MID-INFRARED COHERENT SOURCES AND APPLICATIONS
NATO Science for Peace and Security Series This Series presents the results of scientific meetings supported under the NATO Programme: Science for Peace and Security (SPS). The NATO SPS Programme supports meetings in the following Key Priority areas: (1) Defence Against Terrorism; (2) Countering other Threats to Security and (3) NATO, Partner and Mediterranean Dialogue Country Priorities. The types of meeting supported are generally "Advanced Study Institutes" and "Advanced Research Workshops". The NATO SPS Series collects together the results of these meetings. The meetings are coorganized by scientists from NATO countries and scientists from NATO's "Partner" or "Mediterranean Dialogue" countries. The observations and recommendations made at the meetings, as well as the contents of the volumes in the Series, reflect those of participants and contributors only; they should not necessarily be regarded as reflecting NATO views or policy. Advanced Study Institutes (ASI) are high-level tutorial courses intended to convey the latest developments in a subject to an advanced-level audience Advanced Research Workshops (ARW) are expert meetings where an intense but informal exchange of views at the frontiers of a subject aims at identifying directions for future action Following a transformation of the programme in 2006 the Series has been re-named and re-organised. Recent volumes on topics not related to security, which result from meetings supported under the programme earlier, may be found in the NATO Science Series. The Series is published by IOS Press, Amsterdam, and Springer, Dordrecht, in conjunction with the NATO Public Diplomacy Division. Sub-Series A. B. C. D. E.
Chemistry and Biology Physics and Biophysics Environmental Security Information and Communication Security Human and Societal Dynamics
http://www.nato.int/science http://www.springer.com http://www.iospress.nl
Series B: Physics and Biophysics
Springer Springer Springer IOS Press IOS Press
MID-INFRARED COHERENT SOURCES AND APPLICATIONS
edited by
Majid Ebrahim-Zadeh ICFO - Institut de Ciències Fotòniques, ICREA - Instituticio Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avancats Barcelona, Spain and
Irina T. Sorokina Norwegian University of Science and Technology Department of Physics Trondheim, Norway
Published in cooperation with NATO Public Diplomacy Division
Results of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Middle Infrared Coherent Sources (MICS) 2005 Barcelona, Spain 6 – 11 November 2005
A C.I.P. Catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress.
ISBN 978-1-4020-6462- 3 (PB) ISBN 978-1-4020-6439-5 (HB) ISBN 978-1-4020-6463-0 (e-book)
Published by Springer, P.O. Box 17, 3300 AA Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
www.springer.com
Printed on acid-free paper
All Rights Reserved © 2008 Springer Science + Business Media B.V. No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work.
PREFACE
Coherent sources of mid-infrared (mid-IR) radiation are of great interest for a wide range of scientific and technological applications from spectroscopy and frequency metrology to information technology, industrial process control, photochemistry, photobiology and photomedicine. The mid-IR spectrum, which may be defined as wavelengths beyond ∼2 µm, covers important atmospheric windows, and numerous molecular gases, toxic agents, air, water, and soil pollutants, components of human breath, and several explosive agents have strong absorption fingerprints in this region. The development of practical coherent solid-state sources in the mid-IR can thus provide indispensable tools for a variety of applications in environmental monitoring and pollution control, detection of water and soil contaminants, food quality control, agriculture and life sciences, and noninvasive disease diagnosis and therapy through breath analysis. Coherent mid-IR sources also offer important technologies for atmospheric chemistry, free-space communication, imaging, rapid detection of explosives, chemical and biological agents, nuclear material and narcotics, as well as applications in air- and sea-born safety and security, amongst many. The timely advancement of coherent mid-IR sources is, therefore, vital to future progress in many application areas across a broad range of scientific, technological, and industrial disciplines. On the other hand, more than 40 years after the invention of laser, much of the mid-IR spectrum still remains inaccessible to conventional lasers due to fundamental limitations, most notably a lack of suitable crystalline laser gain materials. This has confined the spectral range of conventional solid-state lasers mainly to wavelengths below ∼3 µm, resulting in a severe shortage of coherent laser sources at longer wavelengths, and presenting a major obstacle to the widespread advancement of mid-IR science and technology. At the same time, alternative technologies for the generation of mid-IR radiation have been proposed, devised and developed, with the goal of overcoming this persistent barrier. In particular, over the past decade, there have been major new developments in mid-IR sources, driven by the emergence of a number of new technologies and continuing innovations and refinements in many of the more established techniques. Advances in material science, crystal growth, and semiconductor material processing have led to the realisation of a new generation of coherent mid-IR sources based on novel operating principles such as quantum cascade lasers, new types of semiconductor
v
vi
PREFACE
lasers, as well as novel diode-pumped crystalline and fiber lasers based on new solid-state laser gain materials and structures. At the same time, there has been unprecedented progress in some of the more traditional technologies for mid-IR generation, in particular nonlinear frequency conversion and parametric sources, brought about by breakthroughs in nonlinear materials, innovative device design concepts and ongoing advances in pump laser technology. The advent of a new generation of birefringent, quasi-phase-matched, doped, waveguide, fiber and semiconductor nonlinear materials together with novel solid-state, semiconductor, and fiber pump lasers have led to the development of new frequency conversion and parametric sources for the mid-IR with previously unattainable performance capabilities. The ongoing progress in related technologies including synchrotron, free-electron and gas lasers, as well as novel techniques for terahertz (THz) generation have also led to further improvements in such radiation sources with enhanced overall operating capabilities. The important advances in mid-IR science and technology have also had a major impact on new application areas, paving the way for the practical deployment of mid-IR sources in spectroscopy, environmental trace gas detection and sensing, life sciences, imaging, safety and security, and photomedicine. The wide range of mid-IR technologies have proved highly effective in advancing coherent sources in selected spectral regions from ∼1 to ∼100 µm, and beyond, into the THz region. The various techniques are often competitive, and in many cases complimentary. Some technologies can deliver mid-IR radiation in regions not accessible to others, while suffering from drawbacks of low power, temporal and spectral inflexibility, or high cost. There are important merits and limitations associated with each approach, making a particular technology more favorable for a given set of requirements and applications than others. However, the broad scope and multi-disciplinary nature of mid-IR technology across a wide range of disciplines (from semiconductor physics and laser engineering to nonlinear optics, material science, spectroscopy and biomedicine) has, at the same time, led to the confinement of each technology mainly to its own specialist community, resulting in a lack of connectivity among the different areas. This factor, in addition to the fundamental barriers, has contributed yet another important obstacle to a more timely advancement of mid-IR science and technology. The aim of this book is to bring into focus this important research area and provide a comprehensive review of the research topics most pertinent to the advancement of coherent mid-IR sources and their applications. The volume brings together contributions from the most eminent international researchers in the field, covering various aspects of mid-IR technology from fundamental principles to materials, systems and applications, and addresses the most important recent advances in the field since the publication of an earlier volume in 2003 (SolidState Mid-Infrared Laser Sources, I. T. Sorokina and K. L. Vodopyanov, Eds., Springer, 2003). A central theme of the present volume is the strong emphasis on
PREFACE
vii
the applications of mid-IR sources to emerging areas of science and technology, with no less than 8 out of the 22 chapters dedicated to this topic. These include spectroscopic techniques for trace gas detection and sensing in environmental monitoring, life sciences, safety and security, applications of mid-IR sources in breath analysis and medicine, as well as potential applications in high-intensity and attosecond physics. It is hoped that this volume will also provide added stimulus for further progress in the field, where major challenges still remain and great potential exists for further new breakthroughs. The timely advancement of midIR coherent sources will undoubtedly have important implications across a broad range of scientific and technological disciplines and the field promises to remain a fertile ground for further innovation and exploitation in the future. In preparing the book, we have relied on the timely contribution of the authors, without whose expert insight, motivation and commitment the publication of this volume would not have been possible. We, thus, extend our appreciation to all the authors. We also convey our thanks to Springer for affording us the opportunity to publish this volume and to the editorial and publishing staff, in particular Wil Bruins, for their assistance, organization and efficiency in coordinating the timely preparation and production of the book. We are also grateful to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization for their valuable support of the Advanced Research Workshop on Mid-Infrared Coherent Sources (MICS) 2005, Barcelona, Spain, which served as the original impetus for the publication of this volume. Majid Ebrahim-Zadeh, Irina T. Sorokina Barcelona, Vienna, October 2006
CONTENTS
Preface
v
I CRYSTALLINE LASER AND NONLINEAR OPTICAL MATERIALS FOR THE MID-IR 1. New Monocrystals with Low Phonon Energy for Mid-IR Lasers L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, A. Tkachuk, and S. Ivanova 1 Introduction 2 Crystal growth and common properties of RE-doped MPb2 Hal5 (M = K, Rb; Hal = Cl, Br) crystals 2.1 Crystal growth 2.2 Phase transitions 2.3 Structural analysis 2.4 Optical properties of undoped MPb2 Hal5 crystals 2.5 Key physical properties 3 Spectroscopic characteristics of RE3+ ions in MPb2 Hal5 crystals 3.1 Optical spectra and spectroscopic parameters 3.2 Emission spectra in low concentrated crystals 4 Energy transfer and dynamics of RE3+ levels population 4.1 Upconversion processes in praseodymium doped KPC crystals 4.2 Upconversion and dynamics of neodymium levels population 4.3 Upconversion and dynamics of erbium levels population 5 Conclusion 2. Orthorhombic Crystals of Lithium Thioindate and Selenoindate for Nonlinear Optics in the Mid-IR J.-J. Zondy, V. Petrov, A. Yelisseyev, L. Isaenko, and S. Lobanov 1 Introduction 2 Development, growth, composition, and structure of LIS and LISe 3 Band-gap, transparency, and IR cut-off of LIS and LISe 4 Dispersion and birefringence of LIS and LISe 5 Nonlinear susceptibility of LIS and LISe
ix
3 3 6 6 8 9 11 19 20 22 38 46 48 49 55 59 67 67 69 73 75 77
x
CONTENTS
6 7 8
9
Thermo-mechanical properties and damage resistivity of LIS and LISe Phase-matching in LIS and LISe Nonlinear frequency conversion with LIS and LISe 8.1 Mid-IR femtosecond OPA 8.2 Continuous-wave DFG of mid-IR radiation 8.3 Nanosecond OPO Conclusion
3. Quaternary Nonlinear Optical Crystals for the Mid-Infrared Spectral Range from 5 to 12 µm V. Petrov, V. Badikov, and V. Panyutin 1 Introduction 2 Mixed defect chalcopyrites Cdx Hg1−x Ga2 S4 2.1 Growth and properties of CGS, HGS, and CHGS 2.2 Potential and frequency conversion schemes realized with quaternary CHGS crystals 3 Orthorhombic Agx Gax Ge1−x S2 crystals 3.1 Growth and properties of AGGS 3.2 Potential and frequency conversion schemes realized with quaternary AGGS crystals 4 Conclusion 4. Microstructured Semiconductors for Mid-Infrared Nonlinear Optics P. S. Kuo and M. M. Fejer 1 Introduction 2 Properties of zincblende semiconductors 2.1 Dispersion 2.2 Nonlinear susceptibilities 3 Fabrication of microstructured zincblende semiconductors 3.1 Stacked plate methods 3.2 Orientation-patterned growth 4 QPM in bulk microstructured zincblende semiconductors 4.1 Mid-IR SHG 4.2 Mid-IR DFG 4.3 Optical parametric oscillators 4.4 Ultrafast interactions 4.5 THz 5 Current research directions 5.1 Waveguides 5.2 Other QPM semiconductors
82 85 90 90 93 95 97 105 105 107 107 117 125 125 133 140 149 149 150 151 151 154 154 155 158 158 159 159 160 164 164 164 164
CONTENTS
xi
II SOURCES IN THE MID-IR 1. Progress in Quantum Cascade Lasers J. Faist, T. Aellen, T. Gresch, M. Beck, and M. Giovannini 1 Introduction 2 Optimization of doping level 3 High power devices 4 Linewidth enhancement factor 5 Acknowledgements 2. High-Brightness 2.X µm Semiconductor Lasers M. Rattunde, M. T. Kelemen, N. Schulz, C. Pfahler, C. Manz, J. Schmitz, G. Kaufel, and J. Wagner 1 Introduction 2 III-Sb based material system 2.1 Material properties 2.2 Growth 3 High brightness GaSb-based diode lasers 3.1 Active region design 3.2 Vertical epitaxial structure 3.3 Broad-area lasers 3.4 Ridge-waveguide lasers 3.5 Tapered lasers 4 GaSb-based optically pumped semiconductor disk lasers 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Epitaxial layer structure and sample characterization 4.3 Thermal management 4.4 OPSDL device performance 4.5 In-well optical pumping 5 Outlook 3. Broadband Mid-Infrared Solid-State Lasers I. T. Sorokina 1 Introduction 1.1 Motivation 1.2 Applications 2 Bandwidth and wavelength scaling rules 3 TM2+ -based solid-state lasers 3.1 Historical perspective and state-of-the-art sources 3.2 Co:MgF2 laser 3.3 Cr2+ -doped II-VI lasers 4 Conclusion and outlook 5 Acknowledgements
171 171 174 179 184 189 193
193 195 195 196 197 198 200 203 207 208 211 211 212 213 214 215 218 225 225 225 226 228 230 230 232 234 252 253
xii
CONTENTS
4. New Regimes of Excitation and Mid-IR Lasing of Transition Metal Doped II–VI Crystals S. Mirov and V. Fedorov 1 Introduction 2 Non-traditional Cr-doped mid-IR lasers 2.1 Cr:ZnSe and Cr:ZnS microchip lasers 2.2 Hot pressed ceramic Cr:ZnSe lasers 2.3 Multi-line and ultrabroadband Cr:Znse laser 3 Fe-doped mid-IR lasers 3.1 Iron ions in II–VI materials 3.2 Sample preparation 3.3 Spectroscopic characterization 3.4 Fe2+ :ZnSe laser characteristics 4 En-route to electrically pumped TM doped II–VI mid-IR lasers 4.1 TM-doped II–VI thin films for mid-IR applications 4.2 Excitation mechanisms of TM dopant ions in II–VI bulk semiconductors 4.3 Experimental verification of photoionization transitions 4.4 Future directions 5 Conclusion remarks 6 Acknowledgements 5. Advances in Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers M. Pollnau and S. D. Jackson 1 Introduction 2 Fiber materials 2.1 Silicates 2.2 Fluorides 2.3 Chalcogenides 2.4 Ceramics 3 Fiber, pump, and resonator geometries 3.1 Fiber designs for cladding pumping 3.2 Fiber-laser resonators 3.3 Thermal issues 4 Overview of mid-infrared fiber lasers 5 Thulium-doped fiber lasers at 1.9–2.5 µm 5.1 Three-level lasers at 1.9–2.0 µm 5.2 Four-level lasers at 2.3–2.5 µm 6 Holmium-doped fiber lasers at 2.1–2.9 µm 6.1 Three-level lasers at 2.1 µm 6.2 Four-level lasers at 2.9 µm
261 261 263 263 266 268 272 272 274 275 279 285 285 291 294 300 302 303 315 315 316 317 318 318 319 319 320 321 322 323 324 324 326 326 327 328
CONTENTS
7
8 9 10
Erbium-doped fiber lasers at 2.7–2.8 µm 7.1 Excited-state absorption and cascade lasing 7.2 Lifetime quenching by co-doping 7.3 Energy recycling by energy-transfer upconversion Dysprosium-doped fiber lasers at 2.9 µm Outlook Conclusions
6. Mid-Infrared Optical Parametric Oscillators and Applications M. Ebrahim-Zadeh 1 Introduction 2 Mid-infrared optical parametric oscillators 3 Continuous-wave parametric oscillators 3.1 Singly-resonant oscillators 3.2 Multiply-resonant oscillators 4 Pulsed parametric oscillators 5 Applications 6 Summary 7. Mid-Infrared Integrated Optical Parametric Generators and Oscillators with Periodically Poled Ti:LiNbO3 Waveguides S. Orlov, W. Grundk¨otter, D. Hofmann, V. Quiring, R. Ricken, H. Suche, and W. Sohler 1 Introduction 2 Waveguide and resonator fabrication and characterization 3 Experimental setup 4 Optical parametric generators (OPG) 5 Optical parametric oscillators (OPOs) 5.1 Singly resonant oscillators 5.2 Doubly resonant oscillators 6 Conclusions 8. Optical Parametric Generators and Amplifiers V. Pasiskevicius and F. Laurell 1 Introduction 2 Parametric generation and amplification 2.1 Theoretical basis 2.2 Phase matching considerations 3 Broadband optical parametric generation and amplification 3.1 Collinear interaction 3.2 Noncollinear parametric interaction 4 Conclusions and future outlook
xiii 329 330 331 333 335 335 337 347 347 348 350 352 356 357 366 371 377
377 378 380 381 384 385 387 390 393 393 394 394 398 404 404 409 412
xiv
CONTENTS
9. Tunable THz Sources Based on Quasi-Phase-Matched Gallium Arsenide K. Vodopyanov 1 Introduction 2 Theory of optical THz generation in QPM media 2.1 Plane wave analysis, femtosecond pulses 2.2 Plane-wave analysis, picosecond pulses 3 Comparison of nonlinear optical crystals for THz generation 4 THz generation with fs-pulses from OPA/DFG (λ = 2– 4.4 µm) 5 THz generation using OP-GaAs pumped by a fiber laser 6 THz generation with a near-degenerate synchronously-pumped ps OPO 6.1 Extracavity THz generation 6.2 Intracavity THz generation 7 Conclusion 10. Semiconductor Waveguides for Nonlinear Frequency Conversion L. Lanco, M. Ravaro, J. P. Likforman, P. Filloux, X. Marcadet, S. Ducci, G. Leo, and V. Berger 1 Introduction 2 Form birefringence phase matching 3 Modal phase matching 4 Counterpropagating phase matching
III
419 419 421 421 424 427 428 432 434 436 437 439 443
443 444 448 453
APPLICATIONS
1. Semiconductor Laser Based Trace Gas Sensor Technology: Recent Advances and Applications F. K. Tittel, G. Wysocki, A. Kosterev, and Y. Bakhirkin 1 Introduction 2 Trace gas detection based on photoacoustic spectroscopy using QC and IC lasers 2.1 Photoacoustic spectroscopic techniques 2.2 Quartz enhanced photoacoustic spectroscopic techniques 2.3 QEPAS based chemical sensor architecture 3 Chemical sensing based on tunable thermoelectrically cooled CW quantum cascade lasers. Gas sensing with a cw DFB QC laser was first reported in Ref. [54]. 3.1 Detection of trace gases with widely tunable QC lasers 3.2 EC-QCL system configuration 4 Trace gas sensors using a high-finesse optical cavity 4.1 Cavity ringdown spectroscopy
467 467 470 470 471 478
481 481 482 484 485
CONTENTS
xv
4.2 Cavity enhanced absorption spectroscopy Conclusions
486 487
2. Trace Gas Analysis with Isotopic Selectivity Using DFG-Sources H. Waechter and M. Sigrist 1 Introduction 2 Mid-infrared laser sources 3 Detection schemes 4 Applications in trace gas sensing 5 Studies on isotopic compositions of trace gases 6 DFG-studies on CO, CO2 and N2 O isotopomers 6.1 DFG-source 6.2 Isotopomer abundances and line strengths 6.3 Measurements and results 7 Conclusions and outlook
495
5
3. Photoacoustic Spectroscopy Using Continuous Wave Optical Parametric Oscillators A. K. Y. Ngai, S. T. Persijn, M. M. J. W. van Herpen, S. M. Cristescu, and F. J. M. Harren 1 Introduction 2 Physical basics of optical parametric oscillators 2.1 QUASI phase matching in periodically poled crystals 2.2 Periodically poled lithium niobate 3 OPO cavity design 3.1 Oscillation threshold for singly resonant OPO 4 Frequency tuning with OPO’s 4.1 Tuning by changing the poling period and temperature 4.2 Tuning with intracavity elements 4.3 Pump tuning 4.4 Tuning by changing the cavity length 4.5 Frequency tuning by using a combination of tuning techniques 4.6 Wavelength coverage 5 High-resolution spectroscopy with cw OPO’s 6 Trace gas detection with OPO’s 6.1 Photoacoustic spectroscopy 6.2 Photoacoustics with CW OPO’s 6.3 CO2 monitoring from insect breath 6.4 Detection of methane and ethane using OPO cavity ring-down spectroscopy
495 496 498 498 499 501 501 502 503 506 511
511 514 514 515 516 518 518 519 520 521 522 522 523 524 524 525 526 527 527
xvi
CONTENTS
4. Online Monitoring of Exhaled Breath Using Mid-Infrared Laser Spectroscopy M. M¨urtz and P. Hering 1 Introduction 2 The role of trace gases in medicine and biology 2.1 Trace constituents of exhaled human breath 2.2 Other biological sources of volatile markers 3 Suitable laser spectroscopic approaches for online analysis 3.1 Multi-pass absorption 3.2 Cavity-enhanced techniques 3.3 Photoacoustics 3.4 Magnetic resonance 4 Monitoring of exhaled diseasemarkers 4.1 Nitric Oxide (NO) 4.2 Carbon monoxide (CO) 4.3 Ethane 5 Perspectives for laser spectroscopic breath monitoring 6 Acknowledgements 5. Ultrabroadband Solid-State Lasers in Trace Gas Sensing E. Sorokin 1 Introduction 2 Cr2+ -based mid-IR lasers 3 Trace gas analysis in the atmosphere 4 Intracavity laser spectroscopy 5 Conclusions 6. Medical Applications of Mid-IR Solid-State Lasers R. Steiner 1 Introduction 2 Laser-tissue-interaction 3 Transmission systems 4 Medical applications 4.1 Holmium and thulium laser 4.2 Er:YAG laser 5 Conclusions and future aspects 7. Opportunities for Mid-IR Sources in Intense-Field and Attosecond Physics M. Ivanov, V. Yakovlev, and F. Krausz
535 535 537 537 539 540 542 542 543 544 545 545 546 547 549 549 557 557 558 560 563 571 575 575 576 580 583 583 583 587 589
CONTENTS
xvii
8. Ultrawideband Mid-Infrared Spectroscopy of Semiconductor Nanostructures T. M¨uller and K. Unterrainer 1 Introduction 2 Generation and detection of ultrawideband mid-infrared pulses 2.1 Sources of ultrawideband mid-infrared pulses 2.2 Time-domain detection of mid-infrared pulses 3 Intersubband carrier dynamics in quantum wells 3.1 Intersubband electron relaxation in quantum wells 3.2 Quantum interference of intersubband transitions 4 Intraband carrier dynamics in quantum dots 4.1 Electronic states and optical intraband transitions 4.2 Electron capture and relaxation in quantum dots
599 600 600 603 605 605 609 614 614 615
Index
623
599
Part I
Crystalline Laser and Nonlinear Optical Materials for the Mid-IR
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY FOR MID-IR LASERS New Monocrystals LUDMILA ISAENKO, ALEXANDER YELISSEYEV Institute of Geology & Mineralogy, Russian Academy of Sciences, Siberian branch, 3, ac. Koptyug avenue, Novosibirsk 630090 Russian Federation ALEXANDRA TKACHUK∗ , SVETLANA IVANOVA S.I. Vavilov State Optical Institute, 12, Birzhevaja line, St. Petersburg 199034 Russian Federation
Abstract. Various aspects of crystal growth, structure, physical and optical properties of new low phonon energy crystals, namely the rare earth doped alkali-lead halide crystals RE3+ : MPb2 Hal5 (M = Rb, K and Hal = Cl, Br), are described. The crystals were grown using the Bridgman technique, most of crystals were grown for the first time. The results of spectroscopic study of the RE3+ -doped double chloride crystals, RE3+ :KPb2 Cl5 (RE3+ = Pr3+ , Nd3+ , Tb3+ , Dy3+ , Ho3+ , Er3+ , Yb3+ ), and new double bromide KPb2 Br5 and RbPb2 Br5 crystals doped with Nd3+ and Tb3+ are presented, including multiphonon non-radiative relaxation rates, and absorption and emission spectra. Judd-Ofelt intensity parameters, as well as radiative transition probabilities, lifetimes, and branching ratios are summarized. The efficiency of up-conversion is demonstrated in Nd and Er doped KPb2 Cl5 crystals. The luminescence dynamics and energy transfer processes responsible for population of excited RE3+ levels and laser action are discussed. The possibility of laser action in the mid-infrared is considered. Keywords: Double alkali-lead halides, crystal growth, phase transitions, crystal structure, optical properties, rare earth ions, optical spectra, phonon spectrum, absorption cross section, energy transfer, upconversion, multiphonon relaxation, population dynamics, laser action.
1. Introduction Mid-infrared (mid-IR) solid state lasers operating in the 3–10 µm spectral range are of great importance because of the overwhelming variety of fundamental and practical applications such as next-generation imaging devices, near-IR quantum ∗ Alexandra Tkachuk, P.O. box 37, St. Petersburg 195197, RUSSIA. Fax +7(812)328 58 91;
e-mail:
[email protected] 3 M. Ebrahim-Zadeh and I. T. Sorokina (eds.), Mid-Infrared Coherent Sources and Applications, 3–65. c 2008 Springer.
4
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
counting devices, remote sensing, molecular and solid state spectroscopy, clinical and diagnostic analysis, atmospheric sensing, optical metrology, and medicine. Currently, optical parametric oscillator systems are typically used to cover these wavelengths. These systems incorporate both nonlinear media and pump laser sources, leading to some complexity of the optical system. Another simpler approach to solve these problems is direct mid-IR laser operation in solid-state media. In this case, direct pumping of the working laser level is of specific interest for the development of mid-IR lasers with high efficiency. To achieve an acceptable quantum efficiency from a given energy level it is necessary to avoid luminescence quenching via multiphonon relaxation depending on energy gap and maximal phonon energy in given host material. Therefore, the host material must have low phonon frequency, which will ensure low non-radiative losses. Multiphonon quenching of closely-spaced energy levels limits laser operation to wavelengths near and shorter than 3 µm in host-matrices based on the oxygen-containing compounds (e.g. YAG, YSGG, GGG, YAlO3 , YVO4 , CaWO4 ) doped with Rare Earth (RE) ions [1]. More success has been achieved with laser operation in the range shorter than 4 µm with rare-earth-doped fluoride hosts, having effective phonon frequency of 400–560 cm−1 , about two times lower then in the oxygen containing compounds. Under direct pumping, laser action with double fluoride crystals has been achieved at 2.8–2.9 µm on Er3+ laser transition 4 I11/2 → 4 I13/2 in LiYF4 [2–15], BaY2 F8 [16–19], Na0.4 Y0.6 F2.2 [20], on Ho3+ laser transition 5 I6 → 5 I7 in BaYb2 F8 [21, 22], LiYbF4 [23], and at 3.0–3.4 µm on Dy3+ laser transition 6 H13/2 → 6 H15/2 in Ba(Y, Yb)2 F8 [24, 25] and LaF3 [26]. Laser action at 3.4–4.4 µm has been achieved on Dy3+ laser transition 6 H11/2 → 6 H13/2 in YLF [27]; on Ho3+ laser transitions 5 S2 → 5 F5 [28] and 5 I5 → 5 I6 [29] in LiYF4 , and on Pr3+ laser transition 1 G4 → 3 F4 in BaYb2 F8 [30]. Currently, the RE-doped sulfide and chloride hosts attract particular attention due to the possibility of laser action beyond the 4-µm limit owing to their lower vibrational frequencies and higher quantum yields. These low phonon energy hosts have extremely low non-radiative rates and have been demonstrated to be very advantageous for direct diode-pumped solid-state lasers operating in the 3–9 µm region [31–40]. Room temperature laser action in Dy3+ -doped CaGa2 S4 crystal at 4.31 µm was first reported in [37]. Tunable room-temperature laser action near 4.3–4.4 µm has been demonstrated in low-phonon-energy nonhygroscopic sulfide host (calcium thiogallate CaGa2 S4 ) doped with Dy3+ , and it was noted that the 4.3 µm laser emission is in accordance with the five-times-maximal phonon energy rule of thumb, suggesting that laser emission up to 5.7 µm is possible. Some advantages in output laser efficiency of Dy3+ -doped lead thiogallate (PbGa2 S4 :Dy3+ ) over CaGa2 S4 was demonstrated in [41]. The longest laser wavelength of 7.2 µm has been achieved with the low-phonon-energy host lanthanum trichloride (LaCl3 ) doped with Pr3+ [42].
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
5
However, Pr:LaCl3 crystal has the disadvantage of being highly hygroscopic and lasing at low temperatures (T < 200 K). An important step towards practicality was made when the rare-earth-doped alkali-lead halide crystals MPb2 Hal5 (M = Rb, K and Hal = Cl, Br) were identified as promising new low-phonon-energy host materials for mid-IR applications. First, potassium-lead double chloride crystals KPb2 Cl5 (KPC) were synthesized and studied in 1993 [43]. They show high chemical resistance, satisfactory mechanical properties, and have low hygroscopicity, unlike the known simple tri-chloride crystals (RE:LnCl3 ). The KPC material was assigned a promising new laser host material for rareearth ion doping, and having narrow phonon spectrum (h¯ ω0 ∼203 cm−1 ) [44]. The KPC crystal was found to exhibit superior spectroscopic and mechanical properties desirable for practical solid-state mid-IR lasers. Direct pump laser action in Er3+ :KPC at both 1.7 and 4.5 µm from the erbium 4 I9/2 manifold has been demonstrated [45]. In Nd3+ :KPC, laser operation was obtained on the 4 F3/2 → 4 I11/2 transition at 1.06 µm with a slope efficiency of 7.7 % [38] and in Dy3+ :KPC laser action was demonstrated on the (6 H9/2 + 6 F11/2 ) → 6 H13/2 transition at 2.43 µm [37]. New IR emission in Dydoped KPC single crystals around 1.55 µm on the promising 6 F5/2 → 6 H11/2 laser transition is also reported [46]. Narrower phonon spectra are exhibited by bromide crystals. The alkali-lead bromide crystals (RbPb2 Br5 and CsPbBr3 ) were grown first in 1995 and the results of the study of crystal growth and luminescence properties were reported [47]. An efficient purification procedure of starting bromides was proposed and single crystals without cracks, 20 mm in diameter and 30–50 mm in length, have been prepared. Luminescence of undoped RbPb2 Br5 crystal was measured for the first time [47]. The rare-earth-doped potassium-lead bromide (KPb2 Br5 or KPB) and rubidium-lead bromide (RbPb2 Br5 or RPB) crystals have properties similar to that of KPC crystals, but lower phonon cut-off energy (∼140 cm−1 ) [48]. They may be considered as the best matrix for minimizing the primary cause of the passive losses in laser rod arising from nonradiative multiphonon relaxation, therefore, these hosts permit lasing at longer wavelengths with extremely low thermal losses. Laser action in near-IR was demonstrated in Nd3+ -doped KPB and RPB crystals [48]. Spectroscopic study of the Tb3+ :KPB crystals gave evidence that room-temperature laser action should be possible in the mid-IR up to 9 µm [48]. Thus, the rare-earth-doped potassium- and rubidium-lead double halogenides MPb2 Hal5 (M = K, Rb; Hal = Cl, Br) can be considered as promising new materials emitting in a wide spectral range from the UV to mid IR. Interest in these crystals continues to increase each year. Having low hygroscopicity, high chemical resistance, good mechanical properties, and low maximal-phonon
6
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
frequency, they are readily manufactured and available in a large size of high optical quality for applications in solid-state lasers. The low phonon frequency of chloride and bromide crystals allows rare-earth ions to serve as favorable luminescent centers for laser action over a wide range in the IR and UV-visible spectral regions, where the luminescence of fluoride and oxide crystals is quenched by fast multiphonon relaxation. In the present work we considered the crystal growth, physical and optical properties of new laser crystals based on RE3+ -doped alkali-lead halide matrices, which are suitable for diode-pumped IR, visible and UV lasers. The RE3+ -doped double chloride crystals, RE3+ :KPb2 Cl5 (RE3+ = Pr3+ , Nd3+ , Tb3+ , Dy3+ , Ho3+ , Er3+ , Tm3+ , Yb3+ ), and new double bromides KPb2 Br5 and RbPb2 Br5 doped with Nd3+ and Tb3+ , were grown using the Bridgman technique. Most crystals were grown for the first time. Multiphonon non-radiative relaxation rates were estimated for the studied hosts. The absorption and luminescence spectra, Judd-Ofelt intensity parameters, calculated radiative transition probabilities, lifetimes and branching ratios are summarized. The intense luminescent bands in the UV, visible, and near-IR spectral regions show that all excited levels of RE3+ ions separated by energy gap of E > 1400 cm−1 in chlorides and of E > 1000 cm−1 in bromides are radiative, including 4 I9/2 (Er), 5 I5 (Ho), and 4 F5/2 (Nd) levels, which are considerably quenched in oxides and fluorides. The combination of the high intensity of luminescent transitions and long lifetime of rare-earth radiative levels, together with efficient up-conversion processes, permit us to conclude that MPb2 Hal5 :RE3+ crystals may be considered as promising new luminescent materials for UV, mid-IR, and visible laser-diode-pumped lasers. 2. Crystal growth and common properties of RE-doped MPb2 Hal5 (M = K, Rb; Hal = Cl, Br) crystals 2.1. CRYSTAL GROWTH
Synthesis of MPb2 Hal5 compounds with M = K, Rb, Hal = Cl, Br was performed from high purity chloride salts. The starting high purity (99.999%) reagents, PbCl5 , PbBr2 , KCl, KBr, RbCl and RbBr, were additionally purified by repeated directed crystallization by preliminarily removing of dirty parts. REHal3 was synthesized from RE oxides, 99.99%, with further distillation. The MPb2 Hal5 (M = K, Rb, Hal = Cl, Br) single crystals were grown using Bridgman technique in soldered ampoules with halogen atmosphere [32, 40, 43, 49–51]. To prevent compound decomposition, the internal ampoule pressure exceeded the atmospheric pressure. As follows from phase diagrams (Figure 1), KPC, KPB and RPB melt congruently at 434, 382 and 404◦ C, respectively [49, 52]. Linear temperature gradient in a growth zone of the furnace was ∼20 ◦ /cm and the rate
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
7
Figure 1. Phase diagrams for KCl-PbCl2 (a), KBr-PbBr2 (b) and RbBr-PbBr2 (c) [49, 52].
of ampoule translation into cold zone was 2 to 4 mm/day. We found regimes for obtaining single crystals of both undoped and RE-doped MPb2 Hal5 compounds with M = K, Rb, Hal = Cl, and Br, of optical quality and with sizes ∼15 mm in diameter and up to 40 mm long. Generally, halides such as chlorides and bromides hydrolyse and therefore crystals contain some products of hydrolysis. The most frequent radicals in MHal are anions like (OH)− , (O2 )− , and (CO2 )2− [51]. When heated, PbHal2 not only hydrolyses but also decomposes. Moreover, if the material contains water molecules or other impurities, decomposition increases. Because RE-doped halides as well as the halide components of MPb2 Hal5 are sensitive to oxygen and moisture, it is imperative that both O2 and H2 O be strictly excluded from the system. The best results are obtained when both PbHal2 and MHal were dried in a vacuum and treated afterwards in Ar-CHal4 atmosphere. It is important also to prevent any contact between purified material and air (i.e. oxygen and water) in both the handling operations of starting materials and the single-crystal growth process. Segregation coefficient, K, for halide crystals (where K is the ratio of RE concentration in crystal to RE concentration in melt for specific RE dopant), was determined by both crystal type and RE ion type: it varies from 0.1 to 1 (Figure 2). The segregation coefficient depends considerably on the difference between sizes of RE and Pb ions. It is minimal for small Yb ions and reaches unity for large Nd ions. Growth conditions for obtaining high quality crystals depend strongly on existence of phase transitions in the solid below melting temperature. Such
8
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
Figure 2. Segregation coefficients for RE ions in KPC. The Pb radii are given for cubic and octahedral coordination.
