Phase Transitions and Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks
FUNDAMENTAL MATERIALS RESEARCH Series Editor: M. F. Thorpe, Michigan State University East Lansing, Michigan
ACCESS IN NANOPOROUS MATERIALS Edited by Thomas J. Pinnavaia and M. F. Thorpe DYNAMICS OF CRYSTAL SURFACES AND INTERFACES Edited by P. M. Duxbury and T. J. Pence ELECTRONIC PROPERTIES OF SOLIDS USING CLUSTER METHODS Edited by T. A. Kaplan and S. D. Mahanti LOCAL STRUCTURE FROM DIFFRACTION Edited by S. J. L. Billinge and M. F. Thorpe PHASE TRANSITIONS AND SELF-ORGANIZATION IN ELECTRONIC AND MOLECULAR NETWORKS Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe PHYSICS OF MANGANITES Edited by T. A. Kaplan and S. D. Mahanti RIGIDITY THEORY AND APPLICATIONS Edited by M. F. Thorpe and P. M. Duxbury SCIENCE AND APPLICATION OF NANOTUBES Edited by D. Tománek and R. J. Enbody
A Continuation Order Plan is available for this series. A continuation order will bring delivery of each new volume immediately upon publication. Volumes are billed only upon actual shipment. For further information please contact the publisher.
Phase Transitions and Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by
J. C. Phillips Lucent Technologies Bell Labs Innovations Murray Hill, New Jersey
and
M. F. Thorpe Michigan State University
East Lansing, Michigan
KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS NEW YORK, BOSTON, DORDRECHT, LONDON, MOSCOW
eBook ISBN: Print ISBN:
0-306-47113-2 0-306-46568-X
©2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers New York, Boston, Dordrecht, London, Moscow Print ©2001 Kluwer Academic / Plenum Publishers New York All rights reserved No part of this eBook may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording, or otherwise, without written consent from the Publisher Created in the United States of America Visit Kluwer Online at: and Kluwer's eBookstore at:
http://kluweronline.com http://ebooks.kluweronline.com
SERIES PREFACE
This series of books, which is published at the rate of about one per year, addresses fundamental problems in materials science. The contents cover a broad range of topics from small clusters of atoms to engineering materials and involve chemistry, physics, materials science, and engineering, with length scales ranging from Ångstroms up to millimeters. The emphasis is on basic science rather than on applications. Each book focuses on a single area of current interest and brings together leading experts to give an up-to-date discussion of their work and the work of others. Each article contains enough references that the interested reader can access the relevant literature. Thanks are given to the Center for Fundamental Materials Research at Michigan State University for supporting this series. M.F. Thorpe, Series Editor E-mail:
[email protected] East Lansing, Michigan, September 2000
v
This page intentionally left blank
PREFACE
The problem of phase transitions in disordered materials is quite old, but until recently it has seemed too complex a subject for formal study. The advent of computers has changed matters in two important ways. First, it has become possible to implement formal methods for microscopic study of phase transitions in ordered materials, even in the quantum limit, in great detail. This work has been so successful that few qualitative
mysteries remain, and many microscopic details have been measured experimentally and derived theoretically from first principles. The second radical change brought about by computers is that scientists have been forced to recognize that even today phase transitions in disordered materials are very poorly understood. Apart from the inherent statistical problems raised by disorder, it is becoming clear that new fundamental concepts are needed to explain qualitatively new phenomena that arise in disordered materials that were absent in ordered crystalline materials, or even in such materials with disordered sublattices. This workshop addresses the need for fundamentally new concepts in three areas of physical science. The first is network glasses, simple mechanical systems in which important new phenomena (the intermediate phases, the reversibility window) have been discovered as a result of exploring stiffness transitions both experimentally and in
numerical simulations made possible by new computer algorithms. The considerable progress made here is most encouraging, but surprisingly it has turned out that these new mechanical phenomena are closely paralleled by new electronic phenomena. These are discussed for the second area, the metal-insulator transition in semiconductor impurity bands, in which an intermediate phase has also been identified. The third area is (mostly cuprate) perovskites, where an intermediate phase occurs which can have superconductive transition temperatures well above 100K. It appears very likely
that the electronic intermediate phases exist because of disorder, and that the electronic phase diagrams closely parallel the mechanical phase diagrams of network glasses. On a microscopic level, minimization of the free energy of a disordered system at moderate temperatures, followed by some kind of (mild) quenching, can produce selforganization. There are many indications of this in network glasses, but of course life itself is self-organized. Proteins can be described as self-organized disordered networks, and they are discussed briefly here, and in a special issue of Journal of Molecular Graphics and Modelling (edited by L.A. Kuhn and M.F. Thorpe, to appear early 2001). It turns out that several constraint-based concepts that have been developed for network glasses apply equally well to the apparently unrelated subject of protein folding. This focused workshop was held at Hughes Hall, Cambridge, England, July 10-14, 2000. We are grateful to Dr. Martin Dove for assistance with local arrangements, and Ms. Janet King and Mr. Mykyta Chubynsky for extensive editorial assistance. J.C. Phillips M.F. Thorpe
East Lansing, Michigan, September 2000
vii
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
I. Some Mathematics Mathematical Principles of Intermediate Phases in Disordered Systems................................................................................................ 1 J.C. Phillips Reduced Density Matrices and Correlation Matrix.............................................................. 23 A. John Coleman The Sixteen-Percent Solution: Critical Volume Fraction for Percolation................................................................. 37 Richard Zallen The Intermediate Phase and Self-Organization in Network Glasses................................................................................................... 43 M.F. Thorpe and M.V. Chubynsky
II. Glasses and Supercooled Liquids Evidence for the Intermediate Phase in Chalcogenide Glasses........................................................................................... 65 P. Boolchand, W.J. Bresser, D.G. Georgiev, Y. Wang, and J. Wells Thermal Relaxation and Criticality of the Stiffness Transition....................................................................................................... 85 Y. Wang, T. Nakaoka, and K. Murase Solidity of Viscous Liquids................................................................................................ 101 J.C. Dyre Non-Ergodic Dynamics in Supercooled Liquids................................................................ 111 M. Dzugutov, S. Simdyankin, and F. Zetterling Network Stiffening and Chemical Ordering in Chalcogenide Glasses: Compositional Trends of Tg in Relation to Structural Information from Solid and Liquid State NMR ........................ 123 Carsten Rosenhahn, Sophia Hayes, Gunther Brunklaus, and Hellmut Eckert
ix
Glass Transition Temperature Variation as a Probe for Network Connectivity............................................................................................ 143 M. Micoulaut
Floppy Modes Effects in the Thermodynamical Properties of Chalcogenide Glasses....................................................................... 161 Gerardo G. Naumis The Dalton-Maxwell-Pauling Recipe for Window Glass .................................................. 171
Richard Kerner Local Bonding, Phase Stability and Interface Properties of Replacement Gate Dielectrics, Including Silicon Oxynitride Alloys
and Nitrides, and Film ‘Amphoteric’ Elemental Oxides and Silicates ...... 189 G. Lucovsky
Experimental Methods for Local Structure Determination on the Atomic Scale ....................................................................... 209 E.A. Stern
Zeolite Instability and Collapse.......................................................................................... 225 G.N. Greaves III. Metal-Insulator Transitions
Thermodynamics and Transport Properties of Interacting Systems with Localized Electrons.......................................................................... 247 A.L. Efros The Metal-Insulator Transition in Doped Semiconductors: Transport Properties and Critical Behavior............................................................ 263 Theodore G. Castner
Metal-Insulator Transition in Homogeneously Doped Germanium.................................................................. 291 Michio Watanabe IV. High Temperature Superconductors Experimental Evidence for Ferroelastic Nanodomains in
HTSC Cuprates and Related Oxides...................................................................... 311 J. Jung Role of Sr Dopants in the Inhomogeneous Ground State of La2-xSrxCuO4....................................................................................................... 323 D. Haskel, E.A. Stern, and F. Dogan
x
Universal Phase Diagrams and “Ideal” High Temperature Superconductors: ..............................................................................................................331 J.L. Wagner, T.M. Clemens, D.C. Mathew, O. Chmaissem B. Dabrowski, J.D. Jorgensen, and D.G. Hinks Coexistence of Superconductivity and Weak Ferromagnetism in Eu1.5Ce0.5RuSr2Cu2O10......................................................................................... 341 I. Felner
Quantum Percolation in High Tc Superconductors............................................................ 357 V. Dallacasa Superstripes: Self Organization of Quantum Wires in High Tc Superconductors.................................................................................... 375 A. Bianconi, D. DiCastro, N.L. Saini, and G. Bianconi Electron Strings in Oxides.................................................................................................. 389 F.V. Kusmartsev
High-Temperature Superconductivity is Charge-Reservoir Superconductivity.................................................................. 403 John D. Dow, Howard A. Blackstead, and Dale R. Harshman
Electronic Inhomogeneities in High-Tc Superconductors Observed by NMR.................................................................................................. 413
J. Haase, C.P. Slichter, R. Stern, C.T. Milling, and D.G. Hinks Tailoring the Properties of High-Tc and Related Oxides: From Fundamentals to Gap Nanoengineering........................................................ 431 Davor Pavuna
V. Self-Organization in Proteins
Designing Protein Structures.............................................................................................. 441 Hao Li, Chao Tang, and Ned S. Wingreen
List of Participants.............................................................................................................. 447 Index................................................................................................................................... 451
xi
This page intentionally left blank
MATHEMATICAL PRINCIPLES OF INTERMEDIATE PHASES IN DISORDERED SYSTEMS
J. C. PHILLIPS Bell Laboratories, Lucent Technologies (Retired) Murray Hill, N. J. 07974-0636 (
[email protected])
INTRODUCTION Intermediate phases are found in disordered systems that for a long time were supposed to exhibit simple connectivity transitions, similar to dilute magnetic transitions. The latter can be modeled by percolation on a lattice. The paradigmatic disordered offlattice systems that exhibit intermediate phases are network glasses, impurity bands in semiconductors [the metal-insulator transition (MIT)], and high-temperature doped (pseudo-)perovskite superconductors. The first two (relatively simple) examples show that self-organization of the flexibility inherent in disorder is what creates intermediate phases, and that these must be described by finite-size scaling methods. The third (very complex) example shows that high temperature superconductivity (HTSC) itself depends on glassy dopant disorder, and only indirectly on the crystalline matrix with its long-range order. The mathematical principles underlying the filamentary or percolative theory of such internally organized systems are fundamentally different from those of theories based on the effective medium approximation (EMA) or fully disorganized (randomly) diluted lattice connectivity transitions. These principles have been developed only in the last hundred years and are little known to most scientists. The counting methods used in the filamentary theory bear a striking resemblance to those used to prove Fermat’s Last Theorem or to factor efficiently large numbers using quantum computers. Examples of the intermediate phase for these three classes of materials are given that specifically identify the internal self-organized complexity that is responsible for the remarkable physical properties of each case. There is a growing realization that the physics of complex disordered systems differs qualitatively from that of simple crystalline systems with long-range order, especially in the vicinity of connectivity transitions. In this workshop both experimental and theoretical work illustrating this theme are discussed for a wide range of subjects, with special emphasis on three topics: network glasses, impurity band MITs, and HTSC. In each case we find that the single connectivity transition to which we are accustomed in simple
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
1
systems is replaced by two transitions of quite different character. The first resembles the continuous transition expected from percolation theory, but with much simpler exponents,
while the second is a first-order transition with catastrophic character. Between these two transitions we find an intermediate phase which always has novel properties that are indeed qualitatively different from those of simple dilute lattice systems. In some cases these novel properties are of enormous technological value (window glass), and the study of intermediate phases has for the first time enabled us to understand quantitatively why these properties occur. In other cases, such as HTSC, the intermediate phase has properties that are so novel and so unexpected that so far almost all theories have failed to develop beyond the macroscopic or phenomenological stage. Within the physical sciences the level of interest in cuprate HTSC has greatly surpassed that of any other subject, with the sole exception of semiconductive materials (such as Si) basic to modern electronics. Initially the interest was stimulated by amazingly large values of the superconductive transition temperatures Tc, typically five (ten) times larger than the highest values found in compound (elemental) metals [1]. As expected, there were other anomalies as well: high sensitivity to doping by non-magnetic oxygen, and very little sensitivity to the presence of magnetic rare earths [2], both anomalies reversing the situation found in metallic superconductors. In the normal-state to superconductive phase transitions of metals, the superconductive properties are generally rather insensitive to the normal-state behavior, but in the cuprates the normal-state transport at high temperatures itself is anomalous. The anomalous behavior becomes most
characteristic at just those compositions that maximize Tc, even in cases where This tells us that a new electronic theory is needed to describe such “strange metals” [3].
This new theory must be very different from the Fermi liquid or Landau-Ginzburg theories used to describe normal metals, which are based on the effective medium approximation (EMA). The EMA cannot be even qualitatively correct here [4], as the Fermi liquid phase is separated from the intermediate phase by a first-order phase transition. Unfortunately, although the need for an alternative to Fermi liquid or LandauGinzburg theory is widely recognized [2,3], only the author’s own filamentary or percolative theory [5] avoids the EMA. This theory relies essentially on set-theoretic methods derived from number theory to establish quantitative results, and these methods are largely unknown to physical scientists. These methods have long been regarded as rather esoteric, even by most mathematicians, but their true significance, as a way of unifying results from algebra, analysis, geometry and topology, has become apparent recently from the proof [6] of Fermat’s Last Theorem (FLT). Several popular discussions
of set theory and FLT are available, but the connections with network glasses, impurity bands, and perovskite superconductivity are so simple and so direct that this paper will provide them as a matter of convenience to busy readers. We will then show how these novel mathematical ideas match the results of several recent decisive experiments in great detail. DISCRETE INTEGER AND CONTINUOUS REAL NUMBER FIELDS: FLT Physical scientists without a strong background in modern mathematics will find an excellent introduction to the subject, which carries them from its beginnings right through to an outline of the steps that led to the proof of FLT, in [7], amusing, anecdotal and thoroughly entertaining. For a long time number theory was regarded as a collection of
strange and rather accidental results of no general significance, but in the late 1800’s Cantor invented set theory and established an essential difference between integers and real numbers. Although both sets are infinitely large, the number (or order or cardinality) of
2
real (irrational) numbers is larger than that of the integers and rational numbers, which have the same cardinality. He also hypothesized that there is no cardinality intermediate between those of the rationals and irrationals (continuum hypothesis); later Godel established a series of equivalent statements, including the axiom of choice, which showed that this axiom is independent of the rest of mathematics. These ideas are important in the present context because they highlight the idea that the methods of effective medium theories are fundamentally limited because they apply only to simple continuum systems
represented by real number fields. If the number field of interest is the integers or rationals, or a combination of these with the reals, then special methods need to be developed to prove theorems or derive results that do not exist for real number fields only.
The nature of these special methods is dramatically illustrated in the proof of FLT, which states that integer triples exist which satisfy the Pythagorean or Euclidean metric only for n = 2. Physical scientists, familiar with the example find Fermat’s conjecture quite plausible, especially as it has been confirmed by computer searches up to n = four million, but of course these searches do not constitute a proof. The proof involves two abstract mathematical tools, elliptic curves and modular functions.
An elliptic curve is not an ellipse: it is the set of solutions to a cubic polynomial in two variables, usually written in the form y2 = x3 + Ax2 + Bx + C. For number theory x and
y are integers. Modular functions are periodic and are a kind of integral generalization of sines and cosines. One can conjecture that all elliptic curves are modular. It then turns out that if this conjecture is valid, FLT follows. The proof of the latter began with a counter-example (Frey’s curve), which shows that should such an exist, it would generate an elliptic function with anomalous properties, in the sense that it would not be modular, as it is for integer triples with n = 2. To prove that this relation between elliptic and modular functions is necessary, Wiles counted the
number of both and showed that the two numbers were the same; thus the essential step was this counting [7].
Counting is a set-theoretic integral process. It is essential to our filamentary model of network glasses and the semiconductor impurity band transition [8-10] and to our
filamentary model of cuprate superconductivity [5]. In all cases the number of basis functions associated with cyclical vibrational states, or current-carrying states (or Cooperpaired current-carrying states in the superconductive case) is actually counted, as part of their separation from localized states in the neighborhood of the stiffness or metal-insulator transitions. Within the EMA and real number fields only, so far counting methods appear not to be feasible, and have not been used to discuss either the metal-insulator transition (MIT) or HTSC. All the EMA results that have been obtained are based on analytic (continuum) methods alone, which we believe are not well suited even to impurity band metal-insulator transitions and to the anomalous electronic properties of cuprates in the normal or superconductive states. It is obvious that in the network glass case continuum methods cannot identify floppy modes, which are obtained only by numerical solutions of matrix equations. BROKEN SYMMETRY, QUANTUM COMPUTERS, AND SHOR’S ALGORITHM The essential idea of our filamentary or percolative theory of random metals near the metal-insulator transition (MIT) is that in the limit such metals develop a new kind of broken symmetry even in the normal state. Electronic motion tangential ( ) to percolative filaments is phase-coherent, just as in normal metals, but normal to the filaments the motion is diffusive, as it is on the insulating side of the transition. This
3
fractal behavior is what makes it possible for the MIT to be continuous, even in the presence of long-range Coulomb interactions, which could render the MIT first order in the
EMA, for example the MIT or Wigner transition of electrons in a box.
The presence of limited filamentary phase coherence makes many kinds of novel effects possible. Consider, for example, hypothetical quantum computers, which have attracted great interest recently among computer scientists [11]. These process complex integers (amplitude and phase) rather than merely real integers. Such hypothetical computers consist of quantum cells (cubits) connected by quantum wires which transmit
amplitude and phase information and thus are exactly the same as the quantum filaments discussed above. With such hypothetical computers Shor showed [11] how to factor large numbers in polynomial rather than exponential times by making use of fast Fourier
transforms and matrix methods, which rely on taking advantage of interference effects which occur conveniently for complex numbers but not for real numbers. COUNTING IN NETWORK GLASSES: AN EXAMPLE Counting is essential to our understanding of the remarkable properties of network glasses. Unlike the electronic cases, where the analysis is greatly complicated by both long-range Coulomb interactions and phase effects associated with complex wave functions, the properties of network glasses can be modeled by simple point mass-andspring systems. On the one hand, these matrix models with short-range forces and no quantum effects have proved to be (relatively) easily solved, compared to the electronic models (apparently insoluble). On the other hand, all the effects predicted by the network glass models are gradually being observed experimentally, and especially the properties of the intermediate phase are astonishingly similar to those observed for electronic materials. Thus, while it would have been easy to be skeptical of these mathematical analogies alone, it is apparent that they capture most, if not all, of the essential properties of intermediate phases. Recent work on intermediate phases in network glasses is discussed here by Boolchand, Thorpe, and Kerner, and the details can be found in their papers. Apart from the pivotal importance of counting in understanding the properties of network glasses, there is a second, and equally important, analogy between the methods Wiles used to prove FLT and the constraint theory of network glasses. The proof relies on establishing the connection between two sets, modular functions and elliptic curves, that at first seem to be unrelated, except that their numbers are the same. In constraint theory one compares the number of spatial degrees of freedom of the system to the apparently unrelated number of Lagrangian constraints associated with bonding interactions with localized vibrational frequencies (intact constraints). These constraints may involve n-body forces with (such as bond-bending forces, n = 3). In conventional continuum treatments, the relevant number is the number of interparticle forces (off-diagonal elements of the dynamical matrix, each of which contributes a different “interaction line” in diagrammatic perturbation theory). Constraint theory has shown that the relevant number is the number of intact potential interactions in potential space, not the number of forces implied by real-space derivatives of these potentials. In other words, spatial coordinates and interaction potential coordinates are treated as separate and distinct sets. The mean-field condition for the glass stiffness transition is that the numbers of elements in the two (apparently unrelated) sets are equal. This point is illustrated in Fig. 1, where the number of vibrational modes with zero
frequencies (cyclical modes) is plotted [12] against average coordination number r in as glassy network with bond-stretching and bending forces. At r = 2.40 the number of constraints equals the number of degrees of freedom, and the extrapolated number of
4
Figure 1. The number of floppy modes as a function of r in bond-diluted models of three-dimensional glassy networks with stretching and bending forces [12]. The inset shows a blowup of the critical region. The second derivative of these curves shows a peak. This peak resembles the specific heat of a second-order phase transition, which shows that incomplete relaxation of the models generates the largest number of hidden linear
dependencies of constraints very near the connectivity transition.
cyclical modes is zero. (The smoothing of the kink at r = 2.40 is probably due to the fact that in the numerically simulated “random” network the topology is not ideally random.
This leads to redundancies among the constraints.) INTERMEDIATE PHASES: THERE ARE TWO STIFFNESS TRANSITIONS! For a long time we have all believed that in percolative problems there is only one connectivity transition. The first doubts began to appear in Boolchand’s measurements of
the critical coordination number, which was nearly always close to 2.40. However, even in cases where there was no evidence for nanoscale phase separation in the critical region, in other words, in cases where the theory should have worked, there were small discrepancies. Indeed, the numerical simulations shown in Fig. 1 predict small discrepancies, with a shift of the critical coordination number to 2.38 or 2.39. Experimentally, the shifts were in the other direction, to Those not familiar with constraint theory would probably say that such small discrepancies are insignificant - after all, in non-equilibrated glasses one should not expect better agreement between theory and experiment. But to us these discrepancies seemed significant. In particular, Boolchand’s ultraprecise Raman data also began to show evidence for a first-order transition, whereas all percolative models predict a continuous transition. The problems took definite form in 1998 workshop papers, where Boolchand et al. showed (see Fig. 2) that an apparent jump in the Raman frequency associated with corner-sharing tetrahedra in (Ge, Se) glassy alloys occurs at r = 2.46. This is the same critical value of r as occurs in the density and non-reversible part of the glass-transition enthalpy (discussed in more detail below). Yet still other Mossbauer experiments showed that some kind of transition, probably continuous, was happening at r = 2.40. I also found 5
Figure 2. Composition dependence in glasses (r = 2 + 2x) of corner-sharing Raman frequency, nonreversible enthalpy of glass transition, and molar volume.
6
some marginal evidence for two transitions in elasticity data, with the compressibility transition occurring at r = 2.40, and the Young’s modulus transition occurring at r = 2.46. Today we are quite certain that these two transitions mark the boundaries of a new kind of phase in disordered systems, that we call the intermediate phase. To see what causes the intermediate phase, suppose we prepare an underconstrained network by bond dilution. Next we add bonds to the network at random until we reach the first connectivity transition. At this point the backbone begins to percolate from one face of the sample to the opposite face. It percolates as a “pure” filament that neither branches nor intersects itself. As we continue to add more bonds, two things can happen: we may get new “pure” filaments, or one of the old filaments can branch or cross. At the branching or crossing points locally the network is overconstrained and this increases the strain energy anharmonically compared to growing new filaments. Therefore the enthalpy, and initially the free energy, can be reduced by adding bonds selectively to avoid branching and crossing (“smart bonds”), and creating new filaments. However, as we add more and more bonds, and more and more filaments, at a certain point adding one more bond will lead to crossing or branching, no matter where it is added. This is the upper density limit for the second transition. It is intuitively plausible, and it is confirmed by numerical simulations, that the first transition is continuous, and the second is first-order (M. F. Thorpe et al., this volume). [It should be remarked that it is not surprising that the intermediate phase was overlooked for so long. It occurs only because the glassy network is not confined to a lattice. Whenever percolation occurs on a randomly diluted lattice with short hops (shortrange forces), there is only one transition, and it is continuous. It is the off-lattice selective relaxation character of the glassy network that makes “smart bonds” and a first-order transition possible.] COUNTING IN QUANTUM PERCOLATION THEORY: ANOTHER EXAMPLE In a d-dimensional sample with Nd randomly distributed impurities the formation of phase-coherent ballistic states is blocked (in the sense of Lagrange) by constraints [13,14]; note that from a counting viewpoint the microscopic nature of these constraints, orbital or spin, external or electron-electron interactions, is irrelevant; all that matters is their number. The central result of the filamentary theory of the MIT is the existence theorem, which states that these filaments can exist providing that the following condition on the log of this number is satisfied (Eqn. (7) of [8]):
This is a very amusing equation because of the way that it combines real and complex numbers. On the left hand side we have the exponent that represents the number of transverse degrees of freedom of our complex, current carrying basis states. Had these states been real standing waves, the factor 2 would have been absent. The first term on the right hand side is the number of real constraints generated by randomness. The second term is the (transverse) areal density of current-carrying filaments, an observable which of course is also real. Thus the left hand side measures complex quantum dimensionalities, while the right hand side measures real observable dimensionalities. In a simple but very fundamental way this equation describes all the implications of the quantum theory of measurement for the transport properties of random metals [14]. Quantum percolation theory explains all the experimentally observed critical exponents and prefactor sign reversals which are observed [15,16] in uncompensated random metals near the MIT such as Si:P and Ge:Ga. It applies to the scaling phase, which exhibits power-law behavior over
7
a range 100 times larger than that found for magnetic critical phenomena. Very close to the continuous MIT, even the purest materials exhibit the effects of compensation, and the residual resistivity associated with scattering from compensating impurities dominates the transport properties, which revert to the conventional behavior predicted by the EMA.
COMPARISON WITH SCALING THEORY The dependence of (1) on dimensionality is strongly suggestive of scaling theories that have been developed to describe critical behavior of magnetic phase transitions [17]. It seems, however, that the results given in [8,9] differ fundamentally from those in the magnetic literature in two important respects. The latter rely on Bose, not Fermi, statistics, and hence contain no destructive interference effects. The interparticle forces of the latter are of short range, while electron-electron interactions are long range. Whether these two differences are necessary or sufficient to explain the large qualitative differences between the properties of random magnets and random metals has been unclear for a long time. It was even suggested [18] that the experimental data [15] may have been in error, a
suggestion which has recently been laid to rest [16]. Detailed comparison of filamentary quantum percolation theory with magnetic lattice percolation theory [17,18] has shown [10] that both Fermionic destructive interference and
long-range forces are necessary and sufficient to produce a consistent and successful theory of impurity band random metals such as Si:P and Ge:Ga. The destructive interference suppresses the divergence of the specific heat which is otherwise a characteristic of quasione dimensional ( d* = 1 ) Fermionic systems embedded in a d-dimensional matrix. This destructive interference is represented mathematically by a non-crossing condition for
semiclasical percolative paths similar to one that is already known for the integral quantum Hall effect at large n. (The elliptic curves which play an essential part in the proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem also satisfy a non-crossing condition [19], which suggests that
“arithmetic algebraic geometry” [briefly, “modern arithmetic”] may have a lot to offer in treating problems involving many Fermions.) In the limit Fermion statistics combined with long-range interactions cause d to be replaced by d + d* = d + 1. One can identify d* with the fluctuations of the component of the internal electric field that is locally tangential to the filament. Or one can introduce local times for Fermi-energy electrons moving along the filament. Then Newton is replaced by Einstein, and because of internal fields the filamentary paths fluctuate dynamically not only in space, but also in their local time It is amusing that the concepts of special relativity, originally developed to explain non-linear aspects of the Doppler effect, should reappear in the context of critical fluctuations in random metals. If the intermediate phase has a distinct topological character that is associated with off-lattice disorder, then one can immediately infer that it can occur in any disordered system that either has long-range forces, or can self-anneal. So I reasoned, and this led me to re-examine all the experimental data on strongly disordered systems near a connectivity
transition. Two such systems immediately spring to mind: the simpler system is the metalinsulator transition in semiconductor impurity bands, such as Si:P; following Shockley’s rule, we discuss it first.
There are two kinds of data on the metal-insulator transition in Si:P, both taken some 20 years ago. At that time everyone assumed that there was only one transition. This transition was supposed to occur continuously in both the conductivity and the coefficient of the linear term in the specific heat at the same value of uncompensated dopant density n and with related exponents, as both observables were supposed to be continuous functions of n.
8
The trouble with this assumption was that when it was applied to the experimental data, the two sets of data, transport and thermal, did not lie on smooth, power-law curves (see Fig. 3 ). However, as everyone at that time was certain that there was only one transition, this problem passed unnoticed. Naturally, when I re-examined the by-now-allbut-forgotten thermal data some twenty years later [14], I immediately saw that the critical density for the thermal transition was actually much larger than that for the transport transition (by almost a factor of 2). All the effects of the intermediate phase that we have been discussing are connected with filamentary coherence and finite-size scaling. When a few minority dopants are present in the sample, two things happen, both based on interruption of coherence. Very close to the low-density continuous MIT, the conventional incoherent MIT occurs, which is smoother and has larger density exponents than the coherent transition. This conventional transition is of little interest here, except that it shows how different the intermediate phase is from a Fermi liquid. The second point of interest is that the presence of the minority dopants creates a natural length scale, associated with the average minority-minority spacing, that is larger than the majority-majority spacing. Physically this larger length scale is that associated with the residual resistance [8], a quantity that does not arise in many “modern” scaling theories of metallic behavior. The residual resistance is, of course, a very important quantity, as it eliminates divergences in the conductivity as It also provides a natural platform for filamentary counting. One constructs Voronoi polyhedra around each minority impurity, and counts the number of filaments crossing such polyhedra in various limits. Thus here counting shows up as a very basic operation. The omission of this construction has led some authors to the conclusion that the residual resistance of metals is not associated with impurities at all, but depends on “interactions of the electromagnetic field with the environment”, which is nonsense [8]. Counting has important implications for scaling in general. In continuum scaling
theory critical densities are irrelevant constants, and only the critical exponents are universal for a given class of interactions, independent of coupling strength, at least over limited ranges. Moreover, these critical exponents are in general irrational numbers. In
Figure 3. The electronic specific heat coefficient
for Si:P, showing both the continuous transport
transition at nc and the first-order thermal transition at ncb. The dashed line shows the value expected for a Fermi liquid.
The transition from the Fermi liquid to the filamentary metal occurs at n = n cb , and this
transition is first-order [14].
9
network glasses, for simple alloys, there are only a few classes of intact constraints, and the condition that their average number/atom be integral automatically leads to average coordination numbers that are simple small fractions (such as 12/5). The existence of such “magic” fractions is a direct consequence of treating the bonding interactions as a set separate from the set of spatial coordinates – in other words, the bonding interactions form a “space” different from real space. By connecting these two separate spaces we can identify one, and possibly even both, of the connectivity transition compositions. The process of connecting two apparently different spaces to prove a certain arithmetic result is much the same as in the proof of FLT. It has often been conjectured that the results obtained from continuum lattice scaling theories are “universal”. Specifically for given classes of interactions, for example, the critical densities for different diluted lattices – cubic, hexagonal, etc., will differ, but the critical exponents will be the same. This is no doubt correct, but it does not include the effects associated with intermediate phases in disordered solids, which are a new phenomenon that lies entirely outside the framework of continuum lattice scaling theory. The new phase transitions and the intermediate phase cannot even be described properly in terms of diluted lattices with their single connectivity transitions. A more flexible and more abstract description is required, that uses the methods and concepts of modem mathematics. In particular, one must be satisfied to describe the properties of sets, as the presence of disorder makes it impossible to describe fully the properties of the individual elements of the sets.
BASIS FUNCTIONS IN FILAMENTARY METALS
Suppose we have an impurity band in the intermediate phase. In this phase the metallic states are centered on arrays of filamentary, non-crossing paths that extend from electrode to electrode. These paths are similar in some respects to the Self-Avoiding random Walks (SAW’s) that are used in statistical mechanics to describe the mathematical properties of diluted magnetic lattices. There are also important differences. In the magnetic case the SAW’s are closed loops with pseudovector symmetry, whereas the electrical paths have
vector symmetry. In the magnetic case we are concerned with minimizing the free energy associated with magnetic susceptibility, essentially an equilibrium property. In the electrical case, the metallic conductivity contributes to dielectric screening of internal electric fields, thus it also can be varied to minimize the free energy. Because of quantum mechanics, the kinetic energy associated with transverse localization of charge carriers on filaments increases as the filaments become more closely packed, eventually delocalizing the electrons and leading to the transition to the Fermi liquid state at higher densities. This does not occur in the spin case, as spins are already localized objects with no intrinsic kinetic energy. The generalization of Fermi liquid wave functions, indexed by the continuous momentum p and represented by the EMA wave functions to the discrete case of filamentary arrays, is not difficult. One assumes that the real-space centers of density of each filament j are known, and denotes the corresponding path by Longitudinal wave vectors are oriented parallel to the local tangent to the path. There are no transverse wave vectors, only a local transverse localization length. In the normal state in the absence of a magnetic field these wave vectors can be used to construct basis functions for each filament. The actual wave functions near the Fermi energy will be time-dependent linear combinations of individual filamentary wave functions that minimize the free energy by screening internal electric fields.
10
BROKEN SYMMETRY IN THE SUPERCONDUCTIVE AND NORMAL STATES
The key feature of the BCS theory of metallic superconductivity is the formation of Cooper pairs, which become the Landau-Ginzburg order parameter with 1 = and As the volume of the system tends to the number of possible
choices for 2 (even when these are restricted by the isoenergetic constraint ) also tends to but from this infinitely large set only one state, the time-reversed one, is used to form the Cooper pair. In other words, the cardinality of the set of states consisting of the time-reversed state is lower than that of the set consisting of all the isoenergetic states. This is a characteristic feature of continuum or effective medium models in which scattering by some kind of disorder is added after the basis states have been chosen. In strongly disordered systems, such as random metals near the MIT, the situation is quite different. In order to explain the critical properties of such systems one must select the correct filamentary basis states at the outset. This is done variationally, and it affects both normal-state and superconductive properties in many ways that are radically different from normal metals, where all the isoenergetic states are essentially equivalent, as in Landau Fermi liquid theory. The special properties of filamentary metals are the result of atomic relaxation that leads to preselection of basis states even in the normal state, where there are only two states per filament, and with In other words,
Figure 4. There are two components in the filamentary model, the CuO2 planes (A), and the impurity bridges combined with secondary metallic planes (B). This Figure shows the density of electronic states near the Fermi energy, for with the energy scale set by the resonant bridging impurity width WR. There is a strong peak in due to the impurity resonance pinned by electron-ion polarization energies and the anti-Jahn-Teller effect, and a strong dip in NA (E) due to electron-electron Coulomb interactions. The product has peaks near At the optimal composition there are only extended states for The scattering rates are also shown for the optimal
composition. They are much larger for the localized states,
than for the extended states,
11
for the one-dimensional filaments the Fermi surface collapses to two points, and this has happened in the normal state because of quantum percolation. Another extremely unexpected feature of filamentary states is that they maximize (minimize) the conductivity (resistivity). This variational property means that the dynamically optimized filamentary states already include all many-electron interaction effects, including those of electron-electron scattering which give rise to T2 resistivities in Landau Fermi liquid theory. That such many-electron interactions are absent in impurity band random metals has been shown by a filamentary analysis [8,9] of critical exponents in Si:P [15] and neutron-transmutation-doped, isotopically pure Ge:Ga [16]. The dominant remaining source of scattering in the cuprates is thermal excitation into localized states with energies outside the WR resonance region [5] shown in Fig. 4. (This disappearance of the Coulomb interaction between discrete and dynamically optimized filamentary currentcarrying states is analogous to the existence of zero-frequency floppy modes in the intermediate phase of network glasses.)
FILAMENTARY MODEL FOR HTSC
Even without measurements of the properties of the cuprates it was clear to crystal chemists and materials scientists that these multinary compounds would be extremely unusual from a structural point of view [1]. In addition to containing rare earths and
oxygen, these pseudoperovskites nearly always contain Cu, an element that in one oxidation state shows a greater diversity in its stereochemical behavior than any other element. This observation, together with the extremely anomalous transport properties, certainly bodes ill for any microscopic theory of the cuprates which is based on the EMA, as that approximation ignores the flexible material properties of Cu, and the ferroelastic properties of the perovskite family, altogether. (All materials with unusual properties, from Si to conjugated hydrocarbons to DNA, conform to the central principle of organic chemistry, “structure is function”.) Undeterred by these inescapable ground rules, almost all the theories developed so far, such as [2] and [3], are based on the EMA, augmented
only by good intentions and wishful thinking; given the richness and complexity of materials science, this is unlikely to suffice. The filamentary theory of HTSC diverges from EMA theories in two basic ways: it incorporates an extensive knowledge of the experimental data [1], and it has a sound mathematical foundation in the filamentary theory of the MIT in semiconductor impurity bands [14], which supersedes inadequate EMA theories of the Fermi liquid or LandauGinzburg type [2,3]. Because of interlayer ferroelastic interactions the “metallic” CuO2 planes are partitioned into metallic nanodomains separated by semiconductive domain walls. A specific filamentary path was envisaged [20] that connects metallic CuO 2 planes with secondary metallic planes (CuO chains or BiO planes) via resonant impurity states located in semiconductive planes (such as BaO) sandwiched between the metallic planes, as shown in Fig. 5. In addition to the bridging impurity points most samples contain two kinds of extensive defects which act as blocking lines or layers. Blocking macroscopic ab planar layers explain the usually semiconductive c-axis resistance; this aspect of the data has received too much attention [3], as these blocking layers are essentially extrinsic and can be avoided in some cases, by relieving interlayer strain energies [21], or by overdoping [22]. The interesting extensive defects are intraplanar semiconductive nanodomain lines in the metallic planes; these form grids, and each cell of a grid is connected to a square in an adjacent metallic plane by resonant (metallic) tunneling through a bridging impurity. The experimental evidence for the existence of such buckled cellular grids is discussed here by Jung. It is difficult to obtain evidence for spatial inhomogeneities on this scale, but the evidence available has been growing steadily if slowly. 12
Figure 5. The variationally optimized percolative filaments, shown in cross section, follow planar locally metallic CuO2 layers until they approach a domain wall which is locally insulating. The zigzag metallic path is continued by resonant tunneling through a state pinned at the Fermi energy associated with a defect, such as an oxygen vacancy. The next segment of the path is that of a chain, and this segment terminates at a chain O vacancy, where the zigzag path is continued by resonant tunneling back to a CuO2 layer, and so on. This model is designed for YBCO; in LSCO the tunnel paths simply connect CuO2 layers. Such filamentary paths should never be confused with “stripe phases” or pinned charge density waves, which are incidental
minority insulating phases.
