Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 1
PHOTOGRAPHERS
A Sourcebook For Historical Research
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 2
Sourcebook pt.1R2
4/10/04
12:03 PM
Page 3
PHOTOGRAPHERS
A Sourcebook For Historical Research
Featuring Richard Rudisill’s
Directories of Photographers
An Annotated Bibliography
Edited by Peter E. Palmquist
Foreword by Martha A. Sandweiss
Essays by David Haynes • Drew Heath Johnson Steven Joseph • Steve Knoblock Peter E. Palmquist • Linda A. Ries • Jeremy Rowe
Carl Mautz Publishing
N e va d a C i t y
2000
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 4
Revised Second Edition Copyright 2000 Carl Mautz Publishing All rights reserved in all countries. Edited by Rosemarie Mossinger Designed by Richard D. Moore Composed in Palatino, Mrs. Eaves and Franklin types Printed by Thomson Shore, Dexter Michigan, U.S.A.
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 99-070538 Cataloging -in-publication data Photographers: a sourcebook for historical research /Richard Rudisill ... [et al.]; edited by Peter E. Palmquist].—Rev. 2nd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN: 1-887694-18-X (paper)
ISBN: 1-887694-17-X (cloth)
1. Photography—History—Sources. 2. Photographers—History— Sources. 3. Photography—History—Bibliography. I. Rudisill, Richard. II. Palmquist, Peter E. III. Rudisill, Richard. Directories of photographers. 1991.
TR15.P477 1999
770'.722
QBI99-572
Frontispiece: Self-portrait of G. W. Browning, Chicago, Illinois. Cabinet card with manuscript date, 1879. Collection of Carl Mautz.
Carl Mautz Publishing 228 Commercial Street, No. 522 Nevada City, CA 95959 Telephone 530 478-1610 Fax 530 478-0466 www.nccn.net/~cmautz/
Sourcebook pt.1R2
4/10/04
12:03 PM
Page 4
Contents
F O R E W O R D 1
Martha A. Sandweiss
THE EXPERIENCE OF REGIONAL DIRECTORY RESEARCH
Where Did You Find That One? 5
Sources for Finding Dead Photographers David Haynes Lochman Located 13
Further Adventures in Photographer Research Linda A. Ries The Regional Photography Collection 21 A Case Study at the Oakland Museum of California Drew Heath Johnson Copyrights and Other Rights 25
Jeremy Rowe
Women in Photography International Archive 33
Peter E. Palmquist
City Gallery 37
Research in the Twenty-First Century Steve Knoblock DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
41
An Annotated Bibliography Richard Rudisill APPENDICES
Looking For Lochman 142
Researching an Historical Photographer Linda A. Ries Regional Photographic History in Europe 146
A Review of Methodology and Sources Steven Joseph CONTRIBUTORS
150
AUTHOR INDEX
151
REGION INDEX
154
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 6
Carte-de-visite of the studio of Hedger & Noe, formerly Sutterly’s Photographic Gallery, Virginia City, Nevada, c. 1870. Collection of Carl Mautz.
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 1
Foreword Martha A. Sandweiss Anyone who embarks on a serious research project in the field of photographic history quickly finds that the most satisfying and most maddening parts of the search are both occasioned by the same situation—the scarcity of good pri mary and secondary sources. The thrill of the chase and the knowledge that one is producing truly original work make photo history among the most exciting of academic pur suits. But one often longs to simply reach over to a shelf and pull out a good biographical dictionary that lays out the basic facts and provides a foundation for further research. Our colleagues in the more traditional fields of art history have long had access to comprehensive reference books. Biographical compilations are so central to the field of art history and so often used, they’re known simply by their authors’ names, such as Bénézit (1911), ThiemeBecker (1925), and Groce and Wallace (1957). Since the early twentieth century, comprehensive catalogue raison nés that detail the chronology of an artist’s life, identify exhibitions and publication, and date all significant (and insignificant) works have likewise been indispensable tools for scholars of painting, printmaking and sculpture. The field of photographic history, however, has been slow to engender the foundational reference tools needed for seri ous scholarship, although it covers a much shorter period of time than the older arts. There are any number of reasons for the paucity of basic reference tools for the photographic historian, some attrib utable to the academy, some to popular thinking about photography, and some to the very nature of the photo graphic profession. Until quite recently, it has been nearly impossible to focus on the history of photography at the graduate school level. A dearth of trained academics had translated into a scarcity of academically generated schol arship and a slim demand for reference books in the field. While the age-old debate about the status of photography as an art seems finally (and thankfully) put to rest, there’s no question that such doubts inhibited serious research earlier in this century. Finally, one can’t get around the fact that photographers are difficult subjects. People who move in and out of the profession, ardent amateurs, short-lived practitioners, workers in allied fields, all appear in the his torical record. But how should one track them and docu ment their work? And what does one do about the sheer number of images photographers might produce? It is one thing to produce a catalogue raisonné for a printmaker who made 350 etchings, but quite another to systematically document the work of a photographer who produced twenty or thirty thousand negatives. But enough complaining. This book celebrates just how far the field of photographic history has come in the past decade. Richard Rudisill’s annotated bibliography of books with biographical entries for photographers reflects the growth of scholarship in the field, in large measure because
of a burgeoning interest in photography on the part of museums. Such an institutional interest, of course, reflects the increasing public interest in photography, an interest than can only continue to spur the development of the pho tographic history field. The impressive scope of the bibliog raphy suggests the wealth of information now available to researchers. Finally, we have a body of reference material broad enough in scope and rigorous enough in content to begin supporting truly ambitious scholarly research efforts. But even as it celebrates a renewed museum interest in photographic history, this book also celebrates the work of the many individuals—amateurs (or lovers of their work) in the very best sense of the word—who have done much of the basic object-collecting and fact-gathering work essential to serious research. It seems fitting to present pho tography, long ago dubbed the most democratic art, as a field that can be explored by anyone, whether professional or amateur. Although many of the books listed in the Bibliography are written by professional curators and schol ars, the efforts of amateur photographic historians have been absolutely essential to the preservation of important collections and to the growth of the field as an academic discipline. Without the efforts of those who salvaged col lections for institutions, preserved local history records, ini tiated collectors’ groups for the exchange of information, compiled the photographic history of particular regions, and tediously assembled genealogical information, it is dif ficult to imagine where the field would be today. Surely the historical record would be much poorer. Nonetheless, it is important to keep in mind that although the basic facts of a photographer’s life are an essential starting point, they should not be the only goal of photohistorical investigations. There are countless other questions to ask. What kind of pictures did the photo grapher make and why did he or she make them? How did these pictures find an audience? How did people under stand them? What ideas did they convey, and what kind of responses and actions did they inspire? The growing body of biographical data for photographers makes it possible to go on to ask these and other, even broader, conceptual questions about the place of photography in the nineteenth and twentieth century world. Given the centrality of photo graphic documentation to virtually every aspect of modern life, there is no end to the questions we might ask of photo graphs, nor to the information they might provide about the social, cultural and material world in which we live. With this book as a guide, it is hoped that even more researchers will plunge into the ever-expanding field of photographic history and become ardent collectors, researchers, and writers themselves. Much basic fact-gathering work remains to be done; many hard questions remain to be asked; many useful and thought-provoking books remain to be written. Let the work begin! 1
This page intentionally left blank
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 3
The Experience of
Regional Directory Research
3
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 4
Title page from Zell's United States Business Directory for 1876.
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 5
Where Did You Find That One?
Sources for Finding Dead Photographers David Haynes
Getting Started You will save a lot of time and considerable work if you discuss your project with as many librarians as possible. A good librarian will know of potential sources, and may also be able to put you in touch with other researchers who are engaged in similar projects. If someone in your area is working on another trade—cabinetmakers, for instance—you might split the work and make notes for each other. Genealogical librarians can be particularly helpful because their patrons are also looking for sources of information about individuals. Be sure to let your col leagues and acquaintances know about your project, and ask them to tell you if they stumble across a reference to a photographer. Sources for data fall into two categories: primary sources—those created by or with the photographer; and secondary sources—those created by others after the fact. Experienced researchers point out that printed documents are much easier to handle and read than handwritten mate rial. Records that list people by occupation are more pro ductive than those that include such information incidentally. The best way to begin is to gather a large number of names as quickly as possible, and two methods are detailed below. But first, there are a few rules:
Finding and gathering information about early photo graphers can either be exhilarating or frustrating—usually it is both. A little planning, however, can smooth the road, produce better results, and be far more satisfying. Most directory projects do not to start at the beginning. You may have gathered a little information about one photo grapher here, about another there, and have accumulated material on a dozen or so individuals. Then it seems like a terrific idea to try to collect data on all the photographers who operated in a particular place. Now you need a plan, and these notes will help you put one together. At the very outset, you must determine your definition of “photographer.” If your purpose is to assemble a list that will help date images that have a photographer’s name printed on the mount, you might be tempted to exclude those who worked for photographers, such as operators, printers, and colorists. However, people changed occupa tions frequently in the nineteenth century and some mar ginal workers later became photographers. The effort to record these names is fairly small, and the information may be very useful later. You must also decide whether to collect data on those in related fields, such as photographic supply manufacturers and dealers, photo-engravers, and document copyists. If you are interested in social history, it is important to record data about these workers, and indeed, to find as much as possible about all your entries. What did they do before and after engaging in photography? How did they fit as individuals in their time and place? It is important to consider how you will record and retrieve your data. Today’s computer programs are ideal for this task. In addition to making it very easy to record basic facts—who, where, when, and source—database managers allow for the inclusion of extensive notes, comments, and text. The main advantage, however, is the ability to sort your data. With the touch of a few keys, you can list the photogra phers by name, location, dates, sex, race, techniques used, or any other information you have entered. You could just as easily produce a list of photographers’ street addresses in ascending or descending order. Nevertheless, there are a few disadvantages to using a computer: it takes time and patience to learn the program, data must be written down before transferring it to com puter (unless you use a laptop), and of course, you need a computer and program. On the plus side, most modern programs are not too difficult to master. Many libraries have computers for patrons’ use, and computers and their programs can be rented inexpensively in most parts of the country. All in all, the advantages of using a computer rather than a notebook or a card file far outweigh the disadvantages except for the smallest projects.
1. You will never find all the photographers. 2. The people who created the sources were no more careful than we are today. 3. In the nineteenth century, few cared how names were spelled or whether the initials were correct. 4. Before 1870 many photographers were listed as “artist.” 5. In addition to daguerreotypist, ambrotypist, and tintypist, watch for “shadow catcher” and heaven only knows what else. 6. Make a note of all the information you find about a photographer, then you won’t need to go back to get it later. 7. Carefully record the complete source of all information so you can go back when you violate rule 6. If a large collection of early photographs is readily at hand, you can spend a pleasant afternoon or two recording the names and addresses on the mounts. You should also record any date written on the mount, but these dates must be carefully considered. In most cases it is impossible to know whether the date was written at the time the print was made, added later by owners of the image, or written even later by a helpful, but perhaps uninformed librarian or collector. You must specify in your notes the prove nance of any such date. No matter how knowledgable you 5
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 6
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
are, resist the temptation to assign a date to an image (and thus to the photographer who made it) based on the process, format, or costume of the subject. Another good beginning is to comb through city, state, and regional directories. State libraries and major university libraries often hold city directories for the entire state or region. Many volumes are recorded on microfilm, and can be borrowed by smaller libraries that might have only the directories issued for their town. City directories were published from the mid-1800s until around 1900 when telephone books appeared, listing similar information. The data was collected annually or bi annually, and in some cases included only those who paid a fee. Regional and state directories were sometimes issued less frequently than other types. The titles vary; they may be called a General Directory, Business Directory, Business Guide, Gazetteer, Railroad Guide, or other similar names; ask your reference or local-history librarian for assistance. Directories are easy to use. Those for cities are common ly arranged like a telephone book, listing all residents in front alphabetically, with a classified business directory in the back. Work through the business directory first, then read the alphabetical section. If you don’t have time to read the entire alphabetical section, at least look up each of the photographers you find in the business directory; this sec tion often contains additional information. When photogra phers disappear from the business section in one directory, check the alphabetical section of the next issue; they may be listed there. By the same token, when a photographer appears for the first time in the business section, check for them in the alphabetical section of the previous issue. Regional and state directories are very similar to those for cities, except they are usually organized geographically. Other local and regional publications that are worth a quick look are almanacs, mug books, and booster books. While these usually do not include business directories, they provide other valuable information. Early almanacs contain advertisements, some of photographers. Mug books, common in the late 1800s, are composed of biogra phical sketches and pictures of prominent citizens of a state or region, and often include photographers. These are usu ally indexed by name or the entries appear in alphabetical sequence. Booster books, such as The Industrial Advan tages of Cornfield County, often contain biographies of business leaders and almost always include the photogra pher who produced the book’s portraits and illustrations. The subjects of these sketches generally paid to be included, so these works are far from comprehensive. While the results of checking these sources are usually modest, so is the effort. After you have followed these strategies, you should have a good beginning list. The next steps will be more dif ficult. For this discussion, the types of sources are divided into two categories—electronic and traditional.
E-mail is perhaps the most useful resource, allowing researchers to correspond directly with other photo histori ans. It is like conventional mail, but instantaneous, and usually not priced by the message. Many photo historians around the world have e-mail accounts, and you can send them a request, a message, a document, or a picture elec tronically. It will arrive in seconds. Through e-mail, you can access thousands of mailing lists, each one made up of people who are interested in a particular subject. Individual messages are sent to a central server then distributed to everyone on the list by e-mail. Answers to your question can then be sent directly to you, or to the group as a whole. Many of these lists maintain archives of previous messages so that new members can search through them for possible answers to their questions. Photo historians are indeed fortunate to have such a group, photohst, established years ago and operated by Richard Pearce-Moses. The membership includes about 750 people from around the world who are interested in the his tory of photography. The group is moderately active, aver aging twenty to thirty messages per week. Messages on any subject pertaining to photo history are welcome. Another type of mailing list is similar to a subscription list; a group of people receive messages only from the person who owns the list and members do not correspond with each other. One such group is DagNews, operated by Gary Ewer. Members receive copies of advertisements and edito rial material about daguerreotypists, usually on the calendar day the original was published. Both the discussions on pho tohst and the material provided by DagNews is archived. There are several discussion groups devoted to photogra phy that use the Internet newsgroup utility, Usenet. None of these groups, however, is presently devoted to the history of photography, but many photo historians read one or more of these groups. Each group specializes in some particular aspect of photography; those devoted to equipment, for example, discuss old cameras or other gear. The World Wide Web is a utility that allows users to place documents on servers. The documents may then be read by nearly anyone with Web access, and most can be downloaded or printed. Millions of documents are posted on the Web, but some will present difficulties for experi enced researchers and novices alike. Computer hardware and software are evolving rapidly, and new Web docu ments often require the latest browser or most powerful computer; their creators forget that many users do not have the latest technology. In addition, documents and the addresses to access them (URLs) change frequently, and published addresses (such as those given here) may no longer work when you try them. Another problem is finding what you want amid the vast domain of the web. The search programs currently in use are fairly inefficient. These programs search documents on the Web, looking for those that contain words specified by the user. These search engines will improve with time, but at the present, the researcher who requests “history of photography” will receive the addresses of sites that con tain those words, and the list may vary from less than 100 to more than 19,000,000, depending on which search program is used. All programs function well, however,
Electronic Sources Over the past ten years the volume of information available via the Internet has increased tremendously. Among the most important utilities provided by your Internet service are electronic mail (e-mail), discussion groups on Usenet, and the World Wide Web. 6
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 7
WHERE DID YOUR FIND THAT ONE?
Traditional Sources Newspapers are a rich source of information. Photohistorian Richard Rudisill read more than 130,000 pages in 82 newspapers looking for photographers who were in New Mexico from 1854 to 1912. In Texas there were more than 400 newspapers published between 1839 and the Civil War. Many were published for a very short time and a con siderable number of issues have been lost, but there are still plenty around.1 During the 1930s, numerous newspapers were indexed in projects supported by the Works Progress Admin istration. The indexes vary—some are by name, some of editorial matter, and some are of very limited scope. The original indexes are probably located in major libraries of each state. Some were local projects, however, and the results may be in a nearby library—another good reason to talk to your librarian. Most early Texas newspapers consist of four or eight pages, and can be read quickly. New advertisements were sometimes placed in a special column, and these often were given a short mention in the local news column as well. Some photographers’ advertisements were illustrated with a daguerreotype case or similar design, making them easi er to spot. Newspapers have always been printed on some of the worst paper known to man, and most libraries are reluctant to allow researchers use original copies if micro film is available. Most newspapers are reproduced with two or more frames to the page, and it is difficult to read them in this form. If your area is small or had few newspapers, it would certainly be worth the trouble to go through all available issues. A large or populous area, however, probably gener ated numerous papers. If you cannot read them all, choose the most important papers for the time periods that have few other sources, and read those thoroughly, rather than picking through issues at random. The following national publications are also important sources:
when the researcher is looking for specific information. They rapidly list the occurrences of the name of an individual, company, or organization, and provide enough information about each site to narrow the search. Numerous non-photographic sites might also have very useful information for the researcher. These include library card catalogs, genealogical organizations, government departments, and book sellers. Some museums and libraries with substantial photo graphic holdings have documents on their Web sites specifically designed for the photograph historian. The site for the International Museum of Photography at the George Eastman House, for example, leads the researcher to a database of thousands of photographers worldwide that can be searched by name. The listing includes all the data IMP has collected, such as birth and death informa tion, working dates, exhibitions, and collections of works. Both the famous and the obscure are included. In addition to numerous non-photographic sites that might have useful information for the researcher (library card catalogs, genealogical organizations, government departments, book sellers, and the like), there are several specifically designed for photohistorians. Some museums and libraries with substantial photographic holdings have finding aids and other information available on their Web sites. An example is the International Museum of Photo graphy at the George Eastman House. Its Web site leads the researcher to a database of thousands of photographers world wide that can be searched by name. The listing includes all the data IMP has collected, such as birth and death information, working dates, exhibitions, and collec tions of works. Both the famous and obscure are included. Web sites maintained by individuals also provide impor tant photographic information and list links to similar sites.
Internet Addresses: Please remember that Internet addresses may change from time to time. If you cannot reach one, try another and see if a link to your other choice is provided. To join photohst, send an e-mail to:
[email protected] with the following message on the first line. Do not use the “Subject” line and do not sign the message. subscribe photohst your_first_name your_last_name
Daguerreian Journal and Humphrey’s Journal of Photography, 1850–1870
Photographic Art Journal, 1851–1861
American Journal of Photography, 1852–?
Philadelphia Photographer, 1864–1888
St. Louis Practical Photographer, 1877–1882
St. Louis Photographer (later the St. Louis and
Canadian Photographer), 1883–1910.2
To join DagNews, send an e-mail request in regular English to Gary Ewer at:
[email protected] To access the International Museum of Photography Web site, point your browser to:http://www.eastman.org/ 1_geninfo/curator/gehdata.html and follow the telnet link.
These journals published letters, news notes, and articles about photographers. Letters in early issues are often signed only with initials, but some of your photographers are probably represented. Large libraries should have either originals or microfilm copies.
To access William Allen’s list of photo historians, point your browser to: http://www.clt.astate.edu/wallen/ photohistorians To access City Gallery, point your browser to: http://www.city-gallery.com
Finding Aids OK, so you say you are tired of looking through easy-toread printed sources. Boy, do I have a treat for you. The most useful records for finding individuals associat ed with particular professions are the U.S. census sched ules. Almost every person in the country is listed (even if
To access McIntire’s Photography Guide, point your browser to: http://photography.mininngco.com/arts/photography To access Safier’s site, point your browser to: http://www.ozemail.com.au/~msafier/ausnzphoto.html To access Safier’s site, point your browser to: http://www.ozemail.com.au/~msafier/ausnzphoto.html 7
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 8
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
only every ten years) and entries include copious informa tion about each individual. While the types of data vary somewhat with each decade, all census entries of the early photography period list the individual’s name, age, race, sex, birthplace, and occupation. Some censuses list proper ty value, residential address (if in a city), parents’ birth places, education, marital status, and the number of months not employed. Later censuses also record each individual’s birth month and year, and date of immigration (and immigration status) for the foreign born. The 1840 census is not very useful, however, because it lists only the name of the head of each family, and actual occupations are not specified. The 1890 schedules for most states were destroyed by fire before they could be microfilmed. Before beginning to work with the actual census sched ules, there are several other sources to check. After each census, the government issues a report, usually called the compendium or the statistical view.3 Most important to the researcher are the tables that give the total number of indi viduals in each state by occupation. This tells you how many photographers you may expect to find. The com pendium of the 1850 census, for instance, claims three daguerreotypists and seven artists in Texas out of a total of 212,592 individuals (approximately one photographer in every 21,260 entries). It gets better, though. In 1900, you could expect to find a photographer for every 4,160 entries in Texas (733 photographers out of a total population of 3,048,710). In case you are interested, the other years break down as follows: 1860, one per 9,906; 1870, one per 7,442; 1880, one per 7,999; and 1890, one per 5,187. You should also check the name indexes compiled for many early censuses, prepared primarily for genealogists.4 Some include entire states, and some are county and local indexes. Portions of various censuses have also been pub lished, usually the local sections. Ask your genealogical librarian before you start. The indexes can help you find the actual entry for a known individual quickly, but you really should read the entire census for the maximum benefit. Reading a census is not too difficult, and they are all available on microfilm. The film can be used in a library or rented for home use. Scan the “Occupation” column until you find an entry that meets your requirements, then record the data for that person and household. The vast majority of people in most places during the period for which censuses are available (1910 is the last one that has been released) were farmers and farm laborers, so you can quickly scan past occupations that begin with “F” and con centrate on the others (unless, of course, your enumerator lists “Fotographer”). Now and then you may want to stop and consider what some of the listed occupations actually were in the nineteenth century—stock broker or drug deal er, for instance. You might even find an old man whose occupation is listed as “talks politics.” Deciphering early penmanship (not to mention spelling) is only one of the challenges in researching microfilmed manuscript records. The original document may be torn and folded over, or repaired with tape that appears black on the microfilm. The film may be underexposed, scratched, or variably out of focus. Try your best to record the data as accurately as possible, then compare your findings against
the list that you compiled from printed sources. Many of your census “photographers” will not be on your list. Some may be photographers who did not make it into the printed sources, but most of them will actually be people who worked for other photographers—operators, printers, retouchers, framers, and others. The following chart gives a sample of this difference. Photographers Found in Selected Texas Cities in 1900 by Source City
City Directory
Dallas Fort Worth Galveston Houston San Antonio
16 10 6 10 11
Census Compendium
Actually Found in Census
29 14 24 30 27
27 16 24 30 28
It is difficult to cite censuses. For each one, a state or ter ritory was divided into supervisory districts and these were further divided into enumeration districts. Each cen sus taker started the list in his enumeration district with page 1, household 1, family 1. When he was finished, the individual sheets were bound into volumes and every other page was rubber-stamped with a sequential number. When the originals were microfilmed, each volume (or more commonly parts of two volumes) was filmed on one roll. Thus, to completely describe a page, you must record the date, state, roll, volume, rubber-stamped number, county, division of the county, and the hand-written page number. Each entry on that page includes a household number, a family number, and a line number. The most parsimonious way to cite an individual entry is to use the date, state, roll, volume, rubber-stamped number, and line, but the county and division within the county are usually cited as well. Various states and localities have occasionally produced similar records, for instance, the Great Registers of California. Again, the easiest way to find out about these sources is to ask your librarian. The next large body of manuscript records you need to examine are tax records. In 1862 the United States Congress passed an internal revenue act to help pay for the Civil War. The law went into effect August 1, and among many other provisions, required anyone who wished to produce photographs for sale (and almost anyone else in business) to obtain a license from the federal government. This pro vided for a whole new bureaucracy to assess and collect the license fees, and to record the name, occupation, location, payment, and term of each license issued. The great bulk of these records has survived—as a matter of fact, it compris es 8,763 volumes measuring 933 linear feet. Unfortunately, not all of the records are microfilmed, and relatively few copies of the film have been distributed. The original records are housed in the National Archives in Washington, D.C. Some of the original records are housed in various National Archives Regional Branches around the country. The requirement for photographers to pay federal license fees was repealed in 1870 (effective May 1, 1871). These records are the best source for locating 8
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 9
WHERE DID YOUR FIND THAT ONE?
photographers during this period, but covers only the areas of the country controlled by the federal government. The Archives staff is very helpful; occupations are shown in a separate column that can be quickly scanned; all you have to do is spend a couple of weeks in Washington. Federal law also required photographers and various other producers of paper goods to purchase and affix revenue stamps to each piece produced from 1864 to 1866. The same stamps were used on a variety of products, how ever, and the records do not indicate the occupation of the purchaser. At various times during this period, photogra phers and other businessmen were required to pay ad val orem or gross receipts taxes, and these records provide additional information about individuals. As you may have noticed, once a tax is established, other agencies quickly assess additional taxes of their own. One month after the federal government repealed the license requirement for photographers in 1870, the Texas legisla ture levied a similar tax. Although it was in effect well into the twentieth century, the records indicate that it was only vigorously collected from 1871 to 1876. Once again, a large body of records was created and for the most part, saved. While some of these records still exist in county courthous es across the state, the majority are housed in the Archives Division of the State Library in Austin. Unfortunately, the occupation tax records are mixed in with an even larger quantity of other fiscal records (a total of about 400 boxes) in the State Archives and are very time-consuming to use. It’s possible your state imposed such a tax, and the records may be more accessible. Ask your state archivist. In recent years many local governmental entities, faced with an ever-increasing volume of paper and a fixed amount of space, have been forced to destroy old records that have relatively little value for the government. In many places there is a formal plan to determine how long each type of record must be kept. For several decades, for tunately, the Mormon Church in Salt Lake City has been quietly microfilming many types of local records of genealogical interest. If you know that some record existed at one time, but you cannot find it locally, check with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. If you are working on a small area with relatively few photographers, you can probably gather a great deal of interesting information from local government archives. Land records, such as deeds and liens, and probate records, are typically kept at the county level, are indexed by name and often provide details about a person’s life. Birth and death records may be kept by the city, county, or state. In recent years many jurisdictions have decided that these records are not public and allow access only to family members. There are stories, however, that some researchers have gained access by claiming to be a descen dant of the photographer. Death certificates are useful because they usually also give the date of birth and may list the place of burial. Cemetery records are normally kept by the cemetery or the organization that owns it; sometimes, however, the records for all or most of the cemeteries in a city are kept by a city agency. It is not unusual to find that a genealogical or local history society has published some of these records or an index to them. Ask your local librarian.
