and organic acids, such as acetic acid, are potent inhibitors of the subsequent fermentation processes for biofuels. In order to control the conversion process, we must understand the chemical reactions occurring in the process. Therefore, kinetic studies are essential in the commercialization of the biomass conversions. The solid residue after complete hydrolysis can be recovered by filtration (number 3 porosity glass filter) and considered to be Klason lignin. The monosaccharides, acetic acid, and other compounds contained in the hot-water extract liquor can be determined by 1 H NMR spectroscopy (Kiemle et al., 2004). Wood extracts and hydrolyzate have been characterized by 1 H NMR extensively using the method developed at ESF (e.g., Kiemle et al., 2004). While the NMR analysis is reliable when the compositions are predominantly monomers and dilute, it does present challenges to complex mixtures. These challenges have made any research program more interesting. Figure 3.6 shows a 2D HSQC NMR (Two Dimensional Heteronuclear Single Quantum Correlation Nuclear Magnetic Resonance) spectrum we have been able to obtain on a wood extract sample. On the top, it is shown a 1 H NMR spectrum. One can observe the challenge of distinguishing the different molecules as shown inside the box by this top curve. Analytical technique development will continue, as knowledge of the complex mixture is needed for fundamental understanding that can lead to expanded commercial efforts.
3.6.4
Wood Extracts: Processing and Conversion
The conversion of woody biomass to platform chemicals, materials and energy can be achieved via two main routes: biochemical and thermochemical, with some overlap. A biochemical route has been the focus of this description. When dealing with cellulose and hemicellulose utilization, water as the solvent holds advantages over all other choices because of environmental and product recovery advantages. However, ionic liquids as solvents are also showing promise and may become major methods in the future. Recent work has shown that a cellulose solubility of up to 30 wt% can be achieved in ionic liquid solvents (Heinze et al., 2005). Ionic liquids in combination with acidic catalysts could also be used to promote the hydrolytic deconstruction of cellulose and hemicelluloses to five- and six-carbon sugars (Zhao et al., 2007). Many scientific strides are needed to push the utilization opportunities enough to enable biorefinery commercialization.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
76
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
ppm 92 GluN Glu Gal GluA Ara Xyl
94 GluN Rha
96
Man
Man Rha
Glu
Gal
GluA
98 Ara 100
Xyl
Oligomers
β-Region
13C
102 104
α-Region Oligomers
106 108
5.6
5.5
5.4
5.3
5.2
5.1
5.0
4.9
4.8
4.7
4.6
4.5
4.4
4.3
ppm
1H
Figure 3.6. 2D HSQC NMR spectrum for a concentrated wood extract sample. Credit Dr. B. Bujanovic, SUNYESF.
Fractionation and Concentration of Wood Extracts Microfiltration of extracts is conducted to separate colloidal and particulate material in the extract. Following microfiltration, separation processes are applied for the removal of acetic acid and other small molecules from the wood hydrolyzates, leaving purified sugar streams for fermentation. These processes include nano and reverse osmosis membranes and adsorptive membrane systems. Hot-Water Wood Extract Hydrolysis One method of hydrolysis of hot-water wood extract is to add xylanase to reduce oligomeric xylose to monomers. This will not hydrolyze non-xylan/xylose-derived oligomers and can take a long time. A second hydrolysis method of hydrolysis of hot-water wood extracts in aqueous media is to use mineral acid(s). Challenges remain on the enzymatic xylan hydrolysis due to the complex mixture generated during the hot-water extraction process. Microorganism adaption/evolution is being carried out to meet the challenges. Kinetic studies of the hydrolysis have focused on the molecular level mechanistic evaluations, coupled with computational modeling (Liu, 2008). The ability to control, separate, and analyze the low molecular weight polysaccharides is of great importance. Both proton and carbon NMR can be combined (i.e., 2D NMR) to identify and characterize the polysaccharides.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
77
P
Permeate holding tank
Feed and concentrate tank
Figure 3.7. Schematic of the Nano Filtration unit setup. Multiple passes are required for obtaining the substrate for ethanol and PHA fermentation: sugars and levulinic acid stream from the wood hydrolyzate.
Hydrolysate Fractionation and Sugar Stream Purification One critical problem in fermenting wood extracts is the toxicity of various lignin-derived components and phenolics to the microorganisms. Furthermore, small molecules such as acetic acid, furfural, and 2-hydroxy methyl-furfural are potent inhibitors affecting the commercial viability of a biorefinery processes. The success of manufacturing bioproducts is dependent upon reliable and efficient means to separate and purify these wood extract liquors to render them easily fermentable, while recovering additional products. Selective removal of various toxic compounds such as acetic acid, furfural, and other aromatics prior to fermentation is necessary. Development of a comprehensive database for the selection, design, and optimization of separation and purification processes for the extracts is ongoing. The ability to co-flocculate, adsorb, and recover inhibitory compounds is also a developing technology. The dispersed phases can then be separated by (1) sedimentation, (2) centrifugation, (3) dead-end (cake) filtration, and (4) cross flow filtration. Parameters for scale-up of these separation operations such as the specific filtration resistance, permeability, and compressibility of the sediments or dispersed phases are still being developed. For the membrane separation/purification processes, flux–transmembrane pressure maps to identify optimal operating conditions have been obtained. A schematic of the membrane unit is shown in Figure 3.7. The objective of using the membrane is to eliminate the commonly referred to detoxification steps in most cellulosic ethanol process. This is a unique approach at SUNY ESF (Liu, 2008; Amidon et al. 2008). Product recovery is promoted over the generation of a waste stream by detoxification procedures.
Hot-water Wood Hydrolysate Fractionation and Ethanol and PHA Fermentations The sugars solutions, after membrane separation as described above, have been found to be directly usable by Burkholderia cepacia, E. coli fbr5, and Pichia stipitis to convert the separated sugars to PHA and ethanol.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
78
3.6.5
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Residual Solid Wood Biomass: Processing and Conversion of the wood mass after extraction, an example
Pulping Cellulose fiber currently enjoys extensive utilization by the paper industry. One of the most surprising results from recent research is the observation that when hot-water extraction is used to extract ∼15% of the chip mass or more prior to pulping, the cooking time in the Kraft process can be decreased from 120 minutes to <30 minutes at 165◦ C (Amidon et al., 2006; 2008). Further research at SUNY-ESF indicates that the cleavage of lignin carbohydrate complexes (LCCs) during the hot-water extraction may be a major contributor to subsequent leaching of lignin out of the chips under alkaline conditions. Hot-water extraction would remove a significant amount of xylan from the chips and this produces in pulps with lower tensile strength (Francis et al., 2007). The xylan in pulp acts as a binder both within and on the fiber surface. Saake et al. (Saake et al., 2005) has reviewed the literature and also present experimental results showing that strength values of paper sheets can be increased 50%–150% by addition to the papermaking process of a few percent of wood or other plant xylan along with synthetic wet strength additives. These wet strength additives (kymene for example) are already being used in papermaking (Saake et al., 2005). The residual extracted chips have also been shown to have enhanced properties for burning, pellet production, and reconstituted wood products. The improved properties are mainly a result of decreased moisture reactivity due the reduced hemicellulose content and a reduction in ash content that results from hot-water extraction under the acidic conditions that occur in the process as a result, primarily, of acetyl group liberation from the wood to make acetic acid.
3.7 Summary Civilization has been built upon the ability of humankind to exploit the material resources that nature has provided. Liquid fuel and chemicals are the “life blood” of today’s economy. As we move into 21st century, the finite and uneven distribution of natural resources is increasingly apparent, and many of our activities are adversely impacting the environment. The fossil sources can only be replenished when living plants and animals are converted to fossil deposits. This cycle finished over 200 million years ago (Liu et al., 2006). While it was once axiomatic that civilization would always advance into the future, questions of “sustainability” now arise, as fossil resources do not replenish as we use them. Sooner or later, we will have to be able to use “renewable” energy and chemical sources on an industrial scale for our civilization to continue. Forestry and woody biomass will help to achieve that goal.
References Alen, R. 2000. Determination of the main aliphatic carboxylic acids in kraft black liquors by high performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. In: Stenius, P. (ed.) Forest Products Chemistry. Helsinki, Finland: Fapet Oy. Amidon, T. 2006. The biorefinery in New York: Woody biomass into commercial ethanol. Pulp and Paper Canada, 107, 47–50. Amidon, T.E. PhD Thesis, SUNY ESF, 1975.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
79
Amidon, T. & Liu, S. 2009. Water-based woody biorefinery. Biotechnology advances, 27, 542–550. Amidon, T., Wood, C., Shupe, A., Wang, Y., Graves, M. & Liu, S. 2008. Biorefinery: Conversion of woody biomass to chemicals, energy and materials. Journal of Biobased Materials and Bioenergy, 2, 100–120. Aoyama, M. 1996. Steaming treatment of bamboo grass. II. Characterization of solubilized hemicellulose and enzymatic digestibility of water-extracted Residue. Cellulose Chemistry and Technology, 30, 385–393. Argyropoulos, D. & Menachem, S. 1997. Lignin. In: Scheper, T. (ed.) Advances in Biochemical Engineering Biotechnology. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag. Bateman, I. & Lovett, A. 2000. Estimating and valuing the carbon sequestered in softwood and hardwood trees, timber products and forest soils in Wales. Journal of Environmental Management, 60, 301–323. Bowyer, J., Briggs, D., Johnson, L. & Al, E. 2001. CORRIM—A report of progress and a glimpse of the future. Forest Products Journal, 51, 10–22. Brown, C. 1976. Forests as energy sources in the year 2000: What man can imagine, man can do. Journal of Forestry (USA), 74, 7–12. Burner, D. & Brauer, D. 2003. Herbage response to spacing of loblolly pine trees in a minimal management silvopasture in southeastern USA. Agroforestry Systems, 57, 69–77. Campbell, J., Fahey Jr, G. & Wolf, B. 1997. Selected indigestible oligosaccharides affect large bowel mass, cecal and fecal short-chain fatty acids, pH and microflora in rats. Journal of Nutrition, 127, 130. Clason, T. 1998. Silvopastoral practices sustain timber and forage production in commercial loblolly pine plantations of northwest Louisiana, USA. Agroforestry Systems, 44, 293–303. Conner, A. & Lorenz, L. 1986. Kinetic modeling of hardwood prehydrolysis. Part III. Water and dilute acetic acid prehydrolysis of southern red oak. Wood and Fiber Science, 18, 248–263. Coyle, D. & Coleman, M. 2005. Forest production responses to irrigation and fertilization are not explained by shifts in allocation. Forest Ecology and Management, 208, 137–152. Davis, J. 2008. Genetic improvement of poplar (Populus spp.) as a bioenergy crop. Genetic Improvement of Bioenergy Crops, 397–419. Dekker, R. & Wallis, A. 1983. Autohydrolysis-explosion as pretreatment for the enzymic saccharification of sunflower seed hulls. Biotechnology Letters, 5, 311–316. Dence, C. & Lin, S. 1992. Introduction. In: Dence, C. & Lin, S. (eds.) Methods in Lignin Chemistry. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg. Fengel, D. & Wegener, G. 1984. Wood: Chemistry, Ultrastructure, Reactions. Berlin, New York: Walter De Gruyter Inc. Fisher, R. K., Gardiner, E. S., Stanturf, J. A. & Portwood, C. J. 2002. Disking Effects of Fifth-Year Volume Production of Four Eastern Cottonwood Clones Established on an Afforestation Site, Sharkey County, Mississippi. Gen. Tech. Rep. SRS–48. Asheville, NC: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station; pp. 515–519. Francis, R., Amidon, T., Shin, N., Bolton, T. & Kanungo, D. 2007. Mild acid and alkaline pretreatments before kraft and SAQ pulping. Presented at 3rd Int. Coll. on Eucalyptus Pulps, Belo Horizonte, Brazil, March 4th–7th. Gan, Q., Allen, S. & Taylor, G. 2003. Kinetic dynamics in heterogeneous enzymatic hydrolysis of cellulose: An overview, an experimental study and mathematical modelling, Process Biochemistry, 38 (7), 1003–1018.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
80
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Garrote, G., Dominguez, H. & Parajo, J. 2001. Generation of xylose solutions from Eucalyptus globulus wood by autohydrolysis–posthydrolysis processes: Posthydrolysis kinetics. Bioresource Technology, 79, 155–164. Garrote, G., Dom´ınguez, H. & Paraj´o, J. 1999. Mild autohydrolysis: An environmental friendly technology for xylooligosaccharide production from wood. Journal of Chemical Technology & Biotechnology, 74, 1101–1109. Gonzalez, R., Wright, J. & Saloni, D. 2009. Filling a need: Forest plantations for bioenergy in the southern United States. Forest Landowner Magazine, 68, 26–29. Grethlein, H. & Converse, A. 1991. Common aspects of acid prehydrolysis and steam explosion for pretreating wood. Bioresource Technology, 36, 77–82. Gruenwald, H., Brandt, B., Schneider, B. & Al, E. 2007. Agroforestry systems for the production of woody biomass for energy transformation purposes. Ecological Engineering, 29, 319–328. Halls, L. & Schuster, J. 1965. Tree-herbage relations in pine-hardwood forests of Texas. Journal of Forestry, 63, 282–283. Hassan, E., Steele, P. & Ingram, L. 2009. Characterization of fast pyrolysis bio-oils produced from pretreated pine wood. Applied Biochemistry and Biotechnology, 154, 3–13. Hatton, J. & Keays, J. 1973. Effect of chip geometry and moisture on yield and quality of kraft pulps from western hemlock and black spruce. Pulp and Paper Magazine of Canada, 74, T11–T19. Heinze, T., Schwikal, K. & Barthel, S. 2005. Ionic liquids as reaction medium in cellulose functionalization. Macromolecular Bioscience, 5, 520–525. Heitz, M., Capek-Menard, E., Koeberle, P., Gagne, J., Chornet, E., Overend, R., Taylor, J. & Yu, E. 1991. Fractionation of Populus tremuloides at the pilot plant scale: Optimization of steam explosion pretreatment conditions using the STAKE II technology. Bioresource Technology, 35, 23–32. Ichikawa, T. & Mitsumura, Y. 1996. Effects of the addition of new saccharide sweeteners on the properties of sponge cakes. Journal of Home Economics of Japan, 47, 445–452. Imaizumi, K., Nakatsu, Y., Sato, M., Sedarnawati, Y. & Sugano, M. 1991. Effects of xylooligosaccharides on blood glucose, serum and liver lipids and cecum short-chain fatty acids in diabetic rats. Agricultural and Biological Chemistry, 55, 199–205. Jeffries, T. & Jin, Y. 2004. Metabolic engineering for improved fermentation of pentoses by yeasts. Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 63, 495–509. Johnson, J., Coleman, M., Gesch, R., Jaradat, A., Mitchell, R., Reicosky, D. & Wilhelm, W. 2007a. Biomass-bioenergy crops in the United States: A changing paradigm. The Americas, 1, 1–28. Johnson, J., Franzluebbers, A., Weyers, S. & Reicosky, D. 2007b. Agricultural opportunities to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. Environmental Pollution, 150, 107–124. Keenan, T., Tanenbaum, S., Stipanovic, A. & Nakas, J. 2004. Production and characterization of poly-beta-hydroxyalkanoate copolymers from Burkholderia cepacia utilizing xylose and levulinic Acid. Biotechnology Progress, 20, 1697–1704. Kennedy Jr., H. E. & Henderson, W. 1976. Cultivation in cottonwood plantations—Practice and equipment. In: B.A., T. & S.B., L. (eds.) Symposium on Eastern Cottonwood and Related Species., Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA. Division of Continuing Education, pp. 379–384. Kiemle, D., Stipanovic, A. & Mayo, K. 2004. Proton NMR methods in the compositional characterization of hemicelluloses. ACS Symposium Series, 864, 122–139. Kram, J. 2008. Managing woody biomass. Biomass Magazine, April.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
81
Leininger, T., Solomon, J., Wilson, A. & Al, E. 1999. A guide to major insects, diseases, air pollution injury, and chemical injury of Sycamore. General Technical Report. Asheville NC: USDA Forest Service, Southern Research Station. Li, A., Zhang, Q., Zhang, G., Chen, J., Fei, Z. & Liu, F. 2002. Adsorption of phenolic compounds from aqueous solutions by a water-compatible hypercrosslinked polymeric adsorbent. Chemosphere, 47, 981–988. Liu, C. & Wyman, C. 2005. Partial flow of compressed-hot water through corn stover to enhance hemicellulose sugar recovery and enzymatic digestibility of cellulose. Bioresource Technology, 96, 1978–1985. Liu, S. 2004. A simplistic mechanistic model and effect of consistency on alkaline peroxide brightening of mechanical pulps. Chemical Engineering Science, 59, 20. Liu, S. 2008. A kinetic model on autocatalytic reactions in woody biomass hydrolysis. Journal of Biobased Materials and Bioenergy, 2, 135–147. Liu, S. & Amidon, T. 2007. Essential components of a wood-based biorefinery. O. Papel, 68, 54–75. Liu, S., Amidon, T., Francis, R., Ramarao, B., Lai, Y. & Scott, G. 2006. From forest biomass to chemicals and energy. Biorefinery initiative in New York State. Industrial Biotechnology, 2, 113–120. Lora, J. & Wayman, M. 1978. Delignification of hardwoods by autohydrolysis and extraction. Tappi, 61, 47–50. Lynd, L., Wyman, C. & Gerngross, T. 1999. Biocommodity engineering. Biotechnology Progress, 15, 777–793. May T., Mackie R.I. and Garleb K.A. 1995. Effect of dietary oligosaccharides in the intestinal growth of and tissue damage by Clostridium difficile. Mikrooekol Ther, 23, 158–170. McKeand, S., Abt, R., Allen, H., Li, B. & Catts, G. 2006. What are the best loblolly pine genotypes worth to landowners? Journal of Forestry, 104, 352–358. Mitchell, W. 1998. Physiology of carbohydrate to solvent conversion by clostridia. Advances in Microbial Physiology, 39, 31. Montagnini, F. & Nair, P. 2004. Carbon sequestration: An underexploited environmental benefit of agroforestry systems. Agroforestry Systems, 61, 281–295. Myerly, R., Nicholson, M., Katzen, R. & Taylor, J. 1981. The forest refinery. Chemtech, 11, 186–192. Okazaki, M., Fujikawa, S. & Matsumoto, N. 1990. Effects of xylooligosaccharide on growth of bifidobacteria. Journal of Japanese Society of Nutrition and Food Science (Japan), 43, 395–401. Okazaki, M., Koda, H., Izumi, R., Fujikawa, S. & Matsumoto, N. 1991. Effect of xylooligosaccharide on growth of intestinal bacteria and putrefaction products. Journal Japanese Society Nutrition Food Science, 44, 41–44. Overend, R. P., Chornet, E. & Gascoigne, J. A. 1987. Fractionation of lignocellulosics by steam-aqueous pretreatments [and Discussion]. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Mathematical and Physical Sciences, 321, 523– 536. Perlack, R., Wright, L., Turhollow, A., Graham, R., Stokes, B. & Erbach, D. 2005. Biomass as feedstock for a bioenergy and bioproducts industry: The technical feasibility of a billion-ton annual supply, Technical Report A357634. Pu, Y., Zhang, D., Singh, P. & Ragauskas, A. 2007. The new forestry biofuels sector. Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining, 2, 58–73.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
82
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Qureshi, N., Dien, B., Nichols, N., Saha, B. & Cotta, M. 2006. Genetically engineered Escherichia coli for ethanol production from xylose substrate and product inhibition and kinetic parameters. Food and Bioproducts Processing, 84, 114–122. Ranney, J., Wright, L. & Layton, P. 1987. Hardwood energy crops: The technology of intensive culture. Journal of Forestry (USA), 85, 17–28. Roberts, S., Rousseau, R., Hatten, J. & Al, E. 2009. Interspecific competition in a loblolly pine-switchgrass co-culture system for biomass production. Sun Grant Proposal. Rockwood, D., Rudie, A., Ralph, S. & Al, E. 2008. Energy product options for Eucalyptus species grown as short rotation woody crops. International Journal of Molecular Science, 9, 1361–1378. Rousseau, R.J., Adams, J.P. & Wilkinson, D.W. 2008 Nine-year performance of a variety of populus taxons on an upland site in Western Kentucky. Presented at 15th Biennial Southern Silvicultural Research Conference. Hot Springs. AR. 11/18/2008–11/20/2008. Ruark, G., Schoeneberger, M. & Nair, P. 2003. Agroforestry—Helping to achieve sustainable forest management. Report and Papers of the UNFF Intersession Experts Meeting on the Role of Planted Forests in Sustainable Forest Management, 24–30 March 2003, Wellington, New Zealand. Saake, B., Busse, T. & Puls, J. 2005 The effect of xylan adsorption on the properties of sulfite and kraft pulps. Presented at 13th International Symposium on Wood, Fibre and Pulping Chemistry, 16–19 May, Vol. 2, pp. 141–146, Auckland, New Zealand. Schmidtling, R., Robison, T., McKeand, S., Rousseau, R., Allen, H. & Goldfarb, B. 2004. The role of genetics and tree improvement in southern forest productivity. General Technical Report SRS–75. For delivery at the UNFF Intersessional Experts Meeting on the Role of Planted Forests in Sustainable Forest Management, 24–30 March 2003, New Zealand. Schoeneberger, M. 2009. Agroforestry: Working trees for sequestering carbon on agricultural lands. Agroforestry Systems, 75, 27–37. Schoeneberger, M. & Ruark, G. 2003. Agroforestry—Helping to Achieve Sustainable Forest Management. Schroeder, P. 1994. Carbon storage benefits of agroforestry systems. Agroforestry Systems, 27, 89–97. Schultz, T., McGinnis, G. & Biermann, C. 1984. Similarities and differences in pretreating woody biomass by steam explosion, wet oxidation, autohydrolysis, and rapid steam hydrolysis/continuous extraction, Technical Report CONF-840111-4. Scott, D. & Tiarks, A. 2008. Dual-cropping loblolly pine for biomass energy and conventional wood products. Southern Journal of Applied Forestry, 32, 33–37. Stanturf, J., Van Oosten, C., Netzer, D., Coleman, M. & Portwood, C. 2001. Ecology and silviculture of poplar plantations. In: Dickman, D. & Isebrands, J. (eds.) Poplar Culture in North America. Ottawa, Ontario: NRC Research Press. Steinbeck, K., Mcalpine, R. & May, J. 1972. Short rotation culture of sycamore: A status report. Journal of Forestry, 70, 210–213. Stettler, R., Fenn, R., Heilman, P. & Al, E. 1988. Populus Trichocarpa × populus Deltoides hybrids for short-rotation culture: Variation patterns and 4-year field performance. Canadian Journal of Forestry Research, 18 (6), 745–753. Stettler, R., Zsuffa, L. & Wu, R. 1996. The role of hybridization in the genetic manipulation of Populus. In: Stettler, R. F., Bradshaw, Jr., H. D., Heilman, P. E. & Hinckley, T. M. (eds.) Biology of Populus and Its Implications for Management and Conservation. Ottawa, ON: NRC Research Press; pp. 87–112.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
3 Growing Systems for Traditional and New Forest-Based Materials
83
Sun, Y., Lin, L., Pang, C., Deng, H., Peng, H., Li, J., He, B. & Liu, S. 2007. Hydrolysis of cotton fiber cellulose in formic acid. Energy & Fuels, 21, 2386–2389. Toyoda, Y., Hatakana, Y. & Suwa, Y. 1993. Effect of xylooligosaccharides on calcium absorption. Presented at 47th Ann Meeting Japan Society for Nutrition and Food Sci, Tokyo, Japan. 100. Treasure, E., Cohen, E., McNulty, S. & Al, E. 2008. Vulnerability of the Southeastern United States to climate change. USDA Forest Service. Tuskan, G. 1998. Short-rotation woody crop supply systems in the United States: What do we know and what do we need to know? Biomass and Bioenergy, 14, 307–315. Tuskan, G., Difazio, S., Jansson, S., Bohlmann, J., Grigoriev, I., Hellsten, U., Putnam, N., Ralph, S., Rombauts, S. & Salamov, A. 2006. The genome of black cottonwood, Populus trichocarpa (Torr. & Gray). Science, 313, 1596. Wear, D. & Greis, J. 2002. Southern forest resource assessment: Summary of findings. Journal of Forestry, 100, 6–14. Weil, J., Sarikaya, A., Rau, S., Goetz, J., Ladisch, C., Brewer, M., Hendrickson, R. & Ladisch, M. 1997. Pretreatment of yellow-poplar sawdust by pressure cooking in water. Applied Biochemistry and Biotechnology, 68, 21–40. Wilder, H. & Daleski, E. J. 1965. Delignification rate studies: Part 2 of a series on kraft pulping kinetics. TAPPI Journal, 48, 293. Wolters, G. 1973. Southern pine overstories influence herbage quality. Journal of Range Management, 26, 423–426. Yang, L. & Liu, S. 2005. Kinetic model for kraft pulping process. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 44, 7078–7085. Zhang, Y. & Lynd, L. 2003. Cellodextrin preparation by mixed-acid hydrolysis and chromatographic separation. Analytical Biochemistry, 322, 225–232. Zhao, H., Holladay, J., Brown, H. & Zhang, C. 2007. Metal chlorides in ionic liquid solvents convert sugars to 5-hydroxymethylfurfural. Science, 316, 1597–1600.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c03 BLBS075-Hood December 16, 2010
16:59
Trim: 244mm×172mm
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Chapter 4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops Keat (Thomas) Teoh, Shivakumar Pattada Devaiah, Deborah Vicuna Requesens, and Elizabeth E. Hood
4.1 Introduction Early implementation of the biomass to biofuels industry will depend on available feedstocks such as agricultural residues and wood waste from mills and forests. However, long-term productivity of the industry will require dedicated energy crops with more predictable biomass production. According to the Billion-Ton Annual Supply report, 48 million dry tons of biomass would be available in 2009 and beyond, from agricultural residues at current harvest logistics for conversion into raw materials (http://www.eere.energy.gov/biomass/publications.html). With increases in productivity, this number could double for crop residues, but would still fall far short of the necessary biomass for transportation fuels. In addition, crop residues from food/feed production can be critical for soil health (see Chapter 7 in this volume). Thus, the need for high-productivity crops whether annual or perennial will be required. It is feasible to achieve over a billion tons of biomass from US forest and cropland within the next few years (Billion-Ton study). At 80 gallons per ton, this amount of biomass could produce 80 billion gallons of renewable fuels, or about half the current usage for US transportation. Dedicated energy crops can come from multiple sources. This chapter focuses on nonwoody, high-yielding annual and perennial crops—Miscanthus, switchgrass, and sweet sorghum (Figure 4.1). Although we recognize that there are many other possibilities, these crops are the top candidates in the USA currently and are the subjects of much recent research. Woody crops are the subject of Chapter 3 in this volume.