There is also dramatic evidence for the existence of nanoscale spatial inhomogeneities in Debye-Waller factors measured by ion channeling, which are very sensitive to a few large out-of-plane atomic displacements and show striking precursive anomalies at Tc; these are absent from neutron diffraction data which measure EMA properties [23,4]. It is the electronic structure associated with Fermi-level pinning defects which experimentalists tune when they adjust oxygen concentrations, refine by annealing or observe as aging or quenching effects. To understand transport properties one must understand the topological
connectivity of these states, which is scarcely possible within the EMA. Within a single-particle picture the Fermi-level pinning metallic states can be represented as a narrow band of resonant states of width few meV the valence band width as shown in Fig. 4. Ordinarily one might expect that such states would be unstable against a Jahn-Teller distortion, and indeed it has been stated [3] without proof or citation that this is always the case. In fact, it is easy to find exceptions where such peaks are located self-consistently (with respect to both electronic and atomic coordinates) at EF, for example, in many total energy calculations. Moreover, Fermi-level pinning by impurity, surface or interfacial states at metal-insulator junctions (Schottky barriers) is one of the basic principles of semiconductor device physics. The error [3] arose from simplistic inclusion of only one-electron interactions and neglect of both core-core
and non-local electron-electron interactions. An amusingly similar error (sometimes called the Wentzel mistake), also on the subject of instabilities and superconductivity, led Wentzel to suggest [24] that the Bardeen-Frohlich attractive electron-phonon interaction was not the correct mechanism for simple metallic superconductivity. What is needed for the cuprates is a general mechanism for frustrating the Jahn-Teller effect. This is provided by a self-screening atomic relaxation mechanism which involves 13
long-range Coulomb interactions not representable as local single-particle energies [25]. The attractive self-screening energy of the already narrow band of resonant states is maximized by further narrowing the band and centering it on EF. This “anti-Jahn-Teller
effect” has the congenial feature that it is expected to be especially effective in strongly ionic materials where the long-range Coulomb forces are only weakly screened by a few metallic electrons. This is exactly the situation in the cuprates, which are close to a metalinsulator transition; it is also the case for impurity band random metals [8-10], where this
weak screening is responsible for the anomalously small exponent [15,16] which lies below the limit expected from scaling theory [18] with Boson statistics and shortrange forces only, and far below the value of 3/2 predicted by some one-electron EMA theories. The narrow resonance region of width WR was previously portrayed [5] as a peak in the density of electronic states centered on EF, but this need not be the case. All that is necessary is that in this region the scattering rate be extremely low compared to that at higher energies outside this region. Thus the picture we have now is that shown in Fig.4. The density of extended states is depressed relative to that of the localized states by Coulomb interactions, as happens for the random metal on the insulating side of the MIT [16,26]. This density of states would go to zero at E = EF and T = 0 were it not for the antiJahn-Teller effect, which leaves a residue of carriers at T = Tc which is about half that for T = T0 [27]. The pinning of the most polarizable filamentary states to EF by Coulomb interactions is similar to the energy-level reordering responsible for the pseudogap in
random metals [26]. NORMAL-STATE TRANSPORT
In a normal metal electron-phonon interactions typically contribute a temperaturedependent term to the resistivity proportional to with For large crystalline disorder, as in metallic glasses and thin films quenched at low temperatures, electronelectron scattering is strong and In certain cuprates, notably those without secondary metallic planes involving metallic elements other than Cu (Bi or Hg), the ab planar normalstate resisitivity is linear in T approximately from T0 to Th, where T0 is close to Tc and Th is the high-temperature limit of compositional stability [5]. This is a very remarkable result, as in cases where Tc is low, the ratio Th/T0 has been observed to be as large as 100. However, it holds only for those samples whose composition corresponds to a maximum in Tc; increasing doping causes to cross over to the Fermi liquid (strong electron-electron scattering) value of 2. This means that a satisfactory theory should contain some continuously tunable factor which will alter both anomalies at the same time, and this factor should be responsible for the MIT as well. As the reader will realize, these demands are very severe. He will probably not be surprised to learn that they are met by the author’s filamentary theory [5], but not by any theory based on the EMA, such as [2] or [3]. The limitations of EMA models becomes obvious when one examines the field theories developed by various authors [28] to implement Anderson’s suggestion that electric (holon) and magnetic (spinon) effects are somehow separated in the cuprates [3]. It is clear that such a separation is essential if the magnetic moments of the rare earths are not to quench superconductivity, but Anderson gives no microscopic explanation of how this can happen; it is merely one of his axioms, or, as he prefers, dogmas. Given this dogma, one is able to explain microscopically why normal-state transport anomalies exist and are loosely correlated with the optimization of Tc. However, one is unable to derive any functional form for the temperature dependence of the resistivity, much less to explain why 14
without assuming what was to be derived. Even the temperature scale ratio Th/T0 is merely the ratio of an inelastic high-temperature scattering rate to Tc, which is yet another assumption, which turns out to be incorrect, as we shall see. The separation (“spin bags” [2]) of magnetic and electrical effects, moreover, need not be axiomatic. It is derivable in the filamentary model simply by observing that the magnetic states are all localized, and that the separation of the extended current-carrying states from the localized states [14,5] automatically separates spin and Cooper-pair-forming states. Note, however, that this separation cannot be carried out correctly within the EMA because in that picture one is unable to count [6,7,19] the states that are being separated. The importance of counting is illustrated convincingly by the much simpler case of random impurity band metals, where the EMA has failed in calculating critical exponents [8,9], By contrast, the dogmatic holon-spinon separation [3] becomes, in the filamentary model, what one would naturally expect in optimized HTSC because of the success of the filamentary model for the closely related impurity band MIT. It is nothing more than intralayer nanoscale phase separation, driven by interlayer ferroelastic misfit forces.
Because the CuO2 planes are divided into an irregular checkerboard or grid of nanodomains by intraplanar domain lines which have semiconductive gaps currents can flow only along filamentary paths passing through interplanar resonant tunneling centers (impurity bridges). In YBCO, for example, such centers might be represented by the much-studied apical oxygen sites between Cu atoms in the CuO2 planes and the chains, selectively associated with vacancies on the later. For optimal doping there are two such centers per CuO2 planar domain, one source and one drain. When there are fewer than two, the sample is underdoped, and when there are more than two, it is overdoped (see Fig. 2 of [5]). Thus the average integral (bridge/domain) ratio is the continuously tunable factor mentioned above; there it was shown that when this factor is two all the normal-state anomalies are explained, as is the optimization of Tc. It was also
explained why overdoping depresses Tc and increases
from 1 to 2, at the same time producing the observed anomaly in the Hall resistance [29]. An important historical point is that the fact that all the normal-state transport anomalies can be explained by the existence of a narrow, high-mobility band pinned to EF was first explained in [29]. At that time the explanation was not generally accepted because it was not accompanied by a specific structural model that explained the origin of
the narrow band. Such a model is shown in Fig. 5, and it is the only such model that has been advanced. The narrow high-mobility band itself is the only way of explaining the normal-state transport anomalies, so that together with Fig. 5 it may be taken as the only satisfactory, perovskite-specific model for HTSC. What happens to underdoped samples? In the YBCO case, underdoping produces
more O vacancies on the chains that generate the crystalline orthorhombic symmetry. These chains are almost surely responsible for the phase shifts at twin boundaries where the chain orientations rotate by which experimentalists and many EMA theorists often like to describe as “d-wave superconductivity”. This is an EMA (or Fermi liquid) misnomer that is entirely inappropriate for the non-Fermi liquid intermediate phase. It implies a fundamental significance of what amounts to a non-bulk edge or surface
effect, which is seen to be trivial as soon as one realizes that the b-axis chains are essentially involved in constructing filamentary paths, so that the observed phase shift is unavoidable. The chain segments become shorter as x increases, and although probably only short chain segments are needed to bypass intraplanar CuO2 domain walls, it is clear that the ab planar resistance will increase as the chain segments shorten. Aside. Many experiments have shown that residual states exist within the pseudogap; these residual states are also often described as the result of “d-wave superconductivity”. In fact, the observed residual states are very similar to those predicted by [26]. Thus if
15
there are dopants in semiconductive domain walls that generate a pseudogap, then this would easily account for the experimental observations, without nonsensically using Fermi liquid terminology to describe the non-Fermi liquid intermediate phase. In fact, we expect increasing phonon-assisted currents across oxygen vacancies within the chains. The importance of these will increase with x and (the orthorhombic plateau in Tc(x)), it is possible that virtual phonon exchange at these vacancies will provide a stronger attractive interaction for forming Cooper pairs than phonon exchange at the caxis impurity bridge resonances does. The width and strength of the density-of-states peak of the latter may not depend on the oxygen mass, as they may well be associated with collective relaxation and optimization of many internal coordinates. This would explain the disappearance of the oxygen isotope effect for small x [30]. On the other hand, the electron-phonon interactions at chain vacancies promote phonon-enhanced coherent currents across these micro-weak links, enhancing the local energy gap. When this effect is linearized with respect to vibrational amplitudes, it may still be equivalent to a local Bardeen-Frohlich interaction and may thus give rise to what resembles a normal isotope effect for large After the above was written, a very important paper [31] appeared concerning the relaxation of Tc in YBCO after abrupt release of pressure. The relaxation was found to follow the form of a “stretched exponential”, with The key parameter of interest is the dimensionless stretching fraction which turns out to be highly informative. The stretched exponential can be derived from a microscopic model. The model involves diffusion of excitations in a configuration space of dimension d*p to
randomly distributed traps.
As time passes, all the excitations near the traps have disappeared, and only excitations distant from the traps remain. The latter must diffuse further and further. This leads to the stretched exponential and to
At first, it might appear that all that has been done is to replace one empirical parameter, with another, d*p. In fact,
for homogeneous glasses. (The dopants in a well-annealed and homogeneous HTSC presumably form a glassy array.) Here d = 3 is the dimensionality of Euclidean space. The key factor now is p. Comparison with experiment and several very accurate MDS showed that for homogeneous glasses p is nearly always 1 or 2; it measures the number pd of interaction channels involved in diffusion of excitations in d dimensions. In metals where phonon scattering dominates the resistivity, one of these channels is always e-p interactions. However, if other classes of interactions are present, there may be other diffusive interaction channels as well. It is easy to see that adding channels increases the stretching factor, which is Mathematically the simplest and most rigorous example with p = 2 is provided by quasicrystals, where the Euclidean coordinates r become and the Penrose projective coordinates are Motion in space (the first d channels) involves phonons and
produces relaxation, while motion in space (the second channels) involves phasons, which only rearrange particles without diffusion or relaxation. In the ideally random quasicrystal a given hop may tale place along either or Thus
16
where f p measures the effectiveness of hopping in pd channels, only d of which is associated with relaxation. For an axial quasicrystal, which is quasi-periodic only in the plane normal to the axis, the calculation is somewhat more complex. There are five channels, three in space, and two in space, so that fp = 3/5, and d*p = 9/5. Thus in excellent agreement with MDS15 which give From the value one can rigorously infer that p = 1, and thus only electronphonon interactions can cause HTSC. The proof is based on grouping the interactions involved in diffusive relaxation into classes of interactions that are effective (such as electron-phonon interactions) and ineffective (such as electron-magnon interactions) [32]. Because only the electron-phonon interaction is needed to explain all other interactions (such as electron-[magnon, plasmon, any-old-whaton] interactions) are excluded by experiment [31,33]. The remarkable aspect of this experiment and theory is that the conclusion transcends all the details of structure and large-scale relaxation around
dopants in these complex materials. Note that once again, the success of this approach rests on identifying two different sets, interaction space and real space, and then connecting them, just as in constraint theory and the proof of FLT.
CHAIN LENGTHS AND LOW TEMPERATURE CUFOFF T0 In the filamentary theory there is a close relation between average chain lengths L and the lower cutoff (or pseudogap) temperature T0 in for optimally and
underdoped samples:
(see (1,2) of [5]); here This relationship gave good results for the YBCO T0(x)], which are linear in x with T0 (0.1) 150K for Tc optimized 90K. It should be mentioned here that many samples appear to give T0 less than Tc, but these are probably inhomogeneously overdoped. For optimally doped (x = 0.1) samples the value T0 (0.1) 150K has been confirmed for single crystals and for thin films grown by several methods, and even fine-tuned with low-energy electron irradiation [27]. In a large magnetic field Tc is suppressed, “unmasking” or exposing the normal-state
resistivity at temperatures lower than Tc(H) for H = 0 in relatively “low Tc” cuprates ( T c
40K), such as [35], The central “unmasked” single-crystal results stressed by [34] are that for underdoped compositions pab(T) increases and becomes semiconductive below T0. Even more significant, however, is the disappearance of the pseudogap (the dip in normal-state resistivity between Tc and T0) in large magnetic fields. This disappearance is not discussed at all, as it is virtually inexplicable within the EMA. In terms of our topological model of the intermediate state, the explanation is immediate. The large magnetic field replaces the self-organized, non-crossing coherent filamentary basis states with vector symmetry by quasi-circular orbital states with pseudovector symmetry, thereby restoring Fermi liquid character, including strong electron-electron scattering, to states near EF.
Because chains represent the ideal local structure for filamentary currents, microscopic probes of the local chain structure in untwinned samples of YBCO are of great interest. Recently two experiments have done this, with results that cannot be explained by EMA models based on bulk energy bands and bulk phonons. The first experiment [36] revealed systematic changes in scattering strength with doping of longitudinal optic (LO) phonons
17
propagating in the basal plane normal to the chain direction. These phonon spectra contain a pseudogap which can be explained [33] as the result of short-range ordering of chain segments that alternate in oxygen filling factors. The changes in scattering strength are more interesting, as they turn out to be direct measures of phonon coherence along filamentary paths, and they change abruptly in as the composition passes
through the metal-insulator transition near x = 0.4. There is also a second abrupt change in scattering strengths centered on x = ¾ [the transition between the Tc = 60K and 90K plateaus] as the smaller filling factor passes through ½; this change is just what one would expect from percolation theory, and from it one can successfully predict the change in the Tc ratios of the two plateaus. In the second experiment [22], the longitudinal magnetoresistance in slightly overdoped untwinned YBCO was studied; in these samples the c-axis resistivity is linear in T, just as the ab planar resistivity is, which means that the coherent percolative paths are 3dimensional. Again the results show strong anisotropy that is connected with coherent current flow along the chains.
NMR RELAXATION AND THE SPIN PSEUDOGAP
Anderson has discussed (see [3], Fig. 3.27) the observation of anomalous nonKorringa planar Cu relaxation in various cuprates, and states that “this anomalous relaxation seems to be one of the common features of the high-Tc. state”, but “it is actually relatively more pronounced for somewhat lower Tc materials., so is not closely related to superconductivty.” This author concurs, and would add that in his opinion in most cases (LSCO is an exception) all that spin-scattering experiments are measuring is spin relaxation in pockets of insulating material with compositions which can be quite different from those of the superconductive bulk. For example, this effect is quite small in optimal with but is much larger in optimal Note that the oxygen diffusivity is very high in YBCO, but not the Sr diffusivity in LSCO, so that while it is possible to make very nearly homogeneous samples of the former, this is not possible for the latter. Thus in general there is no connection between T0 and the spin pseudogap Tsg, nor should we expect to find one, except for materials like LSCO, where magnetic microphase inclusions may be absent. In that case both T0 and the spin pseudogap Tsg can be related to the resonance width WR. COMPOSITION DEPENDENCE OF THE ENTROPY OF THE VORTEX PHASE TRANSITION
The physics of magnetic vortices in the mixed state is extremely complex, and it is nearly always treated from the point of view of the EMA, although it is clear that if the sample is spatially inhomogeneous the vortices will nearly always localize preferentially in regions of lower Tc. In the author’s view this is the most natural explanation of the “step kink - peak” phenomena in vortex lattice melting which have attracted much attention from experimentalists [37]. However, two-phase models have many adjustable parameters and it would appear that this greatly limits what can be gained from the analysis of such phenomena. Thus most of the discussion of these phenomena by experimentalists has focused on the fact that the entropy of vortex lattice melting is much larger than would be expected if the vortices are treated merely as point objects [38]. This can be easily explained by taking account of changes in the nonlocal structure [39] of the vortices near Tc. There is, however, 18
one very puzzling feature of these data which is explained quite easily by the present theory. This theory is a counting theory, and thus it is well-suited to studying the entropy of the vortex phase transition. In Bi2Sr2CaCu2Oy single crystals it is observed [37] that this entropy is several times larger for overdoped than for optimally doped samples, especially
at low T. Ordinarily in the EMA one would expect that Tc would reach its maximum value at the composition where N(EF), the density of electronic states in the normal state, has its maximum value, that is, at optimal doping EF coincides with a peak in N(E). In such a case
the entropy should reach its maximum at the same optimally doped composition. However, in the present model N(EF) is larger in the overdoped state than in the optimally doped state, so giving a larger entropy of melting. The transition temperature decreases in the overdoped state because the electrons at the Fermi energy spend more time in Fermi-liquidlike states in the CuO2 planes, where the electron-phonon coupling is weak, and less time at the discrete resonant tunneling centers, where it is very strong. See Eqn. [3] and Fig. 2(c) of [5].
INTERMEDIATE PHASES AND FIRST-ORDER PHASE TRANSITIONS
The mathematical character of intermediate phases is characterized by some discrete features (the filaments) and some continuous features (the off-lattice space in which both the network glasses and the spatially disordered impurities of the electronic examples are embedded). One felicitous consequence of mixing discrete and continuous features is that the lower-density (or first) transition from the disconnected (or insulating) phase to the intermediate phase is continuous, while the higher-density (second) transition from the filamentary phase to the effective medium (overconstrained, or Fermi liquid) phase is first order. This asymmetry is quite striking, and it cannot be explained by an entirely discrete
lattice model, or by an entirely continuous effective medium model. Both of the latter contain only one transition, and it was the similarity in this respect that has led many people to suppose (mistakenly) that there is a “universal” character of phase transitions that can be independent of the discrete/continuous dichotomy. In this workshop both Boolchand and Thorpe discuss these two phase transitions in convincing detail. In Figs. 3 and 6 the two transitions are sketched for impurity bands in Si:P. The two critical densities are separated by a factor of 2, and there is no doubt that the first one is continuous, and the second is not. The layered cuprates that form HTSC are complex multinary compounds, and
preparing samples that are microscopically homogeneous is not easy. Of course, unless such homogeneity is achieved, the second transition will be greatly broadened, and it will be difficult to show that the second transition is first-order. So far, three successful studies have reported first-order phase transitions: (1) near x = 0.21 in (after annealing for several months [41] at high T and constant O partial pressure), (2) near = 0.19 in
(also after annealing at constant composition [42]), and near x =
0.95 in (carefully designed chemical and thermal history, including slow cooling [43]). Normally ones observes only parabolic Tc(x)’s. Self-organization is not easily achieved, that is why only in a few experiments are the two HTSC transitions
separated to give trapezoidal Tc(x)’s.
19
Figure 6. A sketch of the thermal data on Si:P, showing both transition [40].
and
in relation to the transport
GENERAL CONCLUSIONS: ANALYTICITY AND CARDINALITY The essence of filamentary percolation theory is that it replaces the analyticity of field theory, which has been an excellent guide to the physics of the “old” metallic superconductors, by the “countability”, or cardinality of modern set theory. The justification for this in HTSC is an internally consistent theory of the crucial experimental properties, notably the normal state transport properties, as functions of both temperature and composition. Analytic models [3] can be constructed which account qualitatively for the temperature dependence, for example, but when these are examined in detail it soon becomes apparent that they are not capable of accounting precisely for the observed functional forms, either the resistivity linearity in T or the linearity and magnitude of the composition dependence of the low-temperature pseudogap linear resistivity cutoff T0(x) in YBCO7-x. The filamentary theory exhibits many similarities between the MIT in impurity bands and that in the cuprates, especially YBCO, which is the most homogeneous and macroscopic-defect free of the cuprates, because of its chains. In this sense the theory is self-proving (self-testing), because one would expect those similarities to be most pronounced for the best material. The disappearance of many of these properties from LSCO and (Y,Ca)BCO alloys shows that the theory is both selective and incisive, for it
successfully differentiates those properties which EMA models cannot explain because they are microscopic, from those which it cannot explain because they are macroscopic. Both electronic theories are reduced to their simplest form in the intermediate phases of network glasses. The overall similarity of the three systems shows that it is their shared
20
(discrete/continuous) topology that is responsible for their remarkable properties, from the reversibility window to HTSC itself.
THE BIG, BIG PICTURE
The differences between pure continuum models (or the effective medium approximation, EMA) and discrete off-lattice models (embedded in a continuum) are huge, not only conceptually, but also psychologically. Scientists who have been educated to think only in terms of continuum models, and who have developed their own concepts in that framework, often find themselves enslaved by that framework. (A concrete analogy, close to home, is that of the experimenter married to his equipment, or the computer scientist married to his software.) In this volume one can find many examples of problems and principles that certainly go beyond the limits of the continuum approach. Perhaps it is not surprising that many of these examples occur in the context of network glasses, as these materials are obviously unsuited to continuum treatments. On the other hand, that nanodomains should exist in perovskites and pseudoperovskites should come as no surprise, as this family of materials has been known to be ferroelastic (and prototypically so) for more than 50 years. Yet Jan Jung’s elegant survey in this volume of these nanodomains reaches conclusions that are
politically very unpopular, as anyone who has attended one of the numerous conferences on
HTSC can testify. One can ask oneself just why such an obvious consequence of one of the most general
principles in the materials properties of oxides should be deemed “politically incorrect”. More than 10 years ago, when the subject of HTSC was still in an embryonic stage, I believed that most people were still being conservative; perhaps there was not enough direct evidence for the existence of nanodomains, and their dimensions remained to be determined. As Jung shows, this is certainly not the case today. Another explanation is that most people feel that if their own experiments do not
directly exhibit nanodomain features, then those features are not needed to explain their results. This is not so naïve as it sounds: in the theory of critical exponents of continuous phase transitions, some very sophisticated theorists have postulated that (loosely speaking), all such transitions are equivalent. (This is the concept of universality.) Such on-lattice transitions never exhibit an intermediate phase. Thus, it is the existence of intermediate phases in self-organized disordered systems that causes the breakdown of universality. We are now at the crucial point, both conceptually and psychologically. It is widely admitted, even by almost all those who still adhere to continuum descriptions of HTSC, that the intermediate (often called “non-Fermi liquid”) phase is responsible for HTSC. If this is the case (and all the experimental evidence so indicates), then the fact that no microscopic continuum model is known that produces an intermediate phase between the insulating and Fermi liquid phase, becomes decisive. There is such a model in discrete theories, and it is very successful in describing intermediate phases in network glasses and semiconductor impurity bands, as discussed elsewhere in this volume. It follows that a discrete network model is the only practical model for HTSC. Of course, a successful continuum model based on the EMA may be developed someday for HTSC, about the time that there is pie in the sky.
REFERENCES 1.
J. C Phillips, Physics of High-Tc Superconductors, Academic Press, Boston 1989.
2.
J. R. Schrieffer, X. G Wen and S. C Zhang, Phys. Rev. B 39, 11663 (1989).
21
3.
P. W. Anderson, Theory of Superconductivity in the High-Tc Cuprates, Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton 1997.
4.
J. C. Phillips, Physica C252, 188 (1995).
5.
J. C. Phillips, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 94, 12771 (1997).
6.
A. Wiles, Ann. Math. 141, 443 (1995).
7.
A. D. Aczel, Fermat’s Last Theorem, Four Walls Eight Windows, New York, 1996; S. Singh and K. A. Ribet, Scien. Am. (11): 68 (1997); D. Mackenzie, Science 285, 178 (1999). 8. J. C. Phillips, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 94, 10528 (1997). 9. J. C. Phillips, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 94, 10532 (1997). 10. J. C. Phillips (unpublished). 11. A. Ekert and R. Jozsa, Rev. Mod. Phys. 68, 733 (1996); C. H. Bennett, Physics Today 48 (10), 24 (1995). 12. H. He and M. F. Thorpe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54, 2107 (1985); M. F. Thorpe, D. J. Jacobs, N. V. Chubynsky and A. J. Rader, Rigidity Theory and Applications (Ed. M. F. Thorpe and P. Duxbury Kluwer Academic / Plenum Publishers, New York, 1999), p. 239. 13. Y. Imry and S.-K. Ma, Phys. Rev. Lett. 35, 1399 (1975). 14. J. C. Phillips, Solid State Commun. 47, 191 (1983). 15. G. A. Thomas, M. A Paalanen,. and T. F. Rosenbaum, Phys. Rev. B 27, 3897 (1983). 16. K.M.Itoh, E. E.Haller, J. W. Beeman, W. L. Hansen, J.Emes, L.A. Reichertz, E. Kreysa, T. Shutt, A. Cummings, W. Stockwell, B. Sadoulet, J. Muto, J. W. Farmer, and V. I. Ozhogin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 4058 (1996). 17. M. F. Collins, Magnetic Critical Scattering, Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford (1989). 18. J. T. Chayes, L. Chayes, D. S. Fisher and T. Spencer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 2999 (1986). 19.
K. A. Ribet, and B. Hayes, American Scientist 82, 144 (1994).
20.
J. C. Phillips, Phys. Rev. B 41, 8968 (1990).
21.
X. D. Xiang, W. A. Vareka, A. Zettl, J. L. Corkill, M. L. Cohen, N. Kijima, and R. Gronsky, Phys. Rev. Lett., 68,530(1992). N. E. Hussey, H. Takagi, Y. Iye, S. Tajima, A. I. Rykov, and K. Yoshida, Phys. Rev. B 61, R64 (2000). R. P. Sharma, F. J. Rotella, J. D Jorgensen,. and L. E. Rehn, Physica C 174, 409 (1991). G. Wentzel, Phys. Rev. 83, 168 (1951). J. C. Phillips, Phys. Rev. B 47, 11615 (1993). A. L. Efros and B. I. Shklovski, J. Phys. C 8, L49( 1975). S. K. Tolpygo, J.-Y. Lin, M. Gurvitch, S. Y. Hou and J. M. Phillips, Physica C 269, 207 (1996). N. Nagaosa and P. A. Lee, Phys. Rev. B 45, 966 (1992). H. L. Stormer, A. F. J. Levi, K. W. Baldwin, M. Anzlowar, and G. S. Boebinger, Phys. Rev. B 38, 2472 (1988).
22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
J. P. Franck, Physica C 282-287, 198 (1997); Phys. Scrip. T66, 220 (1996).
31. 32.
S. Sadewasser, J. S. Schilling, A. P. Paulikas and B. W. Veal, Phys. Rev. B 61, 741 (2000). J. C. Phillips, Rep. Prog. Phys. 59, 1133 (1996); J. C. Phillips and J. M. Vandenberg, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 9, L251-L258 (1997).
33. 34.
J. C. Phillips (unpublished). G. S. Boebinger, Y. Ando, A. Passner, T. Kimura, M. Okuya, J. Shimoyama, K. Kishio, K. Tamasaku, N. Ichikawa, and S. Uchida, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 5417 (1996). T. Ito, K. Takenaka, and S. Uchida, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 3995 (1993). Y. Petrov, T. Egami, R. J. McQueeney, M. Yethiraj, H. A. Mook, and F. Dogan, LANL CondMat/0003414 (2000).
35. 36.
37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42.
T. Hanaguri et al., Physica C 256, 111 (1996). A. I. M. Rae, E. M. Forgan, and R. A. Doyle, Physica C 301, 301 (1998). H. Darhmaoui and J. Jung, Phys. Rev. B 53, 14621 (1996). J. C. Phillips, Solid State Commun. 109, 301 (1999). H. Takagi, R. J. Cava, B. Batlogg, J. J. Krajewski, W. F. Peck, P. Bordet, and D. E. Cox, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 3777 (1996); H. Y. Hwang, B. Batlogg, H. Takagi, J. Kao, R. J. Cava, J. J. Krajewski, and W. F. Peck, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2636 (1994). J. Wagner (this workshop).
43.
E. Kaldis, J. Rohler, E. Liarokapis, N. Poulakis, K. Conder, and P. W. Loeffen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79,
4894 (1997).
22
REDUCED DENSITY MATRICES AND CORRELATION MATRIX
A. JOHN COLEMAN Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario, K7L 3N6, Canada
[email protected]
I tackle a herculean task - attempting to wean our imagination from the 1-particle picture which, implicitly, we have all been using since our youth. I shall try to entice you to join a crusade for the creation of new concepts and images needed for problems in which interaction between 3 or more electrons is significant and which are appropriate for describing the information encapsulated in the second order reduced density matrix. (“2-matrix” for short) Perhaps the difficult part of our task is changing our language and mental images. It was to this task that we were called by Charles Coulson in private conversation, and in his speech [1] in Boulder in June 1959, urging us to look in the 2-matrix for correlation. Also, by H. Froehlich [2] when he bemoaned the fact that we have failed to exploit the deep import of the results [3] of C.N Yang on the 2-matrix. It is to this task that I have devoted much of my time and interest since 1952 culminating in the publication of REDUCED DENSITY MATRICES - Coulson’s Challenge [4]. I shall refer to this book, by Coleman and Yukalov, as “CY”. When we wrote CY, although it was known that the order parameter of one of the phases of He3 had p-symmetry, we were unaware that the existence of s,p and d symmetry has appeared in some of the high temperature superconductors. As a result there is only a brief reference in CY to the correlation matrix. I have made a modest effort to redress this lacuna in the present paper. ENERGY AND N-REPRESENTABILITY A reduced density operator (RDO), for a normalized pure state, (123... N), of a system of N identical fermions or bosons can be represented as an integral operator. For example, the kernel of a 1-RDO, D1 , is the first order reduced density matrix (1-RDM):
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
23
whereas, the 2-RDM is
Thus the operator, D 1 , acting on a symmetric or antisymmetric function f of N particles,
defines a function D1 f such that
More generally, the p-RDO, Dp, is an operator with unit trace such that
In the context of Second quantization, it is usual to employ RDO’s with somewhat different normalization introduced by Dirac and defined by
and
Thus, and
As far as I am aware, it was Dirac [5] who first made effective use of RDM’s. But he considered only states described by a single Slater determinant formed from N orthonormal
spin-orbitals
in which case
As can be easily verified, this operator is merely the Identity operator on the linear space, spanned by the N functions Dirac showed that all the physical properties of the Slater state, including the p-matrices, can be obtained from a knowledge of or,equivalently, of It is astounding that so much physics, including our understanding of the Periodic Table, has been built with what would seem to be a trivial tool - the identity operator on a linear space of dimension N. As we all know, the physics consists of a skillful choice of the spin-orbitals, or rather of It is precisely the purpose of Hartree-Fock theory to lead us to the “best possible” choice. A large thriving industry and much of the wealth of the pharmaceutical companies is based on the simple equation (7). Such is the power of mathematics! It was Husimi [6] who, apparently, first discussed the more general RDM’s in (1) and (2) .Indeed, he considered p-RDM’s for arbitrary p. When the hamiltonian is represented in the form
as a sum of N one-particle terms and two-particles terms, it is easy to see that, for both fermions and bosons, the exact energy, E, of the state is given by
where the reduced hamiltonian is defined by
24
In my view, these last two formulas are absolutely basic for understanding the quantum mechanics of many-particle systems in which interaction among the particles plays a significant role. From the form of (10) it appears that as N increases the relative importance of interaction becomes increasingly significant! Unfortunately, hitherto little attention has been given to the eigenstates of K and the role of N in determining its eigenvalues. I regard this as a key challenge for any analyst who is interested in making a significant contribution to the N-body problem. - cf. pp. 11 and 257 of CY. I discovered (9) in 1952 while trying to understand Frenkel’s exposition of so-called Second Quantization. Husimi had seen it at least ten years earlier! I immediately applied (9) to calculate the ground-state energy of Li by assuming a simple ansatz A for D2 such that
I did extremely well, indeed too well! The result was about 20% below the observed value! This was impossible and forced me to realize that imposing fermion statistics was more subtle than I had imagined. This led me to invent the concept of N-representability: The 2-matrix of a pure state,
must be representable in the form (2) in order to satisfy
fermion or boson statistics. Analogously for a p-matrix.
So, in 1952 I proudly announced to a group of able physicists at Chalk River that I had reduced the N-body problem to a body problem - we now merely had to solve the N-representability problem, which I assumed would be child’s play, and using (9) find the ground states using Rayleigh-Ritz. After 48 years there is no easy practical way of doing this in general. However, Carmela Valdemoro made a big break-through in 1992 which was quickly followed up Hiroshi Nakatsuji and then by David Mazziotti. They have devised an
effective method of calculating the energy levels, which I have dubbed the VNM method and which has been described [7] as “wave mechanics without wave functions”. For atoms and molecules with as many as 20 electrons, the VNM method competes favourably with FCI calculations of equal accuracy. Since RDM’s are initial values of Green’s Functions, a similar condition must be satisfied by GF’s. This has been generally unnoticed until quite recently and still has not been really absorbed by main-line physicists. However, the book [8] by Parr and Yang about Density Functional Theory (DFT) contains an early Section pointing out that N-representability is a dark cloud hovering over the validity of DFT. The usual methods of dealing with this problem is either not to be aware of it or to hope that it will go away! The latter method is not satisfactory. For small N, my experience with Li shows it is risky; whereas, for large N, the theorem of Hugenholtz [9] that, for an interacting system in the limit as N gets arbitrarily large, a single Slater determinant is orthogonal to the true wavefunction is rather dramatic. Perhaps this was in Froehlich’s mind [2] when he spoke to David Peat! BCS, MATTHIAS AND ALL THAT
I would be the first to admit that the BCS theory has been extraordinarily successful, making a contribution of immense value to Condensed Matter theory. Even so, as with the remarkable success of a single Slater determinant, I have always been amazed how the original BCS simple theory, managed to change and persist so long. In the cold light of current knowledge we now realize that the simple BCS theory had only two essential ingredients (i) The choice of a trial wavefunction formed with the same material as is needed to characterize one antisymmetric 2-particle function, or geminal. 25
(ii) An extremely simple ansatz for the potential as a step function exercising a positive attraction between electrons with energy close to the fermi energy.
Of these, I certainly consider (i) as more important. The BCS wavefunction is a Fock space equivalent of the wavefunction considered by Schafroth [10] and which, by a stroke
of luck, is as Yang proved [3], the type of wavefunction most likely to give rise to a large eigenvalue of the 2-matrix. To my mind this is the explanation of the success of the BCS
model. As for the nature of the force involved, we were told that the positive isotope effect definitely proved that it was phonon-mediated. So in my innocence, as a naive mathematician when a negative isotope effect was observed, I immediately inferred that this proved that the force could not be phonon mediated. But no! Since by this time the idea that the force was phonon-mediated had become firmly implanted in our collective consciousness, it was soon “proved” by an able theoretician that a negative isotope gave us even added evidence of our - by now - blind faith that the force was phonon-mediated! Also the myth was firmly established that “Cooper pairs” consist of two electrons with opposite spins.