All these finding aids can be very useful, but remember that errors are common in secondary sources. It is wise to double-check the data in original documents—primary sources—if possible. In Texas, a list was published of all printed material (that the compilers could find) produced in the state up to the mid-1870s.5 The index includes an entry under “Photographers” that leads to an advertising broadside for three photographers in Austin in 1859. Similar documents may have been compiled in other states. Local histories of many cities and counties are available, but they vary in accuracy, completeness, and usefulness. Some were carefully researched and written, with compre hensive indexes; others were quickly and carelessly thrown together and poorly indexed, if at all. Most of these books were created by or for historical societies, but some were prepared by the WPA, businesses, chambers of commerce, and similar organizations. If you find one with an index, check for the listing of “Photography” as well as for the names of photographers who may be covered. Read the acknowledgments for photograph sources, and check the cutlines under the illustrations for photographer credits. Some state and local photographers’ associations have published histories, and these will obviously include a lot of information in our field. Most of these groups are rela tively new, however, and will not offer much material on nineteenth century photographers.6
Where Does Your Tax Money Go? In early 1977 I discovered that the National Archives Regional Branch in Fort Worth had several volumes of assessment lists for Texas, covering the period of the photographers’ occu pation. The archivist told me that while they physically possessed the records, they belonged to the IRS and he could not grant permission to look at them. An IRS employee at the Archives also could not grant permission, but suggested that I write to the IRS in Austin (the office that had deposited the records) and request, under the Freedom of Information Act, permission to use them. I wrote such a request March 22. On March 30 that office replied that it had forwarded my request to Washington. After requesting two delays, the IRS responded on June 28 denying my request. On July 12, I appealed the denial on various grounds. On August 10 the IRS acknowl edged my appeal and promised a response by September 2. After four IRS requests for more time during the next three months, the Service finally granted my request on December 29 (nine months after my initial request). The records, by the way, do contain significant information that is not duplicated in Washington.
9
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 10
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
Notes
Information on early photographers occasionally appears in local and regional historical periodicals. These journals are usually indexed, and the articles are well-prepared and documented. Be sure to ask your local librarian for sugges tions; there are many fairly obscure serials, particularly those devoted to genealogy.7 College students often take some aspect of the history of photography as the topic for a thesis or dissertation. Check the indexes and abstracts of these papers published by University Microfilms in Ann Arbor. Your local library may be able to borrow copies that interest you.8 Finally, since you are holding this book in your hands, be sure to check the following list for published works that cover your region or those adjacent to it. Good luck.
1. Richard Rudisill, P hotographers of the New Mexico Territory, 1854–1912 (Santa Fe: Museum of New Mexico), 1973, p. iii. The number 400 is an estimate based on the 101 newspapers reported in Thomas W. Streeter, Bibliography of Texas, 1795–1845 (Cambridge: Harvard University Press), 1955–1960, and the 347 titles, 1845–1861 listed in Marilyn McAdams Sibley, Lone Stars and State Gazettes: Texas Newspapers before the Civil War (College Station: Texas A & M University Press), 1983. 2. S. D. Humphrey began publication of the Daguerreian Journal in 1850 and continued as Humphrey’s Journal of Photography until 1870. The Photographic Art Journal, edited by H. H. Snelling, was absorbed by Charles A. Seely’s American Journal of Photography in 1861. The St. Louis Practical Photographer was followed by the St. Louis Photographer, and later the St. Louis and Canadian Photographer. 3. The full title of the report for 1880 for example, is Statistics of the Population of the United States at the Tenth Census (June 1, 1880), Embracing Tables of the Population of States, Counties, and Minor Civil Divisions, with Distinction of Race, Sex, Age, Nativity, and Occupations; Together with Summary Tables, Derived from Other Census Reports, relating to Newspapers and Periodicals; Public Schools and Illiteracy; the Dependent, Defective, and Delinquent Classes, Etc. (Washington: Government Printing Office), 1883.
Who Told You That? In 1938 Robert Taft published his classic study, Photography and the American Scene.9 At the time this was the most comprehensive study of photography in the United States. In many ways the same is true today. Taft was a very careful researcher and documented all of his facts. The only Texas photographer mentioned in the book is H. B. Hillyer “who began practice in Austin, Texas, in 1857.” A close reading of Taft’s source, however, shows that Hillyer claims he began photography in 1857 and also that he worked for many years in Austin, but he does not claim to have started in that city. In actual fact he learned photography from his father in Goliad County in the mid 1850s and did not begin his career in Austin until after the Civil War. The importance of checking the original source of statements made in secondary works, no matter how well researched, written, and cur rently regarded, cannot be overemphasized.
4. A Texas example is Ronald Vern Jackson, Gary Ronald Teeples, and David Schaefermeyer, editors, Texas 1850 Census Index (Bountiful, Utah: Accelerated Indexing Systems), 1976. 5. Ernest W. Winkler and Llerena Friend, eds., Check List of Texas Imprints: 1846–1876, two Vols. (Austin: Texas State Historical Association), 1949, 1963. 6. The history of the first seventy-five years of the Texas Professional Photographers Association was published as The Diamond Years of Texas Photography by Ava Crofford (Austin: Ava Crofford), 1975. 7. A Texas example is Wayne Daniel, “A Ragsdale Biography,” Fort Concho Report 19, No. 2 (Summer 1987), pp. 13–27. 8. William Russell Young, “H. B. Hillyer: Life and Career of a Nineteenth Century Texas Photographer” (MA Thesis, University of Texas at Austin), 1985. 9. Robert Taft, Photography and the American Scene (New York: Macmillan), 1938. Reprinted by Dover Publications (New York), 1964. Taft’s source is a letter from Hillyer published in the Philadelphia Photographer, Vol. 13, No. 333, in 1876.
10
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 11
WHERE DID YOUR FIND THAT ONE?
11
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 12
Figure 1. Carte-de-visite of three men gathered around a camera; reverse contains imprint of Benjamin Lochman of Allentown. Collection of the author.
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 13
Lochman Located:
Further Adventures in Photographer Research* Linda A. Ries “You wish certain questions answered,” the letter ran, “regarding the life of Charles Leightheiser Lochman who was born July 20, 1821 and died Aug. 14, 1900.” If only I had found it at the beginning of researching Lochman in 1988! It would have saved me time and effort piecing together bits of his life from disparate and sketchy resources. Instead I found it a year or so later, a photocopy tucked inside the front cover of a rare Lochman book about medicinal plants, at the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia.1 The letter was written in 1916 by Eugene Rau, a pharma cist an Allentown, Pennsylvania, to J. N. Barnhart of the New York Botanical Garden. It went on in great detail about Lochman, telling me things I already knew, and hint ing at things I did not. The irony was that Barnhart had asked Rau for the same information that I was asking, more than seventy-five years later. It did corroborate informa tion I had painstakingly mined and verified many of my educated guesses. Historical information never arrives in the original chronological order in which it happened, if indeed it is acquired at all. The bits and pieces come in jumbles, like a jigsaw puzzle waiting to be sorted and put together. It was by chance this letter survived and was discovered to add to our knowledge of Charles Lochman. We are not so lucky with most nineteenth century photographers. In the first edition of this Sourcebook, I outlined a method for research when personal data such as diaries and letters are lacking. Using Lochman as a model, the reader took a journey through public and private information sources, including the federal population censes, local government records, community and regional histories and municipal directories, and newspaper advertisements. By assembling and comparing seemingly disparate data, more can be deduced about a nineteenth century image and its creator. It is a holistic approach, where the sum is greater than the individual parts. The time lines of a photographer’s life can produce a “skeleton” of vital and useful knowledge to aid in dating his or her images. By pursuing other, somewhat obscure, or lesser-known sources of national and local information, flesh and muscle can be added to this skeleton. The chronology can be finetuned, enabling a tighter dating sequence. With Lochman, this process took me to unexpected and interesting places, and enabled me to modify, correct, and add to my original data. A number of such sources are discussed here, and no doubt others exist. After publishing, an author is immediately perceived as somewhat of a magnet on the subject by fellow scholars. New information, clarifications, and corrections, arrive without solicitation. For example, in my previous essay I 13
made the mistake of assuming that William J. Lochman of Hamburg, Charles’ younger brother, also ran a studio in York. An expert on York area photographers politely pointed out to me that the York Lochman was William H., not William J., Lochman. I had mistakenly extrapolated that the same person had studios in these two different cities, and that there was simply a transcription error with his middle initial, not uncommon in the days of moveable type. Mea culpa, although it’s an honest mistake. William J.’s obituary lists him as William L. Lochman!2 Doublechecking my friend’s more thorough research clearly proved that there was a William H. Lochman in York.3 I was not in the least offended, but pleased with the clarifi cation. This means that another photographer named Lochman, possibly a cousin, or uncle, is mixed up in this somehow, offering further research venues to pursue. I was also contacted by a scholar in Kentucky who told me about “Lochman’s Locomotive Writing Ink.” He sent copies from a reference book on antique ink bottles that included a photograph of a tiny glass ink bottle shaped like a train engine (figure 2). Embossed printing on the bottle reads: “Lochman’s Locomotive Ink” and “Trademark Pat. Oct. 1874.” Patent research revealed it was granted October 13, 1874 to Charles L. Lochman of Carlisle, Pennsylvania.4
Figure 2. Bottle for “Lochman’s Locomotive Writing Ink.” From Ink Bottles and Ink Wells. See Footnote 4.
Then an antique photography dealer contacted me about a carte-de-visite image from the early 1860s with the imprint of Benjamin Lochman of Allentown on the reverse (figure 1). The subjects are three men of varying ages, hap pily positioned around a large format gallery camera, one wearing two sets of pants! There is no other identification on the image, and it is sorely tempting to think that these are the three Lochman Brothers as the dealer would have me believe, but I can only speculate at this point. More like ly it is Benjamin Lochman with assistants, the one with two pants perhaps wearing protective darkroom garb. None of
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 14
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
research on an individual. However, there are other cate gories of information collected by the U.S. Census Bureau for its mandated purpose of determining representation in Congress, such as mortality and birth statistics. Of particu lar interest to historical photographer research is the U.S. Census of Manufacturers, also conducted decennially. Of all the decennial tables available, Charles Lochman was found only on the 1870 list for Carlisle. Nevertheless, this one appearance reveals much: entries indicate Lochman had two businesses, one as a photographer and the other as an ink manufacturer. The listing as an ink man ufacturer corroborates the “Locomotive Writing Ink” data. He listed the value of the businesses at $1,500 each, employing one male over the age of sixteen (besides him self?), type of power used (hand), the materials used for ink (“nut galls, sulph. iron, chemicals, oils & other articles”), and photographs (“chemicals and other articles”). He gave the yearly amount produced: ink at 500 gallons and photo graphs at 8,000. This last statistic is revealing as an example of the out put of just one small-town commercial photography busi ness in the 1870s.7 Carlisle, with a population of only a few thousand in 1870, had at least four or five other photogra phers operating at the same time as Lochman. The amount of 8,000 possibly refers to the number of negatives pro duced rather than prints, for photographers, as they do today, commonly made several negatives of the same sub ject in hopes that at least one good image would result from the lot. The failure rate was far greater in 1870, when commercial photographers used the fragile collodion wet plate developing process. The materials were highly sus ceptible to seasonal temperature and humidity fluctua tions, and the results depended on the quality of handling, mixing and purity of chemicals, and the knowledge and ability of the operators.8 Another useful record series from the National Archives is the Internal Revenue Assessment Lists, 1862–1866.9 The U.S. Department of the Treasury was authorized under an act of July 1, 1862 to raise revenues for “payment of the public debt,” in support of the war effort. This was accom plished by requiring certain businesses, including commer cial photographers, to purchase annual or monthly licenses. Lochman was assessed three times while operating alone: $25 in September 1862; $6.67 in May 1863 for an eight-month license; and $25 in 1866. He was assessed with his partner, George Bretz, at their Newville business at $3.33 for three months beginning January 1863, and $25 in May 1865. The act fixed the tax according to the amount of receipts. Twenty-five dollars was levied at the level of $1,000 in annual receipts, which gives an idea of the rev enue generated by Lochman’s business. Another very useful and telling national resource is a group of private records, the R. G. Dun and Company Collection housed at the Baker Library of Harvard Univer sity in Boston, Massachusetts. The company was founded early in the nineteenth century and is still in operation today as Dun & Bradstreet. Dun & Company assessed an applicant’s financial status, and loans and credit were granted on the basis of their reports. Their representatives
Figure 3. Lochman’s grave at Niskey Hill Cemetery; Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. Photograph by the author.
the men look even remotely like the image of an elderly Charles found in the introduction to the book of medicinal plants. The image remains an enigma. I deeply appreciate all this information; a network of fellow scholars can be immensely helpful in furthering research. Shortly after the original essay was published, I made a pilgrimage to Lochman’s grave in Niskey Hill Cemetery, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. Yes, I’m a sentimentalist, and I thought it appropriate to pay him tribute. I’m also a prag matist, and wanted to see if the gravestone noted any infor mation I didn’t already have. Lot 139, section F contains Lochman; his second wife Alice Mary Weaver; his son Charles Napier Lochman and his wife Elva E. Lochman; his daughter Alberta Lochman Lewis and her husband Robert B. Lewis; C. N. Lochman’s daughter Lucie J. Mitman and her husband Walter Mitman, who was a close friend of the mother of photogra phy historian, Willliam C. Darrah.5 Besides life dates, there was little else to learn from the stone (figure 3). Researchers are often tempted to give up at this point, assuming nothing else can be found. It pays to stop by the cemetery office. Memorial parks usually have maps of plots, grave locations and interment files on each of its occupants. Most of this information is usually in the public domain, and I was happy to pay the small research fee. The helpful clerk found and allowed me to copy the Lochman Family interment information, part of a file of 5 x 7 inch cards. I discovered more than I wanted to know. For instance, Charles Napier Lochman paid $136 to purchase the plot in 1900. However, I was able to obtain death dates for the people listed above, enabling me to look up their obituaries in the local newspapers. Reviewing son Charles Napier Lochman’s obituary revealed he had followed his father into the drug business, but had more formal education. He received a degree from the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy in the 1880s, and worked for many years at the Simon Rau and Company Drugstore in Allentown, one of the oldest retail drugstores in the nation. Eugene Rau, the writer of the informative 1916 letter, was the son of Simon Rau.6 Most scholars are aware of the federal decennial popula tion records, the census, a starting point for any kind of 14
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 15
LOCHMAN LOCATED
would visit a potential applicant and log their findings in registers established for that region or county. Information on Lochman was found for the years 1874–1888. Despite his seeming wealth in Carlisle, he was not above applying for credit when he moved to the Allentown/Bethlehem area in 1874. The precisely dated, terse and unforgiving assessments written in a cramped and peculiar shorthand depict a man struggling for success in yet a third profession:
this list of titles to a local library and asked the staff to undertake a search. Several locations emerged for two of the books. Dose and Price Labels of all the Drugs and Preparations of the United States Pharmacopoeia of 1880 . . . (1887) and The German Pharmacopoeia (1873 and 1884 editions) were at the Library of the Philadelphia College of Phys icians, the nearest location to me. I was then able to visit the Li brary and view these rare books. Dose and Price Labels . . . is a convenient aid for “pharma cists, physicians and students,” consisting of the actual labels for chemicals and medicinal drugs. They are printed several to a Figure 4. A typical page page, to be cut out and pasted to from Dose and Price Labels. a bottle by the medical or phar maceutical professional. Each label includes information on the Latin and common name of the drug, appropriate applications and dosage, and toxic or poisonous warnings (figure 4). The German Pharmacopoeia (figure 5) was an English trans lation of “the only legally recognized Pharmacopoeia for the whole German empire.” In “Introduction by the Translator,” Lochman explains the need for the book in America: “In view of the already large, and rapidly increasing German population, including many physicians, the work, it is
C. L. Lochman . . . Allentown . . . Drugs . . . Ins.Agt. . . . Oct 1 74. . . . Formerly a druggist at Carlisle, Pa moved here recently. Has an office in front room of his dwlg house & displays a sign as Agt for sevl fire Ins Cos. Also Mfd Ink. Has no RE but formerly owned a ho at Carlisle wh he says he sold for 26c. his wf carries on Dress Making in same hous. Think he hon & indust but don’t go ahead much. . . . Nov 9 74 . . . “C. L. L.” is not a very sharp bus.man & his success therefore problematical. . . . July 12 76 Very hard up & slow pay, Claims vs him & cannot pay . . . July 13 77 No chge, Not Much to base cr on & caution advised . . . Nov 6 77 Stock . . . held for Sale by Sherif on a judgmt lately serv.[?] Jany 7 77[78?] Sold out by Sheriff.10 Entries could not be found for Lochman between 1878 and 1881. By that time he seems to have gotten back on his feet, but was still having some financial difficulties: C. L. Lochman . . . Bethlehem . . . Photographer . . . Octr 15. 81 . . . This party has no means upon which to base a recommendation for cr. He is however, spoken of as an hon & trustworthy man, who would not buy what he did not intend to pay for. Can only be crd on the strength of honesty & good intentions . . . June 26/83. There has been no change. We hear of some complaints of late that he is rather slow in meeting his bills. Oct 30/83 . . . is well advanced in yrs, seems content to live from hand to mouth.11 In all fairness to Charles Lochman, a glance at other reg ister entries reveals the Dun & Company agents had the same level of condescension for all credit applicants. Aside from social bias, new facts are uncovered: Lochman was also dabbling in selling fire insurance; Lochman’s wife Alice helped the family by dressmaking; and local authorities seized his stock of drugs in 1877 due to legal claims against him. Investigating city and county court records for the Allentown area may reveal more con cerning the latter incident. It does not appear he was ever granted credit by the R. G. Dun & Company. The Internet and World Wide Web have emerged as new research tools in the ten years since I began my Lochman study. We can now plug into and browse various institu tional library database catalogs from all over the world. The On-Line Computer Library Catalog or OCLC can speed the process of data-gathering by locating the institutions that hold the desired books or manuscript collections. Lochman’s obituary in the August 1900 Bethlehem Globe conveniently mentioned a few of his publications. I took
Figure 5. Title page from the second edition of The German Pharmacopoeia. 15
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 16
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
hoped, will be acceptable to many pharmacists, who are frequently called upon for medicines by the German names, or by the Latin terms, in use in Germany.” Seeing these works, with their sophisticated and precise technical language, gave me a new appreciation for Lochman’s abilities and scientific knowledge, an apprecia tion I perhaps never realized through study of his commer cial and portrait photographs. I was not as successful with other sources on a national level. Lochman did not serve in the Mexican or Civil Wars (no record could be found of him serving in the Mexican War and he was too old—thirty-nine—when the Civil War began in 1861). His brother Benjamin, however, served in the Civil War, and I found his federal pension application file at the National Archives. These are chock-full of personal details, and often include affidavits from friends and family mem bers testifying to the needs of the applicant. Alas, there are none from Charles in the file of Benjamin Lochman.12 The George Eastman House on-line catalog, maintained by the International Museum of Photography in Rochester, New York, was also not productive. The only information they had on Charles Lochman was the material that I had provided them years ago, but it is nice to know your research is used and appreciated. I had no luck studying various photographic trade jour nals of the late nineteenth century such as Anthony’s Photographic Bulletin and The Philadelphia Photographer. These usually are unindexed and research is incredibly time-consuming.13 Local property and tax records are also helpful. These are usually generated by county and municipal govern ments and are therefore found at courthouses and city or borough offices. Older records, having outlasted their use fulness to the agency that created them, are sometimes transferred to local government archives or historical soci eties. Many original records for Cumberland County are still at the courthouse, but some of these have been micro filmed by the Latter-Day Saints or other organizations and the film is available at the Cumberland County Historical Society and elsewhere. A search through the records at the Cumberland County Courthouse revealed that Lochman bought and sold vari ous properties while he was in Carlisle between 1859 and 1874. The first deed is dated 1863. His earliest newspaper ads declare he was staying at a local hotel, so he may have rented and resided at his gallery on 21 W. Main Street dur ing the 3 1/2 years between June 1859 and February 1863. He bought and sold the property at 38 Pomfret Street twice; bought it from Hagun Carney on February 9, 1863; sold it to George W. Neidich on October 6, 1865; bought it back from Neidich April 10, 1867; then sold it again September 21, 1868 to David Strohm. Although these facts may seem triv ial, they became crucial in later research, as we shall see.14 We know from his newspaper advertisements between October 1865 and January 1867, that he ran a gallery in partnership with George Bretz in Newville, about twelve miles away. Sure enough, these records reveal his purchase of Newville property lot number 33, on March 21, 1865. He sold this same property September 8, 1866.15 This roughly
Figure 6. Stereoview of Lochman’s home at 38 Pomfret St., Carlisle. Collection of the Cumberland County Historical Society, RS9.
coincides with the dates of his newspaper advertisements that note his business move from Carlisle to a lot on West Louther Street, now part of the campus of Dickinson College, where he lived between 1870 and 1873.16 By 1874, he had moved his family to Allentown. Tax records also reveal Lochman’s whereabouts during his Carlisle years. He is listed in all assessments as an “Artist” living in the West Ward, Carlisle, for the years 1862–1876. The assessments for different years also denote his dwelling places, which dovetail with the property and newspaper advertisements. For example, between 1862 and 1864 he is listed as a tenant; between 1865 and 1873 he is taxed for ownership of various dwellings; between 1874 and 1876 he is taxed, but with “no property listed.” This last bit of information implies that though he had moved his family and set up a drug store in Allentown in 1874, he still maintained business ties with Carlisle. He probably traveled between the two towns during this time period, maintaining a rental property in Carlisle. The “Locomotive Writing Ink” patent was granted to C. L. Lochman of Carlisle in October 1874, but that was long after he had moved to Allentown. Recently, Cumberland County Historical Society cura tor Richard Tritt alerted me about their newly acquired copies of a collection of sixty-four stereoviews.17 All views appear to have been made by Charles Lochman or his gallery assistants; many are clearly labeled “C. L. Lochman” on the reverse, in what I suspect is his handwriting.18 More importantly, many of the stereos match a group of collodion glass stereo negatives in the A. A. Line Collection at the Society. Line was an apprentice to Lochman, then successor to one of his Carlisle galleries. In my previous writings, I had surmised these negatives were made by Lochman, rather than Line, who was quite young, about twelve, when they were produced. The stereo prints prove the negatives were made by Lochman, or at least his gallery. Some of the prints helped to identify locations for unidentified negatives, and vice versa. 16
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 17
LOCHMAN LOCATED
Figure 7. Stereoview of Lochman’s home at W. Louther St., Carlisle. Collection of the Cumberland County Historical Society, RS2.
Figure 8. Stereoview of “Group–Commandant’s House, #64, Lochman’s Stereoscopic Views of Carlisle Barracks,” circa 1861. Collection of the Cumberland County Historical Society, RS33.
