Osip Mandelstam and the Modernist Creation of Tradition
This page intentionally left blank
Osip Mandelstam and the ...
87 downloads
1300 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Osip Mandelstam and the Modernist Creation of Tradition
This page intentionally left blank
Osip Mandelstam and the Modernist Creation of Tradition • C LA R E C AVA N AG H
P R I N C E T O N
U N I V E R S I T Y
P R I N C E T O N,
N E W
•
P R E S S
J E R S E Y
Copyright 1995 by Princeton University Press Published by Princeton University Press, 41 William Street, Princeton, New Jersey 08540 In the United Kingdom: Princeton University Press, Chichester, West Sussex All Rights Reserved
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Cavanagh, Clare. Osip Mandelstam and the modernist creation of tradition / Clare Cavanagh. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-691-03682-9 1. Mandel’shtam, Osip, 1891–1938—Criticism and interpretation. 2. Modernism (Literature) I. Title. PG3476.M355Z59 1994 891.71′3—dc20 94-11248
This book has been composed in Galliard Princeton University Press books are printed on acid-free paper, and meet the guidelines for permanence and durability of the Committee on Production Guidelines for Book Longevity of the Council on Library Resources Printed in the United States of America 1
3
5
7
9
10
8
6
4
2
•
TO MIKE
•
This page intentionally left blank
THE ARTICULATION OF SIBERIA When the deaf phonetician spread his hand Over the dome of a speaker’s skull He could tell which diphthong and which vowel By the bone vibrating to the sound. A globe stops spinning. I feel my palm On a forehead cold as permafrost And imagine axle-hum and the steadfast Russian of Osip Mandelstam. —Seamus Heaney
This page intentionally left blank
•
C
O
N
T
E
N
T
S
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS NOTE ON ABBREVIATIONS, TRANSLATIONS, AND TRANSLITERATION
•
xi xiii
CHAPTER ONE
Introduction: The Modernist Creation of Tradition
3
CHAPTER TWO
Self-Creation and the Creation of Culture
29
CHAPTER THREE
Making History: Modernist Cathedrals
66
CHAPTER FOUR
Judaic Chaos
103
CHAPTER FIVE
The Currency of the Past
146
CHAPTER SIX
Jewish Creation
193
CHAPTER SEVEN
Powerful Insignificance
215
CHAPTER EIGHT
Chaplinesque, or Villon Again: In Place of an Ending
279
APPENDIX
305
NOTES
313
INDEX
359
This page intentionally left blank
•
A
C
K
N
O
W
L
E
D
G
M
E
N
T
S
•
THE CREATION of tradition is, Mandelstam insists, a collaborative endeavor, the work of “colleagues” and “co-discoverers.” A book is no less a collaboration, and for whatever merits this study may possess I am indebted to many—although its faults are entirely my own. A poet finds his true reader only in posterity, Mandelstam laments. As a graduate student, I was more fortunate. I had three readers: Donald Fanger, Stanislaw Baranczak, and especially Jurij Striedter, whose reading of my work—scrupulous, generous, and inspiring—was my best graduate education; and my book and I have both benefited from their continued interest in my research on Mandelstam. Many other colleagues and co-discoverers have helped this book along its way. Svetlana Boym and Andrew Kahn helped to shape my thought early on through memorable conversations about Mandelstam, and Andrew Kahn’s encouragement and criticism have been invaluable at every stage of this project’s evolution. I was lucky to find in my senior colleague at the University of Wisconsin, David Bethea, an inspired interlocutor, astute critic, and generous friend, whose unflagging faith in “the manuscript that wouldn’t die” helped bring the book to life. Others—Jane Garry Harris, Judith Kornblatt, Charles Isenberg, Caryl Emerson—gave much-needed support and advice at critical stages in the book’s development. Jennifer Presto, Mandelstam fan and research assistant extraordinaire, went far beyond the call of duty as I struggled with the manuscript’s beginnings in 1989–90. Andrew Swenson’s assistance at the project’s conclusion was equally invaluable. As materials on and by Mandelstam began to proliferate in a Russia anxious to revive a suppressed poetic past, I relied on the kindness of friends and colleagues—Margaret and Mark Beissinger, Eliot Borenstein, Yuri Shcheglov, Irina Bagrationi-Mukhraneli—to provide me with texts that had not yet reached the West. My parents, John and Adele Cavanagh, have been generosity itself—they have helped in more ways than I can name. Fellowships from the Mrs. Giles Whiting Foundation and the Social Science Research Council helped to fund my work on Mandelstam early on; subsequent support and leave time granted me by the University of Wisconsin Graduate School and Department of Slavic Languages allowed me both to expand the scope of my study and to bring it to a conclusion. My editors at Princeton University Press, Robert Brown and Marta Steele, provided assistance and encouragement throughout the arduous process of turning the manuscript into a book. Part of Chapter 1 was published, in somewhat different form, as “Mandel’shtam i modernistskoe izobretenie Evropy” (Mandelstam and the Modernist Invention of Europe), in Diapazon: Vestnik inostrannoi literatury, Vol. 213, No. 1 (1993), 40–47. A longer version of the same essay,
xii
•
A C K N O W L E D G M E N T S
•
entitled “The Modernist Creation of Tradition: Mandelstam, Eliot and Pound,” appears in American Scholars on Twentieth-Century Russian Literature, ed. Boris Averin and Elizabeth Neatrour (St. Petersburg: Petro-Rif Publishers, 1993): 400–421. Chapters 6 and 8 appeared in abbreviated form as the following articles: “The Poetics of Jewishness: Mandel’shtam, Dante and the ‘Honorable Calling of Jew,’ ” Slavic and East European Journal, Vol. 35, No. 3 (1991): 317–38; and “Rereading the Poet’s Ending: Mandelstam, Chaplin and Stalin,” PMLA, Vol. 109, No. 1 (January 1994): 71–86. This last essay is reprinted by permission of the copyright holder, The Modern Language Association of America. The quotation from “Chaplinesque” in The Complete Poems and Selected Letters and Prose of Hart Crane by Hart Crane, edited by Brom Weber, copyright 1966 by the Liverright Publishing Corp., is reprinted by permission of W. W. Norton Publishers. The quotations from T. S. Eliot, The Complete Poems and Plays, 1909–1950, copyright by T. S. Eliot 1962, renewed by Esme Valerie Eliot in 1971, are reprinted by permission of Harcourt Brace and Company. The quotations from Osip Mandelstam, Sobranie sochinenii, 4 vols., edited by G. P. Struve, N. Struve, B. A. Filipoff, copyright 1967–69, 1981 by Inter-Language Literary Associates and the YMCA Press, are reprinted by permission of the YMCA Press. Ezra Pound’s poem “Histrion” in Collected Early Poems of Ezra Pound, edited by Michael John King, copyright 1976 by The Trustees of the Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust, is reprinted by permission of New Directions Publishers. The quotation from Canto I in The Cantos of Ezra Pound, copyrighted 1971 by Ezra Pound, renewed 1972 by the estate of Ezra Pound, is reprinted by permission of New Directions Publishers. The quotation from Ezra Pound’s parody of “Under Ben Bulben” is taken from his collection Pavannes and Divagations, copyrighted 1958 by Ezra Pound and quoted by permission of New Directions Press. The quotation from William Butler Yeat’s “Byzantium” in The Collected Poems of W. B. Yeats, copyright 1940 by Georgie Yeats, renewed 1956 by the Macmillan Publishing Co., is reprinted by permission of the Macmillan Publishing Co. I also would like to thank Seamus Heaney for his generous permission to use his poem “The Articulation of Siberia” as this book’s epigraph. Finally my standards of both personal and scholarly integrity were set by my best critic and reader, my “faithful friend” and “favorite relation,” Michael Lopez. This book is dedicated to him as an installment on debts greater than I can ever express or repay.
N
O
T
E
O T
A
N
D
R T
N A B B R E V I A T I O N S , A N S L A T I O N S , R A N S L I T E R A T I O N
UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED, all prose translations are taken, with some modifications, from The Prose of Osip Mandelstam, trans. Clarence Brown (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1965; abbreviated in the text as POM); and Osip Mandelstam, The Complete Critical Prose and Letters, ed. Jane Gary Harris, tr. Jane Gary Harris and Constance Link (Ann Arbor: Ardis Press, 1979; abbreviated in the text as CPL). The volume and page number of the original Russian text in the Struve/Filipoff edition of Mandelstam’s work will be given whenever the translation has been substantially altered or the original Russian is cited along with the English translation (Sobranie sochinenii, 4 vols. Vols. 1–3: ed. G. P. Struve, B. A. Filipoff. Washington: Inter-Language Literary Associations, 1967–69. Vol. 4: ed. G. P. Struve, N. Struve, B. A. Filipoff. Paris: YMCA Press, 1981). Poems will be referred to in the text by their number in the Struve/Filipoff edition of Mandelstam’s writing. All translations of the poetry are my own, unless otherwise noted. For the purposes of this study, I have placed accuracy and readability over artistic merit in my English renditions of Mandelstam’s Russian; unfortunately and inevitably, then, what makes his poems poems in the original has thus been lost even more thoroughly than is usual in the translation of verse. I have used the Library of Congress system in transliterating Russian texts, with some modifications. The final -skii in proper names has been changed to the more common -sky, and well-known proper names are given in their most commonly used forms; e.g., Mandelstam, not Mandel’shtam, Lydia Ginzburg, not Lidiia Ginzburg, Mayakovsky, not Maiakovskii. The spelling Mandel’shtam will be used, however, in book and article titles transliterated from the Russian in the endnotes.
This page intentionally left blank
Osip Mandelstam and the Modernist Creation of Tradition
This page intentionally left blank
•
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
O
N
E
•
Introduction: The Modernist Creation of Tradition
Perhaps the strongest impulse towards a shift in the approach to language and linguistics . . . was—for me, at least—the turbulent artistic movement of the early twentieth century. The great men of art born in the 1880’s—Picasso (1881– ), Joyce (1882–1941), Braque (1882– ), Stravinsky (1882– ), Khlebnikov (1885–1922), Le Corbusier (1887– )—were able to complete a thorough and comprehensive schooling in one of the most placid spans of world history, before that “last hour of universal calm” (poslednii chas vsemirnoi tishiny) was shattered by a train of cataclysms. The leading artists of that generation keenly anticipated the upheavals that were to come and met them while still young and dynamic enough to test and steel their own creative power in this crucible. The extraordinary capacity of these discoverers to overcome again and again the faded habits of their own yesterdays, [joined] together with an unprecedented gift for seizing and shaping anew every older tradition or foreign model without sacrificing the stamp of their own permanent individuality in the amazing polyphony of ever new creations. —Roman Jakobson, “Retrospect” (1962)
I was born in the same year as Charlie Chaplin, Tolstoy’s “Kreutzer Sonata,” [Gumilev] the Eiffel Tower, and, apparently, [T. S.] Eliot. —Anna Akhmatova, “Notes Towards a Memoir” (undated)
4
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
INVENTION AND REMEMBRANCE One often hears: that is good but it belongs to yesterday. But I say: yesterday has not yet been born. It has not yet really existed. —Osip Mandelstam, “The Word and Culture” (1921)
To speak of modernist culture as a culture born of crisis and catastrophe seems to have become in recent years a critical commonplace, a cliché no longer adequate to the phenomena it purports to describe. Indeed, much recent discussion of the modernist movement in European and American culture has focused precisely on exposing what one scholar has called “the myth of the modern,” the myth, that is, of a radical break with a past that modern artists continued to draw on even as they mourned—or celebrated—its loss. Such skepticism can be bracing, and certainly it is necessary if we are to achieve anything like a critical distance on a movement whose parameters are as ill-defined and shifting as those of modernism.1 Revisionist approaches to the modernist sense of an ending should not, however, lead us to overlook the degree to which this particular truism is rooted in historical fact. The modernist artist may have exagerrated the uniqueness of his historical situation: other generations, other ages and cultures have experienced upheavals and disasters that seemed truly cataclysmic at the time and that had a profound and lasting impact on the art and thought that sprang up in their wake. Moreover, the Judeo-Christian models that have shaped Western culture predispose us to perceive all history in terms of “eternal transition, perpetual crisis.”2 Living as we do in the extended aftermath of the modernist movement, we may find it difficult to give credence to the French poet Charles Péguy’s hyberbolic claim, made in 1913, that “the world has changed less since Jesus Christ than it has in the last thirty years”; history has not yet screeched to a dead halt, nor has the modern world or the human condition changed beyond all possible recognition as we draw to the end of this century and the millennium. The modernist artist had, however, historically grounded reasons for considering that what he lived in was indeed a qualitatively different kind of society, a technologically transformed, radically innovative, international “culture of time and space.” And the Great War, the War to End All Wars—along with the massive social upheavals that followed in its aftermath—undoubtably left a generation of artists and thinkers with scars, both literal and figurative, of a kind that previous generations would have found difficult to imagine.3 The artists and thinkers of early-twentieth-century Russia could lay even greater claim to living in an age of unprecedented disaster. Their experience of World War I was framed by bloody revolutions, first the failed revolt of 1905 and then the February and October revolutions of 1917, which were followed by three years of civil war. This is not the place to
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
5
rehearse the many horrors that have shaped the course of modern Russian history. But even if we strip away the inflated, apocalyptic rhetoric that colors so many poetic accounts—Symbolist, Futurist, and Acmeist alike—of the Russian experience of war and revolution, we are left, nonetheless, with the genuine, profound sense of an ending and accompanying shock of the new that lent the Russian modernist movement such energy and finally such poignance. Péguy makes his claim for the birth of a new age in 1913. Other modernists dated the death of the past somewhat differently. “It was in 1915,” D. H. Lawrence announces, that “the old world ended”; while Virginia Woolf proclaims, with even greater assurance, that “on or about December, 1910, human nature changed.” Anna Akhmatova was one of the few poets to survive the disasters that befell what Roman Jakobson prophetically called, in a famous essay of 1931, “the generation that squandered its poets.” She thus bore firsthand witness to the many tragedies, national and personal, that followed in the revolution’s wake. Nonetheless, the date she picks for the beginning of the new era comes close to those moments of crisis chosen by Lawrence and Woolf. As she looks back on the past from her vantage point in 1944—in the midst of yet another cataclysm, World War II—she watches “not the calendar, but the real twentieth century approach” along the Petersburg embankments of 1913. Osip Mandelstam joins in this modernist chorus as he mourns the modern loss not just of past times, but of time itself as earlier generations had understood it: “The fragile reckoning of the years of our era has been lost,” he laments in “Pushkin and Skriabin” (1916; CPL, 91).4 The approximate convergence of these dates, taken together with their divergent sources in French, English, and Russian writing, points to one of modernism’s most salient features, a feature we might call continuity in crisis, or, perhaps more precisely, continuity in the perception of crisis. The modern sense of an ending was not confined to one country or one continent alone, and modernist art likewise defies national and linguistic boundaries. The very pervasiveness of this sense of crisis in modernist writing has led to what has become yet another commonplace of the vast scholarship on the movement. It is now “almost a truism,” Matei Calinescu writes, “to describe the modern artist as torn between his urge to cut himself off from the past—to become completely ‘modern’—and his dream to found a new tradition, recognizable as such by the future.” Charles Feidelson and Richard Ellman present us with another variant on this modernist dilemma. The modernist artist who has been, in Mandelstam’s phrase, “excommunicated from history” (CPL, 84), can read his exile from the past in one of two ways: it may be either a “liberation from inherited patterns” or “deprivation and disinheritance.” The modernist must cast his lot either among the “Futurists” or the “Pastists.” He must either celebrate his release from the dead weight of tradition or forever mourn the loss of an infinitely precious, infinitely distant history.5
6
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
This kind of opposition—between Pastists and Futurists, Archaists and Innovators, Apollonian preservers and Dionysian destroyers—is far too schematic to encompass the range of responses to the pervasive modern sense of rupture with the past, as Ellmann and Feidelson readily admit. For a variety of reasons, though, it has proved remarkably resilient on Russian soil, and nowhere is this literary two-party system more in evidence than in the responses to Russian modernist poetry. Indeed, the poetry itself might seem to invite just such a polarized reaction. The Russian post-symbolists, in hindsight at least, appear to have divided themselves neatly into two camps, as if for the convenience of future researchers: the Futurists were dedicated, as their name suggests, to casting unwanted cultural ballast off the “Steamship of Modernity”; while their coevals and competitors the Acmeists, whose name proclaimed their allegiance to the akme, the highest and best that Western and Russian culture could offer, were equally bent on demonstrating that this “Steamship of Modernity” was “the ship of eternity,” the ship entrusted with bearing past treasures of world culture into an unknown future. In postrevolutionary Russia, the very notions of “past” and “future,” of “tradition” and “innovation” became valorized to a degree that made it still more difficult to cross these particular party lines in quest of an accurate assessment of the presence of the poetic past in Futurist writing, and of avant-garde innovation at work among the “pastist” Acmeists.6 This thumbnail sketch cannot do justice, poetic or otherwise, to the complicated history of Russian post-symbolist art—but it is not my goal here to address the many problems and issues involved in the critical reception of this poetry. I want to turn now instead to the real subject of my study, to Osip Mandelstam (1891–1938) and his modernist invention of tradition. I have spoken of the Acmeist commitment to “world culture”; the phrase itself is Mandelstam’s. Shortly before his final arrest in 1938, he defined the Acmeist aesthetic as a “yearning for world culture (toska po mirovoi kulture)”; and he thus provided us with the best possible shorthand description of the impulse that charges his own poetry and prose. This definition might seem initially to place Mandelstam and his poetics squarely in the camp of the cultural “passéists” (CPL, 176; II, 346). Taken from its proper context in his work, it might appear to signal a hopeless, helpless longing for an all-encompassing culture that existed once but has long since disappeared, or that has known its only life in the pipe dreams and poems of traditionless modernists. The vast scope of Mandelstam’s poetic ambitions, which will be satisfied with nothing less than all of Western culture, attests inversely to the intensity of his sense of cultural deprivation. If modernist artists considered themselves to be the casualties of “an apocalypse of cultural community,” then Mandelstam must be ranked among the movement’s most representative figures.7 In a suggestive essay on Mandelstam’s notion of history, Gregory
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
7
Freidin observes that “only a cultural orphan growing up in [Russia’s] revolutionary years could possess such an insatiable need for a continuous construction of a gigantic vision of culture meant to compensate for the impossibility of belonging to a single place.” When Mandelstam was born, and where, and to whom—all three conditions apparently conspired to keep him from the European and Russian cultural legacy he craved. He was born, he writes, “in the night between the second and the third/Of January in the ninety-first/Uncertain year, and the centuries/Surround me with fire” (#362). In his autobiography The Noise of Time (1925), Mandelstam laments a generation of Russian modernists born beneath “the sign of the hiatus” (POM, 122) and thus deprived by history of the cultural treasures that should have been theirs by rights. But Mandelstam would not have stood to inherit these treasures in any case. His parents, as he describes them in The Noise of Time, were themselves orphans of sorts, Central European Jews who, uprooted from their own culture, were not at home in their adoptive nation either. Mandelstam himself, born in Warsaw, could not claim Russia and its culture as his birthright. Even as an adopted motherland, though, Russia presented him with as many problems as it solved. It was itself an orphan, “the orphan of nations,” in Belinsky’s phrase, uncomfortably straddling the border between East and West, a feudal past and the foreign present forcibly imported by Peter the Great.8 Mandelstam’s definition of Acmeism appears to place him in the paradoxical position of being a pastist who had no past he could legitimately call his own. This paradox brings us in turn to the apparent contradiction contained in the title of my book, the contradiction that lies at the heart of Mandelstam’s work. It is not finally the intensity of Mandelstam’s sense of loss that distinguishes him among his fellow modernists. It is the energy and the imagination with which he sets about converting his deficits into assets as he works to create a usable past for himself and for a generation of artists that found itself abandoned by history. Gifted with the capacity to generalize from his own dilemma, to convert isolation to connection, to turn disruption to his advantage, and to use all these skills in the service of an encompassing cultural vision, Mandelstam was singularly well equipped to address his own and his epoch’s paradoxical legacy of disinheritance; and he responded with one of modernism’s most complex, ambitious, and challenging visions of tradition. In his famous poem “Tristia” (1918), Mandelstam movingly describes the “profound joy of recurrence” that informs his poetry and vision of history alike: “Everything once was, everything will be repeated/And the moment of recognition alone is sweet to us” (CPL, 114; #104).9 As scholars and critics recognized early on, Mandelstam seeks to provide both himself and his readers with this joyful shock of recognition by reviving in his work the classical, European, and Russian traditions he craved. His aim, though, is not merely to repeat the past, to deliver it intact and unaltered into the
8
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
present. The very act of remembering the past changes it irreparably, and this is as it should be, according to Mandelstam. “Invention and remembrance go hand in hand in poetry,” he insists in his essay “Literary Moscow” (1922). “To remember also means to invent, and the one who remembers is also an inventor” (CPL, 146). Invention and remembrance: this complex and energizing dialectic shapes Mandelstam’s work and the vision of tradition it both embodies and describes from his earliest poems and essays to the last “Voronezh Notebook” (1937). It is ideally suited to the needs of the cultural orphan who must invent his way into the past that he desires—but it also demonstrates the ways in which Mandelstam was able to turn necessity to his artistic advantage. The dialectic he develops to counter his sense of loss and isolation serves to place him at the very heart of a modernist art preoccupied with what Guillaume Apollinaire calls the modern “debate between tradition and invention.” Like Mandelstam’s inventive remembrance, the very notion of a modern tradition is an “apparent oxymoron,” as Charles Russell notes, and the ground of this paradoxical tradition “is always slipping out from under [modern] writers’ and artists’ feet.” It slips from beneath the feet of critics as well. Ellman and Feidelson issue the following disclaimer as they struggle to define their own version of The Modern Tradition (1965): “If we can postulate a modern tradition, we must add that it is a paradoxically untraditional tradition.” Renato Poggioli reaches much the same conclusion when he speaks, in his Theory of the Avant-Garde (1968), of modernism’s reliance on a self-consciously “anti-traditional tradition.” My goal in this chapter and the chapters that follow is chiefly to trace the workings of Mandelstam’s invented tradition as it takes shape in both his poetry and his prose. But I also call attention to the ways in which Mandelstam’s seemingly sui generis version of tradition serves to tie him to other modernist writers and thinkers—Russian, European, and American—who struggled to make sense of the past in an age apparently bent upon turning all history on its head.10 Influence study has largely dominated Mandelstam scholarship during what one might call its formative years: I am thinking of the pioneering works of Kiril Taranovsky, Omry Ronen, Dmitrii Segal, Iurii Levin, and others whose development of a “subtextual” and “intertextual” structuralist approach to Mandelstam has defined and refined our understanding of the intricate web of quotations and references that shape Mandelstam’s world culture as it is embodied in his texts.11 I have drawn extensively on this scholarship in my own work—no student of Mandelstam or of Russian modernism in general can afford to neglect it. There is a danger, though, that subtext will take the place of context in such criticism, and that the larger poetic community drawn from all times and ages, the community to which Mandelstam aspired and in which he did indeed participate, at times unconsciously, will be confined to those writers whose works we can safely
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
9
assume he knew and read. However, this very vision of an international, multilingual community of poets serves to mark him as a modernist; and he shares this vision with other modern poets, most notably T. S. Eliot and Ezra Pound, whose work he could not have known. (He could not read English, and their work was virtually unknown in Russia at the time he was writing.) If we are to understand what is specifically modernist in Mandelstam’s work, and what is distinctively Mandelstamian about his particular brand of modernism, we must make the same kind of unexpected and, one hopes, illuminating, connections that Mandelstam and other “modern poet-synthesizers” placed at the heart of their endeavor (CPL, 116).12 Our understanding of his work would be impoverished indeed without the glimpses of a larger modernist context that a comparably “synthetic” criticism—a criticism that takes into account not only subtext, but context, that examines affinities as well as influence—can provide.13 Modernism generally makes for strange bedfellows, as this chapter’s first epigraph attests. Roman Jakobson begins his pocket-sized portrait of the linguist as a young man by creating a backdrop in which Russian poets and composers rub shoulders with French architects, Spanish painters, and Irish novelists—even as he emphasizes their shared need to reinvent the various foreign and native traditions that inform their creations. The company Akhmatova keeps in the opening passage of her unfinished memoirs is no less unlikely; she was born, she claims, in the same year as were T. S. Eliot, her fellow Acmeist and first husband Nikolai Gumilev, Tolstoy’s famous novella “The Kreutzer Sonata,” Charlie Chaplin, and, of all things, the Eiffel Tower. Such juxtapositions are entirely true to the spirit of the modernist movement, and necessary to its proper understanding. Indeed, Akhmatova and Jakobson suggest as much by prefacing their selfportraits with these modernist collages.14 In both quotes, we notice a characteristic modernist blurring of boundaries not only between nations, but between different media, genres, and modes of creation. We also note in Akhmatova’s quote particularly a tendency to disregard strict boundaries not only between high and low art, as Charlie Chaplin rubs elbows with the likes of Tolstoy, T. S. Eliot, and Akhmatova herself. She also juxtaposes two “pastist” Acmeists (and Eliot, whom we might consider an honorary Acmeist of sorts) with the Eiffel Tower, which represented for Futurists all over the world the essence of high technology and unabashed modernity that they themselves aspired to in their art.15 Akhmatova’s dates are mistaken on several counts—but it is not my aim to take her to task for what were, I suspect, the intentional mistakes in her chronology. Rather, I wish to call attention to the way in which Akhmatova, a lifelong Acmeist dedicated, like Mandelstam, to the preservation of Western culture within her work, begins her unfinished memoirs with what is, if not precisely a slap in the face of public taste, then at least a calculated gesture intended to disrupt fixed perceptions of a life
10
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
and work that should not be rooted too firmly in any form of purely “pastist” aesthetics. The same warning holds true for Mandelstam and his invented tradition, and I will now turn to some of the affinities that Mandelstam shares with several unlikely modernist comrades-at-arms.
MODERNIST GENEALOGIES On or about December 1910 human nature changed. . . . All human relations shifted—those between masters and servants, husbands and wives, parents and children. —Virginia Woolf, “Mr. Bennett and Mrs. Brown” (1924) You cannot carry around on your back the corpse of your father. You leave him with the other dead. —Guillaume Apollinaire, The Cubist Painters (1913)
Following the revolution, Nadezhda Mandelstam notes, the comtemporaries of Akhmatova and Mandelstam “seriously thought of them as old people,” although both notorious pastists were in reality not much over thirty. After the publication of Kornei Chukovsky’s influential essay on “Akhmatova and Mayakovsky” (1920), the Acmeist movement came to be perceived as the essence of a dying culture that had quickly outlived what little usefulness it had for the new regime. Chukovsky is basically sympathetic when he describes Akhmatova as the “heiress of an old and high culture” who “values her inheritance [and] her many ancestors: Pushkin, Baratynsky, Annensky.” He contrasts her with Mayakovsky, who has “no ancestors” and is mighty not in his precursors but his descendants. Chukovsky concludes, however, by proposing not a purge of the poetic past, but a fusion of the “Akhmatova” and “Mayakovsky factions” in a Soviet poetry that has learned to cherish its prerevolutionary legacy. Other critics, including Mayakovsky himself, were less temperate. In a 1922 talk, Mayakovsky calls for a “clean-up of modern poetry” and begins by casting the Akhmatovas of the world on Trotsky’s dust heap of history: “Of course, as literary landmarks, as the last remnants of a crumbling order, they will find their place in the pages of histories of literature. But for us, for our age, they are pointless, pathetic and comic anachronisms.” And in an essay on “The Formalist School of Poetry” (1923), Trotsky himself remarks acidly that “it does not make new poets of you to translate the philosophy of life of the Seventeenth Century into the language of the Acmeists.”16 Mandelstam had never been as widely known or read as was his more celebrated colleague. He was thus spared the kind of direct public attack that Akhmatova endured in the Soviet press of the early twenties.17 Even sympathetic postrevolutionary critics, though, followed Viktor Zhirmunsky’s lead in seeing Mandelstam chiefly as a subtle, elegant advocate of art
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
11
for art’s sake, the creator of a poetry almost too pure for this world in the best of times, and certainly not up to the monumental tasks set by the modern age for would-be poets of the future. He composes only “chamber music” in an age that demands Mayakovskian marches, Jakobson notes in an essay of 1921. And Iurii Tynianov echoes Jakobson in “Interim” (“Promezhutok,” 1924), as he gives us a Mandelstam who is a “pure lyricist,” an otherworldly poet who deals only in “small forms” refined almost out of existence.18 It is difficult to find traces of this quiet, well-mannered poet in the essays of the twenties, essays that celebrate a Russian history that is “active, forceful, thoroughly dialectical, a living battle of different powers fertilizing one another” (CPL, 141), and a Russian language formed “through ceaseless hybridization, cross-breeding and foreign-born (chuzherodnykh) influences” (CPL, 120). (And in this last phrase, we also see the foreign-born Mandelstam writing himself into the Russian tradition he describes.) Mandelstam’s versions of Russia’s past and language might do double duty as descriptions of his world culture and invented tradition. “Poetic culture,” he asserts in “Badger Hole” (1922), “arises from the attempt to avert catastrophe” (CPL, 137). We may be tempted to hear Jakobson’s chamber musician at work here, struggling in vain to tune out the discordant noise of his times. There is, however, another, more convincing way to read this statement. Mandelstam’s poetic, or world, culture (they are one and the same) not only manages to stave off impending disaster time and again. It actually requires the continuous stimulus of crises barely contained, if it is to survive and flourish. Mandelstam himself implies as much when he speaks in the same essay of culture’s “catastrophic essence” (CPL, 137). Mandelstam longs for his world culture not because it is lost forever, trapped in an irrecoverable past. This culture is beyond his reach precisely because it is, as Freidin suggests, under continuous construction, and, one might add, under a continuous “threat of destruction” as well (POM, 79). Mandelstam weaves the upheavals that mark his and his age’s histories into the fabric of a resilient tradition that draws power from the very forces it is intended to combat. In an essay of 1933, Boris Eikhenbaum notes that Mandelstam’s best lyrics are fueled by an ongoing “battle with the craft” of other poets. Those who would wish to learn from this “great poet” must likewise be prepared to do battle: “You must conquer Mandelstam. Not study him.”19 This rhetoric of battle and mastery is entirely appropriate to Mandelstam’s vision of poetry, which thrives on storm and stress, on insult, injury, and “literary spite” (POM, 127). In his autobiography, Mandelstam gives us his ideal literary history, which comes to him by way of his high school literature teacher, Vladimir Vasilievich Gippius: “Beginning as early as Radishchev and Novikov, V. V. had established personal relations with Russian writers, splenetic and loving liasons filled with noble enviousness, jealousy, with jocular disrespect, grievous unfairness—as is customary between
12
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
the members of one family” (POM, 130). If we substitute “strong poet” for Eikhenbaum’s “great poet” and combine his remarks with Mandelstam’s vision of literature as an endlessly squabbling family, we come up with a version of poetic tradition that looks very like Harold Bloom’s more recent notion of a poetry that derives its force from the ceaseless battling of poetic parents and their rebellious offspring.20 In such traditions, Apollinaire’s debate between tradition and innovation turns into something considerably less civil. It becomes a heated argument that threatens to erupt into the literary equivalent of war. But we need not look as far afield as Bloom to uncover comparable visions of a disruptive modern tradition. Modern Russian artists and thinkers were by necessity adept at weaving catastrophe into the substance of their visions, and it is not surprising that we should find similar theories of tradition far closer to home. The authors of these theories might have been startled to find themselves in such company. For all his astute observations on Mandelstam’s poetics, Iurii Tynianov clearly views Mandelstam as one of the exemplary poetarchaists at war with their more experimental brethren in his monumental study of literary Archaists and Innovators (1929). The tradition Tynianov describes in this study bears, however, clear affinities with Mandelstam’s lively, combative world culture. To the scholars of other ages, Tynianov claims, literary history may have seemed to follow an even course and its changes appeared to occur in “peaceful succession (preemvstvennost’).” The principle of genuine literary transformation lies, however, not in simple succession but in “battle and takeover”; and traditions grow through “upheavals,” in “leaps and bounds (smeshchenie, skachok),” not through the systematic evolution posited by earlier, happier generations. Indeed, Mandelstam anticipates Tynianov when he speaks in “The Wheat of Humanity” (1922) of all history and culture as driven by “catastrophe, unexpected shifts, destruction (katastrofa, neozhidannyi sdvig, razrushenie).”21 Only happy families are alike—or so Tolstoy claims in the famous opening lines of Anna Karenina. There are striking similarities, though, between the unhappy literary families that emerge in the traditions described by Mandelstam, Tynianov, and his fellow Formalist Viktor Shklovsky. Such unstable, crisis-ridden traditions would seem to lead inevitably to broken homes, disrupted families, and skewed, peculiar genealogies, and indeed, in Tynianov’s version of the ongoing struggle between literary fathers and sons, children inherit from their parents only by displacing them, and battle-hardened young artists often end up inadvertently “resembling their grandfathers more than the fathers who fought with them.” Writers avoid unwelcome parental interference in a still more roundabout way in the tangled family tree that Shklovsky proposes in an essay of 1923. “In the history of art,” Shklovsky insists, “the legacy is transmitted not from father to son, but from uncle to nephew.”22 Mandelstam is still more insistent on the rights of literary offspring to
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
13
pick and choose the ancestry that suits them in his early poem “I have not heard the tales of Ossian” (1914; #65). “I’ve come into a blessed legacy,” he announces in the poem’s final stanzas: Hu'ix pevcov blu'da[]ie sny_ Svoe rodstvo i skuhnoe sosedstvo My prezirat; zavedomo vol;ny. I ne odno sokrovi]e, byt; mo'et, Minuq vnukov, k pravnukam ujdet, I snova skal;d hu'u[ pesn[ slo'it I kak svo[ ee proizneset. The wandering dreams of other bards; We’re free to despise consciously Our kin and our dull neighbors. And this may not be the only treasure, either, To skip the grandsons, descending to their sons, And a skald will once again set down another’s song And speak it as though it were his own.
Brave words indeed—but such absolute freedom from the burden of the past is more easily proclaimed than practiced, as Mandelstam’s own poetry demonstrates. Suffice it to note for now, though, that the poem not only provides us with yet another skewed and twisted modernist genealogy. It also indicates the ways in which disinheritance may become a form of liberation for the poet unlucky enough to have been born with an unprepossessing family tree and raised in less than inspiring cultural company. Such a poet, if he is daring and desperate enough, may find himself in possession of a past and present community far grander than anything his actual origins might have seemed to portend. Poetic justice can at last be served, and fairy tales may finally come true, as cultural paupers contrive to take possession of princely treasures through ingenuity and pluck—or so “Ossian”’s optimistic young author would have us believe. Though Mandelstam’s later writings inevitably complicate this triumphant early vision, it remains nonetheless the ideal, ideally liberating version of tradition to which Mandelstam will return throughout his poetry and prose. THE SHIPWRECK OF MODERNITY Elam, Ninevah, Babylon were but beautiful vague names, and the total ruin of those worlds had as little significance for us as their very existence. But France, England, Russia . . . these too would be beautiful names. Lusitania, too, is a beautiful name. —Paul Valéry, “The Crisis of the Mind” (1919)
14
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
“Do “You know nothing? Do you see nothing? Do you remember Nothing?” I remember Those are pearls that were his eyes. —T. S. Eliot, The Waste Land (1922)
Mandelstam was adept at deriving cultural capital from apparently irremediable losses, and in his prose of the early twenties particularly, he manages time and again to turn the modern sense of an ending to his own purposes. He appears to mourn the modern rupture with the past in “Humanism and the Present” (1923): “The chaotic world has burst in—into the English ‘home’ as well as into the German Gemüt; chaos sings in our Russian stoves, banging our dampers and oven doors. . . . No laws preserve the house from catastrophe, provide it with any assurance or security” (CPL, 182). And it is not merely our homes that are at risk, he warns in “The End of the Novel” (1922). Our very selves are at stake, as we bear collective witness to “the catastrophic collapse of biography”: “Today Europeans are plucked out of their own biographies, like balls out of the pockets of billiard tables, and the same principle that governs the collision of billiard balls governs the laws of their actions” (CPL, 200). We have all fallen prey to a universe governed by contingency and chaos alone, as earlier ways of ordering experience fall far short of the needs of the modern age. The collapse of European culture may actually work to the advantage of the modernist orphan in search of cultural community, as Mandelstam demonstrates in “The Nineteenth Century” (1922), where his own dilemma and his generation’s merge. “We appear as colonizers to this new age, so vast and so cruelly determined,” Mandelstam proclaims: “To Europeanize and humanize the twentieth century, to provide it with teleological warmth—this is the task of those emigrants who survived the shipwreck of the nineteenth century and were cast by the will of fate upon a new historical continent” (CPL, 144). After the collapse of history and the shipwreck of the nineteenth century, all modern survivors are equally orphans and emigrants in the unknown land that is the twentieth century. The Jewish émigré turned Russian modernist finds his true community through disruption, and he takes his place at the center of his uprooted age as he works to articulate its mission. In “The Nineteenth Century,” Mandelstam stresses the affinities that modern Russians share with their European brethren: the historical differences that divided Russia from its Western neighbors in the past have been washed away by the shipwreck of the modern age. The disasters and catastrophes that punctuate the pages of Mandelstam’s postrevolutionary essays serve as great levelers. They erase the differences that separate nations
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
15
blessed with long, distinguished cultural traditions from countries whose pasts are more erratic, marked with the “incoherence and gaps” that Mandelstam sees as the trademark of both his family’s and his adopted nation’s history (POM, 172). And this is where we find the ties that link Mandelstam not so much to his fellow Europeans as to two Americans, T. S. Eliot and Ezra Pound, who turned to Europe’s past and present in search of what Eliot would also come to call “world culture.” Mandelstam’s dilemma and his compensatory vision were singular, but they were not unique; and it is no accident that two companions with whom he unwittingly shared his quest for an encompassing culture came, like him, from a country that stood uneasily on the outskirts of the European tradition.23 In Pound’s oblique self-portrait of the artist “Hugh Selwyn Mauberley” (1920), he mourns his hero’s birth “in a half-savage country, out of date.”24 Mandelstam himself could conceive of only one country whose “impenetrable thickets” (CPL, 87) were less hospitable to culture’s shaping energies than those of his adopted homeland. The “elemental forests” and “mighty vegetation” of American civilization are, he claims in an early essay, “impenetrable to the life-giving rays of culture” (CPL, 99). This America is clearly akin to the Russia—a “young country of half-animated matter and half-dead spirit” (CPL, 81)—that Mandelstam seeks to colonize with the aid of Petr Chaadaev in his 1915 essay on the romantic philosopher.25 And although we need not take Mandelstam’s characteristic hyperbole entirely at face value, America, like Russia, has always stood at an uncomfortable remove from the centers of European culture, and it shares with Russia a profound ambivalence toward the continent and the tradition to which it both does and does not belong. Mandelstam, Eliot, and Pound were alike, too, in sensing not only the difficulties, but the possibilities that accrued to the ambitious poet-synthesist who found his native land sorely lacking in the cultural legacy that could feed his outsized needs. “The Arts insist that a man shall dispose of all he has, even of his family tree, and follow art alone,” Eliot announces in The Sacred Wood (1920).26 The freedom that Mandelstam claims for the poet in “I have not heard the tales of Ossian” becomes an imperative for Eliot, but the impulse that lies behind both statements is recognizably the same, and the art both poets follow leads them in similar directions. Mandelstam’s Jewish emigrant origins made his relations with his adopted homeland even more complex than Eliot’s with his native land. Eliot and Mandelstam were alike, though, in their early sense that their inherited pasts barred them from the European culture they required, and they were alike in their insistence on the poet’s right to choose his own ancestry and sources. The provincial modernist is free to orphan himself in the hopes of achieving a more distinguished lineage and a richer, more rewarding legacy. Mandelstam was preoccupied throughout his life, his wife observes, by the question of “succession and continuity (preemstvennost”), which he
16
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
sought everywhere—in history, in culture, in art.” In a late essay Eliot claims that the ideal tradition grows from “the hereditary transmission of culture within a culture.”27 But the younger Eliot knew, as Mandelstam did, that his only hope for the heritage he sought lay in creative appropriation and inventive disruption. Mandelstam’s Chaadaev may have venerated “the sacred bond and succession of events”; but dispossessed poets who, like lands they come from, lack “continuity and unity,” are forced to find more roundabout ways to acquire traditions not rightfully theirs by birth (CPL 84, 88). One method is theft. Great poets “pile up all the excellences they can beg, borrow, or steal from their predecessors and contemporaries,” Ezra Pound announces in an early essay on Dante. And Eliot echoes Pound in a famous dictum from “Philip Massinger” (1920): “Immature poets imitate; mature poets steal.” Mature poets steal, and so do dispossessed ones, like Mandelstam’s François Villon, Pound’s Dante, or Pound, Eliot, and Mandelstam themselves. For the Mandelstam of the twenties and thirties, cultural theft becomes a way of life; true, unofficial culture thrives, like the poets who shape it, on “stolen air” (CPL, 316). The young Eliot chooses a less dubious route to European culture, a route that reveals his own origins in a nation of self-made citizens who value industry over inherited fortune and family name. Tradition, Eliot proclaims in “Tradition and the Individual Talent” (1919), “cannot be inherited, and if you want it you must obtain it by great labour.” Honest labor replaces thievery in this version of events, which is nonetheless still the cultural vision of the “Displaced Person” or “resident alien,” who must start from scratch and struggle ceaselessly to work his way into his chosen tradition.28 Eliot’s tradition places a heavy burden on the shoulders of the assiduous outsider who must work to earn his culture. It burdens him—but it also grants him special privileges. Tradition cannot be inherited. It cannot be sustained by passive reception or unreflecting repetition, and those who might appear to be in the direct line of succession are actually ill-served by their inherited histories. They do not perceive, as an outsider might, the need to work for what appears to be their birthright. They lack the drive and desire that come “from the fact of being everywhere a foreigner” and that are the special property of the perennial outsider.29 “There are advantages in coming from a large flat country that no one wants to visit.”30 Eliot’s remarks refer to Turgenev and James, but they speak just as well to his own situation and to Mandelstam’s. Though both poets sought to cut themselves off from inadequate pasts, they also learned to use their lack of a European birthright as they worked to invent and remember their world culture. The outsider who comes from the hinterlands may be inspired to go visiting himself, and his very foreignness and freedom from the European past may prove an unexpected asset in his travels. Mandelstam’s Chaadaev, whose historyless homeland has granted him “freedom of choice,” “steps on to the sacred soil” of the European tradi-
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
17
tion, a tradition “to which he is not bound by inheritance,” “precisely by the right of being a Russian”; and he energizes the sleepy, tradition-bound West by his foreign, unfettered presence (CPL, 88). Eliot’s disinherited American goes one step further. “It is the final perfection, the consummation of an American,” Eliot declares, “to become not an Englishman, but a European—something which no born European, no person of any European nationality can become.” The young Mandelstam observes the Europe he covets in the outlines of a map: “For the first time in a century, right before my eyes,/Your mysterious map is shifting!” he exclaims (#68). The perspective could only come from one who stands outside the picture’s frame. Only the outsider, unconstrained by national boundaries, can hope to see Europe whole. And only the outsider can lay claim to all of its treasures, past and present, by becoming a true European—or so Eliot implies. In The Sacred Wood, Eliot laments the American “remoteness in space from the European centre,” but this very remoteness may also generate the “tendency to seek the centre” that permits the foreigner to become not a born, but a self-made, European. Mandelstam was very much aware that the new arrival who comes to Europe seeking unity ends by inventing his own West. Like Eliot and like his Chaadaev, he was nonetheless possessed by the “wholeness hunger” of modern poetry, and the whole that Mandelstam and Eliot longed for lay, like Chaadaev’s, in a Europe visible only to the eyes of the perennial outsider.31 Mandelstam, Eliot, and Pound began their careers with a quest for what Eliot calls “a living and central tradition,” and their search for the center of world culture took all three “exiled, wandering poets” to the same source—to the Mediterranean, to the ancient worlds of Greece and Rome, and to the Romance cultures that sprang up where Rome had sown its colonies. Pound’s ambitions ultimately led him beyond the confines even of this capacious heritage. His vaulting goal was “to unite the cultures of America, Europe and the Orient” in his Cantos; and Noh Dramas, Saxon sagas, and Chinese calligrams all find their way into the new civilization made up of other cultures that his work is intended to create.32 For Eliot and Mandelstam, however, the Mediterranean remained the center of the world and of its culture, and both sought the cultural home they lacked in their imagined Europe. “The main stream of culture is the culture of Latin Europe,” Eliot writes in 1948. The capital of Mandelstam’s world culture shifts with the “place of man”—and of Mandelstam himself—“in the universe” (#66); it migrates from Rome to Greece and even takes up residence in Erevan for a time, as it follows the poet on his “Journey to Armenia” (1933). But even when Mandelstam and his culture take up wandering for good, his final fellow traveler is Dante Aligheri, the “Great European” for Mandelstam and Eliot alike, and Mandelstam’s “yearning for world culture” translates in a late poem into a longing for the “universal hills” of Dante’s native Tuscany (CPL, 400; #352). The Mediterranean and its great poet, whose Divine Comedy reaches back to antiquity and forward to
18
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
the modern world, accompanied Mandelstam throughout the exile, persecution, and isolation he endured in Stalin’s Russia of the thirties.33 “We are all, so far as we inherit the civilization of Europe, still citizens of the Roman Empire,” Eliot proclaims in a late essay. It is one thing to see a culture whole and another thing entirely to enter it, though. How does an outsider come to inherit a civilization that apparently moves in unbroken succession from ancient Rome to modern Europe? If Europe is already a whole, does it allow for or require further additions? Does it want the contributions of outsiders? How are uprooted modernists from the outskirts of Western culture, upstart poets, “wanderers with no fixed abode,” to find their way into this tradition, even with plenty of hard work or diligent theft? Where are the apertures and gaps that will admit them?34 Such problems are particularly tricky for the modernist from the provinces, from the large flat places along the edges of European history. He must come to terms not only with the pervasive modern sense of an ending; he must also cope with the no less troubling knowledge that he has not even had the opportunity to lose the culture he misses because it was never his to begin with. The provincial modernist in search of an encompassing tradition is barred from his longed-for inheritance not only by time, but by space. He is distant from the European center in every possible way. He may have come too late for European culture, but he was not in its direct line of succession in any case. Geography and history have already seen to that. The provincial modernist can turn the disruptions of the modern age to his advantage, though. The modern collapse of “the world of time and its connections,” though it may seem to mean the collapse of tradition itself, can actually lead to a new kind of tradition, one that permits the outsider to defy space and time—and this is true for Pound and Eliot as well as Mandelstam.35 With the “shipwreck of the nineteenth century,” all are freed to stake their claim to those treasures of the past that still remain. In this new and orphaned age, Europeans and provincials, cosmopolitans and country cousins are equally out of place and ill at ease. The old order may have vanished, but, with the line of succession broken once and for all, endless possibilities open up for those who are willing to invent as well as remember as they shape new wholes from the fragments of vanished pasts.