Apparently
many phyicists still believe that this is essential to BCS theory. As suggested in Chapter 4 of
CY, this is not necessarily the case. For every new observation that contradicted the currently accepted theory our faith was saved by a small add-on or by a major or minor modification of the current formulation. The evolving BCS theory became more and more complex and subtle. But at that period, during
which I had the rare privilege of meeting and challenging Bernd Matthias every winter at Sanibel until his death, I developed the feeling that BCS theory had become, like Ptolemaic astronomy, a system of epicycles piled on epicycles! Bernd proudly proclaimed that he was anathematized by all theoretical physicists because for every new version of the theory proposed, he would go into the Bell Lab and emerge with a counter-example! Perhaps because he was a polite Swiss being kind to a Canadian or perhaps because he took pity on me as an innocent mathematician wandering among chemists and physicists, he carefully stroked my ego by stating that the ideas re. superconductivity that
I advanced were not contradicted by any known observation. I will pursue this below! However, in private conversation and in his lectures [11] at McGill in 1968, Matthias insisted that the truly interesting theoretical question is why do nearly all substances manifest
a form of Long Range Order (LRO) at sufficiently low temperature. He asserted that even gold would become a superconductor! I very much regret that he died before the discovery of HTSC. He would have so much fun bating theoreticians re. “anyons”, “RVB” and the other exotic ideas that have been bruited! When I asked John Harrison, the former Editor of JLTP and my colleague in Physics at Queen’s, to explain Matthias’s observation, his response was immediate. “It’s really not so surprising. At absolute Zero the entropy will vanish so we should expect total order”. Indeed, this is true and proves that my knowledge of thermodynamics is almost nil or I would have made this point to Matthias. So the interesting question becomes, not why there is LRO, but rather why is the LRO of the nature that actually occurs in a particular substance? I do not pretend to have a detailed answer to this question. I do think that I offer the basic set of the ideas essential for its answer. Another beef that I have with current physics practice is the error which Whitehead [12] calls “The Fallacy of Misplaced Concreteness” exhibited in such terms as p-electrons or Cooper pairs. If you understand the meaning of the word fermion or if you believe in democracy you know that all electrons are equal. They do not live in George Orwell’s Animal Farm
in which “all electrons are equal but some are more equal that others”. Only occasionally, have I noticed momentary indications of a bad conscience by chemists or physicists about this misuse of language. If challenged, as I am doing now, they excuse themselves with the same remark Bourbaki often uses “This is merely an innocent abus de language”. Whereas, I regard it as a noxious avoidance of our proper task of instilling in the minds of students a
26
set of valid concepts with which to explore the inner riches of Quantum Theory. It is not an electron which has p-symmety but a spin-orbital. In fact, it is a partially occupied eigenfunction of the 1-matrix! There are no such things as Cooper pairs, even if we think of them in the charming image, due I understand to Schrieffer, as partners dancing to Rock so that they can be at far ends of the floor yet fully synchronized, rather than breastto-breast in a gentle Strauss waltz. To even propose such an image almost makes the concept absurd. The functional unit is not a pair of electrons it is a spin-geminal. In fact, the key concept which we must learn to deploy is that of a partially occupied eigengeminal of the 2-matrix. CORRELATION MATRIX AND ORDER INDICES
I read somewhere that the nobellist, C.N. Yang, regarded the paper [3], in which he associated the onset of superconductivity with the appearance of a “large” eigenvalue in the 2-
matrix, as the most important paper of his distinguished career. My initial conjecture [13] was the obvious generalization of his observation and asserts that every type of LRO is associated with a large eigenvalue ot the 2-matrix. This was refined [14] by the definition of order indices and the correlation matrix. It is known that the least upper bound for the eigenvalues of the 2-matrix of a boson system is N(N – 1) and for a fermion system [15] the unattainable such bound is N. If we call the occupants of geminals pairons then we can say that the l.u.b. for the pairon occupation of a natural geminal is N(N – 1) for a system in which the constituent identical particles are bosons and N for a system if they are fermions. If a “Cooper pair” is anything it is a “pairon”. But the term pairon is more general and is not necessarily associated with superconductivity. Yang argued that superconductivity in a metal is triggered when
has an eigenvalue
of order N. Bloch [16] connected such an eigenvalue with flux quantization related to carriers with charge 2e, confirming Yang’s theory. From energy considerations sketched below, I inferred that eigenvalues of proportional to N were associated with eigengeminals describing a correlation which extends throughout the substance.- in other words, a Long Range correlation. The order index was then defined [17] as the largest value of such that has a finite non-zero value, in the thermodynamic limit. The correlation matrix is defined as By the above-mentioned [14] result, for systems of fermions For one or more eigenvalues of is proportional to N so LRO is present. For systems of bosons, could be as large as 2. As long as we conjecture that some form of mesoscopic [17] or local order is present. If we compare this with a percolation model for the onset of a new
phase of matter, cluster is infinite,
corresponds to the critical value of p when the diameter of an open close to 0 corresponds to the first moments at which nuclei of the new
phase are present. As
increases these nuclei become more widespread and larger. I am
thinking of the small bubbles becoming more widespread and larger which appear in water as it approaches the boiling point, or the complex systems of “fjords” of superconducting phase penetrating the whole of a cylindrical block of material which I had the privilege of viewing via polarized light as it was cooled by Martin Edwards in his Low Temperatre Lab at the Royal Military College of Canada many years ago. CONJECTURE. For all mono-particle systems, the appropriate order parameter (OP) is the correlation matrix From the structure of the 2-matrix it immediately follows that the order parameter can have spin character s, p or d and any combination of these. This is consistent with recent observations [18] that the order parameters of some HTSC’s exhibit s, p or d spin-symmetry or a combination of these - a phenomenon, which, apparently, BCS has difficulty accommo-
27
dating. My conjecture is that is the appropriate order parameter for all types of order in many-particle systems of one type of identical particles. Thus, I am making a bold generalization of Yang’s observation from superconducting to many other order transitions. I am encouraged by the fact that this conjecture is consistent with observations on the symmetry of the OP for HTSC and also for He3 in which p-type order occurs in at least one phase. I assume that for helical magnetism and many other types of order it will be necessary to study not only spin-symmetry but the total symmetry of the eigengeminals. I have called the above a conjecture rather than a theorem because a “proof” has not been obtained. This is because we do not yet have a sufficient understanding of the relation of the eigenvalues of to the occupation numbers of eigenstates of the reduced hamiltonian K. I regard this as an important urgent issue for theoretical research. Another is to explore the
dependence on the Order Index, of the physical properties of substances near the critical point. Note that if fermi-pairons were bosons, their occupation numbers could go to N(N – 1). This differs from the actual limit of N by a factor of (N – 1) which is infinite in the thermodynamic limit. Thus the universal practice in text-books, and in articles by writers who should know better, of saying that superconductivity arises as a result of a bose condensation of pairs is misleading talk which brings comfort, by creating the illusion that we know what we are talking about, but prevents us from coping with the real task of forging a set of meaningful concepts with which to understand condensed physics.
It is known that when Fock space is displayed with respect to a basis of a finite number, r, of orthonormal orbitals (i.e. 1-particle functions), the highest possible value for the eigenvalues n2i of is This is attained(CY,Chapter 3) only if the wavefunction is an antisymmetrized power of a single geminal - an AGP function and if the eigenvalues n1i of are equal. In this case(CY, p. 137) there is one large eigenvalue and the rest are equal to 2 N ( N – 2 ) / r(r–2). If we relax the condition that n1i be equal, it is possible to arrange that for an AGP function has several eigenvalues which are proportional to N. and thus model a variety of other situations including the co-existence of superconductivity and magnetic ordering. It is perhaps worth recalling here that r = N is a necessary and sufficent condition that
the wave function be a Slater determinant. In this case all the eigenvalues of are equal to 2 which is a long way from N. This corresponds to the fact that HF is accurate if and only if the effective hamiltonian has no 2-particle terms. We introduce some essential notation by recalling that in CY. Denote the eigenfunctions of Dp by
with corresponding eigenvalues
so
Setting
we obtain
and
28
Further, if the reduced hamiltonian (10) has eigengeminals, gi, such that then the total internal energy
where
Suppose that the are so numbered that they increase monotonically with i, and the numbering of n2i so that they decrease. Then in the ground state the system will choose so that pi for small i, and especially for i = 1, are as large as possible consistent with N-representability. The largest occupation of a natural geminal is n21. By the familiar theory of separation of eigenvalues of hermitian operators, 2 (N – 1)
In particular,
2(N – 1) p1 = n21 if and only if the eigenfunction g1 of K coincides with the first natural geminal, of the state. Exact coincidence is highly unlikely, but there will be a strong tendency towards this so it is possible that p1 will be of order N. In this case, we would expect that g1 describes a 2-particle correlation which extends throughout the sample, that is a LRO. For N electrons in a lattice if we neglect spin, we are led to study the hamiltonian
where i and j refer to electrons and k to nuclei; Z k is the charge on an ion at sk. For neutral systems This implies, in the notation of (8), that
Notice that, though we mentioned electrons in a lattice, if k assumes only one value, (23) would describe the hamiltonian of an N-electron atom with nuclear charge Z k = N, whereas, if k takes two values, a diatomic molecule. And so on. In fact, almost anything. By (10), associated with (23) is the Reduced Density Operator, K. However, for reasons which will become apparent, we introduce an additional parameter, t, and define K (t) by
If we divide by N2, set then (25) takes the form
and N2U (t) = K(t), and replace Nr i by ri and Nsk by sk,
29
For a neutral system,
For fixed N the spectrum of U(t) will depend continuously
on t. A famous theorem [19] of Zhislin assures us that when
the operator
(26) has an infinite number of bound states with energy levels crowding up to the limit of the continuous spectrum.
U (0) is a two-electron hamiltonian which approaches the hamiltonian of H – as N increases to infinity. On the other hand, for t = 0, and N = 2, (25) is the hamiltonian of the helium atom. According to (18) and (22) it is the spectrum of K = K(1) which is of real
interest in the study of energy levels of N-particle systems. Since K = N2U (l), it follows that the spectrum of K is obtained from that of U (1) by scaling by the factor N2.
It is known [20] that H– has only one bound state. It is a 1S state slightly below the continuum which accounts for an absorption line in the solar spectrum. The two lowest states of the helium atom are a 1 S and a 3S state. For a fixed system, (25) depends continuously on t so we expect that as t varies from 1 to 0 a correspondence will be established between the spectra of U (1) and U (0). However, while U (0) is an atomic hamiltonian, we shall expect the spectrum of U ( t ) , when t > 0, to be a series of bands, possibly narrow, each of which collapses, when and which could be named by an energy level of the atomic system which U (0) describes. If spin is neglected then it would be reasonable to expect that all levels of the lowest band would be 1 S.
In this case, for a system manifesting long-range order at low temperature, we would anticipate that the correlation matrix will depend on the eigenfunctions corresponding to the levels of the lowest band weighted by a distribution function depending on the inverse temperature, Unfortunately, little study has been made of the spectrum of K for solids or other condensed matter even though the fact that it must play a key role in understanding the energetics of condensed matter has been obvious for forty or fifty years. We noted above that the late Bernd Matthias, who probably discovered more superconductors than any three other experimentalists together, constantly insisted that an important
task for theoretical physics was to explain why nearly all fermion systems manifest longrange order of some type at sufficiently low temperatures - superfluidity, superconductivity, ferro- or antiferro-magnetism, charge density waves, coexistence of superconductivity and helical spin density waves, etc. To properly describe the electrons in condensed matter, our hamiltonian (23) would need to be supplemented by terms describing L·S coupling, spinspin effects, motion of the ions etc. However, the electric forces described by (18) would probably dominate the energy. If in fact the spectrum of K is similar to that of H— in having one eigenvalue, or a band of eigenvalues significantly below all others, then that level would tend to be occupied as fully as possible consistent with the statistics, the inter-particle forces and the temperature. For fermions, n21 could be of order N which, if it occurred, would manifest itself as long-range order. The nature of the particular LRO would be characterized by the correlation matrix. ANTISYMMETRIZED GEMINAL POWER
A theorem attributed [21] to Zumino states that a fermion geminal, in other words, an antisymmetric two-particle function, can be transformed by a unitary transformation into a canonical form in which each orbital is a member of a unique pair of orbitals. The reader should be aware that it is my custom to denote by the word orbital a function of a single particle including all relevant coordinates. Thus, depending on context, the word may denote the classical meaning of a chemist(if the particle is without spin), or what a chemist means by spin-orbital, or a function of spatial co-ordinates and two dichotomic variables for spin and isotopic spin. Thus if
30
is such that the normalized function g (12) = – g (21), with then r = 2s is even, and by a unitary transformation it is possible to find an orthonormal basis αi with respect to which
In (27), r is the rank of g and also the rank of the matrix c ij. It is well-known that the rank of an antisymmetric matrix is even. The antisymmetrized power of an orbital is always zero. Thus f(1)f(2) – f ( 2 ) f ( 1 ) = 0. However, the antisymmetrized power of a geminal, g, to obtain a function of N particles will vanish if and only if the rank, r, of g is less than N. When N = r, this N-particle function is a single Slater determinant formed with a basis of g. Perhaps inadvisedly, I have adopted the symbol gN to denote a normalized N – particle function obtained by antisymmetrizing an appropriate power of g. Several persons, of whom Nakamura [22] may have been the first, showed that the projection of the BCS function(which is a coherent ensemble in Fock space of functions of all possible particle number) onto a subspace of Fock space of particle number N produces an AGP function of rather special type. The importance of the AGP function is signalled by the fact that it has appeared in a variety of contexts with different names such as: Schaftroth condensed pair function; projected BCS function; correlated pair function; pairiing function; Generalized Hartree-Fock function. The mathematical concept goes back to Hermann Grassmann in the 1840’s since it arises naturally in Grassmann algebra. I prefer to use a name which suggests its mathematical nature and does not place it in a misleading context. For applications to physics and chemistry there is no need to insist that the occupants of a geminal are particles with opposite spin. Any kind of fermion geminal forces a natural pairing. Therefore it can be cogently argued that the apparent “pairing” in BCS is not forced by the physics but rather appears as a mathematical artifact forced by the assumption that the wavefunction is AGP. I realize that there is such a widespread commitment to the religious
belief that Cooper pairs are “real” that there is a high probability that I shall be accused of blasphemy, tried, condemned and burned at the stake!! Since the whole of Chapter 4 of CY is devoted to AGP, here I shall restrict myself to quickly mentioning what every young person should know about Grassmann algebra and fermions. 1) If is an N-particle fermion function and is an orbital such that the Grassmann product then there is an (N – l)-particle function, such that Further, these equivalent conditions are necessary and sufficient that be a natural orbital of with occupation unity.
2) Suppose that an AGP function formed from an arbitrary geminal, g, then if r is the rank of a) r < N implies that b) r = N implies that is a Slater determinant, c) r > N implies that can be expressed as a linear combination of ( ) Slater determinants consisting only of paired orbitals, where r = 2s, and N = 2m. 3) If N is even and the natural orbitals of
are evenly degenerate, with occupation
strictly less than unity, then there exists a geminal g such that This remarkable result, proved around 1965 by Erdahl, Kummer and myself, implies that for a manyparticle fermion state satisfying these conditions, all one-particle properties can be exactly described by an AGP function.
4) Further, suppose that N = p + q where q is even and precisely p natural orbitals have
occupation unity, then where S is a Slater determinant containing the indicated p natural orbitals and g is a geminal. Such functions have been called Generalized AGP functions.
31
5) On p. 139 of CY we indicate that an AGP function might have the possibility of having a 2-matrix with a finite number of “large” eigenvalues. It is therefore conceivable that observed co-existence of superconductivity and helical magnetism could be modelled by GAGP. 6) If N is even and if is of rank N + 2, then by making use of the so-called Hodge Correspondence between subspaces of dimension 2 and those of dimension N in a space of dimension N + 2, we can prove that is an AGP function. As the “cranking model”, AGP proved useful in nuclear theory. At first a theory with the fanciful sobriquet “superconducting nuclei” was introduced using the BCS coherent ensemble
equation subject to a condition that the expected value of the number operator be N. However, Nogami and others soon noticed that it was more accurate to use a projected BCS function, that is an AGP function. Chemists also found that AGP, as an ansatz for the wave-function, was more successful in modelling the dissociation of diatomic molecules than Haertree-Fock. It was observed that the Random Phase Approximation is self-contradictory i f , as is common, a single Slater is taken as the initial ground state, whereas the most obvious contradictions are avoided if the ground state is assumed to be a Generalized AGP.(For this, cf. p. 140 of CY). In view of these properties and the fact that GAGP can be a single Slater modeling a fermion system with no correlation or, on the other hand, a system with a with the largest possible eigenvalue and therefore modelling the highest possible correlation, it is apparent that the GAGP ansatz is of great scope and could be used to provide insight into a wide variety of fermion systems.
GRASSMANN AND THE FERMI SURFACE I come now to a little-known theorem of Grassmann for which I will present a proof, partly because I do not want to disappoint your expectation that proving theorems is my main
purpose in life, as a mathematician, but also because the result is unexpected and may be the “real” reason why we must replace “fermions” by “fermi pairons” in our thinking and
therefore the ultimate reason that “Cooper pairs” proved so serviceable. I announced this result [23] without giving the proof in 1961. In fact the proof was rather easy making use of the Hodge correspondence between sub-spaces of dimension p and those of dimension n – p in a linear space of dimension n. With a more complicated proof, the same result was proved later in the RMP by a theoretical physicist, but I have lost the reference. In fact, Whitehead [24] provides an almost trivial proof, attributing it to Grassmann - presumably from the 1840’s! Here in two equivalent forms, first Grassmann’s and secondly mine, is the
Theorem (i) A homogeneous element of order n in a Grassmann algebra of rank n + 1, is elementary. (ii) If is a pure N-particle state, then the rank of is not N + 1. Proof. I shall state the argument in the language of antisymmetric wavefunctions. Suppose the basis has N + 1 orbitals. Associated with a Slater determinant of order N is a unique subspace of dimension N spanned by the N vectors of the determinant or by any N linearly independent vectors in the same subspace. Changing these vectors does not change the subspace but may multiply the Slater by a constant. Suppose that is a linear combination of two Slaters. By a basic theory about subspaces, the dimension of the intersection of the subspaces associated to the two Slaters is N + N – (N + l ) = N – l. This intersection is common to both subspaces and is characterized by a Slater S. of order N – 1. Adjoin vectors and 32
to the intersection so that S and are N-th order Slaters respectively characterizing the two subspaces Then there are constants a and b such that
which is a single Slater of rank N. By induction we see that any linear combination of Slaters
of order N, in a space spanned by N + 1 orbitals, is again a Slater(i.e , in the language of Grassmann algebra, “elementary”) of N orbitals. It follows easily that version (ii) is implied by version (i) of the statement of the theorem. Hence if is not a Slater it must have rank at least N + 2. But it could have that rank as follows from Item 6 of the previous Section. The discussion of the energy of an AGP state in Section 4.6 of CY was used to estimate the change in energy if a Slater state of rank N is changed to a state of rank N + 2 by replacing two orbitals each of occupancy 1 by four orbitals each with occupancy 1/2. It was found (CY, p.155) that the change in energy of the state was
where κ and name distinct “pairs” of orbitals. The number denotes the interaction energy where and and has fixed phase. Whereas, denotes the interaction energy and has adjustable phase which was used to arrange the negative contribution in (29). Thus the Fermi surface is unstable with respect to pair formation unless is positive and numerically greater than If the so-called “pairing hamiltonian” is used, automatically so that for the pairing hamiltonian, the Fermi surface is always unstable. This seems to contradict the commonly expressed view that the
existence of superconductivity requires an attractive force which was part of the rational for the existence of Cooper pairs.
It is now widely recognized that HTSC is usually associated with phase separation. In the next section we find that a sufficiently strong repulsive Coulomb force is required to account for phase separation. PHASE SEPARATION AND SUPERCONDUCTIVITY
In his well-known survey [25], published in 1989, of the properties of HTSC, Phillips has 11 references to “Lattice instabilities”, a topic to which he devotes several pages at various points in the book. He even went so far as to suggest that lattice instability is the only factor that causes HTSC. I do not admit this since in 1991 Yukalov [26] surveyed 508 experimental and theoretical papers which dealt with evidence bearing on the incidence of phase transitions of what he called “heterophase fluctuations”. Yukalov, who is a Senior theoretical physicst in the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research in Dubna, is a remarkably competent and careful authority on Quantum Statistics . He agrees that instability of the lattice can be important but there are other significant factors. During the past ten years more evidence [26] has accumulated similar to the impressive collection which he assembled. In his basic paper referenced above, are foreshadowed many ideas that have recently become current. Chapters 5 and 6 of our book were laregly due to Yukalov since I know so little of the nitty-gritty of physics. In particular this is the case for Section 6.2 of CY in which we attempt to work out in a form relevant to HTSC the theory developed in his paper [26] when there are only two phases interpenetrating. Here I merely sketch the course of our argument directing the interested reader to Section 6.2 of CY and the references in Notes 2 and 3. We posit a situation which can be thought of as microsopic or mesoscopic nuclei of one phase (e.g. “superconducting”) scattered randomly through a host phase (e.g. “normal”) Experimental observation of this possibility was recently provided by a group from Dubna 33
with associates in a paper [28] entitled “Microscopic phase separation in
induced
by the superconducting transition”. We propose a simple model which takes into account the three interrelated factors: Coulomb interaction, phase separation, and lattice softening. We give a detailed analysis of the dependence of the critical temperature on parameters related to the attractive and repulsive interactions and to the superconducting phase fraction w.
Since the Hartree-Fock-Bogolubov - essentially AGP - approximation is used, our formulas look very much like those in usual presentations of BCS theory.. However, they have quite different meaning because they involve the parameter w in an intricate manner.We assume that the interaction between electrons is the sum of two components
- a direct part which is taken as a Debye-type shielded Coulomb force. and - an indirect part for which we assume the conventional Froehlich phonon term. Additional parameters are introduced by which it is possible to vary (i) the phonon
frequency, (ii) electron-phonon coupling, and (iii) the strength of the direct interaction. The resulting equations were solved numerically by Dr. E. Yukalova. The results are exhibited in CY as twelve graphs portraying the superconducting critical temperature against w, in three
groups corresponding to weak, moderate and strong softening of the lattice. We were pleasantly surprised by the wide variety of shapes of these graphs. Despite the rough approximations assumed for our model, the behaviour of the critical temperature in Figs. 3,4,7 and 8, has striking similarity to some corresponding experimental curves observed for HTSC. Even though one might expect the relation between doping intensity and w to be monotone, the actual relation is not known so a detailed comparison of our results with those of experiment is not possible. We were led to the following conclusions: - The presence of repulsive interaction is a necessary condition for mesoscopic phase separation. - Phase separation favours superconductiviy making it possible in certain het-
erophase samples when it would not occur in a pure sample. - The critical temperature as a function of the relative fraction of superconductive phase can exhibit the nonmonotonic behaviour characteristic of HTSC. FINAL REMARKS
1) I conclude that we need to develop a habit of thinking more comfortably about the second order reduced density matrix its eigenvalues and its eigengeminals. 2) For a system of a large number of identical particles which is all that I discussed,
the “large” component of the 2-RMD, denoted by parameter. If
is proposed as the appropriate order
there is no “order” present so this could correspond to what we usually
call “normal”. For fermion systems Long Range Order corresponds to
and for bosons,
to I have not expatiated on my conviction that neither bose nor fermi condensation, as normally understood, in the simple-minded sense derived from London(whose memory I honour!), actually occur in an interacting system and that we poison the innocent minds of our students if we persist in suggesting that they do. 3) More imporrtant, it is my view that because for the earliest discovered superconductors, Tc was so low and the isotope effect had a simple explanation, we were misled into thinking that the origin of superconductivity is exotic and/or subtle. However, I take seriously Matthias’s observation that LRO at sufficiently low temperature is universal and therefore should have a robust explanation.. Further the behaviour of various substances near the 34
critical temperature seems to have much in common. When charged particles are involved, I conclude that Coulomb forces are the real culprit. So I claim that the secret for this universal phenomenon is to be found in the second order reduced hamiltonian. The isotope effect implies that interaction with the lattice must play a role. My musings at the end of Section 3, suggest that contributions by the static coulomb interaction, specified by Zhislin’s theorem, involve quite minute energy differences for K jbetween the continuum level and a narrow energy band which is almost at the continuum limit. This means that lattice dynamics, L. S coupling and other spin-effects could also play a significant role accounting for the known variation of Tc across the Periodic Table which was noted by Matthias [11] in his McGill lectures. 4) I fully realize that some of my heterodox opinions are anathema to many. I shall try to face this with the equanimity of old age, welcoming all comments, questions and counterexamples at my email address on the title-page.
NOTES 1. 2.
Charles Coulson, in conversation with graduate students and Coleman in Oxford June 1975. Also in a speech in Boulder, Colorado: Rev. Mod. Phys. 32, 175 (1960). H. Froehlich, shortly before his death, in private conversation with David Peat.
3.
C.N. Yang, Rev. Mod. Phys. 34, 694 (1962).
4. 5. 6.
By A.J. Coleman and V.I. Yukalov, Vol 72 in Series published by Springer in Lecture Notes in Chemistry, April, 2000. P.A.M. Dirac, Proc. Cam. Ph. Soc. 26, 376 (1930); 27, 240 (1931). K. Husimi, Proc. Phys. Math. Soc. Japan 22, 264 (1940).
7.
Section 7.3 of CY.
8.
9.
R.G. Parr and W. Yang, Density Theory of Atoms and Molecules, Oxford University Press, 1980.
N.M. Hugenholtz, Physica 23, 481 (1957); L. van Hove, Physica 25, 849 (1958).
10.
M.R. Schafroth, Phys. Rev. 96, 1149, 1442 (1954); 100, 463, 502 (1955); 111, 72 (1958).
11.
B. Matthias, Three Lectures, in Superconductivity, Proc. Ad. Summer Study Institute, June, 1968, at
12.
McGill University, ed. P.R. Wallace, Gordon and Breach, New York. A.N. Whitehead, p. 64 Science and the Modern World, Cambridge U.P., 1933; p.11 Process and Reality,
13. 14. 15.
Macmillan Comp.,1929. A.J. Coleman, Can. J. Phys. 42, 226 (1964). A.J. Coleman, V.I.Yukalov, Nuovo Cimento B 108, 1377 (1993). A.J. Coleman, Rev. Mod. Phys. 35, 668 (1963).
16.
F. Bloch, Phys. Rev. A 137, 787 (1962).
17. 18.
A.J. Coleman, Jl. Low Temp. Phys. 74, 1 (1989). H. Srikanth et al., Phys. Rev. B 55, R14 733 (1997); K.A. Kouznetsov et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 3050 (1997); in Physica C 317-318, 410 (1999), van Hartington claims “unambiguous determination” of d-wave symmetry in HTSC cuprates; in Nature 396, 658 (1998), Ikeda et al. observe p-wave symmetry in a second HTSC. G.M. Zhislin, Trudi Mosk.Mat. Obsc. 9, 81 (1960), Th.III, p.84. R.N. Hill, J. Math. Phys. 18, 2316(1977).
19. 20.
21.
B. Zumino, J. Math. Phys. 3, 1055 (1963); see also Thm.6, Coleman, Bull. Can. Math. Soc. 4, 209 (1961).
22. 23. 24. 25.
K. Nakamura, Progr. Theor. Phys. (Kyoto) 21, 273 (1959). A.J. Coleman, Can. Math. Bull. 4, 209 (1961), Thm.7. A.N. Whitehead, Universal Algebra, Cambridge University Press, 1898. J.C. Phillips, Physics of High-Tc Superconductors, Academic Press, 1989.
26.
V.I. Yukalov, Phase Transitions and Hetrophase Fluctuations, Physics Reports 206, 395–488(1991).
27. 28.
Phys. Rev. B 54, 9054 (1996); Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 439 (1996). V.Yu. Pomjakushin et al., Phys. Rev. B 58, 12 350 (1998).
35
This page intentionally left blank
THE SIXTEEN-PERCENT SOLUTION: CRITICAL VOLUME FRACTION FOR PERCOLATION
RICHARD ZALLEN Department of Physics, Virginia Tech Blacksburg, VA 24061
INTRODUCTION The English call it “value for money” (vfm). The American equivalent is “bang for the buck”. The idea is simple: to provide a rough measure of the ratio of benefit to cost. For an author of scientific papers, one possibility for a vfm-type measure of “benefit” (impact) to “cost” (time and effort) is this: vfm = (number of citations)/(paper’s length in printed pages). In my case, the vfm winner is clear. It is a two-page paper by Harvey Scher and myself, published quietly as a note in J. Chem. Phys. [1], which has been cited over 350 times. Later work related to the central idea of that paper has also been widely cited [2, 3]. That idea is the concept of a critical volume fraction for site-percolation processes. NOSTALGIA One afternoon in mid-May of 1970, at my desk in the research building of the Xerox complex near Rochester, NY, I was poring over experimental Raman spectra, searching for significant peaks with my “spectroscopist’s eye” [4]. I was not having much luck, and I needed a break. So I left my office, walked down the hall, and went into the office of a colleague, Harvey Scher. Harvey was, as usual, good-natured and patient about the interruption of his own work, and he took the opportunity to describe an interesting problem that he was working on. A very approachable resident theorist, Harvey had been consulted by a technology group working on photosensitive layers in which photoconductor particles were dispersed in a resin. Their measurements had shown a dramatic threshold in the dependence of photosensitivity on photoconductor concentration. Elliott Montroll, then a frequent visitor to Xerox, had suggested to Harvey that he look at the literature on percolation theory. Harvey had assimilated that literature and made use of it, and he introduced me to percolation theory that afternoon. I was fascinated by this stuff,
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
37
and when I got back to my office I did not return to the strip-chart recordings (no PC’s in 1970). Instead, I worked on some geometry problems related to ideas that we had kicked around, and I became enthusiastic about writing up a short paper reporting what we had found. Ten days later the paper was circulated internally within Xerox, and it was submitted for publication in mid-June. This speed was then, and is now, uncharacteristic of both authors. The reason for the choice of J. Chem. Phys. is somewhat obscure. We did not want to send it to a math or math-phys journal, and we had seen a short paper in J. Chem. Phys. that mentioned percolation. It turns out that the referee for our paper was almost certainly a mathematician! He (or she) chided us for the empirical and approximate nature of our
critical density. (We knew it was approximate, and we were proud of “empirical”!) But he (or she) nevertheless pointed out to us an additional result for (an exact value for the two-dimensional Kagomé lattice) which fit our ideas very well. We added it to the Table in
our paper. The anecdote described above, dealing with the fruitfulness of an afternoon schmooze session at the Xerox lab in Webster, NY, was characteristic of a period now remembered by some as a “golden age” of industrial research [5]. The scientific issue arose in the context of a technological setting, which is of course a familiar tradition in condensedmatter physics [6]. The atmosphere was one in which it was OK to spend time on scientific
issues as well as on product-development and engineering ones. In the year 2000, that era is history and opportunities to do science are rare in present-day corporations. Globalization is sometimes given as the reason (or excuse) for this, but human herd-instinct considerations also enter: Everybody did it then (corporations supported research) because everybody else did it; nobody does it now because nobody else does it. This is a
cooperative phenomenon, so perhaps we can hope that a phase transition can happen again. CRITICAL VOLUME FRACTION In three dimensions, the percolation threshold
for site-percolation processes varies
from lattice to lattice by more than a factor of two [7]. For two-dimensional lattices,
varies by more than a factor of 1.5 [7, 8]. The Scher-Zallen construction for the critical volume fraction associates with each site a sphere (or circle, in 2d) of diameter equal to the nearest-neighbor separation. Spheres surrounding filled sites are taken to be filled. At the critical value of the site-occupation probability p , the fraction of space occupied by the filled spheres is taken to be the critical volume fraction The key point is this: From lattice to lattice (in a given dimensionality), is nearly constant, varying by just a
few percent. It is an approximate dimensional invariant. In three dimensions, 0.16; in two dimensions, is close to 0.45 [1, 3]. The relationship between and is
is close to
where f is the filling factor of the
lattice when viewed as a sphere packing. The values forming the basis of the 1970 paper correspond to familiar crystal structures. A structure that is not crystalline but is experimentally well defined is random close packing (rcp). The rcp structure corresponds to the atomic-scale structure of simple amorphous metals [3]. Since f is known for the rcp structure, predicts the value for this structure. Experiments carried out to determine the conductivity threshold (insulator-to-metal transition) of rcp mixtures of insulating and metallic spheres are in good agreement with this prediction [9, 10, 11]. One way to view is as an expression connecting the ease-of-percolation with the connectivity of the underlying structure. For bond percolation, such an
38
(approximate) connection had been found earlier, in 1960 [12, 13]. A reasonable measure
for the ease-of-percolation for a given structure is (1/ p c) , the reciprocal of the percolation threshold. For bond percolation,
(1/p c) is very close to (2/3)z in three dimensions and
(l/2)z in two dimensions. Here z is the average coordination number of the lattice. The proportionality between ease-of-percolation and coordination number shows that, for bondpercolation processes, the coordination number is the appropriate measure of the connectivity of the lattice. This, of course, makes sense. But for site-percolation processes, z does not work. Instead, shows that (1/p c) is proportional to f. This reveals that, for site-percolation processes, the sphere-packing filling factor is the appropriate measure of the connectivity of the underlying structure. This insight is a byproduct of the work on the critical volume fraction.
LIMITATIONS
Thanks to the piece of information provided by the unknown referee, we knew immediately that is only approximately invariant. The site-percolation threshold is known exactly for two two-dimensional lattices, the triangular lattice (2d close packing) and the Kagomé lattice, so that
is exactly determined for each. The two values differ by
2%. A few people in the critical-phenomena community took an instant dislike to It wasn’t exact. It wasn’t rigorous. It wasn’t even an exponent, so why care about it? [One can imagine one of them having the following reaction to the experimental discovery of a new superconductor: “So Tc is 450 K, so what? What are the exponents?” But maybe that’s unfair.] The value of
can be estimated from a plot of (1/p c) versus f [3]; the slope is
Here a question arises at the low end of the plot, where the proportionality
between the ease-of-percolation and the filling factor has to eventually fail because (1/ p c) cannot be less than 1. This consideration is unimportant in three dimensions in which (1 / pc ) does not closely approach unity; the values cluster in the region from about 2.3 to 5.0. In two dimensions, typical (1/p c) values are closer to 1.0, lying between 1.4 and 2.0. Within this region, the proportionality of (1/p c) to f holds very well [1]. However, Suding and Ziff [8] have recently considered very-low-connectivity two-dimensional lattices with (1/p c) values down to 1.24. Their results show that at these very low connectivities, the deviation from becomes appreciable. Suding and Ziff offer a revised, nonlinear relation between pc and f that improves the fit in the very-lowconnectivity region. Most structures of physical interest are far from this region. APPLICATIONS The notion of a critical volume fraction insensitive to the details of local structure, as
suggested in the 1970 paper, is an attractive one. But it is heuristic, empirical, approximate. It had been my original plan for this paper to review its success (or failure) in relation to experimental literature on metal/insulator composites. This has turned out to be too
mammoth an undertaking for the presently available space and time, and will have to be deferred. The experimental literature is vast; one extensive compilation can be found in a 1993 article by Ce-Wen Nan [14]. The experimental studies span an enormous variety of systems and differ greatly in depth and quality.
39
Figure 1. The conductivity threshold in graphite/boron-nitride composites [19].
At a later time I may attempt a plot of frequency-of-occurrence versus value, but here only some less-than-satisfactory observations will be offered. For three-dimensional
composites a value close to 0.16 is very often encountered, and it is interesting that this occurs for some of the most carefully studied systems. Examples are the carbonblack/polymer composites studied by Heaney and co-workers [15, 16, 17] and the graphite/boron-nitride composites studied by Wu and McLachlan [18, 19]. Figure 1 displays the very clean experimental results of Wu and McLachlan, showing a conductivity threshold spanning many orders of magnitude. Graphite and boron nitride are structural
and mechanical isomorphs, but differ in conductivity by a factor of 1018. The points are
measured values; the curves are scaling-law fits that closely determine
(0.15 for this
system). But there are many systems for which is quite different from 0.16; this value is not universal. The reason is unclear, though different classes of topology have been suggested. One of these is the “Swiss-cheese” void-percolation topology analyzed by Halperin and coworkers [20] and studied experimentally by Lee et al. [11] ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I wish to thank Wantana Songprakob for crucial help in preparing this paper. I also wish to thank Harvey Scher for thirty years of friendly interaction.
40
REFERENCES 1. 2.
3. 4.
Scher, H. and Zallen, R. (1970) Critical density in percolation processes, J. Chem. Phys. 53, 3759. Zallen, R. and Scher, H. (1971) Percolation on a continuum and the localization-delocalization transition in amorphous semiconductors, Phys. Rev. B. 4, 4471. Zallen, R. (1998) The Physics of Amorphous Solids, John Wiley and Sons, New York. pp. 183-191. I first heard this apt term mentioned in a talk given by Manuel Cardona.
5.
In the seventies, the Xerox lab in Palo Alto was the site of some now-famous computer-science
6.
Harvey Scher, now at the Weizmann Institute, has commented on technology as a rich source of
examples: Hiltzik, M.A. (1999) Dealers of Lighting, Harper, New York.
7. 8.
9. 10.
scientific questions in his recent Festschrift article: Scher, H. (2000) Reminiscences, J. Phys. Chem. B 104, 3768. Reference [3], p. 170. Suding, P.N. and Ziff, R.M. (1999) Site percolation thresholds for Archimedean lattices, Phys. Rev. E 60, 275. Fitzpatrick, J.P., Malt, R.B., and Spaepen, F. (1974) Percolation theory and the conductivity of random close packed mixtures of hard spheres, Physics Letters 47A, 207. Ottavi, H., Clerc, J.P., Giraud, G., Roussenq, J., Guyon, E., and Mitescu, C.D. (1978) Electrical conductivity of conducting and insulating spheres: an application of some percolation concepts, J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 11, 1311.
11. 12.
13. 14. 15. 16.
17. 18.
19. 20.
Lee, S.I., Song, Y., Noh, T.W., Chen, X.D., and Gaines, J.R. (1986) Experimental observation of nonuniversal behavior of the conductivity exponent for three-dimensional continuum percolation systems, Phys. Rev. B 34, 6719. Domb, C. and Sykes, M.F. (1960) Cluster size in random mixtures and percolation processes, Phys. Rev. 122, 170. Shklovskii, B.I. and Efros, A.L. (1984) Electrical Properties of Doped Semiconductors, SpringerVerlag, Berlin, p. 106. Nan, C.W. (1993) Physics of inhomogeneous inorganic materials, Prog. Mater. Sci. 37, 1. Viswanathan, R. and Heaney, M.B. (1995) Direct imaging of the percolation network in a threedimensional disordered conductor-insulator composite, Phys. Rev. Letters 75, 4433. Heaney, M.B. (1995) Measurement and interpretation of nonuniversal critical exponents in disordered conductor/insulator composites, Phys. Rev. B 52, 12477.
Heaney, M.B. (1997) Electrical transport measurements of a carbon-black/polymer composite, Physica A 241, 296. Wu, J., and McLachlan, D.S. (1997) Percolation exponents and thresholds obtained from the nearly ideal continuum percolation system graphite/boron-nitride, Phys. Rev. B 56, 1236. Wu, J., and McLachlan, D.S. (1997) Percolation exponents and thresholds in two nearly ideal anisotropic continuum systems, Physica A 241, 360. Halperin, B.I., Feng, S., and Sen, P.N. (1985) Differences between lattice and continuum percolation transport exponents, Phys. Rev. Letters 54, 2391.