Subjects include the ruins of Chambersburg, sacked by Rebel forces in 1864; some offer dated views of the main street and square in Carlisle; and on a more personal level, show images of Lochman’s two Carlisle homes at 38 E. Pomfret and West Louther (figures 6 and 7). The deed research has therefore borne fruit, for we can narrow the dates for the images to the years he owned these properties. There is also a group of views of the Carlisle Barracks with pasted, printed labels on the reverse, “Lochman’s Stereoscopic Views—Carlisle Barracks.” Photographers usually numbered their stereoviews, and these were no exception. The highest number given on the handful of images from Carlisle Barracks is sixty-six, indicating Lochman made and sold at least that number of this series alone (figure 8). The “kicker” in this collection was a sixty-fifth photo graph, a carte-de-visite, not a stereo. It was an image of a photographer who for all the world looked like somebody’s dutch uncle, somberly posed with his arm on a stu dio camera. Because it was purchased with the Charles Lochman stereoviews, the owner assumed it was a selfportrait of Lochman himself. However, the reverse bears the imprint of Lochman’s brother, William J. Lochman of Hamburg. There is no other identification (Figure 9). The fellow has a heavy brow ridge, much like Charles Lochman in the portrait mentioned previously. But as with the cartede-visite of the three photographers, there is no other infor mation on which to base conclusions. Because of the imprint, the image, then, is perhaps William J. Lochman. Only further research and other comparable images will help establish the identity with certainty. What have I gained by additional research on Charles Lochman using more obscure, or less-used resources? I have discovered, as a rule of thumb, that the more obscure the resource, the more specific the information gathered. A federal census population record gives general data about an individual every ten years; a local property deed gives ultra-specific locations and dates. City directories give
business and residential locations; tax records and credit applications give a more precise idea of an individual’s worth. In a pragmatic sense, I can now provide fairly spe cific dates for much of Lochman’s Carlisle period, which will assist in dating his images. In a larger, more academic sense, this has been a journey of self-education as well, for I now realize that photogra phy was an integral, but small percentage of this man’s life. I suspect this is true for many nineteenth century commer cial photographers, who floated in and out of the profes sion as an occasional means of gaining revenue. The career photographers, the ones who stayed in it for life with no other means of income, are probably fewer than we think. Lochman was foremost a chemist, a profession that undoubtedly led him to the allied vocation of photography which was just one means of making a living. He was also a druggist, author, poet, insurance agent, inventor, transla tor, and purveyor of writing ink. It is therefore a disservice to our subjects to dwell only on the photography aspects of their lives, mistakenly assuming images and photography-specific data are the only resources at our disposal. This is like an archeologist who concludes a past culture was based entirely on stone tools, because they are the only artifacts available for research. Organic remains of a culture, such as items made of wood or leather, often do not survive, but are just as crit ical for study. Likewise, if much of the non-photographic aspects of the life of a nineteenth century photographer are not readily apparent, it does not mean they are unavailable for research. There are clues, hints, and crumbs of evidence about these people in our collective written record waiting to be discovered and interpreted. One must try to look at the whole before drawing conclusions about the parts. My research at this point is focused where it began, at the Cumberland County Historical Society. I feel I have come full circle, and analysis of the stereoviews will keep me busy for quite some time. Again I realize one never real ly stops research, but only pauses occasionally to publish. 17
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 18
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
Figure 9. Carte-de-visite of a man and camera, reverse bears the imprint
of William J. Lochman of Hamburg, Pennsylvania.
Collection of the Cumberland County Historical Society, RS1.
18
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 19
LOCHMAN LOCATED
notes
Photographers, (Baltimore, Maryland: Historic Graphics, Inc.). Pennsylvania is covered in volume two (1991), and also includes assessments for Lochman’s two brothers William and Benjamin, and the mysterious William H. Lochman of York. The original lists, however, give more complete information—non-photographic data that Kelbaugh does not include in his directories, but that may be useful for extend ed research purposes. For example, Lochman is also assessed for two gold watches in 1866, an indication of his wealth at the time.
* The initial essay on Lochman from thre first edition of this book is reprinted in the Appendices, beginning at page 141. 1. Eugene A. Rau to J. H. Barnhart, June 7, 1916. The original letter is at the New York Botanical Garden Library, J. H. Barnhart Collection. Lochman’s birth year was actually 1822. A helpful researcher, Mary Panzer, found the letter in 1982 at the Botanical Library, and supplied the Academy with the photocopy. I never would have known about it but for her foresight.
10. Dun & Co. Collection, Pennsylvania, Vol. 87, p. 46, Baker Library, Harvard Business School, Boston, Massachusetts. The Dun Collection is difficult to access. Records are not on microfilm, therefore one must make a personal visit, and the Baker Library does not permit researchers to purchase and permanently retain copies of entries. The Library also main tains the historical business records of the letterbooks with correspondence from photographers all over the country, although I found none relating to Lochman.
2. Bethlehem Globe, August 1900. William J.’s brother Charles died just two weeks later. 3. Eric D. Battorff, “York Area Photographers, 1840–1997,” Special Publication No. 56 of the South Central Pennsylvania Genealogical Society, p. 62. 4. I am grateful to Dr. Joe Nickell of the University of Kentucky for this information. Covill, William E. Jr., Ink Bottles and Ink Wells, Sullwood Publishing (Taunton, Massachusetts), 1971, p. 160.
11. Dun & Co. Collection, Pennsylvania, Vol. 122, p. 113, Baker Library, Harvard Business School, Boston, Massachusetts.
5. “Looking f or Lochman: Researching a Historical Photographer,” by the author, essay in Photographers: A Sourcebook for Historical Research (Nevada City, California: Carl Mautz Publishing), 1991, p. 18. Lochman’s first wife, Margaret Napier of Philadelphia, died in 1867 and is buried in the Old Burying Ground in Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
12. The Civil War Pension Files at the National Archives also include the veteran’s war service records. Neither the com plete Pension nor the Service Files are on microfilm and one must endure a six month wait for copies if corresponding by mail, or visit and examine the records in person. 13. The only reference found to date for Lochman was pointed out to me by a friend who noticed it by chance in an issue of Anthony’s Photographic Bulletin. See: “Looking for Lochman . . .” Photographers: A Sourcebook for Historical Research (Nevada City, California: Carl Mautz Publishing), 1991, p. 18.
6. It is presently unknown if the Allentown Rau Family is relat ed to the Philadelphia photographer William H. Rau. 7. U.S. Census of Manufacturers, 1870, District No. 174, Schedule No. 4, Products of Industry in East Ward, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, page 4. This census is available on microfilm at the National Archives and at many large libraries around the country.
14. Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle Property Deed 2N491, February 19, 1863; Deed 2S95, October 6, 1865; Deed 2V33, April 10, 1867; Deed 2Z179, September 21, 1868. I am grateful to Richard Tritt of the Cumberland County Historical Society for sharing these results of his research.
8. I am grateful to Mark Osterman, editor of the Collodion Journal, for this information.
15. Cumberland County Courthouse, Newville Property Deed 2R206, March 21, 1865; and Deed [?], September 8, 1866.
9. Internal Revenue Assessment Lists for Pennsylvania, 1862–1866, National Archives, Roll 71, M–787. The act was abolished as of July 1, 1873. The lists have been microfilmed only up to 1866. For information between 1866–1873, you must access the original records at the National Archives. Much informa tion from this microfilm has been extracted in a helpful series of publications by Ross J. Kelbaugh, Directory of Civil War
16. Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle Property Deed 3B354, March 31, 1870; and Deed 3L291, June 2, 1873. 17. The originals are owned by a private collector. 18. I have other examples of Lochman’s handwriting, and the
19
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 20
Figure 1. Storage cabinets for the Andrew J. Russell collection of collodion “wet plate” negatives in the Oakland Museum of California History Department. Containing nearly 800 wet-plate negatives of construction of the transcontinental railroad in the 1860s, the collection is one of the largest and most important archives of collodian negatives outside of federal archives. Pictured is Marcia Eymann, Curator of Historical Photography, Oakland Museum of California.
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 21
The Regional Photography Collection
A Case Study at the Oakland Museum of California Drew Heath Johnson Upon opening its doors in 1969, the new Oakland Museum boldly proclaimed its identity as “The Museum of California,” the first major museum devoted exclusively to the art, history and ecology of the golden state. Housed in a sprawling, innovative 7.7 acre building which some said resembled a garden more than an intimidating temple of high culture, the new institution had ambitions beyond those of a typical municipal museum. Strolling its three permanent galleries and 20,000 feet of temporary exhibi tion space, visitors encountered a sweeping view of the region’s natural setting, the history of its people from pre historic times, and the art they had created. Clearly, some thing important was happening at the Oakland Museum.1 Particularly in the field of art, the new Museum amounted to a declaration of independence for a region whose culture was often regarded with disdain or suspicion by the eastern art establishment. In the words of former curator Paul Mills, “It is hard today to understand what a variant, radical idea specializing in California art, especially in its historic phases, was then.”2 The very identity of the region’s aes thetic heritage was in question. Was there, in fact, such a thing as a California tradition in the visual arts? If so, how could that tradition be interpreted in an innovative and engaging way? Much to the credit of the Museum’s founders, photogra phy was given a high priority in framing a reply to these questions. Two of the Museum’s three departments, Art and History, devoted great energy to building definitive collections of California photography. The late 1960s were propitious times to take on the task of assembling a worldclass, regional photography collection. A seed was provid ed by the former collections of the old Oakland Museum and Municipal Art Gallery, which had collected a smatter ing of photographs from the 1920s on. By 1969, many of the best known California photographers of the first half of the twentieth century were still living. Imogen Cunningham, Ansel Adams, Dorothea Lange, Minor White and others represented the older generation—artists who had made an enormous, world-wide impact on the development of photography as a legitimate, expressive art. These photog raphers were personally cultivated by curators in the Museum, as were the heirs of deceased artists such as Anne Brigman, Edward Weston, Arnold Genthe and others. This policy resulted in several seminal gifts to the collection. Lange’s estate represented perhaps the most impressive of all. Although she passed away during construction of the Museum, her husband Paul Taylor honored her wishes by donating her personal archive of prints and negatives, ultimately a gift of more than thirty thousand images. In the midst of this collecting activity, California photo graphy in the late sixties and early seventies was under
going a revolution in style and technique, thanks to a new generation of artists. Judy Dater, Richard Misrach, Bill Owens and Robert Heinecken among many others were in their prime, producing work that would define the art of photography in the second half of the century, much as Weston and Lange had in the first. Curators also involved these photographers in the creation of the new Museum, both by invitations to participate in exhibitions and through gifts to the collection. As important as these gifts were, donations of photo graphs alone could not build a collection of the scope envi sioned by the Museum’s founders. Where purchases became necessary, the timing was also fortunate, for pho tography had not yet claimed much of a presence on the fine art market. Anyone familiar with recent auction results knows that photography has finally claimed its place as a desirable and expensive art collectible. It is difficult to imagine, from this perspective, just how affordable good photography was just a couple of decades ago. This fact helped the Museum to build its collection in two ways: not only were purchases affordable, but artists and collectors had less motivation to sell, providing further incentive for donations of California photography. All of which begs the question: “What is California pho tography?” This deceptively simple query is precisely the issue Therese Thau Heyman faced upon arriving as the Museum’s first curator of photography in 1961, fully nine years before the building opened. Definitions seemed in order. The obvious answer: “Pictures taken in California.” But might California photography also encompass work done by photographers identified as California artists, whether taken in the state or not? (For example, Carleton Watkins’ work in Yellowstone and Oregon or Edward Weston’s photographs of Mexico). Conversely, photogra phers not identified as Californian often visited the state, and many have produced work of great interest (Robert Frank, Diane Arbus and William Henry Jackson spring to mind). Should these images be included? Chronology required definition as well: what time period should the collection represent? Of course this was less of an issue for photography, which had a recognizable begin ning, than for other arts. As Heyman wrote, “Both California and the technologies of photography . . . were in their infancies in the 1840s and 1850s.”3 She and the staff of the Museum made the decision to adopt the broadest possible definition, to cast the widest net in defining the photography of California. Visitors to museums across the country were already acquainted with the traditional presentation of matted and framed photographs on paper; in Oakland, curators expanded the meaning of photographic art to include other sorts of treasures. Daguerreotypes, albums, 21
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 22
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
autochromes, cameras and darkroom equipment, panora mas, snapshots, photographically illustrated books and periodicals, huge negative collections, commercial photo graphs, the photograph “morgue” of a century-old urban newspaper, and a souvenir coffee can with a photograph by Ansel Adams—all have been collected and displayed by the Museum at various times. Further guidance for collecting was suggested by the Museum’s basic structure, with the Art Department tending to favor the work of expressive artists, and the History Department more concerned with images possessing his toric or documentary value. This too is fraught with ambi guities and value judgements. If Anne Brigman clearly falls into the “fine art” category and a carte-de-visite portrait is “historical” or documentary in nature, where then does the work of Dorothea Lange belong? Or anonymous daguerreo types of the California Gold Rush? Despite early protesta tions against being labeled an “artist,” Lange came in time to regard herself in that light; similarly, there are “documen tary” daguerreotypes in the collection that are quite simply as beautiful as any photographs taken in the past 160 years. These are currently fashionable lines of inquiry, which go to the heart of the age-old debate over photography’s place among the more venerable arts. The issue of bound aries in the discussion of photography as art and history are ambiguous, with definitions continually shifting. In gener al, the categories of photographic criticism and curatorial theory are much less rigid than they were twenty-five years ago when the Museum first opened (Weston was art; stereo views were not). The anonymous portrait and the commer cial photograph now take their place next to beautiful and meticulously crafted exhibition prints. A recent show of anonymous snapshots at the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art (closely following an exhibition of police pho tography!) was an indication, from a mainstream art muse um, that non-traditional photographic imagery is acceptable to audiences if presented in a serious manner. Such a willingness to break traditional barriers is utterly consistent with the sorts of collecting and exhibition policies adopted by the Oakland Museum twenty-five years ago.
approach to integrating photography into permanent displays of historical objects, painting and sculpture. Photographs are chosen for their importance as individual works of art, but equal weight is given to an image’s place within an artistic movement, its interpretive value in tracing aesthetic, technical and social trends, or the way in which it illustrates an artist’s development. Although displays follow a rough chronological scheme, the openness of gal leries and the close proximity of art from different periods encourages visitors to make connections and discover continuities in California art and history. While permanent displays call on visitors to see the “big picture,” special exhibitions offer an opportunity to exam ine a particular artist or period in detail. Oakland has a number of special galleries set aside for temporary exhibi tions, including the Oakes Gallery in the Art Department, an intimate space specifically designed for photographs and other small works. Since 1969, the Museum has an exceptional record of frequent temporary photography exhibitions covering the entire scope of photography in the state, ranging from single artist retrospectives and experi mental exhibitions to massive historical overviews. Such temporary exhibitions also offer an opportunity to present work, through loans, owned by private collectors and other institutions. As an example, the recent exhibition of cased images from the California Gold Rush, Silver & Gold, pre sented daguerreotypes and ambrotypes from more than forty-five collections across the country.
Issues of Cataloging Of course, every photograph in collections must be tracked, whether in storage, on display or on loan to other institu tions. Such basic information as artist, physical dimensions, precise storage location, donor and insurance value must be recorded for hundreds of thousands of photographs and kept centrally available. In the early years of the Museum, this information was kept as file cards and catalog sheets, but in the 1980s conversion to electronic records began. Funded by special grants, a massive data-entry drive accomplished the remarkable task of creating computer records for virtually all of the Museum’s collections. Partly because of its flexibility in this area, the ARGUS database was selected. Designed specifically for museums, ARGUS proved enormously flexible for a multi-disciplinary, regional museum such as Oakland. Collections from all three departments are linked but clearly demarcated in a single database, which is in turn linked to the fund-raising and membership arms of the institution. Objects are tracked from their first appearance at the Museum to their final dis position in collections or displays, with video images and source information such as donor meticulously tracked. From the beginning, the regional focus of the institution has guided cataloging as well as collecting policies, partic ularly in the thorny field of subject indexing. Computer technology has offered the tantalizing possibility of effec tive searches of large photographic collections based on their subject content. But what is a photograph’s subject? In the most basic sense, the objects, individuals, location, date and other physical descriptors of an image are its “subject.” But what of its value in explaining larger issues in history?
Issues of Display Having established collecting guidelines, the Museum faced issues of interpretation and display. More than most works of art or historical objects, photographic collections have precise and unique requirements for preservation. Issues of temperature, humidity and above all, light expo sure place severe restrictions on exhibition. The very notion of “permanent” displays of photography is controversial, as it implies long-term exposure to gallery lights. Since only a tiny fraction of the collection may be on display at any time, the problem of image rotation is usually resolved by the simple expedient of pulling a new photograph from storage. Even so, there are certain icons that are so emblem atic of the development of photography that a temptation exists to exhibit them more than is healthy. A partial solu tion in Oakland has been the installation of motion sensor lights over such popular images, which only illuminate when visitors come within a few feet of the photograph. Early on, the Oakland Museum took an innovative 22
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 23
THE REGIONAL PHOTOGRAPHY COLLECTION
Issues of Public Access and Research The Oakland Museum of California is a public museum, supported by funds from a combination of Federal, State and City agencies as well as private foundations. The radi cal decline in government funding for museums in recent years has resulted in drastic staff cuts, without reducing our obligation to provide access to collections and archives. Computerized collection records have helped somewhat, by allowing visitors to search collections on their own, but this is also a mixed blessing. Easy, self-guided access to col lections, whether by serious scholars or the general public, gives visitors a glimpse of collections rarely if ever exhibit ed. Rather than reduce demands on staff, such effortless access has increased the use of collections, encouraging more publication, loans and collection research, all of which call for heavy involvement by curators and registrars. Perhaps more important, the philosophical ramifica tions of random public access to the complete, but unedit ed, collections of images, without the mediation of a curator, are just beginning to emerge. Such access calls into question old notions of the museum as Guardian of Culture, a place where one goes to find art or history or sci ence presented, interpreted through the eyes of connois seurs and experts. It looks instead toward a vision of museums as places of discovery, where one might use the evidence of collections to challenge accepted views, even those presented by the museum itself. The degree to which the Oakland Museum of California has opened its collec tions, welcoming this participation of new voices and ideas, provides a model for a new vision of museums in the twenty-first century. It is a vision wholly consistent with the Museum’s aims and history since 1969. A collection is (or should be) a living, breathing thing, open to new concepts but not dictated by fashions. The har monious blend of images from a century-and-a-half of West Coast photography housed at the Oakland Museum of California represents an epic spectrum of photographic art and history, shown in an innovative and accessible fashion. The source of the collection’s strength lies in its regional focus. From the work of the first daguerreians who came ashore at San Francisco in 1849, to the postmodern visions of artists that question the very nature of the medium, the Museum continues to collect the images that give California a unique and influential place in the history of photography.4
Its place in an artistic style or school? Its relation to the Museum’s California mission? Developing usable subject terms for such concepts required connoisseurship and a scholarly familiarity with topics in the humanities and arts as they relate to California. It also required a computer lexicon of great power and flexibility which could adapt to the special concerns of a regional museum. To help develop such a lexicon, outside scholars from various disciplines were brought into the Museum to give advice regarding current thought on topics in California studies, the arts and humanities. Subject terms developed from these meetings were then entered into records to describe images in the collection. Subject indexing is a massive and ongoing project, to a large extent imperfectly implemented, but which has increased intellectual access to collections in a way unthinkable a decade ago. It is now possible to search photographic archives such as the Dorothea Lange Collection, creating lists (with video images) in a matter of minutes.
Issues of Storage and Conservation Because only a fraction of collections are exhibited at any given time, proper storage is a primary concern. Photographic collections present a bewildering array of antique and obsolete processes, each with unique preserva tion needs. Photographs are usually flat and require less space for storage, but such collections tend to contain a large number of items. In Oakland, the great majority of exhibitable photographs on paper are kept unframed, boxed in flat storage. Most are matted, although large collections, such as work prints, are filed in Mylar sleeves. Framed works are kept vertical in sliding racks, which allows storage of the largest possible number of photographs in the small est possible space. Temperature and humidity are carefully controlled in storage areas, as in exhibition spaces. Negative collections offer special challenges for storage and access. Glass negatives face obvious dangers, particu larly in earthquake country, which are compounded by their sheer weight. Storage cabinets for collections such as Andrew J. Russell’s collodion negatives are carefully anchored to concrete floors, with special latches to prevent accidental opening. Although more recent, film negatives can actually deteriorate far more rapidly than glass, due to “inherent vice” (a conservator’s term), which causes them to decompose from within. The instability and combust ibility of nitrate negatives is well publicized, sometimes to the detriment of later, less stable acetate negative collec tions. The Oakland Museum of California is implementing a grant for refrigerated storage of nitrate negatives, a process which has proven far more complex than imag ined. Besides the technical challenges of maintaining on-site accessibility to negatives while controlling tem perature and humidity, the Museum faces a thicket of complicated fire codes designed to ensure safety from a potentially toxic collection. Although early safety films made of acetate do not pose such a fire danger, they tend to be even less stable than nitrate films, their base subject to alarming shrinking which cracks and shrivels the emulsion.
Notes 1. In order to reinforce its identity as “the Museum of California,” not just a city museum, the institution’s name was recently changed to “Oakland Museum of California.” 2. Paul Mills, quoted in The Art of California: Selected Works from the Collection of the Oakland Museum, Christina Orr-Cahall, edi tor, (Oakland: The Oakland Museum Art Department and Chronicle Books), 1984, pp. 9–10. 3. Therese Thau Heyman, “California Prints, Photographs and Drawings,” from Orr-Cahall, The Art of California, p. 24. 4. 1849 is the earliest known presence of daguerreians. It seems unlikely that no daguerreotype artists visited California before the Gold Rush, but years of research by Peter Palmquist and others has failed to discover irrefutable evidence of prior visits. 23
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 24
Tintype, c. 1865. Collection of Jeremy Rowe.
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 25
Copyrights and Other Rights
Jeremy Rowe
The Image Market The control of photographs and other visual resources is a vital concern for both private and public collections. Questions and issues of ownership and the rights to use and reproduce images are complex. The answers depend on many factors, including the circumstances of acquisi tion, age of the image, provenance, and the status of the previous owner. As the market for images continues to grow, it is important to understand the changing legal and technological environment in which researchers, collectors, curators, and publishers must work. The interest in historic images—and their value—has grown remarkably as a result of film documentaries, the awareness of the fine arts market, and the voracious appetite of multimedia. Digital media, including CDROMs, Internet, and the World Wide Web, and the ease of reproducing, retouching and distributing material, have further fueled the demand. The total market for all photographs is now estimated at a billion dollars per year, and historic images represent a rapidly expanding share. The high demand and prospects for profit have led to the creation of companies that deal in stock images. Some of these large agencies such as the Bettmann Archive, Liaison, and Digital Stock, have merged into huge consortiums. Corbis [http://www.corbis.com], operated by Bill Gates, controls the Bettmann Archive, Ansel Adams collection and electronic rights for museum collections including those of The Hermitage. Corbis aggressively acquires and markets both contemporary and historic visual materials. Getty Images [http://www.gettyimages.com/] is operated by oil company heir, Mark Getty. Other potential forces in the stock photography market are museums, educational institutions, private and public collections, and companies with access to images, such as auction houses. With the increased awareness of the value of collections, many public institutions face the dilemma of providing access, while retaining some level of control. Administrators are changing their policies, and many are creating and marketing their own stock collections or forming cooperatives. One example is the Museum Digital Licensing Collective, Inc. which includes the Amon Carter Museum, The Historical Society of Washington, DC, and The New York Public Library. By coordinating their efforts, these groups not only improve the level of control over their resources, but provide greater public access to collec tions with digital and computer systems. Private individuals, photograph dealers, and auction houses have begun to create their own stock collections, and are becoming more aggressive in monitoring uses and in demanding royalty, permission, and use fees. Digital technology has brought about an urgent need for
copy protection and water-marking software. Companies such as Digimarc provide methods to encode ownership information in digital images, and to track their use on the Internet and in print. New programs are being developed that permit copyright holders to bill those who view, download, and use digital images. One result of the growing market is an increase in the fees charged for reproduction and use. The large stock agencies have raised their prices and many private and public institutions followed suit. Charges at the present time vary from a few dollars to $200 or more per image. Fees are kept low in some cases because images may be obtained in numerous places, and copies of historical images can be found in many collections. The fees also tend to be lower for contemporary commercial photography. Nevertheless, academic publishers and scholars who were previously granted free or reduced rates by many collections, now face significant charges and commercial-style contracts. This has placed a greater financial strain on authors and researchers as well, who may be required to provide pho tographs to their publishers along with their manuscripts. Because historic images are a limited resource, the growth of the market is inevitable and fees probably will continue to escalate as the entire system becomes ever more complex.
Background: Copyright and Ownership For years, many authors used libraries and archives as sources of images to illustrate their articles and texts. Typically, they would visit an institution, browse and select photographs, then order copies for publication. The costs often included the production of a negative and print. Occasionally the institution charged a fee for non academic publications or commercial uses. They usually required a credit line to indicate the source of the image, and sometimes a copy of the published article or book. Rarely was any attention paid to the context of the intended use or accuracy of presentation of the image, and few controls were in place to follow up on the image or its future uses. Today, however, researchers and authors face a daunt ing task when seeking illustrations, and must address chal lenging questions such as the following: • What rights do you obtain when you purchase or acquire a
photograph? If you have a physical copy in hand, can you copy it and use it for your own private or commercial uses? • Can you restrict others from reproducing the image from
their original copies?
• Can you sell copies of the photograph for others to use? • Can you display the image in your office reception room or
public space?