4.2 Miscanthus Miscanthus is a member of the grass family Graminae and is closely related to the genus Saccharum (which includes sugar cane), another energy crop. Miscanthus is native in Plant Biomass Conversion, First Edition. Edited by Elizabeth E. Hood, Peter Nelson and Randall Powell. C 2011 John Wiley & Sons Inc.
85
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
86
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
a
b
c
Figure 4.1. (a) Miscanthus × gigantueus (Photo credit: Marcia Sofonoff), (b) switchgrass, (c) sweet sorghum (left side of the field) and grain sorghum (right side of the field).
south-eastern Asia, China, Japan, and the Pacific Islands with a few species occurring in Africa. It is a C4 rhizomatous perennial grass that can grow up to 4 m tall. Miscanthus was first introduced into Denmark from Japan in 1935 as an ornamental plant and is now cultivated throughout Europe and North America primarily for energy production with other end uses being explored. Miscanthus is valued for its qualities as an ideal biomass crop and as such in recent years has received widespread attention as a bioenergy crop. Extensive evaluation of Miscanthus as a biomass crop has been going on in Europe for the last two decades and its yield potential has been shown to be substantial (Jones and Walsh, 2001). It is being tested in Europe as solid fuel for combustion in farm heating plants as well as for cocombustion with coal, straw, and wood to generate power. Evaluation of Miscanthus as a biomass crop in North America is fairly recent compared to switchgrass, another perennial grass common in the Midwest of the United States and adopted by the Department of Energy (DOE) as the model biomass crop. However, projected yields of Miscanthus in the US Midwest, based on a mathematical productivity model developed for Miscanthus from the European studies (Clifton-Brown et al., 2002) and yields recently reported from field trials in Illinois (Heaton et al., 2008), far exceed those of switchgrass. The promising yield deserves serious investigation into the potential of Miscanthus as a dedicated energy crop in North America in addition to switchgrass, to address the energy security of the country and global carbon emissions. It is estimated that about 14 species of Miscanthus are known (Hodkinson et al., 1997). The most common species investigated as a biofuel in Europe and N. America is Miscanthus × giganteus (Figure 4.1), a naturally occurring sterile triploid hybrid that has its origin in Japan (Greef and
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
87
Deuter, 1993). The genetic origin of M. × giganteus is uncertain but some evidence suggests that this hybrid is a result of a cross between M. sinensis (diploid) and M. sacchariflorus (tetraploid) (Linde-Laursen, 1993). In general, M. sinensis types are well adapted for cooler climates, whereas M. sacchariflorus can provide genetic resources for warmer regions.
4.2.1
Characteristics That Make Miscanthus a Potential Biomass Crop
An ideal potential biomass crop should have a sustained capacity to capture and convert the available solar energy into harvestable biomass with highest efficiency, with lowest energy and financial inputs and with minimal environmental impacts. Miscanthus, like all C4 plants, is highly efficient in converting solar energy into biomass. The photosynthesis potential of C4 plants is estimated to be 40% greater than C3 plants (Monteith, 1978). Miscanthus × giganteus is more tolerant of low temperatures than most C4 perennials, allowing it to maintain its photosynthesis and leaf growth even at temperatures as low as 10 ◦ C (Naidu and Long, 2004; Naidu et al., 2003). This enables M. × giganteus to establish a photosynthetically active canopy earlier in spring and persist longer in the fall, thereby lengthening its productive period. As a perennial grass, Miscanthus is a low maintenance crop that can persist for 15– 20 years requiring no tillage once it is established, thus lowering cost of energy and labor and significantly reducing soil erosion and nutrient loss. An established crop of Miscanthus requires very little fertilizer to support growth because the plants are able to acquire and conserve large quantities of nutrients and translocate these nutrients into the rhizome at the end of a growing season to support regrowth in the following season. This will amount to a substantial savings in fertilizer cost and at the same time minimize environmental problems caused by potential water pollution from leachates and run-off. Miscanthus can be grown in a wide variety of soil, which means that the crop can also be grown on marginal land or land not being used for crop production. Often, a concern when a new species is introduced into an area is the risk of escape. Miscanthus × giganteus is a sterile hybrid and poses little risk as an invasive species because it does not produce viable seed, though it does have an active rhizome.
4.2.2
Agronomy
Establishment Miscanthus can be established from seeds, rhizomes, micropropagated plantlets derived from tissue culture, and stem cuttings. The short growing period and the cold winter in Europe and the Midwest of continental North America do not favor establishment by seeds. The use of micropropagated plantlets to establish Miscanthus offers potentially a much higher multiplication rate, but conventional micropropagation is considered too expensive to make commercial production economically viable. Moreover, issues still need to be resolved concerning low winter survival rate in the first year with plants established from micropropagated plantlets. Establishment by rhizomes is the preferred method for achieving high survival rate. Rhizomes or rhizome pieces are planted directly in the field. Automated precision planting of the rhizome on a commercial scale is now possible in Europe. The factors identified as important in establishing a Miscanthus crop from rhizomes are the size of rhizomes, depth of soil, and condition of the rhizomes (fresh or stored over winter). The field trials in Europe have demonstrated that the greatest success with establishment from rhizomes is achieved with
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
88
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
fresh, healthy rhizomes approximately 200 mm in length, planted at soil depths of 200 mm (Christian and Haase, 2001). Establishing Miscanthus from stem cuttings has been tested in Europe and shown to be feasible but requires further investigation. Miscanthus has been established successfully in Europe from latitude 37◦ N to 56◦ N. In N. America, Miscanthus has been established successfully in the Midwest from latitude 38◦ N to 48◦ N covering Ohio, Michigan, Indiana, and Illinois, and expanding into other areas in the south like Georgia and Florida and as far north as Quebec, Canada.
Factors Influencing Establishment Miscanthus prefers the mild temperatures and high water availability of its natural habitats in the tropics and subtropics, but the successful establishment of Miscanthus × giganteus in Europe and the US Midwest suggests that it is relatively tolerant of temperate temperatures and water availability. Nevertheless, low temperature still limits the growth of Miscanthus. This has been observed in field trials in Europe where the winter survival rate in Northern Europe is low and harvestable yield is 40% lower than in Central and Southern Europe (CliftonBrown et al., 2001b). Similar effects, but to a lesser extent, are observed in field trials in Illinois where the yield in the north is 25% lower than in central and southern Illinois (Heaton et al., 2008). Water availability affects the success rate of establishment in the first year. In locations where precipitation is high such as northern and central Europe M. × giganteus has been successfully grown without irrigation, but in southern Europe where annual rainfall is typically below 20 inches (500 mm), irrigation is necessary for substantial growth and biomass yields (Clifton-Brown et al., 2001b). Winter loss in the first year of Miscanthus establishment has been a significant problem in northern Europe. Two factors were notably important in improving winter survival in the first year of establishment. Plants established from rhizomes have a significantly higher winter survival rate than plants established from micro-propagation. This is often attributed to the reserves stored in rhizomes. Plants established from fresh rhizomes are less likely to succumb to the adverse winter conditions (5%–30% winter loss) compared to plants established from rhizomes that have been stored prior to planting (50%–90% winter loss). Rhizomes that have been stored for a certain period of time before planting are likely to dry out and exhibit less vigor. Interestingly, field trials in Illinois did not experience any significant winter loss in the first year. The northern site experienced only a 14% loss during the first year and no losses in the central and southern sites. This is in contrast to 100% loss in some European sites even though the mean winter minimum temperature may be milder than in the US Midwest. The timing of planting also contributes to the success of crop establishment. In order to avoid the damaging effect of frost, rhizomes are normally planted after the risk of the latest spring frost is over, typically from March until May depending on the climate while micro-propagated plants or pot-grown plants are planted later (mid-April to May). No disease has been reported to date, but the crop has been known to be susceptible to Fusarium blight and Barley Yellow Dwarf Luteovirus (Walsh and McCarthy, 1998). The slow initial growth of Miscanthus means weed control is essential during the establishment phase of the crop. Fields are typically sprayed with herbicide before planting followed by at least two sprayings a year for the first 2–3 years. A range of selective herbicides containing an active ingredient appropriate for cereals (with the possible exception of some graminicides) are deemed suitable for Miscanthus. C4-specific herbicides such as atrazine could also be used (Bullard et al., 1995).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
89
Planting, Harvesting, and Storage Rhizomes of Miscanthus can be planted using existing farm equipment such as potato planters and manure spreaders, and the plants harvested by a modified forage harvester. In Europe, significantly improved and patented planting equipment designed specifically for Miscanthus has increased the speed and efficiency of the farming process. This planting equipment can establish 16 hectares of rhizomes a day compared to 6 hectares a day with traditional farm equipment (Nixon et al., 2001). Harvesting is carried out after the crop has senesced with moisture content preferably at its lowest and with nutrients translocated into the rhizomes. The transfer of nutrients from the plants to the rhizomes is important as it will ensure winter survival and support regrowth the following spring. Harvesting is timed to achieve a balance between attaining lowest moisture content and minimizing biomass losses caused by adverse winter conditions. Harvesting is typically done between late autumn and early spring before plant regrowth. Crops grown in cooler climates are typically harvested in early spring when the moisture content is lowest. Crops grown in warmer climates reach their maturity earlier and can be harvested in late autumn to avoid biomass losses caused by adverse winter conditions or in early spring when the moisture content is lowest. However, delaying harvest until early spring results in yield reduction by as much as 30%–50% due to winter losses of dead and decaying leaves and upper stem parts. Such losses are tolerated because lower moisture content (20%) improves the fuel quality, permits ease of handling, and requires little need for drying. Drying of the harvested crop is necessary to ensure stability during storage so that the biomass material is available throughout the year. A few methods are available to dry Miscanthus. Some methods employ mechanical ventilation during storage, while others employ industrial dryers, but the most cost-effective way is to leave the crop out in the field to dry using ambient air and solar radiation. Miscanthus can be stored in the open air with or without covering or in low-cost farm buildings with roof and open sides. Harvested Miscanthus can be processed into different fuel types, such as (1) chopped into specified length and bulk transported, (2) baled, or (3) formed into pellets and briquettes. The end use of the biomass ultimately determines the methods with which the harvested crop is handled as regards to harvest, storage, and transport. For a more detailed discussion of handling strategies for the Miscanthus crop, readers are referred to the following references (El Bassam and Huisman, 2001; Nixon and Bullard, 2003).
Yields The first year crop does not yield sufficient biomass to merit harvesting, hence the crop is normally harvested from the second year onwards, but yields will continue to improve after year two until they level off. Ceiling yields can be reached in two years under good growing conditions but may take up to 5 years at some locations. The ceiling yields are attained more quickly in warmer climates and those total yields are higher than in cooler climates. The yields reported for the field trials both in Europe and in the United States so far have been promising. The winter yields reported for Europe following the third growing season varied with location and ranged between 7 and 26 dry ton/ha from northern to southern Europe (Clifton-Brown et al., 2001a). These field trials were conducted in 15 locations across the European Union countries, extending as far north as Denmark (56◦ N) and as far south as southern Italy (37◦ N). In North America, Miscanthus has been successfully established in many regions, but so far extensive evaluation of its productivity has been reported in only one region. This evaluation comes from field trials conducted in Illinois by researchers at the University of Illinois, beginning in 2001 covering the northern, central, and southern plains of the state. The reported
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
90
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
average winter yields of dry matter for the 3 years following the third growing season were 20.9, 33.4, and 34.6 dry ton/ha in the north, central, and south, respectively (Heaton et al., 2008). The average yield per year across the three sites is approximately 30 dry ton/ha. This yield is significantly higher than the yields reported in Europe and almost three times higher than for switchgrass cv. Cave-in-Rock, grown side-by-side with Miscanthus in the same field trials (Table 4.1) (Heaton et al., 2008). The 2005 DOE and USDA supported Billion-Ton study projected 377 million dry tons of plant material from perennial crops on approximately 24 million hectares of agricultural land (Perlack et al., 2005). A yield of 30 t/ha would achieve the projected target of 377 million tons on 12.6 million hectares, half the area estimated in the Billion-Ton study projections. An assessment of fertilizer requirements from field trials in Europe and from a quantitative review of literature by Heaton et al., (2004) revealed that nitrogen has only a modest influence on the yields of M. × giganteus and relatively low fertilizer application is required during the growing season. It is estimated that the annual requirement of nitrogen is 50–70 kg/ha, phosphorus is 5–10 kg/ha, and potassium is 70– 100 kg/ha (Christian and Haase, 2001; Himken et al., 1997; Lewandowski et al., 2000). The yield of Miscanthus is strongly influenced by the availability of water, especially during the growing season. It is estimated that Miscanthus requires a minimum of 20 inches (500 mm) of water per year (Long and Beale, 2001). Application of fertilizer is generally not needed in the first two years of Miscanthus establishment unless the soil is very lacking in important nutrients like phosphorus and potassium. The plant is able to acquire and conserve large quantities of nutrients; therefore, relatively low fertilizer applications are required to support growth once the crop is established.
4.3 Sweet Sorghum Sweet sorghum is a variety of sorghum, Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench. Several common names include sorghum (English), zuckerhirse (German), durra (Africa), Jowar (India), and bachanta (Ethiopia). It belongs to the grass family, Gramineae. The plant has a high concentration of soluble sugars in the sap or juice. This crop is attractive because of the easy accessibility of readily fermentable sugars combined with very high yields of green biomass. Most countries where sweet sorghum is cultivated have their own breeding programs aimed at the development of sweet sorghum varieties adapted to different cultivation conditions or for producing higher yields (Koppen et al., 2009). However, no overview is available on the number and description of common varieties. Sweet sorghum was introduced to the United States in the early part of the 17th century and has been extensively cultivated in the United States since the 1850s for use in sweeteners, primarily in the form of sorghum syrup. By the early 1900s, the United States produced 20 million gallons of sweet sorghum syrup annually. Currently, less than 1 million gallons are produced annually in the United States, mostly in Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Nebraska, North Carolina, Oklahoma, and Tennessee (Holmseth, 2008). Interest in sweet sorghum to produce biofuels is not a new concept. In the mid-1970s, during the first energy crisis, significant research was carried out to explore the development of sweet sorghum as a supply for biofuels and energy production (McBee et al., 1987). Research emphasis was focused on developing high-yielding varieties (Clark, 1981; Hallam et al., 2001). When worldwide oil prices dropped in the late 1980s, demand for alternative fuels was reduced and consequently efforts to develop high-yielding varieties were concomitantly
Miscanthus (t/ha) (±1 SE) 25.1 (2.5) 31.1 (3.2) 44.1 (2.6) 33.4 (2.8)
Switchgrass (t/ha) (±1 SE) a
Miscanthus (t/ha) (±1 SE)
13.7 (1.6) 19.1 (2.3) 29.9 (3.3) 20.9 (2.4)
Year
2004 2005 2006 Average
Source: Adapted from Heaton et al. (2008). a Signifies data not available.
7.8 (0.6) 7.7 (1.0) 7.8 (0.6)
Central
North
12.8 (1.2) 10.6 (1.3) 15.6 (2.6) 13.0 (1.1)
Switchgrass (t/ha) (±1 SE) 37.3 (3.0) 27.3 (5.7) 39.2 (2.9) 34.6 (2.6)
Miscanthus (t/ha) (±1 SE)
South
7.8 (0.6) 9.1 (2.6) 6.7 (1.1)
a
Switchgrass (t/ha) (±1 SE)
25.4(3.2) 25.8 (3.8) 37.7 (2.4) 29.6 (1.8)
Miscanthus (t/ha) (±1 SE)
State Average
12.8 (1.2) 7.9 (0.8) 15.6 (2.6) 10.4 (1.0)
Switchgrass (t/ha) (±1 SE)
20:50
Table 4.1. Comparison of mean harvestable dry matter after complete plant senescence from Miscanthus and switchgrass grown at three locations in the Midwest USA during 2004–2006 (n = 4).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010 Trim: 244mm×172mm
91
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
92
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
reduced. The renewed interest in bioenergy has increased research activities in sweet sorghum as a dedicated bioenergy crop for its fermentable juice as well as biomass for the production of cellulosic ethanol. Breeding and development programs for sweet sorghum germplasm and hybrids are being conducted at several universities in the United States (University of Kentucky, Purdue University, Louisiana State University, Texas A&M University, University of Florida and Oklahoma State University).
4.3.1
Biology of Sweet Sorghum
Sweet sorghum is typically an annual, but some cultivars are perennial. Propagation is accomplished through seeds. It is easily grown in areas that are too dry for maize. Sweet sorghum originated in Ethiopia, although today it has spread to other parts of Africa, India, Southeast Asia, the United States, and Europe, in semi-arid to humid climates. Plants grow in clumps and height of stalks ranges from 0.8 to 4 m (Figure 4.1). The thickness of stalks also varies, ranging between 1.25 cm and 3.75 cm. Prop roots regularly grow from the lower nodes. Seeds are produced by self-pollination from a panicle that emerges at the top of the plant and contains both the male and female inflorescences. Seeds are small, round, and may be white, yellow, brown, or red in color. Each panicle can produce up to 4,000 starch-containing grains. Sweet sorghum, a C4 crop that is very drought resistant, shows good adaptability to poor soil types, including saline soils. It has a very short vegetation period and thus is ideal for double cropping, either three crops of sweet sorghum or with an alternative crop (Koppen et al., 2009; Reddy et al., 2005; 2007). Even though sorghum is predominately self-pollinating, hybrids and crosses can be produced using male-sterile plants as the maternal parent. Sugar content in the juice increases with maturity and is low prior to seed development. In all varieties, the primary carbohydrate is sucrose, with variable amounts of reducing sugars and starch (Billa et al., 1997; Clark, 1981).