transitions are often a reason for twin structure formation and sharply worsen the optical quality of the crystal. 2.2. PHASE TRANSITIONS
Using a set of optical techniques such as differential scanning microcalorimetry, temperature dependence of birefringence and turning angle of optical indicatrix, the phase transitions were studied in MPb2 Hal5 (M = K, Rb, Hal = Cl, Br) crystals in the 270 to 620 K temperature range [53, 54]. Depending on the ratios of ionic radii, M/Hal and Pb/Hal, these compounds can be related to two structural types: monoclinic P21 /c and tetragonal I4/mcm [55]. Examinations showed phase transitions at 530 K/528 K in KPC and at 519.5/518.5 K in KPB in the heating/cooling regimes, respectively. The obtained data are in good agreement with previous data [52]. Phase transition is accompanied by a birefringence jump and a temperature hysteresis, which are typical of first type transitions. Geometry of twinning and turning of optical indicatrix shows that the phase is monoclinic with second-order axis along [010] at room temperature, which is in agreement with the P21 /c symmetry. As follows from observations in polarized light a high temperature phase has rhombic symmetry. This phase transition is related to ferroelastic ones of first type, with ∆H = 1000 ± 200 J/mol and 1300 ± 200 J/mol enthalpy changes for KPC and KPB, respectively. The transition is accompanied by twinning and mmm ←→ P21 /c symmetry changes. As a result of such transition, a component of shear spontaneous deformation appears and crystal is broken into twins with a ±ϕ turning around [010] for optical indicatrix. One can see in Figure 3 that temperature dependence ϕ = ϕ(T) is very unusual for KPC: at room temperature ϕ angle is small (only ∼1 to 2◦ as follows from points 1). This value remains constant with heating and it increases to only 5◦ near phase transition, but
Angle ϕ, deg
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
9
4 1 2 2
0 300
400
500
600
Temperature, K
Figure 3. Temperature dependence for a turning angle of the optical indicatrix ϕ(T) for KPC (1) and RPC (2) [54].
falls to zero afterwards. With further heating, extinction in the sample does not change. For RPC (points 2 in Figure 3) a value of off-orientation angle between adjacent areas does not change up to the melting temperature. There is no phase transition here and as a result we see no twin structure. The same situation (no twins, no phase transitions) also takes place in RPB, which crystallizes in tetragonal structure. Thus change of halogen ion and passing from chlorides to bromides in an MPb2 Hal5 family slightly decreases a boundary for rhombic phase stability, whereas a cation change with passing from potassium to rubidium increases this temperature, shifting the phase transition to the liquid state of the compound. Thus, RPB structure has tetragonal I4/mcm symmetry and this structure is stable up to the melting temperature. 2.3. STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
Previously crystal structure of double chlorides was studied [56–58]. The single crystal structural analysis was carried out for all crystals of MPb2 Hal5 family using a STOE STADI4 diffractometer with a Mo Kα radiation. The refined lattice parameters for MPb2 Hal5 crystals are given in TABLE 1. In MPb2 Hal5 structure one can distinguish the layers from polyhedrons KHal9 and Pb(1)Hal9 , bound together by joint triangular faces: these layers are alternating along direction perpendicular to x axis (Figure 4). The Pb(2) ions are in asymmetric anionic cavities (Figure 4). The K and Pb(1) polyhedrons are tri-cap trigonal prisms, whereas Pb(2)Hal8 polyhedron is close to a tetragonal antiprism. Asymmetry in Pb(2) position in a Hal6 cycle brings to an umbrella character of cations location in polyhedrons. Cavities for Pb in chloride matrix and even to a larger extent in bromide matrix are too large for a Pb2+ cation: as a result Pb ions are shifted outside cavity center in both positions and pressed to one of the
10
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. TABLE 1. Crystal
KPb2 Cl5 KPb2 Br5 RbPb2 Cl5 RbPb2 Br5
Symmetry
P21 /c P21 /c P21 /c I 4/mcm
Results of structural analysis for MPb2 Hal5 [59]. Lattice parameters, Z = 4 3
˚ a(A)
˚ b(A)
˚ c(A)
β, degrees
˚ ) V(A
8.854(2) 9.256(2) 8.959(2) 8.43(1)
7.927(2) 8.365(2) 7.973(2) 8.43(1)
12.485(3) 13.025(3) 12.492(5) 14.54(1)
90.05(3) 90.00(3) 90.12(2) 90
876.3(4) 1008.4(4) 892.3(4) 1033(4)
Figure 4. The KPB structure presented as combination of K and Pb(1) polyhedrons.
cavity walls. Imperfection of single crystal KPB samples depends strongly on a microtwin structure. Study of samples with different microtwinning brought one to the following conclusion: microtwinning results in increase of the sample volume and a decrease of monoclinic angle to 90◦ ; in other words microtwinning results in pseudorhombic unit cell. Optical measurements in polarized light showed that twin sizes are of about several microns, whereas the twinning pattern depends on thermal prehistory of the sample. In Figure 5 two KPC crystallographic unit cells are shown. One can see that YZ plane is close to a mirror plane. After twinning operation relative to the X (-x,y,z) axis, one obtains K , Pb and Cl positions, which are close to positions of these atoms in the initial cells. Maximal distances between atom ˚ positions in the initial cell and in the twin cell are 0.11, 0.16, 0.64 and 1.03 A for Pb(1)-Pb(1) , K-K , Cl(2)-Cl(2) and Pb(2)-Pb(2) , respectively. For other Cl ˚ Thus distances between atom positions atoms these distances are less than 0.1 A. of corresponding atoms in initial and twin cells are less than a half of the bond
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
11
Figure 5. Superposition of two crystallographic unit cells in the KPC structure. One type of unit cell is shown at left from the central vertical line and the other one, obtained after twinning operation (1-x, y, z), is shown at right.
length. Maximal shift is observed for Pb(2), which corresponds to atom jump from one half of the elongated Cl6 cycle in YZ plane to another half of the cycle. This allows one to suppose that twinning happens by hopping mechanism at crystal cooling and depends considerably on a set of point and extended defects, which are formed during crystal growth. The β angle is close to 90◦ for crystals under consideration, which promotes twinning relative to Y and Z axes. The RE ions incorporation into crystal lattice is supposed to go with Pb ions substitution, whereas formation of K vacancy provides local charge compensation. 2.4. OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF UNDOPED MPB2 HAL5 CRYSTALS
Since low frequency crystal dynamics is important both from fundamental and applications point of view, the study of optical properties of new low phonon energy crystals included refractive indices with their dispersion curves and temperature dependence, Raman, absorption, reflection and emission spectra of undoped MPb2 Hal5 crystals, including the nature of UV host absorption bands. 2.4.1. Refractive indices and thermo-optic coefficients Refractive indices were measured using a conventional technique of minimum deviation angle with two prisms of different orientation: n values were found to
12
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. 2,20
a
Refractive indices
Refractive indices
3 1,95 2 1 1,90
2,15
2
8 4 6 Wavelength, µm
1 2
2,10 2,05
0
b
3
10
0
2
4 6 8 Wavelength, µm
10
Figure 6. Refractive indices nx (1), ny (2) and nz (3) versus wavelength in the 1 to 10 micron range for KPC (a) and KPB (b) at 300 K.
−7
−11
a bx
−12 bx
−8
i
−13 −14 by
i
−9
bz
−15 bz
−10 −11
b
bi=dn/dT, 10-5*C-1
bi=dn/dT, 10-5*C-1
−6
by 0
2
4
6 8 10 Wavelength, microns
−16
0
2
4
6 8 10 Wavelength, microns
Figure 7. Thermooptic coefficients βi = dni /dT with i = x, y, z for KPC (a) and KPB (b).
grow in the set KPC → RPC → KPB → RPB. Dispersion characteristics for KPC and KPB are given in Figure 6. In accordance with lattice parameters, nx and ny values are close, whereas nz values are considerably larger. Temperature dependence at 6 wavelengths (1, 2, 3, 5, 7 and 10 µm) was studied using a specially controlled heating device, which was mounted on the optical goniometer, and thermo-optic coefficients βi = dn i /dT were calculated: they are given in Figure 7 for KPC and KPB. One can see that refractive indices n i and βi values become larger in bromides as ion sizes and lattice parameters increase and crystal lattice becomes more friable. These parameters are considerably anisotropic: βx values are about 30 % higher than β y , βz . 2.4.2. Vibrational (Raman) spectra Since low frequency crystal dynamics is important both from fundamental and applications point of view, the Raman spectra were studied. For interpretation of vibrational spectra and establishment of lattice vibration frequency-to-structure correlations, we used the recently developed first-principles approach [60–62]. It is necessary to note that empirical techniques traditionally used ([63, 64], for example) bring in a large number of adjusting parameters in the case of low symmetry structures with many atoms in the unit cell, and it is impossible to
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
Figure 8.
13
Raman spectra for KPC (1) and KPB (2) crystals.
determine these parameters using a limited amount of experimental data. Thus, the use of parameter-free techniques becomes fundamentally important. Raman spectra were recorded in polarized light at room temperature for MPb2 Hal5 samples with edges oriented along crystallographic axes. For KPb2 Cl5 and KPb2 Br5 , the vibrational representation is reduced to the following irreducible representations in the center of Brillouin zone: = 24Ag (x x, yy, zz, x y, yx) + 24Bg (x z, zx, yz, zy) + 24Au + 24Bu ,
(1)
where the parentheses contain the Raman tensor components for which the corresponding lattice vibrations are active. The experimental spectra are shown in Figure 8. As expected, the spectra are restricted to frequencies hωmax < 250 cm−1 and hωmax < 150 cm−1 , with high frequency peaks located at 203 and 138 cm−1 , respectively; the spectra are strongly anisotropic, and the spectral lines are highly polarized. The number of well-resolved peaks is slightly smaller than the number of modes determined from Eq. (1); therefore, their interpretation requires comparison of the peaks with the results of model calculations. Taking these distortions into account is especially important for low-symmetry structures, since the interactions of multiple moments of ions in these structures contribute substantially to the total lattice energy and the crystal vibration frequency. The short-range part of inter-ionic interactions is calculated in terms of density functional theory, whereas for far-ranging part we used a multipole expansion (up to quadrupoles); multipole moments were found by minimizing the total crystal energy with respect to the corresponding moment. The eigenvectors were obtained by diagonalizing the dynamical matrix and subjected to symmetry analysis. The complete vibrational representation P(g) of the crystal space group was constructed and it was used further to calculate the
14
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
TABLE 2. Experimental and calculated frequencies of Raman-active lattice vibrational modes in KPC crystals [66]. Ag , ω(cm−1 ) Calculation 33.4 i 16.5 i 7.7 i 16.7 35.0 39.6 43.7 43.7 51.9 56.5 57.7 61.8 70.1 73.9 77.6 86.7 88.7 93.1 101.7 103.2 112.7 124.5 127.1 132.6 158.3
Experiment
18 27 35 43 50 56 62 73
85
108 120 124 127 132 200
Bg , ω(cm−1 ) Calculation 37.7i 28.3i 6.2 28.0 38.3 43.9 46.1 46.1 57.0 65.0 68.6 72.2 74.1 81.9 84.7 89.1 95.7 100.7 102.7 105.0 115.0 120.7 128.4 137.9 161.7
Experiment
33 40 42 48 57
75 85 88 95 108 119 132 144 158 173 202
projection operators [65]. The experimental and calculated frequencies of the Raman spectrum are given in TABLE 2. Note that these experimental and calculated frequencies agree well in the middle portion of the spectrum. For the lowest frequencies (below 20 cm−1 ), the calculated frequencies depend strongly on small changes in the atomic coordinates; their variation within the experimental error can result in significant (up to 100 %) changes in the vibration frequencies. A large number of vibrations in this portion show weak lattice stability: it is likely a result of a near phase transition.
15
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
A larger discrepancy at high frequencies (the understated calculated values) may be due to an incomplete consideration of the shape of electronic cloud of weakly polarized Cl ions in frames of multipole approximation (a partial covalence of M-Cl bonds). One can see that position of the peak with maximal frequency depends considerably on the halogen type (Figure 8): thus halogen ions take part in this vibration. 2.4.3. Absorption and reflection spectra Absorption spectra for MPb2 Hal5 crystals are shown in Figure 9, both in the IR (Figure 9a) and UV-visible region (Figure 9b). Position of the long-wave edge of the transparency range is determined by masses of the participating ions and vibration frequencies. It is 20 µm(500 cm−1 ) for KPC and 32 µm (312 cm−1 ) for KPB, as estimated on the 1 cm−1 absorption level. Taking into account that hωmax < 250 cm−1 and < 150 cm−1 from Raman spectroscopy, one can conclude that long-wave transparency edge is determined by two-phonon absorption. The short-wave edge of the transparency range was determined as a result of approximation of the fragments with maximal inclination angle relative to the abscissa in Figure 9 b until crossing with this axis (TABLE 3). Chlorides demonstrate maximum of transparency at short waves (RPC is transparent up to 306 nm), whereas for bromides the edge is shifted to longer waves (∼400 nm). The absorption edge shifts to lower energies when temperature increases. Analysis of the reflection spectra reveals several dips at shorter wavelengths, which are better pronounced at temperatures as low as 8 K (Figure 10). These dips are related to exciton absorption and their position depends on M and Hal components and on temperature. The average temperature coefficient for the main peak E1 in the 8 to 290 K range is ∂ E 1 /∂ T = −(2.8–3.0) × 10−4 eV/K. These values as well as specific form of the reflection spectra are typical of large radius excitons. Analysis of exciton peak positions carried out in frames of hydrogen-like Wannier-Mott model [67] allowed one to determine the band gap value Eg and exciton bonding energy R a
b 1
Optical density, D
2,0
2
3
4
1,5 1,0 1a
2 5
6
7
5a
8 1
0,5 0,0
40
60 80 100 Photon energy, meV
2
3 Photon energy, eV
4
0
Figure 9. Absorption spectra for undoped crystals KPB (1, 1a, 2), RPB (3, 4), KPC (5, 5a, 7) and RPC (6, 8), recorded at 290 K (1, 1a, 3, 5, 5a, 6) and 8 K (2, 4, 7, 8).
16
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
TABLE 3. Position of the short-wave absorption edge at 300 K and 8 K, band gap Eg from reflection spectra (8 K) and exciton parameters E1 , R (8 K) for different halide crystals. Parameter
Short-wave absorption edge
Temperature
KPb2 Cl5 KPb2 Br5 RbPb2 Cl5 RbPb2 Br5
300 K
Eg , eV
E1 , eV
R, eV
4.79 4.12 4.83 4.22
4.45 3.87 4.51 4.0
0.34 0.25 0.34 0.22
8K
E, eV
λ, nm
E, eV
λ, nm
3.77 3.10 3.89 3.36
329 400 318 370
3.99 3.23 4.06 3.56
310 383 306 348
Figure 10. Fragments of reflection spectra for RPC (1), KPC (2), RPB (3) and KPB (4), recorded at 8 K. Arrows show position of the first exciton peak E1 and band gap Eg .
(TABLE 3). Crystal RPC has maximal band gap and the Eg value decreases when Cl is replaced with Br. As follows from TABLE 3, the real short-wave absorption edge is located in MPb2 Hal5 crystals at longer wavelengths relative to Eg position: thus it is due to excitonic absorption. 2.4.4. Photoluminescence and luminescence excitation spectra In the photoluminescence (PL) spectra of MPb2 Hal5 crystals one can see broad non-elementary bands in 1.6–2.9 eV region, with their shape and maximal position depending on M and Hal components as well as on excitation wavelength. In Figure 11, PL spectra for RPC (a) and RPB (b) at different excitations are
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
17
Figure 11. Low temperature photoluminescence spectra (a, b) and luminescence excitation spectra (c). Photoluminescence spectra recorded at 8 K for RPC (a) and RPB (b) at different excitation: in the transparency region (1), in exciton absorption range (2) and in the range of band-to-band electronic transitions (3). c) Luminescence excitation spectra for RPC (1–4) for 2.4 eV (1) and 2.0 eV PL(2–4) in comparison with the reflection spectrum (5). Spectra (1, 2, and 5) were recorded at 8 K whereas (3, 4) were obtained at 80 and 300 K, respectively.
given. In the general case, one can see that different PL bands are excited in the transparency region, in exciton absorption range and in the range of bandto-band electronic transitions (Figure 11 a), although their position is sometimes close (for example, for bromides (Figure 11 b)). For RPC, the short-wave PL with maxima at 2.0 and 2.4 eV takes place only at band-to-band or excitonic excitations as well as in the region of inter-band transitions whereas a long-wave PL component (∼1.75 eV) corresponds to intra-center transitions in the defects. Intensity of 2.0–2.4 eV PL is maximal at low temperatures of 8–50 K and decreases as temperature increases: PL becomes completely quenched at ∼200 K. The luminescence excitation spectra (LES) demonstrate a set of bands depending on the crystal type: those for RPC are given in Figure 11 c. In all cases, PL intensity decreases in region of inter-band transitions, at excitation energies hν > E g, and the antibate behaviour of details takes place between
18
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
reflection and luminescence excitation spectra (Figure 11 c). Specific features are considered in the region of Eg and excitonic absorption maxima. The LES longwave edge for 2.0–2.4 eV PL coincides with a long-wave edge of the transparency spectrum (Figure 9 b). In the case of excitation in the transparency range, excitation efficiency increases as temperature increases to 80 and 300 K (Figure 11 c, spectra 2–4), which can testify to thermally activated processes with participation of native or impurity defects. 2.4.5. Electronic excitations and energy transfer Comparison of the obtained experimental results on spectroscopy of MPb2 Hal5 crystals with known data concerning PbHal2 testifies to similarity of these crystal families from the point of view of physics of low-energy electronic excitations and dominating input of lead cations into formation of electronic structure of the states, which determine electronic transitions with minimum energies. In PbHal2 the valence band top is formed by hybridizated orbitals of 6s states of Pb2+ and np-states of Hal− ions (n = 4 for Hal = Br and n = 3 for Hal = Cl). Below, there are orbitals formed by np-states of Hal− ions [68]. Since bottom of the PbHal2 conduction band is formed mainly by 6 p orbitals of Pb2+ ion, electronic transitions with minimum energy take place between Pb ion states and correspond to 6s → 6 p electric dipole transition, bringing to excitation the cation exciton [69–71]. Thus, features in low-temperature reflection spectra of MPb2 Hal5 crystals may be related to electric dipole transitions 6s → 6 p between Pb2+ states, bringing about cation exciton excitation. Analysis of exciton parameters (TABLE 3) [69–72], calculated in frames of hydrogen-like model, allows one to suppose that observed excitonic-related features in reflection spectra (Figure 10) correspond to first (E1 ) and second excited states of free large-radius exciton. Typical dissociation channels for such exciton may be vibrational relaxation with further radiative annihilation, energy transfer to impurity or native defects with further PL in such center, non-radiative recombination in surface states and, finally, dissociation into individual charge carriers or partly bonded electron and hole pairs. Radiative exciton dissociation usually results in a set of specific narrow PL bands near the fundamental absorption edge. Such near-edge PL was not found for MPb2 Hal5 crystals but several bands in low-temperature PL spectra are obviously of excitonic origin. Among them are a short-wave 3.65 eV band in KPC and a weak 2.9 eV band in KPB, which are observed only at low temperatures and are not associated with any defect. There are exponential components in decay kinetics and these bands are excited only near the fundamental absorption edge. Considerable Stokes shift (0.4–0.5 eV) and large width of PL bands mean that excitonic emission appears after vibrational relaxation and therefore the exciton undergoes self-trapping. At 8 K, the mentioned PL bands appear only at excitation
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
19
in low-energy excitonic absorption band, which corresponds to 6s 2 → 6s6 p transition in Pb2+ ion. Further increase of photon energy results in a fast decline of PL excitation efficiency because of increasing input of non-radiative losses. It is an evidence of high mobility of excitons photo-excited in the excitonic band. Excitation of short-wave PL in the range of interband transitions (hν > E g ) is of low enough efficiency and it shows a low efficiency of recombination channel for these PL bands. Indeed the 3.65 eV band was not found in either X-ray excited or thermo-activated luminescence. Incorporation of the RE ions such as Pr, Er, Nd, Ho, Tb, and Tm results in the appearance of typical PL emission with a well-pronounced fine structure: a set of lines and relative intensity depend considerably on the RE type [72]. Impurity emission appears both at a selective direct excitation of the impurity (RE) center by photons with Eexc < Eg energy and at indirect excitation by high energy photons with Eexc ≥ Eg . In the first case, the lines in LES spectra characterize position of the excited states in energy diagram of the impurity center. Concerning high energy excitation, the analysis of spectra shows an effective energy transfer both by excitonic mechanism and as a result of migration of free electrons and holes with their further recombination in the RE ion. The energy transfer efficiency depends on temperature: it is higher at low temperatures. On the other hand, at Eexc > Eg the efficiency decreases as photon energy increases, which is due to growth of kinetic energy of created charge carriers and their non-radiative annihilation on crystal surface. A multiplication effect is absent for electronic excitations for energies, Eexc > (2 − 3)Eg , and this fact confirms efficiency of the surface losses channel. At T = 8 K there is low probability of exciton thermal dissociation in KPC crystals: thus excitonic mechanisms of energy transfer are effective. Analysis of optical spectroscopy data for KPC with Ho or Er as dopants shows that one of the possible mechanisms of RE excitation at low temperatures is a non-radiative resonant transfer of self-trapped exciton (STE) to impurity center as a result of the dipole-dipole interaction. In fact, there are several broad overlapping PL bands centered at 2.4 and 1.9 eV with microsecond decay and a fast emission at 3.75 eV with τ1 = 0.8 nsec, τ2 = 3.5 nsec. The 1.9 eV emission is due to crystal lattice defects in KPC, whereas 2.4 and 3.75 eV bands correspond to radiative annihilation of triplet and singlet self-trapped excitons, respectively. At room temperature, the STE emission is thermally quenched. Moreover, a thermal dissociation of non-relaxed excitons is possible. In such conditions, an electron-hole mechanism of energy transfer is dominating and recombination luminescence of the impurity (RE) center is observed. 2.5. KEY PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
The MPb2 Hal5 crystal-hosts are of high transparency in the UV to mid-IR spectral range (from 0.3 to 30 µm), have satisfactory mechanical properties, high
20
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. TABLE 4.
The main physical properties of MPb2 Hal5 crystals.
Property
KPC
RPC
KPB
RPB
Transparency range, µm Space group Melting temperature, ◦ C Density, g/cm3 Refraction index at 300 K
0,33–20
0,32–20
0,4 −30
0,37 −30
5 P21 /c − C2h 434
5 P21 /c − C2h 423
5 P21 /c − C2h 382
18 I 4/mcm − D4h 382
4,629 nx = 1.9406 ny = 1.9466 nz = 1.9724 (at 1 µ m) −7.0 −10.0 −10.5 (at 1 µm)
5.041 n = 2, 019 (at 0.63 µm)
5,619 nx = 2, 191 ny = 2, 189 nz = 2, 247 (at 0.63 µm) −13.0 −14.1 −14.9 (at 1 µm)
5.83 no = 2, 2410 ne = 1, 9654 (at 0.63 µm)
4
4
2,5 203
2,5 203
2,5 138
2,5 138
stable
stable
stable
stable
Thermo-optic coefficient β∗ (10−5 ), ◦ C−1 (near 300 K) Thermal conductivity, W/m∗ K Mohs hardness Maximal phonon energy, h¯ ω0 , cm−1 Chemical stability
chemical resistance, low hygroscopicity, extremely low maximal phonon energy (∼200 cm−1 in chlorides and ∼150 cm−1 in bromides), and incorporate RE3+ ions with concentration up to 3%. The main physical properties of MPb2 Hal5 crystals are summarized in TABLE 4. 3. Spectroscopic characteristics of RE3+ ions in MPb2 Hal5 crystals Up to now, the strategy used to search for new laser channels of RE3+ activated crystals involves the problem of determining their spectroscopic characteristics. The feasibility of exciting stimulated emission on f-f transitions of RE3+ ions is most often reduced to the estimate of luminescence quantum yield for steadystate excitation. From the 1970’s until now comparatively simple semi-empirical methods for determination of the most important intensity characteristics of
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
21
intermanifold j → i radiative transitions of RE3+ ions in laser crystals have been developed and tested. The most important of these characteristics are the probability of spontaneous emission A ji and the probability of nonradiative transition W ji . These parameters affect both real luminescence efficiency of a given j-manifold, quantum yield of which is: ηj = A ji / (A ji + W ji ), (3.1) i
i
and corresponding branching ratios β ji = A ji /
A ji .
(3.2)
i
The values of A ji and W ji can be measured directly in some cases, calculated theoretically, or estimated using semi-empirical methods. Correlation between radiative and nonradiative relaxation rates is very important for consideration of potential of j → i transition for laser action. The classical 4-levels laser scheme is shown in Figure 12. After absorption of the pump energy (transition 0 → 3, B03 – Einstein absorption coefficient), followed by nonradiative W32 and radiative A32 relaxation, stimulated emission can be achieved on the transition 2 → 1 in case the population of the level 2 (N2 ) becomes more than that of the level 1 (N1 ). Laser action is possible if the gain for this 2 → 1 transition is positive: G(λ21 ) = σ21 (λ21 ) · (N2 − N1 ) − L > 0.
(3.3)
Here λ21 is the laser wavelength, σ21 (λ21 ) is the stimulated emission cross section at λ21 , and L is the total losses in laser rod and cavity. In this scheme, high values of B03 , σ21 , W32 , W10 and N = N2 − N1 are desirable for efficient laser action at transition 2 → 1. Probability A ji is the sum of magnetic dipole (md) and electric dipole (ed) transition probabilities. It is simple to calculate the probabilities of the radiative τ3
3 W32
A3i
τ2
2 B03
σ21
A2i
τ1
1
W10
A10
0
Figure 12. The 4-levels laser scheme. B03 – absorption at transition 0 → 3, W ji nonradiative multiphonon relaxation at j → i transitions, A ji radiative (luminescent) j → i transitions, τ j – lifetime of energy level “ j”. Figures near the levels are levels numbers.
22
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
md-transitions if the dispersion of crystalline refractive index n(λ) is known. Probabilities of the radiative ed-transitions may be calculated using semi-empirical methods and experimental data on absorption cross-section spectra, emission spectra, and life times of energy levels. The values of W ji can be measured directly, calculated theoretically or estimated using the experimental exponential relation, the so-called “energy gap law”. Based on the experimental results and analysis of the relation between W ji and energy gap E ji the following phenomenological dependence was obtained, which describes satisfactorily the experimental data: W ji (T, E ji ) = B · exp(−α · E ji ) · [1 − exp(h¯ ω0 )/kT]− p .
(3.4)
Here B and α are assumed to be defined for a given crystal, energy gap E ji = E j − E i is that between the level “ j” and the nearest lower level “i”, ω0 is the maximal frequency of phonon spectrum or “cut off”, and p = E ji /h¯ ω0 . As it follows from expression (3.4), the lower multiphonon relaxation rate at the given energy gap E ji will be found in crystals with narrower phonon spectrum, in which one of crystalline sub-lattices consists of heavy ions. Thus, the crystal-hosts on the basis of alkali-lead chlorides and bromides may be considered as the most promising for laser action in the IR. In the previous section, high frequency peaks in Raman spectra were found to be at h¯ ω0 = 203 and 138 cm−1 in KPC and KPB, respectively. Selected results of the experimental and theoretical determination of spectroscopic intracenter characteristics of inter-multiplet transitions, such as absorption cross section spectra, radiative and nonradiative probabilities, radiative life times of energy levels, and branching ratios obtained for the RE doped MPb2 Hal5 crystals, are considered in this chapter. 3.1. OPTICAL SPECTRA AND SPECTROSCOPIC PARAMETERS
The RE doped MPb2 Hal5 crystals reveal high values of peak absorption and emission cross-sections of RE ions. In contrast to fluorides, intensive absorption bands with maximal peak absorption cross-sections of RE3+ ions of order (1 ÷ 3) × 10−19 cm2 , located mainly in UV and visible spectral regions, are demonstrated in these crystals. As a result of low phonon-energy, several radiative transitions over a wide spectral region from the UV to mid-IR are exhibited in these new hosts doped with RE ions. 3.1.1. Low-temperature absorption and luminescence spectra Optical transitions in RE3+ :MPb2 Hal5 crystals are characterized by high oscillator strengths and large number of radiative transitions over a wide spectral range from the UV to mid-IR. The peculiarities of substitution of cations by RE ions in
23
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
TABLE 5. Stark level energies of Er3+ manifolds in KPb2 Cl5 crystal and total level splitting [73]. Er+ multiplet
4F
9/2
4I
9/2
4I
11/2
4I
13/2
4I
15/2
Energy level (cm−1 )
Overall level splitting (cm−1 )
15328, 15291, 15250, 15220, 15201 12513, 12501, 12444, 12427, 12349 10247, 10244, 10236, 10232, 10181, 10179 6675, 6663, 6644, 6550, 6539, 6530, 6513 241, 200, 159, 63, 38, 20, 5, 0
127 164 68 162 241
The error bars for this data are given as ±3 cm−1 for the 4 I15/2 manifold and ±1 cm−1 for the excited states
RE3+ :MPb2 Hal5 crystals are reflected in the optical absorption and photoluminescence spectra. The optical spectra at room temperature exhibit weakly structured bands. Stark component structure was determined for the ground and the first four excited erbium states in the Er:KPC crystals using spectroscopic measurements performed on oriented, single crystals at room and low (10 K) temperatures [73]. The results are presented in TABLE 5. The quantity and positions of the energy levels were consistent with a single erbium site in the host material. The conclusion was made that the erbium ion replaced only one of the two non-equivalent lead ion sites in the material lattice, with the assumption that a potassium vacancy compensates for the charge difference. 3.1.2. Absorption cross section spectra At present, the spectroscopic properties of RE ions are investigated in more detail in KPC host. Examples of room temperature absorption cross-sections spectra for the 4fn -configuration transitions in the RE3+ :KPb2 Cl5 (RE3+ = Pr, Nd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm and Yb) crystals are shown in Figure 13 [34], [74–77]. Absorption cross-section spectra for Nd doped KPb2 Br5 and RbPb2 Br5 are presented in Figure 14. Absorption cross-sections were calculated from the absorption spectra measured for the samples with known average RE concentration. The KPC matrix enables doping with RE ions with concentrations of about several percent as maximum. The segregation coefficient is decreasing with changing of the RE ion from the first half of the lanthanide series to the second half (see the Section 2.1 and [78]). For example, in Nd:KPC crystals, the segregation (replacement) coefficient for neodymium is close to 1, K Nd = 0.86 [79]. Neodymium concentration in a boule slowly varies along the crystal length
24
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. σabs , 10−20 cm2
σabs , 10−20 cm2
Pr:KPC
a)
1
10
Pr:KPC
I6, P0
3,0
3
F3, 3F4
2,0
6 3
4
P2
1,5
3
P1
1,0 1
D2
2
1
G4
0,5 0,0
500
550
600
650
1000
1500
σabs , 10−20 cm2
Nd:KPC
c) G5/2 +2G7/2
16
400
500
F5
0,6 F5/2+ H9/2
7
2
F5
4
7
F4 7F3
4
F3/2
0,2
0,0
700
800
2
900
4
6
F4
5
0,6 7
5
F5 F4
16
18
4
F2 7
F1,7F0
Dy:KPC
f)
3
6
F3
14
2
2000
3000
4000
−1
Wavenumber, cm
5000
6000
0
350
400
F9/2
I15/2
4
1000
4
1
0,0
4
F4 7F3
G11/2
7
4
0,2
7
4
7
0,4
12
6
( P, P)3/2 M19/2 4 4 4 I13/2+ K17/2+ I17/2 4 M21/2
7
10
6
F6-7F5
σabs , 10−20 cm2
4
e)
I11/2+ M5/2+ P7/2
Tb:KPC
0,8
8
Wavelength, µm
Wavelength, nm
7
F4
4
F9/2
H11/2 600
σabs , 10−20 cm2
5
7
0,4
4
2
0
d)
7
F6
F4
4
G9/2,7/2, 2K13/2
2
2
2
4
P1/2
4
G9/2,2K15/2
4
6
D1/2,3/2,5/2
12
2500
Tb:KPC
7 7
F7/2+4S3/2
14
0,8
F0,1,2,3
σabs , 10−20 cm2
2000
Wavelength, nm
Host cut-off
450
Wavelength, nm
8
H6, 3F2
3
2,5
8
0 400
10
b)
3,5
3
4
Absorption Cross Section
12
450
500
Wavelength, nm
Figure 13. Absorption cross-section spectra of RE3+ :KPC crystals in UV-VIS-IR spectral domains. RE=Pr (a, b); Nd (c), Tb (d, e), Dy (f, g), Ho (h, i), Er (j, k), Tm (l, m), Yb (n).
according to variations of neodymium concentration in the melt volume and depends on the crystal length. However, these changes are low compared with the fluoride crystals, for comparison in Nd:YLF KNd = 0.3. Since the distribution coefficient for rare-earth ions in KPC host depends on the RE and crystal growth method, the RE concentration has to be known in the sample under study. For this purpose, we used a simple non-destructive
25
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY σabs , 10−20 cm2
6
σabs , 10−20 cm2
Dy:KPC
6
g)
6
Ho:KPC
h)
14
H9/2+ F11/2
5
12
5
5
F1 , G 6
10 4
3
8 6
H13/2
H6
G2,3
5 5
6
6
6
1 F5/2
2
H11/2
3
G5
K8 5
3
F7/2
4
G4, K7
H5/2
5
S 2 , F4
5
F5
F2 5
5
6
5
6
6
2
H7/2+ F9/2
3
6
F3
0 400
0 500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
Wavelength, nm
σabs , 10−20 cm2
Ho:KPC
i)
1,2
5
500
600
700
800
Wavelength, nm
σabs , 10−20 cm2
3+
KPb2Cl5:Er , along Z
j)
4
G11/2
I7
1,0 0,8 5
H11/2
2
4
I5
0,0 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 2200 2400
300
350
400
σabs , 10−20 cm2
Er:KPC, along Z
k)
1,5 4
F9/2
4
1,0
4
4
F7/2
S3/2
450
500
550
600
Wavelength, nm
Wavelength, nm σabs , 10−20 cm2
F5/2, 3/2
5
4
0,4
G(H)9/2
2
I6
0,2
2
G9/2, 7/2+ K15/2
0,6
Tm:KPC, along Y 3
3,0 2,5
I13/2
1
F3, 2
l) 3
H4
D2
2,0 1,5 1
0,5
4 4
I11/2
G4
1,0
I9/2
0,5
0,0
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
0,0 300
400
500
600
700
800
900
Wavelength, nm
Wavelength, nm
Figure 13. Continued.