25
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 26
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
Can you post a scanned copy on your Web page or as part of an electronic publication? Can you continue to use copies after you sell the original image?
outlined in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act that, if successful, would return everything to the 1976 calendar. Once a work is created and fixed in a tangible form such as a photographic image, copyright law assigns several important rights to the copyright holder. They may permit or restrict the following:
If you sell or buy an image through an auction or on consignment, do you or the auction house control future publication of the image? Several factors are involved in determining ownership of a photograph, including copyright law, the ownership status of the seller or donor, and the rights that are trans ferred as a result of sale or gift. Copyright and intellectual property law has the greatest potential impact. These laws vary from country to country; those in effect in the United States will be considered here. United States copyright laws apply to tangible, fixed works, such as photographs, and assigns ownership to the creator, or to the hiring agent in specific cases defined as“work for hire.” The duration of ownership depends on the age of the image and the copyright laws that were in effect when the image was created (see table at http://www.library.yale.edu/~okerson/pubdomain.html). An important factor in determining the length of time a work is protected is whether or not it was published. Until recently, copyright assigned ownership for a finite time, and barring unusual circumstances, extended for a maxi mum of 75 years for items created and published before the 1976 revision. Material originally created and published after 1976 is copyright protected for the life of the creator plus 50 years. Unpublished materials, such as diaries and family snapshots, were protected for the life of the creator plus 50 years. Congress delayed initial implementation of this provision, however. Under the copyright revision that took effect in 1978, the copyright holder of unpublished material was given control of use until 2003 regardless of the original creation date. After the time specified under copyright law, ownership control lapses, and the item enters the public domain; the original creator or copyright holder has little or no legal right to control its subsequent use. Copyright notices are no longer required, but in works published before 1986 the failure to include it or the use of an incorrect notice potentially shortens the protection period. Such materials may have fallen out of the control of the copyright holder. This creates yet another category of public domain as a potential resource for researchers and publishers. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act, passed October 1998, has changed public domain timelines and is an excel lent example of the shifting legal environment. The act was strongly supported by businesses such as Walt Disney Productions, and the estates of creative individuals such as the Gershwins, whose valuable property would soon enter the public domain. Under this law, a twenty-year moratori um is established, and only material published prior to January 1923 will lose copyright protection. Thus, no new material will enter the public domain until 2018. The impact on unpublished work is unclear, since the act does not specifically address such material. A further compli cation is a recent legal challenge to the extension of protection
1. Copying or reproducing the work (such as print or electronic reproduction of a photograph);
2. Preparing derivative works (such as scanning to create
a digital copy of a photograph);
3. Distributing or marketing copies of the work (such as posting a digital copy on the Internet, selling posters,
postcards, or copy prints of the image);
4. Publicly displaying the work (such as in museum or gallery).
Each of these four rights is separate and the copyright holder may permit or restrict others from using the materi al in any or all of these ways. In addition, they may retain, assign, or license each of the rights listed below, in whole or part, to another party: • License a single right, such as reproduction for publication,
or involve all aspects of copyright ownership for a given work. • Restrict use to a single instance, such as one print edition, or unlimited use, such as permitting unlimited print and electronic reproduction. • Grant rights for a finite or unrestricted period of time. Obtaining permission can be a complex and sometimes frustrating process, particularly if any or all of the rights have been transferred to another party. There is no central repository of information about the rights held or trans ferred, and in many cases extensive research may be neces sary to locate the owner of the copyright. In addition, there is no requirement for the copyright holder to grant permis sions or to respond to requests. Failure of the copyright holder to respond does not imply permission. There is one exception to the requirement to obtain per mission of the copyright holder for any of the four cate gories of uses outlined above, defined as fair use. The fair use exemption permits some types of use, such as in edu cation and reporting (see 17 USC Sec. 107). One of the key factors in determining fair use is the potential impact on the marketability of the item in ques tion. In the digital environment, building a case for fair use is troublesome because of the ease of duplication of files, and the difficulty in controlling it. Digitizing a photograph creates a derivative work, a right not addressed under fair use, and requires permission of the copyright holder. Obviously, any digital posting on CD-ROM or the World Wide Web will affect the market for the work. Unfortunately the laws and policies change much slow er than technology. Most were established long before the advent of Internet and digital imaging, and are still grap pling with issues related to past developments such as pho tocopying and video. Recently, however, international agreements have addressed the problems, and congress 26
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 27
COPYRIGHTS AND OTHER RIGHTS
has moved to amend and update copyright law. Researchers should be aware of the changes, and periodi cally monitor the revisions.
copyright policies under the World International Property Organization (WIPO). The concept of moral rights varies significantly across countries. In general, they transcend the assignable copyrights and address the ability of the author or creator to claim ownership and object to distor tion, mutilation, modification, or derogatory action related to their honor or reputation. Some countries such as France, include the right of retraction—the authority to remove the work from public view. Another issue currently in flux is the right of publicity, and the use of the likeness of recognizable personalities such as Charlie Chaplin, W. C. Fields, James Dean, as well as unauthorized pictures of private individuals. Strong lob bying, particularly by the entertainment industry and estates of prominent people, has led to increasing control of the use of photographs by individuals and their estates. Again, even though you own an original copy of a photo graph, the right of publicity may limit your ability to use the image in other ways without obtaining permission from the subject. An interesting variation of individual control of their likeness has arisen in Hopi Tribal Resolution H-70-94 (adopted May 23, 1994) and policy documents from the Hopi Cultural Preservation office. Under the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAG PRA), the Hopi demand that archival records, including field notes, audio tapes, videotapes, (and) photographs; which describe and depict esoteric ritual, ceremonial, and religious knowledge, be placed under restriction by muse ums and other repositories for public access and hereby are declared to be the cultural property of the Hopi people. The Hopi seek to limit exploitation of their culture and beliefs by controlling access to collateral materials such as photographs. The tribe has worked for years with local museums and public collections to educate archivists and assist in identifying sensitive materials whose access and use should, in their view, be restricted. The interesting factor is the claim of a broader moral right to control access, instead of the trail of ownership upon which copyright is based. Case law which addresses moral rights and rights of publicity is relatively sparse, so legal interpretations are the primary guide to decisions concerning liability and the potential risks of using non-public domain photographs and images of individuals. The pace of change in copyright and intellectual proper ty issues has increased dramatically with the advent of scanners, digital reproduction, and the Internet. The Internet evolved as a tool for education and research. Since its recent transition from a non-profit educational entity to a commercial media, its tone now emphasizes ownership and control. Other factors that are affecting the rate of change in copyright licensing and use include:
Application: How Copyright Affects Photographic Researchers Virtually all original prints of historical photographs pub lished before January 1923 are now in the public domain. This means that anyone possessing an original image pro duced before that date can copy, prepare derivative works, distribute, or display the photograph without obtaining permission. The most common method of controlling reproduction is limiting access to the original photograph. Access and use of unpublished materials or those creat ed after January 1923 can be much more complex, since each of the four rights of the copyright holder can be con trolled separately. For example, it is possible to acquire a physical print of an image through purchase or gift, with out obtaining any other rights to the image. The copyright holder may retain any or all of the supplemental rights associated with subsequent use of the work. Copyright has little impact on reproduction of historical images from public or private collections if they are in the public domain, despite the many policies and release forms involved. Here, too, control is maintained by limited access. Savvy collections have begun to indicate in their release forms and reproduction contracts that they only provide access, and in no way warrant copyright permis sion. The researcher or publisher is held responsible for researching copyright status, and for obtaining the neces sary licenses and permissions. Many photographers and artists and their estates—such as those of Ansel Adams, Edward Weston, Georgia O’Keefe, Dorothea Lange—retain the rights to their images, and have begun to aggressively protect them. However, some of the work done for the federal government—the Farm Security Administration or National Parks Service, for example—may be governed by the agency policies and is not under the control of the individ ual or their estate. Government collections such as the National Archives hold materials produced under contract and typically include assignment of rights to government entities. Reproduction for print is relatively straightfor ward, and other than using frequently reproduced collec tions, raise few concerns for older, public domain material. Recently, however, some subcontractors have begun to grant the government agency permissions for specific use only, and retain other ownership rights. Electronic access to government collections, such as the Library of Congress American Memory project may involve addressing the ownership claims of the subcon tractors. Those who created the digital derivative works by scanning and structuring the image collections may retain some ownership rights. The issue of ownership of deriva tive works has yet to play out in the courts, but appears to hinge on the level of creative input in digitizing projects, as well as project contracts. Moral rights extend beyond the life of the creator and are becoming a more important factor in use of photo graphs, as the U.S. and other countries coordinate their
• The entry of Microsoft and Corbis into the field of digital
image licensing. • Enhanced tracking and reporting capabilities of water
marking software and related services.
• Increasing marketplace for licensing and use of images. • Aggressive efforts of publishers and producers in the
review and recommended revision of copyright law, and 27
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 28
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
U. S. participation in international copyright and intellectual property treaties.
• Ease of digital copying and distribution and the potential for loss of revenue, attribution, and subsequent control of uses once material has been posted without permission.
As fees continue to rise and the legal issues become more complicated, many scholars find it advantageous to acquire original images in their area of interest. When this involves private sources or auction, it is important to ask what policies affect the transfer of ownership, particularly for images less than 75 years old or unpublished material. Relevant questions include:
Recommendations Researching the copyright status of a photograph intended for publication is a vital part of the project. Currently, the process for print is less complex than for electronic publica tion. Some of the steps are listed below: Identify the intended uses as completely as possible. Specify whether the material will be printed or distributed electronically; if it is for an academic journal or for-profit publisher; the size of print run, etc. Will supplemental materials such as video or CD-ROM, or on-line presenta tion be a component of the project? Identify the warrants and permissions made by the col lection, and whether they provide access to the image, copyright permissions, or both. Donor or gift stipulations that may limit use should be noted for materials protected by copyright, such as photographs created after January 1, 1923, or unpublished images. If necessary, obtain contact information for, and permissions from parties who may have an ownership claim to the images before publication. Check the current length of Copyright duration and the date for public domain status. Determine whether the material was published prior to 1978. If not, copyright pro tection may extend until at least 2003 or the life of the cre ator plus fifty years, whichever is longest. If the material was not published, use will probably require permission from the copyright holder. Note whether the image is from an original print or copy print. Many collections have been built on copy prints from other collections. Rarely are reproduction rights transferred along with the copy print. Reproduction from published material may also involve the additional copyright claim of the author or publisher. Whenever pos sible, for reasons of both ownership and reproduction quality, locate and work with an original print rather than a copy. Determine if the work was created by a well-known pho tographer or publisher. If so, the photographer, estate, or designee may retain ownership of some or all rights needed for publication. Also, materials created in other countries may be more heavily influenced by moral rights, potential ly limiting some uses without additional permissions. Identify any fees for duplication and reproduction that are associated with the intended use. Also, note whether copies of the publication are required by the collection. Identify necessary credits and insure that they are included throughout the reproduction and publication process. Get all agreements and stipulations in writing from collections and copyright holders. Many publishers now require verification of permissions, such as reproduction, display or other rights that are involved in a given project. For your protection, maintain a file of correspondence related to your research, including written permissions and fees paid.
• What ownership rights reside in the image? • Who controls any subsidiary rights not associated with
the sale? • Are any ownership rights transferred to the purchaser, or
is only the physical copy of the image involved? • What rights are transferred and what rights, if any are
retained, if an auction or dealer is involved? For example, do they retain any rights to reproduce images? Historical photographs have become a valuable resource for individuals and private and public collections. Hope fully, this essay will promote a general awareness and act as a catalyst for action to clarify policies and action to influ ence the changing copyright and ownership environment.
PROBLEMS, DISCUSSION AND SOLUTIONS 1. The Curator’s Nightmare As a curator of an institution, you have just completed an exhibition addressing the early settlement of your local area. The signature photograph of the exhibition is a unique daguerreotype from the institution’s collection. The daguerreotype was used to illustrate the exhibition’s cata logue and in the solicitation literature for a campaign to attract donations for a new building. As you are driving to a fund-raising event, you notice a billboard for a nationally advertised soft drink which uses the institution’s daguerreotype image to show community pioneers imbibing the soda pop. The daguerreotype has been altered and some individuals eliminated from the image, and of course, no credit is given to the institution. What is your recourse? The issues are: 1. What rights does the institution have over the reproduction of the daguerreotype? 2. What restrictions, if any, apply to the reproduction of the daguerreotype image by the owner, its agents or assigns, or third parties with no ownership interest in the daguerreotype? Discussion: 1. Unless the institution purchased the daguerreotype under a reservation of rights from a prior owner, it holds the right to reproduce the daguerreotype itself. This is a property right. The institution also holds the right to restrict the use of reproductions of the daguerreotype by third parties. This is a privilege of the property owner that can be exercised through the law of contracts. Assuming the daguerreotype was made prior to January 1, 1923, and was “published” prior to that year, the institution does not hold the “copyright” to the daguerreotype. When the copyright term ends, a creative work such as a 28
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 29
COPYRIGHTS AND OTHER RIGHTS
f. Payment, including monetary and/or copies of the finished product; g. Permitted length of use; h. Contact information to obtain permission for any
additional uses;
i. Transfer restrictions regarding third-party use.
daguerreotype enters the “public domain” allowing any one to copy the original without restriction. Therefore, if the daguerreotype was made before January 1, 1923, and was published prior to that time, it is in the public domain and anyone owning a copy of the daguerreotype, or rights to reproduce the image that pre dates its acquisition by the institution, could give the soft drink company the right to use the image. However, if the daguerreotype was never “published,” i.e., reproduced and distributed, it may be protected as an unpublished work until at least 2003 under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The duration of this protection will be clarified as the legislation is interpreted by case law.
Realistically, a written agreement cannot prevent all unauthorized use, because it is difficult to follow the trail of photographs as they wind through production companies and advertising agencies. The greater the scope of restric tions, the more time required to monitor the photographs and the more reluctant a producer may be to use them.
2. If the reproduction of the daguerreotype used by the soft drink company was made from a copy made by the institution or a prior owner and the copy had been deliv ered to a third party with contract restrictions, then the soft drink company would be subject to those restrictions even though the copy was in the public domain under copyright law. When a copy of an image is made avail able, conditions of use such as permission for reproduc tion, commercial use and credits required, and any editorial restrictions such as limitations to cropping or captions, must be clearly stated.
3. Auction Purchase You have purchased a photograph for your collection from an auction house. A few months later you are pleased to find an article providing new information about the pho tographer. Your photograph is used to illustrate the article, but the ownership is attributed to the auction house and not to the consignor nor to you, the purchaser. When you call the auction house for an explanation, they inform you that they operate a stock photography service and routinely retain and sell reproduction rights to photographs they sell at auction. Discussion: Copyright considerations as discussed in“The Curator’s Nightmare” above pertain to this question. If the photo graph was made and published after January 1, 1923, or was unpublished, you may have acquired the image but not the reproduction, use, or other rights. The creator may still retain copyright control over the image and can control use and authorize others to reproduce the image. If the auction company operates a stock business and obtains permission from the consignor or, if appropriate, from the copyright holder to use the photograph for publicity and advertising or for stock use, there is little you can do to restrict such use. If reproduction rights are an issue, you should ask about future uses of the photograph before bidding. As the mar ket demand for photographs continues to grow, the market ing of reproduction rights will become more enticing.
2. A Collector’s Temptation As a private collector, you are flattered when a major film company calls you about the development of a historical documentary that might include photographs in your collec tion. They have heard of your collection and expertise and would like to discuss their project with you. At the meeting they select several photographs from your collection and state that you will be prominently included in the credits and will receive a videotape copy of the film when it is com pleted. You provide them with background information about the photographs, allow them to videotape them, and provide several slides in case they are needed. A few months later you see a promotional brochure for the film with one of your photographs on the cover with no attribution to you. In addition, the photograph has been used in a way that is his torically inaccurate and ignores your research.
4. Historical Society Use To fill gaps in the collection of your local historical society, you make copies of your photographs for them. You receive a letter of thanks from the outgoing society presi dent. Later that year, you receive a solicitation to buy a cal ender from the society. Your images are prominently used to illustrate the calendar, but they are credited to the society’s collection. To make matters worse, their collection is absorbed by a state agency and your images now appear on their Web page and include strict warnings not to copy or use them without permission. Your name and your asso ciation with the material are nowhere to be found.
Discussion: With no written agreement, you have little or no recourse against the production company. Although oral agree ments are enforceable, your case is difficult to prove with out a written contract, and invites much greater loss than the use of your photograph. If control of your photographs is important, a written agreement is essential and must include the following:
a. Description of each photograph; b. Formats in which each photograph may be used, such as print, video, world wide web, etc.; c. Permitted use in derivative media, such as advertising,
promotion, etc.;
d. Limitations, such as number of uses, editorial consider
ations such as cropping, etc.;
e. Required acknowledgments or credits;
Discussion: Without a written agreement restricting use, there is noth ing you can do about the use of your photographs in the society’s calendar. Regarding the use by the state agency, you can inform 29
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 30
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
the agency of your claim of rights in the photographs and request that the images be correctly credited or removed, but you are at the mercy of the new director and staff for resolving the issue. Without a written agreement restrict ing use, you cannot require the state agency to withdraw your images from their web page. If you want to control use of your donations to an insti tution, you must have a written agreement such as that discussed above in “A Collector’s Temptation.” In addi tion, you should clearly mark each image with your iden tity as the source. Marking can include stamped ID on the reverse, credit line in the photo, electronic water marking, or other methods. Some circumstances may dictate pro viding a lower quality copy such as a photocopy or low resolution scan to limit possible uses to research and not reproduction.
Your publisher sends a contract that requires you to warrant that you have appropriate permissions and clear ances for all of the images submitted with the manuscript. Discussion: What do you need to do before you can commit to the publisher’s contract?
a. Virtually all creative works published before January 1, 1923, are in the public domain and therefore have little or no limitations on reproduction rights. Unpublished materi als may still be protected under the digital Millennium Copyright Act or common law copyright and such use will be based on practical considerations determined in discus sions with the publisher. For example, an anonymous carte-de-visite portrait found at a flea market would be extremely unlikely to cause a problem under common law copyright theory. b. The FSA materials were produced after 1923, but were made under contract to the government that allows free use of any of its photographs. Reproduction from original prints in an institution or with permission from a source such as the Library of Congress or National Archives will likely be a matter of filling out forms and paying a modest copying fee. However, if the images were not made under the federal contract, permission of the copyright holder would be needed for the publication. c. In the case of Ansel Adams images or those of other photog raphers made after 1923, permission from the copyright holder would be required to meet your publisher’s require ments for your manuscript.
5. A History Book You are working on a book that documents the history of your town, and intend to illustrate it with photographs. You plan to use the following images: a. Historic post cards and photographs taken by local photog raphers between 1870 and 1920. The sources of these images are your collection and public archives; b. Views of building facades taken by Walker Evans and Arthur Rothstein while they worked for the Farm Security Administration. These images are available by copying vintage prints owned by the local museum; c. Scenic views of the area taken by Ansel Adams from origi nal prints in your collection.
30
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 31
COPYRIGHTS AND OTHER RIGHTS
31
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 32
Female photographic retoucher at work, photographer unknown, c. 1880. Copy print from the collection of Peter E. Palmquist.
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 33
Women in Photography International Archive Peter E. Palmquist
The Women in Photography International Archive is a grassroots, research-oriented agency located in Arcata, California. Its stated goals are to identify, collect, preserve, and disseminate information about women photographers. This material has been gathered without a predetermined bias for one particular type of photography and encom passes work by commercial and amateur photographers, fine art and performance photographers, photo-journalists, feminist image makers, and film makers. Photo-related activities and professions are also tracked, and include stu dio bookkeepers, retouchers and colorists, Kodak finishers, camera clerks and others. Indexing of the collection’s resources is ongoing, and a limited publishing program is planned. Eventually, it is hoped that the WIP Archive will become part of a major research institution to continue in perpetuity. Ambitious? Yes! This ambition becomes more remark able when you consider the modest beginnings of the WIP Archive, and its steady growth without either financial or institutional support. It is also remarkable that this archive devoted to women, is operated by a man. How did the archive begin? I have been a professional photographer since 1954. In 1971 I went into a local antique store where I was asked: “What do you collect?” “Nothing,” I replied. Undaunted, the owner asked me about my occupation, then proclaimed that as a photogra pher I “should collect old photographs.” I was soon hooked, not only on collecting images, but also on learning the history of photography itself. I wrote several essays on photographers and tackled my first book, a monograph on A. W. Ericson (1848–1927), a male photographer who had been active in my area. This was followed by a study of Emma B. Freeman (1880–1928), who photographed the local Native Americans in a roman tic style in the years 1910–1920, and resulted in the publica tion of With Nature’s Children (1976). This fascinating (and challenging) experience led me to investigate women pho tographers as a special subject. The task of separating the photographs (and related data) of women photographers from my overall collection of more than 150,000 images took longer than a year. However, by 1994 this material had become the heart of the Women in Photography International Archive.
ings, interviews and referrals, etc. I seek resumes and artis tic statements from living photographers wherever possi ble. Filing, as you might imagine, is a nearly endless task. One of the major problems is deciding if a particular name belongs to a woman or a man. “Shirley” or “Sidney,” for instance, could be either. If “Joe” seems male, then “Jo” should be female but this is not always the case. This is unbelievably more difficult when the name is written in Japanese or Arabic! I am sometimes criticized for closely tracking a woman’s marital status, yet it is one of the best indicators of gender, especially in cases where the woman is only identified as Mrs. Charles Smith, for example. If I learn that her name was also Mary Jane Smith, I file her under both names and cross-reference them. The Women in Photography International Archive is continuously seeking information about women photogra phers past and present. Biographical profiles, professional vitae, advertising items, exhibition announcements and reviews, newspaper clippings and promotional pieces are always welcome. This diverse data is collected in manila files, labeled A–Z. When a file becomes too overloaded, I carefully re organize it and have the contents hardbound as a book. Summarizing biographical information remains a huge and daunting task. It has already taken me nearly four years to enter each woman’s name into the computer and I have only just reached the letter “K.” I have also tried to create a biographical statement for each woman and to this end, have nearly finished the “A” and “B” groupings (approximately 3,500 entries). Thus, at any given moment, information organization will be at varying degrees of completeness. Thus far, I have been unable to find the time needed to tackle cross-indexing by topic such as “photo journalist” or “left-handedness.” The long term goal, natu rally, is to bring all information on-line in a searchable database. II. General information—approximately 2,600 books and 5,000 articles by and about women photographers. Collecting the literature field has been an education in itself. Books focused on women photographers are scarce; they were often produced regionally, were generally pub lished in small numbers, and many were self-published. A surprising number of early women travel writers were also amateur photographers who provided their own book illustrations, thus creating a special category of travel books. Each book is catalogued and organized by date (the most recent book first) under the photographer’s name. Small paperback catalogues and publications are housed in an archival enclosure and spine-labeled. Articles have also proven to be a goldmine of information about women pho
Current Resources: I. Biographical files—nearly 27,000. Access and organization begins with the woman’s name. These names are gathered in the widest way possi ble: from periodical sources and local newspaper accounts, from other researchers’ listings and business directory list 33
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 34
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
tographers and have been avidly collected. The most frag ile publications are stored in archival boxes.
resources to maintain large and vital holdings of promi nent photographers. As time passes, I can look back at some of the completed tasks that grew out of my interest in tracking women pho tographers. A brief rundown of these projects may be use ful in helping the reader assess the effectiveness and overall scope of the WIP Archive generally (see also the Appendix at the end of this essay.):
III. Ephemeral archive objects concerning women photographers—approximately 10,000 items. This is another very important part of the collection: business cards, correspondence, exhibition announce ments, and other useful objects that might generally be abused are kept in manila pocket files or Mylar sleeves, and all are housed in archival boxes. These also tend to be items that might one day be considered for exhibition.
1. Monographs and catalogues: Camera and Brush (1976)
Catharine Weed Barnes Ward: Pioneer Advocate for Women
in Photography (1992) Elizabeth Fleischmann: Pioneer X-Ray Photographer (1990) Louise E. Halsey: An American Pictorialist (1985) With Nature’s Children: Emma B. Freeman (1880–1928)
IV. Vintage Photographs by Women—approximately 12,000. While the collection contains relatively few “big name” photographs, it is particularly rich in the historical ele ments of the craft—areas that are generally ignored in tra ditional fine art collections. There are daguerreotypes and ambrotypes by women, prints in all formats, and more than 600 carte-de-visite images by Swedish women pho tographers dated 1860–1920. Approximately half of all the original images were taken before 1910. It has been espe cially gratifying to discover the uniformly high quality of work done by women during the entire span of photogra phy, since this is traditionally considered a male-dominated profession. All vintage photographs are carefully stored in clear Mylar sleeves and acid-free boxes. It should be noted that women photographers working today will continue to enjoy all legal rights to the creative works they donate to the WIP Archive. Finally, I have also collected a consider able number of photographs of women, from the daguer reian era to current times. Many of these were taken by men, or the photographer is unknown.
2. Projects resulting in publications: Women Photographers: A Selection of Images from the Women in Photography International Archive (1997). This project provided an opportunity to survey the vin tage photographs in the collection, make a selection, and publish them with nearly 90 new biographies. A Bibliography of Writings By and About Women in Photo graphy 1850–1990 (2nd edition, 1994). Also, Camera Fiends and Kodak Girls I (1989) and Camera Fiends and Kodak Girls II (1995). These publications represent a long-standing effort to capture periodical writings by and about women pho tographers. The bibliography has source data for approximately 3,000 women. The Camera Fiends and Kodak Girls series reprints 110 of the more choice essays in context. The project continues to evolve, with the third edition of the bibliography still in computer. It is approximately fifty percent larger than the published version, but is not indexed.