THE FAMILY OF PHILOLOGY In poetry the boundaries of the national are destroyed and the elements of one language exchange greetings with those of another over the heads of space and time. —Osip Mandelstam, “Remarks on Chénier” (1914–15) Between the true artists of any time there is, I believe, an unconscious community. —T. S. Eliot, “The Function of Criticism” (1923)
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
19
Thus am I Dante for a space and am One François Villon, ballad-lord and thief. —Ezra Pound, “Histrion” (1908)
Dante, Mandelstam insists, “is an antimodernist.” The reasons he gives for Dante’s antimodernism, are, however, precisely what make his Dante modern. “His contemporaneity,” Mandelstam claims in his “Conversation about Dante” (1933), “is continuous, incalculable and inexhaustible” (CPL, 420): “Having combined the uncombinable, Dante altered the structure of time or perhaps, on the contrary, he was forced to a glossolalia of facts, to a synchronism of events, names and traditions severed by centuries, precisely because he had heard the overtones of time” (CPL, 439). Dante employs, in other words, the techniques of the modernist outcast to create his poetic culture. The modern poet who is sensitive to the overtones, or the noise, of his times realizes that the very crisis of the age has laid an inexhaustible wealth of traditions and names before him. He is free, with Dante, to shape a new synchronic order from the inexhaustible contemporaneity that is history in the modern age. “Today,” Mandelstam announces in “The Word and Culture” (1921), “a kind of speaking in tongues is taking place”: “In sacred frenzy poets speak the language of all times, all cultures. Nothing is impossible. As the room of a dying man is open to everyone, so the door of the old world is flung open before the crowd. Suddenly everything becomes public property. Come and take your pick” (CPL, 116). All are free to bid as the holdings of the old world are auctioned off. The “modern poet-synthesizer” (CPL, 116) may pick and choose, or mix and match his pasts, for all ages are equally close at hand. Phenomena have been liberated, along with the provincial modernist, from the tyranny of sequence and succession; and the poet, if he is able “to preserve the principle of unity amidst the vortex of changes and the unceasing flood of phenomena” (CPL, l17), can take the pasts he desires and create from them a new order, a new history, a new lineage and new community that exist in defiance of time and space. Mandelstam shared his sense of the age’s possibilities with his AngloAmerican contemporaries. “We are the heirs of all the ages,” Ford Madox Ford exults, and Pound and Eliot agree. “All ages are contemporaneous,” Pound proclaims in The Spirit of Romance (1910): “This is especially true of literature, where the real time is independent of the apparent, and where many dead men are our grandchildren’s contemporaries.” Eliot, who insists in “Tradition and the Individual Talent” on the past’s continued presence in true culture, creates his world literature on the basis of this “real” time. For the truly traditional poet, he explains, “the whole of the literature of Europe from Homer and within it the whole of the literature of his own country has a simultaneous existence and composes a simultaneous order.” Such a literature vanquishes both time and space. It occupies its own territory and commands its own chronology. It is as accessible to the disinherited modernist as it is to the provincial poet who dreams of conquering the
20
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
capitals of Europe. It is ideal for the poet who is a child both of the provinces and of the modern age.36 In his prescription for a simultaneous tradition, Eliot insists on wholeness, history, and order. In “On the Nature of the Word,” Mandelstam demands a “principle of unity” that will give shape to the unstable landscape of modern civilization (CPL, 117). The world that these poets envision, freed from its moorings in time and space, would seem, however, to lend itself more readily to chaos than to culture. The possibilities of the modern age are inextricably bound to its problems, and even the most gifted, ambitious poet-synthesizer might falter before the task of transforming the age’s hodgepodge of places, people, dates, and artifacts into a cohesive culture. How is the poet-synthesist to proceed if what he seeks is not fragments from a vanished past but a new kind of living whole, not complete liberation from history but creative dialogue with it? What culture can accommodate both history and simultaneous order? What tradition can withstand the shocks of the modern age and retain its wholeness, while holding room for newcomers and outsiders? How is one to preserve, or discover, a principle of unity that will provide both coherence and flexibility amid the vortex of changes that is the modern age? Language, Mandelstam observes in “On the Nature of the Word,” “changes from period to period, never congealing for a moment. Yet at every point, within the confines of all its changes, it remains a fixed quantity, a ‘constant’ that is blindingly clear to the philological consciousness. At every point it remains internally unified.” It may thrive, like Mandelstam’s Russian, on ceaseless hybridization. Still “it will always remain true to itself”; it will retain at every moment its identity and inner unity (CPL, 120). Mandelstam’s Russian changes and grows throughout history. It derives its energy from difference, from variety and “inoculations of foreign blood” (POM, 81). It possesses, nonetheless, a wholeness that cannot be undone by its heterogeneity, and an integrity that persists in spite of its transformations in history. This integrity is apparent at every moment to the philologically sensitive mind of the linguist or the poet. In his “Retrospect” Jakobson notes that the artistic ferment of the early twentieth century gave birth to a new way of looking at language. This movement went both ways, and new notions of language as a “perpetual present” that retained the past even as it pointed to the future, influenced not only budding linguists but poets in quest of world culture as well.37 Eliot, Pound, and Mandelstam shared, if not a common language, then a common philological consciousness, and they find the basis and the model for their world culture in the type of language that Mandelstam celebrates in “On the Nature of the Word.” “The generation of Pound and Eliot,” Hugh Kenner observes, “had access to a new way of thinking about language,” and Kenner’s remarks on modernist philology hold as much for Mandelstam as they do for Eliot or Pound. The modern poet-philologist perceives that language is “an organism that can maintain its identity as it
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
21
grows and develops in time” and that “keeps all times simultaneous” while it grows. It changes endlessly, yet it is continuous. It outlasts the fall of empires and ages while bearing at every moment its complex, hybrid history within it. “Behind every sound we utter extends a history of ordered changes and remote cultural transactions,” Kenner notes, and “the poetic of our time grows from this discovery.”38 The modernist poet need only speak, then, to lay claim to the complex network of histories and cultures that inhabit his native tongue and tie his speech to other languages and traditions. “It was possible,” Kenner comments, for the Anglo-American modernist “to ignore the national literatures, to conceive poetry as international and interlingual . . . [hence] the literature of Europe, like its speech, could be conceived as one rich organism, and the study of poetry be seen as inextricable from the study of philology.” “The very idea of an interlingual community of poets” stems for Eliot and Pound from “the great idea that languages were siblings, that a creating urgency flowed across their (miscalled) boundaries.”39 The English-speaking modernist may simply turn to his native English in order to receive instant access to a poetic community that ignores the divisions between languages, ages, and nations. “Philology is the family,” Mandelstam announces in “On the Nature of the Word” (CPL, 123). Once again, though, he finds himself possessed of the wrong family tree. Russian, of course, derives from different sources than does English; and Mandelstam’s great essay is preoccupied with the problem of how to lay claim, on his own behalf and on Russia’s, to the classical and European heritage he requires to complete his imaginatively refigured genealogy. He is finally forced to claim kinship with European culture on the basis of Russian’s inner, non-etymological affinity with the Western tradition—but the resourceful poet-synthesist is no more daunted by the gaps in his linguistic genealogy than he is by the lacunae in his literary inheritance. His hybrid Russian contains, he claims, an “inner Hellenism” that guarantees its access to a larger Western tradition (CPL, 127). Mandelstam would have found his way into this expanded philological family in any case. In his “Remarks on Chénier” (1914), he insists that poetic speech itself, whatever its national origins, participates by its nature in a multilingual community of world poetry: “In poetry the boundaries of the national are destroyed and the elements of one language exchange greetings with those of another over the heads of space and time, for all languages are bound in a fraternal union which is strengthened in the freedom and domesticity of each, and within this freedom they are fraternally related, and they greet each other as members of a single family” (CPL, 81). For Pound, Kenner notes, “all poets are contemporaneous, not merely the poets a common idiom unites,” but “the poets of whatever date or language.”40 Pound and Eliot would not have known the language in which Mandelstam describes his brotherhood of poets. They would, however, have recognized the poetic language he celebrates and the poetic
22
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
community this language creates, for it is the same language and community to which they themselves aspired. This philological community offers multiple advantages to the outsider in search of world culture. It is uncommonly hospitable—at least to the writer who is willing to work for his keep, who is prepared to take on the requisite linguistic labors. A poet who desires membership in this community does not require a distinguished pedigree. He has only to recognize and master the possibilities of his native speech to be welcomed into an extended poetic family. This community is, moreover, like its component languages, a hybrid; each of its member languages is equally foreign and equally native within its heterogeneous whole. Russian derives its vitality, Mandelstam claims, from its very impurity, from the continuous crossbreeding that shapes its hybrid nature. The best poetry grows, Eliot notes, from “the struggle between native and foreign elements.” For Pound, the “constant cross-fertilization between different languages” prevents the “linguistic provincialism” that is the death of true culture.41 The mobile, polyglot unity of Eliot’s or Pound’s English, like Mandelstam’s Russian, allows for and even requires the continuous contributions of outsiders. Their world culture is no less dependent on the generosity of strangers. The notion of a heteregeneous poetry that draws on all cultures while retaining its inner unity lends itself more readily to theory than to practice. Yet the dream of such a poetry informs the very texture of the poetry shaped by these would-be citizens of world culture. In “Conversation about Dante,” Mandelstam celebrates “the orgy of quotations” and the abundance of “lexical thrusts” he finds at work in Dante’s Divine Comedy (CPL, 401): “There is the barbarian thrust towards German hushing sounds and Slavic cacophony; there is the Latin thrust, at times toward Dies irae and Benedictus qui venit , at other times towards kitchen Latin. There is the great impulse toward the speech of his native province—the Tuscan thrust” (CPL, 446). The same multiplicity of voices and speeches informs the poetry of Mandelstam, Eliot, and Pound. Eliot’s Waste Land (1922) is, of course, this century’s most famous patchwork of poetic quotations. “These fragments I have shored against my ruins,” Eliot mourns as his poem draws to its close. Its last stanza mimics the kind of linguistic and cultural disruption that is for Eliot the landscape of modern culture, even as its final lines, given in the Sanskrit that is among the oldest of all Indo-European languages, hint at a linguistic and cultural unity that underlies “the immense panorama of futility and anarchy which is contemporary history”: I sat upon the shore Fishing, with the arid plain behind me Shall I at least set my lands in order? London Bridge is falling down falling down falling down Poi s’ascose nel foco che gli affina
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
23
Quando fiam uti chelidon —O swallow swallow Le Prince d’Aquitaine à la tour abolie These fragments I have shored against my ruins Why then Ile fit you. Hieronymo’s mad againe. Datta. Dayadhvam. Damyata. Shantih shantih shantih 42
Almost any page of Pound’s Cantos, taken at random, will yield a similar amalgam of linguistic fragments, often not just in multiple languages but in more than one alphabet. The conclusion of Pound’s first Canto (1915/ 1925) may be less conspicuously polyglot than the closing of “The Waste Land.” As Pound begins his lifelong struggle to “write the Paradise” of a new civilization, though, he is no less preoccupied than Eliot with the role of language in shaping a new cultural community from the linguistic artifacts of the past. And I stepped back, And he strong with the blood, said then: “Odysseus “Shalt return through spiteful Neptune, over dark seas, “Lose all companions.” And then Anticlea came. Lie quiet Divus. I mean, that is Andreas Divus, In officina Wecheli, 1538, out of Homer. And he sailed, by Sirens and thence outward and away And unto Circe. Venerandam, In the Cretan’s phrase, with the golden crown, Aphrodite, Cypri munimenta sortita est, mirthful, orichalchi, with golden Girdles and breast bands, thou with dark eyelids Bearing the golden bough of Argicida. So that:
These lines conclude Pound’s free translation of a passage from Homer’s Odyssey, and they demonstrate the degree to which language itself becomes the hero of Pound’s modern saga. “The language of Canto I,” as Christine Froula notes, “is not simply a translator’s modern English version of the ancient Greek, but folds together, ply over ply, Homer’s Greek, the Latin of the [sixteenth century] translator, Andreas Divus, whose text mediates between Pound and the Greek.” Past and present, foreign and native coexist in a linguistic fabric that is “heavy with history.”43 Froula’s imagery of fabric and weaving is equally apt for Mandelstam’s poetics of history. “I love the custom of weaving,” he writes in “Tristia” (1918; #104), and Ovid’s ancient Rome converges with postrevolutionary Russia in his version of the poet as weaver of histories and tongues: Snuet helnok, vereteno 'u''it, Smotri, navstrehu, slovno pux lebq'ij, U'e bosaq Deliq letit!
24
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
The shuttle warps, the spindle hums, And look! like swan’s down, barefoot Delia Comes flying to meet us.
Mandelstam’s strategies for weaving his world culture into the fabric of his verse are less flamboyant than Eliot’s or Pound’s; his borrowings seldom take the shape of long quotations in foreign tongues complete with glosses. The barefoot Delia Mandelstam magically summons up with his weaving hints, though, at the ways in which he endows his Russian speech with “inner Hellenism.” This Delia comes to him through Ovid’s contemporaries Tibullus and Horace, in whose verse she appears; and her Greek and Roman name had, moreover, already been given a Russian inflection by Konstantin Batiushkov (1787–1855), who had translated Tibullus’ poem on Delia over a century earlier. Mandelstam draws both the classical and the Russian past into his web of remembered and invented culture by way of a single name.44 An astute early critic of Mandelstam’s verse hints at the distinctiveness of his hybrid poetic speech when he dubs it “classical transsense.”45 And Mandelstam uses still subtler ways of weaving foreign pasts into the fabric of modern Russian speech in other lyrics. . Let us turn here, by way of example, to an early version of the Homer who haunts Mandelstam’s verse as well as Pound’s: Bessonnica. Gomer. Tugie parusa. Q spisok korablej prohel do serediny% Sej dlinnyj vyvodok, sej poezd 'uravlinyj, Hto nad Ellado[ kogda-to podnqlsq. Kak 'uravlinyj klin v hu'ie rube'ió Na golovax carej bo'estvennaq penaó Kuda plyvete vy? Kogda by ne Elena, Hto Troq vam odna, axejskie mu'i? I more, i Gomeróvse dvi'etsq l[bov;[. Kogo 'e slywat; mne? I vot Gomer molhit, I more hernoe, vitijstvuq, wumit I s tq'kim groxotom podxodit k izgolov;[. 1915 (#79) Sleeplessness. Homer. Taut sails. I’ve read halfway through the list of ships: That long-drawn flock, that convoy of cranes That arose once over Hellas. Like a wedge of cranes toward foreign borders— Divine foam on the emperors’ heads— Where are you sailing? If not for Helen, What is Troy alone to you, Achaean men?
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
25
Both the sea and Homer—all is moved by love. To whom should I listen? Homer now falls still, And the black sea rumbles, orating, And with a heavy crash, draws up beside the bed.
Mandelstam’s brief lyric, like Pound’s first Canto, evokes both the presence of the past and its pastness, as the events described in Homer’s writings converge with and diverge from the experience of the modernist poet-synthesizer who works to recuperate an ancient history for the modern age. Mandelstam’s poem moves from mediation—in the poem’s opening stanza he contemplates the Iliad’s famous catalog of ships—to immediacy, when, in its final lines, Homer’s wine-dark sea sweeps up along the poet’s bedside. Mandelstam achieves this transformation through linguistic sleight of hand, as he endows a purely Russian word with a Hellenistic soul by way of his creative etymology. The sea itself, móre in Russian, is anagrammatically concealed within Homer, Gomér; and Homer, conversely, lies partially hidden in the Russian “sea,” as Mandelstam reminds us by rocking the two words back and forth in the poem’s closing lines: “I mó-re, i Go-mér”; “I vót Go-mér molchít/ I mó-re chérnoe . . .” Centuries, traditions, and linguistic boundaries wash away in the verbal play that gives all Russian speakers permanent access to a Homeric past through their own sea, their more. Such inventive etymologies are one way into the expanded philological family that Mandelstam, Eliot, and Pound seek. In an early essay, Eliot describes another way to acquire the rich history craved by modern orphans; and his method is one that Mandelstam and Pound energetically employ as well. The poet works his way into a new past through what Eliot calls “a feeling of profound kinship, or rather of a peculiar personal intimacy, with another, probably a dead author. . . . Our friendship gives us an introduction to the society in which our friend moved; we learn its origins and its endings; we are broadened . . . we have been quickened, and we become bearers of a tradition.”46 He might be describing the Mandelstam who calls François Villon his “friend and favorite,” his “favorite relation,” who “feels himself the poet’s contemporary” (III, 23; #382; II, 307) and who discovers a fellow traveler in an endlessly contemporaneous Dante obscured by centuries of misguided criticism (CPL 410, 440). The young Pound goes even further in his search for “mine own kind,” “my kin of the spirit” among the poets of the past. He resurrects his absent “soul kin” in his own flesh as he converges with distant poets recovered for a moment from other times and places. “No man hath dared to write this thing as yet,” he proclaims with a very young poet’s brashness in “Histrion” ( 1908): And yet I know, how that the souls of all men great At times pass through us, And we are melted into them, and are not Save reflexions of their souls.
26
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
Thus am I Dante for a space and am One François Villon, ballad-lord and thief Or am such holy ones I may not write, Lest blasphemy be writ against my name; This for an instant and the flame is gone.
Pound would soon abandon the fussy diction that so often gives his early lyrics the flavor, he later complained, of “stale creampuffs.” He was quick to put into practice, though, the kind of composite speaker he imagines in these lines; and Mandelstam and Eliot were equally adept at creating poetic speakers who simultaneously resist time and embody history by yoking together the disparate “I” ’s of different nations and ages with their own lyric voices. One need only think here of Pound’s Odysseus, his Seafarer, his Sextus Propertius; of Eliot’s Tiresias or his Magi; or of Mandelstam’s Ovid and his Chaadaev (#79, #80, #104, #69).47 Pound’s poem also suggests the ways in which the ambitious modernist who works to acquire a past much vaster than any one family or nation could provide is also able to circumvent the burden of this overwhelming past. The modern poet who has been denied the European history he requires both by his origins and his age depends on the past that he desires for his community and for the impetus to new creation. At the same time, though, this past depends on him, for without his intervention it cannot be brought to life again within the modern age. The outcast modernist may seek out new kin and neighbors among the dead poets of distant times— but the dead poets also require their self-chosen descendants. They will remain dead to the present age unless their potential is tapped by a selfproclaimed “spiritual heir” and translated into a new idiom for another generation, another tradition or nation. “The present only keeps the past alive,” Eliot asserts.48 Mandelstam is still more audacious: “Yesterday has not yet been born. It has not yet really existed. I want Ovid, Pushkin, and Catullus to live once more, and I am not satisfied with the historical Ovid, Pushkin, and Catullus” (CPL, 113). The poet must assist at the birth of his poetic fathers in the present moment, and as the present moment becomes the past, his task begins again. Tradition is obtained only by great labor, Eliot writes. The same labor that the modernist poet expends in acquiring his history can also work to liberate him from its weight. The fate of the past lies in the hands of the poet-parvenu, and Mandelstam is quick to assert his power. “Not a single poet has yet appeared. We are free from the burden of memories,” he proclaims in “The Word and Culture” (1921; CPL, 114). This can never be entirely true for a poet whose work depends as much on remembrance as invention, and this was the case for Pound and Eliot as well as Mandelstam. For all three poets past and present are engaged in what is both an endless struggle and a fruitful collaboration that revives the life of the past as it provides the modern outsider with his tradition and community.
•
M O D E R N I S T
C R E A T I O N
O F
T R A D I T I O N
•
27
For all the congruences between their visions of a world culture, Mandelstam, Eliot, and Pound are in many ways worlds apart. The traditions they came from—Russian and Jewish on the one hand, Anglo-American on the other—were vastly different, even if the traditions the poets worked to create resemble each other in important ways. I will not address the many differences in temperament and poetic practice between the three here, differences that were significant to begin with and that became still more acute with the passage of time. To compare even briefly their later careers is to become aware, though, not of the powers of time so much as of the dictates of space. What separates Pound and Eliot from Mandelstam is not chronology—their early poetic careers roughly coincide in terms of dates— but geography, and the gap it opened between them was wide indeed. The late twenties saw Eliot, “the successful self-exile” in England, formalize his adoption into his British “homeland of the spirit,” consolidate his self-created identity as a “classicist in literature, royalist in politics, and anglo-catholic in religion,” and find for himself and his revised modernist vision a large, attentive audience in his own generation. The year 1929 specifically marked the apogee of Pound’s success; he found himself, Frank Lentricchia notes, “with the literary revolution won [and] modernism fully in place,” while he himself was hailed as its chief “entrepreneur and guru.”49 These same years witnessed the final defeat of their Russian contemporaries, as socialist realism became the order of the day and Stalin’s compliant “engineers of human souls” took the place of even the most ardently revolutionary avant-garde artists and poets. The years that marked Eliot’s and Pound’s great successes bore witness a world away to Mandelstam’s gradual exclusion, in practice if not in fact, from the nation he had worked so hard to adopt. They saw his world culture become the forbidden homeland of the poet-pariah who could only hope that his “moving lips” (#306) would find an understanding ear in some later generation, and that a distant interlocutor would bring him and his words to life again just as he had revived the voices and visions of others. By the late twenties the Soviet state was doing its best to block the kinds of border crossings, both literal and figurative, that were for Mandelstam the essence of a living culture. Only the poet-pariah who lives defiantly on his own culture’s margins would dare to keep crossing, in spirit at least, into the forbidden zones of other cultures in search of the stolen air that nourishes world literature. But what is stolen may be taken back, and the thief may be locked up or hanged, as Mandelstam had learned early on from his friend François Villon. “I think it would be a long time before Soviet society could afford to approve a Villon if one arose,” Eliot remarked prophetically in 1932, one year before Mandelstam wrote the poem on Stalin that would ultimately become his death sentence.50 Mandelstam paid a high price indeed for his stolen air. The boundaries that came to divide Russia from the West in the years following the revolution may seem as vast and insuperable as those that
28
•
C H A P T E R
O N E
•
separate centuries, epochs, millennia. Yet Eliot’s use of Villon as a touchstone or test case for the new Soviet state testifies to the ways in which Mandelstam succeeded in finding a community of poets who unwittingly joined forces in defiance of space, if not of time, in their quest to create a world culture. Pound envisioned a “world community of poets” made up of “the sons of Homer.”51 By laying claim to the same genealogy—Homer, Villon, Dante, Shakespeare, Gautier—the modernist orphans Mandelstam, Eliot, and Pound become, if not brothers, then at least not-so-distant cousins. “A common inheritance and a common cause unite artists consciously or unconsciously,” Eliot announces in an early essay. Mandelstam, Eliot, and Pound are linked both by their chosen legacies and by the ends to which they put their self-selected pasts. Modernist poetry grew, Eliot observes in 1953, from the efforts of “a number of scattered investigators” who didn’t “like [their] relatives” and turned instead to “writers of another country and another language, or of a remoter age.” These investigators shared what Eliot calls elsewhere the need “to collaborate, to exchange, to contribute” as they worked to invent their new culture.52 In “Conversation about Dante,” Mandelstam calls for “joint international endeavors” to resurrect the long-dead Dante and restore him to the present age. It is only through such efforts, he suggests, that time can be mastered and made to serve human ends. “For Dante,” Mandelstam asserts, “time is the content of history understood as a single synchronic act and vice-versa: the contents of history are the joint containing of time by colleagues, competitors, and co-discoverers” (CPL, 420). In the first decades of the twentieth century, Mandelstam, Eliot, and Pound became in ways they could not have suspected colleagues and co-discoverers as they worked to uncover a world culture vast and varied enough to satisfy the desires of provincial modernists determined to overcome the constraints of time and space through a modern creation of tradition.
•
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
T
W
O
•
Self-Creation and the Creation of Culture It was as if the stone thirsted for another being. It itself discovered the dynamic potential hidden within it, as if it were begging admittance into the “groined arch” in order to participate in the joyous cooperative action of those like it. —Osip Mandelstam, “The Morning of Acmeism” (1913)
SELF-CREATION Whenever I remake a song . . . it is myself that I remake. —William Butler Yeats, “Epigraph,” Collected Works (1908), vol. 2
All the “things that Mandelstam creates have biographies,” Nikolai Berkovsky remarks apropos of the many people and objects that Mandelstam endows with succinct, suggestive histories throughout his prose and, most notably, in his autobiography, The Noise of Time (1925). Berkovsky’s observation is entirely apt—and yet it seems puzzling in the light of Mandelstam’s own pronouncements on biography generally and on his own personal history in particular. In “The Nineteenth Century” (1922), Mandelstam records “the catastrophic collapse of biography” to which the twentieth century has borne reluctant witness (CPL, 144). To judge from the evidence of his autobiography, though, this collapse may have been less than catastrophic for Mandelstam himself: it is instead precisely the kind of crisis that serves as the necessary spur to new creation throughout his work. Mandelstam, paradoxically, makes it clear in his autobiography that he himself aspires to be what Boris Tomashevsky would call “a poet without a biography,” a poet who does not invite attention to a private life that lies safely concealed behind an opaque, apparently impersonal art. The distaste for dreary kin and neighbors that Mandelstam expresses early on in “I have not heard the tales of Ossian” is intensified in The Noise of Time, where he announces that his memory, so welcoming and open to all of Western culture, “is inimical to everything personal” (POM, 122). Mandelstam would have sympathized with Eliot’s insistence that the poet’s progress consists of a “continual extinction of personality” or with the assertions of his fellow post-symbolist, Boris Pasternak, who remarks in his autobiography, Safe
30
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
Conduct (1931), that “impersonality is more complex that personality,” and who claims to speak of his own life only “when someone else’s biography requires it.”1 For all their personal and poetic differences, Mandelstam and Pasternak were united in their resistance to the cult of personality that preoccupied their Symbolist precursors. The escape from personality that these poets celebrate, though, is predictably far more complex in practice than it appears to be in theory. Indeed Eliot, arguably the century’s most influential advocate of impersonal verse, tacitly admits as much when he notes that “only those who have personality and emotions know what it means to want to escape from these things.”2 And Mandelstam’s autobiography can be read as testimony to his ongoing struggle with a personal history that refuses to remain mere history, that makes its presence felt even—especially—in his most fervent efforts to resist it. We need only restore his literary declaration of independence—“My memory is inimical to everything personal”—to its proper context in The Noise of Time to sense the complexities that mark Mandelstam’s use and abuse of his personal history. The phrase comes from the magnificent set piece on modernist alienation à la Mandelstam that opens the chapter entitled “Komissarzhevskaia”: My desire is to speak not about myself but to track down the age, the noise, and the germination of time. My memory is inimical to everything personal . . . and it labors not to reproduce but to distance the past. A raznochinets needs no memory—it is enough for him to tell of the books he has read, and his biography is done. Where for happy generations the epic speaks in hexameters and chronicles I have merely the sign of the hiatus, and between me and the age there lies a pit, a moat, filled with clamorous time, the place where a family and reminiscences of a family ought to have been. What was it my family wished to say? I do not know. It was tongue-tied from birth—but it had, nevertheless, something that it might have said. Over my head and over the heads of many of my contemporaries there hangs congenital tongue-tie. We were not taught to speak but to babble—and only by listening to the swelling noise of the age and the bleached foam on the crest of its wave did we acquire a language. A revolution is itself about life and death and cannot endure idle chatter about life and death in its presence. Its throat is parched with thirst, but it would not accept a single drop of moisture from alien hands. Nature—revolution—eternal thirst—inflammation (perhaps it envies those ages when thirst was quenched in a quiet home-like way by simply going off to the place where the sheep were watered . . . [but] it dares not, it is afraid to approach the sources of being.). But what did these “sources of being (istochniki bytiia)” ever do for the revolution? (my ellipses; POM, 122–23; II, 99–100)
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
31
This dense, occasionally perplexing passage is typical, both in its devices and in what we might call its master plot, of Mandelstam’s ongoing efforts to shape a life for himself through writing that will guarantee for him a place both in his own age and in his ideal world culture.3 Mandelstam’s gift for taking what seem to be the troublesome specifics of his own situation and transforming them into his bond with his nation and his age is abundantly in evidence in this passage. His memory, Mandelstam claims, is inimical to his personal past. He proceeds to tell us, though, that he has no past to oppose; where happier generations have family archives, he laments, “I have merely the sign of the hiatus.” He then uses this very absence of a past to allign himself with a peculiarly Russian tradition, that of the raznochintsy, the self-made intellectuals who sprang up between the cracks in the Russian class system early in the nineteenth century. As the passage progresses, it becomes clear, however, that what Mandelstam lacks is not a family per se, but a speaking family that can articulate whatever history it does possess: “What was it my family wished to say? I do not know. It was tongue-tied from birth.” And once again, the unfortunate family legacy that initially seems to bar him from his age (“between me and the age there lies a pit, a moat, filled with clamorous time”) is made to serve his purposes. It becomes his bridge to an entire generation of tongue-tied Russians, handicapped, perhaps, by the Symbolist murkiness of their literary precursors: “Over my head and over the head of many of my contemporaries there hangs congenital tongue-tie. We were not taught to speak but to babble.” Mandelstam does not so much distance his past as displace it; and nowhere are the resulting deformations clearer than in the idiosyncratic portrait of the revolution that concludes the passage. This revolution apparently has vocal problems of its own; its throat “is parched with thirst.” Its most salient feature, though, draws it still closer to the poet who depicts it: Mandelstam’s revolution is preoccupied with its relations to an oddly personalized past. It also apparently envies earlier, happier generations, when things were done “in a quiet, home-like way.” And it , too, is troubled by its ambivalence toward its origins: “It is afraid to approach the sources of being. But what did these sources of being ever do for [it]?” Like Mandelstam himself, this revolution cannot decide on the proper distance to be kept between itself and its family history. The master plot that informs this passage and other of Mandelstam’s works might be summarized as follows: the poet, or one of his many surrogates, must struggle to re-form or outrun a chaotic past that can only be mastered by language. This language, in turn, provides the entryway into the society and culture that Mandelstam requires. This is the chief story of The Noise of Time, which culminates in the poet’s mastering the secrets of Bildung in a double sense, as he learns to shape not just a self, but a “home” and a “family” (dom , sem’ia) in art by learning to “construct liter-
32
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
ature as family history (stroit’ literaturu kak rod)” (POM, 130; II, 106). And this is the story that lends its shape to all Mandelstam’s early poetry and prose, from his first essay on “François Villon” (1910) to the multiple variants of his early collection, Stone (Kamen’, 1913, 1916; 1923, 1928).4 All the things that Mandelstam composes do have biographies, and this includes not only images or characters within individual texts, but the very structure of the early work as such. What emerges in this work in variation after variation is a complex, refracted, highly self-conscious portrait of the artist in search of a self, a language, and a society that will facilitate his plans for an encompassing world culture. This is the poetic life that concerns me here and in future chapters: not the actual biography of the historical Osip Mandelstam so much as the shape that biography takes as it is deformed and reformed to serve the needs of Osip Mandelstam the modernist artist. Similarly, the Mandelstam I refer to in these pages is not only the Mandelstam who lived and died in Russia in the first part of this century; it is also the Mandelstam who struggles to shape and reshape his poetic self within the boundaries of his art. These boundaries are themselves permeable and shifting. “The borderline dividing what is a work of poetry from what is not,” as Roman Jakobson remarks, “is less stable than the frontiers of the Chinese empire’s territories”; and Mandelstam himself was notoriously impatient with fixed and finished boundaries in life or art. Nevertheless, it is the interaction between “modernist making and self-making”—the shifting shape of Mandelstam’s life in art as it intersects with his created tradition—that is the subject of this study.5 Stone marks, I have argued, a complex effort at self-creation. Mandelstam’s first critics, though, were quick to complain that there was no self to be found in the poems of Stone. “He never speaks about himself, his soul or his immediate perceptions of either his inner or outer life,” Viktor Zhirmunsky writes in a generally favorable assessment of Stone’s second redaction. Other critics were less sympathetic to Mandelstam’s apparent refusal to bare his soul in his verse. He is, A. Deich charges in a review of Stone’s second edition, a thoroughly “lifeless poet,” and other critics concurred. “If you read through O. Mandelstam’s book of poems and then try to construct an image of the poet’s appearance (lik),” I. Oksenov grumbles, “you can’t do it. . . . Mandelstam as a poet is simply missing (I’m afraid he’s gone for good).” Zhirmunsky is right to see the apparent impersonality of Mandelstam’s early verse as a reaction against the self-celebration that dominated so much of his precursors’ work—“I’m a sudden break, I’m playful thunder, I’m a crystal stream, I’m everyone’s and no one’s,” Konstantin Bal’mont proclaims in one famous Symbolist self-celebration—and the critical response to Stone can be explained in part by the expectations of a generation of readers trained by two generations of Symbolists to expect soul-baring of cosmic proportions from their poets.6 Zhirmunsky and his fellow critics err, though, in supposing that, since
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
33
there is no overt, assertive self in the Symbolist mode on display in the lyrics of Stone, then the poems hold no self at all. They are simply looking in the wrong places for the wrong kind of self. Mandelstam himself was highly critical of his Symbolist precursors’ excessive self-preoccupation, and in an early essay he takes Bal’mont to task specifically for his sollipsistic sins: “[Bal’mont] is downright pathological. He cannot utter the word ‘I’ softly. He screams ‘I’ ” (“On the Interlocutor,” 1913; CPL, 70). He expands these charges a decade later in “A Letter about Russian Poetry” (1922) to include an entire generation of Symbolists who suffered from “hypertrophy of the creative ‘I’ ” and thus neglected “the most interesting process in poetry—the growth of the poetic personality” (CPL 157). Elsewhere he warns that in “raising [society] from chaos to the harmonious order of organic existence,” “the amorphous, formless person, the unorganized personality is society’s greatest foe” (CPL 108). These remarks call attention to what is distinctive about Mandelstam’s own notions of “personality” and the “creative ‘I.’ ” For Mandelstam’s “creative ‘I’ ” is also a created I. It is a conscious, carefully crafted construct; and what we trace in Stone’s progress is a scrupulously composed record of the making of this self. Chaadaev, Mandelstam writes, learned to “look upon himself as raw material [and] the results were astonishing”: “This idea organized not just his intellect, but his personality, and gave it a structure, an architecture” (CPL, 83). This architectural imagery is entirely apt in the context of Acmeist aesthetics. But the quote also provides us with a key to reading Stone as a cryptographic self-portrait of the artist as a young man. In “The Morning of Acmeism” (1913), Mandelstam gives us another oblique self-portrait, with a stone playing the part of the young poet: [Fedor] Tiutchev’s stone [from his poem Problème (1833)] which “had rolled down the mountain, and lay in the valley, having torn itself loose, or cast down by a sentient hand,” is the word. The voice of matter in this unexpected fall sounds like articulate speech. Only architecture can answer this challenge. Reverently the Acmeists raise this mysterious Tiutchevian stone and make it the foundation stone of their own building. It was as if the stone thirsted for another being. It itself discovered the dynamic potential hidden within it, as if it were begging admittance into the “groined arch” in order to participate in the joyous cooperative action of those like it. (CPL, 62)
We recognize key elements of Mandelstam’s master plot in this passage: the acquisition of speech and self, and finally, of a new society of like-minded kin and neighbors in the movement from unformed matter into art. The ambiguity in Tiutchev’s poem—did the stone tear itself loose or was it cast down by another force?—is resolved by Mandelstam in favor of the stone.7 The stone itself initiates its progress and decides the nature of its future incarnation. This stone is the raw material of unformed self on which Man-
34
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
delstam as craftsman sets to work in his eponymously titled collection, and which submits itself to progressive reshapings in successive editions as Mandelstam perfects the story of his origins in art.8
GRAVITY AND GRACE Consider the first invention of that creature who eventually would conceive of the word “Man.” I ask you to suppose that its first invention was its own muteness. Muteness is not something attributable to a rock or a stone, a tree or a beast. For anything to imagine its own muteness it would have to desire not to be mute, to desire already to be other than what it is, to become different and to make a difference. Suppose that the next invention was the sound that erased the muteness. —Richard Poirer, “Why Literature Can’t Save Us” (1987) Poetry begins with our awareness, not of a Fall, but that we are falling. The poet is our chosen man, and his consciousness of election becomes a curse; again, not “I am a fallen man,” but “I am Man, and I am falling.” —Harold Bloom, The Anxiety of Influence (1973)
Mandelstam tacitly conflates several beginnings in his parable of the fallen stone. His birth as a poet overlaps with the birth of the Acmeist movement from what he sees as the chaos of Symbolist poetics. The juxtaposition of a fall and new creation also echoes the paradigm of biblical beginnings that opens the Book of Genesis (Knigi bytiia, or the Books of Being, in Russian)—although in this case, new creation comes after, not before, the fall. A similar web of beginnings is at work in the poem that opens Stone’s later versions. This poem, “The sound, cautious and muted” (1908; #1) is both a literal and a symbolic point of departure for the young poet in search of a self; it marks Mandelstam’s recreation in verse of his first, fragmentary efforts to unleash his own voice. Zvuk ostoro'nyj i gluxoj Ploda, sorvavwegosq s dreva, Sredi nemolhnogo napeva Glubokoj tiwiny lesnoj . . . The sound, cautious and muted Of a fruit broken loose from the tree, Amidst the ceaseless melody Of deep forest silence . . .
This brief lyric, over almost before it has begun, is the first of a number of poems in the early part of Stone which take for their theme the process, uncertain and equivocal, of deriving a self from the sources of being. As Clarence Brown notes, the poem enacts what it describes; he cites Tsve-
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
35
9
taeva, who saw in its four lines an emblem of the fallen fruit itself. And like the single sound of the fruit which dies away in the forest’s stillness, the poem’s single stanza, which ends in ellipses, gives way to the silence of the surrounding page. The very idea of individuality becomes problematic, even ominous here as the single sound vanishes and the poem itself trails off into empty space. The struggle between sound and silence begins in the poem’s opening line. The crisp, stressed monosyllable zvuk that opens the poem is immediately qualified by the two modifiers that soften its blow and muffle its sound—but also render it human by making it “cautious” and hesitant. Or, more probably, it is produced cautiously, by an agent that is itself thus indirectly humanized. The fruit whose fall creates the sound comes to life, or half-life, by way of its modifier, the past active participle from the verb sovrat’sia, which can mean simply “to fall down” but which also signifies breaking loose, breaking free. It is the same verb that Tiutchev uses to describe the equally ambiguous fall of his mysterious stone; unlike the confident Acmeist of 1913, though, this Mandelstam is unwilling to endow his surrogate, fallen self with unequivocal life. “What sort of fruit is this Mandelstam? (Chto eto za frukt takoi etot Mandel’shtam?)” the poet asks ironically in “Fourth Prose” (1930; CPL, 323; II, 189), and the answer here would seem to be, “one that dares not fall too far from the tree.” The poem’s subject dwells on the edge of a “double being” (#22). It hesitates between volition, willed activity, and passive submission to the powers that be—in this case, to the powers that govern physical being, to the force of gravity. In a poem written about a year later and published only posthumously, Mandelstam writes: Mne stalo strawno 'izn; ot'it;ó I s dereva, kak list, otprqnut;, I nihego ne pol[bit;, I bezymqnnom kamnem kanut;. 1910 (#457t) I’ve become afraid of living life out— And pulling back, like a leaf from a tree, And that I’ll love nothing, And vanish like a nameless stone.
“I have bad relations with my family tree (V durnom rodstve/Ia so svoim rodoslovnym drevom),” Tsvetaeva announces in a poem of 1918; and in these poems, Mandelstam hints at a similar dilemma. One can see in the movement of the leaf or the fruit a fall from grace and a falling away from the family tree (rodoslovnoe derevo), from genealogy itself. In uprooting himself, the speaker is in danger of loosing what little identity he has, as the unnamed stone vanishes into a latter-day variant of Tiutchev’s “nameless abyss.”10
36
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
In a late poem, Mandelstam returns to the fall from grace that marks his poetic beginnings: “The disgraced verse has fallen, not knowing its father (Upal opal’nyi stikh, ne znaiushchii ottsa )” (1937; #357). The question of paternity is vexed and complex in the early lyric as well. This little poem, with its slavonicized tree (drevo) and its fallen, forbidden fruit (zapretnyi plod), hints at forbidden knowledge and violation of the Father’s will. There are suggestions of other paternal legacies at work in the poem as well. The very name that is Mandelstam’s paternal legacy evokes the notion of family tree: Mandelstam in German means “almond bough,” “almond tree,” and its root stam signifies not only “stem” or “tree,” but also “family,” “clan,” or “ancestry,” and even stammering, stammeln in German.11 In The Noise of Time, Mandelstam mourns a family heritage of tongue-tie; and he assigns this legacy specifically to his German Jewish father, who had, he insists, “absolutely no language” (POM, 90). The attempt to acquire a language would then be a betrayal of this peculiar family legacy, and one might see in the poem’s interrupted silence a first, failed attempt to move from tongue-tied birth to articulate speech. The particular kind of silence that the fallen fruit disturbs suggests another inheritance with which the young poet is struggling. This silence is not absolute. It is an oxymoronic stillness, a “ceaseless melody” of quiet. The fruit is an intruder here, like Tiutchev’s “thinking reed” whose rustling disrupts nature’s “common chorus.” Mandelstam’s native tongue-tie is compounded by his poetic legacy, the “mute musicality” or “plangent, sounding silence” (nemaia muzykal’nost’, zvonko-zvuchashchaia tishina) of his Symbolist forbears. The forest in which the fruit has fallen is also Baudelaire’s “forêt de symboles” in its Russian incarnation; and Mandelstam has already violated “the horror of the forest, the silent thunder scattered in the leaves” that is, according to Stéphane Mallarmé, the proper subject of poetry, through his own opposing sense of “the intrinsic dense wood of the trees.” The awkward drop of the all-too-solid fruit into the uncanny silent music of the woods suggests that the budding Acmeist is already ill at ease in the Symbolists’ “sacred Druidic grove” in which “nothing is real or genuine” (CPL, 128–29).12 The poem enacts Mandelstam’s dilemma in still another sense. The fruit falls in a wood that is both silent and full of song, and what lies behind this sounding silence is “both a poetic anxiety and a natural anxiety, a fear of being overcome by a babble of voices and by silence.”13 By opening Stone with this poem, Mandelstam dramatizes the introduction of his voice into a space both empty and full. The page around the poem is blank, the book is still unread, the poet’s own voice has not yet been heard: This empty space echoes, though, with the music of his poetic predecessors’ words, and his task is now to take this empty, echoing space and make it his own. Before Mandelstam could master anything, though, he had to find out what was his already, and to uncover or create the boundaries of his self in time and space. The first edition of Stone begins with a slightly later poem,
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
37
in which he has apparently made some progress toward the self-creation and artistic creation that elude him in “A sound, cautious and muted.” “I’ve been given a body” (1909; #8) takes up where “A sound, cautious and muted” leaves off, as it offers tentative answers to the questions the earlier lyric had left open. Dano mne teloóhto mne delat; s nim, Takim edinym i takim moim? Za radost; tixu[ dywat; i 'it;, Kogo, ska'ite, mne blagodarit;? Q i sadovnik, q 'e i cvetok, V temnice mira q ne odinok. Na stekla vehnosti u'e leglo Moe dyxanie, moe teplo. Zapehatleetsq na nem uzor, Neuznavaemyj s nedavnix por. Puskaj mgnoveniq stekaet mut;ó Uzora milogo ne zaherknut;. I’ve been given a body—what do I do with it, So single and so my own? For the quiet joy of breath and life, Tell me, whom should I thank? I am the gardener, I’m also the flower, I’m not alone in the world’s dungeon. My breathing, my warmth Already lies on eternity’s glass. The pattern that will be etched on it Is unrecognizable in recent times. Let the moments’ lees flow down— The dear pattern will not be crossed out.
“I’ve been given a body—what do I do with it?” The comical clumsiness of the diction mirrors the oddity of the question itself.14 In acknowledging both his connection to and his distance from his physical self, Mandelstam apparently takes up the awkward, lonely object of the earlier lyric and makes it his own. The poem never entirely answers the question that opens it, though; and the stanzas that follow show that the relationship between self as creator and self as raw material, and between these two and the outside world, is still far from settled. In his essay on Villon, Mandelstam praises his favorite’s awareness of
38
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
“the abyss between subject and object,” which Villon extends even to his relations with himself: “Villon’s attitude toward himself never exceeds certain limits of intimacy. He expresses no more tenderness, attentiveness, or concern for himself than a good lawyer would show his client” (CPL, 56). In “I’ve been given a body,” Mandelstam sets new terms for his association with his self; the poem’s subject, the self-as-artist, takes as its object the body it wishes to master. Gregory Freidin notes that Mandelstam, in refusing to “check [his] body at the gate” of the Symbolist poets’ club, was defying reigning taboos against the propriety of physical being in poetry.15 But Mandelstam is not simply flouting Symbolist conventions. By taking credit for his own being, he also neatly circumvents the whole uncomfortable issue of origins, whether personal or poetic. His body is a gift; no matter, then, from whom or whence it comes. No need, he seems to say, to look a gift horse in the mouth. The seed, born of unknown sources, has already been planted, and the poet, both gardener and flower, will cultivate and shape it on his own. “I am not alone,” he insists, “in the world’s dungeon.” Perhaps—but within the world of the poem itself his only companion is what he can bring forth by and from himself. The poem is populated solely by his consciousness, the body it nurtures, and the pattern that this body’s breath will leave on eternity’s glass. In this bell-jar universe, Mandelstam can breed only hothouse flowers. “I stand, dissatisfied and quiet,/The creator of my own worlds,” Mandelstam complains in another early lyric (#147). His attempt to resist his Symbolist precursors in “I’ve been given a body” likewise leaves him stranded in the midst of the Symbolist sollipsism he seeks to escape. His efforts at artistic self-assertion are equally unpersuasive. Not only the poet’s body is, he claims, uniquely his own in the poem. The pattern that will be his distinctive gift to posterity is also, he claims in yet another ungainly phrase, “unrecognizable in recent times (neuznavaemyi s nedavnikh por).” This pattern is cast into doubt not only by the passive form (“will be etched,” zapechatleetsia) that introduces it: what role precisely does the artist himself play in shaping this design? Its relationship to both past and future is also problematic. The design still remains to be etched; the poet postpones until an unspecified future the creation that will make his lasting mark on art. At the same time, he also struggles to carve out a space for himself and his art by resisting the immediate past, a past that cannot take credit for his being and does not acknowledge his writing. His work is “unrecognizable in recent times,” and the present passive particle allows him to evade the question of who precisely has failed to recognize his art. The phrase also implies that Mandelstam’s true precursors, those who would recognize his pattern, are to be found not among his immediate predecessors, but in a more distant time and place. As Mandelstam would soon come to see it, this leaves him free to bypass recent history and choose his friends himself from among those to whom he is bound by elective
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
39
affinity rather than by ties of blood and chronology. In the early poetry, though, where the young poet still seeks to keep “everything big” (#4) at bay in a safe and static cosmos, the imagining of such a past is troublesome at best. “Tell me, who might expertly combine/Tiutchev’s severity with Verlaine’s childishness,/Having given this fusion his own stamp?” Mandelstam asks in one early lyric (#498). The “unconstrained creative exchange” he envisions in this poem still lies far beyond his powers; he apparently fears that such mighty precursors, if invited whole and untamed into his work, will succeed only in “crossing out” the aesthetic pattern he labors to create. (“The dear pattern will not be crossed out,” he insists, perhaps too strenuously, in “I’ve been given a body.”) This would seem to be the unspoken message of Mandelstam’s first attempt to formulate his version of poetic tradition in verse, “There are chaste charms” (1909; #7). In this lyric Mandelstam attempts to set up housekeeping with domestic gods who appear to be his unnamed, self-selected poetic precursors. Est; celomudrennye haryó Vysokij lad, glubokij mir, Daleko ot /firnyx lir Mnoj ustanovlennye lary. U t]atel;no obmytyx niw V hasy vnimatel;nyx zakatov Q sluwa[ moix penatov Vsegda vostor'ennu[ tiw;. Kakoj igruwehnyj udel, Kakie robkie zakony Prikazyvaet tors tohenyj I xolod /tix xrupkix tel! Inyx bogov ne nado slavit;% Oni kak ravnye s toboj, I ostoro'no[ rukoj, Pozvoleno ix perestavit;. There are chaste charms— High harmony, deep peace, The Lares arranged by me Are distant from ethereal lyres. By their well-washed niches At the times of attentive sunsets I listen to my Penates’ Always rapturous stillness.
40
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
What a toy-like lot, What timid laws Are laid down by a molded torso And the cold of these brittle bodies! No need to praise other gods; These are like your equals, And one may rearrange them With a cautious hand.
Victor Terras speculates that the poem may have been inspired by Pushkin’s unfinished translation of Southey’s “Hymn to the Penates” (1796); and this would be in keeping both with the spirit of the poem and the vision of tradition that Mandelstam would soon articulate more fully and forcefully.16 The ancient Roman custom of household gods, Penates, is brought home by a relatively recent Russian writer; and a foreign voice is domesticated by a local poet in the process. Both Pushkin and the recipient of his Penates, Mandelstam himself, thus participate in the mission of the true poet, which is to invite the literary “giants” of other times and places to “pull up their stakes and come be our guests” (“On the Nature of the Word,” CPL, 131). The legacy that Mandelstam attempts to master here is apparently too much for him, though. The literary home he presides over shelters not lively, adventurous giants, but cold and brittle figurines moved only by the poet’s “cautious hand.” He claims to be on equal footing with his gods: “These are like your equals,” he exclaims. Their relationship, though, is more like a one-man game of chess than the easy give-andtake of true equality, the fraternal union of world poetry that Mandelstam envisions elsewhere in his writing. He himself mocks his “toy-like lot” and the “timid laws” that adhere in his “little kingdom” (#9). Its virtues are “high harmony, deep peace”; its code enforces caution, quiet, and retreat. If the young poet has mastered the past and made peers of its gods, he has done so only by reducing them to his own size, by making them less than whole (one is a mere “molded torso”) and less than real. Most strikingly, Mandelstam’s household gods are silent. “The bare walls” of his house are adorned only with “the masks of other men’s voices” (POM, 127); and his Lares’ “rapturous stillness” returns us to the “ceaseless melody” of silence with which Stone begins. In the early poems, poetry is rooted in an impersonal, primordial stillness, an endless quiet that cannot be reconciled with individual, specific, and temporally bounded speech. This paradoxically makes the work of the individual poet virtually impossible, in theory if not in practice, for in articulating his own vision, he withdraws from the boundless silence that is the source of that vision. In the early “poetry of stasis,” Mandelstam circumvents this dilemma by drawing his imagery of art exclusively from the visual and plastic arts: etching, sculpture, textiles, enamel, ceramics.17 He creates within
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
41
these poems an image of an art not spoken, but shaped; of an art that is a fixed and lasting artifact. This strategy gives birth to the airtight, lifeless world of these verses—but it also preserves Mandelstam from the full and troubling implications of being a writer endangered by speech. “In art there are no ready-made things,” Mandelstam proclaims in “Conversation about Dante” (1933; CPL, 415). The young poet deals almost exclusively, though, in what critics called “natures mortes,” “still lives” or literally, “dead natures.”18 He has not yet mastered the energy that will enable him to endow the artifacts of later poems with the dynamic, open-ended being that eludes him here. In his essay on Villon, Mandelstam praises in his precursor precisely what he misses in his own work. Villon may have lacked “traditional bonds with the past”; he is filled nonetheless with a “tremendous dynamic ability” and with a passion for “life’s powerful rhythm.” This Villon would have had no difficulty in converting Symbolist music to new uses. He would have adapted, so Mandelstam claims, Verlaine’s famous motto to read, “Du mouvement avant toute chose!” (CPL, 57–58) The Mandelstam of the early poems can master neither movement nor music, and his words return him repeatedly to the possibility, both ominous and attractive, of utter speechlessness. Muteness and tongue-tie are central themes of the early verse, as Clarence Brown observes, and he adds that “Silentium” would have been a fitting title for Stone’s first edition.19 And Mandelstam indeed calls on a favorite precursor, Fedor Tiutchev (1803–73) and his famous “Silentium” (1830), as he struggles to formulate his own response to his legacy, both poetic and personal, of tongue-tie and speechlessness. In “Silentium,” Tiutchev commands his fellow poets to retreat into the uncorrupted, authentic realm of a self untainted by speech’s inevitable distortions—“To live inside your self alone is wiser,/A whole world dwells within your soul”—and a generation of Symbolists was relentless in its celebrations of Tiutchevian silence.20 In a number of early poems, including his own “Silentium” (1910; #14), Mandelstam exceeds both Tiutchev and his own Symbolist precursors. For the young Mandelstam, the notion of self is as disturbing and troublesome as the idea of speech, and his solution in these poems is retreat from both self and speech into the mute and boundless unity of “pre-being.”21 In a discussion of poetic origins, Harold Bloom notes that “poets tend to incarnate by the side of the ocean, at least in vision, if inland far they be,” and the sea that is their source is made up chiefly of their own precursors’ words: “Ocean, the matter of Night . . . mothers what is antithetical to her, the makers who fear (rightly) to accept her and never cease to move toward her. If not to have conceived oneself is a burden, so for the strong poet there is also the more hidden burden: not to have brought oneself forth . . . but to be awash in the Word not quite one’s own.”22 The sea change that Mandelstam proposes in “Silentium” is more radical even than the transformations he envisions in other early lyrics. In “Why is the soul so
42
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
songful” (1911; #25), forgetting a “useless I” signals the poet’s final defeat. In “Silentium” it is the consummation devoutly to be wished. The poet does not mourn a vanished self and an uncreated world. He yearns to return both self and world to a state that precedes all creation. And unlike the soul-turned-dolphin of “There’s nothing to talk about” (1909; #11), the poet of “Silentium” desires not to be reborn, but to bypass birth entirely; he longs to be made one with the unformed source of all being. Yet even in the poem in which he foresees his final undoing, Mandelstam leaves loopholes, opportunities for poetic rebirth from the speechless seas made up of the silence extolled by his Symbolist forebears and by their own poetic parent, Tiutchev.23 SILENTIUM
Ona e]e ne rodilas;, Ona i muzyka i slovo, I potomu vsego 'ivogo Nenaruwaemaq svqz;. Spokojno dywat morq grudi, No, kak bezumnyj, svetel den;, I peny blednaq siren; V mutno-lazorevom sosude. Da obretut moi usta Pervonahal;nu[ nemotu, Kak kristallihesku[ notu, Hto ot ro'deniq hista! Ostan;sq penoj, Afrodita, I slovo v muzyku vernis;, I serdce serdca ustydis;, S pervoosnovoj 'izni slito! She has not yet been born, She is both music and the word, And thus the inviolable bond Of everything that lives. The sea’s breasts breathe peacefully, But the day shines like a madman, And the foam’s pale lilac Lies in a basin of muted blue. May my lips acquire this Primeval muteness, Like a crystal note Pure from birth.
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
43
Remain foam, Aphrodite, And word, return to music, And heart, be ashamed of heart, When fused with life’s foundation!