4.3.2
Production
Sweet sorghum is of interest as a dedicated agricultural energy crop because of its drought tolerance, relatively low input requirements, and ability to produce high yields under a wide range of environmental conditions (Bennett and Anex, 2009; Buxton et al., 1999; Grassi et al., 2004; Hunter, 1994; Hunter and Anderson, 1997; Miller and McBee, 1993; Rooney et al., 2007). These traits make sweet sorghum a potentially important feedstock for bioenergy production, mainly in regions where conditions are not favorable for growing starch-rich crops such as maize. The great advantage of sweet sorghum is that it can become dormant under adverse conditions and can resume growth after relatively severe drought, which has implications for crop management. Shoot removal lowers its capacity to endure drought. Early drought stops growth before floral initiation and the plant remains vegetative; it will resume leaf production and flower when conditions again become favorable for growth. Late drought stops leaf development but not floral initiation (Wilson and Whiteman, 1965; Whiteman and Wilson, 1965). Sweet sorghum can be grown in a wide variety of soil types, but yields are normally highest in deep, well-drained soils with good fertility. Sorghum grown in shallow soils or soils with very low organic matter may be more prone to drought stress. Although sorghum is more tolerant of drought stress than many other crops, ample moisture during the growing season is important for good yields of stalks and juice. Its deep root system can extract water from deep sources. Its optimal soil pH range lies between 5.0 and 8.5. Nitrogen usually has the greatest
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
93
impact on yields and will likely be needed on most soils, determined by soil type and rainfall. Lime may be applied to soils with a pH below 6.0 to correct soil acidity. A basic application of NPK may be required, and the crop usually responds well to supplementary applications of nitrogen during growth, although fallowed black clay may not need fertilizer. Rotation with a leguminous crop can provide a low-cost fertility build-up, for example, use of gum arabic (Acacia senegal). Asher and Cowie (1974) showed that the consequence of nitrogen deficiency on grain yield is greatest when the deficiency occurs early in the growing season. Low grain protein results when nitrogen deficiency occurs between anthesis and maturity. In some areas of California, accumulation of salt in the soil is sufficiently high to inhibit germination of seed, and young plants are injured. The tolerance of sweet sorghum to salt, however, appears to be relatively high after the plants become well established. Sweet sorghum is typically seeded in widely spaced rows (75–100 cm) using a corn planter. The ideal seeding rate for most sweet sorghum varieties is 3–4 seeds per foot of row with a final stand of 2–3 plants per foot of row. If plant populations are too high, the canes will be spindly and contain less juice than an equal tonnage of larger diameter canes. Currently, the only commercially viable harvest method for sweet sorghum is removing the entire crop with a forage harvester and transporting it to a mill/pretreatment/ethanol facility. Sweet sorghum has found limited use because of poor post-harvest storage characteristics and short harvest window in cooler climates. A study by Bennett and Anex (2009) indicates that fermentable carbohydrates can be produced at less expense from sweet sorghum than from corn grain. Further results published by same authors on costs associated with off-farm transportation, storage, or capital costs associated with milling and energy recovery equipment that are required to provide fermentable carbohydrates suitable for biological conversion re-evaluates sweet sorghum as a biocommodity feedstock. Hunter and Anderson (1997) indicate that the sugar produced in sweet sorghum has the potential to yield up to 8000 L of ethanol per hectare or about twice the ethanol yield potential of maize grain and 30% greater than the average Brazilian sugarcane productivity of 6000 L/ha (Luhnow and Samor, 2006). Field trials in 2009 tested field–based, mobile extractors, a method that could increase commercial viability and rural development (P. Nelson, personal communication). Roughly 4000 cultivars of sweet sorghum are distributed throughout the world (Grassi et al., 2004), providing a diverse genetic base from which to develop regionally specific, highly productive cultivars. In addition to producing large amounts of sugar-rich biomass, hybrids can be developed from crosses between grain-type seed parents and sweet-type pollen parents (Hunter and Anderson, 1997). The product of these crosses typically increases biomass yields and sugar content when compared to the original grain-type seed parents. Such hybrids can co-produce grain at levels approaching the yields of the grain-type seed parent (Miller and McBee, 1993). The co-produced, protein-rich grain can be consumed as food, animal feed, or converted to bioproducts like ethanol (Hong-Tu and Xiu-Ying, 1986; Hunter, 1994; Hunter and Anderson, 1997; Rajvanshi and Nimbkar, 2004). Proper variety selection will play a large role in the success of sweet sorghum production for ethanol. The ideal variety for a particular location should produce high yields with minimal inputs, have a high percentage of high quality and easily extractable juice, be disease and insect tolerant, and tolerate both drought and wet conditions. Undersander et al. (1990) showed that different varieties of sweet sorghum differ in terms of total biomass, brix (the dissolved sugar-to-water mass ratio of a liquid), fermentable carbohydrate, and ethanol yield (Table 4.2).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
94
Table 4.2. Comparison of different varieties of sweet sorghum and corn.
Total Dry Matter (tons/acre)
Varieties
Percentage Stalk
Stalk Moisture (%)
Brix
Fermentable Carbohydrate Yield (ton/acre)
Calculated Ethanol Yield (gal/acre)
Stalk Lodging (%)
—
—
332
15
1.19
161
13 98
Corn Dekalb 524
8.2
—
46
Cargill MorCane
8.6
40
76
Sorghum
Dale
8.9
10.0
70
74
12.3
3.00
408
9.2
41
73
10.0
1.25
171
8
Keller
10.1
70
72
13.4
2.96
403
97
M81E
96
DeKail FS5
10.0
66
73
12.7
2.83
385
NC+940
9.2
51
70
13.2
1.83
248
15
Northrup King 301
9.4
52
68
13.2
1.81
247
47
Northrup King 405
11.0
60
70
7.3
1.25
170
70
Northrup King 8361
13.1
68
73
7.4
1.96
267
93
Rox Orange
10.6
46
75
10.3
1.84
250
33
Source: Undersander et al. (1990).
4.3.3
Potential Yields
Sweet sorghum yields vary considerably depending on the varieties/hybrids that are used, the location (soil, water, climate, pests, and diseases), inputs, and production practices. When considering sweet sorghum for ethanol production, the most important yield components are biomass yield, juice yield, and sugar production per acre. The concentration of soluble sugars in sorghum ranges widely depending upon variety. Biomass yields of sweet sorghums are also variable ranging from 8 to 48 tons per acre and juice content from 65% to 80% of biomass. The combined sugar content of the juice varies between 9 and 15%. Sugar yields vary from 1.6 to 6.9 tons per acre. The bagasse (crushed stalks) and leaves make up the remainder of the wet biomass. The bagasse represents approximately two-thirds of the dry matter and leaves represent the remaining portion. Fermentation of the sugar in the juice yields 400–600 gallons of ethanol per acre (Vermerris et al., 2009). Potential yield per acre in the United States depends on the region where it is grown (Table 4.3). In warmer regions, sweet sorghum yield in terms of total biomass per year and gallons of ethanol per acre is higher when compared with colder regions.
4.3.4
Economic and Environmental Advantages of Sweet Sorghum
Sweet sorghum has generated interest as a feedstock for ethanol production since the 1970s. Juice from sweet sorghum can be converted to ethanol using currently available, conventional fermentation technology. The bagasse that remains after removal of the juice can be used for
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Table 4.3.
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
95
Production yield per acre in the United States.
Latitudes
Up to 32◦ N
25◦ N54◦ –26◦ N12◦
Average yield biomass (tons/acre) Ethanol production (gallons/ton) Harvests/year Total biomass in tons/year Gallons/acre
36 20 2 73 1,424
36 20 3 109 2,136
Source: Holmseth (2008).
Table 4.4.
Comparison of five ethanol feedstocks.
Parameter
Sugarcane
Forage Sorghum
Sweet Sorghum
Grain Sorghum
Maize
Crop duration (irrigated crops)
12 months
2 × 4 months
3 × 4 months
2 × 4 months
4 months
Total water requirement/ha/year
36,000 m3
8,000 m3
12,000 m3
11,000 m3
8,100 m3
17
8.7
5,950
3,211
Grain yield for food (tons/ha/year)
15
Grain yield for ethanol (tons/ha/year) Green stalk yield for ethanol (tons/ha/year)
80
120
240
Total ethanol output (litres/ha/year)
6,000
6,660
12,000
Source: AgriFuels Limited.
cellulosic ethanol production. Typically, sweet sorghum varieties have low grain yield, but recently varieties with more balanced grain/sugar production have been developed in India and China (Gnansounou et al., 2005; Hong-Tu and Xiu-Ying, 1986; Rajvanshi and Nimbkar, 2004; Reddy et al., 2005; 2007). These varieties can be used as a dual-purpose crop, whereby the grain is harvested for human or animal utilization, the juice for the production of first generation ethanol and cellulosic biomass for the production of second generation ethanol. Alternatively, these varieties can be used as a dedicated bioenergy crop, where both the sugars and the grain are used for ethanol production. Being a water-use efficient crop, sweet sorghum has the potential to be a good alternative feedstock for ethanol production. It is a multipurpose crop that can be cultivated for simultaneous production of food and feed ingredients, syrup, jaggery (human dessert-type treat), ethanol, fodder for animals, organic fertilizer, or for paper manufacturing. It can be grown in soil that is not ideal for other crops. Sweet sorghum is drought resistant and its growing period and water requirement are three times lower than that of sugarcane (Table 4.4). Sweet sorghum is better than sugarcane, forage sorghum, grain sorghum and maize in terms of water usage, grain yield for food, and grain yield and biomass for ethanol production (Table 4.4). It is best suited for ethanol production because of its higher reducing sugar content as compared to other
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
96
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
sources. These important traits, along with its suitability for mechanized crop production and seed propagation, make it a viable alternative source of raw material for ethanol production. The cost per liter of ethanol production from sweet sorghum grain and juice is lower than that from maize and sugarcane, respectively. The stillage from sweet sorghum is rich in micronutrients and minerals and can be used as fodder or for cogeneration of power. Sweet sorghum costs $1.74 to produce a gallon of ethanol, compared with $2.19 for sugarcane and $2.12 for corn (Koppen et al., 2009). It also compares well on energy balance, with 8 units of energy produced for every unit of energy invested in its cultivation and production, compared with 8.3 units for sugarcane and 1.8 for corn grain. Comparatively, only 0.8 unit of energy is produced from fossil fuel production for every unit invested (Koppen et al., 2009). Additionally, massive amounts of cellulosic ethanol could be produced from already existing sweet sorghum plantations, since the new ethanol manufacturing techniques would use only residual products. This means sweet sorghum could be adapted to biofuel use without requiring the massive carbon-releasing deforestation inextricably linked to other crops, such as cane sugar. Because the grain of sweet sorghum is not used in ethanol production, it does not have any impact on food prices and food security, in contrast to corn and sugar cane. “As an added benefit, dry land farmers in the tropics can get three sweet sorghum crops a year, versus only one for corn and sugarcane” (Table 4.4). It is also easier and cheaper to grow sweet sorghum than other biofuel crops. For example, it requires one-eighth the amount of water compared to sugarcane and about half that required to grow corn. Moreover, sorghum requires only half as much fertilizer as corn. Besides low water requirements, sorghum grows readily in saline or alkaline soils. It can withstand environmental stress and is inexpensive to cultivate. Ethanol produced from sweet sorghum, as from many renewable sources, is carbon neutral. The carbon dioxide fixed during the growing cycle offsets the carbon dioxide produced during crop production, processing, and ethanol utilization. And, since sweet sorghum thrives on marginal lands, the need to clear rainforests or use productive cropland is reduced.
4.3.5
Production Challenges
The costs associated with transportation of the crop to a mill will be the major limiting factor for where sweet sorghum can be profitably grown. Varieties that have higher sugar contents per ton of biomass will be more efficient to process and haul to the mill. Currently, there are a limited number of varieties for which seed is commercially available. If sweet sorghum is widely and rapidly adopted as an energy crop, seed may become difficult to obtain. Disease and insect problems may also limit yield potentials, suggesting that further research in this area is essential. Leaf diseases are the most troublesome for forage producers. These are anthracnose caused by Colletotrichum graminicola (which can be overcome by using resistant varieties) and leaf blight caused by Helminthosporium turcicum. Charcoal rot (Macrophomina phaseoli) causes plants to lodge badly. Grain may be affected by covered smut (Sphacelotheca sorghi) in which the seed is replaced by a sac of spores; fungicidal seed dressing before planting corrects this latter malady (Koppen et al., 2009. From a forage point of view, grasshoppers appear to be the worst pest, and feral pigs can damage the crop in some locations. Grain pests include the sorghum midge, Contarinia sorghicola, whose larvae feed on the developing seeds. Bird damage is also important with the weaver bird, Quelea quelea, causing major losses in Africa. Damage can be prevented by using awned varieties of sorghum, giving some hope of reducing losses. The high tannin
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
97
content of sweet sorghum seed is another deterrent, and early harvesting for silage avoids the main problems.
4.4 Switchgrass Switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) from the Poaceae/Gramineae is a perennial warm-season C4 grass indigenous to the Central and North American tall-grass prairie. It is also called prairie switchgrass, tall panic grass, water panicum, wild redtop, or thatchgrass. Switchgrass is an immense biomass producer and can reach heights of 3 m (10 feet) or more in wetter areas of the country. Switchgrass is found from central Mexico to Quebec and ecotypes have been identified in regions from the Atlantic coast to the eastern Rocky Mountain area. This grass was an important part of the North American tall-grass prairie and was adapted to other regions by European settlers. Perennial grasses like switchgrass have been widely used for forage purposes in their native state prior to being established as a crop. Since the 1940s, switchgrass has been used for conservation and warm-season pasture purposes in the Great Plains and Midwest states (Stubbendieck et al., 1992; Sanderson et al., 1996; Casler et al., 2004). The different ecotypes tolerate a large variety of growing conditions, from arid sites in the shortgrass prairie to brackish marshes and open woods (Gunderson et al., 2008). Two genetically and phenotypically distinct ecotypes of switchgrass are recognized: (1) the lowland ecotypes, vigorous, tall, thick-stemmed, and generally found in wetter, and more southern habitats and (2) the upland form, typically shorter, rhizomatous, and fine-stemmed, mainly found in drier mid- and northern latitudes (Casler et al., 2004; Hultquist et al., 1997; Sanderson et al., 1996). In general, ecotypical differences are related to local soil and climatic characteristics, with eastern and southern varieties adapted to higher moisture conditions, and western and northern varieties adapted to drier conditions.
4.4.1
Physiology
Switchgrass usually grows in large clumps that can be as much as 3–10 feet (0.9–3 m) tall. The stem cross section is round and reddish. The leaf blade is flat and sturdy and can measure as much as 30 inches (76.2 cm) long and 0.5 inch (1.3 cm) wide. The inconspicuous flowers have reddish-purple anthers. Flowers are borne in open 10-inch (25.4 cm) panicles and produce shiny seeds measuring around 1/8 inch (0.3 cm) long and shaped like teardrops. Switchgrass growing on Midwestern prairies and bottomland sites develops long rhizomes that grow horizontally and interlace to form a thick sod. In the southeast and on upland sites, switchgrass grows as a bunchgrass, with roots reaching depths of more than 10 feet (3.1 m). Switchgrass is a warm season perennial. The underground stems or rhizomes grow actively from late winter through mid-spring, but the top stays dormant until the soil warms up. Switchgrass typically turns a pale yellow in the fall, but some cultivars have been selected for color, such as “Shenandoah,” for its striking burgundy foliage or “Dallas Blues” and “Heavy Metal” exhibiting a bluish color. The “Rehbraun” cultivar has foliage of 3–4 feet (0.9–1.2 m) that turns red in the late summer and “Haense Herms” has very characteristic pink flowers and dark red autumn leaves. Switchgrass growth is optimum in deep sandy loams but is able to grow on a wide variety of soils; it tolerates moderate soil salinity and pH levels ranging from about 4.5 to 7.6. Switchgrass grows best in association with site-adapted mycorrhizal fungi, can be mowed or grazed down
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
98
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
in the winter, and does best when burned occasionally. Switchgrass can be found in dry, mesic and wet habitats, can tolerate temperatures as low as −34◦ C (−30◦ F), and will grow in partial shade. Most research on switchgrass fertility has focused on its use as a forage, and higher nitrogen applications can ensure high yields and better quality feed. Nonetheless, some researchers have considered nitrogen fertilizer recommendations for switchgrass to be higher than necessary for biomass production. Switchgrass has a remarkable ability to extract nitrogen from unfertilized soils, and as Parrish and Fike (2005) reported, fields were harvested for seven years with no fertilizer applications, and averaged only 53 pounds of nitrogen removed per year with one harvest per year. Clearly this crop has the genetic ability to survive and produce with minimal if not zero inputs (Duever, 2003; Vogel, 2004). Switchgrass should be harvested with conventional haying equipment from mid- to late October in most regions. Parrish and Fike (2005) demonstrated that a single harvest of switchgrass from late fall or early winter will result in the highest sustainable biomass yields.
4.4.2
Switchgrass Ecotypes
As switchgrass evolved across North America, different ecotypes as well as variations within an ecotype (reproductive phenology and winter-hardiness) have emerged with specific genetic and morphological characteristics that provide a good “fit” to a particular region. More southern cultivars tend to have longer season growth, flowering later in the season and allowing more time for vegetative growth and higher dry matter yield. Through natural selection, two major types have emerged: upland and lowland varieties. The upland types fare better in semi-arid climates and prefer drier soils. The lowland varieties are found in wetter and heavier soils, favoring lands where water availability is more reliable. Lowland varieties are genetically more able to produce dry matter than the upland cultivars. They have lower winter-hardiness, which may result in low winter-survival when grown too far north (Parrish and Fike, 2005). Productivity of upland ecotypes tends to exceed that of lowland ecotypes at very high latitudes and be reduced at southern locations, yet yields from upland strains adapted to relatively more southern locations may be sustained at low latitudes. Similarly, yield and winter survival declines at high latitude sites, especially for southern strains, whether of lowland (Casler et al., 2004) or upland morphology (Berdahla et al., 2005; Casler and Boe, 2003; Casler et al., 2004). Research studies have determined that in order to increase the survivability and productivity of a switchgrass, stand selection must be based on location. Parrish and Fike (2005) have found a “strong correlation between latitude of origin and yield,” and “the main factor determining adaptation of a cultivar was its latitude of origin, with southern cultivars having higher yield potentials as they are moved north.” Switchgrass varieties should therefore be chosen based upon both latitude of origin and ecotype. The cytotypic diversity existing in switchgrass explains the high degree of phenotypic and ecotypic variation. Lowland switchgrass ecotypes are predominately tetraploid, with a base chromosome number of 9 (diploid number 18), leading to 36 chromosomes (2n = 4x = 36). Upland ecotypes are octoploid (2n = 8x = 72) and less frequently, hexaploid (2n = 6x = 54) (Gunter et al., 1996; Hopkins et al., 1995).
4.4.3
Advantages
Several benefits associated with the perennial nature of switchgrass have been identified, such as less intensive agricultural management practices, reduced energy and agrochemical
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
99
consumption, and positive effects on soil and wildlife quality (Dunn et al., 1993). Parrish and Fike (2005) suggest that switchgrass can be grown on soils of moderate fertility without fertilizing, or with limited additions of fertilizer, and still maintain productivity (Rinehart, 2006). Growing switchgrass could have a positive effect on erosion control, contributing to soil stabilization on strip-mine spoils, sand dunes, dikes, and other critical areas. Hohenstein and Wright (1994) estimated a 95% reduction in soil erosion rates and a 90% reduction in pesticide use for herbaceous energy crops such as switchgrass relative to annual row crops like corn and soybean. It is also suitable for short windbreak plantings in truck farm fields (Fike et al., 2006), and it has been shown to improve water and soil quality by reducing carbon emissions through carbon sequestration (Bouton et al., 1998; Duffy and Nanhou, 2002). Switchgrass has an extensive and deep root system that, added to the large amount of above-ground biomass, can increase carbon storage. It can be easily integrated into existing farming operations because conventional equipment for seeding, crop management, and harvesting can be used (Vogel et al., 2002). Thanks to its heavy growth during late spring and early summer, switchgrass provides good warm-season pasture and high quality hay for livestock. Its benefits can be extended to the wildlife surrounding it, by providing nesting and fall and winter cover for pheasants, quail, and rabbits, while its seeds provide food for birds. It is resistant to heavy snow (particularly “Shelter” and “Kanlow” cultivars) and is useful on shooting preserves (USDA NRCS Plant Fact Sheet, 2001). Switchgrass has also been tested for the ability to remediate contaminated soils. Entry and Watrud (1998) tested soils contaminated with cesium-137 and strontium-90 using Alamo switchgrass. These elements are radionuclides released during nuclear testing, nuclear reactor accidents, and weapons production. The authors reported a 36% removal of cesium and a 44% removal of strontium over a 5-month period.
