Non-crimp fabric composites
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Related titles: Creep and fatigue in polymer matrix composites (ISBN 978-1-84569-656-6) Creep and fatigue in polymer matrix composites reviews ways of modelling creep and fatigue in polymer matrix composites with the aim of predicting and preventing failure. Part I focuses on viscoelastic and viscoplastic modelling. Part II covers environmental effects and stress corrosion, while Part III analyses creep rupture and damage interaction. Part IV investigates fatigue modelling and characterization and Part V covers the monitoring of creep and fatigue. Physical properties and applications of polymer nanocomposites (ISBN 978-1-84569-672-6) Polymer nanocomposites are polymer matrices reinforced with nanoscale fillers. Understanding the physical properties of polymer nanocomposites is a key factor in gaining wider uptake of the materials in new applications. The book is divided into sections covering polymer/nanoparticle composites, polymer/nanoplatelet composites and polymer/nanotube composites. It finishes by reviewing the range of applications for these important new materials. Fatigue life prediction of composites and composite structures (ISBN 978-1-84569-525-5) Fatigue is the progressive and localised structural damage that occurs when a material is subjected to cyclic loading. The use of composites is growing in structural applications and there is a need to understand how they respond to loading. This authoritative book reviews ways of predicting the service life of composites subjected to variable amplitude, multiaxial and other types of loading.
Details of these and other Woodhead Publishing materials books can be obtained by: • •
visiting our web site at www.woodheadpublishing.com contacting Customer Services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 832819; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 499140 ext. 130; address: Woodhead Publishing Limited, 80 High Street, Sawston, Cambridge CB22 3HJ, UK)
If you would like to receive information on forthcoming titles, please send your address details to: Francis Dodds (address, tel. and fax as above; e-mail: francis.
[email protected]). Please confirm which subject areas you are interested in.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Non-crimp fabric composites Manufacturing, properties and applications Edited by Stepan V. Lomov
Oxford
Cambridge
Philadelphia
New Delhi
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, 80 High Street, Sawston, Cambridge CB22 3HJ, UK www.woodheadpublishing.com Woodhead Publishing, 1518 Walnut Street, Suite 1100, Philadelphia, PA 19102–3406, USA Woodhead Publishing India Private Limited, G-2, Vardaan House, 7/28 Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi – 110002, India www.woodheadpublishingindia.com First published 2011, Woodhead Publishing Limited © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011 The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publisher, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN 978-1-84569-762-4 (print) ISBN 978-0-85709-253-3 (e-book) The publisher’s policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elemental chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publisher ensures that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by RefineCatch Limited, Bungay, Suffolk Printed by TJI Digital, Padstow, Cornwall, UK
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Contents
Contributor contact details Introduction
xiii xvi
Part I
Manufacturing of non-crimp fabrics
1
1
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
3
A. SCHNABEL and T. GRIES, Institut für Textiltechnik (ITA) of RWTH Aachen University, Germany
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.10
Introduction Warp-knitted non-crimp fabric (NCF) Weft-knitted NCF Non-crimp woven fabrics 3D woven and non-interlaced NCF Fixation by adhesion Comparison of production technologies Future trends Acknowledgements References
3 5 22 23 27 30 33 35 37 37
2
Standardisation of production technologies for non-crimp fabric composites
42
F. KRUSE and T. GRIES, Institut für Textiltechnik (ITA) of RWTH Aachen University, Germany
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5
Introduction Classification and standardisation of non-crimp fabric (NCF) production methods Outstanding patents of existing machines for the production of NCFs The ‘Hexcel patent’ – EP 0972102 B1 Product patents in the production of NCFs
42 42 47 59 61
v © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
vi
Contents
2.6
Immobilisation of adhesive on the surface of semi-finished textile products (DE 102008004112 A1) References
64 65
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
67
2.7 3
P. MITSCHANG, Institut für Verbundwerkstoffe GmbH, Germany
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6
Introduction Threads for structural stitching technology Stitching technology and sewing machines Quality aspects for structural stitching Applications and future trends References
67 68 70 74 81 82
4
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching on the geometry of non-crimp fabrics
84
S. V. LOMOV, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8
Introduction General parameters of the fibrous plies Geometry of the stitching Distortions of fibres in the plies Change of the geometry after shear A geometrical model of NCF Conclusion References
84 85 86 92 98 100 100 102
5
Automated analysis of defects in non-crimp fabrics for composites
103
M. SCHNEIDER, Toho Tenax Europe GmbH, Germany
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5
Motivation Quality characteristics of non-crimp fabric (NCF) Quality analysis of NCF by digital image analysis Future trends References
Part II Manufacturing of non-crimp fabric composites 6
Deformability of textile preforms in the manufacture of non-crimp fabric composites
103 104 106 111 114 115
117
S. V. LOMOV, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
6.1
Introduction
117
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Contents
vii
6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7
Shear Biaxial tension Compression Bending Conclusion References
118 128 132 136 139 141
7
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric composites
144
P. HARRISON, University of Glasgow, UK, W-R. YU, Seoul National University, Korea and A. C. LONG, University of Nottingham, UK
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8
Introduction Behaviour of fabric architecture on the shear and draping behaviour of non-crimp fabrics (NCFs) Modelling strategies for NCF forming Energy-based kinematic mapping Finite element modelling of forming for NCFs Future trends Further information and advice References
144 145 148 149 156 161 162 162
8
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
166
R. LOENDERSLOOT, University of Twente, The Netherlands
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7 8.8
Introduction Experimental permeability results Geometric effects Deformation and permeability Conclusions Acknowledgements References Appendix: nomenclature
166 168 187 196 208 209 210 214
9
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric composite reinforcements
216
A. ENDRUWEIT and A. C. LONG, University of Nottingham, UK
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6
Introduction Material characterisation Permeability measurement Modelling and simulation Future trends References
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
216 217 222 233 239 239
viii
Contents
10
Modelling of the permeability of non-crimp fabrics for composites
242
B. VERLEYE, S. V. LOMOV and D. ROOSE, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7 10.8
Introduction Numerical simulation Experimental validation Parametric study Influence of shear Conclusion Acknowledgements References
Part III Properties of non-crimp fabric composites 11
Mechanical properties of non-crimp fabric (NCF) based composites: stiffness and strength
242 246 251 253 256 257 257 258 261
263
S. V. LOMOV, T. TRUONG CHI and I. VERPOEST, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4
11.6 11.7 11.8 11.9 11.10
Introduction Materials and composite production Test procedures Mechanical properties of non-crimp fabric (NCF) composites Mechanical properties of composites based on sheared MMCF Damage development in B2 (0°/90°) laminates X-ray radiography Damage initiation in non-sheared and sheared materials Conclusions References
274 279 283 285 286 287
12
Damage progression in non-crimp fabric composites
289
11.5
263 264 265 266
L. E. ASP, J. VARNA and E. MARKLUND, Swerea SICOMP and Luleå University of Technology, Sweden
12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5
Introduction Damage progression in non-crimp fabric (NCF) composites due to in-plane loading Damage progression in impacted NCF composites Conclusions References
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
289 290 300 308 308
Contents
13
Fatigue in non-crimp fabric composites
ix
310
K. VALLONS, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6
Introduction Fatigue in non-crimp fabric (NCF) composites Post-fatigue residual properties Conclusions and open questions References Appendix
310 311 330 332 332 333
14
Mechanical properties of structurally stitched non-crimp fabric composites
335
N. HIMMEL, Institut für Verbundwerkstoffe GmbH, Germany and H. HEß, BASF Engineering Plastics Europe, Germany
14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5 14.6 15
Introduction Materials and stitching configurations Characterisation of structurally stitched NCF laminates Simulation of mechanical behaviour of structurally stitched laminates Conclusions and future trends References Predicting the effect of stitching on the mechanical properties and damage of non-crimp fabric composites: finite element analysis
335 337 341 348 354 355
360
D. S. IVANOV, S. V. LOMOV and I. VERPOEST, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6 16
Introduction Representative volume element (RVE) of non-crimp fabric (NCF) composites Elastic analysis Damage accumulation in NCF composites Conclusions References
360 363 369 372 383 384
Modelling drape, stress and impact behaviour of non-crimp fabric composites
386
A. K. PICKETT, University of Stuttgart, Germany
16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4
Finite element (FE) methods for drape, stress and impact analysis Laminate analysis and FE stiffness for non-crimp fabric (NCF) FE methods for infusion analysis Draping and FE simulation
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
386 387 389 390
x
Contents
16.5 16.6 16.7 16.8
Infusion simulation Stiffness and failure Impact and failure References
394 394 396 400
17
Modelling stiffness and strength of non-crimp fabric composites: semi-laminar analysis
402
E. MARKLUND, J. VARNA and L. E. ASP, Swerea SICOMP and Luleå University of Technology, Sweden
17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4 17.5
Introduction Stiffness models Strength models for non-crimp fabric (NCF) composites Conclusions References
402 405 420 435 436
Part IV Applications of non-crimp fabric composites
439
18
441
Aerospace applications of non-crimp fabric composites P. MIDDENDORF and C. METZNER, EADS Innovation Works, Germany
18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 18.5
Introduction Aeronautic requirements Application examples Future trends References
441 443 445 447 448
19
Non-crimp fabric: preforming analysis for helicopter applications
449
F. DUMONT and C. WEIMER, Eurocopter Deutschland GmbH, Germany
19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 19.5 19.6 20
Introduction Preform techniques for non-crimp fabrics (NCFs) Main NCF deformation mechanism observed during preforming Preforming defect analysis Conclusion and future trends References
449 449 454 456 458 460
Automotive applications of non-crimp fabric composites
461
B. SKÖCK-HARTMANN and T. GRIES, Institut für Textiltechnik (ITA) of RWTH Aachen University, Germany
20.1 20.2
Introduction Applications of non-crimp fabrics (NCF) in the automotive industry
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
461 466
Contents
20.3
xi
20.4 20.5 20.6
Research and development for the use of NCF in automotive applications Future trends Conclusion References
469 476 478 479
21
Non-crimp fabric composites in wind turbines
481
G. ADOLPHS and C. SKINNER, OCV Technical Fabrics, Belgium
21.1 21.2 21.3 21.4 21.5 22
Introduction Development of non-crimp fabric (NCF) composites in wind energy NCF materials used in nacelle construction Future trends References
481 483 491 492 493
Cost analysis in using non-crimp fabric composites in engineering applications
494
P. SCHUBEL, University of Nottingham, UK
22.1 22.2 22.3 22.4 22.5 22.6
Introduction Costing methodologies: current approaches Technical cost modelling Case study: 40 m wind turbine blade shell Acknowledgements References
494 495 496 504 509 509
Index
511
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Contributor contact details
(* = main contact)
Chapter 1
Chapters 4, 6 and 11
A. Schnabel* and T. Gries Institut für Textiltechnik (ITA) of RWTH Aachen University Otto-Blumenthal-Strasse 1 52074 Aachen Germany
S. V. Lomov Department of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Kasteelpark Arenberg 44 bus 2450 B-3001 Heverlee (Leuven) Belgium
e-mail:
[email protected]; thomas.gries@ita. rwth-aachen.de
e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 5 Chapter 2 F. Kruse* and T. Gries Institut für Textiltechnik (ITA) of RWTH Aachen University Otto-Blumenthal-Strasse 1 52074 Aachen Germany e-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected]
Chapter 3 P. Mitschang Manufacturing Science Institut für Verbundwerkstoffe GmbH Erwin-Schroedinger-Strasse 58 67663 Kaiserslautern Germany
M. Schneider Toho Tenax Europe GmbH Kasinostrasse 19–21 42103 Wuppertal Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 7 P. Harrison* University of Glasgow School of Engineering University Avenue Glasgow G12 8QQ UK e-mail:
[email protected]
e-mail:
[email protected]
xiii © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
xiv
Contributor contact details
W-R. Yu Seoul National University Department of Materials Science and Engineering Gwanak _ 599 Gwanak-ro Gwanak-gu Seoul 151–742 Korea A. C. Long University of Nottingham Faculty of Engineering University Park Nottingham NG7 2RD UK
Chapter 8 R. Loendersloot University of Twente Faculty of Engineering Technology – Applied Mechanics & Production Technology P.O. Box 217 7500 AE Enschede The Netherlands e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 9 A. Endruweit and A. C. Long* Faculty of Engineering (M3) – Division of Materials, Mechanics and Structures University of Nottingham University Park Nottingham NG7 2RD UK e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 10 B. Verleye*, S. V. Lomov and D. Roose
Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Celestijnenlaan 200A B-3001 Leuven Belgium e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 12 L. E. Asp* and E. Marklund Swerea SICOMP AB Box 104 SE-43122 Mölndal Sweden e-mail:
[email protected]; erik.
[email protected]
J. Varna Div. Polymer Engineering Luleå University of Technology SE-97187 Luleå Sweden e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 13 K. Vallons Department of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Kasteelpark Arenberg 44 bus 2450 B-3001 Heverlee Belgium e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 14 N. Himmel* Institut für Verbundwerkstoffe GmbH (Institute of Composite Materials) University of Kaiserlautern Erwin-Schrödinger-Strasse 67663 Kaiserlautern Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Contributor contact details
H. Hess BASF Engineering Plastics Europe 67056 Ludwigshafen Germany
xv
D-81663 Munich Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 19 Chapter 15 D. S. Ivanov, S. Lomov and I. Verpoest Department of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Kasteelpark Arenberg 44 bus 2450 B-3001 Heverlee Belgium e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 16 A. K. Pickett Institute for Aircraft Design University of Stuttgart Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 17 E. Marklund* and L. E. Asp Swerea SICOMP AB Box 104 SE-43122 Mölndal Sweden e-mail:
[email protected]; erik.
[email protected]
J. Varna Div. Polymer Engineering Luleå University of Technology SE-97187 Luleå Sweden e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 18 P. Middendorf* and C. Metzner EADS Deutschland GmbH Innovation Works
F. Dumont* and C. Weimer Production Techologies and Projects Laboratories, Materials and Processes Eurocopter Deutschland GmbH D-81663 Munich Germany e-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected]
Chapter 20 B. Sköck-Hartmann* and T. Gries Institut für Textiltechnik (ITA) of RWTH Aachen University Otto-Blumenthal-Strasse 1 52074 Aachen Germany e-mail: Britta.Skoeck-Hartmann@ita. rwth-aachen.de; thomas.gries@ita. rwth-aachen.de.
Chapter 21 G. Adolphs and C. Skinner* OCV Technical Fabrics Chaussée de la Hulpe 166 1170 Brussels Belgium e-mail: Christopher.Skinner@ owenscorning.com; Georg.adolphs@ owenscorning.com
Chapter 22 P. J. Schubel University of Nottingham Faculty of Engineering University Park Nottingham NG7 2RD UK e-mail:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Introduction
The subject of this book, non-crimp fabrics (NCF), is a textile engineer’s answer to a long-standing challenge faced by designers of composite parts: to combine a perfect placement of the reinforcing fibres with easy, inexpensive, automated manufacturing of the part. A part made using unidirectional (UD) tapes, placed by hand or by robot and consolidated in an autoclave, has ideal fibre placement and the best local mechanical properties due to the UD microstructure of the reinforcement. However, the manufacture of such parts is cumbersome and costly. On the other hand, an out-of-autoclave manufacturing process, for example vacuum-assisted resin transfer moulding (RTM) which uses woven laminates, is relatively cheap and takes advantage of easy handling of large sheets of the fabric. In this case, however, the local mechanical properties are affected, because the fibres deviate from their ideal directions due to the crimp (inherent to the woven fabric) and because of the necessary presence of the second fibre system, lying transverse to the direction of the design loads. Hence the challenge to create a reinforcement which would combine UD fibres with integrity, ease of handling and drape of textile fabrics. There are different ways to create such a non-crimp textile structure, which are reviewed in Chapter 1 of this book. These include quasi-UD woven fabrics, noncrimp and non-interlaced three-dimensional weaving, weft- and warp-knitting of UD plies and adhesive bonding of the plies. However, the rest of the book is dedicated to the most widely used type of NCF – multiaxial multiply warp knitted fabrics. The impressive examples of applications of composites reinforced by such NCFs include: a floor pan of a car, which weighs half was much as its steel prototype (carbon fibre NCF); a six-metre diameter pressure bulkhead of an A380 aircraft (also carbon fibre NCF) and a sixty-metre-long blade of a wind turbine (glass fibre NCF). This book presents a comprehensive overview of all the aspects of NCF usage as composite reinforcement – manufacturing of NCF in the textile industry, manufacturing of composites with NCF reinforcements and the mechanical properties of NCF composites and their applications. The chapters are rich in factual material, including test results for the most popular types of carbon and xvi © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Introduction
xvii
glass NCF and their composites, which makes the book a useful reference source. The book can also serve as a textbook for courses on NCF composites in an advanced study programme. Part I, ‘Manufacturing of non-crimp fabrics’ starts with an overview of types of NCF and production methods (Chapter 1, A. Schnabel and T. Gries), which is supported by the discussion of available standardisation of NCF in Chapter 2 (F. Kruse and T. Gries). NCF laminates, with plies in NCF layers stitched (warpknitted) with a thin polyester yarn with linear density of few tex, can be further stitched together with a thick strong glass, aramid or carbon thread, which will provide delamination resistance for the composite. The technology of such ‘structural stitching’ is described in Chapter 3 (P. Mitschang). The ideal UD placement of fibres in the plies of NCF is distorted by the needles and yarns during warp-knitting process. These distortions create an intricate pattern in the internal geometry of fibre placement and free spaces (which become resin-rich zones in the composite), as described in Chapter 4 (S. V. Lomov). As the fibre distortions define the significance of knock-down factors of the mechanical properties of NCF composites in comparison with their UD laminate counterparts, the characterisation and control of these defects is of paramount importance for quality control. An automated system for quality control is described in Chapter 5 (M. Schneider). Part II, ‘Manufacturing of non-crimp fabric composites’ focuses on two crucial phenomena: deformability of NCF during draping on a three-dimensional (3D) mould and resin flow through the fabric. Chapter 6 (S. V. Lomov) describes the resistance of NCF to shear, bi-axial tension and compression, as measured in laboratory tests. This knowledge is further advanced in Chapter 7 (P. Harrison, W-R. Yu and A. C. Long), which describes the behaviour of NCF during draping on a mould, based on mathematical models of the behaviour of a unit cell of NCF and the drape of NCF cloth. Discussion of resin flow through NCF starts with an overview of permeability measurements in Chapter 8 (R. Loendersloot), which also includes measurements of sheared and compressed laminates. Variability issues surrounding the permeability of NCF are covered in Chapter 9 (A. Endruweit and A. C. Long). The models of resin flow of NCF at unit cell level are introduced in Chapter 10 (B. Verleye, S. V. Lomov and D. Roose). These models allow prediction of the permeability of NCF, including sheared configurations, which can be used in macro-models of the part impregnation. Part III, ‘Properties of non-crimp fabric composites’ discusses the mechanical behaviour of NCF composites under different loading types and methods to model this behaviour and predict the mechanical properties. Chapter 11 (S. V. Lomov, T. Truong Chi and I. Verpoest) summarises the results of measurements of mechanical properties of NCF composites in tension and shear, and describes damage progression during a tensile test based on acoustic emission registration and X-ray post-mortem examination. Chapter 12 (L. E. Asp, J. Varna and
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
xviii
Introduction
E. Marklund) continues with a detailed microscopy examination of damage to NCF composites under tension, compression and impact loading. Fatigue behaviour of NCF composites is studied in Chapter 13 (K. Vallons), and mechanical properties of structurally stitched NCF composites in Chapter 14 (N. Himmel). All these studies have a common focus: to reveal and understand how distortions of the UD fibrous plies, introduced by the non-structural and structural stitching, influence the mechanical behaviour of the composite. This understanding helps to establish design limits for NCF composite part and to determine the knock-down factors for the mechanical properties in comparison with the properties of UD laminates, which can be predicted with well-known methods. Because of the complex internal geometry of NCF, predicting the mechanical behaviour of its composites is not that straightforward. Chapter 15 (D. S. Ivanov, S. V. Lomov and I. Verpoest) introduces meso-level (unit cell) finite element (FE) models which allow prediction of elastic response, damage initiation and progression and strength of NCF composites. Chapter 16 (A. Pickett) describes FE modelling of NCF composite parts on macro-scale, which integrates models of forming and infusion during manufacturing and structural analysis of the consolidated part. More engineering-type models (semi-laminar analysis) are described in Chapter 17 (E. Marklund, J. Varna and L. E. Asp). Part IV, ‘Applications of non-crimp fabric composites’ describes the existing and prospective use of NCF composites in aeronautics (Chapter 18, P. Middendorf and C. Metzner, and Chapter 19, F. Dumont and C. Weimer), automotive (Chapter 20, B. Sköck-Hartmann and T. Gries) and wind energy (Chapter 21, G. Adolphs and C. Skinner) industries. The authors do not limit themselves to success stories, but also describe the requirements and limitations for using NCF composites in their respective fields. This part finishes with the important issue of cost analysis of using NCF composites in engineering applications, in Chapter 22 (P. Schubel). The book summarises the results of research and developments performed mainly in the last ten years. During this time, I have worked in the Composite Materials Group (CMG) (Department MTM, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven). The leader of CMG, Professor Ignaas Verpoest, introduced me more than ten years ago to a fascinating world of textile composites. I acknowledge with gratitude his influence, leadership, scientific inspiration and – most of all – friendship. In wider terms, the research in the field of NCF was for myself an interesting and inspiring experience of being a part of a Europe-wide ‘NCF composites community’, spanning different ‘walks’ of science and engineering – textile and composites engineers and manufacturers, designers, experimentalists, university professors, software developers – and combining so many different application fields at the cutting edge of development of modern technologies such as aeronautic, automotive and energy. Woodhead Publishing undertakes continuous efforts in creating a comprehensive library of books on textile and composites science and technology. The present book is a part of this library, and I am grateful to the publisher for the opportunity
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Introduction
xix
to edit it and to gather together a group of distinguished authors – experts in the field. Special thanks are due to Professor. Andrew Long, who has taken the role of editor for the chapters written by myself, and to the Woodhead staff – Adam Hooper, Bonnie Drury and Nell Holden, who helped in putting the book together. Stepan Lomov Leuven
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
1 Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites A. SCHNABEL and T. GRIES, Institut für Textiltechnik (ITA) of RWTH Aachen University, Germany
Abstract: For the manufacturing of non-crimp fabrics there is a wide range of production technologies. The focus in this chapter is on the production of warp-knitted non-crimp fabrics. The production process of coursewise and non-coursewise biaxial and multiaxial warp-knitted NCF is described in detail and the production of non-crimp fabrics by means of weft knitting with weft insertion and specially adapted weaving processes is explained. Other processes are shown to produce non-crimp fabrics made of tapes and threads by means of resins or adhesives. The different technologies are compared and evaluated. An outlook on actual and future research topics and developments concludes this chapter. Key words: production of non-crimp fabric (NCF), warp-knitted NCF, weft-knitted NCF, non-crimp woven fabric, fixation by adhesion.
1.1
Introduction
The chapter ‘Production of non-crimp fabrics, for composites’ comprises a short introduction to non-crimp fabric (NCF), an overview of production technologies and the produced fabrics, a comparison of production technologies, current trends and an outlook on the future. Non-crimp fabrics are defined as drawn parallel oriented layers of reinforcing threads or tows, which are positioned by means of an additional fixation material. Figure 1.1 gives an overview of different NCF structures. In technical literature, there is a wide range of terms for the production technologies for different kinds of fabrics. Furthermore, no uniform designation of thread systems is used. Therefore, at the beginning of each section, the terms used are introduced and, for clarity, throughout the chapter the terms ‘thread’ and ‘fibre’ will be used for reinforcement systems and ‘yarn’ for auxiliary systems. The definition of Roye et al. (2005), is used for the expressions two-dimensional (2D) textile and three-dimensional (3D) textile. • •
A textile is defined as a 2D structure if it does not extend in more than two directions, neither in yarn architecture nor in textile architecture. A textile is defined as a 3D structure if its yarn architecture and/or its textile architecture extends in three directions, regardless of whether it is made in one step or in a multiple-step process.
A cornerstone for the production of NCF was set in 1949 with patent number DD000000008194A, granted to Heinrich Mauersberger. The patent describes a 3 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
4
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.1 Overview of different non-crimp fabrics (ITA).
novel textile material and the associated production method. The basic idea is that chain-stitch seams are used for the production of textile fabrics by interlinking loose filling threads or drawn parallel weft threads. Intersecting weft threads are routed with a guide rail and connected with chain-stitch seams. Threads that are fed in process direction to the stitching unit can be fixed via a ‘zig-zag’ chain stitch. The position of the needle puncture should be between two weft threads (Mauersberger, 1954). NCF can also be produced with coursewise warp-knitting technology, weftknitting technology and specially adapted weaving processes. Besides the above-
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
5
mentioned methods, incoherent reinforcing fibre layers are joined and positioned by being pre-impregnated with resin or by fixation with adhesives. Adhesives for the joining of non-crimp fabrics are used in the form of fluid, powder, granulate or non-woven hotmelt.
1.2
Warp-knitted non-crimp fabric (NCF)
Knitting processes with loop formation in production direction are called warpknitted fabrics. The compound needles are assembled on a continuous needle bar and moved together during the loop formation. Due to the production process, warp-knitted fabrics are created with several yarn systems (Anon., 1969). In warp-knitted NCFs the loop formation is used to bind reinforcing layers together. The machine technology is very productive compared to other technologies. Warp-knitted NCFs are very flexible in respect to layer setup and fibre orientation, but they are limited to a constant width and area weight. There is coursewise and non-coursewise fixation of the reinforcing threads. In a machine with coursewise weft insertion, every warp and weft thread is bound with a single knitting loop. Compared to other technologies, the threads remain undisturbed. The stitch length can be defined in the machine settings. The technology for coursewise biaxial and multiaxial NCF is called warp-knitting. In machines with a non-coursewise weft insertion, the stitch length is independent to the position of the thread. Therefore, threads can be damaged or deflected. There exist non-coursewise biaxial and multiaxial NCF. Non-coursewise multiaxial NCFs are called warp-knitted multiaxial layers (Verwirkte multiaxiale Gelege; WIMAG) or stitch-bonded fabrics (Nähgewirkte variable Gelege; NVG). These phrases were coined in the Federal Republic of Germany and in the former German Democratic Republic, respectively. The term ‘stitch-bonding’ is more appropriate to describe non-coursewise weft insertion technology. Nevertheless, in the following, the more common term ‘warp-knitting’ will be used for noncoursewise biaxial and multiaxial NCF (Weber and Weber, 2004; Wulfhorst, 1998). Table 1.1 shows the important properties of coursewise and non-coursewise fabrics and the relating production technologies. Table 1.1 Characteristics of coursewise and non-coursewise non-crimp fabric and the relating production technologies
Fibre damage Dislocation of the reinforcing threads Variability of the stitch length Complexity of the machine technology
Coursewise weft insertion
Non-coursewise weft insertion
− − + +
+ + + −
+ Higher/− Lower
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
6
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.2.1 Biaxial warp-knitted NCF Fabric set-up Biaxial warp-knitted NCFs are made out of at least three thread systems. • • •
Pillar threads (0°). Weft threads (90°). Warp-knitting yarns.
The reinforcing threads are fed parallel (pillar threads) and perpendicular – respectively diagonal – (weft threads) to the process direction. Warp-knitting yarns are often manufactured from a thermoplastic, such as polyethylene or polyamide, and are used for the fixation of the intersection points of the pillar and weft threads. The yarn spacing between the pillar and weft threads can be adjusted depending on the application. Figure 1.2 shows a scheme of biaxial warp-knitted fabrics with coursewise (a) and non-coursewise (b) weft insertion and different yarn spacings. Unidirectional warp-knitted fabrics can be produced in principle with biaxial warp-knitting machines with weft insertion. Thereby, only weft threads are processed and positioned with warp-knitting yarns.
1.2 Biaxial warp-knitted non-crimp fabrics with coursewise (a) and non-coursewise (b) weft insertion (ITA).
Working principle The warp-knitting machine with biaxial weft insertion can be divided into three machine modules. • • •
Feeding module. Warp-knitting module. Take-up module.
The feeding module consists of a weft insertion system, which is continuously filling weft threads into the hooks or needles of two transport systems. There is one transport system on each side of the machine. The distance between the transport systems defines the width of the fabric. The transport system continuously supplies the loose fibre layers to the warp-knitting module. The pillar threads are
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
7
1.3 Warp-knitting machine with biaxial weft insertion (ITA).
guided by the pillar thread sinkers and fed directly between the compound needles. The weft and pillar threads are fixed in the warp-knitting unit together, by means of warp-knitting yarns. Afterwards, the NCF is cut out of the transport chain and is wound onto the take-up module. Figure 1.3 shows the working principle and the essential functional features of a warp-knitting machine with biaxial weft insertion. Feeding module Weft carriage system Weft carriage systems are mounted on a portal, which is positioned above the transport systems of a warp-knitting machine with weft insertion (Fig. 1.4). The weft carriage system swings permanently between the two transport systems. Thus the weft carriage system take-off takes threads out of a stationary creel and supplies these threads to the transport systems. In the reversal points of the insertion device, the weft threads are pressed down mechanically. Subsequently, the threads lay between the hooks of a shogging rake and at the same time at the back of the weft lay-in units of the transport system. The shogging rake shifts laterally and the weft insertion starts to move in the other direction, whereby the threads are fixed in the weft lay-in units. As soon as the weft threads are fixed, the weft-insertion device moves to the other side of the machine and continues with the same procedure (Wunner, 1987). Parallel and cross-weft insertion can be realised with computer-controlled weft carriage systems (Mayer, 2007).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
8
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.4 Weft carriage system (ITA).
Weft thread transport system Transport chains are widely used as weft-thread transport systems in weft insertion machines. The ratio of the speed of the transport chain to the number of revolutions of the knitting elements determines the stitch length of the warp-knitting yarns. Weft thread transport chains of warp-knitting machines with biaxial weft insertion can be equipped with a wide range of different weft lay-in units. The weft lay-in units can be divided into hook and needle systems (Fig. 1.5), which are used for coursewise and non-coursewise weft insertion (LIBA, 2007c).
1.5 Hook (left), needle (middle) and pin-hook system (right) (ITA).
Hook systems are applied generally for coursewise weft insertion. Weft threads are endlessly filled into open transport hooks, which are closed by weft clamps automatically. The clamps fix the weft threads with an optimum tension and in their exact position during the warp-knitting process. Therefore, the weft threads are drawn parallel and no thread tension difference can occur (LIBA, 2007e). The thread density in the transport system is unequal to the thread density in the fabric. Open, as well as closed, structures can be produced. Closed structures are produced with a fully threaded hook system and an adapted ratio of the speed of the transport chain to the number of revolutions of the knitting elements. Open structures can be manufactured with partly and fully threaded hook systems and a corresponding speed of transport chain. In needle systems, the transport chain segments are equipped with needle hook leads (LIBA, 2007c). When the weft threads are laid down into the weft lay-in units, the needle hooks can penetrate and split the weft threads. Due to this system, the exact position of the threads cannot be guaranteed. Needle systems are used,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
9
therefore, for non-coursewise weft insertion. If many threads are supplied to the needle hooks, closed fabrics with a high density and an even distribution of weft threads can be produced. The pin-hook system is a further development of the needle system. Pins and hooks are arranged in two separate rows. The vertical pin row defines the gauge of the weft layers, whereas the horizontal hooks take up the tensile force of the threads. Therefore, the weft threads can be filled directly – without a shogging rake system – into the weft lay-in units (Wiedenhöft and Vettermann, 1999; Zeidler et al., 2005). The pin-hook system promises a higher quality (e.g. a reduced number of gaps between the weft threads) of the finished textile, but also a higher percentage of blends. Creel Rovings – endless, drawn, twist-free filament bundles – from cheeses and bobbins are fed from creels. These creels are equipped with thread brakes or compensation thread tensioners to regulate the thread tension. Integrated thread breakage and tensioned thread inspection displays show fractured and tensioned threads optically. Bobbin creels for weft insertion have to be adapted, because of the intermittent thread consumption and the brittle fibre material. Bobbin creels are equipped with individual bobbin drives and buffer storages to achieve a constant tension and take-off speed (Fig. 1.6). These creels can also be used to spread fibre tows with up to 48 000 filaments in warp-knitting machines with multiaxial weft insertion. There are also cheese creels with compensating thread tensioners, which are used for biaxial and multiaxial weft insertion (Hoersting and Wienands, 1999; LIBA, 2004; Mayer, 2009c).
1.6 Bobbin creels (left and middle) and cheese creel (right) with compensating thread tensioner (ITA).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
10
Non-crimp fabric composites
Machine equipment Additional equipment for warp-knitting machines with biaxial weft insertion are conveyors, fibre choppers and fleece devices. The conveyor transports chopped fibres to the knitting elements, where fibre layers and chopped fibres are fixed together. Fleece devices are used for feeding of fleece rolls above or underneath the weft threads. Warp-knitting module In the warp-knitting module, the loose fibre layers are fixed together with knitting loops. The motions of the knitting elements (Fig. 1.7) are generated with eccentric gears and corresponding actuating levers. Each knitting element has its own gear. The eccentric gears are driven by a three-phase asynchronous motor with servo converter, which is controlled electronically (LIBA, 2007e).
1.7 Knitting elements (coursewise weft insertion) and walking needle concept (LIBA, 2007e).
Warp-knitting machines with biaxial weft insertion are produced mainly with working widths from 102 to 245 inches and gauges from 3.5 to 24. A gauge is defined as the number of needles per inch (25.4 mm). Loop formation process The loop formation process is divided into seven steps (Fig. 1.8), which are carried out continuously and represent one revolution of the main shaft (Mayer, 2009e; Weber and Weber, 2004). 1. In the first step of the loop formation process, the compound needles and closures, respectively slides, are in their lowest position. The heads of the compound needles are covered from the closures, the guide bars are in their foremost position and the underlapping of the guide bars is carried out.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
11
1.8 Loop formation process (ITA). See text for further explanation.
2. In the second step, the compound needles stroke upward, whereas the closures stay in their lowest position and the pillar thread sinkers fix the vertical position of the fabric. The knit loops slide out of the needle heads onto the needle shafts and the guide bars complete the underlapping motion. 3. In the third step, the compound needles reach their topmost position, the closures start to stroke upwards and the guide bars begin to swing past the compound needles. 4. In the fourth step, the compound needles and closures stay in their topmost position. The closures are still inside the grooves of the compound needles. The guide bars reach their sternmost position, begin to overlap and start to swing backwards. 5. In the fifth step, the guide bars swing past the compound needles and closures, which are still in their topmost position. The guide bars lay the warp-knitting yarns into the hooks of the compound needles. 6. In step six, the guide bars swing into their foremost position. The compound needles stroke faster downwards than the closures. The closures emerge out of the grooves and begin to cover the heads of the needles. The previous knit loops start to slide upwards from the needle shafts. 7. In the seventh step, the compound needles and the closures emerge between the knock-over sinker. The knit loop slides over the covert compound needles and is cast off. Thereby the warp-knitting yarns in the needle heads are pulled through the casted loops and complete the loop formation process. Walking needle The puncture of the fabric through the compound needles and the simultaneous movement of the fabric can lead to damage and deflection of the reinforcing threads. In the walking needle system, an additional horizontal movement – in the direction of production – during the vertical stroke, is carried out in order to reduce the negative influence of the needles. The degree of horizontal needle movement can be adjusted manually with an adapted actuating lever (LIBA, 2007c).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
12
Non-crimp fabric composites
Weft thread sinkers Weft thread sinkers as well as weft inserters allow a precise positioning and fixation of weft threads in coursewise weft insertion systems. The weft thread sinkers place the weft thread closest to the knitting elements on the back of the compound needles. The weft threads are kept in this position until they are fixed with warp-knitting yarns. One of the limiting factors for the working speed of biaxial warp-knitting machines is the weft insertion frequency. Therefore, special thread-forward devices were developed. They accelerate the weft thread next to the warp-knitting elements and therefore increase the distance to the following weft thread. The accelerated weft thread can then be fixed without being constrained by the previous, or the following, weft thread. Thereby a reduced gauge of the weft lay-in units can be realised. Hence, more weft threads can be fed at any one time and, furthermore, the amount of the weft threads in the transport chain is reduced (Wunner, 1974; Wunner, 2009; Weiland, 1988). Yarn let-off Yarn let-off systems are generally classified in positive and negative systems. In negative systems, the needles pull the required amount of yarn from warp beams, section warp beams or bobbins. The yarn tension is controlled with yarn-tension devices or yarn brakes, which limit the maximum working speed. In positive systems, the required yarn length is provided from usually electromechanically driven warp beams. Furthermore, electronically controlled yarn let-off systems with a constant or a variable yarn intake are used. For the adjusted supply of the pillar threads, electromechanically driven delivery rolls are used (Wuensch, 2008). Stitch types There exist different stitch types in knitting patterns to join the loose fibre layers together. The stitch types are predetermined by the scaling of the underlap of the guide bar, which is driven mainly by pattern discs. The most common stitch types are pillar, tricot and plain (Fig. 1.9). The stitch type and the stitch length affect the drapability of the fabric. The drapability is defined as the spherical deformability of flat textile material without structural folds, which is equivalent to the adaptation of flat textile material onto curved 3D surfaces. A larger underlap and a greater stitch length of the warp-knitting yarn increase the formability and at the same time complicate the handling of the material (Hanisch et al., 2007; Hufenbach, 2007). Take-up module The take-up module is located towards the warp-knitting module and consists of a weft thread cutting device, a suction device, a fabric take-off and a fabric wind-up.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
13
1.9 Stitch types – pillar (left), tricot (middle) and plain (right) (ProCad Warpknit 3D ITA).
The cutting device and vacuum cleaner The weft thread cutting device detaches the weft thread ends from the transport chain after the warp-knitting elements. Common cutting devices are thermal systems, hard metal scissors and motor-driven diamond-disc blades. The weft thread blend in the transport chain is brushed out and removed with a vacuum cleaner. Fabric take-off For the fabric take-off, mechanically or electronically controlled systems with two to three rollers are used, which provide an appropriate tension in the fabric. In mechanical roller systems, the take-up speed can be adapted by changing the transmission ratio of the gearbox. Electronically controlled roller systems offer the possibility to adapt the take-up speed as input into the machine’s operation (Wuensch, 2008). Fabric wind-up Two different kinds of batching devices – radially or axially driven – are applied in warp-knitting machines with biaxial weft insertion. They are selected depending on the material. Axially driven wind-up systems have a centre drive with a slipclutch. The wind-up speed can be controlled with skipping rollers. Radially driven wind-up systems are constantly driven at the circumference by friction rollers. They have two operating modes: speed and instantaneously regulated (LIBA, 2005; Mayer, 2007, 2009a). Machine operation The machine operating system is housed in a dust-resistant and air-conditioned control cabinet to protect it from fluff and mechanical damage. The central machine operating system controls all functions of the machine, such as production
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
14
Non-crimp fabric composites
speed and fabric take-off speed. The operating system is equipped with a counterlayer calculation including automatic optimizing and a printer to keep records of product and fault protocols. The operating panel shows production parameters, malfunctions and indicates necessary maintenance work. Furthermore, the operating system is linked to an external customer network by an ethernet interface. External remote diagnostics via modem allow machine diagnostic and customer support for rapid problem-solving through the machine manufacturer (Petrenz, 2009; Mayer, 2009b; Anon, 2010a).
1.2.2 Multiaxial warp-knitted NCF Multiaxial warp-knitting technologies for coursewise and non-coursewise weft insertion (Fig. 1.10) have been developed (Arnold et al., 2000; LIBA, 2007d; Parekh, 1989). Multiaxial warp-knitted NCF with coursewise weft insertion has not yet become generally accepted in practice. Therefore, only the most important characteristics of the fabric and the production technology are given in this chapter. Multiaxial warp-knitted NCF with non-coursewise weft insertion is produced with a machine technology that is similar to the warp-knitting technology with biaxial weft insertion and therefore only the main differences are explained in this chapter. The productivity of the machine depends mainly on the number of stitches per minute and on the stitch length of the warp-knitting module as well as the frequency and the width of the weft insertion (Petrenz, 2009). Warp-knitting with multiaxial weft insertion is one of the most commonly used production technologies for the manufacturing of multiaxial NCF. Fabric set-up Multiaxial warp-knitted NCF with coursewise weft insertion is made of up to four reinforcing fibre layers consisting of diagonal weft threads (e.g. 45°), weft threads (90°) and warp threads (0°). They are fixed using warp-knitting yarns (Anon, 1986).
1.10 Multiaxial warp-knitted non-crimp fabric with coursewise (a) and non-coursewise (b) weft insertion (ITA).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
15
Multiaxial warp-knitted NCF with non-coursewise weft insertion consist of a current maximum of seven parallel layers of rovings or spread fibre tows. The orientation of the single fibre layers can be freely adjusted to between −20° and +20° relative to the production direction (angle specification analogous to EN13473-1). On the top side of the fabric, an additional layer at 0° can be attached. The introduction of two surface fabrics, for example non-wovens, is also possible (Fig. 1.11). The mass per unit area, the structure – closed or open – of the fabric, the material as well as the thread count of each layer can be varied individually for each layer. The single fibre layers are fixed together with a warp yarn (LIBA, 2007d; Mayer, 2009d).
1.11 Schematic set-up of a multiaxial warp-knitted non-crimp fabric with non-coursewise weft insertion (LIBA, 2007d).
Working principle In coursewise weft insertion machines, the knitting unit, a beam with multiple pillar threads (0°), a transport system for weft insertion (90°) and a take-up unit are mounted on a large turntable, which rotates around its own vertical axis. Stationary beams or creels supply reinforcing threads for the diagonal weft insertion to the rotating knitting machine (Fig. 1.12). Up to two diagonal thread systems can be fed. Because of the superposition of the stationary and the rotating systems, the threads are laid diagonally across the width of the fabric (Parekh, 1989). The working principle of non-coursewise weft insertion machines is comparable to that of biaxial warp-knitting machines. The standard machine configuration consists of three weft carriage systems, which are adjustable in small ranges or between −45° and +45°. The single fibre layers are filled in consecutive steps into the weft lay-in units of the transport system. The pillar threads made out of rovings have to be supplied directly between the compound needles to avoid shifting after deposition (Fig. 1.13). Fibre deflections (undulations) can lead to fabrics with lower quality and, therefore, to fabrics with reduced mechanical properties. Therefore, the pillar threads are fixed immediately together in the warp-knitting module by at least two knitting heads (Wienands et al., 2004).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
16
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.12 Coursewise multiaxial warp-knitting machine (top, ITA; bottom, Anon, 1986).
Several other approaches to producing multiaxial warp-knitted NCF with 0° layers at any position – between or on top of the other fibre layers – have been developed. In one process, a conventional fabric with a 0° layer on top is manufactured and afterwards merged with another fabric on a separate machine. To get a symmetrical NCF, the upper fabric has to be turned over. Threads in the production direction can also be fixed on any layer by coating them with glue or heating them up to their melting point. A fixation by means of adhesive is not necessary when spread and torsion-free fibre tows are fed (Friedrich, 2002; Wagner and Palmer, 1998; Anon, 2005).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
17
1.13 Non-coursewise multiaxial warp-knitting machine (top, LIBA, 2007d; bottom, Karl Mayer Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 2010).
Feeding module Weft carriage system There exist two substantial weft insertion technologies in non-coursewise multiaxial warp-knitting machines. • •
Insertion of endless weft threads. Insertion of finite weft threads.
Weft carriage systems for the insertion of endless weft threads manipulate roving and small spread fibre tows (<12k) from bobbins and cheeses. A fibre tow with 12k consists of 12 000 single filaments. The insertion of finite weft threads was developed for the precise and distortion-free placing of discontinuously and continuously spread fibre tows (>12k) made of carbon. These tows are less expensive than conventional carbon fibre rovings. A weft carriage system with a clamping and cutting device is used for the placement of the fibre tows.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
18
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.14 Stationary (left) and mobile (right) weft insertion portal (ITA).
Closed NCF with an areal weight of at least 75 g/m2 can be produced (Bompard et al., 2005; Bittmann, 2006; Anon, 2002, 20056; LIBA, 2007b; Mayer, 2009f). There are stationary and mobile weft insertion portals (Fig. 1.14). In stationary systems, only the weft carriage systems are moveable. They are positioned on a linear guide of the weft insertion portals. In stationary systems, the orientation of the fibre layers is predetermined by the position and accordingly the angle of the weft insertion portal in respect to the direction of the process. The angle has to be adjusted to the ratio of working speed and weft insertion speed. The fibre angle can be changed mechanically within a predefined range (Naumann and Wilkens, 1986). In machines with mobile weft insertion portals, the weft carriage systems can move independently parallel and lateral to the process direction of the warpknitting machine. The orientation of the fibre layers result from the superposition of the transport system motion and the portal movement (Wunner, 1987; Hoersting et al., 2002). In stationary systems, the moving mass is lower and the carriage system can be guided more accurately, but they are less flexible compared to mobile systems. Weft thread transport system Transport chains with needle, pin-hook (q.v. 1.2.1 Biaxial warp-knitted NCF) and pin-pin systems are used for the production of multiaxial warp-knitted NCF, which are made out of endless weft threads. Finite weft threads are fixed and transported with needle fields or clamping systems in warp-knitting machines with multiaxial weft insertion (Fig. 1.15).
1.15 Pin-pin (left), needle-field (middle) and clamping system (right) (ITA).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
19
The pin-pin system was developed for the processing of small fibre tows (<12k). Small mass per unit areas of the fabric can be produced (150 g/m2). The pins are arranged in two separate rows. The upright pin row fixes the position of the weft layers, whereas the horizontal pins take up the tensile force of the weft threads. The weft threads are filled directly into the weft lay-in units with the corresponding weft carriage system (Anon, 2005). Needle-field systems consist of upright needles, which are arranged in several shifted rows. In these systems, the fibre tows are fed above the needles from a weft carriage system. Afterwards the fibre tows are kneeled down to the transport chain, by means of insertion profiles. Due to the needle field, the fibre tows are divided into strand-shaped sections and clamped between the needles. An additional magnetic tape can clamp the weft threads (Erth et al., 2005). In clamping systems, spring devices bear a versatile weft clamp against a steady clamping plate. The weft carriage system conveys spread fibre tows to the insertion position. The current as well as the previously inserted fibre tows are fixed with a supporting clamping unit. Afterwards, the self-locking clamping system on the transport chain is opened with a rocker. The new fibre tows are pressed into the open clamping unit on the transport chain. After closing the clamping system, the support clamping unit releases the fibre tows (Anon, 2002; Volbers, 2005; Munzert and Unglaub, 2008). Creel For the insertion of endless weft threads, similar creels to those in warp-knitting machines with biaxial weft insertion are used. The insertion of finite weft threads can be performed from pre-spread pancake coils and creels with an online spreading device. Carbon fibres are often provided in form of carbon fibre hanks (heavy tows) by the manufacturer, which can consist of over 46 000 filaments. The fibre tows are wound on bobbins or placed in containers. They are too thick as textile reinforcement materials, where small mass per unit areas are desired. For the subsequent treatment, the filament bundles have to be spread to achieve a constant areal weight. The spreading of the filament bundles is more even if the filaments are heated during the process. The filament bundles can be heated with hot air, heated rollers, heat radiators and electrodes (Fig. 1.16). A spreading device consists, for example, of three staggered electrodes so that the filaments rest on the electrodes. The heated filament bundle runs through a spreading device. The filaments are deflected at the run-in and at the run-out. The width of the opening determines the width of the spread fibre tow (Nestler et al., 2009).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
20
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.16 Spreading device with electrodes (Nestler et al., 2009).