The poem’s unborn Aphrodite, herself both “music and the word,” holds out the promise that the fallen fruit can return to the tree, to which it will now be tied by an “inviolable bond.” Through Aphrodite the poet seeks to reunite the lonely, speaking subject of the early poems with the mute music that is his source: “May my lips acquire this/Primeval muteness.” And through the force of his own speech, he seeks to undo speech as such: “Word, return to music.” The name he invokes, though, indicates that his desires go far beyond his own dissolution. Clarence Brown notes that “the poet invites the ordered world to collapse [into] a condition of infinite rawness, of chaos,” the chaos from which, according to legend, Aphrodite herself was born. In commanding the goddess of beauty to remain unformed, mere foam, Mandelstam seeks to erase not only his own birth but the very principle of generation as such; for Aphrodite is “the irrestistable force impelling procreation and production, who ‘strikes fond love into the hearts of all, and makes them in hot desire to renew the stock of their race.’ ” She inspires not only procreation but artistic creation. “Both the sea and Homer—all is moved by love,” another early lyric declares, and this “love” could be interpreted literally as Aphrodite who, in giving Helen to Paris, began the war that prompted Homer’s epic (#78). Mandelstam thus undoes the earliest source of the Western literary tradition, and with it his own poetic precursors, both near (Tiutchev, the Symbolists) and far (Homer himself). Mandelstam’s own cry for silence, he tacitly boasts, far outdoes the more qualified summons to speechlessness articulated by Tiutchev and his Symbolist followers. His muteness, unlike theirs, is absolute and abolishes not only word and world but the very notion of self.24 Mandelstam’s annihilation of self is, however, predictably ambiguous and tricky; he mythologizes his birth in the process of undoing it. In Aphrodite’s parentless birth he locates a model for his own self-origination, and he finds in Aphrodite herself an adoptive mother and muse whom he can follow into oblivion. Moreover, Aphrodite is herself “the eternal and alldominating female through whom resurrection and new life may be attained,”25 and the poem hints that her canceled birth, and thus the poet’s own, may be followed by some form of rebirth. The “primeval muteness” he seeks is “like a crystal note/ Pure from birth”; this silence, in other words, will take on shape and sound in a single, separate form made of a substance that symbolizes permanence as well as purity, that can be both water and wrought stone. The simile thus clears a space for individual creation in a poem that celebrates the unmaking of all creation. It allows for
44
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
birth as well. In the same stanza in which the poet wishes himself back into Aphrodite’s inchoate state, the crystal note, “pure from birth,” is born from muteness; and the language itself calls to mind Mandelstam’s own efforts to escape from a family “tongue-tied from birth (ot rozhdeniia)” (POM, 123; II, 99). In “Silentium” Mandelstam does not simply undo and outdo his poetic precursors; he continues to revise his tongue-tied heritage by imaginatively staging an immaculate rebirth from inherited speechlessness. Two poems written in the same year as “Silentium,” “From an evil, miry pond” (1910; #17) and “In the vast pond it’s transparent and dark” (1910; #18), reveal the dark undercurrents that lie just beneath the surface of “Silentium” ’s pristine waters. These poems restage the ambiguous tale told in “Silentium,” as the poet yearns both to emerge from and return to “being’s sources,” to the waters that both nourish and destroy. And all three lyrics are, in turn, small-scale retellings of the Mandelstamian master plot that traces the painful emergence of self and speech from primal chaos. In the pond poems, though, Mandelstam decides to muddy the waters, as he revises once again his mythopoetic account of his personal and poetic origins. The ambiguities that lie concealed beneath the apparently transparent surfaces of the earlier lyrics become the very stuff of which this pair of poems is made, as Mandelstam traces his vacillating responses to a pond that is vast and confining, transparent and dark. Iz omuta zlogo i vqzkogo Q vyros, trostinkoj wurwa, I strastno, i tomno, i laskovo Zapretno[ 'izn;[ dywa. I niknu, nikem ne zamehannyj, V xolodnyj i topkij pri[t, Privetstvennym welestom vstrehennyj Korotkix osennix minut. Q shastliv 'estokoj obido[ I v 'izni, poxo'ej na son, Q ka'domu tajno zavidu[ I v ka'dogo tajno vl[blen. From an evil, miry pond I grew up, rustling like a reed, Passionately, languidly, and tenderly Breathing forbidden life. And noticed by no one, I droop, Into the cold and boggy refuge, Greeted by the friendly rustle Of autumn’s fleeting moments.
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
45
I am happy for this harsh insult. And in a life like a dream, I envy everyone secretly And am secretly in love with everyone.
V ogromnom omute prozrahno i temno, I tomnoe okno beleet A serdceóothego tak medlenno ono I tak uporno tq'eleet? To vse[ tq'est;[ ono idet ko dnu, Soskuhivwis; po milom ile, To, kak solominka, minuq glubinu, Naverx vsplyvaet bez usilij. S pritvornoj ne'nost;[ u izgolov;q stoj I sam sebq vs[ 'izn; ba[kaj, Kak nebylice[, svoej tomis; toskoj I laskov bud; s nadmennoj skukoj. In the vast pond it’s transparent and dark, And a languid window shows white; But the heart—why does it so slowly And stubbornly grow heavy? First it sinks with all its weight, Grown homesick for the dear silt, Then, like a straw, it bypasses the depths And effortlessly rises to the top. Stand by the bedside with pretended tenderness And sing yourself lullabies all life long, Yearn with your make-believe longing And be gentle with haughty ennui.
Kiril Taranovsky and Omry Ronen have argued for this pond as an early incarnation of the “Judaic chaos” that Mandelstam seeks to escape in The Noise of Time (POM, 88); and indeed the same ambivalence that marks his response to his family past in the autobiography also shapes the movement of these poems.26 But the topoi that govern these lyrics would already be familiar to the reader of Stone, at least in its final, and fullest, incarnation.27 Stone begins with a fall that hints at violations of taboos, and a new, forbidden life. The fallen fruit’s motion is reversed in these lyrics; rising, not falling, constitutes the poet’s transgression, his abandonment of dear and dangerous roots. Indeed, his successive incarnations as a reed and then a straw seem designed to illustrate both the dangers and the possibilities of rootlessness. Mandelstam’s reversal of his first fall indicates how difficult it is for him, or any poet for that matter, to break free and discover a wholly new
46
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
point of departure; and what obstructs him here is the ambivalence that takes the shape of an apparently endless series of rises and returns. The poems themselves embody opposing, apparently irreconcilable forces. The first revolves around the centrifugal powers of a seductive and forbidden outside world, while the second centers on the centripetal pull that emanates from the pond itself. “From an evil, miry pond” begins unequivocally enough: the pond is wholly evil, and the poet is wholly free of it. He is literally a “grown-up,” vzroslyi, a reed that has completely emerged from its sources.28 He possesses at last a fully independent “I”: “I grew up” (Ja vyros; my italics). This reed-self is itself highly derivative, though. It is descended from the “thinking reed” that Tiutchev had borrowed in turn from Blaise Pascal, and its “grumbling” speech, Tiutchev warns us, serves only to sever it from nature’s “common chorus.”29 Speech is a dangerous force in Mandelstam’s early verse as well. The self of this lyric, though, is troubled more by its body than its voice. It is drawn from its native element by sensual love; it yearns for a forbidden world “passionately, languidly and tenderly.” The poet’s body, “so single, so my own” is intimately linked to Mandelstam’s vision of poetic creation from the start, and this singular, physical self will prove to be the building block on which he shapes first an Acmeist “biological” poetics (CPL, 132) and finally world culture itself; in “Conversation about Dante,” Mandelstam celebrates the “youthful, animal appetite,” the “sensual lust after rhyme” that inspired the Divine Comedy (CPL, 399). And the “sensual lust” that impels the young poet of “From an evil, miry pond” does literally inspire him. It moves him to “breath forbidden life,” and breathing can be as in “I’ve been given a body,” the first step toward the shaping of new art. 30 It is precisely for this reason that the body and its impulses are dangerous to the poem’s would-be grown-up; they draw him from his element. Perhaps this is why the Mandelstam of “Silentium” commands his Aphrodite to remain unborn; in this way he can keep the love that moves all things from propelling him into an illicit, forbidding new life. And in the second stanza of “From an evil, miry pond,” the poet shrinks from this forbidden air: “And, noticed by no one, I droop,/Into the cold and boggy refuge.” The phrase “noticed by no one” carries a double weight and pulls in two directions at once. The reed, like the earlier pattern shaped by the poet’s breath, remains unrecognized by the world outside his “little kingdom” (#9). His love for the outside world—be it the Russian world, the world of poetry, or the forbidden world of gentile culture generally—is unrequited and so he withdraws it. The phrase also evokes the furtiveness of a child who tastes forbidden fruits and hides before his trespass can be discovered. It suggests that the poet himself still abides by the taboos of his cheerless home, which deny him the other life he longs for but also shield him from its threat. Even acoustically this line suggests that the vaunted, grown-up self of the opening stanza is on the verge of dissolution. Variants of the negative
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
47
particles ne and ni echo throughout the line: “I niknu, nikem nezamechannyi.” This sound patterning, with its persistent ns, ks and is, returns us to the opening stanza’s hapless self-as-reed, trostinkoi, and reminds us that at its heart lies the very antithesis of self, nikto, no one. Born of mud, the poet cannot or will not complete the breath that would make him whole and human, like a perverse Adam who clings to the familiar earth and refuses the gift of life. The rest of the poem is colored by an acute, clear-sighted ambivalence. The pond is no more attractive than before—it is cold and marshy—and yet it offers refuge from a world that the poet fears will not have him. Safely back in his subterranean home, this latter-day underground man is defined and paralyzed by his irreconcilable polarities of feeling. He is suspended between envy and love for the unseen other to whom he is drawn, and his ambivalence traps him in an “uncreated world” (#25) that is a nightmare inversion of the pure and boundless potentiality Mandelstam invokes in “Silentium.” “Heart, be ashamed of heart,” Mandelstam admonishes his nascent self in “Silentium”; and the heart he addresses in that poem is, like the body of the “evil pond,” the force that propels him toward individual identity and away from fusion with life’s sources. The heart that takes the place of the poet’s self in “In the vast pond” symbolizes, though, a very different kind of impulse. Its function is not just metonymical; it is also a realized metaphor, a “heavy heart,” a “sinking heart,” or even a sui generis “heart of stone.” Such combinations are not uncommon in Russian. The idiom “a stone on the heart” is equivalent to our “heavy-hearted”; and Mandelstam himself speaks of a “heart dead as a stone” in a humorous poem of 1921 (#459). The English adage that the poem illustrates best, though, is perhaps “home is where the heart is”; the entire poem works to demonstrate that the pond’s hold on the poet is not wholly negative. This pool’s darkness is also a source of light; it is transparent, and in it a “languid window shows white.” But the poet’s heart chooses not to take this escape route into a longed-for other world (and the “languid window” echoes the “languid” yearnings that had pulled him earlier toward forbidden life). “Why does the heart so stubbornly grow heavy?” Mandelstam asks, and the second stanza suggests both what the heart gains in remaining at home and what it loses by leaving. “There is joy in heaviness/And in falling there is vacillating sweetness,” Mandelstam confesses in another early lyric (#508); and this poem’s heart is clearly drawn to the pool’s depths not by gravity or fear alone. Whenever it ventures to the water’s surface, it misses the “dear silt” that is its source and that pulls it homeward once more. A later poem makes relatives of “heaviness and tenderness”: “Sisters—heaviness and tenderness—your features are the same” (1920; #108). In “In the vast pond,” the poet’s tenderness for his sources serves, at least potentially, as the “specific gravity” that unites all beings in “The Morning of Acmeism” (1913; CPL, 63). Part of the burden of being, the poem suggests, lies in accepting
48
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
the self you were born with, in establishing relations with this self that are, like Villon’s, guarded but “tender (nezhen)” (CPL, 56; II, 305). “The power to love and to recognize is given,” another poem warns, “to mortals” alone, that is, to those who embrace the burden of human being (#113). The stanza’s closing lines hint at the cost of failing to take up this burden, of abandoning the “dear silt” for the surface: “Then, like a straw, it bypasses the depths,/And effortlessly rises to the top.” This straw might be the earlier poem’s reed torn from its roots; weightless and lifeless, it cannot govern its own movements. The heart that, like a stone, is pinioned to the pond’s bottom by its own weight, is in danger of becoming mere lifeless matter; but the heart that is utterly unattached is condemned by its very weightlessness to yet another kind of death-in-life. In “Sisters—heaviness and tenderness,” Mandelstam unites air and water in the vessel of his own body: “I drink the troubled air like dark water.” He also finds a pattern that unites the rhythms of rising and falling that oppose each other in the pond poems. He finds in the rose that grows from and returns to earth an emblem of the “eternal recurrence” that signifies, in its distinctively Mandelstamian variant, the poet’s capacity to remember and remake both his own and human history. He can thus lift the “burden of time,” which is also the gravity of human being, with its double knot of tenderness and weight.31 Ambivalence, warring forces, shifting energies held in check by the poet’s body writ large—these are the essence of the culture that Mandelstam the Acmeist will build on the self he has been given. The poet of “In the vast pond” has yet to master the shifting rhythms of his ungovernable heart, though. He can neither reconcile them nor choose between them, and this ambivalence once again fixes him in a netherworld, neither here nor there. In the poem’s final stanza, he condemns himself to a travesty version of the “enchanting duet” Villon sings with himself as both “mother and child” (CPL, 56): “Stand by the bedside with pretended tenderness/ And sing yourself lullabies all life long.” The poem ends on the same note of helpless self-consciousness that concludes “From an evil, miry pond.” The poet is trapped in a half-life, but he cannot or will not choose between worlds. His paralyzing self-awareness goes even further than it had in the earlier poem. In the final stanza he apparently addresses the observer self who contemplates the rise and fall of its own heart. This self, in turn, lulls what seems to be another, newborn self (“And sing yourself lullabies”) in a life “like a dream.” Even grammatically, the personal pronoun that should stand for the poet’s self is suggested only by surrogates, by forms that refer back to an implied but absent subject: sam, sebia, svoei. Mandelstam thus condemns the myth of self-generation he had earlier embraced; here it leads only to an endlessly reflexive, artificial state, in which self, born of self, has only itself to address. In “From an evil, miry pond,” Mandelstam defines the forbidden life he desires but is denied only in terms of his longing for it. A poem of the
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
49
following year, “The cloudy air is damp and resonant” (1911; #22), hints at the nature of the other life whose insults he both courts and flees: I opqt; k ravnoduwnoj othizne Dikoj utkoj vzov;etsq uprekó Q uhastvu[ v sumrahnoj 'izni I nevinen, hto q odinok! And once again to an unfeeling fatherland A reproach soars up like a wild duck— I take part in a twilight life And I’m not to blame that I’m alone!
Mandelstam’s defiance here, as the rest of the poem reveals, is fleeting and unsuccessful, but suggestive. The young poet clearly yearns to be adopted by the “unfeeling fatherland” that spurns him. He longs to exchange his lonely “twilight life” for the right to take part in another kind of life, one totally unlike the half-lit, uncertain existence that “stuns” him with its “reflected double being.” The “light cross” that the poet bears elsewhere in the lyric suggests one route that Mandelstam will take as he works his way into his adopted fatherland and thence into Western, Christian culture. In the grandest and most ambitious variant of his master plot, he will conflate his own emergence from “Judaic chaos” into Western culture with the emergence of Christianity itself from its Jewish roots, the emergence that marked, as he sees it, the beginnings of true European culture (CPL, 92). In the early poems of Stone, though, both fall and redemption are played out in tentative, almost parodic form: the fall is “cautious,” and the cross is “light.” This fall and resurrection, moreover, lack a public. They go unnoticed by the fatherland for whom they are performed, and are instead staged and restaged by a lonely poet who plays all parts, including that of audience. “We do not wish to amuse ourselves with a stroll through a ‘forest of symbols,’ ” Mandelstam proclaims in “The Morning of Acmeism,” and he already confidently speaks both for himself and for “those like him” (1913; CPL, 63). The poet of 1911 had yet to emerge from the forest that is both his personal and his poetic inheritance. He is still in the process of uncovering the poetic strategies that would give him access to his coveted fatherland and longed-for fraternity of world culture.
LIMITLESS FISSION The moment comes in the life of every person when, as a child, he suddenly says: “The table—and I,” “The cat—and I,” “The ball— and I,” then, as an adult: “The world—and I.” —Mikhail Kuzmin, “On Beautiful Clarity” (1910)
50
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
The way in which I create myself is by means of a quest: I go out to the other in order to come back with a self. —Katerina Clark and Michael Holquist, Mikhail Bakhtin (1984) Item nothing to the Foundlings It’s the lostlings that I have to help. —François Villon, Grand Testament (1461)
Modernism, Edward Said observes, “was a response to the crisis of what could be called filiation—linear, biologically grounded process, that which ties children to their parents—which produced the counter-crisis within modernism of affiliation, that is, those creeds, philosophies and visions reassembling the world in new non-familial ways.” One might borrow Said’s terms to describe the dilemma Mandelstam faces in the early verse: the young poet has not yet learned to convert what he has inherited through filiation into a source for the modernist affiliations he desires. I use the term “young poet” here advisedly, for these remarks demand to be qualified: Mandelstam the novice poet remains baffled by problems that Mandelstam the budding essayist has already tackled and largely resolved. In his prose of the twenties, Nadezhda Mandelstam observes, Mandelstam was “defining his place in life”; this place, once found, permitted him to recover and redefine his poet’s voice. Her observation holds for the early prose as well. The young poet still wanders through the unpeopled landscapes of his early lyrics while the essayist is busy mapping out the means by which he can enter the society that surrounds him, inherit its history, and shape from his new-found present and past a poetic community that defies the bounds of space and time.32 “The first literary meeting is irreparable,” Mandelstam warns in The Noise of Time (POM, 127). Mandelstam himself was fortunate in the literary meeting he commemorates in his earliest essay, “François Villon” (1910). He could scarcely have made a better choice of precursors than “the incomparable Villon, François,” whom he celebrates in a late poem— his work is virtually framed by tributes to the French poet—and in whom he finds a “contemporary,” a “friend,” and “favorite relation” (CPL, 58, 222; #382). A great deal depends on such friendships for a young poet in search of a viable self and a usable past. The right literary friendship, T. S. Eliot explains, turns “a bundle of second-hand sentiments” not just “into a person,” but into a person possessed of a genuine past: “It gives us an introduction to the society in which our friend moves . . . we have been quickened, and we become bearers of a tradition.”33 He might be summarizing the lessons Mandelstam learns and the gifts he receives at the hands of the “thief and poet” François Villon (CPL, 57). Jane Gary Harris suggests that “François Villon,” rooted far more deeply than later essays in biographical and historical fact, may derive from Mandelstam’s student days at Heidelberg.34 Certainly the essay demonstrates a thorough familiar-
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
51
ity with the particulars of Villon’s life and writings—but the student abroad may also be seeking a new way home through Villon. In giving shape to the late-medieval writer’s life and times, Mandelstam is apparently trying to find a paradigm or program for his own self-creation. That Mandelstam leaves his own life and writing scrupulously out of the picture should not surprise us by now—but we should also not be surprised to find elements of his biographical master plot at work in “François Villon.” What “François Villon” gives us in fact is the first full-fledged version of Mandelstam’s inventively reshaped autobiography: An outcast, cursed with an unlikely past, both personal and poetic, turns this curse into a blessing as he takes on a turbulent age by way of his linguistic gifts. This, Mandelstam implicitly tells us, is exactly how a poet’s remade biography ought to read. At the outset of his essay, Mandelstam speaks of the miraculous convergence of “voice timbre and biography” that makes Villon the unwitting twin of his distant literary descendant and fellow poète maudit Paul Verlaine (1844–96) (CPL, 53). Mandelstam points here to the procedures he will use to make Villon his own double and brother, as the biographical outlines of one self-made poet converge with those of another across the centuries. And Mandelstam proceeds to read his own plight backward into his precursors’ pasts. Both Villon and Verlaine, Mandelstam claims, did battle with various forms of Symbolism avant la lettre: “Each poet was fated to emerge in an epoch of artificial, hothouse poetry; thus just as Verlaine destroyed the serres chaudes [hothouses] of Symbolism, so Villon rejected the call of the reigning rhetorical school that might be properly considered the Symbolism of the fifteenth century” (CPL, 53). Mandelstam’s reading of French literary history is idiosyncratic, to say the least. Verlaine’s work is usually taken to mark the beginnings of Symbolism, not its end; and Villon’s life and work were embraced as models by Romantics and Symbolists alike, who saw in him the prototype for their own version of the poet-outcast as “demonic” criminal. Mandelstam thus trumps his Russian poetic parents by stripping them of their own adoptive forefathers.35 This is not, however, Mandelstam’s chief goal in creating parallels between his precursors’ fate and his own, as other early essays demonstrate. The André Chénier of his “Remarks on Chénier” (1914) is engaged in a struggle with reigning poetic norms that recall Mandelstam’s battles with his Symbolist legacy in the early verse, as his Chénier flees the “empty, transparent ponds (omuty)” of neoclassical poetics in search of “the living water of poetry” (CPL, 75–76; II, 293). The Chaadaev of “Petr Chaadaev” (1915) does not do battle with some form of proto-Symbolism; he does, however, forge his “personality” through his efforts to reconcile the chaos he inherits from a historyless Russia with a Europe “petrified” by its excess of tradition (CPL, 83–89). Villon’s Middle Ages are preoccupied with a similar struggle. For medieval society, Mandelstam claims in “The Morning of Acmeism” (1913), “completely unadorned personal existence” was “valued as a heroic feat,” which bound all people in the “com-
52
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
plicity of those who exist in a conspiracy against emptiness and nonbeing” (CPL, 64). In his essays Mandelstam uncovers his comrades-in-arms through a shared battle for being against the two demons, fixed and lifeless forms versus vital chaos, that haunt the early verse. He selects his own society from among those for whom existence is not given but achieved. What Mandelstam effects through this dispersion of his biography is a new kind of existence, existence as the “event” of “shared being (sobytie bytiia)” in Mikhail Bakhtin’s evocative pun.36 These remarks may suggest that invention far outweighs remembrance in Mandelstam’s early essays, that his portraits of the past serve the needs of the uprooted modernist far better than they do historical accuracy. Certainly Villon’s “obscure biography” (CPL, 56) lends itself to the inventive revision Mandelstam recommends for the gaps in Petr Chaadaev’s life and writings: “Let us attempt to develop [Chaadaev’s] Philosophical Letters as if they were a negative photographic plate” (CPL, 56, 86). The Villon of Mandelstam’s essay, moreover, invites just such imaginative mishandling; he himself abandons all moral scruples in quest of the experience that will feed both his personal and his poetic needs. Villon himself, as Mandelstam presents him, appears to grant his latter-day interlocutor license to ransack the past and to use or abuse its contents as he sees fit. Such wholesale reinvention of the past would defeat Mandelstam’s own poetic purposes, though; it would leave him stranded in a fancy-dress version of the Symbolist sollipsism he seeks to escape in the early verse. Mandelstam’s choice of Villon as the unlikely patriarch of his literary family tree testifies not only to the soundness of the historical sense that leads him throughout his work to precisely that source which will best serve his poetic ends. It also demonstrates the ways in which he manages time and again to tie himself to a larger modernist community by way of his personal quest for a new tradition. Villon was among the poetic grandfathers, or rather great-great-grandfathers, that rebellious modernist children were quick to claim as their own. He became the patron saint of a European avant-garde in search of past poetic rebels whom they could use as models for their calculatedly outrageous behavior in art and life. One such rebel, Guillaume Apollinaire, was the author of a “Futurist Anti-Tradition” (1913) as scandalous as any Russian Futurist’s assault on public taste; he nonetheless acknowledges Villon as the greatest of his own masters taken from “far in the past.” More to the point, perhaps, Villon was a favorite of both Eliot and Pound, who return to him repeatedly in their poetry and prose; and Pound in particular was drawn to Villon for reasons that are close to Mandelstam’s own.37 Pound, like Mandelstam, was a student of early French literature, and his essay on Villon, in The Spirit of Romance, also dates from 1910. In another early essay, Pound announces his new-found “world citizenship” and demands his rights as a self-proclaimed “heir of the ages.” Chief among these rights is the privilege of discarding unwanted American poetic precursors
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
53
in favor of “more congenial ancestry—Dante, Shakespeare, Theocritus, Villon.” The very title of Pound’s essay on Villon suggests one element of the medieval poet’s modern appeal: it is “Montcorbier, alias Villon” (italics in original). Mandelstam’s summary of Villon’s biography adds yet another name to this dual christening; he speaks of one “François de Montcorbier (or François des Loges)” who only gradually became the François Villon who signs his name to the Petit and Grand Testaments (CPL, 54). Both Pound and Mandelstam stress the necessary self-creation that went into the making of the François Villon whose heritage they claim.38 The names that Pound and Mandelstam cite are historically accurate; Villon presumably took the names of Montcorbier and des Loges from his parents, of whom nothing is known, only to discard them in favor of the name of the priest who later adopted him, Guillaume de Villon. More importantly, though, both Pound and Mandelstam point in their writings on Villon to what proved to be his most important legacy to later French poetry. What is distinctive in Villon’s work is his ability to negotiate between the self he was given by history and nature, the self he creates in his writing, and the larger social world these selves inhabit; and he achieves this through creation of a capacious, innovative “poetic ‘I.’ ” “Villon’s poetic ‘I’ ” Nancy Freeman Regalado explains, “is dramatically plunged into a world of historical time, space, and identity,” and he thus manages to take the whole “world of experience into his poetry”; “he fused lyric feeling and expression of lived experience within the lyric itself by characterizing his poetic ‘I’ fully in terms of historical experience and naming it ‘Villon.’ ” Hugh Kenner observes that all Pound’s early lyrics pose one implicit, unresolved question: “Who am I?” Small wonder, then, that a dispossessed modernist, anxious to ground a newly shaped self in a history likewise reconceived, should take for his model “one François Villon, ballad-lord and thief.”39 “I intend to cut off no one/In this present dispensation,” Villon writes in his Grand Testament. “But don’t let word of this leak out/Beyond the borders of France.” The very form his greatest works take, though, invites creative appropriation by foreigners and natives, “lostlings” and “foundlings” alike. As their names suggest, the Petit and Grand Testaments (1456, 1461) are designed as his ironic legacy to the ages, in which the impoverished outlaw’s possessions are “put up for grabs.” The value of such a legacy may seem dubious—the would-be testator owns only a handful of change, as he himself admits—but what Villon offers the dispossessed modernist in search of self and history is far more valuable than such inventories suggest. Villon’s biography and writings are object lessons in acquiring through language what one wants and lacks in life. His Grand Testament, his “monument for the ages,” is an ironic testimonial to his skill in poetry and thievery alike. It is a litany of stolen goods received and bequeathed through language. “As a poet,” Mandelstam writes, he “ironi-
54
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
cally assert[ed] his mastery over all those things he would like to own”: “A pitiful vagabond, he attained for himself unattainable goods aided only by his sharp irony” (CPL, 56–58). Such procedures would undoubtably appeal to modern poets convinced that their only route to tradition was to beg, borrow, or steal the history they required from unwitting poetic precursors. “I await an inheritance and am no one’s heir,” Villon announces in one of his Ballades; he might be speaking for either of his self-proclaimed descendants.40 The Villons of Pound’s and Mandelstam’s essays share a great deal, and their similarities—specificity, concreteness, a commitment to this world and to its speech—point to the congruences that would emerge between Acmeism and its Anglo-American cousin, the Imagist movement that developed under Pound’s direction. Mandelstam’s essay, however, is far more concerned than Pound’s with the specifics of Villon’s self and life as revealed in his art, as Mandelstam works to answer questions left open by the early verse. Let us turn, now, in more detail to the implicit self-portrait of the artist that lies hidden behind Mandelstam’s depiction of his adopted kinsman, François Villon. “There is absolutely no basis for ascribing to [the poet] characteristics of spontaneous generation (samorozhdeniia),” Mandelstam declares in “On the Interlocutor” (1913; CPL, 73; II, 240); and his Villon is carefully rooted in the time and place that gave him birth. Like his biographer, this Villon is the product of an age in transition. “The last born child of the Middle Ages” (CPL, 59) was born into a France that was itself in the process of being reborn as the Renaissance, a France that had been, moreover, impoverished and disrupted by English rule. “From childhood on I’ve been poor/Of poor and obscure origins,” Villon laments in the Grand Testament.41 Mandelstam’s essay makes clear that such poverty may actually be a blessing in disguise. From birth Villon is bound to his city and nation precisely by their common wants: “The indigence that surrounded [Villon’s] cradle matched the nation’s misfortune and, in particular, the misfortune of the capital,” Mandelstam observes (CPL, 54). In an inversion of the fairy-tale formula, misfortune becomes for the impoverished outcast a kind of unlikely fairy godmother, who presents him in his cradle with the neediness that reveals his true genealogy. “How well I know,” Villon admits in his Testaments, “that I am not the son of an angel”; and Mandelstam, the reluctant heir of otherworldly Symbolists, quotes his remarks approvingly (CPL, 60). Villon’s acceptance both of what he is and is not leaves him free, paradoxically, to recreate himself as the occasion and his poet’s calling demand. I have mentioned already the adoption by Guillaume de Villon that led him to abandon his family name. This was only the first of a series of strategic self-transformations. “In the Middle Ages,” Mandelstam writes, “people loved to think of themselves as children of the city, of the church, of the university” (CPL, 55). Villon—who was born a child of the city and became a child of the church as a clergyman’s foster
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
55
son and a child of the university through his haphazard studies—becomes a child of his age by way of these multiple adoptions. In Mandelstam’s early verses, the poet who finds himself poised “on the threshold of a double being” is paralyzed by his own uncertain position.42 The same marginality invigorates Villon, and his multiple citizenships held in different worlds and different kinds of being become the source of the dynamism that Mandelstam celebrates in his precursor and seeks to release in himself. Villon, who lacks “traditional bonds with the past,” is placed by his adoption within society proper, and by his birth and proclivities beyond its pale (CPL, 59). He uses this freedom from the past and his sui generis position, though, to create “an intricate network of acquaintances, connections, and reckonings,” “a composite of brillant complexity”: “This man contrived to establish vital, fundamental relationships with enormous numbers of people of the most varied backgrounds, from every rung on the social ladder—thieves to bishops, barmaids to princes” (CPL, 57–58). The later poems of Stone bear witness to the diligence with which the pupil has attended to his master’s lessons. In these poems, the modernist writer, like his medieval teacher, lays claim to a whole range of experience, drawn from both past and present, from home and abroad, from every kind of art and walk of life. He creates his own complex and brilliant network, where Beethoven and Bach, Dickens, Socrates, Ovid, and Akhmatova all meet in a world that offers not only tennis, ice cream, and silent films, but Byzantine churches, bronze horsemen, and Scythian bullock-carts. The relationship between morality and free will that preoccupies Mandelstam in “Petr Chaadaev” and “Pushkin and Skriabin” (1915) surfaces in this essay only at moments.43 Mandelstam is careful, though, to distinguish his favorite’s “amoralism” from the Romantic and Symbolist cult of Villon the demonic outlaw (CPL, 59). “I think that Villon was captivated,” he writes, “not by demonism, but by the dynamics of transgression (dinamika prestupleniia),” and his emphasis on the energy generated by his precursor’s misdeeds points to what he himself seeks to learn from this “comfortingly sinful singer” (CPL, 58; II, 307; #382). “Might there not be some inverse ratio between the moral and the dynamic development of the soul?” Mandelstam asks, and his question takes us back to problems that plague him in the early verse (CPL, 58). How is the young poet to develop the self he has been given? Can he unleash its energies without obliterating its outlines entirely? Villon, who made plans to rob his own uncle, who abandoned his given name and disgraced his adopted name, may have inspired his latter-day descendant to make a final leap of faith. The young poet who cannot free himself from the pull of his family tree may have found in Villon’s example the courage to complete his fall from grace, confident that he, too, will create new roots in his age; like his adoptive ancestor, he will succeed in adapting himself to his age and in shaping the age through his art. This dynamic amorality, however, presents Mandelstam with another set of
56
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
problems, at least potentially. Villon, so thoroughly imbued with the Gothic love of motion, turns out to have been “unreceptive to its ethical aspect, to its mutual guarantees” (CPL, 59). If the constraints of conscience or social obligation do not restrict Villon, what, if anything, can serve to check his ceaseless thievery, poetic and otherwise? The Symbolists, Mandelstam complains, were entranced by the apparently boundless powers of a “creative ‘I’ which confused its own boundaries with those of a newly discovered and fascinating world” (CPL, 157). How is his Villon, so taken with his own and his age’s many energies, to escape a similar fate? The poet’s “I,” Mandelstam insists in “On the Interlocutor,” is not born of itself alone, whatever the Symbolists may claim for their overgrown selves. It arises in dialogue with other selves, other “I”’s; and Mandelstam places this dialogue at the heart of the self-creation he envisions in “François Villon”: “The lyric poet is a hermaphrodite by nature, capable of limitless fission in the name of his inner dialogue. Nowhere is this ‘lyrical hermaphroditism’ so clearly expressed as in Villon’s work. What a varied selection of enchanting duets: the aggrieved and the comforter, the mother and child, the judge and the judged, the property-owner and the beggar” (CPL, 56). For all his endless duets with his many selves, Villon manages to avoid the reflexive self-absorption that imprisons the poet of Mandelstam’s early lyrics, for by his very generation of selves, he sets limits on his intimacy with any one of them: “Villon’s attitude to himself never exceeds certain limits of intimacy. He expresses no more tenderness, attentiveness, or concern for himself than a good lawyer would show his client” (CPL, 56). In “On the Interlocutor,” Mandelstam faults his Symbolist forebears for ignoring “the contractual relationship, the mutuality that attends the act of speaking” (CPL, 67). The legal and musical metaphors Mandelstam uses to describe Villon’s dialogues suggest the nature of these dialogues. In duets, as in courtroom dramas, each voice both responds to another voice and is restricted by its formal relationship to it—much as in “On the Interlocutor” a poet’s voice arises not of itself but in response to the summons of a still-undiscovered reader. Mandelstam’s fellow post-Symbolist, Mikhail Bakhtin, also saw the “I” as born in dialogue: “Because I live on the borders between my own subjectivity for myself and my status as object for others, I am able to cross this border and, in my imagination, see the other as subject and myself as object.”44 The dialogues of Mandelstam’s Villon begin within himself, or, more precisely, among his selves, and these selves, like Noah’s animals. come only in pairs. This means that each is both self and other, subject and object; the “abyss between subject and object” that Mandelstam’s Villon feels so strongly is bridged, but not abridged or denied (CPL, 57). Even the particular congregation of couples that Mandelstam finds assembled in Villon suggests a system of checks and balances by which the growth of any particular self can be monitered and contained. The first two
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
57
pairs—“aggrieved and comforter,” “mother and child”—bring to mind the poet as insulted and injured, the poet as his own parent at the end of “From an evil, miry pond” and “In the vast pond it’s transparent and dark.” These “tender” pairings, if left to themselves, might well fall into the early poems’ paralyzing self-pity. Villon’s selves, however, are bound together in a balance of power, and these couples are countered by pairings that come closer to duels than duets: “judge and judged,” “property-owner and beggar.” Thus, even within himself, or among his selves, Villon maintains that “living equilibrium” which sustained the medieval world at large according to Mandelstam (CPL, 65). In the early poems, Mandelstam is trapped with and by the very selves he generates in an unreal, “uncreated” world. Villon’s duets, on the other hand, derive from and are themselves in dialogue with the society around him, as the callings of his various selves suggest. His intricate inner world mirrors in miniature the complex social network he uncovers and develops in his age; and his self-revision and “limitless fission” are fitting responses to an epoch teetering on the brink of its own renascence. Villon’s creative force matches that of his nation and age in yet another way. He shares with his captive, captivating France and his hapless age a “feminine” temperament and fate. In his essay Mandelstam celebrates Villon’s “feminine nature, with its excitable temperament and its powerful sense of life’s rhythm.” His “feminine epoch” and that “true woman” France presumably draw power from the same sense of energy and motion (CPL 54, 57). The imagery is entirely appropriate for an endlessly fertile poet and his fruitful age—but it also reminds us of the “feminine” vitality that Mandelstam fails to tap in the early verse. “The woman of Gallic tradition,” Bakhtin claims in Rabelais and His World, “represents in person the undoing . . . of all that is finished, completed, and exhausted. She is the inexhaustible vessel of conception”; and his description takes us back to Mandelstam’s disembodied embodiment of unbounded creative energy, the oceanic Aphrodite of “Silentium.”45 Villon has learned to draw on this power both within himself and in his age. But this feminine nature is only half the story, both for the “hermaphroditic” Villon and for France itself. Images of generation, of masculine and feminine creativity conjoined, permeate the essay: the coming together of two nations, the invader England and a captive France who, like a “true woman,” flirts with her conquerer; the maternal Middle Ages who reluctantly cedes her children to a new era; and even the student mock-wedding of two signboards, the “She-Goat” and the “Bear,” in which Villon himself played a part (CPL, 54–58). Nations, ages, even species come together in the world Villon inhabits, and the pairings, in turn, that inhabit Villon are themselves the progeny or kin of the larger couplings of unlikes that surround him in his nation and his age. “Who am I? A double-dealer with a double soul,” Mandelstam announces in the “Slate Ode” (1923; #137). He had learned his master’s lessons well. The double being that had para-
58
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
lyzed him in Stone’s early verses becomes the essence of both individual poetic being and social, historical being for Villon’s adroit and gifted descendant. Villon responds creatively to the summons of his age and thus becomes his era’s interlocutor. He and his age become yet another of the essay’s fruitful pairings, another set of partners in dialogue, both limited and liberated by the presence of the other and bound by the contractual relationship that governs all such exchanges (CPL, 67). The essay’s chief pairing, though, is the crucial dialogue that engages the medieval poet with the modern age, the conversation that takes place between Villon and his “distant heir,” the poet Osip Mandelstam (CPL, 68). Villon’s reader, Mandelstam notes, “feels himself the poet’s contemporary,” and the modernist writer finds potential solutions to the problems that plague his early poetry in this conversation with his fifteenth-century contemporary (CPL, 58). These problems—static form versus vital essence, transformation versus permanence, individual identity versus community—become, under Villon’s tutelage, not paralyzing incompatibles, but productive pairings of opposites. They become the kind of unlikely couplings that animate both Villon and his age. The Mandelstam of “There’s nothing to talk about” (#11) can unleash his “dark, bestial (zverinaia) soul” only by dissolving the self that holds and inhibits its force. Villon, however, both nurtures and contains the “predatory lean little beast (zverek)”’ within him (CPL, 57; II, 306). To draw on the sea’s vitality, the poet of “Silentium” must relinquish speech itself, and with it all hope of community, while for Villon Paris itself becomes a sea whose energy he can tap in shaping his life and art (CPL, 55). Villon shows his latter-day disciple how to break free of the “fenced-in garden” of a poetry divorced from life while preserving the flower-self he nurtures in “I’ve been given a body” (CPL, 53). The plant that is firmly rooted in its age can be transplanted. It can cross the abyss between ages and survive its migration unharmed: “The passing moment can . . . endure the pressure of centuries and preserve itself intact, remaining forever the same ‘here and now.’ You need only know how to extract that ‘here and now’ from the soil of Time without harming its roots, or it will wither and die” (CPL 58). The Mandelstam of the early verse dreads the change that will efface his carefully crafted, static self and verse; this new version of poetic permanence, though, is achieved through ceaseless change: the passing moment changes hands and ages while remaining itself. And the poet who extracts this living moment from the past finds himself in possession not of the brittle shells of long-dead precursors, but of a living being capable of endless fission in the name of unending creation. This being, moreover, is not given but achieved. The poet must actively seek it out, and through his careful recovery of this inherited moment, he himself participates in its continued existence. He becomes, in Eliot’s phrase, the “bearer of a tradition.”
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
59
In “François Villon” Mandelstam is given a new kind of being by Villon—though it is a gift he must work to receive, indeed must help to create. This gift is not just a body of work. It is also the body of the poet himself, which cannot be separated from his work and which stands as a model of vital force both developed and contained. This body is not only Mandelstam’s, “so single, so his own”: it is also Villon’s and his age’s and the human body itself, being as such, “unadorned personal existence.” This body, in turn, serves as Mandelstam’s entryway into the social body of his own and other ages; it allows him to participate in the complex structures that these ages have built in their shared quest to conquer emptiness.
AKME AND ADAM In [William] Blake’s own Bible . . . the Poetic Genius, no longer dependent on myths of nature, creates perpetual Genesis in its own image. —Lawrence Lipking, The Life of the Poet (1981) There is no theory that is not a fragment, carefully prepared, of some autobiography. —Paul Valéry, “Poetry and Abstract Thought” (1939)
Villon and his verse waited nearly five centuries before finding, Mandelstam implies, a fitting Russian reader in posterity, a reader equipped to uproot the medieval writer’s life and work and replant them in the fertile soul of early-twentieth-century Russian poetry. The essay in which Mandelstam recovers his poetic kinsman was destined, however, to suffer a fate similar to that of the poet it celebrated, although on a far smaller scale. Like Villon and Mandelstam himself, it did not come into the world with a place already prepared for it among those like it; it had to wait before reaching its true audience. “François Villon” found its proper home only three years after its composition, in the April 1913 issue of Apollon, where it was accompanied by Nikolai Gumilev’s translations from Villon’s Grand Testament; and its way had been paved by the Acmeist poem-manifestos, including Mandelstam’s own “Hagia Sophia” and “Notre Dame,” that had appeared in the preceding issue. Villon thus becomes his descendant’s contemporary in yet another sense through their shared debut as Acmeist poets. Gumilev, moreover, had already prepared a welcome for Mandelstam’s “favorite relation” in the manifesto published in the January 1913 issue of Apollon. In “The Precepts of Symbolism and Acmeism,” Villon was made an honorary ancestor of the fledgling movement, a “cornerstone” on which the “Acmeist building” would stand. Both Villon and his newfound friend, the author of “François Villon,” find a new home and a new community on the pages of Apollon and among those whose programs filled its
60
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
pages. Villon’s “here and now,” the “passing moment” that Mandelstam seeks to recover singlehandedly in his essay, becomes, in Gumilev’s manifesto, one of the four “moments” (the other three are Shakespeare, Rabelais, and Gautier) from which the Acmeist movement was born: “To unite within ourselves these four moments—this is the dream that joins together those who so boldly call themselves Acmeists.”46 Mandelstam’s quest to retrieve the past and revive its presence unites him with colleagues who also aim to live, as Eliot writes, “not merely in the present, but in the present moment of the past.” It was at this “moment in his life,” Nadezhda Mandelstam observes, that the solitary “I” of Osip Mandelstam “was linked by the pronoun ‘we’ with a group of others,” which “enabled his personality (lichnost’) to come into being.”47 Moments from past and present converge as the lonely stone joins at last in the “joyous cooperative action of those like it.” The first task of the critic, Mandelstam tells us in “Badger Hole” (1922), is to determine the poet’s “literary genesis,” his “ancestry and origins” (italics in original). The Acmeists, in their struggle to replace their Symbolist fathers and their fathers’ fathers, came up with new grandfathers and new “progenitors (rodonachal’niki).”48 But Mandel’stam’s kinship with the Acmeists was not based on shared genealogy alone. “In the face of nonbeing,” Gumilev proclaims in “The Precepts of Symbolism and Acmeism,” “all phenomena are brothers.” “To exist is the artist’s greatest pride. He desires no paradise other than being,” Mandelstam declares in “The Morning of Acmeism” (CPL, 61). For Sergei Gorodetsky, another of the group’s charter members, the only “ugliness” is the “formlessness” of whatever “is not fully incarnated (nedovoploshcheno)” and “fades between being and non-being.”49 Mandelstam thus finds companions and brethren in his battle with non-being in the present as well as in the past. The young poet’s solitary quest for existence has become part of a larger poetic program; it is at the heart of the artist’s mission as Mandelstam and his fellow Acmeists conceive it. Mandelstam joins forces with his fellow Acmeists to create the paradise that is being in poetry and on earth. “Acmeism is in essence mythopoeism,” Gumilev proclaims in the 1912 review that first christened the newborn movement; and the central myth of Acmeism, the myth that will counter Symbolist “chaos, Nirvana, emptiness,” is “the self-sufficient image, which has its own name, which develops through inner correspondence with itself.” Mandelstam’s Acmeist stone, itself the discoverer of the energies contained within it, might be an exemplar of this mythic image with its properties of wholeness, identity, and growth. Gumilev’s central myth is also akin to another, far older and grander legend, though, one that also deals with the creation of self-contained forms from chaos. This is the myth of Genesis, of first, divine creation and absolute originality. The myth governs the first beginnings of Acmeism itself, if we trace them back to the pages of Mikhail Kuzmin’s proto-Acmeist manifesto “On Beautiful Clarity” (1910). Kuzmin’s clarity
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
61
emerges, like God’s handiwork, from the “void,” from “darkness” (Genesis 1:2), or, more specifically, from the “chaos” of Symbolist poetry. The article itself begins by paraphrasing the opening passages of Genesis, as it sets the artist’s work in the light of God’s original labors: “When the hard elements were first joined together in dry land and moisture surrounded the earth and seas and flowed over it in rivers and lakes, then the earth first came forth from a state of chaos, over which blew the divine, dividing spirit. And then—by means of demarcations, clear furrows—this complex and beautiful world emerged, [which] artists strive to recognize, to see and imprint in their own way.” Acmeism’s founding myth leaves its traces in the alternate name that Gorodetsky and Gumilev propose for the new movement: Adamism. The task of the “new Adam,” the Acmeist, was not only, as Gumilev puts it, to fix “a manfully hard and clear gaze on life”—a gaze perhaps inspired by the divine spirit that first brought forth firmness from flux. It was also, Gorodetsky writes, to “name the world’s names, and in so doing to summon all creation from damp and dusk into transparent air.” In his poem “Adam,” published in the March 1913 issue of Apollon, Gorodetsky bids farewell to “captivating dampness and primordial mist.” The Acmeists-as-Adamists, who relate the birth of the young movement to the genesis of the human race itself, who follow divine and primal inspiration in their creation from chaos, could call all language, creation, and human history their rightful property, and humanity as such becomes their proper family.50 The young Acmeists, Viktor Zhirmunsky writes, experienced “a certain duality vis-à-vis the tradition that had shaped their age.” He far understates the case. In naming and creating themselves, the Acmeists stake out two ambitious, contradictory claims by way of their double christening. If Adam represents the first of all beginnings, Acmeism is, as Gumilev instructs us, derived from the Greek akme, “the highest degree of something, the flower, a flourishing time,” “the prime of all powers, spiritual and physical.” As Acmeists, the poets are rooted in history and represent the crowning achievement of a long and venerable tradition, and the history they inherit is presumably the one that begins, like their name, in ancient Greece. As Acmeists they build on the legacy left by the past and are indebted to those who precede them. In his manifesto, Gumilev is not only a rebel proclaiming Symbolism’s downfall: “Symbolism has come full circle in its development and is now in decline.” He is also a dutiful son who respectfully solves the problems set him by his Symbolist schoolmaster-parent: “To be a worthy successor to what has gone before it, [Acmeism] must accept its inheritance and answer all the questions it poses. The glory of our ancestors obliges us, and Symbolism was a worthy father.” Both titles of Gumilev’s manifesto—“Acmeism and the Precepts of Symbolism” was later reprinted as “The Symbolist Legacy and Acmeism”—reveal his acute awareness of the past’s burdens even as he sets out to challenge them. In “The Life of Verse” (1910), an essay that prefigures his Acmeist endeavors,
62
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
Gumilev ruefully concludes that “we cannot avoid being Symbolists now. This is not a summons, not a desire, but simply a fact that I have verified.”51 Adam’s only ancestor, on the other hand, is God himself. Human time is born with the first man, and human history commences with his fall. There is no past to burden unfallen Adam. God’s work is his sole model for creation, and Adam, authorized by God and formed in his image, is both creature and fellow creator: “And whatsoever Adam called every living creature, that was the name thereof” (Gen. 2:19). The very title of Mandelstam’s manifesto, “The Morning of Acmeism” (my italics), suggests not only repetition, the dawn of a new day that follows, all the same, in the wake of countless mornings and will be followed in its turn by countless other dawns and days. It also hints at the quintessential newness that accompanied the first creation. God’s first invention is, after all, morning: “And darkness was on the face of the deep. . . . And God said, Let there be light” (Gen. 1:2–3).52 The Acmeists, Zhirmunsky claims, set out to surmount the “restless chaos of the [Symbolist] epoch that preceded them.” An Acmeist, enmeshed in history, might reluctantly acknowledge his aesthetic legacy: “We appreciate that the Symbolists pointed out the symbol’s significance in art,” Gumilev admits in his manifesto. The Adamist denies this inheritance entirely. This same symbol, Gumilev warns elsewhere, leads only to confusion in art and life. The Symbolist legacy of chaos, translated into the language of Genesis, precedes all creation; it comes before Adam and his names. “No poet since Adam,” Harold Bloom remarks, “speaks a language free of the one wrought by his precursors.” The Acmeists-as-Adamists strive for precisely this kind of poetic priority. The Symbolist verse that sought to transcend speech is made, through the agency of Genesis, to precede speech, and language is born, with Acmeism, from Symbolist chaos. “Then the world first came forth from a state of chaos,” Kuzmin writes of the creation that is his model. “To name, to know, to tear the covers/Of empty mysteries and ancient mist” is the “first feat” of Gorodetsky’s Adam, and the task of Russia’s new Adams is to “name the world’s names, and in so doing to summon all creation from damp and dusk into transparent air.” “Acmeism,” Boris Eikhenbaum observes, “is modernism’s last word.” In the young poets’ language, he continues, the speech of their Symbolist forefathers reaches its akme, its peak. The Acmeists-as-Adamists, however, follow only chaos, and human speech is theirs alone.53 Adam and Acme together represent “a kind of alpha and omega: a primal beginning and a final ripeness.”54 “We will prove our rightness,” Mandelstam proclaims, “in such a way that in answer to us the entire chain of cause and effect, from alpha to omega, will shudder” (CPL, 65). The Acmeists-as-Adamists, at once cause and effect, sense both the weight of history and its liberating absence. The Acmeists struggle to supplant their immediate precursors and to replace their fathers with more sympathetic, more comfortably distant ancestors. The Adamists, on the other hand,
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
63
make cause and effect “shudder” by becoming in effect their own fathers, for all humanity descends from Adam. The Symbolist legacy is subverted and the descendant becomes the father of the movement it follows. The Acmeists-as-Adamists also manage to outdo, in theory at least, their poetic brethren and rival “myth-creators,” the Futurists. Mandelstam strips them of their vaunted “word as such (slovo kak takovoe)” in “The Morning of Acmeism” and accuses them of the cardinal sin for any avant-garde innovator: instead of forging new paths, he charges, they are merely “repeating the crude mistakes of their [Symbolist] precursors.” He turns to a more recent myth of origination, to evolution, as he stakes his claim for an Acmeism that is more progressive and original than any pseudo-creation proposed by misnamed Futurists: “If, for the Futurists, the word as such is still down on its knees creeping, in Acmeism it has for the first time assumed a dignified upright position and entered the Stone Age of its existence” (my italics; CPL, 62). No matter what challenges Symbolists or Futurists may contrive for them, the Acmeists, by virtue of their superior mythmaking, retain poetic priority as practitioners of the first truly human creation—or so Mandelstam’s myth-in-miniature proclaims.55 Acmeism is, of course, the name by which the new movement finally came to be known. It is the name that survived in the minds and writings of Akhmatova, Gumilev, and Mandelstam long after Acmeism proper had ceased to exist. In a post factum manifesto of 1922, “On the Nature of the Word,” Mandelstam insists on the vitality of a movement whose members had long since scattered, whose Russia had vanished, and whose leader had been among the first casualities of the new regime.56 He revises the Acmeist past even as he asserts its presence, though, and the movement’s other name falls victim to his changes. “Gorodetsky,” he charges, “attempted to inoculate Acmeism with his literary world view, ‘Adamism,’ a form of doctrine of a new earth and a new Adam.” His efforts, Mandelstam insists, were unsuccessful—yet Mandelstam’s new description of Acmeism still draws indirectly on its Adamist heritage. The “manly will” that is, he says, Acmeism’s moving force is a direct descendant of Adamism’s “manly gaze” fixed on a reawakened world. Mandelstam stresses the group’s newness, the “new tastes” that reshape the world and place humans firmly at its center (CPL, 130). Gorodetsky’s unsavory later history—he became Acmeism’s “first apostate”57 and denounced Gumilev after his death—may have led Mandelstam to erase the traces of his early influence on the group. More importantly, the Acmeist task of recalling the past must have seemed far more urgent than Adamist newness in the wake of a revolution that claimed to have overthrown all history. The Adamist legacy of a primal, human force that converts the past to new presence survives just the same, concealed beneath another name. For the young Mandelstam, both Akme and Adam point a way out of the tremulous half-life of the early poetry and into a full-fledged “paradise” of being. In his review of the 1916 version of Stone, Gumilev recognizes
64
•
C H A P T E R
T W O
•
the Mandelstamian master plot at work behind this collection’s seeming impersonality: he traces in this poetic “tale of a developing spirit” a movement from “pre-being” into history, vitality, and the “human I.” This tale dovetails neatly with the mythologized history of Acmeism itself, as given in its manifestos; and Stone’s turning point, set by Gumilev at 1912, coincides with the group’s first christening.58 Mandelstam anticipates the direction of his own poetic growth and the principles of the nascent Acmeist movement in his early essay on Villon; and his myths of origination converge with those of Acmeism first tacitly, in the manifestos, and then explicitly, in Gumilev’s review. The two-year gap between Mandelstam’s theory, the discoveries he makes by way of Villon, and his poetic practice is perhaps akin to the gap that separates the essay’s composition from its publication. As Mandelstam observes in “The Morning of Acmeism,” an “organism” must uncover or shape for itself a proper “organization” before it can attain the being it requires, and the organization that facilitates Mandelstam’s growth is Acmeism, both in its theories and its practice (CPL, 63). Mandelstam requires both Acmeist history and Adamic newness for his self-creation and creation of tradition. They are the two indispensible forces from which poetry and the poet himself are born. “Remembrance and invention go hand in hand in poetry,” Mandelstam insists in “Literary Moscow” (1922; CPL, 146); and though Akme and Adam have been rechristened here, they are recognizable nonetheless in their new incarnations. Through Adam and Akme Mandelstam masters two kinds of creation, creation within history and an original creation that precedes all history; and two kinds of tradition, an Acmeist tradition transmitted through history and a paradoxical tradition of Adamic newness. By combining these different traditions and creations Mandelstam can create the tradition he requires. By choosing his names carefully, the modern orphan can acquire the history he desires; and the acoustic affinities between the name that Mandelstam gives his encoded self-portrait—Stone (Kamen’ in Russian)—and the names assumed by his new community—Akme, Adam—allow him to take on vast territories indeed.59 He lays claim through the first to the firstness and originality that enable him creatively to reshape the past he inherits through the second. A newcomer to history, he is free to name the world’s names anew, and the chains of historical cause and effect will fall away at his bidding. The stone of this chapter’s epigraph is a fallen stone, and it is kin to the fallen fruit with which Stone itself opens. The Acmeists, “stonemasons of every time and nation,” redeem this fallen stone. They raise it up and use it to begin their building. Mandelstam and his new companions, whose model as Adamists is unfallen Adam, seek ways in verse to reverse humanity’s, and the poet’s, fall from grace. The legacy of fallen Adam is labor— “In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground . . . for dust thou art and unto dust shalt thou return” (Gen.