4.4.4
Disadvantages
Switchgrass seeds can be very dormant, and a dormancy-breaking step is necessary in the planting process for the majority of seeds to germinate. This is thought to be one reason so many switchgrass and other native warm-season plantings fail. Dormancy-breaking can be achieved by stratification (humidity and low temperatures), drill planting in winter, or early spring or “after-ripening,” which practices storing seeds in a warm environment for several years. The establishment of switchgrass is faced with competition from weeds. Planting switchgrass into cool soils can be problematic; cool season weeds can germinate first and choke out switchgrass seedlings when the soil warms (Vogel, 2004). Perennial forbs and warm-season grasses such as crabgrass germinate in cooler soils and can have a severe negative impact on switchgrass stand establishment. This native grass may also become weedy or invasive in some regions or habitats and may displace desirable vegetation if not properly managed (NRCS, 2001). Switchgrass is generally planted as a monoculture, either as a forage crop or a feedstock. Monocultural production is thought to be problematic by many farmers and more generally by advocates of a more sustainable agriculture because they are not as resilient as polycultures. Biodiversity provides a better use of soil and water resources as well as food and cover for numerous beneficial organisms, from microbes to small mammals. A monoculture of switchgrass will never compare to the benefits obtained with a naturally diverse prairie. Nonetheless, monocultures of switchgrass can have significant benefits, especially for fields suffering from erosion and depleted soil organic matter (Rinehart, 2006; Vogel, 2004), as well as for consistent yield for fuel production.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
100
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 4.5. Example of biomass yields from several switchgrass cultivars in the USA (Sanderson and Adler, 2008). Yields are expressed in tons dry biomass per ha. State Cultivar Cave-in-Rock Dacotah Forestburg Shawnee Sunburst Trailblazer Alamo Pathfinder Shelter Kanlow Blackwell NJ50 Summer BoMaster Performer
ND
SD
WI
4.9 5.4
3.8 2.9 3.9 5.1 4.6 4.6
14.3 7.4 9.4 11.4 11.5 11.0
5.6 7.4 6.9
IA
Mid-West
PA
Mid-Atlantic
TX
AL
9.3
9.2
8.2–8.6
10.8–15.4
2.6
6.9 8.8 6.8 7.9 12.1
8.8 15.2–16.3
15.3
12.9–23.0
10.3–13.6 15.0–16.4
11.0
11.6–18.2
NC
12.4
8.5 6.7–12.4 8.3
14.2
11.0 12.1
9.1 12.6 5.5 15.8 12.8
Another potential disadvantage of growing switchgrass is that it is slow to establish and it can take 2–3 years for productive stands to develop (Sanderson and Adler, 2008).
4.4.5
Yields
Unlike other crops such as corn, where yield data have been available for a many years, data for switchgrass as a biomass crop are rather limited and are based mainly on smallplot research. A search across the literature provides switchgrass yield estimates that vary considerably, from less than 1 ton/ha to almost 40 ton/ha. Nonetheless, the most frequently observed yield class across all ecotypes, cultivars, soils, and management practices is between 10 and 12 ton/ha (Table 4.5). This great variability in yields is explained by the wide range of ecotypes as well as the strong interactions between genotypes and the environment. Cultivar × environment interactions must be taken into account in biomass evaluations of switchgrass cultivars (Casler and Boe, 2003; Fuentes and Taliaferro, 2002). Gunderson et al. (2008) observed higher yields on average within the lowland cultivars, 13.11 ton/ha versus 9.30 ton/ha in upland cultivars with Alamo and Kanlow being the highest yielding cultivars among the lowland varieties and Cave-in-Rock from the upland ecotype (McLaughlin et al., 1999). With newer varieties of switchgrass, yields in excess of 20 ton/ha have been reported for test plots. For example, Sanderson et al. (1996) reported 15–20 ton/ha in field trials in Texas, and Thomason et al. (2004) reported yields in excess of 30 ton/ha from field work in central Oklahoma. These yields are relatively high and the site-specificity of the test plots needs to be taken into account. In a larger scale study, Parrish and Fike (2005) reported average biomass yield in a 10-year study of 14.2 ton/ha. Schmer et al. (2008) reported on-farm yields ranging from 5.2 to 11.1 ton/ha for field trials in the United States. Being a perennial, switchgrass grown for biomass can be harvested only once per year, in the winter. Under good management, a producer can expect high yields over much of the country. According to the Agricultural Research Service, growers can expect from 7 to 16
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
101
tons an acre (17.3–39.5 ton/ha) in the Southeast and the western Corn Belt, to 1–4 tons (2.5– 10 ton/ha) in the northern plains (Comis, 2006).
4.4.6
Switchgrass as a Bioenergy Crop
Switchgrass has been chosen as one of the best crops for biofuels in the United States. This crop not only grows well under a wide range of conditions, but it also produces high yields over much of the country (Comis, 2006). Traditionally, switchgrass has been managed primarily as a hay crop and bred mainly to improve its value as a forage crop for livestock. It has been typically bred for high nutrient content and high leaf to stem ratio. However, the traits necessary and relevant for biofuels crops are different. High cellulose and low ash content are important for energy conversion and low contamination of combustion systems (McLaughlin et al., 1999). From the late 1980s to early 1990s, the Department of Energy initiated research on plant species with high yield quality and quantity for biofuels. They assessed 34 species of plants with trials being conducted on a wide range of soil types in 31 different sites spread over seven states. Switchgrass became a major focus of research for bioenergy production among some other grasses and legumes. In their trials, they found switchgrass to have the potential for high yields, and they were interested in its deep rooting characteristics, the potential value in carbon sequestration and the expected positive environmental impact (Wright, 2007). Many subsequent studies have focused on switchgrass as a bioenergy crop. Ethanol yields obtained from a mature bioenergy crop production system were calculated by Morrow et al. (Morrow et al., 2006) to be between 330 and 380 L of ethanol per ton of dry switchgrass. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory’s theorical yield calculator provides similar estimates: (http://www1.eere.energy.gov/biomass/ethanol yield calculator.html). Parrish and Fike (2005) obtained similar results by calculating the theoretical ethanol production from switchgrass yielding 15 ton/ha to be between 5000 and 6000 L/ha. A model was developed by David Bransby at Auburn University to estimate delivery costs of switchgrass. After 6 years, they produced up to 15 tons of dry biomass per acre (37 ton/ha), with an average of 11.5 tons per acre (28.4 ton/ha) (Bransby, 2005). With a production of roughly 100 gallons of ethanol per ton of feedstock and the yields obtained in this model, there will be enough to make 1,150 gallons of ethanol per acre each year. US cellulosic fuel production costs are now estimated at more than $2.25 per gallon, compared with $1.03–1.65 per gallon for corn ethanol (Coyle, 2007; Goldemberg, 2007). Switchgrass feedstock costs per gallon of ethanol produced would need to be low enough to at least compete with corn ethanol to make cellulosic ethanol production a cost-effective fuel. However, the market for this crop is still immature and work is currently under development to better understand the costs of conversion as well as the cost to develop processing plants and marketing outlets (Rinehart, 2006).
4.5
Conclusions and Future Prospects
Growing crops specifically for energy is a concept developed in the past few decades with the hope of developing renewable energy sources that will mitigate the effect of soaring energy costs, reduce the global carbon footprint, and reduce dependency on fossil fuel. Miscanthus possesses many qualities of an ideal biomass crop and has a great potential as a dedicated energy
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
102
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
40 Portugal
30 20 10 0 1
5
7
Yield (t DM ha−1)
40 Early
13
Denmark
Late
30 20 10 0 1
5
7
13
Genotype
Figure 4.2. The effect of climate and genotype on yield. Genotype 1, M. giganteus; 5, M. sacchariflorus; 7 & 10, M. sinensis hybrids; 11&13 , M. sinensis collections. (Adapted from Clfton-Brown et al. (2001).)
crop. Tapping into Miscanthus as a source of renewable energy is a relatively new concept with much room for improvement. The yield reported from field trials in Europe and N. America was achieved with an unimproved Miscanthus. Therefore, yield would be expected to increase dramatically and the cost of production expected to fall with breeding improvement efforts. The two major concerns with cultivating Miscanthus have been the high cost of establishment and currently the narrow genetic base. Future development can address these concerns through crop improvement and technology advancement. Efforts have already been undertaken by the European Miscanthus Improvement (EMI) project (www.biomatnet.org/secure/Fair/F659.htm) and research institutes across N. America to broaden the genetic base of Miscanthus and maximize the productivity and adaptive range of the crop through traditional breeding as well as modern genetic engineering. The efforts of the EMI project have demonstrated that different hybrids of Miscanthus sinensis can be found for a wide range of climatic conditions in Europe. One particular hybrid combines winter hardiness with high biomass potential (Figure 4.2), a combination that will result in improved crop quality through delayed harvest without significant loss in yield (Clifton-Brown et al., 2001b). Improved farming equipment and farming practices tailored specifically to working with Miscanthus rhizomes and plants could reduce loss of harvested material, time, and labor costs. The development of new machinery to process rhizomes (that include lifting, cleaning, splitting, sorting, and boxing) and carry out precision rhizome planting has made commercial rhizome multiplication farming and commercial production of Miscanthus feasible. Improvement in the crop together with improvement in farming technology and processing of this biomass crop into fuel would undoubtedly make
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
103
Sweet sorghum
Grain
Sugar juice
Biomass (bagasse & leaves) Pretreatment & cellulase treatment
Fermentation
Methane
Ethanol
Waste water treatment
Figure 4.3. Sweet sorghum energy model.
Miscanthus a very attractive crop to the biofuel industries and at the same time helping the country meets its bioenergy goals. High-biomass sweet sorghum will play an important role as the United States moves toward alternative energy sources, particularly biomass, to supply transportation and electrical energy to the country. Compared to fossil fuels, first- and second-generation ethanol from sweet sorghum holds considerable potential to help lower fossil energy use and reduce greenhouse gas emissions since most expenditures are more than compensated by credits for bioethanol and the respective by-products (Figure 4.3). Even with the use of grain as food, there is significant potential for saving fossil energy and greenhouse gas emissions with the help of first-generation ethanol produced from juice. This makes sweet sorghum an ideal crop for reducing the competition between food and fuel. If both grains and juice are used as food, energy and greenhouse gas balances are neutral. This means that under-maximized food production in the form of grains and sugar, all expenditures occurring during food production can be compensated by ethanol production from bagasse. Hence, limited negative environmental impacts occur regarding fossil energy savings and greenhouse effects. Therefore, from a climate protection point of view, efforts should be put on optimized crop varieties and cultivation methods aiming at higher total yields. Switchgrass has been considered a model for bioenergy crops mainly due to its perennial growth habit, the compatibility of its farming practices with conventional crops and the high value in improving soil conservation and quality. More importantly, switchgrass’ potential for high yields has made this warm season prairie grass of national interest in the biofuels strategy. Trials across North America have identified three distinctive high-yielding cultivars, the lowland varieties “Alamo” and “Kanlow” and “Cave-in-Rock” for the upper Midwest. Yields for switchgrass can be as high as 40 ton/ha, but the best adapted cultivars have averaged approximately 16 Mg/ha in research plots. Even though several constrains have been identified in the establishment of switchgrass, the benefits associated with the culture of this remarkably adaptable grass make it ideal as an energy crop. The US Department of Energy believes crops grown for biofuels such as switchgrass could reduce North America’s
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
104
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
dependence on foreign oil as well as carbon dioxide emissions. Nonetheless, further research is fundamental to increase the overall production potential of this perennial grass. Studies on boosting its hardiness and yields will be necessary to improve switchgrass as a cultivated, production crop.
References Asher, C. J. & Cowie, A. M. 1974. Grain sorghum: high yield, satisfactory protein content of both? Proceedingsof Agronomy Society of New Zealand, 4, 79–82. Bennett, A. S. & Anex, R. P. 2009. Production, transportation and milling costs of sweet sorghum as a feedstock for centralized bioethanol production in the upper Midwest. Bioresource Technology, 100, 1595–1607. Berdahla, J., Franka, A., Krupinskya, J., Carrb, P., Hansona, J. & Johnsona, H. 2005. Biomass yield, phenology, and survival of diverse switchgrass cultivars and experimental strains in western North Dakota. Agronomy Journal, 97, 549–555. Billa, E., Koullas, D. P., Monties, B. & Koukios, E. G. 1997. Structure and composition of sweet sorghum stalk components. Industrial Crops and Products, 6, 297–302. Bouton, J., Bransby, D., Conger, B., McLaughlin, S., Ocumpaugh, W., Parrish, D., Taliaferro, C., Vogel, K. & Wullschleger, S. 1998. Developing switchgrass as a bioenergy crop. Presented at Fourth National New Crops Symposium, Phoenix, AZ. Bransby, D. 2005. Switchgrass Profile [Online]. Oak Ridge National Laboratory: Bioenergy Feedstock Development Program. Available: http://bioenergy.ornl.gov/papers/ misc/switchgrass-profile.html. (accessed November 30, 2010) Bullard, M. J., Nixon, P., Kilpatrickm, J., Heath, M. & Speller, C. 1995. Principles of weed control in Miscanthus spp. under contrasting field conditions. Presented at British Crop Portection Conference, Brighton, UK. Buxton, D. R., Anderson, I. C. & Hallam, A. 1999. Performance of sweet and forage sorghum grown continuously, double-cropped with winter rye, or in rotation with soybean and maize. Agronomy Journal, 91, 93–101. Casler, M. D. & Boe, A. R. 2003. Cultivar × environment interactions in switchgrass. Crop Science, 43, 2226–2233. Casler, M. D., Vogel, K. P., Taliaferro, C. M. & Wynia, R. L. 2004. Latitudinal adaptation of switchgrass populations. Crop Science, 44, 293–303. Christian, D. G. & Haase, E. 2001. Agronomy of Miscanthus. In: Jones, M. B. & Walsh, M. (eds.) Miscanthus for Energy and Fibre. London: James & James Ltd. Clark, J. 1981. Inheritance of fermentable carbohydrates in stems of sorghum bicolor Moench, PhD Dissertation, Texas A&M University. Clifton-Brown, J., Lewandowski, I., Stampfl, P. & Jones, M. B. 2002. Modelled biomass production potential of Miscanthus and actual harvestable yield as influenced by harvest time. Presented at 12th European Biomass Conference and Exhibition, Amsterdam. Clifton-Brown, J., Long, S. P. & Jorgensen, U. 2001a. Miscanthus Productivity. London: James & James Ltd. Clifton-Brown, J. C., Lewandowski, I., Andersson, B., Basch, G., Christian, D. G., Kjeldsen, J. B., Jorgensen, U., Mortensen, J. V., Riche, A. B., Schwarz, K.-U., Tayebi, K. & Teixeira, F. 2001b. Performance of 15 Miscanthus genotypes at five sites in Europe. Agronomy Journal, 93, 1013–1019.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
105
Comis, D. 2006. Switching to Switchgrass Makes Sense. USDA-ARS. Available: http://www.ars.usda.gov/is/AR/archive/jul06/grass0706.htm?pf=1. Coyle, W. 2007. The Future of Biofuels. Amber Waves, 5. Duever, L. C. 2003. Floridata: Panicum virgatum [Online]. Available: http://www.floridata. com/ref/p/pani vir.cfm (accessed October 25,2010). Duffy, M. & Nanhou, V. 2002. Costs of producing switchgrass for biomass in Southern Iowa. In: Janick, J. & Whipkey, A. (eds.) Trends in New Crops and New Uses. Alexandria, VA: ASHS Press. Dunn, C., Stearns, F., Guntenspergen, G. R. & Sharpe, D. M. 1993. Ecological benefits of the conservation reserve program. Conservation Biology, 7, 132–139. El Bassam, N. & Huisman, W. 2001. Harvesting and storage of Miscanthus. In: Jones, M. B. & Walsh, M. (eds.) Miscanthus for energy and fibre. London: James & James Ltd. Entry, J. A. & Watrud, L. S. 1998. Potential remediation of 137Cs and 90 Sr contaminated soil by accumulation in Alamo switchgrass. Water, Air, & Soil Pollution, 104, 339–352. Fike, J. H., Parrish, D. J., Wolf, D. D., Balasko, J. A., Green, J. J. T., Rasnake, M. & Reynolds, J. H. 2006. Long-term yield potential of switchgrass-for-biofuel systems. Biomass and Bioenergy, 30, 198–206. Fuentes, R. D. & Taliaferro, C. M. 2002. Biomass yield stability of switchgrass cultivars. In: Janick, J. & Whipkey, A. (eds.) Trends in New Crops and Uses. Alexandria, VA: ASHS Press. Gnansounou, E., Dauriat, A. & Wyman, C. E. 2005. Refining sweet sorghum to ethanol and sugar: Economic trade-offs in the context of North China. Bioresource Technology, 96, 985–1002. Goldemberg, J. 2007. Ethanol for a sustainable energy future. Science, 315, 808–810. Grassi, G., Tondi, G. & Helm, P. 2004. Small-Sized Commercial Bioenergy Technologies as an Instument of Rural Development. Biomass and Agriculture: Sustainability, Markets and Policies. Paris: OECD Publication Service. Greef, J. M. & Deuter, M. 1993. Syntaxonomy of Miscanthus × giganteus. Berlin, Allemagne: Blackwell. Gunderson, C. A., Davis, E., Jager, Y., West, T. O., Perlack, R. D., Brandt, C. C., Wullschleger, S. D., Baskaran, L. M., Wilkerson, E. & Downing, M. E. 2008. Exploring Potential U. S. Switchgrass Production for Lignocellulosic Ethanol. Technical Report ORNL/TM2008/103. Gunter, L. E., Tuskan, G. & Wullschleger, S. 1996. Diversity among populations of switchgrass based on RAPD markers. Crop Science, 36, 1017–1022. Hallam, A., Anderson, I. C. & Buxton, D. R. 2001. Comparative economic analysis of perennial, annual, and intercrops for biomass production. Biomass and Bioenergy, 21, 407– 424. Heaton, E., Voigt, T. & Long, S. P. 2004. A quantitative review comparing the yields of two candidate C4 perennial biomass crops in relation to nitrogen, temperature and water. Biomass and Bioenergy, 27, 21–30. Heaton, E. A., Dohleman, F. G. & Long, S. P. 2008. Meeting US biofuel goals with less land: The potential of Miscanthus. Global Change Biology, 14, 2000–2014. Himken, M., Lammel, J., Neukirchen, D., Czypionka-Krause, U. & Olfs, H. W. 1997. Cultivation of Miscanthus under West European conditions: Seasonal changes in dry matter production, nutrient uptake and remobilization. Plant and Soil, 189, 117–126. Hohenstein, W. & Wright, L. 1994. Biomass energy production in the United States: An overview. Biomass and Bioenergy, 6, 161–173.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
106
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Holmseth, T. C. 2008. Sweet harvest. Ethanol Producer Magazine. Hong-Tu, M. & Xiu-Ying, H. 1986. Breeding for sweet sorghum with high grain yield and sweet stalks. Sorghum Newsletter, 29, 2–3. Hopkins, A. A., Vogel, K. P., Moore, K. J., Johnson, K. D. & Carlson, I. T. 1995. Genotype effects and genotype by environment interactions for traits of elite switchgrass populations. Crop Science, 35, 125–132. Hultquist, S. J., Vogel, K. P., Lee, D. J., Arumuganathan, K. & Kaeppler, S. 1997. DNA content and chloroplast DNA polymorphisms among switchgrasses from remnant midwestern prairies. Crop Science, 37, 595–598. Hunter, E. L. 1994. Development, sugar yield, and ethanol potential of sweet sorghum, Masters Thesis, Iowa State University. Hunter, E. L. & Anderson, I. C. 1997. Sweet sorghum. Horticulture Reviews, 21, 73–104. Jones, M. B. & Walsh, M. 2001. Miscanthus for Energy and Fibre, London: James & James Ltd. Koppen, S., Reinhardt, G. & Gartner, S. 2009. Assessment of Energy and Greenhouse Gas Inventories of Sweet Sorghum for First and Second-Generation Bioethanol. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Lewandowski, I., Clifton-Brown, J. C., Scurlock, J. M. O. & Huisman, W. 2000. Miscanthus: European experience with a novel energy crop. Biomass and Bioenergy, 19, 209–227. Linde-Laursen, I. 1993. Cytogenetic analysis of Miscanthus “Giganteus,” an interspecific hybrid. Hereditas, 119, 297–300. Long, S. P. & Beale, C. V. 2001. Resource capture by Miscanthus. In: Jones, M. B. & Walsh, M. (eds.) Miscanthus for Energy and Fibre. London: James & James Ltd. Luhnow, D. & Samor, G. 2006. It wears off energy imports. Wall Street Journal. Mcbee, G. G., Miller, F. R., Dominy, R. E. & Monk, R. L. 1987. Quality of sorghum biomass for methanogenesis. In: Klass, D. (ed.) Energy from Biomass and Waste X. London: Elsevier. McLaughlin, S., Bouton, J., Bransby, D., Conger, B. & Al, E. 1999. Developing switchgrass as a bioenergy crop. In: Janick, J. (ed.) Perspectives on New Crops and New Uses. Alexandria, VA: ASHS Press. Miller, F. R. & Mcbee, G. G. 1993. Genetics and management of physiological systems of sorghum for biomass production. Biomass & Bioenergy, 5, 41–49. Monteith, J. L. 1978. Reassessment of maximum growth rates for C3 and C4 crops. Experimental Agriculture, 14, 1–5. Morrow, W. R., Griffin, W. M. & Matthews, H. S. 2006. Modeling switchgrass derived cellulosic ethanol distribution in the United States. Environmental Science & Technology, 40, 2877–2886. Naidu, S. L. & Long, S. P. 2004. Potential mechanisms of low-temperature tolerance of C4 photosynthesis in Miscanthus × giganteus: An in vivo analysis. Planta, 220, 145–155. Naidu, S. L., Moose, S. P., Al-Shoaibi, A. K., Raines, C. A. & Long, S. P. 2003. Cold tolerance of C4 photosynthesis in Miscanthus × giganteus: Adaptation in Amounts and Sequence of C4 Photosynthetic Enzymes. Plant Physiol., 132, 1688–1697. Nixon, P., Boocock, H. & Bullard, M. J. 2001. An evaluation of planting options for Miscanthus. Aspects of Applied Biology, 65, 123–130. Nixon, P. & Bullard, M. J. 2003. Optimisation of Miscanthus Harvesting and Storage Stategies [Online]. Available: http://www.berr.gov.uk/files/file14955.pdf (accessed October 25, 2010). NRCS. 2001. Plant Fact Sheet [Online]. USDA. Available: http://plants. usda.gov/factsheet/pdf/fs pavi2.pdf (accessed October 25, 2010).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
4
Dedicated Herbaceous Energy Crops
107
Parrish, D. J. & Fike, J. H. 2005. The biology and agronomy of switchgrass for biofuels. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 24, 423–459. Perlack, R. D., Wright, L. L., Turhollow, A. F., Graham, R. L., Stokes, B. J. & Erbach, D. C. 2005. Biomass as feedstock for a bioenergy and bioproducts industry: The technical feasibility of a billion-ton annual supply. Technical Report A357634. Rajvanshi, A. K. & Nimbkar, N. 2004. Sweet sorghum R&D at the Nimbkar Agricultural Research Institute. Presented at First European Seminar on Sorghum for Energy and Industry, Toulouse, France, April 1–3. Reddy, B. V. S., Kumar, A. A. & Ramesh, S. 2007. Sweet sorghum: A water saving bioenergy crop. Presented at Linkage Between Energy and Water Management for Agriculture in Developing Countries, ICRISAT, Hyperabad, India. Reddy, B. V. S., Ramesh, S., Reddy, P. S., Ramaiah, B., Salimath, P. & Kachapur, R. 2005. Sweet sorghum—A potential alternate raw material for bio-ethanol and bio-energy. Journal of SAT Agricultural Research, 1, 8. Rinehart, L. 2006. Switchgrass as a Bioenergy Crop [Online]. ATTRA National Sustainable Agriculture Information Service. Available: www.attra.ncat.org/attra-pub/switchgrass.html (accessed October 25, 2010). Rooney, W. L., Blumenthal, J., Bean, B. & Mullet, J. E. 2007. Designing sorghum as a dedicated bioenergy feedstock. Biofuels Bioproducts & Biorefining (Biofpr), 1, 147–157. Sanderson, M. A. & Adler, P. R. 2008. Perennial forages as second-generation bioenergy crops. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 9, 768–788. Sanderson, M. A., Reed, R. L., McLaughlin, S. B., Wullschleger, S. D., Conger, B. V., Parrish, D. J., Wolf, D. D., Taliaferro, C., Hopkins, A. A., Ocumpaugh, W. R., Hussey, M. A., Read, J. C. & Tischler, C. R. 1996. Switchgrass as a sustainable bioenergy crop. Bioresource Technology, 56, 83–93. Schmer, M. R., Vogel, K. P., Mitchell, R. B. & Perrin, R. K. 2008. Net energy of cellulosic ethanol from switchgrass. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105, 464– 469. Stubbendieck, J. L., Hatch, S. L., Butterfield, C. H. & Jansen, B. P. 1992. North American Range Plants. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press. Thomason, E. W., Raun, R. W., Johnson, V. G., Taliaferro, M. C., Freeman, W. K., Wynn, J. K., & Mullen W. R. 2004. Switchgrass Response to Harvest Frequency and Time and Rate of Applied Nitrogen. Philadelphia, NJ: ETATS-UNIS, Taylor & Francis. Undersander, D. J., Lueschen, W. E., Smith, L. H., Kaminski, A. R., Doll, J. D., Kelling, K. A. & Oplinger, E. S. 1990. Sorghum—For Syrup. University of Wisconsin Cooperative or Extension Service. Vermerris, W., Rainbolt, C., Wright, D. & Newman, Y. 2009. Production of biofuel crops in florida: Sweet sorghum. Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences, University of Florida. Vogel, K. 2004. Switchgrass. In: Moser, L. E., Sollenberger, L. & Burson, B. (eds.) WarmSeason Grasses. Madison WI: ASA-CSSA-SSSA Monograph. Vogel, K. P., Brejda, J. J., Walters, D. T. & Buxton, D. R. 2002. Switchgrass biomass production in the Midwest USA: Harvest and nitrogen management. Agronomy Journal, 94, 413– 420. Walsh, M. & McCarthy, S. 1998. Miscanthus Handbook. In: 10th European Bioenergy Conference. Wurzburg, Germany: CARMEN Publishers; pp. 1071–1074. Whiteman, P. C. & Wilson, G. L. 1965. Effects of water stress on the reproductive developement of Surghum vulgare. University of Queensland Department of Botany Papers, University of Queensland.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c04 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
108
20:50
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Wilson, G. L. & Whiteman, P. C. 1965. The Influence of Shoot Removal on Drought Survival of Sorghums. University of Queensland Deptartment of Botany Papers. St. Lucia: University of Queensland. Wright, L. L. 2007. Historical perspective on how and why switchgrass was selected as a “model” high-potential energy crop. Presented at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Chapter 5
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock David J. Webster
5.1 Introduction This chapter discusses municipal solid waste (MSW) as a source of cellulosic feedstock for production of biofuels. Along with forest wood, solid waste in the United States represents a major potential source of cellulosic feedstock that has today a mature collection infrastructure, cost structure, and regulatory framework. These attributes suggest that solid waste should play an increasingly important role as a primary cellulosic feedstock. MSW has valuable potential as a cellulosic feedstock and has been evaluated by state agencies and private concerns for its use in producing ethanol. Several second-generation biofuel technology applications have targeted MSW as a cellulosic feedstock. MSW differs from wood and agricultural biomass since it is a heterogeneous feedstock that varies by region, particular markets, and by time (seasonal variations and periodic collection practices). MSW also represents an available feedstock that does not require considering the impact of expanded use of agricultural land and resources for production of feedstock. Abundant public material on solid waste management, market issues, and characterization are available. Many materials were prepared by or for regulatory and public health agencies. However, a gap in information remains about potential use, pretreatment, and processing for biofuels production of MSW as a cellulosic feedstock. This chapter focuses on information published by public agencies such as the Office of Solid Waste in the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) and selected regional references. Additional research and investigation, as it applies to specific project or process development, will be required by parties involved in such activities. Such parties will likely use other references targeted to their project area and will conduct, mostly likely, new investigations of the MSW stream being considered for a particular project. Detailed planning would benefit from waste composition studies that quantify variations in composition and quantities in a particular market area. Plant Biomass Conversion, First Edition. Edited by Elizabeth E. Hood, Peter Nelson and Randall Powell. C 2011 John Wiley & Sons Inc.