Facilities and Access The WIP Archive is housed in a variety of small archives at my home. However, there is also a somewhat larger library/reading room where researchers can work by appointment. Staffing consists of a half-time curator (me), one intern, and two or three volunteers. The archive can be visited by appointment: telephone and e-mail access is available, but postal requests are best. Once a year—usually in December—I produce a hard bound summary of each of the following resources: 1) Current status of biographical entries; 2) Up-to-date listing of catalogued books; 3) Chronological summary of all arti cles dealing with women photographers before l990. These books may be found at the International Museum of Photography, Rochester, New York; National Museum of Women in the Arts, Washington, DC; The Beinecke Library, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut; and The Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. How good is the WIP Collection? The Women in Photography International Archive is probably the very first place to check for details on any obscure woman pho tographer, or for information with a regional context. However, the archive is not a substitute for more major archives, such as the Center for Creative Photography, in Tucson, Arizona, which has both the physical and financial
Shadowcatchers: A Directory of Women in California Photography Before 1901 (Vol. I, 1990, and Vol. 2, 1991) Represents nearly fifteen years of investigation into the women photographers in California—approximately 850 for the nineteenth century and 1,065 for the first two decades of this century. Volume III, covering the period 1920–1940, is still in note form in a five-drawer filing cabinet. 3. Current Projects: A Monograph on Laura Adams Armer. “Journey into the WIP Archive.” Project will review, and generate new essays about books in the WIP collection published before 1950. Publication planned for early 1999. “IN/SITE: The Women Photographers of Humboldt County, California, 1850–2000.” 34
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 35
WOMEN IN PHOTOGRAPHY INTERNATIONAL ARCHIVE
A comprehensive study; major aims: 1) to complete the Archive’s task of gathering all available information on women photographers; 2) to interpret and celebrate their contributions. All aspects of photography will be included. An exhibition of selected works and publica tion of a detailed record of the study are planned.
I feel that the answers to these questions will be positive only if the present work goes forward in perpetuity. At age 62, I can look forward to continued stewardship for only a few years more before the WIP archive must be handed to others. Ideally, the Women in Photography International Archive will go to an institution that will actively continue to pursue the subject, and who will make the collection widely available. This will probably be an educational institution on the East Coast, primarily because larger numbers of students in the corridor running from Boston to Washington, DC, would have access to the collection. Your thoughts on the matter are most welcome. In the meantime, I encourage you to continue to send information on women photographers to the WIP archive.
In conclusion, I must say there is no conclusion. The work of the archive will never be finished and will never be complete. The past continues to be investigated and new names come to light every day. New photographers are arriving on the scene in remarkable numbers; their stories must also be told and their products collected as well. Am I pleased with the results so far? What of the future?
35
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 36
www.city-gallery.com ~ est. 1995 ~ Detail from the City Gallery web page.
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 37
City Gallery
Research in the Twenty-First Century Steve Knoblock unexpected results. I found answers to some of my ques tions on identifying and dating antique photographs in the reference section. I was surprised to see Mangold listed in Eskind’s Index to American Photographic Collections and Edwards’ International Guide to Nineteenth Century Photographers and Their Works. Then I learned that he was a publisher of stereographic views, that several of his views were available in the International Museum of Photography collection, and hundreds of his photographs still existed. I might some day see more of his photographs! I wrote to the museum and received helpful advice and some reprints of Mangold’s views. They welcomed my genealogical information on Mangold, and I was delighted and surprised that this man who had made our family photographs was highly regarded by museums. As I continued my research, I combed through old photographs at antique shows and flea markets, looking for Mangold images, family or otherwise. There were plenty of nineteenth century images to be found, and I was both sad and angry that so many people just discard ed them. It may be frustrating to deal with an album full of unidentified images, but they are priceless records of one’s family and should be preserved. I had initially found a wealth of information, but it was increasingly difficult to obtain more, especially in dating the photographs and determining their type. Eventually I discovered that much of the material was in books that were out of print or somewhat obscure, and not readily available. It occurred to me that genealogical methods might be important tools for researching an historic photographer. Perhaps I could find cousins who might have other family photographs, and as a side-line, I might be able to rescue old photographs and encourage others to do the same. Because of my familiarity with computer technology, I began to think about creating an on-line bulletin board system featuring genealogy and photography. During the summer, I worked to develop material and software for the system, and named it City Gallery, after the name of Mangold’s studio in Daikon, Illinois. One big drawback of the system, however, was the potential cost to users; every connection would incur a long-distance charge. When I heard of the Internet in 1994, the World Wide Web seemed like the perfect method for the City Gallery project. There were other major advantages to using the web, aside from very low costs. Graphic display and the prom ise of multimedia—impractical or impossible on the bul letin board system—were basic components of the web. I decided to make the Mangold photographs a significant element of my site. People might be interested in seeing
Part 1: Catching Ancestors on the Web The faces of my ancestors fascinated me. Several dozen cartes-de-visite and cabinet cards had been handed down from my great-great grandmother, Susan (Mangold) Barnum, and when I first saw them in 1980, I made 35mm copies for my parents. But years passed before I took the time to find out more about them. Who would guess that those elegant old images would start me on a journey that would lead to an electronic research project known by the old-fashioned name, City Gallery? My interest in the old family photographs was rekin dled by my parents in 1995. I discovered that most of the images were made by my great-great grandmother’s older brother, J. G. Mangold, a photographer. One of the cabinet cards showed Mangold and his camera; another showed him as an older gentleman in front of a seaside backdrop. Most were portraits of my grandmother, her siblings and family. I remember my grandmother (Susan’s granddaughter) saying Mangold “had taken photographs in the civil war, had his own studio, and made photographs along the Mississippi River.” She described the family as wealthy and prosperous, living in southern Illinois. My ancestors had left fascinating handwritten notes and signatures on the small cards. On one, my great-greatgrandaunt wrote “I penciled this picture”; she had handtinted a portrait of children. But only one-fourth of the photographs were identified with any degree of certainty. Ironically, as recently as the 1950s my great-grandfather could have identified all these people; he had grown up with them. He had talked with my dad about his life and work in Little Egypt, as the lower counties in Illinois were called. Names of his friends and co-workers in the carpentry trade came easily to his mind. But my father had only been a boy, and naturally had failed to remem ber much of what his grandfather related, much less write it down. Not only were most of the people unknown to me, but the types of images that made up our collection were a mystery. I knew very little about them, not even their proper names, but I suspected that the decorations on the cards and fancy imprints would help date the images. The designs, together with the handwritten material, made a compelling historical mixture. They were mes sages from the past, puzzles left for me to solve. I realized that perhaps this was the last chance my generation would have to research the photographs of nineteenth century ancestors before too much valuable information was lost. The pictures had an interesting story to tell, and I had a growing desire to tell it. A trip to the library helped a great deal, and brought 37
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 38
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
searched and queried in virtually endless combinations, much like data in a spreadsheet application. My vision for the site had been mainly personal—I pic tured the genealogical web pages as a fishing net, trawl ing the web sea, hoping to snag a relative who might have information or other photographs. But I was realistic about my chances of finding anyone related, much less one with family pictures to share. Only a small fraction of the population had Internet access or an e-mail address. And even if I did find a cousin, any possible photographs would have had to survive from the nineteenth century, passing through many hands. I was amazed at what happened during the next year. One of the first important contacts was a cousin descend ed from the brother of Mangold’s mother, who opened up a significant branch of the Gunnell family. Two of our cartes-de-visite depict members of this family, and there are clear connections to western Pennsylvania where Mangold was born, all the way west to Moline, Illinois where Mangold was a major publisher of stereoviews in the 1870s. My cousin provided copies of family photo graphs of Mangold’s Gunnell relatives and of sites in Pennsylvania. One of the most significant was a cabinet card by one of Mangold’s sons. This geographic area and family line are still being investigated. Meanwhile, I became involved with an informal e-mail discussion group devoted to all aspects of history of photography. PhotoHst is operated by Richard PearceMoses, and subscribers include museum curators, archivists, photography historians, artists, biographers, and amateur collectors, among many others. Topics cover the general history of photography, processes and techniques, biographies, and aesthetics and criticism of photographer’s works. Announcements, reviews of relevant publications and exhibitions, and job announce ments are frequently posted, but no job solicitations are allowed. The list is open to anyone and members are usually friendly and helpful to the professional and novice alike. To subscribe, send an e-mail from the address where you wish to receive mail to
[email protected]. ASU.EDU and put “subscribe” (without quotes) in the subject field of the message. Follow the instructions, and your subscription will be confirmed by e-mail. Further subscription information is also available at citygallery.com/resource/photohst/photo_h.html. Through PhotoHst, I located and purchased cabinet cards made by Mangold’s three sons, who had all fol lowed in their father’s business. Another mailing list, GenWeb, originated in 1994 and closed August 1997. It was set up to globally distribute and link genealogy databas, and members discussed many complex issues and ideas. Many of today’s stan dard tools and concepts originated with this group. The discussions and full archive of messages can be found at http://www.genweb.org/genweblist/ The web pages brought in another cousin descended from Mangold’s brother, Benjamin Franklin Mangold. While there was no treasure trove of original Mangold images or papers, my cousin generously shared family
the old images, and there were always those unknown but hoped-for cousins that might turn up. New informa tion could be added to the “Mangold Family Album,” and others might be encouraged to get involved in searches. America Online was scheduled to offer a personal web page service in the fall of 1995, so I started learning the sys tem and scanned the Mangold images in preparation. But the homepage space from AOL was slow in coming and I was impatient. The Digital Daguerreian Archive run by Greg Walker was hosted at Webcom, an early web pres ence provider, and I decided to place City Gallery there. My goals were simple: to provide a means of exchange between genealogists and historic researchers; and to offer information and advice on the preservation, identifi cation and interpretation of old photographs. I thought City Gallery could help popularize the history of photo graphy and encourage people to research the older photographs, with their more intractable mysteries. With the reach of the web, I felt I could spread the word that it was imperative to begin researching our photographic heritage in earnest. I was overly ambitious, to say the least. At the same time as I began to learn about the history of photography, I started working on the web site. There was nothing to use as a model for the site I envi sioned, and the web itself was new. I wanted to do as much as possible myself, and thus discovered my strengths and weaknesses as the project went forward. The technical work was my strong point, and I eagerly made use of the newest advances and techniques. I had been researching and writing only a short time when I realized that creating content was my weak point. I found others who could write for me and my role became editor. Clearly, though, some limits had to be placed on the projects and the scope of City Gallery. Would its focus be history, or photography, or genealogy? My loyalties were divided, and as a result, I ended up with four web sites: City Gallery (http://www.city-gallery.com) Mangold Family Album (http://www.city-gallery.com /gallery/mangold/): Family photographs and an inter pretive text. Digital Album (http://www.city-gallery.com/digital/): Instructions for building a web family album, and direc tory of other digital albums on the web. Directory(http://www.citygallery.com/digital/ add_page.html) I also created a web genealogy as a companion to my Album. A printed genealogical chart has only two dimen sions and denotes connections between individuals with an obscure and confusing numbering system. A web gen ealogy adds a third dimension, and is essentially a book with a series of linked web pages. You simply click the links to follow the myriad connections between you and your ancestors. In addition, the data can be rearranged, 38
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 39
CITY GALLERY
deal of confusion and distracted from the basic activities of creating content. The number-one browser maker usually determines what is considered “standard.” However, with the broad acceptance of basic web technology, more of the limited systems are used by a wider variety of people. The systems able to access the web now range from shell accounts to WebTv units. New technologies such as eXtensible Markup Language and style sheets allow individual web builders to define their own standard languages, but may introduce other unforseen problems. It’s always best to start by learning the basic functions before tackling more complex tasks. It is important to consider how you will fund your site. Web hosting has great appeal, but while it is cheaper than publishing, it demands a commitment of time and money to continuously maintain and publish material. Unlike a book, you cannot just publish and move on. I considered creating a non-profit organization to support the activities of City Gallery, but I found the procedure too complex. In addition, grants are difficult to obtain, advertisers aren’t interested in a small-traffic site, and micro-transactions have never become popular. To place your site on the web, you must rent space from a host or server. The web host provides a place to store your files and serve them on the web. They maintain the web server computer and provide a fast connection to the Internet. The higher the bandwidth and faster the connection, the better the host. Each host may have thousands of accounts, serving web pages for many companies, organizations and individuals. The host may consist of dozens of separate computers networked together. As an account holder, you will receive a certain amount of storage space and be allotted an amount of system resources, such as web traffic, interactive forms and database features. Web pages can be created in any HTML editing application and freely uploaded by file transfer protocol from anywhere in the world. When choosing a web server, consider these factors:
photographs, information, and helped obtain rare books on the area where the Mangolds had lived. Meeting my new cousin over the web and through e-mail was an exciting and pleasurable experience. Not long after, another second-cousin discovered my Mangold genealogy and web photograph album. Through this connection I was able to obtain two unusual cabinet card images of the family, produced by Mangold. More importantly, by comparing images on my web site to my cousin’s family photographs, we were able to posi tively identify nearly one-fourth of the previously unknown cartes-de-visite in my collection. During that first year, a number of other cousins and genealogists who were working on the lines posted on my site also made contact, but they had no connections with the Mangold family. Nevertheless, this was proof that caring about family photographs was an important issue and confirmed my belief that there was a great untapped need out there. I was pleasantly surprised at the number of hits racked up by my homepage counter. I disliked counters, but was curious to see how many people would actually be inter ested in a site that combined genealogy and photography, and I also wanted to let visitors see the numbers. The same net continues to produce a generous catch to this day. One of my early goals was to offer texts on preserving, copying and identifying old photographs; another was to set up a registry or database of family photographs being researched or shared. Both of these goals are yet unreal ized, but remain at the forefront of my plans as I continue to unravel the puzzles of the faces in my past. The possibilities for research in the twenty-first century are beyond imagination. I am excited about the growing enthusiasm for photography history and genealogy, and encourage others to join the research on the web. City Gallery can be visited at http://
www.city-gallery.com
The Mangold Family Album is at http://
www.city-gallery.com/gallery/mangold/
The Digital Album is at http://
www.city-gallery.com/digital/
Add your URL to the directory at http://
www.city-gallery.com/digital/add_page.html
Amount of storage space. The average web page is 10 20k, with some reaching 50k. Amount of traffic. Look for a minimum traffic limit of 1,500 to 3,000 megabytes per month. Over-traffic charges for traffic above your limit. Over-storage charges for exceeding your storage limit.
Part 2: Guidelines for Creating a Web Site When I started to work on a web site, I felt like a kid sur rounded with colorful and exciting new toys—tempted to play with everything. I wanted to make my site the best possible and was loath to turn down anything new. However, I learned that it’s best to stay away from the “bleeding-edge” of technology and avoid programs that are not proven or widely supported. Some of these techniques will no doubt be available in the future, but if they don’t work in most popular com puter systems and their browsers at this time, you do a great disservice to both yourself and your potential visi tors by using them. How do you know what will work? Different opinions of web standards for fonts and layout have caused a great
Most hosts will charge for a monthly average; if you exceed the limit by several megabytes for a short time, you may not be charged the full amount. Most sites charge between fifty cents and one dollar per megabyte per month. If your goal is to offer an archive of e-texts (old docu ments converted to electronic form), pictures or other bulky items such as mailing-list archives, then look for a host with a low storage cost per unit (usually megabytes). Traffic charges may not be important if your site is visited infre quently. If you have a large archive that becomes very popu lar, however, you will need a web host with both low storage and low traffic charges. Be sure the host has a clear policy on over- charges, and will notify you when traffic or 39
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 40
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
storage limits are exceeded.There should be a grace period to allow you to deal with the over-traffic situation by finding supporting funds, asking users to pay an access fee, by using paid advertisements, or by moving to a less costly web host. If you pay by credit card, ask if traffic limit warnings can be set to an acceptable level. Be sure a policy is in place to take your site off-line if an over-traffic situation occurs, so you’re not surprised with a big bill. Beware of hosts that advertise extremely low costs—some unscrupulous servers may later claim several hundred dollars of over-traffic charges. Look for a well-known provider with a good reputa tion. Ask friends and associates for the name of site hosts, and select one that has been business for a long time. Web sites seem to work best when a highly focused subject is established with its own domain name. Choose a single, identifiable topic. You will need a suite of applications to create, edit and upload a web page. There are many fine web page editing applications and several popular file transfer applications (FTP or File Transfer Protocol applications) available at shareware sites on the web. If you plan to include photo graphs on your web site, you will need a scanner to input the images. The image-editing software necessary to pre pare the pictures is also available on the web. Most major vendors provide demonstration software at their web site and it can be downloaded for trial use. They may also pro vide help with their image-editing product.
will be many times larger than the 72 dpi of a typical computer screen. Don’t fill your pages with advertising banners, animated graphics, sound effects and music, or other gimmicks. They waste time and often crash visitor’s browsers— sometimes the computers must be restarted to get back to normal. Remember that most visitors won’t have all the latest technology. Use several pages if you have a large amount of textual material, rather than placing it all on one page. Use web technology that works now. Stay away from new technology, no matter how attractive or how convinc ing its claim of acceptance by a “standards body.” Often, what is standard is not implemented, and what is imple mented is not standard. Don’t abuse your visitors with unworkable features. Once your web site is up, you can keep track of the response. The server log records every request for files (HTML page, picture, media file, etc.) made by visitors. The log can be analyzed to determine the domain where the request originated, the date and time of the request, and the original page if the visitor followed a link. You can identify the popular pages or those that are ignored. The log will also show error or status codes, such as “file not found” messages, that can help you weed out broken links, poorly designed navigation, or other problems with the design. For a genealogical chart, the first software application I used was ged2html, a very basic GEDCOM to HTML con verter. It was the the first practical and widely used appli cation for generating a genealogical chart as static web pages. The full history can be read in the GenWeb archive at http://www.genweb.org/genweblist/. If you are serious about creating your own web site, check the manuals currently available that offer detailed instructions. Finally, if you create a web site album, be sure to post it in the directory at the City Gallery Digital Album to help guide other researchers to it (http://www.city-gallery. com/digital/).
Here are a few basic guidelines: Create a site of several pages and link them together, rather than placing all your pictures on one page. Keep the total page load weight under 50k including associated images. Keep your image file sizes under 50k. With JPEG com pression, there is no need for larger files. A snapshot-size picture (or quarter-plate daguerreotype) should require no more than 24-30k at today’s screen resolutions. Carefully note the different resolutions of screen monitor and printer. An image the size of a postage stamp, scanned at 300 dpi
40
Sourcebook pt.1R2
4/10/04
12:03 PM
Page 5
Directories of Photographers An Annotated World Bibliography
Compiled by Richard Rudisill and Steven Joseph
41
Sourcebook pt.1FF
4/10/04
11:49 AM
Page 42
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 43
Introduction
This new edition of Directories of Photographers: An Annotated World Bibliography contains more than one thousand entries— books, exhibition catalogues, university dissertations, and periodical and festschrift articles. These represent an enor mous body of research into the lives of photographers during the medium’s first century, and our aim is to present a practical guide to this literature. Research has increased dramatically during the past two decades. As recently as 1982, a prominent scholar and writer lamented, “There are hardly any reference tools, periodicals or basic texts [on regional photo-history]. Anyone wishing to discover even general details about photographers’ lives, frequently ends up in the dark.”1 Interest in the heritage of photography has grown rapidly, however, especially after the sesquicentennial celebration of the photograph in 1989. The recognition of the intrinsic value of the medium is now evident world-wide in new museums, festivals, and public auctions. Since the first edition of the Bibliography appeared in 1991, several major long-term projects have been printed, and groundbreaking work has been published on many countries and regions that were previously unsurveyed. Faced with this huge volume of literature, we have been stringent in our criteria. Within the time-frame of photography’s first hundred years, the Bibliography aims for thorough and extensive coverage for the nineteenth century, and selected coverage for 1900 to 1940. The works must contain basic career details and substantial documentation to qualify as valid research. In some cases we included thin or flawed works when they were the best presently available, and they are so noted. Omitted are many popular souvenir books that were illustrated with early photographs, but were steeped in nostalgia and lacked research-based texts. Monographs on individual photographers or families of photographers also lie outside the scope of our work. Nevertheless, the total number of entries increased in eight years from 413 in 1991 to approximately 1,070 in 1999. The contents are organized in two parts. Part A, Published Works, is divided into nine sections. The first, headed General and International, lists catalogues of insti tutional and private collections that reflect current biogra phical research. Each of the eight following sections broadly corresponds to a continent or sub-continent, and begins with an overview, General and International, then with entries set out by country, alphabetically. Part B, Works in Progress, follows the same basic format as Part A. The list of countries reflects the current geo-political status. Some areas retain earlier names to correspond with older publications or historical borders. Where the current name of a country is new (e.g., Iran for Persia), a crossreference is provided. Countries with profuse photo-histor-
ical research may have two categories for entries: General and National, and Regional and Local. The place of publi cation and titles are given in the original languages unless otherwise indicated. Some of the English versions of place names are added for clarity. Foreign language works that contain texts in English (a summary or picture captions, for example) are indicated in our commentary. We considered adding a category for electronic media because of the great increase in computing and telecommu nications, along with the scholarly use of the World Wide Web. However, we concluded that such a designation was unnecessary since all forms of material may be properly listed in the Published Works section, regardless of the medium employed. The actual character of research is changing due to the explosion of information available through the internet. Electronic databases offer a superb tool for gathering and organizing material, but this method must be balanced with careful, traditional research that encompasses all historic records, including many sources unavailable in electronic form. Appreciation of the photograph and its history continues to grow. Research using an interdisciplinary approach and a variety of sources yields the best results. The Bibliography is the result of a twenty-year search through many types of published works, many examined firsthand, and often checked against existing bibliogra phies in the literature of photography or art history. These are listed below in Frequently Cited Sources. Our work has been supplemented and greatly enhanced by willing col laboration. We are grateful to a global network of fellow scholars, researchers, and librarians, whose assistance we acknowledge within the relevant entries. Specialist bookdealers have acted as indefatigable trackers, especially Martijn and Ada Oleff (Posada Art Books) of Brussels, Belgium, Fred and Elizabeth Pajerski of New York City, and David Margolis and Jean Moss of Santa Fe, New Mexico. We pay tribute to our editor Peter Palmquist, whose committment encouraged us, and whose many sug gestions improved and refined our initial draft. We hope this current version of the Bibliography will serve as a useful research tool, provide information on the scope and reliability of available works in the field, and further encourage the rewarding research that remains to be done in this essential aspect of photographic history.
notes 1. Janos Frecot, editor, Berlin fotografisch: Fotografie in Berlin, 1860 1982 (Berlin: Berlinische Galerie), 1982, p. 12. 43
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 44
Directories of Photographers An Annotated World Bibliography Compiled by Richard Rudisill and Steven F. Joseph
6. Latin America (including Mexico) 100
a. General and International 100
b. By country 101
FREQUENTLY CITED SOURCES 45
A. PUBLISHED WORKS 46
7. Near and Middle East 105
a. General and International 105
b. By country 106
1. General and International 46
2. Africa (See also Near and Middle East: Egypt) 54
a. General and International 54
b. By country 55
8. North America (excluding Mexico) 108
a. General and International 108
b. Canada 109
I. General and Regional 109
II. By province 110
c. United States (excluding Hawaii) 112
I. General and Regional 112
II. By state 115
3. Asia 56
a. General and International 56
b. By country 56
4. Caribbean 61
5. Europe 61
a. General and International 61
b. By country 63
9. Oceania (including Hawaii) 129
B. WORKS IN PROGRESS 132
44
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 45
FREQUENTLY CITED SOURCES
Ochsner: Ochsner, Bjørn. Fotografer i og fra Danmark indtil År 1900 (København [Copenhagen]: Det Kongelige Bibliotek), 1969, second edition.
ABM: ARTbibliographies Modern (Oxford, England and Santa Barbara, California: Clio Press), ongoing.
Pelizzari: Pelizzari, Maria Antonella. “Nineteenth Century Italian Photography: Selected Bibliography,” History of Photography, Vol. 20, No. 1 (Spring 1996), pp. 73–77.
Arnal: Arnal, Ariel. “Mexican Photography: A Bibliography,” History of Photography, Vol. 20, No. 3 (Autumn 1996), pp. 250–254.
Roberts: Roberts, Andrew D. “Photography in Africa: A Bibliography” Supplement to the PhotoHistorian, No. 100 (Spring 1993).
Auer et al.: Auer, Anna, Monika Faber, et al. Geschichte der Fotografie in Österreich (Bad Ischl, Austria: Verein zur Erarbeitung der “Geschichte der Fotografie in Österreich”), 1983.
Roosens and Salu 1: Roosens, Laurent, and Luc Salu. History of Photography: A Bibliography of Books (London and New York: Mansell), 1989.
BHA: Bibliography of the History of Art (Santa Monica, California: The Getty Information Institute, in collab oration with the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique—Institut National de l’Information Scientifique et Technique, Vandoeuvre-lès-Nancy, France), 1991–ongoing.