•
S E L F - C R E A T I O N ,
C R E A T I O N
O F
C U L T U R E
•
65
3:19)—and this is the labor that Gumilev’s Adam laments: “Now you know heavy labor. . . . as you recall the words ‘Too late.’ ” Acmeist labor in history, though, may be used to regain Adamic firstness. The same stone that summons the Acmeists to build also provides the means to challenge their fall: “Who throws stones to us from on high—/And does the stone negate the yoke of dust?” (#34) In rebellion against Symbolist inspiration, the Acmeists embrace the work that makes a work of art. “He who is willing to work gives birth to his own father,” Harold Bloom proclaims. In the later poems of Stone, Mandelstam uses Acmeist work to create Adamic firstness. Akme and Adam thus take pride of place among the fruitful pairings of opposites that Mandelstam uncovers through Villon. By yoking together history and firstness, past and present, work and effortless creation, he finds a way to build on what Villon has taught him.60
•
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
T
H
R
E
E
•
Making History: Modernist Cathedrals When a person steps beneath the vaults of Notre Dame . . . doesn’t he become a Catholic merely by virtue of being under those vaults? —Osip Mandelstam, in a 1909 letter to Viacheslav Ivanov. The churches and the literary tradition are to be rebuilt by modernists strong enough to inherit by choice and to revise by necessity. —Gregory Jay, on T. S. Eliot’s pamphlet, “The Value and Use of Cathedrals in England Today” The man visited churches rather than went to church. —Omry Ronen, “Osip Mandelshtam” (1990)
VISITING CHURCHES For the Greeks, a stone possessed symbolic meaning. . . . Man and stone represent two cosmic powers, the movement of gravity and grace. A rough stone falls from the sky. Submitted to an architect’s toil, to the suffering of number and measure, it soars to the dwelling of the gods. —Zbigniew Herbert, Barbarian in the Garden (1962)
As concerns culture, T. S. Eliot observes, “one cannot be outside and inside at the same time.” He gives a grisly example to illustrate his point: “The man who, in order to understand the inner world of a cannibal tribe, has partaken of the practice of cannibalism, has probably gone too far: he can never quite be one of his own folk again.”1 Eliot’s cannibals would seem to be immeasurably distant from the Christian Europe that he himself seeks to penetrate. The experience that lies behind Eliot’s grim anecdote is, however, recognizably his own. It is the bitter experience of the newcomer, the alien who has tried and failed to be outside and in at the same time. The same dilemma faces Mandelstam. It is the dilemma of any modern outsider who works to inherit a culture not his by rights without relinquishing entirely his outsider’s identity or vision. The young Mandelstam seeks to inherit the Western, Christian tradition by entering its churches—but he also seeks the freedom to exit these churches, this tradition at will. He requires
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
67
the capacity to be both outside and inside, if not at the same time, then in successive moments. Mandelstam puts his newfound Acmeist and Adamist legacy to work in two crucial poems of Stone, “Hagia Sophia” (1912; #38) and “Notre Dame” (1912; #39), as he struggles to create a tradition that accommodates both the history he desires and the strangeness and newness of the poet-parvenu, the modernist outsider. “Culture should begin in the right place,” Nietzsche proclaims, “[and] the right place is the body.” Mandelstam would have agreed; but building on the body is easier said than done for the young poet of Stone. In “I’ve been given a body”(#8), he labors to reconcile the seeming antinomies of an ephemeral, living self held within a fixed and lasting structure. In a later poem, “Shell” (1911; #26), these properties are reversed. The sea that lies outside the body is vital and changing, while the shell-self is a rigid “empty vessel,” and the poet can only hope that the ocean will enter and fill the “frail shell’s walls” on his command. Though the world and the self shift positions, the terms of the argument remain the same. Form opposes content; self struggles with what exceeds it and is eclipsed by what will outlast it. The poet anticipates a consummation of self and sea in “Shell”—but even here the sea that enters the shell is not the one that lay outside it. It is diminished by its confinement and fills the shell not with oceanic vigor but with “whispers of foam/With mist, wind and rain.” After this disappointing sea change, the poem itself trickles off in ellipses. The shell-body not only cannot contain these oppositions; it cannot even hold the poet himself, whose consciousness hovers beyond the confines of his physical self. This consciousness seeks to negotiate the rift that separates self and world, but can adopt one only by denying the other and is ultimately at home in neither. In “Shell” Mandelstam begins with an “I” that defies the night’s abyss. This abyss becomes the ocean by way of the metaphors that end the first stanza—“Like a shell without a pearl/I am thrown upon your shore”—and remains Mandelstam’s addressee, but his physical being becomes a mere object, an “it,” and the poet’s consciousness is doomed to remain beyond its bounds.2 The Acmeists and their honorary ancestor François Villon help Mandelstam to find new answers to the question that troubles him early on: “I’ve been given a body/What should I do with it?” Villon offers the model of a body whose contained complexity echoes the intricate network that is the social body of his age. His body bonds him to his age and this kinship, in turn, expands the limits of his own restricted self. Moreover, because he is rooted deeply and physically in his age, he can be transplanted, roots and all, into other ages, as Mandelstam demonstrates. He transcends his age and remains alive for generations yet to come; he is expanded spatially and temporally by the very intensity of his physical being. The Acmeists’ kinship with Villon and with his age is likewise born of the body, of their shared, human being. Villon nurtures the “little animal” he bears within him. The Acmeists also cherish the animal in man, that which is purely physical in his nature: “As Adamists,” Gumilev asserts, “we are a
68
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
little bit beasts of the forest and we won’t give up the beast in us.” The Adamists spring from the first human body, and their own creation in words is tied to God’s physical creation of the world, and to his Word that is both flesh and spirit, through which all things come to be. If Adam stands for man’s first body, then Akme, “the prime of all powers, spiritual and physical,” represents the best, most perfect human form, and this is the source of true poetry, as Gumilev explains in “The Life of Verse” (1910): “The origin of individual poems is mysteriously akin to that of living organisms,” and the poem itself “must be a copy of a beautiful human body.”3 The “divine physiognomy” of the human body becomes both foundation and master plan for Mandelstam’s Acmeism. In “On the Nature of the Word,” he praises the movement’s “organic poetics,” whose “organization” derives from “the infinite complexity of our own dark organism” he first celebrates in “The Morning of Acmeism” (CPL, 130, 63). Reverence for the body unites the Acmeists with the “physiologically gifted” Middle Ages, and this reverence also brings together self and world, for the world, a “God-given palace,” is, like the body and Tiutchev’s fallen stone, a gift from above (CPL, 63). The organism is akin to the organization of the world that is its home, since their origins are the same. Both world and self are the work of the first builder, and human architecture reflects and answers divine building. Hence God’s first creation and humanity’s highest creation, Adam and Akme, converge in what is built from the body. The Symbolists, “ungrateful guests,” reject the body and the world in favor of an incorporeal being forever beyond their reach (CPL, 63). They are prodigal children who spurn the legacy of a generous father. Mandelstam claims the inheritance his predecessors had refused. He picks up “the stone which the builders rejected” and uses it to construct poems that answer and extend the work of the architect, whether human or divine. Ajq-Sofiq Ajq-Sofiqózdes; ostanovit;sq Sudil Gospod; narodam i carqm! Ved; kupol tvoj, po slovu ohevidca, Kak na cepi podvewen k nebesam. I vsem vekam primer {stiniana, Kogda poxitit; dlq hu'ix bogov Pozvolila ?fesskaq Diana Sto sem; zelenyx mramornyx stolbov. No hto 'e dumal tvoj stroitel; ]edryj, Kogda, duwoj i pomyslom vysok, Raspolo'il apsidy i /ksedry, Im ukazav na zapad i vostok?
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
Prekrasen xram, kupa[]ijsq v mire, I sorok okonósveta tor'estvo; Na parusax, pod kupolom, hetyre Arxangela prekrasnee vsego. I mudroe sferiheskoe zdan;e Narody i veka pere'ivet, I serafimov gulkoe rydanie Ne pokorobit temnyx pozolot. HAGIA SOPHIA Hagia Sophia—here did God decree That nations and emperors should halt! In fact, your cupola, as one eyewitness said, Seems suspended from the heavens on a chain. And Justinian’s example holds for all ages, When Ephesian Diana permitted him To abduct for foreign gods One hundred and seven green marble columns. But what was your lavish builder thinking When high in spirit and design He distributed the apses and exedrae Having shown them which was west and which was east? A beautiful temple bathing in the world, And its forty windows are the triumph of light; On the pendentives beneath the cupola four Archangels are the most beautiful of all. And the wise, spherical building Will outlive nations and ages, And the resounding sobs of seraphim Will not warp the dark gilt. NOTRE DAME
Gde rimskij sudiq sudil hu'oj narodó Stoit bazilika, i radostnyj i pervyj, Kak nekogda Adam, rasplastyvaq nervy, Igraet mywcami krestovyj legkij svod. No vydaet sebq snaru'i tajnyj plan, Zdes; pozabotilas; podpru'nyx arok sila, Htob massa gruznaq steny ne sokruwila, I svoda derzkogo bezdejstvuet taran.
69
70
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
Stixijnyj labirint, neposti'imyj les, Duwi gotiheskoj rassudohnaq propast;, Egipetskaq mo]; i xristianstva robost;, S trostinkoj rqdomódub, i vs[du car;óotves. No hem vnimatel;nej, tverdynq Notre Dame, Q izuhal tvoi hudovi]nye rebra, Tem ha]e dumal q: iz tq'esti nedobroj I q kogda-nibud; prekrasnoe sozdam. NOTRE DAME Where a Roman judge had judged a foreign nation There stands a basilica, and joyful and first, As Adam once was, a light groined arch Spreading out its nerves, plays with its muscles. But a secret plan is betrayed from without: Here the strength of the saddle-arches has taken care So that the weighty mass won’t crush the walls And the bold arch’s battering ram is immobilized. Elemental labyrinth, inscrutable forest, The Gothic soul’s rational abyss, Egyptian might and Christian modesty: Beside the reed—the oak, and everywhere the plumbline is emperor. But the more attentively, O fortress, Notre Dame, I studied your monstrous ribs, The more often I thought: from evil weight I too will create beauty some day.
These programmatic poems, which appeared in the March 1913 issue of Apollon and concluded the first edition of Stone, are sister poems, or “doublets,” dvoichatki, in Nadezhda Mandelstam’s term. “Hagia Sophia” and “Notre Dame” both celebrate great Christian structures built at the crossroads of cultures. Both churches in turn embody the highest feminine principles of the Christian faith: divine wisdom, Sophia, and the holy and pure maternity revered in the Mother of God. As poem-manifestos, though, they are not only buildings in verse. They are also blueprints for the construction of an Acmeist poetics and poetry. As such, they have been much discussed.4 They also represent Mandelstam’s own efforts to make the world and its history his home. The eighteen-year-old poet, studying in Paris, hoped that Christianity could be entered as easily as its churches. Mandelstam at twenty is in exile from the longed-for, unfeeling fatherland and carries his light cross alone (#22). The twenty-one-year-old Acmeist is more ambi-
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
71
tious. He neither goes on pilgrimage to distant monuments nor does penance to appease his indifferent homeland. He no longer simply enters churches; now they are also made to enter his verse. The Christian church was a natural choice for the young Acmeist in search of a tradition at once venerable and vital, a tradition open, in principle, to all comers. “The myth of Christianity” is, Mandelstam writes in “Pushkin and Skriabin” (1915), “the legitimate heir of the myths of antiquity” (CPL, 93). Christianity links the legacy of Classical Greece and Rome with the rich heritage of the West, and though Mandelstam seldom mentions it in his early writings, Christianity’s roots are, of course, Jewish, like his own. Moreover, the very essence of Christian being is rebirth, self-creation in Christ. Christianity is governed by “the spirit of adoption” (Rom. 8:15). And through this adoption all become “heirs of God and joint-heirs with Christ” (Rom. 8:17): “Ye are no more strangers and foreigners, but fellowcitizens . . . of the household of God,” Paul announces to the Ephesians (Eph. 2:19). God’s household is the church, which is built of the bodies of its members: “Ye also, as lively stones, are built up a spiritual house,” says Peter, himself the “rock” on whom the church stands (Peter 2:5; Matt. 6:18). The church is made up of all who choose to join it, and these “living stones” united form its being. “We, being many, are one body in Christ,” Paul rejoices (Rom. 12:4–5). “The Christian world,” Mandelstam asserts, “is an organism, a living body,” endowed with a “multiple unity” (CPL, 94, 408). This body is one and many, spirit and flesh, human and divine. Born in history, it links humanity with what lies beyond history, and it is renewed throughout history by each new addition. “The achievement of early Christian architecture is that the content created its vessel— spontaneously, and yet in an endlessly complex and complicated creative process,” Heinz Kahler observes. The church’s body is incarnated in its buildings, in the cathedrals where its members gather. Indeed, the “content” and the “vessel” are etymologically the same in Russian: sobor means both “cathedral” and “congregation.” “If any man enter in he shall be saved,” the inscription over Hagia Sophia’s doors once read. Hence Mandelstam’s early dream of entering the Church’s body through its churches’ doors is not as naive or unlikely as it might seem. The Acmeist Mandelstam discovers, however, more complex ways of gaining access to this body and its history by way of his churches in verse.5 Among Christians, Paul declares, all differences dissolve: “There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus” (Gal. 3: 28). The student of Villon, though, finds his churches precisely at the points where differences are most acute and cultures and peoples collide. “Where races are mixed, there is the source of great cultures,” Friedrich Nietzsche proclaims—and Mandelstam’s poems might have been written to illustrate his maxim.6 Conquest, colonization, cross-fertilization, cultural theft—these are the common themes of Mandelstam’s cathedrals.
72
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
CHILDLESS BYZANTIUM A starlit or a moonlit dome disdains All that man is, All mere complexities, The fury and the mire of human veins. —William Butler Yeats, from “Byzantium” (1932)
Justinian’s Church of Holy Wisdom lies not in the Eternal City itself, but in its Eastern double, Constantinople, the Second Rome intended to stave off the empire’s enemies to the East. Justinian himself, whose example, Mandelstam tells us, holds for all ages, struggled to sustain an empire torn by religious rifts, and regional and linguistic cleavages, as Roland Bainton notes. Another historian, Herbert Muller, remarks that the Byzantine Empire, built of multiple cultures, was “an artificial empire,” a “nation without nationality.” And the Byzantine art created during Justinian’s reign grew from his empire’s schisms and rifts. Its greatness lay not in its purity, but in a fusion of elements drawn from East and West alike, from Greece and Rome, from the Orient and the Judaeo-Christian tradition. Justinian’s own example for the ages, according to Mandelstam, is his kidnapping of Ephesian Diana’s columns for the glory of Byzantine, Christian Sophia.7 Mandelstam’s Notre Dame rises “where a Roman judge had judged a foreign nation,” and its foundations conceal “an altar of Jupiter from the period of Tiberius’ reign on which the images of Roman gods were mingled with those of the Gallic druids,” as eighteenth-century excavators discovered.8 Notre Dame is also, like Villon, the creation of a time of fruitful upheaval. Both church and poet are born of the vital play of opposing forces that Mandelstam admires in the French Middle Ages. Mandelstam’s later Russian cathedrals in verse rise where cultures intersect, where East and West meet in medieval Moscow and nineteenth-century Petersburg. A Russian serf trained in Rome modeled the Kazan cathedral on St. Peter’s— “The architect was not Italian/But a Russian in Rome” (#61)—while the Kremlin Church of the Dormition, with its “Italian and Russian soul,” was the work of an Italian architect commanded by Ivan III to imitate Russian models (#84). Like Villon, Mandelstam is at home in the places where foreign and native meet; and culture itself arises, or so his churches suggest, precisely from these unexpected, even unwelcome, meetings of unlikes. In “Conversation about Dante” (1933), Mandelstam links the “complex of culture, homeland, and settled civilization” with “the pilgrimage, the journey, colonization, migration” (CPL, 410). The migrations and colonizations that give birth to his cathedrals also pave the way for the newcomer Osip Mandelstam to enter these churches and build them anew in his words. Like his empire, Justinian’s temple has a double orientation. It points to
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
73
both East and West, but, as Mandelstam’s poem hints, the pull of the East is strongest: “[Justinian] distributed the apses and exedrae/Having shown them which was west and which was east.” The exedrae, the arcades of the atrium that led to the church, lay in the West, but Hagia Sophia’s apses and its altar rose in the East and would have drawn the gazes and spirits of those who entered eastward.9 Mandelstam’s poems likewise point in two directions, towards East and West, toward the Greek Orthodox and Roman Catholic faiths. Indeed, in pairing the poems Mandelstam tacitly draws our attention to the schisms and conflicts that riddle Christianity itself, for all its dreams of all-embracing unity. Unlike Justinian, Mandelstam begins in the East and moves to the West in his search for an entrance into Christian tradition. And unlike Justinian’s temple, Mandelstam’s own “Hagia Sophia” is subtly directed to the West, to its French counterpart, Notre Dame. “Hagia Sophia,” like “Notre Dame,” begins with foreignness from its very title. The church’s name, though transliterated, remains untranslated from the original Greek, and the reader is thus on foreign soil from the start.10 Notre Dame’s name surfaces again only in “Notre Dame”’s final stanza, after Mandelstam has had time to leave his own mark on the phenomenon he names. Hagia Sophia, on the other hand, is emphatically christened from the start. The name comes doubly first in the poem—it is both the title and the opening phrase, in which the poet apostrophizes the church. Its primacy is underscored metrically: the foreign “Aiia (Hagia)” is the only trochaic foot in an otherwise consistently iambic poem.11 The name dominates the poem. There is no room for a second Adam to renew this church through calling it by name in his own way. The dash that follows the name also sets it apart from its surroundings and creates a visual sense of remove and isolation. Like the name that stands a pause away from the rest of the poem, the temple stands at a little distance from the world beyond it. The temple’s name is fixed from the start. Its place is just as firmly fixed by what follows. The dash breaks the line in two, and the “here” (zdes’) that begins the second hemistich is thus doubly stressed. The line itself ends with a literal “stop” (ostanovit’sia). The two words pin the cathedral down; they demonstrate from the poem’s outset the force of immobility and the power of permanence. But the “stop” does not end the sentence itself, which continues into the next line and reveals the source of the power that keeps cathedrals, and nations, in their place. The power to command is in the hands of the Lord, and it is he who “decreed” or “judged” (sudil) that emperors and their nations should halt their forward progress where the cathedral would come to stand. Indeed, according to legend, Constantine chose his new Rome with divine aid, and the city’s boundaries were fixed by God himself: “I shall advance, till He, the invisible guide who marches before me, thinks proper to stop,” Constantine purportedly declared. Hagia Sophia, which dates from 537, rises on the highest point of
74
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
ancient Byzantium, at the city’s center and the empire’s; it stands on “a holy place,” and the temple’s form itself, legend has it, came to Justinian in a dream. “Justinian the Builder” laid his church’s foundation stone and supervised each step of the construction, but he himself was “impelled,” as the church’s chronicler Procopius writes, “by God (for is he not himself a master-builder?)”12 The Christian, or Acmeist, architect’s play can be ferocious: “The handsome arrow of the Gothic belltower rages because its function is to stab the sky, to reproach it for its emptiness” (CPL, 63). Hagia Sophia’s dome, on the other hand, echoes the sky and is a part of it. The chain of command from God to humanity becomes literal in the stanza’s final lines: it is the chain on which the dome hangs from the sky. Unlike the tower the Acmeists build to reach and challenge the heavens—“We can ascend only those towers which we build ourselves”—this church descends from above, and the chain it hangs from is steady, unlike “the mobile chains of being” that the Acmeists embrace (CPL, 64–65). The model for Notre Dame is our own physiology, the human body writ large. Hagia Sophia’s dome is the sky made small. It is a “second firmament,” early witnesses reported. If the church duplicates the heavens, then the heavens are also like the church, as the stanza’s last image suggests. Thousands of lamps hung on chains from the ceiling of Hagia Sophia like heavenly constellations.13 Thus illuminated, Hagia Sophia, suspended on a chain from heaven, itself becomes a lamp hanging from an infinitely vaster ceiling. The crystal firmament that traps the poet in his early work is back in place, and the worshiper who enters Hagia Sophia is doubly confined beneath two equally alien, equally impenetrable domes. Mandelstam himself has not yet entered the church, and his very words are secondhand; he merely passes on the account of “one eyewitness.” But art for Mandelstam grows precisely from that moment when information received from afar becomes immediate, and another’s words become one’s own. The poet who has “not heard the tales of Ossian” bears witness nonetheless to “Scotland’s bloody moon” and repeats another’s song “as if it were his own” (#67). In the third and fourth stanzas, Mandelstam seeks an aperture in the past through which he can approach Hagia Sophia and resurrect Justinian’s temple “in the present moment of the past” by turning from the work of the master builder to his earthly servant, Justinian. Mandelstam apparently finds in Justinian’s theft of pagan columns for his Christian edifice a point of contact between the Byzantine emperor and the pupil of Villon. For both, theft is the very stuff of art; just as the poet borrows others’ words to make his verses, so the architect steals another’s stones to build his church. The columns’ source and their new purpose point to the kind of juncture of ages and places in which Mandelstam, like Villon, feels most at home. Hagia Sophia occupies what Kahler calls “a terminal position”: “It stands at the end of an epoch, which it has outlived, and contains the seeds of a new one.” The Ephesian temple to Diana, one
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
75
of the seven wonders of the ancient world, is torn apart and born again in a new wonder at the center of Justinian’s New Rome, his New Jerusalem.14 This crossbreeding of cultures brings the church to life in another way; it is the offspring of an encounter between a Byzantine emperor and an ancient deity. The temple to Diana becomes the goddess herself in the poem, “Ephesian Diana,” who permits Justinian to “kidnap” or “abduct” her columns (the Russian pokhitit’ can mean both, as well as “to steal”). The personification, the permission, the abduction give the cultural theft a flavor of seduction. As such it echoes feminine France’s flirtation with her captor England in “François Villon,” and here, as in “Villon,” “cultural values ornament” nations and give them “color, form, and even sex” (CPL, 113). The new Byzantine culture and ancient, pagan Greece take on bodies and gender to produce unexpected fruit. “Ephesian Diana” not only offers Mandelstam a way to humanize the temple and its maker. She also allows him to defuse the force of Byzantium’s dictatorial God. Seen from her eyes he becomes simply “foreign gods,” not one and universal, but many and alien. These foreign gods must compete for their temples with other gods just like any other ancient deity. Moreover, the divine, incontrovertable “here” of the poem’s first line suddenly shifts to become Diana’s tacit “over there.” From Diana’s point of view, this god, or these gods, are the foreigners; and foreign and native, center and peripheries, temporarily change places. Mandelstam’s concern with Justinian’s columns represents, perhaps, another attempt to bring Hagia Sophia and its builder literally down to earth by emphasizing the specific, physical nature of what presumably holds the temple up. The church’s “one hundred seven green marble pillars” show humanity and matter working upward against gravity and so pose a counterthrust to the chain on which the church at first seems to dangle helplessly from the heavens. Mandelstam seems in this stanza to have brought God’s static world and his suspended temple subtly back to life, and he has apparently restored “the human place in the universe” (#66) by celebrating the labors of Justinian the Builder. The phrase that begins the stanza serves, however, to freeze its shifted perspectives and unexpected encounters into place. Justinian’s example holds “for all ages,” and the “and” (i), that opens the phrase stresses that his action does not contradict the work of God but continues it. As in the first stanza, the divinely inspired actions of the past intersect not with the present but with eternity. The actions themselves may be rooted in history, but their results are imperishable and unchanging. The individual age vanishes in the face of all ages, just as individual nations and rulers—to say nothing of the mere mortals who make up these nations— are diminished by God’s command, which governs all peoples and kings alike. The stanza establishes a pattern by which historically specific, original acts become immutable models to be followed without question in ages to come.15
76
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
Mandelstam enlists the aid of the church as he works to recover the past in the next stanza, which takes the shape of a question addressed to Hagia Sophia herself; he interrogates the architecture in his attempt to engage its architect in dialogue. The “but” (no) that opens the stanza signals a change in direction and perhaps in tactics as the poet once again takes on a church and a world that have thus far resisted his advances. Indeed, the entire opening phrase no chto zhe (but whatever), with its emphatic particle, signals a more personal, engaged poetic voice than we have heard so far. Both the form and sense of the verb that follows, dumal (was thinking), aim to open the mind of the Byzantine ruler to the Acmeist poet. Mandelstam attempts to penetrate the inner sanctum of Justinian himself by way of his building, and to bring these thoughts from a closed past into an unfinished present. The verbs of the preceding stanzas are past perfectives, with perfective infinitive complements. The actions they indicate were finished long ago, and they have borne results that cannot be undone. Here, though, Mandelstam emphasizes the mental processes that shape the structure and continue in the builder even as the stages of the building are completed, and the verb he uses to describe these processes is the poem’s only past imperfective form.16 His efforts to open a closed past were still clearer in an early version of this line: “Where was your lavish builder aiming? (Kuda stremilsia tvoi stroitel’ shchedryi?)” (I, 414). The traces of this motion remain, however, in the two directions, east and west, to which Justinian’s building points. These directions open up the temple’s space, and the poem’s. They remind us that the church and earthly life are not subject to a hierarchical, heavenly axis of up and down alone. The church has not only height, but breadth. It is both physical and spiritual, accommodating East and West as well as high and low. Justinian himself is both lofty in his intentions (“high in spirit and design”) and broad in their execution (“having shown them which was west and which was east”). Even the epithet that describes Justinian, shchedryi—meaning “lavish,” “munificent,” “generous”—suggests breadth and openness.17 Perhaps Mandelstam is hoping that the builder’s munificence extends across time as well as space, and that a distant, dispossessed poet can benefit from the Byzantine emperor’s generosity. And Mandelstam does benefit from the largesse of another builder-emperor. In “The Admiralty” (1913) Peter the Great reaches the present through his building and teaches his successors by its spire that “beauty is not a demigod’s whim/But the measure of a simple joiner’s predatory eye” (#38). The Admiralty, open to earth, air, and water, half-building and halfboat (“frigate or Acropolis”), teaches those who study it to resist the confines of space and time not by denying them but by using them to create. Like the Acmeists’ fallen stone, it teaches them to undo humanity’s fallen state by building from it: “Does not this chastely built ark/Negate the supremacy of space?” The building and its maker insist on human freedom—
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
77
“Free man has created a fifth [element]”—and open “all the world’s seas” to us. Mandelstam may be trying in this stanza to enter Justinian and his church by echoing another poet’s portrait of Peter standing poised on the border between East and West as he prepares to negotiate this boundary by building. “Stojal on, dum velikikh poln (He stood, full of great thoughts),” Pushkin writes in “The Bronze Horseman” (1833); and the sense and construction are close to Mandelstam’s description of Justinian, “dushoi i pomyslom vysok” (high/lofty in spirit and design). Both lines end in shortform adjectives that govern nominal complements in oblique cases; both portray emperor-builders guided by historical and spiritual forces of great magnitude. Unlike Mandelstam, though, Pushkin effortlessly penetrates his subject’s mind. The phrase I I dumal on (and he thought [“was thinking”]; my italics) begins the passage in which Pushkin recreates Peter’s great idea, his dream of cutting “a window through to Europe.” The westward motion of Peter’s vision is clear—but Justinian’s aims remain ambiguous. The stanza itself closes in the East—but the church fails to answer Mandelstam’s question.18 Or perhaps Hagia Sophia’s eastward pull is its answer to Mandelstam, and this is what closes the church to him at last, for the temple of the poem’s final stanzas is a perfect, finished, and finally impenetrable structure. It loses its moorings in this world entirely in the fourth stanza’s first line. Indeed, the world itself dissolves away completely, to become a sea—v mire, “in the world” is only one vowel away from v more, “in the sea”—and the temple merely “bathes” in it. Weightless, it floats on the world’s surface. Hagia Sophia is in the world, but not of it, and were it to admit the world within its walls, it would sink beneath the weight. The participle that describes the cathedral, kupaiushchiisia, “bathing,” is the only verb form in the poem to indicate imperfective present action. Yet what it shows us is not an activity, a process, a present charged with energy, but an endless, changeless, seemingly aimless state. Past, present, and future fade in the light of Hagia Sophia’s incorruptible permanence. Mandelstam does, in a sense, enter the temple in the stanza’s final lines. He describes its interior fleetingly, though, and with an eye to precisely those features that dematerialize the building, that draw the viewer upward, outward, and beyond both self and church. Kahler observes that the forty windows that arched beneath the central cupola created the illusion that the dome, unsupported by mere stone, rose above a wreath of light.19 Mandelstam goes still further; the windows and cupola mark “light’s triumph.” In “The Admiralty,” the dominion of the four elements is destabilized by “free man,” who makes from them his own fifth element. In “Hagia Sophia” unity prevails over multiplicity, as light triumphs over the substance of the church, the elements of earth, and the will of individual humans. The church’s many windows only serve to bear witness to the one
78
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
true source of light, which lies far beyond this world. They are like the “monotonous stars” whose light the poet “hates” in an early lyric (#29). In the same poem, Mandelstam dreams of “a tower’s lancet growth” that would pierce and challenge this changeless light. “We do not fly,” he announces in “On the Morning of Acmeism.” “We ascend only those towers that we build ourselves” (CPL, 64). The fourth stanza of “Hagia Sophia” concludes, though, with emblems of superhuman flight, not human building. The church that dissolves the world is “beautiful.” The dome admitting light from beyond this world is, by extension, still more beautiful. The archangels, which symbolize flight in another world, are the “most beautiful of all.” The beings depicted in Hagia Sophia’s pendentives, her sails—the Russian parus means both—are actually seraphim, not archangels, and their forms are made entirely of wings: they are the disembodied essence of flight. The stanza begins with simple beauty—Prekrasen khram, “Beautiful is the church”—and ends with beauty’s highest degree: Chetyre arkhangela prekrasnee vsego, “The four archangels are the most beautiful of all.” Forms of the adjective beautiful frame and finish the stanza just as the church itself is closed and completed in its beauty. Within these limits, though, beauty stretches beyond our comprehension; and the highest degree of beauty in Hagia Sophia transcends human understanding entirely.20 Notre Dame’s vital splendor invites Mandelstam to answer it in kind: “I too will create beauty some day.” Hagia Sophia prompts panegyric, not dialogue. Its beauty exceeds the reach of any merely human builder. “There are places where history is inescapable,” Joseph Brodsky claims in his “Flight from Byzantium” (1985). “Such is Istanbul, alias Constantinople, alias Byzantium.”21 History, though, is precisely what Mandelstam’s Hagia Sophia manages to avoid. The fifth stanza’s “wise, spherical building” will pass human history by entirely; it will “outlive nations and ages.” The God of the first stanza interferes with emperors and nations long enough at least to put them in their place. Justinian has some bond with ages to come, even if it is only to instruct them by example in the procedures of the past. The spherical church, however, seems to have no surface to which time could stick.22 It will outlast the first stanza’s nations and the second stanza’s ages. Past perfective verb forms dominate the poem’s first three stanzas—these are the completed actions that shaped the Church of Holy Wisdom. The church, once built, becomes a timeless state. Its description in the fourth stanza requires little by way of verbs. Both verbs in the final stanza are future perfective forms, perezhivet, “will outlive,” and ne pokorobit, “will not warp” (the subject of the last verb is “the resounding sobs of seraphim,” and its object is the church’s “dark gilding”). Both signify the church’s incorruptible permanence, a permanence that has no place for the present tense or for present being. Even metrically the final stanza pulls away from the rest of the poem as the church itself retreats from earthly life. The basic meter is iambic pentameter. The frequent pyrrhic substitions mean, however, that three or
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S 23
•
79
four stresses often alternate with the expected five stresses. This alternation ceases midway through the fourth stanza, though, and each of “Hagia Sophia” ’s final six lines has only three stresses. The poem’s irregular rhythms fall into place, but this rhythm is marked as much by the absence of the missing stresses as it is by the predictability of those that appear. The very pulse of the poem grows slower as it draws to a close. The poem’s final two lines hint at what the church omits by refusing to admit the present within its walls. “The resounding sobs of seraphim” that will not warp its gilding suggest several interpretations, all dealing with the different ways in which history intersects with divinity. The archangels or seraphim of the fourth stanza bear the traces of the Byzantine cathedral’s complex past, and of its true place at the center of every kind of human strife. Only two of the apse’s angels are the original mosaics. The others were recreated on the plaster that covered the church’s images for centuries as Hagia Sophia was transformed from Christian temple to Moslem mosque. The only human aspect of the angels, moreover, remains lost in the restored or recreated figures. After Constantinople’s fall to the Turks in 1453, their faces were concealed beneath golden stars, in accordance with Muslim prohibitions against figural representation. The seraphim might well weep, if they could, for their mutilation at the hands of history, which took away their human faces.24 Even before their disfigurement, though, they would have born witness to the violent changes wrought by history within the church’s walls. The Iconoclast controversy of the eight and ninth centuries led to the destruction of much of Hagia’s Sophia’s ornamentation, and the church itself, in an earlier form, had actually burned down during earlier fourth- and fifthcentury controversies on the nature of the Holy Trinity. The Vatican’s ambassadors laid down the papal bull by which the Western church finally separated from the church of the East on Hagia Sophia’s altar in 1054. The Fourth Crusade, sent by the Western church to win back the East, led to the devastation of Constantinople and to wholesale pillage within its cathedral. The people of Constantinople turned to the church for protection against the invading Turks in the fifteenth century. They congregated within the temple’s walls and were captured or slaughtered there by the invaders. Even nature worked to change the structure, which was damaged through the centuries by numerous earthquakes.25 The angels would have had reason to weep. But though the physical structure of the church may have been subject to violent transformations, the wise, spherical form that is the essence of the Eastern faith remains impervious to change, according to Mandelstam. Its essential nature resists the historical realities to which its own structure bears witness. But if the cathedral remains untarnished by age, why does Mandelstam describe the gilt that filled its mosaics and covered its domes as dark? Early witnesses celebrated the radiance that emanated from the church’s gilded walls. Its gold and precious stones transformed its structural substance “into the re-
80
•
C H A P T E R 26
T H R E E
•
flection of a higher light.” The golden walls and domes helped to transform the church into pure light, and to transport it to a world beyond our own. The gilt’s darkness, then, is not physical but metaphysical, and the angels’ tears once again suggest an interpretation. Angels—eternal, ethereal, and otherworldly—would shed tears for human suffering only if drawn into human history. The place where human history and divinity meet in the Christian faith is, of course, in the person of Christ. In Christ endless, changeless divinity takes on human form and experiences directly the sufferings of human flesh. The passion of Christ is what makes angels weep. (And one thinks here of Giotto’s Lamentation over Christ, in which angels suffer no less than Christ’s mortal followers at the sight of his lifeless form.) The passion of Christ, the “seed” of his death, gives birth to the “organism, the living body” that is for Mandelstam the Christian world (CPL, 94). It is this Christ, this fusion of timelessness with the passing moment, of divine and boundless force with the pathos of human being, that Hagia Sophia lacks. Its luster is dimmed precisely because it denies the humanity of which Christ’s church on earth is truly built.27 For Mandelstam “Byzantium represented a kind of canonical thinking that blocked out any living sense of the world, of things, of warmth and color,” his widow writes;28 and Mandelstam himself concludes in “On the Nature of the Word” that Byzantium is sterile and childless (bezdetnaia) (CPL, 120; II, 245). The church that is the emblem of this infertile culture can hardly serve as an adoptive parent to the modern orphan in search of a new legacy. Hagia Sophia’s perfect beauty inspires a beautiful poem, but the temple whose contained and fruitless loveliness the poem recreates refuses to collaborate in Mandelstam’s self-creation and creation of culture. Mandelstam indirectly addresses a dual tradition, both Byzantine and Russian, by way of Justinian and his church. Russia’s religion and culture were of course descended from the Byzantine East. Indeed, after Byzantium’s fall the Russian church claimed to be its sole legitimate heir, and Moscow was to take the Eastern capital’s place as the third and final Rome. The name Sophia itself had a more immediate resonance for the reluctant scion of Symbolist fathers. The philosopher Vladimir Soloviev’s Sophia, the “World Soul,” “eternal womanhood,” became the elusive, otherworldly muse to a generation of Russian Symbolists. Soloviev’s vision of world history was complex, and his attitudes toward Russian orthodoxy were far from uncritical. Nonetheless, Soloviev’s Sophia, like Justinian’s, moves toward the dematerialization and transcendency that is the aim of the Byzantine temple. The “World Soul,” fallen matter, and fallen humanity will be redeemed, Soloviev proclaims, at history’s end when they are finally, fully infused with light and spirit, when they are reunited with God’s high and holy being.29 Mandelstam rejects this legacy of transcendence, whether Byzantine, Russian Orthodox, or Symbolist, in turning from Hagia Sophia to the wel-
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
81
coming vaults of Notre Dame. Soloviev’s apocalyptic vision of “All-Unity,” of a universal community that would ultimately heal not only the schisms on earth but the rift between heaven and earth, was rooted in the nineteenth-century, Slavophile concept of sobornost’ (its root is the same sobor that means both “cathedral” and “assembly”). Sobornost’ signified to the Slavophiles a free community of true believers, whose roots lay not in a West riven by individualism, but in untainted, Orthodox, pre-Petrine Rus’.30 Mandelstam aspires to a very different kind of sobornost’. His church is brought to life by the fruitful strife between individual and communal vision. It is to be found not in the static, otherworldly East, but in the energetic Catholic West, and it looks not to the past or future alone, but to the moment when past and present intersect in giving birth to the future.
THE MOTHER CHURCH Verily, the man who once piled his thoughts to the sky in these stones— he, like the wisest, knew the secret of all life. That struggle and inequality are present even in beauty, and also war for power and more power. . . . How divinely vault and arches break through each other in a wrestling match; how they strive against each other with light and shade. —Friedrich Nietzsche, Thus Spoke Zarathustra (1883–92)
The church that embodies Western energies for Mandelstam is Notre Dame. The poem that recreates the church begins, like “Hagia Sophia,” in foreignness. Its title is borrowed from another culture and another speech, and the Latin letters that head a Russian text seem themselves to enact the confrontation of Rome and a “foreign nation” that the poem’s first line describes. In “Notre Dame,” however, foreignness serves very different ends than it does in Mandelstam’s aloof and otherworldly Hagia Sophia. Though the title’s letters are strange, the words they spell in a foreign tongue are welcoming as well as alien: Notre Dame is Our Lady. The inclusive possessive pronoun provides Mandelstam with an immediate point of entry into the church and its history. The cathedral’s name may be French, but the church it represents, the “mother church,” is apparently willing to adopt all comers. This particular embodiment of the mother church, moreover, is dedicated to the essence of maternity, to Mary, the Mother of God. Hagia Sophia is “holy,” and her church points beyond matter to pure spirit, but Notre Dame is “ours,” and the lady the church celebrates is the vessel through which spirit descended to matter, through which divinity first came to earth and was made flesh. The poem proper opens, again like “Hagia Sophia,” with a judgment, and the judgment that leads to the building of Notre Dame is doubly stressed: “Where a Roman judge had judged (sud’ia sud il) a foreign nation” (my italics). This emphasis seems to weight the phrase in the judge’s
82
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
favor—but the judgment that begins “Notre Dame” is very different from the one that puts a stop to history in “Hagia Sophia.” The Roman laws that rule a foreign nation do not descend from above. They are human laws and govern the relations between the nations of the earth, not between divinities and humans. As such they are subject to historical transformation, the kind of transformation that gives birth to Notre Dame itself, the offspring of imperial Rome and her distant province France. Peter Steiner argues convincingly for the “Roman judge” as architect, shaping through his laws the foreign nation’s formless mass, but this nation is far from being the wholly negative force that Steiner sees.31 The uneasy alliance between containing form and raw, unshaped vitality that operates here is akin to the forces at work in “François Villon,” and in the body of the cathedral itself. Mandelstam also reminds us that the classical heritage of the ancient world was by necessity transfigured as it was transmitted through time and space. He reminds us too that the venerable culture of France and Europe alike began in barbarism, and that “Europe, the new Hellas” (#70) is itself a hybrid.32 This past, unlike that of “Hagia Sophia,” continues into the present, just as the history of the first line feeds directly into the second line’s present tense, into the present being of the church that stands where Rome and France had first crossed paths: past and present, history and firstness come together in the body of the church. Mandelstam calls the building a “basilica,” a Greek word used to designate a secular Roman structure that was later transformed to serve the needs of the newly emerged Christian church. “The Gothic cathedral,” William Fleming observes, “was the culmination in the long process of reconciling the northern urge for verticality with the southern horizontal basilica form.”33 Notre Dame’s basilica, with its “bold vault,” synthesizes the history of North and South, of northern loftiness and southern breadth within its walls. The structure, like the word that describes it, is born of a tradition that works through transformation. It stands for both the continuation and the transfiguration of cultures through history. The intersection of Roman civilization and an untamed foreign nation marks a kind of newness or originality within history. History itself meets with a newness that lies beyond its limits in the lines that follow. The Acmeist history that reaches its peak in Notre Dame’s “groined arch” dissolves into Adamist firstness as the arch, “joyful and first,” and by extension, the church it supports, are transubstantiated to become metaphorically Adam’s body, the body that both precedes and initiates human history.34 Adam does not undo Akme, though; a creative, unstable relationship is established within the stanza between history and “firstness.” The church as human structure is rooted in human history. Its basilica and its arch are the work of architects whose originality is bound by time and place. The church as body, which “plays with its muscles” and “spreads out its nerves,” is, however, the work of God’s first and boundless originality.