109
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
110
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
5.2 Definitions MSW does not have a rigid definition. However, most characterizations describe MSW as comprising a wide variety of material and products generated for disposal by households, commercial establishments, and institutions. MSW includes paper and packaging, green waste (e.g., yard trimmings), bulky goods (e.g., furniture), clothing, food waste, and durable goods (i.e., appliances). Household hazardous waste (HHW) is often included as a fraction of the overall MSW stream. HHW typically comprises small amounts of batteries, paint, solvents, petroleum products, pesticides, and other material. Even with HHW present, MSW is not regulated as hazardous waste. Generally excluded from MSW are construction and demolition debris, industrial nonhazardous waste and sludge, agricultural wastes, and municipal wastewater sludge. This chapter is limited to considering MSW in the United States. Examples have been selected that represent proven or promising approaches to addressing the complexities inherent in using MSW as a cellulosic feedstock, but do not include use of methane from landfill gas and anaerobic digestion of MSW. USEPA publishes periodic reports on character and source of MSW in the United States. Municipal Solid Waste in the United States: 2007 Facts and Figures (EPA530-R-08-010) is a primary source of data on solid waste generation (USEPA, 2008).
5.2.1
Second-Generation Conversion Technologies for Biofuels
Conversion technologies are divided into two broad categories by the USDOE Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) Biomass Program: biochemical and thermochemical. Biochemical processes break down cellulosic feedstocks into sugars using enzymes or chemicals. The sugars are then fermented into ethanol. Thermochemical processes use heat and pressure to breakdown biomass (cellulosic and noncellulosic fractions) into intermediate compounds. The intermediate compounds are then converted to fuel or chemicals using catalysts, heat, and pressure (http://www1.eere.energy.gov/biomass/biochemical conversion.html). The Biomass Program provides funding and support for “integrated biorefineries.” Biorefineries use biomass feedstock for production of fuel, chemicals, heat, and power. Integrated biorefineries may use combinations of feedstocks and conversion technologies to target production of value-added products in addition to ethanol. Value-added products can include chemicals, lignin, waxes, and heat and power (http://www1.eere.energy.gov/biomass/integrated biorefineries.html). The Biomass Program is currently supporting several demonstration projects for individual processes and for integrated biorefineries. Bluefire Renewables and Enerkem are two companies supported by the Program that intends to use solid waste as a feedstock and other companies are actively engaged in pilot and demonstration projects designed for solid waste conversion into biofuels and other products.
5.3 Disposal Infrastructure and Transfer Stations Infrastructure used in waste management in the United States may be divided into collection, transportation, recovery (for recycling), and disposal. These practices vary according to
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
111
regional and subregional infrastructure, laws, regulation, and local practice. Generalities can be made at high levels, but local practice driven by applicable law and regulation varies widely across the country. Within the United States, three major handling and disposal systems are used to treat solid waste: recycling/recovery, landfills, and incineration. For the United States as a whole, recovery of materials in MSW is now estimated at 33.4% by the USEPA. Essentially, all remaining material is disposed of in landfills and incinerators. Landfills accept 54.0% of all solid waste either by discharging at the landfill or through transfer stations. Incineration—almost always with some form of energy recovery—accounts for 12.6% of all solid waste disposal. Biofuel production from MSW will likely focus on the portion of waste currently delivered to landfills. The gross amount of MSW available for processing into second-generation biofuel is the fraction of total generated waste that remains after recycling and recovery, delivery to other sources under long-term commitments (such as incinerator/waste-to-energy (WTEs) facilities), and diversion to other facilities (such as compost or biogas production plants). The convertible fraction is further reduced by reduction of water, primarily by drying, since it does not contribute to biofuel production. As the disposal sites for solid waste move farther away from urban areas, transfer stations have experienced an increasingly important role in handling waste and in the cost structure for solid waste management. Transfer stations are employed to consolidate solid waste from collection vehicles and serve to improve logistical efficiency and reduce transportation cost (Figure 5.1). Ownership of waste disposal sites and transfer stations are split between the private sector and the public sector. A profile of the spilt in ownership of waste handling and disposal systems is summarized in Table 5.1 (Repa, 2001).
Figure 5.1.
Transfer trucks queuing for disposal.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
112
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 5.1.
Public and private sector ownership of waste facilities (about 2001).
MSW landfills C&D landfills Transfer stations Incineration/WTE MRFs
Private Sector
Public Sector
Percent Publicly Owned (%)
1,100 200 900 70 2,300
2,100 400 2,200 70 1,200
66 67 71 50 34
Rounded numbers. WTE: waste-to-energy; MRFs: material recovery facilities (include mixed waste and source-separated material MRFs) C&D: Construction and demolition waste.
5.3.1
Collection Practices
Collection by municipality or private hauler (sometimes called subscription service) of solid waste is the primary mechanism used to gather waste from the curbside and deliver it to a disposal site or a transfer station. Self-haul is largely limited to rural areas. State and local laws primarily govern collection practice. Like disposal sites and transfer stations, control of solid waste collection is split between the private and public sectors. Municipal control here includes collection by municipally owned and operated vehicles and municipal crews, municipal contracts or franchise arrangements with private collection companies, or a combination of these mechanisms. Repa (2001) estimated the split between public and private organizations in the waste industry using a comprehensive industry survey conducted by R.W. Beck Inc. Approximately 27,000 organizations in the United States are involved in the solid waste industry. Public entities comprised 56% of this group. When municipalities or local authorities control and regulate solid waste services, contracts to collection companies often extend for five years or more. Thus, municipal control of solid waste provides an opportunity for long-term commitments for the MSW feedstock stream. Smaller urban and most rural areas of the United States rely on private collection companies to collect solid waste from households and businesses. The terms of these subscription contracts vary widely but may be characterized as short-term (12 months, for example) agreements between a household and a private company for periodic collection services. Short-term contracts pose a business challenge for a long-term reliable supply of MSW as a feedstock. A much smaller portion of solid waste is handled directly by the residential or commercial waste generator, and reliable figures are lacking. This portion of the market will be omitted from this discussion since it does not appear to comprise a significant portion.
5.3.2
Cost Parameters
MSW is unique as a potential cellulosic feedstock since generators pay to dispose of their waste. Thus, MSW is a “negative cost” feedstock. Like handling any bulk material, costs are incurred in each step of the supply chain—collection, transfer, hauling, and disposal. The range of disposal cost at landfills and WTE plants across the nation vary widely. Simmons et al. (2006) noted in their annual The State of Garbage report that landfill tipping fees range from $18 (Oklahoma) to $98 (Vermont) per ton and WTE tipping fees range from $40 (North Carolina) to $98 (Washington) per ton based on values supplied during their study. These figures are limited to the gate fees charged at the disposal facilities. Local curbside collection,
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
113
transfer (if needed), and hauling to disposal sites are additional. Also, many jurisdictions have incentives to offset the cost of recycling that are either a user surcharge or an additional tax levy associated with the overall cost of solid waste management.
5.4 Waste Generation The USEPA reported that the United States generated 254 million (wet) tons of MSW in 2007 (USEPA, 2008). This waste stream includes residential, commercial, and institutional generators. This tonnage corresponds to a per capita generation rate of 4.62 pounds per person per day (365 days per year). Depending upon local and regional conditions, the portion of residential waste (by weight) ranges from 55% to 65% (USEPA, 2008). Commercial and institutional generators create the remaining portion of between 35% and 45%. Comparison to annual collection of forest-derived biomass is useful for context. Hoekman (2009) discusses the United States biofuel potential and challenges for various feedstocks. He notes that the United States currently utilizes approximately 142 million dry tons per year of forest-derived biomass for fuel, pulp-and-paper, and lumber products. Significantly, Hoekman also points to projections from the US government that indicate 368 million dry tons per year of forest-derived biomass may eventually be available for biofuel production. Using the USEPA (2008) average of 54.0% of total generated waste being landfilled, approximately 137 million wet tons of MSW is potentially available annually for biofuel production (http://www.epa.gov/solidwaste/nonhaz/municipal/pubs/msw07-rpt.pdf). Assuming about one-third of this waste material is water, approximately 92 million dry tons of MSW is available for conversion, or about two-thirds of the forest biomass currently used in the United States.
5.5 Waste Characterization 5.5.1
Composition of Generated MSW Prior to Disposal or Processing
The composition of MSW needs to be examined to understand its potential as a cellulosic feedstock. For second-generation biochemical processes, the primary component in MSW for the production yield of ethanol is the carbohydrate content of solid waste. Sugars derived from the carbohydrates for subsequent fermentation to ethanol are obtained by hydrolyzing carbohydrates by enzymatic or other means, such as dilute or concentrated acid. Thermochemical processes do not rely on carbohydrate content for value-added processing, but such processes will still need to understand waste composition to design for the various material components of MSW. Both process approaches require an understanding of moisture and heavy metals in the waste feedstock stream. Paper and organics in waste are composed of carbohydrates, water, and lignin. Carbohydrates are composed of cellulose and hemicellulose. Cellulose is a stable polymer and a crystalline material made of glucose sugars. The cellulose polymer requires pretreatment to break apart the crystalline structure so glucose can be accessible to the hydrolyzing catalyst. Hemicellulose is a more easily decomposed polymer made of mixed sugars (primarily xylose, glucose, mannose) and organic acids. Hemicellulose is water soluble and noncrystalline. It almost always is the minor portion of the carbohydrate fraction in paper and organic waste.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
114
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Figure 5.2.
MSW in WTE bunker.
Lignin is a phenolic compound that is not convertible to sugar and, in biochemical processes, does not contribute to ethanol production yield. Indeed, in many second-generation biofuels processes, lignin must be specifically separated to facilitate conversion of carbohydrates to sugars. However, like wood and agricultural feedstocks in many second-generation biochemical processes aimed at biofuel production, lignin separated from the MSW feedstock provides a solid fuel that is used to produce thermal power at the processing facility. Gasification processes use the combined syngas streams created from the gasified lignin and carbohydrates in waste feedstock. A majority of the materials included in MSW may be considered good sources of cellulosic feedstock. The fractions of MSW that contain cellulose may be divided into four main groups. The largest component of MSW generated by weight (and prior to recovery efforts) is paper and cardboard. Paper and paperboard represent 32.7% of MSW. The second largest component of MSW is yard trimmings at 12.8%. The third largest fraction of MSW includes food waste amounting to 12.5%. Wood is 5.6% of MSW across the United States. These four material categories represent over half of all MSW generation (63.6%) and are considered good material for cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin although each will have contaminants and moisture that must be addressed in any process arrangement (Figures 5.2 and 5.3). The remaining fraction of MSW (36.4% by weight) comprises largely material that will contribute little to cellulosic fuels and chemicals. These materials categories include glass, metals, plastics, rubber, leather and textiles, and miscellaneous wastes. The USEPA recently reported the amount of waste generated and recovered nationally as shown in Table 5.2.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
115
Figure 5.3. Green waste prior to shredding.
5.5.2
Landfilled Waste Compared to Waste Generation
Biofuel production likely will utilize only the portion of waste destined for landfill. Two illustrations help differentiate between gross waste generation and the portion of overall generated waste sent to landfill. The case study by Chester (2009) on the potential ethanol production from exclusively landfilled MSW in California uses an annual estimate that shows about 22 million tons of wet MSW is useable for ethanol production. This is about one-half of the 44 million tons of landfilled waste he obtained from various studies of MSW in the state. After adjusting for moisture content, Chester used about 16 million dry tons per year of convertible solids to calculate a production potential of between 1 and 1.5 billion gallons using California landfilled waste. Likewise, a 2003 study in Pennsylvania conducted by R.W. Beck Inc. illustrates the variation between total waste generation in the USEPA report and waste destined for landfill in Pennsylvania (Table 5.3) (http://www.dep.state.pa.us/dep/deputate/airwaste/wm/recycle/waste comp/1 Intro.pdf). Differences in definitions and survey approaches make direct comparisons unwieldy for this discussion, but one can readily discern notable differences in waste fractions destined for recovery versus gross generation. Note that the standard deviation values more than twice the average reflect a nonnormal distributions of waste. The nonnormal distribution indicates that material comprising certain waste categories is delivered inconsistently and, when it is delivered, it arrives in large amounts.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
116
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 5.2.
Generation and recovery of materials in MSW in the United States (2007). Weight Generated (MMTPY)
Material
Weight Recovered (MMTPY)
Recovery as Percentage of Generation
Paper and paperboard Glass Metals Steel Aluminum Other nonferrous metalsa Total metals
83.0 13.6
45.2 3.22
54.5% 23.7%
15.6 3.35 1.76 20.8
5.28 0.73 1.22 7.23
33.8% 21.8% 69.3% 34.8%
Plastics Rubber and leather Textiles Wood Other materials Total materials in products
30.7 7.48 11.9 14.2 4.43 186.1
2.09 1.10 1.90 1.32 1.16 63.3
6.8% 14.7% 15.9% 9.3% 26.2% 34.0%
31.7 32.6 3.75 68.0
0.81 20.9 Neg. 21.7
2.6% 64.1% Neg. 31.9%
85.0
33.4%
Other wastes Food, otherb Yard trimmings Miscellaneous inorganic wastes Total other wastes Total municipal solid waste
254.1
Includes waste from residential, commercial, and institutional sources. Details may not add to totals due to rounding. MMTPY, million metric tons per year; Neg., less than 5,000 tons or 0.05%. a Includes lead from lead-acid batteries. b Includes recovery of other MSW organics for composting.
Table 5.3.
Summary of landfilled MSW composition in Pennsylvania.
MSW Component
Average Composition of Disposed Material (wt %)
Standard Deviation
Paper and cardboard Plastic Glass Metals Organics Inorganics
33.3% 11.3% 3.0% 5.4% 34.2% 12.7%
20.0% 9.2% 5.3% 8.6% 21.7% 23.2%
Readers should refer to the Beck report for detailed explanation of sampling methods and statistics.
5.5.3
Water in MSW
Water content is a key concern when evaluating conversion potential of cellulosic waste and economics of conversion approaches. In many second-generation cellulosic biofuels facilities,
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
117
Table 5.4. Moisture content in California MSW components. Component of Disposed MSW Biomass components of MSW Paper/cardboard Food Leaves and grass Other organics Construction and demolition lumber Prunings, trimmings, branches, and stumps Nonbiomass carbon component compounds All nonfilm plastic Film plastic Textiles
Moisture (wt %)
10 70 60 4 12 40 0.2 0.2 10
control of moisture in the processed feedstock is an important consideration for reaction and yield efficiencies and value-added processing. Water in the waste is not convertible to biofuel and often must be removed by drying to be acceptable to the conversion process. Drying MSW requires energy and adds to operating cost. Emission controls for dryers may be needed, adding to capital cost. Moisture content in MSW varies by the material within the waste. The University of California Davis reported on the moisture content in the primary material components of solid waste, summarized in Table 5.4 (Williams et al., 2003). Williams et al. (2003) report that approximately 30% of the biomass component of California waste is water. Similarly, Chester (2009) reports an aggregate water component of 32% for landfilled California waste. Although these data provide initial guidance numbers, variations in moisture content of MSW will occur seasonally in concert with changes in waste composition. For example, yard waste has moisture contents higher than average and one may reasonably expect to receive most of this material in spring, summer, and autumn. Also, periods of wet weather will temporarily increase moisture contents in solid waste especially if collection is weekly instead of semiweekly.