41
This page intentionally left blank
THE INTERMEDIATE PHASE AND SELF-ORGANIZATION IN NETWORK GLASSES
M.F. THORPE and M.V.CHUBYNSKY Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824
INTRODUCTION The study of the structure of covalent glasses has progressed steadily since the initial work of Zachariasen [1] in 1932 that introduced the idea of the Continuous Random Network (CRN). Zachariasen envisaged such networks maintaining local chemical order,
but by incorporating small structural distortions, having a topology that is non-crystalline. This seminal idea has met some opposition over the years from proponents of various microcrystalline models, but today is widely accepted, mainly as a result of careful diffraction experiments from which the radial distribution function can be determined. The CRN has been established as the basis for most modem discussions of covalent glasses, and this has occurred because of the interplay between diffraction experiments and model building. The early model building involved building networks with ~ 500 atoms from a seed with free boundaries in a roughly spherical shape [2]. Subsequent efforts have refined this approach and made it less subjective by using a computer to make the decisions and incorporating periodic boundary conditions. The best of these approaches was introduced by Wooten, Winer and Weaire [3] and consists of restructuring a crystalline lattice with a designated large unit supercell, until the supercell becomes amorphous. The large supercell contains typically ~5000 atoms. Both the hand built models and the Wooten, Winer and Weaire model are relaxed during the building process using a potential. The final structure is rather insensitive to the exact form of the potential and a Kirkwood [4] or Keating [5] potential is typically used. Despite this success in understanding the structure, some concerns remain. Perhaps the most serious of these is that the network cannot be truly random. Even though bulk glasses form at high temperatures where entropic effects are dominant, it is clearly not correct to completely ignore energy considerations that can favor particular local structural arrangements over others. A simple example of this is local chemical ordering, where, for example, bonding between certain same-type atoms is unfavorable. This can lead to chemical thresholds that appear at certain concentrations, at which unfavorable bonding can no longer be avoided. A more interesting and subtle effect of interest to us here is how the structure itself can incorporate non-random features in order to minimize the free
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
43
energy at the temperature of formation. Such subtle structural correlations, which we refer to as self-organization, will almost certainly not show up in diffraction experiments, but may have other manifestations, as discussed in the paper of P. Boolchand in this volume. Here we focus on the mechanical properties and critical mechanical thresholds, as this is where it is easiest to make theoretical progress at this time. How can such an idea be developed theoretically? A proper procedure might be to consider a very large supercell and use a first principles quantum approach, like that of Car and Parrinello [6], to form the glass. The problem with this is that the relaxation times at the appropriate temperatures are very large, so full equilibration is impossible. The structure thus obtained would be unreasonably strained. This situation is made worse as only small supercells with about 100 atoms can be used at present and in these the periodic boundary conditions produce unacceptably large internal strains. Using the fastest linearscaling electronic structure methods or even molecular dynamics with empirical potentials is still much too slow. We therefore need to look at other ways of generating selforganizing networks. One promising approach is that of Mousseau and Barkema [7] who explore the energy landscape of a glass by moving over saddle points. In network terms, this corresponds to selective (thus non-random) bond switching. In these lecture notes, we look at even more simplified approaches that show what kinds of effects self-organization, and the resulting non-randomness, can lead to. The layout of this paper is as follows. In the next section we review ideas of rigidity percolation that lead to a mechanical threshold in networks as the number of bonds per atom in them (related to the mean coordination number) changes. Then we describe our
model of self-organization of glassy networks, which has two thresholds instead of one and
thus exhibits an intermediate phase, and study the properties of this model. We also consider a similar model for random resistor networks, based on the analogy between the usual (connectivity) percolation and rigidity percolation. Throughout much of this paper we focus on both central force networks in two dimensions and bond-bending networks in three dimensions that have central and noncentral forces as these are more relevant to glasses. The reader should be aware that we do flip back and forth between these model systems, as appropriate, in order to illustrate various points.
RIGIDITY PERCOLATION Going back more than a century, Maxwell was intrigued with the conditions under which mechanical structures made out of struts, joined together at their ends, would be stable (or unstable) [8]. To determine the stability, without doing any detailed calculations (that would have been impossible then except for the simplest structures), Maxwell used the approximate method of constraint counting. The idea of a constraint in a mechanical system goes back to Lagrange [9] who used the concept of holonomic constraints to reduce the effective dimensionality of the space.
The problem under consideration is a static one – given a mechanical system, how many independent deformations are possible without any cost in energy? These are the zero frequency modes, which we prefer to refer to as floppy modes because in any real system there will usually be some weak restoring force associated with the motion. Sometimes it is convenient to look at the system as a dynamical one, and assign potentials or spring constants to deformations involving the various struts (bonds) and
angles. It does not matter whether these potentials are harmonic or not, as the displacements are virtual. However it is convenient to use harmonic potentials so that the system is linear. It is then possible to set up a Lagrangian for the system and hence define a dynamical matrix, which is a real symmetric matrix having real eigenvalues. These eigenvalues are either positive or zero. The number of finite (non-zero) eigenvalues defines 44
the rank of the matrix. Thus our counting problem is rigorously reduced to finding the rank of the dynamical matrix. The rank of a matrix is also the number of linearly independent rows or columns in the matrix. Neither of these definitions is of much practical help, and a
numerical determination of the rank of a large matrix is difficult and of course requires a particular realization of the network to be constructed in the computer. Nevertheless the rank is a useful notion as it defines the mathematical framework within which the problem is well posed.
The rigidity of a network glass is related to how amenable the glass is to continuous deformations that require very little cost in energy. A small energy cost will arise from weak forces, which are always present in addition to the hard covalent forces that involve bond lengths and bond angles. These small energies can be ignored because the degree to which the network deforms is well quantified by just the number of floppy modes [10] within the system. This picture of floppy and rigid regions within the network has led to the idea of rigidity percolation [11,12]. When new constraints are added to an initially floppy network and it crosses the rigidity percolation threshold, a single rigid region percolates through the network and it becomes stable against external straining (elastic moduli become non-zero). There are two important differences between rigidity and connectivity percolation. The first difference is that rigidity percolation is a vector (not a scalar) problem, and secondly, there is an inherent long-range aspect to rigidity percolation. These differences make the rigidity problem become successively more difficult as the dimensionality of the network increases. In two dimensions, Figure 1(a) shows four distinct rigid clusters consisting of two rigid bodies attached together by two rods connecting at pivot joints. Now the placement of one additional rod, as shown in Figure l(b), locks the previous four clusters into a single rigid cluster. This non-local character allows a single rod (or bond) on one end of the network to affect the rigidity all across the network from one side to the other.
Using concepts from graph theory, we have set up generic networks where the connectivity or topology is uniquely defined but the bond lengths and bond angles are
arbitrary. A generic network does not contain any geometric singularities [13], which occur when certain geometries lead to null projections of reaction forces. Null projections are caused by special symmetries, such as, the presence of parallel bonds or connected collinear bonds. Rather than these atypical cases, their generic counterparts as shown in Figures 1(b) and (c) will be present. This ensures that all infinitesimal floppy motions carry over to finite motions [13-15].
Figure 1. The shaded regions represent 2D rigid bodies. The (closed, open) circles denote pivot-joints that are members of (one, more than one) rigid body. (a) A floppy piece of network with four distinct rigid clusters. (b) Three generic cross links between two rigid bodies make the whole structure rigid. If the bonds were parallel, the structure would not be rigid to shear. (c) A set of three non-collinear connected rods connecting across a rigid body is generic and contains one internal floppy mode. If they were collinear (along
the dashed line), then there would be two infinitesimal (not finite) floppy motions, and under a horizontal compression buckling would occur.
By considering generic networks, the problematic geometric singularities are completely eliminated. Therefore, the problem of rigidity percolation on generic networks leads to many conceptual advantages because all geometrical properties are robust.
45
Moreover, real glass networks have local distortions, and are modeled better by generic networks.
Constraint Counting The genius of Maxwell [8] was to devise the simple constraint counting method that allows us to estimate the rank of the dynamical matrix and hence the number of floppy modes.
The number of floppy modes in d dimensions is given by the total number of degrees of freedom for N sites (equal to dN ) minus the number of independent constraints. A dependent (redundant) constraint does not change the number of floppy modes. It can only add additional reinforcement and it cannot be accommodated without changing the natural bond lengths and angles of the network, so stressed (over-constrained) regions would be created. A key quantity is the number of floppy modes, F , in the network, or normalized per degree of freedom, f = F/dN. By defining the total number of constraints per degree of freedom as nc and the number of redundant constraints per degree of freedom as nr , we can write quite generally,
It is straightforward to find the total number of constraints (and consequently nc) for each
given network. Neglecting redundant constraints [n r in Eq. (1)] as first done by Maxwell [8], we come to Maxwell counting:
Now the idea is to associate the rigidity percolation transition with the point where fM goes to zero. The Maxwell approximation gives a good account of the location of the phase transition and the number of floppy modes, but it ultimately fails, because some constraints are redundant and also because, as we will see soon, there are still some floppy pockets inside an overall rigid network. We now describe Maxwell counting for specific cases. Central Force Network in Two Dimensions. The elastic properties of random networks of Hooke springs have been studied over the past 15 years [11,16-20]. This system can be viewed as a network of Hooke springs in 2 dimensions, which is built from a regular (say, triangular) lattice, whose bonds are represented by springs, by removing the bonds at random, so each one is present with probability p (bond dilution). The site diluted version of the problem was also considered (see, e.g., [21]). For constraint counting it is convenient to introduce the mean coordination as an average number of bonds stemming from a site. It is given by where p is the probability of the bond being present, z is the coordination of the underlying regular lattice (6 for the triangular lattice, for example). If the total number of sites is N , the number of bonds is Each of these bonds represents one constraint, as always in central force networks, and therefore the number of constraints per degree of freedom is given by
46
Therefore, according to Eq. (2), Maxwell counting gives
This quantity goes to zero at
which we associate with the rigidity percolation transition. For the triangular lattice this corresponds to pc =2/3. Bond-Bending Glassy Networks in Three Dimensions. We start by examining a large covalent network that contains no dangling bonds or singly coordinated atoms. We can describe such a network by the chemical formula GexAsySe1–x–y , where the chemical element, Ge, stands for any fourfold bonded atom, As for any threefold bonded atom and Se for any twofold bonded atom. Each atom has its full complement of nearest neighbors and we consider the system in the thermodynamic limit, where the number of atoms There are no surfaces or voids and the chemical distribution of the elements is not
relevant, except that we assume there are no isolated pieces, like a ring of Se atoms. The total number of atoms is N and there are nr atoms with coordination r (r = 2, 3 or 4), then
and we can define the mean coordination
We note that (where ) gives a partial but very important description of the network. Indeed, when questions of connectivity are involved the average coordination is the key quantity. In covalent networks like GexAsySe1–x–y , the bond lengths and angles are well defined. Small displacements from the equilibrium structure can be described by a Kirkwood [4] or Keating [5] potential, which we can write schematically as
The mean bond length is l,
is the change in the bond length and is the change in the bond angle. The bond-bending force is essential to the constraint counting approach for stability, in addition to the bond stretching term The other terms in the potential are assumed to be much smaller and can be neglected at this stage. If floppy modes are present in the system, then these smaller terms in the potential will give the floppy modes a small finite frequency. For more details see Ref. [16]. If the modes already have a finite frequency, these extra small terms will produce a small, and rather uninteresting, shift in the frequency. This division into strong and weak forces is essential if the constraint counting approach is to be useful. It is for this reason that it is of little, if any, use in metals
47
and ionic solids. It is fortunate that this approach provides a very reasonable starting point in many covalent glasses.
To estimate the total number of zero-frequency modes, Maxwell counting was first applied by Thorpe [16], following the work of J.C. Phillips [22,23] on ideal coordinations for glass formation. It proceeds as follows. There are a total of 3N degrees of freedom. There is a single central-force constraint associated with each bond. We assign r/2 constraints associated with each r-coordinated atom. In addition there are constraints associated with the angular forces in Eq. (7). For a twofold coordinated atom there is a single angular constraint; for an r-fold coordinated atom there are a total of 2r–3 angular constraints. The total number of constraints is therefore
Using Eqs. (5) and (6), their fraction nc can be rewritten as
thus, according to Eq. (2),
Note that this result only depends upon the combination
which is the relevant
variable. When (e.g. Se chains), then fM = 1/3 ; that is, one third of all the modes are floppy. As atoms with higher coordination than two are added to the network as crosslinks, fM drops and goes to zero at and network goes through the rigidity percolation transition. This mean field approach has been quite successful in covalent glasses and helps explain a number of experiments. Also in later sections, we discuss the results of computer experiments and show that they are rather well described by the results of this subsection.
We note that Eq. (8) holds only when there are no 1-fold coordinated atoms. Their presence leads to the threshold being shifted down [24-26].
The Pebble Game
Until recently it has not been possible to improve on the approximate Maxwell constraint counting method, except on small systems with up to ~ 104 sites using brute force numerical methods. Now a powerful exact combinatorial algorithm, called the Pebble Game, has become available. This algorithm, first suggested by Hendrickson [13] and implemented by Jacobs and Thorpe [12,27,28], allows systems containing more than 106 sites to be analyzed in two-dimensional generic central-force networks and in threedimensional networks with both central forces and bond-bending forces. The crux of the Pebble Game algorithm in two dimensions is based on a theorem by Laman [14] from graph theory. We note first that if for a two dimensional network Maxwell counting gives less than 3 floppy modes (3 modes are always there, as they correspond to rigid motions of the network), the counting cannot be exact and thus a redundant bond (or bonds) are present. One says that the Laman condition for the network is violated in this case. But if the opposite is true (the Laman condition is satisfied), this is not sufficient for redundant bonds to be absent, as the network can have more than 3 floppy modes and redundant bonds simultaneously. The statement of the theorem is that non48
violation of the Laman condition for every subnetwork is sufficient for not having redundant bonds. This statement does not generalize to dimensions higher than two. We do not go into details of the algorithm, which can be found elsewhere [12,27,29]. For this consideration it is enough to know that one starts from an “empty” lattice (having no bonds, only sites) and adds bonds one at a time. Each newly added bond is tested for independence and each independent bond decreases the number of floppy modes by one. Besides providing exact constraint counting, the algorithm is able to identify all rigid
clusters (and thus whether or not rigidity percolation occurs) and find all the regions, in which redundant bonds introduced stress (over-constrained regions).
Figure 3. The topology of a typical section from a bond-diluted generic network at p = 0.62 (below percolation) and at p = 0.70 (above percolation). A particular realization would have local distortions (not shown), thus making the network generic. The heavy dark lines correspond to over-constrained regions. The open circles correspond to sites that are acting as pivots between two or more rigid bodies.
Sections of a large network on the bond-diluted generic triangular lattice are shown in Figure 2 after the pebble game was applied. Below the transition the network can be macroscopically deformed as the floppy region percolates across the sample. Above the rigidity transition, stress will propagate across the sample. However, below the transition there are clearly pockets of large rigid clusters and over-constrained regions, while above the transition there are pockets of floppy inclusions within the network. While Laman’s theorem does not generally apply to three dimensions, it is possible to generalize the Pebble Game algorithm for a particular class of networks, namely, the bondbending networks with angular forces included as in a Kirkwood or Keating potential [Eq. (7)]. Fortunately, the bond-bending model is precisely the class of models that is applicable to the study of many covalent glass networks. A longer discussion of the three dimensional Pebble Game is given in Refs. [28,30].
Two Dimensional Central Force Network. In this subsection, we review some results for central-force generic rigidity percolation on the triangular net. A more detailed account can be found in Ref. [27]. We begin by finding the number of floppy modes and comparing it to the Maxwell counting result. The exact value of f is very close to fM far enough below the mean-field estimate for the rigidity transition
but then starts to deviate significantly and does not reach zero (until full coordination, is reached). The quantity f looks quite smooth, but the second derivative of it with respect to (shown in the insert) does in fact have a singularity. This singularity corresponds to the rigidity percolation threshold, as can be checked by detecting the percolating rigid cluster directly. Using finite-size
49
scaling, the position of the transition was found to be This is amazingly close to the mean-field value of 4. The behavior of the second derivative suggests that the number of floppy modes is an analogous quantity for rigidity and connectivity percolation. In the case of connectivity percolation, the number of floppy modes is simply equal to the total number of clusters, which corresponds to the free energy [16,31-33]. It would be nice if a similar result holds for rigidity percolation. It turns out that the second derivative of the total number of clusters changes sign across the transition, thus violating convexity requirements. Noting that typically rigid clusters are not disconnected, it was suggested that the number of floppy modes generalizes as an appropriate free energy [16,31-33]. With this assumption, the exponent is estimated in the usual context of a heat capacity critical exponent, even though no temperature is involved here. Again analogously to connectivity percolation, the fraction of bonds in the percolating rigid cluster serves as the order parameter for this system. The critical exponent is
defined as the rigid cluster size critical exponent. Another order parameter is also possible, namely, the fraction of bonds in the percolating stressed cluster, which is defined as a percolating stressed subset of the percolating rigid cluster. It was found (and this is an important point) that both and go to zero at the same point – the percolation transition. This will be different in the next chapter on self-organization and will lead to the existence of the intermediate phase, and two phase transitions. The results of study of this model [27] lead to the conclusion that the rigidity transition in this system is second order, but in a different universality class than connectivity percolation. It has been suggested by Duxbury and co-workers [21] that the rigidity transition might be weakly first order on triangular networks. While we think this is unlikely, it
cannot be completely ruled out at the present time. Three Dimensional Bond Bending Networks. It can be shown [28] that the only floppy element in a three dimensional bond-bending network is a hinge joint. Hinge joints can only occur through a central-force (CF) bond and are always shared by two rigid clusters – allowing one degree of freedom of rotation through a dihedral angle. Note that in two dimensional central force generic networks, sites that belong to more than one cluster act as a pivot joint, and more than two rigid clusters can share a pivot joint. Because of this difference between CF and bond-bending networks, the order parameters analogous to and of the previous subsection, have to be defined as a fraction of sites in respective percolating clusters and not bonds, as bonds can be shared between a percolating and a non-percolating clusters. For purposes of testing rigidity in generic three-dimensional bond-bending networks, it is only necessary to specify the network topology or connectivity of the CF bonds, since the second nearest neighbors via CF bonds define the associated bond-bending constraints. Here, we have considered two test models. In the first model, a unit cell is defined from our realistic computer generated network of amorphous silicon [34] consisting of 4,096 atoms having periodic boundary conditions. Larger completely four-coordinated periodic networks containing 32,768, 262,144 and 884,736 atoms are then constructed from the amorphous 4,096-atom unit cell. The four-coordinated network is randomly diluted by removing CF bonds one at a
time with the constraint that no site can be less than two-coordinated. That is, a CF bond is randomly selected to be removed. If upon removal either of its incident atoms becomes less than two coordinated, then it is not removed and another CF bond is randomly selected from the remaining pool of possibilities. The order of removing CF bonds is recorded. This process is carried out until all remaining CF bonds cannot be removed, leading to as low an
50
average coordination number as possible. All CF bonds that were successfully removed are marked. This method of bond dilution gives a simple prescription for generating a very large model of a continuous random GexAsySe1-x-y type of network. For comparison, a second test model, a diamond lattice, was diluted in the same way and contained 32,768, 262,144 and 106 atoms. The results of simulations of both models are qualitatively similar to those for 2D central-force networks. Both have a rigidity transition slightly below the Maxwell counting estimate of 2.4. Again, the rigidity transition can be accurately found from the sharp peak in the second derivative of the fraction of floppy modes. In particular, for the diamond lattice and for a-Si, Remarkably, the Maxwell counting estimate is accurate to about 1% in locating the threshold in both cases. A more detailed account of the results can be found in Ref. [35]. SELF-ORGANIZATION AND INTERMEDIATE PHASE Self-Organization in Rigidity Percolation
Description of the Model. We have mentioned that starting from an “empty” lattice
(without bonds) and adding one bond at a time, we can use the pebble game to analyze whether the bond we are adding is independent of those already in the network or redundant. We also know that redundant bonds create stressed (over-constrained) regions. Thus within the present approach we have a rather unique opportunity to construct stressfree networks without a huge computational overhead. The idea is to start, as before, from an “empty” lattice and add one bond at a time to it, applying the pebble game at each stage. If adding a trial bond would result in that bond being redundant and hence create a stressed region, then that move is abandoned. Thus the network self-organizes in such a way that there is no stress in it at all. Note that the pebble game now serves not only as a tool to analyze the network, as before, but also as a decision-making mechanism when building the network. It is not possible to keep adding bonds beyond a certain point, without introducing stress (this is considered in more detail below). How should we proceed then? While going on with some sort of self-organization would be reasonable (as some bonds would create less stress than others), it is impossible to analyze this within our model, so we start inserting bonds completely at random, once avoiding stress becomes impossible. General Properties. First of all, how long is it possible to keep adding bonds to a network without introducing stress? It is certainly impossible to have more independent constraints then there are degrees of freedom in the network. Now recall that in the Maxwell counting approximation, the rigidity transition occurs when the numbers of constraints and of degrees of freedom balance. Thus it is certainly not possible to have an unstressed network with the mean coordination above where Maxwell counting predicts the transition (that is, above for central-force networks in 2d and for glassy networks in 3d). This provides an upper limit (still not always reachable, as we will see) for the unstressed networks. Note, though, that since the Maxwell counting percolation limit is not exact, this does not mean that rigid networks are necessarily stressed! The actual rigidity transition may occur below the point where Maxwell counting puts it. This is a very important point that leads to possibility of an intermediate phase, as described below. Secondly, we know that the Maxwell counting result for the number of floppy modes would be exact if all constraints in the network were independent. But this is exactly what we have in our case! Thus the number of floppy modes in Maxwell counting is exact for as
51
long as we are able to keep the network unstressed. Hence we follow the Maxwell result for the number of floppy modes in the floppy and intermediate phases. We now analyze some specific cases in more detail. Intermediate Phase in 2D Central-Force Networks. Let us first prove that it is indeed possible to reach the Maxwell counting limit without any stress in this case (and for any CF networks), provided that the fully coordinated (undiluted) network has no floppy modes (which is the case for triangular networks). As we have seen before, generally speaking, we should distinguish carefully between constraints and bonds. A constraint can be thought of as one algebraic relation for the coordinates of atoms; stress appears whenever one or more of such relations are not satisfied. A bond can have several associated constraints, as in bond-bending networks. In the case of CF networks, though, each bond has only one associated constraint (the distance between the sites it connects), so “bonds” and “constraints” are identical. Recall once again that every single constraint can be either independent (in which case it reduces the number of floppy modes of the network
by 1), or redundant (so it does not change the number of floppy modes). At the point where stress becomes inevitable any trial bond would cause stress (be redundant). So all the bonds, which will be subsequently inserted, are redundant. Thus f will remain constant up to the very end (which is the full lattice), therefore f = 0 at this point. Since Maxwell counting is still exact there, the proof is complete. We would like to emphasize that equivalence of “bonds” and “constraints” was essential for this proof (we used these terms
interchangeably). See the next subsection for comparison. Secondly, it is possible to establish a relation between the self-organized networks and those obtained by usual completely random insertion (to which we for simplicity refer as “random” in contrast to “self-organized” in what follows). Indeed, assume we are using the same random list of M bonds to build a random network and a self-organized one, trying to insert bonds as they are listed. For the random network, all the M bonds will get in; for the self-organized network, some of them will be, generally speaking, rejected, so that will be inserted. The bonds rejected in the self-organized network will be redundant in the random one; they do not influence the number of floppy modes, the configuration of rigid clusters (and thus whether or not rigidity percolation occurs) and the redundancy or independence of all the subsequently inserted bonds. Thus all these characteristics will be identical for the two networks. The consequence is that there is a
correspondence between self-organized and random networks having the same number of floppy modes; in particular, rigidity percolation occurs at the same number of floppy modes. This analysis allows us to make a very important conclusion. Since in random networks rigidity percolates at a non-zero f and the same has to be true for self-organized networks (because of the just mentioned consequence), yet stress appears exactly at f = 0, we conclude that there exists an intermediate phase, which is rigid (i.e. the infinite rigid cluster exists), but unstressed (so, evidently, there is no stress percolation). This is different from the situation with random insertion, where the rigidity and stress percolation thresholds always coincide (see Figure 3). It could be possible that stress does not percolate immediately after it is introduced; we will see from simulation results that this is not the case, so the upper boundary of the intermediate phase (the stress transition) may be defined as either the point where stress first appears, or equivalently, the point where it percolates. As is seen from our consideration, it lies at As we have mentioned, the fractions of bonds in percolating rigid and stressed clusters (denoted and respectively) can serve as order parameters. Now, since there is an intermediate phase where rigidity percolates, while stress does not, these two parameters 52
turn zero at different points, between which the intermediate phase lies. Besides, since the number of floppy modes is zero above the stress transition, the whole network is rigid, and thus is identically 1. These facts are illustrated in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Order parameters and for self-organized and random triangular networks. It is seen that the intermediate phase (shaded) is formed in the self-organized case, extending from 3.905 to 4, while in the random case the two thresholds coincide and there is no intermediate phase. All results are averages over two realizations on 400×400 networks.
Given the discussion of the floppy modes in the random and self-organized networks, it is tempting to suggest that the same relation holds for the just defined rigidity order
parameter. The subtlety is that the relation is defined in terms of sites (i.e., same sites are in the percolating cluster and same sites are pivot joints on its border), while the order parameter is defined in terms of bonds. Of course, there is no direct correspondence between bonds, as there are different numbers of bonds in related random and selforganized networks. Still it might be safely assumed that the rigid cluster size critical exponents are the same for rigidity percolation in random and self-organized networks. Other critical exponents may be different, though. It is interesting to note that since f given by Maxwell counting is exact in the whole unstressed region, in both the floppy and the intermediate phase f is a perfect straight line and the rigidity transition does not show up in f .
Results of our simulations of this model are shown in Figures 3 and 4. The simulations were done for networks with periodic boundary conditions in both directions. There are several facts to be inferred (besides confirming all the results we have obtained
so far). We see that stress percolates immediately after it appears at (this fact was mentioned above). Second, the cluster size critical exponent for the stressed cluster is quite small (smaller than the one for the rigid cluster). In random networks, the stressed cluster exponent is larger than the rigid cluster exponent, which is because the stressed percolating cluster is smaller than the rigid cluster (the former being a subset of the latter) and the two thresholds coincide.
53
Figure 4. Number of floppy modes per degree of freedom for self-organized and random triangular networks. Thresholds are shown with different symbols. The intermediate phase in the self-organized case is shaded. Note that rigidity percolation occurs at the same f in the random and self-organized cases. The self-
organized plot is strictly linear up to
and coincides with Maxwell counting.
Intermediate Phase in 3D Bond-Bending Networks. In case of glassy networks there is a slight problem with implementing our general algorithm of self-organization. In the CF case we were starting from an empty lattice to ensure that it had no stress initially. In the present case the initial dilution can only go as far as to the point where any further dilution would create a 1-coordinated site. At this limit there are no bonds with both ends being sites of coordination 3 and higher, so that further dilution is impossible. It is
generally not true that this final network is unstressed. For smaller networks (~104 sites and less), it is possible to pick those that are unstressed; for larger ones such cases are rare, and it is reasonable to assume that the fraction of constraints that are redundant is a constant in the thermodynamic limit. This constant seems to be very low, though (in our simulations, typically about 0.05% of constraints were redundant). Besides, the number of redundant constraints does not grow when new bonds are inserted according to our algorithm (up to the stress transition), so this problem is largely irrelevant. Unlike the case of CF networks, BB networks have more than one constraint associated with each bond. When a new bond is added, not only the distance between the sites it connects is fixed, but the angles between the new bond and those stemming out of the two sites at either end of that bond are fixed as well. Any bond that has at least one redundant constraint associated with it would cause stress. Some of the stress-causing bonds have only part of the associated constraints redundant and the rest independent, and such a bond will change the number of floppy modes. This makes some of our conclusions made for CF networks invalid in this case. Firstly, this invalidates the proof of the reachability of the Maxwell counting limit ( in this case). This is because even when at the upper reachable limit all the as yet uninserted bonds would cause stress, some of these bonds may further decrease the number of floppy modes and thus this number is not necessarily zero at this point.
Secondly, the nice relation between random and self-organized networks no longer holds, because out of the redundant bonds by which the two differ, some (namely, the partially redundant ones) change f , rigidifying the network and changing the 54
configuration of rigid clusters. Still the equality of critical exponents for rigid cluster sizes in random and self-organized cases probably holds. At the same time, some facts are unchanged. In particular, f given by Maxwell counting is still exact in the unstressed region. Most importantly, the intermediate phase still exists. The results of simulations done for the diluted diamond lattice are given in Figures 5 and 6. As in the previous subsection, we use periodic boundary conditions in all directions. We note in addition to the graphs that, as in the CF case, stress percolates immediately
after it appears. The intermediate phase extends from to 2.392 (not reaching 2.4). Again, the stress transition is sharper than the rigidity transition. Our results are consistent with the second order transition with the very small critical exponent or a first order transition is more likely. Another feature of the plot in Fig. 5 is that the rigidity order parameter is not exactly unity in the stressed phase (which is expected, as some floppy modes remain in the stressed phase) and the second transition shows up as a kink in the rigidity order parameter. In conclusion to this section, we would like to mention that it is possible within our approach to establish a hierarchy of stress-causing bonds (by the number of associated
redundant constraints) and when stress becomes inevitable, first put those having one redundant constraint, then those having two, and so on. Exactly at only those bonds having no associated independent constraints will remain uninserted. It is unlikely, though, that there is a good correlation between the number of redundant constraints and the actual increase in stress energy, as the distribution of stresses caused by different bonds is quite wide, so this complication seems unreasonable.
Figure 5. The order parameters and for the self-organized diluted diamond lattice. The intermediate phase is shaded. Circles are average over 4 networks with 64,000 sites, triangles are averages over 5 networks with 125,000 sites. The dashed lines are the power law fit below the stress transition and for guidance of the eye above. Note the break in the slope at the stress transition.
Elastic Properties of Self-Organized Networks. So far our study of self-organized networks was limited to their geometrical properties. Of course, this work becomes really meaningful when we turn to what the physical consequences of self-organization are. The simplest quantity to look at is the elasticity of the networks of springs. Unfortunately, the 55
pebble game, being concerned with the geometric properties only, is unable to help us find the numerical values of elastic constants, so we have to do a usual relaxation using, for
example, the conjugate gradient method [36] and consider particular configurations, and not just the connectivity. So far in this preliminary study, we have only considered the 2d case. The first and quite surprising fact is that in case of periodic boundary conditions in all directions the elastic constants are exactly zero in the intermediate phase, regardless of the
size of the supercell and despite the existence of the percolating rigid cluster. Indeed, periodic boundary conditions mean that positions of images of same site in different supercells are fixed with respect to each other. The network is built stressless with these additional constraints taken into account. The exact specification of these constraints beyond stating what sites are involved is determined by the particular size and shape of the supercell, but is never taken into account (just as particular bond lengths never matter in determination of stressed regions). So straining the network by changing this size and shape leaves it stressless. The important thing here is that straining does not add any new
constraints. We confirmed this result numerically by doing exact diagonalization of the dynamical matrix (similar to [37]), rather than by relaxation, which ensures better precision.
Figure 6. The fractions of floppy modes per degree of freedom for the diluted diamond lattice (both selforganized and random cases). Different thresholds and the Maxwell prediction for the rigidity threshold are shown with different symbols. The intermediate phase in the self-organized case is shaded. The Maxwell
counting line is seen only above the stress transition point in self-organized networks, as below this point it coincides with the self-organized line.Note that the rigidity transition in the two cases no more occurs at the same f . Instead, the values of are close, which is probably coincidental.
Of course, for different boundary conditions the elastic constants may be non-zero for finite samples, but are expected to vanish in the thermodynamic limit. We consider the busbar geometry, in which busbars are applied to two opposite sides of the network and it is strained perpendicular to the busbars. The network is built assuming open boundaries at the busbars and periodic boundary conditions parallel to the busbars. The first and the last rows of sites are assumed belonging to the respective busbar (i.e., attached rigidly to it). In addition, when building the network, we consider the sites belonging to each busbar as being fixed with respect to each other, connecting them with fictitious bonds and considering these bonds as belonging to the network. This makes the open boundaries “less open” and eliminates certain boundary effects, as will be clear from an analogy in the next 56
section with connectivity percolation. The arguments of the previous paragraph do not apply here, as the network is built not assuming a fixed distance between the busbars (as if it is allowed to relax) and straining changes and fixes it thus imposing an additional constraint.
Figure 7. An example of the triangular self-organized network 150×150 in the intermediate phase (at ). The thickest bonds belong to the applied-stress backbone, those of medium thickness are in the percolating rigid cluster (but not in the backbone), the thinnest ones are not in the percolating cluster. The busbars are shown schematically.
When introducing the boundary conditions as described above, we will have non-zero stress when an external strain is applied, and some of the bonds will be stressed. These bonds are said to belong to the applied stress backbone [21] (which we refer to as simply backbone in what follows). It can be found easily by the pebble game using a method proposed by Moukarzel [38], which in our case consists in putting an additional bond across the network emulating the external strain, and finding those bonds in which stress is induced. A typical result is shown in Figure 7. It is seen that the backbone has filamentary structure. We note that stress in this backbone was created by putting just one extra bond and thus it is enough to take any one bond out of the backbone for it to be destroyed, so it is extremely fragile. Also, since the backbone always has only one redundant bond (when the bond across is added), it does not grow throughout the intermediate phase after it appears at the rigidity transition, because growth can only occur by adding new redundant bonds. This means that for any given sample the elastic constants are the same throughout the intermediate phase (here we mean finite samples, of course, as in the infinite limit the elastic constants are zero).
57
Figure 8. The elastic modulus c11 for self-organized triangular networks. Each point corresponds to one sample (their linear sizes are specified by different symbols). The intermediate phase is shaded. The dashed line is the mean-field linear dependence, reaching 1 at the full coordination.
We found the elastic modulus c11 numerically in both the intermediate and stressed
phases. The triangular lattice was distorted by random displacement of atoms. For displacements along each axis uniform distribution on an interval (–0.1; 0.1) in units of the lattice constant was chosen, but the results are only slightly sensitive to the width of the distribution. Equilibrium lengths of springs were chosen equal to the distance between the atoms they connect, so the initial network is unstressed. Thus subtraction of two large energies when finding elastic constants is avoided. The results are shown in Fig. 8. Predetermining the applied stress backbone speeds up the relaxation greatly, as was first pointed out in Ref. [21]. Still, we were unable to reach full relaxation in the intermediate phase in all but the smallest samples (up to 30×30). The values in the intermediate phase are very low and are assumed to go to zero in the limit of large samples. We are currently doing finite size scaling to test this. Above the stress transition, the modulus seems to grow linearly, but, of course, it is hopeless to try and determine the critical exponent with reasonable precision from our data. Self-Organization in Connectivity Percolation
The model. It is interesting and useful to see if similar phenomena are possible in the more familiar case of connectivity percolation, especially as connectivity percolation is easier to study and understand. The essence of our algorithm of building self-organized networks in the rigidity case is rejecting stress-causing bonds (or those having redundant constraints). As we have seen, in the CF case, when “bonds” and “constraints” are the same, we may equivalently formulate this as rejecting redundant or irrelevant bonds. In bond connectivity percolation we also can build the networks by inserting bonds one by one; most importantly, there is a clear analog to redundant bonds. The relevant property now is connectivity, by which we mean the presence or absence of paths connecting any two sites of the network. Redundant bonds are those which connect sites already connected, that is would close a loop in the network. Thus the analog of self-organization is building loopless networks. There are other equivalent ways to draw this parallel. The first is based on the fact that connectivity percolation can be considered as rigidity percolation with the sites having one
58
degree of freedom regardless of the lattice dimensionality. Each site thus has one coordinate and each bond is a relation between the coordinates of the sites it connects. Then the concepts of rigid clusters and clusters in the usual connectivity sense coincide. The number of floppy modes f is now the number of clusters. A redundant bond in the rigidity sense is the one that does not change f, it is also stress-causing, as it would introduce a relation between coordinates that cannot generally be satisfied. On the other hand, viewed from the connectivity perspective, such a bond connects the sites belonging
to the same cluster and closing a loop, and our model is again recovered. Yet another way is to recall that rigidity percolation with angular constraints in 2D (or with angular and dihedral constraints in 3D) is equivalent to connectivity percolation. Then stresslessness is equivalent to looplessness. Connectivity percolation and related phenomena were studied so extensively in all imaginable flavors that it would be strange if this and similar models were not studied before. Indeed exactly this model was proposed as far back as 1979 [39] and rediscovered in 1996 [40]. Besides, there was an extensive study of loopless graphs (trees) in relation to various phenomena ranging from resistance of a network between two point contacts (considered by Kirchhoff in mid nineteenth century [41]) to river networks [42] to certain optimization problems [43,44]. In many of these and other papers the algorithm for building trees was equivalent to ours. Still, we consider this model from a different perspective. Given that connectivity percolation can be considered as rigidity percolation with one degree of freedom per site, we can apply the usual two-dimensional pebble game with the simple modifications. Of course, the essence of our self-organization algorithm is still the rejection of bonds that are not independent. The pebble game allows the determination of all analogs of the quantities considered for rigidity. The Intermediate Phase. In this section we carry out the same kind of analysis as was done for rigidity percolation.