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
83
Notre Dame is both the body that is the mysterious gift of “I’ve been given a body” and the body that human beings have used to begin their building. These couplings of civilization and foreignness, history and firstness suggest that Mandelstam is clearing a place for his own alien and unexpected presence within the walls of a church capable of holding both tradition and absolute newness.35 Indeed, Mandelstam’s own foreign body is, one suspects, the catalyst that generates Notre Dame’s Adamic newness. The cathedral’s “body” in fact takes on a familial resemblance to the “bisexual being (dvupoloe sushchestvo)” that is the lyric poet in “François Villon” (CPL, 56; II, 305). Notre Dame, Clarence Brown remarks, is anagrammatically transformed into Adam in the poem’s opening stanza, and the two words even rhyme in Russian.36 The female body that gave birth to Christ, the Second Adam, and the first, male body from which woman herself was born come together under the same roof. Villon’s “hermaphroditic” nature renders him endlessly fruitful and incomplete. Notre Dame as Adam is likewise mobile and growing. It stretches its nerves to uncover or expand their limits; it plays with its muscles and tests the strength of its new form. Such energy and incompletion actually characterize Gothic building as much as they do Adam’s, or the poet’s, body. “What’s the point in rebuilding Notre Dame?” Mayakovsky asks in his irreverent portrait of the French cathedral (“Notre Dame,” 1925). The point, Mandelstam might say, is that the church was never finished to begin with. “There are no finished Gothic cathedrals,” William Fleming explains. The spectator must collaborate with the architects to create a (provisional) whole: “Completion can take place only in the imagination of the observer.”37 In another early lyric, Mandelstam celebrates a cathedral that is “incomplete, but beautiful just the same” (#181). His Notre Dame is beautiful precisely because it is incomplete. Its unfinished form invites, indeed requires Mandelstam’s participation if it is to be completed. He finds an aperture in a space that is structured yet open, a space that holds both history and its opposite. The single stone finally enters “the ‘groined arch”’ of the Gothic church where it at last “participate[s] in the joyous cooperative action of those like it” (CPL, 62). Notre Dame as Gothic church is incomplete. Notre Dame as body is also by definition unfinished. The human body “makes itself or it unmakes itself, but it is never something made,” in Henri Bergson’s phrase;38 and the monstrous form of “Notre Dame,” the human body, both male and female, made large, would presumably possess even greater capacities for growth than would the bisexual being it resembles and dwarfs, the lyric poet of “François Villon.” The problem of “François Villon”—how to inhibit the poet’s energy and fecundity without destroying them—resurfaces here, this time on a giant’s scale. How can the play of Notre Dame the monstrous body be kept from shattering the crafted structure Notre Dame? Villon is built of dualities, and the network of dialogues between the selves within him and between those selves and the society that sur-
84
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
rounds him becomes a supple system of checks and balances that curbs, but does not curtail, his growth. The system that sustains Notre Dame is likewise based on the dual natures both of the cathedral itself and of the observer who builds it anew in words. The shift from inside to out that marks the movement from the first to the second stanza suggests the types of “double being” that are open to the church and its observer. The poem’s Notre Dame is both body and building, both divine and human in its origins. It is a product of human history and of the creation that precedes and transcends that history. The historical structure of the first line is infected midway through the second line by the body’s primal vitality, by the Notre Dame that Mandelstam calls elsewhere a “festival of physiology,” a “Dionysian orgy” (CPL, 63).39 This festival threatens literally to raise the roof off Notre Dame, to lift its light vault right off the church, to disrupt the already unstable balance of body and building at work in the first stanza. The poet as spectator and participant in this festival staves off catastrophe by exploiting his capacity for motion. He draws on Villon’s lessons in the art of crossing boundaries as he moves from the church’s interior, where he had watched its muscles and nerves at play, and joins forces with the architectural constructs that labor to contain this giant’s motion. Mandelstam brings his own dual nature to bear in his movement from inside to out. As human body, he is akin to Notre Dame’s monstrous Adam. As the stone that finds its home in its “groined arch,” he is part of its substance. But Mandelstam has learned from Villon to manipulate even those boundaries that seem to shape his very self. He has learned to organize his organism by standing just a little beyond its bounds: the poet is himself both creature and creator, gardener and flower, architect and stone. The architect of his own physical being, he is free to participate in the building of Notre Dame’s body. Unlike Justinian’s fixed, impermeable temple, the Gothic cathedral as building and body lends itself to just such an exchange between the inner world it contains and the outer world that contains it. Gothic architecture, as Fleming describes it, sought to bridge the gap between spirit and matter, between the Word and the world. The vast windows of its cathedrals rendered the barrier between these realms of being transparent and permeable. The Gothic church also worked to heal the rift between mind and faith. It appealed to reason by openly displaying the means by which its seeming miracles of soaring space were achieved. Each upward thrust of its lofty vaults was answered by the counterthrust of the piers and buttresses that circled the church’s outer walls, and this architectural pro and contra could be followed by the worshiper entering the church.40 In his study of François Rabelais, Mikhail Bakhtin describes the “grotesque body” of medieval and Renaissance folk culture in terms that echo Fleming’s portrait of the Gothic church and call to mind the monstrous body of Mandelstam’s Notre Dame. Bakhtin himself, I should add, would
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
85
have been the last to see the resemblance. His Gothic church, rigid, fixed, and humorless, invariably plays straight man to the antics of the body it opposes, while for Mandelstam, medieval culture takes life precisely from the creative strife between the body and the church that dwell for him quite literally under one roof. There are, nonetheless, strong family resemblances between these outsized bodies. Bakhtin’s “grotesque body” is, like the Gothic cathedral, unfinished by nature. It is “a body in the act of becoming. It is never finished, never completed; it is continually built, created.” Like the Gothic church, it is defined by its very lack of definition, by the play of inside and out that keeps its outlines from becoming clear-cut and fixed. The boundaries that divide this body from the world are obscured: “Its exterior aspect is not distinct from the inside” and the “exchange between [this] body and the world” is crucial and continuous.41 The world in which the “grotesque body” finds its home is for Bakhtin the world of carnival. In the carnival all hierarchies are turned topsy-turvy, “inside out and upside down,” as the “grotesque body” is given leave to follow its own propensities.42 It is free to upset the structures—social, political, linguistic, ecclesiastic—that threaten to limit its open-ended being. For all his love of the Gothic “festival of physiology,” however, Mandelstam turns his church inside out to very different ends in the poem’s second stanza. The church that is an open book, or more precisely, an open body on the inside, keeps its secrets outside, where they would seem to be in plain view: “But a secret plan is betrayed from without.” The open secret and the line’s conspiratorial tone raise a question—from whom is this architectural plot being kept? The answer would seem to be that structural secrets are being withheld from the church itself, or rather, from its interior, from the body that rises within its walls and threatens to overwhelm them. Mandelstam’s plotting, his partial inversion of inside and out, aims neither at completing the “carnivalization” of Notre Dame nor at thwarting it completely. Instead, he works to orchestrate an uneasy, even antagonistic relationship between the cathedral’s dualities. His goal is neither war nor peace, but the sort of unresolved, fruitful standoff between opposing forces that led to the building of Notre Dame in the first place. His “secret plan” counterbalances the “battering ram” that the vault, which had been Adam, has now become.43 Mandelstam’s architect’s tools—for the Acmeist, “worldview” becomes a “tool and an instrument, like a hammer in the hands of a stonemason”(“The Morning of Acmeism,” CPL, 61–62)—are busy crafting material that contains within itself the means for its own destruction. A battering ram’s sole purpose, after all, is to undo building, to reduce structure to rubble. The church is thus built on the instrument, at least potentially, of its own downfall. And if the Gothic cathedral depends on its viewers for completion, if it is being built continually in the eyes of its beholders, then it is also, by extension, undone each time they turn away. It is a perfect vessel
86
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
for the Acmeist vision of the past. The Acmeists rely on and are justified by the history whose apex they claim to be. As Adamists, however, they lay claim to absolute newness and originality. True Acmeists climb only those towers that they themselves have built; to scale Acmeist heights, though, they must, as Adamists, dismantle and rebuild the monuments of the past as they climb. The potential for catastrophe is built into such a task, and the constant presence of catastrophe momentarily kept in check serves as the stimulus that propels continued creation. The “modest exterior” of a true poem, Mandelstam warns in “The Morning of Acmeism,” conceals a “monstrously condensed reality”; and such artworks, needless to say, are highly combustible and fraught with danger (CPL, 61). The stanza’s final two lines reveal that catastrophe is at best a breath away from Mandelstam’s Notre Dame. Only one syllable keeps the weight of the church as matter from “crushing” its walls (ne sokrushila, literally “[would] not crush”; my italics). Only one syllable restrains the upward motion of its vault (bezdeistvuet, literally “is inactive”; my italics). The forces of catastrophe are forestalled, but their continued power is evident even in the phrases that mark their—temporary—defeat.44 Gothic architecture’s “resilient equilibrium of weights and balances” is an uneasy counterbalancing of opposites: “If any part should give way, the entire structure would be endangered.”45 Perhaps Mandelstam, who is both material and architect, inside and out, the viewer on whom the structure depends and a stone at home in its groined vault, is himself the unreliable part that endangers the integrity of Notre Dame’s structure. Through his movements and shifting identities, he has courted disaster so that he might participate in forestalling it. “Poetic culture,” Mandelstam announces in an essay of 1922, “arises from the attempt to avert catastrophe” (CPL, 137). The catastrophe that Mandelstam activates and contains in Notre Dame allows him in the third stanza to reenter the church and to find in it an even grander and more capacious vessel than it had been before. It becomes a receptacle capable of holding his most ambitious visions of culture. The vital, but unstable, intersections of opposites that animate Notre Dame in the poem’s first stanza join together to form the “living equilibrium” that was for Mandelstam the medieval world’s essence (CPL, 65). The pairs that populate François Villon reflect his nation and his age; they echo the structure of the medieval world that surrounds him. Mandelstam’s renewed Notre Dame, with its more complex, expansive couplings, reflects not just the medieval world but the world of all times and the world beyond time. History and the abyss, nature and culture, spirit and matter, Christian and pagan, victim and oppressor, strength and weakness, reason and belief: the forces interlocked within Notre Dame’s newly reinforced walls suggest in their richness and scope the workings of the cosmos itself. At the same time, this cosmos bears the stamp of a particular, personal universe conquered and contained. The rebuilt Notre Dame holds em-
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
87
blems of the struggles that shape the early poetry of Stone. “[Mandelstam] loves buildings,” Gumilev writes in his review of Stone, “the same way that other poets love mountains and seas.”46 Indeed, Mandelstam’s buildings contain mountains and seas, the forces of nature that other poets might celebrate more directly. The nature held in Notre Dame is, however, a very specific one. It is the same nature in which Mandelstam himself had earlier been contained, the nature he longs for and fears in the early verse. The cathedral’s “elemental labyrinth,” its “inscrutable forest” are akin to the ominous, labyrinthine forests in which the young poet of Stone wanders, uneasy and alone. Elsewhere Mandelstam finds in Gothic building a force to match the boundless energy of the sea, the energy he covets in the early poetry: “Which is more mobile, which is more fluid—a Gothic cathedral or the ocean surge,” he asks in “François Villon” (CPL, 59). And in “Humanism and the Present”(1923), Gothic society is “a complex and dense architectural forest” (CPL, 181). Both the forest and the sea threaten to overwhelm the frail self of the early poems, and this self withstands their primal force only by withdrawing from their vitality. In this stanza, though, the reed that represents a weak and wavering self in earlier lyrics stands beside the oak, an emblem of might and thus apparently the feeble reed’s antithesis. In this new construct, however, it is the equal of the forest’s most powerful tree, and their proximity does not endanger the distinct identity of either. They are united by a structure that yokes together differences and makes of them a strength, a structure that derives its vitality precisely from the volatile, incongruous combinations of which it is made.47 The quest to span the seemingly insuperable distance between absolute differences is the essence of Gothic art, which strove “to bridge the impossible gap between matter and spirit, mass and void, natural and supernatural, inspiration and aspiration, the finite and the infinite.”48 It is an art made to order for the young poet of Stone, suspended between opposing worlds, contradictory desires and fears, and equally contradictory images of the self that fears and desires. This art does not require him to replace one world, one self with another. It provides him instead with the means to forge “mobile chains of being” between worlds and selves without denying their differences. The “emperor” (tsar’) that governs the intricate network of the third stanza’s Notre Dame is not a person, divinity, or principle. It is the plumbline, the instrument that makes architectural creation possible. It is a mobile tool; its reign can be extended everywhere; and like Peter the Great’s “ruler,” the yardstick his descendants inherit in the Admiralty’s spire, it is available, one assumes, to all times as well. This “emperor”—accessible, flexible, and designed to extend the powers of its subjects—is the antithesis of the rigid chain of command that keeps “Hagia Sophia” ’s stern hierarchy in place. Nonetheless the plumbline provides fixed measure; it remains unchanged whenever or whereever it is used. With it, human beings can gauge distances and depths and judge how best to bridge them. With it,
88
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
those “rational” mystics, medieval builders, can take on the abyss that threatens them. They can measure the distance they have fallen and use that knowledge to fight their way upward again. This plumbline offers moral guidance as well. In the Old Testament the plumbline becomes a symbolic means of gauging relations between heaven and earth, God and humanity.49 The plumbline as biblical metaphor spans the distance between spirit and matter. It is thus a fitting ruler, in more ways than one, for a church that stands as testament to the medieval builders who used reason’s tools to fathom mysteries seemingly beyond the reach of reason. Perhaps the plumbline that mediates between God and humanity can likewise be used to trace the relation between God’s creation and the creations of his creatures. Or even to collapse the space between them, to overcome the distance that divides divine and human being, and divine and human making. For God’s building and humanity’s ultimately converge in “Notre Dame” ’s third stanza. The Gothic architect, says Mandelstam, built his church on the model of the body. The Gothic cathedral is “the logical development of the concept of the organism” (CPL, 63); and the medieval notion of organism seems to possess in embryo the vast capacities for containment that reach their peak in Notre Dame. Villon’s intricate organism had hinted at the body’s apparently limitless potential as a vessel for shaping the networks of human history and culture. This potential is realized in Notre Dame’s monstrous, built body, which metonymically holds all Judeo-Christian history within its walls. It is Adam, humanity’s first beginnings, and also the mother of God, whose son, the Second Adam, is the race’s final salvation. It holds “Egyptian might,” which evokes the Old Testament oppressions of the Chosen People, and “Christian modesty,” the meekness and suffering through which these oppressions were redeemed. Its basilica is a classical inheritance transfigured through Christianity, and with its “Gothic soul” it enters European history. The “dark organism” of “The Morning of Acmeism” shares Notre Dame’s capacity for containing nature, if on a smaller scale. Its “divine physiology” is itself a “forest” (CPL, 63). As in “Notre Dame,” the nightmare landscape of the early verse is mastered by being turned inward, and this inner forest becomes fresher, “denser,” “more virgin” than the forests of the outside world (CPL, 63). The human body makes nature natural again; it restores nature’s true nature to it. The “grotesque body,” Bakhtin writes, “is the cosmos’ own flesh and blood, possessing the same elemental force, but better organized. [It] is the last and best word of the cosmos.”50 Notre Dame is divine physiology developed by humanity to its highest degree. It amplifies and unites within itself the twin capacities of the human form; it contains both nature and culture, for it is itself the height of nature and culture. It is Adam, God’s annointed master of his newly created nature, and Akme, the summit of all endeavor in human history since the Fall. In Notre Dame, the contours of the body given from above seem to over-
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
89
lap with, indeed to become, the contours of the “God-given palace” that is the world itself (CPL, 63). In this vastest, most cataclysmic of inversions, the church becomes the vessel for the universe that holds it. Bakhtin’s “grotesque body” aims, like Mandelstam’s Notre Dame, to restore “the human place in the universe” by taking the universe inside itself. This body is born of humanity’s awareness of the “cosmic elements within [ourselves],” just as Notre Dame grows from medieval humanity’s recognition of the mystery of its physical being. For both Mandelstam and Bakhtin, the human being at odds with his or her physical self is subject to fear of “the starry sky, the gigantic material masses of the mountains, the sea,” of “cosmic upheavals” and “elemental catastrophes.” Yet the human body provides a bond that unites all people in the battle against the forces that threaten human being as such. This colossus, whether Bakhtin’s “cosmic body” or Mandelstam’s Notre Dame, assumes the form of the forces humanity fears, and turns their power to human ends. It absorbs “mountains, rivers, seas, islands, and continents,” Bakhtin writes. “[It] can fill the entire universe.”51 The task that Bakhtin’s “grotesque body” must accomplish, vast as it is, is ultimately less daunting than the demands Mandelstam makes of his Notre Dame, which must master culture as well as nature and bring them together under one roof. According to Bakhtin, the “grotesque body” was medieval folk culture’s chief weapon directed against the oppressive, ossified hierarchy of the medieval church. This ever-unfinished body draws its strength from nature’s cycles of renewal and change and opposes “official medieval culture,” a “monolith of the Christian cult and ideology” determined to keep this giant’s body, which is the body of the people itself, in its place. “Official culture” seeks to impose the forms of the past on the growing, changing present, while “folk culture,” the culture of the body, looks to the future that will undo and renew both past and present.52 Official medieval culture and medieval folk culture are, in other words, worlds apart. “One might say,” Bakhtin writes, “that [folk culture] builds . . . its own church versus the official church, its own state versus the official state.” For Mandelstam, however, the Middle Ages are “physiologically brilliant” precisely in their interweaving of “Gothic stability and morality” with the body’s dynamics; and medieval culture, high and low, grows from this mixture of moral force and physical vitality (CPL, 59). It is not my task to determine which Middle Ages are more accurate, Bakhtin’s or Mandelstam’s; I suspect that both visions are made up of more or less equal parts of history and myth. Mandelstam’s version of medieval is more complex and finally more challenging, though, than the rigid, if suggestive, binary opposition Bakhtin creates between an oppressive church and the endlessly playful “folk” who work to subvert it. The church as structure in a literal, physical sense is the heart of Mandelstam’s Middle Ages, and its shape and substance are taken from the human form to which, according to Bakhtin, it should be irreconcilably opposed. Mandelstam’s
90
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
monstrous church draws on the resources both of the “organism,” the body as such, and of “organization,” the uses to which this body has been put in the past, the structures it has helped to build in human history.53 Like Bakhtin’s “grotesque body,” Notre Dame aims to give the world a human sense by bringing it within the human form. But Notre Dame and its makers also aim to complete the human shaping of the world through building, through human endeavor, human culture. Just as the word organization (organizatsiia) grows from organism (organizm)—and both stem from the Greek word meaning “implement” or “tool” as well as “bodily organ”—building is rooted in the body. Human structures derive from “divine physiology,” from God-the-architect’s initial shaping of the human form itself. Fallen humanity may no longer be master in the universe conceived for its use—but it can employ the model of its own divinely inspired form to reclaim its place in the cosmos. Building becomes a way to extend the realm of the body throughout the world, and upward into the skies as well, for it is also, as Mandelstam’s towers and spires declare, a way to challenge the breach opened by Adam’s fall: “The handsome arrow of the Gothic belltower rages because its function is to stab the sky, to reproach it for its emptiness” (CPL, 63). “In Canto XXVI of the Paradiso, Dante goes so far as to have a private conversation with Adam,” with “St. John the Divine, the author of the Apocalypse” acting as Dante’s chief assistant, Mandelstam writes in “Conversation about Dante”(CPL, 422). This interview, “the alpha and omega of all scripture,” in Dante’s phrase, unites the beginning and end both of the Bible and of world history itself; biblical history’s Adam and Akme, its beginnings in Genesis and culmination in the Apocalypse, are conjoined.54 Mandelstam arranges a similar interview in “Notre Dame.” Notre Dame’s walls enclose the whole of Christian history, from Adam to Christ’s birth (the church, after all, is named for his mother) and beyond. The walls themselves grow from the body of both the first Adam and the second, Christ, who was sent to redeem Adam’s fall, and whose body on earth is the Christian church. Christ, who is both building and body, whose “temple of the body” “filleth all in all” (John 2:21; Eph. 1:23), is Mandelstam’s model for the body that frees humanity from its fear of non-being, as it humanizes, or “Hellenizes,” death itself (CPL, 94). The historical task of the Christian artist, Mandelstam declares, is to reenact “the single creative act that began our historical era,” the “redemption of the world by Christ” (CPL, 91). In “Here the Eucharist, like a golden sun,” the priest who recreates Christ’s passion and resurrection can “take the world into [his] hands like a simple apple” (1920; #117). The Christian artist’s imitation of Christ offers similar possibilities. In “Notre Dame,” Mandelstam uses his art not only to imitate Christ’s first creative act but to anticipate the creative act that will end the Christian era, according to biblical prophecy. This is Christ’s final redemption of the world, the Apocalypse, when beginnings and endings will meet; the fallen world and fallen humanity will be restored at last; and Christ’s body, the body of the
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
91
church, will finally triumph as the Christian world becomes the world as such. In his Anatomy of Criticism (1957), Northrop Frye describes the Apocalypse as “the imaginative conception of the whole of nature as the content of an infinite and eternal living body.” In the apocalyptic world-as-body, “nature becomes not the container, but the thing contained,” and the forms “imposed by human work [and] human civilization . . . are no longer the desirable forms that man constructs inside nature, but are themselves the forms of nature” and of “a human universe.” Christ, who unites in himself divine and human, nature and culture, is the medium through which these cosmic transformations are achieved. He is “both the one God and the one Man, the Lamb of God, the tree of life, or vine of which we are the branches, the stone which the builders rejected, and the rebuilt temple, which is identical with his risen body”; and we exist in this body “as in a city or temple.”55 We recognize in this description of the apocalypse the contours of Mandelstam’s Notre Dame, built in imitation of Christ’s allencompassing creative act. Itself both natural and cultural, it can absorb both nature and culture, and it transforms and humanizes nature through culture. Notre Dame arises not only from the drama of its nation’s past and of the age in which it itself was built. It is also a protagonist, a monstrous everyman in the cosmic drama of the struggle to make the world human again. It also represents Mandelstam’s attempt to use the struggles of the early verse to shape the larger context—social, historical, even cosmic—he requires. As manifesto, as Adam and Akme, “Notre Dame” ties him to his own age and nation by way of the Acmeists, whose fight for being, poetic and otherwise, he shares. Through his affinity with the medieval age that produced Villon and Notre Dame, Mandelstam lays claim to other nations and ages; and by declaring his kinship with France’s distant past, he inherits the French tradition that is descended from that past. He can become part of Christendom merely by stepping beneath Notre Dame’s vaults, and his mobility ensures that he can enter and exit this tradition as easily as he steps in and out of the church itself. For all their historical specificity, the Acmeists, medieval humanity, and Christianity are akin on a cosmic scale in Mandelstam’s vision. They are united by their shared quest to shape a place for human life in the inhospitable universe they work to domesticate. Mandelstam’s name for this struggle to assert “the human place in the universe” is Hellenization, and the name itself transforms a historically specific place and time, Hellas, ancient Greece, into a process, Hellenization, and a principle, Hellenism, that are accessible to anyone who seeks to master a hostile cosmos.56 Such Hellenization is the chief task facing the Acmeists themselves, as Mandelstam describes it in “On the Nature of the Word”; within the disembodied universe bequeathed them by their Symbolist parents, “the master was chased out of his own house and no longer dared to enter” (CPL, 129). In reacting against the Symbolists, the Acmeists must reenact the Fall and res-
92
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
toration of humankind, or so Mandelstam’s scenario implies; and the Hellenistic system they employ in recovering the cosmos is very like Frye’s apocalypse. Hellenism, Mandelstam explains, is “the transformation of impersonal objects into domestic utensils, and the humanizing and warming of the surrounding world with the most delicate teleological warmth”; in a Hellenized world, all things are “subjected through the human ‘I’ to an inner connection” (CPL, 127–28). Both Frye’s apocalypse and Mandelstam’s Hellenism reclaim the world for human being, and the human home becomes identical with the “God-given palace” that is the world itself. There is, however, a crucial difference between the two. Frye’s apocalypse concludes human history, as time comes to a close in paradise regained. Time in Mandelstam’s Hellenized cosmos, on the other hand, is simply suspended; it is held in check until human history, or poetically induced catastrophe, intrudes to disrupt its precarious structure once again. This is the tenuous, temporary apocalypse at work in “Notre Dame.” The vital equilibrium achieved in the third stanza is paradoxically timeless and changeless; its “intricate network” is sustained entirely without verbs. Time, whose transforming presence makes itself felt in the many active verb forms of the earlier stanzas, is marked here only by its absence. Notre Dame can contain the cosmos, it would seem, only in an interval that stands outside of time; it holds all human history in a moment that lies beyond history’s reach. Time, history, and humanity intrude once more in the poem’s final stanza in the shape of the poet himself. He inserts human time into the body of the church by using his immediate past, his study of the cathedral as body and structure—the fourth stanza’s “ribs (rebry)” refer to architectural terminology as well as to the body57—to propel the church into an open-ended future still remaining to be built. The poem begins in an unresolved past, in a history driven by conflict and conquest, and this past refuses to remain past; it feeds into the present that it continues to shape. “Notre Dame” ends with an equally unsettling leap into the future: “I too will create beauty some day,” Mandelstam tells the church defiantly. As he had in the second stanza, he opposes the very structure whose energies he celebrates, and in each case he registers his opposition with the conjunction but (no), which opens both the second and the fourth stanzas. The war between building and battering ram that had threatened to erupt earlier seems to reignite as Notre Dame itself becomes a stronghold, a fortress (tverdynia). This time, however, the sides are reversed, as Mandelstam, that “double-dealer with a double soul” (#136), turns on the structure he had earlier worked to reinforce. In the second stanza he stands outside to sympathize with the walls that resist the giant’s might of that battering ram, Adam’s body. In the final stanza, though, he threatens to disrupt the hard-earned balance he had himself helped to create, as he takes the place of the forces he sought to suppress. He is inside the church, studying its ribs, apparently held captive by what has become an all-toosolid structure; and his “secret plan” now is presumably designed to free
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
93
him from its confines. The Acmeist, though, is subtler than the monstrous Adam of the earlier stanzas. He uses Acmeist reason, Acmeist logic and craft to draw his weapons from the very structure he opposes—hence his intensive, attentive study of its shape. But why should Mandelstam turn on the church that embodies his humanized, Hellenized cosmos? Why should he create his own beauty when in his Notre Dame he seems to find precisely the kind of vital, fully human loveliness that Hagia Sophia lacks? Why would he disrupt the structure he had worked so hard to construct? Mandelstam’s vision of architecture relies as much on unbuilding or rebuilding as on building proper, and his poetic culture arises only in the face of a catastrophe that is narrowly averted and, if necessary, artificially induced. A catastrophe that has been completely contained, forestalled once and for all, cannot give birth to true poetic culture, for the vessel that holds catastrophe completely, or holds it off completely, has itself become whole and complete and is thus impervious to change and new creation. Such a vessel stands, like Hagia Sophia, beyond the reach of human influence. Perhaps this is why Mandelstam calls Notre Dame by name only in the last stanza, for only here does it threaten to become a finished structure that can be finalized by the name that history has given it. “You cannot Hellenize the world once and for all the way you can paint a house,” Mandelstam warns in “Pushkin and Skriabin” (CPL, 94), and his words are both a statement of fact and a command: the Russian nel’zia (one cannot) can signify either impossibility or prohibition. “In art there are no finished things,” Mandelstam insists in “Conversation about Dante,” and the artist’s task is to “destroy the integrity (tselostnost’)” of everything ready-made, even if he or she has helped to create it (CPL, 415– 16; II, 384–85): “Poetic speech creates its instruments on the move and annihilates them likewise on the move” (CPL, 433). Two decades divide Mandelstam’s “Notre Dame” from his Dante; we can trace nonetheless in the 1912 poem the same pro and contra that shapes Mandelstam’s late vision of tradition. Culture evolves, “Notre Dame” suggests, through a chain of unlikely creative coalitions among elements whose positions shift and twist to form equally unlikely oppositions. There is no final synthesis: “But only once a year does duration overflow/In nature as it does in Homer’s metrics” (#62). Culture and nature coincide only fleetingly. The world is Hellenized only at moments. And this is as it should be. For only in such a world, forever awaiting fresh Hellenization, is the artist necessary at all. In “Pushkin and Skriabin” Mandelstam labors to define the role of the artist in a world that has already witnessed the ultimate creative act in Christ’s redemption of the world (CPL, 91). “What remains?” Mandelstam asks, and the weight of the past is not entirely put to rest by an answer in which “repetition” and “imitation” coexist uneasily with “freedom,” “unfading freshness,” and “personality” (CPL, 91–93). “I am all wholeness (tsel’nost’), I am all personality, I
94
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
am all indivisible unity,” Mandelstam’s Christian world announces in the essay (CPL, 93; II, 316). In “Notre Dame,” however, Mandelstam’s own personality emerges only in challenge to whatever claims the church might make for such all-encompassing wholeness. His “I” emerges only once he finds a way to displace a past made absolute, to shift its weight and thus clear a space for himself and his own creation. In Stone’s early lyrics Mandelstam is born into a world that surrounds him, precedes him, and does not need him, a world both ominously empty and overwhelmingly full. In “Notre Dame,” he and his medieval collaborators have succeeded all too well in their conspiracy against the world’s emptiness. Mandelstam has worked with the past to create a monster, a monument that comes dangerously close to all-encompassing perfection. A church that can hold the cosmos, a tverdynia (fortress) that contains the tverd’—the word signifies both sky and earth, and its root, meaning “hard” or “firm,” unites it with tverdynia—can easily devour one small poet. Such a construct hardly requires his further services in any case. “Man must be the hardest thing on earth (tverzhe vsego na zemle),” Mandelstam proclaims in “On the Nature of the Word” (CPL, 132; II, 258). He must become “harder” (tverzhe) than the “fortress” (tverdynja) that he himself has made. The stone finds itself between a rock and a very hard place, and the creature must again be made to serve its maker. This universal, literally catholic church, shaped from and containing a vast web of histories, nations, and traditions, is an early architectural emblem of the world culture that lay at the heart of the Acmeist endeavor. “Culture has become the church,” Mandelstam announces in “The Word and Culture” (CPL, 112)—but in “Notre Dame” the church has become culture. The final stanza thus becomes a battleground between individual talent and the tradition, between the poet and a cultural past that appears to require no further additions. The poet of “Notre Dame” is clearly ill at ease with the past whose present vast contours he has helped to create. In the final stanza, his “I” surfaces three times in the space of as many lines, and his overinsistence seems designed both to compensate for this “I”’s conspicuous absence elsewhere in the poem and to compete with the massive form in whose shadow he stands. Overpowered by Notre Dame, he must protest too much in order to be heard at all. This “I,” for all its assertiveness, appears to stake its claims for existence on something that does not yet exist itself. “I too will create beauty some day,” he claims—but the contribution to world culture that will be “so single, so his own” remains to be seen. The ambitious poet of “Notre Dame” ’s final stanza is still a diligent pupil who has not finished his study of the structure with which he hopes one day to compete. He is apparently reluctant to make good his boast, to take the final, fearful leap into his own creation. Until the day comes when his lessons finally bear fruit, his existence must rest on assertion alone.
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
95
The first edition of Stone closed with this stanza, with Mandelstam poised on the brink between past and future creation. But the contest between tradition and the individual talent was not, of course, resolved “once and for all” in the poems that followed in later editions. The 1916 version of Stone also ends with this struggle, and it, too, is open-ended. The true subject of the second Stone’s final poem, “I will not see the famous Phèdre”(1915; #81), is Mandelstam’s attempt to convert past culture into present experience and present power, as he attempts to circumvent the “mighty curtain” that bars him from a longed-for past: “I came too late for the festival of Racine,” he laments. The closing line of the poem and of the collection is not only grammatically conditional, and thus counter to reality by definition; it is also literally incomplete: “If a Greek could see our games . . . (Kogda by Grek uvidel nashi igry . . . )” The meeting of neoclassical France, modern Russia, and ancient Greece the line anticipates can only be imagined in a space that remains conspicuously empty. Mandelstam articulates his ideally liberating version of tradition and creation most clearly in “I have not heard the tales of Ossian” (1914; #67): Q ne slyxal rasskazov Ossiana, Ne proboval starinnogo vinaó Zahem 'e mne mere]itsq polqna, Wotlandii krovavaq luna? I pereklihka vorona i arfy Mne huditsq v zlove]ej tiwine, I vetrom razvevaemye warfy Dru'innikov mel;ka[t pri lune! Q poluhil bla'ennoe nasledstvoó Hu'ix pevcov blu'da[]ie sny, Svoe rodstvo i skuhnoe sosedstvo My prezirat; zavedomo vol;ny. I ne odno sokrovi]e, byt; mo'et, Minuq vnukov, k pravnukam ujdet, I snova skal;d hu'u[ pesn[ slo'it I kak svo[ ee proizneset. I have not heard the tales of Ossian, I have not tasted of that ancient wine— Why, then, do I seem to see that glade, And Scotland’s bloody moon? And harp and raven calling to and fro Sound for me in ill-omened silence, And the wind-whipped scarves Of the retinue flicker in the moonlight.
96
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
I’ve come into a blessed legacy, The wandering dreams of foreign bards We’re free to despise consciously Our kin and our dull neighbors. And this may not be the only treasure, either, To skip the grandsons, descending to their sons, And a skald once again will set down another’s song And speak it as though it were his own.
In this poem culture and poetic tradition become a kind of licensed thievery. They leave the poet free to ransack history for its treasures, to pick and choose among pasts. He is at liberty to disregard a history he dislikes—even if it would seem to be his rightful inheritance—and to replace it with one more to his taste, however distant its origins may be from his own. A past that is doubly mediated (through Ossian and presumably through his latter-day collaborator James Macpherson) and triply translated (from Gaelic into English and, one assumes, into Russian) becomes effortlessly immediate and rightfully the poet’s own, for tradition allows, indeed requires him to take “another’s song” and recreate it in his own voice.58 “If you want [tradition],” Eliot warns, “you must obtain it by great labour.”59 What appears to be a relatively trouble-free procedure in “I have not heard the tales of Ossian” becomes far more problematic as Mandelstam puts his vision of tradition to the test. Let us return in this context to the stand-off of “Notre Dame” ’s final stanza, which reveals that even selfselected pasts and adopted families can prove troublesome in the making of a tradition that allows for new creation. By the time “Notre Dame” was written, Mandelstam has apparently picked the tradition that best suited his poetic needs, and he has done some additional tailoring to perfect the fit of tradition to poet. He tacitly rejects his Jewish heritage in turning to Christianity. The Christianity of Stone, moreover, is at a twofold remove from the East, or more precisely, it has been removed from two different Easts. Mandelstam’s Christianity grows not so much from an Eastern, Hebrew past as from classical Rome and Greece. Christianity is, he insists in “Pushkin and Skriabin,” “the legitimate heir of the myths of antiquity,” and its birth produced “the profound transformation that turned Hellas into Europe” (CPL, 92).60 He turns from the East again in deciding which side to take in the Great Schism. He chooses not Byzantium, but Rome and the faith that turned Rome’s colonies into the vast web of times and places that was the Holy Roman Empire. The particular embodiment of the church that becomes his point of entry into this Christian tradition is Notre Dame, the essence of transcendent maternity, and through his adoptive parent he acquires a distinguished lineage indeed. His family tree includes not only Gothic France and ancient Rome, but the mother of God, Notre Dame, and Adam, the father of humanity. “One pays a price for being the child of
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
97
one’s parents,” Nietzsche warns in The Gay Science, and the child of these self-chosen parents faces a daunting task: it would be difficult to leave one’s own mark on such a legacy.61 And yet the poem’s rhymes suggest that this is what Mandelstam must achieve. The last word of the poem’s final line, sozdam ([I] will create) is a challenge not only to the “Notre Dame” with which it is paired in the final stanza’s rhyme scheme. It also challenges the first stanza’s “Adam,” which forms an internal rhyme with both sozdam and “Notre Dame.” Mandelstam must take the proper names of his adoptive parents—which encompass male and female, tradition and newness, building and body, human and divine, the first man and humanity’s Akme in Christ—and derive his own name and identity from them. Small wonder, then, if the poet should feel unequal to the task at hand. For the “evil weight” from which he must create is not just the unformed, resisting matter that confronted the first man. He must also take on the weight of history, the weight of Notre Dame, without being crushed or pinioned by its mass. The weight of the past keeps the heavy heart of “In the vast pond it’s transparent and dark” (#18) from leaving its native pool and entering into a new world and identity, for this new self would be bought at the cost of the ties that bind the heart to its past. The “I” of “Notre Dame” ’s final stanza is likewise unwilling to sever the bonds he has forged between himself and Notre Dame: hence his prolonged and difficult birth. (And the physiological landscape of the final stanza suggests the poet as infant staring up at “monstrous ribs” within his giant mother’s womb.) He does not wish to undo the past with new creation. “I too will create beauty one day” (my italics), he tells the church, and his “too” does not express defiance alone. It also leaves intact the tie between his future work and the past from which it springs. It signifies both challenge and connection, both continuity and change. Mandelstam finds other ways to accommodate the mother church within his future work. He absorbs its anatomy into himself through his intensive, ongoing study of its form. Though his body is still held within its walls, he can figuratively take these walls into his smaller frame through his craftsman’s understanding of them. He is thus free to draw on their lessons when the time comes for him to give birth to his own beauty. And this beauty, once it emerges, will presumably bear a family resemblance to its adoptive grandmother, Notre Dame. The rhymes that tie Mandelstam to the church as both Notre Dame and Adam—“Adám,” “Notre Dáme,” “sozdám—suggest yet another model for tradition and creation in the poem. The rhymes that frame the final stanza, “Notre Dame,” “sozdam,” also link it to the poem’s opening, by way of “Adam,” and to its title, “Notre Dame.” Through these rhymes, the poem’s ending evokes its beginning, and Mandelstam’s future creation (sozdam) is bound to God’s creation through the first man (“Adam”). It is joined at the same time to a summit of human creation in history (“Notre Dame”). Mandelstam provides the rhyming words with a common family tree. Through a kind of
98
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
etymological alchemy, he creates a common root for all three in the syllable dam. There is no such root in Russian, and no actual etymological bond exists between the Russian verb and French and Hebrew nouns; still, its meaning in Russian, “I will give,” ties all three words together implicitly in the generous, fertile exchange that is Mandelstam’s ideal tradition. Moreover, rhyme itself must by its nature continually negotiate the boundary between continuity and change; it must “recollect forwards,” in Harold Bloom’s phrase.62 Invention and remembrance, Mandelstam reminds us, collaborate in true poetry; and rhyme “remembers” the sounds and endings of earlier lines even as it “invents” the new combinations that propel the poem forward. Rhyme alters the past, in other words, in the process of recalling it. The wind of “Why is the soul so songful” (#25) “will not return at all/Or will return completely changed.” Both return and change are assured in rhyme, as they serve both to check and extend each other’s movement. The final word of “Notre Dame,” and the last of its three key rhyme-words, propels the poet into a future where he will both draw on and alter the past. Yet his challenge, sozdam, is not on an equal footing with the forces of the past it echoes. These forces, Adam and Notre Dame, have their own names, the “dear names” that preserve identity in the face of time’s transformations. But the poet, whose self will be formed by future action, whose identity is still pure potential, remains nameless. In “Why is the soul so songful” (#25), the poet who cannot master the mighty named forces (“Aquilon,” the “wind of Orpheus”) around him fails in his creation and loses himself in the process: “And cherishing an uncreated world,/I forgot my useless ‘I.’ ” This is the danger that the stilluntested poet of “Notre Dame”’s final stanza must face in taking on future creation. There is, however, one further name linked with the poem “Notre Dame,” a name that suggests that the final stanza’s “I” will succeed in creating a world and a self from the past he has appropriated. This name stands just beyond the frame of the poem proper—it precedes the two cathedral poems in the March 1913 issue of Apollon—and it rhymes with both “Notre Dame” and “Adam” (Adám in Russian). It is of course Osip Mandelstam. Mandelstam’s very name suggests that he has taken his adopted past into himself and made it his own: both Adam and Dame are anagrammatically encoded in this name.63 The Russified German Jewish name that is his family legacy becomes the means by which he claims an ancestry radically different from his own. Through the medium of his name, he absorbs his adopted mother church into himself and emerges with his own identity intact: the Adam and Dame that resurface in “Mandelstam” are altered by their unexpected context, just as his family name is changed by the adopted family that takes up residence within it. Mandelstam thus orchestrates yet another meeting of structure (Notre Dame) and strangeness (Mandelstam). The first such confrontation within the poem, the encounter of Roman law with foreign France, gives birth to the church
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
99
that is the poem’s subject. The poem ends anticipating another birth, the poet’s self-creation from the fertile past he works to master. Mandelstam’s name can be seen as the final outcome of this prolonged and difficult birth—but this ending is also a new beginning. Just as the meeting of form and foreignness that opens the poem leads to the birth of the French medieval Notre Dame, so this new meeting of unlikes produces the Russian modernist Notre Dame. “We will prove our rightness in such a way,” the fledgling Acmeist proclaims, “that in answer to us the entire chain of cause and effect, from alpha to omega, will shudder” (CPL, 65). The poet who proves himself a worthy heir to his chosen parent Notre Dame produces just such an Acmeist “shudder,” for the child of the church is of course the poem’s father; the poet to whom Notre Dame gives birth within “Notre Dame” himself gives birth to “Notre Dame.” Mandelstam’s name can be seen as the final rhyme in the rhyme scheme that doubles as his cultural lineage. He is the church’s offspring, the akme of his adopted history. But “Mandelstam” could as easily be the first rhyme in this sequence, the rhyme that sets the pattern for the rest, for this Notre Dame, this Adam derive from the poet Osip Mandelstam. They are indebted to him for their being and not the other way around. The poet of Stone cannot be born as a poet until he has acquired a rich tradition to replace the inappropriate past with which his fathers, poetic and otherwise, have burdened him. As Mandelstam’s Villon demonstrates, a poet’s wants can spur his creativity, as stolen legacies take the place of traditional ties to the past and provide the inventive outsider with his home in history. If the poet succeeds completely, however, if the new home he constructs from old and stolen treasures is built too well, he is in danger of being superseded by the very structure he creates, for a perfectly adequate home does not demand additions and a perfectly adequate past requires no further creation. The greater the past the poet appropriates, the more he is in danger of being overshadowed by what Harold Bloom calls the “terrible splendor of cultural heritage,” and his own poetic task is made that much more difficult. Inversely, the greater the deficits of the poet’s own past, as he perceives them, the more he must borrow or steal to make up for his missing heritage, and such “self-appropriation involves immense anxieties of indebtedness.”64 The poet may find that paying off old debts and settling scores has taken the place of the new creation his stolen past was meant to facilitate. He may find himself bankrupted, drained of his own poetic resources by his extensive borrowing. In “Tradition and the Individual Talent,” T. S. Eliot tries to resolve this dilemma by claiming that the “new (the really new) work of art” instantaneously modifies the “ideal order” of all the “monuments” that have preceded it. The artist, however, can create such newness and take his place in art’s already extant order only with the weight of “the whole of the literature of Europe” “in his bones”—a burden that would seem to make
100
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
virtually any kind of movement, let alone one that was “new, really new,” almost impossibly hard. If the poet does succeed against all odds in his difficult task of making new verse from old, though, the past will acknowledge his efforts by making room for him among its elect. Eliot’s past thus becomes a kind of Westminster Abbey whose proportions shift whenever a new member has earned his place in its Poets’ Corner. Eliot claims that “the past should be altered by the present as much as the present is directed by the past.” In his model, though, the final word is reserved for the past; it alone sets the standards for the living. The poet must be placed “among the dead” “for contrast and comparison,” and “his significance, his appreciation is the appreciation of his relation” to the “dead poets, his ancestors,” whose voices echo in his work and whose worth is the measure of his merit.65 Mandelstam finds a more radical solution for dealing with a past whose continued presence proves a mixed blessing for the poet who is its beneficiary. By the 1930s he can accommodate both tradition and innovation in the space of a single phrase. In his definition of Acmeism as a “yearning for world culture,” Mandelstam clears a space for himself in world culture’s wholeness precisely by way of his yearning. This longing for what is absent places world culture in a vanished past, or in a future yet to be realized, or both. It is not present in any case, and its absence requires remedy—requires, in other words, the poet’s self and the poet’s work. Eliot’s past is free to pass the poet by entirely, if he proves to be an unworthy vessel for its continuance, if his work is not fit to modify its perfect order. Mandelstam’s world culture, on the other hand, cannot exist without the poet any more than the poet can survive without a world culture to strive for. For Mandelstam it is crucial that world culture remain unrealized and unrealizable. The poet exists not simply to modify art’s ideal order. His task is to disrupt the past’s apparent perfection and end its domination of the present by opening it up to change. True art, he reminds us, holds nothing readymade; hence art itself can never achieve an ideal, finished state. For Mandelstam as for Eliot, awareness of the past must accompany innovation in poetry. But Mandelstam goes beyond Eliot to claim that part of what the artist must invent is the very past that he remembers. The poet must be conscious, Eliot writes, “not of what is dead, but of what is already living.” Mandelstam goes one step further in “The Word and Culture” (1921): “Yesterday has not yet been born. It has not yet really existed” (CPL, 113). The past and its poetry are not the measure by which the present is judged. Rather, the present is the means by which the past may yet come to pass. The past and its poets, “Ovid, Pushkin, Catullus,” exist as pure potential, “rare presentiments,” intimations of what is still to come. They are not finished statements but unfulfilled imperatives, and their future life depends on those who follow them. “Thus,” Mandelstam exults, “not a single poet has yet appeared. We are free from the burden of memories” (CPL, 114). “He who is willing to work gives birth to
•
H I S T O R Y
A N D
M O D E R N
C A T H E D R A L S
•
101
his own father,” Bloom proclaims. Armed with his Acmeist tools, Mandelstam does not merely work to obtain tradition through his labors; he seeks to reverse the flow of time itself and to become a parent to the poetic past that has fathered, or mothered, him.66 Hence the difficult, delicate balance of past and future in “Notre Dame,” for Mandelstam aspires to be both parent and child to the past he adopts in the poem. The Mandelstam of “Notre Dame” lacks the seemingly supreme self-confidence that prompts the pronouncements of “The Word and Culture.” The overly-assertive “I” of the poem’s final stanza masks the child’s uncertainty as he prepares to surpass his parent’s achievement, and the hesitant poet postpones the moment of confrontation until an indefinite future; he will create beauty, he insists, one of these days. Yet we can see in the early poem the outlines of the later strategy by which he will master the past by way of the future. The poet of “Notre Dame” ’s final stanza contrives to deprive the past of its weight by turning it into an imperative demanding further creation, a command issued by a history that can reach fruition only through the good graces of the present. If a poet desires both the Hellenizing presence of a rich and universal tradition and the boundless freedom that comes from being “everywhere a foreigner,”67 he must learn to choose his history carefully. He must pick a past that accommodates strangers and change, and he must use his powers of invention to keep his chosen past from thwarting the transformations he has planned for it. Mandelstam is acute in both his remembrance and his invention. In Christianity he finds a tradition at once venerable and vital. Christianity, founded on the possibility of rebirth and governed, in principle at least, by the spirit of adoption, gives him access to the Europe he covets. It is at the same time an unfinished faith. God’s first revelation is the world’s creation and his second is his son, sent to save a fallen world. The final revelation, the apocalypse through which the rift between God and humanity will be fully healed, has not yet come. This leaves the poet free to treat Christ himself as a presentiment of what is still to pass, an imperative that has yet to be fulfilled. The weight of Christ’s redemption of the world is lifted from him by history itself, by a world that has not yet carried out the divine command. As he wanders in the labyrinths of history, the poet is free to recreate and undo Christ’s incomplete revelation. Hence, “Christian art is always action” and Christian culture is born of Christianity’s “dynamics”: “The divine illusion of redemption in Christian art is explained precisely by this game in which the Divinity plays with us, allowing us to wander the pathways of mystery so that we might happen upon salvation on our own, as it were, having experienced catharsis, redemption in art. Christian artists are like men free of the idea of redemption, neither slaves nor preachers” (CPL,91–92, 87). The Christian church, the emblem of Christ on earth, exemplifies this open-endedness through its dual, ambivalent nature. It is spirit and matter, building and body, organization and organism, continuity and change.
102
•
C H A P T E R
T H R E E
•
The church’s doubled natures will coincide completely only in the Second Coming, in the final triumph of Christ who is both temple and body and will “unite all categories in identity.”68 Until that day, however, the church as body and as building remain locked in a fruitful, restless alliance that prevents the structure from taking on a final form. And the poetic interloper is free to penetrate the church through the apertures left open by the imperfect fit of its dual natures. This is why Mandelstam turns from Byzantium, for he cannot enter a church that abandons its physical nature, that mistakes its truth for final revelation and withdraws from human history. Built on vital contradictions and tenuous agreements, Notre Dame is the ideal vessel for Mandelstam’s Christianity precisely in its seeming imperfection, in the human incompletion that invites outside participation. “When a person enters under the vaults of Notre Dame . . . doesn’t he become a Catholic merely by virtue of being under those vaults?” the eighteen-year-old poet asks (CPL, 477). And Mandelstam does seem to find a perfect home within the walls of Notre Dame. But Mandelstam’s tradition, which endlessly remakes the past in the name of the future, relies as much on homelessness as home. It holds out the prospect of a cosmic, all-embracing culture while requiring that we relinquish our ready-made pasts to achieve this Hellenized future. It thus makes orphans of us all. Mandelstam must make his Notre Dame not only a point of entry into tradition, but a point of departure from tradition. After he has been taken into Notre Dame, he must take the church into himself and recreate it continually as he wanders in history’s labyrinths.
•
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
F
O
U
R
•
Judaic Chaos THE UNREAD BOOKS OF GENESIS Yura had studied the classics and Scripture (zakon bozhii), legends and poets, history and natural science, which had become to him the chronicles of his house, his family tree (semeinaia khronika rodnogo doma). —Boris Pasternak, Doctor Zhivago (1957)
“Culture has become the church,” Mandelstam writes in “The Word and Culture” (1921; CPL, 112). His “Notre Dame” reveals that the church can also become culture, and this is the role that the Christian church—as building, as body, as the embodiment of a living Western tradition—plays for Mandelstam throughout his writing. As Omry Ronen notes, Mandelstam does not go to church so much as enter and exit various churches at will in his search for ever more capacious vessels for his world culture;1 and in “Notre Dame” he seems to have found a way to reconcile his yearning for inclusion in this vast culture with his outsider’s thirst for flexibility and new creation. An early lyric, published only long after Mandelstam’s death, reminds us, though, of the price he pays for his desire to be included within the encompassing structures of a tradition larger than what his own past is apparently prepared to provide. This lyric, “When the grasses of mosaics droop” (1910; #152), marks the first, furtive efforts of the young poet to enter the Christian church: Kogda mozaik niknut travy I cerkov; gulkaq pusta, Q v temnote, kak zmej lukavyj, Vlahus; k podno'i[ Kresta. I p;[ monawesku[ ne'nost; V sosredotohennyx serdcax, Kak kiparisa beznade'nost; V neumolimyx vysotax. When the grasses of mosaics droop, And the plangent church is empty, In the darkness, like an evil serpent, I crawl to the foot of the Cross. And I drink monastic tenderness In concentrated hearts, Like a cypress’s hopelessness In implacable heights.
