This page intentionally left blank
Numerical Notation This book is a cross-cultural reference volume of all attested ...
47 downloads
1330 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
This page intentionally left blank
Numerical Notation This book is a cross-cultural reference volume of all attested numerical notation systems (graphic, nonphonetic systems for representing numbers), encompassing more than 100 such systems used over the past 5,500 years. Using a typology that defies progressive, unilinear evolutionary models of change, Stephen Chrisomalis identifies five basic types of numerical notation systems, using a cultural phylogenetic framework to show relationships between systems and to create a general theory of change in numerical systems. Numerical notation systems are primarily representational systems, not computational technologies. Cognitive factors that help explain how numerical systems change relate to general principles, such as conciseness and avoidance of ambiguity, which also apply to writing systems. The transformation and replacement of numerical notation systems relate to specific social, economic, and technological changes, such as the development of the printing press and the expansion of the global world-system. Stephen Chrisomalis is an assistant professor of anthropology at Wayne State University in Detroit, Michigan. He completed his Ph.D. at McGill University in Montreal, Quebec, where he studied under the late Bruce Trigger. Chrisomalis’s work has appeared in journals including Antiquity, Cambridge Archaeological Journal, and Cross-Cultural Research. He is the editor of the Stop: Toutes Directions project and the author of the academic weblog Glossographia.
Numerical Notation A Comparative History
Stephen Chrisomalis Wayne State University
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi, Dubai, Tokyo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521878180 © Stephen Chrisomalis 2010 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provision of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published in print format 2010 ISBN-13
978-0-511-67934-6
eBook (EBL)
ISBN-13
978-0-521-87818-0
Hardback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of urls for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Contents
Acknowledgments
page vii
1
Introduction
1
2
Hieroglyphic Systems
34
3
Levantine Systems
68
4
Italic Systems
93
5
Alphabetic Systems
133
6 South Asian Systems
188
7
Mesopotamian Systems
228
8
East Asian Systems
259
9
Mesoamerican Systems
284
10
Miscellaneous Systems
309
11
Cognitive and Structural Analysis
360
v
Contents
vi 12
Social and Historical Analysis
401
13
Conclusion
430
Glossary
435
Bibliography
439
Index
471
Acknowledgments
Although the history of scholarship on numeration is lengthy and includes such illustrious figures as Alexander von Humboldt, Alfred Kroeber, and Oswald Spengler, its temporal and spatial breadth inevitably means that its practitioners frequently operate in a seeming near-vacuum. For this reason I am doubly grateful for the assistance I have received over the decade since this work’s inception. This book had its genesis during my time at McGill University. The late Bruce Trigger was the shepherd and guiding hand behind this book, beginning in its formative stages and continuing almost to the final draft. The central premise of this book stems from Bruce’s conviction that comparative research is not only possible but indeed necessary in order for anthropology to be theoretically meaningful. Without Bruce’s mentorship and support for me throughout this decidedly unorthodox anthropological pursuit, this book would not exist. Bruce’s death in 2006 was a momentous loss for the discipline and for comparativism. At McGill, in addition to Bruce, Michael Bisson, Andre Costopoulos, Jim Lambek, and Jerome Rousseau read the manuscript and provided useful suggestions for improvement at various stages, as well as providing invaluable moral support to me. Funding at this stage of the research was provided by a Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (Canada) doctoral fellowship. I wish to thank particularly the interlibrary loan staff at McGill’s McLennan Library, who went well beyond the call of duty in tracking down obscure material.
vii
viii
Acknowledgments
Further refinements and a new draft of the book were produced under a SSHRC postdoctoral fellowship at the University of Toronto. While I was in Toronto, Richard Lee, Trueman MacHenry, and David Olson were particularly helpful to me and provided useful insights on the theories and concepts underlying my work, forcing me to clarify my own positions in ways that I had not previously done. Bob Bunker, John Gilks, Heather Hatch, Andy Pope, and Shana Worthen read portions of the manuscript at this stage and provided very useful editorial advice. A work of this scope inevitably relies upon the individual and collective experience of regional specialists in the writing systems and mathematical practices of various regions and periods, and of theorists working in cognitive and psychologically oriented anthropology and linguistics. I have benefited tremendously from the specialized expertise of Priskin Gyula, Christopher Hallpike, Jim Hurford, Joel Kalvesmaki, Eleanor Robson, Nicholas Sims-Williams, Matthew Stolper, and Konrad Tuchscherer. A School of Advanced Research Advanced Seminar entitled The Shape of Script was the key to moving my work into its final completed form, and introduced me to many additional regional specialists whose advice has been of assistance: John Baines, John Bodel, Beatrice Gruendler, Stephen Houston, David Lurie, Kyle McCarter, John Monaghan, Richard Salomon, Kyle Steinke, and Niek Veldhuis. Scholars of numeration include historians, anthropologists, archaeologists, linguists, mathematicians, and psychologists, to name only a few, and it is all too easy in such a disparate crowd of research traditions to lack a sense of disciplinary cohesion and of one’s scholarly influences. I therefore acknowledge my intellectual forebears in the comparative study of numerals, most notably Florian Cajori, Genevieve Guitel, Karl Menninger, Antoine Pihan, and David Eugene Smith. Although I disagree with his conclusions in many places, I thank Georges Ifrah, whose gargantuan and important Histoire universelle des chiffres (1998) inspired me to produce this volume. Eric Crahan and Frank Smith at Cambridge University Press deserve great credit for their skillful guidance of my work through the editorial process at all stages. Russell Hahn guided the complex copyediting masterfully, and Leah Shapardanis prepared the index and read proofs. Many thanks to the fourteen anonymous reviewers who read and commented on one or more chapters on behalf of the Press, and to the entirety of the production staff for their handling of dozens of specialized typefaces. To my family, all my love and thanks. Arthur Chrisomalis provided useful firsthand insights into the childhood acquisition of lexical and graphic numeration, and rekindled his father’s wonderment at the magic of numbers. Finally, this work is dedicated with love to my wife, Julia Pope, for her patience with me over
Acknowledgments
ix
the past decade, her keen editorial eye, her endless willingness to reread manuscript chapters, and her ongoing conviction that this work is worthwhile. Despite the advice and assistance of the abovementioned, and any others I have forgotten, I have doubtless made many errors of fact and interpretation, and I eagerly anticipate the opportunity to broaden my knowledge of numerical notation systems in the future.
Notes on Style Throughout the book I have used the conventions “bc” and “ad” to refer to chronological periods. Where no era indicator is associated, ad dates are assumed; I do so only when the interpretation of a date is obvious.
chapter 1
Introduction
The Western world is a world of written numbers. One can hardly imagine an industrial civilization functioning without the digits 0 through 9 or a similar system. Yet while these digits have pervasive social and cognitive effects, many unanswered questions remain concerning how humans use numerals. Why do societies enumerate? How does the representation of numbers today differ from their representation in the past? Why does the visual representation of number figure so prominently in complex states? What cognitive and social functions are served by numerical notation systems? How do numeral systems spread from society to society, and how do they change when they do so? And, despite their present ubiquity, why have the vast majority of human societies not possessed them at all? If you look up from this page and examine your surroundings, I am certain that you will encounter at least one instance of numerical notation, probably more. Moreover, unless you have a Roman numeral clock nearby, I am nearly certain that all of the numerals you encounter are those of the Hindu-Arabic or Western1 system. Numerals serve a wide variety of functions: denotation – “Call George, 1
The conventional term used in popular literature, “Arabic numerals,” and the term used in most scholarly literature, “Hindu-Arabic numerals,” can lead to considerable confusion because the scripts used to write the Hindi and Arabic languages use numerical notation systems that differ from those of the West in the shape of the signs. I use the term “Western numerals” to refer to this system because it developed in Western Europe in the late Middle Ages, while fully acknowledging its Indian and Arabic ancestry.
1
2
Numerical Notation
876–5000”; computation – “21.00 × 1.15 = 24.15”; valuation – “25 cents”; ordination – “1. Wash dishes, 2. Sweep floor, 3. Finish manuscript”; and so on. Most of the thousands of numerals we see each day barely register on our conscious minds; regardless, we encounter far more written numbers in our lifetime than we do sunsets, songs, or smiles. Until the past few centuries, the opposite was true for most people. These ten digits are so prevalent that it is easy to equate our numeral-signs with the set of abstract numbers. In this view, 62 does not merely signify the abstract concept “sixty-two” – it is the raw form of the number itself, the stuff of pure mathematics (or perhaps pure numerology). That these signs are frequently encountered and used in mathematical contexts contributes to the prevalence of such attitudes. According to this view, our numeral-signs constitute abstract number, and other systems (when recognized as such) are simply archaic deviations from the abstract entity comprised by these signs. This view is erroneous, and rests on the confusion of a mental concept (signified) with its symbolic representation (signifier). Our numerical notation system has an extensive history, as do the more than one hundred systems that have existed over the past five thousand years. Still, the worldwide prevalence of Western numerical notation is undeniable. Most literate individuals worldwide, as well as a sizable number of illiterates, understand them. Nor does any competing system have any reasonable chance of supplanting our system in the near future. This has led many scholars to assert its supremacy solely on the evidence of its near-universality (Zhang and Norman 1995; Dehaene 1997; Ifrah 1998). Nevertheless, this situation does not imply that our system will dominate the whole world forever. The study of numerical notation remains mired in a theoretical framework that has much more in common with late nineteenth-century unilinear evolutionism in anthropology than it does with early twenty-firstcentury critiques of unfettered scientific progress. Despite this theoretical weakness, numerical notation as a topic of academic study is a relatively common pursuit, with linguists, epigraphers, archaeologists, anthropologists, historians, psychologists, and mathematicians all making significant contributions to the literature. These studies are mostly restricted to the analysis of one or a few numerical notation systems, although a small number of synthetic and comparative works dealing with numerical notation exist (Cajori 1928; Menninger 1969; Guitel 1975; Ifrah 1998). However, such works rarely consider more obscure numerical notation systems, such as those of subSaharan Africa, North America, and Central Asia. Similarly, social scientists such as the anthropologist Thomas Crump (1990), the psychologist David Lancy (1983), and the ethnomathematicians Marcia Ascher (1991) and Claudia Zaslavsky (1973) have undertaken major comparative research on numeracy and mathematics in
Introduction
3
non-Western societies. Yet numerical notation has not been a primary focus of this body of research. This study is a comparative analysis of all numerical notation systems known to have existed throughout history – approximately one hundred distinct systems, most of which can be grouped into eight distinct subgroups. By presenting a universal study of such systems and examining the historical connections and contexts in which they are encountered, I will develop a framework that accounts for cultural universals, identifies evolutionary regularities, and yet remains cognizant of idiosyncratic features, seeking to determine, rather than to assume, the amount of intercultural variability among them. I will distinguish several major types of numerical notation, evaluate their efficiency for performing specific functions, link their features to human cognitive capacities, and relate systems to their sociopolitical contexts.
Definitions A numerical notation system is a visual, relatively permanent, and primarily nonphonetic structured system for representing numbers. Signs such as 9 and 68, IX and LXVIII, are part of numerical notation systems, but numeral words such as nine and achtundsechzig are not. Though there are ties between numeral words and numerical notation, a lexical numeral system, or the sequence of numeral words in a language (whether written or spoken), has a language-specific phonetic component. Every language has a lexical numeral system of some sort, while numerical notation is an invented technology that may or may not be present in a society.2 Some numerical notation systems contain a small phonetic component, as in acrophonic systems whose signs are derived from the first letters of the appropriate number-words in a language. However, since such systems are still comprehensible without having to understand a specific language, they are numerical notation systems. Numerical notation systems must be structured. Simple and relatively unstructured techniques, such as marking lines on a jailhouse cell to count one’s days or piling pebbles in a basket, are largely or entirely unstructured. They rely on oneto-one correspondence, in which things are counted by associating them with an equal number of marks or other identical objects. A numerical notation system, by contrast, is a system of different discrete numeral-signs: single elementary symbols, or, in the terminology used in writing systems, graphemes, which are then 2
I will leave aside for the moment discussions of counterevidence questioning the assumption of the universality of lexical numeral systems (Hurford 1987: 68–78; Gordon 2004; Everett 2005).
4
Numerical Notation
used in combination to represent numbers.3 A numeral-phrase is a group of one or more numeral-signs used to express a specific number (e.g., MMDXXV); numeral-phrases such as 8 or Roman L are nonetheless complete even though they only use one sign apiece. All numerical notation systems (and most lexical numeral systems) are structured by means of powers of one or more bases. A power is a number X multiplied by itself some number of times (its power); 101 = 10, 102 = 100, 103 = 1000, etc. By mathematical definition, a number raised to the power 0 equals 1. A base is a natural number B in which powers of B are specially designated. While mathematicians normally require that a base be extendable to an infinite number of powers of B (e.g., 10, 100, 1000, 10,000, ... ad infinitum), most numerical notation systems are not infinitely extendable. It is sufficient that some powers of B are specially designated within a numerical notation system. Western numerals and many other systems use a base of 10, but this is not universal. In addition to its base, a numerical notation system may have one or more sub-bases that structure it. The Roman numeral system has a primary base of 10 with a sub-base of 5. Unlike bases, the powers of sub-bases are not specially designated; there are no special Roman numerals for 25 or 125. It is, rather, the products of a sub-base and the powers of the primary base that are specially designated – for the Roman numerals, 50 (5 × 10) and 500 (5 × 100). Two topics that I will present only peripherally are number and mathematics. Number is an abstract concept used to designate quantity. For the purposes of my study, a simple (if philosophically naïve) definition will suffice. Questions such as whether numbers are “real” or Platonic entities, or the connection of the set of natural numbers to formal logic, are beyond its scope. The distinction between cardinal numbers – denoting quantity but not order – and ordinal numbers – designating ordered sequences – is extremely important for lexical numerals, where many languages use different series of words (e.g., two versus second ) for the two concepts. This distinction also has implications for our understanding of the origin of numerals and numerical concepts in humans (Crump 1990: 6–10), but has little influence on numerical notation. In defining mathematics as the science that deals with the logic of quantity, shape, and arrangement, I am consciously employing a simple definition for a complex term. In order to understand numerical notation, one needs no mathematical ability save some knowledge of basic arithmetic. While some parts of mathematics make frequent 3
A few numeral-signs are more complex in that they graphically combine two or more signs into one in order to represent multiplication, but they are treated as elementary numeral-signs because their use is identical to that of all other simple signs in the systems in question.
Introduction
5
use of numbers (number theory being the most obvious example), large parts of the discipline have only infrequent or peripheral encounters with numerical notation. Numerical notation systems are not necessarily designed with mathematical purposes in mind. Even in contemporary industrial societies, where mathematical ability is more extensive than in any other historical or modern society, most numerical notation is nonmathematical.
Universal Comparison The present study is, as far as possible, a universal one. I have not excluded any numerical notation system intentionally save where data are not plentiful enough to undertake a reasonable analysis. Most comparative research in anthropology aims to discover generalizations and patterns in human behavior, but using the universe of cases is neither possible nor desirable in most cross-cultural studies. In order to use most analytical statistics on cross-cultural data, each case must be independent of the others, which requires that each case may not be historically derived or diffused from any other case. This issue, known as Galton’s problem, is the thorniest methodological issue in statistical cross-cultural research (Naroll 1968: 258–262). The establishment of correlations between traits among historically independent societies is enormously useful, and is the basis for most cross-cultural research in modern anthropology. Yet to do so in a study such as this one, in which there are perhaps only seven independently invented numerical notation systems, would be pointless. Firstly, seven cases would be too small a sample to analyze statistically. Secondly, by studying all cases, I am able to show that the total observable variability among numerical notation systems is far greater than has previously been believed. This variability cannot be understood by studying only a fraction of numerical notation systems. To paraphrase the old fable, if we study only the elephant’s trunk or tail, we ignore most of the animal. Thirdly, I wish to explain structural variation among historically related systems, which frequently differ considerably from their relations. This would be impossible using a sampling technique that omitted related cases. Finally, were I to omit related cases, I could not analyze how systems change over time or how new systems develop out of existing ones. By taking events of change, rather than static systems, as the units of analysis in my comparisons, I am able to elucidate both synchronic and diachronic patterns among numerical notation systems. It is worth noting that Galton’s problem does not apply to events of change of the sort I am analyzing, since every event is essentially independent of every other, and can thus be analyzed statistically, where relevant. I reject as false the dichotomy in anthropology between universalism (Tylor 1958 [1871], White 1949, 1959; Steward 1955; Harris 1968) and relativism (Lowie 1920,
6
Numerical Notation
Boas 1940, Sahlins 1976, Geertz 1984), both of which presume rather than evaluate the degree of regularity that social phenomena display. While numerical notation systems display remarkable regularities and even universals, historical contingencies also played a major role in shaping the cultural history of numerical notation. Yet the only way to determine which features of numeration are cross-culturally regular and which are idiosyncratic is to undertake cross-cultural comparison. The best way to deal with the messiness of the world – less universal than universalists would like, less relative than relativists prefer – is through a body of theory that deals with constraints. Most anthropological theory is predicated on the existence of very strong constraints on the forms possible within human societies. Some of these constraints are so strong as to produce cross-cultural universals (Brown 1991). Most cultural relativists dismiss these universals as minimally true, but facile, irrelevant, and useless for understanding humanity (cf. Geertz 1965, 1984). The denial of comparativism on this basis is an overly negative position, given that those who criticize comparativism most harshly are very often those who have not undertaken it. One of the most crucial theoretical contributions of anthropology should be to indicate the degree to which human societies are alike and the degree to which they differ. While some aspects of human existence are truly universal, and others are almost infinitely variable, most of the really intriguing domains of activity fall somewhere in the middle. In the early 1900s, Alexander Goldenweiser developed his “principle of limited possibilities,” which stated that for any social or cultural phenomenon, there are a limited number of possible forms that can be expressed in human societies (Goldenweiser 1913). Goldenweiser was particularly interested in the limitations imposed by human psychology on the expression of cultural traits, although, given the inchoate nature of psychological theory at the time, he was unable to describe these mechanisms precisely. Bruce Trigger (1991) has rejuvenated the idea of constraints, proposing that anthropologists should use the concept of constraint to describe the limitations on human sociocultural variation – whether those constraints are biological, ecological, technological, informational, psychological, or historical – in order to analyze statistical regularities among cultures without implying determinism. We must be cautious, with both the “limited possibilities” and the “constraint” approaches, not to restrict our formulations and assume the restricting influence of various factors to be more important than positive (enabling) effects. A very strong propensity in favor of some trait is not the same thing as a very strong constraint against all other possibilities. Constraints and inclinations can and do coexist, and the negative limitations of one variable must be weighed against the positive inclinations of another. Despite this caveat, I find a constraint-based approach to be the most
Introduction
7
promising theoretical perspective for explaining the regularities found in numerical notation systems, something to which I will return in Chapters 11 and 12. In much of my analysis, I follow Joseph Greenberg (1978), whose analysis of significant regularities in lexical numeral systems presents a list of fifty-four generalizations. Unlike much of his later work, Greenberg’s study of numerals is universal and cognitive in orientation rather than phylogenetic. It is synthetic, based on the detailed empirical work of earlier scholars, such as the German linguist Theodor Kluge, who spent years compiling sets of numeral terms in languages throughout the world (Kluge 1937–42). While many of Greenberg’s regularities are extremely complex4 or have some exceptions, others reveal truly universal and nontrivial features of every natural language; for instance, every numeral system contains a complete set of integers between one and some upper limit – each system is finite5 and has no gaps (Greenberg 1978: 253–255). Similarly, no natural language expresses “two” as “ten minus eight” or “twenty” as “one-fifth of one hundred.” While every language has a set of lexical numerals, most pre-modern societies functioned quite well without numerical notation. It is possible to conceive of a world in which there are many regularities in lexical numerals, but in which numerical notation systems are highly specific and unique responses to local needs. We do not live in such a world. There is considerable uniformity among the world’s numerical notation systems, and they display many synchronic and diachronic regularities. In fact, the number and variety of conceivable numerical notation systems is far greater than what is attested historically. To take only a very limited example, a numerical notation system can very easily be imagined that is just like the Western system but – instead of being a decimal system – having a base of any natural6 number of 2 or higher. Yet most numerical notation systems have a base-10 structure (and those that do not use multiples of 10). This does not preclude the existence of binary and hexadecimal numerical notation for specialized computing purposes. Similarly, while there are only five basic principles of numerical notation systems found historically (as described earlier), it is easy to imagine other types that could have existed: a system where the size of a numeral-sign is relevant to its 4
5
6
For instance: “37. If a numeral expression contains a complex constituent, then the numerical value of the complex constituent itself in isolation receives either simple lexical expression or is expressed by the same function and in the same phonological shape, except for possible automatic phonological alternations, stress shifts, or overt expressions of coordination” (Greenberg 1978: 279–280). This is not true of numerical notation systems, some of which (like our own) are truly infinite. Or even, as discussed in some aspects of number theory, having a fractional or negative base!
8
Numerical Notation
value, or where all nonprime numbers are expressed multiplicatively using prime number numeral-signs. Several modern writers, abandoning traditional principles of numerical notation, have created new systems ex nihilo that rely on rather different principles than do the systems discussed in this study (Harris 1905; Pohl 1966; Dwornik 1980–81). Explaining regularities from a constraint-based perspective allows us to speculate about why certain numerical notation systems flourish while others do not. Instead of denying the existence of exceptions, I use general rules to explain why special cases are special, and why some imaginable systems are unattested in the ethnographic and historical records. Yet one might wish to contend that comparison of any sort, much less the universal type of this study, is misleading because each culture, and hence each numerical notation system, is a product of unique historical circumstances. If so, comparing Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals to Shang oracle-bone numerals and Inka khipus might be misleading. At best, even if there is a core of features common to all numerical notation systems, I would be labeling oranges apples in order to compare them to other apples. At worst, if these systems are entirely different phenomena, I am trying to make apples out of abaci. Yet the relative ease of intercultural communication refutes the claim that all cultures are incommensurable. The intercultural transmission of ideas relating to numerical notation systems is frequent and poses a serious challenge to this degree of relativism. Prior to comparing phenomena among multiple societies, one cannot assume either that the phenomenon is cross-culturally regular or that it is not. Having compared numerical notation systems on a worldwide basis, I regard the systems as being sufficiently similar to warrant their theoretical analysis as variations on a single theme. I regard numerical notation as translatable cross-culturally without significant loss of information or change of meaning. The number 1138 is practically identical in referent to MCXXXVIII or t\s\rrr\qqq\qqq\qq or any other representation. These systems have very different structures, but, in Saussurean terms, the various signifiers refer to the same signified (Saussure 1959). Although the linguistic and symbolic signifiers for numbers may differ greatly (23, dreiundzwanzig, XXIII, viginti tres, etc.), the correlation of both numeral-phrases and lexical numerals with natural numbers is not culturally relative. Yet, while seemingly uncontroversial in the exact sciences, the cross-cultural universality of number concepts has been criticized recently by relativistic anthropologists and sociologists. In his recent work on Quechua number and arithmetic, Urton (1997) asserts that Western concepts such as “odd/even” are not appropriate to the Quechua arithmetical experience, and that the Quechua use a fundamentally different ontology of numbers than the Western one. Yet Quechua numbers can be understood in the same way as any others, and the Inka numerical notation used by Quechua speakers (Chapter 10) can be compared to others without any particular difficulty. Relativist philosophers such
Introduction
9
as Restivo (1992) claim that 1 + 1 cannot equal 2 in any absolute manner, because if one were to take a cup of popcorn and add a cup of milk to it, the result would not be two of anything, but somewhat more than a cup of pulpy mush. Resisting the temptation to describe such casuistry as pulpy mush, I simply point out that addition is an arithmetical function that can only represent adding discrete objects of a like nature. Such evidence does not convince me that the number concepts of non-Western societies are incommensurable with our own. On the contrary, my own research suggests that these differences are relatively inconsequential in comparison to the commonalities observed in all societies. I acknowledge that, by treating all numerical notation systems purely as systems for representing number, I do not do justice to the complex symbolism that complements many of them or to the scholarship on numerology (Hopper 1938, Crump 1990). The arrival of the year 2000 was not simply another cause for celebration (or trepidation); rather, the nature of our numerical notation system and the “rolling over” of the calendrical odometer on 2000/01/01 held great symbolic and even mystical significance for much of the world’s population. My decision to underemphasize numerology is based partly on space limitations, but also on my theoretical interest in the comparable core of features underlying all lexical numeral systems and numerical notation systems. These interesting differences do not affect the validity of cross-cultural comparisons, but merely highlight the need to establish, rather than assume, the level of regularity in sociocultural phenomena. It may be true, as Geertz (1984: 276) famously asserted, that “[i]f we wanted home truths, we should have stayed at home,” but if we want human truths, we must compare.
Structural Typology of Numerical Notation The systematic classification of numerical notation systems helps to identify their relevant features, distinguish independent inventions from cultural borrowings, and determine how their features relate to their uses. The goal of typology is not simply to develop a scheme into which every case fits, but to do so in a way that allows us to ask and answer questions that could not otherwise be considered. When poorly done, typology is descriptive but nonanalytical, and thus largely useless; when well done, it organizes knowledge in a way that answers inquiries. Any classificatory scheme is inherently theory-laden, and answers only some of the questions that might be asked of a set of data. The typology presented here represents all the major principles by which numbers are represented and emphasizes the features of numerical notation that are cognitively most important. It removes each system from its temporal, geographic, and spatial contexts and examines how numeral-signs are combined to represent numbers.
10
Numerical Notation
Any natural number can be expressed as the sum of multiples of powers of some base. In Western numerals, 4637 is 4 × 1000 + 6 × 100 + 3 × 10 + 7 × 1 – or, to use exponential notation, 4 × 103 + 6 × 102 + 3 × 101 + 7 × 100. Because the Western numerals use the principle of place-value, the value of any numeral-sign in the phrase is determined by its position – position dictates the power of the base that is to be multiplied by the sign in question. If the order changes, the value changes, so that 6437, 3674, and so on mean different things than 4637. We could also write the number out lexically as four thousand six hundred and thirty seven. Instead of using place-value, the powers (except for 1) are expressed explicitly – thousand, hundred, -ty. Because each multiplier corresponds to a word for a power, we could in theory move each power and its multiplier to a different spot without introducing ambiguity; German lexical numerals, among others, do exactly that – viertausend sechshundert sieben und dreizig “four thousand six hundred seven and thirty.” Some numerical systems, however, do not use multiplication at all. To use the Roman numerals, one simply adds up the values of all the signs: MMMMDCXXXVII – 1000 + 1000 + 1000 + 1000 + 500 + 100 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 5 + 1 + 1. Although there is no logical requirement that systems like the Roman numerals list their powers in order, they almost universally do so. The Roman numeral CCLXXVIII could be unambiguously read even if it were written as VIIICCXXL, or even as XLIVIXCIC, if we omit the slight complexity of the occasional use of subtraction. The fact that such disordered phrases are not valid tells us something about systems that lack place-value, however – they too are structured as the sum of multiples of powers. We can thus interpret the Roman numeral MMMMDCXXXVII as (1000 + 1000 + 1000 + 1000) + (500 + 100) + (10 + 10 + 10) + (5 + 1 + 1). I will return in a moment to the issue of the signs for 500 and 5, and how they affect our understanding of such systems. The only major systematic attempt to date to classify numerical notation systems is Geneviève Guitel’s Histoire comparée des numérations écrites (1975).7 Guitel classifies approximately twenty-five systems (drawn from about a dozen societies) according to whether they use addition alone to form numeral-phrases (Type I, like Roman numerals), addition and explicit multiplication (Type II, like English lexical numerals), or implicit multiplication with place-value (Type III, like Western numerals) – just as I have done here. Each type is further subdivided according to the systems’ base(s) and other features. Despite an admirable attempt, Guitel’s analysis fails the most basic test of classification, which is that it must classify similar systems together and separate dissimilar ones. It is problematic because its primary division is made only on the basis of the degree to which multiplication 7
See also Zhang and Norman (1995). Ifrah’s (1985, 1998) popular studies on the subject follow Guitel’s typology.
Introduction
11
is used in forming numeral-phrases. Her typology assumes that, since positional notation is very important to our own numerical notation system, positionality is the primary criterion by which all numerical notation systems should be judged. It is not factually incorrect in any significant way; systems that are identically structured do end up in the same category. Yet because it is tied to the misleading question “To what extent does system X use multiplication to form numeral-phrases?,” it fails to represent fully the similarities and differences among numerical notation systems.8 There is another way to approach the subject, however. Consider a different system, namely, the Babylonian cuneiform positional system, which expresses numbers as combinations of signs for 1 (1) and 10 (a). Like the Roman numerals, the Babylonian system relies on the repetition of like symbols – the number 37 is written as three signs for 10 followed by seven for 1. However, the system also has a base of 60, and multiples of 60 and powers of 60 are written using the principle of place-value. It shares the use of implied multiplication through place-value with the Western numerals but shares the use of repeated added signs with the Roman system. Yet according to Guitel’s typology there is nothing in common between the Babylonian and Roman systems. The resolution to this difficulty is that when one writes a numeral-phrase in any system, one is actually doing two things: expressing the value associated with each power of the base, and then organizing all the powers in a numeral-phrase into a single total value. Thus, I distinguish two separate dimensions of numerical notation systems, which I call intraexponential and interexponential, in order to analyze them adequately. Intraexponential organization determines how numeral-signs are constituted and combined within each power of the base. The major types of intraexponential organization are cumulative, ciphered, and multiplicative. Cumulative systems are those in which the value of any power of the base is represented through the repetition of numeral-signs, each of which represents one times the power value of the sign, and which are then added. For instance, XXX = 30 in the Roman system because the sign for 10 (X) is repeated three times. Ciphered systems, on the other hand, use at most a single numeral-sign for each power represented, with different signs being used to represent different multiples of the power. The Western numerals are ciphered: a number that has as 103 (thousands) as its highest power (e.g., 1984) will require at most four symbols, one for each power of the base. Multiplicative systems have two components for each power represented: a unit-sign (or sometimes multiple signs), which represents the quantity of that power needed to represent the number, and a power-sign, which represents a power of the base. 8
See Chrisomalis (2004) for a more detailed critique of Guitel’s typology.
12
Numerical Notation
The product of the two signs determines the value of that power. The multiplicative principle is often used only to structure higher powers of the base. Interexponential organization determines how the values of the signs for each power of the base are combined to symbolize the value of each entire numeralphrase. It is subdivided into additive and positional subtypes. Additive systems are those in which the sum of the intraexponential values in a numeral-phrase produces its total value. For instance, the Roman numeral CCLXXVIII consists of two 100s (102), one 50 (5 × 101), two 10s (101), one 5 (5 × 100), and three 1s (100), for a total of 278. Positional or place-value systems, of which the Western system is the best known, are those in which the value of a numeral-phrase is determined not only by its constituent numeral-signs but also by the place of each sign within the phrase. The intraexponential values within a numeral-phrase must all be multiplied by the appropriate power-values before the sum of the phrase can be taken. All numerical notation systems are structured both intra- and interexponentially, creating six theoretically possible pairings of principles. However, it is logically impossible for a multiplicative-positional system to exist because multiplicative systems represent the required positional value (10, 100, 1000, etc.) intraexponentially, leaving only five possibilities, as detailed in Table 1.1. Cumulative-additive systems, such as Roman numerals, have one sign for each power of the base; the signs within each power are repeated and their values added, and then the total value of the phrase is the sum of the signs. Cumulative-positional systems likewise use repeated signs to indicate the value of each power, but this value is then multiplied by the place-values (in the Babylonian example used earlier, 60 and 1) before summing the phrase. In order to be entirely unambiguous, some sort of placeholder or zero sign is required. Ciphered-additive systems have a unique sign for each multiple of each power of the base (1–9, 10–90, 100–900, etc., in a base-10 system like the Greek alphabetic system); the values of these signs are added to obtain the value of the numeral-phrase. Ciphered-positional systems like Western numerals have unique unit signs from one up to but not including the base (e.g., 1, 2, 3 ... 9) and a zero sign; the unit-value is multiplied by the power-value indicated by its position, and then the sum of these products gives the total value. Finally, multiplicativeadditive systems (like the traditional Chinese system shown earlier, but also for that matter spoken English lexical numerals, e.g., three thousand six hundred and twenty four) juxtapose a unit-sign (or signs) and a power-sign, which are multiplied together, and then the sum of those products gives the total value of the phrase. Most numerical notation systems use only one of these five combinations throughout the entire system. However, some additive systems use one intraexponential principle (either cumulative or ciphered) for lower powers of the base, and then use the multiplicative principle thereafter. These systems, which I call hybrids, comprise about 30 percent of those I examine in this study. Systems that
Introduction
13
Table 1.1. Typology of numerical notation systems Additive The sum of the values of each power is taken to obtain the total value of the numeral-phrase.
Positional The value of each power must be multiplied by a value dependent on its position before taking the sum of the numeral-phrase.
Cumulative Many signs per power of the base, which are added to obtain the total value of that power.
Classical Roman
Babylonian cuneiform
1000 + (100 + 100 + 100 + 100) + (10 + 10 + 10) + (1 + 1 + 1 + 1)
(10 + 10 + 1 + 1 + 1) × 60 + (10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1) × 1
Ciphered Only one sign per power of the base, which alone represents the total value of that power.
Greek alphabetic
Khmer
1434 = /auld
1434 =
((1 × )1000 + 400 + 30 + 4)
(1 × 1000 + 4 × 100 + 3 × 10 + 4 × 1)
Multiplicative Two components per power, unitsign(s) and a powersign, multiplied together, give that power’s total value.
Chinese (traditional)
LOGICALLY EXCLUDED
1434 =
MCCCCXXXIIII
1434 = ◒⥪䤍ₘ◐⥪
1434 = b3
e4
(1 × 1000 + 4 × 100 + 3 × 10 + 4)
use two principles are not exceptions to my typology. They simply need to be analyzed in two parts, with each part of the hybrid being assigned the appropriate principle. For instance, the version of the Greek alphabetic system shown in Table 1.1 is ciphered-additive for powers below 1000 and multiplicative-additive for those above 1000.9 No numerical notation system employs more than two of the five basic types, and no positional system uses more than one type. Systems that have a sub-base as well as a base require further typological clarification because they may use two intraexponential principles: one for units up to the sub-base, and another for multiples of the sub-base up to the base. For instance, the cumulative-positional Babylonian system shown in Table 1.1 has a base 9
This feature is the one that leads Guitel to place this version of the Greek alphabetic numerals in her Type II as opposed to Type I.
14
Numerical Notation
of 60 and a sub-base of 10. In this case, we must know both how units from 1 to 9 are expressed and how tens from 10 to 50 are expressed in order to fully describe its intraexponential structure. In this case, both the sub-base and the base use the cumulative principle, so we might more properly describe this system as a (cumulativecumulative)-positional system. However, no system uses a different intraexponential principle for its sub-base than for its base, so this elaboration is mostly unnecessary. Again, none of this affects the interexponential structure of these systems. Because it reflects both intra- and interexponential principles, this typology shifts the focus of analysis from systems to the structural principles that build systems, and thus allows a more nuanced comparison of systems’ structures. Moreover, it allows us to ask fruitful questions regarding the cognitive effects and historical development of numerical notation.
Cognition and Number Cognitive psychology examines how the brain processes information, including the study of sensation and perception, concept formation, attention, learning, and memory. Its methodologies are primarily experimental: because neuroscience cannot yet fully observe the workings of the brain directly, cognitive psychologists study the brain by its observable outputs – the behavior of humans under controlled conditions. Information processing is crucial for human survival, and the ability to form concepts is a major part of our species’ evolutionary adaptation. At the same time, however, these concepts are not perfect representations of reality, because the act of conceptualization requires some information to be emphasized, and because errors in information processing reflect the imperfect conceptual abilities of the brain. In this regard, cognitive psychologists would agree with the archaeologist Gordon Childe’s argument that humans do not adapt to the world as it really is, but rather to the world that they perceive as mediated through culture (Childe 1956: 65–68). Still, Childe insisted, human perceptions must correspond reasonably well to reality or else we would not survive. Two cognitive questions inform the study of numerical notation. Firstly, there is the question of origins – how did numerical abilities originate, and how do they relate to the origins of numerical notation? Secondly, there is the question of what cognitive effects, if any, numerical notation has on its users. George Miller’s seminal paper on the “magic number 7 ± 2” remains an essential work for understanding how the brain processes number (Miller 1956). Miller asserts that in several related aspects of human cognition, our capacity for processing information lies between five and nine “units.” Two aspects of his research are particularly relevant to the study of number. Firstly, using research conducted by Kaufman et al. (1949), Miller discusses subitizing, in which small quantities of figures or objects are perceived directly, while larger quantities must be encoded
Introduction
15
by counting, a more time-consuming process. This experiment involved showing groups of dots to subjects for one-fifth of a second, after which they would indicate how many were present; up to five or six dots, few errors were made (subjects were subitizing), while above that number subjects had to estimate and hence made more errors. In more recent studies, the limit of subitizing has been found to be somewhat lower than six, ranging around three or four for most experimental subjects under typical conditions (Mandler and Shebo 1982). Closely related to subitizing is chunking, which organizes large quantities of objects into smaller groups, thereby enabling the brain to process the larger number as a certain number of the smaller sets rather than requiring each object to be cognized independently. North American telephone numbers of ten digits are divided into three “chunks” such as 212-555-2629 rather than written 2125552629, in part to distinguish the area code, local exchange, and individual phone line but also to facilitate memorization and recall. Chunking normally involves the division of a collection of objects into groups of three or four units each, which speeds up the process of perception and accurate quantification by the brain. The perception of larger units as gestalts thus maximizes the brain’s efficiency within the limits of its biological evolution. A third element to be considered, related to the first two, is the principle of one-to-one correspondence defined earlier. This capacity has been studied primarily through research on infants and children (Piaget 1952, Lancy 1983, Wynn 1992). Adults use one-to-one correspondence when they hold up eight fingers to represent eight coconuts, put aside twenty-seven pebbles to count their flock of sheep, or mark twelve lines on a sheet of paper to indicate the number of pints of beer consumed before staggering out of the local pub. Counting (as opposed to subitizing) cannot take place without one-to-one correspondence. One-to-one correspondence can be used in combination with chunking to increase the ease of representation and cognition. After my fifth pint, I might place a horizontal stroke through the four existing strokes to indicate a group of five; my twelve pints would thereby be rendered as two groups of five strokes followed by a group of two (rather erratic) strokes. By extension, numerical notation systems, particularly cumulative ones, rely on one-to-one correspondence. Much of the debate on cognitive domains relating to mathematics and its origins takes place in the realm of comparative ethology, specifically studying number concepts in animals in order to create meaningful analogies with the abilities of human infants and adults (Fuson 1988, Gallistel 1990, Dehaene 1997, Butterworth 1999).10 There is much skepticism about the ability of animals to count, after it 10
These authors go into far more detail on the various research programs undertaken to study animal and human infant perception of numerosity than is warranted here.
16
Numerical Notation
was shown that the mathematical abilities of Clever Hans and other animal calculators were the result of subconscious cues passed from human trainers to these purported prodigies (Fernald 1984). Yet, following in the footsteps of Koehler’s (1951) work on counting among birds, and the enormous literature studying primate numeracy (Matsuzawa 1985; Boysen and Berntson 1989, 1996), we now know that many animal species are able to perceive quantity at least accurately enough to perform tasks involving small quantities, mostly up to three to five units. It is not yet known whether animal quantification is a homology inherited from an ancestral species, a specific convergent adaptation in many species to the requirements of similar physical environments, or a general cognitive response of animals of a certain level of neurological complexity. Many experiments involving many different species have confirmed that something more than a Clever Hans phenomenon is being observed. The same is true in the case of human infants, who are able to distinguish small numerical quantities (Gelman and Gallistel 1978, Wynn 1992). While our hominid ancestors did not need numerical notation, the ability to distinguish between two gazelles and three gazelles would have been cognitively important and evolutionarily adaptive. As the survival of early hominids was strongly predicated upon the ability to function in groups, the number concept likely developed relatively early in human prehistory, although direct evidence is limited. It is highly probable that by the time of the Upper Paleolithic (40,000 to 10,000 years ago), Homo sapiens sapiens possessed languages including two or more numeral words and the ability to conceptually distinguish cardinal and ordinal quantities (Marshack 1972; Wiese 2003, 2007). Any human being (save those suffering from certain types of brain damage or other serious mental deficiencies) has the capacity to learn how to use numerical notation. As a technology invented in particular historical contexts, however, its use is limited to those who have encountered it. Anatomically and cognitively modern humans survived for millennia without any need for numerical notation, and the variability among numerical notation systems cannot be explained fully by the universal human mathematical ability. Even so, this does not prevent us from considering the possible effects of human cognitive capacities on the types of numerical notation system that have been developed historically. It is very likely that the evolved capacity of some primates to distinguish five from six bananas is related to the human visual capacity to distinguish five from six strokes on a tally or knots on a cord. Three biological characteristics of humans pertain to the development of the concept of number, which in turn is necessary for the development of numerical notation. 1. Perception of discrete external objects. The ability, common at least to all animals, to distinguish foreground from background, to perceive the borders of external objects, is necessary to the creation of the concept of “oneness.”
Introduction
17
2. Perception and cognition of concrete quantity. The ability to distinguish the quantity of sets of objects is present in human infants and some animals, but is generally restricted to small quantities. 3. Possession of language. The ability to identify numbers using linguistic symbols, as opposed to the pre-linguistic quantitative abilities possessed by infants and animals, permits the conceptualization of number through a series of lexical numerals, each greater than the previous by one unit.
While numerical notation systems are useful because they enable the human brain to conceptualize quantities efficiently, we must not assume that their structure and evolution can be derived entirely from the principles of cognitive psychology. Some neuropsychologists examine the development of numerical notation from a cognitive perspective (Dehaene 1997, Butterworth 1999). Dehaene (1997: 115–117) uses a stage-based unilinear scheme to describe the development of numerical notation from its beginnings in one-to-one correspondence, through chunked groupings of notches and ciphered numerals, to the ultimate stage of positional notation with a zero. However, I am very suspicious of such schemes in the absence of significant historical documentation. The contention that the history of technology can be understood as a sequence of ever-superior inventions “the better to fit the human mind and improve the usability of numbers” is untested at best, ethnocentric at worst (Dehaene 1997: 117). There are three sociocultural features that are likely prerequisites for the development of numerical notation. These are nonuniversal and derive from contingent historical circumstances, so it is possible to establish whether they are necessary conditions for the development of numerical notation using my universal cross-cultural methodology. 1. Presence of organizing principles that structure the number line. This refers to the ability to structure the natural numbers in a manner most convenient to thought, usually taking the form of a numerical base. No known numerical notation system has ever been developed by speakers of any of the world’s many languages whose lexical numerals have no base. 2. Presence of a nonstructured tally-marking system based on one-to-one correspondence. Often claimed as the earliest stage of numerical notation through which all societies must pass, tallying is a very intuitive way to represent number visually. There is evidence for this form of representation as early as the Upper Paleolithic (Marshack 1972). 3. Social need for long-term recording and communication of number. The social need for a relatively permanent record of numbers is essential to the development of numerical notation. One of its main functions is to assist memory, so the social need to preserve
18
Numerical Notation numbers beyond the ordinary limits of memory – for whatever specific purpose – is probably necessary to its development. Related to this is the need to communicate number outside a local community. While verbal numbers suffice for local communication, the ability of numerical notation to communicate numbers across barriers of geography and language is an important feature that would make its development likely in such circumstances.
Because numerical notation is a human invention, it must be subject to the constraints imposed by our cognitive abilities. Yet, because it is an invention deriving from specific historical contexts, I study its historical development inductively before turning to cognitive approaches. A full explanation of the origin of numerical notation must consider both cognitive and sociohistorical factors. Turning from causes to consequences, I believe that numerical notation has important cognitive effects on its users. These consequences, I suspect, are of a similar nature to Goody’s (1977) suggestions regarding the cognitive consequences of literacy. Goody himself believes this to be the case, as seen from his observations regarding the process of counting cowrie shells among the LoDagaa (1977: 12–13). The LoDagaa separate large groups of cowries into smaller groupings of five and twenty cowries to facilitate the counting of the larger group. While this is not numerical notation, since it does not represent large numbers using new signs for a base and its powers, it is an efficient way of counting a large group of objects. Yet, while LoDagaa boys were expert cowrie counters, they had little ability to multiply, a skill they had only begun to acquire recently in school. The very existence of multiplication tables, a technique used by almost all Western children to learn to multiply, links literacy and the use of numerical notation. While Goody is careful not to overextend this distinction into a rigid dichotomy, he rightly insists that the formalization of numerical knowledge that accompanies written numeration is a more abstract way of using numbers. The comparison of the cognitive abilities of groups who lack numerical notation and those who possess it would best be done through the ethnographic study of a group before and after its members learned such a system, or in a group where some but not all members use numerical notation. To date, no such study exists, although Saxe (1981) has done so for the “body counting” system used by the Oksapmin of Papua New Guinea. I discuss only societies that possess numerical notation, and even then, there is rarely specific contextual information about how the numerals were used. However, it may be possible to determine whether different types of numerical notation have different cognitive effects on their users. It is often assumed that cumulative systems such as the Roman numerals represent “concreteness” in numeration because of their iconicity, while positional systems represent “abstraction” because of their infinite extendability (Hallpike 1986: 121–122; Damerow 1996). The existence of cumulative-positional systems is highly problematic for this
Introduction
19
dichotomy. All associations of numerical structure with cognitive ability are untested, and rely on the equally untested assumption that numerical notation develops from concreteness to abstraction over time. By examining the diachronic patterns that actually occurred in the evolution of numerical notation, I will show that these patterns are multilinear, not unilinear. By comparing the structure of systems to the functions for which they were used, I will examine the cognitive framework within which different groups used numerical notation, keeping in mind that it is only one part of a cluster of techniques that includes mental calculation, lexical numerals, finger numbering, and computational artifacts. Rather than assigning labels such as “concrete” and “abstract” to numerical notation systems, or identifying any other single factor on which the utility of a system should be judged, I focus on a constellation of features of numerical notation systems that have cognitive consequences. This approach is similar to that adopted by Nickerson (1988), who lists the relevant criteria as being ease of interpretation, ease of writing, ease of learning, extensibility, compactness of notation, and ease of computation. A set of nonhierarchical criteria for evaluating systems from a cognitive perspective is a very valuable tool. Nickerson notes usefully: If one accepts the idea that the Arabic system is in general the best way of representing numbers that has yet been developed, one need not believe that it is clearly superior with respect to all the design goals that one might establish for an ideal system. It may be, in fact, that simultaneous realization of all such goals is not possible. (Nickerson 1988: 198)
There is no ideal numerical notation system; rather, each system is shaped by a set of goals that its users and inventors seek to attain, and that they can achieve only by compromising on other factors. There may be patterns of change among systems, but the burden of proof lies with those who wish to maintain that numerical notation evolves in a unilinear sequence.
Numerals and Writing The scholarly analysis of numerical notation has often been pursued by scholars interested in writing systems. Therefore, numerical notation systems are usually regarded as a subcategory of writing systems (Diringer 1949, Harris 1995, Daniels and Bright 1996, Houston 2004). Most numerical notation systems are associated with one or more scripts, and conversely, most scripts have some special form of numerical notation. Numeral-signs are graphemes that undergo paleographic change over time, just as phonographic signs do. The process of recovering instances of numerical notation archaeologically and interpreting them thus
20
Numerical Notation
inevitably involves epigraphers, paleographers, and other scholars of writing. However, the uncritical acceptance of a close connection between numerical notation and writing can lead to unfounded assumptions. There are three basic ways that number is expressed by human beings: a set of spoken lexical numerals, the written expression of those words in scripts, and the graphic expression of number through numerical notation systems. We can divide these three types into auditory systems (verbal lexical numerals) and visual ones (written lexical numerals and numerical notation). Alternately, we might distinguish lexical (verbal and written numerals) from nonlexical (numerical notation) means of expressing number. If the similarities between the two visual representations are more significant than the similarities between the two lexical representations, then the connection between numerical notation and writing is strong. However, four differences between lexical and nonlexical representations of number suggest that this distinction is the more important one. Firstly, lexical numerals are linguistic, while numerical notation represents number translinguistically. Numerical notations followed the evolution of language chronologically, and could not have occurred in a nonlinguistic species, but they are not inherently linked to any language structurally or semantically. The distinction between “writing” and “not-writing” is an issue of great debate among modern scholars, particularly in Mesoamerican (Marcus 1992, Boone 2000) and Andean (Urton 1997, 1998) studies. The most restrictive approach holds that only phonographic scripts – those whose signs can represent phonemes – constitute writing. Accordingly, the Maya glyph system is a “true” script, while the Aztec system is a pictographic system that requires a great deal of context in order to be interpreted, and the Inka khipu notation is a numerical notation system with some undeciphered non-numerical component. A broader approach holds that phoneticism is not an essential feature of scripts, and classifies pictographic representational systems, numerical notation, and even pictorial art under the rubric “writing.” Gelb’s classic definition of writing as “a system of intercommunication by means of conventional visible marks” (Gelb 1963: 253) would suggest that a numerical notation system is a script, although I do not believe that Gelb meant to imply this. I am sympathetic to the argument that because classifying societies as illiterate can be used to denigrate them, a broad definition of writing helps to counteract ethnocentrism, but there is enormous theoretical value in distinguishing phonographic from nonphonographic representation systems. I do not consider numerical notation to be “writing” in this narrow sense. Because numerical notation is nonphonetic, it transcends language and can traverse linguistic boundaries more easily than scripts. It is also learned much more readily than scripts. To use the terms proposed by Houston (2004b), numerical notation systems are “open” and can thus be employed by many groups, as opposed to “closed” notations that are accessible to one or few linguistic or cultural
Introduction
21
communities. Once an individual learns a numerical notation system, he or she can communicate numerically with any other individual familiar with the system, regardless of their linguistic differences. This does not imply that they exist completely outside of culture. As Houston (2004a: 226) and others have noted, quantification systems exist within cultural contexts, which is why, even though we can identify Inka khipu (Chapter 10) as encoding specific numbers, we know little about the communicative acts or information systems underlying them. Yet the fact that we can read Linear A, or Indus Valley, or Inka numerals even though the rest of those representation systems have eluded decipherment is telling. This suggests that numbering is separate from writing, more decipherable and less bound to culturally conventional encoding than other forms of notation. Secondly, numerical notation systems are not limited to societies possessing scripts, nor do societies with scripts necessarily possess numerical notation systems. Unfortunately, while scholars such as Ifrah (1998) and Guitel (1975) mention the existence of tallies, knotted strings, and other such technologies, they are considered solely as peripheral and/or ancestral to numerical notation proper. However, the khipu and several other tallying systems lie within the scope of this study because they are structured by a numerical base and its powers. One problem with studying such systems is that they are notched on wood, drawn in sand, or knotted on ropes or strings, all of which are unlikely to survive archaeologically, while written numerical notation is often found on durable metal, stone, or clay. Far more numerical notation once existed in nonwritten contexts than has survived. Moreover, just as numerical notation is not necessarily encountered in conjunction with writing, many scripts have no corresponding numerical notation system. For instance, the Ogham script of Ireland, the Canaanite script, the early alphabets of Asia Minor such as Carian and Phrygian, and the indigenous scripts of the Philippines all lack numerical notation and instead express numbers lexically. In societies that possess both scripts and numerical notation systems, there are often strong norms prescribing the means of representing number depending on social context. Throughout the Western world, lexical numerals are preferred in literary or religious contexts, while numerical notation is preferred in commercial transactions and accounting. In cases where both systems are found in a single text, there is often a functional division between the two. For instance, the text of the Bible is written using lexical numerals, but chapters and verses are numbered using numerical notation. In writing checks, numerical notation predominates, but dollar amounts are written out in full to prevent forgery. Such contrasts suggest that lexical and nonlexical representations should be treated separately. Thirdly, numerical notation systems and scripts exhibit very different patterns of geographical distribution and historical change. In part, this may be because scripts are largely phonographic, so their diffusion can be constrained by patterns of
22
Numerical Notation
language use. Numerical notation, by contrast, is largely nonphonetic and translinguistic, and may diffuse more readily than scripts. The Western numerals diffused initially from India and passed through the Arab world before reaching Europe, while the Roman alphabet is of Greek and Phoenician ancestry. This historical differentiation is not uncommon; the path of diffusion of numerical notation is often radically different from that of the diffusion of scripts. Yet there may be a connection between the indigenous development of writing and numerical notation. In several historically unrelated cases (Mesopotamia, Egypt, China, and Mesoamerica), the independent invention of numerical notation immediately preceded or coincided with the development of a full-fledged script. Perhaps the social need for numerical notation and a phonetic script tends to arise under similar circumstances (i.e., during the formative phases of early civilizations). Alternatively, the idea of numerical notation, once developed, might naturally suggest to its users that other domains might also be represented visually. I return to this subject in Chapter 12. Finally, the structures by which written lexical numerals and numerical notation express number are quite different. The simple fact of being denoted visually is not as important as the different principles used in the two symbol systems. Lexical numerals (whether written or verbal) share a common structure that is very different from that of numerical notation.11 For instance, while the cumulative principle is commonly employed in numerical notation, it is nearly absent from lexical numeration. No known language expresses thirty as “ten ten ten,” even though cumulative numeral-phrases (like the Roman XXX = 30) are quite common. In lexical numeral systems that have a base, multiplicative-additive structuring is overwhelmingly prevalent, whereas numerical notation systems are only occasionally multiplicativeadditive. To take a familiar example, let us compare Western numerical notation with English lexical numerals. The English lexical numerals eleven and twelve do not follow the regular pattern for numbers between thirteen and nineteen, and words like dozen and score add further complexity. Our numerical notation system is base10 and ciphered-positional, while English lexical numerals use a mixed base of 10 and 1000 (one million = 1000 × 1000; one billion = 1000 × 1000 × 1000), a situation that becomes even more complex if we include British English, in which one billion normally means one million millions (1012). Finally, while Western numerals are infinitely extendable – one can add zeroes to the right of a number ad infinitum – English lexical numerals are only potentially infinite, since one needs to develop new words to express higher and higher values. The highest number in many English dictionaries is decillion (1033 in American English, 1060 in British English). 11
The major exception to this disjunction is the classical Chinese numerals, which due to the somewhat logographic nature of the Chinese script serve both as lexical numerals and as numerical notation. I will return to this definitional issue in Chapter 8.