First of all we describe Maxwell counting, as this, although simple, is rarely discussed in relation to connectivity percolation. For a network with N sites the number of degrees of freedom is now simply N, the number of constraints is, as before, so the number of floppy modes per site is and this becomes zero at Since, as we have seen, connectivity percolation is nothing but a kind of rigidity
percolation on a CF network with 1 degree of freedom per site, all of the general analysis for CF networks in the previous section is valid. Specifically, Maxwell counting is exact in the “unstressed” (this now means loopless) phase; the limit is reachable without creating loops; the relation between random and self-organized networks also holds. The order parameters are defined analogously to the rigidity case. The first parameter is (by analogy) the size of the percolating (connectivity) cluster. However, the difference is that now the clusters (including the percolating one) can be defined in terms of either bonds or sites (there are no “pivot joints” that would be shared between several clusters). Therefore, there is a possibility to define this order parameter as the fraction of sites (instead of bonds) in the percolating cluster. This makes the relation between the order parameters of self-organized and random networks with the same number of “floppy modes” (clusters) exact. Yet, to be consistent, we ignore this possibility and define the order parameters as fractions of bonds, not sites. The second order parameter is, logically, the fraction of “stressed” bonds (bonds in loops). We do not show the results of simulations (which were done for the square lattice) as they are very similar to those in rigidity case, except that the “stressed” cluster critical exponent is larger, not smaller than the connected cluster exponent. Existence of the
59
intermediate phase is confirmed in the range from to 2 for the square net. The lower transition coincides with the result obtained in Ref. [40]. Conductivity. Similarly to the elasticity case, we consider the busbar geometry here in two variants, with and without fictitious bonds making sites at the busbars rigid with respect to each other (we refer to these two cases as boundary conditions A and B respectively). As in rigidity, it is possible to find the conductivity backbone by Moukarzel’s method [38] (for B all the fictitious busbar bonds have to be put prior to placing the bond across, while they are already in the network in case A). Two examples corresponding to A and B are shown in Fig. 9. For A the backbone consists of just one path, while for B it is tree-like with branching near the busbars. Analog of these “boundary effects” in B is what was eliminated in study of elasticity, when the boundary conditions
analogous to A were chosen. The simulations for conductivity in 2D can be done very efficiently with the FrankLobb algorithm [45], whose only limitation is that it is applicable for the open boundary conditions only.
Figure 9. Examples of self-organized square networks in the intermediate phase with boundary conditions A (left panel) and B (right panel), as described in the text. The thickest bonds are in the conducting backbone,
those of medium thickness are in the percolating cluster (but not in the backbone), the thinnest are not in the percolating cluster. The busbars are shown schematically.
It is known from work on a river network model built in the same way as our network [42] that the backbone branches (in fact, all network branches) are fractal and the fractal dimension is
The only essential difference between the river network model and
our one is that they consider spanning trees (i.e., all sites are in the connecting cluster), which in our case corresponds only to This should not matter, though, since it is the dimensionality of the network that the cluster actually spans (i.e., of the connecting
cluster) that is important and this dimensionality is 2 everywhere in the intermediate phase. Thus we come to a conclusion that the fractal dimension of backbone branches is the same throughout the intermediate phase and equals 1.22. We confirm this fact in our simulations. We note that this differs from both the random walk result (d = 2) and that for selfavoiding random walks (d = 4/3) – in our case branches are more “straight” than both of these walks. Then for boundary conditions A it is obvious that the fraction of bonds in the backbone is and the conductance is Our simulations confirm this result, for both variants of boundary conditions. The effective conductivity in 2D is
equal to the conductance. Thus we come to the conclusion that the conductivity does indeed go to zero in the thermodynamic limit for the intermediate phase.
60
The results in both the intermediate and the stressed phase are shown in Fig. 10. Just as for elastic constants, the dependence in the stressed phase is linear, but now much larger sizes are available, so this linearity may be exact, but we know of no reason for this to be so. Note the finite value of the conductivity in the intermediate phase, which is a finite size effect. This value would be constant for boundary conditions A, as the conducting backbone consists of just one stem not changing across the intermediate phase. Here this value changes slightly across the intermediate phase. We mention here briefly that our preliminary results in 3 dimensions show that the conductivity is also zero in the thermodynamic limit in the intermediate phase, and it goes to zero with increasing size even faster than in two dimensions.
Figure 10. Conductivity for resistor networks with present bonds having resistance R1 = 1 and missing having resistance
(diamonds); superconducting networks (R 1 = 0, R2 = 200, circles); mixed
networks (R1 = 1, R2 = 200, triangles). All results are averages over 10 square networks 100×100 with open boundary conditions parallel to the busbars, the busbar sites are treated as in case B (see text).
Superconducting Networks. We have seen that in the thermodynamic limit the
conductivity is zero in both the disconnected and intermediate phases (just as elastic constants were zero in both the floppy and intermediate phases in the rigidity case). These results make us wonder if the lower transition shows up in any physical quantities for infinite networks. One possibility is to consider superconductor networks instead of resistor networks. In this model all the existing bonds are replaced with conductors of zero resistance (“superconductors”), while all the absent bonds are equal resistors with finite resistance. It turns out that the same kind of correspondence between random and self-organized networks with the same f we had for clusters is valid for the conductance in this case. Indeed, these networks differ by redundant bonds that connect sites already connected. All the connected sites have zero potential difference (as they are connected with superconductors), so putting redundant bonds does not change the distribution of the potential and thus does not influence the conductance. It is known [46] that in the random case the resistivity is zero above the threshold and non-zero below it, with the critical exponent the same as for the conductivity of resistor networks (1.30). Thus in the self-organized case the resistivity will turn zero in the point related to the percolation threshold of random networks by the above relation, i.e., at the 61
lower transition. The critical exponent will be the same as in the random case (1.30), but this is now different from the value for of resistor networks Mixture of Two Sorts of Resistors. We can now “combine” the resistor and superconductor models by introducing two sorts of resistors, with resistances R1 and R2, R1 < R2, and putting R1 resistors in place of present bonds and R2 resistors in place of missing bonds. Assume now that R1 << R2. Below the lower transition there are no lower resistance percolating paths, thus essentially all the potential drop is on the higherresistance bonds connecting lower-resistance clusters. This means the potential is almost constant within these clusters, and they may be considered as consisting of superconducting bonds. Thus we will have a smeared near-singularity in the conductivity at the lower transition. There will be a monotonic rise in conductivity throughout the intermediate phase, but it will remain low, as the low-resistance filaments are irrelevant by themselves in the thermodynamic limit. Above the second transition the low-resistance backbone by itself gives finite conductivity, so the high-resistance part of the network is irrelevant. Unlike the first transition, the second one is sharp, which is an artifact of change in the bond-insertion algorithm. Figure 14 shows the result for this model for R2/R1 = 200. Stability
We have already mentioned the extreme fragility of the backbone and thus of the very fact of percolation in the intermediate phase: removal of a single bond from it can destroy it. In fact, if at some point in the intermediate phase we start removing bonds at random, then since there are more than O(l) bonds in the backbone, percolation will be destroyed immediately. But maybe upon insertion of bonds it is re-created as easily? We can ask a more proper question. Namely, our networks turn out to be strongly biased [47]: at any given not all networks satisfying the condition of stresslessness are equiprobable. What if we build the networks, which are truly random with the only constraint of stresslessness? This question was studied for connectivity by variety of methods [47-49], and, formulating the result in our terms, regrettably, the intermediate phase is destroyed. We did not study this question in rigidity case yet, but it is clearly important and more work needs to be done on this issue. SUMMARY We have discussed the rigidity of random and self-organized networks. We find that there is a single transition from floppy to rigid in random networks, but an intermediate phase intervenes in the self-organized networks. This intermediate phase is rigid but contains no redundant bonds and so is stress-free. Some of this work, in the form of more extensive lecture notes has been presented at a NATO-ASI in Czech Republic in the summer of 2000, and will appear in the NATO-ASI
series. We should like to thank D.J. Jacobs for his many contributions to the “pebble game” algorithm and to the US National Science Foundation for support under grant numbers DMR-0078361 and CHE-9903706.
62
REFERENCES 1. 2.
Zachariasen, W.H. (1932) The atomic arrangement in glass, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 54, 3841-3851. Polk, D.E. (1971) Structural model for amorphous silicon and germanium, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 5, 365376.
3.
Wooten, F., Winer, K., Weaire, D. (1985) Computer generation of structural models of amorphous Si and Ge, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54, 1392-1395. Kirkwood, J.G. (1939) Skeletal modes of vibration of long-chain molecules, J. Chem. Phys. 7, 506509. Keating, P.N. (1966) Theory of the third-order elastic constants of diamond-like crystals, Phys. Rev. 145, 674-678. Car, R. and Parrinello, M. (1985) Unified approach for molecular dynamics and density functional theory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 55, 2471-2474. Mousseau, N. and Barkema, G.T. (1998) Traveling through potential energy landscapes of disordered materials: The activation-relaxation technique, Phys. Rev. E57, 2419-2424; Barkema, G.T. and Mousseau, N. (1996) Event-based relaxation of continuous disordered systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 4358-4361. Maxwell, J.C. (1864) On the calculation of the equilibrium and stiffness of frames, Philos. Mag. 27, 294-299.
4. 5. 6. 7.
8. 9. 10.
Lagrange, J.L. (1788) Mécanique Analytique, Desaint, Paris. Guyon, E., Roux, S., Hansen, A., Bideau, D., Trodec, J.-P. and Crapo, H. (1990) Nonlocal and
nonlinear problems in the mechanics of disordered systems – application to granular media and rigidity problems, Rep. Progr. Phys. 53, 373-419.
11.
12.
13. 14.
Feng, S. and Sen, P. (1984) Percolation on elastic networks – new exponent and threshold, Phys. Rev. Lett. 52, 216-219. Jacobs, D.J. and Thorpe, M.F. (1995) Generic rigidity percolation: the pebble game, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 4051-4054. Hendrickson, B. (1992) Conditions for unique graph realizations, SIAM J. Comput. 21, 65-84 and private communications. Laman, G. (1970) On graphs and rigidity of plane skeletal structures, J. Engrg. Math. 4, 331-340.
15.
Lovasz, L. and Yemini, Y. (1982) On generic rigidity in the plane, SIAM J. Alg. Disc. Meth. 3, 91-98.
16.
Thorpe, M.F. (1983) Continuous deformations in random networks, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 57, 355-370.
17. 18.
Cai, Y. and Thorpe, M.F. (1989) Floppy modes in network glasses, Phys. Rev. B40, 10535-10542. Feng, S., Thorpe, M.F. and Garboczi, E.J. (1985) Effective-medium theory of percolation on centralforce elastic networks, Phys. Rev. B31, 276-280.
19.
20.
Day, A.R., Tremblay, R.R. and Tremblay, A.-M.S. (1986) Rigid backbone: A new geometry for percolation, Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 2501-2504. He, H. and Thorpe, M.F. (1985) Elastic properties of glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54, 2107-2110.
21.
Moukarzel, C. and Duxbury, P.M. (1995) Stressed backbone and elasticity of random central-force
22.
Phillips, J.C. (1979) Topology of covalent non-crystalline solids. 1. Short-range order in chalcogenide alloys, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 34, 153-181. Phillips, J.C. (1981) Topology of covalent non-crystalline solids. 2. Medium-range order in chalcogenide alloys and a-Si(Ge), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 43, 37-77. Boolchand, P. and Thorpe, M.F. (1994) Glass-forming tendency, percolation of rigidity, and onefoldcoordinated atoms in covalent networks, Phys. Rev. B50, 10366-10368. Boolchand, P., Zhang, M. and Goodman, B. (1996) Influence of one-fold-coordinated atoms on mechanical properties of covalent networks, Phys. Rev. B53, 11488-11494. Döhler, G.H., Dandoloff, R. and Bilz, H. (1981) A topological-dynamical model of amorphycity, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 42, 87-96. Jacobs, D.J. and Thorpe, M.F. (1996) Generic rigidity percolation in two dimensions, Phys. Rev. E53, 3682-3693. Jacobs, D.J. (1998) Generic rigidity in three-dimensional bond-bending networks, J. Phys. A.: Math. Gen. 31, 6653-6668. Jacobs, D.J., Hendrickson, B. (1997) An algorithm for two-dimensional rigidity percolation: The pebble game, J. Comput. Phys. 137, 346-365. Jacobs, D.J., Kuhn, L.A. and Thorpe, M.F. (1999) Flexible and rigid regions in proteins, in M.F. Thorpe and P.M. Duxbury (eds.), Rigidity Theory and Applications, Kluwer Academic / Plenum Publishers, New York, pp. 357-384. Fortuin, C.M. and Kasteleyn, P.W. (1972) On the random-cluster model. 1. Introduction and relation to other models, Physica 57, 536-564; Kasteleyn, P.W. and Fortuin, C.M. (1969) Phase transitions in lattice systems with random local properties, J. Phys. Soc. Japan 26 sup, 11-14. Essam, J.W. (1980) Percolation theory, Rep. Prog. Phys. 43, 833-912.
systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 4055-4058.
23. 24. 25. 26.
27.
28. 29.
30. 31.
32.
63
33. 34.
Duxbury, P.M., Jacobs, D.J., Thorpe, M.F. and Moukarzel, C. (1999) Floppy modes and the free energy: Rigidity and connectivity percolation on Bethe lattices, Phys. Rev. E59, 2084-2092. Djordjevic, B.R., Thorpe, M.F. and Wooten, F. (1995) Computer model of tetrahedral amorphous
diamond, Phys. Rev. B52, 5685-5689. 35.
Thorpe, M.F., Jacobs, D.J., Chubynsky, N.V. and Rader, A.J. (1999) Generic rigidity of network glasses, in M.F. Thorpe and P.M. Duxbury (eds.), Rigidity Theory and Applications, Kluwer
36.
Press, W.H., Teukolsky, S.A., Vetterling, V.T. and Flannery, B.P. (1992) Numerical Recipes in FORTRAN, 2nd ed., Cambridge University Press, New York. Franzblau, D.S. and Tersoff, J. (1992) Elastic properties of a network model of glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 2172-2175. Moukarzel, C. (1998) A fast algorithm for backbones, Int. J. Mod. Phys. C9, 887-895. Straley, J.P. (1979) Phase transitions in treelike percolation, Phys. Rev. B19, 4845-4846. Manna, S.S. and Subramanian, B. (1996) Quasirandom spanning tree model for the early river network, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 3460-3463. Kirchhoff, G. (1847) Über die Auflösung der Gleichungen, auf welche man bei der untersuchung der linearen verteilung galvanischer Ströme geführt wird, Ann. Phys. Chem. 72, 497-508. See, e.g., Cieplak, M., Giacometti, A., Maritan, A., Rinaldo, A., Rodriguez-Iturbe I. and Banavar, J.R. (1998) Models of fractal river basins, J. Stat. Phys. 91, 1-15. Prim, R.C. (1957) Shortest connection networks and some generalizations, Bell Syst. Tech. J. 36, 13891401.
Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, pp. 239-278. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42.
43.
44.
Cieplak, M., Maritan, A. and Banavar, J.R. (1994) Optimal paths and domain walls in the strong disorder limit, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2320-2323; Cieplak, M., Maritan, A. and Banavar, J.R. (1996)
Invasion percolation and Eden growth: Geometry and universality, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 3754-3757. 45.
Frank, D.J., Lobb, C.J. (1988) Highly efficient algorithm for percolative transport studies in two
46.
Stauffer, D. and Aharony, A. (1992) Introduction to Percolation Theory, 2nd ed., Taylor & Francis, London. Braswell, W.D., Family, F., Straley, J.P. (1984) Treelike percolation in two dimensions, Phys. Rev. A29, 254-256. Wu, F.Y. (1978) Absence of phase transitions in tree-like percolation in 2 dimensions, Phys. Rev. B18, 516-517. Straley, J.P. (1990) Treelike percolation, Phys. Rev. A41, 1030-1033.
dimensions, Phys. Rev. B37, 302-307.
47. 48.
49.
64
EVIDENCE FOR THE INTERMEDIATE PHASE IN CHALCOGENIDE GLASSES
P. BOOLCHAND, W.J. BRESSER, D.G. GEORGIEV, Y. WANG AND J. WELLS Department of Electrical, Computer Engineering and Computer Science University of Cincinnati Cincinnati, OH 45221-0030
INTRODUCTION Progressive cross-linking of polymeric networks, whether crystalline or noncrystalline in nature, alters their physical behavior in remarkable ways. In crystalline solids the effect is strikingly illustrated if one compares the physical properties of group VI elemental solids (S, Se and Te that possess a coordination number, r, = 2) with those of group IV ones (C, Si, Ge that have r = 4). Thus, although the Pauling single-bond strengths [1] of a Se-Se bond (44kcal/mole) and of a Ge-Ge bond (37.6kcal/mole) are nearly the same, the thermal (melting temperature and heat of fusion), elastic (Young's modulus) and plastic (hardness) behavior of crystalline Ge (r = 4) completely overwhelms that of trigonal Se (r = 2) understandably because of its higher connectivity. More profound effects occur in non-crystalline solids. In the GexSe1-x binary glass system, for example, one has the luxury to change the network connectivity or mean coordination number in a continuous fashion by composition (x) tunning. And one finds that glass transition temperatures [2], T g (x), and bulk elastic constants, progressively increase with or the degree of cross-linking. Furthermore, random networks in contrast to crystalline networks can self-organize [3] with remarkable consequences on physical properties of glasses. In this review, we shall provide experimental evidence for self-organization in glasses. The broad consequences of these observations on percolative transitions in condensed matter, in evolutionary biology and in protein folding, are discussed in the contributions of J.C. Phillips [4] and M.F. Thorpe [5] in this volume. Self-organization in random networks apparently occurs when the global network stress nearly vanishes. The generic condition for a 3d-network to be stress-free is that the number of Lagrangian bonding constraints/atom, nc, exhausts the three available degrees of freedom per atom,
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
65
(1)
Historically, the counting algorithm (1) was first introduced [6] to describe optimization of the glass forming tendency in a covalently bonded random networks, and onset of rigidity [7] in covalently bonded random networks. These two conditions apparently coincide with the stress-free requirement of such networks. Glasses that are under- (nc < 3) and over- (nc > 3) constrained possess stress which appears to be, respectively, entropic and enthalpic in origin. Mean-field predictions of the rigidity transition and existing numerical simulations at T=0, treat enthalpic rigidity [8]. As ideas on entropic rigidity [9] evolve, one may be able to understand stress in under-constrained networks.
The count of Lagrangian bonding constraints (nc) in covalent systems is rather straightforward. In such systems the distinction between the intact nearest-neighbor (bondstretching and bond-bending constraints and the broken more distant (dihedral angle and van der Walls) ones is transparent because of the hierarchical nature of the
bonding interactions. On the other extreme, in metallic systems, the impediment to apply these ideas on constraint counting results from the long range nature of bonding interactions between mobile electrons and the positive ion cores that contribute to the cohesive energy of such solids. The case of ionic solids such as the oxides is a particularly fascinating one and is a subject of current discussions. The hierarchical separation between intact and broken Lagrangian bonding constraints for pure Silica has been facilitated by structure results. Although the bonding angle about cation atoms (Si) is close to the tetrahedral angle, the bonding angle about the anion atoms (O) displays wide excursions (100°-180°). These structure results suggest that while both the bond-stretching and bond-bending constraints on Si appear to be intact, it is only the r-constraints on O that is intact. Indeed that separation permits one to understand [10] why silica, the archetypal glass former satisfies equation (1) exactly, and thus forms a stress-free continuous random network. The counting algorithm(s) also show that window glass, a pseudo-ternary alloy of and in the approximate molar ratio 75:15:10 could well represent [11] yet another example of a stress-free oxide network.
In this article, we review recent optical and thermal experiments that shed light on the existence of the self-organized state in network glasses. The self-organized state apparently occurs in between the rigid phase and the floppy phase and is therefore also termed as the intermediate phase. Our experiments with chalcogenide glasses [12] reveals that glass
transitions (Tg) become almost completely thermally reversing in character in the selforganized state. The thermally reversing character of Tgs can be probed by a recently developed variant of DSC, known as T-modulated Differential Scanning Calorimetry
(MDSC). The non-reversing heat flow term near Tg accessed in an MDSC measurement provides a direct measure of network stress [13] in a glass, and represents a significant recent development in the field. Raman Vibrational spectroscopy in the bond-stretching regime provides a uniquely powerful probe of optical elasticity which displays specific power-laws as a function of in the floppy, intermediate and stressed rigid phases of network glasses. Before describing the results of these experiments, we provide an overview of principle theoretical ideas that have evolved in the field of enthalpic rigidity in the next section. PREDICTION OF A RIGIDITY TRANSITION
Mean-field Theory in Random Networks
66
In 1788, J.L. Lagrange [14] wrote the celebrated book "Mécanique Analytique", and thus laid the foundations of Lagrangian mechanics as we know it today. In particular he
introduced the notion of generalized coordinates and forces that can act as constraints (Lagrangian multipliers) in solving mechanical problems. About a century later, J.C. Maxwell [15] used the notion of constraints to examine mechanical stability of
macroscopic structures such as trusses and bridges. Phillips-Thorpe Rigidity Threshold. In 1979, a new beginning to develop a microscopic theory of glass formation in covalent solids was made [6]. It was suggested that valence forces such as bond-stretching and bond-bending forces can serve as atomic constraints in assembling covalent networks. It was conjectured that glass formation would be optimized when the number of constraints/atom equal 3, the degrees of freedom of an atom in a 3d network (Table 1). These ideas were advanced further in 1983 when a normal mode analysis of covalent networks showed [7] that the number of zero frequency solutions of the dynamical matrix, f (= floppy modes), equal nc – 3. These developments led to the recognition that a glass network will become elastically rigid when the number of zero frequency solutions f vanish, i.e., nc = 3. For 3d networks in which atoms possess a coordination number the number of and constraints/atom, are given by
(2) (3)
The onset of rigidity in such networks it then follows, would occur in a mean-field sense, when or
(4)
or the mean coordination, The Phillips-Thorpe mean-field rigidity threshold, has been refined by numerical simulations [8] using the standard model of a covalent glass as a random network. These calculations are discussed in the contribution of M.F. Thorpe et al., in this
volume. For completeness we summarize the principal results of these calculations here. The numerical simulations [8] start with a base network at r = 4, such as a diamond lattice or a 4096-atom computer generated amorphous Si network with periodic boundary
conditions. Bonds are depleted at random to produce networks of lower in the range insuring that one-fold coordinated atoms are not produced. A Kirkwood or Keating potential is used to describe the and forces between atoms. The number of floppy modes/atom are then calculated as a function of by performing a normal mode analysis at each The results show (Fig. 1) a linear decrease in in the range (as shown by mean-field theory) which is followed by a long exponential tail in the approximate range 2.35 The onset of rigidity transition is then localized by the second derivative, that reveals (Table 1) a sharp peak at for the case of diamond lattice and at for the case of a-Si base network. These results are remarkably close (within 1%) to the mean-field result of for the onset of rigidity in random networks estimated by constraint counting. One-fold Coordinated Atoms (OFC, r=1). The Phillips-Thorpe mean-field estimate for the onset of rigidity is restricted to covalent networks in which and constraints are intact, and all atoms possess a r of OFC atoms (r = 1) have to be handled separately because such atoms do not produce constraints but can only erase them according to the 2r – 3 estimate. Many glass systems include OFC-atoms, such as 67
68
Figure 1. Results of numerical simulations for the fractions of floppy modes per degree of freedom for the bond-depleted diamond network in the random case and the self-organized case. The filled circle gives the stress and rigidity transition for the random case. The open square gives the mean-field predicted rigidity transition at The open circle and triangle give, respectively, the rigidity and stress transitions for the self-organized case. The shaded region gives the intermediate phase. Figure is taken from ref.3a.
halogens in the chalcohalides, hydrogen in hydrogenated a-Si, and alkalis in alkali-silicates. In 1984 Boolchand and Thorpe [16] extended mean-field constraint counting algorithms to include OFC-atoms. They showed that equation (3) takes on a correction term in the presence of a finite fraction, n1/N, of such atoms, and rigidity percolates in such networks when (5)
In general, OFC-atoms play no role if the base glass network (without 1-fold coordinated atoms) is optimally constrained, on the other hand, these atoms will soften [10] an overconstrained base network, and conversely stiffen an underconstrained base glass network. The latter is illustrated in Fig. 2 which shows a plot of the negative of f, henceforth labeled h (= hardness index) as a function of the mean coordination of the base glass network. The base glass network is the network remaining once all 1-fold coordinated atoms have been plucked. For the case when a glass network has no 1-fold coordinated atoms, i.e., n1/N = 0, we recover the usual circumstance, h = -1 at r´ = r = 2 and h = 4 at r = 4, and rigidity onsets at h = f = 0 when In the presence of a finite concentration of 1-fold coordinated atoms, the slope of the line progressively decreases from its maximum value of 5/6 with increasing n 1 /N, with all plots passing through the point h = 0, Such a behavior constitutes evidence of a softening of an overconstrained network or conversely stiffening of an underconstrained network in the presence of OFC-atoms. These ideas provide a means to understand [17] the linear variation of the nano-indentation hardness results of diamond-like films as a function of as discussed elsewhere. Furthermore, these ideas have also provided a basis to understand the glass forming tendency in a wide variety of chalcohalide glasses as recently discussed in a review by Mitkova and Boolchand [18]. In dealing with networks possessing OFC-atoms, two circumstances need to be distinguished [19]. Case 1, when OFC-atoms bond to an atom possessing and case 2 when OFC-atoms bond to an atom possessing an r = 2. Equation 5 is valid for case 1 69
Figure 2. Graphical representation of hardness index h vs. mean coordination of base network showing the straight-line loci for different values of OFC-atom concentration n1/n=0.025 and 0.50. Figure is taken from ref. 17.
above. The more complicated case 2 has also been treated. In case 2, the rigidity threshold for the base glass network does not coincide with that of the (complete) glass network. For these reasons, in general, it is safer to always calculate mean-field constraints of the complete glass network with the OFC-atoms, rather than truncate it and work with the base
glass network. Bond-Bending Forces and Broken Constraints. Valence forces form a hierarchy with force strength exceeding force strength by a factor of 3 or more. And it is possible that as glass transition temperatures Tg increase, the constraint associated with the weaker forces intrinsically break. The structure manifestation of the broken -constraint is that the underlying bond-angle distribution becomes wide. Presumably this results because thermal energies (kTg) can overwhelm the underlying strain energies that would require a unimodal bond angle distribution. The circumstance is encountered in the chalcogenides [17] and oxide glasses [18]. It is useful to examine the underlying meanfield estimate of the rigidity transition in the presence of broken -constraint. Consider a glass network possessing finite concentration (mr/N) of r-fold coordinated atoms that have their -constraint broken. The rigidity transition in such a network will, in a mean-field sense, occur at
where m2/N, m3/N, m 4 N,... represent the fraction of 2, 3, 4,...fold coordinated atoms in the network that have their -constraints broken. A special case of equation (6) is that of a glass network possessing a finite concentration of 2-fold coordinated atoms that
70
have their -constraints broken. In binary GexSe1-x glasses, although the -constraint associated with 2-fold coordinated Se-atoms is intact in a Se-glass at x = 0, upon crosslinking with Ge, Tgs rapidly increase, and the underlying constraint is apparently broken as x increases to 0.20. For this reason, the rigidity transition [20] invariably shifts to higher values of due to the presence of the first correction term of equation (5), i.e.,
where m2/N designates the fraction of Se atoms in Sen-chain fragments in GexSe1-x glasses near x = 0.23. A second illustrative example of broken constraints determining the stiffness transition occurs in the Ge1-xSnxSe2 ternary, where Mössbauer spectroscopy reveals [21] evidence of Sn atoms to become all tetrahedrally coordinated when x increases to 0.35. The overconstrained tetrahedra, when admixed with the underconstrained tetrahedra, drive the network optimally constrained. Equations (7) predicts [22,23] the transition to occur at x = 2/5, indeed quite close to the observed value of 0.35. Two Rigidity Transitions in Self-Organized Networks In 1999, numerical simulations were extended to self-organized networks for the first time, and one found [3] rigidity to onset in two steps at r c(1), rc(2). The first of these transitions (rc(1)) is quite similar to the one described earlier for random networks in which rigid regions percolate at At r > rc(1), if the additional crosslinks are selectively placed in the floppy domains of the network, network stress will not accumulate. This situation must be contrasted to the usual case when crosslinks placed randomly drive some of the isostatically rigid-regions stressed-rigid (redundant bonds) thus building up network stress. One has found that such selective placement of crosslinks saturates at r = rc(2) = 2.395, when it is no longer possible to avoid forming redundant bonds. At (2) the network makes a first order transition to a stressed rigid phase (Fig. 1). The term isostatic or stress-free can be used to describe the self-organized state of a network in the r c (1) < r < rc(2) phase, residing in between the floppy (r < rc(1)) and stressed rigid (r > rc(2)) phase. The unstressed rigid phase is also termed as the intermediate phase. Calculations [24] show that the size of the first order jump in elasticity at rc(2) is controlled by the concentration of small rings (6-membered rings or smaller) where rigidity apparently nucleates. Raman scattering experiments on chalcogenide glasses provide evidence of two elastic thresholds (rc(1), rc(2)), as we shall describe in the next section. And even though there persists a systematic difference between theory and experiments on the values of rc(1) and rc(2), these new numerical simulations represent a significant advance. They not only narrow the gap between theory and experiments, but also provide a physical basis to characterize the order of the transitions and the self-organized state prevailing in between the two transitions. GLASS TRANSITION VARIATION AND NETWORK CONNECTIVITY Glasses are distinguished from amorphous materials in that they display a glass transition temperature, Tg, that represents a softening or melting transition of the solid glass into a metastable liquid glass. Across Tg, viscosity, thermal expansion, entropy, molar volumes and specific heat change [25] qualitatively. The basic nature of glass transition continues to be a subject of profound current discussions. There are undoubtedly 71
kinetic and sample thermal history effects associated with Tg. But, there are also much larger structure or network connectivity related effects that apparently control the magnitude of Tgs in glass forming materials. T-Modulated Differential Scanning Calorimetry (MDSC) In a conventional DSC measurement, the signature of softening of a glass is an endothermic heat flow usually measured with respect to an inert reference, as the temperature of the glass and reference is swept at a fixed scan rate. By programming a sinusoidal temperature variation over the linear T-ramp, it is possible to deconvolute [26]
the heat flow into two components, one that tracks the sinusoidal T-variation and is therefore called the reversing heat flow and the remainder that does not track the periodic T-variation and is called the non-reversing heat flow Figure 3 provides MDSC scans [23] of a GeSe2 glass and Ge0.23Se0.77 glass illustrating the deconvolution of heat flow rates into the non-reversing and reversing components. Two noteworthy features become apparent from these scans, first the apparent glass transition temperature deduced from the total heat flow is, in general, lower than the glass transition temperature (Tg) deduced from the reversing heat flow. Second, is found to be miniscule for the x = 0.23 sample but it is an order of magnitude larger for the stoichiometric glass, GeSe2. The shift, is only 3°C for the x = 0.23 glass sample when is nearly vanishing, but it is 12°C for GeSe2 glass when increases by almost an order of magnitude. The presence of a sizeable term in a glass will lower in relation to
Tg due to kinetic heat-flow effects.
Figure 3. MDSC scans (a) Ge0.23Se0.77 and (b) GeSe2 glasses revealing the deconvolution of the heat flow into the reversing and non-reversing components. Note the qualitative reduction in coordinated glass. See text for details. Figure is taken from ref. 23.
72
for the optimally
Network Stress and Non-Reversing Heat Flow. Important insights into the physical origin of the term in glasses have emerged from compositional trends. The case of the GexAsxSe1-2x ternary is particularly significant because for this system compositional trends in activation energies of Kohlrausch relaxation of an external stress were established in flexural studies [27]. Recently, compositional trends in for this ternary were measured [13], and the comparison of the two sets of results taken in two different laboratories, at different time frames, shows a remarkable similarity (Fig. 4). The results suggest a specific interpretation of the term; the heat-flow term provides a measure of internal stress in a network glass, while the activation energies, a measure of relaxation of an external stress.
Tg and Network Connectivity. The Tg deduced from the reversing flow provide a very useful datum characterizing the connectivity of a glass. At the outset, it should be mentioned that Tgs deduced from the reversing heat flow are virtually independent
of sample thermal history, although these will shift up in T as scan rates are increased. Therefore if Tgs are measured at the same low scan rate at different compositions in a glass system, one can obtain useful structure information. recent development in the field.
Figure 4.
The latter represents a relatively
variation in GexAsxSe1-2x glasses showing the thermally reversing window in the
< 2.42 range (a). Activation energy for Kohlrausch relaxation of an external stress in flexural studies (b). Figure in top panel taken from ref. [13], while the figure in bottom panel is taken from ref. [27].
73
Agglomeration theory [28, 29] developed by R. Kerner and M. Micoulaut provides a quantitative means to analyze compositional trends in Tg in the stochastic regime. One can, for example, predict the T g (x) variation in binary GexSe1-x and AsxSe1-x glasses near x
when cross-linking of Sen-chain fragments by 4-fold Ge and 3-fold As atoms
proceeds in a stochastic fashion, i.e. randomly. These predictions are well supported by experiments. The predictions also provide a quantitative means to distinguish domains of stochastic from non-stochastic network formation in these binary glasses [2].
In the GexSe1-x binary glass system, the prediction of agglomeration theory is that the slope
where T0 is the glass transition of Se glass. In the experiments one observes (Fig. 5a) T g (x) to increase linearly with x, with a slope of T0/ln2 = 44°C/10 at % of Ge up to x = 0.08 defining the stochastic regime. At x > 0.08, the experimental Tgs exceed the predicted Tgs, suggesting onset of extended range structures beyond Ge(Se1/2)4 tetrahedra and Sen-chain
segments, and signaling the onset of a non-stochastic regime (Fig. 5a). It is in this 129
compositional range that I Mössbauer spectroscopy measurements reveal [30, 31] that the oversized Te-tracer atom ceases to replace available Se-sites in a random fashion. Thus the onset of non-stochastic behavior at x > 0.08 in these thermal measurements is in excellent agreement with 129 I Mössbauer spectroscopy results published nearly two decades ago.
RAMAN ELASTIC THRESHOLDS AND THE INTERMEDIATE PHASE Although Raman scattering has been used as a probe of glass structure [32-35] for the past three decades, the application of the optical method as a probe of rigidity transitions in network glasses is a recent development [20, 36-39]. In many cases when
vibrational bands are resolved, it is possible to quantitatively follow mode frequency changes with glass composition and deduce power-laws describing optical elasticity changes. And although the scales of mode frequencies are set by the strength of and forces, variations in mode-frequencies with glass compositions result due to intertetrahedral couplings, i.e. network connectivity. Because of the presence of light-induced effects in glasses, the need to excite Raman scattering at low-laser power is paramount. For this reason, resonant enhancement of the scattering by tunning the laser energy close to the optical bandgap of the glass, is particularly desirable. It results in a large signal to noise ratio with very modest laser exciting power. Raman scattering results on several IV-VI glass systems have now been performed and provide evidence of the intermediate phase. The principal results on the GexSe1-x binary glass system are presented next. Bulk GexSe1-x Glasses. Glasses in the titled binary at several compositions in the 0 < x < 1/3 range were synthesized the usual way and characterized by MDSC [2, 20, 38]. The observed Tgs measured from the reversing heat-flow serve an important check on glass compositions. Raman scattering excited by 647.1nm radiation from a Kr+ ion laser was studied in a conventional back scattering set up using a T64000 triple monochromator system with a CCD detector. The laser beam was brought to a loose focus of about 500µm spot size, to keep the photon flux low (1017 photons/cm2/sec), in a set up [38] usually described as macro-Raman scattering.
74
Macro-Raman Scattering
Figure 6 shows Raman spectra of the glasses obtained at selective compositions.
The lineshapes show evolution of modes of corner-sharing (CS) tetrahedra (200 cm -1 ) and edge-sharing (ES) Ge(Se1/2)4 tetrahedra (215 cm-1) at the expense of the Se-Se stretch mode of Sen-chains (CM) at about 250cm-1 . In general CS and ES modes are symmetric and could be analyzed in terms of a Gaussian each. This was not the case of the CM, however, and it required at least 3 Gaussians for an adequate deconvolution at all x. Figure 7 provides the mode frequency variation for the CS and ES mode from a comprehensive lineshape deconvolution of the Raman spectra [38]. In Fig. 7a, one can discern a regime of a linear variation in v(x) in the 0.08 < x < 0.20 interval, and a regime of a power-law variation in the 0.26 < x < 1/3 interval. In between these two regimes, lies a transition region wherein the variation in v(x) is sub-linear. To extract the underlying power-laws, we have made a plot of against and obtained the slope pCS of the resulting
Fig. 5(a). Observed Tg(x) variation in indicated binary glasses. The Tgs are deduced from the inflection point of the reversing heat flow. (b) variation in GexSe1-x glasses deduced from the non-reversing heat flow showing a global minimum near x = 0.225. Figure taken from ref. 2.