spectro-photometric method of determination of average rare-earth concentration in the sample described in [34]. The method is based on the comparison of the peak optical density Dλ in the reference line at the wavelength λ and the known peak absorption cross-section σa (λ) in a reference crystal sample with the known concentration of RE. Concentration of RE ions in this reference sample was determined by the X-ray spectral analysis performed with the electron-probing
26
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. σabs , 10−20 cm2
k, cm−1
Tm:KPC, along Y
m) 3
H5
2,5
3
2,0
F4
1,5 1,0 0,5 0,0 1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
Yb:KPC
n)
0,16
Absorption Coefficient
3,0
0,14 0,12 0,10 0,08 0,06 0,04 0,02 0,00 900
Wavelength, nm
950
1000
1050
1100
Wavelength, nm
Figure 13. Continued. σabs , 10−20 cm2
Nd:KPB
9
4
8
a)
2
Nd:RPB
b) 4
4
2,0
7 6
2
G5/2+ G7/2
2
F5/2+ H9/2
1,5
5 4 3 2
2 1
σabs , 10−20 cm2
G5/2+ G7/2
2 2
P1/2
4
G9/2,7/2
2
K13/2
4 4
K15/2
4
G9/2
2
0 400
500
600
1,0
2
F5/2+ H9/2
4
F7/2+ S3/2
4
700
K13/2
0,5
1000
F3/2
2
P1/2 G9/2
900
4
K15/2
2
800
4
F7/2+ S3/2
G9/2,7/2
2
F9/2 H11/2
Wavelength, nm
4
4 2
F3/2
2
4
H11/2 F9/2
0,0 400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
Wavelength, nm
Figure 14. Absorption cross-section spectra of Nd3+ :KPB (a) and Nd3+ :RPB (b) crystals in UV-VIS-IR spectral domains.
micro-analyzer Camebax by CAMEKA. The samples were cut off from different parts of the boule and prepared in the form of thin oriented polished plates. The absorption spectra of these samples were recorded with a Perkin-Elmer Lambda-900 spectrophotometer and the peak absorption cross-sections σabs (λ) were determined for each sample. The values of absorption cross-sections on the wavelength at the line maxip p mum σabs = σabs (λmax ), or “peak absorption cross-sections”, measured at room temperature for RE ions in KPC host, are gathered in TABLE 6. The following expression was taken for the integrated (efficient) cross-section σi, j (int): 1 K i, j (ν)dν, (3.5) σi, j (int) = σi, j (ν)dν = N where σi, j (ν) = K i, j (ν)/N is the absorption cross-section [in cm2 ] at frequency ν, and N is the concentration of RE3+ ions. The Pr:KPC crystals exhibit one of the most intensive absorption bands at 487 nm (transition 3 H4 → 3 P0 ) with a peak absorption cross-section
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
27
p
TABLE 6. The experimental maximal peak absorption cross sections σabs (λmax ) for the most intense bands in RE3+ :KPC crystals at room temperature. RE3+ ion
Pr Nd Tb Dy Er Tm Ho Yb
λmax , nm
487 589 3335 1297 379.4 797.9 453 982
p
σabs (λmax ), 10−20 cm2
Transition i → j
Reference
10.9 14.9 0.65 5.18 11 (15 K) 21.5 2.85 11 1.78
3 H → 1 I ,3 P 4 0 6 4I 4 9/2 → G5/2+7/2 7F → 7F 6 5 6H 6H 6 → 9/2 , F11/2 15/2
[75, 76] [74] This work [34] [50]
4 15/2 → G11/2 3H → 3H 4 6 5I → 5F , 5G 8 1 6 2F 2 5/2 → F7/2
[77] [76] [75, 76] [76]
4I
σabs (487 nm) = 1.09 × 10−19 cm2 . The intensity of other absorption bands (Figure 13 a and b), associated with transitions from 3 H4 ground state to excited levels 3 H6 + 3 F2 ; 3 F3,4 ; 3 P1 ; 3 P2 , are significantly lower. Room temperature absorption cross-section spectra for Nd:KPC were studied in [50,74,80]. Among transitions between the ground and excited neodymium levels, the highest integrated oscillator strengths in absorption spectrum correspond to the 4 I9/2 → (4 D3/2 , 4 D5/2 , 2 I11/2 ), 4 I9/2 → (4 G5/2 ,2 G7/2 ), 4 I9/2 → (4 S3/2 ,4 F7/2 ), and 4 I9/2 → (4 H9/2 ,4 F5/2 ) transitions (Figure 13c). The highest peak absorption p cross-section, σabs (589 nm) = 14.9 × 10−20 cm2 [74], corresponds to transition from the ground state to one of the group of excited levels 4 G5/2 , 2 G7/2 . The absorption spectrum of Nd:KPC shows bands matching the emission range of laser diodes. The band at 810 nm, 4 I9/2 → (4 H9/2 , 4 F5/2 ) transition, with the peak p absorption cross-section of σabs (810.4 nm) = 6.51 × 10−20 cm2 , is suitable for laser diode pumping. Optical properties of Nd ions in KPB and RPB crystals are studied in detail in [81]. The authors have presented the growth and physical properties of KPB and RPB crystals, and reported the results of the investigation of room-temperature absorption and emission spectra. A strong dependence of absorption cross-sections p on polarization was observed in the studied crystals. The values of σabs (λmax ) for RE ions measured at room temperature in KPB and RPB crystals are given in TABLE 7. p In Tb:KPC, the most intense absorption band around 4.3 µm, with σabs = −20 2 7 7 0.65 × 10 cm , corresponds to F6 → F5 transition. Absorption spectrum of Tb:KPC was studied also in [75, 76, 81–83], but the absorption cross-section spectrum was not determined. p
28
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. p
TABLE 7. The experimental maximal peak absorption cross sections σabs (λmax ) for the most intense bands in Nd doped KPB and RPB crystals. Crystal
λmax , nm
Nd:KPB
592 591 812 812
Nd:RPB
TABLE 8.
p
σabs (λmax ), 10−20 cm2
Transition i → j
Reference
7.8 (Z) 28 2.0 (Z) 1.4 (Z)
4I
4 9/2 → G5/2+7/2 4 9/2 → G5/2+7/2 4I 4 2 9/2 → F5/2 + H9/2 4I 4 2 9/2 → F5/2 + H9/2
This work [81] This work [81]
4I
Absorption cross section for Dy:KPb2 Cl5 . Dy:KPb2 Cl5
Transition from 6H 15/2 to: 4M 6F
6 5/2 + P7/2
5/2 6H 6 7/2 + F9/2 6H 13/2
p
λ [nm]
σabs · 1020 [cm2 ]
352.6 810.4 1297 2820
2.4 0.99 5.18 2.19
At low temperature, the width of the lines becomes narrower and the peak intensity of the lines increases considerably. Thus, in Dy3+ :KPC, the peak absorpp tion cross-section σabs (λmax ) for transition 6 H15/2 → 6 H9/2 , 6 F11/2 was measured in [50] at low temperature (T = 15 K). It was found to be 11 × 10−20 cm2 , while at room temperature it is 5.18 × 10−20 cm2 (TABLE 8). In the Er:KPC crystal, the maximal peak absorption cross-section is p σabs (379.4 nm) = 21.5 × 10−20 cm2 in the Y (010) direction, and corresponds to a narrow (∆λ ≈ 0.9 nm) absorption band in the UV spectral range [77]. Apart from this narrow band, broad absorption bands suitable for the laser diode pumping were observed in the IR region. Namely, in the region of 960– 985 nm there is a broad band peaked at λ = 982.6 nm, with the peak absorption p cross-section σabs = 0.48 × 10−20 cm2 for Z-orientation (001), which corresponds to 4 I15/2 → 4 I11/2 transition (Figure 13 k); and in the region of λ = 798-810 nm, there is a band with a somewhat lower peak absorption cross-section p σa (799.6 nm) = 0.3 × 10−20 cm2 for Y-orientation (010), which corresponds to transition 4 I15/2 → 4 I9/2 . Room and low (10 K) temperature absorption cross-section spectra for three polarizations of the erbium manifolds with energy E < 16000 cm−1 (transitions
29
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
I15/2 → 4 Ij , j = 13/2, 11/2, 9/2 and 4 I15/2 → 4 F9/2 ) were investigated in [73]. Stark level energies of erbium ion in KPC crystal were determined and it was revealed that the erbium ion replaces only one of the two, non-equivalent, lead ion sites in the KPC matrix. The segregation coefficient for Er in KPC was found to be 0.5 [78].
4
3.1.3. Intensity parameters and radiative probabilities The knowledge of the probabilities of radiative transitions in rare-earth ions is useful for prediction of their possible laser applications. On the basis of the absorption cross-section spectra measurements, the characteristics of spontaneous radiative transitions were calculated with the standard Judd-Ofelt technique [84,85]. Oscilexp lator strengths f i, j (or line strengths Si, j ) for transitions from the ground state i to the excited multiplets j were calculated from the experimental absorption spectra in accordance with: mc2 mc2 exp exp f i, j = K (ν)dν = σ (int), (3.6) i, j N π e2 π e2 i, j exp
where m and e are the electron mass and charge, c is the light velocity, σi, j (int) is the experimental integrated (or effective) absorption cross-section of the i → j transition (in cm). The oscillator strength of the electric dipole transition i → j within the 4 f n configuration of the rare-earth ions in the crystal can be represented as the sum (t) 2 8π 2 mcνχ U S L J | ,
|S | | L| J t 3h(2J + 1)n 2 t (3.7) (t) where |S L| J | U S L J are the matrix elements of unit tensor operator, χ is the local field correction factor, χ = n(n 2 +2)2 /9 is for the dipole transition, n is the refractive index, 2J + 1 is the degeneracy of initial state, and t (t = 2, 4, 6) are the intensity parameters [84,85]. The oscillator strengths for the electric dipole ed,exp exp transitions are calculated from the expression f i, j = f i, j − f md . The oscillator strengths of magnetic dipole transitions f md are taken from [86]. By equating ed,exp experimental and calculated oscillator strengths, f i,ed,calc = f i, j , and solvj ing the obtained set of equations for the intensity parameters t by the least square method, one can find the values of t . These parameters for RE:MPb2 Hal5 crystals are given in TABLE 9. With intensity parameters from TABLE 9, the theoretical oscillator strengths for the absorption bands f ied,calc were calculated for Nd [74] and Er [77] ions in j KPC matrix, and they are listed in TABLES 10 and 11 accordingly. Good agreement between the experimental and calculated oscillator/line strengths is usually observed in case of limited number of transitions used for calculation, when the f i,ed,calc j
S L J , [S L] J =
30
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. TABLE 9. Intensity parameters for RE:MPb2 Hal5 crystals RMS is root mean square error.
RE3+ doped crystal Pr:KPC Nd:KPC
Nd:KPB Nd:RPB Tb:KPC
Tb:KPB Dy:KPC
Er:KPC Er:KPB Ho:KPC Tm:KPC
2 ·10−20 , cm2
0 8.5 5.28 0.33 3.11 15.7 0.41 2.7 2.93−3.0 3.7 23 5.41 11.55 8.73 0.385 0.15 3.11 7.11
4 ·10−20 , cm2
6 ·10−20 , cm2
4.96 6.18 13.09 22.9 7.01 6.3 9.3 7.0 2.16− 0.995 4.3 3.3 0.99 1.41 1.87 1.099 3.64 1.89 4.915
0.57 4.8 7.96 12.74 0.47 3.0 2.6 0.72 0.129− 0.239 0.72 3.9 2.98 1.47 0.78 0.898 2.08 0.39 1.70
RMS, f i j (Si j ) 7.2 · 10−7 7.12 · 10−7
Number of transitions
Reference
8 13 6 4 11 7 9 6 6
[75, 76] [74] [80] [87] This work [81] [81] [75] [83]
(10-40)%
6 8 10
4.26 · 10−7 0.948 · 10−7 (0.38 · 10−20 ) 1 · 10−6 1.7 · 10−6
14 8 7 13 6
[81] [34] [50] [88] [77] [73] [89] [75, 76] [75, 76]
1.5 · 10−6 15% 3.1 · 10−7
most intensive absorption bands for “hypersensitive” transitions are not taken into account. In the case of satisfactory agreement between the calculated and experimental values of the oscillator strengths, it is possible to calculate the characteristics of radiative transitions with these intensity parameters t . Better coincidence between calculated and experimental results was obtained when only the lower energy levels were considered [73]. The following well-known expressions were used to determine the values of radiative characteristics: the oscillator strengths f j,i , the radiative probabilities A Tj,i , and branching ratios β Tj,i of the radiative transitions j → i: f jicalc = A Tji ([S L ]J , [S L]J ) =
gi calc f gj ij
(3.8)
8π 2 e2 ν 2ji n 2 (2Ji + 1) calc ([S L ]J , [S L]J ), (3.9) f mc (2J j + 1) ji
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY TABLE 10.
ed,exp
Experimental and calculated oscillator strengths ( f i, j exp
31
and f i,ed,calc ), integrated j
cross sections (σi, j (int) and σi,calc j (int)) of the dipole-dipole transitions i → j from the ground 4 3+ state I9/2 of Nd ion to excited levels in Nd:KPC crystals; ν¯ (i → j) – is the average transition is 7 · 10−7 [74]. frequency. Root mean square (RMS) error for f ied,calc j
4I
ed,exp
ν¯ (i → j), cm−1
Transitions i → j from term 4 I9/2 to: 13/2
4I
15/2 4F 3/2 4F 2 5/2 , H9/2 4F 7/2 4S 3/2 2H 11/2 4G 2 5/2 , G7/2 2K 4 4 13/2 , G7/2 , G9/2 2K 2 15/2 , G9/2 , 2 2 ( D, P)3/2 , 4 G11/2 2P 2 1/2 , D5/2 2P 2 2 3/2 , ( D, P)5/2 4D 4 2 3/2 , D5/2 , I11/2
β Tji
fi j
10−6
,
f ied,calc , j
10−6
exp
σi, j (int), 10−18 cm
σi,calc j (int),
10−18 cm
3850 5820 11300 12400 13300 14600 15800 17100 19000 21200
1.54 0.27 3.47 12.1 9.7 0.74 0.2 45.6 11.3 3.0
1.90 0.27 4.1 10.87 9.92 0.83 0.23 45.64 10.34 2.09
1.36 0.24 3.07 10.71 8.58 0.65 0.18 40.35 10 2.65
1.68 0.24 3.63 9.62 8.78 0.73 0.20 40.39 9.15 1.85
23300 26140 27900
1.22 0.08 23.3
1.20 0.07 24.41
1.08 0.07 20.62
1.06 0.06 21.60
AjiT = T. k Ajk
(3.10)
Here, ν is the average transition frequency in cm−1 , gi( j) = 2Ji( j) + 1 is the degeneracy of the i( j) level, and n is the refractive index at the frequency ν. The radiative lifetimes can be found from the total probabilities of radiative transitions from the level j:
−1 τ rad = A jk . (3.11) j k
The non-radiative transition probabilities, W jiN R , can be estimated using the values exp of the intrinsic lifetimes, τ j , experimentally measured in the samples with low RE concentration:
−1 exp NR τj = (A jk + W jk ) . (3.12) k
32 TABLE 11.
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. ed,exp
Experimental and calculated oscillator strengths ( f i j exp
and f ied,calc ), integrated j
4 cross sections (σi, j (int) and σi,calc j (int)) of the dipole-dipole transitions i → j from the I15/2 ground state of Er3+ ion to the excited levels in Er3+ :KPC crystals. ν¯ (i → j) is the average transition frequency. RMS = 4.2 × 10−7 [77].
Transition i− > j 4I
13/2
4I
11/2
4I
9/2 4F 9/2 4S 3/2 2H 11/2 4F 7/2 4F 5/2 4F 3/2 2 G(H) 9/2 4G 11/2 4G 9/2 2K 15/2 4G 7/2
ν¯ (i → j), cm−1 6500 10160 12500 15300 18310 19200 20300 22020 22300 24300 26300 27100 27300 27700
ed,exp
fi j
10−6 ,
exp
f ied,calc j
σi, j (int),
σi,calc j (int),
1.32 0.76 0.56 2.81 0.43 18.3 2.09 0.52 0.29 0.69 32.3 2.00 0.96 0.46
1.17 0.56 0.34 2.31 0.62 16.11 1.81 0.48 0.19 0.88 28.7 2.73 1.47 0.46
1.17 0.62 0.5 2.48 0.38 16.2 1.85 0.46 0.26 0.61 28.6 1.77 0.50 0.41
1.32 (1.61∗ ) 0.63 0.38 2.61 0.70 18.2 2.05 0.54 0.22 0.99 32.4 3.08 1.66 (1.69∗ ) 0.52
10−6 ,
10−18 cm
10−18 cm
∗ ) The experimental values f ex p = f ed,exp + f md ij
The low RE concentration eliminated the influence of intercenter coupling processes. The calculated oscillator strengths, radiative probabilities, and branching ratios for radiative transitions between low energy RE levels in RE:KPC (RE = Pr, Nd, Tb and Er) crystals are summarized in TABLES 12–15, respectively. Nonradiative relaxation rates W N R are estimated within the Riseberg L.A. & Moos H.W. model [90]. 3.1.4. Multiphonon non-radiative relaxation rates The real emission ability of a crystal can be characterized by the luminescence quantum yield for transitions originating from the excited levels. The luminescence quantum yield strongly depends on the nonradiative relaxation rate W jiN R , the latter in its turn depends on the energy gap between neighboring energy levels E ji : η = j Ai j /( j Ai j + W jiN R ). (3.13)
33
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
calc , radiative probabilities A T , branching ratios TABLE 12. The calculated oscillator strengths f ji ji
β ji , radiative lifetimes τ rad and multiphonon non-radiative transition rates W N R for dipole-dipole ( j → i) transitions in Pr:KPC crystals [75]. Transition j→i 3H 5 3H 6 1G 4
1D 2
3P
0
3H 4 3H 5 3H 4 3F 4 3H 6 3H 5 1G 4 3F 3 3F 2 3H 6 3H 4 1G 4 3F 4 3H 6 3H 4
ν, ¯ cm −1
calc , f ji
10−6 2050 2570 4330 2700 5310 6980 7190 10408 11600 12500 16837 11250 13950 16560 20880
0.7 0.42 0.17 0.49 1.34 0.91 0.91 0.37 2.02 1.67 0.8 5.12 18.13 1.47 38.34
A Tji ,
β ji
τ rad , ms
∆E, cm −1
W N R, s −1
13.3 3.16 8.6 9.6 101 119 126 108 728 701 605 1730 9430 1077 44707
1 0.27 0.73 0.04 0.40 0.48 0.05 0.047 0.32 0.30 0.26 0.03 0.165 0.02 0.785
75 85
1900 2500
∼1 <1
4
2400
<0.1
0.433 (0.070∗ )
6600
0
17.6 (0.011∗ )
3700
0
s −1
∗ ) Data from [92]
So, to estimate the luminescence intensity, certain information about nonradiative transition rates is required. The phonon energy spectrum is the main parameter, which determines the ratio between probabilities of radiative and radiationless transitions in luminescence. Acceptable quantum efficiency from a given energy level can be achieved when at least four to six phonons of maximal energy span the energy gap to the next-lower level. Otherwise, the luminescence is quenched. Luminescence at wavelengths shorter than 4 µm is typical for fluorides having maximal phonon energies more than 400 cm−1 . The values of maximal phonon energy of MPb2 Hal5 crystals were determined from the Raman spectra (see Figure 8) as a position of a band maximum in the high energy edge of phonon spectra. The phonon energy for RPC and KPC are the same (h¯ ω0 = 203 cm−1 ). The bromide phonon frequencies are reduced by a factor of 1.5 compared to the chlorides, with h¯ ω0 = 138 cm−1 for KPB and 141 cm−1 for RPB. This is close to the change predicted on the basis of the masses of the bromide and chloride ions.
34
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
calc , radiative transition probabilities A T , branching TABLE 13. Calculated oscillator strengths f ji ji
ratios β ji , calculated (dipole-dipole) radiative τ rad and experimental τ ex p lifetimes of ( j → i) transitions and the multiphonon nonradiative transition probabilities W N R in Nd:KPC crystals [74]. ν ¯, cm −1
Transition j→i 4I
11/2
4I
9/2
4I
13/2
4I
11/2
4I
9/2
4I
13/2
4I
15/2
4F
4F
3/2
5/2 +
4I
11/2
4I
9/2
4I
15/2
4I
13/2
4I
11/2
4I
9/2
4F
1700 2100 3700 2100 4000 5900 5100 7300 9300 1110 1050
3/2
calc , f ji
10−6
A Tji , s −1
1.96
15.18
2.27
26.72
1.30
47.46
2.23
26.29
1.12
47.93
0.17
16.11
0.36
25.28
4.00
570.69
14.23
3290.2
10.12
3334.3
0.17
0.50
2.09
215.12
4.48
825.90
2H 9/2 4I
4F
7/2 +
4S
3/2
4F
9/2
2H 11/2
+
6200 8300 10300 12100 800
0.20
2.11
7.17
994.27
5.96
1347.96
8.09
2762.97
8.12
3727.06
+
2000 7200 9200 11300 13100 1200
0.46
1.76
+
2300
0.67
9.51
0.39
10.78
9.55
1802.15
8.77
2637.56
5.40
2328.7
+
3200 8400 10600 12700 14500 1200 2400
+
15/2
4I
13/2
4I
11/2
4I
9/2
4F
5/2 2H 9/2 4F 3/2 4I 15/2 4I 13/2 4I 11/2 4I 9/2 4F 7/2 4S 3/2 4F 5/2 2H 9/2 4F 3/2 4I 15/2 4I 13/2 4I 11/2 4I 9/2 4F 9/2 4F 7/2 4S 3/2 4F 5/2 2H 9/2 4F 3/2 4I 15/2 4I 13/2 4I 11/2 4I 9/2
∗ ) Data from [87]. ∗∗ ) Data from [40].
1.91
542.87
6.63
2594.06
0.24
0.41
8.07
β ji
τ rad , (τ ex p ) ms
1 0.36 0.64 0.29 0.53 0.18 0.004 0.079 0.46 0.46
63 (6.2∗ ) 13 (6.7∗ )
<0.1
11 (8∗ )
<0.1
∆E , cm −1
W N R, s −1
<0.1
0.138 (0.205∗∗ )
5000
0
0.242
750
3.105
0.113
400
108
0.138
800
2.7 · 104
0.89
900
9 · 104
(0.0034∗∗ )
453.53
0.2
0.79
0.6
8.84
3500
1.3
42.56
4400 9700 11800 13900 15700
0.03
1.56
2.65
667.31
0.33
123.13
0.30
157.25
0.19
122.94
35
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
calc , radiative transition probabilities A T , branching TABLE 14. Calculated oscillator strengths f ji ji
ratios β ji , calculated (dipole-dipole) radiative τ rad and experimental τ ex p lifetimes of ( j → i) transitions and the multiphonon nonradiative transition probabilities W N R in Tb:KPC crystals [75]. ν, ¯ cm −1
Transition j→i
calc , f ji
β ji
10−6
A Tji ,
s −1
τ rad , (τ ex p ) ms
∆E, cm −1
W N R, s −1
1
34 (2.8–22)∗ (3.7–2.9)∗∗ 10 (1.4)∗
2000
9
7F
5
7F
6
2100
2.5
29
7F
4
7F
5
7F
6
7F
4
7F
5
7F
6
7F
4
7F
5
7F
6
1300 3300 900 2300 4300 1600 3000 5000
0.57 3.19 0.54 1.66 2.36 0.39 3.04 0.45
2.6 93 1 23 116 2.7 73 97
7F
7F
3
2
0.02 0.98 0.007 0.164 0.83 0.016 0.42 0.56
950
6 · 105
7
800
3 · 106
5.7
500
7 · 107
∗ ) Data from [81]. ∗∗ ) Data from [82].
The narrow phonon spectra of potassium- and rubidium-lead double halogenides caused low rates of multiphonon nonradiative transitions and high quantum yield for low-energy transitions. Estimates of the dependence of multiphonon nonradiative transition rate (W jiN R ) on the energy gap, Eji , for the MPb2 Hal5 matrices were performed in [34, 50,74,77] using expressions obtained in a single-frequency adiabatic approximation in Riseberg and Moos (R&M) [90] and Miyakava and Dexter (M&D) [91] models in a so-called Born-Oppenheimer rough approximation. Both models describe quite well the dependence of the multiphonon relaxation rate on the energy gap. In the M&D model, the dependence of multiphonon relaxation rate is determined as: W jiN R (E ji ) = W ji (0) · exp(−β · E ji ),
(3.14)
where E ji is the energy gap between the j and i levels, and W ji (0) is the relaxation rate W jiN R at E ji → 0. The parameter β is determined by the expression: β = (1/h¯ ωe f f )[ln{ p/g · (n(ω ¯ e f f ) + 1)} − 1]. (3.15)
36
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
calc , radiative transition probabilities A T , branching TABLE 15. Calculated oscillator strengths f ji ji
ratios β ji , calculated (dipole-dipole) radiative τ rad and experimental τ ex p lifetimes of (j → i) transitions and the multiphonon nonradiative transition probabilities W N R in Er:KPC crystals [77]. Transition j→i 4I 4I 4I
13/2
4I
15/2
11/2
4I
13/2
4I
15/2
4I
11/2
4I
13/2
9/2
4I
4F
9/2
4S
3/2
2H 11/2
4F
7/2
15/2 4I 9/2 4I 11/2 4I 13/2 4I 15/2 4F 9/2 4I 9/2 4I 11/2 4I 13/2 4I 15/2 4S 3/2 4F 9/2 4I 9/2 4I 11/2 4I 13/2 4I 15/2 2H 11/2 4S 3/2 4F 9/2 4I 9/2 4I 11/2 4I 13/2 4I 15/2
∗ ) Data from [44]. ∗∗ ) Data from [77].
ν, ¯ cm −1 6481 3642 10123 2150 5870 12350 2885 5113 8755 15326 3200 6003 8230 11870 18350 900 3900 6700 9040 12700 19000 1100 2000 5000 7800 10140 13800 20300
calc , f ji
∆E, W N R , s −1 cm −1
β ji
10−6
A Tji ,
s −1
τ rad , (τ ex p ) ms
1.5 0.95 1.02 0.11 0.74 0.88 0.72 1.80 0.81 4.48 0.04 1.12 0.29 1.73 1.71 0.06 2.26 2.6 0.97 0.81 24.42 0.42 0.006 0.24 1.38 1.76 2.35 4.18
169 34 277 1 68 360 15 126 167 2778 1 108 53 653 1540 0.1 92 313 213 351 24071 1.36 0.07 16.4 224 484 1194 4609
1 0.1 0.9 0.002 0.16 0.84 0.005 0.04 0.05 0.90 0.0004 0.05 0.02 0.28 0.65 0 0.004 0.01 0.01 0.014 0.96 2 · 10−4 10−5 0.003 0.034 0.074 0.18 0.71
5.9 (8.9)∗ 3.2 (4.3)∗
6000 3150
0 0
2.33 (3.2)∗
1950
14
0.324 (0.420) (0.350)
2300
0.3
0.425 (0.250)
2600
0.01
0.40
660
1.3 · 107 (2 · 106 )∗∗
0.153 (0.010)
1100
1.2 · 105 (9.3 · 104 )
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
37
Here, h¯ ωe f f is the energy of the most active phonon in the process, being equal or slightly lower than the cutoff frequency of the phonon spectrum of the crystal lattice ω0 , p is the number of phonons emitted to the lattice, g is the electron-phonon coupling constant, and n(ω ¯ e f f ) is the average equilibrium number of phonons with the energy h¯ ωe f f : n(ω ¯ e f f ) = [exp(h¯ ωe f f /kT ) − 1]−1 .
(3.16)
In the R&M model, the dependence W jiN R (E ji ) is written as: ¯ h¯ ω0 )] p . W jiN R (T, E ji ) = B · exp(−α · E ji ) · [1 + n(
(3.17)
Here p is the number of phonons transferred to the lattice, p = E ji /h¯ ω0 , ω0 is the cutoff frequency of the phonon spectrum. Characteristics of the crystal lattice B = W jiN R (0) (at E ji = 0 and T → 0 K) and α in the R&M model are determined from the experimental data. For the KPC crystals, the phonon cutoff frequency determined from the Raman scattering spectrum is ω0 ∼ 203 cm−1 , and for KPB it is ω0 ∼ 140 cm−1 . The dependence of multiphonon relaxation rates W jiN R on energy gap ∆E ji for double potassium-lead halogenides (KPC and KPB) are presented in Figure 15, WNR, s−1
Multiphonon Relaxation Rates
108
106
1
YLF
104
2 102
3
KPB
KPC
4
100 10−2 500
1000
1500
2000
Energy gap
2500
3000
∆E, cm−1
Figure 15. Calculated (solid curves) and experimental (points) data for nonradiative relaxation N R = f (∆E ). Curves are the data calculated in the R&M model [90] rates versus energy gap W j,i j,i N R = f (∆E ) in crystals KPC calculated for YLF (curve 1), KPC (curve 2), KPB (curve 4) and W j,i j,i N R (∆E ) in Ho:YLF (open in the M&D model [91] (curve 3). Points are experimental data for Wexp j,i circles) [92], Dy:KPC (solid boxes) [34], Nd:KPC (open boxes) [74], Er:KPC (up-triangles) [77], Tb:KPB (down-triangles) and Nd:KPB (diamonds) [81].
38
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
where calculated (solid curves) and experimental (points) data are shown. For comparison, the calculated dependence of W jiN R = f (E ji ) for double lithiumyttrium fluoride Ho:LiYF4 crystal is shown in Figure 15. The values of parameters within the R&M model are: B = 6.4 × 107 s−1 , α = 3.6 · 10−3 cm, and h¯ ω0 = 560 cm−1 for YLF (curve 1) [92]; B = 4 · 109 s−1 and α = 1.2 · 10−2 cm for KPC (curve 2); B = 4 · 109 s−1 and α = 1.9 · 10−2 cm (the same as for LaBr3 ) for KPB (curve 4), and within the M&D model the parameters are g = 0.1 and W ji (0) = 4 · 109 s−1 for KPC (curve 3). NR The experimental values of Wexp (∆E j,i ) are given for Ho:YLF (open cir3+ cles) [92], KPC:Dy (solid boxes) [34], Nd:KPC (open boxes) [74], Er:KPC (up-triangles) [77], Tb:KPB (down-triangles) and Nd:KPB (diamonds) [81]. NR The values of Wexp (∆E j,i ) were determined from comparison of the exexp 3+ levels in perimental τ j,0 and calculated τ rad j,0 radiative lifetimes of the RE accordance with the expression: NR −1 W j,i = (τ rad − (τ j,0 )−1 . j,0 ) exp
(3.18)
The calculated values of multiphonon relaxation rates in RE-doped fluoride, chloride and bromide matrices for transitions between the excited levels, separated by the energy gaps ∆E j,i ∼1000 cm−1 , are about 2 × 106 s−1 in in YLF; ∼3.5 × 105 s−1 in KPC, and ∼2400 s−1 in KPB. Therefore, in bromide matrix all excited levels of rare-earth ions separated by an energy gap of more than 1000 cm−1 are radiative. Multiphonon relaxation rates in bromides and chlorides are significantly lower than in fluorides. Thus, the RE3+ :MPb2 Hal5 crystals demonstrate high quantum yield of luminescence over a wide spectral range. This opens up new possibilities for efficient emission in mid-IR, as well as for up-conversion processes and possibilities to achieve laser action in UV and visible through IR laser diode excitation. 3.2. EMISSION SPECTRA IN LOW CONCENTRATED CRYSTALS
Low nonradiative relaxation rates in RE3+ :MPb2 Hal5 crystals provide a high quantum yield of luminescence for several transitions in the UV, visible and midIR spectral regions. It is evident that knowledge of the processes that play the basic role in the formation of population of potential laser transition levels, such as ground state absorption (GSA), nonradiative relaxation rates via electron-phonon coupling and excited state absorption (ESA) or multistep absorption, is required for the prediction of emission efficiency of a new crystal. The real emission spectra of RE3+ :MPb2 Hal5 crystals depend mainly on the ratio of the radiative and radiationless transition probabilities. The branching ratios of spontaneous luminescence for transitions originating from directly excited levels can be calculated using the intensity parameters. This information,
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
39
together with the knowledge of excited state absorption probability, radiative life times and nonradiative relaxation rates, permits one to estimate the population of excited levels via cascade scheme of relaxation in crystals with low concentration of RE ions. Experimental studies of the luminescence spectra of the RE:MPb2 Hal5 crystals demonstrate the strong dependence of the intensity of radiative transitions on excitation spectral domain. In this section, we will consider some features of emission spectra under broadband and selective excitation of RE-doped KPC and Nd-doped KPB crystals of low concentration. 3.2.1. The Pr:KPC crystals Emission of the Pr:KPC crystals was studied under direct UV-visible [75] and upconversion [93, 94] excitation. Under broadband Hg-lamp excitation, the most intensive luminescence lines originating from the 3 P0 level (Figure 16) correspond to transitions 3 P0 → 3 F j , 3 H6 (j = 2, 3, 4) (Figure 17). The 1 D2 level is also radiative, but the emission intensity from this level is rather low under short wavelength excitation, because the population of this level is created mainly by radiative transitions from 3 P j levels. In low concentrated crystals, upconversion excitation of 3 P1 , 3 P0 levels occurs due to three photon ESA process. The visible luminescence of Pr3+ ions has been analyzed in [93] by using steady-state and time-resolved laser spectroscopy. Strong visible luminescence was observed from 3 P1 , 3 P0 levels under excitation at 450 nm, into 3 P2 level or one of 3 P1 , 3 P0 levels at 474 or 487 nm. At room temperature, luminescence decay from both these levels was exponential with τexp ≈ 11 µs. Under resonant excitation into 1 D2 level at 590 nm, the luminescence decay also was exponential Ilum, a.u. 3F
2
3H 6
~
3H 6 2
0,1
1D
3P
3
2
0,5
3H
4
3F
1,0
4,3
3P
0
1,5
1D
Luminescence Intensity
3P 0
P0,1,2
1G
4
x10
0,0 600
700
800
900
1000
1100
Wavelength, nm Figure 16. Room temperature emission spectrum of Pr:KPC crystal under UV-VIS excitation [75].
40
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. Pr:MePb2Hal5
E, 103 cm−1
τ, µS 3I
21 18
88
2
ESA 1G
3.7 1.5µm
6 0.99
4,3
3
5
367
4
3F
2
1.9
2 1.4 5
0
1D
Lum
9
3
11
GSA
15 12
3P 6 2,1,0
1
996
3H
F2;
3H
5
3H
4
6
Energy levels scheme and optical transitions in Pr3+ :KPb2 Cl5 crystals under IR exci-
Figure 17. tation at 0.98, 1.5 and 1.9 µm. Solid arrows mark transitions in absorption and luminescence upon selective laser pumping. Figures near the arrows are the wavelengths in µm. Wave arrow indicates the non-radiative transition WNR ; solid bold arrow is the promising laser transition near 5 µm, dashed double arrows are the most probable laser transitions in the near IR (1–3.7 µm) in crystals codoped with Yb under LD pumping.
with τexp ≈ 70 µs. Moreover, luminescence from 3 P1 , 3 P0 levels was observed and analysis of luminescence decay showed that population of these levels is caused by energy transfer upconversion (ETU) processes. Direct IR excitation into 1 G4 level in Pr:KPC crystal is not efficient, because of low absorption cross-section at 3 H4 → 1 G4 transition (Figure 13b). Energy level scheme and optical transitions in Pr3+ :KPb2 Cl5 crystals under IR excitation at 0.98, 1.5 and 1.9 µm are presented in Figure 17. Co-doping with Yb may be used to enhance the efficiency of IR luminescence from 1 G4 level. Emission spectra of Pr,Yb:KPC crystal under IR excitation depend strongly on the excitation wavelength. Upconversion emission from 1 D2 level was observed under excitation at 0.99 µm, due to ESA from 3 F4 level [95]. In Figure 17 the most probable IR laser transitions in crystals co-doped with Yb are denoted with dashed double arrows. Laser action in the mid-IR may be achieved at 5 µm under direct pumping into 3 F2 , 3 H6 level. 3.2.2. The Nd:KPC and Nd:M Pb2 Br5 (M=K or Rb) crystals Potassium-lead chloride (KPC), bromide (KPB) and rubidium-lead bromide (RPB) have similar properties but bromides, in comparison with the KPC crystal, demonstrate a reduced multiphonon decay rate due to lower phonon energy. Therefore, in bromide matrices, RE3+ ions have higher quantum yield for
41
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
F7/2
4
2
P3/2
I11/2
I9/2
F3/2
4
4
F3/2
I13/2
4
F3/2
4
F9/2 D3/2
4
4
F5/2
F3/2
4
4
D3/2
4
D3/2
I15/2
D3/2
4
I13/2 D3/2
I9/2
4
4
4
1,0
0,5
4
1
4
2
D3/2
4
3
1,5
4
D3/2
4
4
Luminescence Intensity
4
F7/2
4
2,0
4
D3/2
5
Ilum, a.u.