Introduction
23
The relationship between the origins of writing systems and numerical notation systems is similarly complex. Visual number marks clearly precede phonetic writing by many millennia. A wealth of evidence from Upper Paleolithic portable artifacts (e.g., notched bones and stones) suggests that one-to-one marking of numbers for calendrical or other mnemonic purposes has roots extending back at least 30,000 years (Absolon 1957, Marshack 1972, d’Errico 1998, d’Errico et al. 2003). This may in turn have been related to the early use of the fingers and hands as a visual, though nonpermanent, numerical system around the same time (Rouillon 2006).12 Schmandt-Besserat (1992), on the basis of controversial interpretations of Mesopotamian evidence from the proto-literate period, has been the strongest advocate for an evolutionary sequence from numeration to writing. Houston (2004: 237) argues that most writing systems emerged as “word signs bundled with systems of numeration that probably had a different and far-more-ancient origin,” and this may be correct. However, numerical notation (as opposed to non-basestructured tallies) does not greatly precede, if at all, the earliest writing. As I shall show, in all the independent cases of the development of numerical notation, written numerical systems with bases emerge alongside other conventionalized signs, not as a unilinear predecessor to them. For these reasons, to analyze numerical notation systems as adjunct components of scripts does not do them justice. Nevertheless, throughout this study I will sometimes refer to numeral-signs and numeral-phrases as being “written.” When I do so, it is mere conventionality, and this usage does not indicate any specific relationship between numerals and scripts.
Diffusion and Invention Numerical notation systems develop out of purposeful human efforts to perform tasks related to the visual representation of number. In a handful of instances, they developed independently of influence from other numerical notation systems, while in the vast majority of cases systems were borrowed wholesale or with modification from one society to another. I want to explain the origin, transformation, transmission, and decline of systems, not merely to describe a sequence of historical events. This does not mean that technical and functional aspects should be given priority over social factors; rather, social context and historical contingencies must be incorporated into analyses of the histories of systems. It does require, however, that I distinguish analogies – similarities that derive from independent operation of cause and effect – from homologies – similarities that derive from the 12
It is absolutely clear that manual counting and numerical notation are connected in later societies known through written and oral evidence (see Chapter 12).
24
Numerical Notation
descent of cultural features from a common ancestor or the borrowing of features from one society to another. In anthropology, analogies and homologies are normally seen as dichotomous, with materialists (Steward 1955, Harris 1968) preferring analogical explanations and regarding independent invention as common and idealists (Elliot Smith 1923, Driver 1966, Rouse 1986) assigning priority to homologies and using borrowing to explain most cross-cultural similarities. There is no serious scholar who denies that some features are developed independently multiple times, and similarly no one doubts that societies borrow extensively from one another. Despite this, the anthropological effort to distinguish cultural analogies and homologies has not been especially fruitful (Steward 1955, Kroeber 1948, White 1959, Driver 1966, Tolstoy 1972, Jorgensen 1979, Maisels 1987, Burton et al. 1996). Harris (1968) has attempted to circumvent the debate by noting that regardless of how a trait was exposed to a society, it must still be accepted and integrated into that society, even if it is borrowed from elsewhere. He thus asserts that diffusion is a sterile “nonprinciple” that is “not only superfluous, but the very incarnation of antiscience” (1968: 378). Harris is right that simply classifying an innovation as representing either diffusion or independent invention is insufficient, but he is wrong in implying that it does not really matter whether a trait was of internal or external origin. In practice, Harris’s rejection of diffusion leads him to assume that cultural adaptation is a unitary process and that analogical explanations are the only ones worthy of scientific consideration. Yet if the social consequences of, and motivations for, adopting diffused numerical notation systems and adopting independent invention are different – as I believe them to be – then we must instead compare the two different circumstances while keeping an open mind as to potential differences. “Diffusion” is often implicitly taken to represent a largely benign transfer of features from one group to another, followed by a period in which the recipient society evaluates the innovation, followed by its acceptance or rejection. This extremely naïve view of processes of cultural contact denies entirely the role of imperialism, peer-polity networks, and power structures. For instance, many numerical notation systems developed in societies just as they began to enter into longdistance trading relationships with larger, more politically complex state societies that already possessed numerical notation. Numerical notation, in this instance, is not simply something that happens to be transmitted due to cultural contact; it is a medium through which contact takes place and a feature that becomes important just as societies are becoming integrated into larger intersocietal networks. Power relations are always involved in such cases, and we need to understand how the social statuses of individuals and groups within given contexts affect the transmission process and the eventual outcome. Yet the existence of historical
Introduction
25
contingencies need not be fatal to the development of a cultural-evolutionary theory of numerical notation. In order to demonstrate empirically the cultural evolution of numerical notation, we must examine how systems change in a patterned way, comparing analytically the conditions under which numerical notation systems are invented, transmitted, and adopted. In this study, I address three basic contextual questions regarding each numerical notation system: 1. What antecedent(s) does the system have, if any? I establish whether each system is descended from antecedent numerical notation systems. Numerical notation was independently invented six or seven times, and these “pristine” systems stand at the head of cultural phylogenies, but are certainly not the norm. Independent invention should not be the null hypothesis for any account of the origins of a system, but neither should it be restricted only to very ancient systems. Most systems have one antecedent only, while a few systems blend features of two antecedents. 2. Does the new system supplant one or more older systems? I establish what happens when a new system is introduced into a society that already uses numerical notation. Four outcomes are possible: a) the newly introduced system replaces the existing one; b) the new system is used in conjunction with the older one, normally with some sort of functional division between the two; c) elements of the original and new systems are commingled to create a third system; d) the new system is rejected entirely, while the older system is retained. All these outcomes are attested multiple times. 3. Does the new system use the graphic symbols and/or the structural principles of its antecedent(s)? I establish how specifically the new system resembles its antecedent(s), either in the form of its numeral-signs or in its structure (base, interexponential and intraexponential principle[s], and additional signs). Resemblances among closely related systems, in conjunction with other historical evidence, help to specify the exact connection between them.
To answer these questions, criteria must be adopted to distinguish endogenously invented systems from ones introduced from outside a society and to specify connections between ancestral and descendant systems. Discerning historical relations among cultural phenomena can be extremely contentious, particularly when only archaeological data are available. Rowe (1966) would permit diffusionary explanations only when abundant evidence of colonies, trading posts, or traded objects independently confirms contact between two regions, while Tolstoy (1972) deemed it sufficient to show that a particular combination of features is probabilistically unlikely to have occurred independently. This question is unresolvable in the abstract, because the ease of demonstrating cultural transmission depends on the nature of the specific trait or phenomenon being studied.
26
Numerical Notation
Few inventors of numerical notation systems have ever provided detailed information about the contexts of their inventions. Thus, I must build a circumstantial case for the origins of most systems. In order to demonstrate cultural affiliations between numerical notation systems, I use both internal (structural and graphic) resemblances between systems and external (contextual and historical) considerations. The main criteria I use are as follows: 1. Use of the two systems at the same point in time. This criterion is nearly unavoidable; some chronological overlap in the periods during which two systems are used is needed to sustain a hypothesis of cultural transmission. An extinct system might conceivably be revived and modified by a later society (for instance, on the basis of old inscriptions), but this is hardly a sufficient basis for a hypothesis of cultural transmission. Alternately, a system that is not attested to have survived may in fact have done so; this is the basis of the controversial theory that the Mycenean Linear B numerals (Chapter 2) gave rise to the Etruscan numerals (Chapter 4). Such hypotheses cannot be dismissed immediately, if other factors suggest that they could be true, but they require much more evidence. 2. Similarity in structural features. Because there are only three intraexponential principles (cumulative, ciphered, multiplicative), two interexponential principles (additive, positional), three common bases (10, 20, 60), and two sub-bases (5, 10), no one aspect that is similar in two systems is sufficient to prove a connection. However, when two systems are alike in all or most of these respects, cultural contact becomes a much more likely explanation for the resemblance. Many of the cultural phylogenies of systems that I discuss share a common structure; for instance, all the Italic systems (Chapter 4) are cumulative-additive with a base of 10 and a sub-base of 5. This does not mean that all identically structured systems must be placed in that phylogeny – the Ryukyu sho-chu-ma numerals (Chapter 10) and modern Berber numerals (Chapter 10) do not fit because they were used much later and have different numeral-signs. The use of structural features as evidence of contact suffers from the weakness that, if many systems in a phylogeny are identical or similar, it is often impossible to choose between several equally likely candidate ancestors. 3. Similarity of forms and values of numeral-signs. Because many graphic symbols are very complex, they are unlikely to have developed independently. If the forms of numeral-signs used in two systems are identical or very similar, and if those signs represent the same numerical values in the two systems, it is likely that cultural contact resulted in the invention of the later system based on the earlier one. The more signs that are shared between two systems, the more likely it is that there is a historical connection between them. However, when two systems use similar signs for different numerical values, this is not good evidence of such a connection. For instance, à and J represent 10 and 20 in the Kharoṣṭhī
Introduction
27
numerals (Chapter 3) but mean 7 and 9 in the Brāhmī numerals (Chapter 6). In this instance, even though the two systems were used in the same region at the same time (the Indian subcontinent in the fourth century bc) and have two similar numeral-signs, the dissimilarity of their values reduces the likelihood of a historical connection. Caution must be exercised when invoking this criterion for very simple symbols – vertical and horizontal lines, dots, circles, crosses, and the like – because such designs are cross-culturally common. This is especially true in the case of the use of lines and dots with the value of one, since these signs may have been part of tallying systems before being used in numerical notation systems. Cases where signs are similar but not identical must also be treated with caution. There is no general paleographic principle for identifying relations among graphically similar signs; hence, such efforts usually proceed on an intuitive basis. 4. Known cultural contact between the regions where the two systems are used. In general, where one cultural trait is transmitted from one region to another, multiple traits are likely to have been transmitted. Thus, where there is a known pattern of shared non-numerical features in two societies, or where there is substantial evidence of interregional trade, migration, or colonization, such evidence supports a postulated ancestor-descendant relationship between two numerical notation systems. Determining whether known cultural contact is sufficient to postulate the diffusion of a numerical notation system is always a tricky matter and involves an evaluation of various lines of evidence. For instance, one of the difficulties in postulating that the Brāhmī numerals (Chapter 6) are descended from the Egyptian demotic ones is that, despite structural and graphic resemblances between the two systems, Egypt is well down on the list of areas with which ancient India had contact. In no case do I postulate a connection between two systems solely on the basis that they were used at approximately the same time and in a single region. There must always be some structural or graphic resemblance between postulated ancestor and descendant systems. This problem is made more complex by stimulus diffusion, a complex blend of inventive and diffusionary processes in which awareness of an invention is transmitted, but, because of some obstacle to transmission or acceptance, the actual invention does not take hold in the adopting society (Kroeber 1948: 368–370). However, because the general principle is seen as useful, some members of the adopting society, stimulated by the original idea, invent their own version of the innovation. The most widely cited example of stimulus diffusion is the development of the Cherokee syllabic writing system by Sequoyah in the nineteenth century, based on his rudimentary knowledge of the Western alphabet. While several numerical notation systems resulted from stimulus diffusion (e.g., the abortive
28
Numerical Notation
Cherokee numerals, never used in the syllabary), no principles exist to help identify stimulus diffusion. It is tempting to postulate stimulus diffusion even when the basic fact of incomplete transmission cannot be established. However, I use stimulus diffusion as an explanation only when it can be established that the form of cultural contact that occurred between two regions fits Kroeber’s model. 5. Use of ancestor and descendant systems in similar contexts. If two systems serve similar purposes, on similar media, or among similar social groups in their respective societies, this can serve as further confirmatory evidence that the two systems are related historically. This factor, while useful, is never sufficient on its own to demonstrate such a connection, but it may provide further support. For instance, the spread of the Greek alphabetic numerals into Armenia and Georgia (Chapter 5), though poorly documented, is confirmed not only by the striking similarities in the systems but also by the systems’ use in Bibles and other liturgical texts. The similarities among some of the cuneiform systems of Mesopotamia (Chapter 7) rest on their common use of a wedge-shaped stylus on clay media as much as on specific resemblances in the numeral-signs or their organization. 6. Geographic proximity of the regions where two systems were used. All other factors being equal, a system is more likely to have been modeled on one that is used by neighboring groups than on one used more distantly. This is a particularly dangerous criterion to invoke, especially where there is less cultural contact between neighboring regions than with more distant regions. Many times, two very different and unrelated systems are used in proximity to one another, and other times, closely related systems are used at considerable distances from one another. Geographical proximity is such a weak measure that I will use it only as a last resort, and never as the sole factor for hypothesizing transmission. Establishing links between ancestor and descendant systems, within the limits of the available data, allows me to describe phylogenies of related systems. These are, however, analytical descriptions, which allow the explanation of evolutionary patterns of change in numerical notation systems. These explanations are analogical, because they describe independent recurrences of cause and effect. However, they are also explaining homological processes resulting from cultural contact and the transmission of knowledge among many societies. This is a paradox only if we accept the notion that these two concepts stand in opposition to one another. A phylogenetic perspective is both homological and analogical, seeking to describe particular historical contexts, but also to derive general processes by which numerical notation systems are related to one another. Diffusion may be, as Harris contends, a nonprinciple, but it is not a nonprocess. Comparing ancestor and descendant systems, and understanding the nature of the process of borrowing and adoption of cultural features, is absolutely essential to an evolutionary perspective on cultural change.
Introduction
29
Technology, Function, and Efficiency Modern historians of science such as Thomas Kuhn (1962) have effectively demolished the myth of linear progressivism in science. While in some fields, the accumulation of knowledge leads to a better understanding of reality, and technical innovations likewise have antecedents, the burden of proof has now rightly shifted to those who wish to demonstrate that progress occurs. Progressivist schemes that assume rather than demonstrate the superiority of new technologies, imply that where such progress exists it implies moral superiority, or argue teleologically that present achievements can never be exceeded, have no scientific credibility. Yet these preconceptions abound among scholars of numerical notation; this shift in our conception of progress has not yet taken hold. Consider the following collection of recent laudatory statements regarding Western numerals: Sa perfection va bien au-delà de la civilisation indienne puisqu’aucune autre numération de Type III n’a jamais été en mesure de l’égaler. (Guitel 1975: 758) If the evolution of written numeration converges, it is mainly because place-value coding is the best available notation. So many of its characteristics can be praised: its compactness, the few symbols it requires, the ease with which it can be learned, the speed with which it can be read or written, the simplicity of the calculation algorithms it supports. All justify its universal adoption. Indeed, it is hard to see what new invention could ever improve on it. (Dehaene 1997: 101) Our positional number-system is perfect and complete, because it is as economical in symbols as can be and can represent any number, however large. Also, as we have seen, it is the most efficacious in that it allows everyone to do arithmetic. . . . In short, the invention of our current number-system is the final stage in the development of numerical notation: once it was achieved, no further discoveries remained to be made in this domain. (Ifrah 1998: 592)
Such perspectives accept without proof that the Western numerals are the most efficient ever developed, and are not only the “best” in existence but also “perfect” – the best that could ever be conceived. Their adoption by the vast majority of human societies today is perceived as a natural and inevitable consequence of this superiority, only minimally mediated by social factors. Other, more cumbersome systems are to be evaluated in relation to the Western system, and in particular to their utility for arithmetical calculations and higher mathematics. Since so many modern technologies require mathematics, Western numerical notation is a partial cause of these evolutionary developments. The corollary of this proposition, often left unstated, is that those societies that did not develop or adopt Western numerals failed to compete politically with the West in part because of this.
30
Numerical Notation
I consider the decimal, ciphered-positional system of numerical notation developed in India in the sixth century ad and transmitted by Arab scholars to Western Europe to be a very remarkable invention. Its brevity, unambiguity, and ease of learning make it conducive to the practice of written arithmetic and mathematics. How well numerical notation systems represent number strongly affects the development of new systems, their acceptance after being transmitted, their modification over time, and their eventual abandonment. This pattern of long-term sociocultural change can meaningfully be called evolutionary. The primary difficulty with the assumption of the evolutionary progress of numerical notation is not the notion of evolution itself. The problem is that the efficiency of numerical notation systems cannot be evaluated in the abstract, but only by considering the purposes for which they were developed and used. It is often assumed that the function of numerical notation is to perform written computations. For instance, Ifrah, whose work is the most popular and influential study of the history of numerical notation, writes: To see why place-value systems are superior to all others, we can begin by considering the Greek alphabetic numeration. It has very short notations for the commonly used numbers: no more than four signs are needed for any number below 10,000. But that is not the main criterion for judging a written numeration. What matters most is the ease with which it lends itself to arithmetical operations. (Ifrah 1985: 431)
This view is entirely erroneous. Numerical notation was a necessary condition for the development of modern mathematics, but it is ethnocentric to argue from this that its purpose was to facilitate the development of mathematics. The efficiency of any technology can be evaluated only in terms of the purposes for which it was developed and/or used. There is thus no eternal abstract standard of efficiency for any technology. It smacks of teleology to argue that Western numerical notation is wonderful because it enabled modern mathematics to develop. The origin of Western numerals had little to do with mathematical computation and much to do with writing dates on ancient and medieval southern Asian inscriptions. The primary function of numerical notation is always the simple visual representation of numbers. Most numerical notation systems were never used for arithmetic or mathematics, but only for representation. Even when they are used in mathematical contexts, they frequently simply record the results of computations performed in the head, on the fingers, or with an abacus. Even in industrialized societies, computation remains a secondary function of numerical notation. I am looking at a not-so-crisp Canadian five-dollar bill, on which numerals indicate a monetary value (5), the date the bill was designed (1986), a serial number with some letters to render it unique (GPA6537377), and the number 64 penciled in
Introduction
31
one corner (probably to record the number of five-dollar bills received at some event). None of these numeral-phrases was actually ever used to compute.13 Numbers denote far more often than they reckon, even in our highly numerical society. This was doubly true in pre-industrial contexts. In defining a numerical notation system as a system for representing numbers, I am explicitly making a functional statement. At minimum, whatever else numerical notation may mean in a particular society, it must always express number as one of its functions. I am not saying that a numerical notation system must be fully integrated with other sociocultural phenomena, that it must be perfectly adapted to serve social needs, or that the purpose for which it is used must be that for which it was developed. The representational function of numerical notation is general enough that it can be stimulated by a variety of social or political needs. While trade is the most obvious one – making transactions possible over long distances, enabling monetary calculations, or recording results to facilitate accurate bookkeeping – it is not the only one. For instance, the main impetus behind the origin of the Mesoamerican numerical notation systems was probably astronomical and calendrical, while the Shang numerals were first used in the context of Chinese divination. We should not expect to find a single specific domain of activity correlated with the origin of numerical notation, and we should be skeptical of universal or unilinear schemes. If we wish to compare the efficiency of various numerical notation systems, we must compare systems that served a common purpose in terms of how well they served that purpose. Because all systems represent number visually, some general criteria can be used. A system that represents numbers using few number-signs is more efficient than one that requires many signs. One could then argue that the Roman numerals are not as efficient for representing number as Western numerals are because 1492 is much shorter than MCCCCLXXXXII (or MCDXCII). While the situation is slightly more complex – MMI is shorter than 2001, for instance – the Roman numerals are more concise for only a small fraction of all natural numbers. Two other criteria that are relatively easily definable are a system’s sign-count (how many signs it uses in total) and extendability (the highest number expressible).14 I return to these criteria in Chapter 11 and show how they can be used to ask
13
14
One might protest that the numeral on the bill is used in doing arithmetical computations such as providing change for purchases. To refute this, one need only go into a bank and ask for $100 in five-dollar bills, and see whether the teller looks at the number on each bill, or whether in fact he or she merely counts out twenty bills while doing mental arithmetic. The numeral on the bill denotes its value, but is not used in calculation. See Nickerson (1988: 189–197) for a different, but related, list of criteria used in comparing numerical notation systems.
32
Numerical Notation
fruitful questions that help explain synchronic and diachronic patterns among attested systems. By contrast, efficiency for computation is a Western-centered and historically inaccurate benchmark for comparing numerical notation systems. Zhang and Norman’s (1995) paper on the visual representation of numbers through numerical notation is a major step forward in our understanding of how numerical notation systems work. They analyze how specific systems visually represent (or fail to represent) numerical information, describe three general means by which numerical notation systems are structured (shape, quantity, and position), and then examine how these features are combined in numerical notation systems. Yet their analysis falls apart because they compare and evaluate different numerical notation systems based on their ability to aid in multiplication. Even if Western numerals are the best system for doing arithmetic (which would best be resolved through the use of the systems rather than abstract theorization), most other systems were never designed or used for such a purpose. The situation is analogous to denigrating screwdrivers for being inefficient hammers. The fact that one can use a screwdriver handle to drive in nails does not justify that comparison, just as the fact that one might use Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals to multiply does not justify comparing them to systems such as the Western numerals. To add insult to injury, even though Zhang and Norman recognize that calculation technologies such as the abacus are frequently better than numerical notation for doing arithmetic, they suggest that part of Western numerals’ superiority is that they are used for both calculation and representation, while other societies employed two separate systems (Zhang and Norman 1995: 293). They thus blame the carpenter for using both a hammer and a screwdriver where just the screwdriver would do. Such arguments are little more than elaborate rationalizations for a historical fact (the near-universality of Western numerals) that eludes simple explanation. The only way to compare numerical notation systems fairly is to use functional criteria that apply to all systems (namely, those related to simple representation). Yet, even where there are definite answers to these efficiency-related questions, this does not mean that individuals testing out a new system will immediately perceive its advantages and disadvantages. A familiar but in some respects inefficient system, so long as it is not entirely unworkable, may be retained, despite its “obvious” inferiority. There may be a steep learning curve preventing the easy adoption of the alternative system, or there may be cultural or political reasons for retaining one’s present system. Moreover, numerical notation, as a system for communicating information to others, requires not only that specific individuals adopt it, as would be the case with a more efficient plough or a better mousetrap, but also that an entire social group learn it before its usefulness will be evident. A system with many users is functional for that reason alone, because it can be
Introduction
33
used to communicate with more people than one with few users. Thus, it is inappropriate to evaluate numerical notation systems only in terms of their structural features. Rather, these features must be considered in the broader social context in which systems develop and are used. I examine these social factors and show how, far from negating structural factors, structural and social explanations of regularities combine to produce a more complete understanding of numerical notation than has previously been possible. I turn in the following chapters to the body of data itself. I endeavor to highlight the ways in which the general theoretical principles just discussed relate to the data. I have organized these data according to cultural phylogenies of related systems, presenting the earliest systems first, leading forward to systems developed more recently. The first five phylogenies are probably related to one another historically, so I treat them together, but no other principle has been used in the ordering of chapters. The eight major phylogenies, each of which merits a full chapter, are as follows: Chapter 2: Hieroglyphic – systems historically descended from the Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals; Chapter 3: Levantine – systems used in the Levant, descended from the Aramaic and Phoenician numerals; Chapter 4: Italic – systems used in the circum-Mediterranean region, descended from the Etruscan numerals; Chapter 5: Alphabetic – systems whose signs are mainly phonetic script-signs, descended from the Greek alphabetic numerals; Chapter 6: South Asian – systems originating on the Indian subcontinent and descended from the Brāhmī numerals; Chapter 7: Mesopotamian – systems used in Mesopotamia, descended from the protocuneiform numerals; Chapter 8: East Asian – systems descended from the Shang numerals; Chapter 9: Mesoamerican – systems descended from the Mesoamerican bar-and-dot numerals.
Chapter 10 is devoted to miscellaneous systems and cultural isolates that do not fit into any of these phylogenies, and also to the numerous systems invented in colonial contexts over the past two hundred years. Chapter 11 analyzes synchronic and diachronic regularities among numerical notation systems in a structural and cognitive framework, while Chapter 12 tempers these findings with considerations relating to social context.
chapter 2
Hieroglyphic Systems
A recognizable phylogeny of numerical notation systems was used in conjunction with a group of related scripts and their descendants, beginning with the Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals as early as 3250 bc, which thus rivals the Mesopotamian family (Chapter 7) as the oldest attested numerical notation anywhere. Among these, I include the Egyptian hieroglyphic system, obviously, but also the Hittite hieroglyphic, Cretan hieroglyphic, Minoan Linear A, Mycenean Linear B, and Cypriote numerals. In addition, I include the Egyptian hieratic and demotic systems, which are cursive reductions of the Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals, even though they are structurally closer to the alphabetic systems (Chapter 5), to which they are ancestral. I use the term “hieroglyphic” simply because several systems discussed in this chapter are associated with “hieroglyphic” scripts, rather than to imply anything about the systems’ structure. The hieroglyphic systems are summarized in Table 2.1.1 Of these systems, the Egyptian hieroglyphic has been discussed most extensively, though it has often been misinterpreted, while others, such as the Cypriote system, are severely understudied and poorly known. Identifying these systems and distinguishing them from other, superficially similar ones helps explain the diffusion of numerical notation throughout the ancient Mediterranean region. 1
The hieratic and demotic systems are too complex to be included on this chart; consult their individual entries for their numeral-signs.
34
Hieroglyphic Systems
35
Table 2.1. Hieroglyphic numerical notation systems System
1
10
100
1000
10,000 100,000 1,000,000
Egyptian hieroglyphic
q ù\= Å Å Å q
r • É\• É É É
s 0 æ æ
t ÿ Æ Æ
u\‹
(
)
Cretan hieroglyphic Minoan Linear A Mycenean Linear B Cypriote syllabic Hittite hieroglyphic
v
w
ô
The hieroglyphic phylogeny of numerical notation systems is ancestral to the Levantine (Chapter 3), Italic (Chapter 4), and Alphabetic (Chapter 5) phylogenies, but its systems differ sharply from those of its descendants.
Egyptian Hieroglyphic The hieroglyphic script is the best-known ancient Egyptian script. It was used between about 3250 bc and 400 ad, making it the longest surviving of all scripts (Loprieno 1995). However, its use was restricted geographically to the Nile Valley and nearby areas under Egyptian control. While the hieroglyphic script may well have arisen because of stimulus diffusion and trade with Mesopotamia, the scripts in these two areas emerged essentially simultaneously and show no substantial resemblances. Hieroglyphic inscriptions are written from top to bottom, left to right, or right to left, with the last of these three options being the most common (Ritner 1996: 80). The script is mixed in principle, with both phonograms (consisting of one, two, or three consonants) and logograms indicating words nonphonetically (Ritner 1996: 74). The later hieratic and demotic scripts used to write the ancient Egyptian language, as well as the Meroitic hieroglyphic script, are directly derived from the hieroglyphic, while the early scripts of the Levant and the Aegean are probably its less direct descendants. Numbers other than ‘one’ are very rarely expressed through lexical numerals in Egyptian, making it difficult to determine their structure, although evidence from some Old Kingdom Pyramid Texts and later Coptic writings establishes that they had a purely decimal structure with words for each power of 10 up to 1,000,000 (Loprieno 1995: 71). Most hieroglyphic inscriptions express numbers using numeralsigns rather than words, however, with separate signs corresponding to each power. These signs are shown in Table 2.2 (cf. Gardiner 1927: 191; Allen 2000: 97).
Numerical Notation
36
Table 2.2. Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals 1
10
100
1000
10,000
100,000
1,000,000
R-L
q q
r r
s „
t …
u †
v\ į
w İ
Lex.
w̒
mḏ
št
ḫ
ḏb̒
ḥfn
ḥḥ
L-R
68,257 =
qqqq rrr „„\\\…………\\\\††† qqq\ \\rr\\\\\\\ \\\\\\\…………\\\\†††
The system is purely decimal and cumulative-additive, with each sign repeated up to nine times as necessary, and ordered from highest to lowest rank. The direction in which a numeral is read is always the same as the direction of writing, but varies depending on the inscription in question. The set of signs in the top row of Table 2.2 are those used when the direction of writing is from left to right; when right-to-left writing is used, the signs are mirrored (i.e., q\r\„\…\†\‡). Occasionally, when days of the month are being expressed, the signs for 1 and 10 were placed on their side: ‘ or ^ instead of r or q (Gardiner 1927: 191). Numeral-signs could be used either cardinally or ordinally, with ordinals from ‘second’ through ‘ninth’ adding the ending nw (masculine) or nwt (feminine) to the numeral-phrase, and those from ‘tenth’ upward adding m (masculine) or m t (feminine). To aid in reading long numeral-phrases, five or more identical signs were usually grouped in sets of three or four rather than placed on a single line. Thus, 5 is written as a row of three signs above a row of two signs, 6 as a row of three above a row of three, 7 as a row of four above a row of three, 8 as a row of four above a row of four, and 9 either as a row of five above a row of four or as three rows of three.2 The sign for 1 is a simple vertical stroke. Gunn (1916: 280) suggests that in early well-executed inscriptions, the sides of the vertical bar are curved inward slightly, thus making a biconcave bar, and postulates that it may represent “a small object of bone or wood used in some kind of tally or aid to reckoning,” but I tend to think that it is simply an abstract stroke. The sign for 10 has been described as a heel bone (Kavett and Kavett 1975: 390), a tie made by bending a leaf (McLeish 1991: 42), or even, anachronistically, as a croquet wicket (Boyer 1959: 127). In fact, it corresponds to the phonetic value m (masc. m w, fem. m t) ‘hook, handle’, 2
However, other groupings were sometimes used when it was more convenient for the scribe to do so.
Hieroglyphic Systems
37
and is a rebus for the Egyptian lexical numeral for 10 (m ) (Sethe 1916: 2). The higher power signs also have specific representational qualities and can also represent phonetic values in Egyptian apart from their use as numerical symbols. The sign for 100 ( t) is probably a coiled length of rope; that for 1000 ( ) is a lotus plant; the sign for 10,000 ( b ) is an extended finger; and that for 100,000 ( fn) is a tadpole. These numeral-signs, as well as the overall structure of the system, remained remarkably stable throughout its history. In some older instances in which the sign for 1000 occurs, rather than grouping the signs in clusters of three to five separated signs (as in the numeral-phrase mentioned earlier), multiple “lotus plants” were depicted as emerging from a single bush (e.g., 3000 = ‰). The sign for one million ( ) could also mean “multitude” or “a countless quantity,” just as the Greek word ‘myriad’ can mean a group of ten thousand or, more generally, a large quantity (Loprieno 1995). After the Early Dynastic period, this nonspecific lexical sense predominated over the specific numerical value. In most other respects, Predynastic hieroglyphic numerals would have been completely intelligible to Late Period scribes. The earliest known Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals are those from Tomb U-j at Abydos, which dates to around 3250-3200 bc (late Naqada II or early Naqada III period), and also contains the earliest examples of Egyptian writing (Dreyer 1998). Numeral-signs occur on many drilled bone and ivory tags found in this royal tomb, which were probably once attached to containers of goods. Other tags have other signs that resemble later Egyptian hieroglyphs, but only a very few contain both numerals and hieroglyphs (Baines 2004: 154–157). Some tags have six to twelve vertical or horizontal strokes, others the sign for 100, and one has both a sign for 100 and a sign for 1 (Dreyer 1998: 113–118). This system has three distinctive features as compared to the mature hieroglyphic system: it uses both horizontal and vertical strokes for units; there is no attested numeral-sign for 10; and there are tags with more than nine unit-strokes. Dreyer (1998: 140) explains the first two of these differences simultaneously by noting that on some Old Kingdom linen-lists, horizontal strokes stand for 10. The Tomb U-j tags are very similar to others found at Naqada and Abydos that date from the Naqada III and Early Dynastic periods, which contain the sign for 10 and use only vertical strokes for 1 (Dreyer 1998: 139). The very early date of the tags suggests that the system was developed independently of Mesopotamian influence, although the U-j tags are essentially contemporaneous with the Uruk IV tablets. The margin of error and discrepancies in the different radiocarbon dates from Tomb U-j are large enough that no definite conclusion regarding priority can be reached (Baines 2004: 154). Even though the U-j tags are apparently administrative or commercial, the context of the discovery (a royal tomb) suggests instead that the
38
Numerical Notation
Figure 2.1. A scene from The Narmer mace-head, a late Predynastic ceremonial artifact bearing early but recognizable Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals. At the far right, a quantity of 120,000 prisoners is indicated, while the lower register indicates quantities of 1,422,000 goats and 400,000 cattle. Source: Quibell 1900: Plate XXVI B.
signs were part of a nascent “visual high culture” of interest to elites seeking to legitimate their authority (Baines 2004: 170–171). While we have no evidence for numeral-signs higher than 100 from the Tomb U-j tags, by the Early Dynastic period the system was fully developed. Figure 2.1 depicts the Narmer mace-head found at Hierakonpolis, which may describe the unification of Upper and Lower Egypt by around 3100 bc, and which demonstrates that even the very highest signs were being used at that time (Arnett 1982: 42). The mace-head indicates an exaggerated tally of 400,000 oxen, 1,422,000 goats, and 120,000 humans (Quibell 1900: 8–9, Pl. XXVI). This is traditionally interpreted as an exaggerated and propagandistic tally of booty and prisoners acquired through Narmer’s military victories. Millet (1990), however, provides an alternate interpretation of the mace-head inscription as a year-identifier and suggests that the numbers are purely artificial, meant only to signify the taking of a census. Another early example of hieroglyphic numerals is found on the Second Dynasty statue of Khasekhem indicating the slaughter of 47,209 of the pharaoh’s enemies (Guitel 1958: 692). These large numerical values figure prominently in early hieroglyphic inscriptions, further supporting the idea that early Egyptian monumental writing was primarily oriented toward display purposes relating to the ideological justification of the kings’ authority (cf. Baines 2004). Other numerical inscriptions from the Early Dynastic include tags for commodities from Naqada like the
Hieroglyphic Systems
39
earlier ones found at Abydos, but using ordinarily structured hieroglyphic numerals (Imhausen 2007: 14). In the Old Kingdom (2575–2134 bc), variants on the basic hieroglyphs were not uncommon. Clagett (1989: 56–57) discusses a variant of the hieroglyphic numerals used on the Palermo Stone (a Fifth Dynasty / 2400 bc pharaonic annal), in which certain notations of the aroura measure of land are represented with unit-strokes in a quasi-positional manner. However, this system is not used regularly throughout the Palermo Stone and is not found in any other inscriptions; hence its value for understanding the hieroglyphic numerals is somewhat limited. Another unusual Old Kingdom system has been proposed by Posener-Kriéger (1977) to have been used in papyrus documents from Gebelein indicating area measures of fabric on so-called linen-lists (mentioned earlier). In this system, a single cubit sign meant one square cubit, horizontal strokes ten, and long vertical strokes meant one hundred – each of which were followed by short vertical strokes indicating how many of the requisite units were denoted. Both of these variant systems were employed solely for enumerating particular types of goods, and were never used more generally for denoting numbers. In the Ptolemaic era (332–30 bc), the hieroglyphic numerals became more complex. The sign for 1,000,000 was reintroduced into the numerical sequence, though it is unclear whether its numerical meaning was truly understood. In a few inscriptions from this period, a “ring” sign – ß – is found in the sequence between v and w. While Sethe (1916) believed that the ring sign was a meaningless addition, Gunn (1916: 280) protested that perhaps, in order to lengthen the series of numerals without assigning the god w a subordinate place, ß was assigned the value of 1,000,000, while w either shifted upward in value to ten million or else retained its lexical meaning of “an uncountable number.” Curiously, on the stela of Ptolemy Philadelphos (r. 282–246 bc) at Pithom, the sign used for 100,000 is not v but rather ˆ, with the ring sign placed underneath the ordinary tadpole sign (Sethe 1916: 9). Another curious change in the late hieroglyphic numerals is the occasional use of cryptographic ciphered numeral-signs for many numbers, as shown in Table 2.3. These signs replaced the standard cumulative sets of signs with single signs whose association with the number was homophonic, pictorial, religious, or related to the corresponding hieratic numeral-sign. They were used as early as 950 bc on a wooden votive cubit rod of Sheshonk I, but are found on no artifacts between that point and the Ptolemaic era (Priskin 2003). The most common of these signs is that for 5, a five-pointed star, which often combines with unit-strokes in the same way as V = 5 in Roman numerals (Sethe 1916: 25). However, unlike the Roman numerals and related systems, no signs were developed for 50, 500, or other half-powers. The origin of this sign is almost certainly pictorial, from the five
Numerical Notation
40
Table 2.3. Ptolemaic-era cryptographic hieroglyphic numerals 5 7 9 60 80
Q U Z A B
points of the star. Other common signs were a human head for 7, from the Egyptian understanding of the head as having seven orifices, and a scythe for 9, from the resemblance between that sign and the hieratic numeral-sign for 9 (Sethe 1916: 25). In addition to the signs for the units 1 through 9, there were cryptographic hieroglyphs for 60 and 80, both of which were derived from resemblances to hieratic numerals (Fairman 1963). These new signs never led to a fully ciphered-additive set of hieroglyphic numeral-signs, and were often included in otherwise perfectly ordinary cumulative numeral-phrases. Hieroglyphic numerals are largely written on monumental inscriptions, but not exclusively so. Texts including hieroglyphic numerals include seals, funerary stelae and tomb inscriptions, annals, lists relating to conquest and plundered goods, and certain administrative texts. An often-overlooked source of hieroglyphic numerals is the wide variety of stone balance-weights bearing inscriptions indicative of their weight (Petrie 1926, Petruso 1981). Numerals indicated dates, weights and measures, and a wide variety of quantities of goods, animals, and people. In all of these texts, the numerals are formed in the ordinary fashion just described. The hieroglyphic numerals were rarely if ever used for mathematics and calculation. The vast majority of Egyptian literary texts, and all Egyptian mathematical texts, are written in the hieratic or later demotic scripts (cf. Gillings 1978: 704–705). Nor are there hieroglyphic numerals marked on potsherds, tallies, or other such media that would suggest their use as an intermediate step in performing calculations. Some hieroglyphic numerals are used in an inscription from the tomb of Methen (Fourth Dynasty, twenty-sixth century bc), which indicates the calculation of the area of a rectangle, but this inscription indicates only that the calculation was done; the numerals were not actually used in the calculation process (Peet 1923: 9). Yet, because Egyptologists regularly transliterate documents in the hieratic script into regularized hieroglyphs, historians of mathematics have sometimes
Hieroglyphic Systems
41
inferred wrongly that the Egyptians calculated using hieroglyphic numerals. The hieroglyphic system is cumulative-additive, while the hieratic system is cipheredadditive, but since this difference in structure was underemphasized by Egyptologists of earlier generations (e.g., Gardiner 1927: 191; Peet 1931: 411), historians of mathematics frequently presume that the hieroglyphic numerals were the only ones available to Egyptian scribes (cf. McLeish 1991: 42; Guedj 1996: 34–35; Palter 1996: 228–229; Dehaene 1997: 97). It is to be hoped that the presence of new Egyptological literature may remedy this deficiency (Ritter 2002, Imhausen 2007). It is necessary to treat the hieroglyphic and hieratic systems separately, not despite their very strong historical connection, but because of that connection, inasmuch as the two systems were different in structure and used in entirely different functional contexts. A very few hieroglyphic inscriptions express large numbers (particularly multiples of 100,000) through multiplicative formations instead of purely additive ones. In one Ptolemaic-era text, the number 27,000,000 is expressed by placing a single sign for 100,000 above the ordinary additive hieroglyphic phrase for 270 (Brugsch 1968 [1883]: III, 604).3 The only other way to write 27,000,000 would have been to use 270 signs for 100,000 or 27 signs for 1,000,000, neither of which is an attractive option. Such phrases would be unappealing from the perspective of Egyptian aesthetic canons, in addition to the clear economy of symbols enjoyed through multiplicative phrases. In a second instance (from the time of Amenhotep III, around 1400 bc), 100,000 is expressed multiplicatively using the tadpole-sign v placed above a vertical stroke – 100,000 × 1 = 100,000 (Sethe 1916: 9; Loprieno, personal communication), thus, curiously, requiring more signs than the standard numeral-phrase. Finally, multiplicative hieroglyphs are found on a number of votive cubits from the New Kingdom and later, cubit-long polygonal stone objects inscribed with metrological and religious information, with clear multiplicative phrases for multiples of 100,000 and possibly also for 100 and 1000 (Ritter 2002: 308–309). Yet there is no evidence that this multiplicative-additive structure was widespread. The ciphered-additive hieratic numerals use multiplicative forms far more frequently, and earlier, than do the cumulative-additive hieroglyphs (Sethe 1916: 8–10; Möller 1936: I, 59). Yet because Egyptian grammars mention the hieratic examples (e.g. Gardiner 1927: 191; Allen 2000: 97) but transcribe the numerals as hieroglyphic numerals, it is easy to conclude that multiplicative expressions are common in the hieroglyphic numerals, when in fact almost all such expressions come from hieratic texts. 3
While Brugsch interprets this figure as 100,270, the figure being represented is the amount (in arouras) of land in Egypt, for which 27,000,000 is the only reasonable interpretation (cf. Kraus 2004: 225).
42
Numerical Notation
The question of when this borrowing took place remains open; the first hieratic documents to use this structure date to the Middle Kingdom (2040 to 1652 bc), while the first hieroglyphic example (mentioned earlier) dates to about 1400 bc. Because the hieratic multiplicative numeral-phrases are more common and earlier than the hieroglyphic, I think it likely that the ancestral system (hieroglyphic) borrowed the feature from its descendant (hieratic). Because hieroglyphic numerals were used only for monumental purposes at that time, numbers higher than 100,000 would have been expressed only infrequently. It is entirely possible, given the small number of hieroglyphic inscriptions using multiplication, that it was an exceptional response to the occasional requirement for expressing high numbers in hieroglyphic numerals. There is no evidence supporting Guitel’s assertion that this occasional use of multiplication, which is paralleled in certain Aztec texts (Chapter 9), represents even an abortive step toward a fully positional notation (Guitel 1958: 692–695; 1975: 44). Rather, it represents an alternative means of increasing the conciseness of some (but not all) numeral-phrases and extending a system’s capacity to write numbers while retaining its basic structure. The Egyptian hieroglyphic script possessed two distinct systems for representing fractional values, both of which normally expressed only unit-fractions – those in which the numerator is 1. The first such system, the standard system for expressing fractional quantities, simply required the scribe to place the sign r, which could also mean “part” or “mouth,” above any hieroglyphic numeral-phrase to indicate the corresponding unit-fraction (Loprieno 1986: 1307). If the mouth sign was too small to place over the entire phrase, it was simply placed over the signs for the highest power of 10. This system also used special symbols for some of the most commonly used fractions: 1/2 (gs), 1/4 (r-4), 2/3 (rwj), and 3/4 (hmt-rw) (Sethe 1916: Table II; Allen 2000: 101). The last two of these are not unit-fractions, and are thus exceptions to the general rule. This system was not used in the Predynastic era, but is found in abundance during the Old Kingdom and thereafter. While, in theory, this system could express any fraction, most have denominators smaller than 20. The second system was used primarily for measurements of volume of grain, fruit, and liquids by indicating fractions of the heqat (ḥḳ t), a measure probably equal to 292.24 cubic inches, or roughly 4.8 liters (Chace et al. 1929: 31). This notation is sometimes known as “Horus-eye fractions” because the six hieroglyphic symbols for fractional values can be combined to form the glyph of the wḏ t or eye of Horus (#), a symbol of health, fertility, and abundance. The sum of these signs is only 63/64; symbolically, the remaining 1/64 would be supplied magically by the god Thoth when he healed the Eye of Horus, thus producing unity (Gardiner 1927: 197). Ritter (2002) makes a persuasive case, however, that these signs were originally nonpictographic, hieratic submultiples of metrological units
Hieroglyphic Systems
43
Table 2.4. Egyptian hieroglyphic fractional ideograms 1/2
1/4
x
5
2/3
3/4
2
3
“Horus-eye fractions” 1/2
1/4
1/8
1/16
1/32
1/64
$
%
& *
(
)
rather than pure numerals, and that they were not originally associated with the Eye of Horus at all, and thus he renames them “capacity system submultiples.” Despite the early caution of Peet (1923), the “Horus-eye” interpretation has misleadingly become standard among historians of mathematics. The hieroglyphic forms of these signs are shown in Table 2.4, presuming a left-right direction of writing (Sethe 1916: Table II; Gardiner 1927: 197). This system’s binary structure was probably most useful for dividing and multiplying by two, a standard operation needed when manipulating volumes of goods. The system probably originated in an earlier hieratic series of fractional signs, of which the earliest example is from the Abusir Papyri of the Fifth Dynasty, and only later did the signs assimilate to resemble the parts of the Horus-eye symbol (Reineke 1992: 204). Other than one possible sign for 1/2 from the Fifth Dynasty, the earliest hieroglyphic Horus-eye fractions are from the Nineteenth Dynasty or later (Priskin 2002: 76; Ritter 2002: 304). The Egyptian hieroglyphic numerical notation system has several direct descendants, the most direct of which is the ciphered-additive Egyptian hieratic system (to be discussed later), which developed as early as the First Dynasty as a scribal shorthand for the hieroglyphs (Peet 1923: 11). Egyptian scribes would have learned both the hieroglyphic and hieratic numerals during their education, and used both systems in the appropriate contexts – the hieroglyphs on stone monuments, and the hieratic numerals written in ink on papyrus and ostraca (inscribed potsherds). It is also very likely that the civilizations of the Aegean used the Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals as the model for their own indigenous numerals – the Cretan hieroglyphic system, the Linear A and B numerals, and the Hittite-Luwian hieroglyphic numerals. There was considerable commercial and political interaction between Egypt and the Aegean in the second millennium bc, when the Aegean numerical notation systems began to emerge (Cline 1994). Despite the dissimilarity in the numeral-signs of the two systems, they are identically structured, and thus a hypothesis of diffusion is likely correct. A less direct descendant of the Egyptian hieroglyphs is the Phoenician-Aramaic system, which
44
Numerical Notation
was developed around 750 bc, blending the numeral-signs and script tradition of the Egyptian hieroglyphs with the structure of the Assyro-Babylonian cuneiform numerals (Chapter 7). This development marks the formation of the Levantine systems (Chapter 3), reflecting the intermediary position of the Levantine civilizations between the larger polities of the eastern Mediterranean. By the Greco-Roman period, the use of the hieroglyphic script and numerals had declined greatly, and both writing and numerals had increased in the number of signs used and the complexity thereof, to the point where it was considered to be a purely symbolic or cryptographic script by outsiders (Ritner 1996: 81). By the third century ad, Egypt was becoming increasingly Christian in its religion, and its language was being written in the Greek and Coptic scripts. The latest dated hieroglyphic inscription is on the temple of Isis at Philae, and dates from August 24, ad 394 (Griffith 1937: I, 126–127). By the fifth century, knowledge of how to read and write hieroglyphs had disappeared. The hieroglyphic numerals, as well as their immediate descendants, were replaced by the Coptic alphabetic numerals (Chapter 5).
Egyptian Hieratic The hieratic script was developed around 2600 bc by Egyptian scribes as a sort of cursive shorthand for the earlier hieroglyphic script (Loprieno 1995) and, like its forerunner, used a mixture of logographic and phonographic components. However, unlike the hieroglyphs, hieratic writing was designed for cursive writing on papyrus and on ostraca, making it suitable for administrative and literary purposes. Furthermore, while the hieroglyphs could be written in a variety of directions, hieratic texts are always linear and written from right to left. While the form of the hieroglyphs was very regular and formalized, hieratic writing varied greatly by period, location, and the idiosyncrasies of the scribe’s handwriting. The Old Kingdom divergence of Egyptian scripts into monumental (hieroglyphic) and cursive (hieratic and demotic) variants continued throughout the remainder of ancient Egyptian history. A base-10 ciphered-additive numerical notation system accompanied the hieratic script. The hieratic numeral-signs, like the script itself, changed considerably over the system’s extensive history. The paleographic development of hieratic numerals is traced in the charts provided by Möller (1936). In Tables 2.5, 2.6, and 2.7, I present three distinct sets of numerals, the first and earliest from the Kahun papyrus (Twelfth Dynasty / 2000–1800 bc), the second from Pap. Louvre 3226 (fifteenth century bc), and the third from the Harris papyri (twelfth century bc) (Möller 1936, vol 1: 59–63, vol. 2: 55–59). These three texts contain mostly complete sets of numeral-signs at least as high as 1000, and are thus very useful for
Hieroglyphic Systems
45
Table 2.5. Hieratic numerals (Kahun papyri, Twelfth Dynasty) 1
2
a b 10s j k 100s s t 1000s 1 2 10,000s : :: 100,000s > 4367 = gou4 1s
3
4
5
6
7
8
c l u 3 :::
d m v 4 =
e n w 5
f g h o p q x y z 6 8
9
i r 0 9
Table 2.6. Hieratic numerals (Pap. Louvre 3226, Eighteenth Dynasty) 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
A B C D E F G H I 10s J K L M N O P Q R 100s S T U V W X Y Z [ 1000s \ ] 657 = GNX 1s
Table 2.7. Hieratic numerals (Pap. Harris, Twentieth Dynasty) 1
2
a b 10s j k 100s s t 1000s | } 10,000s 8 9 100,000s , 56,207 = gt4; 1s
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
c l u 1 0
d m v 2 :
e n w 3 ;
f o x 4 <
g p y 5 =
h q z 6 >
i r { 7 ?
46
Numerical Notation
comparative purposes. The Harris papyri numerals, from Table 2.7, include all of the numbers up to 100,000; this is the only text to do so. Looking only at the signs for 5, 6, 7, and 9, the three series appear remarkably distinct. At the same time, however, most of the hieratic numeral-signs show remarkable continuity. Many of the hieratic signs used in the Old Kingdom would have been perfectly comprehensible to a scribe in the Late Period or even the Ptolemaic era. Many of the numeral-signs are very similar to others from the same period; for instance, it is very difficult to distinguish 400 from 600 or 3000 from 5000 in Table 2.7. When used to express days of the month, hieratic numerals, like hieroglyphic numerals, were often rotated ninety degrees counterclockwise to reflect their function. Given the nature of the Egyptian calendar, these forms exist only for numerals less than 30. To write fractional values, a small dot was placed above the numeral-phrase for an integer to indicate the appropriate unit fraction (1/x). The hieratic system is primarily ciphered-additive, and its signs each represent a multiple of a power of 10. Many of the hieratic numeral-signs bear a clear relationship to their cumulative-additive hieroglyphic forerunners, seen particularly in the signs for 1 through 4, 10, 10,000 through 40,000, and 100,000. Other hieratic numerals show no clear correspondence with their hieroglyphic ancestors except in very early periods. The ciphered-additive hieratic system thus shows traces of its cumulative-additive ancestry. For this reason, I include the hieratic system in this chapter even though it is structurally different from its hieroglyphic ancestor. In some hieratic texts, irregular numerical systems were used in conjunction with grain measures (Allen 2000: 102). One early Middle Kingdom system notated sacks of grain using regular numerals, and heqats (1/10 sack) using one to nine dots in a cumulative fashion. Later in the Middle Kingdom, a notation developed whereby ordinary numerals placed before a heqat unit indicated multiples of 100, those after the numeral multiples of 10, and then one to nine dots for the units. These systems were not used outside of this metrological context. As discussed earlier, hieratic fractions were frequently written in unit-fraction form or through capacity system submultiples (Ritter 2002). For writing many numbers above 10,000, multiplicative notation was used in the hieratic numerals; for instance, the sign for 60,000 is written by placing the sign for 6 below the sign for 10,000. This principle is not used for 10,000 through 30,000, but was used occasionally for 40,000, and normally for 50,000 through 90,000 and for values above 100,000. While the multiplicative principle is seemingly used for certain values of the hundreds and the thousands, paleographic analysis of the numeral-signs shows that the sign for 300 represents the abbreviation of the first two of three cumulative 100-signs and the extension of the third rather than the juxtaposition of 3 and 100. Imhausen (2006: 25–26) discusses an
Hieroglyphic Systems
47
Table 2.8. Evolution of cursive from linear Egyptian numerals
6
9
300
Hieroglyphic
Old Kingdom
Kahun papyrus (Dyn. 12)
P. Louvre 3226 (Dyn. 18)
P. Harris (Dyn. 20)
qqq qqq qqq qqq qqq
F
f
F
f
I
i
I
i
„„„
D
u
U
u
ostracon from the New Kingdom workers’ village of Deir el Medina, a scribal exercise in which 600,000, 700,000, 800,000, and five, six, and seven million are expressed multiplicatively using the hieratic signs for 100,000 and one million, respectively. The regular use of multiplicative-additive structuring allowed very high numbers above 100,000 to be expressed easily in hieratic numerals by placing the appropriate multiplier below the “tadpole” sign. The earliest multiplicative hieratic numerals are from the twentieth century bc Kahun papyrus fragments, which are arithmetical problems and accounting documents, suggesting that this technique originated in the context of mathematical or arithmetical practice (Griffith 1898: 16). The development of hieratic numerals was thus a highly creative process involving both the shift to ciphered notation and the use of multiplication where it was deemed useful. The strong similarities between the hieratic numerals and the earlier hieroglyphic numerals, coupled with the indisputable historical connections between the two scripts, prove the historical relationship of the two systems. Whereas the hieroglyphic numerals are found in Predynastic inscriptions, hieratic numerals first appear in the First Dynasty (Peet 1923: 11). Their use became widespread from the Old Kingdom onward, with the two systems (hieroglyphic and hieratic) being used for parallel purposes. The earliest hieratic numerals were little more than cumulative-additive cursive forms of the appropriate hieroglyphic numerals. Over time, the numerals became increasingly removed from their hieroglyphic ancestors as multiple strokes were condensed into single strokes, probably for greater ease of writing. By the Fifth Dynasty, the numerals written in the Abusir papyri (archives of royal funerary cults) had acquired a strongly cursive character that had moved away from the original cumulative signs (Goedicke 1988: xvi–xvii). Table 2.8
48
Numerical Notation
compares how the numbers 6, 9, and 300 were written in Old Kingdom hieratic to the numeral-signs from the three sets of numerals presented earlier. While ciphered signs were the ordinary ones, the system’s origins were not completely forgotten; cumulative hieratic numeral-signs were occasionally employed even into the New Kingdom. No single individual invented ciphered notation in Egypt; rather, its development was a process of abbreviating and combining cumulative signs by scribes over many centuries until, by the Late period, very few hieratic signs bore any resemblance to their hieroglyphic counterparts. It is even possible that the scribes making these changes were not really aware of the importance of the new structural principle they were using. Hence the origin of ciphered notation may, in some sense, have been accidental. Strikingly, in some hieratic documents from the Ptolemaic era, there is a reversion in the numeral-signs away from the ciphered signs used in older hieratic texts and back to the common use of the cumulative principle. In several texts (Leinwand, P. Bremner, Isis-N., Leiden J. 32, and P. Rhind),4 hieratic units were expressed with repeated vertical strokes, tens with horseshoe-shaped curves, and hundreds with coils, in an exact imitation of the hieroglyphic numeral-phrases of the same value (Möller 1936: vol. III, 59–60). While some of these documents retained the ciphered signs for some values, there is a trend over time toward the use of cumulative numeral-signs in these late hieratic documents. Some scribes may have forgotten the ciphered signs; more likely, however, the reversion to cumulative-additive numerals was a deliberate archaism, resulting from the desire to emulate hieroglyphs more exactly. Egyptian scribes would have learned both hieroglyphic and hieratic writing and numerals during their education, and used whichever was appropriate according to the context. Accordingly, while the functions of the hieratic numerals are quite distinct from those of the hieroglyphic numerals, the users of the two systems would have been the same individuals. For the hieratic numerals, two functions stand out above all others: administration and mathematics. Almost all extant Egyptian legal, commercial, educational, and literary texts from 2600 to 600 bc are written in hieratic, and numerals abound on such documents. While hieroglyphic numeral-phrases were very lengthy, requiring an enormous number of symbols to express many small values, hieratic numerals were highly concise, facilitating their use in accounting, commerce, and law, as well as for expressing dates and cardinal quantities. Because they would have been learned and used by only a small and well-educated segment of the populace (i.e., the scribes), their main disadvantage – the large number of signs one needed to learn in order to use the system – would not have been a serious problem. 4
P. Rhind does not refer here to the famous Rhind Mathematical Papyrus, but to a different text dating to 9 bc and having nothing to do with mathematics.