75
Figure 6. Macro-Raman scattering in bulk GexSe1-x glasses at indicated glass compositions x. Note the
growth in scattering of corner-sharing (CS) and edge-sharing (ES) tetrahedra at the expense of Se n -chain mode (CM). See text for details.
line (Fig. 8a) and get a value of pCS = 1.54(6). A parallel analysis for the transition region (Fig. 8b) using xc(1) = 0.21, yields a slope pt = 0.75(15). For the ES mode, our results suggest that the linear variation in at low x (0.10 < x < 0.20) smoothly connects to the power-law variation at higher x (x > 0.21). Figure 8c shows a plot of against which yields a straight line with a slope pES = 1.32(06), defining the underlying power-law associated with elasticity due to ES units. The rational
for extracting the Raman elastic power-laws is discussed next. Stressed Rigid Phase. On general grounds one expects rigidity in the present
glasses to nucleate at moities that are overconstrained units. Changes in
and
such as the ES and CS
result from local or optical elasticities and can be expected
to display a power-law variation with
once
exceeds a critical value
when the
backbone becomes rigid, i.e.,
The justification for such a variation is suggested by the numerical simulations [40, 41] on random networks constrained by and forces (Keating potential) that show the elasticity to display a power-law power p = 1.4 or 1.5. The power-law variation of
(Fig. 7a), starting at x = xc(2) = 0.26 with pCS =
1.54( 10) constitutes direct evidence for onset of stressed rigidity. The power-law pCS= 1.54 is in excellent agreement with numerical estimates [40, 41] of elasticity in random networks. Furthermore, the stressed nature of the backbone at x > xc(2) follows from the
rapidly increasing 76
heat-flow term once x > xc(2) as illustrated in Fig. 5a. The small
Figure 7(a). CS- and (b) ES-Raman mode frequency variation with x in GexSe1-x glasses displaying the various phases as discussed in text. Figure is taken from ref. 38.
jump in v c between x = 0.25 and 0.26 of xc(2) is first order.
suggests that the rigidity transition near
Intermediate Phase. Our Raman experiments also show that rigidity first onsets at
x = x c (l) = 0.20(1) in which both ES and CS units partake. This is suggested by the kink in and the onset of a power-law behavior in both starting near x c (l). The optical elasticity associated with the CS and ES units yields a lower power-law of pCS = 0.75(15) and PES = 1.38(10). The sublinear power-law for the CS units, PCS (=0.75(15)) is
reminiscent of the finite-size scaling result [42] which is 2/d = 2/3 for d = 3 (3d-network). To obtain a power-law p < 1, one must invoke large-scale or long-range fluctuations as are
discussed in equilibrium-scaling theory [43]. The composition x c (l) coincides with the lower bound of the global minimum in suggesting that in the x c (l) < x < xc(2) interval glasses are largely unstressed. Furthermore, the transition at x c (l) appears to be second order as revealed by the continuous variation of mode frequencies and These signatures of the experimental results constitute evidence for glasses in the xc( 1) < x < xc(2) composition range to be unstressed rigid, and to be self-organized, constituting the intermediate phase. 77
Figure 8. Log-log plots of Raman mode frequency squared against glass compositions yielding power-laws
for (a) CS mode in the stressed rigid phase (b) CS mode in the intermediate phase (c) ES mode in the rigid phase. See ref. 38
78
Floppy Phase. The present experiments [38] also suggest that at x < xc(1), glasses are floppy. Both and display a linear variation with x in the 0.10 < x < 0.20 range with a small slope. However at x < 0.10 in the stochastic regime, the slope of
with x actually vanishes. Numerical simulations [40 ,41] using the bond-depleted diamond structure reveal the elasticity in the floppy region to vanish. Thus, theory and experiment agree rather well in the stochastic regime. At x > 0.10, both T g (x) variation and Mössbauer
site occupancy variation [30] with x, signal the emergence of a non-stochastic network consisting of extended rigid inclusions formed in a floppy background. Here the experiments show the elasticity to slowly increase as It would be of interest to see whether such an observed variation can be reproduced in numerical simulations on non-stochastic floppy networks. In summary, the present Raman and MDSC results on GexSe1-x glasses provide evidence of two rigidity transitions, a second order transition at xc(1) = 0.20 from a floppy to an unstressed rigid phase, and a first order transition at xc(2) = 0.26 from an unstressed rigid to a stressed rigid phase. These two rigidity transitions represent the lower (xc( 1)) and
upper (x c (2)) bounds of an intermediate phase that separates the floppy (x < x c (1)) from the stressed rigid (x > xc(2)) phase in the present glasses. Complete Raman and MDSC measurements are now available on the companion IV-VI binary glass system, Si x Se 1-x [36,37]. The results reveal strikingly parallel details of the intermediate phase in this binary glass system with x c (l) = 0.20 and xc(2) = 0.27. Taken together, the close similarity of results on the width and centroid of the intermediate phase in the two independent IV-VI binary glass systems provides for some selfconsistency in the underlying physics of the rigidity transition.
PHOTOMELTING OF THE INTERMEDIATE PHASE
Historically, the rigidity transition in GexSe1-x binary glasses was first investigated in micro-Raman measurements [20]. In these measurements, the exciting laser beam (647. 1nm) was brought to a sharp focus using a microscope attachment. This had the consequence that the photon flux (N f) of 1022 photons/cm2/sec, exceeded that in the macro-Raman measurements (Nf = 1017 photons/cm2/sec) by about 5 orders of magnitude. Changes in Nf reflect the 2 orders of magnitude smaller versus laser spot size in the micro-Raman measurements. In both experiments, the exciting laserbeam wavelength of 647.1nm or Eph = 1.92eV was kept the same. For glass compositions in the intermediate phase, possessing an optical gap Eg > 2.0eV, the exciting beam is thus weakly absorbing and penetrates to a depth of about 100µm. In sharp contrast to the macro-Raman results, the micro-Raman measurements revealed [20] a solitary rigidity transition from a floppy phase to a rigid phase near x = xc = 0.23(1). To facilitate a comparison, we have reproduced variation in GexSe1-x glasses from the macro-Raman (Fig. 9a) with the micro-Raman (Fig. 9b) measurements together. One is led to the suggestion that while the macro-Raman measurements probe the intrinsic rigidity transitions of the glasses, the micro-Raman ones probe a light-induced modification of the transitions. Certain features become transparent from the comparison of these results. The two transitions at x c (1) = 0.20 and xc(2) = 0.26 coalesce to a point at the centroid xc = (xc(1) + xc(2))/2 = 0.23 location in the micro-Raman measurements. Furthermore, the centroid location xc = 0.23 coincides with the global minimum in heat flow term (Fig. 1b). 79
Figure 9. Raman mode frequency variation of CS sharing Ge(Se1/2)4 tetrahedra taken observed in (a) macroRaman and (b) micro-Raman measurements compared. The intermediate phase collapses to a solitary point
at its centroid in the micro-Raman measurements due to the higher photon-flux of the exciting 647.1nm radiation. Figure is taken from ref. 38.
Our interpretation of these Raman results is that the collapse of the intermediate phase to a solitary point is that it represents a photo-structural effect. In the presence of a high flux of near band-gap radiation photomelting of the self-organized
state to a random network takes place. The underlying physical process probably consists of a transient self-trapped exciton [44, 45] that recombines non-radiatively leading to a light-induced dynamic state in which rapid bond-switching and diffusion occurs. The photodiffusion process, apparently is optimized when the network stress vanishes and photomelting is the consequence. It is for this reason that the photomelted state is easily formed at the global minimum of the term (xc = 0.23), when network stress vanishes. Parallel physical effects have recently been observed in Brillouin scattering
measurements [45] on these glasses. In these experiments, one found the longitudinal acoustic (LA) mode to soften reversibly and by a gigantic amount (25%) as a function of laser excitation power, but only for glass compositions near the center of the intermediate phase, i.e. x=0.225. These Raman measurements on GexSe1-x glasses provide an essential link between the two extremal descriptions of the rigidity transitions in glasses. One observes two 80
transitions [38] when the backbone is intrinsically self-organized in the melt-quenched
glasses and one observes a solitary rigidity transition [20] characteristic of a random network in the photomelted state. And one expects the solitary transition to occur in connectivity space when corresponding to the counting algorithm(s).
INTERMEDIATE PHASE AND GLASS STRUCTURE The discovery of the intermediate phase in several chalcogenide glasses [12] is beginning to shed light on its connection to glass structure. Apart from to the IV-VI glasses, there are several other glass systems [13, 39, 46, 47] in which the phase has now been observed (Fig. 10). In table 2 we provide a summary of results on the subject.
Perusal of the results in table 2 shows that the width of the intermediate phase changes by almost an order of magnitude in going from the Ge-S-I ternary [39] to the Ge-As-Se ternary with the results on binary glasses of Ge-Se, and As-Se lying in between 0.08(1)) these two extremes (Fig. 10). The Ge-S-I ternary appears [39] to be a paradigm of a random network. In this ternary, replacement of S in the base Ge0.25S0.75 glass by 1-fold coordinated I, proceeds to randomly depolymerize the network. Enumeration of constraints reveals that only one building block (m=l) out
of the five possible (m=0, 1, 2, 3, 4) mixed GeSe4-mIm tetrahedra is optimally constrained, and thus contributes to the formation of the intermediate phase. In Raman scattering, one can observe modes of these mixed tetrahedra and thus establish details of glass structure. Furthermore, the Raman mode frequency of Ge(S1/2)4 tetrahedra, v 0(x), is found to vary linearly with Iodine concentration (x) to show a kink (change in slope) at the rigidity transition, which coincides with the sharp minimum in The transition, according to mean-field theory, is predicted to occur at Remarkably, the present experiments (Fig. 10 show the transition to occur at Table 2 Experimental Results for the Intermediate Phase in Network Glasses, r c( 1) designates onset of
81
Figure 10.
variation as a function of glass composition revealing thermally reversing windows in
GexSe1-2x(O), GexAsxSe1-2X (z) and
bulk glasses. Note the large variation in the window
width from 0.15 for the Ge-As-Se ternary to < 0.01 for the Ge-S-I ternary.
In sharp contrast, the GexAsxSe1-2x ternary, often described as a prototype of a random network, turns out to be one of the best example of a glass system in which a high degree of self-organization occurs [13] as reflected by the extremely large width of the intermediate phase. We believe the result is intrinsically related to the multiplicity of optimally constrained units and combination of over- and under-constrained units that can form as part of the stress-free backbone. Some of these units include pyramidal As(Se 1/2)3, quasi-tetrahedral Se=As(Se1/2)3, in addition to a combination of Ge(Se1/2)4 tetrahedra (both CS and ES) with Sen-chain fragments. And it is possible that molecular dynamic simulations, in conjunction with the Raman elasticity power-laws can impose stringent restrictions on possible structures prevailing in this special region, for these to be identified in future.
CONCLUSIONS Raman scattering and T-modulated Differential Scanning Calorimetry measurements on several families of chalcogenide glasses have been performed. Comprehensive results are now available on the GexSe1-x and SixSe1-x binary glass systems, where rigidity is found to onset in two steps; a second-order transition at x c (l) =
0.20 in both binaries from a floppy to an unstressed rigid phase, and a first-order transition at xc(2) = 0.26 for Ge-Se, = 0.27 for Si-Se binary from an unstressed rigid to a stressed rigid phase. The two transitions (xc(1), xc(2)) define the bounds of an intermediate phase that separates the floppy from the stressed rigid phase. The near absence of the nonreversing heat-flow, constitutes evidence for the stress-free nature of the backbone of glass compositions in the intermediate phase. Light-induced melting of the intermediate
phase in micro-Raman measurements on the Ge-Se glass system has also been observed. 82
The observation constitutes evidence for photomelting of the self-organized state to a
random network. These results confirm that the breakdown of mean-field theory, results due to an intrinsic self-organization of the backbone, and provide the link between the two extremal descriptions of the rigidity transition in network glasses modeled in numerical simulations. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
It is a pleasure to acknowledge discussions with Mike Thorpe and Jim Phillips during the course of this work. This work is supported by NSF grant DMR-97-02189. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3.
Pauling, L. (1960) Nature of the Chemical Bond, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY pp 85. Boolchand, P. and Bresser, W. J. (2000) Structural Origin of Broken Chemical Order in GeSe Glass. Phil. Mag B 80, 1757 – 1772. a. Thorpe, M.F., and Chubynsky, M.V. (2000), Rigidity and Self-Organization of Network Glasses and the Intermediate Phase in M. F. Thorpe (ed.) Properties and Applications of Amorphous Materials,
Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, (in press). b. Thorpe, M.F., Jacobs, D.J., Chubynsky, M.V., Phillips, J.C. (2000) Self – Organization in Network Glasses, J. Non-Cryst Solids 266-269, 859-866. 4. 5. 6.
Phillips, J.C. Mathematical Principles of Intermediate Phases in Disordered Systems, present volume. Thorpe, M.F., and Chubynsky, M.V. Rigidity and Self-Organization of Network Glasses and the Intermediate Phase, present volume. Phillips, J.C. (1979) Topology of covalent non-crystalline solids I: Short-range order in chalcogenide alloys, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 34, 153-181.
7.
Thorpe, M.F. (1983) Continuous deformation in random networks, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 57, 355-370.
8.
Thorpe, M.F., Jacobs, D.J., Djordjevic, B.R. (2000) The structure and rigidity of network glasses, in P. Boolchand (ed), Insulating and Semiconducting Glasses, World Scientific Press, Singapore, pp. 95145. Joós, B., Plischke, M., Vernon, D.C., and Zhou, Z. (1999) Entropic Rigidity in M.F. Thorpe and P.M. Duxbury (eds.), Rigidity Theory and Applications, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York
9.
pp 315-328. 10.
Zhang, M. and Boolchand, P. (1994) The central role of broken, bond-bending constraints in promoting
11.
glass-formation in the oxides, Science 266, 1355-1357. Kerner, R., and Phillips, J.C. (2000) Quantitative Principles of Silicate Glass Chemistry Solid State Comm. (in press).
12.
13. 14. 15. 16.
17.
18. 19.
Boolchand, P., Selvanathan, D. Wang, Y., Georgiev, D.G., and Bresser, W.J. (2000) Onset of Rigidity in steps in Chalcogenide Glasses – The intermediate Phase in M. F. Thorpe (ed). Properties and
Applications of Amorphous Materials, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dortrecht, (in press). Wang, Y., Boolchand, P. and Micoulaut, M. Glass structure rigidity transitions and the intermediate phase in the Ge-As-Se ternary, Europhys. Lett, (in press). Lagrange, J. L. (1788) Mecanique Analytique, Paris. Maxwell, J. C. (1864) On the calculation of the equilibrium and stiffness of frames, Philos, Mag. 27, 294-299. Boolchand, P., and Thorpe, M.F. (1994) Glass-forming tendency, percolation of rigidity, and one-fold-
coordinated atoms in covalent networks, Phys. Rev. B 50, 10366-10368. Boolchand, P., Zhang, M. and Goodman, B. (1996) Influence of one-fold-coordinated atoms on mechanical properties of covalent networks, Phys. Rev. B 53, 11488-11494. Mitkova, M. and Boolchand, P. (1998) Microscopic origin of the glass forming tendency in chalcohalides and constraint theory, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 240, 1-21. Boolchand, P., Zhang, M., Goodman, B. (1997) One-fold coordinated atoms, constraint theory and nanoindentation hardness, in M.F. Thorpe and M. Mitkova (eds.) Amorphous Insulators and Semiconductors, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dortrecht, pp. 339-348.
20.
Feng, X.W., Bresser, W.J. and Boolchand, P. (1997) Direct evidence for stiffness threshold in
21.
chalcogenide glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 4422-4425. Stevens, M., Grothaus, J., Boolchand, P. and Hernandez, J.G. (1983) Universal structural phase-
83
22. 23. 24.
transition in network glasses, Solid State Comm. 47, 199-202. Phillips, J.C. (1983) Realization of a Zachariasen glass, Solid Stale Comm. 47, 203-206. Boolchand, P. (2000) Vibrational excitation in glasses: Rigidity transition and Lamb-Mössbauer factors, in P. Boolchand (ed.) Insulating and Semiconducting Glasses, World Scientific Press, Singapore, pp. 369-414. Thorpe, M.F., Jacobs, D.J., Chubynsky, M.V. and Rader, J.A. (1999) Generic rigidity of network glasses in M.F. Thorpe and P. M. Duxbury (eds.) Rigidity Theory and Applications, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, pp. 239-277.
25.
Zallen, R. (1983) The Physics of Amorphous Solids, John Wiley and Sons, New York, pp.3.
26.
Modulated DSCTM Compendium (1997) Reprint #TA-210, TA Instruments, Inc., New Castle, DE http://www.tainst.com/ Böhmer, R. and Angell, C.A. (1992), Correlations of the non-exponentiality and state dependence of mechanical relaxation with bond-connectivity in Ge-As-Se supercooled liquids. Phys. Rev. B 45, 10911094. Kerner, R. and Micoulaut, M. (1994) A theoretical-model of formation of covalent binary glasses. 1. general setting, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 176, 271-279.
27.
28. 29.
30.
Micoulaut, M. and Naumis, G.G. (1999) Glass transition temperature variation, cross-linking and structure in network glasses: a stochastic approach, Europhys. Lett. 47, 568-574. Also see contribution
of M. Micoulaut – Glass Transition Temperature variation as a probe for network connectivity in this volume. Bresser, W.J., Boolchand, P., and Suranyi, P. (1986), Rigidity Percolation and Molecular Clustering in Network glasses. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 2493-2497.
31.
Bresser, W.J., Boolchand, P., Suranyi, P. deNeufville, J.P. (1981), Direct evidence for intrinsically broken chemical ordering in melt-quenched glasses 46, 1689-1692.
32.
Galeener, F.L. (1990) The structure and vibrational excitations of simple glasses, J. Non-Cryst. Solids
33. 34. 35.
36. 37. 38. 39.
40.
41. 42. 43.
44. 45. 46. 47.
84
123, 182-190. A symposium was held in 1995 to honor the late Frank L. Galeener’s contributions to glass science. The interested reader may want to look at the proceedings of this symposium published in J. Non-Cryst. Solids 182, 1-212. Lucovsky, G. (1979) Chemical effects on the frequencies of Si-H vibrations in amorphous solids, Solid State Commun. 29, 571-576. Griffiths, J.E., Espinosa, G.P., Remeika J.P., et al. (1982) Reversible quasi-crystallization in GeSe2 glass, Phys. Rev. B 25, 1272-1286. Murase, K. (2000) Vibrational excitations in glasses: Raman scattering, in P. Boolchand (ed.), Insulating and Semiconducting Glasses, World Scientific Press, Inc., Singapore, pp. 415-463. Selvanathan, D., Bresser, W.J., Boolchand, P., and Goodman, B. (1999) Thermally reversing window and stiffness transitions in chalcogenide glasses, Solid State Commun. 111, 619-624. Selvanathan, D., Bresser, W.J., Boolchand, P. (2000) Stiffness transitions in SixSe1-x glasses from Raman scattering and temperature-Modulated Differential Scanning Calorimetry, Phys. Rev. B61, 15061-15076. Boolchand, P., Feng, X., Bresser W.J. (2000) Rigidity transition in binary Ge-Se Glasses and the intermediate phase, J. Non-Cryst. Solids (submitted). Wang, Y., Wells, J., Bresser, W.J., Boolchand, P. (2000) Stiffness Transition in a Zachariasen glass: Theory and experiment (unpublished). Franzblau, D.S., Tersoff, J. (1992) Elastic properties of a network model of glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68: 2172-2175. He, H., Thorpe, M.F. (1985) Elastic properties of glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54: 2107-2110. Josephson, B.D. (1966) Relation between the superfluid density and order parameter for superfluid He near Tc Phys. Lett. 21, 608-609. Chayes, J.T., Chayes, L., Fisher, D.S., et al. (1986) Fubute-size scaling and correlaton lengths for disordered systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 2999-3002, Fritzsche, H. (2000) Light induced structural changes in Glasses in P. Boolchand (ed.) Insulating and Semiconducting Glasses, World Scientific Press, Inc., pp. 653-690. Gump, J., Finkler I., Xia, H., Sooryakumar, R., Bresser, W.J., Boolchand, P. (2000) Direct evidence for photomelting of the Intermediate Phase in Network glasses (submitted to Phys. Rev. Lett.). Georgiev, D.G., Boolchand, P., Micoulaut, M. Rigidity transitions and molecular structure of AsxSe1-x glasses, Phys. Rev. B (in press). Georgiev, D.G., Mitkova, M., Boolchand, P., Brunklaus, H., Eckert, H., Micoulaut, M. Molecular Structure, Glass transition temperature variation, agglomeration theory, and network connectivity of binary P-Se glasses, Phys. Rev. B (submitted).
THERMAL RELAXATION AND CRITICALITY OF THE STIFFNESS TRANSITION
Y. Wang, T. Nakaoka, and K. Murase Department of Physics, Graduate School of Science, Osaka University, 1-1 Machikaneyama, Osaka 560-0043, Japan
INTRODUCTION Covalent network glass system Ge-Se has been well studied and analyzed in terms of testing theories on materials (glasses) science. Mean-field constraint theory [1–4] of network glasses is proving to be a powerful tool in explaining numerous anomalous behaviors around the critical composition of rigidity transition threshold at an average coordination number, corresponding to x=0.20 for at which the number of constraints per atom is equal to the degree of freedom per atom [5–11 ]. Short- and medium-range order in glasses can be varied continuously to form both the floppy and rigid glasses in the sense of the constraint theory, because that for the composition range the coordination numbers of Ge and Se are 4 and 2, respectively. The character of a network glass undergoes a qualitative change, from being easily deformable at to being rigid at Recently, Boolchand et al. [5, 6] demonstrated that the results from Raman scattering, modulated differential scanning calorimetry, molar volumes and Mössbauer spectroscopy work provide evidence of a multiplicity of stiffness transition, an onset point near and a completion point near between which a transition region or an intermediate phase separates the floppy glass from the rigid one. Kamitakahara et al. [7] reported the dynamic density of state around 5 meV to prove the existence of the floppy mode (“zero-frequency” mode in floppy glass) by studying the inelastic neutron spectra of chalcogenide glasses, however, the structural explanation of the floppy mode is still underconstructed yet. In this paper, we report the Raman-scattering results for glasses in a temperature range of 10–1000 K which covers glassy, super cooled liquid (SCL), crystalline and liquid states. The thermal relaxations well below the glass-transition temperature, Tg, in the vicinity of Tg and above Tg differ critically between the floppy and rigid glasses. We propose a micro-structural explanation of the floppy modes in glasses that structural units Sen(n>2) play an important role in influencing the macroscopic properties. The criticality of the stiffness transition is discussed from the point of view of structural admixture of Sen
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
85
Figure 1. The preparation of thin film. (a, b) Se element or bulk source of GexSe1–x are held in the cell where a narrow gap of is confined by two paralleled quartz plates. (c) After sealing the cell in a 10–6 Torr vacuum, we heat up the cell to 200 °C higher than the melting point of GexSe1–x and make the temperature of GexSe1–x source slightly higer than the temperature in the narrow gap. Then, liquid GexSe1–x penetrates into the narrow gap. (d) After quenching, the thin film between the two quartz plates is obtained.
and GeSe4/2 units. We demonstrate that reversible structural changes with temperature are
associated with a medium-range order in GeSe2 glasses, involving significantly layered-like crystalline GeSe2 fragments and inhomogeneously distributed nanophases of Ge–Ge and Se– Se homopolar bonds. The intrinsic Ge–Ge bond that does break the chemical order assists the glass to construct the layered-like crystalline fragments. GLASS PREPARATION Bulk glasses GexSe1–x are prepared by quenching the melts after rocking the ampule of mixed compounds sealed in for at least 48 hours. All the measured bulk samples are
picked from the as-prepared broken pieces with a typical dimension of 5x5x1 mm, except the thin films for studying the temperature dependence at high temperature. The thin films of GexSe1–x, with thickness of about are prepared by quenching from melts held in
evacuated fused-silica cells with a narrow gap defined by two parallel plates. The preparation procedure is sketched in Fig. 1. Confinement of the films in the cells takes advantage of keeping the same composition of glasses even at the high temperature, at which considerable chalcogenide compounds might vaporize if the bulk are held in vacuum. Furthermore, the films are assumed to be quenched with less difference in cooling rate between the surface and the inside than the situation in melt-quenched thick bulks. RAMAN SCATTERING AND MEASUREMENT SETUPS
In noncrystalline materials, wavevector
is not a good quantum number for phonons
because that losing the translational symmetry yields the break-down of the usual wave-vector conservation law. Raman scattering processes are allowed to occur from essentially all the vibrational modes of the material. Usually the intensity of scattered light is proportional to the vibrational density of states
for Stokes process. 86
describes the coupling of the vibrational modes of frequency
Figure 2. Polarized Raman spectra for GexSe1–x at 80 K. The resolution of the spectra is better than 1 cm – 1 .
to the light, and is the Bose factor. Conventional backscattering configuration for incident and scattered lights is employed in our case. For avoiding light-induced events and restricting the sample temperature difference from the environment to less than 3 °C, a low power-density probing light of less than 3W/cm – 2 (< 10W/cm –2 for measuring the spectra of liquid phase around 1000 K) is applied for the Raman measurements. The back-scattered light is collected and analyzed with the triple grating polychromator (JOBIN YVON T64000) and charge-coupled-device (CCD) detector in polarized and depolarized configurations. Generally, we use a 680 nm line from an argon ion laser pumped Dye (DCM) laser due to the sensitivity of our analysis setup, mainly determined by the monochromator and CCD detector, peaking around 600 nm. Insofar as we eliminate the interference of Rayleigh wings in the low-frequency spectra, an 800 nm
line from argon ion laser pumped Ti:Sapphire laser is a better choice that extends our lower limit to 3 cm – 1 at room temperature. A longer wavelength of laser light used as the pumping source yields a higher resolution for Raman spectrum in our experimental setups as well. STRUCTURAL RELAXATION WELL BELOW Tg Stokes Raman spectra of GexSe1–x glasses for various composition at 80 K are shown in Fig. 2. Raman spectra are reduced by and normalized to the maximum intensity,
for low Ge concentration the one at 255 cm –1 or at 200 cm – 1 for high Ge concentration. In g-Se, the dominant peak at 255 cm – 1 and a shoulder at the lower frequency side are
relevant to the bond-stretching modes of Sen chains [12, 13]. The weight of Se-chains related intensity decreases with increasing Ge concentration, which qualitatively reflects the changes in the vibrational density of states. It follows the fact that the number of GeSe4/2 tetrahedra increases with increasing Ge content. A strong peak at lower (A 1 ) and a weak one at higher
87
Figure 3. Raman spectra for Ge8Se92 glass at various temperatures. The spectra are obtained in a T-increasing sequence.
energy side in the vicinity of 200 cm – 1 are classified to the breathing modes of GeSe4/2 tetrahedra which are in the corner-sharing (CST) and edge-sharing (EST) configurations, respectively [14]. It should be noted that even in the glass of Ge content of 8 percents a small amount of tetrahedra shares the edges. For GeSe2 and Ge35Se65, the Ge–Ge bond related band at 180 cm – 1 increases with Ge content. In GeSe2 glass, the homopolar Ge–Ge and Se–Se “wrong” bonds are assumed to release the exceeding tension or stress in the highly distorted network, since its mean coordination number is 2.67 much larger than 2.40. The Se–Se vibrational bands are able to be observed at 260 cm – 1 with the resonant Raman condition as well [15]. Further discussion on the Ge–Ge and Se–Se “wrong” bonds in GeSe2 glass will be done in the following sections and elsewhere. In GexSe1–x glasses, the basic structural units are Sen chains and GeSe4/2 tetrahadra. The former are floppy units that build floppy regions in the network; the latter are rigid units that construct rigid ones. Studying the temperature dependence of vibrational properties of Se–Se or Ge–Se bond for each unit will supply plenty information on the microstructure of the network. Figure 3 shows Raman spectra for Ge8Se92 glass from 20 K to room temperature. The spectrum at the successive higher temperature is plotted with the base line raised by the same value. To take systematic analyses, the line shape of the spectra in the range of 160–300 cm – 1 is fitted by one straight line and four Gaussian curves, corresponding to two breathing modes of GeSe4/2 tetrahedra and two Se-chains related modes. Here, we focus on temperature dependence of peak positions of GeSe4/2 breathing mode, A 1 , at 200cm –1 and Se-Se bond-stretching mode at 255 cm – 1 , as shown in Figs. 4(a– d). In the floppy glass of Ge8Se92, an anomalous peak shift of the A1 mode, a positive shift with temperature, is observed below 100 K. This anomalous feature is hard to be understood without introducing a structural changes at such low temperature. During we cool the glass down to 20 K (well below the Tg’s), in other senses which can be regarded as a second kind of quenching process, each structural unit freezes at the correspondent critical temperature below which the unit is forbidden to frequently change the topology in the network. In Ge-Se network, first the GeSe 4/2 -unit rich region freezes, and
88
Figure 4. The temperature dependence of the A1 breathing mode of tetrahedra and the Se-Se bond-stretching mode. Both are scaled by the frequency of each mode at the lowest temperature we measured, (a) and (b) display the typical case in floppy glasses. (c) and (d) the rigid glasses.
at this time (or temperature) the tetrahedra might not be constraint or stressed. If all the atoms vibrate in limited spaces caused by the construction of volume with decreasing temperature, a large number of stress or tension then should be induced since the glassy sample is not
an ideal glass. Appending such stress or tension on the local structural units of GeSe 4/2 tetrahedra and Sen chains, the structure of each unit must be distorted more or less because in the microscopic region such kind of force will not be isotropic. The lowering frequency of A 1 mode during the cooling process suggests that the tetrahedra are departing from the regular structure. The similar stress or tension should influence the Se-chain structure as well. The reason why the Se-Se bond-stretching mode shows less temperature dependence than the A1 mode does is probably because that the bending force of Se-Se bond is much weaker than its stretching one. Most part of distortion to the Sen (n>2) chains causes a wide distribution of Se–Se–Se bond angle. Unfortunately, we can only detect the “rest” stretching mode of Se-Se bond. Structural Origin of Floppy modes in Ge x Se 1–x
In Ge8Se92 glass, Sen chains are the dominant structural units and GeSe4/2 tetrahedra are probably isolated from each other (few tetrahedra binding together should enhance the isolation). The structural units of Sen (n>2) chains, as shown in Fig. 5, are assumed as the key units for the heavily distorted tetrahedra “relaxing” to the regular structure. We suppose that the rotating motion of Se(2) atom on the axis through the Se(l) and Se(3) atoms will “completely” freeze at 20 K. [For the Se(3) atom, if there is a Se(4) atom next to it, the same discussion we did for the Se(2) atom holds.] With increasing temperature, the rotating mode of Se(2) atom could be thermally excited, since the relative force determined by the structure
89
Figure 5. Schematic diagram for atom arrangements of Se chains. The Se(2) atom rotates on the axis through n the Se(l) and Se(3) atoms. The rotating motion is constrained by two prior free dihedral angles consisting of the next nearest neighbor forces. The same rotating mode for the Se(3) exists with the Se(4) bonding to it.
consisting of two priori free dihedral angles, is fairly weak. Such thermally excited rotating
motion supplies channels to leak the stress or tension by the way of changing the topology of network. The heavily distorted network then relaxes and make the “remaining” (or observed) A1 mode strengthened. When temperature is approaching to 100 K, the rotating modes is totally excited, and thereafter the vibrational peaks start to shift in negative behavior due to anharmonic effects. In our measured samples, the most remarkable positive shift of the A1 mode occurs in the Ge8Se92. For x<0.08, although the positive shift (with the same origin) is expectant, it might be difficult to figure them up strictly because of a smaller population of tetrahedra to form the vibrational density of states (VDOS) that brings big errors in fitting the line shape of A1 mode. Or, the network could settle the stress or tension through the large floppy regions that consist of Sen (n>2) chains surrounding the GeSe4/2-rich region. While for Ge15Se85,
the floppy region that surrounds the rigid region of GeSe4/2 units is not large enough to provide space for the distorted tetrahedra “relaxing”. Nevertheless, we consider the rotating mode in Fig. 5 to be a probable micro-structural explanation for the floppy modes in Secontained covalent network glasses. The same kind of rotating modes has been discussed in the computing analysis for modeling the flexible and rigid regions in proteins [16]. The easy
excited dihedral angles that free the rotating motion of Se(2) and Se(3) in Fig. 5 are assumed as the bananas graphs proposed by Thorpe et al. [4]. In Se-contained glass system, the floppy mode was claimed in the vicinity of 5 meV from the neutron-scattering results of vibrational density of states. Weakly binding forces shift the floppy modes from zero frequency to 5 meV. In figure 4(a), the most positive shift of A 1 mode occurs at 60 K. The relation between the frequency of 5 meV for floppy modes and the critical temperature of ~60 K for the thermal excitation of rotating motion contains rich hints to build a structural picture for the network glasses. It is natural to regard the soft constraint rotating modes as the floppy modes in the realistic floppy glasses. Up to now, most of properties of covalent glasses are discussed at room temperature or higher, at which such “constraint” (weakly binding forces) floppy modes are totally free. That is why the elegant constraint theory works so good [5–11], although the theory settles the problem of networks at 0 K.
Criticality of Stiffness Transition With increasing x, the
of floppy glass is approaching to the rigidity percolation
threshold of (x=0.20). The stiffness transition behavior clearly appears in the temperature dependence of the vibrational modes between 100 K and room temperature where the anharmonic effects determine the essential rules. As shown in Figs. 4(a) and (b), large drops 90
Figure 6. The slope of straight line obtained from the data of each modes in the temperature range of 100–250 K (figure 4). The A1 mode (square) has a fourth time large of the volume obtained from the Se–Se stretching mode( ) for While for they are similar. The solid lines are guide to the eye.
•
of the shifts for both the A 1 mode and the Se–Se mode at room temperature (RT) are observed in the floppy glasses. The RT is the temperature to which the samples were quenched (it should be 0 °C for an accurate discussion), and at which they rested for a long time before the measurement. The lower temperatures (
modes and get well linear fits. The slopes of lines as a function of x and mean coordination number for both the A1 mode and the Se–Se mode are plotted in Fig. 6. A nice convergence of the slopes, like the shifts themselves [Fig. 4(c)], comes to a common value at x=0.22. This is the stiffness transition at which the number of degrees of freedom is equal to the number of constraints [5]. Apparently, all the observed modes shift together at this transition, because the network becomes almost ideally random to realize a maximum mixing of the different local modes. For the rigid glasses, the fact that few Sen (n>2) units are included in the structure is the reason of admixture of all the local modes. Probably the same mixing of Se–Se bending motion (it should be the Se–Se–Ge bending motion) goes into both the A1 and Se–Se stretching modes. So although the local modes of the A1 breathing and the Se-Se stretching have different frequencies, 200 cm – 1 and 255 cm –1 , respectively, the CHANGES in those frequencies (scaled by their frequency at the lowest measured temperature) become the same. This kind of mixing should occur in a long-range scale and well detected by the light-probe technique. It should be stressed that the long-range mixing of vibrational modes is very analogous to critical fluctuations of random system in second-order phase transitions. Comparing the modes mixing (in Fig. 6) in Ge22Se78 and Ge30Se70 glasses, we find that the two modes in Ge3oSe70 glass mix better than those in Ge22Se78. The slope of A1 slightly differ from that of Se-Se mode at (x=0.22). These results should have respect to the transition window in which the glass is not ideally random due to a self-organization. Boolchand et al. has done a systematic study of the width of the transition window and pointed out the completion point ( or x=0.23). For the floppy glasses, the A1 mode shifts much more than the Se–Se bond-stretching mode does. The probable reason is that the mixing of Se–Se bending motion into the bending of Se–Ge–Se permits all the bending modes mixing in the floppy glasses. In other words, the A1 band is not a pure breathing mode because of the admixture of bending modes. Thus,
91
Figure 7. Dynamic phase diagram for Ge-Se glass system. The solid line is the liquidus taken from Ref. [18]. All the data are estimated from the Raman measurement.
the Se–Se stretching mode shows less temperature dependence than the A1 breathing mode in which the soft bending modes are mixed, since the stretching forces are stronger than the bending ones.
CRYSTALLIZATION TENDENCY
An extensive study of the temperature dependence of the spectral shape for the GexSe1–x thin films [17] has been applied to understand the structural changes around and above the glass transition temperature, Tg . In general, the spectrum is accumulated for 10 minutes at each measured temperature which is fixed within and the rate of increase of the temperature between two successive measurements is 2–5 °C/min. For each composition, all the spectra are obtained within ~10 hours. In the vicinity of stoichiometic composition, or the medium range structures of Sen chain or GeSe2 fragments that are topologically similar to the layered crystalline GeSe2, respectively, dominantly contribute to the changes. In the glasses at intermediate composition, the two structural units mix well. With increasing temperature above the Tg, the low viscosity of the SCL enables us to detect the structural changes within our measurement periods. Thus, we define the Tg, obtained by Raman measurement, as the onset of the changes of spectral shapes. Heating the glasses thereafter, characteristic lines of crystalline
(c-) Se or c-GeSe2 may appear in the spectra and disappear at higher temperatures. We term the recrystallization temperature Tc and the melting point Tm as the temperatures at which the crystalline peaks appear and disappear, respectively, regardless of whether the sample is stoichiometic (x = 0, 0.33). The phase diagram of Fig. 7 summarizes the results for Tg (square),
92
and
The Tg (square) from Raman result is in a good agreement
with the result
from DSC measurement [17]. The present values for Tm agree with the
results of Ref. [18], where the liquidus line indicates the primary crystallization temperature for c-GeSe2 or c-Se. For x<0.04, as the small amount of GeSe4/2 tetrahedra fails to prevent the crystallization of Se, mixtures of c-Se and liquid Ge x Se1–x appear between the liquid and super-cooled liquid (SCL) states. While, for x>0.18, the large amount of GeSe4/2 tetrahedra builds a medium-range structure topologically similar to the layered c-GeSe2 to promote the crystallization of GeSe2. For since the time for the (Se)n chains forming the long-
range order is longer than the experimental time period, neither c-Se nor c-GeSe2 appears. Embryo of c-GeSe2 constructs in SCL state for x>0.10, however, only those of x>0.18 evolve into nuclei and crystallize. Here, we define a crystallization ability (CA) by a ratio of crystallizable temperature range to SCL range, using the Raman measurement results, and make the CA to be unit for the glass transferring directly from glassy to liquid phase. The crystallization tendency derives from the glass forming tendency (GFT), with the relation of Figure 8 indicates the crystallization tendency, obtained by the Raman measurement, which is very similar to the graph of glass forming difficulty summarized in Ref. [1]. It is worth to mention the recent result of GFT in GexSe1–xglasses from Boolchand’s group [5]. They synthesized homogeneous and strainfree bulk glasses by cooling melts at a very slow rate of 2.5 °C/minute in a T-programmed resistive furnace. The GFT is apparently optimized in the composition range of 0.20<x<0.24 (very similar to the stiffness transition window they found out) where no eutectic effects can be introduced. In accordance with the CA from the Raman result of heating glasses from RT to liquid phase, we do not observe a minimum of CA in the stiffness transition window. It should be noted that our samples are quenched from the temperature 200 °C higher than
the Tm inferred from the liquidus [18]. Thus, in our samples the local structure must quite differ from the structure in the melts during cooling at the rate of 2.5 °C/minute. The local structure, which is restricted to a nanoscale, attracts wide attention, such as the nanophase separation in GeSe2 glass being discussed in the following sections.