5.5.4
Heavy Metals in MSW
Heavy metal concentrations in raw MSW feedstock will contribute to environmental impacts requiring control measures and also will impact the quality of output from intermediate streams and waste outputs from cellulosic production processes. The presence of trace heavy metals may also influence selection of construction materials. For example, if highly acidic process conditions are used to mobilize the heavy metal fraction in the waste feedstock, then the materials of construction must accommodate this harsh environment. Metals are known to concentrate as the waste feedstock undergoes pretreatment and processing, accumulating in intermediate or recycle streams. Each second-generation biofuel conversion process using MSW must address the fate of heavy metals in the process and the process waste streams, whether liquid, solid, or vapor. Frontend classification systems (including presorting) and temporal (hourly, daily, and seasonal) variations in waste composition will influence downstream metal concentrations. Studies that generalize the metal contents in MSW are scarce and sometimes old and represent the values
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
118
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 5.5.
Heavy metal contents in MSW to illustrate variability (ppm dry solids basis).
Aluminum Antimony Arsenic Cadmium Chromium Copper Mercury Nickel Tin Zinc
TVA: TN-1a
TVA: MNb
TVA: NJc
Law and Gordon (1979)d
12,504 Not reported 0.4 1 47 32 0.1 13 4 755
1,960 <10 <10 <10 50 30 <10 <10 <10 140
20,400 <10 <10 <10 340 330 <10 <10 40 330
5,400–12,000 Not reported Not reported 2–22 20–100 80–900 0.66–1.9 9–90 Not reported 200—2,500
Values reported as <10 signify that amount of metal was less than the detection limit of the analytical equipment used in the test. a TVA: TN-1 is reported from a RDF obtained (about 1990) from Humbolt, TN, using the Lundell processing system. b TVA: MN is reported from RDF obtained (about 1990) from Eden Prairie, MN, using the Buhler-Miag processing system. c TVA: NJ is reported from a RDF sample obtained (about 1990) from K Plant in New Jersey, but the processing system was not known to TVA. d Law and Gordon (1979) show data obtained from the Bureau of Mines report published in 1979.
for a particular waste shed. When heavy metals require an environmental assessment, or pose a significant challenge to a given process technology, an investigation of heavy metal contents may be warranted. In evaluating the environmental considerations of the use of refuse-derived fuel (RDF) for cellulosic fuels and chemicals, the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) obtained RDF from different facilities and analyzed metal concentrations (Broder et al., 1993). In their work, TVA observed that metals contained in MSW feedstock are soluble in low-pH conditions and precipitate out of solution in high-pH conditions. Indeed, pretreatment or process conditions in this acidic environment provide a practical approach to addressing the control and removal of heavy metals from MSW feedstock. TVA observed notable interbatch variations in metal content (Broder et al., 1993). This observation is inferred by older studies conducted by the now-closed Bureau of Mines division of the US Department of Interior (Law and Gordon, 1979). Selected test results are presented in Table 5.5 to illustrate the range and variation in metal concentrations from three facilities from which TVA obtained samples. For comparison, the range of results summarized by Law and Gordon (1979) are presented beside those selected from the TVA work. Variations in metal contents have also been reported within individual components of the solid waste stream. Savage (1994) used information gathered in 1988 from Broward County, Florida. Illustrative selections of his data are presented in Tables 5.6 and 5.7. Clearly, the higher concentration of metals in noncellulosic fractions of MSW suggests that this fraction should be carefully considered when calculating the total metal content in a given waste stream when it is part of the overall feedstock stream. Variations in the metal contents between residential and industrial waste deliveries have been observed and reported in a study by the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN,
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
Table 5.6.
Zinc Cadmium Nickel Chromium Copper Arsenic Mercury Antimony Tin
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
119
Metal contents in cellulosic fraction of MSW (ppm dry basis). Mixed Paper
Newsprint
Corrugated
Plastic
Yard Waste
Food Waste
Wood
Other Organic
96.0 0.3 5.0 6.0 30.0 0.5 0.05 11.1 87.0
59.0 0.3 2.0 2.0 15.0 0.4 0.01 13.5 7.0
36.0 0.3 0.2 9.0 33.0 0.8 0.02 5.1 21.0
73.0 0.4 2.5 43.0 364.0 2.2 0.02 10.1 151.0
52.0 0.3 4.0 6.0 71.0 0.4 0.05 7.2 176.0
25.0 0.2 0.6 1.0 5.0 0.3 0.01 4.3 55.0
36.0 3.2 3.0 55.0 5.0 0.5 0.01 3.3 84.0
525.0 4.3 9.0 67.0 68.0 2.1 5.45 175.0 58.0
Table 5.7.
Metal content in noncellulosic materials in MSW (ppm dry basis). Metal Fraction in Broward County, FL, MSW Stream
Trace Metal Element
Ferrous Metals
Aluminum
Glass
Zinc Cadmium Nickel Chromium Copper Arsenic Mercury Antimony Tin
442.0 0.7 206.0 303.0 180.0 9.9 0.10 0.3 670.0
193.0 1.7 103.0 46.0 640.0 6.0 0.10 0.3 12.0
5.0 0.3 9.0 7.0 7.0 0.2 0.01 1.2 593.0
or the German acronym BAFU) in 2006 for the Thurgau municipal waste incinerator plant in Weinfelden, Switzerland (Morf, 2006). FOEN notes that this was the first Swiss study to examine differences between these two generators even after two decades of periodic waste studies associated with incineration infrastructure. The English summary of the report stated that heavy metals (Sn, Cu, Zn, Sb, and Ar) concentrations in industrial waste were almost uniformly higher compared to domestic waste. Only mercury was found to be about the same in the two waste streams. FOEN indicated that the findings were preliminary and that conclusions on the origins of these differences were not possible.
5.6 Preparing MSW for Conversion Processing—Mixed Waste Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs) Use of MSW as a cellulosic feedstock depends upon the ability of individual process arrangements to accept the waste, prepare it for conversion, and process the desirable materials in MSW into streams that produce value-added fuels or chemicals. As may be seen in the characterization of MSW, the heterogeneity of MSW poses a significant challenge to its use as a cellulosic feedstock.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
120
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Preparation of the solid waste stream is the first step in accessing the cellulosic fraction of solid waste. Preparation involves removal of unwanted material (as much as practical) so that a cellulose-rich stream can be used in the conversion process. Some thermochemical processes claim that little or no preparation is required. Without verifying or disputing these assertions, one can reach the reasonable and practical conclusion that some preparation will be required based on the wide range of component materials in waste streams, some of which pose safety concerns or are unacceptable to the downstream conversion process. One proven approach to preparing a mixed solid waste stream involves design and construction of a mixed waste material recovery facility (MRF). Mixed waste MRFs—sometimes referred to as a mixed waste processing (MWP) plants or, unfortunately, “dirty” MRFs—may be designed to process the typical heterogeneous waste streams from residential, institutional, and commercial generators. However, experience in existing facilities indicates that special handling of some wastes is required and some contamination will remain in the exit stream of the mixed waste MRF even after presorting and preparation. Thus, the process technology that follows the MRF must be able to safely and efficiently address any contaminants that will remain. The design goal is to provide sufficient flexibility to handle the waste stream components while still producing an exit stream suitable for the downstream conversion process. Traditional recyclables can be diverted as part of the MWP, but the market value of these materials is relatively minor compared to higher value-added biofuels. A distinction should be made between mixed waste MRFs and “clean” MRFs. Although some of the mechanical and manual operations are similar between the two systems, a clean MRF is designed to sort source-separated recyclables delivered separately from solid waste. Clean MRFs are designed to produce high-quality, saleable recyclable materials such as plastics, ferrous metals, aluminum, glass, corrugated cardboard, and mixed paper. Contamination must be low to meet market requirements. Volatility of prices in the recycling markets is legendary. Generally, clean MRF facilities require a subsidy in some form—permanent or periodic—to achieve break-even or profitable operations. In the United States, source-separated MRFs far outnumber mixed waste MRFs. Mixed waste MRFs include a tipping floor presort followed by mechanical and manual operations. Although each MRF design is unique according to the desired outputs, the primary components of these systems involve waste screening and sizing, density classification, separation of ferrous and nonferrous metals, and manual sorting stations aligned along conveyors. The final steps likely will include shredding to the desired size and drying if required for the conversion process. Capital costs of MWP facilities are difficult to generalize. So-called standard designs are not available. Each facility is designed to process a given waste stream and the design also will consider local variations in waste generation, deliveries, facility capacity, labor markets, and regulations. Chester (2009) provides a range of capital costs for large capacity MWP facilities for his case study on MSW-derived ethanol in California. He suggests a capital cost range of $26,000–58,000 per short ton capacity per day (2008 dollars). For his work, Chester applied the lower value under the assumption that the MWP facilities in his analysis constituted an expansion to existing transfer stations. This author’s industry knowledge indicates that “greenfield” facilities are more likely to reach the upper limit of Chester’s range for processing facilities near the 1,000-ton per day capacity level. Operating costs, like capital costs, also depend upon several variables, including the degree of automated and manual sorting. Chester (2009) uses a value of $36 per ton, and this author’s experience suggests a range of $30–40 per ton as indicative costs.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
5.6.1
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
121
Presorting
Tipping floor presorting is the first preparation step and, normally, is a requirement of the operating permit of the facility. Over and above the desire to produce a cellulose-rich feedstock, presorting is an important health, safety, and operational step. After solid waste is discharged from the collection or transfer vehicle, waste is spread across the floor for inspection. Floor personnel and mobile equipment operators visually identify bulky items that are unsuitable either for feedstock or are unacceptable to the downstream MRF operation and processing system. Examples include mattresses, furniture, carpets, tires, appliances, rope and cable, and other troublesome components. Personnel are required to look for possible hazardous materials, including large batteries, paint, drums, solvent cans, gas cylinders, asbestos-containing material, and medical waste. Finally, separated loads of green waste, unrecyclable paper and cardboard, and other cellulose-rich streams may be segregated for easier handling or direct bypass to dryers and shredders located immediately downstream from the MRF operation (Figure 5.4). One should not be surprised to learn that the tipping floor presort would not identify all unacceptable components of the waste stream. Nevertheless, trained and experienced staff can accomplish the presort with good results. Studies are available on the effect of presorting on the heavy metal component of waste in MSW incinerators. In a report prepared for the USEPA, SAIC qualitatively describes the benefits of presorting for removal of aluminum, ferrous metal, batteries, glass, and grit (SAIC
Figure 5.4.
Bulky waste offloading and presorting.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
122
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
and SCS Engineers, 1995). They indicate that removal of these waste stream components reduced by 40% air emissions of lead, cadmium, mercury, beryllium, selenium, zinc, and arsenic. While these reductions should not be used as absolute values, they do highlight the benefit of presorting to remove significant portions of metals prior to downstream processing. After presort, only broad descriptions of individual sorting operations are possible. Each MRF design targets the particular requirements of the downstream process. Mixed waste MRFs in operation today are used to either reduce the amount of waste going to landfill or to provide a feedstock to a WTE plant. No mixed waste MRFs have been constructed specifically for cellulose conversion plants. Finally, the MRF design team or owner typically regards as proprietary their selection and configuration of equipment.
5.6.2
Mechanical Sorting Operations
Screening and size sorting are accomplished by disk screens or rotating trommels. Generally, three sizes are targeted—“overs” are larger than about 4–6 inches, “middlings” are between about 2–4 inches, or 2 inches and the lower size of “overs,” and “unders” are the fraction smaller that the “middlings” (Figure 5.5). Density sorting is accomplished to separate light materials from heavier material and is usually accomplished with air classifiers or air knives. In air classifiers, heavy and large fractions fall for collection on conveyors, while lighter material is pulled out with a controlled air stream. Parallel high-velocity sheet flows of air in air knives help separate light material with small differences in density. MWP for second-generation conversion processes may not
Figure 5.5.
Trommel screening.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
Figure 5.6.
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
123
Manual sorting.
utilize density separation to the same extent as processing facilities designed for recyclable material recovery since the removal of cellulose-rich materials may not be the operational objective of the system. Magnets and eddy current separators are used to separate ferrous metal and nonferrous metal, primarily aluminum. Electromagnets are positioned above or below a conveyor that moves waste, and ferrous metals are pulled out and delivered to designated containers for recycling. Eddy current separators use spinning magnetic rotors configured to repel (as opposed to attract) nonferrous metals away from the waste stream moving on a conveyor. Nonmetallic fractions remain on the conveyor for further processing.
5.6.3
Manual Sorting Operations
Manual sorting generally follows the mechanical sorting portion of the MRF. Personnel are positioned at sort stations aligned along conveyor belts. Material from the “overs” and “middling” trommel streams pass by the sort stations. Sorters remove recyclables and unacceptable waste at designated stations. These materials are dropped into containers below the sorting stations. Depending upon the design and throughput capacity, a mixed waste MRF may have a dozen or more sorters per shift (Figure 5.6).
5.6.4
Recovery Rates of the MRF System
Mixed waste MRFs are designed to accomplish removal of portions of the waste stream. Since MSW is heterogeneous, it follows that a processing facility design does not per se produce a uniform feedstock. Designers can configure the processing facility equipment to accomplish defined operations for material sizing and removal. Manual sorting can be tailored to enhance the output to reach the desired target feedstock. In the end, however, the processing facility will have variations in feedstock composition. Table 5.8 shows some typical removal efficiencies based on this author’s experience and general industry metrics.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
124
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 5.8.
Typical removal efficiencies in a mixed waste MRF (by weight).
Component of Waste Stream
Removal Efficiencies (by weight)
Aluminum Ferrous metals Nonferrous metals Glass Plastic Waste wood (separated for chipping) Bulky waste (removed for offsite disposal)
60–75% 80–90% 50–75% Up to 85% Up to 50% 75–90% Up to 5%
Table 5.9.
Weight percent of sugars in MSW. Weight Percent Dry Basis
Raw RDF pellet Raw newsprint Cardboard Recycled paper
Glucose
Mannose
Xylose
Lignin/Ash
72.1 62.2 75.8 62.2
9.9 9.9 7.0 6.2
13.7 9.7 12.0 9.5
4.3 18.2 5.2 22.1
5.7 Cellulosic Content of MSW TVA reported results from their research in waste-derived cellulose conversion using RDF derived from MSW (Broder et al., 1993). TVA utilized a glucose–mannose–xylose (GMX) spectrophotometric procedure that employs concentrated sulfuric acid to hydrolyze the biodegradable fraction into sugars (Table 5.9). The sugars were calculated using their differing absorption in a spectrophotometer. The samples were dried and ground to pass a 40-mesh sieve screen and obvious pieces of glass, plastic, and metal were manually removed. The available cellulose and hemicellulose for conversion depends upon processing technologies such as dilute acid, concentrated acid, or enzymatic hydrolysis (either using yeast or co-fermentation enzymes).
5.7.1
Glucose and Ethanol Yields from MSW
The chemical composition of the feedstock determines the maximum theoretical yield of ethanol (WSEO, 1991). When losses in yield due to conversion inefficiencies are ignored, the maximum theoretical yield from one pound of cellulose is shown in Table 5.10. In conversion processes, typical yields in cellulose to glucose may be expected to be about 60–70%. Fermentation of glucose to ethanol has an efficiency of about 90–95%. These benchmarks are useful and practical when considering overall ethanol production potential using solid waste. For example, an MSW-to-ethanol process provider and project development firm, Masada Resource Group LLC, provided summary data obtained from pilot plant operations that summarize the glucose yield of waste sorted at a mixed waste MRF. Pilot plant trials were accomplished using vendor equipment. Masada reported an average of about 71% glucose yield for multiple samples (Masada Resource Group, LLC, Birmingham, AL).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
Table 5.10. cellulose.
Table 5.11.
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
125
Ethanol yield from 1 pound of
Compound
Conversions
Cellulose Glucose Ethanol Ethanol
1.00 lb 1.11 lb 0.086 gal 0.567 lb
Variations in sugar yield from various sources of MSW.
Theoretical Yield (gal/wet ton) Generated MSW Paper Wood Yard Food
44.9 4.7 4.4 —
Dilute Acid Hydrolysis Yield (gal/wet ton)
Concentrated Acid Hydrolysis Yield (gal/wet ton)
22.2 2.0 2.2 1.5
33.5 2.9 3.2 2.3
Total yield per ton
>54.1
27.9
41.9
Landfilled MSW Paper Wood Yard Food Total yield per ton
35.1 6.5 2.7
17.3 2.8 1.3 2.0 23.4
26.2 4.0 2.0 3.0 35.2
— >44.4
Sakamoto (2004) highlights the variations in yield estimates for MSW. He calculated theoretical and estimated yields of dilute and concentrated acid hydrolysis conversion processes by looking at waste composition (generated vs. landfilled) and estimated production values. Selected data presented in Table 5.11 illustrates the variations in yield. Note that TVA (Broder et al., 1993) indicated a yield using dilute acid hydrolysis of 50.4 gallons of ethanol per dry ton of RDF waste. Chester (2006), as noted earlier, presented an estimate of ethanol production using landfilled waste in California. He estimated that 22 million tons of landfilled waste would produce 1–1.5 billion gallons of ethanol. This corresponds to a yield range of 45–68 gallons of ethanol per wet ton of landfilled waste.
5.8 Framing the Potential The 2007 Energy Independence and Security Act (EISA) established the annual production goal by 2022 of 36 billion gallons of renewable fuel, meaning fuels derived from nonfossil sources. A significant portion of the renewable fuel production is to be advanced biofuels coming from nonedible plants and wastes. Advanced biofuels must also achieve at least a 50%
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
126
Table 5.12.
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
MSW production and ethanol yield.
Generated MSW Landfilled MSW Theoretical ethanol yield Lower ethanol yield Higher ethanol estimate
Annual Production
Use
254 million wet tons 137 million wet tons 7,400 million gallons 3,430 million gallons 6,170 million gallons
54% landfilled 54 gal/wet ton 25 gal/wet ton 45 gal/wet ton
reduction in life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions (Hoekman, 2009). (For perspective, corn ethanol contributed 6.7 billion gallons in 2007, or about 4% of United States total gasoline usage.) The range of waste compositions, conversion process efficiency, waste industry dynamics, and market issues necessitates a dedicated examination to arrive at a comprehensive estimate of ethanol production using MSW feedstock. Such an examination is beyond the scope of this chapter. Nevertheless, reasonable assumptions can be made to acquire a sense of the production capacity potential. Table 5.12 provides an indicative range of ethanol production using rounded values similar to those presented earlier in this chapter. Clearly, with potential ethanol production from MSW ranging between 3.43 and 6.17 billion gallons annually, MSW is a desirable cellulosic feedstock that helps meet the EISA goal. Solid waste represents significant potential as a second-generation cellulosic feedstock. Much remains to be accomplished to demonstrate process technologies capable of safely utilizing this complex feedstock, but the potential is clear. Existing infrastructure and logistics, economic incentives, and ubiquitous cellulosic feedstock combine to make solid was an attractive source of domestic biofuels.
References Broder, J., Henson, L. & Barrier, J. 1993. Municipal Solid Waste and Waste Cellulosics Conversion to Fuels and Chemicals, April 1990–September 1992 Final Report. Muscle Shoals, AL: Tennessee Valley Authority, Biotechnical Research Department. Chester, M. & Martin, E. 2009. Cellulosic ethanol from municipal solid waste: A case study in the economic, energy and greenhouse gas impacts in California. Environmental Science and Technology, 43, 5184. Hoekman, S. 2009. Biofuels in the US—Challenges and opportunities. Renewable Energy, 34, 14–22. Law, S. & Gordon, G. 1979. Sources of metal in municipal incinerator emissions. Environmental Science and Technology, 13, 432–438. Morf, L. 2006. Chemishc Zusammensetzung verbannter Siedlungsabfalle Untersuchungen im Einzugsgebiet der KVA Thurgau Umwelt-Wissen Nr 0602, Bundesamt fur Umwelt, Bern. 104 S. http://www.bafu.admin.ch/publikationen/publikation/00019/index.html?lang=de. Repa, E. 2001. The US Solid Waste Industry: How Big is it? Available: http://wasteage.com/ mag/waste us solid waste/. SAIC and SCS Engineers. 1995. Analysis of the Potential Effects of Toxics on Municipal Solid Waste Management Options. Cincinnati, OH: EPA Office of Research and Development Risk Reduction Laboratory.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
5
Municipal Solid Waste as a Biomass Feedstock
127
Sakamoto, O. 2004. The Financial Feasibility Analysis of Municipal Solid Waste the Ethanol Conversion. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University. Available:http://ageconsearch. umn.edu/bitstream/11179/1/pb04sa01.pdf Savage, G. 1994. The history and utility of waste characterization studies. MSW Management, May/June. Simmons, P., Goldstien, N., Kaufman, S., et al. (2006). The State of Garbage Biocycle April 2006 p. 40. http://www.envortus.com/documents/BiocyleStateofGarbageArticle06.pdf (accessed March 15, 2009). USEPA. 2008. Municipal Solid Waste in the United States: 2007 Facts and Figures (EPA530R-08-010). Washington, DC. Washington State Energy Office (WSEO). 1991. Mixed waste paper to ethanol fuel. Olympia, WA: WSEO. Williams, R., Jenkins, B. & Nguyen, D. 2003. Solid Waste Conversion: A Review and Database of Current and Emerging Technologies. Final Report, University of California—Davis.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c05 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:51
Trim: 244mm×172mm
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Chapter 6
Water Sustainability in Biomass Cropping Systems Jennifer L. Bouldin and Rodney E. Wright
6.1 Introduction As independence from fossil fuels increases in modern societies, the drive for energy will cause a shift in land-use patterns towards bioenergy crops. Consequently, either cropping patterns will change to bioenergy crops or uncultivated land will be brought into production. Newly cultivated land may include marginal land (not typically used for production due to anticipated low crop production) and more fertile areas not previously under crop management (i.e., forested, in Federal Reserve programs, or other production such as pasturing). First-generation bioenergy crops are typically food crops used in the production of either ethanol or biodiesel through fermentation or extraction processes. The use of food crops as energy has raised issues as they compete with the nutritional supply for an increasing global human population. However, these crops currently hold the most promise in fulfilling energy needs as technology exists to produce fuels in the form of ethanol or biodiesel from these crops. Second and subsequent generation bioenergy crops are of interest, given that they do not directly compete with food. Even so, the technology is not currently at the level for mass production from these sources. It should also be noted that competition for arable land to produce these crops creates an indirect competition with food and fiber. It is estimated that 50% additional land will be needed to supply sufficient biomass for current fuel needs (Muller et al., 2007). Second-generation bioenergy crops, grown for their cellulose-to-ethanol potential, are also considered as forage crops that may supply fodder for livestock. By-products of food and lumber production (e.g., crop stover, woody residue) can also be used in second-generation or cellulosic biomass. Whichever bioenergy crop is produced and subsequently used in biofuel production, protecting water and soil quality is of utmost importance for long-term sustainable energy production.