Hieroglyphic Systems
49
A limited but interesting set of hieratic texts directly concern mathematical subjects. The hieratic numerals were first used in Egypt for arithmetic and mathematics in the late Middle Kingdom and the early Second Intermediate Period (Twelfth and Thirteenth Dynasties). The well-known Reisner, Berlin, Kahun, and Moscow mathematical papyri all date from the nineteenth century bc (Gillings 1978: 704–705). Later, around 1650 bc, during the period of Hyksos domination, the Egyptian Mathematical Leather Roll and the famed Rhind Mathematical Papyrus were written using hieratic numerals, though the latter may be a copy of an earlier document. Egyptian mathematics was never perceived as a separate field of activity, but was thoroughly enmeshed and embodied within daily scribal practice, so to search for “pure” mathematics divorced from administrative activities is futile and ethnocentric (Imhausen 2003: 386). While the most thoroughly mathematical texts from ancient Egypt date from roughly 1900 to 1650 bc, these texts are but a minuscule fraction of the total number of hieratic texts containing numerals, and cannot represent the full scope of mathematical practice over four millennia of Egyptian history. A full discussion of the mathematics of ancient Egypt is well beyond the scope of this work (cf. Peet 1923; Neugebauer 1957; van der Waerden 1963; Gillings 1972, 1978; Rossi 2004; Imhausen 2003, 2006, 2007). Tracing the diffusion of the hieratic numerals is quite difficult. As the system was primarily used for administrative purposes, it spread wherever Egyptian domination extended – for instance, into Canaan in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Dynasties (Millard 1995: 189–190). The early Israelites used a minor variant of hieratic numerals (to be described later) starting in the tenth century bc. In addition, the hieratic numerals gave rise to two distinct descendant systems. By the eighth century bc, the hieratic of Upper Egypt (“abnormal hieratic”) was no longer mutually legible with that of Lower Egypt, which is now known as “demotic,” and which eventually replaced its ancestor. In addition, the Meroitic cursive script, found on ostraca in the Sudan starting in the third century bc, contains numeral-signs to which Griffith (1916: 23) assigns ancestry from the hieratic numerals. While the hieratic numerals have relatively few direct descendants, through their demotic descendant they are ancestral to a great number of systems. In the Twenty-sixth Dynasty (664 to 525 bc), the demotic script and numerals, which had only begun to diverge from hieratic a century or so earlier, were accorded royal preference for most purposes. After that point, demotic began to replace hieratic for more and more functions throughout Egypt. By the early Christian era, when hieratic was encountered by the Greeks, it was used only in religious texts – by which means it got its name, hieratikos ‘sacred’. The name that we now give to this script and numerical notation system is, ironically, taken from a purpose for which it was rarely used throughout over two millennia of its history. By around 200 ad, even these religious functions had ceased.
50
Numerical Notation
Hebrew Hieratic In the ninth century bc, the Egyptian scribal tradition, including the use of the hieratic script and numerals, was adopted by the ancient Israelites, who incorporated a great deal of Egyptian learning into their own thought (Millard 1995, Rollston 2006). Prior to this point, there is no evidence that the Israelites used any numerical notation whatsoever, although some may have become familiar with Egyptian notations while in Egypt. From around the ninth5 through the sixth centuries, Hebrew scribes combined their own (Paleo-Hebrew) script with a variant form of hieratic numerals, which I will call “Hebrew hieratic” for simplicity, although they differ only paleographically from ordinary Egyptian hieratic numerals (Kletter 1998: 142). The earliest Hebrew inscriptions containing hieratic numerals are the Samaria ostraca from the late ninth or early eighth century bc. The most notable and complete example of Hebrew hieratic numerals is a large (30 × 22 cm) ostracon, KBar6, excavated from Tell el-Qudeirat (Kadesh-barnea) in 1979, depicted in Figure 2.2, with the numerals transcribed in Table 2.9. The ostracon contains a very complete series of hieratic numerals; only the signs for the units 1 through 9 and 60 were missing, blurred, or unreadable (Lemaire and Vernus 1980; Cohen 1981: 105–107). It was probably a scribal exercise or practice text in writing numerals and measures (Dobbs-Allsopp et al. 2005: 251–260). The number 10,000 is expressed by combining the Egyptian hieratic sign for 10 with the lexical numeral ‘thousand’ in Paleo-Hebrew script, and there are also Hebrew units of measurement (heqat, shekel, gerah) on the ostracon, so it cannot have been written by an Egyptian scribe. The numeral-signs are paleographically very similar and structurally identical to the late hieratic ones, indicating that these numerals were directly borrowed under conditions of economic domination by and cultural contact with Egypt. Ostraca found at Arad and Lachish and mostly dating to the late seventh and early sixth centuries record weights and measures in letters and accounts, and served an administrative function (Levine 2004: 433).6 While Gandz (1933: 61) argued that the numerals from the Samaria ostraca had an Aramaic origin, the numeral-signs are in fact hieratic in origin (Lemaire 1977: 281). The Samaria ostraca signs for 5, 10, and 20 are , , and , respectively, which closely resemble the late hieratic e, j, and k, but not Aramaic aaa\aa, A, and B.
5
6
Shea’s claim (1978) that this system is attested on a Late Bronze Age jar handle from the thirteenth century bc has not been addressed by Semitic epigraphers, but both the paleographic interpretation and the date are questionable. Some of the Arad ostraca record quantities in a West Semitic (Aramaic-Phoenician) notation rather than in hieratic numerals (see Chapter 3).
Hieroglyphic Systems
51
Figure 2.2. The KBar6 ostracon from Kadesh-barnea, most likely the work of a student practicing writing numerals in Hebrew hieratic numerals. Source: Cohen 1981: 106. Reprinted with the permission of the American Schools of Oriental Research.
The Hebrew hieratic numerals were also used on Judaean inscribed limestone weights, a metrological system that reflected the growing commercial importance of Judah within the context of Near Eastern commerce between the late eighth and early sixth centuries bc. Kletter’s (1998) study of 434 of these Judaean weights represents the most thorough examination of these artifacts to date. Although it was once argued that these notations were cumulative-additive and indigenous in origin (Allrik 1954, Yadin 1961), apart from the paleographic variability one would expect when transferring a cursive notation onto stone, they are clearly hieratic, Table 2.9. Hebrew hieratic numerals from KBar6 ostracon from Kadesh-barnea 1 10s 100s 1000s
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
52
Numerical Notation
ciphered-additive numerals like those on the ostraca (Aharoni 1966). The numerals on these weights range from 1 to 50 to indicate multiples of the shekel (approx. 11.3 grams), but curiously, other than the 1- and 2-shekel weights, the numerals are in a 5:4 ratio to the expected masses of the weights. This puzzle has been the source of considerable recent debate among metrologists and remains incompletely resolved, but in any case the numerical interpretations of the signs are paleographically secure (Ronen 1996, Kletter 1998). The ostraca and shekel weights are of a relatively early date in the history of Hebrew writing, and must be understood in the context of growing administrative needs in the Iron Age states of the Levant. This period marks the first in which literacy was relatively widespread in Judah (Kletter 1998: 144). Rollston (2006) rightly sees the presence of hieratic numerals and artifacts such as KBar6 as positive (if not conclusive) evidence for the introduction of formal schooling in late Iron Age Israel. After Judah lost its independence in 586 bc, the system appears to have become obsolescent. The Hebrew hieratic numerals are not directly ancestral to the cumulative-additive Levantine systems that emerged in the eighth century bc, among Phoenicians and Aramaeans. These systems were used contemporaneously with the hieratic numerals and, for instance, occur in the same contexts on ostraca from Arad. There is no evidence of an indigenous Hebrew numerical notation system until about 125 bc, when the use of the familiar alphabetic numerals (Chapter 5) began.
Meroitic The kingdom of Meroë, which flourished from roughly 300 bc to 350 ad, made use of two distinct scripts. The first, Meroitic hieroglyphs, were based on Egyptian hieroglyphs and were used on some stone monuments. The attested Meroitic hieroglyphic inscriptions contain no numerals. The other script, the Meroitic cursive, was written from right to left on ostraca as well as on stone, and was accompanied by a set of numerals. Almost all of our information on the Meroitic numerals rests on the work of F. Ll. Griffith, the original decipherer of the Meroitic scripts. Unfortunately, because the Meroitic language has no known relatives, we are largely unable to read Meroitic inscriptions, even though the values for the signs of the cursive script are more or less fully deciphered. Griffith (1916: 22) first presented the interpretation of the Meroitic numeral-signs shown in Table 2.10. On structural and paleographic grounds, the values for the units, 10, and all of the hundreds are unquestionable, and the remainder of the numeral-signs are fairly certain. This system is ciphered-additive and decimal, and written from right to left (like the Meroitic cursive script). The number 2348 as shown in Table 2.10 appears on the stela of Akinidad, which dates to the late first century bc (Griffith 1916: 22).
Hieroglyphic Systems
53
Table 2.10. Meroitic numerals 1
2
a b 10s j k 100s s t 1000s A B 2348 = hmuB
1s
3
4
5
6
7
c d e f g l m n p u v w x C
8
9
h
i
z
As with the hieratic numerals, the signs for the units, low hundreds, and possibly 1000 through 3000 are somewhat cumulative. There is only one case (again, from the Akinidad stela) where a number greater than 10,000 is expressed; interestingly, where hieratic uses a single sign for 10,000 (8), Meroitic appears to use a multiplicative formation (10 × 1000). However, this evidence is far too limited to conclude that the Meroites regularly used multiplicative-additive structuring to express higher powers. In addition, cumulative sets of one to nine dots apparently indicated tenths from 1/10 to 9/10, while a dot in a semicircle (0) represented 1/20 (Griffith 1916, 1925). Griffith (1916: 22–23) believed this system to be purely metrological, representing tenths and twentieths of some larger unit of measure rather than abstract numbers. By the time of the development of the Meroitic scripts, the hieratic script and numerical notation system had largely been replaced by demotic throughout Egypt. Nevertheless, on paleographic grounds (citing especially the signs for 6, 10, and 20, but also the cumulative unit-signs), Griffith (1916: 23) argued that the Meroitic numerals resemble the late hieratic numerals (eighth to third centuries bc) more closely than the demotic forms, even though the characters of the Meroitic cursive script are almost certainly derived from a demotic rather than a hieratic prototype (Millet 1996: 85). More paleographic analysis is desirable to settle this question. The Meroitic numerals were used for administrative purposes such as tax records and mensuration, as well as in funerary and monumental contexts indicating yeardates and quantities of individuals. Griffith suggests that something akin to the Egyptian heqat or artaba measures, used to indicate volumes of produce such as corn or dates, was probably indicated on some ostraca (1916: 23). There is no evidence that the Meroitic numerals were ever used for arithmetic or mathematics. Even on ostraca upon which multiple numerals have been written, Griffith was unable, except in one instance, to establish any arithmetical correspondence
54
Numerical Notation
between the numerals that would indicate that a tally or sum had been taken (1916: 24). The Meroitic numerals were used until the fourth century ad, but did not outlast the kingdom of Meroë. Millet (1996: 84) suggests that the script may have continued in use until the introduction of Coptic Christianity in the sixth century, but there is no textual evidence to establish whether the Meroitic numerical notation system existed during this late period. The Coptic and Ethiopic numerals, both of which are derived from the Greek alphabetic numerals, were used widely in the region from the sixth century onward.
Egyptian Demotic The demotic script developed in the late eighth century bc (Twenty-fifth Dynasty) and began to replace the hieratic script about a century later. It was a cursive script consisting largely of consonantal characters, derived from the “business hand” hieratic used in the Nile Delta (Ritner 1996: 82). During the Late period and the Ptolemaic era, demotic writing was used very widely for administrative and literary purposes, and more sporadically throughout the Roman period. A set of ciphered-additive, base-10 numerals accompanied this script throughout its history. As with the hieratic numerals, there is a great deal of variation in the demotic numeral-signs; the ones presented in Table 2.11 (after Sethe 1916: Table I) are typical of those found in papyri of the Late and Ptolemaic periods. Griffith (1909: 415–417) provides an interesting paleographic comparison of the demotic numeral-signs found on a selection of papyri dating from the Twenty-sixth dynasty to the Roman period. The demotic numerals are a base-10, ciphered-additive system, written from right to left. They are less reliant on the cumulative principle than their hieratic ancestor (compare hieratic c and demotic C for 3). Some of the signs for the thousands may be vaguely multiplicative, as there is a general resemblance between the signs for the hundreds and the corresponding signs for the thousands, but it is more likely that they are simply further reductions of the nonmultiplicative hieratic signs. Sethe (1916: Table I) suggests that additive phrases incorporating two lower signs (3000 + 2000, 4000 + 3000) were used for the missing 5000 and 7000 signs. Above 10,000, the demotic numerals, like the hieratic ones, are multiplicative (though such large expressions are fairly rare); for instance, Parker has found multiplicative expressions for 90,000 (7, = 9 × 10,000) and 100,000 (8, = 10 × 10,000) in his study of demotic mathematical papyri (Parker 1972: 86). As in the hieratic numerals, a small dot placed above a numeral-sign indicated the corresponding (1/x) unit fraction. The demotic numerals are directly derived from the hieratic forms used in the eighth century bc; as the hieratic numerals were used as late as 200 ad, the two
Hieroglyphic Systems
55
Table 2.11. Demotic numerals 1
2
3
A B C 10s J K L 100s S T U 1000s @ # $ 6268 = HOT&
1s
4
5
D E M N V W %
6
7
8
9
F G H I O p Q R X Y Z ! & * (
systems were used side by side in Egypt for nearly a millennium. This long coexistence can be explained in part by regional variations, with Upper Egypt retaining the “abnormal” hieratic numerals and Lower Egypt using demotic. Unlike the corresponding writing systems, the hieratic and demotic numerals would have been largely mutually intelligible until the Ptolemaic period at least, which may have facilitated communication between different parts of Egypt. The demotic script and numerals were accorded royal preference in the Twenty-sixth Dynasty, and thus they were used for most royal functions thereafter, while the hieratic system was retained primarily for calligraphic religious texts (Ritner 1996: 81–82). Unlike the hieratic script and numerals, which were rarely written on stone except at the very end of their history, demotic inscriptions are found on stone as well as ceramics and papyrus. Like their predecessor, demotic numerals were used for a wide variety of commercial, legal, and other administrative functions, as well as for indicating dates. A number of demotic mathematical papyri have survived from the Ptolemaic period, confirming the suitability of the system for arithmetical and mathematical purposes (Parker 1972, Gillings 1978). However, as with the hieratic numerals, most demotic texts that contain numerals serve no mathematical function. Much of our paleographical knowledge of the demotic numerals comes from administrative texts, such as dowry records and educational papyri (Griffith 1909). An extensive set of demotic numerals is found in P. Tsenhor, the private archive of a sixth-century woman (Pestman 1994). The importance of the demotic numerical notation system lies not in any structural feature or unusual function, but rather in its historical role as the immediate ancestor of several other numerical notation systems. The demotic numerals are almost certainly ancestral to the Greek alphabetic numerals (Chapter 5). These numerals, which are structurally identical to the demotic numerals, first appear in the sixth century bc in Ionia and Caria, at which time Greek trade with Egypt was beginning in earnest, and when the Ionian trading city of Naukratis in the
56
Numerical Notation
Nile Delta was the major center for trade between Egypt and Greece (Chrisomalis 2003). Furthermore, the alphabetic numerals became common in the late fourth century bc, at which time Egypt came under Ptolemaic control. Remarkably, the similarities between the demotic and Greek alphabetic numerals have been substantially ignored over the past century, with most scholars inclined to treat the latter system as a case of independent invention (but cf. Boyer 1944: 159). Secondly, there are strong similarities between the demotic numerals and the Brāhmī numerals (Chapter 6), which began to be used in India around 300 bc. In this case, the historical connection between the two regions is not as clear, but the structural similarities between the two systems suggest some connection. While trade between Egypt and India became common only in the Roman period, there are strong indications of overseas trade dating from the Ptolemaic period and perhaps even somewhat earlier. Again, few historians of mathematics have proposed this connection, although it has held some popularity among Indologists for over a century (Bühler 1896, Salomon 1998). By the Roman period (30 bc–ad 364), the demotic numerals were used increasingly rarely, as the general decline of Egyptian cultural institutions continued apace. However, even though Roman imperialism was the immediate circumstance surrounding the decline of the demotic numerals, they were not replaced with Roman numerals, but rather with the Coptic numerals, which were themselves descended from the demotic through the Greek alphabetic numerals. As Christianity began to take hold in Egypt, and the Coptic script and numerals became more widespread, demotic suffered a fatal decline. The last text with demotic numerals is a graffito on the temple of Isis at Philae (the same temple that contains the last evidence for hieroglyphs), which dates to December 2, ad 452 (Griffith 1937: I, 102–103). The last known demotic text of any sort (dated in Greek) was written nine days later.
Linear A (Minoan) The Linear A script was the standard script used in the Minoan civilization of Crete between 1800 and 1450 bc (Bennett 1996: 132). It is perhaps the most famous of all undeciphered scripts, having foiled decades of effort to interpret it. Only the numerals and a few other ideograms for commodities can be deciphered. Linear A is written from left to right and is almost certainly a mixture of syllabograms and logograms. Its well-attested numeral-signs are shown in Table 2.12 (Sarton 1936b: 378; Ventris and Chadwick 1973: 36). The Linear A numerical notation system is decimal and cumulative-additive, and is written from left to right with the powers in descending order. Where appropriate, signs are grouped in two rows of up to five signs each rather than placing them in an uninterrupted row. The variant dot symbol for 10 is found only in
Hieroglyphic Systems
57
Table 2.12. Linear A numerals 1
Å
10
100
É\ • æ 7659 = ÆÆÆÆ æææ ÆÆÆ æææ
1000
Æ ÉÉÉ ÉÉ
qqqqq qqqq
early Linear A documents and is probably related to the identical numeral-sign for 10 in the contemporaneous Cretan hieroglyphs (see the following discussion). Other than this, however, the system remained unchanged throughout its history. While Evans (1935: 693) suggested that there may have been a sign R or ¹ that stood for zero, this was later shown to be a sort of check-mark or sign for completion of an item, or perhaps served some other bookkeeping function (Bennett 1950: 205). Using statistical methods, Daniel Was (1971) has postulated the existence of a complex base-24 system for representing fractions in Linear A. If correctly deciphered, this system is likely to have been metrological in function. While Struik (1982: 56) suggests that this system is related to the Egyptian unitfractions, no real resemblances exist between the two fractional systems. The Linear A script and numerals were probably borrowed in some manner from the identically structured Egyptian hieroglyphic system (cf. Sarton 1936b: 378). Trade between Egypt and Crete was extensive in the Middle Minoan II period (ca. 1800–1700 bc), when Linear A developed (Cline 1994). Admittedly, there is no real similarity between the numeral-signs of the two scripts, except in the use of vertical strokes for the units, which is common to almost all systems used in the Mediterranean region. Whereas Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals are pictorial representations with phonetic values mostly originating as homonyms of lexical numerals, Linear A numerals are abstract and simplified. However, we would not expect the Minoans to adopt the Egyptian signs, because the signs would have no such phonetic associations for them. I am unconvinced by the isolationist position with regard to Minoan literacy (e.g., Dow and Chadwick 1971: 3–5). The link suggested between Linear A and the Proto-Elamite numerals (Chapter 7) of fourth millennium bc Iran, however, requires implausibly great chronological and geographical gaps (Brice 1963). Egypt is the only plausible ancestral region for the Minoan numerals. The abstract and geometric character of the numeral-signs makes it impossible, however, to exclude an independent origin for the system. Branigan (1969) speculates that concentric circles on sealings from Phaistos may have represented tens, hundreds, and thousands, and may be a geometric precursor to the Linear A
58
Numerical Notation
numerals. A similar system of small circles and large circles inscribed on cylindrical stone weights from the palace at Knossos may have indicated one and ten units of some metrological value (Evans 1906). While either of these systems could be related to Linear A, at present the hypothesis of borrowing from Egypt best explains the structure of Linear A numerals, with the numeral-signs developed indigenously. Numeral-signs are the only known means of representing numbers in Linear A; although it remains possible that lexical numerals were written using syllabic signs, the closely related (and deciphered) Linear B script does not do so, suggesting that this is unlikely. The vast majority of Linear A documents are clay tablets having an accounting or bookkeeping function, and thus we have many examples of the use of numerals. Vertical strokes that probably represented numbers have been found in other contexts – for example, on Minoan balance weights; these marks, however, do not show any clear relation to the Linear A signs found on the clay tablets and are probably simply unstructured unit-marks or tallies (Petruso 1978). What are likely Linear A numerals occur on a number of pieces of pottery from Bronze Age Cyprus (Grace 1940). Stieglitz proposes that a numerical graffito found at Hagia Triada and containing the sequence of numbers (1, 1 1/2, 2 1/4, 3 3/8), in which each number is 1.5 times the previous one, represents a series of musical notes or tunings for a stringed instrument (Stieglitz 1978). I think it equally likely that the series served an economic function such as calculating interest. Since we do not have significant literary or monumental texts in Linear A, we do not know if the numerals were ever used in other contexts. While the Cretan hieroglyphic numerals were formerly thought to be ancestral to Linear A, it now appears that Linear A predates the Cretan hieroglyphs, perhaps by as much as a century. The exact historical relationship between the two numerical notation systems is unclear, but I believe it most likely that the Cretan hieroglyphic numerals were a local variant of the Linear A system. The Linear B Mycenean script used on Crete and the Greek mainland definitely derived from Linear A. Its numerals (to be discussed later) are nearly identical to those of Linear A. The precise relation between the peoples using the Linear A and B scripts is still unclear, as is the question of the cause of the collapse of the Minoan civilization in the fifteenth century bc. Presumably, during this period, the Greek-speaking Myceneans adapted Linear A for their own language, resulting in Linear B. The two scripts coexisted in Crete from about 1550 to 1450 bc, after which time Linear B replaced Linear A completely.
Cretan Hieroglyphic The Cretan Hieroglyphic or Pictographic script was first identified by Sir Arthur Evans (1909) based on his work at Knossos. While it was once considered ancestral to the other Aegean scripts, it probably developed about the same time as, or
Hieroglyphic Systems
59
Table 2.13. Cretan hieroglyphic numerals 1
10
100
1000
ù\\=
• 0 ÿ 8357 = ÿÿÿÿ\000\•••••\\==== ÿÿÿÿ === slightly later than, the Linear A script. Its use is generally thought to have lasted from 1750 to 1600 bc (Bennett 1996: 132). It is found on around 300 attested seal-stones and clay documents (Olivier et al. 1996). While the script is still undeciphered, it is probably of a mixed syllabic and logographic structure, like other Aegean scripts. Among the few Cretan hieroglyphic signs that can be interpreted securely are the numerals, which are shown in Table 2.13 (Evans 1909: 258; Sarton 1936b: 378; Ventris and Chadwick 1973: 30–31). The system is cumulative-additive and decimal, and most often written from left to right, although right-to-left numeral-phrases are also attested. Groups of multiple repeated signs were sometimes organized using two rows, one above the other, each with no more than five signs, but this rule was not strictly applied, and in other cases the organization of signs was more haphazard. Figure 2.3 depicts a Cretan clay rectangular bar on which numerals are written on three of the four long sides plus the base (Evans 1909: 177). While the number 483 is written at the bottom of side (b) according to this principle, for instance, many of the other numerals are oriented irregularly, grouping signs in clusters of six or more. Evans (1909: 257) assigns the uncommon sign P the value 1/4 because it is repeated not more than three times at the end of a few numeral-phrases, while Dow and Chadwick (1971: 12) suggest a quite different fractional system with signs for 1/2, 1/4, and 1/8. Since the Cretan hieroglyphs are largely undeciphered, it is difficult to speculate on the history of their numerals. As with other Aegean scripts, an Egyptian origin for the system has been proposed (Sarton 1936: 378), though this cannot be demonstrated conclusively. There is limited similarity between the numeral-signs for the Cretan hieroglyphs and any other system, except that the use of the dot for 10 is common to some early Linear A inscriptions. Dow and Chadwick (1971: 14) suggest that the differences between the Cretan hieroglyphs and Linear A are attributable to the fact that the former were designed for chiseled inscriptions while the latter were intended to be written with ink. The Cretan hieroglyphic numerals are probably a local variation of the Linear A numerals or, less plausibly, a direct borrowing from the Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals. The contexts in which the
60
Figure 2.3. Cretan hieroglyphic inscriptions on a clay bar containing numerals. For instance, at the bottom of face b, the numeral 483 is represented with four diagonal strokes, eight dots, and three curved strokes. Source: Evans 1909: 177.
Hieroglyphic Systems
61
numerals are found are similar to those for Linear A. The Cretan hieroglyphic inscriptions include information on commodities such as wheat, oil, and olives and thus are probably records of transactions, inventories of goods, and similar administrative documents (Ventris and Chadwick 1973: 31). By around 1600 bc, Cretan hieroglyphs had been entirely replaced by Linear A.
Linear B (Mycenean) The Linear B script was used on Crete and the Greek mainland in the middle to late second millennium bc to write an archaic Greek dialect on clay administrative tablets. It is written from left to right, and consists of a syllabary with a large repertory of logograms and taxograms (classifiers), including a numerical notation system. The Linear B numerals are shown in Table 2.14. The Linear B signs are mostly identical with the Linear A signs, except that the sign for 10 is always a horizontal stroke (never a dot), and there is a sign for 10,000 that is not found in the earlier system. The 10,000 sign is probably a multiplicative combination of the signs for 10 and 1000. The structure of the system is cumulative-additive and decimal, with the highest powers on the left, written in descending order and with five or more identical signs divided into two rows. Unlike the Linear A numerals, Linear B lacks a separate system for expressing fractions; instead, specific logograms express divisions of metrological units and then combine with numeral-signs as appropriate (just as one might say 10 cm instead of 0.1 m). Ventris and Chadwick (1973: 54–55) note that some of the Mycenean logograms for metrological units resemble the Minoan signs for fractions, and may have originally indicated specific ratios of two types of units, which further shows the indebtedness of Linear B to its Minoan forerunner. The Linear B system definitely originated through direct contact with the Minoan civilization and the Linear A numerals. The earliest Linear B inscriptions date from the sixteenth century bc, so the two scripts coexisted on Crete for about a century. Their numerical notation systems are so similar that some authors do not distinguish between the two (Ventris and Chadwick 1973: 53; Struik 1982). The distinction between the two is not nearly as great as between the two scripts, which record different languages. Throughout the history of the Linear B numerical notation, there is no observable change in the form of the numeral-signs or in the structure of the system. Linear B numerals are found almost solely on clay tablets serving accounting and financial purposes (Olivier 1986: 384–386). Numerals are used both for counting discrete objects (men, chariots, etc.) and for measures of dry and liquid volume and weight. Almost all Linear B documents relate to administrative and bookkeeping functions, suggesting a very limited level of literacy and numeracy
Numerical Notation
62
Table 2.14. Linear B numerals 1
10
100
1000
10,000
Å
É æ Æ ô 68,357 = ôôô\ÆÆÆÆ\æææ\ÉÉÉ ÅÅÅÅ ôôô\ÆÆÆÆ\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ÉÉ \\\\ÅÅÅ throughout Mycenean society. Even so, the consistency of the numerals throughout several centuries and across a substantial geographic area suggests that some sort of scribal education system was in place to transmit knowledge of both the Linear B script and its numerals. We do not know if Linear B numerals were written on papyrus or other materials, though such uses are certainly possible. We also do not know whether the Myceneans used their numerals for arithmetical purposes. Anderson’s (1958) theory on the means by which such calculations could be undertaken suffers from the defect that it involves aligning and manipulating numbers as one would in Western arithmetic, although there is no evidence that such a procedure was ever undertaken. Dow (1958: 32) and Anderson (1958: 368) both point to a clay tablet found at Pylos (designated Eq03) in which tallying in groups of five units is used to reach 137. Other tablets from Pylos discussed by Ventris and Chadwick (1973: 118–119) show that the Myceneans could successfully compute complex ratios in order to determine the contributions of goods required from towns of different sizes. Rather than proving that the Myceneans used numerical notation for arithmetic, however, these examples indicate that tallying by units and in groups of five, rather than the purely decimal-structured numerical notation, was the method used for computation. None of this denies that clay tablets recorded the results of rather complex computations done mentally, through tallying, or perhaps by some other method. There is no relationship between the Mycenean numerals and either of the later Greek numerical notation systems (the acrophonic and alphabetic systems). It is conceivable, however, that there is some relationship between the Mycenean and Etruscan numerals (Chapter 4). Both Haarmann (1996) and Keyser (1988) have raised this claim, which will be discussed in detail when considering the origins of the Etruscan system. Mycenean settlements have been found in Sicily and southern Italy, providing one possible locus for cultural contact. However, this theory is controversial, not least because of the time elapsed between the latest known Linear B documents (twelfth century bc) and the first Etruscan ones (seventh century bc). A more likely descendant of Linear B numerical notation is the Hittite hieroglyphic system, which was invented around 1400 bc and used by Hittite and
Hieroglyphic Systems
63
Luwian speakers in Anatolia. The Hittite signs for 1 and 10 are identical to the Linear B ones, and at the time when the Hittite numerals were developed, there were Mycenean settlements in western Anatolia (such as at Miletus) and on Cyprus that were engaged in trade throughout the eastern Mediterranean. The contemporaneity of the two systems makes this scenario plausible, if not proven. The perplexing and apparently violent end of the Mycenean civilization in the twelfth century bc, and the repeated razing of major sites such as Mycenae and Pylos, marks the end of the Linear B inscriptions and the start of the “Dark Age” of Greek civilization. No writing or numerical notation of any kind is attested from the Aegean region between 1100 bc and the introduction of the Greek alphabet a few centuries later.
Hittite Hieroglyphic The Hittites lived in central Asia Minor from about the end of the third millennium bc. The Hittite and closely related Luwian languages are the first Indo-European languages for which we have solid textual evidence. By the middle of the second millennium bc, two distinct scripts were in use in the Hittite Empire. Firstly, a cuneiform script (borrowed from Mesopotamia) was used to write the Hittite language. Its numerals are closely related to the Assyro-Babylonian cuneiform system, and so will be treated in Chapter 7. Additionally, an indigenous hieroglyphic script was used to represent the Luwian language on monumental inscriptions, on a few lead tablets, and probably also on wooden tablets that have not survived (Melchert 1996: 120). This script was used from about 1500 to 1200 bc, during the apogee of the classical Hittite Empire, and then is found only sporadically until the rise of the Neo-Hittite kingdoms between around 1000 and 700 bc, during which time it was again common (Hawkins 1986: 368). This script is known as Hieroglyphic Hittite or Hieroglyphic Luwian, and has a mixed syllabic and logographic structure. Among the purely ideographic signs, the Hittites used a set of written numerals as shown in Table 2.15 (cf. Laroche 1960: 380–400). The system is purely cumulative-additive and uses a base of 10. Numeral-phrases were written from left to right, right to left, or top to bottom, depending on the overall direction of the inscription. As in the Egyptian and Aegean systems, Hittite numeral-signs were sometimes but not always grouped in clusters of three to five unit-signs. Laroche (1960: 395) indicates that 9 was variously written using three rows of three strokes, a row of five above a row of four, or simply with nine strokes in sequence on a single line. The Hittite hieroglyphic numerals were most likely based on one of the Aegean numerical notation systems. Both the Linear A and Linear B scripts were in use around 1500 bc, when the first Hittite hieroglyphic inscriptions are found, but
Numerical Notation
64 Table 2.15. Hittite numerals 1
10
100
1000
q
^ ( ) 3635 = )))((((((*qqqqq Linear A was almost extinct by that time. Like the hieroglyphs, the three Aegean scripts use a combination of syllabograms and logograms. The Linear A, Linear B, and Hittite hieroglyphic numerical notation systems are all decimal and cumulative-additive, and use a horizontal stroke for the units and a vertical stroke for the tens. There was a significant degree of intercultural contact between the Aegean and Asia Minor during this period. The Myceneans had settlements in western Anatolia and traded throughout the eastern Mediterranean, and were possibly the “Ahhijawa” (Achaeans) mentioned in the Hittite archive from Bogazkoy. Because the Luwian language was spoken primarily in western Asia Minor and only later was used in the Hittite Empire, the transmission of the numerals from the Aegean to western and then central Anatolia is plausible (Hawkins 1986: 374). An alternate hypothesis is that the Hittite system was based directly on the Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals, since the Hittites were in contact with Egypt at that time. Due to the paucity of extant examples, little can be said about the function and use of the system. The numerals are found on a variety of stone inscriptions and lead tablets. Most notable among these are the Kululu lead strips (mid to late eighth century bc), which record village census data using an abundance of numerical signs (Hawkins 2000: 503–505). The Hittite numerical notation is used far more frequently than lexical numerals, which is also true of the Egyptian hieroglyphs and Aegean scripts. There is no discernable change in the structure or sign-forms of the system throughout its history, even though there is little evidence for its use between 1200 and 1000 bc, following the invasion of Phrygians and others who ended the classical Hittite kingdom. During these two centuries, the hieroglyphs were likely used only on perishable materials, such as wooden tablets (Hawkins 1986: 374). A few inscriptions on clay jars found at the Urartian site of Altintepe (in eastern Asia Minor) use a syllabary closely related to the Hittite hieroglyphs to write single words in the Urartian language, starting in the early eighth century bc (Laroche 1971, Klein 1974). Many of these inscriptions contain numeral-signs for small numbers using either “pitted” dots or vertical strokes to represent units (i.e., 5 = 554 or 11111), but never to express numbers larger than eight, making this system an unstructured tally system having no base. Klein (1974: 93) accurately states that this usage “should thus be viewed as an isolated and short-lived
Hieroglyphic Systems
65
phenomenon, possibly not outlasting the career of a single (foreign?) scribe.” The numerals that accompany the Cypriote syllabary, which was invented around 800 bc, are also potentially derived from the Hittite hieroglyphic numerals. The proximity of the Neo-Hittite kingdoms to Cyprus, the extensive trade relations between the regions, and the identical structure of the two systems all suggest that such a derivation is likely. However, there are too few Cypriote syllabic inscriptions containing numerals to establish an accurate chronology or even to secure values for certain numeral-signs. Less plausible descendants of the Hittite hieroglyphic system are the earliest Levantine systems, Phoenician and Aramaic (Chapter 3). However, these systems developed around 750 bc, at the very end of the Hittite system’s history, and are structurally distinct from it, since they have a sign for 20 and are multiplicative-additive above 100. The subjugation of the Neo-Hittite kingdoms under the Assyrian empire ended the use of Hittite hieroglyphic numerals around 700 bc, and the system was replaced for all functions by the Assyro-Babylonian common numerals. Later numerical notation systems developed for related peoples of Asia Minor, such as the Lycians, were based on a Greek model and display no obvious relation to the Hittite hieroglyphs.
Cypriote Syllabary As its name suggests, the Cypriote syllabary was a syllabic script used only on the island of Cyprus. It was used between about 800 and 200 bc for writing the Greek language, and thus coexisted with the much more prominent and long-lasting Greek alphabetic script (Bennett 1996: 130). Cypriote is always written from right to left. None of the synthetic works concerning numerical notation have dealt with the (admittedly small) evidence for a distinct Cypriote numerical notation system. However, Masson (1983: 80), whose discussion of the Cypriote syllabary is the most detailed currently available, presents about a dozen inscriptions in which the system shown in Table 2.16 was used. This rudimentary system was decimal and cumulative-additive and, like the syllabary itself, was written from right to left. The numbers expressed using the system are very small; unless certain undeciphered signs are in fact numeral-signs (as discussed later), the largest number expressed in any Cypriote inscription is 22. This system parallels the Aegean Linear systems from which the Cypriote numerals are probably derived. This is strongly suggested by the use of the Cypro-Minoan script, which was very probably borrowed from Linear A, on Cyprus as early as 1500 bc. However, eastern Cyprus was under Phoenician domination well into the period of the use of the syllabary, and the Phoenician numerical notation system is also written from right to left, and uses vertical strokes for units and horizontal
Numerical Notation
66
Table 2.16. Cypriote numerals 1
10
q
^
strokes for tens. Furthermore, Masson (1983: 80) notes the use of two unusual symbols: æ, found in but a single inscription but possibly indicating 100 on the model of the Aegean systems, and Ö, also in only a single document, but possibly signifying 20. It is notable that the Phoenician system used @\and D at various times as the sign for 20. Because Cypriote inscriptions do not contain dates, it is often difficult to place them in chronological context, but it is possible that the Cypriote system is either ancestral to or descended from the Phoenician system. A final complexity is that the Hittite hieroglyphic numerals, which were still in use in the Neo-Hittite kingdoms in 800 bc, also use a vertical stroke for 1 and a horizontal one for 10. Trade between Cyprus and Asia Minor was substantial, and it would have been an extremely short sea voyage between the two regions. None of this material categorically excludes the possibility that the aberrant signs found by Masson are non-numerical and that the Phoenician, Hittite, and Cypriote numerals are unconnected except by their temporal and geographic proximity on the island of Cyprus. The corpus of inscriptions containing numerical signs is simply too limited, and the numbers expressed too small, to resolve the issue of their origin.
Summary Despite the enormous amount of work being done in the archaeology of the eastern Mediterranean, the genetic relations among the systems of this phylogeny have not been analyzed adequately in the past. The connections between the Egyptian hieroglyphic, hieratic, and demotic systems are well established, but more data are needed to establish the specific links between the Egyptian and Aegean systems. Nevertheless, on the basis of a shared set of features that distinguish it from other, superficially similar phylogenies such as the Levantine (Chapter 3) and Italic (Chapter 4), the inclusion of all the hieroglyphic systems in a single group is warranted. First, all the hieroglyphic systems have a base of 10, but they do not use a sub-base of 5 or any additional structuring signs. Second, they mostly have a cumulative-additive structure, although the hieratic, demotic, and Meroitic systems are ciphered-additive reductions of the original structure. Third, large numbers of cumulative signs in a numeral-phrase are grouped in sets of three to five. Fourth, their direction of writing can be quite variable (left-right, right-left, top-bottom,
Hieroglyphic Systems
67
or boustrophedon). Finally, hieroglyphic numerical notation systems are used far more frequently than lexical numerals for expressing numbers. While no hieroglyphic systems survived past 400 ad, its less direct descendants include the Roman numerals and probably even Western numerals (though greatly transformed). In the following four chapters, I will discuss a) the Levantine systems (Chapter 3), the Phoenician-Aramaic numerals and related systems; b) the Italic systems (Chapter 4), the Etruscan and Roman numerals and their descendants; c) the Alphabetic systems (Chapter 5), the Greek alphabetic numerals and related systems; and d) the South Asian systems (Chapter 6), the Brāhmī system and its descendants. While they are distinct enough to warrant placing them in separate families, all originate ultimately from hieroglyphic systems.
chapter 3
Levantine Systems
The first millennium bc was an era of considerable interregional commerce, warfare, and colonization in the Levant. This region was peripheral to both Egypt and Mesopotamia and thus exposed to multiple cultural influences. The various Levantine numerical notation systems that developed in the first millennium bc share several common features that reflect their debt to both Mesopotamia and Egypt, while demonstrating their indigenous creators’ considerable inventive energy. While this phylogeny of numerical notation systems was developed and most widely used in the Levant, it would eventually be adopted in various script traditions in Asia Minor, Arabia, Iran, the Indian subcontinent, and Central Asia. The Aramaic notation is the most important of the Levantine family of systems, which also includes the Phoenician, Palmyrene, Nabataean, Kharohī, Hatran, Old Syriac, Middle Persian, Sogdian, Manichaean, and Pahlavi systems. The most commonly used signs of these systems are shown in Table 3.1. Unfortunately, despite their widespread use over a large geographical area, these systems remain poorly analyzed in recent scholarship, so we must turn to the earlier work of epigraphers and paleographers such as Schroder (1869), Duval (1881), Lidzbarski (1898), Cooke (1903), and Cantineau (1930, 1935) for analyzing Levantine numerical notation. Despite the age of these works, there is no reason to question the data presented. However, this tradition of scholarship was primarily oriented toward the study of the texts of specific societies. Issues of diffusion and 68
69
Pahlavi
Manichaean
Sogdian
Middle Persian
Old Syriac
Hatran
Kharoṣṭhī
Nabataean
Palmyrene
Phoenician
Aramaic
ë
a a a a a a a
10
a b d
f
C D
H
G A
A A H A N K à > A > A
H
5
2
R g
4
1
BA
2
1
Table 3.1. Levantine numerical notation systems
g
E
I
4
C B @ D J J J ê J @
20
ä
s
F
J
5
F\ Ç A I L ü è
100
â
å
² ¶
–
E
ï
500
u
7
7
ç
G μ
1000
—
±
10,000
Numerical Notation
70 Table 3.2. Aramaic numerals 1
10
20
100
1000
a
A C F G 2894 = \0\aaa\A\CCCC\F\aa\aaa\aaa\G\aa cross-cultural comparison have not previously been addressed, and much work remains to be done.
Aramaic The Aramaeans, who originally inhabited a large portion of modern-day Syria, are first recognizable in the archaeological and written records around the end of the second millennium bc. During the ninth and eighth centuries bc, Aramaeans ruled a number of small states in the Levant, until these came under the domination of the Assyrian empire. Around this time, they developed a consonantal script on the model of the pre-existing Phoenician consonantary. By the eighth century bc, Aramaic inscriptions began to include numerical signs, shown in Table 3.2. The system is purely cumulative-additive for numbers up to 99, written (like the script itself ) from right to left, using signs for 20, 10, and 1. The unit-signs are grouped in threes, since up to nine such signs could be required. Occasionally, when an ungrouped unit-stroke was present in a numeral-phrase, it was written at a slight angle (so that 7 would be 0\aaa\aaa). Because there was a sign for 100, no more than four 20-signs and one 10-sign would ever be required, obviating the need for such groupings for higher values. The 10-sign appears to have originally been a simple horizontal stroke, with a tail added cursively. The 20-sign is almost certainly a ligatured combination of two 10-signs, as shown by the occasional use of a variant form B. There is a gradual trend over time toward the use of a special sign for 5 (H), which Lidzbarski (1898: 199) notes appearing on an Assyrian clay tablet as early as 680 bc. However, the majority of Aramaic numeral-phrases do not use a symbol for 5. Above 100, the Aramaic numerical notation system is multiplicative-additive rather than cumulative-additive, and it is thus a hybrid system. To form 800, for instance, eight unit-signs (appropriately grouped) were placed in front of the sign for 100 in order to indicate that the values should be multiplied. The same principle was followed for the thousands. There were apparently two signs for 1000; the first, G, is actually no more than the final two letters of the Aramaic lexical
Levantine Systems
71
numeral ‘LP ‘thousand’ (Gandz 1933: 69–70), while the second, μ, is the same as the corresponding Phoenician numeral-sign (Lidzbarski 1898: 201–202). While there is no distinct sign for 10,000 in the Aramaic system used in the Levant (though see the following discussion for Egyptian variants), rarely numbers greater than 9,999 were written using 10- and 20-signs in conjunction with the sign for 1000. Fractions are apparently found in a handful of inscriptions in which ungrouped unit-strokes aaaa and aaaaa mean 1/4 and 1/5, and one inscription contains a special sign for 2/3 (¼) (Lidzbarski 1898: 202), but they were normally written out lexically. The first Aramaic inscription with numerical notation is an eighth-century bc ostracon from Tell Qasile, in which 30 is expressed as three horizontal strokes (*) rather than the normal form (Lemaire 1977: 280). However, it may be a Hittite hieroglyphic numeral-phrase (Chapter 2), since that system was still in use in the eighth century bc in the Neo-Hittite kingdoms to the north. The earliest uncontestable examples are from the Assyrian bronze lion-weights found at Nimrud by Layard in the nineteenth century. These eighth-century inscribed weights have texts in Aramaic and Akkadian; on the largest (BM 91220; CIS II/1, 1), dating to the reign of Shalmaneser V (726–722 bc), the number 15 indicates the object’s weight of fifteen minas in three different ways on its three lines of text: in Aramaic lexical numerals, as fifteen ungrouped single strokes, and according to the structure detailed above (aa\aaa\A) (Fales 1995: 35). This threefold repetition using different methods of representation suggests that the system was unfamiliar, either because of its novelty or because it was intended for speakers of several languages. Structural similarities between the Aramaic system and the Assyro-Babylonian common system (Chapter 7), with which it shares a decimal base and the use of multiplicative-additive structuring for the hundreds and thousands, suggest a historical connection (Gandz 1933: 69; Ifrah 1985: 356). The conquest of the Aramaeans in 732 bc by the Assyrian empire establishes a clear historical context in which this transmission could have taken place. The lion-weights from Nimrud may well have been taken from the Levant as war booty shortly after this time (Fales 1995: 54). Yet the Aramaic system is also similar to the Egyptian hieroglyphic system. Aramaic speakers would certainly have had considerable contact with Egypt in the eighth century bc, and by the sixth century bc the Aramaic script was being used by settlers in Egypt at Elephantine and Saqqara. There are a number of similarities in the forms for signs. Like the Egyptian hieroglyphs but unlike the Assyro-Babylonian system, Aramaic uses vertical unit-strokes grouped in threes to express the units. A relationship between Aramaic A and hieroglyphic r (both signifying 10) has also been postulated (Schroder 1869: 186), although it is more likely that the hooked Aramaic sign is simply a cursive alteration of a horizontal stroke. Regardless, both signs are very different from the cuneiform Assyro-Babylonian
Numerical Notation
72
Table 3.3. Aramaic, Egyptian hieroglyphic, and Assyro-Babylonian numerals
Aramaic
424 =
\aaaa\C\F\aaaa 4
Hieroglyphic
424 =
qqqqrr„„„„ 4
Assyro-Babylonian
424 = Æ
20 100 4 Å
20
400 Å
4i\b4 4 100 20 4
system. The Aramaic use of unit fractions along the Egyptian hieroglyphic model, including the exception of having a special sign for 2/3, further suggests Egyptian borrowing. West Semitic accounts, like those in the Egyptian hieroglyphic and Aegean scripts, are written with the item being enumerated placed before the numeral, in contrast to Mesopotamian texts, which follow a “quantity + item” order (Levine 2004: 435). Finally, Egyptian hieroglyphic numeral-phrases are primarily written from right to left, as in Aramaic, whereas the Assyro-Babylonian system runs in a left-right direction, although of course the Aramaic script is also written right to left, so this cannot be taken as positive evidence in its own right. These differences are compared in Table 3.3. To muddy the waters even further, two other Hieroglyphic numerical notation systems were used in the eastern Mediterranean around 750 bc and could potentially have been known to the early users of Aramaic numerals. The Neo-Hittite kingdoms, although on the wane by that time, were still present in southeastern Anatolia, immediately abutting the Aramaeans. Moreover, the Cypriote numerals were invented just before that time, and there was enormous trade between Cyprus and the Levantine coast. But while the Cypriote and Hittite systems are cumulativeadditive and decimal and use vertical strokes for 1 and horizontal strokes for 10, they lack the other characteristics that might identify them as potential ancestor systems. The Aramaic numerals were likely developed under a dual cultural influence from Egypt and Mesopotamia. The system’s basic structure is very similar to the Assyro-Babylonian common system, but many paleographic and contextual similarities are far more similar to the Egyptian hieroglyphs. Geographically and historically, the Aramaeans and other Levantine peoples were peripheral to both civilizations in the mid first millennium bc, at the time of the system’s invention.
Levantine Systems
73
Although cultural phylogenies for scripts and numerical notation systems are usually arranged in accordance with a biological taxonomic scheme, cultural phenomena may have multiple origins, each making a contribution to the descendant, much as biological parents contribute to a child’s genetic makeup. If this explanation is correct, we must ask why the Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals, rather than the hieratic, would be chosen as a model for the Aramaic numerals. As I discussed in Chapter 2, the hieratic numerals were widely used in the Kingdom of Judah in the first half of the first millennium bc. Ostraca from Arad in the Negev dating to the late seventh and early sixth centuries attest both hieratic and Aramaic numerals (Levine 2004: 433). Like Millard (1995: 190–191), I find the failure of the Aramaeans to adopt the hieratic numerals to be rather curious. The existence of a distinct sign for 20 in Aramaic, and the recombination of features of two quite different systems, demonstrates that the Aramaeans were numerically inventive. In most of the Semitic languages, the word for ‘twenty’ is etymologically the plural of ‘ten’ – for example, Hebrew eser ‘ten’ versus esrim ‘twenty’ (Menninger 1969: 14). This may explain why the graphic “etymology” of the Aramaic numeral-sign for 20 is two ligatured 10-signs. This development of a special sign for 20 outside the regular decimal base of the numerical notation system is a unique development of the Levantine numerical notation systems; neither the Assyro-Babylonian system nor the systems of the Hieroglyphic phylogeny have this feature. Like the script to which it was attached, the Aramaic numerical notation was used in the Levant, Egypt, Mesopotamia, and farther afield throughout the second half of the first millennium bc. Segal (1983) gives ample evidence for the use of the system among Aramaic texts from Saqqara in Lower Egypt throughout the fifth and fourth centuries bc, and Aramaic papyri found at the fifth-century bc military colony at Elephantine demonstrate the use of the system in numerous administrative documents. While the system as used in the Levant had no special sign for 10,000, the Aramaic papyri found at Saqqara and Elephantine do use such a sign (±), which obeys the multiplicative principle in the same way as detailed earlier for 100 and 1000 (Segal 1983: 131; Ifrah 1985: 335). An alternate sign for 100 (²) was also used in Egyptian Aramaic, but it resembles none of the signs used in the Levant and is not similar to any of the Egyptian demotic or hieratic signs used at that time. The Aramaic script was widely used throughout the Achaemenid Empire from the sixth to fourth centuries bc on clay administrative and legal tablets, stone monuments, and leather and papyrus. While the scripts used in official royal proclamations and dedications were Old Persian, Babylonian, and Elamite, Aramaic was the lingua franca of the empire and served most administrative functions. As such, it was used as widely as Lower Egypt, Asia Minor, and the Transcaucasus and
74
Numerical Notation
even as far east as the Indus River. Throughout its history, the Aramaic numerical notation was used extensively on monumental inscriptions, ostraca, and administrative papyri. In literary and religious texts, however, numbers were more often written using lexical numerals only. Aramaic numerals were used to record the results of calculations used in commerce and administration, but none of the extant inscriptions demonstrate the use of written arithmetic. The end of the Achaemenid Empire did not spell the end of Aramaic influence over the Middle East; however, it did result in the fragmentation of what previously had been a unified script and numerical notation into several regional variants. During this period, Greek alphabetic numerals were often used administratively, although Aramaic numerals continued to be used in a variety of contexts. By the second century bce, political and ethnic divisions in the Near East had led to the emergence of variant numerical notation systems. The Hellenized Palmyrene, Nabataean, Hatran, and Edessan Syrian populations of the Levant each possessed its own variant numerical notations based on Aramaic. In these variants, the use of a distinct sign for 5 was far more prominent than in Aramaic numerals. The Kharoṣṭhī numerical notation used in parts of modern Afghanistan and Pakistan, and the Middle Persian and Pahlavi systems used in Iran, are also variant forms of Aramaic.