Figure 8. Crystallization ability calculated form the dynamics phase diagram (Fig. 7) by equation 2.
93
Figure 9. Three types of typical temperature dependence of the Raman spectra in GeSe2 glasses. Each spectrum is normalized at the most intense peak around 200 cm – 1 . Starting from the Raman spectra at RT, however, the glasses crystallize into (a) the phase, a layered crystal involving both CST and EST units; or (b) the phase, a 3D-network crystal consisting only CST unit; or (c) the phase, for which the Raman spectrum is the first reported.
TRIFURCATED CRYSTALLIZATION AND IN HOMOGENEITY IN GeSe2 GLASS
In this section, we concentrate on the structural changes in GeSe2 glass prior to the crystallization towards three crystalline phases (“trifurcated crystallization”). Thermally induced structural changes are reversible even well below the Tg of ~390 °C. These reversible changes provide an indication that the Ge–Ge wrong bonds bearing a nanophase play an important role on the network stability. Strong correlation between the degree of the structural change and the crystallized phase is discussed in terms of homogeneity in a nanoscale.
Structural changes and crystallizations Free-standing bulk GeSe2 samples are sealed in a silica tube in an argon gas atmosphere (~360 Torr) to reduce evaporation and oxidation effects. Raman spectra are measured using a 1.83 eV laser light with a very low power density of less than 1 W/cm–2. The laser light is focused onto the samples in a ~0.1x4 mm2 rectangular region. Figures 9 (a), (b), and (c) show the three typical temperature dependence of the Raman spectra of GeSe2 glasses from
RT to the crystallization temperatures, Tc. The intense Raman band located at 200 cm –1 at
RT represents an A 1 in-phase breathing vibration of the corner-sharing tetrahedra (CST) [9]. The A 1 companion band at 215 cm – 1 is related to a breathing vibration quasi-localized at edge-sharing tetrahedra (EST). The AG band at 176 cm –1 is interpreted as the stretching mode of Ge–Ge bonds involved in ethane-like units [19, 20]. No distinguishable difference is observed among the Raman spectra of the glasses at RT because all of the measured GeSe2 glasses are prepared at the same conditions. However with increasing temperature, notable spectral changes occur at 300 °C which is well below the Tg of 390 °C.
It was reported that once a crystallization process starts, some of them result in the same crystalline phase as they initially appeared, while some of them transform into other phases after held at the same temperature for an additional long period (~ 60 hours) [21]. In this work, we restrict the discussion of crystalline phase to the initially appeared crystalline phase. We checked the phase transition with keeping temperature for the same as the glasses initially
94
Figure 10. Integrated intensity ratios of the AG band to the A1 band (a–c) and the
band to the A1 band (d–f)
as a function of temperature. The ratios are normalized to those at RT. The GeSe2 glasses crystallize into the phase [(a) and (d)], the phase [(b) and (e)], and the phase [(c) and (f)]. Lines guide to the eye. The error
bars are within the symbols. Two measurement results for each case of crystallization are picked up from over 50 measurements (samples).
crystallizing and found that the phase (low temperature phase) is tending to transform to the phase (high temperature one). Figure 10 depicts the temperature dependence of the integrated intensity ratios of S(AG)/S(A1) and normalized to those at RT. The GeSe2 glass crystallizes into the phase (2D) when the intensity ratios decrease slightly with temperature, and they start to increase above Tg. The increases that relates to the glass transition will be discussed later. The phase (3D) is obtained when the decreases of the ratios are larger than the case of the phase occurring. The Raman spectra of the thermally formed and phases are in agreement with those of previous works [9, 22]. An unreported Raman spectrum of a crystalline phase [Fig. 9(c)] appears when the ratios show the largest decreases among the three types of the crystallization processes. This Raman spectrum is similar to that of the except the low-frequency vibrational modes (see, Fig. 11). We assign this crystalline phase to the phase which was reported to be appearing when Se-rich GexSe1–x glasses (0.15<x<0.32) were well annealed [23, 24]. According to the similarity of the position of Raman band relevant to the vibrations of CST in crystals around 200 cm – 1 , we conclude that the phase is composed of CST units. The details of the phase, such as the basic structural units, are future work. We confirmed that the spectrum of Fig. 9(c) was also observed in the cases of Ge28Se72 and Ge30Se70 glasses being well annealed. The two Se-rich glasses always crystallize into the phase in contrast to the trifurcated crystallization behavior in GeSe2 glasses. The crystallization to the phase always follows a strong growth of a Raman band around 260 cm – 1 (in Fig. 9(c) at 300 °C for example). This strong Raman band has been assigned to the stretching mode of Se–Se bonds [12, 13]. A weak growth of the same Raman band can be distinguished during the process to the a crystallization. The strong growth of the Se–Se mode is in accordance with the fact
95
Figure 11. Expanded view of the Raman spectra of thermally formed crystals shown in Fig. 9(a–c). The spectrum of the is similar to the around 200 cm – 1 but is different in the low frequency –1 range; for example, the Raman peaks at 25 cm and 60 cm – 1 of the are very weak in the spectrum of the and the peak at 90 c m – 1 of the is hardly observed in the spectrum of the A slight admixture of the different phases might happen.
that the
phase is formed by annealing Se-rich glasses as well.
A mixture of the and phases appears after the changes of the intensity ratios whose degree is between those towards the pure and -phases crystallization. Similarly, a mixture of and phases is also observed. Thus, the crystallized phase is strictly determined by the degree of the decreases of the integrated intensity ratios, and S(A G )/S(A 1 ). The close correlation between the changes of the integrated intensity ratios and the crystallized phase suggests the creation and annihilation of structural units besides the deformation
of the units, which also decrease the Raman intensity due to breaking symmetry of the structural units. Figure 12 shows temperature dependence of the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of A1 and bands. The FWHM for the AC band should be more valuable (interesting) to the following discussion if we can measure the extremely weak AG band at high temperature in a good quality. The width of the A1 band first increases with temperature, and then decreases while that of the band increases monotonically. The lower temperature at which the width of A1 band starts to decrease, the more the integrated intensity ratios decrease. Because the degree of the decreases of the S(A G )/S(A 1 ) is much larger than the in all the samples, the breaking of Ge–Ge wrong bonds should play a dominant role on the structural changes. The Ge–Ge wrong bonds are expected to be transformed by heating to energetically more favored Ge–Se bonds. By this transformation, the CST units are formed from ethanelike Ge-Ge units. We believe that a growth of the CST units at the expense of the Ge–Ge bonds promotes an ordering of the CST units to reduce the FWHM of the A1 band. The is consistent with the crystallization of the and phases after the larger decrease of the S(A G )/S(A 1 ) than the phase. The and phases, which are composed of only CST units, should be formed though the higher degree of CST formation.
96
Figure 12. Temperature dependence of the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the A1 band (a), and the band (b) in the GeSe2 glasses which are crystallizing towards the phase the phase ( ), and the phase by further heating. Lines are added to guide the eye. The FWHM of the A1 band increases with temperature and then starts to decrease while that of the band increases monotonically.
•
Medium-range Order of GeSe2 Glass The phase is realized through the least structural changes among the three types of the crystallization processes. The fact stresses that fragments topologically similar to the crystalline phase are significantly involved in the network of GeSe2 glasses. These fragments are larger than the Ge–Ge and CST units, and they are randomly oriented. When GeSe2 glass is heated over the Tg, a lower viscosity yields the local structure to be rearranged more easily. In Fig. 9(a), the increases of the intensity ratios above Tg is assumed as the trend toward the nucleation for crystallization of Thus, the structure of GeSe2 glass is similar to the phase, hence, the large degree of formation of CST units is needed to crystallize into the or
phases. Boolchand et al. [25] have recently suggested that, in the Ge-rich Ge x Se 1–x glasses the presence of Ge–Ge signatures decreases the global connectivity, and it constitutes part of an ethane-like units bearing nanophase formed separately from the GeSe4/2
tetrahedra bearing backbone of the glass. Together with our results, it follows that the ethanlike units involving Ge–Ge bonds and like fragments coexist in the melt-quenched GeSe2 glass. We can observe the trifurcated behavior in GeSe2 and Ge35Se65 glasses, but, we can never observe it in Ge28Se72 and Ge30Se70 glasses. Instead, the Se-rich glasses always crystallize into the phase. Therefore, the Ge–Ge nanophase seems to be the physical origin of the trifurcated crystallization. Generally, disordered materials are more or less inhomogeneous or heterogeneous. For instance, the importance of the inhomogeneity to understand the dynamics at the glass transition has been indicated experimentally [26] and theoretically [27]. Here, we assume an inhomogeneous distribution of the Ge–Ge nanophases. The size of the Ge–Ge phase and the surrounding situation, such as the sorts of surrounding units and the surrounding stresses, are nanoscopically inhomogeneous. Since the laser spot size is 0.1x4 mm2, no evidence of
inhomogeneity is able to be detected among the samples at RT. With increasing temperature, 97
the ethane-like Ge–Ge units are selectively transformed to the CST units. A large size of Ge–Ge nanophase transforms to a large one of the CST region, and thereafter the CST region might grow at higher temperature. However, if the size of Ge–Ge nanophase is smaller than a critical volume, it is not transforming to the CST region. Because larger CST units is more stable due to the gain in volume free energy of a phase composed of CST units at high temperatures. Thus, the degree of formation of CST units spatially differs. When the gain in volume free energy of the CST phase can compensate a larger CST region for the cost in interfacial free energy, the CST formation will produce a nucleus to form the or phases.
The resultant crystalline phase, or seems to be determined by the degree of formation of the Se-chain clusters. Note that a stronger increase of the Se-chain vibrational mode lead the crystallization to the phase [Fig. 9(c)]. The difference in the degree of formation of the Se-chain clusters is also due to the inhomogeneity in an initial distribution of Se–Se bonds and the surrounding situation. On the other hand, if the degree of the CST formation is low and the size is smaller than the critical size above Tg, the like fragments will grow to form the phase. Thus, the appearance of three crystalline phases depends on the degree of the formation of structural units of CST and Se-chain. The nature of the trifurcated crystallization is attributed to the inhomogeneous network that consists of nanoscopically phase-separated structural units.
Figure 13. Integrated intensity ratio of the A G band to the A1 band (a, b) and the ratio of the band to the A1 band (c, d) as a function of temperature. The ratios are normalized to those at RT. The as-quenched sample is heated to and kept at 300 °C for five hours, and thereafter, it is cooled to RT. (a, c) show the first cycle of the heat treatment and (b, d) the second one. Lines are added to guide the eye. The error bars are less than the size of the symbols.
The reason why our samples show such a clear trifurcated behavior is that our meltquench temperature of 960 °C is 220 °C higher than the liquidus [18, 23]. The percentage of the Ge–Ge units in GeSe2 glasses increases with quench temperature [28], and the high temperature quenching will increase the inhomogeneity in the distribution of Ge–Ge units. We should note that the existence of the Ge–Ge nanophase and its inhomogeneity is intrinsic, because the annealed samples also show the trifurcated behavior. A higher temperature quenching process just enhances such properties. 98
Reversibility and stability
The reversibility and stability of the GeSe2 glasses are investigated by heating and cooling free-standing bulk glasses as follow. As-quenched GeSe2 sample is heated to and kept at 300 °C (below the Tg) for five hours, and thereafter, it was cooled to RT. Figure 13 shows the normalized integrated intensity ratios, and S(AG)/S(A1), in the first [Figs. 13(a,c)] and the second [Figs. 13(b,d)] heating cycles. The changes of the intensity ratios with temperature are nearly reversible in the first cycle, and they are fully reversible in the second one. The slightly irreversible parts in the first cycle are due to usual annealing effects. Changes of FWHM’s are also reversible. The reversibility confirms that the thermally transformed structures are stable at each fixed temperature during the experiment time scale (15 minute). The stable structure depends on temperature, and it is realized within a minute. At higher temperature, the structure similar to the phase or phase, which consists of CST units, is more stable than that at lower temperature. The recovery of the S(AG)/S(A1) ratio during the cooling process demonstrates that the network at lower temperature prefers to involve a larger percentage of the Ge–Ge wrong bond. In other words, the Ge–Ge homopolar bond in GeSe2 glass may reduce the total free energy of the network at RT, thus, it could not be wrong. It should be stressed that the temperature dependence of the S(AG)/S(A1) ratio is qualitatively the same as that of the ratio. It could be understood in the restricted sense of the local structure that rising the percentage of the Ge–Ge wrong bond are accompanied by a larger population of EST units. The layered fragments that consist of both EST and CST units must be constructed in GeSe2 glass with the help of the Ge–Ge wrong bond. Thus, the Ge–Ge wrong bond plays an indispensable role on the stability of the glassy structure. The reversible structural change from the as-quenched structure to a quasi-three dimensional structure composed of CST units can be caused by pressure [29]. The comparison of
the reversible changes (with temperature and pressure) between the amorphous-amorphous phase transition observed in SiO2 [30, 31], is interesting and it will be discussed elsewhere. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS It is a pleasure to acknowledge J.C. Phillips and P. Boolchand for helpful discussions and suggestions. This paper draws the recent results developed in our laboratory of collaboration and discussions with K. Inoue, O. Matsuda, M. Nakamura, and M.K. Nakamura. This work was supported by Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research (B)(No. 09440117), Encouragement of Young Scientists (No. 11740173), and a grant for Scientific Research in the Priority Area “Cooperative Phenomena in Complex Liquids”, from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture (Japan). Y.W. acknowledges support from the Inamori Foundation.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Phillips, J.C. (1979) Topology of covalent non-crystalline solid I: short-range order in chalcogenide alloys, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 34, 153–181. Phillips, J.C. (1999) Constraint theory, stiffness percolation and the rigidity transition in network glasses, in M.F. Thorpe and P.M. Duxxbury (eds.), Rigidity Theory and Applications, Kluwer Academic / Plenum Publishers, New York, pp. 155–172. Thorpe, M.F. (1983) Continuous deformations in random networks, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 57, 355–370. Thorpe, M.F., Jacobs, D.J., and B.R. (2000) The structure and rigidity of network glasses, in P. Boolchand (ed.) Insulating and semiconducting glasses, World Scientific Press, Singapore, pp. 95–145. Boolchand, P., Feng, X., Selvanathan, D., and Bresser, W.J. (1999) Rigidity transition in chalcogenide glasses, in the book listed in Ref. [2], pp. 279–296.
99
6. 7.
8.
Selvanathan, D., Bresser, W.J., and Boolchand, P. (2000) Stiffness transitions in SixSe1–x glasses from Raman scattering and temperature-modulated differential scanning calorimetry, Phys. Rev. B61, 15061– 15076. Kamitakahara, W.A., Cappelletti, R.L., Boolchand, P., Halfpap, B.L., Gompf, F., Neumann, D.A., and Mutka, H. (1991) Vibrational densities of states and network rigidity in chalcogenide glasses, Phys. Rev. B44, 94–100. Feng, X., Bresser, W.J., and Boolchand, P. (1997) Direct evidence for stiffness threshold in chalcogenides
glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 4422–4425. 9. Murase, K. (2000) Raman Scattering in the book listed in Ref. [4], pp. 415–463. 10. Wang, Y., Nakamura, M., Matsuda, O., and Murase, K. (2000) Raman-spectroscopy studies on rigidity percolation and fragility in Ge–(S,Se) glasses, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 266–269, 872–875. 1 1 . Tatsumisago, M., Halfpap, B.L., Green, J.L., Lindsay, S.M., and Angell, C.A. (1990) Fragility of Ge-As-
Se glass-forming liquids in relation to rigidity percolation, and the Kauzmann paradox, Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 1549–1552.
12. Nemanich, R.J., Connel, G.A.N., Hayes, T.M., and Street, R.A. (1978) Thermally induced effects in evaporated chalcogenide films. I. Structure, Phys. Rev. B18, 6900–6914. 13.
Lucovsky, G. and Galeener, F.L. (1980) Intermediate range order in amorphous solids, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 35&36, 1209–1214.
14.
Murase, K., Inoue, K., and Matsuda, O. (1993) Medium-range structure and relaxation in chalcogenide glasses investigated by Raman scattering, in Y. Sakurai, Y. Hamakawa, T. Masumoto, K. Shirae, and
K. Suzuki (eds.), Current Topics in Amorphous Materials: Science and Technology, Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 47–58.
15.
Nakaoka, T., Wang, Y., Matsuda, O., Inoue, K. and Murase, K. Reversible photoinduced structural changes in GeSe2 glass at low-temperature, in Proc. 25rd Int. Conf. Phys. Semicond., Osaka 2000, H.
Kamimura and T. Ando (eds.), (Springer Verlag, Berlin), to be published in January 2001. 16. Jacobs, D.J., Kuhn, L.A., and Thorpe, M.F. (1999) Flexible and rigid regions in proteins, in the book listed in Ref. [2], pp. 357–384. 17. Wang, Y, Matsuda, O., Inoue, K., Yamamuro, O., Matsuo, T., and Murase, K. (1998) A Raman scattering investigation of the structure of glassy and liquid GexSe1–x, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 232–234, 702–707. 18. Tronc, P., Bensoussan. M., and Brenac, A. (1973) Optical-absorption edge and Raman scattering in
Ge x Se 1–x glasses, Phys. Rev. B8, 5947–5956. 19.
Bridenbaugh, P.M., Espinosa, G.P., Griffiths, J.E., and Phillips, J.C. (1979) Microscopic origin of the
companion A 1 Raman line in glassy Ge(S,Se)2, Phys. Rev. B20, 4140–4144. 20. Jackson, K., Briley, A., Grossman, S., Porezag, D.V., and Pederson, M.R. (1999) Raman-active modes of a-GeSe2 and a-GeS2: A first-principles study, Phys. Rev. B60, R14985–R14989. 21. Sakai, K, Yoshino, K., Fukuyama, A., Yokoyama, H., Ikari, T., and Maeda., K, (2000) Crystallization of
amorphous GeSe2 semiconductor by isothermal annealing without light radiation, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 39, 1058-1061.
22. Nakaoka, T., Wang, Y., Murase, K., Matsuda, O., and Inoue, K. (2000) Resonant Raman scattering in crystalline GeSe2, Phys. Rev. B61, 15569-15572. 23. Azoulay, R., Thibierge, H., and Brenac. A. (1975) Devitrification characteristics of GexSe1–x, glasses, J. 24.
Non-Cryst. Solids 18, 33-53. Stølen, S., Johnsen, H.B., Bøe, C.S., Grande, T., and Karlsen, O.B. (1999) Stable and metastable phase
equilibria in the GeSe2-Se system, J. Phase Equilib. 20, 17–28. 25.
Boolchand. P. and Bresser, W.J. (2000) The structural origin of broken chemical order in GeSe2 glass,
26.
Moynihan, C.T. and Schroeder, J. (1993) Non-exponential structural relaxation, anomalous light scat-
Phil. Mag. B, to be published. tering and nanoscale inhomogenities in glass-forming liquids, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 160, 52–59; Cicerone, M.T. and Ediger, M.D. (1995) Relaxation of spatially heterogeneous dynamic domains in su-
percooled ortho-terphenyl, J. Chem. Phys. 103, 5684–5692. 27. 28.
29.
Doliwa, B. and Heuer, A. (1998) Consequences of kinetic inhomogeneities in glassess, Phys. Rev. E54, 1652–1662. Petri, I., Salmon, P.S., and Howells, W.S. (1999) Change in the topology of the glass forming liquid
GeSe2 with increasing temperature, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 11, 10219–10227. Murase, K and Fukunaga, T, (1984) Pressure induced structural change of clusters in chalcogenide glasses, in P.C. Taylor and S.G. Bishop (eds.) Optical effects in amorphous semiconductors, A1P Conf. Proc. No. 120 (AIP, New York), pp. 449–456.
30.
Poole, P.H., Grande, T., Angell, C.A., and McMillan, P.P. (1997) Polymorphic phase transitions in liquids and glasses, Science275, 322–323. 31. Lacks, D.J. (2000) First-order amorphous-amorphous transformation in silica, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 4629–
4633.
100
SOLIDITY OF VISCOUS LIQUIDS
J.C. DYRE Department of Mathematics and Physics (IMFUFA), Roskilde University, Postbox 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
INTRODUCTION The glass transition takes place when a liquid upon cooling becomes more and more viscous and finally solidifies to form a glassy solid [1-7]. Most liquids that are able to form glasses are supercooled and thus not in genuine thermal equilibrium, but this fact is probably not important for understanding the dramatic increase in viscosity preceding glass formation. Approaching the glass transition the viscosity becomes so large that molecular motion is arrested on the time-scale of the experiment. The fascination of this phenomenon from a theorist point of view lies in the fact that chemically quite different liquids – involving ionic interactions, covalent bonds, van der Waals forces, hydrogen bonds, or even metallic bonds – have a number of properties in common when they are in the very viscous regime, close to the glass transition temperature Tg. These general properties can be summarized into three “non’s”: • Non-Arrhenius temperature-dependence of the average relaxation time. • Non-Debye linear response. • Non-linearity of structural relaxation even with respect to quite small temperature changes (i.e., 1% of Tg). The last “non” is not very interesting, because non-linearity is unavoidable whenever the relaxation time is strongly temperature dependent. This is true independent of whether the relaxation time is Arrhenius or not, and independent of whether there is just one relaxation time or a whole relaxation time spectrum. Our focus here is on the two first “non”s. Before proceeding, let us briefly remind the reader of them. Almost all viscous liquids have viscosities and average relaxation times that are non-Arrhenius. This is perhaps not very puzzling, given the fact that it is likely a priori that not just one single energy barrier is involved in viscous liquid dynamics. What is puzzling, however, is the “sign” of the non-Arrhenius behavior: Whenever a range of activation energies is involved any naive model predicts an apparent activation energy which
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
101
decreases as temperature decreases; this is because at low temperatures the system prefers the “reaction channels” with lowest energy barriers. However, as is clear from Fig. 1, precisely the opposite behavior is observed:
Figure 1. Angell’s famous plot of the viscosity of a number of viscous liquids [8], giving the logarithm of the viscosity as a function of Tg/T. If the viscosity is Arrhenius this plot gives a straight line (diagonal). Almost all viscous liquids have apparent activation energies (= slope in the plot) which increase as temperature is lowered.
The non-Arrhenius behavior is one of the great mysteries of this research field. Another great mystery is the origin of the non-Debye linear response functions. Typical linear response quantities are dielectric relaxation, frequency-dependent shear or bulk moduli, or frequency-dependent specific heat. The Debye linear response is given by
Via the fluctuation-dissipation theorem this corresponds to a time autocorrelation function that is a simple exponential. Except for certain mono-alcohols Debye relaxation is never observed. Instead, one always observes loss peaks (imaginary parts of response functions) that are asymmetrically deformed towards the high frequency side (Fig. 2): Below the loss peak frequency the response function follows Eq. (1), above the loss peak frequency the loss typically decays as where is often close to 0.5 [see, e.g., Ref. 9 and its references]. Despite many years of research and thousands of measurements there is no consensus on the origin of the non-Debye behavior. The puzzle is not so much why Debye behavior is rarely observed, but rather why
not much broader response functions are observed [10]. If one again naively thinks in terms of energy barriers, the “correct” barrier distribution has a very sharp high energy cut-off and is an exponential towards low energies with a width which is only 5-10% of the maximum activation energy, the activation energy of the loss peak frequency itself. In this paper we shall discuss the physics of viscous liquids from a (perhaps) simplistic point of view. We shall argue that these liquids are more like solids than like ordinary liquids 102
Figure 2. Typical loss peaks for a viscous liquid. The figure shows the dielectric loss of triphenyl phosphite at 206.0 K, 208.0 K, and 210.0 K [10]. Below the loss peak frequency the behavior is as predicted by the Debye
expression Eq. (1)
but above the peak the loss follows an
-decay. At very high frequencies the
so-called relaxation is visible.
and that this “solidity” explains both the non-Arrhenius and the non-Debye behaviors. First, we consider how a viscous liquid flows at all, by asking: Is a viscous liquid like an ordinary liquid (e.g., water) or is it qualitatively different? ARE VISCOUS LIQUIDS “JUST” LIQUIDS THAT ARE VISCOUS?
Any medium described by ordinary hydrodynamics in the long wave-length limit has a shear viscosity, As shown by Maxwell, if denotes the instantaneous shear modulus the shear relaxation time is related to the viscosity by
According to this equation ordinary liquids like water have relaxation times in the picosecond range. In contrast, a liquid approaching the glass transition has a viscosity typically 1015 times larger than that of water and thereby a relaxation time of 1000 seconds or longer. This
enormous difference justifies asking whether there are qualitative differences between the two cases. The decoupling of relaxation times from phonon times as viscosity increases is reflected in a dramatic decoupling of diffusion constants: For “ordinary” liquids the molecular diffusion constant D is of the same order of magnitude as the transverse momentum diffusion constant, the dynamic viscosity of the Navier-Stokes equation is mass density]. With increasing viscosity D decreases – as according to a simple Stokes-Einstein type argument – while increases. At the glass transition is about 1030 times larger than D. The physical interpretation of the very long relaxation times of viscous liquids is simple: If s it takes roughly 100 s for a molecule to move one intermolecular distance. This interpretation is somewhat modified by the existence of dynamic heterogeneities and of the
103
relaxation, but basically there is no reason to question this picture. How can molecular movement be so slow? Again the answer is simple: Average velocities, of course, are determined by temperature, so molecular motion can only be slow because it is ineffective. It is ineffective because almost all motion is vibrational. The vibrations take place around a potential energy minimum in configuration space. For the vibrations to persist for billions and billions of times before anything else happens to the molecules, there must be rather large barriers for jumping into a neighboring minimum. The jumps are referred to as “flow events.” It is the existence of these rare flow events which eventually allows a viscous liquid to flow, but clearly the liquid looks like a solid on shorter time scales. It is interesting to note that this picture is almost as old as the research field itself. Thus Kauzmann referred to flow events as “jumps of molecular units of flow between different positions of equilibrium in the liquid’s quasicrystalline lattice” [1]. He thereby emphasized the fact that a viscous liquid most of the time is in a state of mechanical equilibrium. The flow event picture [11], which has never really been challenged, was recently confirmed by extensive computer simulations of a highly viscous Lennard-Jones mixture [12]. The “solid-like-ness” of viscous liquids – the fact that these liquids are virtually always in a state of mechanical equilibrium – we shall refer to as their “solidity” [13,14]. Solidity expresses the simple fact that on a short time scale there is only vibration. For instance, simulating a liquid with an average relaxation time around 1 s on the fastest computer available today would be a real disappointment: Only vibrations would be visible and one cannot possibly tell the difference between the viscous liquid and a solid. When a flow event finally
does take place, after a short time there is again mechanical equilibrium in the surroundings and the molecules vibrate over and over, now just around a slightly different potential energy minimum [15]. The effects of one flow event in the surroundings is discussed in detail in Refs. 13 and 14. There is a displacement field varying as where r is the distance to the flow event. This result is found by a straightforward application of solid elasticity theory. It is important to note that the solidity of viscous liquids has only a finite range [13]. Thus there is a “solidity length” l beyond which flow events effectively do not induce molecular motions at all. To estimate l we note that elastic displacements propagate with the velocity of sound, c. Consider a sphere with radius R. Within this sphere, if r0 is the size of one rearranging region, there are roughly possible locations for flow events. A molecule at the center of the sphere only feels the full effects from a flow event within the sphere if the following condition is obeyed: The displacement deriving from such a flow event must propagate throughout the sphere and elastic equilibrium be reestablished before another flow event takes place. Since is the average time between two flow events involving the same molecules, the time between two flow events within the sphere is This time must be longer than or equal to R/c. To estimate l we use equality for R = l and note that c is the sound velocity of the glass, cglass. This leads to the following expression for the solidity length l
The solidity length diverges slowly as
When
l
is several thousand Angstroms.
“SHOVING” MODEL OF NON-ARRHENIUS BEHAVIOR
According to the solidity picture, molecules in a viscous liquid have to overcome a relatively large energy barrier in order to move. The non-Arrhenius behavior means that the barrier is temperature dependent. For simplicity, we shall not distinguish between energy
barriers and free energy barriers. If the barrier is denoted by and prefactor (of order 1 picosecond), the average relaxation time is given by 104
is a typical
Experiments (Fig. 1) imply that to understand why.
increases as temperature decreases. The challenge is
Elsewhere we have briefly reviewed the two standard models for non-Arrhenius behavior, the entropy model and the free volume model, and critiques against these models [7]. The alternative “shoving” model is based on the following picture, which involves postulates similar to those of the free volume model: Molecules in a liquid are closely packed, so in order to be able to rearrange – for a flow event to take place – extra space is needed. This is the first postulate. A further input to the model is the well-known fact that intermolecular interactions are strongly anharmonic with harsh repulsions but only weak attractions. It is these harsh repulsions which makes it unfavorable (i.e., too energy costly) to rearrange at constant volume. To lower the barrier the molecules therefore shove aside the surrounding molecules. Let us quantify these ideas. Suppose the rearranging molecules constitute a sphere which at the transition state has increased its radius by The surrounding liquid behaves entirely like a solid during the flow event. Therefore, the energy needed for expanding the sphere is quadratic in The energy barrier to be overcome inside the sphere is given by some function so the total barrier is for some constant A given by Minimizing this leads to Thus, the ratio between the “shoving” work and the “inner” barrier, is given by
Because of the harsh intermolecular repulsions the logarithmic derivative of f must be numerically much larger than one (reflecting the fact that a lot is gained by not rearranging at
constant volume). Consequently, 1 and the “inner” contribution to the activation energy is small. The “shoving” model is characterized by ignoring this contribution. The next step is to determine the “shoving” work. What happens when a sphere in a solid is enlarged? Many people answer that the surroundings must be compressed in the process, but this is wrong. The deformation of the surroundings is a pure shear deformation. In fact, this is a standard exercise in elasticity theory, where one finds [16] that the radial displacement field varies as We know from Coulomb’s law that this field has zero divergence. Since the divergence of the displacement field is the relative volume change, there is no compression. This means that the relevant elastic constant for the “shoving” work is the shear modulus. Now, the shear modulus of any liquid is zero at zero frequency, but on short time scales the liquid behaves like a solid with shear modulus This quantity is crucial to the “shoving” model, because the activation energy is proportional to It is well-known that in viscous liquids increases strongly as temperature is lowered, and this is now our explanation for the non-Arrhenius behavior [7,17]. The final expression for is:
Here, Vc is a proportionality constant with dimension volume. In comparing to experiment Vc is always of order the volume of one molecule. The mathematical expression Eq. (6) may be traced back to 1943 (see, e.g., Refs. 5, 7, and 17).
As a model for the non-Arrhenius behavior the “shoving” model is not fundamental; it does not allow a calculation of the energy barrier because Vc is unknown. Instead, the model is phenomenological in the sense that it links the energy barrier to another macroscopic
physical quantity. In this respect the model is like the entropy model. The “shoving” model,
105
however, has the unique feature of linking short time dynamics with long time dynamics:
reflects short time dynamics and may be measured by a fast experiment. Note also that may be calculated as a simple statistical mechanical canonical average (of the square of the fluctuating shear stress), so if the model is correct a considerable simplification has been achieved. Before comparing the “shoving” model to experiment, we briefly summarize its basic postulates:
• The main contribution to the activation energy is elastic energy. • This elastic energy is located in the surroundings of the reorienting molecules. • The elastic energy is shear energy. It is easy to compare the model to experiment. One simply measures [or equivalently, and to check Eq. (6). It is convenient to use an Angell type plot for this. Instead of having Tg/T as x-axis, however, we use normalized to one at T = Tg. Figure 3 gives two examples. The data confirm the model. More measurements are needed, however, before the model can be said to be well-established. Since the “shoving” model predicts that the rate of relaxation depends on the instantaneous shear modulus, the model should apply even for nonlinear relaxations. This has recently been tested in aging experiments on a silicone oil [19]. The liquid was subjected to
sudden temperature jumps from well annealed states, and was continuously monitored as a probe of the structural relaxation. By using the Tool-Narayanaswami formalism with a reduced time definition based on Eq. (6) it was shown that the model is able to fully account for the aging observed. A DIFFUSION-TYPE MODEL OF NON-DEBYE RELAXATIONS
We now proceed to discuss relaxation phenomena in viscous liquids. Only linear relaxations, i.e., those governing how infinitesimal perturbations decay to equilibrium, are considered. Moreover, the discussion focusses on the so-called a relaxation, the slowest and the dominant relaxation process. The relaxation process defines the average relaxation time which is linked to viscosity by Eq. (2). How does one construct a model exhibiting the kind of asymmetric relaxation seen in Fig. 2? We look for a model based on the solidity of viscous liquids, predicting a sharp cut-off at long relaxation time and an high frequency decay of the loss. Two points of views may be taken towards linear responses of viscous liquids: 1) There are a number of different response functions, all of which are more or less of equal status, probing different autocorrelation functions. Alternatively, 2) some response functions are regarded as more fundamental than others. We adopt the latter viewpoint: The condition of mechanical equilibrium is a zero-divergence condition referring to the stress tensor. This puts stress tensor fluctuations in focus. Consequently, we shall regard the frequency-dependent shear and bulk moduli as the two basic linear response function (the bulk modulus exists in two versions, the adiabatic and the isothermal – here only the isothermal bulk modulus is considered). Other response functions should somehow be derived from the mechanical ones. For example, a rotating sphere model for dielectric relaxation links the dielectric response to the frequency-dependent viscosity (or shear modulus). Consider the shear modulus. The -decay of the shear loss at high frequencies, which is to be reproduced by our model, means that at high frequencies one has (in dimensionless units): Since where is the shear stress, we find that at short times the stress autocorrelation function is given (again in dimensionless units) by 106
Figure 3. Comparing “shoving” model predictions to experiments on molecular liquids (reproduced from Ref. 17). (a) shows our own data, while (b) replots old data of Barlow and coworkers [18]. For both data sets the actual temperature dependence of the viscosity is plotted just as in Fig. 1. Also, the viscosity is plotted as a function of the variable normalized to one at T = Tg. The diagonal line gives the predictions of the “shoving” model, starting at high temperature at a physically reasonable prefactor (lower left corner).
The model we adopt is a diffusion model. The idea is that the stress averaged over some small volume of the liquid (containing, e.g., 100 molecules) – although it changes abruptly whenever a flow event takes place – changes by only a small amount. If so, it might be a good
guess to try to describe the process by a diffusion equation in stress space. This space has 6 coordinates, the 6 independent values of the stress tensor. The diffusion constant must be thermally activated if relaxation is to become strongly temperature dependent. We know that when a large shear stress is applied to a set of molecules
107
they are much more likely to rearrange than otherwise (this is the mechanism behind fracture in its initial stage). Thus a large shear stress lowers the barrier, so the barrier must depend on the stress state. This means that in stress space the diffusion constant depends exponentially on the stress state. Denoting the 6 stress coordinates collectively by our first guess at a diffusion equation for the probability is
Here the diffusion constant is given by where is the stressdependent activation energy. All stress states are regarded as equally likely, but the allowed stress states define only a finite region of stress space. This region is bounded by the states with Diffusion out of this region is forbidden; in the model this is ensured by a suitable boundary condition. This model cannot possibly reproduce Eq. (7), however. For any activation energy that varies down to zero at large stresses, the model gives precisely the kind of very broad loss peaks that are naively expected (and not found in experiments) when a whole range of activation energies are involved. However, we have not yet taken solidity into account. How does this change things? Because of the mechanical equilibrium condition – the solidity – stress changes at one place cannot take place without minor stress changes throughout the viscous liquid. Both before and after a flow event there is mechanical equilibrium, so the stress change must also satisfy the zero-divergence condition. As shown in Refs. 13 and 14 this implies that the stress change in the surroundings varies as and is thus long ranged. Locally, stress may change either as a result of a local flow event or as a result of flow events in the surroundings. The latter changes are small, but quite common, and they are independent of the actual stress state. Thus, we find that the stress diffusion constant has two contributions and is given by
When a large range of activation energies is involved, depending on the actual value of this expression is dominated by either the first term or the last term. In stress space there is a rather sharp edge separating these two cases. On one side of this edge (the “slow” part
of stress space) is almost stress independent while on the other side of the edge varies rapidly and is generally much larger than D (the “fast” part of stress space). The linear size of the slow part of stress space, L, defines a characteristic time by As becomes clear below, is the average relaxation time of the relaxation. How does the model with Eq. (9) reproduce Eq. (7) and the asymmetry of the loss peak? First, we note that there is a cut-off at long relaxation times: Relaxation towards equilibrium can at most last the time it takes to diffuse across the slow part of stress space, The square root time dependence of the initial stress decay comes about in the following way: Stress states close to the edge, but in the slow part of stress space, preferably relax by moving to the edge and crossing it to utilize the fact that motion is fast on the other side. The limiting factor is the time it takes to move to the edge. For systems a distance d away from the edge this time is given by t = d2/D. When d is small the number of states a distance less than d away from the edge is proportional to d. Thus the number of states relaxing within time t varies as This gives us Eq. (7). It is interesting to note that for the model to work properly, there must be relaxations much faster than those of the a relaxation. We tentatively identify these fast relaxations with the Goldstein-Johari relaxation.