Roosens and Salu 2: Roosens, Laurent, and Luc Salu. History of Photography: A Bibliography of Books, Vol. 2 (London and New York: Mansell), 1994. Roosens and Salu 3: Roosens, Laurent, and Luc Salu. History of Photography: A Bibliography of Books, Vol. 3 (London and New York: Mansell), 1996.
Davies and Stanbury: Davies, Alan, and Peter Stanbury, assisted by Con Tanre. The Mechanical Eye in Australia: Photography 1841–1900 (Melbourne, Victoria: Oxford University Press), 1985.
Roosens and Salu 4: Roosens, Laurent, and Luc Salu. History of Photography: A Bibliography of Books, Vol. 4 (London and New York: Mansell), 1998.
Gaskins: Gaskins, William. “Selected Bibliography of Early Australian Photography,” Supplement to the PhotoHistorian, No. 103 (Autumn 1993).
Snyder: Snyder, Robert E. “Photography and the American South: A Bibliographical Introduction,” History of Photography, Vol. 19, No. 1 (Spring 1995), pp. 1–3.
Johnson: Johnson, William S. Nineteenth Century Photography. An Annotated Bibliography 1839–1879 (Boston and London: Mansell), 1990.
Söderberg and Rittsel: Söderberg, Rolf, and Pär Rittsel. Den Svenska Fotografins Historia 1840–1940 ([Stockholm]: Bonnier Fakta), 1983.
López Mondéjar: López Mondéjar, Publio. Historia de la Fotografía en España (Barcelona: Lunwerg Editores, S.A.), 1997.
Stein: Stein, Donna. “Recent Research on the History of Photography in Iran,” History of Photography, Vol. 10, No. 1 (January–March 1986), p. 82.
MABS: Photography. Modern Art Bibliographical Series (Oxford, England and Santa Barbara, California: Clio
Press), 1982. Reprint in book form of all entries on
photography in ARTbibliographies Modern, Vols. 4–11
inclusive.
Sztuka fotografii: Sztuka fotografii: Portret, Pejzazæ, Reportazæ w Fotografii Polskiej XIX Wieku (Warszawa [Warsaw]: Muzeum Narodowe w Warszawie), 1990, unpaginated section “Wybrana Bibliografia.”
Mattison: Mattison, David. “Canadian Photography:
A Selected Bibliography,” History of Photography, Vol. 20,
No. 2 (Summer 1996), pp. 186–188.
45
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 46
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
A. PUBLISHED WORKS
Billeter, Erika, editor. Self-Portrait in the Age of Photography: Photographers Reflecting Their Own Image [sic] (Houston, Texas: [Houston Foto Fest]), 1986.
1. GENERAL AND INTERNATIONAL (See also entries for Lund and Sprange under Europe/Great Britain)
A reduced English edition of a larger exhibit catalogue pro duced in 1985 under the same title for the Musée Cantonal des Beaux-Arts in Lausanne, Switzerland. The section “The Works,” pages 233–247, lists the 200 photographic artists featured and provides years and places of birth and death for each. Many painters and otherwise unreported photo graphers are included.
Adressbuch für Photographie und verwandte Fächer (Wien [Vienna] and Leipzig: Photographische Correspondenz), 1879. An address book for photography and related fields. Extensively international, with 137 entries for Vienna, 420 for Paris, and a few listings for the United States. A reprint was issued in Vienna by Bodo Kralik, 1981.
“Biographical Index of Photographers in the George Eastman House Collection” (Rochester, New York: International Museum of Photography at George Eastman House), 1979.
Auer, Michèle and Michel. Auer Index: Encyclopédie internationale des Photographes (Hermance, Switzerland: Editions Camera Obscura), 1992.
Three microfiche indices—one alphabetical, one geographi cal, one by process; available directly from the George Eastman House, 900 East Avenue, Rochester, New York 14607. Partly superseded by the works cited below under Eskind et al.
Inventory of more than 25,000 names of photographers from the beginning to the present; gives in abridged form the names, dates of birth and death, periods of activity, processes used, places visited, and themes worked.
Blasco, Victoria, et al., editors. Luz y Tiempo: Colección Fotográfica formada por Manuel Álvarez Bravo para la Fundación Cultural Televisa, A. C. (Mexico City: Centro Cultural Arte Contemporáneo), 1995, three volumes.
———. Encyclopédie internationale des Photographes de 1839 à nos jours [Photographers Encyclopaedia International 1839 to the Present] (Hermance, Switzerland: Editions Camera Obscura), 1985, two volumes.
A catalogue of the overall holdings of a major institution in Mexico City, reflecting the choices made by the leading photographer of the country. Fully illustrated in color and offers sections of commentary for selected individuals throughout the history of the medium. Biographical dates or estimated working periods are given for many among the 271 photographers or firms listed although some entries are incomplete or in error.
A very expansive treatment arranged as a biographical dictionary of more than 1,600 names; includes a biblio graphy and indices. French and English texts.
———. Photographers Encyclopaedia International (Neuchâtel, Switzerland: Editions Ides et Calendes), 1997.
Boom, Mattie, editor. Fotokunst 19de eeuw: Hoogtepunten van de internationale fotografie [Nineteenth Century Photographic Art: Masterpieces of International Photography] (Den Haag [The Hague], Netherlands: SDU Uitgeverij), 1989.
Boxed CD-ROM with six-page instruction booklet in English and French. Compatible with Windows 95 or Mac. Second and expanded edition of the work cited immediate ly above. A very creditable effort, comprising biographical entries, including exhibition records and bibliographies, for 3,135 photographers from the beginning to the present day and less complete entries for 3,000 others. Incorporates 5,900 images, and can be searched by gender, nationality, country, period, and themes. The authors state in their preface that “what we present today still represents only a part of our total data bank of photographers which currently contains more than 37,000 creators.”
Issued to reflect the decisions of the Dutch State Art Service and the Rijksmuseum of Amsterdam to establish a true national collection of photography, this volume offers 116 plates of pictures made by fifty-eight named photographers or firms and a few anonymous people from the beginning of the medium to the early twentieth century. Pages 150–199 give discussions for each picture and biographical sketches for each known photographer. This section gives generous information, and sometimes presents new material for some of the photographers who are not noted elsewhere. It is not easy to use, however, because it lists names in the chrono logical order of the illustrations in the book rather than alphabetically. While the text of the work is given in parallel Dutch and English, the biographies are only in Dutch.
Balk, Claudia. Theaterfotografie: eine Darstellung ihrer Geschichte anhand der Sammlung des Deutschen Theatermuseums (München [Munich]: Hirmer), 1989. Reported as a 231-page exhibition catalogue based on the holdings of the German Theatre Museum, including a listing of the photographers represented.
Boom, Mattie, and Hans Rooseboom, editors. Een nieuwe kunst: Fotografie in de 19de eeuw [A New Art: Photography in the Nineteenth Century—The Photo Collection of the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam] (Gent, Belgium: Snoeck, Ducaju & Zoon in association with the Rijksmuseum and the Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam), 1996.
Beaton, Cecil, and Gail Buckland. The Magic Image (Boston: Little, Brown & Company), 1975. Entire book is in format of biographical dictionary of many prominent figures throughout the history of photography. Comprises 200 biographies, arranged chronologically. Reissued (London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson), 1989.
A splendid work issued to celebrate the Rijksmuseum’s opening with the Van Gogh Museum of a major exhibition
46
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 47
DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
marking the establishment of the Dutch National Photo Collection. Several writers give text sections on the overall history of the medium and its uses in various fields. The small text illustrations are well-printed, and the inter spersed sections of plates are all color-toned to the character of the original pictures. Many date periods are indicated in captions for plates and an extensive name list of photogra phers represented in the collection is given (without dates). Taken together with the continuing biographical projects noted in Section B, Works in Progress, this volume becomes a landmark for emulation elsewhere.
The section “Biographies of the Artists,” pages 166–188, compiled by John Bloom and Diana C. Du Pont, comprises biographies and portraits of approximately sixty-five photographers ranging from the early twentieth century to the present throughout the artistic field of Europe and North America.
Darrah, William C. A personal collection of 57,000 Cartes-de-Visite. A file of 48,500 items arranged alphabetically by country or state (of the United States) to illustrate works by more than 21,000 different photographers. Another 8,000 items are filed in the Synoptic Collection by subject categories includ ing “imprints and photographers.” The whole is accompa nied by Darrah’s own index of 50,000 3 x 5 inch cards of information on photographers. Reported in Pennsylvania Historic Photography Group Newsletter, Vol. 1, No. 2 (Spring/Summer 1991), p. 2, as having “a useful four-page descriptive guide . . . available for the visitor’s perusal.” The collection is housed under “controlled” access at the Special Collections Department, Pattee Library, The Pennsylvania State University, State College, Pennsylvania 16803.
Borcoman, James. Intimate Images: 129 Daguerreotypes 1841–1857—The Phyllis Lambert Gift (Ottawa: National Gallery of Canada), 1988. The partially illustrated catalogue of an exhibition celebrat ing a major gift of daguerreotypes. Pages 8–22 give an item ized list of the pieces shown and include some biographical entries or at least dates for most of the approximately thirtyseven known daguerreotypists represented from England, France, Germany, Switzerland, and the United States. Since several have not previously been known in the literature, and the research is solid, this is a significant contribution for the early period.
———. Cartes de Visite in Nineteenth Century Photography (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: W. C. Darrah, Publisher), 1981.
———. Magicians of Light: Photographs from the Collections of the National Gallery of Canada (Ottawa: National Gallery of Canada), 1993.
Includes a “Geographic Index of Photographers,” pages 211–218, based exclusively on the author’s collection, and therefore only partial in coverage (see entry immediately above).
A handsomely illustrated selective catalogue of master pic tures in the collection of one of the leading museums hold ing photography, with life dates or active periods for each individual shown. A “Synoptic Catalogue,” pages 265–291, summarizes the full holdings of the museum and gives dates or work periods for the others represented in the collection.
———. The World of Stereographs (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: W. C. Darrah, Publisher), 1977. Extensive international and American listings of stereoscop ic photographers with estimated time periods of work. An essentially unchanged new edition in paperback is available for $24.95 from Land Yacht Press, P.O. Box 210262, Nashville, Tennessee 37221–0262.
Botanica: Photographies de Végétaux aux XIXe et XXe Siècles (Paris: Centre National de la Photographie), 1987. Published in the series Photo Copies, this volume handsome ly illustrates the work of twenty-three identified and two anonymous photographers of plant forms or flowers since the 1840s. Life years are given for most, and many of the pictures are dated.
Dewitz, Bodo von. Das Agfa Foto-Historama im Wallraf-Richartz-Museum / Museum Ludwig der Stadt Köln (Köln [Cologne], Germany: Agfa Foto-Historama), 1986. A concise catalogue of holdings of the Agfa collection relo cated to museums in Cologne. Pages 91–126 give life dates and comments for a number of individuals represented in the plates.
Breuille, Jean-Philippe, conceptor, and Michel Guillemot, editor. Dictionnaire Mondial de la Photo graphie des Origines à nos Jours (Paris: Larousse), 1994. Heavily illustrated reference work comprising 1,200 entries, mainly biographical, contributed by forty-eight scholars in the field.
Dimock, George. Caroline Sturgis Tappan and The Grand Tour: A Collection of Nineteenth Century Photographs (Lenox, Massachusetts: Lenox Library Association), 1982.
Browne, Turner, and Elaine Partnow. Macmillan Biographical Encyclopedia of Photographic Artists and Innovators: Over 2,000 Leaders in Photography from the 1800s to the Present (New York: Macmillan), 1984.
An exhibit catalogue for a body of early photographs col lected during world travels. “Appendix 1: Biographical Notes on the Photographers,” pages 74–75, gives limited details on sixteen photographers around the world, includ ing some not reported elsewhere.
The work consists of biographical entries, including biblio graphical references, and collections in which work is repre sented. Unfortunately incomplete and arbitrary in selecting “leaders.”
[Ecole des Beaux-Arts.] Les Chefs-d’Oeuvre de la Photographie dans les Collections de l’Ecole des BeauxArts (Paris: Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Beaux-Arts), 1991.
Coke, Van Deren, with Diana C. Du Pont. Photography: A Facet of Modernism (New York: Hudson Hills Press in association with the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art), 1986.
An exhibition catalogue featuring the photographs acquired for reference or study over the past century or more. Thirty
47
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 48
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
Foch, Elisabeth. Berge der Photographen— Photographen der Berge (Bern, Switzerland: Benteli Verlag), 1990.
six photographers, mainly French, are discussed in some career detail with dates, and the texts give passing mention of many others.
A magnificently scaled volume featuring work by ninety photographers active in many parts of the world since the 1860s. Each individual is included in the section “Kurzbiographien,” pages 229–236.
Edwards, Gary. International Guide to Nineteenth Century Photographers and Their Works Based on Catalogues of Auction Houses and Dealers (Boston: G. K. Hall & Co.), 1988.
Ford, Colin, editor, et al. Happy and Glorious: 130 Years of Royal Photographs (London: National Portrait Gallery), 1977.
Index of more than 4,000 photographers collated from more than 300 auction and dealers catalogues. Attempts to give for each name the nationality, life dates, chief subject mat ter, working dates, processes and formats used, general location of studio, and sales catalogue citations. Since the entries are only as accurate or complete as the source texts permit, there are inevitable errors and a heavy emphasis on European and American photographers, but many previ ously unreported people are noted.
An exhibition catalogue in celebration of the Silver Jubilee of Queen Elizabeth II offering many previously unpublished pictures from 1842 to the 1970s. While in no way a biograph ical register of the photographers, some dates are given in picture captions, including an accounting of cinematic records of the monarchy beginning in 1896. Pages 60–61 give a listing by date of the forty-seven photographers or firms who were “Royal Warrant Holders During Queen Victoria’s Reign,” explaining such designation to be no more than an acknowledgment “that the monarch had regularly ordered, and paid for, goods or services . . . over a period of at least three consecutive years.” A number of foreign photogra phers from locations as far away as India, Denmark, and Italy are included, and the specifications of the warrants clarify the individuals’ underlying corporate partnerships.
Eskind, Andrew H., editor, and Greg Drake, Kirsti Ringger, and Lynne Rummey, associate editors. Index to American Photographic Collections (Boston: G. K. Hall & Co.), 1996 third edition. A general guide to holdings of work by 66,830 photogra phers in 582 American collections. The “Photographer Index” itemizes individuals as reported by the collecting institutions, and thus shows considerable variation in names. Where possible, mention is made of nationality and life or estimated activity dates. Supersedes the second edi tion published under the same imprint in 1990. The Index is derived from the Photographers/Creators ‘authority’ files in the catalog database shared by the George Eastman House and the Harry Ransom Humanities Research Center, University of Texas at Austin.
Fralin, Frances, editor. The Indelible Image: Photographs of War—1846 to the Present (New York: Harry N. Abrams, Inc., Publishers for the Corcoran Gallery of Art, Washington, DC), 1985. The extensive catalogue for a major exhibition; pages 17–21 give short biographies of the seventy-four photographers represented.
———. “Photographers on Disc: An International Index of Photographers, Exhibitions, and Collections” (Boston: G. K. Hall & Co.), 1996.
Galassi, Peter. Before Photography: Painting and the Invention of Photography (New York: The Museum of Modern Art), 1981.
CD-ROM based on the same data as the work cited immedi ately above, but including additional details such as places and dates of birth and death, and adding data based on the Institutions and Exhibitions ‘authority’ files, the latter of which comprises 3,500 entries from 1839 to 1996. Each authority file includes bibliographic references to primary and secondary sources from which factual information has been extracted and confirmed. Furthermore, the online ver sion of the database is accessible via TELNET to manning.hrc.utexas.edu and log in as guest 2. A web inter face is expected soon.
An exhibition catalogue illustrating the thesis that a specific “photographic” vision had gained a foothold in the general field of art well before 1839. Short biographies are given for twenty-six well-known photographers and twenty-nine workers in other media (a few of whom were also involved in photography). The commentaries and noted bibliograph ic sources are useful.
Gautrand, Jean-Claude. Visions du Sport: Photographies 1860–1960 (Aix-en-Provence, France: Editions Admira), 1989.
Ewing, William A., editor. Flora Photographica: Masterpieces of Flower Photography, 1835 to the Present (New York: Simon and Schuster), 1991.
An elaborately produced volume ranging from an early academic study of an athlete to recent action shots, with many images chosen for their artistic quality and broad variety. The section “Biographies,” pages 235–249, gives varying amounts of career details for sixty-four photogra phers or firms, some not covered elsewhere.
The section “Commentaries on the Plates,” pages 214–221, gives nationalities and life years or periods of activity for the producers of the 192 pictures, and further details about a few individuals.
Der geraubte Schatten: Photographie als ethnographis ches Dokument (München [Munich], Germany: Thomas Theye for the Münchner Stadtmuseum), 1989.
Faber, Monika, editor. Das Innere der Sicht: Surrealistiche Fotografie der 30er und 40er Jahre (Wien [Vienna]: Österreichisches Fotoarchiv im Museum Moderner Kunst), 1989.
Book accompanying a major exhibition on the topic of pho tography as ethnographic document. Includes an article, “Forscher und Fotografen: Kurzbiographien” [“Researchers and Photographers: Short Biographies”] by Ulrike Prinz,
A 223-page exhibition catalogue that includes 213 items by more than forty photographers working in this special field.
48
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 49
DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
pages 506–526, and other possibly helpful articles, such as an overview history of ethnographic photography in German speaking countries in the nineteenth century, pages 60–119.
Groeneveld, Anneke, editor, et al. Odagot: Photographs of American Indians 1860–1920 (Amsterdam: Fragment Uitgeverij and Rotterdam: Museum voor Volkenkunde), 1992. Exhibition catalogue focusing on the activities of the Dutch ethnologist Herman F. C. ten Kate in North and South America and the pictures he assembled, now in museum collections in the Netherlands. The section “Biographies of Photographers,” pages 99–102, has thirtyfour entries, some unfamiliar and some extracted from secondary sources, in particular from The North American Indians in Early Photographs by Paula Richardson Fleming and Judith Luskey (see North America/United States/ General and Regional); a few spelling errors occur. Parallel Dutch and English texts.
Gernsheim, Helmut. Creative Photography: Aesthetic Trends 1839–1960 (New York: Bonanza Books), 1962. The section “Short Biographies of Photographers Illustrated,” pages 231–247, gives information on 122 notable photographers throughout history.
Gesualdo, Vicente. Historia de la Fotografía desde Alaska hasta Tierra del Fuego en el Siglo XIX (Buenos Aires: Editorial Sui Generis), 1990. An odd but surprisingly broad compendium surveying the Americas from north to south, derived from many other published works and seasoned with new and uncomm on matter. Each country or region is given a section with illustrations varying from Xerox copies to rich images. This work is one of the very few to discuss early photography in the islands of the Caribbean. The section “Indice Biográfico,” pages 275–302, gives short biographies for approximately 400 individuals. The texts and picture captions give dates and life or career details for many unreported elsewhere.
Gruber, L. Fritz. Grosse Photographen unseres Jahrhunderts (Düsseldorf and Wien [Vienna]: Econ), 1964. A biographical dictionary of thirty-five prominent twentieth century photographers, beginning with Atget. Superseded by more complete surveys.
Gruber, Renate, and L. Fritz Gruber. The Imaginary Photo Museum (New York: Harmony Books), 1982. The section “About the Photographers,” pages 238–265, compiled by Jeane von Oppenheim, supplies biographical dates (by year only) and short outline statements about the several dozen photographers included in the 1980 Photokina exhibit. Data is largely compiled from sixteen generally standard references in the history of photography.
Gilbert, George. The Illustrated Worldwide Who’s Who of Jews in Photography (New York: George Gilbert), 1996. A difficult work to define or evaluate for several reasons, as suggested by its own sub-title, “Photographers, Scientists, Israel and Women—150 Photos and over 500 Biographies.” While considerable scarce information is given specifically about photographers, the details have come by such diverse means as to preclude verification. Some primary data is from historians or archivists, some from hearsay or thirdhand references and re-transcription, and some from no clear source. The text and organization are idiosyncratic, sometimes whimsical, and not always clear. Particular details, such as how names were changed, are confused at times and in need of stringent editing and proofreading. Some sections do not reflect their bases for inclusion or omission of major people. Although the concept of establish ing such a category has troubled a number of researchers, this work documents the presence of large numbers of this ethnic group in the field. An interesting and possibly rewarding compilation that requires caution.
Guichon, Françoise. Montagne: Photographies de 1845 à 1914 (Paris: Editions Denoël), 1984. The well-produced catalogue for an exhibition at the Musées de Chambéry that surveyed mountain views, from a daguerreotype in the Alps by John Ruskin, to scenes from Wales, India, and the Pyrenees. The French text section “Notices Biographiques,” pages 119–123, by Dominique Carré, Sylviane de Decker Heftler, and Elvire Perego, gives useful life and career details on twenty-eight individuals notable in this specialized area of interest.
Hall-Duncan, Nancy. The History of Fashion Photography (New York: Alpine Book Company, Inc., Publishers—A Chanticleer Press Edition), 1977. The first large scale history of this specialized topic, published to accompany an exhibition at the International Museum of Photography at George Eastman House, gives a good overview and an opening for further research. The section “Selected Biographies,” pages 224–231, gives details on approximately sixty individuals or firms of substance, many unrecognized outside their particular sphere.
Glassman, Elizabeth, and Marilyn F. Symmes. Cliché verre: Hand-Drawn, Light-Printed—A Survey of the Medium from 1839 to the Present (Detroit: The Detroit Institute of Arts), 1980. Major exhibition catalogue; gives biographical statements on all the major practitioners of the particular medium.
Haller, Margaret. Collecting Old Photographs (New York: Arco Publishing Co., Inc.), 1978.
Greenough, Sarah, et al. On the Art of Fixing a Shadow: One Hundred and Fifty Years of Photography (Boston: Little Brown and Company, Bulfinch Press), 1989.
Chapter Four “Historic Names in Photography,” pages 28–77, lists approximately 312 persons with dates and commentary; there are errors in spelling and information. Chapter Five, “Fifty Twentieth Century Names,” pages 78–90, is similarly flawed.
The section “Artists’ Bibliographies,” pages 483–496, compiled by Megan Fox, gives years and places of birth and death for the 221 photographers featured, along with bibliographic references on each.
49
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 50
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
Biographical Supplement of Photographers,” eighteen pages of brief entries, mostly for recently active photographers.
Hambourg, Maria Morris, and Christopher Phillips. The New Vision: Photography between the World Wars—Ford Motor Collection at the Metropolitan Museum (New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art; distributed by Harry N. Abrams, Inc.), 1989. A major book celebrating a large exhibition of the donated collection of the Ford Motor Company. Both the main section of “Plates,” pages 109–272, and “The List of Text Illustrations,” pages 300–304, give nationalities and life dates for more than seventy-five major international figures from the period 1919–1939.
Hansen, Anna Christine, compiler. To Collect the Art of Women: The Jane Reese Williams Photography Collection—Biographies and Statements of the Artists (Santa Fe, New Mexico: Museum of Fine Arts, Museum of New Mexico), 1997. A free-standing publication issued to supplement the exhib it catalogue cited below under Yates et al. Brief biographical statements and quotations about their own work are given for fifty-six women from Mrs. Cameron to the present. Taken together, the two volumes offer considerable useful information to celebrate the gift of a major pioneer collector of photography by women.
Heilbrun, Françoise, and Philippe Néagu, translated by Carol Pratl. Musée d’Orsay: Masterpieces from the Photographic Collection (Amsterdam: Meulenhoff/Landshoff), 1987.
Jacobson, Ken, and Anthony Hamber. Etude d’Après Nature: Nineteenth Century Photographs in Relation to Art (Petches Bridge, Essex: Ken & Jenny Jacobson), 1996.
A finely produced selection of pieces from a major French museum collection. The catalogue listing for the 177 plates gives life years for nearly all of the ninety photographers included, and most captions include the year the image was made. A few of the French and other European photo graphers are seldom found elsewhere.
A highly dedicated piece of work based on extended research through the literature after primary study of works by the “group of photographers who specialized in [mak ing] artists’ studies in the nineteenth century.” This is a trail blazing examination of the careers and output of photographers who provided reference material for artists to use in lieu of preliminary sketches, illustrated with paral lel images as well as photographs from several noted painters’ collections. A significant contribution towards understanding the complex relationship between fine art and photography in the nineteenth century, the work also places Atget’s work firmly in its utilitarian art-historical context. The section “Photographers,” pages 169–183, com prises 108 short biographies. A very liberal bibliography suggests areas for further study. This work is a highly important contribution to the entire field, and its richness is strengthened by its example of interdisciplinary considera tions that reach beyond all previous offerings of the simple parallels between painting and early photography. Available at US$65 or £40 plus $10 for airmail postage out side Europe and USA. Address: Ken & Jenny Jacobson, “Southcotes,” Petches Bridge, Great Bardfield, Essex, CM7 4QN, United Kingdom. Fax: +44.1371.810845.
Hinson, Tom E., et al. Catalogue of Photography: The Cleveland Museum of Art (Cleveland, Ohio: The Cleveland Museum of Art), 1996. Cited in BHA, Vol. 7, No. 3 (1997), entry 16321, as a 490-page catalogue including biographies.