Machine equipment The warp-knitting machine with multiaxial weft insertion can be equipped with conveyors, fibre choppers and fleece devices. A conveyer supports the fibre layers during the transport in the warp-knitting machine. It is especially used for the production of heavy fabrics with a large working width. Another application is the transport of chopped fibres. Fleece devices are used to feed additional material above or under the weft threads. Warp-knitting module The warp-knitting module is nearly identical in construction and equipment with the biaxial warp-knitting module (q.v. 1.2.1 Biaxial warp-knitted NCF). There are warp-knitting machines with gauges from 3.5 to 14 needles per inch and working widths between 50 and 152 inches. The machines have up to three guide bars and one pillar thread bar, which are manipulated with patterns discs. The pattern is selected depending on the layer setup and the desired drapability. Take-up module The take-up module is similar to the one in the warp-knitting machine with biaxial weft insertion (q.v. 1.2.1 Biaxial warp-knitted NCF) and is located towards the warp-knitting unit. It consists of the weft thread cutting device, the suction device, the fabric take-off and the fabric wind-up. Weft thread cutting devices can additionally be used to cut a fabric into two. Therefore, two 635 mm (25 inch) fabrics can be produced on a 1270 mm (100 inch) production machine. This leads to a reduction of blend and an increase of productivity.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
21
1.2.3 Spacer warp-knitted NCF Fabric set-up Spacer warp-knitted NCF consists of two top surfaces out of weft threads, pillar threads and warp-knitting yarns, which are connected with pile threads (Fig. 1.17). The warp-knitting yarns thereby fix the weft and pillar threads together. Pile threads from monofilaments can be used for a statically effective reinforcement in through-thickness direction. Spacer warp-knitted NCF can be used for integral systems, such as an integrated engine hood system for higher pedestrian safety. Depending on the the number and the type of the pile threads, the absorption characteristics can be adjusted (Skoeck-Hartmann et al., 2008).
1.17 Spacer warp-knitted non-crimp fabric (ProCad Warpknit 3D – ITA).
Working principle Spacer warp-knitted NCF is produced with double needle bar raschel machines. The machine has symmetric build-up warp-knitting elements (Fig. 1.18). The spacer distance of the fabric can be adjusted continuiously by means of changing the distance of the trickplate. The machine is equipped with two 90° weft thread transport systems. They supply the weft threads to the knitting elements. Horizontal magazine weft insertion systems feed the weft threads into weft lay-in units (hook system) of the transport system. A shogging rake system enables regular and non-regular repetition of weft threads without material waste. The pillar threads are fed at the front and at the back of the knitting elements. Warpknitting yarns as well as pile threads are supplied with guide bars. A high pattern flexibility can be achieved with up to six computer-controlled guide bars (Roye, 2007; LIBA, 2007a; Janetzko and Maier, 2007).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
22
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.18 Double needle bar raschel machine (ITA).
1.3
Weft-knitted NCF
The weft-knitting process has a loop formation perpendicular to the production direction. Therefore, one yarn system is already sufficient for the manufacturing of weft-knitted fabrics (Anon, 1969). In weft-knitted NCF, reinforcing threads are fixed within the loops (Fig. 1.19) (Binh, 2005).
1.19 Biaxial (left) and multiaxial (right) weft-knitted non-crimp fabric (ITA).
Fabric set-up Weft-knitted NCF can be produced as biaxial and multiaxial fabrics or as two- and three-dimensional near net-shape textile structures. Warp and weft threads out of rovings are superposed and fixed together with loop systems. Due to the coursewise weft insertion, the reinforcing threads remain non-crimped (Table 1.2). Through the combination of weft insertion over the entire width or part of the width with or without the support of a stitch-transferring device and by changing loop sizes on individual needles, 3D near net-shape preforms can be produced (Binh, 2005; Hufenbach, 2007; Anon, 2009b).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
23
Table 1.2 Multilayer weft-knitted non-crimp fabric structures
Adapted from Hufenbach, 2007.
Working principle On the basis of multiaxial five-ply weft-knitted NCF (Table 1.2), the typical production process is described. The reinforcing threads are merged coursewise in multilayer weft-knitted NCF. The warp threads are positioned in the centre of the needle bed. They are supplied by means of guide bars, which are equipped with thread guides. Weft threads are fed during the lateral carriage movement underneath the needle-backs of the driven-out needles. The reinforcing threads are fixed through the subsequent knitting row. The manufacturing of a knitting row is carried out in two steps. In the first step, four layers are fixed from the right knitting yarn (3) by means of an R–L standard knitting pattern. The retained layers are right weft thread (2), right diagonal thread (5), vertical warp thread (1) and left diagonal thread (5). In the second step the last left weft thread (2) in a knitting row is attached to the already fixed layers by the left knitting yarn (3) through the R–L knitting pattern. The left knitting yarn (3) likewise fixes only four layers (right weft thread (2), vertical warp thread (1), left diagonal thread (5) and left weft thread (2)) (Binh, 2005; Hufenbach, 2007).
1.4
Non-crimp woven fabrics
Woven fabrics consist of two interlacing thread systems: warp and weft. The wavelike yarn crimp of conventional woven fabrics leads to a structural elongation of the fabrics (approximately 1–3%). The elongation reduces the Young’s modulus of composites reinforced with woven fabrics. Therefore, special non-crimp woven fabrics have been developed. These woven fabrics use thin auxiliary yarns or suitable patterns like Atlas to avoid bending of the reinforcing threads. Thin fibre tows made out of spread filament bundles can also reduce the yarn crimp.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
24
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.4.1 Advanced synchron weave Fabric set-up Advanced synchron weave combines a multilayered NCF and a weave. The fabric consists of drawn reinforcing threads, which are retained by thin auxiliary yarns. The reinforcing warp and weft threads are crossed perpendicularly. Bending, which is caused by the weaving process, is only induced in the auxiliary yarn. Figure 1.20 shows a three-layered NCF, with two layers in a warp and one in a weft direction. The fabric is built up by intermittent reinforcing threads and auxiliary yarns (Cramer, 1989, 1991). Working principle The working principle is based on conventional weaving technologies and can be divided into the following steps. • • • •
Shed formation. Feeding of reinforcing warp threads. Weft insertion. Take-up.
A shed must be formed to be able to insert a weft thread. To form the shed, the warp yarns (auxiliary yarns) are raised or lowered individually or in groups. Reinforcing warp threads are fed between the auxiliary yarns without shed formation. A weft insertion system supplies reinforcement threads and auxiliary yarns. Common weft insertion systems for reinforcement threads use rigid rapiers or flexible band rapiers (Cramer, 1989, 1991).
1.20 Advanced synchron weave (left, ITA; right, Cramer, 1991).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
25
1.4.2 Leno weave Fabric set-up A leno weave consists of two perpendicularly crossed thread systems: weft threads and leno threads. In uniaxial reinforced leno weaves, the reinforcing threads are fed as weft threads and interlinked with leno threads with auxiliary yarns. In biaxial reinforced leno weaves, reinforcing threads and auxiliary yarns are used as leno threads. The auxiliary yarns interlink the reinforcing threads in warp and weft. Due to different tensions and diameters, the reinforcing threads remain uncrimped. Uniaxial and biaxial grid-like, as well as closed, fabrics can be produced (Fig. 1.21).
1.21 Leno weave with uniaxial (left) and biaxial (right) reinforcement (ITA).
Working principle The production principle of leno fabrics has been known for a long time, e.g. for the selvedge formation of woven fabrics on shuttleless looms. To build the selvedge, leno heddles and disc lenos are used to enlace neighbouring warp threads. Based on this principle, a technology was developed to produce leno weaves, where leno threads are used to fix reinforcing threads. The tensions of the leno threads are conventionally controlled with one warpthread system and one warp let-off motion. For the production of closed fabrics with reinforcing threads in warp and weft, machines with at least two warp-thread systems and warp let-off motions are deployed. The auxiliary yarns and the reinforcing threads are supplied from two separate warp beams. This system permits the separate adjusting of the tension for reinforcing threads and auxiliary yarns. Due to the lower tension of the auxiliary yarns the reinforcing threads are non-crimped. The auxiliary yarns are twisted around the reinforcing threads (Fig. 1.22) (Wahhoud, 2005; Dornier, 2007; Kleicke et al., 2007).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
26
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.22 Leno weave technique (Dornier, 2007).
1.4.3 Tape weave Fabric set-up Tape weaves are made of spread fibre tows in warp and weft direction (Fig. 1.23). With the fibre tows, more fibres can be inserted into a given volume and undulations can be reduced compared to conventional weaves. This leads to lower areal weights with similar mechanical properties.
1.23 Weave made of rovings (top) and tape weave (bottom) adapted from (Anon, 2010b).
Working principle The working principle (Fig. 1.24) is based on a conventional weaving machine. Significant modifications for the processing of spread fibre tows in warp and weft direction are necessary. The warp tapes are supplied vertically from cylindrical double-flanged packages which are divided into two groups. Each group feeds material for the top and bottom layer. The particular fibre tows are deflected by an
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
27
1.24 Tape weave working principle (top, ITA; bottom, Khokar, 2006).
adapted shedding system. A gripper inserts the weft fibre tow in the shed between the upper and lower warp fibre tows (Khokar, 1998, 2006).
1.5
3D woven and non-interlaced NCF
There are several technologies for manufacturing 3D woven fabrics with different complexity and productivity (Fig. 1.25). These technologies can be classified according to Khokar (2001) into two processes: 2D and 3D weaving. Non-interlaced NCF can be produced with a non-interlacing process called noobing by
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
28
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.25 Categorisation of production technologies for 3D woven and non-interlaced NCF (ITA).
Khokar (2001) and a non-interlacing weaving process called non-crimp 3D orthogonal weaving by Mohamed and Bogdanovich (2009), Khokar (2001), Chen (2005), Behera and Mishra (2007), Stig (2009), and Mohamed and Bogdanovich (2009).
1.5.1 Fabric set-up A 3D weave made from conventional 2D weaving looms consists of either singleor multilayer warp and weft. The different layers of the warp can be interconnected. In 3D weaves, produced with the 3D weaving process, a grid-like multilayer warp is interlaced with vertical and horizontal weft threads. In the 2D and 3D weaving process, reinforcing threads can be integrated in warp and weft direction. In the non-interlacing processes, three mutually perpendicular sets of threads are assembled without interlacing, interloping or intertwining. The following figure depicts a selection of common fabric structures: orthogonal (Fig. 1.26, left), multilayer (Fig. 1.26, middle), angle-interlock (Fig. 1.26, right) and spacer. Multilayer and angle-interlock fabric structures will lead to low-crimped yarns. Based on the existing production technologies solid, shell, hollow, nodal and
1.26 Fabric structures – orthogonal (left), multilayer (middle) and angleinterlock (right) (ITA).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
29
spatial fabrics can be manufactured (Khokar, 2001; Chen, 2005; Behera and Mishra, 2007; Gokarneshan and Dhanapal, 2007; Bogdanovich and Mohamed, 2009; McHugh, 2009; Stig, 2009).
1.5.2 Working principle The 2D weaving process is designed to place two orthogonal sets (single or multilayer) of threads: warp and weft. Through interlacing of multilayer warp and weft threads, a 3D fabric can be produced. Therefore, the multilayer warp threads are manipulated in the 2D weaving loom by means of a mono-directional shedding operation in the fabric width direction. Weft threads are inserted in the formed sheds with weft insertion systems (Fig. 1.27, top left) (Khokar, 2001; Mohamed and Salama, 2001; Behera and Mishra, 2007). Due to the production process a substantial level of crimp and fibre damage can occur in the fabric induced by interlacing and moving machine parts (e.g. heddles) (Mohamed and Bogdanovich, 2009).
1.27 2D weaving, adapted from Khokar (2001) (top left), 3D weaving (top right) (ITA), non-interlacing weaving, adapted from Mohamed and Zhang (1992) (bottom left) and uniaxial non-interlacing process (bottom right) (ITA).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
30
Non-crimp fabric composites
The 3D weaving process works with bidirectional shedding. This means that, contrary to the 2D weaving process, the shed formation takes place in the fabricthickness and fabric-width directions. Vertical and horizontal weft threads are interlaced with the warp threads. The 3D shed formation takes place successively in a given circle (Fig. 1.27, top right) (Khokar, 2001; Behera and Mishra, 2007). Due to the interlacing the reinforcing threads are crimped in the resulting structure (Mohamed and Bogdanovich, 2009). In the non-interlacing weaving process (Fig. 1.27, bottom left) multiple weft threads are inserted simultaneously into the shed and subsequent beat-up by the reed. Only the z-directional (through-thickness) yarns are drawn through heddles of the shedding formation and moved up and down. Since there is no interlacing between the warp and weft layers no crimp occurs (Mohamed and Zhang, 1992; Mohamed and Bogdanovich, 2009; Bogdanovich and Mohamed, 2009). Two types of non-interlacing processes exist: uniaxial (Fig. 1.27, bottom right) and multiaxial. In the uniaxial non-interlacing process, two sets of auxiliary yarns are traversed with carriers vertical and horizontal between uniaxial reinforcing threads that are arranged in a grid. The axial threads are bound in the width and thickness directions by the auxiliary yarns without crimp. In the multiaxial noninterlacing process, four sets of threads are interconnected by stitching in the fabric thickness direction (Khokar, 2001; Gokarneshan and Dhanapal, 2007).
1.6
Fixation by adhesion
Besides the knitting and weaving technology, biaxial as well as multiaxial NCF can be produced through fixation of the reinforcing layers by alternative methods such as chemical, thermal or mechanical consolidation. Ideally the consolidation technologies do not negatively influence the properties of the NCF and the subsequent treatment (Bompard et al., 2008; Cooper, 1989; Friedrich, 2002; Hoersting, 1997).
1.6.1 Bonded tape NCF Fabric set-up Multiaxial bonded tape NCF consist of a plurality of parallel-oriented fibre layers. At least one of the fibre layers is made of spread fibre tows. The 0° unidirectional sheet (in the production direction) can lie between or on top of the transversal layers (Bompard et al., 2008). Working principle Endless and finite unidirectional fibre tows are superposed in different directions and fixed together. A chemical bonding agent can be deposited by spraying a
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
31
1.28 Working principle for a multiaxial bonded tape NCF (ITA).
liquid compound onto the fibres or if the fibres are pulled through a bath with a chemical bonding agent. Another option is to dust a heat-fusible or thermoadhesive polymer onto the fibres. If a removable bonding agent is used, an additional consolidation by needling, stitching or a jet of water under pressure is applied (Fig. 1.28) (Bompard et al., 2008).
1.6.2 Bonded thread NCF Fabric set-up Biaxial and multiaxial bonded thread NCF consists of warp and weft threads, which are combined without interlacing to an open scrim by means of a substrate. In the former fabric the weft threads are orthogonal to the warp threads and lay between an upper and lower layer of warp threads. The latter fabric has warp threads and diagonal weft threads lying upon another. The fabric has an open, net-like structure (Fig. 1.29) (Cooper, 1989; Anon, 2009a).
1.29 Biaxial (left) and multiaxial (right) bonded thread NCF (ITA).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
32
Non-crimp fabric composites
Working principle A weft carrier inserts an array of weft threads in two axially aligned weft retainer wheels. The distance between the wheels defines the width of the later fabric. Warp threads are fed continuously from above and below the machine into the gap between two feed rollers. The distance between the feed rollers coincides with the effective diameter of the weft retainer wheels. The weft threads are cut at their ends, fixed temporarily with a clamping device and inserted between the warp threads. An additional pair of weft retainer wheels can increase the working speed (Fig. 1.30). Subsequently, the warp and weft threads are coated with a binder substrate and dried. In a further development of the system, diagonal weft threads can also be brought in (Cooper, 1989; Anon, 2009a).
1.30 Production process of biaxial bonded thread non-crimp fabric (Cooper, 1989).
1.6.3 Fold-wound NCF Fabric set-up Fold-wound NCF is characterised by a symmetrical layer set-up and a centric 0° fibre layer. Each layer is made of spread fibre tows (Gruenert, 2007; Heinrich et al., 2009).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
33
Working principle One or more diagonally approaching webs (α-layers) are wound around a second fibre layer system (0° layer). A guiding system continuously transports the 0° layer in direction of production and turns it around the rotational axis of the system. The α-layer systems are folded before being placed on the edge of the 0° layer. The α-layers are fixed together by means of binding systems (e.g. adhesives). A subsequent calender consolidates the manufactured multiaxial NCF (Fig. 1.31) (Gruenert, 2007; Heinrich et al., 2009).
1.31 Fold-winding system (Gruenert, 2007).
1.7
Comparison of production technologies
A classification of the production technologies with regard to the productivity of the process and the complexity of the NCF is difficult without considering the whole production process and the quality as well as the geometry of the final FRP component. In addition, the productivity of the individual manufacturing machines in the literature is described only insufficiently. Therefore, Fig. 1.32 can only give a coarse estimation of the mass throughput and the complexity of the semifinished NCF for the most important NCF production technologies. Warp-knitting with biaxial weft insertion was selected as the reference for the highest productivity, and the multilayer weft-knitting for the highest complexity of semi-finished NCF. In Fig. 1.33, the production technologies are arranged regarding their application in the NCF production industry and the quantity of produced NCF. The industrial application is classified as ‘low’ when they are used predominantly in research facilities and as ‘high’ when they are widespread and commonly used standard applications. Apart from these essential criteria, the permeability, the deformability (drapability) and the mechanical performance of the NCF can also be taken into account for an evaluation. These characteristics will be described in subsequent sections of this book.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
34
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.32 Realizable productivity and complexity of important non-crimp fabric production technologies (ITA).
1.33 Classification of non-crimp fabric production technologies regarding produced amount and industrial application (ITA).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
1.8
35
Future trends
For the determination of future trends in the production of NCF, the integrated production process – from the fibre to the fibre-reinforced plastic component – has to be considered. Composite parts are currently manufactured using manual and semiautomated processes. These are time- and cost-consuming and cause an inefficient use of cost-intensive tool forms. Furthermore, manual operations can lead to problems with regard to reproducibility and the complex subsequent finishing steps. On the one hand, the aerospace and wind energy industries demand large-scale fibre-reinforced plastic (FRP) components. The challenges in the production of these parts are the handling of large textile semi-finished fabrics and their storage management. Moreover, sections with large numbers of layers have to be realised and handled using stacking and joining technologies. On the other hand, the automotive industry requires mass-produced FRP components with a wide range of properties. Among these are metallic inserts, reinforcement structures, apertures and 3D curved surfaces with small radii. One possible process chain for the mass production of FRP components is the manufacturing of dry textile preforms and the impregnation and consolidation by resin injection moulding processes. A key challenge for the realisation of this process chain is the economic production of dry textile preforms that fulfill the requirements of the impregnation process. One requirement is the fixation of the reinforcement fibres to avoid disorientations caused by impregnation pressure. Another key challenge is the production of textile preforms with a high level of quality and reproducibility with short cycle times. Future developments are aimed therefore at the production of near net-shape textile preforms in short cycle times and unit costs. Near net-shape preforms are textile fabrics, with dimensions close to the final product’s shape (Grundmann, 2009). There are two strategies to achieve these goals. One approach is to increase the complexity of the semi-finished fabrics e.g. multiaxial warp-knitted NCF, which can also be referred to as tailored NCF. Using complex semi-finished fabrics, handling and further processing steps in a subsequent preforming process can be reduced (Fig. 1.34). Furthermore, expensive material can be saved. Preforming is thereby defined as the production of the textile preforms in a sequence of automated process steps (Grundmann, 2009). The other approach is to enhance the productivity of already near-net shape technologies like multilayer weft-knitting or 3D weaving. Multiaxial warp-knitted NCF with non-coursewise weft insertion can be produced with high production rates. They have good mechanical properties and are flexible in respect to their layer set-up and fibre orientation. Therefore, they are already an important raw material for the production of fibre-reinforced composites and they are widely used in many applications such as wind turbine blades and aerospace. Current drawbacks are the constant width and thickness of these fabrics as well as the constant stitching type. Further development of the production
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
36
Non-crimp fabric composites
1.34 Preforming technologies (ITA).
technology provides complex semi-finished fabrics. The research goals are the manufacture of multiaxial warp-knitted NCF with local reinforcements (braided structures, NCF, tapes and rovings), a locally adjusted drapability and a large number of layers (Hufenbach, 2007; Grundmann et al., 2009; Heinrich and Vettermann, 2009). In order to produce locally reinforced NCF, a warp-knitting machine with multiaxial weft insertion is supplemented with a feeding module. Focus during the development was set on depositing large textile structures, because of their difficult handling. The feeding module consists of a storage unit with an endless web on a shaft, an integrated cutter and a buffer storage. Several modules can be staggered in a row to produce multilayer textile structures. The warp-knitting module and the take-up module have to be adapted for a continuous process (Schnabel et al., 2009). Local reinforcements, especially bionic structures, can be realized by variable filament or tape placement on NCF. Therefore, racking devices are positioned directly in front of the warp-knitting elements. The racking devices are manipulated with servo drives and can move in opposite directions. Crossbreed structures with and without changes in density are possible (Heinrich and Vettermann, 2009).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
37
Adhesives for the fixation of loose fibre layers provide a high potential for the economic production of near net-shape textile preforms. On the one hand, a certain amount of adhesive is necessary to fix the filaments. On the other, the adhesives can build a barrier and reduce the permeability, enhancing the impregnability as well as the drapability of the fabric. Future research must focus on solving these problems. There are several approaches to adjust the drapability locally. The stitch type has the biggest influence on drapability. To modify the knitting stitch type during the process, an electromechanically driven guide bar will be integrated into the warpknitting machine (Grundmann et al., 2009). Another approach to influence the local drapability is the use of laser transmission welding. The laser unseams partial warp thread loops without damaging the reinforcement fibre and the finish (Falk, 2005). For the design of FRP components out of complex semi-finished NCF new component design methods are necessary, which consider the above-listed material characteristics. Furthermore, advanced drape simulation tools are necessary, with which the deformation of the semi-finished NCF during a preforming process can be determined and also predict the effects of defects (e.g. the effect of fibre angle deviation on strength). Highly efficient planning tools are needed to develop economically viable and cost-effective fibre-reinforced composite parts. These tools have to be specifically designed to allow the representation of preforming process chains – which include the production of semi-finished NCF – and their assessment under the perspectives of technical feasibility and cost-effectiveness. The development of virtual process chains has to be combined with adapted fabric planning to pave the way for massproduced fibre-reinforced composite parts.
1.9
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) for supporting and funding the FOR860 working group of researchers.
1.10
References
Anon. (1969) Textiles, Basic Terms and Definitions, DIN 60000, 1/1969, Beuth Verlag GmbH, Berlin und Köln Anon. (1986), Schwierige Konstruktionsaufgaben mit Multiaxial-MagazinschussRaschelgewirken fortschrittlich geloest, Kettenwirk-Praxis, Band 20, Heft 2, 5–9. Anon. (2002), Klemmvorrichtung für Fadenlagen bei einer Multiaxialmaschine zum Vorlegen und Fixieren von Filamentscharen zu multiaxialen Fadengelegen sowie Multiaxialmaschine mit einer solchen Klemmvorrichtung, DE20212521U1, 10.12.2002. Anon. (2005), Karbonverarbeitung leicht und flexibel gemacht. Mit Karl Mayer Malimo zu multiaxialen Gelegen aus Kohlenstofffasern höchster Qualität und Anwendungsspezifik. (Easy and flexible processing of carbon fibres. With Karl Mayer Malimo to multi-axial layering made from carbon fibres in highest quality and applications), KettenwirkPraxis, Band 39, Heft 3, 25–26.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
38
Non-crimp fabric composites
Anon. (2009a), James Dewhurst, Altham Lane, Altham, Lancashire, England, BB5 5YA, UK, http://www.jamesdewhurst.com; 28.11.09 Anon. (2009b), Institut für Textilmaschinen und Textile Hochleistungswerkstofftechnik der TU Dresden, 01062 Dresden, http://tu-dresden.de/die_tu_dresden/fakultaeten/fakultaet_ maschinenwesen/itm/forschung/forschungsschwerpunkte/faserverbundwerkstoffe, 20.01.10 Anon. (2010), LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH – P.O. Box 1120 – D-95112 Naila – Germany, http://www.liba.de/tricot/cop_max_computer.htm, 20.01.2010 Anon. (2010), Oxeon AB – Norrby Långgata 45 – SE504 35 Borås – Sweden, http://www. oxeon.se/index.php?page=product-examples Arnold R, Hufnagl E, Stopp J, Puffi F and Sfregola P (2000), Verfahren zur Herstellung multiaxialer Kettengewirke (Multi-axial warp knitted fabric has at least two diagonal yarn systems with standing wefts and structured part-wefts on variable alignments to give force lines in all directions), DE000019928635C1, 05.10.2000. Behera B K and Mishra R (2007), 3-Dimensional weaving (3-Dimensionales Weben), Indian Journal of Fibre and Textile Research; Band 33, Heft 3, 274–287. Binh L P (2005), Konstruktive und technologische Weiterentwicklung der Flachstricktechnik zur Herstellung von Multilayer-Gestricken mit bis zu neun Verstärkungslagen, Dresdner Forschungen. Maschinenwesen, Band 21, 1–120. Bittmann E (2006), Das schwarze Gold des Leichtbaus, München, Carl Hanser Verlag. Bogdanovich A and Mohamed M (2009), Three-Dimensional Reinforcements for Composites, Sampe Journal, No. 6, Vol. 45, 33–41. Bompard B, Olry P, Duval R, Bruyere A, Coupe D and Aucagne J (2005), Method and machine for producing multiaxial fibrous webs, US000006919118B2, 19.07.2005. Bompard B, Olry P, Duval R, Bruyere A, Coupe D and Aucagne J (2008), Machine for producing multiaxial fibrous webs, US020080223505A1, 18.09.2008. Chen X (2005), 3D weaving and 3 woven structures: ChenSchool of Materials, 2005, The University of Manchester. Cooper P (1989), Improvements in or relating to fabric production, WO001989003445A1, 20.04.1989. Cramer J (1989), Gewebebahn für Jachtsegel, EP000000246400B1, 13.09.1989. Cramer J (1991), Textiles Flächengebilde, EP000000408830A1, 23.01.1991. Lindauer DORNIER GmbH, Easy Leno®, Lindau, Lindauer DORNIER GmbH, 2007 [corporate literature]. Erth H, Erth D, Pester W, Thieme M, Vettermann F and Reuchsel D (2005), Method and device for feeding and fixing band-shaped filament bundles, WO002005033394A2, 14.04.2005. Falk E M (2005), Drapierbarkeit von Multiaxialgelegen und Nutzung des Laserdurchstrahlschweißens, Technische Textilien, 1/2007, 53–55. Friedrich V (2002), Verfahren und Vorrichtung zur Herstellung eines Fadengitters, DE000003910245C2, 24.10.2002. Gokarneshan M and Dhanapal P (2007), 3 – D Woven Preforms: Review on its Manufacture, Technical Parameters, Characterization and End Uses, Institution of Engineers (India) Journal (TX), Vol. 88, 27–33. Gruenert J (2007), MD-Gelegebildungsmaschine, Cetex-Tätigkeitsbericht, 2007. Grundmann T, Schnabel A, Kruse F F and Gries T (2009), Automated textile Preforming: for the mass production of FRP components, JEC Composites Magazin, Issue 53, page 57–58. Grundmann T (2009), Automatisiertes Preforming für schalenförmige komplexe Faserverbundbauteile, Textiltechnik/Textile Technology, 1–167.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
39
Hanisch V, Henkel F and Gries T (2007), Performance of textile structures determined by accurate machine settings, 14th International Techtextil – Symposium, Frankfurt am Main, 11–14.06.2007. Heinrich H J and Vettermann F (2009), Design options for bionic reinforcing structures by means of variable filament placement on mulitaxial multiply fabrics. Chemiefasertagung Dornbrin, 48, 16.09.2009. Heinrich H J, Födisch J and Gruenert J (2009), Method for production of a multidirectional fabric web, US020090056857A1, 05.05.2009. Hoersting K and Wienands C (1999), Low cost tangential bobbin creel for wisp-free intermittent reinforcement fibre placement, Textile Research Journal, Band 69, Heft 6. Hoersting K-H, Wienands C and Unglaub M (2002), Multiaxial-Maschine mit Portalaufbau, DE19726831C2, 10.01.2002. Hoersting K H (1997), Machine for the production of prefabricated reinforcing webs, EP000000754794A2, 22.01.1997. Hufenbach W (Editor), ‘Textile Verstärkungen, Halbzeuge und deren textiltechnische Fertigung [Ch, Di, Gr]’ and ‘Bauteilentwicklung Versteifte Schale [Mi, Re, Schm]’ in Hufenbach W, Textile Verbundbauweisen und Fertigungstechnologien für Leichtbaustrukturen des Maschinen- und Fahrzeugbau, Dresden, SDV – Die Medien AG, 25–56, 60–72 and 338–345, 352–364. Janetzko S and Maier P (2007), Development and industrial manufacturing of innovative reinforcements for textile reinforced concrete, In: Küppers, B. (Ed.): Proceedings Aachen Dresden International Textile Conference, Aachen November 29–30, 2007. – Aachen : DWI an der RWTH Aachen e.V., 2007. Khokar N and Peterson E (1999), An Experimental Uniaxial Noobing Device: Construction, Method of Operation, and Related Aspects, Journal of the Textile Institute, Volume 90, Issue 2 1999, 225–242. Khokar N (1998), Woven material comprising tape-like warp and weft and an aid for producing the same, WO001998046817A1, 22.10.1998. Khokar N (2001), 3D-Weaving: Theory and Practice, Journal of the Textile Institute, Volume 92, Issue 2, 193–207. Khokar N (2005) Gewebtes dreidimensionales Warenmaterial, DE000069729221T2, 23.06.2005. Khokar N (2006), Method and Apparatus for weaving tape-like warp and weft and material thereof, WO002006075961A1, 20.07.2006. Kleicke R, Lotzmann H, Metzkes K, Hoffmann G and Cherif C (2007), Dreherweben – Anknüpfen an alte Wurzeln mit neuer Technologie, Melliand-Textilberichte, Band 88, 2007, Heft 6, 423–425. LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH (2004), Tangential Creel TC 16/TC 24, Naila: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, 05/2004 [corporate literature]. LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH (2005), Fabric Wind-up Systems Naila: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, 02/2005 [corporate literature]. LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH (2007), The new LIBA double weft spacer: DG 506–30– 2HS, Naila: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, 09/2007 [corporate literature]. LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH (2007), The new LIBA multiaxial-machine for carbon fibre processing: COPCENTRA MAX 5 CNC CARBON S3 M5 45°/90°/45°, Naila: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, 09/2007 [corporate literature]. LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH (2007), Tricot machine with magazine weft insertion and glass-fibre chopper system: COPCENTRA HX-2-ST-CH – Biaxial, Naila: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, 07/2007 [corporate literature].
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
40
Non-crimp fabric composites
LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH (2007), Tricot Machine with Multiaxial Weft Insertion: COPCENTRA MAX3 CNC, Naila: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, 08/2007 [corporate literature]. LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH (2007), Tricot machine with weft insertion: COPCENTRA HS-2-ST, Naila: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, 07/2007 [corporate literature]. Mauersberger H (1954), Verfahren zur Herstellung von Kettenstichware, DD000000008194A, 06.09.1954. KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH (2007), Biaxial: Warp knitting machines with parallel weft insertion, Obertshausen; KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 08/2007 [corporate literature]. KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH (2009), HKS 2 | HKS 2–3 | HKS 2–3 E: Tricot Machines, Obertshausen; KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH,08/2009 [corporate literature]. KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH (2009), Kamcos® Karl Mayer Command System, Obertshausen; KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 09/2008 [corporate literature]. KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH (2009), Malitronic® Multiaxial Special, Obertshausen; KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 10/2009 [corporate literature]. KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH (2009), Multiaxial Warp knitting machines with multiaxial weft insertion, Obertshausen; KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 08/2009 [corporate literature]. KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH (2009), Technical Textiles, Obertshausen; KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 04/2009 [corporate literature]. KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH (2009), MULTIAXIAL ‘Cut & Lay’ Carbon, Obertshausen; KARL MAYER Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 08/2009 [corporate literature]. McHugh C (2009), Creating 3-D, One Piece, Woven Carbon Preforms using Conventional Weaving and shedding, Sampe Journal, No. 6, Vol. 45, 8–28. Mohamed M and Bogdanovich A (2009), Comparative Analysis of Different 3D Weaving Processes, Machines and Products, Proceedings of 17th International Conference on Composite Materials (ICCM-17), Edinburgh, UK, July 27–31, 2009. Mohamed M and Salama M (2001), High speed three-dimensional weaving method and machine, US000006315007B1, 13.11.2001 Mohamed M and Zhang Z (1992), Method of forming variable cross-sectional shaped three-dimensional fabrics, US000005085252A, 04.02.1992 Munzert H and Unglaub M (2009), Haltevorrichtung an den Transportketten einer Maschine zum Vorlegen von Fadengelegen, Verfahren zum Vorlegen und Fixieren von Filamentscharen zu einem Fadengelege und Multiaxialmaschine zur Durchführung des Verfahrens mit einer Haltevorrichtung, DE000010214140B4, 20.03.2008. Naumann R and Wilkens C (1986), Kettenwirkmaschine mit Magazinschußvorrichtung und auf dieser hergestellte Kettenwirkware, DE3447643C1, 07.08.1986. Nestler J, Vettermann F and Reuchsel D (2009), Device and method for spreading a carbon fibre hank, US000007536761B2, 26.05.2009. Parekh D (1989), Reinforcing fabric for power transmission belts, hoses and the like, US000004845963A, 11.07.1989. Petrenz S (2009), Malitronic® – eine neue Maschinengeneration zur Herstellung von Hochleistungsgelegen, Chemitzer Textiltechnik Tagung, 12, 129–141.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Production of non-crimp fabrics for composites
41
Roye A, Stüve J and Gries T (2005), Definition for the differentiation of 2D – and 3D – textiles. Part 1: production in one – stepprocesses, Technical Textiles, 48, 212–214. Roye A (2007), Hochleistungsdoppelraschelprozess für Textilbetonanwendungen, Textiltechnik/Textile Technology, 1–175. Schierz M, Waldmann M, Franzke G and Offermann P (2003), Direction-dependent yarn tensioning regulation for the production of multi-axial reinforcement structures – Richtungsabhängige Regulierung der Garnspannung für die Herstellung von multiaxialen Verstärkungsstrukturen Techtextil, Techtextil-Symposium, 10, 1–9. Schnabel A, Kruse F F, Behling T and Gries T (2009), Automated Textile Preforming of Semi-Finished Fabrics for the Mass Production of Fibre-Reinforced Plastic Components, Intelligent Textiles and Mass Customisation International Conference, Marocco Casablanca, 12.11.2009. Skoeck-Hartmann B, Diesel O, Cherif C and Gries T (2008), Integrated bonnet systems for pedestrian safety in Dörfel, A. Proceedings of the 2nd Aachen-Dresden International Textile Conference, Dresden, Dresden : Institute of Textile and Clothing Technology. Stig F (2009), An Introduction to the Mechanics of 3D-Woven Fibre Reinforced Composites, Licentiate degree; Stockholm. Volbers J (2005), Breitenverstellbare multiaxiale Kettenwirkmaschine zur anwendungsspezifischen Verarbeitung von Carbonfasern, Abschlussbericht über ein Entwicklungsprojekt, AZ: 22075, Deutsche Bundesstiftung Umwelt. Wagner G and Palmer R J (1998), Improved warp/knit reinforced structural fabric, WO001998010128A1, 12.03.1998. Wahhoud A (2005), Neue Gestaltungskonzepte zur Gewebeherstellung, WebereiKolloquium Denkendorf, 10, Denkendorf, 26–27 Apr, 2005. Weber K and Weber M (2004), Wirkerei und Strickerei – Technologische und bindungstechnische Grundlagen, Frankfurt am Main, Deutscher Fachverlag. Weiland J (1988), Kettenwirkmaschine mit Magazinschusseinrichtung, DE3720348C1, 29.09.1988. Wiedenhöft K and Vettermann F (1999), Die neue Malimo-Multiaxial als Beispiel für mechatronische Lösungen im Textilmaschinenbau, Chemnitzer TextilmaschinenTagung, 7, 179–186. Wienands C, Unglaub M and Maier S (2004), Verfahren und Vorrichtung zum kontinuierlichen Herstellen von verwirkten/vernähten multi-axialen Gelegen aus mehreren Lagen von Fäden, DE19913647B4, 01.04.2004. Wuensch I (2008), Lexikon Wirkerei und Strickerei, Frankfurt am Main, Deutscher Fachverlag. Wulfhorst B (1998), Textile Fertigungsverfahren – Eine Einführung, München, Wien, Carl Hanser Verlag. Wunner R, 1974. Kettenwirk- und Raschelmaschine mit vorbereitetem Eintrag mehrerer Schußfäden. DE000002244096C3. 08.09.1974. Wunner R (1987), Verfahren und Vorrichtung zum Legen von Querschußfäden für eine Kettenwirkmaschine, DE000003343048C2, 14.05.1987. Wunner R (2009) Kettenwirkmaschine nach Art einer Raschelmaschine, DE102007004315B4, 20.05.2009. Zeidler G, Reuchsel D and Vettermann F (2005), Verbesserung der Gelegequalität durch ein neues Verfahren zum Schusseintrag auf Karl Mayer Multiaxialmaschinen, Chemnitzer Textilmaschinen-Tagung, 10, 263–268.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
2 Standardisation of production technologies for non-crimp fabric composites F. KRUSE and T. GRIES, Institut für Textiltechnik (ITA) of RWTH Aachen University, Germany
Abstract: This chapter reviews the standardisation of the production of non-crimp fabrics (NCFs), as well as the patents protecting these methods. The first part discusses some common considerations in the production and use of NCFs, such as layer orientation, areal weight and bonding patterns. The second part focuses on some of the most important inventions and patents in this area: the computer-controlled weft insertion system (DE 19726831 C2), the LIBA type weft thread transport system (MAX5), the online tow-spreading system, and the ‘Hexcel patent’ (EP 0972102 B1). Key words: production of non-crimp fabric (NCF), warp-knitted NCF, weft-knitted NCF, non-crimp woven fabric, fixation by cohesion.
2.1
Introduction
This chapter gives an overview of the standardisation of the production of noncrimp fabrics (NCFs) and the patent situation. The first part refers to some of the typical questions asked about the production and use of NCFs. For example, it is concerned with topics such as the reference coordinate system of the orientation of single layers, and the estimation of areal weights. The second part is dedicated to selected important patents. It has not been easy to limit the extent of this chapter as the patent situation changes daily and the number of interesting patents is very high. In many conversations with European machine producers, the authors tried to determine those inventions which have had a major influence on the machine technology. These achievements can be read about in the second part of the chapter, which also offers an overview of the famous ‘Hexcel patent’.
2.2
Classification and standardisation of non-crimp fabric (NCF) production methods
Standards are very helpful in terms of allowing for successful communication between customers and textile producers. Terms and units must be defined, as well as a unified designation system for textile construction. Furthermore, important process parameters such as the layer orientation or testing procedures for the areal weight, fabric thickness, moisture, length and width should also be standardised. A very comprehensive standard in respect to the aspects quoted above is the European standard EN 13473, Parts 1, 2 and 3. In the following 42 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
43
section, parts of this standard and references to other standards, which are linked to EN 13427, are described.
2.2.1 Classification Non-crimp fabrics (NCF) are officially defined and standardised as multiaxial multi-ply fabrics. Contrary to other production technologies for textile fabrics, the fibres of each layer are orientated straight, and are only laid upon each other during the production process. Finally, the fixation of the single layers to a useable fabric is done by warp-knitting or by binder application. The fibre materials and the orientation, as well as the areal weight, of each layer can be chosen in a very flexible manner. Furthermore, fibre mats or short fibres can be inserted between each layer, as is shown in Fig. 2.1. Chopped strand mat
Auxilary material (Non-woven)
0º
+45º
90º
–45º
Stitching pattern
2.1 Classification of a non-crimp fabric.
2.2.2 Important terms and definitions A standard for the designation of a multiaxial NCF is given in EN 13473, Part 1. It consists of three data blocks, which are shown in Table 2.1. The three data blocks provide the following information: • • •
Data block 1: identification of the layer stacking sequence and textile construction Data block 2: identification of the binding system Data block 3: identification of the fabric manufacturer
In general, the individual item block shall be separated from the identity block by a comma (,). The three data blocks of the individual item block are framed by © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
44
Non-crimp fabric composites
Table 2.1 Designation system for multiaxial non-crimp fabrics according to EN 13473-1 Designation Identity block
Individual item block
International standard
Data block 1 Example [. . .]
EN 13473-1
Data block 2
Data block 3
[. . .]
[. . .]
rectangular brackets ([. . .]). If a data block is not used, this shall be indicated by empty rectangular brackets ([]). Data block 1 The descriptions of the single layers in data block 1 are separated by a double slash (//), starting with the first layer due to the production succession, see Fig. 2.2. In position 1 of each layer description, the material types and grades used in the layer are identified by code letters according to Table 2.2. In position 2 of the layer description, the areal weight is identified in the unit grams per square metre. Position 3 indicates the orientation of the layers. Data block 2 In this block, the binding system is defined and described by three values, which are separated from each other by a comma (,). In position 1 of the binding description, the used materials are identified by abbreviations according to Table 2.2.
Table 2.2 Abbreviations for material type from EN 13473-1 Code letter
Material type
A C G K PA PE PES PET PP
Aramide Carbon Glass Ceramic Polyamide Polyethylen Polyester Polyethylenterephthalate Polypropylene
NOTE: Supplements of further material types are possible. The material grades have to be additionally specified in each case.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
45
Table 2.3 Code letter for the type of binding system from EN 13473-1 Code letter
Type of binding system
L C
Loop system Chemical binding system
In position 2, the areal weight or the mass per unit area is identified [g/m2]. In data block 3, the binding type is identified according to Table 2.3. Data block 3 Data block 3 can be used as a code for the NCF’s producer. An example of the use of the designation system is shown below. The NCF has the following characteristics. • • • • • • •
E-glass reinforcement yarn. Three layers in the sequence −45°//+45°//0°. Parallel weft. Areal weight of the 45° plys: 235 g/m2. Areal weight of the 0° layer: 425 g/m2. Joined by a loop system using PES, 12 g/m2. The manufacture’s code is ITA-FOR860-TP1 (in this example).
The correct designation for this NCF is therefore: EN 13473,[G, 235, −45°//G, 235, +45°//G, 425, 0°][PES, 12, L][ITA-FOR860-TP1] Following this introduction to the designation of an NCF, this chapter will now provide some important definitions of the layer orientation and the estimation of the areal weight.
2.2.3 Definition of the layer orientation One very important standard used to define the layer orientation is the reference coordinate system. According to the ISO/DIS 1268-1 the 0° direction is parallel to the direction of production, e.g. the movement of the transport chains. The ‘1’ axis in Fig. 2.2 represents the y axis and, therefore, the 90° direction. Layer orientations within the positive quadrant from 0° to 90° are defined as positive. The ‘2’ axis or the z axis indicates the direction of the stacking sequence.
2.2.4 Estimation of the areal weight The estimation of the areal weight, or the mass per unit area, is a common procedure carried out when setting up a new product, or in order to control the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
46
Non-crimp fabric composites
2.2 Definition of the layer orientations according to ISO/DIS 1268-1/EN 13473-1.
areal weight randomly during production. A normative definition for textiles made with glass, carbon or aramid yarns is given in ISO 3374. To perform the tests, the specimen must be cut out of the textile in a specific manner, which is shown in Fig. 2.3. Each specimen must have a square or circular shape and an area of 100 cm2. The permissible error in the area of the resulting specimens should be 1% or less. In practice, this value can only be achieved through the use of a computer-controlled cutter or a stamping device. The use of handheld cutting disks or knives would result in a more or less pronounced shape distortion. Once it has been cut out, the specimen must be handled with great care, as otherwise some fibres may be lost. Before it is weighed, the specimen must be dried in a ventilated oven at 105°C±3°C for one hour. The specimen is cooled down to room temperature in a desiccator in order to keep the moisture as low as possible.
2.3 Suggested method for cutting out fabric specimens. Useable for fabrics wider than 50 cm. 1 = width of textile; 2 = warp direction.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
47
Table 2.4 Necessary characteristics and resolution of the used balance according to ISO 3374 Material
Measuring capability
Limit of permissible error
Resolution
Mats, all weights Fabrics ≥ 200 g/m2 Fabrics < 200 g/m2
0 to 150 g 0 to 150 g 0 to 150 g
0.5 g 10 mg 1 mg
0.1 g 1 mg 0,1 mg
The process of weighing must immediately follow the removal of the specimen from the desiccator. The necessary characteristics of the balance are given in Table 2.4. For a specimen area of 100 cm2, the resulting areal weight in grams per square metre is then:
[ g] PA = 10 000 + m A m2
[2.1]
Where m is the mass of the specimen in grams, and A the area of the specimen in cm2.
2.2.5 Bonding patterns In contrast with other warp-knitted fabrics, the loops in NCFs are only used for fixation. Therefore, the complexity of the bonding patterns used is relatively low. Nevertheless, a standardisation of the different and possible bonding patterns, as well as the basic concepts and the vocabulary which underpin them, is necessary and exists in the form of the international standard ISO 4921. One technique that is very common in biaxial or triaxial NCFs without any 0° layers is the simple pillar stitch, which is described under paragraph 3.2.37 of the ISO 4921 standard and sketched in Fig. 2.4. If 0° layers are applied, a weft insertion is necessary to prevent the 0° rovings from being lost. This can be achieved through the use of the tricot or the satin stitch, as shown in Fig. 2.4 centre and right.
2.3
Outstanding patents of existing machines for the production of NCFs
2.3.1 Computer-controlled weft insertion system (DE 19726831 C2) One very practical invention is the computer-controlled weft insertion system, which was patented on 10 Jan 2002 by the LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, Naila. It was first used in the LIBA MAX 3 CNC, as can be seen in Fig. 2.5. In contrast to the parent machines produced by the LIBA company and its competitors, which
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
48
Non-crimp fabric composites
2.4 Four commonly used bonding patterns in non-crimp fabrics: pillar stitch (top left), tricot stitch (top right), cord stitch (bottom left) and satin stitch (bottom right), according to ISO 4921.
2.5 New, computer-controlled weft insertion system of the LIBA MAX 3 CNC (left) and the old, fixed weft insertion system (right). (Source: LIBA GmbH).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
49
2.6 Computer-controlled weft insertion system, patented in DE 19726831 C2.
have fixed weft insertion systems, the new system facilitates a much higher rate of efficiency and flexibility. Figure 2.6 provides an overview of the new machine architecture. The universal weft layer (5) consists of one or more servomotor driven portal system (9), which moves in parallel with the direction of production (x-direction) on a gear rack (9) which is mounted on the modular machine frame (4). The fibers (3) are deposited by a layer carriage (2), which runs transversely to the direction of production (y and z-direction). With the degree of freedom offered by the portal system and the layer carriage, it is possible to realise every desired layer angle between −20° and +20° relative to the x-direction. The single layers are fixed up to the warping unit (8) by two chains (11) equipped with hooks on both sides of the machine, as shown in Fig. 2.7. This item is important insofar as it allows for the use of the full anisotropic potential of fibre-reinforced materials. Furthermore, the invention has led to a considerable reduction in the level of effort required to change the layer set-up. The desired angle of each ply is set in the computer via an interactive user interface. There is no mechanical work required, with the exception of some reed changes, if the areal weight is to be modified. Due to the lightweight portals and powerful servo motors, this invention made possible a much higher machine speed.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
50
Non-crimp fabric composites
2.7 Transport chain and layer carriage of DE 19726831 C2.
2.3.2 New weft thread transport systems (DE 10214140 B4) Despite all the advantages of the aforementioned invention, there are still some requirements regarding the production of textiles made from carbon fibres which remain unsatisfied. Carbon fibres are brittle and tend to break if they are bent around a small radius. So with the hook chains, which were the state-of-the-art technology until the patents dealt with in the following were published, there were some types of carbon fibres that could not be processed. Furthermore, there is a strong and economically driven demand for high-quality NCFs made from cheaper ‘heavy tow’ carbon rovings with up to 50k filaments. With the classical method of producing an NCF, which involves placing tows directly from the creels into the hook chain, it is not possible to realise low areal weights by using heavy tows with 24k filaments and above. The solution to this problem was found in a new process step prior to the placement. Before being placed, the carbon tows are spread into unidirectional (UD) tapes with a maximum areal weight of 300 g/m2. The spreading process can be done either online (see Section 2.3.3) or offline using a special machine. A special mechanism pulls out the tapes from the spreading unit or coils, then cuts them to a predefined length and places them into the transport chain with the clamping device. Despite the spreading process, the above-mentioned transport chain is one very important and critical item while producing NCFs out of spread tapes. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
51
One invention of the Karl Mayer Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH was a combination of a hook chain with a clamping mechanism. The relating patent was granted on 11 November 2006. The invention refers to a process and device to lay and fix band-shaped filament yarn sheets onto two transport devices arranged in parallel to one another to produce a uni-, bi- or multiaxial multi-ply fabric that is comprised of at least one layer of band-shaped filament sheets drawn in one direction, arranged side by side in one plane and separated from one another. The filament sheet is held on pin rows, as shown in Fig. 2.8.