108
SUMMARY
The solidity of viscous liquids is the key to understanding the physics of these liquids. Solidity is a direct consequence of the extremely high viscosity. Thus the similarity between chemically quite different liquids becomes less surprising. If this viewpoint is correct, understanding the physics of viscous liquids may be simpler than has hitherto been recognized. REFERENCES 1.
2. 3. 4.
5. 6. 7.
8. 9. 10.
11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
16. 17. 18. 19.
Kauzmann, W. (1948) The nature of the glassy state and the behavior of liquids at low temperatures, Chem. Rev. 43, 219-256. Harrison, G. (1976) The dynamic properties of supercooled liquids, Academic Press, New York. Brawer, S. (1985) Relaxation in viscous liquids and glasses, American Ceramic Society, Columbus, OH. Angell, C.A. (1991) Relaxation in liquids, polymers and plastic crystals - strong/fragile patterns and problems, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 131-133, 13-31. Nemilov, S.V. (1995) Thermodynamic and kinetic aspects of the vitreous state, CRC, Boca Raton, FL. Debenedetti, P.O. (1996) Metastable liquids: Concepts and Principles, Princeton University Press, Princeton. Dyre, J.C. (1998) Source of non-Arrhenius average relaxation time in glass-forming liquids, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 235-257, 142-149. Angell, C.A. (1985) Strong and fragile liquids, in K.L. Ngai and G. B. Wright (eds.) Relaxations in complex systems, U.S. G.P.O., Washington, DC, pp. 3-11. Olsen, N.B., Christensen, T., and Dyre, J.C. (2000) Time-temperature superposition in viscous liquids, e-print cond-mat/0006165. Voit, P., Tarjus, G., and Kivelson, D. (2000) A heterogeneous picture of relaxation for fragile supercooled liquids, J. Chem. Phys. 112, 10368-10378. Dyre, J.C. (1987) Master-equation approach to the glass transition, Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 792-795. Schrøder, T.B., Sastry, S., Dyre, J.C., and Glotzer, S.C. (2000) Crossover to potential energy landscape dominated dynamics in a model glass-forming liquid, J. Chem. Phys. 112, 9834-9840. Dyre, J.C. (1999) Solidity of viscous liquids, Phys. Rev. E 59, 2458-2459. Dyre, J.C. (1999) Solidity of viscous liquids. II. Anisotropic flow events, Phys. Rev. E 59, 7243-7245. Goldstein, M. (1969) Viscous liquids and the glass transition: A potential energy barrier picture, J. Chem. Phys. 51, 3728-3739. Landau, L.D., and Lifshitz, E.M. (1970) Theory of elasticity, Pergamon Press, Oxford. Dyre, J.C., Olsen, N.B., and Christensen, T. (1996) Local elastic expansion model for viscous-flow activation energies of glass-forming molecular liquids, Phys. Rev. B 53, 2171-2174. Barlow, A.J., Lamb, J., Matheson, A.J., Padmini, P.R.K.L., and Richter, J. (1967) Viscoelastic relaxation of supercooled liquids. I Proc. Roy. Soc. A 298, 467- 480. Olsen, N.B., Dyre, J.C., and Christensen, T. (1998) Structural relaxation monitored by instantaneous shear modulus, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 1031-1033.
109
This page intentionally left blank
NON-ERGODIC DYNAMICS IN SUPERCOOLED LIQUIDS
M. Dzugutov, S. Simdyankin and F. Zetterling Department of Numerical Analysis Royal Institute of Technology 100 44 Stockholm, SWEDEN
INTRODUCTION The nature of the glassy state and the liquid-glass transition admittedly remains the most interesting unsolved problem of the solid state theory [1,2]. The interest is focused on two universal features observed in the liquids which remain in a (possibly metastable)
equilibrium when approaching the glass transition. In fragile glass-formers [3], a superArrhenius increase of the relaxation time is observed below a characteristic temperature TA, leading to an apparent solidification at a finite temperature Tg. Simultaneously, these liquids exhibit another feature, related to the first one, the stretched-exponential decay of the time correlation functions. Laboratory glass transition is defined as a point where the relaxation time of a supercooled liquid exceeds the experimentally accessible observation time. A liquid cooled below the glass transition temperature thus remains, on the experimental time-scale, in a nonequilibrium state, being unable to comprehensively explore the relevant area of its configurational space. Viewed from this point, Tg is commonly regarded as a crossover temperature separating the ergodic and non-ergodic regimes of the supercooled liquid dynamics. It is clear that this definition is not helpful for understanding the possible transformation in the behaviour of a liquid undergoing the glass transition. Indeed, the observation time limit affordable for an experimentalist involved in the study of the glass transition is not a relevant quantity for the description of relaxation processes in a supercooled liquid, and, therefore, both the glass transition and the ergodicity breaking as defined in the above way may be regarded as just artifacts of observation. In order to address this issue, we need an operational definition of ergodicity breaking that would indicate a criterion for discerning a possible change in the phase-space behaviour of a liquid in the the glass transition domain from the macroscopic observations. Moreover, this criterion should be formulated in terms of equilibrium liquid parameters. The ergodic aspects of the glass-transition can be considered in the context of a longstanding problem known as the Kauzmann paradox [4]. The latter is an observation that the extrapolation of experimental results for the specific heat in supercooled liquids leads
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
111
to zero value of the configurational entropy at finite temperature. This can be interpreted as indicating an underlying phase transition [5]. The existence, the nature, and the possible
location of such a transition are key issues for the problem of glass transition. Two possible scenarios can be considered. The mode-coupling theory [6] interprets the characteristic dynamics observed in the supercooled domain, and the eventual glass transition, as a purely dynamical equilibrium phenomenon arising as a result of an inherent feedback
mechanism - the so-called cage effect whereby the diffusive dynamics is coupled with the structural relaxation. Liquid dynamics remains in equilibrium as it slows down under cooling to complete structural arrest which in the idealized version of the theory occurs at a critical temperature Tc. In this context, the condition of ergodic equilibrium implies that the local structural fluctuations relax sufficiently fast so that the liquid remains spatially homogeneous on the time scale relevant for the diffusion. The theory thus circumvent the problem of Kauzmann paradox. A number of experimental observations, however, indicate a different scenario. It was found that, in the vicinity of Tg, structural relaxations in a number of glass-formers become significantly retarded as compared with the diffusive dynamics, breaking the Stokes-Einstein relation. This observation was interpreted as indicating that the liquid decomposes into subsystems which relax at different rate. Moreover, the slow dynamical states were concluded to be confined to structurally distinct spatial domains with the life-time much exceeding the time-scale of the diffusive dynamics. Formation of these domains, conceivably confining an energy favoured structure, may be regarded as an indication of an underlying phase transition which is possibly masked by the onset of the laboratory glass transition. On the other hand, the conjecture of a long-lived spatial heterogeneity in supercooled liquids implies that, on the time scale characterizing the relaxation dynamics of the faster subsystems, the liquid falls out of ergodic equilibrium already above Tg. In terms of the phase-space behaviour, this can be viewed as decomposition of the entire phase-space region corresponding to the thermodynamic equilibrium (the region of motion) into distinct components which are connected only on a time scale long as compared with the characteristic equilibration time within a component. To a considerable degree, the controversy that arises in discussing the ergodic aspects of the glass transition stems from the fact that there is currently no uniformly accepted definition of ergodicity. It is clear that a meaningful discussion of ergodicity breaking must refer to some qualitative change in the phase-space behaviour. In the following, we shall discuss a conjecture relating the characteristic anomalies arising in a supercooled liquid to the anomalies in its phase-space behaviour as well as the possible ways of detecting these latter anomalies from finite-time measurements of macroscopically accessible quantities. AN OPERATIONAL DEFINITION OF DYNAMICAL ERGODICITY
A statistical-mechanical system is regarded as ergodic if the time-average of a dynamical variable converges to its ensemble average as defined with respect of an invariant measure
The invariant measure here specifies the region of motion - the subspace to which the system is confined by the macroscopic constraints. A major problem involved in the above definition of ergodicity is that it refers to an
ensemble of identical systems and infinite observation time, whereas we, in fact, need to assess the ergodicity of a single system within finite time. Moreover, the definition (1) is usually interpreted in the spirit of the original Boltzmann’s ideas asserting that, to attain an
112
ergodic equilibrium, the system’s phase trajectory has to cover with sufficient density the whole relevant phase-space region. This picture of the ergodicity restoring relaxation process is obviously wrong, as far as liquids are concerned. Indeed, the number of configurations the phase trajectory has to explore, and, consequently, the conjectured relaxation time, increase exponentially with the number of particles, whereas the relaxation times in real liquids are not size-dependent [12]. This problem can be resolved if we redefine the concept of statistical ensemble. We can do it using the fact that the entropy S of an equilibrium system of N particles is an extensive quantity: The extensivity implies that there exist a finite correlation length and a finite correlation time [12], such that regions separated by distances exceeding evolve independently and produce statistically indistinguishable time averages for time intervals exceeding An equilibrium liquid system can thus be viewed as an ensemble of independently evolving subsystems which are confined to regions separated in space by the distances exceeding In dealing with systems of particles, it appears reasonable to consider effective ergodicity based on the concept of mixing [12,13]. The latter requires that the measure of the points of a region R of the phase space which happened to be in any other region R´ after sufficiently long time t must be proportional to the volumes of these regions:
If a dynamical system satisfies this condition, its phase trajectory uniformly samples the coarse-grained phase space. Notice that although the property of mixing is sufficient to ensure ergodicity, it is not known whether this is also a necessary condition for ergodic behaviour [12,13]. The approach to effective ergodicity can be monitored by a measure based on the idea of statistical symmetry. The latter means that time-averages of the quantities associated with
independently evolving regions of a system (or its constituent particles) must become statistically indistinguishable when approaching ergodic equilibrium; this is an obvious result of the independence principle. If f i is a quantity associated with particle i, the respective measure
of ergodic convergence for a system of N identical particles is defined as [14]
where
is the ensemble average (average over all the particles of the system). In the domain of Arrhenius liquid dynamics above TA, this measure, defined for the particle energy e, was found [14] to decay with time universally as By contrast, in the glass-transition domain it asymptotically approaches a non-zero limit indicating ergodicity breaking. Thus, using the measure defined by Eq. 1 we can detect the divergence of the structural relaxation time-scale in a strongly supercooled liquid which is an indicator of the ergodicity breaking. Although such microscopic diagnostics can be useful in the analysis of computer simulations, its major drawback is that it requires full information on the phase trajectory which is not available in macroscopic experiments. The mixing behaviour is realized for the systems with the property that two phase trajectories, initially infinitely close, diverge exponentially with time [13,15]. For each phase space coordinate xi, this divergence is quantified by the respective Lyapunov exponent Notice that the connection between the exponential chaos and mixing, although intuitively clear, has been rigorously proved only for a few simple cases, like the gas of hard spheres [16]. Numerical simulations appear to be a natural way to extend these results to real systems. We discuss here a conjecture [17] that ergodicity of a dynamical system should be understood as global chaotic connectivity of its region of motion. If exponential chaos is confined to 113
subregions connected only on a sufficiently long time-scale, two trajectories, arbitrary close but belonging to different regions of chaotic behaviour, do not diverge exponentially. Obviously, such decomposition of a single chaotic domain results in (i) separation of the relaxation time-scales and (ii) slowing down the relaxation dynamics. In the following, we present arguments, supported by evidence from simulation, indicating that the discrepancy between the volume of a single stochasticity region and the total volume of the region of motion can be assessed by exploiting a recently found universal relation between the diffusion coefficient and the entropy [18]. ERGODIC DIFFUSION
The process of diffusion in liquids is controlled by the so-called cage effect whereby the diffusive motion of a particle surrounded by a cage of its neighbours is coupled with the relaxation of the local structural environment [19,20]. If a liquid is regarded as an ensemble
of independently relaxing regions as we pointed out above, the rate of diffusion is determined by the frequency at which these regions change their configurations. The phase-space picture of structural relaxation in the liquid state can be conveniently
discussed in terms of the energy landscape paradigm [2]. The topography of the energy landscape can be probed by mapping an instantaneous configuration of onto a local potential energy minimum by the steepest descent minimization [21]. The process of structural evolution of an independently relaxing region in a liquid can be viewed as a sequence of transitions between adjacent energy minima. Each point of the ensemble representing these regions explores adjacent minima positions by performing random trial moves at a rate which is determined by the general rate of the momentum and energy transfer. We assume that the probability that a random move in the configurational space results in a successful transition to a new minimum is proportional to the number of adjacent minima which, in its turn, is proportional to the total number of available minima. The latter scales with the thermodynamic excess entropy as The excess entropy represents the difference between full thermodynamic entropy and that of the perfect gas at the same conditions: Sex = S – SPG [22]. It has been recognized by Enskog [23] that the momentum and energy transfer in a dense hard-sphere fluid is mediated by binary collisions. The collision rate thus provides a natural time-scale for the dynamics. It can be assessed from the value of the radial distribution function, g(r), at the collision distance [23]:
where m is the particle mass, is the hard-sphere diameter and T is the temperature. At the same time, the hard-sphere diameter is a natural unit of length. If we express the diffusion coefficient in dimensionless form using these units, the diffusion coefficient in the hard-sphere liquid can be expresses, according to the conjecture suggested above, can be expressed as follows: with the empirically found value of the scaling factor A = 0.049. In real liquids, the hard-sphere diameter can be replaced by the position of the first peak of g(r), which allows the calculation of In this way, we can express D in different liquids in terms of universal units of time and length. Another approximation concerns calculation of Sex. The latter can be expressed as an expansion in terms of n-particle correlation functions [24]. In two-particle approximation, this gives:
114
It was found [18] that, with the use of these approximations, eq. (6) universally describes the relation between S and D in a wide range of simple liquid systems. The scaling relationship between the thermodynamic entropy and diffusion rate is based on the assumption that the system explores its phase space at a rate proportional to The rate at which the state of an exponentially chaotic system is delocalized in the phase space can be quantified by the Kolmogorov-Sinai entropy [13]. This quantity, according to Pesin’s theorem [25], can be presented as the sum of all positive Lyapunov exponents:
Thus, the scaling relation between D and Sex implies the existence of a respective relation between hKS and Sex. Recently, it was indeed found [26] that the Kolmogorov-Sinai entropy in simple liquids, expressed in terms of is uniquely and universally related to the thermodynamic entropy. This implies that the collision frequency represents a universal time-scale for the liquid dynamics. Another conclusion, important in the context of the present discussion, is that the observed relation between D and Sex can be regarded as an indicator of exponentially chaotic behaviour of a liquid. Eq. (6) can be compared with other theories of liquid dynamics involving entropy. In the model of Adam and Gibbs [27] the central quantity is the minimum size of the cooperativity
rearranging region the configuration of which can be changed without interfering with the and the configurational
environment. The model conjectures that the the relaxation time entropy Sc are relates as:
Another model [28], suggested by Rosenfeld, relates the entropy and diffusion in liquids in a different way:
Recently, Di Marzio [29] proposed a relation between the relaxation time and the configurational free energy Fc: Notice that parameter A in Eq. (9) is the number of particles participating in a single jump. If that relation is interpreted in terms of hard spheres where with an additional assumption that A = 1 it becomes clearly consistent with (6). In that case, B would be expressed in terms of the collision frequency. An obvious advantage of relation (6) as compared with (8), (9) and (10) is that it does not involve free parameters. Therefore, a deviation from it is an unambiguous signatuture of a break down in the fundamental mechanism postulated for liquid diffusion which in the case of other relations may be masked by fitting.
NON-ERGODIC DIFFUSION
A central postulate in the model of liquid diffusion in ergodic domain presented in the previous section is that the probability of transition from a current energy minimum configuration to an adjacent one is entirely determined by the total number of these configurations
which can be expressed through the excess entropy. This postulate implicitly assumes that all adjacent configurations available are accessible within the same time-scale characterizing the local dynamics. The universal relation between the hKS and Sex also implies the validity of this assumption. We now consider a situation where this assumption is not valid, and analyze its possible consequences for the system’s behaviour in the phase space. A connection will be shown between this behaviour and the non-ergodic dynamics as it was defined in above, 115
Figure 1. A simple model demonstrating the impact of the valley structure of the phase-space on the relax-
ation dynamics. Energy barriers separating the valleys are depicted by solid lines. Squares and circles denote configurations belonging to different valleys. The crossover point between the valleys is marked by the cross.
and its possible diagnostics in terms of the macroscopically measurable parameters will be discussed. It was found that the average energy of the potential energy minima which remains constant above TA drops rapidly as the temperature decreases below TA [30]. This indicates that in the supercooled domain, the liquid resides on a different part of the energy landscape than the normal liquid, predominantly staying in deep valleys connected by narrow bottlenecks.
These connections are effectively used only on the long time-scale, while the short time-scale dynamics of a supercooled liquid unfolds in a limited subregion of the total region of motion. In order to illustrate the impact of such strongly profiled landscape on the liquid relaxation dynamics, we consider a simple model sketched in Fig. 1. The whole set of configurations comprising the region of motion is divided in two components (valleys), depicted by squares and circles. The filled symbols denote the configurations which are energetically forbidden. The components are separated by barriers, indicated by solid lines, and the single connecting pass is marked by the cross. Consider the probability wij of transition between the configurations i and j. At high temperature, where the components separation is not relevant, the average transition probability is entirely determined by the average probability that the destination configuration is allowed, and, in this way, by the entropy: Clearly, this leads to the relation (6) for the diffusion rate. In the case when the dynamics unfolds in the valley landscape, the average probability of transition can be estimated as where is the average probability that both i and j belong to the same valley. Obviously, in this case and, therefore the the diffusion rate is expected to show a negative deviation from the relation (6). This deviation, indicating that the liquid dynamics is not any more related to the static properties, can be used as a macroscopic diagnostics of the onset of the supercooled (non-ergodic) regime.
116
Figure 2. Reduced diffusion coefficient in the binary mixture of hard spheres as a function of packing fraction (dots). Dashed line corresponds to the universal scaling law (6) relating the diffusion coefficient to the excess entropy, in the pair approximation, S2, with A = 0.049.
EVIDENCE FROM MOLECULAR DYNAMICS SIMULATION
In order to test the above conjecture, we investigated a two-component hard-sphere liquid simulated by molecular dynamics. The model consisted of 862 particles. The two species of hard spheres comprising the model (A and B) are characterized by the ratio of diameters and the ratio of the number densities The liquid phase of this system was found [31] to lose its thermodynamic stability when compressed beyond the critical value of packing fraction At higher densities, its stable phase was identified as the AB13 crystal, the unit cell of which includes 112 atoms. Due to the complexity of its crystallization pattern, this system possesses a pronounced glass-forming ability. In this simulation, it was found to remain in long-living metastable
equilibrium liquid state when compressed beyond the indicated critical packing fraction value. The absence of crystalline nucleation was thoroughly verified by monitoring the pressure and
the diffusion coefficient, both of which remained constant during the simulation run. In order to test relation (6) we calculated the diffusion coefficient and the excess entropy, in the pair approximation, S2 for the smaller atomic species B, exploring a wide range of both below and above the critical value. S2 was derived using (6) from two partial radial distribution functions gAB (r) and gBB (r). The results of this simulation are presented in Fig. 2. It is clear that the results agree well with relation (6) for which corresponds to the stable liquid domain. For higher values of the packing fraction corresponding to the metastable liquid domain, the diffusion coefficient demonstrates a negative deviation from the prescription of the scaling relation (6) which increases rapidly with increasing Another simulation demonstrating effects of non-ergodic diffusion that we consider here explores a simple monatomic liquid [32] with predominantly icosahedral short-range order induced by a properly constructed pair potential. Because of its structure, this liquid can, under supercooling, avoid crystallization and remain in a state of metastable equilibrium for a time sufficiently long for observation of its essential dynamics [33]. It was found that the 117
Figure 3. Reduced diffusion coefficient in a simple monatomic glass-forming liquid [32] as a function of temperature. Dashed line corresponds to the universal scaling law (6) relating the diffusion coefficient to the excess entropy, in the pair approximation, S2, with A = 0.049. In this liquid TA = 0.6
Figure 4. Time evolution of energy-based measure of ergodicity as defined by Eq. (2) calculated for the glassforming liquid [32] shown in Fig. 3 for three temperatures indicated in the inset.
118
domain of temperatures where the liquid exhibits the characteristic anomalies of supercooled dynamics regime is bounded by TA = 0.6 [33]. In Fig. 3 we present its diffusion coefficient plotted as a function of temperature in a manner convenient for testing (6). As the liquid is cooled below TA, the diffusion coefficient displays a pronounced deviation from the scaling behaviour with respect to the excess entropy as postulated by relation (6).
OTHER EFFECTS OF ERGODICITY BREAKING
The latter model of the two discussed in the previous section can also be exploited to directly show the separation of the relaxation time scales that we associate with non-ergodic dynamics. Based on the microscopic information provided by molecular dynamics, the rate of the ergodicity restoring structural relaxations can be assessed using the ergodicity metric introduced by Eq. (3). Fig. 4 shows the evolution of this quantity as a function of the average mean square displacement at different stages of cooling. At sufficiently high temperatures, the results demonstrate an apparent universality in the relationship between the structural relaxation and diffusion. In the supercooled dynamics domain below TA, this universality breaks down as the structural relaxation gets strongly retarded as compared with diffusion. This observation, together with the results shown in Fig. 3, explicitly confirm our analysis
that conjectures non-ergodicity of the liquid diffusion below TA. The long-time decomposition of the region of motion can be viewed as reduction of the time-dependent effective entropy which measures the volume of the accessible phase-space region, as compared with the thermodynamic entropy. On the other hand, the entropy, can, as was pointed out above, be related to the correlation length. Therefore, on the time scale characteristic of the fast (itracomponent) relaxation, the liquid is expected to exhibit timelimited correlations the length scale of which would exceed the range of the static structural correlations which correspond to the ensemble average (or infinite time average). Therefore, the separation of time-scales in the relaxation dynamics of a supercooled liquid that we regard
as a signature of dynamical non-ergodicity, suggests the existence of large-scale clusters with the life time exceeding the time-scale of the “fast” relaxation processes. These time-limited clusters are conjectured to confine an energy favoured local structure incompatible with periodicity [9], and, therefore, their growth is limited by geometric frustration. In the case of the molecular dynamics simulation presented in Fig. 3, this structure corresponds to icosahedra packing. To detect such clusters, we looked for extended structures comprising connected icosahedra. Two icosahedra were regarded as connected if they shared at least three atoms. The results of this analysis are presented in Fig. 4 which depicts the largest clusters of interconnected icosahedra found in the liquid at different stages of cooling. One can indeed see a rapid increase of the cluster size as the temperature decreases below TA. Development of domain structure in supercooled liquids is consistent with a recent observation of long-range cooperativity in diffusive dynamics [34]. We also remark that the development of a network of icosahedral clusters that is observed here resembles the picture of bonding network that was discussed in the context of chalcogenide glass-formers [35]. Experimentally, the characteristic length of the described cooperative effects can be directly probed by measuring the rate of liquid dynamics in confined geometries [36], It has to be emphasized that the time-limited cooperativity is decoupled from the static structure and, therefore, from the thermodynamic entropy. Attempts to interpret the cooperative dynamics of supercooled liquids in terms of the Adam-Gibbs theory which refers to the (static) configurational entropy, although common, are logically incorrect. In order to detect the growth of time-limited domain structure in supercooled liquids, one has to compare the cooperativity range derived from the dynamical measurements in confined geometries with the range of the static structural correlations which, at least for quasi-simple liquids, can be assessed from the diffraction measurements. Ergodicity breaking implies that the former considerably exceeds
119
Figure 5. Maximum size icosahedrally structured clusters observed in the glass-forming liquid [32] presented in Figs. 3,4 at different temperatures: (a) T = 1.0, (b) T = 0.5, (c) T = 0.45
the latter. DISCUSSION
We considered here the concept of dynamical ergodicity in the context of liquid dynamics. According to this concept, ergodic behaviour of a liquid is identified with globally connected chaotic behaviour in the phase space. Macroscopically, this behaviour is characterised by a single time-scale in the relaxation dynamics. It is shown that the proposed scenario of ergodic phase-space behaviour of a liquid is inherently consistent with the recently observed universal relationship between the dynamic properties, like transport coefficients or the KS entropy, and the static properties as quantified by the thermodynamic entropy. On the
other hand, decomposition of the phase space into separate regions of connected stochasticity results in long-time confinement of a phase trajectory. This leads to the appearance of characteristic anomalies, like separation of the time scales and spatial heterogeneity, which are commonly associated with the behaviour of a supercooled liquid. An important conclusion of the discussion presented here is that the long-time decom-
120
position of the phase space into components developing in the supercooled liquid domain
breaks any conceivable relation between the rate of liquid dynamics and the thermodynamic entropy. In particular, this conclusion concerns the Adam-Gibbs relation which is commonly used for interpreting the behaviour of supercooled liquids approaching glass transition. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This work was supported by the following Swedish agencies: Natural Science Research foundations (NFR), Technical Research Foundation (TFR) and National Network for Applied Mathematics (NTM). We used the graphics software from ref. [37]. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3.
Jackle, J. (1986) Models of the glass transition Rep. Prog. Phys., 49, 171-231 Ediger, M.D., Angell, C.A. & Nagel, S.R. (1996) Supercooled liquids and glasses J. Phys. Chem. 100, 13200-13212 Angell, C. A. (1991) Relaxation in liquids, polymers and plastic crystals - strong/fragile patterns and problems, Journ. of Non-Cryst. Solids, 131-133, 13 (1991)
4.
Angell, C. A. (1997) Entropy and fragility in supercooled liquids Journ. of Res. of the Nat. Inst. of Stand.
8.
and Techn 102 171-185 Kirkpatrick, T. R, Thirumalai, D. & Wolynes, P. G. (1989) Scaling concepts for the dynamics of viscousliquids near an ideal glassy state. Phys. Rev. A 40, 1045-1054 Götze, W., and Sjögren, L. (1992) Relaxation processes in supercooled liquids, Reports on Progress in Physics, 55, 241-295 Blackburn, F. R., Wang, C.-Y. & Ediger, M. D. (1996) Translational and rotational motion of probes in supercooled l,3,5-tris(naphthyl)benzene. J. Phys. Chem. 100, 18249-18257 Sillescu, H. (1999) Heterogeneity at the glass transition: a review. J. Non-Cryst. Solids 243, 81-108
9.
Kivelson, D., Kivelson, S. A., Zhao, X., Nussinov, Z. & Tarjus, G. (1995) A thermodynamic theory of
5.
6. 7.
supercooled liquids. Physica A 219, 27-38
10. Fischer, E. W. (1993) Light scattering and dielectric studies on glass forming liquids. Physica A 201, 183-206 11. 12. 13. 14.
Palmer, R. G. (1982) Broken ergodicity Adv. in Phys. 31, 669-735 Ma, S.-K., (1996) Statistical mechanics, World Scientific, Singapore (1985) Lichtenberg, A. J. and Lieberman, M. A. (1983) Regular and Stochastic Motion, Springer Verlag, NY Mountain, R. D. and Thirumalai, D. (1989) Measures of effective ergodic convergence in liquids Journ. of Phys. Chem, 93, 6975
15.
Krylov, N. S. Works on the Foundations of Statistical Physics, Princeton Series in Physics, Princeton 1979; see also Sinai, Ya. G. Development of Krylov’s Ideas, pp. 239-281 of the same volume. 16. Sinai, Ya. G. (1966) Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR. Mt 30, 15-32 (in Russian) 17. Dzugutov, M., (1996) Dynamical diagnostics of ergodicity breaking in supercooled liquids J. Phys. Cond. Matter, 11, 253-259
18.
Dzugutov, M., (1996) A universal scaling law for atomic diffusion in condensed matter Nature, 381, 137-139
19. J. P. Boon and S. Yip, (1980) Molecular Hydrodynamics, McGraw-Hill, New York 20. Cohen, E. D. G. (1993) Fifty years of kinetic theory Physica A, 194 , 229-257 21. Stillinger, F. H. & Weber, T. A. (1984) Packing structures and transitions in liquids and solids. Science
225, 983-989 21. Hansen, J. P. and McDonald, I. (1976) Theory of Simple Liquids, Academic Press, London 23.
S. Chapman and T. G. Cowling, (1939) The mathematical theory of non-uniform gases, Cambridge University Press
24. Mountain, R. D. & Raveche, H., (1971) Entropy and correlation functions in open systems. II Two- and three-body correlations Journ. Chem. Phys. 35, 2250-2255
25. Pesin, Ja. B. (1976) Lyapunov characteristic exponents and ergodic properties of smooth dynamical systems with an invariant measure Sov. Math. Dokl., 17, 196-203 (in Russian)
26. Dzugutov, M., Aurell, E., and Vulpiani, A., (1998) A universal relation between the Kolmogorov-Sinai entropy and the thermodynamic entropy in simple liquids Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 1762
121
27. Adam, G. and Gibbs, J.H., (1965) On the temperature dependence of cooperative relaxation properties in glass-forming liquids Journ. Chem. Phys. 43, 139-146 28.
Rosenfeld, Ya., (1977) Relation between the transport coefficients and the internal entropy of simple systems Phys. Rev. A, 15, 2545-2549 29. Di Marzio, E. A. and Yang, A. J. M. (1997) Configurational entropy approach to kinetics of glasses, Journ. of Res. of the Nat. Inst. of Stand. and Techn 102, 135-157 30. Sastry, S., Debenedetti, P., and Stillinger F. H. (1998) Signatures of distinct dynamical regimes in the
energy landscape of a glass forming liquid Nature, 393, 554-557; Angell, C. A. Liquid landscape ibid., 521-524 31. Eldridge, M. D., Madden, P. A., and Frenkel, D. (1993) Entropy driven formation of a superlattice in a hard sphere binary mixture Nature, 365, 35
32. Dzugutov, M. (1992) Glass formation in a simple monatomic liquid with icosahedral inherent local order. Phys. Rev. A 46, R2984-R2987 33. Dzugutov, M. (1994) Hopping diffusion as a mechanism of relaxation stretching in a stable simple monatomic liquid. Europhys. Lett. 26, 533-538 34. Donati, C., Douglas, J. F., Kob, W., Plimpton, S.J., Poole, P.H. & Glotzer, S.C. (1998) Stringlike cooperative motion in a supercooled liquid. Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 2338-2341 35. Phillips, J.C., and Thorpe, M.F.,. (1985) Constraints theory, vector percolation and glass formation, Dynamics of glass-forming materials confined in thin films Sol. St. Comm. 53, 699-702 36. Jérôme, B. (1999) Dynamics of glass-forming materials confined in thin films Journ. Phys. Cond. Matter
11, 189-199 37. Humphrey, W., Dalke, A., and Schulten, K., (1996) VMD - visual molecular dynamics, Molecular Graphics 14, 33-38
122
NETWORK STIFFENING AND CHEMICAL ORDERING IN CHALCOGENIDE GLASSES: COMPOSITIONAL TRENDS OF Tg IN RELATION TO STRUCTURAL INFORMATION FROM SOLID AND LIQUID STATE NMR
CARSTEN ROSENHAHN, SOPHIA HAYES, GUNTHERBRUNKLAUS, and HELLMUT ECKERT Institut für Physikalische Chemie; Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster, 7, D-48149 Münster, Germany
INTRODUCTION During the past few years, there has been a resurgence of the interest in nonoxide chalcogenide glasses based on the sulfides and selenides of the group 13-15 elements. From a technological point of view, arsenic and germanium sulfide-based glasses in particular are promising low-phonon host materials for luminescent rare-earth dopants, with potential applications in the fiber optic laser industry [1-4], From a scientific point of view, non-oxide chalcogenide glasses represent interesting model systems for testing simple mean-field concepts used to discuss structure-property relations. It has been pointed out that certain physical characteristics of chalcogenide glasses, such as glass transition temperatures, melt viscosities, and molar volumes often depend non-linearly on their chemical composition [5-9]. An explanation has been offered on the basis of percolation theory, by considering the overall connectivity of the network [8,10-12]. For any two- or three-dimensional network one can define an average coordination number
where ni is the number of atoms of species i, ri is the number of bonds formed by it, and the summation extends over all of the different atomic species present in the network. Any covalent network constrained by bond-stretching and bond bending forces possesses a critical connectivity threshold at Glasses having average
Phase Transitions And Self-Organization in Electronic and Molecular Networks Edited by J. C. Phillips and M. F. Thorpe, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2001
123
coordination numbers higher than this threshold value represent single infinite clusters with no residual zero-frequency modes [12-16]. Accordingly, abrupt changes in physical properties are expected at such critical compositions. In this regard, much discussion has been focused on the dependence of the glass transition temperature on composition [1723]. While universal dependences of Tg on
have been found in certain binary and ternary systems, there are numerous other glass systems in which no such universality has been observed. The applicability of the average coordination number concept implies that bond formation proceeds in a random fashion, i.e. without any chemical bond preferences. Thus, the concept works at its best when homo- and heteropolar bond energies are of equal magnitudes. In chalcogenide glasses, however, this situation is rarely encountered. Indeed, a considerable body of evidence proves that this situation is unrealistic in many
arsenic and germanium-based chalcogenide glasses, which have rather been found strongly chemically ordered. Because of significant differences in the corresponding bonding energies, heteropolar As-Se and Ge-Se bonds dominate over homopolar As-As, Ge-Ge or weakly polar As-Ge bonds in these systems. Tichy and Ticha were the first to recognize that in such chemically ordered systems the Tg value is well correlated to the overall mean bonding energy <E> [24,25]. Thus, maximum Tg values have been predicted (and found) at the composition of a chemical threshold, defined by R = 2z/(4x + 3y), where x, y, and z refer to the atomic fractions of Ge, As, and Se, respectively [26]. In systems with a strong dominance of heteropolar over homopolar bonds, the
chemical threshold R = 1.0 marks the minimum selenium content at which a chemically ordered network is possible without metal-metal bond formation. Driven by this interest, from both the technological and the scientific point of view, more detailed fundamental concepts concerning the local structure and intermediate range order of these materials are being developed. Amongst other techniques, solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) has played an important role in this endeavour. In particular, the favorable NMR properties of the 31P and 77Se isotopes have been exploited to advantage for a structural determination of binary and ternary phosphorus sulfide, selenide, and telluride materials [27]. In the solid state, magic angle spinning 31P NMR spectra have provided information about the microstructural units present, while dipolar spin echo decay methods have given information about the extent of P-P bonding. Complementary high-temperature liquid state NMR studies of the glassforming compositions have provided important insights into the chemical equilibria and the kinetics leading to glass formation [28]. These studies have been recently extended to arsenic and germanium selenide glasses [29]. It is the purpose of this contribution to review the current state of this field, and to discuss physical and chemical threshold effects on the compositional dependence of Tg in relation to the short range order in various binary and ternary chalcogenide glass systems. Based on this structural information we will show how the concepts of physical and chemical threshold behaviors can be unified within a more comprehensive model providing satisfactory correlations between elemental composition and macroscopic physical properties.
124
BINARY PHOSPHORUS-CHALCOGENIDE GLASS SYSTEMS. Short Range Order
Both the binary systems P-S and P-Se have a strong tendency for glass formation, extending until about 50 at.% phosphorus [6,9,30], In spite of this similarity, the principles governing the structural organization of these glasses are fundamentally different from each other. This difference becomes immediately obvious when comparing the compositional dependences of the glass transition temperatures Tg(see Figure 1).
Figure 1: Compositional dependence of the glass transition temperature Tg in P-S and P-Se glasses. The curve is drawn as a guide to the eye.
In P-Se glasses, an increase in the phosphorus concentration is accompanied by a Tg increase up to about 40 at.% P, followed by an increase at a greater rate at higher
phosphorus contents. This behavior can be understood on the basis of percolation theory as applied to a polymeric network: the composition 40 at.% P corresponds to the rigidity percolation threshold, at which the average coordination number equals 2.4 bonds per atom. Such a change in slope, dTg/d, occurring at = 2.4 has been observed for various other binary and ternary chalcogenide glass systems, and it appears to be a general property of polymeric covalent networks. In contrast, the binary P-S glasses have a decidely different compositional trend [27]. At smaller phosphorus contents the Tg values are larger than in the P-Se glasses. There is a maximum near 25 at.% P, followed by a decrease at larger phosphorus contents. For glasses containing more than 40 at.% phosphorus the glass transition temperatures lie below room temperature. For this glass system, the rigidity percolation concept seems to be inapplicable. 31 P nuclear magnetic resonance studies have given substantial insights into the structural origins of these differences in behavior. Figure 2 compares the 31P MAS-NMR spectra of both systems. On the right, spectra of P-S glasses are displayed. Up to P contents of 15 at. % the spectra are dominated by a broad resonance centered near +110 ppm, which can be assigned to S=PS3/2 units. As the P content increases above 15 at.%, novel sharp resonances appear, signifying the formation of P4S10, P4S9 and P4S7 molecules embedded in the polymeric matrix [27,31]. The sharpness of these resonances
125
indicates efficient averaging of the anisotropic interactions on the NMR timescale by virtue of fast molecular reorientation processes. At P concentrations