Phoenician The Phoenicians, who inhabited various cities (Tyre and Sidon foremostly) along the Levantine coast in the first millennium bc, were perhaps the greatest mercantile people of the ancient Mediterranean. The Phoenician consonantal script was a descendant of the earlier Canaanite consonantary that diverged from its ancestor late in the second millennium bce. However, none of the earliest Phoenician inscriptions contain numerical notation. While the Aramaic writing system developed from the earlier Phoenician, the Aramaic numerals appear to be slightly prior to the Phoenician, and there is no reason to assume that script and numerical notation must be borrowed jointly. The Phoenician numerical notation system is similar in structure to the Aramaic, with distinct signs for 1, 10, 20, 100, and 1000. These signs (including some paleographic variants) are shown in Table 3.4 (cf. Schroder 1869; Lidzbarski 1898; Gandz 1933; van den Branden 1969: 42–43). Like Aramaic, this system is purely decimal with the exception of the 20-sign, cumulative-additive below 100 and multiplicative-additive thereafter. Unit-signs are simple vertical strokes, although a left-slanting stroke is often used for ungrouped single strokes, and are grouped in threes, as in the Egyptian hieroglyphic and Aramaic systems. Like the Phoenician script itself, numeral-phrases are nearly always read from right to left, although van den Branden (1969: 43) notes at least
Levantine Systems
75
Table 3.4. Phoenician numerals 1
a
10
20
A B @ D 697 = 0\aaa\aaa\ADDDD\â\aaa\aaa
100
ä
Ç
1000
â
¶
E
μ
one exception (CIS.87,ph) in which left-to-right ordering is used, probably in error. The most notable feature of Phoenician numerals is the wide variety of forms for number-signs, particularly for 20 and 100. Schroder (1869: 188–189 and Table C) lists over twenty variants each for these two numbers, some of which can be attributed to differing individual scribal styles, while others may reflect regional or diachronic variation. I list only the more common forms for the sake of brevity. The 1000-sign is extremely rare; Lidzbarski (1898: 201) reports only a single instance from Tyre. There is no evidence whatsoever of the use of a distinct sign for 5, in contrast to later Levantine systems, nor is there any evidence of numeralsigns for fractions. For numbers greater than 100, a multiplicative-additive structure is employed as in Aramaic; a group of cumulative unit-signs preceding a single 100-sign indicates multiples from 100 to 900, with any additional signs to the left indicating the component of the number less than 100. It is likely that the rare sign for 1000 also combined multiplicatively with sets of grouped unit-signs. It is sometimes claimed that the Phoenicians used an alphabetic (presumably ciphered-additive) numerical notation system as early as 900 bc (Dantzig 1954: 295; Zabilka 1968: 117–119). The myth of Phoenician alphabetic numeration has been repeated for more than a century, but there is no foundation for this assertion. The first alphabetic numerals were developed by the Greeks in the late sixth century bc (Chapter 5). Zabilka (1968: 118) claims that the first ten letters of the Phoenician alphabet were used on coins minted at Sidon to represent the numbers 1 through 10, based on Harris (1936:19), who is, however, referring only to Alexandrine coins. By this time, the Greek alphabetic numeral system was used throughout the Levant by speakers of both Indo-European and Semitic languages. Even this does not prove the existence of a true alphabetic numerical notation system among the Phoenicians in the fourth century bc; it could, rather, indicate a system of letter labeling as used by the Greeks (Tod 1979: 98–105), which is not really different from the practice of modern writers who label points of discussion A, B, C, and so on. The first example of numerical notation in a Phoenician inscription is the Karatepe inscription of around 750 bc, which contains a single stroke for 1 (Millard 1995: 191). If this is a true example of the system just described, then its appearance
76
Numerical Notation
is virtually simultaneous with that of the Aramaic system. However, one unit-stroke is scant evidence for this. From the seventh century onward, however, Phoenician texts containing numerals are relatively common, including inscriptions on stone, ink writings on clay, administrative documents on papyrus, and, at a somewhat later period, inscriptions on coins. Phoenician numerals were often used to enumerate regnal years and for record keeping of commodities. However, between the seventh and first centuries bc, Phoenicia was politically dominated in turn by the Assyrian, Neo-Babylonian, Achaemenid, and Alexandrine Greek empires. The Phoenician numerical notation thus predominated in the Levant only during its early history. However, in the Phoenician colonies in North Africa and Spain (including, most importantly, Carthage), the Phoenicians continued to use the system detailed here, without significant regional variation, until Roman and Greek conquests in the second century bc effectively ended its use. Coins from Akko, Tyre, and Sidon used Greek alphabetic numerals as early as 265 bc, though at Arvad and Marathus, Phoenician numerals were used on coins until about 110 bc (Millard 1995: 193). The fruitful transmission of the Phoenician consonantal script throughout the Aegean and the Middle East has led some to speculate as to the transmission of its numerical notation system. Millard argues that Phoenician may have been the model for the Greek acrophonic (base-10, sub-base 5, cumulative-additive) numerical notation system (Millard 1995: 192). However, the acrophonic system’s sub-base of 5, coupled with the more obvious derivation of acrophonic numerals from the very similar Etruscan system, makes such an origin unlikely. Schroder (1869: 187f ) suggests that the Lycian numerals (Chapter 4) are a variant of Phoenician, but that system much more closely resembles the Greek acrophonic numerals than the Phoenician. It is entirely possible that one or more of the later Levantine systems have a Phoenician as opposed to Aramaic origin, but there is no good way to demonstrate this in most circumstances. The lack of a symbol for 5 in Phoenician numerals suggests that most of these later systems were Aramaic-based. Phoenician numeration, then, unlike the Phoenician writing system, is essentially a side branch of the broader Levantine family.
Palmyrene Palmyra was an important mercantile city located in modern Syria around 200 km northeast of Damascus, and whose inhabitants, Aramaic-speaking Semites, managed to retain considerable control over their own affairs despite Greek and Roman influence in the area. Palmyrene inscriptions are found dating from the first century bc to the mid third century ad, continuing the tradition of the earlier Aramaic script. Palmyrene numerical notation retained much of the structure of
Levantine Systems
77
Table 3.5. Palmyrene numerals 1
a 178 =
5
10
20
H A J aaa\\H\\\A\\J\J\J\\A\a
the older Aramaic system, while introducing new numeral-signs. Despite their relative obscurity, the Palmyrene numerals were first analyzed over a quartermillennium ago by Swinton (1753–54). The Palmyrene system had distinct signs for 1, 5, 10, and 20, as shown in Table 3.5. These four symbols express any number less than 100. While in earlier Aramaic scripts the sign for 5 appeared only sporadically, it was a fundamental part of the Palmyrene system. Because of this, only four unit-signs were required at most, so there was no need to group sets of unit-signs into threes. Like its Aramaic ancestor, Palmyrene numerical notation is base-10 and cumulative-additive below 100. For numbers greater than 100, Palmyrene, like Aramaic, is multiplicative-additive, with the complexity that the sign for 100 is identical to that for 10. The possibility of confusion is avoided by the requirement of having one or more unit-signs before the 100-sign, whereas no such signs could precede a 10-sign. While this feature resembles the use of the positional principle, such phrases are multiplicative, not positional. To represent 100, the sign A had to be combined with unit-signs; alone, it always meant 10, not 100. Cantineau (1935: 36) contends that the original Palmyrene sign for 100 was a horizontal stroke placed above a dot, but that it was later reduced until it was identical to the 10-sign. If so, the identity of the two signs may be largely coincidental. In monumental inscriptions on stone, Palmyrene numerals are among the clearest and most unambiguous of all the Levantine systems. Figure 3.1 is a memorial inscription dating to the year 492 (ad 181); the phrase is clearly visible on the last three lines of the inscription (Arnold 1905: Plate IV). Palmyrene numerical notation was restricted geographically and temporally to the city of Palmyra during the period from about 100 bc to 275 ad. During that time, however, it was used widely on inscriptions and records of commercial transactions, though not normally in literary contexts. We do not know the extent to which it may have been used in a broader range of genres due to the poor survival of evidence. The importance of Palmyra as a commercial center rested on its strategic location on the Roman frontier and its trade ties with peoples outside the empire. Despite considerable Hellenisation and Latinisation, Palmyra retained its script and numerical notation through the third century ad, though Greek alphabetic
78
Numerical Notation
Figure 3.1. A Palmyrene memorial inscription dating to ad 181; the year-date (492) is clearly visible on the final three lines of the inscription, including multiplicative use of the sign for 100. Source: Arnold 1905: Plate IV.
and Roman numerals came to be used more frequently for administrative and mercantile purposes. In 273 ad, following the short-lived independent rule of Queen Zenobia over the province (266–272 ad), Palmyra was destroyed by the Roman emperor Aurelian, abruptly ending its importance as a commercial center. Thus, political factors, rather than criteria of function and efficiency, led to the complete replacement of the Palmyrene numerical notation system by those of Greek and Roman colonizers. It has sometimes been argued that Palmyrene is ancestral to the Syriac numerical notation, though I will show below that this is only one of many possible scenarios of transmission.
Nabataean The Nabataeans were a South Semitic people of Arabian ancestry who inhabited the area between Syria and Arabia in the southeastern Levant in the late first millennium bc and into the Christian era. Though not Aramaeans, they came under considerable Aramaean influence and adapted the Aramaic script for their South
Levantine Systems
79
Table 3.6. Nabataean numerals 1
A
4
5
R N 178 = aaa\\NA\\J\J\J\\I\a
10
20
100
K
J
I
Semitic language, including a variant of its numerical notation. This system was used from approximately 100 bc to 350 ad in inland areas of the Levant (modern southern Syria and Jordan) including the cities of Damascus and Petra, and even as far south as the port of Aqaba on the Red Sea. Its signs are indicated in Table 3.6. As with all the Levantine systems, Nabataean is decimal, cumulative-additive below 100 and multiplicative-additive above, with additional signs for 4, 5, and 20. Unit-strokes are grouped in threes where necessary and are sometimes joined together at the base in cursive writing. The sign for 4 is used only in some inscriptions, and then only in numeral-phrases for 4 (never 5 through 9); 8 is expressed as 111N (5 + 3) or 11\111\111, but never (to my knowledge) as RR. Lidzbarski (1898: 199) argues that its shape represents four unit-strokes placed in a cross, strictly on graphic principles, but this is unproven. Its historical connection with the identical Kharoṣṭhī sign for 4 is still unclear, but some link seems probable, as the Nabataeans were frequently engaged in commerce with peoples to the east. However, Gibson (1971: 13) notes that the eighth-century bc Samaria ostraca, in which the Hebrew variant of the Egyptian hieratic numerals (Chapter 2) predominates, contain a “+” or “X”-shaped sign for 4, which would antedate either the Nabataean or Kharoṣṭhī symbol by several centuries. Finally, Cantineau (1930: 36) and Lidzbarski (1898: 199) believe the signs for 4 and 5 to be quite late inventions, possibly independent of any other system. The Nabataean sign for 10 is a more arched version of the hooked horizontal stroke used in most Levantine systems, while the 20-sign can easily be shown to derive from the Aramaic form. In one inscription from Egypt, the year-number 160 (ad 266) is written irregularly as “100 20 10 20 10” instead of the expected “100 20 20 10 10”; this seems unlikely to be a scribal error but is otherwise unexplained (Littmann and Meredith 1953: 16). The sign for 100 is not obviously related to that of any other notation, though Cantineau (1930: 36) argues for its possible derivation from Phoenician Ç. The sign for 100 combines with signs for 1, 4, and 5 multiplicatively. Accordingly, the 4-sign is used to express 400, as in an inscription from Dumêr (near Damascus) from 94 ad in which the number 405 is expressed as NIR (4 × 100 + 5) (Cooke 1903: 249). Such numeral-phrases make the system look less cumulative than it actually was. No Nabataean writings contain numbers higher than 1000.
80
Numerical Notation
The Nabataean numerical notation system is found on inscriptions dating from around 100 bc to the late fourth century ad, primarily in the inland Levant from Damascus south to Petra. Throughout its history, it was used in inscriptions on edifices, on ostraca, and on coins. I do not know of any attested Nabataean numerals in the poorly attested cursive script tradition, which varies from the monumental script in several paleographic respects. The Nabataean legal papyri from the Cave of Letters dating to the early to mid second century ad express all numerals lexically (Yadin et al. 2002). The Greek alphabetic numerals (Chapter 5) and Roman numerals (Chapter 4) were also well known and frequently used in otherwise Nabataean inscriptions. Though the Nabataeans were politically subordinate to Rome throughout most of the period under consideration, they held a monopoly over the caravan trade that passed from inland Arabia to the Levantine coast. Nabataean numerical notation has been found on economic documents and inscriptions from Greece, Italy, and Egypt. In the fourth century ad, the Nabataean numerals began to be replaced by the Greek alphabetic and, to a far lesser extent, Roman numerals. While the Nabataean script is ancestral to the earliest Arabic script, there is no connection between the Nabataean numerals and the systems used by the early Arabs. Millard (1995: 193–194) reports the use of Nabataean numerals on the pre-Islamic Arabic inscriptions from En-Namara (dated 328 ad), and possibly on the sixth-century ad Zabad and Harran inscriptions. Such late occurrences become increasingly rare, however, as Greek alphabetic numerals and systems based thereupon predominated throughout the Middle East, and by the time of the introduction of Islam, no trace of the Nabataean system remained.
Hatran A variant Aramaic script was used in the region around the city of Hatra (modern Al-Hadr, in northern Iraq), an outpost of the Parthian Empire and later the capital of the small autonomous state of Araba. The Hatran script, for which inscriptions have been found dating from about 50 bc to 275 ad, possessed a distinct numerical notation system with signs for 1, 5, 20, and 100, as shown in Table 3.7. As with all Levantine systems, the Hatran numerical notation is decimal, cumulativeadditive for numbers less than 100, multiplicative-additive above 100, and written from right to left. The precise relation of the Hatran system to the other Levantine systems is unclear, but it is descended in some way from the Aramaic system used around Hatra in the centuries prior to the development of the Hatran script, given the similarity of signs for 1, 10, and 20 to earlier Aramaic forms. The sign for 5 is identical to that of the Old Syriac script used around Edessa at that time. Finally, the 100-sign is of entirely mysterious origin, though a case could be made that it is related to the Phoenician â.
Levantine Systems
81
Table 3.7. Hatran numerals 1
5
10
20
a
>
A
ê
100
J
ü
697 = 11>AJJJJü1>
The Hatran numerals were probably ancestral in some way to the Middle Persian numerals, at least giving rise to some of the Middle Persian numeralsigns. Hatran numerical notation was used widely on ostraca, on inscriptions on stone, and in economic documents. Unlike the Palmyrene and Nabataean states, which were subjected to Roman political and economic domination for most of their history, Hatra remained independent from both Roman and Parthian control until 272 ad, when the Middle Persian king Shapur I conquered the region. After this time, Hatran inscriptions are more rarely encountered, and the Middle Persian script and numerals (and its successors) replaced them.
Old Syriac A consonantal script was used at the ancient city of Edessa (modern Urfa, in southeast Turkey) in the early years of the Christian era. Based on an Aramaic model, this script, which resembles the estrangela Syriac script that emerged in the later manuscript tradition, was used to write the Old Syriac language, a close relative of Aramaic. A large number of Old Syriac inscriptions on stone, mosaics, and parchment have survived, dating from the beginning of the Christian era to 500 ad, and largely found in northern Syria and southern Turkey.1 The Old Syriac numerical notation system used signs for 1, 5, 10, 20, and 100, and possibly also 2 and 500, as shown in Table 3.8 (cf. Rödiger 1862, Duval 1881, Segal 1954). Numeral-phrases, like the script itself, are always written from right to left. The system is decimal (with a special sign for 20), cumulative-additive for numbers less than 100, and multiplicative-additive for higher values, all of which points to its membership in this phylogeny and its close relationship to Aramaic. However, it has some curious features. The sign for 2, as defined by Duval (1881: 14–15), is simply a ligatured form of two unit-strokes, a paleographic convenience that was never used consistently or regarded as a structural feature of the system. The sign for 5 is identical to that of the Hatran system, and the sign for 20 to one variant form used in Phoenician. The sign for 5 was not consistently used in numeral 1
The earliest dated Syriac inscription is from ad 6, although Drijvers and Healey (1999: 17) argue that it may have originated earlier.
Numerical Notation
82
Table 3.8. Old Syriac numerals 1
2
5
10
A
ë > A 697 = ë>A@@@@èï
20
@
100
‚
è
500
’
ï
phrases for 5 through 9 (Segal 1954: 35). For instance, in three separate inscriptions dating to ad 165, the date 476 of the Seleucid era is written in three different ways, as indicated in Table 3.9 (Drijvers and Healey 1999). The earliest dated Old Syriac inscription (As55, dating to ad 6) expresses the year-date (317) using seven unitstrokes (Drijvers and Healey 1999: 141). This suggests that the sign for 5 may have been a later development, and at best an occasional one. Duval (1881: 14) argues that the 100-sign is a slightly modified form of the 10sign, resembling the Palmyrene numerical notation in this respect. The Old Syriac symbol for 500 is rare, partly because numbers of this magnitude are infrequent in Syriac writings. Duval (1881: 14) insists that it ought to be understood in many numeral-phrases where it is not written, such as in year-dates. However, in the Old Syriac slave sale contract, P. Dura 28, written at Edessa in ad 243, 700 is written multiplicatively as seven unit-strokes (some ligatured) followed by the powersign for 100, rather than with a sign for 500. The notion of a sign for 500, if not its form, may have been borrowed from the Roman numerals, given the cultural and political dominance of Rome in Syria throughout the period. Old Syriac numerical notation was used on numerous inscriptions on stone around Edessa, but not in the short-lived tradition of mosaic inscriptions from the third century ad. It evidently originated as a variant of the Aramaic system, but its specific relationship to the other Levantine numerical systems remains unclear. Three Old Syriac legal texts written on parchment survive, dating from ad 240–243; of these, only P. Dura 28 (just discussed) contains Syriac numerals (Drijvers and Healey 1999: 232–235; Goldstein 1966). In many inscriptions and manuscripts, lexical numerals were used instead of numerical notation. Although the Edessan Table 3.9. Old Syriac year-dates for 476 / ad 165 Inscription
Date
As29
a>A\‚‚‚\’\aaaa
As36
aaaaaaA\‚‚‚\’\aaaa
As37
ëaëaA\‚‚‚\’\aaaa
Transliteration (1 + 1 + 1 + 1) × 100 + 20 + 20 + 20 + 10 + 5 + 1 (1 + 1 + 1 + 1) × 100 + 20 + 20 + 20 + 10 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 (1 + 1 + 1 + 1) × 100 + 20 + 20 + 20 + 10 + 1 + 2 + 1 + 2
Levantine Systems
83
Christians were subject to Roman imperial authority throughout most of the history of their script and numerical notation, and although both Greek alphabetic and Roman numerals were widely used in Syria, the Old Syriac numerals were not displaced by either system. By the fifth and sixth centuries ad, however, the older numerals began to be replaced by the ciphered-additive Syriac alphabetic system (Chapter 5), which assigned numerical values to the twenty-two letters of the Syriac consonantary. This gradual obsolescence corresponds to the development of the indigenous Syriac Christian manuscript tradition, particularly oriented toward liturgical subjects. Many texts use the two systems side by side. A seventh-century Syriac religious commentary (BM Add. 14,603) contains several lines of Old Syriac numerals that are incomprehensible until the numeral values are converted into their corresponding values in the Syriac alphabetic numerals; the resulting alphabetic signs can then be read as the author’s epigraph (Wright 1870: II, 586–587). While this demonstrates that the numerals were still in use, the cryptographic nature of the note suggests that they may not have been well known. The very latest evidence of the Old Syriac system is from the eighth century, after which only alphabetic numerals were used (Duval 1881: 15).
Kharos.t.hī The Kharoṣṭhī script was used in the region of Gandhara in eastern Afghanistan and northern Pakistan from around 325 bc to 300 ad and, from the second century ad onward, in parts of Central Asia. Given that this region was under the control of the Achaemenid Empire (for which Aramaic was a lingua franca) from 559 to 336 bc, the similarity in form and value of many of the signs in the two scripts, and their common right-to-left directionality, Kharoṣṭhī is clearly descended from Aramaic. During the earliest periods of its use (before about 100 bc), Kharoṣṭhī inscriptions containing numerals are quite rare, being found in only a few royal inscriptions of the Mauryan King Aśoka, who reigned from about 273 to 232 bc. Only the numbers 1, 2, 4, and 5 are represented, and they are always formed using simple unit-strokes. In the later Saka, Parthian, and Kusana inscriptions (dating from about 100 bc onward), a more complex system was used, and much larger numbers were represented. This system possessed unique signs for the numbers 1, 4, 10, 20, 100, and 1000, as shown in Table 3.10 (cf. Das Gupta 1958: Table XIV; Salomon 1998: Table 2.6; Glass 2000: 139–143). In common with all the Levantine systems, Kharoṣṭhī is purely cumulativeadditive up to 100 and multiplicative-additive thereafter. As in the script as a whole (and in other Aramaic-derived scripts), the direction of writing is always from right to left. Unlike other Levantine systems used at the time, Kharoṣṭhī has no special sign for 5; numbers from 4 through 9 were always expressed through combinations of units and 4-signs. Unit-signs in the cursively written texts of Central Asia are
Numerical Notation
84
Table 3.10. Kharoṣṭhī numerals 1
20
100
g à J 697 = aaa\R\à\JJJJ\å\aaR
L
a
4
10
1000
å
–
ç
—
usually ligatured together in groups of two and three. The sign for 1000 is found only in the late (perhaps fifth century ad) texts from Inner Asia (Das Gupta 1958: 259; Mangalam 1990: 48; Glass 2000: 143). It is most likely a variant of the similar Aramaic sign, which was a conventionalized version of the lexical numeral for 1000, ‘LP (Salomon 1998: 64). The signs for 100 and 1000 combine multiplicatively with signs for units less than 10, with the units to the right (before) the power-sign. Figure 3.2 is the obverse of a leather text written in cursive script found at Niya by Sir Aurel Stein; the numerals 3 and 25 (20 + 4 + 1) are readily visible at the bottom of the text (Boyer, Rapson, and Senart 1920: 120, Plate V). The Aśokan-period system of vertical strokes may or may not be of Aramaic origin, though the geographical proximity of its users, coupled with the obvious relation of the Kharoṣṭhī alphasyllabary to the Aramaic consonantary, suggests that it was. In its fully developed form, however, it is definitely part of the Levantine phylogeny, and not related to the Brāhmī numerals (Chapter 6) used in India. Kharoṣṭhī shares with the other systems the right-to-left direction of writing, the use of vertical strokes for units, similar forms for the numeral-signs for 10 and 20, and the use of the multiplicative principle for 100. The use of X\ for 4 is common to both Kharoṣṭhī and Nabataean, and this is unlikely to be coincidental, since they share a common sign for 20 as well, and both systems developed around 100 bc. These are the only two cumulative systems worldwide ever to use a special sign for 4. As mentioned earlier, the Hebrew hieratic ciphered sign for 4 was + or X, suggesting transmission from west to east. However, Datta and Singh (1962: 23) argue that the sign may have developed by rotating the Brāhmī sign for 4 (+) by forty-five degrees, and may then have been transmitted westward to the Nabataeans. Buhler (1896: 73), in turn, contends that the Nabataean and Kharoṣṭhī signs were invented independently of one another. The Kharoṣṭhī numerical notation system was used primarily on inscriptions on stone and on copper, but there are also surviving documents from Inner Asia written on wood, palm leaf, birch bark, and leather (Salomon 1996: 378). Throughout its history, it was in competition with its rival, Brāhmī numerals (Chapter 6), the system used on the Mauryan inscriptions of the Indian heartland. The use of Kharoṣṭhī was tied to the political independence of the Greek, Scythian, and Parthian kingdoms, which looked to Bactrian and Iranian traditions rather than
85
Figure 3.2. A Kharoṣṭhī leather text found by Sir Aurel Stein at Niya. The numeral 25 is clearly visible at the bottom left of the page (20 + 4 + 1). Source: Boyer, Rapson, and Senart 1920: Plate V.
86
Numerical Notation
to Indian ones. By the late third century ad, the Bactrian and Indo-Scythian polities of the Kharoṣṭh heartland were seriously weakened, and the advent of the Gupta Empire in the fourth century ad heralded the predominance of Brāhmī throughout the Indian subcontinent. However, Kharoṣṭhī survived longer in the small states of Inner Asia. Inscriptions on wooden documents from the city of Niya date to as late as the seventh century ad, and contain a variant of the Kharoṣṭhī script and numerals.
Middle Persian The Persians of the Achaemenid, Seleucid, and Parthian Empires used the Old Persian numerals (Chapter 7), the Greek alphabetic numerals (Chapter 5), or the common Aramaic numerals already described. The Sassanian dynasty began in ad 228 when Ardashir I destroyed the Parthian Empire, which had ruled much of the territory of modern Iraq and Iran for several centuries prior. For several centuries, the Sassanian empire was a rival of Rome and later Byzantium to the west, and of the Gupta Empire in India to the east, and was the dominant power in Mesopotamia and Persia until the Islamic conquest. The Middle Persian language (the ancestor of modern Farsi), the language of Sassanian administration and commerce, was written in an Aramaic-derived consonantary, reflecting the legacy of Achaemenid, Seleucid, and Parthian rule in the region. The numerical notation system associated with the Middle Persian script is shown in Table 3.11 (Frye 1973). Like its ancestor, the Aramaic system, the Middle Persian system was cumulativeadditive and decimal for numbers below 100, and written from right to left with the highest powers at the right. The signs for 1, 10, and 20 resemble closely the signs used in the other contemporary Levantine systems, while the sign for 100 resembles only that of the Hatran system. Unlike most of the later variants of Aramaic, however, there was no sign for either 4 or 5, and units from 5 to 9 were written using grouped sets of three or four unit-strokes. The sign for 1000, as in Aramaic and Kharoṣṭhī, is a reduced version of the Aramaic lexical numeral ‘LP ‘thousand’. For numbers above 100, the signs for 100 and 1000 combined multiplicatively with cumulative numeral-phrases, as in the other Levantine systems. Thus, in the Qa’ba inscription of Kartir, the number 6798 is written as shown in Table 3.11 (Frye 1973: 4). It is impossible to determine the precise historical affiliation of the Middle Persian system to the other Levantine systems, other than to note that it is most definitely descended from the Aramaic system in some way. The lack of a sign either for 4 or 5 is quite unusual for such a late descendant of Aramaic, as all of the other contemporary Levantine systems have some such sign. The Middle Persian script is most closely affiliated with the Hatran script, and the two systems share similar signs for 100, suggesting a historical connection. Middle Persian numerals
Levantine Systems
87
Table 3.11. Middle Persian numerals 1
10
20
100
1000
1
2 3 4 5 6 6798 = 1111\1111\24444\5\111\1111\7\111\111
7
were employed on silver bowls and plates to indicate weights, inscribed on stone texts, and written in ink on ostraca. As the Middle Persian period progressed, the script and numerals tended to be written increasingly cursively, with signs ligatured together. The Middle Persian Empire came to an abrupt end in ad 637 after the child-king Yezdigird III was overthrown by the Islamic Umayyad caliphs. By that time, the Middle Persian script had diverged into several variants, one of the more important of which was Book Pahlavi. The Book Pahlavi numerals are sufficiently different from their Middle Persian ancestor to warrant separate treatment.
Sogdian The Sogdian language was an Iranian language closely related to Middle Persian but spoken further to the north, in modern Uzbekistan and Tajikistan. Sogdian was written using three separate scripts: the Sogdian script descended from Middle Persian, the Manichaean script used by Sogdian followers of that religion and descended from the Estrangelo Syriac script, and the Christian Sogdian script used by Nestorian Christians and descended from Nestorian Syriac (Skjaervø 1996). This religious and scriptal pluralism greatly complicates the history of Central Asian Iranian scripts and numerals. The Sogdian script is first attested from the “Ancient Letters” dating to ad 312–313 found by Stein in Chinese Turkestan, but may have originated in the third century. The Sogdian script proper and the Manichaean script had distinct numerical notation systems of the basic Levantine structure, which I will treat in turn, while the Christian Sogdian script used lexical numerals or Syriac alphabetic numerals (Sims-Williams, personal communication). There has been no systematic comparative treatment of Sogdian numerals to date, and minimal paleographic work. The Sogdian numeral-signs are shown in Table 3.12 (cf. Sundermann and Zieme 1981). Table 3.12. Sogdian numerals 1
10
20
100
1000
G
H
I
J
7
697=
G\GGG\GGGHIIII\JGGG\GGG
88
Numerical Notation
The Sogdian system has numeral-signs for 1, 10, 20, and 100. It is cumulative-additive below 100 and multiplicative for the hundreds and thousands, with numeral-phrases always written in descending order from right to left. The sign for 1 is never used to write 1 alone but always phonetically as ‘yw (Sims-Williams, personal communication). Units from 2 to 9 are usually ligatured, although they can be arranged in groupings of two to four units, or sometimes ungrouped. There is no special sign for 5, in contrast to many of the Levantine systems (including Manichaean), but in common with Middle Persian, Kharoṣṭhī, and Pahlavi. While the sign for 10 is similar to the Sogdian letter δ that begins the word δs ‘ten’, the similarity is probably the result of later paleographic assimilation rather than being indicative of an alphabetic origin for the sign. Paleographically, the sign for 20 was originally two superimposed signs for 10, and in the “Ancient Letters” 30 was occasionally expressed using three such signs (Sims-Williams, personal communication). By the seventh and eighth centuries the Sogdian letters dāleth (d) and ‘ain (‘) had become assimilated to the forms of the numerals 20 and 100, respectively (Livshitz 1970: 259). The sign for 1000 is not a numerical-sign per se, but, as in Aramaic and Middle Persian, an abbreviated ideographic form of the Aramaic word ‘LP ‘thousand’; similarly, 10,000 is written using an ideogram RYPW (Aramaic ribbō) (Sims-Williams, personal communication). Fractions are poorly understood, although Grenet, Sims-Williams, and de la Vaissière (1998: 96) suggest that there is a sign for 1/2 that had previously been interpreted as a variant for 100. The majority of the texts in which this system was used are religious in nature (the so-called Sogdian sutra script), although the “Ancient Letters” are personal correspondence, and there are a few inscriptions on stone from Pakistan (Skjaervø 1996: 517). Numerals are used ordinally and cardinally in texts in various ways. Sundermann and Zieme (1981) discuss some fragmentary lists of sequential numbers in the “Sogdian-Turkish word lists” used as translation glossaries, one of which simply lists numerals from 88 to 100, and another of which contains undeciphered (non-Sogdian) numerical symbols associated with the Turkish numeral words ‘one’ through ‘five’. Numeral-signs could be combined with lexical numerals, as in the phrases 100 ‘št ‘108’ and δwy 100 20 ‘220’ in the Padmacintāmaņi-dhāraņīsūtra dating to around ad 700 (Mackenzie 1976: 12–17). Multiplicative powerideograms could also be combined together, as in the phrase 100 1LPW RYPW ‘100,000 myriads’ (= billions) in the Dhyāna text (Mackenzie 1976: 72–73). Following the conversion of most of the Central Asian peoples to Islam, the Sogdian script was used increasingly infrequently. In the eighth and ninth centuries Sogdian writing was adopted by Buddhist Uygurs, around which time the script was rotated ninety degrees counterclockwise, resulting in vertical columns (Coulmas 1996: 472–473). By this time, however, it appears that no numerical
Levantine Systems
89
symbols were used (numbers were written lexically). It had largely fallen out of use by the tenth century ad.
Manichaean The development of a specifically Manichaean writing system is usually attributed to Mani himself in the third century ad, although this tale is likely mythical, and, the script may indeed be older than the religion (Skjaervø 1996). Manichaean writing is derived from the Estrangelo variety of Syriac, and its numerical system owes much to its ancestor. It was used to write a wide variety of languages, including Middle Persian, Sogdian, and Uygur. The best-known Manichaean texts are those from the oasis of Turfan along the Silk Road, which date from the eighth and ninth centuries ad. As with many of the Central Asian scripts, Manichaean numerals remain understudied paleographically and comparatively; the signs shown in Table 3.13 derive from the manuscript published by Müller (1912). Manichaean numerals are always written from right to left with the highest powers written first. The system is cumulative-additive below 100, with signs for 1, 5, 10, 20, and 100, while the hundreds are expressed multiplicatively. Units are generally ligatured together, with long flourishes at the end (left) of the phrase. Figure 3.3 depicts a section of a hymn book (Mahrnâmag) in Manichaean script dating to ad 761–62; the year-number 546 (dated from Mani’s birth) is found on lines 1–2 (5 100 20 20 5 1), while the last line contains the year-number 162 (100 20 20 20 1 1), reckoning from the death of Mari Schad Ormizd (Müller 1912: 36, Taf. II). The presence of a distinct sign for 5 very similar to that of Syriac, as well as similarities in the sign for 20, suggest that Iranian and Central Asian scripts such as Middle Persian and Sogdian played little role in shaping the Manichaean numeral-signs. However, all of the Manichaean numeral-signs, with the exception of the upright stroke for 1, are assimilated to letters of the Manichaean consonantal script (5 = ‘; 10 = h; 20 = p; 100 = m), so reconstructing the diachronic paleographic history of the system is complex (Sims-Williams, personal communication). It is unclear whether Manichaean had any signs for 1000 or higher powers. While the Manichaean religion flourished for several centuries after its peak, texts in the Manichaean script became less numerous after the tenth century, by which time it seems to have acquired a dignified and prestigious but also arcane quality (Sundermann 1997). The Manichaean numerals do not appear to have left any descendant systems.
Pahlavi Following the Islamic conquest, the Arabic script was normally used for writing the Middle Persian language. The Zoroastrian Persians, however, continued to use
Numerical Notation
90
Table 3.13. Manichaean numerals 1
10
20
100
BA C D 697 = BACDEEEEFAC
E
F
A
2
5
their own Aramaic-derived script for their religious texts and for other purposes. No Persian texts on papyrus survive from the early Middle Persian period, but late in the Middle Persian period, and following the Islamic conquest, Persian began to be written using a cursive, highly ligatured version of the earlier Pahlavi script, known as Book Pahlavi. Alongside this script, a set of numerals was employed (which I will call simply “Pahlavi”), shown in Table 3.14 (Abramian 1965: 285; Mackenzie 1971: 145). The Pahlavi system is decimal and written from right to left with the highest powers at the right. Frye (1973: 4–6) established conclusively that the Pahlavi numeral-signs are cursively derived from those of the earlier Middle Persian system. The signs for 1 through 9 are ligatured and cursive reductions of unit-strokes, and the Middle Persian practice of grouping unit-signs in groups of three and four
Figure 3.3. A portion of the Manichaean Mahrnâmag of ad 761–62, with the numeral 546 spanning the first two lines and 162 at the beginning (reading from right to left) of the last line shown. Source: Müller 1912: Taf. II.
Levantine Systems
91
Table 3.14. Pahlavi numerals 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
a b c d bc cc cd dd ccc 10s f j l m n o p q r 100s s 1000s u 4697 = cdrsccud
1s
strokes can also be seen in the phrases for 5 through 9. Like the Middle Persian system, the Pahlavi system is multiplicative-additive for the hundreds and thousands. Yet the Pahlavi numerals are structurally quite divergent from their ancestor. The signs for the tens, in particular, show almost no trace of their cumulative ancestry, and the unit-signs have largely become ligatured into single signs or, in the case of 5 through 9, into combinations of two or three signs. Combinations of tens and units were usually ligatured together. The Pahlavi system is thus, for all intents, ciphered-additive rather than cumulative-additive below 100. This transformation from cumulation to ciphering occurred when the epigraphic Middle Persian script and numerals, written mostly on stone and metal, were transferred to papyrus, which is more amenable to cursive and ligatured writing. This transformation is directly analogous to the derivation of Egyptian hieratic numerals from their hieroglyphic ancestor (Chapter 2), corresponding to the switch in medium from stone to papyrus. These two instances, in fact, are the only two known cases where a cumulative system directly gave rise to a ciphered one. The Zoroastrian Persians continued to use the Book Pahlavi script for their religious writings and for new pieces of literature into the tenth century ad. Most surviving Pahlavi numerals are found in these papyrus texts, although there are also epigraphic texts on stone and metal. After about ad 1000, the Middle Persian language underwent a set of changes that led to its transformation into Modern Persian (Farsi). By this time, the abjad numerals (Chapter 5) and Arabic positional numerals (Chapter 6) had completely replaced the Pahlavi system.
Summary The Levantine phylogeny is descended from the Aramaic and Phoenician systems developed around 750 bc, based on the dual model of the Egyptian hieroglyphic system and the Assyro-Babylonian common system. Over the second half of the first millennium bc, the Aramaic system and its descendants spread throughout
92
Numerical Notation
Assyria, Persia, Egypt, Asia Minor, and even into India and Central Asia. While these systems were used for over a millennium, they ceased to be used once the polities in which they predominated (most significantly, Achaemenid and Seleucid Persia) declined in importance. Levantine numerical notation systems steeply declined in frequency of use after the rise of Islam, as the systems were replaced by those of the alphabetic (Chapter 5) and South Asian (Chapter 6) phylogenies. They persisted the longest in Central Asia, where Islam was somewhat slower to take hold. The central features of Levantine numerical notation systems are as follows: a) a decimal base; b) a special sign for 20 (sometimes a combination of two 10signs); c) the use of vertical strokes for units and horizontal strokes (usually with some degree of curvature) for tens; d) a cumulative-additive structure for numbers smaller than 100; and e) the use of multiplicative-additive notation for expressing multiples of 100 (and also of 1000 and 10,000, where appropriate). Signs for 4 are found in Nabataean and Kharoṣṭhī. The presence of a sign for 5 used in late Aramaic, Palmyrene, Nabataean, Hatran, Old Syriac, and Manichaean helps to clarify some of the relationships among the systems of the family. The late Pahlavi system, which is heavily ligatured, is essentially ciphered-additive and thus somewhat anomalous, but it shares all the other structural features of this phylogeny, and is clearly derivative of a cumulative-additive ancestor. While these systems were used extensively for administrative and mercantile purposes, as well as on inscriptions, there is no direct evidence that any Levantine numerical notation system was ever used as a computational aid. We simply do not know by what means the users of these script traditions performed arithmetic, but there is no reason to assume that it was done with pen and paper. There are issues relating to the survival of perishable materials such as wooden tablets, papyrus sheets, and leather scrolls, none of which survive well in the archaeological record. Yet, even in surviving texts, numbers were often written out lexically in religious and literary contexts and even occasionally in economic documents. As such, numerical notation occupied a less significant role in the script traditions of these societies than would otherwise have been the case. Moreover, in comparison to the incredibly wide diffusion of Aramaic-derived scripts throughout Europe, the Middle East, and South Asia, Levantine numerical notations spread only sporadically, and their imprint was impermanent. The reason for this deserves careful attention, and I will return to the question in Chapter 12, after looking at the history of these systems’ competitors.
chapter 4
Italic Systems
The Roman numerals are undoubtedly one of the better-known numerical notation systems, and have received a tremendous amount of scholarly attention. Nevertheless, they constitute only a part of a larger phylogeny of numerical notation systems that originated, not among Romans, but among Etruscans and Greeks on the Italian peninsula around 600–500 bc. The name “Italic” refers only to this geographical origin, and thus does not reflect any shared linguistic or cultural affiliation. Italic systems flourished between 500 bc and 500 ad throughout the Mediterranean region, Western Europe, and North Africa, under conditions of Greek and Roman cultural hegemony and political domination. Ironically enough, however, the collapse of the Roman Empire brought about the greatest expansion of one particular system – the Roman numerals – in medieval Europe, and ultimately throughout the modern Western world. The most common variants of the Italic numeral-signs are shown in Table 4.1.
Etruscan The Etruscans were a non-Indo-European people whose civilization had its center in north central Italy, in the region of modern Tuscany (whose name is taken from the Latin Tusci, meaning Etruscan). The origins and civilization of the Etruscans are poorly understood, and large parts of their language remain undeciphered. Yet Etruscan civilization was the most potent political force on the Italian peninsula between around 800 and 300 bc, and significantly influenced Roman culture 93
Numerical Notation
94
Table 4.1. Italic numerical notation systems System
1
5
10
50
100 500 1000 5000 10K 50K 100K
Etruscan
1 Q R ÷ ; \¬ \ì ¡ Ä
Greek – archaic
1 Â È Á
Greek acrophonic
1 b c d e f g h
Greek –Argos/Nemea
•
ó d\ Ü
g
Greek – Epidaurus
•
2
Ü
g
Greek – Olynthus
1
g
á
¥
Lycian
1 < ó Ð 1Ò
Roman
1 P R S\ U W Y\ ,
. ½ ~
Roman multiplicative
1 P R S U W a
d e g
Arabico-Hispanic
Ø Ù Ú Û Ý
Calendar numerals
A E J
South Arabian
1 ! @ # $
À
b
i j
%
throughout the Republic and even later. The Etruscan alphabet, developed in the early seventh century bc on the model of the archaic Euboean Greek alphabet, usually runs from right to left (Bonfante 1996). The Etruscan lexical numerals were probably base-10 with a special term for 20, zathrum (but not for 40, 60, 80 ...), and it appears that subtractive structures formed the words for 17 through 19 (Lejeune 1981; Bonfante 1990: 22). However, these irregularities are not reproduced in the Etruscan numerical notation system, shown in Table 4.2. Table 4.2. Etruscan numerals 1
5
10
50
100
500
1000
5000 10,000
1 Q R :\ ÷\ ;\ VaU U î ¬ ì /\ ¡ 1378 = aaaQRR÷;;;ì
Ä ?\
Italic Systems
95
This system is cumulative-additive with a base of 10 and a sub-base of 5, very much like the Roman numerals, but is most often written from right to left, with the highest values at the right side of the numeral-phrase. Each power-sign of the primary base (10) may be repeated up to four times, but the half-decade values may occur only once in any numeral-phrase. The numeral-signs for 1, 5, 10, and 50 are quite regular throughout the system’s history. The sign ; for 100, though rarer, is found in many inscriptions from a relatively early date; the use of C is seen by Keyser (1988: 542) as a development occurring between 250 and 200 bc. It may be that C = 100 arose first in Latin inscriptions and found its way into Etruscan only when the Etruscan system was already declining. The signs for 1000 and 10,000 are encountered only rarely (Keyser 1988, Bonfante 1990). The signs for 500 and 5000 are unattested, but because the numeral-signs 5 and 50 are the bottom halves of the signs for 10 and 100, we would expect this same graphic principle to be followed (Buonamici 1932: 244; Keyser 1988: 544–545). This theory is given some support in that the earliest Roman sign for 500 is X (later to become W). Furthermore, two Etruscan inscriptions contain an unidentified sign ¬ that might have had such a value (Keyser 1988: 545). A special sign, í, is used primarily on coins to indicate ½ (Bonfante 1990: 48). While the Etruscan script is attested from around 700 bc, there is no evidence of Etruscan numerals until the late sixth century bc. Their invention may have been entirely independent of other base-10, cumulative-additive systems used around the Mediterranean in the early first millennium bc. No earlier system used a mixed base of 5 and 10, and most of the numeral-signs can be derived from successive crossings and circlings of tally marks for 1, 5, and 10. The most common sign for 100 is simply 10 with a vertical line through it, while 50 is made by drawing a straight line from the apex of the “upside-down V” 5-sign (Keyser 1988: 533). This theory is closely allied to Zangemeister’s (1887) theory regarding the origin of Roman numerals. Tallying practices in which numbers were marked sequentially, then crossed off as appropriate, could thus have led to a numerical notation system. However, because tally sticks are normally wooden, no evidence survives that the Etruscans ever used tallies in such a manner. Alternatively, the Etruscan numerals may be descended from the Mycenaean Linear B system (Chapter 2). Peruzzi (1980) argues that Mycenaean Greece influenced some aspects of Etruscan culture but does not discuss the numerical evidence. Mycenaean settlements have been found in southern Italy and Sicily, though these are too early to have had much direct cultural contact with the Etruscans. Keyser (1988: 542–543) notes that the Aegean systems, like Etruscan, use strokes to represent the lower powers of the base and strokes in conjunction with circles for higher powers. Unfortunately for this theory, 100 is ; in Etruscan but æ in Linear B. The similarity between Etruscan Ä and
96
Numerical Notation
Linear B ô for 10,000 is notable, but it is the only numeral-sign to be relatively close in form and value in both systems, other than their historically meaningless use of a vertical stroke for 1. I think it likely that the Etruscan system arose relatively independently of other systems, but with some continuity or influence from Linear B numerals. Base-10, cumulative-additive systems abounded in the Mediterranean between 1100 and 650 bc – the Egyptian hieroglyphic system, the Aramaic and Phoenician systems, the Hittite hieroglyphic numerals, the Cypriote numerals, and any remnants of the Linear B numerals. Regardless, the invention of a mixed base of 5 and 10 is an important development, and the use of halved signs for the sub-base of 5 is an ingenious means of deriving sign-values, suggesting that whatever system(s) the Etruscans knew, their numeral-signs are of their own invention. The early history of the Etruscan numerals is, in essence, a shared history with that of the Greek acrophonic numerals to be described later. While the numeralsigns of the mature systems are quite different, they are structurally identical. The ancestral role of the Greek scripts with respect to Etruscan is now very widely accepted, and many other aspects of Etruscan culture owed much to contact with Greek traders. Many early Greek numerals are found in the late sixth century bc in south Italy in the context of contact with the Etruscans (Johnston 1975: 362–364; Johnston 1979: 31). Yet it is impossible to assign chronological priority to one or the other. Instead, we might recognize a single ancestral system in the late sixth century bc, which later diverged into Greek and Etruscan variants. The Etruscan system is, however, the direct ancestor of the Roman numerals (Rix 1969, Keyser 1988). Etruria was politically dominant over Rome throughout its early history and remained a potent force in Roman culture well into the Republican period. Similarly, several Indo-European languages of the Italian peninsula, including Oscan, Umbrian, and Faliscan, adopted scripts and numerical notation systems based on an Etruscan model; their numerals are essentially identical to the Etruscan numerals. Etruscan numerals were used in a wide variety of contexts. Out of nearly 10,000 Etruscan inscriptions known to Kharsekin (1967), about 200 contain numerical notation, while only 40 contain the (as yet poorly understood) Etruscan lexical numerals. Numeral-signs were often used on funerary inscriptions to indicate the age of the deceased; other inscriptions on stone make use of numerical notation, but more rarely. From the fifth century bc onward, Etruscan coins were stamped with the numeral-signs for ½, 1, 5, 10, 50, and 100 in various combinations. As well, many graffiti inscribed on potsherds contain Etruscan numerals. These graffiti often recorded the quantity or value of goods in containers. A lead tablet whose purpose has not been reliably established contains the numeral-signs for 1000 and 10,000 (Keyser 1988: 544, Fig. 9).
Italic Systems
97
Figure 4.1. The Etruscan “abacus-gem” (CII 2578 ter) showing a figure seated at a board working with Etruscan numerals. Source: Fabretti 1867: 224.
Figure 4.1 depicts the so-called Etruscan cameo or abacus-gem (CII 2578 ter), a small gem (1.5 cm high) dating from the fifth century bc that depicts a seated individual working at a large board upon which rows of Etruscan numerals have been inscribed, including the elusive signs for 1000 and 10,000, but not 500 or 5000 (Fabretti 1867: 224; Keyser 1988: 545). This demonstrates the association of the numerals with pebble-board computation at an early date. Similarly, Etruscan numerals may have been used on wooden tallies and similar perishable materials, despite the lack of evidence for such a function. There is no evidence, however, for the use of the Etruscan system for performing arithmetical calculations as we would (on papyrus or slate). Computations would have been done in the head, with the fingers, or on a counting board. Large numbers and long numeral-phrases are very rarely encountered; even the sign for 100 is relatively uncommon. The demise of the Etruscan numerical notation system was a direct consequence of the rising fortunes of the Roman republic. The lack of Etruscan political unity in the third century bc, coupled with the political advantages of association with Rome, led to the slow but steady assimilation of the cities of Etruria into the Roman political and cultural milieu. While the Etruscans remained a culturally
Numerical Notation
98
Table 4.3. Post-Etruscan tally numerals 1 5
10
50
100
500
1000
1 Q P\U R O A ÷ Õ õ ; « ì ¾ ø Z û ð distinct people at least until the beginning of the Roman Empire, by 100 bc they were entirely within the Roman political sphere. This inevitable trend was accompanied by the slow replacement of the Etruscan language, script, and numerical notation with those of the Romans. Given the similarity of the two numerical notation systems, there would have been little difficulty in making the change to the new system. The last certainly dated examples of Etruscan numerical notation are from the second century bc. However, A. P. Ninni (1888–89) first presented the theory that the Etruscan numerals survived into the nineteenth century. While studying the tally marks used by fishers along the coast of the Adriatic Sea, near the town of Chioggia (near Venice), Ninni discovered a numerical notation system that he called cifre chioggiotte (numerals of Chioggia). This potential vestige is cumulative-additive, with a mixed base of 5 and 10, like both the Roman and Etruscan systems. Its numeralsigns are shown in Table 4.3 (Ninni 1888–89: 680). Ninni noted that the signs of the cifre chioggiotte more closely resemble the Etruscan numerals than the Roman numerals, and on this basis proposed that they were of ancient origin. Furthermore, in both the Etruscan system and the cifre chioggiotte, several of the sub-base numeral-signs are halved versions of the signs for powers of ten (Ninni 1888–89: 680–681). Could this system in fact be a survival, over 2,000 years, of an Etruscan tradition among modern fishers? At present, there is simply not enough surviving data to speculate on the possibility of such longterm cultural survivals, particularly in a region, such as Italy, that has experienced immense social change over two millennia. On the one hand, certain signs of the cifre chioggiotte (e.g., the first signs in Table 4.3 for 50 and 100) are identical to the Etruscan numeral-signs for those numbers, but are quite dissimilar to the intervening Roman numerals. On the other hand, Chioggia is not in modern Tuscany, and there is no evidence that the systems’ users believed the cifre chioggiotte to be ancient. Since no information has come to light for over a century, perhaps we have lost our opportunity to learn more about this system.
Greek Acrophonic Between 750 and 500 bc, what we now call archaic Greece was a conglomeration of small city-states in mainland Greece, the Aegean islands (including Crete), the southern half of the Italic peninsula (known as Magna Graecia), and western Asia
Italic Systems
99
Table 4.4. Greek acrophonic numerals 1 5
10
50 100
500 1000
5000 10,000
50,000
1 b
c
d e
f g
h
j
ΠΕΝΤΕ ΔΕΚΑ
ΗΕΚΑΤΟΝ
ΧΙΛΙΟ∑
i ΜΥΡΙΟ∑
36,849 = iiihgfeeeccccbaaaa
Minor, sharing in common only the use of Greek dialects. A tremendous number of local scripts, known as epichoric scripts (from Greek epi-, upon, over, and chora, place, country), were used during this period, all of which were based on the model of the Phoenician consonantary around 800 bc. In their earliest phases, some of these alphabets were written from right to left or in alternating directions (boustrophedon), although by around 500 bc all the epichoric scripts were written from left to right. Adjoining these scripts were two very distinct types of numerical notation: the acrophonic, to be described here, and the cipheredadditive alphabetic numerals (Chapter 5). For our present state of knowledge of these two systems, we are greatly indebted to the tireless and unparalleled work of Marcus Niebuhr Tod.1 The acrophonic system as used in classical Athens is shown in Table 4.4 (Tod 1911–12: 100–101). The system is cumulative-additive, uses vertical strokes for units, has a base of 10 with a sub-base of 5, and is always written from left to right, with numeralphrases in descending order of numeral-sign value. The acrophonic system is so named because the signs for many numbers are taken from the first letter (akros = highest, outermost; phone = sound) of the corresponding (classical) Greek word. Other names for this system, now largely rejected, include “Herodianic” and “decimal” (Tod 1911–12: 125–127). The signs for 50, 500, 5000, and 50,000 combine the sign for 5 with the sign for the appropriate power of 10. Whether we choose to see these sub-base signs as single signs or as two ligatured multiplicative ones is largely a matter of definition, and does not substantially affect how we classify the entire system. Similar acrophonic signs were used in large portions of the Hellenic world, the only difference being that the appropriate letters from each epichoric script were used in place of the letters used in the Attic inscriptions. Dow (1952) notes that the variety of acrophonic Greek numerical notation systems stands in sharp contrast to the Greek alphabetic system (Chapter 5), which is remarkably consistent 1
Tod’s six papers on Greek numerical notation (Tod 1911–12, 1913, 1926–27, 1936–37, 1950, 1954) have been reprinted in one volume (Tod 1979). My citations are taken from the original papers.