2.8 Karl Mayer type clamping system for spreading tapes (patent claim EP 1512784 B1).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
52
Non-crimp fabric composites
2.9 Tape layer system of the LIBA MAX 5 CNC carbon with the clamping head (22), the sword (29) and the pressure pad (14). The numbers refers to the numeration in DE 10214140 B3 (Source: LIBA).
2.10 Transport chain of the LIBA MAX 5 CNC Carbon. As in Fig. 2.9, the numbers refer to the numeration in the text of the patent DE 10214140 B4 (Source: LIBA).
Another invention of the LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH was patented on 20 March 2008, patent number DE 10214140 B4. Before being placed, the carbon tows are spread into unidirectional (UD) tapes with a maximum areal weight of 300 g/m2. The spreading process can be done either online (see section 2.3.3) or offline using a special machine. A special mechanism pulls out the tapes from the spreading unit or coils, then cuts them to a predefined length and places them into the transport chain with the clamping device.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
53
The mechanism of clamping and transporting the UD tape is very simple, but also very effective. A sequence of clamping consists of eight phases, which are shown in Fig. 2.11. Note that the direction of production is perpendicular to the plane of the picture. Furthermore, only the left transport chain with the clamping device is shown.
2.11 Clamping sequence of an LIBA MAX 5 transport chain (patent claim DE 10214140 B4).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
54
Non-crimp fabric composites
In the first step, the UD tape (2) is pulled out from the coil or the online creel (see 2.3.3) and gripped by the clamping head (22). In step 2, the pressure pad (14) fixes the tape on the lower clamping plate (26) and a row of hooks (13). All parts of the clamping mechanism are mounted on the chain links of the transport chain (3), which moves steadily downwards to the warp-knitting unit (not shown). In the third step, the upper clamping plate (27) opens. Its movement is governed by a guide rail (30), which has a curvature at this point to generate the stroke of the clamping plate (27). In the fourth step, the clamping head (22) opens. Now, the part of the UD tape that is outside of the pressure pad is released. Thereafter, a sword (29) bends this free end of the tape down to an elastic profile (28). In step 6 the sword moves upwards, while the free end of the UD tape is fixed by the backwards-moving clamping plate (27) shortly afterwards (step 7). In the last step, the hub with the clamping head (22), the pressure pad (14) and the sword (29) moves up and against the direction of production. The process then repeats itself with the next tape. Another critical point while producing NCFs is the warping unit. Within this unit, the single layers are only fixed in the clamping or hook chains. Thus, only the parts of the layers that are beneath the clamping chains are stabilised while the rest is only kept in a straight orientation due to a certain pre-tension. An invention of the Karl Mayer Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH refers to a device where a continuous converser belt running synchronously to the transport chains supports the weft layers up to the knitting area of the multiaxial machine. As a consequence thereof, a significantly higher process stability and fabric quality can be achieved. The principle is shown in Fig. 2.12, where the converser belt is designated with the number 6.
2.3.3 Online tow spreading and feeding systems (EP 2003232 A1) This invention, which uses spread tows or UD tapes in the production of multiaxial NCFs was a major step forward. But in practice it has been found that it is necessary to establish a very homogeneous state of stress within the UD tapes when placing them into the transport chains. Furthermore, there is a strong customer demand to spread the tows directly in the machine, rather than using a separate spreading unit. For these reasons, the coils used to store and transport the UD tapes once spread, which are a potential origin of failures, are now obsolete. The solution that has been found for both requirements is the use of online tow spreading systems. An example for such a complex online spreading system is given in Fig. 2.13 and 2.14. In order to achieve a constant state of stress, a combination of the creels (5) and the spreading unit (6) in one moveable frame called a carriage (3) was created. The carriage itself is supported via rollers (4) in the machine frame (1), which is aligned with the tape-laying system and fixed to the ground.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
55
2.12 Principle for the use of transport belts between the warping needles (patent claim DE 19852281 C2).
The single tows run from the bobbin (7) via the guide pulleys (9) into the spreading unit (6) as is shown in Fig. 2.14. The major advantage of this combined creel and spreading unit consists of the simple fact that the tows are pulled from the bobbins and spread by the spreading unit at a constant speed and without any interruptions. This leads to there being a very high and uniform quality amongst the produced tapes and the carriage (3) is able to deliver the tapes discontinuously to the gripper (15) due to its own movement (Fig. 2.15).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
56
Non-crimp fabric composites
2.13 Online tow spreading system according to EP 2003232 A1 (Source: LIBA).
2.14 Principle of the combined creel and spreading unit according to EP 2003232 A1.
The sequence of pulling out a spread tape and placing it into the clamping chain is illustrated in Fig. 2.16. In the first step, the carriage (3) runs into its endpoint (Lmax) while permanently spreading a tape, which is held at its free end by the gripper (15). The restraint (11) remains open. In step 2, the carriage (3)
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
57
2.15 Movements of the tape (a), the gripper (b) and the carriage (c) during a lay-up sequence (EP 2003232 A1).
reaches its aft position and the gripper begins to pull out the tape. While pulling out the tape in step 3, the carriage moves forward in the same direction, but with a different speed, as shown in Fig. 2.16. At step 4, the carriage (3) reverses its movement while the gripper 15 slows down. In step 5, the tape is fully pulled out and the restraint (11) closes. At this point, the carriage (3) is on its way to its endpoint and constantly produces a tape reservoir. The tape-laying system (16, see section 2.3.2) is now moving against the direction of production to overtake the tape. In step 6, a cutter separates the tape, the gripper (15) opens and the tapelayer (16) puts the tape into the transport chains (12a and 12b) in the manner described in section 2.3.2. In step 7, the gripper (15) moves into its starting position while the carriage (3) or the spreading unit produces the tape reservoir. In step 8, the tape is clamped into the transport chains (12a and 12b respectively), the gripper (15) is in its starting position, and the carriage (3) is only a short distance away from its end position. Now everything is ready for the next sequence. On 17 December 2008 the patent EP 1512784 B1 was granted to the company Karl Mayer Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, which protects an alternative invention to feed spread carbon fibres tapes continuously into a knitting machine. The carbon fibres are unwound from a creel with carbon band bobbins by means of delivery rolls and led to a weft-laying device provided on the knitting machine. To do so, a band accumulator has been provided in between the creel and the weft laying device, the accumulating length of which can be varied. A control unit affects both delivery rolls and accumulator so that, notwithstanding an idle return motion of the weft laying device, the bobbins are unwound continuously and start-up tension and slow-down motion of bobbins will not adversely affect band tension in the multi-ply fabric. Further, a spreading device has been installed to ensure uniform width and thickness of carbon band before the weft laying device. The principle is shown in Fig. 2.17.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
58
Non-crimp fabric composites
2.16 Sequence of the placing of an offline spread tape into the transport chains according to EP 2003232 A1.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
59
2.17 Principle of a device to feed fibrous bands into a knitting machine (patent claim DE 102005008705 B3).
2.4
The ‘Hexcel patent’ – EP 0972102 B1
On 20 November 2003, a very famous and comprehensive patent was awarded to the French companies Société National d’Étude et de Construction de Moteures d’Aviation (National Company for the Design and Construction of Aviation Engines, SNECMA) and Hexcel Fabrics. In the preamble of the patent, it was stated that in a common production of NCFs, a certain amount of fibre undulation is unavoidable due to the warping loops in the fabric. In consequence of this fact, reduced mechanical properties are to be expected. One goal of the patent is therefore to avoid undulations and improve the mechanical properties by using alternative methods to fix the single layers of an NCF. Another goal of this patent also had a great influence on the development of production technologies for NCFs. The primary goal of the invention was to create a reduced-cost production method for NCFs, especially for those which are made from carbon fibres. As stated above, the production cost can be lowered by using tows with a very high number of filaments, e.g. heavy tows. The inventors of the Hexcel patent were among the first to identify the huge potential of using spread heavy tows, especially those made of carbon fibres. Following this, a wide range of methods of producing multiaxial NCFs out of heavy tows by spreading them to very low areal weights are given in the patent. An overview of the range of the patent is shown in Fig. 2.18.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
60
Non-crimp fabric composites
2.18 Figure from EP 0972102 B1, which is an indicator of the wide scope of this patent claim.
In patent claims 1 and 2, a maximum areal weight of 300 g/m2 and a minimum of 5 cm are protected. The used materials include every useable continuous and discontinuous high-performance fibre, including both carbon, ceramics and blends of the two, as well as glass and aramid fibres. Up to patent claim 9, further material properties, such as the use of use of carbon fibre tows with a minimum number of filaments of 12k, are also protected. In the sub-claims 10 to 22, different methods of applying a transversal cohesion to the fibres and the single UD layers are discussed. In the sub-claims 23–43, different methods of handling and fixing the different layers are protected. These refer particularly to methods which use all kinds of binders to prevent undulations, but also to those which function by warpknitting. In the claims 44–56, many of the above-named properties are protected for UD layers made from discontinuous fibres with a filament number higher than 12k, a width of more than 5 cm and an areal weight of a maximum of 300 g/m2. In claims 57 and above, the same is valid for spread cracked, and therefore also discontinuous, tows. In summary, the Hexcel patent was a highly visionary patent at the date of its announcement. However, the transfer of the patent claims to a commercially available machine has not taken place up to now. The use of carbon fibre heavy tows and the spreading of these into UD tapes to produce multiaxial NCFs is meanwhile the standard process of the companies LIBA and Karl Mayer Malimo. But the basic architecture of these modern machines is very similar to the Hexcel concept. Figure 2.19 shows this clearly.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
61
2.19 Figure 6a from EP 0972102 B1 – the basic architecture of all modern machines like the LIBA Max 5 or the Karl Meyer Multiaxial ‘cut and lay’ Carbon.
2.5
Product patents in the production of NCFs
2.5.1 Integrated manufacturing process for stringerstiffened panels (DE 10 2005 052573 A1) Thin-walled and stiffened-shell structures are very common in lightweight applications. A dry textile preform of a stringer-stiffened panel structure can be produced in various different ways. Reinforcement textiles for the panel of the structure are usually woven fabrics and/or multiaxial multi-ply fabrics. Stringers e.g. those in the form of hat or double-T profiles, are attached to these reinforcement textiles. The production of the hat or double-T profiles can be achieved through the forming, draping and fixing of plane reinforcement textiles to 3D textiles. However, hat or double-T profiles can also be manufactured through braiding, as this production process makes it possible to manufacture 3D structures in one step. The joining of both components, panel and stringer, can take place in a separate processing step before or after the consolidation of the construction units. In DE 10 2005 052573 A1, invented by the Institute of Textile Technology of RWTH, Aachen University and released on 3 May 2007, an integrated manufacturing process is described. During the multiaxial multi-ply fabric production of the basic textile, the prefabricated hat profiles are directly joined with the basic textile using warp-knitting.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
62
Non-crimp fabric composites
In order to allow for the implementation of an integrated manufacturing process, the multiaxial warp-knitting machine (Copcentra MAX 3 CNC from LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH, Naila) that is used at ITA was modified so that the multiaxial multi-ply warp-knitted fabrics and hat profile could be joined in one production step (Fig. 2.20 Integrated production process). The modification now permits a variable supply of stringer elements with a height of 50 mm, depending on position and number. The modification was achieved through the construction of a split piercing compound needle bar, a split closure bar and a split knock-over sinker, as well as split good rollers and a special device construction for hat profiles. A comparison of the joining technologies used in the project, ‘sewing with lockstitch’ and the ‘integrated manufacturing process’, is made according to the standard DIN 65148 ‘determination of the interlaminate shear strength in the tensile test’. The connection of the stringer to the panel is examined herewith. The test specimens are loaded in such a way that a shearing stress works in the connecting level between panel and stringer. The laminated sample test specimens are prepared with two milled grooves at a distance of 12.5 mm (Fig. 2.21) apart. During the tensile test, shear stress arises in the area between these grooves. This stress leads to material failure. The test specimens are stressed up to break. According to the standard, the constant test speed was selected in such a way that
2.20 Integrated production process.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
63
2.21 Preparation of test specimen (measurements in millimetres).
material failure takes place after approximately 60 seconds. In preliminary tests, an optimal test speed of 2 mm/min was determined. For the evaluation of the breaking tension, the ratio between the maximum strength and the shear crosssection is calculated. This is the interlaminate shear strength. The test series consisted of four different test specimens. The reference sample is a stringer-reinforced panel, which was added by one lockstitch seam per flange. Three further test specimens were manufactured in the integrated warp-knitting process, each with a different number of seams per flange. In order to eliminate discrepancies arising as a result of using different sewing threads, the same sewing thread material that was used by the lockstitch is used again in the integrated warp-knitting process in the area of joining the flanges. The evaluation of the test shows that the samples of the sewn textile preforms do not reach the values of the samples that were manufactured using the integrated process. The value of the breaking tension lies approximately 25% below the value of the test specimens of the integrated process. There is a difference in breaking tension between the sample test specimens from the integrated manufacturing process with a different number of seams per flange, but it is not significant.
2.5.2 NCFs stitched together using a fusible thread (EP 1 352 118 B1) Either stitching or the application of a binder is essential to allow for the handling of NCFs, but both serve to decrease the drape properties. In order to solve this problem, a fusible thread is used. Therefore, the stitched plies can be tailored and handled in the same way as common NCFs, and can also be heated in order to soften or melt the fusible thread, and hence to improve the drape of the fabric. The patent EP 1 352 118 B1 covers the draping of such an NCF over a forming tool within the steps of placing the NCF and heating it to soften the fusible thread to reduce the restriction of the drape by the stitching. It was published on 15 October 2003 by Airbus UK and Devold AMT.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
64
Non-crimp fabric composites
Claims 2–4 comprise different settings of the processing temperature, for example, to heat the NCF no higher than the fusion temperature of the thread, in order that a part of the thread remains. Claims 5–10 are about creating resin channels in the NCF by increasing the tension in the unfused stitching, and infusing the NCF with different types of matrix resin through those channels. Claims 11–18 concern manufacturing parameters such as the mass ratio of fusible thread to NCF, the melting temperature, or the material of the thread. The claims cover all possible NCF settings as known from the EN 13473, including different stitching patterns, such as tricot closed, and different yarn directions, from ±20° to 90°.
2.6
Immobilisation of adhesive on the surface of semifinished textile products (DE 102008004112 A1)
On 16 July 2009, a patent application from the company SAERTEX Wagner GmbH & Co. KG was published. It presupposes a semi-finished textile product with at least one surface provided with adhesive exhibits. It is a fact, particularly in the range of the rotors of wind power plants and also in boat building, that an adjustment of the textile single layers is welcome, especially when trying to fix them to vertical surfaces (Fig. 2.22). In order to achieve this, the composites are often implemented with selfadhesive. For example, a special thermoplastic adhesive based up on epoxy resins is applied to the surface of the textile. That is why the textiles can be fixed in a form, or on a pre-fixed layer. Furthermore, it is especially important in the group of sandwich components that the adhesions to the core material, e.g. balsa wood or various types of plastics, such as PVC or PE, are guaranteed. The problem with the special thermoplastic adhesives used is that the stickiness of the textiles is
2.22 Adjustment of textiles at the vertical surfaces of a rotor blade mold (source SGL Rotec).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Standardisation of production technologies
65
already beginning to decrease after only a short time. The capillary effect of the filaments, together with the affinity that the adhesives have to the size of the used fibres, leads to the adhesive migrating to the inside of the textile after a short time. Therefore, such textiles cannot be stored for long periods of time. Another possible means of increasing the adhesiveness of the surfaces is to apply natural rubber emulsions to the textiles. Unfortunately, natural rubber is barely soluble, so it tends to remain as a foreign particle in the fibre-reinforced construction unit and the strength of the NCF is reduced tremendously. The goal of this invention is to propose a textile with a sticky surface that is capable of being stored for a longer time with a normal strength. The solution is the immobilisation of the adhesive on the surface of the textile by the partial networking of at least one component of the glue, most commonly a monomer with double bonds, e.g. acrylic resin or vinyl ester. A preferred compound for the adhesive (related to its weight) is 25–40% natural rubber, 5–10% epoxide resin and 40–60% partial ester. In addition, the adhesive can contain an initiator, additives such as colourants or processing aids. It is also advantageous if the adhesive is capable of being swelled, because this facilitates a thorough mixture of the glue with the resin matrix. The adhesive can be sprayed onto the surface of the textiles in a quantity between two and 50 g/m2. In such a way, treated half-finished products exhibit a stable surface adhesiveness at ambient temperature which is consistent for a period of more than four months, and up to several years, so they are able to be positioned. Examples of such an adhesive include the self-adherent fabrics SAERfix® EP and SAERfix® UP from the company SAERTEX. The adhesive material is compatible with epoxy resins and is chemically incorporated into the matrix during the course of curing. There is no need to spray an additional adhesive and one can remove and reapply the fabric as necessary, as SAERTEX assures on its website: http://www.saertex .de/produkt_technik/produkte/saerfixR/ (15th June 2010).
2.7
References
Ref.No. DIN EN 13473–1 : 2001–11 Reinforcement – Specifications for multi axial multi-ply fabrics Part 1: Description Ref.No. DIN EN 13473–2 : 2001–11 Reinforcement – Specifications for multi axial multi-ply fabrics Part 2: Methods of test and general requirements Ref.No. DIN EN 13473–3 : 2001–11 Reinforcement – Specifications for multi axial multi-ply fabrics Part 3: Specific requirements Ref.No. ISO/DIS 1268–1 ISO Standard BS ISO 1268–1:2001 Fibre-reinforced plastics. Methods of producing test plates. General conditions Owner: BSI filed: 2002–01
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
66
Non-crimp fabric composites
Ref.No. ISO 3374 : 2000(E) Reinforcement products – Mats and fabrics – Determination of mass per unit area Ref.No. ISO 4921 : 2000(E/F) DIN EN ISO 4921 Knitting – Basic concepts – Vocabulary (ISO 4921:2000); German version EN ISO 4921:2001 Owner: filed: 2002–04 Ref.No. DE 19726831 C2 Patent DE 19726831 C2 Owner: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH Multi axial-Maschine mit Portalaufbau filed: 2002–10 Ref.No. EP 1512784 B1 Patent EP000001512784B1 Owner: MAYER Malimo Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 09117 Chemnitz, DE filed: 2006–11 Ref.No. DE 10214140 B4 Patent DE 10214140 B4 Owner: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH filed: 2008–03 Ref.No. DE 19852281 C2 Patent DE 000019852281 C2 Owner: KARL MAYER Malimo Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 09117 Chemnitz, DE filed: 2003–04 European Patent Ref.No. EP 2003232 A1 Owner: LIBA Maschinenfabrik GmbH filed: 2007–06 Ref.No. DE 102005008705 B3 Patent DE 102005008705 B3 Owner: KARL MAYER Malimo Textilmaschinenfabrik GmbH, 09117 Chemnitz, DE filed: 2006–09 Ref.No. EP 0972102 B1 European Patent Method for producing multiaxial fibrous webs Owner: Hexcel Fabrics, 69608 Villeurbanne Cedex, FR filed: 2003–11 Ref.No. DIN 65148 DIN Standard Aerospace; testing of fibre-reinforced plastics; determination of interlaminar shear strength by tenside test Owner: filed: 1986–11 European Patent Ref.No. EP 1 352 118 B1 Owner: Airbus UK Limited Devold AMT AS filed: 2001–12 Publication of the invention Ref.No. DE 102008004112 A1 Owner: SAERTEX GmbH & Co. KG filed: 2009–07 SGL Rotec http://www.sgl-rotec.com Owner: SGL Rotec GmbH & Co. KG, 27809 Lemwerder, DE
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
3 Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites P. MITSCHANG, Institut für Verbundwerkstoffe GmbH, Germany
Abstract: This chapter contains a short introduction on preform technology and answers the question of why stitching technology should be used. Different types of threads are described, followed by a short discussion about the advantages and disadvantages of each, which will help the reader to select the right type for a specific application. Quality aspects of sewn preforms are evaluated. Information is given about stitching technology, based on the requirements of composites. A description of the main technologies and a short overview of different stitching machines and their capabilities for structural stitching are also given. Finally, quality aspects of manufacturing structural stitched non-crimp fabrics (NCFs) are addressed. Special focus is given to machine parameters and their influence on compaction behaviour, permeability and laminate quality. Key words: stitching technology, thread selection, stitch hole ellipse, stitching parameters, stitched preform.
3.1
Introduction
The processing of non-crimp fabric (NCF) composites is generally carried out using a liquid moulding process like Resin Transfer Moulding (RTM) or Vacuumassisted Resin Infusion (VARI). During the manufacturing of structural components, the main focus is on maintaining the necessary fibre orientation in the component. This is the reason why, during the processing of NCFs in liquid moulding processes, a preforming process is established before the actual infusion process can be carried out. In addition to the use of a moulding process with thermoplastic binders, the stitching technique can be offered as preform technology to strengthen the fibres. Due to its development and broad application in the clothing industry, stitching technology offers a considerable range of advantages, such as the variable selection of stitch types and sewing threads. The potential applications of NCF composites, as well as the RTM process, can place demands on their structural seams. Therefore, it is necessary to differentiate between stitching for fixation or positioning, stitching for assembly reasons, and structural stitching (Mitschang et al., 2003). Table 3.1 shows the advantages as well as the challenges of structural stitching. Aside from the quality of the basic textile product (in this case, a non-crimp fabric) and the injection or infusion process (including the hardening of the resin), the quality of a laminate or component is decisively defined by the quality of the preform. Figure 3.1 shows how the quality of the component depends on the materials and processing steps used to produce it. 67 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
68
Non-crimp fabric composites
Table 3.1 Advantages and challenges of structurally stitched non-crimp fabric preforms Advantages
Challenges
Easy handling of complex textile structures Manufacturing of semi-finished products Assembly for 3D geometries Waste reduction Pre-compaction of preforms Complex component Efficient injection or infusion processes Elimination of post-processing (net-shape) Improved 3D properties
3D and surface quality of laminate Thread material as a third component Thread impregnation Prevention of void formation Fibre separation Fibre deflection Prevention of resin-rich zones Reduction of in-plane properties Surface appearance and resin shrinkage
3.1 Factors influencing laminate and part quality.
The following sections describe the selection of sewing threads, an estimation of the available stitching technologies, the applicable machine technology, and the parameters that have to be taken into account in the construction of structural seams for NCFs.
3.2
Threads for structural stitching technology
According to the role of the individual seam, there are different sewing threads available (Ogale et al., 2004). In the first instance, these seams are to be differentiated according to the materials used in their construction. While thermoplastic sewing threads are primarily used for positioning, fixing, and as
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
69
Table 3.2 Classification for yarn types to be used for stitching Thread type
Description
Mechanical properties
Spun yarn
Fibres with twist level, ∼ 400 turns/m 10–50 filaments, twisted ∼150 turns/m Bulky, looped filament orientation Filament core, staple fibre sheath
Medium strength and elongation Good strength and high elongation Inherent high elongation
Twisted multi filaments Textured yarn Core spun yarn
High performance thread
assembly seams, due to their high elongation at break, materials with high strength or stiffness are preferred for structural seams. These materials are mainly glass, aramid and carbon. As a second characteristic, the thread type is crucial in terms of determining the behaviour of the sewing thread. Table 3.2 shows a comparison of different types of sewing thread. The various types of sewing thread are generally all suitable to be used as needle threads as well as bobbin threads. In most cases, textured threads made of very fine polyester filaments (<15 tex) are used as bobbin threads. In the selection of a needle thread, it is important to consider the fact that the thread will have to pass through the needle eye several times and must therefore be able to withstand looping with the bobbin thread (knot formation). It is especially important to take account of this aspect when using carbon sewing threads. Core spun yarns and twisted multifilament yarns are suitable for structural sewing. Some commercially available threads include glass fibre sewing threads from Culimeta (Culimeta, 2010), PPG (PPG Fiber Glass, 2010) and Vetrotex (SaintGobain Vetrotex International, 2010) and carbon fibre sewing threads from Schappe Techniques and Toray. Typical here is the use of relatively thick sewing threads (70–150 tex) with medium to low twist. The low knot strength is a considerable problem in the manufacture of carbon fibre sewing threads, but it can be considerably increased through the use of core spun technology with a hybrid solution. Figure 3.2 shows the different sewing threads based on carbon fibre rovings. Type CF-1, CF-2, and CF-3 are hybrid threads manufactured using a crochet technology (Weimer, 1999), a wrapping technology, or a braiding technology (Schappe, 2004). An advantage of these technologies is that the carbon filaments are placed straight in the core of the sewing thread, which serves to optimise their load-bearing ability. A disadvantage is the cover of the used polyester thread, which is an additional component and an unwanted material in the composite. Alternatively, it also is possible for a carbon fibre roving to be turned or twisted, as shown in Fig. 3.2 by type CF-4, CF-5, and CF-6.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
70
Non-crimp fabric composites
3.2 Different types of carbon fibre sewing threads (IVW GmbH).
The process of turning and twisting carries a risk of causing pre-damages and leads to the suboptimal placement of fibres in the composite, as wells as inadequate load-carrying ability, due to the twists it creates in the filaments. Another important parameter for the selection of fibres is fibre sizing. The impregnation properties of the thread and the chemical compatibility between the sewing thread and the resin during the curing process is defined by the fibre design and the fibre sizing used. In addition to the requirement to be compatible with the resin system, a further function of fibre sizing is to reduce the sliding friction between the thread and the needle, as well as between the thread and the stitched textile structure. If there is too much friction, abrasive thread wear can occur and lead to thread breakage. Thus, not only will the efficiency and economic performance of the process be endangered, but the structural properties of the stitching will also be considerably reduced. The properties of strength, stiffness, elongation, and friction are all important for the complete performance of a chosen thread.
3.3
Stitching technology and sewing machines
Almost all stitching technologies are applicable in the manufacturing of preforms for NCFs (Poe et al., 2002). The specific selection has to be carried out according to the demands of its respective application. The modified lock stitch, chain stitch, blind stitch, one-side stitch and tufting are particularly suitable for structural stitched laminates (Ogale and Mitschang, 2004; Herkt et al., 2006; Drechsler,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
71
3.3 Schematic diagram of stitch formation using lock stitch and micrograph of a non-crimp fabric laminate stitched with a modified lock stitch.
2000). Figure 3.3 shows the lock stitch formation, as well as a NCF laminate stitched with a modified lock stitch using a glass fibre sewing thread. The modified lock stitch differs from the deployed standard lock stitch used in the apparel industry in terms of the interlace position of the needle and bobbin thread. While in the apparel industry, the interlace is positioned within the work piece, for structural stitching the interlace must be positioned on the rear side of the laminate due to there being minimal fibre undulation inside the laminate. This can be achieved through the adjustment of the tensile forces between the needle and bobbin thread during stitch formation. Aside from the lock stitch, which is well known and used in the apparel industry, there have been other seams established for structural stitching. These include one-side stitching techniques (such as KSL blind stitch RS 510, KSL double needle RS 530, and ITA sewing head) and tufting (KSL Tufting RS 522). Table 3.3 summarises the most commonly used stitch types in relation to their influence on the quality and properties of the preform. The one-side stitching heads (Fig. 3.4 and Fig. 3.5) are characterised by the fact that they form a chain stitch with one or two threads and that access to the textile (NCF) is granted only from one side. The blind stitch RS 510 can be performed while the textile is held in a tool because the curved blind stitch needle need not necessarily penetrate the textile material. Compared to stitch types such as the lock stitch, one-side stitch and blind stitch, no interlacing of the needle thread occurs during tufting (Fig. 3.6). The needle thread is inserted into the textile material by use of a hollow needle and forms a loop in the reinforcing material due to the difference in friction forces between the needle and thread, and the textile and thread. Typical of this stitch are the visible loops on the rear side of the laminates. Theoretically, it would also be possible for the loops to end in the material without penetrating it, but this cannot be realised in practice because the interior friction forces between the reinforcing textile and the sewing thread cannot be reproduced. Automation is a major aspect of structural stitching during the preforming process. Two different types can be distinguished. The first type consists of 2D
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
72
Non-crimp fabric composites
Table 3.3 Stitch type and related influence on preform characteristics Stitch type (IAW DIN 61400)
Thread consumption
Handling
Lock stitch (Kl. 301)
– Hybridisation and high efficiency possible – High thread tensile forces
– Good shear – Different fibre – Exactly strength of displacement on adjustable layer package the upper or – Low fibre – Low tendency lower surface of material to warp the material content in the – High thread laminate tensile forces
Blind stitch – No bobbin – Possible (Kl. 103) thread stitching in a necessary solid tool – Large thread – Lower layers demand are not fixed – Low efficiency
One side stitch
– No bobbin thread necessary – High fibre consumption
Tufting
– Very high – No efficiency with interlacing, optimal thus no placement in joining the laminate between the (no loops) single layers
Fibre disorientation
– Lower single layers are not influenced by the stitching process – Local thread concentration, therefore, high shear
Compression
– Compaction of the layers not adjustable – Due to precompaction slight deviation of needle possible
– Good shear – Material – Seam width strength of penetration with influences the layer package 2 needles material in a – Different larger area orientation of 3D-reinforcement – Low thread strength – Thick needle necessary, thus movement in the laminate
– Thread strength (joining) insufficient for insertion of compaction force – Low fibre material content in the laminate
automatic sewing machines, which are generally equipped with the lock stitch. Figure 3.7 shows a two-dimensional (2D) plant for the manufacture of plane preforms, so-called textile reinforcements. The second type consists of the so-called sewing robots, which can be flexibly equipped with different stitching heads. These sewing robots have been developed especially for structural stitching in the spatial (3D) direction. Figure 3.8 shows the use of a flexible robot system for structural stitching as a gantry system with a suspended sewing robot.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
73
3.4 Stitching heads and schematic diagram of stitch formation using blind stitch (KSL, Lorsch; left: blind stitch RS 510, right: double needle RS 530).
3.5 Schematic diagram of stitch formation using one-side stitch and micrograph (ITA, RWTH Aachen).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
74
Non-crimp fabric composites
3.6 Tufting head and schematic diagram of stitch formation during tufting (KSL, Lorsch; tufting RS 522).
Table 3.4 shows more clearly the selection of the particular stitch types and sewing threads which have to be used, depending on the required seam type and task (Ogale, 2007).
3.4
Quality aspects for structural stitching
The sewing thread is inserted into the laminate oriented widthways, so positioned vertically to the in-plane reinforcement fibres. In order for the sewing thread to
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
75
3.7 2D sewing plant for manufacturing of plane preforms (IVW, Kaiserslautern).
3.8 Flexible robot systems for structural stitching (KSL, Lorsch).
achieve the required effect of structural stitching, it is necessary to insert into the textile structure an adequate filament diameter in the form of bundled single filaments, which should be reinforced. Thicker sewing threads (filament bundles, as shown in Fig. 3.2) are normally used to keep the number of stitches per unit area low. When the needle penetrates the textile (NCF) the in-plane filaments are moved aside and the sewing thread is inserted. An ellipse is formed around the stitch hole due to the movement of the in-plane fibres. The dimensions of the ellipse depend upon the set-up of the layer orientation, the sewing thread, the stitching direction, and the machine parameters. It is possible to characterise the ellipse by measuring its half-axis. The real ellipse area has approximately 65%
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
76
Non-crimp fabric composites
Table 3.4 Seam type related applicability of stitch types and threads Seam type
Stitch type
Thread applicable
Fixing and positioning
Modified lock stitch
Thin, flexible, high elongation, polyester Medium thick, less elongation, polyester Medium thicker, polyester Thicker polyester, Nomex®, or Kevlar® Thick, less elongation, polyester, Kevlar® Thick, polyester Polyester, Nomex®, or Kevlar® Polyester, Kevlar®, glass Carbon, glass, Kevlar® Carbon, glass, Kevlar® Carbon, glass, Kevlar®
Chain stitch
Assembling
Blind stitch Modified lock stitch Chain stitch One-side stitch Blind stitch
Structural
Tufting Modified lock stitch One-side stitch Tufting
of the area of an ideal ellipse, as calculated from the minor and major ellipse axis values measured from the laminate (Ogale, 2007). For the purpose of analysis, the stitch hole can also be modelled as a diamond shape of which the longer axis is oriented in parallel with the fibre direction of the individual layer (Roth, 2005; Heß et al., 2007). Figure 3.9 shows the top view of a stitched structure with the specification of the minor and major half axis. The set-up of the laminate has a major influence on the formation of the ellipse. The longer (major) half-axis of the ellipse is always positioned in the direction of the fibre orientation. If the stitching direction is running vertically to the fibre direction, a maximum expansion can be observed. The closer the stitching direction is to the fibre orientation, the lower the in-plane fibre undulation will be. This means that, in the case of a real laminate, each layer has a different orientation in fibre undulation, due to the variable laminate set-up. Figure 3.10 shows a fourply set-up, as well as a micrograph of the respective laminate. The fact that the fibre undulation is different in each laminate layer results in there being a loss of the in-plane mechanical properties, which should not be neglected. The formation of the stitch hole expansion depends directly on the type of sewing thread used. Figure 3.11 shows the ellipse formation (top view) and the stitch hole expansion in the cross-section of the laminate. A comparison between a flexible polyester thread and a very rigid carbon fibre sewing thread is shown in Fig. 3.11. The larger stitch expansion and, thus, the ellipse enlargement for the rigid carbon fibre thread is clearly visible. The optimised adjustment of the sewing machine parameters, especially the balance
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
77
3.9 Ellipse formation in the laminate (top view) with half axis.
3.10 Influence of the layer set-up on ellipse formation in the laminate.
between needle and bobbin thread tension, also have a major influence on the quality of the seam. Figure 3.12 shows the impact of thread tension being too high, and compares this to an optimised machine parameter. The stitch hole expansion increases and the knot placement of the needle and bobbin thread moves into the laminate and generates additional fibre undulations in the intermediate layers. A further aspect that is directly influenced by ellipse formation is the surface quality of the laminate. A local compaction of the reinforcement fibres and visible fibre undulations in the upper laminate layer (Figure 3.13) occurs due to the penetration of the needle and the insertion of the needle threads. This leads to matrix-rich areas at the surface and the formation of sink marks due to the hardening of the used matrix macroscopic. After the preform has been placed in
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
78
Non-crimp fabric composites
3.11 Influence of the thread material on ellipse formation.
3.12 Influence of the machine parameters on ellipse formation.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
79
3.13 Surface characteristic due to fibre concentration (left) and matrix shrinkage (right).
3.14 Reduction in ellipse size by preform compaction.
the injection mould, the preform is normally compacted to the final height required to reach the necessary fibre volume content. Figure 3.14 demonstrates the influence of preform compaction on ellipse formation, based on textured and twisted multifilament threads. It is possible to reduce the ellipse area by a factor of three to five depending on the sewing thread used. The compression force that is necessary in order to reach the required fibre volume content depends on the sewing thread used and the sewing machine parameters selected. Figure 3.15 clarifies this by using a
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
80
Non-crimp fabric composites
3.15 Influence of stitch density on compaction pressure to reach a defined fibre volume content.
four-layer NCF [0/90]4. The layer set-up was stitched at three different stitch densities (13.33 and 3.33 stitches per cm2 and unstitched) with a twisted multifilament thread and high thread tension. Up to a fibre volume content of approximately 55%, no significant influence was recognised. A reduction in the compaction force necessary to reach a high-fibre compaction can be seen when using a very high stitch density and a high thread tension. An increase in the compaction force must be accepted when using lower stitch densities or low thread tension. This results from the fibre nesting being hindered by the inserted needle thread during compaction. This behaviour is unique to an NCF under the conditions described, and cannot be directly transferred to other lay-ups or other textiles, such as woven fabrics. A very high pre-compaction of the layer set-up during the stitching of structural seams can create flow channels at the surfaces of the preform due to insufficient compaction behaviour in the mould. These influence the injection flow in such a manner that the injected resin runs first of all along the seams and from there impregnates the reinforcing fibre structure. Figure 3.16 shows the change in flow front geometry in a biaxial NCF lay-up influenced by a stitch density of 3.33 stitches per cm2. Due to the fact that structural stitching is only used locally within a complete structure, this effect must be classified as negative. Flow channels are hardly used in the form of desired flow assistance due to their inadequate reproducibility.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
81
3.16 Influence of stitching on the flow front of a biaxial NCF (left: unstitched; right: stitch density 3.33 stitches per cm2; fibre volume content 50%).
3.5
Applications and future trends
At present, the use of structural sewing of NCFs is not widespread. The first applications of this technology can be found in aviation (Weimer, 2003), e.g. in the Airbus A380 pressure bulkhead or very fast rotating fan wheels. Structural sewing is used in these applications to improve the assembly properties of preforms, as well as the material properties of the component. From the component perspective, the essential motivation is the improvement of the impact behaviour and, consequently, the reduction of a delamination risk in the laminates. Therefore, it is the structural components with impact hazard in particular, such as the bottom of fuselages, rail vehicles and automobiles, or structures in airflows, such as turbine blades, the wing-leading edges of aeroplanes, or the blades of wind energy plants, that are predestined for future areas of application. The further development of stitching technology for the structural stitching of NCFs depends greatly on the complete development of stitching technology as the preform technology for liquid composite moulding processes. The machine technology is sufficiently developed. Specific adjustments are expected in the area of sewing thread development. The development of carbon fibre sewing threads, especially if achieved in combination with CFRPC compatible sizings, will serve to increase the effectiveness of NCFs. A further area of minor investigation is the influence of stitching on the actual impregnation process. Until now, there have been only publications on the influence of stitching on the flow of resin in fabrics (Rieber and Mitschang, 2010) but in principle these results should be transferable. By discovering new knowledge in the area of the structural effects of stitched NCFs, conclusions can be drawn about the optimal specifications such as stitch density, fibre diameter and others. General information for the use of the stitching technology in the preforming and structural application of NCFs is published in Long (2005), Beier et al.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
82
Non-crimp fabric composites
(2006) and Weimer and Mitschang (2001). Direct textile technologies for the manufacturing of 3D reinforcement structures are investigated by Tong et al. (2002). An excellent summary of the state of the art of structural stitching can be found in Ogale (2007).
3.6
References
Beier U, Fischer F, Sandler J K W, Altstadt V, Weimer C and Buchs W (2007), Mechanical Performance of Carbon Fibre-Reinforced Composites Based on Stitched Preforms, Composites Part A, 38, 1655–1663. Culimeta (2010), Technical yarns. Available from http://www.culimeta.de/technical-yarns. php (Accessed 26 January 2010). Drechsler K (2000), Advanced textile structural composite – needs and current developments, The Fifth International Conference on Textile Composites. 18–20 September, 2000, Leuven, Belgium. Herkt M, Middendorf P, Less C, Riedel W, Schouten M and Drechsler K (2006), 3-D reinforcement of composite T-joints by means of robot-assisted stitching technology, SAMPE April 30 May 2006, Long Beach, CA, USA. Heß H, Roth Y C and Himmel N (2007), Elastic Constants Estimation of Stitched NCF CFRP Laminates Based on a Finite Element Unit-Cell Model, Composites Science and Technology, 67, 1081–1095. Long A C (2005), Design and manufacture of textile composites, Cambridge, Woodhead Publishing Limited. Mitschang P, Ogale A, Schlimbach J, Weyrauch F and Weimer C (2003), Preform technology: a necessary requirement for quality controlled LCM processes, Polymer and Polymer Composites, 8, 605–622. Ogale A, Weimer C and Mitschang P (2004), Selection of sewing threads for preform manufacturing, Advanced Composite Letters, 13, 145–153. Ogale A, and Mitschang P (2004), Tailoring of Textile Preforms for Fiber-reinforced Polymer Composites, Journal of Industrial Textiles, 34, 77–96. Ogale A (2007), Investigations of sewn preform characteristics and quality aspects for the manufacturing of fiber reinforced polymer composites, IVW-Schriftenreihe, 70. Poe Jr C C, Dexter H B and Raju I S (2002), A review of the NASA textile composite research. Available from http://techreports.larc.nasa.gov/ltrs/PDF/1997/aiaa/NASAaiaa-97-1321.pdf (Accessed 7 October 2002). PPG Fiber Glass (2010), Bobin and texturized yarns. Available from http://www.ppg.com/ glass/fiberglass/products/pages/default.aspx (Accessed 26 January 2010). Rieber G, and Mitschang P (2010), 2D Permeability changes due to stitching seams, Composites Part A, 41, 2–7. Roth Y C (2005), Beitrag zur rechnerischen Abschätzung des Scheibenelastizitätsverhaltens in Dickenrichtung vernähter Faser-Kunststoff-Verbund-Laminate, IVW-Schriftenreihe, 55. Saint-Gobain Vetrotex International (2010), Glass filament yarns. Available from http:// www.vetrotexeurope.com/yarns.html (Accessed 26 January 2010). Schappe (2004), Carbon thread for composite industry by Schappe Techniques. Available from http://www.schappe.com (Accessed 12 December 2009). Tong L, Mouritz A P and Bannister M K (2002), 3D fibre reinforced polymer composites, Oxford, Elsevier.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Structural stitching of non-crimp fabric preforms for composites
83
Weimer C (1999), Carbon fiber sewing thread for compound fiber and plastics materials, German Patent DE19932842. Weimer C and Mitschang P (2001), Aspects of the Stitch Formation Process on the Quality of Sewn Multi-Textile-Preforms, Composites Part A, 32, 1477–1484. Weimer C (2003), Preform-Engineering: Applied Technologies to Incorporate Part and Process Functions into Dry Textile Reinforcements, Composites Science and Technology, 63, 2089–2098.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
4 Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching on the geometry of non-crimp fabrics S.V. LOMOV, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
Abstract: Internal geometry of multiaxial multi-ply warp-knitted non-crimp fabrics (NCFs) and their composites is described in this chapter, based on the understanding of the production process of NCF, experimental studies of the internal structure of NCF composites and models of the same. The internal geometry of NCF is treated as geometry of cross-ply laminate of unidirectional fibrous plies, with fibres in the plies distorted due to interaction with the knitting needles and the stitching thread. The positions and dimensions of the distortions are characterised for different types of NCF in their relaxed state and after consolidation into composite material. This characterisation includes changes of NCF geometry due to shearing of the reinforcement during composite forming. A ‘virtual NCF’ model implemented in a software tool is described. Key words: internal geometry, warp-knitting, fibre distortions, shear, geometrical model.
4.1
Introduction
The production process (explained in Chapter 1) of specific types of non-crimp fabric (NCF) – produced by knitting together unidirectional plies of fibres – results in the fibrous structure of the fabric, which is very close to a laminate of unidirectional (UD) plies, the difference being distortions of the fibre placement given by the stitching. The plies of the fabric are formed as continuous layers of parallel fibres, placed as uniformly as the technology allows. These plies are formed by placement of thick tows, but the tows are spread as finely as possible before placement and are positioned as close together as possible. As the technology allows usage of tows of a variety of thickness and width (which can be larger than the spacing of knitting needles), and as the tows can be placed with any chosen orientation, it is impossible to ensure that the knitting needles go through the plies at positions in between the tows. The needles will penetrate the spread fibre bundles and the production parameters of the machine are set in such a way as to minimise possible fibre damage (e.g. ‘walking needle’, etc). The description given in the previous paragraph is idealised. The process of the piercing of the fibrous ply by the needle and forming of the stitching (warpknitted) loop results in a certain disturbance of the uniform placement of the fibres. These disturbances can cause resin-rich regions in the impregnated 84 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
85
composite, affecting the mechanical performance of it. They can also change the permeability of the fabric, affecting the processability of it in liquid composite moulding. Another source of deviation of the behaviour from an ideal pile of multi-axial plies are the stitching loops, whose three-dimensional (3D) geometry can cause different geometrical features of the preform, which may affect processing and/or performance in a positive or a negative way. This chapter starts with a description of the idealised geometry of fibres in the plies and the stitching loops and proceeds to a discussion of distortions of the fibres due to stitching, including the transformation of the geometrical features of the fabric caused by shear deformation during draping of the preform. Finally, a model (with software implementation) of the internal geometry of NCF is introduced. The geometry description of NCF given in this chapter has been initially introduced in (Lomov et al., 2002).
4.2
General parameters of the fibrous plies
European standard EN 13473 defines a multiaxial multi-ply (non-woven) fabric (which is synonymous to the term ‘non-crimp fabric’ in the language of composite community) as follows. A textile structure constructed out of one or more laid parallel non-crimped nonwoven thread plies with the possibility of different orientations, different thread densities of the single thread plies and possible integration of the fibre fleeces, films, foams or other materials, fixed by loop systems or by chemical binding systems. The threads can be oriented parallel or alternating crosswise. These products can be produced on machines with insertion devices (parallel-weft or cross-weft) and warp-knitting machines or chemical binding systems.
In this book the NCF created by chemical binding systems will not be considered. The definition stresses the fact that the fibrous plies are laid up with threads. Binding the plies together by warp-knitting can be deliberately made in such a way that the stitching yarn pierces the plies in between the laid threads. This would result in open preform architecture. However, in NCF used in high-end composite production (which is the subject of this book), wide threads (flat tows) are laid very close together, forming continuous fibrous plies. The plies are bound by warp-knitting, with piercing sites positioned on the surface of the preform according to the needles’ spacing, without any connection to the tow positioning. Needles pierce the fibrous plies (probably in the middle of the laid-up tows), distorting them locally. This results in a preform construction close to an ideal laminate composed of unidirectional uniform plies. According to the standard, a fabric is characterised by the following parameters: • •
Fibrous nature of the plies – glass (G), carbon (C), aramid (A), etc. Areal density of the plies (g/m2). It is not necessarily the same for all the plies.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
86 •
• • •
Non-crimp fabric composites Direction of fibres in the plies, given by an angle with the machine direction (0°). The angles lie in the range [−90°, 90°], positive sign corresponds to x0y quadrant of a right-hand Cartesian co-ordinate system xyz, x going in the machine direction and z in the vertical direction of the successive layout of the plies. Nature of the binding – polyamide (PA), polyethylene (PE), polyester (PES/ PET), polypropylene (PP). This may refer to a stitching yarn or to a chemical binder. Areal density of the binding. Type of the binding agent – stitching or loop (L), chemical (C)
For example, the designation stipulated by the standard for three-ply glass fabric +45/−45/0, stitched by polyester yarn is [G, 235, +45° // G, 235, −45° // G, 425, 0°][PES, 12, L] The total areal density of the fabric is 235 + 235 + 425 + 12 = 907 g/m2. The weight of each single ply depends on the yarn weight and the yarn placement density. In general, the yarn weight is characterised by the number of filaments, which ranges from 3k up to 80k in the case of carbon tows. The areal density usually ranges from 100 g/m2 upwards. The higher the yarn weight, the higher is the minimum ply areal density to be reached with a closely covered surface. To reach low ply areal density using thick tows, the latter are spread with the special unit. Yarns with higher fibre count present economical advantages: the raw material is cheaper and the production can be faster (as more fibres are laid in one weft placement). Low ply areal weight is desirable as lighter fabrics have better drapability. The current technology allows achieving 150 g/m2 with a 12k yarn in the weft or 24k in 0° layer. The aim of ongoing development work is to reach the same 150 g/m2 with 40k to 80k yarns for all orientations.