Plant Biomass Conversion, First Edition. Edited by Elizabeth E. Hood, Peter Nelson and Randall Powell. C 2011 John Wiley & Sons Inc.
129
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
130
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Water and energy are basic resources for human existence. Clean water is fundamental for healthy lives, and modern societies would face gridlock without energy for transportation and electrical power. Without both of these resources, we cannot produce, process, distribute, or prepare food. Globally, the largest agricultural production regions are those with ample water supplies in the form of precipitation, water available for supplemental irrigation (ground or surface water), and fertile soils. Producing energy from crops will support independence from fossil fuels but must be balanced with water stewardship. Care must be taken to produce these crops without stressing available water resources and protect water quality. This chapter considers the water quality and quantity issues surrounding bioenergy cropping and production; processing and water footprints are not considered. Water for processing bioenergy crops in biofuel facilities is of local concern, and facilities are increasing their water conservation by recycling and reduction measures (Water Science and Technology Board, 2007). Waste streams from these facilities are regulated as point source discharges by the US Environmental Protection Agency under the Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1972. Point source discharges are permitted through the National Pollution Discharge Elimination System, thus water released from these plants must meet individual permitted limits.
6.2 Water Use in Bioenergy Production Agriculture is the leading user of water worldwide. In the United States, 62% of total freshwater withdrawals is used for irrigation and thermoelectric power combined; 37% of total freshwater withdrawals is used for irrigation (Kenny et al., 2009). Irrigation increases crop production, enabling available land to meet the global needs for food and fiber. It is recognized that bioenergy crops will compete with food production for land and water resources (Berndes, 2002); however, the introduction of bioenergy crops into food crop rotations is more likely to occur in locations where the change is economically feasible to the farm manager. The decision of cropping practices relies heavily on market values, but the availability of sufficient freshwater to support economically desirable crops also plays a role in determining these changes. Typically, water used for agriculture is locally supplied (either surface or groundwater), and thus the demand from agriculture cannot exceed local availability. Many heavily irrigated areas are currently experiencing groundwater deficit (withdrawals exceed aquifer recharge), and rotation of more water-demanding crops may further exacerbate water depletion; conversely, rotation of more drought-tolerant crops may lessen the stress on local water supplies. Presently, approximately 1% of total agricultural land is dedicated to bioenergy production but is predicted to increase as a result of positive externalities, such as tax incentives for reduced greenhouse gas emissions and carbon sequestration, and improved farm revenue (de Fraiture et al., 2008) especially from the second-generation (lignocellulosic) crops (McLaughlin and Walsh, 1998; Sanderson and Adler, 2008). As increased land is dedicated to bioenergy crop production, either through voluntary changes or economic incentives, care should be taken to consider freshwater resource availability in this decision-making process. Water use efficiency (WUE) is the ratio of biomass accumulation to water consumed (Sinclair et al., 1984) and has been calculated for most bioenergy crops. Sinclair et al. (1984) noted that WUE is higher in C4 than C3 crops due to differences in photosynthetic pathways, leaving more room for WUE improvement through breeding and genetic modification in C3 plants. It was noted that higher efficiency in C4 plants leaves less room for increased efficiency, while selection of more efficient cultivars in C3 plants will result in greater WUE for those
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
6 Water Sustainability in Biomass Cropping Systems
131
specific crops. Studies have compared WUE among assorted bioenergy crops (Berndes, 2002; De La Torre Ugarte et al., 2008; Gerbens-Leenes et al., 2009; Reddy et al., 2007) and even among crop genotypes (Clifton-Brown and Lewandowski, 2000). Differences in water use vary among crops, but will also vary among regions, soil types, topography, and land management; thus, interpretations must be made carefully. For a sustainable future in bioenergy crops, management decisions must take into consideration the environmental consequences to the natural resources available locally. The complexity of these issues will not result in a blanket best-case scenario for cropping types, land management, and water use, but rather must be a local decision as to which bioenergy crops are best suited for a particular region. With present technology, it is more water efficient to burn total biomass than to produce biofuels (Gerbens-Leenes et al., 2009). Greater energy recovery per water use is expected as technologies improve to include large-scale cellulose-to-ethanol techniques. Early stages of the biofuel industry are improving on existing techniques for producing biodiesel and ethanol from first-generation crops while awaiting technologies for lignocellulose-to-ethanol conversion. The demand for bioenergy crop production and subsequent water availability issues mirror the available energy conversion technologies. As these techniques are developed, water use will change as cropping evolves to the next generation. An increase in corn production has paralleled present emphasis on ethanol conversion in the United States. Biorefineries are available to process corn into ethanol; consequently, crop production in the Mississippi River Basin (MRB) has changed in response to increased demand and enhanced crop revenue. Farming technology in the form of equipment and management practices is readily available for corn and grain sorghum, making cropping changes easily manageable. Many studies have examined the WUE of corn with conflicting results. In semiarid environments, greater ethanol potential was measured with the production of sweet sorghum [Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] than corn (Zea mays L.) (Reddy et al., 2007). WUE of sweet sorghum has been reported as approximately 84%–85% of corn and results in greater biomass production per hectare (De La Torre Ugarte et al., 2008; Reddy et al., 2007). Conversely, Gerbens-Leenes et al. (2009) calculated that the global average water footprint of sorghum is four times higher than maize, deeming it the highest water user among 12 first-generation bioenergy crops, including sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) with the lowest water footprint. Regional differences are recognized in a summary of previous studies reporting that in 19 US states producing corn, water use increased from east to west and midwest to southwest (Chiu et al., 2009). Dramatic regional differences in water use for corn production can be calculated from Chiu et al. (2009). The study states that corn grown for ethanol production in California used 68 times more irrigation water than corn grown in Ohio. Differences in regional rainfall, soil types, topography, and evapotranspiration rates constitute some of these dissimilarities. This study emphasizes the regional variability of WUE in cropping systems and the importance of locally or regionally available data for sustainable bioenergy production. Water use has been calculated for numerous bioenergy crops by various methods and a summary can be found in Table 6.1. As cellulose-to-ethanol techniques are developed and become more economical, a shift from first-generation bioenergy crops (e.g., corn) to lignocellulosic crops will follow. WUE for second-generation bioenergy crops is generally lower. This shift will include C4 grasses such as switchgrass (Panicum virgatum), which are perennial natives of mixed-grass prairies of North America. As native prairie grasses, they exist within plant assemblages, without irrigation water, and are drought tolerant; however, management in monoculture necessitates additional water for establishment and maximum biomass production. Tall prairie grasses (e.g., switchgrass) have been used to manage erodible soils in the Conservation Reserve
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
132
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 6.1.
A review of reported water use in bioenergy crops. Water Use Reported
Citation
Inches/gp Plant WUE Plant WUE Plant WUE WUE WF
De La Torre Ugarte et al., 2008 Clifton-Brown and Lewandowski, 2000 Clifton-Brown and Lewandowski, 2000 Clifton-Brown and Lewandowski, 2000 Berndes, 2002 Gerbens-Leenes et al., 2009
Inches/gp
De La Torre Ugarte et al., 2008
Inches/gp Plant WUE(kg) WF
De La Torre Ugarte et al., 2008 Reddy et al., 2007 Gerbens-Leenes et al., 2009
Corn (Zea mays L.)
Inches/gp WUE Plant WUE(kg) WF EWe
De La Torre Ugarte et al., 2008 Berndes, 2002 Reddy et al., 2007 Gerbens-Leenes et al., 2009 Chiu et al., 2009
Sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.)
WUE WF
Berndes, 2002 Gerbens-Leenes et al., 2009
Energy Crop Perennial crops Switchgrass (Panicum virgatum) Miscanthus (Miscanthus × giganteus) Miscanthus (Miscanthus × sacchariflorus) Miscanthus (Miscanthus × sinensis) Sugar cane (Saccharum spp.) Alfalfa (Medicago sativa) Annual crops Biomass sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L. Moench)
WUE, kg dry mass/ha/mm ET; Plant WUE, g (kg) H2 O/kg plant dry mass; Inches/gp, inches/growing period; WF (water footprint), m3 /GJ electricity; Ewe (embedded water in ethanol), Irrigated water + process water)/ethanol production.
Program (CRP) since 1985, providing water quality protection. Tall grasses reduce runoff from agricultural land to adjacent streams by obstructing overland flow, decreasing water velocity, and allowing absorption into well-developed root zones. These attributes decrease the amount of runoff entering streams and protect water quality by reducing sediment, nutrient, and pesticide transport into receiving waters. The same attributes that make perennial prairie grasses desirable for establishment on CRP land make them good candidates for second-generation sustainable bioenergy production in many areas. Drought-tolerant species [e.g., switchgrass, big bluestem (Andropogon gerardii)] use less irrigation water following first-year establishment but can also be flood-tolerant for use near wetlands and streams. Staggering the annual establishment in production fields by a single producer will allow for moderate to small irrigation water use by a single farm manager. The need for irrigation of perennial crops at establishment and an occasional severe drought will provide a regional water savings when replacing fields previously planted with annual crops. The 10–15 year rotations of these crops also permit re-establishment in staggered years to follow similar patterns of prior plantings. Positive environmental benefits (e.g., increased soil organic matter, carbon sequestration, decreased agrochemical inputs) and greater energy production than corn (McLaughlin and Walsh, 1998) increase the attractiveness of replacing first-generation corn crops with perennial grasses. While reduction of nonpoint source runoff in agriculturally dominated areas is the goal of CRP management planning, concerns exist about the establishment of large-scale dedicated energy crops (i.e., trees). Although perennial and requiring less maintenance than annual crops,
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
6 Water Sustainability in Biomass Cropping Systems
133
the deep roots of trees will increase local evapotranspiration, leaving less water to recharge groundwater aquifers as was noted in tropical hardwood plantations (Evans and Turnbull, 2004). Establishment of bioenergy plots with nonwoody (herbaceous) perennials, such as switchgrass, will use irrigation water primarily during seedling establishment, allow for soil absorption of runoff water, have lower transpiration rates, and result in long-term water (and soil) savings following crop establishment. As bioenergy crops expand, the demand on natural resources such as arable soils and available freshwater will increase. Water competition will be seen on several fronts: crop irrigation, processing of bioenergy crops, and increased evapotranspiration where these crops are grown (Berndes, 2002). Although bioenergy crops presently account for only 1% of agricultural production globally, 2% of total irrigation withdrawals are used for these crops (de Fraiture et al., 2008). With present technology for most crops, direct production of electricity by burning biomass would consume approximately half the freshwater resources as production of bioenergy (i.e., biodiesel, bioethanol) (Gerbens-Leenes et al., 2009). With a growing global population and increasing water scarcity, water efficiency must be improved for bioenergy sustainability. Water conservation during crop production and energy conversion must be a priority with future generation bioenergy crops.
6.3 Water Quality Issues in Bioenergy Crops Agricultural production comprises about 65% of the land use in the MRB and is the main contributor to nonpoint source pollution (Turner and Rabalais, 2003). Pesticides, suspended sediments, pathogens, and nutrients are listed as leading causes of surface-water impairment in the MRB (US EPA, 2003) and monitoring indicates the northern segments of the MRB as the largest contributors to the nutrient load (US EPA, 2007). This area coincides with the corn and soybean areas of the Midwest but also has a high concentration of pasture and rangeland. It is thought that nutrient contribution from pasture and rangeland may be higher than previously believed (Alexander et al., 2008). Regardless of the nutrient source, reduction of the nutrient loading in the MRB is critical and infield nutrient management efficiency will be necessary in high nutrient input watersheds (US EPA, 2007). Corn hectares have decreased slightly from the peak in 2007, which was the highest year since 1933 (NASS, 2009). Increased corn planting in 2007 was contributed to conversion of CRP land to production (Wisner, 2007) and concerns have also been raised that typical corn–soybean rotations will shift to either continuous corn or longer rotations such as corn–corn–soybean (Donner and Kucharik, 2008). This causes concern as the nutrient management plans called for by the Hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico Science Advisory Board recommended increased land in CRP and other Federal programs (i.e., CSP, EQIP) (US EPA, 2007). Nitrogen (N) loads from the MRB to the Gulf of Mexico have nearly tripled from 1955 to 1996 and are the leading cause for the hypoxic zone (Goolsby et al., 2000). The increased production of bioenergy crops in the southern segments of the MRB may exacerbate water quality problems due to the close proximity to the Gulf of Mexico. Nutrient and pesticide transport distances are shorter in this region of the MRB and will increase the likelihood of impaired waters reaching the river outlets. In a study using the “SPARROW” computational model, the USGS determined that large metropolitan areas and agricultural land bordering major rivers increased the contribution of nutrient transport to the Gulf (Alexander et al., 2008). Furthermore, the timing differences in fertilizer applications from the northern
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
134
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Table 6.2. NASS harvested acres for major row crops in the 3 state region: Arkansas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. Commodity
State
1999
2004
2009
Corn for grain Cotton all Rice all Soybeans Total
AR-MS-LA AR-MS-LA AR-MS-LA AR-MS-LA AR-MS-LA
299 1,113 1,038 2,505 4,955
467 1,008 940 2,339 4,754
694 413 881 2,525 4,513
Acreage in thousand hectares.
Table 6.3.
AGNPS model output and soil test recommendations for cropping scenarios.
Scenario
Condition
Water Runoff (cm)
1 2 3 4
04-08 Landuse Cotton Rice Soybeans
28.8 31.3 26.9 29.9
0.987 0.991 1.113 0.955
5
Corn
32.0
1.549
6 7 8 9
Switchgrass Bermuda Alfalfa Tall fescue pasture
21.8 22.5 22.5 21.6
Sediment Load (t/ha/year)
0.101 0.088 0.133 0.054
N Load (kg/ha/year)
U of A: Soil Test Recsa
P Load (kg/ha/year)
kg/Nb
kg/Pc
1.424 3.248 3.065 0.000
0.018 0.021 0.010 0.024
Various 140 202 0
Various 7 4 8
10.461
0.083
371
10
0.982 8.061 0.086 4.206
0.010 0.029 0.045 0.011
67.4d 449 0 225
0.0d 19 22 18
a Espinoza
et al., 2008. recommendation for fine-textured soils. c P recommendation pro-rated by soil test P levels for the soil series. d Garland, 2008. bN
and southern MRB may lengthen the time window of impaired water entering the Gulf. Already the shift in cropping patterns is evidenced over the first decade of the 2000s in the lower delta states of Arkansas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. Table 6.2 lists the four major row crops in this region and their harvested area statistics. The dramatic 132% increase in corn in these three states reflects the mandate for firstgeneration bioenergy crops to replace traditional crops such as cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) and rice (Oryza sativa L.). Potentially, a switch to corn could have a negative environmental impact due primarily to its high nutrient requirements. Recommended N and P rates for corn are among the highest of the row crops. Rates are shown on the right side of Table 6.3, which includes University of Arkansas soil test recommendations for the listed crops on a clay soil in the Arkansas Delta (Espinoza et al., 2008). N rates given are generally maximum rates and recommendations include reductions depending on soil texture and residual soil N. Rice N rates vary drastically from 84 to 225 kilograms per hectare (kg/ha) depending on variety, soil texture, and previous crop. The most common varieties planted require 202 kg/ha of N on clay soils following soybean rotation
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
6
Water Sustainability in Biomass Cropping Systems
135
(Espinoza et al., 2008). Corn, by comparison, requires nearly twice the amount of N typically applied to a rice crop and 2.6 times the amount applied to cotton. Increased applications will add to the total N loads already flowing to the Gulf from the MRB (Goolsby et al., 2000). Impacts from changes in cropping scenarios and nutrient loads may be estimated through the use of watershed models.
6.3.1
AGNPS Watershed Model
Numerous water quality models are available for different applications and among the choices are plot, field, basin, and regional spatial applications. The type of output parameters simulated, such as hydrology, sediment, nutrients, and pesticides, provides further differentiation of models. Water movement in and through the watershed is the primary carrier for sediment, nutrients, and pesticides exiting the watershed and entering connected rivers and streams. Therefore, precise simulation of flow is essential to accurately predict water quality parameters (Parson et al., 2004). Two of the most popular watershed models incorporate the USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) runoff curve number to calculate a daily water balance. In addition, these models, SWAT (soil and water assessment tool) and AGNPS (Annualized Agricultural Non-Point Source), are long-term continuous simulation models. This makes them especially useful for analyzing changes in water quality due to best management practice (BMP) implementation in agriculturally dominated watersheds (Borah et al., 2003). The AGNPS model is designed for use in ungauged watersheds to determine the effects of BMPs, develop total maximum daily loads, and for other cost analysis (Bingner and Theurer, 2005; Yuan et al., 2001). The model incorporates the USDA–NRCS Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE), which is the latest technology to determine erosion loss and the impact of conservation practices in the watershed (Bingner and Theurer, 2005). Soil type, digital elevation information, land use, and land management practices are input into the model. The flow network generator of the model uses digital elevation information to divide the watershed into drainage cells. These cells are then used to track the quantity and movement of water, sediment, nutrients, and pesticides. Fertilizer application rates, tillage practices, crop rotations, and other management practices are entered for evaluation. Model calculations are made on a daily basis and also account for features such as feedlots and point source discharge. Overall, the model is an excellent tool for assessing the impacts of BMPs and land use choices in a watershed. More details on the theoretical background of AGNPS are reported by Bingner and Theurer (2005). The AGNPS model is available from Agriculture Research Service homepage (http://www.ars.usda.gov/ main/main.htm). In order to estimate the effects of the aforementioned change in cropping patterns, an agriculturally dominated Mississippi River Delta watershed was selected for evaluation. The modeled area extends from north of the St. Francis River Bridge on US Highway 64 in eastern Cross County, Arkansas. The study area is a small sub-watershed (approximately 6,070 hectares) of the St. Francis River watershed (HUC 08020203) that extends from southeastern Missouri to the Mississippi River near Helena, Arkansas. Detailed soils, digital elevation, and cropping systems information were acquired. The study area is bound on the west by Crowley’s Ridge, a hilly region consisting primarily of forested land. The cultivatable portion of the St. Francis Bay study area is approximately 3,100 hectares. Historically, this area has been planted to a rice–soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) rotation with limited areas of cotton and corn. This watershed is characteristic of delta watersheds with slow hydrological relief, including landscape features of crop and forested lands.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
136
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Model results are shown in Table 6.3 as average annual stream loading over the 10-year period of the model analysis. The table presents nine different cropping scenarios on the cultivatable land in the watershed. The first scenario is the 2004–2008 historical cropping period, which consisted of 61.4% soybeans, 34.8% rice, 3.3% cotton, and 0.5% corn (NASS, 2009). To enable a direct comparison of crop model output, scenarios 2–5 simulate conditions in the watershed for each crop individually, including the first-generation biofuel crops, soybeans and corn. Scenarios 6–9 in Table 6.3 present model output for select second-generation biofuel crops. These data are presented for comparison to the first-generation biofuel crop corn (center of Table 6.3). Output from the model includes average annual values for surface water runoff, soil erosion, N loading, and P loading. It is assumed the entire cultivatable area is planted to the selected crop for each 10-year modeled period. N loading, one of the primary drivers in the formation of the hypoxic zone in the Gulf, is compared for each scenario. A conventional-tillage corn crop will produce the highest amount of N exiting the watershed at 10.5 kg/ha per year. Calculations from the AGNPS model indicates that N loading from this watershed would be seven times greater, with 100% corn production, than crops planted in the 2004–2008 historical land-use period. Comparing the traditional and first-generation biofuel crops individually, N loss from the watershed is more than three times higher when corn is planted versus cotton and rice. The N loss is considerably higher than soybeans, which have essentially no N runoff since, as a legume, they require no supplemental inorganic N applications. P loading to the MRB is potentially as detrimental as N loading. In coastal waters, N is typically the limiting factor in algal blooms, but recent studies have shown that P can be a limiting nutrient in these areas as well (Sylvan et al., 2006). Generally, corn will require increased P applications over the traditional crops, which result in further stress on the MRB system. Recommended nutrient applications for P are dependent on the soil test results for individual fields. The values included in Table 6.3 were determined using soil test P ranges for the predominant soil series in the watershed and calculated as an average application rate for the soil series. P loading to the watershed from corn is almost four times the amount associated with scenarios 1, 2, and 4 (2004–2008 historical land-use, cotton, and soybean simulations, respectively). The P loss from corn is over eight times the amount lost from rice fields in scenario 3. P losses are tied very closely to soil erosion. It has been shown that P attached to soil particles constituted 74% of total P exported from a watershed (Sharpley et al., 2008). It was also determined by Sharpley et al. (2008) that high intensity rainfall events, which mobilized soil loss, accounted for the majority of P loss. Erosion modeled from AGNPS in this watershed was highest for corn [1.5 metric tons per hectare (t/ha)], constituting a 57% increase over historical land-use. Field operation schedules for modeled crops assumed that conventional tillage practices were used; although no-till model simulations resulted in lower total soil loss, ratios of soil loss for cropping scenarios remained the same. Because of the timing of soil disturbance for corn during high spring rainfall periods, erosion can create high soil loss, especially without BMPs in place. The impact of spring soil loss can be seen in Figure 6.1 as a sediment plume entering the Gulf of Mexico at the Mississippi and Atchafalaya river outlets. It should be noted that sedimentation is the leading contributor to nonpoint source pollution and also acts as a carrier for pesticides, pathogens, and nutrients (US EPA, 2003). The influx of sediment to the Gulf of Mexico can therefore contribute to the zone of hypoxia as can N exported from contributing watersheds. As the demand for bioenergy crops continue and the technology becomes available for efficient energy extraction from second-generation (cellulosic) crops, a change in cropping scenarios will be seen. Modeled results from land use of 100% second-generation bioenergy
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
6
Water Sustainability in Biomass Cropping Systems
137
Figure 6.1. March 28, 2009 (MODIS bands 7,2,1). Satellite image showing sediment plume in the Gulf of Mexico from Atchafalaya and Mississippi rivers. Light gray represents sediment plume following rain event in MRB; white is cloud cover obstructing satellite image. Image courtesy of the USDA Foreign Agricultural Service Crop Explorer at http://www.pecad.fas.usda.gov/ and NASA Global Agriculture Monitoring (GLAM) Project at http://www.pecad.fas.usda.gov/glam.cfm.
crops indicate sediment loss substantially lower than traditional crops (i.e., cotton, rice, soybeans). In these model scenarios, soil loss in traditional cropping systems was approximately 1 t/ha, while modeled second-generation cellulosic crops ranged from 0.054 to 0.133 t/ha—an average reduction of 90% in comparison. The lower half of Table 6.3 summarizes results from AGNPS model runs with four cellulosic cropping scenarios. The potential second-generation crops included in the analysis are switchgrass, alfalfa, bermuda grass (Cynodon dactylon L. Pers.) (warm-season) pasture, and tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea) (cool-season) pasture. Because of high N applications to promote maximum yield, bermuda and fescue hay crops would significantly increase N loading in the MRB over traditional crops but would still export less N from the watershed than corn. With regard to water quality issues, switchgrass and alfalfa offer promising alternative crops since N runoff is 10 and 120 times lower than corn, respectively. Switchgrass is also preferable over first-generation and other second-generation crops in that it has very low P loss. The fertile Mississippi Delta clay soils are naturally rich in P and typically require minimal additional P applications. The remaining second-generation biofuel crops modeled (i.e., alfalfa, bermuda, fescue) require the highest P inputs of the nine scenarios. However, because of the continual ground cover and lack of tillage, they also have higher soil infiltration rates
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
138
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
and less erosion than traditional row crops. This combination results in lower P loss rates per kg applied than first-generation crops requiring annual tillage. Note that alfalfa would result in a 50% reduction of P exported from the watershed as compared to corn, yet alfalfa requires twice the P application.