104
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
One might read these rather awkward stanzas as a very young writer’s tribute to the Silver Age’s reigning decadent clichés, to the quasi-blasphemous images and attitudes that the Symbolists and their epigones had cultivated in their writings. If we examine it in the context of Mandelstam’s own early poetry, though, its imagery becomes both more revealing and more disquieting. The mosaics’ drooping grasses call to mind the drooping reed of “From an evil, miry pond” (#17), and the verb used in both poems is the same, niknut’. Both these poems, in turn, echo another early lyric, “Implacable words” (1910; #182), which places the drooping reed in an explicitly biblical context that proves to be no less “implacable” than the scene in which Mandelstam operates here; and I will return to these affinities at a later point in my discussion. The atmosphere these stanzas evoke harken back to the world of Stone’s early poems generally, in which the lonely poet wanders through an inhospitable landscape. The particular landscape and scenario that Mandelstam sketches here, though, bears a telling relationship to the great cathedral poems that appear to mark his triumphal entry into Western, Christian culture. This poem also concerns entering a church, and the form this forced entry takes is disconcerting indeed. The poet can enter the church only under cover of darkness; and the church itself must apparently be empty before he can make his illicit entrance. The hopes that he entertains in the later poems of conflating church, congregation, and the community of Christian culture at large—sobor and sobornost’—as he enters the portals of his churches in verse, are dashed here from the start. But the poem’s most disturbing note is sounded by the metaphorical form that the poet himself assumes upon entering the church. He is like an “evil serpent,” and the adjective Mandelstam uses to describe his snake is synomous with Satan himself: Lukavyi, the Evil One. The Jewish poet who enters the Christian church is Old Testament evil personified. He may try to identify himself with the New Testament and human time redeemed: “I crawl to the foot of the Cross.” He remains aligned nonetheless with the evil force that precipitated the Fall and drove humanity from Paradise into history at the Old Testament’s outset, the force that led to the crucifixion but could not itself be saved by it. It is a chilling image. In this lyric Mandelstam himself embodies the evil power that bars him from the Eden of world culture. The Jewish interloper whose foreign presence tacitly catalyzes Christian churches in his cathedral poems, who inspires Notre Dame itself to reach new heights through his outsider’s challenge, here remains trapped and alone beneath “implacable skies.” This image of the poet excluded by his Jewish origins from the culture he craves continues to haunt Mandelstam’s writings long after the apparent triumphs marked by the Acmeist manifestos in prose and verse; and this chapter will chiefly concern several poems from Stone and Tristia (1922) that mark Mandelstam’s most ingenious efforts to use his Jewish past as a bridge into Christian history, a bridge that can presumably be burned as
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
105
soon as it has served its unsettling purpose. Before I turn to these lyrics, though, I want to deal, however briefly, with the context in which Mandelstam himself places his Jewish background in The Noise of Time and elsewhere, and with the Russian and European context in which he and his family were placed by their efforts at assimilation.2 “As a little bit of musk fills an entire house,” Mandelstam writes in The Noise of Time, “the least influence of Judaism overflows all of one’s life” (POM, 80). The writer of 1925 thus reluctantly acknowledges the all-pervasive force of a past that the younger poet had sought to evade, transform, or erase. But Mandelstam is not simply recognizing the power that any family past retains over the individual being it has shaped, however unwillingly he may continue to bear its traces into the present. He speaks specifically of Jewishness, and in tsarist Russia, Jewish origins marked their bearer for life. The threat of exclusion haunts The Noise of Time in hints: the Dreyfus affair, Jew-free Finland, Riga divided into two parts, “that which had been cleansed of Jews and that which had not” (POM, 69, 71, 87, 93). “What had all this to do with me?” is Mandelstam’s refrain as he describes the splendors of imperial Petersburg as seen through childish eyes (POM, 78, 79). The official answer would have been, “Very little, indeed.” In the tsar’s empire, Jews’ “residence permit[s] as Russians [were] constantly subject to revocation.” At best, Russia’s Jews were citizens on probation; at worst they were subjected to official constraints and persecution, including state-sanctioned pogroms, of a kind that Western Europe no longer tolerated. “We shall make your position in Russia so unbearable that the Jews will leave the country to the last man,” one of Nicholas II’s ministers allegedly boasted to a delegation of Ukrainian Jews. Mandelstam’s fear that his Jewish birth would exclude him from his adoptive homeland’s culture was perfectly justified in the Russia he knew. In this nation, to be unequivocally Russian was beyond the reach of the Jew.3 Only Jews who practiced particularly valuable trades or professions were allowed to reside in the imperial capital itself—Mandelstam’s father, a leather merchant, presumably obtained such permission—but official persecution did not end for those Jews fortunate enough to gain entry into the sanctum sanctorum of Russo-European culture. Mandelstam himself converted to Christianity to evade the stringent quotas on Jewish admissions in force at all institutes of higher education; and his studies abroad, from 1907 to 1910, were likewise motivated by his efforts to escape Russian restrictions on Jewish education.4 Unofficially, his Jewish past followed him even into the non-Jewish “home and family” he attempted to construct for himself in Russian and European literature (POM, 130). Even the prestigious, progressive Tenishev School he attended as a boy was plagued by occasional outbreaks of anti-Semitism. The young poet was known in Symbolist circles as “Zinaida [Gippius]’s little Yid” (Gippius had been one of his early supporters); and Aleksandr Blok, no admirer either of Acmeists or
106
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
of Jews, later noted in his diary that “Mandelstam has grown a great deal. Gradually one gets used to the kike and sees the artist.”5 Mandelstam’s first response to the threat of exclusion his Jewishness posed was apparently to exclude all mention of his Jewish roots from his own writing. Even the two pond poems (#17, #18), which deal with his Jewish origins in the most veiled and cryptic of terms, appear together only in the 1928 version of Stone. He refers to his Jewish past only obliquely until his great prose works of the mid-twenties—chiefly The Noise of Time (1925), “The Egyptian Stamp” (1928), and “Fourth Prose” (1929–30)— works that mark a concerted effort to reconcile his Jewish heritage with his quest for world culture, on the one hand, and his struggle to place both himself and his culture in relation to the new Soviet state, on the other. But the influence of Judaism is powerful even—especially—in those writings in which Mandelstam apparently tries his hardest to ignore it. It is, like the role of Jewishness in Derridean thought, “a hidden center and motivation for other issues that might at first glance seem to be entirely unrelated to it.”6 Mandelstam’s later writings, and The Noise of Time particularly, provide keys for decoding the furtive influence of Judaism that lies hidden beneath the surface of the early poetry and prose. They indicate, too, the nature and potency of the fears that led the young Mandelstam to conceal the Jewish influence on the writing of this would-be Russian poet. “All the elegant mirage of Petersburg,” Mandelstam writes in his autobiography, “was merely a dream, a brilliant covering thrown over the abyss, while round about there sprawled the chaos of Judaism—not a motherland, not a house, not a hearth, but precisely a chaos, the unknown womb world whence I had issued, which I feared, about which I made vague conjectures and fled, always fled” (POM, 79). The influence of his past is anything but benign, and the “chaos of Judaism,” with its ubiquitous “threat of destruction,” he continues, “showed through all the chinks in [our] stone-clad Petersburg apartment” (POM, 79). The Jewishness he describes here acts as a universal solvent that undoes the singular synthesis of Russia and Europe, past and present, history and new creation that is Petersburg, the Russian capital of Mandelstam’s world culture. “Everything melts. Even Goethe melts,” the narrator mourns in “The Egyptian Stamp,” as he contemplates a ruined landscape made up of “wooden, stonebound book[s], whose interior[s] have been ripped out” (POM, 181, 183). Certainly the verbal splendors of Stone would be no match for this chaotic force capable of dissolving the stone splendors of Petersburg—or so Mandelstam’s refusal to admit this “chaos” into his stone-clad early verse would suggest. As Mandelstam admits in the “Slate Ode” (1923, #137), though, he is anything but a “straightforward stoneworker (kamenshchik priamoi).” Even his most monumental structures are built partly on chaos, and they thrive on the “threat of destruction” that such uncertain foundations guar-
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
107
antee. The very passage in which Mandelstam describes his efforts to outrun his amorphous past reminds us that he is what Wallace Stevens would call a “connoisseur of chaos.” The Jewish chaos that apparently serves only to drive him from the true home he desires in Russian and European culture actually does something like the opposite. For the chaos he combats in this passage is a composite, an artistic construct made up of both Jewish and Russian forms of formlessness. It has its roots in the metaphysical abyss that lies concealed beneath a “brilliant covering” in Tiutchev’s famous lyric, “Day and Night” (1839); and it calls to mind, too, the tumultuous “element (stikhiia)” with which Peter the Great does battle as he builds his new city on the Finnish swamps in Pushkin’s “Bronze Horseman” (1833). The “chaotic” inheritance that would appear to bar Mandelstam from his desired history and homeland is made instead to serve his ends, as he tacitly turns it into his bond with Russia’s own struggles to wrest poetic and cultural form from chaos. 7 In “On the Nature of the Word,” Mandelstam places a version of his native chaos at the heart of Russian culture. “Russian history,” he warns, “travels along the brink, along a ledge, over an abyss” made of the chaotic potentials of Russian speech itself: “Russian history and culture are ever awash on all sides, circumscribed only by the ominous and boundless element (stikhiia) of the Russian language, which cannot be contained within any governmental or ecclesiastical form” (CPL, 122, 120; II, 248, 245). Chaos is no less a part of Mandelstam’s world history and culture. It is the necessary enemy who propels his art and prompts him to enlist a range of allies drawn from all nations and ages. This chaos is contradictory. It can signify the absence of life or its superabundance, oblivion or an unbounded energy fruitful in its formlessness. It is protean. It may be Tiutchev’s chaos, or that of the Symbolists, or the chaos faced by medieval humanity, by modern Acmeists, or by a whole generation of Russians deafened by the noise of their times. It can take the shape of Peter the Great’s “element” or the formless darkness of Genesis. Chaos becomes Mandelstam’s bond with Acmeism, Russia, the European tradition, with the human race itself. By identifying his family legacy as chaos, he places it at the core of his endeavor. But why does Mandelstam perceive his inheritance as chaos, and not as a concrete, if oppressive, history and body of traditions? And why is he so anxious in the early work to call this chaos by any but its proper name, by a name that would reflect its Jewish beginnings? One answer to the second question might be that Mandelstam tacitly “christens” his chaos in hopes of gaining entry into Christian culture. And Mandelstam himself suggests an answer to the first question in The Noise of Time as he traces his chaotic inheritance back to the “bookcase of early childhood”: “The chaos of Judaism showed through all the chinks of the stone-clad Petersburg apartment: in the threat of ruin, in the cap hanging in the room
108
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
of the guest from the provinces, in the spiky script of the unread books of Genesis, thrown into the dust one shelf lower than Goethe and Schiller.” (POM, 79). “I always remember,” he continues, “the lower shelf as chaotic”: [the books] lay like ruins: reddish five-volume works with ragged covers, a Russian history of the Jews written in the clumsy, shy language of a Russianspeaking Talmudist. This was the Judaic chaos thrown into the dust. This was the level to which my Hebrew primer, which I never mastered, quickly fell. . . . Above these Jewish ruins there began the orderly arrangement of books; those were the Germans—Schiller, Goethe, Kerner, and Shakespeare in German. . . . All this was my father fighting his way as an autodidact into the German world out of the Talmudic wilds. Still higher were my mother’s Russian books—Pushkin in Isakov’s 1876 edition. . . . It bore an inscription in reddish ink: “For her diligence as a pupil of the Third Form.” (my ellipses; POM 81–83)
“Any object in space is a memory system” to the modernist mind, Hugh Kenner remarks, and this bookshelf represents just such a system.8 It contains “a history of the spiritual efforts of the entire family, as well as the innoculation of it with foreign blood” (POM, 81), and the word Mandelstam uses for “family” is suggestive. It is rod, which means “family” in the largest sense: birth, origins, tribe, nation, even the human race (chelovecheskii rod) as such. The story that Mandelstam recounts through this bookcase does not concern simply his own parents. It is also a succinct, idiosyncratic, and finally suspect retelling of the efforts of the Jewish race to assimilate, to cast off the linguistic and cultural traces of their “chaotic” beginnings as they enter into the main current of European, and (here) Russian, culture. In his autobiography Mandelstam describes his parents’ efforts to acquire a new language and culture to replace the Jewish past that bars them from a European present. Their efforts meet with varying degrees of success, but the context Mandelstam gives them in the bookshelf saturates them with symbolic import. He begins “in the beginning,” with the chaos of Genesis, the chaos that leads to the origins of the human race, on the one hand, and to the founding of the Jewish faith, on the other. But this particular account of origins must be “unread,” or so Mandelstam’s bookshelf suggests. The Hebrew primer (drevne-evreeskaia azbuka) that would, if mastered, provide the key to the family’s unread Genesis, is cast, like the books of Genesis themselves, back into primordial Jewish chaos, where it is left to collapse into “ruins” and “dust.” The family, and by extension, the Jewish people, should not move backward but forward, or so Mandelstam implies; they must join him in his flight from Jewish chaos. And the set of books that accompanies the discarded primer and the unread books of Genesis suggests the shape that this movement should take. This is the “reddish five-volume works with ragged covers, a Russian history of the Jews written in the clumsy, shy language of
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
109
a Russian-speaking Talmudist.” It is quite literally a transitional work. It not only tells the history of the Jews in Russia (one commentator identifies the work as I. G. Orshansky’s The Jews in Russia [Evrei v Rossii, 1872, 1878]).9 It also enacts this history, insofar as it is a history of linguistic and cultural assimilation, for its author has apparently managed to master, however imperfectly, the language that enables him to mediate between the two cultures. Mandelstam’s father and mother continue this movement; and their progress is measured, Mandelstam implies, by the distance they manage to put between themselves and their past. His father attempts to escape the “Talmudic wilds” of his upbringing by way of German culture but ends stranded between cultures, languages, and ages: My father had absolutely no language; his speech was tongue-tie and languagelessness. The Russian speech of a Polish Jew? No. The speech of a German Jew? No again. . . . It was anything in the world, but not a language, neither Russian nor German. In essence, my father transferred me to a totally alien century and distant, although completely un-Jewish atmosphere. These were, if you will, the purest eighteenth or even seventeenth century of an enlightened ghetto somewhere in Hamburg. ( my ellipses; POM, 90)
Mandelstam’s mother moves closer to the unspoken goal of full assimilation. Unlike her “autodidact” husband, she was educated in the Russian schools of Riga; and her academic success is marked by the “Isakov Pushkin” she receives “for her diligence as a pupil of the Third Form” (POM, 82). Russian culture may not have been her birthright, but she attains it nonetheless through hard work and determination. And unlike her “languageless” husband, she also achieves a true speech: “Her vocabulary was poor and restricted, the locutions were trite, but it was a language, it had roots and confidence. Mother . . . took joy in the roots and sounds of her Great Russian speech. . . . Was she not the first of her whole family to achieve pure and clear Russian sounds?” (my ellipses; POM, 90) There is an unspoken sequel to the saga Mandelstam tells here of Jewish chaos partially overcome through European and Russian culture, and that is the story that he tells in the autobiography itself, which recounts the making of a Russian writer from Jewish emigré beginnings. “The speech of father and the speech of mother—does not our language feed throughout all its long life on the confluence of these two, do they not compose its character?” Mandelstam asks in The Noise of Time, and his answer is implicit in the language in which his question and the autobiography that frames it are composed (POM, 90). He shapes from his father’s “languagelessness” and his mother’s pure but impoverished Russian the rich and flexible idiom that is his bid for inclusion in the canon of Russian culture proper. He has advanced his family’s “spiritual efforts” toward linguistic and cultural assimilation to their next, perhaps final, stage by becoming a
110
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
poet, that is, someone who does not merely draw on his language’s resources—and who certainly does not repeat its worn-out locutions and clichés—but who works to transform and extend the language through his own contributions to it. The Russian language, he insists in “On the Nature of the Word,” thrives on “cross-breeding, grafting, and foreign-born (chuzherodnykh) influences” (CPL, 120; II, 245); and through his hybrid writing, the foreign-born Mandelstam stakes his claim to be considered a truly Russian writer. Mandelstam’s efforts to become a Russian writer are riddled with paradoxes. “My memory,” he announces in The Noise of Time, “is inimical to all that is personal”; he claims that his task is “to distance the past” as he replaces his extra-literary ancestry with a purely literary family tree. “A raznochinets,” he insists, “needs no memory—it is enough for him to tell of the books he has read, and his biography is done” (POM, 122). Elsewhere though, he admits that even this bibliographic curriculum vitae must begin in “the bookcase of early childhood”; no book contained in this early bookcase “can ever be expelled” either from “the universe of world literature,” or, presumably, from the self that is shaped by way of one’s reading as well (POM, 81). Mandelstam thus implicitly underscores the Jewishness of his efforts both to escape his past and to create a new self and homeland through culture. Through his flight from “Judaic chaos” into Russian and European culture, he does not break with his immediate family past: he continues it. His very struggle to abandon this past extends the efforts of his parents—his father’s escape from the “Talmudic wilds” of his childhood, his mother’s triumphant mastery of Russian speech—to shape new selves from what their son perceives as the rubble, or ruins, or chaos, of Jewish beginnings. Unlike Boris Pasternak, who was born Jewish but raised in a thoroughly Russian cultural milieu, or Isaak Babel, who grew up “steeped in Jewish cultural and literary life,” Mandelstam was brought up between cultures by parents who abandoned the past without mastering the new world that was to take its place.10 Mandelstam’s Jewishness is chaotic because it signifies this no man’s land, neither here nor there, inside or out. In The Noise of Time, he hints that his modernist creation of tradition is Jewish in crucial ways. He gives no indication, in The Noise of Time or elsewhere, that he is aware of the larger Jewish “tradition” of self-creation in which he and his poetic project participate. To look over the vast literature on modern European and Russian Jewry is to encounter, though, a seemingly endless series of variants on Mandelstam’s plight and on his compensatory self-invention and invention of tradition. “The alienated Jew,” Daniel Bell observes, “is the Jewish orphan. . . . Asked, in the classic question of identity, ‘Who are you?’ . . . the apikoros, the ‘sophisticated unbeliever,’ instead of giving the traditional response: ‘I am the son of my father’ . . . says ‘I am I’—meaning, of course, I stand alone, I come out of myself, and, in choice and ac-
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
111
tion, make myself.” Since the Enlightenment, Milton Gordon observes, Jews have been seen as “classic ‘marginal men,’ poised on the edge or dividing line of two cultures, fully at home in neither, and therefore on the margins of both”; and indeed, the pioneering sociologist Georg Simmel takes the European Jew as his exemplar of modern society’s “marginal men” in his classic study “The Stranger” (1908).11 Mandelstam was not alone in his dilemma, then, and he was not alone in the ways he sought to escape from it. In his History of Jewish Literature, Meyer Waxman notes that “to the Jews, literature took the place of the fatherland, and their history is to a fair degree, a history of literature.”12 One thinks of Mandelstam’s raznochinets-reader, whose history consists exclusively of books. And one recognizes the Jewish ancestors of this would-be raznochinets throughout the pages of Lvov-Rogachevsky’s History of Russian Jewish Literature (1922), which are peopled by Jewish “knights errant, with the name of European culture on their lips,” driven by what Mandelstam calls “the reading demon [which] breaks loose from the depths of cultural wastes (kul’tura opustoshitel’nitsa)” (CPL, 393; III, 165).13 For Mandelstam, the self-made man of letters, literature was to take the place of home and family. His parents’ bookcase demonstrates, though, that he was not the first in his family to conceive of such a refuge in art. Such dreams, moreover, were not the property of Mandelstam and his family alone. In Lvov-Rogachevsky’s History and other accounts of modern Jewish writing, such aspirations come to seem the very hallmark of that writing. The French Jewish poet Edmond Jabès (born 1912) is concerned, Allan Megill notes, with “a certain Judaism, as a birth and passion of writing. In the universe of Jabès’s poetry, ‘the Jew’ is defined by his homelessness, by his utter lack of a patrie. Lacking a homeland, he makes a homeland of his own through writing,” for “the house is in the book.” As Murray Baumgarten sees it, this is the true homeland of all modern Jewish writers, who have learned through their art to make “out of worldlessness . . . an independent realm.”14 Even in this thumbnail sketch, we can see ways in which Mandelstam’s calling as modern poet-synthesist might be revised to include his identity as uprooted Jew. The two identities converge in crucial ways; and indeed, in “Fourth Prose” and “Conversation about Dante,” Jewishness, imaginatively reconstrued, becomes the essence of all true culture. The Noise of Time, shaped by unresolved, often unacknowledged ambivalences, marks a halfway point on Mandelstam’s journey toward the calling of poet-Jew he embraces in “Fourth Prose.” The books of Genesis that symbolize both his personal and his ancestral past may, for the time, remain unread; but they have at least earned a permanent place in the family bookcase that is “a man’s travelling companion for life”: “Every book in the first bookcase is, willy-nilly, a classic, and not one of them can ever be expelled” (POM, 81). The younger poet, the poet of Stone and Tristia (1922), does not abide by
112
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
such strictures. He too conflates ancient and recent Jewish beginnings— but not in order to forge a new synthesis from the two. His role comes closer to exorcist than to synthesist as he works to expel his Jewish past from his Russian modernist present.
THE BACKWARD FLOW OF TIME With my love, instincts, and inclinations I should not have been born a Jew. —Boris Pasternak, in a 1928 letter to Maksim Gorky.15
“Who am I?” Mandelstam asks in his “Slate Ode,” and his answer speaks as much to his composite identities as Russian Jew or poet-Jew as it does to his position as an ambivalent postrevolutionary modernist: “Not an honest stoneworker,/A roofmaker or boat-builder,/I’m a double-dealer with a double soul” (1923; #137).15 Double-dealing, double vision, dual identities: these are the animating spirits of Mandelstam’s art from early on, whether they take the form of Villon’s hermaphroditic being, of his paired poetic churches, eastern and western, or of the doubled natures that animate his Notre Dame. In a late poem (1931; 236), Mandelstam finds a striking metaphor for the double vision he cultivates in his late work: On [Zeves] glqdit v binokol; prekrasnyj Cejsaó Dorogoj podarok Car;-Davida,ó Zamehaet vse mor]iny gnejsa, Gde sosna il; derevuwka-gnida. He [Zeus] peers into his splendid Zeiss binoculars— King David’s precious present— He notes all the wrinkles of gneiss, The pine tree and the hamlet-nit.
In this stanza Mandelstam conjures up a double vision made in equal parts of Hebrew and ancient Greek beginnings: the Judaic and Hellenic sources of Western culture fuse in the fabulous binoculars that are King David’s gift to Olympian Zeus. For the younger Mandelstam, though, these traditions are at war. To acknowledge his family history, whether recent or ancient, means to abandon all hope of possessing the classical and Christian cultures he craved. Mandelstam uses his outsider’s status obliquely and slyly in the early work to make other nations and histories his own. His exemplary outcast may be a Russian thinker, Chaadaev, or a French thief, Villon, but he is never a Jewish émigré; and the chaos from which these outcasts shape their culture may be Eastern or Western, ancient or modern, but it will not be Judaic. In the early work, Jewishness operates in disguise, and Jewish origins betray themselves chiefly in the pernicious, centripetal pull that pre-
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
113
vents Mandelstam from emerging full-grown from his “dear” and “evil” pond. In The Noise of Time, Mandelstam speaks of the “unknown womb world” he flees (POM, 79); and he tacitly identifies the “Judaic chaos” of this womb world with the chaotic force that emanates from the family’s unread Genesis. These two forms of genesis converge in a number of early lyrics, in which Mandelstam conflates his Jewish beginnings with the beginnings of Judeo-Christian culture itself, as he works to create a personal and historical mythology of origins that will permit him to cast off his past and enter the Christian world of culture. The shape that these Jewish beginnings take in these lyrics ensure that his task will not be easy. In “Pushkin and Skriabin” (1915), Mandelstam warns that Christian culture can be undone: “The Christian calendar is endangered, the fragile reckoning of the years of our era has been lost—time is rushing backward (vremia mchitsia obratno)” (CPL, 91; II, 314). Elsewhere, in a passage that Mandelstam omitted from the finished essay, he identifies a chief culprit in the plot against Christian time: Rome has surrounded Golgotha with an iron ring: this hill which has become Greek and universal must be set free. A Roman soldier guards the crucifixion and his spear is at hand: now the water will flow: the Roman guard must be removed. . . . The infertile part of Europe, the part without grace (bezblagodatnaia), has risen up against the fertile, graced [part]. Rome has risen up against Hellas. . . . Hellas must be saved from Rome. If Rome triumphs, it is not even Rome that triumphs, but Judaism (iudeistvo)—Judaism always stood behind its back and is only awaiting the hour when it will celebrate its awful, unnatural motion (strashnyi, protivuestestvennyi khod ): history will turn back the flow of time. (Mandelstam’s ellipses; IV, 100)16
Mandelstam implicitly fuses the pull of origins that shapes his pond poems with the insidious, quasi-historical force of a Judaism, iudeistvo, that threatens to suppress or reverse all Christian culture through its “unnatural” backward motion, through the misguided loyalties that lead this Judaism to prefer its fallen past to a redeemed Christian future. This apocalyptic backdrop informs, in turn, Mandelstam’s vision of a contemporary Russia consumed by world war and revolution. A triple history—personal, JudeoChristian, and modern Russian history in the making—comes into play in the lyrics in which Mandelstam struggles to remake his own beginnings. Mandelstam was not alone among modern poets in his efforts to rewrite his past and his nation’s present according to patterns of biblical transformations The task of the true “Poetic Genius,” according to William Blake, is to “create perpetual Genesis in its own image”; “Every true poet must spend his life making the Bible anew.” The Russian modernists hardly required Blake’s inspiration to aspire to “write a last judgment or universal history to fit the revolutionary needs of modern times”; like many romantic and postromantic poets, they were adept at finding ways to make their per-
114
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
sonal history “coincide[] with the universal spiritual history of mankind” conceived along Judeo-Christian lines.17 The cataclysms of modern Russian history, combined with Russia’s powerful eschatological traditions, invited poets to conceive of Russia’s modern struggles as convulsive battles between the past and the future, between a dying order and a new world waiting to be born. Belyi, Blok, Esenin, Akhmatova, Mayakovsky—all read the war and revolution in terms of cosmic, Christian transformation, and all worked, with varying degrees of conviction and success, to place their poetic voice in relation to the upheaval by way of Judeo-Christian models of prophecy and redemption.18 For Mandelstam these models hold both special possibilities and special perils. He cannot claim as his birthright the Christian apocalyptic imagery and thought that enabled his contemporaries to create the poetic cosmologies that would, so they hoped, assure their place in world history. And he can use his Jewish legacy for such purposes only by abusing it. By enlarging his battles with his Jewish past to biblical proportions, he can justify his break with this legacy while placing himself at the heart of Christian culture. By identifying the battle of Judaism and Christianity with Russia’s own divisive struggles, and by linking Christ’s Passion with Russia’s ordeal of war and revolution, Mandelstam can take his place in his adopted nation’s present and stake a claim in its future. His struggle with his Jewish past becomes a modern reenactment of another, far vaster schism: the rift that split time and history in two, the rift that divides the Old Testament from the New. This struggle takes the shape of a battle between a Judaism that remains stubbornly rooted in the past and the “Hellenistic” Christian creed through which time is, in Mandelstam’s eyes, redeemed. We could see in these procedures yet another instance of Mandelstam’s inventive remembrance, as he converts seeming deficits into cultural assets. Mandelstam’s use and abuse of his Jewish past and of Jewish history generally in these texts suggests, however, a far less flattering rubric under which we might place these efforts; their guiding spirit might be called “creative selfhatred,” as Mandelstam turns on his Jewish past in his efforts to fashion a new self fit to enter the portals of Christian culture.19 A complex, imperfect poem that was not included in any of Stone’ s several editions marks Mandelstam’s first, failed attempt to dramatize his battle with his past in biblical terms. “I’ve become afraid of living life out” (1910; #457 t) appears to be, in Eliot’s phrase, “full of some stuff that the writer could not drag to light, contemplate or manipulate into art.”20 Its tangled thread of metaphors seems to be spun from some compelling fear that eludes Mandelstam’s clear understanding and resists his efforts to master it in verse: Mne stalo strawno 'izn; ot'it;ó I s dereva, kak list, otprqnut;, I nihego ne pol[bit;, I bezymqnnym kamnem kanut;_
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
115
I v pustote, kak na kreste, "ivu[ duwu raspinaq, Kak Mojsej na pustote, Isheznut; v oblake Sinaq. I q sle'uóso vsem 'ivym Menq svqzu[]ie niti, I bytiq uzornyj dym Na mramornoj sliha[ plite_ I sodrogan;q teplyx ptic Ulavliva[ herez seti, I s istleva[]ix stranic Pritqgiva[ prax stoletij. I’ve become afraid of living life out— And pulling back, like a leaf from a tree, And that I’ll love nothing, And vanish like a nameless stone. And in emptiness, as on the cross, Crucifying my living soul, Like Moses in the emptiness, I’ll vanish into Sinai’s cloud. And I observe the threads That bind me to everything living, And on a marble tablet I collate The patterned smoke of being; And I snare in nets The warm birds’ trembling, And from moldering pages I dredge the dust of centuries.
I do not intend to decipher all of the poem’s awkward, oddly arresting imagery and will focus instead on its crux, on the crisis that comes at the end of the second stanza.21 The poem breaks into two parts around this troubled center, and each of its halves consists of a sequence of images cobbled into a single sentence by a breathless, insistent series of ands. The first two stanzas lead the poet from fear to fear until he finds himself, with Moses, facing annihilation at the hands of an unseen god. The final stanzas, on the other hand, read like an incantation or exorcism designed to preserve him from this awful, otherworldly force. Mandelstam frantically summons up his store of images for art’s restorative powers as he attempts to put the demons of the opening stanzas to rest. His efforts are less than successful, though, and what remains with the reader is not an image of the poet restored to life through art, but a lingering sense of the propulsive force that pushes him to the brink of destruction in the poem’s opening.
116
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
“Falling is fear’s faithful companion, and fear itself is the sense of emptiness,” another early poem warns (#34). I have suggested already that a “fear of falling” unites the opening stanza’s images; that the falling leaf stands for Mandelstam’s imagined break with his “family tree”; and that it is this fall from grace that costs him his name (the stone is “nameless”) as it turns connection into emptiness and changes vital substance into lifeless matter. This stanza is linked to the second by the conjunction and, which suggests some form of continuity, some single thought or feeling that runs from one stanza to the next. This connection, though, lies more in the mind of the poet than in the poem itself, for the fear that fuels the early imagery shifts radically as it enters the second stanza. The first stanza gives oblique testimony to the emptiness that an abandoned past leaves in its wake. The second bears witness, again indirectly, to the continued, ominous presence of a past that will not be cast off. It testifies to the power of a past that consumes its offspring as it extinguishes present and future. In the second stanza, the books of Genesis are not only unread, but unwritten as “Sinai’s cloud” swallows up their apocryphal author—the Bible’s first five books are also known as the Law or Books of Moses—in Mandelstam’s elliptical, highly personal version of early biblical history. It is here that we find “the influence of Judaism” in its Mandelstamian variant. The stanza actually begins in the New Testament: in attempted imitation of Christ, the poet “crucif[ies]” his “living soul” “as on the cross.” Through this imagery, Mandelstam not only makes his bid for inclusion into his chosen “homeland of the spirit” (CPL, 85) by way of its most venerable archetypes and traditions. He also calls on a complex model for redemptive transformation. “Christian art,” Mandelstam writes in “Pushkin and Skriabin,” is “an eternal return to the single creative act that began our Christian era.” In imitating this act, Mandelstam legitimately takes part in “the profound revolution that turned Hellas into Europe” (CPL, 91–92). Mandelstam’s Christianity ideally begins in Hellas, not Judea. Christianity itself, however, provides the first and perfect paradigm for transforming Jewish origins into what is in Christian belief a new, truly cosmic culture. This revolution is achieved through the sufferings and resurrection of Jesus, a Jew and, one might add, a half-orphan, raised by an adoptive father while his true lineage remains concealed. Christ’s seeming defection from his native tradition is undertaken with the aim of fulfilling that tradition, of revealing its true nature and creating a greater culture from it. Christ himself, moreoever, is restored through his sufferings to his true nature, and he returns from exile to the quintessential homeland of the spirit by way of the cross.22 Mandelstam’s imitation of Christ in “I’ve become afraid of living life out” ends, though, not in rebirth and reconciliation but in destruction, and its final failure is signaled by the third stanza’s opening phrase. Mandelstam’s ordeal takes place not in the desert (pust-ynja), in the purifying wastelands that lead in the Bible to revelation and redemption. (And that
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
117
lead, no less importantly, to true poetic inspiration in Pushkin’s “The Prophet” [Prorok ; 1826], the poem that established the model of poet-asprophet for generations of Russian poets to come.)23 Mandelstam’s metaphoric crucifixion unfolds “in emptiness (v pust-ote)” (desert and emptiness share a root in Russian); and his model for redemption through suffering fails him in this enveloping emptiness. His abortive Passion Play falls under the overwhelming influence of origins, under the spell of the Judaic “backward flow of time.” History reverses itself as the New Testament gives way to the Old and Christ is replaced by his precursor Moses in the stanza’s third line. Time’s backward motion does not end with Moses, though. Mandelstam’s Moses is no less singular than his Christ, and no less subject to time’s “unnatural” flow. This Moses cannot escape the emptiness that had plagued the would-be savior. The third line ends as the first line begins, “in emptiness (na pustote).” This emptiness is less ominous, though, than the implacable force that draws the poet, “like Moses,” into Sinai’s “devouring” cloud in the stanza’s final line (Exodus 24:17). Mandelstam’s Moses symbolizes not new beginnings—new laws, new guarantees from God, an end to exile, and a promised land—but absolute ending. The Moses of “Exodus” withdraws into God’s “devouring fire” more than once. He returns from this “thick darkness” to relay God’s word to his people and set the history of the Israelites in motion (Exodus 19:9, 20:21, 24:17). Nadezhda Mandelstam notes that her husband feared “the Old Testament God and his awesome, totalitarian power.”24 In this poem, Mandelstam’s Yahweh becomes a Hebrew Cronos consuming his young. He not only opposes rebirth and regeneration; he undoes the principle of genesis itself, the principle that he had used to generate both his world and his book. The creator sucks his creatures into himself, as Christ, Moses, and Mandelstam all succumb to time’s unstoppable backward flow. Mandelstam’s Christ cannot counteract the force of Judaic origins, which take on truly cosmic dimensions in this poem. Mandelstam’s own origins have become nothing less than the “patriarchal, paternal source,” in the Judeo-Christian cosmogony, of existence itself (POM, 130). In The Noise of Time, Mandelstam describes his futile flight from Jewish origins. The younger poet likewise takes flight in “I’ve become afraid of living life out.” He cannot vanquish the past on its own terms, and so he changes the terms of the struggle entirely in the poem’s remaining stanzas. He takes refuge behind a screen of metaphors that leave him grasping at threads and nets, smoke and dust as he struggles to retrieve his being from the vortex of all-consuming origins. One of these images suggests that Mandelstam attempts to countermand the laws of Moses and God by creating his own commandments through art: “And on a marble tablet I collate/The patterned smoke of being.” The poem itself demonstrates, though, that Mandelstam is not yet able to rewrite the Old Testament in a way that would remake his past while preserving him from it, that would transform this
118
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
past into a pathway leading him to a new present and a different history. It is perhaps for these reasons, for the poem’s failure as myth-creation, as much as for its evident artistic problems—its unwieldy syntax and scattershot imagery—that Mandelstam chooses to exclude it from the autobiography-in-art he painstakingly constructs in Stone’s various editions. There is one poem that Mandelstam included in all of Stone’s variants in which he apparently manages to convert the Jewish desert to new purposes as he translates his unwanted past into a liberating present. This is “The bread is poisoned and the air’s been drunk” (1913; #54). Otravlen xleb i vozdux vypit. Kak trudno rany vrahevat;@ Iosif, prodannyj v Egipet, Ne mog sil;nee toskovat;@ Pod zvezdnym nebom beduiny, Zakryv glaza i na kone, Slaga[t vol;nye byliny O smutnom pere'itom dne. Nemnogo nu'no dlq naitij% Kto poterql v peske kolhan, Kto vymenql konqósobytij Rasseivaetsq tuman_ I esli podlinno poetsq I polnoj grud;[ónakonec Vs∏ ishezaet% ostaetsq Prostranstvo, zvezdy i pevec! The bread is poisoned and the air’s been drunk. How hard it is to heal the wounds! Joseph, sold into Egypt, Could not yearn more powerfully! Bedouins beneath a starry sky, With closed eyes and on horseback, Compose free ballads About the dimly lived-through day. You don’t need much for inspiration: Someone’s lost his quiver in the sand, Another’s traded horses—the fog Of events clears; And if you sing authentically With your whole chest—at last All vanishes: what remains Is the expanse, the stars, and the singer!
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
119
Mandelstam tacitly compares one Jewish Joseph—Osip is a Russian variant of the name—to another, the Joseph of the Book of Genesis, who is sold into Egyptian slavery by his own brothers.25 Mandelstam thus evokes not only his own Jewish origins, but a history of betrayal, exile, and oppression brought on by a family divided against itself. Joseph’s history is not a perfect fit with Mandelstam’s past as he describes it in The Noise of Time and elsewhere, and the discrepancies between the two stories leave crucial questions unanswered. Does the poet lament his lost family, or what his family causes him to lose? Is he in exile from the land of his origin or because of the land of his origin, because of his family in the larger sense (rod)? What causes the deadly state of affairs we find in the opening line? Does a family past the poet cannot abandon poison his new life? Or does he find himself unable to breathe the air of a forbidden, foreign present? The lines that provoke these unanswered, perhaps unanswerable questions are expressive in their very ambiguity, which permits Mandelstam to voice his double sense of yearning and oppression, of betrayal and longing, without having to take sides or set the story straight. Mandelstam neatly cuts the Gordian knot of tangled past and present in the stanzas that follow. He liberates himself and his namesake from their stifling life-in-death by way of metaphor; he transforms one nomadic people into another, as Jewish Joseph and his troubled tribe become the Bedouins whose “free ballads” go back no further than the dimly remembered events of the day just passed. Mandelstam emerges as a master of the vanishing act that had earlier threatened to destroy him, as he sets time’s destructive backward motion in reverse. The past does not devour the present. Rather, the present, in the person of the poet tutored by Bedouin bards, dissipates the past. “The fog of events clears” and, under the spell of the poet’s “authentic” song, “all vanishes” except for open space, the stars, and the singer himself.26 Mandelstam rids the present of the past’s destructive force by way of song—but the solution he finds in “The bread is poisoned” cannot serve his larger purposes. He does not wish to cast his lot among Bedouins, whose memory lives only in a past so recent that it is really an extension of a present as vast as the expanse they roam. “The present tense, completely isolated from both the future and the past, is conjugated like pure fear,” Mandelstam warns in “Conversation about Dante”; and history is Mandelstam’s antidote to “the horror of the present tense” (CPL, 403). Like the Chaadaev of his 1915 essay, Mandelstam yearns to fertilize the vacant, timeless desert by bringing it into proximity with history (CPL, 83–89). One of the nineteenth century’s most infamous, and influential, antiSemites, Richard Wagner, condemns what he perceives as the aridity of Jewish culture in his essay “Jews in Music” (1850): “The Jew has stood outside the pale of any [true] community, stood solitarily with his Jehovah in a splintered, soilless stock, to which all self-sprung evolution must stay denied.”27 Perhaps unwittingly, Mandelstam echoes Wagner’s complaint in
120
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
the lyric that marks his first effort to transplant his dilemma into stony Judean soil, “Implacable words” (1910; #182). “We are not prophets, not even precursors,” Mandelstam laments in another early lyric (#37). In “Implacable words,” “Pushkin and Skriabin,” and Tristia’s “Jewish” sequence (#91, #100, #109), Mandelstam uses his difficulties with the past he cannot master to establish his kinship with prophets, precursors, and even Christ himself. Like them, he labors to change the landscape of the past as he sows his metaphorical seed on soil that resists new life, and he finds a framework for his struggle that is at once historical in its origins, mythical in its dimensions, and universal in its claims and aspirations. Contra Wagner, he labors to demonstrate that the seemingly barren soil of Judea, which once gave birth to Christ and Christian culture, may prove fertile ground for another birth, for his own “self-sprung evolution” into the Christian traditions of the West. Neumolimye slova . . . Okamenela Iudeq, I s ka'dym migom tq'eleq, Ego ponikla golova. Stoqli voiny krugom Na stra'e stynu]ego tela_ Kak venhik, golova visela Na steble tonkom i hu'om. I carstvoval i niknul On, Kak liliq, v rodimyj omut, I glubina, gde stebli tonut, Tor'estvovala svoj zakon. Implacable words . . . Judea turned to stone, And, heavier by the moment, His head drooped down. Soldiers stood guard Around the body growing cold; His head hung like a halo On a frail and foreign stem. He reigned and He drooped, Like a lily, into his native pond And the depths where stems drown Celebrated their law.28
Mandelstam’s earliest lyrics return time and again to the figure of the poet-Christ, the figure who will prove to be, so he hopes, his point of entry both into what Gregory Freidin has called the kenotic tradition of Russian
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
121
• 29
poetry and into the larger traditions of Western culture. The Passion Plays the young poet stages, however, frequently look more like parodies than authentic calvaries, as Mandelstam himself implies in his descriptions of these poeticized travails. The cross that he bears is “delicate” and “light”; and the “cup” he drinks from is “heavy,” like Christ’s in the garden, but also “shallow” (#22, #19, #161).30 The adjectives suggest an imposter, a mock-Christ whose ordeal is closer to masquerade or child’s play than it is to cosmic drama. These early imitations of Christ, moreover, too often betray their derivative origins in previous, decadent versions of Christ’s Passion; they are pale imitations of Symbolist imitations of Christ and thus succeed neither as poetry nor myth. “Implacable words” is more daring in its ambitions and design. Freidin argues for this lyric as the final part of a triptych that includes the two pond poems, written in the same year.31 The pond that is the locus of his own struggles with his Jewish past is transported to the Judean desert, the birthplace of Christian history and myth. This transplanted pond continues, though, to harbor the unsettling sense of ambivalence that animates the other pond poems, and Mandelstam’s revised crucifixion takes on a peculiar, highly personal resonance in its new setting. Golgotha “has become Greek and universal,” Mandelstam claims in “Pushkin and Skriabin” (IV, 100)—but the Golgotha of “Implacable words” becomes specific, individual, and Jewish. A personal symbol of Mandelstam’s Jewish past becomes an emblem of Judaism as such, of the Hebrew faith from which Jesus and Christianity were born. It embodies the Old Testament and its reign of law, which gives way in the Christian tradition to the New Testament and the triumph of grace. “The soil of Rome” is “infertile,” Mandelstam warns in “Pushkin and Skriabin”; it is “stony” and “lacks grace (lishenaia blagodati )” (CPL, 94; II, 318). Judaism “stands behind” sterile, stony Rome, he warns in the same essay (IV, 100), and the Roman Judea of “Implacable words” has in fact been “turned to stone.” This landscape derives of course from the stony ground on which the seed that is Christ’s word falls and perishes (Matt. 13: 3–22; Mark 4: 5–16). In “Implacable words” Mandelstam attempts to revise the fate of the doomed seed, and to provide it, through his own words, with the fertile soil on which it will thrive. “The seed of [Christ’s] death, having fallen on the soil of Hellas, miraculously flourished,” Mandelstam proclaims in “Pushkin and Skriabin.” “Our entire culture has grown from this seed; we reckon our history from the moment when the soil of Hellas accepted that seed” (CPL, 94). The seed replanted in “Implacable words” will provide its sower with an equally rich culture and history—or so he hopes. “I am the gardener, I’m also the flower,” Mandelstam announces early on; and in “Implacable words” the poet-gardener tacitly draws our attention to the illustrious genealogy of the wounded reed he cultivates in the pond poems. “Noticed by no one, I droop (niknu) into my cold and boggy
122
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
refuge,” he mourns in “From an evil, miry pond” (#17); and this outcast reed is descended not only from Tiutchev and Pascal. The Messiah will be, Isaiah proclaims, “a bruised reed,” “a tender plant,” “despised and rejected of men” (Isaiah 42: 3, 53: 2–3); and “Implacable words” plays on the affinities between these two sensitive plants. It opens with a new version of the plant’s retreat from a world that will not receive it, a world that is hard- or “stony”-hearted, in the Russian idiom.32 In this lyric, Judea takes on the role that Russian gentile culture plays in the pond poems. And, as in the other lyrics, rejection by the longed-for outside world, whether Judean or Russian, results in the tender reed’s final defeat. “Judea turned to stone,/ And, growing heavier by the moment,/His head drooped down” (my italics), Mandelstam laments; and the conjunction that joins the second and third lines suggests a causal connection between Judea’s hard-heartedness and the downfall of the poem’s Christ.33 The New Testament’s Christ promises liberation from the past he fulfills: “For the law was given by Moses, but grace and truth came by Jesus Christ” (John 1:17); we are delivered “from the curse of the law” “by the body of Christ that we should serve in newness of spirit, and not in the oldness of the letter” (Romans 7:4–6; Galatians 3:13). One of the laws from which we are delivered is apparently the Fourth Commandment. “I have come to set a man at variance against his father,” Jesus proclaims, and Christ’s true disciple will “hate” and “forsake” his “house,” his “brethren” (Matt.: 10:35, 19:29; Luke 14:27). This Christ seems to offer a perfect model for a poet who seeks both to continue the past and to escape it, who works to replace his unchosen ancestry with a self-selected, “universal” family: “For whosoever shall do the will of my Father which is in heaven, the same is my brother, and sister, and mother,” Matthew’s Jesus promises (Matt. 12: 50). Mandelstam’s Christ, though, cannot free even himself from the past, let alone save those who would follow him. The prophet who is not honored in his native land withdraws to his “native pond” in the opening stanza, and the rest of the poem traces his descent into the dark places where life’s sources take back what they have given. The savior who was to defeat law with grace is himself defeated by law. Moses the lawgiver and Yahweh the maker of laws are once again victorious over Christ. The scenario of the pond poems is not a good fit with the biblical narrative, and the discrepancies between the two stories create an unsettling, finally unsatisfying poem. Mandelstam finds himself helpless before the force of the pond into which he casts the “seed” that is his Mandelstamian Christ, or Christ-like Mandelstam. His revised biblical narrative falls prey to the fatal influence of origins, as the weight of the past defeats the hoped-for resurrection. In this battle of gravity and grace, gravity has the final word. The poem’s ambiguous imagery suggests that this Christ’s fate is determined more by his author’s confused allegiances than it is by cosmic design. The emblems of Judaism, “stony” Judea, on the one hand, and the
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
123
“native pond,” on the other, take on opposing, seemingly irreconcilable forms in the poem. Judea, the historical homeland of the Jews, the birthplace of Christ, is as unwelcoming as Mandelstam’s “indifferent fatherland,” Russia, had been in other lyrics, and it is as different from his “native pond” as stone is from water. These two opposing forms of Jewishness join forces, though, to assure that the poet-Christ will be at ease neither on land nor in water. This Christ is already divided against himself in any case. The reed of the other pond poems has become a lily, made up of “head” (flower) and “stem” (body).34 The head, the flower, has presumably grown beyond the waters of the pond that is its home, and has learned to breathe “forbidden life,” to partake in the realm of grace. It has become a stranger to itself in the process, for the “stem” that joins it to its “native pond” is not only “frail” but “foreign.” Or perhaps both stem and blossom have grown “foreign” to their native source. In any case, the fragile plant cannot find a home in either world—the seed cast upon stony ground will perish no less surely than will the flower tethered to the “depths where stems drown.” This savior’s victory over death is predictably unconvincing; he “reigns” and “droops” in the same breath, and his reign ends, with the poem, in the triumph of the pond and its law, which is the law of Moses and of time’s backward flow. There is no hint here of the death that fertilizes life in “Sisters—heaviness and tenderness”—“A plough turns up time, and the rose once was earth” (#108), or of the poet who brings together stone and water through Christ’s body in the “Slate Ode” (1923)—“And I want to place my fingers into the flinty path/As into the wound, concluding the juncture/Of Flint and water” (#137).35 What is new in this version of Mandelstam’s battle with Judaism is the battle’s context, a context at once mythic and historical. Mandelstam himself underscores its importance in the passage from “Pushkin and Skriabin” I have already quoted, which reads in this context like a revised and annotated translation of the poem into prose. In this passage Rome, the holy city, Chaadaev’s Mecca and Mandelstam’s—“I took up my staff, rejoiced,/And set out for distant Rome” (#69)—appears in an unexpected role. It no longer continues Mandelstam’s cherished Hellas; it opposes it. But why should the Rome that is Christian culture’s heart in Stone become its enemy? According to the Gospels, Jesus was condemned by both Jewish and Roman courts, but it was the Romans who enacted the will of the Jewish priests by crucifying Christ. Jewish ecclesiastical law did therefore “stand behind,” or hide behind, the force of Roman civil law in Christ’s execution in the Gospels’ telling. Apart from biblical history, there is Mandelstam’s own history to consider. “It is not the city Rome that lives among the ages, but the human place in the universe,” he insists in an early lyric (#66). The capital of Mandelstam’s world culture changes more than once over the course of his career; and between Stone and Tristia, his allegiances shift from Catholicism and West-
124
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
ern Rome to Greece and its Russian descendant, the Orthodox Church.36 This shift is more a matter of orientation or tendency than of absolute repudiation of one faith and one tradition in favor of another: in Tristia ‘s final poem, the “eternal cathedrals” of St. Peter and Hagia Sophia stand united as vessels of a “universal good” (#124). This new direction may, however, partly explain Mandelstam’s condemnation of Rome in “Pushkin and Skriabin,” and the presence in the essay of the Roman soldiers who keep Christ from escaping the deadly embrace of Jewish law in “Implacable Words.” More important than Rome itself, though, is what Rome stands for, or rather, what “stands behind” Rome in both the essay and the poem. “The great Jewish revolts against Rome” in the first and second centuries A.D. were “at bottom a clash between Jewish and Greek culture,” Paul Johnson observes.37 The battle that Mandelstam orchestrates between Rome and Hellas likewise masks a deeper struggle—the struggle in history, in the Christian faith, and in Mandelstam’s created tradition, between Judaism and Hellenism. JUDAISM AND HELLENISM Could Judaism survive if Hellenism became dominant in the civilization of [Judah]? Or were the two spirits mutually exclusive and a menace to each other? —Abram Leon Sachar, A History of the Jews (1966) Ancient Israel was the exact opposite of Hellas. —Faddei Zelinsky, The Religion of Ancient Greece (1918) Hebraism and Hellenism,—between these two points of influence moves our world. —Matthew Arnold, Culture and Anarchy (1869)
“A simoon flew over the meadows and groves of Hellas; Hellas grew yellow and black.” The idea and the imagery could easily be Mandelstam’s—yellow and black were for him the emblems of his Jewish heritage and the Jewish faith.38 The phrase belongs, though, to Faddei Zelinsky (Tadeusz Zielinski) (1859–1944), the Polish classicist who taught at St. Petersburg University from 1885 to 1921. Zelinsky’s ideas influenced not only Mandelstam but his Symbolist predecessors Viacheslav Ivanov and Aleksandr Blok and his great contemporary Mikhail Bakhtin, who, like Mandelstam, attended Zelinsky’s lectures on classical culture at St. Petersburg University.39 Zelinsky’s interpretation of Hellenistic Greek culture attracted not only poets and philosophers; it captivated a generation of Russian intellectuals in search of “true community” in a disrupted age. As Katerina Clark and Michael Holquist note, these Russian “neo-Hellenists” saw important
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
125
parallels between the Hellenistic era and their own. In the Hellenistic epoch “the old lines separating nations, classes, families, races, and even sexes had faded,” and “a new social cosmos had to be created” to replace the old order that had vanished. The Hellenic solution to their age’s upheavals held an obvious appeal for postrevolutionary Russians in search of a new order. It was, in Paul Johnson’s phrase, “universalist culture,” or, in the Greek term, oikumene, “world civilization”: “Isocrates argued that ‘the designation Hellene is no longer a matter of descent but of attitude’; he thought Greeks by education had better titles to citizenship than ‘Greek by birth.’”40 It was Hellenism’s universalist vision that Zelinsky celebrated in his writings, and it was this vision that drew his followers living in a Russia torn by war and revolution. In “hospitable Hellas,” Zelinsky proclaims, “the community was an extended family,” and Hellas itself “was an extended community” built around a “common hearth (ochag).” This is the “Hellenistic” home that finds its way into Mandelstam’s poetic universe: “Hellenism is the warmth of the hearth (ochag) experienced as something sacred. . . . [it is] the humanizing and warming of the surrounding world with the most delicate teleological warmth” (CPL, 127–28). For both Zelinsky and Mandelstam, ancient Greece is an antidote to the ailments of the modern age. It provides a model for an era whose “centrifugal tendencies,” Zelinsky complains, “divide us from one another” and “introduce isolation and coldness where once there was shelter and warmth.”41 Zelinsky’s followers “saw the Hellenistic tradition as a part of the pedigree of the Russian religious tradition, which followed the Byzantine or Greek Orthodox Church rather than the Roman Catholic.” What actively opposes Hellenism in Zelinsky’s thought, though, is Judea, not Rome. His vision has its origins in the centuries-long strife that plagued the relations between Jewish and Greek culture from Alexander’s conquests in the fourth century B.C. until well after the death of Christ. What was at stake, Paul Johnson notes, were two equally ambitious, radically opposed versions of “universalism.” The Greeks, he writes, saw “the civilized universe (as opposed to the chaos beyond it) where their ideas prevailed, as a multiracial, multi-national society, and those who refused to accept it were enemies of man.” The Jews, on the other hand, found universal meaning in the One God who had chosen them and kept them apart from all other nations and faiths. Jewish reformers tried to find ways to bring the two cultures together, but the principles that guided them were finally irreconcilable. The “marriage between the Greek polis and the Jewish moral God” that these reformers envisioned did not and could not take place.42 The Jews, who “refused to associate with the rest of humanity,” were, one early chronicler concluded, “an inhospitable and anti-human” race.43 Romantic and postromantic historiographers and thinkers continued the arguments of Hebrew and Hellenes throughout the nineteenth century in their quest to locate the origins of Western culture, and these explorations
126
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
culminated in the writings of Friedrich Nietzsche (1844–1900), who was, like Zelinsky and Mandelstam, vitally concerned with the relation of the ancient world to an orphaned modern age: “At last one longs back for that place in which alone one can be at home . . . the Greek world,” he mourns in the Will to Power. Zelinsky was one of the first academic Nietzscheans in Europe, and like his master, he is preoccupied with Christianity’s mixed parentage, both Jewish and Greek, and the influence of this dual heritage on modern culture. Nietzsche, the self-proclaimed “anti-Christ and antiChristian,” aggressively prefers the Old Testament to the New—“I have the courage of my bad taste,” he writes—precisely because the New Testament is “not so much Jewish as Hellenistic” and so dilutes the strength of a great nation. When Zelinsky brought this debate to early-twentieth-century Russia, though, he actively sided with the “hospitable” Hellenes and was as partisan in his arguments as any ancient Greek.44 The issue on which Zelinsky based his case against the Judeans was one that crucially concerned Mandelstam. To compare the attitudes of the “two ancient peoples who most influenced modernity” “toward foreign cultures” would produce, he declares, “one of the most interesting and instructive pages of ancient history”; and Zelinsky proceeds to write this page in the light of his Hellenistic proclivities. The Jews, whose universal idea, monotheism, was founded on exclusiveness, are clearly the losers in Zelinsky’s modern version of the ancient conflict. The Jews “possess[ed] a tradition which traced their history in an uninterrupted succession of generations back to the very creation of the world,” a tradition in which “they were explicitly presented as chosen among nations and tribes” and so regarded “foreign cultures” “with hostility and disdain,” Zelinsky argues. Their deity, he claims, does much the same: “Jehovah [was] the tribal god of his ‘chosen people’ and recognized other nations only as the tools of his rewards or his punishments.” The Greek cosmogony, on the other hand, readily adopted foreign gods and allowed itself to be adapted in turn to the needs and beliefs of other nations. The Greek “was capable of the humane and tolerant idea that seemed so hard for the Semitic mind of Israel to grasp—namely that mankind might worship the same godhead under different names.” Zelinsky uses what he sees as a deep-rooted Jewish intolerance for other faiths to justify his distaste for the Hebrew faith, and he also uses it to explain “all the persecutions of the Jews that defile the history of the Christian religion.” These persecutions have their roots, he insists, in an Old Testament legacy of religious intolerance: the Jews, in other words, have only themselves to blame. Zelinsky’s anti-Semitism is the subtext of his version of ancient history, and Mandelstam’s borrowings from this revised history reveal the disturbing depths of his own response to his Jewish past.45 A more balanced scholar of Hellenism, writing at about the same time, noted that “whereas today the charge is made that the Jews are cosmopolitan in a national society, then the current complaint was that they were
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
127
national in a cosmopolitan society.” Mandelstam, whose vision of a universal culture can be traced in part to a modern Jewish sense of worldlessness, draws on Zelinsky’s argument to escape his Jewish origins. Indeed, according to this argument, this would be Mandelstam’s only hope of achieving the “Hellenistic,” Western tradition he craved. “The world belongs to the nation-disciple (narod-uchenik),” Zelinsky asserts in Christianity’s Rivals (Soperniki khristianstva; 1906/1910): “Whoever complacently proclaims that his nation’s period of discipleship has come to an end has sacrificed its future by that very act.” “Hellas,” he writes elsewhere, “regarded herself as the eternal disciple of almost all the nations with which fate brought her into contact.” Zelinsky’s Judea has, however, chosen to remain obstinately closed in its past; it is the same “unnatural” nation that strives, in Mandelstam’s vision, to turn back the flow of time.46 Zelinsky’s image of the “nation-disciple” takes us to the crux of his argument, which lies in the problem of Christianity’s true lineage and its rightful disciples and descendants. His studies are intended to fight “the fatal Judaization of Christianity,” to challenge what he perceives as the distorted and dangerous notion that Judaism is the chief, the crucial “stock from which Christianity grew.” Judaism is, he warns, the “negative source of Christianity”; it threatens the Hellenistic legacy that Christ introduced into the Hebrew tradition. Christ’s message, Zelinsky claims, was “a protest against Judean attachment to the letter of the Law, in the spirit of Hellenic liberty, Hellenic humanitarianism, the Hellenic filial relation to a god whom men love.” And this Hellenic legacy, Zelinsky argues, makes all Christians of whatever time or place the true “heirs of Hellenism.”47 In “The Ideology of the Jewish Question” (1915), Viacheslav Ivanov takes on would-be Hellenists like Zelinsky who choose to ignore Christian culture’s Jewish heritage in their subservience to the “cowardly and pernicious” “ideology of spiritual anti-semitism” in fashion. Such dubious doctrines, he argues, attempt to “hack off Christianity’s deepest root, its taproot”; they refuse to recognize that the church’s body has grown “from the seed of Abraham.” Mandelstam, however, disregards his former mentor as he creates his version of Christianity’s family tree. His Christianity, like Zelinsky’s, grows not from Judea’s stony soil but on the fertile ground of ancient Greece: “The seed of [Christ’s] death, having fallen on the soil of Hellas, miraculously flourished: our entire culture has grown from this seed” (CPL, 94). And those who partake of this Hellenic Christian culture become the ancient world’s “legitimate heir[s]”(CPL, 93). This revised version of Christianity’s origins allows Mandelstam in turn to escape the overbearing power of the “totalitarian” Old Testament God he fears and to replace this God with a “Hellenic filial relation to a god whom men love.” Mandelstam “used to say,” his widow notes, “that with its doctrine of the Trinity, Christianity had overthrown the Jewish God’s absolute rule,” and this is what Mandelstam himself attempts to do, with Zelinsky’s help, as he revises Christian history.48
128
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
In “Pushkin and Skriabin” Mandelstam embraces a vision of a filial relationship with a loving god divided, with the birth of Christ, into father, son and spirit. Christ’s sacrifice frees us for “joyous communion with God, like some game played by the Father and his children, some blind-man’s bluff or hide-and-seek of the spirit” (CPL, 91). The “profound revolution that turned Hellas into Europe” also transforms humanity’s, and Mandelstam’s, relation to his own past and creates a new bond between parent and child, between life and its sources. The past, redeemed by Christ, releases humans “into freedom” and into the future “for the sake of play,” for the sake of new, flexible, free relations with the “patriarchal paternal” origins of being (CPL, 92; POM, 130). This escape from the past’s dark power comes at a cost, though: the force of origins is not easily overcome. “We are free of the burden of memories,” Mandelstam exults in “The Word and Culture” (CPL, 113–14)—but his poems tell a different story. The unsettling network of history, family, and myth that Mandelstam develops in three intertwined poems from the period of Tristia (1922) testifies to the difficulty of casting off this burden and to the price that Mandelstam’s seeming release from the past exacts.49 I have mentioned that Mandelstam moves the capital of world culture from Rome to Greece in Tristia, and Tristia’s Jewish sequence—“This night is irreparable” (1916; #91), “A young Levite among the priests” (1917; #100), and “Return to the incestuous womb” (1920; #109)—plays a crucial role in enabling him to make this shift. In this sequence Mandelstam creates the mythological framework that permits him to claim the legacy of the Greek world whose legends and myths give the collection its cohesion and power. Within these lyrics Mandelstam develops, with Zelinsky’s help, the historical and mythical scenario that enables him to resist the force of origins, to use his Jewish past as a bridge into “Hellenic,” Christian culture and, finally, to reject that past, not ostensibly because of his discomfort with it, but because of its inadequacy as history and myth.50 ?to noh; nepopravima, A u vas e]e svetlo. U vorot Erusalima Solnce hernoe vzowlo. Solnce 'eltoe strawneeó Ba[ ba[wki ba[ó V svetlom xrame iudei Xoronili mat; mo[. Blagodati ne imeq I svq]enstva liweny, V svetlom xrame iudei Otpevali prax 'eny.