Numerical Notation
100
Table 4.5. Non-acrophonic archaic Greek numerals 1
5
10
50
100
a
Â
È
Á
À
throughout its geographic and temporal range. This degree of variation among local systems is far greater than the variety of lexical numerals used in the Greek dialects. However, the differences in sign-forms were probably not great enough to affect their comprehensibility (Tod 1936–37: 246). For expressing monetary values, the acrophonic numerals were often modified to reflect the forms of currency being expressed; for example, in Attica, £ (talanton = 1 talent = 6,000 drachmas), Z (mna = 1 mina = 100 drachmas), Σ (1 stater), ¢ (1 drachma), I (1 obol), Ã (1/2 obol), » or £ (1/4 obol), and R (1/8 obol) (Threatte 1980: 111). These could sometimes be ligatured to the sign for 5, just as the ordinary acrophonic powers of 10, to express multiples of units of currency. While there is some potential for confusion (£ can mean 1 talent or ¼ obol; Z can mean 1 mina or the numeral 10,000, etc.), numeral-signs are always listed in descending order, which averts most ambiguities. In some regions, special signs were used to indicate monetary values that did not fit easily into the standard system. For instance, a system found in inscriptions from Thespiae (in Boeotia) uses numeral-signs for 30 and 300, which consist of a sign £ (for triobole, or 3 obols) ligatured to the appropriate sign for 10 or 100 (Tod 1911–12: 109; Feyel 1937). Other acrophonic subsystems used cumulative signs related to systems of weight or volume, such as those described by Lawall (2000) on graffiti from the Athenian Agora from the last quarter of the fifth century bc; for example, EEEE = 4 hemichoes. Despite the name of the system, not all numeral-signs used in the Greek epichoric scripts are acrophonic, and in fact the earliest ones are nonacrophonic. Johnston (1975, 1979, 1982) has found several instances of a very early Greek cumulative-additive but nonacrophonic system with a mixed base of 5 and 10 dating from the sixth and fifth centuries bc. The signs of the system are shown in Table 4.5 (cf. Johnston 1979: 29–30; Johnston 1982: 208). Johnston argues that this system was built up systematically by cumulatively adding oblique lines to a vertical stroke to obtain higher numeral-signs. Curiously, he does not note that the signs for the sub-base (5 and 50) are the right halves of the appropriate primary bases (10 and 100). This structure parallels the halving of Etruscan numeral-signs, which is notable because many of the examples of this “pre-acrophonic” system are of South Italian provenance. Johnston (2006: 17) notes several sixth-century Greek inscribed vases where X = 10, paralleling the Etruscan practice but in contrast with later Greek acrophonic practice. A very unusual numerical notation system used only to express monetary values is found in five fourth-century bc inscriptions from the Greek colony of Cyrene
Italic Systems
101
Table 4.6. Cyrenaic numerals 20,000 10,000 5000 1000 500 100
¿
ƒ
Z
í
20
b 2 R
4
2
1
1/5 1/10 1/50
¿ ƒ Z í 2 c
(in modern Libya). These numeral-signs are nonacrophonic, and their interpretation is controversial (Tod 1926–27, Oliverio 1933, Tod 1936–37, Gasperini 1986). Our best evidence comes from the temple of Demeter at Cyrene, where inscriptions list the prices of various goods and the temple’s revenues and expenditures (Tod 1936–37: 255). They present a dual series of figures in which each numeralsign has both a higher and lower value; the specific amount must be inferred from the context within the numeral-phrase. Normally the higher is 5000 times the value of the lower, but this breaks down for some of the lower signs. The relative values of different units of currency used in Cyrene during this period (drachmas, staters, minas, and talents, where 1 talent = 50 minas = 1250 staters = 5000 drachmas) help explain its unusual structure. The interpretation presented by Oliverio, Tod, and Gasperini is derived from an analysis of the maximum number of times each sign is repeated (and is thus open to question if more inscriptions are found). This system is shown in Table 4.6.2 Still another aberrant acrophonic system is found in fourth-century bc inscriptions from Olynthus (in the northern Chalcidice region). There, a system was used that is nonacrophonic and lacks a sub-base of 5 (Tod 1936–37: 248–249; Graham 1969). The signs for 10, 100, and 1000 (R, á, and ¥, respectively) are the last three letters of the western Greek alphabet used in the region. Of course, R = 10 is common to the Roman and Etruscan systems as well.3 On this basis, Graham (1969: 356) argues that the Roman/Etruscan system was borrowed from the Chalcidian colony at Cumae (in southern Italy). This theory, while attractive, has several flaws, many of which derive from Mommsen’s (1965 [1909]) flawed “lost-letter” theory of the Roman numerals discussed later. Moreover, the fourth-century bc numeral-signs of Olynthus cannot have spread to the sixth-century bc Etruscans by means of a colony at Cumae that never used the numeral-signs in question. I suspect that the Greek letters were borrowed for the higher powers, just as the Romans began with nonalphabetic numeral-signs, but later modified their signs into alphabetic ones for mnemonic purposes. 2
3
The numbers listed are amounts in drachmas, based on the assumption that the lower Z sign represents one drachma, without which the absolute value of each sign would be indeterminate. No significance should be attributed to the fact that the sign _, a common Roman numeral-sign for 1000, is rotated ninety degrees from the Olynthian sign á for 100.
Numerical Notation
102
Table 4.7. Epichoric Greek numerals System
1
5
10
Standard Acrophonic
1 1 • •
b
c d None g 2 None ó\\« d\\b
Olynthus Epidaurus Argos and Nemea
None None None
50
100
500
1000
e á Ü Ü
f
g ¥ g g
None None None
A similar system was used in Epidaurus, on the southern Greek mainland (Tod 1911–12: 103–104). It is acrophonic for 100 and 1000 but not for the lower powers. Nearby, in Argos and Nemea, a closely related system was used that apparently had a sign for 50, but not for 5 (Tod 1911–12: 102–103; Ifrah 1985: 235). The systems of Epidaurus and Argos, alone among the Italic numerical notation systems, use a dot rather than a vertical stroke for 1. Table 4.7 compares the numeral-signs of these irregular systems to the standard acrophonic system. Most scholars explicitly or implicitly assume that the acrophonic system was invented independently of the Roman, Phoenician, and other systems used at the time (e.g., Ste. Croix 1956: 52). Because of the use of the acrophonic principle, the numeral-signs are often Greek letters, which makes reconstructing the history of the system rather difficult. It could be argued that the acrophonic nature of the system suggests that it could only have been invented in Greece. Yet like the Roman numerals, the earliest Greek acrophonic numerals are not phonetic signs at all, which provides crucial evidence allowing us to reconstruct their origin. While the traditional and widely quoted dates given for the use of the acrophonic system in Athens are 454 to 95 bc (Heath 1921: 30), there is indisputable evidence of an earlier origin for the system. Tod argues, solely on logical grounds, that a seventh-century bc origin is not unreasonable, as the system was fully developed by the middle of the fifth century bc (Tod 1911–12: 128). Mabel Lang mentions a seventh-century bc decorated Greek amphora inscribed with three vertical strokes, but this does not prove that the numeral was part of the acrophonic system; it might have been part of an unstructured tallying system or almost any numerical notation system in use in the Aegean at the time (Lang 1956: 3). For the second half of the sixth century bc, however, there is more promising evidence of the acrophonic system. Johnston (1979: 27–29) discusses three different variations of the “pre-acrophonic” system mentioned earlier, used in the sixth century bc in southern Italy, Sicily, western Asia Minor, the Aegean islands, and various parts of mainland Greece – almost the entirety of Greek civilization during that period. Several vases from southern Italy and Sicily, which Johnston dates to the last quarter of the sixth century bc, bear marks used in commercial transactions
Italic Systems
103
( Johnston 1975, 1979, 1982). It is telling that so many variations of the acrophonic system were used in the fifth and fourth centuries bc, suggesting an initial period of experimentation followed by consolidation and agreement on a single form of the numerals. The Greek acrophonic numerals likely originated on the Italian peninsula around 575–550 bc, around the same time and in similar contexts as the Etruscan system. As I accept Keyser’s (1988) contention that the Etruscan numerals developed relatively independently as an outgrowth of tally marks, the obvious conclusion is that the Greek system developed on the model of the Etruscan numerals in southern Italy and Sicily, an area of considerable Greco-Etruscan commercial and cultural contact. It is difficult to believe that two cumulative-additive, quinary/ decimal numerical notation systems developed on the Italian peninsula in the second half of the sixth century bc independently of one another. Yet because the Etruscans owe their script to contact with the Greeks, it is counterintuitive to think of the transmission of numerals moving in the opposite direction. In any event, separating out questions of chronological priority of the two systems is virtually impossible. There may also have been some influence from the Phoenicians, who were in contact with both the Greeks and the Etruscans in the sixth century bc. In at least one document, tablet V from Entella in west central Sicily, the early acrophonic numerals for 10, 50, and 100 were written with the smallest numbers on the left and ascending to the right – perhaps in emulation of the right-to-left direction of the Phoenician system (Nenci 1995). The Phoenician system, however, has a special sign for 20, is a hybrid multiplicative system above 100, and does not have a sign for 50 at all. In the early classical period, acrophonic numerals were used in Asia Minor, the Aegean islands, North Africa, southern Italy, and Sicily, in addition to mainland Greece, but their spread to the non-Greek world was relatively limited. The Lycians of southern Asia Minor used a nonacrophonic numerical notation system in the late fifth and fourth centuries bc that is probably an epichoric variant of the acrophonic system, although their language was not Greek (see the following discussion). The enormous cultural debt of Lycia to classical Greece is beyond doubt, and its geographic and temporal proximity strengthens this hypothesis. Also likely is the possibility that the South Arabian numerals, which arose in the fifth century bc, derive from the acrophonic system. The South Arabian numerals are cumulativeadditive, base-10 with a sub-base of 5, and use acrophonic numeral-signs. However, more evidence of cultural contact is desirable before this hypothesis can be proven. Acrophonic numerals are found on inscriptions on stone, lead, and silver as well as on potsherds; they may also have been used on wood or other perishable materials, though evidence is lacking. Of the thousands of Greek papyri from
104
Numerical Notation
the fourth century bc onward, only a handful from Saqqara contain acrophonic numerals (Turner 1975). Inscriptions on stone use acrophonic numerals far more frequently, including accounts, inventories, lists, regulations, treaties, and boundary markers. As well, graffiti or other marks on pottery often indicate quantities for commercial purposes. The acrophonic numerals expressed measures of volume or distance, quantities of goods, or monetary values. What is notable is the wide range of purposes for which acrophonic numerals were not used, even compared to other cumulative-additive systems used in the Mediterranean in antiquity. Firstly, the numerals could only be used to express cardinal numbers; ordinal numbers were expressed using lexical numerals or, when available, alphabetic numerals (Tod 1911: 128). Similarly, with the exception of monetary amounts, there was no acrophonic numeral expression for fractions. The Greeks never expressed dates in acrophonic numerals. The practice of expressing the age of the deceased at death on funerary inscriptions, a source of much information on other numerical notation systems, was not customary in Greece. The custom of dating using regnal years did not arise until the Alexandrine period. Documents in connected prose (decrees, for instance) rarely contain acrophonic numerals, except to indicate the price of executing the inscription (Threatte 1980: 112). There is no evidence that the acrophonic numerals were used direcly for arithmetic or accounting. For these purposes, as with the Roman and Etruscan systems, the Greek acrophonic system was complemented by the use of the pebble-board abacus, in which several grooves were labeled with the appropriate acrophonic numerals. Lang (1957) has established that many of the mathematical errors made by Herodotos demonstrate his use of the abacus to perform calculations, with which certain types of errors (especially in multiplication and division) can occur easily. All of the thirteen examples of abaci (and fragments thereof ) known from classical Greece have the row values inscribed with acrophonic numerals (Lang 1957: 275–276). Most notable among these abaci is the remarkably well-preserved “Salamis tablet,” which probably dates from the fifth century bc (Menninger 1969: 299–303). The numerals on it range from T (one talent) to X (1/8 obol); the monetary values of the numeral-signs suggest that it was used for practical commercial computations. The decline of the acrophonic system is thoroughly entwined with the fate of the Athenian state as a Greek power. As Athens ceased to be a dominant power in Mediterranean affairs, acrophonic numerals were used less often; by the third century bc, they had been supplanted by the alphabetic numerals for most purposes throughout large parts of the Hellenistic world, including Ptolemaic Egypt and Seleucid Persia. Only in Athens and the surrounding areas did the acrophonic system continue to flourish. There are only a handful of known first-century bc
Italic Systems
105
examples from Athens (Threatte 1980: 113). By this time, Greece was firmly under Roman control. Yet there is no evidence that the acrophonic system was replaced by Roman numerals except, as one might expect, in southern Italy, where Latinspeaking populations dominated. However, the use of acrophonic numerals did continue in one very limited domain – stichometry, or the enumeration of lines of verse in classical texts (Tod 1911–12: 129–130). This practice continued as late as the third century ad with the writings of the Neoplatonist philosopher Iamblichus. Such late examples are analogous to the use of Roman numerals in the modern West, in contexts in which it is very useful to have two separate numerical notation systems – for paginating introductory sections versus the body of a work, or for distinguishing volume numbers from page numbers in certain texts.
Lycian Lycia was a small state of southern Asia Minor in the middle of the first millennium bc, centered around the city of Xanthus. The Lycians spoke an incompletely understood Indo-European language related to the earlier Luwian language, which was spoken in the Neo-Hittite kingdoms of Asia Minor. Lycia occupied an intermediate position between the Greek and Persian spheres of influence, and was intimately involved in interregional commerce and conflict. The Lycian alphabet, which was developed around 500 bc, is an epichoric variant of the Greek script, like many others used in the Greek peninsula and western Asia Minor, except that the language of the inscriptions was not a Greek dialect. A few hundred instances of the Lycian script have survived, mostly from inscriptions on stone and on coins; they are written almost exclusively from left to right and date from the fifth and fourth centuries bc. The Lycian numerical notation system is still very poorly understood. The Lycian system, like the Greek acrophonic, Etruscan, and Roman systems, is cumulative-additive with a base of 10 and a sub-base of 5. However, the exact values of the numeral-signs are still in debate. The signs of this system are shown in Table 4.8 (cf. Shafer 1950, Bryce 1976). There is also a sign, 2, that probably represents ½, although Shafer (1950: 260) argues that it may represent an additional one-half of any numeral-sign that precedes it; ó2 would be 15 and <2 would be 7½ according to this theory. The numeral-signs for 50 and 100 are found only on a few inscriptions. The value 50 is assigned to Ð primarily by default; its value is certainly between 10 and 100 (it is found after 1Ò but before ó). I follow Frei (1976: 15) in assigning it the value of 50. We can be fairly certain about the value of the sign for 100, because it is found in the Lycian portion of a trilingual Greek-Lycian-Aramaic inscription found at Letoon and dating from 358 bc (Frei 1976: 13–15). Shafer (1950: 258–259) suggests,
Numerical Notation
106 Table 4.8. Lycian numerals 1
1
5
< 127 = 1Òóó<11
10
50
100
ó
Ð
1Ò
based on one inscription, that the Lycians may have used the subtractive principle to express the number 4 as a<. However, in other inscriptions, 4 is expressed as aaaa. The Lycian numerals are very likely a previously unidentified variant of the Greek cumulative-additive systems. Lycian numerals arise in the early fifth century bc at the time of the peak use of the Greek acrophonic numerals in Athens and throughout the Hellenic world. Both systems were cumulative-additive, had a base of 10 with a sub-base of 5, and were used in the fifth century bc in the Aegean region. While the Lycian numerals are not acrophonic, this is true of many of the epichoric numerical notation systems of the classical Greek world. Alternatively, the Lycian system may have been based on an Aramaic model, with the sign for 100 (1Ò) being in fact multiplicative (1 × 100) rather than constituting a single numeral-sign (Frei 1976, 1977). No numbers higher than 120 are expressed in any Lycian inscriptions, so we do not know whether, for instance, the Lycian numeral-phrase for 200 was additive (1Ò\ 1Ò) or multiplicative (11Ò). Because none of the Semitic systems had separate signs for 50, but all of them had signs for 20, we would need to modify the value of the Lycian Ð to 20, which is consistent with the numeral-phrases known from inscriptions. There is little similarity, however, between the numeral-signs of Lycian and either Phoenician or Aramaic, and the Lycian system uses a sign for 5, which is very rare in Aramaic. As well, Lycian, like the acrophonic numerals, is written from left to right, whereas the Levantine systems are all written from right to left. The Lycian numerical notation system apparently did not diffuse outside Lycia. Although Shafer (1950) argues that the similarities between the Roman and Lycian numerals are sufficient to indicate the derivation of the former from the latter, this likeness is no greater than that between Lycian and the Greek acrophonic system. Furthermore, while there is some similarity between the Lycian numeral-signs and other systems of the Italic phylogeny (especially South Arabian), these similarities do not correspond to any plausible circumstances of cultural contact. In Asia Minor, scripts such as Phrygian and Lydian, both of which are closely related to Lycian and were used in the fifth and fourth centuries bc, used numerical notation based on the Phoenician-Aramaic model rather than on the Greek or Lycian. Lycian numerals are found primarily in a single context – sepulchral epitaphs indicating monetary amounts, normally including a numeral-phrase preceded by the word ada, now considered to be a monetary unit (Bryce 1976: 175). The
Italic Systems
107
monetary values may have stipulated a penalty to be paid should the tomb in question be violated (Shafer 1950), or they may indicate fees paid in advance by the family for a tomb site (Bryce 1976). The only nonfunereal context in which Lycian numerals are used is the trilingual inscription found at Letoon, a public legal regulation (Frei 1976). As Lycian numerals are not found on coins or on financial inscriptions, they are quite distinct from the numerals of the rest of Asia Minor and the Aegean. As the Lycians became increasingly caught up in imperial conflicts between the Persians and the Greeks, their script was used increasingly infrequently. By 300 bc, the Lycian script had assimilated to the Greek, and its numerical notation ceased to be used, replaced by the Greek alphabetic numerals.
South Arabian The Old South Arabian scripts are of a very ancient origin, first appearing around the turn of the first millennium bc in the southern part of the Arabian peninsula (modern Yemen). They are consonantal and are characterized by large, well-formed letters and by their extremely varied direction of writing (left-to-right, right-to-left, or boustrophedon, depending on the inscription). They were used to write South Semitic languages such as Minaean, Sabaean, Qatabanian, and Hadramauti. During their early history, these scripts did not possess any numerical notation system, but following the rise of the kingdoms of Minaea and Saba in the fifth century bc, numerical notation began to be used in monumental inscriptions. The numeralsigns used are shown in Table 4.9, including both left-to-right and right-to-left sign forms, where appropriate (Halévy 1873: 511–512; Hommel 1893: 8). The system is cumulative-additive, with a base of 10 and a sub-base of 5, and is written in whichever script direction is used in the inscription as a whole. The sign for 1 is, as in all Italic systems, purely iconic. The signs for 5, 10, 100, and 1000, however, are acrophonic; each is simply the first letter of the appropriate South Arabian lexical numeral (Beeston 1984: 8). The sign for 50 is non-acrophonic, but is simply a halved version of the sign for 100. In one inscription (Biella 1982: 531), the sign X is apparently used with the numerical value 4, possibly in imitation of the Nabataean system (Chapter 3). There are no signs for 500 or 5000 known from any South Arabian inscriptions; these numbers were written with five signs for 100 and 1000, respectively (Biella 1982: 1, 265). Normally, numeral-phrases were placed between large hatched bars to avoid confusing numeral-phrases with words, given the use of the acrophonic principle (Halévy 1875: 78). Large sets of unit-signs were not divided into smaller groups, which creates a legibility issue because the sub-base of 5 is not used throughout the system; one inscription from Sirwah denotes 12,000 using twelve signs for 1000 (Ifrah 1998: 187).
Numerical Notation
108
Table 4.9. South Arabian numerals 1
5
10
50
1 ! @ # Right to left 1 Ê @ Ë 3697 = Î\%%%$$$$$$#@@@@!11\Î (L-R) Î\11Ê@@@@ËÌÌÌÌÌÌÍÍÍ\Î (R-L)
Left to right
100
1000
$ Ì
% Í
In some inscriptions, the South Arabian numerals used an unusual technique of implied multiplication that resembles positional notation. Most often, this was done when expressing values greater than 10,000, by placing signs to the left of a sign for 1000 (when reading from left to right), which were implicitly taken to represent multiples of 1000. For instance, one inscription (R3943/2) has Î\@@@%\Î for 31,000, in which the three @ signs have the value of 10,000 instead of 10, while % retains its ordinary value of 1000 (Biella 1982: 349; Ifrah 1998: 187). Apparently this technique was also sometimes used for multiples of 100; Halévy (1875: 79) notes an inscription that has Î\111\Î instead of Î\$$$\Î for 300. We know that the multiplied value is correct because of contextual information and because South Arabian inscriptions commonly list the appropriate lexical numeral beside the numeral-phrase. Ifrah sees in this use of implied multiplication “what might be called the germ of our place-value notation” (Ifrah 1985: 232). However, without contextual information, such numeral-phrases would simply be confusing and ambiguous, as there is no sign for zero. These formations are very rarely attested throughout the system’s history. The South Arabian system is derived from the Greek acrophonic system (Ifrah 1998: 186; Fevrier 1948: 579). Both systems are decimal and cumulative-additive, and both have a sub-base of 5. Additionally, both systems use the acrophonic principle, a feature that is otherwise uncommon during this period. The numeral-signs are not similar to those of any other system, but this is unsurprising, since the system is acrophonic. In the fifth century bc, when the South Arabian numerals were first used, the Minaeans and Sabaeans were actively engaged in trade with the Greeks at a time when the acrophonic numerals were the only ones the Greeks were using for monetary and metrological purposes. While one would expect the South Arabian scripts to have numerical notation systems similar to those used in North Semitic scripts at the time (Aramaic or Phoenician), this is not borne out by comparing the systems. There is no sign for 20 in the South Arabian system, while the Aramaic and Phoenician systems did not normally use signs for 5 and 50. There is no evidence that the South Arabian numerals ever diffused outside the Arabian peninsula. The Ge’ez script used for the Ethiopic languages, which is
Italic Systems
109
derived from a South Arabian model, used numerals based on the Greek alphabetic system (Chapter 5). Although some South Arabian cursive inscriptions on wood have been found, these contain no numerals. The system just described is documented only in monumental contexts. The functions of the numerals included recording details of sacrifices or offerings to gods, quantities of booty obtained, numbers of military troops, and information on construction projects such as monuments and irrigation systems. The South Arabians did not use an enumerated dating system, nor do South Arabian coins contain numerical notation of any kind. By the second century bc, instances of the South Arabian numerals were normally preceded by the appropriate lexical numeral written out in full. While this aids modern scholars in their interpretation, doing so also removed any incentive to continue to use the system. By the first century bc, although the South Arabian scripts continued to be used, the numerical notation system had become extinct, and it was not replaced until the seventh century ad, when the Islamic conquest brought alphabetic and later positional numerals to southern Arabia.
Roman Despite the importance and continued use of Roman numerals, the early history of the system was very poorly understood until Keyser’s (1988) study. There are several different classical variants of the Roman numerals, while the sign forms and structure of the Roman numerals used today are medieval in origin. The Roman alphabet was developed on an Etruscan model around 600 bc at a time when much of Italy was under Etruscan political domination; it was written from left to right, as it is today. Like its Etruscan precursor, the Roman numerical notation system has a base of 10, with a sub-base of 5, and is essentially cumulativeadditive; unlike it, the Roman numerals are written from left to right and are sometimes used subtractively. The great variety of numeral-signs used throughout two millennia of its history contrasts strongly with the highly static quality of the equally long-lived Babylonian cuneiform and Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals. Table 4.10 presents the numeral-signs used during the republican period (Ifrah 1985: 132; Keyser 1988). These numerals were cumulative-additive in structure in most inscriptions. Only the signs for 1 and 10 remain unchanged throughout the entire history of the system. The “inverted V” sign for 5, Q, is found only in early contexts, and is evidence of the system’s indebtedness to its Etruscan ancestor, but P is used exclusively thereafter. The signs for 50 in Table 4.10 are roughly in chronological order; the “inverted arrow” forms are earliest, with the “inverted T” forms prevalent until about ad 25, and L most common thereafter (Gordon and Gordon 1957: 181).
Numerical Notation
110
Table 4.10. Roman numerals (republican period) 1
5
10
50
100
1
Q P\
R
õ\ V § U T \¸ S
500
X W
1000 5000 10,000 50,000 100,000
¤ , Y\\ ® _ \© ¦ | 19,494 = ¯®YYYYUUUUTRRRRaaaa 19,494 = ¯Y¯UXRUaP
.\ ¯
½
~\ °
There is no sign for 100 in any early Roman inscription although there surely must have been one to complete the series. The V form for 100 is extremely rare; Ifrah (1998: 188) lists only a single inscription where it is found. Keyser indicates that the first Roman C = 100 whose date is secure is from 186 bc, but he postulates a third-century bc origin for the symbol as a reduction of the Etruscan ;, even though there is no example of any sign for 100 at this early date (Keyser 1988: 542). The number 500 is expressed using X in all early contexts, with assimilation to the alphabetic D occurring around the transition to empire. The familiar M = 1000 used from the Middle Ages to the present occurs only in one classical Latin inscription as part of a numeral-phrase, although it is also found in various places where M is simply an abbreviation for mille or milia (Gordon and Gordon 1957: 181–182; Gordon 1983: 45). The signs for 5000, 10,000, 50,000, and 100,000 are rarely encountered, though they are all attested as early as the third century bc. Adding arcs on either side of the most common sign for 1000, Y, indicates successive powers of 10, while the right half of the appropriate base-10 sign represents the quinary component. In a very limited set of texts, ´ is used to represent 500,000 (Mommsen 1965 [1909]: 788–791; Gordon 1983: 45). The sign is probably derived from alphabetic Q and is thus an abbreviation of quingenta milia. Its use was limited to the later Republic, and it was certainly not familiar a century later to Pliny the Elder, who, in his Natural History, wrote “Non erat apud antiquos numerus ultra centum milia” or “Among the ancients there was no numeral larger than 100,000” (Natural History 33.47.133). Alongside the Roman numerals, the Romans had a duodecimal fractional system based on the as of twelve unciae (Menninger 1969: 158–162; Cagnat 1964: 33).
Italic Systems
111
There was very little regional variation in the signs or the structure of the classical Roman numerals (due, no doubt, to the centralization of the empire). In North African inscriptions, however, the signs for the sub-base were sometimes not used, for example, IIIII for 5 and XXXXXX for 60 (Cagnat 1964: 30–31). Similarly, the signs for C and L were often written cursively, even in inscriptions on stone, to distinguish them from the corresponding letters (Salama 1999). This practice of cursively writing Roman numerals on stone was also attested in Spanish inscriptions of the fifth and sixth centuries ad, borrowing the numeral forms used on much earlier Roman paypri written in Egypt (Mallon 1948). Starting in the late republican period, the subtractive principle was occasionally used for writing multiples of 4 or 9 (or rarely 8) of powers of 10. As would later become the rule with modern Roman numerals, placing a lower-valued power of 10 to the left of a higher numeral-sign indicated subtraction of the former from the latter (IX for 9, XL for 40, but never using sub-base signs as the subtrahend – i.e., VC is unacceptable for 95). This reduced the length of numeral-phrases – four or five numeral-signs were replaced by two. Similarly, in the Augustan period and into the early empire, the use of the subtractive XIIX and XXIIX for 18 and 28 were common, and IIX and XXC for 8 and 80 are also attested (Gordon and Gordon 1957: 176–181). Addition was used almost exclusively in the early republican period, and is the more usual form even in later classical inscriptions (Sandys 1919: 55–56).4 Subtractive numerals are more common where a numeral is at the end of a line of an inscription, allowing the engraver to avoid crowding many numeral-signs into a limited space (Cajori 1928: 31). They may be more common in informal texts than in formal inscriptions (Gordon and Gordon 1957: 180–181; Cagnat 1964: 30–31). Despite Guitel’s (1975: 202–203) denigration of subtractive notation because it lacks the simplicity of the pure additive principle, it is a very economical way of structuring numeral-signs. The Latin lexical numerals use the subtractive principle for 18 and 19 (duodeviginti, undeviginti), perhaps explaining the origin of this practice. Note, however, that while duodeviginti and undeviginti are subtractive, novem (VIIII/IX), quatuordecim (XIIII/XIV), nonaginta et novem (LXXXXVIIII/XCIX), and all other Latin lexical numerals are not. Around the same time, the multiplicative principle began to be employed to write very large numbers. Even as early as the third century bc, the Roman republic had become a large centralized state, and the need to express large numbers was acute, yet the highest numeral-sign was 100,000. At times, this led to extremely cumbersome numeral-phrases, such as the inscription on the famed Columna 4
In the tradition of modern Roman numeral hour-numbers on clocks, 4 is normally denoted additively (IIII), while 9 is denoted subtractively (IX), possibly because IIII aesthetically balances the left and right sides of the clock face (Hering 1939: 319).
112
Numerical Notation
rostrata of the consul Gaius Duilius, originally erected in Rome in 260 bc, which celebrated a naval victory over Carthage in which over two million aes worth of loot was plundered. The column is inscribed with at least twenty-two signs for 100,000, and possibly as many as thirty-two, as the inscription is fragmentary (Menninger 1969: 43–44). Although it was recut, probably in the Augustan period when other means of expressing this number were available, the original structure of the expression was retained (Stenhouse 2005: 59–60). One is struck, in looking at this inscription, at the sheer enormity of the numeral-phrase, and thus by the impressive amount of booty obtained, and in fact this may have had something to do with the reason it was written at all. Gordon and Gordon (1957: 180–181) suggest that one of the factors working against the widespread acceptance of subtractive notation was the desire of public officials to impress and indulge. This “conspicuous consumption of numerals” is cross-culturally frequent, for example, in the “Narmer macehead” (Chapter 2) and other royal commemorative inscriptions. Starting in the late republican period, a horizontal bar (vinculum or virgula) placed above a numeral-phrase or some portion thereof indicated that the number under the bar should be multiplied by 1000 (Smith 1926: 76–78; Gordon and Gordon 1957; Cagnat 1964: 31–32; Gordon 1983). This principle was first used in the Lex de Gallia Cisalpina written between 49 and 42 bc (Gordon 1983: 47). For most numbers, doing so did not improve conciseness; both gedddda\SROOO and °½....YSROOO for 191,063 require twelve symbols. The main advantage is that one need no longer remember so many numeral-signs or invent new ones; the signs for 1, 5, 10, 50, and 100 are sufficient to express any number up to 500,000, whereas eleven different signs would be needed under the purely additive system. One slight complexity is that starting around the same time, barred numerals were often used to distinguish ordinal from cardinal numbers, as in abbreviations such as aaVIR for duumvir (Gordon and Gordon 1957: 166–176). In one irregular inscription from Pompeii from the first century ad, the numeral-phrase LXXXX¦ apparently indicated 90,000 using a regular sign for 1000 multiplicatively, a practice not encountered again until the Middle Ages (Smith 1926: 7). Starting around the early Imperial period, three vertical bars enclosing a numeral-phrase on the top and sides signified multiplication by 100,000. Thus, instead of the thirty-two signs for 100,000 found on the Columna rostrata, one would need only to write mdddaan. This technique was first used in the late first century bc, according to Gordon (1983: 47), but was employed rather sparsely until the second century ad.5 In this way, any number less than 500 million could 5
According to Suetonius (Galba, 5), the emperor Tiberius willfully read the will of Livia in such a way as to read a three-barred numeral min as i in order to reduce by a factor of 100 the amount of inheritance owed to the future emperor, Galba (Cagnat 1964: 32).
Italic Systems
113
Table 4.11. Roman numerals (multiplicative) 1
Regular signs Multiplicative (1000)
5
10
50
100
500
1000
a
P
R
S
U
W
Y
1000
5000
10,000
50,000
100,000
500,000
1,000,000
a
b
d
e
g
j
k
100,000 500,000 1,000,000 5,000,000 10,000,000 50,000,000 100,000,000
Multiplicative (100,000)
man mbn mdn men 35,863,120 = mgggebaaan edaaa URR
mgn
mjn
mkn
be expressed with just the lowest numeral-signs plus two types of bar to express multiplication. This revised system is still a decimal system with a sub-base of 5; however, instead of being purely cumulative-additive, it is a hybrid system using cumulative-additive structuring for numbers up to 1000 and multiplicativeadditive thereafter. The entire system (up to 100,000,000) as used in the Imperial period is shown in Table 4.11. Gordon (1983: 47) claims that the largest number expressed using this hybrid cumulative and multiplicative system is 35,863,120, though an inscription at Ostia from ad 36 apparently indicates 100 million as mkn (Menninger 1969: 245). Most of the higher signs are attested only rarely. Curiously, Guitel (1975: 215) regards Roman multiplicative notation as an evolutionary dead end, because, she argues, they no longer needed to develop a more efficient positional system. The teleology of this argument is immediately apparent, as it regards this development only with respect to its failure to lead to a “superior” system. The Romans themselves likely perceived it as a means of improving conciseness, while reducing the number of signs one needed to memorize. Although the use of the 1000 “bar” continued among some post-Roman scribes, the use of the 100,000 “box” did not outlast the empire. While the origin of the Roman numerals is a common topic of inquiry, unfortunately, as Cajori (1928: 31) noted, “the imagination of historians has been unusually active in this field.” Fortunately, Keyser’s (1988) panoptic essay on the origin of the Roman numerals, which examines a variety of theories, ranging from the sixth-century theories of the grammarian Priscian to the twentieth-century theories of modern classicists, has firmly settled the issue. The popular belief that the Roman numerals originated as alphabetic signs is false. While the modern Roman numeral-signs are also letters, the signs I, V, and X mean 1, 5, and 10, rather than U, Q, and D, for unus, quinque, and decem. C is the first letter of centum, but this is coincidental, since C is a reduction of the older Etruscan sign ; or VaU (Keyser
Numerical Notation
114
Table 4.12. Etruscan and Roman numerals
Etruscan Roman
1
5
10
50
100
1 1
Q Q\P\
R R
÷\: U\\; õ\§\T U
500
1000
\¬ \X
ì\\\/ Y\\\¤
1988: 542). The signs for 50 and 500 were not associated with the letters L and D until the late Republic, and M was not used for 1000 until the Middle Ages. It is fortuitous that the older sign for 1000 (Y) could be easily transformed into an M. Similarly, theories employing the pictographic principle (for instance, I = 1 from a single finger; V = 5 from an outstretched hand, and X = 10 from two hands together) were proffered by many early modern antiquarians, and later by classicists such as Sandys (1919), but, while they are imaginative, there is no evidence to support them. Until recently, the most widely accepted theory was that of Theodor Mommsen (1965 [1909]), who argued that the signs for 50 (õ), 100 (U), and 1000 (Y) were taken from letters of the Chalcidic Greek alphabet that were not needed to transliterate the Latin language: chi, theta, and phi, respectively, which somewhat resemble the numeral-signs. Unfortunately, this attractive theory has several flaws: the sign for 100 does not really resemble the Chalcidic theta; these “lost letters” were sometimes used in Etruscan and Roman inscriptions; and special pleading is required to derive the origin of X = 500. While it was once plausible, it is no longer a parsimonious theory. In fact, the Roman numerals up to 1000 developed through direct diffusion from the Etruscans. The astonishing similarity between the Etruscan and archaic Roman numeral-signs, as shown in Table 4.12, ought to be enough to prove a relationship between the two systems. The Etruscan numerals have temporal priority over the Roman numerals, which do not appear until well into the fifth century bc, and are not frequently encountered until the third century bc. In fact, the similarities between the two systems are so great that one could treat them as a single numerical notation system; they are identically structured, and many of their numeral-signs are similar or identical. I treat them separately because the two systems are written in opposite directions and because the Roman system used signs for much larger powers at an early date. The Roman numerals were used in a broader range of contexts than any other cumulative-additive system. In its earliest forms, they were used on coins, on pottery, and on inscriptions on stone. Dates, monetary values, and measures were all frequently expressed in the Roman numerals. The Roman numerals could be employed to express both cardinal and ordinal values. Their use in administration and literature was widespread from the republican period onward. In texts, Roman numerals were used to enumerate page and line numbers. Accounts, inventories,
Italic Systems
115
and legal documents also occasionally provide us evidence of their use in commercial and institutional contexts. While Roman numerals certainly were used in the contexts of arithmetic and calculation, there is minimal evidence that they were ever used for calculation. Glautier (1972) discusses the Roman account records, which he characterizes as primitive from an accounting standpoint because of the lack of positionality. A similar point is raised by Meuret (1996) in his discussion of the Lamasba tablet, an irrigation regulation from North Africa during the reign of Elagabalus (218–222 ad), which contains a multiplication table to enable quick calculation of water supplies, thus overcoming the computational deficiencies of the system. Maher and Makowski (2001) demonstrate persuasively, however, that the assumption that Roman mathematics was poor because of Roman numerals cannot be correct, given the complexity of the arithmetical calculations attested in Latin texts. Nevertheless, their stronger claim – that Roman mathematicians actually used written numerals to do arithmetic, in particular for calculations involving fractions – remains unproven. Roman numerals were used for computational functions – if not directly for computation, then certainly to mark the rows on the abacus. While few Roman abaci survive, Taisbak claims that the Romans did all their calculations with them, and even that “the notation of Roman numerals originates from the abacus reckoning” (Taisbak 1965: 158). This finding is contradicted by the derivation of the Roman numerals from the Etruscan system and ultimately from an older tallying system. Because cumulative systems use one-to-one correspondence intraexponentially, just as one counter equals one multiple of a power on the abacus, the Roman techniques of numeration (Roman numerals) and computation (the abacus) complement one another. This correlation is confirmed by the quinary (base-5) component of the abacus (there are rows not only for the powers of 10 but also for their halvings). No row on the abacus ever would have contained more than four counters, which would have facilitated reading and working with them. However, because the original Etruscan system probably emerged from a system of tallying, it is more likely that the structure of the abacus emerged out of the structure of the numerals than vice versa. Despite the enormous influence of Roman civilization on Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East, and despite the extraordinary chronological duration of the Roman numerals (almost 2,500 years), they produced relatively few descendants. While other systems in use over similar periods, such as the Brāhmī numerals and Greek alphabetic numerals, changed their form greatly as they spread across time and space, the Roman numerals of antiquity spread largely unmodified throughout Western Europe and other areas where the Roman alphabet was used. While the Indian and Greek systems spread throughout many different scripts, changing
116
Numerical Notation
the forms of signs as they were transmitted, Roman numerals were infrequently adopted by users of other scripts. Of the few descendants of the Roman numerals, I have already discussed the hybrid multiplicative-additive system used occasionally from the first century bc onward. In the medieval period, Roman numerals were essentially the same as classical ones, though with slight differences in form and structure. In Arabinfluenced Spain, certain variant Roman numeral systems were used starting in the tenth century ad. Around the same time in northern Europe, certain types of medieval calendars contained unusual Roman numerals. Finally, as the Roman numerals came increasingly under assault from the rival Western system, certain positional variants of the numerals were occasionally used, combining features of both systems.
Computation with Roman Numerals The computational efficiency of the Roman numerals is a common subject in the history of mathematics. The consensus of these arguments, with which I am in general agreement, is that the Roman numerals are poorly suited to performing arithmetical calculations. This accords with the historical finding that people used abaci or finger computation to actually manipulate numbers, with the Roman numerals being used only to express the result. Yet the rejection of the efficiency of the Roman numerals for computation has been used to draw two unwarranted implications. Firstly, it is unlikely that the use of the Roman or other cumulative-additive numerals has any simple or unilinear correlation with developmental stages of psychology, as Murray (1978), Hallpike (1979), and Dehaene (1997) have suggested, either as the cause or effect of a less abstract way of thinking about number. Although many ancient numerical notation systems are cumulative-additive, this is not evidence that the Roman number concept is less abstract than the modern one. Other evidence, such as the use of abaci and finger reckoning, refutes any simple correlation between the cultural evolution of numerical notation and cognition. There may be some correlation, but it must be demonstrated, not assumed from the inefficiency of the Roman numerals for a task for which they were never intended. Secondly, some scholars claim that the Roman numerals prevented the Romans from developing other useful institutions or techniques. Glautier (1972) asserts that the Romans did not develop an efficient accounting system due to the lack of a suitable numerical notation system, while Williams (1995) bemoans the limitations of Roman numerals for doing the complex calculations with fractions needed for alloying coinage. Yet the Romans evidently had sufficient accounting techniques
Italic Systems
117
to administer their empire, and while double-entry bookkeeping is made easier by a ciphered-positional numerical notation system, it must have functional equivalents, or else no society lacking such numerals could administer a large political entity. The inferiority of Roman numerals is used by Guitel (1975) to explain why the Romans were poor mathematicians as compared to their Greek subjects. However, both Greek and Roman mathematicians relied considerably on Babylonian knowledge, and educated Romans knew the Greek alphabetic numerals. Maher and Makowski (2001) show that the Romans were, in fact, quite good at arithmetical computation. If, in fact, the Romans were poorer mathematicians than the Greeks, evidence other than their numerals must be sought. In contrast, a small body of research within the subdiscipline of the history of mathematics holds that the Roman numerals are not less efficient for computation than the Western numerals. At least four modern scholars claim to show how the Roman numerals could have been used in written calculations without the aid of an abacus or similar technology (Anderson 1956, Krenkel 1969, Detlefsen et al. 1975, Kennedy 1981). These analyses, apparently derived independently of one another, differ in the exact technique used in performing calculations, but all conclude that even if the Romans never used their numerals in such a fashion, the Roman numerals are in fact amenable to computational functions. While this is superficially true, I regard this argument as highly spurious. The proposed techniques are often more complicated than they are presented to be, and certainly more complicated than the standard arithmetical techniques using Western numerals. For instance, the technique proposed by Detlefsen and colleagues (1975) involves a complex “transformational grammar” that is far removed from the knowledge systems of Roman or medieval scholars. Additionally, none of these studies establishes that the Roman numerals are equally or more efficient for computation than Western or other numerals. A system’s minimal utility for a function is hardly proof that it was or should have been used for it. These studies presume that it is natural for numerals to be manipulated for computation, even in the absence of historical evidence. Anderson (1956: 145) suggests that “any reader, once he discovers how simple the operations are, will be inclined to imagine that some Roman engineers and surveyors, in building their great projects, did occasionally do their computations very much in the way described below, even though they left no records of their work.” Detlefsen and colleagues (1975: 147) go so far as to blame the Romans for not recognizing the computational potential of their numerals. While the possibility that the Roman numerals were used in this way cannot be ruled out, the argument ex silentio is highly implausible. We have persuasive evidence that ancient and medieval scholars used the abacus, finger computation, and other techniques (Lang 1957, Taisbak 1965, Murray 1978). The best way to counteract the denigration of the Roman numerals is not to show that they are
118
Numerical Notation
mildly (or even greatly) useful for a function for which they were never known to have been used. The issue is not simply a mathematical game to see whether a system can serve some arithmetical function. By understanding the functions for which the Roman numerals were not used, we may better understand the circumstances of their eventual replacement.
Medieval – Additive As early as the second century ad, but most prominently in the fifth and sixth centuries, Roman numerals inscribed on stone inscriptions frequently took on a cursive quality, and some signs became ligatured together (Gordon 1983: 46). A special sign for 6, ³, which is nothing more than a cursively written and ligatured vi or ui, occurs on many inscriptions from late antiquity (Lassère 2005: 57–59). On sixth-century Byzantine imperial coins, ³ was as common as VI (Wroth 1966: cx). The use of this sign probably ceased in the eighth century (Bischoff 1990: 176). Similarly, in late antique and early medieval inscriptions, 40, 60, and 500 could be written cursively, even in inscriptions on stone. The Visigothic script used between the seventh and thirteenth centuries was particularly characterized by these and other ligatured Roman numerals, particularly for 40 (XL) (Schapiro 1942, Bischoff 1990). These sporadic shifts toward ligatured notation would later play some role in the paleographic modification of Arabic signs into what would become the Western numerals (Lemay 1982: 393; see also Chapter 6, of this volume). Yet these ligatures did not represent an inexorable diachronic trend toward ciphering in Roman numerals, and the majority of early medieval Roman numerals remained cumulative-additive. After the fall of the western Roman Empire, literate knowledge was distributed rather sparsely – for instance, among Western monks, Byzantine bureaucrats, and Middle Eastern scholars. The great early medieval Mediterranean polities – the Byzantine Empire and the early Muslim caliphates – mainly used cipheredadditive numerical notation systems such as the Greek and Arabic alphabetic numerals (Chapter 5). In Western Europe during the Middle Ages, the Roman numerals were the only ones in common use. Knowledge of other systems was restricted to peripheral regions such as Spain and southern Italy, and to a tiny well-educated elite. Even at the height of the Carolingian Renaissance (around 800 ad), arithmetic was the province of a learned few, and was acquired late in the scholar’s education (Murray 1978). Still, while the need for large-scale bureaucracy and the corresponding need to express large numbers had declined since the height of the Roman Empire, Roman numerals were still frequently encountered, and even expanded in the range of functions they served. The medieval Roman numeral-signs differ from the classical ones in several aspects. Rather than being written solely in majuscule characters, Roman numerals
Italic Systems
119
were frequently written in the lowercase script on perishable materials. When written in minuscule form, placing a stroke through the last numeral-sign of a numeral-phrase indicated that one-half was to be subtracted from the represented value. As a measure against fraud, the last i in cursive numeral-phrases was often extended into a j, preventing anyone from adding additional signs to the end of the phrase (Menninger 1969: 285). This practice originated around ad 900 in South Italian manuscripts, although it may have had an antecedent in the upward rather than downward extension of phrase-final cursive i into I in a few classical texts (Smith 1926: 74). Alphabetic forms of the numerals for 500 (D) and 1000 (M) replaced the earlier X and _, marking the end point of a long process of alphabetization. This would have had the advantage of some mnemonic convenience; even if most of the numeral letters did not correspond to the numbers they represented, at least literate learners of the system would not need to learn an entirely new set of signs. Alphabetization of the numeral-signs also enabled one to use them for numerical riddles, particularly chronograms, in which the total value of the Roman numerals in a line of verse expressed the date of an event described in that verse (Menninger 1969: 281). The multiplicative vinculum bar for 1000 used in classical antiquity continued to be used under a new name, the titulus, but the three-sided box symbol for multiplying by 100,000 was no longer used (Menninger 1969: 281). Large numbers were very rarely needed, and even the need for the titulus was limited. Subtractive forms were used more frequently in the Middle Ages, though purely additive forms (e.g., IIII) were still common. Finally, starting in the tenth century, numeral-phrases for ordinal numbers were often adverbialized using superscript endings such as -o and -mo – for instance, Mmo CCmo Lmo IVto, incorporating aspects of the medieval Latin lexical numerals into numeral-phrases (Smith 1926: 75). Shipley (1902) suggests that the changing use of Roman numerals between classical antiquity and the ninth century ad led to transcription errors in medieval manuscripts. Comparing the fifth-century ad Codex Puteanus, containing sections of the works of Livy, and the ninth-century ad Codex Reginensis, a copy of the former, the analysis of copying errors reveals much about the Roman numerals used at the time of copying. Where the classical Roman form for 1000 was _, the medieval scribe was more accustomed to using Z, and thus _ was often transcribed as R. Where the classical manuscripts contained X for 500, medieval scribes used W, and thus often omitted the X symbols entirely on the theory that the horizontal stroke indicated that the scribe had crossed out an error. Finally, because the subtractive form XL for 40 was used in medieval times as opposed to RRRR, instances of RRRR were abbreviated to RRR to correspond to correct medieval numeral-phrases. Shipley’s analysis confirms the increased use of both subtractive structuring and alphabetic Roman numeral-signs.
120
Numerical Notation
The range of functions for which Roman numerals were used expanded considerably in the Middle Ages. Astronomical texts, which in antiquity were almost exclusively written using Greek numerals, often employed Roman numerals in the medieval era. As mentioned earlier, the alphabetizing of the signs for 500 and 1000 to D and M allowed the creation of number-riddles such as chronograms in which the numerical value of the Roman numerals in a phrase expressed the date of an event. Evidence for their use in legal documents and account records increases greatly, though this may be a function of the differential survival of perishable materials from later periods.
Medieval Modifications The replacement of the Roman numerals by the Western system was neither easy nor uncontested. Instead, between the twelfth and seventeenth centuries, there was great controversy throughout Western Europe regarding which system to use, with cultural, sociopolitical, and practical considerations being invoked in favor of one system or the other. Nor was the situation simply a choice between two options. While the general trend was toward the Western system in the great majority of contexts, as knowledge of the ciphered-positional system spread into Western Europe, a few individual writers made idiosyncratic modifications to the Roman numerals in response to the interloping newcomer. While none of these modifications was adopted on a wider scale, they can enlighten us about the circumstances under which the Roman numerals were replaced. The most complete positionalized version of the Roman numerals is one of the earliest. Around 1130, the mathematician “H. Ocreatus,” a student of Adelard of Bath, invented a positional numerical system using the Roman numeral-phrases for 1 through 9 (I, II, ... IX) along with a special sign (O or t, called cifra) to indicate an empty position (Smith and Karpinski 1911: 55; Burnett 1996, 2002c, 2006). This system is attested only in one thirteenth-century manuscript, a collection of arithmetical texts (Cashel, G.P.A. Bolton Library, Medieval MS 1), of which Ocreatus’s Helcep Sarracenicum (Saracen Calculation) is only one part. Positions were separated using a dot to avoid confusion; thus, 1089 was expressed as I.O.VIII.IX.6 This system, which blends the Roman cumulative-additive and Arabic ciphered-positional systems, is cumulative-positional and base-10 with a sub-base of 5. While Murray (1978: 167) characterizes Ocreatus’s system as clumsy, it should be noted that it is fully positional, far more so than later compromises 6
Smith (1926: 72) argues that this practice was attested in a few classical inscriptions as well, such as XII.L.D for 1,250,500 (!), but I know of no inscriptions where this was actually done.
Italic Systems
121
Table 4.13. Medieval multiplicative Roman numerals Year
Numeral-Phrase
Roman with Multiplication
Western Source
1220–25
II•DCCC•XIIII
Menninger 1969: 285
IX.XX.XVI
aaWUUUROP URUPO ZUUSPOOO ZZSROOO SRRRPOOO
2814
1231
196
Smith 1926: 6
1258
Steele 1922: xvii
2073
Crosby 1997: 208
88
Guitel 1975: 225
aaaUSRRROOO
3183
Cajori 1928: 33
USOR ZWP UU UWSR ZWROP ggg baWUUROOO
159
Preston 1994
1505
Menninger 1969: 285
200 460
Cajori 1928: 34
1514
Smith 1926: 7
300000
Menninger 1969: 285
6713
Menninger 1969: 283
gddaaaUWSPO
123456
Cajori 1928: 33
c
1258
Mij lviii
1340
IILXXIII
1388
1437–38
IIIIxx et huit M XX III C IIII III VIIXXXIX
1505
I•Vc•V
1392
C
1514
II IIIIC.LX
1514
XVCXIV
1550
CCCM
1554 1771
M
C
vi vii xiii c m c i xxiij iiij lvj
made between the Roman and Arabic systems. Nevertheless, this system was not taken up more widely in medieval scribal or mathematical texts. The speculation of Busch (2004) that a difficulty with seafaring travel times in the fifteenthcentury Icelandic Landnámabók can be resolved by interpreting VI (6) as “V I” (e.g., 51) is highly dubious. While the use of barred numerals to indicate multiplication by 1000 was of early origin and continued throughout the Middle Ages, new multiplicative forms began to be used starting in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. Some examples of such numeral-phrases are listed in Table 4.13, along with the transcriptions of the appropriate number both in the classical Roman system (including the use of subtractive and multiplicative forms, where appropriate) and in the Western system. These numeral-phrases primarily express multiplication by 100 or 1000 by juxtaposing C or M either immediately beside the appropriate multiplier, above it, or in superscript, and sometimes interposed with a dot. Often, the number 20 occupies a special role as a multiplier; such phrases are almost all from France and result from assimilation to the partly vigesimal structure of the French lexical numerals and/or to the monetary system (Preston 1994). These numeral-phrases have a multiplicative component, but they are not positional – the value of the
122
Numerical Notation
Table 4.14. Partially positional Roman numerals M•CCCC•8II CC2 ICC00 1•5•IIII 15X5 MDZ4 MCCCC4XVII IV0II
1482 202 1200 1504 1515 1624 1447 1502
numeral-signs does not change due to their position, but rather due only to their juxtaposition with another sign. It might be thought that multiplicative forms were adopted in order to write numerals more concisely or with a smaller set of numeral-signs – as was the case with the initial use of multiplicative forms in classical Rome. However, as seen by comparing the numeral-phrases in Table 4.7 to their equivalents in standard Roman numerals, there is no such benefit. In addition to these multiplicative forms, we find many cases where the signs of the Roman system were intermingled with the positional principle of the newer Western system, as well as its actual numeral-signs. The earliest known example is from the late twelfth-century Microcosmographia, in which the only known copy (from the thirteenth or fourteenth century) is dated mclxxviii (1178) but in another place as mc87 (an error for 1178) (Williams 1934: 107). Preston (1994) describes a number of such mixed uses in Durandus of Saint-Pourçain’s Commentary on the Sentences of Peter Lombard of 1336, such as xxx3 for 33 and xl7 for 47. In one example from an English almanac from 1386, Western numerals both precede and follow Roman numerals in a numeral phrase for 52,220, written as 52mcc20 (Halliwell 1839: 116). Menninger (1969: 287–288) provides examples of such admixtures starting in the late fifteenth century, as indicated in Table 4.14. In these partly ciphered-positional numeral-phrases, conciseness is greatly increased over their Roman counterparts. It is unknown whether this was being done consciously as a compromise between the two systems, as a misunderstanding of the Western system, or as numerical playfulness. In at least one case, the blending is obviously erroneous; in an astronomical table, the scribe wrote MCC6 for 1269, then crossed out the entire phrase and wrote 1269 in Western numerals (Steele 1922: xvii). Such combinations are not necessarily advantageous; the idiosyncratic nature of these numeral formations almost certainly decreased their comprehensibility. None were used frequently or consistently enough to create a true variant system. These hybrid formations no longer appear after about 1650. The roughly contemporaneous expansion of Roman multiplicative notation and the introduction of hybrid forms employing ciphering and positionality in
Italic Systems
123
late medieval European scribal traditions meant that any number could be written in several ways. The wide range of textual genres containing such variants, and their geographical and chronological breadth, confirm that this variety was not isolated, but neither was it standardized. In any event, a parallel process was ongoing from the twelfth century onward that would eventually lead to the nearly complete replacement of Roman numerals by Western ones throughout Europe and eventually throughout the world.