Nd:KPb2Cl5
4
6
Luminescence Cross Section
cm2 I11/2
−20
σlum , 10
0 400
500 600 700 Wavelength, nm
a)
800
0,0 800
900
1000
1100
1200
1300
1400
Wavelength, nm
b)
Figure 18. Luminescence spectra of Nd:KPC crystal under different ways of excitation. a) UV excitation (the 4 I9/2 → 2 P3/2 , 2 D5/2 transitions, λexc ≤ 360 nm), b) luminescence under IR excitation, (the 4 I9/2 → 4 F5/2 , 4 F7/2 transitions, λexc = 650–800 nm).
transitions in the mid-IR. This improves the potential for laser action in the mid-IR spectral range. The emission spectra of Nd:KPC crystals show strong dependence on the excitation wavelength [74]. Under UV Hg-lamp excitation in the region of λexc ∼ 340–360 nm, a number of intense bands are observed in the UV, visible, and nearIR, which are assigned to transitions from 4 D3/2 level to lower energy neodymium states (Figure 18 a). Thus, lower energy levels are populated due to radiative cascade transitions from 4 D3/2 level. IR luminescence from 4 F3/2 level, which is usually the most intensive in Nd-doped garnets and fluorides under UV-visible excitation, has low intensity in Nd:MPb2 Hal5 crystals. Under a longer-wavelength excitation in the range 400–760 nm, three emission bands are observed, corresponding to transitions from the 4 F3/2 to the lower 4 Ij (j = 9/2, 11/2, and 13/2) levels and lie in the 870–1320 nm range (Figure 18b). The intensities of transitions 4 F3/2 → 4 I9/2 and 4 F3/2 → 4 I11/2 in the region of 0.9–1.05 µm are nearly equal (Figure 18b), which is in agreement with the calculated branching ratios of 4 F3/2 → 4 Ij ( j = 9/2, 11/2, 13/2, 15/2) transitions, β9/2 :β11/2 :β13/2 :β15/2 = 0.456: 0.461:0.079:004. Quantum efficiency for 4 F3/2 level was found to be ≈ 1 and for 4 F5/2 it was ≈ 0.013. The fluorescence lifetime for 4 F5/2 level was measured to be 3.4 µ s, and for 4 F3/2 level 340 µs [50]. This means that the 4 F5/2 level in KPC host is practically quenched via multiphonon relaxation, the rate for the 4 F5/2 → 4 F3/2 multiphonon transition was estimated to be WNR = 3 × 105 s−1 (TABLE 13). In Nd-doped KPB and RPB crystals, there are intense emissions not only from 4 F3/2 level, but also from the 4 F5/2 level, under selective direct excitation at λexc = 821 nm into 4 F5/2 level [81]. That follows from comparison of fragments of emission spectra of Nd-doped KPC (Figure 19, curve 1) and KPB
42
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. Nd:KPC & Nd:KPB 2000
Luminescence, a.u.
4
F3/2
4
I11/2
1
1500 4
F5/2
1000 4
F3/2
4
I11/2
4
I9/2
500
0 900
950
1000
1050
Wavelength, nm Figure 19. Room-temperature unpolarized emission spectra obtained by excitation of the 4 F5/2 level of Nd3+ -doped KPC (dash curve) and KPB crystals (solid curve).
(Figure 19, curve 2) crystals. Thus, new emission lines originating from 4 F5/2 level are observed at 0.82, 0.97 and 1.19 µm, indicated in the energy level scheme by arrows together with transitions originating from 4 F3/2 level (Figure 20). Lasing at 1.07 µm was obtained with slope efficiency of 4.4% in Nd:KPB and with 16.8% in Nd:RPB on 4 F3/2 → 4 I11/2 transition. Laser action from 4 F5/2 level was achieved in Nd:KPB and Nd:RPB on the transitions {4 F5/2 + 2 H9/2 } → 4 Ij ( j = 13/2, 11/2) at the new wavelengths of 1.18 and 0.98 µm, accordingly [48]. The fluorescence spectrum from the first excited state 4 I11/2 near 5.5 µm was recorded in [78]. The results of the study of luminescence kinetics from the lowest 4 Ij (j = 11/2, 13/2 and 15/2) levels and cross-relaxation processes in Nd:KPC crystals under pumping into 4 I15/2 level gave evidence for the possibility of laser action on the 4 I11/2 → 4 I9/2 transition at ∼ 5.5 µm [80, 87]. Consideration of excited state dynamics of a potential laser transition 4 I11/2 → 4 I9/2 at either 800 or 880 nm excitation [80], taking into account self-quenching processes occuring via cross-relaxation schemes (SQ1 and SQ2 in Figure 20), demonstrated the possibility of achieving the population inversion on the 4 I11/2 → 4 I9/2 transition [80, 87]. The conclusion was that Nd:KPC crystals appear to be good candidates for mid-IR lasers. 3.2.3. The Tb:KPC crystals The lower excited levels in Tb-doped crystals are separated with an energy gap of less than 1000 cm−1 , with the exception of the first 7 F5 level (Figure 21). In Tb:KPC crystals, the most intense band observed in the IR luminescence spectrum corresponds to transition 7 F5 → 7 F6 at (4.6–5.5) µm, as indicated in Figure 21 by the dashed arrow. Other levels are partly quenched via multiphonon relaxation.
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
43
Figure 20. Energy level scheme and optical transitions in Nd3+ :MPb2 Br5 crystals. Arrows mark transitions in absorption and luminescence upon selective laser diode pumping (0.75, 0.81, and 0.89 µm). Figures near the arrows are the wavelengths in µm; solid double arrows are the laser transition at 1.07 µm in KPC:Nd [32], 0.97, 1.19 µm in KPB:Nd and RPB:Nd [48]; dashed double arrow is the most probable laser transition in the mid-IR (4.8–5.5 µm) [80, 81]. ESA – excited state absorption, SQ1 and SQ2 – selfquenching processes. Tb: MPb2Hal5 E, 1000cm 6
−1
τ (KPB) 7F
5
0,1
1.9 µm 2 µm
7F
2
Wji
7F
4
3
λpump
10 µm
4.7 µm
7
3
7F
5
2
1
0
F4
2.10 µs
8 µm
2.9 µm
2.3 µm 3 µm
2.8 µs
5 µm
7F
6
Figure 21. Energy level scheme, and absorption and luminescence transitions in Tb:KPC crystal. Solid arrows indicate the absorption transitions; wave arrows – multiphonon relaxation; dash arrows – luminescent transitions in IR, and possible laser transition in the 5 µm spectral region. The numbers near solid arrows are the wavelengths in micrometers.
44
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
This coincides with calculation of the radiative probabilities and estimate of the multiphonon relaxation rates for 7 Fj ( j = 0 − 5) levels (TABLE 14). The emission cross-section spectra of Tb:KPB crystals were measured at room temperature in the mid IR. The maximal emission cross-sections are 6 · 10−21 cm2 (transition 7 F4 → 7 F6 at ∼3 µm), 6 · 10−21 cm2 (transition 7 F5 → 7 F6 at ∼5 µm), and 5 · 10−21 cm2 (transition 7 F4 → 7 F5 at ∼ 8 µm) [81]. The values of calculated radiative lifetimes τ rad for 7 F5 , 7 F4 and 7 F3 levels are 34.6, 12.5, and 8.7 ms, correspondingly, and close to the reported values for Tb:KPC in [75]. Experimental values of τ ex p for the 7 F4 and 7 F5 levels in Tb:KPB crystals were measured at room temperature. They vary from 3 to 22 ms for the 7 F5 level and from 0.19 to 0.42 ms for the 7 F4 level, which is likely due to concentration dependent effects or other impurities in the crystals. The largest quantum efficiency for the 7 F5 level is 0.64 and 0.03 for the 7 F4 level, which were estimated depending on the ratio of the measured and radiative lifetimes [81]. The long lifetimes of the 7 F5 and the 7 F4 levels in Tb:KPB crystals inspire the hope for laser action in the mid-IR region. The promising transitions for laser action in mid IR are shown in Figure 21. The properties of the Tb:KPB crystals make them potentially useful for long-wavelength infrared applications. 3.2.4. The Er3+ :KPC crystals The emission spectra of the Er3+ :KPC crystals strongly depend on excitation wavelengths [77]. The intensity of the transitions originating from the directly excited levels to the lower energy levels correlate with the branching ratios for both the broadband excitation and selective excitation. For example, under UV selective excitation at λexc = 355 nm, corresponding to the transition from ground state 4 I15/2 to (4 G9/2 + 2 K15/2 + 2 G7/2 ) group of levels, the most intense are the bands in the regions of 383 and 508 nm, corresponding to the transitions 4 G11/2 → 4 Ij ( j = 15/2, 13/2) (Figure 22 a, curve 1). Whereas the 4 G11/2 level is efficiently populated by the radiative and multiphonon relaxation from directly pumped 2 G7/2 level, much weaker lines near 408 and 560 nm can be assigned to transitions from the 2 G9/2 level. Luminescence from lower levels 4 F9/2 , 2 H11/2 , 4 S3/2 and 4 F9/2 show low intensity under UV pumping, but increase significantly upon excitation in the visible spectral range (400–600 nm) (Figure 22 a, curve 2). Luminescence in the near-IR region from 4 I11/2 , 4 I13/2 is the most intense under excitation into 4 I9/2 level or under direct excitation into 4 I11/2 at 975 nm (Figure 22 b, c). Energy level scheme and radiative and nonradiative transitions in Er:KPC crystals are shown in Figure 23, together with indications of transitions. Most of the levels in Er:KPC are radiative, as shown on the scheme by bold lines. The
45
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY Er:KPC
Ilum, a.u.
4
I13/2
I13/2
4
I15/2
4
I15/2 I9/2
I11/2
4
4
G9/2
800
900
3
4
4
0,2
S3/2
4
2
F7/2
G9/2
4
4
I11/2
4
G11/2
2
4
0,4
4
I15/2
S3/2
4
4
I15/2
1 0,6
I11/2
4
F9/2
G11/2
4
4
0,8
I15/2
I13/2
I15/2
4
4
G11/2
1,0
2
Luminescence Intensity
1,2
0,0 400
500
600 700 Wavelength, nm
a) Er:KPC
Er:KPC 4
1,2
I13/2
4
I15/2
Luminescence intensity, a.u.
Luminescence intensity, a.u.
1,2
1,0 0,8 4
0,6 0,4
I11/2
4
I15/2
2 1
0,2 0,0
1000
1200 1400 Wavelength, nm
b)
1600
4
I11/2
1,0
4
I13/2
0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0,0 2500
2600
2700 2800 2900 Wavelength, nm
3000
c)
Emission spectra of Er3+ :KPC: crystals. T = 300 K. a) UV selective excitation
Figure 22. at λexc = 355 nm (bold curve 1), UV-VIS excitation in the range 400–600 nm (curve 2), and RED excitation in the range 600–700 nm (dashed curve 3); b) LD excitation at 975 nm, transitions 4I 4 4 4 11/2 → I15/2 (curve 1) and I13/2 → I15/2 (curve 2); c) LD excitation at 975 nm, transition 4I 4 11/2 → I13/2 .
transitions originating from these levels are indicated by arrows. Figures near the arrows are the wavelengths in nm. Lasing was performed in Er:KPC crystal at room temperature using 803 nm laser diode pump, and laser action on the 4.53 µm transition was achieved with 6.5% optical slope efficiency [45]. The crystal had no antireflection coatings and no environmental precautions were taken to protect the laser rod from the atmosphere. Laser action on three lines centered at 4.42, 4.53 and 4.67 µm was achieved using a high-Q cavity. Corresponding laser transition 4 I9/2 → 4 I11/2 [44, 45] is indicated in Figure 23 as bold solid arrow. Among the other transitions in the mid-IR, the 4 I11/2 → 4 I13/2 transition at 2.8 µm may be considered as promising for laser action under direct laser diode pumping. This transition is indicated in Figure 23 as bold dashed arrow L3.
46
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. EXCITON AND CONDUCTION BANDS 2
2
G7/2 4G 9/2 4 G11/2 H(G)9/2 4F
3/2 4F 5/2 4 F7/2 2 H11/2 4 S3/2 4F
355
380 nm
Exc.
408 450 495
Wij
530 550
L2
9/2
Aij
FSA
660
4
I9/2 4I 11/2
800
L1 L3
980 4
I13/2 LD1
1500
4I 15/2
Figure 23. Energy level scheme and radiative transitions in Er3+ :KPb2 Cl5 crystals. Arrows mark transitions in absorption and luminescence upon selective laser pumping. Figures near the arrows are the wavelengths in nm. Aji are the radiative transitions; W ji are the non-radiative transitions; Exc. is UV pumping at 355 nm, LD1 is the IR laser diode pumping (λ L D = 975 nm); L1 (bold arrow) is the laser transition near the 4.4 µm [45]. Dashed bold arrows are the most probable laser transitions at 3.4 (L2) and 2.8 µm (L3).
4. Energy transfer and dynamics of RE3+ levels population Energy transfers arising from interaction of excited states of RE ions play the important role in the laser crystals. In crystals with low RE concentration, upconversion excitation of RE ions under laser diode pumping occurs mainly through multi-step absorption from ground and excited states, followed by relaxation from the upper excited levels. These processes are shown schematically in Figure 24 a. Increasing the dopant ion concentration leads to energy transfer through nonradiative interactions, followed by quenching of luminescence from one of the excited levels in ion “a” and excitation from ground state in the nearest ion “b”. This cross-relaxation process (2 − 1) in ion “a” and (0 − 1) in ion “b” is shown in Figure 24 b. If crystals are doped with one type of RE ion, this process is denoted as “self-quenching” (Figure 24 b). Nonradiative interaction between “a” and “b” ions, both being in excited states, leads to upconversion of excitation in ion “a” and down conversion in the other ion “b”. As a result, emission at shorter wavelength is observed and this is the so-called anti-Stokes’ luminescence (Figure 24 c).
47
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
hn2
ESA
Ilum
ETU
SQ
1
hn1
GSA
GSA
2
2
2
1
1
Ilum
Ilum
GSA
0
0 a)
ion a
ion b
Selfquenching
GSA
ion a
ion b
0
Upconversion
b)
c)
Figure 24. Excited state absorption (a) and nonradiative energy transfer processes: selfquenching (b) and upconversion (c).
Thus, population inversion on the working laser levels under IR selective pumping by laser diodes strongly depends on: 1) ground state absorption (GSA) at pump wavelength, 2) nonradiative relaxation (W N R ) via electron-phonon coupling, 3) excited state absorption (ESA) or multistep absorption, 4) non-radiative energy transfer (ET) via: – self-quenching, – nonlinear quenching or upconversion via cross-relaxation scheme, – cooperative coupling. Combination of all processes noted above determines the ability to achieve laser action in desired spectral range under diode laser pumping. The efficiency of these nonlinear effects strongly depends on RE ion concentration, excitation spectral region, and pump power density. Upconversion of the excitation energy due to ESA and ETU can play the desired or adverse effect on laser action: these processes populate either one or the other level of laser transitions. So, they are positive in the case of population increase of the initial level of the laser transition or population decrease of the terminal level of the laser transition. In the opposite case, upconversion processes play a negative role, leading to a drastic increase in pump threshold and saturation or decrease of output power. It is especially important to take account of upconversion processes in laser hosts having narrow phonon spectrum, such as RE:MPb2 Hal5 crystals. In these crystals, with extremely low multiphonon relaxation rates, a great number of levels take part in upconversion processes.
48
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
An understanding of the processes responsible for the creation of population on the RE levels is of great importance. One of the most effective ways to solve this problem is the study of energy transfer dynamics under selective excitation, including the dependencies on concentration, pump power and temperature. Additional information about energy transfer processes can be obtained on the basis of experimental study of the emission spectra under different excitation conditions using the methods of steady-state and time-resolved spectroscopy with selective excitation. These processes become most brightly apparent under short-pulse IR excitation. To discriminate between ESA and ETU upconversion processes, it is useful to study luminescence spectra under both CW laser diode and short-pulse laser excitation. The efficiency of these processes will be demonstrated on the examples of Pr, Nd and Er-doped KPC crystals. 4.1. UPCONVERSION PROCESSES IN PRASEODYMIUM DOPED KPC CRYSTALS
The study of the upconversion spectra and luminescence decay in Pr:KPC crystal [93, 94] have been performed with different methods of excitation: under orange excitation in resonance with the 3 H4 → 1 D2 transition [93], and IR excitation coincident with the 3 H4 → 1 G4 transition [94]. Upconversion emission from 3 P0 and 3 P1 as well as from 1 D2 levels has been observed. Temporal evolution of the decay of the upconverted emission, together with experiments with IR excitation, provided evidence that at room temperature both energy transfer upconversion and excited state absorption are responsible for luminescence from the 1 D2 and 3 P0 levels. However, at low temperature a dominant ESA upconversion mechanism involving praseodymium ions in the intermediate 3 F3,4 states seems to be responsible for the upconverted luminescence from the 1 D2 level. The possible upconversion processes (UC1, UC2 and ESA) are shown in Figure 25. Consideration of the relaxation and upconversion processes in Pr:KPC crystal shows that the (3 F2 , 3 H6 ) → 3 H5 (∼5 µm) transition can be considered as promising laser transition in the mid-IR under direct pumping into the 3 F2 , 3 H6 levels by Er-laser at 1.5 µm or laser diodes. Pumping of the 1 G4 level by laser diodes emitting at 0.98 µm is not efficient for the Pr:KPC crystal, due to low absorption cross-section of the 3 H4 → 1 G4 transition (Figure 14). More efficient population of 1 G4 level and upconversion luminescence from 3 P0 level was observed in crystals co-doped with Yb using excitation at 937.5 nm [95]. New processes leading to laser-induced internal cooling based on electronphonon dynamics in Yb:KPC was observed and discussed in [96]. It was observed that the material cools to 150 K under pumping of the sample at high and low pump power densities. This effect may be used to decrease thermal losses in mid-IR laser rods.
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
49
Figure 25. Energy levels scheme and optical transitions in Pr3+ :KPb2 Cl5 crystals under upconversion IR excitation. Arrows denote transitions in absorption and luminescence upon selective laser pumping at 988 nm. Wave arrow indicates the non-radiative transition W N R ; bold solid arrow is the most promising laser transition near 5 µm. Figures near the arrows are the wavelengths in µm. ESA – is excited state absorption, thin arrows are nonradiative energy transfer: upconversion (UC1 and UC2) and selfquenching (SQ).
4.2. UPCONVERSION AND DYNAMICS OF NEODYMIUM LEVELS POPULATION
Upconversion processes in Nd-doped KPb2 Cl5 crystals were studied in [97] and [98]. Upconversion spectra of the Nd:KPb2 Cl5 crystals under CW laser diode pumping into the 4 F5/2 level (λLD = 807 nm, Ppump = 1.8 W) are presented in Figure 26, together with indications of the transitions [98]. One can see that the most intense bands in the emission spectrum of Nd:KPC originate from the 4 F3/2 and 4 F5/2 levels (882 nm and 812 nm, respectively). Several bands of lower intensity are observed in the visible and UV, which are excited by two or three photons at 807 nm. The emission bands were found near 870, 812, 750, 660, 590, 530, 470 and 435 nm, corresponding to the transitions 4 Fj (j = 3/2, 5/2, 7/2) → 4 I9/2 ; (4 G7/2 + 4 G9/2 + 2 K13/2 ) → 4 Ij (j = 13/2, 11/2, 9/2); 4 G11/2 → 4 I9/2 and 2 P3/2 → 4 I9/2 , respectively. The analysis of the dynamic behavior of upconversion luminescence, together with its dependence on the excitation wavelength and pump intensity, was performed in [97]. It was found that the most likely mechanism responsible for emissions at 535, 595 and 655 nm arising from levels (4 G7/2 , 4 G9/2 ) and (4 G5/2 , 2 G7/2 ) is ETU involving two ions in the 4 F3/2 state, whereas emission from level 4 D3/2 requires a three-step mechanism involving ions in both the 4 F3/2 and 4 G7/2 states. The emission at 435 nm arising from level 2 P1/2 suggests that ETU involving two ions in the 4 F3/2 level is responsible for this luminescence
50
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
Nd:KPC
G7/2
4
4
F3/2
I15/2
4
4
4
F5/2
4
I9/2
I9/2
4
F7/2
4
4
G7/2
4
I13/2
4
4
4
I9/2
4
G7/2+ G9/2
4
G11/2
I9/2
I9/2
4
1
4
0,5
P1/2
4
1,0
4
1,5
I9/2
I11/2
LD x 50
2
G7/2+ G9/2+ K13/2
2,0
2
Luminescence Intensity, a.u.
2,5
0,0 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 800 850 900 950 Wavelength, nm
Figure 26. Upconversion emission spectra of Nd:KPC crystals under laser diode (LD) excitation of the 4 F5/2 level at 807 nm together with indications of transitions. Curve 2 is multiplied by 50 with respect to curve 1. Pump power Ppump = 1.8 W.
when pumping into the 4 F5/2 band, whereas when pumping at 851 or 858 nm the emission can be attributed to an ESA process from level 4 F3/2 . Upconversion process arising from absorption of pump energy from excited level 4 F3/2 in Figure 27 are denoted as ESA; the nonradiative transitions leading to self-quenching are labeled as SQ1 and SQ2, and nonradiative upconversion energy transfer are indicated as ETU. We have recorded upconversion spectra of Nd-doped KPB and RPB crystals under comparable conditions to those in Nd:KPC - that is under IR laser diode excitation into the 4 F5/2 level (λLD2 = 807 nm) and at the same pump power level of ∼1.8 W. Similar to Nd:KPC, in Nd-doped KPB and RPB crystals, one can see a number of emission bands in the IR and visible spectral region near 870, 812, 750, 660, 590, 530, 470 and 435 nm, corresponding to the radiative transitions 4 Fj (j = 3/2, 5/2, 7/2) → 4 I9/2 , (4 G7/2 + 4 G9/2 + 2 K13/2 ) → 4 Ij (j = 13/2, 11/2, 9/2), 4 G11/2 → 4 I9/2 and 2 P3/2 → 4 I9/2 , respectively (Figures 28 a and 28 b). The positions of the bands in Nd-doped KPB and RPB crystals are practically the same as in Nd:KPC, but relative intensities of the bands are different. Sharp distinction from KPC crystal is the intensive luminescence originating from directly (one-photon) pumped 4 F5/2 level. In the Nd:KPB and Nd:RPB crystals, nonradiative relaxation rate is significantly lower and as a result quantum yield of the luminescence from 4 F5/2 level (the band near 812 nm) in both crystals is significantly higher as compared with Nd:KPC, in spite of the same energy gap as in Nd:KPC crystal. This is clearly seen in Figures 28 a and 28 b, curves 1.
51
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY E, 103 cm−1
Nd:MPb2Hal5 4
2L
30
D7/2
15/2
2
I11/2 4 D3/2, 5/2
364
2P
3/2
2
P1/2,2D5/2 2 K15/2 2 G9/2,4G11/2
435 20
4
G7/2,
535
WNR ESA
4
9/2,
,2G
G5/2
590
2K
13/2
7/2
4 F 4F9/2 4F7/2 5/2 4F 3/2
ETU 10 LD
750
750
SQ 4I
668
15/2
4
I13/2
595
4
I11/2
5.5µm
4I
0
9/2
Figure 27. The energy levels scheme and radiative and nonradiative transitions in the Nd:KPC crystal under selective excitation by laser diode (LD). ESA – excited state absorption, SQ – selfquenching, ETU – nonradiative upconversion, solid arrows indicate luminescent transitions, dash arrow – the most probable laser transition in mid-IR. Figures near the arrows are the wavelengths in nm.
I9/2
4
F5/2
4
I9/2
4
F3/2
4
2
4
F7/2+ S3/2 I9/2
4
4
4
4
4
3
1
4
2
P1/2
4
4
I9/2
1,0 0,5
G7/2,9/2 I11/2
4
1,5
I9/2 G7/2 I11/2
(3) x 50
4
2,0
LD
4
4
G7/2,9/2 I13/2
4
G11/2 I9/2
Luminescence Intensity
F3/2
4
2
4
G7/2+ G5/2
G7/2,9/2 I9/2
I9/2
2
4
I9/2
4
F5/2
4
I9/2
4
F7/2+ S3/2
1
4
4
4
3
G7/2,9/2 I13/2
4
4
I9/2
I11/2
4
4
G7/2,9/2
G7/2+ G5/2
I9/2
4 4
G7/2,9/2
4
2
P1/2 I9/2
4
4
6
2
(3) x 50 8
2,5
2
Luminescence Intensity
(2) x 5 10
Nd:RPB
Ilum, a.u.
LD
2
Nd:KPC
Ilum, a.u. 12
0 400
500
600 700 800 Wavelength, nm
900
1000
0,0 400
500
600 700 800 Wavelength, nm
900
1000
a) b) Figure 28. Upconvrsion emission spectra of Nd:KPB (a), and Nd:RPB (b) crystals under laser diode (LD) excitation at 807 nm together with indications of transitions. Curve 2 is multiplied by 5 and curve 3 by 50 with respect to curve 1. Pump power Ppump = 1.8 W.
52
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
Besides that in the emission spectra of Nd:KPB and Nd:RPB, there are some differences in the relative intensity for the emission originated from the same neodymium levels in KPB and KPC hosts. For example, the ratios of peak intensities for the bands near 890 and 812 nm (transitions originated from 4 F3/2 and 4 F5/2 levels), namely R = I1 (890)/I2 (812) in Nd-doped KPC, KPB and RPB crystals, are R(KPC) = 8.5, R(KPB) = 0.9 and R(RPB) = 0.2, respectively (Figures 25 and 27). The spectra were recorded under comparable conditions of excitation into the 4 F5/2 level (807 nm). The ratio of multiphonon relaxation rates for KPC and KPB crystals is estimated as ∼10 (see Figure 15), and it is of the same order as the ratio of line intensities R(KPC)/R(KPB) = 9.4. As follows from multiphonon relaxation rates measurements [81], the W N R for Nd:KPB and Nd:RPB are practically equal, but the ratio R(KPB) is distinctly higher than that for RPB, namely R(KPB)/R(RBP) ∼ 4.5. This discrepancy for KPB and RPB crystals may be explained by different structures of KPB and RPB crystals: KPB 5 crystal belongs to monoclinic P21 /c (C2h ) space group symmetry, but RPB crys18 tal belongs to tetragonal I 4/mcm (D4h ) group symmetry (see TABLE 4). The different crystal structures also cause the disparity in line intensities in optical absorption and emission spectra (Figures 14 and 28). Noticeable differences in upconversion spectra of Nd:KPC and Nd:MPb2 Br5 crystals reflect the different upconversion processes: ESA and nonlinear coupling (ETU), denoted in Figure 27 as thin solid arrows. In crystals with narrow phonon spectrum, the greater number of levels take part in upconversion processes. In Nd:MPb2 Br5 crystals, the emission from 4 F5/2 , 4 F7/2 and (2 G5/2 + 4 G5/2 ) levels is more intense than that in Nd:KPC, because of higher population of these levels in bromides due to more probable ESA upconversion processes. That is why the bands near 812, 750, 660 and 590 nm in bromides are more intense. ESA is the main upconversion mechanism for population of the 2 P3/2 level, in which two photons are involved in excitation of the luminescence near 435 nm, transition 2 P3/2 → 4 I9/2 . Both energy transfer processes, ESA and upconversion (ETU in Figure 27), seem to be responsible for luminescence from 4 D3/2 level [97]. In order to elucidate the role of ESA and ETU excitation in the Nd-doped KPC crystal, we have recorded the upconversion spectra and luminescence kinetics under nanosecond laser pulse excitation into the 4 F5/2 level (at 807 nm). The fragments of room-temperature emission spectra of Nd:KPC recorded with CCD camera are shown in Figure 29. Laser pulse duration was about 15 ns, gate width was the same as gate step and equal to 1 µs (Figure 28 a, b) or 10 µs (Figure 29 c, d). It is clearly seen in Figure 29 that the intensity of all lines originating from Nd excited levels 4 F3/2 , 4 S3/2 + 4 F7/2 , 4 G5/2 + 2 G7/2 , 4 G9/2,7/2 , 2 P1/2 , 2 P3/2 and 4 D3/2 (numbers 1, 3–10) have risetimes and increase during the first several microseconds. The only 4 F5/2 level directly pumped by laser pulse at 807 nm is populated during the pump pulse.
53
4
1
3
0 10 20
15
Tim 20 25 e, µ 30 300 s
µs
10
5
400
500
600
700
Wavelength, nm
30 500
600
700
800
900 1000
Wavelength, nm
b) Intensity, a.u.
a) 5 6 10
9
8 7
2
5
Intensity, a.u.
5
6 8 7
1 4
3
0 10 20 500
600
Wavelength, nm
c)
700
e,
e,
m
500
600
700
800
900 1000
30
Ti
400
µs
µs
0 10 20
Ti
30 300
Ti m e,
9
10
Intensity, a.u.
2
5
m
Intensity, a.u.
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
Wavelength, nm
d)
Figure 29. Room temperature upconversion luminescence spectra of Nd:KPC crystal under IR pulse laser excitation of the 4 F5/2 level at λexc = 807 nm. Pulse duration ∼ 15 ns. The spectra were recorded using CCD camera with delay = 0. In a) and b) time between neighbouring spectra is 1 µs, each spectrum was recoded during 1 µs. In c) and d) time between neighbouring spectra is 10 µs, each spectrum was recoded during 10 µs. The numeration of the emission bands corresponds to transitions: 1–4 F3/2 → 4 I9/2 (890 nm); 2–4 F5/2 → 4 I9/2 (812 nm); 3–(4 S3/2 + 4 F7/2 ) → 4 I9/2 (750 nm), or/and (4 G5/2 + 2 G7/2 ) → 4 I13/2 (760 nm); 4–4 G9/2,7/2 → 4 I13/2 (675 nm) or/and (4 G5/2 + 2 G7/2 ) → 4 I11/2 (668 nm); 5–4 G9/2,7/2 → 4 I11/2 (595 nm) or/and (4 G5/2 + 2 G7/2 ) → 4 I9/2 (595 nm); 6–4 G9/2,7/2 → 4 I9/2 (535 nm); 7–(4 G11/2 + 2 G9/2 ) → 4 I9/2 (480 nm); 8–2 P1/2 → 4 I9/2 (434 nm); 9–2 P3/2 → 4 I9/2 (380 nm); 10–4 D3/2 → 4 I9/2 (360 nm).
This can also be seen from luminescence kinetics curves shown in Figure 30. Luminescence decay from directly pumped 4 F5/2 Nd level has no risetime (Figure 30, curve 1) and shows at least two components (τ1 ∼ 2.3 µs and τ2 ∼ 221 µs). The fast decay component corresponds to the lifetime of the directly pumped 4 F5/2 level. The slow decay component reflects indirect population of the 4 F5/2 level after the end of excitation pulse. There are two reasons for indirect population of the 4 F5/2 level: the first is radiative relaxation from the upper two-photon excited levels, and the second is the population of 4 F5/2 level due to nonradiative upconversion processes (ETU in Figure 27) in which the 4 F3/2 state takes part. These processes may be a result of nonradiative nonlinear coupling of two long living 4 F3/2 states and/or nonlinear coupling of the 4 F3/2 state and one of
54
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
Nd:KPC
Luminescence intensity, a.u.
1
2
τ1 = 26 µs
τ = 221 µs
3 1
5
τ2 = 71 µs
4 0,1
τ1 = 2.3 µs
τ = 38 µs
τ2 = 221 µs 0,00
0,02
0,04
0,06
0,08
0,10
0,12
0,14
Time, ms Figure 30. Upconversion luminescence kinetics for Nd:KPC crystal (Nd 1 at.%) under selective laser excitation of the 4 F5/2 level (excitation at wavelength λexc = 807 nm, pulse duration ∼ 15 ns). Curve 1 – the luminescence band at 807 nm; curve 2 – at 891 nm; curve 3 – at 595 nm, curve 4 – at 434 nm, and curve 5 – at 364 nm, these bands correspond to 4 F5/2 → 4I 4 4 4 4 2 4 4 4 15/2 , F3/2 → I15/2 , G9/2,7/2 → I13/2 , P1/2 → I15/2 , and D3/2,1/2 → I15/2 transitions, respectively.
lower 4 Ij levels, most likely the 4 I11/2 level. The 4 F3/2 level is populated due to fast relaxation from the 4 F5/2 level, the luminescence decay from the 4 F3/2 level being exponential with a lifetime of ∼ 220 µs (Figure 30, curve 2, λem = 891 nm). Luminescence from all other excited levels, 4 G9/2,7/2 (Figure 30, curve 3), 2 P1/2 (Figure 30, curve 4) and 4 D3/2,1/2 (Figure 30, curve 5) (λem = 891, 595, 434 and 363 nm, respectively) have risetimes and complicated decay curves, reflecting the processes responsible for their population. Thus, the conclusion may be drawn that ETU processes are responsible for upconversion population of Nd levels under IR pulse excitation. The possible schemes of upconversion processes in Nd-doped crystals are shown in Figure 27, where energy transfer processes arising from selective excitation by laser diode are indicated as SQ (self-quenching) and ETU (nonradiative) upconversion processes, and solid arrows indicate luminescent transitions. In the visible spectral range, 4 G7/2 → 4 Ij (j = 9/2, 11/2, 13/2) transitions at 660, 590, 530 and 435 nm can be considered as promising for the attainment of laser action. The possibility of achieving laser action in new Nd:KPb2 Cl5 crystals in the mid-IR at 5 µm was considered in [86]. On the basis of the experiments and subsequent Judd-Ofelt analysis of the low-lying 4 Ij multiplet, it was found that the first excited state 4 I11/2 is metastable with millisecond lifetime. Using a simple laser rate model, the excited state dynamics for a new 5.5 µm laser was investigated and it
55
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
was shown that this laser should be easily realized under 800 nm excitation using moderately concentrated samples [80]. Thus, the most probable mid-IR laser transition is 4 I11/2 → 4 I9/2 at 5–5.5 µm (Figure 27). 4.3. UPCONVERSION AND DYNAMICS OF ERBIUM LEVELS POPULATION
Erbium-doped MPb2 Hal5 crystals are promising candidates for mid-IR lasers pumped directly by commercial high-power laser diodes at 0.67, 0.80 and 0.98 µm [44, 45]. Upconversion luminescence in blue (450 nm) and green (550 nm) was observed for Er:KPC crystal, pumped by 0.8 µm laser diode [78]. Upconversion spectra and luminescence decay dynamics for Er:KPC crystal are reported in [98]. In this work, we continue the study of upconversion luminescence for Er:KPC crystal under CW laser diode and short-pulse laser excitation. Upconversion spectra with one-wavelength CW laser diode pumping into 4 I11/2 level (λLD1 = 975 nm) and two-wavelength CW laser diode pumping (λLD1 = 975 nm and (λLD2 = 808 nm) are presented in Figure 31a and b. Single-wavelength CW laser diode pumping into the 4 I11/2 level leads to two-step (GSA and ESA) excitation of the 4 F7/2 level (band around 495 nm, in Figure 31 a). Following this, the process of multiphonon relaxation populates the 2 H11/2 and 4 S3/2 levels (emission bands near 530 and 550 nm in Figure 31a). Thus, under CW excitation, the most intense luminescence bands near 530 and 550 nm originate from 2 H11/2 and 4 S3/2 levels. Population of other higher energy levels, 4 F5/2 , 2 G9/2 and 4 G11/2 , occurs through more complicated schemes including nonradiative ETU as well as multistep ESA followed by relaxation from higher levels KPC:Er
0,2
2
0,4
4 4 4
H11/2-> I15/2
4 4
3
1
2
0,6
2
0,8
4
1,0
G11/2-> I15/2
4
1,2
G9/2-> I15/2
4
4
1,4
4
1,6
F7/2-> I15/2
4
1,8
G11/2-> I13/2
F5/2-> I15/2
2,0
4
4 4 2
4
4
1
4
4
x5
4
0,4
G9/2-> I15/2
0,6
2
4
0,8
G11/2-> I15/2
1,0
F5/2-> I15/2
1,2
G11/2-> I13/2
4
1,4
H11/2-> I15/2
4
1,6
4
F7/2-> I15/2
1,8
2,2 Luminescence Intensity, a.u.