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
I nad mater;[ zveneli Golosa izrail;tqn. Q prosnulsq v kolybeli, Hernym solncem osiqn. This night is irreparable, But you are still in light. By Jerusalem’s gates A black sun rose. The yellow sun is still more awful Lulla lulla lullaby— In a lighted temple Judeans Were burying my mother. Deprived of grace And lacking priests, Judeans in a lighted temple Laid to rest a woman’s dust. And over the mother rang Voices of the Israelites. I awakened in a cradle Illuminated by the black sun.
Sredi svq]ennikov levitom molodym Na stra'e utrennej on dolgo ostavalsq. Noh; iudejskaq sgu]alasq nad nim I xram razruwennyj ugr[mo sozidalsq. On govoril% nebes trevo'na 'eltizna. U' nad Efratom noh;, begite, ierei@ A starcy dumali% ne nawa v tom vina_ Se herno'eltyj svet, se radost; Iudei. On s nami byl, kogda na beregu ruh;q My v dragocennyj len Subbotu pelenali I semisve]nikom tq'elym osve]ali Erusalima noh; i had nebytiq. A young Levite among the priests He stayed long on the morning watch. The Judean night grew thick above him And the shattered temple gloomily arose. He said: the skies’ yellow is alarming. Night has already fallen over the Euphrates; run, priests! But the elders thought: It is not our fault; This black-yellow light, this joy of Judea.
129
130
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
He was with us, when on the stream’s banks We swaddled the Sabbath in precious linen And illuminated with a heavy menorrah Jerusalem’s night and the fumes of non-being.
Vernis; v smesitel;noe lono, Otkuda, Liq, ty priwla, Za to, hto solncu Iliona Ty 'eltyj sumrak predpohla. Idi, nikto tebq ne tronet, Na grud; otca v gluxu[ noh; Puskaj glavu svo[ uronit Krovosmesitel;nica-doh;. No rokovaq peremena V tebe ispolnitsq dol'na% Ty budew; Liqóne Elena,ó Ne potomu narehena, Hto carskoj krovi tq'elee Struitsq v 'ilax hem drugojó Net, ty pol[biw; iudeq, Isheznew; v nemói Bog s toboj. Return to the incestuous womb, Whence, Leah, thou hast issued, Because to the sun of Ilium Thou has preferred the yellow dusk. Go, no one shall touch thee; To your father’s bosom, to deep night, Let the incestuous daughter Cast her head down. But a fateful transformation Should be fulfilled in thee: Leah thou shalt be, not Helen, Named, not because Royal blood flows more heavily In veins than any other— No, thou shalt come to love a Judean, Will vanish in him—and Godspeed.51
Tristia’s Jewish poems were written over the course of several years, from 1916 to 1920. These dates also mark the period of Russia’s own great transformation, a transformation achieved at enormous cost through world war, revolution, and civil strife. The outcome of this prolonged, unpredict-
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
131
able series of cataclysms, though it could not be foreseen in 1917 or 1920, would be neither Hellas, nor Europe, but something entirely, unnervingly new. The struggles of fathers and sons, of past, present, and future, became crucial and universal during the revolutionary period in ways that a poet as keenly attuned to the noise of his times as Mandelstam could not fail to grasp and exploit in his writings; and I will return to Russia and revolution as a context for these poems at a later point in this chapter. “This night is irreparable” emerged near the end of Russia’s involvement in the European war. “A young Levite” appeared on the heels of the revolution, in November of 1917. “Return to the incestuous womb” was written during the height of the Russian Civil War. Seen in this light, the Jewish sequence might seem to have been dictated by the age’s upheavals. Its opening and closing poems were prompted, though, not by politics but by deeply personal events: the death of Mandelstam’s mother and separation from the woman who would later become his wife, as Nadezhda Mandelstam writes. Although the poems themselves were chronologically divided by the seismic convulsions of the revolutionary era, the impulse that runs through them is recognizably the same. They are bound together by problems, imagery, and tactics that Mandelstam had first explored in “Implacable words” and “Pushkin and Skriabin” and that he now puts, for the first time, into truly effective poetic and mythopoetic practice.52 The poems themselves mark a progression in more than one sense. Mandelstam shapes yet another version of his poetic autobiography in these lyrics, in which he moves from infancy (“I awakened in a cradle”) to youth, as he becomes the “young Levite among the priests,” and finally, to manhood and the prospects of marriage in “Return to the incestuous womb.” They also mark an apparent growth in Mandelstam’s confidence, an increased assurance in his capacities to do battle with his stubborn, recalcitrant past. His success in shaping a cohesive, mythologized history from his family past is due in part to the new way he finds to place his voice and self in relation to Christ’s Passion. Mandelstam himself no longer occupies center stage. His quest to transform his Jewish origins no longer fuses completely with Christ’s mission to redeem Jewish history and revise the Jewish faith through suffering and sacrifice. “Having endowed us with inner freedom, Russia offers us a choice, and those who make this choice are true Russians,” Mandelstam proclaims in “Petr Chaadaev” (CPL, 89). In “Implacable words” and “I’ve become afraid of living life out,” the force of a Jewish past proves irresistible and the mark of a Jewish birth cannot be erased. In the later Jewish poems, identity, whether Jewish or Christian, is no longer innate. It is, like Russianness, chosen or created, freely elected. Christ’s fate is foreordained. The witness to Christ’s destiny, though, may choose to accept its meaning and message or to reject them; he may recognize the forces of radical historical transformation or remain forever fixed in an unenlightened past. Mandelstam allies himself in these poems not with Christ himself, with the agent and embodiment of historical
132
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
change, but with Jesus’ Jewish contemporaries, who were free to side with the Jewish world, which resisted rebirth, or with the “Hellenic,” Christian world that embraced it. Mandelstam would later admit that his past could not and should not be replaced, as he learns to weave his Jewish heritage into his adopted Russian and European traditions. For the Mandelstam of Tristia, working under Zelinsky’s influence, this is not an option. He is given a choice—but this choice is absolute. He may embrace Judaism or its bastard child, a “fatally Judaized” Christianity, or accept a true, “Hellenic” Christian faith that has wholly disowned its unfortunate origins. He cannot have both, and he cannot fuse the two into a new, synthetic faith to match his “synthetic nationality” (CPL, 88).53 The cost of this choice is clear in “This night is irreparable,” which recreates the funeral of Mandelstam’s mother, who had died of a heart attack earlier that year.54 Mandelstam’s private life ordinarily informs his poetic writings in oblique, frequently irretrievable ways; the autobiographical impulse behind the poetic text is seldom readily available to his reader. “I am not interested in my kinfolk,” the young Mandelstam reportedly told a friend, and his poems are populated not by the “kin and dull neighbors” that a misguided fate has sent him, but by the adoptive family he appropriates from other times and places.55 His mother’s funeral as the pretext for a lyric marks a startling departure from Mandelstam’s usual poetic practice. The death of a loved one might seem to be the stuff of which lyric poems are made; but Mandelstam’s lyric gifts work in entirely different ways. The death of Mandelstam’s mother does not produce the expected elegy. It leads instead to a new variant of the mythologized biography that Mandelstam constructs for himself around the life of Christ and the birth of Christianity. François Villon contains in himself both mother and child, so Mandelstam tells us (CPL, 56). Mandelstam’s new version of the poet as “lyrical hermaphrodite” is chillingly literal. He transposes his mother’s funeral to the time and place of Christianity’s birth, and he himself is reborn with the advent of the new faith. The death of his mother in its Judean context allows Mandelstam to replace the “womb world” of his origins as he becomes both parent and child to himself; he is free to be fully reborn. The poem’s mythic vision commemorates liberation, not loss. The self that is tethered to the “dear silt” of its family past can never be entirely reborn: “Stand by the bedside with pretended tenderness,/And sing yourself lullabies your whole life (I sam sebia vsiu zhizn’ baiukai)” (#18). In “This Night” Mandelstam apparently succeeds where his younger self had failed. The lullaby that accompanies his mother’s funeral in the second stanza—“Lulla lulla lullaby (Baiu baiushki baiu)”—marks not bondage to the world of his birth, but new birth and new beginnings. Indeed, his mother’s three incarnations in the poem show Mandelstam in the process of severing his bonds from an unwanted parent and past.56 In the poem’s second stanza, the mother is intimately, obviously tied to her son: “Judeans were burying my mother” (my italics). In the third stanza,
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
133
the Judeans lament what is only “a woman’s dust.” By the poem’s final stanza, the dead woman is once again “a mother,” but not, it would seem, the poet’s. She exemplifies the Jewish mother as such, the mother through whom Jewishness is transmitted, according to tradition, and her bond now lies with the Israelites who mourn her, not with the man who had been her child. Only after this process is finished, in the poem’s final lines, can the poem’s “I” emerge: “I awakened in a cradle/Illuminated by the black sun” (my italics). As long as the poet’s self is bound to the world of its birth, it cannot exist in its own right. The “I” that lies hidden behind the pronoun my—“my mother”—can appear full-fledged only after it has broken its bond with “congenital” Jewishness and replaced it with another, selfchosen past and future. “Whoever is within the Church must love Mary; and whoever loves Mary, must also love Israel like his own mother,” Viacheslav Ivanov proclaims.57 For Mandelstam these two loves are opposed. In his lyric he takes the central emblems of the Christian faith—a mother, a son, a birth, and a death—and reworks them to create a version of Christian rebirth that allows him to cast off his unwanted “mother Israel”; he shapes his own inverted variant of the Pieta, in which the mourning mother cradling her lifeless son is replaced by the reborn son who shuns his mother’s corpse. Such warped conflations of biblical and personal narratives run throughout the lyric that marks Mandelstam’s poetic declaration of independence from his Jewish past. His mother’s actual funeral is translated in verse to a distant time and place, as St. Petersburg and its assimilated Jews are transformed: Judeans and Israelites mourn the mother, while the son keeps watch by Jerusalem’s gates. The death and birth the poem describes are charged with new import in this richly resonant context. The poem is illuminated by both a “yellow” and a “black” sun; and the second of these leads to the scene’s essence. The “darkened sun,” biblical scholars tell us, “signal[s] divine intervention in history”; its appearance prefigures “cosmic transformation” and “a transition to a radically different world order.” The sun whose light irradiates the reborn Mandelstam is, as Ronen notes, “the black sun of Apocalyptic Christianity.” The Gospels report that in the sixth hour of Christ’s crucifixion darkness covered the earth: “And the sun was darkened, and the veil of the temple was rent” (Luke 23: 45). The sky will grow dark again, Christ warns, before his second coming: “The sun shall be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light” (Mark 13: 24). The poem’s Judea does not recognize the black sun that spells the end of one era and the beginning of the next. It cannot see the sign that marks the birth of a new time and that presages humankind’s final salvation. The poem’s Israelites are trapped in the light of the yellow sun; they are governed by repetition, by a time that will not yield to cosmic revelation. The yellow sun’s unvaried cycles thus become another form of the unnatural motion that imprisons Mandelstam’s Judaism in a stern and sterile past.58
134
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
“This night” ’s Judea may elect to remain bound to ritual and repetition, to Old Testament Law and a death unredeemed by grace. Judea’s offspring, though, are free to turn their backs on their parentage and past, as they embrace the discipleship their nation has disdained. The Gospels’ Christ encourages such insurrection. “Think not that I am come to send peace on earth; I came not to send peace, but a sword,” he warns in Matthew. The peace he disrupts is not among nations, but within them, and the sword he sends will sever the ties that bind parent to child: “I am come to set a man at variance against his father, and the daughter against her mother,” for “a man’s foes shall be those of his own household” (Matt. 10: 34–36). Luke’s Jesus is still harsher: “If any man come to me, and hate not his father, and mother . . . he cannot be my disciple” (Luke 14: 26). This Christ countermands the force of the Old Testament’s Fourth Commandment. His disciples must use their newfound freedom to abandon the past for the future. This is the freedom that Mandelstam exploits in “This night is irreparable.” The Mandelstam of the early poems cannot resist the terrible, intimate pull of his origins. The later poet, who identifies his plight with Christianity’s struggle to emerge from its Jewish sources, is entitled to deny his family and its history. Indeed, he can be reborn only by leaving the dead to bury the dead, by abandoning his mother to the benighted Israelites. The act may seem as awful, unnatural, and extreme as anything Mandelstam ascribes to Judea, but it is undertaken on the highest authority. He is following the dictates of Christ himself and the dictates of Christian history, as seen through the distorting lens of Zelinsky’s writings. Within the polarized world of “This night,” lit by the light of two wholly opposing suns, Mandelstam gives himself no other choice. To behave in any other way would mean to relinquish both Hellas and Europe. It would mean to succumb once more to time’s backward flow and be consumed by it. In his letter to the Romans, Paul rebukes the Jews who refuse the crisis and conversion he himself has undergone: “Behold, thou art called a Jew, and restest in the law, and makest thy boast of God. . . . And art confident that thou thyself art a guide of the blind, a light of them which are in darkness” (Romans 2: 17–19). In “This night is irreparable,” Mandelstam likewise repudiates those who refuse the dark night that must precede the appearance of true light. The poem is shaped by oppositions—light and darkness, death and birth—and the poem’s “I” derives from these opposing forces. Unlike Mandelstam’s Villon and Notre Dame, who grow from the yoking of opposites, this “I” evolves from its ability to distance itself from the forces it resists: from the mother turned to dust; from the first stanza’s “you” (u vas), who become a “they,” the alien Judeans and Israelites of later stanzas; and from the world of death and deceptive light they inhabit. The newly emerged “I” of the poem’s end is born into isolation, though. Having abandoned parents and past, this “I” has yet to find the new community that will take their place.
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
135
This is the task of the young Levite who is the hero of the next poem in this sequence, “A young Levite among the priests.” In “This night is irreparable,” Mandelstam manages to combine two Jewish pasts, his own and Christianity’s, and to cast them off simultaneously. Having freed himself, so it seems, from this double burden, he is able to elaborate more fully the historical mythology that has helped to liberate him, and he can now expel from this mythology the powerful, personal ghost who haunts “This night.” Through the young Levite who is his proxy, Mandelstam can distance himself still further from the past’s doomed company as he establishes new bonds with the community of the future.59 Unlike the implicit “I” who narrates “This night is irreparable,” the Levite seeks to warn his heedless compatriots—“Night has already fallen over the Euphrates; run, priests!”—and abandons them only when they refuse his message. He is justified, then, in his flight from the past; he has done what he could to open that past to the future. Having broken with the old priesthood, the Levite turns to a new order, to the “we” whom he joins in the poem’s final stanza. This new priesthood does not preside over what has already passed; it assists at the birth of the future. It helps to plant the seed of Christ’s death in new and fertile soil. The “Sabbath” swathed in linen in the final stanza is Christ himself, whose disciples wrapped him after death in “clean linen cloth” (Matthew 27: 59).60 Mandelstam’s image, though, holds birth as well as death. The verb he uses, “to swaddle” (pelenat’), evokes life’s beginnings, not its end, and draws us back to Christ’s own birth: “Ye shall find this babe wrapped in swaddling clothes” (Luke 2: 12). It reminds us, too, that the Russian for “shroud,” pelena, is only two letters removed from the “swaddling clothes,” pelenki, in which the infant Christ was wrapped. It is not Christ alone who will emerge renewed from death; time itself will be transformed through his resurrection. The Jewish holy day, the Sabbath (subbota), which stands for the crucified Christ in the poem, will be reborn with him. More precisely, its priority and its sanctity will be superseded by the new day that will dawn with the risen Christ. Time itself will shift; a new age will begin with Christ’s return from the dead; and the Jewish calendar will find itself quite literally outdated. The Sabbath will become a mere stepping stone to Sunday, whose Russian name is “resurrection,” voskresen’e. Though they help to bring the new age into being, the Levite and his companions remain on the verge of the coming era, “at the dawn of some new life” (#104); they have not yet crossed over with Christ into the future. Perhaps this is why they still rely on Jewish rites and implements—the fourth’s stanza’s “heavy menorrah”—to ward off Judaism’s dark power, “Jerusalem’s night and the fumes of non-being.” The poet who speaks in “Return to the incestuous womb” (1920; #109) has seen the new age dawn and knows that it is lighted by a Greek sun, the “sun of Ilium” (Ilium is the Greek name for Troy). The new world marks the triumph of a
136
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
Hellenism that remains beyond the poet’s range of vision in the earlier lyrics. The poet himself, moreover, has apparently mastered the power of the past that had threatened to undo not only him but Christendom and Hellas itself, according to the mythology he has constructed. He discovers the magic spell that eluded the poet of “I’ve become afraid of living life out,” and his word blocks time’s backward flow. More than this—time stops and starts at his command. It is he who orders Leah to return to her source, to the womb (or breast, or lap; the Russian lono is notoriously vague and can designate almost anything beneath the shoulders and above the knees) whence she came. The power that emanated earlier from Yahweh or the Law, from Jewish origins in their different forms, now issues from the poet himself. His new voice holds a prophet’s force, and with it he can turn back time’s motion and free himself from the past’s destructive pull. This pull has also undergone a change. It is not only destructive: it is immoral, taboo, the illicit coupling of past and present. It is incestuous. “Return to the incestuous breast whence thou hast issued,” the poet commands the Hebrew Leah. He identifies the excessive Jewish attachment to the past with a specific sin, and his speech derives its prophetic strength from the gravity of Judaism’s failing. The biblical stories Mandelstam evokes in the poem testify to the dangerous force of family, to kinship as a curse, not as a blessing. The Old Testament Leah joins in her father’s plotting against Jacob, who becomes her husband through deception and intrigue (Gen. 29: 1–25). The poem’s speaker, from this point of view, is rewriting biblical history. Unlike the long-suffering Jacob of Genesis, he rejects his unwanted bride and returns her to her deceitful or, more precisely, incestuous father’s breast. For Mandelstam has revised his version of the tale in a still more radical way. The sin of the father and of the unloved bride is no longer deceit alone, but the far greater evil of incest. Mandelstam borrows this sin from another biblical story of fathers, daughters, and deception. Nadezhda Mandelstam notes that he combines two erring daughters to create his Leah, and his Old Testament vision brings two neighboring chapters of Genesis and two different family romances together.61 The poem’s second source is the story of Lot. After the downfall of Sodom and Gomorrah and the punishment of Lot’s wife, his daughters sought to “preserve seed” of their father by setting him drunk and “lying with him” (Gen. 19: 12–34). The story is a cautionary tale on the uses and abuses of the past in a double sense. Through his destruction of the unholy cities Sodom and Gomorrah, the Hebrew God teaches that a debased past must be wholly purged from hearts and minds as well as from the earth. “Look not behind thee,” he commands as Lot and his family flee the doomed cities. Lot’s wife, who disobeys and looks back to see what she has lost, forfeits life itself and is turned to lifeless matter. Lot’s daughters, who work to preserve their father’s seed in false and sinful ways, are seemingly no less guilty: they too turn to the past instead of toward the
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
137
future. Unlike their mother, though, they are not punished. In Genesis Lot’s daughters bear sons by their father and so begin new nations. Mandelstam’s Leah, on the other hand, has chosen extinction in choosing the past: “Thou shalt come to love a Judean/[And] will vanish (izcheznesh’) in him.” Hers is the fate that the hapless poet of “I’ve become afraid of living life out” struggles to avoid. She will vanish, as he had feared to, into the all-consuming vortex of Jewish origins. In the light of these Old Testament narratives—to say nothing of the cautionary tale that is the poem itself—it is surprising to find Nadezhda Mandelstam supplying us not only with the poem’s biblical keys, but with what she sees as its real-life prototypes. She herself, she writes, was the inspiration for the poem, and Mandelstam played Judean father to her erring Leah: “Our relationship must have aroused in him a keen awareness of his Jewish roots, a tribal feeling, a sense of kinship with his people (rodovoi moment, chuvstvo sviazi s rodom).” Mandelstam himself “used to say,” she notes elsewhere, “that all Jews are related by blood, and that all marriages between Jews are incestuous”; “He thought of the Jews as one family, hence the theme of incest in the poem.”62 Several critics, most notably Omry Ronen and Gregory Freidin, have followed Nadezhda Mandelstam’s lead in reading the lyric as Mandelstam’s attempted reconciliation with his Jewish legacy, with incest as a somewhat idiosyncratic metaphor for intimacy and affection.63 The poem itself seems to militate against such a reading. Its dramatis personae comprise not two figures, as Nadezhda Mandelstam implies, but three: a father, a daughter, and the speaker, who seeks with great energy and conviction to distance himself from the sinning couple. His prophetic rhetoric suggests not greater closeness to a Jewish past but moral revulsion from it. Far from marking the beginning of Mandelstam’s reconciliation with his past, the poem marks the apogee of the “creative self-hatred” that animates the Jewish sequence. The image of incest also works against Nadezhda Mandelstam’s interpretation: psychologically, it evokes not secure and friendly familial warmth, but a family come entirely too close for comfort. More discomfiting still are the likely sources of Mandelstam’s imagery. Far from being idiosyncratic or personal, the charge of Jewish “incest” had become a stock accusation leveled by anti-Semites against an “inbred race” by the end of the nineteenth century. “They are themselves the cause of their own downfall through their perverse sexuality and . . . their degeneracy is the outward sign of their fall from grace,” one fin de siècle pamphleteer claims; and the biblical rhetoric of downfall and grace has a familiar ring to the reader of Mandelstam. This notion of Jewish insularity and inbreeding is, moreover, perfectly consonant with the vision of ancient history that Mandelstam takes from Zelinsky. Zelinsky does not accuse the Jews of incest as such, but their great fault in his eyes is their obstinate refusal to mingle with other races, unlike the “hospitable” Greeks. Mandelstam combines Zelinsky’s complaints of “Semitic exclusiveness” with anti-Semitic rhetoric
138
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
and his own uneasy sense of a possessive, threatening past to create an image in which family and faith conspire together with time’s perverse backward flow, in which offspring willingly (“thou shalt come to love a Judean”), wrongfully return to their origins. The poet who resists such a past is not willfully abandoning family and faith. He is escaping mortal sin.64 Moreover, the poem’s larger context—“Pushkin and Skriabin,” the Jewish cycle, indeed, the whole of Tristia—speaks for Mandelstam’s choice of Ilium’s sun over Judaic darkness. “A fateful transformation should be fulfilled in thee,” the poet-prophet reproaches his Leah; and this transformation echoes the “profound revolution” that “turned Hellas into Europe,” as it fertilized Judea’s stony soil with the seed of Hellenic grace (CPL, 92). This kind of cultural crossbreeding is the corrective Mandelstam seeks from Jewish “incestuousness.” The crucifixion, Mandelstam insists, made at least one part of “graceless” Judea “Greek and universal” (IV, 100), and this part must be saved from fatal Judaic provincialism, from the insular, inbred faith that rejoices in its backwardness. Mandelstam’s Leah is the emblem of this unnatural motion. She chooses the “womb world whence [she] issued” over “Ilium’s sun.” She prefers her Jewish name to the Greek name, Helen, that would place her at the heart of Western culture; she resists the christening that would take her, with her people, from arid Judea to a new, “Greek and universal” world.65 “If not for Helen/ What is Troy alone to you, Achaian men?” Mandelstam asks in an early poem (#78), and he observes in the same poem that “all is moved by love.” Helen is the fateful catalyst that literally set Greek culture in motion, by inspiring the great epic with which Western literature begins. She is the antithesis of the Hebrew Leah who retreats into the past. To a creative etymologist like Mandelstam, the phonic echoes between Helen (Elena) and Hellas (Ellada) would have seemed no accident. Helen’s name resonates in the name of the culture, Hellenism (ellinizm), and the process, Hellenization (ellinizatsia), through which he seeks to work his way into world culture. Though its origins are utterly different, Leah’s name (Liia) is acoustically kindred to that of the queen she chooses not to become, Helen, and the country she chooses not to join, Hellas. The name alone seems to lend itself to the creation of a new genealogy and etymology that would run from Leah to Elena, and from there on to the modern muses whom Mandelstam celebrates in “Solominka” (1916): Lenor, Ligeia, Salomeia, Seraphita, Solominka (#86). Yet Leah refuses her new incarnation and will participate neither in the revolution that turns Hellas into Europe, nor in the series of transformations that keep Helen alive in modern European culture, and Mandelstam makes it clear that Leah’s fate is choice, not destiny. She will keep her name not because it is preordained by her parentage, by the pull of her Jewish blood: “Leah thou shalt be, not Helen, named,/not because/Royal blood flows more heavily/In veins than any other.” She will remain Leah because
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
139
she has chosen incest, because she will mix her blood with Jewish blood alone: “Thou shalt come to love a Judean.” The Russian for “incest,” krovosmeshenie, means literally the mixing of blood. The mixture, though, is of like with like, of kin with kin. What Mandelstam seeks is the creation of new, synthetic families. He strives for the intermingling of foreign and native, of different ages, races, and nations: his aim is not incest but miscegenation. This is what Leah rejects, and this is why Mandelstam rejects Leah and all that she represents.66 We must remember, though, that Mandelstam has created in the Jewish poems of Tristia, a Judaism that conforms to his own fears and fulfills his own purposes. He shapes a Jewish mother and, in Leah, a Jewish muse whom he must reject if he is to survive himself, and he creates a scenario in which such rejection seems justified, necessary, even sacred. Though the Mandelstam of Stone embraces foreignness, he works to discard the sources of his own foreign nature. In “Pushkin and Skriabin” and the “Jewish” poems of Tristia, he apparently finds a formula that delivers him at last from his bonds with his past. He has invented, with Zelinsky’s help, a history that permits him to turn his back forever on his Jewish beginnings. This is not, however, what finally happens. The Mandelstam of “Fourth Prose” (1929) takes up the weight of the past he had earlier sought to abandon. “I am proud,” he writes, “[of] the honorable calling of Jew,” and his “blood,” he boasts, is “burdened with the heritage of sheep-breeders, patriarchs, and kings” (CPL, 321). This is the heavy, inbred Jewish blood he had scorned in “Return to the incestuous breast,” and it is burdened with the weight of the Old Testament legacy he had worked so hard to escape. The reasons for this remarkable reversal form the subject of another chapter. Perhaps it was inevitable, though, that a poet so devoted to taking up the weight of other pasts and converting them to new energy would return to the burden of his own inheritance and find in it new sources of poetic strength. “Return to the incestuous breast,” Mandelstam bids his Leah as he turns from the past that she embraces. His own poetics, though, is based on the notion of return—on the present’s endless return to the past, on the eternal resurgence of the past within the present, and on the vital exchange that must govern the relations between other ages and our own. Mandelstam’s poet, determined to remember as well as invent, serves as midwife at the past’s rebirth within the present. He instigates exchange at the line that divides past from future.67 “Who stops the sun as it rushes along its sparrow harness to its paternal home, possessed by the desire to return?” (“The Word and Culture,” 1921; CPL, 112). This desire to harness time’s backward flow is part of the very fabric of Mandelstam’s poetics, and he cannot reject this part without undoing the whole. The poet who remembers and invents other histories so skillfully in Tristia has not yet brought this dialectic to bear on his personal past. He reinvents his family history in order to disregard it and thus free himself to acquire new memories. He learns to create, with his fellow
140
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
Acmeists, from the “evil weight” of fallen matter, but he cannot come to terms with the weight of his own history-laden blood. Mandelstam’s Judaism, insular, stubborn, and sterile, is the antithesis of his fruitful, hospitable Hellas. His Leah will not become Helen, and Ilium’s sun cannot penetrate Judaic dusk. The two worlds are worlds apart, and Mandelstam must and does choose between them. The line that divides Judea from Hellas blurs, however, when seen in the context of Tristia as a whole. Here, as elsewhere, “the influence of Judaism” seeps into Mandelstam’s writing in unexpected ways, and he uses it to serve his purposes even as he openly works against its influence. In “Return to the incestuous womb,” incest is the sin of the obstinate Judeans, locked in an unyielding past that turns back endlessly on itself. Tristia begins, however, with incest not among the retrograde Jews, but among the forward-looking Greeks. It opens with Mandelstam’s reenactment of a Greek tragedy, Euripides’ Hippolytus, as transmitted through neoclassical France by way of Jean Racine’s Phèdre (1677). Phaedra, wife of Theseus and granddaughter of the Sun itself, destroys and is destroyed through her guilty love for her stepson Hippolytus. Phaedra’s illicit love is unrequited and unconsummated. Her lofty lineage is nonetheless infected by her sin, whose evil influence extends to the “Sacred Sun” itself, to the “great elder of [her] race.” The crime of incest is not confined to Judea alone, it would seem. Through Phaedra it taints ancient Greece, and through Euripides and Racine it enters into the culture of Hellas-turned-Europe, the culture to which Mandelstam elsewhere opposes his Judea.68 Why should Mandelstam choose to connect the “Judean” sin of incest with his beloved Hellas? Why should he, through Racine, bring this sin into the European tradition he seemingly wishes to purge of any trace of his own past? The answer lies in a strategy that we have seen at work before in the life that Mandelstam shapes for himself in his writing. The Mandelstam of Stone and Tristia works to free himself from the burden of the past he has inherited, and to appropriate a broader, more synthetic legacy made up of Russia, Europe, and antiquity. At the same time, the “Judaic chaos” that has no openly acknowledged place in Mandelstam’s life in art becomes the de facto basis for his appropriation of alien cultures and histories.69 Mandelstam’s unwanted biography, revised and writ large, becomes his tie to all history. Mandelstam uses the sin that symbolizes Jewish insularity, Jewish wrongheadedness and exclusiveness, to similar ends, as the story of Phaedra discloses that perilous origins are not the property of Judaism alone. Racine’s Phaedra sees the Theseus she had married, the young man she had loved, alive again in his son: “He is not dead; he breathes in you./ My husband still seems present to my view.”70 In confusing father and son, Phaedra blurs the line that divides generations. She violates the code that prevents the unnatural, destructive mingling of parents and children, of past and future. Her stepson’s life is the price for her passion, and with him dies the future, or at least the future of the house of Theseus. Phaedra be-
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
141
comes, like Mandelstam’s Judaism, an unnatural parent, a consuming “womb world” willing to destroy both present and future for the sake of its destructive appetites. “Fear your mother, Hippolytus,” Mandelstam’s chorus bids Phaedra’s unwitting stepson (#82).71 Hippolytus’s unhappy fate seems to vindicate Mandelstam’s choice in “This night is irreparable,” his decision to flee a mother and a culture doomed to remain in darkness, or rather, false light. Unlike Hippolytus, he has the foresight, the good fortune, and the will to escape a fatally possessive past. The myth of Phaedra, however, does not simply reinforce Mandelstam’s myth about his and Christianity’s emergence from Jewish origins. One myth enhances the other; Phaedra gives Mandelstam’s Judeo-Christian myth new dimensions, new meanings and connections. The myth that results is a hybrid in more ways than one. Mandelstam ties his personal past to a mythologized version of Christianity’s growth from Jewish roots, and he combines this myth with that of Phaedra to create a paradigm of the present’s ceaseless struggle to emerge from a treacherous past, a plot that is not confined to any one time or place. Within this encompassing myth, he creates a model in which children must abandon oppressive, overwhelming parents, or, to translate the language of kinship into the language of time, a model in which present and future must be set free from the force of a devouring past. And he finds in this hybrid myth both the justification and the means for his own escape from treacherous origins. By combining myths of incest from two different races and nations, he is able to crossbreed two incestuous families, as the Judean race and the family of the unfortunate Phaedra intertwine in his reworked histories. But the stories of Phaedra and Judea do not simply provide an escape route out of one undesirable past into other, more attractive histories, and Mandelstam does not exploit it for its denouement alone. He imports the whole paradigm into the present, as he uses the complex narrative he has shaped as a way to enter the present of twentieth-century Russia, and as a means, potentially at least, of locating himself within its future.72 Mandelstam’s Phaedra, like his Judea, perverts time’s proper flow. She turns time back on itself and thwarts its forward motion. Mandelstam makes this connection clear in the passage from “Pushkin and Skriabin” in which he warns that “Greek and universal” Golgotha must be saved from Judea’s fatal force. Thusfar I have abbreviated the fragment’s final sentence in quoting it. In its closing phrase, Mandelstam explicitly allies the two forces that work in his composite myth to defeat time’s flow: “Judaism is only awaiting the hour when it will celebrate its awful, unnatural motion: history will turn back the flow of time—Phaedra’s black sun” (IV, 100). This black sun is not the apocalyptic Christian sun that promises new birth and new life. It is that sun’s antithesis, not “the sun of redemption, but the sun of guilt” (CPL, 91), the emblem of “unnatural” time thrown in reverse. Through her sin and her perversion of time, Phaedra has blemished her own lineage: “I have stained the sun with my black love,” she
142
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
laments in Mandelstam’s lyric (#82). Hers is a sun of sin and tainted origins, “the sun of guilt and doom,”73 and its light, like Judea’s yellow light, is unnatural. In “Pushkin and Skriabin” Mandelstam tacitly creates an alternate, inverted genealogy made up of those forces in history and culture that obstruct time’s flow and threaten its regeneration; this perverse and negative muse might be called Judea-Phaedra. Mandelstam links another name with Phaedra, and obliquely with Judea, elsewhere in the essay. His adoptive homeland is apparently in danger of succumbing to the fatal force that has enslaved his native past, and in “Pushkin and Skriabin,” he gives us a Russia created in his own image, “Russia, as baptized Jew, lapsing back into the religion that Christianity has already superseded.”74 “Time can go backward,” Mandelstam warns his spiritual homeland, “Phaedra-Russia” (CPL, 90). He thus brings his battle with a Jewish past into the Russian present, and a new name, history, and nation join his list of those who oppose the redemption of time and resist apocalyptic transformation. By identifying the battle of Judaism and Christian Hellenism with Russia’s struggles, and by linking Christ’s Passion with Russia’s ordeal of war and revolution, Mandelstam can, in turn, stake a claim in his adopted nation’s present and future. “The fabric of our world is renewed through death,” the poet-prophet of “Pushkin and Skriabin” proclaims (CPL, 94). The nation that refuses this renewal requires a prophet, and the prophet whose warning is ignored is entitled to turn his back on the past, as he forges new allegiances among those aligned with the forces of the future. The son must reject a doomed mother so that he may be saved himself. He must likewise turn from a dying motherland, be it Judea or Russia, in order to witness the birth of a transfigured nation from its ashes. The young Levite must flee all those, whether Russians or Jews, who will not heed his warning, and he will cast his lot among the chosen ones through whom the old world will be transformed and redeemed. Mandelstam manages to turn his rupture with his Jewish past into the basis for his kinship with a turbulent Russian present. It is a variant on the ploy he uses to adopt the orphan of nations in “Petr Chaadaev,” and it prefigures the strategies he employs in The Noise of Time to make Russia and its revolutionary years his own. One sentence from “Pushkin and Skriabin” in particular points to ways in which Mandelstam works to appropriate his adoptive nation and his age in his autobiography. “The Christian calendar,” he warns in “Pushkin and Skriabin,” “is endangered, the fragile reckoning of the years of our era has been lost—time is rushing backward, roaring and splashing” (CPL, 91; II, 314). This “roaring (shum)” is the same tumult that Mandelstam records in The Noise of Time (Shum vremeni), and the roar of time run amuck unites the outsider with the children of his coveted “homeland of the spirit.” “Judaic chaos” converges with the uproar of a troubled modern Russia, and the reluctant Jew joins the “chil-
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
143
dren of Russia’s terrible years” as they learn to create anew from time’s clamor.75 Mandelstam creates community from rupture in a still more subtle way through his synthetic mythologies. For T. S. Eliot, postwar London merges with other “unreal” cities teetering on the edge of the abyss. “Jerusalem Athens Alexandria Vienna London”—so runs the list of doomed and ghostly sister-cities from The Waste Land. For Mandelstam, “dying Petersburg, the end of the Petersburg era of Russian history, called Jerusalem’s fall to mind,” his widow notes. “The fall of both cities is equated: the modern city perishes for the same sin as did the ancient one.”76 This sin is the rejection of revelation, the refusal to accept a redeeming, regenerating death and emerge from it reborn. It is the sin that perverts the flow of time and leads to disruption and desolation. As such, it would seem to defeat all attempts to transmit, or create, tradition. Like Eliot, Mandelstam manages, though, to shape a peculiarly modern form of tradition by aligning comparable kinds of destruction. It is a tradition based not on continuity or succession, on direct transmission from father, or mother, to son: it derives instead from dislocation and interruption. What unity this tradition has comes from the poet who wrenches moments from the past in order to forge their connection with the present. “In order to preserve the principle of unity amidst the vortex of changes and the unceasing flood of phenomena,” Mandelstam insists, the modern thinker must learn to follow the “internal connection among phenomena” and to “liberate[] this connection from time and consider it independently”; phenomena thus linked “form, as it were, a kind of fan whose folds can be opened up in time; however, this fan may also be closed up in a way intelligible to the human mind” (CPL, 117). Mandelstam and Eliot create through their composite cities just such a “fan”; to phrase it differently, they devise in these cities a palimpsest through which the outlines of the past can be traced in the shapes of the present. Through such palimpsests, the noise of the present age takes on historical resonance, and the present age’s vortex of events assumes a historical dimension. This may seem to take us far afield from Mandelstam’s battle with his Jewish origins, and this may well be part of Mandelstam’s intention in creating his synthetic myth, his historical palimpsest. “Remembrance and invention” is a useful and tricky dialectic. It permits Mandelstam to invent complex ways to keep his memory at bay. It enables him to reinvent his past, to cast it in new shapes; and after it has been transformed almost beyond recognition, he can then allow it back into his writing. Mandelstam relies on his seemingly endless capacity for creation from rupture to turn an unwanted past into an asset while removing the outward signs of its presence from his work. Nadezhda Mandelstam claims that Mandelstam’s Jerusalem is merely a symbol or stand-in for a Petersburg in mortal danger in “A young Levite
144
•
C H A P T E R
F O U R
•
among the priests.” If this indeed is the poem’s key, then Jerusalem, the center of Jewish culture and the birthplace of Christianity, becomes simply the second figure in the poem’s tacit simile, while dying Petersburg emerges as its true setting and subject. According to this reading, Mandelstam the Russian poet dons the robes of Jewish apostate turned Christian prophet only in order to give greater resonance to his vision of a modern Russian apocalypse. He picks a Hebrew past only to explore a Russian present, and his Jewish origins vanish from the poem’s frame of reference. Such an interpretation might well have served Mandelstam’s own purposes. His complex juxtapositions of different pasts and presents may compensate for what the modernist orphan has failed to inherit directly—but it can also obscure a legacy that the would-be orphan would sooner leave behind. Mandelstam himself, however, has given us the means to develop a reading that ties Jerusalem directly to the “womb world” of his origins. In “This night is irreparable,” Mandelstam observes his mother’s funeral from Jerusalem’s gates, as he conflates not two, but three dying pasts—Jerusalem’s, Petersburg’s, and, crucially, his own—into one unsettling image, and this image derives its force precisely from its deeply personal nature. Behind the dying pasts of cities and nations lies the death of Mandelstam’s mother, the death her poet-son transforms into a means of liberation. Mandelstam must brutally cast off the curse of his Jewish ancestry, if he is to achieve new legacies and new spiritual homelands. The cultural orphan must work to orphan himself. It is a troubling solution. The poet of “In the vast pond it’s transparent and dark” (#18) suspects the cost of such a liberation; the reed uprooted from its native silt becomes mere straw, lifeless matter. The poet who abandons his past for the sake of new life may condemn himself to a similar death-in-life. He betrays, in any case, the sacred mission that the “Christian” Mandelstam of “Pushkin and Skriabin” undertakes: “To remember at all costs! To conquer forgetfulness!” (CPL, 94). The Mandelstam of Tristia seems finally to have found a scheme through which he can abandon his family with what appears to be perfect equanimity, as he forgets at last his intrusive, unwanted past. This discarded past continues, though, to infiltrate and influence Mandelstam’s writings in various guises and under a variety of names. The very dates of Tristia’s three “Jewish” poems—1916, 1917, 1920—suggest that Mandelstam himself senses the persistence of this past, as he periodically repeats and revises his formula for keeping a troublesome inheritance at bay. His exorcisms become increasingly complex and eloquent, but their effects are apparently fleeting at best. Indeed, Mandelstam’s spells cannot take effect without disrupting the substance of his poetic vision. Just as catastrophe is the catalyst for his poetic culture, so chaos lies at the heart of his creation. The Mandelstam of Tristia works to shape a clear-cut opposition between the “Hellenized” world he longs for and the Judaism he rejects. The Judaism Mandelstam takes over from Zelinsky is inbred, exclusive, fixed on the past, while its
•
J U D A I C
C H A O S
•
145
Hellenic antipode offers a domesticated cosmos open to all nations and, through them, to the future. The version of Hellenism he acquires by way of Zelinsky, however, resembles not only the tumultuous world of earlytwentieth-century Russia, but also, and perhaps more importantly, the dilemma of the modern, “worldless” Jew.77 Hellenism, modern Russia, the homeless Jew—all three dwell at the crossroads of cultures and ages. The past Mandelstam describes in The Noise of Time is possessive—its forces pursue him relentlessly—but it is also chaotic, and its chaos derives from its openness to other cultures, from the multiple infusions of “foreign blood” that mark Mandelstam’s family history. Unlike Zelinsky’s Judaism and like his Hellenism, it is intercultural and international, though its many elements remain unsynthesized. It would be too easy, though, to see the battle of Hellenism and Judaism as a struggle between chaos and cosmos, Judaic “worldlessness” and Hellenic home. What is crucial for Mandelstam is not one force or the other, but the dynamic exchange between them, which generates, in turn, the impulse to create. Where Mandelstam the uprooted Jew and Mandelstam the would-be Hellene meet is in the attempt to wrest culture from disruption and to make a home from chaos. Zelinsky’s Hellenism represents an effort to forge order from an age convulsed by change. In “On the Nature of the Word,” Mandelstam recognizes the Hellenic spirit that informs Russia’s mission to shape history from hybridization and foreign-born influences. The poet of Tristia refuses to admit the kinship between the Hellenistic quest to shape an oikumene from disparate nations and traditions, and his own drive, as a dislocated Central European Jew, to synthesize a new homeland from an array of cultures, peoples, and ages. Isaac Deutscher’s remarks on modern European Jewry apply equally to Zelinsky’s Hellenes; both peoples dwell “on the borderlines of various civilizations, religions, and national cultures,” “on the borderlines of various epochs.” And both derive their creations from those places “where the most diverse cultural influences cross and fertilize each other.”78 In the late twenties, Mandelstam begins to explore the bonds that tie his dreamed-of culture to his despised Jewish past, and world culture and “Judaic chaos” become allies as he journeys further into the “irreparable night” of the Soviet age.
•
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
F
I
V
E
•
The Currency of the Past Money and language exist by being current. The acceptance of coin as of value; of words as having meaning, are the essence of currency and speech. —Ezra Pound, “Towards Orthology” “Money, money maketh man,” he said, When he lost his friends and possessions together. —Pindar, Second Isthmian Ode
MANDELSTAM’S POETIC ECONOMY OF THE TWENTIES In The Noise of Time, Mandelstam describes his naive childhood efforts to envision in the century’s “prehistoric” years a “human economy” in which every thing and person would find its proper place in an all-encompassing cosmic order: I was able to populate, to socialize the visible world with its barley, dirt roads, castles, and sunlit spider webs, breaking it down into diagrams and setting up under the pale blue firmament ladders, far from biblical, on which not the angels of Jacob but small and large property holders ascended and descended, passing through the stages of capitalist economy (kapitalisticheskoe khoziastvo). What could be stronger, what could be more organic: I perceived the entire world as an economy, a human economy (chelovecheskoe khoziastvo). . . . Yes, I heard with the sharpness of ears caught by the sound of a distant threshing machine in the field the burgeoning and increase, not of the barley in its ear, not of the northern apple, but of the world, the capitalist world, that was ripening in order to fall! (my ellipses; POM, 111; II, 88).
The rhetoric of this boyhood vision, with its petty landowners and decaying capitalists, may seem incongruous, to say the least, in the writings of a poet whose resolutely un-Soviet views were ultimately to cost him his life. Indeed, Mandelstam himself presents his brief adolescent career as a “prepared and finished Marxist” as a juvenile infatuation or childish illness whose intensity is matched only by its evanescence (POM, 112).