Replacement and Persistence Although positional numeration was first introduced into Western Europe in the late tenth century by Gerbert of Aurillac (later Pope Sylvester II), it was rarely used before the publication in 1202 of Liber Abaci by Leonardo of Pisa, also known as Fibonacci. This mathematical text sparked an important debate between two camps: the abacists, those who preferred computation with the medieval abacus, and the algorithmists, who preferred pen-and-paper calculations using the Western ciphered-positional numerals. The history of this debate is well documented, as it involved many important commercial families, renowned mathematicians and clergymen, and even state authorities (Menninger 1969: 422–445; Evans 1977; Murray 1978: 163–175). Issues of computational efficiency were often addressed. In his dictionary of 1530, the English lexicographer-priest John Palsgrave included the sentence, “I shall reken it syxe tymes by aulgorisme or you can caste it ones by counters” as a sample sentence for the verb to reckon (Palsgrave 1530: 337).7 However, these debates did not compare the Roman and Western numerals, but rather two techniques of computation: pen-and-paper arithmetic versus abacus calculation. The use of these techniques was correlated with specific numerical notation systems, but evaluations of computational efficiency require more information about how numbers were manipulated. Yet the debate was not only about efficiency. In 1299, the Arte del Cambio or moneychangers’ guild of Florence prohibited the use of Western numerals in its registers, a prohibition that was maintained for at least twenty years (Struik 1968). The reason given in the document is to prevent fraud, which was encouraged by the numerals’ ease of falsification, but Struik rightly notes that socioeconomic explanations for this prohibition are just as persuasive, taking into account conflict between conservative (aristocratic) and progressive (mercantile) factions. In 1348, booksellers at the University of Padua were required to list prices in their 7
This statement must be considered in light of the fact that a) it is a sample sentence rather than part of an evaluation of the two methods and b) Palsgrave’s book was paginated throughout using Roman numerals.
124
Numerical Notation
inventories “not by ciphers but by plain letters” (Berggren 2002: 361). As late as 1494, the Frankfurt Bürgermeisterbuch (a mayoral book of edicts) ordered reckoners not to compute using Western numerals (Menninger 1969: 426–427). One can certainly imagine the consternation of merchants and bookkeepers upon learning that one can simply add zeroes to the end of a numeral ad infinitum to multiply its value by ten each time, but the role of xenophobia and traditionalism in all of these cases should not be underestimated. The Western numerals may have been rejected in part because of practical considerations, but they were, after all, a foreign and newfangled invention that involved the unusual principle of positionality and that (because of their novelty) could be used to conceal information or deceive others. The rarity of paper in the earlier Middle Ages may also have contributed to the continued use of the Roman numerals (Smith and Ginsburg 1937: 29). Until penand-paper calculation became feasible, the “Roman numeral–friendly” abacus was the computational technology of choice, whereas the switch to pen and paper made the conciseness of Western numerals more attractive. This attractiveness increased with the introduction of printing presses, where long strings of movabletype Roman numerals would have been unwieldy in comparison to Western numerals. Yet despite Eisenstein’s contention that, “[t]he use of Arabic numbers for pagination suggests how the most inconspicuous innovation could have weighty consequences – in this case, more accurate indexing, anotation, and crossreferencing resulted” (1979: 105–6), most incunabula contained no Western numerals. Even where the utility of Western numerals for computation was recognized, the Roman numerals were not always abandoned entirely, as in Italian metrological documents studied by Travaini (1998), in which computations were undertaken using Western numerals, but totals were then written in Roman numerals. William Cecil (Lord Burghley), England’s Lord High Treasurer from 1572 to 1598 and a chief advisor of Elizabeth I, would frequently transcribe economic documents from Western back into Roman numerals, and was decidedly uncomfortable with the new system (Stone 1949: 31). Despite such resistance, the Western numerals had taken hold by around 1300 in the Italian city-states. Elsewhere in Western Europe, particularly in Germany and England, the Roman numerals predominated until the late fifteenth century or even later. Jenkinson (1926) finds limited evidence for the use of Western numerals in English archives before 1500, and notes that Roman numerals were forbidden from use in state accounts only in the nineteenth century. Barradas de Carvalho’s (1957) study of fifteenth- and sixteenth-century Portuguese texts showed that the Roman numerals were replaced there only around 1500. Several important sixteenth-century arithmetical texts continued to use Roman numerals in preference to Western ones. Jacob Köbel’s (1470–1533) Rechenbiechlin, published in
Italic Systems
125
Figure 4.2. Tables of variant Roman numerals from the Mysticae numerorum significationis (1583–84) of Petrus Bungus. Source: Smith 1908: 380–383.
Augsburg in 1514, an important commercial arithmetic book intended for mercantile instruction, uses Roman numerals throughout and strongly advocates the use of the counting board, although Köbel frequently used multiplicative phrasing for hundreds and thousands, and his text is the source of the unorthodox “260/400” Roman numeral fraction in Table 4.13 (Smith 1908: 100–107). However, by the seventeenth century, the battle was essentially finished, and the Roman numerals ceased to be used in most contexts. Figure 4.2, from the Mysticae numerorum significationis of Petrus Bungus (d. 1601), first published in 1583–84, depicts a wide variety of archaic and curious Roman numeral phrases, but is essentially a text on number mysticism and symbolism rather than a manual for practical use (Smith 1908: 380–383). Why, after over a millennium of essentially unchallenged use in Western Europe, should the Roman numerals have ceased to be used for most purposes? The traditional answer given – that Roman numerals were less efficient for computation – is correct but incomplete. The Roman numerals were used alongside the Greek
126
Numerical Notation
alphabetic numerals for well over a thousand years, despite the great increase in conciseness that could have been achieved by abandoning the Roman system. In medieval Western Europe, debates over the use of Roman numerals lasted into the seventeenth century, with the relative usefulness of the Roman numerals for calculation being greatly increased by the accompanying use of counting boards. However, two developments were fundamental in rendering the Roman system obsolete in the West. Firstly, the development of the printing press and the consequent rise in literacy after 1450 correlates very well with the rapid adoption of Western numerals throughout Europe (particularly in northern regions). The newly literate middle classes of Western Europe were learning to read and calculate, unconstrained by centuries of traditional use of the Roman numerals. At the same time, the rise of mercantile capitalism in the Renaissance changed how numbers were viewed and used (cf. Swetz 1987). The functional needs of Western society to represent number changed dramatically between 1300 and 1700, and the computational functions that are better served by Western than by Roman numerals increased in importance. Nevertheless, Crosby’s (1997: 41) insistence that Roman numerals were “adequate for the weekly market and for local tax collection, but not for anything grander” is misplaced if intended as an explanation for their replacement. In fact, as Crosby himself notes, Roman numerals persisted for centuries in the record books of institutions as grand as the British Exchequer (Crosby 1997: 115–116). Double-entry bookkeeping was facilitated to some degree by the transition to Western numerals, but it was by no means a requirement. The introduction of a more fully mercantile and urban economy in Western Europe did, however, expose more people, particularly members of the newly wealthy and increasingly literate middle class, to a new form of numeration. Rather than examining this change in notation simply by comparing the two notations, it is more productive to examine the question from a social perspective. If Roman numerals were truly so inferior, how did they persist for two millennia without being replaced? Why did it take six centuries even after the introduction of Western numerals for this shift to take place? The most likely scenario is that the new users of writing and written numeration, unconstrained by past practices, provided a critical mass of users for the Western numerals that facilitated certain mercantile functions. Even today, the Roman numerals have not disappeared. The use of the Roman system on clock faces, in the enumeration of kings and popes, on many dated inscriptions, and to mark the copyright dates on films is rather archaic, but the cultural importance of its symbolic connotations of antiquity, tradition, and prestige likely guarantee its future survival. In media where archaism is desired, Roman numerals are often preferred; this is the case among the Cornish church sundials from 1670–1850 studied by Burge (1994), for instance. An inscription on a gateway at Harvard uses archaic Roman numeral-signs, noting the college’s 264 years of
Italic Systems
127
existence in 1900 as “ANN. DOM. _WUUUU. COLL. HARV. UUTROOOO” (McPharlin 1942: 18). Pot (1999) notes the existence of several twentieth-century postage stamps in which additive Roman numerals rather than the ordinary subtractive ones are employed – for instance, XXXXI instead of XLI on a 1990 German issue. Presumably these variants are not errors per se, but are mobilized for aesthetic reasons, just as on Roman numeral clock faces, 4 is normally written IIII instead of IV, even though 9 is IX (Hering 1939). The fifteenth-century accountant Luca Pacioli advocated the use of Roman numerals for the year-dates in accounting books for aesthetic reasons (although Western everywhere else), recommending “[u]se the ancient letters in making this entry, if only for the sake of beauty” (Crosby 1997: 222). At the other end of the class and prestige spectrum, Roman numerals were often retained in peasant or rural traditions and trades long after they had ceased to be used in formal texts and administration. Gmür (1917) describes a wide variety of wooden tally sticks of Swiss provenience, dating from the sixteenth to the nineteenth centuries, containing Roman numeral-phrases. The same principle applies to the much earlier “calendar-numerals” used on Northern European calendrical documents (see the following discussion). With the inexorable spread of industrialization and capitalist commercial practices throughout Europe, the use of wooden tallies containing Roman numerals has essentially disappeared. When used to paginate the introductions of books, or to enumerate items in sublists or subsections, Roman numerals continue to serve the very practical function of providing an alternate form of enumeration wherever two different series of things must be listed. I would not expect that any industrial society could function solely with a cumulative-additive system such as the Roman numerals. Conversely, however, I would not expect them to be replaced entirely. The failure of over five hundred years’ worth of predictions of the Roman numerals’ imminent demise, and complaints regarding their utility, suggests that functional considerations, while important, do not tell the entire tale with respect to the history of numerical notation systems.
Arabico-Hispanic Variants Arabic and Western European knowledge systems interacted intimately on the Iberian peninsula between the tenth and sixteenth centuries – the period of the Reconquista and somewhat beyond. At this time, the Roman numerals were well known in Spain and Portugal, as in the rest of Europe. Arab mathematicians and astronomers had, since around 800 ad, used a ciphered-positional system much like the one used today (Chapter 6), along with older cipheredadditive abjad numerals related to those of the Greeks (Chapter 5). Medieval
128
Numerical Notation
Spain thus presents us with a remarkable case where three coexistent systems each had a different structuring principle (cf. Labarta and Barceló 1988). But rather than a simple case of the two Arabic systems replacing the Roman numerals, medieval Spanish astronomers, bookkeepers, and scribes experimented and mixed principles, incorporating ciphering and positionality into the basic structure of the Roman numerals in innovative ways. It was, as described by Berggren (2002: 358), a “promiscuous blend of systems,” a mélange that persisted for several hundred years. In the tenth and eleventh centuries ad, Spanish astronomers wrote extensive astronomical texts using primarily the Roman numerals. Even the use of the subtractive principle was very infrequent in Spain at this time. Despite the use of Arabic positional numerals in the region for some time previous and familiarity with works such as the Arithmetic of Al-Khwarizimi, Spanish astronomers did not adopt the system directly (Lemay 1977: 458). Instead, the Roman numerals were modified to increase their conciseness. Instead of using the cumulative principle to express the numbers 3 through 9 (III, IIII, V, etc.), they used new acrophonic symbols based on the first letters of the Latin numeral words: 3 = t = tres; 4 = q = quatuor; 5 = Q = quinque; 6 = s = sex; 7 = S = septem; 8 = o = octo; 9 = N = novem. Of these, only the symbols for 4, 8, and 9 were common, probably because they are the longest numeral-phrases below 10 in Roman numerals (IIII, VIII, VIIII). In addition, a special sign for 40 was employed: Ó, a cursive ligatured version of XL, and the only exception to the abandonment of subtractive forms (Lemay 1977: 459). Bischoff (1990: 176) reports that this sign for 40 is also found in some Visigothic manuscripts, suggesting considerable antiquity for the sign on the Iberian peninsula. These changes altered the classical Roman numerals into a partly ciphered-additive system. However, these modifications were not accompanied by the adoption of positional notation, and the system still had a mixed base of 5 and 10 and was purely additive. These developments increased the conciseness of numeral-phrases considerably. The number 99, which would have been LXXXXVIIII, could now be expressed as LÓN. This system was used in mathematical and astronomical texts until about the mid twelfth century, at which time the Western numerals took hold in astronomy, as in the rest of Western Europe. Yet while the Arabic positional numerals had firmly established themselves and were later transformed into the Western numeral-signs familiar to us, the Roman numerals did not cease to be used on the Iberian peninsula, though their use became increasingly limited. Labarta and Barceló discuss two curious offshoot Roman numeral systems found in early modern Spanish documents, as shown in Table 4.15 (Labarta and Barceló 1988: 32–34). Both systems are cumulative-additive, decimal systems with a sub-base of 5, unlike those of the earlier astronomical texts. Unlike most Roman numerals,
Italic Systems
129
Table 4.15. Arabico-Hispanic numerals 1
5
10
50
100
Ø 1
Ù V
Ú ó
Û
Ý
numeral-phrases are written from right to left (highest values at the right), which is curious because even in the Arabic script, which has a right-to-left direction, the numerical notation system has a left-to-right direction. The first system is found in a few late sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century documents to indicate monetary quantities, and its numeral-signs are somewhat similar to letters of the Arabic script. The second system is found only in a single Inquisition document from 1576 (Labarta and Barceló 1988: 34).8 From the sixteenth century onward, Western numerals became increasingly common throughout the Iberian peninsula, but certain anomalies remained in the Roman numerals of the early modern period. Subtractive numerals remained rare in comparison to the rest of Europe. A symbol known as the caldéron was sometimes used; it meant 1000 but was used multiplicatively, preceded by unit-signs, not additively (Cajori 1922, Lowe 1943). The caldéron was most often shaped like a U, sometimes with one or two diagonal bars across it (™). Thus, a manuscript from the Ponce de Leon papers from 1501 has the year dated as J™DJ (1 1000 500 1), reminiscent of the use of M for that purpose in other parts of medieval Western Europe (Lowe 1943: 9). Cajori (1922) hypothesizes that the caldéron originated in Italy in the fifteenth century, possibly as a modification of the older Y for 1000 that was not fully replaced by M until the modern period. Curiously, even after the Roman numerals had been abandoned entirely, it continued to be used multiplicatively with Western numerals, as in a contract written in Mexico City in 1649 in which a sum of 7291 pesos is expressed both as 7U291 and VIIUCCXCI (Cajori 1922: 201).
Calendar Numerals In the late Middle Ages, unusual numerals were used in some Northern European documents and inscriptions pertaining to calendrical calculations. Known as “calendar numerals,” “runic numerals,” or “peasant numerals,” they are a variant of the Roman numerals. I reject the term “runic” because few runic inscriptions contain 8
However, see Chapter 10 for a discussion of a potential descendant of this system in the form of Berber numerals used in North Africa.
Numerical Notation
130
Table 4.16. Calendar numerals 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
a b c d e f g A B C D E F G 1 2 3 4 5 5 5 1 2
8
9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
h H 5 3
i j k l m I J K L M 5 6 6 6 6 4 1 2 3
n o p q r N O P Q R 6 7 7 7 7 4 1 2 3
s t S 8 7 8 4
them.9 Likewise, the term “peasant numerals” tells us who may (or may not) have been using them, but lacks the precise functional association of “calendar numerals.” Some examples of these signs are shown in Table 4.16 (cf. Kroman 1974: 121; Ifrah 1985: 146–147). These systems are all cumulative-additive and have a base of 10 with a sub-base of 5. Units are marked by strokes or dots; fives are marked by angled or curved lines or loops to create “U” or “V” shapes, and tens are marked by transecting the vertical line perpendicularly, creating a cross or X. Although these numeralsigns are often joined together into single figures resembling digits by using a vertical stroke, the system is not ciphered. There are no signs for 50, 100, or higher values, and I am not aware of calendar numerals being used for numbers higher than 31 (the number of days in the longest months). Other than their unusual numeral-signs, the calendar numerals are identical to ordinary Roman numerals. While they were used in rural traditions that suggest to some that they were part of the large cultural substratum of tallying and notching in medieval and early modern Europe (Menninger 1969: 249–251; Ifrah 1985: 146–147), the calendar numerals are not tallies in this sense. A tally is used ordinally – one places marks as necessary on some material (wood, paper, stone, etc.) in sequence in order to keep a running total, rather than, as with numerical notation systems, marking an already totaled value. The calendar numerals are simply a variant of Roman numerals in which numeral-phrases are written vertically and attached to a line. By the late fifteenth century, the Western numerals were fairly well known in Germany and were becoming much more common in England and Scandinavia. Calendar numerals were used in a very delimited set of contexts, namely
9
The medieval antiquarian tradition of manuscripts discussing runic writing contains minimal evidence of any specifically “Runic” numerical system. The clophruna (Old Norse klapprúnir) system of notating numbers by dots (a = 1 = .; b = 2 = ..; c = 3 = … ) discussed by Derolez (1954: 134) is of obscure origin and is not clearly related to any other numerical notation.
Italic Systems
131
on documents of wood, stone, or horn designed to assist the largely nonliterate populace in determining the dates of festivals, especially Easter. Throughout the medieval period, the Metonic cycle of nineteen years, after which the moon’s phases recur on the same day of the year, was used as a rough-and-ready guide to calculate the date of Easter. The function of the calendar numerals was solely to denote the various years of this cycle on stylized perpetual calendars, known as “runic calendars” in German- and Norse-speaking areas and as “clog almanacs” in England. Because of this specialized function, there was almost never any reason to express numbers higher than 19. While these texts were used for computation, the numerals were not used directly for arithmetic. One merely needed to line up the appropriate days and years to get the correct value. Calendar numerals were, however, reasonably compact and easily understandable by anyone who knew the Roman numerals. The calendar numerals lie at the heart of one of the major pseudoscientific controversies of New World archaeology – the so-called Kensington Rune Stone of Minnesota, which purportedly contains a Viking inscription left in 1362 by Norse explorers who had traveled westward from Vinland. At issue are the calendar or runic numerals used in the inscription, particularly the numbers 14, 22, and 1362, expressed as ad, bb, and acfb, respectively (Hagen 1950; Nielsen 1986: 51). These numeral-phrases are ciphered-positional, like our Western numerals but unlike the cumulative-additive calendar numerals (in which 14 would be written as n). It is improbable that a Norse explorer in “Vinland” would have been familiar with the Western numerals in 1362, which were known only by the very educated in northern Europe at the time (Struik 1964: 167). Even if this knowledge is presumed, we need to explain why the savant substituted the cumulative-additive runic numeral-signs for the appropriate Western figures. While some fourteenth-century runic inscriptions used Western numerals (Nielsen 1986), calendar numerals were never used in such a positional fashion. There is no evidence for the use of calendar numerals except in calendrical texts, which the Kensington stone is not. Ohman, the Swedish-American “discoverer” of the stone, was likely familiar with the calendar numerals (easily found in any book on runology) but not with the proper structure of the system. Similar inscriptions with runic numerals, such as that on No Man’s Land, an island south of Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts, are undeniable forgeries (Marstrand 1949). The calendar numerals were a brief and local phenomenon in northern Europe. As the Western numerals came increasingly to be used for calendrical purposes, their use waned. By 1643, when Ole Worm wrote his Fasti Danici describing the runic numerals used in calendar tables, it was primarily as a curiosity and to aid the transition to newer methods of calculation (Worm 1643).
132
Numerical Notation
Summary The Italic numerical notation systems developed in the early sixth century bc with the invention of the Etruscan and Greek acrophonic numerals, based on a previously existing but still poorly understood system of tallies, and spread eastward from Italy during the period of classical Greek preeminence in the Mediterranean. However, of all the Italic systems, only the Roman numerals had any extensive use in the Christian era, as the Greeks had switched to the ciphered-additive alphabetic numerals (Chapter 5) by the Hellenistic period. The remarkable persistence of the Roman system and the swift decline of other systems are best explained by the changing political fortunes of their users. The use of the earlier Italic systems was mainly limited to inscriptions and commercial marks, though the Roman numerals were later used for an enormous variety of functions in different social contexts. All the Italic numerical notation systems are cumulative-additive and decimal, with a sub-base of 5, and virtually all use a single vertical stroke for the units. Some unusual structural features occasionally emerge in the higher powers of 10, such as the use of implied multiplication in South Arabian and the hybrid multiplicative structure of later Roman numerals. Although the epichoric numerals of Argos, Nemea, and Epidaurus use dots rather than vertical strokes for units, they are related to the Greek acrophonic numerals and must be considered part of this phylogeny. The cultural history of some Italic systems is intermingled with those of the Hieroglyphic (Chapter 2) and Levantine (Chapter 3) phylogenies, making the construction of accurate cultural phylogenies more difficult, particularly because the systems of all three are cumulative-additive, decimal, and used in the eastern Mediterranean. Often the three families can be distinguished on structural grounds: the Hieroglyphic systems all lack a quinary component, while the Levantine systems all have special signs for 20 and are multiplicative-additive above 100. This structural distinction can be confirmed independently by examining known patterns of historical contact. Despite the jumbled state of our present knowledge, we can identify phylogenies, not only because of similarities in their systems’ structure, but also as a result of the attested cultural connections among the societies in which they were developed. Nevertheless, to insist too strongly on “pure” cultural phylogenies following a model of speciation would be erroneous. In comparison to either the Alphabetic (Chapter 5) or South Asian (Chapter 6) systems, however, the diversity of Italic systems is far less than might be expected, given the preeminence and impact of the Roman Empire on European social life. The Roman numerals gave rise to relatively few descendant systems – when they were borrowed, they were copied rather than modified. We would do well to remember that the Roman numerals are simply one numerical notation system among the world’s diverse systems, despite their importance within the Western consciousness.
chapter 5
Alphabetic Systems
The systems discussed in the previous three chapters are primarily cumulative, repeating signs within each power of the base to indicate addition. In contrast, the next two families – the Alphabetic and South Asian systems – consist mainly of ciphered systems, which use, at most, a single sign for any power to indicate its different multiples: 1 through 9, 10 through 90, 100 through 900, and so on, in the case of decimal systems. Ciphered numeral-phrases are thus much shorter than cumulative ones, but require their users to be familiar with many more signs. Alphabetic numerical notation systems generally use phonetic script-signs, in a specified order, to express numerical values, and thus mitigate the effort needed to memorize both script-signs and numeral-signs. Despite the name, the scripts in question are not always alphabets; some, such as the Hebrew and early Arabic, are abjads or consonantaries, expressing primarily consonantal phonemes, and one, the Ethiopic Ge’ez script, is an alphasyllabary or abugida, expressing consonant + vowel clusters.1 Alphabetic systems were used as far north as England, Germany, and Russia and as far south as Ethiopia, and throughout Africa and the Middle East from Morocco eastward to Iran. Their history spans over two thousand years, from the development of the Greek numerals around 600 bc to the present, but in some 1
For more extensive discussion of script typology, which is not warranted here, see Daniels and Bright (1996).
133
134
Numerical Notation
cases important historical questions remain unresolved. While they are mostly ciphered-additive, they are not structurally identical. We can learn much more from these structural differences than from the paleographic curiosities of the signs of various systems. I hope in this chapter to illuminate areas of study where our knowledge is less than perfect in order to draw attention to the need for further specialized research. Table 5.1 shows the most common variants of the major alphabetic systems.
Greek Alphabetic In Chapter 4, I discussed the cumulative-additive Greek acrophonic numerals, which were given their name because the letters used are the first letters of the appropriate Greek numeral words. Another Greek system, much more common, is sometimes called the “Ionic” or “Milesian” system due to its origin in western Asia Minor, but is most commonly called the alphabetic system. While the Greek alphabet was based on a Phoenician model, probably in the ninth or eighth century bc, none of the earliest Greek inscriptions contains numerical notation; thus, the debates on the time of the origin of the alphabet are not relevant to the origin of alphabetic numerals (cf. McCarter 1975, Swiggers 1996). The first examples of the alphabetic numerals date to the sixth century bc and are written using the letters of the archaic Greek script used in Ionia and the Ionian cities of Caria, such as Miletus. Table 5.2 has representative examples of these early signs. The system was purely ciphered-additive and decimal, and was usually written from left to right, though right-to-left and boustrophedon (alternating direction) inscriptions are not unknown. The numeral-signs are archaic variants of the twenty-four familiar Greek letters, plus three special signs called episemons: vau or digamma (6), qoppa (90), and san or sampi (900), which were added to reach a full complement of twenty-seven signs for all the values from 1 through 900, allowing one to write any natural number less than 1000.2 Vau and qoppa were occasionally used phonetically in the Ionic script, with the values of [v] and [k], while san appears to have been borrowed from Phoenician sādē [ts], and was possibly used in archaic Greek with a similar phonetic value (Swiggers 1996: 265–266). There are very few examples of alphabetic numerals from this early period, and all of them express values under 1000, so we do not know whether higher values could be represented. 2
There was no general name for the three signs in classical Greek; the term episemon originally referred only to the sign for 6, but following its etymology, some classicists use the term in a more generic sense (J. Kalvesmaki, personal communication; Foat 1905).
135
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
a b g d e v z\ h q i k l m n x o
Greek
Coptic
Ethiopic
.a. .b. .c. .d. .e. .f. .g. .h. .i. .j. .k. .l. .m. .n. .o. .p.
Gothic Hebrew
Table 5.1. Alphabetic numerical notation systems
g h i j k l m n o p
Syriac
a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p
Arabic
a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p
Fez
a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p
a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p
a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p
(continued )
a b c d e f g h i k l m n o p q
Armenian Georgian Glagolitic Cyrillic Latin
136
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
90
80
p , r s t u f c y w . /a /b /g /d /e /v
Greek
Coptic
Ethiopic
.q. .r. .s. .t. .u. .v. .w. .x. .y. .z. .{.
Gothic Hebrew
Table 5.1. Alphabetic numerical notation systems (continued )
q r s t u v sv tv uv vv svv /a /b /c /d /e /f
Syriac
q r s t u v w x y z : ;
Arabic
q r s t u v w x y z ,
Fez
q r s t u v w x y z ! @ # $ % ^ &
q r s t u v w x y z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 q r s t u v w x y z / 1 2
q r s t u v w x y z {
r s t u x y z θ φ
Armenian Georgian Glagolitic Cyrillic Latin
137
1,000,000
100,000
90,000
80,000
70,000
60,000
50,000
40,000
30,000
20,000
10,000
9000
8000
7000
z h q i p
/z /h /q a b g d e V
Greek
Coptic
Ethiopic
Gothic Hebrew
-f -g -h -i -j -s
/g /h /i -a -b -c -d -e
Syriac
Arabic
Fez
* ( )
8 9 0 -
Armenian Georgian Glagolitic Cyrillic Latin
Numerical Notation
138
Table 5.2. Greek alphabetic numerals (archaic) 1
a 10s j 100s s 562 = wob
1s
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
b k t
c l u
d m v
e n w
f o x
g p y
h q z
i r ,
In the classical and Hellenistic periods, the familiar Greek alphabet supplanted the archaic regional (or “epichoric”) variants, and the alphabetic numerals developed along with them, retaining their order and numerical values but assuming their modern (majuscule) forms. In addition, starting in the middle of the fifth century bc, two new techniques were used to express higher values. For multiples of 1000, a small slanting mark (known as a hasta) was placed to the left and below a sign for 1 to 9 to indicate that its value should be multiplied by 1000; thus, G means 3, but /G means 3000 (Threatte 1980: 115). Values above 10,000 are rarely encountered except in mathematical works, and individual writers used different methods to do so. The most common method, used by Aristarchus, involved placing a small alphabetic numeral-phrase (less than 10,000) above a large M character (= myriades) to indicate multiplication by 10,000 (Heath 1921: 39–41).3 Thus, 3,000,000 would be expressed with only two signs, as y. This allowed any number less than 100 million to be easily expressed.4 The system thus appeared as shown in Table 5.3, using the Athenian letters. The system is thus ciphered-additive for values under 1000, and thereafter is multiplicative-additive at two different levels: firstly, through the use of a hasta to indicate multiplication by 1000, and then through the use of an M to indicate multiplication by 10,000. The alphabetic numerals were generally written in descending order, with the highest values on the left. Numbers between 11 and 19 were often written with the 10-sign (I) following the unit-sign, however, to correspond with the way in which the ancient Greek lexical numerals were formed: 3
4
Heath also discusses techniques such as that of Heron’s Geometrica, where two dots placed over a sign indicate multiplication by 10,000; that of Apollonius, using “tetrads,” turning the system into a mixed base-10/10,000 ciphered-additive system; and that of Nicholas Rhabdas, a fourteenth-century scholar who used Heron’s technique, except that additional pairs of dots above a number indicated successive powers of 10,000. None of these systems was ever widely used. For the ancient Greeks, ‘ten thousand times ten thousand’ – 100 million, the first uncountable number in the alphabetic system – was of symbolic significance, as in Revelation 5:11: “and the number of them was ten thousand times ten thousand.”
Alphabetic Systems
139
Table 5.3. Greek alphabetic numerals (classical) 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Aa Ii
Bb Kk
Gg Ll
Dd Mm
Ee Nn
Vv Xx
Zz Oo
Hh Pp
Qq <,
1000s
Rr /A
Ss /B
Tt /G
Uu /D
Cc /E
Ff /V
Yy /Z
Ww /H
>. /Q
10,000s
A
B
G
D
E
V
Z
H
Q
1s 10s 100s
562 = CXB
hendeka, dodeka, treis kai deka, tettares kai deka, and so on. For instance, Threatte (1980: 114) provides a number of examples from Attica where GI, ZI, HI, and QI appear for 13, 17, 18, and 19. Starting in the Roman period, the signs became more rigidly fixed in highest-to-lowest order. There was a mild taboo against the use of theta (Q) for 9 in some texts because it is the first letter of θανατοσ ‘death’; circumlocutions were used instead, such as writing the number lexically, or as an additive combination of alphabetic numerals such as EΔ (5 + 4) or AH (1 + 8) (Smith 1926: 69; Thomas 1977). Because alphabetic numerals could easily be confused with written words, classical Greek alphabetic numerals were sometimes distinguished from the rest of the text with special signs, most commonly a horizontal stroke above the numeralphrase, but occasionally with dots placed to either side of it. One of the problems in identifying earlier Greek alphabetic numerals is the lack of such marks, meaning that any single letter could be an alphabetic numeral or a non-numerical label. Even in later periods, numerals frequently appear without any indicator mark whatsoever (Threatte 1980: 115). In most Greek monumental inscriptions, the only fractions used are acrophonic signs for fractions of different monetary units (Tod 1950: 134). In mathematical and literary texts, an entirely different system was used in which small accents or strokes placed above and to the right of a numeral indicated unit-fractions (Thomas 1962: 43). Special signs existed for 1/2 (<’ and U’) and 2/3 (ω’), in addition to standard unit-fractions (Thomas 1962: 45). From the second century ad onward, the requirement of using only unit-fractions was lifted, and fractions were expressed with both numerators and denominators using alphabetic numerals. Finally, a special system for fractions was used in astronomy, combining the alphabetic numerals with sexagesimal structures borrowed from the Babylonians. There is no evidence for an early (eighth century bc or earlier) origin of the numerals, although prominent classicists such as Larfeld (1902–07) endorsed this
140
Numerical Notation
theory, arguing for descent from the Phoenician alphabetic system, because the Greek alphabet was borrowed from a Phoenician ancestor and because many Semitic scripts have alphabetic numerals (Brunschwig and Lloyd 2000: 388). Yet no Semitic consonantal numerical notation systems existed before the second century bc, and they were based on Greek rather than the other way around (Gow 1883). None of the very earliest Greek alphabetic inscriptions contains numerals. Conversely, however, the once-popular theory of a very late origin (late fourth or even third century bc) cannot be sustained in light of evidence from earlier periods (Gow 1883). The first epigraphic evidence for alphabetic numerals comes from a vase, dating to around 575 bc, found at Corinth, which contains the inscription “SYM g,” which Johnston reads as “mixed batch of 7” (Johnston 1973: 186). There is good evidence from Attica and Corinth for the system’s use on mercantile vases in the late sixth and early fifth centuries bc (Hackl 1909). Yet it is unlikely that the numerals actually developed in either of these localities. Rather, the numerals probably developed in western Asia Minor, in the regions of Ionia and Caria, especially in the cities of Miletus5 and Halicarnassus, where several early instances of the numerals have been found (Heath 1921: 32–33). Another early example is found in the “tunnel of Eupalinos” on the Ionian island of Samos, constructed around 550 bce, in which distances are noted using letters that are probably alphabetic numerals (as opposed to non-numerical or ordinal labels) (Verdan 2007: 12–13). All the early examples of the alphabetic numerals, even those found outside Asia Minor, are written using the Ionic script, which was used in Ionia, Caria, and various Ionic colonies throughout the Mediterranean. This reflects the predominance of Ionia in regional and international commerce during the sixth and early fifth centuries bc. While vau and qoppa were used phonetically in the early Ionic script, san was not, and so had lost its place between pi and qoppa in the numerical order (Jeffery 1990: 327). Later, it was reincorporated into the script for the purpose of providing a twenty-seventh sign for the numerals to function, but was placed at the end of the system, with the numerical value 900. The principle of the Greek alphabetic numerals was borrowed directly from the Egyptian demotic numerals in the early sixth century bc, only using alphabetic signs as numeral-signs (Chrisomalis 2003; see also Zaslavsky 2003). Boyer (1944: 159) regarded the similarity between the two systems as indicative of a historical connection, but his paper was not primarily oriented toward such an argument. Because the alphabetic numerals were the first to use phonetic signs as numeralsigns, there will be no paleographic similarity between the Greek numeral-signs 5
Miletus, from whence the adjective “Milesian,” was the most important Ionian city in Caria, the region of Asia Minor immediately to the south of Ionia proper.
Alphabetic Systems
141
and any other system. Yet the alphabetic numerals are structurally similar to the demotic numerals. They are both ciphered-additive, base-10 systems. While it has yet to be established whether the alphabetic numerals used multiplicative notation at an early date, both systems are multiplicative-additive above 10,000. Unlike the demotic numerals, the alphabetic system is also multiplicative for the thousands. The Greeks could simply have continued the series above 1000 using 10 through 90 and 100 through 900 (/I = 10,000; /K = 20,000; etc.), so the use of two-stage multiplication may be a clue to the alphabetic numerals’ history. It would be reasonable for the Greeks to adopt the multiplicative principle at the same level as in the demotic numerals, namely 10,000. However, it would not have been feasible to find nine extra signs for the values 1000 through 9000. Consequently, the inventor(s) of the alphabetic numerals may have had the idea of using multiplication for the thousands values as well as the ten thousands. The only remaining problem is to explain why the Greeks, recognizing this irregularity, did not then abandon the higher multiplicative series. Furthermore, Greek arithmetical techniques for dealing with fractions strongly resemble the Egyptian unit-fraction (1/x) tradition of computation (Knorr 1982, Fowler 1999a). Both systems used unit-fractions formed by placing a small mark above numeral-signs to indicate the appropriate unit-fraction. As well, both used non-unit-fractions for specific values such as 1/2 and 2/3. Historians of mathematics are unanimous that the Greeks borrowed the unit-fraction technique from the Egyptians, and I see no reason to doubt that the Greek use of special signs for 1/2 and 2/3 is also a result of Egyptian influence. Turning to the historical evidence, the demotic numerals were the predominant ones in use in Egypt (especially Lower Egypt) in the early sixth century bc, when Greeks were just starting to encounter Egyptians in large numbers for the purposes of international trade. Most notable among the Greek traders in Egypt were Ionian colonists from Miletus, who set up an important emporion (port of trade) at Naukratis in the western Nile delta in the seventh century bc. Naukratis quickly became the central locus for cultural contact between Greece and Egypt, a position that it held until the Ptolemaic era. Inscriptions in the Ionic Greek script dating as early as 650 bc have been found at Naukratis (Heath 1921: 33). It should be noted, however, that no known inscriptions from Naukratis contain alphabetic numerals, and there are later (fourth-century bc) inscriptions with acrophonic numerals (Gardner 1888). Since the earliest examples of the alphabetic numerals are from containers for commercial goods, the context of the system’s development was probably in mercantile activity. The only alternative to the hypothesis of Egyptian origin is that the Ionians independently developed a ciphered-additive, decimal numerical notation system within a few decades of coming into contact with Egyptians in large numbers,
142
Numerical Notation
founding a colony at Naukratis, and being exposed to the demotic numerals used throughout Lower Egypt. These connections are too significant to be coincidental. This should not be taken as a denial of the Greeks’ inventiveness, however, because the alphabetic numerals have several distinctive properties. Firstly, while some of the demotic numeral-signs use the cumulative principle, the alphabetic numerals use purely ciphered signs. Secondly, as mentioned earlier, the alphabetic numerals use the multiplicative principle for 1000 through 9000, obviating the need for nine more signs for those values, as one could simply write a hasta before a unitsign. Finally, correlating numeral-signs with the ordered set of alphabetic signs meant that anyone who knew the order of the alphabet could determine the signs’ values as long as the episemons were taken into account. The often-mentioned “weakness” of the alphabetic numerals, that too many signs needed to be learned, is thus illusory. In learning to read and write, Western pupils must learn twentysix alphabetic signs (in their proper order) plus ten digits in order, making thirtysix total signs in two separate series, while the ancient Greeks needed to learn only twenty-seven alphabetic signs and two auxiliary signs (/ and :), and needed only twenty-nine total signs in one series. After a period of Ionian cultural dominance between 575 and 475 bc, when alphabetic numerals were commonly found, alphabetic numerals are found only rarely in a period starting in 475 bc and lasting around 150 years (Johnston 1979: 27). During this period, the height of Greek civilization, Athens came to the forefront as an Aegean power, while Ionia’s power waned after the Milesian-led Ionian revolt of 499 to 494 bc against Achaemenid Persia. The system did not disappear entirely; at Halicarnassus, there is evidence of its continued use (Keil 1894; Heath 1921: 31–33). A curious inscription from Athens (IG I2 760) from the middle of the fifth century bc contains a long series of alphabetic numerals, written with Ionic letters (Tod 1950: 137). There is, as well, good reason to believe that some of the graffiti on amphorae from the Athenian Agora had weight and volume marks notated in alphabetic numerals (Lawall 2000). In general, however, acrophonic numerals were used in most Greek texts during this period. The resurgence of the alphabetic numerals in Greece around 325 bc corresponds precisely with the rise of the Ptolemies in Egypt. In this renewed period, some of the earliest instances of the numerals come from Egypt. Figure 5.1 depicts a portion of a Greco-Egyptian astronomical text including a calendar for the Saite nome (Hibeh Papyrus i 27) dating to around 300 bc, one of these very early instances (Grenfell and Hunt 1906, Fowler and Turner 1983). Ordinary (unmarked) Greek letters stand for whole numbers, while 1/x “unit-fractions” are represented by signs modified with long oblique strokes. This is the earliest attested example of alphabetic numerals used in a scientific context. Coins dating to 266 bc indicating the regnal year of Ptolemy II Soter are, to my knowledge, the first coins bearing
Alphabetic Systems
143
Figure 5.1. Hibeh papyrus i 27, with Greek alphabetic numerals indistinguishable from letters, but with unit-fractions clearly distinguished through the addition of long upward slanting strokes. Source: Grenfell and Hunt 1906: Plate VIII.
any ciphered-additive numerals (Tod 1950: 138). It is interesting that while these examples come from Egypt, we have no record of the alphabetic numerals’ use in Egypt during the interlude of the fifth and fourth centuries bc. The evidence, at present, is simply too scanty to conclude what stimulus caused the rejuvenation of the alphabetic numerals. From the third century bc onward, the alphabetic numerals were preferred over the acrophonic numerals throughout most of the Greek-speaking world, with only Athens retaining the acrophonic system until around 50 bc (Threatte 1980: 117). While the acrophonic numerals used in different city-states varied quite widely, the alphabetic numerals had no regional variants. As such, they could be used as an effective instrument of cross-cultural communication and trade among diverse regions (Dow 1952: 23). Whereas Greece before Alexander was highly fragmented, rendering the development of a universal Greek numerical notation system unlikely, Alexandrine and especially Roman Greece provided a suitable environment for the development of a single pan-Hellenic notation. That the system was a very concise way to represent numbers, and that it relied on alphabetic symbols that had become invariant throughout Greece by this period in history, cannot have hurt this process.
144
Numerical Notation
In the sixth and fifth centuries bc, the alphabetic numerals were no more than a system for labeling mercantile containers. All the early instances of the system’s use are from marked vases and potsherds. Even then, most numerals on vases are acrophonic or other cumulative-additive Greek numerals, not alphabetic ones. In these very early contexts, the alphabetic numerals, like the acrophonic ones, were used for cardinal quantities, particularly of money, weights and measures, and discrete quantities of commodities, the sorts of numerical expressions likely to be found in inventories and decrees. From the third century bc onward, though, when the alphabetic system became the predominant one throughout the Greek world, the numerals were used in a much wider range of contexts. In contrast to the acrophonic numerals, which are found solely on ceramic vessels and stone, alphabetic numerals are found, in addition, in manuscripts of various sorts as well as on coins. As described by Tod (1950: 130–134) and Threatte (1980: 115–116), the functions for the alphabetic numerals include: a. b. c. d. e. f.
cardinal quantities of commodities, persons; phrases indicating lengths of time in days, months, and years; monetary values (denarii, drachmas, and obols); weights, measures, and distances; ordinal numerical adjectives and adverbs; ordinal dates, for example, to indicate a specific year in the tenure of an archon.
Before the Hellenistic period, we have no evidence that the alphabetic numerals were used for arithmetic or mathematics. Early writers such as Herodotus instead used the acrophonic numerals to record the results of computations performed with a pebble-board or abacus (Lang 1957). This situation changed once the alphabetic numerals began to be used more widely. Most surviving Greek mathematical manuscripts use the alphabetic numerals, which were used by all Greek mathematicians beginning with Archimedes and Apollinius (third century bc). Users of alphabetic numerals had a wide variety of computational techniques available. Schärlig (2001) suggests that while the earliest abaci are most conducive to working with acrophonic numerals, certain types of abaci were well suited to working with alphabetic numerals also. Furthermore, the Greeks developed a complex system of computing on the fingers up to 9999, reminiscent of the alphabetic system’s structural shift above 10,000 (Williams and Williams 1995). To facilitate multiplication and division, which were difficult to undertake using the abacus or finger computing, the Greeks used multiplication tables written with alphabetic numerals (Dilke 1987: 16; Sesiano 2002). Finally, Greek arithmetic was sometimes done in a manner analogous to modern Western practice, by writing down numbers and manipulating numeral-signs directly; the primary difference between the
Alphabetic Systems
145
two techniques is that in the Greek case, because the numerals are nonpositional, there was no need to line up numbers in columns (Smyly 1905). One would think, as Boyer (1944: 160) comments, that the adoption of the alphabetic numerals by such prominent Greek mathematicians would curb the criticism of modern scholars that the system was dysfunctional for mathematics. Yet many modern scholars denigrate the alphabetic numerals in comparison not only to ciphered-positional systems but also to cumulative-additive systems such as the acrophonic numerals (cf. Boyer 1944: 160–166). In particular, the need to learn many signs and the lack of resemblance between numeral-signs for common multiples of different powers (e.g., 5, 50, and 500) are perceived as serious weaknesses. In the only instance where a modern scholar actually attempted to learn and use the numerals, however, the system fared very well. The classicist Paul Tannery found that calculation with alphabetic numerals took little more effort than with Western numerals, with which Tannery, despite all his efforts, surely had far greater experience and familiarity (Boyer 1944: 160–161). In any event, only a small fraction of the Greek texts containing alphabetic numerals serve mathematical functions. Like virtually all numerical notation systems, numerals are primarily for representation and only secondarily for computation. Throughout their history, the Greek alphabetic numerals were used primarily in Greek-speaking areas or in regions under the control of Greek speakers. During its early history, the system was used in the eastern Mediterranean (particularly the Aegean), Ptolemaic Egypt, and Seleucid Persia. Cursive varieties of the alphabetic numerals on Greco-Egyptian papyri show a great deal of paleographic variability (Foat 1902, 1905). A large number of variant multiplicative signs for 1000 and 10,000 were used in these papyri, most notably Ô for 10,000, which was the normal form starting in the second century ad (Brashear 1985). While alphabetic numerals were not used for administration during the height of Roman power, from the fourth century ad onward, they were used as the primary numerals of administration, law, literature, and mathematics in the Eastern Roman Empire. Whenever and wherever the Greek alphabet was used in the Middle Ages, the alphabetic numerals followed. Additionally, the Greek alphabetic numerals were the most common system used in Arabic papyri for several centuries after the Islamic conquest for recording the results of financial transactions (Grohmann 1952: 89). Most of the descendants of the Greek alphabetic numerals substituted the letters of their own scripts for the Greek signs. In the late second century bc, the Israelites developed the Hebrew alphabetic numerals along a Greek model. In the mid fourth century ad, the Goths developed alphabetic numerals along with their Greek-influenced script, while in regions of Africa under Greek influence, the Coptic script of Egypt and the Ge’ez script used in Ethiopia both developed alphabetic numerical notation systems based on a Greek model. In Armenia and
146
Numerical Notation
Georgia, right on the border of the Eastern Roman Empire, scripts and alphabetic numeral systems developed in the fifth century ad at around the time they were Christianized. In the sixth century ad, the Syriac script abandoned an earlier cumulative-additive numerical notation system (Chapter 3) in favor of one based on the Greek. Around the same time, the Arabic abjad numerals used following the Islamic conquest of the Middle East were derived at least in part from the Greek alphabetic system. The Glagolitic and Cyrillic numerals, developed in Slavic regions in the late ninth century ad, under the auspices of the missionary-related script development of Cyril and Methodius, closely resemble their Greek ancestor. Finally, knowledge of the Greek alphabetic numerals in Western Europe led to the development of a set of Latin alphabetic numerals in the twelfth century ad. It is remotely possible that the Greek numerals are ancestral to the Brāhmī numerals (Chapter 6), which were used from the late fourth century bc onward in India, and which eventually gave rise to Western numerals. The Brāhmī numerical notation system is ciphered-additive and decimal, and used a variety of the multiplicative principle. The chronology of its invention, corresponding almost exactly with the Alexandrine conquests and journeys in India, is also suggestive. However, the Brāhmī system is more similar in structure and numeral-signs to the Egyptian demotic numerals than to the Greek alphabetic numerals. The large number of descendants of the Greek alphabetic numerals is due in part to their longevity. This cannot be a full explanation, however; other systems, such as the Egyptian hieroglyphs, were used over a much longer period, yet generated few direct descendants. Other long-lived systems, such as the Roman numerals, spread very widely over large parts of the world due to Roman imperial power, but they were often accepted by colonized or subordinate societies unchanged, and did not replace indigenous systems entirely. Because the Greek system was alphabetic, cultures borrowing the principle of alphabetic numeration tended to modify the signs to fit their own scripts (whether alphabets or consonantaries) rather than adopting the Greek alphabetic numerals directly, and also made minor structural changes to the system. In the early Middle Ages, when the Eastern Roman Empire’s fortunes were prosperous, the numerals were widely used throughout Greece, the Balkans, Egypt, the Levant, and Asia Minor, and were incorporated into the learning of all European mathematicians. For instance, they were known to the English scholar Bede, who described them in his De temporum ratione (The Reckoning of Time) in the early eighth century ad (Wallis 1999). Many Western European manuscripts include numerical glossaries, for instance, a tenth- to eleventh-century codex (Vatican Library, Codex Urbinas Latinus 290) that lists (among other information concerning non-Latin alphabets) the Greek lexical numerals, letter names, and alphabetic numerals along with their translations into Roman numerals
Alphabetic Systems
147
(Derolez 1954: 106–109). Such tables would have aided medieval scribes in understanding texts, but the Greek alphabetic numerals were not actively used except in rare instances. For instance, in one ninth-century Latin manuscript, the Greek numerals 1 (A) to 21 (KA) stand for the letters A through X in a cryptogram to indicate that it was written by Irish writers at the Welsh court of Merfyn Frych (824–844) (Derolez 1954: 97–99). Such cryptographic uses confirm rather than refute the obscurity of the system, however. In the Western European debate between the “abacists” and “algorithmicists,” the Greek alphabetic numerals, used by all the great mathematical minds of antiquity, did not rate a mention. The eventual fate of the Greek numerals was directly tied to the fortunes of the Byzantine Empire. Byzantine mathematicians and astronomers used alphabetic numerals exclusively until the twelfth century, and numerals such as regnal years were often stamped on Byzantine coins. By 1300, however, the geographical extent of the numerals’ use had become very limited, and mathematicians were using Western numerals under the influence of Arab learning in Spain and Italy. In the Byzantine Empire, mathematicians used Arabic positional numerals in marginal notes on Euclid’s Elements in the twelfth century (Wilson 1981). The first major Byzantine mathematician to recommend the switch to the Arabic numerals was Maximus Planudes (c. 1260–1310) (Schub 1932). In some Byzantine astronomical texts, Arabic numerals were used to write year numbers while Greek alphabetic numerals were used for all other functions; even then, the Greek equivalent of the Arabic numeral-phrase was often written in the margin of the page (Neugebauer 1960: 5). In a few late Byzantine mathematical texts, combinations of Greek alphabetic numerals and Arabic positional numerals with a zero occurred, such as υνο (400 + 50 + 0) instead of υν for 450 (Neugebauer 1960: 5). The ultimate extension of this principle was the use by some writers of only the first nine Greek letters (A through θ) to indicate the units, then adding a dot, a circle, or a special sign, Ч, to indicate a zero position (Schub 1932: 59; Menninger 1969: 273–274). In 1453, with the fall of Constantinople, the Greek numerals ceased to be used administratively. Nevertheless, they continued to be used thereafter for restricted purposes, such as paginating the introductions to scholarly texts and enumerating ordinal lists, just as the Roman numerals were used in Western Europe. Starting in the seventeenth century, the sign for 90 (qoppa), little used in alphabetic contexts, underwent a palaeographic alteration, so that a new, roughly Z-shaped sign served only as a numeral, while the older Q-shaped sign could serve both alphabetic and numerical functions, but was regarded as a different sign (Everson 1998). Alphabetic numerals are still used today in many Greek Bibles to enumerate chapter and verse numbers, in certain legal contexts, and in pagination. Given the prestige associated with these functions, it is unlikely that the alphabetic numerals will cease to be used entirely.
148
Numerical Notation
Coptic The Coptic language is the last descendant of the Egyptian languages. It was written using the Greek alphabet until the fourth century ad, when a distinctive Coptic alphabet originated based on a Greek model, but using six additional characters taken from the demotic script to express uniquely Egyptian phonemes. Unlike the earlier Egyptian scripts, it is written from left to right and has signs for vowels. The adoption of the Coptic script was accompanied by the introduction of a numerical notation system based on the model of the Greek alphabetic numerals (Megally 1991, Messiha 1994). The Coptic numeral-signs are shown in Table 5.4. The numerals, like the script itself, were written from left to right, and were ciphered-additive and decimal. The numeral-signs closely resemble the Greek uncial signs used between the fourth and ninth centuries ad. In addition, as in the Greek alphabetic numerals, a horizontal stroke above the numeral-phrase indicates that it is a numeral rather than a word, and a slanted subscript stroke under a unitsign (the Greek hasta) indicates multiplication by 1000 (Megally 1991: 1821). There is no known sign or multiplier for 10,000 or higher values for these numerals. The classical age of Coptic lasted from the fourth to the tenth centuries ad, during which time the script and numerals were used extensively, surviving the seventh-century ad Muslim conquest of Egypt. There may have been a geographical division in the frequency of their use, with northern Egyptian scribes using them frequently, while southern writers tended to write out numbers using lexical numerals (Till 1961: 80). While the Coptic numerals were generally used in formal manuscripts, the ordinary cursive Greek alphabetic numerals were used for calculation and administration, possibly because the Coptic numerals, being uncials without tails, were less practical for rapid writing (Megally 1991: 1821). It is unclear whether the Ethiopic numerals (used to write the Ge’ez language from the fourth century ad onward) were based directly on the Greek alphabetic numerals or derived through a Coptic intermediary. While the Ethiopic system is generally said to derive directly from Greek, the Coptic uncial letter-signs are similar enough to the Greek to render such a determination premature, and given the geographic proximity of Egypt and Ethiopia, this possibility cannot be dismissed outright. While the primary function of Coptic numerals has always been religious, in the context of the Coptic Church, their administrative and arithmetical functions should not be discounted. Despite the control of the population of Egypt by a succession of foreign powers, and despite the decline of Coptic as a spoken language from the twelfth century onward, the use of Coptic numerals continued as late as the fourteenth century. They are still used today in Coptic Christian liturgical texts for pagination and stichometry, although for most ordinary purposes, either Western or Arabic positional numerals are preferred by those familiar with Coptic.