Holme, Bryan, editor-in-chief, et al. Landscape [in the series The Library of World Photography] (Boston: Hill & Company, Publishers), 1987. A handsome survey of 210 outstanding images from the entire history of photography. Pages 213–220 give biograph ical paragraphs for most of the photographers represented.
Hülsewig-Johnen, Jutta, et al. Das Foto als autonomes Bild: Experimentelle Gestaltung 1839–1989 (Stuttgart: Cantz), 1989. The section “Biografien,” pages 207–216, gives life details for seventy-eight makers of experimental photographic images throughout the 150 years of the medium.
Jaguer, Edouard. Les Mystères de la Chambre Noire: Le Surréalisme et la Photographie (Paris: Flammarion), 1982.
International Center of Photography Encyclopedia of
Photography (New York: Crown Publishers, Inc.—
A Pound Press Book), 1984.
Reproduces 300 images, each with complete caption and commentary, by 130 photographers, most of them active before 1940. Includes much embedded biographical informa tion on surrealist photographers, as well as mainstream pho tographers who alluded to surrealism. The entries are not in alphabetical order, so the index on page 222 is essential.
A full-scale international encyclopedia with 250 biographical entries on notable individual photographers throughout the history of the medium. Also includes “Appendix I:
50
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 51
DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
Lang, Robert J. “Panorama Documentation Project— List of Museums and Other Organizations with Panoramas—List of Panoramic Photographers.” Third printing January 1991.
Jeffrey, Ian, editor. The Photography Book (London: Phaidon Press), 1997. Alphabetical presentation of 500 photographers, from the beginning to the present, each represented by one image, brief biographical notes, and a concise commentary.
Compiled for the International Association of Panoramic Photographers, the listing contains information on more than 1,100 panoramic photographers active over the last 150 years. It is backed by a computerized database of biographi cal information. Available from the compiler at 100 Cooper Court, Port Jefferson, New York 11777.
Johnson, Brooks. Photography Speaks: 66 Photographers and Their Art (Norfolk, Virginia: Chrysler Museum of Art), 1989. Covering a full range of the history of the medium, the volume presents one picture from the museum’s collection by each of the sixty-six individuals and adds a brief biogra phy and a commentary by the photographer, sometimes about the specific work illustrated.
Lionel-Marie, Annick, et al. Collection de Photographie du Musée National d’Art Moderne, 1905–1948 (Paris: Editions du Centre Georges Pompidou), 1996. Cited in BHA, Vol. 7, No. 3 (1997), entry 16326, as a 516-page catalogue including 120 biographies.
———. Photography Speaks II. 70 Photographers on Their Art from the Collection of the Chrysler Museum (Norfolk, Virginia: Aperture in association with the Chrysler Museum of Art), 1996.
Lloyd, Valerie. Photography: The First Eighty Years (London: P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. Ltd.), 1976. Gives some degree of reference on approximately ninety early photographers worldwide with main emphasis on English, Scottish, and French; occasional errors.
The volume covers figures from the complete period of photography, from the daguerreotype through Robert Mapplethorpe, in a format similar to the earlier work cited immediately above.
Lowry, Bates, and Isabel Barrett Lowry. The Silver Canvas: Daguerreotype Masterpieces from J. Paul Getty Museum (London: Thames and Hudson), 1998.
Johnson, William S. Nineteenth Century Photography: An Annotated Bibliography 1839–1879 (Boston: G. K. Hall & Co.), 1990.
Catalogue of a collection rich in beautiful images. The section “Roster of Daguerreian Makers in the Getty Museum Collection,” compiled by Michael Hargraves, pages 230–232, gives life years (or approximate work peri ods) and nationalities for 164 individuals and partnerships.
An absolute tome of research. Pages 1–720 list entries alphabetically, with bibliographic notations, for thousands of photographers or writers on photography from the first forty years of the medium. Many entries give solid biogra phical notes; many more have at least life or career dates. Six additional sections offer historical surveys of literature in general history, by individual country, by year, by application, and by “Apparatus, Equipment, Cameras and Lenses” for a total of more than 950 pages. Inevitably omissions and errors exist in the first issue of any such massive work, but the quality of detailed information is quite high and offers one of the most substantial additions to the overall literature yet produced.
[Marbot, Bernard, editor.] Une Invention du XIXe Siècle. Expression et Technique. La Photographie (Paris: Bibliothèque Nationale), 1976. Catalogue of a major exhibition based on the holdings of the Société française de photographie, giving annotated biographical or career entries for approximately 100 early photographers, most of them French, but including some from many countries, from America to Russia; several are major pioneers, while others are almost unknown. Since later research has revealed more details on the life and work of some of the earlier members of the Société française de photographie, the volume is best used in conjunction with The Art of French Calotype, with a Dictionary of Photographers, 1848–1870 by André Jammes and Eugenia Parry Janis, cited below under France: General and National.
Kraus, Rosalind, and Jane Livingston. L’Amour Fou: Photography and Surrealism (New York: Abbeville Press, Publishers, for the Corcoran Gallery of Art), 1985. The section “Artist Biographies and Bibliographies,” pages 193–237, compiled by Winifred Schiffman, gives biographi cal data and source references for twenty-four key figures of this twentieth century international school of photography.
Mathews, Oliver. Early Photographs and Early Photographers: A Survey in Dictionary Form (New York: Pitman Publishing Corporation), 1973.
Krichbaum, Jörg. Lexikon der Fotografen (Frankfurt am Main: Fischer Taschenbuch Verlag), 1981. Entire book of 198 pages gives 500 biographies of photo graphers active from 1830 [sic] to 1980.
The section “Photographers and Photographic Inventors,” pages 6–44, gives sketchy biographies for approximately 300 photographers in various parts of the world. The entries are sometimes unsound or confusing, and the work as a whole has been overtaken by more recent scholarship.
Kunstphotographie um 1900: Die Sammlung Ernst Juhl (Hamburg: Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe), 1989. Massive and lavish exhibition catalogue surveying one of the great surviving collections of Pictorialist photography. The section “Bestandskatalog,” pages 173–301, compiled by Margret Kruse and Jens Jäger, describes 933 prints in the collection by approximately 220 individual photographers. The entries are presented alphabetically, and the collection’s holding by each photographer is preceded by a concise biography.
———. The Album of Carte-de-Visite and Cabinet Portrait Photographs 1854–1914 (London: Reedminster Publications Ltd.), 1974. Includes an alphabetical list of 750 photographers and firms notable for work in these formats.
51
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 52
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
A superbly produced exhibit catalogue for one of the major personal collections of the particular photographic form. The historical text is in the form of an interview with the collector, Joachim Bonnemaison, presented in French and English. The section “Index,” pages 177–186, is in French only and gives short career summaries and some biographi cal dates for thirty-two individuals or firms working in the particular format.
Mrázková, Daniela, et al. Co Je Fotografie: 150 Let / What Is Photography: 150 Years of Photography (Praha [Prague]: Videopress), 1989. A major exhibit catalogue issued for the sesquicentennial of photography and covering works borrowed from eightynine international sources. Several historical and inter pretive essays are interspersed among sections of pictures with dated captions, all with Czech and English texts. The section “Fotografové,” pages 328–350, gives biographical details for 384 individuals, including many central and eastern Europeans usually not found in the literature, and noting many women. Unfortunately, this material is written in Czech only and is difficult to use. One helpful clue is that feminine names in Czech all end in “ová.” There are occa sional mechanical errors, but this is a remarkable reference source. An entire catalogue of modern Czech photography is given in an appendix: see Europe/Czechoslovakia.
Pare, Richard. Photography and Architecture 1839–1939 (Montréal: Callaway Editions for Canadian Centre for Architecture), 1982. The “Catalog,” pages 217–272, compiled by Catherine Evans Inbusch and Marjorie Munsterberg, gives biogra phies for eighty notable architectural photographers or part nerships, including several unresearched elsewhere, who were active during the first century of photography. Somewhat difficult to use because names are given accord ing to the order of plates in the book rather than alphabeti cally. Some particularly good research. Also published in a French edition.
Naef, Weston J. The Collection of Alfred Stieglitz: Fifty Pioneers of Modern Photography (New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Viking Press), 1978. The “Catalog,” pages 253–495, gives biographical data, portraits, samples of signatures or logos, and other informa tion for fifty important photographers of the Pictorialist era drawn from a major collection in the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Naggar, Carole. Dictionnaire des Photographes (Paris: Editions du Seuil), 1982. Gives biographies of 420 photographers throughout history, together with listings of sixty museums, magazines, and other related items.
Naturalist Photography 1880 to 1920 (Winchester, Massachusetts: Lee Gallery), 1998. An illustrated catalogue including sections on twenty-eight American and British individuals or groups. The biographi cal entries by Maura Boylan give details for several persons not seen elsewhere. The Lee Gallery issues occasional thematic catalogues of a similar type. Address: 1 Mount Vernon Street, Winchester, Massachusetts 01890. Fax: (781) 729–4592.
Palmquist, Peter E., and Gia Musso. Women Photo graphers: A Selection of Images from the Women in Photography International Archive 1852–1997 (Kneeland, California: Iaqua Press), 1997.
Peterson, Christian A. Alfred Stieglitz’s Camera Notes (New York and London: W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., for the Minneapolis Institute of Arts), 1993.
A rich sample of the holdings of this recently established archive and a strong example of dedicated achievement in the field. The volume features one image by each of eightyeight women photographers, drawn from a total holding of 8,400 works by 1,190 individuals and biographical files on more than 18,000. A section of “Biographies” at the back of the book, which is without page numbering, gives varying amounts of information on each person, as well as total holdings and estimated dates of activity for all photogra phers represented by works in the collection. The edition is limited to 300 copies and is available directly from the authors. Address: 1183 Union Street, Arcata, California 95521. E-mail:
[email protected]
A very fine monograph which includes a section “The Photographers,” pages 157–178, giving copious biographi cal information on fifty-one photographers whose work was published in Camera Notes, periodical of the New York Camera Club, between 1897 and 1903.
[———.] Fotografs [sic] of Flowers (Minneapolis, Minnesota: The Minneapolis Institute of Arts), 1998. An exhibition brochure which includes a biographical cata logue listing fifty-two photographers, mostly American but including Europeans and Asians. The time coverage runs from Julia Margaret Cameron and Emile Tourtin to the present day, and includes both major and little-known photographers.
Panoramas: Photographies 1850–1950: Collection Bonnemaison ([Arles, France]: Rencontres Internationales de la Photographie/Actes Sud), 1989. 52
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 53
DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
La Photographie d’Art vers 1900 (Bruxelles [Brussels]: Crédit Communal), 1983.
pages of advertisements. It gives the most thorough picture of the scope and nature of photography at a specific time as anything else ever published. There are inevitable over sights, and some scattered inaccuracies in names or geogra phy, but the scale and depth of information make this work a landmark of research in the field for any period. See relat ed entries for 1893 editions under Europe: Great Britain: General and National; and North America: General and International; they are substantially different publications in form and content. Xerox copies can be ordered from Peter Palmquist, 1183 Union Street, Arcata, California 95521. E-mail:
[email protected]
The book for a major exhibition of international Pictorialist photography; includes essays by Pool Andries, Roger Coenen, and Margaret Harker. Extensively illustrated alpha betical catalogue gives one-page biographies for all thirtyeight photographers. Also published in a Dutch edition.
Photographs: Sheldon Memorial Art Gallery Collection, University of Nebraska—Lincoln (Lincoln, Nebraska: Nebraska Art Association), 1977. The section “Catalog,” pages 115–202, gives alphabetical listing of 201 photographers throughout the history of the medium; includes biographical dates and notes on edu cation, awards, solo exhibitions, locations of work in collections, and a few small reproductions of pictures.
Steinert, Otto, and Bjørn Ochsner. Det Kongelige Bibliotek: Fotografien aus der Sammlung der Königlichen Bibliothek Kopenhagen (Essen, Germany: Museum Folkwang), 1976. A thirty-eight page exhibition catalogue for an historical survey of photography selected from the collection of the Danish Royal Library. A brief essay on the history of photo graphy in Denmark by Bjørn Ochsner gives a few datable references, and the two sections of the catalogue—Danish photography and the international collection—give life dates for a number of mostly European individuals.
Photomontages: Photographie Experimentale de l’Entre-Deux-Guerres (Paris: Centre National de la Photographie with the Ministère de la Culture), 1987. Published as No. 31 in the series Photo Poche; includes biographies of several notable workers in this genre active in the period 1918–1939.
Pictorialismus in der Photographie (Zürich, Switzerland: [Galerie] Zür Stockeregg), 1984.
Tooming, Peeter. Hõbedane Teekond [The Silver Journey] (Tallinn, Estonia: Valgus), 1990.
Exhibition catalogue includes a section “Biographien,” pages 63–65, compiled by Wolfgang Wiemann, giving biographical statements for fourteen, mostly well-known, practitioners of the Pictorialist aesthetic.
A short general history of photography that includes expla nations of early processes and a brief history of cameras. The book also contains a “calendar of the most important events in the photographic field around the world,” mainly drawn from various standard works, and a “lexicon” of the leading persons in photographic history in which some “Estonian inventors and photographers are included.” Some illustra tions show work by Estonian photographers as well as Russ ian and Baltic items, so that a bit of career information can be gleaned by careful examination. Estonian text throughout.
[Pinet, Hélène, and Michel Poivert, editors.] Le Salon de Photographie: Les Ecoles Pictorialistes en Europe et aux Etats-Unis vers 1900 (Paris: Musée Rodin), 1993. Well-illustrated collective work accompanying an exhibi tion of Pictorialist photography. The section “Biographies,” pages 183–191, contains thirty-six entries, some including portraits of the photographers discussed.
Travis, David. Photographs from the Julien Levy Collection Starting with Atget (Chicago: The Art Institute of Chicago), 1976.
Rosenblum, Naomi. A History of Women Photographers (Paris, London, and New York: Abbeville Press), 1994.
Gives one-page biographies for twenty-eight major photog raphers active in Europe and America during the first half of the twentieth century.
A section, pages 291–327, contains biographies of 238 photographers worldwide.
Treadwell, T. K., and William C. Darrah. Stereographers of the World ([n.p.]: The National Stereoscopic Association), 1994; Volume I—Foreign; Volume II—U.S.
Sipley, Louis Walton. Photography’s Great Inventors (Philadelphia: American Museum of Photography), 1965. Includes biographical sketches and portraits for 112 indi viduals.
An absolute landmark in the field of photographic history, the result of rare personal dedication. Building far beyond the files collected over decades by the late William C. Darrah, T. K. Treadwell has verified vast amounts of infor mation that was denied earlier publication since it was not drawn from direct observation. Adding data gathered by his own research and from several hundred correspon dents, he has compiled a computer database of more than 10,000 entries in varying depth. The foreign data is arranged by country, but is somewhat patchy and of variable accura cy because of transcription errors and a misinterpretation of the output of carte-de-visite photographers who are not known to have produced stereos. The published work is available in hard or soft covers, unbound, or on computer disk from National Stereoscopic Association Information Service, 4201 Nagle Road, Bryan, Texas 77801.
Sprange, Walter, editor. The “Blue Book” for Amateur Photographers. American Edition, 1895. (Beach Bluff, Massachusetts: Walter Sprange), 1895. An almost inconceivable compendium of detail, the more remarkable for the period in which it was produced. The editor states his intention to offer a volume as full as possi ble of useful information to amateur photographers in all countries, and then sets forth 337 pages of broad and sub stantive detail: lists of photographic societies all over the world (many with their members and officers named), “Dark Rooms and Dealers—Professional Photographers” (a similar worldwide enumeration), technical and scientific information, and travel details. The book also includes 115 53
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 54
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
A thin, illustrated catalogue for an exhibit/sale timed to coincide with the Fifth National Conference of Women in Photography, held at Simmons College in Boston. The section “Select Biographies” gives brief sketches on thirteen women photographers of substance, mostly American, from throughout the history of the medium.
[Walter, Paul F.] A Personal View: Photography in the Collection of Paul F. Walter (New York: The Museum of Modern Art), 1985. An exhibition catalogue celebrating one man’s taste as a collector that developed from his interests in Asian art into his becoming a member of the Committee on Photography of the Museum of Modern Art. The “Catalogue” section, pages 98–132, gives biographical notes on fifty-three persons, a few that are rarely examined elsewhere.
[Yates, Steve, Eugenia Parry Janis, et al.] To Collect the Art of Women: The Jane Reese Williams Photography Collection (Santa Fe, New Mexico: Museum of Fine Arts, Museum of New Mexico), 1991.
Walters, Judith Allison. Photographers of North America, Great Britain and Europe (Bothell, Washington: Privately published), 1980.
An exhibit catalogue in celebration of the gift made by a pioneering collector of work by women photographers. Pages 29–32 give life years and nationalities for fifty-six women and one man represented in the exhibition. These details were compiled by Anna Christine Hansen, whose more substantial work on the collection is cited above under her name.
A privately produced commercial computerized reference work intended to assist genealogical dating and family histo ry work. Available directly from the compiler for US $8.25. For the compiler’s ongoing research, see under Works in Progress. Has also issued A Guide to Dating Old Family Photographs (1993), which includes 145 examples of photo graphs from the 1840s to 1905, with descriptions, sugges tions for use, and an index, for US$16.45. Address: P. O. Box 129, Bothell, Washington 98041. E-mail:
[email protected]
Zannier, Italo. Le Grand Tour in the Photographs of Travelers of [the] Nineteenth Century (Venezia [Venice]: Canal & Stamperie Editrice and Paris: Canal Editions), 1997.
Weiermair, Peter. Photographie als Kunst 1879–1979/ Kunst als Photographie (Innsbruck, Austria: Allerheiligenpresse), 1979.
One of the most impressive productions thus far in the social history of photography and an elegant tribute to the author, who has long been a valued contributor to the field. Tracing the traditional route of the Grand Tour from Switzerland, through Italy and around the Mediterranean from Greece to Spain, the book offers an excellently repro duced selection of typical views, drawn from a number of archives and private collections in Italy. While not a directory, the seventy-five individuals or firms featured can be recognized and given estimated dates of activity from the plate captions, and the text offers career details and valuable insights that are seldom considered elsewhere. Text in Italian, French, and English; occasional curious forms of technical terms result from translators lacking specific vocabulary.
Extensive exhibition catalogue surveying the multifaceted relationship between art and photography. Gives capsule biographies for several hundred photographers throughout the history of the medium, with an emphasis on modern and contemporary individuals.
Welling, William. Collector’s Guide to Nineteenth Century Photographs (New York: Collier Books), 1976. Probably the most reliable and informative of the many col lectors’ guides published in the recent past. The section on pages 117–127 gives listings and biographical notes on some early English, Scottish, and American photographers plus membership lists of several turn-of-the-century societies.
2. AFRICA (also see Near and Middle East/Egypt)
Witkin, Lee D. A Ten Year Salute: A Selection of Photographs in Celebration [of] The Witkin Gallery 1969–1979 (Danbury, New Hampshire: Addison House), 1979.
General and International Bensusan, A. D. Silver Images. History of Photography in Africa (Cape Town, South Africa: Howard Timmins), 1966.
Basically an exhibit catalogue with added reminiscences and numerous illustrations with personal comments. The section “Technical Information,” pages 196–198, is actually a picture listing that gives life years for approximately ninetyfive well-known individuals.
This continuous text history has not yet been superseded, and contains information on individuals not available elsewhere. While laying stress on the development of photography in South Africa, the author attempts to survey the whole continent, and includes a chapter, “Rhodesia and Moçambique,” pages 29–32.
Witkin, Lee D., and Barbara London. The Photograph Collector’s Guide (Boston: New York Graphic Society), 1979. Pages 63–275 give biographical data, career assessments, specimen signatures or logos, and bibliographical and collection data for 234 major, mostly recent, photographers. Pages 313–323 give biographical or activity dates and locations for 1,000 daguerreotypists around the world. Pages 325–388 give biographical or activity dates and general locations for several thousand additional photographers.
Fleig, Alain. Rêves de Papier: La Photographie Orientaliste, 1860–1914 (Neuchâtel, Switzerland: Editions Ides et Calendres), 1997. Very handsome presentation of images by photographers in North Africa and the Middle East—residents and visitors— drawn mainly from the collections of the author and Michel and Michèle Auer. The section “Biographies,” pages 169–173, contains brief but informative entries on eightyfour individuals, including forty-one “pioneer travelers,”
Women in Photography (Winchester, Massachusetts: Lee Gallery), June 1997. 54
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 55
DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
twenty-five “photographers resident in the Middle East,” and eighteen “photographers in the Maghreb.” The latter sub-section, covering present-day Algeria and Tunisia, is particularly valuable.
Pankhurst, Richard, and Denis Gérard. Ethiopia Photographed: Historic Photographs of the Country and its People Taken between 1867 and 1935 (London and New York: Kegan Paul International), 1996. The first substantial compilation. While most of the photo graphs are unattributed, the introduction sections, “Images of the Country and its History” (pp. 7–18) and “The Coming of Photography” (pp. 19–36), give a good background and written descriptionson pre-photographic images, and the period of photography beginning with the camera obscura. The early period of work by missionaries or British invaders in the 1860s leads into the later years of work by numerous foreign visitors and several resident studios, and the discus sion offers many useful details. The notes for the text refer to two previously published articles by Professor Pankhurst.
Jenkins, Paul. “The Earliest Generation of Missionary Photographers in West Africa and the Portrayal of Indigenous People and Culture,” History in Africa, Vol. 20 (1993), pp. 92–93. Not directly examined. Cited by Yarak (see entry under Ghana).
Monti, Nicholas, editor. Africa Then: Photographs 1840–1918 (New York: Alfred A. Knopf), 1987. The section “The Photographers,” pages 161–172, gives biographical and career information on 115 photographers from many countries who were active in various parts of Africa, including Egypt.
Triulzi, Alessandro. “Photographic Records of Nineteenth Century Ethiopian Towns in Italian Archives” in Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Centenary of Addis Ababa (Addis Ababa), 1987, pp. 97–117.
Algeria (See entry for Fleig under Africa/General and International)
Not directly examined. Cited by Roberts, p. 4.
Angola (See entry for Siza and Weiermair under Europe/Portugal)
Ghana Yarak, Larry W. “Early Photography in Elmira” ([n.p.]: [n.p.], 1995). Research article on daguerreotypists in a town on the Ghanaian coast, an important trading post in West Africa. The article appears to have been published electronically only. URL: http://acs.tamu.edu/~yarak/photo-el.htm
Cameroon Geary, Christraud. Images from Bamum: German Colonial Photography at the Court of King Njoya. Cameroon, West Africa, 1902–1915 (Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press), 1988.
Gold Coast (See entry for Jenkins under Africa/General and International)
An anthropological case study, drawing on images by several named German photographers. Translation of a work originally published in German (München [Munich]: Trickster), 1985.
La Réunion
Congo (Also see entry for Joseph, Schwilden, and Claes under Europe/Belgium/General and National)
Ryckebusch, Jackie. Louis Antoine Roussin et ses Précurseurs. Les Débuts de la Lithographie et de la Photographie à La Réunion (Paris: F. & R. Chamonal), 1994.
Meyfroot, Véronique. Fotografen en de Kolonisatie van Congo 1885–1914 (Leuven [Louvain], Belgium: [Master of Arts thesis, KUL-Catholic University of Louvain]), 1982, two volumes.
Lavishly produced and illustrated monograph document ing the early development of the twin nineteenth century printing technologies on the island of La Réunion, a French overseas department off the East coast of Africa. Contains a considerable amount of previously unpublished biographi cal information in the text.
Contains copious biographical information, especially on expeditionary photographers, and many previously unknown images.
Mauritius
Ethiopia Pankhurst, Richard. “The Genesis of Photography in Ethiopia and the Horn of Africa,” British Journal of Photography, Vol. 123, Nos. 41–44 (1976), pp. 878–882, 910–913, 933–936, and 952–957.
Pavard, Claude. Mémoires de Couleurs: Ile Maurice (Sèvres, France: [n.p.]), 1994. Not directly examined. Cited as a 139-page work compris ing “photographic history and contemporary photo graphs,” in Roosens and Salu 4, p. 208.
Multisection study, including many names unreported else where. The author covers European traveler-photographers, beginning with H. A. Stern in 1859, various French and English military deputations and religious missions, as well the first studio photographers in Addis Ababa in the early twentieth century.
Morocco (See entry for Sanchez Montoya under Spain/Local and Regional)
55
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 56
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
Mozambique (See entry for Bensusan under Africa/General and International)
Schoeman, Karel. “‘Photographisten’ en ‘Photographic Artists’: Fotografie in die Vrystaat, 1850–1900,” African Notes and News, Vol. 25, No. 7 (September 1983), pp. 232–237, and Vol. 25, No. 8 (December 1983), pp. 291–294.
Rhodesia (See entry for Bensusan under Africa/General and International)
Reported by Jackie Loos of the South African Library, Cape Town, as a two-part study containing a directory of more than 100 photographers active in the Orange Free State in the nineteenth century.
Sierra Leone
Spencer, B. “Nineteenth Century Natal Photographers” in The Documentation and Care of Photographic Collections: Proceedings of a Symposium held April 22–23, 1982 (Pietermaritzburg, South Africa), 1982, pp. 77–87.