4.3
Geometry of the stitching
4.3.1 Knitting pattern To understand the patterns of stitching seen on the surface of a non-crimp fabric (NCF), it is necessary to understand the principle of warp knitting. Here, a brief explanation is given; more detail can be found in (Spencer, 1997). The principle of warp knitting is illustrated in Fig. 4.1. A knitted fabric (in a warp-knitting process as such), or a knitted web (when warp-knitting is used to stitch fibrous plies) is an assembly of loops formed by the interaction between knitting needles and guides. Yarns are fed through the guides simultaneously on all the knitting needles, which are fixed on a needle bar and move together. Loop-forming action also
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
87
4.1 Principle of warp-knitting: interaction of the knitting needles and guides.
occurs simultaneously at every needle in the needle bar during the same knitting cycle. Consider one warp yarn (‘new yarn’, a yarn which is about to make a new loop), going through the guide in the beginning of the knitting cycle (Fig. 4.1a). Knitting needles are in the high position. Old loops at the edge of the previously formed fabric are on the stems of the needles. The guide, carrying the new yarn, moves around a knitting needle, forming new loop (b, c). The knitting needle moves down, connecting the new loop with the old one, sitting on its stem (d, e). In the case of stitching of fibrous plies, the needles pull the new loop through the plies. Finally, the guide moves to another needle to start the next knitting cycle (f). The knitting action of the needles creates connection of the loops in the machine (‘wale’) direction (Fig. 4.2a). Movement of the guides across the needle bed creates the connection in the cross (‘course’) direction, forming a warp-knit pattern. The
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
88
Non-crimp fabric composites
4.2 Principle of warp-knitting: pattern formation (a), coding (b) and examples of knitting patterns (c).
positions of the gaps between the needles, where the guides pass in the subsequent knitting cycles, can be used to code the pattern (so-called Leicester notation). Consider a diagram of the guide’s movement, a so-called lapping diagram (Fig. 4.2b). Rows of dots represent needles in plane view. The numbering of needles assumes the pattern mechanism to be on the right side. As the guides position themselves in the spaces between needles, the positions between the vertical columns of dots represent shift of the guides. The pattern is coded by the sequence of these numbers: s1 − S1/s2 − S2/ . . . /sN − SN where si and Si are the positions of the guides forming the i-th loop, N is the number of knitting cycles in the pattern. The positions of the guides si and Si refer to gaps between needles, where the elementary movement of the guide starts. A pair si – Si represents an overlap movement of the guides (the guides move behind the needles), Si/si+1 represents underlap movement (the guides move in front of the needles). We consider only the patterns with one-needle overlap, which means that /si − Si / = 1. Figure 4.2c presents examples of warp-knitting patterns, used for NCF reinforcements.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
89
When fibrous plies are stitched, the pattern is seen on the face of the fabric (see Fig. 4.2a). These yarns are laid on the face of the fabric by the guides. On the back of the fabric, chains of loops are seen, going in the machine direction. These are the loops formed on separate needles and interconnected due to the knitting action of the needles.
4.3.2 Positions of the stitching sites The stitching yarn pierces the fibrous plies at the positions defined by the needle spacing in the needle bed (spacing in the cross-direction, A) and by the speed of the material feeding in the knitting device (spacing in the machine direction, B). Normally B < A. The value of A is also expressed by the machine gauge, which is the number of needles per inch. In the warp-knitted fabric without fibrous plies, the yarn tension during knitting leads to significant deviations of the actual spacing of loops in the relaxed fabric from these values. In the case of multiaxial multi-ply fabrics, the stitching yarn is fixed by the fibrous plies, and the loop spacing is fairly regular. Figure 4.3 gives an example of the variability of these parameters in a fabric. Deviations of the positions of the stitching lead also to deviation of the loops from the ideal machine direction orientation. The inclination of the loops relative to the machine direction can be as high as 15°.
4.3 Actual spacing of the stitching loops. Carbon fabric 0/−45/90/45: (a) definition of A and B; (b) values of A and B for adjacent wales; (c) actual positions of the stitching sites (the grid is A x B).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
90
Non-crimp fabric composites
4.3.3 Geometry of the stitching loop To describe the loop geometry one can select between a pure geometrical approach, in which certain assumptions about the shape of the loop are introduced, or a mechanical approach, in which the shape of the loop is computed based on equations of equilibrium for the curved yarns forming the loop. The latter, much more sophisticated treatment, is felt to be unnecessary in our case, as the positions of the loops are fixed by the stitching going through the mat, and experimentally observed uncertainties of the loop shape are too large to justify refinements offered by a mechanical treatment of the problem. Hence, the geometrical approach is adopted here. The stitching yarn (polyester, polyamide, aramid, etc.) has normally low linear density (ca 10 tex, number of filaments ca 15) and low twist (<100 1/m). Hence it is easily compressible, which explains large variations in its dimensions. Three characteristic states of the yarn in the loop are considered: 1. Free: diameter of the circular cross-section dinit. The value of dinit is measured on the relaxed stitching yarn (off the bobbin) and represents the packing of its fibres before any interaction with the knitting device. 2. Compacted: diameter of the circular cross-section. [4.1] where T is the linear density of the yarn, ρ is the density of the fibres and K is the packing coefficient. Experimentally observed values of K lie in the range 0.8–0.9. The value of d0 represents the ultimate compacted state of the yarn of the yarn and does not depend on dinit. 3. Extreme flattened: dimensions of the cross-section d1min and d2max. These values are measured in a compression test of the stitching yarn. Figure 4.4b provides typical values of these dimensions. The values dinit, d0, d1min, d2max characterise the relaxed state and the compression behaviour of the stitching yarn (measured on the standard textile equipment). They are not specific to the fabric architecture. Figure 4.4 shows regions of these characteristic states along the yarn in the loop. The dimensions of the yarn crosssections in the straight parts of the yarn are kept constant; circular arcs connecting the straight parts introduce a linear transition from one dimension of the cross-sections to another. The model depicted in Fig. 4.4a introduces several assumptions for the yarn dimensions. Most of them, e.g., the maximum flattened state of the yarn on the surface of the fabric, are supported by experimental observations. The dinit value for the yarn knee (place difficult to observe in a real material) is stated to ensure a smooth transition between flattened horizontal and compacted vertical parts of the yarn. The geometry of the centre line of the yarn is defined by identifying a set of ‘anchor points’ A–M (Fig. 4.5) along the loop, and approximating the loop centre
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
91
4.4 Dimensions of the stitching yarn: (a) scheme; (b) compression diagram and typical yarn dimensions; (c) typical configuration in the head of the loop; (d) spread yarn on the face of the fabric, seen from the top, (e) same, in the gap between two layers in a composite. Examples: polyester stitching yarn 6 tex.
4.5 Shape of the stitching loops. Schemes of positions of anchor points and examples of loops produced under average (left) and high (right) knitting tension.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
92
Non-crimp fabric composites
line between the anchor points by straight lines or circular arcs. Positions of the anchor points on the centre line of the yarn are shown in Fig. 4.5, where h is the total thickness of the plies (accounting for possible sinking of the stitching, see below), and all the arcs of the centre line (AB, CD, EF, GH, IJ and KL) are circular arcs with the diameter d0. The width of the loop w depends on the knitting tension. Considerable tension produces longish loops with w = 3d0; lesser tension increases w to (4 . . . 5)d0.
4.4
Distortions of fibres in the plies
4.4.1 Classification of the distortions The stitching causes distortions of the fibre orientations in the fibrous mat. These distortions can be localised near the stitching sites, or collate into a linear channel Fig. 4.6. Different authors use different terminology to designate these distortions: ‘cracks’ and ‘channels’ (Lomov et al., 2002), ‘SYD, yarn-induced fibre distortion’ (Loendersloot et al., 2006), ‘fish eyes’ (Lekakou et al., 2004; Schneider et al., 2004), ‘openings’ (Truong Chi et al., 2008). In this book the term ‘fibre distortion’ will be used, with the term ‘openings’ applied to the localised distortion and ‘channels’ for long separations of the fibrous plies. When the preform is being impregnated, the distortions provide routes for the resin flow. In a consolidated composite they create resin-rich zones, which may play an important role in initiation of damage. A localised distortion has a rhomboidal shape, with width b and length l (Fig. 4.7). A channel is formed if localised distortions touch or overlap each other, and is more common for 0°/90° fabrics. Because the placement of the stitching sites has different spacing in the length and the width direction (B
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
93
4.6 Examples of fibre distortions, face (left) and back (right) of carbon non-crimp fabric: (a) 0°/−45°/90°/+45°, channels on the face and openings on the back; (b) +45°/−45°, openings on both sides; (c) 0°/90°, openings on the face and channels on the back; (d) 0°/90°, openings on both sides. All the fabrics produced on machine gauge 5, different producers.
back plies creates a system of fibre bundles inside the fabric, held together by the stitching and separated by these straight channels. Dimensions of these fibre bundles are defined by the knitting parameters A and B. They are sometimes referred to as ‘tows’, which should not be mistaken as the tows used in the fabric production.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
94
Non-crimp fabric composites
4.7 Definition of the dimensions of an opening.
4.8 Openings and channels inside a composite plate. Carbon noncrimp fabric 0°/−45°/90°/45° (as in Figure 4.6a). Lines show average dimensions of the cracks/channels observed from the surface and width 2d0 for the inner layers. (a) A section in the machine direction, opening in the −45° inner ply; (b) a section in the cross-direction, channel in the 0° face ply and an opening in the −45° inner ply; (c) a section in the cross-direction, channels in the 45° back ply, 0° face ply and an opening in the −45° inner ply; (d) gaps between layers of the non-crimp fabric in a laminate.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
95
4.4.2 Dimensions of the distortions It can be expected that the width of fibre distortions is proportional to the thickness of the stitching yarn. Choosing the compacted diameter d0 as a representative parameter (see Eq. [4.1]), one can introduce empirical coefficients k = b/d0 to calculate width b = kd0. Table 4.1 shows results of the measurements of dimensions of the openings/channels in various fabrics. The length of the openings is related to the width by a coefficient λ = l/b. The variation of the values of k is quite large. It seems that the fibres in a powdered fabric are more difficult to push away by the stitching, which explains low values of k and λ for this fabric. In non-powdered fabrics, channels tend to be wider than cracks, with averages for k of about 4 (openings) and about 6 (channels), and λ for openings of about 21. The dimensions of the openings/ channels are also influenced by knitting tension. For a given fabric the distribution of the dimensions of the distortions can be quite wide (Fig. 4.9). The values in Table 4.1 refer to the dimensions of the fibre distortions on the back and face of the fabric, which is easier to measure than dimensions of the distortions in the inner plies of three- or four-axial NCF. Figure 4.8 shows that for the inner plies the opening width can be taken approximately as bin = 2d0. This estimation corresponds also to the detailed measurements of the distribution of the width of the distortions in the plies of structurally stitched NCF (Hess et al., 2007). After consolidation of a composite plate/part, dimensions of the fibre distortions can somehow change. The measurements in (Koissin et al., 2009) show the following changes after composite consolidation: the width of the openings in +45°/−45° carbon NCF has changed from 0.50 ± 0.09 mm in the dry fabric to 0.43 ± 0.08 mm after consolidation, and the length of the openings from 9.3 ± 3.5 mm to 4.1 ± 0.9 mm after consolidation.
4.9 Distribution of width of the fibre distortions in 0°/−45°/90°/45° carbon non-crimp fabric (same as in Figure 4.6a): (a) face, channels, (b) back, openings.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Lomov et al., 2002
Loendersloot et al., 2006
Loendersloot et al., 2006
Koissin et al., 2009
Koissin et al., 2009
0°/−45°/90°/45°, 12K
0°/90°, 24K
45°/−45°, 12K
0°/90°, 12K
−45°/−45°, 12K
PA = polyamide; PES = polyester
0°/90°, 12K, powdered n/a
Lomov et al., 2002
Reference
−45°/−45°, 12K
Fabric construction and tows used in production
PA, 10 tex
PES, 7.4 tex
PES, 7.4 tex
PES, 6 tex
PES, 7.6 tex
PES, 7.6 tex
PES, 7.6 tex
Material, linear density
0.107
0.087
0.087
0.071
0.088
0.088
0.088
d0, mm
Stitching
Face openings Back openings Face channels Back openings Face channels Back channels Face openings Back openings Face openings Back openings Face openings Back openings Face channels Back openings
Opening/channel
Table 4.1 Dimensions of fibre distortions in different non-crimp fabrics, average values
0.276 0.434 0.658 0.483 0.62 0.36 0.28 0.27 0.33 0.26 0.50 0.49 0.18 0.53
b, mm
5.05 7.15 n/a 7.28 n/a n/a 7.43 7.85 7.3 3.4 9.3 9.2 n/a 3.46
l, mm
3.13 5.39 7.47 5.48 7.04 4.09 3.94 3.80 3.79 2.98 5.74 5.73 1.68 4.95
k = b/d0
18.3 16.5 n/a 15.0 n/a n/a 26.5 29.1 22.1 13.0 18.8 18.7 n/a 6.53
λ = l/b
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
97
4.4.3 Gaps between the non-crimp fabric (NCF) layers in a laminate The stitching loops, lying on the surface of NCF, can create gaps between layers on NCF in a laminate. Such a gap is shown in Fig 4.4e. These gaps do not necessarily have a constant thickness, but may be concentrated near the stitching sites Fig. 4.8d. When a large channel is formed, which goes in the machine direction (direction of the production of the fabric, parallel to the stitching loops), a stitching yarn section on the face or a loop on the back of the fabric can sink inside this channel (as is the case in Fig. 4.6a). This so-called ‘nesting’ behaviour is less pronounced in NCF laminates than in woven or braided fabric laminates, which translates to less variability of the laminate structure. However, this phenomenon also exists for NCF laminates: in the presence of this sinking the layers can come closer, closing gaps between layers introduced by the stitching yarn laying on the surface of the fabric (Lomov et al., 2002).
4.4.4 Fibre volume in fraction in the plies and deviations of the fibre directions Overall fibre volume fraction in a composite is estimated using the formula: [4.2] where m is the areal density of all the layers of the fabric, h is the thickness of the composite, ρ is the fibre density. The value of the thickness in this formula includes the thickness of the stitching yarn on each surface of the fabric (d1min). An average fibre volume fraction in the plies is estimated as [4.3] where ms is the areal density of the stitching. Finally, the stitching pulls fibres in the plies aside, increasing the local fibre volume fraction, which is evaluated with the formula [4.4] where Svoid is the area of a crack or a channel per one knitting needle: [4.5] where the length of the channel l within the rectangle between the neighbouring needles is
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
98
Non-crimp fabric composites
[4.6] For example, for a quadriaxial carbon fabric the following values have been found: Vf = 60%, Vfpl.ave = 64%, Vfpl.loc = 66 . . . 74% (this is different in the inner and outer plies due to the difference in the size of the channels/opening). The fibres around the openings deviate from their ideal positions in the plies. The deviation can be described with a linear (Truong Chi et al., 2008) or a cosine (Hess et al., 2007) function, which aligns the fibre direction with the direction of the opening boundaries close to it, and returns the fibre direction to the ideal direction in the ply far from the opening.
4.5
Change of the geometry after shear
When NCF is sheared during the forming of a 3D preform, the distances between the stitching sites and dimensions of the fibre distortions change. This change affects the permeability of the preform and positions and dimensions of resin-rich zones in the composite. The change of biaxial NCF geometry after shearing was studied by (Loendersloot et al., 2006) and used for modelling of mechanical properties of NCF composites in (Truong Chi et al., 2008). Shearing changes the fibre orientation, areal density and thickness of the fabric, and hence the fibre volume fraction of the composites. The shear deformation is shown in Fig. 4.10a. The ply angle α, representing fibre direction in the sheared fabrics, can be computed based on the initial ply angle α0 and shear angle γ using the formula
α = α0 − γ/2.
[4.7]
The average fibre volume fraction of the composite plates made from the sheared fabrics Vf(shear) can be predicted based on that of the same thickness plates made from non-sheared fabrics Vf(no_shear) by applying a formula: Vf(shear) = Vf(no_shear)/cosγ.
[4.8]
During shear the stitching sites retain the rectangular configuration but come closer, changing according to the formula: [4.9] When the fabric is sheared, the distortions in the fibrous plies change their dimensions, staying aligned with the direction of the fibres (which is changed as a result of the shear deformation of the fabric). Measurements in (Loendersloot et al., 2006) for three different carbon NCFs suggest the following scenario of the change in the dimensions of the distortions.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
99
4.10 Change of geometry of biaxial non-crimp fabric fabric after shear: (a) a scheme of shear deformation; (b) non-dimensional width of the openings k = w/d0 in a carbon +45°/−45° non-crimp fabric, face (kf) and back (kb) of the fabric, for different shear angle γ; (c) distribution of non-dimensional width of the openings in a carbon +45°/−45° NCF, before shear and (d) after shear with γ = 30°.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
100
Non-crimp fabric composites
For low shear angles, below 30°, the width of the distortions decreases as the result of in-plane compression of the ply, associated with the shear deformation. The non-dimensional width k = w/d0 decreases to the value of about kmin≈2, which also corresponds to the non-dimensional width of the openings in the inner, constrained plies of four-ply NCF (as mentioned in section 4.4.2). For the higher shear angles, the width of the opening does not change. Subsequent shear deformation results in lateral compaction of the fibrous plies rather than narrowing of the openings. The value of kmin≈2 can be explained by the fact that there are two stitching yarns, each with a diameter not smaller than d0, which go through the opening, and have to be accommodated within the width w = kmind0. This behaviour is illustrated in Fig. 4.10b, which shows a typical result of measurements of change of the opening width in a biaxual +45°/−45° NCF. The distribution of the width of the openings changes from symmetric (close to normal) in non-sheared fabric to asymmetric (close to log-normal), with more openings of smaller width in the sheared fabric (Fig. 4.10c). The length of the openings does not change significantly after shearing.
4.6
A geometrical model of NCF
The geometrical description of NCF described in this chapter is implemented as a module of the textile simulation software WiseTex (Lomov et al., 2002; Verpoest et al., 2005) (Fig. 4.11). The input data for the model comes from the manufacturer’s specification of NCF, fibre volume fraction of the preform, measured or estimated dimensions of cross-sections of the stitching yarn and parameters of the fibre distortions, measured on the composite or estimated by approximate values given above: k≈4 (openings) or 6 (channels), λ≈21. The model also allows compression and shear of the fabric. The same geometry described in this chapter can be easily transferred to models of the permeability of NCF (Chapter 10) and finite element models (Chapters 16–19).
4.7
Conclusion
An NCF composite can be considered as a cross-ply UD laminate with the ideal UD placement of the fibres in the plies distorted by the stitching. The internal geometry, described in detail in this chapter, defines the features of processing behaviour and performance of NCFs and their composites, and the advantages and limitations of their applications, which will be discussed in detail in the subsequent chapters of the book.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding and modelling the effect of stitching
101
4.11 Geometrical model of non-crimp fabric in WiseTex software: input data and 3D visualisation of the fabric.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
102
Non-crimp fabric composites
4.8
References
Hess, H., Y. C. Roth and N. Himmel (2007). Elastic constants estimation of stitched NCF CFRP laminates based on a finite element unit-cell model. Composites Science and Technology 67: 1081–1085. Koissin, V., J. Kustermans, S. V. Lomov, I. Verpoest, B. Van Den Broucke and V. Witzel (2009). Structurally stitched NCF preforms: quasi-static response. Composites Science and Technology 69 (15–16): 2701–2710. Lekakou, C., S. Edwards, G. Bell and S. Amico (2004). Computer modeling for the prediction of the in-plane permeability of non-crimp stitch bonded fabrics. Flow Modelling in Composite Materials (FPCM-4), Newark, Delaware. Loendersloot, R., S. V. Lomov, R. Akkerman and I. Verpoest (2006). Carbon composites based on multiaxial multiply stitched preforms. Part 5: Geometry of sheared biaxial fabrics. Composites Part A 37: 103–113. Lomov, S. V., E. B. Belov, T. Bischoff, S. B. Ghosh, T. Truong Chi and I. Verpoest (2002). Carbon composites based on multiaxial multiply stitched preforms. Part 1: Geometry of the preform. Composites Part A 33(9): 1171–1183. Lomov, S. V., I. Verpoest, T. Peeters, D. Roose and M. Zako (2002). Nesting in textile laminates: Geometrical modelling of the laminate. Composites Science and Technology 63(7): 993–1007. Schneider, M., K. Edelmann and U. Tiltmann (2004). Quality analysis of reinforcement structure for composites by digital image processing. Proceedings of the 25th International SAMPE-Europe Conference. Paris, France: 267–272. Spencer, D. J. ed. (1997). Knitting Technology. Cambridge, Woodhead Publishing. Truong Chi, T., D. S. Ivanov, D. V. Klimshin, S. V. Lomov and I. Verpoest (2008). Carbon composites based on multiaxial multiply stitched preforms. Part 7: Mechanical properties and damage observations in composite with sheared reinforcement. Composites Part A 39: 1380–1393. Verpoest, I. and S. V. Lomov (2005). Virtual textile composites software WiseTex: integration with micro-mechanical, permeability and structural analysis. Composites Science and Technology 65(15–16): 2563–2574.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
5 Automated analysis of defects in non-crimp fabrics for composites M. SCHNEIDER, Toho Tenax Europe GmbH, Germany
Abstract: In order to judge the textile quality of non-crimp fabric (NCF), a discontinuous laboratory testing method is developed, which is based on a digital image processing system. A flatbed scanner with an additional transmitted light device is used for the digital image acquisition of flat fabric reinforcement. In principle, the pixels of a digital image are similar to a map of numbers, which in this case range from 0 (i.e. black pixel) to 255 (i.e. white pixel). The user selects geometrical dimensions to be measured and the software analyses all pixels according to this selection. According to Airbus Industrie Material Specifications (AIMS), standard testing routines are developed in order to quantify the following parameters: regularity of knitting structure (distance between all adjacent knitting points), fish eye measurement in the layers, gap quantification, reinforcement fibre orientation and abrasion particles. Key words: carbon fibres, textile, non-crimp fabric, effect of defects, digital image processing, quality inspection, pixel.
5.1
Motivation
Textile reinforcements show a potential to decrease the overall production costs of composites. General process optimisation of standard textile machinery, which has been worked out since many decades for mass-production of standard textiles provides a very useful basis for composite production. These improved efficiencies and process robustness have to be transferred to the processing of highperformance materials, such as glass and carbon fibres. Moreover, new techniques, such as non-crimp fabric (NCF) production, are created, based on conventional knitting in combination with multiaxial placement of reinforcement fibres. But it is not only inexpensive production methods for reinforcement textiles that are required; moreover, high-quality textiles are needed. The mechanical performance of composites reinforced with textiles is not only determined by the type of textile and fibre as well as the resin to be used, but is also affected by the textile quality. In particular, the accuracy of the reinforcement fibre alignment affects the fibre-dependent properties of the final carbon fibre-reinforced polymer (CFRP). This fibre orientation is determined in the manufacturing method of the textile, but can also be modified during the manufacturing process and the post-processing (e.g. handling of the material). On the one hand, all defects within the textiles (gaps, misaligned fibres, etc.) lead directly to a drop in mechanical 103 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
104
Non-crimp fabric composites
performance. All volumes which are not homogeneously covered by filaments will be filled by resin in the final component and thus provide resin-rich area with limited performance. On the other hand, the reinforcement fibre must be straight in the textiles. Carbon fibres only show excellent mechanical performance when all filaments perfectly follow the load paths. Any yarn undulations created, for instance, by textile patterning or harmful post-processing result in reduced performance. Besides the defect localisation in the material, the aerospace industry demands a total documentation of the material quality. It is an important task of the supplier to document and guarantee material properties to a given specification. In order to minimise this effort, any automatic system is welcomed. Therefore, it is important to characterise, and if necessary to optimise, the quality of textiles as soon as possible in the production process in order to meet high mechanical requirements. The quality (e.g. homogeneity and orientation of the reinforcement fibres, gaps between the fibres, etc.) of textile structures has to be judged either directly online during the production, by e.g. visual inspection, or indirectly with mechanical testing and quality control procedures on the final laminate composite. These latter procedures are time-consuming, expensive and generally unsuitable as techniques to improve production processes or material performance. This chapter describes the principal development of a tool to detect automatically and document fabric anomalies as described in typical fabric material specifications. The primary focus is on biaxial NCF, because these materials are standard in current Airbus material specifications.
5.2
Quality characteristics of non-crimp fabric (NCF)
Defects of NCF may occur in both production (i.e. placement of the reinforcement fibres or knitting of the total system) and subsequent manufacturing of the CFRP components (see Chapters 1 and 2). Any post-processing of NCF may produce additional effects which reduce the mechanical performance. Airbus Industrie Material Specifications (AIMS) define and quantify several defects of NCF, for example: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
crease or wrinkle (break or line, usually caused by a sharp fold, Fig. 5.1); cut or tear (adjacent yarns are cut or broken, Fig. 5.1); yarn splice (broken or severed yarn, which is rejoined); fuzz ball (accumulation of loose or frayed fibres within the fabric or on the surface, Fig. 5.2); gap (open space between parallel fibres or even between filaments, Fig. 5.2); missing knitting loop (partly missing knitting row, Fig. 5.2); incorrect fibre orientation (fibre, which is not aligned or not along given orientation, Fig. 5.2); and missing reinforcement yarn (totally missing reinforcement fibre).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Automated analysis of defects in non-crimp fabrics
105
5.1 Non-crimp fabric with exemplary defects (defects 1, 2).
5.2 Non-crimp fabric with exemplary defects (defects 4, 5, 6, 7).
Yarn splices (defect 3) cannot be illustrated since carbon fibres to be used for NCF are usually not spliced. Missing reinforcement yarns (defect 8) are almost impossible in NCF due to fibre detectors which stop the production when fibres are broken. Nevertheless, gaps between reinforcement fibres are sometimes regarded as missing
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
106
Non-crimp fabric composites
fibres, although the fibres are only pushed away/together. Figure 5.2 shows additional parameters which give further indices of the NCF quality: A. angle between knitting yarn and carbon fibre and B. distance between knitting points. In order to limit the effects of these defects, the maximum number of their occurrences is regulated in material specification. Materials are usually checked by means of a visual inspection upon shipping by the material supplier and upon receipt by the customer. At the moment, automated tools of inspection to detect and quantify the number of defects are not available.
5.3
Quality analysis of NCF by digital image analysis
5.3.1 System The system consists of a flatbed scanner with an additional transmitted light device, a state-of-the-art powerful personal computer with an enlarged main memory and a standard digital imaging software package. Based on this equipment, a custom-made routine is developed in order to analyse and quantify the textile quality of NCF. The final efficiency of the systems is a result of the computer performance, calculation algorithms and image resolution. Since a general method for quality monitoring (QM) based on digital image processing is addressed and only a laboratory offline system is created, the analysis time is not that important. An overall analysis time of several minutes is realised at the moment. If the system is transferred to an online method and placed directly into an NCF machine, the efficiency has to be improved. In any case, reduced resolution of the scanned pictures decreases the analysis time dramatically. High-resolution flatbed scanners are capable of acquiring a digital picture of any flat textile; the transmitted light device in particular delivers further insights. Other reasons to choose a scanner instead of a microscope or a digital camera with additional illumination are the easily adjustable and reproducible light and scanning conditions. Any light reflections or optical phenomena are almost excluded by the linear movements of the illumination and scanning device. In order to find a compromise between all conflicting aspects, i.e. file size and processing speed as well as sampling size and resolution, a picture 10 cm by 10 cm is scanned with a resolution of 720 dpi. These parameters produce a manageable file with a size of around 8 MB which is finally saved in a grey value 8-bit TIF format. In principle, the pixels of a digital image are similar to a map of numbers, which in this case range from 0 (i.e. black pixels) to 255 (i.e. white pixels).
5.3.2 Working principle Figure 5.3 presents a scanned picture of the important elements of NCF in detail to explain the working principle. One may see two loops of the knitting yarn in the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Automated analysis of defects in non-crimp fabrics
107
5.3 Detailed picture of non-crimp fabric. (Please note that the abovementioned scanning conditions are not kept.)
vertical direction and the carbon fibres under an angle of 45°. In the centre of the picture a so-called fish eye results from the penetration of a knitting yarn. Two disadvantages stem from fish eyes: the carbon fibres are no longer straight and the open volumes of the fish eyes will end up in the final laminate as unreinforced resin-rich areas. Fish eyes and wider gaps, which may extend over several knitting points or even over the total width of an NCF, are discontinuities in the laminate and may cause final failure of the laminate and, therefore, are important to analyse. The flexibility of the reinforcement fibre, the tension of the knitting yarn and the needle size, as well as the movement of the needle during the needle penetration in the moving NCF, influence the size of the gap eyes. Gap eyes are also responsible for the out-of-plane permeability of NCF (among others). It is worth correlating gap eye properties with impregnation properties (see Chapter 8). In Fig. 5.4 a graph is plotted of the grey values that generated the picture of the NCF in Fig. 5.3. The peak of the gradient is given by the majority of grey pixels coming from the wide area covered with carbon fibres. By means of the digital image software, all pixels in two user-defined ranges can be selected: In range 1, with a threshold from 0 to 29, all dark pixels are chosen. These pixels present fish eyes, but also gaps between the carbon fibres or even between single filaments. In range 2, all light pixels (threshold 174 to 255) build the knitting yarns. If these two ranges are applied to the pixels of Fig. 5.3, the interesting items of NCF are selected and highlighted (and marked in colour in the original software) (Fig. 5.5, light areas = range 1, dark areas = range 2). In the next step the digital software measures, based on implemented standard routines, selected geometrical
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
108
Non-crimp fabric composites
5.4 Graph of the grey value distribution.
5.5 Detailed picture of a non-crimp fabric with selected pixels and geometrical dimensions.
dimensions on all particles, which are built from connected pixels of the same range. The following dimensions of NCF are measured in detail. • • •
Orientation, width and area of fish eyes and gaps (between single filaments as well as between whole carbon yarns). Width of knitting loops (i.e. knitting errors). Orientation and curvature of knitting yarns.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Automated analysis of defects in non-crimp fabrics
109
These data are automatically displayed in tabular form and the measurements of all individual fish eyes, gaps, knitting yarns, etc., are collected and analysed statistically. By combining certain results further information is gathered. For example, the orientation of carbon fibres is calculated from the orientation of all small filament gaps as well as from the fish eye directions. The difference between the orientation of the knitting yarns and the carbon fibres indicates the accuracy of the production process.
5.3.3 Results In Fig. 5.6 the described working principle is applied to a 10 cm by 10 cm scan of NCF. One may easily see that the wide gap between the carbon fibres is detected (light area) as well as small fish eyes at all knitting points. Additionally, the knitting yarns are found and marked in a dark colour. A knitting error (detailed picture in Fig. 5.6) increases the measured width of the knitting row and thus will be detected. A short summary of the final results is shown in Table 5.1, which compares three different NCFs: NCF 1 in standard quality, NCF 2 with a wide gap over the whole NCF width, shown in Fig. 5.6, and NCF 3 with a strong curvature in the knitting rows (Fig. 5.7). For example, the gap in NCF 2 is detected via 14 particles as gap 2 (width >2 mm). The maximum width of these particles is 3.5 mm (light shaded area in Table 5.1). The knitting error in NCF 2 produces a maximum width of 3.2 mm in the local width of the knitting row (light shaded area in Table 5.1) compared to a standard level of 1.0 mm (dark shaded area in Table 5.1). Also, the curvature of the knitting rows in NCF 3 increases the width of the total knitting row to a value of 6.5 mm (standard mean value 1.4 mm).
5.6 Non-crimp fabric 2 with gap and knitting errors.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Mean value Maximum Number of detected part Mean value Maximum Number of detected part Mean value Maximum
Number of detected part
NCF = non-crimp fabric
NCF 3 – curvature in knitting yarns
NCF 2 – gap and knitting error
NCF 1 – standard configuration
Area
0.0 0.4
0.0 0.3
0.0 0.3
Width 0.1 0.1
2899
0.1 0.1
1775
0.1 0.1
3659
Orientation 30.7
149.0
12.9
Area 0.4 3.4
1.4 3.3
0.4 1.7
Width 0.2 0.7
2139
0.5 0.7
1757
0.2 0.4
1894
37.4
163.4
14.1
Area 15.7 18.4
Width 0
2.9 3.5
14
0
27.3
Orientation
Gap (width >2 mm)
Knitting parameter
136.0
47.2
135.7
Orientation
Fish eyes
3.1 6.5
27
1.5 3.3
37
1.4 1.7
25
Curvature of knitting rows
Filament gaps
Orientation
Table 5.1 Summary of final results of three different non-crimp fabrics analysed by digital image processing
0.8 1.0
0.9 3.2
0.9 1.0
Local width of knitting row
44.5
47.2
47.8
Carbon fibre orientation vs. knitting yarn orientation
Automated analysis of defects in non-crimp fabrics
111
5.7 Non-crimp fabric 3 with curvature in knitting rows.
The system is used at the moment in daily work to improve carbon fibres for their processing properties in NCF, to judge the NCF qualities from different origins and to document NCF within material specifications. All data are collected in an internal database, but they cannot be published. The current drawbacks of the described principles are that only visible layers may be scanned. The separation of multilayer NCF via melting the knitting thread may provide an interim solution. However, until now the system works only offline on a laboratory scale. In order to solve these drawbacks, it must be a main focus of future developments to install the system directly onto the NCF production machine and collect the digital pictures of individual layers online.
5.4
Future trends
In addition to the NCF discussed in this chapter, this technology can also be used on a number of other flat, semi-finished products employed to manufacture highperformance CFRP components. These semi-finished products include fabrics
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
112
Non-crimp fabric composites
(used in various resin transfer mould [RTM] processes) and prepregs (usually processed in autoclaves). An example of a digitally processed image of a woven fabric is depicted in Fig. 5.8, where light reflections on the warp yarns are used to measure the yarn width behind every single weaving point. The numbers in Fig. 5.8 are the actual yarn widths in millimetres. Based on these figures, the yarn width variation may easily be determined. These details may help to localise process problems or select inhomogeneously spreading fibres.
5.8 Yarn width (in mm) of warp yarns in a woven fabric.
A further measurement of woven fabrics is shown in Fig. 5.9. By means of the transmitted light device a transparent projection is created. The small light marks in Fig. 5.9 result from fibre-uncovered areas in the immediate area of weaving points. If one subtracts the area of the detected marks from the total area of the analysed woven fabric, the area coverage is determined (e.g. 93.2% area coverage for the fabric in Fig. 5.9). This information also reflects the out-of-plane permeability of the fabric. Of course, other measurements based on the light marks are possible: yarn orientation in both horizontal and vertical directions, etc.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Automated analysis of defects in non-crimp fabrics
113
5.9 Area coverage of woven fabric via transmitted light device.
In the case of prepregs, especially when laid on curved surfaces, so-called blisters may occur. Blisters are small areas lifting on the surface and appearing predominately as the prepreg is laid flat or draped on 3D surfaces. With the tool developed the amount of blistering can be characterised for different materials. The blistering varies both in the shape and number of blisters for different materials (Fig. 5.10, left and middle). An example of blisters detected by the software is shown in the right picture of Fig. 5.10.
5.10 Blisters on different prepreg materials.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
114
Non-crimp fabric composites
The procedure described above will allow automated inspection according to product specification of semi-finished products by both the supplier and user. Compared to the currently employed inspection methods, this will result in a significant reduction of cost and effort. Additionally, the developed tool can also be used for an in situ online quality monitoring tool. If this tool is integrated in the process control, process parameters may automatically be changed during the production cycle. Furthermore, quantified textile quality parameters will enable a reproducible comparison of the mechanical performance of such materials containing textiles with different defects. The effect of these defects will be correlated with the mechanical performance of these materials (see Chapter 3). Once the effects of certain fabric defects are known, the need to perform additional mechanical testing with fabrics can be eliminated. This will save the yarn and fabric manufacturer time and effort during the development process. Additionally, influences of noticed defects could be estimated at the shop-floor level. Any postprocessing of NCF to component reinforcements needs clear guidelines of tolerable, minor changes of NCF.
5.5
References
v. Diest, K., Entwicklung einer Bilderkennungssoftware zur Bestimmung der Faserorientierung von GMT-Bauteilen. IVW-Bericht 93–57. Fischer, G., Quantitative Ermittlung der Orientierung von Kurzglasfasern mit der Bildanalyse. Kunststoffe (1987) 77 (5): 509–512. Huber U., Maier, M., Optische Bestimmung der Faserorientierung in Verbundwerkstoffen. Nachr Chem Tech Lab (1997), 45: 134–136. Michaeli W., Heber M., Easy and quick method for the measurement of fibre orientation. ANTEC (1994), 1790–1793. Yaguchi H., Hojo H., Lee D.G., Kim E.G., Measurement of planar orientation of fibers for reinforced thermoplastics using image processing. International Polymer Processing (1995) 10 (3): 262–269.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
6 Deformability of textile preforms in the manufacture of non-crimp fabric composites S. V. LOMOV, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
Abstract: Deformability of multiaxial multi-ply stitched preforms is studied in biaxial tension, shearing and compression. Biaxial tension tests reveal a strong interrelation between the two directions of tension in the case of tension in bias direction. The picture frame test is combined with full-field optical measurements of the shear strain, allowing true registration of the fabric shear angle. The difference between the shear behaviour in different directions relative to the stitching is shown. Thickness is measured for one of the sheared fabrics. Compression tests reveal a high compressibility of the preforms and a limited nesting effect in laminates. Key words: deformability, biaxial tension, shear, compression.
6.1
Introduction
Deformability of textile preforms plays a key role in the quality of a composite part formed into a three-dimensional (3D) shape. The deformation modes of primary importance are in-plain deformation (tension and shear) and compression of the preform. Resistance of dry preform to bending also plays a role in composite forming. This chapter, largely based on papers (Lomov et al., 2003a; 2005) with the addition of results of more recent research, describes resistance to these types of deformations of a set of typical non-crimp fabrics (NCF) (internal geometry of the same fabrics is described in Chapter 4). The most important deformation mode of a preform in forming is shear. Shear resistance of NCF is the subject of a number of publications (Long et al., 2002; Harrison et al., 2003; Yu et al., 2004; 2005; Lee et al., 2007). An important feature of NCF shear behaviour is the difference of shear resistance for different directions of the test vis-à-vis the stitching. The picture frame test, which is the main instrument of the published studies of shear resistance of NCF, is, as has been recently revealed by the international benchmarking round-robin exercise (Cao et al., 2008), a difficult test to standardise and interpret the results. In the study reported in this chapter, the picture frame test is accompanied by optical measurements of the strain field on the surface of the fabric (Lomov et al., 2008), which allows correct interpretation of the test results. The bias extension test, which is widely used for measurement of shear resistance of woven fabrics, is not applied to NCF because of asymmetry of the fabric 117 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
118
Non-crimp fabric composites
deformation introduced by the stitching, which makes interpretation of the results of bias extension difficult. There are no publications on biaxial tension of NCF, apart from a qualitative discussion in (Hoersting, 1998). The tensile behaviour of a preform can seriously influence its drapability, as a tension may be introduced in the actual forming process by use of a blankholder. Apart from a quantitative characterisation of the preform behaviour, the biaxial tensile test must answer two qualitative questions, which are discussed in this chapter. •
•
When tested in the direction of fibres, how large is the initial non-linear region of the stress–strain diagram, caused by crimp of the fibres? The lesser this region, the more close to reality will be the assumption of linearity of the preform resistance (which would be advantageous to use to make the draping simulation less computationally demanding). Do tension deformations in two directions affect one another (as it is the case for woven fabrics)? If yes, then the independent description of the fabric tensile resistance in two directions, adopted in some draping codes, does not describe the real behaviour and the material models should be made more complex.
The compression behaviour of glass NCF is covered in the series of papers (Robitaille and Gauvin, 1998a; 1998b; 1999); carbon NCFs are studied in Endruweit (2003), Chen et al., (2001) and Hammani (2000). Knowledge of the compression diagrams is necessary to calculate the thickness of a preform in vacuum-assisted resin infusion (VARI) and similar processes, where it is not defined by the distance between rigid parts of the mould, but by the pressure involved in the process, acting on the flexible part of the mould. It is also interesting to observe and assess the degree of nesting in a NCF laminate (a model of the nesting is presented in (Lomov et al., 2002)). Apart from this, the compression behaviour determines normal forces acting on a preform during forming, hence friction between the preform and the tool and between the preform layers, which strongly affects preform formability. In an actual compositeforming process, a preform is under simultaneous action of compression and shear. This chapter reports the results of such a test. The work reported in this chapter was done in the Department of Metallurgy and Material Engineering (MTM), Katholieke Universiteit (KU) Leuven, Belgium, and in the Department of Mechanical Engineering, Universiteit Twente. Four fabrics are studied in this Chapter (Fig. 6.1). Their parameters are shown in Table 6.1. The terminology used for description of the defects in the fibrous layers, induced by the stitching, is explained in Chapter 4. Table 6.2 summarises the tests done for all the fabrics.
6.2
Shear
Only the biaxial fabrics (B1, B2 and B3) were tested in the picture frame test, as for a quadriaxial fabric the test is impossible because of tension applied to the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Quadriaxial 4 carbon fabric
Q
2
0;−45;90; +45
+45;−45
0;90
2
Bidiagonal carbon fabric
B2
B3
+45;−45
Bidiagonal carbon fabric with glass stabilising yarns Biaxial carbon fabric
B1
2
629±31
541±12
329±14
322±16
Tricotchain
Chain
Tricotchain
Tricot
5
5
5
5
24K Toray T700 50E 12K Tenax HTS 5631 12K Toray T700 50E
Stitching
PES 7.6 tex
156± 8
5.09 2.58 6
PES 5.79 2.22 5 5 tex
260
Channel 0.66
Opening 0.28
Opening 0.18
5.03 2.64 6
PES 7.6 tex
Back
n/a
7.7
4.2
5.05
Opening 0.48
Opening 0.29
Channel 0.40
7.28
8.0
n/a
7.15
Width, Length, mm mm Opening 0.43
Width, Length, Type mm mm
Opening 0.28
Mass, Face g/sq Type m
Defect in fibrous plies
4.94 1.71 3
B, mm
150± 8
PES 7.6 tex
Mass, Yarn A, g/sq mm m
12K 156± Toray 8 T700 50E
Preform Description Number Orientation Mass of Stitching Gauge Plies ID of plies of plies, the pattern (needles degrees fabric, per inch) Tow g/sq m
Table 6.1 Parameters of non-crimp fabric
120
Non-crimp fabric composites
6.1 Samples of non-crimp fabric, face (left) and back (right).
fibres oriented in the load direction. Shear tests were done in the laboratories of KU Leuven (fabrics B1 and B2) and Universiteit Twente (fabric B3) on the identical picture frames. Tests in Leuven were supported by full-field strain measurements; in the tests in Universiteit Twente, the thickness of the sheared fabric was measured with a special device under a pressure of 0.5 kPa. Table 6.2 Summary of the deformability tests performed for different types of NCFs Shear
B1 B2 B3 Q
Biaxial tension
Shear diagram
Strainmapping
Thickness
+ + + −
+ + − −
− − +
+ + − +
Compression Unsheared
Sheared
+ + + +
+ + + −
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
121
6.2.1 Picture frame test Figure 6.2 depicts the picture frame of the Department MTM, KU Leuven, and shows the method of gripping the sample. Hinge 1 moves freely in groove 3. Hinge 2 is connected to the bottom grip of the machine. When the crosshead moves up, pulling at point A, the frame starts closing, its sides rotating in hinges; hinge 1 goes up inside groove 3. Note that the centres of the hinges are in line with the internal edges of the frame. The maximum stroke of the machine, allowed by groove 3, is 22 mm, which gives the maximum shear angle of the frame (50°). The picture frame of the Department of Mechanical Engineering, Universiteit Twente, has the same dimensions and gripping system. The loading arrangement is, however, different: the load is applied directly to hinges 1 and 2. Hence, the displacement of the hinges is not restricted and the test can go on to higher shear angles. The frame was mounted on a Zwick machine; the force is measured with a 1 kN force-cell and a 12-bit AD converter, which results in a step size of 0.2441 N in the force data. In KU Leuven, the frame was mounted on an Instron 4467 machine with a 1 kN load cell with the same precision parameters as in Twente. The shear angle of the
6.2 Picture frame (Department MTM, KU Leuven): (a) empty frame: 1, 2 – hinges, 3 – groove, 4 – lip, 5 – plate with screws; (b) grips; frame with samples of fabrics B1, SC test (c) and B2, SS test (d); (e) load-displacement diagram of the empty frame.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
122
Non-crimp fabric composites
frame γ is related to the displacement of the machine x via a solution of a trigonometrical equation describing the movement of the frame. A test speed of 20 mm/min was used in all the tests. First, the load-displacement diagram was registered with an empty frame (Fig. 6.2), to be subtracted from the load diagram in the test with the fabric, to produce the net force F, acting on the fabric. Lips 4 are pressed by screws in plates 5. The lips and the frame beneath them have a wavy surface, securely gripping a fabric sample (Fig. 6.2). When the sample is fixed in the frame, it is possible to feel that it is tensed. The deformation of the pre-tensed fabric cannot exceed a value of 2.8%, given by the geometry of the lips. In practice, the pre-tension is significantly smaller: a very rough estimation of the difference in the distance between the stitching before and after mounting of the fabric gives the range of the pre-tension as 0.5–1%. In the tests performed in the University of Twente, the mounting procedure was different, with the aim of minimising the fabric tension. The grips were loosened to the point where the tension in the fabric disappeared (felt by the operator). The effect of this is discussed in section 6.5. The fabric is firmly gripped in the frame, with the fibres parallel to the frame sides. During the test, the fibres near the grips are gradually bent and the shear angle in the central part of the sample is different from the shear angle of the frame. The lesser the bending resistance near the grips, the smaller this deviation. One of the ways to minimise it is to take out of the fabric the fibres parallel to the nearest frame side (Fig. 6.2). In the preliminary test it was found that without this measure the test is impossible to perform because of the extensive wrinkling of the material. Therefore, the fibres near the grips were taken out in all the experiments described in this chapter. The result of the test is the dependency of the shear force per unit width of the frame side T on the shear angle of the frame γ. The latter is easily calculated from the displacement on the testing machine (1); the former is calculated as
[6.1]
where F is the force applied by the loading machine, w is the width of the gripped side of the sample, α is the frame angle, γ is the shear angle. Three loading cycles were performed for each sample. Load diagrams and strain fields during unloading (return of the frame to initial rectangular configuration) were not registered. The normalisation issues are discussed in (Peng et al., 2004). In some regions of the shear diagrams, the force measurements were performed at the limit of the machine precision (the difference in tensile force of the frame with fabric and the empty frame was about 1 N, which corresponds to a shear force less than 0.01 N/mm). Another factor that may affect the precision of the measurements is friction in the hinges. In the presence of high fabric pre-tension
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
123
this is an uncontrollable factor, which might lead to unsatisfactory results in the first shearing cycle. Fabrics B1 and B3 can be mounted in the picture frame with their fibres parallel to the frame sides in two ways: with the stitching parallel to the loading direction and across it. In the former case, the stitching, firmly clamped by the frame grips, is in tension, and one can expect high resistance to deformation. This test direction will be abbreviated as ST (stitching–tension). In the latter case the stitching is in compression, which should not affect the test result very much. This test direction will be abbreviated as SC (stitching–compression). These observations were also made in other studies of the deformability of NCF (Long et al., 2002; Harrison et al., 2003; Yu et al., 2004). The presence of the glass stabilising yarns in fabric B1 introduces another complication: they are oriented along the tension directions. Therefore, even in the SC tests some ‘parasitic’ tension may be present. To minimise it, the glass yarns were cut near the grips after mounting the sample. In spite of this, the glass yarns are firmly set inside the fabric by the stitching. This leads to irregularities of the fabric shear, shown in the next section. When fabric B2 is mounted with the fibres parallel to the frame sides, the stitching is also parallel to them. There should be no difference in the test direction. This case will be referred as SS (stitching–shear). To constitute a true characterisation of the fabric shear behaviour, the test must provide dependency of the shear force on the average shear angle of the fabric. Due to the complications of the gripping discussed above, one cannot be sure that it is the same as the shear angle of the frame. The shear angle of the fabric was measured using the ARAMIS strainmapping system. The reader is referred to (Lomov et al., 2006; 2008; Willems et al., 2008; 2009) for details of the measurement technique and data processing. Plate I (see colour section between pages 396 and 397) shows results of the full-field registration of the shear field in the example of fabric B2. The curves are the result of averaging data for three samples. There was no statistically significant difference in the average shear angle of the fabric in different shear cycles. Fabric B1 develops a lot of local wrinkling, which prevents resolving the deformation field after the frame shear angle reaches approximately 18°, hence results for it are not shown. Fabric B2, in the SS test, behaves in a more stable way, and the strain field can be resolved up to the maximum shear angle of the frame. The local shear angle of the fabric was determined by the angle between the diagonals of initially square facets visible in Plate I. The measurements show the following: • •
The average shear angle of the fabric is the same as the shear angle of the frame. The scatter of the local shear angle is about ±2°. The size of the facets is about 15 × 15 mm. The local shear angle in these measurements is the result of averaging over three unit cells of the fabric, hence local variations within unit cells do not cause the scatter value given above. This value (±2°) is quite low, allowing the conclusion that the shear field is fairly even.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
124
Non-crimp fabric composites
6.2.2 Shear diagrams Fabrics B1 and B2 were tested in laboratory of the Department MTM, KU Leuven. Figure 6.3 shows the results of the picture frame tests on fabrics B1 (SC and ST tests) and B2 (SS test): shear force as a function of the frame shear angle and average fabric shear angle. Three shear cycles are shown.