Alphabetic Systems
149
Table 5.4. Coptic numerals 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1s 10s 100s 1000s 6085 =
ZIMĀM Numerals In Egypt in the tenth century ad, when the Coptic script was being replaced by Arabic for most administrative purposes, a different Coptic cursive numerical notation system developed, known as “numerals of the Epakt” (named after the computation used to resolve the discrepancy between the solar and lunar calendars) (Messiha 1994: 26) or, more generally, as ḥurūf al-zimām ‘account book; register’ numerals. Often simply labeled “Coptic numerals” in modern scholarship, it seems prudent to distinguish them from their uncial antecedents, particularly since the zimām numerals are often found alongside Arabic or Hebrew texts, not ones in the Coptic language or the Coptic alphabet. Their long-standing use in a wide variety of contexts renders their importance far greater than the restrictedfunction Coptic uncials. While doubtless many users of the zimām numerals were Coptic Christians from Egypt, this was certainly not an ironclad rule, and Egyptian Jews and Muslims writing in Arabic script frequently used Coptic numerals instead of the Arabic abjad or Hebrew alphabetic numerals. The zimām system is shown in Table 5.5. This system is structurally identical to the classical Coptic system, but the numeral-signs are cursive minuscule letters rather than uncial ones. Many of these signs bear little or no resemblance to the classical signs. Some of them are probably taken from the signs of the Arabic abjad numerals, which I will describe later, while others are of indigenous development. This system also uses two stages of multiplication (at 1000 and 10,000), like the Greek alphabetic system. A horizontal stroke and two dots placed below a sign indicated multiplication by 10,000 (Sesiano 1989: 64). A fifteenth-century multiplication table includes instructions on writing “numerals of the Epakt,” and indicates that this sign for 10,000 could be used in conjunction with any of the twenty-seven letters, thus allowing any number less than ten million to be expressed (Sesiano 1989: 54–55). It may be that the two-stage multiplicative principle at 1000 and 10,000 existed even in
Numerical Notation
150 Table 5.5. Zimām numerals 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1s 10s 100s 1000s 7104 =
the earlier uncial numerals, and that we simply have no paleographic evidence to confirm this. The paleographic relation between the first and second Coptic systems remains unclear; although some of the signs are related, more are not, and in fact many are modifications of Greek minuscule letters rather than Coptic uncials. These numerals were often used in early bilingual Arabic-Coptic documents, suggesting that the Arabs were making concessions to local administrators. This situation is quite extraordinary, because many Egyptian Arabs by this time were employing the ciphered-positional Arabic numerals used today. This suggests that the advantages of ciphered-positional systems over ciphered-additive ones may not have been perceived to be important. In addition to Arabs, many users of the zimām system were Egyptian Jews who used the system alongside their own alphabetic numerals (Goitein 1967–88: II, 178). Their primary functions were commercial, including contracts, bills of sale, payments, and accounts. There is no evidence for or against the position that numerals were manipulated for arithmetic; this surely would not have been done on permanent media, even perishable ones like papyrus. Although zimām numerals originated in commercial contexts and are rare in attested astronomical and mathematical texts, Lemay (1982: 384) has found one early text dating to ad 938 (MS Garullah Efendi 1508, Süleymanie Library, Istanbul) in which the numbers in the text are written lexically, the Arabic abjad numerals used in astronomical tables, and the zimām numerals used in pagination. King (1999: 76–78) discusses an astrolabe made in Cairo in ad 1282–83 with an Arabic inscription but zimām numerals. At this period, particularly in Egypt, the Coptic calendar was used for various purposes by Muslims, potentially explaining this artifact’s unusual blend of representational systems. Zimām numerals were also used very widely for pagination and foliation of Arabic texts written by adherents of all three Abrahamic faiths, throughout Egypt and more broadly throughout the Maghreb (Troupeau 1974). Mingana (1936: II, 183–184) reports that an Arabic
Alphabetic Systems
151
letter of bequest from 1586 relating to a Syriac Christian manuscript (Mingana Syriac 617) is dated in Coptic numerals (presumably zimām rather than uncial), suggesting that even at this late date, their use was widespread and not restricted to Coptic Christians and Egyptian Muslims. Although Coptic began to become obsolescent as a language in the twelfth century, and Coptic Christians made the transition to the Arabic language and script, the zimām numerals continued to be used widely in economic documents otherwise written in Arabic, and for divinatory purposes. Their obscurity lent itself to cryptographic uses; a letter sent in 1139 from the Egyptian Jewish trader Halfōn ben Nethanel to the poet Isaac ibn Ezra uses zimām numerals as a code for Hebrew characters that in turn denote Arabic words (Goitein 1971: II, 303). Their opacity and rarity could also be useful in avoiding fraud, for instance, on a thirteenth-century check in which the amount was written in Arabic words and zimām numerals, presumably because their obscurity made it less likely that they would be altered fraudulently (Reif 2002: 26).6 In the fourteenth-century Muqadimmah of Ibn Khaldūn, he mentions the use of “zimâm ciphers, the same as those used for numerals by government officials and accountants in the contemporary Maghrib” alongside the Arabic abjad numerals and the ghubar positional numerals (Chapter 6) in the zā’irajah technique of numerical divination (1958: I, 239). The zimām numerals played a considerable role in the development of the socalled Fez numerals used in Spain and parts of North Africa from the twelfth century onward (see the following discussion). Both the Greek alphabetic numerals and the Arabic abjad numerals were also involved in the development of the Fez numerals, however, and the paleographic lines of descent among these systems are complex. The problem is made more complex by the fact that the later users of zimām numerals were otherwise writing Arabic texts, not Coptic ones. Moreover, the Fez numerals are first attested in Spain, not in Africa. However, the similarities of some of the sign-forms for particular numerals suggest some relationship. The zimām numerals were used for several centuries, and survived the conquest of Egypt by the Ottoman Empire in 1517. Egyptian Coptic children in the sixteenth century learned Arabic before Coptic in kuttāb schools, and their practical education emphasized their assimilation to Ottoman practices, but they continued to learn and use zimām numerals for bookkeeping and accounting, thereby acquiring a reputation for competent and secure financial practices associated with 6
The use of highly ligatured Roman numerals in late medieval Europe, and of special complex numeral-signs in Chinese banking, are additional examples of the practice of using unusual numerical systems to avoid fraud, and are somewhat paralleled by the modern requirement of writing out numerals lexically in addition to using Western numerals on checks.
152
Numerical Notation
what was by this time a highly cryptic numerical code (Hamilton 2006: 38). They ceased to be used only in the seventeenth century, after which time Arabic positional numerals were used for these functions (Ritter 1936; Messiha 1994: 26).
Ethiopic The Ethiopic script developed in the late third century ad, primarily on the model of the Minaeo-Sabaean consonantary used in South Arabia, but also influenced by the Greek and Coptic alphabets used to the north. It was used (and continues to be used) for writing various languages of Ethiopia, especially Ge’ez, the liturgical language of the Ethiopian church, and modern Amharic. While the earliest Ethiopic script has no signs for vowels, by the fourth century ad, the script was an alphasyllabary, in which each individual sign represents a consonant + vowel. The direction of writing is always left to right. While the Ethiopic script is based on South Arabian writing, its numerical notation is strictly Greek and Coptic in origin. The earliest Ethiopic numerical notation, such as that found on third- and fourth-century inscriptions from the kingdom of Aksum (on which the signs for 70 and 90 are not found) is shown in Table 5.6 (Drewes 1962; Ifrah 1998: 247). The earliest inscription with Ethiopic numerals is on the late third-century Anza stela erected by Bazat, negus (local king) of Agabo, in which the highest number expressed is 20,620 (loaves of bread) (Drewes 1962: 65–67). The modern Ethiopic script uses a system derived from these early inscriptions, structurally unchanged but slightly modified, as shown in Table 5.7 (Fossey 1948: 99; Haile 1996: 574). The Ethiopic numeral-signs are not letters of the Ethiopic script, but rather are derived from the Greek or Coptic letters. Even though the signs have no nonnumerical meaning in Ethiopic, the signs normally have marks both above and below them to indicate that their value is numerical. This practice was universal only from the fifteenth century onward, and it is not found at all in the Aksum inscriptions (Ifrah 1998: 246–247). In addition to these signs, modern Amharic texts use a sign for 1000 ( ), which lacks marks above and below it (Bender et al. 1976: Table I). It may be that the minimal demand for writing very large numbers led to the abandonment of the higher multiplicative formations and the introduction of an indigenous 1000-sign. The system has a hybrid structure: it is ciphered-additive for the units and tens but multiplicative-additive for numbers over 100. For 10,000, a multiplicative sign consisting of two ligatured 100-signs was used, as shown in Table 5.7. Thus, because there are special signs for 100 and 10,000, the Ethiopic system has a mixed base of 10 and 100, with the base-10 formations governed by eighteen ciphered characters for 1 through 9 and 10 through 90 and the hundreds and ten thousands governed by multiplicative power-signs that combine with the ciphered signs.
Alphabetic Systems
153
Table 5.6. Ethiopic numerals (Aksumite period) 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1s 10s 100s 1000s
etc.
10,000s
etc.
20,620 =
This flexibility allowed the Ethiopic system to express very large numbers with a very limited set of numeral-signs. In theory, it could be extended infinitely by adding additional signs for 10,000 as needed, although such large numbers rarely occurred in practice (Guitel 1975: 272–273). The development of the Ethiopic system occurred under cultural contact and Christianization by Egyptian and Syrian missionaries. While some scholars argue that borrowing of the signs must have been from the Greek uncial script (Bender et al. 1976: 124; Ifrah 1998: 246), Haile (1996: 574) raises the possibility that this transmission might have taken place by means of a Coptic intermediary. Egyptian missionaries were active in Ethiopia throughout the fourth century ad, which might tip the scales slightly in favor of a Coptic origin. Saint Frumentius, generally held to be the first major converter of the Aksumites, was a Syrian by birth, trained by Greeks, but his missionary work was based in Alexandria and focused on establishing connections between the Aksumites and the Egyptian Copts. The Table 5.7. Ethiopic numerals (modern) 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1s 10s 100s 1000s 10,000s 647,035 = 100,000,000 =
(60 + 4) × 10,000 + 70 × 100 + 30 + 5 (10,000 × 10,000)
8
9
154
Numerical Notation
South Arabian numerals were already extinct by this time and had no influence on the Ethiopic system. The use of base-100 for the multiplicative component of the system is the Ethiopic system’s most notable feature. No other alphabetic system begins using the multiplicative principle until 1000 or 10,000. This innovation had a clear antecedent in the Greek and Coptic use of multiplication at 10,000, but it eschews the extra nine signs for 100 through 900 needed for both Greek and Coptic numerals. Instead, it employs the entire set of eighteen ciphered signs, then the same set again beside the 100-sign, then the same set beside the 10,000-sign. While the Ethiopic numerals were based on the Greek or Coptic systems, the Ethiopic script was not. Of all the descendants of the Greek alphabetic numerals, the Ethiopic system is the only one to use non-phonetic signs as numeral-signs. While this makes it more cumbersome, since one needs to learn all the script-signs as well as twenty numeral-signs, there is also no impetus to use all the borrowed numeral-signs. In systems that assign numerical values to an ordered series of script-signs, it is natural that one would assign values to all the signs, rather than stopping at some arbitrary point. In this case, however, the Aksumites borrowed the first eighteen symbols of the alphabet and then, rather than adopting another nine signs for 100 through 900, which were meaningless to them, took only the sign for 100 and used the multiplicative principle thereafter, thereby reducing the number of new signs they needed to learn. Many Aksumite inscriptions on coins (indicating regnal years) and stone monuments (indicating cardinal and ordinal quantities of various kinds) contain Ethiopic numerals. After the fall of the kingdom of Aksum and the Islamic conquest, the Ethiopic script was used only rarely, and over time became an esoteric script known only to scholars and Ethiopian Orthodox priests. It was used in the mathematical, numerological, and astronomical texts of medieval Ethiopia, both for writing whole numbers and for writing fractions in a special sexagesimal notation based on Greek traditions (Neugebauer 1979; see the following discussion). In Amharic texts, Ethiopic numerals were used for a wider variety of functions from the fifteenth century to the present day; for instance, they were used in the personal correspondence of Amharic elites in the nineteenth century (Pankhurst 1985). The New Testament printed in Amharic in 1852 uses the Ethiopic numerals throughout for page, chapter, and verse numbers (Novum Testamentum in linguam amharicam 1852). Today, the numerals are still occasionally used for writing dates, but have largely been supplanted by the Western numerals (Bender et al. 1976: 124).
Gothic The Gothic alphabet was developed around 350 ad by Wulfila, a bishop who translated the Bible into his native language. Gothic was an East Germanic language
Alphabetic Systems
155
Table 5.8. Gothic numerals 1
2
a b 10s j k 100s s t 665 = .xoe.
1s
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
c l u
d m v
e n w
f o x
g p y
h q z
i r {
spoken by the Germanic tribes who migrated throughout Europe in the latter years of the Western Roman Empire (Ebbinghaus 1996: 290). The script was alphabetic and written from left to right. Along with the script, an alphabetic numerical notation system was employed, as indicated in Table 5.8 (Braune and Ebbinghaus 1966: 10). Like the Greek alphabetic numerals, the Gothic numerals were usually distinguished from the rest of the text either through dots to either side of the numeralphrase or by placing a horizontal stroke above the phrase (Braune and Ebbinghaus 1966: 10). The Gothic numerals never expressed quantities higher than 1000, and thus there is no evidence of the use of the multiplicative principle. Larger numbers were always written out in full (Menninger 1969: 260). The system is therefore ciphered-additive and decimal throughout. The numeral-signs are related to the Greek uncial letters. Of the episemons, f (6) was the sixth letter of the Gothic alphabet, and had the phonetic value [kw]. The other two episemons, qoppa (r) and san ({), had no phonetic value and were simply used to fill out the full complement of twenty-seven signs using Greek models (Fairbanks and Magoun 1940: 319). The possibility has been considered, but now largely rejected, that the Gothic script owes its ancestry at least in part to either the Latin alphabet or the Germanic runes (Ebbinghaus 1996: 290–291). However, since neither of these scripts uses alphabetic numerals, the Gothic numerals must be of Greek origin. The Gothic alphabet is attested in only a limited set of documents, mostly translations of parts of the New Testament, but also in a small number of secular texts. Most numerals in Gothic texts indicate chapter and verse numbers in Bibles. Additionally, they were used within the text to indicate numerical values, while in Greek Bibles such numbers were always written out in full (Menninger 1969: 260). There is no evidence that the Goths ever did arithmetic or mathematics using these numerals. The sign for 900 is only attested in the Codex Vindobonensis 795, an antiquarian text of the ninth century, by which time the script had already fallen out of use (Fairbanks and Magoun 1940, Ebbinghaus 1978).
156
Numerical Notation
Very little of what surely must have been written in Gothic has survived. Most surviving texts date to the sixth century ad, although the assignment of a fourth- century ad origin to the numerals is undisputed. It is unclear exactly when in the seventh or early eighth century the Gothic language died out, but around that time the script and numerals ceased to be used, and were replaced by the Roman numerals that were coming to be used throughout Western Europe.
Hebrew Alphabetic The earliest Hebrew scripts began to diverge from the earlier Phoenician consonantary in the ninth or tenth century bc. Then as now, Hebrew consisted of twenty-two consonantal signs, written from right to left, and placed in a customary order. Early Hebrew inscriptions used a variant of the Egyptian hieratic numerals (Chapter 2). Somewhat later, particularly in the fifth and fourth centuries bc, some Hebrew speakers used the Aramaic numerals (Chapter 3) for administrative and commercial purposes. Only at a much later date, probably in the second century bc, did a uniquely Hebrew set of numerals develop. This system is indicated in Table 5.9. The first twenty-two signs, indicating 1 through 400, are the letters of the Hasmonean Hebrew script circa 125 bc, at the time of the writing of the Dead Sea Scrolls and also when the numerals were first used (Goerwitz 1996: 488). The system is decimal and ciphered-additive, and written from right to left. Values between 500 and 900 were represented using the sign for 400 in conjunction with one or more signs for the lower hundreds (i.e., 500 = 400 + 100, 600 = 400 + 200 ... 900 = 400 + 400 + 100). This structural irregularity exists because there are too few letters in the Hebrew consonantary to fill out the twenty-seven signs needed to extend the system to 900. The number 400 occupies a special structural role, but is not a base of the system, as its powers (16,000, 6,400,000, etc.) do not receive any special treatment. While the very earliest Hebrew inscriptions contain no signs for numbers above 1000, the need to do so quickly arose, as the numerals began to be used for dating on grave inscriptions using the Hebrew calendar. For multiples of 1000, a mark – either a small curved stroke to the left of a numeral-sign or two dots placed above it – could be used to indicate multiplication by 1000; thus, would signify 9000 and 90,000. This feature is similar to, but distinct from, the Greek alphabetic system, which adds a stroke above or below a numeral to indicate multiplication by 1000, but begins again at 10,000 by placing the multiplicand above the sign Z. Thus, while the Greek system could express any numeral up to ten million, as opposed to one million for the Hebrew numerals, the Hebrew system is arguably easier to use because it has only one value at which the multiplicative principle is employed.
Alphabetic Systems
157
Table 5.9. Hebrew alphabetic numerals (Hasmonean) 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1s 10s 100s 369 =
The Hebrew alphabetic numerals were derived from the Greek alphabetic numerals between 125 and 100 bc for use on coins inscribed with the Hasmonean script (Gandz 1933: 76; Millard 1995: 192). Theories of a much earlier (ninth- to seventh-century bc) independent origin are no longer credible (Smith and Karpinski 1911: 33; Gandz 1933: 75–76; Schanzlin 1934; Zabilka 1968: 176–178). A bilingual ostracon from the Palestinian village of Khirbet el-Qôm and dating to 277 bc uses both Aramaic and Greek alphabetic numerals to denote a financial transaction (Geraty 1975). Although it is not a Hebrew text, the village was in Judah and hundreds of contemporary Hebrew inscriptions have been found there. If the Hebrew alphabetic numerals had been in use at that time, they likely would have been used instead of the Aramaic numerals in a situation where the Greek inscription a few lines below used a similar system. The first safely dated instance in which the use of Hebrew alphabetic numerals is certain is on coins from the reign of the Hasmonean king Alexander Janneus (103 to 76 bc), some of which were stamped with Greek script and alphabetic numerals, others with the Hebrew script and alphabetic numerals, in both cases using alphabetic signs (Naveh 1968). Avigad (1975) suggests that a clay seal reading “Jonathan high priest Jerusalem M)” might refer to the fortieth (m = 40) year of the Hasmonean kings, and thus dates it to 103 bc, early in the reign of Alexander Janneus, whose Hebrew name was Jonathan. That these early Hebrew alphabetic numerals would both be found in the context of the same man is strong circumstantial evidence. Despite the special formation of Hebrew numerals from 500 to 900, the similarities between the Greek and Hebrew numerical notation systems are striking. The two systems share not only a similar structure (decimal and ciphered-additive) but also the alphabetic principle for forming the numeral-signs. The notion that the Hebrew numerals were independently developed can no longer seriously be sustained, despite the agnostic attitude of some scholars, including Ifrah (1998: 239). That Hasmonean coins were struck in both languages and using both systems provides specific contextual evidence that the Hasmonean kings adopted the technique
158
Numerical Notation
from the Greeks. The cultural influence of the Ptolemaic and Seleucid kingdoms in the Levant at this time was enormous; Greek alphabetic numerals were used on coins from the Phoenician cities of Sidon, Tyre, Byblos, and Akon from the mid third century bc onward (Millard 1995: 193). At the same time, the Hebrew use of 400 as a “stepping-stone” for representing the higher hundreds is an important innovation, as it did not require that Hebrew speakers learn and adopt additional nonphonetic signs. Despite the development of the Hebrew numerals, most Semitic peoples of the ancient Levant (Nabataeans, Aramaeans, Palmyrans) never used alphabetic numerals, but continued to use their own hybrid cumulative-additive/multiplicativeadditive systems (Chapter 3), which coexisted with the Hebrew alphabetic system for several centuries, and were replaced only over a long period. Until the seventh century ad, inscriptions on Jewish graves throughout the Mediterranean region were often written, not with the Hebrew numerals, but rather in the Greek alphabetic numerals (Ifrah 1998: 238–239). Gradually, the Hebrew numerals replaced the Greek and Levantine systems, until they were firmly established as a distinctive system peculiar to the Jewish populations of Europe, North Africa, and the Levant. Also, in the sixth century ad, the Hebrew numerals were partly or wholly used by the creators of the Syriac alphabetic numerals (to be discussed), which are also ciphered-additive and decimal and have the same break at 400 as the Hebrew system. The modern Hebrew alphabetic numerical notation system has the same structure as the ancient system, but uses modern script-signs, as shown in Table 5.10. Around the beginning of the tenth century, five additional Hebrew characters, the signs used for kof, mem, nun, pe, and tsade in word-final position, were sometimes used to complete the sign set for 500 through 900. These signs occur in some Masoretic commentaries on the Old Testament, but were never the regular forms used (Gandz 1933: 96–102). The older formations using additive combinations of hundreds-signs are the usual means of representation. The newer forms probably were not widely accepted because the word-finality of these signs is inconsistent with the principle of the numerical notation system that the highest values should come first in a numeral-phrase (Gandz 1933: 98). To put a word-final letter for 500 through 900 at the head of a numeral-phrase would be inconsistent with its original purpose; to put it at the end of the numeral-phrase would be inconsistent with the rule of decreasing ordering of the powers. Also in the tenth century, Hebrew scholars became aware of positional numerals, and occasionally experimented using combinations of the alphabetic numerals and the positional principle. In a Masoretic poem by Saadia Gaon (ad 882–942), numbers are written quasi-positionally in two columns; the rightmost represents the thousands, while the leftmost column represents the ones, so that 42,377 was
Alphabetic Systems
159
Table 5.10. Hebrew alphabetic numerals (modern) 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1s 10s 100s OR
, i.e., (7 + 70 + 300) + ((2 + 40) × 1000) (Gandz 1970: 487–488). written as Some medieval Hebrew writers simply used the first nine alphabetic symbols in place of the ordinary Western or Arabic signs, supplementing them with a circle for zero, which made the system ciphered-positional (Gandz 1933: 110). This practice is first attested in the mid twelfth-century Sefer ha-Mispar of Abraham ibn Ezra (Burnett 2000c: 14). The ordinary Hebrew numerals were always used in the regular text of such works, with the positional variants used only for mathematical expressions (Schub 1932). This technique was not commonly used, however, and later Hebrew mathematicians and astronomers simply used Western or Arabic numerals. One of the more important functions for which the Hebrew numerals have been used historically is gematria, the art of number-magic (Ifrah 1998: 250–256). Because every letter of the Hebrew script has a numerical value, every Hebrew word has a numerical value equal to the sum of its letters’ values. Among medieval and early modern scholars, this practice was commonly employed for interpreting passages from the Talmud and the Midrash and for finding symbolic associations among words that share the same numerical value. For instance, two of the terms associated with the Messiah, shema ‘seed’ and menakhem ‘consoler’, have the same numerical value (8 + 40 + 90 = 40 + 8 +50 + 40 = 138). A related practice is the construction of chronograms, in which a specified set of words has a numerical value equal to the date of an event (e.g., a person’s death) to which the words refer. Because these practices (also used with the Arabic abjad, described below) can only be done with a system for correlating phonetic signs with numerical values, they probably contributed to the retention of the alphabetic numerical notation systems long after ciphered-positional systems had been adopted. While the Western numerals are used in modern Israel for most purposes, the alphabetic system is regularly used for dates using the traditional Jewish calendar, especially in religious texts and on graves. In 1999, the Israeli Supreme Court ruled that gravestones in orthodox Jewish cemeteries could henceforth record numbers using Western numerals rather than the Hebrew alphabetic system, whose use had previously been mandatory in that context (Copans 1999). It is unclear whether this ruling will have any long-term effect on the use of the Hebrew numerals for
160
Numerical Notation
dating. However, the fact that such a ruling needed to be made at all shows the continued health and vibrancy of Hebrew alphabetic numerals, albeit in a limited set of religious contexts. The Hebrew alphabetic numerical notation system is now over two millennia old, and is one of the oldest systems in continuous and regular use.
Syriac Alphabetic In Chapter 3, I described the numerals used alongside the Old Syriac script between about 50 and 500 ad. Around the fifth century ad, this script diverged into two forms: an eastern variety, Nestorian, used by the Christians of Persia, and a western variety, the Serto script used by the Jacobite Christians of Syria (Daniels 1996). This split was precipitated by the expulsion of the Nestorian Christians from the Byzantine city of Edessa and their subsequent migration into the Sassanian Empire (Duval 1881: vii). Soon thereafter, both the Nestorian and Serto scripts began to use an alphabetic numeral system akin to those used elsewhere in the Middle East. The basic signs of this system (sign-forms are those of the Serto script) are shown in Table 5.11. The system is decimal and ciphered-additive, and written from right to left. As in many alphabetic numeral systems, numerals were sometimes distinguished from letters by placing a horizontal stroke above a numeral-phrase, but often no special mark was present. Like the Hebrew alphabetic numerals, values from 500 to 900 were usually written using the signs for the lower hundreds with the sign for 400 in various additive combinations. Alternately, the upper hundreds were occasionally expressed multiplicatively, by placing a small dot above the signs for 50 through 90 to indicate multiplication by 10 (Duval 1881: 15; Noldeke 1904: 316–317). For values above 1000, a slanted stroke placed beneath a unit-sign indicates multiplication by 1000, while a horizontal stroke placed beneath a sign indicates multiplication by 10,000 (Hoffman 1858: 6–7). In this way, any number below ten million could be expressed. Even higher values could be expressed by placing two small strokes beneath a sign to indicate multiplication by ten million, and placing one small stroke above and one small stroke beneath a sign indicated multiplication by ten billion; however, these techniques were used extremely rarely and not followed uniformly (Duval 1881: 15–16). As in several other alphabetic systems, placing an oblique stroke above a numeral-sign indicated the appropriate (1/x) unit fraction (Duval 1881: 16). The Syriac alphabetic numerical notation system was probably invented in the sixth century ad, and gradually replaced the Old Syriac system over the next two hundred years (Duval 1881: 15). Independent invention of this system can be ruled out, given its strong similarity to others used in the region. Two likely possibilities
Alphabetic Systems
161
Table 5.11. Syriac alphabetic numerals
1s 10s 100s
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
a j s
b k t
c l u
d m v
e n sv w\ /e -e
f o tv x /f -f
g p uv y /g -g
h q vv \z /h -h
i r svv , /i -i
OR
/a 10,000s -a 369 = iou 1000s
/b -b
/c -c
/d -d
are that it was modeled on the Greek alphabetic numerals prevalent in the Byzantine Empire or else on the Hebrew alphabetic numerals. The Hebrew and Syriac numerals are the only two systems in which 400 occupies a special structuring role, in that the higher hundreds are expressed using additive combinations of 400 and the lower hundreds. The ordering of the Syriac numerals follows the letter-order shared by the Syriac and Hebrew scripts, not that of Greek. Finally, the Syriac system was written from right to left like the Hebrew system, but unlike the Greek. On the other hand, the Syrians were closely affiliated with Eastern (Greek) Christianity, and many Syrians lived under Byzantine rule. The hypothesis of Greek ancestry is supported by the shared feature of the two systems that the multiplicative principle was used at two different powers of the base, 1000 and 10,000, whereas the Hebrew numerals did so only at 1000. The inventor(s) of the Syriac numerals probably would have been familiar with both the Greek and Hebrew numerals, so it is possible that features of both systems were blended in the Syriac system. The Syriac scripts were never used as the official script of any polity, and thus Syriac numerals are rarely found on stone monuments or coins. However, their use in religious texts is extremely prevalent from the time of their invention to the present day, a situation afforded by the relative separation of the Jacobites and Nestorians from both Roman and Greek Christianity. Most Syriac liturgical texts are dated and paginated using the numerals, making it easy to examine paleographic changes. There is no evidence that the Syriac numerals were ever used in mathematical texts, nor, in contrast to the Hebrew numerals, were they used for letter-magic or numerology. Although the heyday of the Syriac scripts came and went before ad 1000, both the Nestorian and Serto scripts survive to this day, the former in Iraq, Turkey, and Iran among a small number of Nestorian Christians, the latter in Lebanon
162
Numerical Notation
among the Maronite Christians of that country. Both scripts retain their distinctive numerical notation systems, albeit restricted in the contexts of their use to the same liturgical functions for which they have been employed for nearly 1,500 years. Arabic or Western numerals serve most other purposes. Nevertheless, there is no reason to think that the Syriac numerals are about to disappear, particularly given the special status accorded to Maronite Christianity in Lebanon’s 1990 constitution.
Arabic Abjad In pre-Islamic times, Arabic speakers used a variety of the Nabataean script and numerals (Chapter 3). While the classical Arabic script is directly descended from this ancestor, the Nabataean hybrid cumulative-additive/multiplicative-additive numerals were abandoned in favor of a ciphered-additive system based on the Arabic script-signs. The basic signs of this system are shown in Table 5.12 (Saidan 1996: 332). The system is decimal and ciphered-additive below 1000 and, like the Arabic script, is written from right to left with the signs in descending order. The numeralsigns shown are the unligatured signs of the Arabic consonantary; in numeralphrases, signs were ligatured to one another as appropriate for the letters in question. Often, a horizontal stroke was placed above a numeral-phrase to distinguish it from an ordinary word. Curiously, the signs are not valued according to the normal Arabic letter-order, but rather according to the letter-order of the Hebrew and Syriac scripts, which was also the order used early in the Arabic script’s history. The first three signs of this order (‘alif, ba, jim) gave the system its most common name, h.isa-b abjad.7 Because the Arabic script has twenty-eight basic consonantal signs, the remaining sign, ghayn (;), was assigned the numerical value of 1000. Ghayn was not used as a single unit-sign, but as a multiplier in numeral-phrases by placing another sign before it. In this way, any number up to and including one million could be written. The system is thus multiplicative-additive above 1000. The values assigned to six of the abjad numerals were different among users of the Arabic script in the Maghreb (North Africa and Spain). This ordering developed somewhat later than that used elsewhere, probably in the ninth century ad. Other than the different values assigned to the six signs in Table 5.13, the system is structurally identical to the regular abjad numerals. It is possible that the abjad numerical system is of pre-Islamic origin, and that it spread from the north. However, it is more likely to have originated around 650 ad, at or shortly after the time of the early Islamic conquests in Syria, Egypt, 7
The first three letters in the modern Arabic script are ‘alif, ba, and ta.
Alphabetic Systems
163
Table 5.12. Arabic abjad numerals 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
b k t
c l u
d m v
e n w
f o x
g p y
h q z
i r :
1000
a j s ;
7642 =
b m x;g (7 × 1000 + 600 + 40 + 2)
1s 10s 100s
and Mesopotamia. Under Byzantine rule, this region used the Greek alphabetic numerals for administrative and commercial functions; furthermore, both the Syriac and Hebrew alphabetic numerals were used in their respective scripts. The abjad numeral-signs have exactly the same order as the corresponding Syriac and Hebrew characters up to 400 (above which point the other two systems are structurally irregular). The Arabic script adopted a different letter-order starting in the eighth century ad, but the older order was retained for the numerals. The Greek system follows an order similar to that of the Syriac and Hebrew numerals up to 80, but diverges thereafter by putting sampi (equivalent to the Hebrew tsade) at the end of the system, rather than in the middle. Thus, either the Hebrew or Syriac systems inspired the development of the Arabic abjad numerals (Guitel 1975: 276–278; Ifrah 1998: 243). Table 5.14 illustrates how the Arabic order is directly parallel to the Hebrew and Syriac, while the Greek numerals diverge from them starting at 90. Table 5.13. Arabic abjad numerals (Eastern vs. Maghreb) Sign
o r u z : ;
Letter-name
Eastern Value
Maghreb Value
sin
60
300
sad
90
60
shin
300
1000
dad
800
90
ẓa
900
800
ghayn
1000
900
Numerical Notation
164
Table 5.14. Arabic, Greek, Hebrew, and Syriac numeral-signs and letters Arabic 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900
o p q r s t u v w x y z :
Greek sin ayin fa sad qaf ra shin ta tha kha dhal dad ẓa
X O P < R S T U F C Y W >\
Hebrew
Syriac
xi
samekh
omicron
ayin
pi
pe
qoppa
tsade
rho
quf
sigma
resh
tau
shin
upsilon
tav
phi chi psi omega sampi
o p q r s t u v w x y z ,
semkat ‘e pe sode quf rish shin taw
However, the Arabic abjad was rarely used in the same texts as either the Hebrew or the Syriac numerals. In contrast, Greek alphabetic numerals are found in Arabic documents from the seventh to the ninth centuries ad. In ad 706, Caliph Walid I dictated that, although his Greek financial administrators in Damascus should no longer use the Greek alphabet, they could continue to use the Greek alphabetical numerals (Menninger 1969: 410). In an eighth-century ad Arabic tax record, numbers are expressed in both Greek alphabetic numerals and abjad numerals (Cajori 1928: 29). Because many of the regions conquered by the Arabs – even those such as Syria and Palestine in which the Syriac or Hebrew numerals were found – were under Greek rule, Greek numerals were the normal system used for administration, on coins, and in inscriptions. It is unlikely that the Greek system played no role in the development of the abjad numerals. The phonetic values of the final six Arabic characters do not correspond to the Greek, however. Furthermore, the Greek system has only twenty-seven rather than twenty-eight signs (lacking a sign for 1000). While the Arabs were aware that the Greek system had signs for the higher hundreds, and may thus have attached
Alphabetic Systems
165
numerical values to the remaining signs in their own script, the use of a special sign for 1000 is unique to the Arabic system among all four systems under consideration. More likely, the Arabic system was based on the Semitic letter-order but employed the structural advantages of a system, such as the Greek, with a full complement of numeral-signs. This feature would have been particularly important, since the administrative needs of the new Islamic caliphate were growing rapidly. By the late eighth century ad, the Arabic abjad numerals had spread throughout the Middle East and into the Maghreb, including southern Spain. They were used on administrative documents, in literary and scientific texts, on dated coins, and on monuments, though not for the most part on ephemeral media such as ostraca. In areas in which an existing administrative apparatus was retained from the Byzantine Empire (such as Egypt), the Greek and Coptic alphabetic numerals were used much more frequently on administrative and financial documents than were the abjad numerals (Grohmann 1952: 89). While the systems are structurally similar to the abjad numerals, it would have taken some effort for Arabic writers to learn an entirely new set of twenty-seven signs, so its failure to be used more widely is somewhat surprising. Issues of identity and ethnicity may have played a significant role in determining the scope of their use. For instance, Ifrah describes a ninth-century ad Christian manuscript written in Arabic but in which the verses are numbered in Greek (Ifrah 1998: 243). In this case, the writer was a Christian who associated himself with Greek Christianity through the alphabetic numerals even though he wrote in the Arabic language and script. Abjad numerals were rarely if ever used directly for arithmetical calculation. Instead, a system of finger computing borrowed from the Byzantine Greeks, and known as h.isab al-’uqūd (finger-joint arithmetic), was employed (Saidan 1974: 367–368), as well as computation on dust-covered boards. Despite their use over a wide area, the abjad numerals did not give rise to a large number of descendants. In part, this must be due to the remarkable stability of the Arabic script itself. The Coptic zimām numerals used in Egypt from the tenth century ad onward are an interesting blend of Greek and Arabic influences, although relatively few of the numeral-signs are evidently based on those of the abjad, and it is unclear to what extent the Arabic abjad affected the structure of the system. A similar situation probably arose in Morocco, where “Fez numerals,” incorporating elements of the Arabic abjad as well as Greco-Coptic alphabetic numerals, were used until very recently (Colin 1933). Finally, like Greek and Hebrew scholars, Arabic astronomers used a very unusual system for writing fractions, which combines a ciphered-additive system with a base-60 (sexagesimal) positional notation. Shortly after they were invented, the abjad numerals began to be supplanted by the well-known ciphered-positional Arabic system (Chapter 6) borrowed from
166
Numerical Notation
the Hindus, and known in Arabic as al-h.isāb al-hindī (Indian arithmetic). The Islamic conquest of enormous territories to the east brought the Arabic and Indian spheres of influence into close contact by the mid seventh century. As Islam spread eastward throughout the eighth century ad as far as the Indus River, the Indian style of numeration began to diffuse westward and supplant the Arabic abjad, which itself was still a novelty in western regions such as North Africa. This replacement was hastened by the arrival in 773 ad of Hindu astronomers and astronomical knowledge at the court of Caliph al-Mansur in Baghdad, which formed the basis for the early ninth-century ad writings of the famed Arab mathematician al-Khwārizmī, who popularized the Arabic positional system (Menninger 1969: 410–411). By the late ninth century, the positional system was being used in administrative and financial documents, and by the late tenth century, on inscriptions (Grohmann 1952: 89). The latest Arabic papyrus in which abjad numerals express a date is from 517 ah, or 1123/4 ad (Destombes 1987: 131). Despite the introduction of positional notation, abjad numerals survived in a variety of contexts. Astronomers continued to use ordinary abjad numerals much later than other writers, probably because they had also adapted them for use in the quasi-positional sexagesimal fractions to be described later. Until the thirteenth century all astronomical and astrological texts used abjad numerals alone, and for several centuries thereafter, abjad and positional numerals were often used side by side in any given text (Lemay 1982: 385–386). Abjad numerals were commonly used on most Arabic astrolabes (both for marking gradations on the instrument and for recording dates of construction) until the sixteenth century (Destombes 1987). Mauritanian mathematicians did not adopt Arabic positional numerals until the end of the eighteenth century (Rebstock 1990). That positional numerals would be adopted more rapidly in nontechnical manuscripts than in scientific ones is seemingly paradoxical, but only because it is customarily assumed that positional numerals would be accepted owing to their efficiency for arithmetic. In fact, however, Arabic arithmetic was largely conducted using dust-boards, flat surfaces covered with a layer of fine dust on which calculations could be made using any numerical system, but of course no record of this would survive; in contrast, permanent records were often made in more traditional and authoritative numerical systems like the abjad numerals (Lemay 1982: 383–384). We do not know to what extent pre-modern Arabic astronomers may have performed computations using Arabic positional numerals. The abjad numerals survive to the present for very limited cryptographic, literary, and magical functions, such as chronograms (described earlier for Hebrew numerals), known in Arabic as h.isāb al-djummal (Colin 1971: 468). Chronograms using the abjad numerals were common throughout the Middle Ages, particularly in Persia and Islamized parts of India (Ahmad 1973). Babajanov and Szuppe
Alphabetic Systems
167
(2002) have recently published an unusual Persian cryptographic inscription in Arabic script dating to 1790 from the site of Chār Bakr near Bukhara, Uzbekistan. It is notable not only for its late date, but also because it records the computational work performed in translating the name whose numerical value is being taken (into abjad numerals, then into Arabic figures, then performing arithmetical calculations [using Arabic positional numerals] to double the entire abjad value to give the number associated with the unnamed writer). Finally, the abjad numerals were retained for pagination of prefaces and tables of contents of books, in a manner similar to the Western conventional use of the Roman numerals (Colin 1960: 97). Abjad numerals survived particularly well in the Maghreb, and continue to be used there for chronograms, cryptographic correspondence, and functions related to magic and divination. Several abjad-derived systems were used by nineteenth-century Ottoman administrators for cryptographic purposes (Chapter 10) (Decourdemanche 1899). Similarly, Monteil (1951) describes a text from Mali that discusses many cryptographic systems derived from the abjad numerals that were used in North Africa in the mid twentieth century.8 Most modern Arabic grammars mention the existence of abjad numerals and note the numerical values of the various letters.
Astronomical Fractions In addition to the ciphered-additive decimal systems peculiar to their civilizations, ancient and medieval astronomers from various linguistic backgrounds and script traditions used distinct systems for fractions, combining their ordinary alphabetic numerals with a base of 60 and the positional principle, borrowed from Babylonian astronomy. This ingenious system of astronomical fractions represents a curious digression in the history of numerical notation. From about 2100 bc to 0 ad, Babylonian astronomers and mathematicians used a cumulative-positional numerical notation system with a base of 60 and a sub-base of 10 (see Chapter 7). Numbers smaller than 60 were expressed through cumulative combinations of cuneiform signs for 10 (l) and 1 (k), while the positional principle was used to express multiples of powers of 60 (60, 3600, 216,000, ...). By the third century bc Greeks firmly controlled most of the lands formerly under Babylonian rule, under the potent Seleucid kingdom that came into existence after the Alexandrine conquests. At some point between the third and first centuries bc, the Babylonian positional notation and the sexagesimal base were married to the Greek ciphered-additive numerals and used thereafter by Greek astronomers (Jones 1999: 9). The first Greek 8
Curiously, one of these systems is known as el-Yunani (Ionian!), suggesting that its users were aware of the Greek origin of such notations.
Numerical Notation
168
Table 5.15. Astronomical numerals (Greek) 1
2
a b 10s i k /afie k ie 1s
1515
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
g l
d m
e n
v
z
h
q
+ 20 (× 1/60) + 15 (× 1/3600) = 1515.3375
mathematical astronomer to use sexagesimal notation was Hypsicles in the second century bc (Fowler 1999). The first major text in which this new system appeared was the Syntaxis of Ptolemy, written in the second century ad (Heath 1921: 44–45). In place of the cumulative Babylonian signs in each position, fourteen of the Greek alphabetic numerals were used (the units 1 through 9 and the decades 10 through 50) to write any number from 1 through 59, as shown in Table 5.15. Unlike the Babylonian system, however, the Greek sexagesimal system was never used for expressing integers. Numbers greater than 60 were always written with the ordinary alphabetic numerals. The sexagesimal numerals correspond to Greek astronomy, in which, as today, the circle is divided into 360 degrees, each degree into 60 minutes, each minute into 60 seconds, and so on. Thus, in Theon of Alexandria’s (fourth-century ad) commentary on Ptolemy’s Syntaxis, the numeral-phrase /afie k ie expresses 1515 (/afie) degrees, 20 (k) minutes, and 15 (ie) seconds (Thomas 1962: 50–51). The degrees value uses the decimal alphabetic numerals,9 while the latter two positions are sexagesimal. Sexagesimal fractions could be used to express any fractional value; successive positions represent 1/60, 1/602, 1/603, and so on, to express as small a value as desired. Within each sexagesimal position, decimal ciphered-additive numeral-phrases represent the value from 1 to 59. However, the primary base of the system – the one involved in the positional aspect of the system – is 60; thus, 10 (the base of the ordinary alphabetic numerals) becomes the sub-base of the sexagesimal fractions. The system’s base and sub-base thus follow the Babylonian system, but the intraexponential principle used in forming the signs of each position is ciphered rather than cumulative. This system is thus both ciphered and positional, but it is not identical to ordinary ciphered-positional systems such as the Western numerals. Rather, because it has a sub-base, it is intraexponentially cipheredadditive rather than simply ciphered. It is thus a (ciphered-additive)-positional system. 9
If this value were expressed sexagesimally, we would expect it to be written as ke ie, or (25 × 60) + 15.
Alphabetic Systems
169
The astronomical numerals used a special sign as a placeholder to indicate an empty position in order to avoid ambiguity. In some late (fourth- to first-century bc) Babylonian texts, a placeholder sign that served some of the functions of zero was used (see Chapter 7). Greek astronomers from the first century ad onward took up this practice, originally using a sign (, which in later manuscripts was written as ) (Irani 1955; Jones 1999: 61–62). The latter sign is sometimes held to represent omicron, the first letter of the Greek word ouden, ‘nothing’, with a stroke added above to distinguish it from the appropriate letter (Ifrah 1998: 549). Yet it is unlikely that the Greeks would have chosen a sign that already had a numerical value (o\= omicron = 70) in the alphabetic system (Neugebauer 1957: 14; Jones 1999: 61). The zero-sign was probably a paleographic outgrowth of the earlier form, which was, like the Babylonian placeholder sign, purely ideographic. As far as can be discerned, however, it is completely unrelated to the later Hindu zero, which emerged in the sixth century ad in India. The principle of sexagesimal fractions could, in theory, be combined with any alphabetic numeral system, replacing the Greek signs for 1 through 59 with those of any other system. The Arabs, who inherited the bulk of Greek astronomical knowledge when they took control of Mesopotamia in the mid seventh century ad, used the signs of the Arabic abjad rather than the Greek alphabetic numeral-signs. Unlike the abjad numerals, the Arabic sexagesimal fractions are written from left to right, following the Greek practice, and the Arabic symbol for zero (), or later () is derived from the Greek symbol (Irani 1955). Similarly, medieval Hebrew astronomers adopted sexagesimal fractions, as in the fourteenth-century astronomical writings of Levi Ben Gerson (Ifrah 1998: 158). From the Arabic translations of Greek astronomical texts, sexagesimal positional numeration reached the Byzantine Greeks and, by ad 1000, Western Europe (Neugebauer 1960, Berggren 2002). Medieval European astronomers used sexagesimal notation for fractions thereafter, and in the Alphonsine tables edited in Paris in 1327, even whole numbers were written sexagesimally, the only case I know of where this was done (Berggren 2002: 364). Medieval Ethiopian astronomers used sexagesimal fractions in their own computations and in translations of Greek and Arabic documents (Neugebauer 1979). The use of the Greek variant waned after the end of the Byzantine Empire in the mid fifteenth century, after which Western numerals were used for most purposes. The Arabic version of the system survived even longer; Irani (1955: 3) lists many texts from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries and one from as late as 1788, although I suspect that this latter text is deliberately archaic. Astronomical numerals often occur in the same texts as pure decimal systems (either ciphered-additive ones such as alphabetic numerals, or cipheredpositional ones such as Arabic or Western positional numerals). In effect, sexagesimal notation is not so much a distinct numerical notation system as it is a technique
170
Numerical Notation
that can be used with any numerical notation system as a means of combining numeral-phrases for 1 through 59 into a positional notation system for fractions. The sexagesimal fractions were used only by astronomers and mathematicians working with astronomical problems and writing in manuscripts. Even so, when writing non-astronomical material, or when paginating and dating astronomical texts, they used other numerical notation systems. Yet, on astronomical instruments and in astronomical manuscripts, sexagesimal notation alongside alphabetic numerals was employed continuously for well over a millennium. That sexagesimal notation was used solely for astronomy suggests that the demands of the discipline led to its retention. The division of the circle into 360 degrees (with subdivisions of 60 minutes per degree and 60 seconds per minute) is very useful, since 60 has a large number of divisors.10 Faddegon (1932) showed that this feature enables quick and easy multiplication and division using sexagesimal fractions. The utility of sexagesimal fractions must therefore be evaluated in relation to computations involving this specific metrological system. The tenth-century Persian mathematician al-Biruni reported, however, that because it was inconvenient to multiply using a 60 × 60 multiplication table, Islamic astronomers would convert sexagesimal fractions into decimal numbers, multiply them, and then convert them back into sexagesimal notation (Berggren 2002: 362). Although sexagesimal fractions are no longer used, modern astronomers still use the sexagesimal division of the circle, and anyone who can read a digital clock uses a kind of sexagesimal numeration. While we no longer mix additive and positional principles in notating time and angles, astronomers continue to restrict themselves to values under 60 for the division of the sky into segments, just as everyone is able to realize that thirty minutes pass between 1:50 and 2:20. These vestiges come to us, via Greek and Arabic sexagesimal fractions, from the Babylonian custom of numbering by 60. In this way, a peculiar custom of numeration, useful for astronomy but not much else, influenced how humans perceive and structure time throughout most of the world today. However, these do not represent a sexagesimal numerical notation system, but simply a sexagesimal division of various metrological units (for angles and for time) that are then represented with decimal numerals. The notation “11:05” does not mean 665 minutes (11 × 60 + 5), but simply 11 hours and 5 minutes. That we continue to measure time and angles in this way is a fascinating issue in the history of astronomy and of timekeeping.
10
In number theory, 60 is a “highly composite” number, defined as a natural number that has more divisors than all the numbers below it (Wells 1986: 127–128). The number 60 has twelve divisors: {1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10, 12, 15, 20, 30, 60}.
Alphabetic Systems
171
Table 5.16. Fez numerals 1
a A 10s j J 100s s 766 = foy 1s
2
3
4
5
6
b B c d D e f k l L m n N o t T u v V w W x X
7
8
9
g G h H i I p q Q r y z , <
Fez Numerals In the western extremity of the Muslim world, first briefly in medieval Spain, then around the city of Fez in modern Morocco starting in about the sixteenth century, an alphabetic numeral system was used, distinct from both the Arabic and Greek systems. This system was known as ḥisāb al-qalam al-Fāsī (‘Fez signs’) or rūmī signs (‘Roman’, the name given to the Byzantine Greeks) (Guergour 1997: 68). The numeral-signs, including paleographic variants where appropriate, are indicated in Table 5.16 (Colin 1933: 199–201).11 The system is decimal and ciphered-additive, and is written from right to left with the highest values on the right. The twenty-seven signs are thus sufficient to express any number smaller than 1000. The resemblance between the signs for 6 and 7 and the modern Western numerals is likely a coincidence. For higher numbers, a stroke placed to the left of or beneath any of the twenty-seven signs indicates that its value should be multiplied by 1000. In some documents, two strokes placed underneath a figure indicated multiplication by one million (1000 × 1000) (Guergour 1997: 69). The Fez system is thus a hybrid multiplicative-additive system for values above 1000. At least in later periods, there were signs for specific fractions, and for specific monetary values (Sanchez Perez 1935). The earliest version of the Fez numerals was used among the Mozarabs (Arabic Christians) of Toledo, Spain, in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries (Colin 1933: 204). Levi Della Vida’s (1934) study of these documents, which includes a table of these numeral-signs, confirms that they are essentially identical to the later ones except that they are written from left to right. The question then arises how these numerals reached Spain in the twelfth century. Three possible ancestors – the Arabic abjad (Maghreb variant), the Greek minuscule alphabetic numerals, and the Coptic zimām numerals – are depicted alongside the Fez numerals in Table 5.17.
11
See also Sanchez Perez (1935) and Guergour (1997) for different paleographic variants of this system.
Numerical Notation
172
Table 5.17. Arabic abjad, Greek, zimām, and Fez numerals Arabic Greek Zimām Fez Numerals 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 20 30 40 50
a b c d e f g h i j k l m n
A b\ G D E V z\ E Q I k l m n
a A b B c d D e f g G h H i I j J k l L m n N
Arabic Greek Zimām Fez Numerals 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900
r p q z s t o v w x y : ;
x o p < r s t u f c y w >\
o p q Q r s t T u v V w W x X y z , <
All four systems are written cursively and have an enormous amount of variation. It is possible that the Mozarabs’ numerals are paleographic variants of the Greek alphabetic numerals, and thus came to the Arabs of Spain via direct diffusion from the Byzantines (Levi Della Vida 1934: 283). The attribution of these signs as rūmī (Byzantine) would tend to confirm this origin. However, many of the numeral-signs bear no resemblance to the Greek alphabet. Colin suggests, rather, that the Fez numerals (and their Spanish antecedent) were borrowed, not directly from the Greek alphabetic numerals used in the Byzantine Empire, but by way of the Egypto-Coptic zimām numerals (Colin 1933: 213). The paleographic similarities between several of the Coptic and Fez numeral-signs (e.g., 8, 80, and 500) suggest that some connection must exist between the two. Yet while the Fez numerals are multiplicative at only one level (1000), both of these candidates for its origin are multiplicative at both 1000 and 10,000. An alternate ancestor is the Arabic abjad system used for number-magic and astronomy in the Maghreb at that time. Some of the paleographic resemblances between the Fez numerals and the zimām numerals (e.g., the signs for 7, 30, and 90) can be explained by both systems’ connection to the appropriate letters of the Arabic abjad. Furthermore, unlike the other two
Alphabetic Systems
173
systems, the Arabic abjad is multiplicative only in combination with 1000. Most likely, the Fez numerals are an unusual blend of the Greek, zimām, and Arabic alphabetic systems adopted among a very unusual group of users, highly educated Arabized Christians living in Muslim-dominated southern Spain. The Fez numerals did not last long in Spain; I know of no texts from the fourteenth century or later in which they are used. They were described by the Moroccan mathematician Ibn al-Banna in the early fourteenth century, and later by the great historian Ibn Khaldun in the late fourteenth century, both of whom lived and worked at Fez (Colin 1933: 206; Guergour 1997: 68). Their use in Morocco began in earnest only in the sixteenth century, however, after the expulsion of the Moors from Spain in 1492. They were used frequently throughout the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries in accounting and other commercial contexts, after which time they began to be replaced by the Arabic positional numerals. While they were known to scholars, their use was always mercantile and legal, never mathematical or astronomical (Guergour 1997: 74). The Fez numerals were still used in the early twentieth century for indicating monetary values in wills and in related legal documents (Colin 1933, Sanchez Perez 1935). Because the meaning of the numerals was known to only a few learned notaries by this time, the system had become a cryptographic notation to prevent fraudulent modifications and forgeries, and generally to restrict access to information (Colin 1933: 195). Political changes in post-colonial Morocco have ended this system’s use.