6.3.2
Water Quality and the Gulf Hypoxic Zone
Water quality implications of large-scale corn production are devastating. Model results indicate that soil erosion and N and P loading to the Gulf of Mexico would exacerbate the zone of hypoxia and negate any environmental protection that has been accomplished to date. Since water quality results were modeled specifically for a typical delta watershed, they do not fully represent the entire MRB area because of varying ratios of cropland versus noncropland, soil type, and a multitude of other factors. However, the environmental impacts due to drastic changes in crops have been illustrated in these models and numerous previous studies. Other researchers have concluded that first-generation biofuel crops, specifically corn, will create problems with water quality (Costello et al., 2009; Hill et al., 2006; Pimentel, 2003; McLaughlin and Walsh, 1998). On the basis of two models using physical watershed properties in the MRB drainage area, N loading would increase by 10%–34% if corn was planted to meet the mandated renewable fuels requirement (Donner and Kucharik, 2008). Thus, to protect water quality in the MRB, it is imperative to enforce conservation practices, specifically nutrient management plans for corn production (Simpson et al., 2008). Thus far, initial crop swapping that has taken place has not affected the size of hypoxic zone in the Gulf of Mexico. According to Rabalais et al. (2007), in spite of annual fluctuations, the overall hypoxic zone in the Gulf has remained close to the same since the mid-1990s. A decrease in N flux has been measured by USGS in the first decade of the 2000s vs. the 1990s; however, low river flows for the decade may be a contributing factor to the corresponding lack of nutrient movement and resulting stability in the hypoxic zone area (Aulenbach et al., 2007). Wetter conditions and spring floods in the MRB for the years following these measurements may provide different results from the previous decade.
6.4 Conclusions—Water Quantity and Quality Water quantity and quality are of utmost importance for a sustainable and secure global future. It is imperative that freshwater resources be protected. While the subject of bioenergy crops is at the forefront of political agendas and agricultural communities, the requirement for clean freshwater for human populations and natural ecosystems must be maintained. Sustainable agriculture cannot exist without freshwater security. Protecting this vital resource by choosing bioenergy cropping scenarios that will, in turn, protect water quantity and quality are warranted. Large increases in corn hectares in response to ethanol demands will rapidly degrade water quantity and quality. To ensure global sustainability through freshwater preservation and energy independence, a rapid evolution to second-generation (cellulosic) is required. Second-generation crops, especially perennial crops with 10–15 year rotations, are very promising for water conservation and water quality protection of freshwater resources. With a relatively low environmental impact based on nutrient loading and water use, cellulosic perennial crops will provide the sustainability desired based on bioenergy and water protection.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
6 Water Sustainability in Biomass Cropping Systems
139
As technology advances and large-scale cellulose-to-ethanol techniques are developed, freshwater resources (quality and quantity) will afford greater protection from the negative effects of agricultural runoff. Future biomass production may also offer the benefits of carbon sequestration and possible “cap and trade” for greenhouse gases making bioenergy crops a more economically viable option. The additional use of freshwater in bioenergy agriculture will most certainly add to the stress on global freshwater supplies. Ensuring availability of freshwater for a worldwide population and maintaining freshwater ecosystems to preserve the services they provide are both crucial for long-term global sustainability. Integrating the need for energy, decreasing dependence on fossil fuels, reducing impacts of climate change by carbon sequestration, growing need for food and fiber, and maintaining freshwater supplies must all be incorporated into future considerations of bioenergy production.
References Alexander, R., Smith, R., Schwarz, G. & Al, E. 2008. Differences in phosphorus and nitrogen delivery to the Gulf of Mexico from the Mississippi River Basin. Environmental Science & Technology, 42, 828–830. Aulenbach, B. T., Buxton, H. T., Battaglin, W. T. & Al, E. 2007. Streamflow and Nutrient Fluxes of the Mississippi-Atchafalaya River Basin and Subbasins for the Period of Record Through 2005—Updated [Online]. US Geological Survey. Available: http://toxics.usgs.gov/ hypoxia/mississippi/flux ests/delivery/index.html (Accessed 11 december 2009). Berndes, G. 2002. Bioenergy and water—the implications of large-scale bioenergy production for water use and supply. Global Environmental Change, 12, 253–271. Bingner, R. L. & Theurer, F. D. 2005. AnnAGNPS Technical Processes Documentation, Version 3.2. Oxford, MS: USDA-ARS National Sedimentation Laboratory. Borah, D. K., & Bera, M. 2003. Watershed-scale hydrologic and nonpoint-source pollution models: Review of mathematical bases. Transactions of the ASAE, 46 (6), 1553–1566. Chiu, Y.-W., Walseth, B. & Suh, S. 2009. Water embodied in bioethanol in the United States. Environmental Science & Technology, 43, 2688–2692. Clifton-Brown, J. C. & Lewandowski, I. 2000. Water use efficiency and biomass partitioning of three different Miscanthus genotypes with limited and unlimited water supply. Annals of Botany, 86, 191–200. Costello, C., Griffin, W. M., Landis, A. E. & Matthews, H. S. 2009. Impact of biofuel crop production on the formation of hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico. Environmental Science & Technology, 43, 7985–7991. De Fraiture, C., Giordano, M. & Laio, Y. 2008. Biofules and implications for Agricultural water use: Blue impacts of green energy. Water Policy, 10, 67–81. De La Torre Ugarte, D., He, L., Jensen, K. L. & Al, E. 2008. Estimating agricultural impacts of expanding ethanol production: Policy implications for water demand and quality. Presented at Annual Meeting of the American Agricultural Economics Association, Orlando, FL. Donner, S. D. & Kucharik, C. J. 2008. Corn-based ethanol production compromises goal of reducing nitrogen export by the Mississippi River. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105, 4513–4518. US EPA. 2003. National Management Measures to Control Nonpoint Source Pollution from Agriculture, Polluted Runoff (Nonpoint Source Pollution). Washington, DC. US EPA. 2007. Hypoxia in the Northern Gulf of Mexico. Washington DC.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
140
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Espinoza, L., Mozaffari, M. & Slaton, N. A. 2008. University of Arkansas Lime and Fertilizer Recommendations. Marianna, AR: Univeristy of Arkansas, Division of Agriculture, Soil Testing and Research Lab. Evans, J. & Turnbull, J. W. 2004. Plantation Forestry in the Tropics. New York, NY: Oxford University Press. Gerbens-Leenes, W., Hoekstra, A. Y. & Van Der Meer, T. H. 2009. The water footprint of bioenergy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106, 10219–10223. Goolsby, D. A., Battaglin, W. A., Aulenbach, B. T. & Al, E. 2000. Nitrogen flux and sources in the Mississippi River Basin. The Science of the Total Environment, 248, 75–86. Hill, J., Nelson, E., Tilman, D., Polasky, S. & Tiffany, D. 2006. Environmental, economic, and energetic costs and benefits of biodiesel and ethanol biofuels. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 103, 11206–11210. Kenny, J. F., Barber, N. L., Hutson, S. S. & Al, E. 2009. Estimated use of water in the United States in 2005. US Geological Survey Circular, 1344, 4–15. McLaughlin, S. B. & Walsh, M. E. 1998. Evaluating environmental consequences of producing herbaceous crops for bioenergy. Biomass and Bioenergy, 14, 317–324. Muller, A., Schmidhuber, J., Hoogeveen, J. & Al, E. 2007. Some insights in the effect of growing bioenergy demand on global food security and natural resources. Presented at Linkages Between Energy and Water Management for Agriculture in Developing Countries, January 28–31, Hyderabad, India. NASS. 2009. USDA Agricultural Statistics Service. Quick Stats Land Use 1999–2009. Available at http://www.nass.usda.gov/ USDA. Parson, J., Thomas, D. & Huffman, R. 2004. Agricultural non-point source water quality models: Their use and application. Southern Cooperative Series Bulletin, 398. Pimentel, D. 2003. Ethanol fuels: Energy balance, economics, and environmental impacts are negative. Natural Resources Research, 12, 127–134. Rabalais, N. N., Turner, B. K., Sen Gupta, D. F. & Al, E. 2007. Hypoxia in the Northern Gulf of Mexico: Does science support the plan to reduce, mitigate and control hypoxia. Estuaries and Coasts, 30, 753–772. Reddy, B. V. S., Kumar, A. A. & Ramesh, S. 2007. Sweet Sorghum: A water saving bioenergy crop. Presented at Linkage between Energy and Water Management for Agriculture in Developing Countries, Hyperabad, India. Sanderson, M. A. & Adler, P. R. 2008. Perennial forages as second generation bioenergy crops. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 9, 768–788. Sharpley, A. N., Kleinman, P. J. A. & Heathwaite, A. L. 2008. Phosphorus loss from an gricultural watershed as a function of storm size. Journal of Environmental Quality, 37, 362–368. Simpson, T. W., Sharpley, A. N., Howarth, R. W. & Al, E. 2008. The new gold rush: Fueling ethanol production while protecting water quality. Journal of Environmental Quality, 37, 318–323. Sinclair, T. R., Tanner, C. B. & Bennett, J. M. 1984. Water-use efficiency in crop production. BioScience, 34, 36–40. Water Science and Technology Board. 2007. Water Implications of BIofuels Production in the United States. Washington, DC: National Academic Press. Sylvan, J. B., Dortch, Q., Nelson, D. M. & Al, E. 2006. Phosphorus limits phytoplankton growth on the Louisiana shelf during the period of Hypoxia formation. Environmental Science & Technology, 40, 7548–7553.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
6 Water Sustainability in Biomass Cropping Systems
141
Turner, R. E. & Rabalais, N. N. 2003. Linking landscape and water quality in the Mississippi River Basin for 200 years. BioScience, 53, 563–572. Wisner, R. 2007. Global Economic Impacts of Ethanol Industry Growth. Ames, Iowa: Iowa State Univeristy. Yuan, Y., Bingner, R. L., & Rebich, R. A. 2001. Evaluation of AnnAGNPS on Mississippi delta MSEA watersheds. Transactions of the ASAE, 44, 1183–1190.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c06 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:53
Trim: 244mm×172mm
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c07 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:54
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Chapter 7
Soil Sustainability Issues in Energy Crop Production V. Steven Green
7.1 Soil Sustainability Concepts The concept of sustainability focuses on three main areas: environmental, economic, and cultural (Figure 7.1). Each of the three main focus areas is important and none of them can be ignored or diminished. They are all interlinked. Many definitions of sustainability have been written. A broad, global theme for sustainability is “the ability to endure.” The following definition encompasses the main ideas of sustainability and will be used as a platform for our discussion of the sustainability of energy crop production. Sustainability (n): The ability to meet present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs. Within the environmental area of sustainable bioenergy production lays soil quality, water quality, and atmospheric quality (Figure 7.1). Each of those is critically important, none can be ignored or diminished, and they are all interlinked. Soil quality or soil health can also be divided into three areas: soil biological, soil chemical, and soil physical parameters and dynamics (Figure 7.1). Soil health is the intersection or interaction among soil biological, chemical, and physical characteristics. Once again, all three soil characteristic areas are equally important, none can be ignored or diminished, and they are all interlinked. The issues facing the sustainable production of bioenergy are varied and complicated. Sustainable agriculture, under which bioenergy crop production fits, refers to the ideology or practice of farming that attempts to actualize long-term, sustained yields by using ecologically sound management practices (Altieri, 1995). The goal is to reduce external inputs by increasingly relying on natural nutrient and energy cycles, thereby reducing carbon footprints and on- and off-farm detrimental externalities, and maintain profits, all while enhancing a quality lifestyle of the producer both now and in the future.
Plant Biomass Conversion, First Edition. Edited by Elizabeth E. Hood, Peter Nelson and Randall Powell. C 2011 John Wiley & Sons Inc.
143
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c07 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
144
20:54
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Economic
Cultural
Soil
Water
Environmental
Atmosphere
Sustainable energy crop production
Environmental quality
Chemical
Physical
Biological
Soil health
Figure 7.1. Relationship among sustainable crop production, environmental quality, and soil health. Soil health is integral to a sustainable biomass crop production system.
Modern agriculture has focused on assuring that crops have adequate nutrients for maximum potential growth. The use of chemical fertilizers has greatly increased yields in modern crops, yet the inattention to the soil has caused a decline in soil health of many farming systems. The major missing link when applying chemical fertilizers is the organic matter. Organic matter affects the soil’s many physical, chemical, and biological properties and processes. Applying chemical fertilizers and then removing the crop from the field at harvest has resulted in a decline in soil organic matter and subsequently soil health. Additionally, our practice of working the land through tillage, to prepare a clean seed bed, results in optimal conditions for rapid organic matter decomposition, which causes a decline in soil organic matter. We put a lot of demand on our soils by asking this resource to fulfill many tasks. Our soils are used for agricultural, industrial, engineering, urban, wildlife, and recreational purposes. Often forgotten are all of the ecological services that soils provide. Soils sequester carbon (help mitigate climate change), provide habitat for organisms that are essential in the carbon and nutrient cycles that are essential for human survival, manage waste, act as a filter, etc. (Lal, 2007). As we demand more and more of our soils to provide the food, fiber, feed, and fuel for a potential 10 billion person population in the coming century, we must make sure that we maintain the important ecological services that the soil provides.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c07 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:54
Trim: 244mm×172mm
7 Soil Sustainability Issues in Energy Crop Production
145
To this end, it is essential that as we develop dedicated bioenergy cropping systems, we take into account the soil health issues and develop management strategies that enhance soil health.
7.2 Bioenergy Crops and Soil Sustainability There are many energy crops that are being researched, proposed, experimented with, etc. The two main categories of cellulosic energy crops consist of using (1) crop residues or (2) growing dedicated energy crops. When growing dedicated energy crops, we must concern ourselves with the lifecycle of the crop, including the nutrient and water inputs, the nutrient exports, and the off-site and unintended exports that may consist of polluting nutrients, suspended solids, and pesticide runoff. When using agricultural residues, we must concern ourselves with the loss of use of that residue for other purposes, most notably soil cover and soil organic carbon buildup. Here, we will focus on the agricultural plant biomass possibilities for cellulosic ethanol production at the exclusion of forest products, municipal solid wastes, and other materials that are, or could be, exploited for cellulosic conversion to ethanol.
7.2.1
Crop Residues
Agricultural residues, such as stovers and straw, the non-harvested material, are often termed a “waste.” However, these leftovers are not wastes at all, but are a valuable resource that can be returned to the soil to provide nutrients, organic matter, and habitat for beneficial organisms. This material is essential for the conservation of the soil resource; it is also extremely important in terms of crop productivity. Agricultural residues are an essential key protectant of the soil resource. These agricultural residues provide cover for the soil over the winter, protecting the soil surface from the abrading impacts of rain and wind. In fact, for those crops that have a fragile residue (one that decomposes easily and rapidly), it is often recommended that an additional crop be planted in the winter (non-crop season) for the main purpose of protecting the soil from climatic perturbations such as wind and rain. These crops, called cover crops, are an added cost to the producer in the form of seed cost, time, and planting. However, the benefits are many and the producer reaps those benefits for many years (Clark, 2007). In fact, these crop residues are so beneficial to protecting the soil that keeping the residues on the soil surface through no-tillage management has greatly improved soil conservation efforts over the last decade. As of 2004, 24 million ha (hectare) of cropland (23% of total cropland) in the United States was planted using no-tillage management for corn, soybean, wheat, and cotton (Triplett and Dick, 2008). Leaving the crop residue on the soil surface has many conservation benefits. Blanco-Canqui and Lal (2007) showed that wheat residue had a substantial positive impact on water retention, bulk density, soil porosity, and earthworm populations. Other studies have shown that high residue levels increase soil organic carbon storage (Amuri et al., 2008). Green et al. (2007) also found important soil quality benefits from no-tillage management that included increased soil biological activity, a greater nitrogen pool, and greater carbon and nitrogen mineralization potentials over that of plowed soils. Both the crop residue left at the soil surface and the decreased soil disturbance contributes to the enhanced soil health properties of no-tillage management. Looking at estimates from only corn, the United States produces corn on 28,579,000 ha and produces 196,244,000 Mg (megagram) of corn stover (the residue left after grain harvest).
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c07 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
146
20:54
Trim: 244mm×172mm
Plant Biomass Conversion
Of the stover produced, only about 30% is harvestable if erosion control needs are taken into account. In many southern states, crop residues are needed to remain in place since much of it is decomposed too quickly to be useful in controlling erosion such that 100% of the residue is needed to remain on the soil surface for erosion control. In the western United States, much of the corn stover is needed in order to protect the soils from wind erosion. However, this does not take into account other needs for the crop residue such as organic matter accumulation and nutrient cycling in the soil. The benefits of the crop residue left on the soil also include crop yield benefits. It is imperative to remember that the soil is the most valuable resource available to agriculture. The improvements in soil health have a positive impact on crop yields. In Ohio, where soil organic carbon contents are typically greater than in southern and western state soils, BlancoCanqui et al. (2006) found that removing only 50% of the corn stover on sloping lands caused a significant decrease in both grain and stover production in subsequent years, clearly demonstrating the need to manage crop residues wisely. A study by Maskina et al. (1993) in Nebraska, USA, showed that for each Mg/ha of stover removed from a corn crop resulted in 0.13 Mg/ha decrease in grain yield the following year. This effect continued even after the end of the project when all the stover was returned to the soil, indicating that these effects on the soil are prone to be long lived, requiring many years of improved management to return the soil to its potential productivity. The yield decreases can be attributed to declining water retention and a decrease in natural nutrient cycling. In long-term studies (13 years) by Clapp et al. (2000) and by Linden et al. (2000), greater grain and stover production was observed in treatments where the residue was returned to the soil compared to treatments where residue was removed. If only 20–30% or less of the corn stover can be harvested for bioenergy (only considering the soil erosion factor), the question begs to be answered if this is economically feasible to harvest when yields have been shown to suffer when residues are harvested. Many questions still remain with regards to harvesting crop residues for bioenergy, especially due to the spatial variability in soil types and climatic conditions across the United States and the world. There is great variability in soils and climates, and these must be taken into account when determining how much of the corn stover (or any other crop residue) can sustainably be removed. This is one of the reasons that there is so much debate about if and how much corn stover can and should be harvested for cellulosic conversion to ethanol. Obviously, corn stover is easily obtained and readily available as well as not requiring any land to be diverted to some other energy crop. Corn stover has many uses, including energy, but it is essential to remember that these residues are needed to contribute to soil organic carbon status, protect the soil from erosion, supply microorganism habitats, and sustain nutrient cycling. The amount of corn stover needed to control erosion is much less than that needed to maintain soil organic carbon status. In a continuous corn conservation tillage management system, 0.65 Mg/ha of corn stover is needed to control water erosion, while 5.25 Mg/ha of corn stover is needed to maintain the soil organic carbon status (Wilhelm et al., 2007).
7.2.2
Dedicated Energy Crops
The use of dedicated energy crops has been proposed as a more sustainable approach to biomass for energy. Dedicated energy crops include both annual and perennial crops. Of great interest in the United States is the dedicated energy crop species switchgrass (Panicum virgatum; Figure 7.2). However, there are many crops that have great potential for biomass production in the United States and abroad.
P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK c07 BLBS075-Hood December 15, 2010
20:54
Trim: 244mm×172mm
7
Soil Sustainability Issues in Energy Crop Production
147
Figure 7.2. Panicum virgatum (switchgrass) in its third year of production at the Arkansas State University Farm Complex.
Dedicated nonwoody biomass crops receiving significant research attention are included in Table 7.1 with a sa