S3/2-> I15/2
2,0
4
Luminescence Intensity, a.u.
2,2
S3/2-> I15/2
KPC:Er
2
0,2 0,0
0,0 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580
360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580
Wavelength, nm
Wavelength, nm
a)
b)
Figure 31. Emission spectra of Er3+ :KPC crystals upon LD excitation. a) Excitation by LD1 emitting at 975 nm; curve 2 is multiplied by 5 with respect to curve 1. b) Excitation by one LD1, emitting at λLD1 = 975 nm (curves 1, 2) and excitation by two laser diodes: LD1 emitting at λLD1 = 975 nm and LD2 emitting at λLD2 = 808 nm (curve 3). Curve 2 is multiplied by 5 with respect to curve 1. The spectrum 3 is normalized to a line near 495 nm, corresponding to transition 4F 4 7/2 → I15/2 . T = 300 K.
56
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL. EXCITION AND CONDUCTION BANDS 2
G7/2 4G 9/2 4G 11/2
2
ESA 380nm
H(G)9/2
408
4F 3/2
4F 5/2
450
2F 7/2 2H
11/2
4
495 Wij
530
S3/2
4
550
F9/2 Aij
ESA
4I 9/2 4I 11/2
L2 NC2
660
L1
800
980
L3
NC1
4
I13/2 LD1
LD2
SQ 1500
4I 15/2
Figure 32. The energy levels scheme and radiative and nonradiative transitions in the Er:KPC crystal under selective excitation by laser diodes LD1 (λLD1 = 975 nm) and LD2 (λLD2 = 808 nm). ESA – excited state absorption, SQ – selfquenching, NC1 and NC2 – nonradiative upconversion (ETU), thin solid arrows indicate luminescent transitions at the shortest wavelength. Figures near the arrows are the wavelengths in nm corresponding to the highest energy transitions. Laser transition at 4.4 µm is marked with bold arrow L1, the probable mid-IR laser transitions in Er:KPC crystal denoted with double dash arrows L2 (near 3.4 µm) and L3 (near 2.8 µm).
(Figure 32). In any case, population of the 4 F5/2 , 2 G9/2 and 4 G11/2 levels requires at least three photons at 975 nm. Corresponding luminescence bands originating from 4 F5/2 level (around 455 nm), from 2 G9/2 level (near 410 nm) and from 4 G11/2 level (around 385 and 507 nm), have lower intensity (note that curve 2 in Figure 31, corresponding to these transitions, is multiplied by 5). Pumping of Er:KPC with two laser diodes, LD1 (λLD1 = 975 nm) and LD2 (λLD2 = 808 nm), leads to significant increase of the luminescence from the 4 F5/2 level at 450 nm (Figure 31 b, curve 3). In the case of two-wavelength CW laser diode pumping, the 4 F5/2 level is populated due to two-step excitation: transitions 4 I15/2 → 4 I11/2 (GSA of LD1 emission) and 4 I11/2 → 4 F5/2,3/2 (ESA of LD2 emission), as shown in Figure 32. The last process is efficient only in the presence of LD1 emission, because of rather low absorption cross-section at 808 nm, which p is σabs (808 nm) = 0.09x10−20 cm2 .
57
3
7
5
1
4
3
3
5
2
2
1
6
2
4
1
0 0 50 100
Ti me ,
µs
Tim 150200 250 e, 300 µs
0 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200
460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 600
Wavelength, nm
650
700
750
800
850
b) 20 15
5 10
6
5 0
20
3
1
15 10
2
4
5 0
Wavelength, nm
c)
Ti
3
460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600
Ti
me
me
,µ
s
,µ
s
0
Luminecsence intensity, a.u.
a)
7
900
Wavelength, nm Luminecsence intensity, a.u.
Intensity, a.u.
6 4
Luminecsence intensity, a.u.
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
6000 600 650 700 750 800 850 900
Wavelength, nm
d)
Figure 33. Room temperature upconversion luminescence spectra of Er:KPC crystal under IR pulse laser excitation of the 4 I11/2 level at λexc = 980 nm. Pulse duration ∼15 ns. The spectra were recorded using CCD camera with delay = 0. Time between neighbouring spectra (gate width) was varied from 10 µs to 200 µs, each spectrum was recoded during the time interval (gate step) from 10 µs to 200 µs. a) Gate width = gate step = 10 µs; b) gate width = gate step = 40 µs; c) gate width = gate step = 100 µs; d) gate width = gate step = 200 µs. The numeration of the emission bands corresponds to transitions: 1–4 S3/2 → 4 I13/2 (850 nm); 2–4 I9/2 → 4 I13/2 (800 nm); 3–4 F7/2 → 4 I13/2 (712 nm); 4–4 F9/2 → 4 I15/2 (660 nm); 5–4 S3/2 → 4 I15/2 (540 nm); 6–2 H11/2 → 4 I15/2 (530 nm); 7–4 F7/2 → 4 I15/2 (490 nm).
Further experiments with short-pulse IR laser excitation provided direct evidence on the efficiency of ETU processes in Er:KPC crystal with Er concentration of about 2.7 at.%. The population dynamics of erbium levels was studied using short-pulse laser excitation at λexc = 980 nm. Fragments of time-resolved room-temperature luminescence spectra are presented in Figure 33 a-d. The luminescence bands in the visible spectral range (455–600 nm) correspond to the 4 F7/2 → 4 I15/2 (495 nm), 2 H11/2 → 4 I15/2 (530 nm) and 4 S3/2 → 4 I15/2 (545, 555 nm) transitions, respectively. As follows from Figure 33, and from study of luminescence kinetics, only the 4 F7/2 level is populated directly via two-step absorption (GSA and ESA). Measurements of luminescence kinetics obtained under the same excitation conditions by short laser pulses at 980 nm (Figure 34) have
58
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
1
Luminescence intensity
Luminescence intensity, a.u.
lg(Ilum /I0)
τ1exp = 10.7 µs 0,1
τ2exp = 150 µs
1
4 3 2 1
0,1
0,01 0,00
0,05
0,10
0,15
0,20
0,0
0,5
1,0
1,5
Time, ms
Time, ms
a)
b)
2,0
2,5
3,0
Figure 34. Luminescence kinetics for Er:KPC 2.7 at.% crystal under selective laser excitation of 4 I11/2 Er level (λexc = 980 nm, pulse duration ∼15 ns). a) Luminescence decay from 4 F7/2 level, transition 4 F7/2 → 4 I15/2 , λem = 495 nm. b) Curve 1 – the luminescence band at 380 nm; curve 2 – at 455 nm; curve 3 – at 660 nm; and curve 4 – at 800 nm, these bands correspond to 4G 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 11/2 → I15/2 , F5/2 → I15/2 , F9/2 → I15/2 , and I9/2 → I15/2 transitions, respectively.
shown that luminescence from level 4 F7/2 (Figure 34a) has no risetime and exhibits two components with exponential decay and lifetimes τ1 exp = 10.7 µs and τ2 exp ≈ 150 µs. The first component coincides with lifetime of the 4 F7/2 level, the second corresponds to ETU process (NC2 in Figure 32). Except the one-photon directly pumped 4 I11/2 level, emission from all other levels, namely 4 S3/2 (546 and 850 nm), 2 H11/2 (531 nm), 4 F5/2 (455 nm), 2 G(H)9/2 (408 nm), and 4 G11/2 (384 and 507 nm), occur with different risetimes and have complicated kinetics with non-exponential decay (Figure 34 b). This means that all these levels are populated due to ETU processes, which play the most important role in Er:KPC crystals under IR excitation. Optical properties of Er3+ -doped KPb2 Br5 crystals are reported in [89]. Under 975 nm diode laser pumping, Er:KPB revealed intense blue upconversion emission, whereas Er-doped KPb2 Cl5 (KPC), which has maximal phonon energy of 203 cm−1 , exhibited a dominant green Er3+ upconversion emission. The blue upconversion from Er:KPB can be attributed to emission from the 4 F7/2 excited state of Er3+ , which is quenched in most solid hosts due to strong multiphonon non-radiative decay. In KPB, the 4 F7/2 level becomes highly radiative with a room-temperature lifetime of ∼ 0.085 ms and estimated quantum efficiency of 94%. For comparison, the 4 F7/2 decay time in Er:KPC was only ∼ 0.011 ms at room temperature and the radiative quantum efficiency was estimated to be ∼ 9%. The other emission bands in Er:KPB crystals were observed in the IR at 1.5 µm (4 I13/2 → 4 I15/2 ), 1.7 µm (4 I9/2 → 4 I13/2 ), 2.0 µm (4 F9/2 → 4 I13/2 ), 2.7 µm (4 I11/2 → 4 I13/2 ), 3.6 µm (4 F9/2 → 4 I9/2 ), and 4.5 µm (4 I9/2 → 4 I11/2 ), indicating the potential of Er:KPB for IR laser applications.
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
59
Laser action of Er:KPC crystal in mid-IR, tunable in the range from 4.4 to 4.7 µm, was achieved in [45] at the 4 I11/2 → 4 I13/2 transition. This transition is labeled in Figure 32 by bold arrow, the probable mid-IR laser transitions in Er:KPC crystal are denoted with double dash arrows, L2 (near 3.4 µm) and L3 (near 2.8 µm). 5. Conclusion Experimental techniques for obtaining MPb2 Hal5 crystals of optical quality were developed, RE impurity structure, vibrational spectra, phase transitions and electronic excitations were studied, and RE segregation coefficients were estimated. Spectroscopic study of low-phonon-energy RE3+ :MPb2 Hal5 crystals grown by Bridgman techniques showed that their optical spectra exhibit broad nonstructured absorption and emission bands. The absorption spectrum of Nd, Er and Tm doped crystals shows bands matching the emission range of laser diodes. The RE3+ :KPb2 Cl5 crystals exhibit intense luminescence bands in the UV, visible and IR spectral ranges. Low nonradiative relaxation rates in the KPb2 Cl5 hosts provide a high luminescence quantum yield for transitions in the UV, visible, near- and mid-IR spectral regions. These features of the RE3+ :KPb2 Cl5 crystals create real possibilities for highly efficient laser action in mid-IR and make them promising active media for direct laser-diode-pumped solid-state lasers emitting in the nearand mid-IR spectral range up to 5 µm. The distinctions in phonon spectra for MPb2 Br5 and KPb2 Cl5 matrices lead to differences in luminescence properties of RE3+ :MPb2 Br5 and RE3+ :KPC crystals. The lower multiphonon relaxation rates in RE3+ :MPb2 Br5 crystals permit one to consider these crystals as promising active media for laser action at wavelengths longer than 5 µm. But the same reason causes difficulties in achieving laser action in RE3+ :MPb2 Br5 crystals under indirect laser diode pumping. Thus, low multiphonon relaxation rate from the 4 F5/2 Nd level in MPb2 Br5 matrices worsens the conditions for population of 4 F3/2 level. Consequently, direct laser diode pumping into the upper laser level is preferable for studied crystals. Moreover, energy transfer (self-quenching and upconversion) processes play a significant role in the creation of population inversion on the desirable laser transition levels and they have to be taken into account. The combination of high intensity of luminescent transitions, low multiphonon relaxation rates, together with efficient up-conversion processes give us an opportunity to consider RE3+ :MPb2 Hal5 crystals as one of the most promising active media not only for mid-IR, but also for visible and UV solid-state upconversion diode-laser-pumped lasers with extremely low Stokes (thermal) losses.
60
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
Acknowledgments It is a pleasure to acknowledge Prof. W. Krupke for initialization of this work and Prof. S. Payne of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory for his support through CRDF Grant No. RE2 2222. We would like to thank Dr. M.-F. Joubert and Dr. Y. Guyot for fruitful discussions and kind help with kinetics experiments. We acknowledge Profs.V.A. Pustovatov and I.N. Ogorodnikov for the VUV spectroscopic measurements, Prof. A.N. Vtyrin and Drs. S.V. Melnikova, A.A. Merkulov for study of phase transitions and Dr. V.P. Gapontsev for help with LD pumping sources. The authors from State Optical Institute acknowledge the support of INTAS, grant No. INTAS-97-787 and Russian Foundation for Basic Researches, grants No. 00-02-16637 and 03-02-17196. References 1. A.A. Kaminskii, in Crystalline Lasers:Physical Processes and Operating Schemes, (CRC Press N.Y. London, Tokyo, 1996). 2. S.A. Pollack, D.B. Chang, J. Appl. Phys. 64(6), 2885–2893 (1988). 3. F. Auzel, S. Hubert, D. Meichenin, Appl. Phys. Lett. 54(8), 681–683 (1989). 4. M. Pollnau, R. Spring, S.Wittwer, W. Luthy, H.P. Weber, J. Opt. Soc. Am.B 14(4), 974–978 (1997). 5. A. Shmaul, G. Huber, R. Clausen, B. Chai, P. LiKamWa, M. Bass, Appl. Phys. Lett. 62(6), 541–543 (1993). 6. R.S. Stoneman, J.G. Lynn, L. Esterowitz, IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics 28(4), 1041–1045 (1992). 7. T. Jensen, A. Diening, G. Huber, B.H.T. Chai, Optics Letters, 21(8), 585–587 (1996). 8. M. Pollnau, R. Spring, Ch. Ghisler, S. Wittwer, W. Luthy, H.P. Weber, IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics, 32(4), 657–662 (1996). 9. Chr. Wyss, W. Luthy, Heinz P. Weber, IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics 34(6), 1041–1045 (1998). 10. G.R. Knitz, R. Allen, L. Esterowitz, Appl. Phys. Lett. 50(22), 1553–1555 (1987). 11. S. Hubert, D. Meichenin, F. Auzel, Journal of Luminescence 45, 434–436 (1990). 12. Chr. P. Wyss, W. Luthy, H. P. Weber, L. Brovelli, Ch. Harder, H. P. Meier, P. Rogin, J. Hulliger, Proceedings of Biomedical Systems and technologies II, SPIE Proceedings series 3199, 206–213 (1997). 13. V.V. Shumilin, A.M. Tkachuk, V.V. Laso, N.N. Smirnov, V.F. Danilichev, A.F. Gatzu, D.V. Ganin, Proceedings of 4th International Conference on Laser Applications in Life Sciences, 7–11 September, 1992, Juvaskyla, Finland, 255–262 (1992). 14. A. Diening, G. Huber, Book of Abstracts of Conference on Lasers and Electrooptics CLEO 2000, CFA3 (2000).
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
61
15. Chr. P. Wyss, W. Luthy, H.P. Weber, P. Rogin, J. Hulliger, Optical Communications 139, 215– 218 (1997). 16. S.A. Pollack, D.B. Chang, R.A. MacFarlane, H. Jenssen, J. Appl. Phys. 67(2), 648–653 (1990). 17. M. Pollnau, W. Luthy, H.P. Weber, T. Jensen, G. Huber, A. Cassanho, H.P. Jenssen, R.A. MacFarlane, Optics Letters 21(1), 48–50 (1996). 18. C.S. Knowles, H.P. Jenssen, IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics 28(4), 1197–1208 (1992). 19. A.A. Kaminskii, S.E. Sarkisov, F. Belov, H.-J. Eichler, Optical and Quantum Electronics 22, S95–S105 (1990). 20. A.M. Tkachuk, S.E. Ivanova, M.-F. Joubert, Y.Guyot, and V.P. Gapontzev, Population of Excited Erbium Levels in Er3+ :Na0.4 Y0.6 F2.2 (Er:NYF) Laser Crystals, J. Alloys and Comp. 380(1–2) 130–135 (2004). 21. B.M. Antipenko, B.V. Sinitzin, T.V. Uvarova, Kvantyovaya electronika 7, 2019–2022 (1980). 22. G.D. Gilliland, R.C. Powell, L. Esterowitz, in Dig. Topical Meeting on Tunable Solid State Lasers, Williamsburg, Virginia, 1987, WE4, (1987). 23. B.M. Antipenko, I.G. Podkolzina, Yu. V. Tomashevitch, Kvantyovaya electronika 7, 647–649 (1980). 24. N. Djeu, V.E. Hartwell, A.A. Kaminskii, A.V. Butashin, Optics Letters 22(13), 997–999 (1997). 25. L.F. Johnson, H.J. Guggenheim, Appl. Phys. Lett. 23, 96 (1973). 26. B.M. Antipenko, A.L. Ashkalunin, A.A. Mak, B.V. Sinitzin, Yu. V. Tomashevitch, G.S. Shahkilimyan, Kvantyovaya electronika 7(5), 983–987 (1980). 27. N.P. Barnes, L. Esterowitz, R. Allen, in Tech. Digest Papers Conf. Lasers and Electro-Optics (OSA, Washington, D.,C., 1984), WA5 (1984). 28. R.C. Eckardt, L. Esterowitz, I.D. Abella, in Digest Tech. Pap. Conf. Lasers and Electro-Optics (OSA/IEEE, Washington, D.,C., 1982), 160 (1982). 29. L. Esterowitz, R.C. Eckardt, R.E. Allen, in Digest Tech. Pap. Conf. Lasers and Electro-Optics (OSA/IEEE, Washington, D.,C., 1982), 160 (1982). 30. A.A. Kaminskii, K. Kurbanov, T.V. Uvarova, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Neorg. Mater. 23, 1049 (1987). 31. R.H. Page, K.I. Schaffers, S.A. Payne, W.F. Krupke, Dy-Doped Chlorides as Gain Media for 1.3 mm Telecommunications Amplifiers, J. Lightwave Technol. 15(5), 786–793 (1997). 32. L.I. Isaenko, A.P. Yelisseyev, V.A. Nadolinny, V.I. Pashkov, M.C. Nostrand, S.A. Payne, R.H. Page, and R.W. Solarz, Growth and Spectroscopic Properties of Rare Earth doped Chloride Crystals for Telecommunication Amplifiers, in Solid State Lasers VII, R. Scheps, ed, Proc. SPIE 3265, 242–249 (1998). 33. M.C. Nostrand, R.H. Page, S.A. Payne, W.F.Krupke, P.G. Schunemann, and L.I. Isaenko, Spectroscopic data for infrared transitions in CaGa2 S4 :Dy3+ and KPb2 Cl5 :Dy3+ , in Advanced Solid State Lasers, W.R. Bosenberg and M.M. Fejer, ed., OSA TOPS. 19, 524–528 (1998). 34. Alexandra Tkachuk, Svetlana Ivanova, Ludmila Isaenko, Aleksandr Yelisseyev, Stephen Payne, Richard Solarz, Mike Nostrand, Ralph Page, Comparative Spectroscopic Study of the Dy3+ Doped Double Chloride and Double Fluoride Crystals for Telecommunication Amplifiers and IR Lasers, Acta Physika Polonika A 95(3), 381–394 (1999).
62
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
35. A.M. Tkachuk, S.E. Ivanova, L.I. Isaenko, A.P. Eliseev, W. Krupke, S. Payne, R. Solarz, M. Nostrand, R. Page, and Stephen Payne, Dy3+ doped crystals of double chlorides and double fluorides as the active media of IR solid-state lasers and telecommunication amplifiers, J. Optical Technology 66(5), 460–462 (1999). 36. M.C. Nostrand, R.H. Page, S.A. Payne, and W.F. Krupke, P.G. Schunemann, Room-temperature laser action at 4.3–4.4 µm in CaGa2 S4 :Dy3+ , Opt. Lett. 24(17), 1215–1217 (1999). 37. M.C. Nostrand, R.H. Page, S.A. Payne, W.F. Krupke, P.G. Schunemann, L.I. Isaenko, Room temperature CaGa2 S4 :Dy3+ laser action at 2.43 and 4.31 µm and KPb2 Cl5 :Dy3+ laser action at 2.43 µm, OSA TOPS in Optics and Photonics Series, ASSL, 26, 441–449 (1999). 38. M.C. Nostrand, R.H. Page, S.A. Payne, W.F. Krupke, P.G. Schunemann, L.I. Isaenko, Laser Demonstrations of Rare-Earth Ions in Low-Phonon Chloride and Sulfide Crystals, OSA TOPS in Optics and Photonics Series, ASSL, 34, 459–463 (2000). 39. M.C. Nostrand, R.H. Page, S.A. Payne, W.F. Krupke, and L.I. Isaenko, Quantum efficiency measurements for long-wavelength operation of rare-earth doped KPb2 Cl5 , in Technical Digest of conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics CLEO 2000, May 7–12, San Francisco, USA, 566– 56 (2000). 40. L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, A. Tkachuk, S. Ivanova, S. Vatnik, A. Merkulov, S. Payne, R. Page, M. Nostrand, New laser crystals based on KPb2 Cl5 for IR region, Material Science and Engineering B81, 188–190, (2001). 41. T.T. Basiev, M.E. Doroshenko, V.V. Osiko, D.V. Badikov, Mid-IR Laser Oscillation in new low phonon PbGa2 S4 :Dy3+ crystal, OSA Topical Meeting, Advance Solid State Photonics, 2005, paper TuB10, (2005). 42. S.R. Bowman, L.B. Shaw, B.J. Feldman, J. Ganem, A 7-µm Praseodymium-Based Solid-State Laser, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 32(4) 646–649 (1996). 43. K. Nitsch, A. Cihl´ar, Z. M´alkov´a, M. Rodov´a and M. Vanecek, J. of Crystal Growth 131 (3–4), 612–615 (1993); K. Nitsch, M. Dusek, M. Nikl, K. Pollak, and M. Rodova, Ternary alkali lead chlorides: crystal growth, crystal structure, absorption and emission properties, Prog. Cryst. Growth Charact. 30, 1–22 (1995). 44. S.R. Bowman, S.K. Searles, Josef Ganem, Paul Schmidt, Further investigation of potential 4 µm materials, OSA TOPS 26, Advance Solid-State Lasers, 487–490 (1999). 45. S.R. Bowman, S.K. Searles, N.W. Jenkins, S.B. Qadri, E.F. Skelton, Josef Ganem, New MidIR Laser on an Erbium activated low phonon energy crystal, Technical Digest of conference of Lasers and Electro-Optics 2001, May 8–10, Baltimore, Maryland, USA, CLEO (2001), CFD2, 557–558 (2001). 46. J.L. Doualan, R. Moncorge, Laser crystals with low phonon frequencies, Ann. Chim. Sci. Mat. 28, 5–20 (2003). 47. K. Nitsch, V. Hamplova, M. Nikl, K. Polak, V. Rodova, Lead bromide and ternary alkali lead bromide single crystals-growth and emission properties, Chem. Phys. Lett. 258, 518–522 (1996). 48. Katja Rademaker, Ernst Heumann, G¨unter Huber, Stephen A. Payne, William F. Krupke, Ludmila I. Isaenko, Arnold Burger, Laser activity at 1.18, 1.07, and 0.97 mm in the lowphonon-energy hosts KPb2 Br5 and RbPb2 Br5 doped with Nd3+ , Opt. Lett. 30(7), 729–731 (2005). 49. M. Cola, V. Massariti, R. Richard, C. Siristri, Binary systems formed by lead bromide with (Li, Na,K,Rb and Tl): a DTA and diffractometry study, Z.Natuforsch., A26, 1328–1332 (1971).
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
63
50. M.C. Nostrand, R.H. Page, S.A. Payne, L.I. Isaenko, and A.P. Yelisseyev. “Optical properties of Dy3+ and Nd3+ – doped KPb2 Cl5 ”. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 18, 264–275 (2001). 51. M. Voda, M. Al-Saleh, G. Lobera, R. Balda, J. Fernandez, Crystal growth of RE-doped ternary potassium lead chloride single crystals by the Bridgman method, Opt. Mater. 26(4) 359–364 (2004). 52. A. Gabriel, A.D. Pelton, Phase diagram measurements and thermodynamic analysis of the PbCl2 –NaCl, PbCl2 –KCl and PbCl2 –KCl–NaCl systems, Can.J.Chem., 63, 3276–3282 (1985). 53. S.V. Melnikova, L.I. Isaenko, V.M. Pashkov, V.M. Pevnev, Study of phase transition in KPb2 Cl5 crystal, Fizika Tverd.Tela 47 (2) 319–325 (2005) in Russian. 54. S.V. Melnikova, L.I. Isaenko, V.M. Pashkov, V.M. Pevnev, Search for phase transitions in some representatives of the APb2 X5 family, Fizika Tverd.Tela, in press, (2006), in Russian. 55. Y.P. Beck, G. Clicque, H. Nau, A study of AB2 X5 compounds (A:K,In,Tl; B: Sr,Sn,Pb; X: Cl,Br,I), Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 536, 35–44 (1986). 56. H. Keller, Notiz zur Kristallstruktur von APb2 Cl5 -Verbindungen, Z.Naturforsch., B31, 885 (1976). 57. F. Ras, D. Ijdo, G.C. Verschoor, Ammonium dilead chloride, Acta Crystallogr., B33, 259–260 (1977). 58. M. Nikl, K. Nitsch, I. Velicka, J. Hybler, K. Polak, T. Fabian, Photoluminescence of KPb2 Cl5 , Phys.Stat.Sol.(b), 168, K37 (1991). 59. A. Merkulov, L.I. Isaenko, V.M. Pashkov, V.G. Mazur, A.V. Virovets, D.Yu. Naumov, Investigation of KPb2 Cl5 and KPb2 Br5 crystal structure, Zhurn.Strukt.Khimii, 6(1) 106–110 (2005), in Russian. 60. O.V. Ivanov, D.A. Shport. E.G. Maksimov, Microscopic calculations of ferroelectric instability in perovskite crystals, J. Exp. Theor. Physics, 87, 186–199 (1998). 61. N.G. Zamkova, V.I. Zinenko, O.V. Ivanov, E.G. Maksimov, S.N. Sofronova, Lattice dynamics calculations of the ionic crystals with ion dipole and quadrupole deformations: perovskite structure oxides, Ferroelectrics, 283, 49–60 (2003). 62. A.N. Vtyurin, S.V. Goryainov, N.G. Zamkova, V.I. Zinenko, A.S. Krylov, S.N. Krylova, A.D. Shefer, Hydrostatic pressure-induced phase transitions in RbMnCl3 : Raman spectra and lattice dynamics, Physics of Solid State, 46, 1301–1310 (2004). 63. M. Born and K. Huang, Dynamical Theory of Crystal Lattices (Clarendon, Oxford, 1954). 64. M.B. Smirnov, in: Dynamic Theory and Physical Properties of Crystals, edited by A.N. Lazarev (Nauka, St.Petersburg, 1992), pp. 41 (in Russian). 65. H. Streitwolf, Gruppen theorie in der Festkoperphysik (Teubner, Leipzig, 1967). 66. K.S. Alexandrov, A.N. Vtyurin, A.P. Eliseev, N.G. Zamkova, L.I. Isaenko, S.N. Krylova, V.M. Pashkov, P.P. Turchin, A.P. Shebanin, Vibrational spectrum ans elastic properties of the KPb2 Cl5 crystals, Fizika Tverd.Tela, 47(3) 512–518 (2005). 67. A.K.S. Song, R.T. Williams, Self-trapped excitons (Berlin-Heidelberg, New-York; Springer Verlag, 1996). 68. A.F. Malisheva, V.G. Plekhanov, Investigation of optical constants of PbCl2 and PbBr2 in the 3.5 to 11 eV energy interval, Optika i Spectrosckopiya, 34 (3), 527–531 (1973), in Russian. 69. V.A. Pustovarov, I.N. Ogorodnikov, S.I. Omelkov, A.A. Smirnov and A.P. Yelisseyev, Excitons and energy transport in crystals KPb2 Cl5 and RbPb2 Br5 , Nuclear Inst. and Methods in Physics Research, A. 543(1) 216–220 (2005).
64
LUDMILA ISAENKO ET AL.
70. V.A. Pustovarov, I.N. Ogorodnikov, N.S. Kuzmina., A.A. Smirnov, L.I. Isaenko, A.P. Yelisseyev Electronic excitation and luminescence in APb2 X5 (A = K, Rb; X = Cl, Br) laser crystals, HASYLAB Annual Report (HASYLAB, Hamburg, 2005), pp.277–278. 71. V.A. Pustovarov, I.N. Ogorodnikov, N.S. Bstrikova, A.A. Smirnov, Low-temperature timeresolved spectroscopy of APb2 X5 (A = K, Rb; X = Cl, Br) single crystals, Optika I Spektroskopija, 2006, in press, in Russian. 72. I.N. Ogorodnikov, V.A. Pustovarov, M. Kirm, A.V. Kruzhalov, LI Isaenko, A.P. Yelisseyev, A time-resolved VUV spectroscopy of KPb2 Cl5 :RE single crystals (RE = Nd, Er and Ho), HASYLAB Annual Report (HASYLAB, Hamburg, 2001) Part 1, pp. 233–234. 73. N.W. Jenkins, S.R. Bouman, S. O’Connor, S.K. Searles, Josef Ganem, Spectroscopic characterization of Er-doped KPb2 Cl5 laser crystals, Opt. Mater. 22(4), 311–320 (2003). 74. A.M. Tkachuk, S.E. Ivanova, L.I. Isaenko, A.P. Yelisseyev, Steve Payne, R. Solarz, R. Page, M. Nostrand, Spectroscopic Study of the neodymium-doped double potassium-lead chloride crystals KPb2 Cl5 :Nd3+ , Optics and Spectroscopy 92(1), 83–94 (2002). 75. A. Tkachuk, S. Ivanova, L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, D.I. Mironov, M. Nostrand, Ralph Page, and Steve Payne, Spectroscopic properties of TR3+ doped double chloride crystals, Proc. SPIE “Spectroscopy of Crystals Activated by Rare-Earth and Transition Metal Ions”. B.Z.Malkin, A.A. Kaplyanskii, and S.I. Nikitin eds., 4766, 22–36 (2002). 76. L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, A. Tkachuk, S. Ivanova, S. Payne, R. Page, M. Nostrand, New low-phonon frequency crystals, based on rare earth doped double halogenides for multiwavelengths, diode pumped solid-state lasers, Proc. 7th int. symposium on Laser Metrology Applied to Science, Industry, and Everyday Life, Proc. SPIE., part 2, Eds. Yu.Chugui, S. Bagaev, A, Weckenmann, P. Osanna, Novosibirsk 4900, 962–972 (2002). 77. A.M. Tkachuk, S.E. Ivanova, L.I. Isaenko, A.P. Yelisseyev, M.-F. Joubert, Y. Guyot, S. Payne, Spectroscopic studies of erbium-doped potassium – lead double chloride crystals KPb2 Cl5 :Er3+ . 1. Optical spectra and relaxation of the erbium excited states in potassium – lead double chloride crystals Opt. Spectrosc. 95(5), 722–740 (2003). 78. U.N. Roy, Y. Cui, M. Guo, M. Groza, A. Burger, Gregory J. Wagner, Timothy, J. Carrig, S.A. Payne, Growth and characterization of Er-doped KPb2 Cl5 as laser host crystal, Journal of Crystal Growth 258, 331–336 (2003). 79. A.M. Tkachuk, A.V. Poletimova, M.A. Petrova, V. Ju. Egorov, N.E. Korolev, Opt. Spektrosk.(rus) 70(6), 1230–1235, (1991). 80. N.W. Jenkins, S.R. Bowman, L.B. Shaw, J.R. Lindle, Spectroscopic analysis and laser modeling of neodymium-doped potassium lead chloride, Journal of Luminescence 97, 127–134 (2002). 81. K. Rademaker, W.F. Krupke, K. Petermann, G. Huber, L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, U.N. Roy, A. Burger, K.C. Mandal, K. Nitsch, Optical properties of Nd3+ and Tb3+ -doped KPb2 Br5 and RbPb2 Br5 with low nonradiative decay, JOSA, B 21 2117–2129 (2004). 82. A.G. Okhrimchuk, L.N. Butvina, E.M. Dianov, N.V., Lichkova, and V.N. Zavgorodnev, Sensitization of MIR Tb3+ luminescence by Tm3+ ions in CsCdBr3 and KPb2 Cl5 crystals, in Advanced Solid-State Photonics, OSA Trends in Optics and Photonics Series (Optical Society of America, Washington, D.C., 2003), 83, 303–308 (2003). 83. L.N. Butvina, E.M. Dianov, A.G. Okhrimchuk, N.V. Lichkova, V.N. Zavgorodnev, MIR Spectroscopy of Tb3+ -doped low phonon crystals and polycrystalline fibers, in Abstracts book of XI-th Feofilov symposium on spectroscopy of crystals activated by rare earth and transition metal ions, 2001, Kazan, September 24–28, Russia, PF61, (2001).