6.3 Shear diagrams of fabric B1, SC (a) and ST (inset) tests, and fabric B2, SS test (b). Error bars show standard deviation of five tests. Only loading diagrams were registered.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
125
The diagrams for the first shear cycle for both fabrics show extremely irregular behaviour and evidence of tension of the fibres in the frame. This type of behaviour was labelled in (Lomov et al., 2006) as ‘bad tests’, and normally such tests are discarded from the data processing. The cause of ‘bad’ behaviour of a woven fabric has been identified in (Lomov et al., 2006) as deviations of the yarns from directions parallel to the frame sides and variations of the pre-tension of the different yarns. The arrangement of an NCF sample in the frame is much more difficult than mounting of woven fabrics. Fibres, which have to be taken away near the grips, are firmly fixed in the fabric by stitching. Hence, the disturbances given to the fibres in the fabric by the process of taking these fibres away are more serious than in a woven fabric. These disturbances are larger for fabric B1, as in this case the fibres are inclined 45° to the stitching, and ‘cracks’ in the fibrous ply do not form continuous fibre bundles between the stitching sites (as ‘channels’ in fabric B2 do). We were not able to make a ‘good’ test (without evidence of the fibre tension) in the first shear cycle. After the first cycle the sample is ‘conditioned’ (Nguyen et al., 1999; Long, 2000; Mohammed et al., 2000; Lebrun et al., 2003; Sharma et al., 2003; Peng et al., 2004; Lomov et al., 2006) and its behaviour is much more stable. In our measurements the first cycle represented the experimental rig behaviour rather than the material itself and therefore it was not used for the material characterisation. In the second and the third shear cycles some tests also resulted in ‘bad’ diagrams. These were considered faults in mounting the sample and discarded from the data processing. For the ‘good’ tests the second and the third shear cycles produce very close diagrams for both fabrics. The differences lie well inside experimental scatter, but the third cycle gives shear resistance some 5% less than the second. The scatter is quite large for fabric B1 (up to 50%), and less for fabric B2 (about 20%). On closer inspection, the diagrams for fabric B2 bear evidence of the fibre tension even on the second and the third cycles. The difference in the shear diagrams of the two fabrics compared in Fig. 6.4 is not large, but the shear resistance of fabric B2 is definitely lower than that of the fabric B1 (the initial region of the B2 diagram, possibly influenced by the fibre tension, still present in the second cycle, should not be considered). The difference in the shear resistance has to be attributed to the differences in the stitching pattern and direction, since the fabrics have the same areal density. The fibres are tightly fixed by the tricot pattern in fabric B1; the 45° direction of the fibres does not connect diagonally the stitching sites (rectangular spacing 4.94 × 1.71 mm, Table 6.1). This produces ‘openings’ in the fibrous ply, without formation of continuous fibre bundles in the plies. The tight fixation of the fibres is evidenced by a significant resistance of the fibres to pulling them out of the fabric (as it was done along the grips). In fabric B2 the fibres are fixed by the tricot-chain stitching much more loosely. There are ‘openings’ on the face (0°) ply and ‘channels’ in the back (90°). The latter give fibres freedom to rotate during the shear deformation, behaving like a trellis up to a certain ‘locking’ shear angle, when the rotation
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
126
Non-crimp fabric composites
6.4 Comparison of the shear diagrams of fabrics B1 and B2 (picture frame test, see Fig. 6.3 and KES-F) and fabric B3 (picture frame test, Fig. 6.5).
becomes impossible without lateral compaction of the fibres (about 23°, judging by a geometrical estimation of the locking angle γlock = arccos(w/p), where w is the bundle width and p is the bundle spacing). Finally, Fig. 6.3a (inset) shows results of ST tests of fabric B1, with the stitching in tension. The shear force (which actually represents the tensile resistance of the chain of the stitching loops) is five times higher than in SC tests, and the shear modulus is 20 times higher; the test had to be stopped at the shear angle of 1.7° because of the too-high load on the load cell of the machine. Fabric B3 was tested in the laboratory of the Department of Mechanical Engineering, Universiteit Twente. Figure 6.5 shows the results of the tests: shear force as a function of the frame shear angle. Three shear cycles are shown. The curves are an average of five experiments, which are quite reproducible: coefficient of variation in the range of 20%. To study the influence of the shear rate, the experiments were repeated at machine speeds from 10 to 1000 mm/min. No systematic variation of the shear resistance has been found; the curves changed within the experimental scatter range. The results demonstrate the same difference between the first shear cycle and the second and third shear cycles. In this test the full cycle has been registered, showing a hysteresis effect. Measurements up to higher shear angles show a
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
127
6.5 Shear diagram of fabric B3 (picture frame test).
sharp increase of the fabric resistance, starting at the frame shear angle of around 45°, which is in accordance with the measurements for fabrics B1 and B2 (Fig. 6.3). When sheared in the ST direction (negative shear angles in Fig. 6.5), the same increase of the shear resistance is registered as for fabric B1 (Fig. 6.3b). In spite of the qualitative likeness, the quantitative results of the tests in Universiteit Twente (fabric B3) are quite different to those from KU Leuven (fabrics B1 and B2). The shear resistance of fabric B3 is about ten times lower than of fabrics B1 and B2 (Fig. 6.4), in spite of the fact that the areal density of the former is 50% higher than of the latter. This can be explained by the difference of the mounting procedure in two laboratories, which led to difference in the fabric pre-tension. Fabric B3, tested with deliberately loosened grips in Universiteit Twente, had much less pre-tension than fabrics B1 and B2, which were tested in KU Leuven without a special procedure to minimise the pre-tension and were subjected to a considerable pre-strain of about 0.5%. The reader is referred to the discussion and quantitative estimation of the influence of pre-tension on the results of picture frame test in (Lomov et al., 2004; 2006). When compared with measurements from the Kawabata Evaluation System (KES-F) (Lomov et al., 2003a), Fig. 6.4, the picture frame shear diagrams show close values of the diagram slope, i.e., shear modulus of the fabric. However, the values of the shear force in the KES-F measurement are significantly lower than in the picture frame test. This is explained by the difference in the level of the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
128
Non-crimp fabric composites
fabric pre-tension in the two tests. In the KES-F measurement (Lomov, Verpoest et al., 2003a), a controlled pre-tension of 0.01 N/mm is given to the fabric. In the picture frame test the pre-tension is not controlled, but by the values of the prestrain, given above as about 0.5%, and results of the tension tests, the pre-tension can be estimated as lying in the range 0.1–1 N/mm, which is by two orders of magnitude higher than in the KES-F test.
6.3
Biaxial tension
Biaxial tension tests were performed for fabrics B1, B2 and Q.
6.3.1 Equipment and samples The biaxial tester of the department of MTM, KU Leuven (Fig. 6.6) is a tensile machine equipped with four independently controlled axes, developed for the study of deformation of textiles, films and thin sheets. The clamping system consists of freely moveable clamping rigs (mechanical or pneumatic) mounted on each axis. The axes’ movements are fully computer-controlled; the output consists of force-displacement curves in the two principal directions. The apparatus can be used to investigate the constitutive behaviour, anisotropy and limits of deformation of the material. The types of tests that can be performed are: • • •
uniaxial stress tests with clamping in one single direction; biaxial tests with principal strain ratios varying between zero and infinity; and shear tests using a tensile bar clamped over the centreline of the material.
The biaxial tensile tester has four different axes, which can all be driven separately. The machine has two force transducers in total, one for each direction. They can register a maximum force of about 5 kN, with an accuracy of 0.1%. The axes can be moved at different speeds, ranging from 25 to 175 mm/min, in steps of 25 mm/min.
6.3.2 Tension diagrams The fabric behaviour in a biaxial tester is determined by the interaction between the yarns or fibres. The theory of the test is well developed for woven fabrics, where interference between warp and weft is determined by the crimp of the yarns (Kawabata, 1973a; 1973b; Boisse et al., 1999; Launay et al., 1999; Lomov et al., 2003b; 2008; Willems et al., 2008; 2009). In NCF, the fibres in plies are almost straight and are not interlaced one with another. They are, however, linked by the stitching. The extent of the link is different for different fabrics and the different directions of the test. The tests were performed with the following ratios of deformation on the machine axes: ‘1 : free’, meaning that only one pair of the clamps is used, ‘1 : 0’,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
129
6.6 Biaxial tensile tester (a), clamping of the sample (b).
when one set of the clamps is moving, the other staying fixed, ‘1 : 1’ (equal deformations in both directions), ‘1 : 2’ and ‘1 : 5’ (ratio of deformation in two directions). Different axis speeds were set, corresponding to the chosen ratio of deformations. The tests were performed in the 0°/90° and +45°/−45° directions relative to the production direction of a fabric. At the end of the diagrams, the apparent stiffness reduces because of the onset of slippage in the grips. In the case of 0°/90° test of the fabric B1 and the +45°/−45° test of fabric B2 (Fig. 6.8) the deformation goes in the direction in-between the fibres. Stitching serves as ‘hinges’ between the two fibre systems in the plies. This ensures a strong link between the two tension directions. The direction of the stitching in fabric B1
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
130
Non-crimp fabric composites
6.7 Tension of fabrics B1 and B2: (a) biaxial and uniaxial in fibre direction (deformation ratios 1 : free, 1 : 0, 1 : 1, 1 : 2, 1 : 5 for each fabric); (b) uniaxial and (c) biaxial in the bias directions (ratio between deformations in two directions is shown on the curves, the first value being the direction of the strain and load shown by the curve). Five tests are averaged for each curve, Cv ≈ 5–10%.
is different in the tests in 0° and 90°. No statistically significant difference was found in these two cases. In the uniaxial tension test in the bias direction (Fig. 6.7a) the fabrics are highly extensible (‘bias extension test’). When deformation in the direction perpendicular to load is restricted (biaxial test, Fig. 6.8b), the stiffness of the fabric increases together with the decrease of the deformation ratio (loading : perpendicular), shown in Fig. 6.10b. This behaviour is
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
131
6.8 Compression diagram, fabric B3: (a) Instron measurements, numbers refer to the compression cycles; (b) combination of Instron and KES-F measurements.
caused primarily by the test configuration: fibres gripped in the clamp in one direction are also gripped in the clamp in the other direction. The results of the tests should be considered as a qualitative indication of the fabric’s behaviour, as the quantitative results depend on the test configuration. The test reflects the combination of shear and tension, which may happen in the actual forming. Comparing the diagrams for fabrics B1 and B2 in Fig. 6.7, one notices that the diagrams are quite close. Fabric B2, however, offers higher load resistance, with identical areal density of the fabrics (see Table 6.1). This can be attributed to the straighter fibres in the fibre bundles of fabric B2 (to compare the width of the openings and channels in the two fabrics, see Table 6.1, which gives the degree of deviation of the fibres from straight lines). In the cases of +45°/−45° test for B1, 0°/90° for B2 (Fig. 6.7a) and both directions for fabric Q, fibres lie in the directions of applied tension. In this case, one may expect non-linearity in the initial stage of deformation, because of the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
132
Non-crimp fabric composites
waviness of the fibres in the plies. Fibres undergo straightening before taking up the full load of the tension. Tension diagrams of fabric Q in 0/90 and +45/−45 tests are quite similar to those of fabrics B1 and B2 and are not included in Fig. 6.7a. No link between the test directions is revealed by the tests of fabrics B1 and B2. The curves for the different deformation ratios are mixed and are not distinguishable statistically. Fabric B2 exhibits higher tension resistance because of the straighter fibres in it (see above). It is interesting to note that the non-linearity range in strain (about 0.1%) is of the same order as has been registered for woven fabrics (Lomov et al., 2003b).
6.3.3 Validity of simplified models In forming simulation software, fabric tension is normally characterised independently for two directions, and it is preferable to have a linear tension diagram of the fabric for the sake of computational effectiveness. Our observations lead to the following conclusions regarding these two assumptions. All the measured diagrams exhibit a nonlinear behaviour. The authors are not aware of studies where simulation with linear and nonlinear diagrams would be compared. Such a study is needed to conclude on the necessity of using true nonlinear diagrams instead of linear approximation. One may argue that, in the absence of comparative simulations, it is not clear if incorporation of tensile data is needed at all, and whether the assumption of inextensible fibres would not be enough for an acceptable simulation. Because of low deformations in the fibre direction this reasoning might be true, but one should take into account interdependence between tension and shear. Studies of shearing of woven fabrics show that calculation of the tension forces is of paramount importance for the correct calculation of the shear resistance, which can differ by orders of magnitude when coupled with tension (Lomov and Verpoest, 2006; Cao et al., 2008; Launay et al., 2008) which should also be the case for NCF. A model with inextensible fibres does not allow such a calculation. Our results show that there is no significant coupling between the tension directions if they coincide with the fibre directions in the fabric. Hence, for NCF this assumption in the material models of the existing simulation software can be retained.
6.4
Compression
Compression tests were performed in the laboratory of the department of MTM, KU Leuven on Instron and in the laboratory of Centexbel, Gent on KES-F. A flat cylindrical punch with a diameter of 50 mm is mounted in the Instron 4467. A load cell of 1 kN is used. The lowest pressure measured on Instron with sufficient accuracy is 1–5 kPa, which is the upper limit of the KES-F pressure range. To study the effect of nesting of the layers (Lomov et al., 2002), tests on one, two and four layers of each fabric were performed. In each test, three compression cycles
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
133
were performed, up to a pressure of 200 kPa. For more detail on the experimental technique see (Lomov et al., 2003a; 2005).
6.4.1 Compression test results The behaviour of the NCF in compression exhibits common well-known features of compression (Gutowski et al., 1986; Lomov and Verpoest, 2000; Chen et al., 2001; 2006). The initial stiffness is low, fabrics are compressed to about 70–80% of the initial thickness at a pressure of 50 kPa. With the pressure increase to the maximum value of 200 kPa, the thickness of the fabric additionally decreases to about 60–70% of the initial thickness. Actual values depend on the number of layers and compression cycle. Figure 6.8 shows typical results of the Instron tests: one layer of fabric B3 for different compression cycles, measured on Instron and KES-F. One sees that the diagrams of the second and the third compression cycles are very close to one another. To make the data overview more brief, we do not discuss below the data on the third cycle. As mentioned above, the Instron diagrams do not provide reliable data for the low-load range, hence, they do not allow determination of the initial fabric thickness. These data are provided by the KES-F measurement. The Instron and KES-F measurements (fabric B3) are compared in Fig. 6.8, which shows typical features common for the fabric behaviour in all of the studied cases. For the first cycle, KES-F and Instron measurements fairly correspond to one another. A certain jump is evident when passing from KES-F to Instron results for the second cycle. This can be explained by the fact that in contrast with the KES-F measurements in the lower pressure range (up to 5 kPa), the first cycle up to 200 kPa cannot be treated as ‘conditioning’, as it gives permanent high deformation to the sample (note that the thickness at the start point of the second cycle of the Instron diagram in Fig. 6.8 almost coincides with the end-point of the first cycle). Based on this, the first cycle of the Instron tests is used below for discussions on the fabric behaviour. The ‘conditioning’ of the sample by a first cycle of compression is recommended for KES-F measurements at low loads (Lomov et al., 2003a). Hence, the second cycle of KES-F test is adopted as representing the fabric behaviour. To present the considerable amount of data in a concise form, the diagrams were approximated with a power law: [6.2] where T is the fabric thickness, mm; p is the pressure, kPa; p* is a parameter, kPa; T0 is a parameter, mm, corresponding to the fabric thickness in the relaxed state ( p = 0); Tmin is a parameter, mm, corresponding to the fabric thickness at p = ∝; a is a dimensionless power parameter.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
134
Non-crimp fabric composites
Approximation 6.2 was applied to the data set as follows. Consider a set of repetitive measurements for a given test parameters: type of fabric, number of layers, number of the compressive cycle. The set of measurements normally consists of five Instron diagrams. These diagrams are processed to produce an averaged diagram. The coefficient of variation of such a set lies within 5–10% for all the measured data. As discussed above, the averaged Instron diagram does not allow us to define T0. This is defined by the KES-F measurement in the second cycle, as the first KES-F cycle serves to condition the sample. Hence, the averaged KES-F second cycle diagram was added to the averaged Instron first cycle diagram for p < 5 kPa. The combined diagram was used via a least-square minimisation procedure to determine the best-fit parameters T0, Tmin, p0 and a in Equation 6.2. In this case T0 represents true initial fabric thickness, and the approximation 6.2 can be used in the pressure range 0–200 kPa. For the second compressive cycle, KES-F and Instron data do not correspond one to another. Therefore, only averaged Instron diagram was used to fit the Equation 6.2. Such an approximation is strictly usable only in the range 5–200 kPa, and in this case T0 value has to be considered as an extrapolative estimation of the fabric thickness at the beginning of the second compression cycle. The results of this processing are summarised in Table 6.3, which provides the results of the compression tests in full. For the discussion of characteristic features of the behaviour of the fabrics, the data on the first compressive cycle will be used.
6.4.2 Trends in the compressive behaviour The studied fabrics show quite similar compressive behaviour. Moreover, certain dependency can be established on the areal density of the fabrics. Consider the parameters of the compression diagrams for the first compressive cycle (one layer). Figure 6.9a shows the dependency of these parameters on the areal density of the fabric. Parameters T0 and Tmin increase with the increase of the fabric areal density, as may be expected. Parameters p* and a do not exhibit a trend – the shape of all the diagrams is very much the same. Hence, the compression diagrams of the studied fabrics can be approximated with Equation 6.2, where p* and a are the same for all the fabrics (average values, shown in Fig. 6.9a), and T0 and Tmin are calculated using the linear regression formulae, also shown in Fig. 6.9a. Figure 6.9b compares the results of such an approximation with the measurements. The fabrics in question are obtained from different producers and were manufactured using different heavy carbon tows. The similarities of the compression behaviour and the recognisable trend vs. areal density of the fabrics reflect similarities of the fibre bundle structure and of the textile manufacturing process. The approximations shown in Figure 6.9 could probably be applied to other NCFs.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
135
Table 6.3 Compression test. Parameters of Equation 6.2 Fabric
Layers
Cycle
T0, mm
Tmin, mm
p, kPa
a
B1
1
1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2
1.153 0.957 2.082 1.541 4.268 2.972 0.829 0.835 1.425 1.718 2.673 3.203 0.945 0.870 1.517 1.540 3.499 3.291 1.360 1.046 2.410 2.310 4.868 3.972
0.324 0.251 0.635 0.547 1.245 0.979 0.309 0.246 0.593 0.527 1.135 1.050 0.396 0.485 0.850 0.834 1.805 1.669 0.601 0.515 1.054 0.961 2.072 2.005
1.343 1.097 1.901 4.824 1.490 4.952 2.660 0.953 3.845 0.802 6.368 1.346 6.932 3.691 15.231 1.926 6.309 1.577 2.652 8.742 5.707 5.297 4.719 14.450
0.631 0.339 0.624 0.438 0.620 0.393 0.709 0.372 0.546 0.360 0.476 0.330 0.382 1.013 0.535 0.335 0.578 0.326 0.637 0.448 0.484 0.367 0.476 0.452
2 4 B2
1 2 4
B3
1 2 4
Q
1 2 4
6.9 First compressive cycle, one layer: (a) parameters of the Equation 6.2 vs. areal density of the fabric; (b) compression diagrams, points – measured, lines – calculated using Equation 6.2 with averaged parameters.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
136
Non-crimp fabric composites
6.4.3 Nesting effect in the fabrics As is discussed in (Lomov et al., 2002; 2003a), nesting of the layers (decrease of the thickness per layer in a laminate) in NCF laminates is of minor importance, being caused by the thin stitching yarn lying on the surface of the fabric and creating the surface roughness of the fabric. Our current measurements show variable nesting for the studied unsheared fabrics. Table 6.4 gives nesting coefficients ζ, calculated as ,
[6.3]
where N is the number of layers in the laminate, T(N) – thickness of the laminate, T(1) – thickness of one layer. The initially significant nesting decreases with the increase of pressure (nesting coefficient increases), and for sheared fabric it even gives the opposite effect: increase of thickness per layer in a laminate. The latter phenomenon can be explained by the fact that when sheared, layers in a laminate tend to buckle because of irregularities of fibre placement in layers and unevenness of tension applied to different layers.
Table 6.4 Nesting coefficients in the compression tests Fabric
Shear angle, °
B1
0
B2
0
B3
0
Q
0
6.5
Number of layers
2 4 2 4 2 4 2 4
Nesting coefficient T0
T(10 kPa)
Tmin
0.90 0.93 0.86 0.81 0.80 0.93 0.89 0.89
1.00 0.97 0.99 1.00 0.94 0.97 0.99 0.97
0.98 0.96 0.96 0.92 1.07 1.14 0.88 0.86
Bending
Bending rigidity of NCF was measured on KES-F in Centexbel, Gent. Bending rigidity is expressed as the slope of the torque versus curvature between 0.5 and 1.5 cm−1. Bending hysteresis is expressed as the difference in momentum at a curvature of 1 cm−1. Figure 6.10 and Table 6.5 show the results of the measurements for fabrics B1, B2 and Q. To assess isotropy of the bending properties, let us consider a formula introduced in (Jiang and Hu, 1999), which accounts for difference of curvature of differently
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
137
6.10 Typical bending diagrams on NCF. Two diagrams are registered on one graph, with an offset for clarity.
Table 6.5 Bending rigidity Fabric and test direction
B Bending rigidity, 10−4 Nm2/m
2HB Bending hysteresis 10−2Nm/m
B1, MD B1, CD B1, +45° B1, −45° B2, MD B2, CD B2, +45° B2, −45° Q, MD Q, CD Q, +45° Q, −45°
0.59 ± 0.18* 0.62 ± 0.15 0.63 ± 0.117 0.62 ± 0.132 2.48 ± 0.65 1.41 ± 0.38 2.07 ± 0.31 2.20 ± 0.14 1.90 ± 0.704 1.324 ± 0.57 1.27 ± 0.365 1.16 ± 0.22
2.08 ± 0.114 2.45 ± 0.316 2.01 ± 0.152 2.09 ± 0.138 5.03 ± 0.27 4.19 ± 0.262 3.88 ± 0.22 3.66 ± 0.25 8.88 ± 1.05 8.91 ± 0.716 7.56 ± 1.23 8.02 ± 1.11
oriented tows in the fabric under bending. They state that if the interaction between carbon fibre plies and influence of stitching could be neglected, then the bending rigidity of the multi-ply fabric Bfabric is given by [6.4]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
138
Non-crimp fabric composites
where Bi is the bending rigidity of the ply, αi is the angle between the direction of the ply fibres and the direction of bending. The difference between properties (both bending rigidity and hysteresis) in machine/cross and bias directions for the fabrics B1 and B2 is not statistically significant. This applies not only for values of bending rigidity, but also for the full shape of the diagrams (Fig. 6.10). This remarkable observation shows that the influence of stitching and frictional interaction of the plies is negligible for these fabrics. Indeed, Equation (6.1) gives for the machine or cross direction Bfabric = 2Bicos245 = Bi, and for bias direction also Bfabric = Bi. Fabric B2 demonstrates certain differences in bending rigidity in machine and cross directions. The fibrous structure of the plies in these directions is indeed different (Fig. 6.1). The stitching introduces relatively large gaps between fibres in machine and cross directions, forming fibre bundles between stitching yarns. The fibres in these bundles are tightened together, and the bending resistance of such a bundle must be larger than that of the loosely placed fibres in the ply, because intra-ply slippage of the fibres is prevented. The fibre bundles in the machine direction are more tightly packed than in the cross direction, which may explain the observed difference. Measurements show a significant difference in bending rigidity between fabrics B1 and B2, the latter being three times higher. Areal density of the fabrics B1 and B2 are same. As the bending rigidity of the fabric B2 is also higher than the bending rigidity of the fabric Q (which is twice as heavy), then the difference cannot be attributed to the different stitching pattern of the fabrics B1 and B2. A possible source of the difference is the difference in the raw material: carbon tows of 12 k and 24 k. For the fabric Q, the bending rigidity in machine/cross is about 25% larger than in the bias direction, and this difference is statistically significant. By the placement of the fibres in the fabric, the properties in machine/cross and bias directions should be identical. The observed difference may be attributed to the difference in influence of stitching and friction between plies. In the MD ply, the stitching introduces fibre bundles increasing the bending resistance, as discussed above. In the bias plies, the stitching produces smaller ‘cracks’ in the plies, which do not affect the bending resistance (in the same way as it is not affected for the fabric B). Hence, the plies in machine/cross directions are stiffer in bending than the bias direction plies. However, the difference in the global shape of the diagrams is not large (Fig. 6.10). The diagrams demonstrate large initial stiffness. When estimated by a secant to the curvature 0.5 cm−1, the initial bending rigidity for fabrics B1, B2 and Q is about 7.5, 20.1 and 18.0 Nmm, or more than ten times higher than the bending rigidity measured between 0.5 and 1.5 cm−1. To estimate the relationship between the bending properties of the fabrics and carbon tows, the ratios of the bending rigidity of the fabrics (units Nmm) to their areal density and the bending rigidity of the tows (units Nmm2) to their linear density
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
139
can be estimated. The ratio, which can be called relative bending rigidity, is expressed then in Nmm2/Ktex both for fabrics and tows. The ratio for the fabrics B1, B2 and Q is 0.19 Nmm2/Ktex, 0.60 and 0.22 Nmm2/Ktex (machine direction), which is quite close. The measurements of the bending rigidity of the heavy carbon tows (Fig. 6.11) suggest a value of about 0.4 Nmm2/Ktex (calculated as the slope of the best fit straight line). The large scatter of the data is probably caused by the difference in sizing of the tows. The average value for our fabrics (0.33 Nmm2/Ktex) and the data for the yarns correspond to one another. The ratio of the bending rigidity to the linear density of individual carbon fibres themselves is about 0.3 Nmm2/Ktex, which is close to the quoted values. The values in the range of 0.2–0.6 Nmm2/Ktex can be proposed as rough estimations for similar fabrics.
6.11 Bending rigidity of heavy carbon tows. Line = simple sum of bending rigidity of the fibres; points = experimental (Lomov et al., 2003a).
6.6
Conclusion
Characterisation of the behaviour of NCF in tension, shear, compression and bending leads to the following conclusions.
6.6.1 Shear Shear of biaxial NCF is characterised by the same phenomena as other bi-directional textiles, when sheared in the direction of compression of the stitching: hysteresis of the diagram, leading to non-zero starting shear resistance, low shear modulus up to approximately 30°, when the main shear resistance mode is friction, and rapid increase of the shear modulus with the onset and intensification of the lateral
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
140
Non-crimp fabric composites
compression of the fibre bundles. Shear in the direction of tension of the stitching produces high and rapidly increasing resistance in the picture frame test. Shear resistance depends strongly on pre-tension of the fabric. In the absence of the universally adopted procedure to control and measure the pre-tension, any reporting of picture frame tests should be supplemented with a thorough description of the gripping procedure and estimations of the pre-tension. The KES-F and picture frame shear tests coincide in shear modulus with a large difference in the absolute value of the shear resistance, caused by the difference in pre-tension. For the same pre-tension conditions, the shear resistance of the fabrics of 0°/90° and +45°/−45° construction of the same areal density is close. Average angle of shear of a fabric corresponds to the shear angle of the frame. Variations of the local shear angle of the fabric do not exceed 2°.
6.6.2 Tension Tension resistance in two test directions is strongly coupled for a test in a bias direction, and is not significantly coupled for a test in the fibre directions. When two directions are coupled, the resistance in direction X increases with the increase of deformation ratio Y : X. Tension diagrams exhibit a non-linear region. Biaxial tension resistance of fabrics with 0°/90° and +45°/−45° construction of the same areal density is close.
6.6.3 Compression The behaviour of NCF in compression exhibits common features, typical for compression of textile reinforcements in general. The initial stiffness is low, with reduction of thickness to 70–80% of the initial thickness at a pressure of 50 kPa. With the pressure increase to the maximum value of 200 kPa, the thickness of the fabric additionally decreases to about 60–70% of the initial thickness. The compressive resistance significantly increases after the first compressive cycle, becoming stable in the subsequent cycles. Instron compressive diagrams of the first cycle coincide with KES-F measurements. Compression diagrams of all the studied unsheared fabrics can be estimated by formula 6.2 with the shape parameters p* and a constant, and thickness parameters T0 and Tmin linearly depending on the areal density of the fabric. The limited nesting effect has been confirmed for NCF under different pressure levels.
6.6.4 Bending The measured values of bending rigidity and its anisotropy correspond to measurements of bending rigidity of carbon tows and simple model Equation 6.4. A rough estimation of bending rigidity of carbon NCF is given by the value 0.2–0.6 Nmm2/Ktex
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
6.7
141
References
Boisse, P., A. Cherouat, J. C. Gelin and H. Sabhi (1999). Experimenal study and finite element simulation of a glass fibre fabric shaping process. Polymer Composites 16(1): 83–95. Cao, J., R. Akkerman, P. Boisse, J. Chen, H. S. Cheng, E. F. d. Graaf, J. L. Gorczyca, P. Harrison, G. Hivet, J. Launay, W. Lee, L. Liu, S. V. Lomov, A. Long, E. d. Luycker, F. Morestin, J. Padvoiskis, X. Q. Peng, J. Sherwood, T. Stoilova, X. M. Tao, I. Verpoest, J. Wiggers, A. Willems, T. X. Yu and B. Zhu (2008). Characterization of mechanical behavior of woven fabrics: experimental methods and benchmark results. Composites Part A 39: 1037–1053. Chen, B., A. H.-D. Cheng and T.-W. Chou (2001). A nonlinear compaction model for fibrous preforms. Composites part A 32: 701–707. Chen, Z. R., L. Ye and T. Kruckenberg (2006). A micromechanical compaction model for woven fabric preforms. Part I: Single layer. Composites Science and Technology 66(16): 3254–3262. Endruweit, A., S. Gehrig, and P. Ermanni (2003). Mechanisms of hydrodynamically induced in-plane deformation of reinforcement textiles in resin injection processes. Journal of Composite Materials 37(18): 1675–1692. Gutowski, T.G., J. Kingery and D. Boucher (1986). Experiments in composites consolidation: fiber deformation. Annual Technical Conference of the Society of Plastic Engineers. Brookfield: 1316–1320. Hammani, A. and B. R. Gebart (2000). Analysis of the vacuum infusion molding process. Polymer Composites 21(1): 28–40. Harrison, P., J. Wiggers, A. C. Long and C. D. Rudd (2003). Constitutive modelling based on meso and micro kinematics for woven and stitched fabrics. Proceedings ICCM-14. San Diego: CD edition. Hoersting, K. ed. (1998). Rationalising the production of long fibre reinforced composite materials using multiaxial multiply fabrics. Aachen, Shaker Verlag. Jiang, Y. and J. Hu (1999). Characterizing and modelling bending properties of multiaxial warp-knitted fabrics. Textile Research Journal 69(9): 691–697. Kawabata, S., M. Niwa and H. Kawai (1973). The finite-deformation theory of plain weave fabrics. Part I. The biaxial-deformation theory. Journal of the Textile Institute 64(1): 21–46. Kawabata, S., M. Niwa and H. Kawai (1973). The finite-deformation theory of plain weave fabrics. Part II. The uniaxial-deformation theory. Journal of the Textile Institute 64(2): 47–61. Launay, J., K. Buet-Gautier, G. Hivet and P. Boisse (1999). Analyse experimentale et modeles pour le comportement mechanique biaxial des renforts tisses de composites. Revue des composites et des materiaux avances 9(1): 27–55. Launay, J., G. Hivet, A. V. Duong and P. Boisse (2008). Experimental analysis of the influence of tensions on in plane shear behaviour of woven composite reinforcements. Composites Science and Technology 68(2): 506–515. Lebrun, G., M. N. Bureau and J. Denault (2003). Evaluation of bias extension and picture frame test methods for the measurement of intraply shear properties of PP/glass commingled fabrics. Composite Structures 61: 341–352. Lee, J. S., S. J. Hong, W. R. Yu and T.J. Kang (2007). The effect of blank-holder force on the stamp forming behavior of non-crimp fabric with a chain stitch. Composites Science and Technology 67(3–4): 357–366. Lomov, S. V., M. Barburski, T. Stoilova, I. Verpoest, R. Akkerman, R. Loendersloot and R. H. W. ten Thije (2005). Carbon composites based on multiaxial multiply stitched
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
142
Non-crimp fabric composites
preforms. Part 3: Biaxial tension, picture frame and compression tests of the performs. Composites part A 36: 1188–1206. Lomov, S. V., P. Boisse, E. Deluycker, F. Morestin, K. Vanclooster, D. Vandepitte, I. Verpoest and A. Willems (2008). Full field strain measurements in textile deformability studies. Composites part A 39: 1232–1244. Lomov, S. V., T. Stoilova and I. Verpoest (2004). Shear of woven fabrics: Theoretical model, numerical experiments and full field strain measurements. Proceedings of the 7th Esaform Conference on Material Forming. Trondheim, Norway: 345–348. Lomov, S. V., T. Truong Chi, I. Verpoest, T. Peeters, V. Roose, P. Boiss and A. Gasser (2003b). Mathematical modelling of internal geometry and deformability of woven preforms. International Journal of Forming Processes 6(3–4): 413–442. Lomov, S. V. and I. Verpoest (2000). Compression of woven reinforcements: a mathematical model. Journal of Reinforced Plastics and Composites 19(16): 1329–1350. Lomov, S. V. and I. Verpoest (2006). Model of shear of woven fabric and parametric description of shear resistance of glass woven reinforcements. Composites Science and Technology 66: 919–933. Lomov, S. V., I. Verpoest, M. Barburski and J. Laperre (2003a). Carbon composites based on multiaxial multiply stitched preforms. Part 2: KES-F characterisation of the deformability of the preforms at low loads. Composites part A 34(4): 359–370. Lomov, S. V., I. Verpoest, T. Peeters, D. Roos and M. Zako (2002). Nesting in textile laminates: Geometrical modelling of the laminate. Composites Science and Technology 63(7): 993–1007. Lomov, S. V., A. Willems, I. Verpoest, Y. Zhu, M. Barburski and T. Stoilova (2006). Picture frame test of woven fabrics with a full-field strain registration. Textile Research Journal 76(3): 243–252. Long, A. (2000). Process modelling for textile composites. International Conference on Virtual Prototiping EUROPAM 2000. Nantes: 1–17. Long, A. C., B. J. Souter, F. Robitaill and C. D. Rudd (2002). Effects of fibre architecture on reinforcement fabric deformation. Plastics, Rubber and Composites 31(2): 87–97. Mohammed, U., C. Lekakou, L. Dong and M. G. Bader (2000). Shear deformation and micromechanics of woven fabrics. Composites Part A 31: 299–308. Nguyen, M., I. Herszberg and R. Paton (1999). The shear properties of woven carbon fabrics. Composite Structures 47: 767–779. Peng, X. Q., J. Cao, J. Chen, P. Xue, D. S. Lussier and L. Liu (2004). Experimental and numerical analysis on normalisation of picture frame tests for composite materials. Composites Science and Technology 64(1): 11–21. Robitaille, F. and R. Gauvin (1998a). Compaction of textile reinforcements for composites manufacturing. I: Review of experimental results. Polymer Composites 19(2): 198– 216. Robitaille, F. and R. Gauvin (1998b). Compaction of textile reinforcements for composites manufacturing. II: Compaction and relaxation of dry and H2O-saturated woven reinforcements. Polymer Composites 19(5): 543–557. Robitaille, F. and R. Gauvin (1999). Compaction of textile reinforcements for composites manufacturing. III. Reorganization of the fiber network. Polymer Composites 20(1): 48–61. Sharma, S. B., M. P. F. Sutcliff and S.H. Chang (2003). Characterisation of material properties for draping of dry woven composite material. Composites Part A 34: 1167– 1175.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Deformability of textile preforms
143
Willems, A., S. V. Lomov, I. Verpoest and D. Vandepitte (2008). Optical strain fields in shear and tensile testing of textile reinforcements. Composites Science and Technology 68: 807–819. Willems, A., S. V. Lomov, I. Verpoest and D. Vandepitte (2009). Drape-ability characterization of textile composite reinforcements using digital image correlation. Optics and Lasers in Engineering 47: 343–351. Yu, W. R., P. Harrison and A. Long (2005). Finite element forming simulation for noncrimp fabrics using a non-orthogonal constitutive equation. Composites Part A 36: 1079–1093. Yu, W. R., P. Harrison and A. C. Long (2004). Ideal forming of non-crimp fabric preforms through optimization of blank shape and blank holding force. Proceedings ESAFORM-2004. Trondheim: 309–312.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Plate I Difference of the shear angle of the fabric B2 and frame shear angle (a), error bars show standard deviation; image of the deformed fabric B2, frame shear angle 14° (b) and distribution of the fabric shear angle (c) (Chapter 6).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
7 Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric composites P. HARRISON, University of Glasgow, UK, W-R. YU, Seoul National University, Korea and A. C. LONG , University of Nottingham, UK
Abstract: This chapter is focused on modelling the forming behaviour of biaxial non-crimp fabrics (NCFs). In Section 7.1, the motivation for modelling NCFs is given. Following a short description of the meso-structure of NCFs (Section 7.2) the effect of the stitch architecture on the shear and forming behaviour of NCFs is demonstrated. In Section 7.3, the two main approaches to modelling the forming behaviour of NCF are reviewed and in Sections 7.4 and 7.5, the capabilities, advantages and disadvantages of each method are considered. In Section 7.6, likely avenues for future research are outlined. Key words: non-crimp fabric forming, modelling.
7.1
Introduction
Most engineering fabrics are supplied as planar sheets of material and are not initially manufactured in the shape of the final component that they are intended to create. Instead, they are required to conform to the component’s surface geometry through fabric draping. This raises several questions that must be considered when a manufacturer sets out to manufacture a part. The initial questions relate to the forming process itself. • •
• • •
How to drape the component without creating forming-induced defects or, alternatively, where to introduce cuts and darts in the fabric prior to forming in order to prevent wrinkles occurring? If press-forming the part, what are the optimum forming conditions for the process, for example, what pressure should be applied around the perimeter of the fabric (using a so-called ‘blank-holder’) and is there an optimum blankholder pressure distribution that can reduce forming defects? If hand-forming the part, where is the best place to begin draping – on the top of the component, or does some other starting point provide better fabric drapability? Could pre-shearing the fabric prior to forming help reduce defects such as wrinkles? The problem can also be inverted: can the fabric’s structure be tailored by the material supplier to produce bespoke fabrics more suitable for forming over a given component geometry?
144 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
145
A further question arises, more directly relevant to the subsequent resin infusion stage of the manufacture, but directly informed by results of the fabric forming, namely: •
How will the final draped fibre pattern affect infusion of the resin through the dry fabric and how can the infusion strategy be modified (for example, repositioning of resin inlet and outlet valves) to account for this draped fibre pattern? (See also Chapters 8–10.)
Finally, but of equal importance, are questions relating to the component’s final quality and structural performance. •
How will the final draped fibre pattern influence the component’s dimensional stability when removed from the mould (spring forward or spring back) and crucially, how will this fibre pattern affect the component’s final structural performance? (See also Chapters 11–14.)
Determining the answers to these questions is a difficult task and most manufacturers currently use a combination of technical skill, practical experience and trial and error to produce components of acceptable quality; a blend of art and science. However, numerical simulation and the use of optimisation algorithms can play an important role in producing better components, resulting in savings in time, cost and final component weight. Recent advances in computational power coupled with the complexity and rewards in determining ideal manufacturing solutions have motivated the development of computer-aided engineering (CAE) tools aimed at creating a virtual try-out space for the manufacture of textile composites. While some experimental characterisation work on the forming of multiaxial (triaxial) non-crimp fabrics (NCFs) has been published (Kong et al., 2004), to the best of the authors’ knowledge, all modelling work published so far has been limited to biaxial NCFs and consequently provides the focus of work reviewed in this chapter.
7.2
Behaviour of fabric architecture on the shear and draping behaviour of non-crimp fabrics (NCFs)
The unique fabric architecture of biaxial NCFs results in deformation mechanisms (see also Chapters 6, 8 and 16) particular to these materials (Long et al., 2002; Wiggers et al., 2003; Thije et al., 2003; 2005a; 2005b; 2007; Harrison et al., 2004a; Kong et al., 2004; Creech et al., 2003; Creech and Pickett, 2006). As with woven fabrics, micro-mechanisms include fibre–fibre interactions within the tows during both tow compaction (in-plane and through-thickness) and intra-tow in-plane shear. Certain meso-scale mechanisms are unique to NCFs: stitch strain and inter-stitch friction, stitch-tow interactions, and tow-slip through the stitching. In contrast, crossover slip involving relative lateral motion of the two layers of tows is common to both woven fabrics and NCFs; though this particular mechanism is much less
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
146
Non-crimp fabric composites
obvious in woven fabrics as the interweaving of tows tends to restrict lateral motion in comparison to the relatively unconstrained tows in NCFs. The challenge to the modeller is in accounting for these mechanisms in NCFs during forming. As will be discussed, the approach adopted in modelling the material determines to a large extent which of these mechanisms are incorporated in the model. Figure 7.1 shows an example of the front and back faces of a +/−45° NCF knitted with a tricot stitch pattern. Figure 7.1a shows the NCF in an undeformed state with the two sets of fibres perpendicular (the fibre directions are indicated by
7.1 Shearing the fabric in different directions produces different amounts of strain in the fabric stitching, resulting in significantly different fabric shear compliance in the two directions. The superimposed arrows indicate the fibre directions in: (a) an unsheared fabric; (b) a fabric sheared parallel to the stitch direction; and (c) a fabric sheared perpendicular to the stitch direction.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
147
superimposed arrows). Figures 7.1b and c show the fabric when extended in the two different bias directions (at 45° to the original fibre directions), i.e. parallel and perpendicular to the stitch direction. The figure demonstrates how extending the fabric leads to trellis shear (the angle between the two sets of tows either increases or decreases) resulting in either stretching or compression of the fabric stitching. Note that this mode of deformation does not require the fibre tows to stretch, instead the two sets of tows rotate relative to each other (indicated by the change in the included angle between the arrows shown in Fig. 7.1). Extending the fabric parallel to the stitch, Fig. 7.1b, stretches the stitching, whereas extending the fabric perpendicular to the stitch, Fig. 7.1c, compresses the stitching. As one might imagine, this results in very different shear compliance depending on the direction of fabric shear. Typical shear force versus shear angle curves produced using picture frame tests, similar to those described in Chapter 6, are presented in Fig. 7.2. The tests were performed on a ±45° tricot warp knit NCF (Souter, 2001). Figure 7.2 clearly demonstrates the large difference in shear compliance of the NCF when shearing in opposite directions. The effect of this asymmetric shear response has an obvious influence on the forming behaviour of NCFs, as shown in Fig. 7.3. Here a NCF is draped over a symmetrical hemispherical geometry with symmetrical boundary conditions applied around the fabric blank-holder. This is the most obvious difference between the forming of NCFs and woven
7.2 Shear compliance curves for E-glass +/−45° tricot warp knitted fabric, highlighting the asymmetric shear properties due to the knitted thread. Here parallel indicates shearing parallel to the stitching direction (Souter, 2001).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
148
Non-crimp fabric composites
7.3 Formed shape of non-crimp fabric (Cotech Ebx318: +/−45° tows with chain stitch) after hemispherical forming showing asymmetric deformed shape due to the asymmetric shear behaviour (Souter, 2001).
fabrics and so any attempt to model the forming behaviour of NCFs must capture not only the strongly anisotropic mechanical response of the two directions of high modulus fibres, as with woven engineering fabrics, but also the asymmetric shear behaviour of the NCF resulting from its stitching. Strong differences in the degree of intra-ply slip seen in woven fabrics and NCFs are also evident in forming experiments; intra-ply slip is much more prevalent in NCFs. Thus, predictions of intra-ply slip should ideally also be possible when modelling NCFs.
7.3
Modelling strategies for NCF forming
Ideally, modelling predictions should be accurate (able to identify problem areas during draping and predict fibre angles), computationally inexpensive and input information should be simple and easy to acquire, preferably with a minimum amount of experimental characterisation. From a user perspective, models should also be easy to use and the software inexpensive to buy. The challenge in meeting these requirements has led to competing modelling strategies and the designer’s final choice of approach depends on the weighting assigned to the different goals. Kinematic mapping methods (e.g. Mack and Taylor, 1956; van der Ween, 1991; Long and Rudd, 1994; Hancock and Potter; 2006a; 2006b) are computationally much less expensive than the finite element (FE) method and first order approximations of the forming behaviour can readily be obtained with minimal user training. A recent advance enables a user-interactive approach allowing quick investigation of different forming possibilities (Hancock and Potter, 2006a; 2006b). As such, the technique has become well established within composites
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
149
manufacturing industries and a number of user-friendly codes are available commercially. However, most kinematic codes are designed to model the drape of woven fabrics. In order to capture the asymmetric material response of NCFs and also to include process boundary conditions, modifications to kinematic simulations have been made (Long, 2001; Long et al., 2002; 2005). This energybased kinematic method, reviewed in Section 7.4, provides an intermediate level of accuracy in modelling NCF forming, somewhere between the FE approach and unmodified kinematic mapping algorithms. However, when using the kinematic method one should keep in mind that under certain circumstances the technique can lead to significant errors (e.g. Vanclooster et al., 2009). FE simulations consider the mechanics of the forming process and can provide more accuracy. Not only are fibre angle predictions usually better, but wrinkling predictions and boundary conditions can also be modelled with greater accuracy than with kinematic models. FE simulations can also offer the possibility of predicting NCF-specific forming defects such as deviation from ideal trellis shear deformation, stitch breakage or tow pull-out (Creech et al., 2003; Creech and Pickett 2006; Thije et al., 2007). Even with these benefits, the FE method has yet to find widespread application in industry despite the availability of commercial codes dedicated to textile-forming mechanics. Reasons for the slow uptake of the FE method include the following. • • •
Much higher levels of user expertise and investment in staff training are required compared to that for kinematic codes. The constitutive models for engineering fabrics and NCFs necessary for the FE method are still undergoing development and validation. Correct material characterisation and consequent parameter determination for these models requires considerable time and expertise.
An example of how FE forming simulations can be used in the design of NCF components is given in Chapter 16.
7.4
Energy-based kinematic mapping
Kinematic modelling involves the assumption that the biaxial fabric deforms as a pin-jointed net (PJN). This means that the two sets of yarns are free to rotate at the crossovers between yarns and also that the yarns are inextensible. This approach provides a fast, first-order approximation to the draping behaviour of the fabric across a given geometry but, in its original form, the method does not include the asymmetric shear behaviour of the fabric or the effect of boundary conditions (see Section 7.2) and is thus limited in its ability to predict defects such as wrinkling or to provide much information on the effect of the boundary conditions for the forming process for NCFs. However, a modified version of the PJN technique has been proposed (Souter, 2001; Long, 2001; Long et al., 2002; 2005) based on an energy minimisation argument. The method behind the modified PJN technique
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
150
Non-crimp fabric composites
involves optimisation of the simulations’ ‘generator paths’, the paths of two fibres passing over the component, for which the intersection angle between the paths is specified and from which the kinematic constraint of fibre inextensibility allows the rest of the draping pattern to be calculated. This modified PJN energy minimisation technique incorporates the material’s shear behaviour, albeit in a simple manner, and thus provides a numerical simulation option lying somewhere between the FE and basic PJN methods, both in terms of computation time and accuracy.
7.4.1 Modelling asymmetric shear behaviour In this modified approach (Souter 2001; Long et al., 2002; Long et al., 2005) the strain energy required to produce each mapping is calculated iteratively, with the mapping resulting in the lowest energy assumed to represent the actual behaviour of the fabric. The total strain energy is the sum of two components: the shearing energy involved in forming the material and the frictional energy involved in pulling the material from inside the blank-holder. The shear strain energy (Us) can be calculated simply from the area under the torque-shear angle curve: [7.1] where T(θ) is the torque required to reach a shear angle θ and can be obtained directly from a picture frame (PF) test (see Chapter 6) or alternatively predicted using analytical or numerical sub-models (see section 7.4.2). The total energy is calculated within the fabric drape simulation by summing the contribution at each node (tow crossover). A simple way to determine the drape pattern corresponding to the minimum energy is to use an iterative scheme and involves finding the two intersecting paths that result in the lowest total energy. To do this, a Hooke and Jeeves minimisation method is used, where the generator path is defined one step at a time from a user-defined starting point. Each successive set of nodes is optimised by iterating the generator path angle until the minimum energy for this iteration is determined. The procedure is described in detail elsewhere (Souter, 2001).