Viditz-Ward, Vera. “Photography in Sierra Leone, 1850–1918,” Africa, Vol. 57, No. 4 (1987), pp. 510–517. A pioneering article that focuses on several African profes sional photographers who worked in Freetown during this period.
Not directly examined. Cited by Roberts, p. 4.
Tunisia (Also see entry for Fleig under Africa/General and International)
———. “Notes toward a History of Photography in Sierra Leone, West Africa,” Exposure, Vol. 28, No. 3 (1991–1992), pp. 16–22. Reworking of aspects of the survey article cited immediately above.
Gabous, Abdelkrim. La Tunisie des Photographes 1875–1910 (Paris: Editions Cérès, Editions Paris Audiovisuel, and Editions du Cygne), 1994.
South Africa (Also see entry for Bensusan under Africa/General and International)
A general overview with very brightly printed plates. The section “Les Photographes de Tunisie,” pages 125–129, gives biographical entries for ten persons, mostly unreport ed elsewhere.
Bensusan, A. D. “Nineteenth Century Photographers in South Africa,” Africana Notes and News, Vol. 15, No. 6 (June 1963), pp. 219–252.
3. ASIA
Introduction followed by an “Alphabetical List of Photographers of Nineteenth Century in South Africa,” giving entries for more than 400 individuals, including addresses, dates of activity, and references to partnerships. The listing, compiled from local directories and news papers, is an excellent pioneering effort, that has not yet been superseded in South Africa nor equalled elsewhere in Africa. The compilers are grateful to Carol Hardijzer for supplying a photocopy of the article.
General and International Falconer, John, Steven Wachlin, and Anneke Groeneveld. Van Bombay tot Shanghai [From Bombay to Shanghai] (Amsterdam: Stichting Fragment Foto and Rotterdam: Museum voor Volkenkunde), 1994. Another important contribution in the fine series produced over several years by this collaboration (with a reorganiza tion of the original Fragment Uitgeverij into a nonprofit foundation). Parallel texts in Dutch and English give a sound overview. The section “Biographical Notes on the Nineteenth Century Photographers in the Indian SubContinent, South-East Asia and the Far East,” pages 96–107, gives career details for 490 individuals or firms. A valuable coverage for both quality and infrequency in the field.
Bull, Marjorie, and Joseph Denfield. Secure the Shadow: The Story of Cape Photography from Its Beginnings to the End of 1870 (Cape Town, South Africa: Terence McNally), 1970. Appendix A, pages 222–253, lists photographers and studios active in South Africa 1846–1870 with selected biographies; Appendix B, pages 254–257, categorizes by location. The authors’ alphabetical card index of printed citations, mainly compiled from local newspapers, and on which the appendices were largely based, is now housed in the South African Library, Cape Town.
Burma Singer, Noel F. Burmah: A Photographic Journey, 1855–1925 (Gartmore-Stirling, United Kingdom: Paul Strachan—Kiskadale Ltd.), 1993.
Carstens, Antenie. Waardevolle Foto-dokumentering van die Paarl deur Fotograwe van die Tydperk 1871–1960 [Valuable Photodocumentation of Paarl by Photographers during the Period 1871–1960] (Paarl, South Africa: [Research paper]), 1988.
Basically a book of narrative text and pictures but includes a single-page “List of Photographers and Post Card Publishers,” page 31, comprising forty names without biog raphical details or dates. Some captions are dated and some time periods can be surmised from the pictures themselves. Hopefully, further research will be undertaken for the area.
Reported by Renée van der Riet of Museumafrica, Johannesburg. The author comments on difficulties encoun tered in dating photographs in the course of the research, undertaken to obtain a higher qualification in photography, in a letter published in The Photographic Journal, Vol. 130, No. 9 (September 1990), p. 381.
Ceylon Falconer, John. “Nineteenth Century Photography in Ceylon,” The Photographic Collector [London], Vol. 2, 56
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 57
DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
[One Hundred Years of Historical Photographs of the Region Anping, Tainam, Taiwan] (Taipei, Taiwan: Taiwan Cultural Foundation), 1995.
No. 2 (Summer 1981), pp. 39–54. A textual article outlining the history of European contact and surveying six major photographers or partnerships on the island. Aside from the author’s recognized quality of research, the article is valuable since it stands substantially alone in the field. This area clearly merits further research.
A 176-page exhibition catalogue, documenting the develop ment of photography on the island of Taiwan from the late nineteenth century on. The images appear to be drawn from collections worldwide, including the Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Paris. Text in Chinese throughout.
China (including Taiwan) Boissier, Jean-Louis, and Jacques Willaume. 30 Ans de Photographie Chinoise, 1930–1960 (Paris: Presses de l’Université de Vincennes), 1984.
Worswick, Clark, and Jonathan Spence. Imperial China: Photographs 1850–1912 (New York: Penwick Publishing, Inc.), 1978.
Well-illustrated exhibition catalogue containing much
unfamiliar material.
Pages 150–151 give an “Index of Commercial and Amateur Photographers of China, 1846–1912,” listing eighty-five photographers and firms with date periods and locations or topics of work. Book also published under an English imprint (London: Scolar Press), 1979.
Fontana, C. “Cronache de Commercianti Ambulanti e Indigeni Fotografi nella Cina Imperiale,” Rivista di Storia e Critica della Fotografia, Vol. 2, No. 3 (1981), pp. 37–50.
Wu Qun. Guangdong Sheying Shihua Tekan [Special Issue on Topics in the History of Cantonese Photography] (Guangzhou, China: The Photographers’ Company), 1993.
One of the few resources available in any language but Chinese. There is a listing of names, dates, and events in early photography in China. The text surveys the activities of commercial itinerants and indigenous photographers.
This entry and the two that follow are reported by Edwin K. Lai as collected volumes of essays by the noted photography historian Wu Qun, now deceased. Apparently they give a wide-ranging sample of both the general field of photography in China and more detailed information on some specific areas. All texts are in Chinese.
Huang Shaofen, editor. Shanghai Sheying Shi [History of Photography in Shanghai] (Shanghai: Shanghai Remin Meishu Chubanshe [The Photographers’ Association of China] in association with the Faculty of Arts, Shanghai University), 1992.
———. Zhongguo Sheying Licheng [Historical Developments of Chinese Photography](Beijing: Xinhua Chubanshe [Xinhua Publications], 1986.
Reported by Edwin K. Lai as providing “some useful infor mation about the photographic history” of Shanghai, which had early interaction with foreign influence and trade. Chinese text.
———. Zhongguo Sheyingjia Xiehui Guangdong Fenhui Chengli Sanshi Zhounian Jinian Tekan [Special Issue for the Thirtieth Anniversary of the Establishment of the Photographers’ Association of China, Canton Branch] (Guangzhou, China: The Photographers’ Company), 1988.
History of Photography in China 1840–1937 ([Taipei]: Photographer Publications), 1993. A 320-page textual history, produced by a group of histori ans based in Peking. The work appears to be divided into two periods for ideological reasons: 1840–1919 (founding of the Communist Party) and 1919–1937 (year of the invasion of China by Japan). Contains much information (including biographical) unfamiliar in the West. Text in Chinese only (except for title and publisher’s name).
Reported by Edwin K. Lai as “an anthology of essays on
the history of photography in Guangdong [Canton].”
Wue, Roberta. Picturing Hong Kong: Photography 1855–1910 (New York: Asia Society Galleries), 1997.
[History of Photography in Shanghai] (Shanghai: The Photographers’ Association of China in association with the Faculty of Arts, Shanghai University), 1992.
Well-illustrated study accompanying an exhibition and containing much new information on the development of photography in the territory which was a possession of the British Crown from 1842 through 1997. Embedded biogra phical data in the two essays “Picturing Hong Kong: Photography through Practice and Function,” by Roberta Wue, pages 27–47, and “The Beginnings of Hong Kong Photography,” by Edwin K. Lai, pages 48–57. The latter includes a listing of foreign professionals active in Hong Kong to 1881, page 51.
Reported by Edwin K. Lai as providing “some useful infor mation about the photographic history” of Shanghai, which had early interaction with foreign influence and trade. Chinese text.
Marbot, Bernard, and René Viénet. La Chine entre le Collodion Humide and le Gélatinobromure: Notes sur Quelques Photographies de la Chine au XIXe siècle (Paris: Centre de Publication Asie Orientale, Bibliothèque Nationale), 1978.
Zhongguo Sheying Shi 1840–1937 [History of Photography in China 1840–1937] ([Taipei]: Photographer Publications), 1990.
Essentially an exhibit catalogue with a few scattered biogra phical details in the text and a few advertisements from early business directories, including a listing from The China Directory for 1865. The work is solid and important, but makes clear the immensity of the region that still lacks a photographic history.
A 320-page textual history produced by a group of histori ans based in Peking, including Chen Sen, Hu Zhichuan, and Ma Yunceng. The work appears to be divided for ideologi cal reasons into two periods, 1840–1919 (founding of the Communist Party), and 1919–1937 (year of the invasion of 57
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 58
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
China by Japan). Clearly contains much information (including biographical) unfamiliar in the West. Text in Chinese only (except for title and publisher). First edition (Beijing: Zhongguo Sheying Chubanshe), 1987.
directory, it is a solid survey with much material not available elsewhere.
Wachlin, Steven. “Beeldvorming in de Fotografie, 1839–1939,” Geschiedenis in de Klas, Vol. 10, No. 29 (1989), pp. 2–41.
Dutch East Indies (see Indonesia)
Article surveying the Western image of the Dutch East Indies through photography. Includes short biographical sketches of five notable studios and partnerships.
India Desmond, Ray. “Nineteenth Century Indian Photographers in India,” History of Photography, Vol. 1, No. 4 (October 1977), pp. 313–317.
———. Woodbury and Page: Photographers Java (Leiden, Netherlands: KITLV Press), 1994.
Article containing career details on six prominent individuals.
A full text examination of the major historic firm in the area. While the single focus precludes any true directory, the overall survey and a specific “Chronology of the Firm of Woodbury & Page,” pages 195–200, offer career dates and details on several other photographers involved.
———. “Photography in India during the Nineteenth Century,” India Office Library and Records Report, 1974, pp. 5–36. Useful introductory study, still not superseded.
Japan Falconer, John. “Ethnological Photography in India 1850–1900,” The Photographic Collector [London], Vol. 5, No. 1 ([1984]), pp. 16–46.
The Advent of Photography in Japan (Tokyo: Tokyo Metropolitan Museum of Photography; Hokkaido, Japan: Hakodate Museum of Art), 1997.
A long article rather than a true directory but rich with details on several significant, specifically ethnographic, photographers.
Catalogue for a major exhibition, with much previously unpublished information and images. While the work contains no directory, the individual essays give biographi cal and career details for several prominent early Japanese photographers. The work includes a list of exhibits. Text in Japanese and English.
[Rogers, Brett, and Sean Williams, organizers, et al.] A Shifting Focus: Photography in India 1850–1900 (London: The British Council [and] The British Library), 1995.
Bennett, Terry. Early Japanese Images (Rutland, Vermont & Toyko, Japan: Charles E. Tuttle Comany), 1996.
Very fine exhibition catalogue containing an informative introductory essay by John Falconer of the British Library, and a “List of Exhibits,” pages 78–84, with carefully anno tated entries for the 153 prints shown. While not strictly biographical, much new information can be extracted and extrapolated.
An excellent survey of nineteenth century photography in Japan, making much information accessible to an English speaking readership for the first time. The chapters “Early Western Photographers in Japan,” pages 33–45, and “Early Japanese Photographers in Japan,” pages 46–58, give detailed career information on several prominent practitioners. In all, an essential reference work.
Thomas, G. History of Photography: India 1840–1980 (Andhra Pradesh, India: State Akademi [sic] of Photography), 1981. A solid textual history containing some individual career details. The index lists several hundred photographers, many active before 1914.
Indonesia Groeneveld, Anneke, et al. Toekang Potret: 100 Years of Photography in the Dutch Indies 1839–1939 (Amsterdam: Fragment Uitgeverij and Museum voor Volkenkunde, Rotterdam), 1989. A well-illustrated general history in both Dutch and English. The section “Commercial Photographers and Photographic Studios in the Netherlands East Indies 1850–1940: A Survey,” pages 177–192, compiled by Steven Wachlin, gives 537 alphabetical entries, followed by a chronological index by locality.
Levy Reed, Jane, editor. Toward Independence. A Century of Indonesia Photographed (San Francisco, The Friends of Photography), 1991. Exhibition catalogue containing fourteen well-illustrated short essays, following the development of photography from the 1840s to the mid-twentieth century. While not a 58
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 59
DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
———. Bakumatsu Shashin no Jidai (Tokyo: Chikuma Shobo), 1994.
Borhan, Pierre, and Kohtarô Iizawa. La Photographie Japonaise de l’Entre-Deux-Guerres: du Pictorialisme au Modernisme (Paris: Association française pour la Diffusion du Patrimoine Photographique), 1990.
Beautifully produced and richly illustrated study of photo graphy in Japan of the Bakumatsu era (through 1867). Includes a reprint in facsimile of the first textbook on photography published in Japan and a chronology. Text in Japanese only.
Cited in BHA, Vol. 3, No. 1 (1993), entry 5092, as a 140-page exhibition catalogue surveying the development of Japanese photography in the 1920s and 1930s. The work includes a directory of photographers and the 199 items represented are clearly captioned.
———. Shashin de Miru Bakumatsu Meiji (Tokyo: Sekai Bunkasha), 1990. Companion volume to the work cited immediately above, covering the period to the end of the Meiji era (through 1911). Reported to be equally richly illustrated. Not directly examined.
History of Japanese Photography, 1840–1945 (Tokyo: Heibonsha), 1972. Cited in MABS, p. 157, as a 516-page volume illustrating 100 years of Japanese history and society. Divided into ten, roughly chronological chapters. In Japanese, with an English summary.
———. Shashin no Makuake (Tokyo: Shogakukan), 1985. First volume in a projected comprehensive textual history of Japanese photography from its origins to the present day, Nihon Shashin Zenshu, presented by the Daiichi Art Center. The title translates as The Origins of Photography in Japan. Text in Japanese, with a two-page introduction in English. The title of the second volume, reportly published in 1986, translates The Heritage of Art Photography in Japan.
[Kaneko, Ryuichi.] Japanese Photography—Form In/Out. Part 1: From its Introduction to 1945 (Tokyo: Tokyo Metropolitan Museum of Photography), 1996. Exhibition catalogue, including a section “Artists’ Biography [sic],” pages 114–130, giving career details for more than one hundred individuals. While the main body of the text and captions are in Japanese and English, the biography section unfortunately is in Japanese only.
Winkel, Margarita. Souvenirs from Japan: Japanese Photography at the Turn of the Century (London: Bamboo Publishing Ltd. in association with Ukiyo-e Books bv, Leiden, The Netherlands), 1991.
[———, editor] Japanische Photographie 1860–1929 (Berlin: Argon Verlag for the Berliner Festspiele), 1993.
A handsomely reproduced set of the typical hand-colored “tourist” pictures from the late nineteenth century, mostly unattributed. Two of the sections of the text give more dates and specifics on several early photographers than most previous publications. The research is thorough and careful and offers an international bibliography that apparently includes several works that may offer dates on other individual careers.
A very handsome catalogue for an exhibition jointly pro duced by the Tokyo Metropolitan Museum of Photography and the Edo-Tokyo Museum for the 1993 Berlin Festival. Many of the pictures are dated and the section “Biografien,” pages 97–99, gives short summaries and life dates for the seventeen photographers featured in the exhibit in a context of considerable anonymous early work. The volume was published in soft cover as a catalogue and hardbound as a trade book.
Worswick, Clark. Japan: Photographs 1854–1905 (New York: Penwick Publishing, Inc. & Alfred A. Knopf, Inc.) 1979.
Marbot, Bernard. Objectif Cipango: Photographies anci ennes du Japon (Paris: Bibliothèque Nationale and Paris Audiovisuel), 1990.
Pages 129–139 provide historical survey text on Japanese photography in the nineteenth century; pages 144–149 give an annotated catalogue of 106 photographers.
An exhibit catalogue drawn from the holdings of the Bibliothèque Nationale. Few dates are given, but a special section, “Cipango devant L’Objectif (1862–1889),” gives scattered dates for albums and collections, with a brief general note about dates. The arrangement of the material makes it rather difficult to use.
Korea Bennett, Terry. Korea: Caught in Time (Reading, England: Garnet Publishing Limited), 1997.
Ono, Tadashi. “Un Dictionnaire des Photographes Japonais,” La Recherche Photographique, No. 9 (October 1990), pp. 80–91.
A fine addition to the Caught in Time series, devoted to bringing forth truly unfamiliar images and sources. A review in Stereo World (November–December 1997), by the historian and collector Norman Thorpe, indicates that the book includes more than 150 plates and information on approximately forty individuals. The reviewer notes that “some of the author’s identifications may be disputed, and there were other early photographers whose names also could have been included,” but adds that the work is “the best one . . . on early photography in Korea, and it provides an excellent starting place for other researchers.” Mr. Thorpe’s commentary is useful in its own right for giving in capsule form an outline of photography’s late entry into Korea and details on some of the pioneers who practiced there.
Directory containing thirty short biographies of Japanese photographers from all periods up to the present day. This special issue of La Recherche Photographique devoted to Japan also includes a survey of six national archives.
Ozawa, Tekesi. “The History of Early Photography in Japan,” History of Photography, Vol. 5, No. 4 (October 1981), pp. 285–303. A general article on the subject, covering the period to the end of the 1870s; gives details on a number of individuals including some from noble families not otherwise reported.
59
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 60
PHOTOGRAPHERS: A SOURCEBOOK FOR HISTORICAL RESEARCH
Malaysia (see Singapore and Malaya)
names, notably John Thomson, and a few others show logo types or professional announcements. There are also some listings of professional photographers and participants in the 1905 Bangkok photography exhibition. These and any other details on photographers are to be derived only by extrapolation or very close scrutiny of images, since the entire volume is in Thai (except for a brief English summa ry), but the range of images is still important as an introduc tion to the nation’s photographic history. The work reflects the establishment of a national museum of photography at Chulalongkorn University in Bangkok, with an internation al advisory board. Taken in tandem with the very useful 1987 publication by Nawigamune cited above, it bodes well for more accessible historical publishing in the country.
Nepal Shreshta, Padma Prakash, editor. Nepal Rediscovered: the Rana Court, 1846–1951: Photographs from the Archives of the Nepal Kingdom Foundation (Kathmandu: Nepal Kingdom Foundation), Vol. 14, 1986. Not directly examined. A ninety-seven-page book with ninety illustrations cited in Roosens and Salu 2, p. 217.
Philippines (Also see entry for Yañez-Polo et al. under Spain/General and National) Colonial Philippines Photographs 1860–1910 (Berkeley, California: Lowie Museum of Anthropology, University of California), 1987. Sixteen-page catalogue of an exhibition presented by the Philippine-American Research Center. Includes a checklist of ninety-seven images with the photographers identified. This area clearly requires further thorough research.
Singapore and Malaya Falconer, John. “G. R. Lambert and Co., and Some Notes on Early Photographers in Singapore,” The Photographic Collector [London], Vol. 5, No. 2 ([1984]), pp. 212–231. A textual article which briefly discusses several individuals and firms.
———. A Vision of the Past: A History of Early Photo graphy in Singapore and Malaya—The Photographs of G. R. Lambert and Co. (Singapore: Times Editions), 1987. An impressive volume extending the author’s earlier work. The section, “Index of Photographers in Singapore and Malaya 1813 [sic, for 1843]–1914,” pages 189–192, gives career notes on more than 100 photographers and studios. A valuable contribution.
Sri Lanka (see Ceylon)
Tibet
Thailand
Hoffman, Michael E. Tibet: The Sacred Realm. Photographs 1880–1950 (Millerton, New York: Aperture, in association with the Philadelphia Museum of Art), 1983.
Nawigamune, Anake. Early Photography in Thailand (Bangkok, Thailand: Sangdad Publishing House), 1987, second edition 1988.
The section “The Photographers,” pages 148–155, compiled by Martha Chadroudi, gives short biographies for twentytwo individuals.
A small paperback volume of 190 pages written almost entirely in Thai, but with numerous interesting plates (some from other known publications). The three-page English summary identifies the first four photographers in Siam and gives some biographical details for those and a few others. The second edition published in 1988 includes two-page errata with otherwise unaltered text.
Uzbekistan Kurbanov, Sabir, introduction. Samarkand (Reading, England: Garnet Publishing Limited), 1992. In the series and surtitled Caught in Time: Great Photographic Archives, the work presents photographs of this area of Uzbekistan. The images are drawn from archival holdings in St. Petersburg, Russia. The section “The Photographers,” pages 8–10, gives varying amounts of career detail for eight individuals, most of them Russian and quite unfamiliar in the West. Unfortunately the work of Paul Nadar is wrongly attributed to his father Félix.
Siripant, Sakda. King and Camera: Evolution of Photography in Thailand 1845–1992 (Bangkok: Darnsutha Press Co., Ltd.), 1992. A substantial volume reproducing many images previously unseen in the West, including some in color, and suggesting the continued interest in the medium by several of the kings of Siam (later Thailand). A few plates carry photographers’
60
Sourcebook pt2FF
4/10/04
11:57 AM
Page 61
DIRECTORIES OF PHOTOGRAPHERS
[Dansk Vestindien i Gamle Billeder] (København [Copenhagen]: The Danish West Indian Society), 1967.
Nedvetsky, Andrei G., compiler. Bukhara (Reading, England: Garnet Publishing Limited), 1993. In the series and surtitled Caught in Time: Great Photographic Archives, the work presents photographs taken by seven identified Russian expeditionary photographers in the 1890s and early twentieth century. The images are drawn from archival holdings in St. Petersburg, Russia.
A bilingual exhibition catalogue for the fiftieth anniversary of the cession of the Virgin Islands to the United States of America. The items shown were drawn from a number of Danish institutions, and the ten photographers covered are best researched further in Bjørn Ochsner’s major work on photographers in and from Denmark. (See below under Europe/Denmark/General and National.)
———. Khiva (Reading, England: Garnet Publishing Limited), 1993.
5. EUROPE
In the series and surtitled Caught in Time: Great Photographic Archives, the work presents photographs of the former Khanate of Khiva, a city in present-day Uzbekistan. The area became the object of Russian military expeditions in 1858, 1873, and 1878, when many of the photographs were taken. The images are drawn from the collections of the Russian Geographical Society and the Russian Academy of Sciences Institute of the History of Material Culture in St. Petersburg, Russia. While there is little detail given on the lives of the four identified photographers, the text and captions illuminate a previously unknown chapter in the early application of expeditionary photography.
General and International (Also see entry for Aguilar Ochoa under Latin America/Mexico) Allgemeines Adress—Handbuch Ausübender Photographen von Deutschland, den Österr. Kaiserstaaten, der Schweiz und den Hauptstädten der Angrenzenden Länder als Brüssel, Kopenhagen, London, Paris, Petersburg, Stockholm u.a. (Leipzig: Robert Schaefer’s Verlag), 1863. A seventy-four page general address book of practicing photographers of Germany, the Austrian Empire, Switzerland, plus the neighboring capitals of Brussels, Copenhagen, London, Paris, St. Petersburg, Stockholm, and others. As the first attempt at a pan-European directory of photographers, it is an historical curiosity, but useful for inferring periods of activity.
Vietnam (See entry for Falconer et al. under Asia/General and International) 4. CARIBBEAN (Also see entries for Gesualdo under 1. General and International, for Billeter et al. under Latin America/ General and International, and for Karel under North America/General and International)
Arbasino, Alberto, and Daniela Palazzoli. I Viaggi Perduti (Milano: Bompiani), 1985. An expansively illustrated volume on early travel photogra phy. The section “Note Biografiche,” pages 181–190, gives information on fifty-six photographers who were important early figures in this genre, including several not discussed elsewhere.
Cuba (Also see entry for Yañez-Polo et al. under Spain/General and National) Haya Jiménez, María Eugenia. Breve Historia de la Fotografía Cubana (Havana: n.p.), 1980.
Arts Council of Great Britain. “From Today Painting is Dead”: The Beginnings of Photography ([London]: The Victoria & Albert Museum), 1972.
Not directly examined. Cited in Roosens and Salu 3, p. 79.
Keynote exhibition catalogue of 914 items. Capsule biogra phies are included for a number of photographers, mainly British and French, active up to 1880. Unrevised reprint 1975.
———. La Fotografía Cubana en el Siglo XIX (Havana: Dirección de Artes Plasticas y Diseño), 1982. Not directly examined. Cited in Roosens and Salu 2, p. 78.
Baden Pritchard, H. The Photographic Studios of Europe (London: Piper & Carter), 1882; reprinted (New York: Arno Press), 1973.
Libby, Gary R., Sandra L. Miller, and Judith Zollinger, editors. Salon and Picturesque Photography in Cuba, 1860–1920: The Ramiro Fernandez Collection (Daytona Beach, Florida: Museum of Arts and Science), 1988.
Described in its introduction as a source book of descriptive and operational information collected by the author over a two-year period spent visiting notable and successful studios in western and central Europe, from Britain to Hungary. The volume discusses approximately seventy-four individuals or studios and how they function