NEW MONOCRYSTALS WITH LOW PHONON ENERGY
65
84. Judd B.R. Phys. Rev. 127, 750–761 (1963). 85. Ofelt G.S. J. Chem. Phys. 37(3), 511–519 (1962). 86. Carnall W.T., Matsinger B.H., Donlan V., Surratt G.T. J. Chem. Phys. 49, 4412 (1972). 87. Neil W. Jenkins, Steven R. Bowman, Lifetime measurements for potential neodymium 5 µm laser, in Technical Digest of conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics CLEO 2001, May 8–10, Baltimore, Maryland, USA, 280–281, (2001). 88. P.Y. Tigreat, J.L. Doualan, R. Moncorge, B. Ferrand, Spectroscopic investigation of a 1.55 µm emission band in Dy3+ -doped CsCdBr3 and KPb2 Cl5 single crystals, Journal of Luminescence 94–95, 107–111 (2001). 89. U. Hommerich, Ei Ei Nyein, S.B. Trivedi, Crystal growth, upconversion, and infrared emission properties of Er3+ -doped KPb2 Br5 , J. Luminescence 113, 100–108 (2005). 90. L.A. Riseberg, H.W. Moos, Multiphonon orbit-lattice relaxation of excited States of rare-earth ions in crystals, Phys. Rev. 174(2), 429–438 (1968). 91. T. Miyakava, D.L. Dexter, Phys. Rev. B1, 2961 (1970). 92. A.M. Tkachuk, A.V. Chilko, M.V. Petrov, Opt. Spektr. 58(2), 361–366 (1985). 93. R. Balda, M. Voda, M. Al-Saleh, J. Fernandez, Visible luminescence in KPb2 Cl5 :Pr3+ crystal, Journal of Luminescence 97, 190–197 (2002). 94. R. Balda, J. Fernandez, A. Mendioroz, M. Voda, M. Al-Saleh, Infrared to visible upconversion in Pr3+ -doped KPb2 Cl5 crystal Optical Materials 24, 91–95 (2003). 95. R. Balda, J. Fernandez, A. Mendioroz, M. Voda, and M. Al-Saleh, Infrared-to-visible upconversion processes in Pr3+ , Yb3+ -codoped KPb2 Cl5 , Phys.Rev. B 68 165101-1–165101-7 (2003). 96. A. Mendioroz, J. Fernandez, M. Voda, M. Al-Saleh, and R. Balda, Anti-Stokes laser cooling in Yb3+ -doped KPb2 Cl5 crystal, Opt. Lett. 27(17), 1523–1527 (2002). 97. Mendioroz, R. Balda, M. Voda, M. Al-Saleh, J. Fernandez, Infrared to visible and ultraviolet upconversion processes in Nd3+ -doped potassium lead chloride crystal, Optical Materials 26(4), 351–357 (2004). 98. A.M. Tkachuk, S.E. Ivanova, L.I. Isaenko, A.P. Yelisseyev, V.A. Pustovarov, M.-F. Joubert, Y. Guyot, V.P. Gapontsev, Emission Peculiarities of TR3+ -doped KPb2 Cl5 Laser Crystals under Selective Direct, Upconversion and Excitonic/host Excitation of Impurity Centers, OSA TOPS Trends in Optics and Photonics Series (TOPS), ASSP-2005, 98, 69–74 (2005).
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM THIOINDATE AND SELENOINDATE FOR NONLINEAR OPTICS IN THE MID-IR Orthorhombic Crystals of Lithium J.-J. ZONDY Institut National de M´etrologie, Conservatoire National des Arts et M´etiers (INM-CNAM), 61 rue du Landy, 93210 La Plaine Saint Denis, France V. PETROV∗ Max-Born-Institute for Nonlinear Optics and Ultrafast Spectroscopy, 2A Max-Born-Str., 12489 Berlin, Germany A. YELISSEYEV, L. ISAENKO, and S. LOBANOV Institute of Geology and Mineralogy, Siberian Branch of Russian Academy of Sciences, 3 Ac. Kopyug Av., 630090 Novosibirsk, Russia
Abstract. We review the optical and other relevant properties of two lithium indium compounds with wurtzite type structure, LiInS2 and LiInSe2 , which occupy a unique position among the mid-IR nonlinear crystals, having band-gaps at 347 nm and 433 nm, respectively. Realized and potentially interesting frequency conversion schemes with these two biaxial crystals are discussed. Keywords: Lithium thioindate, lithium selenoindate, nonlinear optical crystals, mid-infrared spectral range, down-conversion, optical parametric oscillators, optical parametric amplifiers, ultrashort laser pulses.
1. Introduction To date, only a few suitable nonlinear crystals combining a transparency extending into the mid-IR range above ∼5 µm (the upper limit of oxide materials) and largeenough birefringence to allow phase-matching over their transparency ranges are available. The binary and ternary birefringent noncentrosymmetric crystals now in use in that spectral range include the chalcopyrite semiconductors AgGaS2 (AGS), AgGaSe2 (AGSe), ZnGeP2 (ZGP) and CdGeAs2 (CGA), the defect chalcopyrite HgGa2 S4 (HGS), GaSe, CdSe, and Tl3 AsSe3 (TAS) [1]. Some other crystals like ∗ To whom correspondence should be addressed: e-mail:
[email protected]
67 M. Ebrahim-Zadeh and I. T. Sorokina (eds.), Mid-Infrared Coherent Sources and Applications, 67–104. c 2008 Springer.
68
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
proustite (Ag3 AsS3 ) and pyrargyrite (Ag3 SbS3 ) have already lost their importance because they were completely replaced by the more technological AGS while the growth technology of HgS was never developed [2]. The list of the nonoxide birefringent inorganic crystals ever used will be full if the elemental Se and Te are added: Their linear losses are, however, so high that at present they could be interesting (especially Te) only for diagnostic purposes of short pulses at longer wavelengths [2]. All these mid-IR crystals are uniaxial. All of them that are now available commercially or quasi-commercially (from laboratories) have their specific advantages but also some drawbacks: AGS and AGSe have low residual absorption but poor thermal conductivity and anisotropic thermal expansion with different sign, ZGP has excellent nonlinearity and thermal conductivity but multi-phonon and residual absorption limit its transparency from both sides so that pump wavelengths for optical parametric oscillators (OPOs) should lie above 2 µm which corresponds to less than 1/3 of its band-gap, CGA possesses extremely high nonlinearity but exhibits also absorption features and low temperatures are required to avoid the residual losses, HGS has a very high nonlinear figure of merit but its growth technology is very difficult and only small sizes are available, GaSe has large nonlinearity and birefringence but it is a soft, cleaving compound, with very low damage threshold, CdSe is transparent up to 18 µm but its birefringence and nonlinearity are quite modest, TAS exhibits rather low losses in its transparency range but its thermal conductivity is extremely low, and finally Te is a unique nonlinear material having in mind its extended wavelength range and superior nonlinear susceptibility but as already mentioned its applicability is limited by the high linear losses. Two approaches to develop alternative solutions and avoid these drawbacks in specific applications will be presented in two other Chapters of this book: These are the manufacturing of quasi-phase-matched orientation patterned structures with highly nonlinear but isotropic semiconductors, e.g. GaAs which has a mature technology [3], and the doping or mixing of nonlinear crystals to produce more complex quaternary compounds like Cdx Hg1−x Ga2 S4 and Agx Gax Ge1−x S2 [4]. The extremely difficult and specific for each compound growth technology and the complex and expensive methods necessary to characterize the properties make it really an event when new mid-IR nonlinear crystals can be added to the above short list. This Chapter is devoted to two such ternary chalcogenides whose growth technology was recently improved to such an extent that it was possible to perform extensive characterization and even realize some applications. These two materials, LiInS2 (LIS) and LiInSe2 (LISe), not only proved to be useful for the mid-IR spectral range but possess some unique properties which will definitely guarantee them a place among the other mid-IR nonlinear crystals if some technological issues are developed to an end. Moreover, their attractive features already stimulated the study of further crystals belonging to the same class, like LiGaS2 , LiGaSe2 , and LiGaTe2 which are now also under development [5, 6].
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
69
Here, we will briefly review the history of LIS and LISe, and the growth methods used, summarize their properties relevant for nonlinear optics, and describe previously realized and possible future applications. 2. Development, growth, composition, and structure of LIS and LISe Single crystals of LIS were shown to crystallize in the β-NaFeO2 structure, which is a superstructure of the wurtzite type, by Hoppe as early as 1959 [7], although the compound itself was synthesized also earlier [8]. This means that LIS is an 9 orthorhombic crystal with space group Pna21 ≡ C2v and point group mm2. It is isostructural to the oxide nonlinear crystal LiGaO2 [7]. Such compounds have the same chemical formula as many chalcopyrites, AI BIII CVI 2 , but different structure when the monovalent element is an alkali metal (A = Li. . .Cs). LIS crystals with optical quality were grown for the first time by Boyd et al. at Bell Labs in 1973 [9]. Notwithstanding the small size and the poor quality of these first samples this group managed in their unprecedented manner to measure the transparency, linear dispersion, birefringence and nonlinear susceptibility of LIS. They grew the isostructural LISe in the same year but its characterization, comparative to LIS, was limited to electro-optic and pyroelectric properties [10]. Probably due to the growth difficulties, the development of LIS, LISe and other related compounds was slower than that of AGS and AGSe. Although Kish et al. [11] systematically described the structural and band-gap properties of the whole class of AI BIII CVI 2 compounds with A=alkali ion, B=Ga, In, Tl, and C=S, Se, Te, they did not place much attention on the development of the crystal growth and no further optical properties were analyzed. The same refers to the Japanese group of Kuriyama et al. at Hosei University who were more interested in the electrical and photo-emission properties. By the 1990-ies two groups, from Russia (Novosibirsk, the present authors) and Germany (Leipzig-Freiburg i. Br.), independently succeeded in the growth of some LiBC2 compounds. Most of the important results of the German group are summarized in the two dissertations (one of them devoted solely to LISe) [12, 13], and the references therein, but this group is unfortunately no more active. Their efforts were focused more on the crystal growth methods, creating phase diagrams, and crystallographic studies while optical aspects were restricted to transmission measurements near the band edge and infrared (reflection and Raman) spectroscopy. On the opposite, the activities of the Russian group were devoted more to the improvement of the crystal quality and the growth of large size single crystals as well as applications as nonlinear optical materials and that is why their activities included also profound optical characterization of the linear and nonlinear optical properties. The work on LIS crystals grown by this group which was performed in collaboration with several European partners was recently summarized in a comprehensive review [14]; a similar review on LISe was just submitted for publication [15].
70
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
LIS and LISe are congruently melting compounds and can be grown from the melt using the three elements as starting materials. Boyd et al. grew LIS in graphite crucibles by directional solidification [9]. The melting point was around 880◦ C. The obtained crystals were either colourless or with yellow or red tinge. They used the same method to grow LISe and obtained deep red colour crystals [10]. Kamijoh and Kuriyama grew single crystals of LIS (colourless or light yellow in colour) of about 5 × 4 × 4 mm3 and LISe (deep red in colour) of about φ18 mm × 20 mm by directional solidification with a temperature gradient of 6◦ C/cm (LIS) and 4◦ C/cm (LISe) at a cooling rate of 2◦ C/h [16, 17]. They determined a melting temperature of 904◦ C for LISe [17]. Kish et al. [18, 19] and Kovach et al. [20] used the horizontal Bridgman-Stockbarger technique at a rate of 0.4. . . 0.8 mm/h to obtain single crystals of LIS with yellow tinge and sizes of up to 3 × 3 × 4 mm3 , and established a melting temperature of 990◦ C [20, 21]. The LIS growth parameters used for the directional solidification and the horizontal Bridgman-Stockbarger methods were described in [12]. The Bridgman-Stockbarger technique yielded larger single crystals (φ8 mm × 12 mm) which were colourless, yellow or red in colour [22]. An excess of Li and S had to be used to compensate the losses during evaporation and incorporation in the crucible [12, 16, 22]. The melting temperature of LIS was determined to be 980◦ C [22]. Phase diagrams of the system Li2 Se-In2 S3 can be found in [12,23]. The LISe growth parameters used for the directional solidification and vertical Bridgman-Stockbarger methods were described in [13]. LISe crystals as large as φ10 mm × 20 mm were obtained by directional solidification and their colour was yellow brownish [24]. The melting temperature was determined to be 897◦ C. Similarly, an excess of Li and Se was required in order to compensate the loss during the growth process [13, 17, 24]. The phase diagram of the system Li2 Se-In2 Se3 was also studied [13, 25]. In order to prevent the violent reaction between Li and S due to rise in temperature, Kuriyama and Kato [26] used LiIn alloys as a starting material for the growth of LIS. The crystals grown by this socalled indium solution method were colourless and transparent or light yellow in colour with a maximum size of 5 × 4 × 4 mm3 . More recently, Badikov et al. [27] grew LIS and LISe by the vertical Bridgman-Stockbarger technique starting with In2 S(e)3 , Li and S(e), and achieving crystal sizes of φ18 mm × 50–60 mm. They determined melting temperatures of 1030◦ C for LIS and 920◦ C for LISe. Finally, the isostructural mixed compound LiInSSe, which can be regarded as a solid solution LiIn(S1−x Sex )2 for x = 0.5, was also successfully grown by the same method achieving similar sizes [28]. We use a seeded Bridgman-Stockbarger process in a vertical two-zone furnace with counter pressure to grow large size single-crystal ingots of LIS and LISe. Details on the growth procedure can be found elsewhere [29, 30]. In principle, the synthesis and growth of LIS and LISe follows the same procedure as that for growing chalcopyrites, except for some refinements related to the volatility of the
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
71
elements and the chemical reactivity of Li with the container walls. The purity of the starting materials is 99.999% (In, S, Se) and 99.9% (Li). The chalcogens are additionally purified by sublimation in vacuum while the metals are subjected to repeated zone melting and directional crystallization. Since the most volatile component, S or Se, has a high partial pressure at the temperature of the LIS(e) pyrosynthesis, the latter is carried out in a two-zone furnace to avoid the container explosion. The temperature of the “hot” zone, in which the crucible with the reaction mixture is placed, is 50. . .100◦ C higher that the melting temperature of the crystal. Our up-dated values for the melting temperatures are 1037 ± 7◦ C for LIS, which is close to [19, 27, 31], and 915 ± 5◦ C for LISe, which lies between the values specified by others [11, 17, 24, 27]. The temperature of the “cold” zone is selected in such a way that the vapour pressure does not exceed 2 atm. The synthesized compound is placed into a glasscarbon ampoule which is in turn mounted inside a sealed silica ampoule of larger diameter filled by dry Ar (0.5. . . 1 atm). The inner ampoule is necessary to prevent the outer quartz tube from reaction with Li. Such a double-wall growth ampoule containing the polycrystalline synthesis charge and a seed is placed in the furnace so that charge and the upper portion of the seed are melted. A temperature gradient of 10. . .15◦ C/cm is sufficient to maintain a stable growth interface in the furnace. Growth is accomplished by moving the melt interface slowly from the seed. The ampoule is shifted at a rate of 1. . . 10 mm/day. Initially we used (010) and (001) oriented seeds. However, since the thermal expansion of LIS and LISe is almost isotropic, in contrast to AGS and AGSe, the present state of the art allows to use any seed orientation in order to grow sufficiently large crystals along the required phase-matching directions. Typical dimensions of the single crystal ingots obtained are 15. . . 20 mm diameter and 30. . . 40 mm length. They are free of extended defects as inclusions, twins, cracks, etc. In order to improve the synthesis conditions for stoichiometric growth, the LIS(e) evaporation process was studied using an unique thermo-microscopic technique [30]. Incongruent sublimation at temperatures lower than the melting points was observed. According to chemical analysis, the vapour condensate consists of S(e) and later Li, which allows to account that the final compositions are shifted towards binary sesqui-chalcogenides. This depends on the pressure inside the ampoules. Incongruent sublimation is one of the reasons for deviation from stoichiometry of the as-grown crystals. Samples of stoichiometric composition are colourless for LIS and yellowish for LISe. Sometimes such crystals can be directly grown and no annealing is necessary. However, usually the as-grown ingots are cloudy (milky) and display a variety of tinges from colourless or slightly yellow (typical for LIS) to yellow or greenish (typical for LISe), depending on the growth conditions and initial reagent composition (Fig. 1, left). The milky features occur during cooling when fine-textured precipitates of a second phase appear. The second phase precipitates can be removed by annealing the as-grown ingots
72
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
Figure 1.
As grown and annealed pieces of LiInSe2 (LISe) and LiInS2 (LIS).
in evacuated chamber with a suitable atmosphere close to the melting temperature. The annealing atmosphere depends on the initial charge composition which deviates from the stoichiometric one. Both, this deviation and the annealing procedure aim at achieving stoichiometric composition at the end. However, it is very easy to pass the stoichiometric point in the annealing process. In this case the colour can change, e.g. to rose for LIS and red for LISe, for chalcogen excess. This is related to additional absorption bands near the band edge although the transparency in the IR is restored almost to the theoretical level determined by the Fresnel losses. Such coloured samples with deviation from stoichiometry are shown on the right side of Fig. 1. The stoichiometry of the grown samples is investigated using differential dissolution technique combined with inductively-coupled plasma analysis [29]. As grown crystals may show e.g. up to 3% deficit of S(e)2 relative to Li + In, and up to 4% deficit of Li relative to In but after annealing also excess of S(e) could be observed [32]. A detailed structural analysis of LIS and LISe was performed by Kish et al. [18] and by H¨onle et al. [33], respectively. The structure of LIS and LISe is formed by LiS(e)4 and InS(e)4 tetrahedrons, and the S(e)2− ions are arranged in hexagonal packing with tetragonal and octahedral cavities (tetra- and octapores). This β-NaFeO2 structure of LIS and LISe is less dense than the chalcopyrite structure of AGS and AGSe due to the presence of these empty cavities in the unit cell volume. Only half of the tetrapores are occupied by Li and In while all octapores are empty. The spontaneous polarization is due to the fact that in each bipyramid formed by two adjacent tetrapores only one is occupied by a cation. The unit ˚ b = 8.1 A, ˚ and c = 6.5 A ˚ for LIS, and cell parameters are roughly a = 6.9 A,
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
73
˚ b = 8.4 A, ˚ and c = 6.8 A ˚ for LISe [34]. The exact lattice parameters a = 7.2 A, depend on the coloration, i.e. on the growth and annealing conditions, and the exact stoichiometry, but the structure of all LIS and LISe crystals is the same [34]. The presence of point defects and the influence of annealing on them has been studied in LIS by optical absorption and photoluminescence spectroscopy [22, 26, 29, 31, 35–38]. In principle the nature of such defects can be derived from the analysis of the composition and the structure. Typical examples are sulphur vacancies VS , interstitial sulphur Si after annealing, and antisite InLi defects. Similarly, point defects in LISe were studied by photoluminescence [37], optical absorption [34, 39], and nuclear magnetic resonance [32]. Point defects determine the crystal colour through their absorption bands which are affected by the annealing procedure. On the basis of the detailed study of the structural properties of LIS it has been suggested that the strength of the Li-S bond is weaker than that of the In-S bond (high mobility of the Li cations in the LIS lattice) and that this effect is due to the high ionicity of the Li-S bond [18]. That the Li-S(e) bond is weaker than the In-S(e) bond was confirmed also by other studies of LIS [14] and LISe [40]. Analyzing spectroscopic data it was possible to conclude that the Li-S(e) bonds in LIS and LISe are essentially ionic in nature and the structural properties (stability of the β-NaFeO2 structure) can be understood in terms of the average bond parameters [41]. 3. Band-gap, transparency, and IR cut-off of LIS and LISe Besides to more ionic bonds, the wurtzite-type structure of LIS and LISe is expected to lead to larger band-gaps in comparison to the Cu and Ag chalcopyrites [40]. The band-structure of LIS is of direct type (direct transitions between parabolic bands) [26, 31, 32, 34, 36]. The band-gap energy of LIS has been estimated at low and room temperature by photoluminescence [16, 35] and transmission [12, 19, 22, 26, 31, 42] measurements. Our updated value of 3.57 eV measured at room temperature with thin plates of LIS [14] is in good agreement with most of the previous transmission measurements [12, 22, 26, 31, 42]. Similarly, a lot of works dealt with the band-gap of LISe at low and room temperature using transmission [13,17,23,43–45], electrical resistivity [46], diffuse reflectance [47], and photoluminescence [37] measurements. Electronic structure calculations yielded a band-gap energy less than 2.1 eV [48]. The experimental results depend on the colour of the samples used, i.e. on the point defects present, and their interpretation and comparison are complicated: For instance, in one of the studies a band-gap at 2.03 eV was attributed to indirect or pseudodirect transitions in LISe but for a thickness of 4 µm a direct band-gap near 2.9 eV was also identified [45]. However, transmission measurements with yellow colour LISe indicated a direct band-gap [13, 23, 42, 44], and the results were very close to our updated value of
74
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
Figure 2.
Polarized transmission spectra of LIS (a) and LISe (b) for a thickness of 5 mm.
2.86 eV [32, 34]. The polarization dependence of the band-gaps of LIS and LISe is only weakly pronounced [29, 34]. The room temperature unpolarized absorption measurements with the first optical quality LIS samples (light yellow in colour) indicated that the optical losses can be reduced to less than 0.25 cm−1 in the clear transparency range while the 1 cm−1 absorption level corresponded to 0.5 and 10 µm [9]. Other unpolarized transmission spectra of LIS with different thickness can be found elsewhere [19, 49–53]. Losses of 0.1. . .0.25 cm−1 in the clear transparency range and 1.1. . .2.3 cm−1 at CO2 (9.2. . .10.8 µm) laser wavelengths as well as a transparency window of 0.4. . .12.5 µm at the 10% level were specified for a thickness of 3.6 mm [49–52]. Careful measurements with polarized light showed that the 50% transmission level for a thickness of 5 mm extends from 0.5 to 9 µm while the clear transparency range with transmission defined by the Fresnel losses is from 0.8 to 8.1 µm, Fig. 2a [14]. Direct laser line measurements in the clear transmission range with different laser sources (e.g. at 2.53 µm) indicate a total loss coefficient (absorption and scattering) of ≈0.05 cm−1 [14,53]. The IR cut-off edge of LIS is independent of the colour and hence of the annealing procedure [53,54]. Transmission spectra of LISe were measured both for yellow and red coloration [27, 32, 34, 39, 52, 55]. They also reveal independence of the IR cut-off edge from the colour. The long-wave limit for the clear transparency does not extend significantly further into the mid-IR in comparison to LIS [32, 34, 52]. Polarized measurements with a 5 mm thick sample [15], see Fig. 2b, indicate that the 50% transmission level extends from 0.6 to 12 µm while the clear transparency range is roughly from 1 to 9 µm. Absorption coefficient of less that 0.05 cm−1 was specified near 1 µm for some special samples [27], but loss coefficients of < 0.1 cm−1 in the clear transmission range, and 0.5 and 1.2 cm−1 at 9.55 and 10.6 µm, respectively, were also given in the literature [52, 55]. The variation of the transmission at different points of the sample surface did not exceed 2% [55]. The transmission of LiInSSe extends to roughly 13.7 µm at the “0”-level and also shows the characteristic dip at 10 µm [28], like for LISe, see Fig. 2b. Raman studies of LIS have been performed with unpolarized [12, 20, 42] and polarized [14, 56] light. They were complemented by unpolarized IR absorption
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
75
[20], and unpolarized [57] and polarized [14, 42] IR reflectivity measurements which allowed to identify the vibrational modes, tabulated in [14, 56]. There are several important consequences of these results: Higher thermal conductivity and damage threshold in comparison to AGS and AGSe are expected for LIS as a result of the increased lattice phonon energy; the IR absorption edge of LIS is determined by multi phonon processes (three-phonon for the absorption onset near 8.1 µm and two-phonon for the cut-off at longer wavelengths) because the phonon spectrum of LIS is located at wavenumbers below 410 cm−1 . IR reflectivity and Raman spectra at room and low temperature were recorded for yellow LISe with polarized light [13, 42, 58]. The optical mode frequencies were tabulated in [13, 58]. No difference was observed for the frequencies between the red and yellow colour LISe [13]. As expected from reduced mass considerations the optical modes of LISe are shifted to lower frequencies due to the substitution of S by Se. The dominant line of the symmetric A1 mode lies at 268 cm−1 for LIS and at 161.5 cm−1 for LISe [58]. From absorption features of the transmission spectra and the maximum phonon energy of LISe (375 cm−1 ) it can be concluded that the onset of absorption near 10 µm is also due to threephonon absorption and the cut-off edge is set by two-phonon absorption. The fact that the IR cut-off edge of LISe is not substantially extended in comparison to LIS is associated with the role of the Li-S(e) sublattice vibrations while in AGS and AGSe, in the presence of the much heavier Ag ion, the high-frequency vibrations are related to the Ga-S(e) sublattice. 4. Dispersion and birefringence of LIS and LISe The three refractive indices of LIS were first measured and tabulated by Boyd et al. for light yellow crystals from 0.425 to 11 µm [9]. LIS is a negative biaxial crystal and the convention n X < n Y < n Z for the three refractive indices leads to the correspondence XYZ ≡ bac between the principal optical and crystallographic axes where c is the two-fold symmetry axis. The two indices n Y and n Z are very close and the birefringence is determined by the difference with n X . However, Sellmeier equations containing UV-poles and quadratic IR-terms were fitted to this data much later [59]. These equations were reproduced in several subsequent publications [34, 49–52, 60]. Another two-pole fit to the same data was suggested more recently [27]. However, no refinement with experimental phase-matching angles was performed. The experimentally observed deviations from the calculated angles made it necessary to refine the original fit using second harmonic generation (SHG) data for type-II phase matching in the X-Y and Y-Z planes in the 2.4. . .5.9 µm spectral range for the fundamental [38, 54, 61], and normal incidence difference-frequency generation (DFG) data in the X- Y plane between 6.6 and 7 µm [62]. The results for the two pole Sellmeier equations of the form n 2 = A1 + A3 /(λ2 − A2 ) + A5 /(λ2 − A4 ) [14], are reproduced in Table 1.
76
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
TABLE 1. Coefficients of two-pole Sellmeier expansions for LIS and LISe (wavelength in µm). Crystal
LiInS2 (LIS)
LiInSe2 (LISe)
n
A1
A2
A3
A4
nX nY nZ nX nY nZ
6.686059 7.095493 7.256327 5.669848 5.676208 6.302234
0.05910334 0.06614640 0.06823652 0.09473786 0.06265155 0.04137438
0.1385833 0.1422326 0.1507200 0.1948525 0.2451579 0.2509052
897.7476 988.2024 983.0503 492.0924 432.8862 713.0767
A5 2047.46509 2511.08936 2626.10840 300.72708 205.05597 755.68622
Concerning LISe, the initial work of Negran et al. [10] contained only refractive index measurements at 633 nm. LISe is also negative biaxial with the correspondence XYZ ≡ bac, and the two refractive indices n Y and n Z are very close. Our index measurements in the 0.5–11 µm range with yellow colour LISe were tabulated in [39] where also one-pole Sellmeier equations with quadratic IR-terms were constructed. Additional refractive index measurements between 0.7 and 1.9 µm of yellow-greenish (as grown) and dark red (annealed) LISe indicated that the index of refraction is the same within the experimental error [32]. Another similar fit for the 0.5..10 µm spectral range appeared in [63] but its origin is unknown. An alternative measurement of the refractive indices of red colour LISe from 0.633 to 10 µm was published in [27], together with two-pole Sellmeier equations which were also reproduced elsewhere [55], and another index measurement with deep red LISe was used to create a further Sellmeier set based again on two poles [28]. The discrepancies between the available sets of Sellmeier equations, made it necessary to remeasure the refractive indices with high quality yellow LISe between 0.525 and 12 µm [15]. Starting with a two-pole fit to this new index values, our refinement was based on DFG data in the 5.9–8.1 µm range for the X-Y plane [64], the signal wavelength obtained at normal incidence in the X-Y plane of a 1.064 µm pumped LISe OPO [65], as well as SHG in the XY and X-Z planes near 2.9 and 2.25 µm, respectively [39]. The coefficients of the final Sellmeier set of equations are included in Table 1. Two-pole Sellmeier equations for LiInSSe were constructed by others using separate refractive index measurements from 0.5 to 11 µm [28]. The thermo-optic coefficients (1/n)dn/dT = A + BT of LIS were measured between T = −20 and +120◦ C at 0.477, 0.632, 1.06 and 3.391 µm by an experimental technique that exploits the shift of Fizeau fringes with temperature [61]. The wavelength dependence of the two parameters A and B can be approximated by analogous two-pole functional forms A = A1A + A3A /(λ2 − A2A ) + A5A /(λ2 − A4A ) and B = A1B + A3B /(λ2 − A2B )+ A5B /(λ2 − A4B ) for the three polarizations.
77
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
TABLE 2. Dispersion of the parameters A and B of the thermo-optic coefficients of LIS and LISe defined by dn/dT = n( A + BT ). The wavelength is in µm and the temperature in ◦ C. crystal parameters A
B
A1A × 105 A2A × 10 A3A × 106 A4A × 10−2 A5A × 103 A1B × 109 A2B × 10 A3B × 109 A4B × 10−2 A5B × 106
LiInS2 (LIS)
LiInSe2 (LISe)
nX
nY
nZ
nX
nY
2.899680 1.207980 2.033761 2.210440 2.970535 19.87083 1.510404 1.860292 2.033450 2.500777
2.478267 1.150032 2.612463 1.937258 1.223207 1.523235 1.575449 2.601335 2.189817 −1.918712
3.315830 1.191312 2.555208 2.384285 3.649813 −6.564806 1.180506 4.291068 2.234460 −3.431015
2.78371 1.49498 5.4189 8.55280 7.32 – – – – –
4.26216 1.82457 4.9903 17.9166 13.97 – – – – –
nZ 3.58743 1.61387 6.2562 8.07974 8.73 – – – – –
The results from [14] are reproduced in Table 2. At 1064 nm and room temperature (293 K), dn X /dT = 3.725 × 10−5 K−1 , dn Y /dT = 4.545 × 10−5 K−1 , and dn Z /dT = 4.467 × 10−5 K−1 . The thermo-optic coefficients of yellow LISe were measured for 27 wavelengths between 0.625 and 12 µm at five temperatures between 20 and 150◦ C [66, 67]. A similar fitting procedure was used to obtain expressions for their wavelength dependence but in this case a first order approximation was sufficient, (1/n)dn/dT = A [15]. The corresponding coefficients for the three polarizations are included in Table 2. At 1064 nm, dn X /dT = 5.676 × 10−5 K−1 , dn Y /dT = 9.339 × 10−5 K−1 , and dn Z /dT = 7.368 × 10−5 K−1 . Above 3 µm where the wavelength dependence is only weakly pronounced, the thermo-optic coefficients of LISe are 1.5–2 times larger than those of LIS, they are comparable to the thermo-optic coefficients of AGSe and 2–3 times smaller than those of AGS [66, 67]. 5. Nonlinear susceptibility of LIS and LISe For the specified correspondence between the principal optical and the crystallographic axes of LIS and LISe, the effective second order nonlinearity deff for propagation in the principal planes can be calculated from [2]: deoe = doee = −(d24 sin2 ϕ + d15 cos2 ϕ) in the X- Y plane (1) doeo = deoo = −d24 sin θ in the Y-Z plane (2) dooe = d31 sin θ in the X-Z plane (θ < VZ ) (3)
78
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
Figure 3. (a) Calculated angle V Z between the optic axis and the principal Z-axis of LIS and LISe in dependence on the wavelength. (b) Principal optical axes and types of interaction in a biaxial crystal. The two optic axes lie per definition in the X- Z plane. For LIS and LISe, XYZ ≡ bac holds.
with the subscripts “o” and “e” denoting the ordinary and extraordinary beams. LIS and LISe behave as optically negative uniaxial crystals in the X- Y and X- Z (for θ < VZ ) planes, and as optically positive uniaxial crystals in the Y-Z plane (Fig. 3). The situation θ > VZ for propagation in the X- Z plane is never reached in practice. General expressions for propagation outside the principal planes, which involve also d33 , can be found elsewhere [14, 15]. The wavelength dependence of the angle VZ (Fig. 3a) reflects the trends observed in the behaviour of the refractive indices. Thus at longer wavelengths, both for LIS and LISe, n Y and n Z get closer. The behaviour of VZ near the band-edge is expected, however, to be affected by defects (colour) and hence is of little importance. At present it is impossible to say whether n Y and n Z cross near the band-edge but this definitely does not happen in the regions of > 50% transparency (see Fig. 2). The first estimation of the nonlinear coefficients of LIS was performed by the Maker fringe (wedge) technique using non-phase-matched SHG at 10.6 µm [9]. The results included in Table 3 are rescaled using d33 (GaAs) = 83 pm/V [1]. We note that traditionally these coefficients are defined in the abc crystallographic frame and we assume that Kleinman symmetry holds, i.e. d24 = d32 and d31 = d15 [2]. It was also established that d31 and d24 have the same sign but the sign of d33 (LIS) remained undetermined [9]. The same authors concluded that the close values of d31 and d24 will lead to almost constant effective nonlinearity deff in the X-Y plane. Estimations of the nonlinear coefficients by the same method at 9.55 µm relative to ZGP gave practically the same result [49–51] if d36 (ZGP) = 75 pm/V is assumed [1, 2]. We previously published several preliminary estimations of the d31 and d24 nonlinear coefficients of LIS, mostly from SHG measurements [34, 38, 53, 54, 61], but also from the performance of an optical parametric amplifier (OPA) [60], assuming equal signs. However, they can be ignored because we incorporated all these results in a more systematic approach to derive consistent values taking
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM TABLE 3. crystal
SHG@
Nonlinear coefficients of LIS and LISe.
d31 [pm/V]
10.6 µm 6.14 ± 15% 2.59 µm 7.94 ± 20% 2.3 µm 7.25 ± 5% LiInSe2 (LISe) 2.3 µm 11.78 ± 5%
LiInS2 (LIS)
79
d24 [pm/V]
d33 [pm/V]
remarks
5.31 ± 15% −9.79 ± 15% wedge, relative to GaAs 5.73 ± 20% – SHG, relative to KTP 5.66 ± 10% −16 ± 25% SHG, relative to AGS 8.17 ± 10% −16 ± 25% SHG, relative to AGS
into account the wavelength dependence and the updated values for the reference samples [14]. We basically compared the results using two different kinds of SHG measurements. In one case the laser source in the range 2.4. . .2.6 µm was the idler output of a type-I LiNbO3 OPO (12 ns pulsewidth, 10 Hz repetition rate). Long LIS samples were used and hence the residual absorption and the beam walk-off effect, as well as the focusing effects, had to be taken into account in the derivation of the nonlinear coefficients. The three thick (5. . .7 mm) samples of LIS used had different coloration (light yellow for as grown and rose for annealed) and were cut for propagation in the X-Y and Y-Z planes. However, the results were independent of the coloration. The measurements were performed in the low depletion limit for the fundamental, relative to a dual-band antireflection coated KTiOPO4 (KTP) crystal cut for propagation in the X-Z plane. We used Gaussian beam SHG theory in the ns regime and put the results on an absolute basis using d24 (KTP) = 2.30 ± 0.2 pm/V [68]. The final results for d24 and d31 obtained for SHG at 2.59 µm are included in Table 3 [14]. In the other case we used 160 fs long pulses from a 1-kHz KTP OPA in the 2.3. . .2.85 µm spectral range but worked also in the low depletion limit to avoid complications from saturation effects and spatial dependence across the beam cross section. Three annealed samples of rose LIS were available, all of them 0.2 mm thick. They were cut for propagation in the X-Z plane, in the X-Y plane, and outside the principal planes, which allows to successively determine d31 , d24 and d33 , albeit with increasing error [14]. The measurement was relative to a type-I AGS crystal and put on an absolute basis using d36 (AGS) = 13.9 ± 2.8 pm/V [69]. It should be emphasized that the last value was measured in the same wavelength range and calibrated by the same d24 (KTP) value quoted above. The final results for d31 , d24 and d33 of LIS are given in Table 3 only with the relative error. One can see that there is very good agreement between the two measurements of d31 and d24 while for d33 we obtained a different sign [9]. A similar measurement with fs pulses was used in the first estimation of the two nonlinear coefficients d31 and d24 of LISe [39]. In order to improve the reliability and to extend the results also to d33 (LISe) we repeated this measurement performing it simultaneously and in an absolutely analogous manner as the above
80
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
described measurement of the LIS nonlinearities with fs pulses. The three yellow LISe samples used were annealed and had the same thickness of 0.2 mm. The final results for d31 , d24 and d33 of LISe in Table 3 are given only with the relative error without taking into account the accuracy of d36 (AGS) for the same reference sample [15]. While the two nonlinear coefficients d31 and d24 of LISe are higher than in LIS the difference between the sulphide and selenide compounds is much smaller if compared to AGS and AGSe [1, 2]. The diagonal elements have the same magnitude within the experimental accuracy. The ratio of d24 /d31 for LIS (0.72. . .0.78) is close to the value of Boyd et al. [9] and this confirms that deff depends only weakly on the azimuthal angle for propagation in the X- Y plane. The same holds for LISe for which we obtained d24 /d31 = 0.69. The higher value of d33 makes it interesting to consider the behaviour of deff for propagation outside the principal planes. In some cases propagation outside the principal planes can ensure increased deff in type-I SHG (Fig. 4) while the curves for type-II SHG have a different character and maximum deff is achieved always in the X- Y plane.