7.4.2 Prediction of trellis shear force versus shear angle behaviour for NCFs using analytical models As discussed in Section 7.2, various deformation mechanisms act during the forming of NCFs. Some of the mechanisms are relevant to ideal trellis shear; the deformation assumed in the kinematic mapping approach to modelling NCF forming. Other mechanisms, i.e. intra-ply slip, allow alternative deformation kinematics to occur. In an attempt to predict rather than measure the shear force
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
151
versus shear angle input curves required in the energy-based kinematic mapping approach, energy contributions for each of the deformation mechanisms operating during ideal shear conditions were calculated, using a series of analytical or semianalytical sub-models (Harrison et al., 2003). Specifically, contributions from stitch strain, inter-stitch friction, fabric compaction and crossover friction were modelled. The assumption of ideal trellis shearing, which is implicit in the kinematic mapping approach, means that intra-ply slip mechanisms are not considered and so the model is unable to predict defects arising from intra-ply slip. Unit cell stitch model Using a geometric unit-cell stitch model, various energy storage/dissipation mechanisms can be analysed, including: stitch tension and inter-stitch friction. Consider the unit tricot stitch illustrated in Fig. 7.4. Shear deformation requires that sections of the stitch not parallel to the tow direction must change dimensions. The variation of c and d with shear angle, θ, can be determined from geometric constraints. Thus, [7.2]
[7.3]
7.4 The central diagram shows one example of a unit cell for a ±45° tricot warp knit non-crimp fabric. The diagrams on either side show the orientation of the stitch in relation to the front (left) and back (right) surfaces of the non-crimp fabric. Referring to the central diagram, the upper layer of tows run vertically (solid grey lines) and the bottom layer of tows run horizontally (dashed grey lines). The stitch runs over the tows (d, black solid line), pierces through the fabric (with a thickness, T ) and then runs under the tows (c, black dashed line).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
152
Non-crimp fabric composites
To determine the variation of the through-thickness stitch segments, T (see Fig. 7.4) the relationship between the stitch tension and tow compaction is required. As a first approximation, T is assumed constant with respect to shear angle (Souter, 2001). This is a reasonable assumption for dry fabrics with low initial fibre volume fraction, as the thickness variation only becomes relevant at high shear angles, where compaction forces dominate. Thije et al., (2005) confirmed this approximation for up to 30° of shear, beyond which thickness increases were observed (see also Chapter 8). Presuming the stitch passes freely through the stitch crossovers (illustrated in Fig. 7.5), the tension in the stitch can be considered constant through the entire length. Summing the overall length of the c, d and T sections gives the overall stitch length, L, in terms of shear angle. From this, the strain in the stitch εs, where the subscript s indicates that variables are related to the stitch, can be determined as [7.4] where Lo is the unstressed stitch length. The stitch is manufactured under a given strain, and so Lo does not necessarily correspond to L when θ = 0, the stitch length at zero shear. The stitching used in the material shows a fairly linear stress–strain relationship so that, prior to failure stitch stress, σs, is related to stitch strain as σs = Es εs. In terms of stitch tension, Ss = As·σs where As is the cross-sectional area of the stitch thread. The energy due to stitch extension, Us, is determined by integrating the stitch tension with respect to stitch length to find [7.5] Equation 7.5 applies for tension only, as the stitch shows virtually no compressive stiffness. This energy can be normalised with respect to the surface area of the unit cell, 2c0h0, and added to the energy contributions from other shear mechanisms. For a shear test in which the whole fabric is in constant, pure shear, this energy
7.5 An enlarged view of a stitch crossover. At the point at which the stitch passes through the fabric, it is constrained by the loop from a previous stitch (adapted from Wiggers, 2007).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
153
can be differentiated with respect to shear angle to produce an overall shear torque per unit length, τ, from which the shear force per unit length due to stitch extension can be calculated by dividing by cosΘ. Experimental observations confirm that the stitching does move through the fabric during shear, as assumed in the above analysis. A simple model for approximating the frictional resistance to stitch movement was proposed. Referring to Fig. 7.5, the stitching is taken to be stationary at the apex of the loop, as this is a point of symmetry with respect to both stitch tension and geometry. Considering the loop section of the stitch, c in Eq. 7.2, and the diagonal section of the stitch, d in Eq. 7.3, if the rate of strain imposed in these is not equal then the corresponding unequal tension would cause thread to pass from one to the other. Approximating the lateral force at the point of contact to the tension in the stitch, the frictional resistance, Ff, is given as Ff = µsSs, where µs is the dynamic friction of stitch on stitch movement. This force can be integrated with respect to distance and multiplied by the number of contact points in the unit cell (four) to find the energy dissipation due to stitch–stitch friction, Uf. This can subsequently be combined with the other energy dissipation/ storage mechanisms to find the total shear force of the fabric. Compaction model As a NCF is sheared and the degree of compaction within the fabric changes, energy stored or dissipated during this change can be estimated using compaction models. For convenience, the Cai and Gutowski (1992) model for compaction of lubricated fabrics, as adapted by McBride (1997) for dry aligned E-glass tows, has been used. Thus, given the following variation of volume fraction with shear angle (assuming constant thickness), [7.6] this equation is considered valid until Vf approaches the maximum volume fraction of 85% (McBride, 1997) at about θ = 60° (note, this is about twice the angle measured by Thije et al., 2003). Assuming zero axial strain, compaction stress lateral to the fibre direction, σc, can be derived as [7.7] where eb is the applied lateral strain, and the constants are evaluated as suggested by McBride (1997) for dry E-glass. The applied lateral strain can be expressed in terms of fibre volume fraction, which in turn can be related to the shear angle. This stress can be integrated to produce an energy term, Uc, the energy storage/ dissipation due to compaction. As indicated earlier, this can be added to the other energy contributions to find the total energy storage/dissipation. Conveniently, σb can also be used to provide an estimate of the pressure parameter in the crossover model, Pj, as discussed in the crossover model section.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
154
Non-crimp fabric composites
Crossover model In a woven textile composite, a crossover may be defined as the in-plane contact area existing between two individual tows. If the in-plane intra-tow shear rate of the individual tows is less than the average in-plane shear rate across the fabric then relative motion between the faces of the tows occurs. The relative velocity between the faces can be estimated using Eq 7.8 [7.8] . where is the relative velocity field between the crossovers, γt is the in-plane shear strain rate in both sets of tows and in the following calculation is considered constant in time, ω is the relative angular shear rate of the two sets of tows, θ is the material shear angle and X, Y are the position co-ordinates, with the origin at the centre of the crossover. If the normal pressure and coefficient of friction between the tows is known then a measure of the energy dissipation during shear can be made. Comparison of contributions of different mechanisms The separate normalised force contributions from each mechanism are shown in Fig. 7.6 and suggest that for a constant thickness assumption, the stitch tension provides the dominant contribution to the total shear force at low θ, with stitch friction providing the next largest contribution. At higher θ the compaction contribution becomes the most important mechanism. The crossover contribution appears to be negligible until relatively high values of θ. The sudden increase of
7.6 Four separate contributions to the total normalised shear force of the stitch fabric (from Wiggers, 2007).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
155
7.7 Forming set-up for Tay nose cone using a spring-loaded blankholder, also indicating line of maximum shear along which shear angle measurements were taken (from Long et al., 2005).
this contribution can be explained by the sharply increasing normal pressure, Pj, predicted by Eq. 7.6 and 7.7, as the fabric is compressed towards its maximum possible fibre volume fraction. Figure 7.7 shows that stitch contributions and fabric compaction are essential for accurate modelling of NCFs. Contributions from friction occurring between crossovers due to tow rotation are much less important and can probably be neglected.
7.4.3 Modelling the effect of the blank-holder During the energy minimisation algorithm, nodes are mapped to the surface one step or annulus at a time, so that at each step the area covered has grown by one row of nodes in the warp and weft directions. To incorporate the blank-holder friction energy contribution at each step, firstly the undeformed net-shape of the fabric is calculated. For every node around the perimeter of this undeformed net-shape, the distance to the initial starting (ply/tool contact) point is calculated. The projected distance between the corresponding draped node and the starting point is also calculated. The difference between these values represents the amount of material pulled through the blank-holder during the mapping. Frictional energy is calculated as the product of blank-holder force, friction coefficient and linear distance pulled through the blank-holder, multiplied by 2 as there are two contact interfaces. The total frictional energy dissipated during the mapping for the latest step is added to the total intra-ply shear energy and then minimised for each net-draping increment. In order to compare the modified code predictions with experiments, the forming of a jet engine nose cone was analysed (Long et al., 2005), using the tooling shown in Fig. 7.7. The pressure supporting the fabric was varied using eight spring-loaded pressure-pads around the blank-holder. Clamping force was varied by adjusting the spring compression for each pressure-pad, allowing the pressure to be varied around the perimeter. A uniform clamping pressure was used for all experiments. Simulation results are shown in Fig 7.8 and clearly show the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
156
Non-crimp fabric composites
7.8 Predicted fibre patterns for nose cone draped with tricot-stitched non-crimp fabric, with BHF of 0N (left), 126N (centre) and 252N (right) (from Long et al., 2005).
effect of the NCF’s asymmetric shear behaviour and also how the asymmetry of the draped fibre pattern decreases with increasing blank-holder pressure, an effect validated by their experiments and by others (Lee et al., 2007).
7.4.4 Modelling statistical variation of the manufacture process One important factor considered in other manufacturing environments is the prediction and optimisation of product variability and discard rates. Fabric reinforcements are variable in geometry; for example, tow spacing and orientations show a statistical distribution. This can lead to variable preform quality, ultimately increasing unit cost. Thus, understanding and predicting the effects of variability on the final part should allow variability to be controlled (see also Chapter 9). Variation in inter-tow angles for a nominally ±45° NCF, taken directly from the roll, i.e. before draping, has been measured (Endruweit et al., 2004; Yu et al., 2005a). Tow angles were found to adhere closely to a normal distribution, with a standard deviation of 5.6°. Long et al. (2005) presented a simple technique, using the Monte Carlo method, to incorporate the NCF fibre angle variability into the energy-based kinematic model. Predictions showed how this initial fabric variability could produce significant variation in the code’s fibre angle draping predictions. Clearly this variability can subsequently affect further processing behaviour, such as infusion (see Chapters 8 to 10) and ultimately will influence the final mechanical properties of the formed component (see Chapters 11, 14 and 16).
7.5
Finite element modelling of forming for NCFs
FE analysis of the forming of biaxial engineering fabrics is relatively young (e.g. Boisse et al., 1997) compared to the kinematic approach (e.g. Mack and Taylor, 1956). Having said this, intense effort over the past decade or so has resulted in an
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
157
extensive body of work in this area. However, despite the large volume of work on woven fabrics, so far relatively little attention has been paid specifically to modelling the forming of NCFs using the FE approach. Notable exceptions include the work of Yu et al. (2005a; 2005b), Creech et al. (2003) and Creech and Pickett (2006) and Thije et al. (2003; 2005a; 2005b; 2007). Both Yu et al. (2005a; 2005b) and Creech and Pickett (2006) employed an explicit rather than an implicit FE numerical technique (Abaqus Explicit™ and PAM-CRASH™) when modelling the forming of the NCF sheet over tooling, due to its suitability in analysing problems with complex and changing contact conditions (see also Chapter 16). When modelling woven fabrics, both continuous and discrete modelling approaches, or a combination of these two, can be found in the literature. The same is true for modelling of NCFs; both Yu el al. (2005b) and Thije et al. (2005a; 2005b; 2007) adopted continuum approaches with twodimensional models implemented in structural membrane and/or shell elements, while Creech et al. (2003) and Creech and Pickett (2006) used a mixed, semidiscrete approach, incorporating solid elements to model individual tows and bar elements to represent the stitching.
7.5.1 Modelling asymmetric shear behaviour The constitutive model of Yu et al. (2005b) originally developed for woven fabrics, consists of two parts: contributions from fibre directional properties and shear properties. To model the stress and strain relationship dependent on the fibre directional properties, a non-orthogonal equation was developed in an explicit mathematical form using a homogenisation method taking into account the fabric architecture and yarn stiffness (Yu et al., 2002). The shear component of the equation was developed using a covariant analysis of the traction vector acting along the side of a biaxial fabric undergoing PF-type deformation. This resulted in an equation relating the in-plane shear stress in the NCF sheet to the shear force measured by PF tests on the same material. Thus, by fitting a polynomial function to the measured PF shear test result, a convenient method of determining the shear parameters of the model directly from test results was devised. The only change in the original model required in accommodating the asymmetric response of the NCF, rather than the symmetric response of a woven fabric, was to include different polynomial functions according to the direction of shearing of the NCF (with respect to the orientation of the stitch pattern). The approach also allows simple incorporation of the shear force versus shear angle predictions discussed in Section 7.4.2, rather than using PF test data to produce shear input data for the model, resulting in a fully predictive approach (Harrison et al., 2004a). Thije et al. (2003; 2005a; 2005b) originally used a viscous constitutive model, based on the ideal fibre-reinforced fluid model proposed by Spencer (2000) to model NCFs. In later work they implemented a hyperelastic constitutive equation and applied this to model NCFs (Thije et al., 2007). Both these models are
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
158
Non-crimp fabric composites
symmetric in their shear response; thus, in order to model the asymmetric behaviour, the contribution to the total stress in the material due to the stitching was calculated using a vector representation for the stitch. Strains in the stitch were calculated via multiplication of the stitch vector by the deformation gradient tensor. Tensile stress–strain data for the stitching allowed conversion of strain to stress. This simple approach provided the stress contribution from stretching of the stitch and consequently an asymmetric shear response in the shear force versus shear angle curve during the simulation. However, the method neglects any contribution from inter-stitch friction, which, according to Fig. 7.6, is probably significant. Other model parameters accounting for trellis shear resistance due to compaction and rotation of the tows were determined via experimental testing. Finally, the approach adopted by Creech and Picket (2006) is based on the actual meso-scale architecture of the NCF, resulting in a geometrically more complicated but more realistic model than those adopted by Yu et al. (2005b) and Thije et al. (2003; 2005a; 2005b; 2007) (see also Chapter 16). A consequence is FE models with large degrees of freedom, e.g. 120 000 solid and 70 000 bar elements, and therefore much larger computation times. The two sets of tows within the fabric were modelled by two layers of solid elements divided into discrete rows and the stitch was modelled using bar elements, see Figure 7.9 (from Creech and Pickett, 2006). Thus, the model represents a special case in which the stitch positioning results in discrete tows within the fabric (in practice the more general situation is that the stitching tends to pierce tows resulting in so called ‘fish-eye’ openings in the fabric rather than discrete and continuous tows, see Chapter 6 for more details on the NCF’s internal geometry). They used a bi-phase material model for the solid tow elements (PAM-CRASH, 2000), fitting the transverse compression properties using PF test data, though the constant stiffness parameter in the bi-phase model resulted in problems with the fitting. The stitch properties were determined through PF tests using an analytical expression for the strain versus fabric shear angle, see Eqs 7.2–7.4 in Section 7.6. The approach assumed that most of the shear force produced by the NCF at low shear angles was due to the stitch contribution, an assumption confirmed in Fig. 7.6. Connector elements were used to model friction between tow and stitch (solid elements and bar elements), though here again inter-stitch friction was ignored.
7.9 A ‘representative cell’ of the meso-mechanical model for non-crimp fabric (from Creech and Pickett, 2006).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
159
7.5.2 Modelling of intra-ply slip The approach of Yu et al. (2005a; 2005b) while being fully predictive and relatively simple, prohibits prediction of any of the intra-ply slip mechanisms that can occur in NCFs. In contrast, the work of Thije et al. (2003; 2005a; 2005b; 2007) involves a method of modelling tow slip along the axial direction of the tow (see Fig. 7.10). To do this, they added additional layers and degrees of freedom to a membrane element, effectively creating a multi-layer element (Thije, 2005b). A similar methodology has also been used by the same group to model multi-layer forming of woven fabrics (Thije et al. 2009). The method provides a computationally efficient approach to calculating the contribution to the total stress due to tow slip along the tow directions (as opposed to crossover slip). However, predictions of the magnitude of the cumulative tow slip in their forming simulations have yet to be published. The model proposed by Creech and Pickett (2006) offers an intuitive but computationally more expensive way of determining intra-ply slip. In this case, both tow slip along the tow longitudinal directions and lateral crossover slip can be predicted. Both methods adopted by Thije et al. (2005a; 2005b) and Creech and Pickett (2006) require tow pull-out characterisation tests to determine the value of the tow/stitch friction coefficient (Kong et al., 2004).
7.10 Slip of the tows through the stitches in their axial direction (from Thije et al., 2005).
7.5.3 Modelling of out-of-plane bending stiffness The out-of-plane bending stiffness of engineering fabrics is partly responsible for the wrinkling behaviour during forming. Two-dimensional constitutive models are suitable for implementation in either membrane or shell elements. Membrane elements only allow calculation of in-plane stresses and assume zero out-of-plane bending stiffness, an assumption which can possibly overestimate the tendency of
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
160
Non-crimp fabric composites
the fabric to wrinkle during forming. Thin shell elements treat the material as a continuum of small but finite thickness and automatically determine the associated out-of-plane bending stiffness from the elements in-plane properties. For engineering fabrics, which in practice do not behave as a continuum, the usual shell element formulation can lead to an unrealistically high out-of-plane bending stiffness and therefore lead to under-predictions of the wrinkling behaviour of the sheet. Yu el al. (2005c) presented a method of decoupling the in-plane and out-ofplane properties for shell elements, permitting more accurate modelling of the fabric’s wrinkling behaviour. In contrast, the method adopted by Creech et al. (2006), which involved the use of solid elements to represent the tows, meant the axial stiffness of the fabric had to be significantly decreased from its actual value in order to match the bending properties of the fabric with experiments. However, the stiffness still remained high enough to prevent significant stretching along the fibre directions during forming simulations. Thije et al. (2003; 2005a; 2005b; 2007; 2009) used a membrane element formulation for their simulations, neglecting any effect of out-of-plane bending stiffness.
7.5.4 Modelling the effect of the blank-holder The effect of increasing the blank-holder pressure in forming experiments was discussed in Section 7.4.3; increasing pressure tends to reduce the asymmetry of the draped fibre pattern for NCFs (Long et al., 2005; Lee et al., 2007). A suitable choice of friction coefficient between the NCF and tooling allows the effects of blank-holder pressure to be studied conveniently in FE simulations. Various doubly curved male tool geometries have been used to explore this effect. In Yu et al. (2005b), the effect of the blank-holder force on the forming behaviour over a hemisphere was investigated. Figure 7.11 shows how the asymmetry of the fabric drape pattern changes as the force on the blank-holder increases from 0 N to 5000 N. As with the kinematic energy-based simulations described in Section 7.4, the increase in the blank-holder force resulted in greater symmetry of the draped fibre pattern. Thije et al. (2005) similarly showed how introducing friction at the boundary reduced asymmetry when forming over a topped cone geometry.
7.5.5 Modelling statistical variation of the manufacture process In Section 7.4.4 an attempt to model the natural statistical variation in fibre angle of NCFs ‘off the roll’, using the energy-based kinematic method was described. A tentative first step to introduce the same variability into FE simulations was presented in Yu et al. (2005a). Though, as acknowledged by the authors, the method of randomly assigning fibre shear angles to elements meant that the fibre path was not preserved between adjacent elements, resulting in spurious stress predictions. In his PhD thesis, Wiggers (2007) describes a more consistent way of
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
161
7.11 Effect of BHF on the formed shapes (from Yu et al., 2005).
generating a full-field variable fibre angle distribution for introduction into FE models, in future this variability could be incorporated into FE simulations.
7.6
Future trends
Optimisation algorithms have already been employed to explore the manufacturing design space associated with forming woven fabrics, such as blank-holder pressure and pressure distribution (Long et al., 2006). This approach involved the use of a simple and efficient forming code to narrow the design space using a genetic algorithm, followed by the use of a more accurate but computationally
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
162
Non-crimp fabric composites
slower model in the final stages of optimisation. It is easy to see how a similar strategy could be adopted in optimising the forming of NCFs; with energy-based kinematic (e.g. Long et al. 2005) and continuum models (e.g. Yu et al. 2005b; Thije et al. 2007) performing the initial search while more detailed but computationally expensive models (e.g. Creech and Pickett, 2006) are employed in the final stages; providing detailed predictions of potential defects such as those described in Chapter 19. This approach will become ever more attractive as computational power continues to increase and textile-specific solid modelling software becomes more widely available for NCFs (e.g. TexGen; WiseTex). Further efforts to incorporate variability into simulations (see Sections 7.4.4 and 7.5.4), producing probabilistic rather than definitive predictions (Long et al., 2005; Yu et al., 2005a) and the consequent impact of this variability on final composite properties (Potter et al., 2008) is also a likely future development. Also, replacing time-consuming characterisation tests, such as those described in Chapter 6, using a multi-scale modelling strategy is a key issue. Once again, increases in computational power mean that numerical models at the micro-scale will become more feasible (Durville, 2008) eventually replacing less accurate analytical models (Cai and Gutowski, 1992; McBride 1997).
7.7
Further information and advice
Due to space limitations, only the constitutive models that have been directly applied to modelling NCFs have been reviewed. Several other models developed for woven fabrics have been proposed, which could potentially be adapted in modelling NCFs (e.g. Aimene et al., 2008; 2010; Xue et al., 2003; Lee et al., 2008; Peng et al., 2010). Also, another consideration when modelling the forming of biaxial fabrics that has been discussed in the literature, but not in this chapter, is the numerical problem of element locking that can occur when the fibre directions of the fabric are not aligned with the mesh (Yu et al., 2006; Thije and Akkerman 2008; 2009). Such locking can produce spurious results in FE simulations if the user is unaware of the problem.
7.8
References
Aimene, Y, Hagege, B, Sidoroff, F, Vidal-Sallé, E, Boisse, P and Dridi, S, 2008, Hyperelastic Approach for Composite Reinforcement Forming Simulations. International Journal of Material Forming, 1: 811–814. Aimene, Y, Vidal-Sallé, Hagege, B, Sidoroff, F and Boisse, P, 2010, A hyperelastic approach for composite reinforcement large deformation analysis. J. Comp. Mat., 44, 1, 5–22. Boisse, P, Borr, M, Buet, K, Cherouat, A, 1997, Finite element simulation of textile composite forming including the biaxial fabric behaviour. Compos Part B-Eng; 28B: 453–64. Cai Z and Gutowski, T, 1992, The 3D Deformation Behaviour of a Lubricated Fiber Bundle, Journal of Composite Materials, 26, 8, 1207–1237.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
163
Creech G, Pickett AK, Greve L, 2003, Finite element modelling of non crimp fabrics for draping simulation. Sixth International ESAFORM Conference on Material Forming. Salerno, Italy, 863–66. Creech G and Pickett AK, 2006, Meso-modelling of Non-Crimp Fabric composites for coupled drape and failure analysis, J Mater Sci, 41, 6725–6736. Durville, D, 2008, A finite element approach of the behaviour of woven materials at the microscopic scale. Eleventh Euromech-Mecamat conference Mechanics of microstructured solids: cellular materials, fiber reinforced solids and soft tissues, Torino, Italy. Endruweit, A Long, AC Robitaille, F Rudd, CD, 2004, Dependence of permeability variations on the textile structure, Proceedings of the eleventh European Conference on Composite Materials, Rhodes, Greece. Hancock, SG and KD Potter, 2006a, The use of kinematic drape modelling to inform the hand lay-up of complex composite components using woven reinforcements, Composites Part A, 37, 413–422. Hancock, SG and Potter, KD, 2006b, Implementation and applications of virtual fabric placement in forming fabric reinforcement for production of complex shaped components. Eighth International Conference on Textile Composites, Nottingham, UK. Harrison, P, Wiggers, J, Long, AC and Rudd, CD, 2003, A constitutive model based on meso and micro kinematics for woven and stitched dry fabrics. Fourteenth International Conference on Composite Materials, 14–18 July, San Diego, California, USA. Harrison, P, Yu, WR, Wiggers, J and Long, AC, 2004a, Finite Element Simulation of Fabric Forming, Incorporating Predicitons of a Meso-Mechanical Energy Model. Seventh International ESAFORM Conference on Materials Forming, 28–30 April, Trondheim, Norway. Kong, H, Mouritz, AP and Paton R, 2004, Tensile extension properties and deformation mechanisms of multiaxial non-crimp fabrics. Comp Struc, 66, 1–4, 249–259. Lee, JS, Hong, SJ, Yu, WR and Kang, TJ, 2007, The effect of blank-holder force on the stamp forming behaviour of non-crimp fabric with chain stitch. Comp. Sci. Tech., 67, 357–366. Lee, W, Cao, J, Badel, P and Boisse, P, 2008, Non-orthogonal constitutive model for woven composites incorporating tensile effect on shear behaviour. Int J Mater Form Suppl, 1, 891–894. Lin, H, Wang, J, Long, AC, Clifford, MJ and Harrison, P, 2007, Predictive modelling for optimization of textile composite forming. Composites Science and Technology, 67, 15–16, 3242–3252. Long, AC and Rudd CD, 1994, A simulation of reinforcement deformation during the production of preform for liquid moulding processes. International Mechanical Journal of Engineering and Manufacturing, 208, 269–278. Long, AC, An iterative draping simulation based on fabric mechanics, 2001. Proceedings of the fourth ESAFORM Conference on Materials Forming, Liège, Belgium. Long, AC, Souter, BJ, Robitaille, F and Rudd, CD, 2002, Effects of fibre architecture on reinforcement fabric deformation. Plastics Rubber & Composites, 31, 87–97. Long, AC, Wiggers, J and Harrison, P, 2005, Modelling the effects of blank-holder pressure and material variability on forming of textile preforms. Ninth International ESAFORM Conference on Material Forming, 2, 939–942, April, 27–29 April, Cluj-Napoca, Romania. Long, AC, Skordos, A, Harrison, P, Clifford, M and Sutcliffe, M, 2006, Optimisation of Sheet Forming for Textile Composites Using Variable Peripheral Pressure. Society for the Advancement of Material and Process Engineering (SAMPE), 27–29 March, Paris, France.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
164
Non-crimp fabric composites
Mack, C, Taylor, HM, 1956, The fitting of woven cloth to surfaces. J Textile Inst, 47(8), 477. McBride, TM, 1997, The Large Deformation Behaviour of Woven fabric Microstructural Evolution in Formed Textile Composites. PhD Thesis, Boston University College of Engineering. PAM-CRASH Theory Manual, 2000, ESI Group. Peng, XQ, Guo, ZY, Rehmen, ZU and Harrison, P, 2010, A Simple Anisotropic Fibre Reinforced Hyperelastic Constitutive Model for Woven Composite Fabrics. Thirteenth International ESAFORM Conference on Materials Forming, 7–9 April, Brescia, Italy. Potter, KD, Khan, B, Wisnom, MR, Bell, T and Stevens, J, 2008, Variability, fibre waviness and misalignment in the determination of the properties of composite materials and structures. Composites: Part A, 39, 9, 1343–1354. Souter, BJ, 2001, Effects of Fibre Architecture on Formability of Textile Preforms, PhD Thesis, University of Nottingham. Spencer, AJM, 2000, Theory of fabric-reinforced viscous fluids. Composites: Part A, 31, 1311–1321. ten Thije, RHW, Loendersloot, R and Akkerman, R, 2003, Material characterisation for finite element simulations of draping with non-crimp fabrics. Sixth ESAFORM conference on Materials Forming, Salerno, Italy, 859–862. ten Thije, RHW, Loendersloot, R and Akkerman, R, 2005, Drape simulation of non-crimp fabrics. Eighth ESAFORM conference on Materials Forming, Cluc Napoca Romania, 991–994. ten Thije, RHW and Akkerman, R, 2005, Finite element simulation of draping with noncrimp fabrics. Fifteenth International Conference on Composite Materials, Durban, South Africa (CD-ROM). ten Thije, RHW, Akkerman, R and Huétink, J, 2007, Large deformation simulation of anisotropic material using an updated Lagrangian finite element method, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 196, 33 34, 3141–3150. ten Thije, RHW and Akkerman, R, 2009, A multi-layer triangular membrane finite element for the forming simulation of laminated composites. Composites Part A, 40, 6–7, July, 739–753. ten Thije, RHW and Akkerman, R, 2008, Solutions to intra-ply shear locking in finite element analyses of fibre reinforced materials. Composites Part A, 39, 7, 1167–1176. TexGen 2008 http://texgen.sourceforge.net/index.php/Main_Page (accessed 23 February, 2010). Vanclooster, K, Lomov, SV, Verpoest, I, 2009, Experimental validation of forming simulations of fabric reinforced polymers using an unsymmetrical mould configuration. Composites: Part A, 40, 530–539. Van Der Ween, F, 1991, Algorithms For Draping Fabrics on Double-Curved Surfaces. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 31, 1415–1426. Wiggers, J, Long, AC, Harrison, P and Rudd, CD, 2003, The Effects of Stitch Architecture on the Shear Compliance of Non-Crimp Fabrics. Sixth International ESAFORM Conference on Materials Forming Symposium on Composite Forming Processes, 28–30 April, Salerno, Italy. Wiggers, J., Analysis of Textile Deformation during Preforming for Liquid Composite Moulding. PhD thesis, University of Nottingham, 2007. WiseTex http://www.mtm.kuleuven.be/Research/C2/poly/software.html (accessed 23 February, 2010).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Modelling the deformability of biaxial non-crimp fabric
165
Xue, P, Peng, XQ and Cao, J, 2003, A non-orthogonal constitutive model for characterizing woven composite. Composites Part A, 34, 2,183–93. Yu, WR, Pourboghrat F, Chung, K, Zampaloni, M. and Kang, TJ, 2002 Non-orthogonal Constitutive Equation for Woven Fabric Reinforced Thermoplastic Composites, Composites Part A, 33, 8, 1095–1105. Yu, WR, Harrison, P and Long, AC, 2005a, Finite Element Forming Simulation of NCF Considering Natural Fibre Variability. Eighth International ESAFORM Conference on Materials Forming, 27–29 April, Cluj-Napoca, Romania. Yu W.R., Harrison P. and Long A.C. 2005b, Finite Element Forming Simulation for Noncrimp Fabrics using a Non-Orthogonal Constitutive Equation, Composites Part A, 36, 1079–1093. Yu, WR, Zampaloni M, Pourboghrat, F, Chung K and Kang TJ, 2005c Analysis of flexible bending behavior of woven preform using non-orthogonal constitutive equation, Composites Part A, 36, 6, 839–850. Yu, X, Cartwright, B, McGuckin, D, Ye, L and Mai, YW, 2006, Intraply shear locking in finite element analysis of woven fabric forming processes. Composites Part A, 37, 790.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
8 Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms R. LOENDERSLOOT, University of Twente, The Netherlands Abstract: Experimental permeability data of non-crimp fabrics (NCFs) is discussed in this chapter. The chapter starts with a general introduction on permeability, followed by a discussion on experimental permeability data. The influence of geometrical features of the textile architecture, in particular the stitching, is discussed in the third section, whereas the relation between fabric deformation and permeability is addressed in the fourth section. Two types of deformation can be distinguished: compression and in-plane shear. Both are addressed in this section. The chapter ends with concluding remarks, including comments regarding the benchmark project recently initiated and some future developments. Key words: permeability, experiments, textile geometry, compression, shear deformation.
8.1
Introduction
The permeability of a porous medium has been defined by Darcy (1856) as ‘the easiness with which a fluid, subject to a macroscopic pressure gradient, flows inside a porous medium’. Strictly speaking, the permeability only depends on the geometric characteristics of a given porous medium. It is a property of significant importance in the field of composite material processing technologies of the family of liquid composite moulding (LCM) processes, such as resin transfer moulding (RTM), vacuum-assisted resin transfer moulding (VARTM), liquid resin infusion (LRI), resin film infusion (RFI) and resin infusion under flexible tooling (RIFT). Knowledge of the permeability of a fibre reinforcement does not only allow estimation of the processing time, but also evaluation of the success rate or robustness of the process. Hence, a better quality control is achieved, which is crucial in manufacturing structural, load-bearing parts in, for example, aircraft applications. Such parts generally have a high fibre content and often also a complex geometry. Simulations are desirable to assess the robustness and quality of the injection or infusion process designed for this type of application, whilst avoiding costly experimental programmes. Therefore, detailed knowledge on the permeability of textile reinforcements is of utmost relevance. The permeability of textile reinforcements has been investigated by a large number of researchers. Research activities range from theoretical and numerical studies to experimental studies, using different methods and different measuring techniques. Despite a considerable history of research, a standardised measurement has not yet been established. A key factor is the large variation found in the results, which is also addressed in Chapter 9. Clearly, measuring the permeability of a 166 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
167
textile reinforcement is not at all trivial. The discussion in this chapter is – in line with the topic of the book – limited to measurements of non-crimp fabric (NCFs). However, the reader should be aware of the fact that the topics addressed also partly apply to measuring the permeability of textile reinforcements in general. The results presented in the literature (see Section 8.2 for more details) show large deviations. Differences in measured permeability can be as large as an order of magnitude. Moreover, a significant amount of scatter is generally observed. The source of these differences can be attributed to a number of reasons, which are becoming more and more accepted. • • •
The permeability experiment is sensitive to precise conditions. The method of measuring can affect the results. The internal geometry of textile reinforcements has a certain degree of variability, directly affecting the fluid flow in the material.
It is beyond the scope of this book to discuss these topics in detail. The focus will remain on the experimental results obtained for NCF, rather than an elaborate discussion on the origin of deviations caused by the measuring technology applied. However, it is accepted that this type of deviation exists and hence it is considered as important to mention the methods applied, even without the formulation of a judgement. An exception is the last point, concerning the internal geometry of the fabric. The internal geometry of NCF is discussed in detail in Part II of this book. The effects on the permeability of the internal geometry, including fabric deformation (see also Part I), is addressed here. Research over the past few years has established a theoretical foundation for the concept that the variability in the internal geometry is one of the main factors in the scatter observed in the permeability (Bechtold and Ye, 2003; Chen and Papathanasiou, 2008; Endruweit et al., 2006a, 2006b; Frishfelds et al., 2003; Hoes, 2002; Hoes et al., 2004; Loendersloot, 2006; Loendersloot et al., 2006; Lundström et al., 2000b, 2004, 2010; Nordlund, 2006; Nordlund et al., 2006). Here, the focus is on the identification based on observations from experiments, whereas the link to modelling strategies is discussed in Chapter 9. Relevant sources of permeability data are found in the results of the fifth Framework EU research programme FAiLure, performance and processing prediction for enhanced design with non-crimp fabric COMposites – GRD12001-40184 (FALCOM), the TECABS Brite Euram project and measurements performed by the author in an EU-funded Marie Curie Fellowship programme (HPMT-CT-2000-0030) at the Katholieke Universiteit (KU) Leuven. These results are supplemented with results obtained in the permeability benchmark project, initiated by S.V. Lomov (KU Leuven) and B. Laine (ONERA) at the seventh FPCM conference, organised at the École des Mines de Douai, France 2006. Other results found in the literature are added to the list of results, providing an overview as complete as possible of experimental permeability data.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
168
Non-crimp fabric composites
8.2
Experimental permeability results
Various methods are available to measure the permeability of a textile reinforcement. A concise discussion on these methods is presented to better understand the results obtained and reported in the literature. Secondly, an overview is presented of the results found in the literature.
8.2.1 Measuring technologies The internal geometry of an NCF has to be described at multiple scales, see Figure 8.1, in order to fully capture its deformability (as discussed in Part I) and also to model its permeability (as will be discussed in Chapter 10). Three levels are distinguished: the scale of the preform (macro: 10−1–100 m), the scale of the bundles and stitches (meso: 10−3–10−2 m) and the scale of the fibre filaments (micro: 10−5 m). However, it is extremely difficult, if not impossible, to quantify the effects of multiple length scales in permeability experiments. The only practical solution appears to be to measure the permeability at a macro scale (preform scale) under various conditions and attempt to explain the global observations with model predictions based on multi-scale models. The theory applied to calculate a permeability value from experimental data is based on Darcy’s law: [8.1] with v the fluid velocity vector, K the permeability tensor, µ the dynamic viscosity of the fluid and ∇P the pressure gradient vector. This could be considered as a homogenised relation. The permeability tensor K contains the orthogonal components
8.1 Schematic representation of a non-crimp fabric. The geometry of a non-crimp fabric can be assessed at three different length scales: the preform scale (macro: 10−1–100m), the scale of the bundles and stitches (meso: 10−3–10−2m) and the fibre filament scale (micro: 10−5m). This meso level representation does not correspond to non-crimp fabrics of later date, which possess more homogeneously spread plies of fibres, rather than individual fibre bundles in each ply (meso scale image courtesy of R.H.W. ten Thije).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
169
of the macroscopic permeability. The meso- and microscopic effects are not directly captured by this value, but may appear by variations in the macroscopic permeability depending on the measuring conditions. The permeability measured can therefore appear to be dependent on more than the geometry only (Kim and Daniel, 2007). Various measuring technologies have been developed. Initially, only the in-plane permeability of fabrics (K1, K2) was investigated, since only plate-like structures were manufactured using LCM production technologies. Recent developments in structural, load-bearing aircraft components have raised the need for a complete characterisation of the permeability tensor. The difficulties involved in measuring a three-dimensional (3D) permeability in a single measurement are in general avoided by measuring the in-plane and out-of-plane or transverse permeability K3 separately, although a few references are available (Ahn et al., 1995; Saouab et al., 2001; Stöven et al., 2003) on measuring the 3D permeability tensor. Stöven et al. (2003) performed 3D measurements on NCFs, which are presented in this chapter. A brief discussion on measuring conditions is considered appropriate, prior to a more detailed discussion on the experimental results of the permeability measurements. First of all, a distinction is made between pressure-driven and flow-driven measurements. Injection of the fluid at a constant pressure can lead to high fluid flows in the first moments of the measurement, potentially resulting in problems such as fibre-wash and other instabilities. A constant flow rate requires a more complex control and different flow regimes can occur (hydrostatic or capillary pressure driven flows) due to the large difference in pressure gradient during the process. A steady state is obtained as the textile is fully wetted (Bréard et al., 2003). A more stable flow and higher reproducibility is obtained compared to transient permeability measurements. However, the saturated permeability cannot be measured by all injection strategies and, moreover, is most likely an inadequate estimate for the unsaturated permeability. Two variants of in-plane permeability measurements exist: line-injection and central injection, both conceptually shown in Fig. 8.2a and b. The theory to extract permeabilities from the measured quantities such as the flow-front position, pressure gradient and/or volumetric flow, is beyond the scope of this book. The reader is referred to other literature for theory and comparison of both technologies (Ferland et al., 1996; Han et al., 2000; Heardman et al., 2004; Lekakou et al., 1996; Lundström et al., 1999, 2002; Wang et al., 1994; Weitzenböck et al., 1999a, 1999b). The main characteristics of the measuring methods are listed in Table 8.1. The parallel injection strategy (Lundström et al., 1999) is also included in Table 8.1. A limited number of measuring devices for transverse permeability is developed (Drapier et al., 2002; Scholz et al., 2007; Van de Ven et al., 2006; see Figure 8.2c). The characteristics are listed in Table 8.1). In most cases, the saturated permeability is measured, although Drapier et al. (2005) reports on unsaturated transverse permeability measurements.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
170
Non-crimp fabric composites
8.2 Typical line, radial and transverse permeability measuring equipment. (a) Line injection set-up. Dashed lines indicate the upper mould half. The upper mould can either be rigid (RTM) or flexible (RFI, VARI, RIFT). (b) Radial injection set-up. Dashed lines indicate the upper mould half. The upper mould can either be rigid (RTM) or flexible (RFI, VARI, RIFT). (c) Cross-section of a transverse permeability measuring device. The preform is compressed between a honeycomb (or similar) construction. Generally, tube-shaped devices are employed.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
171
8.2.2 Measured permeabilities The earliest experimental permeability data on NCF date from the beginning of the 1990s (Gebart, 1992; Parnas et al., 1995; Steenkamer et al., 1995). Over the years, large differences are observed, which are partly attributed to differences in material and partly to evolutions in the measuring technology. The latter is also a result of an increasing understanding of the process parameters governing the flow through porous media, leading to a higher quality of measurements. However, there has also been a development in the fabric material itself, affecting the permeability. Early results generally refer to fabrics with a more distinct separation between individual bundles in each ply, which are stitched together to obtain their structural integrity. These fabrics are often referred to as ‘engineered fabrics’. NCFs of a later date tend to possess more evenly, and consequently more densely spread fibre plies, in which the distinction between individual fibre bundles has nearly vanished. The New Concept 2 (NC2) NCF (Drapier et al., 2002) manufactured by Hexcel is the latest example of the manufacturer’s attempts to increase the homogeneity of the individual fibre plies of the fabric (see also Chapter 2.4).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Prone to race tracking Single measurement required for full in-plane permeability tensor
Yes
Yes
Prone to race tracking
Multiple measurements required for full in-plane permeability tensor
Constant pressure
Constant flow rate
Robustness
Limited number of data points required ∼300 mm
Limited number of data points required
∼300 mm
Typical flow length
Visual flow front tracking possible
Visual flow front tracking possible
Data acquisition
More complex mould design required
Mould requirements low
Experimental complexity
Low
Low
Mathematical complexity
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Saturated
Yes
Yes
Parallel injection
Unsaturated
Linear injection
∼200 mm
Higher number of data points required
Visual flow front tracking possible
More complex mould design due to clamping requirements
High
Potentially high mould deflections Single measurement required for full in-plane permeability tensor Allows measurements on sheared fabrics
Sensitivity for preform inaccuracies in the centre
Seldom
Yes
No
Yes
Radial injection
More complex mould design to allow fabric compression without introducing flow obstruction
Low
Potential absence of stable flow regime due to low flow length
Yes
Yes
Yes
Very limited
Transverse injection
∼200 mm (in-plane) ∼10 mm (transverse)
∼5–10 mm
Higher number of data Limited number of data points required points required
Limited visual flow Difficult flow front tracking front tracking possible
High
Single measurements required for full 3D permeability tensor
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Three-dimensional
Table 8.1 Overview of general properties, advantages and disadvantages of permeability measuring technologies
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
173
Another difference between the experimental results reported is the test fluid used. Micro-level flow phenomenon can be reflected in a different macroscopic permeability and explain differences in measured permeabilities. According to Luo et al. (2001), the effect is not significant compared to the experimental scatter. The combination of fibre sizing and test fluid is reported to have a more pronounced affect on the wetting permeability according to Sharma et al. (2009). A graphical overview of the permeabilities measured is found in Fig. 8.3. A distinction is made between the in-plane permeability of carbon and glass fibre fabrics (Fig. 8.3a and 8.3b, respectively) and the transverse permeability (all
8.3 Measured permeabilities. The labels refer to the fabrics listed in Tables 8.2–8.6. UT: University of Twente; NLR: National Aerospace Laboratories; CLS: Clausthal; CTS: Center of Structures Technologies; UoN: University of Nottingham; SiComp: Swedish Institute of Composites. (a) In-plane permeability of carbon fibre non-crimp fabrics. Note that fabrics B3 and B4 were measured by a number of institutes and that T1 and B3 comprises a series of different variants of the same fabrics. (Continued)
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
174
Non-crimp fabric composites
(b) In-plane permeability of glass fibre non-crimp fabrics. (c) Transverse permeability of carbon and glass (B7 and T2 only) fibre non-crimp fabrics.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
175
carbon fibre, except the biaxial fabric B7 and the triaxial fabric T2). The markers in the graphs indicate the type of measuring technology applied. Filled markers refer to saturated permeabilities, whereas the open markers refer to unsaturated permeabilities. The error bars are either based on the variability provided by the authors of the articles from which the data are extracted, or calculated from the data set available. No information on the variability is available for the data points without error bars. Moreover, the variability is only calculated if three or more permeabilities were available. The fabrics can be identified by the code (U = uniaxial, B = biaxial, T = triaxial, Q = quadriaxial, M = multiaxial, the subscript is the fabric number) and can be traced back in the Tables 8.2 to 8.6, which also include references to the articles from which the data are extracted. The variability is calculated assuming a lognormal distribution of the permeabilities measured. This assumption is based on the observations on the dimensions of the stitched induced distortions in the internal geometry (Loendersloot, 2006), which also exhibit a lognormal distribution. Another motivation is that the lower limit of the variability is unlikely low if a normal distribution is assumed. The upper and lower bounds s+ and s− of the variability are calculated as:
[8.2]
with:
[8.3]
and t0.95(N−1) the Student-t-distribution with N−1 degrees of freedom and a 95% – significance level, N the number of permeabilities measured Ki, and K the mean permeability. The subscript ln indicates the value is calculated in the logarithmic space. Note that the value of a Student-t-distribution with 2 degrees of freedom (three measurements) equals approximately 4.3. The scatter can therefore be quite large, given the low number of measurements that is generally performed. A number of observations can be made from the graphs. The most obvious one is the huge differences between seemingly similar fabrics. The lowest permeabilities for the carbon fibre NCFs are approximately 2–3·10−11 m2, whereas the highest values are approximately 1–3·10−9 m2. The most striking point of this observation
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
U3
Ahlstrom R12-256
Ahlstrom R12-256
Ahlstrom R12-256
Ahlstrom R12-256
Ahlstrom R12-256
Ahlstrom R12-256
TechTextiles E-LPb
TechTextiles E-LPb
TechTextiles E-LPb
TechTextiles E-LPb
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Saertex 12K T700 600
U1
U2
Name
ID
—
—
—
—
0.266
0.266
0.266
0.266
0.266
0.266
0.64
ρA [kg·m−2]
[0]
[0]
[0]
[0]
[0]
[0]
[0]
[0]
[0]
[0]
[90]
θ [°]
1.64E-10
1.24E-10
3.20E-10
2.89E-10
—
5.00E-11
—
1.10E-10
2.24E-10
8.25E-10
—
K1,unsat [m2]
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
4.80E-11
K1,sat [m2]
3.93E-11
3.29E-11
8.67E-11
6.15E-11
8.00E-12
—
2.00E-11
—
3.50E-11
1.10E-10
—
K2,unsat [m2]
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
2.10E-11
49.9
49.9
44.3
44.3
55
59
48
52
45
35
60
K2,sat [m2] Vf [%]
1
1
1
1
17
15
17
15
13
10
5
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
N [-] Method
Table 8.2 Basic characteristics of uniaxial fabrics and characteristics and results of in-plane permeability experiments
Weitzenböck et al., 1999a
Weitzenböck et al., 1999a
Weitzenböck et al., 1999a
Weitzenböck et al., 1999a
Gebart, 1992
Gebart, 1992
Gebart, 1992
Gebart, 1992
Gebart, 1992
Gebart, 1992
Labordus, 2004
Reference
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
B3
B2
B1
ID
Saertex biaxial
Saertex biaxial
Devold biaxial
Devold biaxial
Devold biaxial
Devold biaxial
Devold biaxial
Devold biaxial
(2)
(3)
B(1)
B(2)
B(3)
B(4)
B(5)
B(6)
Saertex biaxial
(3)
Saertex biaxial
Saertex biaxial
(2)
(1)
Saertex biaxial
(1)
Name
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.329
0.329
0.329
0.322
0.322
0.322
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
ρA [kg·m−2] θ [°]
2.47E-11
3.48E-11
7.25E-11
5.18E-10
5.33E-10
9.01E-10
2.66E-09
5.10E-09
3.50E-09
2.18E-09
4.30E-09
3.90E-09
2.60E-11
2.02E-11
8.40E-11
9.24E-10
6.56E-10
2.74E-09
—
—
—
—
—
—
1.62E-11
2.93E-11
7.13E-11
—
—
—
6.00E-10
2.59E-09
3.10E-09
8.71E-10
2.53E-09
2.99E-09
K1,unsat [m2] K1,sat [m2] K2,unsat [m2]
1.65E-11
1.68E-11
8.81E-11
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
K2,sat [m2]
54.9
54.9
56.69
57.45
54.85
50.28
52.28
42.68
36.97
52.17
41.78
36.18
Vf [%]
0
0
0
0
0
0
45
30
0
45
30
0
γ [°]
7
7
7
4
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
N [-]
Parallel
Parallel
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Method
Table 8.3 Basic characteristics of biaxial carbon fibre fabrics and characteristics and results of in-plane permeability experiments
(Continued)
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Reference
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
B6
B4
ID
Hexcel NC2
Hexcel NC2
(3)
Saertex 6K T700 600
Hexcel NC2
G
(2)
Devold biaxial
H
(1)
Devold biaxial
S
Devold biaxial
Devold biaxial
M
Devold biaxial
Devold biaxial
L
G(2)
Devold biaxial
(1)
Devold biaxial
T
Devold biaxial
F2
F1
Name
Table 8.3 Continued.