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
147
The program that Mandelstam chooses to shape his childhood cosmic order may be jarring in the context of his later work; the order itself, though, is not. It is an early incarnation of the world culture that haunts Mandelstam from the first poems of Stone to the final “Voronezh Notebooks.” It thus gives us a precocious prototype of the system that provides a place for every outsider by the warming hearth of Western culture in a thoroughly domesticated cosmos. One word in particular alerts us to the convergence between Mandelstam’s early imaginings and his mature poetic vision. This is khoziaistvo, whose Russian meanings span the distance from “economy,” in the sense of “socialist,” “capitalist,” or “world economy”; to “agriculture” (sel’skoe khoziaistvo); to humble “housekeeping” (domashnee khoziaistvo). It encompasses the ordering of human life from the largest scale—that of nations, continents, the globe itself—to the smallest, to the intimate details of daily life as experienced and organized within our own four walls. It bridges the gap between human society’s rural beginnings—sel’skoe khoziaistvo, translated literally, gives us “rural housekeeping”—and its complex modern incarnations in the industrial age. It is ideally suited to Mandelstam’s cosmic vision, in which the modern age is made homely and human again through the efforts of the poet who sees our early beginnings in our present ends. Indeed, the definition of khoziaistvo in Ozhegov’s dictionary might be a kind of shorthand for Mandelstamian Hellenism; it is “the entirety of objects required for daily life (byt).” Mandelstam’s Hellenistic economy consists of just such objects: “[It] is an earthenware pot, oven tongs, a milk jug, kitchen utensils, dishes. . . . [It] is the conscious surrounding of humans with domestic utensils instead of impersonal objects” (CPL, 127). Through such utensils, infused with “teleological warmth,” the poet will transform his domestic housekeeping writ large into the basis for a truly human and universal economy.1 This cosmic economy lies at the heart of Mandelstam’s vision from the start, though it assumes multiple guises, from boyish Marxism to Villon’s Middle Ages and the body of Notre Dame, to Zelinsky’s ideal Hellas, and so on. Mandelstam officially christens his Hellenistic vision as early as 1916, in “Pushkin and Skriabin.”2 He develops his version of this Hellenistic myth in a series of seminal essays that date from the early twenties: “Government and Rhythm” (1920); “The Word and Culture” (1921); “The Wheat of Humanity” (1922); “Humanism and the Present” (1923); and, most importantly, “On the Nature of the Word” (1921). He explicitly articulates his Hellenistic principles in response to a competing cosmic economy, which extends, like his, from the smallest details of daily life to the life of the nation, of Europe, of the planet itself, and even up into the stars. Mandelstam’s Hellenism must coexist with a revolution whose aspirations were nothing less than the radical transformation of human life as we know it. And this transformation was to be accomplished by a thoroughgoing revision of the myriad notions encompassed by the Russian word khoziaistvo.3
148
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
Mandelstam’s Hellenistic economy might seem to be fundamentally at odds with the state-sponsored economy then taking shape under the reins of the newly installed Bolshevik regime. And indeed, it is hard to imagine that Lenin, Trotsky, Lunacharsky, and company would have endorsed Mandelstam’s claim that “classical poetry is the poetry of revolution” (CPL, 116); or that they would have been swayed by his argument that “affirmation and justification of the real values of the past is just as revolutionary an act as the creation of new values” (CPL, 176).4 Mandelstam’s assertions may not have convinced the revolutionary powers-that-be; they demonstrate, nonetheless, the degree to which he himself yearned to reconcile his own poetic principles with the ambitions and aims of the Soviet state. And this desire to fuse what would appear to be two radically opposing worldviews dictates the shape that his Hellenized cosmos takes in the prose of the early twenties. “They say the cause of revolution is hunger in interplanetary space. Grain must be scattered through the ether” (CPL, 116). Mandelstam’s cryptic prescription for cosmic revolution in “The Word and Culture” would seem to lie well beyond the pale of any revolutionary program that the state might be expected to tolerate, let alone endorse. In fact, it demonstrates just the opposite: it places Mandelstam squarely within a postrevolutionary tradition of utopian visionaries that encompassed not only poets, artists, and other notoriously unreliable eccentrics but respected party members and prominent politicians. Poets were disposed from the start to view the revolution in the light of their own eschatological imaginings: one has only to recall, in this context, the Symbolist phantasmagorias of Belyi and Blok, the fantastical Futures conjured up by Mayakovsky and Khlebnikov, or the rural utopias extolled by peasant poets like Nikolai Kluiev and Sergei Esenin. Each writer projected his deepest poetic needs and aspirations onto a revolution that was to prove fatally unreceptive to such creative revision; and each ultimately succeeded only in inadvertently disclosing the abyss that separated his personal poetic apocalypse from Soviet reality as it gradually took shape under the Bolshevik regime. This reality finally proved uncongenial to such imaginings. In the early postrevolutionary years, though, anything seemed to be possible; the wildest “scientific fantasy,” in the Russian phrase, appeared to be within the reach of a regime bent on changing the nature of human life on earth. Indeed, the Marxist philosophy on which the new state was based, lent itself to dreams of a humanity liberated from the social shackles that had hitherto confined its untapped capacities for new creation. The October Revolution, Richard Stites observes, created an atmosphere in which “the utopian appears no madder than other men”: “As memoirists and contemporaries put it again and again, it was the deep radicalism of the economic revolution, unprecedented in human history, that seemed to fling open the portals to unending possibilities for drastic change.”5 In this climate, visions of worldwide or cosmic transformation seemed
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
149
less the stuff of childish daydreams than the possible, even necessary ends of the cataclysmic chain of events set in motion by a revolution whose true scope was not national but global. The revolutionary writer Maksim Gorky and Anatoly Lunacharsky, who became Commissar of Education under Lenin, were ardent “Godbuilders” who sought to create a human-based religion to complement the new socialist state; they envisioned “a future world of dreams and myths, of sounds, and rituals that would elevate humanity to the status of divinity and bring collective immortality.” The “biocosmic” philosophy of Nikolai Fedorov (1828–1903) attracted not only susceptible poets and writers such as Mayakovsky and Andrei Platonov. Devout Bolsheviks and respected Soviet scientists were likewise drawn by Fedorov’s vision of a final “victory over death, resurrection of all the dead, and the settlement of outer space” and by the Biocosmists’ slogan of “Immortalism and Interplanetism.”6 In Literature and Revolution (1923), Trotsky scoffs at the “Cosmist” pretensions then current among poets of the “Proletkult” movement: “It seems that the poets are becoming Cosmists, not because the population of the Milky Way is knocking at their doors and demanding an answer, but because the problems of earth are lending themselves to artistic expression with so much difficulty that it makes them feel like jumping into another world.” Trotsky himself, though, was not above indulging in utopian reveries, as the final pages of his study show. He confines his imaginings to Planet Earth alone, but the paean to a human-made paradise that concludes Literature and Revolution is no less fantastical than any Cosmist dream of intergalactic conquest: “Man will become immeasurably stronger, wiser and subtler; his body will become more harmonized, his movements more rhythmic, his voice more musical. The forms of life will become dynamically dramatic. The average human type will rise to the heights of an Aristotle, a Goethe, or a Marx. And above this ridge new peaks will rise.” Even Lenin, who was notoriously resistant to such revolutionary flights of fancy, permitted himself the occasional cosmic daydream, as he demonstrated in an interview, fittingly enough, with H. G. Wells: “Human ideas—he told to Wells—are based on the scale of the planet we live in. . . . If we succeed in making contact with the other planets, all our philosophical, social, and moral ideas will have to be revised, and in this event these potentialities will become limitless.”7 In this context Mandelstam’s interplanetary agrarian fantasies seem, if not less far-fetched, then far less marginal; he shared his cosmic daydreams with lofty company. The values on which he based his Hellenistic vision, though, differed drastically from those of the new state and its proponents. Hellenism, he insists in his essays, is the culture of the future; revolutionary art is classical by its nature; and old values, revived and revised, are as vital to the new age as those that have yet to be created. His very insistence, though, holds a note of doubt—as well it might. For the young Soviet state predicated its visions of the future on the total collapse of a past that was,
150
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
if not dead, then gravely ill; a new life would emerge only from “the turmoil of a dying civilization and the agonized death throes of an ancient culture.”8 One does not have to look far to find similar imagery, used to very different ends, in Mandelstam’s poetry of the early twenties. “My age, my animal, who will dare/To gaze into your pupils/And mend with his own blood/The backbone of two centuries,” he mourns in one paean to a passing culture. He recognizes that new culture can only be built from the bones of the old: “To tear the age from its prison,/To begin a new world,/ The gnarled joints of days/Must be bound into a flute” (“The Age,” 1923; #135). Mayakovsky had eagerly tuned his “backbone flute” to the key of a new, revolutionary music. The Mandelstam of these poems, though, is unable to follow suit; he is himself the sickly son of a dying age (#140), and he cannot shape a new art from the desecrated corpse of his beloved culture. New creation apparently bears too high a price—or so the poems might lead us to believe. The essays tell a very different story, though. In “The Word and Culture,” Mandelstam celebrates the cultural treasures that the old world’s death has placed within the reach of audacious grave robbers: “As the room of a dying man is open to everyone, so the door of the old world is flung wide open before the crowd. Suddenly everything becomes public property. Come and take your pick” (CPL, 116). The revolution’s redistribution of wealth takes on new meaning as past traditions become the rightful property of the culturally dispossessed, who ransack history like landless peasants raiding a vanquished master’s estate. And the postrevolutionary “poet-synthesizer” is only too happy to sing a new song in his benefactor’s praise: “He sings of ideas, scientific systems, and State theories (idei, nauchnye sistemy, gosudarstvennye teorii) just as his predecessors sang of nightingales and roses” (CPL, 116; II, 227). This poet-synthesizer effortlessly achieves in his verse what Mandelstam strives for in the essays; he fuses past and present, old world and new, as he plays his classical and revolutionary tunes on a “thousand-stop flute brought instantly to life by the breathing of all ages” (CPL, 116). Mandelstam is not adverse to turning the systems and theories of the new regime to his own ends in the essays, though the state he warily commends would not have recognized itself in his idiosyncratic portraits. At his most optimistic, he sees Mandelstamian Hellenism and Soviet Marxism as a nearly perfect fit: each system is profoundly teleological, and each is guided by a goal of a global, truly human-centered economy at once universal and domestic. In “Humanism and the Present,” he uses Hellenized vocabulary to extoll the “humanist” goals of the Soviet regime: The monumentality of the approaching social architecture is conditioned by its calling to organize the world’s economy (mirovoe khoziaistvo) according to the principle of universal domesticity (vsemirnaia domashnost’) to meet man’s greater demands, broadening the scope of his domestic freedom to universal
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
151
proportions, fanning the flame of his individual hearth to the dimensions of a universal flame. The future appears cold and terrifying to those who do not understand this, but the internal warmth of the future—the warmth of efficiency, home economy, and teleology (tselesoobraznost’)—is just as tangible to the contemporary humanist as the heat of the incandescent stove of the present. (CPL, 182; II, 354)
This cosmic hearth heats the future dreamed of by Bolshevik and poet alike—or so Mandelstam would have us believe. In “The Wheat of Humanity,” he fuses Hellenist and Marxist terminology with even greater abandon: “Blessed be the economy (ekonomika) with its pathos of universal domesticity. Blessed be the flint axe of the class struggle—blessed be all that is absorbed in its tremendous concern for the creation of a world economy (mirovoe khoziaistvo); blessed be all domesticity and domestic economy (khoziaistvennost’), all concern for the universal hearth.”9 “The flint axe of the class struggle” improbably joins forces with the “domestic utensils”—clay pot, oven tongs, kitchenware, dishes—whose help Mandelstam enlists elsewhere in his Hellenistic battle with an inhospitable cosmos (CPL, 127).10 Mandelstam is more cautious in other essays. He does not anticipate full cooperation between the forces of Hellenism and those of the Soviet state; he aims more reasonably, if no less optimistically, for peaceful coexistence and respectful collaboration. In “The Word and Culture,” he envisions an amicable, even advantageous new division of labor between the state and culture. “The separation of Culture and the State,” he proclaims, “is the most significant event of our revolution” (and again, one wonders what Soviet leaders would have made of this singular interpretation). In a regime distinguished by its “tolerant” attitude to the “old world” and its traditions, the continuers of those traditions are “internally free” to practice their calling as they choose (CPL, 112–13). And the regime will learn in time to cherish the culture whose continued life it has permitted: A new kind of organic interrelationship is beginning to appear, one which connects the State with Culture in a way not unlike that which once linked the appanage princes to the monasteries. . . . The isolation of the State insofar as cultural values (kul’turnye tsennosti) are concerned makes it fully dependent on culture. Cultural values ornament the State, endowing it with color, form, and, if you will, even gender. Inscriptions on State buildings, tombs, and gateways insure the State against the ravages of time. (my ellipses; CPL, 112–13; II, 223–24)
The State may make the mistake of thinking that its interests lie not with the truly human values of Hellenistic culture, but with the new values that it itself creates. Culture, however, will have the final word. Its values will outlast the ravages of time that will finally lay bare the State’s pretensions;
152
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
and revolutionary Russia will be remembered in millennia to come not for its own grandiose schemes and plans, but for the cultural grace notes that gave those dreams their true, if unacknowledged, meaning. Mandelstam concludes “Humanism and the Present” with a triumphal assertion of the longevity and power of his beloved Hellenistic values, values that do not derive their worth from the imprimature of any single kingdom of this earth. “The fact that the values of humanism (tsennosti gumanizma) have now become rare,” he claims, “is not a bad sign in itself.” They have merely been “taken out of circulation (upotreblenie) and hidden underground”: “Humanistic values have simply withdrawn, concealed themselves like gold currency (zolotaia valiuta ), but like the gold reserves, they secure contemporary Europe’s entire circulation of ideas (vse ideinoe obrashchenie sovremennoi Evropy) and control them more competently for being underground.” These values, this currency will resurface with the birth of a new, pan-European cultural economy: The transition to gold currency is the business of the future, and in the province of culture what lies before us is the replacement of temporary ideas—of paper banknotes (bumazhnye vypuski)—with the gold coinage (zolotoi chekan) of the European humanistic tradition; the magnificent florins of humanism will ring once again, not against the archaeologist’s spade, but when the time comes, they will recognize their own day and resound like the jingling coins of common currency (khodiachaia zvonkaia moneta) passing from hand to hand. (CPL, 183; II, 354)
In this passage Mandelstam mints the currency that will circulate in the ideal economy of a fully Hellenized cosmos. The language and imagery in which he describes these eternal values, though, mark him as very much a man, and poet, of his time. The system of values he proposes—with its permanent cultural “reserves” linking revolutionary Russia to a pan-European past and future—would have been anathema to a Soviet leadership bent on radical reform of cultural and economic systems alike. Mandelstam’s very preoccupation with questions of value, though, reflects the most pressing concerns of the society in which he found himself and the state that was struggling to govern it. His metaphors—of coinage, currency, banknotes, and gold reserves—link him intimately, if precariously, to the vast social and economic experiments undertaken by the new regime. For Mandelstam, the language of finance provides the aptest metaphor for the cultural values that, as he sees it, underlie all human, or all Western, society; these values govern “contemporary Europe’s entire circulation of ideas,” and these ideas, in turn, guarantee the ongoing life of Western civilization. For the Bolshevik regime, this equation was put in reverse; it had undertaken its revolution in the name of an economic theory that proclaimed that all culture and ideas were determined finally by a state’s means of production, that is, by the economic values at work in a given nation. Culture is derivative, peripheral, even parasitic: it “feeds on
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
153
the sap of economics,” as Trotsky puts it in Literature and Revolution.11 Mandelstam and the Soviet leadership may have disagreed on the relationship between “superstructure” and “base”; they were alike, though, in their sense that the notion of value was now adrift in the uncharted seas of a brave, new Soviet reality.12
CULTURAL BANKRUPTCY The poetry of the revolution is synthetic. It cannot be changed into small coin for the temporary lyric use of sonnet-makers. —Leon Trotsky, Literature and Revolution (1923) If I’ve got the right to change—/Please change my golden coin for me. —Osip Mandelstam, “The Golden Coin” (“Zolotoi”; 1912)
Though Mandelstam and the Soviet state were in crucial ways operating at cross purposes in the early twenties, they shared a common concern with uncovering, or creating, a stable basis for the value systems on which their different endeavors rested. I have argued that the economic metaphors of “Humanism and the Present” link Mandelstam to central concerns of the new regime; and indeed, the essay itself appeared only months after Soviet leaders had decided to base the foundering economy on a gold standard in hopes of curbing the rampant inflation that had rendered the state’s paper currency all but worthless. This decision, reached in the summer of 1922, was merely the latest in a series of experiments intended both to stabilize an economy shattered by war and revolution and to convert Marxist theory into workable Soviet practice. Mandelstam and his contemporaries bore witness to a bewildering sequence of monetary transformations in the years following the overthrow of the tsarist regime. The short-lived kerenki of Aleksandr Kerensky’s Provisional Government replaced the imperial currency of the war years, itself already severely inflated; and Kerensky’s banknotes were themselves replaced in short order during the radical economic experiments that characterized Russia’s years of War Communism (1918–21). Money was abolished entirely for a time—it had become virtually worthless in any case—and its place was taken by barter and pay in kind. Soviet leaders celebrated the end of what Lenin called all “colored pieces of worthless paper” and the beginning of a moneyless, truly communist world order—but their rejoicings were premature. Runaway inflation forced them to introduce the so-called sovznak (“sovtoken” or “sovsign”) in 1921; and the sovznak , in turn, coexisted unhappily for a short while with the chervonets, the unit that marked the regime’s return to a gold standard in 1922. The word money itself, exiled from the Soviet lexicon during War Communism, was permitted back into official circulation at about the same time.13
154
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
These monetary goings-on may seem to have little bearing on the work of poets struggling to make a place for themselves in the new Soviet reality. Mandelstam was not alone, though, in his sense that the values of an older culture might vanish with its coins; and he was not alone in his foreboding that, for good or ill, the fate of poetry, at least in its pre-Bolshevik incarnations, was precarious in the new state’s cultural economy. Percy Bysshe Shelley may have felt that poetry and money were “the God and Mammon of the world.” For the poets of postrevolutionary Russia, though, the bonds that linked verse to currency were more ambiguous, and the ties between the two were not simply metaphorical. Did the new regime want or need the verse of even its most ardent supporters, let alone that of fellow travelers and internal émigrés? Who would pay to print their poetry? Who could afford to buy it? “Inspiration can’t be bought,” the bookseller advises his otherworldly client in Pushkin’s “The Bookseller’s Conversation with the Poet” (1824). “But you can sell your manuscript. . . . Just name your price.” The worth of both poets and their manuscripts was far less certain in the postrevolutionary marketplace. (Stability came only later, and at great cost, as Stalin consolidated his state monopoly on art as well as industry in the late twenties and early thirties.)14 Mandelstam was not the only writer to draw on the language of finance to describe the plight and prospects of poetry under the new regime. Politicians, critics, and poets alike relied on economic metaphors to describe the value of poetry, new and old, to the revolutionary state. In “On Poetry” (1919–20), Velimir Khlebnikov warns the readers of the future not to expect the kind of simpleminded clarity that marked poetic economies of the past, when a misguided bourgeoise demanded that “a poem must be understandable. Like a sign on the street, which carries the clear and simple words, ‘For Sale.’ ” Elsewhere he foresees an international revolution in poetry to parallel the coming global triumph of the Bolshevik regime, a revolution that will do away with the past’s unseemly trade in verbal merchandise. He calls on the “artists of the world” to put an end to the literary “tariff wars” and “verbal marketplaces” in which every “system of auditory currency” vies for linguistic supremacy. On a less grandiose note, Leon Trotsky warns revolutionary poetry against squandering its new-found wealth on small change “for the temporary lyrical use” of has-been versifiers and sonnet-crafting hacks. And in an early essay on Futurism, Roman Jakobson reproaches retrograde critics for their unthinking allegiance to the poetic currency of bygone times; they “prefer the paper currency” of conventional verse to the “gold” of avant-garde experiments. Poets, he notes in another early essay, are no less guilty of pawning off ersatz verse as the genuine article: “Pushkin-style poems are now as easy to print as counterfeit Kerensky banknotes (kerenki): they lack any value of their own and circulate only in the absence of good hard cash.” Jakobson’s metaphor might have derived from the realities of Soviet publishing in the twenties. Poets who found themselves low among the state’s priorities for paper allocations—the treasury alone required monumental amounts of paper to
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
155
keep up with demands for an increasingly devalued currency—were reduced to printing their poems “on money which had gone out use,” or so Mayakovsky recalls.15 Though Mandelstam shares a common vocabulary with Jakobson, Khlebnikov, and Trotsky, he is far from sharing what might be called their verbal economy. His faith in a poetic gold standard that unites past and future may seem naive in light of Trotsky’s dismissal of earlier cultural values, or Jakobson’s establishment of a new value system that explicitly awards its gold prize to the Futurist avant-garde. In other ways, though, the return to a gold standard that marked the early stages of the state’s New Economic Policy, or NEP (1921–28), appeared to justify Mandelstam’s hope that other values from the past might be readmitted into circulation as well. The NEP, with its encouragement of small-scale free enterprise and petty entrepreneurs, was designed to restore the Soviet economy, shattered by war and revolution, to prewar norms. As such, Mayakovsky charges, it “led people to believe, quite simply by analogy, that the old norms should be applied in our cultural life as well.” Such beliefs did finally prove to be misguided, but the loosening of cultural restrictions that accompanied the government’s new hybrid economy seemed for a time to indicate that the revolutionary state might tolerate, if not embrace, artistic traditions and values first cultivated under the ancien régime. Indeed, Mandelstam could have cited the peculiar fate of one of his poems in support of such guarded optimism: his ambiguously titled, highly ambivalent hymn to the new state, “The Twilight [or Dawn] of Freedom” (“Sumerki svobody,” 1918; #103) had appeared in a 1921 issue of Red Militiaman (Krasnyi militsioner) just opposite an article praising the brutal suppression of the recent Kronstadt sailors’ revolt against Soviet power.16 As this perverse juxtaposition suggests, though, the grounds even for guarded optimism were shaky at best, and Mandelstam’s claims for the kinship of Hellenistic and revolutionary values were, by and large, far from cautious. Though he does not mention Mandelstam by name, Trotsky might have composed his critique of “Literary ‘Fellow Travellers”’(1922) to show the would-be revolutionary classicist the error of his ways. He attacks Akhmatova and other erstwhile Acmeists for mistakenly assuming that “neo-Classicism” is “a child of the Revolution in the same sense in which the NEP is”: “We consider that the historic train [of the Revolution] has just begun to move, and that this is only a brief stop at a station for the purpose of taking on water and getting up steam,” while would-be “revolutionary conservatives” are convinced that the train has stopped for good, or better yet, is even going backward. Trotsky rephrases his point in “The Formalist School of Poetry” (1923): “It does not make new poets of you to translate the philosophy of life of the Seventeenth Century into the language of the Acmeists.”17 Trotsky’s views on revolutionary culture might themselves seem suspect when we recall that his days on the Soviet train of history were already numbered. But Mandelstam did not require Trotsky’s warnings to make
156
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
him doubt the worth of his services to the state. The bravado of his essays is undercut by, among other things, his wife’s accounts of his struggles throughout the twenties to earn a living by letters in an increasingly inhospitable marketplace. The early twenties, as Clarence Brown notes, mark the beginning of Mandelstam’s slow fall from grace, and Nadezhda Mandelstam remarks that Mandelstam himself would later consider the first years of NEP the hardest of his life—which is saying a great deal in light of what lay ahead. By 1923, she recalls, he had fallen subject to an unpublicized ban that prohibited him from publishing anything but translations in stateowned journals; and even this “hackwork,” in Mandelstam’s dismissive phrase, was difficult to come by and poorly paid.18 “Ich bin arm. I am poor”: Mandelstam’s rebellious motto in “Fourth Prose” (1930) recasts in a defiant note the plaintive refrain that sounds throughout his own correspondence of the twenties (CPL, 325).19 “Everything is going well for us,” he writes to his father early in 1923. “There is just one problem. Although we have the essentials, lately we have had just barely enough money. Right now I can’t send you a single cent” (Mandelstam’s italics; CPL, 487). A letter sent some eight months later is far more desperate: “A room in the city costs forty chervontsy. We were ready to leave—but where to? We had to stop our account at the store in order to live. . . . What am I doing? I’m working for money. The crisis is grave. It’s much worse than last year.” (Mandelstam’s italics; 1923/24; CPL, 491). Mandelstam struggles to reassure his wife in letters written during her periods of convalescence in Yalta, where she struggled with recurring bouts of tuberculosis. His anxieties manifest themselves, nonetheless, in the worried kopeck-counting that alternates with solicitous endearments throughout the letters: Later, I went everywhere: to Priboi and to GIZ [publishers]. They promised to pay 60 roubles at the paper tomorrow. . . . Gorlin [an editor] submitted some kind of “Billya” [reference unclear]—100 lines—50 roubles, and Priboi wanted Edgar Allan Poe. (1925; CPL, 490) And Nadichka, tomorrow I’ll pay for the insurance and part of what we owe to Sasha. . . . Today we paid the interest on the watch. Tomorrow the Leningrad Red News will give me 60 roubles, and on Wednesday the 21st, Gorlin will give me 50 more rubles for some poems. That means I already have 110 of the 200 rubles. . . . I have twenty pages left of The Thousand and Second Night [a work by F. Heller], but tomorrow GIZ will give me only 100 rubles, and 125 more on the twentieth. (1925; CPL, 491–92) I wrote you not to spare money. Those were not empty words: I have enough money. Even if you spend 400 rubles in March, there will still be enough money for April. I don’t know how, but everything can be taken care of for a price. (1926; CPL, 516) Rent for the room eats up all my pay. How can we survive, Nadik, how. . . . The next paycheck: 15 rubles on account—a deduction (what’s left of the ear-
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
157
lier one)—30 rubles (I owe the cafeteria)—the literary fund (?)—What will I do with 90 rubles minus 60 for the room (not counting debts totaling 25 rubles, they’re beginning to mount up). Nadik, Nadik, tell me how to survive. (1930; CPL, 541)
The sums are as precise and poignant as those that punctuate the speech of any of Dostoevsky’s downtrodden students or clerks. But Mandelstam was troubled not only by his precarious finances. It became increasingly clear in the twenties that he had little of value to offer the new regime in exchange for what meager pay he received. Indeed, the very currency he trafficked in was suspect. The 1918 Constitution of the Russian Republic gave the vote to all legitimate “toilers,” while disenfranchising, among others, anyone living on rent or other unearned income.20 Mandelstam had carefully hoarded the gold coins of European humanism throughout the years of war and revolution, in hopes that the Soviet state might come to recognize their value. Instead he finds himself living on what he calls in a 1928 questionnaire “unearned cultural income (kul’turnaia renta),” on cultural contraband smuggled into an economy that required all citizens to work for their keep in the officially designated fashion. “I feel I’m in debt to the revolution,” Mandelstam continues, “but I offer it gifts for which it still has no need (Ia chuvstvuiu sebia dolzhnikom revoliutsii, no prinoshu ei dary, v kotorykh ona poka chto ne nuzhdaetsia )” (CPL, 275; II, 217). The currency of the past, in other words, is not only worthless in the Soviet present. It also places its bearer in a dubious position vis-à-vis a regime that acknowledges no values but its own. The debtor who has mistakenly invested in the riches of the past now finds himself confessing his cultural bankruptcy to a creditor whose tolerance for such transgressions is limited indeed.
PINDARIC TRIUMPH AND MANDELSTAMIAN DEFEAT If there is a single Greek word that can best capture for us [the] driving force behind Pindar’s poetics, that word is surely oikonomia, ancestor of our borrowed English terms economy and economics. For Pindar, oikonomia is not merely a material concern. . . . In the traditional poetics of Pindar, the reciprocity between poet and patron, which is the oikonomia or “traffic” of praise poetry, depends on a world view that places the ultimate value on the notion that value itself is sacred. —Gregory Nagy, Foreward to Leslie Kurke, The Traffic in Praise: Pindar and the Poetics of Social Economy (1991)
Thus far I have drawn on documents from the late twenties in making a case for Mandelstam’s sense of cultural bankruptcy. Mandelstam’s most complex and moving testimony to this fear dates, however, not from the end of the NEP, but from its early years—the same years in which he stub-
158
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
bornly affirms the worth of a Hellenized Europe in his essays. In critical prose, T. S. Eliot remarks, “one may be legitimately occupied with ideals,” but “in the writing of verse, one can only deal with actuality.”21 He might be describing the rift that divides prose from poetry in Mandelstam’s writing of the early twenties. The reality Mandelstam evokes in his poems of the period forms a grim counterpoint to the resilient, resolutely hopeful tone of the essays, as the glittering golden currency of “Humanism and the Present” turns up, tarnished and diminished, at the end of one of his greatest and most pessimistic lyrics, “The Horseshoe Finder” (1923; #136): “Time cuts me like a coin,/And there’s no longer enough of me for me.” Though it was written in the same year as “Humanism and the Present,” “The Horseshoe Finder” stands in gloomy reproach to that essay’s most hopeful passages; it forms a wrenching antithesis to the essay’s optimistic thesis. The essayist insists that humanistic values, now hidden underground, will return again as common currency. Their burial, in other words, was premature, or perhaps predestined, and will be followed by a glorious resurrection as they triumphally reenter the life of the European culture whose vitality they ensure. Mandelstam the essayist thus assures the stability of his own poetic economy, based as it is on the continuous renovation of past values. The poet, though, tells us something else again. The past, he says, is dead and gone, and no amount of effort—the poem itself is a series of such efforts—will suffice to bring it back to life. The gold coins of the humanist tradition are worthless, and if the spade of some future poet-archaeologist succeeds in digging them up, it will resurrect not living values, but mementos to a vanished past. The bottom of Mandelstam’s poetic economy has dropped out, or so the poem tells us, and with it the very basis of all future poetic creation. “The Horseshoe Finder” is, then, a poem about failure, both personal and artistic, and, at crucial moments, it couches its presentation or enactment of these failures in the language of finance. This language, in turn, lies at the heart of the web of issues—the nature of cultural value; the relationship of the poet to society, to tradition, to the state; the possibilities for poetic language in an age of revolution— that shape Mandelstam’s great modernist lament.22 THE HORSESHOE FINDER (A Pindaric Fragment) We look upon a forest and we say: Here is a forest of ships, of masts, The rosy pines Are free to the very tops from their shaggy burden, They should be creaking in a storm like lone Italian pines in the angry treeless air; the plumbline will resist, fitted to the dancing deck, beneath the wind’s salty heel.
5
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
And the seafarer, In his unbridled passion for space, Dragging the geometer’s brittle implement through damp furrows, Checks the rough surface of the seas Against the pull of the earth’s breast. And inhaling the scent Of tarry tears that have oozed through the ship’s planks, Admiring boards Riveted, ordered into bulkheads Not by Bethlehem’s peaceful carpenter, but the other— father of wanderings, seafarer’s friend— We say: They too stood upon an earth Awkward as the backbone of an ass, Their tops forgetting their roots, Upon the famous mountain ridge, And they sounded beneath the sweet downpour, Imploring the heavens in vain to exchange their noble burden For a pinch of salt. Where to begin? Everything cracks and sways. The air trembles with similes. One word is no better than another, The earth rumbles with metaphors, And the light two-wheeled carts, In bright harness of bird flocks thick with strain, Shatter into pieces, Vying with the racetracks’ snorting favorites. Thrice blessed is he who leads a name into his song; The song adorned with a name Lives longer among the rest— She is marked among her friends by the band upon her brow, which preserves her from fainting, from too strong, stupefying smells— Whether from a man’s nearness, Or a powerful animal’s fur, Or simply the scent of savory rubbed between the palms. Sometimes the air is dark as water, and everything living swims in it like a fish, Sundering with its fins the sphere, dense, resilient, slightly warm,— A crystal, in which wheels spin and horses shy, The damp black earth of Neaera, furrowed again each night With pitchforks, tridents, hoes, and ploughs.
159 10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
160
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
The air is mixed as densely as the earth— You can’t get out and it’s hard to enter. A rustle runs across the trees like a green ball; Children play jacks with dead animals’ backbones. The frail chronology of our era draws to a close. Thank you for all that was: I myself made mistakes, miscalculated, bungled the accounts. The era rang out like a golden sphere, Hollow, molded, held by no one. At every touch it answered “yes” and “no.” Just as a child answers: “I’ll give you the apple,” or “I won’t give you the apple,” Its face the exact form of the voice saying those words. The sound still rings, although the sound’s cause is gone. The horse lies in the dust and snorts in a lather, But the sharp arch of its neck Still holds the memory of racing with legs outstretched— When there were not four, But as many as stones on a road, Renewed in four shifts at a time As often as a blazing pacer strikes the ground. Thus, The one who finds a horseshoe Blows the dust from it And rubs it with wool until it shines, Then Hangs it above the lintel, To let it rest. It will never need to strike sparks from flint again. Human lips which have nothing more to say Preserve the shape of the last word spoken, And the hand keeps feeling the weight Though the pitcher lost half its water while being carried home. What I’m saying now isn’t said by me, It’s been dug up from the ground like grains of stony wheat. Some engrave a lion on their coins, Others— a head;
55
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
Varied lozenges of copper, gold, and bronze Lie with equal honor in the earth. The age, which tried to gnaw them through, broke its teeth on them. Time cuts me like a coin, And there’s no longer enough of me for me.23
161
95
“The Horseshoe Finder” is exceptional in Mandelstam’s work in more ways than one. It is not only his longest single lyric; it is also his only poem written entirely in free verse, and Mandelstam’s choice of form leads us to the poem’s chief concern: the poet’s cultural bankruptcy and the failure of his poetic economy. Rhyme and meter “recollect forward”;24 they return continuously to a poem’s past in the process of propelling us into its future. One can see why variants worked on traditional verse forms would appeal to a poet like Mandelstam, preoccupied with altering the past in the process of calling it to mind. “Poetry is the plough that turns up time,” Mandelstam announces in “The Word and Culture” (CPL, 113), and the plough’s circling motion—what was below is now above; what was past is now present; what was buried returns to life and will be buried again, and so on, ad infinitum—is the central movement of all his poetry, whether his image is the plough, a ship’s prow, Persephone, or Christ himself. We see one version of this motion at work in “Humanism and the Present,” as the buried coins return to circulation. The coins that end “The Horseshoe Finder,” though, stay buried, and this unfinished cycle, this broken circle dominates the poem from the start—the horseshoe of the title is itself an incomplete circle—and dictates its very shape. The rhyme and meter that any reader of Mandelstam would have known to expect do not materialize; and, as a result, the circling motion and the continuous negotiation between the poem’s own past and future that rhyme and meter create are conspicuous in the poem only by their absence. “Will the circle be unbroken?” runs the chorus of an old American spiritual, and this question, with its manifold implications, preoccupies Mandelstam throughout “The Horseshoe Finder.” The poem abounds in images of circles and spheres, whether partial or full: the title’s horseshoe is followed by cart wheels (33); the band on the song’s brow (40); the crystal sphere and the spinning wheels within it (46–48); the circling horse races (36; 48; 67–70); the green ball (53); the golden sphere (58); the apple (62); the horse’s curved neck (66); the lintel, or threshhold (porog)(77); human lips (80); and finally, the concluding image of coins both broken and whole (91–97). Behind the poem’s openly circular imagery lies a network of less overt patterns of circulation. Throughout the poem, glimpses of a world whose ideally Hellenistic order remains intact are juxtaposed with visions of a disrupted cosmos in which the patterns of the past do not apply. The opening stanzas evoke Mandelstam’s ideal Hellas, in which humanity and the elements labor in concert: water is drawn up into the skies, whence it falls to fertilize earth’s trees, which in turn offer themselves up to
162
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
human purposes and return to the seas as ships. Mandelstam’s imagery of plowing—“The damp black earth of Neaera, furrowed again each night” (49)—likewise summons up his Hellenistic cosmos, in which poetry, the plow that turns up time, restores, or “recycles,” in a modern term, past traditions for future use. The song-maiden and her companions (37–39) also call this cosmos to mind through their kinship with the muses who perform a circle dance (khorovod) in two of Tristia’s “Hellenistic” lyrics (#105, #123). And the poem ends with the ancient coins—“varied lozenges of copper, bronze, and gold” (92)—that are Mandelstam’s tokens of past value in “Humanism and the Present,” the tokens that will return to circulation in some future golden age of European culture.25 All these beneficent forms of circulation, though, be they natural or cultural—and nature always joins forces with culture in the best of all Mandelstamian worlds—operate, if at all, in the shadow of failure, destruction, or defeat. They are summoned up only to be cast into doubt by powerful, opposing imagery. The circling elements of the poem’s opening become a trap by mid-poem, an impenetrable sphere mixed of water and air, resistant to human enterprise: “You can’t get out and it’s hard to enter” (52). The values of a bygone era are reduced in the following stanza to a “golden sphere,/Hollow, molded, held by no one” (58–59). Western culture’s gold standard has lost its center and support, and the poet of “The Horseshoe Finder,” himself supported by “unearned cultural income,” cannot sustain it alone. Finally, the poet himself becomes a devalued coin—yet another diminished circle—that will be destroyed by time, not redeemed by it: “Time cuts me like a coin,/And there’s no longer enough of me for me” (96–97). The past and its values will not return again, at least not through the agency of a poet who has, by his own admission, “bungled the accounts” in his efforts to convert old currency to new purposes. I have returned repeatedly to two words borrowed from Mandelstam’s essays in describing the failed or faltering poetic economy of “The Horseshoe Finder”: circulation (obrashchenie) and return (vozvrashchenie). The Russian words share a common root, vrat or vorot, which etymologically has ties to the Old Slavic for “neck”—one thinks here of the dying horse’s arched neck in “The Horseshoe Finder”—but which is also related to the Latin vertere, “to turn,” and this is the sense its many Slavic offspring share.26 The idea of turning or circularity is built into the words themselves, whose presence makes itself felt in the spirit, if not the letter, of “The Horseshoe Finder.” This spirit, however, is countered by the sense of an opposing word, which is again absent from the poem’s actual text but central to its sense, and which shares, in one Russian variant, its root with obrashchenie and vozvrashchenie. This is revolution, which has in Russian both a native and a foreign form. The imported word, revoliutsiia, is the one by which the end of Imperial Russia and the Bolshevik takeover came to be known. But there is a native equivalent, perevorot, which means literally “a turning around” or “reversal of course.” As in English, then, the
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
163
word revolution is ambivalent literally to its roots. The English word can signify both repetition, as in the earth’s continuous revolving around the sun, and radical transformation, as in the French, American, or Russian revolutions. The Russian perevorot contains no directly antithetical meanings in itself; the same root, though, generates not only the opposing meanings I’ve mentioned, but also provides, in a direct parallel to English, the word for the earth’s daily circling of the sun, “vrashchenie.”27 The ambivalent, even antithetical meanings at war in the Russian root vrat lie at the heart of the poetic enterprise that Mandelstam defines in his essays and despairs of in his verse. “Poetic culture,” he writes in “Badger Hole” (1922), “arises from the attempt to overt catastrophe, to make it dependent on the central sun of the system as a whole” (CPL, 137). The catastrophe Mandelstam faces in the early twenties is a revolution that views all history as an unwelcome obstacle in its progress to the radiant future that will vanquish the past forever. Even the subject of history, one scholar notes, was banished for a time from postrevolutionary curricula “on the grounds that it was irrelevant to contemporary life.”28 If Mandelstam is to avoid being cast onto Trotsky’s “dust heap of history,” he must find a way to transform a revolution that turns its back on history into a revolution that turns back to history continuously, that revolves around a history creatively refigured to serve the needs of present and future. The fate of Western civilization itself depends on just such a transformation, or so Mandelstam the essayist insists at his most hyperbolic. The more hesitant voice of “The Horseshoe Finder” reminds us, though, that Mandelstam has staked his own poetic fate on his capacity to fuse classical and revolutionary values—and the odds against him are nothing short of monumental. In “The Word and Culture,” Mandelstam issues a challenge to the revolutionary cult of the future: “One often hears: that is good but it belongs to yesterday. But I say yesterday has not yet been born. . . . I want Ovid, Pushkin, and Catullus to live once more, and I am not satisfied with the historical Ovid, Pushkin, and Catullus” (CPL, 113). In “The Horseshoe Finder,” Mandelstam sets himself the task of putting this vision of history—in which vanished past becomes vital future through the agency and energies of a latter-day poet-entrepreneur—into postrevolutionary poetic practice. The poet he picks, though, as his test case is neither his great precursor Pushkin, nor the Ovid whose life and writings haunt his own work. It is not even Catullus, whose “silver trumpet” serves as Mandelstam’s summons to action in “The Word and Culture” (CPL, 114). It is Pindar, the Greek lyric poet whose dates run from 518 to sometime after 446 B.C. The choice may seem surprising, for Pindar’s name appears only once in Mandelstam’s writings, in “The Horseshoe Finder” itself, which bears the subtitle “A Pindaric Fragment.” Even this solitary reference vanishes in editions that follow the lead of the 1928 Poems in printing the poem’s title without its explanatory gloss. Two questions, then, remain to be addressed
164
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
before returning to the poem itself: Why Pindar? And what has he to do with Mandelstam’s precarious poetic economy of the early twenties?29 To look even briefly at Pindar’s poetry and his times is to discover parallels and contrasts that illuminate both Mandelstam’s text and its context. Superficially Pindar might seem far removed from the work of a “pastist” poet working to carve a place for himself in an unreceptive new state, a poet struggling to make his lyric voice heard above the uproar of a triumphant revolutionary order relentlessly bent on the future. Pindar was in many ways one of history’s great poetic success stories. His gifts were recognized early on, and he remained until his death in high demand among the ruling families of ancient Greece for the victory odes he wrote to commemorate their triumphs in the various athletic competitions and games staged throughout the different city-states. He was the first great practitioner of the ode, and, as the premier poet of his day, was well compensated for his labors, while his poems received public stagings in Greece’s greatest palaces and stadiums. This thumbnail sketch gives us an artist who is, in crucial ways, Mandelstam’s poetic antipode—but who might also be seen as the fulfillment of his most anxious, heartfelt dreams. In “The Word and Culture,” Mandelstam imagines relations between poetry and the state that are respectful and mutually beneficial; the state can no more ignore its poetic “counselors” than they can survive without its goodwill and patronage. Such relations do seem to obtain between Pindar and his clients; he depended on his lofty patrons for largess and inspiration, while his services immortalized the athletic triumphs that assured both their social preeminence and their place in history.30 There are other suggestive parallels between the poet that Pindar apparently was and the poet that Mandelstam longed to become during the turbulent years of the NEP. Unlike Mandelstam, Pindar enjoyed prosperity and acclaim in his own lifetime; but his poetic path, though glorious, was anything but smooth. “A treacherous age hangs over men’s heads,” Pindar warns in his Eighth Isthmian Ode, and, like Mandelstam, he bore witness to great historical upheavals: invasion, war, uprisings, violent rivalries both within and among the Greek city-states. Both poets, moreover, witnessed large-scale social and political transformations, as older orders, with power based on rank and birth, gave way to radically new forms of government: democratic, in Pindar’s Greece, and Marxist-Leninist in modern Russia. For both writers these upheavals threatened to put an end to cherished visions of a larger cultural community, whether Panhellenic, in Pindar’s case, or all-European for the latter-day Hellene Mandelstam.31 Unlike Mandelstam, however, Pindar managed to negotiate these troubled social waters with aplomb; he contrived not only to stay afloat but to prosper. Perhaps most importantly, for Mandelstam’s purposes, he accomplished this feat without compromising either his conscience or his art; to phrase it differently, he served his patrons without doing a disservice to his gift. He was, as one critic puts it, a “hired poet” who sold his praise to
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
165
the highest bidder—Pindar himself mocks what he calls his “mercenary Muse”—yet his faith in his vocation as “poet, priest and prophet” convinced him that it was he who finally conferred the greater gift on his patron, whose deeds would perish without the “sounding words” that were their guarantee of immortality: “The story of things done outlives the act,” he reminds would-be clients. The patron is thus left in the debt of the poet whose wages he pays.32 This transaction sounds very like the ideal exchange that Mandelstam imagines between Culture and the State in his essays. The poet may depend on the State’s patronage for his present welfare, but the State’s future glory rests entirely in the words of the poet whose voice wards off oblivion. Only the poet’s “inscriptions on State buildings, tombs, and gateways insure the State against the ravages of time,” Mandelstam insists in “The Word and Culture” (CPL, 113). The adroit maneuverings between poetry and the powers-that-be that characterize Pindar’s long career came, however, far less easily to Mandelstam, who was temperamentally unsuited to the role of court poet in any case, and who was faced with a regime whose regard for poetry bore no resemblance to that of Pindar’s Greece, much less to Mandelstam’s Hellenized ideal. Pindar was attacked, both in his lifetime and after, for being “a relic of the past in his own time,” whose “backwardlooking,” “outmoded” attachment to “the dying genre of choral lyric” reflected the old-fashioned way of life that nourished it.33 For Mandelstam, though, struggling to reconcile his love for past cultures with the needs of a state consecrated to the cult of the future, Pindar represents the glorious beginnings of a history to which he himself may be destined to make a less than glorious end. The title and subtitle of “The Horseshoe Finder” hint at such a destiny. The horseshoe is all that remains of the great odic tradition that had its beginnings in the chariot races that were Greece’s most prestigious competition. And the horseshoe finder himself, the latter-day poet who stumbles on this memento of past greatness, can answer a fragment only with a fragment, or so the poem’s subtitle suggests. The verbal fragment echoes the physical fragment, and both are metonyms for a cultural unity that is, perhaps, lost forever, whatever the boastful essayist of “The Word and Culture” may claim to the contrary. Taken together, they seem to spell failure. Defeat is not the message with which the poem proper opens, though. Its initial stanzas project a voice and vision that evoke Pindar while being recognizably Mandelstamian. Mandelstam apparently achieves the kind of verbal palimpsest that marks many of the poems from Tristia and Stone, in which his “I” speaks for both himself and the voices of history: Chaadaev (#69) or Ovid (#79, #80, #104); an exiled Decembrist (#94), a Trojan warrior (#119), or a courtier of old Muscovy (#85).34 His voice in “The Horseshoe Finder” is explicitly collective from the start: “We look upon a forest and we say . . .” (my italics). The first-person plural verb forms—the personal pronouns are omitted in the Russian—of the opening stanzas in-
166
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
dicate that the poet, in Pindaric fashion, speaks for and to a larger community, and that he bears responsibility for shaping and guiding this communal endeavor: when you look on a forest, he tacitly tells his audience, this is what you should see, and these are the words in which you should articulate your vision. The poet’s voice, in other words, is public and rhetorical, aimed at persuading his audience to take his vision for their own. It is, in short, the odist’s voice, and we may hear in the poet’s “we” the presence of yet another “I,” that of Pindar himself, whose supremely confident public persona lends his would-be descendant similar energy and assurance.35 What vision does this collective voice articulate? And, if these stanzas truly operate in the Pindaric tradition, whose victory do they seek to commemorate? There are traces of Pindar’s work scattered throughout the opening stanzas: the master mariner and his ship echo the sea voyages that serve in Pindar’s odes as favorite images for the creation of song itself, while the emphasis on human craftsmanship evokes Pindar’s concern with the poet as maker (poixtxs in Greek), as divinely inspired artisan in a world given its best and highest form by human shaping, human accomplishment. This last notion, in particular, leads us back to Mandelstam’s Acmeist poet-maker, and the human-centered, domesticated cosmos he occupies in the essays and early verse. Certainly the poem’s opening stanzas draw a picture of a world ideally subjugated to human purposes. The very trees that begin the poet’s reverie are “teleological,” in Mandelstam’s specifically “Hellenistic” sense. Not only are they defined by their future use at human hands: “Here is a forest of ships, of masts” (2). They are “rosy”; their very bark seems to glow with “teleological warmth,” as though blood, not sap, were flowing beneath their bark. (And when their sap appears in line 15, it takes the human form of “tarry tears.”) Moreover, they themselves plead to be allowed to serve their would-be masters; they “implore the heavens . . . to exchange their noble burden/For a pinch of salt” (26–27). The trees are turned to human purposes not only by the mariner whose feats the poet celebrates, but also by the poet himself. They are raw material for both the shipbuilder and the poet-maker whose imaginings give shape and meaning to the still-unformed forest he evokes in the opening lines. One might even argue that the poet’s making takes precedence over that of the “seafarer”(9), whose presence in the poem springs from the chain of images unleashed by the poet who acts on the forest’s hidden potential. The tools used by the poem’s unnamed mariner further reveal his affinities with Mandelstam’s poet-maker. Human tools hold pride of place in Mandelstam’s Hellenized cosmos and we recognize the tools his seafarer employs from his Acmeist early verse. The “geometer’s brittle implement” might be borrowed from the toolbox of that “simple joiner” Peter the Great, who battles the four elements as he shapes his “frigate” Admiralty (#48); and the mariner’s “plumbline” is the same instrument that allows medieval humanity to challenge the abyss by building Notre Dame (#39).
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
167
The identification that Mandelstam orchestrates here between the poetmaker and the poem’s master builder or man of action is central to his poetics from the earliest Acmeist manifestos in prose and verse, where he draws his colleagues from among the ranks of history’s carpenters, architects, and masons, not to mention emperor-builders like Justinian or Peter. And poem-ships, be they Chinese junks, Achaean warships, or the Egyptian boats of the dead, surface almost as frequently in Mandelstam’s work as they do in Pindar’s.36 But the enigmatic identity of “The Horseshoe Finder” ’s master mariner suggests that this poem-ship bears an usually heavy load, one that proves finally to be beyond its strength, as its voyage breaks down midway through the lyric. I have mentioned Peter the Great and the Admiralty that doubles as his ship of state in Mandelstam’s early lyric, and Steven Broyde has argued persuasively for Peter—“carpenter, founder of the Russian fleet, and helmsman of the ship of state”—as the prototype for the poem’s unnamed “father of wanderings.”37 As the emperor who tore Russia from its historical moorings and set it sailing on a new and uncharted course, Peter would be certainly an apt point of reference for a poet struggling to find historical analogies for a revolution that claimed to be utterly without precedent. Peter, though, is not the only figure whose image lies concealed behind the mariner’s shadowy form. The task of the poet, as Pindar saw it, was to forge links between the present victor’s attainments and the past glories of his ancestors and nation, and, further, to root all these merely human marvels in the world of the divine by way of the myths that celebrate the matchless feats of the gods themselves. This mission has clear affinities with Mandelstam’s efforts to create poetic palimpsests in which past and present coexist in multilayered images that endow the modern age with historical resonance. It is not difficult to imagine mythological precursors for the poem’s Peter, who might equally deserve the riddling epithets that Mandelstam bestows on his shipbuilder: “father of wanderings, seafarer’s friend” (19). Poseidon, sea god and “father of horses,” comes to mind; his dual allegiances would link the poem’s opening images with the chariots that dominate its later sections, and as patron deity of the Isthmian games, he makes frequent appearances in Pindar’s Isthmian odes. And, perhaps most suggestively, there is the sailor whose voyage home from the Trojan Wars in the Odyssey propels the Western tradition itself and all the many literary journeys that followed in Homer’s wake; indeed, Odysseus’ most frequent epithet, polymxchanos, paid tribute to his skills not only as mariner and shipwright, but as ploughman, carpenter, and steersman.38 No single one of these figures provides the key to the identity of Mandelstam’s mysterious seafarer. Instead of giving him a single, clear-cut prototype, Mandelstam endows his wanderer with an aura of suggestive openendedness. He is “sated with time and space” (#92), and this time and space extend across national and historical boundaries to encompass both Peter’s Russia and Pindar’s classical Greece. But this catalog of past heroes
168
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
and gods does not exhaust the seafarer’s possible identities. Pindar evokes past histories and myths to celebrate present triumphs, and his praise poetry thus guarantees his patron a place in the tradition that will bear his feats into the future. In the process, Pindar demonstrates his own worth to the nobles, kings, and even tyrants who commission his work, and so secures his own place in an uncertain world. If Mandelstam is following Pindar’s lead, then the latter-day triumph he commemorates in his poem’s opening lines can only be that of the revolution itself, and Peter’s ship of state exists largely to provide historical ballast for the revolutionary ship that Lenin and his allies were sailing into an uncharted future.39 Mandelstam had described this journey’s beginning in an earlier lyric, “The Twilight [or Dawn] of Freedom” (“Sumerki svobody,” 1918; #103). Like the opening stanzas of “The Horseshoe Finder,” the poem depicts a voyage by sea; and despite its strongly Hellenic coloration, the voyage is clearly that of the new state making its way through unknown waters, as Mandelstam’s contemporaries were quick to recognize. Broyde notes the metaphoric parallels between this poem and “The Horseshoe Finder”—its ship is a “forest” of snares, its rudder “plows” the sea, and so forth—but the real significance of the poems’ similarities lies elsewhere. Both poems employ a lofty, archaic diction, and in both the poet speaks with authority to and for a larger community, a “we.” In this public voice, he takes on themes of great import: the nation, its history, and its fate. The poems operate, in other words, in the tradition of the ode—“The Twilight of Freedom” was originally entitled “A Hymn,” that is, an ode to the gods—and like many odes, they take praise of the nation’s rulers as one of their central topoi. “Let us praise the fateful burden,/Taken by the nation’s chief in tears,” Mandelstam intones in “The Twilight/Dawn of Freedom,” and friends and enemies alike saw Lenin’s portrait in this ambiguous figure. Clarence Brown is right to question those critics in the 1960s who interpreted these lines as expressing unadulterated enthusiasm for the new state’s leader in hopes of restoring Mandelstam to posthumous favor; the poem is nothing if not ambivalent, beginning with its title (the Russian sumerki can mean either dawn or dusk). It would be equally misguided, though, to overlook the poem’s dawn in favor of its dusk; the ship of state may be headed to perdition, Mandelstam seems to say, but its captain may also be steering us toward the dawn of a new day. Whatever his own misgivings may be, the poet does not hesitate to cast his lot among those who have set to sea: “Well then, let us try: an enormous, awkward, creaking turn (povorot) of the rudder.” His praise may be qualified, but it is praise nonetheless for those who have dared to risk all in hopes of gaining all.40 No doubts apparently beset the poet who celebrates ‘The Horseshoe Finder” ’s dauntless mariner, who is as much Lenin as Peter or Odysseus. This captain’s force and mastery are in evidence throughout the opening stanzas, and his power is even greater than it had been in “The Twilight/Dawn of Freedom.” In the earlier poem, Mandelstam celebrates
•
T H E
C U R R E N C Y
O F
T H E
P A S T
•
169
a collaborative undertaking in which he himself participates: “Let us praise,” “We have bonded,” “Let us try.” The “people’s leader (narodnyi vozhd’)” merely guides these efforts; it is the people (or “men,” muzhi) who turn the rudder that shifts the nation’s course. The ship’s captain in “The Horseshoe Finder,” however, charts his course alone; it is his “passion for space” that propels the ship of state, and he alone manipulates the instruments governing its motion. The poet serves merely to laud his master’s achievements as he leads the people’s chorus in praise, and the verbs that describe their behavior stress not action, but perception or reaction: “we look,” “we say,” “[we] admire,” “[we] inhale.”41 This shift accurately reflects the changing nature of Soviet power, as the party’s policies moved away from the utopian dreaming of War Communism—when even committed Bolsheviks believed that a leaderless paradise would emerge from the crucible of war and civil strife—to the more pragmatic considerations that prompted the NEP, as party leadership realized that this paradise would have to be postponed indefinitely while the party, under the unofficial leadership of the equalest of its equals, Vladimir Lenin, established its de facto dictatorship over people and state alike.42 Mandelstam’s goal in the poem’s opening stanzas is not to find fault but to praise, and he apparently achieves his goal in these lines, which lack the pervasive ambivalence that colors his first paean to the revolution’s ship of state. Or do they? The poem itself forces us to challenge this conclusion: if Mandelstam’s hymn of praise is proceeding as planned, then why does it break down so completely at the end of the second stanza? “Where to begin?” the poem asks as the third stanza opens, and ship, captain, and admiring chorus are abruptly jettisoned as Mandelstam challenges not simply these images, but the power and potency of poetic language as such. The ship of state runs aground as the language that had fueled it suddenly loses its force: S hego nahat;? Vs∏ tre]it i kahaetsq. Vozdux dro'it ot sravnenij. Ni odno slovo ne luhwe drugogo. (28–31) Where to begin? Everything cracks and sways. The air trembles with similes. One word is no better than another.
These lines invite us to reread the earlier stanzas in their light, and to examine these stanzas for clues as to what Mandelstam both wishes and fails to achieve in his aborted praise poem. The opening stanzas apparently lack the ambivalence that dominates his earlier ode to the state—but only if we restrict our attention to the poem’s
170
•
C H A P T E R
F I V E
•
“we,” the speaker and his hypothetical community, and its “he,” its composite leader figure. There is, however, another personal pronoun that figures in these opening lines: the “they” representing the trees that are raw material for poet and shipbuilder alike. I have noted their humanized, “Hellenized” nature—their tears, their rosy glow, their yearning to serve the shipbuilder’s lofty goals—and their participation in a “Hellenistic” economy, in which nature submits to human purposes in its desire to help shape a true home for its enterprising masters. Mandelstam’s essays speak to his own desire at this time to find a comfortable fit between this Hellenized cosmos and the Marxist programs of the new state. “The Horseshoe Finder” ’s half-human trees indicate that this fusion of economies, Marxist and Hellenistic, is far from perfect and may even be perilous, if indeed it is possible at all. The opening stanzas grow from these trees and return to them again as the poem’s first segment draws to a close. On their reappearance, the trees are alligned with the poem’s collective speaker—“We say/They too stood upon the earth” (my italics)—and the description that follows hints at why Mandelstam should feel obliged to abandon so abruptly his collective voice and the celebratory vision it articulates. Govorim% I oni stoqli na zemle, Neudobnoj, kak xrebet osla, Zabyvaq verxuwkami o kornqx, Na znamenitom gornom krq'e, I wumeli pod presnym livnem, Bezuspewno predlagaq nebu vy