Armenian Before the introduction of Christianity, there was no native Armenian script, and the Babylonian, Greek, and Old Persian scripts were used for literary purposes. The Armenian adoption of Christianity in the early fourth century ad was followed by enormous influence from the Greek-speaking world. In the early fifth century ad (probably in 406 or 407), the Armenian scholar-monk Mesrop Mashtots (c. 360–440) developed the first uniquely Armenian script, an alphabet of thirtysix letters, in order to translate the Bible from Greek into Armenian (Sanjian 1996: 356).12 At the same time, the letters of the alphabet were assigned numerical values as shown in Table 5.18. These signs are the erkat’agir ‘iron-forged letters’ preferred from the fifth through thirteenth centuries ad, and still used for epigraphic inscriptions (Thomson 1989; Sanjian 1996: 357). In the tenth century, cursive letters known as bolorgir began to be used, and are the standard forms used in modern Armenian writing. The Armenian system is ciphered-additive and decimal, and is written from left to right. 12
The modern Armenian script has thirty-eight letters, the last two of which (o and fé) were introduced in the medieval period and have no numerical value.
Numerical Notation
174
Table 5.18. Armenian erkat’agir numerals 1
A 10s J 100s S 1000s 2 346 = UMF
1s
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
B K T 3
C L U 4
D M V 5
E N W 6
F O X 7
G P Y 8
H Q Z 9
I R 1 0
Because the ancient Armenian alphabet had thirty-six letters, it had enough signs to express the complete series from 1000 to 9000 as well as all the units, tens, and hundreds. The system could thus denote any number less than 10,000. However, unlike many ciphered-additive alphabetic systems, the Armenian system does not use multiplication to express higher values, which were written in full using lexical numerals. Very little epigraphic or paleographic evidence survives from the earliest centuries of the system’s use. The Armenian numerals were probably developed on the model of the Greek alphabetic numerals, just as the Armenian script itself was derived from the Greek. Many other scripts have been suggested as possible ancestors of the Armenian script, based on resemblances in the shapes of certain characters (Gamkrelidze 1994: 37), while there are few resemblances to the Greek alphabet. However, of these likely ancestors, only the Greek alphabet used appropriate alphabetic numerals. Thus, regardless of the origins of the script-signs, the principle of alphabetic numeration was certainly borrowed from Greece. It is unclear whether the Armenian alphabetic numerals were developed by Mesrop Mashtots himself (or his assistants) in the early fifth century ad, or whether they were produced later in the century. Figure 5.2 is a monumental grave inscription from the temple of Garni east of Yerevan, which commemorates a ninth-century Armenian Catholicos, also named Mashtots; the first three signs are numerals (300 + 40 + 6), indicating his death-year to be 346 according to the Armenian calendar, or 897 ad. Although a connection is sometimes asserted to exist between the Armenian and Georgian alphabetic numerals, the evidence for this is too tenuous to suggest any definite link. The primary similarities between the two are that they were used in the same region and had distinct signs for 1000 through 9000. The only system that is derived from the Armenian alphabetic numerals is the variant Armenian system developed in the seventh century ad by Anania Shirakatsi. The Armenian numerals did not spread beyond the limited area around Lake Van where Armenian was spoken, nor do they appear to have inspired the creation of any foreign
Alphabetic Systems
175
Figure 5.2. Grave inscription of the Armenian Catholicos Mashtots (897 ad); the first three visible signs of the inscription are 300 + 40 + 6, the year of his death. Courtesy Gabriel Kepeklian.
systems. After the development of the minuscule Armenian script, these signs were also used numerically in the same manner. Ciphered-positional numerals – the Arabic system used by the neighboring Seljuk Turks – were first used in Armenia in the twelfth century (Shaw 1938–39: 368). Yet Armenian writers retained the alphabetic numerals for most ordinary purposes long afterward. Only in the mid seventeenth century, when Armenia had been firmly under Ottoman control for some time, did ciphered-positional numerals (Arabic, then later Western) replace the alphabetic system. Wingate (1930) has published an unusual, undated, and unsolved “magic square” arithmetical puzzle using both Arabic positional and Armenian alphabetic numerals, part of a scroll contained within a Armenian “family amulet” designed to be worn upon the person. The Armenian alphabetic system is still sometimes used for numbering chapters of the New Testament, although page and verse numbers are most often written using Western numerals. Otherwise, the numerals used in modern Armenia are the standard Western numerals.
Shirakatsi’s Notation The Armenian astronomer, geographer, and mathematician Anania Shirakatsi13 was born ca. ad 595–600 and was most likely a monk in the Armenian Church (Hewsen 1968: 34). While little-known today outside his native country, Shirakatsi’s contribution to Armenian learning is unparalleled, particularly his synthesis 13
Also known as Ananiah Shiragooni, or Ananias of Shirak.
Numerical Notation
176
Table 5.19. Armenian numerals: Shirakatsi’s notation
1s 10
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
A j
B
C
D s
E
F
G 2
H
I
100
1000
of Persian, Arabic, Greek, and other scientific knowledge. In addition to these accomplishments, Shirakatsi developed a very interesting numerical notation system in his “Book of Arithmetic” (T’uabant’iwn), which is a collection of arithmetical tables designed for the instruction of pupils. The basic form of this system uses twelve signs, as shown in Table 5.19 (Shaw 1938–39: 270). The individual signs are identical to those used for the appropriate numbers in the traditional Armenian system. However, Shirakatsi showed how these signs could be combined to express numbers through multiplication as well as addition. In this system, a unit-sign followed by one of the three power-signs (for 10, 100, or 1000) indicates that the values of the two should be multiplied; these pairs of signs were combined into numeral-phrases through addition. Instead of writing 9642 as 0XMB (9000 + 600 + 40 + 2), as in the traditional Armenian alphabetic numerals, Shirakatsi would write the same number as I2FSDjB (9 × 1000 + 6 × 100 + 4 × 10 + 2). Thus, where the traditional Armenian system is ciphered-additive, Shirakatsi’s system is multiplicative-additive. Any numeral-phrase can be written more compactly with the traditional alphabetic numerals than with Shirakatsi’s variant – so why would Shirakatsi advocate its use? Firstly, it requires knowing fewer symbols (twelve versus thirty-six) in order to express any number less than 10,000. More importantly, numbers greater than 10,000 could be expressed using multiplicative combinations of two or three signs. To do so, however, one needs the entire repertoire of Armenian numerals from 1 through 9000, as described earlier. For numbers from 10,000 through 90,000, Shirakatsi juxtaposed the signs for 10 through 90 with the sign for 1000. Similarly, the numeral-phrases for 100,000 through 900,000 combined the signs for 100 through 900 with the sign for 1000. Alternatively, the hundred thousands could be expressed using unit-signs followed by a 100-sign and then a 1000-sign. Thus, one could write 460,000 as VO2 – (400 + 60) × 1000 – or DSO2 – ((4 × 100) + 60) × 1000. This system is no longer a purely decimal system, but has a mixed base of 10 and 1000. For values below 1000, it is purely multiplicativeadditive, but above 1000, the multiplicand that is juxtaposed with the sign for 1000 (2) is not a single sign, but rather a ciphered-additive numeral-phrase. In the “Book of Arithmetic,” numbers up to the ten millions are expressed relatively compactly (Abgarian 1962: 46; Hewsen 1968: 42).
Alphabetic Systems
177
Shaw (1938–39: 369) believes that this system was not developed by Shirakatsi in the seventh century, but was a commonly used variant system, of which Shirakatsi’s writings are the only surviving remnant. I do not believe there is any reason to regard the system as anything other than the creation of Shirakatsi himself, since its structure is never found in Greek, Syriac, Hebrew, or any other alphabetic system. Shirakatsi may have borrowed the notion of multiplicative structuring from one of two foreign sources. The numerals developed by the fifth century ad Indian mathematician Âryabhata (Chapter 6) were multiplicative-additive; it is possible that Shirakatsi, a mathematician with extensive knowledge of foreign writers, knew of Âryabhata’s numerals and emulated them. Similarly, it is vaguely plausible that Shirakatsi knew of the classical Chinese multiplicative-additive numerical notation system (Chapter 8). Neither hypothesis has any direct evidentiary support. Shirakatsi’s system is thus a structurally innovative local variant of the Armenian numerals designed to facilitate the representation of large numbers of the sort that would be needed for his astronomical and mathematical calculations. There is no evidence that his system was adopted by any later writers, or that it had any effect on the development of other numerical notation systems throughout the world. Instead, we should view this system as the creative invention of a single individual, used only within his lifetime.
Georgian Like the Armenians, the Georgians developed a script and numerical notation system modeled after the Greek alphabet shortly after they converted to Christianity. While the creation of this first Georgian alphabet is often attributed in folklore to King Parnavaz in the third century bc, there is no direct evidence of Georgian writing until the fifth century ad, at which time the asomtavruli or majuscule script began to be used (Holisky 1996). More familiar to modern scholars, however, are the mxedruli characters developed in the eleventh century ad, which continue to be used to write the Georgian language today. The numerals associated with this script are shown in Table 5.20 (Holisky 1996: 366). The system is decimal and ciphered-additive and, like the Georgian script, is written from left to right. Like the Armenian script, the Georgian script had enough letters to serve for all numerical values up to 9000. Some later inscriptions even include a special sign for 10,000 (-). There is no evidence that the Georgian alphabetic numerals were ever used to express larger numbers than this, either through multiplication or through additional signs. Presumably, such numbers were always written out in full using lexical numerals. There is an undeniable structural similarity between the Georgian and Armenian systems, which both, unlike the Greek alphabetic numerals, have enough
Numerical Notation
178
Table 5.20. Georgian numerals 1
a 10s j 100s s 1000s 2 4808 = 5zh 1s
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
b k t 3
c l u 4
d m v 5
e n w 6
f o x 7
g p y 8
h q z 9
i r 1 0
additional letters to represent the values from 1000 through 9000. However, while the Georgian and Armenian scripts both use thirty-six signs for 1 through 9000, the letter-order of the two scripts is vastly different. The Georgian letter-order was modeled very closely on the Greek, with additional signs added as necessary at the end of the series, while the uniquely Armenian signs in that script were interspersed randomly within the original Greek letter-order. It is unlikely that the Georgian numerals would be modeled on the Armenian numerals but retain the Greek letter-order for their values (Gamkrelidze 1994: 77). There may have been some mutual influence between the two numerical notation systems, given certain similarities in the sign-forms, but the direction of this influence remains unclear (Gamkrelidze 1994: 81–82). For now, the hypothesis of direct diffusion from the Greek alphabetic numerals, while using distinctly Georgian signs and using distinct signs for the thousands, is most strongly supported. The Georgian numerals were used in literary and religious texts throughout the medieval period, particularly for pagination, dating, and stichometry, as well as in monumental inscriptions. Their regular use ended in the sixteenth century, when Georgia came under Ottoman control, after which Arabic positional numerals were used for administrative and commercial purposes, although the alphabetic numerals may have been retained for religious functions. However, Paolini and Irbach’s 1629 Georgian-Italian dictionary, the first book printed in Georgian, does not contain any mention of the alphabetic numerals alongside its list of Georgian letters. Since the eighteenth century, when Georgia fell under the Russian sphere of influence, the Western numerals have been those normally used for all purposes in written Georgian.
Glagolitic The Glagolitic script was probably developed between 860 and 870 by the brothers Cyril and Methodius, who, while on a mission to the Moravian Slavs of what is today modern Serbia, Croatia, and Macedonia, created an alphabet for liturgical
Alphabetic Systems
179
Table 5.21. Glagolitic numerals 1
a j 100s s 708 = yh
1s
10s
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
b k t
c l u
d m v
e n W
f o x
g p y
h q z
i r /
writings in the language now known as Old Church Slavonic (Schenker 1996: 166–167). There may have been a pre-Christian script in the region, which might explain why many of the Glagolitic letters have no correlation with the Greek alphabet, but no pre-Christian numerical notation existed (Cubberley 1996). The numeral-signs of the Glagolitic numerical notation system are shown in Table 5.21 (Vaillant 1948, Gardiner 1984). As with the Greek and many other systems, Glagolitic numerals were frequently distinguished from words in texts by placing dots to either side of a numeralphrase or by placing a mark of some sort above it (Vaillant 1948: 24; Schenker 1996: 182). In addition to these twenty-seven signs, additional signs for 1000, 1, and 2000, 2, were purportedly used in some texts. The system is ciphered-additive and decimal, and is always written from left to right. However, for the numbers 11 through 19, the ordinary sign order is reversed (e.g., bj instead of jb for 12), which reflects the Slavic lexical numerals for the teens (Schenker 1996: 182). Yet none of the surviving Glagolitic manuscripts apparently use numerals higher than 1000 (Gardiner 1984: 15; Lunt 2001: 28). Schenker (1996: 182) contends that the Glagolitic thousands were expressed by placing a small diagonal or curved stroke (like the Greek hasta) to the left of a numeral-sign to indicate that its value should be multiplied by 1000; if so, Glagolitic is a hybrid multiplicative-additive system above 1000. Gamkrelidze (1994: 39–40) and others contend that, because the earliest Glagolitic script had thirty-six characters, the last nine letters of the alphabet (most of which were later dropped from the script) originally had the values 1000 through 9000. The issue remains unresolved and contentious. The Greek alphabetic numerals were the sole and direct ancestor of the Glagolitic numerals. The similarities in structure between the Greek and Glagolitic systems are considerable, and Cyril, Methodius, and their followers were Greeks. Among other possible ancestors, the Gothic numerals were long defunct by the ninth century ad, and the Cyrillic numerals were not invented until later in the century. Nickel’s (1973) suggestion that the Glagolitic numerals may have originated from the tamgas (clan identifiers) used by Turks and Iranians in southern Russia as early as the first century is problematic. While a variety of scripts, such as the Latin,
180
Numerical Notation
Greek, Samaritan, and Hebrew, may have been used as the model for one or more of the letters of the alphabet, many other signs have no obvious correlates in other scripts (Schenker 1996: 168–172). Regardless, the Glagolitic letters must have been assigned their numerical values under the influence of Greek Christianity. Manuscripts were written in Glagolitic throughout the medieval period in the region of modern Croatia, Serbia, Slovakia, and even into the Czech Republic and Poland. Yet, even during the Middle Ages, Catholic or Western-influenced areas began to prefer the Roman numerals to the Glagolitic, while areas under Bulgarian or Serbian control tended to adopt the Cyrillic numerals and script. By the fifteenth century, almost all the Slavs had adopted either Roman or Cyrillic numerals. Only in Croatia, particularly along the Adriatic coast (Dalmatia), where they were retained for the Croatian Roman Catholic liturgy (Cubberley 1996: 350), did the Glagolitic script and numerals flourish. They were also used in monumental inscriptions in Croatia from the eleventh century onward, a context not seen elsewhere. Yet, even in Croatia, the Glagolitic script and numerals declined greatly in use after the Ottoman conquests of the sixteenth century, and were used only rarely from the seventeenth century onward (mostly in religious texts). It is not clear whether the Glagolitic numerals survived as long as the Glagolitic script, which persisted until the beginning of the twentieth century in the Quarner archipelago in northwestern Croatia.
Cyrillic Like Glagolitic, the Cyrillic script was developed under the guidance of the missionaries Cyril and Methodius. It is quite likely that Cyrillic was developed in ad 890– 900, after the deaths of Cyril and Methodius, by Cyril’s followers and disciples in Bulgaria, who then named the script after their deceased mentor. Cyrillic was originally used for writing the Old Church Slavonic language, but later was adopted for writing a variety of Slavic languages, most notably Russian. An alphabetic numerical notation system14 was developed around the same time. The Cyrillic numeral-signs are shown in Table 5.22 (Gardiner 1984: 16–17; Cubberley 1996: 348). The system is ciphered-additive and decimal, and is normally written from left to right. For the numbers 11 through 19, the ordinary sign order was often reversed (e.g., bj instead of jb for 12), which reflects the structure of Slavic lexical numerals (Vaillant 1948: 24). Numeral-phrases were often distinguished from ordinary letters by placing a bar or other mark (titlo) above the phrase, and sometimes also by 14
While some scholars call this system “Slavonic,” I use the term “Cyrillic” to prevent confusion with the Glagolitic system.
Alphabetic Systems
181
Table 5.22. Cyrillic numerals 1
A 10s J 100s S 708 = yh
1s
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
b k t
c l u
d m /
e n w
f o x
g p y
h q z
i r 0
placing dots on either side of the signs (Lunt 2001: 28). Placing a small stroke to the left of a number indicated that its value should be multiplied by 1000 (Vaillant 1948: 24; Schenker 1996: 182). The Cyrillic numerical notation system is thus a hybrid: purely ciphered-additive below 1000 and multiplicative-additive for higher powers. In some cases, higher Cyrillic numerals were expressed by using the signs preceded by an unusual sign, [, to indicate multiplication by 1000 (Gardiner 1984: 15). Apparently in some cases the multiplier-stroke could be repeated two or three times to indicate multiples of 1,000,000 and 1,000,000,000, respectively (Berdnikov and Lapko 1999: 16). In the earliest phase of the script’s history, there were a number of ideograms for powers of 10 from 10,000 up to 1,000,000,000, but these rare notations are poorly studied, and the range of their use is unknown (Berdnikov and Lapko 1999: 17). While there are only twenty-seven signs listed in Table 5.22, there are more than twenty-seven signs in all varieties of the Cyrillic script; modern Russian Cyrillic uses thirty-two letters, and earlier Cyrillic scripts used a number of older signs that have now fallen into disuse. The signs that are assigned numerical values in Cyrillic are those that are directly derived from Greek, including the otherwise rarely used signs for xi (o), psi (y), and theta (i). Yet numerical values were never assigned to the commonly used but non-Greek characters (Gardiner 1984: 14–15). Thus, the Cyrillic numerical values do not correspond to the customary order of letters, remaining faithful to the Greek order instead. The Cyrillic script and numerals originated around 890 ad, at which time Slavs and Greeks who had been influenced by Cyril and Methodius were extremely active in the Christianization of the Slavs in the region of modern Bulgaria and Serbia. That this missionary work was undertaken under the auspices of the Byzantine Empire confirms what is clear from the paleographic evidence – that the sole external influence on the Cyrillic script and numerals was the Greek uncial alphabet used at the time. The non-Greek signs for additional consonantal Slavic phonemes were never assigned numerical values, further confirming the Greek origin of the Cyrillic numerical notation system.
182
Numerical Notation
The Cyrillic numerical notation system spread to Kievan Rus in the tenth century. The earliest printed books in Cyrillic script, those printed in Kraków from 1491 onward, were paginated using Cyrillic rather than Roman or Western numerals (Zimmer et al. 1983). The Balkans fell under Ottoman influence in the fifteenth century, after the fall of Constantinople, and the alphabetic numerals largely ceased to be used there by around 1500. In Russia, the Cyrillic numerals were used much longer. The late sixteenth-century English Slavist, Christopher Borough, authored a Russian copy of the pseudo-Aristotelian Secret of Secrets (Bodleian MS Laud misc. 45 (SC 500)), which was paginated in Western numerals but used Cyrillic numerals and Arabic positional numerals elsewhere in the text (Pennington 1967: 681–682). Western numerals were known in Russia in the seventeenth century; a seventeenth-century sundial from Mangazeia (in Siberia, near the Arctic coast) is numbered using Western numerals, showing that they were known even in the Russian hinterland (Ryan 1991: 375). Yet the popular Schitanie udobnoe ‘ready reckoner’ arithmetic text of 1682, intended for merchants, contained only Cyrillic numerals (Okenfuss 1973: 329). For most purposes, the schety or Russian beadabacus, which had been used in Moscow since the eleventh century, was perfectly adequate for the computational needs of pre-Petrine Russia (Ryan 1991: 373–374; Simonov 1993). Not until the reforms of Peter the Great around 1700, and the introduction of technical training in mathematics by scholars from Western Europe, were the Western positional numerals introduced into Russia on a widespread basis (Hans 1959–60, Fedosov 1995). Magnitskii’s Arifmetika of 1703 used both systems side by side (Ryan 1991: 373). In the same year, logarithm tables published for the use of students at the Moscow School of Mathematics and Navigation were printed in Western numerals only. In 1710, however, Peter deferred to the clergy in decreeing that church texts were to be printed using the traditional Cyrillic numerals (Cracraft 2003: 103). Throughout the eighteenth century, aristocrats and literate officials would have needed to be familiar with Roman, Western, and Cyrillic numerals in order to read the full range of textual genres used in Russia (Billington 1968: 209). As late as 1918, Tsaritsa Alexandra (Alix of Hesse) was learning Cyrillic numerals and using them to paginate her final diary, demonstrating that their use was still relevant, if increasingly formal, in the late tsarist period (Kozlov and Khrustalev 1997: 2–3). Many texts were paginated using the older system even as Western numerals increasingly were employed for a wider variety of functions. Unlike the transition in Western Europe, where the Western numerals took centuries to be adopted fully, the change from the Cyrillic to the Western numerals took place relatively smoothly and rapidly, however. Today, the Cyrillic numerals are occasionally used in modern Church Slavonic texts (especially for numbering chapters and verses in Bibles), but never in ordinary Cyrillic writing (Gasparov 2001: 17–18).
Alphabetic Systems
183
Latin From the fifth through the twelfth centuries, knowledge of the Greek exact sciences in Western Europe was relatively limited. Starting in the eleventh century, as Arabic translations of Greek astronomical works began to be retranslated into Latin, Western European scholars became increasingly aware of the Greek numerals. In a handful of texts, an attempt was made to convert the Greek alphabetic numerals or Arabic abjad numerals for use with the Latin alphabet, as shown in Table 5.23 (cf. Lemay 2000, Burnett 2000c). The system is ciphered-additive and written from left to right, and simply employs twenty-two letters of the Latin alphabet as it existed at the time to represent 1 through 9, 10 through 90, and 100 through 400 (e.g., xlh = 328). Additionally, in the Dresden Almagest of 1121, z, θ, and ϕ represent 500 through 700 (Burnett 2000c: 61). There is, however, no known way to write 800 and 900, and there is no known multiplicative technique to express numbers higher than 1000. In one of the texts containing such an alphabetic system (MS Cambrai Bibliothèque Municipale 930, a copy of Hermann of Carinthia’s Astronomia), even the sign for 400 is not used (Lemay 2000: 378–379). Yet, because the texts containing the Latin alphabetical numerals are astronomical treatises, in which numbers higher than the 360 degrees of the circle are rarely needed, this was not a serious weakness of the system, which was perfectly adequate for such values. While minuscule letters were used most of the time, in one text, majuscule letters for K, M, and N, and occasionally for G, R, Q, and L were used, in order to prevent confusion with similar-appearing Western numerals (Burnett 2000a: 82). Burnett (2000c: 61–62) briefly discusses a few tenth- to twelfth-century astrolabes and manuscripts with Latin letters serving as numerals, but these are direct transliterations of Arabic or Hebrew numerals that follow the Semitic alphabetic order rather than the Latin one. The earliest documents containing the Latin alphabetic numerals in Table 5.23 date to 1121 and 1127 and were copied in Antioch in the Crusader States, probably in association with the work of Stephen of Pisa, an early twelfth-century translator of Arabic scientific texts. These contain no key, suggesting that the system would already have been understood by its intended audience (Burnett 2000a: 76). The copy of Hermann of Carinthia’s Astronomia similarly contains no key, and simply uses Latin alphabetic numerals to annotate astronomical diagrams (Lemay 2000). A later manuscript (MS London, British Library, Harley 5402), dated 1160 and written in a mixture of Latin and Italian, does, however, have a key for translating Roman numerals into the Latin alphabetic system (Burnett 2000a: 76). All of these manuscripts use Roman numerals in the text and for nonastronomical purposes such as column labels, and some of them use positional numerals as well. The Liber Mamonis uses Roman numerals
Numerical Notation
184
Table 5.23. Latin alphabetic numerals
1s
1 a
2 b
3 c
4 d
5 e
6 f
7 g
8 h
9 i
10s
k
l
m
n
o
100s
t
u
x
y
z
p
q
r
s
θ
ϕ
for single digits and some low compounds, Latin alphabetic numerals for many two- and three-digit compound numbers, and represents larger numbers using Arabic positional numerals (not Western numerals) (Burnett 2000c: 64–65). The Latin alphabetic numerals represent a brief and abortive attempt to adapt the Greek and Arabic systems to the Latin alphabet for the sole purpose of translating astronomical documents efficiently. They did not, however, lead to a consistent or long-lived tradition of Latin alphabetic numeration. By the time the Latin alphabetic system was developed, ciphered-positional numeration was already being widely adopted by Western European mathematicians and scholars, rendering the alphabetic system obsolete. I know of no thirteenth-century or later documents that use the system described here. However, two late thirteenthcentury manuscripts probably written in Flanders use the letters A through I in place of 1 through 9, in conjunction with 0, in a ciphered-positional alphabetic system written from right to left (e.g., B0G = 702), parallel to but probably independent from ibn Ezra’s use of Hebrew alphabetic numerals in the same way, discussed earlier (Burnett 2000b: 200; 2000c: 62–63). In some medieval Latin texts from Western Europe, a set of unusual lettersymbols were associated with numerical values in a sporadic and nonsystematic way, of which one example is shown in Table 5.24 (Cappelli 1901: 413–421). In some respects, this notation resembles the ciphered-additive Latin notation. These letter-symbols occur in very different contexts, however – in the same texts as Roman numerals rather than in translations of Greek or Arabic astronomical texts. The only letters that were not assigned values in this system were I/J, U/V, X, L, C, D, and M, for obvious reasons – these already had numerical values in the Roman numeral system. Like the corresponding Roman numerals, placing a bar above any of these abbreviations indicated multiplication by 1000; e.g., Ō = 11,000. Unlike the Latin alphabetic numerals or the Roman numerals, however, these abbreviations could not be combined to form numeral-phrases – that is, one Table 5.24. Medieval Latin numeral abbreviations A B E F G H K N O P Q R S T Y Z 500 300 250 40 400 200 151 90 11 400 500 80 70 160 150 2000
Alphabetic Systems
185
could not write HN for 290 and be understood. Some numbers are represented twice (G and P both equal 400); many multiples of powers of 10 (30, 60, 600) are not represented; and strange numbers such as 151 are assigned letters. In other manuscripts (e.g., the tenth-century De inventione litterarum in Strasbourg, Bibliothèque Nationale et Universitaire MS. 326), the numerical associations of the letters are completely different than the ones in Table 5.24 (Derolez 1954: 332–335). In fact, this form of notation is not related to either the Greek or Latin alphabetic numerals, but instead is a complex but unstructured quasi-numerical abbreviatory system.
Summary Alphabetic numerical notation systems originated with the Greeks in the sixth century bc, who combined the structure of the Egyptian demotic system with the idea of using phonetic signs as numeral-signs. The political and ecclesiastical authority of Greek speakers, coupled with the brevity and adaptability of ciphered-additive numeration, led to the development of other alphabetic systems using numeral-signs specific to each script. This phylogeny expanded tremendously between the fourth and seventh centuries ad (the time of greatest Eastern Roman/ Byzantine power), with eight new systems arising during this period. Yet most systems of this phylogeny had died out, or had at least been greatly reduced in the contexts of their use, by the sixteenth century ad, during which time the Arabic and Western positional numerals replaced them. Many alphabetic systems are still used today, but only in limited contexts such as liturgical texts, numbered lists, and divinatory magic. There is no one feature common to all the alphabetic systems. Most are cipheredadditive and decimal, with or without the use of multiplicative structuring for the higher powers. However, the Armenian notation of Shirakatsi is multiplicativeadditive and sometimes uses a base of 1000, while the astronomical fractions are positional and involve a sexagesimal base. The number of signs used, the degree to which multiplication is used, and the correspondence of numeral-signs with script-signs are all variable. One of the great advantages of alphabetic systems is that, if the signs are ordered using a local script, one need not learn both a set of script-signs and a set of numeral-signs; one merely superimposes the decimal structure of the numerals onto the script, thereby lessening the mnemonic burden on both new learners and experienced users. The Greek alphabetic, Coptic, Gothic, Hebrew, Syriac, Armenian, Georgian, Glagolitic, and Latin systems all take advantage of this feature. However, the values assigned to Arabic and Cyrillic letters do not correspond to the customary letter-order, thus reducing this benefit. The Fez numerals and the
186
Numerical Notation
zimām numerals are blended alphabetic systems, combining the numeral-signs of two or more existing alphabetic systems to create a new system that does not correspond with the sign-order of any script. Finally, in the Ethiopic system, the users of one script adopted the ordered numeral-signs of another (in this case, the Greek alphabet) rather than adopting both the script and numerals. Despite the advantage of combining phonetic and numerical representation systems, alphabetic numerical notation systems require many more signs than the cumulative-additive systems of Chapters 2 through 4. Even the Ethiopic system, which is multiplicative above 100, uses nineteen separate signs, more than any cumulative-additive system, and the Armenian and Georgian systems require thirty-six signs. Decimal ciphered-additive systems require nine signs for each power: twenty-seven signs to express all numbers up to 1000. In the case of the Hebrew and Syriac systems, whose scripts had only twenty-two signs, numerals above 400 were expressed through cumulative combinations of hundred-signs. While this solves the problem of having only twenty-two phonetic signs, it makes numeral-phrases longer and more complex. As it is inconvenient to develop nine new signs for each higher power of 10, many alphabetic systems are ciphered-additive for lower powers but use multiplicative-additive structuring above some specific point, a feature originally borrowed by the Greeks from the Egyptian demotic numerals. The Gothic, Armenian, Georgian, and Latin systems do not use multiplication at all, and express only numbers below 1000 (Gothic) or 10,000 (Armenian and Georgian). The Ethiopic system is multiplicative above 100, a feature that can exist only because the signs of the system are not Ethiopic script-signs. A large plurality of systems – Cyrillic, Hebrew, Fez numerals, Coptic, Arabic abjad, and possibly Glagolitic – use multiplication above 1000, a natural way to proceed in systems with twentyseven ordinary signs. Three other systems – the Greek, the Syriac, and zimām numerals – are multiplicative at both 1000 and 10,000; that is, after 8000 (8 × 1000) and 9000 (9 × 1000), one uses a new sign for 10,000 (1 × 10,000) rather than (10 × 1000) as in systems that are only multiplicative at 1000. Interestingly, only the obscure Armenian system developed by Shirakatsi takes the step of making the entire system multiplicative-additive. Because multiplicative-additive numeral-phrases are usually longer than ciphered-additive ones, doing so may not have been appealing. While there were occasional efforts to “positionalize” Greek, Hebrew, and Latin alphabetic numerals by simply using the first nine letters along with a zero, these attempts were sporadic and short-lived. The longevity of the alphabetic systems is remarkable. Seven alphabetic numerical notation systems were regularly used for a millennium or longer (Greek, Coptic, Ethiopic, Arabic, Hebrew, Syriac, Armenian, and Georgian). In cases such as the Greek system, this can be explained by the political importance of the
Alphabetic Systems
187
system’s users, but in others, such as Hebrew and Armenian, the systems’ users have largely been politically and culturally marginalized. That these systems could survive in such circumstances and where, in many cases, ciphered-positional systems were available, requires explanation. Structural features may partly explain it: alphabetic systems’ “alphabeticity” means that one need not learn a set of numerals in addition to a script, and ciphered-additive systems are more concise than ciphered-positional systems – for any Western numeral-phrase containing zeroes, the corresponding ciphered-additive numeral-phrase will be shorter. A more satisfying explanation, however, is that alphabetic numerical notation systems, like scripts, can be important markers of cultural identity. In many cases (e.g., Coptic, Gothic, Armenian, Georgian, Glagolitic, and Cyrillic), a group of people developed a unique set of alphabetic numerals and developed their own script at the same time. The point of alphabetic numerals is not to be comprehensible translinguistically, but rather for each system to serve for one script alone. Under these circumstances, an alphabetic numeral system becomes an integral part of a script, and thus marks ethnic identity. Even when these systems ceased to be used regularly, many of them continued to be used in restricted functions, particularly in the domain of religion (e.g., Hebrew, Syriac, Coptic, Greek, Cyrillic). Of course, it must not be forgotten that ultimately, in the face of massive globalization over the past five centuries, Western and Arabic positional numerals have become the earliest and standard systems learned and used by almost everyone. The future of alphabetic numerals seems likely to be one of increasing vestigiality and obsolescence.
chapter 6
South Asian Systems
The South Asian numerical notation systems include all systems that derive from the Brāhmī numerals used on the Indian subcontinent, including Western numerals. With the possible exception of China, South Asian numerical notation systems are predominant throughout the entire world today. While most of the modern South Asian systems are ciphered-positional, the earlier systems were cipheredadditive or multiplicative-additive. An important evolutionary development was the shift from ciphered-additive systems, such as the early Brāhmī numerals, to ciphered-positional systems. Despite attempts to postulate the origin of the important ciphered-positional structure elsewhere (Greece, China, or Mesopotamia), this development came out of South Asia.
Brāhmī The Brāhmī script came to prominence in the mid third century bc, during the reign of the Mauryan emperor Aśoka, although inscribed potsherds from the site of Anuradhapura in Sri Lanka have been dated (controversially) to 400 bc (Coningham et al. 1996). Brāhmī script was probably derived from a Semitic prototype (Aramaic, South Semitic, or Phoenician), although many South Asian scholars still support the theory that the script was indigenously developed (Salomon 1996: 378–379). Along with the slightly earlier Kharoṣṭhī script used in the northwestern regions of India, it was the first script used in India after the collapse of the 188
South Asian Systems
189
Table 6.1. Brāhmī numerals
1s 10s 100s 1000s
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
A J S 1
B K T 2
C L U 3
D M V 4
e N w 5
F O
G P
H Q
I R
Harappan civilization.1 Both scripts are alphasyllabaries (scripts in which each sign has a consonantal base that is modified to indicate which vowel sound is associated with it), but structural differences between the two suggest that their origins are different. This is supported by the fact that the Kharoṣṭhī numerals (Chapter 3) are a hybrid cumulative-additive/multiplicative-additive system very much like the Aramaic system, while the Brāhmī numerals are quite different in principle. The basic Brāhmī numerals are shown in Table 6.1 (Bühler 1896: Plate IX; Datta and Singh 1962 [1935]: Tables III-IX; Salomon 1998: 58). The signs shown in Table 6.1 are those found on Kṣatrapa coins (second to fourth century ad); however, there are enormous paleographic variations among Brāhmī inscriptions. Numeral-phrases are written from left to right, proceeding from higher to lower powers; thus, 289 might be written as TQI. The signs for 1 through 3 are cumulative, with horizontal strokes indicating units, but otherwise, the Brāhmī system is ciphered-additive up to 100, using separate signs for each of the units and the tens. In later inscriptions, even the cumulative signs become ligatured or distorted; for instance, the seventh/eighth-century ad grants of the Gangâ dynasty contain + and = for 2 and 3 (Datta and Singh 1962 [1935]: Table V]. Above 100, the system’s structure becomes more complex. The numeral-signs in Table 6.1 are not, as they appear, simple multiplicative formations that juxtapose a unit-sign with a power-sign for either the hundreds or the thousands; otherwise, one would expect 3 for 2000 rather than 2. Instead, these numeral-signs for 100 through 300 and 1000 through 3000 are quasi-multiplicative. Still, the graphic similarity of the various signs for the hundreds and thousands to the corresponding units is significant. On an inscription from Nana Ghat (first century bc), the numbers 400, 700, 1000, 4000, 6000, 10,000, and 20,000 are written in a straightforward multiplicative fashion as @, #, $, %, ^, &, and *, and thus combine unit-signs with signs for 100 (!) and 1000 ($) (Indraji 1876, 1877). Slightly different but equally straightforward signs are found on slightly later inscriptions 1
Most Western epigraphers and archaeologists accept that, aside from the Harappan script, there was no pre-Mauryan writing in India (Salomon 1995, 1998).
190
Numerical Notation
Figure 6.1. Rubbing of an inscription from Nāsik, Maharashtra state, dating to 120 ad, bearing a variety of Brahmi numerals. Source: Senart 1905–6: 82.
from Nāsik, as in Figure 6.1, dated 42 Śaka (ad 120) (Senart 1905–6: 82; Sircar 1964: 164–167). The Vâkâtaka grants (fifth century ad), one of the latest texts containing signs for the thousands, denote 8000 as x, a ligature of the signs for 1000 (y) and 8 (z) that occur on the same grants (Datta and Singh 1962 [1935]: Tables IV, IX). Despite paleographic changes, the basic structure of the Brāhmī numerals was always ciphered-additive below 100 and multiplicative-additive at both 100 and 1000. No special sign for 10,000 was used; 10,000 and 20,000 are written as 1000 × 10 and 1000 × 20 rather than 10,000 and 10,000 × 2. In the Nana Ghat inscriptions, 24,400 is written as *%@ (1000 × 20 + 1000 × 4 + 100 × 4). The Brāhmī numerals appear on some of the earliest Aśokan inscriptions, dating to the middle of the third century bc, but not in the early Sri Lankan writings. These early inscriptions contain only a few signs (for 1, 2, 4, 6, 50, and 200), but already the hybrid cumulative-additive/multiplicative-additive structure of the system was in place.2 Most of the signs are recognizably ancestral to later ones, such as the more complete sets of numerals found at Nana Ghat and at Nāsik Cave. While there is no paleographic evidence of Brāhmī numerals prior to 300 bc, Datta and Singh (1962 [1935]: 37) claim that, because the Aśokan 2
This opinion contradicts that of Guitel (1975: 605), who sees the Aśoka numerals as being non-multiplicative on the basis that the sign for 200 does not sufficiently resemble a ligatured multiplicative 100 × 2.
South Asian Systems
191
inscriptions are found all over India, the Brāhmī system must have been developed much earlier than the paleographic evidence would indicate, perhaps between 1000 and 600 bc. This is a spurious use of the discredited “age-area” method (determining the age of features by their geographical distribution). In the early Mauryan Empire, an enormous region was quickly encapsulated within a single polity, so it is unsurprising that Mauryan administrative inscriptions are widely distributed. While it was certainly plausible for nineteenth-century Indologists to hope to find earlier paleographic evidence for the numerals, such hopes now seem remote. I agree with Salomon (1996, 1998) and many other Indologists that a midthird-century origin for the Brāhmī numerals and script is probable. The question of the ultimate origin of the Brāhmī numerals – specifically, whether or not they constitute a case of independent invention, and if not, on which ancestor(s) they were modeled – is unresolved, and is made more complex by the politicization of the matter. Previous scholars have emphasized the paleographic comparison of individual signs. I believe that the consideration of the system’s structural features and historical context of origin – supplemented by paleography, where appropriate – will be a more fruitful approach. One set of theories regarding the origin of the Brāhmī numerals derives them from existing representational systems used in South Asia. Borrowing from the letters of the Brāhmī script to create an alphabetic numeral-system, while once a popular theory, is not really sustainable (Prinsep 1838, Woepcke 1863, Indraji 1876, Datta and Singh 1962 [1935], Gokhale 1966, Verma 1971). While a few Brāhmī numeral-signs resemble phonetic signs, if one accepts certain paleographic transformations, these correspond neither to the standard Brāhmī letter-order nor acrophonically to any language’s lexical numerals. Renou and Filliozat (1953) note that in texts containing both purported “letter-numerals” and the corresponding signs used phonetically, the two varieties are quite different. The derivation of the Brāhmī numerals from the Kharoṣṭhī letters is even more improbable, and has not been seriously proposed for over a century (Bayley 1882). Ifrah (1998) proposes but discards the theory that the Brāhmī numerals derive from the Kharoṣṭhī numerals, which can easily be dismissed by noting the temporal priority of the former. Finally, a more recent set of theories derives the Brāhmī numerals from those of the Indus Valley civilization (Sen 1971, Kak 1994), but there are no examples of any writing from India between the latest Harappan inscriptions (around 1700 bc) and the first Brāhmī inscriptions (around 250 bc), and only limited and conflicting evidence for the nature of the Harappan numerical notation system (Parpola 1994; cf. Chapter 10). If not derived from any South Asian system, the Brāhmī numerals could have developed independently. Woodruff (1994 [1909]: 53–60) speculated that both the Chinese and Brāhmī numerals derived from a hypothetical ancient set of cumulative tally signs for 1 through 9, which would then have spread to both China and
192
Numerical Notation
India. Kaye (1919) argued that the Brāhmī numerals developed independently during Aśoka’s time, with their structural features representing three different stages of development, but inexplicably then argues against Indian creativity. Ifrah (1998: 390), arguing that there are “universal constants caused by the fundamental rules of history and paleography,” postulates nonattested cumulative signs for 1 through 9 which later became abbreviated and ligatured into the Brāhmī system. Salomon’s position is more sensibly agnostic; recognizing the problems involved with many other theories, he simply notes that numerical signs are sometimes “cursive reductions of collocations of counting strokes,” citing the hieratic and demotic systems as examples (Salomon 1998: 60). Finally, a number of theories argue for a foreign origin of the Brāhmī numerals. Falk (1993: 175–176), noting structural and paleographic resemblances between the Brāhmī and the earliest Chinese (Chapter 8) numerical notations, argues for a Chinese origin. However, there is little evidence of contact between the two regions at this period, and the only paleographic similarity between the systems is the common use of horizontal strokes for 1, 2, and 3. It has occasionally been proposed that the Greek alphabetic numerals inspired the Brāhmī numerals, given their appearance following the Alexandrine period, the strong trade ties with the Greco-Iranian kingdoms of Parthia and Bactria, and the structural similarities between the two systems. However, the evidence for the “alphabeticity” of the Brāhmī numerals is weak at best (see the previous discussion), and there is no paleographic correspondence between the Greek and Brāhmī numerals. It is most plausible that the Brāhmī numerals are derived from the Egyptian hieratic or demotic numerals. Burnell (1968 [1874]) argued for a demotic origin, while Bühler’s (1963 [1895]) much more prominent analysis argued for a hieratic origin. The three systems are structurally similar: they are all decimal, hybrid cipheredadditive/multiplicative-additive systems, and represent 200, 300, 2000, and 3000 by adding quasi-multiplicative strokes to the signs for 100 or 1000. There are resemblances in around one-third of the sign-forms, and very close resemblances for a few, such as 9 (hieratic = i; demotic = i; early Brāhmī = i) (Bühler 1963 [1895]: 115–119; Salomon 1995, 1998). While there was not tremendous Egypto-Indic cultural contact, Ptolemaic traders reached as far as the city of Muziris (modern Cranganore) on the Malabar Coast, and Aśoka is known to have sent Buddhist missionaries to Alexandria (Basham 1980: 187). Of the two Egyptian systems, I believe the demotic to be a more likely ancestor, because in the Ptolemaic period the use of hieratic numerals was very limited. Thus, although the demotic and Brāhmī systems differ in both the power at which multiplication is used and the direction of writing, I believe that a demotic origin should be adopted as a working hypothesis. The Brāhmī numerals spread throughout the Indian subcontinent during the Mauryan period. Only in the northwest, where Kharoṣṭhī numerals predominated,
South Asian Systems
193
did the Brāhmī numerals fail to penetrate until around the fourth century ad. They were used primarily for writing dates on stone inscriptions and copper land grants. Thus, a full set of numeral-signs up to at least 1000 is attested, and the numeral-signs can be assigned exact dates. Other functions for which Brāhmī numerals were used include stichometry and the recording of financial transactions. While it is interesting to speculate on the use of Brāhmī numerals on other materials than stone and copper, the Indian climate and geography are unsuitable for the survival of perishable materials. In Central Asia, manuscripts in the Tocharian language were written using a variant of Brāhmī script and numerals from the sixth to ninth centuries, and in this drier climate, Brāhmī numerals are attested to have been used on wood tablets, palm leaves, and paper (Sander 1968). There is no surviving evidence that the Brāhmī numerals were used for arithmetic or accounting; the rather substantial body of medieval Indian mathematical works, sometimes attributed to very early dates, use either lexical numerals only, or employ one of the alphasyllabic notations to be described here. After the Kharoṣṭhī script died out in the fourth century ad, variants of the Brāhmī numerals were the only ones used in India until the late sixth or early seventh century. They spread not only throughout the Indian subcontinent, but also into Central and Southeast Asia, regions that were heavily influenced by India during this period. In some Central Asian manuscripts, numeral-phrases were written from top to bottom rather than from left to right (Renou and Filliozat 1953: 702). There was enormous variation in the shapes of the numeral-signs from location to location, suggesting that, as with the Indian scripts, no pressure existed toward the formation of interregional standards. The primary regional division, between northern and southern systems, began as early as the second century ad, and these two basic variants diverged further in later centuries. The end of the traditional Brāhmī numerals and the later local additive variants was a gradual process, instigated not by external influences but by the invention of ciphered-positional notation beginning in the late sixth or early seventh century ad. Over the next couple of centuries, the older ciphered-additive forms became increasingly rare, and by the ninth century ad, the Brāhmī numerals had been replaced by the modern ciphered-positional system throughout India and Southeast Asia. Only on the southern tip of India and in Sri Lanka were additive systems retained (though in an altered form) until significantly later.
From Addition to Position No numerical notation systems have been as widely studied and discussed as the ciphered-positional systems that originated in India, primarily because, through the intermediary of the Arabs, these systems are ancestral to Western numerals.
194
Numerical Notation
While it would be teleological to portray the history of numerals in a linear fashion leading to our own system, the present near-universality of the cipheredpositional, decimal structure originating in India and spreading westward throughout the Islamic and Western spheres requires explanation. Around ad 600, a change began in the writing of dates in the Brāhmīderived scripts of India and Southeast Asia. Instead of writing smaller numbers with ciphered-additive notation and larger numbers with multiplicative-additive notation, all numbers were written using paleographic variations of the nine Brāhmī numeral-signs and a dot to indicate zero – a purely ciphered-positional system. The spread of the older additive systems throughout South and Southeast Asia between the third century bc and the seventh century ad was followed by a second wave of diffusion of the positional principle and zero (seventh century ad onward), wherein the additive systems changed into positional ones. The change is actually a very simple one. The unit-signs were retained, but the power-signs were replaced with a single sign for zero. This process is confirmed by comparing the signs for 1 through 9 in the nonpositional (Brāhmī-derived) systems with the very similar unit-signs used with a zero in later periods. This was not the first zero; the Babylonians (Chapter 7) and the Maya (Chapter 9) had already invented the positional principle and zero-signs well before this time. Some scholars have claimed that the Babylonian zero diffused eastward to India just as it diffused westward to Greece (Février 1948: 585; Menninger 1969: 398–9). Yet the Babylonian and Maya systems were both cumulative-positional, and used a sub-base in addition to a base (Babylonian 10 and 60, Maya 5 and 20). Similarly, while Greek and Arab astronomers used positional fractions with a zero, these had a sexagesimal (Babylonian-derived) base and never used positional notation for whole numbers. Thus, there is no apparent historical relation between these systems and the later Indian one. The Indian positional system first combined ciphering, a zero, and a single, decimal base. It is frequently claimed that the earliest example of ciphered-positional numerals is found on the Sankheda or Mankani copper plate bearing the date 346 in the Kalacuri era, which translates to 595 ad (Bühler 1896: 78; Smith and Karpinski 1911: 46; Das 1927a: 118; Kak 1990: 199). This plate is a donation charter of Dadda III, used to certify a land grant. When discussing any land grant, the issue of a later forgery always arises, as attempts to claim land by producing such evidence were common in India (as elsewhere). Since much of the paleographic evidence for early positional numerals comes from such land grants, we must be cautious to avoid dating inscriptions simply by the date as inscribed, and also take paleography and historical context into account. We must also remember that texts containing positional notation that are transcriptions or translations of earlier works must not be assigned an early date based simply on their putative earlier authors.
South Asian Systems
195
While we need not go so far as Kaye (1919: 346), who claimed that all positional numerals in India prior to the ninth century ad were forgeries, most Indologists are very wary of the Sankheda plate (Salomon 1998: 61). The fact that it is ninety years older than any other positional numeral-phrase suggests that we need to question carefully any sixth-century ad evidence for ciphered-positional numerals in India. The earliest surviving and unquestionable examples of ciphered-positional numerals with a zero derive, not from India itself, but from Southeast Asia, in Khmer, Old Malay, and Cham inscriptions from the late seventh century ad. A calendrical inscription found at Sambor (in Cambodia) and written in a mixture of Old Khmer and Sanskrit is dated 605 in the Śaka dating system, or 683 ad; the zero appears as a small dot (Coedès 1931: 327). As the Sambor inscription is a calendrical passage rather than a land grant or financial document, it is unlikely to be a forgery (Diller 1996: 126). Similar inscriptions from the Old Malay kingdom of Sriwijaya have been found at Palembang and at Kotakapur on the nearby island of Bangka dating to 683, 684, and 686 ad, or 605, 606, and 608 Śaka, respectively; in these cases, the zero was written as a circle rather than as a closed dot (Diller 1995). It is intriguing that the Old Khmer and Old Malay inscriptions appear in the same year (Diller 1995: 66). Nevertheless, there is no reason to believe, as Kaye (1907) did, that the existence of these inscriptions must mean that ciphered-positional numerals actually originated in Southeast Asia and diffused from there to India. The existence of intermediate additive-positional forms from the sixth and early seventh centuries ad, which I will discuss later, coupled with the probability that some of the earlier copper grant plates are authentic, make it likely that the invention of ciphered-positional numerals occurred around ad 600. However, there is compelling evidence for something akin to the positional principle and zero in certain earlier literary and religious texts. In texts using the bhutasa khya or word-numeral system, special cryptic words for one through nine could be combined in a sort of positional fashion with a word for zero in order to represent dates lexically in a fashion quite different from that of ordinary Sanskrit number-words (Datta and Singh 1962 [1935]: 53–63; Mukherjee 1977). The earliest attested text to use this system is the Yavanajātaka of Sphujidhava (ad 269), a Sanskrit version of a Greek astronomical text (Yano 2006: 15). In it, the words ‘moon’ and ‘earth’ mean one, ‘eye’ and ‘twin’ two, and so on, with ‘sky’ and ‘dot’ meaning ‘zero’, suggesting a sort of positionality of words if not of graphemes, while also allowing multiple words to represent the number, a key to producing numeral-phrases that are unambiguous and yet flexible enough to fit into strict Sanskrit verse (Plofker 2007: 395). The bhutasa khya system is thus suggestive of positionality but does not constitute a system of graphic numerical signs, nor should its use be taken to imply the widespread use of decimal positional numerals
196
Numerical Notation
in Indian manuscripts. Notably, the regular name for Indian numeral symbols, anka ‘mark’, is also a numerical word for ‘nine’ in this system, which suggests that there were originally only nine numerical graphemes – that is, that the zero, and place-value, were latecomers to Indian numerical notation even though they existed conceptually in the word-numerals (Clark 1929: 229–230). The earliest Sanksrit word for the zero-sign, śûnya-bindu (literally, ‘void-dot’), is first used in Subhandu’s Vasavadatta, written around 600 ad (Sen 1971: 175; Salomon 1998: 63). This evidence suggests a correspondence between the early use of numeral-words and the structurally identical later use of the ten numeral-signs. Thus, the literary concept of a “zero-space” in Hindu thought, the use of chronograms, and the term śûnya-bindu in the fifth and sixth centuries ad may have prefigured the eventual development of ciphered-positional numerals. Within the interlinked tradition of Indian religious and mathematical thought, the invention of the zero is as much a metaphysical concept as it is an arithmetical tool, if not more so. Almost all the attested early ciphered-positional numerals are nonarithmetical, and are simply used to register dates and other numbers on inscriptions and copper plates. It would be erroneous to assume that the positional numerals originally had an arithmetical function, and then to use this assumption to hypothesize an ancient mathematical tradition of ciphered-positional numerals. There is no evidence that true ciphered-positional numerals were used prior to the middle of the sixth century ad, and any claim prior to the middle of the seventh century ad requires careful examination. The Indian climate and topography are not particularly suitable for the survival of materials other than stone and metal, and we certainly do not have as much evidence as we would like. Nevertheless, there is plenty of inscriptional evidence for continued use of the old additive numerals from the sixth through the eighth centuries ad, they decline significantly in frequency only in the ninth century. It is unlikely that all the evidence for ciphered-positional numerals was lost where so much survives for the additive system – though not impossible, if positional numerals were used only on perishable media at first. Further evidence for the chronology of the shift comes from inscriptions dating from the late sixth to the middle of the eighth century ad from the Orissa region, which are written with unusual mixed structures combining the features of the older additive and newer positional notations (Datta and Singh 1962 [1935]; Acharya 1993; Salomon 1998: 62–63). The earliest of these is from the Urlam copper plates of the Eastern Gangâ king Hastivarman, dated to 578 ad, in which the Gangâ era year 80 is written as the additive sign for 80 followed by a zero, but this date is questionable (Salomon 1998: 62). Acharya (1993) describes many Orissan inscriptions dating from 635 to 690 ad in which dates such as 137 are written as 100 3 7 rather than 137. This series of dates leads directly into the first fully
South Asian Systems
197
positional date found in India, on the Siddhantam grant of Devendravarman (195 Gangâ = 69