Figure 4. Effective nonlinearity deff versus azimuthal angle ϕ for type-I (solid lines) and type-II (dashed lines) SHG in LIS (a) and LISe (b) outside the principal planes. The labels indicate the fundamental wavelengths. The curves start from the X-Z plane (ϕ = 0◦ ) and end at the X- Y plane (θ = 90◦ ) or start from the X-Y plane (θ = 90◦ ) and end at the Y- Z plane (ϕ = 90◦ ).
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
81
Figure 5. Down conversion (DFG, OPA, OPO) outside the principal planes of LIS (a) and LISe (b) for a pump wavelength of 1064 nm and selected idler wavelengths (indicated in the figures). All curves start from the X- Z plane (ϕ = 0◦ ), where deff for type-II interaction (dashed lines) vanishes, and end at the X-Y plane (θ = 90◦ ) where deff for type-I interaction (solid lines) vanishes.
For various applications it is important to consider also the down conversion into the mid-IR of high power sources, e.g. lasers emitting at 1064 nm (Fig. 5). Calculations in the principal planes for the selected wavelengths indicate that the absolute negative extremum of the type-II deff curves which occurs in the X- Y plane is larger than the extremum of the type-I curves in the X- Z plane. Hence type-II interaction in the X-Y plane will be more efficient than type-I interaction in the X-Z plane. However, propagation outside the principal planes allows to increase the effective nonlinearity for type-I interaction (−7 < deff (θ, ϕ) < −7.5 pm/V for LIS and −8 < deff (θ, ϕ) < −9.6 pm/V for LISe) which can be advantageous since other parameters like e.g. the spectral acceptance can be better in type-I interaction [14, 15]. Another nonlinear parameter of higher order which plays an important role for high intensity ultrashort laser pulses is the two-photon absorption (TPA) coefficient. Since most high power fs laser systems rely on Ti: sapphire laser technology it is important to measure the TPA coefficient near 800 nm. In our initial
82
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
measurement with a 1.5 mm thick LIS sample using 200 fs pulses at 800 nm the nonlinear losses were rather low and their intensity dependence could not be properly fitted by a TPA process. However, an upper limit of βT P A = 0.04 cm/GW (independent of the polarization) was derived while simultaneous measurement of a 0.3 mm thick AGS crystal yielded βT P A = 3.5 cm/GW±10% for o-polarization and βT P A = 5.6 cm/GW ± 20% for a mixed (o and e) polarization with reasonable fits [60]. A very similar upper limit of βT P A = 0.05 cm/GW was derived for LIS using another rose colour annealed sample of 5 mm length and 300 fs pulses at 820 nm [14]. An analogous measurement of a 3-mm thick annealed (yellow-brown) sample of LISe with 220 fs pulses at 820 nm showed that the TPA contribution can exceed the linear losses: The measured data were fitted by βT P A = 0.6 cm/GW [5]. Having in mind that typical peak pump intensities in fs OPAs are of the order of 50 GW/cm2 and the nonlinear crystals used are relatively short [5, 38, 60], it is clear that LIS with its extraordinary large band-gap lying in the UV (≈347 nm) is an unique mid-IR crystal that can be pumped by high power fs laser systems near 800 nm. This is obviously not the case with LISe while AGS will experience serious TPA problems even with much longer pulses. 6. Thermo-mechanical properties and damage resistivity of LIS and LISe The heat capacity at constant pressure of LIS and LISe has been measured previously from 200 to 550 K using polycrystalline samples [70]. The results at 300 K are C p = 90 and 96 Jmol−1 K−1 ± 1% for LIS and LISe, respectively. Measurements with single crystals of LISe yielded C p = 96.06 Jmol−1 K−1 ± 1.2% [71]. More recently we directly compared unoriented single crystals of rose LIS and LISe measuring C p with a differential scanning calorimeter in the temperature range 113–483 K [14, 66]. The results are partially reproduced in Fig. 6.
Figure 6. Heat capacity versus temperature for LIS and LISe (experimental points with error bars) and fitting results (curves).
83
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
TABLE 4. Heat capacity C p = C0 − C1 /T − C2 /T 2 [Jmol−1 K−1 ] and thermal conductivity K = K 0 − K 1 T [Wm−1 K−1 ] of LIS and LISe where T is measured in K. crystal LiInS2 (LIS) LiInSe2 (LISe)
C0
C1
C2
K 0X
K 0Y
K 0Z
K 1X
K 1Y
K 1Z
112.98 114.02
3988 5708
139312 187540
– 6.739
– 7.70
– 8.539
– 0.00668
– 0.0101
– 0.0103
The values at 300 K are C p (LIS) = 92.9 ± 1.1 Jmol−1 K−1 and C p (LISe) = 98.1 ± 1.4 Jmol−1 K−1 . The obtained temperature dependence can be fitted by the function C p = C0 − C1 /T − C2 /T 2 and the coefficients are summarized in Table 4. It was established in [70] that the specific nature of the Li-S(e) bonds which has a considerable effect on the lattice vibrations gives rise to changes in the anharmonic properties in comparison to the chalcopyrites. This was confirmed in [66] by measurements on single crystals of LIS and LISe. The thermal conductivity of LIS along the principal optical axes was known at 300 K [72]: K X = 6.2 ± 0.5, K Y = 6.0 ± 0.5, and K Z = 7.6 ± 0.5 Wm−1 K−1 . We measured the thermal conductivity of red oriented LISe samples from 293 to 343 K [66, 67]. The results at 300 K are: K X = 4.7 ± 0.2, K Y = 4.7 ± 0.2, and K Z = 5.5 ± 0.3 Wm−1 K−1 . The temperature dependence can be approximated by linear fits the coefficients of which are included in Table 4 [67]. The values at room temperature were confirmed by an independent measurement at 302 K [73]: K X = 4.5 ± 0.3, K Y = 4.8 ± 0.2, and K Z = 5.8 ± 0.1 Wm−1 K−1 . Therefore the average value published for LISe in [55], comparable to AGS, should be an error. Thus the thermal conductivities of LIS and LISe are more than 4 times larger than the thermal conductivities of the corresponding chalcopyrite sulphide AGS and selenide AGSe. The thermal conductivity is related to the phonons which are responsible for the transfer of the thermal motion energy. The slightly lower thermal conductivity of LISe in comparison to LIS can be attributed to the lower energy of the phonon vibrations discussed in Section 3. The presence of the heavier metal ion (Ag) in AGS and AGSe explains their substantially lower thermal conductivity. The linear thermal expansion coefficients of LIS were measured by an absolute interferometric dilatometer from 253 to 393 K [14,61]: At room temperature (293 K): α X = (1.64±0.05)×10−5 K−1 , αY = (0.91±0.05)×10−5 K−1 , and α Z = (0.68±0.05)×10−5 K−1 . The temperature dependence can be approximated with linear functions. The coefficients obtained are given in Table 5. The linear expansion coefficients of red LISe were measured between 300 and 460 K [66,67]. The values obtained at room temperature (300 K) are: α X = (1.76 ± 0.18) × 10−5 K−1 , αY = (1.1 ± 0.16) × 10−5 K−1 , and α Z = (0.87 ± 0.11) × 10−5 K−1 .
84
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
TABLE 5. Thermal expansion coefficients α = α0 + α1 T + α2 T 2 [10−6 K−1 ] of LIS and LISe where the temperature is in K. crystal
α0X α0Y α0Z
α1X
α1Y
α1Z
α2X
α2Y
α2Z
LiInS2 12.2 6.93 4.06 0.0144 0.0072 0.0093 – – – LiInSe2 7.0 30.3 1.0 0.0463 −0.1051 0.0417 −3.67 × 10−5 1.359 × 10−4 −5.38 × 10−5
They are rather close to the values known for LISe from measurements of the changes of the unit cell parameters in the 303. . . 773 K temperature range [13]: α X = 1.98 × 10−5 K−1 , αY = 0.936 × 10−5 K−1 , and α Z = 0.64 × 10−5 K−1 . The parameters obtained for quadratic fits of the temperature dependence are included in Table 5 [66,67]. Although the thermal expansion of LIS and LISe is anisotropic, the signs of the linear expansion coefficients are the same in contrast to the uniaxial chalcopyrites AGS and AGSe. This property is an essential advantage in relation to the crystal growth and mechanical stability of dielectric coatings. The damage properties of LIS were studied at 5 µm with a free electron laser [34,54]. At a pulse duration of 500 fs the damage threshold was 1.1 J/cm2 but this is the fluence of the 5 µs macropulse consisting of fs pulses at 1 GHz. No surface damage was observed in LIS up to 140 GW/cm2 using amplified 200 fs pulses at 800 nm [60]. However, at the repetition rate of 1 kHz, gray tracking phenomena were observed which were attributed to the absorption of the non-phase-matched second harmonic generated at 400 nm because a similar effect was produced by unamplified fs pulses at 400 nm. These gray tracks were partially reversible and increased the crystal absorption mainly in the UV and visible while in the near-IR their effect was weaker. With a conventional lamp source it was established that the gray track formation is maximized near 360 nm but was absent for illumination above 450 nm [38]. Interpretation of these effects can be found in [14]. At 1.064 nm, the CW damage threshold of LIS should lie above 120 kW/cm2 while measurements with 10 ns pulses at 10 Hz yielded a damage threshold of roughly 1 J/cm2 or 100 MW/cm2 which is quite high [14]. In several papers the damage threshold of LIS was determined at 9.55 µm with 36 ns long pulses [49–51], the last result being 214 MW/cm2 which is roughly 50% above the values determined for AGS and AGSe. The damage threshold of LISe measured at this wavelength was even higher: 248 ± 16 MW/cm2 [55]. Illumination of LISe with amplified 200 fs pulses near 820 nm produced also gray tracks but no crystal damage was observed up to 50 GW/cm2 [5]. Some other properties of LIS and LISe which are not necessarily related to nonlinear optics have also been studied: Besides the already mentioned photoluminescence and electrical properties, citations for which can be found in [14, 15],
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
85
we want to mention here the pyroelectric, piezoelectric, and electro-optic effects in LIS [10, 14, 61, 74] and LISe [10, 15]. 7. Phase-matching in LIS and LISe The biaxial phase-matching loci for collinear SHG in LIS and LISe can be categorized using the classification of Hobden [75]. The computation is based on relatively simple transcendental equations [76]. Figure 7 illustrates the different SHG classes for LIS and LISe at several representative fundamental wavelengths. The surface of the unit sphere is projected onto the X-Z plane of the crystal. The direction of the wave vectors of the interacting waves for phase-matching as given by their interception with the surface of the unit sphere is plotted. The stereographic projection of the first octant is presented only but the loci in the other octants can be obtained by mirror reflections across the principal planes.
Figure 7. Stereographic projections of the SHG in the first octant of LIS (a and b) and LISe (c and d) calculated for wavelengths representative of the Hobden classes. Type-I (ss-f) interaction (solid lines) and type-II (fs-f≡sf-f) interaction (dashed lines).
86
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL. TABLE 6. Hobden classes and transition wavelengths in nm for LIS and LISe.
crystal/classes 14 → 13 13 → 11 11 → 10 10 → 9 9 → 10 10 → 11 11 → 13 13 → 14 LiInS2 (LIS) 1617 LiInSe2 (LISe) 1860
1783 2078
2353 2672
2675 3051
5493 7799
6111 8259
8224 10881
8710 11071
Figure 8. SHG phase-matching in the principal planes of LIS (solid lines) and LISe (dashed lines) and inverse group velocity mismatch, GVM (∆31 = 1/v 3 − 1/v 1 and ∆32 = 1/v 3 − 1/v 2 where v 1 , v 2 , v 3 denote the group velocities at λ1 , λ2 , and λ3 ) for the cases where deff = 0. The thin dashed lines indicate the correspondence between the two branches of the tuning and GVM curves.
The transitional (fundamental) wavelengths between the different Hobden classes are summarized in Table 6. They correspond to propagation directions along the Y or Z principal optical axes (noncritical phase-matching) either for the ss-f or the fs-f (≡sf-f) polarization configurations. As can be seen from Fig. 7, double solutions for the angles exist (e.g. for Hobden’s class 9) which is equivalent to the existence of points outside the principal planes where ∂ϕ/∂θ = 0 holds. This means that noncritical phasematching in one direction can also occur outside the principal planes (e.g. at ϕ ≈ 26.7◦ , θ ≈ 74.35◦ for ss-f type SHG at 4 µm and at ϕ ≈ 23.2◦ , θ ≈ 70.3◦ for ss-f type SHG at 5 µm in LIS and LISe, respectively). The SHG phase-matching directions in the principal planes of LIS and LISe are shown in the lower part of Fig. 8. The transitional wavelengths from Table 5
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
87
can be easily identified in Fig. 8. The SHG ranges for LIS (LISe) where deff = 0 are 1783–8224 nm (2078–10881 nm) for type-I (oo-e) phase-matching in the X-Z plane, 2353–6111 nm (2672–8259 nm) for type-II (eo-e) phase-matching in the X-Y plane, and 2353–2675 nm and 5493–6111 nm (2672–3051 nm and 7799– 8259 nm) for type-II (oe-o) phase-matching in the Y- Z plane. We observe an interesting feature in these crystals: The SHG limits with deff = 0 are larger for propagation outside the principal planes where type-I phase-matching down to 1617 nm and up to 8710 nm in LIS, and down to 1860 nm and up to 11071 nm in LISe is possible. Under the convention n X < n Y < n Z the largest birefringence and consequently the shortest SHG wavelength is obviously achieved for type-I interaction and propagation along the Y-axis. However, when the Y-axis is approached in the principal planes X-Y or Y-Z of LIS and LISe, deff for type-I phase-matching vanishes and this is true also for the limiting case of propagation along the Y-axis. This is the reason why propagation outside the principal planes can be used, e.g., to shorten the SHG lower wavelength limit (Fig. 7). A similar situation has been observed previously in KTP [77]. It is seen from Fig. 8 that in the Y-Z plane the type-II interaction is quasi angle-noncritical which ensures a large acceptance angle and a small walk-off angle. In contrast, type-I interaction in the X-Z plane and type-II interaction in the X-Y plane have regions of quasi wavelength-noncritical phase-matching centered at 3889 and 3803 nm for LIS, and at 5223 and 4919 nm for LISe, respectively. Further analysis of the angular acceptance and the walk-off angle dependence can be found elsewhere [14, 15]. The chosen presentation of the inverse group velocity mismatch, GVM, in the upper part of Fig. 8 is equivalent to the spectral acceptance but contains the sign as additional information. Note that in the case of type-I SHG the spectral acceptance is given by 0.886/|∆31 | where the indices are related to λ1 ≥ λ2 > λ3 with 1/λ3 = 1/λ1 +1/λ2 . The two parameters ∆31 and ∆32 simultaneously vanish at 3889 nm (LIS) and 5223 nm (LISe) in the X-Z plane which means large spectral acceptance for SHG of short pulses and necessity to consider higher order effects (group velocity dispersion). The situation is different for type-II interaction in the X-Y plane: here ∆32 = −∆31 at 3803 nm (LIS) and 4919 nm (LISe), at 2915 nm (LIS) and 3701 nm (LISe) ∆32 vanishes, and at 4946 nm (LIS) and 6328 nm (LISe) ∆31 vanishes but in none of these cases an extremum of the spectral acceptance occurs because in type-II SHG of short pulses all three waves should be considered as broad-band. The spectral acceptance is smallest in the Y-Z plane and this can be used for spectral narrowing. Type-I phase-matching in the X-Z plane for non-degenerate three-wave interactions is presented in Fig. 9 where two branches of the solution can be seen. The whole transparency range of LIS and LISe can be covered for 0◦ ≤ θ ≤ 40◦ in the X-Z plane but deff increases with the phase-matching angle θ. Note that
88
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
Figure 9. Type-I (oo-e) phase-matching for sum and difference frequency mixing or optical parametric amplification in the X-Z plane of LIS (a) and LISe (b). The uncritical configurations are shown by thick lines. The curves are terminated by the transparency ranges of the crystals.
deff = 0 in the uncritical (θ = 0◦ ) configuration and that the situation θ > VZ , is never reached. At larger angles θ a retracing behaviour in the left branch is observed: e.g. in the case of OPO one and the same pump wavelength λ P ≡ λ3 corresponds to two pairs (λ I ≡ λ1 , λ S ≡ λ2 ) of idler and signal wavelengths. In such regions the spectral acceptance is very large. Thus, e.g. for θ = 40◦ (LIS) and 45◦ (LISe) in Figs. 9a and b, respectively, at λ1 ≈ 11.4 µm, λ2 ≈ 0.963 µm and λ3 ≈ 0.888 µm for LIS, and at λ1 ≈ 9.64 µm, λ2 ≈ 1.94 µm and λ3 ≈ 1.615 µm for LISe, all three group velocities are very close and the absolute values of the GVM parameters do not exceed 20 fs/mm. Such phase-matching configurations are especially suitable for frequency down-conversion of fs pulses or generation of fs quasi continuum. In OPAs, however, seeding must be used for control of the spectral bandwidth. In the regions near the degeneracy points (SHG points) one has on the other hand ∆21 ≈ 0 but the wave at λ3 has in general a different group velocity. Such a regime is attractive for broad-band parametric amplification in the field of a narrow-band pump pulse as in the case of chirped pulse optical parametric amplification. Increasing the phase-matching angle (curves for θ = 45◦ in Fig. 9) the two branches merge into a closed contour and the point is approached where SHG phase-matching only for a single wavelength is possible, see Fig. 8. In this limit all three group velocities are again very close but the tunability is very limited. The curves for type-II phase-matching (Fig. 10) have a completely different shape. The two branches of the solution are represented by curves of opposite curvature which can cross at two points where phase-matching for degenerate DFG or SHG is realized. With decreasing phase-matching angle these branches separate and a single crossing point is reached (near ϕ = 50◦ for LIS and between ϕ = 40◦ and 50◦ for LISe) which corresponds to the single SHG solutions in Fig. 8. For yet smaller angles no crossing occurs and the degeneracy point is not reached.
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
89
Figure 10. Type-II (eo-e and oe-e) phase-matching for sum and difference frequency mixing or optical parametric amplification in the X-Y plane of LIS (a) and LISe (b). The uncritical configurations are shown by thick lines. The curves are terminated by the transparency range of the crystals.
For all phase-matching angles presented we observe again a retracing behaviour at longer λ P ≡ λ3 : For each λ3 two couples (λ I ≡ λ1 , λ S ≡ λ2 ) are phase-matched. At the points where these two pairs merge into one (at the maximum λ3 permitting phase-matching) the waves at λ1 and λ2 have equal group velocities and similar to the cases discussed for Fig. 9, broad-band parametric amplification in the field of a narrow-band pump wave can be realized. The deviation from the pump group velocity remains, however, essential. Thus e.g. at ϕ = 90◦ and λ3 = 3310 nm (LIS) and λ3 = 4330 nm (LISe), ∆21 ≈ 0, and ∆31 ≈ ∆32 ≈ −1.65 ps/cm (LIS) and ∆31 ≈ ∆32 ≈ −1.57 ps/cm (LISe). Improved group velocity matching with the pump wave occurs for these points at smaller phase-matching angle ϕ, in accordance with Fig. 8. The GVM depends on the specific wavelengths chosen. At λ3 = 1064 nm (a case interesting for parametric down-conversion) ∆21 (X-Z) < ∆21 (X-Y) is fulfilled in the main part of the transparency ranges of LIS and LISe. This means that type-II phase-matching in the X-Y plane is more advantageous for development of narrow-band parametric generators or oscillators.
90
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
Crystals of LiInSSe or various compositions between LIS and LISe occupy an intermediate position also with respect to the phase-matching properties. Some phase-matching analysis for LiInSSe and estimations of the acceptable composition variations for various phase-matched processes can be found elsewhere [28, 78]. 8. Nonlinear frequency conversion with LIS and LISe The first phase-matched nonlinear process realized in 2000 with LIS was SHG from 2.35 to 2.65 µm in the X-Y and Y-Z planes using a 10 ns LiNbO3 OPO operating at 10 Hz [34, 38, 53, 61]. These measurements were complemented with SHG between 3.85 and 6 µm of a free electron laser [34, 38, 54]. They all served basically to test the validity of the existing Sellmeier equations, for preliminary estimations of the nonlinearity, and to establish the equivalence of the phasematching properties for the yellow (as grown) and rose (annealed) LIS. The purpose of the first SHG experiments in the X-Y and X-Z planes of LISe, using fs pulses between 2.1 and 2.8 µm, was similar [39]. LIS is not phase-matchable for SHG at CO2 laser wavelengths. The CO2 laser SHG efficiency obtained with LISe shows that this selenide crystal cannot compete with AGSe for this important application [52,55,63]: The SHG external efficiency obtained with a 6.2 mm thick LISe crystal using 33 ns long pulses was 2.6% in terms of peak power and 1.5% in terms of energy for a peak pump intensity of 38.5 MW/cm2 at 9.55 µm, and the obtained second harmonic energy was 7.2 mJ; somewhat higher efficiency, 4.3% in terms of peak power, was reported at 9.26 µm. In the following three subsections we will present three different applications realized so far with LIS and LISe. 8.1. MID-IR FEMTOSECOND OPA [5, 14]
For the production of ultrashort mid-IR pulses, it is highly desirable to realize direct down-conversion from the 800 nm spectral range where the most widely spread Ti:sapphire fs sources operate [79]. LIS was the first nonlinear optical crystal for which such a process was demonstrated in 2001 using only a 1.5 mm thick uncoated sample which allowed the direct conversion of amplified 200 fs pulses at 800 nm and 1 kHz to the mid-IR, reaching 9 µm by type-II phase-matching in the X-Y plane [60]. This was possible because this material allowed to avoid TPA near 800 nm to a great extent. Nevertheless, as can be seen from Fig. 11 the GVM in LIS is still rather large for pumping near 800 nm and in particular the idler pulse travels much faster than the other two. This makes it difficult to achieve high parametric gain with such a seeded OPA using fs pump pulses. In a subsequent experiment, the parametric gain in terms of pulse energy was considerably increased by lengthening the pump pulses to 300 fs and using a 5 mm thick uncoated LIS crystal which was
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
91
Figure 11. Calculated inverse GVM at λ P = λ3 = 820 (a) and 1250 nm (b) for type-II interaction in the X-Y plane of LIS and LISe: ∆ S P = 1/v S − 1/v P (dashed lines), ∆ I P = 1/v I − 1/v P (dotted lines), and ∆ I S = 1/v I − 1/v S (solid lines). The Sellmeier equations used for LIS and LISe are from Table 1.
Figure 12. Idler spectra that demonstrate the achieved tunability with the continuum seeded LIS OPA pumped at 820 nm. The labels indicate the FWHM.
again rose (annealed). The tunability obtained with this sample is illustrated in Fig. 12. Although more than 80 nJ were achieved for the idler energy between 8 and 12 µm, the gain was still rather low having in mind that the OPA stage, seeded by a spectral portion of continuum, was pumped by 150 µJ pulses at 820 nm with a peak on-axis pump intensity of 60 GW/cm2 [14, 38]. As a consequence the idler pulse duration was also just below 600 fs although the pulses were almost transform limited (time-bandwidth product equal to 0.44 assuming Gaussian pulse shapes) [14]. Using a similar set-up which is explained in more detail in another Chapter of this book [4], we directly compared LIS and LISe under identical pump and seed conditions. In this case both samples (cut for type-II phase-matching in the X-Y plane) were uncoated, annealed and 3 mm thick. The OPA was pumped at 820 nm by 220 fs, 230 µJ pulses at 1 kHz [5] and the peak on-axis pump intensity was 50 GW/cm2 . It was seeded by continuum generated with ≈30 µJ of pump radiation in a 2-mm thick sapphire plate by selecting ≈10 nm wide spectral portions with the use of interference filters. The GVM in LISe is even larger and
92
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
Figure 13. Idler energy measured with 3-mm thick samples of LIS and LISe used in an OPA pumped at 820 nm by fs pulses. Type-II phase-matching in the X-Y plane is used.
the TPA effect is rather strong. Consequently, the performance of this crystal was inferior in comparison to LIS, see Fig. 13. This is a good example of a situation where although the effective nonlinearity is higher, the performance of a given crystal is limited by other factors. Very recently, LIS was used in a similar OPA pumped at 1240 nm by fs pulses with an energy of 160 µJ produced by a Cr: forsterite amplifier system [80]. In that case the continuum generated by the second harmonic of the pump wave was preamplified in two LiB3 O5 stages. The pump pulses used for the LIS OPA stage were 100–140 fs long and the pump intensity was between 140 and 200 GW/cm2 . The uncoated crystal was 3 mm thick and cut for propagation in the X-Y plane. Although tuning from 8 to 10.8 µm was demonstrated, the external conversion efficiency in terms of energy was only 0.6%, and the maximum idler energy – only 1 µJ at 9.5 µm. Thus this scheme, although containing two additional stages, did not improve the conversion efficiency (either overall or in the last OPA stage) in comparison to the use of crystals with higher nonlinearity [4]. The important conclusion is that, as long as TPA can be avoided, the higher effective nonlinearity can compensate for the larger GVM. It can be seen from Fig. 11 that the point of matched group velocities in LISe is shifted towards longer idler wavelengths in comparison to LIS and that longer pump wavelengths provide better chance to achieve this regime within the transparency ranges of the crystals. The large band-gap values of LIS and LISe ensure lower GVM, and lower TPA and Kerr-type nonlinearity n 2 can be expected. However, only LIS is applicable for pumping near 800 nm while its second-order nonlinearity is moderate. Near λ P = 1250 nm, it is clear that LISe can be preferable over LIS but for this pump wavelength also other crystals like AGS and HGS are applicable. LIS could be very useful for pumping with ps amplified Ti:sapphire laser systems which are also tunable because in that case TPA plays also essential role but longer crystals can be used. On the other hand
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
93
LISe might prove advantageous for ps OPAs and optical parametric generators (OPGs) pumped near 1 µm (Nd or Yb based amplifier systems with duration in the 1-30 ps range) because in this case the low GVM and the high damage threshold would play a more essential role. 8.2. CONTINUOUS-WAVE DFG OF MID-IR RADIATION [62, 64]
DFG with CW laser sources has been studied with LIS and LISe in order to produce narrow-band mid-IR radiation for high resolution spectroscopy [62, 64]. If both laser sources have linewdths <1 MHz, the mid-IR radiation at λ1 allows to perform sub-Doppler spectroscopy of heavy atmospheric molecules with only ∼1 µW of power. Two single-frequency Ti:sapphire lasers were used for DFG. They were tunable roughly from 700 to 810 nm (λ3 ) and from 800 to 900 nm (λ2 ). The laser beams, orthogonally polarized, were collinearly focused onto the mixing crystal with a 35-cm focal-length lens, yielding nearly optimum Gaussian waists of 55 µm. Behind the nonlinear crystal, the input beams were blocked by an uncoated Ge-filter and the mid-IR radiation was measured by a calibrated HgCdTe photoconductive detector. Type-II (eo-e) interaction in the X-Y plane was used. Uncoated samples of 5 × 5 × 10 mm3 (yellowish LIS, length: 10 mm, cut at ϕ = 42◦ ) and 6 × 7 × 9 mm3 (greenish LISe, length: 9 mm, cut at ϕ = 55◦ ) were available for this experiment. Tuning with this scheme was possible both at fixed crystal angle (normal incidence) and by rotation of the nonlinear crystal. At normal incidence the tuning ranges that were covered with LIS and LISe in the mid-IR were 6.6–7 µm and 6.2–6.8 µm, respectively (Fig. 14a) [62,64]. These ranges were extended by angle tuning to 5.5–11.3 µm for LIS and to 5.9–8.1 µm for LISe (Fig. 14b). In these cases λ2 was fixed at ≈ 836 nm (LIS) and ≈ 807 nm (LISe) and only the input
Figure 14. Tunability obtained in the mid-IR with LIS (full symbols, solid lines) and LISe (open symbols, gray lines) under normal incidence (a) and when rotating the nonlinear crystals in the X-Y plane (b). The symbols show the experimentally measured points and the lines are calculated with the Sellmeier equations from Table 1.
94
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
wave at λ3 was varied. The data presented in Fig. 14b correspond to incidence angles in the −20 . . . + 20◦ range. As could be expected the agreement with the calculated phase-matching curves is excellent because the same experimental data were used in the corresponding Sellmeier sets refinement procedures. The same holds for the comparison of the experimental and calculated angular acceptances [62, 64]. It is obvious from Fig. 14b that LIS provides broader tunability range and longer wavelengths in the mid-IR can be achieved with the given laser sources. However, the conversion efficiency obtained with LISe is higher. This can be seen in Fig. 15 showing the dependence of the mid-IR power generated at normal incidence with the two crystals (λ1 = 6.7 µm) on the product of the input powers. The external slope efficiency obtained with LISe was 1.1 µW/W2 . Comparing the two slopes in Fig. 15 and taking into account the different lengths, cut angles and refractive indices it can be concluded that deff (LISe) ≈ 1.37deff (LIS). This is in excellent agreement with the estimated ratio using Table 3 which is deff (LISe) = 1.35. . .1.43deff (LIS). The DFG power produced is proportional to the square of the DFG frequency. Despite the strong mid-IR absorption of LIS at λ1 = 11.3 µm, it was possible to still detect ∼3 nW at this wavelength for input powers of 200 mW at λ3 and 265 mW at λ2 . This is associated with nonlinear frequency conversion in the exit layer of the crystal. The spectral tuning characteristics are shown in Fig. 16. In the case of LIS (Fig. 16a) the experimental curve was recorded at fixed λ2 = 836.2 nm varying only λ3 near 710 nm [62]. In the case of LISe (Fig. 16b) the fixed wavelength was λ2 = 807.2 nm and λ3 was varied near 721 nm [64]. The fact that the experimental acceptance bandwidths are broader can be attributed to the effect of spatial walkoff which reduces in both cases the actual interaction lengths.
Figure 15. Dependence of the DFG power at normal incidence (λ1 = 6.7 µm) produced by LIS (full symbols) and LISe (open symbols) versus input power and the corresponding linear fits (lines) for the external slope efficiencies.
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
95
Figure 16. Measured (solid lines) and calculated by a plane-wave model (dashed lines) phase– matching characteristics for mid-IR DFG with LIS (a) and LISe (b) when tuning only one of the input wavelengths at a fixed phase-matching angle. Water-vapour absorption lines are observed since the path to the detector was not evacuated.
8.3. NANOSECOND OPO [65]
In the ns and eventually in the CW regime the most attractive pump wavelength for OPOs is 1064 nm due to the existence of high-power Nd:YAG laser systems. The high peak intensities available from ns pump sources allow to achieve parametric oscillation even in the presence of large cavity round-trip loss for the signal and idler waves. Furthermore, the effect of thermal lensing – whose typical relaxation timescale is on the order of milliseconds – is less critical at lower repetition rates. The main problem encountered in such ns parametric devices pumped at 1064 nm and employing chalcogenide materials is related to the optical damage threshold. With a 20 mm long AGS sample for instance (the nonlinearity of which is scalable to that of LISe), the threshold for oscillation of a singly resonant OPO pumped by 12 ns pulses at 1064 nm was 0.03 J/cm2 while optical damage of the surface was observed at 0.2 J/cm2 [81]. The higher damage threshold of LISe (see Section 6) allows, however, to predict oscillation in the ns regime even using the present state-of-the-art crystal quality. In this sense LIS and LISe seem attractive for this application owing to their largest band-gap energies among all chalcogenides which is related to their damage resistivity. Moreover, their thermal conductivity is larger and their thermo-optic coefficients are smaller in comparison to the commonly used AGS. Recently we demonstrated successful operation of a ns OPO based on LISe pumped at 1064 nm at repetition rates ranging from 10 to 100 Hz [65]. Again type-II eo-e interaction in the X-Y plane was utilized. A sample with dimensions 5 × 6 × 17 mm3 (deep red annealed LISe, length: 17 mm, cut at ϕ = 72◦ ) was available for this experiment. It was broad-band antireflection coated for the pump, signal, and idler spectral ranges. As a result of the intrinsic losses (absorption and scattering) the actual transmission at the three wavelengths was
96
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
about 92%. Despite these excessive losses, the OPO threshold was estimated to lie in the mJ pump energy range [82]. The pump source was a flash-lamp pumped electro-optically Q-switched Nd:YAG laser delivering 10 ns pulses with a spectral linewidth of 1 cm−1 (∼0.1 nm). The walk-off length calculated from the pump beam size and the crystal birefringence was roughly 4 times the physical crystal length. Damage of the antireflection coating observed with a separate test plate at a pump fluence of the order of 0.25 J/cm2 made it necessary to restrict the pump energy incident on the LISe crystal to about 8 mJ. We studied several cavity configurations consisting of two plane mirrors starting with a true doubly resonant cavity with high reflectance of both mirrors at λ S and λ I , and recycling the pump beam by a retroreflection [65]. Subsequently we introduced a 0.5 mm thick CaF2 plate to couple out, depending on its orientation, more signal or idler energy. The requirement to have highly reflecting dielectric mirrors both for the signal and idler was the limiting factor for the choice of the crystal cut and the resulting tunability. The maximum idler energy that was extracted at 10 Hz near 3.6 µm was 43 µm. The achieved tunability was 1474.8 nm < λ S < 1561.6 nm and 3339.1 nm < λ I < 3819.8 nm. The spectral width estimated at the signal wavelength was narrow, less than the 0.6 nm resolution, as expected for type-II interaction. It is obvious that more idler energy could be extracted only in a singly resonant OPO configuration and such a cavity is depicted in Fig. 17. Its physical length amounts to 2.3 cm and although only the signal was resonated, both the pump and the idler wave were recycled by the rear metal mirror. The input-output characteristics are shown in Fig. 18a for three representative repetition rates. Thresholds of 3, 4, and 5 mJ were measured at 10, 30, and 50 Hz, respectively. The maximum idler energy achieved at 10 Hz was 92 µJ which corresponds to a conversion efficiency of ∼1.15%. No roll-over in the dependence of the output energy is observed even at 50 Hz where the maximum pump energy of 8 mJ corresponds to an average power of 400 mW. This supports the assumption of slow heating effects as the reason for the decreasing efficiency at higher repetition rates (Fig. 18b) although this set-up was actually least sensitive to thermal
Figure 17. Experimental set-up of the singly (signal) resonant OPO cavity. DM, dichroic mirror reflecting the pump and transmitting the idler wave. M1: highly reflecting (>99.5%) mirror at λ S with 98% transmission at 1064 nm (λ P ) and 90% at λ I , Ag: highly reflecting (>98.5%) mirror for all three waves.