0.64
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
0.534
[0/90]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
[45/−45]
ρA [kg·m−2] θ [°]
1.80E-11
8.93E-11
—
1.54E-11
9.86E-11
2.60E-11
9.73E-11
5.89E-11
1.01E-10
3.84E-11
6.63E-11
1.64E-10
3.72E-10
—
—
8.00E-11
—
1.15E-10
2.39E-11
9.09E-11
6.45E-11
1.06E-10
4.62E-11
7.19E-11
4.28E-11
3.82E-10
—
4.22E-11
—
6.35E-12
—
2.02E-11
—
6.19E-11
—
—
—
—
—
K1,unsat [m2] K1,sat [m2] K2,unsat [m2]
—
—
3.29E-11
—
—
1.92E-11
—
7.30E-11
—
—
—
—
—
K2,sat [m2]
60
48
50
50.8
56.69
54.8
56.69
56.69
56.69
56.69
56.69
60.34
50.28
Vf [%]
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
0
0
0
0
γ [°]
5
4
6
11
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
8
6
Linear
Radial
Radial
Linear
Linear
Parallel
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
N [-] Method
Labordus, 2004
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Reference
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
B13
B12
B11
NCS 82675
NCS 82675
NCS 81053
NCS 81053
NCS 81053
NCS 81053
NCS 81053
NCS 81053
NCS 81053
NCS 81053
NCS 81053
Ahlstrom
Ahlstrom
Ahlstrom
Ahlstrom
Ahlstrom
Ahlstrom
(2)
(3)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(1)
(2)
(3)
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.618
0.618
0.618
0.618
0.618
0.618
0.618
0.618
0.618
0.64
0.64
0.64
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
—
—
—
—
—
—
2.02E-10
2.22E-10
1.14E-10
1.18E-10
7.90E-11
5.43E-11
3.95E-10
6.91E-10
1.37E-10
1.09E-11
2.86E-11
4.93E-11
[45/−45] 2.19E-11
0.95
NCS 82675
FGE 106HD
B9
(1)
[45/−45] 1.51E-11
0.424
Cotech EBX 424
B8
B10
[45/−45] 2.10E-11
Saertex 0.616 V91025-00620
B7
2.09E-11
7.20E-11
1.65E-10
2.10E-11
7.66E-11
1.49E-10
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
3.36E-11
2.66E-11
3.90E-11
3.70E-11
4.34E-11
3.85E-11
1.97E-11
2.96E-11
6.71E-11
9.87E-12
2.17E-11
3.85E-11
1.84E-11
1.13E-11
2.10E-11
48.35
46.44
44.88
42.65
41.4
40
60
50
40
62
52
41
56
49
55
1.03E-11 60.3
2.43E-11 52.7
6.85E-11 46.9
1.95E-11 60.3
4.54E-11 52.7
1.41E-10 46.9
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
K1,unsat [m2] K1,sat [m2] K2,unsat [m2] K2,sat [m2] Vf [%]
Name
ID
ρA [kg·m−2] θ [°]
0
0
0
0
0
0
32
28
24
16
8
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
3
3
3
3
3
5
5
5
5
5
5
4
4
4
8
8
8
3
6
γ [°] N [-]
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
3D
Method
Lundström, 2000 (Continued)
Lundström, 2000
Lundström, 2000
Lundström, 2000
Lundström, 2000
Lundström, 2000
Hammani et al., 1996
Hammani et al., 1996
Hammani et al., 1996
Hammani et al., 1996
Hammani et al., 1996
Hammani et al., 1996
Hammani et al., 1996
Hammani et al., 1996
Hammani et al., 1996
Gauvin et al., 1996
Gauvin et al., 1996
Gauvin et al., 1996
Endruweit et al., 2006a
Endruweit and Ermanni, 2004
Stöven et al., 2003
Reference
Table 8.4 Basic characteristics of biaxial glass fibre fabrics and characteristics and results of in-plane permeability experiments
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
B20
Hexcel CD180 0.686
Hexcel CD180 0.686
Hexcel CD180 0.686
Hexcel DB170 0.595
Hexcel DB170 0.595
Hexcel DB170 0.595
Hexcel DB170 0.595
(3)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
—
—
(2)
ELT850
B18
B19
EBXhd396
B17
—
(1)
EBX936
Cofab-A1118B —
(2)
0.806
0.806
0.806
Cofab-A1118B —
Devold
(4)
Devold
Devold
(3)
0.806
0.806
(1)
Devold
(2)
6.95E-11
5.04E-11
4.32E-11
7.55E-11
9.74E-11
—
—
5.50E-09
4.15E-09
3.08E-09
—
[45/−45] 1.68E-09
[45/−45] 1.56E-09
[45/−45] 1.35E-09
[45/−45] 1.25E-09
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[45/−45] 5.52E-12
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
5.19E-11
9.97E-11
1.52E-09
1.22E-09
1.17E-09
9.00E-10
2.26E-09
1.54E-09
1.04E-09
1.48E-12
3.00E-12
5.42E-12
3.09E-11
1.82E-11
2.69E-11
5.23E-11
6.88E-11
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
37.6
43.9
51.2
58.6
42.2
50.6
57.3
55
55
55
49
49
57.2
52.5
52.5
3.46E-11 57.2
6.63E-11 52.5
K1,unsat [m2] K1,sat [m2] K2,unsat [m2] K2,sat [m2] Vf [%]
[45/−45] 6.54E-12
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
[0/90]
ρA [kg·m−2] θ [°]
(5)
Devold
(1)
Name
B16
B15
B14
ID
Table 8.4 Continued
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
6
6
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Linear
Radial
Radial
Radial
Parallel
Parallel
Parallel
γ [°] N [-] Method
Steenkamer et al., 1995
Steenkamer et al., 1995
Steenkamer et al., 1995
Steenkamer et al., 1995
Steenkamer et al., 1995
Steenkamer et al., 1995
Steenkamer et al., 1995
Lekakou et al., 2006
Lekakou et al., 2006
Lekakou et al., 2006
Wang et al., 1994
Wang et al., 1994
Lundström et al., 2000
Lundström et al., 2000
Lundström et al., 2000
Lundström et al., 2000
Lundström et al., 2000
Reference
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Q1
T1
ID
[45/90/−45]
[45/90/−45]
Devold Triaxial 0.801
Devold Triaxial 0.801
Devold Triaxial 0.801
Devold Triaxial 0.801
Devold Triaxial 0.801
F2
T
L
M
H
G(1) Devold Triaxial 0.801
G
B
Devold Quadriaxial
1.068
Devold Triaxial 0.801
[45/90/−45]
Devold Triaxial 0.801
F1
(2)
[45/90/−45]
B(3) Devold Triaxial 0.801
[45/0/−45/90]
[45/90/−45]
[45/90/−45]
[45/90/−45]
[45/90/−45]
[45/90/−45]
[45/90/−45]
Devold Triaxial 0.801
B
(2)
[45/90/−45]
ρA [kg·m−2] θ [°]
B(1) Devold Triaxial 0.801
Name
1.04E-10
1.60E-11
3.88E-11
9.62E-11
2.32E-11
1.88E-11
5.57E-11
2.12E-11
1.69E-10
1.74E-11
2.70E-11
6.07E-11
1.58E-10
1.72E-11
4.65E-11
1.14E-10
2.77E-11
2.50E-11
6.28E-11
3.81E-11
2.04E-10
1.66E-11
—
7.75E-11
K1,unsat [m2] K1,sat [m2]
1.43E-10
8.69E-12
7.83E-11
1.16E-10
2.79E-11
2.18E-11
3.19E-11
1.90E-11
2.92E-10
1.00E-11
1.83E-11
2.48E-11
K2,unsat [m2]
1.52E-10
9.36E-12
8.28E-11
1.25E-10
3.09E-11
2.46E-11
3.51E-11
2.46E-11
4.51E-10
1.18E-11
—
2.79E-11
56.57
54.7
56.57
56.57
56.57
56.57
56.57
60.74
50.28
54.6
56.25
56.57
3
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
4
5
5
5
Linear
Parallel
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Linear
Parallel
Radial
Linear
K2,sat [m2] Vf [%] N [-] Method
(Continued)
Loendersloot, 2006
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Thuis, 2003
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Loendersloot, 2006
Thuis, 2003
Reference
Table 8.5 Basic characteristics of triaxial (T), quadriaxial (Q) and multiaxial fabrics and characteristics and results of in-plane permeability experiments
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
M14−1
Q5
Q4
Q3
ID
DBLT1150E11-1 Liba Co
DBLT1150E11-1 Liba Co
DBLT1150E11-1 Liba Co
DBLT1150E11-1 Liba Co
DBLT1150E11-1 Liba Co
Ahlstrom
Ahlstrom
Ahlstrom
Technolglas
Technolglas
Technolglas
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(1)
(2)
(3)
Saertex 32047
DBLT1150E11-1 Liba Co
(1)
Name
Table 8.5 Continued
3.654
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
1.13
1.13
1.13
1.13
1.13
1.13
[45/−45/0/90/0/ −45/45]S
[0/45/−45/90]
[0/45/−45/90]
[0/45/−45/90]
[0/45/−45/90]
[0/45/−45/90]
[0/45/−45/90]
[0/45/−45/90]
[0/45/−45/90]
[0/45/90/−45]
[45/0/−45/90]
[45/0/−45/90]
[45/0/−45/90]
ρA [kg·m−2] θ [°]
2.20E-11
—
—
1.56E-10
—
—
—
5.55E-10
9.10E-10
1.26E-09
1.40E-09
1.50E-09
2.22E-09
—
4.24E-11
8.02E-11
1.62E-10
1.26E-11
3.82E-11
9.96E-11
—
—
—
—
—
—
K1,unsat [m2] K1,sat [m2]
2.20E-11
—
—
7.90E-11
—
—
—
3.49E-10
3.23E-10
3.75E-10
4.01E-10
2.15E-10
1.15E-10
K2,unsat [m2]
—
1.66E-11
3.53E-11
7.91E-11
7.36E-12
1.34E-11
3.74E-11
—
—
—
—
—
—
55
56.1
50.9
46.7
60.9
54.2
48.8
49.4
49.4
49.4
49.4
49.4
49.4
1
4
4
4
3
3
3
4
4
4
4
4
2
3D
Parallel
Parallel
Parallel
Linear
Linear
Linear
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
Radial
K2,sat [m2] Vf [%] N [-] Method
Stöven et al., 2003
Lundström, 2000
Lundström et al., 1999
Lundström, 2000
Lundström, 2000
Lundström, 2000
Lundström, 2000
Chiu and Cheng, 2002
Chiu and Cheng, 2002
Chiu and Cheng, 2002
Chiu and Cheng, 2002
Chiu and Cheng, 2002
Chiu and Cheng, 2002
Reference
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
M14
Q2
B7 T2
B5
B4
ID
(2)
(1)
(2)
(1)
(8)
(7)
(6)
(5)
(4)
(3)
(2)
(1)
(7)
(6)
(5)
(4)
Saertex 32047
Hexcel NC2 Hexcel NC2 Hexcel NC2 Hexcel NC2 Hexcel NC2 Hexcel NC2 Hexcel NC2 – automotive Hexcel NC2 – automotive Hexcel NC2 – automotive Hexcel NC2 – automotive Hexcel NC2 – automotive Hexcel NC2 – automotive Hexcel NC2 – automotive Hexcel NC2 – automotive Saertex V91025–00620 Hexcel NC2 – wind energy Hexcel NC2 – wind energy Hexcel NC2 – aeronautic Hexcel NC2 – aeronautic
(3)
Hexcel NC2
(1)
(2)
Name
3.654
0.534 0.534 0.534 0.534 0.534 0.534 0.43 0.43 0.43 0.43 0.43 0.43 0.43 0.43 0.616 0.975 0.975 0.6 0.6
0.534
ρA [kg·m−2]
[45/−45/0/90/0/ −45/45]S
[0/0] [0/90] [0/90] [0/90] [0/90] [45/−45] [0/90] [0/90] [0/90] [0/90] [0/90] [0/90] [0/90] [0/90] [45/−45] [−45/45/0] [−45/45/0] [−45/0/45/90] [−45/0/45/90]
[0/0]
θ [°]
1.60E-12
— — — — — 2.41E-13 — — 6.64E-12 8.39E-12 3.78E-12 9.81E-12 2.09E-12 3.82E-12 6.50E-13 — — — —
—
K3,unsat [m2]
—
2.40E-14 1.10E-13 6.37E-13 1.51E-12 2.47E-13 — 4.46E-13 8.62E-13 — — — — — — — 9.96E-13 2.40E-13 1.06E-12 1.87E-13
2.10E-14
K3,sat [m2]
55
65 65 65 65 65 50.8 41 41 37 37 41 41 43 43 55 52 52 64 64
65
Vf [%]
1
1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 15 1 1 4 4 4 4 4 4
3
N [-]
3D
Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse 3D Transverse Transverse Transverse Transverse
Transverse
Method
Stöven et al., 2003
Drapier et al., 2002 Drapier et al., 2002 Drapier et al., 2002 Drapier et al., 2002 Drapier et al., 2002 Drapier et al., 2002 Elbouazzaoui et al., 2005 Elbouazzaoui et al., 2005 Elbouazzaoui et al., 2005 Elbouazzaoui et al., 2005 Elbouazzaoui et al., 2005 Elbouazzaoui et al., 2005 Elbouazzaoui et al., 2005 Elbouazzaoui et al., 2005 Stöven et al., 2003 Drapier et al., 2005 Drapier et al., 2005 Drapier et al., 2005 Drapier et al., 2005
Drapier et al., 2002
Reference
Table 8.6 Basic characteristics of biaxial (B), triaxial (T), quadriaxial (Q) and multiaxial fabrics and characteristics and results of transverse permeability experiments
184
Non-crimp fabric composites
is the permeability of materials with same fibres and stitching, but a biaxial or triaxial structure exhibits large differences. The number of layers does not seem to be the reason for the difference, as it is for woven fabrics which exhibit a significant dependency on the number of layers due to nesting (Hoes et al., 2004; Lomov et al., 2003). It can also be observed that a significant anisotropy is measured in the in-plane permeability. In general, the saturated permeability is higher than the unsaturated permeability. However, the number of fabrics for which both saturated and unsaturated permeabilities were measured is limited. Moreover, a few authors have reported the opposite (Drapier et al., 2005; Pillai, 2004). The difference between saturated and unsaturated permeability depends on the contribution of the capillary flow wetting the fibre bundle and affecting the flow at the flow front. The influence of the capillary forces is expected to be higher for lower injection pressures or lower flow rates (Verrey et al., 2006). The ratio between inter- and intra-bundle space is a geometrical parameter affecting the amount of capillary flow (Bréard et al., 2003). This ratio is determined by the fibre count and the homogeneity of the fibre bed (compare engineered fabrics with, for example, NC2 fabrics) which changes as a function of the compression of the fabric (see Section 8.4.1). The ratio generally also changes due to the saturation itself, as the fibre bundles swell after wetting. The ratio between the unsaturated and saturated permeability is written as: [8.4] The ratio χ is shown in Fig. 8.4. Limited information is available, particularly as only a number of fabrics have been measured at different fibre contents and different pressures. Nearly all results presented are obtained in the framework of the FALCOM project (fabrics B3, T1 and Q1, see Table 8.6 for the properties of the fabrics). Measurements were performed by the NLR, SiComp and the University of Twente (Loendersloot, 2006, Thuis, 2003). The exception is fabric Q5, which is a glass fibre fabric (Lundström et al., 1999). Despite the geometrical differences, see Table 8.7, there is no significant difference in the ratio χ for these fabrics. On the average, a ratio of approximately 0.8–1.0 is observed, with some anomalies. The fibre content of fabrics B3-B(1) and B3-F1 is equal. Hence the ratio χ is expected to be equal as well, which is clearly not the case. The difference is most likely found in the number of layers: one versus six. The ratio χ of fabric B3-F2 is extremely large compared to the other ratios. It is at the upper limit reported in literature (Drapier et al., 2005). The injection pressure during the wetting part was very low. Combined with the high fibre content, it is likely that capillary flow was dominant, resulting in a relatively high permeability. Once the preform was fully saturated, the effect of capillarity dropped and the pressure had to be increased to maintain the flow rate constant. According to Pillai (2004), the ratio χ cannot exceed the value 1. This holds if the same conditions apply, which is not the case for this particular
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
185
8.4 Ratio of the unsaturated over the saturated permeability for the biaxial fabric B3, the triaxial fabric T1 and the quadriaxial fabrics Q1 and Q5. (a) Fabric B3. The letters refer to the type of fabric specified in Table 8.7. The numbers in the bars refer to the principal direction to which the data applies. (b) Fabrics T1, Q1 and Q5. The letters refer to the type of fabric specified in Table 8.7. The numbers in the bars refer to the principal direction to which the data applies.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
186
Non-crimp fabric composites
Table 8.7 Properties of the base configuration of the Devold non-crimp fabrics defined in the FALCOM project
Areal density Fibre Fibre count Orientation Stitch Stitch linear density Knit pattern Gauge Stitch length Gap width
B3
T1
Q1
0.534
0.801
1.068
±45
45/0/−45/90
[tex]
Tenax HTS 5631 12K 45/90/−45 PES 7.6
[inch−1] [mm] [mm]
chain 5 2.5 0–2
[kg m−2] [−] [°]
Source: Thuis, 2003
measurement, but is the case for the measurements on fabric B3-B(3) for which a ratio below 1 is found. A high ratio for variant F2 is not found for the triaxial fabric. The injection pressure was substantially higher than the pressure during the measurement of the biaxial variant F2 (approximately 5 bar versus 1.5 bar). Analysing the results obtained for the triaxial and quadriaxial fabrics (Fig. 8.4b), it can be concluded that there is no significant difference for the different variants and between biaxial, triaxial and quadriaxial fabrics and between carbon fibre (B3, T1 and Q1) and glass fibre (Q5) fabrics. Other results in the literature report a wide range of values. Drapier et al., (2005) measured the unsaturated and saturated transverse permeability for the Hexcel NC2 fabric and measured a value of 8–10 for the ration χ, substantially higher than other results reported in literature (Ma and Shishoo, 1999: χ ≈ 0.4; and Binétruy and Pabiot, 1999: χ ≈ 1.5–2). Drapier et al. (2005) used relatively low injection pressures and high fibre contents. Their study also indicated a significant influence of the stitching density. This means that limited inter-bundle space is present apart from the stitch penetration areas. Therefore, a significant amount of capillary flow can be expected and therefore a high ratio of χ, comparable to the measurement on fabric B3-F2. A final observation from Figure 8.3 is that the transverse permeability is approximately two orders of magnitude lower than the in-plane permeability (see also Table 8.5). The research of Drapier and Elbouazzaoui (Drapier et al., 2002, 2005; Elbouazzaoui, et al., 2005) revealed a strong correlation between the stitch density and the permeability of transverse permeability of NC2 fabrics (as also concluded in Chapter 9). This is also a relevant result for the research to the processing of stitched preform packages (Han et al., 2003; Talvensaari et al., 2005; Rieber and Mitschang 2010), consisting of woven fabrics that are stitched together to increase the structural integrity of a complete (non-flat) preform. This
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
187
process is also known as structural stitching. The stitching affects the mechanical properties of the finished product (Weimer and Mitschang 2001; Truong et al., 2005), but also the processing conditions, in particular since these products are often manufactured by resin infusion processes, hence they are governed by transverse resin flow.
8.3
Geometric effects
Typical geometrical features in the architecture of an NCF affect the flow of a fluid through the textile. On one hand, these geometrical features partly explain the differences observed in the permeabilities measured. On the other hand, they serve as input for permeability models, such as are discussed in Chapter 10. Two geometrical effects will be discussed. 1. Multi-layered NCFs versus multi-ply NCFs. 2. The effect of the stitching.
8.3.1 Multi-ply versus multiple layers NCFs are generally available as biaxial, triaxial and quadriaxial fabrics, though sometimes even more plies are stitched together to form a single layer of material (see, for example, Stöven et al., 2003). It is possible to build a preform using either multiple layers of biaxial NCFs or multiple layers of quadriaxial NCFs with the same number of plies and the same ply orientations. Consider, for example, the lay-ups: • •
[ [45,−45], [0,90], [90,0], [−45,45] ] [ [45,0,−45,90], [90, −45,0,45] ]
Both lay-ups have the same number of plies (8) and the same set of ply orientations (2 × −45, 2 × 0, 2 × 45, 2 × 90). The permeability of both preforms is therefore expected to be equal, according to the theories described in Advani et al. (1994), Lundström (2000) and Parnas (2000). The approach assumes plies with a unidirectional fibre bundle orientation. Inherently, it is assumed that the fluid flow through the fabric is not, or insignificantly, influenced by the geometrical characteristics induced by the stitches. This topic will be further addressed in the following section. One aspect related to the stitching is relevant to be mentioned here: A pattern of stitch threads covers the surface of a NCF. A small layer, typically of the order of magnitude of the diameter of the stitch yarn, is found between two individual layers. This layer forms a potential flow path, especially since a slight increase of the local fibre content of the plies will occur due to a thickness reduction of each layer, as schematically shown in Fig. 8.5. The measurements carried out in the framework of the FALCOM project (Thuis, 2003) are used to investigate this topic, as the base configuration fabrics (B3-B, T1-B and Q1-B; see Table 8.7) were all built with the same type of
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
188
Non-crimp fabric composites
8.5 Schematic cross-section of a biaxial and quadriaxial fabric, indicating the interlayer, bundle and layer thicknesses. A given thickness of the complete preform with an equal number of plies will give different values for the thicknesses for biaxial and quadriaxial fabrics. (a) Cross-section of a biaxial fabric. (b) Cross-section of a quadriaxial fabric.
fibres, employing the same type of stitching (chain knit pattern) and stitching material (polyester [PES]). The graphs in Figure 8.6 show the permeability measured of the biaxial (a), triaxial and quadriaxial (b) fabrics. The measuring condition differed as different equipment was used at each institute. The fibre content was set as close to 55% as possible with the equipment of the institutes. The measurements B3-B(1)–(3) (University of Twente) and B3-F1/2 (NLR) were performed at different fibre contents. Moreover, the number of layers was varied in the measurements at the University of Twente (1, 2, 4 for the measurements B3-B(1), B3-B(2) and B3-B(3)) whereas seven layers for the biaxial and five layers for the triaxial fabrics were used for the other measurements (except measurements B3-F1/2 and T1-F1, where the number of layers was six, eight and four, respectively, to achieve the desired fibre content). The equivalent permeability at a fibre content of 55% is calculated using the Kozeny–Carman equation (see Section 8.4.1). The relation to calculate the permeability Vf,source at an arbitrary fibre content Vf,target is based on the Kozeny– Carman equation (Williams et al., 1974, see also Section 8.4.1) reads: [8.5]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
189
8.6 Comparison of permeabilities at a 55% fibre content equivalent permeability for the fabrics B3-B, T1-B and Q1-B. The variants F1 and F2, measured by the NLR, refer to the same fabric at a lower and higher fibre content compared to variant B that was measured at the NLR. (a) Biaxial fabric B3-B. (b) Triaxial and quadriaxial fabric T1-B and Q1-B.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
190
Non-crimp fabric composites
The light grey bars refer to the unsaturated, whereas the dark grey bars refer to the saturated permeability. The measured permeabilities of the biaxial fabric by the UT (B3-B(1)–(3)) are substantially higher than those measured by the NLR (B3-F1, B3-B(4), B3-F2), whereas those measured by SiComp (B3-B(5)–(6)) are substantially lower than the NLR results. The same trend is observed for the triaxial fabric: the permeability measured by SiComp (T1-B(3)) is lower than the permeability measured by the NLR (T1-B(1)). The measurements (T1-B(2)) performed with a third rig (radial injection at the KU Leuven) is in between the results of the NLR and SiComp. The lay-ups of the bi-, tri- and quadriaxial fabrics were not adapted to obtain an equal number of plies with the same orientation. The first and second principal permeabilities of the triaxial fabric (oriented in the 90° and 0° direction) are expected to be higher and lower, respectively than the principal permeability of the biaxial and quadriaxial fabrics, which are expected to be (nearly) isotropic. Due to the large variation in the experimental results, there is no clear indication of a higher permeability in the first principal direction. Furthermore, there is no significant difference between the permeabilities of the biaxial and quadriaxial fabrics, indicating that the number of plies versus the number of layers is of insignificant influence on the permeability measured. The effect of the number of layers can also be assessed, using the data measured on the biaxial fabrics. The measurements at the University of Twente were performed with one, two and four layers (the fabrics B3-B(1), B3-B(2) and B3-B(3) respectively). The bars in Fig. 8.6 show a consistent equivalent unsaturated permeability at a fibre content of 55% (light grey bars). The equivalent saturated permeability (dark grey bars) exhibit more variation and mutually differ significantly more than the unsaturated permeabilities. The variation appears to decrease with an increasing number of layers (for a constant fibre content, see remarks in Chapter 9, section 9.3.2). Large variations are not uncommon in permeability measurements, but these measurements on the single-, double- and four-layer fabrics were performed with the same equipment, material from the same roll, by the same operator and in a short period. Consequently, it is reasonable to exclude external effects as a major cause of the variation and attribute the variation mainly to the conditions inside the mould cavity. The permeability is more profoundly influenced by boundary effects at the interfaces of the fabric and mould for a low number of layers. Increasing the number of layers will decrease the contribution of boundary effects. The boundary conditions at the interface of the fabric and mould also depend on the stitching at the top and bottom faces of the fabric. Other than the interface between two layers of fabric, only one side of the interface is deformable (fabric), whereas the other is rigid and generally smooth (mould). The microscopic image of the cross-section of a biaxial fabric in Fig. 8.7 shows that it is not unlikely that small flow channels are formed. Note that the tri- and quadriaxial fabrics inherently suffer less from this type of boundary effect, as the number of plies automatically results in a larger number of ply–ply interfaces compared to the two ply–mould interfaces.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
191
8.7 Microscopy image of the cross-section of a biaxial non-crimp fabric. The stitch yarn passing over the top and yarns forming the loop at the bottom of the fabric create a small layer which can form flow channels enhancing the permeability.
Some conclusions can be drawn on the effect of the number of layers versus the number of plies, and the total number of layers in the preform. Unfortunately, the conclusion does not have a very firm character, as both the number of measurements is limited and the variation of the results is large. Bearing this in mind, it is stated that: • •
The number of plies per layer is of insignificant influence on the permeability if the total number of plies remains equal. The total number of plies in the mould cavity has a significant influence on the amount of variation if the total number of plies is low.
The first conclusion implies that it should be possible to calculate the permeability of NCFs based on the permeability of single plies (but note that this ply permeability has to include all relevant geometrical features). The second conclusion indicates a structural difference with the permeability of stacks of woven fabrics: increasing the number of woven fabric layers leads to an increase in the variation on the permeability due to nesting (Hoes et al., 2004; Lomov et al., 2003), whereas the variation decreases with an increasing number of NCF layers.
8.3.2 Influence of stitching Several authors have reported on the effect of stitching on the internal geometry of NCFs and Chapter 4 of this book is entirely dedicated to this subject. It is known that stitching affects the structural properties of the composite (both strength and fatigue properties), which is mainly attributed to the formation of resin-rich areas (Truong et al., 2005). Limited experimental data are reported on the role the stitches and the stitching-induced geometrical characteristics on the flow pattern of the impregnating resin (Lekakou et al., 2006; Loendersloot, 2006).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
192
Non-crimp fabric composites
Firstly, it is important to analyse the flow path of the fluid. The flow front is observed in the transient permeability measurements, either visually (amongst others: Heardman et al., 2004; Loendersloot, 2006; Lundström et al., 2000) or digitally (amongst others: Hoes et al., 2002; Liu et al., 2007; Luthy and Ermanni, 2002; Luthy and Ermanni, 2003; Stöven et al., 2003; Visvanathan and Balasubramaniam, 2007; Yenilmez and Sozer, 2009). The resolution of these data (either digital images of the flow front, or sensor read outs) is insufficient to analyse the flow path in detail. Measurements were performed at the University of Twente using two transparent plates. The set-up is depicted in Fig. 8.8. The impregnating fluid is polyol, to which a penetrant fluid (Ardrox® Biopen P6F5) is added. The penetrant is fluorescent and hence allows the flow front to be traced more easily if ultraviolet or black light is used. The fabric B3–B (see Table 8.7) is employed. The progressing flow front is shown in Fig. 8.9. Macroscopically (Figure 8.9a), the fluid flows in machine direction. A pattern of lines corresponding to the direction of the fibres in the top ply is visible. This suggests a preferential flow along the fibre bundles. The overall flow in the machine direction is a combination from the flows through both plies, resulting in a straight (in the image: vertical) flow front. The images of Figure 8.9b show three close-ups of the fabric being wetted. The fluid is clearly concentrated around the stitches, according to the light grey colour, caused by the fluorescent penetrant. The images show that the fluid is also flowing along the stitches, apart from the preferential flow along the fibres. Based on this observation, an anisotropy is expected, even for
8.8 Experimental set-up to track the flow front in detail (courtesy of S.P. Haanappel). The set-up was also used to measure the thickness change of the cavity during impregnation of the fluid.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
193
8.9 Progressing flow front of a mixture of polyol–Ardrox® Biopen impregnating a biaxial non-crimp fabric (B3–B). (a) Complete impregnation cycle in six steps. (b) Three details of the flow front. (Photos courtesy of S.P. Haanappel).
symmetrically built NCFs. Moreover, the principal direction of the permeability of the fabric can be tilted with respect to the machine direction, depending on the stitch pattern; a chain-knit pattern will lead to a higher permeability in the machine direction and hence no tilt of the principal directions of the permeability but, for example, a tricot chain will lead to a small tilt (see also Chapter 9). The loops of the stitches on the bottom face of the fabric are, inherently to the production process (see Part I), oriented in the machine direction and hence only enhancing the permeability in that direction. However, the loops show a fair amount of tilt, as shown in Chapter 4 Fig. 4.6, depending on the stitch tension. The higher the stitch tension, the more the loops will be aligned in the machine direction. The anisotropy of symmetrically built fabrics (even number of plies per layer, Fig. 8.10a and b) is expected to become strengthened whereas the anisotropy of asymmetrically built fabrics (uneven number of plies per layer, Fig. 8.10c) is weakened by the stitching, since the first principal direction is oriented in the cross-direction due to the presence of the 90° ply. The anisotropy α is defined according to: [8.6]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
194
Non-crimp fabric composites
8.10 Comparison between the anisotropy of fabrics with an even and uneven number of plies. (a) Carbon fibre based biaxial and quadriaxial fabrics. (b) Glass fibre based biaxial, quadriaxial and multiaxial fabrics. (Continued)
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
195
8.10 (c) Carbon and glass fibre based uniaxial and triaxial fabrics.
It should be noted that the anisotropy of fabrics measured with a linear injection strategy is based on the measurements of separate preforms. This generally leads to a reduced accuracy of the results. The loss of accuracy is attempted to be limited in the multi-cavity set-up (Lundström et al., 1999), which does use different preforms but a single preparation and injection phase. The measurements on the biaxial fabrics B3-B(4) (classic linear injection) versus B3-B(5) and B3-B(6) (multicavity linear injection) show no difference in results, but a comparison of the results on T1-B(1) and T1-G(1) (classic linear injection) and T1-B(3) and T1-G(2) (multi-cavity linear injection) with T1-B(2) (radial injection) shows a consistent deviation of the anisotropy measured employing the classic linear injection strategy. On average, an anisotropy of 0.7–0.8 is observed for the carbon fibre fabrics with an even number of plies. The fabrics B4(1)–(3) are an exception exhibiting a lower anisotropy than average, where as B6 and M14 are isotropic. The high anisotropy of the fabric B4 can be caused by the chain-knit stitch pattern, but there are no additional data available to explain why the anisotropy is significantly higher than the other chain knit fabrics (B3 and B6). The isotropy of fabric M14 indicates that the stitching on the top and bottom faces of a layer increases the anisotropy and, consequently, the more plies per layer, the more isotropic the material will be. The anisotropy of glass fibre shows a large amount of variation, even for a single type of fabric. There is insufficient data available to explain the variation.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
196
Non-crimp fabric composites
Some experimental results, such as those on fabric Q3, are very unlikely (α < 0.1). On average, the anisotropy seems to be lower for glass fibre fabrics, but there is no physical explanation for this observation. The fibre waviness discussed in Chapter 9 is a potential explanation, but the information available is insufficient to confirm this hypothesis. The expected strong anisotropy of the uniaxial fabrics is confirmed by Fig. 8.10c. The carbon fabric (U1) shows a weaker anisotropy compared to the glass fabrics (U2 and U3). The data set is too limited to state firm conclusions on this observation, in particular since the other results only concern a single triaxial carbon fibre fabric (T1). The results show more variation than the results on the bi- and quadriaxial fabrics, but it is difficult to attribute the variations to the specific characteristics (see Table 8.8) of the fabrics, in particular since only the permeability in machine direction was measured for the biaxial variations of these fabrics. On average, an anisotropy of 0.5–0.6 is observed. This corresponds to the a weighted mean of the anisotropies of a uniaxial fabric and a biaxial fabric: [8.7] The experimental results show that the presence of stitching does affect the anisotropy of the fabric. However, it is not possible to quantify the effect of the stitching properties on the anisotropy based on the results available. Table 8.8 Definition of the identifiers of the variants of the Devold non-crimp fabrics defined in the FALCOM project Sub-Id
Variable
B T L M H G F1
Base configuration Thermoplastic stitch thread 4.0 mm stitch length Mixed tricot-chain stitch pattern High stitch tension 2–5 mm gap width
F2
Higher fibre content (∼60%) Maximum free shear angle
S
Lower fibre content (∼50%)
Source: Thuis, 2003
8.4
Deformation and permeability
Deformation has a large influence on permeability. The two leading types of deformation are compression of the textile reinforcement and shear deformation. The effects of both are investigated experimentally by a number of researchers (Chen et al., 2001; Endruweit and Ermanni, 2004; Govignon et al., 2010;
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
197
Heardman et al., 2001; Lai and Young, 1997; Loendersloot, 2006; Louis and Huber, 2003; Schuster et al., 2008; Smith et al., 1997; Stadtfeld et al., 2002).
8.4.1 Compression Two driving phenomena can be distinguished for fabric compression. Firstly, the fibre content of the fabric in relaxed state is lower than the fibre content desired and hence the fabric is compressed until the desired fibre content is obtained. Moreover, the level of compression can change during a resin infusion process (Govignon et al., 2010). Secondly, a trellis type of shear deformation, as occurs in double curvatures, results in fabric compression due to a reduction in the surface area. The effect of shear itself will be discussed more elaborately in section 8.4.2. Macroscopically, the relation of the fibre content Vf and the permeability K can be described with an empirical function, such as initially defined by Kozeny– Carman (Williams et al., 1974) and later adapted by various authors (Gebart, 1992; Berdichevsky and Cai, 1993; Cai and Berdichevsky, 1993) by introducing a distinction between flow longitudinal and perpendicular to the fibres or bundles. Senoguz et al. (2001) presented a convenient overview of the models available. Here, the relations for longitudinal and transverse flow as proposed by Gebart (1992) are used: [8.8a]
[8.8b] The variables rf and Vf,max refer to the fibre filament radius and maximum fibre content respectively. A hexagonal packing of the fibres is assumed here. Eq. 8.8 is effectively the original Kozeny–Carman equation with a specific value for the empirical Kozeny constant (Lundström, 2000). There is only a limited physical relation between the internal geometry of the fabric and the parameters in the functions (for example the factor 8/53) but the equations are slightly more applicable for NCFs, as they are derived for aligned fibre beds and not for fabrics with commingled yarns. However, the effect of stitching is not accounted for, although it has a clear influence on permeability. The same applies for the effect of fibre bundle waviness, which is discussed in Chapter 9. Compression of a fibrous preform yields a change in the ratio between the inter- and intra-bundle space. Basically, two phenomena occur: • •
Bundles are getting closer to each other (reduction of the inter-bundle space). Bundles are compacted (reduction of the intra-bundle space).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
198
Non-crimp fabric composites
It is therefore not only expected that the permeability decreases with an increasing level of compression of the fabric, but also that the ratio between the wetting and saturated permeability changes. However, there is no difference in the ratio χ for varying fibre contents, as discussed previously in Section 8.2.2 (see Fig. 8.4). The curves fitted through the permeability data of each set are shown in Fig. 8.11. The fitted fibre radii are listed in Table 8.9. In most cases, the model has the tendency to overestimate the permeability at higher fibre contents. The conclusion that can be drawn based on the available data, both on the measurements and the fabrics (fibre count, gap width, stitch density, etc.), is that Gebart’s equation provides a reasonable fit for the relation between the permeability and the fibre content. However, a more accurate model must incorporate information on the textile’s architecture and compression behaviour, in particular for the higher fibre contents.
8.4.2 Shear deformation NCFs tend to be very shear compliant. It was observed by several researchers (Endruweit et al., 2006b; Loendersloot, 2006) that NCFs can shear up to 5–7° Table 8.9 Fitted values for bundle radius rf based on a least squared approximation of Gebart’s equation (Gebart, 1992) on the experimental data of various fabrics. The fit for each class of materials is printed in italics. No distinction is made between saturated and unsaturated.
B3-B(1)–(3)
0.676E-04 0.656E-04 0.169
0.220
B3-F1B(4)F2
1.116 E-04 1.735E-04 0.013
0.118
T1-F1B(1) F2
0.451E-04 0.503E-04 0.135
0.069
Carbon B3T1
0.594E-04
0.347
U2
0.484E-04
0.048
0.393E-04
0.093
U3
0.468E-04
0.020
0.502E-04
0.028
Glass U
0.479E-04
0.034
0.430E-04
0.154
B10
0.170E-04
0.307
0.330E-04
0.388
B11
0.435E-04
0.405
0.267E-04
0.368
B12
0.373E-04
0.060
0.749E-04
0.386E-04
rf,unsat (90) [m]
1.185E-04 1.461E-04 0.426
0.081 0.009
rf,sat (90) [m]
εunsat εsat (90) [-] (90) [-]
rf,unsat (0) [m]
B13
rf,sat (0) [m]
εunsat (0) εsat (0) [-] [-]
ID
0.098 0.527E-04
0.074
B14
0.355E-04 0.403E-04 0.002
B19
1.985E-04
0.551
2.725E-04
0.253
B20
1.922E-04
3.963
1.892E-04
2.251
Glass B
0.284E-04
0.388
0.483E-04
0.624E-04 0.704E-04 0.008
0.322E-04
0.111
0.425E-04
Q5
0.373E-04
0.034
0.552E-04
0.355E-04
0.098
0.008
0.477
Q4 Glass Q
0.479
0.508E-04
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
0.055 0.075 0.123
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
199
8.11 Comparison of relation between the permeability and the fibre content according to Gebart’s equation and experimental results for various fabrics. (a) Carbon fibre bi- and triaxial fabrics. (b) Glass fibre biaxial fabrics. (c) Glass fibre uniaxial fabrics. (d) Glass fibre quadriaxial fabrics.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
200
Non-crimp fabric composites
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
201
during handling (see also fabric B3-S, Table 8.8, Thuis, 2003 and Chapter 9). Typical shear diagrams of NCFs can be found in Chapter 6. The main reason for this low shear compliance is the absence of locking, as occurs in woven fabrics due to fibre commingling (see also Chapter 6). Moreover, it was established in previous section that the stitching affects the permeability of the fabric by the formation of additional flow paths. Shear deformation also changes the stitching and, therefore, an additional, stitching-dependent effect is observed in the relation between permeability and shear. Shear can be modelled as a rotation of the principal directions of the fabric. An unsheared fabric with an isotropic permeability will have an anisotropic permeability once it is sheared. The principle axes are oriented in the bisectrices of the ply orientation angles. This simplified approach allows for an estimation of the orientation of the principal permeabilities and the anisotropy, as proposed by Advani et al. (1994):
[8.9]
With Kx and Ky the longitudinal and transverse permeability of a unidirectional ply of fibres, θ the ply orientation and γ the shear angle. The transverse permeability is generally small compared to the longitudinal permeability (Gebart and Lidström, 1996; Smith et al., 1997): Ky<
[8.10]
Experimental results show deviations to this (simplified) theoretical approach, which can be attributed to the presence of the stitching. Firstly the additional flow paths, formed by the stitch threads on the top and bottom faces, affect both the orientation and the anisotropy of the permeability (as discussed in Section 8.3). On top of that, the stitching is also affected by applying a shear deformation to the fabric. Once sheared, the stitches are either tensioned or compressed, depending on the direction of shear and on the stitch pattern, as depicted in Fig. 8.12. This results in a non-symmetric permeability versus shear relation and an additional rotation ϕ of the principal directions. It can be concluded from this basic approach that, globally, the permeability is expected to obey Eq. 8.9 with ‘second order’ deviations due to the stitchinginduced geometrical characteristics of the fabrics. This implies that an increase in the first principal permeability is expected, as the fibres in the individual plies become more aligned, and a decrease of the second principal permeability,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
202
Non-crimp fabric composites
8.12 Effect of shear deformation on two different stitch patterns. (a) Tricot stitch in unsheared state. (b) Tricot stitch in sheared state. (c) Tricot-chain stitch in unsheared state. (d) Tricot-chain stitch in sheared state.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
203
204
Non-crimp fabric composites
effectively resulting in an increase of the anisotropy. Most authors presenting on the permeability of sheared fabrics show an initial increase of the first principal permeability followed by a decrease for larger shear angles. This decrease is due to the increasing fibre content. The increase of the fibre content Vf as a function of the shear angle γ reads: [8.11] with n the number of layers, ρA the areal density, ρ the density of the fibre material and hc the cavity height. The increase of the permeability due to the realignment of the fibres competes with the decrease due to the increasing fibre content. The question could be raised of whether the permeability of sheared fabrics has to be measured at the same fibre content, or with the same cavity height. The first is preferred from a modelling point of view, whereas the second method corresponds better to the practical situation, where the mould cavity thickness is defined. In the latter case, shear always results in a (locally) higher fibre content. Measurements on sheared fabrics were performed by the author on two types of biaxial NCF (B1 and B2, Table 8.3). The measurements were performed in the framework of a Marie Curie Fellowship at the KU Leuven. A radial measuring technology was applied and the measurements were performed on single-layer material, sheared at 30° and 45°. A second set of shear permeability data is provided by Hammani et al. (1996) (Fabric B11, Table 8.4, maximum shear angle 32°). The results are shown in Fig. 8.13. Both sets of data confirm the expectations discussed above. The general trend is that Eq. 8.9 is satisfied, although the decrease of the second principal direction is much lower than predicted. The first principal permeability increases up to a maximum, whereas the second principal permeability only decreases. The maximum is reached at a shear angle of approximately 30°, which is higher than the maximum reported in literature for woven fabrics (Heardman et al., 2001; Lai and Young, 1997) and higher than predicted based on Eq. 8.10 (shear angle: 10–15°). The plies in a biaxial NCF can be rotated further without suffering from locking, as occurs in woven fabrics. As a result, the decrease in permeability of woven fabrics is initiated at lower shear angles. Another explanation is found in the effect of shear on the stitching. The stitches induce a geometrical distortion in the fabric, which is changed with the changing shear angle. It was shown by Loendersloot (2006) that the dimensions of these distortions of the fabric B1, B2 and B3 (see also Chapter 4.5) reach a minimum value at approximately 30° shear. This was related to the stitch yarn diameter, or more precisely, the minimum space the stitching requires. The result is a minimum size of the flow channel, causing a higher permeability. The location of the maximum of the first principal permeability appears to be consistent, as it is equal for the three fabrics for which permeability of sheared preforms is available, despite the significant difference between the fabrics. The first two fabrics are carbon fibre based, whereas the last is glass fibre based.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
205
8.13 Permeability versus shear for the fabrics B1, B2 and B11. The solid and dashed lines correspond to the theoretical permeability shear relation for the first and second principal direction, respectively (with the unsheared permeability as the fixed reference value).
Although the stitch pattern of the latter is unknown, those of the two carbon fabrics are different, as are the ply orientations and the fibre count of the fibre bundles. Based on the standard level at the time of production of the glass fibre fabric, it is expected that it is a relatively open fabric, with clear separations and flow channels between the individual bundles. The newer carbon fibre based fabrics possess a much more homogeneous fibre bed, resulting in a high number of fibre crossings and only a few flow channels of larger length, as are expected for the glass fibre fabric. This would suggest that the model proposed by Advani et al. (1994) fits better on the glass fibre fabric. However, there is no clear evidence for this. The conclusion is that the influence of the stitching in both cases results in a significant difference compared to the theory based on unidirectional fibre beds only. The anisotropy of the fabrics is shown in Fig. 8.14. The solid line corresponds to Eq. 8.10. The trend is reasonably well predicted. In all cases, an initial anisotropy is observed, corresponding to the previous observation that a certain amount of anisotropy is expected due to the presence of the stitching (Section 8.3). The glass fibre fabric B11 exhibits a higher amount of anisotropy (αmeasured < αtheory) than predicted by Eq. 8.10, whereas for the carbon fabrics B1 and B2 a lower amount of anisotropy (αmeasured > αtheory) is observed for the sheared fabrics, but not for the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
206
Non-crimp fabric composites
8.14 Anisotropy of the permeability of the sheared fabrics compared to the predicted anisotropy shear relation (solid line). The dashed lines are shifted with respect to the solid line to fit the measured data in a least-square sense.
unsheared fabrics. The direction of shearing is part of the explanation. Consider the stitch patterns shown in Fig. 8.12. Initially, the first principal permeability will be oriented in the direction of the stitching, but will be switched as the fabric is sheared according to the direction indicated in the figure. As a result, the stitching will enhance the second rather than the first principal permeability. This results in a lower amount of anisotropy. The anisotropy of the fabrics is defined according to Eq. 8.6 and hence the switch of first and second permeability direction is implicitly accounted for. The six- and five-pointed stars in Fig. 8.14 correspond to the inverse of the anisotropies of fabrics B1 and B2, respectively. This implies an anisotropy without accounting for the switch of the principal directions of the permeability. The dashed lines are least-squared-based fits of Eq. 8.10 plus a constant shift Δα: [8.12] The fit is observed to agree well with the experimental results. The shift Δα for the fabrics B1, B2 and B11 is found to be equal to 0.2647, 0.1233 and −0.2022 respectively. The conclusion can be drawn that the initial anisotropy of the fabric, induced by the stitching, is maintained during shear, but it depends on the direction of shear and the shear pattern.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
207
According to Eq. 8.10, the principal direction of the permeability is aligned with the smallest bisectrix of the sheared orientation of the two plies (see also Chapter 10). However, it was already established that the stitching affects the orientation of the permeability. Hence, a difference is expected, depending on both the direction of shear and the stitch pattern (ϕ in Figure 8.10d). The orientation angle β of the principal directions for the two carbon fabrics is shown in Fig. 8.15. The error bars indicate the variability of the orientation of each measurement, based on a series of flow-front positions. A significant orientation angle is already observed for the unsheared fabric B1, which is even higher than expected based on the initial misalignment of the plies of 5–7° degrees (Endruweit et al., 2006; Loendersloot, 2006). Fabric B2 shows a lower orientation for the unsheared configuration. However, the orientation for the sheared configurations is comparable to that of fabric B1 and both show large difference between measurements. The dashed line corresponds to the relations derived by Lai and Young (1997) for the relation between the orientation and β and the shear angle γ : [8.13] with α the anisotropy and m a fit parameter to account for the deviation ϕ. The value for m was found by applying a least-squared approximation, yielding
8.15 Orientation angle β as a function of the shear angle γ for the fabrics B1 and B2 compared to the model proposed by Lai and Young, 1997.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
208
Non-crimp fabric composites
m = 0.501 and m = 0.489 for the fabrics B1 and B2 respectively. Lai and Young (1997) reported a value of 0.5865 and 0.723 for two different types of woven fabric. There is no physical interpretation for m, but it is clear that there is a significant difference between the actual orientation of the principal directions and those based on theory. This is at least partly to be attributed to the presence of stitching, as in most cases the fibres in the plies are equal, whereas woven fabrics often exhibit a certain amount of unbalance, causing the orientation to differ from theory.