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
97
Figure 18. (a) Output idler energy versus pump energy at 1064 nm (a), and versus repetition rate for a pump energy of 8 mJ (b), at normal incidence to the LISe crystal.
effects. The identical slopes of the three curves in Fig. 18a indicate that scaling of the output energy can be expected at higher pump energies. The pulse-to-pulse fluctuations observed in the output energy of the OPO were of the order of ±15% which is consistent with the ±10% pump pulse fluctuations. Substantial improvement of the present results in terms of output energy and tunability in the mid-IR can be expected. However, to utilize the high thermal conductivity of LISe and its high damage threshold it will be necessary to improve the quality of the antireflection coatings and to reduce the residual absorption losses. Once these problems are solved, LISe crystals could be useful for 1064 nm pumped OPOs also at kHz repetition rates. We note that among the new chalcogenide compounds under development, HGS and mixed quaternary crystals of the same type with higher nonlinearities but poorer thermal conductivities have recently demonstrated their capabilities in Nd:YAG laser pumped ns OPOs [4]. 9. Conclusion The interest in the chalcogenides LIS and LISe was motivated by several remarkable properties distinct from those of the matured AGS, AGSe or ZGP crystals. These properties are related more or less to the different nature of the Li-S(e) ionic bonds: (1) Both compounds display larger band-gap energy in comparison to other sulphide or selenide nonlinear crystals and this allows to pump them at relatively short wavelengths without the onset of TPA; (2) Their thermal conductivities are substantially larger than those of AGS(e), owing to the increase in lattice phonon energy and Debye temperature which, together with the smaller thermo-optic coefficients (relative to AGS), at equivalent residual absorption losses, will minimize the thermal lensing effects; (3) Their wurtzite-type lattice structure is less prone to stresses and laminar defects – no sign anisotropy in the thermal expansion coefficients like in AGS(e); and (4) Owing to their orthorhombic structure, LIS and LISe are pyroelectric (existence of a spontaneous macroscopic polarization).
98
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
From the binary or ternary mid-IR crystals now in use, LIS and LISe are the only biaxial crystals, which in general means extended phase-matching capabilities. Future applications of LISe and LIS in the mid-IR could be related also to the utilization of propagation schemes outside the principal planes. The transparency range of both LIS and LISe corresponds to the one of AGS and it can be expected that they can develop into an interesting alternative to this mature crystal with specific advantages in various applications above ∼5 µm (the limit for oxide nonlinear crystals) up to about 12 µm. Most of the attractive features specified before, together with the increased damage resistivity, obviously point out high peak and/or average power applications. In many cases these advantages could compensate for the slightly lower effective nonlinearity. Ultrafast frequency conversion schemes based on LIS and LISe are interesting basically because they allow conversion of conventional fs pulse sources from the near to the mid-IR. While the large band-gap helps to avoid TPA and decrease the temporal walk-off, the possibility to pump LIS near 800 nm is attractive also for single (or sub-) cycle pulse generation in the mid-IR by mixing different spectral components of extremely short (sub-15 fs) pulses from Ti:sapphire laser systems. Ultrafast (fs or ps) down-conversion schemes like DFG, OPA or OPG pumped in the near-IR by amplified systems operating at 0.01–100 kHz require relatively short crystal lengths and the average powers are relatively low. The realization of high repetition rate (∼100 MHz) fs or ps synchronously pumped OPOs (SPOPOS) in the mid-IR will also profit from the lower GVM and the absence of TPA. Such devices based on LIS or LISe could be pumped either near 800 nm where the pump sources are tunable, or near 1 µm with fixed wavelength pump sources. Especially in ps SPOPOs, however, it is expected that thermal effects related to the residual losses could also play an essential role. The use of longer crystals for down conversion of ns pulses or CW radiation will depend even more critically on the thermal management and the level of residual losses in LIS and LISe in the region of clear transparency. As long as the loss level, e.g. at 1064 nm, is not reduced to the one typical of productionquality AGS (0.01–0.02 cm−1 ) it will be difficult to utilize the advantages of LIS and LISe related to their superior thermo-mechanical properties and realize novel operational regimes like CW or kHz repetition rate OPOs. CW OPOs offer the advantage of >1000 times narrower emission linewidths over pulsed OPOs owing to their single-frequency oscillation capability stemming from the homogeneous character of the parametric gain in the steady-state regime (the gain saturates as soon as a mode-pair starts to oscillate). CW operation of an OPO based on a non-oxide crystal has been to-date only demonstrated with AGS pumped at 845 nm, by resonating both the signal and idler waves at 1267 and 2535 nm, respectively, in an uncritically phase-matched configuration [83,84]. This pioneering experiment allowed to highlight the severe limitations associated with the use of chalcogenide mid-IR materials in CW OPOs, as compared with
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
99
technologically mature oxide-based materials [85]. The output performance of these CW AGS-based OPOs was clamped to about 2 mW at ∼1.5 times the oscillation threshold (∼100 mW) of the doubly-resonant cavity, as a result of strong thermal lensing effects due to the low thermal conductivity of AGS, and despite the extremely low losses of the selected samples (0.005–0.01 cm−1 measured at 1064 nm). Owing to their more than 4 times larger thermal conductivities (as compared to AGS) and lower thermo-optic coefficients, LIS and LISe are potentially better candidates for implementing CW OPOs in the deep mid-IR. However, due to the present status of the residual losses within their clear transparency ranges (about 0.05 cm−1 at 1064 nm, higher than the above quoted values for production quality AGS, and much higher as compared to the < 0.001 cm−1 loss levels typical for oxide materials), CW parametric oscillation with LIS and LISe is precluded by the still large cavity round-trip loss. Further progress in the growth technology of LIS and LISe is still needed to bring down their residual loss to a level similar to that in AGS and compatible with the parametric gain in the CW regime (typically 100-1000 times lower than with high peak power ns pump lasers). Thus the work to obtain improved stoichiometry crystals of LIS and LISe so as to reduce the number of point defects responsible of the residual transmission loss, especially near the short wave transmission edge, continues. However, for several of the above mentioned applications, it will be also necessary to develop highly resistant antireflection coatings with damage thresholds at least comparable to those of the uncoated crystals. Acknowledgements This work was written in the frame of Project D/0427481 supported by the German-French bilateral programme PROCOPE. Most of the results presented were achieved in the frame of the INCO-Copernicus contract IC15-CT98-0814 within the International Cooperation of the 4th Framework Programme, and with the partial support of Grant 04-02-16334 from the Russian Foundation for basic research and the RUS 01/223 Project of BMBF (Germany) for cooperation with Russia. We acknowledge the participation of F. Noack and F. Rotermund from the Max-Born-Institute in the fs frequency conversion experiments and thank W. Chen (Universit´e du Littoral Cˆote d’Opale, Dunkerque, France) for provision of the experimental data used in Subsection 8.2 prior to publication. References 1. D. N. Nikogosyan, Nonlinear optical crystals: A complete survey (Springer, 2005). 2. V. G. Dmitriev, G. G. Gurzadyan, and D. N. Nikogosyan, Handbook of Nonlinear Optical Crystals, Third Revised Edition (Springer, 1999).
100
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
3. P. S. Kuo and M. M. Fejer, Microstructured semiconductors for mid-infrared optics, This Book: Part I.4. 4. V. Petrov, V. Badikov, and V. Panyutin, Quaternary nonlinear optical crystals for the midinfrared spectral range from 5 to 12 micron, This Book: Part I.3. 5. V. Petrov, A. Yelisseyev, L. Isaenko, S. Lobanov, A. Titov, and J.-J. Zondy, Second harmonic generation and optical parametric amplification in the mid-IR with orthorhombic biaxial crystals LiGaS2 and LiGaSe2 , Appl. Phys. B 78(5), 543–546 (2004). 6. L. Isaenko, P. Krinitsin, V. Vedenyapin, A. Yelisseyev, A. Merkulov, J.-J. Zondy, and V. Petrov, LiGaTe2 : A new highly nonlinear chalcopyrite optical crystal for the mid-IR, Crystal Growth & Design 5(4), 1325–1329 (2005). 7. R. Hoppe, Untersuchungen an tern¨aren Sulfiden, Angew. Chem. 71(14), 457 (1959). 8. B. N. Ivanov-Emin and E. A. Ostroumov, On the chemistry of Indium III. Sulphoindates of alkali metals, Zhurnal Obshchei Khimii 12(9), 1601–1607 (1947). In Russian. 9. G. D. Boyd, H. M. Kasper, and J. H. McFee, Linear and nonlinear optical properties of LiInS2 , J. Appl. Phys. 44(6), 2809–2812 (1973). 10. T. J. Negran, H. M. Kasper, and A. M. Glass, Pyroelectric and electrooptic effects in LiInS2 and LiInSe2 , Mat. Res. Bull. 8(6), 743–748 (1973). 11. Z. Z. Kish, E. Yu. Peresh, V. B. Lazarev, E. E. Semrad, Systematics and the rules of variations in the properties of AI BIII CVI 2 -type compounds, Inorg. Mat. 23(5), 697–703 (1987) [transl. from Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR: Neorganicheskie Materialy 23(5), 777–784 (1987)]. 12. J. Br¨uckner, I-III-VI-Verbindungshalbleiter mit Lithium als Gruppe I-Element: Kristallz¨uchtung und Characterisierung, Dissertation, Albert-Ludwigs-Univerit¨at, Freiburg i Br., Germany, 1997. 13. S. Weise, Z¨uchtung und Charakterisierung von Kristallen im System Li 2 Se-I n 2 Se3 , Dissertation, Albert-Ludwigs-Universit¨at, Freiburg i Br., Germany, 2000. Also Shaker-Verlag, Aachen, Germany, 2002 (www.shaker-online.com). 14. S. Fossier, S. Sala¨un, J. Mangin, O. Bidault, I. Thenot, J.-J. Zondy, W. Chen, F. Rotermund, V. Petrov, P. Petrov, J. Henningsen, A. Yelisseyev, L. Isaenko, S. Lobanov, O. Balachninaite, G. Slekys, and V. Sirutkaitis, Optical, vibrational, thermal, electrical, damage, and phasematching properties of lithium thioindate, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 21(11), 1981–2007 (2004). 15. V. Petrov, J.-J. Zondy, A. Yelisseyev, L. Isaenko, S. Lobanov, O. Bidault, and W. Chen, Optical, thermal, electrical, and phase-matching properties of lithium selenoindate, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B (2007), submitted. 16. T. Kamijoh and K. Kuriyama, Single crystal growth of LiInS2 , J. Cryst. Growth, 46(6), 801–803 (1979). 17. T. Kamijoh and K. Kuriyama, Single crystal growth and characterization of LiInSe2 , J. Cryst. Growth 51(1), 6–10 (1981). 18. Z. Z. Kish, S. A. Kanishcheva, Yu. N. Mikhailov, V. B. Lazarev, E. E. Sempad, and E. Yu. Peresh, Synthesis and crystal structure of lithium thioindate LiInS2 , Doklady Physical Chemistry 280(1–3), 36–38 (1985) [transl. from Doklady Akad. Nauk SSSR 280(2), 398–401 (1985)]. 19. Z. Z. Kish, V. B. Lazarev, E. E. Semrad, E. Yu. Peresh, and I. V. Galagovets, Some properties of single crystals of LiInS2 and NaInS2 , Inorg. Mat. 20(5), 647–649 (1984) [transl. from Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR: Neorganicheskie Materialy 20(5), 750–752 (1984)].
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
101
20. S. K. Kovach, E. E. Semrad, Yu. V. Voroshilov, V. S. Gerasimenko, V. Yu. Slivka, and N. P. Stasyuk, Preparation and principal physicochemical properties of alkali metal indates and thioindates, Inorg. Mat. 14(12), 1693–1697 (1978) [transl. from Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR: Neorganicheskie Materialy 14(12), 2172–2176 (1978)]. 21. M. I. Golovei, E. Yu. Peresh, and E. E. Semrad, Production and characteristics of semiconductor materials of complex composition, promising for quantum electronics and opto-electronics, Kvantovaya Elektronika, Kiev, 20(0), 93–103 (1981), in Russian. 22. J. Br¨uckner, V. Kr¨amer, E. Nowak, V. Riede, and B. Schumann, Crystal growth and characterization of LiInS2 , Cryst. Res. Technol. 31(Suppl.), 15–18 (1996). 23. Z. Z. Kish, V. B. Lazarev, E. Yu. Peresh, E. E. Semrad, and I. S. Shaplygin, Phase equilibria in AI2 CVI − In2 CVI 3 systems, Russ. J. Inorg. Chem. 30(6), 854–856 (1985) [transl. from Zhurnal Neorganicheskoj Khimii 30(6), 1499–1501 (1985)]. 24. S. Weise, E. Nowak, B. Schumann, and V. Kr¨amer, LiInSe2 and phase relations in the ternary system Li-In-Se, Cryst. Res. Technol. 31(Suppl.), 817–820 (1996). 25. S. Weise and V. Kr¨amer, Phase study of the system Li2 Se-In2 Se3 , J. Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry 71(3), 1035–1038 (2003). 26. K. Kuriyama and T. Kato, Blue-band emission of LiInS2 single crystals grown by the indium solution method, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 32(Suppl. 3), 615–617 (1993). 27. V. V. Badikov, V. I. Chizhikov, V. V. Efimenko, T. D. Efimenko, V. L. Panyutin, G. S. Shevyrdyaeva, and S. I. Scherbakov, Optical properties of lithium indium selenide, Opt. Mat. 23(3–4), 575–581 (2003). 28. Yu. M. Andreev, V. V. Atuchin, G. V. Lanskii, N. V. Pervukhina, V. V. Popov, and N. C. Trocenco, Linear optical properties of LiIn(S1−x Sex )2 crystals and tuning of phase matching conditions, Solid State Sciences 7(10), 1188–1193 (2005). 29. L. Isaenko, I. Vasilyeva, A. Yelisseyev, S. Lobanov, V. Malakhov, L. Dovlidova, J.-J, Zondy, and I. Kavun, Growth and characterization of LiInS2 single crystals, J. Cryst. Growth 218(2–4), 313–322 (2000). 30. L. Isaenko, I. Vasilyeva, A. Merkulov, A. Yelisseyev, and S. Lobanov, Growth of new nonlinear crystals LiMX2 (M=Al, In, Ga; X=S, Se, Te) for mid-IR optics, J. Cryst. Growth 275(1–2), 217–223 (2005). 31. K. Kuriyama, T. Kato, and A. Takahashi, Optical band gap and blue-band emission of a LiInS2 single crystal, Phys. Rev. B 46(23), 15518–15519 (1992). 32. L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, S. Lobanov, A. Panich, V. Vedenyapin, J. Smirnova, V. Petrov, J.-J. Zondy, and G. Knippels, Characterization of LiInS2 and LiInSe2 single crystals for nonlinear optical applications, Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 692(0), 429–434 (2002). 33. W. H¨onle, G. K¨uhn, and H. Neumann, Die Kristallstruktur von LiInSe2 , Z. anorg. allg. Chemie 543(12), 161–168 (1986). 34. L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, J.-J. Zondy, G. Knippels, I. Thenot, and S. Lobanov, Growth and characterization of single crystals of ternary chalcogenides for laser applications, OptoElectron. Rev. 9(2), 135–141 (2001); reproduced in Proc. SPIE 4412, 342–350 (2001). 35. T. Kamijoh and K. Kuriyama, Blue-band emission in LiInS2 crystals, J. Appl. Phys. 51(3), 1827–1828 (1980). 36. K. Kuriyama and T. Kato, Optical band gap and photoluminescence studies in blue-band region of Zn-doped LiInS2 single crystals, Sol. St. Commun. 89(11), 959–962 (1994).
102
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
37. T. Kamijoh, T. Nozaki, and K. Kuriyama, A photoluminescence study on lithium ternary compounds, Nuovo Cimento 2D(6), 2029–2033 (1983). 38. L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, S. Lobanov, V. Petrov, F. Rotermund, J.-J. Zondy, and G. H. M. Knippels, LiInS2 : A new nonlinear crystal for the mid-IR, Mat. Sci. Semicon. Process. 4(6), 665–668 (2001). 39. L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, S. Lobanov, V. Petrov, F. Rotermund, G. Slekys, and J.-J. Zondy, LiInSe2 : A biaxial ternary chalcogenide crystal for nonlinear optical applications in the midinfrared, J. Appl. Phys. 91(12), 9475–9480 (2002). 40. T. Kamijoh, T. Nozaki, and K. Kuriyama, Dielectric constants and bond parameters of LiInSe2 and LiGaSe2 , J. Appl. Phys. 53(1), 761–763 (1982). 41. H. Neumann, Bond ionicities and structural trends in some LiI BIII CVI 2 compounds, Cryst. Res. Technol. 21(9), 1207–1212 (1986). 42. A. Eifler, V. Riede, J. Br¨uckner, S. Weise, V. Kr¨amer, G. Lippold, W. Schmitz, K. Bente, and W. Grill, Band gap energies and lattice vibrations of the lithium ternary compounds LiInSe2 , LiInS2 , LiGaSe2 and LiGaS2 , Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 39(Suppl. 1), 279–281 (2000). 43. W. H¨orig, H. Neumann, and G. K¨uhn, The fundamental absorption edge of LiInSe2 , Phys. Stat. Sol. (b) 121 (1), K55–K58 (1984). 44. A. Eifler, V. Riede, S. Wenger, S. Weise, E. Nowak, and V. Kr¨amer, Optical band gap of LiInSe2 single crystals, Cryst. Res. Technol. 31 (Suppl.), 233–236 (1996). 45. H. J. Beister, S. Ves, W. H¨onle, K. Syassen, and G. K¨uhn, Structural phase transitions and optical absorption of LiInSe2 under pressure, Phys. Rev. B 43(12), 9635–9642 (1991). 46. T. Kamijoh and K. Kuriyama, Annealing effects on electrical properties of LiInSe2 , J. Appl. Phys. 52(2), 1102–1103 (1981). 47. C. J. Smith and C. W. Lowe, Stoichiometric effects on the optical properties of LiInSe2 , J. Appl. Phys. 66(10), 5102–5104 (1989). 48. H. Sommer, D. W. Bullett, H. Neumann, and G. K¨uhn, Valence band density of states in LiInSe2 , Phys. Stat. Sol. (b) 152(2), K47–K50 (1989). 49. Yu. M. Andreev, L. G. Geiko, P. P. Geiko, and S. G. Grechin, Optical properties of a nonlinear LiInS2 crystal, Quantum Electron. 31(7), 647–648 (2001) [transl. from Kvantovaya Elektron. 31(7), 647–648 (2001)]. 50. Yu. M. Andreev, V. V. Badikov, P. P. Geiko, and S. G. Grechin, Fulfillment of phase-matching conditions and optical characteristics of lithium thioindat nonlinear crystals, Atmos. Oceanic Opt. 14(11), 1001–1004 (2001) [transl. from Optika Atmosphery i Okeana 14(11), 1087–1090 (2001)]. 51. J. Huang, D. Ren, X. Hu, Y. Qu, Y. Andreev, P. Geiko, A. Shaiduko, and S. Grechin, Optical properties and phase-matching in LiInS2 , Chin. Opt. Lett. 1(4), 237–240 (2003). 52. M. V. Kabanov, Yu. M. Andreev, V. V. Badikov, and P. P. Geiko, Parametric frequency conversion based on new nonlinear crystals, Russ. Phys. J. 46(8), 835–846 (2003) [transl. from Izv. Vysshikh Uchebnykh Zavedenii, Fizika 46(8), 84–94 (2003)]. 53. A. Yelisseyev, L. Isaenko, S. Lobanov, J.-J. Zondy, A. Douillet, I. Thenot, Ph. Kupecek, G. Mennerat, J. Mangin, S. Fossier, and S. Sala¨un, New ternary sulfide for double application in laser schemes, in Advanced Solid State Lasers, H. Injeyan, U. Keller, and C. Marshall, eds., Vol. 34 of OSA Trends in Optics and Photonics Series (Optical Society of America, Washington, DC, 2000), pp. 561–568.
ORTHORHOMBIC CRYSTALS OF LITHIUM
103
54. G. M. H. Knippels, A. F. G. van der Meer, A. M. MacLeod, A. Yelisseyev, L. Isaenko, S. Lobanov, I. Thenot, and J.-J. Zondy, Mid-infrared (2.75–6.0-µm) second-harmonic generation in LiInS2 , Opt. Lett. 26(9), 617–619 (2001). 55. Yu. M. Andreev, V. V. Badikov, P. P. Geiko, S. G. Grechin, V. V. Efimenko, T. D. Efimenko, V. L. Panyutin, A. A. Tikhomirov, and A. V. Shaiduko, Second harmonic generation of TEA CO2 laser radiation in LiInSe2 , Atmos. Oceanic Opt. 17(2–3), 115–120 (2004) [transl. from Optika Atmosphery i Okeana 17(2–3), 133–139 (2001)]. 56. V. S. D’ordyai, V. A. Stefanovich, E. I. Pan’ko, V. B. Lazarev, E. Yu. Peresh, and Z. Z. Kish, Raman scattering in LiInS2 , Inorg. Mat. 24(4), 461–464 (1988) [transl. from Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR: Neorganicheskie Materialy 24(4), 555–559 (1988). 57. H. Sobotta, H. Neumann, V. Riede, and G. K¨uhn, Lattice vibrations and interatomic forces in LiInS2 , Cryst. Res. Technol. 21(10), 1367–1371 (1986). 58. A. Eifler, V. Riede, S. Wegner, S. Weise, E. Nowak, D. Sprinz, G. Lippold, and W. Grill, Infrared and Raman study of lattice vibrations of LiInSe2 single crystals, Cryst. Res. Technol. 31(Suppl.), 353–356 (1996). 59. C. Ebbers, Summary of known linear and nonlinear optical properties of LiInS2 , Preprint UCRL-ID-116744 (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, 1994). 60. F. Rotermund, V. Petrov, F. Noack, L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, and S. Lobanov, Optical parametric generation of femtosecond pulses up to 9 µm with LiInS2 pumped at 800 nm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 78(18), 2623–2625 (2001). 61. J. Mangin, S. Sala¨un, S. Fossier, P. Strimer, J.-J. Zondy, L. Isaenko, and A. Yelisseyev, Optical properties of lithium thioindate, Proc. SPIE 4268, 49–57 (2001). 62. W. Chen, E. Poullet, J. Burie, D. Boucher, M. W. Sigrist, J.-J. Zondy, L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, and S. Lobanov, Widely tunable continuous-wave mid-infrared radiation (5.5–11 µm) by difference-frequency generation in LiInS2 crystal, Appl. Opt. 44(19), 4123–4129 (2005). 63. Yu. M. Andreev, P. P. Geiko, and M. V. Kabanov, New crystals for frequency-tunable lasers, Optoelectronics, Instrumentation and Data Processing 40(5), 96–106 (2004) [transl. from Avtometriya 40(5), 119–133 (2004)]. 64. W. Chen, M. W. Sigrist, C. Julien, X. Gao, J.-J. Zondy, L. Isaenko, A. Yelisseyev, and S. Lobanov, Continuous-wave mid-infrared (6–8 µm) difference-frequency generation in lithium-based semiconductor: LiInSe2 , Appl. Phys. B (2007), submitted. 65. J.-J. Zondy, V. Vedenyapin, A. Yelisseyev, S. Lobanov, L. Isaenko, and V. Petrov, LiInSe2 nanosecond optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 30(18), 2460–2462 (2005). 66. A. P. Yelisseyev, V. A. Drebushchak, A. S. Titov, L. I. Isaenko, S. I. Lobanov, K. M. Lyapunov, V. A. Gruzdev, S. G. Komarov, V. Petrov, and J.-J. Zondy, Thermal properties of the midinfrared nonlinear crystal LiInSe2 , J. Appl. Phys. 96(7), 3659–3665 (2004). 67. A. P. Yelisseyev, A. S. Titov, K. M. Lyapunov, V. A. Drebushchak, L. I. Isaenko, and S. I. Lobanov, Thermal and thermo-optic parameters of LiInSe2 single crystals, J. Cryst. Growth 275(1–2), e1679-e1684 (2005). 68. J.-J. Zondy, M. Abel, and A. Clairon, Type-II frequency doubling at λ = 1.30 µm and λ = 2.53 µm in flux-grown potassium titanyl phosphate, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 11(10), 2004–2015 (1994). 69. J.-J. Zondy, D. Touahri, and O. Acef, Absolute value of the d36 nonlinear coefficient of AgGaS2 : prospect for a low-threshold doubly resonant oscillator-based 3:1 frequency divider, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 14(10), 2481–2497 (1997).
104
J. -J. ZONDY ET AL.
70. G. K¨uhn, E. Pirl, H. Neumann, and E. Nowak, Heat capacity of LiInS2 , LiInSe2 and LiInTe2 between 200 and 550 K, Cryst. Res. Technol. 22(2), 265–269 (1987). 71. E. Gmelin and W. H¨onle, Anomalous lattice specific heat of LiInSe2 at low temperatures, Thermochimica Acta 268/270(0), 575–590 (1995). 72. C. Ebbers, (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA), 2000, personal communication. 73. D. Beasley, (Cleveland Crystals, Highland Heights, OH), 2005, personal communication. 74. O. Bidault, S. Fossier, J. Mangin, P. Strimer, A. Yelisseyev, L. Isaenko, and S. Lobanov, Study of the pyroelectricity in LiInS2 crystal, Solid State Commun. 121(4), 207–211 (2002). 75. M. V. Hobden, Phase-matched second-harmonic generation in biaxial crystals, J. Appl. Phys. 38(11), 4365–4372 (1967). 76. J. Q. Yao and T. S. Fahlen, Calculations of optimum phase match parameters for the biaxial crystal KTiOPO4 , J. Appl. Phys. 55(1), 65–68 (1984). 77. M. H. van der Mooren, Th. Rasing, and H. J. A. Bluyssen, Determination of type I phase matching angles and conversion efficiency in KTP, Appl. Opt. 34(6), 934–937 (1995). 78. J. J. Huang, Y. M. Andreev, G. V. Lanskii, A. V. Shaiduko, S. Das, and U. Chatterjee, Acceptable composition-ratio variations of a mixed crystal for nonlinear laser device applications, Appl. Opt. 44(35), 7644–7650 (2005). 79. V. Petrov, F. Rotermund, and F. Noack, Generation of high-power femtosecond light pulses at 1 kHz in the mid-infrared spectral range between 3 and 12 µm by second-order nonlinear processes in optical crystals, J. Opt. A: Pure Appl. Opt. 3(3), R1–R19 (2001). 80. V. M. Gordienko, S. S. Grechin, A. A. Ivanov, A. A. Podshivalov, and E. V. Rakov, Efficient parametric oscillation in the 8–10-µm range upon pumping by a femtosecond Cr:forsterite laser, Quantum Electron. 36(2), 114–116 (2006) [transl. from Kvantovaya Elektron. 36(2), 114–116 (2001)]. 81. K. L. Vodopyanov, J. P. Maffetone, I. Zwieback, and W. Ruderman, AgGaS2 optical parametric oscillator continuously tunable from 3.9 to 11.3 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 75(9), 1204–1206 (2006). 82. S. J. Brosnan and R. L. Byer, Optical parametric oscillator threshold and linewidth studies, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 15(6), 415–431 (1979). 83. A. Douillet and J.-J. Zondy, Low-threshold, self-frequency-stabilized AgGaS2 continuouswave optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 23(16), 1259–1261 (1998). 84. A. Douillet, J.-J. Zondy, A. Yelisseyev, S. Lobanov, and L. Isaenko, Stability and frequency tuning of thermally loaded continuous-wave AgGaS2 optical parametric oscillators, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 16(9), 1481–1498 (1999). 85. J.-J. Zondy, A. Douillet, A. Clairon, A. Yelisseyev, L. Isaenko, and S. Lobanov, Thermal effects limitations in mid-infrared continuous wave optical parametric oscillators, J. Mat. Science: Materials in Electronics 12(8), 451–460 (2001).
QUATERNARY NONLINEAR OPTICAL CRYSTALS FOR THE MID-INFRARED SPECTRAL RANGE FROM 5 TO 12 µm Quaternary Nonlinear Optical Crystals V. PETROV∗ Max-Born-Institute for Nonlinear Optics and Ultrafast Spectroscopy, 2A Max-Born-Str., 12489 Berlin, Germany V. BADIKOV and V. PANYUTIN High Technologies Laboratory, Kuban State University 149 Stavropolskaya, 350040 Krasnodar, Russia
Abstract. We review all known optical and other relevant properties of the two solid solutions Cdx Hg1−x Ga2 S4 (x = 0. . .1) and Agx Gax Ge1−x S2 (x = 0.17. . .0.5) emphasizing their unique advantages as nonlinear optical crystals for the mid-IR spectral range between 5 and 12 µm and describe all frequency conversion schemes realized so far with them as well as future potential applications. Keywords: Ternary and quaternary semiconductors, defect chalcopyrites, solid solutions, nonlinear optical crystals, mid-infrared spectral range, down-conversion, optical parametric oscillators, optical parametric amplifiers, ultrashort laser pulses.
1. Introduction II IV V The chalcopyrite semiconductors with chemical formulae AI BIII CVI 2 and A B C2 (uniaxial crystals with 42m point group symmetry) are at present the most widely used nonlinear optical materials for the deep mid-IR range above 5 µm extending to roughly 20 µm [1]. A great number of ternary compounds belonging to these two classes exist [2], however, optical properties have been studied only for few of them because of the lack of high-quality defect-free crystals [3]. Unfortunately in many cases the birefringence is not sufficient for phase-matching. The phase-matchable chalcopyrites that have been primarily studied in the past 35 years are AgGaS2 (AGS) and AgGaSe2 (AGSe) belonging to the AI BIII CVI 2 class, ∗ To whom correspondence should be addressed: e-mail:
[email protected]
105 M. Ebrahim-Zadeh and I. T. Sorokina (eds.), Mid-Infrared Coherent Sources and Applications, 105–147. c 2008 Springer.
106
V. PETROV ET AL.
and ZnGeP2 (ZGP) and CdGeAs2 (CGA) belonging to the AII BIV CV 2 class [1, 4]. AGS, AGSe and ZGP are nowadays commercially available. The materials efforts required for the growth technology of a new crystal are enormous and in some cases birefringent chalcopyrites that had been already characterized but had no specific advantages were not developed further, e.g. ZnSiAs2 [3], while in other cases empirical predictions based on first-principles calculations seem advantageous, e.g. CdSiP2 [5]. One exception is the newly discovered LiGaTe2 (LGT) belonging to the AI BIII CVI 2 class [6], for which a phase-matched frequency conversion process was immediately demonstrated. A third type of related compounds, VI the so-called defect chalcopyrites AII BIII 2 C4 with point group 4, possess substantially increased second order nonlinear susceptibility in comparison to their chalcopyrite counterparts especially in relation to their band-gaps [7,8], but in fact only one such crystal, HgGa2 S4 (HGS), has been used so far for phase-matched frequency conversion [4]. Having in mind the very limited number of technologically mature nonlinear optical crystals for the above spectral range it is clear that mixed versions of such crystals are potentially interesting since they provide the opportunity to tailor the energy band-gap and the overall transparency window, the refractive index and the birefringence as well as the nonlinear susceptibility and the thermo-optical properties. In addition it might happen that the growth of large sizes with good optical quality is easier with a mixed crystal than with one of the parent ternary compounds. The engineering of the optical properties and especially the birefringence is similar to the periodic poling of ferroelectric crystals where this is normally connected with utilization of the maximum nonlinear coefficient using identical polarization of the three waves. However, on the one hand such ferroelectric materials are basically oxides which are not transparent above 5 µm. The only known exception, the monoclinic Sn2 P2 S6 [9], has a phase transition to a centrosymmetric paraelectric phase at the relatively low temperature of 338 K. An alternative here is the realization of quasi phase-matching in orientation-patterned GaAs [10] which is a great technological challenge. On the other hand solid solutions relying on the birefringence offer additional advantages in comparison to the quasi phasematching materials especially in the case of high intensities and short laser pulses: The tailoring of the band-gap allows to avoid two-photon absorption (TPA) and the variation of the group velocity mismatch (GVM) in combination with the use of different polarizations can ensure longer interaction lengths. A great number of quaternary crystals belonging to the chalcopyrite and defect chalcopyrite families have been grown and studied from crystallographical point of view but their optical characterization has been restricted basically to the band-gap evaluation. In the past, only three such mixed chalcopyrites were demonstrated to be useful for phase-matched optical frequency conversion processes: AgGax In1−x S2 , [11] AgGax In1−x Se2 , [12] and CdGe(Px As1−x )2 [13] exhibit complete solubility since the parent compounds have identical
QUATERNARY NONLINEAR OPTICAL CRYSTALS
107
structure and their properties vary smoothly with the composition. In all three cases the idea has been to extend the phase-matching capability (especially towards uncritical interaction in the case of the negative crystals) by reducing the birefringence (AgInS2 , AgInSe2 , and CdGeP2 do not possess sufficient birefringence for phase-matching within their transparency ranges). Moreover, the Incontaining components increase the nonlinearity of the quaternary mixtures while CdGeP2 substantially extends the transmission of CGA to shorter wavelengths. Unfortunately, practical applications of CdGe(Px As1−x )2 and AgGax In1−x S2 were limited to demonstration of their phase-matching capability [13–15]. The only mixed chalcopyrite crystal which has been extensively studied is AgGax In1−x Se2 because it is interesting for uncritical second harmonic generation (SHG) of CO2 laser radiation. This compound is the only quaternary crystal of this type included in the Handbook [4] containing extensive literature on its properties and applications; several systematic studies on it appeared more recently [16–18]. The present Chapter is devoted to two different sulphide classes of mixed quaternary nonlinear optical crystals for the mid-IR spectral range between 5 and 12 µm: The first one is represented by Cdx Hg1−x Ga2 S4 , a complete solid solution with two parent compounds possessing the same defect chalcopyrite structure, and the second one consists of Agx Gax Ge1−x S2 which has AGS as a parent compound in the limit x = 1 but does not represent complete solid solution because the compound in the limit x = 0, GeS2 , exhibits different crystallographic structure. Although single crystals both of Cdx Hg1−x Ga2 S4 and Agx Gax Ge1−x S2 were grown as early as 1980 [19, 20] it was only very recently that the growth technology was substantially improved to allow optical characterization and implementation. We will review all the known optical and related properties of the above compounds and present all the applications realized up to now emphasizing the specific advantages and future potential. 2. Mixed defect chalcopyrites Cdx Hg1−x Ga2 S4 2.1. GROWTH AND PROPERTIES OF CGS, HGS, AND CHGS
The crystal growth conditions and the properties of Cdx Hg1−x Ga2 S4 (CHGS) are closely related to those of the two isostructural parent compounds CdGa2 S4 (CGS) and HGS. Such defect chalcopyrites can be obtained in polycrystalline form by fusion of the three components or the binary compounds, grown in small sizes by chemical transport reactions or in larger sizes from the melt. Both ternary compounds CGS and HGS were first synthesized by sintering of the binary constituents by Hahn et al. in 1955 [21]. The obtained polycrystalline samples were used to establish their defect chalcopyrite structure (space group S42 − I 4). High optical quality crystals of CGS with large (>1 cm) size were reported for the first time with the Bridgman-Stockbarger technique [22–25]. The last two
108
V. PETROV ET AL.
papers also review earlier work on the growth and properties of CGS. Feigelson and Route [24] indicate a congruent melting character of CGS and a melting temperature of 980 ± 5◦ C. Different phase diagrams for the system CdS − Ga2 S3 can be found in the literature [24, 25]. According to Anosova et al. [25], the solid solutions existing on the basis of CGS extend for CdS content from 47.5 to 50.5 mol % and the point of complete melting of the stoichiometric composition of CGS is 990 ± 2◦ C. In general, in order to achieve homogeneous composition of the grown boule it is necessary to have a charge corresponding to the maximum melting temperature: According to our latest estimations this maximum melting temperature (995 ± 2◦ C) corresponds to slight (0.5 mol %) CdS deficit. The situation with the growth of HGS is similar but much more complicated. Large size (>1 cm) crystals of good optical quality were reported for the first time by Badikov et al. in 1979 using the vertical Bridgman-Stockbarger technique [26, 27]. This earlier work was reviewed in