8.5
Conclusions
The effects of a number of geometrical characteristics of NFCs on textile permeability were presented in this chapter. The presence of the stitching was recognised as an important factor in permeability. It was observed that experimental data show a significant number of inconsistencies. It is impossible to attribute the variations in the experimental data to either the measuring technology used or the geometrical characteristics. Partly because the total data set, despite its extent, is too limited. Measurements on the same fabric under different conditions (injection pressure, fibre content, different stitching, etc.) are seldom. Partly, the information provided with each measurement is too limited. Information on the experimental parameters is often missing, as is information on the fabric and stitching (fibre count, stitch pattern, stitch thread, etc.). These, however, are key issues for a well-founded assessment of the measured permeabilities and the scatter measured which, as reported by Lundström et al. (2000), can be in the order of 15% for in-plane measurements, even if the same equipment is used and a strict protocol is followed. The recent studies of Roy et al. (2007) Pillai (2009) and Tan and Pillai (2009) confirm these observations, but add a flow rate dependency to the accuracy of the experiment. A couple of years ago, an initiative was launched to start a benchmark project for measuring and calculating the permeability of textile reinforcements, including NCF. The aim of the benchmark project was, in the first place, to characterise the permeability of different types of fabric as a function of textile architecture, compression and shear deformation. Secondly, a standardised measuring technology was aimed for. This does not imply that only one type of measuring technology will be selected based on the results obtained by the participants. Rather, the conditions and protocols for the different technologies available will be defined, such that the currently observed variation in permeability can be explained and interpreted to a value to be used in numerical models. The last task in the project is the development of numerical models that are able to predict the permeability of a fabric based on the internal geometry of the textile. A lithographybased reference structure was developed (Morren et al., 2009) to validate the experiments as well as the numerical models. The discussion in this chapter has revealed a number of geometrical characteristics that are specific for NCF. It could therefore be argued that the reference geometry will not provide useful results for the models of NCF. A
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
209
detailed analysis of the flow through the fabric as, for example, done by the experiments at the University of Twente (see Fig. 8.8), provide a more significant contribution to the understanding and interpretation of permeability measurements of NCF. The measurements as carried out by Drapier et al. (2002) and Elbouazzaoui et al. (2005) can be used to identify the effect of the stitching as they varied the stitch density over a conveniently wide range. A similar approach was followed in the FALCOM project (Thuis, 2003), where a number of variants of the same NCF were analysed. The measurements, performed by the NLR, SiComp and the University of Twente (Thuis, 2003; Loendersloot, 2006), were, however, not as conclusive as was hoped. A larger range of variability in the geometrical features may have been more effective. The success of the benchmark project does not only depend on the experimental and numerical efforts by the participants, but also on two other factors: • •
Completeness of the information on the geometrical characteristics of the fabrics studied. The recognition of the differences between woven fabrics and NCFs.
Addressing these differences in specific experiments will lead to a more fundamental understanding of the effect of textile geometrical characteristics on permeability. This will be an important input for permeability prediction models. This chapter did not elaborate on the measuring technologies themselves, or on the mathematics behind them. The reason for not addressing these topics is that they are not specific for NCF and there already exist a wide range of articles and books on this topic. The reader is in particular referred to the book edited by Advani et al. (1994) and the book by Parnas (2000), in which most of the topics on permeability measurements are discussed. Recent developments in permeability measuring technologies relate to a more automated process, in an attempt to both decrease the time required for a measurement and to increase the quality in terms or accuracy, repeatability and reproducibility. This implies that new types of sensors are being developed. The new generation of sensors is capable of detecting the position of the flow front. Either a large number of sensors is used (Hoes et al., 2002; Hoes, 2003; Liu et al., 2007) or sensors with a certain length or nonintrusive techniques (Danisman et al., 2007; Dominauskas et al., 2003; Dunkers et al., 2001; Gupta and Sundaram, 2009; Kueh et al., 2002; Luthy and Ermanni, 2002; Visvanathan and Balasubramaniam, 2007) are employed. The main goal is to increase the amount and quality of measured permeabilities to improve the qualification and quantification of the variability of the permeability.
8.6
Acknowledgements
The author acknowledges the partners of the EU-funded FALCOM project (GRD1-2001-40184) for allowing the publication of the data acquired in this project, the financial support of the European Commission of the TECABS Brite-Euram
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
210
Non-crimp fabric composites
project and the Marie Curie Fellowship Programme (HPMT-CT-2000-0030); the author participated in these projects during his PhD research. Furthermore, the valuable input of S.P. Haanappel on his experiments with the penetrant fluid is acknowledged. Finally, the author thanks R.H.W. ten Thije for providing Fig. 8.1.
8.7
References
Advani S.G., M. van Bruschke and R.S. Parnas (1994). Flow and rheology in polymer composite manufacturing. Composite Materials Series Volume 10 Chapter 12. Ahn S.H., W.I. Lee and G.S. Springer (1995). Measurement of the three-dimensional permeability of fiber preforms using embedded fiber optic sensors Journal of Composite Materials 29(6):714–733. Batch G.L., Y.-T Chen and C.W. Macosko (1996). Capillary Impregnation of Aligned Fibrous beds: Experiments and Model Polymer Composites 15:1027–1051. Bechtold G. and L. Ye (2003). Influence of fibre distribution on the transverse flow permeability in fibre bundles Composites Science and Technology 63:2069–2079. Berdichevsky A.L. and Z. Cai (1993). Preform permeability predictions by self-consistent method and finite-element simulation Polymer Composites 14(2):132–143. Binétruy C. and J. Pabiot (1999). Effects of fabric architectural heterogeneities on effective and saturated permeabilities in RTM Proceedings of ICCM-12 Paris, France 10p. Bréard J., Y. Henzel, F. Trochu and R. Gauvin (2003). Analysis of dynamic flows through porous media. Part I: Comparison between saturated and unsaturated flows in fibrous reinforcements Polymer Composites 24(3):391–408. Cai Z. and A.L. Berdichevsky (1993). An improved self-consistent method for estimating the permeability of a fiber assembly Polymer Composites 14(4):314–323. Chen B., E.J. Lang and T.-S. Chou (2001). Experimental and theoretical studies of fabric compaction behavior in resin transfer molding Materials Science and Engineering A 317:118–196. Chen X. and T.D. Papathanasiou (2008). The transverse permeability of disordered fiber arrangements: a statistical correlation in terms of the mean nearest interfiber spacing Transport in Porous Materials 71:233–255. Chiu C.-H. and C.-C. Cheng (2002). In-plane permeability of stitched MMWK laminates in resin transfer moulding Journal of Reinforced Plastics and Composites 20(5):391–408. Danisman M., G. Tuncol, A. Kaynar and E.M. Sozer (2007). Monitoring of resin flow in the resin transfer molding (RTM) process using point-voltage sensors Composites Science and Technology 67:367–379. Darcy H. (1856), Les Fontaines Publiques de la Ville de Dijon Dalmont Paris. Dominauskas A., D. Heider and J.W. Gillespie Jr. (2003). electric time-domain reflectometry sensor for online flow sensing in liquid composite molding processing Composites Part A 34:67–74. Drapier S., A. Pagot, A. Vautrin and P. Henrat (2002). Influence of the stitching density on the transverse permeability of non-crimped new concept (NC2) multiaxial reinforcements: measurements and predictions Composites Science and Technology 62:1979–1991. Drapier S., J. Monatte, O. Elbouazzaoui and P. Henrat (2005). Characterization of transient through-thickness permeabilities of Non Crimp New Concept (NC2) multiaxial fabrics Composites Part A 36:877–892.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
211
Dunkers J.P., J.L. Lenhart, S.R. Kueh, J.H. van Zanten, S.G. Advani and R.S. Parnas (2001). Fiber optic flow and cure sensing for liquid composite molding Optics and Lasers in Engineering 35:91–104. Elbouazzaoui O., S. Drapier and P. Henrat (2005). An experimental assessment of the saturated transverse permeability of non-crimped new concept (NC2) multiaxial fabrics Journal of Composite Materials 39(13):1169–1193. Endruweit A. and P. Ermanni (2004). The in-plane permeability of sheared textiles. Experimental observations and a predictive conversion model Composites Part A 35:439–451. Endruweit A., P. McGregor, A.C. Long and M.S. Johnson (2006a). Influence of the fabric architecture on the variations in experimentally determined in-plane permeability values Composites Science and Technology 66:1778–1792. Endruweit A., A.C. Long, F. Robitaille and C.D. Rudd (2006b). Influence of stochastic fibre angle variations on the permeability of bi-directional textile fabrics Composites Part A 37:122–132. Ferland P., D. Guittard and F. Trochu (1996). Concurrent methods for permeability measurement in resin transfer molding Polymer Composites 17(1):149–158. Frishfelds V., T.S. Lundström and A. Jakovics (2003). Permeability of clustered fiber networks: modelling of the unit cell Mechanics of Composite Materials 39(3): 265–272. Gauvin R., F. Trochu, Y. Lemenn and L. Diallo (1996). Permeability measurements and flow simulation through fiber reinforcement Polymer Composites 17(1):34–42. Gebart B.R. (1992). Permeability of unidirectional reinforcements for RTM Journal of Composite Materials 26(8):1100–1133. Gebart B.R. and P. Lidström (1996). Measurement of in-plane permeability of anisotropic fiber reinforcements Polymer Composites 17(1):43–51. Govignon Q., S. Bickerton and P.A. Kelly (2010). Simulation of the reinforcement compaction and resin flow during the complete resin infusion process Composites Part A 41:45–57. Gupta N. and R. Sundaram (2009). Fiber optic sensor for monitoring flow in vacuum enhanced resin infusion technology (VERITy) process Composites Part A 40:1065–1070. Gutowski T.G., Z. Cai, S. Bauer, D. Boucher, J. Kingery and S. Wineman (1987). Consolidation Experiments for Laminate Composites Journal of Composite Materials 21:650–669. Hammani A., F. Trochu, R. Gauvin and S. Wirth (1996). Directional permeability measurement of deformed reinforcement Journal of Reinforced Plastics and Composites 15:552–562. Han K.K., C.W. Lee and B.P. Rice (2000). Measurements of the permeability of fiber preforms and applications Composites Science and Technology 60:2435–2441. Han N.L., S.S. Suh, J.-M. Yang and H.T. Hahn (2003). Resin fil infusion of stitched stiffened composite panels Composites Part A 34:227–236. Heardman E., C. Lekakou and M.G. Bader (2001). In-plane permeability of sheared fabrics Composites Part A 32:933–940. Heardman E., C. Lekakou and M.G. Bader (2004). Flow monitoring and permeability measurements under constant and transient flow conditions Composites Science and Technology 64:1239–1249. Hoes K. (2003). Development of a new sensor-based set-up for experimental permeability identification of fibrous media PhD-Thesis.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
212
Non-crimp fabric composites
Hoes K., D. Dinescu, H. Sol, M. Vanheule, R.S. Parnas, Y. Luo and I. Verpoest (2002). New set-up for measurement of permeability properties of fibrous reinforcements for RTM Composites Part A 33:959–969. Hoes K., D. Dinescu, H. Sol, R.S. Parnas and S. Lomov (2004). Study of nesting induced scatter of permeability values in layered reinforcement fabrics Composites Part A 35:1407–1418. Kim S.K. and I.M. Daniel (2007). Observation of permeability dependence on flow rate and implications for liquid composite molding Journal of Composite Materials 41(7):837–849. Kueh S.R.M., R.S. Parnas and S.G. Advani (2002). A methodology for using long-period gratings and mold-filling simulations to minimize the intrusiveness of flow sensors in liquid composite molding Composites Science and Technology 62:311–327. Labordus M. (2004). Permeability measurements: In plane and through the thickness Proceedings of FPCM-6 Newark, Delaware USA 477–481. Lai C.-L. and W.-B. Young (1997). Model resin permeation of fiber reinforcements after shear deformation Polymer Composites 18(5):642–648. Lam R.C. and J.L. Kardos (1989). The permeability and Compressibility of Aligned and Cross-Plied Carbon Fibre Beds During Processing of Composites Proceedings of ANTEC 1408–1412. Lekakou C., M.A.K. Johari, D. Norman and M.G. Bader (1996). Measurement techniques and effects on in-plane permeability of woven cloths in resin transfer moulding Composites Part A 27:401–408. Lekakou C., S. Edwards, G. Bell and S.C. Amico (2006). Computer modelling for prediction of the in-plane permeability of non-crimp stitch bonded fabrics Composites Part A 37:1–6. Liu Q., R.S. Parnas and H.S. Giffard (2007). New set-up for in-plane permeability measurement Composites Part A 38:954–962. Loendersloot R. (2006). The structure-permeability relation of textile reinforcements PhDThesis ISBN: 90–365–2337–0. Loendersloot R., S.V. Lomov, R. Akkerman and I. Verpoest (2006). Carbon composites based on multiaxial multiply stitched preforms. Part V: geometry of sheared biaxial fabrics Composites Part A 37:103–113. Lomov S.V., I. Verpoest, T. Peeters, D. Roose and M. Zako (2003). Nesting in textile laminates: geometrical modelling of the laminate Composites Science and Technology 63:993–1007. Louis M. and U. Huber (2003). Investigation of shearing effects on the permeability of woven fabrics and implementation into LCM simulation Composites Science and Technology 63:2081–2088. Lundström T.S., B.R. Gebart and E. Sandlund (1999). In-plane permeability measurement on fiber reinforcements by the multi-cavity parallel flow technique Polymer Composites 20(1):146–154. Lundström T.S. (2000). The permeability of non-crimped stitched fabrics Composites Part A 31:1345–1353. Lundström T.S., R. Stenberg, R. Bergström, H. Partanen and P.-A. Birkeland (2000). In-plane permeability measurements: a nordic round-robin study Composites Part A 31:29–43. Lundström T.S., S. Toll and J.M. Håkanson (2002). Measurement of the permeability tensor of compressed fibre beds Transport in Porous Materials 47:363–380.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms
213
Lundström T.S., V. Frishfelds and A. Jakovics (2004). A statistical approach to permeability of clustered fibre reinforcements Journal of Composite Materials 38(13):1137–1149. Lundström T.S., V. Frisfelds and A. Jackovics (2010). Bubble formation and motion in non-crimp fabrics with perturbed bundle geometry Composites Part A 41:83–92. Luo Y., I. Verpoest, K. Hoes, M. Vanheule, H. Sol and A. Cardon (2001). Permeability measurement of textile reinforcements with several test fluids Composites Part A 32:1497–1504. Luthy T. and P. Ermanni (2002). Linear direct current sensing system for flow monitoring in Liquid Composite Moulding Composites Part A 33:385–397. Luthy T. and P. Ermanni (2003). Flow monitoring in Liquid Composite Molding based on linear direct current sensing technique Polymer Composites 24(2):249–262. Ma Y. and R. Shishoo (1999). Permeability characterization of different architectural fabrics Journal of Composite Materials 33(8):729–750. Morren G., M. Bottiglieri, S. Bossuyt, H. Sol, D. Lecompte, B. Verleye and S.V. Lomov (2009). A reference specimen for permeability measurements of fibrous reinforcements for RTM Composites Part A 40:244–250. Nordlund M. (2006). Permeability modelling and particle decomposition mechanisms related to advanced composite manufacturing PhD-Thesis ISSN: 1402–1544. Nordlund M., T.S. Lundström, V. Frishfelds and A. Jakovics (2006). Permeability network model for non-crimp fabrics Composites Part A 37:826–835. Parnas R.S. (2000). Liquid composite moulding, Hanser. Parnas R.S., J.G. Howard, T.L. Luce and S.G. Advani (1995). Permeability characterization. Part 1: A proposed standard reference fabric for permeability Polymer Composites 16(6):429–445. Pillai K.M. (2004). Modeling the unsaturated flow in liquid composite molding processes: a review and some thoughts Journal of Composite Materials 38(23):2097–2118. Rieber G. and P. Mitschang (2010). 2D permeability changes due to stitching seams Composites Part A 41:2–7. Roy T., H.Tan and K.M. Pillai (2007). A method to estimate the accuracy of 1-D flow based permeability measuring devices Journal of Composite Materials 41(17): 2037–2055. Saouab A., J. Bréard, P. Lory, B. Gardarein and G. Bouquet (2001). Injection simulation of thick composite parts manufactured by the RTM process Composites Science and Technology 61:445–451. Scholz S., J.W. Gillepsie jr. and D. Heider (2007). Measurement of transverse permeability using gaseous and liquid flow Composites Part A 38:2034–2040. Schuster M., A. Ogale, L. Peetz, J. Schuster and P. Mitschang (2008). Analysis of sewed preforms by visual on-line monitoring of stitch-hole variations under compaction Composites Science and Technology 68:312–320. Senoguz M.T., F.D. Dungan, A.M. Sastry and J.T. Klamo (2001). Simulations and experiments on low-pressure permeation of fabrics: Part II – the variable gap model and permeability prediction Journal of Composite Materials 35(14):1285–1322. Sharma S., D.A. Siginer, R.K. Dukipatti and K.A. Soschinske (2009). Effect of fiber sizing – test fluid interaction on the unsaturated and saturated flow in the VARTM process Journal of Composite Materials 43(15):1589–1601. Smith P., C.D. Rudd, A.C. Long (1997). The effect of shear deformation on the processing and mechanical properties of aligned reinforcements Composites Science and Technology 57:327–344.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
214
Non-crimp fabric composites
Stadtfeld H.C., M. Erninger, S. Bickerton and S.G. Advani (2002). An experimental method to continuously measure permeability of fiber preforms as function of fiber volume fraction Journal of Reinforced Plastics and Composites 21(10):879–899. Steenkamer D.A., S.H. McKnight, D.J. Wilkins and V.M. Karbhari (1995). Experimental characterization of permeability and fibre wetting for liquid moulding Journal of Materials Science 30:3207–3215. Stöven T., F. Weyrauch, P. Mitschang and M. Neitzel (2003). Continuous monitoring of three-dimensional resin flow through a fibre preform Composites Part A 34:475–480. Talvensaari H., E. Landstätter and W. Billinger (2005). Permeability of stitched preform packages Composite Structures 71:371–377. Tan H. and K.M. Pillai (2009). A method to estimate the accuracy of radial flow-based permeability measuring devices Journal of Composite Materials 43(21):2307–2332. Truong T.C., M. Vettori, S. Lomov and I. Verpoest (2005). Carbon composites based on multiaxial multiply stitched preforms. Part 4: mechanical properties of composites and damage observation Composites Part A 36:1207–1221. Thuis H.G.S.J. (2003). Measurements of permeability of different non-crimp fabrics FALCOM Deliverable D2.1.2/NLR-CR-2003–275 38p. Ven E.C. van de, R. Loendersloot and R. Akkerman (2006). Experimental investigation of the compressibility and permeability of fabric reinforcements Proceedings of FPCM-8 241–248. Verrey J., V. Michaud and J.-A.E. Månson (2006). Dynamic capillary effects in liquid composite moulding with non-crimp fabrics Composites Part A 37:92–102. Visvanathan K. and K. Balasubramaniam (2007). Ultrasonic torsional guided wave sensor for flow front monitoring inside molds Review of Scientific Instruments 78:8p. Wang T.J., C.H. Wu and L.J. Lee (1994). In-plane permeability measurement and analysis in liquid composite molding Polymer Composites 15(4):278–287. Weimer C. and P. Mitschang (2001). Aspects of the stitch formation process on the quality of the sewn multi-textile-preform Composites Part A 32:1477–1484. Weitzenböck J.R., R.A. Shenoi and P.A. Wilson (1999a). Radial flow permeability measurement. Part A: theory Composites Part A 30:781–796. Weitzenböck J.R., R.A. Shenoi and P.A. Wilson (1999b). Radial flow permeability measurement. Part B: application Composites Part A 30:797–813. Williams J.G., C.E.M. Morris and B.C. Ennis (1974). Liquid flow through aligned fibre beds Polymer Engineering and Science 14(6):413–419. Yenilmez B. and E.M. Sozer (2009). A grid of dielectric sensors to monitor mold filling and resin cure in resin transfer molding Composites Part A 40:476–489.
8.8
Appendix: nomenclature
Roman hc i K _ K K1 K2 K3
cavity height index permeability tensor averaged permeability first principal permeability second principal permeability third principal permeability
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
[m] [-] [m2] [m2] [m2] [m2] [m2]
Permeability of non-crimp fabric preforms Kx Ky Klong Kperp – Kln Kunsat Ksat m n N P rf s+ s− sln t0.95 v Vf Vf,max
permeability in longitudinal direction in ply permeability in transverse direction in ply longitudinal permeability transverse permeability average permeability based on a lognormal data distribution unsaturated/wetting/transient permeability saturated/steady state permeability fit parameter number of layers number of elements/degrees of freedom pressure fibre (bundle) radius upper value variability of a lognormal distribution lower value variability of a lognormal data distribution estimate of standard deviation of a lognormal data distribution Student-t-distribution with a 95% significance level fluid velocity vector fibre content theoretical maximum fibre content
215 [m2] [m2] [m2] [m2] [m2] [m2] [m2] [-] [-] [-] [bar] [m]
[-] [m·s−1] [-] [-]
Greek
α β γ θ μ ρ ρA χ
anisotropy orientation angle of the first principal permeability shear angle ply orientation angle dynamic viscosity volumetric density areal density ratio of unsaturated over saturated permeability
Mathematical
Δ ∇
Difference gradient operator
Abbreviations U B T Q Mn
uniaxial fabric biaxial fabric triaxial fabric quadriaxial fabric multiaxial fabric with n plies
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
[-] [°] [°] [°] [Pa·s] [kg·m−3] [kg·m−2] [-]
9 Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric composite reinforcements A. ENDRUWEIT and A.C. LONG , University of Nottingham, UK
Abstract: This chapter discusses the variability in experimentally determined in-plane and through-thickness permeability values of non-crimp fabrics. Experimental uncertainties in permeability measurement are quantified for a specific measurement technique. Variability in local fibre orientation and fibre spacing in a fabric is described, and its influence on the local in-plane permeability is modelled for a representative material. Stochastic distributions of the local permeability are generated and implemented in flow simulations, which are evaluated statistically to estimate the global in-plane permeability and its variance and to predict probable outcomes of resin injections. The variability in through-thickness permeability is caused mainly by multi-layer effects such as misalignment, resulting in discontinuity of through-thickness pores. Key words: non-crimp fabrics, permeability, variability, resin flow, probabilistic methods.
9.1
Introduction
In liquid composites moulding (LCM) processes, composite components are produced by impregnation of a dry reinforcing textile structure with liquid matrix resin. As formulated in Darcy’s law, the resin flow during impregnation depends on the permeability of the textile material. Different models exist for reinforcement permeability, all of which describe a dependence on the fibre volume fraction and geometry parameters. However, such models generally involve one or more empirical parameters, so that in practice permeability must be determined experimentally for each material and over a range of fibre volume fractions. For description of fabric impregnation at the component scale (macro-scale), fibre volume fraction and permeability are typically assumed to be uniform. However, non-uniformity in the fibre volume fraction of actual fabrics, caused by local variation of fibre angles and fibre spacing across several unit cells, results in variability in the global permeability (Endruweit et al., 2006c). In multi-layer preforms, nesting, which was analysed in detail by Hoes et al. (2002), may induce additional permeability variations. However, for non-crimp fabrics (NCFs) with alternating layers of aligned fibre bundles, the effect of nesting is not expected to be significant. Variability in fabric permeability results in variability in mouldfilling patterns and injection times in processing of actual components. Therefore, product quality and production cycle time may be affected. 216 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric
217
Since textile reinforcements are often processed in thin shell-like structures, in-plane resin flow and in-plane permeability have been discussed extensively in the literature. The in-plane permeability of actual fabrics can be determined from quantitative evaluation of injection experiments, which implies homogenisation of local variations in material properties. The resulting global permeability values show, in general, high variations (e.g. Lundström et al., 2000a; Luo et al., 2001). For woven, unidirectional and stitch-bonded fabrics, Parnas et al. (1997) estimated the typical uncertainty (standard deviation/average value of a series of experiments) in measured permeability as ±20%. This variability is caused by variability in the fabric structure, but also by experimental errors (Pan et al., 2000). With increasing interest in the production of geometrically more complex thick structural components applying LCM technology, through-thickness resin flow becomes more relevant. However, information on the through-thickness permeability of actual bi-directional fabrics and its variability is sparse. In this chapter, the variability of experimentally determined in-plane and through-thickness permeability values of NCFs is quantified, and experimental uncertainties in permeability measurement are discussed. The material nonuniformity is related to the variability in local fibre orientation and the fibre spacing, and its influence on the local permeability is described. For the in-plane permeability, stochastic distributions of the local permeability are generated and implemented in flow simulations, which are evaluated statistically to estimate global permeability variations and to predict probable outcomes of resin injections. Whilst results are presented primarily for a single NCF, the concepts described are applicable to a wide range of textile reinforcements.
9.2
Material characterisation
All textile fabrics show, in general, some degree of non-uniformity, which affects the local permeability and contributes to the uncertainty in measured global permeability values. Local variations in fibre spacing and fibre angle, both of which are interdependent, are inherent to any fabric architecture. They may also be induced by the effects of gravity and handling during storage and transport, as well as by cutting, stacking and draping (i.e. localised shear deformation, see Chapter 8, Section 8.4.2) of fabric layers during preform preparation. In addition, the textile structure may be affected by quality issues such as missing yarns and irregularities in the stitching pattern (the latter specifically in the case of NCFs). While considerable efforts have been made to develop formulations for, in particular, the effect of drape on the fabric’s properties (e.g. Smith et al., 1997), variations due to external influences and quality issues are case-specific and cannot be discussed in a generalised way. Here, the material-inherent non-uniformity is discussed for the example of a ±45° NCF, in which two layers of unidirectional E-glass fibre yarns are stitchbonded using a high-drape tricot stitch construction (as in Endruweit et al.,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
218
Non-crimp fabric composites
9.1 Unit cell of a ±45° non-crimp fabric: definitions of the in-plane axis of the fibre tow cross-section, Rp, the spacing between the axes of adjacent fibre tows, a0, the inter-yarn angle, α, and the angle between fibre tow axis and fabric weft direction, χ.
2006c). The fabric is characterised geometrically by the superficial density S0 (nominal value 0.950 kg/m2), the average ratio of in-plane dimension of fibre tows Rp and fibre-tow spacing a0 (identical in both fibre directions) and the standard deviation σα of angles α between both fibre directions (Fig. 9.1). The angle χ between the fibre direction and the weft (transverse to roll) direction of the fabric, which is expected to have identical absolute values on both faces on the fabric and to coincide with half the angle α, was determined experimentally at various positions on both faces of the fabric by means of photographic imaging and digital image analysis. Statistical evaluation of the data indicates that χ is normally distributed with a mean value of 42.7° and a standard deviation of 5.6° (Fig. 9.2). From the value for χ, a standard deviation of 7.9° in the angle α between both fibre orientations can be determined from [9.1] which applies for symmetry reasons. The local superficial density of the fabric was determined experimentally by weighing series of specimens with given surface area. The specimens were stamped out from positions across the width of the fabric roll. For three different sizes of specimens, the masses were determined and evaluated statistically as indicated in Fig. 9.3. The histograms indicate that the width of the distribution of
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric
219
9.2 Distribution of angle χ between fibre direction and fabric weft direction; histogram and corresponding normal distribution; correlation coefficient R2 = 0.985 (adapted from Endruweit et al., 2006c).
9.3 Distributions of local superficial densities S0; evaluation is based on three different surface areas As of the specimens (Endruweit and Long, 2006b).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
220
Non-crimp fabric composites Table 9.1 Fabric superficial density S0, average ratio Rp/a0 and standard deviation of fibre angles σα. S0/g/m2
Rp/a0
σα
965 ±4 (±0.4%)
0.39
7.9°
Source: Endruweit et al., 2006c.
the superficial density increases with decreasing specimen dimensions, because of the increasing local resolution of the sampling procedure. Average values of Rp and a0 were determined visually from fabric specimens by photographic imaging and digital image analysis. Values of the parameters for geometrical fabric characterisation are summarised in Table 9.1. The relatively high value of σα and the significant deviation of the average value of Rp/a0 from the ideal value of 0.5 are caused by the stitches through the fabric and the resulting gaps, which cause local disturbances (waviness) in the otherwise aligned fibre bundles. The low relative variation in the superficial density indicates that the typical dimensions of material non-uniformities are smaller than the specimen dimensions. A study of different fabrics (Endruweit et al., 2006c) suggested that, for [9.2] Rp/a0 and σα are correlated via [9.3] Here, ωmax is the maximum frequency of the fibre tow waviness. Based on the values in Table 9.1, the constant of proportionality ωmax a0 is determined as 0.627. At a fibre spacing a0 of approximately 2.1 mm, the value of ωmax is 0.30/mm. To discuss the relation between stitching pattern and waviness, the configuration of the gaps as seen in Fig. 9.4 is represented schematically in Fig. 9.5. Simplifying the geometrical description proposed by Lomov et al. (2002), the tricot stitching pattern is characterised by the distance D between stitches and the stitch length L. Assuming that the fibres are oriented mainly at 45° to the stitch (warp) direction, the length of the gaps l and the width of the gaps w are approximated by [9.4] and [9.5]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric
221
9.4 Effect of the stitching thread on the fibre configuration on both faces, (a) and (b), of the non-crimp fabric (adapted from Endruweit et al., 2006c).
9.5 Schematic configuration of the gaps in non-crimp fabrics; dashed lines indicate idealised fibre paths (Endruweit et al., 2006c).
where d is the diameter of the stitching thread. The opening angle of the gaps is [9.6] where [9.7]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
222
Non-crimp fabric composites
The angle γ /2, which describes local deviations of the fibre orientations from 45°, is expected to be related to the standard deviation of the angle χ and thus ultimately to determine ωmax. The ratio d/D is approximately 0.12, which according to Eq. 9.6 gives an angle γ /2 ≈ 3.5°. The measured variation in fibre angles is σχ = 5.6°. The values of γ /2 and σχ differ, because the actual fibre structure is not as regular as the idealised configuration. While Eqs. 9.4 to 9.7 refer to the specific case of frequently used ±45° NCFs, the waviness of fibre tows in any NCF is determined by the diameter of the stitching thread and the stitch density along the fibre tow direction. The influence of the stitching pattern on the fibre tow alignment is small, if the stitch direction coincides with the fibre orientation (e.g. in 0°/90° fabrics) and the stitches are positioned in inter-tow spaces. Relations of the type in Eq. 9.3 can be applied to fabrics of any architecture, but if a fabric is not bi-directional, σα needs to be defined differently, e.g. as the standard deviation of the distribution describing the angle between the fibre direction and a reference direction (as σχ). If the properties of fibre tows are not identical along different fibre directions, Rp, a0 and σα need to be determined separately for each direction.
9.3
Permeability measurement
9.3.1 Methods and errors In addition to the local non-uniformity of the textile structure, experimental errors contribute to the variability in measured permeability values. Experimental errors are uncertainties in each individual experiment for permeability measurement, induced by the limited accuracy of the experimental set-up and the data evaluation procedure. A general overview of concepts and techniques for permeability measurement is given in Chapter 8, Section 8.2. While, in the following, experimental errors are analysed for selected frequently used permeability measurement techniques, similar considerations apply to other methods. The in-plane permeability values K1 and K2 are frequently determined in unsaturated radial flow experiments at constant injection pressure, based on measurement of the extent of the flow front ellipse as a function of time (e.g. Endruweit et al., 2006c). For this type of experiment, the permeability of an anisotropic material in an equivalent isotropic system of elliptical co-ordinates is [9.8] as discussed, e.g. by Chan and Hwang (1991). Here, R1 is the semi-major axis of the flow front ellipse, R0 the radius of the circular injection gate, Δp the gauge
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric
223
pressure at the injection gate, t the time for the flow front to reach R1, Φ the porosity of the textile lay-up, and η the viscosity of the injected fluid. The equivalent injection gate dimension R01 in direction of R1 in elliptical co-ordinates is [9.9] where R2 denotes the semi-minor axis of the flow front ellipse. With R1(t) and R2(t) determined experimentally, the principal permeability values K1 and K2 are calculated from [9.10] Substituting [9.11] in Eq. 9.8, the experimental error of ke is [9.12] The uncertainties in the injection pressure Δp, the flow front arrival time t and the liquid viscosity η are given directly by the respective measurement errors. The uncertainty in the fabric porosity Φ is given by the uncertainty in cavity height h. According to Eq. 9.9, the uncertainty in R01 is [9.13] For the ratio of the axes of the flow front ellipse, R2/R1, the uncertainty can be estimated. The uncertainty in F can be determined statistically following the method suggested by Heardman et al. (2004). The through-thickness permeability can be determined in saturated unidirectional flow experiments at constant volume flow rate Q (e.g. Goulley et al., 1993). Measurement of the pressure drop Δp across the specimen allows [9.14] to be calculated, where h is the thickness of the specimen, A the cross-sectional area of the cylindrical flow channel and η the viscosity of the test fluid. The experimental error is calculated according to
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
224
Non-crimp fabric composites
[9.15] The uncertainties in η, h and Δ p are given directly by the respective measurement errors. The uncertainty in the injection flow rate Q depends on the accuracy of the pump used. For the effective cross-sectional area of the flow channel, the uncertainty is determined by the uncertainty in diameter. For series of Nexp experiments, the contribution of the error in each individual experiment to the observed permeability variations is reduced by a factor Nexp−1/2. Variations in the permeability values, which are higher than the reduced error for the respective series of experiments, indicate variations in the fabric properties.
9.3.2 Results For the fabric described in Section 9.2, the in-plane permeability was measured in unsaturated radial flow experiments at constant injection pressure. Circular fabric specimens with a radius of 200 mm were placed in an injection tool, which is made from aluminium with an additional stiffening steel structure to minimise deflection. The fibre volume fraction was set by adjusting the cavity height. A test fluid, engine oil with given viscosity, was injected through a central circular injection gate with a radius of 5 mm. The flow front propagation along three co-planar axes was determined by evaluating the readings from an array of pressure transducers (Endruweit et al., 2006c). Implementation of a method derived by Weitzenböck et al. (1999a, 1999b) from Eqs. 9.8 to 9.10 allows the principal permeability values and the orientation of the principal permeability axes to be determined from the flow front position as a function of time. Additional injection experiments with a transparent upper half of the tool were conducted to verify visually that the flow fronts are approximately elliptical during impregnation, which is a premise for the validity of the evaluation procedure. Deviations of the flow front shape from a perfect ellipse (Fig. 9.6) are caused by local fabric nonuniformity. Considering all sources of uncertainty, the upper estimate for the experimental errors of ke according to Eq. 9.8 and of K1 and K2 according to Eq. 9.10 is approximately 14%. The results of experiments for three fabric layers, all at identical orientation, at a cavity height of 2 mm (Endruweit et al., 2006c) are listed in Table 9.2. For comparison, additional published data (average values and coefficients of variation) for different NCFs and fabrics of different architectures, which complement the average in-plane permeability values in Tables 8.2 to 8.5, are listed in Table 9.3. The observed coefficients of variation of 22.5% and 26.1% for K1 and K2 are in the same order of magnitude as typical values for different fabrics quoted in the literature. On the other hand, the expected error for the principal
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric
225
9.6 Example for experimentally determined flow front shape at a given injection time (extracted from photograph); grey area indicates impregnated fabric.
Table 9.2 Number of experiments Nexp, fibre volume fraction Vf, angle θ between fabric weft direction and principal flow direction, principal in-plane permeability values K1 and K2, and ratio of anisotropy K1/K2. Nexp
Vf
θ
K1/10−10 m2
K2/10−10 m2
K1/K2
20
0.56 ± 0.00 (± 0.8%)
112° ± 43°
0.219 ± 0.049 (± 22.5%)
0.184 ± 0.048 (± 26.1%)
1.19
Note: mean values, standard deviations and coefficients of variation are given where applicable. Source: Endruweit et al., 2006c
permeability values at Nexp = 20 is approximately 3%. The mismatch between the observed coefficients of variation and the expected error for the series indicates a strong influence of variations in the fabric properties on the results. The distributions of values for K1 and K2 and the corresponding normal distributions, which were determined from the average values and standard deviations in Table 9.2, are compared in Figs. 9.7 and 9.8. While there is a strong correlation between the original values of K1 and the normal distribution, the correlation for K2 is weaker. However, the trend identified by Hoes et al. (2002) for the permeability values to be normally distributed seems in general to be followed.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Test method
Radial flow, unsaturated, const. injection pressure
Unidirectional flow, saturated, const. injection pressure
Unidirectional flow, saturated, const. flow rate
Source
Lundström et al. (2000a)
Lundström (2000b)
Pan et al. (2000)
Plain weave glass fibre fabric
0°/90° non-crimp glass fibre fabric
Quadric-axial non-crimp glass fibre fabric
0°/90° non-crimp glass fibre fabric
0°/90° non-crimp glass fibre fabric
Tri-axial non-crimp glass fibre fabric
Plain weave glass fibre fabric
Fabric type
0.382 0.126 2.96
0.54 0.61 0.45
0.45
0.720 0.209 0.996
0.53 0.60 0.49
0.432 0.766
0.57 0.53
1.65
0.378 0.755
0.55 0.53
0.47
0.888
K1/10−10 m2
0.50
Vf
Average
1.30
0.134 0.074
0.243 0.103 0.374
0.685
0.269 0.454
0.264 0.523
0.541
K2/10−10 m2
16% 18% 6%
27% 48% 15%
24%
4% 22%
29% 20%
22%
Var coeff
13%
11% 12%
11% 16% 8%
8%
6% 8%
24% 18%
16%
Table 9.3 Published average values and coefficients of variation of the principal in-plane permeabilities K1 and K2 of different fabrics at different fibre volume fractions Vf
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Radial flow, unsaturated, const. injection pressure
Radial flow, unsaturated, const. injection pressure
Endruweit et al. (2009)
Radial flow, unsaturated, const. injection pressure
Hoes et al. (2004)
Endruweit et al. (2006c)
Radial flow, unsaturated, const. injection pressure
Luo et al. (2001)
Satin weave carbon fibre fabric
Satin weave carbon fibre fabric Plain weave glass fibre fabric Unidirectional carbon fibre fabric
Twill weave glass fibre fabric Continuous glass filament random mat
Plain weave glass fibre fabric
Plain weave glass fibre fabric
6.334
1.395 0.386 1.665 0.557 0.472 0.194
0.58 0.68 0.43 0.52 0.61 0.70
1.240
0.53 0.49
0.328
11.861
2.56
0.56
0.28
0.53
1.79
2.06 0.75
0.49 0.54 0.42
4.73
0.43
0.457 0.208 0.129
0.165 0.067 1.274
1.140
0.650
0.246
10.423
1.23
1.44
1.97 0.69
4.59
1% 10% 8%
22% 36% 11%
8%
29%
18%
29%
19%
22%
6% 17%
18%
6% 9% 2%
20% 55% 8%
14%
26%
12%
28%
14%
20%
6% 33%
20%
228
Non-crimp fabric composites
9.7 Distribution of principal in-plane permeability value K1; histogram and corresponding normal distribution; correlation coefficient R2 = 0.774 (adapted from Endruweit et al., 2006c).
9.8 Distribution of principal in-plane permeability value K2; histogram and corresponding normal distribution; correlation coefficient R2 = 0.430 (adapted from Endruweit et al., 2006c).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric
229
9.9 Distribution of angle θ between fabric weft direction and principal flow direction; histogram and corresponding normal distribution; correlation coefficient R2 = 0.640.
The values of θ, which describe the angle between the main flow direction and the fabric weft direction, lie mainly in the range between 80° and 160° (Fig. 9.9). Visual inspection of the fabric (Fig. 9.4) suggests that the tricot stitching pattern creates more pore space between the fibres on face A than on face B. The difference in porosity, which was also observed and quantified by Lomov et al. (2002) for stitch-bonded carbon fibre NCFs, creates a preferential flow direction. Since the stitching thread on face A is doubled, its influence on the local porosity and permeability is higher than that of the thread on face B, thus resulting in enhanced flow along the thread on face A (in warp direction). Superposition of the effects of flow enhancement along the gaps between the fibres and along the fixation thread suggests that the value of the angle θ is between 90° and 135°. The experimental results show an average angle of 112° (Table 9.2), which indicates that the preferential flow direction is determined mainly by the fibre configuration on face A. A more general overview of the influence of the stitching pattern on the typical impregnation behaviour is given in Chapter 8, Section 8.3. Here, results are discussed in detail for one fibre volume fraction. Results presented elsewhere (Table 9.3) do not imply a dependence of the coefficient of variation on the fibre volume fraction for bi-directional fabrics with similar
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
230
Non-crimp fabric composites
permeability values along both principal fabric directions. However, for unidirectional material with strongly anisotropic permeability, there is a trend for the coefficients of variation of K1 and K2 to increase with increasing number of fabric layers at given cavity height, i.e. increasing fibre volume fraction (Endruweit et al., 2009). This reflects the limited accuracy of the alignment of layers in the stack and a relatively high sensitivity of flow in the unidirectional layers to misalignment. An additional observation based on the values in Table 9.3 is that while there is a dependence of the permeability variations on the fabric architecture, no clear influence of the test protocol can be identified. Detailed analysis of the coefficients of variation of the global permeability for fabrics with different fibre angle variability at similar fibre volume fractions (Endruweit et al., 2006c) suggests that, starting from zero for a hypothetical perfectly uniform fabric structure, the global permeability variations increase rapidly with increasing σα. They reach a maximum at a relatively low σα and then decrease slightly with increasing σα. This decrease suggests that the fabric appears the more uniform at the macro-scale, the higher σα and the maximum frequency of the fibre tow waviness ωmax, i.e. the more periods of waviness there are across the injection tool. Thus, an increase in σα, indicating a continuous increase in local non-uniformity, does not necessarily translate into an increase in variability on a global scale. The through-thickness permeability was determined in saturated unidirectional flow experiments at constant volume flow rate according to Eq. 9.14 (Goulley et al., 1993). The upper estimate for the experimental error of K3 as defined in Eq. 9.15 is approximately 8%. The results of the flow experiments, which were carried out for six fabric layers at a specimen thickness of 4 mm to give the same target fibre volume fraction as for the in-plane experiments, are given in Table 9.4. At an expected error of approximately 2% for the series of Nexp = 21 experiments, the actual coefficient of variation of 17.5% indicates variability in the specimen properties. The distribution of values for K3 and the corresponding normal distribution are plotted in Fig. 9.10. The difference in the actual values of Vf in Tables 9.2 and 9.4 suggests a difference in S0 of 3%, which may be caused by variations between different material batches and the history of the specimens (transport, storage, handling). Table 9.4 Number of experiments Nexp, fibre volume fraction Vf, and principal through-thickness permeability value K3 (mean values, standard deviations and coefficients of variation are given where applicable) Nexp
Vf
K3/10−12 m2
21
0.59 ± 0.01 (±1.5%)
1.961 ± 0.344 (±17.5%)
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric
231
9.10 Distribution of principal through-thickness permeability value K3; histogram and corresponding normal distribution; correlation coefficient R2 = 0.735.
Studies of the through-thickness permeability of any type of fabric are generally sparse. Experimental results were presented by Goulley et al. (1993), Han et al. (2000) and Lundström et al. (2002). Scholz et al. (2007) found comparable results for the through-thickness permeability of various fabrics measured using gas flow and saturated fluid flow. Wu et al. (1994) addressed the problem of permeability changes induced by preform compression, and Endruweit et al. (2002) derived an empirical model for description of the influence of hydrodynamically induced compression on the through-thickness permeability. Drapier et al. (2002) found that the through-thickness permeability of a specific kind of stitch-bonded NCF increases linearly with increasing stitch density. Elbouazzaoui et al. (2005) observed a strong influence of K3 of various NCFs on the orientation of the layers relative to the flow direction, but could not explain their finding. It can be speculated that it may be a result of asymmetrical compression or deformation effects induced by the fluid pressure. Published values of K3 for various non-crimp fabrics and fibre volume fractions are compiled in Table 9.5, which complements Table 8.6. The variability of measured through-thickness permeabilities was quantified by Lundström et al. (2002) for a press fabric used for de-watering of paper. They found coefficients of variation of 12.4% at a fibre volume fraction of 0.63 and a mean permeability of 1.6 × 10−12 m2,
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
232
Non-crimp fabric composites
Table 9.5 Published values of the through-thickness permeability K3 for different types of non-crimp fabric and different fibre volume fractions Vf (coefficients of variation are given where applicable)
σK3/K3
Source
Fabric type
Vf
K3
Wu et al. (1994)
Bi-axial non-crimp glass fibre fabric
0.36
6.1 × 10−11 m2
0.40 0.44 0.49 0.54
4.5 × 10−11 m2 3.4 × 10−11 m2 2.2 × 10−11 m2 1.8 × 10−12 m2
0.36
2 × 10−12 m2
0.43 0.53 0.61 0.68 0.79 0.65
1 × 10−12 m2 8 × 10−13 m2 6 × 10−13 m2 3 × 10−13 m2 7 × 10−14 m2 2.1 × 10−14 m2
0.65 0.65 0.65 0.65 0.65 0.41
2.4 × 10−14 m2 1.1 × 10−13 m2 6.4 × 10−13 m2 1.5 × 10−12 m2 2.5 × 10−13 m2 8.6 × 10−13 m2
9%
0.41 0.52
4.5 × 10−13 m2 2.4 × 10−13 m2
3% 8%
0.52 0.64
10 × 10−13 m2 1.9 × 10−13 m2
15% 13%
0.64 11 × 10−13 m2 No information 1.5 × 10−13 m2 given 6.0 × 10−13 m2
14%
Parnas et al. (1997) Endruweit et al. (2002)
Drapier et al. (2002)
Elbouazzaoui et al. (2005)
Scholz et al. (2007)
±45° non-crimp glass fibre fabric ±45° non-crimp glass fibre fabric
Bi-axial non-crimp carbon fibre fabric, [0]2 unstitched [0/90] unstitched [0/90] 1000 stitches/m2 [0/90] 4000 stitches/m2 [0/90] 16000 stitches/m2 [±45] 4000 stitches/m2 Bi-axial non-crimp carbon fibre fabric, face A Face B Tri-axial non-crimp glass fibre fabric, face A Face B Quadric-axial non-crimp carbon fibre fabric, face A Face B ±45° non-crimp carbon fibre fabric
and 18.6% at a fibre volume fraction of 73% and a mean permeability of 0.55 × 10−12 m2. For the through-thickness permeability of a plain weave glass fibre fabric, Scholz et al. (2007) determined coefficients of variation between 5% and 8%. As the only source to quantify the variability in K3 of various non-crimp fabrics, Elbouazzaoui et al. (2005) quote coefficients of variation between 3% and 15%. At identical target fibre volume fraction, the average values of K1 and K2 differ by a factor of approximately ten from the value of K3. The coefficient of variation is significantly smaller for K3 than for K1 and K2, suggesting that the variabilities
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
Understanding variability in the permeability of non-crimp fabric
233
in the in-plane and through-thickness permeability are caused by different mechanisms. Possible reasons for measured variations in the permeability values exceeding the experimental uncertainty are: • • •
shift of layers relative to each other, affecting the continuity of throughthickness pores; non-uniformity of the fabric superficial density; and increased porosity and permeability along the specimen circumference because of uncontrollable loss of fibre bundle segments.
Results presented by Drapier et al. (2002) imply that the fabric through-thickness permeability is dominated by gaps created around stitches, as illustrated schematically in Fig. 9.5. The influence of flow through fibre bundles is not significant, since the permeability of fibre bundles perpendicular to their axes is small. This suggests high sensitivity to continuity of the gaps through the specimen thickness, but no sensitivity to the actual fibre arrangement. The probability for formation of continuous through-thickness pores depends on the number of layers in the specimen, which may explain the trend for the coefficient of variation in Table 9.4 to be higher than those quoted by Elbouazzaoui et al. (2005) for a single fabric layer. Loss of fibre segments is a defect induced by specimen preparation and can be remedied by sealing of the flow channel along the specimen circumference.
9.4
Modelling and simulation
The range of probable outcomes of resin injections and the global permeability and its standard deviation, or an envelope for the flow front position at a given injection time, can be predicted from evaluation of stochastic flow simulations. The variability in global permeability can be related to the variability in local geometrical